id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05881v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05881v1 | Controllable Chest X-Ray Report Generation from Longitudinal Representations | 2023-10-09T17:22:58 | 2023-10-09T17:22:58 | Francesco Dalla Serra, Chaoyang Wang, Fani Deligianni, Jeffrey Dalton, Alison Q O'Neil | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Radiology reports are detailed text descriptions of the content of medical
scans. Each report describes the presence/absence and location of relevant
clinical findings, commonly including comparison with prior exams of the same
patient to describe how they evolved. Radiology reporting is a time-consuming
process, and scan results are often subject to delays. One strategy to speed up
reporting is to integrate automated reporting systems, however clinical
deployment requires high accuracy and interpretability. Previous approaches to
automated radiology reporting generally do not provide the prior study as
input, precluding comparison which is required for clinical accuracy in some
types of scans, and offer only unreliable methods of interpretability.
Therefore, leveraging an existing visual input format of anatomical tokens, we
introduce two novel aspects: (1) longitudinal representation learning -- we
input the prior scan as an additional input, proposing a method to align,
concatenate and fuse the current and prior visual information into a joint
longitudinal representation which can be provided to the multimodal report
generation model; (2) sentence-anatomy dropout -- a training strategy for
controllability in which the report generator model is trained to predict only
sentences from the original report which correspond to the subset of anatomical
regions given as input. We show through in-depth experiments on the MIMIC-CXR
dataset how the proposed approach achieves state-of-the-art results while
enabling anatomy-wise controllable report generation. | [
0.027350286,
0.0702364296,
0.0087968213,
-0.0110204853,
-0.0353117995,
0.0216509011,
0.027806066,
0.0364498459,
0.0030251613,
0.0043084081,
-0.0268924553,
-0.0582793579,
0.0275048409,
0.0737760514,
0.00522719,
-0.1205333024,
0.0022265723,
0.0137539133,
-0.0023034723,
0.0050213696,
-0.0052292845,
0.0014626193,
-0.0039187893,
0.0351287238,
-0.0379055478,
-0.0124973422,
-0.0140900901,
0.035134539,
0.0125804031,
-0.046633184,
-0.0049366066,
0.0437144563,
0.0372344553,
0.0163019281,
0.0000021919,
-0.0017928871,
-0.0214209761,
0.0397440307,
0.0111350361,
-0.0325896889,
0.0886656418,
-0.0461975895,
-0.0023084637,
-0.0200390574,
-0.0082541937,
-0.0260078739,
0.0514828488,
0.0385336019,
0.0841316655,
0.0297667086,
-0.0330151618,
0.0305335745,
-0.0109125515,
-0.0343642086,
0.0461941659,
-0.0200394336,
-0.011273291,
0.0037930699,
0.0270986054,
-0.0054040216,
-0.052315481,
0.0586283989,
0.0319591947,
-0.0117260888,
0.0334165879,
0.0619876646,
0.0554764979,
-0.0324196368,
-0.0138992174,
0.0530910976,
-0.0537811257,
0.0062456075,
0.0087259728,
-0.0343673043,
-0.0443229526,
-0.0278071072,
-0.0396248512,
0.0010442119,
-0.0151552651,
-0.0016941848,
-0.0286640432,
-0.0070320433,
-0.0167342499,
-0.0225851201,
-0.0434834249,
-0.05961309,
0.0015713259,
-0.003156377,
-0.0218411796,
0.0191444438,
0.0431455486,
-0.0863311812,
0.0304143522,
0.0468354449,
-0.0710309446,
0.0123260105,
-0.0410638973,
-0.0384203233,
0.0613937266,
-0.0130846128,
0.0036416312,
-0.0317048877,
-0.0826334804,
0.058820419,
-0.027997233,
0.0687127709,
-0.0623488724,
0.0828067064,
-0.0213559642,
0.0318132639,
-0.0331721604,
-0.042966079,
-0.000637598,
0.0017458245,
0.0119727291,
-0.0186957102,
-0.071998179,
-0.0052112904,
-0.021710651,
0.0263378844,
0.0209200662,
0.0723093376,
-0.097554341,
0.0243731514,
-0.0115148183,
0.058770787,
0.0175936185,
-0.0168184526,
0.0008216451,
0.0076314253,
0.0025799675,
0.0652854517,
0.0236279778,
0.0260431133,
-0.0343132764,
0.0156949498,
-0.0412594453,
0.0197802577,
0.018166909,
-0.076868318,
-0.0409987308,
-0.0266069341,
0.0553507283,
-0.0377236269,
0.0288895871,
-0.0063439952,
0.0073077148,
-0.0211978778,
0.0069942037,
0.0030917428,
0.0046736165,
0.0556374267,
-0.0291488282,
-0.0277318768,
0.0217650551,
0.0123406164,
0.0468050875,
0.0131713767,
0.0295336507,
0.057381209,
-0.0233042017,
0.0335519239,
0.0113474717,
-0.0023619148,
0.0119437966,
-0.0172296576,
-0.0559786297,
-0.0165118836,
-0.004196451,
0.0863574594,
0.0173942354,
0.0265859719,
-0.0183963962,
-0.0142431203,
0.0322916359,
0.0317902789,
0.054811582,
-0.0204671286,
0.0888415426,
-0.0211357828,
-0.0495189168,
0.0008776303,
-0.0189878922,
0.0547014177,
0.0736528859,
0.0116083361,
-0.0265009832,
-0.0112310573,
-0.0397782139,
-0.048978284,
0.0039381948,
-0.0235920344,
-0.037983194,
-0.0126537764,
0.0551230609,
0.024395505,
-0.0531532429,
-0.0002245635,
0.0167077407,
-0.0166002121,
-0.0072941929,
-0.0462169871,
-0.0098344823,
0.0781850368,
0.0668210685,
-0.0018084836,
-0.0409389585,
-0.0026256037,
0.0620080829,
0.0779115483,
0.0209930614,
-0.0013241846,
0.0427273102,
-0.0384013951,
-0.0693174452,
0.0429822505,
-0.0036693153,
0.0075683463,
-0.0133512216,
-0.0011935557,
-0.0164440274,
-0.0315311179,
-0.0133083332,
0.0547211617,
-0.0564192422,
-0.0063228277,
-0.0107578356,
0.0350625329,
0.0124367718,
-0.0186574198,
-0.0150072714,
0.0081348363,
0.0229057651,
-0.0021433001,
-0.0548331849,
0.0561321713,
-0.0613062978,
-0.0213934332,
0.0128626628,
-0.0502328314,
0.0125096729,
-0.0416458845,
-0.030675482,
-0.040445786,
-0.0040289997,
-0.0507569723,
0.0256655719,
-0.0189339034,
0.0008262494,
0.0707757175,
-0.02776164,
-0.0192157999,
0.0514000207,
-0.0194588099,
0.0094655054,
0.0287382081,
0.023769686,
0.0111742662,
-0.0355853625,
-0.0107489647,
0.0244447384,
0.0130054867,
-0.0286194757,
-0.0100887837,
0.0150610842,
-0.0112904944,
-0.0232365113,
-0.0458128527,
-0.0201011263,
0.0204779543,
-0.0361290015,
0.0271017421,
-0.0114118578,
0.0133527229,
-0.0599344298,
-0.0548197106,
-0.0029213903,
0.0502792709,
0.0059060878,
0.0579195619,
0.0152801173,
0.0045482088,
-0.0374132581,
-0.0123712402,
-0.011146076,
0.0065184366,
0.0537478626,
-0.0072871982,
-0.028914392,
0.0049955947,
-0.0416948795,
0.00157934,
0.0018593299,
-0.0195047073,
0.0444694385,
-0.0276823305,
-0.0328977443,
0.056493111,
0.017702885,
0.0514059961,
0.0122265937,
0.0049597565,
-0.0229884181,
-0.0080253622,
-0.04014102,
-0.019817112,
0.020470269,
-0.0603413805,
-0.0019171883,
0.0490752086,
0.0328119993,
0.0370527916,
-0.0551602282,
-0.0546252131,
-0.0134393508,
-0.016914349,
-0.0539387651,
0.0010902481,
-0.0135368742,
-0.0115718506,
-0.0524013005,
-0.0747354627,
0.067750968,
0.016262034,
0.0162438843,
-0.0101702297,
0.0285636075,
-0.03116435,
0.0840131268,
0.0312178191,
0.0427384935,
0.0333031043,
-0.0315885954,
-0.05343033,
0.0321354754,
0.0139018325,
-0.0494200401,
-0.0515672676,
-0.024834659,
0.0148851378,
-0.0094081862,
0.0023336019,
-0.0136695635,
-0.028369816,
0.0327396989,
-0.0221953373,
-0.0029816772,
-0.0026362948,
-0.0772379562,
0.0279912055,
0.013334671,
0.0552258603,
-0.0288586989,
-0.0161547456,
-0.0161340199,
0.0478861816,
0.0244888216,
0.0400249436,
-0.0666863769,
-0.0473831706,
-0.0187537223,
0.0914676636,
-0.0018635119,
0.0212983806,
-0.0462687612,
0.0264167469,
-0.0347190015,
0.019529894,
-0.0047197668,
0.0070644766,
0.0365842618,
-0.0507141761,
-0.0258581527,
0.0385934561,
0.0343826935,
-0.0365350246,
-0.0349569507,
0.0414679125,
0.0283433069,
0.0073223896,
-0.0104597835,
-0.0291874111,
0.0087763332,
-0.0186398569,
0.0411547534,
-0.0067953141,
0.0086309416,
0.0049408092,
-0.0179435797,
0.0765528083,
0.0065746466,
-0.055155009,
-0.0477258265,
-0.015657939,
-0.0052741086,
-0.0147422459,
-0.0584787764,
0.0219441596,
-0.0027894073,
-0.0178216938,
0.0298602525,
-0.0400930643,
-0.0235812459,
-0.0175020639,
-0.022019973,
-0.0305584166,
0.0545183904,
0.0566748716,
0.0129760755,
-0.0379446782,
-0.031631168,
0.0227424428,
0.0198400673,
0.0052242796,
0.1044576243,
0.009185655,
-0.0280512255,
-0.0532523505,
0.0517962612,
0.0333929509,
-0.0089171333,
-0.0282421261,
0.035376925,
-0.0289510377,
-0.0134720877,
-0.0713814721,
0.0427952483,
0.0412163548,
0.0150366807,
0.0058438079,
-0.0102782315,
-0.0462204367,
-0.0149518624,
0.0910188481,
-0.0633143857,
-0.0083180293,
0.0180543344,
-0.0710809976,
-0.0377873406,
-0.0764379948,
-0.0121054221,
0.0112535004,
0.0395258553,
-0.0065581249,
0.012198491,
-0.0338273235,
-0.034645088,
-0.0610549264,
0.0283014774,
0.0089954808,
0.0026126625,
-0.0148198539,
-0.0387515947,
0.0379960164,
-0.0185312387,
-0.0204728451,
0.0465394594,
-0.0608357601,
0.0078855576,
-0.0207382366,
0.0659946799,
0.023553133,
0.0235270783,
0.0009182699,
-0.0171516556,
0.1005194932,
0.02707191,
0.0172643121,
0.0030523341,
-0.0062978291,
-0.0237548444,
-0.046904631,
0.0001127304,
-0.0239238627,
0.0150985038,
0.0192828495,
0.0134454444,
-0.0116970623,
-0.0071301032,
0.0245246328,
-0.0051274598,
-0.0145984096,
-0.0569404624,
-0.0106125437,
-0.0215977319,
-0.002539966,
-0.0394985899,
0.0161715019,
-0.0296513271,
0.0363814533,
-0.0045762453,
-0.001366739,
0.0030689649,
-0.019428052,
-0.0418977365,
-0.0036747688,
-0.0688930303,
0.0338742919,
0.0031603754,
-0.0191961657,
0.0065028067,
0.019611273,
-0.0145191466,
-0.0206246246,
-0.0167462304,
0.0017861247,
-0.0002553026,
0.0439671166,
0.0390716866,
0.0427061543,
-0.0241256356,
0.0208327882,
-0.0373415537,
0.0022858405,
-0.0574754812,
0.0148772653,
0.0330495313,
0.0294131935,
0.0110560236,
-0.0303255748,
0.0023276072,
0.0072703916,
0.0813803151,
0.0052879928,
-0.0231893491,
0.041186396,
-0.0202929769,
0.0353682227,
-0.021116605,
0.0867844447,
0.0309367366,
0.0243630316,
-0.0309735052,
-0.0267971456,
-0.0847761706,
-0.0025650994,
0.0429975539,
-0.0048795301,
-0.0156331509,
-0.0115394881,
-0.0234123562,
-0.0339083746,
0.062032558,
0.0091704968,
-0.0053992607,
-0.0224222783,
0.070479095,
0.0282767303,
0.0145615498,
-0.0178727079,
-0.0070684496,
0.0393920951,
0.0366487354,
-0.0195476413,
0.0094229868,
-5.983240899e-33,
-0.0057991892,
-0.0493862703,
0.0395253077,
-0.0669392943,
-0.0199340209,
0.0326192565,
-0.0540993214,
-0.0130870799,
0.0484917015,
0.007968667,
-0.0056153145,
-0.0183109734,
0.0168591272,
0.0400330611,
0.0141103314,
-0.0017373841,
0.0384325497,
-0.0450034514,
0.003827523,
0.0454394706,
0.0286368653,
0.0362333842,
0.0386017226,
-0.1012458056,
-0.0072647855,
0.0214667376,
-0.018790815,
-0.0265851002,
0.0074395062,
0.0332537331,
-0.0421586595,
-0.0119235497,
0.0235096812,
-0.0396200381,
-0.0231877193,
0.0173199177,
-0.0547270849,
-0.0072965948,
-0.0318238437,
-0.0132697904,
-0.0705199987,
0.0070326682,
0.0401926301,
-0.0382012762,
0.0459464192,
-0.0427499153,
0.0572698265,
-0.0018746239,
-0.0232958775,
-0.0002224108,
-0.0406058617,
0.0422804095,
-0.0153115718,
-0.0410804562,
0.0054409956,
0.0356946066,
0.0008655722,
0.0286929626,
-0.0112339547,
0.0171638932,
0.0565054417,
0.0359456912,
0.0329463929,
0.0019721542,
-0.0135638062,
0.0629818141,
0.0655112267,
-0.0434356965,
-0.0351025499,
0.05024096,
-0.0213170499,
0.0555347018,
0.0255143046,
0.0222308859,
0.0444823764,
-0.0123087959,
-0.0584309176,
0.0448911302,
-0.0726719648,
0.0748566464,
0.0230023228,
-0.0022898763,
-0.0226836149,
0.0245860778,
0.0319698714,
-0.0730343163,
-0.0048426529,
-0.0155144921,
0.0499873422,
0.0738120452,
-0.0130897341,
0.0260763075,
0.0251594521,
0.0379429013,
0.014261364,
-0.0412288047,
0.0302281119,
0.0504341051,
-0.01639653,
-0.0312001705,
-0.0022698923,
-0.022378711,
0.0695006996,
0.0178608783,
0.0459695831,
0.0075539034,
0.0270274002,
0.0414471664,
-0.0519902445,
-0.0007318638,
0.0023066122,
-0.0419881046,
-0.0471357703,
0.0059700902,
0.0415202789,
-0.0040153847,
-0.0374432616,
0.0091929091,
-0.0271824952,
0.0200566351,
-0.0336917676,
-0.0504736118,
-0.0170089249,
0.0258852858,
-0.0332515724,
-0.0130485408,
-0.0356991999,
-0.0083792545,
0.0621732324,
-0.0676943883,
-0.0184923317,
0.0306936484,
2.807e-7,
0.0267422497,
-0.0097319577,
0.0505057424,
-0.0288109407,
0.0262290724,
-0.0199212246,
-0.0370186083,
0.0175240431,
-0.001278834,
-0.0314701721,
0.0416585095,
-0.0058381893,
0.0107197035,
0.0329676606,
-0.0487147383,
-0.0202254616,
-0.0314567275,
0.0207007546,
-0.0218056329,
-0.0307712778,
0.0962358415,
0.0405482128,
-0.0434761681,
-0.0479855947,
0.0402666368,
0.0121002439,
0.0601323433,
-0.000286703,
0.0309311748,
-0.0406146199,
0.0502719358,
0.0041216849,
-0.0103135621,
0.027005652,
-0.0219593737,
-0.0420259647,
0.0237451866,
0.0390702002,
-0.0304122996,
-0.0313031636,
0.024863109,
0.0271814987,
0.002573526,
-0.0198617,
0.0378091261,
-0.0517128967,
0.0141271958,
-0.0297099352,
-0.0451414362,
0.057691101,
0.0397054553,
-0.0330052339,
-0.061208088,
0.0518119223,
0.0340703949,
0.0216220915,
-0.0140151484,
-0.0753911957,
-0.0380587652,
0.0101198219,
-0.0350133292,
0.0054989588,
-0.0214011483,
0.0220475178,
-0.0072243237,
-0.0610193126,
-0.0533933565,
2.675357414e-34,
0.0081457924,
-0.0164489094,
-0.0074153417,
-0.0116850669,
0.0008720524,
-3.064e-7,
0.0328970887,
0.0355286412,
0.0203058179,
-0.0223647058,
-0.0341082476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.13002v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.13002v1 | Are Large Language Models Geospatially Knowledgeable? | 2023-10-09T17:20:11 | 2023-10-09T17:20:11 | Prabin Bhandari, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Dieter Pfoser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the impressive performance of Large Language Models (LLM) for various
natural language processing tasks, little is known about their comprehension of
geographic data and related ability to facilitate informed geospatial
decision-making. This paper investigates the extent of geospatial knowledge,
awareness, and reasoning abilities encoded within such pretrained LLMs. With a
focus on autoregressive language models, we devise experimental approaches
related to (i) probing LLMs for geo-coordinates to assess geospatial knowledge,
(ii) using geospatial and non-geospatial prepositions to gauge their geospatial
awareness, and (iii) utilizing a multidimensional scaling (MDS) experiment to
assess the models' geospatial reasoning capabilities and to determine locations
of cities based on prompting. Our results confirm that it does not only take
larger, but also more sophisticated LLMs to synthesize geospatial knowledge
from textual information. As such, this research contributes to understanding
the potential and limitations of LLMs in dealing with geospatial information. | [
0.0378497057,
0.0438271984,
-0.0231391303,
0.0069123674,
-0.0441455729,
0.0488959216,
0.046039924,
-0.0267348476,
0.0407892317,
-0.0637099668,
-0.0095825652,
-0.0282682031,
0.0154840555,
0.015138559,
0.0408859774,
-0.0641249046,
0.0192401689,
-0.069268778,
0.0174074937,
0.0130364671,
-0.047490146,
-0.0124529013,
-0.0344727971,
0.0273713935,
-0.0020708088,
0.0115249008,
-0.0104636988,
-0.0340269022,
-0.0032070803,
-0.0488271303,
-0.0183707587,
-0.0109710498,
0.0320328102,
-0.0056362464,
0.0000018286,
-0.0047508241,
0.0057422537,
-0.0117843375,
0.0247682873,
0.004305575,
0.0071173189,
-0.0285689887,
0.0220687557,
0.0074801426,
-0.0465814844,
-0.0373238064,
0.0470459387,
-0.0057785939,
0.0331177115,
0.0498335548,
-0.0098258527,
-0.0567413606,
0.0089548323,
0.0003025936,
-0.0208998322,
0.0167211853,
0.0224259216,
0.0057775928,
0.0194612332,
0.0874210596,
-0.0120539498,
0.0287717637,
-0.0156170856,
0.0162242483,
-0.0405254066,
0.0347158425,
-0.0213070977,
0.0334534235,
-0.0114210919,
0.0155280735,
0.0209530089,
-0.0022695784,
0.0387227908,
0.0237374436,
-0.0015537173,
0.0493454039,
-0.0539032519,
-0.002215897,
0.0008962409,
0.0557033122,
-0.0169078019,
-0.0124732461,
0.0395085439,
0.0347773433,
-0.0588444844,
0.1526910514,
-0.0133782467,
-0.054631073,
-0.0618039593,
0.0279292297,
-0.0094067063,
-0.0792602822,
0.0118779587,
0.0556227006,
-0.0171978697,
0.0057387403,
0.0318369977,
0.0749226287,
-0.0036275056,
-0.0418440923,
0.0540242903,
0.0069779158,
-0.0180354025,
0.0554901361,
-0.0133040436,
0.0717676356,
-0.0195135772,
0.033603292,
-0.0000280385,
-0.0198966246,
-0.0102666905,
-0.0168083422,
0.0074110944,
0.0004477035,
-0.0250776839,
0.0206880346,
-0.0022890081,
0.0046809739,
0.0095401453,
0.0361940153,
-0.0721325204,
0.0153711028,
0.0108004594,
-0.0444888994,
-0.0633065552,
0.0366139933,
-0.0313989148,
0.0214958452,
-0.0273025706,
0.0244947001,
0.0314382911,
0.0062203733,
0.0201662816,
0.0082696024,
-0.000978107,
0.052618254,
0.0500258021,
-0.0242120456,
-0.067608647,
0.0028645964,
-0.0280625597,
-0.0394253097,
0.022353122,
-0.0758339614,
-0.0293370504,
0.0416376032,
-0.0397541709,
-0.0202592015,
-0.0226633567,
0.0187680572,
-0.0398732349,
0.0583356991,
0.012647613,
0.0502802134,
0.054904677,
-0.0361220017,
0.0515519939,
0.0785361752,
0.021144405,
0.0758203417,
0.0284405537,
-0.0108750565,
0.0029491021,
0.0011999547,
-0.0131296469,
0.0455355532,
-0.0808788612,
0.0110751214,
-0.0244904291,
0.0293469578,
0.018525457,
0.0445309579,
-0.0017889603,
0.0337069146,
0.0851904899,
0.089804031,
0.0045079403,
-0.0123583339,
0.0799396262,
0.0305083506,
-0.0500045121,
0.0108212261,
-0.0558120534,
-0.0213384647,
-0.0433514975,
0.006803296,
0.0135878678,
0.0473145545,
-0.004713533,
-0.0372046158,
-0.045612812,
0.001803228,
0.0288971644,
0.0270539541,
0.0651013777,
-0.0288242102,
0.0206846874,
0.0281843282,
0.0152117154,
0.0134023335,
0.0188431665,
0.0158344675,
-0.0056283148,
0.009773613,
-0.0219309758,
-0.0011531397,
0.0113731874,
-0.0103874216,
0.0478102639,
0.0164912529,
0.0813792199,
0.0104915695,
-0.0415569581,
-0.0305923168,
-0.0490433052,
-0.00473984,
0.0146582527,
-0.0309405457,
0.0506804436,
0.0507509708,
0.0335185714,
-0.0787924007,
0.0217837933,
0.0050119529,
-0.0010415561,
-0.0321148634,
-0.0566899665,
0.0336308032,
-0.0386091098,
-0.0067360937,
0.0019780805,
0.0250589214,
-0.0017441313,
-0.0155595476,
-0.009367181,
0.0161693711,
-0.0246820729,
0.0033389181,
0.0101489192,
0.0017845429,
-0.0105524678,
-0.0170417037,
-0.0087364996,
-0.0337026007,
0.017556848,
-0.0261881463,
0.0467404388,
-0.0087918406,
0.02860488,
-0.0147118261,
0.0069105318,
-0.0449184254,
0.0743239,
-0.0094525833,
0.0387274846,
0.0106864413,
0.0117196832,
0.0305839349,
0.0113686165,
-0.0110606728,
-0.0435301736,
0.0063528852,
-0.0047480823,
-0.0082497923,
-0.0186970253,
-0.004164381,
-0.0515322648,
-0.0738402084,
0.0086758165,
-0.0213023666,
0.0371465571,
0.0059416667,
-0.0523843281,
-0.042586159,
-0.0150991101,
-0.0013356445,
0.0101517262,
0.0076437881,
0.0580875203,
0.0492564701,
-0.0421483815,
0.0379867889,
0.0200709291,
-0.0204046052,
-0.0379643477,
0.0437571816,
0.0160841271,
0.0055760676,
-0.0669520721,
0.0105536114,
-0.0417075939,
0.0084559005,
0.008251586,
-0.033217255,
0.0221507084,
-0.0378370062,
0.008683851,
0.0276851319,
-0.0029035592,
0.0052753785,
0.0556112789,
-0.0363571346,
-0.0408574641,
0.0164736249,
-0.0536482334,
0.0197125301,
-0.0683756694,
-0.0169395208,
-0.0124563128,
0.0591673069,
-0.0084072994,
0.0043158522,
0.0139683783,
0.0319996141,
-0.0639474839,
-0.0003048019,
-0.0398795977,
0.0312671624,
0.0163118653,
0.0998910442,
-0.0148682017,
-0.0936586112,
0.028298825,
-0.0243271422,
0.0106239738,
-0.025793504,
-0.0084991679,
-0.0318744816,
0.0767180622,
0.0214158744,
0.0086676814,
-0.0187400207,
-0.0467032641,
0.00610284,
-0.0513328761,
-0.0264342241,
0.0194113776,
0.0159376599,
-0.0421900637,
0.0098255612,
0.0085452162,
-0.0472206175,
-0.0330535844,
-0.0295608323,
-0.0529658087,
-0.0159324687,
0.001019849,
-0.057440836,
0.0044173421,
0.0762051716,
0.0502489619,
0.0237975083,
-0.0208689924,
-0.0159075391,
-0.0078708325,
-0.0047263661,
0.0602419451,
0.0932578072,
-0.0131667443,
0.0350309163,
-0.0427320525,
-0.011958722,
-0.0331020728,
0.0224747695,
-0.0232494175,
0.0472214296,
0.0338120535,
-0.0389847495,
-0.0541879833,
0.0288460497,
0.0379742682,
-0.0547556654,
-0.0521620736,
0.0950800031,
0.0735313594,
-0.0154286195,
0.0031284685,
-0.022378413,
-0.0119754029,
0.0591310263,
0.0377728529,
-0.0382142253,
0.0158974752,
0.0101361265,
-0.0749471113,
-0.0096465079,
-0.0400603488,
-0.0059121274,
-0.1249157041,
0.064902395,
-0.0035563724,
-0.028193986,
-0.0215295106,
-0.0584486686,
-0.0205305386,
0.0255001336,
-0.0212203711,
-0.0341125615,
-0.0385803916,
0.0016664062,
0.0469875187,
-0.0831371173,
-0.0385382585,
-0.0218903571,
-0.0598733313,
0.0428815521,
0.0227741301,
0.0677944347,
-0.0273294523,
-0.0671901703,
-0.0065427404,
0.0653542876,
0.0692894235,
-0.0085164728,
0.0059339087,
0.0321112163,
-0.0343658514,
-0.0056530954,
-0.0346360989,
-0.0262891967,
-0.0151159959,
0.0102283498,
0.0775494203,
-0.0511498004,
0.0279264729,
-0.0058894013,
0.0359324068,
0.0152950594,
0.0149435271,
0.0326166041,
0.0114245396,
-0.0524162129,
-0.0503962263,
-0.0339512415,
-0.0189003944,
-0.0353562124,
0.0666571856,
0.0418812372,
-0.0159097947,
-0.052168373,
-0.0170272738,
0.0240078643,
0.0371837318,
0.0030394562,
0.0068879989,
0.0493035242,
-0.0356177539,
-0.031648159,
0.054766424,
-0.0160057936,
0.0135319317,
-0.0224713366,
0.0212083105,
0.0329722315,
-0.0313836448,
-0.0240301285,
-0.0048778784,
-0.0531288683,
-0.06720718,
0.0214233547,
0.0024138873,
0.0229966994,
-0.031866435,
-0.0375634432,
-0.0484565608,
0.0426653698,
0.0110657392,
-0.0333841704,
-0.007094922,
0.0050928085,
0.0494484752,
0.0190980565,
-0.0016739549,
0.0163614471,
0.0304144528,
0.0212202501,
-0.003588144,
-0.0513740964,
-0.0001956523,
-0.020081168,
0.0073942072,
0.105552949,
-0.0123335356,
0.0044619972,
-0.0009935452,
-0.0394897908,
-0.0286449827,
0.001497367,
0.005371735,
0.0105775166,
0.0452283733,
0.0421081446,
-0.0267101675,
-0.0031613111,
0.0048894943,
-0.0479854234,
-0.011252637,
0.0130258352,
0.0110078743,
0.0096046049,
0.0248090047,
0.0337726027,
-0.0208189357,
0.0255781189,
-0.0056846817,
0.0362603441,
0.0030522167,
0.022715928,
0.0072667436,
0.0125730094,
-0.0724940673,
0.0132474648,
-0.0670843869,
-0.0658397824,
0.027835058,
0.0391357429,
0.0538542345,
-0.0390804596,
-0.0071810484,
-0.0173775442,
-0.0024165325,
0.0247294046,
-0.0214235298,
0.0428144857,
-0.0427029133,
0.0397777893,
-0.0083412463,
-0.0625981688,
0.0266432278,
0.0300539769,
0.0194907486,
0.0199754238,
0.0258836895,
-0.0602729172,
0.0006269538,
-0.0045079519,
-0.0167961344,
-0.0062878258,
-0.0422783755,
0.0201725829,
-0.0437197872,
-0.0840115696,
-0.004371848,
-0.0117287394,
-0.0309344642,
-0.0234260373,
-0.0039007312,
0.0522052757,
-0.0015857965,
-0.0114562782,
-0.0676024482,
0.0345328003,
-0.0146261388,
-0.019054886,
-0.0065244418,
-5.819220499e-33,
-0.0033828921,
-0.0710968375,
0.0745084807,
-0.038809821,
0.0080329552,
-0.0113278292,
-0.0112291137,
0.0049204314,
-0.0276274867,
0.0051230062,
-0.0210855044,
-0.0086933495,
0.0207928289,
0.0055763624,
0.0418416113,
0.0006666514,
-0.0037953462,
0.0041112513,
-0.0099552143,
-0.0235756524,
0.0544043332,
0.0005606895,
0.0467416793,
-0.0788943022,
0.0044692666,
0.0292541832,
-0.0080995038,
0.0401595868,
-0.0001166577,
0.0649936125,
-0.0272497404,
0.0301742777,
0.0404504091,
-0.023279978,
-0.0374356881,
0.0238781124,
-0.0499128625,
-0.0517232604,
0.0213235952,
-0.003797879,
0.0180693697,
-0.0092588766,
0.0259571057,
0.0223304369,
0.016080739,
0.0391281284,
0.033337418,
-0.012167736,
-0.0475248955,
0.0372928344,
-0.0303504299,
0.0308176652,
-0.0027357824,
0.0032033538,
0.0109659545,
0.00958909,
0.0001201641,
0.0067094634,
-0.0082388883,
0.0402047969,
0.0649256259,
0.0322432294,
0.0255634654,
0.0082643209,
0.021570785,
0.0627103373,
-0.000841137,
-0.0096156523,
-0.0426289029,
-0.0321020819,
0.0612904504,
-0.0023479783,
-0.0174006838,
0.0510425121,
-0.01187516,
-0.0245928951,
-0.0255369805,
0.0150739048,
-0.0210116431,
0.0050229784,
0.0193022303,
-0.0353481472,
-0.0438483134,
-0.0355109535,
-0.0394862518,
-0.0272040758,
-0.0211639591,
-0.017362535,
0.0332248881,
0.0029625674,
0.0480919778,
0.0957081765,
0.0132720424,
-0.0189246759,
-0.0636477917,
0.0093862927,
0.0119172065,
0.0082329726,
-0.0094570313,
0.0413539372,
-0.0599733293,
-0.0392625742,
-0.0413519889,
0.034845829,
-0.0096618393,
0.0291318074,
-0.0235253647,
0.0250170194,
-0.0694866404,
-0.008852059,
-0.0380127802,
-0.0238502733,
-0.0127066812,
-0.0218615178,
0.0406944267,
-0.018527817,
-0.0033655788,
0.0155248735,
0.0134908129,
-0.0084074344,
0.0134988725,
-0.017054975,
-0.0356998108,
0.0434581935,
-0.004407444,
-0.0098279808,
-0.0241039209,
0.0340180211,
0.0226439629,
-0.0278784931,
-0.0099991141,
0.0104936315,
2.632e-7,
0.0599633567,
0.0928036794,
-0.0048004962,
-0.0165608115,
-0.0033662131,
0.0080264295,
-0.0027800973,
-0.0218828321,
0.003080833,
0.0398049466,
0.0247459561,
0.033779759,
0.0307108872,
0.0523969084,
-0.1081465334,
0.0701696798,
-0.0425782204,
-0.0130158858,
-0.0786794648,
-0.00480022,
0.0151352361,
0.032185711,
0.0155125707,
-0.0052315611,
-0.0197694469,
-0.0605151281,
0.0236930344,
-0.0544084124,
-0.003298512,
0.0058308709,
0.0436652042,
0.0026892622,
0.0133025385,
-0.0028744224,
0.0007893941,
-0.0064677121,
0.0020578061,
0.0420435965,
-0.0018264299,
0.0120355077,
-0.0334501602,
-0.0899420381,
-0.0244099516,
-0.1091140956,
0.0525300615,
-0.0697001815,
-0.028610941,
-0.0031478407,
0.0193606429,
-0.014923187,
0.0258492958,
-0.0029596104,
-0.0041464013,
-0.0204862598,
0.0150889056,
0.0125098219,
0.0086434009,
-0.0842099264,
-0.0124370055,
0.0551729053,
-0.0043277862,
-0.0115768304,
-0.0463227816,
0.0034727238,
0.0423054099,
-0.0218627695,
0.0005589628,
2.006238938e-34,
-0.0090824785,
0.0208784305,
-0.0238026045,
-0.0384767614,
0.0496342145,
0.0229457393,
-0.0013156162,
0.0245185141,
0.0071839802,
-0.0652551353,
0.0131912436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05872v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05872v2 | ViCor: Bridging Visual Understanding and Commonsense Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T17:10:35 | 2024-05-17T17:24:35 | Kaiwen Zhou, Kwonjoon Lee, Teruhisa Misu, Xin Eric Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | In our work, we explore the synergistic capabilities of pre-trained
vision-and-language models (VLMs) and large language models (LLMs) on visual
commonsense reasoning (VCR) problems. We find that VLMs and LLMs-based decision
pipelines are good at different kinds of VCR problems. Pre-trained VLMs exhibit
strong performance for problems involving understanding the literal visual
content, which we noted as visual commonsense understanding (VCU). For problems
where the goal is to infer conclusions beyond image content, which we noted as
visual commonsense inference (VCI), VLMs face difficulties, while LLMs, given
sufficient visual evidence, can use commonsense to infer the answer well. We
empirically validate this by letting LLMs classify VCR problems into these two
categories and show the significant difference between VLM and LLM with image
caption decision pipelines on two subproblems. Moreover, we identify a
challenge with VLMs' passive perception, which may miss crucial context
information, leading to incorrect reasoning by LLMs. Based on these, we suggest
a collaborative approach, named ViCor, where pre-trained LLMs serve as problem
classifiers to analyze the problem category, then either use VLMs to answer the
question directly or actively instruct VLMs to concentrate on and gather
relevant visual elements to support potential commonsense inferences. We
evaluate our framework on two VCR benchmark datasets and outperform all other
methods that do not require in-domain fine-tuning. | [
0.0365573876,
0.066507414,
-0.0125646116,
0.0504264683,
-0.0251101404,
0.0302662048,
0.0008896508,
0.0020179295,
0.0333660208,
-0.0809032694,
-0.0025911913,
0.0173840541,
-0.0004199262,
0.019616494,
0.0153423622,
-0.0457079485,
0.0320222527,
-0.0391189232,
-0.0093503175,
0.0141010461,
0.0327373855,
0.0214596223,
0.0239138752,
0.0428524651,
-0.0154048428,
-0.0227481928,
0.0108885616,
-0.0109948441,
0.0304814558,
0.0058817295,
-0.0453807637,
0.0267153103,
0.1072317287,
-0.0019002077,
0.0000018156,
-0.0064116227,
0.0368236266,
-0.0053584762,
0.0236812979,
0.0040559121,
0.0107293632,
-0.059792202,
0.0362217687,
-0.0124444338,
-0.0435440764,
-0.0201265924,
0.0292568933,
0.0430570059,
0.0610589124,
-0.0108875427,
-0.0145140355,
-0.0425833389,
-0.0187618788,
-0.0152305849,
0.0244629923,
-0.0740729719,
0.016352294,
0.0654345453,
-0.0050451448,
-0.0256947316,
-0.0524671897,
0.0651602671,
0.0362119302,
-0.0466395095,
-0.022582775,
0.0468484983,
-0.0419721231,
-0.0318093859,
-0.0261388589,
0.102272898,
0.0010473809,
-0.0097617889,
-0.0190917682,
-0.0035045482,
0.0215810295,
0.032299675,
-0.0272833854,
0.0495047122,
0.0031382719,
0.0118790474,
-0.0233852863,
-0.0255324133,
-0.0019630028,
0.0535379648,
-0.006177492,
-0.0122539708,
-0.0127978921,
0.0417447202,
-0.0003579462,
0.041458033,
-0.0688602254,
-0.038065739,
-0.0107312957,
0.0682649985,
-0.0040516062,
0.0154790748,
-0.0205079149,
-0.0255954713,
-0.0085686389,
-0.0652440414,
0.0375673249,
-0.0054057585,
-0.0565584861,
0.0917555615,
-0.0278855376,
0.0285857711,
-0.0253848806,
0.0433422588,
-0.0013101117,
-0.0230079833,
-0.0352107286,
-0.0136582237,
-0.0252359062,
0.0183350686,
-0.063144505,
-0.0434635878,
-0.0012703852,
-0.0028402489,
-0.0222819541,
0.0228685737,
-0.0026768525,
0.0578632951,
-0.0027715627,
-0.0323187299,
-0.059573397,
0.050487224,
-0.0015787747,
0.0556268357,
-0.0409051627,
-0.0057217088,
0.0083692726,
0.03226294,
0.0262316465,
-0.0166673437,
0.0113269724,
0.046988558,
-0.046419017,
-0.0134731065,
-0.0442785583,
-0.0150527991,
-0.0051961895,
-0.0413093157,
0.0149883898,
-0.0536930002,
0.0069803037,
0.0047148345,
-0.0022055162,
0.0128659746,
0.0098160673,
0.0059437226,
-0.0293607507,
0.119053036,
0.004315719,
-0.0101289768,
0.010685063,
0.0312599279,
0.0368824191,
0.0713854358,
-0.0121100983,
0.0291394331,
0.0237746611,
-0.0074907192,
0.02045363,
0.0094054127,
-0.0003888791,
-0.0098319035,
-0.0349334031,
0.0136366151,
-0.0127223721,
0.022703087,
0.0495535918,
0.0249161832,
-0.0296743773,
-0.0130530531,
0.0768938661,
0.0540890694,
-0.0176749881,
-0.0016208839,
0.0257284287,
0.0162915532,
-0.0055620079,
0.0061705369,
-0.0627651438,
0.062382549,
0.005380671,
-0.0228391923,
-0.0463433824,
0.0271568578,
-0.0224744286,
-0.0217533689,
-0.0069117979,
-0.0105287759,
0.014406492,
0.0199945178,
0.0342483111,
0.0104519483,
-0.0259641223,
0.0472558849,
0.0174562149,
-0.0267864428,
0.0052623185,
-0.0242483485,
0.0354616903,
0.0389775448,
0.0394403264,
-0.0007766948,
-0.0021068451,
-0.0022490197,
0.0376150906,
0.0337876193,
0.0059650899,
-0.0032271512,
0.0124154165,
-0.0488353893,
-0.0372858681,
-0.0069571598,
-0.0135177318,
-0.0069352686,
-0.003619046,
-0.0068879337,
0.0107847098,
-0.0186303537,
-0.0134509318,
0.0227167588,
0.0486074314,
-0.0013595691,
-0.0245366935,
0.0133645572,
0.017009424,
-0.0244890433,
-0.0102674859,
-0.0228944998,
-0.0198521726,
-0.0254501477,
-0.0195786003,
0.0461570323,
-0.038888637,
-0.0741086006,
0.0467677638,
-0.0708625987,
-0.0695048347,
0.0189842805,
-0.0562478863,
0.0022655171,
0.0049052029,
-0.0176774338,
-0.0131158531,
-0.076277934,
-0.0402013138,
-0.0120403431,
-0.0014453286,
0.0027373631,
0.08223176,
-0.031048663,
-0.041547779,
0.0131121436,
-0.0166210886,
0.0122011174,
0.0077652708,
-0.0068584145,
-0.0246042982,
0.0057782368,
0.0113200182,
-0.0173574314,
0.0410498381,
-0.0471004508,
0.0144101996,
-0.0978946984,
-0.0530901775,
-0.0215228144,
-0.0477231666,
-0.0257911589,
-0.035633605,
0.0207239203,
-0.0280131064,
-0.0126313847,
0.0383739211,
-0.0004662184,
0.0060231811,
0.0553451963,
0.0070941295,
0.0275848825,
0.0013242582,
0.0209493563,
0.011468973,
0.0536121316,
0.051651895,
0.0335750766,
-0.0164701436,
0.0131241726,
-0.0281871259,
0.0423315689,
-0.0126271592,
-0.0344230421,
0.019161351,
-0.018034922,
-0.0074669267,
0.0892167911,
0.0037719307,
0.0345614329,
0.0255133454,
-0.0087496573,
-0.0391106531,
0.0001970379,
0.0037813825,
-0.0352720097,
-0.0117728803,
-0.004298639,
-0.044993557,
0.0103547834,
-0.03968025,
-0.0059908135,
-0.0651040599,
0.0303638838,
0.0050100982,
-0.0401058942,
-0.0655586347,
0.0111144828,
0.0330705754,
0.0397567078,
-0.0340232253,
-0.0665085316,
0.07354711,
-0.0187121108,
0.007423379,
-0.004865014,
0.0114791915,
-0.0633644089,
0.0813713595,
0.0132511007,
-0.0017536723,
-0.0554455891,
-0.0066408231,
-0.0356329121,
-0.0472266935,
0.0389299467,
0.0086025596,
0.0726948157,
-0.0852175802,
0.0109048504,
-0.0396251306,
-0.0554318689,
-0.0273163226,
-0.0544306375,
-0.0401859097,
-0.0034860161,
-0.0376440287,
0.001375591,
-0.0148509787,
0.0337213464,
0.0236283578,
0.0116223693,
0.0144431777,
-0.0004502809,
-0.021946013,
0.0403831974,
0.0531224534,
0.0434465297,
-0.0112684928,
-0.0066448404,
0.0060900776,
0.0558320098,
-0.0070550716,
-0.0172146522,
-0.0439697765,
0.0477013588,
0.0209104586,
0.0412650071,
0.0241039693,
0.0288727265,
0.0691982359,
-0.0563170835,
-0.0127520449,
0.0676062554,
0.0142554631,
-0.0313316137,
-0.0357300378,
0.0132786911,
-0.009904637,
0.0302930865,
0.0081401132,
-0.0745833591,
-0.063711293,
-0.0264615417,
-0.0332170539,
0.0061037918,
-0.0344437473,
-0.0165695027,
-0.0973215476,
0.0699701533,
0.0014485207,
-0.0253311899,
-0.0456629246,
-0.0067359377,
-0.0093158232,
-0.0020774412,
-0.0190051571,
-0.0246736389,
-0.0191927757,
-0.0016801762,
-0.0011808184,
0.0285133403,
-0.0322116017,
0.0205657538,
-0.0668973178,
-0.0068168268,
0.0279171914,
0.0340767354,
-0.0067079589,
-0.0956425443,
0.0043130228,
-0.0515828989,
0.0273730997,
-0.0214304961,
0.0443359055,
-0.0164760761,
-0.0444348939,
-0.0065905359,
0.0512525402,
-0.019986704,
-0.0316413753,
-0.0146637131,
0.0511819683,
-0.032842759,
-0.0257806405,
-0.0378300212,
0.0291776545,
0.0229766462,
0.0609266944,
0.0549888499,
0.0201236606,
-0.0500256084,
-0.0029479454,
-0.0441857912,
-0.0347808115,
-0.0459966548,
-0.0113556571,
0.0412768386,
-0.0127193797,
-0.0335107967,
-0.0014800139,
0.0529458337,
0.0469147079,
-0.0106654977,
-0.0053071911,
0.0005325908,
0.024074778,
-0.054133717,
0.0790657327,
-0.044452481,
0.009373486,
-0.0070878132,
0.0153549882,
0.0325265042,
-0.0284030754,
-0.0460067056,
0.0410882384,
-0.0531526729,
-0.0338957384,
-0.0405974612,
0.0701775327,
0.0134253092,
0.0261295866,
0.0178491119,
-0.0468814485,
0.0521217026,
0.0562523417,
0.0126844402,
0.0012228445,
-0.0021723972,
-0.033135049,
0.0025808625,
0.0400157459,
0.0077660442,
0.0078931823,
0.0263638254,
0.0084928079,
-0.0372878276,
0.0181017146,
-0.0168327689,
0.0002540245,
0.0222532358,
-0.0213796105,
0.0375818685,
-0.0326641314,
-0.0038651549,
0.0137274759,
-0.0099459141,
-0.0556066595,
0.0143118454,
0.0170692764,
-0.0033428804,
-0.0078812828,
0.0322964042,
-0.0023452139,
0.0318585373,
-0.0076696458,
0.0132998461,
0.0708253309,
0.0024853358,
0.0118490178,
-0.0173300561,
0.0049292818,
-0.005992719,
-0.0223169923,
0.0479957797,
0.0191931892,
0.102495499,
0.0587726235,
-0.0134501988,
-0.0192097928,
0.0094616627,
-0.0188776627,
-0.0588282496,
0.0092413221,
0.0838699266,
0.0554988496,
-0.026855519,
-0.0201559924,
-0.0159927681,
-0.0322371498,
0.0116269048,
0.0408552364,
-0.0141299004,
-0.0539355688,
0.1047881842,
0.0224236753,
-0.008629892,
-0.0065615582,
0.0448741838,
-0.0120348865,
0.0001065372,
-0.0009896563,
-0.0445044823,
-0.0329333507,
-0.0440238938,
0.0481099449,
-0.002361001,
0.015429059,
0.061905656,
-0.0564931706,
-0.0703700557,
-0.0130232116,
0.0197172295,
-0.0109727783,
0.0400197729,
0.0121323299,
0.0647088513,
0.0499952771,
-0.0528789982,
0.0001631215,
0.0042200433,
-0.0599114075,
0.0255166907,
-0.0161772706,
-6.01319323e-33,
-0.0284522343,
-0.0630563647,
0.0361506641,
-0.0186585952,
0.0082114218,
0.0251142923,
-0.0398531072,
-0.0217111502,
-0.0269270539,
0.0311182253,
0.0263571683,
0.0235599745,
0.0009766455,
0.0296842381,
0.0105037736,
-0.0276747346,
0.0223852415,
0.0243871454,
-0.0133512113,
-0.0073001483,
0.0230933353,
-0.0195108093,
0.016724484,
-0.0393562317,
-0.0136382366,
0.0205486622,
-0.0059480243,
0.0441442803,
-0.0167379417,
0.0502883308,
-0.016269926,
0.0232656132,
0.0236142222,
0.0059041134,
-0.01290482,
0.0556106716,
-0.086713165,
-0.0168121252,
0.0623041131,
0.0276130345,
-0.0629373118,
0.0130203897,
0.0125104096,
0.0057210205,
0.0091464212,
-0.0320783854,
0.0482439026,
-0.0301252585,
0.0248765443,
-0.0182664692,
0.0020476587,
0.0052581858,
-0.017566951,
-0.026898833,
0.0365964547,
-0.0133579606,
0.0035441292,
0.0427560396,
-0.0600097589,
0.0142891649,
0.0103309508,
-0.0260860566,
0.0915596187,
0.0066249375,
0.0129213352,
0.0444809794,
-0.0517107509,
-0.0448075682,
-0.0892552361,
0.0097754495,
0.0079153161,
0.0717583299,
0.0642022938,
0.0463422723,
0.0136504127,
0.0223759413,
-0.0506188236,
-0.002126626,
-0.0643920898,
0.0868696049,
0.0185461491,
0.0013204161,
0.0020152237,
-0.0157744903,
-0.0601684675,
-0.0258627348,
-0.0275796875,
0.0181093756,
0.026786577,
0.0191033408,
-0.0272214804,
0.0629979074,
0.0661305264,
-0.0452010334,
-0.0191057045,
0.0402695648,
0.0041491878,
0.0178451221,
0.0160905141,
0.0345755443,
-0.0384090319,
-0.0066707283,
0.0657317936,
-0.0174406581,
-0.0130226994,
0.0067195077,
0.051427003,
-0.0096071688,
-0.0087108621,
-0.0119358413,
-0.0394492932,
0.005738779,
-0.0208873432,
0.0277898796,
0.0297803115,
0.0393791012,
-0.0445925407,
-0.0072901617,
-0.0215057805,
-0.0090081282,
0.0033252945,
0.0022167105,
-0.0150312502,
0.011623295,
-0.0252619088,
0.0023845099,
-0.0390442163,
-0.0580030829,
0.0358557701,
-0.0677413121,
-0.0077187414,
0.0613696426,
2.443e-7,
0.0299706012,
0.0044202683,
0.0035853039,
0.0069836136,
0.0031059082,
0.0752522647,
-0.0144903418,
0.0148114879,
0.0121381385,
-0.0498902127,
0.017869303,
0.0962599516,
0.0194527768,
0.0136458315,
0.0067658387,
0.0305511244,
-0.0332921334,
-0.0388016738,
-0.0651256815,
-0.0062380848,
0.0586066395,
0.0652510151,
-0.0127681438,
-0.0472795852,
0.0600458458,
-0.0852788314,
0.0588218123,
-0.0312173832,
-0.0001147225,
-0.0290117357,
-0.0089435931,
0.0076277475,
-0.030129157,
0.0519982576,
0.0204439126,
-0.0098504443,
0.010342584,
0.0344361104,
-0.0085495794,
-0.0037185964,
-0.0611834526,
-0.0046893191,
-0.0020458084,
-0.0526842959,
0.0934970304,
-0.1007303149,
-0.0217264034,
-0.0282452591,
-0.0074462038,
-0.0387515575,
0.0285613872,
0.0101081524,
0.0011793821,
0.0197098777,
0.0204829201,
-0.0528395362,
-0.0298533272,
-0.0960361212,
0.0088979322,
-0.0134991072,
-0.0275411103,
-0.0041360459,
-0.0472925715,
-0.0054413029,
0.068597056,
-0.0422956385,
-0.0398207866,
1.760510109e-34,
0.0245506708,
-0.0101672625,
-0.0137053961,
-0.0004892166,
0.051292412,
0.0117770471,
-0.0432956479,
-0.000505603,
0.003683025,
-0.0694701076,
0.0227994733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05861v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05861v2 | Rephrase, Augment, Reason: Visual Grounding of Questions for Vision-Language Models | 2023-10-09T16:57:57 | 2024-04-02T17:37:42 | Archiki Prasad, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Mohit Bansal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG | An increasing number of vision-language tasks can be handled with little to
no training, i.e., in a zero and few-shot manner, by marrying large language
models (LLMs) to vision encoders, resulting in large vision-language models
(LVLMs). While this has huge upsides, such as not requiring training data or
custom architectures, how an input is presented to an LVLM can have a major
impact on zero-shot model performance. In particular, inputs phrased in an
underspecified way can result in incorrect answers due to factors like missing
visual information, complex implicit reasoning, or linguistic ambiguity.
Therefore, adding visually-grounded information to the input as a preemptive
clarification should improve model performance by reducing underspecification,
e.g., by localizing objects and disambiguating references. Similarly, in the
VQA setting, changing the way questions are framed can make them easier for
models to answer. To this end, we present Rephrase, Augment and Reason
(RepARe), a gradient-free framework that extracts salient details about the
image using the underlying LVLM as a captioner and reasoner, in order to
propose modifications to the original question. We then use the LVLM's
confidence over a generated answer as an unsupervised scoring function to
select the rephrased question most likely to improve zero-shot performance.
Focusing on three visual question answering tasks, we show that RepARe can
result in a 3.85% (absolute) increase in zero-shot accuracy on VQAv2, 6.41%,
and 7.94% points increase on A-OKVQA, and VizWiz respectively. Additionally, we
find that using gold answers for oracle question candidate selection achieves a
substantial gain in VQA accuracy by up to 14.41%. Through extensive analysis,
we demonstrate that outputs from RepARe increase syntactic complexity, and
effectively utilize vision-language interaction and the frozen LLM. | [
0.030809585,
0.0478142463,
0.0059041246,
0.0433382392,
-0.0149155362,
0.016460022,
0.0276014898,
0.0002186447,
-0.0163318571,
-0.0797648653,
-0.006069798,
0.0114835771,
0.0095977401,
0.0229788274,
0.0324028023,
-0.0800708011,
0.0332065113,
-0.0389558375,
0.0080882758,
0.0111176483,
0.0151749142,
-0.0092541603,
0.0070822272,
0.0342352465,
-0.0057432991,
-0.0191305168,
-0.0175549388,
0.0383102149,
0.0272403862,
0.0002555466,
-0.0334634744,
0.0276311785,
0.0425255634,
-0.002529518,
0.0000019503,
-0.0258430857,
0.0097644692,
0.0004158073,
-0.0292682219,
-0.0022412683,
-0.0078221522,
-0.0475177877,
0.0077808956,
0.0068022269,
-0.0351853259,
-0.039987985,
0.0664254352,
0.0507024266,
0.0645399317,
0.0487295426,
-0.017717395,
-0.0385161228,
-0.0006199373,
-0.0087509938,
0.0546579659,
-0.0403017588,
-0.0047749048,
0.0439857766,
-0.0094190976,
0.0042798668,
-0.0618807822,
0.0467994362,
0.0555645674,
-0.0329791605,
0.0322537534,
0.0551879592,
-0.0430640094,
-0.0265107807,
-0.009444261,
0.1014919579,
-0.0202528723,
-0.0109515227,
-0.0315734819,
0.0010219754,
0.0234665461,
-0.0001811746,
-0.0649028048,
0.0494940989,
0.0130507294,
0.0104966471,
-0.0433730148,
-0.0072426787,
0.0011985606,
0.0089751361,
-0.0077480432,
0.0114828805,
0.0211799052,
0.0295973662,
-0.0207802299,
0.0289974567,
-0.0519306138,
-0.0908865482,
-0.0485684983,
0.0649012998,
-0.00909671,
0.0065949266,
-0.0439208485,
0.0016500156,
-0.035180442,
-0.0253071319,
0.0423642397,
0.0243919007,
-0.0546960682,
0.0699378848,
-0.0540205836,
0.0696238652,
-0.0031413762,
0.0339174718,
-0.0350444727,
-0.03527648,
-0.0122423489,
-0.0047380985,
-0.041832231,
0.0153571162,
-0.0696564987,
-0.0338128693,
-0.0182411242,
0.0221806988,
-0.0061060437,
-0.0085730515,
-0.0296293665,
0.0504288003,
-0.0096788025,
-0.027015835,
-0.0409284383,
0.0750547945,
-0.0290201493,
0.0178115871,
0.0012872875,
-0.0730497465,
-0.0189165659,
0.0437481739,
0.0506005362,
-0.0193642657,
-0.0152475014,
0.0548011065,
-0.0510509759,
-0.0288453661,
-0.0280087255,
-0.0324502066,
-0.0039504478,
-0.0406009182,
0.0172295552,
-0.0545255989,
0.0036947802,
-0.016349582,
-0.0155253243,
-0.0481326021,
0.0132374642,
0.0251034312,
-0.0131626446,
0.0961897895,
-0.0165442657,
-0.0171444397,
0.0179421287,
0.0148179941,
0.0092306286,
0.0511299782,
0.0147567159,
0.0328692757,
0.0336656794,
-0.0138321072,
0.0468135141,
0.0015713511,
0.0034609514,
0.0053105825,
-0.0557245798,
0.0178030673,
-0.0159392059,
0.0207555294,
0.0435462855,
0.0347385257,
-0.0441137105,
-0.0323909111,
0.0807754621,
0.0472808145,
0.0005706036,
-0.0300951209,
0.0319193043,
-0.0062092682,
0.0062581124,
-0.000121719,
-0.0591492914,
0.0788587481,
-0.0151127763,
0.0181757659,
-0.0318188518,
0.0025925701,
-0.0496609025,
-0.0589269139,
-0.0003008903,
-0.0159779415,
0.0234351326,
0.051754158,
0.0410295054,
0.0336584412,
-0.0343626067,
0.0041513331,
-0.0093174726,
-0.037822336,
-0.0099341245,
-0.041539818,
0.0557705089,
0.0472798981,
0.0237882715,
0.0240725819,
-0.0409223512,
-0.0080909813,
0.039027337,
0.0718709454,
0.0064402032,
-0.0014624422,
0.0316114612,
-0.0518169925,
-0.0534642152,
-0.0418875553,
-0.0031943698,
-0.0088352533,
0.017168019,
-0.0213618651,
0.0348319523,
-0.0298899561,
0.0085251499,
0.0318945609,
0.0298230462,
-0.0200491771,
0.0055714855,
0.0182373747,
-0.0242057834,
-0.0020179753,
-0.0000649104,
0.0030965717,
0.0147247342,
-0.0443740338,
-0.0055381805,
0.0060985666,
-0.0404184535,
-0.04554075,
0.0270453412,
-0.0532380417,
-0.0093865395,
0.009042793,
-0.0468634181,
-0.0245074928,
0.0180191975,
-0.0288035721,
0.0025904339,
-0.0519257337,
-0.0307053179,
0.0035090458,
0.0249896329,
-0.0378452651,
0.0420141518,
-0.0011731029,
-0.031123165,
0.0065726093,
-0.0097359177,
0.0110672535,
-0.03053624,
0.0027554964,
-0.0119128218,
0.00168832,
0.0076617226,
0.0151868407,
0.0288281068,
-0.0582752936,
0.0229021907,
-0.0893242732,
-0.0300110858,
-0.037650343,
-0.0362313204,
0.0218439754,
0.0212773643,
0.0056707808,
-0.0615600236,
-0.040973492,
0.02952406,
-0.0050211898,
0.0153894247,
0.0527434088,
0.0001946012,
-0.0022070615,
-0.0160447583,
-0.0018603078,
0.0367858931,
0.06771788,
0.0364523977,
0.000938118,
-0.038053412,
0.0210482832,
-0.0765029788,
0.0238734875,
-0.0003600275,
-0.00747274,
0.0178874973,
-0.0061696265,
0.0295172166,
0.1067954376,
-0.0241773892,
0.0164799988,
0.01920758,
-0.0005868119,
-0.0410347246,
-0.0009658681,
-0.0058933445,
-0.0553960465,
-0.0038429971,
-0.0213031936,
-0.0441055298,
0.0288307462,
-0.0239458233,
-0.0028889957,
-0.0643630326,
0.0569161959,
0.0112211816,
-0.034731999,
-0.0779357478,
0.0159842931,
0.0263972469,
0.072689645,
-0.0559201948,
-0.0798440129,
0.0615687557,
-0.0183602087,
-0.0211975146,
0.0142539116,
0.0069163642,
-0.0363012329,
0.0568960458,
0.0071431366,
0.00351184,
0.0048948657,
0.0018662966,
-0.0486155115,
-0.0614722669,
0.0015467149,
-0.0075365519,
0.0776667297,
-0.0746232122,
0.0085580535,
-0.0307598412,
-0.0213740692,
-0.048212342,
-0.0185455978,
-0.0433285274,
0.0225057583,
-0.1093983427,
-0.0166730173,
-0.0185410194,
0.0163937975,
0.0522653535,
0.0348998792,
-0.0290503856,
-0.0029644498,
-0.011185253,
0.0381301865,
0.0942387432,
0.0625822246,
0.0176932272,
-0.022912221,
0.0356959291,
0.0593360253,
0.0037491834,
0.0009634921,
-0.028644545,
0.024943972,
0.0025515941,
0.024326833,
0.0034486724,
0.0334733166,
0.0868394151,
-0.057701353,
-0.0205130335,
0.0945851728,
0.0206968393,
-0.0105506992,
-0.011872096,
-0.0272801649,
0.0430198014,
0.0453254431,
0.0301235728,
-0.0889590979,
-0.057141345,
-0.0096833399,
-0.0030831643,
0.0187804289,
-0.0021407828,
-0.0411431417,
-0.1059479043,
0.0812432095,
0.0007934571,
-0.0226521026,
-0.0357358232,
0.0091822539,
-0.0030922964,
0.0081854109,
0.0061448403,
-0.006256578,
0.0098231183,
0.0135362716,
-0.0084307818,
0.0302825086,
-0.0257454757,
-0.0008105825,
-0.0388902724,
-0.0017216522,
0.0617525019,
-0.0077751824,
0.0074047432,
-0.0588670969,
0.0167238284,
-0.025940435,
0.0172759462,
-0.0124792987,
0.068100445,
-0.0103323581,
-0.0365690254,
0.0037857832,
0.0375177711,
-0.0186938047,
-0.0176209155,
-0.0133979321,
0.0317182243,
-0.016674716,
0.0020284136,
-0.0184981637,
-0.0100473724,
-0.0191295817,
0.0433760881,
0.0631230921,
-0.0198802333,
-0.0320353433,
-0.0321695544,
-0.0370626636,
-0.0505995117,
-0.0346334688,
-0.0108363871,
0.0207896102,
-0.0117311282,
-0.0746328458,
-0.0385022573,
0.0556636192,
0.0412080139,
-0.030400455,
-0.0355978459,
-0.0046458445,
0.0055704173,
-0.0758000761,
0.0601809919,
-0.0393816084,
0.0280972347,
-0.0180108827,
0.0182407182,
0.0139113292,
-0.0441518463,
-0.0041899579,
-0.0099382531,
-0.057680659,
-0.03021257,
-0.0297458004,
0.0815703794,
0.0194093604,
0.0556573085,
0.0127522405,
-0.0480899885,
0.0261572674,
0.0093447762,
0.0243947376,
0.0476939455,
0.0063774749,
-0.018877482,
0.0129205137,
0.0459007658,
-0.0308460575,
0.0120240152,
0.0410369895,
0.0209322292,
-0.0091332011,
0.0012677186,
0.0201003123,
0.0125263967,
0.042440448,
0.0041774777,
0.0076836469,
-0.004148317,
0.0369550921,
-0.0301328674,
0.00065113,
-0.0733607709,
0.0156367291,
0.0036636549,
0.0162166823,
0.0147604598,
0.003259422,
-0.0433279499,
0.0294710379,
-0.0261575524,
-0.0094179874,
0.0213405881,
-0.0165781882,
-0.0172201525,
0.022435233,
0.0016519682,
0.0174414273,
-0.0123118917,
0.0573842786,
0.0077515882,
0.0557792783,
0.0244063921,
-0.0209425092,
-0.0504745767,
0.0258702226,
-0.0444425121,
-0.0393321551,
0.0082653509,
0.0668459013,
0.035212636,
0.0133775268,
0.0174095035,
0.0215752739,
-0.0276569743,
-0.0031319989,
0.0404103361,
0.0311970506,
-0.0535604283,
0.0778337419,
0.0285053719,
-0.0120018516,
-0.0055106152,
0.0568826534,
0.0129836528,
0.034485355,
-0.0105525367,
0.0139808636,
-0.0414519794,
-0.0097284503,
0.0224756114,
-0.0023680388,
0.0085991016,
0.0680346563,
-0.0413083211,
-0.0649558455,
-0.0073199025,
0.0214430131,
-0.029348461,
0.0110708149,
0.0458713397,
0.0217635538,
0.0297540817,
-0.0439226627,
-0.0276056025,
0.0093088588,
-0.030503327,
-0.0108637884,
0.0043122205,
-6.269781973e-33,
-0.0369848907,
-0.0378417224,
0.0369636975,
-0.0096372692,
-0.0234606676,
0.0401096642,
-0.0427108184,
0.0164344721,
-0.0490073003,
0.0183415301,
0.0173460972,
0.0042331559,
0.0077215447,
0.0449247584,
-0.0342477784,
-0.0256133601,
0.0152518526,
0.0116222817,
-0.0329652093,
-0.0180630926,
-0.0036046635,
-0.0050694016,
0.0516570471,
-0.0228577163,
-0.0117634023,
0.014472899,
-0.0169773549,
0.0414326228,
0.0121407034,
0.066667676,
-0.0022399449,
0.0325604789,
0.0162877645,
-0.0184281375,
-0.0264268126,
0.0259080511,
-0.0830178931,
-0.0167411659,
0.0465467535,
0.030960463,
-0.0918549001,
-0.0163233466,
0.0469278656,
-0.0100945057,
0.0238872934,
-0.0565923229,
0.0301447343,
-0.02891225,
-0.0191561691,
0.0226315036,
-0.0305582918,
-0.0072611948,
-0.0013983347,
-0.052292265,
0.0308035929,
0.0406932607,
0.0087315785,
0.0433613621,
-0.0319373086,
0.0000733996,
0.005267241,
0.0258908365,
0.099159576,
0.0565013215,
0.004558045,
0.0366790071,
0.025207337,
-0.0446305089,
-0.0561743006,
-0.0190095454,
0.0130753992,
0.0295973755,
0.0750506595,
0.0501371399,
0.0390680246,
0.0533812568,
-0.0770497024,
0.0023930783,
-0.0763064697,
0.0670187324,
-0.0033802704,
0.0172934569,
0.0081924833,
-0.0101570673,
-0.0598272607,
0.0065339454,
-0.0505996533,
-0.0112439096,
0.0533816814,
0.020205019,
-0.025018746,
0.0401996225,
0.0521523654,
-0.0348952301,
0.0269705448,
0.008405569,
-0.0104627153,
0.0542588197,
0.0151268048,
0.004166326,
-0.0238376949,
0.0534055531,
0.0736739933,
0.0054678088,
-0.0044794418,
0.006772507,
0.057061024,
0.0113752168,
-0.0386217684,
-0.0112633323,
-0.0558675565,
0.0101377703,
-0.0234224331,
0.0457601547,
-0.0018303304,
0.0479796715,
-0.0717240497,
0.0370669104,
-0.0177200157,
-0.0091478173,
-0.0114675537,
-0.0169332176,
0.0112652835,
0.0306980703,
-0.0328985229,
0.0096153747,
-0.0226168185,
-0.0021596609,
0.009792991,
-0.0551735535,
-0.0334965624,
0.0467437617,
2.57e-7,
0.0459991805,
0.0148838898,
0.0300888009,
0.0064036311,
-0.0017186875,
0.057238318,
0.0021959641,
0.0025445549,
0.0144503685,
-0.0485655926,
-0.0053696972,
0.0760528818,
0.0363400728,
-0.0177161396,
-0.0291686896,
0.0428930447,
-0.0115473401,
-0.0260473695,
-0.033615265,
-0.0101977326,
0.0655621067,
0.0848126784,
-0.0107503133,
-0.0262690298,
0.0507314391,
-0.013655954,
0.0623156987,
-0.0279439967,
-0.0122467661,
-0.0428963974,
0.0021999639,
0.0112832747,
0.003923147,
0.015889585,
0.0002963037,
-0.028504895,
0.0214120224,
0.0297817532,
-0.0532937162,
-0.0291346759,
-0.055007074,
0.0233606417,
-0.002431798,
-0.0526980385,
0.0969480053,
-0.0503870919,
-0.0382479839,
-0.0211657379,
-0.0467360318,
0.0103347851,
0.0410921276,
-0.0150536066,
-0.0536809973,
0.0041550333,
0.0538598672,
-0.0204457995,
-0.0350577869,
-0.0723906681,
-0.0438260399,
-0.0155738723,
0.0029545857,
-0.0081194593,
-0.0528835654,
-0.0235326439,
0.0424700156,
-0.0294229835,
-0.0475841574,
2.056563412e-34,
0.0298352577,
0.0102173071,
0.0156388022,
0.0237405393,
0.0126642101,
-0.0064816773,
-0.0469234884,
-0.0267976001,
0.0126632396,
-0.0704636201,
-0.0127737094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05857v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05857v2 | Improving Summarization with Human Edits | 2023-10-09T16:52:07 | 2023-10-24T20:00:21 | Zonghai Yao, Benjamin J Schloss, Sai P. Selvaraj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent work has shown the promise of learning with human feedback paradigms
to produce human-determined high-quality text. Existing works use human
feedback to train large language models (LLMs) in general domain abstractive
summarization and have obtained summary quality exceeding traditional
likelihood training. In this paper, we focus on a less explored form of human
feedback -- Human Edits. We propose Sequence Alignment (un)Likelihood Training
(SALT), a novel technique to use both the human-edited and model-generated data
together in the training loop. In addition, we demonstrate simulating Human
Edits with ground truth summaries coming from existing training data --
Imitation edits, along with the model-generated summaries obtained after the
training, to reduce the need for expensive human-edit data. In our experiments,
we extend human feedback exploration from general domain summarization to
medical domain summarization. Our results demonstrate the effectiveness of SALT
in improving the summary quality with Human and Imitation Edits. Through
additional experiments, we show that SALT outperforms the conventional RLHF
method (designed for human preferences) -- DPO, when applied to human-edit
data. We hope the evidence in our paper prompts researchers to explore,
collect, and better use different human feedback approaches scalably. | [
0.0723101497,
0.0426072218,
0.036101561,
-0.0367959291,
-0.0125404606,
0.0079887416,
-0.0315599367,
-0.0054004942,
-0.0199119449,
-0.0435214564,
-0.0364037864,
-0.0639279708,
0.0463414751,
-0.0126947956,
0.0619801581,
-0.10287752,
0.0233057402,
0.0016722971,
-0.006019393,
0.0042710458,
0.0090369843,
-0.008304826,
0.0144471582,
0.0375644527,
0.0378287546,
0.0047127432,
-0.0056217914,
0.0126490202,
0.0624810308,
-0.0266101547,
-0.0113656931,
0.0703453645,
0.0202034377,
0.0264943372,
0.0000019665,
-0.041808717,
-0.0144886952,
0.0234642271,
-0.028902553,
0.0269773975,
0.0414857715,
-0.042184975,
-0.0187160876,
0.0182102099,
-0.0092288973,
-0.0296738707,
0.0221051909,
0.0339552909,
0.0799305066,
0.0744945481,
-0.0066847261,
-0.0211194046,
0.0323665552,
-0.0498267412,
-0.0117008286,
0.0065929834,
0.0357733481,
0.0328978375,
0.0171740483,
-0.013398069,
0.0171785541,
0.032034751,
0.0056460225,
0.0006632097,
0.029562192,
0.0444938652,
-0.0305403098,
-0.0062802285,
0.0214850008,
0.0529585816,
0.0093885977,
-0.0258074179,
0.0281297639,
0.0096418951,
0.0141589232,
0.0097249513,
-0.0426260382,
0.0445872508,
-0.0196416117,
0.0185945705,
-0.0176943857,
-0.0243202727,
0.0153263845,
0.0226791725,
-0.0052212602,
-0.0245408043,
0.0181351174,
-0.0245353673,
-0.017002942,
0.0157254376,
-0.0451441109,
-0.0758759379,
0.0111623816,
0.010964605,
-0.031417042,
-0.0058258898,
-0.0907110944,
-0.063465558,
0.0347217917,
-0.0692263022,
0.0120813698,
0.0124812797,
0.0284052342,
0.0161689334,
0.0018741575,
-0.001486285,
0.0003495554,
0.0342084244,
-0.0549533665,
0.021803027,
-0.034267433,
0.0126868663,
-0.0238894131,
0.0245470796,
-0.0410178192,
0.0117070638,
-0.0928141475,
0.0023847634,
0.0126463221,
0.0093896585,
-0.0275851022,
0.0070003886,
-0.0500389114,
-0.0239683222,
-0.0085181352,
0.0062487451,
0.0015188332,
-0.0229915958,
0.0270636082,
-0.0032079432,
-0.0082279108,
0.0234641265,
0.0222468562,
-0.0086439587,
-0.0071631749,
0.0262923185,
-0.0202136897,
-0.0281214174,
-0.0102672745,
-0.0413085558,
0.0074922829,
-0.0165439267,
-0.040326681,
-0.0654804185,
0.0077434494,
-0.0156766884,
-0.0220449343,
-0.0463758931,
0.017143717,
0.0147523284,
-0.0408689417,
0.046808321,
-0.0568726137,
0.020590052,
0.0551779829,
-0.0099906558,
0.0166689884,
0.0213418026,
0.057447046,
0.0217536446,
0.0184209719,
0.0178246591,
0.016503986,
0.0225713402,
0.0102084065,
0.0139944991,
0.0080984347,
-0.0055366615,
-0.003879081,
0.0622287691,
0.0502399281,
0.0700564981,
-0.0397397391,
0.0188214406,
0.087678127,
0.0534745343,
0.0016879549,
0.0052096723,
0.0334015563,
0.0324660055,
0.0379087739,
0.0589660704,
-0.0225904696,
0.010539283,
-0.0265887734,
0.0894203112,
0.0883138627,
-0.017249858,
-0.007629063,
-0.0398572311,
-0.023285199,
0.0030399722,
-0.0078788465,
-0.0076610418,
0.0305302348,
0.000633208,
-0.0478086844,
0.034338396,
0.0449289195,
-0.0565065444,
0.0167270135,
-0.0313135162,
0.0075455252,
0.0692513809,
0.0673511252,
-0.0183603857,
-0.024704216,
-0.0407189801,
-0.0054353699,
0.0404415615,
0.0487197265,
-0.0145026799,
-0.0328435935,
-0.0377689153,
-0.0248275101,
0.0415758528,
-0.0033418715,
-0.0051497193,
0.0103205657,
-0.0614373498,
0.0336943977,
0.0004307092,
-0.0955470279,
0.0471514538,
-0.0594854429,
0.0005961718,
-0.0077789435,
0.0031397771,
0.0275826268,
0.0373653434,
-0.0362376533,
0.037003722,
0.01979471,
-0.0183143429,
-0.0234175306,
0.0214798357,
-0.0156113682,
-0.0297510307,
0.034696307,
-0.0415353552,
-0.035753265,
0.0126040932,
0.0026486116,
-0.0447898284,
-0.041290883,
-0.0664191768,
0.0300352499,
-0.0562130921,
0.040406812,
0.0363527015,
-0.020887142,
-0.0431876667,
0.0328500532,
-0.0150054879,
-0.0085262675,
0.0344441198,
-0.0403494053,
-0.0077094533,
-0.0450654961,
0.0019418905,
0.0024497553,
0.026706554,
0.012937665,
0.0375581309,
0.0047272388,
-0.0448959768,
-0.0086453855,
-0.1107247397,
-0.0044928645,
-0.0182457753,
0.0255642962,
0.0607450902,
0.0258799717,
-0.013866337,
-0.0025977765,
-0.0312140174,
-0.0605954118,
-0.0119589707,
0.0113815926,
0.0491844304,
0.0181861334,
0.0329808071,
-0.0841325149,
-0.0012262204,
-0.0201710463,
0.027868567,
0.0142822051,
-0.032052774,
-0.0440327525,
0.0193931665,
-0.0057392865,
-0.0152213508,
0.0295887105,
-0.0249025654,
-0.0122600589,
0.0088309394,
0.0760363415,
0.0426612683,
0.0406416804,
-0.0126779731,
0.0419146828,
0.0418501496,
-0.0209719259,
-0.0197676718,
-0.0206297785,
-0.0005561292,
-0.0007685158,
-0.0298279133,
0.0374623612,
0.0770490542,
0.0111148963,
0.0123963868,
-0.0412916578,
0.0010066095,
-0.0118466942,
-0.0262716692,
-0.0463663153,
-0.0155349206,
-0.0515736006,
0.0385796726,
-0.0308521893,
-0.0333220474,
0.1168207526,
-0.0084261987,
0.0309223849,
-0.063681677,
0.0009011684,
-0.0280656498,
-0.0006381689,
0.0010248049,
0.0320109613,
0.0140580647,
-0.0081583327,
-0.0520010851,
-0.0087404652,
0.0523729175,
-0.0443363637,
0.0788829848,
-0.0792235956,
0.0123557178,
-0.0297727156,
-0.0311787538,
-0.0317407623,
-0.055850517,
-0.0158376135,
0.0107364515,
0.0185225308,
-0.0169580188,
-0.0476609431,
0.0159748867,
0.0321865082,
0.0785006434,
-0.0127746249,
-0.0136241764,
-0.0026262738,
0.0372501053,
0.0747040659,
0.0034276322,
-0.0053353175,
-0.070402436,
0.0274850167,
0.0524215214,
0.0373302475,
0.0097312331,
0.0153236296,
-0.0291015692,
-0.0103728976,
-0.0740680397,
0.0131171076,
0.0292940475,
0.0612338744,
-0.0279565789,
0.0051786778,
0.123283647,
0.0306209344,
-0.0549533032,
0.0012082482,
-0.0001915533,
0.026225917,
-0.0087988125,
0.0376875922,
-0.0549723655,
-0.0348133929,
0.012667574,
0.0461440943,
0.0118775656,
-0.0355027169,
0.0066674561,
-0.0880800858,
0.0091502862,
0.0363525152,
-0.0641533509,
-0.0614226386,
-0.0356782004,
0.0144835813,
-0.024443958,
0.0056654727,
0.0520140976,
-0.0202425923,
0.029162813,
0.0126085831,
-0.039612826,
-0.0283047818,
-0.0362138674,
-0.0659841299,
0.0238987822,
0.1029153243,
0.0270336252,
0.0116141159,
0.00549467,
0.0287171267,
0.0147117283,
0.0036320444,
0.0171238277,
0.0733853877,
-0.0220674556,
0.0285197198,
-0.030720165,
0.0704973266,
0.0166749153,
-0.0190168321,
0.0003323126,
0.025121782,
-0.0094013652,
0.0215667225,
-0.0362781063,
0.0293383952,
-0.011356107,
0.0469687916,
0.0449893735,
-0.0386949964,
0.0040469519,
-0.029759869,
0.0153760631,
-0.0311582759,
-0.0460082702,
-0.0174248498,
-0.0723991543,
-0.0050024888,
-0.1081917882,
-0.0535512008,
0.0375465304,
-0.0170025621,
0.0212465432,
-0.0071358718,
0.0175685938,
-0.0200780053,
-0.0315575413,
0.0229489207,
-0.0115557723,
0.0115265353,
-0.0683825314,
-0.0536408164,
0.035877075,
-0.0372097194,
-0.0044466192,
0.0248701889,
-0.0511294827,
-0.0499540418,
-0.0187626388,
0.0460037589,
0.0204289835,
0.0812137499,
0.026957741,
-0.0239110868,
0.0320011415,
0.009972739,
0.0052778265,
0.0305595323,
0.0172402076,
0.047072161,
-0.0177034829,
0.0191814657,
-0.0288576279,
-0.0009565059,
0.0168157388,
0.038074974,
0.0020638239,
-0.0723201111,
0.0393993743,
0.0270771515,
0.0501288064,
-0.0416216888,
-0.0362302996,
-0.0182023421,
0.0002956157,
-0.0299569089,
-0.0132011324,
-0.0203582924,
0.0091557615,
-0.0048050513,
0.0079098307,
-0.021199394,
0.040509399,
-0.0467305109,
-0.0071249981,
-0.0444054529,
0.0053151259,
-0.0459098332,
-0.0169893038,
0.003498774,
-0.0055762785,
-0.0253869724,
-0.0111506032,
-0.0108505832,
0.041064363,
0.0103417952,
0.0268741753,
0.0092779323,
0.0101797041,
0.0092162145,
0.0576419197,
-0.0832383558,
0.0111003863,
-0.0693173334,
0.0087726228,
0.0452268347,
-0.0114913657,
0.0674663633,
-0.0132966321,
-0.007287221,
-0.0335511826,
0.0651974007,
-0.0328554399,
0.0256361421,
-0.0194599014,
0.0170268659,
0.0034840177,
-0.0014852881,
0.090230234,
-0.0012607729,
0.0310326759,
-0.0358641967,
-0.0375285819,
-0.0475717783,
-0.0264212228,
-0.0160971601,
-0.0017428888,
-0.0524489433,
-0.035672877,
-0.0624781474,
-0.0397786349,
-0.004301602,
0.03377942,
-0.0052630799,
-0.0054747262,
0.0420095585,
0.0000134469,
-0.0505855903,
-0.0111684594,
-0.0546919033,
0.0243278258,
0.0111946752,
-0.0099559873,
-0.0227257702,
-5.789407023e-33,
-0.0247807167,
-0.0316935852,
-0.0052581197,
-0.0029814839,
-0.0422981419,
0.0012349675,
-0.0728503242,
0.0107791284,
0.0400282852,
0.0023467988,
-0.0364369787,
-0.0046306695,
0.004737047,
0.0205190629,
0.0221552625,
0.0414558686,
0.0635247827,
0.0012188077,
-0.0396355279,
-0.0015053692,
-0.0199281294,
0.0372560658,
0.0389944986,
-0.0262993015,
0.0426277854,
0.0030544912,
-0.0052759098,
-0.0089828707,
0.0117167002,
0.0251905285,
-0.006173864,
-0.0108508598,
0.0018213503,
-0.050662078,
-0.0597601272,
-0.0048579341,
-0.05773592,
0.0308211334,
0.0105340378,
-0.0423613898,
-0.0546598658,
-0.0444126911,
0.0535240993,
-0.0231327917,
-0.0196471456,
-0.0225654654,
0.048460003,
-0.0437235273,
-0.0318737552,
-0.0375389606,
-0.0384420082,
0.0585235357,
-0.0068814345,
-0.0285621565,
0.0138969319,
0.0256703217,
-0.0154862776,
-0.0156089058,
-0.0338898711,
0.0445875041,
0.0510208979,
0.042243354,
0.0255028401,
0.0136497794,
0.0137927243,
0.0366372913,
0.0236396827,
-0.0114829559,
-0.0034695286,
0.018019015,
-0.0357470326,
-0.006282649,
0.0251559839,
0.069872655,
0.0378564745,
0.0152895832,
-0.0237931367,
0.0963679254,
-0.0957690254,
0.0329500958,
-0.0031365626,
0.023989195,
-0.0242467783,
0.0053075384,
-0.0236766506,
0.0038121722,
0.0120403534,
-0.0188928563,
-0.0278784726,
0.0090084309,
-0.0400611237,
-0.0022429097,
-0.0001171896,
-0.0180087332,
0.0317639746,
-0.0309719592,
-0.0060235448,
0.0297804344,
-0.0318340808,
-0.0526749454,
-0.0452000462,
0.0255403221,
0.0321923569,
0.0220760852,
0.0148661183,
-0.00815864,
0.0582730249,
-0.0088975206,
-0.0477126427,
0.0232641418,
0.0041029672,
0.0123095801,
-0.0025206138,
0.0158519447,
0.0308791343,
-0.0007325549,
0.0186156109,
0.0485901646,
-0.0213975925,
-0.0198782999,
-0.0375196487,
0.0270344131,
0.0257958751,
0.0103561021,
-0.0233342908,
0.0427977033,
-0.0040315641,
0.0226130728,
0.0557747856,
-0.0369903408,
-0.0292358603,
-0.0177803691,
2.574e-7,
0.0499391332,
0.0598477833,
0.070689626,
-0.040628016,
-0.0153445415,
0.0551796556,
-0.0019869839,
0.0256868564,
0.0135991462,
0.0135459546,
0.076910235,
-0.0098279901,
0.0757491589,
-0.0081665805,
-0.1150725335,
-0.0337250531,
-0.0906385407,
0.0058745164,
-0.0093135759,
-0.0390698202,
0.0439062454,
0.0663992986,
-0.0234152284,
-0.0032228602,
0.0235046446,
0.0009099948,
0.0514601916,
-0.0381661281,
-0.047482688,
0.0186995734,
0.030762786,
0.011130698,
-0.0044147121,
-0.0094238417,
-0.0587108694,
-0.0404936075,
0.0280131251,
0.0680349246,
-0.0267326552,
0.0188403782,
0.0052224458,
0.0057360167,
0.0398935042,
-0.0033917294,
0.0174404457,
-0.05525361,
-0.0212823134,
-0.0420965217,
-0.0145904822,
0.0059991381,
-0.0059056855,
-0.0152595174,
-0.0269660149,
0.0515040979,
0.0149877751,
0.0319327451,
-0.0220370032,
-0.0417033732,
-0.0644493178,
0.0030560009,
-0.0159316417,
-0.0184037462,
0.0010461542,
-0.0235838089,
-0.0156150125,
-0.078683272,
-0.0084259156,
2.49931864e-34,
0.0740532652,
0.003929419,
-0.0109792668,
0.0212760177,
0.0396197587,
-0.0164958779,
-0.0003828418,
0.0009439414,
0.0345480256,
-0.0667059869,
-0.0225945916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05845v1 | GraphLLM: Boosting Graph Reasoning Ability of Large Language Model | 2023-10-09T16:42:00 | 2023-10-09T16:42:00 | Ziwei Chai, Tianjie Zhang, Liang Wu, Kaiqiao Han, Xiaohai Hu, Xuanwen Huang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has remarkably pushed the
boundaries towards artificial general intelligence (AGI), with their
exceptional ability on understanding diverse types of information, including
but not limited to images and audio. Despite this progress, a critical gap
remains in empowering LLMs to proficiently understand and reason on graph data.
Recent studies underscore LLMs' underwhelming performance on fundamental graph
reasoning tasks. In this paper, we endeavor to unearth the obstacles that
impede LLMs in graph reasoning, pinpointing the common practice of converting
graphs into natural language descriptions (Graph2Text) as a fundamental
bottleneck. To overcome this impediment, we introduce GraphLLM, a pioneering
end-to-end approach that synergistically integrates graph learning models with
LLMs. This synergy equips LLMs with the ability to proficiently interpret and
reason on graph data, harnessing the superior expressive power of graph
learning models. Our empirical evaluations across four fundamental graph
reasoning tasks validate the effectiveness of GraphLLM. The results exhibit a
substantial average accuracy enhancement of 54.44%, alongside a noteworthy
context reduction of 96.45% across various graph reasoning tasks. | [
0.021608308,
0.036084339,
0.012379515,
0.0612640604,
-0.0366174988,
0.0241505522,
-0.0103675872,
-0.0015518203,
0.0527471043,
-0.0253202971,
0.0011096139,
-0.0157785099,
0.0012528041,
0.0519446507,
0.0207614154,
-0.0247963928,
0.0047570192,
-0.0344969854,
0.0245143063,
-0.0139379166,
-0.0138337761,
0.0579202212,
0.0150261475,
0.0218504295,
-0.0269890502,
0.0031918127,
-0.0012027818,
0.0368837081,
-0.0165684018,
-0.0570813455,
-0.059195172,
-0.0030247397,
0.0564394444,
0.0121991187,
0.0000017853,
-0.0346686617,
-0.010977569,
0.0079830876,
-0.0471769907,
-0.0061544264,
0.0161772277,
-0.0387579687,
0.0384988785,
-0.0127406614,
-0.0383974761,
-0.0141721964,
0.0325901583,
0.0332310982,
0.0471182764,
0.0588951111,
-0.0240674596,
-0.0498063155,
-0.0071577081,
-0.0067089926,
0.0189640764,
-0.0589500032,
0.0320021957,
0.0296405964,
0.0496262126,
-0.0310531668,
-0.0443223268,
0.0148233566,
0.0204978399,
-0.0256994348,
0.0360539071,
0.0346800238,
0.0012965399,
0.0083760973,
0.0201116167,
0.1165786311,
0.0068077124,
-0.0302134473,
0.0026987367,
0.0026055484,
-0.0099165179,
0.0324678198,
-0.0506806672,
-0.0000059071,
-0.02784466,
0.026920082,
-0.0306897908,
-0.0548260435,
0.0914515108,
0.0102871982,
-0.0450579859,
0.1066073924,
-0.0204481911,
0.0199859291,
0.0387484282,
0.0070329001,
-0.04282213,
-0.0131353736,
0.0007233266,
0.0739992112,
-0.058480598,
0.0182611216,
-0.0013574427,
0.0241363384,
-0.0104376562,
0.0064697117,
0.0276471283,
-0.0137838814,
0.017032221,
0.0779489726,
-0.0156008517,
0.0400557667,
-0.0367211103,
0.0692744851,
-0.036885336,
-0.056838423,
-0.0534999333,
-0.0061612516,
-0.0280788001,
0.0243596304,
-0.0065024309,
-0.0764409527,
-0.022359211,
0.0456981622,
-0.0190472286,
0.0100644771,
0.0222008731,
0.0436562188,
0.028060142,
-0.0393242799,
-0.0150891757,
0.013845141,
0.0076051983,
0.0151611613,
-0.0346424393,
-0.0028444987,
0.008664364,
0.0106084347,
0.0568604507,
-0.0212671664,
0.0221216548,
0.0853390247,
0.0365682878,
-0.0113245007,
-0.0187763441,
-0.0197636317,
-0.010511579,
-0.0648095161,
0.0166193824,
-0.0776399225,
0.0191484373,
0.0478360541,
-0.0168143362,
-0.0334886387,
0.0267537069,
-0.0266064852,
-0.0820770115,
0.0804425701,
-0.0327965878,
0.0332823507,
0.009228671,
-0.0156653821,
-0.0233373307,
0.020391129,
0.0437080637,
0.0069388491,
0.023032628,
0.0059138676,
-0.0244016051,
0.0203943923,
0.0148336096,
-0.0074857497,
0.0030950636,
-0.0107954601,
-0.0442496091,
0.0074857706,
0.0008821063,
0.0731732696,
-0.0167341344,
-0.0219746456,
0.0360055231,
0.0548927449,
-0.0079804929,
-0.0470550284,
0.0420768,
0.0292741787,
-0.0157590024,
-0.0073313904,
-0.0732081681,
0.0086276596,
0.009031021,
0.03776595,
-0.0069396342,
-0.0230464041,
0.0166974068,
-0.0098614525,
-0.025726229,
-0.0225075893,
0.0981469005,
0.0156429838,
0.0638312474,
0.009505976,
-0.0268099774,
0.030579932,
0.0322755612,
-0.0039450522,
0.0023715051,
-0.0114984605,
-0.0052176518,
0.0805345699,
0.0336253457,
0.0075043645,
-0.0224254746,
0.0096681183,
0.0007272519,
0.0039438559,
0.0150961112,
-0.0125758937,
-0.0113245286,
-0.0454323031,
-0.0317838266,
-0.0473513603,
-0.0159322042,
0.00581198,
0.0066724946,
-0.0069757812,
-0.0051189032,
-0.1056500673,
-0.0414300896,
-0.0105674956,
0.0347536355,
0.0008839578,
-0.0078256847,
0.013559957,
-0.0205441266,
0.0120822731,
0.0122461971,
0.0327552147,
0.0017985398,
0.0045706932,
-0.032189358,
0.0069637252,
-0.0377326719,
-0.0360909551,
0.0498919934,
-0.0350730605,
-0.0480185784,
0.0015560704,
-0.0701390952,
-0.0355614498,
0.0354990736,
-0.0662154853,
0.0411242843,
0.0082853809,
-0.0132840807,
0.0114001231,
-0.0064255144,
0.0066812295,
0.0569120385,
0.0079724872,
-0.026726922,
0.0112988828,
0.0492834039,
0.0086577442,
-0.0457520038,
0.02001632,
0.0393863954,
0.0054499228,
0.0091890087,
-0.0002073998,
-0.006871942,
-0.0486111753,
0.0600819625,
-0.080952473,
-0.021634372,
0.0115348315,
0.0099151758,
-0.0057162661,
-0.0150616029,
0.01561563,
-0.0297497157,
-0.0382464714,
0.0262468047,
0.0275705624,
0.0073896158,
0.0384564511,
-0.0374999866,
-0.0227865819,
-0.0077492264,
-0.0406675786,
-0.0431585573,
0.0968561172,
0.048194021,
-0.0311764535,
-0.0046178717,
0.0334180966,
-0.0521791354,
0.0165150315,
-0.0042814724,
0.0393877178,
0.0183699839,
-0.0330447853,
0.0178047866,
0.069787778,
-0.0426655486,
0.025921151,
0.0337728523,
-0.0045596119,
-0.0250844285,
-0.0114596775,
-0.0244317818,
-0.0092210472,
-0.0489917994,
-0.025937397,
-0.0536444671,
0.0007455375,
0.0027801041,
-0.0005554349,
-0.0261097178,
0.0029421102,
-0.0120154526,
0.0431932621,
-0.0441540219,
-0.0510118753,
0.0225118231,
0.0083993403,
-0.0639562234,
-0.0204140544,
0.0874607489,
-0.0154044461,
0.0018269791,
0.0396395735,
-0.034229286,
-0.082268931,
0.0950561911,
0.0378614292,
0.0206933357,
-0.0216772258,
-0.0416503325,
-0.0260784607,
-0.0098355748,
0.0503290705,
-0.0201012008,
0.0378006808,
-0.0310985558,
0.0413461402,
0.0235510431,
-0.0107155303,
-0.0071358215,
0.0224395003,
-0.0680197999,
0.0288875345,
-0.0090902504,
-0.0396141484,
0.0076628141,
-0.0006243991,
-0.0168299098,
-0.0274585597,
-0.0232082903,
0.0130919954,
-0.0267713405,
0.0294517875,
0.0335175991,
0.004506046,
-0.0030215743,
-0.0373141728,
0.0141405165,
0.0397002287,
0.0091622882,
-0.0158641767,
-0.0432443097,
0.0424718671,
-0.0232232399,
0.0156464726,
-0.0134273116,
-0.0203492735,
0.0547803007,
-0.0731536299,
0.0206325855,
0.0715066418,
0.0042848154,
-0.0204177629,
-0.0052182078,
0.0166672263,
-0.0043329587,
0.0331493206,
0.0040728282,
-0.0831081942,
-0.0476302467,
-0.0016199995,
0.0084574297,
0.0449648015,
-0.0477435775,
-0.0150169916,
-0.0987515599,
0.0224921592,
0.0332859829,
-0.0118896905,
-0.0487562045,
-0.0600247718,
-0.006519563,
0.0005559736,
-0.0068282071,
-0.0320021585,
-0.026959423,
-0.0075700074,
0.001306986,
-0.0118847089,
-0.015578662,
0.0434650965,
-0.0162178073,
-0.0122929541,
-0.0267084204,
0.045628354,
0.0369786061,
-0.0107349223,
0.0507985055,
0.0453837328,
-0.0045208922,
-0.0183695462,
0.0383194908,
0.014722269,
-0.0008471875,
-0.0316276699,
0.0241622906,
-0.0470255092,
-0.0395784229,
-0.0760318711,
0.1009590849,
0.0005114261,
-0.0445715189,
0.0013662206,
0.0016941011,
-0.027750669,
0.0210971236,
0.0488582142,
0.0460265689,
-0.0741729811,
-0.0649280325,
-0.0181008019,
-0.0568566695,
-0.038102258,
0.040686816,
-0.0173499752,
0.0153269107,
-0.0124681527,
-0.0124263261,
0.0391449295,
-0.0036471174,
-0.0134532917,
0.0140195256,
0.03784113,
-0.0464847945,
-0.0898229107,
0.0487739705,
-0.046253968,
0.0585173629,
0.0228616036,
-0.0097327242,
0.00181754,
0.0048689195,
-0.0103678573,
0.0304151196,
-0.062020231,
-0.0811705589,
-0.0501632877,
-0.0214875899,
0.0228773598,
0.0552148633,
-0.0026666757,
-0.0009834081,
0.0352848992,
0.0133361891,
-0.0042040828,
-0.0232212562,
0.0175349303,
0.0054398165,
-0.0144030573,
0.0309514273,
-0.0563938357,
-0.0082599577,
0.0297538191,
0.037719626,
-0.0273856688,
-0.0252530407,
0.0081288815,
0.0800952092,
-0.0005194778,
0.0345260575,
0.0009589189,
-0.0400268957,
-0.0286052097,
-0.0067637879,
-0.0281880312,
0.0022576796,
-0.0021881429,
0.0249657184,
0.0005993754,
0.004481147,
-0.0478230938,
0.0289415382,
0.0259793978,
-0.0122134779,
-0.0192676336,
0.0095548481,
-0.023716446,
0.0423383489,
-0.0050292248,
0.0005849532,
0.0363723859,
0.021708617,
0.0102657219,
0.0009302346,
0.0299767125,
0.0358662046,
-0.0254795756,
-0.0685704723,
-0.0064993268,
-0.0584467836,
-0.0779024661,
0.0351603739,
-0.0072873584,
0.0597471446,
0.015754655,
0.0317268483,
-0.0037319751,
-0.0117823137,
-0.0014431204,
0.0651204884,
0.0045574429,
-0.057913065,
0.0519067198,
0.0242866781,
0.0006149987,
0.0274637453,
0.0245735701,
0.0361361429,
0.0171318296,
-0.0036056831,
-0.050630264,
-0.022589054,
-0.0374269523,
-0.0243303552,
0.0310272649,
0.0037901653,
0.0263593532,
-0.0445027761,
-0.111527577,
0.009740633,
-0.0000339123,
-0.0013894924,
0.0029970396,
0.0095491949,
0.0165565051,
0.0524563529,
-0.0303088538,
-0.0327916443,
0.0456147008,
-0.0251669232,
0.0133204516,
0.0084022889,
-5.948483735e-33,
-0.0003306332,
-0.107207045,
0.0238056872,
0.0122157978,
-0.0436723381,
0.0166905299,
-0.0652240962,
-0.0178413112,
-0.0343924649,
0.0323250368,
0.0134734595,
0.0212986581,
-0.0033237026,
0.0169463493,
-0.0352153629,
-0.0258431919,
0.0039998787,
0.0340631977,
0.003424539,
0.0261912756,
0.0456897914,
0.0354238525,
0.0323743522,
-0.0716319159,
0.026127141,
-0.0141388755,
0.0109973261,
0.0295148566,
-0.009564382,
0.0399853848,
-0.0081171691,
0.0402505957,
0.0420229547,
0.010517356,
-0.0013987559,
0.0387245975,
-0.0868505687,
-0.0098595461,
0.0305112395,
0.0146207381,
-0.0474803559,
-0.0234307796,
0.0511491224,
0.0071512274,
0.0323970169,
-0.0508602373,
0.0551046506,
-0.0024542024,
-0.0267291665,
0.033387199,
-0.0398528837,
0.0243271701,
-0.0276472885,
0.0023036706,
0.0147623038,
-0.0193543136,
-0.0115648033,
0.0307276305,
-0.0381466858,
0.0332780741,
-0.0480345003,
-0.0488108061,
0.0398235619,
0.0113406712,
0.0140219284,
0.0375727788,
-0.0105197495,
-0.015733052,
-0.0538269877,
-0.0027673482,
0.0062388116,
0.1101120934,
-0.0107671292,
0.0006844839,
-0.0262693428,
0.0115358606,
-0.0972465947,
-0.005018943,
-0.0146549745,
0.0516955853,
-0.0093129063,
0.0309949573,
0.0066536767,
-0.0586314835,
-0.0189398881,
-0.020503141,
-0.0420743264,
-0.0034406956,
-0.0154953701,
-0.0401785746,
-0.0211659875,
0.0353310965,
-0.0083327433,
-0.0677184314,
-0.0351638533,
0.0811316818,
-0.0005552123,
0.0177178178,
-0.0210835263,
0.0331001207,
-0.0116960304,
-0.0197452847,
0.0047536651,
-0.0220570732,
0.0271764733,
0.0220249332,
0.0531459861,
0.0148184281,
-0.0085054357,
-0.0056377635,
-0.0807447731,
-0.045284491,
-0.042180527,
-0.0178538915,
0.0535544045,
0.0735239536,
-0.0043534632,
0.0647727996,
0.0193378665,
0.0507244989,
-0.0187260658,
0.0210390668,
-0.0152115794,
0.0321985967,
-0.0302741919,
-0.0154238725,
-0.028679844,
0.0069492124,
0.031205941,
-0.0545014888,
-0.0238497667,
-0.0126678869,
2.588e-7,
0.0721288025,
0.0582704023,
0.0303091481,
0.0503451377,
0.0083340099,
0.0305270609,
-0.0368846953,
-0.0066946512,
0.0035039689,
-0.0081885373,
0.0357107557,
0.098824434,
-0.0192503799,
0.024380764,
-0.0255891718,
0.0633127242,
-0.0602326244,
-0.0609920211,
-0.0675597563,
0.0440943576,
0.047010731,
0.0382956266,
0.0406114012,
-0.0385472514,
0.0010643764,
-0.0852085948,
0.0491987355,
-0.0175317936,
-0.0006818276,
-0.0120957689,
-0.0150103085,
-0.0079979254,
-0.0202437192,
0.0181476399,
0.0136541212,
0.0152113158,
0.021365393,
0.0282015093,
-0.0221996978,
-0.0004429533,
-0.01762297,
-0.0420922451,
0.0153037515,
-0.0344030373,
0.0816302896,
-0.0354183875,
-0.0666633025,
-0.0185589194,
-0.0233653188,
-0.0337652117,
-0.0114873014,
0.0095899375,
-0.0059663136,
0.0051134815,
0.0132797891,
-0.0373744965,
0.0152020259,
-0.0865309015,
0.0114415577,
0.0355672091,
-0.0062693045,
-0.0138637926,
0.0076963208,
0.0275161304,
0.0458950326,
0.0014335009,
0.0124684144,
2.043715856e-34,
0.0311048571,
0.0164385159,
-0.0048643374,
-0.0166051425,
0.0614188462,
-0.0203524977,
-0.0475929901,
0.0278559588,
0.0285132919,
-0.0981792435,
0.00227156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05824v1 | Terminology-Aware Translation with Constrained Decoding and Large Language Model Prompting | 2023-10-09T16:08:23 | 2023-10-09T16:08:23 | Nikolay Bogoychev, Pinzhen Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Terminology correctness is important in the downstream application of machine
translation, and a prevalent way to ensure this is to inject terminology
constraints into a translation system. In our submission to the WMT 2023
terminology translation task, we adopt a translate-then-refine approach which
can be domain-independent and requires minimal manual efforts. We annotate
random source words with pseudo-terminology translations obtained from word
alignment to first train a terminology-aware model. Further, we explore two
post-processing methods. First, we use an alignment process to discover whether
a terminology constraint has been violated, and if so, we re-decode with the
violating word negatively constrained. Alternatively, we leverage a large
language model to refine a hypothesis by providing it with terminology
constraints. Results show that our terminology-aware model learns to
incorporate terminologies effectively, and the large language model refinement
process can further improve terminology recall. | [
0.0418692715,
0.0338995978,
0.0187923089,
0.0245962124,
-0.0048133456,
0.000365188,
-0.0346423313,
-0.0179312564,
-0.0581716523,
-0.0418638699,
-0.0399912819,
-0.0488315821,
0.0170081295,
-0.011504977,
0.0371381938,
-0.0206863694,
0.0564509295,
-0.0082470411,
-0.0538587719,
0.0085554179,
-0.0052776295,
0.0113118635,
0.006859405,
0.0001028654,
-0.0277497992,
-0.023123499,
0.0330624692,
0.0375445411,
0.0016057462,
-0.010635172,
0.0305512976,
0.0355229415,
0.0305582788,
0.0895247087,
0.0000018495,
-0.077589266,
-0.0848935395,
0.0023433976,
-0.0150714666,
0.0264327694,
0.0472266451,
-0.0712805539,
-0.000101072,
-0.0118323462,
-0.0265496168,
-0.0335152037,
0.0712619871,
0.0174336415,
0.0753788576,
0.0493904389,
-0.0119230375,
-0.0369035564,
-0.0163596254,
-0.0410537235,
-0.0077902279,
-0.0760630518,
-0.0039478485,
0.0104453815,
-0.0402511321,
0.0262771081,
-0.0095270183,
0.0458395891,
-0.0150439637,
0.027323287,
0.0555750914,
-0.0092912056,
-0.010775649,
-0.0386617035,
-0.0017009276,
0.0704383403,
0.0513964593,
-0.0111678522,
-0.0329789594,
0.0231783092,
0.0005232386,
0.0270450301,
-0.0348103605,
0.0190485362,
-0.0056255586,
-0.0130520472,
0.0296564084,
0.0354414918,
0.0436080322,
0.0166019592,
-0.0489882044,
0.0291046295,
0.0326071866,
-0.0433067493,
-0.0197902657,
0.0048406278,
-0.0426313207,
0.0058024963,
0.0224462599,
-0.0135753527,
-0.0223018136,
0.0430295132,
-0.0136533538,
-0.0128047224,
0.0411935076,
-0.0730178952,
-0.0024150503,
0.0350761525,
0.0023049952,
0.0379549004,
-0.0076694665,
0.0566451587,
-0.0176879913,
-0.0021772878,
-0.0752874613,
-0.0133314682,
-0.0409158207,
-0.0001224339,
-0.0444632024,
-0.0125690298,
0.0067534796,
0.0059913201,
-0.0463879257,
0.0117245484,
0.003525174,
0.0305440165,
-0.0081974715,
-0.0232688375,
-0.0946603864,
-0.0340806805,
0.0026214053,
0.0313807987,
-0.0025968081,
-0.032300923,
-0.0145190414,
-0.0158854853,
-0.0313303359,
0.0118331574,
-0.0437764674,
-0.0434582308,
-0.0223229155,
0.0481929295,
-0.0170146599,
-0.019303564,
0.0111031411,
-0.0217755865,
-0.0288577601,
-0.0057918592,
-0.0102485865,
-0.0405726917,
0.0213954393,
-0.008924176,
0.023852434,
-0.0708614886,
0.0276231449,
-0.0153047917,
-0.0441965275,
0.1014047638,
-0.0015625312,
-0.019840667,
0.0595421642,
0.0267645232,
0.0206185095,
0.0654339641,
0.0324095711,
0.0072324341,
0.0435501374,
0.0036889766,
-0.020643644,
0.0563275702,
-0.0180279389,
0.0082509052,
-0.0510956347,
-0.0153449457,
0.0562070385,
0.0579018854,
0.0340478607,
0.0343806744,
-0.0052942196,
0.0151293585,
0.0364391916,
0.0332104117,
-0.0188037921,
0.0214692168,
0.0003876573,
-0.0170431677,
-0.0383028835,
0.007216156,
-0.0318144932,
-0.0194903258,
-0.0033495163,
0.0442501269,
0.0374992676,
0.0176182613,
-0.0047624097,
-0.0230965409,
-0.0204377733,
0.0043441993,
0.0143219195,
-0.04201857,
0.0687137321,
0.0082140882,
-0.0327850617,
0.0889616683,
0.0104105994,
-0.025739165,
0.016714599,
-0.0021502119,
-0.0326900221,
0.0687149167,
0.07733915,
-0.037475016,
-0.0980216339,
-0.0080082845,
0.001156938,
0.1024666503,
0.052013766,
-0.0140075004,
-0.0241048597,
-0.0550203063,
-0.0145454574,
0.0291961208,
0.0271228515,
0.0165264234,
0.0260360241,
0.0083789937,
0.0427369177,
-0.0309676509,
-0.079361476,
0.0386901349,
-0.0245273802,
-0.08022324,
-0.0123438798,
0.0075449226,
-0.0018060746,
0.0255464315,
-0.0301456694,
0.0059776492,
0.0161696058,
-0.0446323343,
0.0112982504,
0.003701132,
-0.032522019,
-0.0014487511,
0.0635584742,
0.0025941429,
-0.0188440848,
0.0137304049,
-0.0208207648,
-0.0284525845,
-0.0215243232,
-0.0129957749,
0.0264753737,
-0.0429932587,
0.0380634815,
-0.0071647563,
0.0040670107,
-0.064814873,
0.0251853131,
0.002694604,
0.0174778346,
0.0046532741,
-0.0470698811,
0.006323643,
0.0046120919,
-0.027146725,
0.0208475944,
0.0052549746,
0.0360485129,
0.0333154872,
0.0217409115,
-0.0280283205,
-0.006210912,
-0.0586312935,
0.0548317581,
-0.0196815208,
0.0252250042,
0.0276249815,
0.0171460062,
-0.0070522102,
-0.0069770152,
0.014114785,
-0.0023467082,
-0.0098042032,
0.0277629122,
0.0117739663,
0.009009405,
-0.0126440125,
-0.0209989045,
0.0042451252,
0.0047030142,
0.0313866138,
0.028827602,
-0.0494615398,
-0.0678374469,
0.0457469784,
-0.034433458,
0.0025808972,
0.0321245976,
-0.03711918,
-0.0228982009,
0.0097633582,
0.0155178132,
0.0304451045,
0.0087797847,
-0.0014983158,
0.0647871345,
0.0024775923,
-0.0252957288,
-0.0102954479,
0.0003467696,
-0.0896441862,
0.0051021809,
-0.049305208,
0.0033518416,
0.0567346811,
-0.032910496,
-0.0011076655,
-0.0475301854,
-0.0005713942,
-0.0571218058,
-0.0393000804,
-0.0331150033,
0.0273031183,
-0.0250664167,
0.0367863439,
-0.0172167905,
-0.0332523584,
0.0646945313,
-0.0367064588,
-0.0010090377,
-0.0314763375,
0.0169872064,
-0.0087929964,
0.0466460846,
-0.0412818715,
0.0189207196,
0.0210686289,
-0.0393526778,
-0.0338026769,
-0.0031013601,
0.0326051265,
-0.0539872423,
0.0526691936,
-0.064515844,
0.0231019948,
-0.0231748968,
-0.0002734577,
-0.0678250119,
0.0042916304,
0.0237069428,
0.0132983103,
0.0195139982,
-0.0251955558,
-0.0185372718,
0.0199715253,
0.0004153781,
0.061570175,
0.0197609235,
-0.0050236406,
-0.0387002714,
0.0262873843,
0.0494509265,
0.0111374818,
-0.0107526602,
-0.0334266275,
0.0120060816,
0.0221662521,
-0.0333754048,
-0.0470724739,
0.0089759063,
-0.0333796144,
0.0521605611,
-0.0382500365,
0.0112708388,
-0.0127536487,
0.0159932505,
-0.023450179,
-0.0548651889,
0.1401997209,
0.0653317347,
-0.0398320332,
-0.0199461859,
-0.0223055817,
0.0233676899,
0.0141940331,
0.0247363914,
-0.0800740793,
-0.0214521382,
0.0163580552,
0.0448983423,
0.0465164632,
0.0120672593,
-0.0285936855,
-0.0713582709,
0.0119311959,
0.0692819431,
-0.0048011001,
-0.0424050279,
-0.0009110372,
-0.0205101296,
-0.0345125869,
0.0567635372,
0.0054972135,
0.0183239505,
-0.01889202,
0.0030526607,
0.0229317993,
-0.0491876826,
0.0233069863,
-0.0602958016,
0.0387578793,
0.0798302069,
0.0016014121,
-0.0210571587,
-0.0076289922,
0.0286060404,
-0.0310293883,
-0.0042750523,
0.0047816858,
-0.0089853415,
-0.0129861739,
-0.0081800306,
0.0167890452,
-0.0069499868,
-0.0606458373,
-0.0124952737,
0.015874438,
0.0741863623,
0.0059228754,
0.046592921,
0.0167758446,
-0.0111178393,
0.0090493737,
0.0779267624,
-0.006293423,
-0.0362002216,
0.0301367659,
-0.0298403148,
0.0008960667,
-0.0216228869,
-0.0114528956,
-0.0101282755,
-0.1013726071,
-0.0594907254,
-0.1068140566,
-0.0352805778,
0.0071207862,
0.0337336771,
0.0413635038,
0.0317861475,
-0.001191661,
-0.0012527489,
-0.0760820732,
0.0617439039,
-0.0233819336,
-0.0094210058,
-0.0475112759,
-0.0180817209,
0.0344518684,
0.00154314,
-0.0069492357,
0.100541167,
-0.0217842031,
-0.0671673715,
-0.003973363,
0.0110951513,
0.0266432632,
0.0680315793,
-0.0363000631,
0.0069471295,
-0.0337739736,
0.0467468686,
0.0035526983,
0.0279255919,
0.034291517,
-0.0120980218,
-0.0392829441,
0.020934388,
-0.0336968154,
-0.0217674468,
-0.0118253808,
0.0676371679,
-0.0280761495,
-0.0772421584,
0.0676828548,
-0.0024839244,
0.0517461784,
-0.0576296262,
-0.0461764187,
-0.0114731891,
0.0069519784,
0.0121042803,
-0.0441938937,
-0.001945526,
-0.0093838517,
0.0544814095,
-0.035582047,
0.0154169295,
0.0436470062,
-0.0259331651,
-0.0173365474,
0.0067544091,
-0.0445264578,
-0.047644008,
0.0185113251,
0.0173140392,
0.0116056809,
-0.022751905,
0.022681037,
-0.0180504136,
0.0269405376,
-0.0386170708,
0.0412087515,
0.0207446795,
0.0292512365,
-0.035395816,
0.0161481053,
-0.0010131119,
0.0099006966,
-0.0331370533,
0.0222570039,
0.0632446334,
-0.0132360458,
0.0631537959,
-0.0269800518,
-0.0284687839,
-0.0260938536,
0.0097992606,
-0.0122246752,
0.0112445997,
-0.0117093362,
0.0056442427,
0.0112237222,
0.0057571358,
0.0819160417,
0.0249242634,
0.0026983279,
-0.0053091021,
-0.0262246318,
-0.0074693253,
-0.0245457552,
0.0100873318,
-0.0056287972,
-0.0485118367,
0.0188691914,
-0.0595184676,
-0.0658070296,
0.0410899371,
0.0085384995,
-0.0219310727,
0.0468907729,
-0.0031372579,
0.066612646,
-0.0559238493,
-0.0179635938,
-0.0348852947,
0.0336309895,
-0.0057287547,
-0.0283673182,
-0.0424896441,
-6.3773904e-33,
-0.0476780459,
-0.0266761109,
0.0082994225,
-0.0537131727,
-0.0420451462,
-0.0053191427,
-0.0183692575,
-0.0144249462,
0.0267916825,
0.0266309716,
0.0047618132,
-0.0035478238,
0.0166910198,
0.0055373968,
0.0268577244,
0.0048695644,
0.0357909128,
0.0357335545,
-0.0141101303,
0.0031040972,
0.0525220223,
0.0444607884,
0.0814025253,
-0.0369562432,
0.0779233351,
-0.0272806995,
0.0032835675,
0.0257214662,
0.032467898,
0.0223561358,
-0.0376869589,
0.0135538075,
0.0280106012,
-0.0375386663,
-0.0042168829,
0.0198533088,
-0.0655816197,
0.0034614645,
0.0493585318,
0.0299082138,
0.0155831426,
-0.0895846561,
0.0435246937,
-0.0390996821,
-0.0276126713,
0.0217533074,
0.0029869135,
-0.0682280362,
-0.0449507684,
-0.0194487218,
-0.0869102627,
0.0093669714,
-0.0033207249,
-0.0344730429,
0.0165250693,
0.0110976938,
0.0187127534,
0.0021950316,
-0.0448349416,
0.0316572189,
0.0110746529,
0.0599805675,
0.1013092995,
0.0455013402,
-0.0293129515,
0.0216122549,
-0.0388239846,
-0.0160772614,
0.0308077838,
-0.0556359291,
-0.0021949597,
-0.0150295934,
0.0109452493,
0.0685027987,
0.061263971,
-0.0181029998,
-0.0254315436,
0.0313746966,
-0.0523923002,
0.014975342,
0.0250292644,
0.0183184016,
-0.0584647954,
-0.0020922178,
-0.0276044309,
0.0356843583,
-0.0428750068,
-0.0151123321,
0.0309153106,
0.0066937422,
-0.0214484856,
0.0322987959,
0.0517249815,
-0.0234599672,
0.0261400882,
-0.0140840756,
0.0348222069,
-0.0195465181,
-0.0549121313,
0.0465233251,
0.019466266,
-0.0250605531,
0.0009980251,
-0.0127069512,
-0.0036969027,
-0.0123063326,
0.0331216753,
-0.0012713444,
-0.0281043611,
0.0114522129,
-0.0367312916,
-0.029125724,
-0.0296962988,
-0.0093552386,
0.0271685291,
0.0285050161,
0.0050949794,
0.0528365038,
0.0620388836,
-0.0149460305,
-0.0196278505,
0.0030542926,
0.0032142904,
0.028934544,
-0.0133532938,
0.0386730172,
0.0341934673,
0.024422612,
0.0044321544,
-0.012578493,
0.0047776494,
-0.0391537584,
2.655e-7,
0.0474874862,
0.0905084834,
0.0078100557,
0.00737753,
-0.0129037462,
0.0029571867,
-0.0388067998,
0.0414142311,
-0.0311934166,
-0.020629162,
0.0452925228,
0.0240385029,
0.041256845,
0.015334826,
-0.0882558823,
-0.0517349951,
0.0150137506,
0.0342476107,
-0.0502215177,
0.0018667455,
0.0584154651,
0.1122819185,
-0.01253777,
-0.0001228705,
-0.0447726548,
-0.0619368106,
0.0602304414,
-0.0445796549,
-0.0362523794,
0.055353459,
0.0304992218,
0.0213596821,
-0.0249719471,
0.0088541713,
-0.0350040011,
-0.003475622,
0.0435945578,
0.0835313052,
-0.0125358412,
0.014255248,
-0.02346058,
-0.011229326,
0.0095301298,
-0.0241057742,
-0.0155451596,
-0.0334550813,
0.0086193876,
0.0022681868,
-0.032100521,
0.0461958647,
0.0064801616,
-0.0376997218,
-0.0153600797,
0.0145968413,
0.0268617906,
0.0368089937,
-0.049433969,
-0.0631958246,
0.0037647968,
0.0522453748,
-0.0178353917,
-0.0409292765,
0.0154539822,
-0.0203250814,
0.0040207058,
-0.0534283966,
0.0214572698,
2.348541974e-34,
0.0498968884,
0.0031019298,
-0.0064857285,
0.0427610874,
0.0282161664,
-0.0373433344,
-0.0331424363,
0.0395292789,
0.0034839618,
-0.0506952778,
0.0217547547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05818v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05818v1 | SC-Safety: A Multi-round Open-ended Question Adversarial Safety Benchmark for Large Language Models in Chinese | 2023-10-09T16:03:22 | 2023-10-09T16:03:22 | Liang Xu, Kangkang Zhao, Lei Zhu, Hang Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs), like ChatGPT and GPT-4, have demonstrated
remarkable abilities in natural language understanding and generation. However,
alongside their positive impact on our daily tasks, they can also produce
harmful content that negatively affects societal perceptions. To systematically
assess the safety of Chinese LLMs, we introduce SuperCLUE-Safety (SC-Safety) -
a multi-round adversarial benchmark with 4912 open-ended questions covering
more than 20 safety sub-dimensions. Adversarial human-model interactions and
conversations significantly increase the challenges compared to existing
methods. Experiments on 13 major LLMs supporting Chinese yield the following
insights: 1) Closed-source models outperform open-sourced ones in terms of
safety; 2) Models released from China demonstrate comparable safety levels to
LLMs like GPT-3.5-turbo; 3) Some smaller models with 6B-13B parameters can
compete effectively in terms of safety. By introducing SC-Safety, we aim to
promote collaborative efforts to create safer and more trustworthy LLMs. The
benchmark and findings provide guidance on model selection. Our benchmark can
be found at https://www.CLUEbenchmarks.com | [
0.0261114314,
0.0559349544,
-0.0141970376,
0.0482419878,
-0.0157258976,
-0.0027997373,
0.0032887603,
-0.0025263252,
0.0338431336,
-0.0224034786,
-0.0327588618,
-0.0710644647,
-0.0067983377,
0.0251379684,
0.0431493744,
-0.0309570748,
0.0622898117,
-0.0278538559,
-0.0028194867,
0.0126784695,
0.0278810691,
-0.0108716963,
0.0099785198,
0.0540562198,
0.0091412133,
-0.0215458069,
-0.0088084908,
0.0221476573,
0.0597595163,
-0.0481551364,
0.0294363406,
0.0477979779,
0.0089130076,
0.0885762647,
0.000002117,
-0.0179169029,
-0.0122789312,
0.0019867036,
-0.0063000177,
0.0286590625,
0.0264568496,
-0.0152603658,
-0.0380499959,
0.0502329059,
-0.0405916795,
-0.022144787,
0.0309140962,
0.0581779368,
0.0743130818,
0.0802938938,
-0.0093904091,
0.0111699793,
0.0480965003,
-0.0448432229,
-0.0156445764,
-0.0907848775,
0.0366625264,
0.0257786643,
-0.0314663574,
0.0158215873,
-0.0093180826,
0.0121941958,
0.0265939757,
-0.0073716533,
-0.0355638452,
0.0014834964,
-0.0331244282,
-0.0197534189,
-0.0059711076,
0.1174334958,
-0.0366173089,
0.0112170679,
-0.0092796246,
0.0050014332,
-0.0035707974,
-0.0210851133,
-0.0406397358,
0.0161447711,
-0.0066040461,
-0.0158766657,
-0.0083854925,
0.0078230575,
0.0469419099,
0.0408612974,
0.0393690169,
0.0469369292,
0.0140849156,
-0.0104375528,
0.0412983038,
-0.0297209639,
-0.0355718695,
-0.0497818589,
0.0204362199,
-0.0069172704,
-0.04995092,
0.0228439923,
-0.0315700024,
-0.0133766029,
0.0409313329,
-0.0799800307,
0.0361324921,
0.0205647685,
-0.0048417062,
0.0125294803,
0.0170671642,
0.01403262,
-0.0212343447,
0.0266356673,
-0.0296086092,
0.0328974649,
0.0068914173,
-0.0070097619,
-0.0211001225,
-0.0013038761,
-0.0531798564,
0.0142045319,
-0.0552966148,
0.0290957261,
-0.0081277816,
0.0145749887,
-0.0148889553,
0.0230979621,
-0.0334110148,
-0.0070847184,
0.0046331896,
-0.0103390431,
-0.0534391887,
0.0018911836,
0.0232839175,
-0.0623605549,
-0.0295735672,
0.0432613976,
-0.0271912646,
-0.0445206463,
-0.0398177952,
0.1039550751,
-0.0062804683,
-0.0028826839,
-0.0290454943,
-0.0376519971,
-0.0410866775,
-0.0514715239,
0.0064408793,
-0.0313574187,
-0.0060072658,
-0.0298958719,
-0.021651661,
-0.0709232613,
0.0326918289,
0.0154437171,
-0.010227087,
0.0392308198,
-0.0047169714,
-0.0307228807,
-0.0160106141,
0.0655921847,
-0.0296223033,
0.0582853965,
0.0252797343,
0.059264984,
0.0388710909,
-0.0039153066,
0.0030801382,
0.0393548608,
0.0334743448,
0.03406813,
-0.0245801061,
0.0141261909,
0.0178861134,
0.0141540635,
-0.0317593813,
0.0793871954,
-0.0259560701,
-0.0356947482,
0.0959504843,
-0.013810752,
-0.0623762161,
0.0391160548,
0.0163178537,
0.0099944519,
-0.0005440968,
0.0225003231,
-0.0553679168,
0.0020732367,
-0.0866866484,
-0.0221047048,
0.0246928036,
0.0204414167,
-0.0422477871,
-0.0432401523,
-0.0124050425,
-0.0034593546,
0.0605101436,
-0.0081518944,
-0.0148695735,
-0.0114555452,
-0.0595869087,
0.0053161718,
0.0188628696,
-0.0378349982,
-0.0316491649,
-0.0388039462,
0.009693468,
0.0491744727,
0.0578366071,
-0.0078956624,
-0.035348881,
-0.0346060693,
0.0115155615,
0.0256094038,
0.0351107977,
-0.0006163468,
0.0451063365,
-0.0397031978,
-0.0190076996,
0.0117157511,
0.0239994712,
0.0241241772,
0.0428768247,
0.0156879704,
0.0305831898,
-0.0228862539,
-0.0501767695,
0.0256776977,
-0.0533122011,
-0.0292499233,
-0.010135008,
-0.0007917976,
0.0113104004,
-0.0151028158,
-0.0311133806,
0.0078672031,
0.0358304344,
-0.0157590397,
-0.0334481783,
0.0185414031,
-0.0680015832,
-0.0280307084,
0.0266973954,
-0.0360949859,
-0.031942986,
0.0636171848,
-0.0570237525,
-0.0001134768,
-0.0027106903,
-0.011338911,
-0.032988023,
-0.0460227653,
0.0152530316,
-0.0036060237,
0.0164876487,
-0.0185024962,
0.0756059438,
-0.0149600888,
-0.0162499081,
-0.0010232009,
-0.001553132,
0.0187643077,
-0.0321601704,
-0.0465316102,
0.0154303964,
-0.0342685729,
0.0608680286,
0.0251736995,
0.0267519392,
-0.0619669296,
-0.0047803088,
-0.0459712557,
0.0114913974,
-0.0488676392,
0.0152427508,
0.0245572831,
-0.0171140581,
-0.0057599586,
0.0098886974,
-0.0527318716,
0.0234982744,
-0.0215130914,
0.0075316462,
0.0087849451,
0.0058843638,
0.0099523291,
-0.0384203009,
0.0061305398,
-0.0059096497,
0.0364844687,
0.0032315063,
-0.0010194455,
-0.016625423,
0.0437826775,
-0.0351806059,
0.0160518177,
-0.0275514908,
-0.0862545297,
0.0134806847,
0.0254266858,
0.0159069896,
0.0550675914,
0.0389492474,
0.0193617996,
0.0273898523,
0.0150428498,
-0.0278902762,
0.0143481307,
0.0213985126,
-0.0406343415,
-0.006863073,
-0.0273027569,
-0.0164779238,
0.0470363088,
0.0129539091,
-0.0138236461,
-0.0434766188,
0.0320322961,
-0.0386154093,
-0.062347725,
-0.0375287496,
-0.0162822045,
-0.0320822634,
0.0213791821,
-0.0192833785,
-0.0366627201,
0.0685212538,
0.0101227704,
0.0182126574,
-0.0219136607,
-0.0197824743,
0.001652082,
0.0627214536,
-0.0135747194,
0.0414369404,
0.0289013404,
-0.0030390995,
-0.0550793,
-0.0082321903,
0.0180134587,
-0.0346288979,
0.0088485451,
-0.0405542627,
-0.0041898633,
-0.0128214387,
-0.0630074739,
-0.082766898,
-0.0701676086,
-0.0136145009,
0.0088939518,
0.0267768539,
-0.0064354083,
-0.014847951,
0.0209026132,
0.0006807304,
-0.0010977903,
-0.0378437527,
0.0181865469,
-0.01309002,
0.0378731713,
0.074702166,
-0.0359232128,
0.0403740741,
-0.0482591465,
0.0977242291,
0.1143064573,
0.0217072442,
0.0307052787,
-0.0161120426,
-0.0093959346,
-0.0127443373,
0.0176969618,
-0.0185382701,
0.0480774976,
0.0694070756,
-0.0373236351,
-0.0005489072,
0.0622247644,
0.0084368158,
0.0246277731,
0.0245875195,
0.0041816249,
0.039904017,
-0.0164565239,
-0.0197159518,
-0.0649555251,
-0.0187930949,
0.0184043031,
0.0259606838,
0.0030320401,
-0.0391529575,
0.0078248978,
-0.0798079446,
0.0260053556,
0.0255906135,
-0.0738342777,
0.0070820502,
-0.0036423579,
-0.0184536036,
-0.02319902,
0.0698788688,
0.0155721949,
0.0038391605,
-0.0394232459,
-0.0050137104,
-0.00398535,
-0.0406324491,
0.0501796082,
-0.0429597162,
0.0386448726,
0.0640403032,
0.0342089981,
-0.0020705359,
-0.0070227343,
0.0292934179,
0.0027068723,
-0.0081397751,
0.0012824512,
0.0763033032,
-0.0072962083,
-0.0047637667,
-0.015988972,
0.0469053797,
-0.0125352088,
0.007608314,
0.0265547503,
0.0177230053,
0.0030536035,
-0.0477249064,
-0.0316758193,
0.0572368391,
0.0292158108,
0.0908732042,
0.0147735272,
-0.0397592187,
-0.0045079286,
-0.0379750244,
0.0045678108,
-0.0579044297,
-0.0279812664,
0.0385093465,
0.0044087525,
-0.0287016667,
-0.0900289565,
-0.0218775906,
-0.0074809701,
0.0065671192,
-0.0003173214,
-0.0027391198,
-0.0100039067,
0.0289376546,
-0.0167288445,
0.0190512463,
-0.012855107,
0.0341589488,
-0.0394476764,
0.0441495106,
0.0116303284,
-0.0115074785,
-0.0163133088,
0.0759815201,
-0.0866942555,
-0.0926721245,
0.0044460008,
0.0515768752,
0.0176097602,
0.0120790508,
-0.0356652662,
-0.0370802991,
0.0332398228,
0.0304356255,
-0.0277930573,
-0.0205549914,
0.0461253673,
-0.0297430735,
0.0073601748,
0.0363938808,
-0.0340318419,
0.0064627491,
0.0388823934,
0.0275550187,
-0.0405529179,
-0.0242183562,
0.0207856316,
0.0531081073,
0.0308836717,
-0.0005714428,
0.0169899911,
-0.009504674,
0.0188809782,
-0.0284787994,
-0.0288043432,
-0.0379866175,
0.0306313336,
0.0401451439,
-0.0299781971,
-0.0109876366,
0.0135450196,
-0.0069845589,
0.0476625524,
-0.0243043955,
-0.004109832,
0.0020445024,
0.0475842468,
0.0340880305,
0.0032395038,
-0.035482008,
0.0297694337,
-0.0058548176,
0.047756739,
0.0022325513,
0.0500043221,
0.0023120567,
0.0268403683,
0.0381104425,
0.0417420305,
-0.0644417778,
-0.0599157773,
-0.0495021977,
0.0419687964,
0.0410286225,
0.0280099921,
0.0347286165,
-0.0302564278,
-0.0132283391,
-0.0473637059,
0.0298430324,
0.0062042549,
-0.0521509312,
0.038112551,
0.0090749189,
-0.025847856,
0.0058080559,
0.0880362913,
0.0345662087,
0.0426323004,
0.0496716909,
-0.0107738087,
-0.0452121124,
-0.0231055245,
0.0524573438,
0.0107078981,
-0.0099372296,
0.0227392688,
-0.0780713409,
-0.0836181045,
-0.0284356009,
0.0080696028,
0.0127681568,
0.0084360531,
0.0114663085,
0.0237084869,
-0.0013789672,
0.0010805384,
-0.0209135916,
-0.0068839164,
-0.0173462834,
-0.0153170107,
-0.0036809605,
-6.780540881e-33,
0.0047160233,
-0.0351639837,
-0.0178440344,
-0.0434690639,
-0.0210154429,
-0.0028570239,
-0.026940085,
0.0252119154,
-0.0427390374,
0.001362451,
-0.0101219332,
0.0191306509,
0.0036433556,
0.019592993,
-0.0387665927,
-0.0493419655,
0.0310114697,
-0.0142368879,
-0.0062837144,
0.0357844569,
0.0380789228,
0.0299981106,
0.0327538364,
-0.0656256452,
0.0440043919,
0.0073507046,
-0.0372511894,
0.0011213028,
-0.0230812002,
0.0436575413,
0.0084420694,
0.0432452187,
-0.0026162001,
-0.0159910712,
0.0042583211,
0.0025556961,
-0.0390602536,
-0.0119766314,
0.0068836757,
-0.0163381156,
-0.0627522096,
-0.0417683236,
0.0240235459,
-0.0369142145,
0.0130194919,
-0.0251407679,
-0.0093284594,
-0.0245199595,
-0.0295122471,
-0.0320780575,
-0.0347946212,
0.0346582681,
-0.0158595536,
-0.0277819056,
-0.0298467483,
0.0741437152,
0.0150654009,
-0.0154618975,
-0.0304162782,
-0.0180761497,
0.0307059083,
0.0012699681,
0.0345417261,
-0.017728731,
-0.0002692996,
0.0534456894,
-0.0195437633,
0.0089439061,
-0.0200862642,
-0.0194545463,
-0.0041807243,
0.083929494,
0.0445565619,
0.1057612598,
0.0238101929,
-0.0432903282,
-0.1349976063,
0.0538056083,
0.0148180528,
0.0347758718,
0.0146934418,
0.0020908252,
-0.0805649757,
-0.0155757684,
-0.0477735773,
-0.0116447983,
-0.0298312642,
-0.0445805229,
0.0318746641,
0.0014532339,
-0.0540694892,
-0.0627205148,
0.0001811436,
-0.054944668,
0.0473174267,
0.0412349068,
-0.0165600777,
-0.0541932285,
-0.0062871971,
0.0758299604,
-0.0367168747,
0.0017187175,
0.0153203979,
-0.0118117686,
0.0065453355,
-0.0009781906,
0.045607917,
0.0253613777,
-0.0304564051,
0.0099084377,
-0.0253846943,
0.0402684137,
0.0357556716,
0.0158167053,
0.0273456555,
-0.0228151288,
-0.0224067755,
0.0053272764,
0.0500643998,
0.0293626525,
-0.0341048725,
-0.0055307378,
-0.0096352361,
0.0232766103,
-0.0096879238,
0.0027022839,
-0.008712302,
-0.0279341824,
0.0741949081,
-0.0736900344,
-0.016015185,
-0.0159178954,
2.801e-7,
-0.0017632153,
0.0399144776,
0.020364739,
0.0438196249,
0.0228155758,
0.060706269,
-0.0231881104,
0.0538535379,
-0.0123601006,
-0.0048679458,
0.0181577429,
0.0155260032,
0.0939957425,
0.0729318485,
-0.0404602885,
-0.0142579526,
-0.0996893123,
0.0111352494,
-0.0119701959,
-0.0208750349,
0.0470249578,
0.0948642492,
-0.0259357914,
-0.0126686804,
0.0317127556,
-0.0642933995,
0.0717082173,
-0.0331982933,
-0.0156009672,
0.0223378055,
0.0342449956,
0.0615230761,
0.0085301632,
0.0072971359,
-0.00091375,
-0.0227838475,
0.0244605448,
0.0802383497,
0.0167651456,
-0.058423087,
-0.0012518524,
-0.0349455029,
0.0199943744,
-0.0660611093,
0.0711541176,
-0.0377978534,
-0.0364510976,
0.0054955301,
-0.0081762169,
-0.0196682941,
0.0500391126,
-0.0514077432,
-0.0173448846,
0.0088444781,
0.0018415902,
0.0025754482,
-0.0053767408,
-0.0124509605,
-0.040138565,
-0.0321906209,
-0.0201969221,
-0.0941058844,
-0.0217174403,
0.0187142342,
-0.0408409946,
-0.0377038121,
0.0113545172,
2.255134714e-34,
0.0260642208,
-0.0389564708,
-0.0097541874,
-0.0307150353,
0.0589501597,
0.0105738332,
0.0008433097,
-0.0238677915,
-0.003247598,
-0.0349957608,
-0.0474363752
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05804v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05804v2 | Learning Language-guided Adaptive Hyper-modality Representation for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis | 2023-10-09T15:43:07 | 2023-12-14T13:07:45 | Haoyu Zhang, Yu Wang, Guanghao Yin, Kejun Liu, Yuanyuan Liu, Tianshu Yu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | Though Multimodal Sentiment Analysis (MSA) proves effective by utilizing rich
information from multiple sources (e.g., language, video, and audio), the
potential sentiment-irrelevant and conflicting information across modalities
may hinder the performance from being further improved. To alleviate this, we
present Adaptive Language-guided Multimodal Transformer (ALMT), which
incorporates an Adaptive Hyper-modality Learning (AHL) module to learn an
irrelevance/conflict-suppressing representation from visual and audio features
under the guidance of language features at different scales. With the obtained
hyper-modality representation, the model can obtain a complementary and joint
representation through multimodal fusion for effective MSA. In practice, ALMT
achieves state-of-the-art performance on several popular datasets (e.g., MOSI,
MOSEI and CH-SIMS) and an abundance of ablation demonstrates the validity and
necessity of our irrelevance/conflict suppression mechanism. | [
-0.0094091706,
0.0775954425,
-0.0045210309,
0.0197716262,
-0.0097516272,
-0.006002509,
0.0089109596,
-0.0005780224,
-0.0368168205,
-0.1038654,
-0.0768534318,
-0.0213237256,
-0.0007180285,
0.0163876954,
0.0102507537,
-0.0262745786,
0.0194875579,
0.0374133103,
0.0274733994,
-0.0112951584,
0.0469356775,
0.0138319992,
-0.0299586859,
0.0465075895,
-0.0683471486,
-0.008352614,
0.0080650607,
0.01101352,
0.0202589128,
-0.0041850675,
-0.0089425873,
0.0374139808,
0.0289754495,
0.0098647857,
0.000002031,
-0.0178077184,
0.0126183908,
-0.019866854,
0.0771360397,
-0.035834197,
0.0915011838,
-0.0605999343,
-0.0020218203,
0.0163484849,
-0.0151149835,
0.0026923572,
0.0610735416,
0.0637795404,
0.0774645582,
0.0230050813,
-0.0484496355,
-0.0109395701,
0.0100085679,
-0.0016602089,
0.0033114569,
-0.014035047,
-0.0265148468,
-0.0032584879,
-0.037076775,
0.0039215628,
-0.0467045233,
0.0417408869,
-0.0510037392,
-0.0081684459,
-0.0091864662,
-0.0149059482,
-0.0197077803,
-0.0232806802,
-0.0195270758,
0.087448135,
-0.0097039631,
0.0155660743,
-0.0267677847,
0.0091502741,
-0.0035955647,
0.0227567852,
-0.0238054693,
0.0327363275,
0.0261608027,
0.0424575284,
-0.0451104157,
0.0239295792,
0.0099427896,
-0.00696507,
0.0108344303,
-0.0341062211,
0.0005246557,
0.0147255752,
-0.0069296523,
0.0202405453,
-0.0256867819,
0.0286711566,
0.0140336351,
-0.0117532182,
0.0198688451,
-0.0183043815,
-0.0243114866,
-0.0248017795,
0.0044651623,
-0.0652242675,
0.0086080348,
0.0095502622,
-0.080157049,
0.0304075684,
0.0076551721,
0.0055313315,
-0.00411232,
0.0172908157,
-0.0052414197,
-0.0334414653,
-0.0678849816,
-0.0081333788,
0.0330281742,
0.0222699028,
-0.0437566377,
-0.0289944038,
-0.0369055085,
-0.0205163695,
-0.0791474432,
0.0029095095,
-0.0154149206,
0.0150615163,
-0.0007860413,
-0.0036986673,
-0.0275498237,
0.1088563353,
0.0122619662,
0.0680357367,
-0.0716247708,
-0.0092758192,
0.0366024524,
0.0617649555,
-0.008190183,
-0.0086920736,
0.0083789332,
0.0845894665,
-0.0196159165,
-0.0303548165,
-0.0020856147,
-0.0050344346,
-0.0389932208,
-0.0381422229,
0.0502157137,
-0.0278047901,
0.0665940642,
-0.008080258,
0.0029725384,
-0.0006898259,
-0.0192679614,
-0.0267799441,
-0.0141929137,
0.0941727012,
-0.0055675237,
-0.0245992113,
0.0161673743,
-0.0001160131,
-0.0060277428,
0.0673015639,
0.0165920146,
0.0091759497,
0.023284547,
-0.0130931502,
0.0051276158,
0.0074091386,
-0.0296161007,
-0.0060087899,
-0.0651172027,
-0.0433420762,
-0.0347486585,
-0.0249382239,
0.0530480407,
0.0644421652,
-0.0068378155,
-0.0436229557,
0.0418530516,
-0.0191103444,
-0.0112657789,
0.0440438427,
-0.0305532571,
0.0158787612,
-0.0227126051,
-0.0019659847,
-0.0326115638,
0.0724481568,
-0.0364208333,
-0.013397105,
0.0450976714,
0.0519007593,
-0.0232210495,
-0.0135663943,
0.0245486703,
-0.0524764173,
0.0177592263,
0.0055003692,
0.0239041243,
-0.0029998454,
-0.0389308818,
0.0570066795,
0.0471039675,
-0.0418724865,
-0.0080319848,
-0.0155271795,
-0.0331338495,
0.0380825214,
0.0040845945,
-0.0538415536,
0.014054873,
-0.0479899049,
-0.0186969396,
0.0252928548,
-0.0145346094,
0.0084923618,
0.0423684195,
-0.0588675663,
-0.0580204874,
-0.0053613847,
0.0004532468,
-0.0078427466,
-0.0638214946,
0.0342974775,
-0.0055376031,
0.0228332877,
0.0423025824,
-0.0132956645,
0.0763941407,
0.0186212026,
-0.012262892,
0.0276381094,
0.0163215734,
0.027171893,
-0.025510421,
-0.0188527089,
0.0056110146,
-0.0241797678,
-0.0405440517,
0.0417268053,
-0.0416553542,
-0.0376824215,
0.0477404743,
-0.0702906325,
0.0092564598,
0.0303122438,
-0.0372393839,
0.0025507333,
0.0478802286,
-0.023896357,
0.0195093453,
-0.0384738967,
-0.0093243746,
-0.0046187728,
0.0387264304,
0.001776621,
0.0068814796,
-0.0105456663,
-0.0235176869,
-0.0288080983,
-0.0102883829,
0.0336657874,
0.0436075404,
-0.0545341708,
0.0434539467,
-0.0003283138,
0.0427385047,
0.0043143411,
-0.0263935067,
-0.0056901639,
-0.0398574062,
-0.1122977063,
-0.0492684431,
0.0132435802,
-0.0258186534,
0.0058316602,
-0.0121697392,
0.0361290798,
-0.0187137518,
-0.0089603066,
0.0275709052,
0.0227254555,
0.0305671804,
0.0059835264,
0.0039444417,
0.0301657449,
-0.0286882948,
-0.0074916207,
-0.0174998268,
0.0493015498,
-0.0104222363,
-0.0047568595,
-0.0091196308,
-0.0425147302,
-0.0566951483,
0.0586068183,
-0.0018373026,
-0.0482871197,
0.0152605334,
-0.0180131812,
0.0288446955,
-0.0230701678,
0.0112989806,
0.0140882712,
0.0882918239,
-0.0269094091,
-0.0244973935,
0.0173103772,
0.0154936397,
0.0065423204,
-0.0152378874,
-0.0087217912,
-0.0485358797,
0.0301719718,
0.0376313403,
0.0122128595,
-0.0379037336,
-0.0211895388,
0.0321131498,
-0.0239339918,
-0.0242048949,
-0.0105792824,
-0.0119783506,
-0.0296851359,
0.0007961593,
-0.0152116269,
0.0345082693,
-0.0120258229,
0.0056062262,
-0.049366381,
0.0243868064,
-0.0140029443,
0.0423960388,
-0.0360905826,
0.0211897176,
0.0111028748,
0.0007604854,
-0.025183687,
-0.0301925614,
-0.0022936198,
-0.0185503364,
0.0513158739,
-0.0011204313,
0.0022418785,
-0.0030738332,
-0.0319713317,
0.0079663396,
-0.0766756758,
-0.0250997487,
-0.0247456189,
-0.0107172551,
0.0141968094,
-0.053421136,
-0.0083449651,
0.0297166724,
-0.0198160503,
0.0340287909,
-0.0134701235,
0.0108266389,
0.0796472579,
0.036817316,
0.0642300546,
-0.0044437181,
0.01022078,
-0.0195166934,
0.0299728978,
-0.0067463676,
-0.0200507771,
-0.0352368467,
0.0238750242,
0.0161665529,
0.1033220813,
-0.0112467175,
-0.0357664973,
0.0355180539,
0.001580477,
0.0707556456,
0.0800098702,
0.0082643861,
-0.0798706785,
-0.0038006548,
0.0297182333,
0.0021548632,
0.0380327515,
-0.0192172807,
-0.0735481307,
-0.0650779307,
-0.0292992145,
-0.0046112356,
0.0213166866,
0.0045732572,
0.0019014488,
-0.061690107,
0.0130752353,
-0.0045559872,
-0.0035309645,
-0.035895329,
-0.0234364923,
0.0129100243,
-0.0237895902,
0.0147523321,
-0.0713952482,
-0.0006241667,
-0.0296700168,
-0.0269490387,
0.005870183,
-0.0607093833,
0.0228817072,
-0.0159961637,
0.0260591451,
0.0165402777,
0.0680003539,
-0.0292187706,
-0.0554486103,
-0.0095260348,
0.0158772618,
0.0171661451,
-0.0049609882,
0.0702303499,
-0.0200296547,
-0.0406500734,
-0.0239088517,
-0.023094058,
0.0105855716,
-0.0241206568,
-0.0411799699,
0.0753596351,
-0.0285214428,
-0.0018943221,
-0.0446780697,
0.0357151851,
0.0410852842,
0.0436952524,
-0.0201254468,
-0.067569226,
-0.0005986626,
0.0047360351,
0.0188859552,
0.0053562913,
0.0046336623,
0.0185814276,
-0.0038204708,
-0.0010939068,
-0.0764456317,
-0.0242679659,
-0.0107334433,
0.0088529252,
-0.0206782687,
-0.0028169304,
-0.0160992816,
0.0210201163,
-0.0328999944,
0.06271597,
0.0158615652,
0.011603795,
0.0061215255,
0.013899195,
0.0651828647,
-0.0101363724,
-0.0004737415,
0.0359987505,
-0.0241338052,
-0.0327496082,
-0.0384630673,
0.0367751718,
0.0034289327,
0.007370715,
0.0560545139,
-0.032594014,
-0.0013114208,
0.0557314642,
-0.0285194088,
0.0202099271,
0.0584152676,
0.0236372426,
-0.0275989361,
0.0274146851,
-0.0161581375,
0.0496098474,
-0.0078447396,
0.0138982479,
0.0155177927,
-0.0492678508,
-0.0046563293,
-0.0326461866,
0.0476877764,
-0.0265394542,
0.003185174,
-0.0291821994,
-0.0415200777,
0.0003249393,
0.0041219112,
-0.0513869151,
0.0171173438,
-0.0031631354,
-0.0274558738,
-0.0224774033,
0.0329080708,
-0.0010558099,
0.0202580746,
-0.0243720841,
0.0734515935,
0.0247852188,
-0.0231677704,
-0.0331648849,
0.0498000607,
0.0079673892,
0.0077542872,
0.0232334491,
-0.0466921069,
-0.0308454223,
0.0710754916,
-0.0003909245,
-0.0273869094,
-0.0530046262,
0.0311891008,
0.0182958543,
0.0644007251,
-0.0190526918,
0.0168396905,
0.0504545644,
-0.0159497056,
0.0477414206,
0.0028014495,
-0.0025379055,
-0.0052781063,
0.0455109999,
-0.0385020748,
-0.0046038674,
0.0623799078,
-0.0063146576,
0.0033984622,
0.0335011892,
0.0555187166,
-0.0666653141,
0.011136109,
-0.0217892379,
0.0193843506,
-0.0541293509,
-0.0190242734,
0.0692427084,
0.0367718302,
-0.0037410338,
0.031097576,
-0.0254659522,
-0.0564249307,
0.0550987497,
-0.061163079,
-0.0175353792,
-0.0041309046,
0.027063828,
0.0266939793,
0.0163081698,
0.013543522,
-0.0277630538,
-0.013650747,
0.0241385847,
0.0058358395,
0.0080137486,
-6.266370836e-33,
0.0014046907,
-0.0018501923,
-0.0357337147,
-0.0359070487,
-0.0141347535,
0.0130458931,
-0.0203294363,
0.0282024574,
-0.0224008281,
0.0259100534,
0.0300845206,
-0.0125449719,
-0.0054701064,
0.0328877643,
0.0310172047,
0.045699656,
0.0484232828,
-0.0064393431,
0.0056284727,
0.0206933767,
0.0798692033,
0.0112266559,
0.0825656503,
-0.1512301117,
-0.0025624598,
0.0326448642,
-0.0617384762,
-0.0357446633,
0.0415342823,
0.0437741801,
-0.0411948152,
0.0890562534,
0.0307403412,
-0.0077275527,
-0.0117306774,
0.039442949,
-0.0378789194,
0.0001458264,
0.0004938258,
0.0107435007,
-0.0368529782,
-0.0095354989,
0.0577898361,
-0.0223984495,
-0.0306031723,
-0.0380684026,
0.0480399057,
-0.0297854654,
0.0212791637,
-0.0239210371,
-0.0834443569,
0.0059570614,
-0.0299989078,
0.0015658187,
0.0340926163,
0.0404715277,
0.0455413498,
0.0175505169,
-0.0697448552,
0.0462868586,
-0.0626439601,
-0.0203245897,
0.0304235779,
-0.008530831,
-0.0098516531,
0.0900910273,
0.0114784893,
-0.0130704837,
0.0137958135,
0.0169443116,
0.0457031876,
0.040555533,
0.0259876996,
0.1095615923,
0.0000621945,
-0.0213968437,
-0.0350830927,
0.0144361425,
-0.0250460505,
0.020092167,
0.0416564345,
0.0431016758,
-0.0033625083,
-0.0023667463,
-0.0031837071,
0.0029023336,
-0.0399137959,
-0.0335568674,
0.0001949839,
0.0118617164,
0.0038462779,
0.0383385308,
0.0690109134,
-0.0364466421,
-0.0402392857,
0.0645978525,
-0.0326661728,
0.0604405142,
0.0196403861,
-0.0325088017,
0.0040988913,
-0.0162818637,
0.0490077734,
-0.0179786049,
0.0292633604,
-0.022299068,
0.0053612725,
0.056530647,
-0.0710008368,
-0.0098580401,
0.0078845825,
-0.0085084196,
0.0065395441,
0.0431740545,
-0.0043975296,
0.0039028923,
-0.0424850546,
0.0405294746,
-0.0194218066,
0.0322767794,
-0.0003896853,
-0.0125747155,
-0.0037062408,
0.0369849205,
-0.0330656581,
0.0050956071,
-0.0293521918,
-0.0917511582,
0.0242199246,
-0.0706006512,
-0.0192878824,
0.0158898067,
2.813e-7,
0.0126340622,
0.0390156619,
-0.0187916476,
-0.073008284,
0.0282754507,
0.0765352845,
-0.0306817126,
0.0301536974,
0.0100355456,
-0.0212834608,
0.0053064656,
0.021423405,
0.0075801974,
0.0421468951,
0.0013715455,
0.0040427847,
-0.0240514912,
-0.0203183573,
-0.0249076877,
0.0589474924,
0.0907223746,
0.125031516,
-0.0105365887,
-0.0476430245,
-0.0159231964,
-0.0201555099,
0.08009056,
0.0045871981,
-0.0212370977,
-0.0239696074,
-0.022673659,
-0.0270580575,
-0.0269897953,
-0.0206801668,
-0.0157866254,
-0.0075246785,
0.0350220241,
0.0314505547,
-0.0119344573,
-0.1051794738,
0.0006936524,
0.0698137134,
-0.0253426898,
-0.0113854175,
0.0489680655,
-0.0409698971,
-0.0579337254,
-0.0718455091,
-0.0183533002,
0.025177002,
0.0227361768,
-0.010220862,
-0.0428251624,
0.0119508812,
0.0072841821,
-0.0104264412,
-0.0529050417,
-0.0876541063,
-0.0033787987,
0.0406663902,
-0.051868964,
-0.0018046778,
0.026456533,
-0.0276350472,
0.0474220477,
-0.0403839834,
0.0138133485,
1.986688309e-34,
0.0244743433,
-0.0507519431,
0.0271568988,
-0.0280386303,
0.0056992006,
-0.0037449088,
-0.0971610919,
-0.0022509608,
0.0172830038,
-0.0389622264,
-0.0023291674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05797v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05797v3 | Are Large Language Models Post Hoc Explainers? | 2023-10-09T15:31:03 | 2024-02-26T20:33:36 | Nicholas Kroeger, Dan Ley, Satyapriya Krishna, Chirag Agarwal, Himabindu Lakkaraju | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The increasing use of predictive models in high-stakes settings highlights
the need for ensuring that relevant stakeholders understand and trust the
decisions made by these models. To this end, several approaches have been
proposed in recent literature to explain the behavior of complex predictive
models in a post hoc fashion. However, despite the growing number of such post
hoc explanation techniques, many require white-box access to the model and/or
are computationally expensive, highlighting the need for next-generation post
hoc explainers. Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful
tools that are effective at a wide variety of tasks. However, their potential
to explain the behavior of other complex predictive models remains relatively
unexplored. In this work, we carry out one of the initial explorations to
analyze the effectiveness of LLMs in explaining other complex predictive
models. To this end, we propose three novel approaches that exploit the
in-context learning (ICL) capabilities of LLMs to explain the predictions made
by other complex models. We conduct extensive experimentation with these
approaches on real-world datasets to demonstrate that LLMs perform on par with
state-of-the-art post hoc explainers, opening up promising avenues for future
research into LLM-based post hoc explanations of complex predictive models. | [
0.0120183816,
0.0767927319,
-0.0212288853,
0.0439203829,
-0.0216983166,
0.0105139464,
0.0372063443,
0.0057700127,
-0.0100807035,
-0.0170985069,
0.0350570083,
-0.0466235019,
0.0152390106,
0.0397773273,
0.0388101824,
-0.0464934632,
-0.0079720765,
-0.0439678207,
-0.003363807,
-0.0107836444,
0.0101321647,
0.0261051487,
0.0313094072,
0.074700579,
0.0255583525,
0.0075242748,
-0.0290168151,
-0.0127008688,
-0.0154968211,
-0.0027407503,
-0.0093370145,
0.0294743925,
0.0704333037,
0.0432382338,
0.0000020447,
-0.0358275659,
-0.0280033555,
0.0005329688,
-0.0602051504,
0.0332360566,
0.0114677288,
-0.0128923105,
0.0181859732,
0.0291396026,
-0.0128862998,
0.0118398722,
0.0613236576,
-0.0073721418,
0.0118413968,
0.0475510806,
-0.0054116156,
-0.0093516083,
0.0000788015,
-0.0299810804,
-0.0109708142,
-0.034053199,
0.0255138818,
-0.0301649738,
-0.0453376248,
-0.0025017664,
-0.016279934,
-0.0053288615,
0.0459064506,
-0.0210331529,
-0.0230989531,
0.0464644693,
0.0135452552,
-0.0098132966,
-0.0038563523,
0.0354128182,
-0.0074273595,
-0.0470118485,
0.0165708307,
-0.0104662627,
0.0032732133,
0.0439613163,
-0.0522024035,
0.0036984335,
-0.0032044488,
0.0268554594,
0.0337492302,
0.0290035848,
0.071132496,
0.0348460563,
-0.0372220799,
0.0690003112,
-0.0243159011,
-0.008747966,
-0.0301517323,
-0.0031324544,
-0.0200830624,
-0.0511091389,
-0.0078614699,
0.0181502886,
-0.04325426,
0.0297688432,
0.0283417664,
0.0158927049,
0.0008331455,
-0.0426128022,
0.048540391,
0.0466180854,
-0.0142970188,
0.0353431478,
-0.0115484614,
0.0489228889,
-0.0104839643,
-0.0051191361,
-0.0111788968,
-0.0216630436,
-0.063037619,
-0.0362761132,
0.024374038,
-0.0234117433,
-0.0430504642,
0.0094193071,
-0.0316733755,
0.01845406,
-0.0451222584,
0.002996465,
0.0024401927,
0.0121682957,
-0.0041758996,
-0.0573860221,
-0.0345701873,
0.0405353196,
-0.0145444451,
0.0250596553,
0.0027601353,
-0.0406349935,
-0.007412584,
0.01454149,
-0.0125379171,
-0.0061427676,
0.0016954177,
0.0572216846,
0.019930752,
0.0123132532,
-0.0204431005,
-0.038965784,
-0.0387945808,
-0.0702896789,
-0.03259046,
-0.0543121062,
0.0005663373,
0.0455480367,
-0.0010779419,
-0.0564055964,
0.000106793,
-0.0256473646,
-0.0445170179,
0.0887745395,
-0.0031100896,
0.0353896804,
-0.010974816,
0.0122769121,
-0.0020798929,
0.0667667836,
0.0107983947,
0.0016332621,
0.0252863448,
-0.0500524044,
0.0388778634,
0.0365066044,
0.0422614999,
0.0410133824,
-0.0465699323,
-0.0166526977,
-0.0027381009,
0.0032236828,
0.0169188268,
-0.0071103079,
0.0001112271,
0.0136162015,
0.069653675,
0.0339914672,
0.0128961904,
0.0257248208,
0.0413094386,
-0.0009558395,
-0.0259951185,
0.0102484701,
-0.060266085,
0.010675706,
-0.0499945432,
-0.0065705134,
0.0365918353,
0.0263030976,
-0.0107085621,
-0.0693505481,
0.0089182369,
0.006382945,
0.0033625211,
0.0598680452,
0.0580775402,
-0.0393776186,
-0.0428260751,
0.0268801413,
0.0657826886,
-0.0312463026,
-0.0064127943,
-0.0927949324,
0.0299052075,
0.095457986,
0.0451715067,
-0.0281941015,
0.0212579481,
-0.0229903832,
0.0481695831,
0.0190358143,
0.013898083,
0.0006267584,
0.0016771265,
-0.0306147486,
-0.0557859391,
-0.0182796121,
0.0435069054,
0.0225573052,
0.0192893874,
-0.0497200824,
-0.0047194404,
-0.0253267288,
-0.0570938177,
0.0254333727,
-0.0448989756,
-0.0086441329,
0.0007936129,
0.0031081524,
0.0182762649,
0.0085413214,
0.0035879547,
0.0094649429,
0.0131734665,
-0.0091027562,
-0.0098177232,
0.0070298146,
-0.0152795585,
0.0013916158,
0.0167842284,
0.0163578745,
0.027966639,
-0.0003937839,
-0.0398095585,
-0.0252278987,
0.0328128934,
-0.0012282925,
0.0962622687,
-0.0237962808,
0.0094861053,
-0.0413283817,
0.0189259518,
-0.0269998573,
0.0438950695,
-0.0124535579,
-0.006083848,
0.0316431299,
-0.0101273311,
-0.026618937,
0.020477403,
0.0217810124,
0.0177344251,
-0.0286896918,
-0.0089255199,
0.0153893288,
-0.032300286,
0.008330374,
0.0034495261,
-0.0679626241,
-0.0161068961,
-0.0397549719,
-0.0108916461,
0.0198409967,
-0.0327306353,
-0.0151921771,
0.0097257365,
-0.0100697586,
-0.0112063093,
0.0221416708,
0.0186999496,
0.001257641,
-0.0048627802,
-0.0479192138,
-0.0318292938,
-0.0191265475,
-0.0342980139,
0.1103663817,
0.0163949449,
-0.0000095484,
-0.0643508807,
0.024926411,
-0.0107540628,
-0.0088218516,
-0.0507407337,
-0.0240564346,
0.0039298655,
0.0006179154,
-0.000796422,
0.0403363667,
-0.005853015,
0.0865829363,
0.0581002422,
0.010926215,
-0.0654717013,
-0.0286219437,
-0.0627104193,
-0.025916744,
-0.0688891336,
-0.0426355749,
-0.0215232801,
0.0880434811,
0.0139117157,
-0.0022729114,
-0.0435848758,
0.0251398962,
-0.0092206327,
-0.021438906,
-0.0540661663,
-0.0499943048,
-0.007356382,
0.0858113468,
-0.003756416,
-0.0870197415,
0.0739109516,
-0.0267881397,
0.0138069894,
0.0066286637,
-0.0429289043,
-0.0359853953,
0.0602685027,
-0.0288845282,
-0.0053460849,
0.0184726138,
0.0006119161,
-0.0295836031,
-0.0432691425,
0.0124548031,
-0.0185067095,
0.0408999734,
-0.0664762482,
-0.0071584005,
0.047395952,
-0.0223899819,
-0.0238399804,
-0.0498701297,
-0.0450237058,
0.0226508379,
0.0260887835,
-0.0628177822,
-0.0039318218,
0.0240204837,
0.0288285054,
0.0082517993,
-0.0072530452,
-0.0212501977,
-0.0077836872,
-0.0256424602,
0.0146419425,
0.0039570755,
0.0573734865,
-0.076006785,
0.0240756962,
0.0157391224,
0.0313819572,
-0.0432017557,
-0.0520145595,
-0.0164669417,
0.0205532983,
0.0056399885,
-0.0119850161,
0.0378376693,
0.0259565581,
-0.0870411396,
0.0238703564,
0.0988420174,
0.0136632994,
-0.0466295257,
0.0167934895,
-0.0046580499,
0.0443109758,
0.0193449259,
0.0104668736,
-0.040411178,
-0.0282514114,
0.0114069311,
0.0212805867,
-0.0191036668,
-0.0181740224,
0.0047755288,
-0.1019895896,
0.0616050065,
0.0132661574,
-0.0315363742,
-0.0066557573,
-0.0600495227,
-0.0125562968,
-0.0327149667,
-0.0092526535,
-0.0151031604,
0.0171429198,
-0.0101026492,
0.0430944934,
-0.0656936318,
-0.0626049861,
0.035280522,
-0.0283866171,
0.0360377058,
0.0677740648,
0.0249860752,
0.0217690617,
0.0120262485,
0.0292759761,
0.0097108623,
0.0126119833,
-0.0003002007,
0.0558614805,
0.0342044085,
-0.0067523313,
-0.0218980964,
0.0490780994,
-0.0202367827,
-0.0216367841,
-0.0070444196,
0.0785902217,
-0.0110723795,
-0.0177431032,
0.0287708398,
0.0083704134,
0.0379505306,
0.0909222662,
0.030552635,
-0.0277524143,
-0.0453308523,
-0.0774166211,
-0.000689338,
-0.0239360407,
-0.0646154359,
-0.0188142844,
0.0341231003,
-0.0087984037,
0.0031806366,
0.0023027847,
0.0399391614,
0.0053877509,
0.0128694512,
0.0336574949,
-0.0259707309,
-0.0090722814,
-0.0325051732,
0.0414633341,
-0.0115238782,
0.0353022516,
-0.0340294093,
-0.0256958734,
0.0170807093,
-0.0358709022,
-0.0164374933,
0.0172995217,
-0.0360007212,
-0.0736175999,
0.0149294725,
0.022004392,
0.0362715423,
0.0582240969,
0.013988045,
-0.0895246193,
0.0556747913,
0.0240211803,
-0.0313720927,
-0.0290486738,
0.0363811888,
0.0063722804,
-0.0015344296,
0.0557165295,
-0.0118411146,
-0.0165872425,
0.025552934,
-0.0111093502,
-0.0590490773,
-0.0162074696,
0.0407828726,
-0.0417732112,
0.0619272031,
-0.0485129058,
-0.0687382594,
-0.0247195903,
0.0131509695,
-0.0048150015,
-0.0113587137,
-0.0200481936,
-0.0016274108,
0.0272949487,
-0.0126438895,
0.0197476856,
-0.0084917555,
-0.0044068857,
-0.0067859809,
-0.0424003489,
0.0402620733,
0.0051589729,
-0.0168618802,
0.0522944406,
0.0253812131,
0.0283529963,
0.0281474069,
-0.0009584391,
0.0422385782,
0.0189782362,
0.0739121065,
0.0054681469,
-0.0033180711,
-0.0210136455,
-0.0115310727,
-0.0893020406,
-0.063910231,
-0.0180711076,
0.0299968533,
0.0264891051,
-0.0179244559,
0.0401798375,
-0.0047821659,
-0.0151312239,
-0.0114821568,
0.049565006,
-0.00540203,
-0.0396584608,
0.0276131928,
0.0224318523,
-0.0592451096,
0.0321142077,
0.1018895432,
0.0570325628,
0.0438055173,
-0.0011955582,
-0.0241729878,
0.0108032888,
-0.0554352701,
0.0333920494,
0.0189904943,
-0.0269914996,
0.009976401,
-0.0892785713,
-0.056695234,
-0.0256014969,
-0.0359531939,
-0.0291910246,
-0.0389347374,
-0.0289613083,
0.0688906163,
-0.0283947978,
0.0022752648,
-0.0543324165,
0.0056661167,
-0.0062053143,
0.0038381817,
-0.0143821994,
-6.497846245e-33,
0.0072231484,
-0.0614925846,
0.0102895014,
-0.029882282,
0.0294259842,
0.0085823815,
-0.0437077135,
-0.0115872519,
-0.0044349539,
0.03513401,
0.0134892091,
0.0081534125,
0.0100192353,
0.0158519931,
0.024816718,
-0.041811008,
0.0380764306,
0.024163099,
-0.0185480472,
0.0388407968,
0.0722986236,
0.0141425915,
0.0445119515,
-0.0549525805,
0.0664652139,
0.0204532817,
-0.0279956255,
0.0301368292,
-0.0337826274,
0.0586394891,
-0.0199231524,
0.0256957188,
0.0295155812,
-0.0687347874,
-0.0118030729,
0.024739828,
-0.0187418759,
0.042036891,
0.0402904712,
-0.0310254972,
-0.0069981134,
-0.0339287668,
0.0178371146,
0.0092259413,
-0.0232469756,
-0.0224186555,
0.0192696545,
-0.0257012323,
-0.0169247035,
-0.0016074801,
-0.0478179157,
0.046352949,
-0.0553759038,
-0.0170664173,
0.0145401917,
0.0612075552,
0.0087839952,
0.0424061269,
-0.0352676027,
0.0408159345,
0.0169566404,
0.0122038452,
0.0941274464,
0.036794316,
-0.0194867328,
0.0653405786,
0.0312882774,
0.0054801228,
-0.0623422079,
-0.0266346745,
0.0157621056,
0.0476304926,
0.0890209153,
0.0556472912,
0.0062576043,
0.0088511659,
-0.0499582961,
0.0218407903,
-0.0278252382,
-0.0099327965,
0.0625016987,
0.0027998989,
-0.0530583449,
-0.0729802474,
-0.0424309894,
-0.0299664252,
-0.0219620373,
-0.0100323427,
0.0231864937,
-0.0003187236,
-0.0476693697,
0.0136637557,
0.0446778908,
-0.0909797847,
0.0024707858,
0.0338107347,
-0.0019523501,
0.0035366667,
0.0285707321,
0.0038905872,
-0.0406614803,
-0.0096911984,
-0.0180193614,
0.007097621,
0.0231865738,
-0.0102431523,
0.0221924167,
0.0195475575,
-0.0324518085,
0.013403466,
-0.0718102157,
-0.0029466506,
-0.0001479087,
-0.0146647766,
0.0351919383,
0.0167543646,
-0.0193589516,
0.0053079273,
0.0335951298,
0.0083354898,
0.0246681627,
-0.0174017418,
-0.0666270107,
0.0159648973,
-0.0096400082,
-0.0378302783,
-0.0296637788,
-0.0121955518,
0.0701951012,
-0.0044980724,
-0.0400636382,
-0.0252697561,
2.54e-7,
0.0554999188,
0.0380357392,
-0.0003091496,
-0.0235574655,
0.0163701177,
0.0383980684,
-0.0113391196,
-0.0367478244,
-0.0037524255,
-0.0372654796,
0.0384469479,
0.0270830691,
0.1006634533,
0.0058669932,
0.0083832545,
-0.028308725,
-0.0947407708,
-0.0377166681,
-0.0770035386,
0.0012495659,
0.0273898561,
0.0930039957,
0.0325764231,
-0.0050743199,
0.0086290417,
-0.0206176247,
0.0560106225,
-0.0795326158,
-0.0149669573,
0.0287464112,
0.0170749351,
-0.0102549102,
0.0081126885,
0.0150829321,
-0.03131935,
0.0145120723,
-0.0408684984,
0.0649109408,
0.0190518592,
0.0055859112,
-0.0349985808,
-0.0354924463,
0.0007841847,
-0.0872844979,
0.0755691603,
-0.0574999601,
-0.0345368497,
-0.0236641914,
0.0197552927,
-0.0460465811,
0.0151275313,
-0.027744256,
0.0276624672,
0.0361085795,
-0.0469640493,
-0.0211540256,
0.0229522996,
-0.068346329,
-0.0628223866,
0.0096868975,
-0.0343026742,
0.0009887776,
-0.0202115159,
-0.0115365293,
0.0534557439,
-0.026769571,
0.0235985108,
2.761204088e-34,
0.0457053706,
0.0350072049,
-0.0166762266,
0.0181836486,
0.0626053214,
0.0018043969,
0.0131924972,
0.0283330195,
0.0502434447,
-0.0538595133,
0.0104061747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05793v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05793v2 | DiffuSeq-v2: Bridging Discrete and Continuous Text Spaces for Accelerated Seq2Seq Diffusion Models | 2023-10-09T15:29:10 | 2023-10-16T09:56:02 | Shansan Gong, Mukai Li, Jiangtao Feng, Zhiyong Wu, Lingpeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Diffusion models have gained prominence in generating high-quality sequences
of text. Nevertheless, current approaches predominantly represent discrete text
within a continuous diffusion space, which incurs substantial computational
overhead during training and results in slower sampling speeds. In this paper,
we introduce a soft absorbing state that facilitates the diffusion model in
learning to reconstruct discrete mutations based on the underlying Gaussian
space, thereby enhancing its capacity to recover conditional signals. During
the sampling phase, we employ state-of-the-art ODE solvers within the
continuous space to expedite the sampling process. Comprehensive experimental
evaluations reveal that our proposed method effectively accelerates the
training convergence by 4x and generates samples of similar quality 800x
faster, rendering it significantly closer to practical application.
\footnote{The code is released at \url{https://github.com/Shark-NLP/DiffuSeq} | [
-0.0058396654,
0.0632113144,
-0.0136003345,
-0.0156843327,
-0.0243907422,
-0.0182566252,
0.0137013542,
0.0318910629,
-0.0299201049,
-0.0178498626,
0.0304995701,
-0.0587146729,
-0.0241989996,
0.0339298137,
0.0302067585,
-0.0056488798,
0.0261889417,
-0.0232428703,
-0.0537374131,
-0.0120072803,
0.0258079767,
-0.0062248115,
-0.0120131634,
-0.0096891141,
0.0115524912,
-0.0088389637,
-0.0225629769,
-0.0164998621,
0.0389270857,
-0.0161432773,
0.0087184962,
0.0880588815,
0.0414948799,
0.0385194421,
0.0000022562,
0.0060064709,
-0.0212182105,
0.0048874728,
0.0321484879,
0.0386200659,
0.0195912421,
-0.0114514511,
-0.0213850252,
-0.0142616481,
-0.026536854,
0.0138697596,
0.053377457,
-0.0042647929,
0.0643885732,
0.0789844245,
-0.0239001475,
-0.057122346,
0.0045205513,
-0.0409915559,
0.0632485822,
-0.0474795029,
0.0522654653,
0.0032679522,
0.0530704744,
0.0171677936,
-0.0196578503,
0.0603632592,
0.0221234094,
-0.0354410894,
0.0408417247,
0.0462046303,
0.0360982902,
-0.0038532189,
-0.0215298776,
0.0493842959,
-0.0350392573,
-0.0239969976,
0.0165913869,
-0.0205202792,
-0.0297062639,
0.0140927834,
-0.003587265,
-0.0133317942,
-0.0385084674,
0.0220701229,
-0.0492335856,
-0.0543641672,
0.0195540003,
0.0034856489,
-0.0387572683,
0.0127898054,
0.0245121121,
-0.0241213255,
-0.028947344,
0.000390091,
-0.0198400002,
-0.0158693567,
0.0760824978,
0.0188605916,
-0.0053498768,
-0.0208343659,
-0.0720493197,
-0.0653188229,
0.0122690732,
-0.025278043,
0.063963756,
0.0091399187,
0.0503056049,
0.024513213,
-0.0575418733,
-0.0330389477,
-0.0324042402,
-0.0136544313,
-0.0192534328,
0.0310044736,
-0.0417258143,
0.0156011814,
-0.0606778413,
0.026423065,
-0.0235887393,
-0.0252378192,
-0.0132511109,
0.0291028172,
0.0140524926,
-0.0420628525,
0.0085147638,
0.0085447812,
-0.0898946449,
0.0078171566,
0.0130517231,
-0.0026116897,
-0.0110473176,
0.0215646569,
0.0212882757,
-0.007347662,
-0.0347682089,
-0.0217497349,
0.0285412688,
-0.0535122119,
-0.0333587229,
-0.002145133,
-0.0133521343,
-0.0293238107,
-0.0173890684,
0.0139391245,
-0.0436324552,
-0.0079862308,
-0.0082366019,
-0.086893402,
0.0051638447,
-0.0248787981,
-0.0253150743,
-0.0229132269,
0.034370821,
0.0091058398,
-0.0177691188,
0.040861886,
-0.0242070667,
-0.023109423,
0.0554138869,
0.0051079122,
0.055462718,
0.0663893521,
0.0147725176,
-0.0256688017,
-0.0111879492,
0.0057310271,
0.028058866,
0.0204205867,
0.063378565,
0.0490217879,
-0.0358947366,
-0.0452808924,
-0.030746622,
0.0389330238,
0.0771100372,
0.0584228858,
-0.0530753881,
-0.0287360493,
0.0279316343,
0.0150834052,
0.0266982671,
0.0496563986,
0.0358200893,
0.0192178003,
-0.0265733115,
0.0205626171,
0.0409430116,
0.0333835334,
0.0574355982,
0.0231114738,
0.0355857164,
-0.0101902811,
-0.0274430979,
-0.0236194897,
0.0313683338,
0.0016222979,
0.0785542354,
-0.0494487882,
0.0499107502,
0.0287051387,
-0.0752876624,
0.0416341238,
0.0052582202,
-0.0392573848,
-0.0211504698,
-0.0427003242,
0.0258213971,
0.0399212316,
0.0390585586,
-0.0248871837,
-0.0145944394,
-0.0290600881,
-0.0168064032,
0.0185497236,
0.0138139352,
0.0359226912,
-0.0015357441,
-0.0392737091,
-0.0132953189,
-0.0049651135,
0.0136169065,
0.0107426494,
0.016017288,
0.0427902639,
0.0173386298,
0.0029568183,
-0.0294505488,
0.0217084084,
-0.0623338111,
-0.0361886621,
0.030796349,
-0.0197369605,
0.0129949553,
0.0045518181,
-0.0594308488,
0.0056857173,
0.0268816426,
-0.0407516174,
-0.0677538067,
-0.032792788,
-0.0203893464,
-0.0639392734,
0.0387032963,
-0.0363615975,
-0.0100925779,
-0.0017469774,
-0.0520668924,
-0.0005925875,
-0.0022247306,
-0.0666535348,
-0.0088826278,
-0.0810552388,
-0.0017640549,
0.0242612343,
0.0390144624,
-0.0467724539,
0.0424531959,
-0.0269117989,
-0.0094407648,
-0.0152465198,
0.054713551,
-0.0177304316,
-0.0345410034,
0.0088477526,
-0.0507056564,
0.0175569206,
0.0278307069,
0.0014214172,
0.0189704876,
-0.0097347489,
-0.0156795923,
-0.076961346,
0.0254353024,
-0.0583902188,
-0.0042099222,
0.0301569737,
0.0274507422,
-0.0051116487,
0.0222728513,
-0.0306934696,
-0.0130622713,
-0.0207471661,
-0.0232445132,
0.0391517617,
-0.006688443,
-0.0321139619,
-0.0345514081,
-0.0298450962,
-0.0162036549,
0.0336998962,
-0.0506074838,
-0.0519497357,
-0.0502688885,
0.044410456,
-0.0100170104,
0.0386673808,
0.0033376587,
-0.006491669,
0.0024128307,
-0.0179900564,
0.0555860549,
0.0277493913,
0.0744785517,
0.0227952562,
-0.0332444794,
0.0053915335,
0.0389160886,
0.0186057538,
-0.0581801347,
0.0377786607,
-0.0035643494,
-0.012171491,
0.0116024278,
0.0499641895,
-0.0177889578,
-0.0348929279,
-0.0613664016,
-0.0037678059,
0.0286087357,
-0.0098549286,
0.0132746017,
0.0089894831,
-0.0378452688,
-0.0200588834,
-0.032229729,
-0.0385852233,
0.0718058348,
-0.0200563613,
0.0195922796,
-0.106632188,
-0.00954255,
-0.0022419665,
-0.0116211465,
-0.0239397902,
0.0351743996,
-0.0132737532,
-0.0020698216,
-0.004401145,
-0.0062730261,
-0.0023296454,
-0.0178710893,
0.0014697763,
-0.0209831018,
0.0542845801,
0.0235057119,
0.0035126377,
0.0086337766,
-0.0210687574,
0.0447497852,
0.0040989295,
0.0014612959,
-0.0027916331,
-0.0042181709,
0.0336877257,
-0.0172063373,
0.060678903,
-0.0379342139,
-0.0043327073,
-0.0398706049,
0.0544936694,
0.0846389309,
0.0009587482,
-0.0167316999,
-0.0427452028,
0.0322773643,
0.050060153,
0.0381790549,
0.0514386222,
-0.0018706679,
-0.0152137997,
-0.0363810956,
-0.0017261261,
0.0008762681,
0.0137194693,
0.0697246715,
-0.0075878091,
-0.0430479348,
0.0516981073,
0.0088576488,
-0.0417234227,
0.0231678449,
0.0209638309,
0.0421070829,
-0.0088913757,
0.00079432,
-0.1042751819,
-0.0281886589,
-0.0099339029,
-0.0017438313,
0.0051404173,
-0.0014644023,
0.0208284687,
-0.0423092246,
0.033538796,
0.0574190244,
-0.0159492996,
-0.0220943857,
-0.0451450497,
-0.0165329929,
0.0463218316,
-0.0035010851,
0.045692049,
0.0089465734,
0.024459986,
0.0520565957,
0.066585958,
-0.0713898614,
-0.0331093557,
-0.0356756896,
-0.0153240478,
0.1083686873,
0.0013195347,
0.0165786054,
-0.0256653056,
0.0617440492,
-0.0395414978,
-0.0310814213,
0.003839456,
0.0225625969,
0.0196163096,
0.0151788024,
-0.0008349866,
0.0851190165,
0.014277081,
0.0121461013,
-0.0260561258,
0.0526812896,
-0.0269586518,
-0.0473854989,
-0.0365947224,
-0.0242846049,
0.0447041914,
0.0251757242,
0.043831002,
-0.0437202081,
-0.0660269037,
-0.025296472,
0.0272745211,
0.0022093283,
-0.0528280698,
0.0097969202,
-0.0314358883,
-0.0794575736,
-0.0892226323,
-0.0218975078,
0.0120555218,
0.0753153563,
-0.0085803093,
0.029791357,
0.0051908074,
-0.0509483591,
-0.0534265041,
-0.0143326893,
0.0069109448,
0.0284258388,
-0.0032825146,
-0.0413692929,
-0.0017445023,
0.0028392752,
-0.0169482064,
0.0335484855,
-0.164462164,
-0.0578717738,
0.0042937663,
0.0184668321,
0.0190910529,
0.0081839906,
-0.023813298,
-0.0281807091,
0.1291593611,
0.0350943506,
0.0187374167,
0.068779774,
-0.0053720097,
-0.0530512035,
-0.0103471717,
0.0299584493,
-0.0032006381,
0.0019553804,
-0.0361568742,
0.0785117447,
-0.0335718952,
0.0264904443,
-0.0276993252,
-0.0747909397,
0.0248625781,
0.0291794837,
0.0021209987,
-0.0052251881,
0.035689719,
0.0014932107,
0.0220138561,
-0.067398414,
-0.0124514522,
0.0196353924,
-0.0194172356,
-0.0196489282,
-0.0162001345,
0.0228692293,
0.0182833783,
-0.025998421,
0.0061643254,
0.0458306521,
-0.0000378628,
0.0636758432,
-0.0166002307,
0.0031434277,
0.031680692,
0.0144405505,
0.046164114,
-0.008011139,
0.0573004968,
0.0273071546,
0.0222330466,
0.0080922488,
-0.0003321702,
-0.0462727137,
-0.0105228964,
-0.0698630437,
0.0490606427,
0.0571218394,
0.0062568379,
0.0558349863,
-0.0125354063,
-0.0056214212,
-0.0480518714,
0.0359469578,
-0.0052961255,
0.0069670947,
0.0085682916,
0.0084819896,
0.0019558824,
0.0264873896,
0.0627861917,
0.0017975287,
0.0453500971,
-0.0142832268,
-0.0190014187,
-0.0118038487,
-0.01641245,
-0.035099037,
-0.0456354991,
0.0107019087,
-0.0288230348,
-0.0145454966,
-0.0517009087,
0.0382148139,
-0.0044295248,
0.0040916181,
0.005151331,
0.0335027874,
0.0255440902,
-0.0248293579,
-0.0236402042,
-0.0474405065,
0.0367044285,
0.0036462578,
-0.0747008026,
0.0049682842,
-6.542075689e-33,
-0.0214449875,
-0.0004462442,
-0.0004711316,
-0.0254547819,
-0.0410142951,
-0.0207197592,
-0.0538731217,
-0.0114440368,
0.0517089888,
-0.0011830359,
0.0067739305,
0.0273927432,
0.0010586631,
0.0125275701,
-0.0331166387,
0.0141323963,
0.0475969948,
-0.045179259,
-0.0035102288,
0.0504327677,
0.0208414346,
0.0739697739,
0.0100220367,
0.0130944848,
-0.0357033238,
0.0121863596,
0.0047653681,
-0.0687282383,
-0.0022416334,
0.0112455906,
0.0004068957,
-0.0127895139,
-0.0258035138,
-0.0303490274,
-0.0389061645,
-0.0270998422,
-0.0494904071,
0.0177683607,
-0.0466065332,
-0.0097263604,
-0.0008627442,
-0.0310836267,
0.0532819368,
0.0045021907,
0.0060431571,
0.0078904321,
0.0289254654,
-0.0043928795,
-0.0347394906,
-0.0682993308,
-0.011634334,
0.0443190224,
-0.0046321121,
0.0277292263,
0.0121977692,
-0.0268591028,
-0.010557672,
0.0036828457,
-0.0488053672,
-0.0381764993,
0.0671244115,
0.0765897855,
0.0116251297,
-0.0423144288,
0.0746749565,
0.0151730897,
0.0367420502,
0.0000235804,
0.0016650876,
0.0035565149,
0.043865405,
-0.0140904039,
-0.0071097333,
-0.0353472941,
0.0496377982,
-0.0154601624,
-0.0947468504,
0.0299495887,
-0.0388010032,
0.0120478328,
0.057793349,
0.0547001064,
0.0188389122,
0.0037565397,
-0.0369505696,
0.0071620741,
0.0065757651,
-0.0254771281,
0.018383041,
0.0226083398,
-0.0495659374,
0.0138627775,
0.0538361147,
0.0048338026,
-0.0442797914,
-0.0329251178,
-0.0525454618,
0.0047215987,
0.0030998106,
0.0051317103,
-0.0163882188,
-0.0377600305,
0.0342905894,
0.0333920345,
-0.0040124757,
-0.0162412021,
-0.0122685563,
0.0095159132,
-0.0504602976,
0.0172042102,
-0.0499917939,
0.0285368953,
0.0251217447,
0.0931236222,
0.0040846043,
-0.017362861,
0.0210161693,
0.0634124801,
0.0040566875,
0.0012995787,
-0.0287105944,
0.0401603244,
0.0104431007,
0.0431607813,
-0.0482860617,
-0.0128610535,
-0.0202798732,
0.0360778235,
0.0057449909,
-0.0856400058,
-0.0136521664,
0.0368624441,
2.942e-7,
0.0080983676,
0.0359439217,
0.0322556421,
-0.0417072065,
0.0305606332,
0.0092991339,
-0.0284545515,
0.0281463191,
0.0215516258,
0.0159325097,
0.015337415,
0.0502934456,
0.0431539416,
0.0020493621,
-0.0965704843,
-0.0045906915,
-0.0394585878,
0.0406556986,
-0.0546565875,
-0.0335811824,
-0.0305615887,
0.0856947228,
0.0027136323,
0.0012170934,
0.0888107046,
-0.0261359289,
0.0761438757,
0.0494727679,
0.0477680527,
0.0425345451,
-0.0184552316,
-0.0596883595,
-0.0129853664,
-0.0374233723,
-0.0368994176,
0.0085579576,
-0.0216497295,
0.0754879713,
-0.0220111012,
-0.0321924463,
0.0475975126,
0.0351693705,
0.0183297116,
-0.024361318,
0.0566035062,
-0.0002119496,
0.027572317,
-0.0055223932,
-0.0455562733,
-0.0184908733,
0.0296894219,
0.0024400235,
-0.0052795792,
0.029579673,
0.0090010669,
0.0483210236,
-0.0080932919,
-0.0462513641,
0.0020513241,
-0.0236505736,
-0.0476517454,
-0.0281256773,
-0.0584914871,
0.0440582559,
0.0017162455,
-0.001254032,
-0.0093764458,
3.173561307e-34,
0.0107570235,
-0.0117834816,
-0.0086717848,
0.0604253635,
0.0137950629,
-0.0241782237,
0.0016281405,
0.0200513545,
0.0011962001,
-0.0729497373,
-0.0522748828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05791v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05791v1 | Problem-Solving Guide: Predicting the Algorithm Tags and Difficulty for Competitive Programming Problems | 2023-10-09T15:26:07 | 2023-10-09T15:26:07 | Juntae Kim, Eunjung Cho, Dongwoo Kim, Dongbin Na | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent program development industries have required problem-solving
abilities for engineers, especially application developers. However, AI-based
education systems to help solve computer algorithm problems have not yet
attracted attention, while most big tech companies require the ability to solve
algorithm problems including Google, Meta, and Amazon. The most useful guide to
solving algorithm problems might be guessing the category (tag) of the facing
problems. Therefore, our study addresses the task of predicting the algorithm
tag as a useful tool for engineers and developers. Moreover, we also consider
predicting the difficulty levels of algorithm problems, which can be used as
useful guidance to calculate the required time to solve that problem. In this
paper, we present a real-world algorithm problem multi-task dataset, AMT, by
mainly collecting problem samples from the most famous and large competitive
programming website Codeforces. To the best of our knowledge, our proposed
dataset is the most large-scale dataset for predicting algorithm tags compared
to previous studies. Moreover, our work is the first to address predicting the
difficulty levels of algorithm problems. We present a deep learning-based novel
method for simultaneously predicting algorithm tags and the difficulty levels
of an algorithm problem given. All datasets and source codes are available at
https://github.com/sronger/PSG_Predicting_Algorithm_Tags_and_Difficulty. | [
0.0257234965,
0.0065136179,
-0.0565994009,
0.0104266861,
-0.0108073596,
0.0100693535,
0.0264109857,
-0.0201183483,
0.0091518378,
-0.0017023772,
0.0307244137,
-0.0012060006,
-0.0138132321,
0.0517780036,
-0.0017780042,
-0.0197494682,
0.0003504724,
-0.0204729792,
0.0108557949,
-0.0052396082,
0.0061975596,
0.0199900661,
-0.0322810039,
0.078742139,
-0.005148666,
-0.047606796,
-0.0281840153,
-0.0055644773,
-0.018483147,
-0.044066228,
0.0138657624,
0.0243626498,
0.0256691221,
0.030308634,
0.0000020699,
-0.0352535322,
-0.0143849999,
-0.0446736589,
-0.03222524,
0.010895242,
-0.0026576063,
0.0571744628,
0.0109352134,
0.0373397581,
-0.0442818366,
0.0067713032,
0.0506957062,
0.0272052456,
0.0548427776,
-0.0095141977,
0.0071229869,
-0.0120850224,
0.0015580382,
-0.0082296841,
0.0533112548,
-0.079626523,
0.0119720241,
0.0166608617,
0.0075825541,
0.0046318858,
-0.015961403,
0.0054551396,
0.0446791723,
0.0457627103,
0.046253603,
0.0037523443,
-0.0282366741,
-0.0077463547,
0.0103184739,
0.0577013902,
-0.059406694,
0.0062694182,
-0.0008871072,
-0.0357798301,
-0.0048814327,
-0.0302220341,
-0.0067120166,
-0.0016930831,
-0.0191051289,
-0.0182119962,
0.0168782379,
0.0122186914,
-0.0110052833,
-0.0023168018,
0.0002331824,
0.053894911,
-0.0142046232,
-0.00400776,
0.0374373049,
-0.0137258116,
-0.0155559536,
-0.0186740514,
0.0327797495,
-0.0113628451,
-0.0540238097,
0.0061403629,
-0.0111273834,
-0.0687036887,
-0.021074215,
-0.0084846234,
0.0318575464,
-0.0044673276,
0.0148643693,
0.038692046,
-0.0273049194,
0.0460848697,
-0.0238142163,
-0.0165746789,
-0.0146079063,
-0.0114187412,
-0.0842245817,
0.0097461035,
-0.0300933551,
0.0506301746,
0.0439433567,
0.0497315414,
-0.0566033907,
0.0071609169,
-0.0625828877,
0.0251148362,
0.0076644639,
0.0437992103,
-0.0257971995,
0.006641733,
-0.0549237803,
-0.0431431904,
-0.0630855113,
0.0147314416,
-0.0039888364,
0.0014162161,
0.0204590987,
0.0036053606,
0.0139156748,
-0.0202808362,
0.0436423644,
0.0520468131,
0.0140567897,
0.0552673042,
-0.0732339025,
-0.0417742617,
0.0399477482,
0.0111199645,
0.0101781068,
-0.088636823,
0.0162117016,
-0.0180639736,
-0.0110659571,
-0.0453581065,
-0.0030501422,
0.0207505208,
-0.0063113668,
0.0695249289,
-0.0479618497,
-0.0020183942,
0.0926594958,
0.0332377516,
-0.04508885,
0.0309320502,
0.012338304,
0.0594643541,
0.0416058712,
-0.0525376573,
0.0468887724,
0.0223535076,
-0.0242278464,
-0.034444429,
0.0517965518,
0.0069239596,
0.0276915375,
0.0155303506,
-0.0482334048,
0.0024381604,
0.0180256702,
-0.021661222,
-0.0248226989,
0.0135089019,
0.0380519331,
0.0683996156,
0.0324983597,
0.0458738022,
-0.002676738,
-0.0448714271,
-0.000819839,
0.0953198299,
-0.016406266,
-0.0218693279,
-0.009801452,
0.031137865,
-0.042381119,
-0.0781673864,
0.0099837035,
0.0101481183,
0.0069035906,
-0.003597175,
0.0743103325,
-0.010605867,
-0.0601180345,
-0.0343262404,
0.0008283225,
0.0031427164,
-0.030707702,
-0.0366241112,
-0.0189209394,
0.0127141438,
0.0493945405,
-0.0906166211,
-0.0377643891,
-0.0086834971,
0.0479459241,
-0.0672271028,
0.0387255177,
-0.0054030828,
-0.008600519,
-0.0602989718,
-0.0222423654,
-0.0088403542,
-0.0306898877,
-0.0011542812,
0.0497218184,
-0.0081738196,
0.0175042823,
-0.0105189634,
-0.0740106106,
0.0162525382,
-0.0256908555,
-0.030653106,
0.0572122037,
0.0096436208,
0.0097696269,
0.0084161265,
0.0396927781,
0.0063407058,
0.0477102026,
-0.0330954976,
-0.0193614382,
-0.0519293994,
-0.0143170943,
0.028309742,
0.0289004166,
-0.0986294523,
-0.0276777595,
0.0632399023,
-0.0523796082,
-0.0263060331,
0.0790046677,
-0.0407341979,
-0.0112686129,
0.0682332292,
-0.0028726947,
-0.0114162751,
-0.0126506435,
-0.0149758104,
0.0450476743,
0.0716281757,
0.0604039207,
0.0151048051,
0.0093803173,
0.0027983002,
0.0052675791,
-0.0380889028,
-0.0073745814,
-0.051569093,
0.0191513151,
0.0398764908,
0.0133658396,
-0.0546643324,
0.0067300051,
-0.0786235407,
0.0121586043,
0.0288164485,
0.0173192248,
-0.0123908864,
-0.0336786769,
0.0086937463,
-0.0275180694,
-0.0628409386,
0.0342493951,
-0.0599080361,
-0.0170807652,
0.0385025591,
0.0403966382,
-0.0484397151,
-0.0444071144,
-0.0432957299,
-0.0608437359,
0.0321705751,
0.0048833508,
-0.034907952,
-0.0230040587,
0.0758807957,
-0.0222374611,
0.013289623,
-0.0173254125,
-0.0213967692,
-0.0189346559,
-0.0050647934,
0.0523027666,
0.0505066998,
0.0019870473,
0.0325425118,
0.0234016199,
-0.0100399628,
-0.0414073244,
0.0329422206,
0.0154505093,
-0.0347113423,
0.0145157715,
-0.0683830306,
0.0102655655,
0.0774959773,
-0.0125202285,
-0.0051171798,
-0.0134287849,
0.0483208299,
0.0016382854,
0.0346796028,
-0.0121668177,
0.03045181,
0.0336446613,
0.0396801308,
-0.0133630829,
-0.0323203355,
0.0878641903,
0.0172868893,
-0.0210592337,
-0.0340895206,
-0.0591167025,
-0.0293767098,
0.0513721891,
0.0082848081,
0.0231606439,
-0.0008755946,
-0.0141784018,
-0.0736518055,
0.04282948,
0.0298661832,
-0.0471432135,
-0.0119373128,
-0.0309453886,
-0.0367979966,
-0.0186958294,
-0.0153286308,
-0.0248719119,
0.0266105887,
0.0054465192,
0.0042122174,
0.0498191193,
0.0130701009,
-0.0079525206,
-0.0165785514,
0.0150151048,
0.0033545364,
0.0295864455,
-0.0347996801,
0.0004435305,
-0.0071051461,
0.0414843187,
0.0026119268,
-0.0279132649,
-0.0130164856,
0.0164829809,
0.0147636905,
0.0854853839,
0.0120921545,
-0.0778107271,
0.0099624693,
0.0239724088,
-0.0689758211,
0.0059042391,
0.0599015914,
-0.038175188,
-0.0545621738,
0.0157798268,
0.0549641736,
0.0701289624,
-0.0660655946,
-0.0070266044,
0.0061552781,
-0.003184774,
0.0881288797,
0.0214522704,
-0.0826229677,
-0.0386280939,
0.0042331005,
0.0229401495,
-0.0307926983,
-0.0467548817,
-0.0119191585,
-0.0871598646,
0.0001744589,
-0.0206146017,
0.0308966693,
-0.0366542414,
-0.0229558405,
-0.0319414586,
-0.0218524225,
-0.0636970848,
-0.0273470823,
0.0197210256,
0.0045856233,
0.0407121927,
-0.0760821551,
0.002373891,
0.0607883967,
-0.0149548994,
0.0505711548,
0.0472784638,
0.0029782639,
-0.0299185105,
-0.0072592041,
0.0636125877,
0.0374293439,
-0.0173944235,
-0.0235166755,
0.0283603221,
-0.0163374804,
-0.0231407546,
0.0154225975,
-0.0065425178,
-0.0799644962,
0.0128527256,
0.1034394801,
0.0898234695,
0.0206328202,
0.010626358,
-0.0518845059,
-0.0231232196,
-0.0154425204,
0.0409095883,
0.0156861525,
-0.0490404516,
-0.0070976671,
-0.0761575252,
0.0255726296,
-0.0407997221,
-0.0074505587,
-0.0177354962,
-0.0043816012,
0.0247272812,
-0.0178954136,
0.0065089134,
0.0846583694,
0.0107174339,
0.0086985976,
-0.0491306856,
0.0335536189,
0.0323457457,
-0.1147967428,
-0.0014608732,
0.0108248787,
0.0291272812,
-0.0258243959,
-0.0144337872,
0.0362487882,
-0.0236930102,
-0.0412102304,
0.039301049,
-0.0777821764,
0.0083203306,
-0.0327835232,
0.0298431665,
0.0138501618,
-0.0358116962,
-0.0252467543,
-0.0446697511,
-0.0527951904,
0.0034943551,
-0.0126069905,
-0.0252477918,
-0.0027520091,
-0.0202308316,
-0.0006400191,
-0.0327476598,
-0.052395802,
0.0106074447,
0.0031557169,
-0.0145303253,
-0.0245667081,
0.0247883964,
0.0027727743,
0.0326045156,
0.0315117836,
0.0448399484,
-0.0720902234,
-0.0260427054,
0.01780813,
0.0455154814,
-0.0305740125,
-0.0322713219,
0.0219939444,
-0.0040945676,
0.0003917947,
0.0603079982,
0.0510041527,
0.0545634739,
-0.016728377,
-0.0106838904,
0.052359134,
0.0053870925,
0.0663098171,
-0.0075950171,
0.0167810544,
0.0014868607,
-0.02999302,
0.0241979826,
0.028834736,
-0.0048801964,
0.0276093911,
0.0021414151,
0.0596003272,
0.0049582906,
0.0225769579,
-0.0180708151,
-0.0613994226,
-0.0215964112,
-0.0189374667,
0.034267664,
0.0282845329,
-0.0575449951,
0.0051454664,
0.0408501849,
-0.0239699595,
0.0256337319,
-0.0181400143,
-0.0231095348,
0.0111785745,
0.0372005776,
0.0013651275,
-0.000331757,
0.1034147143,
0.0527646318,
-0.018173568,
0.000254689,
-0.0416207276,
-0.0180433802,
0.0229018275,
0.0535514243,
0.0518949628,
-0.0175200254,
-0.0365316197,
-0.0069268998,
-0.0483037643,
0.0052039647,
-0.0243744981,
0.0459132716,
0.0318438374,
0.0793480799,
0.0830391198,
-0.0177025143,
-0.0203715432,
-0.009044107,
-0.0164017044,
-0.0352636538,
-0.0362500958,
-0.0208949521,
-5.526547017e-33,
-0.0018626632,
-0.0507594347,
0.004972619,
0.0118194213,
0.0290668253,
0.0221993197,
-0.0290265772,
0.0293320436,
-0.013364071,
-0.0276485011,
0.0125565985,
0.020630436,
-0.0141562,
-0.00852146,
0.0603699647,
-0.0086789103,
0.0306565873,
0.0125566917,
-0.0007281713,
0.0369530916,
-0.0405686311,
0.0045852326,
0.0233557411,
-0.0478742681,
-0.027476944,
-0.0056202128,
0.0170767978,
-0.0384855382,
0.0392328799,
0.0478175692,
0.0010580987,
0.0582029298,
0.0115043698,
-0.0957936794,
-0.0093713244,
-0.0143560292,
-0.0287784506,
-0.0419029929,
-0.025978405,
-0.0163101833,
-0.0139207868,
-0.0238921363,
0.0475018397,
0.0335175768,
0.0059741703,
-0.0071955416,
0.0942691192,
0.0084304865,
0.0371922627,
-0.0520660356,
0.0049966685,
0.006040677,
-0.0852389485,
0.0145077473,
0.0411735922,
0.0369814746,
0.0093355468,
0.0501483902,
-0.0233992375,
0.0055498509,
-0.0278739687,
0.0532497279,
0.0649624988,
-0.0211400967,
-0.0147296116,
-0.0067041633,
0.0424226858,
0.0294246506,
-0.0032290742,
-0.0054172911,
0.0245379843,
0.0533917584,
0.0399030037,
-0.0001014238,
0.0710082427,
-0.0016866592,
-0.0555383638,
0.0296474285,
0.0034030953,
-0.0042695752,
-0.0088779014,
0.0075886743,
-0.0565466769,
-0.0210661273,
-0.0201960839,
0.0157962143,
-0.035147991,
-0.0214759912,
0.0145764546,
-0.0172189455,
-0.0140880439,
0.0542606451,
-0.0061543663,
-0.0438916832,
0.0286974143,
-0.0242112689,
-0.0045920527,
0.0732880831,
0.0047268607,
0.0298180096,
-0.0248777885,
-0.0421353765,
-0.0230560172,
-0.0296244472,
0.0754355192,
0.0027951335,
-0.0157974325,
-0.0164774414,
-0.0588387623,
-0.0220672693,
-0.0378488675,
-0.0266679563,
-0.0083482405,
0.0659753382,
-0.0068603149,
0.0034590799,
0.005952226,
-0.0015061639,
0.0205823127,
0.0224840455,
-0.0538967289,
-0.0218990296,
-0.021024812,
-0.0098776454,
0.0030642617,
-0.0546525791,
-0.0669873729,
0.0138406754,
0.002597563,
-0.015391048,
-0.0493800007,
0.0056606731,
2.673e-7,
-0.031530384,
0.0583370067,
-0.0103169214,
0.0346061066,
-0.0000762491,
0.0492872782,
0.0301434007,
0.001153855,
-0.0094976621,
-0.0316760987,
-0.0081291059,
0.020727586,
0.0322292633,
0.0395145528,
-0.0569126531,
-0.0199959818,
0.0041166223,
0.0366386138,
-0.0701478422,
0.0329934433,
0.0705507845,
0.0640711635,
0.0295264572,
0.0384807251,
0.0087926928,
-0.0194633082,
-0.0074016973,
-0.003263369,
0.0457223505,
0.0412817113,
-0.0328543223,
0.0722444281,
-0.0378434509,
0.0360327214,
-0.0279486869,
-0.0382886529,
0.0468640961,
-0.0263853893,
0.0159092862,
0.0048504639,
0.0350116827,
-0.0113874516,
-0.0153120048,
-0.0187394861,
0.0027935586,
-0.0113010006,
-0.0417526476,
0.0056520142,
0.0125499535,
0.0064431308,
0.0001196265,
-0.0055311951,
0.0478578135,
-0.0478056818,
-0.0086432053,
-0.0609717891,
-0.0424062125,
-0.0531754196,
0.0152607244,
0.0373251215,
-0.0245578084,
-0.012753468,
-0.0625049099,
0.0270064194,
0.0582826063,
-0.0132353306,
0.0363716632,
2.577160702e-34,
0.0130990259,
0.003869581,
0.0123362271,
0.020149285,
0.0345834121,
-0.0113333901,
-0.0547495335,
-0.0137210088,
-0.0241323486,
0.0091651427,
-0.0340995677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05782v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05782v3 | Aligning Language Models with Human Preferences via a Bayesian Approach | 2023-10-09T15:15:05 | 2024-01-13T11:37:57 | Jiashuo Wang, Haozhao Wang, Shichao Sun, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the quest to advance human-centric natural language generation (NLG)
systems, ensuring alignment between NLG models and human preferences is
crucial. For this alignment, current popular methods leverage a reinforcement
learning (RL) approach with a reward model trained on feedback from humans.
However, inherent disagreements due to the subjective nature of human
preferences pose a significant challenge for training the reward model,
resulting in a deterioration of the NLG performance. To tackle this issue,
previous approaches typically rely on majority voting or averaging to
consolidate multiple inconsistent preferences into a merged one. Although
straightforward to understand and execute, such methods suffer from an
inability to capture the nuanced degrees of disaggregation among humans and may
only represent a specialized subset of individuals, thereby lacking the ability
to quantitatively disclose the universality of human preferences. To address
this challenge, this paper proposes a novel approach, which employs a Bayesian
framework to account for the distribution of disagreements among human
preferences as training a preference model, and names it as d-PM. Besides,
considering the RL strategy's inefficient and complex training process over the
training efficiency, we further propose utilizing the contrastive learning
strategy to train the NLG model with the preference scores derived from the
d-PM model. Extensive experiments on two human-centric NLG tasks, i.e.,
emotional support conversation and integrity "Rule-of-Thumb" generation, show
that our method consistently exceeds previous SOTA models in both automatic and
human evaluations. | [
0.0655645207,
0.0660795942,
0.0003802947,
-0.0177544635,
-0.0713286772,
0.018519992,
-0.0303573851,
-0.0418434255,
-0.0147901746,
-0.0381186977,
-0.0230431519,
-0.0642537251,
0.0232849848,
0.0020582159,
0.0107232677,
-0.1004887,
0.0138411513,
0.0276569501,
0.0565827191,
-0.0182196684,
0.0153698102,
0.0339398421,
-0.0178454388,
0.0431386903,
0.0007229889,
0.02902616,
-0.0081236949,
0.001413606,
0.0583288148,
-0.0199582968,
0.0450013615,
0.0590453818,
-0.0109449029,
-0.0210531987,
0.0000020712,
-0.0513114035,
-0.015346949,
-0.012940987,
0.0384684727,
-0.0287664607,
0.0936138332,
0.0314266682,
-0.0197384562,
0.0278809797,
-0.0289521888,
0.0172811896,
0.0410038307,
0.0583926998,
0.0440339595,
0.0560204796,
0.0038120253,
-0.007686784,
-0.0242614541,
-0.0391071402,
-0.0098124752,
0.0041304342,
-0.0047155693,
0.0051504802,
0.0237944126,
-0.027761763,
0.0220567938,
-0.0137830749,
-0.0046426551,
0.0272540879,
0.0036326547,
0.0291891675,
0.0155898174,
-0.0193138681,
-0.0151252253,
0.050639037,
-0.0055008754,
-0.0037154509,
0.0213275496,
-0.0240418762,
0.0265781023,
0.0226413608,
-0.0071362965,
0.0461696051,
-0.0249907672,
0.0345644839,
0.043479491,
0.0063658771,
-0.0147093814,
0.0464828461,
-0.0011883616,
0.0515482165,
0.0156945847,
-0.0102520939,
0.0089957351,
0.0237353947,
-0.0548419207,
-0.0478353389,
0.0224470999,
-0.0181723312,
-0.0728080124,
0.0231181681,
-0.0717178658,
-0.0040979651,
0.0424553491,
-0.0448329635,
0.0325806439,
0.0336611718,
-0.0067455834,
-0.003684557,
0.0417053886,
0.044639498,
0.0227234717,
-0.0164583325,
-0.0412797555,
0.0448552147,
-0.0272794571,
0.0059862598,
0.0102285892,
0.0456117801,
-0.0542123243,
-0.0197654143,
-0.0731945857,
-0.0024118288,
-0.0453479066,
-0.0059502693,
0.0293314327,
0.0491954535,
-0.0585308447,
0.0056111859,
-0.0471794456,
0.0362507999,
-0.0472920388,
0.0220278781,
0.0614806265,
0.0057058386,
0.038942799,
0.0116640115,
-0.0103179356,
-0.0120501518,
-0.002105372,
0.0480212644,
-0.0311484728,
-0.02129866,
-0.0250322372,
-0.029449055,
-0.0695412979,
-0.0615296848,
-0.0362876058,
-0.0593701899,
0.0112240119,
-0.0224650949,
-0.0322409458,
-0.0361660458,
0.0231249258,
0.0286468398,
-0.0391309895,
0.0481905825,
0.0142965754,
-0.0218157489,
0.030144766,
0.0015841249,
-0.0286032166,
0.0421825573,
0.0367866084,
0.0644419119,
0.0223391522,
0.0280306544,
0.0053566997,
-0.0218163505,
-0.0183096286,
0.0068121878,
-0.0375443511,
-0.0291291866,
-0.0229746774,
0.0244601108,
0.0492330864,
0.0913096741,
-0.0344974324,
-0.0297472272,
0.0827778056,
0.0092051625,
-0.0086066052,
-0.0044354936,
0.0276101902,
0.0684087723,
-0.0398178622,
0.0450824499,
-0.0255690143,
0.0312916152,
-0.033420302,
0.0275740102,
0.0432463102,
0.0363796428,
-0.0047213393,
-0.0682804659,
0.0042887256,
-0.031306006,
0.0308063496,
0.0064967144,
0.0389286876,
-0.0061213449,
-0.0465922505,
-0.0117750168,
0.0528765805,
-0.0713469163,
0.0280473158,
-0.0291350074,
0.0657785013,
0.1064306423,
0.0574311316,
0.0125818336,
-0.012111715,
-0.0248120651,
-0.0529571809,
0.0471625216,
0.0370751731,
-0.0118619557,
-0.025166152,
-0.0681323707,
-0.0218006913,
0.0003586692,
0.0087296488,
0.0575377494,
-0.0007424841,
-0.0112567944,
0.011292587,
0.0232744757,
-0.0501045361,
0.0264437981,
0.0081444765,
0.0181693099,
0.0422174484,
0.0009829941,
0.0423591994,
0.0207009073,
-0.0320290253,
0.0142266769,
0.0200122241,
-0.0112169143,
-0.0313968882,
0.0409290679,
-0.0528583974,
-0.0353527516,
0.0263973698,
-0.0349301547,
0.0251417868,
0.0091150915,
-0.0310227722,
-0.0247191414,
0.0087015517,
-0.04572469,
-0.0132669415,
-0.0338521302,
0.031067282,
0.0400431082,
-0.0203963313,
-0.0689275116,
0.041019395,
-0.0166984834,
-0.027802784,
-0.0176431127,
-0.0069674547,
0.00020174,
-0.0570093021,
-0.015054211,
0.0384454541,
-0.0067842673,
0.0356575698,
0.0860243291,
0.015389598,
-0.0532035157,
-0.0557873659,
-0.068672739,
0.006060943,
-0.0077938656,
0.0258067735,
0.0255559366,
-0.0193841998,
-0.0106224073,
0.0002185321,
-0.0617508702,
-0.047913935,
0.028480256,
-0.012959931,
0.0272390526,
0.0090659307,
0.0090039419,
-0.0682983771,
0.0136552388,
0.0135604925,
-0.0085852072,
0.0188810006,
0.0295167547,
-0.0547892749,
0.0453440547,
-0.0518102422,
-0.0068214135,
-0.0004016449,
-0.0460797362,
0.0248198509,
0.0191347525,
0.0518985391,
0.0746875554,
0.0860187411,
0.0356212407,
0.0442444608,
0.0146798836,
-0.0521222651,
-0.0105868317,
-0.070234023,
0.0193272922,
0.0184009504,
-0.0380811505,
0.019901583,
0.0452294871,
0.0234038066,
0.0102804322,
-0.0759879798,
0.0396133997,
0.0012837576,
-0.027109364,
0.0114916293,
-0.020961469,
-0.0250773933,
0.0171047207,
-0.026349755,
-0.0560908467,
0.0954932198,
0.0055074045,
0.0322251841,
-0.0854082555,
-0.0146746812,
-0.0041670334,
0.0062044035,
-0.0282639302,
0.0328867733,
0.0443132967,
-0.008409664,
-0.0715080053,
-0.0336133167,
0.0348253027,
-0.0468887649,
0.0174250696,
-0.0881536379,
-0.0018432416,
0.0210502371,
-0.0523803569,
-0.0532550141,
-0.0340393633,
-0.0185235441,
0.0140607236,
0.0425198898,
-0.0360935181,
0.0041527026,
-0.0080366656,
0.0102932956,
-0.0115892049,
-0.0018082896,
-0.0137689672,
-0.0037830998,
0.0314457528,
0.0762750208,
0.0064123538,
0.0153775075,
-0.014173572,
-0.0340032391,
0.0549663045,
0.0410575233,
0.0096448166,
-0.0012718883,
-0.0012769969,
0.0229114294,
-0.0340870284,
-0.0244109072,
0.0441993028,
0.0045302254,
-0.008290045,
-0.0024640204,
0.1035080627,
0.0293364208,
-0.0300953444,
-0.0009381944,
0.0165635254,
0.0699518919,
-0.0163045861,
0.0190936942,
-0.0707837045,
-0.0189488959,
-0.0077903178,
0.0720597282,
-0.0279156435,
-0.0204313565,
-0.0144186625,
-0.0969608203,
0.0144157112,
0.0335723571,
-0.0231139101,
0.0004900511,
-0.0094629731,
-0.0111407954,
-0.0428818502,
0.0060026934,
0.0051864688,
0.0224996768,
0.0327655561,
0.0384643674,
0.0107906489,
-0.0680793896,
-0.0049777916,
-0.0528318845,
0.0621296838,
0.0939189717,
0.0338597111,
0.0447183847,
-0.0493028238,
-0.0228625052,
0.0131717408,
-0.0080556748,
-0.0266061928,
0.0292709358,
-0.0343151949,
0.015620077,
-0.0385932773,
0.0646086186,
-0.0183191411,
-0.0183993988,
-0.0069170846,
0.0216923729,
-0.012472691,
-0.0032973622,
-0.0197663214,
0.0428253599,
0.0481990278,
0.0756558627,
0.0074052815,
-0.0808385089,
-0.0251110289,
-0.0114982165,
0.0092921956,
-0.0434295684,
0.0227492489,
-0.0129464632,
-0.0311811678,
-0.0147447959,
-0.1169328466,
-0.0401048176,
-0.022893237,
0.0376649834,
0.0055228979,
-0.0399214514,
0.0307429451,
-0.0278570838,
-0.0315588377,
0.007478965,
-0.0097908042,
0.0082136057,
-0.0562078878,
-0.0462774076,
0.0084754769,
-0.0567763783,
-0.0079111615,
-0.010576712,
0.0114450455,
-0.1067293137,
-0.0085442327,
0.0817377418,
0.0238138121,
0.0325269476,
0.0202925969,
-0.0577109307,
-0.0124163451,
0.0599872731,
-0.0149329379,
0.0107321767,
0.0220348667,
0.0355437361,
-0.0132701239,
-0.0003656233,
-0.0108993025,
0.021111371,
0.0036375816,
0.0570423044,
-0.0014994141,
-0.037740238,
0.04757661,
-0.002515279,
0.0026612498,
-0.0819286928,
-0.000206912,
-0.0428591929,
-0.0405737087,
-0.0176229216,
-0.0341723599,
-0.0454824381,
-0.0318308994,
0.0034158682,
0.0117545072,
-0.0055536805,
-0.0296957642,
-0.0646210164,
0.031873472,
0.0065079886,
-0.0394264758,
0.0190087575,
0.0270848237,
0.0237082522,
-0.004735217,
-0.0008215818,
-0.0206971597,
0.0021155656,
0.0572505593,
0.0063620657,
0.0969919115,
0.0179502387,
-0.0339555815,
0.01006856,
0.0275643878,
-0.0111337006,
-0.011061186,
-0.042253118,
-0.0041561127,
0.0540596582,
0.0040512872,
0.0481959097,
-0.0530622602,
0.0088251587,
-0.0228933748,
0.0518707968,
-0.0126579283,
0.0063283718,
0.0135610737,
0.0212348513,
-0.0195156559,
-0.0084221046,
0.0569651164,
-0.0264853723,
-0.009105253,
-0.0588878356,
-0.0192811824,
-0.0561229698,
-0.0197676662,
0.0056276559,
0.0220874306,
-0.0169517938,
-0.0209834129,
-0.0696729273,
-0.0356237181,
0.0035272625,
0.0555913746,
0.0539564118,
-0.0176182128,
0.07162074,
0.0364648402,
-0.0761189088,
0.0207558423,
-0.0655639768,
-0.0109229041,
-0.0457236543,
0.0099044703,
-0.0580634102,
-6.207118574e-33,
-0.03244064,
-0.0547839403,
0.0161463078,
-0.0257279053,
-0.0166729093,
-0.0410756506,
0.0096786702,
0.0302498527,
0.040466141,
0.0191940013,
0.0186335407,
-0.0223628934,
0.0097452523,
0.0210684408,
0.0165231656,
0.0044350177,
0.0451269671,
-0.0087379375,
-0.049091287,
0.012005385,
0.0443606377,
0.0104610575,
-0.0007334567,
-0.0698268488,
0.0326437503,
0.0402750522,
-0.0448463969,
0.0078960108,
0.0135577982,
0.0455341525,
0.0055221221,
0.0287589058,
0.0046178694,
-0.0096254554,
-0.0046224003,
0.0326697081,
-0.0173973013,
-0.0140907764,
0.0284134168,
-0.0167567488,
0.005476451,
-0.0269073471,
0.0060428041,
-0.011508829,
-0.0437273011,
0.032905262,
0.0226808991,
-0.0350227132,
-0.0263130832,
-0.0050240722,
-0.0320519321,
0.0231261402,
-0.011888898,
-0.0286432505,
-0.0116329538,
0.052322045,
-0.0354586057,
0.0162250735,
-0.030793326,
0.0666500852,
0.0363007411,
-0.0096530141,
0.0622207746,
0.0119405137,
-0.0095157474,
0.0613870174,
0.0363873318,
0.0048375754,
0.0035218343,
-0.0114652663,
-0.0115370136,
0.045829542,
0.0283949282,
0.0669061542,
0.0222455338,
0.0039332048,
-0.0236290153,
0.0610955879,
0.0334728882,
-0.0159220658,
0.0373525061,
0.0424885005,
-0.0570210852,
-0.0206881203,
-0.0252620559,
-0.0608735122,
-0.0180176795,
-0.0500451028,
0.0281744823,
0.0324494094,
-0.0421343148,
-0.0582901575,
-0.0016879962,
-0.0149572333,
-0.0139755961,
0.0089610219,
-0.0790969208,
-0.002843397,
-0.0214096233,
-0.0276749693,
-0.074157007,
-0.0191106517,
0.0190509558,
0.0107949739,
-0.0298070181,
0.0184946936,
0.0110727334,
0.0026803552,
-0.0351707414,
0.0410650373,
-0.006924802,
0.0428626798,
0.0047906665,
-0.0243702028,
0.0392271355,
-0.0030056923,
-0.0253901016,
0.0461272113,
0.0141864792,
-0.0249384828,
-0.0314568058,
-0.0178444665,
-0.0080589242,
0.0223320443,
-0.0066765305,
0.0265263971,
0.0171280596,
-0.0221739039,
0.0043989085,
0.0106600244,
-0.0241032746,
-0.0062999064,
2.775e-7,
-0.0269533042,
0.0260682162,
0.0189858768,
-0.0240112767,
-0.0168357193,
0.0719819888,
0.0308494698,
0.0147064645,
0.0341981798,
0.013497184,
0.0148986541,
-0.0133555196,
0.0657800734,
0.0003451872,
-0.0548783839,
-0.0062704226,
-0.0354994424,
-0.0051943939,
-0.0161167439,
-0.0104673058,
0.0844211504,
0.0288794544,
0.030194886,
-0.0014029387,
0.0128723318,
0.0327353477,
0.0735336468,
-0.0514660589,
-0.0336952843,
0.0021593017,
0.0167986434,
-0.0273534376,
-0.0266672075,
0.0102128778,
-0.0061101052,
-0.0211356338,
-0.0206726734,
0.0581317618,
0.0273860786,
-0.0509517491,
0.0166524108,
0.0336586758,
0.010677265,
-0.0511740558,
0.0150104705,
-0.0896452442,
-0.0265482776,
-0.041222509,
-0.03606968,
-0.0282755606,
0.0176300891,
-0.0421918295,
-0.0432467312,
-0.0024570476,
0.0116854655,
0.0418186784,
0.0022786234,
-0.0333736129,
-0.0107107684,
0.0539899878,
-0.0320120677,
-0.021954922,
-0.0091855759,
0.0442351326,
-0.0191109683,
-0.04204363,
-0.0042283763,
2.329902124e-34,
0.0344884954,
-0.0177808162,
-0.0074799079,
0.0056271022,
0.0422838964,
0.043041192,
-0.0135033773,
0.0101693412,
0.0757768825,
-0.0353748389,
-0.0209959969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05746v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05746v3 | Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is: Evaluating Strategic Planning and Execution of LLM Agents in an Auction Arena | 2023-10-09T14:22:09 | 2024-04-03T03:37:56 | Jiangjie Chen, Siyu Yuan, Rong Ye, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Kyle Richardson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) showcase advanced
reasoning, yet NLP evaluations often depend on static benchmarks. Evaluating
this necessitates environments that test strategic reasoning in dynamic,
competitive scenarios requiring long-term planning. We introduce AucArena, a
novel evaluation suite that simulates auctions, a setting chosen for being
highly unpredictable and involving many skills related to resource and risk
management, while also being easy to evaluate. We conduct controlled
experiments using state-of-the-art LLMs to power bidding agents to benchmark
their planning and execution skills. Our research demonstrates that LLMs, such
as GPT-4, possess key skills for auction participation, such as budget
management and goal adherence, which improve with adaptive strategies. This
highlights LLMs' potential in modeling complex social interactions in
competitive contexts. However, variability in LLM performance and occasional
outperformance by simpler methods indicate opportunities for further
advancements in LLM design and the value of our simulation environment for
ongoing testing and refinement. | [
0.0618554614,
0.0607491061,
-0.0269470681,
0.0350593813,
-0.0509820916,
-0.0026888154,
-0.0125489831,
0.0118796928,
-0.0056785783,
-0.0357771479,
-0.0268890616,
-0.058122009,
-0.0072413571,
0.0337151699,
0.0265356228,
-0.038511049,
0.0189535618,
-0.0385026187,
0.0187123939,
-0.0300183445,
0.0259093735,
-0.0088710217,
-0.0153186359,
0.0506078117,
0.01862178,
0.0094249342,
-0.0557639897,
-0.0093162078,
-0.0025499444,
-0.0823231041,
-0.0018785095,
0.0317505971,
0.0439178422,
0.022436576,
0.0000021907,
-0.0911429226,
-0.0358699262,
-0.0252470393,
-0.0607971475,
0.0591405258,
0.0954672247,
0.0117331324,
0.0313375853,
0.0293017123,
-0.0580890477,
-0.0089202821,
0.0191922113,
0.0242324919,
0.0475953221,
0.0562491678,
-0.0063384539,
0.0065504867,
0.0057940683,
-0.0404081978,
-0.0693226978,
-0.1536005735,
0.0250702035,
-0.0252117217,
0.0093889618,
-0.0069527477,
-0.0051883757,
-0.0045344993,
-0.0057430505,
0.0077939718,
-0.0330485068,
0.0424490497,
-0.0485617258,
0.0106561286,
-0.0545459948,
0.0187881552,
0.0508216061,
0.0190185215,
0.0476498157,
-0.0213005748,
-0.0207199659,
-0.0362835675,
-0.0233642664,
0.0335389562,
0.0313572101,
0.0134039037,
0.0097242128,
0.0342895947,
0.0275768731,
0.047099337,
0.0107409935,
0.0781309232,
-0.0048648901,
-0.038685061,
-0.0187319983,
-0.0206566155,
-0.0220618807,
-0.0797897279,
0.0075835562,
0.0645159781,
-0.0694056526,
0.0345897898,
0.0236140266,
0.0492041074,
0.0259438846,
-0.0551850796,
0.0599700883,
0.0200896133,
0.053408727,
0.0472054146,
0.0155528756,
0.0659738854,
0.0019350426,
0.01409127,
-0.0061648921,
0.0042757583,
-0.0420285277,
-0.0120953592,
-0.0550295003,
0.0182007272,
-0.0516653918,
-0.0415825062,
-0.0276407246,
0.0141958129,
-0.0304577872,
0.0467138328,
-0.00005413,
0.0156528354,
0.0067391014,
-0.0303755254,
-0.1112583652,
-0.0334790424,
-0.0403693244,
0.0164825805,
0.0086802747,
-0.0470478423,
0.0162187424,
0.0077896519,
-0.0307175163,
-0.0366697572,
-0.0091881445,
0.1071458384,
-0.0110923573,
0.0106610423,
-0.0308991652,
-0.0251688305,
0.0170403756,
-0.0887730494,
-0.0026782302,
-0.0442005731,
0.0235727392,
-0.0078267502,
-0.0275417715,
-0.004414788,
0.0048114783,
-0.0226172544,
-0.022409901,
0.0527489558,
-0.0012149224,
0.026909573,
-0.004529384,
-0.0063635926,
0.0279187784,
0.0615793169,
0.0420446023,
0.0368532352,
0.0494740903,
0.0257772766,
0.0238886774,
0.0489030667,
-0.0119273989,
0.0277248174,
0.0152156418,
0.0368843153,
0.0102665955,
0.02744326,
0.0210111719,
0.030034868,
-0.0327363759,
-0.0168246366,
0.0902331471,
0.0158723742,
0.0197049882,
-0.0110265035,
0.0203824919,
0.0158972554,
-0.0028882108,
-0.0450420119,
-0.0127697093,
0.0210260954,
0.0392805487,
0.0026968534,
0.018270053,
0.0006899059,
-0.020755548,
-0.0254153758,
-0.0144176623,
0.0136758974,
0.0354642421,
0.0245404486,
-0.0002193565,
-0.0406339131,
-0.070950225,
-0.0061669126,
-0.0029257354,
0.0007069946,
-0.0065871608,
-0.0809909701,
-0.0156272221,
0.0852064192,
0.0631144494,
-0.0182133093,
-0.0165544711,
-0.0094772354,
-0.0258399788,
0.0885678008,
0.0765836462,
-0.0024589994,
-0.0152186966,
-0.0536055043,
-0.0263254233,
0.0175470505,
0.0055709723,
0.0547292419,
0.0291915685,
0.0052877548,
-0.0226102993,
0.0144922193,
0.0089815678,
0.0375374481,
-0.0183089953,
-0.0681283027,
-0.0480477773,
-0.0251254924,
0.0553500801,
-0.0051567834,
-0.0135776559,
0.0080957003,
0.0153902555,
0.0349704549,
-0.0169216525,
-0.0126604978,
0.0020669124,
0.0308582541,
0.0305839088,
0.04317775,
-0.0161539372,
0.0188658405,
0.0043052621,
-0.0272745863,
0.0283273365,
-0.0189224761,
0.0695682019,
-0.0486029647,
0.0049120928,
-0.0323495455,
-0.0192668103,
-0.0229354668,
0.041831784,
0.050026726,
-0.0239560772,
-0.0192850027,
0.000210636,
0.0039847572,
-0.0672081709,
-0.0217128154,
0.0318090469,
0.0067597092,
0.035598997,
0.028708877,
0.025081994,
-0.0165490247,
-0.0373356938,
-0.110249728,
0.005593529,
0.0022929441,
0.0166624021,
0.0108390236,
-0.0348688737,
-0.0172117259,
0.0357439741,
-0.0108139561,
-0.0019779999,
-0.0013836313,
0.0335975476,
0.0344668366,
0.0127875069,
-0.0441959016,
-0.05401171,
0.0110636195,
-0.0052888999,
0.0169909205,
0.0356398895,
0.0179783963,
-0.0286104511,
0.0376776941,
-0.036381837,
0.0062823873,
-0.0237940252,
-0.0612368621,
0.0177204311,
-0.0111751547,
-0.025591841,
0.016844945,
0.0111664049,
-0.0005294322,
0.0090704644,
-0.0673215985,
-0.0875785947,
0.0299155936,
-0.0534637049,
0.0222388413,
-0.1189123169,
-0.0104452316,
0.0028627953,
0.0592838228,
-0.015113092,
0.0315699056,
-0.0251908805,
-0.0127416989,
0.0202319678,
-0.069220528,
-0.0077912873,
-0.0044216295,
-0.0227177162,
0.0647953525,
-0.0039901095,
-0.0139707513,
0.0409481041,
-0.0136136888,
-0.0217181016,
0.0000108807,
-0.007005034,
-0.0717727467,
0.0694674104,
-0.0185038336,
0.001650902,
-0.0605106093,
-0.0102051012,
-0.0247943867,
-0.0702873245,
0.0358737782,
-0.011987621,
0.0472063906,
-0.0240652822,
0.0195744466,
-0.0051393793,
-0.0269182827,
-0.0288990811,
-0.0161507241,
-0.0438904129,
0.0239398349,
0.07734292,
-0.0294639897,
-0.039732974,
0.0540778525,
0.0237593576,
-0.0034895332,
-0.0153403217,
-0.0239864066,
-0.0121714268,
0.0074071344,
0.0319881998,
0.0532904528,
0.0452989414,
-0.0310433377,
0.0194012132,
0.0106332824,
0.0568236001,
-0.0351610668,
-0.054367695,
0.0168735329,
0.0056373831,
-0.0361278765,
0.0183272865,
0.0222173147,
-0.0040816842,
-0.0569668971,
0.0217810553,
0.06217058,
0.0166068263,
0.0017632861,
0.0075199772,
-0.0258525014,
0.05792851,
0.0095354384,
0.0497881882,
-0.0467817001,
-0.0099332863,
0.0155550912,
0.0136802327,
-0.011902974,
-0.0782723054,
0.0005064478,
-0.1418276578,
0.0591443777,
-0.0356251337,
-0.0027735094,
0.0393300354,
-0.0173756387,
0.0117077567,
-0.0484949462,
0.0330080278,
0.0382133871,
0.0127597684,
-0.0184983443,
0.0264800414,
-0.0635441691,
0.0133871678,
0.0299801417,
-0.0360225663,
0.0973763391,
0.0589703023,
0.0484219417,
-0.0041252659,
-0.0088074179,
0.0036234639,
0.0030569106,
-0.022518849,
0.0083486773,
0.0309056081,
0.0052769841,
0.0078920145,
0.0069821174,
-0.0566637293,
-0.0187993031,
-0.0000205763,
0.0590206645,
0.0468607061,
-0.0131629603,
-0.0183229782,
0.0227946863,
-0.0015661174,
0.0233328138,
0.0500043556,
-0.0085291043,
-0.0175465904,
-0.0823933929,
-0.0194152985,
-0.0329425447,
-0.0713369921,
-0.0318838134,
-0.0026449969,
0.0218244568,
0.00992887,
-0.0444836579,
-0.0803628266,
0.0350228809,
0.019089587,
0.0160608161,
0.0184707381,
0.0119939046,
0.0350505933,
0.0062889289,
-0.0291506182,
-0.0288794376,
0.0220430605,
-0.0156375561,
-0.0106306355,
0.0132275578,
-0.0388794877,
-0.0269289222,
0.0191509258,
-0.0356063433,
-0.0483490005,
0.0225180201,
0.0439854003,
0.0327692479,
-0.0059992564,
-0.0061839982,
-0.0226650145,
-0.0141196102,
0.0063657924,
-0.0487785041,
0.0317693092,
0.0271073915,
0.0440955274,
-0.0036070524,
0.0300975796,
-0.0080487709,
0.0358686037,
0.0157737285,
0.0749726519,
-0.0341200717,
-0.0159881916,
0.0080745798,
0.0119741699,
-0.011916318,
-0.0377836302,
-0.0730089843,
-0.0017150289,
0.0003150952,
-0.0319988169,
0.0006074608,
-0.0366882756,
-0.0383329093,
0.0016246308,
0.0384727977,
0.0205786303,
0.0135230077,
-0.0040350007,
0.0069956598,
0.0217234194,
0.0256189425,
0.0214757603,
-0.0176022686,
-0.0112006227,
0.0259132218,
0.0247933865,
0.0306032486,
-0.0058825561,
0.0384199172,
0.0033681954,
0.0080988295,
0.0188594013,
-0.0494911745,
0.0382470228,
0.0149111515,
-0.0380469263,
-0.0824317634,
0.0491796061,
0.047746256,
0.0293150153,
0.0011946616,
0.0206839386,
-0.0578549132,
0.0404256508,
0.008386963,
-0.0402567498,
-0.0289501064,
-0.0375601016,
0.0110080419,
0.0538494065,
-0.0321953259,
0.0205593873,
0.04399997,
0.0228683818,
0.0489492565,
-0.0216279272,
-0.0183116738,
-0.0300410725,
-0.0492386632,
0.0301009286,
0.0009630364,
-0.0278915502,
-0.0118281525,
-0.0824811831,
-0.0070431177,
-0.0206339341,
0.0391146094,
-0.0031954867,
-0.0302851368,
0.0561744571,
0.0343555026,
-0.010092766,
0.0268922094,
-0.0610367209,
-0.0164509565,
-0.049004484,
-0.0102353413,
-0.0420418121,
-6.541068437e-33,
-0.000988377,
-0.0275093727,
0.0995331332,
-0.0072623645,
-0.019535264,
-0.0151361432,
-0.043921005,
-0.0047535612,
0.0001372456,
-0.0020195011,
-0.0390497893,
-0.0065094484,
0.030247394,
-0.0200604498,
0.0257061422,
-0.0433748737,
0.016298417,
-0.023329936,
-0.0362485796,
-0.0142608043,
-0.0187111143,
-0.0062761786,
0.0375124179,
-0.0301831681,
0.0191466454,
0.013376072,
-0.0573684089,
0.0141842822,
0.0006160685,
0.0591532066,
-0.0232064053,
-0.020967314,
0.0254495312,
-0.0374378636,
0.0195786245,
-0.0118263196,
0.0023933812,
0.0059168041,
0.015379834,
-0.0087501444,
-0.0140712326,
0.0078599611,
0.0035034302,
0.0133679789,
-0.0643965378,
0.0215591583,
0.0131841758,
-0.011546188,
0.0076278145,
0.0322775431,
-0.0627203211,
0.030106172,
-0.0111075062,
0.0023469729,
0.044976525,
-0.0038070802,
-0.0126112988,
0.0167204868,
-0.0479288474,
0.032811489,
-0.0306231752,
0.006415504,
0.026144281,
0.0318328887,
0.0081698904,
0.0765597522,
0.0305583421,
0.0464448631,
-0.010606722,
0.0092890859,
0.0137175601,
0.0706198215,
0.0406636,
0.049066674,
-0.0252181739,
0.0105229774,
-0.0198414866,
0.0258522406,
0.0474577919,
0.041869238,
0.0465798452,
0.0165407211,
-0.0239010602,
0.0127684548,
-0.0214807466,
-0.0210955292,
-0.0182718989,
-0.0238445438,
0.0273943394,
0.0252955221,
-0.0083066588,
0.059005104,
0.0521578826,
-0.0118077006,
-0.0566492751,
-0.0271078777,
0.012859554,
0.0458006077,
0.0039634299,
0.0347382724,
-0.0468780994,
-0.0252002943,
-0.0065673557,
0.0147484457,
0.017101068,
-0.015519795,
-0.0541235283,
0.0236676652,
-0.0344322696,
0.0081280861,
-0.0274951477,
0.0289995726,
0.0108570345,
-0.0055005499,
-0.0062061804,
-0.0377437212,
0.0101323901,
-0.0293622278,
-0.0007779946,
-0.0694128573,
-0.0101455655,
0.0136673059,
-0.0072113657,
0.0034569909,
0.0080964873,
0.0228773467,
-0.0574381985,
0.0286210794,
-0.0117793707,
0.0012655297,
-0.0136894807,
0.0136804562,
2.902e-7,
0.0077152923,
0.0850549266,
0.0015657867,
0.0478433818,
-0.0069068242,
0.0624652691,
-0.050824821,
0.0067508612,
-0.0204400942,
-0.0524400622,
0.0321123973,
0.0673992708,
0.0627385527,
0.0509265773,
-0.0734999627,
-0.0280745775,
-0.0585483313,
-0.0143318288,
-0.0654708371,
-0.0486292951,
0.0142703438,
0.052510839,
0.0268595964,
0.0004351205,
-0.0174191166,
-0.0680400878,
0.0318094678,
-0.041328419,
-0.0223816969,
0.047861252,
-0.0418072604,
-0.0167910066,
-0.0322420038,
0.006874416,
0.0073597864,
-0.0022182341,
-0.0226191096,
0.0627804026,
0.0201017465,
-0.0542614982,
-0.0131377727,
-0.0515444651,
-0.0033534833,
-0.0678505674,
0.0354818814,
-0.0122086499,
-0.0185211524,
-0.0002670461,
0.0231016651,
-0.0179733634,
0.0049989363,
-0.0126643078,
-0.0208750851,
0.0075358008,
-0.0049243742,
-0.0313754678,
0.013289813,
-0.0559999235,
0.0288585071,
-0.0270950608,
-0.0514135398,
-0.0665963888,
-0.0345077217,
0.0497512668,
0.007595188,
-0.0468492731,
-0.0009617493,
2.557080412e-34,
0.0434781872,
0.0093643945,
-0.015380363,
0.054975111,
0.0737286136,
0.0380844735,
-0.0250633936,
0.0427752808,
0.0186642334,
-0.0748262927,
-0.0082598319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05736v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05736v2 | LLMLingua: Compressing Prompts for Accelerated Inference of Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T14:10:21 | 2023-12-06T17:02:25 | Huiqiang Jiang, Qianhui Wu, Chin-Yew Lin, Yuqing Yang, Lili Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have been applied in various applications due to
their astonishing capabilities. With advancements in technologies such as
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting and in-context learning (ICL), the prompts fed
to LLMs are becoming increasingly lengthy, even exceeding tens of thousands of
tokens. To accelerate model inference and reduce cost, this paper presents
LLMLingua, a coarse-to-fine prompt compression method that involves a budget
controller to maintain semantic integrity under high compression ratios, a
token-level iterative compression algorithm to better model the interdependence
between compressed contents, and an instruction tuning based method for
distribution alignment between language models. We conduct experiments and
analysis over four datasets from different scenarios, i.e., GSM8K, BBH,
ShareGPT, and Arxiv-March23; showing that the proposed approach yields
state-of-the-art performance and allows for up to 20x compression with little
performance loss. Our code is available at https://aka.ms/LLMLingua. | [
0.0095965797,
0.0711973011,
-0.0166839529,
0.045440834,
-0.0835454389,
0.0097371051,
-0.0145631777,
0.0172420982,
-0.0415905751,
-0.0060558752,
-0.0067161457,
-0.0272506103,
0.0332297832,
0.0007273446,
0.0146359988,
-0.0147898998,
0.0496591292,
-0.0343857072,
0.0013581943,
-0.0215285588,
-0.014586092,
0.0103684561,
0.052368585,
0.0332641751,
-0.0198233929,
-0.0378014706,
-0.0281067509,
0.0399421006,
-0.0264475737,
-0.0205309726,
-0.0290262103,
0.0768289119,
0.0221641175,
0.0774695352,
0.0000022371,
-0.0656718984,
-0.0441479459,
0.0181179363,
-0.0860093683,
0.0400197916,
0.0465690717,
-0.0139935557,
-0.0200420208,
0.0188046191,
0.0082200812,
-0.0214941353,
0.071438536,
0.0138630122,
0.0648928508,
0.0348465703,
0.00183039,
-0.0012839395,
-0.0093842112,
-0.0378256664,
-0.0365581177,
-0.0292562824,
0.0240789633,
-0.0228417572,
-0.0085741589,
0.0336061083,
-0.0285444111,
0.0411374308,
0.0327054337,
0.0083632916,
-0.050543379,
0.0052401465,
-0.026221212,
-0.043552652,
-0.0092032561,
0.0174828302,
-0.005416384,
-0.0576587841,
-0.017737776,
0.0187476519,
0.0140024312,
-0.0269993264,
-0.0504467487,
0.0702858418,
-0.015363913,
0.0326703116,
0.0386568978,
0.0078811906,
0.0312969387,
-0.014280811,
-0.0407839119,
0.0499169193,
0.0291288998,
-0.0294166543,
-0.0089540919,
-0.0115311714,
-0.0239231307,
-0.0800591484,
-0.0196694341,
-0.0061359936,
-0.0408952348,
0.007643803,
-0.0776720345,
-0.0286858194,
0.0465151407,
-0.0057553775,
0.0384076685,
0.0467564873,
-0.0075693,
0.0296877511,
-0.0218740553,
0.0515747033,
-0.0138751706,
-0.0007010241,
-0.0488893017,
-0.0200281218,
0.001832555,
0.0039222273,
-0.0582700185,
0.0282370578,
-0.042771522,
-0.0002572392,
-0.0252485592,
0.0402521826,
0.0191734862,
0.0429489911,
0.0121498089,
-0.0453656614,
-0.0038420137,
0.0006416541,
0.0218945686,
0.0099751987,
-0.0340476111,
0.005594865,
0.0071086674,
-0.0401441529,
-0.0276140198,
0.0270803589,
-0.0105809476,
-0.0141414888,
0.018282542,
0.0323834531,
0.0156372227,
-0.0210552104,
-0.0263170302,
-0.0353157744,
0.0090976041,
-0.0671494529,
-0.0235209782,
-0.0882243067,
0.0197845902,
0.0108145969,
-0.0191606376,
-0.026200192,
-0.0229938123,
0.0167280622,
-0.0627108067,
0.0471636057,
-0.020225469,
0.0143295405,
0.0209521111,
0.0023815974,
0.0193449818,
0.0803317353,
-0.0026246824,
0.0202517994,
0.0500633344,
-0.0218331851,
-0.0278785303,
0.049352888,
0.0706080869,
0.0372987874,
-0.0269272011,
-0.0038413338,
0.0506553315,
0.0058718896,
0.0476199239,
0.1099652052,
-0.0200518761,
-0.0335347466,
0.03474731,
0.0781239197,
-0.00109819,
0.0133352112,
0.0428230427,
0.0153301572,
-0.0147062615,
0.0085693821,
-0.0497912802,
-0.007087688,
-0.0453798659,
0.0063993149,
0.0629915521,
0.0397668183,
-0.0247182846,
-0.0141160246,
-0.0449019149,
-0.0096501354,
0.0062650512,
0.0114039239,
0.0108842906,
0.0047251182,
-0.0146156959,
0.0727833286,
0.0462340713,
-0.0354419388,
-0.0524627492,
-0.0760127977,
0.0362390131,
0.0171190184,
0.0405564457,
0.0293547194,
0.0113965655,
-0.0043622707,
0.0219188593,
0.0338544957,
-0.0015909493,
-0.0124793518,
-0.0062533696,
-0.0380027555,
-0.0269026384,
0.0373687483,
0.0217827689,
0.0067277038,
0.0207590386,
0.0131356893,
0.0090047708,
-0.0279910285,
0.0029707812,
0.0353431217,
-0.0120528685,
-0.0140299834,
0.0100168278,
0.0177176446,
0.0366943441,
-0.0137769524,
-0.0099800928,
-0.0106996968,
0.0452887677,
-0.0347618386,
0.0138212712,
-0.0351654664,
-0.0536304191,
-0.0508523062,
0.0400759391,
0.0149170952,
-0.0064383438,
0.0157977827,
-0.0496545061,
-0.0395734124,
0.0038442824,
-0.042283766,
0.0664424747,
-0.0497329943,
0.0324892737,
-0.0314206108,
0.031618353,
-0.0258072782,
0.0466116481,
-0.0249642227,
0.0075982837,
0.0659387708,
0.0286352653,
0.0164654292,
-0.0238062814,
-0.0296255499,
0.0206232648,
-0.0430602804,
0.0012768032,
0.0172775518,
0.0262240991,
0.0058404892,
-0.006866971,
-0.0937568322,
0.0042493222,
-0.0130070327,
0.0290051866,
0.0113190468,
0.0157748424,
-0.0301325452,
-0.0028830606,
-0.019930508,
-0.0027542687,
0.020025406,
0.0272668432,
0.0034148705,
-0.0155289005,
-0.0310078859,
-0.013612763,
-0.0394565612,
-0.0052501932,
0.0751615912,
-0.0392885767,
-0.0461894758,
-0.060837239,
0.029018674,
-0.0241822172,
0.012756668,
0.0140393171,
-0.0261534713,
-0.0016369293,
-0.0115128681,
0.0605091043,
0.0545121506,
-0.002440244,
0.0134997061,
0.0663367659,
0.0011513013,
-0.0596420951,
-0.0056759212,
-0.0234639719,
-0.0497158058,
-0.013570697,
-0.0427054502,
0.007449538,
0.096528247,
-0.0054791272,
-0.0128317578,
-0.0541966744,
-0.0343102627,
-0.001043862,
0.0022579106,
-0.0171303339,
-0.0282173362,
-0.0146729257,
0.0567890815,
-0.00390922,
-0.0730761588,
0.082432352,
-0.0830047056,
0.0203553587,
-0.0161046609,
-0.0227910671,
-0.0179938991,
0.0742140859,
0.0040032566,
0.0390853547,
0.0323082805,
-0.0064932746,
-0.0578048825,
0.0336074568,
0.0180274379,
-0.025986528,
-0.0127978846,
-0.0225155223,
0.0147172501,
-0.040305201,
-0.0398189947,
-0.0249820706,
-0.0418357141,
-0.0112901423,
0.0267742611,
0.0399721265,
2.514e-7,
-0.0193023439,
0.0227828175,
-0.0000337183,
0.0479735956,
0.003403795,
0.0043615215,
-0.0170400832,
0.0010945034,
0.0461909845,
-0.0070093996,
0.032535132,
-0.0227102935,
0.0307265837,
0.0521015264,
0.0262233093,
0.0473714322,
0.008808122,
0.0016774939,
0.0564796031,
0.0002831243,
-0.0147555089,
0.0442498252,
0.034835007,
-0.0403988957,
-0.0280900635,
0.1142749712,
0.0279603619,
-0.0704716668,
0.0052545783,
-0.0497200899,
0.0757333189,
0.0046485267,
0.039618507,
-0.099337481,
-0.0348733217,
0.0518652685,
0.0107143968,
-0.0175047275,
-0.0063235778,
-0.0234899726,
-0.1143400148,
0.0339848995,
0.0124778301,
-0.0307061411,
-0.004434316,
-0.0703539923,
0.0097867465,
0.0247891881,
0.0382702202,
0.0284845196,
0.0025875478,
-0.0100463433,
0.0090895975,
-0.011738779,
-0.0355115086,
0.0219070129,
-0.0111846458,
0.0576204918,
0.042467948,
-0.0213159844,
0.0230071079,
-0.0288437679,
0.0497306436,
0.004483439,
-0.0487862453,
-0.0378013439,
-0.0026989661,
-0.0010994554,
0.0206880271,
0.002636493,
0.0476135872,
-0.0063023428,
-0.0122999214,
-0.0010310682,
0.1097766608,
-0.0148872612,
-0.0102516422,
-0.0329335704,
-0.0383810177,
-0.0113636451,
0.1061294302,
0.0485222861,
-0.0275589693,
-0.0032687406,
-0.0269472394,
-0.0301225949,
0.0186092332,
-0.0079000471,
0.0325037241,
-0.0056380639,
-0.0222768467,
-0.0365915596,
0.0243283082,
0.0011726359,
0.0417017713,
-0.0028641049,
0.010790146,
-0.0184034761,
-0.0029975094,
-0.0757311955,
-0.0043073571,
-0.055450961,
-0.0028438733,
-0.1160395816,
0.0328844786,
-0.0045852666,
0.0011775915,
-0.018729588,
0.0389968641,
-0.0946119204,
-0.0601230897,
-0.026756065,
0.0363108255,
0.0273148511,
0.066123344,
-0.00026963,
-0.0401328541,
0.0775858089,
0.0647540689,
-0.0428852178,
0.0512784608,
-0.0037785573,
-0.0210540015,
0.0033619942,
0.0657857507,
-0.0455809161,
0.01838894,
0.0098444549,
0.0356572159,
-0.0089127049,
-0.0521428622,
0.0205000825,
0.0620919839,
0.0321562849,
-0.0432314985,
-0.0311476719,
0.007667989,
0.0410411023,
-0.0271801669,
-0.0165472981,
-0.0360737555,
0.0272437483,
0.0011720834,
-0.0265403502,
0.0322905667,
-0.0342627279,
0.0402009934,
0.0287941266,
-0.0035642916,
-0.0147029581,
-0.0445122384,
0.0041451184,
0.0620904751,
0.0002021347,
-0.0171234831,
-0.027960388,
0.0062542469,
0.0368161015,
-0.0500241295,
0.0512845702,
0.0342344306,
0.0433294438,
-0.0205277391,
0.0453013964,
-0.0240703523,
-0.035307385,
-0.0240630284,
0.0189683177,
0.0422941111,
-0.0033534681,
0.0165956225,
-0.037152417,
-0.0037109978,
-0.0421874821,
0.0223622806,
0.0308668744,
-0.0400411524,
0.0394894667,
0.0058934316,
-0.039063286,
0.0126453964,
0.0696899742,
0.0026729282,
0.0183648448,
-0.0267078169,
-0.0170289408,
-0.0342570245,
-0.0248807371,
-0.0297988337,
0.0014839935,
-0.02581615,
-0.0155180115,
-0.0526975803,
-0.0819024891,
-0.0371299386,
0.0320294537,
-0.0163725857,
0.0086154137,
0.040222276,
0.0646383092,
0.0208735522,
-0.0069279573,
0.0010564656,
0.0002240257,
-0.0166247208,
-0.0456007458,
0.0166195985,
-6.672005284e-33,
-0.0253996085,
0.0180619396,
0.0120384973,
-0.0203392655,
-0.0029337883,
0.0271019414,
-0.0298664067,
-0.0204141419,
-0.0129112238,
-0.0267917272,
-0.0394649357,
-0.009720997,
0.0125986999,
0.026557114,
-0.0203635227,
0.0209654681,
0.0495808274,
0.0043946099,
-0.0423463732,
0.0261323024,
0.0465059839,
-0.0091871219,
0.0077137309,
-0.0170358326,
-0.0156536363,
-0.0078307511,
0.0259122718,
0.030517092,
-0.0023197397,
0.0477739386,
-0.0379310772,
0.0063506011,
-0.0005831125,
-0.0578221157,
-0.0147034852,
0.0455077253,
-0.0704814494,
-0.0336747207,
0.0387559906,
-0.0119048599,
-0.0284389108,
-0.0612015426,
0.0282290205,
0.0106994221,
-0.016508542,
-0.0073462995,
-0.0192725118,
-0.014102458,
-0.0237387475,
-0.0443655774,
-0.0407607108,
0.0118639655,
0.0067991856,
-0.0080815665,
0.0537120439,
0.0209666528,
-0.0106758419,
0.0355760828,
-0.0004853018,
0.0104695726,
-0.0155247878,
0.0840086341,
0.0922483578,
0.000280428,
0.0150755886,
0.0313707106,
-0.0296609383,
-0.0246660057,
-0.0133153405,
0.0242635347,
0.0369544923,
0.0063177282,
0.025007261,
0.0557607748,
0.0352103263,
-0.018700175,
-0.0744336993,
0.0259207562,
0.0474899076,
0.0197891667,
0.0135994721,
0.0017495994,
-0.0138137909,
-0.0372394696,
-0.0577342734,
-0.0234678257,
-0.030581452,
-0.0287738778,
0.0199420489,
0.0092824074,
-0.0257684439,
-0.0348006487,
0.0643386021,
-0.047745809,
-0.0416096225,
0.0150905084,
-0.0207231231,
-0.008327187,
0.0083076917,
0.0528203174,
-0.0414203927,
-0.0136063928,
0.0144525077,
-0.0373739637,
0.0186018981,
0.018803101,
0.0386933833,
0.0293344278,
-0.0629909262,
0.0269933417,
-0.0135354986,
0.0022010233,
-0.0149057787,
-0.0221823286,
0.0575887486,
0.0111213773,
0.0312228613,
0.0007738778,
0.0287986416,
0.0008851283,
-0.0214115828,
-0.0139599862,
-0.0233484227,
0.0379326381,
-0.0235639829,
-0.0060103461,
-0.0645184442,
0.0275957063,
0.0454763062,
-0.0514695384,
-0.0099163465,
0.0459791459,
2.95e-7,
0.0068327351,
0.0487163514,
0.0180804506,
-0.0195972491,
0.0031912413,
0.0159355551,
-0.0034343021,
0.0146366563,
0.0104696508,
-0.0438325368,
0.0064650546,
0.0198588669,
0.0524056926,
0.0276895296,
-0.0984609276,
0.0189474057,
-0.077478148,
0.0034710269,
-0.0738399923,
0.0227039736,
0.0507030338,
0.1530263126,
0.0021478836,
-0.0289026722,
0.0010469321,
-0.0123751834,
0.0158549137,
-0.0338754505,
0.0151504194,
0.0073935743,
-0.013500833,
-0.0190146714,
0.0174523741,
0.0130498642,
0.0051229061,
0.0137650454,
-0.0614886545,
0.0577328317,
0.0233146399,
0.0070972112,
0.0076862271,
-0.0353413373,
-0.0309113022,
-0.0802105814,
0.0667255297,
-0.006083345,
-0.0171851777,
-0.0445813611,
0.009172285,
-0.029803751,
-0.0003250928,
0.0036588048,
0.0070632868,
0.041687116,
0.0049863025,
0.0188303106,
0.0049616485,
-0.0760692656,
-0.0292979535,
-0.0088768331,
-0.0323969983,
-0.0460167825,
-0.0303470325,
0.0239010509,
0.0391723886,
-0.0669956058,
0.0265092589,
3.276280917e-34,
0.0273211598,
-0.0327330455,
0.0233420003,
0.0253882669,
-0.0113737099,
-0.0408061966,
0.0060563618,
0.0504068397,
-0.0090045184,
-0.1000085324,
-0.0201264545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05727v1 | The Program Testing Ability of Large Language Models for Code | 2023-10-09T13:55:45 | 2023-10-09T13:55:45 | Weimin Xiong, Yiwen Guo, Hao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SE | Recent development of large language models (LLMs) for code like CodeX and
CodeT5+ demonstrates tremendous promise in achieving code intelligence. Their
ability of synthesizing code that completes a program for performing a
pre-defined task has been intensively tested and verified on benchmark datasets
including HumanEval and MBPP. Yet, evaluation of these LLMs from more
perspectives (than just program synthesis) is also anticipated, considering
their broad scope of applications in software engineering. In this paper, we
explore the ability of LLMs for testing programs/code. By performing thorough
analyses of recent LLMs for code in program testing, we show a series of
intriguing properties of these models and demonstrate how program testing
ability of LLMs can be improved. Following recent work which utilizes generated
test cases to enhance program synthesis, we further leverage our findings in
improving the quality of the synthesized programs and show +11.77% and +4.22%
higher code pass rates on HumanEval+ comparing with the GPT-3.5-turbo baseline
and the recent state-of-the-art, respectively. | [
-0.0166616198,
0.0590538271,
-0.0401806012,
0.0223714057,
-0.0206255298,
-0.0149645666,
-0.0397997536,
0.046772588,
0.0273192246,
-0.0175794382,
0.0160160456,
0.01399979,
0.0063314424,
0.0071991608,
0.0462912917,
-0.000522164,
0.0561287776,
-0.0669623315,
-0.0489299335,
0.0090505052,
-0.0288216416,
0.0111763813,
0.0238608774,
0.0449446999,
0.0218562223,
-0.0259474125,
-0.019738378,
0.0185978003,
-0.0367485881,
-0.0240826663,
-0.0071571805,
0.0494407453,
-0.0212022997,
0.0372674167,
0.0000020917,
-0.0230939221,
0.0241456814,
0.0254454669,
0.0261938777,
0.048089806,
0.0085388776,
0.0027745618,
-0.0133143831,
0.0371309891,
-0.0102028716,
-0.03200344,
0.0045446102,
-0.0448994711,
0.0598898716,
0.0716057718,
0.0177317169,
0.0011348964,
0.033029329,
0.018077435,
0.0202429369,
-0.0217184648,
-0.0076121758,
0.0522469841,
0.0591748916,
-0.0036972871,
0.0148736369,
-0.0134300953,
0.0583984852,
0.007831214,
-0.0586580224,
0.0462838188,
-0.0373485908,
0.021747224,
0.0034911516,
-0.0036736203,
-0.0732806996,
-0.0563452318,
-0.0151666198,
0.0082382495,
-0.0451866947,
-0.0433089323,
-0.0055182725,
0.042440109,
-0.0118487384,
0.0039498624,
0.0500688441,
-0.0180429779,
0.0369214751,
-0.0404277779,
-0.0417707413,
0.0567671098,
0.0326182134,
-0.0350138694,
-0.0228594001,
-0.0097782677,
-0.0059287227,
-0.048153989,
-0.0220047832,
0.0371078327,
-0.0286727212,
-0.0211200863,
-0.0410512239,
-0.0031450561,
0.0708214641,
-0.0419074669,
0.0290056467,
0.0174082052,
-0.0052364445,
0.013907901,
-0.0799499899,
0.0879747868,
-0.0157243907,
-0.0245493185,
-0.027861556,
0.0234656166,
-0.0125497188,
0.0015786177,
-0.0122776339,
0.0213310141,
0.0143348472,
0.0551318824,
-0.0283489227,
0.0386127308,
-0.0295370128,
0.0988252237,
-0.0273943935,
-0.0562209673,
-0.014339339,
-0.0115546333,
0.0357360542,
-0.0548763461,
-0.0240770187,
-0.0546933189,
-0.0249098521,
-0.0505287871,
0.0130135901,
0.0371671058,
-0.0850767568,
-0.028207615,
0.0276870746,
0.0738936216,
0.0142365173,
0.0128768347,
-0.0200186055,
-0.005741802,
0.0149300313,
-0.0408070646,
0.0207177196,
-0.0852565989,
-0.0513934642,
0.0067167925,
0.0041038608,
-0.05519877,
-0.019244818,
0.0102604041,
0.0177199543,
0.0286589675,
0.0008844062,
0.0497454256,
-0.0073907929,
0.0220361538,
0.0142353801,
0.0742182583,
0.042751424,
0.0042957631,
-0.016372297,
-0.0466059521,
0.0553215444,
0.0596762113,
-0.0046475958,
0.0480658747,
-0.014016347,
0.0267907977,
0.0428615734,
-0.0199519843,
-0.0015943601,
0.0803896338,
0.0126485564,
0.0125516029,
-0.0074944575,
0.0390421562,
0.0116369054,
0.0263321698,
0.0571752563,
0.0113857379,
0.0299904086,
-0.0103453118,
-0.0289924815,
0.0237438641,
-0.0358137749,
0.0275038052,
-0.0022646519,
0.0575395636,
-0.009294861,
-0.0377326943,
-0.0319358557,
-0.0079846354,
0.0018569559,
0.0135816913,
0.0403451547,
-0.0267596003,
-0.0518981516,
0.0326254219,
0.0117004411,
-0.0571921244,
-0.0326337107,
-0.0786006749,
0.0483588576,
0.0241250694,
0.0582877696,
-0.0445387438,
0.0082555981,
0.017202111,
-0.02096848,
0.001974348,
0.0396800414,
0.0015499577,
-0.0334833376,
-0.0106475893,
-0.0012732771,
-0.0170406383,
0.0234592874,
0.0277093779,
0.0302359983,
-0.0312665775,
0.033819221,
-0.0246490519,
-0.0553125888,
0.0433206335,
-0.0234651677,
0.0101488261,
-0.0111698974,
0.0003479253,
0.0349924117,
-0.0240679737,
-0.036719352,
0.0082668578,
0.0552157126,
-0.023506593,
-0.0060629002,
-0.0409941077,
-0.0146328397,
-0.0134833036,
0.0094469339,
-0.0292756762,
-0.0365546122,
0.0477527268,
-0.0241987687,
-0.0153313512,
0.04552266,
-0.0097311633,
0.0152667332,
0.010357393,
0.0377089418,
-0.0493535809,
0.0045464975,
-0.0296068471,
0.0322932638,
0.0042029885,
0.0439443402,
-0.0302133914,
0.0747527629,
0.029537553,
0.0275680497,
-0.0429746881,
0.0477172472,
-0.0232730936,
0.0246526357,
-0.0115236565,
0.097323589,
-0.0198627692,
-0.0653453991,
-0.1107004136,
0.0575011149,
-0.0296061244,
0.029816974,
0.013073111,
0.0126425866,
0.0069065806,
0.0474263839,
-0.0279691182,
-0.0314749926,
0.0268168245,
0.0160634629,
0.0001123288,
-0.0519704148,
-0.0859102011,
-0.0035305906,
-0.0112535143,
-0.0470403209,
0.064226985,
-0.0475906692,
0.0384102128,
-0.0542536937,
0.0679684952,
0.0580143593,
0.026634803,
-0.0250106025,
-0.0516493917,
0.0227120016,
-0.0578232184,
0.0347105712,
0.0735191107,
0.0036269543,
0.0061698263,
0.0258321278,
0.0225345399,
-0.0444980785,
0.0203437693,
0.0749502033,
-0.0654768348,
-0.0154325496,
-0.059795022,
0.0276183914,
0.0377694927,
-0.0476350486,
-0.0057890071,
-0.0521786027,
0.0286365747,
-0.0186485983,
0.0251187608,
0.0105511732,
-0.0128532387,
-0.0164010003,
0.0049493574,
-0.0250480752,
-0.0772662088,
0.019901108,
-0.0790027305,
-0.0062136375,
-0.0226774868,
-0.0272488967,
-0.0449249037,
0.0481609255,
0.0104217259,
0.0062399171,
-0.0529291518,
-0.0091623217,
0.0165573768,
0.0032601855,
-0.0406483673,
-0.0437222235,
0.0734627396,
-0.0392338485,
0.0181041826,
-0.0167714264,
-0.0286920164,
-0.0375365354,
0.0251245573,
-0.0269974824,
0.0250951257,
0.0124437297,
0.0049290014,
0.0548561253,
0.0383221693,
-0.0272251666,
0.0378022119,
0.0108566349,
-0.0160248298,
0.0054925042,
-0.0560402423,
-0.0439885892,
-0.0718459934,
0.0011751463,
-0.0280984957,
0.0059898309,
0.0136206336,
0.0500098579,
0.0653279796,
-0.0830238387,
0.0103272824,
0.0236583091,
-0.0204559304,
-0.0006251876,
0.0661435798,
0.0367083549,
-0.0522077717,
-0.0247723665,
0.0519433282,
0.0199278947,
-0.0270151608,
0.0347228721,
0.0163990818,
0.0516427755,
0.0548970066,
0.0684823245,
-0.0512628295,
-0.0285980441,
0.0146510918,
-0.0073527396,
-0.0293957982,
0.0041147619,
-0.0136146983,
-0.1242068708,
0.0376062468,
0.0330981724,
-0.022287434,
-0.0309322979,
-0.0083034988,
-0.0288086701,
0.0117337229,
0.0276435576,
0.0598286577,
0.0060645356,
-0.0040291897,
-0.0052177859,
-0.031086918,
-0.0165492389,
0.0896812305,
-0.0162636582,
0.0388756245,
0.066736117,
-0.0030891059,
-0.0268091094,
0.0150132589,
0.0516770221,
-0.0067223357,
0.0183863025,
-0.0409294367,
-0.0205808058,
0.0409346633,
-0.0150060738,
0.0563753434,
0.0034146616,
-0.0522194766,
0.0084511572,
0.0647093058,
0.0236803405,
-0.0036963208,
-0.0638270825,
-0.0201597102,
-0.0000493524,
-0.0214622952,
0.0339372605,
0.0320944712,
-0.0230095033,
-0.0252245478,
-0.0637882352,
-0.0671423003,
-0.0566959605,
-0.0417208187,
0.0079034623,
-0.0150796128,
0.0189172439,
0.0115456311,
0.0263606217,
0.0230292175,
0.0406811014,
0.0294489656,
-0.0513599217,
0.0086158738,
-0.0107943648,
-0.0169038046,
0.0323117971,
-0.0261287596,
0.037969254,
-0.0417689532,
0.0046186293,
0.0090860147,
-0.0175060928,
-0.0094530899,
0.0310524646,
-0.0723160952,
-0.0464044139,
-0.0064290049,
0.0804416761,
0.0227645859,
0.0028845423,
-0.0490860045,
-0.0380122699,
-0.0405816957,
-0.0156765841,
-0.0191615783,
0.0163760632,
0.0095381998,
-0.0591078997,
0.0133243306,
-0.0119787948,
-0.0634668693,
0.0101715457,
0.0052513024,
-0.0238418374,
0.0442680717,
0.0076937201,
0.0389308296,
0.0632139817,
-0.0334257931,
0.0222849827,
-0.0177902915,
0.0274447594,
0.0059196083,
-0.019823119,
-0.0342608616,
-0.0283150636,
0.0437462777,
-0.0136980638,
-0.0160599351,
0.0059240367,
-0.0245772544,
-0.0318409465,
0.045344308,
0.0150765777,
0.0410367846,
-0.0221406929,
0.0385040566,
0.081620656,
-0.0169847216,
-0.0184182376,
0.0094500901,
-0.0124132503,
0.0259215459,
-0.0156167746,
0.06267225,
0.0092570977,
0.045060087,
-0.0148352692,
0.034697786,
-0.0222142804,
-0.0287606884,
-0.0153702023,
0.0149813564,
0.0490370281,
0.0499591753,
0.0008363415,
-0.0474658497,
0.0221126601,
-0.0243678279,
0.0002814409,
-0.0220588353,
-0.0432106145,
0.0171983223,
0.0338181853,
-0.01353967,
-0.047208108,
0.0846090242,
0.0209732559,
0.0001741637,
0.0202259142,
0.0222263392,
-0.0425378159,
0.014776581,
0.0298127141,
-0.0206819028,
-0.0198478121,
-0.0394721925,
-0.0266721249,
-0.0786253214,
-0.0132096652,
0.0503371395,
0.0487383381,
0.0090339724,
-0.0076366835,
0.0801655278,
0.0325258747,
-0.0344816521,
-0.0198316127,
-0.0194385778,
0.0096491687,
-0.0220789183,
0.0096271653,
-5.91824047e-33,
-0.0208331421,
-0.0017969052,
0.0177744292,
-0.0202374645,
0.0040509747,
-0.0294336583,
-0.0368692465,
-0.0162443835,
0.0185495708,
-0.0295131188,
0.0035658395,
-0.0028292232,
-0.0166758075,
-0.0394191854,
0.0216597635,
0.0367898792,
0.0325834528,
0.0240883473,
-0.0697877407,
-0.0013054996,
-0.0597434677,
-0.0251244251,
-0.0103609012,
0.0181818027,
-0.0428579487,
-0.0138332555,
0.0053024329,
-0.010081077,
-0.0483030975,
0.0410223678,
0.0272306036,
0.0308086518,
0.0120644625,
-0.0096961949,
0.0092940191,
-0.0349030942,
-0.0029371821,
-0.0103028528,
0.0252754595,
-0.0035923317,
0.0327776559,
-0.0619359575,
0.0626324862,
0.0096708033,
-0.0212396886,
0.0348175429,
-0.033574827,
-0.0112334555,
0.0088569019,
-0.0320059322,
-0.0490278155,
0.022342667,
-0.0488470793,
-0.0052208188,
-0.0211402513,
-0.0060123587,
-0.0159807969,
0.0522231981,
0.0652665496,
0.0106815947,
0.0309545044,
0.035357058,
0.0570771582,
-0.0176520497,
-0.0047693904,
0.0251631718,
0.0246170368,
0.0467708781,
-0.0184516199,
0.0088554267,
0.0844312385,
-0.0018416356,
0.0444361866,
0.0353331491,
0.0048545683,
-0.009828981,
-0.025046533,
0.0230437461,
0.0297665074,
-0.0143142967,
0.0345089883,
0.0074767992,
-0.0650177151,
-0.0071686911,
-0.0755231529,
-0.0099304747,
-0.0272101592,
-0.037862584,
0.0471984372,
-0.0026347577,
-0.0270063952,
-0.022027038,
0.007337247,
-0.0462318361,
0.0062387823,
0.01288231,
-0.0597011559,
0.0163110234,
-0.0290298481,
0.0427279361,
0.0386656821,
-0.0673489198,
0.0060105016,
-0.0280012079,
0.0660293251,
-0.0157439914,
-0.0166694764,
-0.0109244101,
-0.0593067966,
0.0031412835,
-0.0476389006,
0.0069795907,
0.0146973077,
0.007721785,
0.0018560409,
0.0131955175,
0.0487533212,
0.0125244586,
0.0174598452,
-0.0564392917,
-0.0585022345,
0.0098519735,
0.0235223304,
0.033730831,
-0.0132651031,
-0.0111219501,
-0.0541539192,
0.0472634844,
0.0256700851,
-0.0448067524,
-0.0676074028,
0.0384921506,
2.877e-7,
-0.0129238563,
0.0579665489,
-0.0375009477,
0.0500853099,
0.013428607,
0.0319420137,
-0.0489007682,
-0.0167857036,
0.037086688,
0.0186372362,
-0.0593663603,
0.0187862515,
0.0524818674,
0.0368375406,
-0.0281440616,
0.0565856285,
0.0087712156,
-0.009583449,
-0.071906358,
-0.0079027163,
-0.0017950593,
0.0374098755,
-0.0140845506,
-0.0026310678,
0.0156144649,
-0.0577552132,
-0.0320971794,
-0.0186003689,
-0.0570889041,
0.0523662269,
-0.0787888318,
0.002078702,
0.021432545,
0.0312412493,
0.0030058892,
-0.0220549386,
-0.0019076006,
0.0766015947,
0.003122852,
0.0436884984,
0.0538995825,
-0.0314823389,
0.0055959541,
-0.0560709052,
0.0577410646,
0.023614144,
0.0049960925,
-0.0381410271,
-0.0257963315,
-0.0510076806,
-0.0298315082,
-0.0482125245,
0.023807507,
0.0343795195,
-0.0195766222,
-0.0073359646,
0.0100725275,
-0.0085467864,
-0.0516210571,
0.0162997413,
-0.0193694849,
-0.0604587384,
-0.0299111437,
0.0412953086,
-0.0193936564,
-0.0337911882,
0.0380988047,
3.024372248e-34,
0.0317265503,
-0.0315729044,
0.0272944942,
-0.01065154,
0.0499296114,
-0.0195149332,
-0.0127665335,
0.02479605,
-0.035886921,
0.0120064951,
-0.0202067457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05707v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05707v3 | Guiding Language Model Math Reasoning with Planning Tokens | 2023-10-09T13:29:37 | 2024-02-05T18:33:44 | Xinyi Wang, Lucas Caccia, Oleksiy Ostapenko, Xingdi Yuan, William Yang Wang, Alessandro Sordoni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have recently attracted considerable interest
for their ability to perform complex reasoning tasks, such as chain-of-thought
reasoning. However, most of the existing approaches to enhance this ability
rely heavily on data-driven methods, while neglecting the structural aspects of
the model's reasoning capacity. We find that while LLMs can manage individual
reasoning steps well, they struggle with maintaining consistency across an
entire reasoning chain. To solve this, we introduce planning tokens at the
start of each reasoning step, serving as a guide for the model, and add their
embeddings to the model parameters. Our approach requires a negligible increase
in trainable parameters (just 0.001%) and can be applied through either full
fine-tuning or a more parameter-efficient scheme. We demonstrate our method's
effectiveness by applying it to three different LLMs, showing notable accuracy
improvements across three math word problem datasets w.r.t. standard
fine-tuning baselines. | [
0.0105896834,
0.1053337306,
0.0068294192,
0.0357180648,
-0.0504751876,
0.0245248266,
0.0173020288,
-0.014330768,
-0.0355627872,
-0.0321610905,
0.0143830441,
-0.0034801839,
-0.0049531055,
0.0279416218,
0.0350741297,
-0.0396018177,
0.0345533751,
-0.0656143948,
0.0164047852,
0.0038712253,
-0.024827078,
0.011667598,
-0.02476025,
0.0198413432,
-0.0455595218,
-0.0471160561,
-0.0063766325,
-0.0272605084,
0.007727148,
-0.0372186564,
-0.0115717724,
0.0306917857,
0.0273106564,
0.0375208966,
0.0000022216,
-0.0544567034,
-0.0197417513,
0.010477636,
-0.0587790348,
-0.0028899724,
-0.0330521427,
-0.033841148,
0.0284534786,
0.0425602198,
-0.0402759276,
0.0371512212,
0.015622044,
0.0475667641,
0.0668897033,
0.0728574917,
0.0064140297,
-0.0425688624,
0.0253268145,
-0.0188287105,
0.024121955,
-0.0514527224,
0.0234031323,
0.0379158333,
-0.0037200379,
0.0344121642,
-0.0382414721,
0.030655982,
0.0542126335,
0.0030127922,
-0.0132102175,
0.0114746233,
-0.0330735706,
-0.0137912333,
-0.0008638653,
0.061084874,
-0.0319088474,
-0.0323686376,
-0.006869535,
-0.0234270375,
-0.0259980541,
-0.0224700384,
-0.0705172196,
0.0362187028,
0.0193693992,
0.0106058465,
0.0081588933,
-0.020539673,
0.0460261814,
0.0116671911,
-0.0705219507,
0.0977334976,
-0.0036039592,
-0.0251004305,
-0.0064226571,
-0.0164771136,
-0.0547648109,
-0.059851326,
0.0242257658,
0.0566077754,
-0.0215650722,
0.0288677979,
-0.013308242,
-0.0129066901,
-0.0150803849,
0.0197605286,
0.0257089473,
0.0812399164,
0.0100859478,
0.0561065078,
-0.0421135314,
0.0490635,
-0.0193073899,
0.0418664217,
-0.0287064724,
0.0223693531,
-0.0271893851,
-0.0124430861,
-0.018947443,
0.0411143228,
-0.0058260155,
-0.0109527241,
-0.0109594725,
0.0151560409,
-0.0018070749,
0.040360108,
0.0320851617,
-0.035029199,
0.0268024504,
-0.0517306887,
-0.0206168406,
0.0093203783,
-0.0644030124,
0.028151907,
0.0127268825,
-0.0193459876,
-0.0435061753,
0.0031415799,
-0.0104199424,
-0.0136772767,
0.0209743083,
0.080918774,
0.0074022282,
0.0091784978,
-0.0266097561,
-0.0454610996,
0.0142292148,
-0.0753886849,
0.0304583069,
-0.0792947263,
0.0546919331,
0.0409638323,
-0.0139852203,
-0.003177827,
0.0093682157,
0.0327917635,
0.0009265281,
0.0786163807,
0.0384864248,
-0.0016907041,
-0.0104739862,
-0.0016295088,
-0.0403090455,
0.0680984706,
0.0505184717,
0.0029440138,
0.0081050619,
0.0357460827,
-0.0191961918,
0.040210817,
0.0322815478,
-0.0115855988,
-0.0243195575,
0.0195617955,
0.0142515143,
0.0523190424,
-0.0099767502,
0.0307589956,
-0.0494968519,
-0.0004146482,
-0.00654383,
0.0616985932,
0.0065062558,
0.0039142612,
0.04125797,
-0.0236423872,
0.0004072183,
-0.0296951942,
-0.0859566852,
0.0263899826,
-0.0127409045,
-0.0039577871,
0.0063879853,
0.0006855289,
-0.0127170766,
-0.0845799595,
-0.0516312867,
0.0148649188,
-0.0229038037,
0.0106807202,
0.0440061279,
-0.003249269,
-0.0253645778,
0.0563477799,
-0.00085934,
-0.0216970593,
-0.0055079265,
-0.0312831365,
0.0230315123,
0.0149912741,
0.064153634,
-0.0362516381,
-0.0285377596,
-0.016347466,
0.0612578802,
0.0014930868,
0.0288288556,
-0.0085003115,
-0.0090820072,
-0.0722898692,
-0.0310546774,
-0.0268671401,
0.0103597939,
-0.0314691477,
0.0399634801,
0.0019442319,
0.0126932012,
-0.0372445174,
0.0265390053,
0.0436580703,
-0.0318339989,
-0.0311778393,
-0.0219416842,
0.0141425179,
0.017986618,
-0.0131600518,
0.0343509614,
0.0575890467,
-0.0046038758,
-0.0323166214,
-0.0093135871,
-0.024391219,
-0.0757077634,
-0.0427881293,
0.0682475567,
-0.011184793,
-0.029640561,
-0.0096651698,
-0.0701088235,
-0.0269623492,
0.0353119113,
-0.017842453,
0.0262675323,
-0.0044744429,
0.0356827714,
0.0420329981,
-0.0275845919,
-0.0076813432,
0.0676762983,
-0.0235926472,
0.0158058684,
0.0005128047,
0.0118047651,
0.0123930778,
0.0149562331,
0.0177138001,
0.0101123489,
-0.0112757208,
0.0008320556,
-0.0193884503,
0.0137501638,
-0.0542273596,
-0.0442613512,
-0.0201038159,
-0.002020987,
-0.0074157035,
0.0411879793,
-0.00841536,
-0.0142635005,
0.0101760868,
-0.0061992062,
-0.034603253,
-0.0014917114,
-0.0051167929,
-0.0078934291,
0.0418339483,
0.0049468023,
-0.0357649103,
-0.0161936674,
-0.0280506425,
-0.0667661354,
0.0392320156,
-0.0000736779,
0.0149235064,
-0.0306416042,
0.0039725448,
-0.0508533381,
0.0059509627,
-0.0193495825,
0.0026741053,
0.0158846825,
-0.0352583118,
0.0480224192,
0.0724483058,
-0.0253190752,
0.0141459741,
0.0515363216,
-0.0348803699,
-0.066108875,
0.0360149592,
-0.0261145197,
0.0106935985,
-0.0227734894,
0.0010332906,
-0.0292897075,
0.0589802675,
-0.0328302234,
-0.0049710614,
-0.0503997393,
0.0332384482,
-0.0021504902,
-0.0023294869,
-0.0214186143,
0.0084474999,
-0.0012610528,
0.0485904217,
-0.0193345882,
-0.0299704969,
0.0649148375,
-0.0143526969,
-0.0194908362,
-0.0363454334,
0.0330428332,
-0.0708753765,
0.0407378301,
0.0207236931,
-0.0227211714,
-0.0402711295,
0.0035428158,
-0.0448485054,
-0.0220125504,
0.0126486281,
-0.0218660869,
0.0564156286,
-0.0480617397,
-0.000819886,
-0.0112457396,
-0.0479144379,
-0.0461855158,
0.0180571191,
-0.0695909336,
0.0341529138,
-0.0186440311,
-0.0418717936,
-0.0180948358,
-0.0194300711,
0.0250949655,
0.0474363342,
-0.0323104486,
-0.0159337558,
-0.0272393581,
-0.0151760271,
0.0354670621,
0.0181174353,
0.0604089722,
-0.0451585352,
0.0388664566,
0.0177554693,
0.0748735368,
-0.0131581873,
-0.0220561419,
0.0348345377,
0.0080982763,
-0.0050549428,
-0.0154354395,
0.0338351317,
0.0205623116,
-0.0760539174,
-0.0264828596,
0.1276472807,
0.0607246868,
-0.0182634071,
0.0051676817,
-0.0718030035,
0.0576263852,
0.038723547,
0.0199040547,
-0.0644860938,
-0.0575460009,
0.0350751095,
-0.0005602658,
0.0200342424,
-0.048549626,
-0.0178846661,
-0.0928709731,
0.0241944548,
0.0203149375,
-0.0100625046,
-0.011107537,
-0.0438057408,
-0.0133264689,
-0.0006419212,
0.0072830454,
0.011166892,
0.01119442,
0.0132594351,
0.0116795227,
-0.0162066519,
-0.0115426453,
0.02520339,
-0.0255782567,
0.0051997607,
0.0256336555,
0.0115785869,
0.0173750166,
-0.0744115636,
0.0739345476,
0.0413696021,
-0.0216873977,
-0.0346907452,
-0.004934669,
-0.0295067206,
-0.0012336723,
0.0139819961,
0.0753809363,
-0.0590430014,
-0.054292839,
0.0272537321,
0.1181368306,
-0.0253846738,
-0.0109381918,
-0.0048714746,
0.0031679347,
-0.0469129309,
0.06529627,
0.0231667142,
-0.0125827482,
-0.0345871262,
-0.040455658,
-0.0375830606,
-0.0333526544,
-0.0123648252,
-0.0068234,
0.0521674231,
0.0567369722,
-0.0426922366,
-0.0264916681,
0.0757793486,
0.0598326474,
-0.0155814523,
-0.0086936513,
0.0050424091,
-0.0134119922,
-0.0250707604,
0.0527010746,
-0.0514534973,
0.0146277621,
-0.0561948121,
0.0410691611,
-0.0004264771,
-0.0212022047,
-0.0419727564,
0.0306696929,
-0.1174418926,
-0.0560580269,
-0.0179826822,
0.0439594984,
0.0183161031,
0.052862227,
-0.0036586106,
-0.0180954766,
0.0278052893,
0.0100163352,
-0.0511067696,
0.0156680439,
0.0413300693,
0.0267395191,
0.0258428827,
0.0353918411,
-0.0191971883,
-0.0121445796,
0.024627788,
0.0652374178,
-0.0271903761,
0.0146734947,
0.0224715415,
0.0267458428,
0.009447786,
0.0095516471,
0.0184763111,
-0.0130098118,
0.0583566539,
-0.0304913577,
-0.0320165493,
-0.0456786118,
0.0411423035,
-0.0088485517,
-0.0185956042,
0.0018940289,
-0.0380231217,
0.0247132573,
0.01397717,
0.0418235958,
0.0308210962,
0.0042610886,
0.0234205015,
0.0333960801,
-0.0433840975,
0.0130813466,
0.0055762716,
-0.0289354827,
0.017769834,
-0.0332242027,
0.0574604236,
0.0356935449,
0.000904941,
-0.0702241361,
-0.0208727233,
-0.0428301059,
-0.1018043607,
0.0110111851,
0.0067151426,
0.0074100927,
-0.0076948046,
-0.0175871495,
-0.068376556,
-0.014170724,
0.0239870623,
0.0210207365,
0.0191765372,
-0.0284875669,
0.0449342579,
0.0412876867,
0.0072098114,
-0.0564004555,
0.0198942851,
0.0000587674,
0.0424095541,
0.0027239327,
0.0115067661,
-0.0353492685,
-0.0455058813,
0.0033209808,
0.0201804508,
0.0041157813,
0.026953226,
-0.0677417964,
-0.0846857131,
-0.0236788336,
0.0020806247,
-0.0340671092,
0.0158489421,
0.0255867261,
0.06648238,
-0.0359179303,
-0.0279881898,
0.0180125479,
-0.0034310319,
0.0160787869,
-0.0613770001,
-0.0137338452,
-6.126727984e-33,
0.0095837787,
-0.0246762708,
0.0712766275,
-0.0139343478,
0.0047462443,
0.00444791,
-0.0355171822,
0.0012199897,
-0.0125242481,
0.0171658415,
-0.0283635724,
0.0213392545,
0.004036888,
0.0402991064,
0.00277607,
-0.0119150961,
0.0120351817,
-0.0179418419,
-0.0427079052,
-0.0287553109,
0.0147318998,
0.0062743574,
0.047738608,
-0.0203448534,
-0.0079072444,
0.0195957739,
-0.022264028,
0.0631650761,
-0.0529170372,
0.0592539385,
-0.0110965334,
-0.0163565874,
0.0209722035,
-0.0093875527,
-0.0292549878,
0.0038807641,
-0.0676783994,
-0.0433081612,
0.0293020029,
0.013916526,
-0.0773793831,
-0.0318487398,
0.0158401337,
-0.0077679842,
-0.0210231878,
-0.0412661284,
0.0042336984,
-0.0144751035,
-0.010684655,
0.0471896864,
-0.0344409794,
0.0308469106,
-0.0099909632,
-0.0102767376,
0.0446161143,
0.0084367245,
0.0012023841,
0.0112171508,
-0.0140959462,
0.011599265,
-0.0091336668,
0.0372389592,
0.0610244609,
0.0170400385,
-0.0048396615,
0.0483800098,
-0.0058771172,
-0.0427444316,
-0.0297284499,
0.0107790576,
0.0368488729,
0.0562509671,
0.067928575,
-0.0140458029,
0.0286799017,
0.0408426337,
-0.0533808805,
-0.0263694525,
-0.0132774524,
0.0553720109,
0.0142580131,
0.0029996138,
-0.0226601288,
-0.0014422016,
-0.0779400915,
0.0064023794,
-0.0575496554,
0.0065833102,
0.0259185731,
0.0330949463,
-0.0197593533,
-0.0086443843,
0.0307809077,
-0.0200980119,
-0.0312809274,
0.0713340044,
0.0131093459,
0.0225678962,
-0.0134666264,
0.0444036052,
-0.0645996109,
-0.0133902337,
0.001596013,
-0.0114871021,
0.0180482231,
-0.0075449273,
0.0271116123,
0.015810864,
-0.0569888204,
-0.0279344693,
-0.0624088086,
-0.000245341,
0.0161763802,
0.0155492919,
0.0621539205,
0.0307871327,
-0.0005608647,
0.0504504927,
-0.0040669953,
-0.0499693379,
-0.0057343738,
0.0308760703,
-0.0077641187,
0.0453669168,
-0.0247269087,
-0.0251111761,
-0.018607663,
-0.0086031947,
0.0475113951,
-0.0719202906,
0.0090496326,
0.0517929569,
2.841e-7,
0.0453418158,
0.0618847981,
0.021084087,
0.044952333,
0.0004782425,
0.0296391472,
-0.0157198813,
-0.0491177961,
0.0011913958,
-0.0409256518,
0.0260199364,
0.0786932036,
0.0227742027,
0.0165516939,
-0.0591649227,
0.0179644953,
-0.0385711864,
-0.0051319576,
-0.0714445785,
-0.024597466,
0.0352738574,
0.1245838106,
0.0379891209,
-0.0023928098,
-0.016676385,
-0.0362762548,
0.0277916938,
-0.0148001546,
0.0087079583,
0.0081281485,
-0.0212432891,
-0.0151203061,
0.0321068577,
0.0144341867,
-0.0096679041,
0.0434959047,
0.0058388454,
0.0878077075,
0.0222121812,
-0.0004062889,
-0.0313910916,
-0.0130542424,
-0.0248647537,
-0.0564933494,
0.0782670453,
-0.033101704,
-0.0168413538,
-0.0145152137,
0.0238054805,
-0.0255518053,
0.0037751081,
0.0145868585,
0.0291755777,
0.0303472951,
0.030431008,
-0.0042743022,
0.0197245311,
-0.1090589836,
-0.0405178852,
-0.0058742049,
-0.0392014496,
-0.0281142071,
-0.0477008671,
0.0179310888,
0.0325101428,
-0.0441964231,
-0.048634246,
3.253869841e-34,
0.0445133522,
-0.0447002202,
0.0361452773,
0.0425917655,
0.0504711978,
-0.0148771117,
0.0012081118,
0.0425770469,
0.0508680865,
-0.0936380401,
-0.0304173082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.10673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.10673v1 | Towards Emotion-Based Synthetic Consciousness: Using LLMs to Estimate Emotion Probability Vectors | 2023-10-09T13:29:36 | 2023-10-09T13:29:36 | David Sinclair, Willem Pye | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper shows how LLMs (Large Language Models) may be used to estimate a
summary of the emotional state associated with piece of text. The summary of
emotional state is a dictionary of words used to describe emotion together with
the probability of the word appearing after a prompt comprising the original
text and an emotion eliciting tail. Through emotion analysis of Amazon product
reviews we demonstrate emotion descriptors can be mapped into a PCA type space.
It was hoped that text descriptions of actions to improve a current text
described state could also be elicited through a tail prompt. Experiment seemed
to indicate that this is not straightforward to make work. This failure put our
hoped for selection of action via choosing the best predict ed outcome via
comparing emotional responses out of reach for the moment. | [
0.0280390177,
0.028671477,
-0.0252058785,
0.0200219639,
-0.0269637797,
0.0316726193,
-0.0264575481,
-0.0137768853,
0.0371586941,
-0.0853291005,
-0.0179616772,
-0.0690746829,
-0.0325996354,
0.066591844,
0.0269015227,
-0.0577811114,
0.0205258969,
0.0380197316,
0.0108840112,
-0.0199698564,
-0.0126502188,
0.000480677,
-0.0062465626,
0.0149545409,
-0.021919772,
0.0194852985,
-0.0272107758,
-0.0218017586,
0.0332419313,
-0.035970699,
-0.0098056803,
0.0150132338,
0.0288964417,
-0.0404324904,
0.0000019274,
-0.0511558838,
0.0369881764,
-0.0339469537,
0.02884629,
-0.0464498661,
0.0489264168,
0.0254959259,
-0.0005935211,
-0.0063066077,
-0.0492813028,
0.0224538948,
0.0500429273,
0.0453559384,
0.0335727222,
0.0874316022,
-0.0348865315,
-0.0156691764,
-0.0007082997,
-0.0043261372,
0.0637499392,
0.0064944136,
0.0381983779,
-0.0328060426,
0.0333203636,
-0.0517543554,
-0.0174244288,
0.0000398282,
-0.0278716385,
-0.0177356619,
0.0248302221,
0.0225024857,
0.0298561603,
-0.0215585269,
-0.0343184508,
0.036196433,
-0.0105846245,
0.0042544645,
0.0339114107,
0.0094689941,
-0.0237246193,
-0.0302280039,
-0.0005010835,
0.0107440948,
-0.0063500404,
0.0497317202,
0.0066670375,
0.0467801541,
-0.0108736297,
-0.0076353359,
-0.0154664135,
0.0410954766,
-0.0190991201,
-0.0205966085,
0.0617562011,
0.0247838777,
-0.0159887578,
-0.0138880862,
0.0011928441,
-0.001854145,
0.0157110207,
0.014925844,
-0.0454393886,
-0.019552242,
-0.0408554338,
-0.0992016271,
0.0109948777,
0.02016492,
0.0053673848,
0.0207613315,
-0.0137548279,
0.0267934054,
-0.0111645749,
0.0416804925,
-0.0769489333,
0.0469607823,
-0.0271907356,
0.0349589735,
0.0358010679,
0.0678733066,
-0.0260703247,
-0.0488686152,
-0.0909558609,
0.0152388671,
-0.0402381048,
-0.0248434115,
-0.0319249742,
0.0527639166,
0.0432980247,
0.0060993629,
-0.0455134325,
-0.0152947698,
0.016753884,
0.0316208266,
-0.0335508659,
-0.0048556174,
0.0423372947,
0.0335385688,
0.0123681994,
-0.0024728337,
0.0249001142,
0.0673607215,
-0.0106757609,
-0.0501096323,
-0.0364730284,
0.0080807274,
0.0145598389,
-0.0160040427,
0.0016362055,
-0.0125975264,
0.0244920813,
-0.0290000364,
0.0003886783,
-0.0271243304,
0.0426683128,
-0.0247326866,
-0.0093897143,
0.0783353448,
-0.0096535999,
-0.0010917394,
-0.0108585004,
-0.0009998152,
0.0474639572,
0.0233643055,
0.0506284237,
0.0744327232,
0.0110568479,
-0.00264767,
0.0913918391,
0.0073853368,
-0.074073188,
-0.0305494461,
-0.0572368428,
-0.0465929359,
0.0036742908,
0.0332258902,
0.0537476204,
0.0133080753,
-0.006622429,
-0.0151162948,
0.0551366955,
0.0698856115,
-0.0463991538,
0.0156617276,
0.0116447099,
0.0172311924,
0.0069336477,
-0.0067140213,
-0.0173177477,
0.072192885,
-0.0249994881,
-0.0237518847,
0.0067022583,
-0.0408068001,
-0.0165891219,
-0.0536145754,
-0.0077457349,
-0.0177055746,
-0.0411494002,
0.0272759851,
0.0144160287,
-0.0720315129,
-0.042324122,
-0.0234760214,
0.0098614357,
-0.0507776551,
0.0086024683,
-0.056663435,
0.0422004759,
0.1215167269,
-0.0004209597,
-0.065772675,
0.0101174526,
-0.0073005301,
-0.0476174392,
0.0642199367,
0.0052793417,
-0.0237660464,
0.0158274844,
-0.0219641887,
0.0032909,
-0.0129065188,
0.0048036515,
0.0437398218,
-0.0594373494,
-0.001009668,
-0.0291947238,
0.0221708715,
0.0059287455,
0.0338707827,
0.0082843276,
-0.0316660628,
0.0121737076,
-0.0015326163,
0.0605201907,
0.0144186774,
0.0003476054,
-0.0085046757,
0.0404873863,
-0.0289541632,
-0.0357858911,
0.031224044,
0.0207916889,
0.0180319324,
0.0223454032,
-0.0394005142,
0.0189196076,
0.0400507525,
-0.0060554422,
-0.0445633419,
-0.0045625814,
-0.0484392717,
0.0099313678,
-0.0125233131,
0.0272616986,
-0.0018458212,
0.0245053377,
-0.0033568079,
0.0334661454,
-0.0113661531,
0.0091317622,
-0.0143585028,
-0.0068156938,
0.0110610928,
-0.0265299827,
-0.044480741,
0.0058620488,
0.0219854899,
0.0138390549,
0.0242885165,
-0.0186464339,
-0.0417032614,
-0.0707609206,
-0.0819247589,
-0.0356739014,
0.0215749126,
0.0211090203,
0.0157816112,
-0.0242038034,
-0.0380418152,
0.0235025082,
-0.0534883812,
0.0407051146,
0.0086715873,
0.0105285607,
0.0079434393,
-0.0041902387,
0.0045075337,
-0.0787799805,
0.0235606637,
-0.0203860085,
0.0130318105,
0.0171839837,
-0.0808856711,
-0.0508189686,
0.0624863058,
-0.0220320709,
0.0337450244,
-0.0146766398,
-0.0690103695,
0.0133714955,
-0.0496748686,
0.0329950526,
0.0745032951,
0.0325752422,
0.0636951178,
0.0892817751,
0.020601837,
-0.0228004809,
0.0117002437,
-0.0482584834,
0.0212209988,
-0.0425201878,
-0.0221757051,
0.0242511984,
0.0308854748,
0.0304308124,
-0.0075157369,
-0.0591398999,
0.0059883627,
0.0199686978,
-0.0734010562,
-0.0175161362,
-0.0098054186,
-0.0499003977,
0.0599808469,
0.0135497097,
-0.0489135832,
0.0398034006,
0.0250980444,
0.0163282026,
-0.0302116387,
0.0217866674,
0.0101500135,
0.0636400133,
-0.0101385489,
-0.0013704745,
-0.0475873537,
0.0261156317,
-0.0131783029,
-0.0024060556,
-0.0649943203,
-0.043056678,
0.0052269804,
-0.0587871484,
-0.0035320332,
0.0185376909,
-0.0233535916,
-0.0267561805,
-0.0387802683,
-0.044001624,
-0.0317353383,
0.0138748959,
0.0030205455,
-0.0210217312,
-0.0009460887,
0.0361086093,
-0.0296374559,
-0.0117699401,
-0.0444821455,
0.0075431024,
-0.0099863615,
0.0758697838,
0.030741116,
0.026912855,
-0.0190898925,
0.0252467003,
0.0549961329,
0.0492883511,
0.0292511955,
-0.0140819671,
0.0059937928,
0.0247027781,
0.0015518707,
0.001397811,
0.0139409481,
-0.0136531265,
0.0058192662,
0.020960588,
0.1137241349,
0.0251685902,
-0.0609392077,
-0.0039805318,
-0.0148185426,
-0.0727985203,
0.039034009,
0.0494498014,
-0.046515137,
0.0052285562,
-0.0325970761,
0.0251514148,
-0.0254234336,
-0.0240993332,
-0.0102962302,
-0.0818588361,
0.0432348698,
-0.0065260376,
0.0282554161,
-0.0174693931,
-0.007727243,
0.0544156395,
0.0073711015,
-0.0316705629,
-0.0467712507,
0.0117014833,
-0.0222737342,
0.0348316692,
0.0308701191,
-0.0140397726,
0.0103121689,
0.0115421796,
0.0358136036,
0.0357045718,
0.0795160383,
-0.0202916302,
-0.0487488471,
0.0146549959,
-0.0354803428,
0.0147583475,
0.0078369332,
0.0263259672,
0.002438674,
-0.010834951,
-0.0101685021,
0.0491021834,
-0.0321413167,
-0.0022598249,
-0.0103263035,
0.0399708115,
-0.0678469166,
-0.050431218,
-0.0285795443,
0.0317820385,
-0.0204540268,
0.0405458435,
-0.0122168139,
-0.0955007076,
-0.0340171941,
-0.0044198674,
-0.0041477447,
0.0269567575,
-0.0785091147,
-0.0533029996,
-0.0078938529,
-0.0344719701,
-0.0827613249,
-0.0330144092,
0.031005621,
0.0718874931,
0.0261872616,
-0.0138137415,
0.0514477491,
-0.0148137612,
-0.0097141964,
-0.0155873522,
-0.0123916436,
-0.0103064319,
-0.0170714054,
-0.0120917549,
0.0576044507,
-0.0601645224,
0.0205462836,
-0.0288408678,
0.0067941998,
-0.0659639984,
0.0396380126,
0.0485078394,
0.0254944414,
-0.0019410974,
0.0143190259,
-0.0606440194,
0.0531755202,
0.0371461362,
0.018735595,
0.04677682,
0.0188297797,
0.101483956,
-0.0334408656,
-0.0038588184,
-0.0175384171,
0.0276251845,
0.0240293052,
0.0034576254,
0.0083400384,
-0.0815021992,
-0.009331095,
0.0021363446,
0.0435610004,
-0.0238924939,
0.0143915676,
-0.068111971,
-0.0135577964,
-0.0228259712,
0.018038936,
-0.0452802666,
-0.0378145948,
0.0086091245,
0.0388443246,
-0.0592937842,
-0.0289238505,
-0.0269448906,
-0.0348480344,
-0.0141362865,
-0.0246254317,
0.0288233291,
0.0136628691,
-0.0545919985,
0.0444667377,
-0.001824679,
-0.0102664819,
0.0021039199,
0.0061245733,
0.0102569731,
0.0431947783,
0.010644692,
-0.0487011746,
-0.0209207628,
0.0553286374,
-0.0482710302,
0.0087412978,
0.0083896071,
0.0582128838,
0.0236935839,
-0.0069753458,
0.0374764912,
-0.0597423501,
0.0178417768,
-0.0141399466,
0.0170413144,
0.0246475898,
-0.0122346822,
0.0260508768,
0.0041223969,
-0.0188430715,
-0.0055919108,
0.0212151725,
-0.0508514792,
0.0515031554,
0.0148844942,
-0.0484060645,
-0.0386293009,
-0.0017591938,
-0.0030660245,
0.0088202432,
0.0107123479,
0.0105512291,
-0.0840238482,
-0.0238547605,
0.0921457335,
0.0045053842,
-0.0014133013,
-0.0472536199,
0.0463083684,
0.0238752291,
-0.0005274507,
0.0530123226,
-0.0225529373,
0.0036525687,
-0.0420974605,
-0.0228441525,
-0.0128867207,
-5.55029384e-33,
0.0110112792,
-0.0208338704,
-0.0235878788,
0.0343736969,
-0.0671924353,
0.0044239382,
-0.0198021084,
0.0288929306,
0.039293047,
0.0303868633,
-0.0191661809,
0.0024940853,
0.0123662995,
0.0011133789,
0.0175689459,
-0.0185988583,
-0.0008600833,
-0.0226515923,
0.0145287709,
-0.0012388546,
0.0659011379,
-0.0027944143,
0.0361293145,
-0.0871839896,
0.0146333016,
0.0324309766,
-0.0214026552,
0.0393133759,
0.0302931685,
0.0143578621,
-0.0648275986,
0.1000011638,
0.0333738364,
0.0276850145,
0.0044943988,
0.0277469028,
0.0431846641,
-0.0248950776,
0.0076967934,
-0.0330518857,
-0.0257473737,
-0.0211232547,
0.0234019831,
0.0349485911,
-0.0364696085,
0.0357550941,
0.0371569432,
-0.0462504886,
0.011834804,
-0.0937876254,
-0.0415756851,
-0.0289782304,
0.0068628779,
-0.0050158156,
0.0518754907,
0.0215363204,
-0.0170744359,
-0.0092806416,
0.0080101164,
0.0294779297,
-0.0319315903,
0.0287238862,
0.0250339974,
0.0065465062,
0.03569391,
0.0984996483,
0.0260140616,
-0.0061612027,
-0.0424366854,
0.0324678905,
0.022095995,
0.0112497136,
0.0483787023,
0.0785890296,
-0.033594355,
-0.0232225694,
0.0034938664,
0.0503569059,
0.0435237363,
-0.0270807538,
0.0698390156,
0.0049936189,
-0.0066711479,
0.0083616544,
-0.0201646183,
0.0181721076,
-0.0308346525,
0.0074391006,
0.0202066936,
-0.0183242019,
-0.0076954495,
-0.0533992834,
-0.0133589152,
-0.0269286409,
0.0058378065,
-0.0210537035,
-0.0363046117,
0.0725403577,
0.0057341778,
-0.0358631276,
0.016644435,
-0.0427649207,
0.0216243491,
0.0117490925,
0.0157546215,
-0.0248301439,
-0.0793263912,
0.0414074361,
-0.0360264406,
0.0098276874,
-0.031783171,
0.0272856839,
0.024212189,
-0.0104736472,
-0.0125054661,
0.0016965915,
-0.0004663263,
-0.0270194598,
-0.0199706815,
0.0389323868,
0.021269016,
0.0064793043,
-0.0132315429,
0.0411701612,
-0.0554158799,
0.0351692848,
-0.0196831096,
0.0316945687,
-0.002808501,
-0.0479312651,
-0.0003562569,
0.0374670848,
2.818e-7,
-0.0110750468,
0.0288660694,
0.0117197549,
-0.0783021227,
0.0459053032,
0.0497370847,
0.0226364937,
0.063770242,
0.0502153337,
-0.087053299,
0.0305639338,
-0.0078616152,
0.0213005561,
-0.0250725243,
-0.0955477878,
-0.0018895818,
0.0328220837,
0.0114323488,
-0.0109153837,
0.0136235524,
0.1123506054,
0.0411936045,
0.0446792804,
-0.0099109914,
-0.0014548091,
0.0363141485,
0.0336222313,
-0.0498680361,
-0.0046909461,
0.0054539787,
-0.0080991732,
-0.0360895991,
-0.0177664366,
-0.0113362921,
0.0075528272,
0.0019516008,
0.0135229081,
0.0437913053,
0.0075143641,
-0.0394840837,
0.0153263127,
0.0510524809,
0.0076351413,
0.0311248973,
0.0312291104,
-0.0476411916,
-0.0405869409,
-0.060645625,
-0.0113060726,
-0.0189199187,
0.0086285658,
-0.0274224374,
-0.0315969028,
0.0291633774,
-0.0252632201,
-0.0126716699,
-0.0114741977,
-0.0796540231,
0.0067224577,
-0.0207344387,
-0.0440966897,
0.0075097764,
-0.0230023675,
0.0730642676,
0.0407487676,
-0.0675687045,
0.0051577957,
1.96791323e-34,
-0.0222004484,
0.0288774166,
-0.0169871096,
-0.0151871173,
-0.0022499091,
0.0386240296,
-0.0144971209,
-0.0051579834,
0.0304870773,
-0.0935765132,
-0.0003890339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05703v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05703v3 | An Attribution Method for Siamese Encoders | 2023-10-09T13:24:44 | 2023-11-29T15:12:00 | Lucas Möller, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite the success of Siamese encoder models such as sentence transformers
(ST), little is known about the aspects of inputs they pay attention to. A
barrier is that their predictions cannot be attributed to individual features,
as they compare two inputs rather than processing a single one. This paper
derives a local attribution method for Siamese encoders by generalizing the
principle of integrated gradients to models with multiple inputs. The solution
takes the form of feature-pair attributions, and can be reduced to a
token-token matrix for STs. Our method involves the introduction of integrated
Jacobians and inherits the advantageous formal properties of integrated
gradients: it accounts for the model's full computation graph and is guaranteed
to converge to the actual prediction. A pilot study shows that in an ST few
token-pairs can often explain large fractions of predictions, and it focuses on
nouns and verbs. For accurate predictions, it however needs to attend to the
majority of tokens and parts of speech. | [
0.0252186488,
0.036148984,
-0.011179382,
0.0514561273,
-0.033703085,
0.0240048226,
0.0411214381,
-0.0428681038,
-0.0472943373,
-0.0482837372,
-0.0130054308,
-0.0148425223,
0.0273058433,
0.0441724844,
0.0373718068,
-0.0431130081,
-0.0092014922,
-0.0205917917,
-0.046197027,
-0.0074120844,
0.0155810053,
-0.0028886877,
0.0218770318,
0.0652413592,
-0.0387966111,
0.0083832806,
0.0207758602,
0.0123450058,
0.0112079568,
0.0396839753,
0.006264546,
0.0350273922,
-0.0001827752,
-0.0130721405,
0.0000020422,
-0.018994309,
0.0107797943,
0.0223924909,
0.0265220385,
-0.0205357578,
-0.0180909019,
-0.047092095,
0.0469325185,
0.0192038827,
-0.0246726796,
-0.0034101964,
0.0317541845,
0.049512364,
0.0548303761,
0.0462857522,
-0.0320403948,
-0.0742062554,
0.0435741432,
-0.0024533344,
-0.0055574863,
0.0323306285,
0.0269320104,
-0.0696124956,
-0.0652769804,
-0.0339673944,
-0.0356170572,
0.0552891195,
0.0392474271,
-0.0052091512,
0.0747031048,
0.0176929832,
-0.0222977921,
-0.0094536515,
-0.0323280245,
0.0301586576,
-0.0000174573,
0.0024835651,
0.0166057888,
0.0049943365,
-0.0208036285,
0.0191375166,
-0.0415331014,
-0.0278768465,
0.0066171438,
-0.0015547589,
0.006021705,
0.0042910259,
-0.0018179069,
-0.0242350921,
-0.0410054922,
0.0298228376,
0.0292652454,
-0.025198862,
-0.0288179833,
0.0397494584,
-0.0074389232,
-0.0383051299,
0.0218727943,
0.0171724744,
-0.0130990399,
-0.0074063577,
-0.0112766633,
-0.0802359432,
-0.0541786775,
-0.0744156837,
0.0220420603,
0.0056530302,
-0.0217772014,
0.0159264188,
-0.0377533287,
0.1142543107,
-0.0206539799,
0.0714492202,
-0.0669617131,
-0.04223774,
-0.0543136075,
-0.0321152918,
-0.0657184422,
0.0720517859,
-0.0077104042,
-0.042598661,
-0.0155551974,
-0.0197638068,
-0.0367260203,
-0.0357164517,
0.0277583469,
0.030583974,
-0.0500435457,
-0.0117192054,
-0.0058095022,
0.0558590256,
-0.0302733928,
0.0191265829,
-0.0079372544,
-0.0338170603,
-0.0443830118,
0.0555837005,
0.0274906829,
-0.0545570962,
0.0154133756,
0.0525019653,
-0.0209487528,
-0.0251035988,
0.0073235002,
-0.0229459051,
-0.0337413624,
-0.042887263,
-0.0070972978,
-0.0494168103,
0.0308161434,
0.0279884301,
0.0071193092,
-0.0500742607,
-0.0285713878,
0.0282855071,
-0.0414247997,
0.0705283061,
0.0847157836,
0.0001750757,
-0.0070721325,
-0.0479759872,
0.0022858093,
0.0454614908,
0.0539585985,
0.0806668699,
-0.0070746224,
0.0282915886,
0.0430041887,
0.0198459327,
-0.0042121508,
-0.0009850609,
-0.0584741831,
-0.03063347,
0.0375402533,
-0.0031903419,
0.0309028085,
0.0942348763,
-0.0222514309,
0.0324349478,
0.0345674418,
0.0443299897,
0.0139674684,
0.0091201998,
0.0957493708,
-0.0338994525,
-0.0192546844,
0.0292483345,
-0.01654361,
0.0508915298,
0.0197067373,
-0.0109827043,
-0.0136800194,
0.0305476673,
-0.051280532,
-0.0312112644,
0.0015613227,
-0.003719389,
-0.0316865966,
-0.0317989849,
0.0610084683,
0.0195127614,
-0.0586941801,
0.0637786761,
-0.0381135903,
-0.057713069,
0.0399955884,
-0.0403008163,
-0.0436747149,
0.0505437776,
0.0131230606,
0.0179499704,
-0.0135099431,
-0.0329776183,
-0.0305483937,
0.0245416611,
0.0024219798,
-0.0153158614,
-0.0026973099,
-0.0361498967,
-0.0357018448,
-0.0200444236,
0.0237427428,
0.0321570747,
-0.0256809946,
0.0307388287,
0.0249086991,
-0.0178839788,
0.0360334702,
0.0298073199,
-0.011860162,
-0.0136992456,
0.0322134681,
0.022659922,
0.053606648,
0.0188623089,
0.0147383111,
0.0141651789,
0.0000961542,
-0.0550561771,
-0.0422668941,
0.0839574113,
-0.0356366858,
-0.0623356253,
0.0006049856,
-0.0873174816,
0.0202798788,
0.0546319932,
-0.0264195278,
-0.0816717669,
0.016144203,
-0.0481100976,
-0.019342823,
-0.0244299099,
-0.0003958587,
0.0160558876,
0.0322065167,
-0.006079501,
0.0264486037,
-0.0175954085,
0.0080256108,
-0.0032111297,
-0.0178229045,
0.0004596883,
-0.0256564654,
-0.0379428379,
0.0050820746,
2.474e-7,
0.0128293987,
0.0280529186,
-0.0272159185,
0.0203721244,
-0.0845953152,
-0.0453847423,
0.0142933391,
-0.0344010964,
0.0424058437,
0.0159150474,
0.0171413515,
0.0277849548,
-0.0061712265,
-0.0303128026,
-0.0019732825,
-0.0312492792,
0.002220612,
0.0182331856,
0.0055286638,
-0.035554409,
-0.011704009,
-0.0060941144,
-0.0228853337,
0.0629792586,
-0.0151685299,
-0.0433712564,
-0.0536235422,
0.0024421585,
0.0288374182,
-0.0004750279,
0.003109833,
-0.0387514234,
-0.0144402655,
-0.0064754286,
0.0462350585,
0.0662626252,
0.0122447796,
0.0671782941,
0.0067382921,
0.0020890851,
-0.0185249858,
0.0311170742,
-0.0493276529,
0.0094931787,
-0.0373604037,
-0.0444488116,
0.006992681,
0.0822499916,
0.0022676236,
0.0122363055,
-0.0720837936,
0.0041199289,
-0.0068859737,
-0.0284777321,
-0.0292057507,
-0.0251664761,
-0.0328321494,
-0.0217656549,
-0.0133496784,
-0.0269951727,
0.0622524507,
-0.0375359245,
0.0009978177,
-0.0328714401,
0.0165327545,
-0.0585294738,
0.0786958039,
0.0096561508,
-0.0159515608,
0.010485244,
-0.0490699224,
-0.0686413422,
0.006404669,
0.0503433906,
0.0114901504,
0.0215718932,
0.0050282199,
0.0116119469,
0.0084869042,
-0.0471832231,
-0.007776814,
-0.0425556377,
-0.0487130918,
0.0270251986,
0.0178294517,
-0.0202034619,
-0.039307069,
0.007926981,
0.0126967244,
0.0124057746,
-0.023739025,
0.0073832255,
-0.0363169387,
0.031507276,
0.0565608591,
0.0198967289,
-0.0265934095,
-0.0595049895,
-0.0020276373,
0.0121565396,
-0.0058370261,
0.019978907,
-0.0267451126,
-0.0077994308,
0.0299222339,
-0.0076171914,
-0.0236528143,
-0.0108088255,
0.0255293362,
-0.0099522462,
-0.0173854362,
0.1064775363,
0.0115024885,
-0.0502426587,
-0.0066400105,
0.0117779588,
0.0215690006,
0.03158677,
-0.0042230776,
-0.0590960383,
-0.0391532965,
0.0161149278,
-0.0151994685,
0.0318485536,
-0.0048699803,
0.0101998197,
-0.0944414884,
0.0134788547,
-0.0074968147,
-0.039540384,
-0.0421099477,
0.0005510073,
-0.0125992298,
-0.0434634574,
-0.0068650255,
-0.025255315,
-0.0201031715,
0.0190331023,
0.0321573839,
-0.0061753956,
0.0023842882,
0.0048805326,
-0.0315871648,
0.0085492656,
0.0380836651,
0.0333371572,
-0.0170913897,
-0.0269979592,
-0.010823749,
-0.050451722,
0.00994041,
-0.0004753235,
0.0652130097,
-0.0542750806,
-0.0076556774,
-0.0070516616,
0.0338717513,
-0.0472131707,
-0.0237628277,
-0.0205625594,
0.0422962904,
0.0052701943,
-0.0369558781,
-0.0144517832,
-0.0312626325,
-0.0244408902,
0.0729149207,
0.0380513743,
-0.0126753645,
-0.0733528063,
-0.0055522234,
-0.0264075417,
-0.0057810862,
-0.005235061,
-0.0068764249,
0.0337545387,
-0.0656997636,
-0.0771027803,
-0.0163827185,
0.0184620898,
0.0187463742,
-0.0186050516,
-0.0190296024,
0.0162260924,
-0.0076536299,
-0.0171054248,
0.0064243935,
0.0014568024,
0.035779871,
-0.0053053992,
0.0354838334,
0.0514219478,
-0.0029117144,
-0.0536179245,
-0.0161931943,
-0.0657486096,
-0.0275566,
-0.0228744466,
0.0527921841,
0.0161908437,
0.0468986183,
-0.0263912957,
-0.0118728895,
0.0339816958,
0.0584694743,
-0.0082227029,
0.032704331,
0.0327932984,
-0.0397963412,
-0.0063317721,
0.0320702493,
-0.0176606011,
0.0149125336,
0.0076211141,
0.0356485918,
0.0220480915,
-0.0194939896,
-0.0197238624,
0.0055050962,
0.0996889919,
-0.0106851878,
-0.0351238735,
-0.0312528312,
0.0262510329,
-0.0073981155,
-0.0047722952,
-0.0718857646,
0.0085781384,
0.0076283095,
0.0385709368,
-0.0360761024,
0.0183458552,
0.0356209017,
-0.0159859601,
0.0088832304,
-0.0034835436,
-0.0033206653,
-0.0090011433,
0.0064962744,
0.0320145376,
-0.0034000275,
-0.0297332052,
0.0367472991,
0.0082555013,
-0.0051936656,
-0.0100765182,
0.0254935063,
0.0299453344,
-0.0431466848,
0.0193498563,
-0.0943410546,
0.0062499288,
-0.0791476071,
0.0008508872,
0.0140808001,
0.0189691056,
0.0626625642,
-0.0019273205,
0.0082089426,
0.0106257331,
0.0689086765,
0.00328294,
-0.0047570649,
0.0176443085,
-0.0238965973,
-0.0205367226,
-0.0156281702,
0.0831885114,
-0.0333883055,
0.0173543971,
-0.022468118,
-0.0074774968,
-0.0141030885,
-0.0222319029,
0.0136329671,
-0.00266732,
0.0185481235,
0.005900024,
-0.0402435325,
-0.0770062357,
0.0465832725,
-0.0205133334,
0.0309020784,
-0.007496919,
0.0531653464,
0.0255552121,
-0.014661313,
-0.0306377951,
-0.0174034163,
-0.0255399011,
0.028845869,
-0.0333847255,
-0.0087948544,
-6.21765835e-33,
-0.0417851582,
0.0239998512,
-0.0164703839,
0.083075583,
-0.0092447372,
0.0036270851,
-0.0175496321,
-0.0283586197,
0.0215814803,
0.0237476248,
0.0055416087,
0.0345434994,
0.0196891148,
0.0167729631,
0.0320033766,
-0.0444577672,
0.0618807487,
-0.0012604446,
-0.0091159064,
0.0123844473,
0.0594810136,
0.0407076962,
0.1002234593,
-0.019631872,
-0.0084786052,
-0.0088888798,
-0.030845182,
0.025997486,
0.000008644,
0.0567321442,
-0.011438055,
0.0329768211,
0.0183007177,
-0.0707420036,
-0.0189672355,
0.023518784,
-0.063192822,
-0.0571435466,
0.0040932237,
0.0381230228,
-0.0106322635,
-0.0593292899,
0.0519240238,
0.0276393872,
-0.0296354536,
-0.0561565086,
0.0597005002,
0.0191434585,
0.0136067476,
-0.0517986827,
-0.0523240305,
-0.0098509928,
0.0010920926,
-0.0126465857,
0.0356060602,
0.0175435431,
-0.0011744744,
-0.0472508781,
-0.0177745502,
-0.0108374469,
0.0029193882,
0.0409998596,
0.047581926,
0.0128561892,
-0.0003780656,
0.0563730113,
0.0510898232,
-0.0419843607,
-0.0250377674,
-0.0351449661,
0.0305447113,
0.0488892011,
0.0855441242,
0.0396955162,
0.0393421054,
0.0230029635,
-0.062557824,
0.0293029826,
-0.0171617176,
0.0983635262,
0.0398742855,
-0.0016806859,
-0.0088427952,
-0.0480125658,
-0.057302732,
-0.0030803932,
-0.0346157998,
-0.0199572276,
0.0444431603,
0.0261565279,
0.0153693883,
0.0260424856,
0.0386386551,
-0.0704023987,
0.0004286097,
0.0539530292,
-0.0304828454,
0.0649158284,
0.0064200787,
0.0359427594,
-0.0282190796,
-0.0391750634,
-0.0057658516,
0.0823011696,
0.0316296779,
0.0338468067,
0.0634726211,
0.0241236873,
-0.0663286373,
-0.024352828,
-0.0227094498,
-0.0349719524,
-0.0416856445,
-0.003838104,
0.0073957397,
0.0509943627,
-0.029694045,
0.0468180552,
-0.0356216468,
0.0197974127,
-0.042798318,
0.0033756257,
0.0355386622,
0.0412538759,
-0.0100963628,
0.0128194038,
-0.0279942024,
-0.044953607,
0.0469696894,
-0.0236025825,
-0.0100276601,
0.0096926019,
2.846e-7,
0.0435126312,
0.0178843588,
0.0358248726,
-0.0191545486,
0.0037881802,
0.0386914834,
0.0280241612,
0.0780233592,
0.030384222,
-0.0239285026,
0.0314187184,
0.0213871114,
0.0334556624,
0.0005050497,
-0.1195734963,
0.0286176056,
-0.0794328451,
-0.0099972077,
-0.0303243175,
0.0106946575,
0.0565331429,
0.0776095763,
0.0068762884,
0.0047985469,
-0.0350676514,
-0.0170871262,
0.0604083203,
-0.0017047637,
0.0086322548,
0.0189053044,
0.0210562274,
-0.0325485766,
0.0356151126,
0.0505469479,
-0.0266088732,
0.0314830802,
0.0438739285,
0.0506361164,
-0.029638337,
-0.0162330735,
-0.0361700356,
0.0197244342,
-0.0183113348,
-0.039262604,
0.0572853088,
-0.0810982138,
-0.0042038658,
-0.0339183211,
-0.0284963083,
0.0194872953,
-0.0095023355,
0.0216563959,
0.0210960694,
0.0453789197,
0.0470606573,
0.0135034183,
0.0032385415,
-0.0728487298,
0.0025554437,
0.0035995059,
-0.0431586131,
-0.0470929444,
-0.0301764086,
-0.0022080895,
0.0343834907,
-0.0543938503,
-0.0199708845,
2.565791238e-34,
0.0303970817,
0.0390491709,
0.033465039,
0.0499918982,
0.0062441626,
-0.0234714188,
-0.0510843582,
0.0101767862,
0.0214617122,
-0.0957643464,
-0.0316139832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05694v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05694v2 | A Survey of Large Language Models for Healthcare: from Data, Technology, and Applications to Accountability and Ethics | 2023-10-09T13:15:23 | 2024-06-11T13:13:59 | Kai He, Rui Mao, Qika Lin, Yucheng Ruan, Xiang Lan, Mengling Feng, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL | The utilization of large language models (LLMs) in the Healthcare domain has
generated both excitement and concern due to their ability to effectively
respond to freetext queries with certain professional knowledge. This survey
outlines the capabilities of the currently developed LLMs for Healthcare and
explicates their development process, with the aim of providing an overview of
the development roadmap from traditional Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) to
LLMs. Specifically, we first explore the potential of LLMs to enhance the
efficiency and effectiveness of various Healthcare applications highlighting
both the strengths and limitations. Secondly, we conduct a comparison between
the previous PLMs and the latest LLMs, as well as comparing various LLMs with
each other. Then we summarize related Healthcare training data, training
methods, optimization strategies, and usage. Finally, the unique concerns
associated with deploying LLMs in Healthcare settings are investigated,
particularly regarding fairness, accountability, transparency and ethics. Our
survey provide a comprehensive investigation from perspectives of both computer
science and Healthcare specialty. Besides the discussion about Healthcare
concerns, we supports the computer science community by compiling a collection
of open source resources, such as accessible datasets, the latest
methodologies, code implementations, and evaluation benchmarks in the Github.
Summarily, we contend that a significant paradigm shift is underway,
transitioning from PLMs to LLMs. This shift encompasses a move from
discriminative AI approaches to generative AI approaches, as well as a shift
from model-centered methodologies to data-centered methodologies. Also, we
determine that the biggest obstacle of using LLMs in Healthcare are fairness,
accountability, transparency and ethics. | [
0.0461914316,
0.1128412038,
-0.0214220323,
-0.0149092646,
-0.027962029,
0.0270063728,
0.0264578741,
0.0280221961,
0.0102777965,
-0.008726743,
-0.0199531801,
-0.0718083084,
0.0175307691,
0.0247061048,
0.0146426046,
-0.0431930758,
0.0500170216,
0.0210154988,
0.030180132,
-0.0211866852,
-0.0263640899,
0.0177149996,
-0.0236771982,
0.0716952458,
0.0044468311,
0.023994565,
0.02838137,
-0.0138007971,
-0.0005814979,
-0.0544090346,
-0.0044964617,
0.031928461,
0.0072103199,
0.0350016728,
0.0000020567,
-0.0608145222,
-0.0189969912,
0.0382517166,
-0.0425534397,
-0.0379259996,
0.0539871529,
-0.0650354922,
0.0014169825,
0.0247466918,
-0.0302583817,
-0.0238872897,
0.062707141,
0.0110157905,
0.0184428412,
0.0516930968,
-0.0120403692,
0.007213952,
-0.0007535451,
-0.0430686027,
-0.0128026288,
-0.0296374802,
0.0441201404,
-0.0255423803,
0.0174859446,
-0.0429644547,
0.0052992902,
0.0676856637,
-0.0110721253,
0.0327838995,
0.021920111,
0.0543591902,
-0.0230213664,
-0.0025804639,
-0.0197437909,
0.0463143848,
0.0030344168,
0.0048843133,
0.0510661565,
-0.0049097617,
-0.0274629854,
-0.0124383979,
-0.0200391188,
0.0486636646,
-0.0094288578,
0.010934812,
-0.0113777993,
0.0020308839,
0.0473929979,
0.020335434,
-0.0104523171,
-0.0137400106,
0.0228327326,
-0.0356454924,
0.0212253407,
-0.0046915109,
-0.0018614144,
-0.0328644104,
0.0340523869,
0.0418026932,
-0.0423340052,
0.0277415812,
-0.0334270597,
-0.018618403,
0.112033762,
-0.0740620941,
0.04155083,
-0.0017641513,
0.0107891932,
0.0244668573,
0.0338583998,
0.0036715723,
-0.0324190445,
0.0357213654,
-0.0638464913,
0.0216781925,
-0.01720828,
0.0106575619,
0.0012491586,
0.0066312966,
-0.0233129207,
0.0159328822,
-0.0907653272,
-0.0135570783,
-0.0016552532,
0.0155778658,
0.0169106424,
0.0326778106,
-0.0409858637,
0.0099368086,
-0.0158006772,
-0.0150829749,
0.0253179017,
0.0290737357,
-0.0396660715,
-0.0648048669,
0.0190327503,
0.0308165364,
-0.0169167183,
-0.0084837815,
0.0107004857,
0.0684905872,
0.0141041223,
-0.0174055547,
0.0050457185,
-0.0118045518,
-0.0369942747,
-0.0326601006,
0.0002448067,
-0.0750508532,
0.029037796,
-0.0173173938,
0.0132909967,
-0.0720125958,
0.0214489661,
0.0047807698,
-0.0629919171,
0.056102436,
-0.0497044213,
0.0456460863,
0.0562814176,
0.0413456038,
0.0203208253,
0.0467830636,
0.0419926457,
-0.0421477519,
0.0119440882,
-0.0405627079,
-0.002738314,
0.0252234433,
0.0206529368,
0.0007170637,
-0.0075495364,
0.0249429662,
0.0437319539,
0.0952568129,
-0.0306712575,
0.0984772667,
0.0184588563,
-0.0256122053,
0.0382304564,
0.0945215821,
0.0173237696,
0.0090262145,
0.0061533558,
-0.025971137,
-0.0023235281,
-0.0760396942,
-0.0159794204,
-0.0495410189,
0.0098699387,
-0.0303559173,
-0.0243823361,
0.0068106554,
-0.0405556969,
-0.0419174656,
-0.0531456769,
-0.0459426865,
-0.0072050379,
0.0239902698,
0.0463417806,
-0.030141551,
-0.0233837049,
0.0510630235,
0.0582835041,
-0.0580245629,
-0.0026761394,
-0.0928369462,
-0.0022330109,
0.1002658308,
0.0492221676,
-0.0446885638,
-0.018822968,
-0.030917557,
0.0070128934,
0.0255538784,
0.0016764157,
0.0014191116,
0.0277438704,
-0.0490027368,
-0.0166739263,
0.0519315377,
-0.0008481847,
-0.00430068,
-0.0094149094,
0.0206663255,
-0.0133096511,
-0.0088120392,
-0.0625880137,
0.065239124,
-0.0644204915,
0.0046349117,
0.0058510965,
0.0014122707,
0.054439988,
0.0254681837,
-0.0135667501,
0.0257413741,
0.018066803,
-0.0400896184,
-0.0148789454,
-0.0099803852,
-0.025111869,
0.0180555582,
0.0126545085,
-0.0101371538,
0.0153951263,
-0.0095396228,
-0.0167893264,
-0.0048111747,
-0.0336624794,
-0.0324541181,
0.0255664233,
-0.0081750052,
0.0250118244,
-0.0029424976,
-0.0096610673,
-0.0566874258,
0.0248464644,
-0.0383599885,
0.0001102492,
0.0122068711,
-0.0399288163,
0.0217671189,
-0.0368764922,
-0.0257956591,
0.0247253254,
-0.0220610686,
0.0421784483,
-0.008236126,
0.0534746163,
-0.0028412908,
-0.017369777,
-0.106195882,
-0.0058787703,
0.013453153,
-0.0033647518,
-0.0022553748,
0.0220713839,
-0.0040671136,
-0.0170205664,
-0.0384396687,
-0.0344632342,
0.0418375134,
0.0049213613,
-0.0066338507,
0.0222070366,
-0.0143264793,
-0.0314031467,
-0.0114989709,
-0.0284754988,
0.0229389463,
0.0180620551,
-0.0157307852,
0.0021952423,
0.0114101656,
-0.0226231609,
0.005211432,
-0.0096759042,
-0.0364159159,
0.0217181407,
-0.0107795093,
-0.0067936652,
0.0332280435,
0.0009961752,
0.0186102614,
0.0464971252,
0.0167676453,
-0.0215103105,
-0.0040674866,
-0.0293221101,
-0.0362430885,
-0.0058449996,
-0.0517434292,
0.019979937,
0.0732195079,
0.0255790707,
0.0082012117,
-0.0497220308,
-0.0227574278,
-0.0660582036,
-0.0141641647,
-0.0377309658,
0.0098471623,
-0.0462057553,
0.0413531065,
0.0094504673,
-0.0622168519,
0.0789396912,
-0.015474516,
0.0500854775,
-0.0794291422,
-0.0357713476,
-0.033649303,
-0.0008673422,
-0.0382392071,
0.0351341367,
0.009958473,
-0.0256732926,
0.0131702023,
0.0073323562,
-0.0101339901,
-0.0827251077,
0.0764507353,
-0.020306278,
0.0414428711,
-0.001874243,
-0.0615402758,
-0.0479439199,
-0.0251010843,
-0.0234058388,
-0.001717806,
0.0216238685,
0.0134286154,
-0.0339111239,
0.0322535336,
-0.0105596362,
0.0814703405,
0.031341169,
-0.001502844,
0.0110841841,
-0.0320937373,
-0.0010842382,
0.0001939146,
0.0006981348,
-0.005249681,
0.0111580398,
0.0581348427,
0.0407364555,
0.0337391905,
0.0087400135,
0.0018095148,
0.0323784426,
-0.0332502648,
0.0260717347,
0.0335535258,
0.030777853,
-0.0186987761,
0.0036232357,
0.1076472402,
0.0233902708,
-0.0982719287,
0.0343423933,
-0.0176702309,
-0.0314887427,
-0.0140107768,
-0.0016225796,
-0.0727307051,
-0.0054683601,
-0.0128447665,
0.08848501,
-0.04019868,
-0.0144204032,
0.0375575498,
-0.0376945622,
0.0275331382,
0.0214400049,
-0.0415871032,
-0.026297899,
-0.0406992137,
0.0137456944,
-0.0243581254,
0.0170832854,
-0.0150252981,
-0.0292795673,
-0.0433051512,
0.0135604749,
-0.0401209854,
-0.0952014923,
0.0191641059,
-0.0440032184,
0.0650635213,
0.1092395857,
0.0351933278,
-0.0251284968,
-0.0188724492,
-0.0100019015,
-0.0009645543,
0.0051505943,
-0.0259867851,
0.0478599966,
0.0169185251,
-0.0106090074,
-0.0413661599,
0.0248397626,
-0.0447623245,
-0.001918328,
0.0292867962,
0.0631749853,
-0.058977183,
-0.0061313296,
-0.0373820774,
0.0138558215,
0.0498555042,
0.0587889552,
-0.0026995228,
-0.0259009581,
-0.0108253285,
0.0068496489,
0.054054372,
0.0174981393,
-0.0172359832,
0.0335026383,
-0.0413457602,
-0.0408896282,
-0.0423526317,
-0.0149344709,
0.0229234956,
-0.0053769774,
0.0341320187,
0.0205127746,
0.0365094058,
-0.0031446118,
-0.0567733422,
0.0293727908,
-0.0072305701,
0.050262887,
-0.0619789362,
-0.0933305398,
0.0240513459,
-0.0027270406,
-0.0109056169,
0.019894667,
0.0005795402,
-0.0212391615,
0.0269174259,
0.0702562779,
0.0201818924,
0.0177497864,
-0.0102845766,
-0.0294960085,
0.0273358654,
0.0397997275,
-0.0605468862,
-0.0079313638,
0.0003140874,
-0.0014200436,
-0.0133057544,
0.0027620255,
-0.0289636143,
0.0291856546,
0.0220014285,
0.0379631929,
-0.0070954333,
-0.0302597806,
0.0073801638,
0.0346921198,
0.0173891429,
-0.0453848094,
-0.0219211541,
-0.0384685919,
0.001256248,
-0.0336339474,
0.0212444551,
-0.0346292108,
-0.010240321,
0.0386089683,
0.0035147287,
-0.0104439799,
0.015947815,
-0.0651656091,
-0.0256510284,
-0.0625330359,
0.0908904821,
0.0076686009,
0.0322943218,
0.05237161,
-0.0070371293,
-0.0035840168,
0.0405875295,
-0.0029583264,
0.0152942352,
0.0015645761,
0.0541436486,
-0.0023977004,
0.0244582444,
-0.0179507267,
0.0528098978,
-0.0179272369,
-0.0593592413,
-0.0040666889,
0.0213051382,
0.0385371111,
0.0286774505,
0.028415652,
-0.0149591295,
0.0129278712,
-0.027534809,
0.0067408797,
-0.0383599438,
0.002772158,
0.0385247134,
-0.0002133068,
-0.0134994639,
-0.008055456,
0.1026626378,
0.0248208884,
0.0639296547,
-0.0306435134,
-0.0357148908,
-0.0269811265,
-0.0430370644,
0.0428808331,
-0.0093528116,
-0.0880300552,
-0.0157462861,
-0.0547000617,
-0.0431303084,
0.0273745172,
-0.0207616016,
-0.0265742447,
-0.026323216,
0.0574497692,
0.0463801362,
0.001978359,
-0.0296213515,
-0.0357060768,
0.0475063846,
-0.044326704,
-0.0357021689,
0.0257639214,
-5.803754667e-33,
0.0277292524,
-0.0146857304,
0.019677069,
-0.0402723365,
-0.0209339987,
0.0336624496,
-0.0184472408,
-0.0158544499,
0.001070673,
-0.0042876047,
-0.0177613199,
0.0028946875,
0.00814554,
0.0422275886,
0.0158546157,
-0.0360402651,
0.0196185876,
-0.001479725,
-0.0119050313,
0.0578237176,
-0.0539779663,
0.037207976,
0.0474837422,
-0.0680876225,
0.0060711848,
-0.0001805283,
0.0189347845,
0.0368241742,
-0.0306409057,
0.0609381571,
-0.0428392887,
0.0515466742,
0.0303157624,
-0.0045430018,
0.0094972877,
0.0038975594,
-0.0387596264,
0.0225035008,
0.0079060886,
-0.0235793982,
-0.0347767286,
-0.0579635948,
0.0660158992,
-0.0042537483,
-0.0622713007,
0.0158764385,
0.0135203078,
-0.0406038128,
-0.0239504632,
-0.034352839,
-0.0384005345,
0.0528021082,
-0.0207014028,
-0.0028173446,
-0.0067357342,
-0.0277571473,
-0.0514409132,
0.042099949,
-0.0324305519,
-0.0015038591,
0.0427055918,
-0.0085760476,
0.0423009917,
-0.0066981115,
-0.0008772836,
0.0403483286,
0.0300912932,
0.0197228845,
-0.0321522355,
0.0077977781,
-0.0282749999,
0.0241265241,
0.0451138206,
0.0266786143,
-0.0282575767,
-0.0639083385,
-0.0927355886,
0.0357883275,
-0.0507298633,
0.0319472812,
0.0329172947,
-0.0262540802,
-0.0843133777,
-0.0344920233,
-0.0298308302,
-0.000714559,
-0.0097696148,
-0.011838261,
0.0368263759,
0.0193234961,
-0.0011053442,
0.0489964411,
0.0139786834,
-0.0382824987,
0.0209156666,
-0.0108743394,
0.0661418289,
-0.0068586604,
-0.0409932695,
0.0160993747,
-0.0971038938,
-0.0176287126,
0.0098771956,
-0.0096161785,
0.0511102937,
-0.0134362541,
-0.0175982472,
-0.0266535487,
-0.0387386009,
0.0073567992,
0.0330746882,
-0.0086760353,
-0.0104292808,
0.012269564,
0.0439431965,
0.0234994255,
0.0300436895,
0.051724378,
-0.0005440864,
-0.0232035592,
-0.0524661206,
-0.0279526077,
-0.0039121388,
0.0155176222,
-0.0608195439,
0.0143338917,
-0.0524064638,
0.0446305834,
0.05125615,
-0.0592974611,
-0.0095124915,
-0.000719655,
2.695e-7,
0.0852744952,
0.0415374264,
-0.0117500415,
-0.0394822806,
0.0109763583,
-0.0000907754,
0.015159389,
0.0042883563,
-0.0218238439,
0.0172899161,
0.0362951532,
0.0215420686,
0.0690621734,
0.0266234856,
-0.0527456962,
-0.0030452502,
-0.0923557654,
0.000867833,
-0.0531886034,
-0.026040731,
0.0195154101,
0.0633969754,
-0.0434698313,
-0.0480717197,
0.0026174705,
0.0045515955,
0.030383544,
-0.0566581823,
0.0018634661,
0.0397317745,
-0.0030979342,
0.0082019148,
0.0157388672,
0.0113595137,
-0.0186362602,
0.0043369536,
0.0117442235,
0.1225480735,
-0.0762102455,
0.018237032,
0.0237430129,
-0.0018660492,
-0.0005123207,
-0.0446671918,
0.0482994616,
-0.0153864017,
-0.0475940406,
-0.0430386402,
0.0166712385,
-0.0257136375,
0.0639530122,
-0.0194228645,
-0.0209822301,
0.0262868963,
0.0279208347,
0.0097014392,
-0.0268222,
-0.0421776548,
0.011793199,
-0.0010107739,
-0.0288934838,
-0.0417004786,
0.0310423076,
0.0119231427,
-0.0149165066,
-0.065233849,
0.0482948162,
2.298816497e-34,
0.0114531461,
-0.0179692078,
-0.0000467504,
0.0152437175,
0.033586394,
0.0107001271,
0.0105613004,
0.014923689,
-0.007266969,
-0.050458651,
0.0044417069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05688v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05688v1 | Larth: Dataset and Machine Translation for Etruscan | 2023-10-09T12:56:08 | 2023-10-09T12:56:08 | Gianluca Vico, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Etruscan is an ancient language spoken in Italy from the 7th century BC to
the 1st century AD. There are no native speakers of the language at the present
day, and its resources are scarce, as there exist only around 12,000 known
inscriptions. To the best of our knowledge, there are no publicly available
Etruscan corpora for natural language processing. Therefore, we propose a
dataset for machine translation from Etruscan to English, which contains 2891
translated examples from existing academic sources. Some examples are extracted
manually, while others are acquired in an automatic way. Along with the
dataset, we benchmark different machine translation models observing that it is
possible to achieve a BLEU score of 10.1 with a small transformer model.
Releasing the dataset can help enable future research on this language, similar
languages or other languages with scarce resources. | [
0.0232840553,
0.0554868914,
-0.039863117,
0.0271113068,
-0.0278775133,
0.0269287322,
0.0184869505,
0.0087139476,
-0.0253562015,
-0.0168142784,
-0.0161097031,
-0.023250144,
0.0668805465,
0.0323042497,
0.0412892774,
-0.0344323926,
0.0077433293,
-0.0256283171,
-0.0247621667,
0.0144494018,
-0.0202042796,
0.0485956408,
-0.015070335,
-0.011386265,
-0.0061701857,
0.0162712708,
0.0074645793,
0.0466887727,
0.0306053646,
-0.0067152255,
-0.02461401,
0.0171322133,
-0.0148005867,
0.0929092541,
0.0000021466,
-0.0351059809,
-0.030373171,
-0.0101544131,
0.0013103932,
-0.0027067268,
0.048719909,
-0.0493803099,
-0.0260804892,
-0.0187135097,
-0.0312808156,
-0.0011065776,
0.0844026953,
-0.0233208872,
0.0021384966,
0.0987099558,
-0.035106387,
-0.0573183708,
0.0055838786,
-0.0415944383,
0.0070659514,
0.0063521857,
-0.0133134518,
-0.0164342411,
-0.0604200549,
0.04821283,
-0.0351786651,
0.07491979,
-0.0159278307,
-0.0233027302,
-0.0566788241,
-0.0020376646,
-0.0639634505,
-0.0503358468,
0.0018736369,
0.0446542166,
0.0079922015,
-0.031692028,
-0.0036201151,
0.029420441,
-0.0414973199,
-0.0140722813,
-0.0204625372,
-0.0094066709,
-0.0232690591,
-0.0065508522,
0.0483922847,
0.0159136634,
0.0243383292,
-0.0050433693,
-0.042352628,
0.0045154714,
0.0682645366,
-0.0401439331,
-0.0039379303,
0.0166816637,
-0.0056028948,
0.0161115043,
0.0328510255,
0.0151621867,
-0.0020624469,
-0.0169551112,
0.0050647603,
-0.0256166421,
-0.019210184,
0.0077569275,
0.0030212461,
0.0543728098,
-0.0299375243,
0.0616992302,
-0.0382054262,
0.0361490175,
-0.0118688634,
-0.0248243343,
-0.022731524,
-0.0013845505,
-0.0163020659,
0.04085017,
-0.0656282827,
-0.0454503819,
-0.0601747185,
0.0479912162,
-0.0280723125,
-0.0143890148,
0.0585935935,
-0.0069171824,
0.0460280739,
-0.0447840095,
-0.0595425665,
-0.0250488129,
-0.00652315,
0.0218185261,
-0.0065364493,
0.0153773464,
-0.048903551,
-0.0873221755,
-0.0199085325,
0.0125389295,
0.0078423098,
-0.0392045528,
0.0298109986,
0.0343568809,
-0.0091313077,
-0.0674474835,
0.0052898135,
0.0203579944,
-0.0518435687,
-0.0728593245,
-0.0201551225,
-0.0559570119,
0.0722090751,
0.0178715289,
0.0187466554,
-0.0128808692,
-0.0184555184,
0.0121868988,
-0.0130012659,
0.0595186017,
-0.0379278697,
0.0164131932,
0.0391933024,
-0.0188880451,
0.0230069757,
0.0241078883,
0.074462302,
0.0239768066,
0.0232898407,
-0.0068401615,
-0.0399172828,
0.0456919335,
-0.006785355,
0.0333175361,
-0.0134815611,
0.035291601,
-0.0046455842,
0.0502658188,
0.0264447797,
0.0734971315,
-0.0012301297,
0.0264795031,
0.0635981932,
0.0632513836,
-0.0411979407,
0.0934040397,
0.0200100504,
-0.0243286453,
0.0089178719,
-0.0448171981,
0.0069014039,
0.0014422107,
0.0497208945,
-0.0075083068,
0.0102528725,
0.0443293229,
0.0144359944,
-0.0186421312,
0.0223136563,
-0.0254735835,
0.0286573619,
-0.021723723,
0.0724947825,
0.0148876635,
-0.0624651723,
0.0390616618,
-0.0172098111,
-0.0877913758,
0.0037107379,
-0.0110824127,
0.0322636031,
0.0339366496,
0.0633109808,
-0.0353982039,
0.0096049346,
-0.0255985614,
0.0073039839,
0.0591772422,
0.0478439629,
0.0000494343,
0.0493145995,
-0.0724609867,
-0.0001461634,
0.0025071565,
0.00545592,
0.0156941395,
-0.0178237334,
0.0875419602,
0.0308825318,
0.0107904263,
-0.0712717846,
0.0409360304,
-0.0644453466,
-0.028477421,
-0.0149638997,
-0.0061720759,
-0.0040645027,
0.0244128946,
0.0106130773,
-0.0099054221,
0.031040743,
-0.0689153969,
0.0280583315,
0.0327385068,
-0.022973422,
-0.0045879772,
0.0540211126,
-0.1090062112,
-0.0385439806,
0.011991703,
-0.0174823124,
-0.0508385971,
0.0030455699,
-0.0743882284,
0.0222278666,
0.0113050975,
0.053575974,
-0.0161469448,
0.0096581923,
-0.0392455719,
0.0418803543,
0.0017864398,
0.0283486731,
0.0313478447,
-0.0783032477,
0.0332270227,
-0.0118356552,
-0.0334387198,
0.0075214654,
0.0197872352,
-0.0238742903,
0.0291952211,
0.0266300626,
-0.0247466192,
-0.0462693237,
-0.0527092032,
-0.0017237221,
-0.0331939086,
0.0453930646,
0.0434720218,
0.0588466637,
0.0112553854,
0.0001483849,
-0.0053034187,
-0.0166099649,
-0.0169927888,
-0.0214087646,
0.0369849615,
-0.0368298814,
-0.034562774,
-0.01651101,
0.0004144962,
0.0394296348,
0.0201611314,
0.0380182303,
-0.0436931252,
-0.0480948277,
0.0378944874,
-0.0127676697,
-0.0116061801,
-0.0150539223,
-0.0473599695,
-0.0089508165,
-0.0171112623,
0.0460330173,
0.0391448215,
-0.0112038832,
-0.0091210632,
0.0206397492,
-0.0065916711,
-0.0160237402,
-0.0313195512,
-0.0358093716,
-0.0237315651,
-0.0646573156,
-0.0667490587,
0.024504818,
0.0435197651,
-0.0024232322,
0.0196929928,
-0.0341434218,
-0.022448536,
-0.0214356799,
0.0114630256,
-0.0007033023,
0.0352888368,
0.0021486343,
0.0712488219,
-0.022864297,
-0.0110359285,
0.0647060201,
-0.0213013813,
-0.0100971702,
-0.0320894569,
0.0004743386,
-0.0473672301,
0.0353378728,
0.0170719381,
-0.0007405314,
-0.0352226011,
-0.0098986374,
-0.010401791,
0.0471338332,
0.0380380303,
-0.0365347862,
0.0310231987,
-0.0564521961,
0.0113377981,
-0.0388043486,
-0.013950577,
0.0204116385,
-0.0010543948,
-0.0086606964,
-0.0230855513,
0.0408562608,
-0.0496916361,
-0.0578935407,
0.0004479025,
-0.0031819493,
0.0637461096,
-0.0024909745,
0.0042447741,
-0.0041376469,
0.0533112064,
-0.0085671553,
0.0245152451,
-0.0178664122,
-0.0063712969,
0.0071308645,
0.0123872189,
-0.019668689,
-0.0141778802,
-0.0417663679,
-0.0033781114,
0.0584475771,
0.0227294248,
-0.0178486146,
-0.0583813787,
0.0251844246,
-0.0144759668,
-0.0341055132,
0.0609639622,
0.0088139791,
-0.0039733476,
0.0025533831,
-0.0279984046,
0.0257387962,
0.0292585976,
-0.0106977699,
-0.0837488174,
0.018878635,
-0.0064569139,
0.037149258,
0.0369436145,
0.0071026324,
0.0177804194,
-0.0772164613,
-0.0094400505,
0.0268684849,
-0.0614410006,
-0.0813864544,
-0.0243631098,
-0.0629517362,
-0.06960769,
-0.0447513498,
0.0271009523,
0.007754846,
-0.0040929075,
0.0306625944,
0.0445752144,
-0.0616491511,
-0.0155728301,
-0.0236946996,
0.031468343,
0.025689356,
0.0877480954,
-0.0406116433,
-0.0273133554,
0.0016107479,
0.0165050253,
-0.0274678245,
0.0089598997,
0.0490764827,
0.0340678766,
-0.0230257679,
0.0004120175,
0.0286859423,
-0.037340235,
0.0021775861,
0.0437909029,
0.0075511187,
-0.0134331463,
0.0075102206,
0.0488638505,
-0.0413710847,
0.0108849788,
0.0381239727,
0.0084245848,
-0.0046467301,
-0.008312271,
-0.0124776373,
-0.0143853761,
-0.0421899706,
-0.0951932296,
0.0508604944,
-0.0355473608,
-0.0561294742,
-0.0896092057,
-0.0338748246,
0.0339016691,
0.0374454893,
0.0484205335,
-0.0001947505,
-0.0018336768,
-0.0098182978,
-0.0595533401,
0.0827547535,
-0.0192034747,
0.0190865342,
-0.0659066588,
-0.0125159286,
0.0164713748,
-0.0059949337,
-0.0003635852,
0.0735155642,
-0.0573313832,
-0.0579591952,
0.0297250841,
0.0448315367,
0.0346764624,
0.0062839459,
-0.0108354585,
-0.0394485854,
0.0086130677,
-0.0098401187,
-0.0347758122,
0.0060463077,
-0.0037617178,
-0.0177862328,
-0.0097740507,
0.038700819,
-0.0077571175,
0.0102626104,
0.0148666864,
0.0133361733,
-0.0451501906,
-0.066205211,
0.0279635694,
0.0340423509,
0.0499442592,
-0.0830168203,
-0.006601166,
-0.0104539776,
0.0325713977,
-0.017786216,
0.0317718834,
-0.0091594914,
0.014150626,
0.073619999,
0.0030078855,
-0.0195712876,
-0.0208438132,
-0.0050382046,
-0.0146087725,
-0.0357066169,
0.0302757528,
0.0214878414,
0.0610788725,
0.0379018895,
0.0279518031,
-0.023764899,
0.0639000237,
-0.0329460427,
0.0743849427,
-0.0231434871,
0.0110151153,
0.0122998282,
0.0296463799,
0.0261676516,
0.0535486601,
-0.0024482352,
-0.0068463488,
-0.0125245145,
-0.0072383862,
0.0617571138,
-0.0014863577,
0.1303719431,
0.0001733141,
-0.0262783971,
-0.0259694364,
0.0722834617,
0.00983945,
0.0055598752,
-0.0238175225,
-0.0068140919,
0.0041149054,
0.0642234534,
0.0130498344,
-0.0318339616,
0.0141009968,
0.058149226,
0.0068355356,
-0.0043719271,
0.0065629841,
-0.0462732203,
-0.0707352534,
-0.0275264382,
-0.0579696447,
-0.0321578421,
-0.0493745953,
-0.0128452061,
0.0338693485,
0.0141785545,
-0.0229931362,
0.0080316067,
0.0448419824,
-0.0158933215,
0.0249183886,
-0.0446000062,
0.0445907824,
-0.0317632891,
-0.0241941605,
-0.0816408992,
-5.87179228e-33,
-0.0226310454,
0.0128854103,
0.0370523147,
0.0153004564,
-0.0037745396,
-0.0256103985,
-0.0446743742,
-0.0179116409,
0.0089806374,
0.0021046156,
0.0005438018,
-0.002224592,
0.0190361869,
0.0003359744,
0.0297731571,
0.0329913534,
0.0418551452,
0.0184945669,
-0.0403186195,
0.0086310552,
0.0683848858,
0.0045234277,
0.1124584228,
-0.0854727104,
0.0423379615,
-0.0471783057,
-0.0232704505,
0.0025996119,
-0.011734494,
0.0144321099,
-0.0033038359,
-0.0017287468,
0.0191144925,
-0.0146412104,
0.0019684162,
-0.02195834,
-0.1055717021,
0.010923529,
0.0154091371,
0.0755494535,
0.0049424591,
-0.020539891,
0.0142137604,
-0.0100031933,
-0.0290599596,
0.0181443673,
0.0200669579,
-0.0489332713,
-0.0253494363,
-0.0271498132,
-0.04678284,
0.0498886146,
-0.0373410732,
-0.0146609433,
0.0442726798,
0.0932314545,
-0.0161003657,
-0.0202974938,
-0.0637632981,
0.0202820376,
-0.0466882214,
0.0424130782,
0.0710464567,
-0.0433856621,
-0.0270460676,
0.0075895744,
0.0584656633,
-0.0209837202,
0.0608364083,
0.0241584536,
0.010991049,
0.0172330849,
0.0127136959,
0.0452377871,
0.0441111438,
-0.0695687979,
-0.0392646082,
0.0244692136,
0.0057549439,
0.0052837837,
0.0099436138,
-0.0219163708,
-0.0363784246,
-0.0027682183,
-0.028010508,
-0.0321379267,
0.0182448681,
0.0164052639,
-0.0068803043,
-0.0203371402,
-0.0060600848,
-0.0041224253,
0.0009068944,
-0.0293008089,
0.0274721179,
-0.0140574537,
-0.0557794608,
0.0094608022,
-0.0304986387,
0.0379993282,
-0.0252283551,
-0.0606880337,
0.0206306875,
0.0381006002,
0.0287950933,
-0.0110321417,
0.0167795923,
0.0066081281,
-0.0588231571,
0.012498145,
-0.0283311382,
-0.0215444341,
-0.0265054479,
0.0248321928,
0.0246236213,
-0.001805695,
0.0003272805,
-0.0093205106,
0.0437606685,
-0.0170523766,
-0.0112836538,
-0.0022399134,
0.0631301925,
0.0258509815,
-0.0498647355,
-0.0064298538,
-0.0222488325,
-0.0178436488,
0.0485788882,
-0.0254722275,
-0.0200006757,
-0.018029578,
2.886e-7,
0.0546193756,
0.0497857593,
0.0333039872,
0.0137649747,
-0.0198696647,
-0.0005182748,
-0.0546027124,
0.0331105627,
0.0078831539,
0.016260922,
0.0220448617,
0.0056344555,
0.0842033774,
0.0167022813,
-0.0621922612,
-0.0161352865,
-0.0668692365,
-0.0182161778,
-0.0391223878,
-0.0055048913,
-0.0060811499,
0.0773896426,
-0.0035292276,
-0.0411421992,
-0.0406195931,
0.005564969,
0.0255913623,
-0.0348387994,
-0.0223120097,
0.0072591337,
0.0378584079,
0.0254701208,
-0.0466981158,
0.0184102673,
-0.0138865709,
0.0105822887,
0.0252042115,
0.091722697,
-0.0112904776,
0.0462625921,
0.0350500122,
-0.0494589843,
-0.0458062962,
-0.0162452441,
0.0266305339,
0.0320455506,
-0.0106794629,
0.0123173986,
-0.0393621959,
0.0519674867,
0.0204767715,
-0.0242163073,
0.031997297,
0.0021815847,
0.057589855,
-0.0310630631,
-0.0131929768,
-0.0374579877,
-0.0105951866,
-0.0027625121,
-0.0203741454,
-0.0517681129,
-0.0063251308,
0.0024372949,
0.019805273,
0.0183505677,
-0.0185538959,
2.307273169e-34,
0.0191640947,
-0.0289626475,
0.0210237205,
0.0136838416,
0.0122240856,
-0.0599775612,
0.0178913753,
0.0037144835,
-0.0027922089,
-0.036699269,
-0.0230369531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05686v1 | The potential of large language models for improving probability learning: A study on ChatGPT3.5 and first-year computer engineering students | 2023-10-09T12:54:58 | 2023-10-09T12:54:58 | Angel Udias, Antonio Alonso-Ayuso, Ignacio Sanchez, Sonia Hernandez, Maria Eugenia Castellanos, Raquel Montes Diez, Emilio Lopez Cano | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I2, I.2 | In this paper, we assess the efficacy of ChatGPT (version Feb 2023), a
large-scale language model, in solving probability problems typically presented
in introductory computer engineering exams. Our study comprised a set of 23
probability exercises administered to students at Rey Juan Carlos University
(URJC) in Madrid. The responses produced by ChatGPT were evaluated by a group
of five statistics professors, who assessed them qualitatively and assigned
grades based on the same criteria used for students. Our results indicate that
ChatGPT surpasses the average student in terms of phrasing, organization, and
logical reasoning. The model's performance remained consistent for both the
Spanish and English versions of the exercises. However, ChatGPT encountered
difficulties in executing basic numerical operations. Our experiments
demonstrate that requesting ChatGPT to provide the solution in the form of an R
script proved to be an effective approach for overcoming these limitations. In
summary, our results indicate that ChatGPT surpasses the average student in
solving probability problems commonly presented in introductory computer
engineering exams. Nonetheless, the model exhibits limitations in reasoning
around certain probability concepts. The model's ability to deliver
high-quality explanations and illustrate solutions in any programming language,
coupled with its performance in solving probability exercises, suggests that
large language models have the potential to serve as learning assistants. | [
-0.0175646897,
0.0123800654,
-0.0615422167,
0.0002361263,
-0.0585424453,
-0.0043123411,
0.0136691583,
-0.035086982,
0.0075436989,
-0.0209561624,
0.0515190139,
-0.0335533395,
-0.0009611889,
0.0260586515,
0.0193090327,
-0.0650229752,
0.0024115536,
-0.0593057349,
0.0113968048,
-0.0149676995,
-0.0071580834,
-0.0194480736,
-0.046134036,
0.0480757058,
0.0414375067,
-0.0129948268,
-0.0265176035,
-0.0263977237,
-0.0246006437,
-0.0468146764,
0.006385887,
0.0508662127,
0.016662214,
0.0154825719,
0.000002502,
-0.0744982511,
-0.0151579976,
0.0351522788,
-0.0062150443,
0.0520496517,
0.0163914654,
0.0744905248,
-0.0130921854,
0.01689744,
-0.0008513033,
0.016070623,
0.0801299289,
-0.0188562889,
0.0034137771,
0.0178101808,
0.0309631564,
-0.016671,
0.0100667365,
0.0128958747,
0.0576112382,
-0.0181655679,
0.0098796291,
0.1071923375,
0.0707575902,
0.014664147,
-0.0250560939,
0.0099473679,
0.0444940031,
-0.0196920671,
0.001772583,
0.0267939195,
-0.0442808792,
0.0133650908,
0.0039055329,
-0.0013389115,
0.0039448491,
-0.0084642926,
-0.0015697794,
-0.031198075,
-0.0020168927,
0.0580255538,
-0.0926678553,
0.0495300516,
-0.0185124148,
-0.0024793791,
-0.0188685302,
0.001495072,
-0.0062673464,
-0.0080995774,
0.0380849726,
0.0523320101,
0.0078240419,
0.0080053695,
0.0071245059,
0.0443440899,
-0.0240699723,
-0.0231759995,
0.0065546823,
0.0463458858,
0.0110439369,
0.0265213996,
0.0258196257,
-0.0045253565,
0.0369203538,
-0.0742468834,
0.013906735,
0.0376739092,
0.0313147418,
0.0175018776,
-0.013608749,
0.0296256207,
0.01733361,
-0.0137715125,
-0.0216708127,
0.0690980181,
-0.0713074133,
-0.0335011296,
-0.0239870865,
0.0219115019,
0.0144348666,
0.0187092051,
-0.074004896,
0.0100809084,
-0.0003033325,
-0.0293014739,
-0.001459452,
-0.010028895,
-0.0232055597,
0.0184469074,
-0.0758721158,
0.0117656989,
-0.0062687136,
-0.0049449196,
-0.0037874596,
-0.0624525324,
0.0093332492,
-0.0041386862,
-0.0280531216,
-0.0169217587,
0.0029864975,
0.046207834,
-0.0289675929,
0.0257461611,
-0.013915563,
-0.0375171192,
0.0037683847,
-0.0142441178,
-0.000800929,
-0.1036986709,
-0.0283167157,
0.0162141938,
-0.0026863334,
0.0038150533,
0.0387738757,
0.0129644414,
0.0384460911,
0.0543107726,
0.0367171951,
-0.0006116065,
0.0564135574,
0.0251182262,
-0.0310842339,
0.0595189035,
0.0225176718,
-0.002341866,
-0.0136469295,
-0.0678244904,
0.0570628941,
0.0219669193,
-0.0370746963,
-0.0053383936,
0.0126750059,
0.0133321006,
0.0592395365,
0.0032037606,
-0.0215226803,
0.0179713015,
-0.0105522964,
0.059328001,
0.0197402909,
0.0134724909,
-0.0087553896,
0.0448058918,
0.0280207284,
0.0127694402,
0.0319838114,
-0.0236970559,
-0.0345257856,
0.0564033166,
-0.0244632959,
0.0230182428,
-0.0121947294,
0.0351443328,
0.0103055509,
-0.0384272672,
0.0065300437,
-0.0003054643,
-0.0056455131,
0.0046020141,
0.0722813532,
-0.035997618,
0.0069839037,
0.0123442095,
0.0206149705,
-0.0111733563,
0.0047580656,
-0.1114079878,
0.0124734202,
0.0423878543,
0.0379303172,
-0.0366479829,
0.0022607336,
-0.0106972074,
0.0228941366,
-0.0216602124,
0.083402358,
0.013416579,
-0.0320527367,
-0.0339410417,
-0.0107960543,
0.0141100232,
0.0050432859,
0.0332197621,
0.0126848174,
0.0050717858,
0.012238387,
-0.0224299245,
-0.0323333144,
-0.0094989268,
-0.0608831346,
-0.0119306631,
-0.0161698982,
-0.0431546345,
-0.0120325601,
-0.0286212601,
-0.017866483,
0.0435948074,
-0.0145930136,
0.0075081014,
-0.0224861763,
-0.0390400887,
-0.0362406671,
0.0264250841,
0.0556259342,
-0.0343999229,
-0.0152246673,
-0.032928057,
-0.0021524087,
0.0079246843,
0.0501756333,
-0.0349157564,
0.0434687547,
-0.0036412803,
0.0213837326,
-0.0267925244,
-0.0066812304,
-0.0262102131,
0.0331634581,
0.0805933401,
0.038596794,
-0.0212675575,
-0.0134704849,
0.0508038774,
-0.0801516399,
-0.0135645373,
-0.0142275365,
-0.0190799274,
0.0405441038,
0.0319359936,
0.0300434716,
-0.0327726267,
-0.0008304871,
-0.0268706996,
-0.0226659924,
0.0288291723,
0.0378061347,
0.0085036876,
-0.0419365056,
-0.0338808447,
-0.0022044363,
-0.0041375663,
-0.0198491812,
-0.0375213847,
-0.010885112,
-0.0026823406,
-0.0223079715,
-0.0556192249,
-0.0258538257,
-0.0411548652,
-0.0462000035,
0.0111498134,
0.0978331044,
0.015013692,
-0.0301826056,
0.0907414109,
0.0084016602,
-0.0317554399,
-0.0144513324,
-0.0197699945,
-0.0116375126,
-0.0443145707,
0.069458425,
0.0308235977,
-0.0459386632,
0.0100761726,
0.0620548986,
-0.0613070913,
-0.0436391272,
-0.0060865106,
0.0030257227,
-0.0474657528,
-0.012495541,
-0.0936302766,
-0.0597019345,
-0.0026057712,
0.0353100263,
-0.0280982517,
0.0043026842,
0.0293640923,
-0.047713995,
-0.0052068457,
-0.0564889126,
-0.0122166676,
0.0104592573,
0.0595543273,
0.0295692794,
-0.0318699665,
0.0802502334,
-0.0212406386,
0.0102554327,
-0.090858005,
-0.0243040528,
-0.0008721438,
0.0516692735,
0.0151439449,
0.0095338384,
-0.0085440511,
-0.0037060385,
-0.0525695607,
0.0039142254,
0.02136066,
-0.0240415912,
-0.0083738863,
-0.0575410426,
-0.0209264904,
-0.0088507896,
0.0109544434,
-0.0036477628,
-0.0062740925,
-0.0314897969,
-0.0163684133,
0.012076661,
-0.0185501315,
-0.0075691673,
0.0306740776,
0.0733515918,
-0.0379088484,
-0.044760298,
-0.033149533,
0.0335822962,
-0.0028110626,
0.0176574308,
-0.0270617846,
0.0162862744,
-0.0671069548,
0.0228421576,
0.0200270135,
0.0377198793,
0.0453522392,
-0.0517386235,
-0.0122363316,
0.007477399,
-0.0182025991,
-0.0253321957,
0.0627468154,
0.0219751932,
-0.0520394966,
0.0093363812,
0.0726761073,
0.0064775138,
0.0440551154,
-0.0215816852,
-0.0504201837,
0.0180008318,
0.0053883237,
0.0686414093,
-0.0771913305,
0.0248417836,
-0.0083653554,
0.0136389891,
-0.042956572,
-0.0170239322,
-0.0012942521,
-0.0916122347,
0.0444124714,
0.0136478227,
-0.0247425344,
-0.0376807265,
-0.0638111606,
-0.0176991839,
-0.0315911807,
-0.0091226734,
0.0385370776,
-0.0011957979,
0.0511058345,
0.0382001735,
-0.0800160393,
-0.0301791728,
0.0553614721,
0.0037014398,
0.0063190581,
0.0351927653,
-0.0137832751,
-0.0791032091,
-0.0160630532,
0.0391763709,
0.0244937185,
0.0028170939,
0.0253704749,
-0.002912651,
0.0497951023,
0.0078714723,
-0.0466901995,
-0.0021005461,
-0.0195602607,
-0.0436355546,
0.0827680007,
0.0992975086,
-0.0223577451,
-0.0325990915,
-0.0681634843,
-0.0014287272,
0.0077904142,
0.0340306759,
0.0133284014,
-0.0161889549,
0.0156523064,
-0.0852537155,
-0.0214328244,
0.0277528819,
0.0004129343,
-0.0262403619,
-0.016773846,
-0.0403978638,
0.045857124,
-0.0187300146,
0.050345134,
0.0181835443,
0.0208734237,
-0.0009897932,
0.0479513071,
0.0444048531,
-0.0119853746,
0.0236480422,
-0.0273755379,
0.0379106104,
-0.0135764899,
-0.0031946672,
0.0128510669,
-0.0389931798,
-0.052052144,
-0.0021910854,
-0.0566060431,
-0.0428626835,
0.0119960858,
0.0534860715,
0.032482177,
-0.0868714973,
0.0042908965,
-0.0127300946,
-0.0305588264,
0.0100410357,
0.0102217011,
0.0117629031,
-0.0339887217,
0.0155140227,
0.0359643586,
-0.0604313686,
0.0131162563,
-0.0160498451,
-0.0020581542,
0.0329487622,
-0.0626211315,
-0.0509572923,
0.0010044305,
0.0759843215,
0.0306610372,
0.0222075973,
-0.0111127049,
-0.0088417837,
0.0156447291,
-0.0308297295,
-0.0188357756,
0.0154942004,
-0.0337090977,
0.0380007103,
-0.0050435904,
0.0134319775,
-0.0105757946,
-0.0199820697,
0.004238239,
0.026668055,
0.06753622,
0.0707487464,
0.012509739,
0.0847440064,
-0.0241344925,
0.0030055922,
-0.0522078797,
0.0135149369,
0.0545934141,
0.0086038234,
0.0516012087,
-0.0125481309,
-0.0426371731,
0.0361598618,
-0.0480759144,
-0.0124521684,
-0.076920487,
0.0052172472,
0.0570430383,
0.0101241414,
0.027378194,
-0.0316111892,
-0.0708100051,
0.0152637083,
-0.0233504493,
0.0142979417,
0.0223585777,
-0.0014907342,
0.0526413023,
0.0082081761,
-0.0050201723,
-0.0417667106,
0.0364197753,
-0.0244646091,
-0.0122780912,
-0.0111800097,
-0.0379563048,
0.0062564048,
-0.005912282,
0.0408530049,
0.0294800755,
0.0135963522,
-0.0166854616,
-0.0650982112,
-0.0557204336,
-0.048219312,
0.0267424583,
0.0301503967,
-0.0125871785,
0.029901363,
0.0737425387,
-0.035943687,
0.0322408453,
-0.0010205448,
0.045357991,
-0.0126563683,
-0.0154370982,
0.0016847942,
-6.187680305e-33,
-0.0037024983,
-0.0357800685,
0.0392588787,
0.0316804722,
0.0567391403,
-0.0572496355,
-0.0208766144,
0.0456431694,
-0.0043557817,
-0.0053743138,
0.0064482228,
0.0055021211,
0.0104926452,
0.0086061116,
0.0370783471,
0.0052146162,
-0.011908059,
0.0255685486,
0.002044746,
-0.0330501385,
-0.0227103718,
-0.0113672111,
0.0395732932,
-0.0624098815,
0.0107583432,
-0.0065277419,
0.0192696508,
-0.0319659747,
0.0073035639,
0.0267683845,
-0.0007452675,
0.0663067251,
-0.0057584075,
-0.0581737682,
-0.0049167774,
0.037111856,
0.0173665993,
-0.0682961121,
0.0073146457,
0.0301158354,
0.0561795011,
-0.0420254394,
0.0207737144,
0.0002509608,
-0.0425459445,
-0.0224930998,
0.0755848736,
-0.0267881732,
0.0084179156,
0.0084409397,
-0.0007566491,
0.0140829077,
-0.0339246951,
0.0136780282,
-0.005863958,
-0.0123606268,
-0.0240508616,
-0.0501423106,
0.0520425476,
0.0570743941,
0.0588827506,
0.0369844027,
0.0961071029,
-0.0288705174,
0.0087298183,
0.0173262767,
0.0297401901,
-0.0036302009,
-0.0122730425,
-0.0482128896,
0.0107749142,
-0.023976095,
0.0145770572,
0.0712876692,
0.0332760736,
0.0275571905,
-0.1203703359,
0.0440691188,
0.0510006733,
0.0005743692,
0.0164206568,
-0.0076640737,
-0.0601342544,
-0.0477762222,
-0.0362088233,
0.0112096947,
-0.0200030524,
-0.0680685118,
-0.0052181035,
-0.0732144639,
-0.0039800177,
-0.0210556202,
0.0077345511,
-0.0214286298,
-0.0607651509,
-0.0128523652,
0.0094901035,
0.0232660826,
-0.0410925448,
0.0387006477,
-0.044277247,
0.0196705125,
-0.023467537,
0.0008328218,
0.0313241519,
0.0194532163,
-0.0065124817,
0.0154162282,
-0.0479101688,
-0.008799253,
-0.0355457924,
-0.0409388319,
0.0536082499,
0.011729951,
0.016891988,
0.0259297732,
0.0025375884,
-0.0113552036,
0.004337179,
-0.0532434098,
-0.0143595766,
-0.0052685495,
-0.0430464931,
-0.0396164618,
0.006013908,
-0.0231537335,
-0.0627614483,
-0.0039642877,
0.012617847,
-0.0475520007,
-0.016456252,
-0.0079075517,
3.115e-7,
0.0671471804,
0.0469654426,
-0.0348002501,
0.0371995904,
0.0067820372,
-0.0014158607,
-0.0421023443,
-0.016927965,
0.0671164468,
0.0257337764,
-0.0156728607,
0.0322245546,
0.0199795384,
0.0521221347,
-0.0551641956,
-0.0232938174,
-0.0310464203,
0.0154880257,
-0.0230041947,
0.0405332372,
0.1045146659,
0.0531577021,
0.0537065603,
0.0184677429,
-0.0281194765,
-0.0552118085,
0.0093003958,
-0.0264762118,
-0.0155641129,
0.0454391018,
-0.03635877,
0.0276282113,
0.0182429031,
0.0696915165,
0.0054580257,
-0.0658240542,
0.0125893448,
0.0627639145,
0.0461132303,
0.0469294339,
0.0463881381,
-0.017238643,
-0.0053863889,
-0.0770111978,
0.0288954861,
-0.0443493389,
-0.0319470391,
0.0427941121,
-0.0708685517,
-0.0598085187,
0.0110308016,
-0.0005130789,
-0.0018394056,
-0.0305307768,
-0.0454978161,
0.0048424113,
0.0075865895,
0.0349046141,
-0.0200454947,
0.0181253664,
-0.0150858629,
-0.0834771022,
-0.0165805761,
-0.0200180449,
0.0463302471,
-0.0060440693,
0.0181489103,
3.045319924e-34,
0.0320991017,
-0.0014549359,
0.0130925635,
-0.0002492761,
0.0239944998,
0.0202905219,
0.0229922682,
0.0110613657,
0.0261001028,
0.0108472146,
-0.0453399345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05657v1 | A Closer Look into Automatic Evaluation Using Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T12:12:55 | 2023-10-09T12:12:55 | Cheng-Han Chiang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Using large language models (LLMs) to evaluate text quality has recently
gained popularity. Some prior works explore the idea of using LLMs for
evaluation, while they differ in some details of the evaluation process. In
this paper, we analyze LLM evaluation (Chiang and Lee, 2023) and G-Eval (Liu et
al., 2023), and we discuss how those details in the evaluation process change
how well the ratings given by LLMs correlate with human ratings. We find that
the auto Chain-of-Thought (CoT) used in G-Eval does not always make G-Eval more
aligned with human ratings. We also show that forcing the LLM to output only a
numeric rating, as in G-Eval, is suboptimal. Last, we reveal that asking the
LLM to explain its own ratings consistently improves the correlation between
the ChatGPT and human ratings and pushes state-of-the-art (SoTA) correlations
on two meta-evaluation datasets. | [
0.0504245907,
0.027924601,
0.0054559507,
0.0130005535,
-0.0617704615,
0.0146645373,
0.0421553291,
0.0164282508,
-0.012807454,
-0.0606733263,
-0.0694375709,
-0.0472151116,
0.0325764976,
0.0369574837,
0.0199167356,
-0.021608904,
-0.0116389561,
-0.0140809743,
0.0509822257,
0.0045080283,
0.0394134708,
-0.009445874,
0.059004169,
0.0345751867,
0.0275079366,
-0.0299911443,
0.0341842137,
-0.0041038529,
0.0121547673,
-0.0147782378,
-0.0223747063,
0.0518302061,
-0.0419424847,
0.024462238,
0.0000019856,
-0.030706834,
-0.0048863967,
0.021533709,
0.0303269047,
0.0845687166,
0.0701738521,
0.0385414213,
-0.0289920866,
0.0189378858,
-0.0172570217,
-0.0032408114,
-0.0040178383,
0.0261698961,
0.0802237093,
0.0508815832,
-0.0094103916,
-0.0074515101,
0.0001020905,
-0.0198148508,
-0.0210881699,
-0.0154930865,
0.0253759082,
0.048468709,
-0.0091312081,
0.0579673983,
0.0167945363,
0.0298982505,
0.0125430748,
-0.0589413866,
0.0269765444,
0.0123492237,
-0.0355516039,
-0.0217472408,
0.021495793,
0.0494758077,
0.0124203833,
-0.0208690595,
0.0036433074,
0.0073774396,
0.0158879887,
0.0095129954,
-0.0336731374,
0.0239136163,
0.0204579625,
0.0054481374,
0.0117466953,
0.0232343376,
0.026522696,
0.0261721071,
0.0154906949,
0.0534894466,
0.0072720931,
-0.0544328541,
0.0081939837,
0.0076523665,
-0.0303506572,
-0.0380037539,
0.0084816124,
-0.0200544354,
-0.0029987136,
-0.0096926037,
-0.0060527702,
-0.0139360437,
0.0321404301,
-0.0714386553,
0.0348750502,
-0.0040432401,
-0.0017319309,
0.0363646932,
-0.035962414,
0.0678142756,
0.0234679803,
0.0226881951,
-0.0485148132,
0.0216993708,
-0.0503218994,
0.0138445776,
0.0034697971,
0.0243148021,
-0.0005489888,
-0.0114254458,
-0.0597084723,
-0.0113806641,
-0.0108510023,
-0.0143546583,
0.0146462675,
-0.0056033088,
0.0270954892,
0.000945421,
-0.0167504288,
0.0266930182,
-0.0220567677,
0.0239922348,
-0.0123205511,
-0.0055180043,
0.024428241,
0.0431303792,
-0.0004303894,
-0.004023911,
0.0090838494,
0.0250476785,
0.0206736289,
-0.0183153097,
-0.0019497458,
-0.0078640282,
-0.0530934371,
-0.0666646883,
-0.0339056812,
-0.0783662274,
-0.0290035941,
0.0304369908,
0.0066460329,
-0.0033099239,
-0.0118232258,
0.0315265246,
-0.0310575943,
-0.0037588677,
-0.0088015273,
0.0474299304,
-0.0044219843,
0.0062179733,
-0.0030782875,
0.0269981883,
0.0507128909,
0.0462959073,
0.0206067581,
0.0020150691,
0.027716808,
0.030299928,
-0.0123402132,
0.0424950048,
-0.0005133993,
-0.0049996194,
-0.024920553,
0.0253185686,
0.0062581282,
0.1131129116,
-0.0295367949,
0.0193123128,
0.1007148698,
0.0384234153,
0.0496986881,
0.0401660353,
0.0454289615,
0.0381072611,
0.0377429724,
0.0200884566,
-0.0148442723,
0.0196308121,
-0.020857418,
0.0187774654,
0.0701134726,
0.0359350257,
-0.0015081373,
-0.0896473527,
-0.0290304329,
0.0215072222,
0.0069424822,
-0.0371558033,
0.0273933522,
-0.0208035242,
-0.0250815153,
-0.0467711128,
0.0070822681,
-0.0479641482,
0.0187586546,
-0.064853929,
0.0358181857,
0.0802913755,
0.0569318086,
0.0355216302,
0.0482126847,
-0.0235858131,
0.0014164352,
0.0098174522,
0.0096915662,
0.0016468023,
-0.0379420146,
-0.0393670909,
-0.0166439041,
-0.0071334722,
0.0168519728,
-0.0088228025,
-0.0237111207,
0.0064106979,
0.0235342495,
-0.0342535116,
-0.1064134911,
0.0126301683,
0.0092022838,
0.0034853155,
0.0053394805,
-0.0131229348,
0.0372112207,
0.0263624098,
-0.0521129817,
0.0314115733,
-0.0093856808,
-0.0180898998,
-0.0425810404,
-0.0173781496,
-0.0332840122,
-0.0168836359,
0.0121025555,
-0.068347156,
-0.0073580896,
0.0195967387,
-0.0113448547,
-0.0283502191,
-0.0157365575,
-0.050041724,
0.0180015173,
-0.0517405905,
0.0307577457,
-0.02620361,
-0.0266683251,
-0.03644526,
0.0451859906,
0.0053755809,
0.0419759378,
0.0065561845,
-0.0222131629,
0.0399231799,
0.0080083907,
-0.0675889477,
0.0043276418,
0.0061311079,
0.0548023917,
0.0516534448,
0.060304258,
-0.0444177389,
-0.0484001711,
-0.0831021145,
-0.0121937795,
-0.0104693025,
0.0153852152,
0.0346093923,
-0.0506000482,
-0.0038443028,
0.0500667766,
-0.0520001873,
-0.0399114452,
0.0019274731,
0.0191781502,
0.0284621753,
-0.011769142,
0.0187213998,
-0.0261062272,
-0.0201427396,
-0.0091341529,
0.0777728409,
0.0412191153,
0.0040056114,
-0.0339769647,
0.0795935467,
-0.0596835651,
-0.0593985245,
0.0268259477,
-0.0931481868,
-0.0218816139,
-0.0021182457,
0.0288292579,
0.031642288,
0.0113211367,
-0.0197362751,
0.0825199112,
-0.0060330937,
-0.0427406318,
-0.0424111485,
-0.0024793621,
-0.0101230675,
0.0074042398,
-0.0475285575,
0.0176915862,
0.0426171981,
0.0102917897,
-0.0079434896,
-0.0493292809,
0.0275383946,
-0.0643856078,
0.0001196669,
-0.035318926,
-0.0289379787,
-0.0125310477,
0.0548315868,
-0.0060434672,
-0.0598315187,
0.0717186108,
-0.0427196175,
0.006165571,
-0.0588232726,
0.0145201292,
-0.0390429981,
0.0196028706,
-0.0185797289,
0.0355923884,
-0.0249753632,
0.0035200578,
-0.0135862129,
0.0021165861,
0.0519436039,
-0.0454726703,
0.0243531615,
-0.028308617,
0.0109660728,
0.0218487512,
-0.0167897604,
-0.0021932141,
-0.0240854248,
-0.0329023488,
-0.0156732667,
0.0591135472,
-0.0035088276,
-0.0045435508,
0.0334225632,
0.0294222832,
-0.0036735975,
-0.055639822,
-0.0036399406,
0.0315062851,
0.0343782008,
0.0381078981,
-0.0371088795,
0.0299553424,
-0.0301467534,
0.0486030839,
0.042539157,
-0.0113043329,
0.0372658074,
-0.0136017064,
-0.0411278531,
0.015666293,
0.0221580397,
-0.0469182692,
0.0076678614,
0.0382271484,
-0.0493257642,
-0.0123525681,
0.1276784986,
0.0335135013,
-0.0517893247,
-0.0383748561,
-0.031094769,
0.0363286175,
-0.012345111,
-0.0040796781,
-0.0531936213,
-0.0190315377,
0.0143030025,
0.0083996048,
-0.0218502395,
0.0091550862,
0.001628509,
-0.0978936553,
0.0255401004,
0.0209405348,
-0.0006314485,
-0.0039531249,
-0.0390381627,
0.0127102798,
-0.0161431227,
0.0156155247,
0.0149498032,
-0.0076420978,
0.0243128873,
0.0068562482,
-0.0625854582,
-0.0567110814,
0.0433626585,
-0.031841334,
0.068852514,
0.0657232329,
0.0502475873,
-0.0121601149,
-0.068884775,
0.0475508831,
-0.0102371639,
-0.0284200106,
-0.0104474379,
0.0520509928,
-0.0049498314,
0.0235614311,
-0.0550494865,
0.0033351467,
0.0154842036,
0.0295416955,
0.0018766974,
0.0249735992,
-0.0122014172,
-0.0221992768,
-0.0177729093,
0.0429464839,
-0.0349940248,
0.0982557386,
0.0384512022,
-0.0779094771,
-0.020564707,
-0.0294433236,
-0.0405826978,
-0.009585402,
-0.0700870529,
0.0352992304,
-0.0103931921,
-0.0343910232,
-0.0908448026,
-0.0384282991,
-0.0033645399,
-0.0169511847,
0.0153688937,
0.0060182596,
-0.0231917407,
-0.0046041105,
0.0223453864,
-0.0044282726,
-0.006426848,
0.0123137319,
-0.0743926093,
0.0415533856,
0.0459585525,
-0.0159253757,
-0.0139212823,
0.0187764373,
-0.0665899888,
-0.0334418006,
-0.0141534684,
0.0282575823,
0.0172559787,
-0.0091569601,
-0.0346944258,
-0.0624054149,
0.039290525,
0.0326963104,
-0.0551957972,
0.0147980554,
0.0097900713,
0.0170563199,
0.0211164672,
0.033426784,
-0.0342790596,
0.0258045811,
0.0112564117,
0.0204221942,
0.0119648706,
-0.029348487,
0.0278160963,
0.0554806627,
0.0259566214,
-0.0162064061,
0.0106185861,
-0.0041911169,
-0.0247564539,
-0.0495471172,
-0.0358309709,
-0.0449248739,
0.0330133587,
0.0426618122,
0.0237776805,
-0.0552586094,
0.0348744355,
-0.0137671027,
0.0275393445,
-0.0169893,
0.041008953,
-0.0301248096,
-0.0040308861,
-0.0022206856,
-0.0105656022,
-0.0264333691,
-0.0379755646,
-0.0011925698,
-0.0019705172,
0.0064118975,
0.0405565873,
0.0265854876,
-0.0128665352,
0.0298123639,
0.0741892681,
-0.0666086376,
-0.0207905993,
-0.0396911427,
-0.003924367,
0.0271721389,
0.0152485175,
0.0921681896,
-0.0208115932,
-0.0040978235,
-0.0410552248,
0.0372721329,
0.0269711558,
-0.0190401785,
0.0020600609,
-0.0009223102,
-0.040225748,
0.0022560589,
0.0702234954,
0.0037113654,
-0.0466239937,
0.0165385064,
-0.0576207563,
-0.0253909845,
0.0034818316,
-0.040376883,
0.0025470855,
-0.0048319777,
-0.0301748943,
-0.0779829547,
-0.0382396206,
-0.0313986056,
0.0218146425,
0.0399803258,
-0.0264111105,
-0.0022479857,
0.0643518195,
-0.0181562621,
0.0196613632,
-0.0647805855,
-0.0424747951,
0.0193431266,
-0.0223403778,
-0.0107372692,
-6.255255067e-33,
0.0106331352,
-0.0284250695,
-0.0261836573,
0.0027875307,
-0.0156776849,
0.0309112221,
-0.0227254145,
0.0017299786,
-0.0009463522,
0.0401186012,
-0.007190797,
0.0072336635,
0.0033125158,
-0.0097126989,
0.0136546157,
-0.0106500275,
0.0338559933,
-0.0068333414,
-0.050934568,
0.0136908805,
0.0090886476,
-0.013188486,
0.0205847975,
-0.0606011264,
0.0508648232,
-0.0096683372,
-0.050309293,
-0.0412438177,
0.0153694879,
0.0716178417,
-0.0043756138,
0.0551247522,
0.0418001786,
-0.0469987616,
-0.010019619,
0.0088488199,
-0.0332372077,
-0.0060706106,
0.0228997171,
-0.0380384773,
-0.0297873542,
-0.0218927991,
0.0408911072,
0.0062406901,
-0.04117487,
-0.0063699251,
0.0572252125,
-0.042291481,
-0.0040572919,
-0.0444724597,
-0.0153424554,
0.0415445492,
-0.0154086985,
-0.0209531859,
0.013550695,
0.0180676896,
-0.0490641408,
0.0650846064,
-0.0250952747,
0.0483549237,
0.01529771,
0.0450457558,
0.0265953802,
-0.0235585179,
-0.015226393,
0.051188428,
-0.0423927903,
0.0149677303,
-0.0214687996,
-0.0326316506,
0.0418492407,
-0.0081884796,
0.0596143082,
0.0734459236,
0.0222627893,
-0.0362800658,
-0.0552305728,
0.0509435236,
-0.0140861422,
0.0291275755,
0.0333029479,
-0.0085798064,
-0.0377297252,
-0.0360640325,
-0.0550891347,
-0.0181412213,
-0.0460132845,
-0.0446930565,
0.0247686412,
-0.0202801544,
-0.0239679907,
-0.0546903163,
0.0233741365,
-0.0474467054,
-0.0276826601,
0.0367092229,
-0.0902156383,
0.044395756,
-0.0016652326,
0.0369740762,
-0.0477524586,
0.0481738374,
-0.0050215893,
0.0694488361,
-0.0049123485,
-0.0343358554,
0.0630950928,
0.0060080681,
-0.0951224938,
0.003695355,
-0.0259699058,
-0.012246185,
-0.0012915727,
-0.0340254717,
0.0016335757,
-0.0148571488,
-0.0120632574,
0.0517033488,
0.0030055915,
0.025828585,
-0.030390637,
-0.0366806388,
0.0121310921,
-0.0059311804,
-0.0410842448,
0.0081098517,
-0.0250041764,
-0.0140660172,
0.0510590449,
-0.0382685736,
-0.0228376128,
-0.0131454486,
2.693e-7,
0.0327657945,
0.0743452162,
-0.022208618,
-0.0108162435,
0.0015792432,
0.045915544,
-0.0145679126,
0.0075280811,
0.0384630226,
0.0098977666,
0.0215346161,
-0.0071533048,
0.0663191006,
0.0190115869,
-0.0570570156,
0.0296354145,
-0.0981703699,
-0.0462637395,
-0.0239364114,
-0.0169365779,
0.0666429847,
0.0720552877,
0.0077044102,
0.0143323345,
-0.0000713721,
-0.0607322752,
0.0660722107,
-0.0310468581,
-0.0430719703,
0.0362426788,
0.0711399168,
-0.0128089972,
0.0035329659,
0.0046216445,
-0.0108395647,
-0.0039118067,
0.056619592,
0.0745523423,
0.0338244997,
0.0105488561,
0.0119229993,
-0.0186679028,
0.0081669288,
-0.0700743794,
0.0802073777,
-0.0218749158,
-0.0316299759,
-0.0318400115,
-0.0419339426,
-0.0348818228,
0.0530521944,
-0.0177978743,
-0.0380607694,
0.0481743068,
-0.0100734513,
0.009177099,
-0.0065774713,
-0.0318031758,
-0.0355715267,
-0.0030060576,
0.0044463854,
-0.070827283,
-0.0106288716,
0.0184676275,
0.0226813499,
-0.0972201079,
0.0284201894,
2.350600697e-34,
0.081408903,
-0.0573093444,
0.0305754542,
-0.0182369072,
0.0450670794,
0.0294504873,
-0.0167914852,
-0.0102323387,
-0.0043542171,
-0.0719332695,
0.0255296454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05650v1 | RAUCG: Retrieval-Augmented Unsupervised Counter Narrative Generation for Hate Speech | 2023-10-09T12:01:26 | 2023-10-09T12:01:26 | Shuyu Jiang, Wenyi Tang, Xingshu Chen, Rui Tanga, Haizhou Wang, Wenxian Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Counter Narrative (CN) is a promising approach to combat online hate
speech (HS) without infringing on freedom of speech. In recent years, there has
been a growing interest in automatically generating CNs using natural language
generation techniques. However, current automatic CN generation methods mainly
rely on expert-authored datasets for training, which are time-consuming and
labor-intensive to acquire. Furthermore, these methods cannot directly obtain
and extend counter-knowledge from external statistics, facts, or examples. To
address these limitations, we propose Retrieval-Augmented Unsupervised Counter
Narrative Generation (RAUCG) to automatically expand external counter-knowledge
and map it into CNs in an unsupervised paradigm. Specifically, we first
introduce an SSF retrieval method to retrieve counter-knowledge from the
multiple perspectives of stance consistency, semantic overlap rate, and fitness
for HS. Then we design an energy-based decoding mechanism by quantizing
knowledge injection, countering and fluency constraints into differentiable
functions, to enable the model to build mappings from counter-knowledge to CNs
without expert-authored CN data. Lastly, we comprehensively evaluate model
performance in terms of language quality, toxicity, persuasiveness, relevance,
and success rate of countering HS, etc. Experimental results show that RAUCG
outperforms strong baselines on all metrics and exhibits stronger
generalization capabilities, achieving significant improvements of +2.0% in
relevance and +4.5% in success rate of countering metrics. Moreover, RAUCG
enabled GPT2 to outperform T0 in all metrics, despite the latter being
approximately eight times larger than the former. Warning: This paper may
contain offensive or upsetting content! | [
0.0724514946,
0.0855877772,
0.0037993509,
0.0283206236,
-0.0327885896,
0.0049506985,
0.0074688075,
-0.0252559837,
0.0012413253,
-0.0561572164,
0.0232597683,
-0.0201655887,
-0.0208228845,
0.0544979461,
-0.0002948262,
-0.0232296325,
0.0369983651,
0.0481546968,
0.0787133127,
-0.0359930396,
0.0265619848,
0.0201980732,
-0.0265442636,
0.0191618279,
-0.0890863836,
0.0280731749,
0.0458106101,
0.0111548752,
0.0675021708,
-0.0166772362,
0.0411656983,
0.0119138053,
0.0416351706,
0.0588510782,
0.0000018351,
-0.0559031032,
-0.0309214406,
0.0076475167,
-0.0131824585,
-0.0641511604,
0.0406034067,
-0.0297179651,
-0.001380986,
0.0293374397,
-0.0505143702,
0.0362632275,
0.0541183911,
0.0424667969,
0.080687359,
0.103081733,
-0.0010235027,
-0.0331771336,
0.0166427139,
0.0006698751,
0.0038184293,
0.0234722253,
-0.0026824633,
-0.0089726616,
-0.0841022953,
-0.0098212566,
0.0008951278,
0.0249940772,
0.0301998053,
0.0357639752,
0.0049753366,
-0.0043489314,
-0.0389675088,
-0.001184295,
-0.0117232418,
0.0562506057,
-0.009188002,
-0.0338207632,
0.0091390293,
-0.0051180772,
-0.018968299,
-0.0104597835,
-0.0419769287,
0.030460339,
-0.0289016068,
0.0345527083,
-0.0119123179,
0.0264641531,
0.029574262,
0.0329578817,
0.0314423554,
-0.0010639664,
0.003511179,
-0.0241598748,
0.0062082824,
-0.0280810948,
-0.0172512457,
0.0010472977,
0.0004042749,
0.0165741015,
-0.0217497461,
0.0256304927,
-0.0527241044,
-0.0516417585,
0.0119458297,
-0.0844150335,
0.0301952753,
0.0444802605,
0.0122362999,
0.0030636387,
-0.0011361229,
0.0248243734,
-0.014248441,
-0.0051478357,
-0.012796496,
0.0063594822,
-0.0504116714,
-0.0194551442,
-0.0321557857,
0.0034114697,
-0.024673162,
0.0140602821,
-0.0192701314,
-0.0416678376,
-0.0549798235,
0.0030467093,
-0.0312488191,
0.0628722906,
-0.0251178741,
-0.0081131496,
-0.0158362351,
0.0300162137,
-0.0549456067,
-0.0135039063,
0.0007570609,
-0.0743957534,
-0.0159271527,
0.031504456,
-0.0181966852,
-0.0241523217,
0.0316826999,
0.0563992485,
-0.0010126296,
0.0204203185,
-0.0053350716,
-0.0675364807,
-0.0273870043,
-0.0779240355,
0.0246283989,
-0.0654450655,
0.034937162,
-0.0224746726,
-0.0435111597,
-0.0690989941,
0.0274662431,
0.0243286788,
-0.0267524533,
0.0675803572,
0.003174975,
-0.0332971141,
0.0651227608,
0.0239857621,
0.0196462348,
0.0513153151,
0.0237737671,
0.0158946756,
0.0492793955,
0.0123779839,
-0.0261068475,
-0.0037038357,
0.0830526575,
0.0011149993,
-0.0335964635,
0.0315399095,
-0.0501765609,
-0.0035009147,
0.0098484522,
0.055170957,
-0.0282940641,
-0.0786163509,
0.0212553125,
0.0195425171,
-0.0584275909,
0.0042751404,
0.0680756494,
0.0456305966,
-0.0148290293,
0.0029249024,
-0.0331155136,
0.0062269322,
-0.05415022,
-0.0236903206,
0.0314518102,
0.0676769987,
-0.0116014862,
-0.0452398323,
-0.0095901052,
0.0020835013,
0.0467853993,
-0.0284199677,
0.0134748453,
0.0628233999,
-0.0252233837,
0.0085549084,
0.0294709429,
-0.0517347828,
-0.0024566196,
-0.0355754383,
-0.0040592845,
0.0432707891,
0.0368226133,
0.0162046403,
-0.0114044147,
-0.038824711,
-0.0342165157,
0.0569262803,
0.0299540367,
-0.0018250078,
-0.0013191416,
-0.0284752455,
-0.0230650902,
-0.0452391803,
0.021538157,
0.0377675928,
0.040664956,
0.0174149405,
0.0444151387,
0.027999768,
-0.0380920283,
0.019277269,
0.0359494761,
-0.0597382933,
0.0099231806,
0.0139959706,
0.0558038205,
0.0462313779,
-0.0254648868,
-0.0078211166,
0.0233442225,
-0.0138971116,
-0.0525856651,
-0.0000673381,
-0.0344988964,
-0.0527808964,
0.0234808344,
-0.0630694404,
-0.0130787827,
0.0746249408,
-0.000803214,
0.0084525077,
0.0797015354,
-0.0448048338,
0.0158915147,
-0.0581333078,
-0.0602427609,
-0.0130858142,
-0.0039944723,
-0.0262548514,
0.0977796614,
-0.0114138387,
0.0106996484,
0.0316415578,
-0.0498384535,
0.0511183441,
-0.0065806662,
-0.0161701199,
-0.0273691975,
-0.0382323638,
0.0311999433,
0.0425730087,
0.0071449941,
-0.026948614,
0.0229738597,
-0.0754043236,
0.0106616179,
-0.0285119154,
-0.010971101,
0.0273886044,
-0.0284941476,
-0.0054484354,
0.0161651671,
-0.0376446769,
-0.0565817766,
0.0453670844,
0.0189636908,
-0.0001182361,
-0.025198197,
-0.0151811782,
-0.0328936502,
0.0015943303,
-0.013563578,
0.0279348921,
0.0008922135,
-0.033826936,
0.0459175035,
-0.0102080936,
-0.0587353855,
0.0142585486,
-0.03211556,
-0.0478619821,
0.0579724126,
0.0235407315,
-0.0017833856,
0.0145479441,
0.0736942589,
0.054557588,
0.0253532361,
0.0060255271,
-0.0532525182,
0.0056597185,
-0.0419320092,
0.0027125541,
-0.0262556393,
-0.0233344082,
0.0209306423,
0.0609202348,
0.0802808926,
-0.0045556566,
-0.0769817308,
0.0527222902,
-0.0272869058,
-0.0560067743,
-0.0363828652,
-0.0376318395,
-0.0162752047,
-0.0045757303,
-0.038871143,
-0.05358411,
0.0916002244,
-0.0058023692,
0.0306419786,
-0.0389804803,
-0.011583712,
0.0300014578,
0.0377131887,
0.0046370295,
0.0541080385,
-0.0154924756,
0.019204814,
0.0115036061,
-0.0343303457,
0.0464888178,
-0.0443784781,
-0.0692112595,
-0.0263826493,
0.00909549,
0.0286086481,
-0.0195052121,
-0.081591852,
-0.0504371151,
-0.0212223828,
-0.0340925939,
0.0160930697,
-0.0155268442,
-0.0310279354,
-0.014735478,
0.0543674529,
0.006094683,
-0.0030427645,
-0.013406218,
0.0341383666,
-0.0062501361,
0.0334816948,
0.003613018,
0.0389341451,
-0.0035264192,
-0.0253173355,
0.0779574439,
-0.0274991859,
0.0040937862,
0.0023223232,
-0.0031820766,
-0.0200010967,
0.0151288547,
0.0304774307,
-0.0004592779,
0.0274956729,
-0.0115974173,
-0.0086953659,
0.0820957199,
0.0252441876,
0.0277285688,
-0.0083357263,
0.0020441024,
0.012513143,
0.0072187968,
-0.0191644169,
-0.0803903192,
-0.0024191297,
-0.0217049234,
0.0474819764,
-0.0956597552,
-0.0350075811,
-0.0501839519,
-0.0863891691,
0.00883759,
0.0110521195,
-0.0181104429,
-0.036810156,
-0.0083345156,
-0.0113123842,
0.0262164455,
-0.0076204995,
-0.0062684012,
0.0423975736,
0.0147637203,
0.0001888441,
-0.0438241996,
-0.0213440787,
-0.0184310582,
-0.0036881065,
0.0344030969,
0.0555975251,
0.0434805825,
0.005905706,
0.0096635651,
0.0019641102,
-0.0014714187,
-0.0063145272,
-0.0584747493,
0.0455651432,
-0.0323999785,
-0.0164004955,
-0.0419017896,
0.0704346523,
0.0057021338,
-0.0302577782,
0.0086307833,
0.0508518852,
0.0088956114,
-0.0083961198,
-0.0535549372,
0.0482130833,
0.0573482625,
0.10233666,
0.0236692764,
-0.0179322604,
0.0379853286,
-0.0663278997,
0.0213282779,
-0.0777231753,
-0.0643519536,
-0.0232973229,
0.0166423414,
0.0175119266,
-0.0530616231,
-0.0453506038,
-0.0209082067,
0.0395650081,
-0.0230798293,
-0.0277685951,
-0.0132256132,
-0.0233249888,
-0.0800199434,
-0.0070760897,
-0.0204610992,
0.030514054,
0.0070821061,
-0.0255474038,
-0.0249476098,
-0.037486203,
-0.0453690402,
0.0486401655,
-0.0330171473,
-0.0705655143,
0.0091818888,
0.0645544901,
0.0214634109,
0.0384305753,
0.0138384029,
-0.0237629861,
0.0627868697,
0.0785869956,
-0.0419118516,
0.0056641013,
0.0396184772,
0.0046591908,
0.0202105902,
0.0022608337,
-0.0082358476,
0.0185674094,
0.0297280811,
0.0440504998,
-0.0299361199,
0.006640851,
0.0341663845,
0.002554382,
0.0357178971,
-0.014700342,
-0.0316331759,
-0.0308274068,
-0.0220410321,
-0.0373725519,
-0.0524587817,
-0.0327624492,
0.0098174699,
0.0130623523,
-0.0026929784,
-0.0197233446,
0.0110607333,
-0.060961999,
0.038872648,
-0.019920744,
-0.011129613,
0.0206080265,
0.0366548598,
0.0071124495,
0.0006125915,
-0.0266761687,
0.034610033,
-0.006260396,
-0.0133197205,
-0.0089972802,
0.0079371678,
0.0381837338,
-0.0092495717,
0.0405766182,
-0.0295403358,
-0.0147141609,
-0.0088491812,
-0.0571198836,
-0.039594356,
-0.0174074303,
0.0070351847,
0.055574894,
-0.0039459625,
-0.0118601602,
-0.0049039084,
0.0083007729,
-0.0075992914,
-0.048909992,
0.0149697587,
0.0248306822,
-0.0379043967,
0.0228313822,
0.0341517441,
-0.008727517,
0.0472543351,
0.0261515081,
-0.0452652089,
-0.0413661264,
-0.0314867944,
-0.0100886105,
0.0499160327,
0.0222020987,
0.0075162174,
-0.059951134,
-0.0287904497,
0.0192138478,
-0.0058419826,
0.0068410514,
0.0091981255,
0.0166733135,
0.057856407,
-0.0209422279,
-0.006485837,
-0.0044103661,
0.026381392,
-0.0068413317,
-0.0361079462,
0.0086401552,
-6.030045043e-33,
-0.0100105945,
-0.0539934859,
0.0025801093,
-0.0305214822,
0.0001820947,
-0.0130734527,
0.0090042409,
0.0137940794,
-0.0142752836,
0.0454491191,
0.0368837677,
0.0058440831,
0.0040598828,
0.0361695848,
-0.0587170944,
0.0222657435,
0.0400675163,
-0.0119939623,
-0.0363002643,
0.0219106432,
0.0760840997,
0.0068412889,
0.0318364799,
-0.076416336,
0.0329761058,
-0.0082195736,
-0.0119305141,
0.0052031833,
0.0033577287,
0.0419021621,
-0.0164091643,
0.0871867388,
0.0282541197,
0.0025439896,
-0.0048839743,
0.0275391024,
-0.0338408239,
-0.0252853166,
0.0420734659,
-0.0423343554,
0.0139498236,
-0.0022481582,
0.019726729,
-0.0055797342,
-0.0384748094,
-0.0092597017,
0.0147878723,
-0.0153930523,
0.0282751992,
-0.052186925,
-0.0846690163,
0.0229629446,
-0.0332914069,
-0.0108963978,
-0.0513352603,
0.04685314,
0.039875906,
0.0017089372,
-0.0694215521,
0.0498882905,
-0.0277503338,
-0.0105492128,
0.0263545755,
-0.036916554,
0.00353465,
0.088090919,
-0.0039734114,
-0.003117007,
-0.0681567788,
0.0213479344,
0.0248149484,
0.0295847226,
0.053388156,
0.0970887765,
0.0402302481,
-0.0687845796,
-0.0674392283,
0.0058875415,
0.0178769343,
0.0039660195,
0.0072137155,
-0.0223439671,
-0.0498934314,
-0.0232642759,
-0.0353826918,
-0.0564664118,
-0.0128399972,
-0.0274546221,
0.0360174812,
0.0175113976,
-0.0476032831,
-0.022842247,
0.0144573059,
-0.0035344118,
0.0634250045,
0.0785691291,
-0.0214919355,
-0.0214233268,
0.0313108787,
0.0523061454,
-0.0559888557,
0.025852127,
0.0455203429,
-0.0092058536,
0.0100843133,
-0.0190038905,
0.0451652631,
0.0338244587,
-0.0420198217,
0.0349585786,
-0.0132631166,
0.0662609562,
-0.0275065266,
-0.020439757,
0.0121509861,
0.0385453627,
-0.0263638981,
-0.0157835204,
0.0075337081,
-0.0291825235,
-0.0236497298,
0.0155760292,
-0.0072654644,
0.0149820177,
-0.0094920481,
0.0041090413,
-0.0006438557,
0.0050666793,
0.0148458565,
-0.0850835666,
0.0091908723,
-0.0083732763,
2.619e-7,
-0.0092303902,
0.0113667473,
0.0302091446,
-0.0003703782,
0.0045794388,
0.0399717577,
0.0451182425,
0.0264447443,
-0.0251561236,
-0.0644917488,
-0.0342497975,
0.0716884732,
0.0141170314,
0.0554805435,
0.0089703985,
0.0040176064,
-0.0556752048,
-0.0247711651,
-0.0600564629,
0.0057941009,
0.03400838,
0.0493961796,
0.0373139307,
-0.0179877039,
-0.0104935365,
-0.0111702858,
0.0593208447,
-0.0118958224,
-0.0242005922,
-0.0208034012,
0.0423621349,
0.0058810934,
0.0088173011,
-0.0320670605,
-0.0096373595,
0.017012015,
-0.0125832735,
0.0400320552,
0.0377945974,
-0.0612031929,
0.0012506885,
0.0063120453,
-0.0235294383,
-0.0224573575,
0.0373928994,
-0.0267605055,
-0.0094093699,
-0.0365018286,
-0.0423231237,
0.0232902635,
0.0139740221,
-0.0296570454,
-0.0429435559,
-0.0167548675,
0.0375068113,
0.0315417722,
0.0362606309,
-0.0616853051,
-0.0039301678,
0.0088471221,
-0.0405148454,
-0.0214078892,
-0.0197803732,
-0.015353322,
0.0304523632,
0.0348710939,
0.0457733348,
2.290951705e-34,
0.0526339971,
-0.0142730558,
-0.002051601,
-0.0895226225,
0.0462498292,
0.0442219786,
-0.0211028904,
-0.0077371905,
0.061175622,
-0.0234913994,
-0.0302418955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05634v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05634v2 | Towards Verifiable Generation: A Benchmark for Knowledge-aware Language Model Attribution | 2023-10-09T11:45:59 | 2024-05-23T04:51:35 | Xinze Li, Yixin Cao, Liangming Pan, Yubo Ma, Aixin Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although achieving great success, Large Language Models (LLMs) usually suffer
from unreliable hallucinations. Although language attribution can be a
potential solution, there are no suitable benchmarks and evaluation metrics to
attribute LLMs to structured knowledge. In this paper, we define a new task of
Knowledge-aware Language Model Attribution (KaLMA) that improves upon three
core concerns with conventional attributed LMs. First, we extend attribution
source from unstructured texts to Knowledge Graph (KG), whose rich structures
benefit both the attribution performance and working scenarios. Second, we
propose a new ``Conscious Incompetence" setting considering the incomplete
knowledge repository, where the model identifies the need for supporting
knowledge beyond the provided KG. Third, we propose a comprehensive automatic
evaluation metric encompassing text quality, citation quality, and text
citation alignment. To implement the above innovations, we build a dataset in
biography domain BioKaLMA via evolutionary question generation strategy, to
control the question complexity and necessary knowledge to the answer. For
evaluation, we develop a baseline solution and demonstrate the room for
improvement in LLMs' citation generation, emphasizing the importance of
incorporating the "Conscious Incompetence" setting, and the critical role of
retrieval accuracy. | [
0.0784070343,
0.0161257945,
-0.0200994536,
0.0386885442,
-0.046547424,
-0.0034632052,
0.0016167889,
-0.0005658719,
0.0426383428,
-0.0347552523,
0.0264833607,
0.019265769,
-0.017670745,
-0.0128347687,
0.0585888289,
0.0289628953,
0.0009849194,
0.0089120148,
0.0617422163,
-0.0198471453,
-0.0046620537,
0.0183457062,
0.0188393313,
0.0065689208,
0.0207202714,
-0.0073563326,
0.0138406754,
-0.0081930002,
0.0425482653,
-0.013124872,
0.0102570653,
0.034226384,
-0.0474732555,
0.0412969477,
0.0000020543,
-0.0493488833,
-0.0027002487,
0.0133661479,
-0.0333942138,
-0.0077243499,
0.0388798527,
0.0268060621,
0.0305723995,
-0.00429249,
-0.0268568099,
0.0186111461,
-0.0088676447,
0.0126734655,
0.0575107262,
0.0456545427,
0.0021584821,
-0.0341717415,
0.0504312404,
0.0055230451,
0.0152137466,
-0.0158113204,
0.0283853561,
0.0629046857,
-0.007096882,
0.046523422,
0.0341556855,
0.0736509562,
-0.0243858621,
-0.0404694118,
0.0835275576,
-0.0220681708,
-0.0228221938,
0.0059535028,
0.0413032882,
0.0675278679,
0.0332899392,
-0.0491745435,
0.051772017,
0.0037830246,
0.0141692162,
0.0618855171,
-0.0321129523,
0.0461877361,
-0.0344006047,
-0.0412104204,
0.0204919837,
-0.0394884199,
0.0546940379,
0.0072451066,
0.0352696851,
0.0798565075,
0.020843992,
-0.0184985753,
-0.0198750347,
-0.0187622979,
-0.0164940171,
-0.0822892562,
-0.0069950367,
0.0427988023,
0.000898766,
0.019730961,
-0.0040406268,
-0.0155373104,
0.04464655,
-0.0302583091,
0.0051023997,
-0.0337880217,
0.0296850279,
0.048957739,
-0.0307827368,
0.0322997831,
-0.0272966679,
-0.0060583446,
-0.0055861832,
-0.0334873497,
-0.0719901472,
-0.0291207116,
-0.0182514209,
0.0012548127,
0.0166518539,
0.0151946144,
-0.033962708,
0.0356078446,
-0.0210304409,
0.0276838113,
0.0071491478,
0.001676272,
-0.0010381233,
-0.0161949303,
-0.0639967248,
-0.0015958148,
0.0060793124,
0.0390706696,
0.0073129958,
-0.015445618,
-0.0012887886,
0.0268326625,
0.0176840555,
-0.0235847179,
0.0070008226,
0.0423475131,
0.031830851,
0.0056998944,
-0.062846072,
-0.068385154,
-0.0087121651,
-0.0492245257,
-0.0257525761,
-0.0726095438,
0.0364881121,
0.0355820917,
-0.048350729,
-0.0656351745,
0.0136434315,
0.0217024088,
-0.0596626736,
0.0171254463,
-0.057014063,
0.0453003459,
0.0551127903,
-0.0067815552,
0.0018241743,
0.0123654334,
0.0544727296,
-0.0108246878,
0.0292547625,
0.0457457006,
0.0211848691,
-0.0027258417,
0.056722533,
0.0394997932,
0.0347662903,
0.0178036056,
-0.0231375694,
0.0222021565,
0.0271184221,
0.0717931613,
-0.0195421539,
0.0313391872,
0.045085296,
-0.0138160242,
-0.0118900603,
0.0489241034,
0.0598343462,
0.0048662904,
0.0161730368,
-0.0257431101,
-0.0097343298,
0.0108243115,
-0.0248277914,
0.0084240884,
0.0081067979,
0.0103828777,
-0.0012318889,
-0.0075975014,
-0.0022528032,
0.0294113085,
0.0000655892,
0.0063705323,
0.0175754577,
0.0016714076,
-0.0349651761,
0.0736098513,
-0.0117443921,
-0.0491764359,
0.0239720643,
-0.0274633598,
0.0193884689,
0.042352587,
0.0755304992,
0.0082777534,
-0.0239015725,
-0.0102294432,
-0.0090658758,
0.0397302732,
-0.0162298083,
-0.0504104532,
-0.0270269029,
-0.0334177688,
-0.0445586815,
-0.0052457368,
0.0053682872,
-0.0283185523,
0.0106138233,
0.0214068778,
0.0560196228,
-0.0881587192,
-0.0618633591,
0.0293098353,
-0.0638271347,
-0.0054896413,
-0.0370040275,
-0.0119059794,
0.0270176996,
0.0368727073,
0.0041855546,
0.020210566,
0.0164716206,
-0.0244553667,
-0.009403375,
0.0284925979,
0.0347548872,
-0.0197841953,
0.0431400277,
-0.0281956326,
-0.0011251208,
-0.0146029741,
-0.0043242886,
-0.0773933604,
0.0230433922,
-0.04118881,
0.0280687399,
-0.0409078375,
0.0411361158,
-0.0293161236,
-0.0411450192,
-0.0334857181,
0.1113883704,
-0.0036481523,
0.0407282524,
0.0338344015,
-0.0152478842,
0.0505948104,
-0.034107741,
-0.032453768,
-0.0539220236,
0.0039221169,
0.023080226,
0.0376958102,
-0.0250296686,
-0.0628034323,
-0.0062268972,
-0.0445104204,
0.0406394489,
-0.0039276527,
0.0392125547,
0.0105483448,
-0.0090068234,
0.0067092553,
0.011578382,
-0.072767593,
0.0062856041,
0.0148877632,
-0.0192532297,
0.0412789732,
0.0217254031,
0.000480233,
-0.0239765383,
0.015663255,
-0.0178442802,
0.0395215414,
0.0604010597,
0.0312064085,
-0.0634467602,
0.0506653413,
-0.0745733902,
-0.0241780505,
-0.0230739713,
0.0099886777,
-0.0074136723,
0.0079481388,
0.0242868885,
0.0124102291,
0.0008856629,
-0.0299842395,
0.0292320773,
0.0039262916,
-0.0393005349,
-0.0066452818,
-0.0316880308,
-0.0129420161,
-0.0114054019,
-0.0469821207,
0.0226061642,
0.0126416348,
0.0060957368,
-0.0418933183,
-0.041641973,
0.0223595612,
-0.0031770382,
0.0144380024,
-0.0106797209,
-0.0296382923,
0.0052256458,
0.0480341204,
-0.031344831,
-0.0279566869,
0.0402899869,
-0.0359309427,
0.055811964,
-0.000945502,
0.014095217,
-0.0219234265,
0.0564774275,
0.0173624642,
0.0181041546,
0.0429871827,
0.0239056591,
-0.0734868199,
0.0180775765,
0.0662277117,
-0.0370983742,
-0.0144295078,
-0.0295313019,
0.0354959182,
0.0283106007,
0.023779599,
-0.0396748334,
-0.005880442,
-0.0083310511,
0.0187049545,
0.0506777689,
-0.0039206129,
-0.0156956911,
-0.0275916923,
0.064970918,
-0.0223010909,
-0.0025363793,
-0.0032933885,
-0.0195061322,
0.0466550179,
0.0663386956,
-0.0062214499,
0.0565992408,
-0.0278480966,
-0.0349481665,
0.0176421907,
0.0418117009,
0.0107296342,
0.0237133317,
-0.0375947617,
-0.0066370619,
-0.0611839145,
-0.0505224392,
-0.0144263851,
0.0425293744,
-0.0545559675,
0.0040802564,
0.097534962,
0.0297093578,
-0.0497994609,
-0.0320638753,
-0.0500751734,
-0.0105744302,
0.0186187513,
0.0321415029,
-0.1008534804,
0.0238864645,
-0.0326376297,
0.0495336056,
-0.0298784003,
-0.0532413945,
-0.0029695088,
-0.1007118523,
-0.001344603,
0.0045434427,
0.0025832262,
-0.0018319554,
-0.0313778333,
-0.0088517563,
-0.0066658687,
-0.0427760817,
0.0403129086,
0.013559686,
0.0215043128,
0.0150889596,
0.0181262195,
-0.0634636059,
0.0295190457,
-0.0752349868,
0.0715169907,
0.0222836193,
0.0752899572,
0.0187689066,
-0.0341495015,
-0.0284700114,
-0.0424475968,
-0.0564260259,
0.0186516754,
0.0220599957,
-0.0076274602,
0.0120052416,
-0.0420368388,
0.0143228779,
-0.0133969011,
0.00375009,
0.0323885866,
0.073918201,
0.0103622591,
-0.0075468994,
-0.023390675,
-0.0338469408,
0.0128451427,
0.0997204259,
0.0123147313,
0.0189179033,
-0.0299958549,
-0.0027229018,
0.0276859477,
-0.0508532301,
-0.0390102044,
0.0644550547,
-0.0485499091,
0.0060809483,
-0.1136554554,
-0.046060916,
-0.0143485898,
-0.0093118874,
0.0463058949,
0.045090761,
0.0351025835,
-0.0502855927,
-0.0751890764,
-0.0093871569,
-0.0672954917,
-0.0110313389,
-0.0105410982,
0.0009942268,
0.0187181924,
-0.0235871319,
0.0128670698,
0.0318594649,
-0.0256863981,
-0.0468547121,
-0.0092604803,
0.0336309075,
0.0241590273,
0.0568301715,
-0.0373516157,
-0.0444162712,
0.0720980465,
0.0190566983,
-0.0134267053,
0.0128881941,
-0.0297915656,
-0.0312673636,
-0.0284021646,
0.0442724228,
-0.0808448344,
-0.0016463753,
-0.0301911347,
0.0398317575,
-0.0322021469,
-0.0419989154,
-0.0031450531,
0.054891061,
-0.0219345056,
-0.0340290777,
-0.0019042167,
-0.0059847366,
-0.0062694359,
-0.0371543318,
-0.0401903465,
-0.0145554207,
0.0065826639,
0.0078463312,
0.003002668,
0.0248013046,
-0.0027783695,
-0.0227665585,
0.0676499307,
-0.0282686669,
-0.0037144807,
-0.0163389668,
0.0221215244,
0.0006294392,
-0.0236434788,
-0.0089639556,
-0.0191564392,
-0.0032713735,
0.0472508594,
0.0097239912,
0.0273274183,
0.0271863788,
-0.03213742,
0.0162305385,
-0.0019063563,
-0.08310958,
0.026791364,
-0.0155071095,
-0.0226661172,
0.0293427315,
0.0021221917,
0.0846861303,
-0.0154711194,
-0.0292847846,
-0.0096170818,
0.0456778444,
0.0117097292,
-0.0152315088,
0.0089074923,
0.0138948169,
-0.0444141552,
0.0340081379,
0.0579417273,
0.0814544186,
0.0522809997,
-0.0424697623,
-0.0566485412,
-0.0264932942,
-0.0525623411,
-0.0501227751,
-0.0000551326,
0.005097182,
-0.0225552041,
-0.0732512623,
-0.0739068463,
0.0275371075,
0.0207135845,
0.0131343184,
-0.0321710631,
0.0201239586,
0.0409307778,
0.0150509048,
-0.045319628,
-0.0604447126,
0.045556359,
-0.0537785776,
-0.0129836444,
0.0054712114,
-6.310951459e-33,
-0.0280960407,
-0.0662456006,
0.0407808125,
-0.0126702879,
-0.0470560789,
-0.0115601774,
-0.0750280544,
-0.0269005224,
-0.0407595746,
0.0233307574,
-0.0188721437,
0.0195080694,
-0.0102919117,
0.0024558487,
0.0199854802,
0.0159459338,
0.0133832637,
0.0164713897,
-0.0262181889,
0.0615758225,
0.0647354275,
-0.004330318,
0.0132169798,
-0.0753152221,
0.0995422676,
-0.0637037829,
-0.0166073591,
0.0124445399,
0.0019324013,
0.0525168553,
-0.0182099827,
0.0196668208,
0.0218711644,
-0.0425920822,
0.0267035365,
-0.052131664,
-0.0818738192,
-0.0183784086,
0.0342417657,
-0.0172508229,
-0.0228588432,
-0.0644176081,
0.0635561422,
-0.0111859292,
0.0114184832,
0.0101500088,
0.0736865103,
-0.0352792479,
-0.0222881716,
-0.0614091493,
-0.0286926404,
0.0244564246,
0.0181697607,
0.0141500868,
-0.0272724871,
-0.0074092643,
-0.0044710319,
0.0103042768,
-0.0447252095,
0.0165286474,
-0.0127055766,
-0.0065825917,
0.0458982773,
-0.0007580931,
0.0242327917,
0.0293548033,
-0.0361668095,
0.0187181272,
-0.0256116316,
0.0026226945,
-0.0151401786,
0.0675823092,
0.0437694453,
0.0922616273,
-0.0436928682,
-0.014827868,
-0.0558199584,
0.0374534838,
-0.0098975683,
0.0007252141,
-0.0023809476,
-0.0298323464,
-0.0353408232,
-0.0341829248,
-0.0380107202,
-0.035846103,
-0.019677775,
-0.0341147818,
0.0037678289,
-0.0347553007,
-0.0547426715,
-0.0124483323,
-0.0025008698,
-0.0668589622,
-0.0109247807,
0.0395171419,
-0.036438372,
0.0228033885,
0.0090361079,
0.0255838241,
-0.0558868535,
-0.0083235214,
-0.0006048168,
0.0370706469,
0.0255614165,
0.0511905588,
0.0193582047,
0.0012385966,
-0.0193901509,
0.0021826965,
-0.0085843066,
-0.0004230919,
-0.0372870453,
-0.0334358886,
0.0048659891,
0.0473875217,
0.0257071089,
-0.0167612433,
0.0890630037,
0.0293271933,
-0.009068761,
0.0502048805,
0.0088564828,
0.0208737161,
-0.0400822833,
0.018084066,
-0.0170979444,
0.0588201992,
-0.033555422,
-0.0325769596,
0.0084179398,
-0.0154086463,
2.871e-7,
0.0525865257,
0.0272202007,
-0.0103732524,
0.0032910656,
-0.0005391429,
0.0187679734,
0.008163671,
0.0160059966,
-0.008040023,
-0.0396990329,
0.0186490826,
0.002806216,
0.0149522182,
0.0119390907,
-0.0849376395,
-0.0090153925,
-0.0408395343,
-0.0464048646,
-0.0237901155,
0.0105299586,
0.0057986677,
-0.0035158489,
0.0291508678,
-0.0105292182,
-0.0416099504,
-0.0547993742,
0.0638667196,
0.0334412865,
-0.0240230393,
0.0605353937,
0.0735604465,
0.0380576104,
-0.0071188868,
0.0382569768,
-0.021069929,
0.0264732968,
-0.0056568463,
0.0400230959,
0.0204755273,
-0.0144614317,
0.0088404268,
-0.0432511307,
0.0537361056,
-0.0766236112,
0.0489502922,
0.016299298,
-0.0173015986,
0.001143411,
-0.0676785633,
-0.0088257361,
-0.032113038,
-0.0045377598,
-0.0107883392,
0.0149730463,
-0.0345375463,
0.0119698364,
0.0018699327,
-0.0538035594,
-0.0213505886,
0.0096879564,
-0.0080067916,
-0.0870589614,
0.0066031506,
-0.0294498578,
0.0087710321,
-0.0774616227,
0.0653967932,
2.300429588e-34,
0.005614026,
0.0133831985,
-0.0063144509,
-0.0200793426,
0.0149442907,
0.0101749189,
-0.0355756991,
0.0330559909,
0.0248901099,
-0.0609410703,
0.0098802382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05628v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05628v3 | Glitter or Gold? Deriving Structured Insights from Sustainability Reports via Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T11:34:41 | 2024-01-16T14:02:07 | Marco Bronzini, Carlo Nicolini, Bruno Lepri, Andrea Passerini, Jacopo Staiano | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.CY | Over the last decade, several regulatory bodies have started requiring the
disclosure of non-financial information from publicly listed companies, in
light of the investors' increasing attention to Environmental, Social, and
Governance (ESG) issues. Publicly released information on sustainability
practices is often disclosed in diverse, unstructured, and multi-modal
documentation. This poses a challenge in efficiently gathering and aligning the
data into a unified framework to derive insights related to Corporate Social
Responsibility (CSR). Thus, using Information Extraction (IE) methods becomes
an intuitive choice for delivering insightful and actionable data to
stakeholders. In this study, we employ Large Language Models (LLMs), In-Context
Learning, and the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) paradigm to extract
structured insights related to ESG aspects from companies' sustainability
reports. We then leverage graph-based representations to conduct statistical
analyses concerning the extracted insights. These analyses revealed that ESG
criteria cover a wide range of topics, exceeding 500, often beyond those
considered in existing categorizations, and are addressed by companies through
a variety of initiatives. Moreover, disclosure similarities emerged among
companies from the same region or sector, validating ongoing hypotheses in the
ESG literature. Lastly, by incorporating additional company attributes into our
analyses, we investigated which factors impact the most on companies' ESG
ratings, showing that ESG disclosure affects the obtained ratings more than
other financial or company data. | [
0.0169259049,
0.0494562835,
0.0013620945,
0.0573146269,
-0.0138831846,
-0.0130458139,
-0.0259212758,
0.0293298606,
-0.0170176625,
-0.0746256337,
0.009041165,
0.0592025183,
-0.019327458,
0.0434462763,
0.0179892071,
0.0156972278,
0.0188503228,
0.0249273162,
0.0459302664,
0.0174557194,
0.0221908353,
0.0085836016,
0.0654738396,
0.0112734763,
0.0163620841,
0.0022847706,
-0.0112828128,
0.0020305184,
0.0061165867,
-0.0517003611,
-0.018812906,
0.0037253313,
0.0433911532,
0.0389089808,
0.0000020948,
-0.0695627406,
-0.0721548796,
0.0138786901,
0.0334962718,
0.0203588717,
0.0593872704,
-0.0702719837,
0.0286262166,
-0.0039899382,
-0.0384130366,
-0.0539177321,
0.0275446605,
0.0303735882,
0.0422841944,
0.0214559678,
-0.0056672785,
-0.0400195383,
-0.0252828635,
-0.0388578735,
0.008919999,
-0.0043729329,
0.0298408326,
0.0236216858,
-0.0371473543,
0.0005605728,
-0.0189352296,
0.0611210428,
-0.0177683681,
-0.0356988981,
0.0443061218,
-0.0001487997,
0.0020369783,
0.0139127206,
0.0023983154,
0.054801587,
0.0626673773,
0.0341249071,
-0.0019555876,
-0.0302065276,
0.0324786343,
0.0230493657,
-0.0318287946,
0.035706345,
-0.0293505695,
0.0204783473,
0.0186689105,
-0.0037538598,
0.0048820544,
0.0279973559,
-0.0272024367,
0.0517833121,
-0.0288164448,
-0.0199701786,
0.0331101269,
0.0164912958,
0.0094744731,
-0.0161422137,
-0.0348373093,
0.006608,
0.0071699899,
0.0433682911,
0.022723807,
-0.0286169648,
0.0312377084,
-0.0238070637,
0.0431387909,
-0.0077492688,
0.0379189961,
0.0444404557,
0.0178742353,
0.0206111539,
0.0038192191,
-0.0065773614,
-0.0439700186,
0.0125887198,
-0.041323524,
-0.0138587765,
0.0011538605,
0.0719653741,
-0.0616430342,
-0.0131581621,
-0.0484072417,
0.0202690251,
-0.0314488932,
0.0379484966,
0.007580121,
-0.0101944283,
0.0246877316,
-0.0223913658,
0.0016457044,
0.007495963,
-0.0180589557,
-0.0033409772,
0.0038059149,
-0.0000012143,
0.0322863944,
0.0133010941,
0.0361481942,
0.0083212946,
-0.0048414394,
0.0572186969,
0.0341800153,
-0.0106979869,
-0.047209695,
-0.0417290702,
-0.0037815815,
-0.0304015037,
-0.0103940917,
-0.0396741517,
0.0158548392,
0.005487544,
-0.0330936238,
-0.050644923,
0.0201905351,
-0.0170394536,
-0.0159893055,
0.0262408238,
-0.0382361785,
-0.0195242185,
0.0168441534,
-0.0026149955,
0.0305539742,
0.0872289762,
0.0351475887,
-0.0139902718,
0.0624764152,
-0.0097543402,
-0.0230950434,
0.0158059299,
-0.0010480286,
-0.0101151969,
0.0061229216,
0.0139006488,
-0.0071692341,
-0.048493024,
0.0446743332,
0.0377515629,
-0.0162379276,
0.0148850773,
0.0505324081,
0.0438393466,
0.0435060486,
0.0142164966,
0.00751187,
0.0272933375,
0.00546249,
-0.0212101005,
0.0357098244,
-0.0326230712,
0.0371186212,
0.0668135062,
-0.0013351201,
0.0164996684,
0.0106482478,
-0.062450625,
-0.0181325898,
0.0321845785,
0.0119803129,
0.0006420973,
0.0258650873,
-0.0045082131,
-0.0688389242,
0.0436691344,
0.0328143984,
-0.061778795,
0.0209418144,
-0.0041126772,
0.0677104145,
0.0802564323,
0.021512812,
-0.0221488979,
0.0481751338,
-0.009856822,
-0.0480908379,
-0.0037560801,
0.0062725605,
-0.0099093504,
-0.0321800001,
0.002090052,
-0.0447065756,
-0.0158603415,
0.0120822135,
0.0110347783,
-0.0321541876,
0.0156746078,
0.0258283764,
-0.0719422176,
-0.0381967165,
0.0519161485,
0.0435662754,
-0.0219673235,
0.0157804303,
-0.0146562904,
-0.0027993564,
0.0489020012,
-0.0044200472,
0.0289635826,
0.0262531731,
-0.0294526462,
-0.0341183655,
-0.0027321044,
0.0080290083,
0.0126486793,
-0.0033024836,
-0.0353727527,
0.0166179687,
0.004511259,
-0.0257851817,
0.0300616864,
-0.0370315723,
-0.0092920577,
0.0546953343,
-0.0458411947,
-0.0319393836,
0.0007100709,
0.0130581362,
-0.0258665588,
0.0931385532,
-0.0120869447,
0.0227133557,
-0.0571392067,
-0.0260829385,
-0.0090096947,
-0.0370938964,
0.059265282,
0.0515192933,
-0.0340641625,
0.0212189425,
0.089467369,
0.0104090283,
-0.0322092846,
0.001986484,
-0.0992716774,
-0.0208358075,
-0.0108951563,
0.022412505,
0.0062577929,
-0.0093807727,
-0.0174289886,
0.048640497,
-0.0065345438,
-0.0252438355,
-0.0247475728,
0.0171710141,
0.0396422073,
0.0340369567,
-0.0115431435,
-0.0446979925,
-0.0143006789,
-0.0073973071,
0.0864137486,
0.0809516758,
-0.0814161375,
-0.0484532751,
0.0811818987,
-0.0250989366,
-0.0152871925,
-0.0068160752,
0.0327037461,
0.003640173,
-0.0129734818,
-0.0085877851,
0.0214815307,
0.0573920794,
0.0868365243,
-0.0297600515,
-0.0200699642,
-0.06161898,
-0.0133833541,
-0.0281286109,
-0.0113166142,
-0.0212211795,
-0.0341068096,
0.0899674147,
-0.040402405,
-0.021550281,
0.0031461359,
-0.0127179381,
0.0378921255,
-0.0387690291,
-0.0270495564,
-0.060266979,
-0.0449152961,
0.0088797314,
0.0428632125,
0.0197928566,
-0.0606260113,
0.0139964931,
-0.0027599654,
0.0078571727,
-0.0283879694,
0.0048858905,
-0.0557615645,
0.0746894106,
-0.0385481603,
0.0289329607,
-0.0115392525,
-0.0241622571,
0.0012264727,
-0.0265869107,
0.0549607165,
-0.0455028005,
0.0336866528,
0.0002653349,
0.0340560451,
0.0032573603,
-0.0275500063,
-0.0134699922,
-0.0566016175,
0.0196002685,
0.0378609821,
0.0497767366,
0.0009139697,
-0.0559145212,
0.021727331,
0.0117981937,
-0.0329666324,
0.0091586653,
-0.0273919143,
0.00878633,
0.0142560173,
0.0491105467,
-0.0502030551,
0.0343393832,
-0.0544458367,
0.0182328299,
0.0350742042,
0.0268995147,
-0.0078268666,
0.0059373872,
-0.0251199845,
-0.0202349685,
-0.0073601748,
0.0363535509,
-0.0007693507,
-0.0059400839,
-0.0437200256,
0.0054672211,
0.066737175,
0.0060848836,
-0.0214204974,
0.0175670069,
0.0351623595,
0.0156009896,
-0.003444379,
0.0399996452,
-0.0665181875,
0.006657898,
-0.0177542288,
0.028345868,
-0.0061909384,
-0.0531763807,
-0.0476090983,
-0.1165346578,
0.0613684356,
0.0143755367,
-0.0330298916,
-0.0607210472,
-0.043297831,
-0.0170113705,
-0.0289929565,
-0.0220836848,
-0.0044579571,
-0.0556978509,
-0.0154682631,
0.0223193746,
-0.0335436091,
-0.0247739423,
-0.0285177566,
-0.0076333899,
-0.0724951625,
0.0592291728,
0.0088959932,
-0.024075957,
0.0127425957,
0.0090217004,
-0.0259860549,
-0.0215696525,
-0.0048418539,
0.0017515343,
-0.0220658761,
0.0060373363,
0.0069780303,
0.0355664454,
-0.0188076254,
0.0019653263,
0.0223460216,
0.052676335,
0.0232274421,
-0.0247697886,
0.0309148394,
0.0209429059,
0.016388569,
0.0624532104,
-0.0149093326,
-0.0024880255,
-0.0071334927,
-0.0704619735,
0.0146317985,
-0.0006009081,
0.0279820468,
0.0200925749,
-0.0615170598,
-0.0416065417,
-0.0558720492,
-0.0563430227,
0.0034007013,
0.0142915472,
-0.0077489209,
0.0249911956,
0.0500724614,
-0.0116977962,
-0.0554289334,
0.0077955932,
-0.0185699351,
0.0325201824,
-0.0110693881,
-0.0305205937,
0.0045725382,
0.0591988228,
-0.0544390567,
0.0335571282,
-0.0217832401,
-0.0703650489,
-0.0115849832,
-0.0329219252,
0.0212022122,
0.0000079513,
0.0191553831,
0.0430895761,
0.0626060069,
0.1032905728,
-0.0470603891,
-0.0132621797,
0.0254748277,
0.0259653218,
0.0093995221,
0.0098030651,
-0.0531432331,
-0.022531841,
0.0023947889,
0.0711579323,
-0.0144903576,
-0.0170094147,
0.0326615348,
0.0314645767,
0.003844395,
0.0143521763,
-0.0183142405,
-0.0672157332,
-0.0473555326,
-0.0267025325,
-0.0057143965,
-0.0550286137,
0.0011240061,
-0.0013138932,
-0.0103485594,
-0.0088611133,
0.0899132639,
-0.0311065353,
0.0211629272,
-0.0923263952,
0.055846829,
-0.0294015817,
-0.0129029863,
0.0127575761,
-0.0273672044,
-0.0299766473,
-0.0454122089,
0.0300407223,
-0.0403290205,
-0.0078630084,
0.0273494925,
0.0389293134,
0.0367328972,
-0.0294922069,
0.0210214742,
-0.0042235381,
0.0004585174,
-0.0280706026,
0.0089018587,
-0.0173329171,
0.046540387,
-0.012928105,
-0.0443058275,
-0.0152661083,
0.0031483416,
0.054744184,
0.0510513075,
-0.0588641688,
0.0761779621,
0.0163208097,
-0.073817201,
-0.0279946607,
0.0517995246,
0.0426297039,
-0.0423413664,
-0.0682820603,
-0.0314372815,
-0.0386135019,
-0.0406525433,
0.0240296274,
-0.0008168806,
0.0104569523,
0.0073158205,
-0.082761623,
-0.0504025295,
0.0097583849,
0.0043478971,
0.0010625481,
0.0026713533,
-0.0003990431,
0.0873472542,
0.029243689,
-0.0394554026,
-0.0521473922,
0.0021802711,
-0.0697328001,
-0.0238693785,
-0.009893802,
-6.337179677e-33,
-0.0254385751,
-0.0484418906,
0.0010078222,
0.003638281,
-0.0180393681,
0.0227113441,
-0.0222440287,
-0.0032394303,
-0.020193262,
0.0464388281,
-0.0048410892,
-0.0008022212,
0.0126267886,
-0.0204525143,
-0.0087594697,
0.0020151958,
0.0068700896,
0.0014576402,
-0.0351378322,
-0.0155293765,
0.0469606221,
0.0311921109,
0.0181490406,
-0.0751780197,
0.048405204,
-0.0284123756,
-0.0362430662,
-0.0332518294,
0.0680634826,
0.0299587809,
0.0079764165,
0.0499827527,
0.0093291299,
-0.0935200602,
0.0043340735,
0.0639177039,
-0.0735651627,
-0.0058399187,
0.017470289,
-0.0318970084,
-0.0170925036,
-0.0082976557,
0.0202958174,
0.0052212067,
-0.0048489785,
-0.0150170224,
0.0367066935,
-0.0178411454,
-0.0336441062,
-0.1050093547,
-0.0670632944,
0.0163324308,
-0.0146530187,
0.1086603329,
0.0054693739,
0.0438301116,
-0.0150664086,
0.0750235096,
0.0120565677,
0.0055014668,
0.0063916319,
0.0062993835,
0.055040326,
0.0623673275,
0.0312833712,
0.0553117283,
-0.0518862866,
0.0316927917,
-0.0036874581,
-0.0043583387,
0.028762782,
0.0065410011,
-0.0385429896,
0.0080093862,
-0.0281345751,
-0.0423011258,
-0.1008756608,
0.0303433109,
0.0066629187,
0.0061509875,
0.0307364464,
-0.025423212,
-0.0108084381,
-0.0536575951,
-0.0093184868,
0.0091866367,
-0.0089880293,
0.0244146008,
0.0275777243,
0.003924015,
-0.0682684779,
0.0053392188,
0.0239267945,
-0.0188845359,
-0.0594217628,
0.0660065114,
-0.0144355316,
-0.0179735832,
-0.0004541585,
0.0024511118,
-0.0321647301,
-0.0434719473,
-0.032540258,
0.0264133923,
-0.0044501177,
-0.0445610285,
0.0299699679,
-0.029182991,
-0.0367114879,
-0.0034462817,
-0.0309624281,
0.0106891664,
-0.0119353896,
-0.0686236545,
0.0050675292,
0.02188983,
0.0060786614,
0.0049886634,
0.051455766,
0.0175278373,
0.0340304635,
-0.0032184245,
0.0012555383,
0.0318564326,
0.0124405781,
0.0083455201,
0.0203147139,
0.0383154862,
0.0713443235,
0.016941838,
-0.0254832301,
0.051206205,
2.867e-7,
0.0815085247,
0.0052482402,
-0.0277530234,
0.0130575327,
0.0089271795,
0.0351403728,
0.0310233552,
0.0350250565,
-0.0046318043,
-0.0281431396,
0.0220570005,
-0.0096487477,
0.0064806696,
0.036530938,
-0.0247840937,
-0.0183722898,
-0.0279748272,
-0.0418418273,
-0.1013291329,
0.0256381091,
0.0055583278,
0.0275683217,
-0.0198928583,
0.0129952449,
-0.0096449377,
-0.085342437,
0.0657318383,
-0.0870957077,
-0.0196350999,
0.0278924536,
0.0155126108,
-0.0396655723,
-0.0053284019,
-0.0370864831,
-0.0216120053,
0.0228040926,
0.0401370861,
0.0217914525,
0.0449864604,
0.0170865674,
0.0119567011,
-0.0227766689,
0.0001294078,
-0.0396122225,
0.0332965814,
-0.0454468094,
-0.0377012715,
-0.0136221657,
-0.0267076064,
0.0255301856,
-0.0361743532,
-0.0276138317,
-0.0145088425,
0.0321282931,
-0.0160484165,
-0.0224170536,
0.0483643226,
-0.0036297182,
0.0433120616,
-0.0066001508,
-0.0018108606,
-0.0251166672,
0.0102451909,
0.0701630935,
0.0233798437,
0.003822363,
0.0583224334,
2.653417225e-34,
0.027910959,
-0.0504495874,
-0.0319008119,
-0.0175795835,
0.1015875712,
0.024732057,
-0.0667031631,
0.0440717302,
-0.0179382842,
-0.1059474871,
0.0032353522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05627v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05627v1 | Integrating Stock Features and Global Information via Large Language Models for Enhanced Stock Return Prediction | 2023-10-09T11:34:18 | 2023-10-09T11:34:18 | Yujie Ding, Shuai Jia, Tianyi Ma, Bingcheng Mao, Xiuze Zhou, Liuliu Li, Dongming Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.ST | The remarkable achievements and rapid advancements of Large Language Models
(LLMs) such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have showcased their immense potential in
quantitative investment. Traders can effectively leverage these LLMs to analyze
financial news and predict stock returns accurately. However, integrating LLMs
into existing quantitative models presents two primary challenges: the
insufficient utilization of semantic information embedded within LLMs and the
difficulties in aligning the latent information within LLMs with pre-existing
quantitative stock features. We propose a novel framework consisting of two
components to surmount these challenges. The first component, the Local-Global
(LG) model, introduces three distinct strategies for modeling global
information. These approaches are grounded respectively on stock features, the
capabilities of LLMs, and a hybrid method combining the two paradigms. The
second component, Self-Correlated Reinforcement Learning (SCRL), focuses on
aligning the embeddings of financial news generated by LLMs with stock features
within the same semantic space. By implementing our framework, we have
demonstrated superior performance in Rank Information Coefficient and returns,
particularly compared to models relying only on stock features in the China
A-share market. | [
0.0147382068,
0.0582576953,
-0.0101343952,
-0.0097710686,
0.0263936147,
-0.0063775238,
0.0147668021,
0.0184103251,
0.0029012745,
-0.008219705,
-0.0188711602,
-0.0339264162,
-0.0460442118,
0.0491749793,
0.0344526693,
-0.0227424484,
0.0120579116,
-0.0486330017,
0.0255092736,
-0.0283187926,
0.0070229461,
-0.0102615971,
0.0846363753,
0.0040054237,
-0.0122687584,
0.0029433502,
-0.0292870924,
0.0175651647,
0.0085879164,
0.0000900624,
-0.0313925296,
-0.0034138849,
0.0448278151,
0.0506768227,
0.0000018931,
-0.0229314715,
-0.0245824009,
-0.001373629,
0.0428059883,
-0.0190407988,
0.0022140676,
-0.0383434631,
0.0204011593,
-0.0142025175,
-0.0542097539,
-0.0002968228,
0.0495932847,
0.0851327106,
0.0481106937,
0.0767484158,
-0.0149117708,
-0.0217762254,
0.0250316784,
-0.0803977102,
0.0538666472,
-0.0786243901,
0.0278452951,
0.0662894472,
-0.0061575263,
0.0386958569,
-0.0265478045,
0.0397608019,
0.008115123,
0.0153127061,
-0.0198785607,
0.0090485346,
0.0245292746,
0.0291862506,
-0.0085059553,
0.0101749906,
0.0075926352,
0.0127725303,
0.016700875,
-0.0006981519,
0.0080668032,
0.0336859263,
-0.0392995588,
0.0216554627,
0.0133681986,
0.0568072684,
0.0508363917,
-0.0112811886,
0.0091009885,
0.0148064019,
-0.0448232219,
0.0537250228,
-0.0313623734,
-0.0167851876,
0.0040537501,
0.0176873617,
-0.006834737,
-0.0205961335,
-0.0359119773,
0.0257428754,
0.0073790425,
-0.0098849284,
0.044296518,
-0.0095048277,
-0.0091317147,
-0.1106875762,
-0.0544304252,
0.0461488031,
0.0163007136,
0.0575704351,
-0.058738336,
0.081898652,
0.0020555288,
-0.0281967726,
-0.0009344825,
-0.0142636951,
-0.0563331805,
-0.0383067317,
-0.0146661568,
0.0813145638,
-0.0054996959,
-0.0360378772,
-0.0718278065,
0.0289612133,
-0.0141028343,
0.0493198335,
0.0267816298,
-0.0208428428,
-0.0627207533,
-0.0164116584,
-0.0192201324,
-0.0211565625,
-0.0125532262,
0.0114693167,
-0.0132327452,
-0.0121050067,
0.0323721208,
-0.0157008134,
-0.0530397631,
0.0029728457,
0.0086378986,
0.0836132988,
0.0346989557,
-0.0014761093,
-0.0121611208,
-0.0608398616,
-0.0123308916,
-0.0470455959,
-0.0293728188,
-0.0514908098,
-0.0246085282,
-0.0306673665,
0.0050394558,
-0.006227565,
0.0178163443,
-0.0216684062,
-0.0194661785,
0.0543767102,
0.0625775754,
-0.0256788004,
0.006277842,
-0.0190020669,
0.0494827256,
0.1043847725,
-0.0264061652,
0.0577940568,
0.0568042509,
0.0044762916,
-0.0276424736,
0.0169763416,
0.0190265272,
-0.0309113972,
-0.0486671105,
0.0216850322,
0.0436472297,
-0.0283526797,
0.0631972849,
0.0126328971,
-0.0079539688,
-0.0106708929,
0.0706461072,
0.0317828469,
0.0578320026,
0.0334584005,
0.0134063549,
0.0045394604,
-0.0187344197,
-0.0218437351,
0.0131801516,
-0.0037276438,
-0.0217602644,
0.0451334119,
0.0239985678,
0.0514905863,
-0.0556063242,
-0.0047051804,
0.027992405,
-0.0038076367,
0.0022221236,
0.0215667747,
0.0411872678,
-0.097152099,
0.016650727,
0.0163544975,
0.0412945449,
0.007826237,
0.0229076352,
-0.0173802618,
0.0508112907,
0.0629556403,
-0.0212447997,
-0.0133411288,
0.0361593254,
-0.0290979948,
-0.0684917569,
0.0218139924,
-0.0013696786,
-0.0046507395,
-0.0758158341,
-0.007638392,
-0.037808951,
0.0286928546,
0.0186218563,
0.0425913557,
-0.0343318507,
0.0267035253,
-0.0125631811,
-0.0062742624,
-0.0010257678,
-0.0177062973,
0.0092596505,
-0.0535032004,
0.0211171862,
-0.0374094062,
0.0058268243,
0.0348340943,
0.003188472,
-0.0096215317,
-0.0270630885,
0.0082422346,
-0.082721442,
-0.006935114,
-0.0434409901,
-0.0166609995,
-0.0029851284,
0.0175735857,
0.033558771,
-0.005838762,
-0.0181530174,
-0.0353472531,
-0.0089315334,
-0.0303108133,
0.0440477096,
-0.0648426786,
-0.0698044226,
0.0256071575,
0.02103897,
-0.0215012636,
0.0447211564,
-0.0328547731,
0.022921104,
-0.0228085034,
0.0061019016,
-0.0166578572,
-0.0437071808,
0.0069034919,
0.0524981692,
0.0180214327,
0.0450740121,
0.0691722706,
-0.0010899769,
0.0452250056,
-0.0664735287,
-0.0778124258,
-0.0189443007,
-0.0217921939,
0.0163836461,
0.0237781294,
0.0237958748,
-0.0091206618,
-0.0200460609,
-0.0487703346,
-0.0148878274,
0.0087915165,
0.0227707755,
0.0261100233,
0.0288979281,
0.0033295576,
-0.0333716758,
-0.0251066703,
-0.0034716481,
0.0274809059,
0.0134178856,
-0.022314677,
-0.0373856276,
-0.0363895036,
-0.0456577428,
0.0415572375,
-0.0240406115,
0.0164710209,
-0.0291263629,
-0.0521580875,
0.0141588477,
0.0538695306,
0.0199549329,
0.0093910741,
-0.0140586328,
-0.0323376358,
-0.0606968999,
0.0295656454,
-0.0301655047,
-0.0174187161,
-0.0291636549,
-0.0080504017,
-0.0118744858,
0.0463303477,
0.0032947545,
-0.013742527,
-0.0991445333,
0.0348257795,
-0.0242292192,
0.0214784201,
-0.1009578556,
0.0201125275,
-0.0107359001,
0.0522686988,
0.001096183,
-0.0570827909,
0.053471975,
-0.0134708527,
-0.0043060719,
0.0061683464,
-0.0363481976,
-0.0901242048,
0.0331316404,
-0.0150045911,
0.0186128728,
-0.0517618433,
-0.0291038807,
-0.0115725482,
0.0024967464,
0.0264004022,
-0.0413008891,
0.0080349073,
0.0054283226,
0.0352917649,
0.0227167234,
-0.0243198685,
0.0215954501,
-0.0316319354,
-0.0201500524,
0.0364225246,
0.0586738028,
-0.0618493073,
-0.0043263477,
0.0542555973,
0.0221112948,
-0.0076746228,
-0.0368052721,
-0.0301161241,
0.0424188077,
0.0009232485,
0.0857523382,
-0.0165731236,
-0.0002072942,
-0.0293813124,
0.0606100447,
0.0083915638,
0.0393169038,
-0.0260124933,
0.0136767151,
0.0386247821,
0.0297964551,
0.000198371,
-0.0166940056,
0.0216164067,
-0.0045512994,
-0.0437629968,
0.0076919626,
0.0847474784,
-0.0162395313,
-0.0125383558,
-0.0026650501,
-0.0031697061,
0.0126827862,
-0.035831999,
0.0438533016,
-0.0640466809,
0.0167608615,
-0.02211296,
-0.0325127803,
0.0265793223,
-0.0311352871,
0.0066965078,
-0.105848752,
0.0543659963,
-0.007555502,
-0.0697824806,
-0.0521543585,
-0.0473157056,
0.0150273908,
-0.0678528696,
-0.0018183216,
0.0134648737,
-0.0476895273,
0.0248194337,
-0.0134384269,
-0.0754788294,
0.0051974505,
0.0050578923,
0.0084594367,
-0.0272761062,
0.0391344875,
-0.0313784555,
-0.0311034825,
0.0310574826,
-0.0980211347,
-0.0178258698,
0.0180523265,
-0.0053590806,
0.0406503342,
-0.0487457737,
-0.0143369529,
-0.0039759735,
0.0385638885,
0.0601937696,
0.0396478437,
-0.0165919941,
0.017918501,
-0.0135024758,
-0.0379560702,
0.0345010012,
0.0277652759,
0.0140664577,
0.0395291671,
-0.0035115723,
-0.0360308178,
-0.0335056148,
-0.0557078458,
-0.0303658638,
0.0166216958,
-0.0517609268,
-0.0055679046,
-0.0064181141,
-0.0426175259,
-0.0855724066,
-0.0804359168,
-0.0016859496,
0.0295998752,
-0.0204768684,
0.0662188679,
0.0085269623,
0.0035399599,
-0.0306988135,
0.0090542454,
0.0107207512,
-0.0227206741,
-0.0033068743,
0.0540459566,
0.0416098349,
-0.0530654974,
-0.0257487204,
0.011742712,
-0.0487970822,
-0.05644596,
-0.0067058261,
0.0176997427,
0.0172796585,
-0.0036916994,
-0.0309200976,
0.0291722305,
0.0818123072,
0.0391207114,
-0.045808237,
-0.012444309,
0.055770196,
0.039864067,
0.0243951604,
0.0323441066,
-0.03014482,
0.0226757787,
-0.0308347698,
0.0105062788,
-0.0275950637,
-0.0220116377,
-0.0017075099,
-0.0103529729,
0.0409602337,
0.016561795,
-0.0133215468,
-0.0111098588,
-0.0209068879,
-0.011643189,
-0.0099224737,
-0.0170207787,
-0.0189988799,
0.0379235484,
0.0051760944,
-0.0194483362,
0.0328371152,
0.0269120727,
-0.0356429033,
-0.046912685,
-0.0223193951,
-0.0510510914,
0.0100570722,
0.0217740331,
0.0290721711,
0.0038420209,
-0.0313249081,
0.0537444279,
-0.0128348302,
0.0002980593,
0.0220888536,
0.0283153709,
0.0036172736,
0.0005094508,
-0.0514014959,
-0.0585135743,
-0.0581774414,
-0.0168726705,
0.0490615703,
0.046590317,
-0.010101323,
0.021763552,
-0.0676231906,
0.0020926439,
0.0188163072,
-0.0000579219,
0.0048690545,
-0.0166420899,
0.0288836323,
0.0085738944,
-0.065009281,
-0.0121276574,
0.099213928,
0.0278092939,
0.0099539701,
-0.01957733,
-0.0341859721,
-0.0348554403,
-0.0102619939,
0.0913813114,
0.0317776836,
-0.0379360355,
0.0181753375,
-0.0544164702,
-0.0646081641,
-0.0003225157,
0.0241570417,
-0.0273771919,
0.0153828505,
0.0171800889,
0.0444148742,
-0.0024058665,
0.0389584936,
-0.0321683921,
-0.0004685562,
-0.0075334487,
-0.0259486418,
-0.0324625149,
-5.951920954e-33,
-0.028477855,
0.0040496234,
0.0293701701,
0.0359154791,
0.0021304572,
0.0162273515,
0.0021116813,
-0.0008047617,
0.0228184573,
0.0334575512,
0.0294849277,
0.0153058125,
-0.0068253195,
0.0088051995,
0.043540433,
0.0028811113,
0.0116733313,
0.007969684,
-0.0017339337,
0.0124852182,
0.0485848039,
0.0527172126,
0.0470822304,
-0.005792317,
-0.00298947,
-0.0021589471,
-0.0605310649,
0.0038825199,
0.0376563035,
0.0506601594,
0.0042485413,
0.0541623868,
0.020440124,
-0.1077991426,
-0.0208190046,
0.0183813255,
0.0113047194,
-0.063359499,
0.0099404575,
-0.0050704353,
0.0120317405,
0.0374497101,
0.013361712,
0.0011249115,
0.0286930893,
0.0214823745,
0.0466931127,
0.0134247746,
0.004469703,
-0.0481861308,
-0.0514053851,
0.0275397357,
0.0224456042,
0.0749780759,
0.0569573715,
0.0523947626,
0.0147809228,
0.0232375879,
-0.0099413712,
0.0379339345,
-0.0048410324,
0.0623795912,
-0.0096090231,
0.0322400667,
0.0164504722,
0.0372693837,
-0.0289205015,
-0.0048502726,
-0.0189492386,
0.0171056502,
0.0151006188,
0.0329526998,
-0.0019271838,
0.0535376742,
0.0134443846,
0.009131873,
-0.0754935816,
0.0166888125,
0.0155060338,
0.0290427282,
0.0044718808,
0.0147163263,
-0.0597955622,
-0.0400707312,
0.0106066912,
0.0473462455,
-0.0072868657,
-0.0640301555,
0.0164884683,
0.0284622274,
0.0077051315,
0.0269869734,
0.0233917926,
-0.0361491702,
-0.0727485791,
0.016877668,
-0.032388106,
0.0030669167,
-0.0062586521,
-0.0064685964,
-0.03572689,
-0.0429898053,
-0.0263336208,
-0.0154589219,
-0.056169495,
-0.0382030345,
0.013683551,
0.029749753,
-0.0535126738,
-0.0163250845,
0.013458034,
0.0024152836,
0.0042333314,
-0.0614242442,
0.0322164558,
-0.0192352589,
-0.0128179351,
0.0453432947,
0.0160156414,
0.0205387939,
0.0147755742,
-0.0440304689,
-0.0084969848,
-0.0072186473,
0.0475405827,
0.0413080752,
-0.0097270738,
0.0599198639,
0.022747403,
-0.0409715064,
-0.0072312476,
0.056907177,
2.694e-7,
0.0221628062,
0.0655762702,
-0.0232316758,
0.0140433172,
0.0304698125,
0.0287566762,
-0.0304795243,
0.0387039147,
0.0309247747,
0.0022534512,
0.0688105077,
0.0485164821,
0.0333252139,
0.0241306033,
-0.0847413465,
-0.0118757747,
-0.0766874403,
-0.0022455058,
-0.0876226127,
0.0043872483,
-0.0292838383,
0.0642887577,
-0.0009269565,
0.0122564901,
0.0217261128,
-0.0298685078,
0.0694508255,
-0.0599613301,
-0.0618364178,
0.0087261507,
0.0216379594,
0.0231880657,
-0.0187387541,
0.0224430393,
-0.006476643,
0.0309881046,
0.0187501125,
0.0081321504,
0.025106024,
0.0514560938,
-0.012439671,
0.0009516764,
-0.0250133891,
-0.0838641748,
0.0417721085,
-0.0753645152,
-0.0191751644,
-0.0257964525,
-0.0245264769,
0.0170886964,
0.0416233912,
0.0142440796,
-0.0325969867,
0.0240299609,
-0.0064369575,
0.0054558753,
0.0480386093,
-0.0467341244,
-0.0399087183,
0.0407188386,
-0.0598146319,
0.002722471,
-0.0278181359,
0.0002481239,
0.0042932504,
-0.0473742895,
0.0520863831,
2.360237914e-34,
0.0728709549,
-0.0125446254,
-0.0371325798,
0.0138502102,
0.0384456776,
0.0171859618,
-0.0726404712,
0.0344213508,
0.0215254817,
-0.0715408102,
-0.0272899084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05620v2 | LAiW: A Chinese Legal Large Language Models Benchmark | 2023-10-09T11:19:55 | 2024-02-18T05:36:14 | Yongfu Dai, Duanyu Feng, Jimin Huang, Haochen Jia, Qianqian Xie, Yifang Zhang, Weiguang Han, Wei Tian, Hao Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | General and legal domain LLMs have demonstrated strong performance in various
tasks of LegalAI. However, the current evaluations of these LLMs in LegalAI are
defined by the experts of computer science, lacking consistency with the logic
of legal practice, making it difficult to judge their practical capabilities.
To address this challenge, we are the first to build the Chinese legal LLMs
benchmark LAiW, based on the logic of legal practice. To align with the
thinking process of legal experts and legal practice (syllogism), we divide the
legal capabilities of LLMs from easy to difficult into three levels: basic
information retrieval, legal foundation inference, and complex legal
application. Each level contains multiple tasks to ensure a comprehensive
evaluation. Through automated evaluation of current general and legal domain
LLMs on our benchmark, we indicate that these LLMs may not align with the logic
of legal practice. LLMs seem to be able to directly acquire complex legal
application capabilities but perform poorly in some basic tasks, which may pose
obstacles to their practical application and acceptance by legal experts. To
further confirm the complex legal application capabilities of current LLMs in
legal application scenarios, we also incorporate human evaluation with legal
experts. The results indicate that while LLMs may demonstrate strong
performance, they still require reinforcement of legal logic. | [
0.0627584904,
0.0183566529,
-0.0078813611,
0.017137561,
-0.067425184,
0.0296391267,
0.0116101094,
0.0597571544,
0.009914577,
-0.0647509545,
-0.0346869938,
-0.0293212608,
-0.0099491337,
-0.0315958038,
0.0097795036,
-0.0108712921,
0.0229734574,
0.0237314645,
0.0522349738,
-0.009696614,
0.0257102121,
-0.0124279642,
0.0271305107,
-0.0037148753,
0.0002976879,
0.0076656169,
0.0051348754,
0.0243065357,
-0.0110409884,
-0.0090313768,
-0.0151952431,
0.0548972599,
0.0106707625,
0.0032281256,
0.0000018525,
-0.0980473012,
-0.0067577986,
-0.0041840728,
-0.0003199,
0.0570833907,
0.0304514039,
-0.0314701721,
-0.0367488079,
-0.0037912289,
-0.0602824651,
0.0584627055,
-0.0210778993,
0.0198735893,
0.0229383465,
0.098462455,
0.006292081,
-0.0597077124,
0.0527789928,
-0.0354939327,
-0.0021465083,
-0.063466087,
0.0295579359,
0.0629841685,
0.0609571971,
-0.0527988039,
0.025201058,
0.0170320831,
0.0456354246,
-0.0229209214,
-0.0523952767,
-0.0255029891,
-0.0144999605,
0.0370835215,
0.0044745822,
0.0385271497,
0.0623336658,
-0.0182470977,
0.0108831329,
-0.0056242924,
0.0408188961,
0.0259015299,
-0.0314003825,
0.0830837563,
-0.0073856204,
0.0217440538,
0.0207731891,
0.0185734238,
0.0235547777,
0.0377745144,
-0.046631325,
0.0678661838,
-0.0132923722,
-0.0387797318,
0.0193316974,
-0.013697328,
0.0144094033,
-0.0352849551,
0.0298127625,
0.0588825531,
-0.0058436301,
0.0366340131,
-0.0095492704,
0.0018465724,
0.0689139143,
-0.0658453479,
0.0351604745,
0.0126479957,
-0.0235084239,
0.05882705,
-0.0566455387,
0.0247787163,
-0.0092386967,
0.0200503934,
-0.0031456423,
-0.0395187661,
-0.0261276159,
-0.0133854579,
-0.0078874193,
0.0700500607,
-0.0878021419,
0.021613529,
-0.0471588895,
-0.0013780816,
-0.0336784907,
0.0322522148,
-0.0014015266,
-0.0403985865,
0.0042829518,
-0.0412267856,
-0.0810646936,
-0.0579730794,
-0.0180820022,
0.0503885895,
-0.01938322,
-0.025655983,
0.030666573,
0.0233641192,
-0.0287717115,
-0.0009188561,
0.0135571091,
0.1028171033,
0.0018243704,
0.0054756743,
-0.0628330484,
-0.064907141,
-0.025584856,
-0.0878608525,
-0.0360599235,
-0.0753022209,
-0.0145826805,
-0.0134605318,
-0.0295146368,
-0.0470299944,
0.0165049452,
0.0262587573,
0.0043879636,
0.0474623032,
-0.0350210629,
-0.0095329741,
-0.0411788784,
0.0391825736,
0.0232826211,
0.0183361676,
-0.0010597847,
0.0298738033,
0.0132128578,
0.0050812042,
0.0275985226,
0.0490471646,
-0.0235902146,
0.015174468,
-0.0396960005,
0.0315902196,
-0.0225958489,
-0.0048970105,
-0.0014681101,
0.0546751209,
0.0056374073,
0.0116133634,
0.0133035015,
0.0565969795,
0.0376329124,
0.0563131757,
0.0141573967,
-0.0229539946,
0.0543936081,
0.0096790623,
-0.0499950536,
0.0130045265,
-0.0526645221,
0.0173128918,
-0.0661716908,
-0.0028592064,
-0.0084730471,
-0.0771118179,
-0.0164699666,
0.0014420246,
-0.0171195995,
-0.0006523702,
0.048401691,
-0.0015129253,
0.0076405369,
0.0626010224,
0.0297021884,
-0.0465928875,
-0.0341508426,
-0.0261978991,
-0.0042036343,
0.0485784821,
0.0375967696,
-0.0411909334,
0.0000099129,
0.0091852378,
-0.0023818358,
0.04892198,
0.0378422067,
0.0011563078,
-0.0475476533,
-0.0320719071,
-0.0087091411,
0.0196562931,
0.0230337549,
-0.0058524692,
0.0247442294,
0.009234,
0.0536763109,
-0.0771808475,
-0.0104892487,
0.0138415787,
-0.0439253114,
-0.0026422997,
-0.0174420234,
-0.0018472773,
0.034667816,
0.0393150821,
-0.012117004,
0.0018366985,
0.0305191725,
-0.0033995386,
-0.0180345383,
0.0136569813,
0.018514365,
0.0130255166,
0.0637184903,
-0.0270777829,
-0.0048982166,
-0.0065298285,
-0.046190992,
-0.0016306519,
-0.0416159481,
-0.0079758354,
0.0035559249,
-0.0728828833,
0.013877213,
-0.0256644059,
-0.0291193631,
-0.0316401497,
0.057319209,
-0.0024033203,
-0.0024340977,
0.0403188169,
0.0066888835,
0.0316775665,
-0.0356847979,
-0.0388175584,
-0.0247493219,
-0.0309869759,
0.0255468152,
0.012313094,
0.0295714922,
-0.0302374326,
-0.0451861508,
-0.0495566316,
0.0207089484,
-0.0262270756,
0.0109927785,
0.0035578392,
-0.0518608354,
-0.0187582113,
0.0083530825,
-0.0166300219,
-0.0022526255,
-0.0097984923,
-0.0253991187,
0.0298608094,
-0.0504677705,
-0.0468705632,
-0.0109626353,
0.0074763885,
-0.0211925898,
-0.0190715175,
0.0277399253,
-0.0222192928,
-0.0141519606,
0.0756687075,
-0.030599732,
-0.0204403866,
-0.0279996935,
-0.0107321078,
-0.0226120353,
0.0071589104,
-0.0469572917,
0.008045217,
0.0204276349,
0.0194922723,
0.0211157072,
-0.0110465968,
-0.0581012107,
-0.0093665374,
0.0388976112,
-0.0069062198,
-0.0636129007,
-0.0179159008,
-0.0000618511,
-0.0082211206,
-0.003518712,
0.0213072188,
0.0057942513,
-0.0090743396,
-0.0130824214,
0.0033987127,
-0.0046214638,
0.0213753991,
-0.0364671797,
0.0478042513,
0.0109822983,
-0.0654471442,
0.0149728339,
0.0023785916,
0.051340688,
-0.0341309719,
-0.0216686446,
-0.061791122,
0.0814009234,
-0.0356294811,
0.0001153929,
-0.0399646237,
-0.0206375904,
-0.0063567185,
-0.0059988489,
0.0543105938,
-0.0569944717,
0.104079254,
-0.0220347922,
0.0583628565,
-0.0417838469,
-0.0167080387,
-0.0345672742,
-0.0019071085,
-0.020746097,
0.0501413718,
0.0151157798,
0.0208954159,
0.0092835007,
-0.0003607641,
-0.005502061,
-0.0267625283,
0.0283967424,
-0.0080464929,
-0.0394018069,
-0.001455243,
-0.0223789178,
-0.0050162529,
0.0217582844,
-0.009707245,
0.0256394446,
0.0324791297,
-0.0055466639,
-0.0109658651,
0.0253630411,
0.0208514482,
0.0076254229,
-0.0444457047,
-0.0066029863,
0.0669227839,
0.0100174872,
-0.0608084165,
0.0413211472,
0.1104125381,
0.0218124054,
-0.0022614859,
-0.0224065352,
0.0036925308,
-0.0431747921,
0.0479351208,
0.0124450866,
-0.118900761,
0.0101469196,
0.001037358,
-0.0140821077,
-0.0305907093,
-0.0223774444,
0.0005894311,
-0.111789681,
0.1151131094,
0.0284432527,
-0.0016184829,
-0.0225108303,
0.0020272864,
0.0130734202,
0.0149536235,
0.019040741,
0.0111699523,
-0.0304561276,
-0.03149141,
0.0069081997,
-0.0404800922,
0.0085796462,
0.0378591828,
-0.065265879,
0.0456645302,
0.0210600365,
0.017453609,
-0.0409756266,
-0.0199252833,
0.0303422548,
0.0224703215,
0.0245918091,
-0.0102085844,
-0.0174625926,
0.0421888269,
0.0226596072,
-0.0463232324,
0.0208403617,
-0.0262417775,
-0.0165398773,
0.0454382747,
0.0501236096,
-0.0350970328,
-0.0202061441,
-0.0093358001,
-0.0044964026,
-0.0465661213,
0.0674303547,
0.0087311361,
0.0045899041,
-0.0399930626,
-0.0235907529,
-0.0782769546,
-0.0092642298,
-0.0313408151,
0.0162899774,
-0.0173811149,
0.0065090251,
-0.0460071266,
-0.0015465984,
-0.030570101,
0.0404049046,
0.0184038803,
0.0465396792,
0.02679017,
-0.0160691943,
-0.0401070006,
-0.022262102,
-0.0537948012,
0.0260375291,
-0.0281819757,
0.050525967,
0.0245654676,
-0.0057584438,
-0.000781844,
-0.0243856404,
0.0041156705,
-0.0203824304,
-0.0347623192,
-0.0023639833,
0.0185977612,
-0.0191505849,
-0.0399553329,
-0.0243827831,
0.0361907706,
0.0194983967,
-0.0079599731,
0.0103097139,
0.0620756894,
-0.0163938813,
-0.0185563006,
0.0050771055,
-0.0088303136,
0.0201595537,
0.055872716,
0.0229904912,
-0.0169691872,
-0.0216473304,
0.0397575274,
0.1102717221,
-0.0248290394,
0.0197468176,
-0.0282085612,
0.0098455092,
0.0098553523,
-0.0290254876,
-0.0293065496,
-0.0248231217,
-0.0261488613,
0.0228483137,
-0.0018112761,
-0.023383867,
0.086867772,
0.0085678855,
-0.0166431125,
-0.0364117995,
0.0474026874,
-0.0228048842,
0.0077477745,
0.0059205666,
-0.0416117236,
0.0175188202,
0.0211005379,
-0.0291477405,
0.0465016365,
-0.0010207314,
0.0502784327,
0.0033544102,
0.0052972492,
-0.0059740711,
-0.0014556618,
-0.0143205589,
-0.0525593124,
0.0065670372,
0.0750192702,
0.0998060107,
0.020271156,
-0.0018353746,
-0.0544033311,
0.0103879226,
-0.0125496592,
0.0154367983,
-0.0056246873,
-0.0277146548,
0.0377512611,
0.0079422481,
-0.0173989609,
0.0027050809,
0.0201751646,
0.0030548004,
0.005736684,
-0.0172455199,
-0.0136294663,
0.007573043,
-0.0517712831,
0.0174909011,
-0.0069640176,
-0.0355620459,
-0.040566463,
-0.099072732,
-0.0465717949,
-0.005466186,
0.0102379909,
-0.0171263479,
0.0063903076,
-0.0035070518,
0.0723534226,
0.0416968465,
-0.0143557871,
-0.0196791328,
0.0119012501,
-0.0011802727,
0.0054628123,
0.0065037524,
-5.586034746e-33,
-0.0159804039,
-0.0546736903,
0.0368041694,
-0.0048942827,
-0.0036731162,
-0.0458002239,
-0.0133159552,
0.0025849666,
-0.0242907442,
0.0189553648,
-0.0200642049,
0.0297165066,
0.0202589482,
-0.0333192013,
0.0095040305,
-0.0196637269,
-0.0248897634,
0.0203591939,
0.0120098451,
-0.0527330823,
-0.0212863218,
0.0069525936,
0.0158138443,
-0.0935554951,
0.0287358481,
0.0435277186,
-0.0121658007,
-0.0222649556,
-0.0836385489,
0.0499944612,
0.0264195148,
0.0234137308,
0.0261989739,
-0.0492171235,
0.0014533584,
0.0055097211,
-0.0520587973,
0.0202156138,
0.0389267169,
-0.0185071286,
0.0339654945,
-0.0243810713,
0.0564525388,
0.0049045999,
-0.0429807641,
-0.0065339128,
0.0320568644,
-0.0668515489,
-0.0287387539,
-0.0718673468,
-0.0802378133,
0.0590796433,
0.0043506045,
0.0571715571,
0.0066446313,
-0.0287576169,
-0.0145056015,
0.0422652327,
-0.0622521117,
-0.0155227976,
-0.0156655163,
-0.0200887583,
0.0641204566,
-0.070498392,
-0.0128744375,
0.0448163562,
-0.0087305028,
0.0251151733,
-0.0425506122,
-0.022220498,
0.0216771308,
0.1287321597,
0.0266122948,
0.0481176861,
0.0060132076,
-0.0082925819,
-0.0878740102,
0.001202045,
0.0269219074,
0.0414790176,
0.0228211135,
-0.0003619522,
-0.0545348972,
-0.0118274372,
-0.0232724529,
0.0164955705,
-0.0106822662,
-0.0150705464,
0.0298507381,
-0.0036668926,
0.0334859379,
-0.0354299583,
-0.0357772224,
-0.0652105585,
-0.0060412344,
0.0118770683,
0.0078411745,
0.0132925492,
-0.0234094951,
0.0371192805,
-0.0745956451,
-0.0504977293,
-0.0145758931,
-0.01542594,
-0.0015972552,
-0.0090878354,
0.0307678413,
-0.028495416,
-0.0425184593,
-0.0117952004,
0.0081481105,
-0.0092350831,
0.0641296059,
0.002471799,
0.0121994782,
0.0288607441,
0.0324577987,
0.0132668875,
0.0114593543,
-0.0459100194,
-0.0325365551,
-0.0033957935,
-0.0057426901,
-0.0142583502,
0.0035225665,
0.0308041126,
-0.0013218484,
0.0611183718,
0.0449495576,
0.0201881807,
0.0149242058,
0.0640302002,
2.634e-7,
0.0791925713,
0.0120428987,
-0.0212856401,
0.0516553447,
-0.0303086285,
0.0217934567,
-0.0341473222,
0.0100104436,
0.0132008279,
-0.0346915089,
0.0315323398,
0.0206799563,
0.0796907619,
0.0276791938,
-0.0444525592,
-0.0001773567,
-0.0218148362,
-0.065454185,
-0.0314162783,
0.0563975051,
0.0383397713,
0.0483245179,
0.0043305769,
-0.0233649239,
-0.0024451443,
-0.0619652867,
0.0448677018,
-0.0250344928,
-0.0138298599,
0.0201817341,
0.0992371961,
-0.0166231524,
0.0014478681,
0.0337851569,
0.0243178383,
0.0709697157,
-0.0225549955,
0.0880948529,
0.0120076342,
0.0505126789,
-0.0260279588,
-0.0861221179,
0.0237013903,
-0.0169361997,
0.0525791906,
0.0173830241,
-0.0014807994,
-0.0118952701,
-0.0168143772,
-0.0404387899,
-0.0091703897,
0.0130598759,
0.020432584,
-0.016907528,
0.0328025296,
-0.0294882413,
-0.0018799875,
-0.0766851902,
-0.0225705896,
0.0293078572,
-0.0188887026,
-0.024698196,
-0.0085179275,
0.0006536992,
0.037528567,
-0.0698495135,
0.0144259352,
2.080475539e-34,
0.0260349009,
-0.0206987727,
0.0119593386,
0.0590334237,
0.0395899266,
0.0537207983,
-0.0534407534,
0.0156011591,
-0.0386274457,
-0.0591862872,
0.0404805467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05619v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05619v2 | Dynamic Top-k Estimation Consolidates Disagreement between Feature Attribution Methods | 2023-10-09T11:19:33 | 2023-11-03T12:11:17 | Jonathan Kamp, Lisa Beinborn, Antske Fokkens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Feature attribution scores are used for explaining the prediction of a text
classifier to users by highlighting a k number of tokens. In this work, we
propose a way to determine the number of optimal k tokens that should be
displayed from sequential properties of the attribution scores. Our approach is
dynamic across sentences, method-agnostic, and deals with sentence length bias.
We compare agreement between multiple methods and humans on an NLI task, using
fixed k and dynamic k. We find that perturbation-based methods and Vanilla
Gradient exhibit highest agreement on most method--method and method--human
agreement metrics with a static k. Their advantage over other methods
disappears with dynamic ks which mainly improve Integrated Gradient and
GradientXInput. To our knowledge, this is the first evidence that sequential
properties of attribution scores are informative for consolidating attribution
signals for human interpretation. | [
0.0346259326,
0.0246550627,
-0.0252606571,
-0.0155698238,
-0.0176348686,
0.0242882613,
0.0305748526,
-0.0125737237,
-0.0049758265,
-0.0293105878,
-0.0141628636,
-0.0082758758,
0.0505742207,
0.0228595808,
0.0405803509,
-0.0467316508,
0.0001559598,
-0.000217916,
0.0349380113,
0.0156480782,
0.0243607834,
-0.0011365013,
-0.0046609901,
0.0662598088,
-0.0385296084,
-0.0244438909,
0.0004752751,
-0.0338325612,
0.0708636194,
0.0001412034,
0.0127043631,
0.0414603204,
-0.0556001998,
-0.0007193745,
0.0000021498,
0.0064683836,
0.021148989,
0.0098045152,
-0.0312116016,
0.0093692914,
0.0309065022,
-0.00022948,
0.0375476517,
-0.022017315,
-0.0074779163,
0.0370614864,
0.0551415943,
0.0756046176,
0.0380918011,
0.0300626997,
-0.0059208022,
-0.0142946066,
0.0039226622,
-0.0038169764,
-0.0050733439,
-0.0316206142,
0.0001046477,
-0.0756733641,
-0.0475725904,
-0.0263020862,
0.0139662167,
0.0507300608,
0.0235383995,
-0.0248413477,
0.0680492818,
0.0261715353,
-0.0344033688,
0.0044110739,
-0.0229852628,
0.075316675,
0.0104992334,
0.0084470324,
0.0193623211,
-0.0168995652,
0.0038159338,
0.0031187828,
-0.0237351246,
-0.0047937864,
-0.0125629744,
-0.0321253501,
-0.033153832,
0.0335184596,
0.0240077097,
0.0231422242,
0.013161391,
0.0784018859,
-0.0276923664,
-0.0198433474,
-0.0021178059,
0.0268396903,
-0.0383705944,
-0.0540232956,
0.0380885787,
-0.0013237946,
0.0158708952,
-0.0029666591,
-0.0097151836,
-0.0530548058,
0.0094368272,
-0.0230559576,
0.0512851588,
-0.0129357884,
-0.0291396845,
0.0102024777,
-0.0023772579,
0.0602414347,
-0.0043323636,
0.0041912883,
-0.0086435005,
0.0093009882,
-0.0552972928,
-0.0416977108,
0.024996262,
0.0371612646,
0.0290569719,
-0.0103019159,
-0.0764141232,
0.0186577328,
-0.0293957964,
-0.0205245968,
-0.0072045061,
0.0243911371,
-0.0191052388,
0.023138158,
-0.0136992633,
0.0294293538,
-0.0672791153,
0.0278289691,
0.0096996846,
-0.0141718378,
-0.0230594743,
0.0574448891,
0.0014537859,
-0.0247748215,
-0.0296647176,
0.0355153829,
-0.0047326828,
-0.0022139535,
0.0171953533,
-0.0816293135,
-0.0587153696,
-0.0415347591,
-0.0486532636,
-0.0272090062,
-0.0027976397,
0.0484878123,
-0.0201272815,
-0.0154950609,
-0.0268619992,
-0.001614525,
-0.0318853557,
0.0365386456,
0.0128685683,
-0.0013830737,
-0.0139533505,
-0.0282476004,
-0.0387342386,
0.0262771007,
0.0371529721,
0.0850963965,
-0.0014999841,
0.017886959,
0.0195101574,
-0.0113400519,
0.0287401676,
-0.0153585523,
-0.0388585553,
-0.0130845271,
-0.0021631008,
0.0070368978,
0.0248749685,
0.0113230571,
-0.0192605443,
0.0050820396,
0.056155555,
0.0739228278,
0.0080657871,
0.0317891426,
0.0172390584,
0.021539608,
0.0292540696,
0.0083009815,
-0.0515955053,
0.0445281006,
-0.0267643165,
-0.0044186404,
-0.0026049176,
0.013413717,
0.0069703986,
-0.0594531335,
-0.0298242886,
-0.0055742254,
-0.0037683062,
0.0010452492,
0.0626271516,
-0.0209165886,
0.0129071297,
0.0420664027,
-0.0027602992,
-0.0434194915,
-0.0009045342,
-0.0440139249,
-0.0021229156,
0.0806764066,
0.017344825,
-0.0302343406,
0.0325135998,
-0.0163961109,
0.0588371083,
0.0047497116,
0.0058050542,
-0.015484618,
0.0285473093,
-0.0228203014,
-0.0403841808,
-0.0157295354,
0.018948812,
0.0322551653,
-0.0332445949,
0.0251735747,
0.0218398403,
-0.0626776069,
-0.0557109602,
0.036638055,
0.0560292639,
0.0035040327,
0.0108441692,
0.0349258669,
0.0171840601,
0.0398036428,
-0.0031695527,
0.0228626542,
-0.0000558893,
-0.0255246516,
-0.0065665515,
0.034350805,
-0.0063134893,
-0.0427037105,
0.0084775388,
-0.0339713506,
-0.0340315513,
0.0093249828,
-0.0280463174,
-0.02983886,
0.0368730985,
-0.05614274,
-0.0043916074,
-0.0225905571,
0.0103684207,
-0.0201804973,
-0.0156198405,
-0.0268088859,
0.0839455426,
-0.0070214653,
0.0125523368,
0.0038045878,
-0.0632592887,
0.0132496189,
-0.0114170341,
0.0029666836,
-0.0087218154,
-0.0022227126,
-0.0005940055,
0.0272939242,
-0.0280696694,
-0.0398032628,
-0.0301086288,
-0.0842404217,
-0.0338032469,
-0.0149966627,
0.0002634153,
-0.0216831844,
-0.0145689081,
0.0333337113,
-0.0335795656,
-0.0526244529,
-0.0587498471,
-0.0458147451,
0.0117269047,
0.0450778045,
0.0206010323,
-0.0166405104,
-0.0112685366,
-0.0178756267,
-0.0421424806,
0.0787322149,
0.0485014208,
-0.0330413654,
-0.0465243869,
-0.0214287601,
-0.0159703828,
-0.0421440862,
0.0059293229,
-0.0275422577,
0.0287039485,
0.0244252607,
0.0042567831,
0.1173812374,
0.0078516528,
0.0573958196,
0.0105894739,
-0.0025822301,
-0.0708503947,
-0.0151670976,
-0.0137023712,
0.0128984172,
0.0056255511,
-0.0363782495,
0.0271200892,
0.1023375317,
0.0329391249,
0.007718998,
-0.0695559531,
-0.0007660461,
-0.0070886812,
-0.0438810475,
-0.0435936414,
-0.0147047359,
-0.0070980964,
0.0399442352,
-0.022184778,
-0.0531261675,
0.1091495976,
0.0022385006,
0.0264084507,
-0.0186498407,
0.0002491561,
-0.0249965321,
0.0072391159,
-0.0114633683,
0.0135123152,
0.015556707,
-0.026574282,
-0.0083908988,
-0.0020081173,
0.0576743968,
-0.0150822205,
0.0405496173,
-0.0438704081,
-0.0142290639,
0.02995166,
-0.0418952964,
-0.0108936001,
-0.0666598752,
0.0002508836,
0.0003842349,
-0.014585495,
-0.0230522025,
-0.0361765139,
-0.0104196668,
0.0698094591,
-0.0186443012,
-0.0250856318,
-0.0002763208,
0.0221283957,
0.0117751397,
0.0353413299,
0.0032873214,
-0.0056847893,
-0.0355681777,
-0.0008291884,
0.0434513576,
0.0725247785,
0.0501012839,
0.0085894791,
-0.0200850759,
0.0071352283,
-0.0243707951,
-0.049116265,
0.0121225305,
0.0860779807,
-0.065332979,
0.0387305282,
0.0870809928,
0.0144716362,
-0.0776940733,
0.0000488648,
0.0075120418,
0.0196437687,
-0.0084884772,
-0.0023835872,
-0.0578048714,
-0.0414351635,
-0.0353100598,
0.0550291985,
-0.0126420371,
-0.0072744181,
-0.0017462912,
-0.0582414977,
0.0082568452,
-0.0069142682,
-0.0258670822,
0.0302687716,
-0.034981288,
0.0204065889,
-0.0167111214,
-0.0332131833,
-0.0171833914,
0.0321897939,
0.029794639,
0.0536651984,
-0.0386271179,
-0.0420672186,
0.0164994355,
-0.0297240876,
-0.0173237864,
0.0758027732,
0.0373131223,
0.0052666771,
-0.0378784277,
0.0045714499,
0.0055039208,
0.0750876963,
0.0055960924,
0.0907917172,
-0.0344457179,
0.0025407849,
-0.0638580248,
0.0352335609,
0.0021656852,
-0.0012077502,
-0.0092937807,
0.049944438,
-0.001885319,
-0.0022673467,
-0.0285096634,
-0.034181729,
-0.0124361375,
0.0473404266,
0.0383722968,
-0.0679326281,
-0.0531174652,
-0.0145949041,
0.0105235651,
-0.0228524432,
-0.0492697284,
0.0300201755,
-0.0024368274,
-0.0626700148,
-0.0733750984,
-0.0339924619,
0.009643618,
0.0358284824,
0.0103615075,
0.0129199466,
-0.0272935126,
-0.027008798,
-0.0589447059,
0.0367468931,
0.0265292879,
0.0271795243,
-0.023486793,
-0.0072509977,
0.0283909347,
-0.004580718,
-0.0085827364,
0.0223518088,
-0.0605391078,
-0.0564470701,
0.0081775812,
0.0474804379,
0.0179032367,
0.0537948869,
-0.020943895,
-0.078924045,
0.0704060942,
0.0553071871,
-0.0108710183,
0.0030838982,
0.0002307348,
0.0045882333,
-0.0034640832,
0.0435159728,
-0.0498403385,
-0.0048900023,
0.0244375989,
-0.0265560113,
-0.0141240442,
0.0120562157,
-0.0200091843,
-0.0113997841,
0.0622014627,
-0.020191256,
-0.0367005616,
0.0258675348,
-0.0098687336,
0.0118615981,
-0.0155608961,
-0.0219779983,
0.0415418074,
0.0195175745,
0.0020895514,
-0.0188551024,
0.0068750558,
0.0337683037,
0.0064855409,
-0.076247327,
0.0089087896,
-0.0287695825,
0.0325346068,
-0.001524156,
0.0292569045,
-0.034810055,
-0.0100420676,
-0.0135658598,
0.0440943651,
0.0356222987,
0.012554192,
0.0394674502,
-0.0140935536,
-0.0174945984,
0.0435861796,
-0.0892571136,
-0.0101553528,
-0.0402928963,
0.0017648283,
-0.0149853034,
-0.0187743455,
0.0406494625,
0.0017986074,
0.0003436631,
0.0033798262,
0.0621564165,
0.0121863382,
-0.0163871571,
-0.0300508775,
0.0199112333,
-0.0461273901,
-0.0274840333,
0.0505980924,
0.0122737298,
-0.0239116624,
-0.0583073869,
-0.0778466016,
-0.0140633937,
0.0012963084,
-0.0016380937,
0.0400013626,
0.0090696393,
0.0185930338,
-0.0668165907,
-0.0518518128,
0.0485027097,
-0.0438971817,
0.0296567846,
-0.0301699769,
0.0102824187,
0.0537113138,
0.010077293,
-0.0710117817,
-0.0247110464,
-0.0022602575,
-0.0223257188,
0.004862349,
-0.0184163675,
-6.597853631e-33,
-0.0059753601,
-0.0546937026,
-0.0878387019,
0.0586880557,
-0.0188341737,
0.0180607829,
-0.0085516647,
-0.0080891671,
0.0475733466,
0.044947613,
0.0076850955,
0.0431933254,
0.023317134,
-0.020557588,
0.0475156792,
-0.0199224446,
0.0143421711,
0.0050147008,
-0.0528884046,
0.0311323851,
0.0574296936,
0.0124658225,
0.0934313089,
-0.1150013953,
0.0884757265,
0.0353655256,
-0.0150102163,
-0.0402040742,
-0.0216377024,
0.050057929,
-0.0127225723,
0.0404791273,
0.0290998071,
-0.0672200769,
-0.0046379701,
0.0143074095,
-0.0238224994,
-0.0461185537,
0.0081333723,
0.0521809235,
-0.0527289659,
-0.0472321399,
0.0641675442,
-0.0165157802,
-0.0230873339,
-0.015464806,
0.0955215991,
-0.0046340814,
-0.0130218444,
-0.0792895332,
-0.016099263,
0.0259006321,
-0.0421841964,
0.0058324155,
0.0200168807,
0.0273648873,
-0.0033152087,
-0.0176151339,
-0.0525278598,
0.0163207371,
0.0120661724,
0.0026130772,
0.0579857193,
0.01953342,
0.0429244339,
0.06464798,
0.0567126907,
0.0043567647,
-0.0639742091,
-0.0232556183,
-0.010678662,
0.0364624821,
0.0831450894,
0.0587850921,
0.0489824601,
0.0062107486,
-0.0325345285,
0.0243105739,
0.0254855249,
0.0209222697,
0.0363184474,
0.0026590391,
-0.09889476,
-0.0446252115,
-0.0454079919,
-0.0253824797,
-0.0507441349,
-0.036780037,
0.0389770679,
-0.0143682435,
-0.0367349572,
-0.0095962211,
-0.0117610749,
-0.0246689003,
-0.0128173074,
-0.0084106829,
-0.0085245734,
0.0656281561,
0.021506682,
-0.0405657776,
-0.0341524072,
0.0338790864,
-0.0129919294,
0.050294932,
0.0649183616,
0.0224145483,
0.060058102,
0.0051754438,
-0.0330874175,
-0.0103952661,
-0.0077915224,
-0.0310343057,
0.0027459133,
-0.0223656371,
0.0480592474,
0.002227047,
-0.0409203358,
0.0425471328,
-0.0063257841,
0.0488642454,
-0.0329934321,
0.0044120662,
0.0042303461,
-0.0003516878,
-0.0445386618,
-0.0451196954,
0.0082096001,
-0.0746882707,
-0.00223636,
-0.013742513,
-0.021766413,
0.0316079482,
2.856e-7,
0.0102763874,
0.0183308106,
0.045237951,
-0.0197704546,
0.0007030929,
0.0495492406,
0.0287271738,
-0.0024338521,
0.0120506631,
-0.0386627503,
0.0104041109,
0.0108110225,
0.0716394708,
0.0244364608,
-0.0826630592,
-0.0098369364,
-0.0088591361,
0.0258410275,
-0.0371446982,
0.0173638258,
0.0387382358,
0.0186699014,
0.0195893832,
0.0125561859,
-0.0094251372,
-0.0397901461,
0.0597485751,
0.0013227578,
0.0313070342,
0.0077044382,
0.0982063264,
-0.0482628122,
0.0040120487,
0.0483402945,
-0.022612134,
-0.0004837467,
0.0293677002,
0.0508227274,
-0.0364876464,
-0.0423014276,
-0.0263308268,
-0.0071231439,
0.062465135,
-0.0336513743,
0.0409642234,
-0.0263555832,
-0.0401294604,
-0.0198108274,
0.0249963701,
-0.0569855943,
0.0346945226,
-0.0078800563,
0.0357740335,
0.0522103161,
-0.0195368901,
-0.0079188468,
-0.0117619699,
-0.0861424729,
-0.0828494877,
-0.0185410362,
-0.0238673016,
-0.0137330648,
-0.0464339256,
0.0137148369,
0.0418339893,
-0.0709606558,
-0.0203146245,
2.261405471e-34,
0.0234006532,
-0.0019760728,
0.0156450123,
0.0546739474,
0.0438100025,
0.015626194,
-0.0193198193,
-0.0008835992,
0.0960369036,
-0.076886192,
-0.0086361161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05597v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05597v4 | Can language models learn analogical reasoning? Investigating training objectives and comparisons to human performance | 2023-10-09T10:34:38 | 2024-05-03T10:22:13 | Molly R. Petersen, Lonneke van der Plas | cs.CL | cs.CL | While analogies are a common way to evaluate word embeddings in NLP, it is
also of interest to investigate whether or not analogical reasoning is a task
in itself that can be learned. In this paper, we test several ways to learn
basic analogical reasoning, specifically focusing on analogies that are more
typical of what is used to evaluate analogical reasoning in humans than those
in commonly used NLP benchmarks. Our experiments find that models are able to
learn analogical reasoning, even with a small amount of data. We additionally
compare our models to a dataset with a human baseline, and find that after
training, models approach human performance. | [
0.0255812015,
0.0729376227,
-0.0218775924,
0.0405017845,
0.0109322369,
0.0375714563,
-0.0060709193,
-0.0080643408,
-0.020134449,
-0.0412769169,
-0.0443484746,
-0.0018269439,
-0.0244557131,
-0.0343084522,
0.0448452979,
-0.0499685854,
0.022573987,
0.024747232,
-0.0005114291,
0.0087007424,
-0.0049328147,
0.0106008751,
-0.0153672677,
0.0086948583,
0.0275795013,
-0.0041756784,
0.0336583629,
-0.0294665731,
0.0197487995,
-0.0250086393,
-0.0209094416,
0.0251681618,
0.0414154865,
-0.0267511997,
0.0000018087,
-0.0362540185,
0.0557031669,
-0.0162079167,
-0.0264193881,
0.0030231678,
0.0663051158,
0.0030359426,
-0.0013019389,
0.0154394042,
-0.0552219078,
-0.0543160699,
0.0321904495,
0.0253813062,
0.0312843546,
0.0445734821,
-0.0097130537,
-0.0569977909,
-0.0131198876,
-0.018887369,
-0.0054043136,
-0.0165886469,
-0.0153606366,
0.0121309236,
0.0096120425,
-0.030440418,
-0.0233165324,
-0.0021200827,
0.0228863936,
0.0477459133,
0.0148716057,
0.047147803,
-0.0226981267,
0.0142652029,
0.0150788371,
0.0637706146,
-0.0240742434,
-0.0572160818,
-0.023018755,
0.0083878627,
-0.003517244,
0.038239304,
-0.0339292921,
-0.0064058732,
0.0258432236,
0.0376507044,
0.0357118063,
0.0363065153,
0.0249670204,
0.0315465704,
-0.0335630961,
0.0495376885,
-0.0226886179,
-0.0196147822,
0.0439839214,
0.0043842369,
-0.0031609256,
-0.0110676941,
-0.0180828031,
0.0104864715,
0.0180233754,
0.0402667485,
-0.041138459,
-0.0112351943,
0.0142412549,
-0.0877587423,
0.0729657859,
0.0464475602,
0.0104830889,
0.0536251441,
-0.0913218632,
0.0428384803,
-0.0001622102,
0.0996012986,
-0.031838797,
0.0143005978,
-0.0678195506,
-0.0152371544,
-0.0421575047,
0.0195731353,
0.033695776,
-0.009443637,
-0.0159911234,
0.0037717314,
-0.0386919715,
-0.0126279332,
-0.0136787994,
0.0458227061,
-0.0125526711,
-0.0266905297,
-0.0788313672,
-0.0326406658,
-0.089177072,
0.0324302614,
-0.0321067944,
-0.0349598415,
0.0013702502,
-0.0221960191,
0.0224384237,
-0.0499248691,
-0.0008271296,
0.0692799315,
0.0033998955,
-0.0122138672,
-0.0336840898,
0.0111511284,
0.0513228551,
-0.0382447056,
0.0059368564,
-0.0397231281,
0.0418479182,
0.0058378456,
0.0128489761,
-0.0740547553,
-0.0293889493,
0.037658561,
-0.061889369,
0.1200499684,
0.0490537845,
0.0068730381,
-0.0293525979,
-0.0058671841,
-0.0076411362,
0.0398813263,
0.0079216119,
-0.0444220006,
0.001611147,
0.0006693606,
-0.0129213715,
-0.0259776469,
0.0279019233,
-0.0131733567,
-0.0507255793,
-0.0036857047,
-0.047573898,
0.0627759919,
0.0628484711,
0.0478461385,
-0.0192266125,
-0.0733753368,
0.0348018929,
0.0533180796,
0.0316031761,
0.0156136947,
0.0521171689,
0.0029266973,
-0.0101559116,
0.0153443357,
-0.0567709245,
0.0384774134,
0.028450394,
-0.0018072254,
-0.0078062876,
0.0020995024,
-0.0366556272,
0.005314901,
-0.0470486768,
-0.002931556,
0.0057268636,
-0.0230350159,
0.0180395395,
0.0640512258,
0.0010905334,
0.005284722,
0.0373298228,
-0.0252361279,
0.007951702,
-0.0164807122,
0.0028380458,
0.0178098641,
0.0337037742,
-0.0012432532,
0.0183668695,
-0.0033727237,
-0.0014396089,
0.0206570625,
0.107309185,
-0.0225935746,
-0.0012075212,
-0.0374390073,
-0.0021744301,
-0.0445421301,
0.0313818306,
0.0082078539,
0.0056626173,
0.0080415029,
0.0099684214,
-0.0813158527,
-0.0161789116,
0.0690790936,
-0.0835219994,
-0.0389323756,
-0.0338966176,
0.0482330658,
0.0106306011,
-0.0058871633,
0.0043857559,
0.03115087,
-0.0037218472,
-0.0402303413,
-0.0292408876,
0.072951816,
-0.0424323492,
-0.0133922668,
0.0147128208,
-0.0720178783,
0.0204408467,
0.0244763736,
-0.0221511573,
-0.0116836512,
0.0451597013,
-0.0036851428,
0.1160450205,
-0.0232709385,
0.0139557989,
-0.0107810814,
0.0202936903,
0.0015355543,
0.0629405528,
-0.0099069085,
0.0387696885,
0.0019005906,
0.0505008288,
-0.0155034894,
-0.0039600665,
-0.023229409,
0.005155914,
0.0024794789,
-0.0125980703,
-0.0115999794,
-0.048910819,
-0.0499098822,
0.028065037,
-0.0222111028,
-0.0145697016,
0.0128562422,
0.0120470282,
0.0543839559,
-0.0339928642,
0.0086756879,
-0.0161403827,
-0.0183477253,
-0.0092933793,
-0.0472057834,
0.0365886055,
0.0749597698,
-0.025360642,
0.0239275284,
-0.0448121466,
0.0133534996,
-0.0419047475,
0.0658140481,
-0.024486497,
0.0468826592,
-0.0163655393,
0.0159639083,
-0.0322086215,
0.0234425012,
-0.000126605,
-0.0562302396,
0.0134118777,
0.0129628778,
0.0212982148,
0.0841578171,
0.0177819915,
0.0391211845,
0.0574776605,
0.0427466407,
-0.0854699314,
-0.0066905073,
-0.0075677433,
0.0164517276,
-0.0033645073,
-0.0191321336,
-0.0334713683,
0.0815433934,
-0.0039582723,
0.0097138844,
-0.0377771966,
0.0846677274,
-0.0154076265,
-0.0006550117,
-0.020999888,
0.0257073119,
-0.0203066412,
0.0139058987,
-0.0561696477,
-0.0049842224,
0.0864573047,
0.016232688,
-0.0044238865,
-0.0230632257,
-0.005593298,
-0.0098603982,
0.0579433218,
0.0028605307,
0.0046619391,
-0.0044537461,
0.0088843629,
-0.0536622033,
-0.0202194098,
0.0240647942,
-0.0200022012,
0.0547911078,
-0.0237753298,
-0.0022770523,
0.003273139,
-0.0527832806,
-0.0346408598,
-0.0037054166,
-0.0537590124,
0.0075604711,
-0.0556863323,
0.0026353695,
-0.0525982194,
0.0049085002,
0.0069240383,
0.025843557,
0.0206381995,
-0.0223358367,
-0.0029547515,
0.0119892238,
0.0411329083,
-0.0120684877,
0.0098735001,
0.0141881984,
0.0685972124,
0.0365899391,
0.0517312437,
0.0080132727,
-0.0738255531,
0.027577363,
-0.0014636716,
-0.0151692647,
0.0055487072,
0.0062518129,
-0.0039662956,
-0.03328529,
-0.0072357249,
0.0612690561,
0.0537914857,
-0.0146527858,
0.0374786444,
0.0119499387,
0.0229252502,
0.0560572408,
0.0180833489,
-0.0441757999,
-0.0542921312,
0.0267211236,
-0.012095619,
-0.0080768336,
-0.0384387597,
-0.0196731873,
-0.102257818,
-0.0059662829,
0.0061957249,
-0.0527149849,
-0.0432216227,
-0.0218730494,
0.0262381341,
-0.0383971296,
0.0007479098,
-0.0009260072,
-0.019784661,
0.0325708762,
0.0144370329,
-0.0101517029,
-0.0510611311,
0.0276856795,
-0.042132657,
0.1023799628,
0.0111923888,
0.0602732897,
0.0015680809,
-0.0249136351,
0.0064618154,
-0.0037564114,
-0.0185093489,
-0.0118867112,
0.04766519,
0.0025172688,
-0.0039016921,
0.0121944705,
0.0360919982,
-0.0399618037,
-0.0083601121,
-0.0333283804,
0.060136307,
-0.0052579949,
-0.0626055002,
-0.0180558208,
0.0128335105,
-0.0500578359,
0.0701514557,
0.0574261583,
-0.0248882882,
-0.0302780177,
-0.0267621391,
-0.014939771,
-0.0658039823,
-0.052524548,
0.011335331,
-0.004229161,
0.0086419154,
-0.0953432471,
-0.0631996915,
-0.0069686775,
0.0468769073,
0.015749963,
-0.0419600606,
-0.0036898563,
-0.0308111943,
-0.0301321335,
0.0330954567,
-0.0494118258,
0.0271911863,
-0.0004223261,
-0.0134768989,
0.0743122101,
-0.0406367928,
-0.0487215891,
0.0008439184,
-0.0239041243,
-0.041894,
-0.0140791899,
0.0296432786,
0.0253150295,
0.033206448,
-0.028265601,
-0.0506237522,
-0.0007200598,
0.0197407752,
-0.0058763498,
-0.0159508381,
0.0200564321,
-0.0173054263,
0.0289428178,
0.0479919203,
-0.0054664593,
0.0470086895,
0.0382739976,
0.0436530113,
-0.0046815635,
0.0428880788,
0.0537281409,
0.0094796186,
0.0115801021,
0.0405717902,
-0.0304161962,
-0.0424099453,
-0.0206487048,
0.0116943959,
-0.0134901488,
-0.0127947088,
-0.0151862074,
0.0069746422,
0.0403629355,
-0.0552946515,
-0.1215351969,
-0.0199757107,
0.071467869,
0.0202087574,
-0.0153184216,
0.0518470518,
0.0397911742,
-0.0159601886,
0.031207433,
-0.0259591136,
0.0163201932,
-0.0255079139,
0.0538614094,
-0.026628023,
0.0064226706,
0.0186690111,
0.0017485445,
-0.0303734951,
-0.0181567147,
-0.0671255887,
-0.0091911694,
-0.0272779483,
-0.0052420665,
0.037084341,
-0.0862941667,
0.0022330123,
-0.0334438048,
0.0239521153,
0.0226694755,
0.008868889,
-0.0087721348,
-0.0195198935,
0.047322154,
0.0378888845,
0.0024175288,
0.0068603423,
0.0387133509,
-0.0471596383,
0.0647002533,
-0.0497217067,
-0.0284816343,
-0.0250116903,
-0.0161954053,
0.0170856323,
0.0332445949,
0.0068114651,
0.0508887284,
-0.043326553,
-0.0862297714,
-0.0403324068,
0.0294245165,
-0.0093569681,
-0.0017760727,
0.0070463805,
0.0262308046,
-0.021788517,
0.0079386244,
-0.0379055887,
-0.0179190356,
-0.0209437124,
-0.0174326431,
-0.035063006,
-5.928813674e-33,
-0.0072267679,
0.0184315965,
-0.0034253884,
-0.0437468737,
-0.0015097195,
-0.0069483789,
-0.0397665948,
-0.0159924272,
-0.082227014,
0.0311644617,
-0.0343212076,
-0.0220618565,
0.0044010482,
-0.0225575101,
0.0105399555,
-0.0155557087,
0.0016343595,
-0.0126683637,
-0.016377423,
-0.0434286743,
0.0060203522,
0.008216464,
0.042413637,
-0.0231162515,
-0.0062629525,
0.0376242884,
0.0206669848,
-0.0085921055,
-0.000249343,
0.0535901375,
0.0030053146,
0.035750255,
0.0533810034,
0.0143465344,
-0.0148913665,
-0.0147022801,
-0.0903322622,
-0.0436802134,
0.0375236459,
0.0064093685,
0.0049489224,
0.0097664129,
0.0707877278,
-0.0126539078,
-0.0008449445,
-0.0206942987,
0.0480179414,
-0.0240175072,
-0.0108854501,
0.0550623573,
-0.0539228059,
0.0085070385,
0.0024200287,
-0.0117331957,
0.0125078885,
0.045528274,
-0.0162406173,
0.0385914892,
-0.0865393728,
0.0233674459,
-0.0579589456,
0.0054191775,
0.0356036089,
-0.01612317,
-0.0131326504,
0.0888018012,
0.0112830382,
-0.0273645855,
-0.0116530946,
0.0190523043,
0.0523666441,
0.0253310967,
0.0268969964,
0.027466692,
0.0820349455,
-0.015137122,
0.0282112565,
-0.0213942304,
0.0741954297,
0.0457417965,
0.0543112569,
0.0391968004,
-0.0404910743,
0.0136241158,
-0.0667439252,
-0.0477754176,
-0.0623856559,
-0.0514400415,
0.0262160599,
0.005346505,
-0.0127283419,
-0.0046444666,
-0.0182311833,
-0.0352897644,
-0.0132352663,
-0.0038314629,
-0.0095485961,
0.0081244558,
-0.0291687902,
0.0065882569,
-0.0330796875,
-0.0425770432,
0.008649068,
0.035708379,
0.0321121663,
-0.0062806876,
0.055143103,
-0.0052621583,
-0.0665917769,
-0.0400622152,
-0.0663501024,
-0.0321702473,
-0.0067946357,
-0.0485242121,
0.0150200129,
0.0554476157,
-0.0051318733,
0.0462176129,
0.0040149498,
-0.0612159222,
-0.0238979682,
0.0124596795,
-0.0085827913,
0.0111165596,
-0.0150457919,
-0.0202747993,
-0.0306473207,
-0.004159708,
0.0162768196,
-0.0600312389,
-0.0162487496,
0.0306090117,
2.485e-7,
0.0219286308,
0.0203217696,
0.0050375438,
-0.0218747258,
-0.0024234222,
0.0252592303,
-0.0204532649,
0.001593388,
0.0178962238,
0.0064399252,
-0.0000483213,
0.0569989681,
0.0526863784,
0.0103446553,
-0.0777400136,
0.0336530171,
-0.0993855819,
0.0046232459,
0.0103478888,
-0.0459344909,
0.0318560451,
0.0806104764,
0.0671454072,
-0.0034554652,
-0.0031062306,
-0.04929718,
0.0310746003,
-0.0411801152,
0.0445478708,
-0.0158354156,
0.0047991802,
0.0328709148,
0.0115056448,
0.0330463685,
-0.0143582188,
0.0200079549,
0.018314831,
0.017809622,
-0.0051406757,
-0.0318492949,
-0.0209738668,
-0.0239357874,
-0.0038643854,
-0.0765353665,
0.0644582659,
-0.0771929473,
-0.0272572767,
-0.0285928827,
-0.0216842908,
0.0352364741,
0.0098324595,
-0.0005016376,
-0.0416999497,
0.0215198528,
0.0442480072,
-0.0163876191,
-0.0147291925,
-0.0933880284,
-0.0396304429,
0.0418822095,
-0.0277847499,
0.0104593094,
-0.0052293055,
-0.0003339714,
0.0420768484,
-0.0138573246,
-0.0187404752,
1.535282062e-34,
0.0164703522,
0.0388934165,
0.0324698575,
0.0129379984,
0.063400507,
-0.0151318088,
0.0207059998,
-0.0079323519,
0.0436173975,
-0.0419507436,
0.0012153586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05592v2 | InterroLang: Exploring NLP Models and Datasets through Dialogue-based Explanations | 2023-10-09T10:27:26 | 2023-10-23T14:01:26 | Nils Feldhus, Qianli Wang, Tatiana Anikina, Sahil Chopra, Cennet Oguz, Sebastian Möller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | While recently developed NLP explainability methods let us open the black box
in various ways (Madsen et al., 2022), a missing ingredient in this endeavor is
an interactive tool offering a conversational interface. Such a dialogue system
can help users explore datasets and models with explanations in a
contextualized manner, e.g. via clarification or follow-up questions, and
through a natural language interface. We adapt the conversational explanation
framework TalkToModel (Slack et al., 2022) to the NLP domain, add new
NLP-specific operations such as free-text rationalization, and illustrate its
generalizability on three NLP tasks (dialogue act classification, question
answering, hate speech detection). To recognize user queries for explanations,
we evaluate fine-tuned and few-shot prompting models and implement a novel
Adapter-based approach. We then conduct two user studies on (1) the perceived
correctness and helpfulness of the dialogues, and (2) the simulatability, i.e.
how objectively helpful dialogical explanations are for humans in figuring out
the model's predicted label when it's not shown. We found rationalization and
feature attribution were helpful in explaining the model behavior. Moreover,
users could more reliably predict the model outcome based on an explanation
dialogue rather than one-off explanations. | [
0.0340064652,
0.0470773615,
-0.0143996337,
0.0606836453,
0.0028342991,
0.0347877033,
0.0540023558,
-0.0002320826,
0.0066695223,
-0.03405549,
0.018435875,
0.0276620742,
-0.0045176074,
0.0581424832,
-0.004615509,
-0.0866588801,
0.0038956059,
-0.0160391014,
0.0543397367,
0.0356020294,
0.0377670899,
0.0250473022,
-0.021702379,
0.0746375397,
0.0136778504,
-0.0108768567,
-0.0560883135,
-0.0116025619,
-0.0366778038,
-0.0058128117,
-0.0094681745,
0.0474513993,
0.0219142698,
0.0099536441,
0.0000022055,
-0.0401074551,
0.002344582,
-0.0029565892,
-0.0916256383,
-0.0226124842,
0.0162934884,
0.0353784896,
0.0512970872,
0.0221628342,
-0.0223446451,
0.0277407244,
0.0651297942,
0.0793740153,
0.0843354911,
0.0218349751,
-0.0114759309,
-0.0269007552,
-0.0341762677,
0.027777208,
0.0291818753,
-0.0150398025,
-0.013239623,
0.0169496592,
-0.0106486687,
0.0293735396,
0.0181969795,
0.0069635455,
0.0219814535,
-0.0447730981,
0.0429546423,
-0.0070483475,
-0.0041703372,
-0.0641874596,
-0.0030772537,
0.0722459778,
0.0470555425,
-0.0339336395,
0.0006034562,
-0.0137533108,
0.0065322574,
0.0256534107,
-0.0745635554,
-0.0159641467,
-0.0122482609,
-0.0203550234,
-0.0032462312,
0.0073293415,
0.0354893878,
0.0289438479,
0.0020635601,
0.0298379753,
-0.0343244225,
0.0152881294,
-0.0209067408,
-0.0228716861,
-0.0095109558,
-0.0756477863,
0.001380726,
0.0595558956,
-0.0639344379,
0.0281984285,
-0.0020744584,
0.0191597026,
0.0132489959,
-0.0257530026,
0.0044292542,
0.0329401791,
-0.0082223406,
0.0266237501,
0.0305341799,
0.0519347265,
0.0369158685,
0.012267434,
-0.0066457712,
-0.0141876489,
-0.0763177276,
-0.0391358994,
-0.0317233466,
-0.0047693704,
-0.0672250092,
0.0185261164,
0.0194961019,
-0.0007001901,
-0.0196930747,
-0.0056380783,
0.0112123862,
0.0321192667,
-0.011809906,
0.0060460027,
-0.0916743279,
-0.0010008084,
-0.075798355,
0.0047361478,
0.0255883262,
-0.0600279495,
-0.0257389713,
0.0105366996,
-0.0121746594,
-0.010168327,
-0.0167192779,
0.050394401,
0.0109081073,
-0.0031651219,
-0.0143317478,
-0.0514131784,
0.0028310618,
-0.0325909033,
-0.0445739403,
-0.0304623712,
0.0160941184,
0.0307860747,
-0.032823272,
-0.0390590578,
0.0049778013,
0.0277044661,
-0.0475902893,
0.1117110774,
-0.04847572,
0.0137479026,
0.025666222,
0.0233939681,
-0.0288018715,
0.0579010583,
0.0045568743,
-0.0225704554,
0.0500087105,
-0.0369578265,
0.0457687378,
-0.0262916666,
0.0212376062,
-0.0088065881,
-0.0181862302,
0.0372268558,
-0.0655336902,
0.0195083953,
-0.0000347012,
0.0062516155,
-0.0279492736,
-0.015783608,
0.027863035,
0.0793743953,
0.0097940927,
0.0147251869,
0.0190774146,
0.0194749553,
-0.0072193025,
0.0107212951,
-0.0337947793,
0.0422189049,
-0.0168112852,
-0.0152390758,
0.0020827698,
-0.010835385,
-0.0070713414,
-0.0912110507,
-0.0196496118,
0.0321897045,
0.0639722273,
0.0324947722,
0.010264975,
0.0390439108,
-0.0173380729,
0.0410355106,
0.0394936651,
-0.0557951815,
-0.0428925641,
-0.0751168057,
0.0475134626,
0.0989622399,
0.0386309065,
-0.0152607104,
-0.0258485004,
-0.0342676304,
0.0263127778,
0.0014077669,
0.035348136,
-0.0127880704,
0.015457103,
-0.0193193275,
-0.0300974827,
-0.0297528096,
0.0133405998,
0.006679045,
0.0227386802,
-0.0479790643,
0.0003110357,
-0.0139138391,
-0.056618467,
0.0216102786,
-0.0193333551,
-0.048142612,
-0.0016641018,
0.015556993,
0.0202120133,
0.054294534,
0.0441582128,
0.001293936,
0.0185883455,
0.0281925425,
-0.0180880036,
0.0466559678,
-0.0148757547,
-0.0266304333,
0.0162728615,
0.0069770035,
-0.0096701197,
-0.0198544748,
-0.0158201028,
-0.0340677239,
0.0107834339,
-0.0249563586,
0.0157510675,
-0.0341338702,
-0.0211492348,
0.0019370329,
-0.0004357251,
-0.0396153219,
0.054274641,
0.0373317748,
0.0195580125,
0.0509456433,
-0.0043447572,
0.0225703567,
-0.0198557265,
0.0250229258,
0.0294947959,
-0.0109598991,
-0.0117467223,
0.0087084286,
-0.0060982835,
-0.0488651209,
0.0383375958,
-0.0996634737,
0.0053514047,
-0.0167384539,
-0.0061970847,
0.0304503832,
0.0271635223,
0.0125707751,
-0.0239200164,
-0.0336069763,
-0.0082622338,
0.0288239755,
0.0236998238,
0.0613290519,
0.0196753778,
-0.0229493361,
-0.0355702117,
0.0045646713,
-0.0160148218,
0.0650914758,
0.0297131948,
-0.0030112765,
-0.0317478664,
-0.0270235054,
-0.0326584168,
-0.0094254641,
-0.0293355249,
-0.0192530397,
0.0349512473,
0.0131425383,
-0.0314388908,
0.0490134247,
0.0090365428,
0.105354704,
0.0016789256,
0.0125628142,
-0.0685977712,
0.0138146104,
-0.0117783342,
0.0025385574,
-0.0069228127,
-0.0311707798,
0.0072487784,
0.0930792391,
0.0018753158,
0.029468555,
-0.05698248,
0.0542635508,
0.0082160095,
-0.0226667393,
-0.0567738377,
-0.0463896096,
0.0032018721,
0.074720189,
-0.0216944013,
-0.0564419664,
0.0888903514,
-0.0311458725,
-0.0290824473,
-0.0441405848,
-0.0609155037,
-0.0322259143,
0.0923760906,
-0.0247575287,
0.0093531189,
0.0550254025,
-0.0273532607,
0.0082407296,
-0.0480899476,
0.0430130064,
-0.0133987023,
0.0549319983,
-0.0502841845,
-0.0195289683,
0.0144827142,
-0.0031139723,
-0.0314029865,
-0.0500790961,
-0.0556204654,
-0.0259598959,
0.0141702257,
-0.0434225388,
-0.0226495508,
0.0141994627,
0.0342791751,
0.0047789691,
-0.0057369382,
-0.0101225274,
0.005247348,
-0.0323868394,
0.02197285,
0.0688881055,
0.0147599904,
0.0054834741,
0.0756113231,
0.0174582377,
-0.0115127908,
-0.0316841826,
-0.0271153003,
-0.00260656,
-0.0161815602,
-0.0207919944,
-0.0067804139,
-0.0067132595,
0.0942595676,
-0.0602590106,
0.0009171826,
0.122344546,
0.0418495685,
-0.0258122236,
-0.0022806472,
-0.022322122,
0.0411539264,
0.0303519908,
0.0001533671,
-0.0466439128,
-0.0493446626,
-0.0047483132,
0.0395664796,
-0.0144531503,
-0.0218643192,
-0.006030397,
-0.0631403849,
0.0240625329,
-0.0379422307,
-0.0151157472,
-0.0138142044,
-0.0907431692,
-0.0078336122,
-0.0281294826,
0.0243025143,
-0.0000591964,
0.0167505052,
0.0238855146,
0.010437672,
-0.0373634994,
0.0139384102,
0.0293594208,
-0.0137020443,
0.0443703867,
0.0289657116,
0.0414728224,
0.0241345633,
-0.0088311527,
0.0018079138,
0.0100144437,
0.0290323552,
-0.025125714,
0.1077138036,
0.022846695,
-0.0123169785,
-0.0639385059,
0.0437278748,
-0.0170858651,
-0.0381366648,
0.0079887705,
0.0339311436,
-0.024453789,
0.0283472035,
-0.0172865931,
0.0142857637,
0.0006999095,
0.1045421287,
0.0623793118,
-0.0237764288,
-0.0224404186,
-0.0767994672,
-0.0084580686,
-0.0397382416,
-0.0471842326,
-0.0089459671,
0.0117676472,
-0.0145998327,
-0.0373231992,
-0.0424990468,
0.0538219251,
0.0214662217,
-0.0043863957,
-0.0042904732,
-0.0297640394,
0.0191827547,
-0.0131513812,
0.0423603468,
0.0151078003,
0.0126352878,
0.0131551577,
-0.051656764,
0.0079997135,
-0.0394710563,
-0.0135663804,
0.0161557719,
-0.0002531841,
-0.0201287735,
-0.0297234859,
0.0297628939,
0.0308928676,
0.0664674491,
-0.0111972811,
-0.0620315298,
-0.0444619209,
0.0335316174,
-0.02272618,
-0.0499150269,
0.0266737211,
0.043344643,
0.0120108528,
0.0254238565,
-0.0289000105,
-0.0179602765,
-0.0412868261,
-0.0054900413,
-0.0750570223,
-0.0647475868,
0.0201803427,
0.0021318644,
0.0408750847,
0.0169079304,
-0.0327977277,
-0.0238904804,
-0.0142071918,
-0.0122922705,
-0.0302290935,
-0.035600096,
0.0399552248,
-0.018951891,
-0.048060514,
0.014692992,
-0.0327863134,
-0.0584391989,
0.0103704184,
-0.0367167555,
0.0358600095,
0.0311957821,
-0.0119064162,
-0.0235823411,
0.0190372486,
-0.0176348966,
0.0055471607,
0.0072622397,
0.033972539,
0.0111707523,
0.0871376842,
0.0161200128,
-0.0026613174,
0.0115379933,
0.0023888825,
-0.0689066052,
-0.0773974881,
0.0206786543,
0.0086226212,
-0.0291295517,
-0.0232742708,
0.0233216714,
0.0102935052,
-0.0167470947,
0.0305674188,
0.0521672107,
0.0406227149,
-0.0375940725,
0.0207093582,
0.0327031054,
-0.0439114235,
-0.03947955,
0.053779453,
0.0051114745,
0.0165291037,
0.0256342217,
-0.0356156006,
-0.0308992509,
-0.027902158,
0.0014823601,
0.0484144166,
0.0090993159,
0.0033921059,
-0.048904784,
-0.0506388918,
-0.0269778892,
-0.0297493208,
-0.0178310312,
-0.0186606012,
0.0244663991,
0.0684908181,
0.0104087759,
-0.0268544499,
-0.0420097411,
0.0324868858,
-0.0451860167,
0.0013261739,
-0.0369151235,
-5.967312216e-33,
-0.0417328253,
-0.0725533068,
0.0052948277,
0.0081171384,
0.0234701801,
-0.023405971,
-0.0617711544,
0.0303989537,
-0.0312541202,
0.0397598781,
-0.0051916158,
0.0250143092,
-0.0018076671,
0.0044192676,
-0.0097868331,
-0.0741065219,
0.039119482,
0.0344364271,
-0.0137386285,
0.0384781882,
0.0587555282,
0.0049467739,
0.0257321671,
-0.0902906358,
0.0815397352,
0.0241911039,
-0.0074749333,
0.0357907414,
-0.0038866799,
0.0714338943,
-0.0041549942,
0.0466374792,
0.0227086283,
-0.0454501957,
-0.0044309776,
0.036161568,
-0.0576892272,
-0.0227046702,
0.0600534156,
0.0161545146,
-0.0461966246,
-0.0263155401,
0.0342223719,
0.0076998165,
0.0106858267,
-0.0138895819,
0.0524249114,
-0.0224507153,
-0.0089156181,
0.0255516805,
-0.0271153376,
0.0083076321,
-0.0684428886,
-0.0572857074,
0.0084184418,
0.0309557989,
0.0082931677,
0.0080071883,
-0.006865948,
0.0020020746,
0.0332206599,
0.0009171228,
0.047784213,
0.0149554964,
0.0084446147,
0.0595706739,
0.0167635269,
0.0192724112,
-0.0583018437,
0.0123953568,
-0.0269547179,
0.0701416358,
0.0711350963,
0.0411524028,
0.0063681602,
-0.0012388633,
-0.0112732304,
0.0307729505,
-0.0209680758,
0.0114137819,
0.0026390557,
0.015293533,
-0.0482991971,
-0.0075738207,
-0.0640911311,
-0.0089501645,
-0.050392393,
-0.0425485149,
0.0271251854,
-0.0237528626,
-0.0398887023,
-0.0137929618,
-0.0219874699,
-0.0417456925,
0.0136996219,
0.0324022211,
0.0023379512,
-0.0318643786,
0.0199091788,
-0.0278658494,
-0.0166271944,
0.0242538303,
0.0072685536,
0.0329970904,
0.0342872851,
0.0167477038,
0.0117588453,
-0.0038693019,
-0.0307089407,
-0.0115769366,
-0.0541122146,
0.0258672927,
-0.0548477322,
0.0348935425,
0.0036123111,
0.0274236724,
-0.0622808896,
0.0545245856,
-0.0045302906,
-0.0104746595,
-0.0411777757,
-0.0211842414,
-0.0207321644,
-0.0221405607,
-0.0181555729,
-0.0517526641,
-0.0140347537,
-0.0307788868,
0.0408292599,
-0.0500523709,
-0.0059931856,
0.000175727,
2.649e-7,
0.0180459432,
0.0502254777,
0.0229778718,
0.0029293103,
0.0224413071,
0.0550416261,
0.0317899324,
-0.022125639,
0.0174836013,
-0.0767460763,
-0.0022618729,
0.0386882015,
0.0393319018,
0.023404967,
-0.0475600697,
-0.0526710525,
-0.0494939797,
-0.026075013,
-0.0540900044,
0.0271699503,
0.0798155665,
0.0523184501,
0.0130356159,
0.0206553619,
0.0006874306,
-0.0277373474,
-0.0105529884,
-0.0570678748,
-0.0033278733,
-0.0109767029,
0.0543742366,
-0.0044035004,
0.0365410335,
0.0101822466,
-0.034654215,
-0.0036035609,
-0.0324746892,
0.0601054467,
-0.006455271,
-0.0646970347,
-0.0573629774,
-0.0367456228,
0.0384673923,
-0.0820589438,
0.0684041232,
-0.007956014,
-0.0321940631,
-0.0046133129,
-0.0175246689,
-0.0399074927,
-0.0108130779,
-0.0145333959,
0.0050746715,
0.026684517,
-0.0190200955,
-0.0233933236,
0.0190115329,
-0.0598645695,
-0.0407696292,
-0.0225967411,
-0.0159263406,
0.0025062708,
-0.0412549339,
-0.0366389304,
0.0494836085,
-0.0126061058,
0.0041110413,
2.316247333e-34,
0.0101859001,
0.03939192,
0.0185883623,
0.0486820713,
0.0852835253,
0.0260590874,
0.0174369905,
-0.0090569276,
0.0681045502,
-0.0355085172,
0.0043786815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05589v1 | DRIN: Dynamic Relation Interactive Network for Multimodal Entity Linking | 2023-10-09T10:21:42 | 2023-10-09T10:21:42 | Shangyu Xing, Fei Zhao, Zhen Wu, Chunhui Li, Jianbing Zhang, Xinyu Dai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Multimodal Entity Linking (MEL) is a task that aims to link ambiguous
mentions within multimodal contexts to referential entities in a multimodal
knowledge base. Recent methods for MEL adopt a common framework: they first
interact and fuse the text and image to obtain representations of the mention
and entity respectively, and then compute the similarity between them to
predict the correct entity. However, these methods still suffer from two
limitations: first, as they fuse the features of text and image before
matching, they cannot fully exploit the fine-grained alignment relations
between the mention and entity. Second, their alignment is static, leading to
low performance when dealing with complex and diverse data. To address these
issues, we propose a novel framework called Dynamic Relation Interactive
Network (DRIN) for MEL tasks. DRIN explicitly models four different types of
alignment between a mention and entity and builds a dynamic Graph Convolutional
Network (GCN) to dynamically select the corresponding alignment relations for
different input samples. Experiments on two datasets show that DRIN outperforms
state-of-the-art methods by a large margin, demonstrating the effectiveness of
our approach. | [
0.0343412086,
0.0023961302,
-0.0087222802,
0.0251169577,
-0.0007362631,
0.003794481,
-0.0205273014,
-0.0239847954,
0.0192058589,
-0.0387841575,
-0.0045514423,
0.0275740493,
-0.0020981818,
0.0262126587,
0.0486424342,
-0.0663736537,
0.0434144028,
0.0362453088,
-0.0133127961,
0.0277034882,
0.0380811766,
0.0485538356,
-0.0378863737,
0.018486781,
-0.0881729722,
-0.003556815,
-0.0057338681,
0.0481062345,
0.0257400479,
-0.0559387505,
-0.0187261458,
0.0155553184,
0.0235731248,
0.0404728912,
0.0000017986,
-0.0178036876,
0.0112052727,
-0.0035168498,
0.0167042371,
-0.0487200879,
0.0236412939,
-0.0226927456,
0.0318338387,
-0.0277606957,
-0.0146063305,
-0.0486582555,
0.0517232567,
0.0559747815,
0.0339837261,
0.0240090471,
-0.0424426533,
-0.0238525011,
0.0095697287,
-0.032881096,
-0.0205124188,
-0.0453051552,
0.0006868959,
0.0052694278,
-0.017481789,
0.0037719787,
-0.0608433113,
0.0705765337,
0.0109256711,
0.0049149678,
0.0397505648,
0.0387915038,
-0.0416026376,
-0.0116629275,
-0.0003777359,
0.1460456699,
-0.0133148823,
0.0120213963,
-0.0064277919,
-0.0031963498,
0.0087673925,
0.0373024382,
-0.0272534098,
-0.0253491979,
-0.0309478082,
0.0046098041,
-0.0946782827,
0.0102771083,
0.0511076413,
0.0115245413,
0.0212457981,
0.0068649636,
-0.0055411924,
0.0265975073,
-0.0103353243,
0.0260455515,
-0.0363943912,
-0.0281965379,
-0.0047809682,
0.0054618395,
-0.0352996252,
0.0266811345,
-0.0655264929,
-0.0221948829,
0.0177201219,
-0.0286750328,
-0.0094068367,
-0.0072289514,
-0.0416424386,
0.0493040457,
-0.0502335206,
0.0106980735,
-0.0634904951,
-0.0077538085,
0.0047388538,
-0.0466541499,
-0.031059755,
-0.0047243023,
-0.0193821248,
0.0052540554,
-0.0101711284,
-0.0626854897,
-0.057197623,
0.0165165234,
-0.038595736,
0.0721973032,
-0.0466545299,
0.0378792956,
-0.0363227874,
0.0192841664,
-0.0300691016,
0.0199940205,
-0.0481981039,
0.0162605438,
-0.0424243435,
0.0123264063,
0.0299349409,
0.013290789,
-0.0012201992,
-0.0649986342,
-0.0240463335,
0.1134838834,
-0.0118562458,
0.0004817347,
-0.0124548711,
-0.0814300701,
0.002092941,
-0.0424833931,
0.0284464508,
-0.0351829343,
0.0455534123,
-0.002193046,
-0.0144585809,
-0.0563038625,
0.0131035103,
-0.0054295897,
-0.065365456,
0.1073648185,
-0.0101830298,
-0.0355131179,
0.0318344124,
0.004350747,
0.0202343073,
0.0325103961,
0.0650856793,
0.0332964659,
0.0347440466,
0.0577587485,
-0.0487631932,
0.0306393187,
0.0502188466,
-0.012443563,
0.0001806862,
-0.008016184,
-0.0297754444,
0.0452535562,
0.0319017097,
0.0507016182,
-0.0318156146,
-0.0440365933,
0.0514861271,
-0.0050269011,
-0.0054735662,
0.0077431034,
0.0451882854,
-0.001988725,
-0.0168210026,
-0.0037272745,
-0.0685856417,
0.0698575675,
0.0104534412,
0.0203657411,
0.0236794837,
0.0568565875,
-0.01502991,
0.0294197742,
0.0226155315,
0.0081083318,
0.0375720263,
0.0071736886,
0.0331626013,
0.0190850403,
-0.0517408475,
0.0758494884,
0.0190829281,
0.0186047889,
-0.0396909453,
0.0326081552,
-0.0056808153,
0.0292993151,
0.0421487503,
0.0119172754,
-0.064204447,
-0.0188966841,
0.016605787,
0.0618594736,
-0.0083118752,
-0.0270584133,
-0.0013472488,
-0.0330916829,
-0.0483867489,
0.0070527163,
-0.0238208268,
0.0036019306,
0.0345359296,
0.0324397013,
0.0331478082,
-0.0277975332,
0.0383495465,
0.0207518246,
0.0749705136,
0.0476727262,
-0.0440212116,
0.0555739515,
0.0067261965,
0.0293427743,
-0.0004535917,
-0.0210369304,
0.0062638731,
-0.013448948,
0.0129662436,
0.043141745,
-0.0221652295,
-0.0303574223,
0.0386643708,
-0.0706679225,
-0.0270553492,
-0.0500709265,
-0.0660764351,
-0.0456131771,
0.0434655659,
0.0025999651,
0.0165794194,
-0.0049278801,
-0.0228726715,
0.0461055897,
0.051114805,
-0.0063407696,
0.0506824516,
-0.0162452701,
-0.0141525138,
0.0322795212,
0.0277691241,
0.0101364963,
-0.0266479254,
-0.0405208357,
-0.0062722797,
0.0200862028,
-0.0011153513,
-0.0054164412,
-0.0236693844,
-0.0630344078,
0.0156699065,
-0.0700314641,
-0.0107063688,
0.039098464,
-0.0109775383,
-0.0189705975,
0.0026714264,
0.0100454539,
-0.0563628636,
-0.0080123702,
0.0310956202,
-0.0137457885,
0.0111557441,
0.0543124899,
0.0294950809,
0.0058401958,
-0.0523039959,
-0.0142727727,
-0.0086333929,
0.0780469328,
0.0229401067,
-0.0619798191,
-0.0114073101,
-0.017501507,
-0.0688818246,
0.0183422361,
-0.0142926956,
0.011217487,
-0.0006175867,
0.0257357731,
0.0416257866,
0.003143647,
-0.0368662179,
0.0068161632,
-0.0212064553,
-0.0243618581,
-0.0711846799,
0.0350883678,
0.0121790776,
0.0274865348,
0.0103725307,
-0.0025281624,
-0.0411360636,
0.0040501496,
-0.0100308135,
0.0172963906,
-0.01548474,
0.0002232667,
0.0675831661,
0.0048562223,
-0.0314658582,
0.0078298748,
0.0295863226,
-0.0212700516,
-0.0630635098,
-0.0173273683,
0.0375472382,
-0.0093861781,
0.0156156113,
0.0518613458,
0.0253347252,
-0.012729777,
0.0642475188,
0.0439761281,
0.014661707,
0.026049627,
-0.012212377,
-0.0637074411,
0.0338923372,
0.0317189321,
0.0056713619,
0.0543728061,
0.0159006212,
0.0452795848,
0.0079208668,
-0.0006324326,
0.0013643459,
-0.0132289985,
-0.0319098681,
-0.0060367635,
-0.0474437214,
-0.0119550033,
-0.0052750194,
0.016325403,
0.0107702473,
-0.0096451771,
0.0376353078,
-0.0249555893,
-0.006564626,
0.0716898888,
0.0705555752,
0.0138210794,
-0.0094579896,
-0.0054466086,
-0.0261402968,
0.0431954078,
0.0275718011,
-0.0157736205,
-0.0369711332,
-0.0100807855,
-0.0206478853,
-0.0055659348,
-0.0283967406,
0.0139055802,
0.0120249195,
-0.0386983901,
0.0269078501,
0.0584061556,
0.0156113515,
-0.0602953807,
-0.011490169,
0.0795722082,
0.0280002188,
0.0194078013,
0.0262467768,
-0.1060194373,
-0.0581004806,
-0.0207659584,
-0.0489282981,
0.0379870906,
-0.0339312181,
-0.0202622022,
-0.0842548162,
-0.0214472078,
-0.0186244398,
-0.0053714691,
-0.0150444815,
-0.0050450033,
0.0310037397,
-0.0134367691,
0.0084959744,
-0.021329619,
0.0174182002,
0.0040139128,
-0.0157379545,
0.0322421528,
-0.0032959739,
0.0071948669,
-0.0955657363,
0.0377008617,
0.0354542844,
0.0394355878,
0.0203438289,
0.0075723571,
0.0247506965,
0.0169499647,
-0.0275044963,
0.0069547626,
0.0882296786,
-0.0563033484,
-0.0048393998,
-0.0222129487,
0.0013273465,
0.0086263791,
-0.0187594201,
-0.0653544664,
0.0499765947,
0.0043952418,
0.0343226381,
-0.0567685403,
0.0104785906,
0.0125446143,
0.0149207776,
-0.0133859627,
-0.0040711258,
-0.0193473455,
-0.0176132079,
0.0448839925,
-0.0191908125,
0.0245338604,
0.0230662022,
-0.0798851177,
0.0160940308,
-0.0739820749,
-0.0142044956,
0.0125815794,
0.0347829722,
0.0103681209,
-0.001189396,
0.018560987,
0.0057946756,
-0.0795962065,
0.060726855,
-0.0043523121,
0.0552768707,
0.0100069204,
0.0086395638,
0.0485310704,
-0.0316690803,
-0.0131232422,
0.035635829,
-0.0952021852,
-0.0244934484,
-0.0420606434,
0.0053657363,
0.0079862401,
0.0462235659,
-0.0328706577,
-0.0171372928,
-0.021709254,
0.0137301283,
-0.0243545864,
0.0117054023,
-0.0518209971,
0.0292133614,
-0.0073487889,
0.0280201714,
-0.0827193558,
-0.0105832545,
-0.0156873614,
0.034308102,
-0.0460075662,
-0.0595824309,
-0.0250206608,
-0.0044245538,
0.0243476517,
-0.0258806534,
0.0235394929,
-0.0397351608,
-0.0037561653,
0.070561789,
-0.0243837219,
-0.0385659225,
0.025811974,
-0.0144543191,
0.045636829,
-0.0229510088,
-0.0177252889,
0.0514546372,
0.0416521281,
-0.0429436676,
-0.0541129522,
0.0334017277,
-0.0440487824,
-0.0207577962,
0.0110796206,
-0.0058187777,
0.053043548,
0.000431081,
0.0342464745,
-0.0312531106,
0.0599254034,
0.0459789336,
-0.0151748583,
-0.051409997,
0.0302180462,
0.0036165169,
0.0404564366,
-0.0335791558,
0.054827746,
0.0723829418,
0.0222346373,
0.0242715999,
-0.0025820015,
-0.0135436505,
0.0438009575,
0.0291288514,
-0.0298188496,
-0.039439287,
0.0709606558,
0.0020246026,
0.0066694254,
0.0641677827,
0.0201054495,
-0.014769936,
0.0455494523,
-0.0083232205,
-0.0289701503,
-0.0405186825,
-0.0090800878,
-0.0113689443,
0.0235241782,
0.0041307886,
0.0299653579,
-0.0242819376,
-0.0738399699,
0.0583145991,
-0.0047460934,
-0.0275461394,
0.0236834213,
0.0336854905,
-0.0091065047,
0.0729053617,
-0.0291988105,
0.0001917524,
-0.0294699986,
0.0139744589,
-0.0139479656,
-0.0328557119,
-5.558767685e-33,
-0.065599896,
-0.0618215539,
0.0053795218,
-0.0309653264,
-0.0682161599,
0.0017353187,
-0.0037247681,
-0.0209950805,
-0.0620086566,
0.0082706371,
0.0237640459,
0.0012134747,
-0.0033849597,
0.0321245417,
-0.003356396,
-0.0164606869,
0.0149369193,
0.007767899,
0.0032992156,
0.0138056828,
0.0463389754,
0.0276581645,
0.0342420079,
-0.0740286335,
0.0349132419,
0.02721853,
-0.0428432524,
0.0263670217,
0.0426650234,
0.0564928353,
-0.0111088576,
0.0193300974,
-0.0059579704,
0.014240643,
-0.0084080594,
0.0113031985,
-0.1634636819,
-0.0079734819,
-0.0030637435,
0.0552386828,
-0.0330059268,
-0.0026046012,
0.0427836068,
-0.0188362077,
0.0501508377,
-0.0435330682,
0.0561750084,
-0.0037198586,
-0.0323506445,
-0.0621639267,
-0.0380764455,
0.0482728183,
-0.0102832709,
0.013623476,
0.0158733409,
-0.0305874199,
0.0351583734,
0.0057330998,
-0.0750164762,
-0.0094271777,
-0.0639391989,
-0.0216494109,
0.0298946891,
0.035839159,
-0.0071598561,
0.0709065497,
0.026214486,
-0.0519272201,
-0.040251527,
0.0345642492,
-0.0045585041,
0.0236454885,
0.0199416429,
0.0733447075,
-0.0016225768,
0.0043034866,
-0.054930862,
-0.0172758717,
0.0304418355,
0.0315793492,
-0.022490399,
0.0282307193,
0.0160025358,
-0.0013300185,
-0.0112333316,
0.0286684781,
-0.038848754,
-0.0422025099,
0.0066952296,
-0.0028682514,
0.0133907003,
0.08455953,
0.0352130122,
-0.0128564127,
-0.028900722,
0.0256453808,
0.0064010238,
0.0461199507,
0.0070307092,
-0.0061524282,
-0.0245509148,
-0.0232050475,
0.0518685505,
-0.0356252715,
0.0198353361,
0.0176433176,
0.0564998426,
-0.001037871,
-0.0360748172,
-0.0050471155,
-0.0149741797,
-0.0355586857,
-0.0582745336,
-0.0295051783,
0.0339578055,
0.0072356514,
-0.0591667481,
-0.011157847,
0.0411315486,
0.0242201686,
-0.0058942968,
0.0012318768,
0.00149814,
0.0132708866,
-0.0252127498,
0.0048425407,
-0.0195940938,
-0.0329313874,
-0.000016297,
-0.1050472632,
-0.0192062147,
0.0512896851,
2.576e-7,
0.0307325795,
0.0075874897,
0.0302548613,
0.0198889524,
-0.0038408407,
0.0086148083,
0.0207112283,
0.0475573838,
-0.0200123955,
-0.0178148635,
-0.0017454934,
0.0111783259,
0.0086928811,
0.042900648,
-0.0210656226,
-0.0257071927,
-0.0500496477,
-0.0071015069,
-0.0338677578,
0.0143341199,
0.0190487094,
0.060379494,
0.0111077083,
0.0134869451,
0.0031238797,
-0.0722594708,
0.0527754426,
0.0001072142,
0.0252992157,
-0.0222926568,
0.0016177114,
0.0075572277,
-0.0528602786,
0.0413734801,
0.0105349086,
0.0084561985,
0.0740051642,
0.0080949571,
-0.0126084182,
-0.0477407016,
-0.0521114431,
-0.0387506373,
-0.0019501492,
0.0009328015,
0.0492276475,
-0.0543410704,
-0.0154883675,
0.022537047,
-0.0281089246,
0.0225232765,
0.0116798831,
-0.0114413388,
-0.0350850672,
0.0409508497,
0.03413333,
-0.0133751165,
-0.0544141643,
-0.1126051843,
-0.0205069222,
0.0266444143,
-0.0211549439,
0.0018967426,
0.0019769899,
-0.0695972666,
0.0251427181,
-0.0563359261,
-0.0422943793,
1.705825285e-34,
-0.0005139334,
0.0055411062,
-0.0174001995,
0.0275933892,
0.0198842548,
-0.0434457287,
-0.0591845512,
-0.0071872612,
0.0025507915,
-0.0492161885,
-0.0090572247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05553v1 | Regulation and NLP (RegNLP): Taming Large Language Models | 2023-10-09T09:22:40 | 2023-10-09T09:22:40 | Catalina Goanta, Nikolaos Aletras, Ilias Chalkidis, Sofia Ranchordas, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL | The scientific innovation in Natural Language Processing (NLP) and more
broadly in artificial intelligence (AI) is at its fastest pace to date. As
large language models (LLMs) unleash a new era of automation, important debates
emerge regarding the benefits and risks of their development, deployment and
use. Currently, these debates have been dominated by often polarized narratives
mainly led by the AI Safety and AI Ethics movements. This polarization, often
amplified by social media, is swaying political agendas on AI regulation and
governance and posing issues of regulatory capture. Capture occurs when the
regulator advances the interests of the industry it is supposed to regulate, or
of special interest groups rather than pursuing the general public interest.
Meanwhile in NLP research, attention has been increasingly paid to the
discussion of regulating risks and harms. This often happens without systematic
methodologies or sufficient rooting in the disciplines that inspire an extended
scope of NLP research, jeopardizing the scientific integrity of these
endeavors. Regulation studies are a rich source of knowledge on how to
systematically deal with risk and uncertainty, as well as with scientific
evidence, to evaluate and compare regulatory options. This resource has largely
remained untapped so far. In this paper, we argue how NLP research on these
topics can benefit from proximity to regulatory studies and adjacent fields. We
do so by discussing basic tenets of regulation, and risk and uncertainty, and
by highlighting the shortcomings of current NLP discussions dealing with risk
assessment. Finally, we advocate for the development of a new multidisciplinary
research space on regulation and NLP (RegNLP), focused on connecting scientific
knowledge to regulatory processes based on systematic methodologies. | [
0.0528397039,
0.1099570766,
-0.0239508562,
-0.0051159365,
-0.0333311558,
-0.0003765015,
-0.0015154021,
0.012945326,
0.0116150202,
-0.0733089671,
0.0275129192,
-0.013087647,
0.0042753122,
0.0578357317,
0.0232668351,
-0.0352281928,
0.0325327739,
-0.0219708439,
0.06515982,
0.0184312351,
0.0227563977,
0.0217970647,
0.0155487852,
0.073964633,
-0.0228146929,
0.0067957952,
0.0545692034,
-0.0413482785,
-0.0042688963,
-0.0435620323,
0.0138338767,
0.0218590256,
0.0153006408,
0.056895297,
0.0000019518,
-0.0629772022,
-0.0316508487,
0.0473584458,
0.0022597772,
-0.0194485728,
0.0630035102,
-0.0186626967,
-0.0061316341,
0.0164352283,
-0.0456412919,
0.0391276777,
0.0866799355,
-0.0088773342,
0.0192724559,
0.0488919653,
-0.0298021566,
-0.028548941,
0.0631375909,
0.0054109581,
-0.0336172655,
-0.0314891115,
0.0640658811,
-0.0111007458,
-0.000105284,
0.0079122614,
-0.0165420417,
0.0623146184,
-0.0099391406,
-0.0088924449,
-0.0363731906,
-0.0003941508,
-0.0052513205,
-0.0652789176,
-0.0353124253,
0.0434364229,
0.0230320077,
0.013307943,
0.0395199209,
-0.0214677695,
0.0205749851,
0.0294202231,
-0.0197844934,
0.0824790895,
0.0040126536,
-0.0031100167,
0.0336013213,
0.0007298333,
0.0361841023,
0.055946935,
0.0226485673,
0.0537522435,
-0.0090004494,
-0.0544072986,
0.0470863059,
0.0020181558,
0.0316900462,
-0.0226749852,
0.0128210858,
0.0124196829,
-0.0086049978,
0.0519921482,
-0.0358895101,
-0.0054170964,
0.0598665103,
-0.037297897,
0.0067331418,
-0.0080919592,
0.0112735284,
0.0066809952,
0.0366388299,
-0.0091820536,
-0.0349618308,
0.0610171445,
-0.0094437599,
0.0292921532,
-0.0273550004,
-0.0429089405,
-0.0093029458,
-0.0041710497,
-0.0420298725,
-0.0051944633,
-0.0214415211,
-0.0006013231,
-0.080709748,
-0.0040938221,
-0.0337041095,
0.0239569508,
0.0025502301,
0.0144544914,
-0.0327852555,
-0.0305208061,
0.0000414784,
0.0428873077,
0.0032660023,
-0.0434902869,
0.0213423409,
0.0251432024,
-0.0028624234,
-0.0045612985,
0.0111077698,
0.1190230176,
0.0314381868,
-0.0386847407,
-0.0008339192,
-0.0734478608,
-0.0599311069,
-0.0333014987,
0.023751121,
-0.0072691748,
-0.0068867328,
-0.0312807895,
-0.016865164,
-0.0757351443,
-0.005327852,
0.0049083577,
-0.0718196556,
0.0581757687,
-0.040744286,
0.002928993,
-0.0210186709,
0.0188057274,
-0.0093045793,
0.0317159146,
0.0343696252,
-0.0223034546,
0.0462027416,
0.0197512209,
0.0510847904,
0.0249918178,
-0.0092414916,
0.0089586694,
0.0115106115,
-0.0081213498,
-0.0502903275,
0.0005568218,
-0.008442509,
0.0823733211,
-0.0121976053,
0.0145991025,
0.0515225083,
0.1059582978,
-0.0299819112,
0.0057552266,
0.0288731828,
0.0004720646,
-0.0039857747,
-0.0248633139,
-0.0174337458,
-0.0499326177,
-0.0583853014,
-0.024146473,
-0.0213473774,
0.0082261525,
0.0108963242,
-0.0363750048,
-0.0263516828,
-0.00395989,
0.0573621951,
0.0119337682,
0.0035088779,
-0.0062552849,
-0.0028442778,
-0.0052704127,
0.0018549064,
0.013875138,
-0.0321144536,
-0.0673464686,
-0.0351774246,
0.0504924916,
0.0360465422,
-0.0250802618,
0.0007780867,
-0.0496516153,
-0.0218885988,
0.0487611704,
-0.001239731,
-0.013621713,
0.0015030699,
0.0188549925,
-0.0145389587,
0.010739495,
-0.0054413057,
-0.0229264498,
0.0040946444,
0.0103504192,
-0.0336680524,
0.0301852394,
-0.0920201242,
0.0666348934,
-0.0137007656,
-0.0623716973,
-0.0558848493,
0.0033552307,
0.0113865221,
0.0120077617,
-0.0164687578,
0.0383446105,
0.0552038588,
0.015582202,
-0.0361481197,
-0.0186403636,
0.0326098539,
0.0801689252,
0.0435923189,
-0.0444781892,
-0.0431910902,
0.0061381962,
-0.0019913269,
-0.0025546125,
-0.0099261543,
-0.0373521224,
0.027158495,
-0.0000786001,
-0.0129393591,
-0.0254015345,
0.0072565684,
-0.0455090441,
0.022896776,
-0.0141647365,
-0.0059128068,
0.017673688,
-0.0478796922,
-0.0018802448,
0.019774396,
-0.0608194619,
0.0472645611,
-0.0270213373,
0.0371705554,
0.06525895,
-0.0116390279,
-0.020303959,
0.0197303612,
0.018059019,
-0.0106738862,
0.0147885708,
0.0160186626,
-0.0393595062,
-0.0393445268,
-0.014367084,
-0.002449773,
0.0250018146,
-0.0575420335,
-0.0067468407,
0.0533395857,
0.0292549711,
0.010461377,
-0.0350313634,
-0.0144737437,
-0.0259448849,
-0.0336838216,
0.0294852555,
0.037991289,
-0.0334089547,
-0.0547352768,
0.0290145185,
-0.0217446908,
0.0216134302,
0.0125783253,
0.0068035,
0.0379259437,
0.0255530104,
-0.0275851805,
0.0281306189,
-0.0148099652,
0.0580312721,
0.0708071813,
0.0361241773,
-0.0230488051,
-0.0182495173,
-0.0138191245,
-0.0310125388,
0.0044530397,
0.0139464047,
0.047790505,
0.0053739147,
-0.0273324363,
-0.01498756,
-0.0216808617,
0.0586092211,
-0.0748652518,
-0.0561688989,
-0.0177769661,
-0.0808185786,
-0.0461121276,
0.0650035739,
0.0034909197,
-0.0547641218,
0.0667884201,
0.0155324107,
0.0332427248,
-0.0527228042,
-0.0281028487,
0.0174669363,
0.0844619572,
-0.0105445171,
0.0307300799,
0.0780401826,
-0.0144321602,
-0.0208782982,
-0.0185218919,
0.038516514,
-0.0447707288,
0.052455388,
-0.0598779283,
0.0505162999,
-0.0038400784,
-0.056907434,
-0.0167924277,
-0.0544926152,
-0.0225146469,
0.0320793949,
0.0754658282,
-0.010225933,
-0.0241387878,
-0.0241883639,
0.0362060256,
-0.0268051177,
0.0234188233,
-0.0257658809,
0.0011148403,
0.0016006824,
0.042453099,
-0.0316955224,
0.0763876364,
0.0241005514,
-0.0038950988,
0.050161168,
-0.0137536926,
0.0266315676,
-0.0265612174,
0.0093542114,
0.0219854228,
-0.0305988044,
0.0247708615,
0.0507357195,
0.031149298,
-0.0552406535,
0.0184802487,
0.0302876271,
0.0018261184,
0.0191254355,
0.0311586726,
0.0196566395,
-0.0285271611,
-0.0158771463,
0.0041392599,
-0.0740879029,
0.0231911205,
0.0166923236,
0.0112496065,
-0.086198546,
-0.0482101254,
-0.0085966038,
-0.0624395944,
0.0455289334,
-0.0161245987,
-0.0154172042,
-0.0251018293,
-0.0347987115,
-0.0287308879,
-0.0390553623,
0.0782716423,
-0.0221287571,
-0.0360090993,
-0.0257974472,
0.0217217468,
-0.0818187222,
-0.0451677665,
0.00514491,
-0.0480605066,
0.0891399309,
0.0753328651,
0.022351237,
-0.0539922975,
-0.0094027994,
0.0258467235,
0.0203167647,
-0.006476202,
0.010873735,
0.0512004308,
-0.0012532608,
-0.0111983456,
-0.0649027601,
0.0089443261,
-0.0207842756,
-0.0251885075,
-0.0295769926,
0.0531440601,
-0.0371970534,
-0.0436411686,
-0.0545780063,
0.0048189377,
0.0265829992,
0.063090533,
-0.0175147373,
-0.0247741621,
-0.0543853417,
-0.062156152,
0.0095570218,
-0.0255788397,
-0.0623180456,
0.0040233564,
-0.0063336566,
-0.023388423,
-0.0607961267,
-0.0365149379,
-0.0019031784,
-0.0067891697,
0.04317246,
0.0131241856,
0.0569229349,
-0.0046992279,
-0.0043471013,
0.054876931,
-0.0085640782,
0.0070779053,
0.0153865516,
0.0085361395,
0.0076215207,
0.0731797442,
0.0023192021,
0.0681885034,
0.0138515905,
-0.0810682476,
0.031003464,
0.048440367,
0.0329352133,
-0.0050191856,
-0.0204395391,
-0.0483734272,
0.040400885,
0.037290372,
-0.026001174,
-0.0227346867,
0.0341746248,
-0.0035628635,
0.000791732,
0.0015442066,
-0.0185628533,
-0.0232435931,
-0.0016646226,
0.0181315299,
-0.0338574499,
0.00612497,
0.0423369296,
0.0464834683,
0.010300626,
-0.0707907602,
0.0185951404,
-0.0025804865,
-0.0874191895,
-0.0066930149,
-0.0214466471,
-0.0174710955,
0.0066860677,
0.0205660481,
-0.0028810303,
-0.0496553667,
0.0494246222,
-0.0293856952,
0.0332280509,
-0.0437507778,
0.0575398877,
0.0033911716,
0.0281318352,
0.0320400782,
-0.0169808902,
0.0000716259,
0.0749531314,
-0.0404333472,
0.0249273833,
0.0390578024,
-0.0074250433,
0.0196821168,
0.0161686502,
-0.0143623352,
0.0347354896,
-0.0573255792,
-0.0870087892,
0.0092557808,
0.0247721169,
-0.0079467352,
0.0092112217,
0.0115383947,
-0.0309027378,
-0.0100193759,
-0.0099924318,
-0.0228693672,
0.0003310608,
-0.0154944919,
0.0353488177,
0.0013049413,
-0.0538681298,
-0.0099271145,
0.0555919856,
0.0302078407,
0.0592373833,
-0.0267866533,
-0.0245823711,
0.0158214848,
-0.0617073774,
0.0126187624,
-0.0154254958,
-0.0148186637,
-0.0404607765,
-0.0893386155,
-0.0603894889,
-0.0126101421,
-0.003050243,
0.0176173337,
-0.0188230947,
-0.0223455522,
0.0109122153,
0.0431752875,
-0.0459888838,
-0.0271236412,
-0.0012608081,
-0.0190346353,
-0.0184452906,
-0.0159148518,
-6.186465873e-33,
0.0374365523,
-0.0514631905,
0.0123401787,
-0.0063346117,
-0.0351320766,
0.0150661999,
0.0095581664,
0.0172507018,
-0.02645633,
0.0179808345,
-0.0016540354,
0.0035969769,
-0.0021472569,
-0.0059975223,
0.0465757549,
-0.0522384942,
-0.0015520902,
-0.0210817307,
0.0206013396,
-0.0228987467,
0.006876796,
0.0083831334,
0.0065619149,
-0.0766252503,
0.1037013605,
0.0615138002,
-0.0306171998,
-0.0153249968,
-0.0179141816,
0.0552307218,
-0.0029753069,
0.0635940284,
0.0236397553,
-0.0724567547,
-0.0143768825,
0.0727134719,
-0.0203305501,
0.0057654819,
0.0001478814,
-0.0237136781,
-0.0105846785,
-0.0430145115,
0.0750215128,
-0.0148312319,
-0.0448969118,
0.0215118323,
0.0093434555,
-0.0473300666,
-0.0243352763,
-0.0480202399,
-0.0710008666,
0.005410709,
-0.0170730371,
0.0304767266,
0.0450367741,
0.0364080779,
0.0070012896,
0.007909121,
-0.0510230586,
-0.0097552817,
0.0031272699,
-0.0396334194,
0.0300917309,
-0.001422179,
-0.0029815126,
0.0596717596,
-0.0215617456,
0.0083449595,
-0.0181240961,
-0.0511526689,
0.006982028,
0.0751621574,
-0.016066039,
0.0150276916,
0.0016543589,
-0.0496971086,
-0.0650481284,
0.0205149092,
-0.0365302823,
0.0395621695,
0.0232317578,
-0.0143149029,
-0.0714648366,
-0.0364857204,
-0.0157289896,
-0.0123852678,
-0.006250164,
0.0275802407,
0.0157975443,
-0.000297061,
-0.0297633,
0.0551658347,
-0.003883878,
-0.0845658854,
0.0109954644,
-0.0254058912,
-0.0002374172,
-0.0039768112,
0.0000163088,
0.0221221894,
-0.0471714884,
-0.0139261857,
-0.0033066925,
0.0134860128,
0.0537586734,
-0.004967242,
0.0089054629,
0.0268135611,
-0.0258272439,
-0.0010003236,
-0.0056159459,
0.0238503497,
0.0424883626,
0.014165069,
0.0420190766,
0.033276204,
0.0447059907,
-0.0273445845,
0.0523528419,
0.0418191627,
0.0153659023,
0.0334977917,
-0.0233267006,
-0.0243293419,
-0.0316212326,
0.0006609629,
-0.0277237631,
0.0453025699,
0.0666595697,
-0.0563949794,
-0.0103747668,
-0.0255858097,
2.736e-7,
0.088091284,
0.0425120369,
0.0082187848,
0.0109787593,
0.0104815904,
0.0267429557,
0.0302735418,
0.0443041585,
-0.01953578,
-0.037824709,
0.0028126263,
-0.0211833753,
0.005203967,
0.0250521917,
-0.0342944004,
-0.0613931455,
-0.0511315539,
0.0202417113,
-0.0540465042,
0.0249284804,
0.0618489049,
0.0263679828,
-0.0105907908,
-0.0220062584,
-0.0423054621,
-0.0296097714,
0.0311467983,
-0.0368729234,
0.0358632021,
0.001218534,
0.0546703152,
0.0664525479,
0.011264991,
0.0245985761,
-0.0095091444,
0.0173823927,
-0.0156433601,
0.0748168528,
-0.0113124764,
-0.0122198947,
-0.0009141914,
-0.0637450069,
0.0230052862,
-0.0092638051,
0.0530120134,
-0.0403116383,
-0.0383378714,
-0.0559739694,
-0.0171774551,
-0.0180318374,
0.0448736176,
-0.0156223094,
-0.0201515071,
0.013733902,
-0.0132603459,
0.0054273712,
0.0136427609,
-0.0601432696,
0.038137909,
0.0039200941,
0.0261167809,
-0.0238169208,
-0.0004508574,
0.0099074757,
0.0018630545,
-0.0916192755,
0.0075132451,
2.550026298e-34,
-0.0165431481,
-0.0459616184,
0.0161207635,
0.0050332644,
0.0142298983,
0.0517551973,
-0.0041674585,
-0.0015413151,
-0.0146919424,
-0.0530697331,
-0.0144337593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05513v1 | Findings of the 2023 ML-SUPERB Challenge: Pre-Training and Evaluation over More Languages and Beyond | 2023-10-09T08:30:01 | 2023-10-09T08:30:01 | Jiatong Shi, William Chen, Dan Berrebbi, Hsiu-Hsuan Wang, Wei-Ping Huang, En-Pei Hu, Ho-Lam Chuang, Xuankai Chang, Yuxun Tang, Shang-Wen Li, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Hung-yi Lee, Shinji Watanabe | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | The 2023 Multilingual Speech Universal Performance Benchmark (ML-SUPERB)
Challenge expands upon the acclaimed SUPERB framework, emphasizing
self-supervised models in multilingual speech recognition and language
identification. The challenge comprises a research track focused on applying
ML-SUPERB to specific multilingual subjects, a Challenge Track for model
submissions, and a New Language Track where language resource researchers can
contribute and evaluate their low-resource language data in the context of the
latest progress in multilingual speech recognition. The challenge garnered 12
model submissions and 54 language corpora, resulting in a comprehensive
benchmark encompassing 154 languages. The findings indicate that merely scaling
models is not the definitive solution for multilingual speech tasks, and a
variety of speech/voice types present significant challenges in multilingual
speech processing. | [
-0.0350015089,
0.0537158698,
0.0085022226,
0.0548232794,
-0.0249891505,
-0.0034576822,
0.057069689,
-0.0365252979,
-0.0070321164,
0.032840047,
-0.093184337,
-0.0511008948,
0.0116352169,
0.0097717848,
0.0389566086,
-0.0346350931,
0.0599945337,
-0.0744895861,
-0.0118271634,
-0.0125975842,
0.0034354154,
0.0041982564,
-0.0246238876,
0.0034114891,
-0.0275529549,
0.0051197852,
0.0202594008,
0.0176912118,
0.0085139116,
-0.022198746,
0.0063414052,
0.041008167,
-0.010625504,
0.0757764727,
0.0000017349,
-0.0596687756,
-0.0127484128,
-0.0155969756,
-0.0770496055,
0.0017285706,
-0.0005142324,
-0.009096453,
-0.0178062543,
0.0094726374,
-0.0097263874,
-0.0316417255,
0.0591946691,
-0.003513111,
-0.0076539409,
0.0496217422,
-0.0016380979,
-0.0457933024,
0.0263424497,
-0.0214530192,
-0.0661598817,
-0.0276652351,
-0.0229588132,
-0.0197318494,
-0.0183539595,
-0.0407191999,
-0.0030867183,
0.0473012291,
-0.0024408235,
0.0239568502,
0.0091846883,
-0.0038997848,
-0.0353659317,
-0.0437179133,
-0.0243238527,
0.0482449345,
-0.0199499037,
-0.0435927138,
0.0004114599,
0.0046666954,
-0.0658548102,
-0.0594201647,
-0.0118449703,
0.0186677016,
0.0241437629,
-0.0197646953,
0.014571243,
0.0767094195,
0.0545616262,
0.0054411264,
-0.0328030959,
0.0494745634,
0.0085412711,
-0.0249333363,
0.0340373702,
-0.0180892181,
0.0182466805,
0.0379589312,
0.0316486433,
0.0093045365,
-0.0180588719,
-0.0342253558,
0.0259948857,
-0.0407380685,
-0.0051115397,
-0.0398436859,
0.0381578095,
0.0254237559,
-0.0430963449,
0.0438846275,
-0.0217816569,
0.0743703246,
-0.0050810119,
-0.024131909,
-0.0219798274,
-0.0236881077,
-0.0012378618,
0.0172022507,
-0.0077298437,
0.0088046398,
-0.0410624072,
-0.0078018676,
-0.0096949711,
-0.0107524497,
-0.0110188257,
-0.0110052992,
-0.0055423426,
-0.0354490243,
-0.0536307544,
-0.0068968632,
0.0351909883,
0.0710423812,
-0.0211642254,
-0.0003221502,
-0.0443004519,
-0.0963415205,
-0.0029276535,
0.0496975183,
0.0083388388,
-0.0272949934,
0.0578077137,
0.0641414374,
-0.0141607821,
-0.0284949783,
-0.0185285211,
0.0169545691,
-0.0125839142,
-0.0935454816,
-0.0077738087,
-0.0704390854,
0.0525093712,
-0.012469504,
0.0438717976,
-0.0065559223,
-0.021351153,
-0.0731230676,
0.0438026562,
0.0554416813,
0.0004378574,
0.0356561206,
0.0383744091,
-0.0039595971,
0.0322211981,
0.0550277941,
0.006972488,
-0.028390903,
0.0558430739,
-0.0308989007,
-0.0065432624,
0.1109033152,
-0.0121343452,
0.0059670885,
-0.0234402213,
-0.0201225169,
0.0225744378,
0.0252730586,
0.017423654,
0.0246409085,
-0.0014023718,
-0.0197498463,
0.0801365674,
0.0382790081,
0.0164228678,
0.0169801079,
0.0108196391,
-0.016537644,
0.0276942737,
-0.0264809262,
0.0023186752,
-0.0026769454,
0.0139840823,
0.0083801225,
0.0162268858,
0.0646294355,
-0.0484654717,
0.0006308326,
-0.0041385991,
-0.0590927154,
-0.0232957769,
0.0277987309,
0.0486318246,
-0.0340304375,
-0.0210419055,
0.0254287031,
0.0148804886,
-0.0381454565,
0.0354183502,
-0.0309300721,
-0.009701875,
0.0080356207,
0.0214862451,
-0.0143904751,
-0.0529567525,
-0.0388948694,
0.0065511088,
0.0519623831,
0.0314696208,
-0.0100655984,
0.1195608675,
-0.0481058918,
0.0200626981,
0.0565060191,
-0.0275864825,
0.0568389371,
-0.0314870067,
0.0240266901,
-0.0181466695,
-0.0641554743,
0.0092794318,
-0.0093485732,
-0.0382874757,
-0.0260288306,
0.0455371402,
0.0231455173,
0.0347242914,
0.0783365145,
-0.0450808406,
-0.0257398691,
0.027432261,
-0.0236349329,
0.031997107,
0.0435173064,
-0.0414767079,
-0.0201033801,
0.0626510158,
-0.0036024216,
-0.009712453,
0.0561926439,
0.0061538173,
-0.0686604232,
0.0169964246,
0.0201086476,
-0.005786919,
-0.0545523278,
0.0261160862,
-0.0281929374,
0.0370965078,
0.0298042968,
0.0025000484,
0.0222763754,
0.0182225816,
0.0275470428,
-0.0068017626,
0.0473395288,
-0.0735950842,
-0.0697399303,
0.0578298643,
-0.0355474055,
0.0272226129,
0.0276525225,
0.0235548839,
-0.0075211874,
0.0100796586,
-0.0624816082,
0.0139621431,
-0.0544930287,
0.0388615169,
-0.016982846,
0.0214367621,
-0.0466762371,
-0.0555197224,
-0.0080885803,
-0.0587578639,
0.0194789246,
0.0040560067,
-0.0410166048,
-0.0036834409,
0.0207714792,
-0.0280792117,
-0.0179162938,
0.0333298966,
-0.0034117878,
-0.0159911159,
-0.0667429641,
-0.0067613688,
-0.0267590955,
-0.0290834475,
0.0245359465,
0.0011038918,
-0.0348688662,
-0.0403797068,
0.0243646298,
0.0255543347,
0.0507374033,
-0.0419436097,
-0.0202351604,
0.0350272879,
0.0123949265,
-0.0302044973,
0.0121635469,
0.0074470309,
0.0022860619,
-0.0309018735,
0.0258292872,
-0.0173385311,
0.044995714,
0.0035690502,
0.0176643673,
-0.0090112202,
-0.0357029438,
-0.0235821847,
-0.0332915336,
0.0057210387,
0.0135935806,
-0.0209951978,
0.0449789427,
0.0150965238,
-0.0497484505,
0.022295529,
-0.0772211626,
-0.0483767688,
-0.0443933643,
-0.053643465,
-0.0064652106,
0.0263985991,
-0.0157564674,
0.0275718644,
-0.026258219,
-0.0360287651,
-0.0172248203,
0.0118095102,
0.0278928671,
-0.0257125832,
0.0295498166,
-0.0180888977,
-0.0040439074,
-0.0189026371,
-0.0696165189,
-0.0192560088,
0.0066867406,
-0.0180826634,
0.0202800632,
-0.0179180931,
-0.0083953291,
-0.0395113677,
0.0282585751,
-0.0107742455,
0.0546542853,
-0.0112652304,
0.0522222146,
0.002696624,
0.0534706935,
-0.0018791617,
0.0276576448,
0.0411022417,
-0.0253916252,
0.0271514133,
-0.0243247822,
0.0735706836,
0.0074841054,
-0.0421884209,
-0.0052492772,
0.0423132107,
-0.0057542408,
-0.0090634823,
0.0019529306,
0.0525009893,
-0.0086913388,
0.0261966605,
0.0993769392,
-0.0130686769,
-0.0124478368,
-0.0081028529,
-0.0043177204,
0.0206081215,
0.0149446977,
-0.0016266712,
-0.0470705368,
-0.0197435971,
0.0267663244,
0.0246180296,
0.0211655349,
0.0053800554,
0.0129700294,
-0.0699406043,
0.0152710788,
0.0260262042,
-0.0369725823,
-0.0366171673,
-0.0531951711,
-0.0382613316,
-0.0742678642,
0.0165069588,
-0.0410838313,
0.009511197,
-0.034235701,
0.0314653926,
-0.0418211557,
-0.0762660578,
0.0414835736,
-0.0531565212,
0.057952825,
0.0346999317,
0.0074210772,
-0.0353970565,
0.0275931079,
0.0349578969,
-0.0348895043,
-0.0112079838,
-0.0359865502,
0.0235072747,
0.0059604864,
-0.0203025211,
0.0255680792,
0.0060872966,
-0.0037027397,
0.0223350357,
0.0417372696,
0.0624862909,
0.0033195312,
-0.0003288381,
0.0330876037,
0.0018296952,
0.008719692,
0.0548080355,
0.0259860009,
-0.0019705945,
-0.0158090517,
0.0349912271,
0.0434650518,
-0.0308823828,
0.00688553,
0.0080592074,
0.0228680409,
-0.0459218509,
-0.0143363131,
-0.0425833985,
-0.0208356716,
0.0271449145,
0.0315873399,
0.0175570995,
-0.0252402723,
0.018016519,
-0.0428301096,
0.0352490991,
0.0094621032,
0.0424370728,
-0.0885715708,
0.0120165739,
0.0332595445,
-0.0098858215,
-0.0037520151,
0.0309187248,
-0.0798791274,
-0.0585783795,
-0.0192561056,
0.0499763452,
0.0209535342,
0.0650148839,
-0.0166718513,
-0.0419102199,
0.0079624262,
0.0207384266,
-0.0483138748,
0.0193730853,
0.0885850489,
-0.0343908593,
-0.0447728634,
0.0432166569,
-0.0249753762,
0.0421764851,
0.0192707404,
0.0164094716,
0.0145273181,
-0.0700137913,
-0.0314217992,
0.0292223413,
0.0495555922,
-0.0353018492,
0.0033530812,
-0.050386779,
0.0142004387,
0.0298842639,
0.0334831811,
-0.0135105839,
-0.0154515048,
0.0394571088,
0.0504199602,
-0.0104168663,
0.0342267826,
-0.0055457139,
-0.0150259417,
-0.0355865583,
0.0600203313,
0.0304005835,
-0.0102061843,
-0.0186787564,
0.0127466777,
-0.0187430512,
0.0466227159,
0.0399594791,
0.0276801474,
-0.0009426748,
0.0186500568,
-0.0227302611,
0.0289577879,
-0.0152427256,
0.0042608813,
-0.0097417543,
-0.0529244393,
0.0047331438,
-0.0167016722,
0.0683098212,
-0.0182130337,
0.0627315268,
-0.0191080812,
0.0062958822,
-0.0761480778,
0.0128691085,
-0.0429167114,
0.0099714939,
-0.010955967,
-0.0204857998,
-0.0240017828,
0.042944558,
0.0512851402,
-0.0045564757,
0.0067580971,
0.043548543,
0.0687652156,
-0.0149246641,
-0.0502837934,
-0.0035724575,
0.0008511531,
-0.0392310545,
-0.0152163217,
-0.0174541567,
-0.074775368,
0.0555178113,
0.0032517838,
0.0238469448,
-0.0062251319,
0.0067813476,
0.0430425219,
-0.0320511907,
0.0361145809,
-0.0130161149,
-0.0279673506,
0.0147876842,
0.0199716017,
0.0241848454,
-5.754261212e-33,
0.0213087164,
0.0301661082,
-0.0183600932,
-0.0282018483,
-0.013846009,
0.0128679415,
-0.0246969443,
0.0291831139,
-0.0288362801,
-0.0376590379,
-0.0183498617,
-0.0144959874,
0.0376321822,
0.0300513543,
0.0019778681,
-0.0035065252,
0.0886324495,
0.0024566164,
-0.0125836376,
0.0152794747,
0.008857294,
0.0433452092,
0.087034747,
-0.0656636506,
-0.0130817564,
-0.0142976642,
-0.0092514614,
0.004964395,
0.0232583396,
0.0795175284,
-0.0383475758,
0.0472977981,
0.0145365037,
-0.02537876,
-0.0262316316,
-0.0218819026,
-0.0897315294,
-0.0316722654,
0.001494157,
0.0494443811,
0.0091156736,
0.0053058043,
-0.0014864412,
-0.0259323753,
-0.0635238215,
-0.0081014503,
0.0063979281,
-0.0120563451,
-0.0165726151,
-0.0236468762,
-0.0448198281,
0.0549376234,
-0.0182297621,
0.0097632073,
0.0861059651,
0.0483117737,
-0.0315989256,
-0.0116537362,
-0.0711967945,
0.0236216784,
-0.0127908187,
0.0253325254,
0.0963001624,
0.0335216522,
-0.0276757739,
0.0121749155,
0.0934792235,
-0.0471408628,
0.049631197,
-0.0096164066,
0.05690258,
-0.0048015509,
0.0634719953,
0.075313054,
0.0124351606,
-0.0249155685,
-0.045227576,
-0.0170083363,
0.0995985046,
-0.0229725819,
0.0031911437,
-0.0069065909,
-0.0406157449,
0.0002184181,
-0.0605275594,
-0.0395431668,
-0.0206578951,
-0.0018819658,
0.0609444715,
-0.0355638787,
0.0164407641,
0.0328504257,
0.092237778,
-0.0330822393,
-0.0127694923,
0.0203365721,
0.0098614013,
-0.0032729076,
0.0020323691,
0.0779269189,
-0.0604798198,
-0.0448153727,
-0.0277482253,
0.0132695595,
0.0146200871,
-0.0393223353,
0.0106515437,
0.0514695235,
-0.0462769084,
0.0162656046,
0.0051750927,
-0.0018463567,
0.0149281574,
0.0637510791,
0.0320712291,
-0.0222686362,
0.0076041603,
0.0689966083,
0.0099015236,
0.0165601671,
0.0006475986,
-0.0189282838,
-0.0052094804,
0.0404484645,
-0.0105221132,
-0.0078951111,
-0.0395775065,
-0.0260436013,
-0.0001714219,
-0.0319600329,
0.0226681326,
0.0082596792,
2.403e-7,
-0.0018527095,
-0.0077529619,
0.0458531864,
-0.0350679792,
0.0150097236,
0.0111816861,
-0.0624759309,
-0.0208871216,
-0.0369159468,
0.0461033098,
0.0010027688,
0.0058846301,
0.0952956453,
0.0032917806,
-0.0712529495,
-0.0020518766,
-0.0747977048,
0.0225425549,
-0.051750429,
0.0197352953,
-0.0479290858,
0.0950889289,
-0.0331238247,
-0.0098589612,
-0.0172798689,
-0.0386113673,
0.0162124746,
-0.0355164036,
-0.0045186216,
0.0218284819,
-0.0187271293,
0.0175989959,
-0.0195604749,
-0.0103887646,
-0.0526071303,
0.0521203615,
0.0284519996,
0.0694187507,
-0.0018304707,
-0.0267697722,
0.0367156565,
0.0338488631,
-0.0432824828,
-0.0394518562,
0.0526314713,
0.0211384855,
-0.0395080522,
-0.0103337849,
-0.0045339507,
0.0141856177,
0.0479883105,
-0.0469998047,
-0.0283323545,
0.0582312159,
0.0322919115,
-0.0397660583,
-0.056628488,
-0.0301783886,
-0.0034735517,
0.0103650093,
-0.0327500701,
-0.0031227306,
-0.0149607481,
-0.0044823913,
0.0083319889,
-0.0273761097,
0.0067515783,
1.730532478e-34,
0.0325154178,
-0.0295179971,
0.0105210384,
-0.0178157911,
-0.0315241814,
-0.0618278384,
-0.0702143461,
0.0161017776,
-0.0271752123,
0.0153775299,
-0.0123236524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05506v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05506v2 | Query and Response Augmentation Cannot Help Out-of-domain Math Reasoning Generalization | 2023-10-09T08:18:58 | 2023-11-01T08:41:02 | Chengpeng Li, Zheng Yuan, Hongyi Yuan, Guanting Dong, Keming Lu, Jiancan Wu, Chuanqi Tan, Xiang Wang, Chang Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In math reasoning with large language models (LLMs), fine-tuning data
augmentation by query evolution and diverse reasoning paths is empirically
verified effective, profoundly narrowing the gap between open-sourced LLMs and
cutting-edge proprietary LLMs. In this paper, we conduct an investigation for
such data augmentation in math reasoning and are intended to answer: (1) What
strategies of data augmentation are more effective; (2) What is the scaling
relationship between the amount of augmented data and model performance; and
(3) Can data augmentation incentivize generalization to out-of-domain
mathematical reasoning tasks? To this end, we create a new dataset, AugGSM8K,
by complicating and diversifying the queries from GSM8K and sampling multiple
reasoning paths. We obtained a series of LLMs called MuggleMath by fine-tuning
on subsets of AugGSM8K. MuggleMath substantially achieves new state-of-the-art
on GSM8K (from 54% to 68.4% at the scale of 7B, and from 63.9% to 74.0% at the
scale of 13B). A log-linear relationship is presented between MuggleMath's
performance and the amount of augmented data. We also find that MuggleMath is
weak in out-of-domain math reasoning generalization to MATH. This is attributed
to the differences in query distribution between AugGSM8K and MATH which
suggest that augmentation on a single benchmark could not help with overall
math reasoning performance. Codes and AugGSM8K will be uploaded to
https://github.com/OFA-Sys/gsm8k-ScRel. | [
-0.0172429103,
0.0916715413,
-0.0156772006,
0.0523448475,
-0.0202001352,
0.0438792668,
0.000472659,
-0.0105894776,
-0.0225897487,
-0.0085647479,
-0.0369993784,
0.0119857835,
-0.0262469538,
0.0110845473,
0.0388363712,
-0.0364315026,
0.0469309203,
-0.0603712201,
-0.0149988234,
-0.0085156457,
-0.0413693376,
-0.0110924812,
-0.0297895912,
-0.0215241853,
-0.0010055773,
-0.0349472389,
0.0055548968,
-0.025926508,
0.0098297214,
-0.0222198218,
-0.0279448908,
0.028323682,
0.0311486144,
0.0532186143,
0.0000023217,
-0.0599852428,
0.0147083094,
0.0106232762,
-0.0539301857,
0.0043204278,
-0.0269327126,
-0.0051538879,
0.0474820584,
0.0008402911,
-0.0774498358,
0.0040394505,
0.0160612781,
0.0064380425,
0.0250880774,
0.0703028291,
0.018001955,
-0.0542277396,
0.0477067754,
-0.0109937927,
0.0928278491,
-0.0363653824,
0.0000690425,
0.0358400792,
0.0619575977,
0.0370542891,
-0.0362014696,
0.0143281696,
0.0604353137,
0.0074196118,
0.000777208,
0.0168282799,
-0.0495972671,
0.0260291696,
0.0323659554,
0.0596139655,
0.0299123172,
-0.0161764435,
-0.0363631323,
0.01555683,
0.0115931686,
0.0199445803,
-0.1037391201,
0.0080551179,
-0.0058772634,
-0.0104175648,
-0.0282769166,
0.0018685166,
0.042318482,
0.0410840325,
-0.0770664588,
0.1097882017,
-0.0001167523,
-0.0231018476,
-0.0088765649,
-0.0137658278,
-0.0613307767,
-0.0214439444,
0.0259419009,
0.0537286028,
-0.0002048203,
0.0016083572,
-0.0137410611,
-0.0711568072,
-0.0178212784,
0.0221082326,
0.0327796526,
0.0976803526,
0.0033759798,
0.0444597043,
-0.0397935174,
0.0405407399,
-0.035955444,
0.0555385649,
-0.054462757,
0.007810913,
-0.0547803938,
-0.0263038017,
-0.0087324129,
0.0614970326,
-0.0089598373,
0.0078042797,
-0.0418611094,
0.020052094,
-0.0158964265,
-0.0039810496,
-0.006795892,
0.0070524355,
-0.0148058115,
-0.0268584546,
-0.0639736056,
-0.0036459824,
-0.0641580895,
0.0370894447,
0.0199049395,
-0.0567834042,
-0.0273827277,
-0.018293092,
0.0016350944,
-0.0450923033,
0.0340738595,
0.0685807168,
0.006819936,
-0.0088576404,
-0.0229868107,
-0.0063478304,
0.0639595389,
-0.0671391562,
0.0150497239,
-0.0675588995,
0.0539066084,
0.0230632126,
-0.0378134437,
-0.0079358304,
-0.008233753,
0.0156050287,
0.0093919113,
0.0510579571,
-0.0105991503,
0.0070143458,
0.0243173577,
0.0021840297,
-0.0304600652,
0.087155439,
0.0111402962,
-0.0405172072,
0.0158177968,
-0.015532203,
0.0158218574,
0.0094527593,
0.0179673526,
-0.0081748934,
-0.0062936321,
0.0466656573,
0.0210851133,
0.0449703671,
-0.004001556,
0.0182872601,
-0.0777553022,
-0.0316639133,
0.021728171,
0.0360937491,
0.0299523994,
0.004793236,
0.0059600137,
-0.0431163907,
0.0338429585,
-0.0034169478,
-0.0938720778,
0.0397908576,
-0.0157668591,
0.0104460558,
0.0011394346,
0.0155207571,
-0.0225503854,
-0.0872028843,
0.0087247817,
0.0300245266,
0.0036303084,
0.0443689227,
0.0868699104,
0.0047886423,
0.0328364782,
0.0196451694,
0.0109738456,
-0.0261861086,
0.004518209,
-0.0510527715,
0.0217158347,
0.0089097517,
0.0506110899,
-0.0606556721,
-0.058806859,
-0.0056102192,
0.020888472,
-0.0062087784,
0.0287879631,
0.0115202358,
-0.0029978147,
-0.0452977642,
-0.002075752,
-0.0581599027,
0.0028037315,
-0.0187154524,
0.0495520346,
0.004117697,
0.0151967192,
-0.0895147398,
0.036239665,
0.0176282544,
-0.0615383238,
-0.0455190614,
-0.0055804634,
-0.0140044922,
-0.0181644503,
-0.0020654707,
0.0371570401,
0.0411555208,
-0.0097342376,
-0.0210944843,
-0.007442344,
-0.015450988,
-0.0330535769,
-0.0262324493,
0.049221009,
-0.0479125753,
-0.0101133073,
-0.0041131177,
-0.0497333519,
-0.0211754479,
0.087371029,
-0.0140507938,
0.029288169,
-0.0242174957,
0.0183060262,
-0.0174985081,
-0.0223740004,
-0.0200819559,
0.0682357699,
0.0143767139,
-0.0159358233,
-0.0024712509,
0.0301316008,
-0.0017371312,
-0.0013296506,
0.0354808234,
-0.011403692,
-0.0238288157,
0.0037503936,
-0.0531322733,
-0.0277281385,
-0.0553396493,
0.0107337674,
-0.0257474035,
0.0068883058,
0.0041267085,
0.0534193963,
0.0130178379,
0.0115750348,
-0.0067364154,
0.0010450055,
-0.0187018719,
-0.0089500593,
0.0142957559,
0.0252615605,
0.003916028,
0.0221427511,
-0.0055665402,
0.0126645155,
-0.0385927036,
-0.0394281112,
0.0525170937,
0.0032089248,
0.0500147417,
-0.0122623416,
-0.0300256629,
-0.0761598721,
-0.0092154825,
-0.0328757204,
0.0365747549,
0.0236378405,
-0.0452247187,
-0.0133017618,
0.0544021986,
-0.022469325,
-0.0354115739,
0.0268164128,
-0.0104715787,
-0.0446543247,
0.0314543657,
-0.0163069461,
-0.0034206973,
-0.0016862252,
0.0240422245,
-0.0023762661,
0.0336499959,
-0.0567212291,
-0.0299543533,
0.0015494293,
0.0388015918,
0.000055649,
-0.0338414125,
-0.0529533885,
-0.0061131064,
-0.0112284319,
0.0660126358,
-0.003280421,
-0.0437337272,
0.0553402193,
0.0315988697,
-0.0163538419,
-0.0734483376,
0.0140183447,
-0.0560209081,
0.0515548252,
-0.0194568057,
-0.0181402899,
-0.0368843041,
-0.0187766608,
-0.0342135951,
-0.0270710085,
0.037134666,
-0.0347096696,
0.0956927314,
-0.0258043595,
0.0044599283,
-0.0128974058,
-0.0405625664,
-0.035426382,
0.0399491638,
-0.0232338477,
0.0164785851,
-0.0276935603,
-0.0399035886,
-0.014038017,
-0.0324567556,
0.0339506455,
0.0252911597,
-0.0697207078,
-0.026372185,
0.0046878429,
-0.0461844206,
0.005200787,
0.0457973368,
0.0406924412,
-0.0697746202,
0.0054835328,
0.0203910861,
0.0451383404,
-0.0641515031,
-0.0119484337,
0.0291725323,
0.0119049521,
-0.0162527934,
-0.0353791416,
0.0178975947,
0.0230707806,
-0.0870757252,
-0.0152764963,
0.0763211995,
0.0175343491,
0.0092568025,
0.0069813081,
-0.0818779469,
0.020501554,
0.0501974039,
0.0391846783,
-0.0955145285,
-0.021128701,
0.0315768011,
0.0124202399,
0.020424882,
-0.0352621861,
0.0018350997,
-0.1233278438,
0.0204715934,
0.0327229053,
-0.0680155456,
-0.0056870324,
-0.0132159842,
0.0199814793,
0.0010311736,
0.0163655598,
0.0280164089,
-0.0021843086,
0.0344671607,
0.023340743,
0.0412842892,
-0.022541821,
-0.0224409439,
-0.0248980746,
-0.0458614342,
0.0010155445,
-0.0153920827,
-0.0067175534,
-0.0721277669,
0.0641935393,
0.0556078553,
0.0055741663,
-0.0210172068,
0.0234493874,
0.0157675389,
-0.0019591639,
-0.0219679307,
0.0354202054,
-0.0365999602,
-0.0222867224,
0.0203783773,
0.1121646911,
-0.0281519294,
0.001249109,
-0.0405347981,
-0.0110209947,
-0.0776346698,
0.0339370519,
0.0123511748,
0.0108553534,
-0.0306470357,
-0.0527347215,
-0.0410640165,
-0.0565788932,
0.0072733331,
0.0382463522,
0.0516253039,
-0.0128428573,
-0.0185835194,
-0.0145075554,
0.0513695255,
0.0535063334,
-0.0063761398,
0.0063748681,
-0.0016260548,
-0.0097698132,
-0.0152547704,
0.0256596562,
-0.0563090257,
0.0179522466,
-0.0097386362,
0.0293410346,
-0.0108478693,
-0.0489870682,
-0.0287307594,
-0.0084743071,
-0.0836473852,
-0.0502074324,
-0.0030828852,
0.0345843397,
0.0311215576,
0.0175040998,
0.00454927,
-0.0287029929,
-0.0002278206,
0.0562623218,
-0.0499838181,
0.026523415,
0.0245046001,
-0.025595801,
0.0187144522,
0.0022038564,
-0.0172905102,
0.0098562371,
0.0327301323,
0.0470176823,
-0.0126300193,
0.0427969843,
-0.0010310449,
0.0440684035,
0.0127082057,
0.0558096804,
0.0013852017,
-0.0051416988,
0.0474225469,
-0.0385157205,
-0.0070008524,
-0.0022734201,
-0.0208662432,
0.0285156053,
0.0101834796,
0.0332913063,
-0.0171203669,
0.031795457,
0.0502116345,
-0.0014431673,
0.049719654,
-0.0104034729,
0.0285476707,
0.0338538662,
-0.0098448554,
0.0163167864,
0.0076764659,
0.0039925287,
0.0600627437,
-0.0230734441,
0.0317708589,
0.0241354629,
0.0258115139,
-0.0430390313,
-0.0343653932,
-0.0926982239,
-0.0771635696,
0.0179230794,
-0.001758521,
-0.0177842751,
-0.0049828584,
-0.0367252938,
-0.0095277932,
-0.0165805202,
0.0015604071,
0.0046448857,
0.0154890195,
-0.006167009,
0.0344891921,
0.0356636755,
0.0133308852,
-0.0570948571,
0.021967154,
-0.0513139628,
0.036484044,
0.0009110501,
0.0268449225,
-0.0104808295,
-0.0453260988,
-0.0126518402,
0.0241719726,
0.0022189552,
0.0038826871,
-0.0503406748,
-0.0845939741,
-0.051520206,
-0.0052483701,
-0.0185798761,
-0.0199030079,
0.0348841138,
0.0659082979,
-0.002787088,
-0.0202580485,
0.0497399718,
0.0370818526,
-0.0397938415,
-0.0284584239,
0.0011234232,
-6.017906595e-33,
0.008635723,
0.0141775692,
0.0561042763,
-0.0432129428,
-0.017314231,
-0.0407582,
-0.0216297004,
0.0223585516,
-0.0561344959,
-0.0114748906,
-0.0250564944,
0.0416238606,
-0.0005408895,
0.0150059666,
0.0115609616,
-0.0394141898,
-0.0064830063,
-0.0001562438,
-0.034383662,
0.0023072935,
0.0107128816,
0.0176672228,
0.0711057112,
-0.0428080596,
-0.0213543419,
-0.0141201299,
-0.0005766007,
0.0309785269,
-0.059089642,
0.0657414943,
0.010308682,
0.0266343877,
0.012488272,
-0.0287064482,
-0.0221069828,
-0.0179619286,
-0.0545639731,
-0.0498272814,
0.0233455226,
0.0113277957,
-0.0449110717,
-0.0358942226,
0.0478783846,
0.039056167,
-0.0289616734,
-0.0630599186,
0.0086566918,
-0.0399289913,
-0.0112841381,
0.0293741655,
-0.0292175841,
0.022212863,
-0.0206764229,
0.0303775463,
0.0069191884,
0.035649702,
-0.0185084008,
0.0388721228,
0.0135230226,
0.0272250269,
0.0475319512,
0.0024231167,
0.0560162254,
0.0243518576,
0.0245690141,
0.0051284488,
0.0259318966,
-0.0151275015,
-0.0305682272,
0.0080805896,
0.039109461,
0.0773590878,
0.0506913848,
0.0255254619,
0.08002913,
0.022596037,
-0.0673558787,
0.0096530449,
-0.0103593459,
0.035474021,
-0.0014439541,
0.0279859006,
-0.0323834717,
-0.0189382359,
-0.026526114,
0.0711474791,
-0.0682407171,
-0.0273018889,
0.0194233526,
-0.0048172399,
-0.0185771268,
0.0280713085,
0.0105492324,
-0.0394668058,
-0.0231823679,
0.0328701288,
-0.005175292,
-0.001037074,
0.0071768565,
0.0205788855,
-0.0270365998,
-0.0394699536,
0.0090435687,
0.0054866034,
0.0185618233,
0.0076030483,
0.0371071696,
0.0221077111,
-0.0421809368,
-0.0235026684,
-0.0333723649,
-0.0086443443,
0.0467751026,
0.0375897028,
0.0352535583,
0.0361562744,
0.0106124179,
0.0505768918,
-0.0000908695,
-0.0043173037,
-0.0563440174,
-0.0017402858,
-0.0123633668,
0.0266178492,
-0.0116507346,
0.0000421371,
-0.0124622956,
-0.0322911143,
0.026259169,
-0.088760227,
-0.0322804153,
0.0593064986,
2.952e-7,
0.0720135123,
0.039872393,
0.0060182498,
0.0484104455,
0.002401246,
0.0178050511,
-0.0409396291,
-0.0463146754,
0.0415026695,
-0.0412134975,
-0.0062373108,
0.0643905327,
0.0168322064,
0.0371793024,
-0.0205002259,
0.0267336406,
-0.0129786236,
-0.0061702151,
-0.0599634647,
0.0178684443,
0.0138952993,
0.0826916099,
0.0334905684,
-0.0157876462,
0.0245774314,
-0.0459286496,
0.0391634293,
-0.0108444374,
0.0169543978,
-0.0000407556,
-0.0323083848,
0.0322766826,
0.0487085506,
0.0295925997,
-0.0051367078,
0.0324384719,
0.0119086131,
0.0158687979,
0.0176735651,
0.0352983773,
-0.0233990289,
-0.0229245704,
0.0184650943,
-0.0782355517,
0.0992879346,
-0.025880456,
-0.0431376733,
-0.0048111342,
-0.0173054151,
-0.0228955727,
0.0022955204,
-0.0109591391,
0.0345351659,
-0.0098503744,
0.037397936,
-0.0091443025,
0.0003219591,
-0.062537916,
-0.0281967577,
0.034375865,
-0.0644010976,
-0.0459125414,
-0.059852358,
0.0491767414,
0.0285237022,
0.0209285226,
-0.0210269727,
2.800655698e-34,
0.0357395485,
-0.0049922438,
0.0541349873,
0.0220936779,
0.0410547517,
-0.0239013396,
-0.0036714692,
0.0057563079,
0.0543929264,
-0.1049831584,
-0.0166546404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05502v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05502v3 | XAL: EXplainable Active Learning Makes Classifiers Better Low-resource Learners | 2023-10-09T08:07:04 | 2024-03-15T02:30:28 | Yun Luo, Zhen Yang, Fandong Meng, Yingjie Li, Fang Guo, Qinglin Qi, Jie Zhou, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Active learning (AL), which aims to construct an effective training set by
iteratively curating the most formative unlabeled data for annotation, has been
widely used in low-resource tasks. Most active learning techniques in
classification rely on the model's uncertainty or disagreement to choose
unlabeled data, suffering from the problem of over-confidence in superficial
patterns and a lack of exploration. Inspired by the cognitive processes in
which humans deduce and predict through causal information, we take an initial
attempt towards integrating rationales into AL and propose a novel Explainable
Active Learning framework (XAL) for low-resource text classification, which
aims to encourage classifiers to justify their inferences and delve into
unlabeled data for which they cannot provide reasonable explanations.
Specifically, besides using a pre-trained bi-directional encoder for
classification, we employ a pre-trained uni-directional decoder to generate and
score the explanation. We further facilitate the alignment of the model with
human reasoning preference through a proposed ranking loss. During the
selection of unlabeled data, the predicted uncertainty of the encoder and the
explanation score of the decoder complement each other as the final metric to
acquire informative data. Extensive experiments on six datasets show that XAL
achieves consistent improvement over 9 strong baselines. Analysis indicates
that the proposed method can generate corresponding explanations for its
predictions. | [
0.0002365325,
0.0755919367,
-0.0099649867,
-0.008684881,
0.0295724422,
0.0736623332,
0.0295966342,
-0.0039499942,
-0.0000329253,
-0.042883303,
0.0225174837,
0.0256364886,
-0.0151504604,
0.0349770188,
-0.0134233711,
-0.0547257587,
-0.0010079849,
-0.0093728192,
0.0802989453,
0.0075118169,
-0.0168250129,
0.0235970579,
-0.003599887,
0.0303755961,
0.030582536,
0.0041251848,
-0.0119028986,
-0.0228869785,
-0.0074396138,
-0.0078244731,
-0.0008387297,
0.0200046841,
0.0369632505,
0.0035757879,
0.0000021621,
-0.0287209209,
-0.0343658254,
-0.0036232935,
-0.068939738,
0.004266772,
-0.0211993195,
-0.0001318696,
0.0432673357,
-0.0046614134,
-0.0099174185,
-0.0041657472,
0.0412388258,
0.0583352521,
0.0386421829,
0.0323060751,
-0.0119398413,
-0.0272176694,
-0.0169440284,
-0.0241432134,
0.0277700145,
-0.0371724963,
0.0046768305,
0.0166609306,
-0.0321401097,
0.0345435925,
-0.0034544722,
-0.0024739543,
0.0387137458,
-0.0415233634,
0.050380826,
0.0161611196,
0.0211399514,
-0.0306083988,
0.0327844247,
0.058046449,
0.0155242318,
-0.0557445101,
0.0156583916,
-0.0564447343,
0.0112835187,
0.0340788923,
-0.0304854065,
0.0151759433,
-0.0041330252,
0.0412711874,
0.0309871752,
0.0369364694,
0.0527185872,
0.0308161359,
0.008058764,
0.0116221942,
-0.0531149432,
-0.0118690943,
0.0374757685,
0.0426472723,
-0.0396189168,
-0.0275925957,
-0.0068303985,
0.0614849776,
-0.0319368467,
0.0088077933,
0.0139201777,
0.0053652669,
-0.0046946849,
-0.0458758883,
-0.0024208792,
-0.0045607733,
0.0042990306,
0.0654046237,
-0.0107862493,
-0.0056259646,
0.025081588,
0.019375002,
-0.0131436931,
-0.014374719,
-0.0606459379,
-0.0288254675,
-0.0048554917,
0.0201264583,
-0.0264421292,
0.0196846575,
-0.0341575481,
0.0036188161,
-0.0632902309,
0.0053715641,
0.0067827282,
0.0453231968,
-0.0153398402,
-0.0068867635,
-0.0472562909,
-0.0038365086,
-0.0277067162,
0.0469761901,
0.0005749858,
-0.0373391174,
-0.0029066547,
0.0524791181,
0.0044089495,
-0.0290575419,
0.0026150562,
0.0596680082,
-0.0106369033,
-0.0268449783,
-0.0294898674,
-0.0302907284,
0.0252948161,
-0.0215255618,
-0.0177423954,
0.0154023683,
-0.0501721129,
0.0067752362,
0.0120555395,
-0.0739744753,
-0.0163669065,
-0.0176097881,
-0.0513571687,
0.0849935487,
-0.0353476182,
-0.0278469622,
0.0283971727,
0.0010089662,
-0.0052271485,
0.0336134173,
-0.0282355342,
0.0357755609,
0.0501027815,
-0.0313119739,
0.0243102014,
-0.0680844039,
0.0648831353,
-0.0156377219,
-0.0007128731,
0.0241627023,
-0.0721295476,
-0.015664285,
-0.0035106158,
-0.0315839984,
-0.013336625,
0.0194621179,
0.0136791896,
-0.0214954466,
0.0017795387,
0.0001322812,
0.0284978002,
0.021388296,
-0.0025505135,
0.0097440891,
-0.0284447335,
0.0544571616,
-0.0347292461,
-0.0271031614,
0.0178731307,
-0.0381558463,
-0.0549492836,
-0.0948682576,
-0.0102577461,
-0.0558488667,
0.0097396364,
0.0417705178,
0.0811999217,
0.0274366196,
-0.0109172631,
0.0320008919,
0.0362155661,
-0.0141129754,
-0.0031795646,
-0.0497487858,
0.064872086,
0.0169421807,
0.0308172274,
-0.052263353,
0.0166509021,
-0.0134144891,
0.0528996214,
-0.0142313028,
0.033376161,
-0.0274180342,
0.0162542816,
-0.0494074784,
-0.0708576292,
-0.0256965663,
0.0449913405,
-0.0086974483,
-0.0050730826,
-0.0097819837,
0.0200608484,
-0.0770736486,
-0.0498497523,
0.048532784,
-0.0055763661,
-0.0694610029,
0.0158570167,
0.0102125164,
0.0533165894,
0.0210260171,
0.0135528864,
-0.0041665565,
0.0146516692,
-0.0068652695,
-0.0504804514,
0.0275719091,
-0.0091429213,
0.0095939189,
-0.0484714061,
-0.0215464551,
-0.0468382463,
0.0175456237,
-0.0392932892,
-0.0423259623,
-0.011217976,
-0.0364915878,
-0.0206568055,
-0.0544500723,
-0.0187776983,
-0.0187854376,
-0.0099161323,
-0.0472648032,
0.0929824188,
0.003943698,
0.0284581184,
0.0181731433,
-0.0327510424,
0.0168026295,
-0.0129877795,
0.027611088,
0.0001676139,
-0.0115375193,
-0.0245550424,
0.0101178456,
-0.0065477444,
0.0005803094,
0.0414895602,
-0.0161848385,
-0.0394875407,
-0.0337977335,
-0.0465339869,
-0.0016357484,
-0.0039370009,
0.0392484851,
-0.0227360204,
-0.0136314649,
0.0149862971,
-0.0003201296,
0.0280784871,
0.0360557996,
-0.0098902741,
0.0315301567,
-0.0142646441,
0.0028863999,
0.0266340785,
0.0719987154,
0.0448628664,
0.008593902,
-0.0477345884,
0.0059808479,
0.0093294568,
-0.0396346152,
-0.0152264554,
-0.0177790131,
0.00794621,
0.0002254989,
-0.0951591507,
0.0540510565,
0.0014878293,
0.0854225308,
0.0128893321,
0.0420350358,
-0.0426886566,
-0.0127795711,
-0.0636774376,
0.0058424836,
-0.0209962428,
-0.0286511891,
-0.0015702669,
0.0707171336,
-0.0249413587,
-0.0105441613,
-0.0593616776,
0.038354598,
0.0160197131,
-0.0342887938,
-0.0670479983,
-0.035368599,
0.0267530866,
0.0831587315,
-0.010561971,
-0.0827744454,
0.0781979784,
0.005219236,
-0.0040207487,
-0.0343217105,
-0.0150255486,
-0.0238934867,
0.0323796682,
0.0026335784,
-0.0065884115,
0.0073716776,
-0.0070931884,
0.0128343888,
-0.0674991757,
0.0334176682,
0.0168089252,
-0.0049359407,
-0.0454741679,
0.0014620452,
0.0054542995,
-0.0275955312,
-0.0393775105,
-0.0377943814,
-0.0145746581,
0.0181724671,
0.0189331416,
-0.0073609459,
-0.0309774261,
0.0116808508,
0.028433241,
0.0191830043,
0.0003410411,
-0.0179595705,
0.016373653,
0.0200585537,
0.0217898414,
0.0030262654,
0.0085180011,
-0.0501375832,
0.0301970653,
0.041387707,
-0.0364383496,
-0.0292526633,
0.0014726475,
0.0166279729,
0.0120466361,
-0.0146176787,
-0.0144718224,
-0.0111529771,
0.055576928,
-0.024594631,
-0.0122053428,
0.1158308387,
0.0314471386,
-0.0579656251,
-0.0016940455,
-0.0300357565,
0.0082115652,
0.0098826475,
-0.0017387377,
0.0183462519,
-0.0356793813,
-0.0025169712,
0.0826068744,
0.0035336344,
-0.0157965515,
0.0328160562,
-0.0623331144,
0.0452312753,
-0.0226398148,
-0.0177483112,
-0.0130315861,
-0.0894876644,
-0.0313109234,
-0.0528824106,
-0.0314033814,
-0.0299995132,
0.0373047478,
0.0532221347,
0.0639066771,
-0.0503769815,
-0.0302239619,
-0.0052464125,
0.0229234882,
0.0051784525,
0.0068338723,
0.0504268371,
-0.0028895289,
-0.0319378078,
0.0079180468,
-0.0780725107,
0.0273843445,
-0.0302860085,
0.0754759684,
0.0280300062,
-0.005379546,
-0.023580933,
0.0723040029,
-0.0322503895,
-0.0371245332,
-0.0083555803,
0.0632202998,
-0.0401395671,
0.0275362711,
-0.0017653126,
-0.0322342291,
0.0206318125,
0.0560615659,
0.0220637601,
-0.0151399067,
-0.0482053198,
-0.0256106593,
0.0032735644,
-0.0593989678,
-0.0283983704,
0.0222933162,
0.0064153029,
-0.053292796,
-0.0200245846,
-0.0523898154,
-0.0043333261,
0.0847905949,
0.0014752421,
0.0234201271,
-0.0137719465,
-0.0249570906,
-0.0357141048,
0.0217253771,
0.0184408054,
0.0011216322,
0.0455755182,
-0.0708369389,
0.0065389788,
-0.0542609021,
-0.0226120465,
-0.0160347894,
0.0685322285,
-0.0090789013,
0.0019117815,
0.0359556824,
0.0361732692,
0.0732271597,
-0.0279211458,
-0.07029479,
0.0262681283,
0.0238435082,
0.0008354559,
-0.0326049104,
0.0610135272,
-0.0161803979,
0.0246090759,
0.0215918012,
-0.0242692214,
0.0319469534,
0.0447320528,
-0.0221724398,
-0.0653498024,
-0.0040489524,
0.0248701274,
-0.0288138203,
0.0772812888,
-0.0176619217,
-0.0399640799,
-0.0272441171,
-0.0003644128,
0.0167591944,
-0.0153606571,
-0.0169353411,
0.0374797173,
0.0358580872,
0.0181910563,
-0.0243259631,
0.0122641185,
0.0033662168,
0.0416377038,
-0.0116294613,
0.0555180497,
0.0309903529,
0.0378532112,
-0.054479681,
0.0274229236,
-0.0251660831,
0.0051144445,
-0.0013725935,
0.066476956,
0.0087593859,
0.0652098432,
0.0175670665,
0.0538635664,
0.0104792118,
-0.0166361593,
-0.080250062,
-0.033565253,
-0.0093899732,
-0.0218781941,
0.0329000354,
-0.0611053891,
0.0354987457,
0.0207432359,
-0.0145439282,
0.020810049,
0.0682655796,
0.0579007678,
-0.0470943376,
-0.0155486958,
0.0138168754,
-0.0520858504,
0.0150645943,
0.0562454276,
0.0461744964,
0.0066522965,
-0.0211530086,
-0.0455292389,
-0.0309317969,
-0.0138506694,
0.0426199958,
0.0327114165,
-0.0061219013,
0.0114563266,
-0.0091906497,
-0.0625983104,
-0.0230859499,
-0.0326662771,
0.0050836415,
-0.0053026965,
0.0353252366,
0.0642250478,
-0.0066183424,
-0.0159418304,
-0.073597692,
0.0337095633,
-0.0236225482,
0.0229643788,
-0.0202054288,
-6.208581329e-33,
0.0129386084,
-0.0596323982,
-0.0291012377,
-0.0314119458,
0.032576602,
0.0380373299,
-0.0432337336,
-0.0603009313,
-0.0040653022,
0.0591386147,
0.0245353468,
0.0231406484,
0.0143106189,
0.0240872148,
0.0056947013,
-0.0162231866,
0.0324414112,
0.0469438657,
-0.0201063678,
0.0351390578,
0.0665404052,
0.0066192579,
0.0193978213,
-0.1239024699,
0.0550172143,
0.0153466891,
-0.0180704352,
0.0340629555,
-0.0056811157,
0.0400741808,
-0.0059837252,
0.0217527077,
0.0177563578,
-0.0430139452,
0.0182888657,
0.0097308932,
-0.0685339868,
-0.0102732265,
-0.0013383699,
0.0192292426,
-0.0219675358,
-0.0213448089,
-0.0202425774,
-0.0008128284,
0.0067132548,
0.0006598865,
0.0700302497,
-0.0378969237,
-0.0377259664,
-0.0345653668,
-0.0266312771,
0.0428137332,
-0.067334339,
0.0049790326,
0.0061876462,
0.0625114292,
0.0016716713,
0.0260171182,
-0.0563872717,
-0.0203065388,
0.001281564,
0.0007645848,
0.0226237569,
-0.0227933191,
-0.028603496,
0.0696488544,
0.0145421298,
-0.0073704892,
-0.0715632439,
0.0597396828,
-0.0603402145,
0.0389338322,
0.0774922818,
0.0376307927,
0.0293084811,
-0.0202238038,
-0.08465036,
0.0547668226,
-0.004179222,
-0.0171625279,
0.0445275046,
0.0205338001,
-0.0676959008,
-0.0379212089,
-0.0120249866,
-0.0277618598,
-0.0209686272,
-0.0230536405,
-0.0119515257,
0.0005734267,
-0.0750242397,
0.0247103609,
-0.0004968339,
-0.0262510274,
0.0039054062,
0.0271094758,
0.0295935012,
0.0070981006,
0.0085199121,
-0.0606166981,
-0.0252344292,
-0.0418304652,
0.02229972,
0.029921269,
0.0399196297,
0.0171712451,
0.0695222393,
0.0035306532,
-0.008870705,
-0.0108259246,
-0.046945367,
-0.0143182734,
-0.0330558307,
0.0570582896,
0.015538061,
0.0312008578,
-0.0374394543,
0.0393697359,
0.0065552052,
0.0107697379,
-0.0114327688,
-0.0498965122,
-0.028694855,
0.0002034846,
-0.0130700562,
-0.0711090118,
0.0056103659,
-0.021877436,
-0.0126981689,
-0.1025861502,
0.003367841,
0.0116593661,
2.749e-7,
0.0363386199,
0.0136545952,
-0.006353884,
-0.0616344512,
0.0477574058,
0.0604968518,
0.0137442108,
-0.0125848893,
-0.0045788707,
-0.0154258469,
0.0410449393,
0.0108772665,
0.0444121733,
0.0338273607,
-0.0396289229,
-0.0525170267,
-0.0355973952,
-0.0112850247,
-0.0121385595,
0.0144528169,
0.0844278485,
0.0499130003,
0.0269241594,
-0.0276728831,
0.0387742743,
-0.0259268675,
0.0441578515,
-0.0238908641,
0.0419737995,
-0.0145175476,
0.0465335511,
-0.0092281289,
0.0161693357,
0.0177091993,
-0.0490624346,
-0.0116797304,
-0.0184154138,
0.0548474453,
-0.010848593,
-0.0552481189,
-0.0295196231,
0.0070693204,
0.0539924242,
-0.0378626287,
0.1014307663,
-0.0372066796,
-0.0806585252,
0.0741435587,
-0.0648627728,
-0.0084188059,
-0.0060421904,
0.0356618203,
-0.0003851839,
0.0239978395,
-0.0345154703,
-0.0047499142,
-0.0086971689,
-0.0975511149,
-0.0340786949,
-0.0216381624,
-0.0166363511,
0.0044024894,
-0.0081523824,
0.0492651053,
0.0727791935,
-0.0226261504,
0.0102318181,
2.345662472e-34,
0.0404439196,
0.023061268,
0.0037078762,
-0.0158526022,
0.025788134,
0.0279189236,
0.0390249453,
-0.0017081728,
0.0578879155,
-0.007229913,
0.0156897493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05492v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05492v4 | How Abilities in Large Language Models are Affected by Supervised Fine-tuning Data Composition | 2023-10-09T07:56:16 | 2024-06-07T15:51:08 | Guanting Dong, Hongyi Yuan, Keming Lu, Chengpeng Li, Mingfeng Xue, Dayiheng Liu, Wei Wang, Zheng Yuan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) with enormous pre-training tokens and parameters
emerge diverse abilities, including math reasoning, code generation, and
instruction following. These abilities are further enhanced by supervised
fine-tuning (SFT). While the open-source community has explored ad-hoc SFT for
enhancing individual capabilities, proprietary LLMs exhibit versatility across
various skills. Therefore, understanding the facilitation of multiple abilities
via SFT is paramount. In this study, we specifically focuses on the interplay
of data composition between mathematical reasoning, code generation, and
general human-aligning abilities during SFT. We propose four intriguing
research questions to explore the association between model performance and
various factors including data amount, composition ratio, model size and SFT
strategies. Our experiments reveal that distinct capabilities scale differently
and larger models generally show superior performance with same amount of data.
Mathematical reasoning and code generation consistently improve with increasing
data amount, whereas general abilities plateau after roughly a thousand
samples. Moreover, we observe data composition appears to enhance various
abilities under limited data conditions, yet can lead to performance conflicts
when data is plentiful. Our findings also suggest the amount of composition
data influences performance more than the composition ratio. In analysis of SFT
strategies, we find that sequentially learning multiple skills risks
catastrophic forgetting. Our proposed Dual-stage Mixed Fine-tuning (DMT)
strategy offers a promising solution to learn multiple abilities with different
scaling patterns. | [
0.0001060616,
0.0571171641,
-0.0395495705,
0.0003313059,
-0.0061071934,
0.0394277535,
-0.0169230532,
-0.0440496653,
-0.0428005196,
-0.0166844726,
-0.0629946217,
-0.0124857761,
0.0166932382,
0.0131678218,
0.0636916682,
-0.0354735591,
0.0532754213,
-0.0737766847,
-0.0165672787,
-0.0186299328,
-0.0199809484,
-0.0096459063,
-0.0016710804,
0.0350229554,
0.04470063,
-0.0118564283,
0.0107921744,
-0.0194992088,
-0.0089436937,
-0.0059993747,
0.0037001863,
0.0571989454,
0.0265212897,
0.0018719619,
0.0000020119,
-0.0643372908,
0.0190403424,
-0.0051571438,
-0.0067410283,
0.0179681536,
-0.0016364668,
0.0164979827,
0.0103350542,
0.0274905488,
-0.0320383087,
-0.0088285571,
0.0476073883,
0.0058110887,
0.0499237217,
0.0582271554,
0.0180737432,
-0.0327729322,
0.0485545583,
-0.0243339799,
0.0272075497,
-0.0259408522,
0.0237654112,
0.0105988272,
0.0147353793,
-0.0030957744,
-0.0230480563,
0.0132125774,
0.0365701132,
0.0441050343,
0.0143429507,
0.0459254645,
-0.0486613102,
-0.0090325801,
0.0101074278,
0.0227158405,
-0.0427506901,
-0.0194151923,
0.000323921,
-0.0143605182,
0.0292899348,
-0.0053147208,
-0.0672917143,
0.0400919877,
-0.007276353,
0.015944818,
0.013633294,
-0.0646861419,
0.0274972226,
0.0107435854,
-0.0303511694,
0.0554435477,
0.0093131959,
-0.0419826731,
-0.028753981,
-0.0068120919,
-0.0430331789,
-0.0508447327,
-0.0238005053,
0.037655931,
-0.0262994878,
0.0109807542,
-0.0585882105,
-0.0380830429,
0.001191201,
0.0078188442,
0.0681247637,
0.0662764236,
-0.0094042933,
0.0162741262,
-0.0478906259,
0.0524645299,
-0.0089930771,
0.0578119345,
-0.029370565,
0.0361541025,
-0.0684985593,
-0.0326042809,
-0.0222250484,
0.0392414071,
-0.0007638114,
0.0102457879,
-0.0481463708,
0.0253247935,
0.0038110444,
0.0110682929,
0.0102165351,
-0.0297847353,
-0.03484926,
-0.0043650996,
-0.0035179488,
0.0160792414,
-0.0431019329,
0.0160868913,
0.0339723751,
-0.0331532061,
-0.0177923478,
-0.0084458105,
-0.0247867182,
-0.0316832699,
0.0394267179,
0.046846617,
-0.0269456767,
-0.0012265397,
-0.0551862828,
-0.0280271266,
0.0093621118,
-0.0991682187,
0.0208387338,
-0.0836657658,
0.0253488664,
0.0344559327,
-0.0319434293,
-0.0479478985,
-0.0083451066,
-0.0073934691,
-0.0341323502,
0.0395733044,
-0.0017510258,
0.0278934389,
0.01715477,
-0.0149828475,
-0.0227279458,
0.0840378553,
0.0339217782,
-0.0284769405,
-0.0316298157,
-0.0351973139,
-0.0006188918,
0.0197069682,
0.0087342234,
0.0147776511,
-0.0097544743,
0.0096744196,
0.0439689383,
0.0203947835,
0.0140438853,
0.0089673307,
-0.0378269628,
0.0458554998,
0.0396911427,
0.0324692093,
0.0556639358,
0.0390012935,
0.0376232527,
0.0018230925,
0.0369650237,
0.0070294561,
-0.0991346091,
0.0490113162,
-0.0090853926,
0.0305164065,
0.0166305955,
0.073963806,
-0.0340352431,
-0.060610909,
-0.0078875627,
0.0016086602,
-0.0137790041,
0.018867515,
0.0434027724,
-0.0123723019,
-0.0202410966,
0.0409686342,
0.0172537137,
-0.0436665639,
0.0089079821,
-0.0486805774,
-0.0100263506,
0.0473256707,
0.0114407782,
-0.0480897501,
-0.0488364547,
-0.0008915741,
0.0199462734,
-0.0342836492,
0.0343152173,
0.0249254815,
0.0008551404,
-0.0445750169,
-0.023554666,
-0.0660962611,
0.0141485175,
0.0079000508,
0.0178300515,
-0.0105479714,
0.0019172024,
-0.0035972227,
-0.0318682641,
0.0151611846,
-0.0577266663,
-0.0158429127,
-0.0484004766,
-0.0020876508,
0.00127775,
-0.0400376245,
-0.0082893036,
0.0248609018,
-0.0142465299,
0.0025152157,
-0.0044701309,
0.0085605765,
-0.0579585396,
0.0148451207,
0.0314587876,
0.0078936964,
-0.0180406366,
-0.0117747253,
-0.0050327289,
-0.0410591774,
0.0501036383,
-0.012315942,
0.027812507,
-0.0097894147,
0.0443732329,
-0.030816339,
-0.0100613721,
-0.0056887451,
0.0645881817,
-0.0003490892,
0.0094655184,
0.0142159453,
0.0333054624,
0.0029587075,
-0.0100237476,
0.0049551772,
0.0026915886,
-0.0199709237,
0.0470950231,
-0.0175493769,
-0.0053434032,
-0.0593000837,
-0.0453679003,
-0.0400058627,
0.0294763632,
-0.0251567438,
0.0253704749,
0.0250410661,
-0.0245030411,
-0.0220856667,
0.0243778676,
-0.0252627991,
-0.0099644819,
0.0001715498,
0.0350111164,
0.0130764097,
0.0164782628,
-0.0573503822,
-0.0264059938,
-0.0184864327,
-0.0466053374,
0.0242743343,
0.0116566401,
0.0472769476,
-0.0650562197,
0.0612894669,
-0.019670872,
0.0201539826,
-0.013387342,
-0.0603743903,
0.0204314906,
-0.008974174,
0.0612108782,
0.10411302,
-0.0335169323,
0.0128688039,
0.0709939525,
-0.0145329023,
-0.0135922655,
0.0174126811,
0.0058866697,
-0.0387740992,
-0.043136362,
0.0283841174,
-0.0257824231,
0.0667590052,
-0.0133227436,
0.0023816866,
-0.0588464215,
0.0476467982,
-0.003268525,
-0.0157974996,
0.0011878903,
-0.0092544314,
-0.0288277902,
0.0499756746,
-0.0382984169,
-0.0656681433,
0.0584700219,
0.0117079634,
-0.0145722656,
-0.0167899244,
0.0179351103,
-0.0438289419,
0.0412939489,
-0.003225456,
0.003471192,
-0.0128765395,
-0.0340485983,
-0.1046882793,
-0.003706282,
0.0332201384,
-0.0196739286,
0.0452407487,
-0.0410650894,
-0.0315401405,
-0.0142927403,
-0.0631795004,
-0.0331876539,
0.0101222117,
0.0010069179,
0.0446581766,
0.0520235822,
-0.0503527448,
-0.0346789286,
-0.0438997447,
0.0399565846,
0.0040435269,
-0.0326626375,
-0.0221568942,
-0.00816854,
-0.0439437032,
0.0079356842,
0.0217956472,
0.0117086805,
-0.0814757049,
-0.0118335737,
-0.0119527923,
0.0529056825,
0.0192191284,
0.0022013402,
0.0391713344,
0.0189735405,
-0.0134380395,
-0.0424510241,
0.0516465232,
0.0911951885,
-0.0679804534,
-0.0074100555,
0.0913007036,
0.0096587231,
-0.0140440296,
0.0083470391,
-0.0107459482,
0.0384019576,
0.0573090538,
0.0510410592,
-0.0524774007,
-0.0037328966,
-0.0014192784,
0.0297244452,
0.0046147546,
-0.0304145813,
-0.0119816801,
-0.1170289665,
0.0117123751,
0.0570077524,
-0.0596497059,
-0.0231389534,
-0.0061958106,
0.0025450443,
-0.011927329,
0.0073537729,
0.0273543335,
-0.02674843,
0.0128025701,
0.0231511574,
-0.0078921402,
-0.0865666345,
0.0258871317,
-0.0171040744,
0.0358365439,
0.0354675986,
-0.0199626684,
-0.0013500963,
-0.0580260083,
0.0642947331,
0.0116975559,
0.0458300263,
0.0131795667,
0.0365200825,
-0.0068664146,
-0.0156972539,
-0.0090815574,
0.0759449825,
-0.0100767361,
-0.0248931441,
0.0085573727,
0.0785073116,
0.0093046408,
-0.0054937266,
0.0194277484,
-0.0251254793,
-0.0266874116,
0.0474665463,
0.0419197865,
-0.0544979982,
-0.0246260576,
-0.0218716841,
-0.0459967069,
-0.0566451624,
-0.006072294,
0.0371535234,
0.0296331737,
0.0057913694,
-0.0149444696,
-0.0426717773,
0.049973093,
0.0248446483,
0.0158264004,
0.0138091138,
0.0035459602,
0.0084806401,
-0.0250055082,
0.035397131,
-0.0323900469,
0.0135600008,
-0.0715362728,
-0.0380063765,
-0.0038813539,
-0.0631233454,
-0.0104634166,
-0.029115418,
-0.1244077161,
-0.0758823305,
0.0216310583,
0.0554094911,
0.0243811943,
0.0604306124,
0.0253554713,
-0.0816935971,
-0.0243023057,
0.0388370194,
-0.0585574508,
0.0356889218,
0.0353467613,
-0.0235350095,
0.0325741246,
0.0146222552,
-0.0366439521,
0.0084984452,
0.0645114779,
0.0015636456,
0.002881848,
0.0309762266,
0.0229352526,
0.0244533066,
0.0193446912,
-0.0149996309,
0.0170601327,
-0.0357514732,
-0.0080493614,
0.0100749498,
-0.012734279,
-0.0211949237,
-0.0440165959,
0.0226132311,
-0.0020895924,
0.0359170549,
-0.0237661805,
0.0394765921,
0.0215754192,
-0.0232206099,
0.052691903,
-0.028655272,
0.0289601628,
0.0688137114,
0.0139467539,
-0.0143560823,
0.039463453,
-0.0054931613,
0.0333179682,
-0.0000797601,
0.0609307513,
0.0099704806,
0.0321924984,
-0.0408662185,
0.0031069331,
-0.0785614774,
-0.1213206798,
0.0074293488,
0.0009983641,
0.0505617186,
-0.0228837468,
0.0107731819,
-0.0358246677,
0.0083428714,
-0.0265383665,
0.021070607,
-0.0200159382,
0.0126621742,
-0.0007630354,
0.036444243,
-0.0067733573,
-0.0534185357,
0.0812204629,
-0.0308643132,
0.0486627631,
-0.0501628406,
0.0281380545,
-0.0116580231,
-0.0079393378,
0.0180666093,
0.0165418461,
-0.0124924555,
0.0049964162,
-0.0479117557,
-0.0473946892,
-0.037814945,
0.0189259909,
0.0074622207,
-0.007837275,
0.0336259492,
0.072556749,
-0.0643084049,
0.0029701306,
0.0257949717,
-0.0341844372,
0.0362078659,
-0.0105527192,
0.0019465464,
-6.352478001e-33,
-0.0161907617,
0.0155134331,
0.0508824885,
0.0228669997,
-0.0094989073,
-0.0228662677,
-0.0256949384,
0.0417867787,
-0.0289127883,
-0.0352026969,
0.0037377009,
0.0179201271,
-0.0078338832,
-0.0069481716,
0.0546100847,
-0.0035742344,
0.0410099514,
0.006749121,
-0.0479825363,
0.0272655226,
0.0120768296,
0.0042974204,
0.0478565767,
-0.0363405086,
-0.0070133968,
-0.0040125083,
0.0198716186,
0.008175605,
-0.0465982482,
0.0622964948,
0.0312293023,
0.0206586793,
0.0234034043,
-0.0331407487,
-0.0603512749,
-0.0120070521,
-0.0201883167,
-0.0555020832,
0.031556908,
0.0078320326,
-0.0089609893,
-0.0665394813,
0.0796080008,
-0.0050764866,
-0.0539072454,
-0.0702159628,
0.0311696045,
-0.0297748409,
-0.0015143519,
-0.0057914765,
-0.0720251426,
0.0174727365,
-0.0231318586,
-0.0265076496,
-0.0119893569,
-0.004110151,
-0.0171249229,
0.006731418,
-0.0153573388,
0.0123740472,
0.0214229692,
0.0503171086,
0.0615743324,
0.0346474536,
0.0162231922,
0.0296228509,
0.0539311431,
0.0609563887,
-0.010965568,
-0.0148226386,
0.0639113188,
0.0822846144,
0.0270533878,
-0.0046127392,
0.0418665521,
-0.014678386,
-0.0344564617,
-0.0142053599,
-0.0170943979,
0.0217498373,
0.0114589781,
0.0278858859,
-0.0085133919,
-0.0358810872,
-0.0548577011,
0.0208570939,
-0.0250844378,
-0.0059908247,
0.0532098487,
0.0013520968,
0.0020973615,
-0.006493459,
0.0328966714,
-0.0255744737,
-0.0044350568,
0.018098291,
-0.0425149687,
0.0252329987,
-0.023249574,
0.0141720623,
-0.0750780553,
-0.0569856428,
0.0128845982,
0.0119426725,
0.0378644392,
0.0289760269,
0.0625601932,
0.0295915361,
-0.0630965829,
-0.0083248662,
-0.0414368957,
0.009413288,
0.0562231913,
-0.0024791574,
0.0658351108,
0.0252738968,
0.0100438073,
0.0140406396,
-0.0034253267,
-0.0613073558,
-0.0776135027,
0.0173290577,
-0.0164034739,
0.0273104329,
0.0127523309,
0.0009524153,
-0.0548190922,
-0.0298165847,
0.0176663809,
-0.0326619297,
-0.034456715,
0.0354199633,
2.802e-7,
0.023546569,
0.0230586063,
-0.0119243544,
0.0208185706,
0.0083053503,
0.0170343369,
-0.0513751134,
-0.0444453955,
0.0389406644,
0.0239934362,
-0.0030999747,
0.0780450925,
0.0290666427,
-0.0072448812,
-0.0146154575,
0.019856669,
-0.0393275879,
0.0480865315,
-0.0659154728,
0.0180668849,
0.0270460322,
0.0497324839,
0.0140540395,
-0.0024134715,
0.024198493,
-0.0422415249,
0.0658187792,
-0.0014289293,
0.0221297499,
0.0313374475,
-0.0738293752,
0.0564267784,
-0.0019654937,
0.0328193158,
-0.0084422026,
0.0187300704,
-0.0356008224,
0.0557983406,
-0.0114506632,
0.0683965907,
0.0240360815,
0.0122415479,
-0.0377925821,
-0.0643372089,
0.0612824671,
-0.0980380848,
-0.0275699999,
-0.0017279708,
0.0159344207,
-0.0168398693,
0.0318546779,
-0.003546004,
0.037141908,
0.0267864075,
0.0008466842,
-0.0048885164,
0.002811054,
-0.0659870058,
-0.0240020882,
0.0886605084,
-0.0307403393,
-0.0652587712,
-0.0511524715,
-0.0179808661,
0.0453566089,
-0.0297545698,
-0.0127240596,
2.73113531e-34,
0.0160569698,
-0.0359072313,
0.0803769529,
0.0267026443,
0.0381754972,
-0.0283326581,
-0.01435827,
0.0327266455,
0.0318009928,
-0.0420272648,
-0.0283618793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05484v1 | IDTraffickers: An Authorship Attribution Dataset to link and connect Potential Human-Trafficking Operations on Text Escort Advertisements | 2023-10-09T07:43:57 | 2023-10-09T07:43:57 | Vageesh Saxena, Benjamin Bashpole, Gijs Van Dijck, Gerasimos Spanakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Human trafficking (HT) is a pervasive global issue affecting vulnerable
individuals, violating their fundamental human rights. Investigations reveal
that a significant number of HT cases are associated with online advertisements
(ads), particularly in escort markets. Consequently, identifying and connecting
HT vendors has become increasingly challenging for Law Enforcement Agencies
(LEAs). To address this issue, we introduce IDTraffickers, an extensive dataset
consisting of 87,595 text ads and 5,244 vendor labels to enable the
verification and identification of potential HT vendors on online escort
markets. To establish a benchmark for authorship identification, we train a
DeCLUTR-small model, achieving a macro-F1 score of 0.8656 in a closed-set
classification environment. Next, we leverage the style representations
extracted from the trained classifier to conduct authorship verification,
resulting in a mean r-precision score of 0.8852 in an open-set ranking
environment. Finally, to encourage further research and ensure responsible data
sharing, we plan to release IDTraffickers for the authorship attribution task
to researchers under specific conditions, considering the sensitive nature of
the data. We believe that the availability of our dataset and benchmarks will
empower future researchers to utilize our findings, thereby facilitating the
effective linkage of escort ads and the development of more robust approaches
for identifying HT indicators. | [
0.0500458926,
0.1048739552,
-0.0392048955,
-0.0077474844,
-0.0630793646,
0.0082818503,
0.1045621336,
0.0026183503,
0.0227086842,
-0.0450867824,
-0.0376015343,
-0.0514365621,
0.0352886766,
0.0209984053,
0.0210730638,
-0.0166441072,
-0.0166386589,
0.0413121879,
0.0516362227,
0.0100480141,
0.0291895662,
0.0294157602,
0.0149939544,
0.0367153883,
0.0122035081,
-0.0607728101,
0.0232947934,
0.0110122543,
0.0494030789,
-0.0034334031,
0.0717566088,
0.0906881914,
-0.011392259,
0.0679699257,
0.0000016345,
-0.0431827605,
-0.0157551412,
-0.0311706848,
-0.0190997627,
0.0157863945,
0.0525179729,
0.0174237844,
-0.0022380855,
0.0115924636,
-0.0098875239,
0.0224993844,
0.0333407484,
0.0635496303,
0.0401425883,
0.0550846197,
-0.0142821809,
-0.0123732779,
0.0009714214,
0.003766126,
-0.0180797521,
-0.0088398242,
0.0502533093,
-0.0645083934,
-0.0286178142,
0.0045454348,
0.0311121382,
0.0136720194,
-0.0226061605,
-0.0029476862,
0.0020604723,
0.0242818799,
-0.0764051378,
-0.0208036378,
0.02297052,
0.0229961388,
-0.0206683129,
-0.041629158,
0.0166756175,
0.0393150635,
-0.0049909479,
0.0092221573,
-0.0260709431,
0.0638582185,
-0.0526630953,
0.0134825977,
-0.0013575928,
0.0472622849,
0.0159074403,
0.0730910972,
0.0131351519,
-0.0103186034,
-0.0101787923,
-0.035829369,
-0.0204122011,
-0.0305082928,
-0.0020402335,
-0.0135482186,
0.0642834082,
-0.0390469544,
0.0108953156,
-0.0296342168,
0.0071483562,
-0.0730541721,
0.0167524479,
-0.086749509,
0.0034721429,
-0.0208612867,
-0.0562784635,
0.0100299818,
-0.0188781917,
0.0392802693,
0.0151300654,
0.044076141,
0.0153211234,
0.0097293118,
-0.0137147885,
0.0006426975,
-0.0056757643,
-0.0181617159,
0.009350406,
0.0603345186,
-0.0838704109,
0.0107688457,
-0.0472187027,
-0.0169236753,
-0.0288609508,
0.0230814628,
-0.0003963645,
0.0262708049,
0.0066512888,
-0.0213535689,
0.0188033488,
0.0018101565,
-0.0280880742,
0.0113524292,
0.0123289526,
0.0462812558,
0.0381165408,
-0.0454421118,
0.0289639905,
0.0188658256,
-0.0033310456,
-0.0345036015,
-0.0446215868,
-0.0232779626,
-0.0120152598,
-0.041363962,
-0.018127583,
-0.0297202002,
-0.0124422424,
0.0209689178,
-0.0217498671,
-0.0633273274,
-0.0253593381,
0.0117369266,
-0.0614103563,
0.0502739251,
0.0228898562,
0.008575418,
0.016408788,
0.0127834445,
0.0424261466,
-0.045717407,
0.0140246749,
0.141703099,
0.0536542572,
-0.0353231691,
0.0216350667,
0.0373464711,
-0.0037293581,
0.0120126847,
0.0438244492,
0.0179155245,
0.0505232215,
-0.0254968964,
0.0161779393,
-0.0229533389,
-0.0059768371,
-0.0178275406,
0.087537609,
0.0417067409,
0.0035941252,
0.0004022603,
0.0335096009,
0.033703126,
-0.0114244735,
-0.0498343334,
-0.0353451446,
-0.0281306412,
-0.0166557636,
-0.0511819087,
-0.0087490818,
0.0210344698,
-0.015694458,
0.0026006654,
-0.0177861862,
0.0183986798,
0.0114991087,
0.0180272255,
0.0307099428,
0.021946596,
-0.0190615468,
-0.0155396061,
-0.002380969,
0.0178662613,
-0.0320969224,
-0.0308743455,
0.0184008665,
0.0540036857,
0.0262705814,
0.0219404064,
0.019950768,
-0.0589766055,
0.0420983769,
0.0103654303,
-0.0445516482,
-0.015666062,
0.0044307774,
-0.0125309341,
-0.0323360376,
0.0363802277,
-0.0172148254,
0.009346325,
0.0391535051,
0.0192240402,
0.0585242882,
-0.0288660899,
-0.0188315436,
0.0111001534,
0.0287990756,
-0.0270052496,
0.0499551073,
0.0511929616,
0.0402075201,
0.0005120238,
-0.0007339003,
-0.0394451879,
0.0300945193,
-0.0215507727,
-0.0179548897,
-0.0003228166,
0.0445392467,
0.0446697101,
0.021927258,
-0.0212026406,
-0.0213539898,
0.0492023788,
-0.0234314203,
0.0027614296,
0.0674746111,
-0.0006491646,
-0.0433524624,
-0.0381204486,
-0.0033343709,
-0.0187444165,
0.0224850606,
-0.0171647184,
0.0757084489,
-0.0026851252,
0.0249482226,
-0.0359215662,
-0.0614145845,
0.0514995381,
0.0096439486,
0.0161218587,
-0.0519462787,
-0.0649740398,
0.0514414646,
0.0291416068,
0.0309777968,
0.0072028902,
-0.0343477912,
-0.0478734598,
0.0170263629,
-0.0077193999,
-0.0031132284,
-0.0160321239,
-0.0000680821,
0.0028681324,
-0.0014387851,
-0.0296210796,
-0.1235305816,
-0.035015516,
0.0171904676,
0.0361317843,
-0.0291086137,
-0.0468509831,
-0.0046160845,
0.00447291,
-0.0121361371,
0.0411796272,
0.0393144265,
0.0097805411,
-0.0181407146,
-0.0227342602,
-0.0343924016,
-0.030315211,
-0.035902679,
-0.0175622907,
0.0129342992,
0.0125316419,
-0.027530957,
0.0073192059,
0.036611937,
0.0273251403,
0.0032596535,
0.0299282707,
-0.008337236,
-0.0317177325,
-0.0129045099,
0.0352121703,
-0.0013188142,
-0.0776518732,
-0.0055300212,
0.0445970632,
0.0109054707,
0.0060417354,
0.0137505643,
-0.0113991797,
0.0454837307,
-0.0186148025,
-0.0336649604,
0.0069113281,
0.0052678459,
0.0132521,
-0.0396282375,
-0.0738257617,
0.0196870156,
-0.0232252385,
0.0203831345,
0.0417116992,
-0.0601058379,
-0.0166958459,
0.0271739326,
0.01891605,
0.0399628691,
0.0018064159,
-0.0463935286,
0.0388390496,
0.0553944483,
0.0599990264,
-0.0169939175,
0.004178606,
0.0157573,
0.0002122228,
0.0192120615,
-0.0517615415,
-0.0635175183,
-0.129447788,
-0.0148288812,
-0.009544529,
0.0246257782,
-0.037986692,
-0.0746297687,
0.0315240659,
0.0390067995,
0.0118573522,
-0.0367962122,
-0.0032531505,
-0.0074403156,
0.0419323482,
-0.0113942958,
-0.0715215057,
0.0149814002,
-0.0109400386,
-0.0407221168,
-0.0116598513,
-0.0208987277,
0.0086211972,
-0.0283046626,
0.012829233,
0.0227910131,
-0.0288090594,
-0.0037934703,
-0.0246818308,
-0.0182242263,
0.0010815345,
0.0216396507,
0.0654014722,
0.0407455973,
-0.0289700013,
0.0035298304,
0.023790976,
0.0298212264,
0.0143015506,
0.0016416813,
-0.0552524105,
0.0075751846,
-0.0132742915,
0.0295547359,
-0.0895716101,
-0.047306031,
-0.0207694583,
-0.0178416055,
0.0737382248,
0.0044013313,
-0.0528979599,
0.0111668054,
-0.090313971,
-0.0382851399,
-0.0125286812,
-0.0135896718,
-0.0240247604,
-0.0441412218,
-0.0013867569,
0.0157730281,
-0.0233840067,
-0.0200029276,
-0.00442708,
-0.0576750562,
0.004210785,
0.0194318369,
0.0722126216,
-0.035249155,
0.0012592301,
-0.0533389002,
-0.0074079502,
-0.0427635536,
0.0068143457,
0.0994647518,
-0.0365500674,
-0.0095688011,
-0.0884741396,
0.0467403159,
-0.0335649997,
-0.0107377106,
0.0091592325,
0.0426979326,
-0.0251070783,
-0.0340543278,
0.0161360633,
-0.0237086043,
0.001276743,
0.0350643918,
-0.0011260394,
-0.0363437869,
0.001891134,
-0.0263269674,
-0.0161863063,
-0.0103610605,
-0.023374835,
-0.000820571,
-0.0664609075,
-0.0235836897,
-0.034220878,
-0.0005545805,
-0.0017738735,
-0.0214538258,
0.0063039525,
-0.0026922699,
-0.0256564189,
-0.0315020829,
-0.0773579627,
0.0110676223,
-0.0170165617,
0.0705718398,
0.0128225666,
0.0305952858,
-0.0059824795,
-0.0554793328,
-0.0210029949,
0.0497466698,
-0.0798373148,
0.0058530238,
-0.0138071775,
-0.0023020322,
0.0139340116,
-0.0035502911,
-0.0487368815,
-0.0733040571,
0.0102246217,
0.0862681419,
-0.0191964656,
-0.0242819302,
0.017921254,
-0.0387205221,
-0.0150103644,
0.0028641038,
-0.0045654043,
0.0298162196,
0.0678225532,
-0.0785636231,
-0.0476854518,
0.0156404041,
0.0166634396,
0.0287513584,
0.0470591523,
-0.0394253694,
0.0261958335,
-0.0074032596,
-0.0157121588,
0.0198022816,
-0.0172616262,
-0.0048316708,
-0.0028374523,
0.0259029754,
0.016416559,
-0.0568472929,
0.0610844567,
-0.0121164508,
0.0212270748,
-0.0611115061,
-0.0087025035,
-0.0204654019,
0.0728691816,
-0.0176546536,
0.0078894421,
0.022055693,
0.0170526616,
0.025951717,
0.0691972449,
0.0056958636,
-0.0365415886,
0.0304897502,
0.0436001904,
0.0005515798,
0.033609774,
-0.0513681173,
-0.0033677686,
-0.00155724,
-0.0094357496,
0.0128695443,
-0.0105564492,
0.0391556472,
0.0101381512,
0.0145884557,
-0.0101989489,
0.0358543433,
-0.0320093818,
-0.0347013809,
-0.0575197674,
0.0315664597,
-0.0518460162,
0.0680204555,
0.0563928001,
0.0380703434,
0.0067626364,
0.0047959308,
-0.0976258814,
-0.0069583026,
-0.0116051557,
0.02426989,
0.0047018314,
0.0049318629,
-0.0096078673,
-0.0396106318,
-0.035064172,
0.0180090666,
-0.0790418014,
0.035116747,
0.0099338982,
-0.0114771305,
0.0159240775,
-0.0367910601,
-0.0262999721,
-0.0340032019,
-0.0192278903,
-0.0152308689,
-0.0288941246,
-0.0314240269,
-5.422063937e-33,
0.0503550991,
-0.0593132861,
-0.0351623669,
0.0316639021,
-0.0043410189,
-0.0016659306,
0.0092998454,
-0.041655302,
0.0459869653,
-0.0033261133,
-0.0176511798,
-0.0108543355,
0.0148161929,
0.0490435511,
0.0104646571,
0.0247228835,
0.0291922186,
0.0190865397,
-0.0085729081,
0.0507243164,
0.0454252288,
0.0122324098,
0.0490105934,
-0.1237139851,
0.0664204955,
-0.0341732539,
-0.0881669745,
0.0200227685,
0.0121907098,
0.0402881689,
-0.0152821019,
0.0427211523,
0.0262812488,
-0.0055252304,
0.0519838482,
0.0129101509,
-0.0595361777,
0.0181783643,
-0.0102013405,
0.0550886057,
0.036931783,
-0.0436450094,
0.0277528446,
-0.0270222276,
0.0273621362,
0.00541637,
0.0822946429,
-0.0065829572,
-0.0199978035,
-0.0361499377,
-0.0019103091,
0.0126668625,
-0.0518637374,
0.018154595,
0.0158145856,
0.0787086561,
-0.0127194738,
0.0129349465,
-0.080537878,
-0.0018320683,
-0.0056606419,
-0.0362370238,
-0.010057997,
0.0241144039,
-0.009937143,
0.0358133353,
0.0007126495,
-0.0183641873,
-0.0022589185,
-0.0144562302,
0.0127596334,
0.0773454532,
0.0243947189,
0.0503461584,
-0.0065668323,
-0.0061683222,
-0.0456267931,
0.0280446745,
0.0433899723,
-0.0403232463,
0.0295163412,
-0.0394831859,
-0.0437409319,
-0.0220800396,
-0.0283752587,
-0.0693041831,
-0.0176161453,
-0.0245988686,
0.0187877212,
-0.0364550352,
-0.026202077,
0.0338684507,
-0.0033442795,
-0.0550426282,
-0.0340018608,
-0.035904035,
-0.0385168716,
0.0539714769,
0.0237666089,
-0.0071709366,
-0.0366117321,
0.002438385,
0.0189487543,
-0.0203611143,
0.036045853,
-0.0313369483,
0.104567863,
0.011258957,
-0.0526583046,
0.0089839501,
0.0092465328,
0.0458059795,
0.0181497466,
0.0442222431,
-0.0362651423,
0.0043554096,
-0.0088786976,
-0.0048127915,
0.0534845814,
0.0487846173,
0.0243199896,
-0.0258588437,
-0.0098774228,
-0.0014023731,
-0.0033494902,
-0.0204232559,
-0.0104612475,
-0.0007430894,
0.0156853814,
-0.0625676811,
-0.0026181936,
-0.0503861196,
2.446e-7,
0.0213408582,
-0.0020655931,
0.0015553635,
0.0185098369,
0.002313619,
0.0613526851,
0.0678543672,
0.0553658903,
-0.0064208568,
-0.0389477238,
-0.0025714647,
0.0063609425,
0.0673035085,
0.0239124689,
-0.0627476275,
-0.0039140112,
-0.0360512026,
-0.0062605613,
-0.0413945913,
0.0050633317,
-0.0389011726,
0.061615523,
0.0924157575,
-0.0441168509,
0.0150061594,
-0.0321671404,
0.0340312235,
-0.0189072825,
-0.0083528403,
0.0166383237,
0.0192176625,
0.0293697678,
-0.0057260832,
0.0253757127,
-0.0252311658,
0.0254712198,
0.013408592,
0.0207611732,
-0.0018500031,
0.0435029976,
-0.0156795159,
-0.0870899409,
0.0127647119,
-0.0681071132,
0.0674892813,
0.0376839153,
-0.0227125902,
0.0006947786,
-0.0156887267,
-0.0338758677,
0.0288300999,
-0.0009691174,
0.010913182,
0.0452136435,
0.0269661397,
-0.0378679223,
0.0207859725,
-0.0516010039,
0.0320004448,
0.0310223438,
-0.0064215441,
0.0205760635,
-0.0012056713,
0.0461394936,
0.0657027215,
-0.058644183,
0.0489698499,
2.48966099e-34,
0.0203364156,
0.0047829156,
-0.0060970592,
0.0064727254,
0.0444877744,
0.0206965208,
-0.0318603069,
-0.0109022092,
0.0154644828,
-0.0297064651,
0.0210297853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05481v1 | Cabbage Sweeter than Cake? Analysing the Potential of Large Language Models for Learning Conceptual Spaces | 2023-10-09T07:41:19 | 2023-10-09T07:41:19 | Usashi Chatterjee, Amit Gajbhiye, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The theory of Conceptual Spaces is an influential cognitive-linguistic
framework for representing the meaning of concepts. Conceptual spaces are
constructed from a set of quality dimensions, which essentially correspond to
primitive perceptual features (e.g. hue or size). These quality dimensions are
usually learned from human judgements, which means that applications of
conceptual spaces tend to be limited to narrow domains (e.g. modelling colour
or taste). Encouraged by recent findings about the ability of Large Language
Models (LLMs) to learn perceptually grounded representations, we explore the
potential of such models for learning conceptual spaces. Our experiments show
that LLMs can indeed be used for learning meaningful representations to some
extent. However, we also find that fine-tuned models of the BERT family are
able to match or even outperform the largest GPT-3 model, despite being 2 to 3
orders of magnitude smaller. | [
0.0342985392,
0.07168293,
-0.0138687501,
0.0266677495,
-0.0362766832,
0.020272484,
-0.0218590479,
0.0044017341,
-0.0522018671,
-0.0805140957,
-0.0608720444,
-0.0588067397,
0.0036311522,
0.0177462045,
0.0301666185,
-0.061934568,
-0.0002314325,
0.0183771756,
-0.0081238793,
-0.0122036058,
-0.0211306568,
-0.0172601882,
-0.0083797714,
0.0551542304,
-0.0197365619,
-0.0188387856,
0.0014170895,
-0.0123305116,
-0.0168107487,
-0.0266902,
-0.0180723816,
0.035189081,
0.0395479277,
0.0642062575,
0.0000016743,
-0.0314463116,
0.0443746485,
-0.0219833497,
0.0061476538,
0.049233783,
-0.0069718761,
-0.0288299564,
-0.0242116824,
-0.0396311507,
-0.0266811736,
-0.0099599799,
0.0887338743,
0.0694211647,
0.0087434929,
0.0183408782,
-0.0089830328,
-0.0694292709,
0.0174218025,
-0.0149245709,
0.0429989323,
0.008405189,
0.0545466952,
0.0269677509,
-0.0248839762,
-0.0186932869,
-0.0411505811,
-0.0059513068,
0.0107560605,
0.0406806394,
0.0040875594,
0.0813101009,
-0.049364429,
-0.0100903856,
0.0048330384,
0.0642479211,
-0.0362619273,
-0.022336565,
-0.0413877368,
0.0056966012,
-0.0305454247,
-0.002458507,
-0.0249929838,
0.0018460725,
-0.0126804709,
0.043800801,
-0.0208564755,
-0.0183981173,
0.0325505286,
0.0260133408,
-0.0377728939,
0.0537467971,
0.0220178645,
-0.0359000228,
0.0274130553,
-0.0052603851,
-0.0863728672,
0.0083051194,
-0.0202236045,
-0.0010096501,
0.0615578406,
0.0295797456,
0.0026118085,
0.0542553775,
0.014856495,
-0.067077443,
0.0517020933,
0.045854453,
-0.0301444884,
0.0401120409,
-0.0360444225,
0.076698333,
-0.0527029522,
0.0459027849,
-0.0397959128,
-0.0050061592,
-0.0595783442,
-0.0150390705,
-0.0305377729,
0.0475004539,
0.0003792657,
-0.054743778,
-0.0068919868,
0.0298684165,
-0.0325743593,
-0.0153581044,
-0.0062547135,
0.0476262309,
-0.0338817537,
0.0194166545,
-0.0602378584,
0.0096556935,
-0.0147846369,
0.0330069065,
-0.043386735,
-0.0544387624,
0.0258476511,
0.0222828276,
-0.0100491568,
-0.0154857347,
0.0102689983,
0.0569230914,
0.0148868896,
-0.0341982059,
-0.0277256612,
0.0319932625,
-0.0241295621,
-0.0425132103,
-0.0006088663,
-0.0480302833,
-0.0109518683,
0.0262044985,
0.0202666223,
-0.0843013823,
0.0201086104,
-0.0143174855,
-0.0430252478,
0.1077861786,
0.012148302,
-0.0020810852,
0.0206305981,
0.0053922664,
-0.0384670906,
0.0619226024,
0.0207838714,
0.0410972014,
-0.0029885187,
-0.032037627,
-0.0280304868,
0.0066661141,
-0.0198013,
0.0161326453,
-0.091569759,
-0.0085254051,
0.0115204751,
0.0844911039,
0.0330639519,
0.0561801679,
-0.021719832,
-0.0458393507,
0.0833032653,
0.100061059,
-0.0006598689,
0.0387048908,
0.0727581456,
-0.0117119635,
0.0313980058,
0.034887109,
-0.0422722101,
-0.0167343039,
-0.0237979926,
0.0103963651,
0.0023549295,
0.0073281634,
-0.0367274098,
0.008623274,
-0.0280359704,
-0.0053334967,
0.0036252055,
-0.0239799134,
0.0646838099,
-0.0350858197,
-0.0145462546,
0.0802417621,
0.039062731,
-0.0175765343,
0.0163876489,
-0.0452446677,
0.0342373215,
0.0656658709,
0.0016163982,
-0.028700335,
0.0007755415,
0.0285765752,
-0.0009550498,
0.0577964894,
0.0209978949,
-0.008718309,
-0.0025474874,
-0.0146803735,
-0.0148085803,
-0.0411293097,
0.0184901003,
0.0309090856,
-0.0078570275,
-0.008447241,
-0.0003278898,
-0.0436210483,
0.021476863,
0.030927334,
0.0168353859,
-0.0161850378,
-0.0313077047,
0.0136909625,
0.0568719544,
-0.0049387533,
-0.0342614688,
0.0296481773,
0.0042838366,
-0.0520993546,
0.0080376593,
0.0395754203,
-0.0318098962,
-0.0062352298,
0.0256914981,
-0.0340796448,
0.007423644,
0.0247885361,
-0.0097670611,
0.0020036821,
0.0344514437,
-0.0476906076,
0.0904970691,
-0.0595679842,
0.0128217107,
-0.0526751056,
-0.0113917869,
-0.032397557,
0.0692693815,
-0.0189759545,
0.0251735561,
-0.0349294506,
0.0421111993,
0.0359451883,
-0.0185194686,
-0.0016610351,
-0.0048180171,
0.039849516,
0.0145201338,
0.0000839609,
-0.0067077936,
-0.0461159199,
-0.0311246384,
-0.0716928244,
-0.0266571883,
-0.0003519545,
-0.0299670678,
0.0403206721,
-0.0385500938,
0.0001979673,
0.0075525804,
-0.0257062502,
-0.0125733288,
-0.0681478009,
0.0408621319,
0.0112221902,
0.0043839458,
-0.0264557637,
-0.0083025955,
-0.0157208443,
-0.0154552525,
0.0903082862,
-0.0238058176,
-0.0194342081,
-0.0298436731,
-0.0139665874,
-0.0506855883,
0.0443654507,
0.0178112797,
-0.0520555004,
0.0286191981,
-0.0257607177,
0.0438917354,
0.063999325,
0.0290472191,
0.082586132,
0.0555114076,
-0.0171499699,
-0.0433954634,
-0.0301575903,
-0.0419653915,
0.0182511304,
-0.009291213,
-0.0148314144,
-0.0049385978,
0.0689980984,
0.0352261811,
-0.0039615245,
-0.0885988772,
0.0558060519,
-0.0077448776,
-0.0075448859,
-0.0678663924,
0.003242129,
-0.0383779816,
0.0443699025,
-0.0442645326,
-0.0626684949,
0.0590818636,
-0.0411050841,
0.0307171363,
-0.017751487,
0.0095982589,
-0.0225075539,
0.0466626361,
0.0192752369,
0.0276652612,
0.0203101523,
-0.0175317153,
-0.0355333984,
0.0117111802,
0.000391098,
-0.0176566932,
0.0725790858,
-0.0712287948,
0.0032688277,
0.0017314454,
-0.0236403495,
-0.0531583168,
-0.0052851192,
-0.0449628085,
0.0352730453,
0.0136148417,
0.0064797821,
-0.0628304556,
0.0550840646,
0.0089832423,
-0.0131230513,
0.0198700316,
-0.0114815095,
-0.0037540323,
0.031065125,
0.0363548249,
-0.0101865595,
0.0059106178,
0.0039198129,
0.0105305957,
0.0300831888,
-0.0037762772,
0.0105540277,
-0.0339325406,
0.0456257574,
0.0343210101,
-0.0094194673,
-0.0412714556,
-0.0014211368,
0.0200243406,
-0.0093488768,
-0.0292669442,
0.1235604361,
0.0449873358,
-0.0371593535,
0.0331310742,
0.0128183365,
0.0158813018,
0.0278043784,
-0.0199903958,
-0.0430872701,
-0.0191807188,
-0.0297193117,
-0.0530207679,
-0.0090828286,
-0.015939353,
-0.01217297,
-0.1054051593,
0.0053161308,
0.0183437318,
-0.0611477569,
-0.0625795498,
-0.0360335,
0.0264388826,
0.0150093222,
0.013492777,
-0.0031554129,
0.0029629413,
0.000284839,
0.018596286,
0.0049711973,
-0.0362535864,
0.054058224,
-0.0202299263,
-0.0007542659,
0.0619829595,
0.0444704406,
-0.0339633152,
-0.0854974687,
-0.0037358489,
-0.0549341328,
0.0103926407,
-0.0090460945,
0.0197034515,
0.0027375391,
-0.012952649,
0.0052989428,
0.0146427713,
-0.0119180446,
-0.0373086147,
-0.0351349041,
0.051404614,
-0.0287736915,
-0.0273593608,
-0.0044276258,
-0.0039423816,
-0.029550584,
0.0655617714,
0.0690589845,
-0.0544899404,
-0.0346617289,
-0.0265246276,
0.0044443752,
0.0271845926,
-0.0183489379,
0.0216611233,
-0.0009329724,
-0.0422483943,
-0.0274230689,
0.019227365,
0.0246160422,
0.0282436125,
0.0203468949,
-0.020405367,
-0.0081116203,
-0.0010350007,
-0.0565171093,
0.0686823875,
0.019568108,
-0.0080683073,
-0.0528249554,
-0.0604237691,
0.0754299462,
-0.0353374705,
-0.0158057977,
-0.0493359566,
0.0052462504,
-0.0543824397,
0.0150582967,
0.0097400546,
0.0252589192,
0.02375184,
0.0221759975,
-0.0366816744,
0.0381793305,
0.0149159459,
-0.0042944085,
0.0054327343,
-0.002705009,
0.0562063232,
0.0155017907,
0.0468325242,
-0.0421230644,
0.0482631661,
0.0260262433,
0.040184699,
0.0158089083,
-0.005166213,
0.0538675226,
-0.0216095354,
0.0847731307,
-0.0047459393,
0.0004593541,
-0.0054487023,
-0.0209830906,
-0.0025052542,
-0.0088265194,
-0.0210227054,
-0.0314278044,
0.0374120325,
0.0264994111,
-0.0397893898,
-0.0464569964,
0.0089719389,
0.0591855831,
-0.0025067285,
-0.0147921611,
0.0222720653,
-0.0007810293,
0.0299300551,
0.0217408612,
-0.0410775915,
-0.0168162398,
-0.056196969,
-0.0179252997,
0.0040340964,
0.0556716807,
0.0315259732,
-0.0041436222,
-0.0571437031,
0.0429820009,
-0.0362863094,
-0.0246935952,
-0.0124101294,
0.0306700356,
0.0809934586,
-0.0310323481,
-0.0001482174,
-0.0312697403,
-0.0329971574,
-0.0040419581,
0.0102235302,
0.0278456211,
-0.0357587487,
0.0763134435,
0.0417268313,
-0.0023226065,
-0.0416946895,
0.0599220805,
0.0138832899,
0.0792390108,
-0.0074281637,
-0.0307294186,
-0.0088049201,
0.016777698,
0.0277910046,
0.027011428,
0.0197057575,
0.0698551461,
-0.0784827843,
-0.0606935099,
0.0182643402,
-0.0077461535,
0.0019967416,
-0.0013501126,
0.0549474284,
0.0515004732,
0.0011488716,
-0.0055772974,
-0.0049957568,
0.0073351678,
-0.0260199197,
-0.0041468889,
-0.0084371474,
-5.825579923e-33,
-0.0129336957,
-0.0338103026,
-0.0432823114,
0.0213839803,
-0.0218714848,
-0.0131789763,
-0.0244347565,
-0.0044018701,
-0.0166938826,
0.0301527306,
0.0400164761,
-0.0265804101,
0.0001736321,
0.0095115509,
0.0145669831,
-0.0045974539,
0.0240325388,
0.0196604766,
-0.0290143229,
-0.0053305202,
0.0184233841,
0.0053421669,
0.0536906645,
-0.022359889,
-0.0299591441,
0.0461684987,
0.0205724854,
0.0247875582,
0.01378839,
0.0631266832,
-0.0582921617,
0.0956517756,
0.0292083435,
0.0065295692,
0.0061412193,
0.0227301028,
-0.0346771404,
-0.0301623829,
0.0096633686,
-0.0049057589,
-0.0230672155,
-0.022055557,
0.0485520214,
-0.014039061,
-0.0170161333,
0.0285051018,
0.0434144065,
-0.0657005757,
-0.0310044624,
-0.013710482,
-0.0693338215,
0.0054574916,
0.0008962392,
0.0024708074,
0.0247413572,
-0.0299082194,
0.0075726369,
0.0388846882,
-0.0338730626,
0.0297999419,
-0.0044811261,
0.0019082308,
0.037715517,
0.065787293,
0.0488469191,
0.0820920765,
0.0353073962,
-0.0251705572,
-0.0248928536,
-0.0314277709,
0.0386144109,
0.0085764118,
0.0376635343,
0.0087324977,
0.0523627885,
-0.0307248738,
-0.0461565033,
-0.0100766271,
0.0063482127,
0.0229855254,
0.0362330601,
0.0294593126,
-0.0277915932,
-0.0016987273,
-0.0415678211,
-0.0072790016,
-0.0459641553,
-0.0379250646,
0.0166131258,
-0.0545313321,
0.0078260694,
0.0057439092,
0.0082823001,
-0.0390891694,
-0.0324341804,
-0.0062084734,
-0.0128863761,
0.0088080447,
-0.0102737034,
0.0109609216,
-0.0571627133,
-0.0647844449,
-0.002791936,
0.0255670063,
-0.0091465134,
-0.0093953712,
0.0146179618,
0.0301995557,
-0.0415663868,
-0.009577699,
-0.0516905487,
-0.0709100589,
0.0233998001,
-0.0080645876,
0.0099535054,
-0.0036228292,
-0.0244207066,
-0.014793478,
0.0217466149,
-0.0502130836,
0.0050444989,
-0.0076456829,
-0.0016407489,
0.0208289586,
-0.0438175462,
-0.0283681061,
-0.0391282029,
-0.010526198,
0.050155852,
-0.0247514434,
-0.027047161,
-0.0110027781,
2.559e-7,
0.0621087998,
0.0361886434,
0.013481657,
-0.0172146708,
0.0274983719,
0.0084201545,
-0.0048362613,
0.0112781264,
-0.000990877,
-0.0437437408,
-0.0280713812,
0.0245168339,
0.0188319925,
0.0057985298,
-0.0709391311,
0.0449532755,
-0.0188280456,
0.0113156298,
-0.0271375906,
0.0262206458,
0.0640621483,
0.0917719156,
0.0150086051,
-0.0052559432,
0.0090992609,
-0.0304340795,
0.0880256295,
-0.0540556423,
0.078618519,
0.0260658469,
0.0054502967,
0.0026345821,
0.0025061285,
0.0420730188,
0.0416204333,
0.0127075501,
0.0282606203,
0.0235964172,
-0.0305587482,
-0.0458530746,
-0.0172061529,
-0.0135619156,
-0.0060434598,
-0.0942559466,
0.055714339,
-0.0833278149,
-0.0827274993,
0.0305214059,
0.0255513713,
-0.0151170036,
0.0182469115,
-0.0413385816,
-0.0409027487,
-0.0193890985,
-0.0123778591,
-0.0174768716,
0.0005557028,
-0.0806613341,
-0.0203086622,
0.0081186453,
-0.0575780571,
-0.0338595845,
-0.0012163329,
-0.021683462,
0.0346035361,
-0.0378555991,
0.0034431568,
1.969997207e-34,
0.0300865509,
-0.0222676173,
0.012701991,
0.0180420335,
0.0081099747,
-0.0213208925,
0.0596887022,
-0.009822621,
0.034782812,
-0.057238169,
0.015585701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05470v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05470v2 | Generative Judge for Evaluating Alignment | 2023-10-09T07:27:15 | 2023-12-07T08:48:36 | Junlong Li, Shichao Sun, Weizhe Yuan, Run-Ze Fan, Hai Zhao, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has substantially
expanded the range of tasks they can address. In the field of Natural Language
Processing (NLP), researchers have shifted their focus from conventional NLP
tasks (e.g., sequence tagging and parsing) towards tasks that revolve around
aligning with human needs (e.g., brainstorming and email writing). This shift
in task distribution imposes new requirements on evaluating these aligned
models regarding generality (i.e., assessing performance across diverse
scenarios), flexibility (i.e., examining under different protocols), and
interpretability (i.e., scrutinizing models with explanations). In this paper,
we propose a generative judge with 13B parameters, Auto-J, designed to address
these challenges. Our model is trained on user queries and LLM-generated
responses under massive real-world scenarios and accommodates diverse
evaluation protocols (e.g., pairwise response comparison and single-response
evaluation) with well-structured natural language critiques. To demonstrate the
efficacy of our approach, we construct a new testbed covering 58 different
scenarios. Experimentally, Auto-J outperforms a series of strong competitors,
including both open-source and closed-source models, by a large margin. We also
provide detailed analysis and case studies to further reveal the potential of
our method and make a variety of resources public at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/auto-j. | [
0.0543663576,
0.0693383366,
0.0135538178,
0.0235558171,
-0.0559796095,
-0.0004639124,
0.0033378047,
-0.0233786814,
-0.0071612499,
-0.0559994206,
-0.0196205117,
-0.0446994379,
-0.0170671549,
0.0540029556,
0.0268556513,
-0.0152246524,
0.0380697139,
0.0107577387,
0.0300484411,
0.0316968001,
0.0444116406,
0.0351890065,
-0.0178578962,
0.071343869,
0.0039686495,
-0.0368288681,
-0.0117160622,
0.0048915981,
0.0171340257,
0.0055793067,
0.0271237195,
0.0817950442,
-0.0044518001,
0.0672720149,
0.0000018563,
-0.0450330377,
-0.0143955154,
0.0069043138,
-0.0128955338,
-0.0056696809,
0.0325474814,
-0.0022668599,
-0.0022200064,
0.015003195,
-0.0690229014,
-0.0101069314,
0.0542022251,
0.04769326,
0.060410209,
0.090018563,
0.0042857123,
-0.0282504484,
0.0245627239,
-0.0065855864,
-0.0069914777,
-0.0326437764,
0.0064307232,
-0.0020954702,
-0.0331713147,
0.0049245823,
-0.0048802826,
0.0022153375,
0.0083339866,
-0.024180403,
0.0328855217,
-0.0068746516,
-0.0546188168,
-0.0446108244,
-0.0072000897,
0.0770391002,
0.0141568072,
-0.0396923237,
0.0009601488,
-0.0151468506,
0.0014306443,
0.0069808862,
-0.0192637928,
-0.0019336623,
0.0059662969,
0.0248372443,
0.0088869426,
0.0251620263,
0.0178904645,
0.0204038676,
0.0002404978,
0.0553188883,
0.0231246203,
-0.0528736599,
-0.0260992665,
0.0149714258,
-0.0121949576,
-0.0669876635,
-0.0181817729,
-0.0042843563,
-0.0462632403,
0.0107743554,
-0.0617925562,
-0.020200219,
0.0363683179,
-0.0066236267,
0.0550406761,
0.0372215882,
0.0270985141,
0.0484666117,
0.0082156863,
0.0861052424,
-0.0297680572,
0.0115480609,
-0.0332925841,
-0.0067907665,
-0.0532310605,
-0.0158793423,
0.0032063783,
-0.0031706912,
-0.0462730117,
-0.0293049887,
-0.0560696609,
0.0322549269,
-0.0332483537,
0.0226347372,
0.0350650214,
0.0364322849,
-0.0162430834,
-0.0078527564,
-0.0619341247,
0.0240110327,
-0.0329858921,
-0.0109755676,
0.0196144748,
-0.0398441441,
-0.0122492099,
0.0267871469,
0.0014943235,
-0.0491160601,
-0.0243710149,
0.0563544035,
0.012308063,
-0.001112072,
0.0031205765,
-0.025933655,
-0.0366048515,
-0.0696365982,
-0.049725052,
-0.0604864471,
0.0479250662,
0.0166219007,
-0.0201935656,
-0.0502712615,
-0.0035928334,
0.0406282842,
-0.009393421,
0.0665098652,
0.0085056573,
0.0186347757,
-0.0247561466,
-0.0249746963,
0.015740823,
0.0433038175,
0.0224771742,
-0.0102804592,
0.0354881175,
-0.0194877665,
0.0487315543,
0.0233644936,
-0.005208856,
-0.0155042186,
0.0037236062,
0.0200409088,
0.0083449082,
0.0604576319,
0.0241426565,
0.0506594628,
0.0092059895,
-0.0144682014,
0.0582353882,
0.0386876576,
0.055714868,
0.0391683839,
0.0553377308,
0.0209992956,
-0.0228266045,
0.0108929724,
-0.0474865474,
0.0146105615,
-0.044553075,
0.0291581675,
0.0532981306,
0.0282271523,
-0.0039308574,
-0.0496118143,
-0.0416458249,
0.0259998757,
-0.0225254539,
-0.0069100405,
0.0275026262,
-0.0013886192,
-0.0501668751,
0.0160164554,
0.0105235707,
-0.0693457425,
-0.0033894705,
-0.0263295062,
0.038125094,
0.065955691,
0.0636219308,
-0.0030466751,
-0.0318633392,
-0.0114714587,
-0.0242567956,
0.0480030663,
0.066787675,
0.0078655472,
-0.0076832515,
-0.0432113111,
-0.0496936105,
-0.0298181772,
0.0147582777,
-0.0100263311,
0.0389709957,
-0.0286212359,
0.0188938212,
-0.0394233391,
-0.046372924,
0.0464498661,
-0.0197783429,
-0.0246254988,
-0.0184420962,
0.0178501122,
0.0375164934,
0.0343484506,
-0.0171647854,
0.0352870822,
0.0087955827,
-0.0362664051,
0.0023004431,
0.0143844457,
-0.0388442911,
-0.0340959392,
0.0371213518,
-0.03286504,
-0.0323441178,
0.0434221625,
-0.0527658612,
-0.0591455624,
-0.0038098921,
-0.0076441723,
0.0141110923,
-0.0466490686,
0.0164598599,
0.0064178621,
-0.0087298695,
-0.0461346433,
0.0757534206,
0.0144374808,
0.0329113007,
-0.0202341154,
-0.0040959683,
0.0269412547,
-0.01539174,
-0.0546176881,
-0.0038441531,
-0.0172413643,
0.016071219,
0.0440880544,
0.0006962225,
-0.0576823913,
-0.0251724664,
-0.0925393924,
0.0467780568,
-0.0276710503,
0.0323997438,
0.0486784838,
0.0019141182,
-0.0019627286,
0.0038211008,
-0.0730967149,
-0.0283712,
0.0420361124,
0.0024288457,
0.0601059347,
-0.0162817854,
-0.0197912063,
-0.0637818649,
-0.0047069583,
-0.0517476648,
0.0511074252,
0.0275492575,
0.0228793547,
-0.0358188264,
0.0131787853,
-0.03137023,
0.0106543712,
0.012248802,
-0.0253680348,
0.0060809129,
-0.0050823684,
0.0239337664,
0.0332595631,
0.0355579369,
-0.0059197634,
0.0058747954,
0.0170007702,
-0.0797216594,
0.0101193497,
-0.0207822099,
-0.0121371765,
-0.015528705,
-0.022735877,
0.0328011513,
0.1035423949,
0.0274283271,
-0.0122135244,
-0.0759872422,
0.0412525758,
0.004121725,
-0.0093082394,
-0.0264662486,
-0.0170891043,
-0.0206767898,
0.0352459326,
-0.0602561757,
-0.059841387,
0.1040915102,
-0.041286435,
-0.001898503,
-0.033925131,
-0.008408702,
-0.0510315299,
0.0651806444,
0.0005984858,
0.0231295396,
0.0084932027,
-0.0182968974,
-0.035651356,
0.012684253,
0.0230054818,
-0.0479095131,
0.0563180409,
-0.0495032668,
0.0210205875,
-0.0211830847,
-0.0594272874,
-0.0535545982,
-0.0626299828,
-0.0250133276,
0.0147221703,
0.0273746308,
-0.0095427204,
-0.0428780988,
0.0159599558,
-0.0110542011,
0.0319343358,
-0.019842824,
-0.0038809993,
-0.0358665138,
0.0298353881,
0.0648842603,
0.0189766381,
0.0190158188,
0.0095887426,
0.0155944489,
0.0320930257,
0.0209834669,
0.0231750961,
-0.0486485176,
-0.0105459951,
0.0143789994,
-0.0564776249,
0.0135377413,
-0.0118422648,
0.0748287514,
-0.0414384529,
-0.0118050473,
0.114959538,
0.0361260101,
-0.0327948444,
-0.0157466307,
0.0024664355,
0.0410830788,
0.0300160125,
0.0380734168,
-0.0602670647,
-0.0448294468,
-0.0108649004,
0.0300607216,
0.0017301008,
-0.0222928654,
-0.0063701188,
-0.1346468478,
0.0162230637,
-0.0082318541,
0.0009159351,
-0.0314468145,
-0.0180041827,
-0.0011929011,
-0.0444359966,
0.0180679485,
0.0085935686,
0.0109694432,
0.035714291,
0.0098062204,
-0.0320727304,
-0.0368336104,
0.0291901268,
-0.0699592084,
0.0713082179,
0.090792194,
0.0286099371,
0.0407436267,
-0.0370139219,
-0.0045299381,
-0.0196105894,
0.0193269998,
0.0178817809,
0.0256768968,
-0.020920787,
-0.0025579971,
-0.0399946272,
0.0259295814,
-0.0621175058,
-0.0070115128,
0.0031312518,
0.0526094325,
-0.0064043375,
0.0217348281,
-0.0389748029,
0.0117488913,
0.0049786344,
0.1140511557,
0.0249960385,
-0.0277594384,
-0.0665856972,
-0.0207911152,
0.0042914366,
-0.0824236795,
-0.0477282554,
-0.0029313813,
0.0288536381,
0.0152282408,
-0.0649333373,
-0.0389984027,
0.0097224573,
0.0165404137,
0.0118661951,
-0.031916108,
-0.0393218808,
-0.0264658257,
-0.0212481301,
0.069124572,
0.0055656764,
0.0174353886,
-0.0481179729,
-0.0079531642,
0.0038580478,
0.005679918,
-0.0136473663,
0.0346683487,
-0.0823366046,
-0.0656783581,
-0.025099529,
0.0409114286,
0.0209563524,
0.0465774946,
-0.0454554968,
-0.0233800281,
-0.0129698534,
0.0226337444,
-0.0578177162,
-0.0052941479,
-0.0094393725,
0.0203423873,
-0.0086880242,
0.0272975154,
-0.0184984487,
-0.0078312224,
-0.0004679876,
0.0835783258,
-0.021576345,
-0.0450556278,
0.0592791215,
0.00613167,
0.0703878924,
-0.0155929923,
-0.037705373,
-0.0364625268,
-0.0211214665,
-0.0187487043,
-0.0552154705,
-0.0463009663,
0.0004446267,
0.0265280586,
-0.0189263634,
-0.0052753664,
0.0490905531,
-0.0398150571,
0.0416623987,
-0.0558976382,
-0.0147499405,
0.0309306942,
-0.0215684604,
-0.0055048866,
-0.0067949644,
-0.0486178808,
0.0182092115,
-0.002632888,
0.0219572708,
-0.0011274426,
0.0674292445,
0.0051065758,
0.0219802931,
0.0166261215,
0.0291362014,
-0.0622700378,
-0.0040500876,
-0.0315198787,
0.0133543061,
0.0168515649,
-0.0114896204,
0.0398515798,
0.0191178173,
-0.0082059549,
-0.0168199074,
0.0681571662,
-0.0100365523,
-0.0015578279,
0.0260443129,
0.0372518525,
-0.0299438071,
-0.048371695,
0.0594058186,
-0.0019460407,
0.014827597,
-0.0092175733,
-0.0269546211,
-0.0457724258,
-0.0264027175,
-0.0026924366,
0.0059177047,
-0.0155965881,
-0.0068852622,
-0.0649544299,
-0.0377594419,
-0.0024463078,
0.0486202538,
-0.0059929155,
0.0111601045,
0.0158734601,
0.0887318328,
-0.0456280112,
-0.0227672495,
-0.0404842608,
-0.0117059639,
-0.0192669444,
-0.0090188477,
-0.0620554872,
-6.079837515e-33,
-0.0020669699,
-0.0386897512,
0.0296705812,
-0.0584854484,
-0.0421617068,
-0.0036415786,
-0.0274919495,
0.0073713399,
-0.0095757088,
0.0060134786,
0.0010570495,
0.0082482649,
0.0030407228,
0.0365746804,
0.0195610058,
-0.0169143192,
0.0496788472,
-0.0025890684,
-0.0379645936,
0.0023042413,
0.0269192681,
0.0043138913,
0.0364494137,
-0.0336569883,
0.0608065911,
-0.0202885736,
-0.0219447203,
0.0152110988,
-0.0186884999,
0.0805545524,
-0.0234598555,
0.0261207949,
0.0368105397,
-0.0289246067,
0.0027790107,
0.0372396223,
-0.0418710001,
-0.0047670626,
0.0347983353,
-0.0045768619,
-0.0438852012,
-0.0174769592,
0.0529316403,
-0.0105499318,
-0.0253579002,
-0.0033428587,
0.0524338856,
-0.0049561206,
0.002493483,
-0.02110916,
-0.0700324997,
0.0312857106,
-0.0331745222,
-0.0389944576,
-0.0150990942,
0.0829253048,
0.0130801387,
0.0354659222,
-0.060270153,
0.0086686816,
0.0033487312,
0.0329488702,
0.0908310041,
0.0093663819,
-0.013131937,
0.0686446205,
-0.0346884392,
-0.028333744,
-0.0550471954,
-0.0234390851,
-0.0100589106,
0.0513646305,
0.0338229239,
0.1051096544,
0.0330811404,
0.0360625386,
-0.0313205682,
0.0493278652,
-0.0077302181,
0.0300531425,
0.0225795638,
0.0045219385,
-0.0642832443,
0.0095689185,
-0.0342792608,
-0.0223922059,
-0.0642047971,
-0.013035981,
0.0491179302,
0.0097919935,
-0.0126793161,
-0.0036651031,
0.0120272404,
-0.0563844927,
0.0231982935,
0.0181664303,
-0.0217252262,
-0.000947711,
-0.0039173681,
0.0329723246,
-0.01462295,
-0.0198782273,
-0.0063412511,
0.0476200394,
0.0169090256,
-0.0010162931,
0.033737272,
-0.031189315,
-0.0577192195,
0.0266134609,
-0.039675571,
0.0234574601,
-0.0517737679,
0.0009321484,
0.0492748171,
0.0121561131,
-0.0195790268,
0.0412824862,
0.0178150441,
0.0240995511,
-0.0325636454,
-0.0180587955,
-0.003140653,
0.0011841033,
-0.0050526406,
-0.0041905828,
0.0054699481,
-0.0035722509,
0.0162316747,
-0.0106421364,
0.0002873147,
0.040784914,
2.44e-7,
0.0628566146,
0.0270302091,
0.0395242162,
-0.0346822403,
0.0000428014,
0.0414559878,
0.0100588752,
0.023276506,
-0.0150583666,
-0.0080155972,
0.0030998839,
0.0027444258,
0.0623865314,
-0.0076585538,
-0.0668119565,
0.0337625556,
-0.0898542032,
0.0158912893,
-0.0600498058,
0.0087536387,
0.0780580938,
0.0937330127,
0.0111113451,
0.0133070657,
0.0014402283,
-0.0290807821,
0.0521409176,
-0.0177899282,
-0.0310419407,
0.0292124487,
0.0516494401,
-0.0172002427,
0.0184147712,
0.0137108071,
-0.0190477688,
0.0330454931,
-0.0023595041,
0.0788594112,
0.0002930452,
-0.032029029,
-0.0322870277,
-0.0275297333,
0.019420594,
-0.0863271654,
0.0542631745,
-0.0448967554,
-0.0202578437,
-0.0275493767,
-0.0258969236,
-0.0059307371,
0.0260333251,
-0.0002463261,
-0.0052286168,
0.0177308023,
0.034301918,
-0.0145559646,
-0.0362146981,
-0.0746256858,
-0.0322486497,
0.0050744154,
-0.0479708649,
-0.0110742506,
-0.027680235,
-0.0204434749,
0.0518472716,
-0.0692502484,
-0.0024638847,
2.350741435e-34,
0.0306393635,
0.0260544159,
0.0359578691,
0.0074772257,
0.0491592959,
0.0185724087,
-0.0168509949,
0.001004476,
0.0293427873,
-0.088143006,
-0.0157970935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05452v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05452v2 | Parrot Mind: Towards Explaining the Complex Task Reasoning of Pretrained Large Language Models with Template-Content Structure | 2023-10-09T06:57:45 | 2024-04-05T08:07:59 | Haotong Yang, Fanxu Meng, Zhouchen Lin, Muhan Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The pre-trained large language models (LLMs) have shown their extraordinary
capacity to solve reasoning tasks, even on tasks that require a complex process
involving multiple sub-steps. However, given the vast possible generation space
of all the tasks, how the pretrained model learns the reasoning ability remains
an open question. We firstly propose that an intrinsic structural constraint on
the generated sequence of language-based reasoning -- we called it
template-content structure (T-C structure) -- is the key to explain why LLMs
can solve a large number of complex reasoning problems with limited training
data by showing this structure can reduce the possible space from exponential
level to linear level. Furthermore, by generalizing this structure to the
hierarchical case, we demonstrate that models can achieve task composition,
further reducing the space needed to learn from linear to logarithmic, thereby
effectively learning on complex reasoning involving multiple steps. We provide
both examples and formal theory of our T-C structure. We also experimentally
validate the existence of the T-C structure in some current LLMs and its
effectiveness for reasoning. | [
0.0257056598,
0.0210457612,
-0.0125926146,
0.009528555,
-0.0295828599,
0.0653943792,
-0.0048056757,
-0.0112117361,
-0.0319206342,
-0.044273138,
-0.005975713,
-0.0195251908,
0.0069108703,
0.0130100129,
0.0354771912,
-0.0774756223,
0.0321147889,
-0.0744651556,
0.0088819033,
-0.0151556842,
-0.0266877152,
-0.0075524766,
-0.0139650218,
0.025258394,
0.0122339083,
-0.0240534563,
-0.0505854227,
-0.0256414246,
-0.0094421338,
-0.0171726681,
-0.0239331312,
0.0100910608,
0.0546411537,
0.0262712501,
0.0000019389,
-0.0493342541,
0.0049204077,
0.0017603856,
-0.0753409564,
-0.0139503544,
-0.0164543465,
0.0149561819,
0.0139173679,
0.0244070161,
-0.0193972308,
-0.046966359,
0.0314396061,
0.0999576002,
0.049635049,
0.0970589444,
0.0103698215,
-0.0773708299,
-0.0028129776,
-0.021869041,
0.0509694666,
-0.0558757223,
0.0326714739,
0.0650670379,
0.0529563464,
0.0192471445,
0.0072518266,
-0.0203719977,
0.0555683933,
0.0033432285,
-0.0276185405,
0.0366089121,
0.0164693575,
-0.0364352912,
-0.0053463578,
0.0553608574,
-0.0316052698,
-0.0278075524,
-0.0070295534,
-0.0060691349,
0.0045306156,
-0.0030315234,
-0.0519776568,
0.057287205,
-0.0064039957,
0.0379133262,
0.039313212,
-0.0252692793,
0.0353484377,
-0.0131162228,
-0.0671876743,
0.0806197673,
-0.0193019379,
-0.0377587974,
0.0232365094,
0.0094312951,
0.0136241298,
-0.076503396,
-0.0070550377,
0.0840888098,
-0.045035433,
0.0121926144,
0.0008111847,
-0.0101503823,
-0.0137332482,
-0.029672537,
0.0331350341,
0.0374917462,
0.0179763846,
0.0702076554,
-0.0559406355,
0.0772742927,
-0.0650134161,
0.0172929596,
-0.0498713553,
-0.0110195596,
-0.0808127001,
-0.0247810576,
-0.0522207022,
0.0678856,
-0.0082446728,
-0.018774556,
-0.0128810368,
0.0388537347,
-0.0197011065,
0.0355804153,
-0.0031749043,
0.0054860637,
0.0070236269,
-0.0318151936,
-0.0255651511,
-0.0077874316,
-0.0174080078,
0.0367240496,
0.0131435394,
0.019836273,
-0.0021603163,
0.0029558074,
0.0191318654,
-0.0212616455,
0.0093751131,
0.0395468622,
-0.0025773561,
0.0097596087,
-0.0296647232,
-0.0279282164,
0.0047387574,
-0.1002241746,
0.0356036909,
-0.0609841608,
0.027591316,
0.0004270838,
-0.0158599243,
0.0255636126,
0.0120967375,
-0.0042737862,
-0.0555845611,
0.0941667482,
0.0293355957,
0.0091670258,
-0.0000884842,
0.0146761574,
-0.0305167921,
0.047107894,
0.0057944944,
0.0075024739,
-0.0087909605,
-0.0032292525,
-0.0064198109,
-0.0064216149,
-0.0102177057,
-0.0354990736,
-0.0028189598,
0.0289879311,
0.0247898065,
0.0360208377,
-0.0064932127,
0.0385232754,
-0.0276296828,
0.0056250896,
0.0142146526,
0.0173288621,
0.0138260089,
0.0175590999,
0.0852068588,
-0.0067117629,
0.0312448423,
0.0472185798,
-0.084343195,
0.0003357203,
-0.0495063476,
-0.0094990963,
-0.0334636122,
0.0063619241,
-0.0497933328,
-0.057595849,
-0.0273223873,
-0.0061265938,
-0.0029895753,
0.0101096891,
0.0528468043,
0.0062430548,
-0.0288428497,
0.0152676348,
0.0126457307,
-0.0235391036,
0.0061134114,
-0.0435029194,
0.0525397323,
0.0353228748,
0.016372161,
-0.046683386,
-0.0376733057,
-0.0099967895,
0.0087884208,
-0.0031216866,
0.0253555402,
-0.0173972491,
-0.0291619897,
-0.0358937494,
-0.0334025174,
-0.0473383628,
0.0126013914,
-0.0110287108,
0.0022977816,
0.0011454883,
0.0162242744,
-0.0079332655,
-0.02668331,
0.0434153378,
-0.0013887617,
-0.0232591256,
-0.0139392382,
0.0242308788,
0.0242013801,
-0.0067445543,
-0.0069470839,
0.0287102964,
0.0325801075,
-0.0404429249,
-0.0541898869,
0.0161713883,
-0.0758579969,
-0.0461949594,
0.0332906954,
0.0001879056,
-0.0155441156,
0.0245937854,
-0.0355244614,
-0.0595790632,
0.0100348778,
-0.0209719241,
0.074862726,
-0.0194082446,
0.0433784649,
0.0095079131,
-0.0268600173,
-0.006885286,
0.0959374532,
0.0190898031,
-0.0008526659,
0.0049093403,
0.0408746488,
0.0072147944,
-0.0108771734,
0.0004734647,
0.0622459911,
-0.008123694,
-0.0024885545,
0.0010238751,
-0.0163925998,
-0.0418500975,
-0.0224471278,
-0.0706521496,
-0.0010439729,
-0.0155366557,
0.0069326824,
-0.0033128122,
-0.0377989374,
0.0254546162,
-0.0026065137,
-0.0518372394,
0.019011924,
0.0278861057,
0.0205238573,
0.0264242515,
0.0103118047,
-0.0380049795,
0.0121397451,
-0.0064477623,
-0.0400459804,
0.0638957024,
0.009781125,
0.0083931098,
-0.0500112996,
0.0479885004,
-0.0079542436,
0.0353197567,
-0.0149125811,
-0.0034958113,
0.0375336185,
-0.0433355644,
0.0515356809,
0.0941249207,
-0.0121548837,
0.03238919,
0.0596891232,
-0.0045087105,
-0.0070970152,
0.0340982638,
-0.0422404781,
-0.0147145931,
-0.035165336,
0.0131492009,
-0.0274297614,
0.0946265385,
-0.0325676203,
-0.0127714388,
-0.0716689602,
0.019720491,
-0.0030688641,
0.0100491466,
-0.0318381153,
-0.0482055321,
-0.018873753,
0.0367093459,
-0.0259365831,
-0.0262159817,
0.0537371449,
-0.0176859293,
0.0024417995,
-0.0414347015,
0.0060638115,
-0.0420860164,
0.115351975,
0.0348937288,
0.0109149469,
0.0320192575,
-0.0062729609,
-0.052581083,
-0.0212148782,
0.0135820694,
-0.0007102164,
0.0014808989,
-0.0346648805,
-0.0016742732,
-0.0220761616,
-0.0507386327,
-0.0405840985,
0.0146150859,
-0.0561701432,
0.0391386896,
-0.0267753359,
-0.0270004999,
-0.0217653029,
-0.0081636012,
0.0424259193,
0.0142825153,
-0.0151470024,
-0.0103831328,
-0.0376765244,
0.0282879137,
0.0185675323,
0.0470849797,
0.0482305326,
-0.0607344247,
0.0291330311,
0.0189194437,
0.0654032528,
0.011101312,
-0.0203899257,
0.0285707079,
-0.0028460359,
-0.0158097334,
-0.0509099327,
0.0164600834,
0.0294649359,
-0.0680033565,
0.0171917696,
0.1002937332,
0.0191534255,
-0.0115567902,
0.0150729818,
-0.0234777518,
-0.0063284482,
0.0345762521,
0.0398800969,
-0.0635807663,
-0.0161818434,
0.0299822893,
-0.0389055051,
0.0050589507,
-0.0397923477,
-0.0120803872,
-0.0915159285,
0.0317309499,
0.0021550893,
-0.0119509464,
-0.0283753444,
-0.0180792119,
-0.0098868031,
0.0311233867,
-0.0374301299,
0.0120777236,
-0.0010364039,
-0.0090321964,
0.0288865063,
-0.0137180984,
-0.0145799248,
0.0551340356,
-0.0183495451,
0.0302548129,
0.0333386064,
0.0322919004,
-0.0040280647,
-0.0185547192,
0.0354801416,
0.0044161729,
-0.0025569189,
0.0071337917,
-0.0273803845,
0.0265581477,
-0.016803477,
-0.0138343433,
0.0552024543,
-0.0345569365,
-0.0300959609,
0.0021244537,
0.1202459782,
-0.0414937288,
-0.0475735851,
0.0141730662,
-0.0057820263,
-0.0131689822,
0.0917181075,
0.0311549399,
-0.030385077,
-0.0666736886,
-0.0250745323,
-0.0619689338,
-0.013381077,
-0.0023033279,
0.0462300926,
0.0239715725,
0.0064893672,
-0.0586107671,
-0.0107015204,
0.0457769446,
0.0547136851,
-0.0165974107,
-0.0131300902,
0.0241300706,
-0.0029543843,
-0.0216567945,
0.028794311,
-0.027402781,
0.0141268633,
-0.0529517382,
-0.0211037882,
0.0297307372,
-0.0372987092,
-0.0232680514,
-0.0290504452,
-0.0591844022,
-0.0551214181,
-0.0036210881,
0.0493872426,
0.0259728674,
0.0588663705,
-0.0022693204,
-0.0374737754,
0.0519914888,
-0.0165614355,
-0.0412442349,
0.0306846388,
0.0549341813,
-0.0044186283,
0.0143295731,
0.058783561,
-0.0393413492,
0.0000080243,
0.018999666,
0.0064817914,
-0.0010800787,
0.0113622611,
0.0438067541,
0.0045133596,
0.003303238,
0.0293025244,
-0.0091402764,
-0.023747392,
0.0484164283,
-0.0329374112,
-0.0188520979,
-0.0547177009,
-0.0002457372,
0.0116818966,
0.0197490342,
0.0352966264,
-0.044588428,
0.0382710919,
0.0235871132,
0.0133844819,
0.0019571064,
-0.0189640373,
-0.0273881853,
0.0699043274,
0.0045581115,
-0.0130921919,
0.0103880065,
-0.0185099039,
0.0223855823,
-0.0169018563,
0.0794326887,
0.051983878,
0.0035225467,
-0.0686191767,
-0.012254131,
-0.0796597898,
-0.100166738,
0.0595519729,
-0.0213448368,
0.047941234,
-0.0216015559,
-0.0048502893,
-0.0428854637,
-0.0305719543,
0.0031938874,
0.0238549896,
0.0100925658,
-0.0309520457,
0.0369274355,
0.0412069596,
-0.0066043716,
0.0002126912,
0.0643806309,
0.0299958196,
0.0609785505,
-0.0014489734,
0.0143489363,
-0.0172159113,
-0.0270875413,
-0.0068199746,
0.0358239226,
-0.0149712665,
0.0389763787,
-0.0429814346,
-0.0783174783,
-0.0031773152,
0.0136932349,
-0.0353922285,
-0.0140374517,
0.025719244,
0.0562186092,
-0.0041049779,
-0.0423317403,
-0.0185930878,
-0.01296979,
0.0159141906,
0.0018888325,
0.0033586065,
-5.925858775e-33,
-0.0069937813,
-0.0225589909,
0.0289988145,
0.0154624972,
0.0041296072,
0.0009151353,
-0.0318925828,
0.0050338488,
-0.0257353075,
0.018443251,
-0.0090769297,
0.0014431177,
-0.0031084171,
0.0216001123,
-0.0024964819,
-0.0028263249,
0.0221824795,
-0.0127388388,
-0.0174608193,
0.0418194011,
0.040668346,
-0.0160852,
0.0282681491,
-0.0438062549,
-0.0055220565,
-0.0004052479,
-0.0054160864,
0.0629756823,
-0.0525752343,
0.0684463903,
-0.0342071429,
-0.0032100319,
0.0400517248,
-0.034428101,
-0.0077132806,
0.0266208667,
-0.0844208151,
-0.0428612828,
0.0478806607,
0.0001747695,
-0.0649538785,
-0.0350617394,
0.0311631672,
0.002602319,
0.0298747309,
-0.0240139756,
0.0029953739,
-0.0146890515,
0.005507024,
0.0046108197,
-0.055174537,
-0.0057792389,
-0.0183756687,
-0.0307150427,
0.0111442069,
0.0306061711,
-0.0188439004,
0.0035487264,
0.0004706568,
-0.0071027358,
0.0257967748,
0.0123819429,
0.0211658105,
0.0336397253,
0.0345873721,
0.0502300821,
0.0416840315,
0.0181140546,
-0.0787341967,
-0.0067134695,
-0.0181186274,
0.0707357153,
0.039979361,
-0.0307252035,
0.0187471546,
0.0388003439,
-0.0974167436,
-0.0265738703,
0.0103293471,
0.0692332238,
0.0149003463,
0.0100087253,
0.0071358196,
-0.0289354771,
-0.0634675995,
0.0183180254,
-0.0459114164,
-0.0022566919,
0.0204132125,
0.0267586019,
-0.012190178,
-0.0093670962,
0.0404981151,
-0.0413209237,
-0.0073717688,
0.0393964127,
-0.0051078675,
0.0109716216,
-0.0124834385,
0.0302416645,
-0.0479878969,
-0.0460413806,
-0.0007496068,
-0.0349990577,
0.0071730185,
0.0091145858,
0.0503654592,
0.052874282,
-0.0503297336,
-0.0056779506,
-0.0499755219,
-0.0066845864,
0.0288162604,
0.0396172181,
0.0822615623,
0.0248545092,
0.0005749988,
0.0418728366,
0.0007937186,
-0.0367818736,
-0.0425672419,
0.0330635644,
-0.0228676163,
0.0333670229,
-0.0079241227,
-0.0309874211,
-0.0542048961,
0.0031012401,
0.0352006368,
-0.0637166798,
-0.0068771145,
0.0276162047,
2.679e-7,
-0.0007254526,
0.0121899759,
0.0084743751,
0.0171422418,
0.0489012673,
0.0465713479,
-0.0194353219,
-0.0183578525,
-0.0234324243,
-0.0498698018,
0.0140741654,
0.0585550629,
0.0228428841,
0.0124357287,
-0.0407725163,
0.007420131,
-0.0350915343,
-0.0308226608,
-0.0444079228,
0.0092556067,
0.0636434034,
0.1027857512,
0.0192466024,
-0.0091689928,
0.0065719043,
-0.0445756502,
0.064692907,
0.0076759504,
0.0264040884,
0.0027932404,
-0.0189330261,
0.0189605355,
-0.0108275395,
0.0429918095,
0.0129811177,
0.043595247,
-0.0079528838,
0.0814865083,
0.0047862376,
0.0134143513,
-0.0104994662,
-0.0447598062,
-0.0153511688,
-0.070065707,
0.1043978333,
-0.0992966071,
-0.0534739867,
-0.0265579131,
0.0223590862,
-0.0306013282,
-0.0392073505,
0.0071188188,
0.0237990618,
0.0116238669,
-0.0270138476,
-0.0361728705,
0.0401465371,
-0.1200852245,
-0.0160056408,
0.0203495212,
-0.0481857918,
0.0012688753,
-0.027808113,
-0.0137884337,
0.0561478212,
-0.0339459144,
-0.0121583315,
2.625386965e-34,
0.0123992879,
-0.0246216059,
0.0228675082,
0.0009549326,
0.045456484,
-0.0279842578,
-0.0311786924,
0.0144714331,
0.0375965089,
-0.0962677896,
-0.0248718876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05450v2 | Empower Nested Boolean Logic via Self-Supervised Curriculum Learning | 2023-10-09T06:54:02 | 2023-12-31T04:20:00 | Hongqiu Wu, Linfeng Liu, Hai Zhao, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Beyond the great cognitive powers showcased by language models, it is crucial
to scrutinize whether their reasoning capabilities stem from strong
generalization or merely exposure to relevant data. As opposed to constructing
increasingly complex logic, this paper probes into the boolean logic, the root
capability of a logical reasoner. We find that any pre-trained language models
even including large language models only behave like a random selector in the
face of multi-nested boolean logic, a task that humans can handle with ease. To
empower language models with this fundamental capability, this paper proposes a
new self-supervised learning method \textit{Curriculum Logical Reasoning}
(\textsc{Clr}), where we augment the training data with nested boolean logic
chain step-by-step, and program the training from simpler logical patterns
gradually to harder ones. This new training paradigm allows language models to
effectively generalize to much harder and longer-hop logic, which can hardly be
learned through naive training. Furthermore, we show that boolean logic is a
great foundation for improving the subsequent general logical tasks. | [
0.0236612,
0.038266331,
-0.0330363587,
0.0289491788,
-0.0548259281,
0.0466611013,
0.0713659152,
-0.0307654478,
0.0403759927,
-0.0474047214,
0.0109244483,
0.0596261807,
-0.0369137712,
0.0267646778,
0.0027212764,
-0.0081263725,
0.0721489191,
-0.0256462172,
0.0464199409,
-0.0275146514,
-0.043021258,
0.0403326191,
-0.0297785792,
0.0121495035,
-0.0147939874,
-0.0265540835,
-0.0346515886,
-0.0234525241,
-0.0143612083,
-0.0030425771,
0.0099621983,
0.0591953546,
0.0133300284,
-0.0029225675,
0.0000021388,
-0.0419118293,
-0.0329061262,
-0.0272280201,
-0.0403018259,
-0.0074494611,
0.0070557273,
0.0789151192,
-0.0077151661,
0.0047202785,
-0.0546086207,
0.0236854106,
0.0092357025,
0.040055953,
0.0572712012,
0.0496747233,
0.0049912627,
-0.0529789515,
-0.0053347144,
-0.0072925212,
0.0179526098,
-0.0190439858,
0.0039109499,
0.0618115515,
0.0138880638,
0.0053027477,
-0.0064090341,
0.0008989197,
0.0469132066,
-0.0112015642,
0.014530452,
0.0274253823,
-0.0576135665,
0.0074204602,
-0.0004360229,
0.0229747649,
-0.0550636239,
-0.0542166978,
0.0023735645,
-0.0118903778,
-0.0108358115,
-0.0414300002,
0.0024835814,
0.033535067,
-0.0278390143,
0.0357168615,
0.04832175,
-0.0204439517,
-0.0119660534,
0.0280374419,
-0.0512855873,
0.1272294074,
-0.0091035794,
-0.0077016968,
0.0444771573,
-0.0096779475,
0.009180624,
-0.0515690036,
0.0057625333,
0.037812572,
-0.0208296161,
0.0183116458,
-0.0058162436,
0.0434272401,
0.0139852203,
-0.0198097434,
-0.0034180242,
0.0464818068,
-0.0012982759,
0.06365145,
-0.0630058721,
0.0107716387,
0.0034041977,
0.0992417559,
0.0029362577,
0.0367375724,
-0.063411586,
-0.0213564988,
-0.0288146567,
0.0382271074,
-0.006550076,
0.0023344178,
-0.0445414037,
-0.0126092816,
-0.0130504193,
0.039069511,
0.0054162503,
0.007647749,
-0.0044322037,
-0.0477549173,
-0.0425730683,
-0.0071723824,
-0.030124547,
0.0138997175,
0.0035797048,
-0.0005859034,
-0.0106484601,
-0.016653778,
0.0013986153,
-0.029784672,
0.0428041965,
0.0356274918,
-0.0156281516,
0.0102078719,
-0.0785882249,
-0.0559474006,
-0.0113061313,
-0.0502813347,
0.0163192078,
-0.0819860324,
-0.0357474238,
-0.0114574926,
0.0165033843,
-0.0294598844,
0.0154752294,
0.0019293139,
0.0022352086,
0.0812004209,
-0.0107299685,
-0.0486727655,
-0.0256801136,
-0.0038020653,
0.0209424086,
0.051531896,
0.0189670883,
0.0431903042,
0.0239109546,
-0.0021141509,
-0.0231601354,
-0.0302991532,
0.0400246643,
-0.0468859226,
-0.0625068098,
0.0042646453,
-0.0259647369,
0.0119677819,
-0.0256742314,
0.0135584669,
-0.0159474202,
0.0098453276,
0.0099075828,
0.025196366,
0.0210847296,
-0.0096400576,
0.0093693137,
-0.0233890191,
0.0131722409,
0.0370360427,
-0.0470823161,
0.0341193601,
-0.0283111818,
-0.0263605509,
-0.0320078731,
-0.0032465651,
-0.0120734284,
-0.1057066694,
0.0144494353,
0.0044685071,
0.000513511,
0.0075519145,
0.0480858199,
0.0274851359,
-0.0029872847,
-0.0107062813,
0.0757075176,
-0.0734813586,
0.0050612227,
-0.0494247079,
0.0350595564,
0.0260734335,
0.0267928168,
-0.0570031255,
-0.0526516549,
-0.0054072058,
0.0176418498,
0.003580461,
0.0071803094,
-0.0180128794,
0.0207953453,
-0.0464552343,
-0.0311814211,
-0.0250562616,
0.0205258802,
-0.0039224494,
-0.001740958,
-0.031876456,
-0.0038333482,
-0.0184970126,
-0.0159426332,
0.0345378928,
0.0023174374,
-0.0301537849,
0.0163331218,
0.0495274849,
0.0119423661,
-0.0114213591,
0.0112408148,
0.0181907676,
0.0023918985,
-0.0269947872,
-0.0531165376,
-0.0112227285,
-0.0493560992,
-0.0684466138,
0.058871761,
-0.0215840172,
-0.0491992123,
0.0223184973,
-0.0653072223,
-0.0096462173,
0.0122772474,
0.0019113239,
0.0353416689,
-0.0309161246,
-0.0011795304,
0.0232494008,
-0.033221934,
-0.0527631305,
0.082246244,
0.0034547369,
-0.0145457694,
-0.0477896556,
-0.0015112568,
0.0544824973,
-0.0317887291,
0.046619691,
0.000502847,
-0.0363425426,
0.0054209321,
-0.0059001804,
0.0101211919,
-0.0444901399,
-0.0260075592,
-0.0272766761,
-0.0011756974,
-0.0143483514,
-0.0092343893,
-0.0201903582,
-0.0399896018,
0.0264214389,
-0.0207046326,
-0.0432087183,
0.0251666233,
0.0051284581,
-0.0240533259,
0.0252403263,
-0.0211682674,
-0.0009968468,
-0.0163285732,
-0.0397161767,
-0.0563152805,
0.02609488,
0.0246514771,
0.0593880825,
0.0163497701,
-0.0090987692,
-0.0249801707,
0.0238199234,
-0.0115084993,
-0.0029218984,
0.0234303102,
-0.0439862423,
-0.0238052066,
0.1183631346,
0.0139998617,
0.0153811639,
0.083682701,
-0.0116606625,
-0.0328419879,
0.0724551305,
-0.0055580451,
-0.0213705748,
-0.0678925365,
0.0346419476,
-0.0137098078,
0.0182405468,
0.0041454011,
-0.0278883409,
-0.0622747056,
0.0455986224,
-0.0071998024,
-0.0204498433,
-0.063261129,
-0.0089980001,
0.010863306,
0.0860139653,
-0.0081111006,
-0.0034634829,
0.050410971,
0.0071802917,
0.0157486126,
-0.0486441329,
-0.0284745619,
-0.0305026639,
0.0726708099,
-0.0077426038,
0.018191563,
0.0337053239,
-0.0371979363,
-0.0230059065,
-0.054971125,
0.0582603514,
-0.044914566,
0.0181806106,
-0.0468001217,
-0.0062381728,
0.0157832243,
-0.0571237281,
-0.0608236492,
0.0285507943,
-0.0459296666,
-0.0075536435,
-0.0211856496,
0.0021567496,
-0.0040146192,
-0.0377136134,
-0.0345004983,
0.0187018774,
-0.0045552985,
-0.0061998833,
-0.0332146138,
0.0010221589,
0.0215526056,
0.0039067063,
0.0052339658,
0.0073977713,
-0.0001629967,
0.0200022515,
0.0078213224,
-0.00011655,
-0.0464049205,
0.0683225244,
0.0049965749,
-0.0238289386,
-0.0084807239,
0.0146169653,
-0.0100005548,
-0.0576294996,
-0.0018472738,
0.1246122494,
0.0412824973,
0.0167276729,
-0.0142896194,
-0.0451962873,
0.022135634,
0.0388017409,
0.0311559923,
-0.0559729896,
-0.0300121177,
0.0169680137,
0.0106595941,
0.0148785403,
-0.0365589336,
-0.0108308289,
-0.1040655747,
0.0374106541,
0.0112019628,
0.0036032635,
-0.0287335161,
-0.0500744022,
-0.0332813524,
-0.0431555547,
-0.0312685221,
0.0037043581,
-0.006945326,
-0.0115945321,
0.0240919981,
-0.0096507417,
0.0163403563,
0.0598862357,
-0.0136034498,
0.0307048932,
0.0049086828,
0.0460174792,
-0.0219687726,
-0.0226458851,
0.0321636014,
0.0301360879,
0.0156937223,
-0.0246724021,
0.0350276157,
-0.0178304873,
-0.0175355077,
-0.0255743284,
0.0490587614,
-0.0169880167,
-0.0168895964,
0.0219358075,
0.0946333408,
0.0002699068,
-0.0223115683,
-0.035595268,
0.0080569098,
-0.0068858918,
0.0553151183,
0.0059601977,
-0.015977025,
-0.0643400103,
-0.0406369977,
-0.0583789982,
-0.0567665994,
-0.0437065698,
0.0396791808,
0.0200520158,
-0.0424912274,
-0.0421519354,
0.0116772437,
0.0608338788,
0.075136669,
-0.0329047367,
0.0057775602,
0.0540675111,
0.0235104952,
-0.0370549969,
-0.0192206427,
-0.0524502844,
0.0064281458,
-0.0340346061,
0.0320359729,
-0.0177162122,
-0.0219297782,
-0.0402258895,
-0.0063830535,
-0.0362141877,
-0.0444735587,
0.000605462,
0.0601422712,
0.025455771,
0.0055871485,
-0.0090302993,
-0.0130870016,
0.0424386449,
0.0342334248,
-0.0209983252,
-0.01997298,
0.0893979743,
-0.0595746189,
0.0104345363,
0.031419944,
-0.0009542801,
0.0587241985,
0.0293486826,
0.0223234296,
-0.0384235419,
0.0360643417,
0.0722597465,
0.0236722548,
0.0390735492,
0.0094845705,
0.0143421423,
-0.0396119989,
0.018580066,
-0.0220756903,
-0.0516464934,
-0.0028973401,
0.0257176962,
-0.0025166846,
-0.0392385684,
-0.0089436285,
-0.0841195062,
0.0008778797,
0.0224970691,
0.0192168299,
0.0139738601,
0.0214570053,
0.0523093119,
0.0443322808,
-0.0350048617,
-0.0199838039,
0.0065164762,
0.0203299075,
0.0411231443,
-0.0129831461,
0.0378076918,
0.0246011131,
0.0110941175,
-0.0628988147,
-0.0432704613,
-0.0775960088,
-0.0267054271,
0.0297742262,
-0.0174161009,
0.0605564527,
-0.0473779142,
0.0017935637,
-0.0597715639,
-0.019330319,
0.0017112781,
0.0558868609,
0.0527328923,
-0.0342989936,
0.0066611413,
0.0042476919,
-0.0132477321,
-0.039197199,
0.0371704996,
-0.0037256943,
0.0565527156,
0.0390433297,
0.0120883919,
-0.0631181598,
-0.0522879027,
0.0064861882,
0.0663008615,
0.0010429688,
0.0629316494,
-0.0253995452,
-0.062142957,
0.0027639701,
0.0553308092,
0.0236730035,
-0.0128802117,
0.0076525011,
0.0597511418,
0.0158323646,
-0.0527719408,
-0.0187159404,
0.0538734235,
0.0088839037,
-0.0108419321,
-0.0216728598,
-6.178066231e-33,
-0.0331342034,
-0.0123156924,
0.0420997329,
0.0054773604,
0.0487690866,
-0.0173436794,
-0.0374487378,
0.038914524,
-0.021100726,
0.0644098818,
-0.0255266484,
0.0192555171,
0.001911496,
0.0217368267,
0.0440790653,
0.0103557287,
0.0342772529,
0.0171678122,
-0.014610745,
0.0036730103,
0.0564405434,
-0.008810699,
0.0169109758,
-0.0442200787,
-0.0440512188,
0.017712757,
-0.0231624935,
0.0604314543,
-0.0674127936,
0.0416346975,
0.0154103674,
0.0120080663,
0.0218828227,
-0.0109557528,
0.0285733696,
-0.0117709562,
-0.1027562171,
-0.072962299,
0.0077070538,
-0.0170794409,
-0.048927404,
-0.0305500068,
0.0162783451,
0.0123711759,
0.0121332621,
-0.0541265681,
0.0415220708,
-0.0371297821,
-0.0044522732,
-0.0046498636,
-0.0606064275,
0.038267985,
-0.0393145755,
-0.0118753221,
-0.0243491493,
0.0163619127,
-0.0116782309,
-0.0144347278,
-0.0059243212,
0.0359593891,
-0.002739036,
0.0031318397,
0.0399898738,
-0.0030277588,
-0.0185490269,
0.0701576918,
-0.0088919206,
0.0255801175,
-0.0592759922,
0.0399919562,
0.0282581635,
0.1117243916,
0.0360186435,
0.0120991338,
0.0629267991,
-0.0246036295,
-0.1125294045,
-0.0069940579,
0.0466310494,
0.0446641333,
0.0071996129,
-0.0061776559,
-0.0214515049,
0.0063580065,
-0.0314363837,
0.0114558619,
-0.0156067917,
0.0058901664,
0.0033816502,
-0.0055582589,
-0.0572171547,
-0.0333034024,
-0.0078826789,
-0.0340061337,
-0.0087797455,
0.058096543,
0.0105375554,
-0.025526274,
-0.0135211162,
0.06865336,
-0.0383382849,
-0.0115262633,
0.004840333,
-0.0329296403,
0.0140869822,
0.0217802245,
0.0784026906,
0.0208908506,
-0.0567592531,
-0.0259585045,
-0.0248893425,
0.0001994759,
0.0220992491,
0.0212843865,
0.0175998639,
0.0298703108,
0.0082509592,
-0.0084140254,
-0.0221886151,
-0.0407428294,
-0.0521774217,
0.020706227,
0.0090619326,
0.0285275746,
0.0126659963,
-0.0343794636,
-0.0801561102,
-0.0175575819,
0.0182406064,
-0.0426691771,
0.0064343112,
0.0277808215,
2.734e-7,
0.0247912388,
0.0305070821,
0.0003742728,
0.0552379303,
0.0065285265,
0.0249475632,
-0.0108648799,
-0.020051565,
0.0213825796,
-0.0303089432,
-0.0291133057,
0.0519720986,
0.0245621577,
0.0434033535,
0.0014519687,
0.0004228501,
0.0083712675,
-0.0618814863,
-0.0317443423,
0.0035461073,
0.1171489507,
0.0571503565,
0.0693002194,
-0.0270989817,
0.0357834063,
-0.0025021574,
-0.0025505647,
0.0522465482,
0.0393777415,
0.0121832304,
-0.0081195654,
0.0161511078,
-0.0131563144,
0.0460759252,
0.0088888267,
-0.0034106285,
-0.0494213402,
0.0808888748,
-0.0452290103,
-0.003099588,
-0.0150226308,
-0.0241410546,
0.0132453507,
-0.0418485105,
0.0971597433,
-0.0408990718,
-0.0028770957,
-0.0151493978,
0.0120808901,
0.0252180267,
0.0025065721,
0.0180894341,
-0.0355032682,
-0.0012379584,
0.0169596188,
-0.0145907197,
0.0241848081,
-0.101614207,
-0.0130749224,
0.0305498671,
-0.0125418678,
-0.0122746481,
0.0265314914,
0.0425129086,
0.0461683199,
-0.0351830199,
0.0171864759,
2.355130942e-34,
0.0253502745,
0.0058174054,
0.0297272447,
-0.0474324003,
0.0737278312,
0.0194938481,
-0.0372690856,
0.0109238541,
0.0490195267,
-0.019048959,
-0.0097742416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05442v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05442v2 | Establishing Trustworthiness: Rethinking Tasks and Model Evaluation | 2023-10-09T06:32:10 | 2023-10-23T14:43:40 | Robert Litschko, Max Müller-Eberstein, Rob van der Goot, Leon Weber, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language understanding is a multi-faceted cognitive capability, which the
Natural Language Processing (NLP) community has striven to model
computationally for decades. Traditionally, facets of linguistic intelligence
have been compartmentalized into tasks with specialized model architectures and
corresponding evaluation protocols. With the advent of large language models
(LLMs) the community has witnessed a dramatic shift towards general purpose,
task-agnostic approaches powered by generative models. As a consequence, the
traditional compartmentalized notion of language tasks is breaking down,
followed by an increasing challenge for evaluation and analysis. At the same
time, LLMs are being deployed in more real-world scenarios, including
previously unforeseen zero-shot setups, increasing the need for trustworthy and
reliable systems. Therefore, we argue that it is time to rethink what
constitutes tasks and model evaluation in NLP, and pursue a more holistic view
on language, placing trustworthiness at the center. Towards this goal, we
review existing compartmentalized approaches for understanding the origins of a
model's functional capacity, and provide recommendations for more multi-faceted
evaluation protocols. | [
0.0541601032,
0.0871592015,
-0.0123688877,
0.0498920828,
-0.0708337128,
0.0152015481,
0.026997149,
-0.0184571631,
0.0175200664,
-0.0344921499,
-0.0438050218,
-0.0778072476,
0.0137061961,
0.0600038394,
0.0484530404,
-0.0060227774,
0.0410928354,
-0.0309404042,
0.0361394919,
0.0147172622,
-0.0148534225,
-0.014016944,
0.0080503607,
0.0471485332,
-0.0001906876,
-0.0351834297,
0.0158249028,
-0.0138922743,
-0.007186166,
-0.0212821178,
-0.0315940157,
0.0660549402,
0.0076826662,
0.0570495427,
0.0000021657,
-0.060073752,
-0.0173017979,
0.0308785457,
-0.0711375475,
-0.0069820615,
0.0540157445,
-0.0075846543,
-0.0107070925,
-0.012222656,
-0.0387054272,
-0.0084101269,
0.0417405032,
0.029229058,
0.0243465248,
0.0515742414,
-0.0060013304,
0.0265146904,
0.0388333648,
-0.0112983771,
-0.00383413,
-0.0558318011,
0.0294293836,
-0.0057578636,
-0.0082177073,
0.0135493623,
-0.0065306192,
0.0379865915,
0.0339475274,
-0.0283048041,
0.0166184977,
0.0211596247,
-0.0073363641,
-0.0321708322,
-0.0321299843,
0.0092074592,
-0.0011382151,
0.0011018598,
-0.0279371012,
0.0049527846,
-0.028370874,
0.0208078623,
-0.0462802872,
0.0425352156,
0.0177746322,
-0.0100424774,
0.0231075976,
0.023624301,
0.0483083278,
-0.0048794164,
-0.0069713378,
0.1066850498,
0.0051214169,
-0.0297148097,
0.0194475409,
0.024545813,
-0.036496561,
-0.0792620629,
-0.0317768268,
0.011247891,
-0.0077984757,
0.043350447,
-0.0005154896,
0.0134073989,
0.0475276262,
-0.0065195686,
0.0307103358,
-0.0195379835,
-0.0041968012,
0.0440594219,
0.0099429199,
0.0711562485,
-0.0023612096,
0.0043121171,
0.0152628049,
0.004914945,
-0.0577894859,
-0.0208159499,
-0.0094626192,
0.0150009766,
-0.0144930938,
-0.028489612,
-0.0118557736,
0.0126072979,
-0.0448540896,
0.0329067111,
0.0290801283,
0.0040190872,
-0.0139058568,
-0.0159134902,
-0.0373589583,
-0.0169967916,
0.0017762178,
0.035085354,
-0.001121738,
-0.0986492559,
-0.0286937673,
0.009007588,
-0.0278605074,
-0.0552611463,
-0.0255267806,
0.0652455911,
0.0281212293,
-0.0653369948,
-0.0225029867,
-0.0351050906,
-0.0709201396,
-0.0901106298,
0.0140804928,
-0.0398222581,
-0.0125148604,
0.0006343324,
0.0122477505,
-0.0476911254,
-0.004286557,
0.0005515401,
-0.0477605127,
0.0723838136,
0.008429585,
-0.0107942251,
-0.0579685047,
0.0268235207,
-0.0136627527,
0.0311658941,
0.0283863656,
0.0169190783,
0.05276528,
0.0328719802,
0.0363074914,
0.0255069919,
-0.0134688979,
0.0012447559,
0.0095555596,
0.0055032643,
-0.0050955093,
-0.0460052043,
-0.0081547117,
0.0930780172,
-0.0262479987,
-0.034499418,
0.092535831,
0.0627274066,
-0.0105463611,
0.0160314403,
0.0590904094,
0.0112758586,
-0.0107932016,
0.0173755139,
-0.0645625517,
0.0060539166,
-0.0558940433,
-0.0228351094,
-0.0188370235,
0.015620416,
-0.0045266775,
-0.0235002954,
-0.0585626848,
-0.0120563451,
0.0461156927,
0.0020900765,
0.0300946459,
-0.002684952,
-0.0023697272,
-0.0101154232,
-0.0015393253,
-0.0568394847,
-0.0089064138,
-0.0707206577,
0.0417939983,
0.0525489785,
0.0630898997,
0.0367837623,
0.004719771,
-0.0269745197,
-0.0083790319,
0.0424743257,
0.0084171603,
-0.0086689396,
0.0182967875,
-0.0106941247,
-0.0185020063,
-0.0075963866,
0.0343439654,
0.0080248052,
0.0116486643,
-0.0036526041,
-0.0102206459,
-0.0325199403,
-0.0341615938,
0.0289307777,
-0.0177011341,
-0.0194024611,
-0.0429517962,
0.0063541494,
0.0553327724,
0.0286419932,
-0.0174540766,
0.0243271478,
0.0390495732,
-0.0006268476,
-0.0020299267,
0.0289946198,
-0.0300732497,
0.0241104979,
0.0083298832,
-0.0042920578,
0.0026525736,
0.0210067574,
0.0088431789,
-0.0351889357,
0.009422916,
-0.0542368069,
0.0245998073,
-0.0506832935,
0.0234046727,
-0.0434672982,
0.0186988786,
-0.0105075501,
0.0543273613,
-0.0137900664,
0.0031653526,
-0.0444695801,
0.0225414224,
0.0289485324,
-0.0362140536,
-0.0641845763,
0.0216177609,
0.0000310531,
0.000192425,
0.0234836489,
-0.0088367146,
-0.0529175736,
-0.0290245898,
-0.084138535,
-0.0058587356,
-0.0218299646,
0.0394838303,
0.0091396952,
-0.0606519729,
0.0007308374,
0.0313356891,
-0.0163678769,
0.0249413699,
0.0215179026,
0.0157287586,
0.0340687297,
-0.0298864618,
-0.0331934467,
-0.0043770755,
-0.0029553943,
-0.0089987554,
0.0908913612,
0.0338952728,
0.002303069,
-0.0360033736,
0.0318700895,
-0.0292161293,
0.006453759,
0.011646376,
-0.0297189839,
0.0214461498,
0.0426881872,
0.013839894,
0.0396282449,
-0.0060849441,
0.0240037907,
0.0191347301,
-0.0224017967,
-0.0262280572,
-0.009917248,
-0.0145579372,
-0.0477031991,
-0.0090831323,
-0.0204905048,
0.0019025953,
0.0808891878,
-0.0024237337,
-0.0421274379,
-0.0234701633,
0.029473586,
-0.0386239737,
-0.038837716,
0.0186447874,
-0.0476980656,
-0.0177446175,
0.0462112091,
-0.054439608,
-0.0617688745,
0.0646941885,
-0.0643633679,
0.0033574319,
-0.0150291268,
-0.0001575372,
-0.0011664034,
0.1028277576,
0.010982573,
-0.0011054873,
0.0683923885,
-0.0146895219,
0.002463588,
0.0019005226,
-0.0103756646,
-0.0238491297,
0.0215519611,
-0.0544156134,
0.0253532138,
0.0052008214,
-0.0188975036,
-0.0406220108,
0.0013633976,
-0.0223980099,
0.048503492,
0.0311122257,
-0.0263044387,
-0.0258842353,
0.0021644519,
0.046880383,
-0.0056957742,
-0.0182186123,
-0.0179301668,
-0.0261616707,
0.0262568183,
0.0327086225,
0.0071087275,
0.0732197389,
-0.007629788,
-0.0058415248,
0.0697386339,
0.0322340019,
0.0186053775,
-0.0373795442,
0.0158532355,
0.0302658379,
-0.0001684865,
-0.0041934247,
0.0200010184,
0.0713812932,
-0.0545562059,
-0.0428147018,
0.1005655602,
0.0301260762,
-0.022441823,
0.0076133404,
-0.0042189364,
-0.0048441701,
0.0241634324,
0.0036439667,
-0.0839264467,
-0.007760135,
0.0204842314,
-0.013720531,
-0.0475221351,
-0.0697799623,
-0.0258916244,
-0.0988120437,
0.0813580602,
-0.0145377275,
-0.0054408018,
0.0015575076,
-0.061743103,
0.0023880568,
-0.0311799832,
0.048731029,
0.00475029,
0.0135165751,
-0.0175626334,
0.0064899498,
-0.0117637021,
-0.0645582378,
0.0596395023,
-0.0566736534,
0.0952683538,
0.0641962886,
0.0194328092,
0.0030884794,
-0.0443057306,
-0.0177501552,
0.0113140577,
-0.0104548587,
0.0198651068,
0.037806958,
-0.0184476525,
0.0100113647,
0.0183102395,
0.0063473387,
-0.03112383,
-0.0249829721,
-0.0212873314,
0.0609150045,
-0.0020064318,
-0.0354296118,
0.000455847,
-0.0216582678,
0.0336123779,
0.1156045422,
0.0521143042,
-0.0092255566,
-0.0304764565,
-0.023653416,
-0.0150455041,
-0.0394884609,
-0.0481817313,
0.0457335263,
0.0544416904,
-0.0209436361,
-0.0590941645,
-0.0135511197,
0.0007961781,
0.0075162202,
0.0104861148,
-0.0149314115,
0.0278976969,
-0.0193340685,
-0.0477207452,
0.0192026086,
-0.0609833002,
0.0254813042,
-0.0432561748,
0.0325938985,
0.0060162204,
-0.0273942649,
-0.0180726182,
0.0471804552,
-0.0702926964,
-0.0600332431,
0.0130906338,
0.0551040098,
0.0328556634,
-0.0085771708,
-0.0560663454,
-0.0564732663,
0.0422342904,
-0.0076548462,
-0.0746321678,
0.0256883781,
0.0325411335,
0.0048279059,
0.0334058516,
0.0411384851,
-0.0054394989,
0.0527049527,
0.0346331596,
0.0196452253,
0.0085014505,
-0.0114262598,
0.015862925,
0.0395344608,
0.0583938695,
0.0077616689,
0.0248373598,
-0.031596601,
-0.0357258879,
-0.0563275255,
-0.0135526694,
-0.0404446237,
0.0051291669,
0.0218734257,
0.0110828169,
-0.0249148421,
-0.0326326005,
-0.0489622392,
0.073657237,
-0.0223079845,
0.0067560798,
0.005453587,
-0.0354632288,
-0.0013499184,
0.0087404549,
0.000944151,
0.0075372262,
-0.0651026368,
0.0305389352,
0.0373702385,
0.0301058944,
-0.0086248294,
-0.0284242369,
0.0062857321,
0.028405549,
-0.072136268,
-0.0369004272,
0.0064935111,
0.0402645953,
0.0161379445,
0.0024946278,
0.0567970425,
-0.0371518433,
0.0064682532,
-0.0344818495,
-0.0186059698,
0.0257883593,
-0.0697800815,
0.0170195829,
0.0403335579,
-0.034322124,
0.0124576958,
0.0440502204,
0.0002483222,
0.0186837334,
-0.0359009244,
-0.037789762,
-0.0418222845,
-0.0468105115,
-0.0164966453,
0.0051613185,
-0.0231902897,
0.0076965624,
-0.0913666561,
-0.0919252858,
0.0005150626,
0.0418354981,
0.0602026805,
0.0004147754,
-0.0053490652,
0.0822977722,
0.0177149195,
0.0162267536,
-0.0374112763,
-0.0390078761,
0.0068327524,
0.0168480836,
-0.009716698,
-6.952595785e-33,
0.014314536,
-0.0521173142,
0.0150435008,
-0.038489949,
0.0057318835,
0.0393961594,
-0.0550658591,
0.024199985,
-0.0251635201,
0.0159183554,
-0.0182235017,
-0.0027703489,
0.011119511,
0.0252572428,
-0.0054467409,
0.0406893827,
0.0379722863,
-0.0276188962,
-0.0128519591,
-0.0060227974,
0.0518980622,
-0.0214649439,
0.0388856642,
-0.0503330119,
0.0961864665,
-0.003932307,
-0.0242103972,
0.036623992,
-0.0218355879,
0.063590847,
-0.0413087159,
0.0137653723,
0.033656355,
-0.0564344414,
0.0105522582,
0.0100650322,
-0.0513999984,
0.0020399978,
0.035171032,
-0.0325159766,
-0.0720237643,
-0.0257851034,
0.0318739824,
-0.0309976302,
-0.0310813561,
-0.0196566228,
-0.0123545714,
-0.0296293497,
-0.0054309731,
-0.0109426752,
-0.0630789399,
0.0177176297,
0.0098270467,
0.0063442048,
0.0339070857,
0.0223845243,
-0.0162101164,
0.0175782889,
-0.0552336872,
-0.0039935997,
-0.0068460936,
0.0038572655,
0.0848265737,
-0.0324195139,
-0.012569475,
0.0824311078,
-0.0033464136,
-0.0069950595,
-0.0359788239,
-0.0045681763,
0.0293029938,
0.0448128395,
0.0588415973,
0.0653935,
0.0145716993,
-0.0084327934,
-0.0614495501,
-0.0069597741,
0.0317527093,
0.0319460146,
0.0588639788,
0.011714411,
-0.0706208125,
0.0055807089,
-0.0432599075,
-0.0439407527,
-0.0522354059,
-0.0408261083,
0.0257171746,
0.0022896437,
-0.0409647636,
0.0371792726,
0.0319459476,
-0.0537386015,
0.0080526816,
0.0082300659,
0.0009633676,
0.0167531893,
0.0097894669,
0.0520989671,
-0.0335978195,
0.0031879258,
0.0074335816,
0.0306498762,
0.0030724395,
-0.0054851202,
0.052485317,
0.0194860809,
-0.0264142193,
-0.0012180916,
-0.0470124967,
0.0453709811,
0.0186544843,
0.0456380472,
0.0599572137,
-0.0023286419,
-0.0207823571,
0.0095712775,
0.018672049,
-0.0140207289,
-0.0190532077,
0.0746306255,
-0.045005735,
-0.001752803,
-0.0227776561,
-0.0345999412,
0.0010183054,
-0.001633028,
0.0513728894,
-0.015727438,
0.0160756279,
-0.0145273581,
3e-7,
0.016080318,
0.0484070852,
0.0098163532,
-0.0005396538,
0.0433090925,
0.0190654192,
-0.0166362897,
0.0330490097,
-0.011210232,
-0.0429281965,
-0.0290619656,
0.0489607081,
0.0525536388,
0.0550225526,
-0.0438268408,
-0.0148995789,
-0.040518973,
-0.0107750222,
-0.0253975149,
-0.0017121747,
0.0512891524,
0.0864996985,
0.0130090462,
-0.0095512774,
-0.0231713913,
-0.0560401641,
0.0296527371,
-0.0238668397,
-0.0080880197,
0.0052987677,
0.0527090989,
0.0123738172,
0.0060872408,
0.0450704619,
0.0128412051,
0.0269022677,
-0.0280494355,
0.0795340687,
0.0089038555,
-0.0257616024,
-0.0168519448,
-0.0299405791,
0.0181477014,
-0.0993655026,
0.0627932623,
-0.0825737491,
-0.0549516454,
-0.0147013776,
-0.0207383577,
-0.0145128882,
0.0357148051,
0.0082403906,
0.0013169674,
0.0271857902,
0.0102379248,
-0.0065072654,
-0.0025719309,
-0.0556400008,
-0.0182221737,
-0.046040792,
-0.0288661756,
-0.0546333194,
-0.0040877056,
-0.0309465732,
0.0017260899,
-0.1091325507,
0.018561326,
2.869371608e-34,
0.0295680687,
-0.0127544533,
0.0097446013,
-0.0091265487,
0.0670648515,
0.0013502019,
-0.0367375687,
0.0159912109,
0.0122175654,
-0.0655018166,
-0.0232625529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05424v1 | Fast and Robust Early-Exiting Framework for Autoregressive Language Models with Synchronized Parallel Decoding | 2023-10-09T05:53:05 | 2023-10-09T05:53:05 | Sangmin Bae, Jongwoo Ko, Hwanjun Song, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL | To tackle the high inference latency exhibited by autoregressive language
models, previous studies have proposed an early-exiting framework that
allocates adaptive computation paths for each token based on the complexity of
generating the subsequent token. However, we observed several shortcomings,
including performance degradation caused by a state copying mechanism or
numerous exit paths, and sensitivity to exit confidence thresholds.
Consequently, we propose a Fast and Robust Early-Exiting (FREE) framework,
which incorporates a shallow-deep module and a synchronized parallel decoding.
Our framework enables faster inference by synchronizing the decoding process of
the current token with previously stacked early-exited tokens. Furthermore, as
parallel decoding allows us to observe predictions from both shallow and deep
models, we present a novel adaptive threshold estimator that exploits a Beta
mixture model to determine suitable confidence thresholds. We empirically
demonstrated the superiority of our proposed framework on extensive generation
tasks. | [
0.0081923818,
0.1225785688,
0.0181311816,
-0.0184758678,
-0.0081494413,
0.0190913398,
0.0222459864,
-0.0334542431,
-0.0460538976,
0.0010109325,
0.0144947339,
-0.0551040508,
-0.0012814251,
0.0593137331,
0.0125462255,
0.0078683812,
0.0459575094,
-0.0513954274,
0.0503920913,
-0.030708883,
-0.0172735564,
0.0178014915,
-0.0014455494,
0.0934608877,
-0.0014291366,
-0.0056386944,
-0.0216503423,
0.0149729559,
-0.0096983537,
-0.0203227755,
-0.0065394505,
0.0561106689,
0.0106870206,
0.0529084802,
0.0000018166,
-0.0180205833,
-0.0284702238,
-0.0027471255,
-0.0358221456,
0.0144561874,
0.0321314037,
0.000737697,
-0.009809088,
0.0318959542,
0.0222980641,
-0.0476168133,
0.063142553,
-0.0155716138,
0.0162381344,
0.023769876,
-0.0043197684,
0.0151620805,
0.0373948589,
-0.0574907251,
-0.0392797031,
-0.0807114169,
0.009718,
-0.0451672003,
-0.0398198999,
-0.0257150326,
-0.0250174422,
0.0499159507,
0.0438995548,
-0.0086964723,
-0.0323635601,
0.0493992791,
0.0391903035,
-0.0415942967,
-0.0302231908,
0.0138114681,
-0.0409157649,
-0.0484616272,
0.0125803854,
-0.0353510529,
-0.0255688038,
-0.0409039371,
-0.0327429622,
0.0336938389,
-0.0113791712,
0.0503733493,
0.0550724827,
0.0216420647,
0.0309326556,
0.0133043546,
-0.0255651623,
0.0278559532,
0.0486230217,
0.0158782713,
-0.0498943478,
0.0281431694,
-0.0121848397,
-0.0342388637,
0.0252048466,
0.0105772009,
-0.0251942035,
0.0159660336,
-0.0670240745,
-0.0531396382,
-0.027852118,
0.0133988643,
0.0288958345,
0.0591040663,
-0.0301695485,
0.0304137468,
-0.0353130251,
0.0377283469,
-0.0257332511,
-0.0558139756,
-0.0134165268,
-0.0256890506,
0.0399592854,
-0.0103125246,
-0.0366061814,
0.0157283247,
-0.0210408904,
-0.0293846298,
-0.0493625104,
0.0115998397,
0.0151920002,
-0.0048377574,
0.0123860827,
0.0215948578,
-0.0733056888,
-0.0170697607,
0.0461093448,
0.0371294916,
-0.0232914183,
0.0013332728,
0.0207118988,
-0.062195681,
-0.0213651508,
0.0235640407,
0.0181143768,
-0.0039060188,
-0.0118005816,
0.0412812121,
-0.0096003748,
-0.0173839442,
-0.0324248895,
-0.0268480238,
-0.0185473897,
-0.056479767,
0.0391206332,
-0.0778010488,
0.0251224767,
0.0205042455,
0.0060839001,
-0.0342345908,
-0.0032333913,
0.0110995518,
0.00592187,
0.0165644102,
-0.029846577,
-0.0011669218,
0.0056940131,
-0.0086102057,
-0.0041338764,
0.1012381166,
0.0145682665,
0.0552378595,
0.0160336103,
0.028912833,
-0.0138134267,
0.0412552021,
0.0316562615,
0.0010503306,
-0.0416056253,
-0.0371400155,
0.0032150014,
0.0065763714,
0.0573229231,
0.0498788469,
-0.0330335572,
-0.0029254411,
0.0505722016,
0.0466785319,
0.0222091265,
0.0316891856,
0.0622643158,
-0.0218518805,
-0.0202324502,
0.0203988813,
-0.0106427744,
0.0410711505,
0.0158015713,
0.0209893137,
0.0827441961,
0.0707996935,
-0.027621245,
-0.0133003518,
0.00732412,
-0.0010240811,
-0.0289481841,
-0.0090163117,
0.0633156449,
0.0079462891,
-0.0694300756,
0.0381669588,
0.0187867377,
-0.0228060726,
0.0137193026,
-0.0691272691,
0.0264917146,
0.0369992517,
0.041465722,
0.0081456015,
0.0112833753,
0.0163762756,
-0.0117869368,
0.0248104129,
-0.0008241388,
0.0151822213,
0.037793465,
-0.0503321998,
-0.0292189531,
0.0395542644,
0.0326236077,
0.0392159969,
0.023440633,
0.0327564105,
0.0342772678,
-0.0245513692,
0.0115049826,
0.0200143736,
-0.0473342314,
0.0070141838,
0.0333981477,
-0.0023278249,
0.0237409901,
-0.0117529752,
0.0037596219,
0.0352276638,
0.0291737169,
-0.0424955413,
-0.0184800345,
0.0490522608,
-0.0912320316,
-0.0695500672,
0.0187189672,
0.0109677101,
0.0143799977,
0.0277503449,
-0.0020886464,
-0.0474695936,
0.056296546,
-0.0518558249,
0.07806281,
-0.055463627,
0.0172220878,
0.0147341816,
0.0388800725,
0.0076342695,
0.0456132703,
-0.0605241768,
0.0050252639,
0.0461517088,
-0.006057078,
-0.0312295053,
0.0039536301,
-0.0463618599,
-0.0036636123,
-0.0320370235,
-0.0158397593,
0.0185662508,
-0.0094016809,
0.0282525886,
-0.0106673427,
-0.0420817211,
-0.0064359652,
-0.041162096,
0.0068233274,
-0.0011681225,
0.0036084107,
0.0238837264,
-0.0118019432,
0.0102142897,
0.0268061161,
0.0078979256,
0.0298701786,
-0.0248085894,
0.0142139057,
-0.0439118408,
-0.0333211832,
-0.0430377237,
0.0080534574,
0.07659363,
-0.0228075385,
-0.0108367205,
-0.032910753,
-0.0386820883,
0.0126795163,
0.0505383313,
0.0035796016,
-0.0381210782,
0.0138379065,
-0.0531394482,
0.0775984302,
0.0096814726,
0.0123337694,
0.0507576987,
0.0095421644,
-0.0130843241,
-0.0130937984,
-0.0012106402,
-0.031203106,
0.0113157919,
-0.0204682164,
-0.0359059647,
-0.0156176342,
0.0942992866,
0.017166812,
-0.0089749936,
-0.0848148987,
-0.0254690964,
0.0010891465,
-0.0535454229,
0.011503974,
0.0037258568,
-0.0082311789,
0.0185016599,
-0.0331424661,
-0.0650790483,
0.0680530593,
-0.0479652956,
-0.0029155631,
0.0203047376,
0.006170636,
-0.0226745997,
0.0422249101,
0.0180898067,
-0.0003270004,
-0.0149031365,
-0.0493045636,
-0.0086359913,
0.0542740412,
-0.0060423189,
-0.0264841113,
0.0359739363,
-0.028276572,
-0.0033434632,
-0.0049343598,
-0.0111386962,
-0.0276843701,
-0.0114138806,
-0.036901664,
0.0243755095,
0.0715208873,
-0.0432519317,
-0.022993084,
0.0244909618,
-0.0500046611,
0.0741508752,
-0.0142128607,
0.0219344459,
-0.0094928201,
0.0435200222,
0.0738594383,
-0.0205601249,
0.0402679071,
-0.0768668205,
0.0504931398,
0.0612344816,
0.0681024566,
0.0393276326,
-0.0583483726,
-0.014660486,
0.0592453629,
0.0045370483,
-0.0140655078,
0.0378291346,
0.0172265451,
-0.0654727668,
-0.0409774184,
0.1088334024,
-0.0110440012,
-0.0622344799,
0.0002674273,
0.0043940726,
0.0761145875,
0.0063751061,
-0.0134034371,
-0.0432044305,
-0.0210729074,
0.0280814003,
0.0213504434,
0.0038122917,
-0.001214486,
-0.0166639369,
-0.092230089,
0.0280859582,
-0.011153114,
-0.0437171832,
-0.0137795592,
-0.0223033857,
-0.0019267586,
0.0037915413,
0.0201906078,
0.0464899316,
-0.0008199274,
-0.0070113656,
0.0414412916,
-0.0400731824,
-0.0292546097,
-0.0068855882,
-0.0488587618,
0.0723150447,
0.0391152538,
0.0161777399,
0.0268942937,
0.0058747004,
0.0307060666,
-0.0662260875,
-0.010077687,
-0.0136233307,
0.0022938566,
-0.0166720171,
-0.0135346688,
-0.0057482198,
0.0133473938,
0.0002711188,
-0.0059799002,
-0.0379038006,
0.0578433126,
-0.010897289,
-0.057213027,
-0.0315874778,
0.0152296685,
-0.0089999512,
0.0624773055,
0.0386219993,
-0.06292703,
-0.0321262963,
-0.0223785453,
0.0126806879,
-0.0861672834,
0.036171779,
-0.0111355102,
0.0339253433,
-0.0814315826,
-0.0457950793,
0.0092744604,
0.0518956855,
0.0466206223,
-0.0500130244,
0.0410536602,
-0.0184574872,
-0.0324425921,
-0.0298919827,
-0.0292072874,
0.001220021,
-0.0101857185,
-0.0649239868,
0.0246295407,
0.0216910336,
-0.0273295231,
-0.0241764914,
0.0517395511,
-0.1405626535,
-0.0807196498,
0.0219401959,
0.0333980843,
0.0158809852,
0.0290569086,
-0.0040148734,
-0.067157805,
0.0498436168,
0.0038971293,
0.0009830876,
0.0333140939,
0.020956222,
-0.022829432,
-0.0133242188,
0.0415499695,
-0.0369669385,
-0.0158864055,
-0.0052759908,
0.0394292884,
0.0176428296,
-0.0370902829,
0.009316721,
-0.0285998844,
0.0213097483,
-0.0639116913,
0.0008322063,
-0.0258255657,
0.0248154216,
0.0060246703,
0.0163695011,
-0.0602696091,
0.0468448028,
0.0225440934,
-0.0159974247,
-0.0176936612,
-0.0024807642,
0.0503556281,
0.0347969458,
-0.0484576561,
-0.000289743,
-0.0129434913,
0.0207515545,
0.0253370181,
-0.03114154,
-0.0046860916,
0.0078348378,
-0.0103991721,
-0.0198645908,
-0.0433820747,
-0.0030111212,
0.0231512152,
0.0129135894,
-0.0072667887,
0.0041585867,
-0.0457760803,
-0.0187692847,
-0.0635659397,
0.0371907204,
0.0460533574,
0.0149756894,
0.0666619912,
-0.0293042827,
0.0015784533,
-0.0362212025,
0.0276505034,
-0.0106326379,
-0.0531600043,
0.006363722,
0.0245183054,
-0.0174659807,
0.0207610615,
0.0711978376,
0.0634671822,
0.0492594652,
0.0160813574,
0.0128413588,
-0.0135582006,
-0.0231881198,
-0.0200436339,
0.0127651114,
-0.0386309214,
0.0139252506,
0.0085233916,
-0.0549403615,
0.0110537447,
0.0059916456,
-0.0095171807,
-0.0002656632,
0.0144869182,
0.0425728224,
-0.0218656529,
-0.0408087857,
-0.0315726064,
0.026157042,
0.032985907,
-0.0094194412,
-0.0261905529,
-6.896666499e-33,
-0.0410235636,
-0.0131032513,
0.0038548901,
-0.0625745803,
-0.0222374499,
0.0122224363,
-0.0398170501,
0.0020150722,
0.0165622085,
0.0199946798,
0.0109424861,
0.0277984906,
0.0263628364,
0.0377777666,
-0.005239048,
0.0211824123,
0.0918124095,
-0.0177668873,
0.0133034782,
0.0304564554,
0.0151898889,
0.0628752857,
0.034852691,
0.0032601207,
-0.0552447438,
0.0041908794,
-0.0292426385,
-0.0269248001,
0.0034543774,
0.0368285775,
-0.0170424506,
0.0199408308,
0.0072798636,
-0.0353471525,
-0.0426254347,
-0.0104814665,
-0.0848805755,
0.01147319,
0.0030755417,
-0.0001601992,
-0.0256149266,
-0.0078859525,
0.0065887738,
0.0159014259,
-0.0008326846,
-0.0161837544,
0.003997236,
0.0009642702,
-0.0188891273,
-0.0552387983,
-0.043781586,
0.0330844782,
0.0034381433,
0.0075387517,
0.0258313958,
0.0361113846,
-0.0054588816,
0.0130789373,
-0.0275965948,
0.0137793012,
0.016903026,
0.0856287032,
0.0553749874,
0.042267628,
0.0152882989,
0.0220783241,
0.0507694073,
-0.0077755353,
-0.0248640645,
-0.0000322422,
0.0820146725,
0.0199373458,
0.0180170983,
-0.0290637854,
0.0497785546,
-0.0080516441,
-0.0375327282,
-0.014368345,
0.0134842712,
0.0441884063,
0.0731535256,
0.012600177,
-0.0200071447,
-0.028760368,
-0.0460709818,
-0.0354749821,
-0.0378464162,
0.0078207934,
0.0413894542,
0.066473797,
-0.0420094393,
-0.0436222851,
0.0765186176,
-0.0190971624,
-0.0062316307,
0.0234960578,
-0.017010048,
0.0026734171,
-0.0196193811,
0.0591678023,
-0.0461560152,
-0.02946469,
0.012603322,
-0.0101193152,
-0.0055723097,
-0.013750013,
-0.0389250368,
0.0333926417,
-0.0690442771,
-0.0082882326,
-0.0499941781,
0.0447889566,
0.0199238788,
0.0193121377,
0.0557080284,
-0.0284205601,
-0.013675157,
0.0274735149,
-0.0103124436,
0.0381448939,
-0.0070775514,
0.0007223735,
0.0274806544,
0.0358189717,
-0.0441976525,
0.0026748762,
-0.0483566299,
-0.0070899404,
0.0431963094,
-0.062082734,
-0.0382640436,
0.0587171577,
2.505e-7,
0.0130625833,
0.0113354158,
0.0762752295,
0.0043549314,
0.0164859146,
-0.004649011,
0.0172480568,
0.0083435383,
0.0102466401,
0.0242024958,
0.0077471179,
0.0168964081,
0.0464745387,
0.0258502588,
-0.0625814497,
0.040855635,
-0.1133667976,
0.0509246103,
-0.0368427224,
-0.0657178238,
-0.0285184551,
0.0863336623,
-0.0254099406,
-0.0141823655,
0.0401838198,
-0.0111151477,
0.0247790571,
0.0298083965,
-0.0114015061,
0.0001888947,
0.028521983,
0.0034868037,
-0.0042645321,
-0.034746822,
-0.0088332687,
0.0041988809,
-0.0074733975,
0.0302881468,
0.0078099631,
-0.047932364,
0.0455084145,
0.0250528175,
-0.0177633129,
-0.0087917959,
0.0673066154,
-0.0271376614,
0.0140936347,
-0.0915311426,
-0.0301691052,
0.020952072,
-0.0219892282,
-0.0204425622,
-0.009043498,
0.0233305153,
0.030955106,
-0.0056856186,
-0.0227312502,
-0.0724224821,
-0.0374433696,
-0.0309714898,
-0.0848910064,
-0.0329980627,
-0.0712957457,
-0.0008769212,
0.0227524899,
-0.050096333,
-0.0063294074,
2.681409603e-34,
0.060571216,
-0.0343294106,
-0.0069560246,
0.0465146452,
0.0085702538,
-0.0312781148,
-0.0175328702,
0.0454874113,
-0.0075404118,
-0.0543454178,
-0.0693964139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05421v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05421v1 | Automating Customer Service using LangChain: Building custom open-source GPT Chatbot for organizations | 2023-10-09T05:35:10 | 2023-10-09T05:35:10 | Keivalya Pandya, Mehfuza Holia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | In the digital age, the dynamics of customer service are evolving, driven by
technological advancements and the integration of Large Language Models (LLMs).
This research paper introduces a groundbreaking approach to automating customer
service using LangChain, a custom LLM tailored for organizations. The paper
explores the obsolescence of traditional customer support techniques,
particularly Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs), and proposes a paradigm shift
towards responsive, context-aware, and personalized customer interactions. The
heart of this innovation lies in the fusion of open-source methodologies, web
scraping, fine-tuning, and the seamless integration of LangChain into customer
service platforms. This open-source state-of-the-art framework, presented as
"Sahaay," demonstrates the ability to scale across industries and
organizations, offering real-time support and query resolution. Key elements of
this research encompass data collection via web scraping, the role of
embeddings, the utilization of Google's Flan T5 XXL, Base and Small language
models for knowledge retrieval, and the integration of the chatbot into
customer service platforms. The results section provides insights into their
performance and use cases, here particularly within an educational institution.
This research heralds a new era in customer service, where technology is
harnessed to create efficient, personalized, and responsive interactions.
Sahaay, powered by LangChain, redefines the customer-company relationship,
elevating customer retention, value extraction, and brand image. As
organizations embrace LLMs, customer service becomes a dynamic and
customer-centric ecosystem. | [
0.1087217703,
0.000800628,
-0.0489031337,
0.0360211879,
-0.0216612723,
0.0124949859,
0.0025318377,
0.0167422146,
0.0921493024,
-0.0485669896,
-0.0300135333,
0.0100421095,
-0.0091121979,
0.0599510223,
-0.0143763358,
-0.0337610804,
-0.0086217169,
0.0049423482,
0.0181603786,
0.0160632096,
0.0428189635,
0.039301157,
-0.0240780413,
0.0459847637,
-0.0078448663,
-0.0187253039,
0.0152709838,
-0.0119232377,
-0.0074621867,
0.0012686518,
0.047820244,
0.0217408314,
0.0050820271,
0.0301041398,
0.0000021899,
-0.066151835,
-0.0035446766,
-0.0066541247,
-0.0769362077,
-0.0347480997,
0.0748579428,
0.0361163355,
-0.0217543691,
0.0560549311,
-0.0484646559,
0.0197806824,
0.0291836597,
0.0035800382,
0.0553538017,
0.0315770693,
-0.0197835695,
-0.0261608846,
-0.0405449122,
0.0332668722,
0.0123379668,
-0.0292864628,
-0.0086935535,
0.0261743888,
0.0508406833,
-0.0081626391,
0.0212076232,
0.0281391591,
-0.0114534199,
-0.0278421044,
0.0010886329,
0.0324866362,
-0.0695409328,
-0.0146619156,
-0.0225111023,
0.0526461489,
0.04491226,
0.0207978562,
-0.0153883053,
0.0221710969,
0.0468627512,
0.0211597625,
-0.0482576601,
-0.0015014021,
0.0017529599,
-0.0176639631,
-0.0611560717,
-0.0346707813,
-0.0323782489,
-0.0241444875,
0.0043445015,
0.0615533106,
-0.005630516,
-0.0127392551,
0.0013037928,
-0.0151931494,
0.0243247282,
-0.0194771774,
0.0199540313,
0.0689762533,
-0.0074524987,
-0.004074316,
0.0409019887,
-0.0002906747,
0.0458863452,
-0.0555485561,
-0.0421212241,
0.0502014682,
-0.0409551226,
0.0374843739,
0.0077556768,
0.0456856415,
0.0306233428,
-0.0224209987,
-0.0377186649,
0.0044044503,
-0.0502402708,
-0.0091810459,
-0.0320697054,
0.0618800968,
-0.0440262929,
-0.0078077512,
-0.0188971329,
0.0758602694,
0.0596286431,
0.0522293113,
-0.0096944813,
0.0180960894,
-0.0195804071,
0.0003643715,
-0.0383530036,
0.0022044557,
-0.0436185263,
-0.0219213143,
0.0112770051,
-0.0805595517,
0.0314887352,
0.0233460963,
0.0194464214,
0.0124601778,
-0.004266866,
0.0619258657,
0.0070050396,
-0.041870404,
-0.0616786443,
-0.0233647376,
0.0122200735,
-0.0266686659,
-0.0244656336,
-0.0557047464,
0.0248623714,
0.0412703156,
-0.0185265485,
0.0385247022,
0.0161153693,
0.0429411642,
-0.0132626379,
0.0252488777,
-0.0259181019,
0.0058331881,
0.0704648346,
0.0019575369,
0.050291501,
0.0331439003,
-0.0060467198,
0.0523482338,
0.0925881341,
-0.0012261254,
0.0110790422,
0.045176737,
-0.0654609501,
-0.0393949449,
0.0489362441,
0.0236853603,
0.0035645135,
-0.0031087357,
-0.0288162306,
0.0162110161,
-0.0076259729,
0.0506115444,
0.0451991707,
0.0702333748,
-0.0261788275,
0.0215172432,
0.0060769822,
0.0519200526,
0.0260613076,
-0.0222665519,
-0.0018800452,
0.0205526538,
-0.0160809997,
0.0017813371,
-0.0202544946,
0.0283858851,
-0.0275832955,
-0.0421206616,
-0.016969284,
-0.0368001424,
0.0047577526,
0.055774875,
0.0473126322,
-0.0299821254,
-0.0289012697,
0.0020971326,
-0.0006241286,
-0.044834245,
-0.0544225797,
-0.01954275,
0.0223096963,
0.1368201822,
0.0752194226,
-0.0275041759,
-0.0317404941,
-0.0154219065,
-0.044439774,
0.0457311049,
0.0588699728,
0.0112301754,
-0.0382872485,
-0.0266471114,
-0.0153520489,
0.0167905446,
-0.002209784,
-0.0038554955,
-0.0012802901,
0.0605457276,
0.0170308389,
-0.0079930201,
-0.0227020793,
-0.0105763962,
-0.0145766567,
-0.0326725766,
-0.0441660993,
0.0358481556,
-0.0174238365,
0.0684135631,
0.0224849675,
-0.0104717035,
0.0395461507,
-0.0159229375,
-0.005199159,
0.0191030316,
0.0132719669,
0.0350577049,
0.0422978364,
-0.019466918,
0.007084616,
0.0400950685,
-0.0189260114,
-0.0209388956,
-0.0081881881,
-0.0145851672,
0.0827270225,
-0.025819255,
-0.0203014892,
-0.0052670352,
0.0228111763,
-0.0358606987,
0.0166913457,
0.0199891012,
-0.0255051199,
-0.0124793788,
-0.0108631514,
-0.0032756149,
-0.0177977048,
-0.0113898618,
0.0388687365,
0.0093509918,
0.0303695798,
0.0226353668,
0.0336070135,
-0.0702951103,
0.0215108506,
-0.1019292325,
-0.0203033164,
-0.009297356,
-0.0219453294,
0.0163311809,
0.0528258719,
-0.0169296823,
-0.0350409932,
-0.0455779769,
0.0140986936,
0.034700837,
-0.0024608963,
0.0625196174,
0.0077311355,
-0.0570076182,
-0.0555470325,
0.021206826,
0.0338254049,
-0.0194404107,
0.0343062878,
-0.0402187407,
-0.0649651587,
0.0005233556,
-0.0673128888,
-0.0349406824,
-0.0067944569,
-0.0494445451,
0.0003029288,
-0.0378768742,
0.0042193499,
0.0281339362,
0.0258919075,
0.0280581303,
-0.0355605148,
-0.0229672324,
-0.0345716737,
-0.0160166174,
-0.0390211195,
-0.0598000474,
0.0105305901,
-0.0484563969,
0.0253233425,
-0.0405586921,
-0.0108908154,
0.0284493826,
-0.0448900051,
-0.0046519092,
-0.0030541015,
0.0197120812,
-0.0433011875,
0.041775085,
-0.0352840908,
0.0667439476,
0.0514106601,
-0.0402756073,
0.027649235,
0.0200333372,
0.0098756747,
-0.0429829136,
-0.0714242011,
-0.051520478,
0.0592307262,
-0.0634720623,
0.043431174,
-0.0053435895,
-0.0555141047,
0.0082992697,
0.009615208,
0.0240622759,
-0.0690572113,
-0.0040018996,
0.0019559006,
0.0046860599,
0.0136884479,
-0.0143574374,
-0.0379178412,
-0.0185677167,
-0.0518016219,
-0.0341433473,
0.0492689498,
-0.0129945232,
-0.0391116254,
0.0114912847,
0.0129835084,
0.0419397987,
0.0123147583,
-0.0097467536,
0.0167697966,
0.0013042922,
-0.0042178524,
0.0261265524,
0.025896417,
0.0632872954,
0.0372749604,
0.0287631396,
0.045625262,
-0.066134952,
0.0381787717,
-0.0316777006,
0.0511334464,
-0.0309033543,
-0.017774038,
-0.0065120249,
-0.0339831226,
-0.0171612557,
-0.000042031,
0.08926294,
0.045593366,
-0.0484468862,
-0.0125925289,
-0.0545764193,
-0.009358611,
0.0234117229,
0.0546908975,
-0.1043669879,
0.0155687844,
0.0118747121,
0.0554301031,
0.0257366076,
-0.0160321575,
-0.0232326463,
-0.0764555484,
0.0447717495,
-0.012332866,
-0.0183254723,
-0.0442655124,
-0.0122005902,
-0.0190202761,
0.0269945916,
0.0206295718,
0.0254020076,
-0.0524455979,
-0.0252623633,
-0.0028898621,
-0.0673670098,
-0.0343490839,
0.0233839601,
0.0147048701,
0.0013282488,
0.0846303105,
0.0319670588,
0.0169903263,
-0.0237455629,
0.017368637,
0.0262126941,
0.0107455347,
-0.0122624887,
0.0426082574,
-0.0091301706,
0.0086198822,
-0.0110994978,
0.0174461901,
-0.0744561329,
0.064185746,
0.024677515,
0.0028464256,
-0.0135231977,
0.0365383811,
-0.0093928333,
0.0094163949,
-0.0037694369,
0.0582395233,
-0.0075502489,
-0.0591933168,
-0.017036723,
-0.0570472255,
-0.0121421693,
0.0879138708,
-0.0378541909,
0.0241365712,
-0.032754425,
-0.0335845314,
-0.0771357194,
-0.0518017597,
0.0309202485,
-0.0055760848,
0.0220733676,
-0.009716101,
-0.0039673243,
0.0429872014,
0.0268190168,
-0.0290321745,
-0.0565019511,
0.0323061757,
-0.0901615098,
0.0072628506,
0.0096610384,
-0.0648465678,
0.0015373997,
-0.0287181586,
-0.0106918374,
-0.0231410023,
0.0282246862,
0.0086440975,
0.0254549887,
-0.0207515657,
0.0068809758,
-0.034017235,
-0.0301144086,
0.0543270707,
-0.0566409901,
0.0018228106,
-0.0023636539,
0.055541385,
-0.0097496416,
0.0346313231,
-0.099703148,
-0.0088008121,
-0.0635725558,
0.0025827589,
0.0058093537,
-0.0481640249,
0.0561468899,
0.0717956573,
-0.0372334495,
0.0292136222,
-0.0105629768,
-0.006060014,
0.0291908663,
0.0028879633,
-0.0251420159,
-0.048474174,
0.008779427,
-0.0540209487,
-0.0290274844,
0.0390514992,
-0.0180986784,
-0.0445411354,
0.0183103587,
-0.0227172505,
0.0109835565,
-0.0136418678,
0.0229534786,
0.0229407474,
-0.0119333901,
-0.0293680653,
0.0086971372,
0.0163546335,
0.0385320224,
-0.0205034763,
0.0481279455,
0.0082035502,
-0.007310051,
-0.0295678731,
0.0368366949,
-0.0436039194,
-0.1392252147,
0.0002552269,
0.0096622529,
0.0204568412,
-0.0103741577,
0.0082007376,
-0.0584557466,
-0.0013791755,
-0.0155138783,
-0.0076679513,
0.0270937867,
-0.0018788388,
-0.014461278,
0.0097429408,
-0.0282302424,
0.0016356175,
0.0437530354,
-0.0514219142,
-0.0162586179,
-0.0246184617,
-0.0373397321,
-0.0696024075,
-0.0015639474,
0.0425421931,
0.0259766467,
-0.0125069963,
-0.0547481999,
-0.0572044738,
-0.0595908463,
-0.042738989,
-0.0043685758,
-0.0305584203,
-0.0118580647,
0.0707495511,
0.0532979183,
0.0089163911,
-0.0035568224,
-0.0358458236,
0.0410871431,
-0.0673743486,
-0.001228096,
0.0168308895,
-6.526995566e-33,
-0.0055639409,
-0.0252161026,
0.0107277464,
0.0657794997,
-0.0007262958,
-0.0078047048,
-0.0013072753,
0.0367451943,
-0.0143675786,
-0.0040014051,
-0.0318973772,
0.0005191318,
0.0204111319,
-0.0127297258,
0.0126898037,
-0.0255974475,
0.0384528227,
-0.0267303027,
-0.0036651103,
0.053081505,
0.0445039757,
0.0381606407,
0.0346773975,
-0.0805711299,
0.069485873,
-0.072905831,
-0.0012339593,
0.0187464394,
0.0496923514,
0.0367415808,
-0.0163447969,
0.0687602311,
0.0046984032,
-0.0113821998,
0.0496207289,
0.0343684293,
-0.0684923753,
-0.0192568339,
0.038620688,
0.0283549521,
0.0165240746,
0.0175755657,
-0.0197640583,
-0.0459776297,
-0.0127005288,
0.0787765831,
0.0496333018,
-0.0121198641,
0.0089237941,
0.0196860153,
-0.0271580946,
-0.0232328884,
-0.0201594196,
-0.0036683786,
0.0151845226,
0.0743070841,
0.0048666694,
0.0429400615,
-0.0438928641,
0.0201111585,
-0.0424790867,
-0.0458397716,
0.0366208106,
-0.0113342702,
-0.0173775572,
0.0097055184,
-0.027802946,
0.0048990888,
0.0398350693,
-0.0195626896,
-0.0161291771,
0.0457699709,
-0.0085275173,
0.00426408,
-0.0417128354,
-0.0762617514,
0.0116994176,
0.0177687481,
0.0830419362,
0.0149198053,
0.003829052,
-0.0071498994,
-0.0342883505,
0.000348911,
0.0239550266,
0.0459303446,
-0.0419416316,
-0.0474610962,
0.0123571306,
0.0068470994,
-0.0215944704,
-0.0658682585,
-0.0157983042,
-0.0120801153,
-0.0262969416,
0.0044871313,
-0.0086235963,
-0.0163871422,
0.0012638571,
-0.0059541138,
-0.030939959,
0.0389542282,
-0.0681239665,
-0.0375858396,
-0.0180190131,
0.0042586857,
0.003273573,
-0.0061096204,
-0.0239880178,
0.0157113206,
0.0015119488,
0.0547370575,
-0.0208477583,
-0.0364805646,
0.0075374339,
0.0193713028,
-0.0041775778,
0.0779675841,
0.0371309035,
0.0089241154,
-0.0435404554,
-0.0044309851,
0.0228288844,
-0.0428453423,
-0.0520656407,
-0.0050486713,
-0.0236390494,
0.0554199778,
0.0338887572,
-0.0303786676,
-0.0298183672,
-0.0265757162,
2.968e-7,
0.0145069705,
0.0323687159,
-0.0224895999,
0.0170348734,
0.0268828049,
0.0336687788,
0.042047739,
-0.012120707,
0.0182908457,
0.0065080994,
0.0087284315,
-0.0016522771,
0.0330207385,
0.0231661387,
-0.1092383713,
-0.0093317935,
-0.011165279,
-0.0352244712,
-0.0535794906,
0.0395342037,
0.0447175577,
0.0123673687,
-0.0066306968,
-0.0206737816,
-0.0191445481,
0.0055540726,
-0.0078467363,
-0.0613268018,
0.0103851222,
0.0196995046,
0.0014047456,
0.0520437174,
0.0099989325,
-0.0068836017,
-0.0132044191,
0.0123383384,
0.020375656,
0.0086267069,
0.0272460189,
-0.0207674634,
0.0423697755,
-0.0110593094,
0.0281319264,
-0.0804228336,
0.0293132812,
-0.0230247546,
-0.0228230935,
-0.0188546237,
0.0008945056,
-0.0456300937,
-0.0048378091,
-0.0303079039,
-0.0513679348,
0.0401847437,
-0.0044352822,
-0.0256053805,
0.0085976953,
-0.0403185189,
0.0633499324,
0.0090857632,
-0.0316316672,
-0.0418526307,
-0.0159588363,
-0.0167170912,
-0.0290106516,
0.039302215,
0.0311313868,
2.491939658e-34,
0.0090530729,
0.0057334229,
0.007095525,
0.093223162,
0.0426472202,
0.0244373996,
0.016225718,
0.018956596,
0.0313031822,
-0.0444125533,
-0.0069908025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05418v1 | Humanoid Agents: Platform for Simulating Human-like Generative Agents | 2023-10-09T05:30:42 | 2023-10-09T05:30:42 | Zhilin Wang, Yu Ying Chiu, Yu Cheung Chiu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Just as computational simulations of atoms, molecules and cells have shaped
the way we study the sciences, true-to-life simulations of human-like agents
can be valuable tools for studying human behavior. We propose Humanoid Agents,
a system that guides Generative Agents to behave more like humans by
introducing three elements of System 1 processing: Basic needs (e.g. hunger,
health and energy), Emotion and Closeness in Relationships. Humanoid Agents are
able to use these dynamic elements to adapt their daily activities and
conversations with other agents, as supported with empirical experiments. Our
system is designed to be extensible to various settings, three of which we
demonstrate, as well as to other elements influencing human behavior (e.g.
empathy, moral values and cultural background). Our platform also includes a
Unity WebGL game interface for visualization and an interactive analytics
dashboard to show agent statuses over time. Our platform is available on
https://www.humanoidagents.com/ and code is on
https://github.com/HumanoidAgents/HumanoidAgents | [
0.0366270803,
0.0528424233,
-0.0338731483,
-0.0255042855,
-0.0030184705,
0.023972502,
0.0482094549,
0.0004512954,
0.0307352599,
0.0525790676,
0.0217394568,
-0.007228021,
-0.0338347815,
0.0348372385,
0.0376093872,
-0.1013992205,
0.0264725368,
0.0269219466,
0.0205962937,
-0.0057478575,
-0.0010568373,
0.0126728322,
-0.0115513708,
0.0168031231,
-0.0394482687,
-0.0094849644,
-0.0317225195,
0.0045076273,
0.0541286878,
-0.0239545647,
0.0127658192,
-0.0025077935,
0.0428722389,
0.0054722689,
0.000002386,
-0.0473175123,
0.0068632443,
0.021431854,
0.0149881244,
-0.0308465865,
0.1044240966,
-0.0171504747,
-0.023338953,
0.0002499251,
-0.0425805673,
0.0015599683,
0.0248147957,
0.0364664569,
0.0198235326,
-0.0077266926,
-0.0258210283,
0.0052033695,
-0.0316608585,
0.017871704,
0.0349282734,
0.0055015311,
-0.0053554601,
0.0118719181,
0.0891924128,
-0.0729075894,
-0.0130693233,
-0.0478172116,
0.0170708504,
0.0118553471,
0.0504444316,
0.0514358021,
0.0454319492,
-0.1050696895,
0.0074671158,
0.0369520709,
-0.0010884793,
0.0243850481,
0.0398531258,
0.0275844987,
0.0418735109,
-0.018614931,
0.0176175442,
0.0164335072,
-0.026056746,
0.0047122799,
-0.0381193869,
-0.0051232399,
-0.0141873565,
0.0106933219,
0.0122313248,
0.027031336,
0.0175358206,
0.0048674992,
-0.0190893132,
-0.0340346172,
0.0236638598,
-0.0298277438,
0.0187819116,
0.0384732038,
-0.0239138175,
-0.0248020552,
-0.064338319,
0.0261374135,
-0.0036584029,
-0.0214718748,
-0.0001504814,
0.0544474982,
-0.0095115481,
-0.0139963981,
0.009220914,
0.0554158613,
-0.0001801012,
-0.0052172127,
-0.0373638198,
0.0383084416,
-0.0163974613,
0.0298383795,
-0.0234060753,
0.0053737047,
-0.0260126274,
-0.0116065154,
0.0005116196,
0.0436423682,
-0.0555662513,
-0.0228972826,
-0.0683025941,
0.0521595441,
0.0110641597,
0.0474288501,
-0.0372518338,
-0.0210439041,
-0.0826750547,
0.0053644641,
0.0473367199,
-0.0447713099,
-0.0111828856,
-0.0306061022,
-0.0068653929,
0.035110563,
0.0381202735,
0.0583563037,
0.0100067528,
0.0131984372,
0.0494627282,
0.0090516983,
0.0644195378,
-0.0446167737,
-0.0121847922,
-0.0206306186,
0.0316970833,
-0.0454383418,
0.0131971752,
-0.036102213,
0.0272957906,
-0.0089983009,
0.0421886928,
0.0594360344,
0.0231482051,
0.011185322,
0.0314464644,
0.00990301,
-0.0142025193,
-0.0105593158,
0.0368819609,
0.0195049252,
-0.0175391547,
0.0101283072,
0.0336110368,
-0.0177305061,
-0.0334660336,
0.0127435094,
0.0552666038,
-0.0645106584,
0.0067164395,
0.0768002942,
0.030913204,
0.0203945283,
-0.0779261068,
0.0134425834,
0.0433706902,
0.0620090552,
-0.0327487402,
0.0862854719,
0.0274759158,
0.019065395,
0.0017048826,
-0.0364578478,
-0.0249978174,
0.0685964748,
0.0236756261,
-0.009310605,
-0.0627787784,
0.0348348655,
-0.0423733108,
-0.0021902283,
0.0449432209,
-0.030565219,
0.0674145445,
-0.0000381359,
0.0178425573,
0.0061805416,
-0.0028629422,
-0.0338406377,
0.0175951011,
-0.0899368748,
0.0124702109,
-0.0476723649,
0.0497413017,
0.0952903777,
-0.0026974869,
-0.0204036124,
-0.0288257487,
0.0210868791,
-0.0211741235,
0.0429500565,
0.0061153295,
-0.0158636905,
0.0248728227,
0.01818485,
0.0093603479,
0.0193475857,
0.0185177363,
0.0533812381,
-0.0268321447,
0.0076540061,
-0.0134057822,
0.050680764,
0.0140505601,
0.0339504033,
-0.056488432,
0.0561348423,
0.0029342188,
-0.0250198599,
0.0395659432,
0.0027832931,
0.0106724333,
-0.0318947844,
0.0199871343,
-0.0257378127,
-0.003612835,
0.0894065425,
0.023963606,
0.039517682,
0.0237368494,
-0.0296849832,
-0.0075973719,
0.0354147442,
0.0181385688,
0.0024731583,
0.0257509686,
-0.0218433179,
0.008828056,
-0.0489171557,
-0.000597061,
-0.0057149557,
0.0384837165,
0.0294870026,
-0.0000087165,
0.0012519117,
-0.0413570851,
-0.0361720547,
0.0491694883,
-0.0248994827,
-0.0603034943,
0.0262992922,
-0.0106428321,
-0.0062845573,
0.0208203308,
-0.0013861258,
0.0181377269,
-0.0478628911,
0.0217117369,
-0.095419459,
-0.0355365537,
0.0332954675,
-0.0443048142,
-0.0167083591,
0.0037833869,
-0.0293837339,
-0.0153858643,
-0.0169414897,
0.0681781992,
-0.0018676964,
-0.0198060498,
0.0375406705,
0.0031476605,
-0.0012013605,
-0.0561561957,
0.0368451588,
-0.0079250718,
-0.0370619968,
-0.0018312095,
0.0118951956,
-0.0011627907,
-0.0039588721,
-0.0468752384,
0.0509579293,
-0.0047391173,
-0.0692416057,
0.0491057672,
-0.0092092138,
0.0609093644,
0.0821585208,
0.0226444975,
0.0410697237,
0.0586294606,
0.0264782812,
-0.0451094508,
0.0386891589,
-0.0056960969,
0.0507285558,
-0.0202820208,
-0.0418778025,
-0.0215496495,
0.0332866013,
-0.0309955981,
0.0235571396,
-0.0434172601,
0.0258148145,
0.0065973601,
-0.0929388404,
0.0355706327,
0.0509604216,
-0.0505880825,
-0.0068904785,
-0.0128501691,
-0.0049923523,
0.0638085529,
0.0151570737,
0.0016324321,
0.0690844208,
0.0320913494,
0.0302805454,
0.0508731827,
0.0111840796,
-0.0105028832,
-0.0286706723,
0.045181945,
0.0106899496,
0.0131869642,
-0.0030313379,
-0.0350899622,
-0.0331352688,
-0.0661960021,
-0.0405883379,
-0.002228939,
-0.0250813533,
-0.0221514497,
0.0324018374,
-0.0250752494,
0.0215632189,
-0.0234278738,
-0.0435987525,
-0.050553482,
-0.0116002383,
0.0157304909,
0.0439033471,
-0.0317517035,
0.0193512142,
-0.0159251206,
-0.0854544565,
0.0819308832,
0.0556689613,
0.013221601,
-0.0316476747,
0.0302343089,
0.049743928,
0.0466709174,
-0.0275393464,
-0.0265778787,
0.0133125754,
-0.0044898423,
0.008977443,
0.0437049121,
-0.0067661433,
0.0079516871,
0.0073306276,
-0.0185857732,
0.0830507949,
-0.0150213046,
-0.0286034867,
0.0415528268,
-0.0299299657,
0.0136323562,
0.0111191692,
0.0363366678,
-0.0391512178,
0.0170060229,
0.0007907608,
0.0346842371,
-0.0501343794,
-0.0531999134,
0.0433678105,
-0.0232057758,
0.0310979579,
-0.0064422418,
-0.0279375594,
-0.0404672064,
-0.0413540378,
0.0323876664,
-0.0175816808,
-0.0213126,
0.0111651281,
0.0487684757,
-0.0156043414,
-0.0287490617,
-0.0215771925,
0.0053591444,
0.0297519583,
-0.0506935455,
0.0639487728,
0.0607300773,
0.1019183472,
-0.0051207705,
-0.0354634672,
-0.03316148,
0.0671610907,
0.0284503903,
-0.0276381951,
-0.0257776026,
-0.0213651694,
0.0116528897,
-0.0601889938,
0.0554731004,
-0.0206479095,
-0.0109953545,
0.0142509881,
0.0299934819,
-0.0202583168,
-0.0465531833,
-0.0562200621,
-0.0201980583,
0.049679745,
0.0268881787,
-0.0208230875,
-0.0730227083,
-0.0290136561,
-0.0070486399,
-0.0148192067,
-0.0078581721,
-0.0264566503,
-0.0268818233,
-0.0293300506,
-0.0710356534,
-0.0711329877,
-0.0486684293,
0.0014042979,
0.0211902913,
-0.0298342332,
-0.0974697098,
-0.0095813368,
0.0496956408,
0.0061954604,
-0.0078714415,
0.0089827068,
0.0026768812,
0.0297366269,
-0.0434326455,
0.0005444381,
-0.0410825051,
0.0210030824,
0.0118341856,
-0.0005157969,
0.0050221505,
0.0313608758,
0.0788105875,
0.0172372106,
0.0099329995,
-0.0267116241,
0.0130156642,
-0.0223522913,
0.0166361984,
-0.0464314073,
0.0357522033,
-0.0067726923,
0.008743247,
-0.0049436111,
0.012064524,
-0.0192844495,
0.0482615344,
-0.0718381479,
-0.0181165673,
0.0022037993,
-0.0735901296,
0.0235096384,
0.0075356863,
0.006110311,
-0.0148760574,
-0.013895194,
-0.016814841,
-0.031723097,
-0.0425632447,
0.0214505624,
-0.0321980231,
-0.0383107476,
0.0258627795,
0.0473437458,
0.0280604661,
-0.0185674485,
-0.0070893448,
0.0112959882,
-0.0015705188,
0.0196416937,
0.0037564558,
0.0346648134,
-0.0348536856,
0.014287631,
0.00120925,
0.0322919115,
-0.0876462907,
0.0172976069,
-0.0054020821,
0.0236439407,
-0.027916776,
-0.0012986255,
0.0089805676,
0.0320432186,
-0.0470082946,
-0.0341648795,
0.0231261794,
-0.0076926462,
-0.0063597527,
0.0328977965,
0.0500305183,
-0.0479558744,
-0.0016475465,
-0.0380445533,
-0.0019255393,
-0.0176413003,
-0.0386273526,
-0.0301303715,
0.0211764239,
0.0035393648,
-0.0291458759,
-0.0095564164,
-0.024751965,
0.0442845188,
-0.009878167,
-0.0243225675,
-0.0309647098,
0.0035312125,
-0.0430838987,
-0.0312813632,
-0.0288241096,
-0.0189067982,
-0.0568326078,
-0.0045957449,
-0.0087718042,
0.062862061,
-0.0336315855,
-0.0318881907,
0.0260861702,
-0.0307694878,
-0.0474655516,
-0.0405883864,
-0.0370133929,
0.0422951616,
-0.0416060463,
-0.0076002078,
-0.0097170109,
-6.107284206e-33,
-0.0288915094,
0.0212494861,
-0.0012878441,
-0.0041337614,
-0.0453756861,
-0.0658758655,
-0.0631418601,
-0.0353761911,
-0.024129726,
0.0028513519,
0.0109531768,
0.0028268634,
0.003088254,
-0.0500041768,
0.0135265598,
0.0001177052,
0.0356481411,
-0.0050249146,
-0.0038966038,
0.0112353293,
-0.0035323859,
0.0140128313,
-0.0320540965,
-0.0449689105,
-0.0286760442,
-0.0258623064,
-0.0305341445,
-0.0198974591,
-0.029845167,
0.004014066,
-0.0173722059,
-0.0139471106,
-0.0068636546,
0.0585088246,
0.0072501828,
0.0429162309,
-0.0926231444,
0.003595066,
-0.0548861027,
-0.0354536586,
-0.08423049,
-0.0662308112,
-0.0331783928,
0.0071983431,
-0.0505921021,
-0.0146698905,
0.0337820575,
-0.0459776893,
0.0307107177,
0.0004853448,
-0.0587416887,
-0.0152177997,
-0.0139159262,
-0.0362407155,
-0.0161155388,
0.0545521937,
-0.038699124,
-0.022833569,
0.0057171411,
0.0293300394,
-0.0349377282,
-0.0784917176,
-0.0156174218,
0.0225248281,
0.1043989733,
0.043351423,
0.0085340878,
-0.0026322803,
-0.0457712561,
-0.0113813533,
0.0655203164,
0.0571628325,
0.0421805307,
0.0571961552,
-0.011054147,
-0.0734667704,
0.0079795327,
0.0557307489,
0.049759645,
0.0375313386,
0.0082328059,
0.0493515246,
-0.0034024294,
0.0234598797,
0.0468525738,
-0.0373238586,
0.0120310131,
-0.0692935139,
-0.021986559,
-0.0011942252,
-0.0108655449,
-0.0737595409,
-0.005920385,
-0.0160841793,
0.0658044294,
-0.0184073951,
0.0372045189,
-0.0095158713,
0.0143271089,
-0.0303445645,
-0.03303352,
-0.0489958599,
0.0108822566,
0.0187104139,
0.0367337316,
0.043323908,
-0.0125870351,
0.0364726186,
0.0415395163,
-0.0282815583,
-0.027391525,
0.0290650018,
0.0649001747,
0.0148024326,
-0.0210745577,
-0.0356022865,
-0.0083351787,
-0.0071565718,
-0.002177573,
0.0293698423,
-0.0633791313,
0.0943377241,
-0.0198821425,
-0.0097312741,
-0.0212888476,
-0.0286284685,
-0.0813300461,
0.0726888478,
0.022389695,
-0.0488344543,
-0.0069508781,
-0.0268325191,
3.046e-7,
-0.0798148513,
0.0176750459,
0.0428183675,
-0.0370839722,
0.0447529219,
0.0364924669,
0.0126044247,
0.0829639658,
-0.0188236143,
-0.0588701889,
0.0552929714,
0.04331569,
0.0256020855,
-0.0075246254,
-0.0420486555,
0.0157263558,
0.0329548083,
-0.0184468236,
0.028585365,
-0.0189422239,
-0.0029869871,
0.03634331,
0.0787753239,
-0.0062309988,
0.060201019,
0.0376180597,
-0.0073675662,
-0.0408994704,
0.0196328871,
-0.054731369,
-0.0614753589,
0.0008350968,
0.0106626358,
-0.0193254799,
-0.0020811681,
-0.0013356239,
-0.0008131486,
0.0666970909,
-0.0643478557,
-0.0002012313,
0.0197771657,
0.0334595516,
-0.0206269082,
-0.0289359819,
0.0153618492,
-0.0289711189,
0.0028442668,
-0.0059969872,
-0.0116954986,
0.0214068592,
-0.0449034683,
-0.0040829768,
-0.0251755994,
-0.0020704733,
-0.0228190646,
-0.0118224137,
0.0107478211,
-0.0097533492,
0.033648137,
-0.00783493,
-0.0525410026,
-0.0569474436,
-0.0385756455,
0.0174033362,
-0.0098870443,
-0.0186576378,
-0.0116076665,
2.040701126e-34,
-0.0169120301,
0.0592887625,
-0.0324712507,
-0.0103195049,
0.0588110499,
0.0201750249,
-0.002573055,
0.0168223474,
0.0672128126,
-0.008571608,
-0.0537591204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05404v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05404v2 | Exploring the Maze of Multilingual Modeling | 2023-10-09T04:48:14 | 2024-02-12T21:34:52 | Sina Bagheri Nezhad, Ameeta Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Multilingual language models have gained significant attention in recent
years, enabling the development of applications that meet diverse linguistic
contexts. In this paper, we present a comprehensive evaluation of three popular
multilingual language models: mBERT, XLM-R, and GPT-3. We assess their
performance across a diverse set of languages, with a focus on understanding
the impact of resource availability (general and model-specific), language
family, script type, and word order on model performance, under two distinct
tasks - text classification and text generation. Our findings reveal that while
the amount of language-specific pretraining data plays a crucial role in model
performance, we also identify other factors such as general resource
availability, language family, and script type, as important features. We hope
that our study contributes to a deeper understanding of multilingual language
models to enhance their performance across languages and linguistic contexts. | [
0.0123870401,
0.0592457689,
0.0050609275,
0.0341668166,
-0.0367024504,
0.0182959996,
0.0498382859,
-0.0001732465,
-0.0117707262,
-0.0569846816,
-0.0435854532,
-0.0969315395,
0.0042300974,
0.0088016344,
0.0346610174,
-0.026352087,
0.0167143811,
-0.0378488824,
-0.0267269108,
0.0006960787,
0.0120399902,
0.0625121221,
0.0314459428,
0.0336906761,
-0.0235911142,
-0.0042557446,
0.0139740333,
0.0373814702,
0.0383272283,
-0.0354098864,
0.0249521229,
0.0499788523,
0.0136404037,
0.0503450409,
0.0000018194,
-0.0467851162,
-0.0275543705,
0.0039553535,
0.0447989851,
0.0069286814,
0.0549859218,
-0.0659713373,
-0.0083619189,
0.0520563498,
-0.0066346615,
0.0016982616,
0.0570478477,
0.0194250308,
0.0151751526,
0.0643328875,
-0.0300947241,
-0.0085776038,
-0.0056049516,
-0.0414341018,
-0.003731926,
-0.0053456943,
0.0054607922,
0.0175178032,
-0.0107900668,
0.0108256461,
0.0026790285,
0.0173588619,
0.0223376043,
0.0202128328,
-0.0531275682,
0.04184765,
-0.0142779378,
-0.034897197,
0.0159444064,
0.0395537838,
-0.0431391485,
-0.0356621146,
0.0084228907,
-0.0070736692,
-0.0316051431,
-0.0127523737,
-0.0127100758,
0.0706778467,
-0.0161258709,
0.0256562456,
0.0453445055,
0.0228194334,
0.0439440645,
0.0053580361,
-0.0057188561,
0.0280269794,
0.038972117,
-0.0286989994,
-0.0034986353,
0.0325342827,
-0.0144827459,
-0.0469591208,
-0.0006006844,
0.0076597952,
0.0020454992,
0.0158227123,
-0.0730810538,
-0.0413210355,
0.047057163,
-0.0729728416,
0.0525831617,
0.029220175,
-0.0222949535,
0.0050890311,
-0.0204699691,
0.0427118167,
-0.0076227663,
-0.0211981703,
-0.0249280706,
-0.0211910047,
-0.0157555956,
-0.0155391246,
-0.0380142219,
-0.0028513425,
-0.0348024145,
-0.0075737853,
-0.0454935282,
0.0538000427,
0.0355150141,
-0.0291230176,
0.0158380792,
-0.0371669792,
-0.0497725084,
0.0027797916,
0.0194083322,
0.0111046182,
-0.0248826612,
-0.0160586741,
-0.0035787609,
-0.0638597533,
0.0093916198,
0.0630356669,
-0.0263276864,
-0.040459808,
0.0110964635,
0.0695495382,
-0.0383989401,
-0.0281891041,
-0.0451040752,
-0.0110430308,
-0.0227713212,
-0.0831049308,
0.003323901,
-0.0849992931,
0.0481207781,
0.0475736484,
0.0093752341,
-0.0126568889,
0.0119319074,
0.0189530142,
-0.0075139157,
0.0199552737,
-0.0046654423,
-0.0008274348,
0.0369303972,
-0.0224975254,
0.0375943296,
0.0921301171,
0.0223228671,
0.0088549703,
0.0555723943,
-0.0199976861,
-0.0032870744,
0.0651489571,
-0.0139886066,
0.0234568864,
-0.0159263294,
-0.0107481517,
0.0081036128,
0.0131676653,
0.0182674881,
0.0278032254,
-0.0136941634,
0.0149095291,
0.0399502032,
0.0142627209,
-0.002328912,
0.0273858402,
0.0879356265,
-0.002696225,
-0.0331116952,
0.0207130797,
0.0154260332,
0.0212557279,
0.0042305957,
0.0371438302,
0.0105162412,
0.0947675928,
-0.0443229564,
-0.0357869528,
-0.036297515,
-0.0471466891,
0.0106870681,
-0.0139264883,
0.051330395,
-0.0036867803,
-0.0287062991,
0.0424079299,
0.0395082906,
-0.0603448786,
0.0310981683,
-0.0378277712,
-0.0108145438,
0.0376133397,
0.0192414857,
-0.0051436783,
-0.0346630439,
0.0030553495,
0.0031285756,
0.0721392184,
0.0662586316,
0.0084645534,
0.0245735608,
-0.0673515722,
0.0005210059,
-0.0108179329,
0.008991722,
0.0842250288,
0.0071425247,
0.0428981967,
0.0319475122,
-0.0341491997,
-0.0547329709,
0.0197292939,
-0.0790870115,
0.0087420875,
0.0161517188,
-0.0098757632,
0.0099862274,
-0.0075818636,
-0.0384117439,
0.0001600366,
0.0045913109,
-0.0361463316,
0.006708222,
0.0387106426,
-0.0407767668,
-0.0427445956,
0.016202338,
0.0168713555,
0.0198096558,
0.0138948709,
-0.0163354762,
-0.0525143184,
0.0085836658,
-0.0227880199,
0.0329105854,
-0.0604154356,
0.011994075,
-0.0035407345,
0.0082983952,
-0.0130704287,
0.0534277782,
-0.002768008,
0.0279690586,
0.002345063,
-0.0147295622,
0.0629856735,
-0.018666409,
-0.0253045447,
0.0563042201,
0.0018650085,
0.0345828421,
0.0557607487,
0.046636913,
0.009235356,
-0.0406745411,
-0.0948481187,
0.0068370788,
-0.0505851321,
-0.0006608371,
0.0249112528,
0.0128655899,
-0.010486275,
-0.0226001889,
-0.0703065246,
-0.0215747096,
0.0591825359,
0.0338742211,
0.0225968529,
-0.021421602,
0.0268522296,
-0.0165731329,
0.0002895818,
0.0280193482,
0.0551058799,
-0.0046715797,
-0.0345127732,
-0.034872748,
0.0191211347,
-0.0694028959,
-0.0161041096,
-0.0176921133,
-0.0264524948,
0.0025881687,
0.0083103152,
0.078774035,
-0.0055422029,
-0.0021931434,
0.0289873183,
0.0425549969,
0.014931323,
-0.0216489807,
0.0035563493,
-0.0044367486,
-0.0030174933,
-0.0290166419,
-0.079182826,
0.0116713606,
0.0784518421,
0.0143220257,
-0.0310360696,
-0.0591280945,
-0.0132656135,
-0.044120647,
-0.0192014985,
-0.0128809903,
0.0246299934,
0.0163602233,
0.0430353954,
-0.0000059915,
-0.0615947768,
0.0492180809,
-0.0673618093,
-0.0218920931,
-0.055461619,
-0.0387946777,
-0.0550097041,
0.0147454729,
0.0237863567,
0.0590466373,
-0.0296891928,
0.0037269522,
-0.038231235,
0.0053588636,
0.009209862,
0.000371356,
0.0362688825,
-0.0302831642,
-0.0031941072,
-0.025986312,
-0.0314091071,
-0.0276591145,
-0.0323549584,
0.0175997782,
0.0149980662,
0.0257367305,
-0.0125510134,
-0.0357027315,
0.0457303226,
0.0306195095,
0.0484128669,
-0.0345934667,
0.0030288231,
-0.0038525874,
0.0466945283,
0.0526527725,
-0.0243398007,
-0.0088234665,
-0.0702825859,
0.0032991851,
0.0063784239,
-0.0178200137,
-0.0131828925,
-0.0119058397,
-0.0032667886,
0.021057304,
-0.009299376,
-0.0438469052,
-0.0090230852,
0.0642193034,
-0.0225061979,
-0.0311316308,
0.0817289799,
0.0246432927,
-0.045304846,
-0.0174681712,
-0.0174418613,
0.0878483206,
0.0206386298,
0.0253777727,
-0.0528475232,
0.007041987,
-0.009351315,
0.0249619428,
0.0049489751,
0.0173686929,
-0.0260771066,
-0.0915172547,
0.0024684793,
0.0093835341,
-0.0847895145,
-0.0228393804,
-0.0257726796,
-0.0592089891,
-0.0064227018,
0.0094907386,
-0.0263290405,
-0.0107496427,
0.0066724294,
0.0416349359,
-0.0335627832,
-0.0690791681,
-0.0032832806,
-0.0015138497,
-0.0045132707,
0.0495077521,
0.0245771948,
-0.039528016,
-0.0038419457,
0.0239218473,
-0.0135128302,
-0.0097561153,
-0.0147942808,
0.0266049169,
0.0082789408,
-0.0163935609,
0.0038840489,
-0.0094859069,
-0.0040907329,
0.0012446514,
-0.0003684978,
0.0434322916,
-0.0118725374,
-0.0248925425,
-0.0086331852,
-0.0002714403,
0.0015249157,
0.0525922999,
0.0034925374,
-0.0663796887,
-0.0434664972,
-0.034374617,
0.008053435,
-0.0735891089,
0.0132674063,
0.0068951733,
-0.0356111601,
-0.0321105644,
-0.0639595911,
-0.0806603879,
-0.0139133213,
0.0299424585,
0.0094087068,
0.0021554399,
-0.0251449775,
-0.0190768503,
-0.0191192608,
0.0109386873,
0.0074616307,
-0.0149523942,
-0.0643401146,
-0.0382026546,
0.0402169786,
-0.0650122613,
0.0062616984,
-0.0138386469,
-0.0639008284,
-0.0789116472,
-0.0462490804,
0.0483759753,
0.0157962348,
0.0446570031,
0.0237459354,
-0.0221014805,
0.0135430051,
0.0072255065,
0.0113233021,
0.0021628912,
0.0399406999,
0.0153388642,
-0.0389497913,
0.0332835987,
-0.0441924408,
0.0581250526,
-0.0081040384,
0.0351159349,
-0.0326631516,
-0.0262482855,
0.0034825248,
0.0121621368,
-0.0121396333,
-0.0677135289,
-0.0144951278,
-0.0579159521,
-0.0062643057,
-0.0434625,
-0.0064503909,
-0.0500370339,
-0.0067490675,
0.0424527116,
0.0015556001,
-0.0184966438,
0.0026692613,
-0.0043875244,
0.0066047441,
0.0031919596,
0.0118585676,
0.0039214017,
0.0222183969,
0.0312310066,
0.0137162553,
-0.0383754112,
0.011759676,
-0.0238893311,
0.0109267421,
-0.0452606641,
0.0738318264,
-0.0129799983,
-0.0021309224,
0.0339193977,
0.0376478694,
-0.0073941657,
-0.0046876953,
-0.0351296887,
0.0181012452,
0.0861566439,
-0.0276258737,
0.1080945134,
-0.0291936696,
-0.0052856933,
-0.0357322991,
0.0821419284,
0.0433234759,
-0.0428610854,
0.0182970501,
-0.0186854526,
-0.0587089807,
-0.006616605,
0.1162814498,
0.0586252734,
-0.015944751,
0.0215021372,
-0.012559345,
-0.0117466059,
-0.005348485,
0.0468181185,
-0.0100791911,
-0.0201305747,
0.0060460689,
-0.0445668027,
-0.0594498143,
0.0185343716,
0.0006000573,
0.0077125155,
0.0021652584,
0.0263058636,
0.1108535826,
0.0067991158,
0.0402387008,
-0.0758243576,
-0.0206224788,
-0.0240967646,
0.0002289884,
0.0064663766,
-6.020929819e-33,
-0.0180804189,
-0.0240687504,
0.0237370338,
-0.019391777,
0.0169959106,
0.0119068949,
-0.0334946774,
0.0026036082,
0.0079546524,
-0.0100019602,
0.0119564896,
-0.0284106024,
0.0096076792,
0.0595190898,
-0.0047751768,
0.0277018473,
0.0320063643,
0.0091323331,
-0.0226675496,
0.0303170383,
0.0554751344,
0.0294987541,
0.0774084479,
-0.0237318389,
0.010374099,
-0.0531287454,
0.0216400363,
-0.0273181424,
0.0078158677,
0.0559306517,
-0.0454152785,
0.0495760888,
0.0423852131,
-0.0129534397,
-0.0232200529,
-0.0138964113,
-0.0176293254,
-0.0257929545,
0.0040760208,
0.0186912809,
-0.012255678,
-0.0170427673,
-0.021918118,
-0.0392882936,
-0.0043286867,
-0.0097214608,
0.0475516804,
-0.0121664749,
-0.0384001248,
-0.0395561121,
-0.0899308771,
0.051424928,
0.024466984,
0.0015149163,
0.0366778262,
0.1062697247,
-0.0031226652,
0.0204147529,
-0.0356403701,
0.0046659759,
-0.0214973614,
0.0142959636,
0.0460031927,
0.0276904311,
-0.0224616174,
0.0316562541,
-0.0058577368,
0.0346271098,
0.0136802653,
0.0326644927,
0.0203621872,
0.0066610547,
0.0395468995,
0.0741239861,
0.0118991593,
-0.02679158,
-0.1046304405,
0.0278609302,
-0.0063720788,
-0.029853981,
0.0615795814,
-0.0419048518,
0.0078992536,
-0.0234663747,
-0.0270748641,
-0.0295020081,
-0.0255480316,
-0.0360321179,
0.0457873419,
0.0223510787,
0.0002966236,
-0.0131213358,
0.061097607,
-0.0003726014,
-0.0524507202,
0.0330853127,
-0.0490521491,
0.0182819497,
-0.0126457252,
0.0660530031,
-0.0474577136,
-0.0534421317,
-0.0120440526,
-0.0115379812,
0.0075231418,
0.010087789,
0.0505115576,
0.010227669,
-0.063470982,
0.0249202549,
-0.0279076453,
0.0591446571,
0.0053042835,
0.0574569143,
0.0071671819,
-0.0264441166,
0.0019594503,
0.0536230989,
0.0466954298,
-0.0270803832,
-0.0308017693,
-0.0330305099,
-0.005901915,
0.0540640168,
-0.0216673892,
0.036971163,
-0.0475337543,
0.0110237896,
0.0365140997,
-0.0291939117,
-0.0089538768,
-0.0086337188,
2.386e-7,
0.0539615043,
0.0188278183,
0.0004920019,
0.0052949036,
0.0121346666,
0.0156721845,
-0.0588943511,
0.0380841866,
-0.0099320039,
0.0576837696,
-0.015714528,
0.0002856887,
0.0869730711,
0.0510871671,
-0.0407041907,
0.0051140226,
-0.0884532779,
0.0218338575,
-0.0613887981,
0.0097888838,
0.0088482443,
0.0769945011,
-0.0425607227,
-0.0041397214,
-0.0295363739,
-0.0542134419,
0.1189325377,
-0.0425559618,
-0.0330260284,
0.0204872228,
0.0225407332,
0.0227305368,
-0.0157576092,
-0.0156027181,
-0.0371613987,
-0.0154547105,
0.0386769995,
0.0665810704,
0.011533374,
-0.0389536284,
0.0893956423,
0.0159456786,
-0.0397005379,
-0.0871998742,
0.0595580004,
0.008129443,
-0.0103486823,
-0.0094081145,
0.0149780344,
0.0147901326,
0.0667390376,
-0.0591736771,
-0.050906051,
0.0253921673,
0.0332433954,
-0.0196303297,
-0.0141385021,
-0.0204929113,
-0.0240570772,
0.028576931,
-0.0215883218,
-0.0243902989,
-0.0399253406,
-0.0068020257,
0.0272540227,
-0.0192051623,
0.0249021724,
2.364970426e-34,
0.0591227859,
-0.0252382681,
-0.0006581405,
-0.007488559,
0.0123457313,
-0.0243724324,
0.0027853062,
0.0276636761,
-0.0429883935,
-0.0346490555,
-0.0116711697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05388v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05388v2 | GROVE: A Retrieval-augmented Complex Story Generation Framework with A Forest of Evidence | 2023-10-09T03:55:55 | 2023-10-24T01:37:46 | Zhihua Wen, Zhiliang Tian, Wei Wu, Yuxin Yang, Yanqi Shi, Zhen Huang, Dongsheng Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conditional story generation is significant in human-machine interaction,
particularly in producing stories with complex plots. While Large language
models (LLMs) perform well on multiple NLP tasks, including story generation,
it is challenging to generate stories with both complex and creative plots.
Existing methods often rely on detailed prompts to guide LLMs to meet target
conditions, which inadvertently restrict the creative potential of the
generated stories. We argue that leveraging information from exemplary
human-written stories facilitates generating more diverse plotlines. Delving
deeper into story details helps build complex and credible plots. In this
paper, we propose a retrieval-au\textbf{G}mented sto\textbf{R}y generation
framework with a f\textbf{O}rest of e\textbf{V}id\textbf{E}nce (GROVE) to
enhance stories' complexity. We build a retrieval repository for target
conditions to produce few-shot examples to prompt LLMs. Additionally, we design
an ``asking-why'' prompting scheme that extracts a forest of evidence,
providing compensation for the ambiguities that may occur in the generated
story. This iterative process uncovers underlying story backgrounds. Finally,
we select the most fitting chains of evidence from the evidence forest and
integrate them into the generated story, thereby enhancing the narrative's
complexity and credibility. Experimental results and numerous examples verify
the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.042061545,
0.0390115865,
-0.0202558823,
0.0269261114,
-0.0568327755,
-0.0247937012,
-0.035347119,
0.0101088863,
-0.022195071,
-0.0269390978,
0.0306698401,
-0.0109303463,
0.0145135466,
0.1044838279,
-0.0249336474,
-0.0848253593,
-0.0114804562,
-0.0075758686,
0.0515790842,
0.025912812,
-0.0002584447,
0.0528584495,
-0.0038238899,
0.0525868572,
-0.0588290542,
-0.0059758914,
-0.0262142979,
0.0129729044,
0.0332076401,
-0.0385128222,
-0.0477426499,
0.0036136894,
0.0439942703,
0.0132736638,
0.0000019918,
-0.0513156056,
-0.0153519874,
-0.0075080469,
0.0037617146,
-0.0426863991,
0.0306558758,
0.0346683636,
0.002553076,
-0.021079855,
-0.03637309,
0.0099641811,
0.0309970919,
0.0530423932,
0.0449569114,
0.0705281869,
-0.0243116375,
-0.0371193886,
-0.0234802663,
0.0180041138,
0.0341883227,
0.0182560105,
-0.0319030881,
-0.015080343,
0.0848006383,
0.0099241259,
0.0090986444,
0.0030752413,
0.0355930701,
-0.0267337784,
-0.0000384668,
0.0789662451,
0.0100082867,
-0.0152789606,
-0.0106875096,
0.0607648529,
0.005275737,
-0.0259916689,
-0.0030283562,
-0.0237240531,
0.017926693,
0.0403825641,
-0.0833714083,
0.0672881454,
-0.0350732654,
0.0113933329,
0.0144772884,
0.0108461007,
0.0141914031,
-0.011542269,
0.0302062836,
-0.0006552791,
0.032493338,
0.0111049386,
-0.06221864,
-0.0040645897,
-0.0261541232,
-0.0880707651,
0.014122556,
0.0695757046,
-0.0139855295,
0.0097351894,
-0.0523490645,
0.0397808775,
-0.0072365352,
-0.0238815062,
0.0472479537,
0.0060323016,
-0.0136982584,
0.0244517867,
0.0043871561,
0.0165450964,
-0.0019717435,
-0.0650795624,
-0.0225195866,
0.022532545,
-0.0490828827,
0.0019125867,
-0.0516063944,
0.0139753316,
-0.0630238205,
-0.0324471369,
-0.0017013871,
0.0390741937,
0.0282718632,
-0.0134798717,
-0.0154473865,
0.0346191898,
-0.0335230455,
0.0057510375,
-0.0385276265,
0.0173629578,
-0.0540107079,
-0.0039044868,
0.0585394651,
-0.0038066655,
-0.0270757545,
0.0199519284,
0.0472255014,
-0.0133412816,
-0.0006072027,
0.0395725928,
-0.0128797432,
0.0037733335,
-0.0552584305,
-0.0975596681,
-0.0099314395,
-0.048448842,
-0.0355730429,
-0.0483981036,
0.0453806333,
-0.0006283655,
0.0037597881,
-0.0357403569,
0.014969808,
0.0477429293,
-0.033443708,
-0.0056926995,
-0.0280570053,
0.0175723713,
0.0282762405,
0.002417607,
-0.0449463464,
0.0118122436,
0.0791903511,
0.0756465271,
0.0323932208,
0.0163438898,
0.0771209523,
-0.0184675083,
-0.0103138704,
-0.019782424,
0.0032708894,
-0.000075549,
-0.0320850201,
0.0516214594,
0.0004984709,
0.0598037466,
-0.0411173515,
0.0455638915,
0.065837577,
0.0750972629,
0.0253691655,
0.0022083719,
0.1121031046,
-0.0038002911,
-0.0205890723,
0.0567486137,
-0.0191066954,
0.0298004393,
-0.0198915787,
0.0090405159,
-0.0346708708,
0.0156997088,
-0.0059168115,
-0.0137664573,
0.0026409978,
0.0041739251,
-0.0066375225,
-0.0315039568,
0.0136064794,
0.033035893,
-0.0512768999,
-0.0331249349,
0.0165165029,
-0.0967619047,
0.0422811098,
-0.0060842382,
0.0530252494,
0.0828770325,
0.0802059695,
0.0077740904,
0.0079878792,
-0.0182719026,
-0.0004854719,
0.0169860665,
0.0187085643,
-0.0289465226,
0.0067914133,
-0.0261035357,
0.004411567,
-0.0452483632,
0.0018440435,
0.0216899905,
0.017753575,
-0.0111370394,
-0.0003417053,
-0.0227039717,
-0.0439780653,
0.0434351303,
-0.057399042,
-0.0032998947,
-0.0110184532,
-0.0014021004,
-0.0255686156,
0.0055571669,
-0.0346549675,
0.0250584427,
0.0381514728,
-0.0080567906,
-0.0295085479,
0.0646817237,
-0.053853333,
-0.0405028202,
-0.0194208957,
-0.0278287157,
0.0091810971,
-0.0626126006,
0.0256456193,
-0.060352616,
0.008917165,
-0.0687896088,
0.0162085779,
-0.011602629,
0.0222285669,
0.0175938159,
-0.0308942553,
-0.0412956849,
0.0804266483,
0.0179604366,
-0.0087719643,
0.0034037384,
-0.0106935799,
-0.0017519579,
-0.0327792764,
0.0373011753,
0.0144052887,
0.0173710845,
-0.0042447113,
0.0663140342,
0.0009914553,
-0.0177455191,
-0.0498801284,
-0.0612089224,
-0.0010967301,
0.0019418815,
-0.0255846176,
0.0205305927,
0.0166332424,
-0.0386423133,
0.0032143721,
-0.0464775637,
-0.0051151463,
0.0311669633,
-0.0117484154,
0.0262279455,
0.0455412567,
-0.0138145788,
-0.0161054116,
0.0251025464,
-0.0004289007,
0.0912152231,
0.0853550583,
-0.0005413359,
-0.0416859575,
0.0514532551,
-0.0090412842,
-0.0081422878,
-0.0291703865,
0.0358912274,
0.03840404,
-0.0190434363,
0.0791833997,
0.0178726856,
-0.001964791,
0.0280846469,
0.0543137975,
-0.0552382879,
-0.038759768,
0.0038978707,
-0.0325047709,
0.0249880832,
0.0000596128,
-0.0495885871,
0.0592026003,
0.0529346839,
0.025502827,
0.0233521704,
-0.0450680144,
0.032084655,
0.0225304402,
-0.0021449397,
0.0259848237,
-0.0668882504,
0.0079802787,
0.0761238262,
-0.0091511216,
-0.0546352938,
0.1062785611,
-0.0508983843,
0.0179601088,
-0.0083117783,
0.013607977,
-0.0506667644,
0.1100859046,
0.0042515593,
0.0410729758,
0.0427884534,
0.0181312822,
-0.028037848,
0.0032081122,
0.0334418938,
-0.0240945444,
-0.0061296611,
-0.0666118339,
-0.0214649532,
0.0055947723,
-0.012436809,
-0.0429455824,
-0.0602091812,
0.0073852199,
-0.01722656,
0.0559518188,
-0.0416562743,
-0.0406084433,
0.0181541536,
0.0330509767,
0.0308670755,
-0.0112634702,
-0.0302118398,
-0.0193802435,
0.0569760203,
0.0515791699,
-0.0059289802,
-0.0122017302,
-0.0374538563,
0.0500642546,
0.0343390852,
-0.0213805549,
0.0193886701,
0.0197405927,
0.0093183247,
0.007412062,
-0.0094260992,
-0.03392208,
0.0294213034,
0.0433603562,
-0.0529986247,
-0.0279255789,
0.0898029432,
0.0410051011,
-0.0399603099,
0.0052641784,
-0.0252407994,
0.0549334213,
0.0091389548,
0.0266898088,
-0.0487671718,
0.0127277803,
0.0335965641,
-0.0083271228,
-0.0182051994,
-0.0429198928,
-0.0413131304,
-0.1107072532,
0.0839877576,
0.0087150307,
-0.0037109312,
-0.0148097528,
-0.0329344422,
-0.0310985874,
0.041990865,
-0.0244941078,
0.0242590662,
-0.0168740004,
0.0213078745,
-0.0479710475,
0.002616606,
-0.0182888359,
-0.0079950336,
-0.0477352701,
0.0073807267,
0.0586432628,
0.052260112,
0.029139312,
0.0225409977,
-0.0278590824,
0.0462645367,
0.0479244664,
-0.0146230329,
0.0418140553,
-0.0024615368,
0.0107145775,
-0.0546835288,
0.0477877781,
0.0123389214,
-0.0877726376,
0.0288972389,
0.0462923273,
-0.0390730835,
-0.0410109572,
-0.0304585565,
0.0337637998,
-0.0012136126,
0.0636281446,
0.0587208793,
-0.0417979434,
-0.0238611382,
-0.0245076288,
0.0128213689,
-0.053388264,
-0.0159711204,
0.0025167014,
-0.0131295221,
0.0347559229,
-0.085232228,
-0.0599437393,
0.0289402828,
0.073825784,
0.0268390253,
-0.0163904484,
-0.0106786536,
-0.031016659,
-0.0456577875,
0.0399233513,
-0.0171915535,
0.0042380583,
-0.014007384,
0.0277786832,
0.0134371081,
-0.0585126579,
0.0149733713,
0.0227309018,
-0.0263781436,
-0.0464227349,
-0.0415254235,
0.0032628276,
0.0238543469,
0.0507389158,
0.0292922817,
-0.0620481968,
0.0188100785,
-0.0027521255,
-0.0439499654,
0.0052935481,
-0.0394330621,
0.0419144444,
0.0004508746,
-0.0162491798,
-0.0249098819,
0.0040450096,
-0.0115002738,
0.0804308206,
-0.0060377871,
-0.010586543,
0.0532861613,
0.0165415946,
-0.0083398465,
-0.0563935637,
-0.0343271419,
-0.0660746768,
-0.0420989729,
-0.066247344,
-0.0327504203,
-0.0422759019,
0.0261914898,
0.009398913,
-0.0084852139,
0.0070034377,
-0.0273844898,
-0.0521277301,
0.0125816371,
-0.0539127588,
-0.0377798006,
0.0277174357,
-0.0343311206,
0.0433089286,
-0.0078167077,
-0.0113178091,
0.0128686251,
-0.0614706315,
0.0553628393,
-0.0151217533,
0.0542588942,
0.0095493393,
-0.0307987705,
-0.0003032906,
-0.0007517316,
-0.0580570251,
-0.0247821398,
-0.0241206605,
0.0184278786,
0.0515487827,
-0.0002389467,
0.0624720752,
-0.0431304127,
0.0117551871,
0.011640938,
0.0227873456,
0.0405662097,
-0.037418399,
-0.0246991236,
0.0242621358,
-0.0291486755,
0.0133190854,
0.0468688793,
-0.0125671839,
0.0259154048,
-0.0179977957,
-0.0251338501,
-0.0290344097,
-0.0170951281,
0.0160089843,
0.0250507649,
0.0045260452,
-0.0196337812,
-0.0614098571,
-0.0137753552,
0.0312194768,
0.0104072755,
0.013349086,
-0.0107827131,
0.0156847574,
0.027874643,
-0.0103478245,
0.0096707558,
-0.0384068675,
0.0331706554,
-0.0190329105,
-0.0192035902,
-0.0414441265,
-5.763647534e-33,
-0.0508257523,
-0.0669420511,
0.030861361,
0.0106552094,
-0.0268628635,
0.0099962819,
-0.0448724404,
0.0031678264,
0.0259331279,
0.0318004601,
0.011430217,
-0.0298196115,
-0.0151346503,
0.0148631288,
-0.0203604531,
0.0352038369,
0.0328672677,
0.0264277365,
-0.0842756405,
0.040460594,
0.043794062,
0.0212639757,
-0.0274505261,
-0.047162395,
0.0050616264,
-0.0347288512,
-0.0261836555,
0.0122396471,
0.0207976643,
0.0314110294,
-0.0202279985,
0.0216701683,
0.0171496328,
0.0064911274,
-0.0362617075,
0.0179806203,
-0.0367086679,
-0.0196238346,
0.0018238205,
-0.0340233333,
-0.0098858373,
-0.0303248391,
0.0249420088,
-0.0330960788,
0.0181706324,
-0.0047761351,
0.0480981693,
-0.0058067725,
-0.0084520373,
-0.0157019943,
-0.0793693364,
0.0173538178,
-0.0114525789,
-0.0782366246,
-0.0217073299,
0.077973634,
0.0406285077,
-0.002115089,
-0.0057195635,
0.052465722,
-0.0178116057,
0.0060259709,
0.0108741792,
-0.0068643792,
-0.0216429327,
0.080670014,
0.0289401133,
0.0086208591,
-0.0764945671,
0.0146816997,
-0.0326100811,
0.0580313243,
0.0436883457,
0.0549152121,
-0.0054693613,
0.0126523282,
-0.0414761975,
0.0745634213,
-0.0155023262,
0.0121494066,
0.040157862,
0.0124200312,
-0.0371064432,
-0.0332912728,
-0.0383908786,
-0.0197240189,
-0.0298006497,
-0.0161551032,
0.0080999071,
0.0092624677,
0.0231159013,
-0.0105524585,
0.0140348421,
-0.0102779903,
0.0210039783,
0.0162151363,
-0.0746917948,
0.0428044312,
-0.0145944841,
0.0191280749,
0.0296113156,
-0.0202841498,
0.0624867566,
0.0100497287,
0.0203245301,
0.0416949764,
0.0130849956,
0.0307550542,
-0.0287451595,
-0.0011715346,
-0.0389607996,
-0.0019377809,
0.0003820591,
-0.0417960063,
0.0324070379,
-0.0069604544,
-0.0201672688,
0.0087121744,
0.020397272,
0.0117127346,
-0.0420221835,
-0.0205181204,
-0.0294385459,
0.00536429,
-0.0118758064,
0.0437564589,
0.0083546825,
-0.0076849302,
0.02268783,
-0.0421724468,
-0.0135824541,
0.0082406253,
2.658e-7,
-0.0108131394,
0.0115470774,
0.0459086411,
0.0210162792,
-0.0086391903,
0.0245429911,
-0.0144674676,
-0.0223306473,
0.0038008003,
-0.0196311474,
-0.0023180323,
0.0114973541,
0.0439149588,
0.0560805649,
-0.0561752133,
0.0092424452,
-0.0773336589,
-0.050356254,
-0.0680468306,
-0.0355219506,
0.113181904,
-0.0098708924,
0.030411588,
-0.0152944122,
0.0028059774,
-0.0584878214,
0.0786291286,
-0.0416872166,
-0.0453966893,
0.0263241678,
-0.0196249709,
-0.007174178,
-0.0112637933,
-0.0308374371,
-0.0024247209,
0.0235072412,
-0.0005777272,
0.0400475636,
-0.0228655655,
0.0128947282,
0.0513926409,
-0.0213682242,
-0.0053526629,
-0.0391694978,
0.0181656405,
-0.0484415144,
-0.0214203913,
-0.0334738269,
0.0008863717,
-0.0043485044,
-0.0156049738,
-0.0262654312,
-0.016089445,
0.0277819391,
0.0134017719,
0.0396716557,
0.000161123,
-0.0342310853,
-0.0414732657,
0.0181498341,
-0.0473851636,
-0.007480178,
-0.0228198543,
-0.0143533787,
-0.0223360378,
-0.0295462701,
0.013273159,
2.762429173e-34,
0.0263390988,
0.0109152142,
-0.0163085591,
0.0318623595,
0.0722163245,
0.0170692112,
0.0231665615,
0.008381675,
0.0441750921,
-0.0521051958,
-0.0454179682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05381v1 | CCAE: A Corpus of Chinese-based Asian Englishes | 2023-10-09T03:34:15 | 2023-10-09T03:34:15 | Yang Liu, Melissa Xiaohui Qin, Long Wang, Chao Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | Language models have been foundations in various scenarios of NLP
applications, but it has not been well applied in language variety studies,
even for the most popular language like English. This paper represents one of
the few initial efforts to utilize the NLP technology in the paradigm of World
Englishes, specifically in creating a multi-variety corpus for studying Asian
Englishes. We present an overview of the CCAE -- Corpus of Chinese-based Asian
English, a suite of corpora comprising six Chinese-based Asian English
varieties. It is based on 340 million tokens in 448 thousand web documents from
six regions. The ontology of data would make the corpus a helpful resource with
enormous research potential for Asian Englishes (especially for Chinese
Englishes for which there has not been a publicly accessible corpus yet so far)
and an ideal source for variety-specific language modeling and downstream
tasks, thus setting the stage for NLP-based World Englishes studies. And
preliminary experiments on this corpus reveal the practical value of CCAE.
Finally, we make CCAE available at
\href{https://huggingface.co/datasets/CCAE/CCAE-Corpus}{this https URL}. | [
0.0584423207,
0.0592507236,
-0.0329307467,
0.0453171879,
-0.0299435835,
0.003329024,
0.0009365143,
0.0309649296,
0.0189043209,
-0.0471950397,
-0.039835345,
-0.0604668446,
0.027922608,
0.037107002,
0.0273706727,
-0.0719176754,
0.0181312785,
-0.0081743747,
0.0160814449,
0.0019537352,
0.0586498454,
-0.0079972204,
0.0429668203,
0.0752275139,
-0.0274589173,
-0.0299500283,
-0.0032954279,
-0.0057786773,
0.0112401554,
0.0190149117,
0.0419061631,
0.0501738563,
-0.0072975536,
0.024735162,
0.0000018544,
-0.0394924916,
-0.0346370265,
-0.0094117094,
0.0183449276,
0.0027174011,
0.0302434545,
0.035362035,
-0.0314069279,
0.0096035935,
0.0130823813,
-0.0328345746,
0.0610223003,
0.0233157612,
0.020314429,
0.0460084938,
-0.0247401353,
-0.0282445755,
0.0060210102,
-0.0028318129,
-0.0309018418,
-0.0061973021,
0.0380701199,
-0.0444140956,
0.0537605733,
0.0174123812,
-0.0117608029,
-0.0081831357,
-0.0463668741,
-0.0157924891,
-0.0704664364,
-0.0085128229,
-0.0423611104,
-0.0158304423,
0.0201053247,
0.0016523352,
0.0358557142,
-0.0477691554,
0.0089630652,
0.0450653657,
-0.0471396595,
0.0207949802,
-0.02029985,
0.0196200162,
-0.0432475135,
0.0149149913,
0.0706960708,
-0.0204526018,
-0.0242176503,
0.0244098157,
-0.0206368119,
0.0667783543,
0.0586896464,
-0.016318379,
-0.0349612311,
-0.0143326689,
0.0108831283,
-0.0490595661,
0.0478417687,
0.0069384691,
-0.0260619037,
0.0343759954,
0.0304071158,
-0.0404649451,
0.0220568627,
-0.0348001756,
-0.0089018969,
0.0081238104,
-0.0432316326,
-0.0002601215,
0.0353765227,
0.0216618162,
-0.0096498225,
-0.0135491826,
-0.062914364,
-0.0404167511,
-0.0378535688,
-0.0094353352,
-0.0529341884,
-0.0009984395,
0.0099930614,
-0.0162842274,
-0.0358906798,
0.0029618549,
-0.0049770889,
0.0090730255,
0.0241131801,
-0.013965508,
-0.0528574958,
-0.0105628213,
-0.0072101862,
0.0224521793,
-0.0156619512,
0.0028036048,
-0.0334394425,
-0.0518141538,
0.0488897115,
0.0205478743,
0.0101213334,
-0.0086055128,
-0.0322950184,
0.0106465854,
0.0165143646,
-0.0098648015,
-0.035905648,
0.0301195793,
-0.0551046953,
0.0302207321,
-0.0116882306,
-0.0794493631,
0.0032608011,
0.0103700617,
0.0615085661,
-0.0375194587,
-0.0069400687,
-0.01424029,
-0.0128031084,
0.0064994846,
-0.048167631,
-0.0112204785,
-0.0081799412,
-0.0238583796,
-0.0052531301,
0.0502958782,
0.0284838676,
-0.0186718591,
0.1187624261,
-0.0341231637,
0.0313421302,
0.0386799164,
-0.0347770005,
0.0183799285,
-0.0188392196,
-0.0134007176,
-0.008026341,
-0.0081004295,
-0.007918884,
0.05125954,
0.0094155679,
0.0008532652,
0.023006076,
0.0544091612,
0.0279515442,
0.0024479083,
0.0255040713,
-0.0061183884,
0.0206266604,
0.0208689515,
0.0300624948,
-0.0515941381,
-0.0367843211,
0.0273016784,
-0.0278491266,
0.0186643377,
-0.0375302695,
-0.0590997376,
-0.0962595046,
-0.0124622816,
-0.0066689998,
-0.002035347,
0.0486890264,
-0.0244807992,
0.0464337692,
0.0416200943,
0.0504614823,
-0.0143931946,
0.0227588378,
-0.0241976995,
0.0114353206,
0.0611674599,
-0.0147369523,
-0.0491854548,
-0.0043263743,
0.0276495274,
-0.0539395921,
0.067988798,
0.0274395347,
-0.044230707,
-0.0251072869,
-0.0143391872,
0.0245235395,
0.011308657,
0.0478778891,
0.0351108834,
-0.0121790562,
0.0145031856,
-0.0317773111,
-0.0907131806,
-0.0204638876,
-0.0017648665,
-0.0527169518,
0.019783847,
0.0063256007,
0.0040315581,
0.0225250609,
0.0484793968,
-0.0384197272,
0.0250244197,
-0.0044818516,
-0.0405081734,
-0.0208142269,
0.0901516005,
0.0178776812,
0.0150307557,
0.0431715362,
-0.0512612723,
0.0358459316,
0.0237378627,
-0.0095681883,
-0.0422848761,
0.0037324321,
0.0120220976,
0.0483268686,
-0.0780325979,
0.0800283849,
-0.0261562206,
0.0098653166,
-0.0228086859,
0.0421574116,
0.0133249201,
0.0537823364,
-0.0184922684,
0.0072598285,
0.0446111001,
-0.0318650007,
-0.0560266189,
0.0113133658,
0.01175173,
0.026033299,
0.0552506857,
-0.0157219023,
-0.0220773872,
-0.0011421137,
-0.1042362824,
-0.0065138796,
-0.0527213626,
0.0573454425,
0.0170554668,
0.0118993213,
-0.0347525105,
0.0416278057,
-0.0205993317,
0.0033244411,
-0.0276366733,
0.0404443517,
0.0174906943,
-0.0231356453,
0.0549641997,
-0.0241376553,
-0.0047828718,
0.0228678752,
0.0241600033,
-0.0352529921,
-0.0292143412,
-0.0358559042,
-0.0048651667,
-0.0140243843,
0.022459833,
-0.0132409558,
-0.0270487573,
-0.0093907835,
-0.0201415364,
0.0229275525,
-0.0214582905,
0.0190374069,
0.0063468134,
0.018433176,
-0.0175744109,
-0.004356903,
-0.0190085694,
0.0205400698,
-0.0002905166,
-0.0474367738,
-0.0526658781,
0.0255330428,
0.0769959539,
-0.0075197262,
-0.0363872536,
-0.0385308526,
-0.0394203924,
-0.063325271,
0.0061870194,
-0.0088861333,
0.0118710315,
-0.0556864738,
0.0266947206,
0.0030181208,
-0.0024128028,
0.0462070927,
-0.0405444875,
0.0183839053,
-0.0773821697,
0.0164559782,
-0.0589733087,
0.0589175522,
-0.0278487112,
0.0112253949,
0.0834555253,
-0.0633520707,
0.0231168754,
0.0382000916,
-0.0105563588,
-0.0003177701,
0.0354771614,
-0.0400161482,
0.0162491221,
-0.0242562145,
-0.0333600789,
-0.0155761242,
0.029567292,
-0.0299955215,
0.0459930412,
0.0925856233,
-0.006607967,
0.0406889096,
0.0376838073,
-0.0252974275,
0.035888616,
-0.0287871677,
0.0358662456,
-0.0101505909,
0.0604870096,
0.036047183,
0.0525447987,
-0.0073386668,
0.0328926034,
0.0181431752,
0.0219238047,
0.0147073083,
0.0284153391,
0.0221169647,
-0.0086062523,
0.0598313734,
-0.0629480258,
-0.0778135285,
-0.008759737,
0.0336041898,
-0.0055506467,
-0.0190469939,
0.0983735025,
0.0591823459,
-0.0396465398,
0.0334033109,
-0.0328214429,
0.0178905353,
0.0263548419,
0.0094041964,
-0.0792081878,
0.0223586299,
0.01418579,
-0.0397184454,
0.0009892065,
-0.0066184946,
0.0016065619,
-0.0888181999,
0.0188237429,
-0.0079039251,
-0.0195376519,
0.0271996986,
-0.0152466362,
0.0224057734,
-0.0365222804,
0.0117943101,
-0.0199288223,
0.0022155023,
-0.019512495,
0.0480786487,
-0.0106495842,
-0.0736438632,
0.0292731225,
-0.0564316139,
-0.0024411916,
-0.033053264,
0.0444128737,
-0.0682640001,
-0.0180038847,
-0.0106882248,
-0.0201914329,
-0.020995222,
-0.0012025954,
0.0021461351,
0.0186847281,
-0.0116009442,
0.0069006905,
-0.0088384142,
-0.0179258958,
0.0013018952,
0.0576881394,
0.0248902068,
0.0115068723,
-0.0001631713,
-0.017237125,
-0.0508161001,
-0.0012457385,
0.0460312255,
-0.0201109629,
-0.0850555599,
0.0249095522,
-0.0519129932,
-0.0426881649,
-0.0197195578,
-0.0221009888,
0.0474511199,
-0.0251324251,
-0.0505473092,
-0.1098016426,
-0.0334517881,
-0.0179214142,
0.0126781464,
0.0474833027,
-0.0130918557,
0.0429794081,
0.0218877885,
0.0047587943,
0.0190749709,
0.0014298889,
0.0015836393,
-0.0657954514,
-0.0438259207,
0.0417711176,
-0.0238831025,
0.0119341528,
-0.0250811074,
-0.0292251986,
-0.0456629395,
0.0221057739,
-0.0130027579,
0.0071257916,
0.0101243909,
-0.0345424004,
-0.0259498302,
0.0210311972,
-0.0245126467,
0.029775437,
-0.0032110685,
0.0502051115,
-0.021946989,
-0.0165854506,
0.0384290218,
-0.0389369465,
-0.0067064743,
-0.0200349893,
0.0434672982,
-0.0167187955,
-0.0070065018,
0.0400203131,
-0.0107084075,
-0.0254699923,
-0.067802906,
0.0160021018,
-0.0710497573,
-0.0136059979,
-0.0605466999,
-0.0419091806,
-0.0156104323,
-0.0234327037,
0.0148427859,
-0.013139002,
-0.0604945049,
0.0465167016,
-0.0232760217,
0.0008296962,
-0.0134929223,
0.0136421919,
0.037695881,
0.0430803075,
-0.0187655576,
0.005304656,
-0.0228473898,
-0.0200014114,
-0.0352207497,
0.0263458472,
-0.0486927889,
0.0290459059,
-0.015815638,
-0.0171619523,
0.0126343053,
0.0495614931,
-0.0237602685,
-0.0199326109,
0.0235868618,
-0.0079329479,
0.0979049653,
-0.0541766621,
0.0601495467,
-0.0671685338,
-0.0122517692,
-0.0468979068,
0.014614475,
0.0767986178,
-0.0390195996,
0.0162539706,
-0.0065091047,
-0.0356616825,
-0.0173681397,
0.1042977795,
0.0161550008,
-0.0028002018,
0.0477891155,
-0.0246635396,
-0.0146071026,
0.0018508544,
0.0353118367,
0.0268725958,
-0.0414024852,
-0.0214738734,
-0.088127397,
-0.0653402284,
0.0362128355,
-0.0149876233,
0.0445680954,
0.0251665805,
-0.0059516104,
0.070089899,
0.0263246689,
0.0336974226,
-0.080152452,
-0.0077233869,
0.0041030408,
0.0135387415,
0.0201928467,
-6.15591955e-33,
0.0121399425,
-0.0065028677,
-0.0273098554,
-0.0580440648,
0.0330561437,
0.0069662207,
-0.0259998236,
-0.001180421,
-0.0636427552,
0.0055626291,
-0.0593678392,
0.0004169029,
0.0209613051,
0.0264148805,
0.0382500775,
0.0301631261,
0.003992137,
0.0359420963,
0.0248107668,
-0.0221523698,
0.0976804122,
-0.0103316149,
0.0867686272,
-0.0290261023,
0.0782820433,
0.0205088146,
-0.0328846499,
0.0190572944,
0.0155110853,
0.0707538873,
-0.0483621471,
0.094146952,
0.0371987224,
0.0193513073,
-0.019715365,
-0.0352150761,
-0.0478432775,
-0.0292565841,
0.0177382696,
0.018307779,
0.0451625623,
-0.0233017057,
-0.0227404572,
-0.0113458922,
0.0222434606,
0.0299629364,
0.0451903343,
-0.0141698653,
0.0177413654,
-0.0004493746,
-0.0640896857,
0.0234752614,
0.0123161813,
0.0194086451,
0.0209244229,
-0.0192547273,
-0.0253647268,
0.0256376285,
-0.0372618139,
0.0475883,
0.033515349,
0.052323468,
0.0435755961,
0.02049377,
-0.0016505102,
0.0034019051,
-0.0543237068,
0.0084975567,
0.0380510874,
0.007392677,
0.0679882467,
0.0323557071,
-0.0036458129,
0.0498059206,
0.0083119124,
-0.03726165,
-0.0240541454,
0.0130857565,
0.0377472043,
0.0175847542,
-0.0391293429,
0.0145841977,
-0.0332140662,
-0.048062332,
0.0072559854,
-0.0007617168,
-0.0101909824,
-0.0071646459,
-0.0121195847,
-0.0054656798,
-0.0366768762,
-0.0174218137,
0.0206545442,
-0.0615764447,
-0.0509950072,
0.0553004593,
0.0037331888,
0.0073332652,
-0.0156454109,
0.055195801,
-0.0444992147,
-0.0656057671,
-0.0225993246,
-0.0083598448,
-0.0401973352,
0.0000723078,
0.0188869648,
0.0358980522,
-0.0360064097,
0.0172837917,
-0.0173657499,
-0.0339005701,
-0.0014458832,
0.015326106,
0.0137614459,
0.0235792287,
0.0095614232,
0.0317097269,
0.0900889114,
0.0185138136,
-0.0606177598,
-0.0173491109,
-0.0334048271,
0.012097015,
-0.0011742016,
0.0231831148,
-0.0267180409,
0.0396934338,
0.0410117656,
-0.0203714035,
-0.0058201454,
-0.0186750032,
2.638e-7,
0.0335902758,
-0.0025123039,
0.0274975747,
0.0323621444,
0.04818286,
0.0011566074,
-0.0261228736,
0.0537936874,
-0.0247572437,
0.0035728626,
0.0200465918,
-0.034481883,
0.0538384467,
0.0405177511,
-0.0936469808,
0.007794763,
0.0121488981,
-0.0084935632,
-0.0452227592,
0.0432566218,
0.0185098201,
0.0851557925,
-0.0288329814,
0.0382086895,
-0.009460506,
0.0058135684,
0.0212021321,
-0.0090784617,
-0.0164507627,
0.0652724653,
0.0070774513,
-0.0258288216,
0.0378899612,
-0.031166723,
-0.0304918103,
0.0426241644,
0.0195589606,
0.0483806096,
-0.0129092308,
0.0116009843,
-0.0199793801,
-0.0528540649,
0.0116827935,
-0.0815898925,
0.0615570396,
0.0747733265,
-0.0136804823,
-0.0199884921,
0.0135079287,
0.02412102,
-0.0136771174,
-0.0609890111,
-0.051524356,
0.0477412492,
0.0164267197,
-0.0042048837,
-0.0085496278,
-0.0093154097,
-0.0819511488,
0.0068064262,
-0.0270784646,
-0.0346651226,
0.0507767498,
-0.0198284741,
0.0031095946,
-0.0595170967,
0.0147851687,
2.324876426e-34,
0.0226684101,
0.0306453332,
-0.0091375364,
0.055111669,
0.0346282944,
-0.0389501452,
0.0287834965,
0.0353599004,
-0.0211452171,
-0.0165956132,
-0.0534029268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05378v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05378v3 | Transcending the Attention Paradigm: Representation Learning from Geospatial Social Media Data | 2023-10-09T03:27:05 | 2024-01-14T09:29:18 | Nick DiSanto, Anthony Corso, Benjamin Sanders, Gavin Harding | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | While transformers have pioneered attention-driven architectures as a
cornerstone of language modeling, their dependence on explicitly contextual
information underscores limitations in their abilities to tacitly learn
overarching textual themes. This study challenges the heuristic paradigm of
performance benchmarking by investigating social media data as a source of
distributed patterns. In stark contrast to networks that rely on capturing
complex long-term dependencies, models of online data inherently lack structure
and are forced to detect latent structures in the aggregate. To properly
represent these abstract relationships, this research dissects empirical social
media corpora into their elemental components, analyzing over two billion
tweets across population-dense locations. We create Bag-of-Word embedding
specific to each city and compare their respective representations. This finds
that even amidst noisy data, geographic location has a considerable influence
on online communication, and that hidden insights can be uncovered without the
crutch of advanced algorithms. This evidence presents valuable geospatial
implications in social science and challenges the notion that intricate models
are prerequisites for pattern recognition in natural language. This aligns with
the evolving landscape that questions the embrace of absolute interpretability
over abstract understanding and bridges the divide between sophisticated
frameworks and intangible relationships. | [
0.0359824374,
0.0724196061,
-0.0341522098,
0.0257337131,
0.0002694647,
0.0053607379,
-0.0118544949,
-0.0174109172,
0.0038492181,
-0.0582545027,
0.0245845485,
-0.0375228971,
0.0223642346,
0.0456047729,
0.0460950062,
-0.0587072819,
0.0134259705,
0.0341140628,
-0.0075412123,
0.0145828342,
0.0209707655,
0.0127152139,
0.0509775281,
0.0404542275,
0.016341351,
0.0179055315,
0.0140175689,
-0.0057182107,
-0.0052804113,
-0.0172243044,
0.0333199613,
0.0199245699,
0.0263947397,
0.0509982146,
0.0000019515,
0.0162218045,
-0.011135377,
-0.024522569,
0.0407068767,
0.0059663546,
0.0398604795,
-0.046632573,
0.018377075,
0.0017221312,
-0.0400409363,
-0.023918014,
0.0571355633,
0.0185555834,
0.0171912722,
0.063203074,
-0.0198621303,
-0.032293953,
0.0242337845,
-0.023147,
-0.0409380198,
0.0115104737,
-0.009326674,
-0.0344877802,
0.0297410563,
0.0396761373,
-0.0337633416,
0.0172411818,
0.0013205464,
0.0160086676,
0.0386359952,
0.0336701982,
-0.0445318297,
0.0214737765,
0.0078451829,
0.0884957984,
-0.011989085,
-0.0359877795,
0.0439788885,
0.0255464502,
-0.0333579481,
0.0286258869,
-0.0533410348,
0.0037062252,
0.0190164559,
0.0536012165,
-0.0067649898,
0.0087794671,
0.0405732207,
0.0373275541,
-0.0463655218,
0.0470351167,
-0.026408717,
-0.0576133206,
-0.0640781596,
0.0233808942,
-0.048543781,
-0.0505401306,
0.0365475602,
0.0196050107,
-0.0196234621,
0.0158790946,
0.0056557632,
0.0155498404,
0.0042601135,
-0.0443203785,
0.0099566039,
-0.0169438832,
-0.0195481107,
0.0459293388,
0.0312116724,
0.0231245849,
-0.0330188498,
0.0350408815,
-0.0128342556,
-0.0219859779,
-0.0583094135,
0.0068802624,
-0.0000885249,
-0.0104396408,
-0.0066973739,
-0.0054703774,
-0.0116498563,
0.033195097,
-0.0148173934,
-0.0130411629,
-0.0526563488,
0.0283191372,
0.007589737,
-0.0002039804,
0.013752915,
0.0271672141,
-0.0165004563,
-0.0099135796,
-0.0193905011,
0.0150406109,
-0.0052834856,
0.0068262555,
0.0743311346,
0.02087784,
-0.0598105788,
0.0363622718,
0.0445439331,
-0.0501285009,
-0.0185224134,
-0.0064642215,
-0.0058249328,
-0.0344476849,
0.0364345349,
-0.048462905,
0.0099012991,
0.0481376164,
-0.0155423619,
-0.0142594976,
-0.0012948,
0.0222802199,
-0.0557202362,
0.007323103,
0.008351407,
0.0439581312,
0.0045430488,
0.0152000291,
0.0419293121,
0.065110974,
0.0146376537,
0.066263333,
0.0487451702,
-0.0284167603,
0.0039181244,
-0.0051312712,
0.0384314694,
0.0174426641,
-0.0024902581,
-0.0118487719,
-0.0624733306,
0.0080781057,
0.019501688,
0.0393331945,
-0.0125243897,
0.0273675062,
0.0911510289,
0.0752915889,
0.0046616197,
0.0231912006,
0.0361526161,
0.088263303,
-0.033348728,
-0.0281804372,
-0.0504093878,
-0.0080135576,
-0.0096858749,
-0.0193009321,
0.0298342407,
0.0477058776,
-0.0301019661,
0.0156370886,
0.005737348,
-0.0012483684,
0.0299267676,
0.0067396141,
0.0405286178,
-0.0099795666,
-0.0194716975,
0.070517242,
0.0345405936,
-0.0094391499,
-0.0018391268,
0.0277162939,
0.0041744015,
0.0023556135,
0.0105374614,
0.0264099892,
0.0345484726,
-0.014309139,
0.0539845638,
0.0284257736,
0.019567553,
0.0243020561,
0.0104270121,
-0.027570365,
-0.0304768663,
0.0134865865,
0.0229030252,
-0.0275286529,
0.0593208708,
0.0260284059,
0.0197643396,
-0.0451146998,
-0.0022799058,
-0.0141185438,
0.009208546,
-0.0170574337,
-0.0163098462,
0.0323622115,
-0.0045964969,
0.0124791414,
0.0071312683,
-0.0153714679,
0.0211887956,
-0.0301069152,
-0.0388630405,
0.0482250154,
-0.0544264503,
0.0332051888,
-0.0002480557,
-0.0256680604,
-0.0519912504,
0.0470667779,
-0.0458204262,
-0.0110837994,
0.0929603428,
-0.0864047781,
0.0831404775,
-0.0079671787,
-0.004483134,
-0.0292721484,
0.0440313853,
-0.0140376398,
0.0702488571,
-0.0463374183,
0.0152954543,
-0.035825368,
0.0017498953,
0.0226945728,
0.0123343281,
-0.0062513333,
-0.025838051,
-0.0140145449,
-0.0096790167,
-0.0012950889,
-0.0351248831,
-0.0360397846,
-0.0126218013,
-0.0833568573,
-0.001747209,
-0.0540880263,
-0.0100250598,
0.0061338819,
0.012198831,
0.0011183571,
-0.0260305479,
-0.0251620933,
0.009097022,
-0.0058823782,
0.0458679311,
0.0383962579,
-0.0508386195,
0.0000056163,
-0.0203102082,
-0.018357221,
-0.0317486301,
0.0673666671,
-0.0289920401,
-0.0251692999,
-0.0095776785,
-0.0256665517,
-0.0128754927,
-0.001403021,
-0.0144155063,
-0.0193314906,
0.0007882533,
-0.0040374543,
0.0319462009,
0.0051620179,
0.0347329415,
0.0187084824,
-0.0115820719,
-0.0185726006,
-0.0288502965,
0.003777337,
-0.0511575006,
0.0358393006,
-0.0374075919,
-0.0442787111,
0.006816294,
0.0833301842,
-0.0146565679,
-0.0000257064,
-0.0213984605,
-0.0007769155,
-0.028281996,
0.0182690341,
-0.0333947092,
0.0207127482,
0.0013832909,
0.0042167515,
-0.0652581081,
-0.0618582554,
0.0393977612,
0.0133544216,
0.0066648205,
-0.0043752077,
-0.0464921966,
-0.0419915542,
0.0750704557,
0.0567182451,
0.01940649,
0.0085099386,
-0.04524526,
0.0234075263,
-0.0102553181,
-0.0276676659,
-0.016530659,
0.0501118712,
0.0408273786,
-0.0031418395,
0.0110088,
-0.0525536574,
-0.0253291186,
-0.0791858658,
-0.055484008,
-0.0126051009,
0.0401330739,
-0.0678444728,
-0.0374488272,
0.0320518874,
0.0280293133,
0.0017948593,
-0.0125655625,
-0.0240711328,
-0.0087894574,
0.0554836281,
0.0441911705,
0.0376898572,
0.0186126195,
0.0133834332,
-0.0579217374,
0.0238562431,
0.0266286228,
-0.0040753032,
-0.0358112045,
0.012289511,
0.0308153816,
-0.0373603627,
-0.0278050434,
-0.0163320415,
0.0607523806,
-0.0223127212,
-0.0248143449,
0.076768294,
0.023587605,
-0.0382749699,
0.0274311528,
0.0173919685,
0.0124536986,
0.0153981149,
0.059983056,
-0.0611900091,
-0.0018978796,
-0.0165218785,
-0.018160535,
0.0217295494,
-0.0431337133,
-0.0256674662,
-0.0830773637,
0.0314726233,
0.0048699654,
-0.0136663737,
-0.0214857869,
-0.0741217881,
-0.0270221699,
0.0015781542,
0.0052170441,
-0.0479115322,
-0.036713995,
-0.0089715971,
0.0196305308,
-0.0736152679,
-0.0298992265,
0.0280340854,
-0.0388576351,
0.0226866174,
0.008654003,
0.0725028887,
-0.0089208903,
-0.0407589749,
-0.0247758944,
0.0236993413,
0.0053649615,
-0.0073741353,
0.0416551158,
-0.0177356862,
-0.0077603543,
-0.0317051187,
-0.0253569968,
-0.072792232,
-0.0250252374,
-0.032402955,
0.0832392797,
-0.0034884571,
-0.0032643171,
-0.0418562703,
0.010330122,
0.024433801,
0.0077346447,
0.0585318245,
-0.0306313839,
-0.0510660857,
-0.0212214403,
0.0099823084,
-0.0499321222,
-0.0314863883,
0.0095892251,
0.0149578964,
-0.0405039787,
-0.0082173999,
-0.0538980849,
0.0002778587,
0.0112203471,
-0.0158655737,
-0.0264038835,
0.0564367063,
-0.0474553071,
-0.0775446445,
0.0494640134,
-0.0398354866,
0.0046838047,
0.0156198908,
-0.0258694924,
-0.0024090377,
-0.008926631,
-0.0053894222,
-0.0011543509,
-0.102606535,
-0.0398554653,
0.0418707654,
-0.0254089572,
0.0117076822,
0.0045796675,
-0.0421589874,
-0.0694323033,
0.0597853847,
0.0229438413,
-0.0423069075,
-0.0044805785,
0.0017292975,
-0.0075865276,
0.0345223732,
0.0451423191,
-0.0212339479,
0.0682860389,
0.0183022805,
-0.0052146236,
-0.0669218972,
0.0638608038,
-0.0153688136,
-0.0253275484,
0.091654703,
0.0116209602,
-0.0419761166,
-0.0179693624,
-0.0607474968,
0.0079440139,
0.0160649084,
-0.0312152524,
-0.025436148,
0.0275105741,
0.0239657927,
-0.0562154315,
0.0376022533,
0.0088718431,
0.0210590772,
-0.050590802,
0.0388712361,
0.0035963007,
-0.0171576981,
-0.0107412552,
0.0478586555,
-0.0053845164,
-0.0131755555,
-0.0040762746,
0.0396042466,
0.0003222795,
-0.0015352548,
-0.0158512704,
0.0133985989,
-0.0267025307,
0.0251007099,
-0.0938805118,
-0.0253078043,
0.0242617149,
-0.0207080133,
0.059958823,
-0.0826520845,
0.0462110937,
0.0234811176,
0.0086777452,
0.0072987103,
0.0197733939,
-0.0579965785,
-0.0562901683,
-0.0159148611,
0.0012182924,
-0.0592134707,
0.0700455531,
0.0623388775,
-0.0105941128,
-0.0161238145,
0.0416293703,
-0.0133313499,
-0.0056715789,
0.0213468652,
0.0160328671,
0.0448646359,
-0.0058334819,
0.0147501901,
-0.039452929,
-0.0634548217,
0.039300967,
-0.0666686147,
0.0118302368,
-0.0149729587,
0.0010461006,
0.046592176,
0.0109277973,
0.0119575066,
-0.0536931939,
0.0163120609,
-0.0431799516,
-0.0397761501,
0.005214897,
-7.069640492e-33,
0.0342239216,
-0.0832683668,
0.0060480805,
-0.0390414372,
-0.0417987779,
0.0573426932,
-0.0524537861,
-0.020032458,
-0.0134368921,
0.016070934,
-0.0481898971,
0.0290994868,
0.0007065012,
0.0361989476,
0.0341698267,
0.0008831442,
-0.0026606978,
0.0196904261,
0.011891216,
0.0463159829,
0.0616662912,
0.018128369,
0.0390865318,
-0.0871649906,
-0.0039740601,
-0.027943423,
-0.0032005326,
0.0175738465,
0.0600181147,
0.0476479642,
-0.0291389935,
0.0686670393,
0.0503194667,
-0.0092108641,
-0.0321772993,
0.067600444,
-0.0644850209,
-0.0464242212,
-0.0056551029,
-0.0182524417,
-0.0262966547,
-0.0062667648,
0.0370473526,
-0.0044064601,
0.0451579615,
-0.0025302086,
0.0302678719,
0.0434849523,
-0.046425391,
-0.0038815436,
-0.0576138124,
0.0477494337,
-0.030048294,
0.0135158589,
0.0120311519,
0.0348189808,
0.035152141,
0.0504285656,
-0.0412368551,
0.0206591636,
-0.0079581169,
0.0146720503,
0.0307351798,
0.0042596594,
0.0009896186,
0.0741621107,
0.02379377,
0.0319720134,
-0.0477372929,
-0.0399042368,
0.0419180244,
0.0100233927,
-0.0229751468,
0.0243237056,
0.0157970246,
-0.0458104238,
-0.0649072602,
-0.0181095302,
0.012050719,
0.0065104337,
0.0266564637,
-0.0011398534,
-0.0451589711,
-0.0214547664,
0.0117895603,
-0.0266150795,
-0.0224371161,
-0.0213460997,
-0.0141043207,
0.0251772162,
0.012652969,
0.0756231472,
0.0259580947,
-0.0740050152,
-0.0050025019,
0.0014800309,
0.009336466,
0.0098046865,
0.0239990894,
0.0352175869,
-0.0814463273,
-0.0199978147,
-0.0511775985,
0.0259630941,
-0.0121106524,
0.0126797222,
0.052698873,
0.0408571325,
-0.0398373641,
-0.0188955888,
-0.0173590127,
-0.0189679656,
-0.0895223394,
-0.0212167483,
0.0468727723,
0.0308425538,
-0.0039928425,
0.0161802396,
0.0629040822,
0.0439481549,
0.0133776339,
0.0372508876,
-0.0190112274,
0.0429447666,
0.008251057,
-0.0449785478,
-0.0487041213,
0.0552573651,
0.0328488536,
-0.0715458691,
-0.0133725489,
-0.0310395714,
2.791e-7,
0.0338611044,
0.09626811,
-0.0039609368,
0.0028475174,
0.0383687131,
0.0073591713,
0.0401613377,
0.0392912701,
-0.0248590466,
0.0159524325,
-0.0134167066,
0.0409396365,
0.0511735864,
0.043566931,
-0.1095978394,
0.0378162712,
-0.1013716012,
0.0052461727,
-0.0421854965,
-0.0067719314,
0.0065750517,
0.0949752107,
0.0485170148,
-0.0259855464,
-0.0145841604,
-0.0368549116,
0.0530851036,
-0.0415949002,
-0.0089539839,
-0.0016626357,
0.0077051823,
-0.0200484022,
-0.0038774749,
-0.040654067,
-0.0266691167,
0.0202241,
0.0099966889,
0.0464772657,
0.0015730878,
-0.0267938282,
-0.0132645033,
-0.0579562113,
-0.0001728007,
-0.0690314323,
0.0371430367,
-0.0728013813,
-0.0846602991,
-0.0140313013,
-0.0165264253,
0.0053531337,
0.0245025698,
0.0286534764,
-0.0370898768,
-0.009060611,
-0.0037000761,
-0.0291586649,
0.0038708088,
-0.1034307331,
-0.0029299678,
0.0120003112,
-0.003651124,
-0.0023573264,
-0.0527261309,
-0.0132590113,
0.1026327461,
0.0097969659,
0.017576132,
2.354867144e-34,
0.0110318707,
-0.0124037396,
0.0144293485,
-0.0196890831,
0.0204558317,
-0.0226387009,
0.0111158192,
-0.0051585087,
0.0428961031,
-0.0465871803,
0.0231212396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05374v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05374v3 | Improving End-to-End Speech Processing by Efficient Text Data Utilization with Latent Synthesis | 2023-10-09T03:10:49 | 2023-10-24T06:48:55 | Jianqiao Lu, Wenyong Huang, Nianzu Zheng, Xingshan Zeng, Yu Ting Yeung, Xiao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Training a high performance end-to-end speech (E2E) processing model requires
an enormous amount of labeled speech data, especially in the era of
data-centric artificial intelligence. However, labeled speech data are usually
scarcer and more expensive for collection, compared to textual data. We propose
Latent Synthesis (LaSyn), an efficient textual data utilization framework for
E2E speech processing models. We train a latent synthesizer to convert textual
data into an intermediate latent representation of a pre-trained speech model.
These pseudo acoustic representations of textual data augment acoustic data for
model training. We evaluate LaSyn on low-resource automatic speech recognition
(ASR) and spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks. For ASR, LaSyn improves an
E2E baseline trained on LibriSpeech train-clean-100, with relative word error
rate reductions over 22.3% on different test sets. For SLU, LaSyn improves our
E2E baseline by absolute 4.1% for intent classification accuracy and 3.8% for
slot filling SLU-F1 on SLURP, and absolute 4.49% and 2.25% for exact match (EM)
and EM-Tree accuracies on STOP respectively. With fewer parameters, the results
of LaSyn are competitive to published state-of-the-art works. The results
demonstrate the quality of the augmented training data. | [
0.0184939224,
0.0853012279,
0.0084173912,
0.0333372764,
0.0225221831,
-0.0088865925,
0.0308281872,
-0.0174527373,
-0.0150098475,
-0.0775976703,
-0.0309883542,
-0.0247724205,
0.0058651823,
0.0446664877,
0.0384609662,
-0.0634469539,
0.0193864908,
-0.0441499725,
-0.0019077909,
-0.0068289181,
0.0169705618,
0.0353582427,
-0.0451315977,
0.0172515381,
-0.0143756159,
0.005986324,
-0.0396993123,
0.0168999806,
0.0216444079,
-0.0230351649,
-0.0289771091,
-0.0040411898,
0.0655028149,
0.0104373116,
0.0000023404,
-0.0196850263,
-0.0065452033,
-0.016462177,
-0.0913804621,
0.0268628076,
0.0707492977,
0.0002660488,
-0.0052645607,
0.0536746867,
0.0058451784,
-0.0677933544,
0.0137508065,
0.0369068421,
0.035455469,
0.0837402567,
-0.0069777616,
-0.0360798761,
0.0451720245,
0.0032557559,
0.0176691767,
0.000785901,
-0.0253311675,
-0.0148598151,
0.032860484,
-0.0068562832,
0.007363996,
0.0453263856,
0.008875737,
0.0021178701,
0.0104459049,
0.0600185394,
-0.0332084745,
-0.0163340457,
-0.0244017411,
0.0751450434,
0.0056612263,
-0.0456064045,
0.0142689077,
-0.0263191946,
-0.0719345361,
-0.0335743688,
-0.0015828714,
0.0087600425,
0.0152487289,
0.0100225583,
0.0232645068,
-0.0180074815,
0.0155530367,
-0.0460269451,
-0.014805791,
-0.0193012059,
0.0211581737,
-0.0270515997,
-0.0070503675,
-0.0359928049,
-0.0531099662,
-0.0488794297,
-0.0025868614,
0.0016070371,
-0.0101074614,
-0.0046665506,
-0.0597605668,
-0.0582811572,
-0.0319068059,
-0.0079851691,
0.0036917389,
0.0681798905,
-0.0145843681,
0.0055208881,
-0.0074063013,
0.0355094559,
-0.0057415087,
-0.0149716325,
-0.0521040559,
-0.0005363721,
-0.012183195,
0.0168331247,
-0.0555727892,
0.0153481979,
-0.0586698689,
-0.0475011989,
-0.005728418,
0.0197740979,
0.0136985872,
-0.0045895199,
0.0060686911,
0.0201769229,
-0.0405867696,
0.0127268992,
0.0092799338,
-0.0165113751,
0.0121378321,
0.0614690483,
-0.0059953807,
-0.0342514701,
-0.0133181149,
0.0163087677,
0.0697214529,
0.0044409372,
0.0222382415,
0.0427163653,
-0.0092485202,
-0.0409033895,
-0.0552933067,
0.0022514251,
0.0023010601,
-0.0777514353,
-0.0437108316,
-0.0615185574,
0.0333567075,
0.0041464446,
-0.005214144,
0.0178733561,
0.0038280969,
0.0131145334,
0.0058683702,
0.0932639688,
-0.0450109579,
0.0217661485,
0.0133265527,
0.0025759798,
0.0232798606,
0.0315889567,
0.0719968528,
0.020405449,
0.0035907289,
-0.0266690422,
-0.0183247402,
0.0441409275,
0.0036198271,
-0.0288466867,
-0.0033547906,
-0.0063092723,
-0.0165689737,
0.0167464949,
0.0714987814,
0.0218910519,
-0.0573170483,
0.0183262955,
0.0560968332,
0.016266644,
0.0534561053,
0.0233909097,
0.0773583502,
0.066882804,
0.0077387108,
-0.0462085679,
-0.033832252,
0.0026849257,
-0.0146937491,
0.0238645431,
0.0630177259,
0.0041922666,
-0.023518011,
0.0004017321,
-0.0169593152,
-0.01370217,
-0.0263504703,
0.0077262819,
0.0275963023,
-0.0151192555,
-0.0454001613,
0.0753901228,
0.0216142796,
-0.0721781701,
0.016275622,
-0.0097456537,
0.0126217119,
0.0882246047,
0.0319113694,
-0.0533527248,
-0.0092346035,
-0.0596045405,
-0.0123271141,
0.0321199521,
-0.0050949566,
-0.0164067093,
0.0543806888,
-0.0793447569,
-0.0151444515,
0.0073033492,
-0.0075066546,
0.0438165292,
-0.0256699584,
0.0527520925,
0.0203524362,
-0.0536543652,
0.0261885393,
0.0103294589,
-0.0265532155,
-0.0417471826,
-0.0010869042,
0.0065309247,
0.0738084987,
0.0498765446,
-0.0346851274,
-0.0004260165,
0.0388813168,
-0.0437386185,
-0.0171493478,
0.0231434461,
-0.0675883144,
-0.0409339853,
0.0114349136,
-0.0153069608,
0.0294779446,
0.0333545171,
-0.0147119183,
-0.1021566167,
0.0293824971,
-0.0445533842,
0.0508435667,
-0.0461978614,
0.0150664141,
0.0469538197,
0.0130200768,
0.0348702185,
0.0124075962,
0.0003325172,
0.0119320536,
0.0861889422,
0.0329565778,
0.0258319173,
-0.0321639217,
-0.0185835958,
0.0144481678,
0.002311809,
0.0319780037,
0.0000572033,
0.0131519353,
-0.0048220884,
0.0003029988,
-0.1045883149,
0.0143578332,
-0.037678685,
0.0151943676,
0.0402198322,
0.0350310542,
-0.01158108,
0.0082148276,
-0.032055676,
-0.0122168958,
-0.0103646927,
-0.0149268033,
-0.0401356034,
0.00821428,
-0.0463637114,
-0.0295354854,
0.0455813594,
0.0095442403,
-0.0029112021,
-0.0114995698,
-0.0047843624,
-0.0441366322,
0.0107035497,
0.0642934218,
0.0608176254,
-0.0277040154,
-0.0113967089,
-0.0120967757,
-0.0161887668,
0.0248295199,
0.0012088794,
0.0147811668,
-0.0299242586,
0.0122354282,
-0.0104896436,
-0.0769161582,
0.0386296064,
0.016178485,
0.040656127,
-0.0230388977,
-0.0226965714,
-0.0437631533,
0.0323762447,
0.0329326913,
0.0364237465,
-0.0376884043,
-0.044726871,
0.0220004022,
-0.0534800701,
-0.0015389438,
-0.0231647752,
-0.0265960582,
-0.0005843894,
-0.0282605272,
-0.0206273589,
0.0069519412,
-0.0848272517,
-0.0663601235,
-0.0531762168,
-0.0483743511,
-0.0070832614,
0.0282763094,
0.0288014319,
0.0044458928,
-0.0356664248,
-0.0282521416,
-0.0242807437,
0.0487486012,
0.0209824461,
-0.0310581625,
0.034203019,
-0.0333205387,
0.0236640368,
-0.017669037,
-0.0350084417,
-0.0580346026,
-0.0445443019,
-0.0142912995,
0.0168015603,
-0.0059449612,
-0.0297679771,
-0.0272577778,
0.0086313449,
-0.0017999031,
0.0914310589,
0.0367517881,
0.0090850908,
-0.0435483865,
0.0380890593,
0.0179354735,
0.0250581577,
-0.006545472,
-0.0030041912,
0.0704154819,
0.0362497047,
0.0601607896,
0.0001055155,
-0.0465016142,
0.0268072635,
0.0471186973,
0.0080275023,
-0.0219361689,
0.0286256466,
0.0428138897,
-0.0456114896,
0.0157340504,
0.1122957766,
0.0064661382,
-0.0041733263,
-0.0104328701,
0.0246807337,
0.0572000667,
0.019419482,
0.0164132603,
-0.079814449,
-0.0485479869,
0.0256918371,
0.0703876913,
-0.0230864193,
0.0146572748,
-0.029866647,
-0.1010739803,
0.0475119501,
-0.008974391,
-0.0462302119,
-0.0065367795,
-0.0532653891,
-0.0220265556,
-0.0160343945,
0.0138329063,
0.0086020278,
-0.0456833281,
-0.0054012225,
0.0485749319,
-0.0560952164,
-0.0456687734,
0.0140185347,
-0.0263447445,
0.1014193594,
-0.0116089052,
0.061437875,
-0.0075743604,
0.0104462281,
0.0414042994,
-0.0330091901,
-0.0055965669,
-0.0132210199,
0.0479218103,
-0.002122866,
0.0093465149,
0.045959007,
0.0632397383,
-0.0163016487,
-0.027144311,
0.0070921462,
0.060435202,
-0.0176372193,
0.0149497697,
-0.0028135921,
0.0302081387,
0.0155904349,
0.0349530876,
0.0447141565,
-0.0232845712,
-0.0188531466,
0.0225667395,
0.0273289755,
-0.009574783,
0.0123361498,
-0.0090757646,
-0.0188845228,
-0.0459466316,
-0.033887133,
-0.0460235551,
0.0353617296,
0.0285134204,
-0.0001049615,
0.005603516,
-0.0252325833,
0.0015482508,
-0.0491577201,
0.01531127,
0.0008187944,
0.0233988147,
-0.0367411263,
-0.0321077481,
0.0262463894,
-0.0929848775,
-0.0364532359,
0.0210683104,
-0.0609209016,
-0.0682429075,
0.0292508844,
-0.0098887486,
0.0188421458,
0.0872638971,
-0.0294961128,
-0.0285728946,
0.0676969737,
0.032977283,
-0.0630453005,
0.0337635167,
0.0553131998,
0.0136570334,
0.0079461401,
0.0044197151,
-0.0467521697,
0.0470147282,
0.0044164658,
-0.0007013303,
-0.0154739907,
-0.07523112,
0.0107348952,
0.0543790832,
0.040740665,
0.0006024788,
0.0348289125,
-0.0822931156,
0.0512935966,
-0.0107359784,
0.0551485196,
-0.0639901161,
0.0136921117,
-0.0009783562,
0.0117299119,
-0.0613201074,
0.0213861018,
-0.0243053474,
-0.00324996,
-0.0239663944,
0.039611157,
-0.0021252821,
0.0263821781,
0.0269371588,
-0.0244037565,
-0.0264715943,
0.0102712829,
0.0220772345,
0.025652241,
-0.0231720749,
0.0342109688,
0.0003242467,
-0.014201602,
0.0021969955,
0.0248403661,
-0.0930605754,
-0.0551309995,
-0.0638634413,
0.0066075358,
0.0147330221,
-0.0126881879,
0.0681830347,
-0.0263936091,
0.0277963858,
-0.0218444634,
0.0281218328,
-0.0060862657,
-0.0238016285,
0.0080389958,
0.0118486946,
-0.0194661561,
0.0173903052,
0.0369587317,
0.0366076045,
0.0718705133,
-0.0429283455,
0.0420581736,
-0.0277776681,
-0.016744785,
-0.012327726,
0.0141547127,
-0.040294569,
-0.0104865264,
-0.0173577331,
-0.0542646796,
0.0331705362,
0.0069520604,
0.0003016199,
-0.0288930945,
0.0250624642,
-0.0013016313,
-0.0259130057,
0.014472005,
0.0031980546,
-0.0323234908,
0.025285406,
-0.0166145656,
-0.004617231,
-7.024499305e-33,
-0.0235833861,
0.0394397601,
0.0415264107,
0.0062035038,
-0.0510281622,
0.0072507998,
-0.0243523102,
-0.0069495258,
0.0259462353,
-0.0173594616,
-0.0225215033,
0.0188541394,
0.0204433091,
0.0279916674,
-0.0204561874,
0.0022092594,
0.1033394411,
-0.0165008754,
0.0060795159,
0.02497386,
0.0473955087,
0.0229696147,
0.0290542077,
-0.0724259466,
-0.0528877117,
0.0060071396,
-0.0034383421,
-0.0297439359,
0.0148945404,
0.0234494489,
-0.0207223315,
0.0409671552,
-0.0034415112,
-0.0381210335,
-0.0333049186,
0.0138807334,
-0.1046764255,
-0.0309433229,
0.0132073751,
0.0135834934,
0.0029386177,
0.0144803664,
0.0331269279,
-0.0031839306,
0.0079583405,
0.0072923326,
0.0320496932,
-0.0101612853,
0.0004163675,
-0.0611585379,
-0.0327838026,
0.0224893652,
-0.0311463084,
0.0109508187,
0.0441085435,
0.0822925493,
0.003920855,
0.0172212142,
-0.094596535,
0.0117492685,
-0.0368447788,
-0.0020704172,
0.0335413776,
0.0171719845,
-0.0161418468,
0.0437589623,
0.0628475174,
-0.0476056337,
-0.0370586738,
-0.0009032112,
0.0435384996,
0.0257615075,
0.0184657257,
0.0094299093,
0.0448755138,
-0.0403830931,
-0.0418949723,
0.0112815127,
0.0067850356,
-0.0015525991,
0.0023312019,
0.0294853691,
-0.049348332,
0.006257914,
-0.0829575732,
-0.0091374591,
-0.0426652431,
0.0083299512,
0.0753213689,
0.042076312,
-0.0094740307,
-0.0379261337,
0.0220141411,
-0.0058286535,
0.018475486,
-0.0386624411,
-0.0096382443,
-0.0146970162,
-0.0223520137,
0.0436562076,
-0.0663109794,
-0.0524008386,
0.0760094896,
0.0199624673,
0.0175061226,
-0.0445972979,
-0.0124256071,
0.0651239827,
-0.0754220486,
0.0125523843,
-0.0396415405,
0.0466059446,
-0.0236659423,
0.0067998548,
0.0504473001,
-0.0090496084,
0.0156061044,
0.0411154777,
-0.0164696276,
0.0157009009,
-0.0273117367,
-0.0323326476,
0.0239435993,
0.0299232919,
-0.031816151,
0.0152069032,
0.0083293747,
-0.0328006521,
0.0237571504,
-0.0553625897,
-0.0052053784,
0.0487778634,
3.105e-7,
-0.0138373598,
-0.0246109441,
0.013137131,
0.0022733004,
0.0180870239,
0.0184231289,
-0.0104315607,
0.0272556189,
-0.0003370785,
0.0180987753,
0.0262317713,
0.0059189261,
0.050234735,
0.0200233795,
-0.0959540829,
-0.0058670002,
-0.0487178005,
-0.0110227792,
-0.0171353035,
-0.0004654719,
0.0537978932,
0.0844527334,
-0.0108306753,
-0.0295375474,
0.0308757182,
0.000693665,
0.0175571144,
-0.0220225304,
0.000516165,
-0.0187013689,
0.0443124883,
0.0412579067,
-0.0029602086,
0.0204363652,
-0.0564133935,
0.0334765539,
0.0136209149,
0.0478385612,
-0.0188265033,
-0.0403193608,
0.0156097468,
-0.0198352635,
-0.02731812,
0.0043736808,
0.071972996,
-0.002633526,
0.0123336446,
-0.0011017399,
-0.0759963319,
0.0032318868,
-0.015314199,
-0.0014321329,
0.0198945366,
0.0187560115,
0.0058197579,
-0.0283842124,
0.0102546038,
-0.0809447169,
0.0263027623,
-0.008696001,
-0.0699142665,
-0.0180386249,
-0.0396400727,
0.0167227034,
0.0759027228,
-0.0115983635,
-0.0381907076,
2.7660817e-34,
0.0346780345,
-0.0166062601,
0.0060614208,
0.0071994094,
0.0058875536,
-0.0231412388,
0.0342600606,
-0.0169582665,
0.0178422164,
-0.0828297287,
-0.0562253222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05364v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05364v3 | Universal Multi-modal Entity Alignment via Iteratively Fusing Modality Similarity Paths | 2023-10-09T02:50:54 | 2023-10-13T09:47:08 | Bolin Zhu, Xiaoze Liu, Xin Mao, Zhuo Chen, Lingbing Guo, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The objective of Entity Alignment (EA) is to identify equivalent entity pairs
from multiple Knowledge Graphs (KGs) and create a more comprehensive and
unified KG. The majority of EA methods have primarily focused on the structural
modality of KGs, lacking exploration of multi-modal information. A few
multi-modal EA methods have made good attempts in this field. Still, they have
two shortcomings: (1) inconsistent and inefficient modality modeling that
designs complex and distinct models for each modality; (2) ineffective modality
fusion due to the heterogeneous nature of modalities in EA. To tackle these
challenges, we propose PathFusion, consisting of two main components: (1) MSP,
a unified modeling approach that simplifies the alignment process by
constructing paths connecting entities and modality nodes to represent multiple
modalities; (2) IRF, an iterative fusion method that effectively combines
information from different modalities using the path as an information carrier.
Experimental results on real-world datasets demonstrate the superiority of
PathFusion over state-of-the-art methods, with 22.4%-28.9% absolute improvement
on Hits@1, and 0.194-0.245 absolute improvement on MRR. | [
0.0058027152,
0.0453310311,
0.0054053934,
0.0026580042,
-0.039081905,
0.0108357864,
-0.0075585563,
-0.0344432704,
-0.0127256876,
-0.0197137501,
0.0054461481,
0.0333254449,
0.0045737526,
-0.0211426802,
0.0151957106,
0.0011814479,
0.0413893126,
0.0465269983,
-0.0534433909,
0.0173500329,
0.0333898813,
0.0484997816,
-0.0436107293,
0.0161063503,
-0.037651062,
-0.0107186222,
-0.0278653204,
0.0255445335,
0.0818261355,
-0.019070968,
-0.0102818906,
0.0373672955,
0.0132399835,
0.0274984464,
0.0000019637,
-0.0467638746,
-0.0463046059,
0.0377051122,
-0.0319813788,
-0.0515099913,
-0.002693794,
-0.0037594391,
0.0339330472,
0.0119084585,
0.0236999337,
-0.0212380476,
0.0591093525,
0.041559685,
0.020888254,
0.036363896,
-0.0353093557,
0.0041423258,
0.0252554305,
0.0174806342,
-0.0106410813,
-0.0275975,
0.0308627244,
0.0324500315,
-0.0215501338,
-0.0286129136,
0.0134761995,
0.0374466144,
-0.0416992195,
0.0164457466,
0.0069379113,
0.0148896379,
0.0653314665,
0.0286322292,
-0.0256447922,
0.097649999,
0.0201120209,
-0.0099044275,
0.0436953232,
0.0211377069,
-0.0090982392,
0.0347436108,
-0.0073035932,
-0.0422337502,
-0.0499544106,
0.0002150082,
-0.0340587869,
-0.023582913,
0.0365277752,
-0.0216938145,
-0.0217675399,
-0.0141336629,
0.0314184316,
-0.0101296399,
-0.0085460851,
-0.0176409334,
0.0361843221,
-0.0559145547,
-0.001689784,
0.013321951,
-0.0354739428,
0.0077939969,
-0.0527997091,
0.012764209,
0.027365353,
-0.0094398893,
-0.0082053263,
0.0435405374,
0.008804216,
0.0512926839,
-0.0158746019,
-0.0299299881,
-0.0231919531,
0.0111644082,
-0.0249816831,
-0.053755533,
-0.100759387,
0.0459705293,
0.0316571482,
0.0039343829,
-0.0215250496,
-0.0192539673,
-0.0504598692,
0.0388473645,
-0.0335565284,
0.0355129912,
0.0074410639,
-0.0054317098,
0.03873441,
0.0033469943,
-0.0490437485,
0.0353362449,
-0.0244239587,
0.0247364696,
-0.0298517402,
-0.0063859182,
0.0319845155,
0.0034547995,
0.0306107886,
-0.0408110805,
0.0140951071,
0.0588691309,
-0.0028930267,
-0.025743993,
-0.0660269111,
-0.0640640184,
0.0015674237,
-0.036225155,
-0.0160762742,
-0.0351210944,
0.0959437415,
0.0171790253,
-0.0130134216,
-0.0290269312,
0.0084134489,
-0.0259000305,
-0.0320455395,
0.0681413338,
-0.0360900611,
0.0535829104,
0.0209642518,
-0.0246385299,
0.007099092,
0.0004663376,
-0.0054633189,
-0.0609311312,
0.0037185212,
-0.0044635669,
-0.0304002371,
0.0326113664,
0.028576998,
0.0075318939,
0.042275805,
0.0222053695,
-0.0157289747,
0.0306934286,
0.0569577105,
0.0020396481,
-0.0118851718,
-0.0039499924,
0.0177711938,
-0.0191771146,
0.0485158525,
0.0222058333,
0.0277999546,
-0.005388557,
-0.0123696215,
-0.0316545628,
-0.0494207218,
-0.0032216483,
-0.0717760026,
0.0067167161,
0.0337382331,
0.0823332369,
-0.0136308623,
0.048442848,
0.0134008685,
-0.002537179,
0.0062598265,
-0.0001290303,
0.0148645826,
-0.0611329712,
-0.0226483848,
0.0789817795,
0.0429169498,
-0.0249448512,
-0.0312544927,
0.0217008479,
-0.0538482592,
0.0408695713,
0.0265975688,
-0.0145817585,
-0.06517791,
0.0049035079,
-0.0679959655,
-0.0010098225,
-0.0052801222,
-0.0238765031,
-0.0062856483,
-0.0297864154,
-0.067599833,
0.0390395969,
-0.0171848089,
0.0230726637,
0.0079286341,
0.0292368848,
0.0015544817,
-0.0936043039,
0.0547425561,
0.0233972501,
-0.0120151192,
0.0605663881,
-0.0284234248,
0.0392885022,
0.0239560623,
0.0427193493,
0.0049887998,
0.0027011503,
0.0241682958,
0.0132236965,
-0.0147975935,
0.0406715684,
0.0016212781,
0.0004437877,
0.0943150669,
-0.0257382505,
-0.046400737,
-0.016050091,
-0.0164370332,
-0.0473534837,
-0.0474379212,
-0.0054366724,
0.0254054945,
0.0153311417,
0.044395078,
0.0095763756,
-0.0314626433,
-0.0047654985,
0.0726734921,
0.0083836541,
0.025470607,
0.0206027143,
-0.0181199796,
0.0564549826,
-0.0047626682,
-0.0053602611,
-0.0483849905,
-0.0288970992,
0.0193946064,
-0.000218912,
-0.0657088608,
-0.0692688525,
0.0007545226,
-0.1560810506,
0.0202771947,
0.0627796426,
0.0368307233,
0.0163144097,
0.0243180189,
-0.0067786728,
0.0170658622,
-0.014922874,
0.0147563834,
0.0007428818,
-0.0112635428,
0.0130831134,
-0.01178768,
-0.0504310876,
-0.0164870638,
0.0079320837,
-0.0712599531,
0.0190956127,
0.0025759072,
-0.0271989517,
-0.0217844229,
0.0107660387,
-0.0771587193,
0.0191499405,
-0.0021185991,
0.032338582,
-0.0291552898,
0.0544347577,
0.0630865768,
-0.0177638251,
-0.019586781,
-0.0252792183,
-0.0130591448,
-0.0326187201,
-0.0482602529,
0.0116466023,
0.0133874482,
0.031866543,
-0.0127086099,
-0.034914989,
-0.0065739024,
0.0100279152,
0.0347799435,
0.012227525,
-0.0041586128,
-0.0291636512,
0.058262974,
0.0078964662,
-0.0077219899,
0.0321483947,
0.0419153459,
-0.0121623958,
-0.0303236861,
0.0414829589,
0.0649348721,
-0.047936745,
0.0568803139,
0.0162077565,
-0.0002429143,
-0.0333046727,
0.0238769744,
-0.0101304529,
0.0349724516,
0.0128477719,
-0.0194442831,
-0.0108362185,
0.0210606419,
0.0521523133,
-0.0149491662,
0.0716098845,
-0.0124105969,
0.0677965879,
-0.0027668474,
-0.0404736325,
-0.0320734978,
0.005638977,
-0.0042535816,
0.0244558547,
0.0106295478,
-0.0335109495,
-0.0778878033,
0.0334659554,
0.0315735899,
-0.0363199376,
0.0287476555,
-0.0278552193,
-0.0192343518,
0.0514623858,
0.0329727568,
0.0232755914,
0.004760846,
0.0368874669,
-0.0039633238,
0.028283162,
0.0208425019,
0.0153847961,
-0.0063815457,
-0.0303402878,
-0.0089188032,
-0.0473469384,
0.0243767891,
0.0089387316,
0.0519517027,
0.0060696602,
0.045629397,
0.0718591586,
0.0208949111,
0.0048472146,
-0.0187426414,
0.0313466154,
-0.0139652286,
0.0148514844,
-0.0087980917,
-0.0785141438,
-0.0480160229,
0.0003181613,
0.0075806091,
0.0079004476,
-0.0759852231,
0.0433073863,
-0.063574709,
-0.0186933,
-0.0047632391,
-0.032692153,
-0.0433465987,
-0.0470682159,
0.0541214533,
-0.018407071,
-0.0182735063,
-0.0161051303,
-0.018733358,
-0.0358518846,
-0.0013483814,
0.0688002408,
-0.0318480469,
0.0095564313,
-0.0894306675,
0.059621796,
-0.0298617501,
0.0420497395,
0.028378522,
-0.0167189725,
-0.0240542889,
-0.0017855992,
-0.0198349021,
0.0008906063,
0.0147700422,
-0.0535919815,
-0.0054305154,
-0.0772935227,
0.0115128858,
-0.0302796103,
-0.0089614,
-0.0088950489,
0.0724429414,
0.0073876875,
0.0434799232,
-0.0309764799,
-0.0289170444,
-0.0101638511,
0.0703169852,
-0.0391302966,
-0.0064831134,
0.018897431,
0.0146662332,
0.0352632888,
0.0151882144,
-0.0015157693,
0.0526564009,
-0.0648856312,
-0.0087686973,
-0.0171443392,
-0.0383647941,
0.018136682,
0.0133127552,
0.0157777946,
0.0186167918,
0.0138522675,
-0.0313878655,
-0.0774461702,
0.0108004203,
-0.0603218824,
0.0197546836,
-0.0286893714,
0.0244250223,
-0.0035881221,
-0.010122329,
-0.0453162193,
0.0089431675,
-0.0658400655,
-0.066950202,
-0.0453667343,
-0.0346113108,
0.0016765633,
0.04538396,
0.0116942711,
0.0395939387,
0.0280194655,
0.0201892313,
-0.0379492454,
-0.0166647844,
-0.0273245145,
0.0108066024,
-0.0199325606,
0.0063384296,
-0.0685360283,
-0.01964611,
0.0037899448,
0.0414694212,
-0.0355943814,
-0.0807622895,
0.0214524008,
0.0446460061,
0.0013765242,
0.0094904359,
-0.0193524808,
-0.0535251647,
-0.0093867779,
0.0135429017,
-0.0136809507,
0.0144790802,
0.0135654639,
0.0083538899,
0.0102650002,
0.0427779332,
0.0410118289,
0.0228019785,
0.0135222953,
-0.0292419977,
-0.0159430504,
0.0050940574,
0.0151884342,
-0.0087422002,
-0.0497887284,
-0.0120119462,
0.0275828466,
0.0314159542,
-0.0039400058,
-0.0570661873,
0.0435850956,
0.0231982302,
0.0037490863,
-0.039925009,
0.0242067259,
0.0087014399,
0.0328400321,
-0.0058591431,
0.0546585657,
0.0984259024,
0.0394107737,
0.0669455454,
0.0029362987,
-0.0071004098,
-0.0028418642,
0.0140814008,
-0.0074953027,
0.0335224494,
0.0540914796,
0.0150674749,
0.0072430791,
-0.0112372702,
0.0184198637,
-0.0525639839,
0.0862838104,
-0.0428547524,
-0.081858404,
-0.0620235279,
-0.0242935475,
0.0652901009,
0.0044437046,
-0.023024559,
-0.0377965383,
-0.0314893387,
-0.0218760148,
0.057649754,
0.0171788223,
-0.0557699166,
0.0174245033,
0.0044079502,
0.0012591544,
0.0208906699,
-0.0535949133,
0.0072180582,
-0.0173285194,
-0.0573686734,
-0.0098994188,
-0.0002164308,
-5.918646015e-33,
-0.0259548984,
-0.0218655784,
0.0291757882,
-0.0458682403,
-0.0384230502,
0.0016879652,
0.0160998497,
-0.0172681157,
-0.0429190733,
-0.0079875365,
0.0147189749,
-0.0174351428,
-0.0000375286,
-0.0168053228,
-0.0198230986,
-0.0060174381,
0.032189209,
0.0572462678,
-0.0126175145,
-0.0147375921,
0.0230889004,
-0.0059142839,
0.0405346863,
-0.107273683,
0.0473272242,
-0.0037008836,
-0.0430666991,
0.0300487299,
0.0202657133,
0.0633575097,
-0.0053884191,
0.0172243193,
0.0250330791,
0.0180410687,
0.0107250707,
-0.020967748,
-0.1060692593,
0.0049110758,
0.0032844786,
0.0031758409,
-0.0015723943,
-0.0126298433,
0.035989318,
-0.0193715077,
0.0431769826,
-0.0421749465,
0.0616216771,
0.0052101915,
-0.0021621077,
-0.0359004997,
-0.044847887,
0.0369212888,
-0.0104778819,
-0.0094321733,
-0.009257012,
0.0000023236,
0.0637043417,
-0.0406462811,
-0.1065527797,
0.0012405424,
-0.0179069098,
-0.0189750716,
0.0606631823,
0.0197899882,
0.0186612494,
0.0330297016,
-0.0038187772,
-0.0837755874,
0.0082696304,
0.0257842913,
-0.0008722998,
0.0490131564,
-0.0252093282,
0.0879097283,
-0.046921026,
0.0180375054,
-0.0678650215,
0.069778055,
-0.007505286,
0.0012423139,
-0.0367609337,
0.0091953129,
-0.0530912951,
0.0085075609,
-0.0495942347,
-0.0098394109,
-0.0351089239,
-0.0213081129,
0.022486398,
-0.0099783335,
-0.0133166704,
0.0492915809,
0.019007314,
-0.0204835963,
-0.0506980494,
0.0326809473,
0.0053372132,
0.0293843821,
-0.0290217418,
-0.0102835456,
-0.0249220021,
-0.0598549992,
0.049516242,
-0.0445133708,
0.0287146978,
0.0251905676,
0.0035590669,
-0.0319929682,
-0.0501961857,
0.0141705796,
-0.0061916918,
-0.0541534424,
-0.075884901,
-0.0340068154,
0.060445074,
0.0107267722,
0.0220537297,
-0.0129648456,
0.1051341593,
0.0616725646,
-0.0151035152,
-0.023868598,
0.0092132101,
0.032453835,
0.0300574657,
0.0261224527,
-0.027534483,
-0.0785142705,
-0.0018984224,
-0.0327204727,
0.0032292174,
0.0175325722,
2.725e-7,
0.0241222344,
-0.0167512335,
0.0419030525,
-0.0054987399,
-0.0179799963,
0.0611348152,
0.011397549,
0.0306023657,
-0.0069686081,
-0.046468012,
0.0536122024,
-0.0235952623,
-0.0275287274,
0.0610813573,
-0.0070974045,
-0.0263493769,
0.0084084747,
-0.0113208918,
-0.0524721406,
0.0839394927,
0.0724454671,
0.0442732535,
0.0240082107,
0.0071117892,
0.0088679995,
-0.0188930798,
0.0314244553,
-0.0051038945,
-0.0142102763,
0.0595341511,
0.0191199575,
-0.0436427779,
0.0044264938,
0.0418749712,
0.0172482487,
0.0381352454,
0.0178030357,
0.045217447,
-0.0399928614,
-0.0154699404,
-0.0474371463,
-0.0430045836,
-0.0015196116,
-0.0276123956,
0.0380092226,
0.0065899417,
0.0020927461,
-0.007715275,
-0.0415744595,
0.0397343189,
-0.0169274081,
0.0671797544,
-0.0319154523,
0.0224905461,
0.0040977001,
0.0190090369,
-0.0312305596,
-0.0551984049,
0.021746669,
0.0118577983,
-0.027261626,
-0.0053311037,
0.0254919305,
-0.0444146171,
0.0655928403,
-0.0977573767,
-0.0210795421,
2.343038732e-34,
-0.0603484325,
0.0215157457,
0.0148526635,
-0.021239616,
0.0543443933,
-0.0418312885,
-0.0545750819,
-0.0010119007,
-0.0400371365,
-0.059134312,
0.0013264554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05352v1 | A Glance is Enough: Extract Target Sentence By Looking at A keyword | 2023-10-09T02:28:19 | 2023-10-09T02:28:19 | Ying Shi, Dong Wang, Lantian Li, Jiqing Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper investigates the possibility of extracting a target sentence from
multi-talker speech using only a keyword as input. For example, in social
security applications, the keyword might be "help", and the goal is to identify
what the person who called for help is articulating while ignoring other
speakers. To address this problem, we propose using the Transformer
architecture to embed both the keyword and the speech utterance and then rely
on the cross-attention mechanism to select the correct content from the
concatenated or overlapping speech. Experimental results on Librispeech
demonstrate that our proposed method can effectively extract target sentences
from very noisy and mixed speech (SNR=-3dB), achieving a phone error rate (PER)
of 26\%, compared to the baseline system's PER of 96%. | [
0.0269607604,
-0.0135281412,
0.0219790749,
0.0279573165,
-0.0563919581,
-0.0418755151,
0.0187789593,
-0.0155070331,
-0.014899699,
-0.0552533865,
-0.0418420471,
-0.0140059208,
0.0292555336,
0.0017985601,
-0.0008550764,
-0.0341983475,
0.046517849,
-0.0193810351,
-0.0063806185,
0.0323329829,
0.0197480097,
-0.0039667725,
0.0007902594,
0.0260961354,
-0.0499927737,
0.0438644662,
-0.0330187604,
-0.0026174288,
0.0244456585,
0.0153887589,
0.0072408882,
-0.0224699639,
-0.0012728194,
0.0182231907,
0.00000178,
0.010674349,
-0.0288178921,
0.0093304813,
-0.0255041365,
-0.02871342,
0.0025073641,
-0.0123210698,
-0.0407655239,
0.0229914077,
0.0177426934,
0.0168707129,
0.0277023762,
0.0999166742,
0.0428630784,
0.0246919561,
-0.0164753273,
-0.0132808704,
0.047973983,
-0.0135210538,
-0.0065929783,
-0.0817687586,
-0.0136872679,
-0.0464990027,
0.0360461734,
-0.0088245645,
0.0223222207,
0.0982273519,
0.0047405795,
0.0164704192,
0.0041203205,
0.0110574542,
-0.0485736579,
-0.0584840514,
-0.0488347374,
0.0734036565,
-0.04852245,
0.0660493597,
0.0370055027,
-0.0061175944,
0.0156175327,
0.0018371539,
-0.0187463835,
-0.0179210752,
-0.0236286223,
-0.0287084691,
-0.0546308681,
0.0238993298,
0.0110645108,
-0.0269145984,
-0.0681029633,
0.0223444309,
0.0086698784,
-0.034763515,
0.0376088582,
0.0207519494,
0.0078210272,
0.0043255812,
0.080238454,
-0.0032242551,
-0.0323401652,
-0.002966909,
-0.0341799818,
-0.0706566349,
-0.023907505,
-0.0344277956,
0.0188510641,
0.0018281648,
-0.0832841545,
0.0338130035,
0.0301996823,
-0.0024607577,
-0.0464655422,
-0.0160032958,
-0.0234228969,
-0.0200195927,
0.0188644379,
0.0171681028,
-0.0495350808,
0.0591264293,
-0.0566303059,
-0.0607713647,
-0.0231473036,
-0.0034755284,
-0.0195263717,
-0.0193633828,
0.0020653517,
0.0154885938,
-0.0131852226,
-0.0066682934,
0.0533726104,
0.025698524,
0.0060428674,
0.025440082,
0.034530092,
-0.1034736261,
-0.032440003,
0.044018425,
0.0591910109,
-0.0061338525,
-0.0273503177,
0.0593906678,
-0.0228515062,
-0.0773773268,
-0.0051218388,
-0.0259170234,
-0.0567059293,
-0.0193169732,
0.0201926082,
-0.0374966711,
0.0310313795,
-0.0165748466,
-0.0062513524,
0.0273627322,
0.042445343,
0.0146806529,
-0.0444995165,
0.0442684554,
-0.0057655973,
-0.0026829578,
0.0188730564,
0.0199206322,
-0.000416861,
0.0332511812,
0.0407335982,
0.0127948578,
0.0492316149,
-0.0178858042,
0.0288188998,
0.0530999489,
0.0148474276,
-0.0134509485,
0.0366350748,
-0.0093584079,
-0.0364484116,
0.00886863,
-0.0128497807,
0.0555035435,
-0.027888529,
0.0069545433,
0.0424973629,
0.0640314594,
0.0364678577,
0.0242343564,
0.0072235214,
0.0634455904,
-0.045509439,
0.022780478,
0.0025554767,
0.0070860302,
-0.0504933521,
0.0035911056,
0.0385241546,
0.0067234486,
-0.0231240336,
-0.0099259224,
0.0255238786,
-0.0497463346,
-0.0367627069,
0.0365119725,
0.0528637394,
0.0141775059,
-0.0254887305,
0.1204581782,
0.0043004458,
-0.0661638826,
-0.0416840613,
-0.0193705428,
-0.0170013402,
0.0047852993,
-0.005502732,
-0.0229856484,
-0.0195631571,
-0.0336795412,
0.0011294469,
0.0566445738,
0.0129478276,
0.0238500293,
0.0632072687,
-0.0391625389,
-0.0124526825,
0.0451443009,
-0.0232858658,
0.0264079589,
-0.0016281636,
-0.0009553201,
0.0514724404,
0.0544039086,
0.0760752633,
-0.0112229884,
0.0363914557,
0.0117341401,
0.003025403,
0.0036707569,
0.0436487533,
0.0306091271,
-0.0286985785,
0.0231830366,
0.0383537263,
-0.039041169,
0.0088799736,
0.0280399509,
-0.0661910921,
0.0070098666,
-0.0071625705,
-0.0731465742,
-0.0121895839,
0.0741243064,
0.0298292097,
-0.0547140762,
0.0405016504,
-0.0867239237,
0.0520218126,
-0.0208752621,
0.0330871604,
0.054976169,
0.0393903218,
-0.0005602505,
0.0169309638,
0.0042240401,
0.0117442198,
-0.0119105922,
-0.0262437593,
-0.0202312097,
-0.0666618124,
-0.0166680813,
0.0099337846,
-0.0277086925,
0.0151966447,
0.0009050973,
-0.0074478644,
-0.0229613129,
-0.0419391505,
-0.0435453653,
-0.0112441797,
-0.0260790754,
-0.0042509092,
-0.029389983,
0.066854611,
0.0156686306,
-0.0242354106,
-0.0200530179,
-0.000737221,
0.0261586197,
-0.0177476723,
-0.034951888,
0.0162203833,
-0.0439588092,
-0.0330012329,
0.0128003983,
0.0333460905,
0.0191218723,
0.0068522268,
-0.0902340561,
-0.0377389044,
0.0094550382,
0.0530542471,
0.0316499807,
-0.0125040049,
0.0017099559,
0.0156812519,
0.0066949171,
0.0120482827,
0.0326196402,
0.0155173084,
-0.0130236698,
-0.045689214,
-0.0677974224,
-0.0243036281,
0.0322945304,
0.0109504852,
0.0355092958,
-0.0049438318,
0.0325482599,
0.0301696714,
0.0477637462,
0.026955381,
0.0543016903,
-0.0172148943,
-0.0792014748,
0.0236212462,
-0.0311216619,
-0.0375172719,
0.0080125378,
-0.0673149973,
-0.0049793948,
-0.0078732893,
-0.0155392373,
0.0354889333,
-0.0376023464,
-0.0595082752,
-0.0139195435,
-0.030828245,
0.0085286982,
0.0085590007,
-0.057664264,
-0.0052898778,
0.000105815,
-0.0611712746,
-0.0084637441,
-0.0110101774,
-0.0266126953,
-0.054866273,
0.0833249539,
-0.0131479651,
-0.0098458026,
-0.0139525002,
-0.0508921407,
-0.025985714,
-0.0329543166,
-0.0638449341,
-0.0107374825,
0.0197531525,
-0.0111768348,
-0.0580020212,
0.0213003978,
0.0513170213,
0.0371757708,
0.0057911789,
0.0277960654,
-0.0289062317,
0.0758704916,
0.0282422993,
0.0505000465,
0.0004818675,
-0.0158756077,
0.0174668971,
0.0548522137,
0.0648721904,
0.0400710739,
0.0000394816,
-0.0203811321,
0.0396186188,
0.0054480485,
-0.0454537496,
0.0079307817,
0.0463625193,
-0.053383939,
0.0133795096,
0.067929633,
0.0023194528,
-0.0214162003,
-0.0235643405,
-0.0115739582,
-0.0494679995,
-0.0123847527,
0.0101258401,
-0.0435440689,
-0.0623605736,
0.028991295,
0.0156663563,
0.0251518786,
0.0459035449,
-0.0228067022,
-0.0514677279,
0.0337659307,
0.0169925075,
0.0023335116,
-0.0960962847,
0.0224821754,
0.0140171023,
0.0081714094,
0.0394346416,
-0.0014964683,
-0.010598653,
-0.0682335347,
-0.0368183553,
-0.0485650636,
-0.0296436027,
0.011922041,
-0.0188033152,
0.0184502713,
0.0518343858,
0.0067547415,
0.0106533067,
-0.0575490147,
0.0614414588,
-0.0254713912,
-0.0096647535,
0.0229352899,
0.0375585705,
-0.0483748652,
-0.0157005358,
-0.0068771495,
0.0208253004,
-0.0143100936,
0.0065587093,
0.0182085391,
0.0354864635,
0.0018443152,
0.0146048618,
0.0154757723,
0.0554658622,
0.0265389066,
0.041324053,
0.030389538,
-0.0257672612,
-0.0270298366,
0.0108288946,
0.0029443752,
-0.0558522567,
-0.0677582026,
0.0470616296,
0.0203855857,
-0.0805866048,
0.0138794314,
-0.0785807669,
0.0044840425,
0.0152463,
0.0004333092,
-0.0335837044,
0.0500542447,
0.0511392131,
-0.0102164149,
-0.0149398046,
-0.0175506528,
0.0465336442,
-0.0546369031,
-0.0036807852,
-0.002113454,
-0.0473137163,
-0.006010625,
0.0329014286,
-0.0620005131,
-0.0206745975,
0.0266348403,
-0.0085275266,
0.0205000248,
0.0528576188,
-0.0481851958,
-0.01279952,
0.047476206,
0.0085952478,
-0.0780772418,
0.0106291668,
0.0807844996,
-0.0190999862,
-0.0198211055,
0.0290974565,
-0.046893198,
0.0454328395,
-0.0063423743,
0.0023578128,
-0.1173356324,
-0.0516782776,
-0.0217634123,
0.0120839952,
0.0854646936,
0.0123347249,
0.0614599995,
0.0045984401,
0.0413374528,
0.034182813,
0.026069155,
-0.0633883178,
-0.0013640093,
-0.0408498161,
-0.0450201705,
0.0407320447,
0.0171730872,
-0.0493607931,
-0.0274974145,
-0.0255264416,
0.0477842279,
0.0062207826,
0.0124798762,
-0.0092976801,
-0.0286866501,
-0.0166063327,
0.0344774909,
0.0303495862,
0.0533692688,
0.0003158016,
0.037816193,
-0.0012424592,
-0.0382484235,
0.0373651385,
0.0390220657,
-0.0655544251,
0.0159663055,
-0.0099343602,
0.0153186908,
0.0110654095,
-0.0101873549,
0.0393891968,
0.0519757345,
0.0062390026,
-0.0072155655,
0.0786475167,
-0.0156127382,
-0.0194173548,
-0.0136364857,
-0.0109970868,
-0.0107168239,
-0.0099697625,
0.0239415597,
-0.0192809775,
-0.0317690857,
0.0084188189,
0.009258572,
-0.0986793786,
-0.0373299755,
0.0280945469,
0.0055370671,
-0.0270537585,
0.0006693174,
-0.0384958275,
0.0052910889,
0.041199442,
-0.0171318967,
0.0292126499,
-0.0225527529,
0.0252841432,
0.0047606854,
-0.0026540004,
-0.0225297157,
0.0080634253,
-0.0288693216,
0.0211834311,
0.0106185405,
0.0355371162,
-6.073621721e-33,
-0.046338696,
0.0115101133,
-0.0215034541,
0.030948719,
-0.0407905132,
0.0497765243,
-0.0155210616,
-0.0011641814,
-0.0110244472,
-0.0214705858,
-0.017469598,
0.0322945379,
0.0390295424,
0.0315139107,
-0.0084050046,
-0.0227327589,
0.0528946854,
0.0085409163,
0.0164520778,
0.0211126842,
0.0019107534,
0.0765977651,
0.0557401478,
-0.0291309152,
-0.0122142462,
0.0263633151,
0.0018832731,
-0.0482814759,
0.0150064537,
0.0156382769,
0.0074515031,
0.0176425222,
-0.0304625221,
-0.0501336232,
-0.0049169529,
0.0934118927,
-0.0572504513,
-0.0010248651,
-0.009695705,
0.0594832078,
-0.0313489661,
-0.0064237588,
0.0301787481,
0.0221784972,
0.0196547136,
-0.0275563654,
0.02136641,
-0.0060720542,
-0.0407146886,
-0.0286627486,
-0.0078537855,
0.0497272424,
0.0124991285,
-0.0549223386,
0.0601731353,
0.0789943635,
0.0007391364,
-0.0053189206,
-0.0455148891,
0.0288770031,
-0.0096618915,
0.0290636942,
-0.0099770976,
0.0547739863,
-0.028803939,
0.055990275,
0.0204655472,
-0.0832305998,
-0.0139816506,
-0.0347797312,
-0.0161117837,
0.0706701577,
0.0322836675,
0.013339472,
0.0112232938,
-0.0435760207,
-0.0313420556,
-0.0382485241,
0.0497593358,
0.0044026426,
0.0540320426,
0.021291906,
-0.043174047,
0.0298445355,
0.0141117927,
-0.020865811,
-0.0404280312,
0.0075738099,
0.0330194011,
0.0602797084,
-0.0195815489,
0.0383604988,
0.0690190718,
-0.0088523412,
0.0681963563,
-0.0295973476,
0.0052674054,
0.0134444544,
-0.0369085409,
0.0078651058,
-0.0738570616,
-0.0318530872,
0.0330641568,
0.0549455471,
-0.0000846231,
-0.0024041252,
0.0048473198,
0.0226407927,
-0.0670007914,
-0.0285702888,
-0.0020591929,
0.0242582168,
-0.033810921,
-0.0064470354,
0.0528111793,
-0.0015111974,
-0.0427821279,
0.0294579696,
-0.0433616117,
0.0195635948,
-0.0087995809,
0.0013587698,
0.0035095655,
0.047603745,
-0.0411520936,
0.0094420267,
-0.0361014083,
-0.0116147576,
0.0304331873,
-0.0207234006,
-0.0173530616,
0.0195606109,
2.698e-7,
-0.0492268205,
-0.0082969097,
0.0340623707,
-0.0056647933,
-0.005673734,
0.0357388221,
0.0362089202,
0.036760103,
-0.0150941545,
-0.0305665825,
-0.0027159948,
-0.0272614714,
0.0904305652,
-0.016352063,
-0.144709006,
-0.057995934,
-0.0431457646,
-0.0114234956,
0.0109553989,
-0.0040742974,
0.0565643422,
0.0784881413,
-0.0002885942,
-0.0065074447,
-0.0007376241,
-0.0002047723,
0.0164658017,
-0.0079959445,
-0.0273287315,
-0.0249099024,
0.032519225,
-0.0089120967,
-0.0553129651,
0.0257552173,
-0.0103390589,
0.0281157941,
0.0221049115,
0.0531452037,
-0.0164249856,
-0.0736514628,
-0.0349005386,
0.025546426,
-0.0479311906,
0.0451340303,
0.0346500538,
-0.0498699211,
-0.0160576347,
-0.0229844991,
-0.0432768315,
0.0146729359,
-0.044571463,
0.0036411204,
-0.022013789,
-0.0018660171,
0.0078711268,
-0.0304231495,
-0.021678729,
-0.0718919337,
0.0151716983,
0.0294552185,
-0.0310435332,
-0.0257643647,
-0.0506872647,
-0.0611168221,
0.0447526649,
-0.0307993442,
-0.0239434633,
1.811907107e-34,
0.035383191,
0.0060014157,
0.0154528422,
0.0387587063,
0.0020563868,
-0.0243003368,
0.0018353574,
0.0099151991,
0.010609718,
-0.0109299337,
-0.0212343689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05344v1 | SteerLM: Attribute Conditioned SFT as an (User-Steerable) Alternative to RLHF | 2023-10-09T02:11:21 | 2023-10-09T02:11:21 | Yi Dong, Zhilin Wang, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Xianchao Wu, Oleksii Kuchaiev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Model alignment with human preferences is an essential step in making Large
Language Models (LLMs) helpful and consistent with human values. It typically
consists of supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF) stages. However, RLHF faces inherent limitations stemming from
a complex training setup and its tendency to align the model with implicit
values that end users cannot control at run-time. Moreover, reward models in
RLHF stage commonly rely on single-dimensional feedback as opposed to explicit,
multifaceted signals that indicate attributes such as helpfulness, humor, and
toxicity. To address these limitations, we propose SteerLM, a supervised
fine-tuning method that empowers end-users to control responses during
inference. SteerLM conditions responses to conform to an explicitly defined
multi-dimensional set of attributes, thereby empowering a steerable AI capable
of generating helpful and high-quality responses while maintaining
customizability. Experiments show that SteerLM trained on open source datasets
generates responses that are preferred by human and automatic evaluators to
many state-of-the-art baselines trained with RLHF while being much easier to
train. Try SteerLM at https://huggingface.co/nvidia/SteerLM-llama2-13B | [
0.0451403819,
0.0676866993,
-0.0171942487,
0.0145119587,
-0.0088006249,
0.0130868237,
-0.0272564366,
-0.0164635777,
0.0263816789,
-0.0311045684,
-0.0713571608,
0.0113373296,
-0.0200796202,
0.0291155241,
0.0060119694,
-0.0594418719,
0.0452129282,
-0.0139738107,
0.042538017,
-0.0062051509,
0.0466608517,
0.0252872165,
0.0011727224,
0.0493038036,
0.0064118756,
-0.0008318117,
0.0257265735,
0.0113172159,
0.0226357803,
-0.014072285,
0.0504002571,
0.0752043128,
0.0139011042,
0.0205715373,
0.0000020873,
-0.0514625013,
0.0102066882,
-0.0127851786,
-0.0051152669,
-0.0080962367,
0.0628996715,
0.0285315346,
-0.0165947508,
0.0075151054,
-0.0398911647,
-0.0055336002,
0.0588057525,
0.0413296372,
0.0677840635,
0.0488932431,
0.0023631023,
-0.0261169542,
0.008148564,
-0.0150417751,
0.0094725192,
-0.0177786555,
0.0107244281,
-0.0327207595,
0.0024317158,
0.0177784394,
-0.0349996127,
0.0471448377,
0.0186617244,
0.0017252417,
0.0303450245,
0.0178007595,
-0.03724638,
-0.0145161049,
-0.0031111485,
0.1130291224,
-0.0236619916,
-0.0362636708,
-0.0120609617,
-0.0202404056,
0.0218116082,
-0.0107151391,
-0.0123511795,
-0.0237638317,
0.0060838782,
0.0170417558,
0.0261336602,
-0.0090737008,
0.0112522878,
0.0481883064,
0.0325710736,
0.0344290175,
0.00885271,
-0.0380331837,
0.0114587042,
0.0178868268,
-0.037430428,
-0.0141850729,
0.007240287,
-0.0070589003,
-0.064822033,
0.0089959251,
-0.0648419634,
-0.0159877539,
0.0284718126,
-0.0391460508,
0.0220011212,
0.0275802705,
-0.0195108633,
0.0426152945,
-0.0180880912,
0.0191118047,
-0.0233204309,
0.0349957198,
-0.0091682496,
0.0132572148,
-0.0143590514,
-0.0117882956,
-0.0333326384,
0.0077898847,
-0.0159718432,
0.0097887423,
-0.0515971594,
0.0195324142,
-0.0358021483,
0.0215172321,
0.0240338203,
0.0311985537,
-0.0427010916,
-0.0071426379,
-0.0409141257,
0.0595184751,
-0.0765143335,
0.013613374,
0.0000787253,
-0.0121109281,
0.0034375992,
0.0280134026,
0.0142092844,
-0.0493930541,
0.0357650444,
0.0733717084,
0.0054174531,
-0.0328018405,
-0.0282339938,
-0.0121987052,
-0.0251222625,
-0.0712806806,
-0.0146783348,
-0.0469295979,
0.0278850775,
0.0075592585,
-0.0013695115,
-0.0577063859,
-0.0087265726,
0.0283523221,
-0.0489028953,
0.062092822,
-0.0062477435,
-0.0072131176,
-0.0060460554,
-0.0172474105,
-0.011212064,
0.0529043935,
0.0217120033,
0.0342254154,
0.026200328,
-0.0338681974,
0.0132229151,
0.0373260267,
0.0344124697,
0.029606102,
-0.0527334549,
0.0033612801,
-0.0321670249,
0.0456560105,
0.0283773746,
0.0218147207,
-0.0141906673,
-0.0328089781,
0.0809352025,
0.0389850661,
0.0400843285,
0.0258886032,
0.0417155363,
0.0235778261,
-0.0217296258,
0.0032256725,
-0.0816548616,
0.0492777564,
-0.0674649104,
0.0006831698,
0.0032127814,
0.0319001973,
-0.0236022472,
-0.0536199585,
0.0131211979,
-0.0102750547,
0.0524053872,
0.0320141912,
0.0429251865,
0.0071549895,
-0.0295125749,
-0.0289757177,
0.0507922247,
-0.0298361853,
-0.0004849907,
-0.0450263917,
0.0746681839,
0.094303824,
0.050407663,
-0.029072294,
-0.0194491819,
-0.018108895,
0.0043709585,
0.0373800173,
0.0467881784,
-0.008120168,
-0.0040668002,
-0.0429552086,
-0.0057972651,
0.0243012272,
-0.0029973115,
0.0111698247,
0.0405191109,
0.0014617634,
-0.0234128591,
0.0096877245,
-0.0548520572,
0.0292366426,
0.0175348427,
-0.0212181192,
0.0052527324,
0.0289776269,
0.0187241994,
0.0037001697,
0.0035366702,
-0.0170740169,
-0.0089189485,
-0.0036904037,
-0.0308814496,
-0.011347075,
-0.0427766703,
-0.0023073973,
0.0029704152,
0.0017608374,
-0.0338705815,
0.0302029196,
-0.0225488208,
-0.0030370485,
0.0208422542,
-0.0397106335,
-0.0034326962,
-0.0321586654,
0.0079020998,
-0.0081219086,
0.0119308094,
-0.0560536347,
0.0422006883,
0.0153426491,
-0.0101047605,
-0.0167289805,
-0.0168672577,
-0.0121425344,
-0.033797998,
-0.0224277638,
0.0077541564,
0.0048926915,
0.0296605714,
0.0498051941,
0.0553727634,
-0.0447452031,
-0.0149006508,
-0.0329035334,
-0.0235330053,
-0.0255973171,
-0.015268527,
-0.007612342,
0.0077444618,
-0.0133994408,
-0.0219434518,
-0.0465803184,
-0.0078827972,
0.0112289805,
0.0268537197,
0.0343081951,
-0.0204610713,
-0.0301120076,
-0.0582194813,
-0.0156737436,
-0.0212580543,
-0.0035693115,
0.0069165309,
0.020945143,
-0.0528954901,
-0.0238845553,
-0.0323930606,
0.0340666622,
0.0180581957,
-0.0693157688,
0.0015798175,
-0.0117241153,
0.0150298523,
0.1056630164,
0.0196673404,
0.0046127392,
0.0446486585,
0.025764361,
-0.0798715428,
0.0272877421,
-0.0523552187,
-0.0180455036,
-0.0350081027,
0.0234262794,
0.0015390514,
0.079000935,
0.0211707707,
0.020602297,
-0.1227449328,
0.0509037375,
-0.0004698568,
-0.0423379615,
-0.0095233936,
0.0065386961,
-0.0263564736,
0.0240926575,
-0.0103304451,
-0.0455259681,
0.1408396363,
-0.0034019258,
-0.0214196686,
-0.0336031877,
0.0071850629,
-0.0191329103,
0.0098948441,
-0.0096619101,
0.0312058907,
0.0113577656,
0.0067099254,
-0.0439191051,
-0.0222172197,
0.0269274842,
-0.0298807565,
0.0547987819,
-0.0320694,
-0.0102154911,
0.000157719,
-0.0521848798,
-0.0293254238,
-0.0739568397,
-0.0196118876,
-0.0322211944,
-0.0147784175,
-0.0424095206,
-0.0067082723,
-0.0168458875,
0.0169591662,
0.0060733529,
-0.0458780117,
-0.0125735076,
0.0028748382,
-0.0174537487,
0.0927871093,
0.0306724664,
0.0053669857,
-0.0002869556,
0.0189739354,
0.0264545828,
-0.0082662152,
0.0028647492,
-0.0032083893,
0.030839039,
0.0505342185,
-0.0118640075,
0.0149661051,
0.0228883792,
0.0738927871,
-0.0394155867,
-0.0191750657,
0.1016390398,
0.0162949935,
-0.0598702207,
0.0163786635,
-0.0004839963,
0.0683329105,
0.0339974687,
0.0417119339,
-0.0880414546,
-0.0485580228,
-0.0189204551,
0.0506318286,
-0.0094898716,
-0.0185854435,
0.018993767,
-0.1130746529,
0.0400199629,
0.011062257,
-0.0722608268,
-0.0172518734,
-0.0186665691,
0.0152522149,
-0.0438596532,
0.0164386611,
-0.001127271,
-0.0029485156,
-0.0112264045,
-0.0108758733,
0.0186515693,
-0.0214472096,
0.0610063933,
-0.0287759099,
0.0686564445,
0.0679405332,
0.0294118356,
0.0081623551,
-0.0508022979,
-0.0337341614,
-0.0296766367,
-0.0008914364,
-0.0265280642,
0.0506462269,
-0.0339739807,
-0.0140109947,
-0.0367625207,
0.0757087842,
-0.0042044213,
0.0070593511,
-0.0034329391,
0.0632758886,
-0.004247908,
-0.0048095183,
-0.0232261773,
0.0082532838,
0.0123714563,
0.0743236318,
0.0322918259,
-0.125900805,
-0.0124414042,
-0.0021998384,
-0.0428710356,
-0.0318776704,
-0.0829782262,
0.0006747259,
-0.0186730586,
-0.0120715266,
-0.0729537085,
-0.0477808975,
0.0257744305,
0.0108515499,
-0.0113438629,
-0.0384980552,
-0.0251718089,
0.0192975365,
-0.0062801321,
0.0506383218,
-0.0228490252,
0.0379924141,
-0.066288963,
-0.0156457834,
0.0293038022,
-0.0701683015,
-0.0003928398,
0.0282953326,
0.0043713562,
-0.0627838001,
0.0350521244,
0.0738956109,
0.0175850037,
0.0653293654,
-0.0383401252,
-0.077969946,
-0.0082978476,
0.0286763813,
-0.0714485347,
0.0140474597,
0.0417491831,
0.0347756222,
-0.0101416856,
0.0593381189,
-0.0422350466,
0.0549654327,
0.0393889062,
0.0189679842,
-0.0027992274,
-0.0432178117,
0.0242270194,
0.0177515354,
0.0455979891,
-0.0218820814,
-0.0203051344,
-0.0112732835,
-0.0105655771,
-0.0124779921,
-0.0499907732,
-0.026564436,
-0.0266843829,
0.0162853971,
-0.0125381108,
-0.0369995683,
-0.0534011051,
-0.0241702981,
0.0389413908,
-0.0656134859,
0.0341558456,
0.013412023,
0.0139122577,
0.0143174259,
0.0308225993,
-0.0197505839,
0.0374330655,
0.0008217402,
0.0514150113,
-0.0124364309,
0.091810517,
0.0237784032,
0.0089697419,
-0.0380311087,
0.0455449708,
-0.0077052037,
-0.0460108705,
-0.0312977545,
0.0289562866,
0.0244076978,
0.006097463,
0.0735944062,
-0.0237247534,
-0.0230779685,
-0.0062479605,
0.0338960774,
-0.0075881756,
-0.0059925392,
0.0401916131,
0.0277733356,
-0.0270079467,
-0.0330449678,
0.0391024426,
0.0015013398,
0.0414803736,
-0.0182079226,
-0.000627591,
-0.0273579974,
-0.0269304495,
0.0086496724,
-0.0030583837,
-0.0378702506,
0.0086410344,
-0.0731991529,
-0.067833811,
-0.0421332344,
0.0272003487,
-0.012809216,
-0.0063403426,
0.0374979377,
0.040224541,
-0.0264831781,
-0.0166183487,
-0.0327805765,
-0.0349441655,
-0.012802925,
-0.0293412171,
-0.0399646685,
-6.881964003e-33,
-0.0234919395,
0.0054873885,
0.0027967636,
0.0056142421,
-0.0028155295,
-0.0234857649,
-0.0168278087,
0.0448320545,
-0.0389090888,
0.0107248016,
-0.0198104884,
-0.0192464553,
0.0013476737,
0.0045972941,
0.0248970967,
-0.0277922228,
0.0289045591,
-0.0102436366,
-0.0556166768,
0.0399673469,
0.021910416,
-0.0037518176,
0.0726750642,
-0.0857933536,
0.0152546307,
0.0261050276,
-0.0329383649,
0.0328268409,
-0.0432834923,
0.0662558973,
-0.000604852,
0.0805608928,
0.019120058,
-0.032027144,
-0.0019905076,
0.0119295195,
-0.0838695765,
-0.0355293788,
0.0355206244,
-0.0039837346,
-0.0606787317,
-0.0123268105,
0.0579707287,
-0.0194411706,
-0.0504131801,
0.0081848362,
0.0467625633,
-0.0220468733,
0.0078641139,
-0.0101366853,
-0.0700079873,
0.0012030923,
-0.0191818941,
-0.0374181531,
0.0088172639,
0.0447872393,
-0.0069579184,
0.0361115262,
-0.0228583328,
0.0258509722,
-0.0097421957,
-0.0060306899,
0.0351721421,
0.0138675636,
0.0048007634,
0.0489322096,
0.0145914862,
0.0110606598,
0.0163549427,
-0.0163306575,
0.0535222664,
0.024881376,
0.0298985839,
0.0805325583,
0.0101557402,
-0.037727952,
-0.0049424456,
0.0009691913,
0.0158145018,
0.0395812206,
0.0112751024,
0.0284192115,
-0.0920541659,
-0.0299050212,
-0.0348281525,
-0.0051195333,
-0.0454058498,
-0.057477504,
0.0334151126,
0.0161581263,
-0.043744415,
-0.0075167194,
0.0175338313,
-0.0211684331,
-0.0035510212,
0.0223639943,
-0.0101583954,
0.0167273618,
-0.0036487996,
-0.0138953486,
-0.050964728,
-0.0000105662,
0.0105184121,
-0.026590649,
0.0065337834,
0.0212772321,
0.0538659357,
0.0228078626,
-0.0452389605,
0.0250687189,
-0.0002181233,
0.0282752905,
-0.0214420818,
0.0222483426,
0.0328912586,
0.0273243915,
-0.0253846403,
0.0718320906,
0.006243303,
0.0032700989,
-0.0709043965,
-0.0216585472,
0.0245656166,
0.0086035766,
-0.0529130884,
-0.0215812717,
-0.0189747456,
-0.0515500456,
0.0087444121,
-0.077071555,
-0.008673883,
-0.0082080467,
2.845e-7,
0.0147165814,
0.0560487583,
0.0160149746,
0.0317250229,
0.0012423578,
0.0582310632,
0.0166350435,
0.0270700324,
0.0254216585,
0.0287703034,
0.0270087756,
0.0275992211,
0.0445777252,
0.0095782774,
-0.0730541572,
0.0125904614,
-0.0720687211,
0.0312150065,
-0.0353765301,
-0.029969776,
0.0600535348,
0.0847655237,
0.0449744835,
-0.010710326,
0.0297465306,
0.0225050561,
0.0463455133,
-0.0474667847,
-0.0050747776,
0.0112145143,
-0.0309665073,
0.0091441432,
-0.0076771621,
-0.0069354386,
-0.0030358504,
-0.0113104722,
-0.0169421379,
0.0977159888,
-0.0299157016,
-0.0476294421,
-0.0218759496,
0.0149460332,
0.0163572785,
-0.0645712465,
0.0501960032,
-0.0619357079,
-0.0400422141,
-0.0024832883,
0.0021628297,
-0.0319664553,
0.0136940312,
-0.0427655764,
-0.023307424,
0.0166153517,
0.0316143148,
0.0151429698,
-0.0293665323,
-0.0740198269,
-0.0359364189,
0.0247341078,
-0.0236202348,
-0.0487526879,
-0.0226356871,
0.026054671,
-0.0059848186,
-0.0803199485,
0.0085533597,
2.576518313e-34,
0.0425080284,
-0.0009322196,
0.0492635891,
-0.0032115271,
0.0449320972,
0.042567905,
0.0262807384,
0.0115744481,
0.0898698941,
-0.0667977259,
-0.0230041146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05338v1 | Negative Object Presence Evaluation (NOPE) to Measure Object Hallucination in Vision-Language Models | 2023-10-09T01:52:27 | 2023-10-09T01:52:27 | Holy Lovenia, Wenliang Dai, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Ziwei Ji, Pascale Fung | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Object hallucination poses a significant challenge in vision-language (VL)
models, often leading to the generation of nonsensical or unfaithful responses
with non-existent objects. However, the absence of a general measurement for
evaluating object hallucination in VL models has hindered our understanding and
ability to mitigate this issue. In this work, we present NOPE (Negative Object
Presence Evaluation), a novel benchmark designed to assess object hallucination
in VL models through visual question answering (VQA). We propose a
cost-effective and scalable approach utilizing large language models to
generate 29.5k synthetic negative pronoun (NegP) data of high quality for NOPE.
We extensively investigate the performance of 10 state-of-the-art VL models in
discerning the non-existence of objects in visual questions, where the ground
truth answers are denoted as NegP (e.g., "none"). Additionally, we evaluate
their standard performance on visual questions on 9 other VQA datasets. Through
our experiments, we demonstrate that no VL model is immune to the vulnerability
of object hallucination, as all models achieve accuracy below 10\% on NegP.
Furthermore, we uncover that lexically diverse visual questions, question types
with large scopes, and scene-relevant objects capitalize the risk of object
hallucination in VL models. | [
0.0529372953,
0.0361261927,
-0.0025043462,
0.0725061074,
-0.0239025764,
-0.0021536879,
-0.0005273736,
0.0067885541,
0.0228516869,
-0.0573460422,
0.0033004121,
-0.044951003,
0.0038487015,
0.018826114,
0.0364528373,
-0.0407650732,
0.0319914222,
-0.0218053553,
-0.0419779308,
0.0027260992,
0.0136062866,
-0.0217942148,
-0.0038581272,
0.0091380645,
-0.0328498818,
-0.0398406982,
-0.0379984975,
0.031298276,
0.0058864644,
-0.0157520752,
-0.0154834194,
0.0310209021,
-0.0161533542,
0.0172605347,
0.0000020224,
-0.0470366813,
0.012124124,
-0.0002264226,
0.0095251445,
-0.020796448,
0.0022688424,
-0.0279814601,
0.009021325,
0.0225842353,
-0.0128275137,
-0.0011489579,
0.0652586743,
0.0507165752,
0.0459158495,
0.0317112245,
-0.006796448,
0.0368858986,
0.0191584527,
0.0240120795,
0.0587172173,
-0.0089027314,
0.0125484178,
0.0048625772,
-0.011329744,
-0.0321746953,
-0.0611228421,
0.0719635263,
0.0712483525,
0.0374587327,
0.0178474337,
0.0444818921,
-0.0934144184,
-0.0205466561,
-0.0001625692,
0.0879196897,
-0.0146544734,
-0.0446129292,
-0.0021852567,
0.0124050314,
0.0236047916,
-0.0080066612,
-0.0380504839,
0.0360985175,
0.029727608,
-0.0189285371,
-0.0650667846,
0.00022705,
-0.0033762616,
0.0075509148,
0.0162235778,
0.0031336928,
0.0341817327,
-0.0277056191,
0.0088962102,
0.0089167627,
-0.073632665,
-0.0508965217,
0.006481003,
0.0061889361,
-0.0215356071,
-0.004337552,
-0.0190612283,
0.0113684917,
0.0017095818,
-0.0514939204,
0.024780944,
-0.0252204705,
-0.0809927285,
0.0687017515,
-0.0376643203,
0.0603396446,
-0.0205496065,
0.0228831321,
-0.0331312269,
-0.0450758711,
-0.0127708307,
-0.0176740792,
-0.0313615911,
0.0298130233,
-0.033852566,
-0.0533043705,
0.0422159135,
-0.0088353036,
-0.0536855496,
-0.0098109851,
-0.0334641151,
0.0708172619,
0.0114856577,
-0.0324676782,
-0.0285671931,
0.06140811,
-0.0272095297,
0.0013927952,
-0.0515796393,
-0.0923300013,
-0.004742261,
0.0435472615,
0.0260301717,
0.0102549298,
-0.0159463361,
0.0404639505,
-0.0085610906,
-0.0339227803,
0.0049060467,
-0.0370176919,
-0.014172677,
-0.0514936782,
0.010989055,
-0.0767587274,
-0.0156535357,
-0.0190273058,
-0.002350532,
-0.055309616,
0.028020544,
0.0272922814,
0.0022828551,
0.0759614483,
-0.0117783099,
0.0129807312,
-0.0184284095,
0.0207056347,
0.029294489,
0.0653067082,
-0.0264735147,
0.0155142676,
0.0336457454,
0.003910189,
0.0731001943,
0.0059179775,
0.0109788468,
0.0264790282,
-0.0552951545,
0.0163091272,
-0.0079238825,
0.0170370284,
-0.0005096205,
0.0505854115,
-0.0039997823,
-0.091402486,
0.0508645102,
0.0211195797,
-0.0691772252,
-0.0428488292,
0.002539051,
0.0232229456,
-0.0083901472,
0.0034676057,
-0.0563479774,
0.0538525842,
-0.0601208471,
-0.0149277532,
-0.0084635951,
-0.0347082876,
-0.0332931876,
-0.0254408959,
-0.0153297931,
-0.0107455747,
0.0120965,
0.0285872612,
0.0279662162,
0.0319424085,
-0.079193905,
0.0172741506,
-0.0056237099,
-0.0595708974,
-0.0078499848,
-0.0166049413,
0.0718823299,
0.0166478287,
0.063331306,
0.0109931771,
-0.0225678552,
-0.0066404226,
0.0540400259,
0.0604868755,
0.0145175783,
0.0112966495,
0.0542149059,
-0.0067387326,
-0.0160014778,
-0.0021181498,
0.005896864,
-0.0015740852,
0.0291914605,
-0.0006938678,
0.0288955383,
-0.046694804,
0.0027195453,
0.0392042547,
0.0301638246,
0.0051155528,
-0.0268593673,
0.0157409515,
-0.0190994069,
-0.012247066,
-0.0030673994,
0.0159277394,
0.0246797577,
-0.0334429815,
-0.0258413181,
-0.018008735,
-0.04423742,
-0.0172322448,
0.0491219275,
-0.0766433626,
-0.0006796538,
0.072170414,
-0.0089675086,
0.0048767375,
0.0197899472,
-0.0473165102,
0.0158596896,
-0.0461321026,
0.0146052111,
0.0039215214,
0.0233496241,
-0.0157200973,
0.0593265742,
-0.0564639308,
0.024213722,
0.0003811071,
0.0192761123,
0.0336185023,
-0.0413558371,
-0.0213870462,
-0.0169821978,
-0.0205413289,
0.0214952007,
-0.0001465306,
-0.0235206205,
-0.0825501606,
0.0238137059,
-0.0910400897,
-0.0052733673,
-0.0244948678,
-0.058840584,
0.0234981757,
-0.0373305045,
0.0121912314,
-0.0414470695,
-0.0138935391,
0.0476940796,
-0.0106862606,
0.0506486781,
0.0059399451,
-0.0238728635,
-0.0120204659,
-0.0127325496,
0.0029603986,
0.0024103029,
0.0530409291,
-0.0084349792,
-0.0070593241,
-0.0153350644,
0.0490805469,
-0.0742269307,
0.0563514084,
0.0244732704,
-0.0194328725,
0.0070581795,
-0.0144609436,
0.017141588,
0.0899350718,
-0.0291403215,
-0.0080959238,
0.0361077599,
-0.0352544188,
-0.0448394567,
-0.0332308151,
0.0218748394,
-0.0478661582,
0.0094655231,
-0.0436893106,
-0.0209078621,
0.0319198705,
-0.00863906,
-0.0168403406,
-0.0715688765,
0.0722716823,
-0.0415052325,
-0.0854378566,
-0.0340474918,
0.0204824843,
0.0003666934,
0.0479825586,
-0.0485818312,
-0.0495605506,
0.0358250551,
-0.0194822885,
-0.0339110717,
0.0364903249,
0.0351359025,
0.0198623408,
0.0635669976,
0.0518298522,
0.0192342922,
0.0018725301,
0.0233963989,
-0.0812011063,
-0.0293623954,
-0.0294264071,
-0.0271206386,
0.0056327619,
-0.0561405979,
0.0011390456,
-0.0046768584,
-0.0106123667,
-0.072797738,
-0.0290995631,
0.0024209043,
-0.0234897956,
-0.1048712656,
-0.0005153327,
-0.033014182,
0.0420160443,
-0.0300256629,
-0.0046673594,
-0.0109640621,
-0.0172865335,
-0.0133224521,
0.0420965441,
0.1035882086,
0.0220742393,
0.0324454568,
-0.0130451573,
0.006328783,
0.1013697013,
0.01225744,
0.0358042009,
-0.0388998576,
0.0156636946,
0.0071692257,
0.0450830273,
-0.0118908836,
0.0334494747,
0.0374216326,
-0.0542542972,
-0.027799055,
0.088062875,
0.0586540103,
-0.0205507223,
-0.003737089,
-0.0456822999,
0.0459929705,
0.0433652997,
0.0044312156,
-0.0596796423,
-0.0299823992,
-0.0225149505,
-0.0088239433,
-0.0221356899,
-0.0344989486,
-0.023420101,
-0.1349321902,
0.0457731895,
-0.0139382686,
-0.0119516673,
-0.0427350029,
0.015101702,
-0.0000883283,
-0.0200725514,
-0.0136812236,
0.0093258722,
0.0051073665,
0.0107156271,
-0.020188557,
0.0112448875,
0.0358245932,
0.0311463028,
-0.0449064337,
0.0297944099,
0.0485887527,
0.0226401798,
-0.0117599294,
-0.0789370909,
0.0231227633,
-0.0151898814,
-0.0246334001,
0.00153665,
0.0569026247,
0.0082851527,
-0.0188039616,
-0.0190729164,
0.0121540762,
-0.0283573605,
-0.0140248602,
0.012880682,
0.0577698126,
0.0006170339,
-0.0445770733,
-0.0266587287,
0.0162397474,
-0.0036501577,
0.0722647011,
0.0175622981,
-0.0371694639,
-0.0377880745,
0.0151617909,
0.0292226337,
-0.0041648182,
-0.0354345404,
-0.0027303451,
0.0704815388,
-0.0386285894,
-0.0990069509,
-0.0374753214,
0.049697198,
0.0505079441,
-0.0134074353,
-0.0140669886,
-0.028545076,
0.0043486534,
-0.0350981466,
0.0560384169,
-0.0583281554,
0.0260995589,
-0.0290528014,
0.0269497111,
0.0144307548,
-0.0043108081,
-0.0151091702,
0.0183662474,
-0.0558928549,
-0.030873308,
0.0080409832,
0.0552501492,
0.0136638219,
0.0134308934,
-0.0005317976,
-0.0427238159,
0.008946117,
0.0461507998,
0.0297951028,
0.0472734794,
0.0149988718,
-0.0400717109,
0.027030779,
0.0358752646,
-0.0077588283,
-0.0072968397,
0.0303573813,
0.0180910341,
-0.0274846684,
0.0135795409,
0.0331083722,
-0.0064725666,
0.0175567754,
0.0173982475,
0.0171704423,
0.0102053406,
-0.003706482,
-0.0013134031,
-0.004677501,
-0.0683042109,
0.0080805076,
0.0455787703,
0.0157001317,
0.0016982255,
0.0065348931,
-0.0344930366,
0.0366517119,
-0.0219793823,
-0.060675256,
0.0720378086,
-0.0557805561,
0.0004571577,
0.0010323459,
0.0018277956,
-0.013996874,
-0.0112044448,
0.0592405312,
0.0268760528,
0.0760134906,
-0.0066490839,
-0.0179866869,
-0.0534842014,
0.0038205301,
0.0029113779,
-0.0371603668,
0.0055228202,
0.0745484605,
0.0241226777,
-0.019297123,
0.0387226865,
-0.0010264198,
-0.0080695692,
-0.0273119174,
-0.0088951001,
0.0174712539,
-0.0544436835,
0.040052779,
0.0485446826,
0.0016660457,
0.0191224255,
0.0517097004,
0.032935828,
0.0149151329,
-0.0201820154,
0.0021426114,
-0.0193365812,
-0.0059903921,
0.0168826003,
0.0057097003,
0.0193244331,
0.0863307044,
-0.0412930325,
-0.0699167252,
-0.035391625,
0.0059276745,
-0.0071561821,
0.0166459139,
0.0409757681,
0.0309955664,
0.0034423217,
-0.0505484417,
-0.0052189287,
-0.0252211634,
0.0240917113,
0.0053023719,
-0.0155165289,
-6.384137003e-33,
-0.0256480649,
-0.0508323982,
0.0088488404,
-0.0439636558,
-0.0134418914,
0.0175429974,
-0.0035059368,
0.0165906604,
0.0009656582,
0.0161960181,
0.0254638214,
0.0330817141,
-0.0055688801,
0.0392858088,
-0.0203209892,
-0.0468428917,
0.0327337347,
0.0332541317,
-0.0285193454,
-0.020601213,
0.0084871119,
0.0047399532,
0.0316469818,
-0.0805091634,
0.0012644543,
-0.0110097798,
-0.0165266488,
0.029748043,
0.0242558513,
0.0318413787,
-0.0245787669,
0.0492318757,
0.0079760905,
-0.0226051752,
-0.0208450221,
0.0026027081,
-0.0458661094,
-0.0256539751,
0.0262574982,
0.0428147763,
-0.0838966668,
0.0225165766,
0.025340043,
-0.0027178803,
0.0134499269,
-0.0123038162,
0.0441575982,
-0.0128893033,
-0.0013126862,
0.0635010675,
-0.0471014716,
-0.0090972148,
0.0035421979,
-0.0624738149,
0.0267979894,
0.0428732038,
0.0065194098,
-0.0049994723,
-0.0433223508,
-0.0045399438,
-0.0280967746,
-0.0263330396,
0.0766678005,
0.0338368453,
0.0011745137,
0.0580629557,
0.0707034469,
-0.0017408371,
-0.0006736633,
-0.0505492352,
0.0104533024,
0.0405249335,
0.0822280049,
0.0405109078,
0.0451429747,
0.0405130945,
-0.0195398852,
0.0073813163,
-0.1139750928,
0.0603950806,
0.0535553023,
-0.0166726336,
-0.0235135239,
-0.0151506346,
-0.0278908517,
-0.0196895991,
-0.0447951071,
0.004472862,
0.0803155676,
0.005483401,
-0.0705636889,
0.0242644809,
0.0526422188,
-0.0505082905,
0.0016564841,
0.0477095731,
-0.0161461364,
0.0255896766,
0.0170111135,
0.0290760286,
-0.0117699532,
0.0509124175,
0.0485691167,
-0.0070300163,
-0.0010611247,
-0.0148702478,
0.031137079,
-0.0026534419,
-0.0780812204,
-0.0046842359,
-0.0361964218,
0.014518816,
-0.009266438,
0.0284070726,
0.0197658483,
0.0299321078,
-0.0411437973,
0.0082171327,
0.0267087054,
-0.0298705995,
-0.037552435,
0.0137135629,
-0.0520628765,
-0.006468487,
-0.0382204503,
-0.0211289115,
-0.0498078614,
-0.0457055643,
0.0344419628,
-0.0618172772,
-0.021109771,
-0.0168680921,
2.636e-7,
-0.015490111,
0.0114642186,
0.0308951419,
0.0209820252,
-0.0025672773,
0.0600336306,
0.0081975693,
0.0139005724,
0.0365200713,
-0.0446013771,
-0.0204172637,
0.0457807966,
0.0204847846,
-0.0117925098,
-0.0375349596,
0.0520444326,
-0.0075787506,
0.004258242,
-0.0560163632,
0.0029188299,
0.0365337841,
0.0507165864,
0.0128706992,
-0.016755959,
0.0311210565,
-0.0585578755,
0.047784172,
-0.0239180755,
0.0085604265,
-0.0255231969,
0.0175593663,
0.0345002003,
0.0404030904,
0.0394994132,
0.020736035,
-0.0393302627,
0.0616633184,
0.0040702252,
-0.0330085382,
-0.0509005301,
-0.0318112411,
-0.0040656552,
-0.0126576107,
-0.0439461321,
0.132082969,
-0.0269139986,
-0.0038932895,
-0.0038749841,
-0.0383154973,
-0.0051597869,
0.0621533096,
-0.0057350467,
-0.0361550003,
-0.0046011433,
0.0263212677,
-0.0174158365,
-0.0239083227,
-0.0170886386,
-0.034757182,
-0.0332610421,
0.0206274446,
-0.0264056828,
-0.006850136,
0.0167894829,
-0.0095260944,
-0.0508254468,
-0.0377801582,
2.205411073e-34,
0.0252693556,
0.0347666107,
0.0550996624,
0.0116454372,
0.0309995655,
-0.0176451411,
0.0096641127,
-0.0171807148,
0.0052357963,
-0.0241909977,
0.0219635312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05318v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05318v2 | Resolving the Imbalance Issue in Hierarchical Disciplinary Topic Inference via LLM-based Data Augmentation | 2023-10-09T00:45:20 | 2023-10-15T03:34:40 | Xunxin Cai, Meng Xiao, Zhiyuan Ning, Yuanchun Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In addressing the imbalanced issue of data within the realm of Natural
Language Processing, text data augmentation methods have emerged as pivotal
solutions. This data imbalance is prevalent in the research proposals submitted
during the funding application process. Such imbalances, resulting from the
varying popularity of disciplines or the emergence of interdisciplinary
studies, significantly impede the precision of downstream topic models that
deduce the affiliated disciplines of these proposals. At the data level,
proposals penned by experts and scientists are inherently complex technological
texts, replete with intricate terminologies, which augmenting such specialized
text data poses unique challenges. At the system level, this, in turn,
compromises the fairness of AI-assisted reviewer assignment systems, which
raises a spotlight on solving this issue. This study leverages large language
models (Llama V1) as data generators to augment research proposals categorized
within intricate disciplinary hierarchies, aiming to rectify data imbalances
and enhance the equity of expert assignments. We first sample within the
hierarchical structure to find the under-represented class. Then we designed a
prompt for keyword-based research proposal generation. Our experiments attests
to the efficacy of the generated data, demonstrating that research proposals
produced using the prompts can effectively address the aforementioned issues
and generate high quality scientific text data, thus help the model overcome
the imbalanced issue. | [
0.08240401,
0.0142309694,
-0.0199686922,
0.0046449937,
-0.0116104707,
-0.0360742062,
0.0219061263,
-0.0075786589,
-0.0272244532,
-0.0549686998,
-0.0560097434,
-0.0003807371,
0.0212419555,
0.061511036,
0.0193015113,
-0.0281651784,
0.0167870186,
-0.0278305076,
0.04639256,
-0.0232841689,
0.0002043706,
0.0021081192,
-0.0065961131,
0.0282932632,
0.058523301,
-0.0175551251,
0.0241572503,
-0.0056928974,
0.0030512833,
-0.0472481921,
0.0412340164,
0.0849500224,
0.0012015604,
0.0535004586,
0.0000017509,
-0.0683813915,
-0.0224404372,
0.0246106386,
0.0128786806,
0.0309335161,
0.0723471045,
-0.0336815529,
0.0193009283,
0.0132496059,
0.0038947549,
0.0372163244,
0.0176925007,
0.0199539959,
-0.0149416421,
0.0011550075,
0.0139720384,
-0.0249961819,
0.0399729982,
-0.0353469402,
0.0081208861,
0.0532346219,
0.031375628,
-0.0007961418,
0.0393724144,
0.088595286,
-0.0045205168,
0.0148888426,
-0.015208818,
-0.0515671223,
0.1178188473,
0.0403465517,
-0.0331908166,
-0.0002728147,
0.0018088182,
0.0766842142,
0.0520633124,
-0.0187958535,
0.0293415859,
-0.0505672917,
-0.0141356103,
0.032526195,
-0.0586014278,
0.0519209206,
-0.0160093512,
-0.0203879923,
0.0678548813,
0.0252937116,
0.0217980295,
0.0398888625,
0.0231621508,
0.0777101144,
0.0138583025,
-0.051633317,
0.0163045451,
0.032810472,
0.0653343052,
-0.0887726173,
-0.006139969,
-0.0068920497,
-0.0309637673,
0.0178450346,
0.0203590784,
-0.0391892157,
0.0725750551,
0.0033069737,
0.0124296295,
-0.0126166577,
-0.0145049244,
0.0331636816,
0.0459476858,
-0.0293919686,
-0.0301523935,
-0.031810835,
-0.0135337329,
-0.0146920104,
-0.0314156339,
-0.0439711772,
0.0292491801,
0.0158528034,
-0.0222554598,
0.0190285873,
-0.037629649,
0.0244405139,
-0.0365901627,
-0.0296628531,
0.0082743103,
0.0124042975,
-0.0734495744,
-0.0192066003,
-0.0854835585,
0.0516031794,
-0.0082287136,
0.0842138231,
-0.0186323244,
0.0252449848,
-0.0015709749,
0.0419099033,
0.0055219498,
-0.027390793,
0.0330747552,
0.0019459656,
0.0194750838,
-0.0285404027,
-0.0253273733,
-0.0569935367,
0.0052173221,
-0.0275004823,
0.0464192666,
-0.0766851604,
0.0294479914,
0.008538696,
-0.0093155596,
-0.0231093783,
-0.0224504545,
-0.0062645702,
-0.0451152585,
0.0494840033,
-0.0999586657,
0.00434358,
0.0539654717,
0.024096109,
-0.0500399545,
0.022680331,
-0.000163146,
0.0225234926,
0.0413460843,
0.00488918,
0.0452928729,
-0.0042482135,
-0.0098685594,
0.0424584821,
-0.0072985645,
0.0303341076,
-0.0745985657,
0.0221295152,
0.0578092895,
0.0197269227,
-0.017143093,
0.0329279825,
0.0473602004,
0.106133461,
0.0185341388,
0.0369796269,
-0.0229868721,
-0.0020541395,
0.0044808034,
-0.0105363755,
-0.0030223723,
0.0612583831,
-0.014746815,
0.0005078185,
0.0687551275,
0.0136345131,
-0.0028134845,
-0.0423127301,
-0.0093168197,
0.0567386374,
-0.024075646,
-0.0209470205,
0.0446989685,
0.0214658584,
0.0229058582,
-0.0389421247,
0.0528366677,
0.0130131198,
0.0265950896,
0.0043468708,
0.0345735997,
0.0656353459,
0.0660130605,
-0.0488524511,
-0.0391951017,
-0.0136743216,
0.0174267944,
0.0553489365,
0.0106301755,
-0.0207874794,
-0.0524929948,
0.0150397494,
-0.0546299554,
-0.0127362739,
-0.0144571029,
0.0119471345,
-0.0126495361,
0.0001369567,
-0.0225202776,
-0.0428613275,
-0.0233726893,
0.038783785,
-0.0398187898,
0.0320525095,
0.0455205888,
-0.0487448573,
0.0349705592,
0.0266242512,
-0.0340448134,
0.0195538439,
0.0282953754,
-0.0393077284,
-0.0420710966,
-0.0448824912,
0.0405561365,
0.0290024392,
0.0237314794,
-0.0707115754,
0.014381174,
-0.061220143,
-0.0136247445,
-0.0103910128,
0.0374694839,
0.0185070168,
-0.0191581752,
0.0097848941,
0.0016964532,
-0.0190599151,
0.002692068,
-0.0228338372,
0.0426538959,
0.0054268506,
0.0282182321,
0.0226731598,
-0.0352621414,
-0.0001303399,
-0.0448487327,
0.0020408819,
0.014815107,
0.0209300891,
0.0031823646,
0.063644439,
-0.0242857747,
-0.01387682,
-0.0087461174,
-0.0424374379,
0.005257071,
0.0143543137,
-0.0090276795,
0.0036854565,
-0.0097741326,
0.002973255,
0.0085726492,
-0.0066664554,
-0.0393672176,
-0.0009237929,
0.0039847461,
0.0614474788,
-0.0082021002,
-0.0056866296,
-0.0620956123,
-0.0171420425,
-0.0409898087,
0.0212223735,
0.0641152561,
-0.0228109565,
-0.0760440528,
0.0171973296,
-0.0085993679,
-0.0084967539,
-0.0280267168,
0.0260918159,
0.0015028425,
0.0354219861,
0.0186327025,
0.012793296,
-0.0075539309,
0.0079613701,
0.0921889842,
0.0141106844,
-0.0145718092,
-0.0291679893,
0.0073351264,
0.0463681258,
0.0254656654,
-0.0374856554,
0.0472402796,
0.0208453275,
-0.0068169641,
-0.0251244344,
0.0103064468,
0.0228979401,
-0.0255939756,
-0.0031706737,
-0.0069707646,
-0.0357190371,
0.0016069043,
0.0862449035,
-0.0141169531,
-0.0466170758,
0.0467957184,
-0.0338893756,
0.0095748529,
-0.0607596636,
-0.0151389139,
-0.0488508381,
0.0316102467,
-0.0168850124,
-0.0102947615,
-0.0012578961,
0.0388864577,
-0.0664580762,
0.0034965486,
0.0047507272,
-0.015501773,
0.0421802476,
-0.0459227115,
0.0172227956,
-0.0086618178,
-0.0005935456,
-0.0213892963,
-0.0246246886,
0.0158652831,
0.0423761792,
0.0565656535,
-0.0282325987,
-0.0185250808,
0.0021426945,
0.052799128,
0.0414285734,
-0.0072443979,
-0.0328769982,
-0.0310282037,
-0.0043348814,
0.0504028872,
-0.0519584604,
0.0184116866,
0.0013964997,
0.0099999411,
0.000337265,
-0.0081516709,
-0.0112820286,
-0.0266576391,
-0.0106518157,
0.0159911495,
-0.0837571621,
-0.0186781939,
0.0042671189,
0.0200470779,
-0.0220421664,
0.0251146033,
0.0739738643,
0.0187769756,
-0.0887557417,
0.0023063701,
-0.0183322933,
-0.0164733436,
0.0392833613,
0.0421169363,
-0.07984256,
0.0306484979,
-0.0156636499,
0.0534220561,
-0.0483760126,
-0.0517978445,
-0.0307808146,
-0.0720664412,
0.0739824027,
-0.0201079231,
-0.01076137,
-0.0623349175,
-0.0727240592,
0.0068008355,
-0.0019404429,
-0.0101682311,
0.0078650834,
-0.0166467316,
0.0135672018,
0.0189818349,
-0.0425250381,
-0.0392692797,
0.0150544997,
-0.0640742928,
0.0740815327,
-0.0029244113,
0.0164870527,
-0.0285894331,
0.0328925513,
-0.010756921,
-0.0104933567,
-0.0189079568,
0.0031961526,
-0.0072673713,
0.0113805681,
0.0291080382,
-0.0048276107,
0.0197607446,
-0.0475913659,
0.0016158475,
0.0482545756,
0.0925549343,
-0.0267039482,
0.0056201681,
-0.0797904432,
-0.0064615533,
0.0086561115,
0.0810961276,
-0.0029332798,
-0.0418374762,
0.02763463,
-0.0201343689,
-0.0014110322,
0.0344204865,
-0.0148349442,
0.020061329,
-0.0569145605,
-0.049318552,
-0.0507935546,
-0.0436710976,
0.0144837182,
0.0016008377,
0.0425731689,
0.0819698274,
0.0253180657,
-0.053594403,
-0.0077190329,
0.0402508005,
-0.0176329818,
0.0122158704,
-0.0247304812,
-0.0627332181,
0.0224277023,
-0.0426033102,
-0.0428115167,
-0.007875354,
-0.0040124413,
-0.0502726361,
-0.0580315441,
0.001415416,
0.0250911079,
0.0124719115,
-0.0202788934,
-0.0757845268,
0.0291002095,
0.0466144234,
-0.0023827103,
-0.00724761,
-0.0419302136,
-0.0004912147,
-0.0083211577,
-0.0419409238,
-0.0712388679,
0.0465008691,
0.0346010439,
0.0194419622,
-0.0196687561,
-0.0742547438,
0.0051273056,
0.0134044066,
0.0612653345,
-0.0319290534,
-0.0171050802,
-0.0408417992,
-0.0151221501,
-0.0145137571,
-0.0304106213,
-0.0100897364,
0.0036848807,
0.0167551115,
-0.0111836689,
-0.0054032519,
0.0098408349,
-0.0677877665,
0.0578478426,
-0.0390969999,
0.043255832,
0.0073790131,
0.0467329323,
0.0100586237,
-0.0212387796,
0.0029317278,
-0.001000141,
-0.0391202271,
0.0370936617,
-0.0006860613,
-0.0154617513,
0.0120012937,
0.0077055297,
-0.0311482288,
0.0046093925,
-0.0947188959,
-0.0241697114,
-0.0160896275,
0.042945575,
0.0052762576,
0.0514958948,
-0.022021478,
-0.0341177694,
0.0095605236,
-0.0303492639,
0.0327602625,
0.0079967547,
0.0192987286,
0.0550574325,
-0.0006278972,
-0.0343767926,
-0.0166945215,
0.0580671467,
0.0509974025,
0.0142042534,
-0.0278765783,
-0.043844007,
0.0130283395,
-0.0351109914,
-0.0048151207,
0.0219264813,
-0.0198163055,
-0.0198059194,
-0.0782399774,
-0.0072949626,
0.0198102482,
-0.0200346038,
0.0019505424,
-0.0152235804,
0.0020055631,
0.0501897633,
-0.0265817828,
-0.0285893418,
-0.0225914046,
0.012561053,
-0.0252405442,
-0.0658002123,
-0.0299033169,
-6.240216086e-33,
0.007626506,
-0.0629178211,
0.0249467306,
-0.016256582,
0.0005899979,
0.0372467712,
-0.0194911286,
-0.0188026074,
-0.0006100397,
0.0136468997,
-0.0660776272,
0.0168635454,
-0.0126296468,
-0.0313701406,
0.0784877911,
0.0314196162,
0.0467565916,
0.0032310218,
-0.0331416577,
0.0286536291,
-0.0299204923,
-0.0143618453,
0.017087996,
-0.0601326115,
0.069449231,
-0.0096956426,
0.0239875447,
0.0079601593,
0.0366019607,
0.0529881045,
-0.0224410072,
0.0613790751,
0.0231285021,
-0.0640790313,
-0.0103945602,
0.003922028,
-0.0190120246,
-0.0211558398,
0.0203038901,
-0.0450270101,
0.02239866,
-0.0325895585,
0.0512564555,
0.0272836853,
-0.0664797574,
-0.0090224063,
0.0902301595,
-0.0091925422,
-0.01409382,
-0.0830464289,
-0.0723286867,
0.017078016,
-0.011845123,
0.0423375107,
-0.0254637655,
-0.0141401142,
0.015826961,
0.0981046557,
-0.0209436212,
0.0394279361,
0.0203296561,
0.0069315336,
0.0591546111,
-0.0030762602,
-0.0270761289,
0.0452050455,
-0.0075864368,
0.0564965084,
-0.0021747006,
-0.0772990882,
0.0052999146,
-0.0140427807,
0.0165516455,
0.0561306775,
0.0583147556,
0.0222961921,
-0.055270277,
0.0380762033,
0.0540172048,
-0.003810087,
0.0263820644,
0.0078314207,
0.0047787619,
-0.0489826091,
0.0114483628,
-0.0416494273,
-0.0093064392,
-0.0026727864,
0.0135844415,
-0.011253031,
-0.0006923762,
0.0463098995,
0.0064512235,
-0.05178174,
-0.0186096467,
0.0352232903,
0.0044677118,
0.0531745218,
-0.0037307048,
0.0047311666,
-0.0961922035,
-0.023133792,
0.0305629317,
0.0197890308,
0.0302508399,
0.0132962223,
-0.0003732895,
-0.0240935441,
-0.0293722488,
-0.0122249518,
0.0019506025,
-0.0105345305,
0.0330436639,
0.0348340645,
0.0068559279,
0.0284105204,
0.0395079143,
0.0042561707,
0.0579790473,
0.0543743148,
-0.0137332389,
-0.0099521214,
-0.0565743521,
0.0090373326,
-0.0118695861,
0.0001872187,
0.0089856628,
-0.0143068032,
0.0163170248,
-0.0436654724,
-0.0187741928,
-0.0424468778,
2.683e-7,
0.0569421165,
0.0841098651,
-0.0296084341,
-0.0187684838,
0.030102903,
0.0073832241,
-0.002049891,
0.0230044592,
-0.0072208438,
-0.0184797626,
0.018023368,
-0.0202553496,
-0.0214100406,
0.0153297391,
-0.0736433491,
-0.034146335,
-0.0630770251,
0.0045711319,
-0.0846601278,
-0.0230911225,
0.0161140747,
0.0138792032,
0.0231100228,
-0.0205265563,
-0.0498182066,
-0.0271185935,
0.022784926,
-0.0156117771,
0.0330401957,
0.0813893303,
0.0720688403,
0.0065389443,
-0.004939625,
0.0470591858,
-0.0095210625,
0.0278236922,
-0.014664745,
-0.0260727946,
-0.0217211451,
0.0216342714,
0.0255201906,
-0.0049478775,
0.0325647257,
-0.048124738,
0.0250529125,
-0.0152809611,
-0.014116087,
-0.049335748,
-0.0164883696,
-0.0047505628,
0.0216319449,
-0.0405466408,
0.0201436169,
0.0001057196,
-0.0134087102,
0.005142991,
-0.0469717905,
-0.049585212,
0.0250852238,
0.0315596722,
-0.027674146,
-0.0759618878,
-0.0014869345,
-0.006117993,
0.0349158607,
-0.048118066,
0.0427532308,
2.761691505e-34,
0.0596638657,
-0.0241192169,
-0.0198798515,
0.0213791244,
0.0072783949,
0.0247316603,
-0.0271589886,
0.0180843007,
0.0005614305,
-0.0578824282,
-0.0080215074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05317v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05317v5 | Task-Adaptive Tokenization: Enhancing Long-Form Text Generation Efficacy in Mental Health and Beyond | 2023-10-09T00:20:59 | 2023-11-13T14:35:22 | Siyang Liu, Naihao Deng, Sahand Sabour, Yilin Jia, Minlie Huang, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68, I.2.7 | We propose task-adaptive tokenization as a way to adapt the generation
pipeline to the specifics of a downstream task and enhance long-form generation
in mental health. Inspired by insights from cognitive science, our
task-adaptive tokenizer samples variable segmentations from multiple outcomes,
with sampling probabilities optimized based on task-specific data. We introduce
a strategy for building a specialized vocabulary and introduce a vocabulary
merging protocol that allows for the integration of task-specific tokens into
the pre-trained model's tokenization step. Through extensive experiments on
psychological question-answering tasks in both Chinese and English, we find
that our task-adaptive tokenization approach brings a significant improvement
in generation performance while using up to 60% fewer tokens. Preliminary
experiments point to promising results when using our tokenization approach
with very large language models. | [
0.0251074471,
0.0420913361,
-0.0064277085,
-0.0373470038,
-0.0138946418,
-0.0019826607,
0.0415724292,
0.0075521222,
0.0035365536,
-0.0427994542,
0.0085550984,
-0.0537606552,
0.0095370412,
0.0294530839,
0.0485171117,
-0.0626612008,
0.0328551009,
0.0085252989,
0.0603568815,
0.0235604607,
0.0052611791,
0.009416406,
-0.0202304497,
0.0614274964,
-0.0213608202,
-0.0101171276,
-0.0033542099,
0.0069830869,
0.0114565874,
-0.0697297379,
0.0166142508,
0.0660564676,
-0.0265751816,
-0.0010905912,
0.0000018028,
-0.0439865179,
-0.029408576,
-0.0011462423,
0.0060516088,
-0.0369069092,
0.0528539121,
-0.0126065155,
0.025886368,
0.0339116752,
-0.0242658984,
-0.0024183742,
0.03718777,
0.0918921903,
0.0555083416,
0.0411801785,
0.0019877711,
0.0327688642,
0.0298322234,
-0.0384978242,
0.007317842,
0.0053744609,
0.0132398317,
-0.0214798022,
-0.0046054926,
-0.0190075301,
-0.0172903538,
-0.002776447,
0.0025804907,
0.0201942604,
0.0248946529,
0.0470461883,
-0.001034423,
-0.0172739197,
-0.0126788272,
0.0671737194,
0.0028724957,
0.0064027174,
0.0411233567,
-0.0063880584,
0.0343890414,
-0.004988458,
-0.0644362494,
0.0298817493,
-0.0069358549,
0.0078679733,
0.0450290777,
-0.0084699001,
0.0077921976,
0.004270249,
-0.0120335594,
0.0325676575,
0.0098895198,
-0.0293647293,
-0.0070371386,
-0.0156370085,
-0.0536712185,
-0.1231799126,
0.0298740305,
0.0370675139,
-0.0665067062,
0.01989468,
-0.0603785552,
-0.0944326073,
0.0408431478,
0.0221916847,
0.0069563636,
0.0383351482,
-0.0231351722,
-0.0371074416,
-0.0252175629,
0.0431028306,
-0.0015307011,
0.0394593142,
-0.0865304694,
0.0034162975,
-0.059421733,
-0.0448847525,
-0.057284724,
0.0536494888,
-0.0239554569,
-0.042896349,
-0.0950824544,
0.017179586,
0.0025094079,
-0.0508693829,
0.0000494639,
0.0189683978,
-0.0281272307,
0.0137563599,
-0.0071836081,
0.0044956114,
-0.0498912632,
0.0237158611,
0.0805564001,
-0.0000641674,
-0.0071931686,
0.0095505053,
0.0072653554,
-0.0294907205,
-0.0061060232,
0.0324889719,
-0.0391789861,
-0.0013248504,
-0.022612216,
-0.0908256248,
-0.0567241199,
-0.0404513255,
0.0139644602,
-0.0513269529,
0.0398167484,
0.0024188068,
-0.0093055842,
-0.0243944917,
0.0268725846,
0.0318679661,
-0.0281021614,
0.037309166,
-0.0322484933,
-0.0077708997,
0.0360851772,
0.0177123044,
0.017870063,
0.061487399,
0.0541060902,
0.0256612059,
0.0292382482,
0.0095122606,
0.001787407,
-0.0027022727,
0.033179272,
-0.0413371436,
-0.0012633465,
-0.0248215105,
0.0235061534,
0.0454274341,
0.0195380468,
0.0604949966,
-0.0383666009,
0.0461075306,
0.0432032347,
0.0741713271,
0.0065657492,
-0.0114304069,
0.0391950719,
0.0029587126,
-0.0345176756,
0.0497384518,
-0.0288990699,
0.0319724716,
0.0144933257,
0.0364203304,
0.0588339344,
0.0188392736,
-0.0346828923,
-0.0638906881,
-0.0350022838,
-0.0172485318,
0.012723376,
0.0006538942,
0.0035167867,
0.0349204727,
-0.0323350281,
0.0784261152,
0.0152121652,
-0.0734304264,
0.0250964295,
-0.0687020794,
0.0343156345,
0.0748396665,
0.0300164204,
-0.0090000741,
-0.0282715652,
-0.0039781714,
0.0398807898,
0.0472666174,
0.0108670797,
-0.0112931048,
0.0144881196,
-0.0438973121,
-0.0098376712,
0.0023877439,
-0.0009750907,
-0.0231852457,
0.0116759706,
0.0143246828,
0.0168711487,
-0.0547499955,
-0.0079947766,
0.0504642874,
-0.0154421311,
-0.0253034346,
0.0460541919,
-0.0098340744,
0.0201196074,
0.0182657689,
-0.0106123686,
0.0677582845,
0.0128682544,
-0.0419100672,
-0.0606083497,
0.0327019952,
-0.0587219261,
-0.0444680266,
0.0124645624,
0.0092389882,
0.0191839337,
0.0007180598,
-0.0293892529,
-0.0675889999,
-0.012626511,
-0.0530304089,
0.0360959806,
-0.0235891435,
0.0082089026,
0.0549144,
0.0261928141,
-0.0456526503,
0.0471499152,
-0.0026714623,
0.0176499784,
0.0002687384,
-0.0104332091,
-0.0202605296,
-0.053971976,
-0.0135432119,
-0.0065588346,
-0.0250468086,
-0.00215037,
0.0213968381,
0.0183892623,
-0.0512084663,
-0.0501956344,
-0.1407278776,
0.0130459918,
-0.0076333242,
-0.0069314032,
0.0377750285,
-0.0091838911,
-0.0137812076,
0.0166346002,
-0.0570388362,
0.01058337,
0.0430208407,
0.0420007445,
0.0277764928,
0.0049291169,
0.0003686083,
-0.0270931795,
-0.0132561056,
-0.0290888753,
0.0339536071,
0.0212124176,
-0.007248533,
-0.051815927,
-0.0280768797,
-0.0420651063,
-0.0265126508,
0.0148980757,
-0.0275788885,
0.0156829655,
0.0171149727,
0.107571885,
0.0417609029,
0.0572833605,
-0.0023302354,
0.0341256335,
-0.0178731326,
-0.0234802142,
0.0025146296,
-0.02099308,
0.0064180354,
0.0062025711,
-0.079914704,
0.0488808677,
0.0443517976,
0.0622706376,
0.0007015305,
-0.0527890697,
-0.0113151623,
-0.0361054726,
-0.0352226011,
-0.0108799329,
-0.0066063176,
-0.0511407629,
0.0084095122,
-0.0081526022,
-0.0272017829,
0.0647259727,
-0.0189496372,
0.019341778,
-0.0614845082,
0.0171360597,
-0.014477782,
0.0338494964,
0.0035021978,
0.034974359,
0.0552858002,
-0.0304598529,
-0.0387560986,
-0.0047669392,
-0.0413064063,
-0.0250255819,
0.0265171416,
-0.052466929,
-0.0160627868,
0.0178729352,
-0.0344485231,
-0.0503943041,
-0.0151854176,
-0.0081285043,
0.014859301,
0.0440799706,
0.0158517789,
-0.0175468381,
-0.0067044743,
0.0303319544,
0.0397760533,
-0.0510887206,
-0.013129157,
-0.0119002173,
0.0616147816,
0.0901633054,
0.0276617818,
0.0239722859,
-0.0469594821,
0.0257020425,
0.065177612,
0.0637253597,
0.0209357012,
0.0329652056,
-0.0172372852,
-0.012503922,
-0.0524982587,
0.0136469277,
0.0491710491,
0.0580205917,
-0.0295587834,
-0.0260809381,
0.1260086149,
0.02870588,
0.0117683522,
0.0170439705,
-0.017426502,
0.0384761281,
-0.0020897905,
-0.0013130655,
-0.056361787,
-0.0234625302,
0.0012692964,
0.0473405682,
-0.0328624062,
-0.0268504303,
-0.0116225528,
-0.0690765008,
0.0308762398,
0.0051417397,
-0.0506403148,
0.0341465846,
-0.0114886956,
-0.0108655766,
0.028493857,
0.0327324346,
-0.0042952015,
-0.0103034908,
0.0241157282,
0.0356485508,
-0.0389785096,
-0.0138955247,
-0.008783807,
-0.0208517723,
0.0477756821,
0.0487773903,
0.0277150758,
0.0126232998,
-0.0133803757,
0.0240872987,
-0.0010299622,
0.0091712549,
-0.010407039,
0.0740952268,
0.021603493,
0.0283840206,
-0.0210251156,
0.0554571003,
-0.033673685,
-0.0507874973,
0.037286792,
0.0407009944,
0.0002806906,
-0.0018873098,
-0.0233175177,
0.029688824,
0.0189455338,
0.0834258869,
0.0295221489,
-0.0767334327,
-0.0324587636,
0.0099070976,
0.0164248776,
-0.1120501161,
0.0048747859,
-0.0046800002,
-0.0243917927,
0.0201230068,
-0.1253571212,
-0.0547902994,
0.0537945516,
0.0431601889,
-0.0015559968,
0.0146832243,
0.0110948021,
-0.0097693708,
-0.0652432889,
0.0120933624,
0.0051078321,
-0.0106354794,
-0.0820391849,
-0.0308824927,
0.0039295149,
-0.0384283364,
-0.0081588477,
0.0458997637,
-0.0942230895,
-0.0360360853,
0.0189130176,
0.0289604478,
0.0086844256,
0.009440002,
0.030186221,
-0.0056466251,
0.060566932,
0.0236477237,
-0.0399263352,
0.01855921,
-0.0300250445,
0.0269546919,
-0.0105630131,
0.0169297755,
-0.02917381,
-0.0036290239,
0.0395655334,
0.0551141538,
0.0288946033,
0.0175627936,
0.0247229747,
0.0430240445,
0.0132819247,
-0.0558686368,
-0.0134377917,
-0.036586035,
-0.0025006244,
-0.0304132514,
-0.0105784405,
-0.027912708,
0.0168837011,
-0.0080820667,
-0.0120846266,
0.0217385069,
0.0000070151,
-0.0369917676,
0.0238551162,
-0.0477123633,
-0.0466915518,
-0.0816401094,
0.012911357,
0.0175115149,
-0.0093810158,
-0.0181019362,
-0.0277099088,
-0.0137694525,
0.0160090178,
-0.0501776524,
0.0624502711,
0.0015911435,
0.0011825984,
-0.0028584965,
0.0345588475,
-0.0509221256,
-0.0536335818,
-0.0349340476,
-0.0059697083,
0.000175723,
0.0267816428,
0.0365523547,
-0.0388892442,
0.0007559143,
-0.0231839977,
0.0187165327,
-0.0083718998,
-0.0238492899,
0.0053215669,
-0.0049464963,
-0.0190531816,
-0.0715255812,
0.087325491,
0.0037057733,
-0.0102377553,
0.0137845334,
-0.0173473116,
-0.0588414967,
-0.0318983607,
-0.0058641774,
0.0321854353,
-0.0270639695,
-0.0095495889,
-0.0309477802,
-0.0348819457,
0.0519930087,
-0.0134972939,
-0.0101265833,
0.0009477254,
0.0533277243,
0.0518267788,
-0.0287882891,
-0.0436135679,
-0.045369491,
0.0475728102,
0.00595862,
-0.0275090169,
-0.0173515659,
-5.794765074e-33,
-0.0354748592,
-0.057131812,
0.0271214601,
-0.0337020308,
-0.0181864128,
0.0021650451,
-0.0474639907,
0.033728946,
0.0482820123,
0.0048590088,
0.006158561,
-0.0042578927,
0.024009943,
0.0770820677,
0.0177314077,
0.0097459517,
0.0586377084,
-0.0173215438,
-0.0376363508,
0.0364023186,
0.048773136,
0.0207135603,
0.024644915,
-0.0332970768,
0.0214763079,
0.012672645,
0.0146371536,
-0.0117197465,
0.025040755,
0.0715355873,
-0.0121325795,
0.0504771955,
0.053988494,
-0.0245405938,
-0.0319069996,
0.0496624745,
-0.0648904517,
-0.0395106748,
0.0249175578,
-0.0394021831,
-0.0746405721,
-0.0494220592,
0.0354445577,
-0.0213469956,
0.0139953727,
-0.0117821172,
0.0282437354,
-0.0243748184,
-0.0014156124,
-0.0205928907,
-0.0713304356,
-0.0063180556,
0.0169822592,
0.0025199326,
-0.064268969,
0.0414792411,
-0.0167193022,
-0.0010192156,
-0.03333354,
0.0197860543,
0.0132927485,
0.0478662439,
0.0297314096,
0.0309748463,
-0.0266091339,
0.0546267405,
0.0160298347,
-0.0125679793,
-0.0088310149,
0.0324739367,
-0.0022365141,
0.0156373512,
0.041632548,
0.026233431,
0.0231951829,
-0.0199340917,
-0.0585968308,
0.0460196473,
-0.0015109497,
-0.0228816252,
0.0533929691,
-0.011382632,
0.0049305735,
-0.0243145898,
-0.0303719342,
0.0515765734,
-0.0415529534,
-0.02250617,
0.0610102564,
0.0431805737,
-0.0204819143,
-0.037124224,
0.013724112,
0.0154882735,
0.0037658636,
0.0045839557,
-0.0179375559,
0.0171575714,
-0.0209035445,
-0.0130003151,
-0.0471517853,
-0.0095776599,
0.0329594091,
0.0315682031,
0.0123767518,
0.011660791,
0.0538901798,
-0.0116611421,
-0.0607611239,
0.0258334763,
0.0029216267,
0.0589751452,
0.0003339083,
-0.010861624,
0.0097546065,
0.0221151598,
-0.0185007844,
0.0233731717,
-0.0141702127,
-0.0510090366,
-0.0602490194,
-0.0024808648,
0.0079077808,
0.0369703099,
-0.0211966578,
0.020359898,
-0.0101391077,
0.0133518288,
0.025682237,
-0.0376620181,
-0.0056266161,
0.0174282156,
2.466e-7,
0.0344541334,
0.0339616761,
0.0145542705,
-0.003263701,
0.0000884027,
-0.0035612385,
0.027418483,
0.0419053249,
0.0044323499,
0.0023566568,
-0.0129807582,
0.0141583914,
0.0265839733,
0.0432636179,
-0.0770064816,
-0.0077479426,
-0.0394429937,
0.0187994931,
-0.0537435934,
-0.0024846699,
0.0722397193,
0.0481015183,
-0.0244466681,
-0.0079858275,
0.007435516,
-0.0405902788,
0.0549356379,
0.011816185,
-0.0138619849,
0.0573636219,
0.0025703991,
-0.0152510088,
0.0309244506,
0.0185089856,
-0.0353560038,
-0.037626233,
0.0066581117,
0.0441001989,
0.0180016756,
-0.0361203067,
-0.0009052732,
0.0245318841,
0.0073339231,
-0.0361876674,
0.043961931,
-0.0947392583,
-0.0271150693,
-0.0108482325,
0.0029801531,
0.0106730964,
-0.0067917323,
-0.0234905332,
-0.0187016614,
0.0484302603,
0.0248336028,
0.0452781171,
0.0199032072,
-0.066404976,
-0.0456867702,
0.0163527988,
-0.0821143836,
-0.03737057,
-0.0528150536,
-0.0174519178,
-0.0245280899,
-0.0853316709,
-0.0197172221,
2.567133414e-34,
0.0032459013,
0.0261936709,
0.0239544846,
0.0256462358,
0.0229066331,
-0.0118914675,
-0.0037901895,
0.0310805626,
-0.0024548871,
-0.0716174096,
-0.0470498689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05295v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05295v2 | Visual Storytelling with Question-Answer Plans | 2023-10-08T21:45:34 | 2023-10-17T22:43:08 | Danyang Liu, Mirella Lapata, Frank Keller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Visual storytelling aims to generate compelling narratives from image
sequences. Existing models often focus on enhancing the representation of the
image sequence, e.g., with external knowledge sources or advanced graph
structures. Despite recent progress, the stories are often repetitive,
illogical, and lacking in detail. To mitigate these issues, we present a novel
framework which integrates visual representations with pretrained language
models and planning. Our model translates the image sequence into a visual
prefix, a sequence of continuous embeddings which language models can
interpret. It also leverages a sequence of question-answer pairs as a blueprint
plan for selecting salient visual concepts and determining how they should be
assembled into a narrative. Automatic and human evaluation on the VIST
benchmark (Huang et al., 2016) demonstrates that blueprint-based models
generate stories that are more coherent, interesting, and natural compared to
competitive baselines and state-of-the-art systems. | [
0.0325889103,
0.0312887579,
-0.0173557121,
0.0387215242,
-0.0139266159,
0.0107567897,
-0.0319500938,
0.009246896,
0.0056912289,
-0.0186639894,
0.0417759754,
0.0030142895,
0.0001495948,
0.1083279327,
0.0098187681,
-0.1124241725,
-0.0023674532,
-0.0098095704,
0.0262730755,
0.0124968532,
0.0344483741,
0.0205985885,
-0.0009902263,
0.0441660546,
-0.0091063175,
-0.0009376185,
-0.021540843,
0.0107545517,
0.0195845515,
-0.0439055562,
-0.0519731902,
0.009167932,
0.071181573,
-0.0217478797,
0.0000016188,
-0.0060323379,
0.0207770057,
-0.0297949314,
0.0040747579,
-0.0240963083,
-0.0297523271,
-0.0242942888,
0.0478749983,
-0.0189699624,
-0.0559698083,
0.002346186,
0.0494798049,
0.0615065955,
0.0972777084,
0.0402453169,
-0.0271852892,
-0.0489611551,
0.0006260134,
-0.0000356834,
0.0425170995,
0.0004037002,
-0.0219047442,
0.0473945998,
0.0509019531,
0.0085007288,
-0.0486281626,
0.0471497513,
0.0405949019,
-0.0099854767,
0.0297583379,
0.0600388348,
0.0081356689,
-0.0101777976,
-0.0430740528,
0.1144956648,
-0.0405605696,
0.0073518134,
-0.0112713249,
-0.0273357891,
-0.0030611865,
-0.0018224522,
-0.0941040069,
0.0329581909,
-0.0115259616,
0.0059108748,
-0.0369270407,
-0.0006366645,
-0.0017633688,
-0.0326294973,
0.0345065743,
-0.0135084381,
0.0062538306,
0.0247607809,
-0.0612822995,
0.0242195148,
-0.0316507667,
-0.0992374197,
-0.0023973028,
0.0554552861,
0.020726826,
0.0396563262,
-0.0299428385,
0.0310181174,
-0.0383815207,
-0.0184573568,
0.0409780294,
0.0180570707,
-0.0302331671,
0.0715082064,
-0.0190485734,
0.0673620552,
0.0129384883,
0.0019739154,
-0.0537859574,
0.0447612703,
-0.0303273797,
0.0053941291,
-0.0526975021,
0.0193878096,
-0.0818166062,
-0.0677721947,
0.0208310317,
0.0295715649,
0.0296906792,
0.0125717241,
-0.0100320354,
0.0445698723,
-0.0009661796,
0.0054746694,
-0.0741807669,
0.0452583507,
-0.0662009791,
-0.0282654092,
0.0117625492,
-0.0090248259,
-0.0106107937,
0.002028377,
0.026019359,
-0.0077664037,
-0.0320776328,
0.0510121733,
-0.0314800814,
-0.0080144471,
-0.0224412475,
-0.052471742,
-0.0013407741,
-0.025825059,
0.037891347,
-0.0455504619,
0.0622594617,
-0.0034716572,
0.016832497,
-0.028064644,
0.0036078843,
0.0301256906,
-0.049774278,
0.0616489761,
-0.0064000888,
-0.0052081803,
-0.0040670787,
0.0507318228,
0.05043111,
0.0459773056,
0.0456772447,
0.0546691641,
0.0605848543,
0.0076593156,
0.0296959728,
0.0036952675,
-0.0017067284,
-0.0109475199,
-0.0298647117,
0.0433702283,
0.0216284283,
0.06232813,
-0.002958359,
0.0416094996,
-0.0497070737,
-0.0318460986,
0.075678207,
0.0656434074,
-0.0067526391,
-0.0153355263,
0.0758885369,
-0.005299475,
0.0003947916,
0.0418937393,
-0.0180374831,
0.0810770765,
0.0273527279,
-0.004387808,
-0.0013866756,
-0.0033615136,
-0.0377559774,
-0.0262109414,
-0.0079313619,
0.0122927511,
0.0036080268,
-0.0145771736,
-0.0248994362,
0.0381613411,
-0.0890574902,
-0.0254226625,
-0.0205390099,
-0.0687496662,
0.0321650729,
0.0059674331,
0.0652277991,
0.0728585273,
0.059958864,
0.0270409863,
-0.0127297873,
-0.003855028,
0.0178714655,
0.003976502,
0.0159533527,
-0.0251185261,
0.0287509747,
-0.0452383123,
-0.0282370225,
-0.0511458665,
-0.028032871,
0.0030766164,
-0.0093245106,
0.0109308362,
-0.0118942903,
-0.0208768565,
-0.016536897,
0.0467866994,
-0.0006769954,
-0.0115639176,
-0.0331037119,
0.0155102191,
-0.0423209183,
0.0023655663,
-0.0072406856,
0.0070222537,
0.0330679379,
-0.0253815018,
0.0013432931,
0.0337801799,
-0.0781531334,
-0.0936950594,
0.0057421532,
-0.08762905,
-0.0000415417,
-0.040347673,
-0.0290538892,
-0.0341650508,
0.0212756991,
-0.0459897295,
-0.0012353236,
-0.0187826566,
-0.0246952474,
0.048816748,
-0.0051884027,
-0.0203494858,
0.0540067367,
-0.0159176011,
-0.0047994619,
-0.0271819867,
-0.0110763088,
0.0051978058,
-0.044690147,
0.0075213024,
0.0450249799,
0.021878466,
-0.0197062027,
0.027707193,
0.0068161953,
-0.053940244,
0.0132784611,
-0.0890654176,
-0.0283235144,
0.0019255381,
-0.0430086888,
0.0019003375,
0.00439246,
-0.0063088164,
-0.0447663888,
-0.0558203608,
0.0200206395,
-0.0042455359,
0.0070573012,
0.0412936397,
0.0460331701,
0.0323939212,
-0.020026939,
-0.0092236474,
0.0065681092,
0.0727669969,
0.0667247474,
0.0111890091,
-0.0316673629,
-0.0180214383,
-0.0502454899,
0.0070917848,
-0.0054782531,
-0.0004239524,
0.0348949172,
-0.0163545702,
0.0529529117,
0.0459455475,
-0.0093197748,
0.0293627232,
0.0080234529,
-0.0496443585,
-0.0238242876,
0.0146664046,
-0.0370392092,
0.0185592268,
-0.0214042626,
-0.036540892,
-0.0092527196,
0.0404616147,
-0.0034569583,
0.0330317207,
-0.0807702467,
0.0423944145,
0.0350922979,
-0.0063144499,
-0.0553134456,
-0.0409918316,
0.022887947,
0.059720166,
-0.0382283665,
-0.0467807353,
0.0750396773,
-0.0348830447,
-0.0233133081,
0.0268152878,
0.0368689448,
-0.049877774,
0.1058280244,
0.0242373683,
0.018001195,
0.0221729483,
0.0034029332,
-0.0482221209,
-0.0246099513,
0.0154826734,
-0.0141335428,
0.0159192365,
-0.0584802404,
-0.0351020023,
0.0037567697,
-0.0302238539,
-0.0375193618,
-0.0319940671,
-0.0254596956,
-0.0289793182,
-0.0059515103,
-0.0138253663,
-0.0118530095,
0.0305244774,
0.0088041574,
0.0041392017,
-0.0045393291,
-0.0061463313,
-0.004739664,
0.081340231,
0.0924777761,
0.0325471349,
-0.006753766,
-0.0471866019,
0.0524907559,
0.0520824641,
0.0119055938,
-0.0113452403,
-0.0042846128,
0.0551093705,
0.0076052556,
-0.0023727259,
0.0002030465,
0.0255659148,
0.0649620667,
-0.0485953875,
-0.024147084,
0.0630887598,
0.0414390974,
-0.0119961305,
-0.008566427,
0.0144404825,
0.0364198349,
0.026440328,
0.0370077752,
-0.0972298011,
-0.0221550297,
-0.0051475181,
-0.0257826727,
0.0244654249,
-0.036308758,
-0.053040728,
-0.0808747038,
0.0495451353,
0.0065786005,
0.004426897,
0.0053382879,
-0.0107388226,
-0.0328961946,
0.0262203198,
-0.0305702854,
0.0035120486,
-0.0174049847,
0.0182033647,
-0.0330769457,
-0.0218934268,
0.0240429454,
0.0106724147,
-0.0243714191,
-0.0137251932,
0.0669633523,
0.0254183002,
0.0229914878,
-0.0238825306,
-0.036284674,
-0.0077172415,
0.0029801528,
-0.0169068594,
0.0701494068,
-0.045694232,
-0.0257000607,
-0.0052272552,
0.0298805498,
0.0013317073,
-0.0527879633,
0.0166997947,
0.0407120399,
-0.0228684042,
-0.0421922989,
-0.0550731942,
0.0283136573,
0.007385633,
0.0535930283,
0.0567504615,
-0.0261732936,
-0.0321468562,
-0.0237091146,
0.0325361788,
-0.0855451748,
-0.0522617176,
-0.0250863563,
0.0284197424,
0.0353220627,
-0.0953300819,
-0.0545986891,
0.0457116701,
0.0530430377,
0.0035634192,
-0.0237368625,
-0.0083080567,
0.008714973,
-0.0492924675,
0.0449124724,
-0.0067382124,
0.0134474179,
-0.036130961,
0.0080977865,
-0.0240557045,
-0.041218102,
-0.0185955558,
0.0340373889,
-0.0680643618,
-0.0125289764,
-0.0488989092,
0.0505716987,
0.0101585919,
0.0343021378,
0.0206567198,
-0.0427562855,
0.03343907,
0.0045924527,
-0.0030293739,
-0.0039801896,
-0.0340364687,
0.0044322051,
0.0016254622,
-0.0022500616,
-0.0160495732,
0.0106004914,
0.0022973279,
0.0615456142,
-0.0277389325,
-0.0097718453,
0.0121945646,
-0.0120639503,
0.0132951653,
-0.0044930475,
-0.0034101361,
-0.0167952459,
-0.0167083368,
-0.0303105377,
-0.0091123264,
-0.0661692619,
0.0344203673,
0.0115015097,
0.0159081314,
-0.021539323,
0.0095246946,
-0.0273185,
0.0044030645,
-0.0458414815,
-0.0251201969,
0.041278135,
-0.040327616,
-0.0135258939,
0.0246260501,
0.0002944575,
0.0147510553,
-0.0494817607,
0.0531217307,
0.0046933698,
0.0540063083,
0.0147541603,
-0.0232544728,
0.0205852445,
0.020453928,
-0.0345949531,
-0.0586879514,
-0.0159900859,
0.0232606158,
0.0307958331,
0.0048890114,
-0.0115508167,
-0.0071024047,
0.0063373069,
-0.0001347867,
0.0008746773,
-0.0044447388,
-0.0411477722,
0.0407072492,
0.0423361547,
-0.0040768851,
0.0010730425,
0.0318778045,
0.0028923077,
0.0225971937,
0.0066956421,
-0.0194966774,
-0.0446881354,
-0.0099390401,
0.0139852921,
0.0432940125,
0.0227874927,
0.0331558846,
-0.0381471887,
-0.0477112681,
0.0227758288,
0.0350018218,
-0.0095406137,
0.0437881835,
0.0521063246,
0.022617707,
0.0134566026,
-0.0047169426,
-0.0170483757,
0.0115468754,
-0.0392136537,
-0.033388555,
0.004020005,
-5.538478652e-33,
-0.0266932305,
-0.042388007,
0.0327958167,
-0.021611413,
-0.0371569172,
0.0109355813,
-0.0416724794,
0.0218481757,
0.0048244349,
0.0200343858,
0.0190761127,
-0.0210279766,
-0.0055554793,
0.0220633913,
-0.0383394137,
-0.0036739497,
0.0238022488,
0.004391599,
-0.0401233509,
0.0278054941,
0.0179494265,
0.0234987382,
0.0232091714,
-0.0220081136,
-0.0151447738,
-0.0050970567,
-0.0137858549,
0.0201876331,
0.0659701377,
0.0687786862,
-0.037399698,
0.0070537478,
0.0163515396,
0.0150863361,
-0.039972771,
0.0368378907,
-0.0808384866,
-0.0383194499,
0.0395451747,
-0.0037219413,
-0.1140337288,
0.0070718969,
0.0214403626,
-0.0340294577,
0.0205345396,
-0.0405980796,
0.0658520982,
0.0061006229,
0.0091858162,
0.0326190367,
-0.0265558455,
-0.0082453899,
-0.031536188,
-0.0443846323,
0.0203353558,
0.044803299,
0.0544494763,
0.0230631512,
-0.0061810873,
0.0582891442,
0.0005681129,
0.0227814633,
0.0413047485,
0.0003034212,
-0.0011933127,
0.0764621496,
0.0244858321,
-0.0533802621,
-0.0487778261,
0.0330967419,
-0.0064685959,
0.0624797344,
0.0797015801,
0.0167923253,
0.0052609695,
0.0268422663,
-0.0391357839,
0.0290716309,
-0.0358119346,
0.0369615667,
-0.0034900988,
0.0158281717,
-0.0036772676,
0.0106501561,
-0.0529344603,
-0.0186246559,
-0.0343430154,
-0.0252577364,
0.0349136405,
0.0221156925,
0.0023136039,
0.0664969757,
0.0534712784,
-0.0285597108,
0.0036335669,
0.0213084333,
-0.0428982191,
0.0372932032,
0.0177407172,
0.0480630696,
-0.0096554793,
0.0241447426,
0.0631824955,
-0.0012884474,
0.0045434036,
-0.0085139787,
0.020888621,
0.0252577756,
-0.0299875736,
-0.0038028168,
-0.0224182215,
-0.0026132774,
-0.0174570996,
-0.0372453071,
0.026259914,
0.0328496918,
-0.0753426999,
0.0043880548,
-0.0114660207,
-0.0321334451,
-0.0221605226,
-0.0671877488,
-0.002901884,
0.0311770793,
-0.0372953862,
-0.0023247632,
-0.004030549,
-0.0060037454,
0.0060120709,
-0.0620664917,
-0.0242306832,
0.0634959415,
2.191e-7,
0.001101568,
0.0143842753,
0.0498666056,
0.0236242805,
0.0019965868,
0.0173598956,
-0.0037423256,
0.0051926267,
-0.0014314782,
-0.0677653551,
0.0205754787,
0.0613876171,
0.0148408124,
-0.0008304995,
-0.0499643795,
0.0380571336,
-0.0492931865,
-0.0103133796,
-0.0709434152,
-0.02212511,
0.1072725132,
0.0368502289,
0.0053289505,
0.0065277447,
0.0253826585,
-0.0490716361,
0.0775905028,
-0.0242610294,
-0.0184533801,
-0.0099951318,
-0.0454742685,
0.0237064343,
-0.0225732028,
-0.0325788483,
-0.0073800264,
-0.0234241076,
0.0537806712,
0.0324995928,
0.0031170512,
-0.0609209053,
-0.0207792353,
0.0145920701,
-0.0122486604,
-0.0411480628,
0.0752866268,
-0.0443426706,
-0.0240103044,
0.0125170592,
-0.0302487426,
-0.0085300887,
0.027368689,
-0.0090205288,
-0.0466036648,
0.0382553041,
0.0523496717,
0.0064992886,
0.0136972936,
-0.0910375789,
-0.0028806669,
0.0008866834,
-0.0221119504,
-0.0056936536,
-0.0663658008,
-0.0108168675,
-0.0376523696,
0.0004110281,
-0.0517402068,
1.851306487e-34,
0.0151034826,
0.0026766181,
0.0035409669,
0.0253270455,
0.0415406227,
-0.0087993778,
-0.0053034788,
-0.0154189039,
0.0323692933,
-0.0911128744,
-0.0510832407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05294v1 | Hi Guys or Hi Folks? Benchmarking Gender-Neutral Machine Translation with the GeNTE Corpus | 2023-10-08T21:44:00 | 2023-10-08T21:44:00 | Andrea Piergentili, Beatrice Savoldi, Dennis Fucci, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gender inequality is embedded in our communication practices and perpetuated
in translation technologies. This becomes particularly apparent when
translating into grammatical gender languages, where machine translation (MT)
often defaults to masculine and stereotypical representations by making undue
binary gender assumptions. Our work addresses the rising demand for inclusive
language by focusing head-on on gender-neutral translation from English to
Italian. We start from the essentials: proposing a dedicated benchmark and
exploring automated evaluation methods. First, we introduce GeNTE, a natural,
bilingual test set for gender-neutral translation, whose creation was informed
by a survey on the perception and use of neutral language. Based on GeNTE, we
then overview existing reference-based evaluation approaches, highlight their
limits, and propose a reference-free method more suitable to assess
gender-neutral translation. | [
0.0109506901,
0.0675094053,
-0.0296572652,
0.0330586135,
-0.0359545685,
-0.0017109347,
0.0432550646,
0.0071601104,
-0.0264328048,
-0.0420379341,
-0.0174852759,
-0.0652846098,
0.0510002933,
-0.0080675194,
-0.012057595,
-0.0156953447,
0.0210995916,
0.0406085774,
-0.0225133728,
-0.0178842656,
0.0322404169,
0.0213161781,
0.0117999418,
0.0577744246,
0.0102465367,
0.0032429104,
0.0251295157,
0.0764060169,
0.0110287433,
0.022593135,
0.0319723673,
0.0342508182,
-0.0241395254,
0.0592285953,
0.0000017851,
-0.0615335591,
-0.0046080193,
0.0241697915,
0.0187716074,
-0.0204460137,
0.0445403084,
-0.0054029031,
-0.0588035919,
0.0264375955,
-0.0195643511,
0.0015238061,
0.06082974,
-0.0300545655,
0.0423408709,
0.046195522,
-0.0199983977,
0.0167598184,
-0.0454599299,
-0.0341963507,
0.004623747,
-0.0130873136,
-0.02142388,
-0.0625660121,
-0.0455939807,
0.0191898271,
0.0002947141,
0.0565017834,
-0.0234808531,
-0.0347176716,
-0.0316694826,
-0.0022561483,
-0.053432636,
-0.0577009618,
0.0100603234,
0.0385754295,
0.0212634131,
0.0017846553,
0.006192063,
0.0144102313,
0.0090053678,
0.0029813219,
-0.0069957799,
-0.005177517,
-0.0079089114,
-0.0246203076,
-0.001724781,
0.0019301438,
0.00241044,
0.0094889048,
-0.026129121,
0.0644499436,
0.0358675979,
-0.0586625487,
0.0632653758,
0.0270479061,
0.0166674647,
-0.0116524836,
0.0239036102,
-0.0277283601,
0.016302878,
-0.0176195186,
0.0100821489,
-0.0600470752,
0.0419961102,
-0.0790782049,
0.0270827338,
0.0561264381,
0.0154995741,
0.0108558349,
0.0005344548,
0.0428353809,
0.0081530884,
-0.0345822796,
-0.0558209233,
-0.0285398383,
-0.035701558,
0.0202239566,
-0.0391082242,
-0.0414302051,
-0.0542600974,
0.0668723956,
-0.0226206481,
-0.0247534364,
-0.0273905545,
0.0212232359,
0.0123213436,
-0.0267857928,
-0.0250652041,
0.0233798958,
0.0088686887,
0.0459888801,
-0.0943793505,
-0.0124795604,
-0.0524820685,
-0.0915575027,
-0.0056515131,
0.0183159504,
-0.0113617415,
-0.0247489065,
-0.0338677838,
0.0266399477,
-0.0125531936,
-0.042486269,
0.0411565788,
-0.0068496522,
-0.0458973199,
-0.0771613047,
0.020728156,
-0.0550867617,
0.0496649332,
0.0346681029,
0.0362307988,
-0.0353219286,
-0.0130869001,
0.0102129104,
0.0282867309,
0.0419676676,
0.0475781523,
-0.0057937521,
0.0460873991,
0.0087058544,
-0.0242847465,
0.0705187246,
0.0448547155,
-0.017548617,
0.0471097827,
0.0425246283,
-0.0253863726,
0.0700114369,
0.0360592455,
0.0611280836,
-0.0172017589,
0.0410650633,
-0.0179447047,
0.0634113997,
0.0601545908,
0.0155836409,
0.0419499688,
0.0026323455,
0.035778299,
0.0418664329,
0.0048816088,
0.0355580896,
0.0509657972,
0.0238126609,
-0.000372264,
0.0057825106,
-0.037476927,
-0.0221123397,
-0.010145002,
-0.0267189704,
-0.0070723831,
0.0130761163,
0.0047750357,
-0.0476720594,
0.004937029,
0.0015046431,
0.0329801217,
-0.0266324505,
0.0247299429,
0.0177067574,
-0.017488813,
0.0297430977,
-0.0101997191,
-0.0857454985,
0.0023733289,
-0.0274716206,
-0.0034371275,
0.0425219983,
0.0191955306,
-0.0244358592,
-0.0145588182,
-0.020144999,
-0.0242927764,
0.0564029403,
0.0458820425,
0.0335762724,
0.03355534,
-0.0426887423,
-0.0214142874,
0.0646601543,
0.0331437625,
0.0361436941,
0.0227604769,
0.0860210508,
0.0491034985,
-0.0389182866,
-0.065884091,
0.0120205684,
0.0175636131,
-0.0101596788,
0.050396774,
-0.0060501774,
-0.0059469272,
0.0324899219,
-0.0512446873,
0.002531691,
0.0069368337,
-0.0322743244,
-0.0081681777,
0.0524441339,
-0.004950644,
0.0043144403,
-0.0104054017,
-0.0941600055,
-0.0664978549,
0.0278670024,
-0.02809049,
-0.0143914064,
0.0221080687,
-0.0430128351,
-0.0423849784,
-0.0104067419,
0.0243578292,
0.0063397735,
0.028749533,
-0.021283431,
-0.009780962,
-0.0223954767,
-0.000524777,
-0.001814012,
-0.0468194596,
0.0536158755,
-0.0559689999,
-0.0679120049,
0.0546091646,
0.0124889174,
0.0257187709,
0.0563025326,
0.0124065988,
-0.0330652855,
-0.0534198433,
-0.0698910207,
0.0101868408,
-0.0204949901,
0.0387879275,
0.0079050018,
0.049210988,
-0.015546483,
0.0181466192,
-0.0119754625,
0.0032701963,
-0.0024202624,
-0.0097574657,
0.0470639654,
-0.0248414725,
0.0326690823,
-0.0349371321,
-0.0083319815,
-0.0268867183,
0.0284491312,
0.0628979355,
0.0314628854,
-0.0269472208,
-0.0157954749,
-0.0270689689,
-0.0301934537,
0.0137147466,
-0.0638624132,
0.0288428813,
0.0203747563,
0.0480119772,
0.0854927972,
0.0114424657,
-0.0343146399,
0.038131319,
0.0110339811,
-0.0297276322,
-0.0010589903,
0.0340234041,
-0.0367611386,
0.0022512255,
-0.1153434888,
0.0222674068,
0.0053823255,
-0.018353045,
-0.0310418457,
-0.0491268747,
0.0270672217,
-0.0571599193,
-0.031174371,
-0.0228949264,
0.0312489625,
0.0107306018,
0.0484867357,
-0.0107372245,
0.0009819972,
0.0269993916,
-0.0298304502,
-0.0175078046,
-0.0259549003,
0.0204218179,
-0.0436605327,
0.0373685807,
-0.0361526683,
0.0115274815,
-0.0188838355,
-0.0006580121,
-0.0318593942,
-0.0334314778,
0.0637198091,
-0.0208025742,
0.0302348062,
-0.0781761855,
0.0210283566,
-0.00502356,
-0.0264954958,
-0.0189881027,
0.0136595303,
0.0053302511,
0.0061321645,
0.0196419079,
-0.0414350517,
-0.0234954152,
0.0203720424,
-0.0160656516,
0.064715609,
-0.0150042595,
-0.0088147121,
-0.0055640736,
0.0040012691,
-0.0311499592,
0.0111856153,
0.0011428334,
-0.002932061,
-0.0249267425,
0.0243271179,
-0.0238213427,
0.0338556878,
-0.0083744377,
-0.0174245127,
0.0324401595,
-0.0346224718,
-0.0393531397,
-0.0441194847,
0.0331130773,
-0.0360415876,
-0.0273184031,
0.0974089801,
0.021741448,
-0.0739542544,
-0.0129234204,
-0.0203844924,
0.0540321954,
0.0049598934,
0.0190519523,
-0.0853907987,
0.0138059389,
0.0309454706,
0.0477109179,
-0.0141148809,
-0.0351313353,
-0.0205483865,
-0.0921650752,
-0.0039724004,
0.029540414,
-0.0528291576,
-0.0459117591,
-0.0093973931,
-0.0232566353,
-0.0282935463,
0.0056753084,
-0.0078893956,
0.0098618194,
0.0002494922,
-0.0397864282,
0.0040245033,
-0.0427590422,
0.0084581822,
-0.0680306107,
0.0341505036,
0.0317115001,
0.0828397721,
-0.0166407656,
0.0100991298,
0.0245268457,
-0.0293261409,
-0.0144878104,
-0.0307426453,
0.0085944273,
-0.0138441455,
-0.0105216773,
-0.0181048699,
-0.0038242252,
0.0378727205,
0.0258039609,
0.0474886373,
-0.0212501399,
0.0147545775,
-0.0102345236,
-0.0232340507,
-0.0023265709,
0.0516085252,
0.0660966039,
0.0188953821,
-0.0295717008,
-0.0115111889,
-0.0313493498,
0.0156628136,
-0.0302423835,
-0.0638118833,
-0.0128301689,
-0.0165224336,
-0.0598700866,
-0.0846346691,
-0.0733067095,
-0.0050466475,
0.001472499,
0.0087776817,
-0.0833804682,
0.0097707696,
0.0216587633,
-0.0604617521,
0.0447663479,
-0.0028585801,
0.0309178755,
-0.0224784464,
-0.0046477751,
-0.0399610326,
0.0162729435,
-0.0210873168,
0.0638014004,
0.0024994086,
-0.0470744148,
0.0073836306,
0.0592042059,
0.027213376,
0.0209208373,
-0.0451549441,
-0.0373199582,
-0.0091117546,
0.0453074574,
-0.0018132428,
0.0240032636,
0.0556941815,
-0.0182452258,
-0.0007050774,
0.0575611293,
-0.0141925728,
0.0034366383,
-0.0496532805,
0.0245347247,
0.0099966303,
-0.0475829169,
0.0122831641,
0.0141522624,
-0.0204401743,
-0.0748620108,
0.0240370054,
-0.0237633232,
0.0025222574,
-0.02781846,
-0.0276862942,
-0.0255115256,
-0.0237766542,
0.033363618,
0.0086829001,
-0.0038125128,
0.0025645767,
-0.09013284,
-0.0021679185,
0.0124973701,
-0.0048717447,
0.0158783142,
0.0806104988,
-0.0116158053,
0.0219508354,
0.0086374562,
0.0041081295,
-0.0183198024,
0.0499214604,
-0.0209947247,
0.0144284936,
0.007772367,
0.0430443287,
-0.0031789546,
0.0241140351,
0.0011445441,
0.0329510272,
-0.0010559433,
0.0300029162,
0.0439436771,
-0.0043263254,
0.1198032051,
0.0016540664,
-0.0071503278,
-0.0032776005,
0.0099618193,
0.024179725,
0.0252127741,
-0.0204590186,
-0.016600756,
0.0425397828,
0.0029271552,
0.0225920305,
0.010226815,
0.0038542096,
-0.000950937,
-0.0098717185,
-0.0186017677,
-0.0262152404,
-0.031020049,
-0.0522844978,
-0.0116760992,
-0.0379833616,
-0.0790482685,
-0.054049056,
-0.0208849926,
0.0068623042,
0.0463245772,
-0.0015136084,
-0.0014463402,
0.0646058172,
-0.0338275917,
-0.0332906805,
-0.0543120466,
0.0336561203,
-0.021317251,
-0.0008956916,
-0.0832826346,
-5.926305463e-33,
-0.0281578153,
-0.0250479244,
-0.0299339741,
0.0130852852,
-0.03279927,
0.0087392945,
-0.0330994129,
-0.0019721629,
0.0147925001,
0.0286930092,
-0.0236956663,
0.0258014463,
0.0221428331,
-0.0382622518,
0.0116395233,
0.0233963225,
0.0605231896,
0.0230035372,
-0.0692603514,
-0.0199439861,
-0.0138058104,
-0.0166553501,
0.0553179197,
-0.0924202502,
0.1343461722,
-0.0573625006,
-0.0433723778,
0.0043268995,
-0.0105277756,
-0.0096770311,
0.0342796333,
0.0399182141,
0.009988985,
-0.0085446145,
0.0440366454,
0.0505077988,
-0.0790493861,
-0.0345620662,
0.0382347964,
0.042803064,
0.0458697081,
-0.0313967653,
0.033146251,
-0.0095098764,
-0.0644410104,
0.0066398592,
0.0296526235,
0.019376833,
0.0457480215,
0.0118322838,
-0.0480678678,
0.0133989342,
-0.0344946496,
-0.0117775798,
0.0247580688,
0.0672528446,
-0.0069126477,
-0.0370910577,
-0.0647510067,
0.0364109389,
-0.0447370335,
0.0052813422,
0.0458152704,
-0.0197211206,
0.0035038348,
-0.0205522832,
0.0530248694,
0.0280780345,
0.0003116057,
-0.0418656021,
0.055091083,
-0.0645642877,
0.0447735488,
0.0599156246,
0.0470415577,
-0.0030087302,
-0.0319907628,
0.0105559668,
0.0321476199,
0.0235876963,
-0.0424165539,
-0.0306938495,
-0.0805993229,
-0.0336798467,
-0.0562704541,
-0.0874017701,
-0.0016884832,
-0.0205766093,
0.0155134145,
-0.0229699947,
-0.0457638875,
-0.0048837918,
0.0107416036,
-0.0340666436,
-0.0219430979,
0.0189647563,
-0.0141244577,
-0.0188458059,
0.0242415201,
0.0547188632,
-0.0080975397,
0.0015187104,
0.0161154233,
0.0511979498,
0.0301294588,
-0.0132970624,
-0.0075852904,
0.0080959341,
-0.0534668006,
-0.008618569,
-0.040668875,
0.0151832867,
-0.0490326136,
0.0336461514,
-0.0043819668,
0.0423163772,
0.0066700699,
0.007486504,
0.0665031448,
0.0734178871,
-0.0464352667,
0.0215715952,
0.0127353799,
0.0393476151,
-0.0484095328,
0.006329868,
0.0029189528,
0.0265248064,
0.0557375588,
-0.03723564,
-0.0216796566,
-0.0640572682,
2.554e-7,
0.0360361002,
0.0545226112,
0.0124708433,
0.0493735932,
-0.0057460899,
0.0302416552,
-0.0041949986,
0.0598265752,
0.026756119,
0.0789972693,
-0.0108710602,
0.0288361236,
0.0160686467,
0.0369641706,
-0.0678002089,
-0.0478454567,
-0.0211230684,
0.0296531115,
-0.0176107921,
0.0437233746,
0.0183164813,
0.0462121852,
0.0189774595,
0.0233544167,
-0.0340669528,
-0.0347007662,
0.0512036197,
0.0009285614,
-0.0172677971,
0.0276678354,
0.0495342575,
0.0161850955,
-0.013817898,
0.0014415249,
0.0038309461,
-0.0093803611,
0.022545021,
0.05320758,
-0.00290358,
0.0148414131,
0.0209454224,
-0.0456038304,
-0.0338729136,
-0.0300048925,
0.0347883403,
0.0088015385,
0.0107261976,
0.0039251251,
-0.0375057794,
0.0261541028,
0.0755361244,
-0.0351850688,
-0.0670205951,
0.0308206044,
0.0469688214,
-0.0086981542,
-0.0157654099,
-0.0162048973,
-0.0574935041,
-0.0216715895,
0.0229522511,
-0.0670404807,
0.0010697509,
0.0519087277,
-0.0153945368,
-0.0015675484,
0.0296235401,
1.83644911e-34,
0.0247439705,
-0.0014690663,
-0.0035237614,
-0.0035780475,
0.0381881706,
-0.0156086106,
-0.016809199,
0.005968085,
0.0261542108,
0.028166933,
0.0055885054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05280v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05280v5 | Are Personalized Stochastic Parrots More Dangerous? Evaluating Persona Biases in Dialogue Systems | 2023-10-08T21:03:18 | 2023-11-02T23:06:36 | Yixin Wan, Jieyu Zhao, Aman Chadha, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models empower them to follow freeform
instructions, including imitating generic or specific demographic personas in
conversations. We define generic personas to represent demographic groups, such
as "an Asian person", whereas specific personas may take the form of specific
popular Asian names like "Yumi". While the adoption of personas enriches user
experiences by making dialogue systems more engaging and approachable, it also
casts a shadow of potential risk by exacerbating social biases within model
responses, thereby causing societal harm through interactions with users. In
this paper, we systematically study "persona biases", which we define to be the
sensitivity of dialogue models' harmful behaviors contingent upon the personas
they adopt. We categorize persona biases into biases in harmful expression and
harmful agreement, and establish a comprehensive evaluation framework to
measure persona biases in five aspects: Offensiveness, Toxic Continuation,
Regard, Stereotype Agreement, and Toxic Agreement. Additionally, we propose to
investigate persona biases by experimenting with UNIVERSALPERSONA, a
systematically constructed persona dataset encompassing various types of both
generic and specific model personas. Through benchmarking on four different
models -- including Blender, ChatGPT, Alpaca, and Vicuna -- our study uncovers
significant persona biases in dialogue systems. Our findings also underscore
the pressing need to revisit the use of personas in dialogue agents to ensure
safe application. | [
0.0656084642,
0.0558420569,
-0.0506155342,
0.0221007895,
0.0285179131,
0.0088441791,
0.0411165319,
-0.0060959985,
0.0100710141,
-0.0198733322,
-0.0450707413,
-0.014148782,
0.0300594848,
0.0369614512,
0.030158801,
-0.0923898667,
0.0375094749,
0.0010625264,
0.0315685347,
-0.0078663016,
0.0396717116,
0.029823903,
0.0010295429,
0.1084126011,
-0.0368309878,
-0.0479873605,
0.0182908233,
0.0184789076,
0.0437904671,
-0.0138923032,
0.0420998782,
0.0267683044,
-0.0078719966,
0.0473345481,
0.0000018352,
-0.065008834,
0.0372045301,
0.0016909734,
-0.0198855549,
0.0020957545,
0.0487631112,
0.0646788329,
-0.0250275247,
0.0447501093,
-0.0330385678,
-0.016410822,
0.0659006611,
0.0301752966,
0.0781122968,
0.0233535245,
-0.0142926807,
-0.0109831523,
-0.0221319161,
0.0184651408,
0.0056222631,
-0.0531381071,
0.0115611646,
-0.0319306329,
-0.0224286672,
-0.0297517031,
0.0154995369,
-0.0049453131,
-0.0144816134,
-0.0126055488,
0.0060692425,
0.0018972857,
-0.0294651911,
-0.0742831156,
0.0076693697,
0.1105537713,
0.040775381,
-0.0053636837,
-0.0260623191,
0.0199419968,
0.0313150287,
-0.0161153991,
-0.0014538149,
0.0165096149,
-0.0285768099,
-0.0323832855,
-0.0500046015,
0.0253671277,
0.0030969272,
0.0162019525,
0.0001808948,
0.0220278632,
0.0140558518,
-0.0032217361,
-0.0074138492,
-0.0226061642,
0.0276481248,
-0.0484654196,
0.0038660092,
0.0076244222,
-0.0729541183,
0.0230119415,
-0.0619650073,
-0.0041215885,
0.0309516434,
-0.0733578056,
0.0041959528,
0.0606317706,
-0.0105071319,
0.0062680072,
0.0341693573,
0.0248561315,
-0.000892284,
-0.0214523934,
0.0079957349,
0.0155143887,
-0.0072418274,
-0.0286900327,
-0.0248010773,
0.0016847268,
0.0065303533,
0.0230807886,
-0.01620242,
0.0291235968,
-0.0640278906,
0.0206885878,
-0.0316908509,
0.0335151814,
-0.0453212149,
0.0082946261,
-0.0479125902,
0.0031503581,
-0.0835070089,
0.0028245926,
-0.008228085,
-0.0942875743,
0.0229808781,
-0.002893216,
0.0088577569,
-0.010635497,
-0.0226214975,
0.0865070522,
0.0120579721,
-0.0169555917,
0.0170976985,
-0.0253588352,
-0.0270899776,
-0.0563832298,
-0.0571547486,
-0.0280604698,
0.0118753416,
-0.000397148,
-0.0027906997,
-0.0488383137,
0.0232158806,
0.0396575108,
-0.0317746624,
0.0637425706,
-0.0168314427,
0.0300935283,
0.0543824434,
0.0386407226,
-0.0436137579,
0.0689017773,
0.047681544,
-0.0006283112,
0.031121321,
-0.0397169292,
0.0363165103,
0.0428999774,
-0.0194870159,
0.0006431762,
0.0064075384,
0.0154633438,
0.0120473281,
-0.0203580111,
0.0334636085,
0.0563905351,
-0.0353830047,
-0.0527524352,
0.0848300532,
0.0443280116,
-0.0977276042,
0.0434242152,
0.0315335169,
0.0084508043,
0.0014478236,
-0.0071537537,
-0.0454664268,
-0.0104142278,
-0.0225087963,
-0.0402394719,
-0.0080270479,
0.0499327146,
-0.0277139358,
-0.0122725302,
0.008369986,
0.0003965382,
0.0550477616,
-0.0040801759,
-0.0206257924,
0.0303724296,
-0.0201426446,
0.0416728593,
0.0277059898,
-0.0624495707,
-0.0352844633,
-0.0373793021,
0.0151240425,
0.079401955,
0.021493908,
-0.0032561827,
-0.0247266348,
-0.0526980944,
-0.0454709455,
0.0449454337,
0.0570484102,
-0.0231924132,
0.0197344981,
-0.0104045654,
0.0069028446,
0.0382253863,
0.0022311783,
0.0520701818,
0.0580798984,
0.0472628623,
-0.0088174446,
0.0196424127,
-0.0223180223,
-0.0069199158,
-0.0453293584,
-0.0215346385,
-0.023441948,
0.0228816718,
0.0445728898,
0.006513909,
-0.0216448791,
-0.0355962701,
-0.0153296869,
0.0336856619,
-0.006933073,
0.0628854632,
-0.0497719347,
0.0171556585,
0.0398330167,
-0.0277089048,
-0.0519212224,
0.036963515,
0.01809288,
0.0254600048,
0.0503047407,
-0.0282943435,
0.0282820687,
0.0008341546,
0.0056872056,
-0.033800263,
0.0360074006,
-0.0203376152,
0.0003484248,
0.0022516849,
-0.0401103124,
0.007102109,
-0.0060572107,
-0.002668154,
-0.0788293332,
-0.0443332307,
0.001758978,
-0.0087224003,
0.0200539697,
0.0019480779,
-0.0166800804,
-0.0580692925,
0.0022742513,
-0.0950933099,
-0.0262487605,
0.0036457421,
-0.0300724208,
-0.0026963977,
0.0296078995,
-0.0368967615,
-0.0178939812,
-0.0358536243,
-0.0274914168,
-0.0010420235,
0.0451023243,
0.0188277718,
-0.0240179915,
-0.0382998064,
-0.0554426573,
0.010700359,
-0.0167259295,
0.0436565727,
-0.0116221197,
-0.0184223764,
-0.0158589166,
-0.0242755916,
-0.0571968146,
0.0098387701,
-0.011811614,
-0.0704058856,
0.0680748671,
0.056115061,
0.0459969565,
0.0789839178,
0.0581106916,
0.0673885196,
-0.0044638873,
0.0031228082,
-0.0452577658,
0.0139647424,
0.004266989,
-0.0163680352,
-0.0057185297,
-0.0887863487,
-0.0012271361,
0.0342602357,
0.0192827918,
0.0182378273,
-0.073564373,
0.0780558735,
0.0003628108,
-0.0759358779,
0.025569357,
-0.0630488619,
-0.0183156151,
0.0154705774,
-0.0223367233,
-0.0561104156,
0.0603697225,
-0.0222344324,
-0.0164041277,
0.0343129188,
0.0086494135,
-0.0009444534,
0.0433620289,
-0.0091323918,
0.0380758643,
0.0412603803,
-0.0151206339,
-0.0235625822,
-0.0400319807,
0.0297019165,
-0.054250434,
0.0188200865,
-0.0282081459,
-0.014083406,
0.0200872291,
-0.0439792238,
-0.0396157987,
-0.0274637248,
-0.0440405346,
-0.0410838164,
-0.0011953758,
-0.0302982163,
0.0037633015,
0.0220518075,
0.011060873,
-0.0334894769,
-0.0232103877,
-0.0026798237,
0.005257797,
-0.0490572006,
0.0463481247,
0.0356746502,
0.0419115759,
-0.0063291448,
0.0563758574,
0.0313071981,
-0.0008372799,
-0.0125154536,
-0.0132521475,
-0.0082808454,
0.0147861745,
0.0251500905,
-0.009039579,
0.0032863687,
0.0860096365,
-0.0266677793,
0.0201478004,
0.0713143572,
0.0080932202,
-0.0275855437,
0.0187307931,
-0.0098169567,
0.0531760864,
0.0241443664,
-0.0049455217,
-0.0648478046,
0.0048104683,
0.0103848781,
0.0345528461,
-0.0566870533,
-0.0568474904,
0.0053061531,
-0.1076688021,
0.0309599973,
0.0044700373,
-0.0556860492,
-0.003131323,
0.0066599273,
0.0302502215,
-0.0275452938,
0.052083768,
-0.0248440076,
0.0131448125,
-0.0077455556,
-0.0105150677,
-0.0814499483,
0.0089624757,
0.0209633335,
-0.0410916209,
0.069460243,
0.0650085807,
0.0488490984,
0.0047510508,
-0.0174436718,
-0.0134354429,
0.0286554284,
-0.0020782338,
-0.0013582696,
0.0580581091,
-0.0276237279,
-0.0139868818,
-0.0411220603,
-0.0034974618,
0.0034220717,
0.0036972938,
0.0198691264,
0.008728534,
0.0097535215,
-0.0271937698,
-0.0356007293,
0.017226629,
0.035145808,
0.0620130636,
0.0301470794,
-0.0593702793,
-0.0058255298,
-0.0509708524,
0.0036933844,
0.0088577755,
-0.0473656952,
-0.01702361,
-0.011021859,
-0.0944375247,
-0.0588625483,
-0.0654113814,
0.0007718122,
0.024531683,
0.0047952747,
-0.0492429771,
-0.0104135573,
0.0505814366,
0.0458977856,
0.0174232665,
-0.0294381864,
0.0386394672,
-0.0170800537,
0.0090310331,
0.0039031717,
-0.0315607749,
0.0163210202,
0.0103649292,
-0.010521316,
-0.0675189346,
0.0430370197,
0.0778765902,
0.0300643165,
0.0549568869,
-0.0074743121,
-0.0486202687,
0.0187656544,
0.0113688717,
0.0176047795,
0.0206174515,
0.0421235152,
0.0398133472,
-0.0069800527,
0.0188630298,
-0.014851043,
0.0122734345,
-0.020972345,
-0.0160678588,
-0.0693155751,
-0.0867144391,
-0.0036342111,
0.0273052789,
0.003320622,
-0.0026074899,
0.0135834245,
0.0074053914,
-0.0022189901,
-0.0269261599,
-0.0196461398,
-0.011498725,
-0.0345838331,
-0.0058970298,
0.0198838022,
0.0078428909,
-0.0368689485,
-0.0592992976,
0.058663439,
-0.0027702651,
-0.0018276384,
0.0482667312,
0.0354542024,
0.0183445029,
0.0067816447,
-0.024533052,
0.0267977789,
-0.0208912902,
0.0419893265,
0.0307417084,
0.0478558466,
0.0064677,
-0.0043675536,
0.0237858687,
0.0403150357,
-0.0060021821,
-0.0605912283,
0.0147418091,
0.0038736975,
-0.0102143493,
0.0024498771,
0.040175084,
0.0022351667,
0.0015207169,
-0.0112264669,
0.0097310171,
0.005157779,
-0.0518298298,
-0.0154624041,
0.0139859561,
-0.0354165919,
-0.0123606334,
0.035700649,
-0.0115538221,
0.0452155359,
-0.022778254,
-0.0478960723,
-0.0191445276,
-0.011801118,
0.016234573,
0.0102107003,
0.0085611101,
-0.0446541682,
-0.1009303033,
-0.060935501,
-0.009778602,
0.0047930526,
0.0144833699,
-0.0218488947,
0.0053143897,
0.0223112646,
0.0141956713,
0.0045588491,
-0.015877232,
-0.0109351631,
-0.0455479957,
0.0130876862,
-0.005080652,
-5.638043024e-33,
-0.0272147767,
-0.0306798834,
-0.0239190236,
0.0076357713,
-0.0473253131,
-0.056509465,
-0.0280464217,
0.0253948197,
-0.031102702,
-0.0099677332,
-0.0176234152,
-0.0002474918,
0.0092377858,
-0.0412644036,
-0.0120088859,
-0.0172291156,
0.0591521896,
0.0085505089,
-0.0409899987,
0.0115044257,
0.0221784003,
-0.0162161887,
0.0031824887,
-0.0969166979,
0.039505329,
-0.0089766253,
-0.0307439752,
-0.0159839634,
0.0042913933,
0.0508369245,
0.0069095669,
0.0651335046,
0.0063101379,
0.0338898078,
0.0020846238,
0.0597223379,
-0.0314114504,
-0.0309888422,
0.0053091366,
0.0171691589,
0.023053823,
-0.0292676259,
0.0161045566,
-0.000400517,
-0.0329413302,
0.0026838183,
0.0362980962,
-0.0158381276,
0.0404067002,
0.0357688963,
-0.0582093932,
-0.0089230919,
-0.032364931,
-0.0196924377,
-0.0556883067,
0.0507437028,
-0.0003693414,
-0.0062961676,
-0.0500631966,
0.0225719679,
-0.0261830725,
-0.0757017434,
0.0293674041,
0.0625729784,
0.0472022817,
0.0528937615,
0.0672494844,
0.0799587369,
-0.0419496223,
-0.0491167456,
0.0292434208,
0.0297920629,
0.0133687016,
0.0845474377,
-0.0157257654,
-0.0606679879,
0.0155617548,
0.0323207788,
0.0544629954,
0.0159339625,
0.020767929,
0.0065605622,
-0.0963144004,
-0.0262144972,
-0.0185532216,
-0.0215801727,
-0.0044129812,
-0.0547286198,
0.0187041387,
-0.0219905302,
-0.0361024477,
-0.0201744549,
0.0185650643,
-0.0409882069,
-0.0154579701,
-0.0253895652,
-0.0190836247,
-0.0171656813,
0.0070307991,
-0.0114449123,
-0.0084533421,
0.0114183044,
0.0233745761,
-0.0051275939,
0.0411183387,
0.0229712147,
0.0069992431,
0.0185714364,
-0.0689049661,
0.0029988859,
0.0077843545,
0.0601567402,
0.0022005581,
0.0688320026,
0.0390284732,
0.0084376531,
-0.0281976815,
-0.0047310926,
0.0341595076,
0.0174411517,
-0.0763562471,
-0.0007682486,
-0.0551528111,
-0.0075108591,
-0.0410168916,
-0.0246323552,
-0.0309432335,
0.0066384273,
0.0335679948,
-0.0687976778,
-0.0259150714,
-0.0647865981,
2.548e-7,
-0.0448698811,
0.0309905782,
0.0166938379,
0.0543633997,
0.0446738973,
0.0874821395,
0.0354250371,
0.0723952949,
0.0522323474,
-0.0544495657,
0.0083918553,
0.0250617377,
0.0435743816,
0.0726717412,
-0.0722982883,
-0.0069076633,
-0.0467099659,
0.0296168774,
-0.0329600647,
0.0105532343,
0.0449001491,
0.0541400872,
0.0339465551,
-0.0194416475,
0.0182759669,
0.0155218001,
0.0208993237,
-0.040354494,
0.0121914363,
-0.0038088963,
0.0286969393,
-0.0125376265,
0.0204802733,
0.0339249931,
0.0259183627,
0.0218982566,
-0.0129921902,
0.0367214903,
-0.041710522,
-0.0143653518,
0.0110378573,
-0.0028654824,
-0.0120785981,
-0.0635700971,
0.0292952582,
0.0183577184,
-0.0143418722,
-0.0225060228,
-0.0347391255,
-0.0241940133,
0.0419027917,
-0.0375234485,
-0.0374548249,
0.0206688922,
-0.0004809634,
-0.0145506933,
0.0152274799,
-0.0595011264,
0.0041705938,
-0.04304602,
-0.030239094,
-0.087532416,
-0.0018063037,
0.0083502224,
-0.0110667422,
-0.0053184638,
0.045093473,
1.819097827e-34,
-0.017552495,
0.0153859872,
0.0220027212,
-0.0159503892,
0.0695639923,
0.0351308919,
0.0336163752,
0.0022760516,
0.0594794266,
-0.0137578622,
-0.0057466263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05276v1 | Enhancing Pre-Trained Language Models with Sentence Position Embeddings for Rhetorical Roles Recognition in Legal Opinions | 2023-10-08T20:33:55 | 2023-10-08T20:33:55 | Anas Belfathi, Nicolas Hernandez, Laura Monceaux | cs.CL | cs.CL | The legal domain is a vast and complex field that involves a considerable
amount of text analysis, including laws, legal arguments, and legal opinions.
Legal practitioners must analyze these texts to understand legal cases,
research legal precedents, and prepare legal documents. The size of legal
opinions continues to grow, making it increasingly challenging to develop a
model that can accurately predict the rhetorical roles of legal opinions given
their complexity and diversity. In this research paper, we propose a novel
model architecture for automatically predicting rhetorical roles using
pre-trained language models (PLMs) enhanced with knowledge of sentence position
information within a document. Based on an annotated corpus from the
LegalEval@SemEval2023 competition, we demonstrate that our approach requires
fewer parameters, resulting in lower computational costs when compared to
complex architectures employing a hierarchical model in a global-context, yet
it achieves great performance. Moreover, we show that adding more attention to
a hierarchical model based only on BERT in the local-context, along with
incorporating sentence position information, enhances the results. | [
0.0682244599,
0.0348000675,
0.0060258131,
0.0366673805,
-0.0503265634,
0.0064672381,
0.001350912,
0.0000941072,
0.0058049294,
-0.1091158539,
-0.0189854037,
-0.0309630726,
-0.0441090167,
-0.0167521648,
-0.0061065517,
-0.0421344526,
0.0167813543,
0.0116536366,
0.1170992553,
-0.0062888828,
0.0509996824,
0.0216888767,
0.026449414,
0.0440191217,
-0.020758573,
-0.0430526808,
0.0104784407,
0.0200121179,
0.0171392988,
0.0099077951,
0.0526772924,
0.0509077162,
0.0312633924,
0.0117286369,
0.0000015113,
-0.0377988815,
0.0168855805,
-0.0280625969,
0.0384370722,
0.066153802,
0.0432072915,
0.0053902837,
-0.0166565944,
0.0348415859,
-0.0330148973,
0.0367869288,
0.0000377976,
0.0348902717,
0.0366280414,
0.1043017879,
-0.0106703294,
-0.022926202,
0.0256993212,
-0.0294223893,
-0.0047890609,
-0.0280422531,
0.0258729346,
-0.0062656193,
-0.0008018853,
0.0223913938,
0.0158779081,
0.0058038537,
0.0124265328,
-0.0410927422,
-0.0394226722,
-0.0085836975,
-0.0259622857,
0.0358965881,
-0.0043107555,
0.0043078032,
0.0210843943,
-0.0504677258,
0.0014545345,
-0.0071921712,
0.041509334,
0.0051384051,
-0.0064688227,
0.0905979276,
0.0230087042,
0.0177391209,
0.0553125218,
0.024315862,
-0.0143100442,
0.0411137082,
-0.0264180228,
0.0579471774,
0.0154261459,
-0.0654008985,
-0.0046594185,
0.0158827305,
-0.0164673347,
-0.0353283361,
0.0441588238,
0.0376222022,
0.0026238067,
0.0499681272,
-0.0404830165,
-0.0552683361,
0.056041535,
-0.0757309869,
0.025038192,
-0.0095526241,
-0.0137300817,
0.0502015203,
-0.0298506897,
0.0015351739,
-0.0121173756,
0.0153593514,
-0.0261128377,
-0.0222644489,
-0.0176132284,
-0.0600625314,
-0.0424488038,
0.0388261788,
-0.080586791,
-0.0225913022,
0.0012919956,
0.0034699175,
-0.0196012594,
-0.0050432961,
0.0037179159,
0.0256216284,
0.0017577331,
-0.0252299346,
-0.0110380352,
-0.0176627282,
-0.0272549503,
0.0223971512,
-0.0298846383,
0.0102680754,
0.007485508,
0.0296608154,
0.0073823067,
-0.010883485,
0.0060443925,
0.0441812277,
0.001256594,
-0.0368594863,
0.0104102688,
-0.03240861,
-0.0607421324,
-0.0467935875,
-0.0224220175,
-0.0257551838,
-0.0190117396,
-0.0046696193,
0.0020526885,
0.0068698796,
0.0329081081,
0.0461739451,
-0.04239548,
0.0354405679,
0.0197718907,
-0.032673046,
-0.0160316359,
-0.0068544261,
0.0820927322,
0.0481248237,
0.0333823673,
0.0097322799,
0.0319390632,
0.0244475547,
-0.0171835274,
0.025388103,
-0.0172755271,
0.0022018128,
0.0288495012,
0.0136452261,
-0.0417581648,
0.0378069729,
-0.0030244093,
0.0253084973,
0.0124190859,
0.0043533505,
0.01538976,
0.0650533587,
-0.0182629023,
0.0239112116,
0.0353744924,
0.0208452027,
0.0467522405,
-0.0095360857,
-0.0252477117,
-0.0000109819,
0.001711976,
-0.0077315704,
-0.0645940974,
0.0003032962,
-0.0182973817,
-0.0557043329,
-0.0057937112,
-0.0211219788,
-0.0425666533,
-0.0246003289,
0.010284232,
0.0120743606,
-0.0468900166,
0.049610272,
0.0200847648,
-0.0798579603,
-0.0355120972,
0.0356947854,
-0.0112658693,
0.0118707391,
0.041520521,
-0.0795517713,
-0.0488795601,
-0.020535877,
0.0005054708,
0.0550470278,
0.0193137042,
0.0043658707,
-0.023375202,
-0.0215964075,
-0.0351705849,
-0.0430171043,
0.0523145907,
0.0039155809,
0.010460102,
-0.0153377121,
0.0247173775,
-0.0469277874,
-0.0112595595,
0.0463016033,
0.0102541074,
-0.0196579807,
0.0330272056,
0.0139473397,
0.0329438858,
0.0226149168,
-0.0165684037,
0.0215773694,
0.0234668627,
-0.040095672,
0.0042386502,
0.0262650661,
-0.0521244034,
-0.0254052356,
0.0598264597,
-0.0341545157,
-0.0324804448,
0.0264493339,
-0.0476916917,
-0.0075579653,
-0.0011531892,
-0.0402875543,
0.0113721825,
-0.0640820861,
-0.0279300008,
-0.0105631594,
-0.0371828675,
-0.0292661376,
0.0456551947,
0.0096083274,
0.0058015813,
0.004121454,
0.0164869558,
0.0332789533,
0.0008762027,
-0.0547953472,
-0.0645410046,
-0.0158345792,
0.0060267639,
0.0347318202,
0.0045013679,
-0.0067845359,
-0.0460903011,
-0.1328847259,
0.0044130888,
-0.0416520908,
0.0183223728,
0.043888431,
-0.0445581488,
0.010490302,
-0.018756032,
-0.045248881,
-0.0385774709,
-0.0199055653,
-0.0192885194,
0.0619411655,
-0.0463795699,
0.0014133404,
-0.0210887454,
0.018110631,
-0.0555766039,
0.044505842,
0.0250941683,
0.003539654,
-0.0036757588,
0.0381409861,
0.0150109231,
-0.0040917732,
-0.012383,
-0.0394661911,
-0.0167675875,
0.0333500169,
0.0033990738,
0.0543939769,
0.0596497692,
0.0281253774,
0.0144761037,
0.0339485742,
-0.0296342038,
-0.00903924,
0.0046392768,
0.0308149289,
-0.054107789,
0.0287054684,
0.0242128633,
0.0415821858,
0.0026971055,
-0.0323579907,
-0.0009426921,
-0.0099294437,
-0.0060061491,
0.0157053787,
0.0028761092,
-0.033755675,
-0.046483472,
0.0097229443,
-0.0188658759,
-0.0314484872,
0.0297667198,
-0.0166866016,
0.0234633368,
-0.0654004067,
0.0035038632,
-0.0640768185,
0.0598433949,
0.0331781171,
0.0219668504,
-0.0298275538,
-0.0377118774,
-0.0002484163,
-0.0257117376,
0.0385194421,
-0.048548419,
0.044143755,
-0.0004912603,
0.0222733878,
-0.0314537399,
-0.0691652894,
-0.0180648472,
-0.053961657,
-0.0164734703,
0.0329259671,
0.0055174329,
0.0135925012,
-0.014340749,
-0.0404720008,
-0.0170769971,
0.0093145557,
0.0083379596,
0.0243747048,
-0.0502964444,
0.070255518,
0.0035147015,
0.0050601517,
-0.0290136281,
-0.0056590349,
0.0022389363,
0.0169591717,
-0.0520210713,
0.0099404007,
-0.0336718373,
-0.0164458267,
0.0195335131,
-0.0945452824,
-0.0048243646,
0.0032742999,
0.0285637099,
-0.030442534,
0.0138202626,
0.1182555854,
0.0390159711,
-0.0187161379,
-0.0129587557,
0.0240036156,
0.0279471204,
0.0408401489,
0.0246587452,
-0.1014223844,
0.0052897409,
-0.0060562799,
-0.0350425504,
-0.0371664464,
0.0040904889,
-0.0145747941,
-0.1066311523,
0.0547337458,
-0.0169320218,
0.0261737555,
-0.0076678437,
0.0118145989,
-0.0080244513,
0.0220942479,
-0.0013023169,
-0.0076509193,
-0.0268959627,
-0.0042158882,
0.0141553571,
-0.1115854904,
0.0136217466,
0.0017623499,
-0.0467424989,
0.0177405886,
0.0203301702,
0.0654058084,
-0.0241260752,
0.0015660565,
0.0095732622,
-0.0305439867,
-0.0100190714,
0.02286065,
0.0530002527,
-0.048650153,
0.0014507355,
-0.0251635704,
0.0323271118,
-0.0166041236,
-0.0331598222,
0.0351625681,
0.0412838422,
-0.0203260966,
0.0040520197,
-0.0492005646,
0.0387468599,
-0.0009195427,
0.0584171042,
0.0349303782,
-0.0432828367,
-0.06407471,
-0.0488379672,
-0.0030487261,
-0.0793373808,
-0.0268607736,
-0.0414387248,
0.0149160866,
0.0385778174,
-0.0449778251,
-0.0185649637,
-0.0126441792,
0.0420015976,
0.0339716002,
0.037430983,
0.0140289757,
-0.029531518,
-0.0585618131,
-0.0073472862,
-0.0322394073,
0.002033768,
0.0039279694,
-0.0142531116,
0.0578073785,
0.0103573455,
-0.0263919681,
-0.0385850109,
0.0011789163,
-0.0329720266,
-0.0098180482,
0.0098236203,
0.0053890967,
0.029307615,
-0.049239751,
-0.0431393534,
0.1071742401,
0.0448945984,
-0.019490853,
0.0147352479,
0.0648468137,
0.0095486222,
-0.0139388451,
0.0214148927,
-0.0006730395,
0.0226534121,
0.0363160074,
0.0118149752,
-0.0198390614,
-0.0009164733,
0.0151794776,
0.0167824514,
0.05747284,
0.0208606031,
-0.0105875833,
-0.0335896388,
0.0235704761,
-0.0421976149,
-0.0671886504,
-0.0472611599,
0.0158476029,
0.0217060689,
-0.0253339987,
-0.0469980426,
0.0608469993,
-0.0151998168,
0.0191480275,
-0.0071893726,
0.0489906445,
0.0374956615,
0.0187690742,
-0.0311121214,
-0.0171538237,
-0.0015061679,
0.0266257245,
-0.0337392204,
0.0315759927,
0.0231240634,
0.009268241,
0.0097116139,
-0.0047831484,
-0.0055181165,
0.0295809265,
-0.0670202151,
0.0050735953,
-0.0322034135,
0.0200716797,
0.0573510639,
-0.0602650121,
0.0260100774,
-0.0306065362,
-0.0113513777,
0.0023801643,
0.0454407707,
0.0180820487,
-0.0361684859,
0.0221986696,
0.0053288359,
-0.0318463184,
0.021584345,
0.0169072915,
0.0404416658,
0.0181921143,
0.0506915674,
-0.0235446114,
-0.0269182511,
-0.0493416041,
0.0436192676,
0.0266176686,
0.0003683505,
-0.0073417975,
-0.0547928475,
-0.0073390044,
0.0273562651,
0.0023215855,
-0.0137442779,
0.0033335343,
0.0141301015,
0.0411306731,
0.0034447196,
-0.0112978527,
-0.072845377,
0.0224283412,
-0.0065332577,
-0.0151146771,
-0.0129752178,
-5.045051307e-33,
-0.0368676744,
-0.0344114229,
-0.0296182055,
0.0270548835,
-0.0114283171,
0.0201188512,
-0.0103423623,
-0.0019377305,
0.0048517329,
0.0618102476,
-0.0111503396,
0.0168533716,
0.0135570932,
0.0367093422,
-0.0119478032,
0.010357229,
0.0115662841,
-0.0144695751,
-0.0139831239,
-0.0003803399,
0.0098678414,
0.0287797935,
0.0370931514,
-0.0675685704,
0.0244086534,
0.0199057888,
-0.028782919,
-0.0182110928,
-0.0482279174,
0.0354938991,
0.0037207862,
0.046066843,
0.0252603516,
0.0084276451,
-0.0061209034,
0.116905883,
-0.0545754284,
-0.0114084342,
0.0276089683,
-0.013651411,
-0.0023668436,
-0.0338534378,
0.0164654832,
0.0006692092,
-0.0163075719,
0.00760544,
0.063799791,
-0.0211244822,
-0.0076038423,
-0.0654734224,
-0.0844159052,
0.0313360356,
-0.0327478126,
0.0234847311,
0.011020489,
-0.0087103397,
0.0171752106,
0.0702344179,
-0.0402528234,
-0.0090832505,
-0.0456247926,
0.0272191484,
-0.0344689079,
-0.0511657856,
-0.0212789718,
0.0770449117,
-0.0332228541,
0.0154795004,
-0.0508180782,
0.0190785956,
0.0152296349,
0.0608617179,
0.0485800579,
0.0489157811,
0.0105832359,
0.0060036536,
-0.0842717886,
-0.0242674835,
0.0447012708,
0.0023216291,
0.0297193173,
-0.0355388634,
0.002264438,
-0.0205210075,
-0.0356555134,
-0.0729730725,
0.0038332946,
0.011742264,
0.0154166138,
0.0030292077,
0.0169559419,
-0.0075874957,
-0.0159326307,
-0.0488239042,
0.0190237854,
0.0465994775,
-0.0047900262,
0.0206223279,
-0.006874782,
0.0566344447,
-0.0422211252,
-0.0266817473,
-0.0052025616,
-0.0033567166,
-0.010202487,
-0.0338830091,
0.0771327689,
-0.0341959372,
-0.0685861111,
-0.0026127677,
0.0069473027,
-0.002707195,
-0.015865609,
0.0798840076,
0.000677579,
0.023265915,
0.0303538684,
0.0582694262,
-0.000444368,
0.0108822351,
-0.0236591678,
-0.0309191775,
-0.0152228661,
0.0015715405,
-0.0023552184,
-0.0155397505,
-0.002229474,
0.062898919,
-0.0152931847,
-0.0182747077,
0.028804088,
0.0216778256,
2.278e-7,
0.1318696886,
0.0367556363,
0.0170694534,
-0.0289939549,
0.038099587,
0.0244298577,
0.0222706012,
0.0678512976,
0.0144968517,
-0.0135523221,
0.0255607124,
-0.0041849483,
0.0270163175,
-0.0182840824,
-0.1282111108,
-0.0296988022,
-0.0765051544,
-0.0231292807,
-0.0361430608,
0.0298789274,
0.0479234755,
0.0891151503,
0.0104199424,
0.0034073675,
-0.0179888662,
-0.031490203,
0.0810756236,
-0.021790918,
-0.0339043215,
0.0216273777,
0.0373915434,
-0.0305862278,
-0.0116348276,
0.0163513776,
-0.0084585072,
0.080282703,
-0.0433170944,
0.0783893019,
0.0062740352,
-0.0156379156,
-0.036509309,
-0.013331946,
0.0214724094,
-0.0408538654,
0.0551823564,
-0.0447274037,
-0.011957068,
-0.0428086594,
-0.0467079617,
-0.008777421,
0.045579683,
0.0294294152,
-0.030104138,
-0.0186708234,
0.0220789872,
-0.0343548656,
0.0092923595,
-0.1357527971,
-0.0216862168,
0.0327225998,
-0.0323553421,
0.0233814064,
0.0054214243,
-0.0085037434,
0.0854734406,
-0.1001851484,
0.0293622259,
2.195621639e-34,
0.0498430543,
-0.0182866491,
0.0226335209,
0.037061166,
0.034990482,
0.0303695481,
0.0310789365,
-0.0040918016,
0.0165661275,
-0.041056212,
0.0334807523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05253v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05253v2 | Explainable Claim Verification via Knowledge-Grounded Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2023-10-08T18:04:05 | 2023-10-20T02:31:21 | Haoran Wang, Kai Shu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Claim verification plays a crucial role in combating misinformation. While
existing works on claim verification have shown promising results, a crucial
piece of the puzzle that remains unsolved is to understand how to verify claims
without relying on human-annotated data, which is expensive to create at a
large scale. Additionally, it is important for models to provide comprehensive
explanations that can justify their decisions and assist human fact-checkers.
This paper presents First-Order-Logic-Guided Knowledge-Grounded (FOLK)
Reasoning that can verify complex claims and generate explanations without the
need for annotated evidence using Large Language Models (LLMs). FOLK leverages
the in-context learning ability of LLMs to translate the claim into a
First-Order-Logic (FOL) clause consisting of predicates, each corresponding to
a sub-claim that needs to be verified. Then, FOLK performs FOL-Guided reasoning
over a set of knowledge-grounded question-and-answer pairs to make veracity
predictions and generate explanations to justify its decision-making process.
This process makes our model highly explanatory, providing clear explanations
of its reasoning process in human-readable form. Our experiment results
indicate that FOLK outperforms strong baselines on three datasets encompassing
various claim verification challenges. Our code and data are available. | [
0.0187552888,
0.0585430451,
0.0232608542,
0.0389571302,
-0.0050939322,
0.0112994416,
0.0055917823,
-0.0138757592,
0.0169675946,
-0.0257189311,
0.0331158005,
0.0084178299,
0.0186577979,
0.0400144532,
0.0423909314,
-0.0265374742,
0.0046100803,
-0.016044341,
0.0598376095,
-0.0106067285,
-0.0091303298,
0.0382448249,
-0.023737248,
0.0525513105,
-0.0366204791,
-0.034484379,
-0.0006109219,
-0.0072495751,
0.0120693231,
-0.0328591689,
-0.0048330724,
0.0263547469,
0.0524149351,
0.0311101768,
0.0000020219,
-0.0489527471,
0.0006874837,
0.040489547,
-0.0931991115,
0.0336387642,
-0.0430252925,
0.0186536629,
0.014133567,
0.0368367918,
0.0100271171,
0.0003980973,
0.0327209756,
0.0852578655,
0.1029686406,
0.0563188642,
-0.0043017324,
-0.0742717385,
-0.0047397595,
-0.0089408113,
0.0020046446,
-0.0418907963,
0.056619592,
0.0571603552,
-0.002505641,
0.0103206607,
0.0363056995,
0.00843882,
0.0026499897,
-0.0447169207,
-0.0320122354,
0.0235310439,
-0.0322612338,
-0.0111249099,
0.0122551555,
0.0784261525,
0.02469288,
-0.0521657243,
-0.0034486826,
-0.0070265904,
-0.0061748894,
0.0328428484,
-0.0301948562,
0.0734876543,
-0.0196729358,
0.004384262,
0.0142392656,
0.0053688842,
0.0575319529,
0.0245160405,
-0.0322363339,
0.072142683,
-0.0315404125,
-0.0309297591,
0.0306192283,
-0.0120671727,
0.0114477053,
-0.0840734765,
-0.0042512608,
0.0370259285,
-0.0140914591,
0.0264620278,
0.011355889,
0.0211780909,
0.0325389318,
-0.0671344772,
0.0041479119,
0.0126920147,
-0.0297575854,
0.0838798806,
-0.0472078845,
0.031869255,
-0.0157207958,
-0.0263384264,
0.0451825261,
-0.0419837274,
-0.0586104356,
-0.0106896926,
0.0051459838,
0.0386445187,
-0.0582930967,
0.0221430659,
-0.0365554132,
-0.0110338461,
-0.0344349183,
0.0401240438,
0.0126302922,
-0.0034928897,
0.0202718861,
-0.0631942376,
-0.0696797669,
0.0157577563,
-0.041401729,
0.0362045355,
0.0137868412,
-0.0305564925,
0.0004252892,
0.0237911399,
0.0109737087,
0.0125834197,
-0.0024705718,
-0.0172022302,
0.0434960835,
0.0232656766,
-0.0807135925,
-0.0550288372,
-0.0010272762,
-0.0539735742,
-0.0432954021,
-0.0346191414,
-0.0007704952,
0.0011192414,
-0.0118397083,
-0.0289718974,
0.0101153152,
0.0297049135,
-0.0448811874,
0.0724990517,
-0.0159352589,
-0.0057697957,
0.0006399655,
-0.0006358516,
-0.0028423404,
0.0308514368,
0.0200503562,
0.0139838075,
0.0386154354,
0.002773294,
0.0119485613,
-0.0330272056,
0.0689655542,
0.00693584,
0.0316498801,
0.0341457911,
-0.033530537,
-0.0042350325,
-0.0214782562,
0.009014044,
-0.0195419416,
-0.0080977613,
0.06998799,
0.0257844087,
-0.0189498924,
-0.0104861148,
0.0134274969,
-0.0026020578,
0.0034468165,
-0.0414465219,
-0.0463814586,
0.0265703313,
-0.076277554,
-0.0296682175,
0.0090443129,
0.0275822412,
-0.0228865389,
-0.0569604225,
-0.0275973678,
0.00037174,
-0.0167045835,
0.0347819701,
0.0149494614,
-0.0048728106,
-0.0279442463,
0.0466497988,
0.0419088602,
-0.0425074883,
-0.0371644869,
-0.0658525005,
0.0703025088,
0.0068791229,
0.0411188528,
-0.01661155,
0.0083544431,
-0.0406732745,
0.0550150648,
0.0323689915,
0.0138891097,
-0.018732585,
0.0039211432,
-0.0178475436,
-0.0336979739,
-0.0224361885,
0.0158715546,
-0.0189429019,
0.0632459968,
-0.0133885657,
0.0158200786,
-0.0451195203,
-0.0198518969,
0.0176063869,
-0.0116895055,
-0.0025526613,
0.0010896934,
0.0102514429,
0.030827852,
0.0272288006,
0.0248616431,
0.0099754846,
0.0249269456,
-0.0056825462,
-0.0411386937,
0.0271700509,
0.0483625382,
-0.0212378446,
0.0177279804,
-0.0281456597,
-0.037965674,
-0.0099553382,
-0.0547023192,
-0.0074723633,
-0.0400466174,
0.0009308492,
0.0147237666,
-0.0449269339,
-0.0297009088,
0.0031202412,
-0.017657984,
0.0026277117,
0.0892350227,
0.0153024103,
-0.023453692,
-0.0313598253,
-0.0015030162,
0.0161279757,
-0.0168460421,
0.0281348173,
0.0207406767,
-0.0173441339,
-0.0059389817,
0.0081253741,
-0.0419471934,
-0.017586343,
0.0501310937,
-0.0712322369,
-0.0069224504,
-0.0055171908,
-0.0087899622,
0.0036349515,
-0.0204927735,
0.0164573975,
0.0055004479,
-0.0247176047,
-0.0049854545,
0.0094767381,
0.007080839,
0.0431705676,
-0.0109776407,
-0.0026622259,
-0.0064001218,
0.0140393088,
-0.0161487926,
0.0670998916,
0.0436996669,
-0.0026594822,
-0.0696308017,
-0.0224722046,
-0.0541813336,
-0.0039602239,
-0.0146928523,
0.0176221412,
-0.0031565153,
0.0198283289,
-0.0443514511,
0.0417319126,
-0.0140750175,
0.037338037,
0.0078252591,
0.0345430337,
-0.0234645735,
0.0081824148,
-0.0282919649,
0.0115966192,
-0.0247407723,
-0.0149041321,
0.0114725996,
0.0585918166,
0.0039843069,
-0.0105991894,
-0.0609640852,
0.0385028236,
-0.0106592011,
0.0001486639,
-0.0288738105,
-0.0294397492,
0.009106352,
0.0836391151,
-0.0120575465,
-0.0377941988,
0.0927969068,
-0.0226646792,
0.0214178488,
-0.0170743074,
-0.0027323803,
-0.0167708509,
0.0383774489,
-0.0359013304,
-0.0034375191,
0.010144243,
0.0186504275,
0.0221182685,
-0.0724773034,
0.0464175791,
0.0026707987,
0.0378991105,
-0.0743719265,
0.0333248004,
0.0209756549,
-0.038759388,
-0.0541433245,
-0.0631536916,
-0.0486225002,
0.0006050395,
-0.0566578172,
-0.0238034502,
-0.0641267151,
-0.0156964287,
0.0682406276,
0.0241723619,
0.005066473,
-0.0003076662,
-0.0018016484,
-0.0042410712,
0.0065767597,
0.0187030379,
0.0532761514,
-0.0161115695,
0.0215597302,
0.0363318548,
-0.019504888,
-0.0028528646,
-0.0177088194,
-0.0316622593,
-0.0438378192,
-0.0082892738,
0.0305710379,
0.0124297505,
0.0435455516,
-0.0629278421,
0.0361312293,
0.0960321054,
0.0035959296,
0.0657860786,
0.0116149718,
0.0025898418,
-0.0066915564,
0.0210513622,
0.0143130692,
-0.0680459216,
-0.0231163669,
-0.0047553666,
0.0025204429,
0.010369638,
-0.0313130356,
-0.0014577125,
-0.1018819436,
0.0813886002,
-0.0027959964,
0.0090166749,
-0.0776699409,
-0.0740619078,
-0.0071349191,
0.0035147313,
-0.0272574555,
0.0143606635,
0.0326039642,
-0.0088565936,
0.0091112945,
-0.0263935719,
-0.0252451282,
0.0805578753,
-0.0167254359,
0.0210722201,
0.0411111489,
0.0333402455,
0.0129277501,
-0.0623911545,
-0.0258341879,
0.0050890679,
-0.0216556806,
0.0092912195,
0.0356761105,
0.0119134989,
0.0028776105,
-0.0333064273,
0.0529972054,
-0.0497910008,
-0.0330771208,
0.0135935061,
0.0764647871,
-0.0299180355,
-0.0301524736,
0.0166213382,
0.0101841027,
0.0126663372,
0.1002732366,
0.0045336261,
0.0287032444,
-0.026676273,
-0.0448440649,
-0.0587411113,
-0.0269186106,
-0.0273056105,
0.0625217408,
0.0184376724,
-0.0016805223,
-0.0553277135,
0.0055273389,
0.021162929,
0.0303148478,
-0.0182591528,
-0.0280229878,
0.0362977721,
0.0091268206,
-0.0298842695,
0.0522676446,
-0.0492633209,
0.0645764098,
-0.0170559529,
0.0126440581,
0.0450787805,
-0.029846767,
-0.0301960874,
0.0240420327,
-0.0045817471,
-0.0281649567,
-0.0498709492,
-0.0085526723,
0.0226866361,
0.0745045543,
-0.0221405625,
-0.0348046534,
0.0306062289,
0.0159425344,
-0.0199019741,
-0.0052603702,
0.03812683,
-0.006696024,
0.0060178479,
0.0160455722,
-0.0280251019,
0.0207119435,
0.0192095954,
0.0171956811,
-0.0427005701,
-0.0251552146,
0.0376591906,
0.0337174572,
0.0572660491,
0.0180246085,
-0.0454016551,
-0.0317434072,
0.0248385072,
-0.031651672,
-0.0178115349,
-0.0020497569,
0.0334590934,
0.015001799,
-0.058026392,
0.004037464,
-0.0480154529,
-0.0325815417,
0.0079229902,
-0.007503571,
0.0206652936,
-0.0218477063,
0.0271795057,
0.0248752292,
-0.0205910951,
-0.0214111377,
-0.0052834009,
-0.0137287732,
0.0577373803,
0.0008437561,
0.0559545681,
0.020917723,
-0.0071903314,
-0.0105662988,
-0.0446624681,
-0.0388378128,
-0.0641020536,
-0.0099823149,
-0.00639696,
0.0133742327,
-0.0013814266,
0.0154468277,
-0.0110042561,
-0.0431919061,
0.0185434893,
0.034747161,
0.024672851,
-0.0237740558,
0.0451698117,
0.0144368522,
-0.0474711508,
-0.004573965,
0.0577609129,
0.0471427552,
0.0395364389,
-0.0172902867,
-0.0394857042,
-0.0235937368,
-0.0690930337,
-0.0239799488,
0.0532843769,
-0.0083930688,
0.0198935792,
-0.0876371861,
-0.0767292604,
-0.0047504627,
0.0161421411,
-0.0192937981,
0.0365353562,
0.0057540745,
0.0513720177,
0.012563305,
-0.0461180024,
-0.052149754,
0.0227980781,
-0.0197046027,
-0.0087343082,
0.0148620969,
-6.378837727e-33,
-0.0038258326,
-0.0748935193,
0.0037288559,
-0.0260141604,
0.0225044247,
0.0277192369,
-0.0489568152,
-0.0358682759,
-0.031246908,
0.0772141963,
0.0271077249,
0.0429699942,
0.0120747387,
0.0167377274,
-0.0267685838,
-0.009034236,
0.0325638577,
0.0360111333,
-0.0088324985,
0.0465729386,
0.0486988351,
-0.0059136311,
0.0272934027,
-0.0979740098,
0.0682676658,
0.0179293528,
-0.0214809179,
0.0343478806,
-0.0635035932,
0.0570329204,
-0.0151541056,
0.0252611246,
0.0209939629,
-0.0554362796,
0.0311699323,
0.0243129805,
-0.0818027109,
0.0154197719,
0.044387389,
-0.0318576396,
-0.0378200784,
0.0078934785,
0.0118352734,
0.0158413704,
0.0160447434,
-0.0252434053,
0.0199426021,
-0.0498708449,
0.0156585202,
-0.0303381886,
-0.048790656,
0.0330252089,
-0.0246178247,
-0.0109860171,
-0.0259222426,
0.0395244732,
-0.0070455698,
0.0559959188,
-0.0629479289,
0.015602883,
-0.0243931003,
-0.0472796112,
0.051201161,
-0.0347474255,
-0.0268372241,
0.0650458038,
-0.0470826253,
-0.0031061887,
-0.0718800202,
0.0165003166,
-0.0497209728,
0.074485518,
0.0715338141,
0.0710579306,
-0.0022302205,
0.0057329824,
-0.1393461078,
0.0119349314,
-0.0099527054,
0.0163565557,
0.0304848794,
-0.0236390084,
-0.0585189462,
-0.0131511139,
-0.0610922091,
0.0154731348,
-0.0445064753,
0.0330756307,
0.0049528023,
0.0172170084,
-0.0612016097,
0.0462163277,
-0.0080481367,
-0.0422770008,
-0.0049165548,
0.0218824856,
0.0310016219,
-0.0401671976,
0.0110169463,
0.0165734515,
-0.030278746,
0.0307697337,
-0.0076884446,
-0.0169738363,
0.0182479434,
0.0053015179,
0.0566775054,
-0.0195221584,
-0.0441679545,
0.0130125443,
-0.0475659035,
0.0137815038,
-0.0010398148,
0.0045300964,
0.0248680152,
0.0555458143,
0.0005586016,
0.0311506335,
-0.0093967896,
-0.0213545263,
0.0078002526,
-0.0193114821,
-0.0196678229,
0.0073394175,
-0.0282975435,
-0.037029013,
-0.0226227921,
-0.0216159821,
0.0238101948,
-0.0746828243,
0.0108235655,
0.017089868,
2.715e-7,
0.0230214056,
0.0575454608,
0.0045993123,
0.00027019,
0.0368777774,
0.0479579456,
0.0048332261,
-0.0268585235,
0.0044506807,
-0.1187528893,
-0.014175592,
0.0370611921,
0.0377563834,
0.0379300453,
-0.0280763917,
-0.0151096582,
-0.0267041288,
-0.0741988644,
-0.0778296888,
0.0034413908,
0.0484093316,
0.0454487354,
0.0503915437,
-0.0047285575,
0.0235728975,
-0.0217405967,
0.0500272438,
0.0199926402,
0.0003256915,
-0.0132993376,
0.0389612354,
-0.013277078,
0.0238643624,
0.0519272313,
-0.0341028981,
-0.0017535577,
-0.0424212441,
0.0843252912,
-0.0158784799,
0.0096090967,
-0.0656803548,
-0.0380925462,
0.0314611159,
-0.0776542351,
0.066093795,
-0.0408710688,
-0.0353153162,
-0.0062086191,
-0.0038770782,
-0.0281298123,
-0.0195130575,
0.0143568283,
0.0230851509,
-0.0074631507,
-0.0192644615,
-0.0044455165,
0.0225704499,
-0.0524846986,
-0.013896022,
0.0216668732,
-0.0468506292,
-0.0163882375,
0.0293860417,
-0.0333264619,
0.0685065016,
-0.0457998104,
0.0235103555,
2.568384902e-34,
0.0145845376,
0.0255625471,
-0.0057219639,
-0.021656651,
0.1005631164,
0.0408285595,
-0.0188936833,
-0.0123727052,
0.0370040797,
-0.0450538658,
0.0046083345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05242v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05242v2 | ChatRadio-Valuer: A Chat Large Language Model for Generalizable Radiology Report Generation Based on Multi-institution and Multi-system Data | 2023-10-08T17:23:17 | 2023-10-10T01:22:16 | Tianyang Zhong, Wei Zhao, Yutong Zhang, Yi Pan, Peixin Dong, Zuowei Jiang, Xiaoyan Kui, Youlan Shang, Li Yang, Yaonai Wei, Longtao Yang, Hao Chen, Huan Zhao, Yuxiao Liu, Ning Zhu, Yiwei Li, Yisong Wang, Jiaqi Yao, Jiaqi Wang, Ying Zeng, Lei He, Chao Zheng, Zhixue Zhang, Ming Li, Zhengliang Liu, Haixing Dai, Zihao Wu, Lu Zhang, Shu Zhang, Xiaoyan Cai, Xintao Hu, Shijie Zhao, Xi Jiang, Xin Zhang, Xiang Li, Dajiang Zhu, Lei Guo, Dinggang Shen, Junwei Han, Tianming Liu, Jun Liu, Tuo Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Radiology report generation, as a key step in medical image analysis, is
critical to the quantitative analysis of clinically informed decision-making
levels. However, complex and diverse radiology reports with cross-source
heterogeneity pose a huge generalizability challenge to the current methods
under massive data volume, mainly because the style and normativity of
radiology reports are obviously distinctive among institutions, body regions
inspected and radiologists. Recently, the advent of large language models (LLM)
offers great potential for recognizing signs of health conditions. To resolve
the above problem, we collaborate with the Second Xiangya Hospital in China and
propose ChatRadio-Valuer based on the LLM, a tailored model for automatic
radiology report generation that learns generalizable representations and
provides a basis pattern for model adaptation in sophisticated analysts' cases.
Specifically, ChatRadio-Valuer is trained based on the radiology reports from a
single institution by means of supervised fine-tuning, and then adapted to
disease diagnosis tasks for human multi-system evaluation (i.e., chest,
abdomen, muscle-skeleton, head, and maxillofacial $\&$ neck) from six different
institutions in clinical-level events. The clinical dataset utilized in this
study encompasses a remarkable total of \textbf{332,673} observations. From the
comprehensive results on engineering indicators, clinical efficacy and
deployment cost metrics, it can be shown that ChatRadio-Valuer consistently
outperforms state-of-the-art models, especially ChatGPT (GPT-3.5-Turbo) and
GPT-4 et al., in terms of the diseases diagnosis from radiology reports.
ChatRadio-Valuer provides an effective avenue to boost model generalization
performance and alleviate the annotation workload of experts to enable the
promotion of clinical AI applications in radiology reports. | [
0.0362581052,
0.0774409994,
0.0143304197,
-0.0300338343,
-0.0002730451,
0.0342223942,
0.0064845728,
0.0600478984,
-0.0011496012,
-0.0122111822,
0.0006552979,
-0.0635270327,
0.011218206,
0.0646061301,
0.0127323335,
-0.0917820185,
0.0119876582,
-0.0027708479,
0.0288834572,
-0.0167738758,
0.0137416031,
0.009625582,
0.0173422992,
0.0564600304,
-0.0336231403,
0.0133839082,
0.0073721996,
-0.0079736877,
0.0230016783,
-0.0298096277,
-0.0227237381,
0.0474539213,
0.0202636886,
0.0141707612,
0.000002332,
-0.0365622863,
-0.0314608552,
0.0259972159,
0.0151877813,
-0.0090188188,
0.0895827264,
-0.0867982805,
-0.0198722482,
0.0108354604,
-0.0219576024,
-0.0757228956,
0.0501656346,
0.0486143008,
0.0724904388,
0.0798187926,
-0.0271509606,
-0.0091491221,
-0.0002214107,
-0.0318792723,
0.0120727392,
-0.0710067227,
0.0373684764,
0.0639110208,
0.0098744063,
-0.0177759062,
-0.0197865292,
0.024390582,
0.0178992283,
0.0161163211,
-0.0122139836,
0.0655501038,
-0.036304187,
-0.0213317759,
0.017636802,
0.0664042756,
-0.0327909924,
-0.0056154984,
0.0153308334,
-0.0043377108,
-0.004425134,
-0.0077849603,
-0.016354477,
0.0019457861,
-0.0072255195,
-0.0029499587,
-0.0116789732,
0.0018879744,
0.0046500689,
0.0041959104,
-0.0688536763,
-0.022825392,
-0.0038086018,
0.0000255051,
0.0119331265,
0.0066095679,
-0.0556994155,
-0.0524712354,
0.0012399028,
0.0441022925,
-0.088113755,
-0.0102782687,
-0.0099444911,
-0.0142762549,
0.074226141,
-0.0794391483,
-0.0374395438,
-0.0047710817,
-0.0366465636,
0.0482236333,
-0.012424944,
0.0120580299,
-0.0621174052,
0.0453800224,
-0.0483821407,
0.0049102744,
-0.0250367839,
-0.0076936963,
-0.0233998932,
0.0132415276,
0.0144522591,
-0.0344908759,
-0.1061157957,
-0.0048495862,
-0.0136856521,
0.0102610877,
0.039608717,
0.0737267435,
-0.049188491,
0.0150808077,
-0.0114886519,
0.0353394002,
0.0256216172,
0.008123449,
-0.0164132807,
-0.0114733484,
0.0365394987,
0.0288464017,
0.0073385742,
0.0298383888,
0.0178465899,
0.0330155753,
-0.0022483212,
0.0254932828,
0.0318485163,
-0.0424351878,
-0.04147451,
-0.0561326332,
-0.0045366753,
-0.0771738142,
-0.0021535582,
0.0279412381,
0.0283511002,
0.0037064499,
0.0012300147,
-0.0092806825,
-0.0226202682,
0.0311504304,
-0.0336489379,
-0.0038691231,
0.012016559,
0.0177801102,
0.0031785506,
0.0317065977,
0.036117401,
0.0089854812,
-0.0255702436,
-0.008519331,
-0.0032623154,
0.0276910961,
-0.0162631981,
-0.0307896752,
-0.0346515141,
-0.0191057716,
0.0111636063,
0.0670025349,
-0.0148840919,
0.0575265735,
0.0151594533,
-0.0006588275,
0.0154527649,
0.0118284086,
0.063387908,
0.0206916425,
0.0478334315,
-0.0061731464,
-0.0260543991,
-0.015471315,
0.0150347976,
0.0166791677,
0.0207662135,
-0.0053373761,
-0.0283311531,
0.0207513254,
-0.0569997951,
-0.0291463397,
-0.0357579365,
-0.0047817389,
-0.0244030058,
0.0018753774,
0.065325819,
-0.0288412552,
-0.0265330058,
0.0182904638,
0.0683554262,
0.0023331996,
-0.0332764573,
-0.0929459706,
-0.0002574163,
0.0795157775,
0.0319538228,
-0.0385566913,
-0.0072140815,
-0.0036301017,
0.0545134582,
0.0157659743,
0.036422763,
0.0212494638,
0.0223559961,
-0.0390509292,
-0.0208951738,
0.0669657141,
0.0350013785,
-0.0171343163,
-0.0221217573,
0.0279870089,
-0.0218721982,
-0.0112791443,
-0.0579143353,
0.0229608156,
-0.0318375416,
0.0167891588,
0.0138113759,
0.0111803664,
0.0256828927,
-0.021962285,
-0.0328567326,
-0.0141026154,
-0.0106679136,
-0.0150676835,
-0.0620870702,
0.0270789769,
-0.0481135473,
-0.0391876772,
0.0205350127,
-0.0483748391,
-0.0061395001,
-0.0374717116,
-0.0585289262,
-0.0252407603,
-0.0155644892,
-0.0613459758,
0.0184498616,
-0.0185911078,
0.019395411,
0.0452870466,
0.0109507106,
-0.0116040586,
0.0530552939,
-0.0039820937,
-0.009417708,
0.0146431066,
-0.0370351188,
0.0151954331,
-0.0468240492,
-0.0429291539,
0.0239806678,
0.0003678617,
0.0312776789,
0.0085830428,
0.0620026402,
-0.0042696618,
-0.0321964622,
-0.0993272588,
-0.0035751036,
-0.0070548928,
-0.0373306647,
0.0356741622,
0.024863435,
0.0052990988,
-0.0229472592,
-0.0453037433,
0.0052707,
0.0684093684,
0.0154042728,
0.0559752323,
0.0282220915,
-0.0247706883,
-0.0285051595,
0.004737888,
-0.0331729837,
0.0164836869,
0.0498445667,
-0.040552821,
-0.0191793591,
0.0369844027,
-0.0316877477,
-0.0017459793,
0.0068427417,
-0.0713840574,
-0.0059270514,
-0.0452430882,
-0.0299572069,
0.0601172186,
0.0050734924,
0.033627212,
0.0224854238,
0.0205490459,
-0.0340655483,
0.0069302954,
-0.0501476526,
-0.0349139646,
0.0137061058,
-0.0811424926,
-0.0137024205,
0.0464314632,
0.0174724311,
0.0070758327,
-0.0424509905,
-0.0002898882,
-0.0171255693,
0.0035661231,
-0.0447263457,
0.0300532114,
-0.0033350636,
0.0277982038,
-0.0017152975,
-0.0401162095,
0.0768800899,
0.0115430774,
0.0227700938,
-0.0493638627,
-0.027948359,
-0.0593913421,
0.0112377657,
0.0012618242,
0.066848956,
0.0175745171,
-0.0249095485,
-0.0250044316,
0.0234226137,
0.0226766225,
-0.0683711469,
0.0056481841,
-0.0032734103,
0.0245098844,
0.014462674,
-0.0482955724,
-0.0245125797,
-0.0097844824,
0.0051337751,
0.0042194878,
-0.0025015392,
0.0050943121,
-0.0762644783,
0.0838239938,
-0.0077805556,
0.0430460796,
-0.0160306264,
-0.0112507679,
0.0039733341,
0.0069376365,
0.0305451266,
0.0163274202,
-0.0354150012,
-0.0366108827,
0.0358388498,
0.0713638887,
-0.0348619558,
0.0656114891,
-0.0532908961,
0.0170409866,
-0.0203790572,
0.0143341636,
0.0018577296,
-0.0009728692,
0.0120993601,
-0.0351329893,
-0.0077901953,
0.10001342,
0.0090999855,
-0.0445211567,
-0.008832125,
0.0203102175,
0.0209401026,
-0.018244585,
0.0088857496,
-0.0406244695,
-0.0115899304,
-0.0072323419,
-0.0038854089,
-0.0179366209,
-0.0172813348,
0.0281104688,
-0.0223863367,
0.0567703247,
0.0007827281,
-0.0785407722,
-0.0443908572,
-0.0355574749,
0.0063920547,
-0.0354724266,
-0.0111123137,
-0.0125703942,
-0.02005505,
-0.0256119855,
0.021733202,
-0.0863951892,
-0.0964142457,
0.0236085877,
-0.0444437601,
-0.0205184016,
0.0571690015,
0.0356493331,
-0.0307737794,
-0.0152640454,
0.0007611754,
0.084575139,
0.0034627272,
-0.0092348978,
0.0818564743,
0.0272271745,
-0.029535789,
-0.0699490458,
0.04881965,
-0.0015610782,
0.0271416847,
-0.0205372144,
0.0668513849,
-0.0268201791,
-0.020640254,
-0.0531835631,
0.057140436,
0.0458940342,
0.032569211,
-0.0246248711,
-0.0221071094,
-0.0221150219,
0.0041678683,
0.0488315821,
-0.0057763252,
-0.0414263569,
0.0420040488,
-0.0710345581,
-0.0798424259,
-0.0478279777,
0.015050319,
0.0283106901,
0.0120304273,
-0.0029653725,
0.0202936679,
-0.0022431319,
-0.0030594137,
-0.0358938463,
0.0391594432,
0.0385954343,
0.0185846481,
-0.0328590311,
-0.0324505083,
0.0691689849,
-0.0118026454,
-0.0052767396,
0.031529028,
-0.0353035033,
-0.0000959592,
-0.0101505481,
0.0273956135,
0.024199361,
-0.02833171,
-0.0146324076,
-0.0054160161,
0.0795109048,
0.0515771545,
-0.032363005,
-0.0044649355,
-0.0025168073,
-0.0432146788,
-0.0303393882,
0.009514641,
-0.0134733608,
0.0420280397,
0.0029711481,
0.0181816779,
-0.0418495387,
-0.0149636054,
0.0249384325,
0.0377933159,
0.0073651723,
-0.0257256199,
-0.0473423824,
-0.0295309722,
-0.0005640594,
0.0046575973,
0.0128506934,
-0.0525762886,
0.029484259,
0.0326472521,
-0.0123390378,
-0.0194423273,
0.0010261622,
-0.0247942805,
-0.0316682309,
-0.0280038677,
0.0607998073,
0.0228214357,
-0.0088696619,
0.0956055671,
-0.0112867374,
-0.0183900818,
-0.0371922366,
0.0252861809,
-0.014372142,
0.0117188757,
0.0593945198,
0.0218774136,
0.0615414008,
-0.0112246666,
0.0160729811,
-0.0038660008,
-0.0480819456,
-0.0458192304,
0.019489171,
0.0572872534,
0.0273273941,
0.0134944813,
-0.025376223,
0.0083155725,
-0.0306627452,
0.0652253255,
-0.0287673753,
-0.0088258078,
0.0452051833,
-0.0168929305,
-0.0064176251,
-0.0000457209,
0.1108198091,
0.0182160567,
0.0181686766,
-0.0239796899,
-0.0651326403,
-0.0529058129,
-0.0099229338,
0.0380460396,
-0.0147919245,
-0.0485137329,
0.021072913,
-0.0549239032,
-0.0805104598,
-0.0299109295,
-0.0242266059,
-0.0127860764,
-0.011937717,
0.0320133381,
0.0718473867,
0.0012501325,
-0.0026061942,
-0.028905496,
0.0173964109,
-0.0223801881,
-0.0222025719,
0.0373090394,
-6.416668809e-33,
0.0191379953,
-0.0236863028,
0.0306588691,
-0.0420441963,
0.0121604651,
0.0549628809,
-0.014791972,
-0.0093487352,
0.0250148755,
0.0269049387,
-0.0111794537,
-0.017780574,
0.0176404752,
0.0326999836,
0.0288608205,
-0.001222681,
0.020089671,
0.0073859063,
-0.0133540165,
0.0191995222,
0.0109689357,
0.0229070261,
0.029500518,
-0.0943397358,
-0.0541562065,
0.0308477636,
-0.039609313,
-0.0157557782,
-0.0134053947,
0.045219969,
-0.0304416567,
0.0341298766,
0.0270882472,
-0.0359900035,
-0.0049726632,
0.0148456832,
-0.0416746698,
-0.0034924084,
-0.0157368183,
0.0045744851,
-0.000069464,
0.0114256879,
0.0246901624,
-0.0296644252,
0.0371111482,
-0.0154544739,
0.0315697603,
-0.0277655032,
0.0126866931,
-0.0080297729,
-0.030133862,
0.0692074969,
-0.0004527107,
-0.0039279545,
-0.0236694235,
-0.0081039751,
-0.0461325236,
0.0370801389,
-0.0133131947,
-0.0036920076,
0.0635007173,
0.01748663,
0.0139972996,
-0.0170889739,
-0.0325595587,
0.0514140613,
0.0511969812,
-0.0326848663,
-0.0064456146,
0.0044264975,
-0.0450078025,
0.0836349949,
0.0175154544,
0.0439789407,
0.0305501241,
-0.0454053991,
-0.1238665953,
0.0368660912,
-0.0169036593,
0.0636376217,
0.0323181711,
-0.0263629109,
-0.0322132632,
0.0030685915,
0.0174680967,
-0.0059455158,
-0.0162468441,
-0.0458566099,
0.0207348038,
0.0477495342,
0.0066392394,
0.0445495285,
0.0490793213,
-0.0099418163,
-0.0035841707,
-0.0267135892,
0.0039485707,
0.0192861874,
-0.039820388,
0.0130693894,
-0.0350514501,
-0.0598380454,
0.0275814515,
0.0053317901,
0.0375876874,
0.0131927971,
0.0467283577,
0.0163540374,
-0.0511857308,
0.0112663889,
0.0148990797,
-0.0191206634,
-0.0537499972,
0.0317092948,
0.0359147117,
-0.0088318381,
-0.0223898273,
0.0503438748,
-0.0279195663,
0.0273518469,
-0.045710668,
-0.0712859929,
-0.0128173633,
0.0069929562,
-0.0473238342,
-0.0220110975,
-0.0430855192,
-0.0261200313,
0.08026582,
-0.0349635445,
-0.0323958993,
0.0016315349,
3.137e-7,
0.0599995814,
0.0316940695,
-0.0093348343,
0.0088794352,
0.0235668179,
0.0104684755,
-0.0257633999,
0.0337218307,
0.0163871665,
0.0116186729,
0.0326705277,
0.0021309231,
0.0148971397,
0.0385980196,
-0.0748379305,
-0.028853979,
-0.0663488209,
-0.0134469895,
-0.0065639871,
-0.0246195775,
0.0491454452,
0.0989401713,
-0.0349066444,
-0.0684392601,
0.0522947088,
-0.0073279482,
0.0608287305,
-0.0388598144,
-0.000300925,
0.0253054425,
0.0217447747,
0.0226180963,
0.0218483955,
0.0424305983,
0.0029313746,
-0.0032810345,
0.022851374,
0.095827885,
-0.0356771462,
0.0387867205,
0.033238709,
0.0049077813,
0.0205448866,
-0.0518200509,
0.0716091394,
-0.0802813768,
-0.0291105323,
-0.0339405015,
0.0002645793,
-0.0188330673,
0.0614700578,
-0.0563571341,
-0.0239843447,
0.0618430451,
0.0066354838,
0.0094035361,
-0.0231887549,
-0.0650377423,
-0.0084272074,
0.0080403769,
-0.0307719391,
-0.0481027178,
0.0421540998,
-0.0092648985,
0.0206336472,
-0.0532631092,
0.0219690613,
2.853680366e-34,
0.0549208149,
0.0109558236,
-0.026374869,
0.0074753999,
0.0363348871,
-0.0074171419,
0.0130753135,
0.0232479945,
-0.0035609261,
-0.0455531441,
-0.0333794616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05235v1 | XLS-R fine-tuning on noisy word boundaries for unsupervised speech segmentation into words | 2023-10-08T17:05:00 | 2023-10-08T17:05:00 | Robin Algayres, Pablo Diego-Simon, Benoit Sagot, Emmanuel Dupoux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Due to the absence of explicit word boundaries in the speech stream, the task
of segmenting spoken sentences into word units without text supervision is
particularly challenging. In this work, we leverage the most recent
self-supervised speech models that have proved to quickly adapt to new tasks
through fine-tuning, even in low resource conditions. Taking inspiration from
semi-supervised learning, we fine-tune an XLS-R model to predict word
boundaries themselves produced by top-tier speech segmentation systems: DPDP,
VG-HuBERT, GradSeg and DP-Parse. Once XLS-R is fine-tuned, it is used to infer
new word boundary labels that are used in turn for another fine-tuning step.
Our method consistently improves the performance of each system and sets a new
state-of-the-art that is, on average 130% higher than the previous one as
measured by the F1 score on correctly discovered word tokens on five corpora
featuring different languages. Finally, our system can segment speech from
languages unseen during fine-tuning in a zero-shot fashion. | [
-0.0361426696,
0.0454988368,
0.0376866497,
0.0179863255,
-0.0296286568,
-0.0374524631,
0.018486809,
-0.0306146611,
-0.0227006879,
-0.0218488351,
-0.0498092808,
-0.0231365357,
-0.0075267614,
0.0429780558,
0.011129546,
-0.0391140953,
0.0540133305,
-0.0635839626,
0.0144612566,
0.0148582887,
0.0036782997,
-0.0063673374,
-0.019862663,
0.0107600782,
-0.0389620028,
-0.0194306616,
-0.007436723,
0.0009009918,
-0.0057360129,
0.0048191184,
0.0162365362,
0.0260250717,
-0.0012036841,
0.0278367233,
0.0000020051,
-0.05554948,
-0.0821308196,
0.0060368851,
-0.0225701611,
-0.0007259474,
0.0274977218,
-0.0424859039,
-0.0097230766,
0.0135075701,
0.0130707491,
-0.0040296004,
0.0015928382,
0.0369079039,
0.0233736821,
0.0542841405,
-0.0161943734,
-0.0269908141,
-0.0071406462,
-0.0275156926,
-0.0343248174,
-0.0394718051,
0.011725097,
-0.0081569422,
-0.0263879746,
-0.0629301518,
-0.0387095399,
0.0277067628,
-0.0522286557,
-0.0065859198,
-0.0051662317,
0.0052177603,
-0.0872214511,
-0.0623576045,
-0.0368621014,
0.0269399099,
-0.0385263488,
0.003603009,
0.0722943395,
0.0167234018,
-0.0466631427,
-0.0342382602,
-0.0098289642,
-0.0072272103,
-0.0013597716,
-0.0013104549,
0.0220544934,
0.0611012392,
0.0188380536,
0.0114524672,
-0.0452226885,
0.0860603824,
-0.0084242206,
-0.0649529099,
0.0228002891,
0.0029333404,
0.0257669948,
0.0060451813,
0.0420197397,
-0.0301501043,
-0.0005600465,
0.00777537,
-0.0097148065,
-0.0146262711,
-0.0095025646,
0.0443783067,
-0.013629891,
-0.0191753451,
-0.0130277453,
0.0370092615,
-0.0003498411,
-0.0350366868,
0.0479445569,
0.0060983524,
-0.0231025107,
-0.015350516,
-0.0030728506,
-0.0057926085,
-0.0548573434,
-0.0175266806,
-0.0476221703,
-0.0167140588,
-0.0370393768,
-0.0255540684,
0.0012713963,
-0.0137785934,
0.058827579,
-0.0398570895,
-0.0151317036,
-0.0236252137,
0.0200563855,
0.0158626139,
-0.0469804592,
-0.0257171374,
0.0276688356,
-0.0381419733,
-0.0127726756,
0.0113246553,
0.0112753762,
-0.0010570533,
0.0103397304,
0.0668577179,
-0.0278930794,
-0.0374947712,
0.0065906732,
-0.0420948453,
-0.0532383695,
-0.0392699651,
0.0153639372,
-0.0407363176,
0.0101648681,
-0.0086336862,
-0.0072704814,
0.0264359452,
-0.0174698718,
-0.0093791131,
0.0203563292,
0.0679126605,
-0.0442255251,
0.0567669459,
0.01745403,
-0.0041497862,
0.0560356751,
0.0923853815,
0.0233025365,
-0.0024232082,
0.0860676914,
-0.0171691384,
0.029964773,
0.0770133212,
-0.0158743747,
-0.0095109586,
-0.0859897807,
-0.0300024953,
0.0145628145,
0.0187630821,
0.0771767423,
-0.010769302,
0.0088552414,
-0.0224228594,
0.0143279489,
0.0868968219,
0.0018804056,
0.0283025298,
-0.0080070673,
0.0458593853,
0.0075355684,
0.0174494199,
0.0280552879,
-0.0609187745,
0.057843022,
0.0466659255,
0.0534681678,
0.0317807049,
0.0044348915,
-0.0397439562,
-0.0231201854,
-0.037949346,
0.0224461388,
0.0176603775,
0.0782534555,
0.0290083289,
-0.0232902057,
0.061363779,
0.003468337,
-0.0600185283,
0.0035649566,
-0.0472570844,
0.0322022215,
0.0269561522,
0.022976432,
-0.0768517107,
-0.0106344447,
-0.0399232656,
0.0651441887,
0.0542292036,
0.0256652795,
0.0109389573,
0.0520278439,
-0.0792045817,
0.0035980202,
0.0219935309,
0.0226588286,
0.0118570477,
-0.013263681,
-0.0065126084,
-0.0207858589,
-0.0563400686,
0.0153496014,
0.0209928155,
0.0041573388,
-0.0208567251,
0.0202443339,
0.002100687,
0.0106542492,
0.0415338352,
-0.0002475595,
-0.0134355929,
0.0372045189,
-0.0161004309,
0.0358102024,
0.0048394175,
-0.0496858321,
-0.006037089,
0.0053716614,
-0.0084053874,
-0.0309091844,
-0.0023484156,
0.0058761975,
-0.0573125072,
0.0317626484,
0.0273708533,
0.0224053077,
-0.0419702195,
0.0369754657,
0.0411038175,
0.0256800093,
-0.0110245496,
0.000582344,
0.031980142,
0.0149623621,
-0.0333930701,
-0.0007669779,
0.0069827158,
-0.0316735692,
0.0043861433,
-0.0236641895,
-0.0494072214,
0.00224098,
0.0098151127,
-0.0160291642,
-0.034320239,
-0.0020205022,
-0.0442572385,
0.0006313963,
-0.0269994214,
-0.0063397014,
-0.0213826466,
-0.0032455483,
-0.0387652069,
-0.0242191944,
0.0232321713,
-0.0625678673,
0.0106913941,
-0.0323187858,
-0.0058513694,
-0.047954306,
-0.0094826519,
-0.052303277,
0.0042350697,
-0.001671313,
-0.0116200941,
-0.0236703698,
-0.0561596863,
-0.0289714858,
-0.0148089426,
0.0033458422,
0.019896213,
-0.0058182948,
-0.0283834971,
-0.0177840274,
-0.0096987961,
0.0624995381,
0.0637745634,
0.0117261531,
0.0019604035,
-0.008763195,
-0.0518857464,
0.0148341674,
0.0061024604,
-0.0046959636,
0.0370222405,
0.0084737604,
0.0188909192,
0.0171720367,
0.0746122748,
0.0309218448,
0.0278250333,
-0.009008674,
-0.0325677842,
-0.038622994,
-0.033656016,
-0.0029874279,
0.040855214,
-0.0652656108,
0.0278130621,
0.0014183541,
-0.040091943,
0.0078839157,
-0.0764038041,
-0.0464720055,
-0.0726643279,
-0.0644947514,
-0.0252038781,
-0.0017501502,
0.0138992565,
-0.0182451028,
-0.0179247893,
-0.0337430313,
-0.0065205572,
0.0319589302,
0.005180412,
-0.030025214,
0.0208375733,
0.0169292968,
-0.0425029732,
0.0019229868,
-0.0069303042,
-0.0166273117,
-0.0112477355,
-0.0414512157,
0.0039421511,
0.0273653939,
-0.023448782,
-0.0071805995,
0.0514773875,
-0.0069507076,
0.0811636001,
-0.0223957524,
0.0208144095,
-0.0252398681,
0.0767046064,
0.0584490597,
0.0154845091,
-0.0281366166,
-0.0355857424,
0.0205850117,
-0.0236438885,
0.0333591066,
-0.0233131144,
0.0184322856,
-0.0294521283,
-0.0031630683,
-0.0230614301,
0.0324387699,
-0.0042140679,
0.0992360115,
-0.0519296899,
-0.0254678186,
0.106708765,
0.0174784772,
0.0314921476,
-0.0326346755,
-0.0307847168,
-0.0137399584,
0.0646721423,
-0.0115209976,
-0.0269027092,
-0.0509002544,
0.0368649289,
0.0497383662,
0.0244000852,
-0.0050442563,
0.0067934021,
-0.0805367902,
0.07285624,
-0.0017242634,
-0.0370833464,
0.0418191627,
-0.0222654846,
0.0018774873,
-0.038045302,
0.0009052154,
-0.0312298182,
-0.0596274845,
-0.0092650754,
0.050066635,
-0.1037883162,
-0.0027995426,
-0.0201806184,
-0.0635202453,
0.0202404372,
0.0478557236,
-0.0127030406,
-0.0327962041,
-0.0359993204,
0.1221242175,
-0.0593835451,
0.001702959,
0.02035648,
0.0308745783,
-0.021247264,
-0.000258514,
0.0088899639,
0.0538127795,
0.019776104,
-0.0091186855,
0.0430801325,
0.0597438775,
0.0039033764,
-0.0041771126,
-0.0093503129,
0.0441161878,
-0.0152066164,
0.0991361514,
0.0330033079,
-0.0308428667,
-0.0476565324,
0.0136981113,
0.0574863218,
-0.0167825315,
-0.0028669941,
-0.0013643752,
-0.0445905887,
-0.0469936021,
-0.0352448896,
-0.0112909041,
0.077064082,
0.0350386091,
-0.0034484467,
0.0631402582,
-0.0218581129,
0.0124384668,
-0.0567624867,
0.0075391107,
0.003215811,
-0.0186140779,
-0.0913456082,
-0.0355142578,
0.0378593318,
-0.0143854534,
-0.0279287696,
0.0657270625,
-0.013733767,
-0.0574276857,
0.0424837209,
0.0183741022,
0.0167791676,
0.0309285186,
-0.0295825824,
-0.0076787956,
0.0616135038,
0.0807950795,
-0.0530300327,
-0.0194067117,
0.0547560155,
0.0211122185,
-0.0592655912,
0.0027103738,
-0.0085901041,
0.041172646,
-0.025091121,
0.0015586456,
-0.073978819,
-0.0097228149,
-0.0270965789,
-0.0152461417,
0.1142418757,
-0.0392769203,
0.0427014641,
-0.047669787,
-0.016043134,
0.0134826535,
0.0487706773,
-0.0136892591,
0.0090577835,
-0.0096799731,
-0.0267211851,
-0.0130504388,
0.0365447178,
-0.0506223105,
-0.008992549,
-0.0542973988,
0.0220480338,
0.0021915769,
0.0353997983,
-0.009415973,
0.0057039317,
0.0534314997,
0.0538201146,
0.0094995545,
0.0270628724,
0.006954662,
0.064307794,
0.0127156219,
0.0342791118,
-0.0058197486,
0.0199900009,
-0.0039996519,
-0.0184079111,
-0.0414487235,
0.0581795722,
-0.0010149231,
-0.0428882614,
0.018853927,
0.0148052517,
-0.0298472159,
-0.0017311871,
0.0520286411,
-0.0129561769,
-0.0006721456,
-0.005516544,
0.0276453178,
-0.0606130995,
0.0020462167,
0.0374148823,
0.0175754018,
-0.0028022849,
0.0404614955,
0.0019410235,
-0.0413228497,
0.0075557847,
-0.0029030098,
-0.0089305174,
-0.0176727604,
-0.0115448972,
-0.0227700192,
-0.0517549403,
0.041587282,
-0.003417891,
0.006181682,
-0.0017899876,
0.0161625072,
0.0399062783,
-0.0309907757,
0.0049512531,
-0.0082077095,
-0.0013851353,
0.0215731412,
-0.0145191653,
0.0679090545,
-6.251219448e-33,
0.0084638521,
-0.0074539445,
-0.0279635061,
0.0047206562,
0.002906255,
-0.0082107736,
0.0019861653,
0.0095784748,
0.0801314339,
0.0001080484,
-0.0303229727,
-0.0173834544,
0.0490646325,
0.0154507272,
0.0138667263,
-0.0289960653,
0.0949569568,
-0.0379407145,
-0.0165896546,
-0.0319147855,
-0.0003335751,
0.0736076906,
0.0198303461,
-0.0241070371,
-0.0268808044,
-0.0219009947,
-0.0024927212,
0.0313926972,
0.0408353396,
0.0485210605,
-0.0065173134,
-0.0116638876,
0.0132664293,
-0.0384827442,
-0.0224204604,
0.0298789162,
-0.1189361736,
0.0411069505,
-0.0117124114,
0.035484869,
-0.0173559431,
0.0428033732,
0.0237188879,
0.0119099552,
-0.0060661151,
-0.0058533209,
0.0199152306,
-0.046865318,
-0.0165326949,
-0.052038461,
-0.0556536242,
0.0397589095,
-0.019444745,
-0.0409307815,
0.1115076244,
-0.0007189056,
0.0097432788,
-0.0375341251,
-0.0484128408,
-0.0015062452,
0.0430077128,
0.0489531495,
0.035983488,
0.0197135322,
-0.0326520018,
0.0466969609,
0.0795747712,
-0.0490492843,
0.0511170141,
-0.0323159434,
0.0394254811,
0.0413967632,
0.0128044467,
-0.0139495432,
0.0288465135,
-0.0522453785,
-0.0234828498,
-0.0020155024,
0.0325823352,
-0.0291599743,
0.0298664067,
0.0390593372,
-0.0522980466,
0.0194961559,
0.009251914,
-0.0638613179,
-0.0112780333,
0.0448008142,
0.0458843485,
0.0434656665,
-0.0206769556,
0.0016326216,
0.0446805023,
0.0159260854,
0.0469201393,
-0.0476110987,
-0.0305439215,
-0.0378950536,
-0.0192640349,
-0.0061418982,
-0.0618547909,
-0.0318721458,
-0.0031793185,
0.0376971513,
0.017957285,
-0.0139708072,
-0.001283559,
-0.0303838458,
-0.0490239188,
0.0424141102,
0.0170082599,
0.0843709782,
-0.0200588107,
0.0515411235,
0.0550525077,
-0.0162389241,
0.0014116764,
0.047561232,
0.0173316188,
0.0004323005,
0.0274717342,
0.0714529529,
-0.0120268455,
0.0227815285,
-0.0257106777,
0.0046559237,
0.0314659923,
-0.0347046517,
0.0543265045,
-0.0142476996,
0.0065580765,
0.0095620593,
2.648e-7,
-0.0344601572,
0.0677775368,
0.0569204539,
-0.0483584031,
-0.0105468435,
0.0061767949,
-0.0268921033,
-0.0253745299,
-0.0135776615,
-0.0134419734,
-0.0221731924,
-0.0363957025,
0.1174147204,
0.0207977928,
-0.126093924,
-0.0090313489,
-0.040758159,
0.0137159191,
-0.0513513982,
0.0042362371,
-0.0486074686,
0.0732682645,
-0.0140685476,
-0.0066023013,
-0.0175885167,
-0.0389335267,
-0.0335785709,
-0.0212359745,
-0.0111941816,
-0.0027727424,
0.0089498265,
-0.0158114005,
-0.0375525393,
-0.0173413977,
-0.0148713849,
0.0316837691,
0.0577878691,
0.0718812197,
0.037938688,
0.0083479211,
0.0366426148,
0.0325826257,
-0.0286406893,
-0.0125226844,
0.0502671823,
-0.0130464938,
0.0116294445,
-0.015240455,
0.0031878829,
0.0006754747,
0.0038298026,
-0.0230108257,
0.0006976484,
0.0394106768,
0.0326164663,
-0.0047151945,
-0.0239056721,
-0.0296641197,
0.0041329358,
0.0264660101,
-0.0433776379,
0.0053678718,
-0.0303990003,
0.0305827614,
-0.0047100112,
-0.0305888597,
-0.0037051598,
2.64265135e-34,
0.0388300568,
-0.0284251682,
-0.0407141075,
-0.0073407651,
0.0431995578,
-0.0536371022,
-0.0152746588,
0.0221284796,
-0.0196814016,
-0.0024479618,
-0.0206976682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05231v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05231v2 | MindfulDiary: Harnessing Large Language Model to Support Psychiatric Patients' Journaling | 2023-10-08T17:00:04 | 2024-02-22T05:54:18 | Taewan Kim, Seolyeong Bae, Hyun Ah Kim, Su-woo Lee, Hwajung Hong, Chanmo Yang, Young-Ho Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7 | In the mental health domain, Large Language Models (LLMs) offer promising new
opportunities, though their inherent complexity and low controllability have
raised questions about their suitability in clinical settings. We present
MindfulDiary, a mobile journaling app incorporating an LLM to help psychiatric
patients document daily experiences through conversation. Designed in
collaboration with mental health professionals (MHPs), MindfulDiary takes a
state-based approach to safely comply with the experts' guidelines while
carrying on free-form conversations. Through a four-week field study involving
28 patients with major depressive disorder and five psychiatrists, we found
that MindfulDiary supported patients in consistently enriching their daily
records and helped psychiatrists better empathize with their patients through
an understanding of their thoughts and daily contexts. Drawing on these
findings, we discuss the implications of leveraging LLMs in the mental health
domain, bridging the technical feasibility and their integration into clinical
settings. | [
0.0697773397,
0.0581588782,
-0.0140069257,
-0.0120964823,
-0.0082834661,
0.0083652847,
0.0287973993,
-0.0014826565,
0.0858422369,
-0.0127193434,
0.0102700451,
-0.0264213737,
0.016252676,
0.016211668,
-0.0201867502,
-0.0554829352,
0.0002385906,
-0.0041724541,
0.0168140996,
0.031512022,
0.0250305943,
0.0204868093,
-0.0332701765,
0.0450533666,
-0.0070577385,
-0.0219122749,
0.0023158523,
0.0324511416,
-0.0171335563,
-0.0829504207,
-0.0659901723,
0.0394869074,
-0.0200961288,
0.019388482,
0.0000020115,
-0.0018435181,
-0.0032607496,
0.0012619051,
0.0035671408,
-0.0770537555,
0.0396434031,
-0.0631372854,
-0.0021738366,
0.0066824658,
-0.0259419773,
-0.0470182635,
0.033745341,
0.0820677131,
0.0312928893,
0.0300053339,
-0.0312414635,
-0.0012998933,
0.0190795083,
-0.0128702149,
0.0168401152,
0.0293309893,
0.020292392,
0.0315409154,
0.0922599509,
-0.0316752903,
-0.0045188661,
0.0514149852,
-0.0191972665,
0.0048440001,
0.0384021699,
-0.0042594247,
0.0376250595,
-0.0568620265,
0.0242513884,
0.0541079044,
0.0898983926,
0.0233531557,
0.0477235988,
-0.0103479289,
-0.0224812794,
-0.0099045802,
-0.0460235365,
0.0289726537,
-0.0209765341,
0.020426264,
0.0175392795,
-0.0095766997,
0.0414287262,
-0.0122714126,
0.035833858,
0.0140462285,
-0.0060530887,
-0.0137373572,
0.0063882754,
-0.0156429317,
0.0070589073,
-0.088143535,
0.0380848423,
0.0525684208,
-0.0281782635,
0.0060188435,
-0.0295210965,
-0.0603827946,
0.0231488589,
-0.0022730946,
0.02410217,
0.0443654694,
-0.0070335013,
-0.0098515293,
0.0748269632,
0.009211855,
0.0077778003,
-0.0106592048,
-0.0339072235,
0.008784526,
-0.0336495452,
-0.0003930804,
-0.0124371136,
0.0315998532,
-0.0398802198,
-0.0685792863,
-0.0596076883,
0.056536641,
0.0312089343,
0.0063215508,
0.0036192504,
-0.0021206075,
0.014875507,
0.0055824611,
0.030664755,
0.0130282519,
-0.0251632556,
0.0123731242,
0.0292113647,
-0.0447246879,
0.0396242402,
-0.03196178,
-0.0027138367,
-0.0058113849,
-0.0163911879,
0.0759740546,
0.0352738686,
-0.0238428358,
-0.048412241,
-0.0473686196,
-0.0157151781,
-0.0036919049,
0.0115278289,
-0.0418797098,
0.0113908257,
0.0226787385,
0.020964101,
-0.0682716444,
0.0323712677,
0.0187048409,
-0.0585615821,
0.0443727858,
-0.0945667773,
-0.0001018842,
0.029501861,
0.0590810031,
0.0549361184,
0.0264386423,
0.0158318002,
-0.0187739376,
0.0261320639,
-0.0163071603,
0.0445408747,
0.000883916,
-0.0246400032,
-0.0714992136,
-0.0292598754,
-0.0295103043,
0.0046994616,
0.0559271947,
-0.0450559705,
0.0322661065,
-0.0196845252,
0.0836161599,
0.0825896412,
0.0906424075,
0.055972673,
0.04652071,
-0.0294329431,
-0.020734638,
-0.0127484575,
-0.0364214256,
-0.0349978991,
0.038414374,
-0.0024078276,
-0.0010308232,
0.0328814425,
-0.0449487343,
-0.0361153372,
-0.0373384617,
-0.044187054,
-0.0510463044,
0.0034505872,
0.0266736355,
-0.0407610051,
-0.0319237337,
0.043744877,
0.0861975253,
0.029669974,
-0.0283512734,
-0.0247173887,
-0.0126758432,
0.04749256,
0.1203424856,
0.0381436944,
-0.0289522856,
-0.0097977323,
-0.0205323715,
0.0095702568,
0.0195202325,
0.0146325156,
0.015689563,
0.0462273434,
-0.0254282504,
0.0218153223,
0.0177308433,
0.0170981567,
-0.0577401482,
-0.0479854569,
0.0569358319,
-0.0146195712,
0.0197696872,
-0.0172199495,
0.0246777404,
-0.0167094078,
-0.0392544977,
0.0197704062,
-0.0070873806,
-0.0012352722,
0.0527576208,
-0.0050811488,
0.0241666343,
0.0304148365,
-0.0439321548,
0.0120627256,
0.0307396688,
-0.0273929164,
0.0318281204,
0.017610684,
-0.0001003097,
0.0486901551,
0.0111714425,
0.021637531,
-0.0442217514,
0.0020124724,
-0.0359830521,
0.0785008669,
0.0103568546,
-0.0025092454,
0.0232321993,
0.0107341912,
-0.0314856805,
-0.0190591142,
-0.0184753519,
0.034570314,
-0.0233430602,
-0.057229463,
-0.0301316809,
0.0138711818,
-0.0056873062,
0.0708807632,
0.004260649,
0.0247169863,
-0.0129750222,
-0.0059217103,
-0.0334619395,
-0.0510881506,
-0.1587849259,
0.0087237051,
-0.0061758896,
-0.0272273235,
0.0392835662,
0.0474895723,
-0.0087368786,
-0.0343051367,
-0.025391547,
0.0096451165,
0.0426736884,
0.0310472008,
-0.0075091841,
0.0233619567,
-0.0016175515,
-0.0295825414,
-0.0140289087,
-0.0162301101,
0.0325066596,
-0.0320532806,
-0.0481933914,
-0.032534983,
-0.0312435329,
-0.0658292472,
-0.0317902714,
-0.0039330414,
0.0003976618,
0.0343765579,
-0.0295881629,
0.0428524911,
0.0187126156,
-0.0115057286,
0.0363158919,
0.0114073427,
-0.036539685,
0.0073233582,
-0.0322085731,
0.0339953005,
-0.0018240932,
-0.0472909696,
-0.0609434396,
-0.0038418556,
0.0368641503,
-0.0069275545,
0.0310619529,
-0.0008822917,
0.0026290941,
-0.0171992145,
0.0453309976,
0.0035761897,
0.0066473451,
-0.0104098851,
0.0124245193,
0.0033537357,
-0.0286994614,
0.0252740737,
-0.0013614234,
-0.0275618434,
-0.0161976181,
-0.0601776056,
-0.0229873732,
0.0635944009,
-0.0480186082,
0.0362860821,
0.0068319081,
-0.0297011863,
0.0609769262,
-0.0657448918,
-0.0421251282,
-0.0367992669,
0.0541122332,
-0.0783619508,
-0.0203908328,
0.0185891222,
0.0097967805,
-0.0010921169,
-0.0348622426,
-0.1135051399,
-0.0026527068,
-0.0103873676,
-0.0081725242,
-0.0431977063,
-0.0295706596,
0.0503419451,
0.066023387,
-0.0052066706,
-0.0364037566,
0.0107148867,
-0.0034255467,
0.0312921926,
-0.027754195,
0.0425579846,
0.0008213793,
0.044634752,
0.0406347103,
-0.0223171767,
0.0579603091,
0.0465093218,
0.0047992896,
0.0111561008,
0.0060974443,
-0.0272617619,
0.0427131765,
0.0582281463,
-0.0013884224,
-0.0454139188,
0.0902815834,
0.0122916652,
-0.069982186,
0.0348229557,
-0.0497048385,
-0.0359777734,
0.0009472904,
0.0011660424,
-0.0354284607,
-0.0266165119,
-0.0260603968,
0.0299400315,
-0.0267228596,
-0.0431139469,
-0.0112129385,
0.0370294675,
-0.0343245454,
0.0293144956,
-0.0082566841,
0.0278345887,
0.001856951,
0.0003490303,
0.0273370463,
-0.0219952725,
-0.0199815352,
-0.0284895487,
-0.0168274995,
-0.0222129878,
-0.1087303534,
-0.0577831231,
0.0330487564,
0.0170717966,
0.0939672664,
0.0408368185,
0.0427443311,
0.0094144074,
-0.0418467559,
-0.0073627341,
0.0568913259,
0.0115347616,
0.0019240533,
-0.0079548899,
0.0440665185,
0.0182596743,
-0.0506446473,
0.0585660003,
-0.0587382689,
-0.0356966145,
-0.0138701675,
0.0588585362,
-0.029745711,
0.0077321348,
-0.0155414287,
0.0217802227,
0.065667823,
0.0058779418,
0.0314746797,
-0.0585938133,
-0.0082417214,
0.000914499,
0.0130586661,
0.0423701778,
-0.0235933941,
0.0063828374,
0.0188188832,
-0.0062211319,
-0.0622024015,
-0.0419134609,
0.0351977684,
-0.0074340631,
-0.0081169875,
-0.001782638,
0.0548184291,
0.0004915511,
-0.026778819,
0.0113357184,
0.0151610551,
0.0321249664,
-0.0478977077,
0.0145808281,
0.0043768445,
-0.0138427326,
0.043040406,
0.0196158458,
-0.0703547746,
-0.0156852901,
0.0623902231,
0.0140643166,
0.0206510276,
-0.0109925466,
0.026499575,
-0.0494764969,
-0.0570760518,
0.0134788277,
-0.0483794697,
0.0111523047,
-0.0320921913,
0.055217009,
0.0120997876,
0.026973743,
-0.0056672427,
0.0269473959,
0.0291060656,
-0.0002474959,
-0.003822302,
-0.0176854208,
-0.0026802672,
0.0228620209,
-0.0015789114,
-0.0087747006,
-0.0063682571,
-0.0023202405,
-0.0171124991,
-0.0492169559,
-0.00522243,
-0.055682864,
-0.0236158986,
0.0096941637,
-0.0050284676,
-0.0251980443,
-0.0234234929,
-0.0608802028,
-0.0334251858,
-0.0183371734,
0.0087003913,
-0.0447377525,
-0.0364614874,
-0.0153533863,
-0.011813472,
-0.0353839844,
0.0673533753,
-0.0345087312,
0.0312644355,
-0.0319766328,
0.1057173088,
-0.0283958558,
-0.0047131702,
0.0144956056,
0.0336874686,
-0.0588436164,
-0.1252364665,
0.0057993704,
0.0202292986,
0.0558105931,
0.0142901633,
0.0228025224,
-0.0424003564,
0.027577024,
-0.0253288802,
0.0176206082,
0.004147267,
-0.0222413391,
-0.0125463279,
0.003583712,
-0.0148558011,
-0.0539771132,
0.0024425236,
-0.0470027216,
0.0000451505,
0.0306861345,
0.0022855257,
-0.0322466306,
0.0225800108,
0.0260790419,
0.0578513183,
-0.0594585799,
-0.0153930346,
-0.0561587997,
-0.0351061597,
0.0850014165,
-0.0271723196,
-0.0450571589,
-0.0836691037,
0.0165016707,
0.0112900846,
0.0226726644,
-0.019093357,
-0.0512818135,
0.0465754904,
-0.034728203,
-0.0184369218,
-0.0399299823,
-5.307279852e-33,
0.0038170198,
-0.0136444364,
-0.0015655098,
-0.0446570814,
-0.0512505621,
0.0045112167,
-0.0426488891,
0.0547617562,
0.0198613983,
0.0164546017,
0.0029970822,
0.0510700494,
-0.0034613551,
0.0454701185,
0.0317958482,
0.0178660583,
0.0296264645,
0.0167180225,
-0.0093079386,
0.0222432744,
0.0021604532,
0.0431749672,
0.0203062687,
-0.095104374,
0.0139279207,
0.0032699408,
0.0058240639,
0.0225318801,
0.0320563242,
0.0291262623,
-0.047506813,
0.0164779425,
0.0213441662,
0.0096737817,
-0.0061833765,
0.0298008732,
-0.0340457223,
-0.0499264859,
0.0197594874,
-0.0022490642,
-0.0553844273,
-0.0038997116,
0.005522802,
-0.0451359004,
-0.0041191499,
0.013718091,
-0.007242132,
-0.031817019,
-0.0455214903,
-0.000341913,
-0.0087732952,
-0.020255601,
0.0162936635,
0.0049455781,
-0.0138678104,
-0.0536162667,
-0.0494682901,
-0.0215260945,
-0.0627196953,
-0.0030256729,
-0.018225709,
0.0045664054,
-0.0245021395,
-0.0170510896,
-0.0309458114,
0.0619458146,
-0.0228024311,
0.0077836034,
-0.035367433,
0.0337842777,
-0.0043679047,
0.022376772,
0.0263033342,
0.0041673067,
-0.0185044184,
-0.0218286663,
-0.0103381202,
-0.0322087891,
-0.0152576705,
-0.021013055,
0.0242213365,
0.0280040503,
0.0042885086,
-0.019238662,
-0.0164282955,
0.0482141227,
-0.014900282,
-0.0125963874,
-0.0088693816,
-0.0146962749,
-0.0145249125,
-0.0040222565,
-0.0117489211,
-0.019540932,
-0.036020305,
-0.0020963184,
0.0214068331,
0.039853733,
-0.0060224272,
-0.0238454528,
-0.0274025574,
0.0089524249,
-0.0334027074,
0.0271454528,
0.0560704172,
0.033156164,
0.0305956248,
-0.0066956882,
-0.0525043197,
-0.0129949637,
0.0128493849,
0.0593056455,
0.00851053,
-0.005605618,
0.0067880829,
-0.0008819784,
-0.0172918495,
0.0658585802,
0.0109446654,
-0.0134248203,
-0.0583293885,
-0.0039902474,
0.0209169611,
-0.007406387,
-0.0027305931,
-0.0312242396,
-0.0644193441,
0.0410235152,
0.107968986,
0.0025428771,
0.011980366,
-0.0129705947,
2.652e-7,
-0.0129641974,
0.0429682769,
-0.0297256541,
-0.0161012933,
0.0553925894,
0.0132173263,
0.0034251616,
0.0358476825,
-0.0037350792,
-0.0397113375,
-0.0070269587,
0.0171763934,
0.0572859272,
0.0672741011,
0.003265463,
-0.0083544143,
-0.0464978293,
-0.0126013774,
-0.0833829865,
0.0291239973,
0.0668255091,
0.0349657089,
0.0281261783,
-0.0163810104,
0.008115205,
0.0151235918,
0.0355665758,
-0.0353652053,
0.0409060195,
0.0046295589,
0.0260343365,
-0.0067284694,
0.0137074087,
-0.0341537073,
-0.0051620007,
-0.0415182374,
-0.0330170318,
0.083696261,
-0.0714304075,
0.0360111929,
0.0118197184,
0.0297094136,
-0.0073039136,
-0.0197180137,
0.013911481,
-0.0737238452,
-0.0474231653,
-0.035698276,
0.0294175297,
-0.0491624735,
0.0494227745,
0.0056494218,
-0.0237831641,
0.0500120744,
0.0163354725,
0.0146166459,
0.0347054936,
-0.0477539152,
-0.0037151717,
0.0069141812,
-0.0146960393,
0.0218105894,
-0.0434857532,
-0.0160712413,
-0.0590866879,
-0.0799932629,
0.027069252,
1.83750166e-34,
0.0071361987,
0.0574057847,
0.0188077632,
0.0264141317,
0.032895688,
0.0279036202,
0.0368890241,
0.0307947937,
-0.0021429344,
-0.081065461,
-0.0133479247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05224v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05224v1 | Generative Spoken Language Model based on continuous word-sized audio tokens | 2023-10-08T16:46:14 | 2023-10-08T16:46:14 | Robin Algayres, Yossi Adi, Tu Anh Nguyen, Jade Copet, Gabriel Synnaeve, Benoit Sagot, Emmanuel Dupoux | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In NLP, text language models based on words or subwords are known to
outperform their character-based counterparts. Yet, in the speech community,
the standard input of spoken LMs are 20ms or 40ms-long discrete units (shorter
than a phoneme). Taking inspiration from word-based LM, we introduce a
Generative Spoken Language Model (GSLM) based on word-size continuous-valued
audio embeddings that can generate diverse and expressive language output. This
is obtained by replacing lookup table for lexical types with a Lexical
Embedding function, the cross entropy loss by a contrastive loss, and
multinomial sampling by k-NN sampling. The resulting model is the first
generative language model based on word-size continuous embeddings. Its
performance is on par with discrete unit GSLMs regarding generation quality as
measured by automatic metrics and subjective human judgements. Moreover, it is
five times more memory efficient thanks to its large 200ms units. In addition,
the embeddings before and after the Lexical Embedder are phonetically and
semantically interpretable. | [
-0.0186474528,
0.0328346752,
-0.0025348358,
0.033499524,
-0.0415076725,
-0.0339679047,
0.0363176689,
-0.0105998423,
-0.041183468,
-0.0497796796,
-0.0117706712,
-0.0515571348,
0.0263925362,
0.0498868376,
0.0713654384,
-0.0723292902,
0.0247034356,
-0.0448735692,
0.0041804183,
-0.0129858693,
-0.0060206088,
0.0141603239,
-0.0099372566,
0.0553340241,
-0.0578072593,
-0.019134881,
-0.0109505281,
-0.0113419387,
-0.0112463068,
-0.0008680724,
-0.045947507,
0.00811728,
0.0614603087,
0.0127009144,
0.0000018498,
-0.0202597082,
0.0210760478,
0.0093917493,
-0.005057429,
0.0228256155,
0.0332073718,
-0.0067943032,
-0.0361026786,
0.0635014474,
0.0163874943,
-0.0455960967,
0.0293020774,
0.0308816098,
0.0246392451,
0.0761110485,
-0.0181307252,
-0.0635056421,
0.0411747247,
-0.045983728,
0.0245301705,
0.0166048184,
-0.013406557,
-0.0037644224,
0.0319119953,
0.0193843078,
-0.0183541458,
0.0564271547,
-0.0022604521,
-0.0110797556,
0.017461827,
0.0548979305,
-0.03163727,
-0.0053205756,
-0.0010030096,
0.0608929507,
-0.0394446701,
0.0018462824,
0.024112422,
-0.0163564663,
-0.0208232366,
-0.0635220632,
-0.0329293683,
0.0426825732,
0.0502187945,
0.0318052359,
-0.0039843814,
0.0539095514,
0.0406551659,
-0.0257729124,
-0.0073640211,
-0.0012674029,
0.0226793457,
-0.0226751734,
-0.0361615792,
-0.0509907976,
-0.0485506169,
-0.0146927638,
-0.005104234,
-0.0022563951,
0.0015994784,
0.0173365772,
-0.0415558256,
-0.0063926647,
0.0217402,
-0.0518208072,
-0.0017188983,
0.0195324235,
-0.0097026033,
0.0199787989,
-0.0147805475,
0.0250141956,
0.0229958519,
-0.024838753,
-0.0275204312,
-0.0186103713,
0.0108328881,
-0.0144480672,
-0.0415477641,
0.0260584578,
-0.0305046085,
-0.0451048575,
-0.0301073808,
0.0324151888,
-0.0266246442,
0.0390271246,
0.020471381,
0.0255919434,
-0.0219337195,
-0.0053839949,
0.0107879592,
-0.0168031119,
-0.0213921685,
0.0349596888,
0.0066888668,
-0.0401043706,
0.01057282,
0.0407461114,
0.0345692895,
0.0071924054,
-0.0067576985,
0.1062063649,
0.0294254031,
-0.0420960151,
-0.0195960235,
-0.0318088345,
-0.0403144993,
-0.0410697758,
-0.0512620136,
-0.0960915312,
0.0587710403,
-0.0105916429,
-0.0247337427,
-0.0377384946,
-0.0022899029,
0.0319765322,
-0.0170545951,
0.0502686426,
-0.010212427,
0.0378864482,
0.02092099,
-0.0091415867,
0.0261009783,
0.0767798796,
0.1007294804,
-0.0284316465,
0.043925494,
-0.0393507145,
-0.02289127,
0.044934608,
0.0075014262,
-0.0203509554,
-0.0758809894,
-0.0381397605,
-0.0116906818,
0.0840873197,
0.0559312664,
0.0975028127,
-0.0370851085,
-0.0164914336,
0.0374005847,
0.0683322176,
0.0180335212,
0.0414617993,
0.0531939715,
0.0350230932,
-0.0183125902,
0.0105226217,
0.0164514817,
-0.0009276041,
0.0519613549,
0.0396500975,
0.1010629162,
0.0319661796,
-0.0357824005,
-0.015556098,
-0.0354205184,
-0.0312857293,
-0.0169437602,
-0.0257518645,
0.0320638828,
0.0116638374,
-0.0527666323,
0.046895206,
0.0114264078,
-0.0514519662,
0.0390331745,
-0.0107457368,
0.0284899529,
0.0898462832,
0.0545828976,
0.0028222995,
0.031166086,
-0.0472102575,
-0.0461037084,
0.0478164516,
0.0224858578,
-0.0076415017,
0.042459622,
-0.0524589792,
0.0131097529,
0.0140156941,
0.0052286191,
0.0256040692,
-0.0367777832,
0.0423876271,
0.0319219194,
-0.0559803471,
0.0378552377,
-0.0153656965,
-0.041621007,
-0.0165436994,
0.0325977281,
-0.0120769003,
0.02305004,
0.0535354242,
-0.0383045673,
0.0405502394,
0.0239868667,
-0.0568096191,
0.0101992665,
0.0136693092,
-0.0954354852,
-0.0690755323,
0.0029502269,
-0.0306784343,
0.0377440229,
-0.0067600678,
-0.0090740174,
-0.0400385931,
0.030668892,
-0.0274534822,
0.089068152,
-0.0623336285,
0.0123296697,
0.0244890526,
0.0102970246,
-0.0128873112,
0.0232340377,
-0.0081214542,
0.0190784018,
-0.0056380918,
0.0500555374,
0.0109821064,
-0.0812466741,
-0.0261650551,
0.0465893373,
-0.0180567168,
0.0350414813,
-0.0151707651,
-0.0194592457,
0.0077015688,
-0.0249618869,
-0.0874164775,
0.0002560641,
-0.004659785,
-0.0243994948,
-0.0152752483,
0.0237486418,
0.0098560555,
0.0254060086,
-0.039943926,
-0.0172862317,
0.0209950861,
-0.0103952289,
-0.0094023878,
-0.0164329354,
-0.0131318774,
-0.0243436377,
0.0075147501,
0.0201825853,
0.0501546003,
-0.0347883552,
0.0277292933,
-0.0534231663,
0.0443111323,
-0.0036955422,
0.0205446798,
0.0026817347,
-0.0158370975,
-0.0326544158,
-0.0008499395,
0.0894199982,
-0.0016148385,
0.0460274592,
0.0295216888,
0.023872111,
-0.0147409309,
-0.0450892039,
-0.0041253464,
-0.0059255352,
0.0596369989,
-0.0076030097,
-0.0067062224,
0.0017656861,
0.0608566962,
0.0705017969,
0.0080600167,
-0.0358501337,
-0.0273598265,
-0.0282688737,
-0.021224374,
-0.0315746963,
-0.0168533809,
-0.0715449825,
-0.0102465358,
0.0075666495,
-0.0472598039,
0.0076827039,
-0.0609653704,
0.0002113668,
-0.0524671152,
-0.0499728881,
-0.0179687254,
0.0398342311,
-0.0063766055,
0.0194457322,
0.0076250569,
-0.0067399889,
-0.0323946513,
0.0261123311,
-0.0028331825,
-0.0574008748,
0.0231082495,
-0.0038748269,
-0.0231532566,
0.0059964787,
-0.0129197072,
-0.0539209433,
-0.0281840116,
-0.0024449744,
0.0367566794,
0.0355762951,
0.0095813228,
-0.0076521174,
0.0368011557,
0.0224308874,
0.0245230719,
-0.0015424539,
0.0097635034,
-0.0160362665,
0.0715911016,
0.0481679402,
0.0017682335,
-0.0237030014,
0.0094759529,
0.0455197021,
0.0127482684,
0.0577791966,
0.0483349785,
-0.0313305631,
-0.0194150899,
0.0114717474,
0.022683192,
-0.0570541732,
0.0410115197,
0.0209095124,
-0.0288034137,
-0.0276955329,
0.1230876744,
0.0109891593,
0.0067782127,
0.0267350227,
0.0290847085,
0.037947882,
-0.0276226476,
-0.0012436848,
-0.0355152115,
-0.0191984363,
0.0512982383,
0.030213479,
0.0146802012,
0.0200840645,
-0.0189385824,
-0.1159892753,
0.0452648588,
0.0328242667,
-0.0422817804,
-0.0336935669,
-0.0296052303,
-0.0450891927,
0.0068053789,
0.0055930717,
0.0054736817,
-0.006069853,
-0.006486407,
0.0485821813,
-0.0516583845,
-0.0464728922,
0.0050009899,
-0.0543823317,
0.0998693034,
0.0528157875,
0.0496244878,
-0.0179985799,
-0.0632059425,
0.0232419856,
-0.0043582437,
-0.0315223038,
0.0243311655,
0.0247116853,
-0.0376656987,
-0.0051447125,
0.0395731293,
0.0395719931,
-0.0081103994,
-0.0156555735,
-0.0174369253,
0.0529895537,
-0.0000989207,
-0.0096829403,
-0.0415530987,
0.0386449993,
0.0067270114,
0.081612356,
0.0179055072,
-0.0642018989,
-0.0182087477,
-0.0109971361,
0.035362646,
-0.0346014425,
-0.0133889532,
-0.0141679598,
0.0289969873,
-0.0164631903,
-0.0485604145,
-0.0151318787,
-0.0087708822,
0.0499900952,
-0.0033558968,
0.0058948728,
-0.0109632257,
-0.0025686366,
-0.0407891572,
-0.0088482285,
0.0135744615,
0.0463341139,
-0.0727744102,
-0.0315567441,
0.0568256788,
-0.0239663981,
-0.0247631725,
0.0117417024,
-0.0643443018,
-0.0388260297,
-0.0100511173,
0.0092507442,
0.0132439071,
0.0421655327,
-0.0190967657,
-0.0160152372,
0.0791669637,
0.0342887528,
-0.0566179529,
0.0119252084,
0.0043868744,
0.0283378307,
0.0017402512,
0.0338511579,
-0.0465544052,
0.0225370787,
-0.0323674306,
0.0416385829,
0.0224997886,
-0.0282231383,
-0.0605854876,
-0.0488512255,
0.0338314325,
-0.0285175703,
0.0504837893,
-0.0345102325,
-0.008148226,
-0.0284342337,
0.0447818488,
-0.0623790212,
0.0136052053,
0.0192554574,
0.0223368909,
-0.0444031954,
-0.0382447876,
0.0031116873,
0.0322248526,
0.0193979088,
0.0358410589,
0.013668946,
-0.0341673233,
0.0154635152,
-0.0093955025,
-0.0298993438,
-0.0128796399,
-0.0576146021,
0.0131578716,
-0.0220460221,
-0.0020946485,
-0.0301550459,
-0.0210337527,
0.0021388577,
0.0264220368,
-0.0195607767,
0.0092674503,
-0.045522403,
0.0501001328,
0.0267181676,
-0.0127777494,
0.0103612002,
-0.0072526876,
0.035566099,
-0.0564549118,
0.054256279,
-0.0333007909,
-0.0571422391,
0.0308680795,
0.0198506266,
-0.0600589029,
0.0018537851,
0.0708314627,
0.0316667557,
0.0015581517,
-0.041042611,
0.0197321232,
-0.0288407803,
0.0181132257,
-0.0073470981,
0.0556032397,
-0.0216217246,
0.0275287367,
-0.0683406219,
-0.1017207429,
0.028802501,
-0.0024175995,
0.0426097848,
-0.0013946651,
0.0370261446,
0.0131712938,
-0.0056933765,
0.0597890653,
0.0043584392,
-0.0023467874,
0.005700659,
-0.0430785082,
-0.006216005,
-6.010392982e-33,
-0.017727999,
-0.0102157686,
-0.0095471479,
-0.0377990007,
-0.0391481183,
0.0144950924,
-0.0223885011,
0.011716865,
0.0203142595,
-0.0301764105,
-0.0109761208,
-0.0225056559,
-0.0011367672,
0.0581105798,
-0.0064216168,
0.0104139289,
0.0451617725,
-0.034181945,
0.0017369,
0.026952425,
0.0589964092,
0.0451863669,
0.0023008848,
-0.0283752382,
-0.0286771599,
-0.0036958989,
0.0139329731,
-0.0224295203,
0.0476803519,
0.0532720573,
-0.0584164076,
0.0611433685,
0.0007560994,
-0.0397528149,
-0.040376626,
0.0179883633,
-0.0659755543,
-0.0000191303,
0.0073620034,
0.0240354147,
-0.0195315275,
-0.0108900862,
0.0221146364,
-0.0094666677,
-0.0166771729,
-0.0103660459,
0.0195663814,
-0.0086961016,
-0.0702957213,
-0.0476688407,
-0.0417772606,
0.0478922687,
0.0066035949,
-0.0189286787,
0.0114509556,
0.0200330056,
0.0131897349,
-0.0028018176,
-0.0401495695,
0.0309585035,
-0.0011266802,
0.0373959206,
0.0329626724,
-0.0038440402,
0.0128146103,
0.0678745136,
0.0193156004,
-0.0684189498,
-0.0062431563,
-0.0049264226,
0.0254974458,
0.0219447501,
-0.0203942917,
0.0188416559,
0.0201949235,
-0.0810047835,
-0.0102774743,
-0.0044615837,
0.0076209209,
-0.0208905991,
0.0766363814,
0.0279175807,
-0.0362303853,
-0.0254760366,
-0.0544087067,
-0.0350931622,
-0.0086546289,
-0.0314452387,
0.0530468896,
0.0164631475,
0.0110989362,
-0.0335099213,
0.0530858375,
-0.027897127,
-0.0095500108,
0.0144168492,
-0.0155734392,
-0.0017876801,
-0.0045504398,
0.0134822885,
-0.0433863364,
-0.0333841853,
0.0607824177,
0.0121036312,
0.0007079902,
0.0006822723,
-0.0261372551,
0.0583960749,
-0.0623250715,
0.0045748423,
-0.0271454137,
-0.0145082343,
-0.0092076343,
0.0120235924,
0.0219097789,
0.0106176548,
-0.0213928986,
0.0431106761,
-0.0269343331,
-0.0129305134,
-0.004730443,
-0.0258681942,
-0.0315980092,
0.044509951,
-0.038126193,
0.0156564303,
-0.0094404947,
-0.0074937181,
0.0472432487,
-0.0232017711,
-0.0026227676,
-0.0181376971,
2.735e-7,
-0.0316262059,
-0.0014563029,
0.0156174116,
-0.0120178666,
0.0505103581,
0.0208388343,
-0.0086692451,
0.040510878,
-0.0262367949,
0.0213969946,
-0.0113569153,
-0.0336230882,
0.0659648106,
0.0101682357,
-0.1247399822,
0.0438591614,
-0.0531215593,
0.0461474918,
-0.0343386494,
-0.0242380686,
0.0432417728,
0.1377374828,
-0.0026133624,
-0.0038612918,
0.0118392296,
-0.0296800621,
0.0434705131,
-0.0276961066,
0.0037229178,
-0.0884175077,
0.0234891493,
0.0187077001,
0.0058852988,
-0.051995784,
-0.0505683385,
0.0331021808,
0.0657804608,
0.0725983381,
0.0215317365,
-0.0521229655,
0.0324643925,
-0.0003142937,
-0.0392620713,
-0.0187817644,
0.0530797169,
-0.0024115818,
-0.0290198885,
-0.0103414571,
-0.0157405809,
0.01211333,
0.0107320184,
-0.0288728122,
-0.0352139398,
-0.0160289146,
0.0227293931,
-0.0215042606,
-0.0002292774,
-0.047631491,
0.005900214,
-0.0160147678,
-0.07904239,
-0.0377586298,
-0.032671459,
-0.0033562493,
0.0511050224,
0.0074518304,
-0.0091715232,
2.294893055e-34,
0.0503182337,
-0.0323824845,
-0.0172019936,
0.006093407,
0.0098802438,
-0.0130291795,
0.063865535,
0.0165254399,
0.0299308784,
-0.0405899994,
-0.0522565432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05216v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05216v2 | Probing Large Language Models from A Human Behavioral Perspective | 2023-10-08T16:16:21 | 2024-04-13T15:22:39 | Xintong Wang, Xiaoyu Li, Xingshan Li, Chris Biemann | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as dominant foundational models in
modern NLP. However, the understanding of their prediction processes and
internal mechanisms, such as feed-forward networks (FFN) and multi-head
self-attention (MHSA), remains largely unexplored. In this work, we probe LLMs
from a human behavioral perspective, correlating values from LLMs with
eye-tracking measures, which are widely recognized as meaningful indicators of
human reading patterns. Our findings reveal that LLMs exhibit a similar
prediction pattern with humans but distinct from that of Shallow Language
Models (SLMs). Moreover, with the escalation of LLM layers from the middle
layers, the correlation coefficients also increase in FFN and MHSA, indicating
that the logits within FFN increasingly encapsulate word semantics suitable for
predicting tokens from the vocabulary. | [
0.0225038156,
0.0117235323,
-0.0443032794,
0.0394517221,
-0.0016367156,
0.0132891629,
0.0142065659,
0.0068386719,
0.0341002643,
-0.0209042616,
-0.0453698523,
-0.0533363968,
0.0031892818,
0.0400185958,
0.0747698843,
0.0026620422,
0.0305468086,
-0.0479635149,
-0.0523956865,
0.015019604,
0.0469389483,
0.0155842621,
0.0353192426,
0.0377401933,
-0.0125214942,
-0.0219501387,
-0.0138704088,
-0.0015656023,
-0.0100080669,
0.0024736882,
-0.0060912445,
0.058309067,
-0.0177637767,
0.0516152754,
0.000001838,
-0.0197973698,
0.0381197818,
-0.0282434337,
-0.0021344707,
0.0603804104,
0.0204821657,
-0.0124945762,
-0.0060746968,
-0.0063499399,
-0.0128860446,
-0.0083471956,
0.0203301348,
0.0548146442,
0.0381259024,
0.0233255364,
0.0095655806,
-0.0163684282,
0.0767966285,
-0.0381450579,
0.0061525456,
-0.0495798849,
0.0490432791,
-0.0223276615,
-0.0621437058,
0.0091109462,
-0.0223875269,
0.0307091922,
-0.004314844,
0.0180512015,
0.0312975086,
0.0570321903,
-0.0058364971,
-0.023154825,
-0.0002370271,
0.0545153506,
-0.0074995901,
-0.0581047572,
0.0075795641,
-0.0150848748,
-0.0233955719,
0.058681827,
-0.0528885126,
0.0041067279,
0.0028755323,
0.0188819077,
0.0637056157,
-0.0140854428,
0.0287590865,
0.025112845,
-0.0477638692,
0.0597361289,
-0.0082735941,
-0.0275334325,
0.0174382217,
0.0261142515,
0.0345582627,
-0.0402034782,
0.0193380043,
0.0006444279,
0.031089006,
0.0262625013,
-0.0293990541,
-0.0552958734,
0.0515401736,
-0.0701581985,
0.0534638539,
0.0165162347,
-0.0202481337,
0.0381793976,
-0.0490501262,
0.0424734913,
-0.0580144674,
-0.0014316877,
-0.0195808224,
0.0217215214,
-0.0047206841,
-0.0387886912,
-0.0080167884,
-0.016707005,
-0.0029031904,
-0.0837084129,
-0.036180418,
0.0295584947,
0.0231420938,
-0.0342438929,
-0.0100689204,
0.010844144,
-0.0028405413,
-0.0209128689,
-0.0052694767,
0.0305064898,
-0.0203476418,
-0.0047740778,
0.0028142559,
-0.0542209148,
-0.0223875176,
0.0296863168,
-0.013043087,
-0.0116121089,
-0.0290741175,
0.0741053149,
0.0033871825,
-0.0475966111,
-0.0267322119,
-0.0090638753,
-0.0246527996,
-0.0258999132,
0.0093093487,
-0.0483641885,
0.0063397121,
0.0200606603,
0.0031541053,
-0.0045893933,
0.0028055967,
0.0699776039,
-0.0465980098,
0.024882311,
-0.0000375304,
0.035605859,
0.0062192627,
-0.0093197711,
0.0023012501,
0.0649329424,
0.0118294591,
0.0328337774,
0.018314885,
-0.0393652022,
-0.0051095909,
0.0616222098,
0.0023569199,
0.008868942,
-0.0717670023,
-0.0271672532,
-0.0015559255,
0.0100636967,
0.0574517027,
0.0458660051,
-0.0191567168,
-0.0509668253,
0.0904699937,
0.1060833856,
0.0496524051,
0.0214602482,
0.0294014234,
0.0224582702,
0.0269276761,
0.0438878201,
-0.0356321111,
0.0223076697,
-0.040105436,
0.0064425571,
0.0300979801,
-0.0160063524,
-0.0096216043,
-0.0178907886,
-0.0136740636,
0.0373817235,
-0.0063923206,
-0.0033777845,
0.0657802895,
-0.0388125367,
-0.0275073983,
0.0084359664,
0.0363908745,
-0.0158544574,
0.0085300291,
-0.0329699479,
0.0054289931,
0.0622552559,
0.0293620601,
0.0048694322,
-0.0126907779,
0.0327636525,
-0.0078156758,
0.04637146,
0.0285366736,
0.0321661346,
-0.00280979,
-0.0170963109,
0.0467483737,
0.0285208784,
0.0189096406,
0.0138229895,
-0.019749321,
-0.0111337053,
-0.0020436465,
0.0079686949,
-0.0643349141,
0.0550566055,
-0.0754529834,
0.0046642139,
-0.04597985,
0.0164698921,
0.0166170429,
-0.0040131276,
0.0044919956,
0.0422070958,
0.0191194285,
-0.017509168,
0.0215617232,
-0.010367428,
-0.0334947892,
0.0335015543,
0.0287573282,
-0.0089241648,
0.0084420862,
0.023249371,
0.0265472233,
-0.0318397656,
0.0162096415,
-0.066289708,
0.0543902703,
-0.0639373288,
-0.0046887514,
-0.0033451172,
0.0519887134,
-0.0425017253,
0.022655353,
-0.0059876605,
0.0305004083,
-0.0168297458,
-0.0069286805,
-0.0072258492,
-0.0276249349,
0.0066242581,
0.0129204355,
-0.0030560158,
-0.0249806177,
-0.0093841655,
-0.0209082961,
-0.0777111873,
-0.0329486169,
-0.0756906196,
-0.0063271928,
-0.0101714991,
0.0185439829,
0.0169898756,
-0.0194341224,
-0.0275156479,
0.013603582,
-0.0273920707,
0.0280342158,
-0.0150111383,
0.0300429612,
0.0247781239,
-0.0088362116,
-0.0154056391,
-0.0513123684,
-0.039314691,
-0.0380778126,
0.0725640506,
0.0166671909,
-0.0318494551,
-0.0907610953,
0.0269387141,
0.0024381201,
0.036244534,
-0.0275176689,
-0.0297791492,
0.0112824617,
-0.0483047366,
0.026553778,
0.0922256634,
0.0335128717,
0.0306364298,
0.0232147016,
-0.0111180693,
-0.0552264825,
-0.0197217111,
-0.0304807462,
0.0181240998,
-0.036157798,
-0.0336575769,
0.0078235911,
0.0842588022,
0.0322982036,
-0.0159562305,
-0.0334584154,
0.0395129845,
-0.0182389785,
-0.051865112,
-0.039785929,
-0.0026261965,
-0.0730026737,
0.0542349666,
-0.0087236529,
-0.0547228716,
0.0692969486,
-0.0572730601,
-0.0099563012,
0.0314570107,
0.005637785,
-0.0414179303,
0.0516124405,
0.0323730931,
0.0034291209,
0.0050085504,
-0.0700665712,
-0.0312537439,
0.0504155084,
-0.0286019742,
-0.0260748081,
0.0817559063,
-0.0058553591,
-0.0000661432,
0.0272806678,
0.0276425779,
-0.022629492,
-0.0334312171,
-0.0673692971,
-0.0352095738,
-0.0033544737,
0.0167134162,
-0.0564695671,
0.0117398258,
0.0286562648,
0.0280363522,
-0.0446565114,
-0.0131201968,
-0.0263557639,
0.0430721529,
0.0516525283,
-0.012181838,
0.0257103778,
-0.0579954237,
-0.0001987968,
0.0761387274,
0.035454873,
0.0413013771,
-0.0162269026,
-0.0192167126,
0.0661715716,
-0.0372406952,
-0.0223680343,
0.000683345,
0.0256780721,
-0.0890398324,
0.0200900622,
0.1127318591,
0.0211070124,
-0.0621875934,
0.0041905884,
-0.035257522,
0.0287835803,
0.0199336093,
0.0348511748,
-0.0002167462,
-0.0293805338,
0.0068447366,
0.0260386914,
0.009774887,
-0.0382071882,
0.0022116809,
-0.0837320462,
0.012549771,
0.0001835379,
-0.062108472,
-0.0026638175,
-0.0608540401,
0.0317068473,
-0.0006402704,
-0.0098017268,
0.0177305248,
-0.0288868137,
-0.0282760505,
0.0010542836,
-0.0109104337,
0.0429666266,
0.0172097664,
-0.0458023734,
0.0391971879,
0.0619375184,
0.0202162247,
-0.0227626674,
-0.0301004499,
0.0330381803,
-0.0787999332,
0.0395460315,
0.0079886774,
0.0559199266,
-0.0404445864,
0.0196788572,
-0.0346548185,
0.0180217382,
-0.0419924818,
0.0079591293,
-0.022669537,
0.0547637902,
0.0090148477,
-0.0529087558,
-0.0242196843,
0.0357286632,
-0.0397061743,
0.0584278367,
0.0595890768,
-0.0810558572,
-0.0164142866,
-0.0137205357,
0.026095055,
0.0053293947,
-0.0754270405,
0.0117948642,
0.0458378419,
-0.049837824,
-0.0363635309,
-0.044409398,
0.0099153975,
-0.0048176036,
0.0289722551,
0.0628841296,
0.059673626,
-0.0397089534,
0.00007771,
0.0455990471,
0.0046388698,
-0.0044636223,
-0.0669474974,
0.0014485645,
0.0433330685,
-0.050000973,
0.001697264,
0.0351592191,
-0.0941361487,
-0.0510118715,
0.0027461636,
0.0060231779,
0.0205051079,
0.0019650706,
-0.0117513984,
-0.0764934719,
-0.0415325575,
-0.0126196444,
-0.0276724845,
0.0412432179,
-0.0239497367,
-0.0290539805,
0.0038020459,
0.0282062609,
0.0049834433,
0.0179480072,
0.0178447422,
0.0124428635,
0.0088497736,
-0.0706377178,
-0.0060947305,
0.0015554703,
0.0928045586,
-0.0049026902,
-0.0039383811,
-0.0563047007,
-0.0528035909,
-0.009933182,
0.0091824355,
-0.0127258431,
-0.0198868457,
0.02994949,
0.0061055357,
-0.0238545947,
-0.0231220331,
-0.0014768917,
0.0223680232,
-0.0351831503,
0.0255235117,
-0.0444929563,
-0.0100264763,
0.0174602754,
0.0232926272,
-0.0156654362,
0.0009462778,
-0.039976541,
0.0507381037,
0.0055942736,
0.0576204732,
0.0284716208,
-0.0257692263,
-0.0071912385,
0.0227611195,
-0.0697766691,
-0.0316661112,
-0.0005850046,
-0.0051239077,
0.0231418125,
-0.0565895252,
0.0563626178,
-0.0235204604,
0.0048242649,
-0.0207300205,
0.0264865067,
-0.0243821032,
-0.0174410846,
-0.0050611105,
0.0275119394,
-0.0132446904,
-0.0098663094,
0.0788910761,
0.0553462729,
-0.0127464477,
0.0402706973,
-0.035646975,
-0.0158575699,
0.0052764029,
0.0345947482,
0.0282047261,
-0.0347485021,
0.0428206436,
-0.0790248886,
-0.0673587024,
0.0301427525,
0.0068717143,
0.0271546096,
-0.0370627791,
0.0266280323,
0.0932071358,
0.00791209,
0.014864211,
-0.0531103127,
0.038024269,
-0.0347439311,
-0.028956851,
-0.0004014884,
-6.580449702e-33,
0.0005412135,
-0.0580573902,
-0.0159871876,
0.0011273515,
-0.0545617789,
0.0115181766,
-0.0282095261,
0.0405006185,
-0.0128293363,
-0.0051987972,
-0.0496299304,
0.0118319672,
-0.0031999133,
0.004129827,
0.0429027118,
-0.0024609764,
-0.0033125295,
-0.0261725131,
0.0100019034,
0.0031224766,
0.0276517272,
0.0283392016,
0.0497520603,
-0.0156688336,
0.0221681558,
-0.030346619,
0.0403371677,
0.0254940223,
-0.0065689082,
0.0374137275,
-0.0429553725,
0.0578461885,
0.0570550002,
-0.0369564109,
-0.0130701531,
0.0842355713,
-0.0290386304,
-0.0168978143,
0.0442074537,
0.0116291922,
-0.0371568836,
0.0135546876,
0.0796618536,
-0.0234018806,
-0.0208700206,
-0.0026158928,
0.0582562275,
-0.0063885953,
-0.0412199162,
0.0422514752,
-0.0427081883,
0.0218498651,
0.0112699363,
0.0203170329,
0.0262581594,
0.014666005,
-0.000140591,
0.0450478904,
-0.0625686049,
0.0257800017,
-0.0306552239,
0.0210833717,
0.0599872246,
0.0669287965,
0.0117848208,
0.0867473036,
0.0496126562,
0.0348403305,
-0.0562709421,
-0.0446726419,
0.0649983808,
0.028258957,
0.0042556492,
-0.022704713,
0.0353400297,
-0.0139416754,
-0.0358352326,
0.0060827383,
0.0055137887,
0.0427490324,
0.0546658561,
-0.0051575513,
-0.0594008788,
-0.0154091679,
-0.0151289813,
0.0059651816,
-0.0388294049,
-0.013136466,
0.0247308053,
-0.0145051936,
-0.0042422307,
0.0017133373,
0.026223544,
-0.0509097874,
0.0218378957,
0.041757565,
-0.0184483081,
0.0196146537,
-0.0173055977,
0.0268539563,
-0.0652321279,
0.0122000957,
-0.0580195226,
-0.0045795743,
0.0122581152,
-0.0012262538,
0.0000828325,
-0.0486648083,
-0.0392846428,
-0.0417940356,
-0.0258614998,
-0.0421284288,
0.0114225922,
0.0018747993,
0.0826919153,
-0.0248625483,
-0.0261123441,
0.0241861381,
0.0072473777,
-0.0023508945,
-0.063038744,
0.0083430372,
-0.0076322048,
0.0116981119,
-0.0202034172,
-0.0090786424,
-0.0692380741,
0.0077534383,
0.0547279306,
-0.0714720041,
-0.016187096,
0.0295392256,
2.712e-7,
0.026661573,
0.0990110114,
-0.0114767971,
0.0289226677,
0.0583276413,
0.0415589176,
0.0057277116,
0.0249529667,
0.0173432585,
-0.0395077094,
-0.0280774832,
0.014708898,
0.0479417257,
-0.0130191408,
-0.0838648677,
-0.036300052,
-0.03091738,
0.0622407645,
-0.0152975684,
-0.0197746176,
-0.0186006688,
0.0538899265,
-0.0031174128,
-0.0117583191,
0.0309755709,
-0.0317400135,
0.049801778,
-0.0078183105,
-0.0011345721,
0.0012652267,
0.0008511111,
0.0028795158,
-0.006966488,
0.0320237465,
0.0083551873,
0.0142001286,
0.0233433172,
0.0340720303,
0.0016593455,
0.0011514812,
0.011624855,
0.0038799287,
-0.0019103525,
-0.0878283679,
0.0412632637,
-0.0284628794,
-0.0615791567,
0.0083848266,
0.001450712,
-0.0082077011,
-0.0279531144,
0.0060443506,
-0.0028493167,
0.0000845186,
0.0091385404,
-0.0522157177,
0.003909789,
-0.0610467233,
-0.0523224883,
-0.0057076938,
-0.0690331161,
-0.0299198013,
-0.0753772631,
-0.0341360308,
0.0307972897,
-0.0383592136,
-0.0301834866,
2.193221977e-34,
0.0159979109,
0.0098037701,
0.0255067032,
0.0253481939,
0.0108756116,
0.0003581482,
-0.0068060788,
0.0253165569,
0.0217016768,
-0.1080283597,
-0.0134384837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05210v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05210v1 | TILFA: A Unified Framework for Text, Image, and Layout Fusion in Argument Mining | 2023-10-08T15:54:37 | 2023-10-08T15:54:37 | Qing Zong, Zhaowei Wang, Baixuan Xu, Tianshi Zheng, Haochen Shi, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song, Ginny Y. Wong, Simon See | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | A main goal of Argument Mining (AM) is to analyze an author's stance. Unlike
previous AM datasets focusing only on text, the shared task at the 10th
Workshop on Argument Mining introduces a dataset including both text and
images. Importantly, these images contain both visual elements and optical
characters. Our new framework, TILFA (A Unified Framework for Text, Image, and
Layout Fusion in Argument Mining), is designed to handle this mixed data. It
excels at not only understanding text but also detecting optical characters and
recognizing layout details in images. Our model significantly outperforms
existing baselines, earning our team, KnowComp, the 1st place in the
leaderboard of Argumentative Stance Classification subtask in this shared task. | [
0.0223599784,
0.0606716201,
0.0409286432,
0.0807627589,
-0.0155808898,
0.0234203171,
0.0125625124,
0.0193374008,
-0.017427776,
-0.0479847677,
0.0145605113,
-0.0128984284,
0.0144573245,
-0.0215390958,
-0.0108653596,
-0.0709479824,
-0.0221715514,
0.0101442495,
0.0559261777,
0.0056411414,
0.0554610528,
0.0239391811,
-0.0254816879,
0.0415345877,
-0.0215429068,
-0.0650513023,
0.0034820114,
-0.0080023864,
0.0632150173,
-0.0026060042,
-0.0165037699,
0.0298156068,
-0.0021795302,
0.0315261781,
0.00000185,
-0.0036800385,
-0.0155536961,
-0.0111948727,
-0.024385402,
-0.0030438586,
0.0616089366,
-0.0026725912,
-0.0239849053,
0.0248049777,
-0.0444431752,
0.0052017225,
0.0530339517,
0.1279757768,
0.057228934,
0.0798740163,
-0.0282442272,
-0.0201010909,
0.0139305415,
0.0036367266,
-0.0520833768,
0.039894104,
0.0088837892,
0.0001895632,
-0.021921454,
0.0578106232,
0.0086877085,
0.007737413,
0.0281337611,
-0.0522487126,
-0.048315797,
0.0296593029,
-0.0039110882,
0.0001798633,
0.0045667668,
0.0451620854,
-0.0105595775,
-0.0319552012,
0.0063736066,
-0.0389143154,
-0.0151176509,
0.0015810609,
-0.0378744155,
0.0608168952,
-0.0525617935,
0.0517562628,
0.0279722884,
0.0114645166,
-0.0166288167,
0.0234599076,
0.0252777748,
0.0012907046,
-0.0135734119,
0.0108715249,
0.0133666256,
0.0185222197,
-0.0220569819,
-0.0589376315,
0.0284065176,
0.0439736843,
0.0539334901,
0.0240336359,
-0.0143342121,
-0.0276901182,
0.048363924,
-0.0967263058,
0.0320008956,
-0.0308156163,
-0.0451718271,
0.0792957991,
-0.0227194577,
-0.0135029312,
-0.0147083765,
0.0093565462,
0.0067881057,
-0.0010712961,
-0.0339327343,
-0.0043303743,
0.0100321732,
-0.0034100437,
-0.0606247596,
-0.0554605387,
-0.0054712566,
-0.0063215964,
-0.0254358072,
0.0184200276,
0.0388279185,
0.0175647549,
0.0335567594,
-0.0362568609,
-0.0126316864,
0.0249784011,
0.0144020244,
0.0388941504,
-0.0182904117,
0.0119449431,
0.0070335469,
0.0407482125,
0.0320113413,
0.0080537274,
-0.0013787716,
0.0124938115,
-0.0528468713,
-0.0051687178,
-0.0084338291,
-0.0417622365,
-0.0567485839,
-0.0486642495,
0.0170899257,
-0.0843454525,
0.0074612764,
-0.0401819348,
-0.000986208,
-0.0494814068,
0.0043797041,
0.040759299,
0.0119956611,
0.0627840757,
-0.0159975998,
-0.0615652874,
0.0529624112,
0.0419439971,
0.005399595,
0.0463749133,
0.0048767757,
0.0451039001,
0.0407287255,
0.0424354821,
-0.0041464949,
0.0072347713,
-0.0129897157,
-0.0068614362,
0.0643763989,
-0.0015711117,
-0.053859707,
-0.025323933,
-0.0393007547,
0.0319791511,
-0.0286008138,
-0.0502877943,
0.0254336149,
0.0378319211,
0.0037194402,
0.0182962194,
-0.0250680763,
0.0003808689,
0.0510464087,
-0.0131825414,
0.0085274326,
0.0194259882,
0.0138279498,
-0.0251176879,
-0.009041829,
0.0128969699,
-0.0203282312,
-0.0556953363,
-0.0198914222,
-0.0184893664,
-0.0052359821,
-0.0257767178,
0.0360477157,
0.022815967,
-0.0471645035,
-0.0153366383,
0.032595057,
-0.0683694705,
-0.0621481501,
0.0071490621,
0.0470857769,
0.0062668072,
0.0012113206,
-0.0449505299,
0.0235292856,
-0.0209624115,
0.0596614443,
0.0656267628,
0.0066868002,
-0.0255245995,
0.0055951476,
-0.0529346876,
-0.0173514094,
-0.0215906687,
-0.0084797964,
0.0089047328,
-0.0028634893,
0.0171406772,
0.0216212757,
0.0440198556,
-0.0416230224,
0.0397507995,
0.0676525682,
0.0181408767,
0.001356366,
0.0406099111,
0.0165650081,
0.0647059083,
-0.0148060424,
-0.0186600853,
0.0292554069,
-0.0539947376,
-0.0313208289,
0.0260005407,
0.0034536782,
-0.056745518,
0.0582603738,
-0.0609893799,
-0.0152510852,
-0.0258712322,
-0.0358340517,
-0.011176344,
0.0430397168,
-0.012384424,
-0.011235849,
-0.020257676,
-0.0219550561,
0.047356829,
0.0218425579,
-0.0286970027,
0.0772344545,
0.019774843,
-0.0235752203,
-0.0337342136,
-0.0045895139,
0.0671306178,
-0.0524408445,
0.0081495466,
-0.020239722,
-0.0173416901,
0.0341542922,
0.0214290377,
-0.0077221957,
-0.0060219141,
-0.0348422565,
-0.1164532006,
-0.0358773172,
0.0006600467,
0.0169634763,
0.0038676616,
-0.0685299262,
0.0287532285,
0.0062689981,
-0.0338275991,
-0.0162841789,
-0.046797432,
-0.0166773163,
0.041013699,
-0.0208559558,
0.0528336391,
-0.0390956178,
-0.0119732535,
-0.0266176313,
0.0458016917,
0.043560233,
-0.0308259018,
-0.0098636495,
0.007829519,
-0.0083515551,
0.0241397712,
-0.0177592225,
-0.0251081008,
0.058333043,
-0.0195387043,
0.0241072383,
0.0786000416,
0.0323968083,
0.0463884473,
-0.0297995731,
-0.0051243934,
-0.0316379368,
-0.0158457551,
0.0020848811,
0.0869648308,
0.0361614525,
-0.0105912024,
0.0018970284,
0.0475064814,
-0.0255228933,
0.0425387286,
-0.0491654873,
0.0240097456,
-0.0118266456,
0.0092097009,
0.0149168344,
-0.0079272604,
0.0065450482,
0.0257144999,
-0.0482968204,
-0.0055637723,
0.0510151424,
-0.0398683473,
0.0202282015,
-0.0243946202,
-0.0384386219,
-0.0337745324,
0.0243434682,
0.0121826436,
0.023781063,
0.0239576828,
0.0361668579,
0.0282308366,
-0.0462945849,
0.0345307328,
-0.0244282782,
0.0379377082,
-0.0319799222,
0.0369704701,
-0.0315768756,
-0.0528809577,
0.0129793454,
-0.0532145202,
-0.0487928987,
-0.0608936921,
-0.0487668477,
-0.0257216785,
0.006600651,
-0.0011107725,
-0.0018910626,
0.0218624417,
0.0151358619,
-0.0019940571,
0.0182096865,
0.036719203,
0.0155445263,
-0.02814392,
0.0117284749,
-0.0375213213,
0.011468594,
0.1092762128,
-0.0407241806,
-0.0183906835,
-0.054851871,
-0.0474775918,
-0.0112386011,
0.0378174148,
-0.0071927602,
-0.0458174832,
0.0520962328,
-0.052250471,
0.0477763712,
0.0425316319,
0.0495027117,
-0.018066179,
-0.0220320839,
0.0096444022,
-0.0299262013,
-0.0174432434,
-0.0178817231,
-0.0802034363,
-0.0390205048,
-0.0439741127,
-0.012318138,
-0.0263879821,
0.0028291785,
0.0054166182,
-0.0510750413,
0.0479187891,
-0.0084149633,
0.0196998641,
-0.0054843226,
-0.0424833149,
0.0035959007,
-0.0424392,
-0.0549364313,
-0.0213112682,
0.010504391,
0.0066438932,
0.0140487403,
-0.0172046889,
0.0418336838,
-0.0188308246,
-0.0293350425,
-0.0110135041,
-0.0214842707,
0.0743313581,
-0.0046089632,
-0.0561578833,
-0.0089394879,
-0.0112881847,
-0.0258128066,
-0.0316294655,
0.0674976259,
0.0036921974,
-0.0416075587,
-0.0345122293,
0.0445572324,
-0.0259055831,
-0.0776244551,
-0.0024507071,
0.0028836031,
-0.0109629761,
0.0144627867,
-0.0236729067,
0.0257405657,
-0.010237867,
0.0039064498,
0.0078625279,
0.0072886096,
-0.0750501603,
-0.0670923144,
0.0097058956,
-0.1088606045,
-0.0091312379,
-0.0310230535,
0.0254176967,
0.0362546444,
-0.0812470019,
-0.030500913,
-0.0278633721,
0.0708886087,
-0.0117867263,
-0.0239677057,
-0.0206609145,
0.014207012,
-0.0535636432,
0.0205195379,
0.0163753573,
0.0353036709,
-0.0019772712,
0.0172864236,
0.0138534065,
-0.0193420686,
-0.0282731541,
0.0146766733,
-0.0033221818,
-0.0587359294,
-0.0375628695,
0.045152463,
0.0052856845,
0.0096051516,
0.0117160715,
-0.0228293762,
0.0166408457,
0.0283026956,
0.0591060258,
-0.0135368044,
0.06845586,
-0.0217185114,
-0.0076963073,
-0.0138010839,
0.0298890509,
0.0396702215,
0.0057457932,
-0.0406295955,
-0.0916198492,
0.0176429488,
-0.0122959372,
-0.0258141756,
0.0195186846,
0.0119122583,
-0.0614380203,
-0.0380898975,
0.0213474482,
-0.039369341,
-0.0126344291,
-0.0349532999,
0.0229510032,
-0.0388369635,
-0.0348322541,
-0.0096577248,
0.0314531699,
0.0056543089,
0.0662634894,
0.0056208265,
0.0682690516,
0.0470652953,
0.0062475251,
-0.0531749278,
0.0076236795,
-0.0062748645,
0.0183269475,
0.0022895336,
0.0278038327,
0.0116452808,
0.0751537755,
0.0341650806,
-0.0244338922,
0.0284836311,
0.0185413137,
-0.031330429,
-0.0032309559,
-0.0313007832,
-0.0232723895,
0.0356886014,
-0.037885569,
0.0554818995,
-0.0279833358,
-0.0228701849,
-0.0148385633,
0.0079148449,
-0.0257719122,
0.0089767715,
0.0365554169,
0.0373367183,
-0.0103061376,
-0.016649941,
0.0317430794,
-0.0490565598,
-0.0033065495,
0.042914886,
-0.0357192568,
-0.0597624555,
-0.0280728322,
-0.0042823814,
0.0181683414,
0.009902128,
0.0139442468,
-0.0018801764,
0.0001381251,
-0.0152217653,
0.0500420406,
0.0060529527,
0.0715293661,
0.01425118,
0.0351811536,
0.0030409887,
0.0336772464,
-0.0444521308,
-0.012828731,
0.0095541775,
0.00414031,
0.0311441384,
-6.139382916e-33,
0.0088118678,
-0.0358656235,
-0.0196534861,
0.0895145908,
0.0430262238,
0.0360310785,
-0.0227325615,
0.019812014,
-0.0204084907,
0.0817696899,
0.0439860485,
0.017680617,
0.0248499513,
0.0101411575,
-0.0283277184,
0.027428722,
0.0099539496,
0.0150652817,
-0.0189508609,
0.002860069,
0.0526661128,
-0.0525355861,
0.0336672403,
-0.0837403163,
0.0286800005,
0.0495246351,
-0.0317272358,
-0.0155606801,
0.0029149388,
0.0827450082,
-0.0021636523,
0.030392034,
0.0220943186,
-0.0195603985,
0.0101344585,
0.0654755235,
-0.0992391706,
-0.0100656664,
0.0243044235,
-0.0033348231,
-0.0487729833,
-0.0262870044,
-0.0237944592,
0.0075049605,
-0.0063554458,
-0.0606278032,
0.0468374826,
-0.0339338593,
0.0169135351,
-0.0096759452,
-0.0480699465,
0.0545188002,
-0.0283330251,
-0.0133134946,
0.0293519627,
-0.0312856957,
0.0477602221,
0.0726815313,
-0.0850294232,
0.0120242266,
-0.0216658283,
0.0080648493,
-0.0198493693,
-0.0137240812,
-0.0203434825,
0.0568746515,
0.001659402,
-0.0181613807,
-0.0212094244,
0.0188112147,
-0.0238033533,
0.0481629819,
0.1057140604,
0.0641370118,
0.0279906131,
0.032570675,
-0.0768238828,
-0.0119330147,
0.0275123436,
0.0197724607,
0.0135558182,
0.0067668771,
-0.012432199,
0.0091069089,
0.0206132792,
-0.0595377497,
-0.0278614312,
-0.0054178359,
-0.0326166525,
0.057339143,
-0.0158675313,
0.0743258446,
0.0167031977,
-0.0401337557,
-0.0089821499,
-0.002205418,
0.0043133581,
0.0373523571,
-0.0006353745,
-0.0128015,
-0.0641036853,
-0.0086549539,
0.0204902701,
0.0297774766,
0.031840384,
-0.0335077755,
0.0797448754,
-0.0342344344,
-0.0571163595,
-0.0024236913,
-0.0066501359,
0.0236207601,
0.0064023985,
0.0761980861,
-0.0030822211,
0.0257546362,
-0.0095280055,
0.047409296,
-0.020954445,
0.0129768159,
-0.0316534378,
-0.0641147122,
-0.0326208994,
0.0018519872,
-0.0084438082,
-0.0216340236,
0.0271428004,
0.0067922641,
0.0193136539,
-0.0749011412,
0.0087088924,
0.0142776752,
2.387e-7,
0.0644816235,
0.023792319,
0.0152093973,
-0.0450781547,
0.0237080995,
0.0423035398,
-0.0120311342,
0.0055102473,
-0.0045476719,
-0.0291010179,
-0.036899548,
0.0587801374,
0.0671449676,
0.0192885585,
-0.0517019965,
-0.0266702287,
-0.0414585508,
-0.0750297159,
-0.0416275002,
0.0158778485,
0.076255478,
0.0721113011,
0.0018162425,
-0.0279492605,
0.0021441823,
-0.0009337569,
0.0654816628,
0.0115030622,
0.0146862082,
-0.0232946575,
0.0534227453,
-0.0840168968,
-0.0106661869,
0.0213170741,
-0.0153077738,
-0.0014983356,
0.0195658486,
0.0247521847,
-0.0125579797,
-0.020427892,
-0.0104444642,
0.0054182643,
-0.0051992242,
-0.0604586527,
0.0595972277,
-0.0347322375,
-0.0205498505,
-0.0545282215,
-0.0580514707,
0.0238127448,
0.03870368,
0.0070829629,
-0.0110135907,
0.0145838354,
0.0240139067,
-0.0390777104,
0.0009908917,
-0.1138432845,
-0.0247175023,
0.019045826,
0.0061382107,
0.0190111939,
-0.001915197,
-0.0544883832,
0.0063525871,
-0.0601179227,
-0.0092275385,
1.835675855e-34,
0.0315633826,
-0.0085133407,
-0.0067177662,
0.0308341905,
0.018595539,
0.017484121,
-0.0153739471,
-0.0315972343,
0.0027611956,
-0.0349526294,
0.0223682187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05209v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05209v2 | Scaling Laws of RoPE-based Extrapolation | 2023-10-08T15:50:36 | 2024-03-13T08:14:47 | Xiaoran Liu, Hang Yan, Shuo Zhang, Chenxin An, Xipeng Qiu, Dahua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The extrapolation capability of Large Language Models (LLMs) based on Rotary
Position Embedding is currently a topic of considerable interest. The
mainstream approach to addressing extrapolation with LLMs involves modifying
RoPE by replacing 10000, the rotary base of $\theta_n={10000}^{-2n/d}$ in the
original RoPE, with a larger value and providing longer fine-tuning text. In
this work, we first observe that fine-tuning a RoPE-based LLM with either a
smaller or larger base in pre-training context length could significantly
enhance its extrapolation performance. After that, we propose
\textbf{\textit{Scaling Laws of RoPE-based Extrapolation}}, a unified framework
from the periodic perspective, to describe the relationship between the
extrapolation performance and base value as well as tuning context length. In
this process, we also explain the origin of the RoPE-based extrapolation issue
by \textbf{\textit{critical dimension for extrapolation}}. Besides these
observations and analyses, we achieve extrapolation up to 1 million context
length within only 16K training length on LLaMA2 7B and 13B. | [
0.0212396644,
0.0473451056,
-0.0102968533,
0.0228000861,
-0.0223748852,
-0.0014741488,
-0.0067769689,
0.023173904,
-0.0826905295,
0.0156976711,
-0.0237279981,
-0.0332947485,
0.0299316365,
-0.0109177548,
0.0322602168,
-0.0636157393,
0.0196448974,
-0.0605165698,
-0.0059964568,
-0.003219109,
0.0128125073,
-0.0256328993,
0.0143367071,
0.0321762301,
0.001520658,
0.0197647177,
-0.0297720395,
-0.0236374959,
0.0477111228,
-0.0102109155,
-0.0230135676,
0.0036469053,
0.0816325173,
0.0335423984,
0.0000020427,
-0.0055325595,
0.0289100111,
-0.0065693855,
-0.0067899572,
0.0767654479,
0.0583953001,
-0.0673453361,
-0.0058020609,
0.0235227607,
-0.014725253,
-0.0345190875,
0.0365798324,
-0.0057822429,
0.0168680549,
0.0615797676,
-0.0243472289,
-0.0414707474,
0.021193197,
-0.078861028,
0.0024983136,
-0.0528725795,
0.0373238884,
0.0551415347,
0.0384545736,
0.0526329987,
-0.0401506871,
0.0293254536,
0.0347294547,
0.0202124026,
-0.0285256114,
0.0532440841,
0.0146356793,
0.0106072323,
0.0066945981,
0.0609991401,
-0.0531094372,
-0.0257867519,
-0.0181705318,
-0.006595776,
0.0039100205,
-0.0148833683,
-0.0685952753,
0.0151290437,
0.0584732741,
0.0081281131,
0.0201307964,
0.0101397596,
0.0528653413,
0.0037904279,
-0.0711401626,
0.0676323995,
0.0008666073,
-0.0391235612,
-0.0389446504,
-0.0261886884,
-0.0553756505,
0.011201242,
0.0187686663,
0.047964111,
0.0370855667,
0.0331072547,
-0.0514672548,
0.0239627771,
0.0115692774,
-0.0259832442,
0.0640014559,
0.066586107,
0.0168259069,
0.0197155755,
-0.0373045988,
0.0549059473,
-0.051666975,
0.0313975848,
-0.060822811,
0.0481660292,
0.0125771882,
0.0010806789,
-0.027603982,
-0.031872455,
-0.0461846851,
-0.0555757694,
-0.0098959124,
0.0328426771,
0.0568842031,
-0.0382326506,
-0.0078810798,
-0.0018735928,
-0.0249220803,
-0.0179066863,
0.0099415556,
0.038828887,
-0.0349036008,
0.0519906729,
0.0107022589,
-0.037415415,
-0.026121974,
-0.0083038472,
0.0242639948,
-0.0107214218,
0.010615686,
0.0419445895,
0.0145857949,
-0.0238553844,
-0.0063700769,
0.0251491051,
-0.0397980213,
-0.0490602553,
-0.0019957318,
-0.0801836625,
0.0291463863,
-0.0122778248,
0.0083939992,
0.0254351813,
0.028354099,
0.0236625616,
-0.0419966392,
0.0573577099,
-0.0183619484,
0.0234918669,
0.0003857221,
0.0125783738,
0.0285513084,
0.0551912114,
0.0492977239,
0.033798907,
0.0302750021,
0.0133478465,
-0.0563362576,
0.0455319583,
0.0125067346,
-0.0147065492,
-0.0335143842,
-0.025203377,
0.0184933953,
0.0444993488,
0.0394641832,
0.0426155254,
-0.0642663166,
-0.0222531594,
0.0263381135,
0.0735397488,
0.0115101496,
0.0184846725,
0.0505502336,
-0.0146757578,
0.0114563173,
0.0325625986,
-0.0442169011,
0.0138007067,
0.0616719201,
0.0412303768,
0.0318111554,
0.0202062689,
-0.025232181,
-0.0324606821,
-0.0201601423,
-0.0137461806,
0.0046272753,
-0.0467356369,
0.0105089676,
-0.0132281575,
-0.0382362008,
0.01357798,
0.0425874144,
-0.0396523215,
-0.0132846413,
-0.0131254606,
-0.0375432223,
0.0731848255,
0.0110197021,
-0.0200426355,
-0.0382489413,
0.0113691473,
-0.0063088327,
0.0377699025,
0.0039253538,
0.0068643549,
0.0175657738,
-0.056281615,
-0.0141657759,
0.0355701856,
0.0124352667,
0.0257467292,
0.0477194078,
0.0280887764,
0.0310592148,
-0.0375788771,
-0.0039887298,
0.0334709287,
-0.0803393871,
-0.0000146811,
-0.0316274688,
0.0040003741,
0.017549647,
-0.0029460995,
-0.016270414,
0.0063634533,
0.0476919524,
-0.0808907822,
0.0154276369,
-0.0228602085,
-0.1122222841,
-0.0663893148,
0.0662005842,
-0.0185327902,
0.0541945696,
0.0133196879,
-0.0329964496,
-0.0497651063,
0.0251034368,
0.0026626918,
0.0552972145,
-0.0295517035,
0.0232028253,
-0.0206950344,
0.051585611,
-0.0214757174,
0.01480255,
-0.0254825149,
0.0606404059,
0.022073213,
0.0231049918,
0.001078274,
-0.030339336,
-0.0756652802,
0.0092616538,
0.0021859761,
0.0175412148,
-0.0192936808,
-0.0056861257,
0.009483058,
-0.0356162786,
-0.0577502735,
-0.0428776704,
-0.014208151,
0.028409021,
0.0248343926,
0.0147193996,
-0.0147108408,
0.0010887502,
-0.0030490598,
-0.0094758784,
-0.0387856029,
0.0276159104,
0.0220241342,
0.0404822864,
-0.0646962449,
-0.0396639705,
-0.0269537903,
0.0145983361,
0.0469978377,
-0.0182123706,
-0.0106826825,
-0.0647289753,
0.0333172828,
-0.031547185,
0.0141673405,
-0.048568733,
-0.0508182049,
-0.0028700912,
-0.0353135429,
0.0507901013,
0.0418977141,
-0.0326544195,
-0.0036171156,
0.0549078509,
0.0456790403,
-0.0428188518,
-0.0062630554,
-0.0409871824,
0.0091784224,
-0.0718119666,
-0.0031359477,
-0.0397315063,
0.0827413648,
-0.0272120181,
-0.0104470113,
-0.0400225706,
-0.0202231929,
-0.0034383764,
-0.0156358592,
0.0275406353,
0.0072740857,
-0.0436005704,
0.0278842226,
-0.0393205285,
-0.0805286095,
0.0279207285,
-0.0424880609,
-0.0049595209,
-0.0153710358,
-0.0359114371,
-0.0379038155,
0.072411187,
0.0418777876,
0.0106966626,
-0.0342270359,
0.0005066443,
-0.0314714201,
0.0303301364,
-0.0155396769,
-0.0154550411,
0.051356528,
-0.0135476105,
0.0161103792,
-0.0015456609,
-0.0330895372,
-0.0306747928,
-0.0204218999,
-0.0304801371,
-0.0031638118,
0.0132704359,
-0.0575462952,
0.0182516295,
0.0184033178,
0.002488438,
0.0634338409,
-0.0093555022,
0.0375833251,
-0.0403847881,
0.0227596462,
0.043976441,
0.0082126204,
0.0068199364,
-0.0354693122,
0.0353581123,
0.0059210523,
0.022425279,
0.0087169269,
-0.047886245,
0.000718265,
0.018330181,
0.0014039109,
-0.0393889137,
0.0176149309,
0.0014688963,
-0.0267841462,
-0.0081808027,
0.0864383653,
0.0035613365,
-0.0501861311,
0.0332663357,
-0.0132128745,
0.0833780915,
0.0247096606,
0.0321371183,
-0.0423817299,
0.0085006431,
0.0199615806,
-0.0217796415,
0.0282724313,
0.0045449748,
-0.0396985635,
-0.1247721538,
-0.0068590338,
0.0198782161,
-0.0027261011,
-0.0422869809,
-0.0405523516,
0.0043617608,
0.0231570248,
0.0254471693,
0.0463913493,
-0.0249235407,
-0.0168307666,
0.0271490701,
-0.0625820607,
-0.0567288734,
0.0078778425,
-0.012335483,
0.0242341086,
0.0151453288,
0.0311800409,
0.0025608218,
-0.0236390792,
0.0307107829,
-0.0156099042,
0.0268703178,
0.0096097607,
0.0135360202,
0.0272519775,
-0.0100838868,
0.0356645957,
0.0195066612,
-0.0190585144,
-0.0001900025,
-0.0271660499,
0.0930162668,
0.0057496401,
-0.0031248175,
0.0016732925,
0.0168178901,
-0.0416213386,
0.0271408185,
0.0450562984,
-0.0461761951,
-0.012418855,
-0.0167907383,
0.0021706626,
-0.0068112495,
-0.023509901,
-0.004462963,
0.0260713752,
-0.0113637419,
-0.0592428334,
0.0186068472,
-0.0124992775,
0.0921705365,
0.0093450602,
0.0108708749,
-0.0011888882,
-0.0005305668,
-0.0335987136,
-0.0406417958,
-0.0114701632,
0.0306948759,
0.001176053,
0.0594135709,
0.0245841704,
0.0049048872,
-0.0139057254,
-0.0238439832,
-0.1228100583,
-0.0849711373,
0.009986355,
0.0051261457,
0.0232392009,
0.0899170339,
0.0055530295,
-0.0236080196,
0.0710300803,
0.0279808864,
-0.0372755863,
0.0433393046,
0.0484246947,
0.0333883017,
0.0196659304,
0.0530048423,
-0.0069734161,
0.0046815891,
-0.0238466822,
0.0447116867,
-0.0389766693,
-0.0525340624,
-0.0042451741,
-0.0220838487,
0.021403946,
-0.002610299,
0.003896395,
-0.0146502266,
0.0333575681,
-0.0260036848,
0.0318495482,
-0.0551466383,
-0.0062686102,
0.0516236834,
0.0194716137,
-0.0007333342,
-0.0151384454,
0.0393883176,
-0.003032394,
0.0369594395,
0.0229376834,
-0.0025043562,
0.0220109504,
0.0319783501,
0.0330719911,
-0.0333990268,
-0.0203776583,
-0.0358887389,
0.0266146995,
-0.0370317325,
-0.0040811873,
0.0054200091,
-0.001157599,
-0.0448170155,
0.022394741,
-0.1017171517,
-0.0158370342,
-0.0182196833,
0.0037121964,
0.0318407938,
0.0027896897,
0.0382350497,
-0.0128994789,
-0.0115333376,
-0.000752813,
0.0147851696,
-0.0367470793,
-0.0208107457,
0.0292812921,
0.0262959134,
-0.0150444303,
0.0392370038,
0.0436267406,
0.0270985104,
0.0188888554,
0.0221432485,
0.0223463308,
0.0060985624,
-0.0341426395,
-0.0310783796,
0.0005282193,
-0.0080778394,
-0.0112491837,
-0.0218034424,
-0.0865546465,
0.0034358741,
0.0119445007,
-0.0415537916,
-0.0117599033,
0.002078268,
0.0277134757,
-0.0251412746,
0.023540739,
-0.0017789342,
-0.0274236966,
0.0223519821,
-0.0270304941,
0.0049292725,
-6.184038477e-33,
-0.0204272009,
0.0408817977,
0.0027320643,
-0.039234098,
-0.0636996254,
0.0159802716,
-0.0038058362,
0.0016467177,
-0.0188799091,
0.0066490192,
-0.0268636439,
-0.0145073589,
0.0168146435,
0.0213903114,
-0.0294959676,
0.0183839053,
0.026272554,
0.0051285173,
0.0289690383,
-0.0116843032,
0.0219843462,
0.0700429678,
0.0657839254,
-0.0342967063,
-0.0033798669,
0.008282546,
-0.0161523875,
0.030363163,
0.0164686665,
0.0402608141,
-0.043252442,
0.0277713109,
0.0127458367,
-0.0394914895,
-0.0465203412,
-0.0083607007,
-0.0958691165,
-0.0316025056,
0.0260844193,
0.0040667066,
-0.0026343937,
-0.0102526862,
0.0468655154,
-0.0272977259,
-0.0259038806,
-0.021684777,
0.0068524969,
-0.0508038774,
-0.0512544028,
0.0347216018,
-0.0151999947,
0.0114163654,
0.0429507233,
0.0142221991,
0.0105843619,
0.0332833827,
-0.011102926,
-0.019944163,
-0.0438720062,
0.0337223634,
0.0054150722,
0.0759222806,
0.0233757757,
0.0362824574,
0.0344840512,
0.0463200398,
0.0184586383,
-0.0389942527,
-0.0301326886,
-0.0096539455,
0.0404888168,
0.0221393332,
0.0142362015,
0.0007202065,
0.0711797178,
-0.028124908,
-0.049486462,
-0.0392276719,
0.026112847,
0.0356186964,
0.0386370085,
0.0148233315,
-0.0619504228,
-0.0479989201,
-0.0312894993,
-0.0320286825,
-0.0131088663,
-0.0628922135,
0.029915059,
0.0483832285,
0.0039283345,
0.0090358593,
0.0221011043,
-0.0652206838,
-0.0292241704,
0.0343761183,
-0.0289461408,
0.0277665649,
-0.0041588061,
0.0333251767,
-0.0604701601,
-0.0423135348,
-0.0079337368,
0.0042728069,
0.0133512653,
-0.0477575548,
0.0441141278,
0.0561602041,
-0.0763583109,
-0.0368678793,
-0.0342007875,
-0.0319774672,
0.0406587422,
0.0353133641,
0.069126077,
-0.0245295055,
-0.001605894,
0.0780071914,
0.006636458,
0.0184184127,
0.0206417069,
-0.03509764,
0.0041363048,
0.0549390465,
-0.0522642471,
-0.0132378526,
-0.0404280871,
0.018473262,
0.0133695258,
-0.0756124929,
-0.0433284156,
0.0102424435,
2.768e-7,
0.0291843098,
0.0089811143,
0.0530616492,
-0.0044393055,
0.0346455723,
-0.0246483292,
-0.0059067826,
0.0284813587,
-0.0134754628,
-0.0103550358,
0.0253862776,
0.0245832112,
0.0337503478,
-0.0145360408,
-0.0995588601,
-0.0118641248,
-0.080849655,
-0.0152734863,
-0.0127376458,
-0.0397374704,
0.0006979788,
0.1452440023,
0.0172198638,
0.0024997287,
-0.0012574493,
-0.059823174,
0.0379426107,
-0.0438679829,
0.0115029607,
0.0052309516,
-0.0038004511,
0.0301201865,
-0.0288104471,
-0.0328776427,
0.0016868236,
0.0644155741,
0.0077381232,
0.0744202435,
0.0215064399,
0.0224729292,
0.0186100714,
-0.0145865167,
-0.0352084786,
-0.0412224866,
0.0598919168,
-0.0355597362,
-0.0031587319,
-0.0174186826,
-0.0037159126,
0.0045094052,
-0.0083217174,
-0.0175176561,
0.0121874958,
0.00356212,
0.0260544904,
-0.013717439,
-0.0261489637,
-0.1025524363,
-0.0387469642,
0.0178697314,
-0.0740004107,
-0.0290818326,
-0.0733197853,
-0.001931919,
0.0636026561,
-0.0367017239,
0.0015893893,
2.707123542e-34,
0.0356839411,
-0.0242209695,
0.0192158055,
0.0156759247,
-0.0079006366,
-0.0252010748,
0.0647951439,
0.0107895266,
0.0466217287,
-0.1130246967,
-0.0482048467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05203v1 | A Comparative Study of Voice Conversion Models with Large-Scale Speech and Singing Data: The T13 Systems for the Singing Voice Conversion Challenge 2023 | 2023-10-08T15:30:44 | 2023-10-08T15:30:44 | Ryuichi Yamamoto, Reo Yoneyama, Lester Phillip Violeta, Wen-Chin Huang, Tomoki Toda | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.SP | This paper presents our systems (denoted as T13) for the singing voice
conversion challenge (SVCC) 2023. For both in-domain and cross-domain English
singing voice conversion (SVC) tasks (Task 1 and Task 2), we adopt a
recognition-synthesis approach with self-supervised learning-based
representation. To achieve data-efficient SVC with a limited amount of target
singer/speaker's data (150 to 160 utterances for SVCC 2023), we first train a
diffusion-based any-to-any voice conversion model using publicly available
large-scale 750 hours of speech and singing data. Then, we finetune the model
for each target singer/speaker of Task 1 and Task 2. Large-scale listening
tests conducted by SVCC 2023 show that our T13 system achieves competitive
naturalness and speaker similarity for the harder cross-domain SVC (Task 2),
which implies the generalization ability of our proposed method. Our objective
evaluation results show that using large datasets is particularly beneficial
for cross-domain SVC. | [
-0.0237463806,
0.0247320272,
-0.0025484997,
0.0062198811,
0.017082192,
-0.0386547074,
0.0512105413,
-0.0113505488,
-0.0343911722,
0.0165679436,
-0.0974769816,
-0.0160588045,
0.0109666605,
0.0025373439,
0.0256488882,
-0.0646056831,
0.0271973815,
-0.0335808694,
-0.0206554402,
-0.0293098297,
-0.0331801176,
0.0210386105,
-0.0257452168,
0.0003602863,
-0.0176214017,
-0.0281216707,
0.0119089577,
0.0061813206,
0.0262879319,
0.0016234015,
-0.0322442129,
-0.0308399182,
0.049478326,
0.0252530687,
0.0000017839,
-0.0274176542,
-0.0344722569,
0.0295654368,
-0.0477859713,
-0.0023829571,
0.027648,
0.0372148044,
-0.0183766484,
0.029772995,
-0.0349983573,
-0.0415037163,
0.0260973219,
0.0207789112,
0.079087913,
0.0876182318,
0.002809104,
-0.0832029879,
0.0253540948,
-0.0261971969,
0.0104242396,
-0.001416199,
-0.0269190352,
0.0255576372,
0.0100292098,
-0.0222510677,
-0.0274367239,
0.0798856914,
-0.031598404,
0.006271549,
0.0468214378,
0.0236724,
-0.0105638066,
-0.0583170131,
0.0288109016,
0.0319465436,
-0.0016152018,
0.0189669393,
0.0312659107,
0.0444014035,
0.0010526372,
-0.0046931282,
-0.0075948075,
-0.0215391275,
0.025145309,
0.0096079707,
-0.0554272197,
0.0466091596,
0.0295348447,
-0.061214935,
-0.0303392988,
-0.0141722178,
0.0065926872,
-0.0496680774,
0.0290240925,
-0.0107813487,
0.0075830263,
-0.0038379438,
0.0464801975,
-0.0187625438,
-0.0188991893,
-0.0270348787,
-0.0441277586,
-0.0168924108,
-0.0488080867,
-0.0160693005,
0.0574019291,
0.0316211954,
0.0022799061,
0.006982646,
-0.0344479196,
0.0112549588,
-0.0408176333,
-0.0048119975,
-0.0282037687,
-0.0224558692,
-0.0627440885,
0.0334225297,
-0.0537713282,
-0.0123804463,
-0.0044232979,
-0.0087400889,
-0.019438481,
-0.0029815238,
-0.0607853793,
0.0095607787,
0.0519559644,
-0.0149368234,
-0.0484381281,
-0.0318486467,
-0.0133976387,
0.048617024,
0.0215138011,
0.0540638827,
-0.0000319055,
-0.0041646594,
0.0126513187,
0.0052927472,
0.0391812474,
0.029275015,
0.0395546108,
0.0284998119,
-0.0132843079,
0.0094010662,
-0.0058665555,
-0.0027952159,
-0.0133387176,
-0.0639922023,
0.0034935751,
-0.0699804127,
0.0338905491,
-0.0543170348,
0.0008873209,
-0.0307987072,
-0.0264602359,
-0.0015975873,
0.0073398319,
0.0419489965,
0.0401040874,
0.0638523996,
0.0650731102,
-0.0144907432,
-0.0376721323,
0.0176335201,
0.0476008654,
-0.0015554769,
-0.0026998667,
-0.0610752217,
0.026815651,
0.0709698796,
0.0562633052,
0.0417166241,
-0.0169576183,
0.0095238965,
0.0254827794,
0.0750958472,
0.0766812637,
0.0287843756,
-0.000568337,
-0.0483587682,
0.0486388877,
0.0451390669,
0.0529940054,
0.0280394945,
0.0643337592,
0.0408992507,
0.0150351683,
-0.0208254121,
-0.0094803181,
0.0150714694,
0.0105122151,
-0.0212795194,
0.0485285185,
0.0393123217,
-0.0530358851,
0.020658372,
0.0391877927,
0.0021104566,
-0.0153296245,
-0.0050659948,
0.0156791583,
0.0617725551,
-0.0192287248,
0.0235647969,
-0.0606470406,
-0.0892429948,
0.0427214019,
-0.0304529238,
0.0058589196,
0.0016649539,
0.0063522388,
0.0259952564,
0.0478815846,
-0.0551950149,
-0.0071455087,
0.0116482675,
0.0048135347,
-0.0322402492,
0.0438288525,
-0.0139434207,
0.0002076476,
0.0320334695,
-0.0312607884,
-0.0296281893,
-0.046908997,
0.015335625,
0.0283222273,
-0.0469305031,
0.0555283017,
-0.0048785494,
-0.051153481,
-0.0148600498,
0.0716136619,
0.0321523063,
0.0426487066,
0.0404238068,
-0.0200514253,
0.0121493284,
-0.021317197,
-0.0338769518,
-0.0387221873,
0.0157303493,
-0.0333745293,
-0.0433045588,
0.0410988703,
-0.0639940724,
0.0324739143,
0.047935199,
0.008998761,
-0.0887520611,
0.056161467,
-0.0057046134,
-0.0114728743,
0.0136193298,
0.0089580743,
0.0315467902,
0.0107256034,
0.0291042197,
-0.0287057944,
0.0719361827,
-0.0277033299,
-0.0043558865,
0.038510792,
0.0098528033,
-0.0761244223,
-0.0080045434,
0.0055303681,
-0.0137592191,
0.0496343486,
-0.0414451435,
-0.0463417433,
-0.0120948162,
-0.0270333271,
-0.0564867668,
0.0714304149,
0.0048477328,
0.002466744,
0.0078364555,
0.0235790797,
-0.0016528036,
-0.0146122677,
-0.0422126874,
-0.0251097418,
-0.0149678253,
0.0090003442,
-0.0350457057,
-0.0100902021,
-0.0255909003,
0.0001847467,
-0.0027601114,
-0.0130079165,
-0.0086835455,
-0.062267825,
0.0129408361,
-0.0329530649,
0.0393194221,
0.0240471605,
0.0320964418,
0.0232689418,
0.0006133686,
-0.0171180908,
-0.0029714284,
0.0433451906,
-0.0114624538,
0.0049455566,
-0.0761255622,
0.0323180668,
-0.0194658227,
-0.0647134483,
0.0030749156,
0.0519816764,
0.0153382514,
-0.0376164466,
-0.0178015865,
0.0027850538,
0.0074471794,
0.0678428337,
-0.0162422415,
-0.051939521,
-0.0127237355,
-0.0110386945,
-0.0162528027,
0.0068073454,
0.0297933239,
-0.016844742,
0.000303152,
-0.0175292064,
-0.0133223059,
-0.00709836,
-0.0587979257,
-0.0514014736,
-0.0636622086,
-0.0672802255,
-0.0108556803,
-0.0128271086,
-0.065823853,
0.0259298775,
0.0079632364,
0.0139431069,
-0.0590963252,
0.0217687972,
0.031018706,
-0.0412848182,
0.0594050474,
-0.002937088,
0.029032737,
-0.0507916883,
-0.014638951,
-0.0130047658,
-0.0437282883,
0.0244587995,
-0.0146401962,
-0.0095941992,
-0.0473546796,
0.027207857,
0.0306995437,
-0.0162942223,
0.0440653041,
0.0039951727,
-0.01123429,
0.0140476367,
0.0454803333,
-0.0095941098,
0.039033968,
-0.0601093471,
0.0097161103,
0.0416338667,
-0.0038275076,
0.0554854944,
0.0293612313,
-0.0426863357,
-0.0434409529,
-0.0025726182,
0.0106758932,
-0.002002426,
0.0080723753,
0.0574699901,
-0.018309731,
0.0157871824,
0.0602517165,
-0.0328879952,
-0.0384952389,
-0.0197516326,
0.0057241451,
-0.0180538446,
0.0058092587,
0.0033118764,
-0.0323527306,
0.0034188037,
0.027743673,
0.0413715392,
0.028163312,
0.0086061191,
-0.0311355479,
-0.0729519427,
0.0324555375,
0.0415039733,
-0.0249940418,
-0.0415409952,
-0.0006080038,
-0.0173373483,
-0.0176287107,
-0.0175104253,
-0.0189371891,
-0.038209293,
0.0023719233,
0.0102117639,
-0.0121169174,
-0.0254821554,
0.0130775776,
-0.0624432452,
0.0894562304,
0.0434362292,
0.0442178063,
0.0197150204,
-0.0347611941,
-0.0089643784,
0.0150752496,
-0.0030846174,
0.0078175804,
0.0510899089,
0.0564113446,
0.0066701844,
0.0588195436,
0.0427738912,
-0.0411540829,
0.0335853286,
0.0130299125,
0.0811422616,
0.0142616257,
-0.0291205756,
-0.0125469407,
0.0363983028,
0.0400812179,
0.0855221301,
0.0287848767,
-0.0430286974,
0.0065501281,
0.0314875953,
0.0515168682,
-0.0224121884,
-0.0747780427,
0.0295891035,
0.0032083171,
-0.0664509088,
-0.0159250833,
0.0479237214,
-0.0085076597,
0.0835472867,
0.0085481983,
-0.00313471,
0.00888074,
-0.009349972,
-0.0164821688,
-0.0235095639,
-0.0665773004,
0.0589094236,
-0.0094613032,
-0.0240735039,
0.0535679497,
0.0300397836,
0.0151938125,
-0.0314281359,
-0.0612238534,
-0.0233142953,
-0.0046642707,
-0.0155719491,
0.0120259207,
0.069766596,
-0.0149421571,
0.0093616052,
0.0710394308,
-0.0299508143,
0.0152255222,
0.0328429788,
0.0880585685,
0.0049366099,
-0.0204404704,
0.0244145449,
-0.0131493853,
0.0291547365,
-0.002125524,
0.0207556244,
0.0147993062,
-0.0267871693,
-0.0066853268,
0.0145849986,
-0.0253709536,
0.0107503245,
0.0720664263,
-0.0407490171,
-0.014084084,
-0.0213898756,
0.0340945274,
-0.0581896417,
-0.0498115569,
0.1071162149,
0.0372052044,
0.0322319865,
0.0061798673,
-0.020958012,
-0.0141568789,
-0.0438430347,
0.0168223977,
0.0544126406,
0.044852756,
0.0299268626,
0.0121833906,
0.0146276802,
-0.0089813238,
0.0561152846,
-0.0212982148,
0.0129724145,
-0.0028598257,
0.0131765055,
0.0209529493,
-0.0241618454,
0.015161491,
-0.0332191698,
-0.03934763,
-0.02248496,
-0.0303385835,
0.0190250501,
0.0264018923,
0.0574795827,
0.0279141739,
0.0185030624,
0.0042600092,
0.0070810756,
-0.0724136457,
0.028706938,
-0.0082328292,
-0.0447550155,
0.0076673296,
-0.0066706268,
0.0472155809,
-0.0243167747,
0.0280730687,
-0.0314795077,
0.0124478871,
0.0097626215,
-0.0164664425,
-0.0561886951,
-0.0613195486,
0.00652715,
-0.0606946647,
0.0010609077,
-0.0657353476,
-0.0173110142,
-0.0237896312,
-0.0230443329,
-0.0156905707,
0.0230297912,
-0.0074458141,
-0.0095576672,
0.0189212058,
-0.000987325,
-0.0262870789,
0.0308921579,
-0.0360552222,
-0.0243626032,
-5.222020145e-33,
-0.0192733333,
0.068247728,
0.0234223139,
-0.027562229,
-0.0531460866,
-0.0619337484,
-0.0413080938,
0.0080088349,
0.0058961185,
-0.0105167702,
-0.0463676676,
0.0306088217,
0.0085056303,
0.0194339119,
-0.0007043325,
-0.003577407,
0.1471171379,
-0.038812954,
-0.0377259962,
0.0400795452,
0.0666495487,
0.0401504673,
-0.0010163625,
-0.122454837,
-0.0469622836,
0.0323064923,
-0.0272053089,
-0.0121364463,
0.0132453041,
-0.0168076865,
0.0005135951,
0.0440599471,
-0.0084367301,
-0.0396165513,
-0.0782633945,
0.0199901797,
-0.078918539,
-0.0107046012,
-0.0565059781,
0.019874379,
0.0177777354,
-0.0101061342,
0.0218924657,
0.0215760525,
-0.0277408231,
-0.0324251652,
0.0107098026,
-0.0481403656,
0.0180762559,
-0.0597154163,
-0.0134785594,
0.006234243,
-0.0114829112,
-0.0346757248,
0.0737408996,
0.0533609614,
-0.0265443288,
-0.0252151191,
-0.0496711992,
0.0100188078,
-0.053645771,
0.0124243749,
0.0575455278,
0.0333579816,
-0.0048359297,
-0.0199725889,
0.0539616868,
-0.0527970865,
0.0309551023,
-0.0246885587,
0.0282689594,
0.0683067217,
-0.002736462,
0.0208003055,
0.040144898,
-0.0657993034,
0.0197214819,
0.0370505564,
-0.008988101,
-0.0547227487,
-0.0375043787,
0.0583867878,
0.0012289637,
0.0000643233,
-0.0462481566,
-0.0553354993,
0.0208757166,
-0.0324875452,
0.0405299962,
-0.005781692,
-0.0200114138,
0.0102836639,
0.0352421999,
-0.0398543477,
0.0021829244,
-0.0180916861,
-0.0381488837,
-0.0089045307,
0.0060835043,
-0.0352516212,
-0.0211296286,
-0.0691054091,
0.0498335995,
0.0509936623,
0.0327103399,
-0.0089184474,
-0.0272239801,
0.06283243,
-0.0599631108,
-0.0233554151,
0.0093181115,
-0.0044762623,
-0.0109259179,
0.0294123348,
0.0065235859,
0.02747632,
0.015231831,
0.0206789039,
-0.0016692815,
0.0165782683,
0.0189402346,
0.0235163271,
0.0371323489,
0.0118035991,
-0.0035977287,
0.0184942111,
-0.0265259072,
-0.0215109307,
0.1025769562,
-0.0530737601,
-0.0134417368,
0.0230715852,
2.557e-7,
-0.0131417979,
-0.0611784086,
0.0115596494,
-0.0507053696,
0.0185158551,
0.0654349178,
-0.037364129,
0.0254069529,
-0.0146995103,
0.0176351871,
0.0265362989,
-0.0524848104,
0.0964972526,
0.0436492823,
-0.0688378662,
-0.0425526649,
-0.0268655289,
0.036722526,
-0.0230429769,
-0.0077351374,
0.0033381602,
0.0620917305,
0.0161586553,
-0.0549439304,
0.0242859051,
-0.0089382883,
0.0430164486,
-0.0223018285,
0.0079176463,
-0.0129392277,
-0.0124319801,
-0.0313079655,
-0.0067231832,
0.0198544711,
-0.0246114153,
0.0749336407,
0.0599423386,
0.0290260538,
0.0477911942,
-0.0166198947,
-0.0318637714,
0.0424318016,
-0.0253994986,
0.0456324443,
0.0480316989,
-0.0385125354,
-0.0270595104,
-0.0360500515,
-0.0212881099,
0.0383257531,
0.0022042373,
-0.0135963298,
0.0214051716,
-0.0024208415,
0.0195157751,
0.0322150849,
0.0079717441,
-0.0292425882,
0.0262286402,
-0.0030060362,
-0.0919580907,
-0.020446308,
-0.0080088228,
0.0295583233,
-0.0004242319,
0.0012049024,
-0.0074773682,
1.883679762e-34,
-0.0166495815,
-0.0260259006,
0.0250919126,
-0.028367769,
-0.027944291,
-0.0426130705,
0.0247271601,
-0.0081301909,
-0.0120750424,
-0.0480302013,
-0.0524378419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05199v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05199v5 | Loose lips sink ships: Mitigating Length Bias in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback | 2023-10-08T15:14:39 | 2023-11-29T14:45:53 | Wei Shen, Rui Zheng, Wenyu Zhan, Jun Zhao, Shihan Dou, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback serves as a crucial bridge,
aligning large language models with human and societal values. This alignment
requires a vast corpus of human feedback to learn a reward model, which is
subsequently used to finetune language models. However, we have identified that
the reward model often finds shortcuts to bypass its intended objectives,
misleadingly assuming that humans prefer longer responses. The emergence of
length bias often induces the model to favor longer outputs, yet it doesn't
equate to an increase in helpful information within these outputs. In this
paper, we propose an innovative solution, applying the Product-of-Experts (PoE)
technique to separate reward modeling from the influence of sequence length. In
our framework, the main expert concentrates on understanding human intents,
while the biased expert targets the identification and capture of length bias.
To further enhance the learning of bias, we introduce perturbations into the
bias-focused expert, disrupting the flow of semantic information. Experimental
results validate the effectiveness of our approach, indicating that language
model performance is improved, irrespective of sequence length. | [
0.0789130405,
0.0733091086,
-0.0418582,
0.0191671606,
-0.0515436679,
-0.0149870077,
-0.0108880885,
-0.0054576988,
-0.0286057573,
0.0018274746,
0.0019726164,
-0.012711538,
0.0291676484,
0.0349842869,
0.0269673429,
-0.0935603306,
0.0580083393,
-0.0193297789,
0.0717917457,
-0.022349054,
0.0279566646,
-0.0033975861,
-0.0018886551,
0.0635618344,
0.0040582367,
0.0429021679,
-0.0181223415,
-0.0180979073,
-0.0022591702,
-0.0269407164,
0.0240883213,
0.0693660751,
-0.000295108,
0.053699974,
0.0000019668,
-0.0331292972,
0.0144919408,
-0.0104567129,
-0.0102172457,
0.0052017104,
0.0488823764,
0.0161943622,
0.0186138898,
0.0016364461,
-0.0441755615,
0.0253222212,
0.0518925302,
0.0262688305,
0.0231401324,
0.0728697777,
0.0247201398,
0.0054322318,
0.0121994521,
-0.0635217577,
0.0507899933,
-0.0435779057,
0.0188286025,
-0.0151799349,
0.0484892391,
-0.0024821891,
-0.0455190986,
0.0234836247,
0.0270294305,
0.0178970769,
0.021717336,
0.0389735214,
0.0513735116,
-0.0385907106,
-0.0232395772,
0.062529169,
-0.0240514204,
-0.0154953953,
0.0067728846,
-0.0425802767,
0.0686785206,
0.0139648775,
-0.0213379506,
0.0029814537,
0.0145559246,
-0.0080539417,
-0.0203543026,
0.0119852312,
0.0088900905,
0.0016302229,
-0.0202526841,
0.0607717782,
-0.0206984021,
-0.0383193791,
-0.0214502607,
0.0036927387,
0.0014346907,
-0.0492897108,
-0.0077214874,
-0.0011804281,
-0.0363906026,
0.0301503185,
-0.0322714709,
0.0006399922,
0.0124062849,
-0.0325029232,
0.003261569,
0.0065601566,
0.0143001461,
0.0069801044,
-0.0011611348,
0.0154634379,
-0.0083181309,
0.0394589901,
-0.0527844355,
0.0473764054,
-0.0322209299,
-0.031994205,
0.0029465354,
0.0185942929,
-0.0187641568,
-0.0287518408,
-0.0396889113,
-0.0127437999,
-0.0238380563,
0.0197392162,
-0.0166593902,
0.0558876693,
-0.0262732301,
-0.0141112953,
-0.0663094446,
0.052172102,
-0.0567139611,
0.0381192826,
0.0317755975,
-0.0070315292,
-0.0122484583,
-0.0073433374,
-0.0200400483,
-0.0192008596,
0.0003287264,
0.0746939331,
-0.0071856338,
-0.0429122113,
0.0146659827,
-0.0494632907,
-0.0617823862,
-0.0536834337,
-0.0098270373,
-0.0689760819,
0.0249475893,
-0.0284552425,
-0.0313356444,
-0.0681647658,
0.0012188723,
-0.0065719299,
-0.0719256327,
0.0686732382,
-0.013806588,
0.0038170149,
0.0137447082,
0.0188549105,
-0.0012148232,
0.0442240573,
0.0628855377,
0.0428757109,
0.0372032225,
-0.003133741,
0.0142168188,
0.0229898896,
0.0360805169,
-0.0225600731,
-0.0245095789,
-0.004616844,
-0.0035208643,
0.0522052385,
0.0465597697,
0.0428606868,
-0.0345532708,
-0.0200495105,
0.0791379586,
0.0572016276,
-0.015584724,
-0.0098909251,
0.0323262773,
0.0566282868,
-0.0341654941,
0.0488651283,
-0.0367891155,
0.0190436803,
0.0083371848,
0.0117703471,
0.0533797778,
0.0004653351,
-0.0019547071,
-0.0521733798,
0.0228227954,
-0.0058268621,
0.0440783575,
0.0417997055,
0.0064743906,
0.0081410743,
-0.0393211879,
0.0341382772,
0.04175492,
-0.0222203657,
0.0285915583,
-0.0459284112,
0.0379292481,
0.0758792087,
0.0362371989,
-0.0136684533,
-0.0021860697,
-0.0245187916,
-0.0524711125,
0.0492877103,
0.0242785215,
-0.0174473692,
-0.0387292616,
-0.0160524603,
-0.0363388099,
0.0244769547,
0.0172176361,
0.0154013345,
0.0292594861,
-0.0263538919,
0.0212330427,
-0.0001639458,
-0.0275039673,
0.0300979204,
0.0203007255,
-0.0169449113,
-0.0201233309,
0.0179101303,
0.0453869402,
0.0045709899,
-0.0071701179,
0.0338469669,
0.0101721557,
0.0022690811,
-0.0153685361,
-0.0094297379,
-0.0797258392,
-0.0198064409,
0.0290354714,
-0.0476428904,
0.0000063234,
0.0327361114,
-0.0245852452,
-0.0208816454,
0.0186894108,
-0.0644744858,
0.0472416915,
0.02335269,
0.0009215207,
-0.0168374907,
0.0014754169,
-0.0662049279,
0.0244477615,
-0.0196115933,
0.0033639248,
-0.026838176,
-0.0130818319,
-0.0037601434,
-0.0487253927,
-0.0099888593,
0.0378514864,
0.00818187,
0.0217329413,
0.0944314003,
0.0213939995,
-0.0390297659,
-0.066849418,
-0.0650022402,
-0.039115157,
0.0168596916,
-0.0058874879,
-0.0112893712,
-0.008861877,
-0.0064608497,
-0.0132806851,
-0.0655085668,
-0.0489253514,
-0.0047184266,
0.0163358375,
0.0374983102,
0.0238011796,
-0.0674759597,
-0.0551436096,
-0.0245850459,
-0.02392672,
0.0247902051,
0.0129633257,
-0.010638685,
-0.0557564311,
-0.0311297178,
-0.0387325957,
0.0107250717,
-0.0158849992,
-0.0189429037,
0.011893183,
0.0141722551,
0.0480125844,
0.0932978243,
0.0512099527,
0.036236655,
0.0471974313,
0.0108833592,
-0.0702757314,
0.0000709227,
-0.0841947645,
-0.0272419546,
-0.0494010672,
-0.006459076,
0.0011049575,
0.056397479,
0.0093259513,
0.0146518303,
-0.092359595,
0.0391026698,
-0.0072947699,
-0.0747772232,
0.0122606829,
-0.0501227789,
-0.0628500283,
0.0431257151,
-0.0362384357,
-0.0565724596,
0.0977777019,
-0.0003264346,
0.0087496489,
-0.0308930445,
0.0258353967,
-0.0230392776,
0.0546678342,
0.0050284779,
0.0168030858,
0.0237608347,
-0.0113195255,
-0.0711736158,
-0.0109959962,
0.0242863074,
-0.0295121521,
0.00177824,
-0.0524509363,
-0.0049848096,
0.0169851538,
-0.0520043857,
-0.0223390106,
-0.0514331385,
-0.0284214672,
-0.0048942436,
0.0472372547,
-0.0142047601,
-0.0085756704,
-0.0166443307,
0.0643840879,
0.0127014145,
-0.0138880629,
0.0089038676,
-0.019845644,
0.0048051658,
0.0721190348,
-0.0247584824,
0.0236308798,
-0.0437902696,
-0.0425284132,
0.0308537371,
0.0148910359,
0.0220100991,
-0.0000142917,
0.0031171511,
0.0230647046,
-0.0435028635,
-0.0167711582,
0.0869329721,
0.0266906191,
-0.0529673994,
-0.0003743707,
0.0883463845,
0.0290999804,
-0.0688044354,
0.0505814925,
0.0147953471,
0.0642745271,
-0.0062034181,
0.0137727289,
-0.0754958913,
-0.0307930727,
-0.0001019275,
0.0247207005,
-0.0141934687,
-0.0137728341,
-0.0074785934,
-0.1404368281,
-0.0291377213,
0.0174609367,
-0.0066974531,
-0.0223207474,
-0.0260207299,
-0.015221796,
0.002881828,
-0.0063116038,
0.025384387,
0.0013375391,
0.0077771461,
0.0409860834,
0.0007241812,
-0.034501113,
0.0132908979,
-0.0181519073,
0.0949036703,
0.0955994576,
0.0046474002,
0.0022698874,
-0.0261769891,
-0.0017084886,
0.0236278735,
0.0085740313,
0.0093671475,
0.0415300094,
-0.0382026471,
0.0144640822,
-0.0003204637,
0.0538083166,
0.0249028374,
0.0298371855,
0.0135825537,
0.0587148368,
0.0357115082,
-0.03469906,
-0.0319896862,
0.0131786708,
0.0038365552,
0.0686061233,
0.0332574621,
-0.0699882656,
-0.0309235211,
-0.0162485428,
-0.0672800541,
-0.0233136918,
-0.0763152316,
-0.0190701019,
0.0314779095,
-0.0335489176,
-0.0669812858,
-0.0721540153,
-0.0202099811,
0.0378623791,
0.0169806648,
-0.0148802605,
-0.0057386956,
0.0179210268,
0.0042776684,
0.0183453709,
-0.0188872684,
0.0179053098,
-0.0794195309,
0.0076797805,
-0.0377488881,
-0.0426972769,
-0.0172391701,
0.013877213,
-0.0608003475,
-0.0992418304,
0.0058074896,
0.0884733945,
0.0270480923,
0.0730230436,
0.0199652314,
-0.0615532398,
0.0587881207,
0.0463377349,
-0.0733655319,
0.0135879247,
0.0413831808,
0.0347026959,
-0.0026610168,
0.029551547,
-0.0172928907,
0.0089935176,
0.0337907411,
0.056738507,
-0.003805524,
-0.0515854172,
0.0382407568,
-0.0026833927,
0.038196221,
-0.0499495529,
0.0077753384,
-0.0128948754,
0.008579799,
-0.0148072634,
-0.0211433712,
-0.0211017858,
-0.0032968244,
0.0006308216,
0.0075500817,
0.0120244622,
-0.056808982,
-0.0026337479,
0.005020367,
-0.0156169944,
0.0232615862,
-0.0021160827,
0.0101247067,
0.0309537221,
0.0132707013,
-0.0038754386,
0.0232313164,
-0.0247296952,
0.0328058973,
0.0209241994,
0.0457170568,
0.0603210144,
-0.0166884642,
-0.0220369138,
0.0174753387,
-0.0491286889,
-0.0250708815,
-0.0042966441,
0.0106809884,
0.02801992,
0.0053247116,
0.0130274901,
-0.0188724753,
0.0064477175,
-0.000474502,
0.0155375479,
-0.0423330851,
-0.0296091959,
0.0029614849,
0.0320571214,
-0.0301427227,
-0.0220030379,
0.0740560889,
0.0165875293,
0.030145146,
-0.0324114971,
0.0017821002,
-0.0348008312,
-0.0569950975,
0.0143970912,
0.0108481292,
-0.0348416008,
0.0162480716,
-0.0821368471,
-0.0508709997,
-0.039872475,
0.0463552475,
0.058212243,
-0.0104080122,
0.060264647,
0.049233187,
-0.0508068837,
-0.0195983574,
-0.0276269093,
-0.0244405661,
0.0194510221,
-0.0188023876,
-0.0495354347,
-6.038664356e-33,
-0.0086015426,
-0.0279384498,
0.0244687013,
0.0082467292,
-0.0327250548,
-0.0262813885,
-0.0095305033,
0.0525091477,
0.0229260251,
0.0066863489,
-0.0212441217,
-0.032780882,
0.0028662824,
-0.0078720618,
0.0619795248,
0.000858828,
0.0492863171,
-0.0018668724,
-0.0530572459,
0.0140740499,
-0.0029089304,
0.005096355,
0.0275713913,
-0.0416713133,
0.079720594,
0.0379515998,
-0.0203817766,
0.0217455924,
-0.007074371,
0.0459787138,
0.0134388106,
0.0267230142,
-0.0033721945,
-0.0599725395,
-0.0335419215,
0.0144126387,
-0.0497960038,
-0.0117378905,
0.0590760931,
-0.0139676547,
-0.0315712169,
-0.0281508323,
0.0307560023,
-0.017987553,
-0.0448646285,
0.00663285,
0.0516579002,
-0.0068294276,
-0.0263266973,
0.001232293,
-0.060857892,
0.0094474535,
-0.029153714,
-0.0059978659,
0.0324893296,
0.0462205522,
-0.0189083293,
-0.0035091848,
0.0160956476,
0.0424495451,
0.0357102565,
0.0513853356,
0.03517887,
0.0173725318,
0.0306428242,
0.0447795019,
0.0344835296,
0.0263825953,
-0.0191530641,
-0.0297825895,
0.0426099636,
-0.0021806385,
0.0654529035,
0.0268924609,
0.0325457901,
-0.0245196,
-0.0036246418,
-0.0220170971,
0.0039515095,
0.0347593203,
0.0349574536,
0.028472038,
-0.0766932219,
-0.0321900211,
-0.0572213344,
-0.016794771,
-0.0000912303,
-0.0520508587,
0.018741807,
0.0515591949,
-0.0141581334,
-0.003209956,
0.0255931281,
-0.0179103874,
-0.0150637934,
-0.0146312639,
-0.0183507539,
0.0070624454,
0.0036508688,
-0.0259504411,
-0.0962329432,
-0.0019800437,
0.0042908224,
0.0000857163,
0.0188459903,
0.0025807512,
0.0267221984,
0.0066256584,
-0.0400849581,
-0.0028179442,
-0.0256854929,
0.0094109327,
0.0195709411,
-0.0460080802,
0.0713485628,
0.0281380434,
-0.0255813971,
0.0200352054,
-0.0096330391,
-0.0364887938,
-0.0284294151,
0.0042061447,
-0.0293094441,
0.0198213104,
-0.0672161877,
-0.0140764639,
-0.0174687076,
0.0087915771,
0.0091251526,
-0.0339405462,
-0.0268416628,
-0.0097542172,
2.742e-7,
-0.0254912451,
0.0565248355,
0.0554624386,
0.0171384513,
-0.0046355333,
0.0554848611,
0.0329546295,
0.0330703706,
-0.0123050669,
-0.0274392515,
0.0329183675,
0.0302504469,
0.0222477689,
-0.0316937752,
-0.0788500234,
-0.01823432,
-0.0884825438,
0.053764917,
-0.0354672484,
-0.0317811109,
0.0307827909,
0.0535766073,
0.061393559,
0.0167158674,
-0.0246771667,
0.0104672527,
0.0294493455,
-0.052595064,
0.0154784126,
0.0180449411,
0.0273348559,
-0.0401269831,
-0.0050199591,
0.0196702909,
0.0242124293,
0.0166679174,
-0.0264031664,
0.0452622175,
-0.0113741746,
-0.0188886523,
-0.0283127259,
0.0080277789,
-0.0156553965,
-0.0487394482,
0.0154683487,
-0.0548372939,
-0.0320899934,
-0.0252137408,
-0.0094548184,
-0.0329102352,
0.0053875279,
-0.0077185752,
-0.01733936,
0.0058054393,
0.0248682667,
0.0303641558,
0.05129591,
-0.0859810486,
-0.0329805389,
0.0316909328,
-0.0306752194,
-0.0292309616,
-0.0458304361,
0.0552780442,
-0.0228341259,
-0.0637110248,
-0.0070136362,
2.522875593e-34,
0.0230463315,
-0.0341706537,
0.0334693342,
-0.0208435189,
0.0406278595,
0.0101672076,
0.0050953072,
0.0125901839,
0.0931754708,
-0.0350901075,
-0.0509190559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05191v1 | FABRIC: Automated Scoring and Feedback Generation for Essays | 2023-10-08T15:00:04 | 2023-10-08T15:00:04 | Jieun Han, Haneul Yoo, Junho Myung, Minsun Kim, Hyunseung Lim, Yoonsu Kim, Tak Yeon Lee, Hwajung Hong, Juho Kim, So-Yeon Ahn, Alice Oh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated essay scoring (AES) provides a useful tool for students and
instructors in writing classes by generating essay scores in real-time.
However, previous AES models do not provide more specific rubric-based scores
nor feedback on how to improve the essays, which can be even more important
than the overall scores for learning. We present FABRIC, a pipeline to help
students and instructors in English writing classes by automatically generating
1) the overall scores, 2) specific rubric-based scores, and 3) detailed
feedback on how to improve the essays. Under the guidance of English education
experts, we chose the rubrics for the specific scores as content, organization,
and language. The first component of the FABRIC pipeline is DREsS, a real-world
Dataset for Rubric-based Essay Scoring (DREsS). The second component is CASE, a
Corruption-based Augmentation Strategy for Essays, with which we can improve
the accuracy of the baseline model by 45.44%. The third component is EssayCoT,
the Essay Chain-of-Thought prompting strategy which uses scores predicted from
the AES model to generate better feedback. We evaluate the effectiveness of the
new dataset DREsS and the augmentation strategy CASE quantitatively and show
significant improvements over the models trained with existing datasets. We
evaluate the feedback generated by EssayCoT with English education experts to
show significant improvements in the helpfulness of the feedback across all
rubrics. Lastly, we evaluate the FABRIC pipeline with students in a college
English writing class who rated the generated scores and feedback with an
average of 6 on the Likert scale from 1 to 7. | [
0.0466978699,
0.0248472076,
-0.0082586445,
-0.0206847358,
-0.0407022797,
0.0003227208,
-0.0102459835,
-0.0217362214,
0.0096324813,
-0.0661774054,
0.004305738,
0.0078128623,
-0.0070068529,
0.0693669021,
0.0153367724,
-0.018648278,
-0.0026130911,
0.0085034631,
0.0093987333,
0.0274851564,
0.0296962392,
0.0227528531,
-0.0189782381,
0.0308866519,
-0.0082514258,
-0.0318802781,
-0.032495562,
0.0052792151,
0.0140953362,
0.0091038039,
0.0691487044,
0.0939218923,
-0.0234071165,
0.0003184769,
0.0000021959,
-0.0370798223,
0.0102699902,
-0.0460729524,
0.0129931262,
0.0073441854,
0.0824529827,
0.0487256534,
0.0040824618,
0.0270041469,
-0.0314010903,
0.0083408244,
0.0250355601,
0.06795156,
0.0817359611,
0.0422430858,
-0.0074853338,
-0.0123146633,
0.0537808649,
0.026615018,
0.0156288054,
0.0328802653,
0.0059946845,
0.0209103823,
0.0250235926,
0.0191086829,
-0.0258518122,
0.001856901,
0.0227783062,
-0.0724342316,
0.0692268386,
0.0165026169,
-0.0385029055,
0.0087532625,
0.0144033898,
0.066934973,
0.0191620234,
-0.0135868685,
-0.0313427709,
-0.0254138242,
0.0435186066,
-0.0261551049,
-0.0451046117,
-0.0136414878,
-0.0200402699,
-0.0033668405,
0.0340195075,
-0.0154357087,
-0.0175355542,
0.0489715189,
0.0499649011,
-0.0165544916,
-0.0076259417,
-0.0422947183,
-0.0173178595,
0.0332054608,
0.0153085142,
-0.0639541522,
0.0423340984,
0.0364420637,
-0.0421550833,
-0.0117230238,
-0.0409080535,
-0.022926962,
0.0266604386,
-0.0122817196,
0.0698527619,
0.0077755698,
0.0034005977,
-0.0049963882,
-0.0029123381,
0.0526262261,
0.0442989394,
0.0056836605,
-0.0426159613,
0.0360438079,
-0.0538793989,
-0.018657675,
-0.0050300197,
0.0603637397,
0.0202160645,
-0.0011363014,
-0.0566722006,
-0.0321595706,
-0.0590996034,
0.0440132879,
0.0024685697,
0.032009393,
-0.0230451711,
0.0332852788,
-0.0114205629,
0.0394656137,
-0.0140585592,
0.0122555923,
0.0310541559,
0.023874484,
0.0252006371,
-0.0032808704,
0.0265422855,
0.0155418543,
0.0178524535,
-0.0202507712,
-0.0343444534,
0.0059191282,
-0.0049006967,
-0.0437126085,
0.0231767278,
-0.0314642116,
-0.0307231918,
-0.0503075086,
-0.0139011871,
-0.0032744312,
0.0061226371,
-0.0233691018,
-0.0023057857,
0.0327630267,
0.0064248499,
0.0234730598,
-0.0016560234,
-0.0237427875,
0.0328413621,
0.0171528943,
0.0346871875,
0.0233051199,
0.0351274535,
0.0534650758,
0.037559513,
-0.0290342495,
0.0835757554,
0.0134862056,
-0.0274402518,
-0.0242321976,
0.0441661999,
-0.0165806264,
-0.0176242124,
0.0634180829,
-0.0372938514,
0.0024881004,
0.0138752358,
0.0584105887,
0.0655015931,
0.020568246,
0.0455812104,
0.0317319185,
-0.0003562994,
0.0107399821,
0.0185105298,
0.0454332791,
-0.0288397335,
0.0214648955,
-0.0079884622,
0.0085729267,
0.0116796475,
-0.0242258217,
0.0002403767,
-0.1059050485,
-0.0386264101,
0.0150786713,
-0.052424565,
0.0084974244,
0.0177353099,
0.0165649056,
-0.0314523391,
-0.0036969134,
0.0081423707,
-0.0938020274,
0.0580005795,
-0.0384378098,
0.034442395,
0.1412322372,
0.0701505914,
-0.0341703407,
-0.0061636725,
-0.0434881262,
0.063322939,
0.0153519176,
0.0403047726,
-0.065501146,
-0.0314204581,
-0.0357014313,
-0.0295846742,
-0.0253105108,
0.0025079271,
-0.0121288402,
-0.015224657,
-0.0038677498,
-0.0083598644,
0.031830892,
-0.1308577955,
0.0601109713,
-0.0177269559,
-0.0258758161,
0.0181983579,
-0.0029321178,
-0.0078016426,
0.0530546941,
-0.006387034,
0.0057703285,
0.0035920835,
-0.0168822892,
-0.0540935248,
-0.0381543972,
-0.038789019,
0.0156493559,
0.0294620711,
-0.0431702621,
-0.0110781845,
0.0318286829,
-0.0389852449,
-0.0398247838,
0.0161000416,
-0.01918686,
-0.018995719,
-0.0097561572,
0.0047966032,
-0.0409484617,
-0.0347939096,
-0.0336059742,
-0.0220394358,
0.022634346,
0.0589685366,
-0.0580767766,
0.0201723706,
-0.0038432574,
0.0172245186,
-0.021880012,
-0.0273123085,
0.0065891501,
0.0234243385,
0.0244259201,
0.0237262603,
-0.0813847482,
-0.058467377,
-0.0648913085,
0.0028563954,
0.0103794988,
-0.0036162206,
0.0206415169,
-0.0278977249,
-0.0065131094,
0.0091438983,
-0.0512466058,
-0.0215527937,
0.0119838854,
-0.032939896,
0.0344009921,
-0.0171545539,
0.0290293507,
-0.046656739,
-0.0085264742,
-0.0448678918,
0.0069547324,
0.0899279416,
-0.0226900373,
-0.049873963,
0.0446413159,
0.020092804,
-0.0175373219,
0.0236890391,
-0.0885614306,
0.01850136,
-0.0247201771,
0.0635939986,
0.0869458243,
0.015987413,
0.0281288251,
0.0547004342,
-0.0077249641,
-0.0358610339,
-0.0087969331,
-0.0286504105,
0.0119919134,
-0.0024453325,
-0.0564285256,
-0.0012610651,
0.0243443716,
0.0314213187,
-0.045771122,
-0.0417758897,
0.0507838316,
-0.031684231,
0.0084127262,
-0.0079364292,
-0.0310728662,
-0.0063519645,
0.0210894123,
-0.0216235351,
-0.0120869679,
0.0747580528,
-0.0001726614,
0.0125705311,
-0.0265459623,
0.0465629064,
-0.0021987448,
0.0352575332,
0.0089804567,
-0.0218407456,
-0.0371505953,
0.0117105106,
-0.0139633063,
0.021822786,
0.0376543775,
-0.0525551103,
0.0135116652,
-0.038940005,
-0.0387301892,
-0.0111663127,
-0.0168138575,
-0.0264685359,
0.0214202646,
-0.0087382514,
-0.0025690915,
-0.0515444539,
-0.0117739104,
-0.004577409,
-0.0452608466,
-0.0102477986,
0.0529417582,
-0.0845816061,
-0.0271880999,
0.0167736243,
0.0099415751,
0.0299927369,
-0.0470216088,
-0.0363279767,
-0.0113852201,
0.0813313276,
0.042315688,
-0.0027759662,
0.0146706682,
-0.0059925383,
0.0058329543,
0.02546064,
-0.0696014166,
0.0223138779,
-0.0229788106,
0.0254778136,
-0.0732907429,
-0.0458579622,
0.1176798046,
0.0355057828,
-0.0436934941,
-0.0235368647,
-0.0279766377,
0.0002920278,
0.0269080214,
0.0334005281,
-0.042016156,
-0.0174916517,
-0.0051467633,
0.0452182293,
-0.0339125432,
-0.0324311331,
0.0134738404,
-0.0871633068,
0.0594434254,
0.0000517369,
0.0056472477,
-0.0156925675,
-0.0190760251,
-0.0156283025,
-0.0187853742,
-0.0373531394,
-0.0234759096,
0.0067869546,
0.0307143796,
0.0271027889,
-0.0111105768,
-0.0161864497,
0.0063148006,
-0.0311339125,
0.0238432139,
0.0260819457,
0.0503657199,
-0.0173467509,
-0.0470414646,
0.0335807204,
0.0082489233,
-0.0188314654,
0.0018528587,
0.0609314293,
-0.0277422871,
0.0303084459,
-0.0500555485,
0.0554793403,
-0.0099892905,
-0.026907457,
0.0641365796,
0.0501233004,
-0.0122689465,
-0.0034733005,
-0.0522848219,
0.0136173191,
0.0059927278,
0.0488238968,
0.0368763022,
-0.0917316526,
0.0007808304,
-0.06012192,
0.0284945928,
-0.1024685651,
-0.044747714,
0.0304779541,
-0.0376707129,
0.0203318186,
-0.0454146788,
-0.0876718834,
0.0383781306,
0.0247340854,
0.0391797945,
0.0285564307,
-0.0392778665,
0.0030120753,
-0.0812446699,
-0.0088020107,
0.0227653682,
0.0037606228,
-0.006388769,
-0.0403354093,
-0.0088006519,
-0.0270699691,
-0.0211824458,
0.0045963381,
-0.0364921726,
-0.0326701477,
0.0556201153,
0.0494497828,
0.0113098538,
0.0185938105,
0.009875196,
-0.053490255,
0.0169774778,
-0.0166795924,
-0.0090390518,
-0.0057351994,
0.000572736,
-0.0270350911,
-0.0089697223,
0.0130620506,
0.0017547006,
0.0147099262,
0.0510904416,
0.0298105925,
0.0265370924,
0.0012179042,
0.0137192179,
0.0351066142,
0.02966935,
-0.0401102528,
-0.0357652046,
-0.0521921106,
0.0246205572,
-0.0206340421,
-0.0588354506,
-0.0155117409,
0.0139296167,
0.0233002137,
-0.0056367791,
-0.013897636,
0.0090688933,
-0.0641724616,
0.0547259487,
-0.0381435044,
0.0316767283,
0.0283929855,
0.0662473142,
0.0189832784,
-0.0191179775,
-0.0521075577,
-0.0164193846,
0.0161988251,
0.0414395072,
-0.0173121318,
0.077282846,
0.0112317419,
0.0094389962,
0.052190464,
0.0452723242,
-0.0499704629,
0.0402519591,
-0.0664931089,
0.0241138637,
-0.0146668265,
0.0069944733,
0.0341245346,
0.0019521802,
0.0069011524,
-0.0046642199,
0.05498695,
-0.0088801123,
-0.0475699939,
-0.0074592293,
0.0062679104,
0.0283683296,
-0.0163878258,
0.0049676704,
-0.0313881934,
0.0117001124,
-0.0024003158,
-0.0328302793,
-0.0354685113,
0.0154500045,
0.0437754504,
0.0189691074,
0.0158837959,
-0.0029553145,
-0.0281726606,
-0.0113606434,
0.0145493234,
0.0604022592,
0.0119692963,
-0.0201427583,
0.0104161547,
0.0505175628,
-0.0285198316,
0.0137785506,
-0.0770491213,
0.0335118659,
-0.0429456457,
-0.0423281565,
-0.004153776,
-5.846773352e-33,
-0.0138445264,
-0.0392466374,
-0.0039526038,
0.0925486088,
-0.0247517284,
0.0289115049,
-0.0349382646,
0.0137552964,
0.0437711887,
0.0402186736,
-0.0147081139,
0.0095001226,
-0.0156614874,
0.0549791157,
0.0689387694,
0.0144324051,
0.044560872,
0.0024299091,
-0.0318692178,
0.0306006577,
0.0019730562,
0.0049818517,
0.0770712569,
-0.0154810362,
0.0884025767,
-0.0563151836,
-0.034752924,
-0.0272264779,
-0.0324536934,
0.0355375335,
-0.0132350381,
0.0578084923,
0.0255480241,
-0.0254257079,
0.0189546365,
0.0235804748,
-0.0572632924,
-0.0516003482,
-0.00567313,
0.0107098529,
-0.0218659807,
-0.0598299466,
0.0188637152,
-0.012772751,
-0.0491950735,
-0.0422751084,
0.0696606338,
-0.0179383624,
0.0288603418,
-0.0472144075,
-0.0743958801,
-0.0124767562,
-0.0185644105,
-0.0274883565,
-0.0381841101,
0.045082882,
0.0147477444,
-0.0007192364,
-0.0396536291,
0.0348027758,
0.0323549733,
0.0546873957,
0.0433409624,
-0.0001170118,
-0.0519848578,
0.0591260344,
-0.0026151091,
0.0186250973,
-0.0201897249,
0.0357333981,
0.0374030024,
-0.0285446364,
0.1236994192,
0.0837160423,
0.0060111126,
-0.0038869369,
-0.0236915685,
0.0743496493,
0.0103094811,
0.0144232046,
0.0209563766,
-0.0609699525,
-0.0155550465,
-0.0138124712,
-0.0515868105,
-0.0768444911,
-0.0264974907,
-0.0095054321,
0.0392993651,
-0.0212774053,
-0.0171942543,
-0.0122364964,
-0.0305094663,
-0.0062555056,
-0.0398935713,
-0.0298982933,
-0.0320233479,
0.04509921,
-0.0396288857,
-0.03229535,
-0.0079040136,
0.0324160941,
0.0063150912,
0.0356307961,
0.0357188694,
-0.0082343211,
0.0655819923,
0.0177687947,
-0.028299924,
-0.0207114834,
-0.0236195531,
0.0205831192,
0.0010833294,
0.0121591734,
-0.002014111,
0.019885987,
-0.0195329115,
0.06028172,
0.0112363761,
0.0204800889,
-0.0428733043,
-0.0337982476,
0.0320455283,
0.0122494074,
-0.0402001143,
-0.0270725824,
-0.0316719152,
-0.0198552851,
-0.004011441,
-0.0533716865,
0.0098088132,
0.0028215421,
2.696e-7,
0.0288104359,
0.0452066734,
0.0112531083,
-0.0608171113,
-0.0205076579,
0.0359547473,
-0.012107824,
0.0028238341,
0.0515825376,
0.0186941735,
0.0124647329,
0.0008441799,
0.0342613161,
0.0205652937,
-0.1068489626,
-0.0749173686,
0.0013835126,
-0.0217701606,
-0.0307325758,
0.0083852494,
0.0892341807,
0.0123618729,
0.0458987318,
-0.0395381637,
-0.0163253956,
-0.0025839547,
0.0006922677,
0.002256406,
-0.0105280131,
0.0265186876,
0.0050993925,
-0.0338818133,
0.0221906565,
0.0245418381,
-0.0383309573,
-0.0238444898,
0.0106409611,
0.0259063616,
-0.0049144677,
0.0100492565,
0.0019884773,
0.0234261863,
0.0284995157,
-0.0671887621,
0.0366527513,
-0.0103423027,
0.005547266,
-0.0450039096,
-0.024183644,
-0.0125673087,
0.0087278951,
-0.0315974541,
-0.0114045823,
0.0224420484,
0.0118000349,
-0.0069909645,
0.0173745062,
-0.0426336378,
-0.0294543188,
-0.0115556689,
0.0264436491,
-0.0055623371,
-0.0155097051,
0.0048693032,
-0.0129995355,
-0.0917128399,
-0.0214531701,
2.420408531e-34,
0.0284822136,
-0.0366611555,
0.0629269183,
-0.0012478861,
0.0014957038,
0.0256398004,
0.0193407685,
0.0020580131,
0.0136202844,
-0.0103704035,
-0.0379566588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05189v2 | Factuality Challenges in the Era of Large Language Models | 2023-10-08T14:55:02 | 2023-10-10T03:34:46 | Isabelle Augenstein, Timothy Baldwin, Meeyoung Cha, Tanmoy Chakraborty, Giovanni Luca Ciampaglia, David Corney, Renee DiResta, Emilio Ferrara, Scott Hale, Alon Halevy, Eduard Hovy, Heng Ji, Filippo Menczer, Ruben Miguez, Preslav Nakov, Dietram Scheufele, Shivam Sharma, Giovanni Zagni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The emergence of tools based on Large Language Models (LLMs), such as
OpenAI's ChatGPT, Microsoft's Bing Chat, and Google's Bard, has garnered
immense public attention. These incredibly useful, natural-sounding tools mark
significant advances in natural language generation, yet they exhibit a
propensity to generate false, erroneous, or misleading content -- commonly
referred to as "hallucinations." Moreover, LLMs can be exploited for malicious
applications, such as generating false but credible-sounding content and
profiles at scale. This poses a significant challenge to society in terms of
the potential deception of users and the increasing dissemination of inaccurate
information. In light of these risks, we explore the kinds of technological
innovations, regulatory reforms, and AI literacy initiatives needed from
fact-checkers, news organizations, and the broader research and policy
communities. By identifying the risks, the imminent threats, and some viable
solutions, we seek to shed light on navigating various aspects of veracity in
the era of generative AI. | [
0.0582172982,
0.0602567606,
-0.0296875741,
0.0297623929,
-0.0564505942,
-0.0069658491,
0.0295237433,
-0.017706776,
0.040116325,
-0.0406060554,
0.0224662274,
-0.0443322174,
0.0259197131,
0.0463522188,
0.0138833532,
-0.0162801929,
0.0457577407,
0.0017975224,
0.0256648026,
-0.0140560912,
-0.0060280515,
0.0445260704,
-0.009975737,
0.0615604296,
-0.0731986612,
-0.0376482569,
0.0228416659,
-0.013585302,
-0.0098253619,
-0.0020036707,
-0.020454593,
0.028569486,
-0.0123147666,
0.1112330407,
0.0000018785,
-0.047059197,
0.0302860513,
0.0317435823,
-0.0407641642,
0.012676755,
0.0525661893,
0.0094588744,
-0.0293551292,
0.0278096274,
-0.0473608114,
0.0031877891,
0.0603897497,
0.0131852487,
0.0534069315,
0.0951510817,
-0.0121318717,
-0.0275655761,
0.0585377328,
0.0020076458,
0.0137342671,
0.0065705623,
0.0368677825,
0.0098132901,
-0.0227961466,
-0.0070540169,
0.0182013791,
0.0348052084,
0.0094258972,
-0.0307899117,
-0.0097280638,
0.0484171137,
-0.0354799218,
-0.057173837,
0.0190447718,
0.0307673682,
0.0197419133,
-0.0260729287,
0.0188606028,
0.0103016114,
-0.0137649383,
0.0153744835,
0.0078831101,
0.0868461058,
-0.0422562622,
0.0052954168,
0.0282057524,
-0.0370603353,
0.0502138771,
0.0484637283,
0.0037672336,
0.0422019698,
0.0077315336,
-0.0279912166,
-0.0198768713,
0.0046613235,
0.0280230418,
-0.0845361277,
-0.0084438762,
0.0073203552,
-0.0431245826,
0.0291713309,
-0.0538708493,
0.0104341097,
0.0398877114,
-0.0906253904,
-0.0088874074,
0.0197344851,
-0.0271087009,
0.0213776398,
0.0175002087,
0.0092728892,
-0.008095162,
0.0294985995,
-0.0025360889,
-0.0052609029,
0.0042023733,
-0.0117111504,
-0.0102689313,
-0.0117158499,
-0.0195351467,
-0.0071006659,
-0.0339249671,
0.0199571755,
-0.0405212343,
0.0437905602,
-0.0247863978,
0.0266709104,
-0.0414196402,
-0.0092204325,
-0.058293622,
0.0162294898,
-0.0053086355,
0.0308205653,
0.0123542491,
-0.081368275,
0.0119577926,
0.0450793952,
-0.0432600267,
0.0100443037,
0.0003354567,
0.0123162186,
0.0262424406,
0.0004776569,
-0.0291387569,
-0.0651383549,
-0.0435939096,
-0.093360737,
-0.0118479095,
-0.0675173551,
0.0089762937,
-0.0177263375,
-0.0268837959,
-0.0418766886,
0.0085359691,
0.037824925,
-0.0524122082,
0.0377784595,
-0.0494689494,
0.0145192556,
0.0374743752,
0.0150326462,
-0.0089145787,
0.0569993109,
0.0342837647,
0.0696302801,
0.0426228233,
0.029580716,
0.0327284634,
0.0011475161,
0.0101536615,
0.0319782868,
0.0114446552,
-0.0147833452,
-0.0247237198,
0.017912345,
-0.0074855173,
0.0855030045,
-0.0167620126,
-0.0143101383,
0.1026073694,
0.0189039707,
-0.0380334668,
0.0390038304,
0.0762485266,
-0.0035965492,
0.0250804275,
0.0308353715,
-0.0435521714,
-0.0063147396,
-0.0423188955,
-0.0019819946,
0.0293683428,
0.0779817551,
0.0032656633,
-0.0293599479,
-0.0022571669,
-0.0198594537,
0.0210656803,
0.0004639039,
-0.0078165578,
0.0040978487,
-0.016566338,
0.0105913337,
0.0461846218,
-0.0314344764,
0.0133933257,
-0.0892170519,
0.0096735731,
0.0749499574,
0.0644807741,
0.0233052522,
0.0037355816,
-0.0212614667,
-0.0135044642,
0.0734408647,
0.04325708,
-0.0109501565,
-0.0320444591,
-0.0100617148,
0.0240712781,
-0.019360505,
0.0321495533,
0.0064275307,
0.033859428,
0.0243026502,
0.0100019323,
0.0025977355,
-0.0426586196,
0.0103693847,
-0.0294302832,
-0.004507286,
-0.0207984783,
-0.0002220872,
0.0173814241,
0.0201429706,
-0.0400961675,
0.0105209788,
0.0248122942,
0.0161933415,
-0.0240927264,
-0.0022745421,
0.0027307603,
0.0322420634,
0.0281643737,
-0.035494443,
-0.0275614467,
0.0165015329,
-0.0029294824,
0.0071189282,
0.0146020642,
-0.0431605279,
0.0312307347,
-0.0449766032,
0.0032503838,
-0.0068267188,
0.0306246057,
0.0026939337,
0.0741785839,
-0.0222086981,
-0.0128623582,
0.0110727949,
-0.0050910483,
-0.0041885357,
-0.0125596048,
-0.0001828213,
0.032162264,
0.0228986815,
0.0339570455,
0.0150109073,
-0.0318163522,
-0.0315827429,
0.0012007287,
-0.0784620866,
0.0008455604,
-0.0141815739,
0.0006383809,
0.0108725186,
-0.0150755122,
-0.0091149239,
0.0207492281,
-0.0304526743,
-0.0125011085,
0.0164737795,
0.0188635718,
0.025006678,
0.0005867793,
-0.0266641136,
0.013987666,
0.0348825976,
-0.0316575393,
0.0184674095,
0.0514838174,
-0.030657934,
-0.0517772362,
0.0202764012,
-0.099379532,
0.0164756607,
-0.0001303859,
-0.0123434896,
0.0193117,
0.0201570895,
0.0183867384,
0.0299505647,
0.0364502221,
0.0671120062,
0.0583196916,
0.0383813791,
-0.0021263999,
-0.0201276261,
-0.0158737209,
-0.0139295328,
-0.0039809435,
-0.0641330704,
0.0216277,
-0.0079268869,
0.0539606996,
0.0007674923,
-0.0389296934,
0.0565417744,
-0.0367924049,
-0.0491270795,
0.0398283564,
-0.0337338522,
-0.0317280702,
0.0169730056,
-0.0272026937,
-0.0566330105,
0.0803327113,
-0.0450314432,
0.0504112542,
-0.0443281792,
-0.0270896591,
0.0090983799,
0.0283042789,
-0.0040654177,
0.0494873263,
0.0337898172,
0.0169601999,
-0.0155253764,
-0.0053728549,
0.0356402583,
-0.0488254391,
0.0130104432,
-0.056309443,
0.0201610513,
0.0347520933,
-0.0366655663,
-0.0489297807,
-0.0779318959,
-0.0057259961,
-0.0198292956,
0.0267033689,
-0.0296746325,
-0.0560561083,
-0.0418596677,
0.050323084,
0.0132059567,
0.0027500812,
-0.0172678586,
-0.004661093,
0.0072458331,
0.0530681573,
0.0064756982,
0.0665934309,
0.0123311682,
-0.0025468718,
0.0743977949,
-0.0362163968,
0.0202921331,
-0.0078181243,
-0.038820982,
-0.0179440044,
-0.0057323282,
-0.0073550944,
0.0425647125,
0.0221800171,
-0.0345383734,
-0.0113606909,
0.0585768782,
0.0271855462,
-0.0021388284,
0.0046438659,
0.0280198902,
0.0034451091,
0.001784057,
0.0005306734,
-0.1262955368,
0.0237011574,
-0.0030670196,
0.015873136,
-0.0756119937,
-0.0355023853,
-0.0389217436,
-0.1016849726,
0.0684289336,
0.0107198507,
0.0003373622,
-0.0281442851,
-0.0517651401,
-0.0362680592,
0.0295120906,
0.0378872417,
-0.0177321211,
0.0235527195,
-0.0102764424,
0.0107345134,
-0.0184802208,
-0.0369525291,
-0.005293963,
-0.0313322134,
0.081254065,
0.0569914915,
0.0548717864,
-0.0060408511,
-0.017925933,
-0.030587174,
0.0391948745,
-0.0139376344,
0.0093808118,
0.0641920865,
-0.0037402059,
-0.0152732013,
-0.0545782931,
0.0145594301,
0.0276397131,
-0.0132266413,
-0.0174001008,
0.0512006842,
-0.0370723195,
-0.0503285043,
-0.0136690484,
0.0221033804,
0.0484888107,
0.0717131943,
-0.0116120083,
0.0049889227,
-0.0156017169,
-0.0674300864,
0.0199066363,
-0.0079858517,
-0.0494184718,
0.0504837222,
0.0117692063,
-0.0679682493,
-0.07164561,
-0.031410981,
-0.0123425415,
0.0108209671,
0.0017432584,
-0.0243351851,
0.040166229,
-0.0053423364,
0.0051630461,
0.010274983,
-0.0412312225,
0.0220952388,
-0.0142711839,
-0.0140793938,
0.0112567088,
-0.0380398892,
0.0292520113,
0.0352676772,
-0.062456198,
-0.0580380894,
0.0393215083,
0.0203295872,
0.0259331968,
0.0455408283,
-0.0311561301,
-0.0152519252,
0.0630404055,
0.0705242679,
-0.0425330102,
0.0286873262,
-0.0005087558,
0.0050819027,
0.0110969124,
0.0193972606,
-0.014858624,
0.0059080138,
-0.0246176254,
-0.0143930418,
-0.0274697226,
-0.0193842836,
0.0530445427,
0.0571960732,
0.0142340725,
-0.0401212312,
0.0423835814,
-0.02022033,
-0.0184866041,
-0.0539316051,
-0.026572641,
0.0134297628,
-0.0221173279,
0.0007974188,
0.0169334803,
-0.0023082383,
0.0230190549,
-0.0493484885,
0.0121130804,
-0.0309761204,
-0.0234429594,
-0.0161418803,
0.0304159019,
0.0340420231,
-0.0197563749,
-0.0306157973,
0.0693184733,
-0.0261116102,
0.0503803939,
0.0109154582,
0.0284168571,
0.0040417723,
-0.0237994101,
0.0081257988,
-0.0105210356,
-0.0687449127,
-0.0698588192,
-0.0163578354,
0.0746236145,
0.0402272306,
0.0330170877,
0.0246291254,
-0.0449907631,
-0.0148408012,
-0.0015425159,
-0.019532308,
0.0289791692,
-0.0658949912,
-0.0231395699,
-0.0225088447,
-0.0572916158,
0.011666121,
0.0705801696,
-0.0199280549,
0.0740723833,
0.0175779853,
-0.0520794615,
-0.0069959485,
-0.0951397046,
-0.04853715,
-0.0087663038,
-0.003752291,
-0.0333230607,
-0.0868138224,
-0.0621881187,
-0.0092720529,
0.0142042479,
0.038557779,
-0.037547715,
0.0001440886,
0.0661077946,
0.0197866671,
-0.0162381772,
-0.0592300743,
0.0332459472,
-0.0356341414,
0.0102795251,
0.0043529705,
-6.721509759e-33,
0.0150903771,
-0.0515068732,
0.0127007021,
-0.0228103567,
-0.0163144525,
0.0191131067,
-0.0104233176,
0.00097919,
-0.0487240478,
0.0403585359,
0.0117153702,
0.0239664745,
0.0140609592,
0.0060550184,
-0.0422988236,
-0.020251222,
0.0594596453,
-0.0096226949,
-0.0339645594,
0.0390318893,
0.0618180297,
-0.0436281823,
0.0011299985,
-0.0800433531,
0.0636135712,
-0.0009860009,
-0.0571052916,
-0.0055072117,
-0.0557365306,
0.032456588,
0.0024832063,
0.0694413483,
0.0165235531,
-0.0241001491,
0.0014355034,
0.0012387222,
-0.0118623171,
0.0005446982,
0.0318713784,
-0.0037882554,
-0.0010664116,
-0.0354544893,
0.0386938006,
-0.0247176029,
-0.0355458744,
0.0254876576,
0.0144372135,
-0.0253692903,
-0.0072495579,
-0.0260036048,
-0.0496410243,
-0.009419282,
0.0120712528,
0.003889536,
-0.0377134457,
0.013077857,
0.0023372243,
-0.0181561578,
-0.0790188685,
0.0474758781,
-0.0028868441,
-0.0293065924,
0.0584298931,
-0.0322311297,
0.0039833705,
0.0629319474,
0.0338096097,
0.0244357232,
-0.0802812129,
0.0062981988,
-0.0194058176,
0.0551949814,
0.026053248,
0.084199734,
-0.0125267943,
-0.0647256672,
-0.073418133,
0.020661002,
0.0395431444,
-0.0027968206,
0.0261651222,
-0.0530232042,
-0.0794859454,
-0.0281670708,
-0.0076596322,
-0.0022459961,
-0.0338201895,
-0.0173460282,
-0.0081957029,
0.0042268946,
-0.0330832973,
0.0200506877,
-0.014914928,
-0.0743336901,
0.0292704049,
0.015505095,
-0.0384910479,
-0.0094978586,
-0.0015631112,
0.008319878,
-0.0331988484,
0.0072626667,
0.0137943886,
0.0262501333,
0.021887105,
0.0316068083,
0.021156691,
0.0068922467,
-0.0186939333,
0.0216628518,
-0.020152498,
0.0453134328,
0.0480628982,
-0.0330973454,
0.0400547683,
-0.0056021158,
-0.0181107968,
-0.0120420307,
0.0362828597,
0.0581391789,
-0.0180528779,
-0.009844902,
-0.0065608667,
0.0271524992,
-0.0444233529,
0.0097673014,
-0.0719144568,
-0.0014992054,
0.0311448555,
-0.0905941799,
-0.0280111916,
-0.0272693895,
2.777e-7,
-0.0147688324,
0.0487114117,
0.0073205596,
0.0384817831,
0.017329568,
0.0380972922,
0.0295445286,
0.0285556354,
-0.0157592744,
-0.0497036055,
-0.0279282704,
0.0193460975,
0.0225404091,
0.0643130317,
-0.041464787,
0.0050838194,
-0.07319583,
-0.001965432,
-0.0983126387,
0.0171969924,
0.043417614,
0.0678151473,
0.0359892808,
-0.0364276543,
0.0066339541,
-0.0401474461,
0.0290797167,
0.0363938808,
-0.0502477176,
0.0108117433,
0.0549871884,
0.0249286871,
0.0042144377,
0.012420984,
-0.0250052195,
-0.0187595095,
-0.0486793928,
0.0518470965,
0.0125894882,
-0.0007487955,
-0.0207382459,
-0.0548819825,
0.0221436433,
-0.049255345,
0.0726099163,
-0.0025301503,
-0.0442318879,
-0.0588735268,
-0.0123801455,
0.0005828628,
0.0177325346,
-0.028409062,
-0.0327495821,
0.011419029,
-0.0107522905,
0.0308153592,
0.0274905749,
-0.0134341698,
0.0077289077,
-0.0083096903,
-0.0348904096,
-0.0818185061,
0.0156609714,
0.0119689126,
0.022619959,
-0.0520690754,
0.0447929725,
2.586709757e-34,
0.0187899675,
0.002976933,
0.0139035312,
-0.0424716808,
0.0465685129,
0.0374704637,
0.0129814176,
-0.0141478917,
0.0103070168,
-0.0282965656,
-0.0213776305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05185v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05185v2 | Text2NKG: Fine-Grained N-ary Relation Extraction for N-ary relational Knowledge Graph Construction | 2023-10-08T14:47:13 | 2023-10-12T18:26:46 | Haoran Luo, Haihong E, Yuhao Yang, Tianyu Yao, Yikai Guo, Zichen Tang, Wentai Zhang, Kaiyang Wan, Shiyao Peng, Meina Song, Wei Lin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Beyond traditional binary relational facts, n-ary relational knowledge graphs
(NKGs) are comprised of n-ary relational facts containing more than two
entities, which are closer to real-world facts with broader applications.
However, the construction of NKGs still significantly relies on manual labor,
and n-ary relation extraction still remains at a course-grained level, which is
always in a single schema and fixed arity of entities. To address these
restrictions, we propose Text2NKG, a novel fine-grained n-ary relation
extraction framework for n-ary relational knowledge graph construction. We
introduce a span-tuple classification approach with hetero-ordered merging to
accomplish fine-grained n-ary relation extraction in different arity.
Furthermore, Text2NKG supports four typical NKG schemas: hyper-relational
schema, event-based schema, role-based schema, and hypergraph-based schema,
with high flexibility and practicality. Experimental results demonstrate that
Text2NKG outperforms the previous state-of-the-art model by nearly 20\% points
in the $F_1$ scores on the fine-grained n-ary relation extraction benchmark in
the hyper-relational schema. Our code and datasets are publicly available. | [
0.0378962718,
0.0173330959,
0.0287371501,
0.0836446583,
-0.0051674102,
0.0374122486,
-0.0345524997,
0.0050444738,
0.0435094833,
-0.0428570248,
0.0278838966,
0.0118359989,
-0.0324482508,
0.0270275939,
0.0255202763,
-0.0098083215,
0.0283416789,
0.0376713686,
0.0302239303,
0.032275226,
-0.0094231181,
0.0689146593,
-0.0319728889,
-0.0230653062,
-0.0594933555,
0.0291208848,
0.0035883745,
0.0052238032,
0.0392489806,
-0.0273616631,
0.0105196144,
0.0431833155,
-0.0127788968,
-0.0088626659,
0.0000018306,
-0.0318284966,
-0.036799565,
0.0177921224,
-0.0349481888,
-0.0269093271,
-0.0060066129,
-0.041343309,
0.0456501767,
-0.0169646107,
-0.0513124987,
-0.0558495745,
0.0058570923,
0.1091552377,
-0.0049932278,
0.046073541,
-0.04379173,
-0.0640623495,
0.0552834719,
-0.0334421769,
0.0043838667,
-0.0359998383,
0.0397324301,
0.0083628297,
-0.0076452023,
0.0112665743,
0.0259889886,
-0.0042916699,
-0.00699011,
-0.0171787962,
0.0368365198,
0.0389475003,
-0.0492054708,
0.0108838892,
-0.0134937176,
0.0995158255,
-0.0128049608,
0.0437588468,
0.0725213587,
0.0115582859,
0.0114651397,
0.0196319763,
0.0117263962,
-0.0209453162,
-0.0609632693,
0.0092305103,
0.0051666135,
-0.0397786163,
0.0166460183,
-0.008840926,
0.0131505355,
0.0021630658,
-0.0043973182,
-0.0007042417,
0.0477711856,
0.0160668921,
0.0048647881,
-0.0286045987,
-0.0004815889,
0.0185347442,
0.0004412808,
0.0230701752,
-0.0131550459,
0.0535366721,
-0.0126541285,
-0.0395405516,
-0.0338431336,
-0.0143093392,
0.0056527387,
0.0411662757,
-0.0478863306,
-0.0203686375,
0.0075378255,
0.0048210239,
-0.006391068,
-0.0126581639,
-0.0589653477,
0.0403974354,
-0.0195026398,
0.0619732141,
-0.0339404717,
-0.0132811358,
-0.0483990237,
0.0051602363,
-0.0143861836,
0.0568948016,
0.0183223579,
0.0032595494,
0.0079275807,
0.0072244257,
-0.0136890458,
0.0033178923,
-0.0189378634,
-0.0014364119,
-0.0312883593,
-0.0064202705,
0.00579983,
-0.0295762066,
0.0582643859,
-0.0439682603,
0.004399145,
0.0580822974,
0.0062631783,
-0.0210373532,
-0.0208095163,
-0.0504689217,
0.0146198319,
-0.0430923626,
0.0006290335,
-0.0564623587,
0.0921874717,
0.0152052902,
-0.0350948311,
-0.0079642478,
0.0516051389,
-0.0385151468,
-0.0908243805,
0.0322507061,
-0.0333100557,
0.0020090218,
-0.0277142078,
0.0020394241,
-0.0114823263,
0.0466875881,
0.0288425088,
0.018718617,
0.0454850867,
-0.02921631,
-0.0623137429,
0.0083572483,
0.0237426087,
0.0107144443,
0.0445343032,
-0.0095995273,
0.0323624499,
-0.0200979132,
0.0257397201,
0.0314797014,
-0.0302760657,
-0.0263720211,
0.0082879839,
-0.0428777821,
0.0162726864,
0.0299631953,
0.0243096612,
0.0074823727,
0.0068375985,
0.0274722129,
-0.072695151,
0.015137447,
-0.0425668359,
0.0132947695,
-0.0219087247,
0.0508041307,
0.0182006918,
-0.0136617003,
0.0210399199,
-0.0064885579,
0.0173517615,
0.0111569315,
0.0686705187,
-0.0091761434,
-0.0294676516,
0.0404360369,
0.082117781,
-0.0408214889,
0.0197826829,
0.0477959253,
0.0067837071,
0.0557854474,
0.0338400863,
-0.0668354705,
-0.020531781,
0.0087268753,
-0.0108498475,
0.0121886889,
0.0573583059,
-0.0550628379,
0.0304128043,
-0.0292067211,
-0.0681327879,
0.0081090974,
-0.0127505781,
-0.0010055299,
0.0323975869,
0.0278347488,
0.0044846009,
0.0134585109,
-0.0156475455,
0.0248777419,
-0.0188338663,
0.0017329348,
-0.0334590897,
0.0209869761,
-0.0210240316,
0.0569316074,
-0.0223068111,
-0.0233370494,
0.058113277,
-0.0315458551,
-0.0256910324,
-0.0279931985,
-0.0086558843,
-0.0633988529,
0.0539077334,
0.0131293237,
-0.0212171879,
-0.0091641145,
-0.0676982552,
-0.0070955949,
-0.0540136546,
0.0580791086,
0.0318814702,
0.0018634477,
-0.0161240548,
0.0492647476,
-0.0258005895,
-0.0098603787,
0.0739170834,
0.0047382358,
-0.0104779787,
-0.0435044579,
-0.1000373736,
0.0202545375,
0.002702682,
-0.0273917485,
0.0231367052,
-0.0154368607,
-0.0073472192,
0.0189783592,
-0.004652069,
-0.0756158158,
-0.0107545545,
-0.0400169007,
0.0345605947,
0.022396626,
0.0331352167,
-0.0000178468,
-0.0039568464,
0.003481871,
0.0083037242,
-0.0271811578,
0.0053002923,
-0.0630101487,
-0.0155849168,
0.0356635265,
0.0364044867,
-0.0067567998,
-0.0003174538,
-0.0382530168,
-0.0430127233,
0.0531698242,
0.0371624343,
-0.0047236583,
0.0088240206,
0.0141239213,
-0.0513073802,
0.0312086977,
0.0021843023,
0.0202565175,
-0.0255575962,
-0.0127660707,
0.0010671807,
-0.0071396921,
-0.0006667941,
0.0409598649,
0.0157889538,
-0.0108934427,
0.019471636,
0.0354504287,
-0.0492841974,
0.0407008417,
-0.0023603432,
-0.0085476423,
-0.0162651613,
-0.0092709037,
0.0211091843,
-0.0037926359,
-0.0425741933,
-0.0024297074,
0.0238223225,
0.0261366647,
-0.0283211377,
0.0174754243,
0.0297748204,
-0.0152876647,
-0.0417412147,
0.0316885822,
0.041264914,
0.0023519234,
0.0263382867,
0.0046337754,
0.0171436295,
-0.0292652156,
0.0841240361,
-0.0140993567,
0.0394292921,
0.0231324825,
-0.0252100397,
-0.0371922329,
-0.0104147084,
0.0271087307,
-0.0359823927,
0.0433922373,
-0.0224590525,
0.0223077536,
-0.0094172852,
-0.0186898448,
-0.0395298898,
-0.0086375354,
-0.0170755293,
0.0260365047,
0.0087681804,
-0.0302399471,
0.0062474948,
-0.0153587647,
-0.0141039239,
-0.0044553336,
0.0286051072,
-0.0088222465,
-0.0000998856,
0.0936029106,
0.0855432153,
-0.0043300288,
-0.0066175829,
0.0427545644,
0.002322562,
0.0634861663,
-0.0353786536,
-0.0193485897,
0.021601595,
-0.0006858194,
-0.0028733399,
-0.047201138,
0.0140721686,
-0.0102083497,
-0.0030507369,
-0.042021893,
0.0426483601,
0.0893405825,
0.0355874859,
0.0098890699,
0.002925111,
0.0426668003,
0.0473371409,
0.0142535251,
0.0015813273,
-0.1277817786,
-0.0299702752,
-0.0426305458,
-0.0140929967,
0.0260188226,
-0.0994502306,
-0.0036699881,
-0.0908017233,
0.0016980739,
0.0349040031,
-0.032678362,
-0.0144900857,
-0.0220502652,
0.0279426072,
-0.016742561,
-0.0461031161,
0.0035327526,
-0.0397412218,
-0.0067507522,
0.0118083106,
-0.0068269642,
-0.0479857624,
0.0530714802,
-0.0378658399,
0.0006139043,
-0.0538718104,
0.0277500115,
-0.022234967,
0.0269287769,
-0.0240718964,
0.0247439966,
-0.015893722,
-0.0308325067,
0.0855141655,
-0.0260703582,
-0.0036043325,
-0.0425375439,
0.0050822166,
-0.0568066351,
0.0195546299,
0.0146104181,
0.1002999023,
0.0460616164,
-0.0433156453,
-0.0085292608,
-0.0462439172,
0.0173409451,
0.0652742907,
-0.0065423851,
0.0091116764,
-0.026756648,
0.012279653,
-0.0080528883,
-0.0332524143,
0.0263131447,
0.0111255525,
-0.0925419107,
0.0099738203,
-0.0820492879,
-0.0694880038,
0.0539228506,
-0.0084753232,
-0.0348399431,
0.0181791969,
0.0732475296,
-0.0256160256,
-0.0891290903,
-0.0112235826,
-0.013482118,
-0.0001101545,
0.0286073778,
-0.028691126,
-0.0043197824,
0.0027480708,
-0.0368962921,
-0.0271776449,
-0.0203686524,
-0.0530188866,
-0.017898187,
-0.0093409708,
0.0078735519,
0.0350864679,
0.0083546853,
0.015953185,
0.005144353,
0.0754609853,
-0.0543665402,
-0.0292139743,
0.0122692399,
-0.021039756,
0.0011142418,
0.0605719574,
-0.058919102,
0.0081361663,
-0.0127941677,
0.074470453,
-0.053417407,
-0.0189650171,
0.0021053569,
0.0367161222,
0.0207635872,
-0.005374426,
-0.0126119005,
-0.0615093596,
-0.0056379107,
-0.0479048826,
-0.0272943377,
-0.0388183929,
0.046836134,
-0.0104820486,
0.0139435884,
0.0092448639,
-0.0161898416,
0.0485431589,
0.0464145243,
-0.0446488708,
-0.0298325643,
0.0004209728,
-0.0172899514,
0.0515875891,
-0.0448396467,
-0.0220345482,
0.0084543424,
0.0124499016,
-0.0092114331,
-0.0497193709,
0.0042861742,
0.0309565254,
-0.0292853247,
-0.0434108935,
0.0100089293,
0.0136385309,
0.0411909968,
-0.0104302075,
-0.02757621,
0.0562956184,
-0.0039437483,
0.0373967402,
-0.0183304995,
-0.0318234973,
0.0027114179,
0.0382385105,
-0.0273612123,
0.0094874157,
0.0356808342,
0.0162872449,
-0.0247570388,
0.0107845748,
0.0680082217,
-0.0192711093,
0.0599050038,
0.0193506964,
-0.0246198568,
-0.054037746,
-0.0461776033,
0.0135654788,
0.0226953216,
-0.0014968854,
0.0054955599,
-0.0704219565,
-0.0429059416,
0.0069881827,
-0.058682628,
-0.0368075445,
-0.0149947414,
0.0064088884,
0.0041325754,
0.0546896644,
-0.0349680185,
-0.0226085223,
-0.0063482085,
-0.0584179573,
-0.0142818969,
0.0213009883,
-6.153465705e-33,
-0.0216046646,
-0.0473335758,
0.0095084524,
0.0106105357,
-0.052347552,
0.0425443724,
-0.0148203447,
-0.0187216755,
-0.0264630336,
0.0395426527,
-0.0031622986,
-0.009735777,
-0.0019377579,
-0.0094109653,
-0.0110857142,
-0.0128267482,
-0.0004947453,
0.0176774506,
0.0171266664,
0.0408687443,
0.0551409945,
0.033053901,
0.0570346117,
-0.110915795,
-0.0039695282,
-0.0116030509,
0.0243225135,
0.009959586,
0.0563860051,
0.0258415993,
-0.020748917,
0.037420474,
0.041049879,
-0.0175412446,
0.0364948697,
-0.0080951005,
-0.1257255226,
-0.0336501747,
-0.0185751077,
-0.0166844241,
-0.020093713,
0.0212765187,
0.0115734814,
0.0161943585,
0.0740568638,
-0.0830194205,
0.0218400303,
-0.0423874669,
-0.041030094,
-0.0817600191,
-0.0254410487,
0.0312955678,
0.0323373377,
0.0189961065,
0.0086766854,
-0.0581578575,
0.0324948169,
-0.0342276543,
-0.0713007599,
-0.0248119384,
-0.0221231431,
-0.019953439,
0.0052857152,
-0.012401294,
-0.0077780741,
0.043792408,
-0.0207892247,
0.0156083684,
-0.0250221603,
0.0772834644,
-0.0312659033,
0.0942518786,
-0.0238404702,
0.0054754512,
0.0229282584,
-0.0341244265,
-0.1052565575,
0.0341056585,
0.0558938123,
-0.0107334685,
-0.0419744812,
0.0080847275,
-0.0353613012,
-0.0211914368,
-0.0027825339,
0.0482633971,
-0.0102230106,
-0.0190673918,
-0.0064751036,
-0.010013774,
0.0083266422,
0.0792172998,
-0.0214291327,
-0.0208600741,
-0.0418382511,
0.0730056986,
-0.0181431808,
0.005981416,
-0.0248933155,
-0.0156456474,
-0.0383492038,
-0.0583069585,
0.0167784635,
-0.0263369828,
0.005226227,
0.0352904573,
0.0596599542,
-0.016948849,
-0.0324966051,
0.0131891705,
-0.0181411039,
-0.000500424,
0.0100338785,
-0.0082685547,
0.0128449239,
0.0372639894,
0.0188823119,
0.0225842595,
0.0601436161,
0.0289627574,
-0.0179563724,
0.0817993954,
0.0093029309,
0.0002049277,
0.0491169803,
-0.0019612149,
-0.0041393167,
-0.03639495,
0.0288256183,
-0.008843706,
-0.0250747986,
-0.0116679361,
2.619e-7,
0.0220041685,
-0.0083882706,
0.0341380946,
0.0356650129,
-0.0180757828,
0.0385813341,
0.0322532244,
0.0423283093,
-0.034091264,
-0.0056080595,
0.005787686,
0.0064691873,
-0.0058067706,
0.0605937429,
-0.0268613249,
-0.0321866311,
-0.0236241184,
-0.0750717819,
-0.0735924318,
0.0129726343,
0.0968504176,
0.0090914862,
0.0562736839,
-0.0014489241,
-0.0354661755,
-0.0378503986,
0.0260594618,
0.0092458231,
0.0298859589,
0.0400146581,
0.0187887903,
0.0127859078,
-0.0211442951,
0.0603099838,
-0.0171734672,
0.0101331193,
0.0268508289,
0.050553754,
-0.0368435904,
0.0434915982,
0.0179587007,
-0.0659693107,
0.0192619227,
-0.0185767058,
0.059692312,
-0.042627614,
-0.0033596093,
0.0514388159,
-0.0418907404,
0.0056945067,
-0.0544671528,
0.0297227893,
0.0183404423,
0.0348108448,
0.0127885751,
-0.0174169056,
-0.0328483097,
-0.0800458193,
0.035156481,
0.099055104,
0.0385169871,
-0.0165102296,
0.0394759886,
-0.0281225834,
-0.0351500772,
-0.0207692161,
0.0280030854,
2.313085208e-34,
-0.017442571,
0.0249526426,
0.0084491149,
-0.0040754229,
0.0568755493,
-0.0538919978,
-0.0482851677,
-0.0150371529,
-0.0013769452,
-0.054766383,
0.0287721176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05178v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05178v1 | Optimizing Large Language Models to Expedite the Development of Smart Contracts | 2023-10-08T14:29:33 | 2023-10-08T14:29:33 | Nii Osae Osae Dade, Margaret Lartey-Quaye, Emmanuel Teye-Kofi Odonkor, Paul Ammah | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Programming has always been at the heart of technological innovation in the
21st century. With the advent of blockchain technologies and the proliferation
of web3 paradigms of decentralised applications, smart contracts have been very
instrumental in enabling developers to build applications that reside on
decentralised blockchains. Despite the huge interest and potential of smart
contracts, there is still a significant knowledge and skill gap that developers
need to cross in order to build web3 applications. In light of this, we
introduce MazzumaGPT, a large language model that has been optimised to
generate smart contract code and aid developers to scaffold development and
improve productivity. As part of this research, we outline the optimisation and
fine-tuning parameters, evaluate the model's performance on functional
correctness and address the limitations and broader impacts of our research. | [
-0.0012435495,
0.0878571942,
-0.0138291381,
0.0022107395,
-0.0230161753,
-0.0119872512,
0.0253887288,
0.0021315615,
0.0351211317,
-0.0117262602,
0.01170245,
0.0429904386,
0.0097397361,
0.0616326667,
0.0275592003,
-0.0125578875,
0.0489707626,
-0.0344114527,
-0.0179668479,
-0.0040461239,
0.0140776411,
-0.0188320316,
0.0348709971,
-0.0080307303,
-0.0001592236,
-0.0178846754,
-0.0031648474,
0.0252295695,
-0.022671707,
0.0184376966,
0.0026195601,
0.0581184886,
-0.0473775007,
0.0233136378,
0.0000023535,
-0.0289984532,
0.0106598325,
0.0481994934,
-0.0002349702,
0.0719251409,
0.0003031382,
-0.0326622166,
-0.033360146,
0.0442542471,
-0.020000007,
0.0103472024,
0.033017505,
-0.0109847533,
0.0144287432,
0.0329482667,
0.0107034603,
-0.0162269492,
-0.0017850709,
0.0002843463,
-0.0056735361,
-0.0174471475,
-0.0196543634,
0.023427071,
0.0450312942,
0.0061060786,
0.0301972833,
0.0151012195,
0.009736673,
-0.0283527449,
0.0370050371,
0.0193327256,
-0.0150290374,
0.0020462861,
-0.020043727,
-0.0148640107,
-0.006917655,
-0.0051464597,
0.0237966515,
-0.0136792166,
-0.0370402783,
0.0011055067,
-0.0157456268,
0.0511632115,
0.0152487773,
-0.0262410417,
0.0137399407,
-0.0016505019,
0.0016381696,
0.0301033463,
0.0201944169,
0.0599869452,
0.0185769778,
0.0264175758,
-0.0522417165,
-0.0065938341,
0.0132200159,
-0.043053899,
0.0179569088,
0.020133866,
0.0152498968,
-0.0253912732,
0.0025320682,
0.0024050609,
0.0730402619,
-0.0417525731,
-0.0176039264,
0.0166330189,
0.0039779684,
0.0214625895,
0.0013810747,
0.0357380919,
-0.0379873887,
-0.0193438996,
0.0268229302,
0.0273808092,
-0.0576945208,
0.0096325139,
-0.0806464925,
-0.0009186943,
-0.040303465,
0.0570999123,
-0.0218593534,
0.0444038212,
0.0221304893,
0.0653844923,
-0.0056924047,
-0.0322824828,
0.0006392851,
0.0174462944,
0.0269382522,
-0.0077432152,
-0.060771998,
-0.0155116841,
-0.0149003174,
-0.0313359015,
0.0196909104,
0.0242795795,
-0.049977649,
-0.0135060558,
0.0161237381,
0.0921473876,
0.0298593622,
0.0577124655,
-0.040066205,
-0.0910534263,
0.0335771665,
-0.0135802701,
-0.0611654371,
-0.1025083736,
-0.0653191134,
-0.0172445122,
-0.0202444699,
-0.0401380397,
-0.0450989418,
-0.0347969756,
0.0103886873,
0.0011686713,
-0.1087858379,
0.0067243073,
-0.0307038873,
0.0307808351,
0.009046955,
0.00582887,
0.0199649334,
0.0494452454,
0.0338892005,
-0.0577195436,
0.0453939289,
0.0412356444,
-0.0322054513,
0.0097089689,
0.0381110013,
0.0410508774,
0.0601744466,
-0.0338513963,
-0.0564276539,
0.0377176329,
0.0026848924,
0.0362220779,
0.0634167045,
-0.0116177164,
-0.0349449515,
0.0241711829,
-0.0082263537,
0.0502498224,
0.0547604263,
-0.0682151094,
-0.0548992977,
0.0348434411,
0.0179324709,
0.0032579568,
-0.0817551166,
0.0489532202,
-0.0285080373,
-0.0181182567,
0.0208999794,
-0.03280003,
0.0188470986,
0.0441516638,
0.0176461674,
0.0263165776,
-0.0385864079,
0.0300947763,
0.0001638841,
-0.0718814433,
-0.0682516396,
-0.0666070059,
0.0444632396,
0.0147925355,
0.0371491611,
-0.0006136004,
-0.0238819607,
-0.0272111595,
-0.0084595578,
0.0394918248,
0.0457545929,
-0.018490674,
-0.0061421297,
-0.0241140556,
-0.0255156271,
0.0209251735,
0.0213625133,
0.040001519,
0.012981276,
-0.0348292589,
0.0229067914,
-0.016605746,
0.00296679,
-0.0074049812,
-0.0277664382,
-0.0507772602,
0.0074829441,
0.0201901998,
0.0278146956,
-0.0003056907,
-0.0107564805,
0.0001856931,
0.010918376,
0.0238494724,
-0.0161845442,
-0.0060403622,
0.0060382164,
0.0806265399,
0.0083611291,
0.0179981366,
0.0175486039,
-0.0376387537,
-0.0466305092,
-0.0010789102,
0.06911733,
0.0172403883,
-0.025413841,
0.0138452752,
0.0135416901,
-0.0394019485,
0.0243248455,
-0.0324265882,
-0.0161790531,
0.0309447926,
-0.0369388312,
-0.0115561634,
0.0353858434,
0.0460559577,
0.0238129366,
-0.0007377351,
0.0292412117,
-0.0507895723,
0.0477466956,
0.0190368369,
0.1000294015,
0.0055495449,
-0.0409021005,
-0.0785793513,
0.0217577312,
-0.0117505901,
0.0601859167,
0.0206310339,
0.0701476783,
-0.0121537447,
-0.0047725611,
-0.0376522355,
-0.0029505582,
-0.0214600656,
-0.010941593,
-0.0109054362,
0.0058765379,
-0.0780928582,
-0.0068957238,
-0.009257175,
0.003260745,
0.0024517972,
-0.0046163267,
0.0447467379,
-0.0164588336,
0.0358189009,
-0.0080983853,
-0.0207623616,
-0.0104404567,
-0.0143029084,
-0.0140348338,
0.0454108939,
0.0149229029,
-0.0200823229,
-0.0349066742,
0.0183638278,
-0.0015822059,
-0.0207895264,
-0.0148497559,
-0.004241548,
0.0456556045,
-0.0106163071,
-0.0452464037,
-0.0267818086,
0.0295135025,
0.0836933479,
-0.0234516021,
-0.0363904834,
-0.0427772552,
0.0181994271,
0.0159261897,
0.0216291137,
0.0531574562,
0.0035530943,
0.0360588022,
0.0233022794,
-0.0080111548,
-0.0778905824,
0.0076853889,
-0.0678873062,
0.0224845894,
-0.029770961,
-0.0438419394,
-0.0796811357,
0.0530149154,
-0.0409085974,
0.012246578,
-0.0277041607,
-0.0107196216,
-0.0616556369,
-0.0378886685,
0.0540836491,
-0.0063980506,
0.0317030996,
-0.0027203585,
-0.0048099426,
-0.0278494265,
-0.0493691452,
0.0281694699,
0.0332055725,
-0.0399989486,
0.0422693789,
0.0225949567,
0.0235941764,
0.0072053066,
0.0257301256,
-0.0063144928,
0.0391636901,
0.030066343,
-0.0182394907,
-0.0409748964,
-0.0835078061,
-0.0395618603,
-0.1142153814,
-0.0159541555,
-0.0237964485,
0.0202483945,
0.0313512497,
0.0218651276,
0.015369528,
-0.0504970662,
-0.0028862802,
0.0339226834,
-0.0223673396,
-0.0437962972,
0.049402982,
0.0259451233,
-0.0740715787,
-0.0329699069,
0.0639336929,
0.0146405073,
-0.0278568119,
0.0345251076,
-0.0202541426,
0.0495308749,
0.0295645837,
0.0556342788,
-0.1039731801,
-0.0027083054,
-0.0106300954,
0.0401753448,
-0.0129990159,
0.0243009776,
0.0142489159,
-0.0337471664,
0.057015337,
0.013960775,
-0.0497209243,
0.0009084773,
-0.0359126553,
-0.0197670106,
0.0112726353,
-0.0458214246,
0.0217247698,
-0.0135939112,
-0.0058464915,
-0.0095845377,
-0.0403421409,
0.0174595248,
0.0413485169,
-0.0322034359,
-0.0014503285,
0.1043615937,
0.0078893984,
0.032632079,
0.0536884703,
0.028780818,
0.0301657598,
-0.047900483,
-0.0202228706,
-0.0420875177,
0.0719291791,
-0.0266130622,
0.0289286338,
0.0088616926,
-0.0495951734,
-0.0445697941,
0.0422728807,
0.0223436411,
0.0199670922,
-0.0328154452,
-0.0357229039,
-0.0308593791,
0.0206309147,
0.0087535828,
0.0046888753,
-0.0170411598,
-0.0727649108,
-0.0365086496,
-0.0215119366,
-0.0367845483,
0.0333222561,
-0.0226458497,
0.0153056933,
0.0083128223,
0.0146483304,
0.0108053265,
0.0102596739,
-0.0187750887,
0.0439713486,
-0.012611975,
0.0802358538,
-0.023555629,
-0.0625427812,
0.0104864761,
-0.059222687,
0.0485533588,
-0.0542638749,
-0.0126521084,
-0.0359407663,
-0.0404961742,
-0.025532458,
-0.0072416528,
-0.1075076461,
-0.0262327772,
-0.0257213376,
0.0697840527,
0.0211974829,
-0.0709300563,
-0.0330298059,
-0.0646838918,
-0.0622956678,
-0.0146733057,
-0.0349549949,
-0.0257809889,
0.0195110384,
-0.0463490523,
0.0045220433,
-0.0234260261,
-0.0452672541,
0.0139198815,
0.0422210693,
-0.0160320643,
0.0050998759,
0.0009993884,
0.0017845739,
0.0850463212,
-0.0357625447,
0.0143848471,
0.000597603,
0.002553934,
-0.0429565869,
-0.0056365505,
-0.0139717059,
-0.0489558913,
0.0088065723,
0.0008345769,
-0.0118152993,
0.04166447,
0.0262536872,
0.0094173737,
-0.0081531769,
0.0438014753,
0.0840602517,
-0.0530122332,
0.0117046451,
0.0776036754,
-0.0201378744,
-0.0186510943,
0.0399985984,
-0.012631176,
0.0112503106,
-0.0325239524,
-0.0102260569,
-0.0102079026,
0.0448783785,
-0.0155764017,
-0.0123253362,
0.014737403,
-0.095821023,
0.0187663529,
0.0549976863,
0.0214039925,
0.0284712426,
0.0236842129,
-0.0436163768,
0.0042775124,
-0.05128216,
0.0464196503,
-0.0098884236,
-0.0707024261,
-0.0281650871,
0.0131820971,
-0.018905336,
-0.0526828319,
0.1036812142,
0.0282586515,
0.0093547227,
-0.030290084,
-0.0259931181,
-0.0397058055,
-0.0100685535,
0.0337871723,
-0.0355068296,
-0.0664043948,
-0.01656501,
-0.0206112508,
-0.0553306192,
0.0018705989,
0.0040904451,
0.0364730135,
0.029427683,
0.0056096525,
0.0252663475,
0.025953399,
-0.0031981647,
-0.040204782,
-0.0270075202,
0.0052337735,
-0.0555371791,
0.0479220487,
-5.586237886e-33,
-0.0027632262,
-0.0220168792,
0.0483822897,
0.0088564316,
0.0071004289,
-0.0223792586,
-0.0508984812,
0.0125919674,
-0.0025109921,
0.0065665599,
0.0177822672,
0.0001822428,
0.0310265571,
0.0281796064,
0.0213751066,
0.0461731106,
0.0516592488,
-0.0083770668,
-0.0359358415,
0.0008526793,
-0.0422358252,
-0.0138579877,
0.0376985148,
0.0141031481,
-0.0247744806,
-0.0153351603,
-0.0293518305,
-0.0188050196,
-0.0289095081,
0.046447359,
0.0083383815,
-0.0164980162,
-0.0306095313,
-0.0085238572,
-0.0250383578,
-0.0211699922,
-0.0183065422,
0.0354468971,
0.0051102145,
0.0468661152,
0.0125880847,
-0.0633498579,
0.0266311709,
-0.0187330246,
-0.0310604125,
0.0042946958,
-0.006467937,
-0.012256477,
-0.0212069135,
-0.0712325647,
-0.0843273178,
0.0167254135,
-0.0496858656,
0.0459940061,
-0.0129049504,
-0.0281301066,
0.0091138883,
-0.0031050644,
0.002422869,
0.0202843845,
-0.0059433454,
0.0148051353,
0.0206120554,
-0.0332478881,
0.0156569332,
-0.0196414385,
0.0389202237,
0.0599076748,
-0.0071353517,
0.0226903465,
0.0170127489,
0.0642458871,
0.0731169656,
0.0250525158,
0.0159756336,
-0.0467568971,
-0.0185107607,
-0.0185066182,
0.007235195,
0.0156115172,
-0.0065106633,
0.001117346,
-0.0139513351,
-0.012298434,
-0.0395690389,
0.0105589349,
0.0183851738,
0.0047670323,
0.0318631753,
-0.0069401278,
0.0269508138,
0.0142954011,
0.0074021961,
-0.0573867746,
-0.0141424323,
0.0374765061,
-0.009584466,
0.0127878049,
0.0004765204,
0.050068181,
-0.0047845608,
-0.0520450808,
-0.0602701306,
-0.054552462,
0.0551497191,
0.0564023852,
0.0083145229,
0.0128947739,
-0.0659596995,
0.0377244651,
-0.0442096032,
0.0712559596,
0.0360884815,
0.0706231892,
-0.0194544438,
-0.0485204421,
0.0499359667,
0.024131868,
0.0037637195,
-0.055883497,
0.0001354194,
0.0333066881,
0.0272436012,
0.0373636186,
0.0411649086,
0.0071016634,
-0.0580454469,
-0.0176407583,
0.0167520177,
0.0013240264,
-0.0614521019,
0.0524056926,
3.133e-7,
0.0043434729,
0.037905369,
-0.0266933441,
0.067963466,
0.0171032231,
0.0707156658,
-0.0061282651,
-0.0115228118,
-0.0430744141,
0.0543113612,
-0.072075069,
-0.0131417587,
0.0895266384,
0.0123308236,
-0.0329217464,
0.0075264573,
-0.016527256,
-0.0034814449,
-0.0516900122,
-0.0081699388,
-0.0540938154,
0.0177281387,
0.0262867939,
-0.0392329618,
0.0192040708,
-0.0344894007,
0.0101401685,
-0.0101959929,
0.0051513463,
0.0912162662,
-0.0182807595,
0.0135031985,
0.0187688842,
0.015286536,
-0.0102246292,
-0.0293810498,
-0.0301789492,
0.0611753948,
0.0141680883,
0.1028178632,
0.0237198714,
-0.0853619799,
-0.0215438716,
-0.0283167716,
0.0046686521,
0.0241691917,
-0.04682111,
-0.040647693,
-0.0314742178,
-0.0452563502,
0.0413906984,
-0.0128046954,
0.0284858029,
-0.0359019041,
0.015542333,
-0.0348931439,
-0.0225159526,
0.0225046258,
-0.0100448001,
0.012264872,
-0.0371821746,
0.008053978,
-0.006048311,
0.066215843,
0.0461210795,
-0.0140087521,
0.044033099,
3.122784084e-34,
0.0239109695,
-0.0442027561,
0.0548630729,
0.0575572178,
0.0189846251,
-0.001491427,
0.0117795477,
0.0017988974,
-0.0115871225,
0.014344288,
-0.0113024097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05177v1 | Do Large Language Models Know about Facts? | 2023-10-08T14:26:55 | 2023-10-08T14:26:55 | Xuming Hu, Junzhe Chen, Xiaochuan Li, Yufei Guo, Lijie Wen, Philip S. Yu, Zhijiang Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have recently driven striking performance
improvements across a range of natural language processing tasks. The factual
knowledge acquired during pretraining and instruction tuning can be useful in
various downstream tasks, such as question answering, and language generation.
Unlike conventional Knowledge Bases (KBs) that explicitly store factual
knowledge, LLMs implicitly store facts in their parameters. Content generated
by the LLMs can often exhibit inaccuracies or deviations from the truth, due to
facts that can be incorrectly induced or become obsolete over time. To this
end, we aim to comprehensively evaluate the extent and scope of factual
knowledge within LLMs by designing the benchmark Pinocchio. Pinocchio contains
20K diverse factual questions that span different sources, timelines, domains,
regions, and languages. Furthermore, we investigate whether LLMs are able to
compose multiple facts, update factual knowledge temporally, reason over
multiple pieces of facts, identify subtle factual differences, and resist
adversarial examples. Extensive experiments on different sizes and types of
LLMs show that existing LLMs still lack factual knowledge and suffer from
various spurious correlations. We believe this is a critical bottleneck for
realizing trustworthy artificial intelligence. The dataset Pinocchio and our
codes will be publicly available. | [
0.0264496729,
0.0578369685,
-0.0012673406,
0.06423188,
-0.0463870615,
-0.0000584846,
0.0179837663,
-0.0208463892,
0.0065838755,
-0.0361664928,
0.0119113261,
-0.0604150519,
-0.0143508213,
0.0492034778,
-0.0007698621,
0.0013864714,
0.0518566594,
-0.0206060745,
0.0258069132,
-0.0104114749,
0.0037433808,
0.016125083,
-0.0274393428,
0.0021061024,
-0.0407253988,
-0.020414209,
-0.0198670402,
-0.0264890082,
0.0035527302,
-0.0159453936,
0.0026113661,
0.039424669,
0.0138075212,
0.0704027936,
0.0000019768,
-0.0242714137,
0.0252119731,
-0.0147784632,
-0.0808877796,
0.0607378595,
-0.0291380845,
0.0099351536,
-0.0019205698,
0.001340884,
-0.0601504482,
-0.0227994248,
0.0196953733,
0.0464709252,
0.0799202546,
0.1036954001,
0.0171071514,
-0.0058294209,
0.0339492112,
-0.0125936214,
0.0285644531,
-0.0203088429,
0.0018996005,
0.0003558769,
-0.0228373352,
0.0406450108,
-0.0004968248,
0.0134750139,
0.0498117544,
-0.0087461136,
-0.002462094,
0.0599998347,
-0.034967877,
-0.009038642,
-0.0097385645,
0.0591134429,
-0.007689999,
-0.0259737484,
-0.0088907322,
-0.0064817672,
0.0178056173,
-0.0444337055,
-0.0051164059,
0.0297574867,
-0.028854521,
0.0021991848,
0.0286784805,
-0.0164194293,
0.0490349941,
0.0408218913,
-0.0040594335,
0.0818856433,
-0.0051663746,
-0.02635381,
0.0034083596,
-0.0105701042,
0.0127294715,
-0.0985139832,
0.0053900783,
0.0504369773,
-0.0239449646,
0.0081458995,
-0.0575000308,
0.0437071547,
0.0454456322,
-0.0416971333,
-0.0276450459,
0.0246212296,
-0.0470589809,
0.0677481443,
-0.006070374,
0.075970754,
-0.0366490148,
0.0131096039,
0.0023602131,
-0.0061041084,
-0.0122450488,
-0.0056195441,
-0.0021779896,
0.0397479534,
-0.0428486764,
0.0006470899,
-0.0142772207,
0.0296521392,
-0.0140181994,
0.0615522228,
-0.0190109927,
0.0090788789,
-0.0132037234,
-0.0212505534,
-0.0646553934,
0.0371057503,
-0.0343892761,
0.0223971978,
0.015946608,
-0.0822938383,
-0.0323443152,
0.0065620658,
-0.0135520604,
-0.0275616162,
0.0301356427,
0.0097856503,
-0.0029004705,
-0.0290181339,
-0.0490287207,
-0.0585226193,
-0.0173796844,
-0.0997986048,
-0.0118935406,
-0.0794011876,
0.0405324139,
-0.0098485909,
-0.0340184309,
-0.036952503,
0.0086556552,
0.0304449517,
-0.0234740321,
0.0754485428,
0.013640807,
-0.0190311894,
0.0241622273,
0.0181105696,
0.0176435579,
0.0544140786,
0.0092820255,
0.0504921451,
0.0363613479,
0.0206559654,
-0.0221769046,
-0.0044846777,
0.0507823192,
0.0164063536,
0.0321374498,
0.0409109741,
0.0095840273,
0.0414755568,
0.007922519,
0.0695147812,
-0.0071655866,
-0.0600686632,
0.1097201705,
-0.0170198791,
-0.0412884019,
0.0368815362,
0.0641594604,
-0.0309002753,
0.0478553362,
0.0034776356,
-0.0568502955,
0.0211811606,
-0.0296469759,
0.0082576182,
-0.001371626,
0.0586169399,
-0.0377062261,
-0.0486855656,
-0.0253654011,
-0.0219572224,
-0.027535107,
0.0028237696,
0.020058034,
-0.0011540275,
-0.0315502584,
0.053727366,
0.0071652341,
-0.0377041847,
0.0045958403,
-0.0430700183,
0.0499388352,
0.0413240679,
0.0431770496,
-0.0426486805,
-0.0484997891,
-0.0102580804,
0.0374255665,
0.0376354232,
0.0954933092,
-0.0133005967,
0.024292808,
-0.0162226986,
0.012641238,
-0.0540304556,
0.0416400619,
0.0089089302,
0.0369893461,
0.0372065008,
0.0095596528,
-0.0313725062,
0.0111347632,
0.037656609,
-0.0184563696,
-0.0255847517,
-0.017529672,
-0.0124362353,
0.0181354154,
0.01329003,
-0.0191442557,
0.0132968882,
0.0249587875,
-0.0109194936,
-0.0461416468,
0.0001253699,
-0.0418258421,
-0.0251449235,
0.0576314814,
-0.0076689655,
-0.0212269239,
0.0167929307,
-0.0444897823,
-0.0043076631,
-0.0078938967,
-0.0408259258,
0.0175313912,
-0.0390406847,
0.0121009834,
0.0125215538,
0.0305208359,
0.0046146521,
0.0909491777,
-0.0457771234,
-0.022018658,
-0.0017773107,
0.0129020195,
0.0220043827,
-0.0355360955,
-0.0164205339,
0.013456624,
0.0170377828,
0.0149017842,
0.0101006581,
-0.0012354876,
-0.0352572314,
-0.0135749551,
-0.0664724186,
0.0392121524,
-0.0279831402,
0.0026535513,
0.0303426422,
-0.0275091827,
0.0108298697,
0.0068421834,
-0.0474728942,
0.0114252279,
-0.003984903,
0.0273494869,
0.0594567358,
-0.0093448255,
-0.0003715246,
-0.0112609472,
0.0077297594,
-0.0212294254,
0.0412715562,
0.020003438,
0.0337100625,
-0.0395063274,
0.0155428723,
-0.0900748447,
0.0228393953,
0.0069634365,
-0.0211675446,
0.0214110371,
-0.0096155964,
0.0341415033,
0.0795387179,
0.0242362563,
0.0259411354,
0.0693339705,
-0.0097130379,
-0.0246598255,
0.0350375473,
-0.017587794,
0.012295017,
-0.0273667406,
-0.0167094264,
0.0088255815,
0.0488637574,
0.0155416979,
-0.0214157365,
-0.0241046231,
0.0509922132,
-0.0028029941,
-0.0213966519,
-0.0411143489,
0.0058478056,
0.003678204,
0.0406397656,
-0.0404148102,
-0.0466375761,
0.0909225121,
-0.038773708,
0.0185420346,
-0.033528652,
-0.0091311065,
-0.0085186372,
0.0619054437,
0.0251888949,
0.0246271621,
-0.0341539457,
0.0186645277,
-0.0542853102,
0.0004072415,
0.0281355958,
-0.0647938028,
0.0404647402,
-0.073348105,
0.0103008104,
0.0178359319,
-0.0670628846,
-0.0698366165,
-0.0563163348,
-0.0227803644,
0.0116253924,
-0.0180320628,
-0.0291432403,
-0.0247479342,
-0.0425234735,
0.0433494635,
0.043687705,
-0.0002147481,
-0.0033175633,
0.0014507545,
0.0108933346,
0.0499128513,
0.027677061,
0.052747082,
0.0055881385,
0.0068794088,
0.0625690371,
0.0300715305,
-0.0026566098,
-0.0419873372,
-0.0179778691,
-0.0190229025,
-0.0150007131,
-0.0099652782,
-0.0002635694,
0.0392769724,
-0.0594403185,
-0.0505827442,
0.1072982252,
0.0362526998,
0.0215330441,
-0.0021584532,
-0.0005199181,
-0.0106941815,
0.0172170568,
0.0001077765,
-0.0844747573,
-0.004139747,
-0.0004314049,
-0.0159664247,
-0.0161708258,
-0.0330717079,
-0.0515226834,
-0.1290596277,
0.0062756818,
-0.0086385477,
-0.0483929403,
-0.0678874552,
-0.0355089828,
-0.0364046581,
-0.0039962209,
0.0275381505,
0.0303396024,
0.0303174425,
-0.0157066956,
-0.0092616733,
-0.0075005465,
-0.0268813167,
0.0516574979,
-0.0161314551,
0.0649457946,
0.0095933871,
0.0546072684,
-0.0026405877,
-0.0313273147,
-0.012992939,
0.0074533508,
-0.0384089947,
-0.0002618939,
0.0687086284,
-0.0023473774,
-0.034703102,
-0.0081576323,
0.0386055261,
-0.0005122289,
-0.014200612,
0.0158331674,
0.0498935319,
-0.0220801122,
-0.0404747315,
0.0005106083,
0.017540589,
-0.0011173512,
0.0855220929,
0.0266627446,
-0.0023812524,
-0.0277995393,
-0.0352091826,
-0.0199655537,
-0.038169153,
-0.017952133,
0.0338894613,
0.0193694085,
0.0000251132,
-0.0934499353,
-0.0268823784,
-0.0221275482,
0.0381775461,
-0.0208617095,
-0.0425089151,
0.0390982479,
-0.0194420889,
-0.0399084352,
0.0197349153,
-0.0585240647,
0.0037767678,
-0.0140866963,
0.0021905927,
0.0077933832,
-0.0391472317,
-0.0252485406,
0.0337079652,
-0.1124102324,
-0.05392389,
0.0279265549,
0.0417378396,
0.025759859,
0.0333135165,
-0.0269858483,
-0.028638415,
0.0428529494,
0.048736617,
-0.0434410088,
0.0209221356,
0.0002095539,
-0.0257946029,
0.0195552055,
0.03185983,
-0.0193533283,
0.0098913061,
0.0190167613,
0.0172092281,
-0.0403636172,
-0.0187647343,
0.023207441,
0.0291658603,
0.0303263459,
0.0141525073,
0.0211504288,
-0.0249175336,
0.0155550418,
-0.0153546147,
-0.0131470682,
0.0018976093,
0.0108413333,
0.0242790859,
0.0028950085,
-0.0027695806,
-0.028490698,
0.0075175636,
0.0468031541,
0.0128680533,
-0.0825973377,
0.018432321,
0.0211267862,
0.0234953277,
-0.0308770612,
-0.0485857055,
0.0454822108,
-0.0124015408,
0.0654022098,
-0.0098633869,
0.0515540466,
0.0137474546,
-0.0318662338,
-0.0079042418,
-0.0101768607,
-0.0882030427,
-0.0157815982,
-0.009095422,
0.0430055335,
0.0713638365,
-0.01543999,
0.0248893313,
-0.0579719022,
-0.0227531586,
-0.0184979234,
-0.0046771527,
0.0317611098,
-0.0341304168,
0.0345491953,
0.0079226177,
-0.0271039084,
0.0288545638,
0.0696093813,
0.014868129,
0.0804248154,
0.0136505961,
0.0008789775,
-0.0366395935,
-0.0547304191,
-0.0506917089,
-0.0115984008,
-0.0363296233,
0.0098618716,
-0.0860167518,
-0.0729888156,
0.0235023052,
0.0321295448,
0.0216466337,
-0.0135332402,
0.0035305088,
0.056652911,
0.0103808818,
-0.0116141709,
-0.0318039171,
0.0601211786,
-0.0020818885,
0.0073259408,
-0.0110527007,
-6.677692472e-33,
-0.03124444,
-0.0263700727,
0.0348115675,
0.0104388101,
-0.0024984789,
0.0566800013,
-0.0103846285,
-0.0161072928,
-0.0536163561,
0.0150590092,
-0.0065302122,
0.0507979318,
-0.005904078,
0.0171015635,
-0.0166201219,
-0.0544893518,
0.0535688661,
-0.0130663915,
-0.0595355891,
0.0235596392,
0.0721761808,
-0.0198280159,
0.0406185612,
-0.0479594544,
0.0232914705,
-0.0113589363,
-0.0247535128,
0.0450081639,
-0.0740421042,
0.0670061707,
-0.0172192883,
0.0461005904,
0.01440138,
-0.0514957346,
-0.0002290578,
-0.0239151008,
-0.0485633239,
-0.0338581726,
0.0259335898,
-0.0010753431,
0.0008893089,
-0.0177529939,
0.0371853709,
-0.0037660683,
0.0209579114,
-0.0185395125,
-0.002204736,
-0.030928446,
-0.0100308014,
-0.0125503307,
-0.0199653246,
-0.0055034524,
-0.0025001201,
-0.0144273723,
-0.0351604484,
-0.0114471624,
0.022056492,
-0.0244445484,
-0.0909120291,
0.0170127414,
0.002335225,
0.0177560449,
0.0503002182,
-0.0355971344,
-0.0116841001,
0.0583070666,
0.0076052686,
0.0047197975,
-0.0647173077,
0.0417670645,
0.0078630419,
0.0118466318,
0.0581129454,
0.0834340379,
0.033210028,
-0.0170262977,
-0.0943297148,
-0.0019054163,
0.0530095883,
0.0264191721,
0.0251227506,
-0.0402029864,
-0.0448052585,
0.0273550022,
-0.0566018224,
0.0580817908,
-0.0434752107,
0.01394339,
0.0141928094,
0.0168636497,
0.0102607897,
-0.0156535693,
0.0004352766,
-0.0143624851,
0.0317299105,
0.0517425984,
-0.0127446167,
-0.0238450058,
-0.002832311,
0.036000099,
-0.0467886031,
-0.005152226,
0.0066246064,
0.0006024843,
-0.0004847375,
0.0256375428,
0.0305522513,
0.0107000787,
-0.0508405566,
0.0142114107,
-0.0588320717,
0.0256326254,
0.0072990945,
-0.0125599103,
0.0249237046,
0.0022414662,
-0.0336410813,
0.0196734332,
0.0357878953,
0.0234591141,
-0.0324228853,
-0.0135356914,
0.0166748893,
0.0306980237,
-0.0304628517,
-0.0102258306,
-0.0320502259,
-0.0062048719,
-0.0240371209,
-0.0541024245,
0.0071405205,
-0.0062877601,
2.714e-7,
-0.0064347261,
0.0448287353,
-0.0017381646,
0.0485187247,
0.0203839149,
0.0338944085,
-0.0162704904,
0.0227746498,
-0.0306385793,
-0.0653281286,
-0.0070976233,
0.053480722,
0.0355438627,
0.0637966767,
-0.0661928058,
-0.0165059268,
-0.0660400689,
-0.0503870137,
-0.0671273395,
-0.0389445052,
0.03120194,
0.0861773863,
0.0756988078,
-0.0230780747,
0.032345783,
-0.053427808,
0.0646124333,
0.0335265324,
-0.0424842946,
-0.007233568,
0.0818879902,
0.0596413575,
-0.008738515,
0.0316868238,
-0.0058065141,
0.0068734782,
-0.0314481445,
0.0751809627,
0.0186331272,
-0.0120694833,
-0.0195555333,
-0.0534252264,
-0.0288959853,
-0.0401791818,
0.0858734921,
-0.0055759456,
0.0022250258,
-0.0457082652,
0.0103508886,
0.0028174568,
0.0341542773,
-0.0314809494,
-0.0123157213,
0.001173015,
-0.0361938514,
-0.0049986611,
0.0207856949,
-0.0291433204,
-0.0305598658,
0.0132598449,
-0.0412914082,
-0.0622731484,
-0.0199893545,
0.0094556333,
0.0273204334,
-0.0388040505,
0.0213588066,
2.343027482e-34,
0.0295542609,
-0.027109718,
0.0014161289,
-0.0173419528,
0.0254291296,
0.0079115313,
-0.0227745473,
-0.0390351973,
0.0159695912,
-0.0234212186,
-0.0091822846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05165v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05165v1 | On the Zero-Shot Generalization of Machine-Generated Text Detectors | 2023-10-08T13:49:51 | 2023-10-08T13:49:51 | Xiao Pu, Jingyu Zhang, Xiaochuang Han, Yulia Tsvetkov, Tianxing He | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rampant proliferation of large language models, fluent enough to generate
text indistinguishable from human-written language, gives unprecedented
importance to the detection of machine-generated text. This work is motivated
by an important research question: How will the detectors of machine-generated
text perform on outputs of a new generator, that the detectors were not trained
on? We begin by collecting generation data from a wide range of LLMs, and train
neural detectors on data from each generator and test its performance on
held-out generators. While none of the detectors can generalize to all
generators, we observe a consistent and interesting pattern that the detectors
trained on data from a medium-size LLM can zero-shot generalize to the larger
version. As a concrete application, we demonstrate that robust detectors can be
built on an ensemble of training data from medium-sized models. | [
0.0023487571,
0.0626296476,
0.0064898538,
0.0852648616,
-0.0203615371,
0.02630613,
0.0126256384,
0.070968084,
-0.0237339456,
-0.0343068875,
0.0002165199,
-0.0169136766,
-0.0466383919,
0.0403012559,
0.048161909,
0.0240669157,
0.009305248,
-0.0066789291,
-0.0353141278,
0.023153184,
0.0065162196,
0.0050398461,
0.0074312557,
0.0294156298,
-0.008277067,
0.0076932735,
-0.0110694226,
0.0261825882,
0.0277441628,
-0.0273546167,
-0.0186194945,
0.0251861792,
0.0299792308,
0.1233308986,
0.0000015841,
-0.0282135531,
-0.020237213,
-0.0279799942,
-0.037690863,
-0.0339893848,
0.0396261066,
-0.040815074,
-0.0478997864,
0.0186773278,
-0.0110179894,
0.0050859605,
0.0432127975,
0.0261449981,
0.0000514089,
0.1097088605,
-0.0212559532,
-0.0057306662,
0.0488755405,
0.0011999299,
0.0416817255,
-0.0119016832,
0.0118109612,
-0.048241958,
-0.0020685524,
0.0080250753,
0.0105167981,
0.0157921016,
0.0186312236,
-0.0294039659,
-0.0058013545,
0.0434556752,
-0.0413061827,
-0.0173562989,
-0.0219199061,
0.0476348065,
-0.0661872253,
-0.0343019739,
0.0246211328,
-0.033525601,
0.0085019991,
-0.0319509655,
0.0056593665,
0.0550451949,
-0.0303534474,
0.046495948,
0.0073104878,
-0.0026044063,
0.029395543,
0.0223204605,
-0.0179851484,
0.0370606333,
0.0235556588,
-0.0220298748,
-0.0362397656,
0.0329836234,
0.0104893828,
-0.0457581207,
0.0198765323,
0.0481366441,
0.0046669664,
0.0018394359,
-0.0779701546,
-0.0408634841,
0.0077557825,
-0.0222170074,
0.0692250803,
0.0153595535,
-0.0371151827,
0.0125460271,
-0.1030568033,
0.0674694628,
-0.0491832495,
0.0283555854,
-0.0170595683,
0.0094655342,
-0.0322870836,
-0.0128331836,
-0.0097009027,
0.0261502154,
0.0172284935,
-0.0139166145,
-0.034685228,
0.0429823138,
0.0270916391,
0.0223314166,
-0.0460228175,
-0.0241686851,
-0.0425116681,
-0.0199146327,
0.0310983099,
0.007084379,
-0.001414451,
-0.0006180182,
0.0111969858,
-0.1184981167,
-0.0327919386,
0.0692591816,
0.0376891941,
0.0226150658,
0.0082988041,
0.0653965846,
-0.023886105,
-0.0702354908,
-0.0649090856,
-0.0187717974,
-0.0281662103,
-0.0287145413,
0.0274306722,
-0.0649137348,
-0.0260918606,
-0.0187888294,
0.0079812706,
-0.031026734,
0.0035822983,
0.0208916888,
0.0151206702,
0.0443810821,
-0.0419029593,
-0.0213161372,
0.0035063017,
-0.0111757452,
-0.0000773595,
0.0796886533,
0.0268880632,
0.0713686422,
0.0133153088,
0.0075261714,
0.0612334535,
0.0675365999,
-0.0097907539,
0.0355084576,
-0.02145404,
-0.0472585559,
-0.0159940831,
-0.0074086338,
0.0241682269,
0.0201039109,
-0.028472146,
-0.0066970903,
0.0535674803,
0.06108189,
0.0224821735,
0.022612771,
0.0904258564,
-0.0029956126,
-0.0390597805,
0.0813154578,
0.0055859112,
-0.0210544523,
-0.0718456954,
-0.0068102339,
-0.0178422593,
0.0064746882,
-0.0311808214,
-0.0168426391,
-0.0237670839,
-0.0271375217,
-0.0546434633,
-0.0591161884,
0.0643377453,
0.0327035412,
-0.0442772582,
-0.0184203014,
0.0029776013,
-0.0525014251,
0.0240224954,
-0.0701985583,
0.0581921861,
0.0544464476,
0.0313555598,
0.0023204549,
0.0359859541,
-0.019454129,
-0.0121608004,
0.0776706114,
-0.0227584094,
0.0096289692,
0.0385179855,
-0.0349781625,
-0.0114631895,
0.0052599511,
0.0403576009,
0.0423586145,
0.0188711826,
0.0093766749,
0.0319046341,
-0.0039694593,
-0.0147805326,
0.0684360117,
-0.0393551253,
-0.037777625,
0.0098365583,
-0.0018011557,
0.0332544409,
-0.0058816201,
-0.0435146764,
0.0083891246,
0.0273372792,
-0.0722937733,
-0.0361883976,
-0.0053787944,
-0.0205241051,
-0.04280385,
0.0083285067,
-0.0241967645,
-0.0085524023,
-0.00621993,
-0.0306654014,
-0.0243177228,
0.0071948641,
-0.0322266854,
-0.0110679138,
-0.068838872,
0.0422558635,
-0.0149268117,
0.0257213823,
-0.0173059236,
0.0611051358,
-0.0144478884,
0.0018330875,
0.0176033787,
-0.0070074154,
0.0474438407,
-0.074889496,
-0.017059844,
0.0087503204,
-0.0273336601,
0.001195065,
0.0021050787,
0.0214334689,
-0.0141638527,
-0.0372827165,
-0.0301626641,
0.0100618824,
-0.0351651162,
0.0103177596,
0.0517254062,
-0.0244057383,
0.008306765,
-0.0195358209,
-0.0137928464,
0.0335783251,
0.0772166774,
-0.0062975138,
0.0497458093,
-0.0266843121,
-0.0035414021,
-0.0131051708,
-0.0115388455,
0.001956559,
0.0488809347,
0.0257032681,
-0.0350291543,
-0.0952994153,
0.043895267,
0.0019977477,
0.0309793707,
0.0044101644,
-0.0350353979,
0.0191374402,
-0.0451375619,
-0.0144363465,
0.0736346766,
0.0097121866,
-0.0029567915,
0.0263979249,
0.0571182445,
-0.0298179965,
-0.0213156547,
0.0143136373,
-0.021630289,
-0.0396059826,
-0.0417899489,
0.0302148554,
0.0759927109,
-0.0076040966,
-0.0045868955,
-0.0175283011,
0.0175120123,
0.0105140237,
-0.0495605394,
-0.0223518442,
-0.0317586586,
-0.0366474353,
0.0502736494,
-0.0272756219,
-0.0832406208,
0.0226911157,
-0.0449311808,
0.0062275394,
0.0080352724,
-0.0372420177,
-0.0276270825,
0.0138008213,
0.0420185365,
0.0347740799,
0.0114122815,
-0.0039151162,
-0.036448516,
0.008102932,
0.0027435862,
-0.0098142829,
0.0223541278,
-0.0152600668,
0.0204797015,
-0.0292783212,
-0.0096172858,
-0.0856706053,
-0.0105757304,
-0.0124794086,
0.0011504947,
0.0114878491,
-0.0204415526,
-0.0285592154,
0.0073339595,
-0.0063390476,
0.0530715808,
0.0162183736,
-0.0094655063,
-0.0424129963,
0.0871375501,
0.0160373542,
-0.0442425981,
0.0053324886,
-0.0538031571,
0.0230662934,
0.0463433005,
0.001726961,
0.0392370969,
-0.0526929423,
0.0110813612,
0.0259269495,
0.019447593,
-0.0235294681,
0.0186803453,
0.0197266396,
-0.0257313307,
-0.00958772,
0.0905891135,
0.0011699613,
-0.0263584666,
-0.0142327519,
0.0110422457,
0.0298344344,
0.0139475223,
-0.007176382,
-0.0868065208,
-0.0147963744,
0.0178159811,
-0.0142837139,
-0.0490982682,
-0.0082466817,
-0.0174253043,
-0.1136647016,
0.0216338746,
0.0300728567,
-0.0309320632,
-0.0134258214,
0.0326242596,
0.012872546,
0.0064958879,
-0.029652264,
0.009463476,
-0.0038492694,
-0.014457901,
0.006255866,
0.0257915128,
-0.0575078428,
-0.0659636632,
-0.0574923046,
0.0106251007,
0.075945057,
0.0210424718,
-0.0177884251,
-0.0253285281,
0.0113795903,
-0.0169744454,
0.0023635889,
0.0055999602,
0.0671406314,
-0.000586297,
-0.0200398602,
0.0235806219,
0.0302314572,
-0.0057809437,
0.0090682469,
0.0240934473,
0.0014006001,
-0.0068378411,
-0.0757102147,
-0.0113274781,
-0.0054250415,
0.0037975188,
0.0607574955,
0.0547933392,
-0.018988153,
-0.0377142876,
-0.0310900658,
0.0239946805,
-0.0829090029,
-0.0218999106,
0.0126333935,
-0.01109487,
-0.0486206897,
-0.0837782025,
0.0089940578,
-0.0232769884,
0.0392211042,
0.0001959213,
-0.0072138617,
-0.0402720608,
-0.0283561032,
-0.0151288714,
-0.0121596279,
-0.033873789,
-0.0075339801,
-0.065390639,
0.0161869507,
0.0071991803,
-0.043526344,
-0.0082672322,
0.0428173654,
-0.0973787308,
-0.0556422099,
-0.0030829404,
0.0074538803,
0.0271263346,
0.0017586008,
-0.0229369253,
-0.0676378086,
0.0992892832,
0.0387782492,
-0.0053179907,
0.0192120839,
0.0361078866,
-0.0173335038,
-0.031785477,
0.028522471,
-0.0225095954,
0.0493304022,
0.0506902374,
-0.0455011129,
-0.0378488973,
-0.0105037233,
0.0170894898,
0.0025681502,
-0.0062180986,
-0.0318277068,
0.0299074762,
-0.0234069731,
-0.0012527017,
0.0171063263,
0.0050940574,
-0.0596121103,
0.0232370328,
0.0421052426,
-0.0073350305,
0.0008869256,
0.0167864356,
-0.0268073939,
0.0941989869,
-0.037759997,
-0.0061436342,
0.0154849021,
0.0392348021,
0.0219775997,
0.0092049865,
0.009473267,
0.0810796022,
-0.012332377,
0.002787814,
-0.0033131589,
0.0260791089,
0.0152908182,
0.0188580025,
-0.0123379463,
0.0165900011,
-0.0641234517,
-0.0059781787,
-0.0544073209,
0.0684385449,
0.0797002241,
0.0138907274,
0.0313267298,
-0.011375824,
-0.0230541471,
-0.0288646054,
0.0093112281,
-0.0052304976,
-0.0355564952,
-0.0098871365,
0.010452752,
-0.0240463335,
-0.0229352005,
0.0842249691,
0.0361610018,
0.0583121628,
-0.0095695471,
0.0127585381,
-0.0499374941,
0.0009418268,
0.0126466649,
-0.0200804621,
0.0169948786,
0.0382088497,
-0.0119800121,
-0.0492724329,
0.0461755432,
-0.0122965146,
0.0499170907,
0.0081157591,
-0.0139515987,
0.0260125045,
-0.0139011964,
0.0244587734,
-0.0169669483,
0.0226667318,
0.0099400561,
-0.0068663382,
-0.0295550525,
-5.299818034e-33,
-0.043395143,
-0.0469929464,
-0.022868257,
-0.031452477,
0.0205880329,
0.0107492851,
-0.0196194295,
-0.0221099276,
0.0027592357,
-0.0131782731,
-0.0159761645,
0.0253038853,
0.0215334352,
0.0281764958,
-0.0316362865,
-0.0205229204,
0.0673134699,
-0.0391588807,
-0.0289206095,
0.002861727,
0.0399284959,
0.0202624407,
0.0422767028,
-0.0419465601,
0.0043018106,
-0.0429061055,
-0.0554085299,
0.0072467201,
-0.0280955285,
0.0493953899,
-0.0166289993,
0.022262821,
0.0455931909,
-0.0025092841,
-0.0376996435,
0.0307810865,
-0.0269378722,
0.0124130975,
-0.0409967415,
-0.0002363497,
-0.024320595,
-0.0749420673,
0.0482292362,
-0.0453834534,
-0.0301498249,
0.0224833693,
0.0379707664,
-0.0375348628,
-0.0066224509,
-0.0507811606,
-0.0532621816,
0.0257922783,
0.0074508502,
0.0044765342,
0.0360769108,
0.0237979293,
0.0113711143,
0.023929324,
-0.0346682668,
0.0236568321,
0.0498974994,
0.0502744913,
0.0236357003,
0.0512104183,
-0.0252978932,
0.0452063903,
0.0442411676,
-0.0063093598,
-0.0216180179,
-0.0344981477,
0.0230643917,
0.0178158823,
0.0789952204,
0.0781967565,
0.0658631772,
-0.0051629096,
-0.0536893979,
0.0241848864,
-0.0156200938,
0.0030018596,
0.0438539311,
0.0068422249,
-0.0056245513,
0.007293581,
-0.0165184513,
-0.097028695,
-0.0306354482,
-0.0044626952,
0.0347443856,
0.0576508604,
-0.0230613686,
-0.0348117687,
0.0390597656,
-0.0493966304,
0.0067124134,
0.0440233462,
-0.0305788424,
-0.0100581925,
0.0367794745,
0.0093768043,
-0.0200939178,
-0.0377665535,
0.046322085,
0.0338487811,
0.0235589147,
-0.0303492304,
0.0723436102,
0.0396139324,
-0.0517649874,
0.0177541878,
-0.0573259182,
0.0252237227,
0.0338321738,
0.0504241213,
0.0307955313,
-0.0531697012,
-0.0060979025,
0.0174651258,
0.018437095,
-0.0056218463,
0.0046525458,
-0.0073903385,
-0.0176979993,
0.0521169715,
-0.0532343835,
0.0196153708,
-0.0081169996,
0.0387131236,
0.0678560585,
-0.0333257802,
0.0213151742,
-0.0247160196,
2.215e-7,
0.0224701911,
-0.0226882957,
0.05002819,
-0.0017046388,
0.0451272093,
0.0177417658,
-0.0426568612,
0.0361344218,
-0.026133839,
-0.0102270609,
-0.0190429203,
0.0057542371,
0.0628695562,
0.0073860409,
-0.0772586465,
0.0411454253,
-0.0640465915,
0.0451295823,
-0.0509008951,
-0.0067739179,
0.0705548525,
0.0690839216,
-0.0202447735,
-0.0417161323,
0.06427522,
-0.0914823264,
0.0527906902,
-0.0035322329,
0.0342555046,
-0.01202597,
0.0631047785,
0.0420474112,
0.0014483255,
0.0029936843,
-0.0024523691,
0.0034800838,
-0.00410055,
0.0503668934,
0.0104456535,
0.0206690207,
0.0020670902,
-0.0213328786,
0.0205156505,
-0.0141634131,
0.0625545382,
-0.0245793033,
0.0141743971,
-0.0148201166,
-0.0092424564,
-0.0541820712,
-0.0019542514,
-0.0493085943,
-0.0012081368,
0.0214662105,
0.014197289,
-0.0030865329,
-0.0280500557,
-0.0332653038,
-0.0418276265,
-0.053077355,
-0.049556192,
-0.0296064243,
-0.0746379644,
0.0045359912,
0.0247718487,
-0.0551002659,
-0.0005615532,
1.846024798e-34,
-0.0027575891,
-0.0143336579,
-0.0114836143,
0.0327475294,
0.0042148605,
-0.0135890758,
-0.0150303934,
-0.0105995806,
-0.0112632429,
-0.02743355,
0.0210532863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05163v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05163v3 | An Investigation of LLMs' Inefficacy in Understanding Converse Relations | 2023-10-08T13:45:05 | 2023-11-13T07:24:14 | Chengwen Qi, Bowen Li, Binyuan Hui, Bailin Wang, Jinyang Li, Jinwang Wu, Yuanjun Laili | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success in many formal
language oriented tasks, such as structural data-to-text and semantic parsing.
However current benchmarks mostly follow the data distribution of the
pre-training data of LLMs. Therefore, a natural question rises that do LLMs
really understand the structured semantics of formal languages. In this paper,
we investigate this problem on a special case, converse binary relation. We
introduce a new benchmark ConvRe focusing on converse relations, which contains
17 relations and 1240 triples extracted from popular knowledge graph completion
datasets. Our ConvRE features two tasks, Re2Text and Text2Re, which are
formulated as multi-choice question answering to evaluate LLMs' ability to
determine the matching between relations and associated text. For the
evaluation protocol, apart from different prompting methods, we further
introduce variants to the test text and few-shot example text. We conduct
experiments on three popular LLM families and have observed various scaling
trends. The results suggest that LLMs often resort to shortcut learning and
still face challenges on our proposed benchmark. | [
0.0544514582,
0.0333315991,
0.0161325224,
0.0787363797,
-0.0531424433,
0.0076127965,
-0.0514326915,
0.010503483,
0.033515323,
-0.0639500543,
-0.0183267239,
-0.0088369418,
-0.0165889971,
0.0121782115,
-0.0042315642,
0.0100195799,
0.0529619493,
-0.0262954179,
-0.0031052029,
-0.0247014165,
-0.0035462945,
0.0314689316,
0.0054300651,
-0.0230742078,
-0.0161669534,
0.0025997008,
0.0268553384,
0.0044469247,
-0.0162012391,
-0.0401365273,
0.0213807989,
0.0335610546,
-0.0148729691,
-0.0042208247,
0.0000018783,
-0.0820258856,
0.0072241272,
0.0087368861,
-0.0472922362,
-0.0145794237,
-0.0273081139,
-0.0250766706,
0.0538388155,
0.0198802426,
-0.0509260297,
-0.011186556,
0.0088840183,
0.0338131711,
0.0233220495,
0.0491473563,
-0.0094854282,
-0.0409386568,
0.0229632724,
-0.0418379419,
0.0212862752,
-0.0349520668,
0.0415657498,
0.0229882319,
-0.0032232078,
0.0188732408,
-0.0242737643,
0.0271793641,
0.0337745175,
0.0223156232,
0.0108503345,
0.0343658999,
-0.0296367127,
-0.0057711899,
0.0223110616,
0.0790413842,
0.0459888279,
-0.0159655455,
0.0004291546,
0.0110282572,
-0.0069636535,
0.0027990013,
-0.0028528888,
-0.0013668078,
-0.0519581698,
0.021589864,
-0.0204501841,
-0.0306527615,
0.0593140945,
0.010984065,
-0.0509154797,
0.1046017334,
0.0114263054,
-0.0247390065,
0.0339675993,
0.0077274139,
-0.0312048569,
-0.0359123908,
0.0016213699,
0.0418716446,
-0.0574736223,
0.0269536003,
-0.0500299856,
-0.0007616328,
0.0283496883,
-0.0421726517,
-0.0067927344,
0.0217708331,
-0.0071613165,
0.0676829666,
-0.0536527,
0.0224200841,
-0.0020523386,
0.0263858829,
-0.0590063557,
-0.0491374582,
-0.0237237066,
0.0074186376,
-0.0380475782,
0.0685905144,
-0.0326595083,
-0.0234424956,
-0.0263437536,
0.0069562951,
-0.0034637982,
0.052128382,
0.0420734808,
0.0081761694,
-0.0180196706,
-0.0117747001,
-0.0549148545,
-0.00640408,
-0.0179746579,
0.0193729866,
-0.0217838939,
0.0052026669,
0.0137546603,
-0.0133390911,
0.0091430712,
-0.0585567728,
0.0368511006,
0.072814025,
0.0032789232,
-0.0257093348,
-0.0188174825,
-0.0426254272,
0.0106818387,
-0.0844737515,
-0.0084658004,
-0.061314892,
0.0493918657,
0.0652645603,
-0.0087075941,
-0.0318894722,
0.0452744067,
0.006564403,
-0.0615793243,
0.0870518535,
0.0057078828,
0.0094730565,
-0.0209403951,
-0.002162945,
-0.0134612331,
0.0562921613,
0.0178422034,
0.0022283613,
0.0376824923,
0.005659767,
-0.0459878594,
0.0288367607,
0.0729861706,
0.0180255417,
-0.0485505871,
0.0860227644,
0.0268779993,
0.0284749065,
0.0278939959,
0.0902036652,
0.0060317512,
-0.0548785999,
0.0071170121,
-0.0158810019,
0.0042542149,
0.0255842954,
0.030191768,
-0.0065098512,
0.0162160508,
0.0269729532,
-0.090092063,
0.0035505458,
-0.0648330525,
0.019214496,
-0.0015177648,
-0.0116205197,
-0.0302193221,
-0.021560451,
-0.0176945087,
-0.0040915548,
0.0061154813,
0.0283164121,
0.074296996,
0.0282028168,
-0.0415645503,
0.0581113771,
0.0213855281,
-0.0068314513,
0.0024187616,
-0.0156417117,
0.0107640307,
0.0338452682,
0.0314879641,
-0.0141055295,
-0.0293757822,
0.012113031,
0.0084418394,
0.0036232364,
0.027806798,
-0.0137537196,
0.023256734,
-0.0102991797,
-0.0265625529,
-0.0068275882,
-0.0133511852,
-0.0114061488,
0.0363465883,
0.0027598899,
0.017417796,
-0.0732745826,
0.0220717806,
0.0340039991,
-0.0480237864,
0.0004530832,
0.0152322389,
0.0197295379,
0.0219028108,
-0.0020630385,
0.003506009,
0.0266325306,
0.0501830541,
-0.0332955271,
-0.017129004,
-0.0047935401,
-0.0322105214,
-0.0667225346,
0.0591704659,
-0.0283544175,
-0.0602443255,
0.0589946024,
-0.057618659,
-0.0458285175,
-0.0009438946,
-0.0201402232,
0.0748086348,
-0.0174242482,
0.00932738,
0.042399507,
-0.0058595589,
-0.0186888762,
0.0733770952,
-0.024794979,
0.0374391861,
-0.0094199162,
-0.0213097949,
0.0133255934,
0.0155836269,
-0.0299360957,
-0.0259800889,
-0.0051430287,
-0.0072500757,
-0.0020937235,
-0.0090750745,
-0.0526719391,
0.0003871935,
-0.0587682463,
0.0012030714,
0.0012503091,
0.0357572399,
0.0245822463,
0.0030799648,
0.0253176372,
-0.0263996832,
-0.0387139991,
0.0214818325,
0.0046513388,
0.0142224981,
0.0518171564,
0.0072675869,
-0.0313518457,
-0.0490192361,
-0.031830851,
-0.0237455778,
0.0427916683,
0.0194464587,
-0.0002989117,
0.0186224673,
0.0787048414,
-0.0357727297,
0.0343188047,
-0.028241748,
0.015792165,
-0.0034429922,
-0.0125981541,
0.0388247706,
0.0281069241,
-0.0158280022,
-0.0129359998,
0.0357297771,
0.0198974349,
-0.0571150444,
0.0040501561,
-0.0264807176,
-0.0227212012,
-0.0389639847,
-0.0436795056,
-0.0454998836,
0.038978897,
-0.0151800569,
-0.0126935774,
-0.005391676,
-0.0260302052,
0.0177112836,
0.0304262936,
-0.0639821142,
0.0069542332,
0.0299868099,
0.0363257267,
-0.0508185923,
-0.0095029743,
0.0698914379,
-0.0190030616,
-0.0067445445,
0.0140262367,
0.0117060347,
-0.0698408261,
0.0932530165,
0.0289288741,
-0.0070065516,
-0.0017234532,
-0.0145698879,
-0.058515612,
-0.0637414455,
0.0587547235,
-0.0175739322,
0.0346142873,
-0.0202718098,
0.0598305464,
-0.0317270234,
-0.0297021195,
-0.0477456674,
-0.0345400572,
-0.0329563357,
0.0284005962,
0.0181997512,
-0.0026642622,
0.004541121,
0.0060255416,
-0.0195467118,
0.0148100629,
0.0209847726,
-0.0260728188,
-0.0432934836,
0.0407487936,
0.0677058995,
-0.0042598816,
0.0116547914,
-0.0130325034,
0.019848071,
0.0455454513,
0.0407497399,
0.0198553167,
-0.0299403314,
-0.0127264978,
-0.0031821684,
-0.0432040356,
-0.0023574715,
-0.0114979809,
0.0035717927,
-0.0416750051,
-0.0028455949,
0.0962275341,
0.0284049325,
-0.0190634318,
0.0104253748,
0.0075702658,
0.0106611503,
0.0768675134,
-0.0083801923,
-0.1023520231,
-0.023475159,
-0.0012744884,
-0.0067638806,
0.0124210324,
-0.0800498798,
-0.004034976,
-0.1375170946,
-0.0168282036,
-0.0392528549,
-0.0156428758,
-0.0199883338,
-0.0428479537,
0.0183380824,
-0.0053676129,
0.0026347917,
-0.0026383526,
-0.0359743759,
-0.0040100859,
-0.0141639179,
0.0353684612,
-0.0161614344,
0.0390534252,
-0.0556520931,
0.019508969,
0.0015556995,
0.0235981699,
-0.0250322018,
0.0238360278,
0.0659396052,
0.038405519,
-0.0244803578,
-0.0233319961,
0.0434516184,
0.0067288871,
-0.0051082131,
-0.0481100641,
0.0130234053,
-0.065233998,
0.0251632985,
0.0272732992,
0.0767122135,
-0.0037522221,
-0.0183185972,
-0.021082988,
-0.0201572608,
-0.0258365385,
0.0780892223,
0.0362414494,
0.0031113492,
-0.0511794724,
-0.0170058385,
0.0052977595,
-0.0309867114,
-0.0046308041,
0.0030593746,
0.0005862488,
0.0689819828,
-0.0420859344,
-0.0448465347,
0.0593018308,
0.0007128884,
-0.0266320165,
0.0429032668,
0.0027552694,
-0.0182310212,
-0.0586284772,
0.0175223332,
-0.0294824876,
0.0260251667,
-0.0439794846,
0.013968139,
0.0211503468,
0.0037028654,
-0.0278804265,
-0.0522577539,
-0.0930486992,
-0.0129274959,
-0.0445973091,
0.0336628221,
0.0200976115,
0.0601869486,
-0.025436569,
-0.0036706768,
-0.0160111059,
0.0804201812,
-0.0559345558,
0.0212682318,
0.026380755,
0.0035221286,
-0.0042712414,
0.0644627661,
-0.0418297127,
-0.0043917056,
0.0320280716,
0.0643236116,
-0.0082810698,
-0.0359035768,
0.0521901026,
0.052395869,
0.019644076,
0.0167004764,
0.0161030572,
-0.0056898096,
0.0444727913,
-0.0315222964,
-0.0312735476,
-0.0509349555,
0.0210997295,
0.027950678,
-0.0232325029,
-0.0072236196,
-0.041790165,
0.0103685511,
0.0796967223,
-0.0180459991,
-0.0022104804,
0.0209943466,
-0.0076596388,
0.0757716149,
-0.0285344832,
-0.0182471983,
0.0302871633,
0.0495488383,
0.0294927582,
-0.0130804339,
0.010298254,
0.0356907658,
0.0114519298,
-0.0340256244,
-0.01646493,
-0.0231270269,
-0.0282715131,
-0.0133375851,
0.016923923,
0.0551465861,
0.0045027235,
0.0225525629,
-0.0247462355,
-0.0085916454,
-0.0274729189,
0.0302832332,
-0.0208334308,
-0.0205829907,
0.0624811463,
0.0110628456,
-0.0112180635,
0.0686424673,
0.0757111087,
0.0203877166,
0.0601845384,
0.0348124728,
-0.0235633533,
-0.0339323469,
-0.0560137592,
-0.0019379308,
0.0003088448,
-0.0165145006,
0.0323990323,
-0.0523810387,
-0.1167625412,
-0.022903122,
-0.0201839861,
-0.0459054634,
-0.036100179,
0.008029893,
0.031263385,
0.0551061034,
-0.0359173082,
-0.0197431296,
0.0333983488,
-0.0304182861,
-0.0318016633,
-0.0486909114,
-6.225548856e-33,
-0.0493733324,
-0.0545863286,
0.0216794312,
-0.0208850726,
0.0008791448,
0.0050848555,
-0.0361994915,
-0.0142454496,
-0.058425229,
0.0024093359,
-0.0298048705,
0.0223505907,
0.0006701175,
0.0348611884,
-0.0123435427,
-0.0329328515,
0.0119011393,
-0.0050648069,
0.0045950585,
-0.003187442,
0.0153607754,
0.0234410819,
0.0196662731,
-0.0909178108,
-0.0019242269,
-0.0287336968,
-0.0183546282,
0.0419861376,
-0.0557034612,
0.0728010386,
-0.0142843472,
0.0291297212,
0.0332279429,
0.0029180727,
0.0083550327,
-0.0088424059,
-0.1326110959,
-0.0302731059,
0.0371991508,
-0.005823852,
-0.0605836175,
0.0157946236,
0.0532464236,
-0.0034651987,
0.0283250567,
-0.0225471854,
0.0308884941,
-0.0267519113,
-0.050880149,
-0.0242640655,
-0.0414245613,
0.017043896,
0.0131386183,
-0.0047552381,
0.0044110822,
0.033275608,
-0.005607604,
0.0093270699,
-0.0441254601,
-0.0417567566,
-0.0123674627,
0.0195434876,
0.0221429057,
0.0128959091,
0.0027077503,
0.0274265148,
0.0033458972,
-0.0067003043,
0.0181906484,
-0.0047471081,
0.0048229252,
0.0694387257,
-0.0005569386,
0.0464699231,
0.0321781039,
-0.0004192572,
-0.1017003953,
-0.0179286841,
0.0091676489,
0.0379181616,
-0.0064708139,
-0.0329223089,
-0.010831208,
-0.0400042832,
-0.0741899833,
0.027703803,
-0.0527835004,
-0.0213964917,
0.0371802673,
-0.0092958855,
-0.0011440489,
-0.0174255017,
0.0121628586,
-0.076127246,
-0.0622479133,
0.0487557203,
0.0062771854,
0.0217564031,
0.0159212369,
0.0695971921,
-0.0623197295,
-0.0292356052,
-0.0259794723,
-0.0277174022,
0.0056064781,
0.0338563174,
0.0284696408,
-0.0120750498,
-0.0484160334,
-0.0163417738,
-0.0601957925,
-0.0242797229,
-0.0457732789,
0.0094859777,
0.0533391647,
0.0482561365,
0.0131361615,
0.0613922216,
0.0091270246,
-0.0012648384,
-0.0438781604,
0.0123652127,
0.0076144501,
0.0293443166,
0.0131202955,
-0.0276551489,
-0.0273479745,
-0.0237890966,
0.0502644479,
0.0033963446,
-0.0002304763,
0.0191457458,
2.601e-7,
0.0587291084,
0.0242699739,
0.025985565,
0.0889462531,
-0.010270671,
0.0231460314,
0.0005848788,
0.0260197353,
0.0153462095,
-0.0106513388,
0.0153439268,
0.0049861083,
0.019896863,
0.0483863614,
-0.0471547917,
0.0270252898,
-0.0682705566,
-0.0529778078,
-0.0375250429,
-0.0089869266,
0.0479955561,
0.0789652318,
0.0264269635,
0.0073478362,
-0.0491744131,
-0.0665133297,
0.0798218325,
-0.0518558621,
0.0084152883,
0.0338737257,
-0.0133357449,
0.0104784081,
0.0068036644,
0.0666873232,
0.0243935697,
0.0273508187,
-0.0084745651,
0.0708377287,
-0.0038822494,
-0.024428878,
-0.0138157886,
-0.0311090183,
0.0209242534,
-0.0296145529,
0.0914591327,
-0.0632478446,
-0.009147401,
0.0126773855,
-0.0056193927,
-0.0107901236,
-0.0021805104,
0.031697005,
0.0178440213,
-0.0025045183,
0.0316331498,
-0.0052910475,
-0.0164922159,
-0.0562240705,
-0.0016197143,
0.0211909115,
-0.0253777932,
-0.034705963,
-0.0202420801,
0.0142156165,
0.0016059361,
-0.0191136803,
0.0037667828,
2.52696342e-34,
0.0528484173,
-0.0151351662,
0.0039870217,
0.0306995455,
0.0522787683,
-0.0302042291,
-0.0201829802,
0.0259933453,
0.0185398329,
-0.0947716609,
0.018935455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05161v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05161v4 | Recurrent Neural Language Models as Probabilistic Finite-state Automata | 2023-10-08T13:36:05 | 2023-12-19T10:13:33 | Anej Svete, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CC, cs.LG | Studying language models (LMs) in terms of well-understood formalisms allows
us to precisely characterize their abilities and limitations. Previous work has
investigated the representational capacity of recurrent neural network (RNN)
LMs in terms of their capacity to recognize unweighted formal languages.
However, LMs do not describe unweighted formal languages -- rather, they define
\emph{probability distributions} over strings. In this work, we study what
classes of such probability distributions RNN LMs can represent, which allows
us to make more direct statements about their capabilities. We show that simple
RNNs are equivalent to a subclass of probabilistic finite-state automata, and
can thus model a strict subset of probability distributions expressible by
finite-state models. Furthermore, we study the space complexity of representing
finite-state LMs with RNNs. We show that, to represent an arbitrary
deterministic finite-state LM with $N$ states over an alphabet $\alphabet$, an
RNN requires $\Omega\left(N |\Sigma|\right)$ neurons. These results present a
first step towards characterizing the classes of distributions RNN LMs can
represent and thus help us understand their capabilities and limitations. | [
0.0118681379,
0.0472972728,
-0.0130532552,
0.0310382135,
-0.0418555588,
-0.0107458569,
-0.0545267239,
-0.0041608722,
-0.0141576529,
-0.0298935212,
0.0063071512,
-0.0857345313,
0.0502266176,
0.0407586657,
0.046609439,
-0.0432305038,
-0.0105763609,
-0.0590833984,
0.0372360721,
-0.0160941817,
-0.0065723443,
-0.0361808427,
-0.0168407522,
0.028617613,
0.0332003944,
0.013076175,
-0.0202235021,
-0.0452791192,
-0.0675366744,
-0.0364218056,
-0.0415383987,
0.0145361619,
-0.0004407978,
0.023586344,
0.0000015856,
-0.0300399344,
0.0447967649,
-0.029543696,
0.0013760995,
0.0229828265,
-0.0187658705,
-0.0172356311,
-0.021738898,
0.0232715625,
0.0173956882,
-0.0540896282,
0.0998188853,
0.011084157,
-0.0257512294,
0.0661714822,
0.0040821554,
-0.0140712587,
0.0502369069,
-0.0578933805,
0.0142127834,
-0.0175980665,
0.0541020893,
-0.0260974783,
0.0230433047,
-0.0335043669,
-0.0474122651,
0.0070926379,
0.0078830607,
0.0160992183,
-0.036152143,
0.0502824187,
0.0230322294,
0.0091194753,
-0.022902593,
0.0393893234,
-0.0519551039,
-0.024344556,
0.0129698906,
-0.0013807673,
-0.0146437148,
-0.0164999664,
-0.0028881112,
0.0749164447,
0.0088357031,
0.0617051013,
0.0042943773,
0.0404709205,
0.083973743,
-0.0193071552,
-0.0279797632,
0.0736578703,
0.0203264486,
0.0031759187,
-0.0464059412,
-0.0124332085,
0.0320347622,
-0.0881180242,
0.004415384,
0.0611447096,
0.0482532606,
0.0446603633,
-0.0066460897,
-0.0151190525,
0.0155919548,
-0.0643460527,
0.0665484816,
0.024552796,
0.0125731062,
0.0320217088,
-0.0147924228,
0.0401844122,
-0.0080294581,
-0.0070008133,
0.0086081577,
0.0324109867,
-0.0351132378,
-0.0211306009,
-0.0308248494,
0.0420472883,
0.0240241196,
-0.0385861695,
-0.0201363321,
0.0439191386,
-0.0115568079,
-0.0291718543,
0.0052092103,
0.013627341,
-0.0536071844,
0.0385233723,
-0.0691767484,
0.0297879539,
0.025102254,
0.0008811861,
-0.0009150915,
-0.0286429338,
-0.0094469106,
0.0311730113,
0.0114104562,
-0.0075468631,
-0.0668914765,
0.062489491,
0.0374349467,
-0.0047386829,
-0.0272682942,
0.0091454666,
-0.0244491547,
-0.0408525839,
0.0069294809,
-0.0502040274,
-0.0017365449,
-0.0192452502,
-0.0091625201,
-0.0392296575,
0.0225130077,
0.0010909738,
-0.00951201,
0.0719328001,
0.0431558341,
0.0050909249,
0.0108493753,
0.0035143732,
0.0449564084,
0.0202514492,
0.0517612025,
0.0161477551,
0.018565923,
-0.0105597349,
0.0415306687,
0.0455394275,
-0.0385001712,
-0.021751307,
-0.0696496889,
-0.0384949669,
0.0167814679,
0.0375949703,
0.034623798,
0.0697736964,
0.0091187749,
-0.0232430436,
0.023522066,
0.0245927554,
0.0267804265,
0.0234393049,
0.0592654049,
-0.0365354121,
0.0481736548,
0.0513545386,
-0.0489725135,
0.0183977466,
-0.0199295357,
0.0375634693,
0.0142084965,
-0.0041210754,
-0.0489587709,
-0.0299169645,
-0.0240289755,
-0.0510111414,
0.0285119116,
-0.0307544153,
0.0743648559,
0.0084584393,
-0.0331171639,
0.0190716982,
-0.0251675416,
-0.0177126192,
0.0440067686,
-0.0256345607,
0.0410375446,
0.0488207005,
0.0283932909,
-0.0540621355,
0.0188375283,
0.0142794149,
-0.0148026645,
0.0196521673,
0.0292566344,
0.0175911654,
0.0275750291,
-0.0103419591,
0.004442207,
0.0242164452,
0.0210788175,
0.0597108155,
-0.0461486131,
0.0197373144,
-0.0032692435,
-0.0539967306,
-0.0771236792,
0.0158333946,
0.0082361968,
-0.0345371664,
0.0374243259,
-0.0026426776,
0.0479326583,
-0.0101082884,
-0.0051096501,
0.0679307431,
0.0177262314,
-0.0364331454,
-0.0025390135,
-0.0072330534,
-0.042845998,
-0.0031850191,
0.0492591001,
0.0221913513,
0.0113931745,
0.010193238,
-0.0344058797,
-0.0450148135,
0.0877966732,
-0.040716365,
0.0478912145,
-0.0149286175,
0.002613435,
0.0343921371,
0.0621603318,
-0.0096099693,
0.0488992743,
-0.0362791717,
0.0244579017,
-0.0157855581,
0.0165049639,
0.027397912,
-0.0557769239,
-0.0784895644,
-0.0037314035,
-0.0190498084,
0.028226614,
0.0182943083,
-0.041012831,
0.0422781706,
-0.0335263461,
-0.012572404,
0.0022616361,
-0.0168485064,
0.0501500107,
-0.0364484154,
0.0280670617,
0.0238464102,
-0.0241163336,
-0.0691344962,
0.0076641017,
0.0033855205,
0.0175614282,
0.0729028434,
0.0066779791,
-0.0597561076,
-0.050182499,
-0.0310431309,
-0.0102247577,
0.0183151104,
-0.0034423175,
-0.0179532543,
-0.0446494259,
0.0179744344,
-0.0063386704,
0.0466329381,
-0.0324539021,
-0.0224794727,
-0.005654078,
-0.0240915604,
0.0438437611,
0.0458054952,
0.0045939428,
0.0236789305,
0.0580521449,
-0.0146387294,
0.0128897866,
-0.0239540394,
-0.0395850167,
-0.0215470642,
-0.0042287172,
-0.0363889933,
0.0122418664,
0.0718372762,
0.0175460577,
-0.0396424979,
-0.0251190867,
-0.0116174277,
-0.0054362891,
0.0268672872,
-0.0054970668,
-0.0319943801,
-0.0367343351,
0.0498959012,
-0.0167669188,
-0.0549599826,
0.0381291993,
-0.0585364103,
0.0379590988,
0.0021798357,
-0.0437326767,
-0.0552173629,
0.0651970431,
0.062774837,
-0.0254153125,
0.0344740823,
-0.0259022973,
-0.0163033791,
-0.0258172043,
-0.0128222462,
-0.0061210264,
0.0133143235,
-0.048496861,
0.0202469751,
-0.029675113,
-0.0015108769,
-0.0010649931,
-0.0056656306,
-0.0068468945,
0.0081707491,
-0.0387222469,
-0.0238733869,
-0.0045990935,
0.0632120296,
-0.0138210673,
0.0245950669,
-0.0153530389,
0.0073529943,
-0.0115349405,
0.0320741087,
0.0104852887,
0.0046985387,
0.0226521175,
-0.0118685281,
-0.0452074893,
-0.0245621856,
0.0330745652,
0.0716265813,
-0.0670081526,
0.0017906257,
0.0184021294,
-0.0271325111,
-0.0430832058,
0.0670350268,
-0.0153950304,
-0.0390619189,
-0.0095968945,
0.1089008674,
-0.0094149224,
-0.0129506439,
0.026128618,
0.0373623297,
-0.0198115371,
0.0097380718,
0.020674739,
-0.0658704042,
0.0171101429,
-0.0144830607,
-0.0301717445,
-0.023520302,
-0.0575852692,
-0.0041870093,
-0.0691119432,
-0.025314698,
-0.0125182178,
-0.0530880466,
-0.0743225813,
0.00507958,
-0.0170302484,
-0.0067625456,
-0.0166052636,
-0.0101425378,
-0.0049534803,
0.0254258029,
0.0416659974,
-0.040310204,
-0.0283891782,
0.004270745,
-0.0335520022,
0.0487330519,
0.0848346502,
0.0311252829,
-0.0623306744,
-0.0584879145,
-0.0047744666,
-0.0122983027,
-0.0143440245,
0.0534243993,
-0.0229065586,
0.0283429734,
-0.0144571764,
0.0186274536,
0.009275008,
-0.0419052429,
0.0097419042,
-0.0162091237,
0.0791076422,
-0.0212449059,
-0.0627615303,
-0.0128951985,
-0.0445386507,
0.0502141751,
0.0660493746,
0.0416571461,
-0.0052411868,
-0.0527586937,
-0.0502367318,
0.0290563125,
-0.0177453756,
-0.0033837818,
-0.0478965677,
0.0395248011,
-0.0738577172,
-0.0641040057,
0.0009566693,
-0.0086508468,
0.0133814458,
0.0163417738,
0.0252270885,
0.0455156825,
-0.0173003376,
0.0025441295,
-0.0041715079,
-0.0354939625,
0.015926756,
-0.0351616666,
-0.02650249,
0.033233311,
0.0249708463,
-0.0346639268,
-0.0207222085,
-0.1001928821,
-0.0344762243,
0.0044301203,
0.032890074,
0.0252870657,
-0.0673886016,
-0.0100061083,
-0.0645234212,
0.0415983945,
0.0103967031,
0.0048923348,
0.0233422387,
0.0250144377,
0.0277432986,
0.0174683016,
0.0507570915,
-0.0317529589,
0.0029969299,
-0.0291104,
0.0356875435,
0.0214710236,
-0.0566637516,
-0.0333346762,
-0.0118575357,
0.0358342268,
0.0284644775,
-0.0068707592,
-0.0254038833,
-0.0346231349,
0.00068328,
0.0101769892,
-0.020948736,
0.0397273898,
0.0419744663,
0.0098705636,
-0.0284844004,
-0.0420492403,
0.0376540907,
0.0250983592,
0.0361470729,
0.0045828084,
0.0684464276,
0.0020409857,
0.0188658368,
0.0000047459,
0.017807886,
0.0406546742,
-0.047950767,
0.0046475655,
0.0137273371,
-0.0139809148,
0.0087132612,
0.0443801247,
-0.0432377756,
-0.0339870751,
-0.0419642888,
-0.0361587182,
0.0339350775,
0.0545172729,
0.0492129959,
-0.0153813213,
-0.0287488364,
-0.0586563386,
0.0324817821,
-0.0618726462,
-0.0005262485,
0.0414031371,
0.0007195411,
0.0651634037,
0.0341453888,
-0.0297394749,
0.0332434587,
0.1064616144,
0.0391432866,
0.0404682793,
-0.0086643072,
0.0105209937,
0.0002452981,
-0.0227483734,
-0.0085315276,
0.062623024,
-0.0147848101,
0.0008905537,
-0.0623900779,
-0.0785096586,
0.0512571,
0.0482193641,
0.0364361554,
-0.0388865694,
-0.0131334038,
0.0231754575,
0.028330449,
0.0841590762,
-0.0194973573,
0.0040528127,
0.022192616,
-0.0425813235,
-0.0640372485,
-5.787802841e-33,
-0.0005208236,
-0.0362891108,
-0.0182884429,
0.00036432,
0.000751399,
0.0013607302,
-0.0751345009,
0.0061172331,
0.0049091089,
-0.0045943479,
-0.0100160707,
0.011444089,
-0.0107961213,
0.0634392872,
0.0196016002,
-0.033564344,
0.0084106578,
-0.0122964717,
-0.012254796,
-0.0148032494,
0.0298075639,
-0.0042387634,
0.0020674905,
-0.002084889,
0.054095082,
-0.0328285061,
0.0139145944,
0.0193766579,
0.0166836884,
0.0601851344,
-0.0570987612,
0.0464782342,
0.0217462536,
-0.0249299575,
-0.043022383,
0.0374984294,
-0.031395454,
-0.0671098754,
0.024824217,
-0.0105094984,
-0.0367903374,
-0.0204716288,
0.0944229215,
-0.0109945042,
0.0026827194,
0.0342154652,
0.0384346023,
-0.026436666,
-0.0421148092,
-0.0246015657,
0.0034682101,
0.0199374985,
0.0051512336,
0.0052977996,
-0.0018169596,
-0.0775924847,
-0.0206974093,
-0.0034348678,
-0.0372853316,
-0.0160202384,
-0.0123200761,
0.0780739561,
0.007277213,
0.0292966571,
0.0405320711,
0.0185784511,
0.0078599481,
-0.0049169217,
-0.0426555537,
-0.0027548771,
0.0085445615,
-0.0324786752,
0.0122347018,
0.0077500483,
0.0724958107,
-0.0169898272,
-0.0497505181,
-0.0156413279,
0.0614111274,
0.0190484896,
0.0148270745,
-0.018355025,
-0.0434652306,
-0.0494928397,
-0.0315036401,
-0.054845769,
-0.0148043027,
-0.0019920603,
0.0044659306,
-0.0067982334,
0.0417277776,
-0.02903907,
0.003299434,
-0.0384240188,
-0.0399357155,
0.0285892785,
0.0384190008,
0.0090898015,
0.0090247467,
-0.003768601,
-0.0344574116,
0.0104857897,
-0.0419702046,
-0.0095689883,
-0.0173800606,
0.0370152555,
0.0056524044,
0.0525389947,
-0.0436829291,
-0.0292068031,
-0.0266002063,
-0.0095789311,
0.0067868703,
0.1079482958,
0.052471526,
-0.0033393665,
0.0034380897,
-0.0069072768,
-0.0368016511,
-0.0340838507,
0.0274592452,
0.0562896654,
-0.0063678431,
0.0248730313,
-0.0578603521,
-0.0371565893,
-0.0365469046,
0.0308123063,
0.0502275452,
-0.0283649433,
0.0041348976,
0.0352412164,
2.447e-7,
0.0393321067,
-0.0215575099,
0.0870287046,
0.0152630387,
0.0749189034,
0.0054340744,
-0.0291298814,
0.0253592785,
-0.0141293639,
-0.0114031741,
-0.0139890034,
0.0314898267,
0.0061221118,
-0.0485383682,
-0.0956730992,
0.0088980114,
-0.0560766086,
0.0464701355,
0.0163883008,
-0.0111544151,
0.0099421712,
0.1214661077,
0.0368165337,
0.0159338526,
-0.0166142676,
-0.071547538,
0.0250891149,
0.0004072984,
0.0589746758,
0.0109112309,
0.0050291442,
0.0442732945,
-0.0050220885,
-0.0173539091,
0.0150747672,
0.0421727374,
-0.0143195605,
0.0483160615,
0.006338554,
-0.0014830215,
0.0078779738,
-0.035529878,
-0.0227333661,
0.0173294656,
0.017625941,
-0.0430732593,
-0.0498958565,
-0.0200928114,
0.0364203863,
0.0188602526,
-0.0154002048,
0.0468396656,
-0.0438450649,
-0.0083885035,
-0.0094421571,
-0.0407375768,
0.0326953903,
-0.0563824028,
-0.0071799424,
-0.0486420467,
-0.039762374,
-0.0017025096,
-0.05696382,
-0.0114316288,
0.0476205833,
-0.0444874056,
0.0124476273,
2.169516481e-34,
0.0390100814,
-0.029675357,
-0.0155545212,
-0.0079320744,
0.0122302175,
-0.0082981829,
-0.0225616377,
0.0307929944,
0.0375862941,
-0.0751975551,
-0.0523548834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05157v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05157v1 | MenatQA: A New Dataset for Testing the Temporal Comprehension and Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models | 2023-10-08T13:19:52 | 2023-10-08T13:19:52 | Yifan Wei, Yisong Su, Huanhuan Ma, Xiaoyan Yu, Fangyu Lei, Yuanzhe Zhang, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown nearly saturated performance on many
natural language processing (NLP) tasks. As a result, it is natural for people
to believe that LLMs have also mastered abilities such as time understanding
and reasoning. However, research on the temporal sensitivity of LLMs has been
insufficiently emphasized. To fill this gap, this paper constructs Multiple
Sensitive Factors Time QA (MenatQA), which encompasses three temporal factors
(scope factor, order factor, counterfactual factor) with total 2,853 samples
for evaluating the time comprehension and reasoning abilities of LLMs. This
paper tests current mainstream LLMs with different parameter sizes, ranging
from billions to hundreds of billions. The results show most LLMs fall behind
smaller temporal reasoning models with different degree on these factors. In
specific, LLMs show a significant vulnerability to temporal biases and depend
heavily on the temporal information provided in questions. Furthermore, this
paper undertakes a preliminary investigation into potential improvement
strategies by devising specific prompts and leveraging external tools. These
approaches serve as valuable baselines or references for future research
endeavors. | [
0.0641285405,
0.0398609899,
-0.036118947,
0.0236515775,
-0.0708724037,
0.0192711912,
0.0333594866,
-0.0011593457,
0.0103371851,
-0.0498161502,
0.0134154586,
-0.0455330387,
0.005991214,
0.0182741415,
-0.0194153767,
-0.0367369652,
0.076026313,
-0.0346224308,
0.0052416697,
0.0175875444,
-0.0286006872,
-0.007803069,
-0.0253636688,
0.0355197042,
0.043497216,
-0.0614221506,
-0.0173238441,
-0.0642810985,
0.0305750985,
-0.0570129864,
-0.0471055582,
0.0538599826,
0.0183415841,
0.0130623849,
0.0000021223,
-0.0634409189,
0.005978432,
-0.0163041037,
-0.0775191039,
0.0658035725,
0.017695304,
0.0236691032,
0.0255938023,
0.0123579688,
-0.0469678119,
-0.0013931742,
-0.0070873573,
0.0347554646,
0.0130916731,
0.0771158412,
-0.0005740356,
0.0137565937,
0.036364954,
0.0070802416,
0.020673655,
-0.104303807,
-0.002437656,
0.0175523236,
0.0469401926,
-0.0000931357,
-0.0150813852,
0.0428868197,
0.0324769616,
0.0054645617,
0.0039872508,
0.0332400762,
-0.0218004566,
0.003759858,
-0.0517671853,
0.0373114198,
0.0388519913,
-0.0241723191,
-0.0347738676,
-0.0023344003,
-0.0339675322,
0.0136473514,
-0.0576253533,
-0.0145494044,
0.0110799065,
-0.0071533723,
0.0381099023,
0.0370742232,
0.0264863595,
0.022144964,
0.0003009169,
0.1263446808,
0.0111106969,
-0.0309494324,
-0.0291396193,
-0.0140737826,
0.0057520717,
-0.0302620046,
-0.0096121049,
0.066950351,
-0.0210301522,
0.021706678,
0.013442643,
0.0363915414,
0.0301064998,
-0.0493194424,
-0.0097281458,
0.0542242303,
0.0203103106,
0.0624918826,
-0.0055340524,
0.0729635656,
-0.039664872,
-0.0260265563,
-0.0181993041,
-0.0103022167,
-0.0535914041,
-0.0343298353,
0.0446056575,
-0.027987808,
-0.0296751801,
0.0060098744,
-0.046725437,
0.0241144467,
0.0224028043,
-0.0350420848,
-0.0060534403,
0.0062298547,
0.0051036421,
-0.0236099642,
-0.0958645269,
0.030538151,
-0.0402313434,
0.0372933671,
-0.0382360332,
-0.0625430867,
-0.0110828821,
-0.0066327271,
0.0059134695,
-0.0481212512,
-0.0191615,
0.0432540588,
-0.0406843461,
-0.0290011801,
-0.0818329304,
-0.0309385154,
-0.0098292539,
-0.0432523303,
0.0085252123,
-0.0271487683,
0.0286217518,
0.0282689705,
-0.0154724717,
0.0273463484,
-0.0070640361,
0.0273581408,
-0.0130335633,
0.0626024455,
0.0588866286,
0.0752632096,
0.0199896153,
-0.0020598578,
0.0376607999,
0.0277772509,
0.0086545208,
-0.0389543027,
0.0234892052,
-0.0123133222,
-0.0223278999,
0.0318141617,
-0.0258880723,
-0.0131424908,
-0.0549981557,
0.0360443369,
-0.0156292375,
0.0341923684,
0.0273649711,
0.0261593778,
-0.0036835456,
-0.0285592694,
0.0412702523,
0.0243440233,
-0.0099054258,
-0.0022470665,
0.0678809434,
-0.0034834731,
0.0309769269,
-0.0262184385,
-0.0296742134,
0.0209438764,
-0.0067282529,
0.00508792,
-0.0338911377,
0.0199109856,
-0.0135628385,
-0.0341946371,
-0.038018357,
0.0491225831,
0.0112995422,
0.0254200418,
0.0442778543,
-0.0019497923,
-0.0391643159,
0.0500186384,
-0.0162501633,
0.0159922373,
-0.0076977485,
-0.0233559869,
0.0445721075,
0.0792864487,
0.0319680646,
-0.0316084735,
-0.0206936821,
-0.0004516008,
0.0147307087,
0.0266816113,
0.0691195652,
-0.0066306158,
-0.0267328508,
-0.0222469196,
0.0004840745,
-0.0039388603,
0.0205153152,
0.0104392357,
0.0343198255,
0.0522605777,
-0.0053884862,
-0.037691161,
0.0130396774,
0.0417593643,
-0.04559559,
-0.0437877364,
-0.0496160686,
0.0060356031,
0.0351478867,
0.017210193,
0.0086891726,
0.0217525158,
0.0187090877,
-0.0305031184,
-0.0013279316,
0.0350699238,
-0.0640674457,
-0.0263036229,
0.0202433337,
0.0129879676,
-0.0591484196,
0.0457412004,
-0.0098422179,
-0.0285585411,
0.0313543491,
0.0204157978,
0.0528718829,
-0.0260984693,
0.0331602171,
-0.0286022704,
0.0107927117,
-0.0448176228,
0.1064882651,
-0.0242936127,
0.0241720807,
0.0331927612,
0.0255318601,
0.0063799159,
-0.0163124427,
-0.0101610813,
0.0141231166,
-0.0070307055,
-0.0491142049,
-0.0180023666,
-0.0098468559,
-0.0874337181,
0.007667073,
-0.0830803066,
-0.0005070519,
-0.0071088034,
0.0301897954,
-0.001415252,
-0.0291155204,
-0.0085337441,
-0.0050542797,
-0.0023311754,
-0.009565453,
-0.0292657949,
0.0340013467,
0.0242017359,
0.0218381304,
-0.0075000823,
-0.016757613,
-0.0142426575,
-0.0602685325,
0.0708952993,
0.0171960723,
-0.0340646245,
0.0080499239,
0.0152071612,
-0.0159438923,
-0.0108235423,
-0.0165383201,
-0.0010506249,
0.0345594324,
-0.0046702311,
0.0568839237,
0.0776384473,
0.0158834476,
0.032921277,
0.0629280359,
-0.0129999062,
-0.0418868624,
0.0329378396,
-0.0141584827,
-0.0157227889,
-0.0203401446,
-0.0465013869,
-0.0269870367,
0.0791057348,
0.0112880245,
0.0222723763,
-0.0402976424,
0.031307511,
-0.0574925728,
-0.0335593186,
-0.0263072941,
0.009562985,
-0.0383433178,
0.05588153,
-0.0405366123,
-0.0280417483,
0.0411146022,
0.003626066,
0.0100290449,
0.0066344757,
-0.001217416,
-0.0531650111,
0.1187520474,
-0.0260265954,
-0.0198859945,
0.0120408535,
-0.0567855723,
-0.0538574159,
-0.0048067081,
0.0140060633,
-0.028633602,
0.0189314801,
-0.0511276498,
0.009690823,
0.0061859279,
0.0057717757,
-0.0455745347,
-0.0598726869,
-0.0568789467,
-0.0086340941,
-0.0485822149,
0.00971884,
-0.0511012971,
0.0215886123,
-0.0215356182,
-0.0052013132,
-0.0340610482,
-0.0092422226,
-0.013027248,
0.0341260396,
0.0375375412,
0.0377967954,
0.0329425931,
0.0037103361,
0.0543533899,
-0.0015548301,
0.0541651882,
-0.0227819923,
-0.0348292179,
0.0142074795,
-0.0060195136,
-0.029794218,
0.0055921515,
0.0296024326,
0.0464441031,
-0.0800043717,
-0.0020097862,
0.1217986941,
0.0851355568,
0.0149998683,
0.024453776,
-0.0518670119,
-0.0206855722,
0.0443214998,
-0.0040587028,
-0.0330036655,
-0.0315345004,
0.0069402074,
-0.0232838113,
-0.0447424576,
-0.0327108055,
-0.0281385202,
-0.1011660099,
0.0180135798,
-0.0085767899,
-0.0259849541,
0.0149819786,
-0.0197163858,
-0.0205958802,
-0.0110631548,
0.0409464054,
0.0258983485,
-0.0079767425,
0.0042877952,
0.0246661305,
-0.0203945711,
-0.0269799568,
0.1225327477,
0.0368364379,
0.0766336396,
0.0194154531,
0.0519211814,
-0.0150017422,
-0.0457606018,
0.0369560644,
-0.0051400536,
0.0203290805,
-0.026093822,
-0.0036948256,
0.0161141045,
-0.004475282,
-0.0444556214,
0.0106638446,
0.0152192889,
-0.0246746261,
0.019500386,
0.1132769734,
-0.016987294,
-0.0219869688,
-0.0356122069,
-0.0054955548,
-0.0357442833,
0.0671187788,
-0.0009190092,
-0.0257079117,
-0.0457446203,
0.0366855413,
-0.0401564278,
-0.0350648724,
-0.0596287921,
0.023379745,
0.0111426217,
-0.0019633877,
-0.0392820165,
-0.0508936569,
0.0016600949,
0.003602701,
-0.0023272731,
0.0224544164,
0.0235710833,
0.0211673938,
-0.0393209346,
0.0581027195,
0.0144715318,
0.0252657142,
-0.0413150713,
0.0256827045,
-0.0115880016,
-0.0123211397,
-0.0263799299,
0.0385144763,
-0.0723017529,
-0.0337934159,
0.0255106539,
-0.0276851989,
0.0212293826,
0.0097990287,
0.006449122,
-0.0346197635,
0.0151989637,
-0.0096710026,
-0.0516947247,
0.0182060264,
-0.0015864271,
0.0478614941,
0.0066164052,
0.0485932976,
-0.0279357694,
-0.0009490853,
-0.0329173617,
0.0546737053,
-0.0238280464,
0.0052620927,
0.0198990423,
0.0041881688,
0.0390111357,
0.0433459021,
-0.0093005123,
-0.0189552829,
-0.0028376842,
-0.0504692197,
-0.0032367599,
0.0063921185,
-0.0115117934,
0.0311165787,
-0.0119982939,
-0.045834966,
-0.031640403,
-0.0220515169,
0.0044329055,
-0.0211092588,
0.0300739128,
0.0037254416,
0.0222949609,
0.0038114316,
-0.0013646153,
-0.0314524509,
0.0020882387,
-0.0432804339,
0.0132912174,
0.0370383784,
0.0697853863,
-0.0229538605,
0.0329059735,
-0.050395973,
-0.0451187305,
-0.0923021212,
-0.0360064395,
0.0554846488,
-0.017203819,
0.0239390749,
-0.0612890832,
0.0561051629,
-0.0209370889,
0.0026424876,
-0.0052781664,
0.01450771,
0.0204672366,
-0.0254488532,
0.0544936396,
0.0205551814,
-0.0205408018,
0.0105168717,
0.0590778515,
0.0039984528,
0.0372636095,
0.0311348662,
-0.0397085436,
-0.0070034079,
-0.0366441123,
-0.0446016565,
-0.0091682049,
-0.0224778075,
0.0275619496,
-0.0936884955,
-0.0526034385,
0.0212923102,
-0.0064366572,
-0.0201433431,
-0.0098696351,
-0.0257959627,
0.0636426434,
0.0043674689,
-0.0712883025,
-0.0441515371,
0.0394305289,
0.0037595311,
-0.004586291,
-0.0572467856,
-7.045606776e-33,
0.0024030101,
-0.0529827699,
0.050862819,
-0.0474174619,
-0.0095696719,
0.0343280844,
-0.0411970578,
0.0162044,
-0.038880147,
-0.0078082699,
-0.0289870705,
0.0379670896,
0.0264494438,
-0.014508714,
0.0204944555,
-0.0162306018,
0.0177613292,
-0.0094469553,
0.0158183929,
-0.0039295997,
0.0438900404,
0.0025583149,
0.0305315927,
-0.0223696139,
0.0347774103,
0.01371428,
0.0099537093,
0.0426503196,
-0.0245833825,
0.0698155165,
-0.018752018,
0.0300472435,
0.0568059273,
-0.0688124374,
0.0093723191,
0.0319196731,
-0.0746832639,
-0.045693554,
0.0660174564,
0.0201465804,
-0.0066125565,
-0.0306104496,
0.0007888292,
0.0139418291,
-0.016583873,
-0.0295136403,
0.0354877114,
-0.0294792186,
-0.0045184125,
-0.0088615539,
-0.0543527827,
0.0507101938,
-0.0422078893,
0.0020319726,
0.0060445252,
0.0784855485,
-0.011762402,
0.0157945715,
-0.0520889089,
0.0162241962,
0.003293151,
-0.014843354,
0.0634623468,
0.0023098532,
0.0198052227,
0.0298694558,
-0.0054207523,
0.0235695932,
-0.0081105046,
0.006977716,
0.0223513488,
0.0132874865,
0.0262083635,
0.0002849284,
0.0202160273,
-0.0283231214,
-0.059951257,
-0.0148735251,
0.0418818556,
0.0546653271,
0.0471102186,
-0.0065684421,
-0.0461860336,
0.0204654466,
-0.0583490729,
0.0450609289,
-0.0522338971,
0.0167987701,
0.0674237758,
-0.0176350307,
0.0207633674,
-0.0298880544,
0.0360758416,
-0.0250182766,
0.0098348092,
-0.0046280306,
-0.0277991816,
0.0130547592,
-0.0008128168,
0.0598946139,
-0.0596715473,
0.0084235314,
-0.010315055,
-0.0161936358,
0.0209151898,
-0.037994571,
-0.0209657513,
0.0020946395,
-0.0431658626,
-0.0390692651,
-0.0134824365,
-0.0032706119,
0.0064945957,
-0.0158425961,
0.0712559223,
-0.0038140374,
-0.0302415006,
0.0291132275,
0.0052381586,
-0.0011174395,
-0.0067904321,
0.0049391291,
-0.0118389493,
0.0110087227,
-0.0358082466,
-0.0217027217,
-0.0335000753,
0.0403842181,
0.0323714167,
-0.0197219104,
-0.0122927679,
0.0368964598,
2.805e-7,
0.038594421,
0.0714368299,
-0.0288009718,
0.0740398094,
0.0259210113,
0.0041018766,
-0.0158144161,
-0.015842475,
-0.005478208,
0.0399984121,
0.0275656153,
0.0212673172,
0.0323522687,
0.005013566,
-0.0046889419,
-0.0214313474,
-0.0557546839,
0.0089400345,
-0.0849320516,
0.0113283107,
0.0376838036,
0.0703144372,
0.0066408399,
0.0146850646,
-0.0265986361,
-0.0460104011,
0.0352526642,
-0.0272372477,
-0.045349218,
0.0117634237,
0.0506873205,
0.0186633412,
0.0055796816,
0.0410776399,
-0.0099390764,
0.0172253326,
-0.0185322203,
0.0436532199,
-0.020928964,
-0.0450086556,
-0.0302713234,
-0.0346151404,
-0.0195910893,
-0.0739937425,
0.1133350953,
-0.047274556,
-0.0836199373,
-0.029315332,
0.0077571399,
0.0191032011,
0.0368097164,
0.0448891334,
0.0020699149,
-0.0099138012,
0.0148954354,
-0.0368112139,
-0.0240055677,
-0.0783887804,
-0.0227874983,
0.0395646654,
-0.0237707626,
-0.0314909704,
-0.0696371496,
-0.0239257887,
0.0473555513,
-0.040491119,
0.0029813386,
2.326907368e-34,
0.0211272985,
0.0129446648,
0.0132474294,
0.021487033,
0.0389671102,
0.0068071131,
-0.0052532642,
0.0028002658,
0.0283092521,
-0.0930910185,
-0.010020596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05155v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05155v2 | Toolink: Linking Toolkit Creation and Using through Chain-of-Solving on Open-Source Model | 2023-10-08T13:07:42 | 2024-03-18T03:19:33 | Cheng Qian, Chenyan Xiong, Zhenghao Liu, Zhiyuan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable progress in
utilizing tools, but their closed-source nature and high inference costs pose
limitations on their adaptability, necessitating a valid method that leverages
smaller, open-sourced models. In this paper, we introduce Toolink, a
comprehensive framework that performs task-solving by first creating a toolkit
and then integrating the planning and calling of tools through a
chain-of-solving (CoS) approach. We first validate the efficacy of Toolink in
harnessing the model's creativity and CoS ability on ChatGPT. Subsequently, we
curate CoS-GPT, a chain-of-solving dataset designed for tool-using, and
finetune the LLaMA-7B model. It results in LLaMA-CoS, a powerful open-source
model with advanced tool-planning and tool-calling capabilities. Evaluation of
diverse tasks from BIG-bench demonstrates its CoS ability matches that of
ChatGPT while its performance surpasses the chain-of-thought approach. Further
studies highlight the generalization of LLaMA-CoS to unseen tasks and showcase
its capability in using toolkits not explicitly tailored for the target task,
affirming its robustness in real-world scenarios. | [
0.031892553,
0.0196988713,
-0.0115016568,
0.0396926887,
-0.0741247684,
0.0134116402,
-0.0083682025,
-0.0168670844,
0.0277141444,
-0.0193173699,
-0.028958369,
0.0189581905,
-0.0159824658,
0.0351614878,
0.0261001848,
-0.0360435136,
0.0387196131,
-0.0522485971,
-0.053587202,
0.0145056648,
0.0089998981,
0.0442998484,
-0.0221748818,
0.0696647614,
-0.0006130866,
-0.0374367908,
-0.0158986244,
-0.015419106,
-0.0111879166,
0.0120818587,
0.0253672898,
0.0602206811,
-0.001334963,
0.0767086372,
0.0000021217,
-0.0581557378,
-0.0186029244,
-0.0074253194,
-0.0455578715,
-0.0087219207,
0.0207903609,
-0.0105784787,
-0.0051624542,
0.0407281592,
-0.0310228486,
-0.0117704598,
0.0197022483,
-0.0009000135,
0.0521734357,
0.0633849129,
0.010668844,
-0.0050114514,
0.0355030745,
-0.0022233794,
-0.0148771694,
-0.0310057532,
-0.0034414607,
0.0244481917,
0.0685361922,
-0.0103151705,
0.0073096682,
0.0530897379,
0.0559801161,
-0.0183721092,
-0.0014678866,
0.0229049679,
-0.0462420732,
-0.0253099781,
-0.025520036,
0.0740738958,
-0.0352451913,
-0.0559843108,
0.0109482519,
-0.0078619383,
-0.0072672758,
0.0236411337,
-0.0822551921,
0.0323544331,
-0.0106518744,
0.0019811152,
0.0343845114,
-0.0424131304,
0.0251826793,
0.022266278,
0.0079065822,
0.0930858552,
0.0043117148,
-0.000681011,
-0.0084011676,
-0.0139722992,
-0.0106038749,
-0.1040940657,
0.0160605237,
0.0497276112,
-0.037543565,
0.0182480291,
-0.0138563653,
-0.0086524803,
-0.0072363247,
-0.0387190729,
0.0286987685,
0.0585595444,
-0.0492602624,
0.0542686284,
-0.0268002339,
0.0227130894,
-0.0249137636,
0.0278989989,
-0.0591300651,
-0.0164621808,
-0.0683715418,
-0.0118704848,
-0.0399455503,
-0.0023917225,
-0.0472160578,
-0.0156201152,
0.0024848748,
0.0215393286,
0.0097884759,
-0.0083866473,
0.0734349564,
-0.0059652003,
-0.0074640214,
-0.0323983543,
-0.0111592775,
0.0321620591,
-0.021335816,
0.0167633258,
0.002154574,
-0.0553785078,
-0.0302003026,
0.0336270221,
-0.0151125407,
-0.0427425019,
0.0220625643,
0.0765741542,
-0.000882406,
0.0142419683,
-0.0273897089,
-0.0422767252,
0.0206863545,
-0.0864669308,
0.0088951439,
-0.0997870639,
0.0388969854,
0.0353565849,
-0.0265596062,
-0.0133427307,
0.0005831989,
0.0094986968,
-0.0418542996,
0.0316887684,
0.002258728,
0.0372751951,
0.012555683,
0.028061159,
-0.015111126,
0.0887825936,
0.0154333273,
0.0363185517,
0.0171956234,
0.0077111381,
0.00522384,
0.0820306614,
0.0075230571,
-0.0065017659,
-0.001545281,
0.0175384339,
0.0131090991,
0.03522842,
0.0028916148,
0.0199763142,
-0.0083510811,
0.0041698855,
0.0389848277,
0.0476986505,
0.0281209871,
0.0209450461,
0.0375347696,
0.0004099464,
0.0260615926,
-0.0092684347,
-0.0623013191,
0.0439279713,
-0.0486448854,
0.0059864554,
-0.0347380564,
0.0468502454,
-0.0160138961,
-0.0083119702,
-0.0316288918,
0.0089173382,
-0.0478678122,
0.0073029716,
0.0687606484,
0.0103576425,
-0.0637196079,
0.051071465,
0.0184022803,
-0.035119459,
-0.0189266726,
-0.0737359151,
0.0361621678,
0.0441655815,
0.0933814943,
-0.0162673686,
-0.0592269339,
0.0128047522,
0.0091505367,
0.0050096069,
0.0031219574,
-0.0319899879,
-0.0265614036,
-0.0531720705,
-0.0366915129,
-0.0178658646,
-0.0017494326,
0.0059560551,
0.0730287805,
-0.0216675904,
0.0028954546,
-0.0336359106,
0.0124879144,
0.0298643708,
-0.0403266177,
0.0042401985,
-0.0292932484,
-0.0102750789,
0.023559466,
0.0075526144,
-0.007901663,
0.0233792048,
0.0075369631,
-0.0370031185,
-0.0220537819,
0.0333312266,
-0.0058367318,
-0.0214230902,
0.0532400794,
-0.0056619048,
-0.0183926541,
0.0451481119,
-0.0329745412,
-0.043036662,
0.0469496734,
0.0229027607,
0.0221941471,
-0.0332311802,
0.0134432176,
-0.0066009471,
0.0142216654,
-0.0183383562,
0.0593570881,
-0.0036663136,
-0.0120374784,
0.005381023,
-0.0096407318,
0.0094481688,
0.0051034181,
-0.0195293445,
0.0147669548,
-0.0192254968,
0.018460039,
-0.0261033121,
0.0489561148,
-0.0505426824,
-0.0340412334,
-0.1009349972,
0.0468200892,
-0.0264055207,
0.03289859,
0.0429341011,
0.0158311799,
-0.0198817179,
0.0065802792,
0.0089390287,
0.0029774855,
0.0354421213,
0.0109678786,
-0.0210549571,
0.0044644009,
-0.0271244291,
-0.0377115496,
-0.0270205289,
-0.0253470633,
0.0141454851,
-0.0244685821,
-0.0262375623,
-0.0224614963,
0.0588750541,
-0.039227277,
0.0321328416,
0.0012259572,
-0.0283444468,
0.0032957667,
-0.0288171619,
0.0347009264,
0.0272093359,
-0.0660012811,
0.0114523116,
0.0490030646,
-0.055390168,
-0.0480319187,
0.0161747336,
0.000640211,
-0.0541817434,
-0.0021662044,
-0.0158801135,
-0.0352323428,
0.072751075,
-0.0049164467,
-0.0162093043,
-0.0272899065,
-0.0050172615,
-0.0259865317,
-0.0163448397,
-0.037107259,
-0.005263187,
-0.0094470978,
0.0541633479,
-0.0247364715,
-0.0650134087,
0.0581410192,
-0.0396570787,
-0.0298867188,
-0.0205629002,
-0.0115396446,
-0.054103259,
0.0791271329,
0.0017162887,
-0.0035819649,
0.010773873,
0.0239083488,
-0.0602451526,
0.0076985061,
0.0116790989,
-0.0183813069,
0.0370880365,
-0.0751130432,
0.0217993036,
-0.0277368613,
-0.0329276584,
-0.02427461,
0.0101368101,
-0.0516011454,
0.0411011875,
0.0125009511,
-0.0263656639,
-0.0016984293,
0.0176156685,
0.0295780059,
0.0530542023,
-0.011321051,
0.0098958574,
-0.0281225089,
0.0371537358,
0.0269724522,
0.0154515589,
0.0258725453,
0.0243768822,
0.0018758698,
0.0335509591,
0.0842791125,
-0.0218319949,
-0.0268864259,
0.0058638873,
0.0261757318,
-0.0109589715,
-0.0302522648,
0.0073408908,
0.001463468,
-0.0715978891,
-0.0084782531,
0.0902970731,
0.0442655906,
-0.0171918944,
0.0017348808,
-0.0338837169,
0.0467204675,
0.0310044456,
0.0629041716,
-0.1086938381,
-0.0401900858,
0.0298744738,
-0.0133827785,
0.0014097195,
-0.0424705222,
-0.006574037,
-0.1270311028,
0.0701902658,
-0.0058246362,
-0.012823523,
0.0303254295,
-0.0295812208,
0.000005735,
-0.0135235991,
-0.0344586149,
0.0325026214,
0.0027123124,
0.0031297861,
0.0083056139,
-0.0180691201,
-0.0391125493,
0.0533213392,
-0.0081138993,
0.0508751795,
0.0526234657,
0.0039028267,
0.0176869612,
0.0044689425,
0.0733454525,
0.0152357295,
-0.0017111676,
-0.0421550311,
-0.0008774138,
0.0351459719,
-0.0311060473,
-0.0140416119,
0.038939476,
-0.0664805472,
-0.022247212,
0.0088410256,
0.1240050867,
0.0120225521,
0.0048765633,
-0.0073830192,
-0.0148417866,
0.0043386826,
0.0722181201,
0.0162829086,
-0.0046882583,
-0.0570673905,
-0.0146662993,
-0.0723783076,
-0.0381022617,
-0.0422666222,
0.0037300976,
0.0185355842,
0.0042553442,
-0.0451867878,
-0.014906547,
0.0807258561,
0.0338610187,
0.0063048182,
0.011612298,
-0.0144284563,
0.012747433,
-0.0532413796,
0.0548315048,
-0.0446330756,
0.0479274727,
-0.0554277599,
-0.0072137839,
0.0058469982,
-0.0311214924,
-0.0300737675,
0.0798593611,
-0.0956809968,
-0.0805565864,
-0.0231833663,
0.0525396951,
0.0329270773,
-0.004351771,
-0.0356223285,
-0.0690134093,
-0.0033599357,
0.0180877037,
-0.0460611284,
0.0151998196,
0.0002613218,
0.002175834,
0.0141989039,
0.0573895872,
-0.026928518,
0.0116462214,
-0.0114140166,
0.0449244715,
0.0112531912,
-0.0108233867,
0.0198245235,
0.0089315288,
0.0002073371,
-0.0043027131,
0.0016964788,
-0.0512052998,
0.010932982,
0.0079992712,
-0.0286024734,
-0.0541864373,
0.0319328643,
-0.0041356781,
-0.0331503972,
0.0465668589,
0.0413229167,
-0.0108750686,
0.0375149995,
-0.0292301197,
0.0255709048,
0.0048380508,
-0.0106144156,
0.0517643988,
0.0048326422,
0.007096719,
-0.0013370338,
-0.0099177444,
0.0251122862,
-0.0446523279,
0.054711245,
-0.0106684584,
0.001271881,
-0.0258469116,
0.0096533829,
-0.0453054048,
-0.0923136473,
-0.0131183518,
0.0420768075,
0.0494043976,
-0.0003836663,
0.0418998413,
-0.0342052542,
-0.0291761048,
-0.0263204239,
0.036513079,
-0.0223678257,
0.0072379969,
0.0132132825,
0.0332190096,
-0.0062994771,
-0.019296946,
0.0746774748,
0.0038336201,
0.0677730292,
0.0329863392,
-0.0053141695,
-0.0267344415,
-0.087491788,
0.0125210667,
-0.0208762176,
-0.004297575,
-0.0123283574,
-0.0599432662,
-0.0757707581,
-0.0300654359,
0.0299133975,
-0.028805064,
0.0087295976,
0.038723316,
0.0534380488,
0.0024895836,
0.0014745718,
-0.0203163102,
0.0020405066,
-0.0244342424,
-0.0498336479,
0.017009465,
-6.501152322e-33,
-0.037999481,
-0.0148455249,
0.0708317012,
0.0105824936,
0.0085927872,
-0.0017308508,
-0.0605065115,
0.0177145433,
-0.0267144721,
-0.006016131,
-0.0253232084,
0.0048045437,
0.0195381306,
-0.0155448718,
0.0338896886,
0.0144652966,
0.0135340327,
-0.0162217598,
-0.0148709556,
0.0226439666,
0.036159277,
0.0162734948,
0.0796296895,
-0.0434899032,
-0.0218098275,
0.0012590275,
-0.0059510386,
0.0531231202,
-0.0224873014,
0.0685856119,
-0.0095344158,
0.0111139277,
0.0284881331,
-0.0176210888,
-0.0172031987,
-0.013590402,
-0.0759487003,
-0.000371987,
0.0676520541,
0.0002871467,
-0.0266069919,
-0.0216582045,
0.016061997,
0.0097234854,
-0.0147947129,
-0.015141163,
-0.0093061738,
-0.0036323436,
0.0134969084,
0.0289405994,
-0.0476756766,
0.0215399843,
-0.0122262388,
-0.0732238889,
0.0211227704,
0.0278394837,
-0.0053708507,
-0.024969833,
-0.0088213477,
0.0096946107,
0.0177226979,
0.0394698977,
0.1307920963,
0.0035869335,
-0.0037080259,
0.0093726972,
0.0098666614,
-0.0546776243,
-0.0429686755,
-0.0072168764,
0.0179292113,
0.0771258622,
0.0408692248,
0.011277698,
-0.0161174778,
0.0307197962,
-0.0417146049,
0.019888781,
0.0443661436,
0.0563776195,
0.0250911154,
0.0395642146,
-0.0140493792,
-0.0261089206,
-0.0234614667,
-0.0323365517,
-0.0580786914,
-0.01543645,
0.0393375307,
0.00167328,
-0.0064287852,
0.0003841332,
0.0557957925,
-0.0301778894,
0.0235622469,
0.047241699,
-0.0186544005,
0.0645415112,
-0.0030532104,
0.0426783375,
-0.0796066746,
-0.0107771866,
-0.0057874243,
0.0097056227,
0.0239041299,
0.0090233218,
0.003998389,
0.0465768166,
-0.0308980849,
0.0132430783,
-0.085643433,
0.0482738838,
-0.0009820557,
0.0294817388,
0.0277373958,
-0.0231721736,
0.0045996555,
0.0157967415,
0.0104541024,
-0.0315472782,
-0.0317447148,
0.0152570475,
0.0006405815,
-0.0189771932,
-0.0185434502,
0.0192087032,
-0.0295977872,
-0.0076242108,
0.0475389101,
-0.0194223709,
-0.0017486572,
0.0096600503,
2.843e-7,
0.0257984046,
0.0294571463,
0.0129547147,
0.0419913195,
0.0179419238,
0.0108237956,
-0.0193849038,
0.01049239,
0.0009064788,
-0.0222426355,
-0.0275537167,
0.0352280848,
0.0747354031,
0.0348397866,
-0.0699904934,
0.0199802089,
-0.0409398712,
-0.0126010301,
-0.0651037619,
-0.0360505283,
-0.009546035,
0.0794511288,
0.0308675524,
-0.0273058806,
-0.0235194676,
-0.0584028848,
0.021753788,
-0.026880661,
-0.0173957441,
0.0291939825,
-0.0255872346,
0.0472544096,
0.0091093844,
0.0011460355,
0.0039280262,
0.0038662504,
0.0341370292,
0.0691854358,
0.0202461053,
0.000084651,
0.0093084397,
-0.0576505102,
-0.0133040212,
-0.0782552883,
0.0747539252,
-0.0334932208,
-0.0035658635,
-0.0434352048,
0.0614212342,
-0.0173447039,
-0.048425585,
-0.0357333235,
0.0390242785,
0.0339613222,
0.0172498599,
-0.0277254023,
-0.0376240537,
-0.0589050911,
-0.0624318756,
0.0283775777,
-0.0404927433,
-0.0529400408,
-0.0466754287,
-0.0090253651,
-0.0232953597,
-0.0393357389,
-0.0157622732,
2.996602112e-34,
0.0167513359,
0.0283160415,
0.0080855284,
0.0633762851,
0.0326324701,
-0.0223015174,
-0.008784323,
0.0191763248,
-0.0152001129,
-0.087018691,
-0.0432209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05150v1 | From Data to Dialogue: Leveraging the Structure of Knowledge Graphs for Conversational Exploratory Search | 2023-10-08T12:52:09 | 2023-10-08T12:52:09 | Phillip Schneider, Nils Rehtanz, Kristiina Jokinen, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Exploratory search is an open-ended information retrieval process that aims
at discovering knowledge about a topic or domain rather than searching for a
specific answer or piece of information. Conversational interfaces are
particularly suitable for supporting exploratory search, allowing users to
refine queries and examine search results through interactive dialogues. In
addition to conversational search interfaces, knowledge graphs are also useful
in supporting information exploration due to their rich semantic representation
of data items. In this study, we demonstrate the synergistic effects of
combining knowledge graphs and conversational interfaces for exploratory
search, bridging the gap between structured and unstructured information
retrieval. To this end, we propose a knowledge-driven dialogue system for
exploring news articles by asking natural language questions and using the
graph structure to navigate between related topics. Based on a user study with
54 participants, we empirically evaluate the effectiveness of the graph-based
exploratory search and discuss design implications for developing such systems. | [
0.0538736358,
-0.0072419345,
-0.0229358934,
0.0422666743,
0.0077875829,
-0.0217876993,
-0.0100721149,
0.0154392375,
0.0638866723,
-0.0023103647,
0.0022863613,
0.052477777,
-0.0292395409,
0.0485461876,
-0.0341779888,
-0.0558512546,
0.015808858,
-0.0167246368,
0.0605810434,
0.0423717797,
0.0675491616,
-0.0043260683,
-0.0297076553,
0.010761152,
0.0069964896,
0.0202919561,
-0.07369975,
0.0333244689,
-0.0424180999,
-0.0624912865,
-0.0143840443,
0.039206855,
0.0292569734,
0.0274085663,
0.0000018932,
-0.0131016402,
-0.006801208,
-0.0102234818,
-0.0444832183,
-0.0286076516,
0.0137398383,
0.0241433941,
0.0705989003,
-0.0020744826,
-0.0209144857,
-0.0521039739,
0.0231583379,
0.0249350686,
0.0285774451,
0.0346795209,
-0.0103208218,
-0.0140804686,
-0.0391413458,
0.0150937466,
0.0393886305,
-0.031800095,
-0.0057000918,
0.0293366648,
0.068419978,
0.0432783067,
0.0137044666,
0.0305089317,
-0.0527644493,
-0.0544244982,
0.0433485769,
0.0169317443,
0.0029934444,
-0.0214364734,
0.0139603335,
0.0762623996,
0.0468244851,
0.0010351806,
-0.015969608,
0.0021228192,
0.0190783329,
0.0767012835,
-0.0657919273,
-0.0397148021,
-0.0746671706,
-0.0444010571,
-0.0463654064,
-0.0301141609,
0.0408207141,
-0.0285014249,
0.0082702413,
0.0584277511,
-0.0097567951,
-0.0198468976,
0.0485480353,
-0.0378192216,
0.034872219,
-0.0388192274,
0.0130378185,
0.0312500559,
-0.0585030355,
0.0363324806,
0.0131278792,
-0.0110771386,
0.0063277022,
-0.0512819141,
-0.0316497758,
0.0062715104,
0.0175415017,
0.0380992219,
0.0701017231,
-0.0062455097,
0.0278605558,
-0.0036987497,
-0.0203047264,
-0.03009497,
-0.0391884483,
-0.021357961,
-0.051052317,
0.0316968001,
-0.078293696,
-0.0445500053,
0.0478779078,
0.0670455098,
0.0514311716,
-0.0044156788,
-0.0212941058,
0.0297300536,
-0.0033992035,
0.0356643535,
-0.0809834078,
0.0193242077,
-0.0422136001,
-0.0145997461,
0.0297656506,
-0.0014917394,
0.0118577555,
0.0121279554,
0.0347784162,
0.0171210691,
-0.0387926586,
0.03878396,
0.0057762191,
-0.0135589931,
-0.0087120878,
-0.0576686598,
0.0191675611,
0.0207913946,
0.0204465128,
-0.0308019705,
0.0306973886,
0.0290895235,
-0.0282005519,
-0.0059473459,
0.028999323,
0.0588189848,
-0.0486795045,
0.0534133688,
-0.068847008,
0.0066142534,
0.0514785051,
0.0160463825,
-0.0050061783,
0.0470634401,
-0.0177385937,
-0.0124185551,
0.0622513816,
0.0185333509,
0.0022417654,
-0.0381734483,
0.0159195308,
-0.0224714689,
0.0452485159,
0.0526588075,
-0.0629555732,
0.0639596358,
-0.0376443416,
0.0185111426,
-0.0496327095,
0.0055291206,
0.0364632085,
0.0524312928,
0.0268573277,
0.0032993956,
-0.0213701557,
0.0366933271,
0.0217031091,
-0.0008188374,
0.0150769763,
0.0287941545,
0.0097118812,
-0.006785973,
0.0266595371,
-0.0454477668,
-0.0012616327,
-0.0238827504,
-0.0064510829,
0.0643311813,
0.08681494,
0.030934263,
0.0151721425,
-0.0084109828,
-0.0183351971,
0.0189974457,
0.0125565054,
-0.0542428195,
-0.0384889022,
-0.0081855105,
0.0251066424,
0.1048851311,
0.056045223,
0.0092138341,
-0.0871033296,
0.0436269157,
0.0189627707,
0.0209303331,
0.0479516238,
-0.0100564966,
-0.0172011312,
-0.0222316813,
-0.04035528,
-0.0426871926,
-0.0242075864,
-0.0069802389,
-0.0108018657,
0.0138929049,
0.0099313268,
-0.0721744224,
-0.0083134398,
-0.0079035638,
0.0284846202,
0.0210334118,
-0.0170330442,
0.0238079038,
-0.0446710363,
0.0504369475,
0.0183510017,
0.0345933586,
0.0386435129,
0.0441262275,
-0.0276606642,
0.018667357,
0.0023869111,
-0.0415422283,
-0.0064215492,
-0.074671939,
0.0224581938,
-0.0516540669,
0.0212515555,
-0.0648207366,
0.0086164251,
-0.0780516043,
0.0543684661,
0.0009885576,
-0.0150659867,
0.0005266346,
-0.036466483,
-0.0402358621,
0.038013313,
0.0277979914,
0.0064422851,
0.0252629351,
-0.0187683273,
0.0340098962,
-0.0833740979,
-0.0056956154,
0.0283918139,
0.0401642881,
-0.0032672917,
0.0336249918,
-0.0253037568,
-0.0596080907,
0.0467903167,
-0.1429770589,
0.0182072949,
-0.0123502668,
0.0148051977,
0.0032234755,
0.0604805462,
-0.001355189,
-0.0568879284,
-0.0459004678,
0.0298010018,
0.0257810727,
-0.0028950344,
0.0205214024,
0.0603003092,
0.0209580492,
-0.0399042107,
-0.0041638375,
0.0073397141,
0.0320086107,
0.0551161468,
-0.0136334384,
-0.0015193347,
0.0113709634,
-0.0670185909,
0.0269407537,
-0.0034438979,
0.0249235332,
0.0542183407,
-0.0115963705,
-0.010782415,
0.0134295272,
0.0093440143,
0.0571854897,
-0.0137627013,
-0.0744566321,
-0.0454896986,
0.0307929907,
-0.0185263157,
0.0357889719,
-0.0376531184,
0.0259419326,
0.0419996791,
-0.046788957,
0.0075555826,
0.0359322354,
0.0015485159,
0.0156931859,
0.0493892804,
0.0346974283,
-0.0538260378,
-0.03369838,
0.0372779779,
0.0303478353,
-0.0421380103,
0.0189181343,
0.0393993296,
0.008896335,
0.0160932075,
-0.042498868,
-0.005929362,
-0.0228734333,
0.0506504439,
-0.0403543897,
0.0106262658,
-0.0085083209,
-0.0362551771,
-0.0105197988,
-0.0019207292,
0.0520844534,
-0.0422029383,
0.0376712009,
-0.0468677431,
0.0019846861,
0.0681369305,
-0.0319607817,
-0.0049064355,
-0.0169249792,
-0.0124571472,
-0.0319936574,
0.0585824177,
-0.0438232943,
-0.0178797264,
0.0054876716,
0.0337609649,
0.0149124879,
0.0089203389,
-0.0362544246,
0.0140696764,
0.0274609383,
0.0134260803,
0.0150560625,
-0.0074906871,
0.0128429858,
0.0591453239,
0.0385828242,
-0.0171354022,
-0.0449883342,
-0.0060344609,
-0.0434194952,
0.0006882665,
-0.039818164,
-0.041383516,
-0.0466154031,
0.0139091378,
-0.032526195,
-0.0054063275,
0.0779216588,
0.0484155677,
-0.0464545824,
-0.0255410131,
-0.0163221583,
0.0205449015,
0.0264045242,
0.0349955559,
-0.0759801492,
-0.011536994,
0.0081103016,
0.0332502238,
0.0006877769,
-0.0533351116,
0.007734139,
-0.0737841576,
-0.0163881108,
-0.0383887477,
-0.0058947732,
-0.0233014487,
-0.0534373745,
0.0311618112,
0.0307312757,
-0.0532089584,
0.0275013652,
-0.025555402,
0.0092352778,
-0.0265698433,
0.0008534607,
0.0297893472,
0.0104987659,
-0.0020180393,
-0.0311340243,
0.0131081445,
0.0563759059,
0.0365057178,
0.01655633,
0.0027366364,
0.0405020267,
0.0079473229,
-0.0287586041,
0.0599132702,
-0.0117795132,
0.0124068568,
-0.0959877297,
-0.0192913692,
0.0261292998,
0.009313331,
0.0070753004,
0.0039513567,
-0.0590262711,
0.0208170731,
-0.0271678194,
-0.0125202518,
0.0255384371,
0.0218263846,
0.0227130633,
0.0119557753,
-0.0140733952,
-0.0586250648,
0.0212005507,
-0.0147649264,
-0.0127071002,
0.0333917476,
0.0081351642,
0.0383603536,
-0.0657213181,
-0.0332479142,
0.0076367864,
-0.003232735,
-0.0068270727,
-0.0164981876,
0.0338356979,
0.0331171304,
-0.0366404392,
-0.01049913,
0.0100880964,
-0.007385286,
0.0222218428,
-0.0311575066,
-0.0014309206,
-0.0145647796,
-0.0113281878,
0.0390692726,
-0.0328155719,
-0.0148505419,
-0.0561944246,
-0.0422002897,
0.0089017618,
0.0406072997,
-0.0240678806,
-0.0300158691,
0.015858341,
0.0278519765,
-0.0331967324,
-0.0720930099,
-0.0424749143,
0.0343023799,
0.0271420237,
0.0187587682,
-0.056527026,
-0.0411319658,
-0.0660452619,
0.0207405183,
-0.0508180782,
-0.0897071436,
0.0245146174,
0.0386512019,
0.020571094,
0.0607388951,
0.0000811044,
-0.0387795232,
0.0207553171,
-0.0470020436,
-0.018383665,
-0.0146248229,
0.024649011,
-0.0447554551,
-0.0340581387,
0.0194175746,
0.0319190584,
0.006075101,
0.0458214767,
-0.0520914048,
0.0113669354,
0.0406871252,
-0.0594010167,
0.0091570383,
0.0159337427,
0.0079631107,
0.048359517,
0.0194543507,
0.023364082,
-0.0254326165,
0.0525948852,
0.0170540437,
-0.0859459862,
0.0109100221,
-0.0077447486,
-0.1061282456,
-0.0771885291,
0.0201622043,
0.0278598107,
-0.0159495939,
0.0097447205,
-0.0318413712,
-0.0346032381,
0.015527335,
0.0241133012,
0.014507249,
0.0008339454,
-0.026202511,
0.0400704183,
0.0351421498,
0.0091899773,
-0.02696459,
0.0215618536,
0.0018630192,
0.0108902752,
-0.006154879,
-0.0943030491,
-0.036982365,
-0.0129683539,
0.0254095141,
0.0639649555,
-0.0041900668,
0.0004130093,
-0.0108525129,
-0.0077864863,
-0.015383576,
-0.0093392562,
0.0043680239,
-0.0137317507,
0.0884494931,
0.0937716067,
0.0254277755,
-0.0464204289,
-0.0353521518,
0.0371440649,
-0.1013414264,
-0.0093134735,
-0.0171976183,
-5.562247883e-33,
-0.0200640429,
-0.0564659312,
0.0211376511,
0.0330674127,
-0.0162343178,
-0.0541192628,
-0.0432922468,
0.0203937534,
-0.0358870998,
0.0169611499,
-0.005946904,
0.0291418713,
-0.0119235935,
-0.0097781038,
-0.0379189178,
-0.021319123,
0.0441208817,
0.003513423,
0.0073291869,
0.0351716094,
0.0786813125,
0.0221219063,
-0.012999271,
-0.0775702745,
0.0419572592,
-0.0053269151,
0.0454149097,
0.042573493,
0.02641958,
0.0311019234,
0.0110522015,
0.0597018786,
0.0165586211,
0.0096277352,
-0.0120943878,
0.0145757897,
-0.0751166195,
-0.0348945074,
0.0408515334,
0.031733308,
-0.0391739756,
0.0244698264,
0.0578521974,
0.0045456644,
0.0453977399,
0.0259468351,
0.0287670512,
0.0264132358,
-0.0461463332,
-0.0228363704,
-0.0052934019,
0.0070398925,
-0.0418500267,
-0.0202906393,
-0.0231021233,
0.015548626,
0.0382639654,
-0.0392700657,
-0.0079207877,
0.0388649777,
-0.0035478091,
0.0212332886,
0.0017346402,
0.026260037,
0.0071647875,
0.0373558626,
-0.0124686491,
0.0139924996,
-0.0247154422,
0.0315902941,
0.004771708,
0.0449118279,
-0.0029477908,
0.0309157986,
-0.0199447274,
-0.0461913645,
-0.057800401,
0.0115301944,
-0.0135501772,
0.0137469498,
-0.0361439735,
0.0589846484,
-0.0357490294,
-0.0125368703,
-0.0613569207,
0.0080359923,
-0.0399833322,
-0.0403369889,
0.0162854753,
-0.0031484212,
0.029473057,
-0.0157327112,
-0.0426380485,
0.0081982631,
-0.0018495695,
0.0595798157,
-0.023655558,
-0.0140395798,
-0.0166392867,
-0.0339862965,
-0.0384244733,
0.0330856219,
0.0021884204,
0.0274624489,
-0.0103357034,
0.0261478685,
-0.041321151,
-0.0272024106,
-0.0427770391,
-0.027971359,
-0.0112037947,
-0.004343437,
-0.0405199192,
-0.0339143835,
0.0223693922,
0.0440682918,
-0.0248966496,
0.045294188,
0.0193706173,
0.0394045077,
-0.0430303589,
-0.0820065662,
0.0126932887,
-0.0261948798,
0.0123202326,
-0.0098628318,
-0.0042394348,
-0.0127056176,
-0.0043818229,
-0.0708913952,
0.0044295248,
0.0169719178,
2.615e-7,
0.019697817,
0.0530638248,
0.0002343267,
0.054955937,
0.0271916781,
-0.0123593472,
0.0408175737,
-0.0022197138,
0.0323058479,
-0.0834714398,
0.0135888606,
0.0409194678,
-0.0277265515,
0.0541551411,
-0.1035938561,
-0.0586496703,
-0.0076229037,
-0.0578932837,
-0.0438268743,
0.0015872411,
0.0680531859,
-0.0121575324,
-0.015903065,
0.0498386621,
-0.0341593549,
-0.0578219034,
0.0232081506,
0.0183193814,
-0.0025115544,
-0.005259308,
0.0462118462,
0.0205204468,
-0.0220832508,
0.0356172994,
-0.0096685188,
0.0126152998,
0.0137188248,
-0.0241003614,
0.005508672,
-0.0298014637,
-0.0040002167,
-0.0236886833,
0.0290933661,
-0.034722425,
0.0385977365,
-0.0217418466,
0.0150975408,
0.0220662951,
-0.0049672951,
-0.0368885435,
0.0003911118,
-0.0375600457,
-0.0215930752,
0.0070923041,
-0.0272499323,
0.0225065798,
0.0405763052,
-0.020824641,
0.00655554,
0.0101058995,
-0.0279041491,
-0.0351548679,
-0.0571163483,
-0.0333416797,
-0.0374889113,
0.015572546,
0.020317452,
1.506531124e-34,
0.0141337384,
0.0299689434,
-0.0170351639,
-0.0226969495,
0.0700309202,
-0.001771089,
-0.0238965508,
-0.0159926508,
0.0495544747,
-0.0957397372,
0.0106142778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05149v1 | Retrieval-Generation Synergy Augmented Large Language Models | 2023-10-08T12:50:57 | 2023-10-08T12:50:57 | Zhangyin Feng, Xiaocheng Feng, Dezhi Zhao, Maojin Yang, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models augmented with task-relevant documents have
demonstrated impressive performance on knowledge-intensive tasks. However,
regarding how to obtain effective documents, the existing methods are mainly
divided into two categories. One is to retrieve from an external knowledge
base, and the other is to utilize large language models to generate documents.
We propose an iterative retrieval-generation collaborative framework. It is not
only able to leverage both parametric and non-parametric knowledge, but also
helps to find the correct reasoning path through retrieval-generation
interactions, which is very important for tasks that require multi-step
reasoning. We conduct experiments on four question answering datasets,
including single-hop QA and multi-hop QA tasks. Empirical results show that our
method significantly improves the reasoning ability of large language models
and outperforms previous baselines. | [
0.0397555381,
0.036231719,
0.0022655404,
0.0436515436,
-0.0472546183,
-0.009683826,
-0.0048953751,
-0.0084854662,
0.0198430624,
-0.0491333753,
-0.0304987468,
-0.0285016671,
-0.0405938365,
-0.0151179172,
0.0083287451,
-0.0273657851,
0.0436490141,
-0.0285771564,
-0.0276173893,
-0.0121561689,
-0.0074799517,
0.0361293852,
0.0064646141,
0.0228165593,
-0.0043925368,
-0.0364134237,
-0.0001410562,
-0.0032400133,
-0.0000653883,
-0.0054353289,
0.0290155225,
0.030729901,
0.0380197279,
0.0301163737,
0.000001663,
-0.0376111008,
-0.0185541268,
0.0001964956,
-0.042360682,
-0.0030127566,
-0.015969947,
0.0208149049,
0.0470559932,
0.0427139066,
-0.0680251941,
-0.003945413,
-0.0034498838,
0.0330920294,
0.0587753654,
0.0562876835,
0.0039101597,
-0.0298756156,
0.0014483532,
-0.0314869732,
0.0212635733,
-0.0374441929,
0.0239169821,
0.0459289029,
0.0332965702,
0.0413746014,
0.0201257262,
0.033167012,
0.0366406292,
-0.0155794062,
0.0077090506,
0.0276813358,
-0.0248578284,
0.0052352319,
-0.0004562559,
0.0848699212,
0.0119562279,
-0.0075408677,
-0.014833401,
0.0335896462,
-0.0117492406,
0.0541382544,
-0.0684585273,
0.0050380812,
-0.0361567214,
0.0019172961,
0.0149223451,
-0.0278910492,
0.0310816523,
0.0069865701,
-0.0029533301,
0.0986099839,
0.0323557965,
-0.0209335182,
-0.0108413901,
0.0071758158,
-0.0358211212,
-0.0162489917,
-0.0079342388,
0.0549491458,
-0.0450594202,
0.0336861722,
0.0075562289,
-0.0409845896,
0.054984618,
-0.0315484777,
0.0313994177,
0.0180173982,
0.0102072135,
0.0719137564,
-0.0401516557,
0.0031283619,
-0.0299607515,
-0.0291806534,
-0.0620070063,
-0.0525764264,
-0.0397567973,
-0.037185587,
-0.0445703417,
0.047653202,
-0.0438004807,
-0.0231638476,
-0.018188376,
0.0480096899,
0.003129499,
-0.0078029153,
0.036092218,
0.0455530137,
-0.0214511435,
-0.0212766938,
-0.0256554484,
0.0365483575,
-0.0396532603,
0.0351464562,
0.0119313775,
-0.0395163223,
-0.0160062555,
0.0048485855,
0.0213939417,
-0.0503136367,
0.0177187007,
0.0331469625,
-0.0303154886,
-0.0254304633,
-0.0179236922,
-0.0552990548,
0.0137160961,
-0.064902395,
-0.005266916,
-0.060417708,
0.0532596894,
0.0237361845,
-0.0409282036,
-0.0231772866,
0.0061934083,
0.0578232519,
-0.0207363814,
0.0640541017,
-0.0057156412,
0.0176302623,
0.0413600095,
0.0263294894,
-0.0019276474,
0.0647296607,
0.0059613208,
0.0111613059,
0.064270772,
0.0153064355,
-0.002915208,
0.0117306905,
0.0457853451,
0.0287106317,
0.0096196411,
0.0596696101,
0.0154897692,
0.0111279581,
0.0148025881,
0.046447102,
-0.0562775061,
-0.012766744,
0.0238440372,
0.036496494,
0.0512959771,
-0.0037694909,
0.0346500985,
-0.0034145946,
-0.0059186481,
-0.0318327136,
-0.0136394128,
0.0311284196,
-0.0436265767,
0.0129829869,
0.0281866975,
0.0413354039,
-0.0509183072,
-0.0132840499,
-0.00783337,
-0.0010559929,
-0.0066466569,
0.0393264145,
0.0441626124,
0.0307233483,
-0.0237639584,
0.0698297992,
0.0200264733,
-0.0677793548,
0.0052180355,
-0.0307417698,
0.0651552156,
0.0618965402,
0.0762960985,
-0.031105971,
0.000813161,
0.0250979383,
0.0049442858,
-0.0069879051,
0.0346100666,
-0.0405151732,
-0.0040955194,
-0.0473665148,
-0.0245131589,
-0.0321740545,
-0.0289066564,
0.0057259579,
0.0469434261,
0.021916097,
0.0510323197,
-0.0525932088,
0.0196049605,
0.0127992537,
-0.0592839234,
-0.0300961304,
0.0197623707,
0.0022975884,
-0.0041553141,
0.0319731906,
0.0032459993,
0.038891457,
0.0505759306,
-0.0495283082,
-0.0546757914,
0.0191964079,
-0.0184841417,
-0.0663088411,
0.0283033904,
0.0046497132,
0.0203890223,
0.0262276959,
-0.0302351974,
-0.056194108,
0.0307758208,
-0.0191667955,
0.0368813202,
-0.057950642,
-0.0284780916,
0.042062372,
0.0132477004,
-0.0391548872,
0.0714660361,
0.0215838049,
0.0305787809,
0.0214977562,
0.0472855456,
0.0211807881,
-0.0409785323,
0.0181909297,
0.0223153681,
0.0120052807,
0.0266411155,
0.034694843,
-0.0258515179,
-0.0641522706,
-0.0308427643,
-0.1029347852,
0.0198922474,
-0.0212620199,
0.0096761789,
0.0247587096,
0.0155633278,
0.0075214421,
-0.0169050898,
-0.0609983541,
0.0102892667,
0.034753684,
0.0479122214,
-0.0003031998,
0.0304334275,
-0.0055888663,
-0.039550595,
-0.027094448,
-0.000635137,
0.0554545559,
0.0079045007,
0.0257804114,
-0.0620270111,
0.0122476928,
-0.0618598573,
0.0225373693,
-0.0043040733,
0.0077597634,
0.0210314319,
-0.0530857556,
0.0351771526,
0.062166933,
0.0019997309,
0.0000990357,
0.0424971692,
-0.0092932656,
-0.07917054,
0.0266413987,
-0.0401429273,
-0.0033399388,
0.0093823764,
-0.0172250737,
-0.0153163392,
0.0288795084,
-0.0060178386,
-0.0144567378,
-0.0301317517,
0.0245925076,
0.0170402192,
0.0116142044,
-0.0531051047,
-0.0306265224,
0.0191075169,
0.0197618995,
-0.0335003473,
-0.0165667199,
0.0588242933,
-0.0184183195,
-0.0039361296,
-0.0535801537,
0.0205116142,
-0.0653932542,
0.0961962715,
-0.0129170539,
0.0139099676,
-0.0470283478,
-0.0027243956,
-0.0204126481,
-0.0007198545,
0.0054015452,
-0.0504536368,
0.0177819859,
-0.0243072361,
0.0452035479,
-0.0076217307,
-0.0641746968,
-0.0554995574,
-0.0395961404,
-0.0087992745,
0.0318445228,
-0.0332569219,
-0.0125884945,
-0.0129746338,
-0.0158768296,
0.0489859991,
0.0112893358,
-0.0129125332,
-0.0194454398,
-0.0098589165,
0.0765243918,
0.0738972351,
0.0143496562,
0.0056706895,
-0.0176615547,
0.0216469821,
0.0569316484,
0.0929583088,
-0.0122550353,
-0.0028513507,
-0.0246398933,
0.030914003,
-0.0239804368,
-0.0092756087,
-0.0111904796,
0.0235160794,
-0.0482326858,
-0.0334411897,
0.0859426931,
0.0216858592,
-0.0398200452,
-0.020715287,
-0.0510367714,
0.0230228007,
0.0264661014,
0.0470374301,
-0.0787737146,
-0.0491439179,
-0.0024977424,
0.0305541754,
0.0159935486,
-0.0325898193,
0.001887043,
-0.1224917173,
0.0482235141,
-0.0095765274,
-0.0039227582,
-0.0382457525,
-0.070333153,
0.0100387521,
0.0215682238,
0.0025167658,
0.0531029217,
-0.0083770463,
0.0145257032,
0.017464051,
0.057858862,
-0.0064786575,
0.0325773358,
-0.0169945192,
-0.0051493933,
0.0555028506,
0.0104837399,
0.0214889459,
-0.0436288305,
-0.0000633642,
-0.0528754517,
0.0119126393,
0.0025211538,
0.0265078619,
0.0040867827,
0.0005376569,
-0.0345655642,
0.04787926,
-0.0743306428,
-0.0154895773,
0.0101578487,
0.075525403,
-0.0358223096,
-0.0084848339,
-0.0290521923,
-0.0046818247,
0.0269496907,
0.0899758935,
0.0112277707,
-0.0131898355,
-0.0441641174,
0.0083760228,
-0.0063870214,
-0.0434920043,
0.0009420522,
0.0307597965,
0.0328053944,
0.0340005718,
-0.0717768222,
-0.065885745,
0.0188771468,
0.0601805151,
-0.0217196234,
0.0484646261,
-0.0374328643,
-0.004832631,
-0.045470316,
0.0531660914,
-0.0480422452,
-0.002146265,
-0.0221692231,
0.0018950311,
0.0363385379,
-0.0416783765,
-0.0147742778,
0.006836121,
-0.07436198,
-0.0539151952,
-0.037523672,
0.0293904375,
0.0230345782,
0.0522743985,
-0.0167569611,
-0.0379158631,
0.0312616639,
0.0279060472,
-0.0611553155,
0.0092575597,
-0.0047644167,
-0.0185166728,
-0.0144215673,
0.0644843429,
-0.0762033463,
-0.0068732891,
-0.0145654744,
0.0797466934,
-0.0314890444,
-0.0657504946,
0.0197369102,
0.0210848711,
-0.0023074511,
0.018891152,
0.0386716351,
-0.0210201703,
0.0245921761,
-0.0383287258,
-0.0157979354,
-0.0246563517,
0.0413819887,
0.0026231294,
-0.0616457239,
0.0133678103,
0.0186955538,
0.0035877686,
0.06372495,
-0.0373922624,
-0.0193321612,
-0.0114069907,
-0.0030932804,
0.043269325,
-0.0340386443,
-0.0274513438,
-0.0098662497,
-0.010726952,
0.0452018194,
-0.0292284731,
0.0673946962,
0.0281127393,
-0.0177805964,
-0.046593003,
0.0008937889,
-0.072249189,
-0.098845005,
-0.0164317805,
-0.0117518222,
0.0488649197,
0.0027745846,
0.0528593063,
-0.032691624,
-0.0250016656,
-0.0097498409,
0.0013139213,
0.0080455849,
-0.0467718579,
0.0340868533,
0.0309734009,
-0.0138124907,
0.0104391268,
0.0971880704,
-0.0485229231,
0.0346286781,
-0.0355871245,
-0.016213458,
-0.0248857141,
-0.0473896898,
0.0176714435,
0.0099812271,
-0.022274306,
0.0189318564,
-0.0107773328,
-0.0719020367,
-0.0070665753,
-0.0063389423,
-0.045935601,
0.0036877636,
0.0372153595,
0.1002696678,
0.0083844988,
-0.0411008559,
-0.0529385395,
0.0427133031,
-0.0642413944,
-0.0173394401,
-0.0166988429,
-6.212955638e-33,
-0.0031110288,
-0.0145480968,
0.0520347394,
-0.0115090692,
0.0049570901,
-0.0091496557,
-0.0437078923,
-0.0248675533,
-0.0361890122,
-0.0113086626,
-0.0263036676,
0.0261523426,
-0.0022466378,
0.0488140956,
0.0079001328,
0.0031607365,
0.0179570336,
-0.0082476931,
-0.0144495415,
0.0408413447,
0.0691329241,
0.0234481134,
0.0146853905,
-0.0272518359,
0.0126820039,
-0.0401687995,
0.0275000334,
0.0519169085,
-0.0215155873,
0.0700953975,
-0.0050059655,
0.0387325771,
0.0391259715,
-0.0524724573,
0.0176126957,
0.0398077443,
-0.0872767419,
-0.0199253373,
0.018702114,
-0.0303475857,
-0.0792358145,
-0.0418334045,
0.016890483,
-0.0108896131,
0.0245755389,
-0.0201169122,
0.0159590337,
-0.0098556774,
-0.0204434507,
-0.0354697667,
-0.0262763426,
-0.0028144403,
0.0034472803,
-0.0271604136,
-0.0309015904,
0.0756761953,
-0.0008072617,
0.0145213353,
-0.0433150567,
-0.0059064217,
-0.0402656123,
0.0420232862,
0.0403542444,
0.0161455926,
0.0144463135,
0.0357851647,
0.002654182,
0.0020930993,
-0.0238617714,
-0.0260458291,
-0.0221616663,
0.0335532799,
0.0209840909,
0.0430406071,
-0.0119141331,
0.0011000794,
-0.0727199614,
0.0490312725,
0.0277832616,
0.0356769599,
0.0357803367,
0.0020905603,
-0.0047013951,
-0.0146986758,
-0.0569668822,
0.0533683598,
-0.0417013131,
-0.0248699579,
0.0377567261,
0.024384167,
-0.008696896,
-0.0145279188,
0.0398993045,
-0.0220518913,
-0.011719076,
0.0801446885,
-0.029629793,
-0.0110609801,
-0.0174332764,
0.0420676693,
-0.0496861488,
-0.0141541436,
0.01445344,
-0.0034329607,
-0.0443275049,
0.0418140739,
0.0154954046,
-0.0045412639,
-0.0460808463,
0.0066062203,
-0.0452283099,
0.0426347144,
-0.0135111064,
-0.0224386062,
0.0336917043,
0.0557495281,
0.0044492367,
0.0535301417,
0.01737554,
0.0119205695,
-0.0246845465,
-0.0514258593,
0.0213386677,
0.0029900644,
-0.0030068979,
0.0293022655,
-0.0449410826,
0.0116776815,
0.0020005123,
-0.0382969826,
-0.0064074472,
0.033638224,
2.503e-7,
0.0388434231,
0.0002726894,
-0.0009474953,
0.0479468293,
0.0299334023,
0.0200679209,
0.0030819452,
0.014025582,
0.0503546745,
-0.0156255551,
-0.0153620411,
0.0513091646,
0.0308211129,
0.0392003171,
-0.0708522573,
-0.0073170369,
-0.0647436827,
-0.0453188345,
-0.042806752,
-0.0312324949,
0.026020756,
0.0602489822,
-0.0125501873,
-0.0322253928,
-0.0206842329,
-0.0881357417,
0.0880750939,
0.0067520179,
-0.0363387503,
0.0240816157,
0.0569339581,
-0.00777137,
0.0334969983,
0.0262130592,
-0.000690878,
0.023073718,
0.0059857643,
0.0288235508,
-0.0024578897,
-0.0508624949,
-0.017941311,
-0.0557807386,
0.0134341782,
-0.053097561,
0.0880976468,
-0.0423908792,
-0.0073305382,
-0.0011491171,
-0.0254848283,
0.0002213327,
-0.0040967115,
-0.0305949021,
0.0011766891,
0.0221843924,
-0.0009966412,
-0.0055763614,
0.0072254995,
-0.0793975443,
-0.0198171455,
0.0306494161,
-0.0618611872,
-0.0176236667,
-0.0169345457,
-0.0257367883,
-0.011129166,
-0.0562208593,
0.0256837942,
1.962782381e-34,
0.0246940646,
0.01934921,
0.0148526924,
0.0160844643,
0.0478720814,
-0.0303509161,
-0.0416600108,
0.0040019569,
0.0240497645,
-0.1038751006,
-0.0200934429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05146v1 | Large Language Model (LLM) as a System of Multiple Expert Agents: An Approach to solve the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC) Challenge | 2023-10-08T12:37:28 | 2023-10-08T12:37:28 | John Chong Min Tan, Mehul Motani | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We attempt to solve the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus (ARC) Challenge
using Large Language Models (LLMs) as a system of multiple expert agents. Using
the flexibility of LLMs to be prompted to do various novel tasks using
zero-shot, few-shot, context-grounded prompting, we explore the feasibility of
using LLMs to solve the ARC Challenge. We firstly convert the input image into
multiple suitable text-based abstraction spaces. We then utilise the
associative power of LLMs to derive the input-output relationship and map this
to actions in the form of a working program, similar to Voyager / Ghost in the
MineCraft. In addition, we use iterative environmental feedback in order to
guide LLMs to solve the task. Our proposed approach achieves 50 solves out of
111 training set problems (45%) with just three abstraction spaces - grid,
object and pixel - and we believe that with more abstraction spaces and
learnable actions, we will be able to solve more. | [
0.0284292419,
0.016600566,
-0.0248356201,
0.056440752,
-0.0518938638,
0.0265292395,
0.0485225506,
0.0073524513,
0.0221598987,
-0.047351405,
-0.0173154846,
0.0078421747,
-0.0329016447,
0.0311012752,
0.0115289027,
-0.0699505284,
0.0095195128,
-0.076278694,
0.0108153149,
-0.0181774814,
-0.0091407765,
-0.0159321129,
-0.0175646786,
0.0184366833,
-0.0376785025,
-0.0160485897,
-0.0395451039,
-0.0145090912,
0.0116179418,
-0.0209607147,
-0.0650298297,
0.0119657172,
0.0621250719,
0.0268673599,
0.0000019357,
-0.0602352843,
-0.0002019257,
0.0008558617,
-0.0059287348,
-0.0433761217,
0.0096886074,
-0.0116253933,
-0.0034917949,
-0.0315382183,
-0.04038525,
0.0172656253,
0.0764191523,
0.0534625873,
0.1114248633,
0.0689611062,
-0.0087251039,
-0.0488236211,
-0.022052763,
0.0224328078,
0.0213849284,
0.0070304717,
0.0314580984,
0.0582040176,
0.0361037627,
0.0187969748,
-0.0303748101,
0.0413736328,
0.0452939384,
-0.0210818853,
0.0018500955,
0.0363580808,
0.0144887269,
-0.0423645005,
-0.0362696573,
0.0587442815,
-0.0206264686,
0.0172282811,
0.0041662827,
0.0069020553,
-0.0164588559,
0.0018556931,
-0.0494303815,
0.0477739275,
0.0020171914,
0.0136985565,
-0.030299833,
-0.0050475225,
-0.0027123662,
0.0257742945,
-0.0599340238,
0.0637579486,
0.0021768603,
-0.0140520381,
-0.0126985358,
-0.0015877375,
-0.0312272254,
-0.057644669,
0.0130251748,
0.0610687658,
-0.049104929,
0.0295861196,
-0.0242810529,
-0.0478781946,
-0.0133636501,
-0.005759676,
0.0344127975,
0.0197924878,
0.0113797514,
0.1083294749,
-0.0264607817,
0.0718447417,
-0.0298068821,
0.0234749764,
-0.031249579,
-0.0157049466,
-0.0578671023,
-0.0220137667,
-0.0622049905,
0.0673374757,
-0.050770808,
-0.0371227115,
0.0093706334,
0.0119526228,
-0.04303528,
0.0369321592,
-0.0001116756,
0.0020398637,
-0.013837425,
-0.0573985726,
-0.0298883114,
-0.0291262083,
-0.0358930342,
0.0249827616,
-0.00550183,
-0.0065379543,
0.0234683733,
0.0380280204,
0.0021413011,
-0.0125808716,
0.0083877658,
0.0856318101,
-0.0257977545,
-0.0186643731,
-0.0091517,
-0.0223574825,
0.0222679842,
-0.0755004063,
0.0322110802,
-0.0793650672,
0.0240365025,
-0.0259877425,
0.000959784,
-0.011987119,
0.0279504526,
-0.0382885709,
-0.0184603371,
0.1158078313,
-0.0084324963,
0.0245817248,
0.0501073711,
0.0207622629,
-0.0428342447,
0.0638938397,
0.0374508053,
0.0285032485,
0.0055820774,
0.0398905911,
0.0289657712,
0.0507896282,
-0.0378256254,
0.0237783138,
-0.0032895342,
-0.0086374041,
-0.0490041301,
0.0482694134,
-0.00713473,
0.0506393164,
-0.0429126061,
0.0060024201,
0.0176425353,
0.0834802091,
-0.0646960214,
0.0202235784,
0.0658068061,
-0.0103540719,
0.0152824465,
-0.0159744006,
-0.0272262711,
0.037788745,
0.0150675345,
-0.006833801,
-0.0497382618,
0.0181421116,
-0.0410356,
-0.033394523,
0.0038382153,
-0.0188818146,
0.009546658,
-0.011358887,
0.0787955523,
0.0108485539,
-0.0290563274,
-0.0111138765,
-0.0404303037,
-0.0470223613,
-0.0258657206,
-0.0552973635,
0.0767081603,
0.0410630852,
0.0154880546,
-0.0233418867,
-0.015476428,
0.0151858842,
0.0453354008,
0.0581213757,
-0.0437251665,
-0.0035556366,
0.0055074114,
-0.024296537,
-0.0295485072,
-0.0067703715,
-0.0079575935,
0.0310757812,
0.0101939207,
-0.026953036,
-0.0037138835,
-0.0129057793,
-0.0081204884,
0.0403441638,
0.0065833251,
-0.0020226741,
-0.0285787638,
0.0418599062,
0.0256190058,
0.0013607864,
-0.02984602,
0.0070796455,
0.0240067095,
-0.0634880215,
-0.0393359996,
0.0108488379,
-0.0292403381,
-0.0096149044,
0.0501019135,
-0.0685473308,
-0.0289286599,
0.0054641934,
-0.0485941209,
-0.0309332889,
0.025075797,
0.0053276001,
0.0453183316,
-0.0128916726,
0.0209036209,
0.003193354,
-0.0530123003,
-0.015673086,
0.0759843513,
-0.0049926927,
-0.0141599523,
0.0007814278,
0.0348267145,
0.0141988583,
-0.01884095,
-0.0123067964,
-0.0081456201,
0.0268213302,
0.0008366201,
0.019649012,
0.034397006,
-0.0628833994,
-0.0173704214,
-0.0607117042,
-0.0419026203,
0.0064144866,
-0.0248934217,
0.0126158204,
-0.0430163406,
0.0113117294,
-0.0039673909,
-0.0190418679,
0.0489466041,
0.007386127,
-0.0080461111,
0.0031794191,
-0.0042282632,
-0.0314700119,
-0.008754856,
-0.0188319292,
-0.0044791512,
0.0290641394,
0.0435440615,
-0.0638981164,
-0.0505607203,
0.0471861735,
-0.0027462968,
0.0465705171,
-0.0181918871,
-0.0299608707,
0.0305993371,
-0.0673033819,
0.00727339,
0.0910319611,
-0.0614567176,
0.0354513936,
0.0261491165,
-0.0274934154,
-0.0470816344,
0.0081983777,
0.0049700532,
-0.0056316261,
-0.0059494968,
0.0134389065,
0.0012367259,
0.0393301882,
-0.0092301629,
0.0156524554,
-0.0556112565,
0.0230409503,
0.0005826295,
-0.0320438556,
-0.0319268852,
-0.0378770567,
-0.0102712754,
0.0273481067,
-0.0648078546,
-0.0296570677,
0.049683895,
-0.0147127127,
-0.0222512633,
-0.0097020967,
0.0219993554,
-0.0184058528,
0.0832567886,
0.0071622799,
0.0404037721,
0.0258838441,
-0.0023967098,
-0.0420256257,
-0.0370233171,
0.0047603487,
0.0120055014,
0.0359191708,
-0.0897889733,
0.0319555439,
0.0105844084,
-0.0459500551,
-0.0171524957,
0.0159492884,
-0.0280948598,
0.0331330597,
-0.0445040315,
-0.0366257094,
-0.0264317766,
0.0194976125,
0.039069131,
-0.0141942836,
0.0042211171,
-0.006664787,
-0.0576867238,
0.0355302207,
0.0433995761,
0.0228349902,
-0.0409159549,
-0.0357797593,
0.0560089946,
0.0435095243,
0.0296847317,
-0.0054417928,
-0.0618924722,
0.0590105504,
-0.008901854,
0.0205151625,
0.0131767839,
-0.0002695422,
0.0639896616,
-0.0432241596,
-0.0343644321,
0.0743265077,
0.0369368643,
0.0038957375,
-0.01960315,
-0.02221529,
-0.0037314163,
0.0443777256,
0.0291807465,
-0.0527580939,
-0.0201090649,
-0.0135796592,
-0.0559840351,
0.0008057801,
-0.0483698398,
0.006907145,
-0.1203030497,
0.0502632447,
0.0373452157,
-0.0304914694,
-0.0446860529,
0.0172542278,
0.0180239696,
0.0242421292,
-0.0838863701,
-0.0000933399,
0.0470455699,
-0.0309029352,
0.0138351992,
0.0534051508,
-0.0002715698,
0.0183119159,
-0.0416919738,
0.0275205076,
0.0749555305,
0.0118012885,
-0.0112628797,
-0.0464117005,
0.0094885482,
0.0384406857,
0.0220655967,
-0.0109892208,
0.0032844162,
0.0159809962,
-0.0179350767,
0.0187619347,
0.0459082276,
-0.0093133552,
-0.0362024531,
-0.0045962264,
0.0979267061,
-0.0196440462,
-0.0021356237,
-0.0370580144,
-0.0218830146,
0.0380630568,
0.0588912144,
0.0210577697,
-0.0167311374,
-0.0571761504,
-0.0255386885,
-0.0563349836,
-0.0184980873,
-0.0088795768,
0.0130507108,
-0.0252670031,
-0.0219660345,
-0.0587904304,
0.0079242438,
0.0820710957,
0.0844762996,
0.0203775112,
-0.0305629056,
0.0203694887,
0.0075735552,
-0.0099666426,
0.0046288818,
-0.0349590592,
0.0224124808,
-0.0155083779,
-0.010090977,
0.0403032452,
-0.0375902951,
-0.0041520824,
0.0266418569,
-0.048376821,
-0.0593686253,
-0.0013909725,
0.0785379484,
0.0280148592,
0.0161299892,
-0.0093500754,
-0.053345751,
0.0681175664,
-0.0002408099,
0.005635323,
0.0187611133,
0.0033445687,
0.0363363773,
0.0015597215,
0.0286950544,
-0.0277617835,
0.0393603928,
0.0325650312,
0.0382522568,
-0.0768028274,
0.0413247645,
0.020471083,
0.0153902126,
0.0018616375,
-0.0130921919,
0.0242811218,
-0.0244596209,
0.007134649,
-0.0236739703,
-0.0360804461,
-0.0644086897,
0.0083139492,
-0.0086060567,
-0.0178432316,
0.0451620743,
-0.0149762509,
0.0285610128,
0.0216550007,
0.0343200676,
-0.0051466483,
0.0070098974,
0.008610541,
0.0257268716,
0.0265351981,
0.0017846929,
0.017157143,
-0.0150043368,
0.0092778839,
0.0043591498,
0.06671606,
0.0632360503,
-0.0158139057,
-0.0699586198,
0.0253616199,
-0.0229382738,
-0.0777915791,
0.0222041719,
0.0771908984,
0.0666929185,
0.024881795,
0.0041567176,
-0.0756359026,
-0.0080449767,
0.0217173565,
0.0154134277,
0.0576011725,
-0.0354548991,
0.0766404942,
0.0420794636,
0.0244429968,
-0.0138660194,
0.0186810009,
-0.0623116046,
0.0296745058,
0.0143132117,
-0.0161779337,
-0.0500348881,
0.0103797,
0.0056216363,
-0.0219061486,
0.0139284562,
0.0379441045,
-0.0302658193,
-0.0506983139,
-0.0200847406,
0.0496869609,
-0.0269523021,
0.0213808957,
0.0633794218,
0.0647643805,
0.0126228426,
-0.0306635369,
-0.01678144,
-0.0300591011,
-0.0037813992,
-0.0270948522,
-0.0257834923,
-5.704541841e-33,
-0.0462457351,
-0.0576902181,
0.0609378293,
-0.0138288671,
0.0124954823,
-0.0160758775,
-0.0339216441,
0.0065708915,
-0.0120504405,
0.0070801647,
0.0059406585,
-0.0140259936,
0.0115567269,
0.0118986806,
0.0207660869,
0.0275042169,
0.0203301497,
-0.0308386739,
-0.0141822966,
-0.0314205736,
0.0113490578,
-0.0194315631,
0.0094638942,
-0.0841358155,
-0.0113287047,
0.020705739,
-0.0369047262,
0.0563924834,
-0.0114271287,
0.0552737117,
-0.0219685938,
0.0125960074,
0.004224258,
-0.0254349299,
-0.0252930764,
0.0266853217,
-0.0772830695,
-0.0525872931,
0.024856044,
0.018496599,
-0.0787586197,
-0.0297740791,
0.0271723866,
-0.0078396313,
-0.0074843611,
-0.0060426341,
0.0312873274,
-0.0162753481,
0.0065627033,
0.0119479029,
-0.0418416448,
0.0011797423,
-0.0275673643,
-0.0264500361,
0.0555849969,
-0.0141800065,
-0.0123519115,
0.0019182625,
-0.0425540395,
0.034492597,
0.0496155396,
-0.0135543123,
0.0510043912,
0.0215506963,
0.0385573208,
0.0433391333,
0.0214407388,
-0.0197145119,
-0.0395305008,
-0.0011246271,
-0.0026016203,
0.0917368606,
0.0267521311,
0.0297842044,
-0.001533574,
0.030777134,
-0.0372419804,
-0.0035976057,
-0.011180222,
0.105419077,
0.0281615257,
0.0102259992,
0.0004466892,
0.0014018092,
-0.0161733646,
-0.0242786836,
-0.0245198924,
-0.0389283858,
0.0237671379,
0.0052660313,
0.0185838491,
-0.0213449001,
0.0562090762,
-0.030765269,
-0.0053939805,
-0.0125909364,
-0.0084668249,
0.0713038892,
0.0017777319,
0.018863216,
-0.035093721,
-0.0579966269,
0.015456548,
0.012136545,
0.0244767424,
0.0282588489,
0.0038702064,
0.0441379137,
-0.0188255981,
-0.0166165549,
-0.0441161059,
-0.0409828313,
0.0316387638,
0.007247169,
-0.0010141181,
0.0109610306,
-0.0171292592,
0.0053700684,
-0.0208426304,
-0.0607390925,
0.0219254997,
0.0087376488,
-0.0335107744,
0.0085995337,
-0.0490929447,
-0.0063275979,
-0.0545426272,
-0.0004535966,
0.0593151003,
-0.0338928327,
-0.0060989386,
0.039428845,
2.755e-7,
-0.0081074722,
0.0079556536,
0.0089798849,
0.0215632338,
0.0118292673,
0.0402566642,
-0.0401058458,
0.0057139737,
-0.0246425569,
-0.043745175,
0.0305636246,
0.0463617891,
0.014555566,
-0.0102500981,
-0.0778225809,
0.0055327015,
0.026951557,
-0.0214446187,
-0.0910116509,
0.0365467481,
0.0914702266,
0.0615322702,
0.042744562,
-0.0044937874,
0.0090146493,
-0.0517731085,
0.0456593409,
-0.02552028,
0.0407379344,
0.0015656435,
-0.0296172909,
-0.0002299455,
-0.0381371304,
0.0331633165,
0.0223153159,
0.0048822104,
0.0234900992,
0.0527173057,
-0.0401497185,
-0.0035355333,
-0.0026137754,
-0.0064485217,
-0.0065693716,
-0.0291154198,
0.0539951697,
-0.065677695,
-0.0332889929,
0.0101361861,
-0.0074125472,
-0.0206057671,
-0.0426789559,
-0.0201093853,
-0.0378203392,
-0.0259802677,
0.005938496,
-0.0190857369,
-0.0148734059,
-0.0819752887,
0.0290864687,
-0.013542464,
-0.0410134196,
-0.0191315375,
-0.0167385973,
-0.0011988542,
0.0167644229,
-0.0716676041,
-0.0392929018,
2.415083449e-34,
-0.0089198863,
-0.0057860748,
0.0188808944,
0.0887411162,
0.0361236185,
0.0093630953,
-0.0632458851,
0.0337628499,
0.0075885579,
-0.0792925954,
-0.0199778154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05140v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05140v3 | Harnessing the Power of Large Language Models for Empathetic Response Generation: Empirical Investigations and Improvements | 2023-10-08T12:21:24 | 2023-12-07T07:05:50 | Yushan Qian, Wei-Nan Zhang, Ting Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Empathetic dialogue is an indispensable part of building harmonious social
relationships and contributes to the development of a helpful AI. Previous
approaches are mainly based on fine small-scale language models. With the
advent of ChatGPT, the application effect of large language models (LLMs) in
this field has attracted great attention. This work empirically investigates
the performance of LLMs in generating empathetic responses and proposes three
improvement methods of semantically similar in-context learning, two-stage
interactive generation, and combination with the knowledge base. Extensive
experiments show that LLMs can significantly benefit from our proposed methods
and is able to achieve state-of-the-art performance in both automatic and human
evaluations. Additionally, we explore the possibility of GPT-4 simulating human
evaluators. | [
0.0589571893,
0.0223888457,
-0.025352085,
0.0679134876,
-0.0226423219,
0.03241558,
-0.0026637106,
-0.0088554639,
0.0406413265,
-0.0515053347,
-0.0292614195,
-0.0450805426,
-0.0253356677,
-0.0085749887,
0.0327339917,
-0.0656847432,
0.0140187349,
0.0168561768,
0.0330935605,
-0.0454857014,
0.0098227691,
0.0356636904,
-0.007177291,
0.0637995526,
-0.0221046861,
0.0022888738,
-0.013328312,
0.011970263,
0.0227132645,
-0.0188634787,
0.0291565359,
0.0217310414,
0.0197038949,
0.0249969028,
0.0000020917,
-0.0258964319,
0.019584043,
-0.0136637744,
0.0076137949,
0.0029340649,
0.0756723434,
-0.0055825086,
-0.0007026908,
0.024522908,
-0.0515974797,
-0.0347323269,
0.0215893239,
0.0409568101,
0.0918687284,
0.0653380454,
-0.0116553325,
-0.0288066398,
-0.0007269088,
-0.0338519998,
-0.0219790302,
-0.019103637,
0.0076735811,
0.0214617699,
0.0192978829,
-0.0131946784,
-0.0126138031,
0.0138307316,
0.0044975397,
-0.0061857188,
0.012594725,
0.0341116562,
-0.0161455404,
-0.01454503,
-0.0240668189,
0.1136725619,
0.0088980533,
0.0160254464,
0.0018654757,
-0.0173787102,
0.0127059035,
-0.0067524631,
-0.0312554389,
0.0202094857,
0.0016290382,
0.0108625656,
-0.0077431682,
0.0140209887,
-0.0083379131,
0.0342513211,
-0.0013024618,
0.0129147992,
0.0053398702,
-0.0116643067,
0.0123550911,
0.0012726889,
-0.052476503,
-0.0192350075,
-0.0327543207,
0.0378982313,
-0.0291448049,
0.0151520958,
-0.0331019014,
0.0578251481,
0.0220548958,
-0.0248594489,
0.0370563976,
0.0476226695,
0.0071448879,
0.0132807475,
-0.0024036914,
0.0667694956,
0.0051831226,
-0.014525271,
-0.047942888,
-0.0011497909,
-0.0536326356,
-0.0007467752,
-0.0375506282,
0.0493845902,
-0.0492073409,
-0.0144867469,
-0.0563161559,
0.0415276289,
-0.0156744123,
0.0026605548,
0.0104901362,
-0.0168790985,
-0.0191106647,
-0.0113159372,
-0.0373943746,
0.006257196,
-0.0483656079,
-0.0015053267,
0.0003464848,
-0.0755725801,
0.0097911721,
0.0209960863,
-0.0022665088,
-0.0194771029,
0.0050967578,
0.0396567434,
-0.0067909071,
-0.0315600522,
-0.0117644211,
0.0100441175,
-0.0367258675,
-0.0843651742,
-0.0239162967,
-0.0249773804,
0.0518663041,
0.006009419,
-0.0178961363,
-0.0343806967,
0.0320315324,
-0.0109115746,
-0.0715904906,
0.0427652933,
-0.011994645,
0.0347207002,
0.0110512767,
0.0081456127,
-0.0115134418,
0.0420066677,
0.0344155803,
0.0159105994,
0.0230043065,
-0.0233008768,
0.0164076351,
0.0344637893,
0.008264333,
0.0150027554,
-0.0137084043,
-0.0103644161,
-0.0286967475,
0.0525727794,
0.0400418676,
0.0701061189,
-0.050120268,
-0.0101877861,
0.0604507737,
0.0593988784,
-0.0037587155,
0.0919677392,
0.0591004193,
0.053001862,
-0.0069167768,
0.0055017248,
-0.040755745,
0.0297889505,
-0.0241704565,
-0.0060108411,
0.0108021013,
-0.0014574974,
-0.0449421927,
-0.0248979554,
0.0048169601,
-0.0005191553,
0.0296032559,
0.0220107976,
0.0029265,
-0.026741324,
-0.0403573513,
0.0087926108,
0.0524489954,
-0.077697888,
-0.0257077292,
-0.0890206099,
0.0211265907,
0.0885533467,
0.0422845408,
-0.017972691,
-0.0443035513,
0.0048149284,
-0.0453460775,
0.0467714295,
0.0543399714,
-0.0221896637,
0.0123717654,
-0.0623309202,
0.0190337915,
-0.0036818043,
-0.0133985365,
0.0328125469,
-0.0035270101,
0.0231671594,
0.0293795876,
-0.0011807488,
0.0156056713,
0.0172131266,
-0.0174382459,
-0.0119170416,
0.0086315796,
0.0022889187,
0.0313636735,
0.0097514847,
-0.0208606925,
-0.0146142123,
0.0079826759,
-0.0058262902,
-0.0189616904,
0.0324201882,
-0.0551403984,
-0.0747900605,
0.0248895735,
0.0131754791,
0.001223614,
0.0102285342,
-0.0203601383,
-0.0215806253,
0.0127847074,
-0.0379440375,
0.0395198166,
-0.0690958425,
0.0206933916,
-0.0166580603,
0.0054085837,
-0.0271515362,
0.0411628559,
0.0114944549,
-0.0084484629,
0.0091060242,
0.034644708,
-0.0065156473,
-0.0468638502,
-0.0371786244,
0.02070597,
0.0138565162,
0.00784034,
0.0099703856,
0.0537079126,
-0.0501967259,
-0.074477911,
-0.1412508637,
-0.0011786823,
-0.0030801292,
-0.0065657562,
0.0116003901,
-0.0001647249,
-0.0258578043,
0.0254398119,
-0.0708774775,
0.0557361692,
0.0713727921,
-0.0097064534,
0.0140331052,
0.0005332494,
-0.0342220105,
-0.060440097,
0.0062950463,
-0.0025526164,
0.0264391974,
-0.0117624216,
-0.0001093918,
-0.0580989756,
0.0438591912,
-0.0521931276,
0.031254787,
-0.0196730774,
-0.1048939824,
0.0024105022,
-0.0120457159,
0.028805133,
0.0502594747,
0.0261125248,
0.0730808899,
-0.0067223879,
-0.0133401807,
-0.0744714215,
0.0464477316,
-0.0375590064,
-0.0111609986,
-0.0382012278,
-0.03768868,
-0.0302357711,
0.0328223631,
0.0119719207,
-0.0013923531,
-0.0902295858,
0.0139247952,
0.0248777438,
-0.0542537086,
-0.0297143683,
-0.0370956399,
-0.0225720294,
-0.0246991813,
0.0093189869,
-0.0325045437,
0.0553698726,
-0.0014792745,
-0.0298913047,
-0.0382340401,
0.0092742825,
-0.0145965116,
0.080685012,
-0.0147645175,
0.0317025743,
-0.0212605949,
0.0076361313,
-0.0423823521,
-0.0209507812,
-0.0080995075,
-0.033543326,
0.0263957288,
-0.0487599075,
-0.0101668444,
0.0296751894,
-0.0482747443,
-0.0305698998,
-0.0620810278,
-0.010568466,
0.0089350007,
0.021015333,
0.0041846819,
0.0209260788,
0.0103248376,
0.0270907562,
0.0081379712,
-0.0345230848,
-0.0034274813,
-0.0240500402,
0.0338519998,
0.0423925035,
0.0246340744,
0.0370401219,
-0.0184027143,
0.0845834762,
0.0374814458,
0.0543591157,
0.012285416,
0.0093812738,
0.0109367836,
0.0161516815,
0.0291569177,
0.0064383587,
0.0082544498,
0.0408663303,
-0.0029045779,
-0.0119984113,
0.1317119896,
0.0143629871,
-0.0516872481,
0.0240776464,
-0.0191171877,
0.0060628899,
-0.0006582653,
0.0099136299,
-0.0430702753,
-0.0244725235,
-0.0185139626,
0.0160027817,
-0.034517549,
-0.0285367798,
0.0163948014,
-0.1232316047,
0.052760236,
0.0170084927,
-0.0107431514,
-0.0322454423,
0.0259454791,
0.0048385626,
0.0209519751,
0.0104101785,
0.0087069348,
0.0084998384,
-0.0236821547,
0.0124524664,
-0.0064450377,
-0.0435027257,
0.0457282737,
-0.0353859775,
0.0832633376,
0.0441573784,
0.0831559971,
-0.0004406013,
0.022286687,
0.0150025459,
0.0079242932,
0.0004570431,
-0.0014596264,
0.0150900697,
0.0126969032,
-0.0001026156,
-0.0274064988,
0.0500086769,
-0.0236490574,
0.0260918923,
0.0280402619,
0.0447141975,
-0.0439861827,
-0.0150533756,
0.0153223285,
0.0278023575,
0.0466413721,
0.0865849629,
0.0266067777,
-0.0512951128,
-0.0205133799,
0.0298678093,
-0.0069052298,
0.0157381278,
-0.0410690233,
0.0196253452,
0.001355052,
0.0056893798,
-0.0699230433,
-0.08924824,
0.006551065,
0.0063168365,
-0.0166113209,
-0.0440391675,
0.0156171564,
0.0216055047,
0.0048788143,
0.016441118,
-0.0121439043,
0.024518542,
-0.0143374885,
0.0045180586,
0.0530570447,
-0.0464354791,
-0.0042748763,
0.0200326834,
-0.0409556068,
-0.0615491048,
0.0002573738,
0.0587660298,
0.0137403486,
0.0287614893,
0.0082644336,
-0.040294528,
0.008629567,
0.0014751321,
-0.0375676639,
0.0284440853,
-0.003969131,
0.0489022285,
-0.0159811601,
0.0451494753,
-0.0288921557,
0.0587922223,
0.0380818136,
0.0490736216,
0.0119832028,
-0.0707160681,
-0.0010740305,
0.0437167697,
-0.001549228,
-0.0129748508,
-0.0374755897,
-0.0180045906,
-0.0031025335,
-0.045898702,
-0.0057755793,
-0.0793796703,
-0.0041922401,
-0.0057407939,
-0.0019647684,
-0.0290027726,
-0.103038758,
-0.0318032466,
0.0268762428,
-0.0398096144,
0.0116160512,
-0.0250628479,
-0.0251122117,
0.0371106081,
0.0165680144,
-0.0469807349,
0.0016400415,
0.0017912075,
-0.0130293081,
-0.028404301,
0.1178719401,
0.0177690275,
-0.0421761461,
-0.0042469692,
0.044265423,
-0.0073036966,
-0.0354349427,
-0.0522684678,
0.0561591499,
0.0610146932,
0.0398746133,
0.0508337542,
-0.0688303784,
0.008958349,
-0.02167386,
0.0275980178,
0.0065809269,
-0.0308027994,
0.0345406644,
0.0097661987,
-0.0294219758,
0.0046791718,
0.0536566637,
-0.0339200571,
0.0298909098,
-0.0014475076,
0.0151443472,
-0.0465267487,
-0.0317769013,
0.0463827476,
-0.0295115411,
-0.0086889872,
0.043314144,
-0.0777278394,
-0.0482131727,
-0.0377802849,
0.0044305874,
-0.0060389247,
-0.0420855395,
0.0421233922,
0.0630211011,
-0.0203785747,
0.0188571922,
-0.0391579568,
0.0300633423,
-0.0721180514,
-0.0276798438,
-0.0375246108,
-6.282834369e-33,
-0.0249197278,
-0.0207053386,
-0.0043121059,
-0.0033160273,
-0.0688951164,
-0.0214439034,
-0.0070757279,
0.0190427415,
0.0005959172,
0.0282499585,
-0.0246368162,
0.0178972092,
-0.006768682,
0.0030636506,
-0.0238120351,
-0.0041432567,
0.0209957659,
0.0040446552,
-0.0055032116,
0.0819810927,
-0.0131340949,
0.0309951454,
0.0023214179,
-0.0619670562,
0.0058606756,
-0.0308948997,
-0.0224786922,
0.0166791901,
0.0195099022,
0.0485500954,
-0.0374493562,
0.0648666099,
0.0290799998,
-0.0059826523,
0.0259219967,
0.0169882122,
-0.0206467304,
0.008003789,
0.0194650088,
-0.04799987,
-0.0348297544,
-0.0346097425,
-0.0019602601,
-0.0133258775,
-0.044894021,
-0.0053889691,
-0.0200188812,
-0.0196630899,
0.0080512976,
-0.0321795829,
-0.0704205185,
0.0064025843,
-0.0222272892,
-0.0481004119,
-0.0210216604,
0.0201034788,
-0.020968657,
0.0170320794,
-0.0034069563,
0.0013810853,
-0.0004715778,
-0.0227483045,
-0.005136874,
-0.0175887458,
0.0011133718,
0.0718957633,
0.0027027959,
0.0334184319,
0.0035696507,
-0.0439820997,
0.0034178915,
0.0320317112,
0.0238286629,
0.0936715901,
-0.046357546,
-0.0308200531,
-0.0323307402,
0.0240040142,
0.0574237444,
0.0212387834,
0.0499039516,
-0.0173761658,
-0.0348147266,
0.0007423147,
-0.0417653136,
0.0070312698,
-0.021435244,
-0.0398097523,
0.0367109776,
-0.0060866093,
0.0117194131,
-0.0620347634,
0.0219132993,
-0.0549188703,
0.0309176054,
0.0295013413,
-0.0538963787,
0.0039451383,
-0.0175567456,
0.0223280936,
-0.0049567302,
-0.0656076819,
0.0031668812,
-0.0000526338,
0.0048592244,
0.0202863738,
-0.0059241033,
0.0051380009,
-0.0353136994,
0.0326912589,
-0.0252485014,
0.0449540168,
-0.0373038948,
-0.0067954212,
-0.0276797693,
0.0107570859,
-0.0077676303,
0.0139076971,
0.0125637772,
-0.009018979,
-0.0120670777,
-0.0386734344,
0.0280174483,
0.0331372581,
-0.0647727847,
0.0257417075,
0.0047288886,
-0.0259316172,
0.0292034652,
-0.0155327208,
-0.0168886334,
-0.0144487359,
2.763e-7,
-0.039445892,
0.0430930667,
-0.0043314029,
0.0012161456,
0.0276151523,
0.0463057496,
0.0027939389,
0.0578655154,
0.0475234166,
0.0036109993,
0.0617792606,
0.0202467591,
0.0933354199,
0.0116797825,
-0.0770579651,
0.0525041968,
-0.0546204932,
-0.0580725931,
-0.0168274119,
0.0166090932,
0.0950257555,
0.067581594,
0.0039147031,
-0.008070034,
0.01619328,
0.006857309,
0.0636341944,
-0.0698092803,
-0.0460908264,
0.0453115851,
0.0088157365,
-0.017687168,
0.0164310895,
0.0212625992,
0.0397591256,
0.0249178875,
0.0067943195,
0.0942483544,
0.0003682774,
-0.0226139221,
0.0462027937,
0.0000550938,
0.0170178115,
-0.084312126,
0.0368527956,
-0.0927561969,
-0.0149127319,
0.0133492434,
0.0288337991,
-0.0462401249,
-0.0229749605,
-0.0617393367,
-0.0312908404,
0.0411286838,
0.0211538542,
-0.0184150152,
0.0337141566,
-0.0577566549,
0.0245831683,
0.0212999638,
-0.0665918514,
-0.104212299,
0.0017380557,
-0.0064649298,
0.0211879611,
-0.0359777063,
0.0175635889,
2.183661213e-34,
0.0236489084,
0.0135343969,
0.0069017615,
0.033101242,
0.0687304512,
0.0183054768,
0.0045663523,
0.0069733951,
0.032522317,
-0.0884752423,
-0.007040394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05135v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05135v1 | Are Emily and Greg Still More Employable than Lakisha and Jamal? Investigating Algorithmic Hiring Bias in the Era of ChatGPT | 2023-10-08T12:08:48 | 2023-10-08T12:08:48 | Akshaj Kumar Veldanda, Fabian Grob, Shailja Thakur, Hammond Pearce, Benjamin Tan, Ramesh Karri, Siddharth Garg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5, Bard, and Claude exhibit
applicability across numerous tasks. One domain of interest is their use in
algorithmic hiring, specifically in matching resumes with job categories. Yet,
this introduces issues of bias on protected attributes like gender, race and
maternity status. The seminal work of Bertrand & Mullainathan (2003) set the
gold-standard for identifying hiring bias via field experiments where the
response rate for identical resumes that differ only in protected attributes,
e.g., racially suggestive names such as Emily or Lakisha, is compared. We
replicate this experiment on state-of-art LLMs (GPT-3.5, Bard, Claude and
Llama) to evaluate bias (or lack thereof) on gender, race, maternity status,
pregnancy status, and political affiliation. We evaluate LLMs on two tasks: (1)
matching resumes to job categories; and (2) summarizing resumes with employment
relevant information. Overall, LLMs are robust across race and gender. They
differ in their performance on pregnancy status and political affiliation. We
use contrastive input decoding on open-source LLMs to uncover potential sources
of bias. | [
0.0469994508,
0.1145817935,
-0.0384913869,
-0.0127290785,
-0.0263349172,
0.0201852415,
0.0282308292,
-0.0020898604,
-0.0025956074,
-0.0627333,
0.0265353601,
-0.0376375876,
0.0436940975,
-0.0033272752,
-0.0067587695,
-0.0154220294,
0.0170427486,
0.0551374629,
0.0215751268,
-0.0575474501,
0.0032790739,
0.062347047,
0.024958672,
0.0824412331,
0.0051383162,
0.0001142634,
0.0610811748,
-0.0095724361,
-0.0064776349,
0.0226557013,
0.0214996561,
0.0757670403,
-0.0485688522,
0.050879389,
0.0000019468,
-0.0699717626,
-0.0017733049,
0.0230685342,
0.0047035813,
-0.0348143466,
0.0670725778,
-0.0077188248,
-0.0139373858,
0.0390554443,
-0.0340785123,
-0.003802883,
0.0500503294,
-0.0137775382,
0.0340558179,
0.0237337574,
0.0121908253,
-0.0221721418,
-0.0203133523,
-0.010562974,
0.0053828359,
-0.0192347784,
0.0431171469,
-0.0728509426,
0.0050654174,
-0.0266752951,
-0.0030057072,
0.0001204596,
-0.0375091545,
-0.0190429967,
0.0030620603,
0.0371969342,
-0.0402214378,
-0.0167708229,
0.0268306155,
0.0338597819,
0.0118941236,
-0.0075613703,
0.0097208787,
-0.0162534751,
0.0290482994,
-0.0009231759,
-0.0283879023,
0.025212802,
-0.0565930381,
-0.0185024366,
-0.0286630653,
-0.0086992234,
0.000661544,
0.0322089419,
-0.0013589967,
0.0871852115,
0.0111028152,
-0.0555997603,
0.0003621148,
0.0182699692,
0.0671714097,
-0.0528940484,
0.0582157597,
-0.013178844,
-0.0309794787,
0.004779608,
-0.015742952,
-0.0143011054,
0.0230654646,
-0.0655531064,
-0.0091860145,
0.0670139641,
-0.0029506569,
0.0206475388,
0.0219546352,
0.0364450626,
0.00135968,
-0.0182565488,
-0.0047357134,
-0.0299647152,
-0.0657076091,
-0.021447774,
-0.0170555227,
-0.0072052539,
-0.002757269,
0.0682534352,
-0.0544386208,
-0.0113151409,
-0.0472738557,
-0.0073227328,
0.0209311768,
-0.0063911369,
-0.0148117281,
0.0151488492,
-0.0735985786,
-0.0356047861,
0.0184603501,
0.0045515043,
-0.0437473878,
-0.0754200071,
0.0360624827,
-0.0093483133,
0.02196295,
-0.0477555022,
-0.0046350337,
0.050179176,
0.0420598798,
-0.0120388158,
0.0060806298,
-0.0132129649,
-0.0014931728,
-0.0275076777,
-0.0417867154,
-0.0383133143,
0.0383511186,
0.0275688246,
0.0074947556,
-0.0725086033,
0.007897961,
0.0420867279,
-0.0845560282,
0.0560081191,
0.0321759544,
0.0218042694,
0.0602082387,
0.0083674463,
-0.0212369692,
0.0616058484,
0.0395734496,
0.0254883692,
0.0330543555,
-0.0675370768,
0.0266552679,
0.0610165894,
-0.0137313092,
0.0068570818,
-0.0039320774,
0.058683183,
0.0107910745,
0.0054113278,
0.0692885295,
0.0231440105,
-0.0089711538,
-0.0215847157,
0.0434745438,
0.1050055251,
0.0112640113,
0.0348185152,
0.0421606936,
0.0388868563,
-0.0245001018,
0.0007807445,
-0.063050203,
-0.0116871344,
-0.042764429,
-0.0545100942,
0.0082098236,
0.0611996427,
-0.027659731,
0.0049030227,
-0.012182137,
0.0207451358,
0.0481789112,
-0.0013763017,
0.004139733,
-0.0036166296,
-0.0456331037,
0.004339966,
0.0377324373,
-0.02351542,
-0.0164103284,
-0.0667541772,
-0.0255490337,
0.0906730741,
0.0178701524,
0.0050135683,
0.0275089778,
-0.0438498743,
-0.0326972343,
0.0322764181,
0.0701732188,
0.0148985125,
0.0070277778,
-0.0408112295,
-0.0243651439,
0.078320235,
0.0099935913,
0.033652693,
0.0756577477,
0.0429195985,
0.0222127847,
0.0181412008,
-0.0440419093,
0.0196442958,
0.0016376765,
-0.0382042527,
0.0237714425,
-0.0092057288,
0.0071462328,
-0.0006071204,
-0.010807706,
-0.0003076369,
-0.0518930927,
0.0085069295,
-0.0035927074,
0.0075763203,
-0.0228433851,
0.0077269417,
-0.0133262854,
-0.017720364,
-0.0693211481,
0.0263525043,
-0.0059720464,
0.0089346226,
0.0564218946,
0.017345937,
0.0262778848,
-0.0107569229,
0.0147970393,
-0.0361363478,
0.0258523747,
-0.0355157889,
0.0414280146,
0.0027616923,
0.0090599358,
-0.0254167709,
-0.0457451753,
-0.0277923588,
-0.1139342934,
-0.0101160835,
0.0284900181,
0.0142831579,
0.0130131338,
0.004612559,
0.0001280904,
-0.0273328163,
-0.0484325066,
-0.0679709837,
0.0301966723,
0.0388570949,
-0.0001131045,
-0.0242282357,
0.0244840495,
-0.0122007681,
0.0050348165,
-0.0152612673,
-0.0360466838,
0.033864405,
0.045623906,
0.0043726484,
-0.0354194641,
-0.053454183,
-0.0289657693,
-0.0613734052,
-0.0484971777,
0.0336618759,
0.0433284082,
0.0151001913,
-0.0414120443,
0.0161484983,
-0.0279589463,
-0.015327353,
0.0161582734,
0.0101456558,
0.0035309012,
0.0277610514,
-0.0141397659,
0.0385725237,
0.0157412682,
0.0171976872,
0.0005049638,
-0.0083364779,
-0.0212355983,
-0.0185660496,
0.0166039728,
0.0262751915,
0.0018409155,
-0.0839488506,
-0.025071295,
0.0098824454,
0.0207430683,
-0.0369169638,
-0.057733573,
0.0636549145,
-0.0466153994,
-0.0269664507,
-0.0607378595,
-0.0211676192,
-0.0170825087,
0.0209839977,
-0.0465647653,
-0.0510607623,
0.0255138129,
-0.0093820691,
0.0248046815,
0.0015987563,
-0.0360171199,
-0.0525129773,
0.0421470366,
-0.001704804,
0.0169891473,
0.0128363036,
-0.0387872532,
-0.0329613462,
-0.0090166004,
0.0228064172,
-0.0667497665,
0.0082261767,
-0.0053109149,
0.0149450367,
0.0005958384,
-0.0583519265,
-0.0335390233,
-0.0669552982,
-0.0216251519,
0.0288206451,
0.0449001715,
-0.0041342815,
-0.0343773961,
0.0226821695,
-0.0007723012,
-0.0062423269,
-0.0086520184,
-0.0233321358,
-0.0094326548,
0.0084528867,
-0.0209630542,
0.0089972708,
0.0056465659,
-0.0195372272,
-0.0147448964,
0.0000239325,
0.0010803784,
0.0386240222,
-0.003459017,
0.0033442874,
0.0403603464,
-0.0599501692,
-0.0243689697,
-0.0154255349,
-0.0013301314,
-0.0464114733,
0.0647853538,
0.0763434693,
0.0025391874,
-0.0526771434,
-0.0016427999,
0.0072500124,
-0.0276650265,
0.037503235,
0.0335320234,
-0.0867038742,
0.0197476521,
0.0219135694,
0.0413399786,
-0.0460671373,
-0.053627532,
-0.0321730971,
-0.1213936433,
0.033880949,
-0.0165051315,
-0.0370916612,
-0.0106146587,
-0.0467516221,
0.0068963692,
-0.0452038459,
0.0107952012,
-0.0110906512,
-0.0232470315,
0.0288655292,
-0.00031996,
-0.0249391329,
-0.0541549847,
0.051060304,
-0.0460674204,
0.0148323365,
0.0535523631,
0.0532301739,
-0.0342824794,
0.00873568,
0.027870452,
-0.0085453168,
-0.0091179032,
-0.0113147954,
0.0195350107,
-0.0381306224,
-0.0081943786,
-0.0528982095,
-0.0023345817,
0.0052744714,
0.045682881,
0.0299849026,
0.0036818625,
0.0005153177,
-0.0204506684,
-0.0177381448,
-0.0047322819,
-0.0162560232,
0.1015454084,
0.0107631627,
-0.0680537671,
0.0177166518,
-0.074271284,
0.0042756028,
0.019173827,
-0.084853664,
0.0053325202,
0.0086597456,
-0.0009309103,
-0.0050768158,
-0.0675914958,
0.0063998736,
-0.0061508319,
0.012606781,
-0.0128923068,
0.0163134709,
0.0038327684,
-0.0387115218,
0.0239137858,
-0.0393267982,
0.0614590198,
0.0117649287,
-0.0122747896,
-0.0273686219,
-0.0248302668,
-0.0450112931,
-0.0217457134,
-0.0545744747,
-0.016447803,
0.021605771,
-0.0200344902,
0.0329926424,
0.0210293606,
-0.020878356,
-0.0759971589,
-0.006806754,
0.0770211965,
-0.0217170808,
0.0327722132,
-0.0139261335,
0.017179206,
-0.000688584,
-0.00036326,
-0.0233504195,
0.0505946949,
0.0275528654,
-0.0200257711,
0.0138932532,
-0.0282460488,
-0.0082625365,
0.0274494439,
-0.0086310059,
-0.0018453689,
0.0005087557,
-0.046379365,
-0.0097708823,
-0.0133737326,
-0.027991062,
-0.0082888212,
-0.0399401411,
0.0317906886,
0.042453967,
-0.0190957729,
-0.0196121447,
-0.0262053553,
0.0472706296,
-0.0625989214,
0.0564888157,
-0.0355245024,
0.0501258224,
0.0146651166,
-0.0216219537,
0.0068701599,
0.0373423919,
-0.0026037504,
0.0410435162,
0.011106981,
0.0312265977,
-0.0146241365,
0.0186214149,
0.0138435829,
0.0230298787,
-0.0313576646,
-0.0627431273,
0.0054454929,
0.0315107256,
0.0026662794,
-0.0422612242,
0.0176185947,
0.0284187291,
0.001813992,
0.0023994236,
-0.0337467268,
0.0428826474,
0.0179672949,
0.0401810594,
0.0016365509,
-0.0132416273,
0.0032113753,
0.0466713458,
0.0416043252,
0.0325738564,
-0.0310857985,
-0.0445523597,
0.0011713105,
-0.0286937188,
0.0399026945,
0.0182067621,
0.0006402909,
-0.0123453615,
-0.0918935388,
-0.0317091234,
-0.0223826542,
-0.0266994108,
0.0322440825,
-0.0175051522,
0.0002909972,
0.0500497259,
-0.018452039,
-0.0157216508,
-0.0125875482,
-0.0136841554,
-0.0314986184,
-0.0295536127,
-0.0222091172,
-6.155177152e-33,
-0.0202916134,
-0.0285332669,
-0.0012797805,
-0.0216108114,
-0.0052027749,
0.0091275238,
0.0379825979,
-0.0112902904,
0.0007327758,
-0.0277491678,
-0.0409920625,
0.0352133475,
0.0099118045,
0.0057001933,
0.0126167163,
0.0202002805,
0.0496411026,
0.0245738029,
-0.0055347821,
0.0059231715,
-0.0321023799,
0.0261705648,
0.0268411897,
-0.044949241,
0.0662854314,
-0.020245336,
-0.0166796222,
0.0224183071,
0.0082145659,
0.0569107123,
-0.0185503587,
0.0571494922,
0.0299774799,
-0.0424238741,
0.0021848199,
0.0483529083,
-0.0364216492,
0.0011059304,
0.0316337124,
0.0201099701,
0.0588762835,
-0.0376735404,
0.0249744691,
0.0177490134,
-0.0687430725,
0.0044516469,
0.0808632672,
-0.0082920948,
0.0443647988,
0.0515671745,
0.0052834488,
0.0504495874,
-0.0573446713,
0.0444784015,
0.0202935394,
0.0002234938,
0.004269409,
0.0631802529,
-0.0750938356,
0.0142909745,
-0.0272923652,
0.0135664297,
0.0223550964,
-0.0077786637,
0.0244486015,
0.0317424424,
0.0919574499,
0.0529174507,
-0.0001875627,
-0.0834652856,
0.0110040661,
-0.0181127321,
-0.0266046859,
0.0600651056,
0.0540969037,
-0.0473693907,
-0.0188621543,
-0.0181631651,
0.0147674317,
-0.0328092389,
0.0296869949,
0.0056394553,
-0.0793078467,
-0.05593732,
-0.0265151225,
-0.0625496134,
-0.0331486166,
-0.0181232989,
0.035621129,
0.0095827719,
0.0241949465,
0.0306326821,
-0.0059149354,
-0.0478789583,
-0.0269698929,
-0.0062260875,
-0.0502840132,
-0.0422352068,
0.0077325669,
0.0168525483,
-0.0765534341,
-0.0058649369,
0.0000724504,
0.0274001155,
0.0475643426,
0.052910082,
-0.0256261304,
-0.0040293853,
-0.1045061722,
-0.0054914118,
-0.0105151711,
0.0175443497,
-0.016523879,
-0.0035952232,
0.0466112271,
0.0323740356,
0.0503570475,
-0.0043925731,
0.0755482092,
0.0247789174,
-0.0406666398,
-0.0692706779,
0.0012189394,
0.0213322118,
-0.0007781337,
-0.0000360588,
-0.0026619278,
0.0006242779,
0.0315311626,
-0.0359219685,
-0.0170070026,
-0.0372117199,
2.556e-7,
0.0119801434,
0.0512994267,
-0.0461680107,
0.0059563764,
0.0476133674,
0.013446182,
0.0288706645,
0.0594956502,
0.0687505007,
0.0313702933,
-0.0546734482,
0.037527997,
0.0149577754,
0.0263947304,
-0.0655278191,
0.0031160612,
-0.0688821971,
-0.0065739118,
-0.0537817664,
0.029919127,
0.0466841534,
0.0698895678,
0.0779643655,
0.0028060451,
-0.0576271825,
-0.0259973016,
0.040442992,
-0.0245980546,
-0.0083791614,
0.026510017,
0.027166523,
-0.0093127349,
0.00673213,
0.0638411194,
0.0134393247,
0.0450550765,
0.0438718945,
0.0472890995,
-0.0243754424,
0.0720439777,
0.0054990356,
-0.0210783482,
-0.0455052219,
-0.0530730933,
0.0683861449,
0.0209601168,
-0.0480793677,
-0.0505401529,
-0.0361497141,
-0.0314416848,
0.0421170518,
0.020601932,
-0.017370766,
0.0078068129,
0.0091350265,
-0.0042949566,
-0.0379645005,
-0.0366847105,
0.0152774742,
-0.0202634521,
-0.0205961876,
-0.1168456376,
0.0154697029,
0.0246214531,
0.0475353524,
-0.0186775289,
0.0235634893,
2.28173762e-34,
0.0378919132,
0.0489057936,
0.0169811938,
-0.0338871591,
0.0564290248,
0.0227796659,
0.0278200097,
-0.0104354592,
0.0284380689,
-0.027280191,
0.0180247892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05130v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05130v2 | Fast-DetectGPT: Efficient Zero-Shot Detection of Machine-Generated Text via Conditional Probability Curvature | 2023-10-08T11:41:28 | 2024-02-22T08:31:46 | Guangsheng Bao, Yanbin Zhao, Zhiyang Teng, Linyi Yang, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown the ability to produce fluent and
cogent content, presenting both productivity opportunities and societal risks.
To build trustworthy AI systems, it is imperative to distinguish between
machine-generated and human-authored content. The leading zero-shot detector,
DetectGPT, showcases commendable performance but is marred by its intensive
computational costs. In this paper, we introduce the concept of conditional
probability curvature to elucidate discrepancies in word choices between LLMs
and humans within a given context. Utilizing this curvature as a foundational
metric, we present **Fast-DetectGPT**, an optimized zero-shot detector, which
substitutes DetectGPT's perturbation step with a more efficient sampling step.
Our evaluations on various datasets, source models, and test conditions
indicate that Fast-DetectGPT not only surpasses DetectGPT by a relative around
75% in both the white-box and black-box settings but also accelerates the
detection process by a factor of 340, as detailed in Table 1. See
\url{https://github.com/baoguangsheng/fast-detect-gpt} for code, data, and
results. | [
0.0256056227,
0.03987398,
-0.0293937642,
0.0811364353,
-0.0581184961,
-0.00285774,
-0.0354107246,
0.0491527505,
0.0035188929,
-0.0199655537,
0.0134679303,
-0.024807401,
-0.001878157,
0.0641138777,
0.0165504552,
-0.0437010601,
0.0435275361,
-0.0223324597,
0.0464917868,
0.0224980153,
0.0293315277,
0.0332765765,
0.0046009212,
0.0339595154,
-0.0120643489,
-0.0182708874,
-0.0000281638,
0.0269586667,
0.0266381968,
-0.0257162154,
-0.0290471204,
0.0700370371,
-0.0197337437,
0.0986549482,
0.0000021387,
-0.0364671201,
-0.0237746574,
-0.0251837857,
-0.0252341386,
0.0107496735,
0.0386804566,
-0.0487405173,
-0.0344949625,
-0.0010773179,
-0.0259652995,
0.0065228404,
0.0367526263,
0.0269792788,
-0.0182856079,
0.0909509659,
-0.0238197222,
0.0325874537,
0.0423518643,
-0.0079135373,
0.0078495806,
-0.047921963,
0.0170036834,
-0.0243543237,
-0.0282415785,
0.0141612925,
-0.0012731365,
0.013401702,
0.0149644911,
-0.0216276068,
-0.0278055109,
0.0662701353,
-0.0257741995,
-0.0125881545,
-0.0036237857,
0.0705197752,
-0.0738847032,
-0.0620074049,
0.041529946,
-0.0413241237,
-0.0024163306,
0.0009752525,
0.0015396859,
0.0297181942,
-0.0466808118,
0.0221283529,
0.0066881226,
-0.0350231342,
0.0316158421,
0.0169942789,
0.016319504,
0.0647599176,
0.0431011692,
-0.058155667,
-0.0219197106,
0.0252933633,
-0.016526347,
-0.078030467,
0.0267964732,
-0.007465655,
-0.0119472565,
-0.0037984117,
-0.084260717,
-0.0250464529,
0.0187388062,
-0.012828663,
0.053100802,
0.0020229153,
0.0096176136,
0.0532921515,
-0.0587759838,
0.0599637032,
-0.0199143849,
0.0229823776,
-0.0223562773,
0.0271338541,
0.0033553035,
-0.0152651099,
-0.0345710181,
-0.0287246108,
0.0150637021,
-0.0349005051,
-0.0150266448,
0.0464298502,
0.0073838234,
0.0075440691,
0.0198357701,
-0.0293433834,
-0.0138180945,
-0.02895841,
0.0012524877,
-0.0049606836,
-0.021460101,
0.0030687582,
-0.0113306791,
-0.0581333674,
-0.0351118408,
0.0523612686,
0.039265316,
0.0125010619,
-0.0014239117,
0.0489050895,
-0.00598722,
-0.057816755,
-0.0208235383,
-0.0621532574,
-0.0400642566,
-0.044661928,
-0.0170383975,
-0.0718331933,
-0.0262846313,
-0.0187164377,
-0.0220413897,
-0.0026932298,
-0.0070819291,
0.0334230736,
-0.0433552563,
0.0465711281,
-0.0179499742,
0.0097852144,
0.0299650263,
-0.007766501,
-0.0469573587,
0.0861029625,
0.0329721868,
0.0481881611,
0.07178469,
0.0218927469,
0.0371978506,
0.0698099509,
0.0027038429,
0.0377186798,
0.0130297532,
-0.0520972349,
-0.0111592906,
0.0197261609,
0.0985216424,
0.0499683209,
-0.018726198,
-0.0315785818,
0.0692325607,
0.0565507412,
-0.0190803334,
-0.0330865644,
0.0746510401,
0.0521109439,
-0.0234232564,
0.0497170947,
-0.0149720935,
-0.0340144411,
-0.0494065247,
0.0021896013,
-0.0042490615,
0.0065803621,
0.0010392237,
0.0142824175,
-0.0029059886,
-0.0311148912,
0.0294998214,
-0.0355698764,
0.0688260123,
0.0060876142,
-0.0584491417,
-0.0060623754,
0.0014709666,
-0.0409760065,
0.0113216443,
-0.0810167789,
0.0802181885,
0.0366911963,
0.0635587722,
-0.0007013489,
0.0236717165,
0.0031269405,
-0.030973278,
0.0566311628,
0.0223520678,
0.0027181539,
-0.0079618534,
-0.0321639143,
0.0091000572,
0.0524972379,
0.045862861,
0.0313034244,
0.0406315364,
0.0416322313,
0.0285776332,
-0.0475132316,
-0.0057242448,
0.0431872122,
0.0254160315,
-0.0221436489,
0.0031622886,
-0.0049268631,
0.0188742485,
0.0012534643,
-0.0298356004,
0.002475787,
0.0162236374,
-0.0406243727,
-0.0199761055,
-0.0008834601,
-0.0050092568,
-0.0342011228,
0.0112490263,
-0.0470199771,
-0.0280433334,
0.0014881847,
-0.0175563898,
-0.0282797758,
-0.0049509993,
-0.0053531169,
0.033191774,
-0.0669359714,
0.0368382297,
-0.0214346237,
0.0259594489,
-0.0242560431,
0.061581526,
-0.0261439383,
-0.0095363315,
-0.0133723766,
0.0014883415,
0.0358655192,
-0.0496916808,
0.0152749894,
-0.0125426464,
-0.0019412896,
0.0193611048,
0.0281328093,
0.0265040025,
-0.0204511285,
-0.0479044318,
-0.0830638334,
-0.0105240373,
-0.0411112905,
0.0221944284,
0.0315334946,
-0.0168781225,
-0.0397763364,
0.0081527466,
0.0037753049,
0.0037206432,
0.0291439202,
0.0098281568,
0.0234754626,
-0.0477501638,
0.0107796369,
-0.0274732243,
0.0043487153,
-0.0219706483,
-0.0076323245,
0.045759514,
-0.0168401487,
-0.0393976457,
0.0281293318,
0.013501456,
-0.006998199,
0.0093352757,
-0.0400304534,
-0.010827478,
-0.0417178683,
0.0209536236,
0.077416338,
0.0042984411,
-0.0123220831,
0.0226164553,
0.0135560716,
-0.0040933769,
-0.0302260648,
0.002379874,
0.0035194601,
-0.019296227,
-0.0486485399,
0.0532172956,
0.0449331962,
0.0321975313,
-0.0039517637,
-0.0461016744,
-0.0028041359,
-0.0279070847,
-0.0236058645,
0.018215159,
-0.0255934019,
-0.041221723,
0.0393254943,
-0.0387864783,
-0.0450694114,
0.0505848639,
-0.060841985,
0.0388979688,
-0.013909976,
-0.0088276509,
-0.0042287568,
-0.0089778826,
0.0691381842,
0.0351180434,
-0.0066739861,
-0.003556988,
-0.016204793,
0.0257430524,
0.0484105907,
-0.0057237265,
0.0164846852,
-0.0418901332,
0.0254389513,
-0.0064583062,
-0.0295503065,
-0.028452158,
-0.0482989252,
-0.0396954902,
-0.0180241857,
0.011657007,
-0.0692830756,
0.01664529,
0.0252729319,
-0.0223617051,
0.0567287207,
-0.0201066714,
-0.0108643351,
-0.0388415903,
0.0678271502,
0.0726820156,
-0.0595886409,
0.0081981458,
-0.0597753674,
-0.0109004397,
0.0685592741,
0.0107380422,
0.0754360259,
-0.0075915111,
-0.0241439361,
-0.0004548572,
0.0058159065,
-0.030496439,
0.0249880403,
0.0238841996,
-0.0383378863,
0.0081160245,
0.1278259754,
0.0028034737,
-0.0810617134,
-0.0170722045,
0.007096401,
0.0454315506,
-0.0086508235,
-0.0034403512,
-0.0989776328,
-0.0348633155,
0.0279931519,
-0.0130145196,
-0.0668745041,
-0.0381497629,
0.0018053872,
-0.1038564146,
0.0524095558,
-0.0098425588,
-0.0348712243,
-0.0342818126,
-0.0337046087,
0.0105991568,
-0.0050095529,
-0.0237123091,
-0.0288967844,
0.0051952326,
0.0143131511,
-0.0262051094,
-0.044159241,
-0.0510540865,
0.0042111394,
-0.0574326478,
0.0216817148,
0.078349784,
0.0377110541,
-0.0354981534,
-0.0378887132,
0.0018022878,
-0.0024679552,
-0.0223787837,
0.0063488837,
0.0436358489,
-0.0244948342,
-0.0021806241,
0.0009096925,
0.0277886614,
-0.0242510382,
-0.0006348629,
0.0290895943,
0.0749204531,
-0.007537154,
-0.0563927926,
-0.0134000676,
-0.0281693581,
0.0321587697,
0.0870790258,
0.035369698,
-0.0281253476,
-0.0520469509,
-0.0318190977,
0.0277445838,
-0.0389604978,
-0.0111049488,
-0.0379402861,
-0.007887709,
-0.0441746339,
-0.0913351178,
0.0065842192,
0.0058496092,
0.0205893237,
0.001125187,
-0.0016873732,
0.0299635362,
-0.0096199717,
-0.0510492101,
-0.0241408311,
-0.0578945428,
0.0115818549,
-0.0848273858,
0.0213461071,
-0.0134378457,
-0.0015240797,
-0.0241308231,
0.0270457529,
-0.0933056921,
-0.0355919711,
0.0012140245,
-0.0034223252,
0.0232547298,
0.0244149305,
-0.0584435649,
-0.0378955901,
0.0596839897,
0.0203626305,
-0.0037586458,
0.045848228,
0.0082285628,
-0.0241778828,
-0.024698345,
0.0235868543,
-0.0086784856,
0.0034208263,
-0.0231999997,
-0.0189993568,
-0.0614138953,
-0.0419102572,
0.006059702,
0.0160888378,
0.0746768266,
-0.0265224613,
0.0411309153,
-0.0585927367,
-0.0354235433,
-0.0203457475,
0.0110755628,
-0.0325045027,
0.0033612922,
0.0355252102,
-0.0274697226,
-0.0160882622,
-0.0064153331,
-0.0518781133,
0.0324590914,
-0.0440778807,
-0.017002413,
0.0356991962,
0.0341966636,
0.0355311148,
-0.0415840857,
0.022305388,
0.0406607427,
-0.0269414913,
0.031289272,
-0.0147401262,
0.0534662642,
0.0154111562,
-0.0235602111,
0.0202166252,
0.0176905915,
-0.0624889992,
-0.0039769677,
-0.0329658836,
0.0753794238,
0.0767447278,
-0.0262799356,
0.060949631,
-0.0496844873,
-0.02444789,
-0.0381033868,
0.0211074986,
0.0265375711,
-0.0381892845,
0.0173049327,
0.0184248053,
-0.0260597318,
0.0377868116,
0.0900984555,
-0.0137004321,
0.0383645967,
-0.0026726939,
-0.0383142345,
-0.0207234118,
-0.001009512,
-0.0052769268,
0.0120001892,
-0.0038566671,
0.0435612053,
-0.0548185036,
-0.0593259968,
0.0084279403,
0.0049752453,
0.0042973887,
-0.0074902033,
0.0000926271,
0.0707903057,
-0.0310524367,
-0.0023241793,
-0.0643906146,
-0.0057856268,
-0.0219114199,
-0.0356062725,
-0.0172052402,
-6.380141057e-33,
0.0019272342,
-0.0642197356,
-0.0540316179,
0.0394399278,
0.0022592528,
0.0199235585,
-0.0117871398,
-0.0169763491,
-0.0097474838,
0.0411082543,
-0.0127242971,
0.0293078255,
0.0123552391,
0.0149446912,
0.0012710117,
-0.0072282073,
0.040579401,
-0.0237800647,
-0.0372514278,
0.0357741453,
0.0221433043,
0.0008160946,
0.0192038659,
-0.0525557883,
0.0178131647,
-0.01419097,
-0.0327038839,
0.0015007855,
-0.0192119274,
0.0629324391,
-0.0099037988,
0.0331491344,
0.0302458555,
0.025578687,
-0.009138315,
0.0328132026,
-0.0199337099,
-0.0085454369,
-0.0220279396,
-0.0001686358,
-0.0216824133,
-0.0659545437,
0.0098315803,
-0.0248715319,
-0.0090239234,
0.0219794493,
0.0347244069,
-0.0211928971,
-0.0366467163,
-0.0084977057,
-0.0423924699,
0.0623181425,
-0.0077287802,
0.0018208284,
0.0417405106,
0.0017516882,
0.0143588614,
0.0172836445,
-0.0353114158,
0.0154612008,
0.0108460719,
0.0399999768,
0.0381291248,
0.0210809056,
-0.0083196778,
0.0417924747,
0.0430905297,
-0.0110801617,
-0.0062039499,
-0.0074351341,
0.0280422699,
-0.014306956,
0.0251954887,
0.0622548275,
0.039892491,
-0.0286578871,
-0.0247213542,
0.0133970967,
0.0258566607,
0.0036650223,
0.0280411839,
-0.0051951641,
-0.0827303231,
-0.0295679271,
-0.0207705963,
-0.1166828275,
-0.0279864985,
0.007383341,
0.0084075322,
0.0359014831,
0.0117227342,
-0.0386535414,
0.0169744771,
-0.0377413183,
0.0319119021,
-0.0099479435,
-0.0415633395,
0.0177460611,
0.0220710132,
0.0564706139,
-0.0480429195,
-0.0090527823,
0.0275766384,
0.0259682965,
0.0132056167,
0.0183467139,
0.0333588794,
0.0174115263,
-0.0305578187,
0.0114584789,
-0.0163459592,
0.0006987208,
0.0027980059,
0.0346685611,
0.0286041666,
-0.0223864932,
-0.0018105679,
0.0303487331,
0.0384659506,
0.0224704724,
-0.0202390123,
0.0135427434,
-0.0434949994,
0.0166991409,
-0.0543296002,
0.0034861637,
-0.0093015376,
0.0027601889,
0.0452786461,
-0.0748043656,
0.0109735439,
-0.0042040255,
2.748e-7,
0.0413718373,
0.0631408244,
0.0143198855,
0.024033796,
0.0407010466,
0.0444646068,
0.0065375841,
0.034762565,
-0.0056101745,
0.0321386084,
0.0053978572,
0.0198823735,
0.0635843351,
0.0012074235,
-0.0831859335,
0.0591007844,
-0.0667367578,
-0.0005925942,
-0.0610745475,
0.0057549141,
0.0702808648,
0.0566292927,
0.0225409325,
-0.0326875933,
0.042594973,
-0.0596946217,
0.0420674309,
-0.0045860354,
0.025335012,
0.0130064217,
0.0701341256,
0.039434623,
-0.000650204,
0.0376169384,
-0.0169059876,
-0.0030946289,
0.0120346956,
0.0876477957,
0.0094276629,
0.0116897309,
0.0110310549,
-0.0404297039,
0.0069018472,
-0.0787445754,
0.1120729372,
0.0194121953,
0.0043182462,
-0.0531333908,
-0.0178769603,
-0.0410139039,
0.0216788221,
-0.0284662545,
-0.0518069603,
0.0266180839,
0.0280860402,
-0.0017187267,
-0.0216972716,
-0.0530771688,
-0.0112911537,
-0.0256622359,
-0.0298767891,
-0.0195619371,
-0.0196846258,
0.0003145564,
0.0542103536,
-0.0638024434,
0.0319530144,
2.986516967e-34,
0.0360432044,
-0.0111236274,
-0.0035933557,
-0.0260268822,
0.0315276161,
0.0270383693,
0.0382495001,
-0.0086044054,
-0.0104117021,
-0.0763932616,
0.0137008764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05128v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05128v3 | Instances and Labels: Hierarchy-aware Joint Supervised Contrastive Learning for Hierarchical Multi-Label Text Classification | 2023-10-08T11:36:45 | 2024-06-19T14:59:14 | Simon Yu, Jie He, Víctor Gutiérrez-Basulto, Jeff Z. Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Hierarchical multi-label text classification (HMTC) aims at utilizing a label
hierarchy in multi-label classification. Recent approaches to HMTC deal with
the problem of imposing an over-constrained premise on the output space by
using contrastive learning on generated samples in a semi-supervised manner to
bring text and label embeddings closer. However, the generation of samples
tends to introduce noise as it ignores the correlation between similar samples
in the same batch. One solution to this issue is supervised contrastive
learning, but it remains an underexplored topic in HMTC due to its complex
structured labels. To overcome this challenge, we propose $\textbf{HJCL}$, a
$\textbf{H}$ierarchy-aware $\textbf{J}$oint Supervised $\textbf{C}$ontrastive
$\textbf{L}$earning method that bridges the gap between supervised contrastive
learning and HMTC. Specifically, we employ both instance-wise and label-wise
contrastive learning techniques and carefully construct batches to fulfill the
contrastive learning objective. Extensive experiments on four multi-path HMTC
datasets demonstrate that HJCL achieves promising results and the effectiveness
of Contrastive Learning on HMTC. | [
0.0295252148,
0.0383662879,
0.0073674559,
0.0387593955,
-0.0350172818,
0.0209923796,
-0.005943479,
0.0322930217,
0.0356945321,
-0.0467470922,
-0.0521491021,
-0.0270594172,
-0.0312368367,
-0.0201237313,
0.0039543752,
-0.0912216306,
0.0072004804,
0.0087928111,
0.0005673804,
0.006627575,
-0.0085579939,
0.0092715109,
-0.0036734969,
-0.0027780347,
-0.0308672693,
-0.0622798242,
-0.0086089829,
0.0079196217,
0.0675138161,
-0.0430838279,
0.0582882576,
0.0344750211,
0.0072082966,
0.008124386,
0.0000021199,
-0.040580254,
0.0007714677,
0.0091225514,
0.0118589187,
-0.0008813046,
0.0851472169,
-0.0130741997,
0.010680031,
0.006009297,
0.0031885528,
-0.0281779431,
0.0099526215,
0.0691386536,
0.0236456394,
0.0169368871,
-0.0288496446,
-0.0417615622,
0.0189061891,
-0.0099845054,
0.0171252862,
-0.0193779226,
0.0243232474,
-0.0085827624,
-0.0171647351,
0.0665996447,
0.010944128,
0.0010117424,
0.0360458195,
0.0069361278,
0.0326483808,
0.0571246855,
0.0047854185,
0.0177502669,
0.0075422865,
0.0571783409,
-0.0019717852,
-0.0110510532,
-0.0050604963,
-0.025651563,
0.0016954764,
-0.0371172279,
0.0121839335,
0.0025987867,
-0.0336856134,
0.0096874004,
0.0811994001,
0.0633377284,
-0.0079568485,
-0.0039757132,
0.0106963189,
0.0149279265,
-0.0137413424,
-0.0424243547,
0.0171549451,
0.0432461463,
0.03526593,
-0.0139926225,
0.0109432014,
0.0180591419,
-0.0058994149,
0.0020114975,
-0.0163171589,
-0.069667764,
0.0244179871,
-0.0779015645,
-0.0083223525,
-0.0242854655,
-0.0514330342,
0.0234358013,
0.0438954271,
-0.0423086658,
-0.0252187699,
-0.0047121067,
-0.0188922379,
0.0029132396,
-0.0448657721,
-0.0049626869,
-0.0369304307,
0.0583676174,
0.0052167536,
0.0271881949,
-0.062651664,
0.0264755487,
-0.0082801366,
0.0030096453,
-0.0031304122,
-0.0108693792,
-0.0381381772,
0.0028701543,
0.0320083499,
-0.0100609772,
-0.0360526182,
0.0227709282,
-0.0293662772,
0.0071792221,
0.0030351016,
0.039377369,
0.0097802654,
-0.0202030428,
0.0099765453,
0.0905096158,
-0.0271836091,
-0.0551414676,
-0.1047622636,
-0.0004106666,
-0.0480637066,
-0.0257739872,
0.0096872523,
-0.0527304783,
0.0103254141,
-0.0159649737,
0.0194837004,
0.0059829429,
-0.0157172158,
-0.0031107028,
-0.0497412831,
0.0635799542,
-0.0035823595,
-0.0677815303,
0.052353967,
0.0110800704,
-0.0475587323,
0.0029969972,
0.02391872,
0.0146687916,
0.0336312279,
0.0149742477,
0.0118104191,
0.0015983189,
0.0104315886,
-0.002137986,
-0.025187308,
-0.005479774,
-0.0301395413,
0.0067435182,
0.0285613313,
0.0353329256,
-0.0216626655,
0.0058807423,
0.0255320538,
0.0257989038,
0.0134832803,
-0.0045336685,
0.0512147136,
0.0075201909,
-0.0465135798,
0.0512253232,
0.0193384197,
0.0348873325,
-0.0352516137,
0.0023871965,
0.0779621527,
0.001278526,
-0.0342021585,
-0.0720871687,
-0.0002636039,
-0.0169222336,
-0.0360763855,
-0.0407144949,
0.0791271329,
0.0344630182,
-0.0068268203,
-0.0414304063,
0.1091620997,
0.0003208833,
0.006870185,
-0.0093834223,
0.0114588588,
0.0581091307,
0.004759396,
-0.0513159186,
0.0403238647,
-0.0097929351,
-0.011735322,
0.0149914958,
0.0132308379,
-0.0349185243,
0.0336850844,
-0.0241874363,
-0.0337729268,
-0.0050666858,
0.0018492857,
0.0238720439,
-0.044614546,
0.0113927061,
0.0017342116,
-0.0080216546,
0.0109679615,
0.0152754905,
0.0055172234,
0.0074691633,
0.0680546835,
0.0459577367,
0.0636431351,
0.0093834633,
-0.0251593702,
-0.0340932459,
0.0293073785,
-0.0360348672,
-0.0257226378,
-0.0718399063,
-0.0145709198,
-0.1221996546,
0.0148865487,
-0.0204611048,
-0.0053940271,
-0.0033847007,
-0.0361545943,
-0.0071077789,
-0.0148125757,
-0.0237360094,
0.0128454948,
-0.0281217583,
-0.0157556422,
0.0284021646,
0.0117754387,
-0.035846062,
0.109282136,
0.0073344293,
0.0301318113,
-0.0281155184,
0.0197531115,
-0.010163418,
-0.0011189681,
-0.0066703516,
0.0173584577,
-0.0015681357,
0.0001105672,
0.0013788069,
0.0541030839,
-0.0467781834,
-0.0085622668,
0.0288281441,
-0.0160891935,
-0.0035304492,
0.006663647,
-0.0057845903,
-0.0422447957,
0.0405752026,
-0.0250134803,
-0.0318454318,
-0.0133938212,
-0.0640858412,
0.022988338,
0.0518279113,
-0.0025589678,
-0.0065283496,
0.0068149264,
-0.0207519978,
-0.0255685188,
0.0680875257,
-0.0171707291,
-0.0246589035,
-0.0226048455,
0.0182076395,
-0.0221127775,
-0.0093077831,
0.0201531127,
0.0251699854,
-0.0144510539,
-0.0066985521,
0.0248761922,
0.0389116257,
0.0189881735,
0.047005862,
0.0120105892,
0.0007069248,
-0.0194832087,
0.0289491378,
-0.0248704851,
0.043339394,
-0.0110073714,
-0.0161973871,
-0.0265865736,
0.0884566903,
0.0246930029,
0.0079339165,
-0.0347731002,
-0.0378106125,
-0.0148099046,
0.007037797,
-0.0439958498,
0.0517460555,
-0.0224452894,
0.0011748832,
0.0014388668,
-0.037016727,
0.0897829905,
0.0109347999,
0.0035393059,
-0.040373981,
-0.0433420613,
-0.0103737265,
0.0369462073,
0.0161618888,
0.0370636918,
0.0583059303,
-0.0178202447,
-0.0098116994,
0.0129204839,
0.0109806452,
-0.0152697815,
-0.008616698,
0.012472637,
0.0068300799,
-0.0192756448,
-0.0840036869,
-0.0092234425,
0.0061786915,
0.0155942952,
0.0078673493,
0.0221140403,
0.0127343042,
-0.0036748548,
-0.0001667602,
0.0356782861,
0.0557549745,
0.0280178655,
-0.0519657917,
-0.0042116926,
0.1089647785,
0.0186893065,
-0.062974669,
0.0024509444,
-0.0267445873,
0.0186317042,
0.0383563936,
0.0316436402,
-0.0210397039,
0.0016787002,
0.0297241751,
0.0317964219,
0.0024008271,
-0.0319956355,
0.0128272241,
-0.0396038182,
-0.0127877826,
-0.0242406521,
0.0670008659,
0.0318074971,
-0.0635809004,
0.0090923198,
0.0252541341,
0.030311469,
0.0015199051,
0.0164402779,
-0.0462230407,
-0.0085890517,
-0.0231950991,
0.0331365615,
0.0012877288,
-0.0154647836,
0.0211902391,
-0.0643454418,
0.0403740779,
-0.0014546298,
-0.0539566837,
-0.0039610923,
-0.047246512,
0.0052603814,
-0.0134919453,
-0.0352532715,
-0.0072930758,
0.0139355268,
-0.021076005,
0.0291487779,
-0.0264073648,
-0.026311757,
0.0623546503,
0.0074144849,
0.0015287945,
-0.0158901475,
0.0253103543,
-0.0086810654,
-0.0491856709,
-0.0184090324,
-0.0593849421,
-0.0466190875,
-0.0296577513,
0.0508492664,
-0.0554053858,
0.0014558117,
-0.0236795601,
0.0334850326,
-0.036634732,
-0.0277615804,
0.0033717279,
0.0585836992,
-0.010406374,
-0.0174501874,
-0.0440128893,
-0.0065269209,
0.0230266117,
0.0218328685,
-0.0057541225,
-0.1017038152,
0.0000726942,
0.0036843782,
-0.0065765046,
-0.0159657653,
0.0286404453,
0.0449481085,
-0.0470216274,
-0.0165715739,
-0.0514124557,
-0.0594982691,
-0.0420086868,
0.0533573627,
-0.0542177968,
0.0034675554,
-0.0280304402,
-0.0193945374,
-0.0397698469,
-0.01118859,
-0.019455336,
0.0142572634,
-0.0295742713,
-0.0143121285,
0.1034170017,
-0.0472794436,
-0.0609446131,
0.0088533824,
-0.0093918778,
-0.0609765947,
-0.0443867147,
0.0269816387,
-0.0063163773,
0.0489628725,
0.0197704937,
-0.0392784588,
0.0366243236,
0.0461709313,
-0.0264867153,
-0.0182453319,
0.0464568734,
0.0264815092,
-0.0141088925,
0.0293707438,
-0.0465316996,
0.0639062673,
0.0226170532,
0.0245483518,
-0.0481330045,
-0.0578353591,
-0.001340255,
-0.0439134166,
0.0929034501,
-0.0294904057,
-0.0116215432,
-0.0453391112,
0.0387257971,
0.0112163564,
-0.0673217401,
-0.0059261443,
0.0090432744,
0.017010361,
-0.0022465903,
-0.0505934507,
0.0174361151,
0.0197408292,
0.0361901633,
0.0316752493,
-0.0408945307,
-0.0170811843,
0.054246977,
0.010872121,
0.0031115783,
-0.0148566635,
-0.0408041552,
0.0339362919,
0.0257028863,
0.0070982915,
0.0552261956,
0.0401734039,
0.0150328577,
-0.0486801676,
-0.0134781608,
-0.0379805826,
0.1157785729,
-0.0618816912,
-0.0261494983,
0.0651357546,
0.0144028347,
0.0084935399,
-0.0393692218,
-0.0357524082,
-0.0207927339,
0.028099766,
0.0069856807,
-0.0500457622,
0.0137323188,
0.0078632124,
-0.0307170972,
0.0289871879,
0.0667250156,
0.0340037309,
0.0006041397,
0.0121483533,
-0.0130864959,
-0.053779304,
0.0206376966,
0.0355136916,
0.0631445274,
0.0185333751,
0.02351919,
-0.0475609228,
-0.0434731767,
0.0728748888,
-0.0021606958,
-0.0059612081,
0.0282178801,
0.0409476981,
0.0241644308,
0.013400103,
-0.0456253961,
-0.0474101603,
-0.0399537832,
0.037165191,
-0.0229551978,
-0.0288015585,
-6.469151693e-33,
-0.0220686179,
-0.0292691942,
-0.0143600209,
0.0460359082,
0.0180471074,
0.020153841,
0.0049995449,
-0.0189708229,
-0.0138845462,
0.0485009737,
-0.0080042249,
-0.0174644087,
0.0039564422,
0.0625428483,
0.0223087166,
0.02032784,
0.0088603413,
-0.0142278569,
-0.0049090385,
0.0425510332,
0.0273357052,
0.0272721015,
0.080172807,
-0.096169807,
-0.0038820209,
-0.024460962,
-0.0092083123,
0.0258196183,
0.0068390439,
0.0476508439,
-0.0330213644,
0.0661025047,
0.0494758189,
-0.0246417858,
0.0446309559,
0.0122893807,
-0.0976136997,
-0.0380212776,
-0.0720185637,
-0.0200509429,
-0.0837909058,
-0.0336425044,
-0.0243382752,
0.0614020862,
0.0006362094,
-0.0462494977,
0.0719374344,
-0.0112512084,
-0.0288249943,
-0.1043059677,
-0.0229251571,
0.0438510142,
-0.0188915301,
-0.0031143532,
-0.0191796403,
0.0223238301,
0.0320315249,
0.090436019,
-0.1027054489,
0.012651274,
-0.0207403731,
-0.0108516384,
-0.025649691,
0.0390332155,
0.005503302,
0.021285383,
0.030545976,
0.0324979648,
0.0576054305,
-0.0069240462,
-0.0147267571,
0.0123960134,
-0.0173625555,
0.0625592023,
0.0193822049,
0.0048893848,
-0.0917116851,
0.0211189259,
-0.0107382163,
-0.0374037661,
0.0012314983,
0.0179085284,
-0.0256793089,
-0.0149186151,
-0.0195225291,
-0.0558197498,
-0.0395492949,
-0.0075653642,
0.0032094854,
0.0243881252,
0.0109467991,
0.0082029039,
0.0081861271,
-0.017395772,
-0.0855493248,
-0.0046261516,
-0.026673615,
0.0594014153,
-0.0078185042,
-0.0015255654,
-0.0550388284,
-0.0476643592,
0.0043094321,
0.0036321611,
-0.0006460588,
-0.0119039826,
0.1058915704,
-0.016092604,
-0.0702197775,
0.00653507,
0.0249879826,
-0.0061188554,
0.0017847066,
0.0002017776,
0.0252765827,
-0.0161176454,
0.0177873205,
0.114109464,
0.0503468998,
-0.0131112849,
-0.0054605766,
-0.0072999448,
-0.0251319651,
0.0157905892,
0.015258966,
-0.0021418454,
-0.0060798051,
0.0121941855,
0.0616636947,
-0.0646199435,
0.0081953499,
0.0067443927,
2.8e-7,
0.0204992164,
0.0201081149,
-0.0039012865,
-0.0392189585,
0.0264076181,
0.0662974194,
0.0035551924,
0.0193508603,
-0.0513332635,
-0.0101510491,
0.0419463813,
-0.0250684321,
0.0589166619,
0.0236903876,
-0.0163802095,
-0.006298312,
-0.0807917044,
-0.0304023493,
-0.0612384789,
0.0027520487,
0.0985420272,
0.0550609753,
0.0501824766,
-0.0244739614,
-0.0004265015,
-0.0062976349,
0.0507759489,
0.0422549546,
0.019168403,
0.0221132487,
-0.0366909094,
0.0000131347,
-0.0114815468,
0.0216106586,
-0.0538985245,
0.0147136692,
0.0143837016,
0.0598276816,
-0.0125688445,
-0.0220196433,
0.0482884273,
0.0358094238,
0.0008545,
-0.0046347873,
0.0279227663,
-0.0683924481,
-0.0052424548,
0.0067544421,
-0.0244236533,
-0.0121044759,
0.0364940353,
-0.0063000266,
-0.0275534615,
0.0209755711,
-0.0117469141,
0.0327052064,
-0.0432383828,
-0.0878311023,
0.0334981531,
0.0723209754,
-0.0203801598,
0.003737472,
0.0338399373,
0.0091641778,
0.0528701842,
-0.032973744,
-0.0046711285,
2.210333915e-34,
0.0242325142,
-0.0542798601,
-0.0129182423,
-0.0230654571,
0.0029575867,
-0.0136199538,
-0.0722723752,
-0.0345541574,
0.0287170131,
-0.0282350406,
0.0190836862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05991v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05991v3 | Enhancing Document-level Event Argument Extraction with Contextual Clues and Role Relevance | 2023-10-08T11:29:10 | 2023-10-20T02:20:20 | Wanlong Liu, Shaohuan Cheng, Dingyi Zeng, Hong Qu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level event argument extraction poses new challenges of long input
and cross-sentence inference compared to its sentence-level counterpart.
However, most prior works focus on capturing the relations between candidate
arguments and the event trigger in each event, ignoring two crucial points: a)
non-argument contextual clue information; b) the relevance among argument
roles. In this paper, we propose a SCPRG (Span-trigger-based Contextual Pooling
and latent Role Guidance) model, which contains two novel and effective modules
for the above problem. The Span-Trigger-based Contextual Pooling(STCP)
adaptively selects and aggregates the information of non-argument clue words
based on the context attention weights of specific argument-trigger pairs from
pre-trained model. The Role-based Latent Information Guidance (RLIG) module
constructs latent role representations, makes them interact through
role-interactive encoding to capture semantic relevance, and merges them into
candidate arguments. Both STCP and RLIG introduce no more than 1% new
parameters compared with the base model and can be easily applied to other
event extraction models, which are compact and transplantable. Experiments on
two public datasets show that our SCPRG outperforms previous state-of-the-art
methods, with 1.13 F1 and 2.64 F1 improvements on RAMS and WikiEvents
respectively. Further analyses illustrate the interpretability of our model. | [
0.0418582223,
-0.0039695138,
0.0211500507,
0.066776365,
-0.0321488418,
0.0095871417,
0.0020917663,
-0.0471898019,
-0.0040442916,
-0.0599177741,
-0.0011753878,
-0.0033561289,
-0.03547832,
0.008954037,
0.0075131669,
-0.0547067933,
0.0362674743,
0.0016196659,
0.033304207,
0.0222799331,
0.0292288866,
0.0289692972,
-0.0140300151,
0.0499399491,
-0.0103338705,
-0.0345364474,
-0.0090172673,
-0.0017745659,
0.0512302779,
-0.022568278,
0.0154294809,
0.0065860022,
0.0477710254,
0.0132508716,
0.0000019,
-0.0615567043,
-0.0302313939,
-0.0322206281,
-0.0449676998,
0.0089463443,
-0.0045821387,
0.0063268207,
-0.003496222,
-0.0199843328,
0.0010972582,
-0.0317270085,
0.0128362011,
0.0849594697,
-0.0074034198,
0.0866728574,
-0.0223456118,
-0.0237617809,
0.0073549165,
-0.0239925105,
-0.0036102799,
-0.0747795254,
0.0152920214,
0.0058860704,
0.0047587669,
0.0384198129,
0.003280604,
-0.0008697443,
0.0280692503,
-0.0274743345,
0.0017193168,
0.0385596901,
-0.0275932588,
0.0267539658,
-0.0193842389,
0.039222531,
-0.0253827702,
-0.0190957375,
0.01645476,
-0.0339464694,
0.0083071161,
0.0352898948,
-0.0472162887,
0.0355011187,
-0.0184946749,
0.0130750071,
0.0889987275,
0.0771728605,
0.0036886823,
0.0237378553,
0.0073067797,
0.0368306451,
0.0044305674,
-0.0219268631,
-0.0144445784,
0.0124693699,
-0.0506628379,
-0.0460874476,
0.0288715456,
0.0324539132,
0.0029157645,
0.0363174938,
-0.0458814539,
-0.0002104488,
0.0131600434,
-0.0961692333,
-0.0003944181,
0.0018529881,
-0.021892231,
0.0979837552,
-0.0158709902,
-0.0152963251,
-0.0248847194,
-0.0122468267,
-0.0250218827,
-0.0307106506,
0.0024803921,
0.011575751,
-0.0299749952,
0.0173460376,
-0.0562824681,
-0.0548785813,
0.0224428866,
0.0114834681,
0.0155214975,
-0.0194456093,
0.0046726214,
0.0079652211,
-0.026133921,
-0.0124587817,
0.0137862181,
-0.0086006271,
-0.0350604989,
0.0239785593,
0.0091965832,
-0.0140681658,
-0.0543708168,
0.0208813436,
0.0434611812,
-0.0366710722,
-0.0217925627,
0.0091572879,
-0.0284654908,
-0.0300289094,
-0.0307016857,
-0.044110328,
-0.0342224687,
-0.026754098,
-0.0270631388,
-0.0288819429,
0.0425320081,
-0.0196220912,
-0.0161033943,
0.0068158242,
0.0080094784,
0.0123601537,
-0.0207829196,
0.0327056572,
0.0180844292,
-0.038372416,
0.0172643475,
0.0251641944,
-0.0106855007,
0.083138369,
0.0417184085,
0.0541228503,
0.052831497,
0.0289399531,
-0.0223218109,
-0.0175138693,
0.0350186117,
0.0005133147,
0.1092734933,
-0.0054940856,
-0.0116712954,
-0.0225029215,
0.040233653,
-0.0472134128,
-0.0593143143,
-0.0128189493,
0.0240224134,
0.0272545218,
0.0328198001,
-0.0054900241,
0.053106714,
0.0013112274,
0.0003465776,
0.0092264768,
-0.015822662,
-0.0157110803,
0.0033062389,
-0.0011823275,
-0.0031846361,
-0.0123661421,
-0.0207722336,
0.0066990866,
0.0108140968,
-0.0420706682,
-0.0217904449,
0.0079198238,
0.0417400301,
0.0021786718,
-0.0369603187,
0.066443339,
0.0294634327,
-0.0677538663,
-0.0009738767,
0.0116488794,
0.0202606078,
0.004017266,
0.0126273967,
-0.0647895187,
-0.0356913954,
0.0080204569,
0.065347828,
0.0171031635,
0.0387484692,
-0.0148521997,
0.0533380993,
-0.0577660762,
-0.0059462269,
-0.0300570261,
0.012439914,
0.0196877122,
0.0080376556,
-0.0086415727,
0.0247684475,
0.0197360665,
-0.0002337041,
0.0230797213,
0.0178223532,
-0.0695748404,
-0.0069155763,
-0.0050745904,
0.0365529582,
0.0301604625,
0.0213887356,
0.0074538691,
0.0305206683,
-0.0453793183,
-0.0144013539,
0.0429642051,
-0.0798710734,
-0.0563617498,
-0.0024136882,
0.0036752771,
-0.0095326332,
-0.0159967393,
-0.0457326137,
-0.0493854061,
0.0111987051,
-0.0047215805,
0.0158105046,
-0.0241730809,
0.0072574164,
0.0248688143,
0.0043789609,
-0.042876523,
0.0960892662,
0.0263679754,
-0.0163837839,
-0.0085178865,
0.0775567591,
0.0272367336,
-0.0472004786,
-0.0288310014,
0.0021783051,
-0.0036855706,
-0.0338985771,
0.0664515048,
-0.0356280692,
-0.0260527879,
0.0112309223,
-0.0880341008,
0.037352819,
-0.030055346,
0.0570903644,
0.0495210774,
0.0113331759,
0.0050323661,
-0.0005018887,
-0.0235665757,
-0.0735654533,
-0.0416420586,
-0.0097172884,
0.0251518767,
0.0169634931,
0.0311137531,
-0.057518743,
0.0119960504,
-0.0446243212,
0.0633159429,
0.006904636,
-0.0254488029,
-0.0162812974,
0.0236968286,
0.0470202267,
0.0213229582,
-0.0362979062,
0.008635168,
0.0056423964,
0.0056661176,
-0.0005057759,
0.0784879848,
0.0088001741,
0.0547399148,
-0.0136803705,
-0.0303582866,
-0.064812921,
0.0320497863,
-0.027142508,
0.030916322,
-0.0197837986,
0.0360942148,
0.0541005284,
0.0701158196,
-0.0008463219,
0.0161032993,
-0.0401407778,
-0.0537475385,
0.0212596413,
-0.0264107194,
0.0229188539,
-0.0788525045,
-0.0282281917,
-0.009949022,
-0.0621640682,
0.0100260191,
0.0655759573,
-0.0255497117,
-0.0269769225,
-0.0593800433,
-0.0127376281,
-0.0697267205,
0.0618944243,
-0.0204365719,
0.0058135944,
-0.0146192713,
-0.0416160263,
0.0288187023,
-0.0166936778,
0.045209337,
-0.0119257811,
0.039804481,
-0.0180408526,
0.0160499383,
-0.0450613536,
-0.0281944796,
-0.0356514603,
-0.0645507053,
0.0034287262,
-0.0018421297,
0.0024973764,
0.0163236596,
-0.0123678017,
0.0214933679,
0.0050519183,
0.0254796818,
-0.0101137897,
0.0155036803,
-0.0070710988,
0.048364047,
0.0174768604,
0.0323318169,
0.0138554098,
0.0239721183,
0.0486440584,
0.0956768468,
-0.0009551243,
-0.0157566816,
-0.0306062866,
-0.0038663906,
0.0031129878,
-0.051586125,
-0.0002374105,
-0.0553739816,
0.0643693954,
-0.0879875571,
0.0395125449,
0.0635446534,
0.0266134404,
-0.050861381,
-0.0067369803,
0.0215041712,
-0.0065422677,
-0.0257611871,
0.0063018124,
-0.0613696538,
-0.0377137177,
-0.0063496255,
-0.0223604515,
-0.0183874555,
-0.0277753416,
-0.0145119438,
-0.0713561699,
0.0155663444,
0.0077134296,
0.0086053414,
0.0187829081,
-0.0384130888,
0.0480652191,
-0.0187406447,
-0.0239524767,
0.0152782863,
-0.0182526093,
-0.0112015493,
0.0077046929,
-0.0418028198,
-0.0374160707,
0.0140786627,
-0.0354325622,
0.0071287919,
0.0298997741,
0.0370284431,
0.0431596264,
0.0344347395,
0.0360286385,
-0.0933430344,
-0.0140908426,
-0.0057306406,
0.0457454212,
-0.0496983342,
0.0132809114,
-0.0099953236,
0.0702318177,
-0.0250908956,
-0.0633051321,
-0.0013757842,
0.0458134077,
-0.0214082506,
0.0156710185,
-0.0066366536,
0.0116358986,
0.0333757177,
0.0707236826,
0.0234949868,
0.0206898898,
-0.022380475,
0.0068037342,
0.01362471,
-0.0709424913,
-0.0125053329,
-0.0177514795,
-0.0053844131,
-0.040130116,
-0.0512096696,
-0.0726106018,
0.0349339247,
0.0112154596,
-0.0493370146,
0.0381373912,
0.0026352494,
-0.0151299359,
-0.0140545508,
0.0378107913,
-0.0179995093,
0.0161054898,
0.0336105935,
0.0050160191,
0.0143891713,
0.0083774794,
-0.0255199857,
0.0430465899,
-0.0305745397,
-0.0479245745,
-0.0004101816,
-0.0190180689,
0.0056476719,
0.0480065793,
-0.0483534299,
-0.0211586859,
0.0370309167,
-0.0098621231,
-0.0133275157,
0.001732163,
0.0435448326,
0.0215482544,
-0.0079494249,
0.0304601882,
-0.0494947359,
0.0451399982,
-0.0105477711,
0.044068031,
-0.0811674148,
-0.0084055318,
0.0007575204,
-0.0240249131,
0.0552709252,
0.0044581685,
-0.0151098846,
-0.0250057112,
0.0329088345,
-0.0396334864,
0.0050572543,
-0.0379893743,
0.0354938768,
-0.0532420464,
-0.0304210857,
-0.0029683262,
0.0107574295,
0.011666826,
0.0030573385,
-0.0577138588,
0.0453842916,
0.0591052882,
0.0128174908,
-0.0429759771,
0.0369949229,
-0.0527273193,
0.0158572234,
-0.0050466564,
0.0138086984,
-0.0182453562,
0.0113803763,
0.0394413732,
-0.0365066938,
0.0072040972,
0.013388834,
-0.1296176016,
0.0345360711,
-0.0115054436,
-0.0292505622,
0.0546486229,
-0.0850105733,
0.0585709177,
0.0016322115,
-0.0009551552,
0.0166459642,
0.0050344323,
0.0225910563,
0.0106392708,
0.0284472853,
0.0350103565,
-0.0246872138,
0.030853238,
0.0473693088,
-0.0071034171,
0.0410079993,
0.0031750742,
-0.009507901,
-0.0261551812,
-0.0388881676,
0.0154611543,
0.0852396861,
-0.026320463,
-0.0281436946,
-0.0470578708,
0.0378050953,
-0.0054030102,
0.0010488653,
-0.0151351867,
-0.0030606566,
0.0208139159,
0.0523073375,
0.0214386731,
-0.0178495925,
-0.0234646723,
0.0022270835,
0.0054548499,
-0.0199885946,
-0.0389370769,
-6.003315037e-33,
-0.0274126437,
-0.0109781828,
-0.0063878614,
0.0838835388,
-0.0339835919,
0.0643815026,
-0.0339911766,
-0.0457249321,
-0.0100826705,
0.023965558,
-0.0015903279,
-0.0096377227,
0.0176717434,
-0.0036696855,
-0.0080596777,
-0.030837873,
0.0459383205,
0.0370656773,
-0.0005411021,
0.0322854631,
0.082353197,
0.0159179866,
0.0472105928,
-0.0985552892,
0.052619718,
0.00196295,
-0.0102727301,
-0.025196474,
0.0526782311,
0.0762981549,
0.0157976523,
0.0144595047,
0.0270300452,
-0.0529973507,
-0.00806865,
0.0662467778,
-0.1132683754,
-0.0332553983,
0.0391105562,
-0.0220417604,
-0.01867304,
-0.0656501129,
-0.0149979144,
0.0235538185,
0.0625212342,
-0.0510997698,
0.0236041136,
-0.0012175264,
-0.0211647041,
-0.0714783669,
-0.0674069524,
0.0573818386,
0.0062625017,
0.0083083762,
0.0151399476,
0.0130752558,
0.0264033619,
0.0616205297,
-0.0461274348,
-0.0232777577,
-0.0632431507,
0.0199565981,
-0.0103642996,
0.0137479659,
-0.0456625931,
0.0383868665,
-0.0441726707,
-0.0231523681,
-0.0501082577,
0.0186094884,
-0.0247089975,
0.0703364238,
0.0235543493,
0.0427015722,
0.0437126942,
0.0434853435,
-0.0902682096,
0.0184801072,
0.0602351129,
0.0297997091,
-0.0050589312,
0.0248779282,
-0.0473864153,
-0.0036482834,
-0.0046964549,
0.0152100502,
-0.0199014191,
-0.0193028133,
0.0044698184,
0.0294747334,
-0.0205032527,
0.0963654891,
0.0285015441,
-0.0141006745,
0.0069303187,
0.0117290178,
0.0164272562,
0.0152367447,
0.0012358407,
0.0071624266,
-0.0379348658,
-0.0096719852,
0.0395803712,
-0.0143304942,
0.0162943751,
0.0189293474,
0.029549662,
-0.0123248659,
-0.0248938724,
-0.0004810713,
-0.0166944489,
-0.0236208141,
-0.0570640713,
0.0385922417,
0.0060569081,
0.0042596688,
-0.0097456425,
0.0273421071,
0.0218249522,
0.0185388383,
-0.0012997168,
-0.0670974106,
-0.0313874744,
0.027486505,
0.008573181,
0.0047583161,
0.0201650299,
0.0248493589,
0.0397705473,
-0.026939895,
-0.0031679026,
0.0212630741,
2.576e-7,
0.0589908436,
0.0018400067,
0.0405642204,
-0.0015088796,
-0.0176535323,
0.0209994093,
0.0198218543,
0.0614321381,
0.0193105191,
0.0088257464,
0.0019486828,
0.0356853418,
0.0293332897,
0.0312436465,
-0.0794128105,
-0.064585723,
-0.065012522,
-0.0269524995,
-0.057779666,
-0.0172566697,
0.0864953175,
0.0863643661,
0.037815664,
-0.00200095,
-0.0048597907,
-0.0473004766,
0.0390534289,
-0.0023365777,
-0.0477185473,
0.0185733382,
0.04285267,
-0.0309346355,
-0.0325167403,
0.0362406597,
-0.024144927,
0.0615923963,
-0.0145222377,
0.0449164137,
-0.0122810379,
-0.0399229713,
-0.0250036102,
-0.0452092811,
0.0241396185,
-0.041060321,
0.0859646872,
-0.0383809432,
-0.0035114773,
-0.0384626277,
-0.0650961697,
0.0370013155,
-0.030121861,
0.0438646786,
-0.0254666843,
0.0284750219,
-0.0016188199,
-0.0214006584,
-0.0107070021,
-0.1351961792,
-0.031715069,
-0.0014426725,
-0.0181147642,
-0.0209864005,
-0.0207141321,
-0.0394464172,
0.0280203167,
-0.0409976952,
-0.0081132632,
2.389540325e-34,
0.0050702575,
0.0199161042,
-0.0074053765,
0.0368199572,
0.0396160856,
-0.0029658822,
-0.0301745273,
0.0017866278,
0.0233521778,
-0.0574078001,
-0.0024964416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05116v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05116v4 | Utilizing Contextual Clues and Role Correlations for Enhancing Document-level Event Argument Extraction | 2023-10-08T11:09:16 | 2024-04-03T05:41:05 | Wanlong Liu, Dingyi Zeng, Li Zhou, Yichen Xiao, Weishan Kong, Malu Zhang, Shaohuan Cheng, Hongyang Zhao, Wenyu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Document-level event argument extraction is a crucial yet challenging task
within the field of information extraction. Current mainstream approaches
primarily focus on the information interaction between event triggers and their
arguments, facing two limitations: insufficient context interaction and the
ignorance of event correlations. Here, we introduce a novel framework named
CARLG (Contextual Aggregation of clues and Role-based Latent Guidance),
comprising two innovative components: the Contextual Clues Aggregation (CCA)
and the Role-based Latent Information Guidance (RLIG). The CCA module leverages
the attention weights derived from a pre-trained encoder to adaptively
assimilates broader contextual information, while the RLIG module aims to
capture the semantic correlations among event roles. We then instantiate the
CARLG framework into two variants based on two types of current mainstream EAE
approaches. Notably, our CARLG framework introduces less than 1% new parameters
yet significantly improving the performance. Comprehensive experiments across
the RAMS, WikiEvents, and MLEE datasets confirm the superiority of CARLG,
showing significant superiority in terms of both performance and inference
speed compared to major benchmarks. Further analyses demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed modules. | [
0.0288957022,
0.0378711447,
0.0206356887,
0.0675981343,
-0.0243192744,
0.0264553428,
-0.0012127784,
-0.0337326042,
-0.0065987958,
-0.0568439476,
0.02209666,
0.0102411928,
-0.0303570926,
0.0149259716,
-0.0093873497,
-0.0486914888,
0.0259591285,
0.0268519204,
0.0331141725,
0.0199433565,
0.0328357145,
0.031462267,
-0.0164239779,
0.0542425588,
-0.0329007953,
-0.031038193,
0.0009227148,
0.0173449516,
0.0672238097,
-0.0214460641,
0.0112654548,
-0.0114052454,
0.0411894545,
0.0090940008,
0.0000019921,
-0.0763914809,
-0.0376684181,
-0.0214251392,
-0.0356480591,
0.0027818892,
-0.0246672146,
-0.0119627258,
-0.0084879696,
-0.0124639319,
-0.0006166646,
-0.037111979,
0.0220588818,
0.0840847343,
0.0023051924,
0.0988367349,
-0.0328518264,
-0.0494137965,
0.0241279155,
-0.0221096203,
0.0017482066,
-0.0621263161,
0.0181612093,
0.0013971858,
-0.0084851747,
0.0161123518,
0.0272071175,
-0.0007762048,
0.0460527129,
-0.0126939453,
-0.0208929405,
0.0346347615,
-0.0134765673,
0.0169391911,
-0.01868774,
0.0285339002,
-0.0102480752,
-0.0209557712,
0.0133041628,
-0.0193941798,
0.0047847,
0.0458848812,
-0.0344356336,
0.0447739102,
-0.0407671519,
0.0005604552,
0.102721937,
0.087926805,
-0.0007424995,
0.0056844996,
-0.002847184,
0.0394628048,
0.0029511177,
-0.0251609534,
-0.0071834498,
0.0139759891,
-0.041051656,
-0.0446698479,
0.0292716213,
0.0483832881,
0.0040173768,
0.0281019006,
-0.0504341982,
-0.0050384211,
0.0059578829,
-0.0918639526,
-0.0186851062,
0.0111455098,
-0.0075372518,
0.0993892848,
-0.0118671926,
-0.0086493464,
-0.019102186,
-0.0275905579,
-0.0083879838,
-0.0505855754,
0.0007675816,
0.0051707299,
-0.0400040187,
0.0129623627,
-0.0536736883,
-0.0345277041,
0.0223249272,
0.0158137642,
0.0085820379,
0.0111255823,
0.0069648526,
0.001085039,
-0.0267352797,
-0.0300043579,
0.0029238036,
-0.0085408362,
-0.0441887528,
0.0169284865,
0.0200018343,
-0.0031944474,
-0.0498720035,
0.0308226384,
0.0308381096,
-0.0426953584,
-0.0076015368,
0.0148591399,
-0.0228892006,
-0.0248314459,
-0.0307146162,
-0.0370091349,
-0.01746081,
-0.0268945228,
-0.0400917605,
-0.0315688588,
0.0480799973,
-0.0077509047,
-0.0177827086,
-0.0142056942,
-0.0041396399,
0.001261855,
-0.021301344,
0.0326887183,
-0.0016344344,
-0.0492556728,
0.0383325778,
0.0253239572,
-0.0252863206,
0.0770329088,
0.0418968312,
0.051496353,
0.0506178811,
0.0309804715,
-0.0222678781,
-0.0068576615,
0.024245318,
-0.0176869705,
0.0877006575,
-0.0112616075,
0.0025891261,
-0.0253492724,
0.0426520668,
-0.0372073613,
-0.0455717333,
-0.0256588738,
0.0158324763,
0.014818402,
-0.0063421526,
-0.0146414405,
0.0413887687,
-0.0121993003,
0.0235447455,
0.0075168209,
-0.0066237012,
-0.0076615084,
-0.0014752597,
0.0163401049,
-0.0016081698,
0.0211904999,
-0.0156177664,
-0.0118694594,
0.00589999,
-0.0380641185,
-0.0169882476,
0.0090139601,
0.0381908268,
0.0068601165,
-0.046254158,
0.025725333,
0.0494260266,
-0.0604885444,
-0.0038606969,
0.0134815974,
0.0198924635,
0.0046735234,
0.0403520092,
-0.0493283644,
-0.0462205037,
0.0064430404,
0.0365630686,
0.0134281134,
0.0412398502,
-0.0220531859,
0.0445790775,
-0.0449263714,
-0.0336631387,
-0.0240619127,
0.0096746488,
0.0119583961,
0.0099662235,
-0.0071147527,
0.0304405652,
0.0450294986,
-0.0145688904,
0.02045618,
0.0029202825,
-0.0519919246,
-0.0064909961,
0.0067525711,
0.0295261815,
0.0396195017,
0.0125988713,
-0.0039819158,
0.0373541601,
-0.0475203209,
0.0116351815,
0.0421269201,
-0.0506407991,
-0.0504577607,
-0.0055007963,
-0.00567271,
-0.0348793194,
-0.0039598639,
-0.0327016301,
-0.0504256226,
-0.0049747447,
-0.0035775674,
0.0333269201,
-0.0150095504,
-0.0017087564,
0.0281348247,
-0.0046151737,
-0.0262485258,
0.0941937044,
0.033745978,
-0.0433559194,
0.0022173873,
0.0620635822,
0.0030856736,
-0.029737683,
-0.0125788385,
-0.0044078166,
0.0111896452,
-0.0333554223,
0.0608524829,
-0.0553734861,
-0.0300430451,
0.0080423774,
-0.0837393552,
0.0301607586,
-0.0359765999,
0.0519972667,
0.050126072,
0.0117662428,
-0.0094372584,
-0.0024306325,
-0.0112738293,
-0.0756688118,
-0.0449117236,
0.0007614199,
0.026940329,
0.0180015992,
0.0221645106,
-0.0523935556,
0.0076091061,
-0.0445313975,
0.0671169236,
0.0331759416,
-0.0325333327,
-0.0224807784,
0.0206079967,
0.0178402942,
0.007164753,
-0.0417302586,
0.0103040142,
0.0075014057,
0.0111332452,
0.0202083327,
0.0800465569,
0.016741557,
0.0788393468,
-0.0223931912,
-0.0294620078,
-0.0521249399,
0.0208792072,
-0.04607917,
0.0407079346,
-0.0170792583,
0.0291393306,
0.0509979203,
0.0783309042,
-0.0126859033,
0.0305470936,
-0.023206057,
-0.0192888603,
0.0320350341,
-0.0104240179,
0.0176277403,
-0.0702066571,
-0.0123040164,
0.0088965809,
-0.0623442717,
0.013561069,
0.0848269314,
-0.0182906333,
-0.0137183294,
-0.058074154,
0.0043230322,
-0.0531104207,
0.057176251,
-0.0086047808,
0.0034497951,
0.0050635603,
-0.0411970355,
0.0387489684,
-0.0110365469,
0.0532339513,
-0.0116918581,
0.0197300538,
-0.0229186174,
0.0224123225,
-0.0283027086,
-0.0241656024,
-0.0436928645,
-0.0414259918,
0.0063999789,
0.0023061601,
0.0156211369,
0.0088377288,
-0.0590995736,
0.0138579831,
0.0056405584,
0.0408456288,
-0.0028368854,
0.0002511038,
0.0017099398,
0.0618743226,
0.0275884513,
0.0105006769,
0.0162152071,
0.0073211687,
0.0324902534,
0.0853829384,
-0.0266815554,
-0.0417509191,
-0.0272328798,
-0.0240932237,
-0.0133450897,
-0.0674118325,
0.0197662301,
-0.0520938896,
0.0483911149,
-0.1076158658,
0.0361146629,
0.0813089907,
0.0209221374,
-0.0553227849,
-0.0198420752,
0.0111167766,
0.0093541322,
-0.0150222341,
0.0089981128,
-0.0496063717,
-0.0421332866,
-0.0057401042,
-0.0157612935,
-0.012647327,
-0.0228401609,
0.0015735283,
-0.0481813513,
0.0272205546,
0.0000505119,
-0.0087134577,
-0.0056366245,
-0.0702303052,
0.0452668779,
-0.0330481492,
-0.008148144,
0.0152541045,
-0.0119516579,
-0.0070304913,
0.0024057431,
-0.0460148379,
-0.0389194414,
-0.0134265544,
-0.0252850223,
0.003573763,
0.0224332921,
0.0087520191,
0.0266876724,
0.0284610614,
0.0189461876,
-0.0779644027,
-0.0141487559,
-0.0091872392,
0.0505893677,
-0.0656354204,
0.0144269671,
-0.0103673516,
0.0640263557,
-0.015596441,
-0.0569283701,
0.0193409249,
0.0531821623,
-0.0116974022,
0.0175644569,
-0.0101172375,
-0.0252335109,
0.0179659277,
0.0688089281,
0.0281153899,
0.0275799688,
-0.0172702502,
0.00034728,
0.0004154723,
-0.0386186391,
0.0068213074,
-0.0320359543,
-0.0085908212,
-0.023065215,
-0.0617544316,
-0.0867730975,
0.0192766767,
0.0137987118,
-0.0446319208,
0.0054116207,
0.0140829645,
-0.0165176876,
-0.0589424446,
0.0324869677,
-0.0078183524,
-0.0112799788,
0.0317197219,
0.0108270189,
0.0121046994,
0.0211212784,
-0.0213926323,
0.0429326259,
-0.0051578786,
-0.0433535092,
-0.0102352789,
-0.0146127092,
0.008313681,
0.068154037,
-0.0379019193,
-0.0258176904,
0.0349049158,
-0.0043030223,
-0.0071485997,
-0.0229341164,
0.0334426612,
-0.0043910155,
-0.0019110874,
0.0176543687,
-0.030825438,
0.0597171001,
-0.0323327109,
0.0251726005,
-0.0842830688,
-0.0343753919,
0.0028921997,
-0.0332679376,
0.0568441153,
-0.0067984522,
-0.0092005432,
-0.0347961001,
0.0346990637,
-0.0578682832,
0.0093352143,
-0.0226607528,
0.046254456,
-0.0517950803,
-0.0228567291,
0.0073839813,
0.0310604982,
0.0089065824,
-0.001798272,
-0.0486391075,
0.0473686755,
0.0126089975,
0.0245923027,
-0.0279395916,
0.0081907324,
-0.0436049476,
0.0085565289,
0.0127000036,
0.033719223,
-0.0166925769,
0.0252299346,
0.0394512564,
-0.0247766469,
0.0121094473,
0.0099691916,
-0.1097034812,
0.0201848242,
-0.0199903231,
-0.0280134436,
0.0551924929,
-0.0801880211,
0.0782629848,
-0.0041433349,
-0.0018755968,
0.0165474117,
0.0095681995,
0.0259149577,
0.0105141699,
0.0164998975,
0.0208828617,
-0.0251548551,
0.0527511425,
0.0501721203,
-0.0357620008,
0.0398985445,
-0.0117637515,
-0.0139237512,
-0.0189842694,
-0.0539382882,
0.0421890393,
0.0644687489,
-0.0357160904,
-0.0362952575,
-0.0360687524,
0.0275732093,
0.0037118592,
0.006407131,
-0.0231761616,
0.0144334268,
0.0117029697,
0.0327602737,
0.0276391692,
-0.0310636219,
-0.0094273919,
0.0057545542,
-0.0300770197,
-0.0225271806,
-0.0278121103,
-6.191083361e-33,
-0.0212150086,
-0.0169245563,
-0.0126354806,
0.0843820721,
-0.0115643442,
0.0667066425,
-0.0349390619,
-0.0634704828,
0.0005138346,
0.033064574,
0.0024663873,
-0.0118759908,
0.0127461711,
-0.0002816562,
-0.0117699495,
-0.0181182344,
0.0373523086,
0.0441040285,
-0.0157813542,
0.0335993916,
0.0703744665,
0.0009541611,
0.0608199425,
-0.1106127277,
0.0598505326,
0.0107254265,
-0.0074603721,
-0.0228421651,
0.040464852,
0.0782844573,
0.0118634077,
0.0038525367,
0.0188551713,
-0.0536638536,
-0.0037477645,
0.0513598435,
-0.1045908779,
-0.0396984406,
0.021718353,
-0.0223784111,
-0.0244952086,
-0.0581664592,
0.0135519337,
0.0194504056,
0.0633005202,
-0.0443394296,
0.0350858793,
-0.0057739401,
-0.0119992066,
-0.0945876092,
-0.0764160827,
0.0728381798,
-0.0026022159,
0.0255308542,
0.016628392,
0.0083934115,
0.0323349833,
0.0526181646,
-0.0579755381,
-0.0369056389,
-0.0731916428,
0.010170823,
-0.001777672,
0.004340779,
-0.0370188244,
0.0407423638,
-0.0301328655,
0.0018554254,
-0.0487997271,
0.0378546454,
-0.0434640981,
0.054433018,
0.0263919998,
0.0476367101,
0.0623533092,
0.0328704081,
-0.1038589925,
0.0495758317,
0.057374768,
0.0415507816,
-0.0084681306,
0.015593823,
-0.0625504777,
0.0159078371,
0.0040521878,
0.0300452113,
-0.0135120954,
-0.0213980507,
-0.0149613898,
0.0123834908,
-0.0243146177,
0.0897601619,
0.0143441809,
-0.0240751989,
0.0241238941,
0.0140275676,
0.0088800658,
0.0098293591,
-0.0082444502,
-0.003261508,
-0.0428090654,
-0.0055097817,
0.044580996,
-0.0130879097,
0.0195958149,
0.0122678587,
0.0380493887,
-0.0240775589,
-0.0188375469,
-0.0009485696,
0.0007516282,
-0.000699399,
-0.0474549457,
0.0000975511,
0.0212112293,
0.0097914385,
0.0002322963,
0.0317738354,
0.0109318802,
0.0275550485,
-0.0238229278,
-0.0614863373,
-0.0123029025,
0.0321097299,
0.0173413847,
0.0022627052,
0.0155644715,
0.0092153754,
0.0126283197,
-0.0294143539,
0.0005807242,
0.0068063675,
2.623e-7,
0.0598184317,
0.0041637244,
0.0643279925,
0.0090209041,
-0.0103766387,
0.0121948123,
0.0411718786,
0.0463911854,
0.0305072907,
-0.0102811046,
0.0162246432,
0.0366151594,
0.031016469,
0.0263457354,
-0.0551672652,
-0.085840486,
-0.0547983684,
-0.0455637984,
-0.0684259608,
-0.0023885835,
0.1066875681,
0.0574370548,
0.0335691832,
-0.0070406715,
-0.0175949521,
-0.0128570804,
0.0535166003,
-0.0016086298,
-0.0386995189,
0.0250841621,
0.0425456874,
-0.0393340327,
-0.0280332621,
0.0513260551,
-0.0265994649,
0.060823556,
-0.0207854267,
0.052969873,
-0.0156844053,
-0.0299491603,
-0.0126382131,
-0.0427905321,
0.0216956884,
-0.0438104495,
0.0938211009,
-0.047903344,
-0.0050937347,
-0.0188527722,
-0.0946726128,
0.0504115932,
-0.0348814502,
0.0367542915,
-0.027764149,
0.0337141119,
-0.0126164937,
-0.0160251148,
-0.0129785044,
-0.1279869229,
-0.0205947887,
0.0196311343,
-0.0027067736,
-0.0168173872,
0.0063192644,
-0.0568016917,
0.0332237631,
-0.0396237597,
0.0001223547,
2.368093292e-34,
0.0258844178,
0.0160217211,
-0.0088298786,
0.0392939374,
0.0530094989,
-0.0083924383,
-0.0591060333,
-0.0061840913,
0.0121073425,
-0.0464048423,
0.0025566826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05115v1 | Breaking Down Word Semantics from Pre-trained Language Models through Layer-wise Dimension Selection | 2023-10-08T11:07:19 | 2023-10-08T11:07:19 | Nayoung Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Contextual word embeddings obtained from pre-trained language model (PLM)
have proven effective for various natural language processing tasks at the word
level. However, interpreting the hidden aspects within embeddings, such as
syntax and semantics, remains challenging. Disentangled representation learning
has emerged as a promising approach, which separates specific aspects into
distinct embeddings. Furthermore, different linguistic knowledge is believed to
be stored in different layers of PLM. This paper aims to disentangle semantic
sense from BERT by applying a binary mask to middle outputs across the layers,
without updating pre-trained parameters. The disentangled embeddings are
evaluated through binary classification to determine if the target word in two
different sentences has the same meaning. Experiments with cased
BERT$_{\texttt{base}}$ show that leveraging layer-wise information is effective
and disentangling semantic sense further improve performance. | [
0.0015934762,
0.0580784716,
-0.0290109795,
0.0916576013,
-0.0387018248,
0.0385375395,
-0.0059095086,
-0.0074763438,
-0.0032950977,
-0.0523433685,
-0.0221384205,
0.0076771923,
-0.0043927133,
0.0494483188,
0.0067230933,
-0.0355714969,
0.0601181351,
0.0331932977,
-0.0223319344,
0.0008523185,
0.0120712491,
-0.0049889968,
0.005105373,
0.020117145,
0.0157680046,
-0.0063340976,
0.0024170973,
-0.0212617256,
0.0191015769,
-0.0268037263,
0.0088078408,
0.0254503265,
0.0793466792,
0.0407881774,
0.0000019993,
-0.0397428498,
-0.0243674219,
-0.0267481338,
-0.0269735716,
-0.0252277926,
-0.0325566716,
-0.0195020679,
0.0271676481,
-0.0063533811,
-0.0461357236,
-0.0453001931,
0.0144744376,
0.0253030583,
0.0581310131,
0.0445968919,
-0.0272870604,
-0.034817975,
0.002755953,
-0.0255922992,
-0.0279309172,
-0.0010229289,
0.0180667918,
-0.0132170171,
-0.0576568432,
-0.0166767146,
-0.0564524457,
-0.006070327,
0.0239351466,
0.0262343418,
0.0030273367,
0.0479758568,
-0.0346507765,
-0.0255182497,
-0.0028030749,
0.1148354933,
-0.0434008539,
-0.0183676314,
0.0051882071,
-0.0213428121,
-0.0510879941,
-0.0061742854,
-0.0086326236,
0.0125423893,
0.034958344,
0.0702118725,
0.0165222175,
0.0605517477,
0.0313548334,
0.0151917925,
-0.0563000068,
0.037247926,
0.0331130959,
-0.0231531709,
-0.0135351997,
-0.001070022,
0.0251057148,
-0.0183927193,
0.009320599,
-0.0048783435,
0.0281284209,
0.0151930433,
-0.0505968705,
-0.0380743854,
-0.0270528272,
-0.08469484,
0.0324921161,
0.037595924,
-0.0219876096,
0.0545864291,
-0.0555534326,
0.017799722,
-0.0003905934,
0.0769083723,
-0.030631559,
-0.0097223204,
-0.0429229438,
-0.0124158943,
-0.0403833687,
0.0854327306,
-0.054821007,
-0.0858824849,
0.0042628222,
0.0130735273,
-0.0207752734,
0.007351019,
-0.0346033797,
-0.000198918,
-0.0085623981,
0.0016637514,
-0.0265775137,
0.0042003915,
-0.0383839272,
0.0162941646,
-0.0698923171,
-0.0191939399,
-0.0076929685,
0.0352885462,
0.021554349,
-0.0489439666,
-0.0022779328,
0.0433556773,
-0.0107067525,
-0.0582052693,
-0.0191640891,
0.0074022287,
0.0146219097,
-0.0125591997,
0.0048836479,
-0.0340982676,
0.0417239144,
0.0000614905,
-0.0057562878,
-0.044379469,
0.0050807372,
-0.0324739926,
-0.0203883741,
0.1014273837,
-0.0347018242,
-0.0309663098,
-0.0015169361,
0.0378454626,
0.0245853737,
0.066505,
0.0403165929,
0.040084783,
0.0270074904,
-0.0141659072,
-0.0430695079,
-0.0308385156,
0.0281331409,
0.000709777,
-0.085488908,
0.0175143126,
0.0175131727,
0.0095199337,
0.0193527378,
0.0481076241,
-0.0760865286,
-0.0008777797,
0.0390660614,
0.0526189916,
0.0505896434,
0.0171242487,
0.0015392635,
0.0352591574,
-0.0225477591,
0.0277100485,
-0.0081173535,
0.0131783485,
-0.0190313533,
-0.0251885485,
0.0340324938,
0.0022708415,
-0.0520553142,
-0.0039207158,
0.0144304363,
-0.0288716443,
0.066132687,
-0.0170795228,
0.0366197601,
0.0287206899,
-0.0474447757,
0.0692106634,
0.0260171928,
-0.0438509732,
0.0210254379,
-0.0507691652,
-0.019710619,
0.0486782864,
0.0408351645,
-0.0273411274,
-0.0011658586,
-0.0023765184,
-0.0075978395,
0.0704305321,
-0.0159922764,
-0.0073270444,
0.0637162998,
-0.0611493476,
-0.0516893789,
-0.0502809919,
-0.0004420053,
0.0183703657,
-0.0052217953,
0.0065224334,
0.0297762118,
-0.0170436855,
0.0604780018,
0.0289421752,
-0.0230778605,
-0.0276934374,
-0.0112953195,
0.0310600363,
0.034453921,
-0.0183600578,
-0.0286420118,
0.0095837992,
0.024764806,
-0.069670856,
-0.0426340401,
-0.002417899,
-0.0176831353,
-0.0960442498,
-0.0029446608,
-0.0521002188,
0.0043149865,
0.0409389064,
-0.0393490903,
-0.0259700026,
0.0451914184,
-0.0115921907,
0.0942021981,
-0.0579090901,
-0.0135410707,
-0.0515517108,
0.0104476465,
-0.0293300711,
0.0663717166,
-0.0143048614,
0.0045548701,
-0.0365222879,
0.0426870994,
0.0283930413,
0.0291828364,
-0.0184852835,
0.0108052436,
0.0150415599,
-0.0025888667,
0.0117581971,
0.0062637706,
-0.0303624365,
-0.0443868227,
-0.0604819469,
-0.024194885,
-0.0084269373,
0.0136433765,
0.050592985,
0.0125357769,
0.0212517194,
-0.033155676,
0.0005856475,
-0.0108677009,
-0.0361533538,
0.0212323107,
0.0555063002,
-0.0334749632,
-0.0237768553,
-0.0378294215,
-0.0138037419,
-0.0053916192,
0.068876043,
-0.0349445753,
-0.038556397,
-0.0093895365,
-0.005480329,
-0.0434845798,
0.0259569716,
-0.0033958859,
-0.0350502767,
0.0160404723,
-0.0168536641,
-0.0069087455,
0.0443057008,
-0.0151103018,
0.1014457196,
0.092955336,
-0.0109913656,
-0.0422330685,
0.0055084084,
-0.0464816354,
0.0633370057,
-0.011185728,
0.0231603254,
0.0120542403,
0.0418248549,
0.0265189465,
0.0066558686,
-0.0501865894,
0.0063985954,
0.0040004873,
-0.0176167153,
-0.0514033698,
-0.0226301998,
-0.018183792,
0.0562397651,
-0.0279432759,
-0.0442541018,
0.0639532804,
-0.0262270197,
0.0234388243,
-0.0692375302,
-0.0086143464,
-0.0224596113,
0.1047540456,
-0.017261235,
0.0453990623,
-0.0763294995,
-0.0201463774,
-0.0478579812,
-0.0091825128,
0.0164085031,
-0.0196696036,
-0.0092371143,
-0.0145111019,
0.016662335,
0.0161103103,
-0.0107657863,
-0.0382246599,
-0.0686252117,
-0.0205644853,
0.0205282308,
0.0167885628,
0.0048814104,
-0.0007584143,
-0.0053126113,
-0.0188463349,
0.013925449,
0.0274686478,
0.0087517565,
-0.057705231,
0.0436893441,
0.034268707,
-0.0275439695,
0.018628398,
-0.0023283039,
0.0357987247,
-0.0033912926,
-0.025108438,
0.0075554997,
-0.0467404686,
0.0428609028,
0.0193657055,
-0.0115273558,
-0.0021177942,
-0.0281892102,
0.0100077251,
-0.0079096425,
-0.0123195723,
0.1182361171,
0.0234403256,
-0.0148436558,
0.0086479746,
0.0146886185,
-0.0101853553,
0.0022010256,
0.0032672277,
-0.0485559031,
-0.0473028459,
-0.0156097654,
-0.0308035035,
0.0470168255,
0.0057242191,
0.0096382657,
-0.0765626431,
-0.0368586928,
0.0031831828,
0.0136343753,
-0.0718173608,
-0.0452763774,
0.0130205089,
0.0232410394,
0.0229939222,
-0.0239928886,
0.0198180024,
-0.0151791777,
-0.02556674,
0.0183896255,
-0.0327620916,
0.0336825661,
-0.0207382645,
0.0134222573,
0.0983441919,
0.0506233275,
-0.0140257431,
-0.0560032092,
-0.0221214443,
-0.058074791,
-0.0467092954,
-0.0060114386,
0.0451855585,
-0.0237866845,
-0.01551711,
-0.0212313794,
0.0039353925,
-0.0167752821,
-0.0230695121,
-0.0518924445,
0.0303435847,
-0.0432360508,
-0.0245491005,
-0.0090892417,
-0.0024581803,
-0.0132423947,
0.0924596041,
0.0549499877,
-0.0305715185,
-0.03085679,
0.0248071179,
0.036768347,
-0.0146517884,
0.0442086793,
0.0094801551,
-0.0359419845,
0.0146682067,
-0.0495432615,
0.0169529859,
0.0324089751,
0.0196924657,
0.0186782368,
0.0204068758,
0.0603059307,
-0.0400254317,
-0.0563339628,
0.0065582041,
0.0301606208,
0.0276155248,
-0.0017235404,
-0.0210760068,
0.0267540067,
0.0139689166,
-0.0472780988,
-0.0410291329,
-0.0362885073,
-0.0506324731,
0.0054651052,
0.006425553,
0.008004616,
0.0321633182,
-0.0090137059,
-0.0100042457,
0.0311349574,
-0.0033458082,
-0.009920557,
0.0221246146,
0.0296532605,
0.0273308959,
-0.0032429462,
0.0491825826,
-0.0374434069,
0.046370402,
0.048632618,
0.0503755696,
-0.0245891288,
-0.0350494534,
-0.0120719234,
-0.0126043465,
0.0984508172,
0.0211653765,
0.0186857134,
-0.0343719199,
0.0033428106,
-0.013798154,
0.011632923,
-0.0467133038,
-0.0181345008,
0.033800479,
-0.0165195614,
-0.0073262262,
0.0372373499,
-0.014095135,
0.0080380533,
-0.0317780636,
0.0029536248,
-0.0195984691,
0.0382288732,
-0.0130015714,
0.0106679574,
-0.0333322696,
0.0267211515,
-0.01160195,
-0.0254140478,
-0.0405819602,
0.0111831967,
0.0300797056,
0.0035491923,
-0.0645736977,
0.0421634987,
-0.0387379974,
-0.0266106259,
-0.0033308873,
0.027772963,
0.0100039132,
-0.008559905,
0.0191547964,
-0.0046454947,
-0.0104058878,
0.0112057747,
0.0518620759,
-0.0027737648,
-0.0080981376,
0.0409373604,
-0.0012036074,
-0.0332799703,
-0.0312814973,
0.0590902008,
-0.0004128983,
0.0509814993,
0.0187816713,
0.0105530107,
-0.0450884365,
-0.0100734159,
0.0602735542,
0.100025475,
-0.0067446865,
0.0863920152,
-0.0526258834,
-0.0259504281,
-0.0255876891,
0.0030636645,
-0.0081373136,
0.024968598,
0.0519537292,
0.0209909566,
0.028196061,
-0.0209554434,
-0.01073182,
0.0357309021,
0.0318140574,
-0.0283149742,
-0.0031333913,
-6.515915797e-33,
-0.0282589756,
0.0084704636,
-0.0327287614,
-0.0351309441,
-0.0159111917,
0.0356320255,
-0.0290469304,
-0.0421571396,
-0.0275223739,
0.0161584318,
0.0377743915,
0.027874697,
-0.0029621019,
0.0460604802,
-0.0391461477,
-0.0190136023,
0.0472245142,
0.0226800516,
0.0080193877,
0.0187485553,
0.052384939,
0.0408320315,
0.0286414158,
-0.0352599956,
-0.0275213066,
-0.0151464948,
0.0222919863,
0.0331569165,
0.0259905625,
0.0157551691,
-0.0400492996,
0.0197006948,
-0.0011776215,
0.0197687913,
-0.0333781317,
0.0153207919,
-0.0805227011,
-0.1058604494,
0.0233926792,
-0.0262954719,
-0.0458270945,
0.01265998,
0.0299904551,
0.0036108189,
0.0074458499,
-0.0118482681,
0.0255949982,
0.0108478796,
-0.0301745813,
-0.0318516754,
-0.0683650523,
0.0083390689,
0.006764248,
-0.0389204547,
0.0572756864,
-0.004950189,
-0.0008333183,
0.0201879293,
-0.0972620994,
-0.0055494499,
0.0130225532,
0.0087272283,
0.0211471338,
0.0274101477,
0.0418375842,
0.1035434529,
-0.0061470689,
-0.0579780266,
-0.0249389075,
-0.0001114479,
0.0485123023,
0.0548641831,
0.0017165708,
0.0051856535,
0.0358374566,
-0.0076124007,
-0.091578491,
-0.0051946673,
-0.0012884343,
0.0141880512,
0.0273960326,
0.0233863108,
-0.0007030588,
-0.0465103909,
-0.06120589,
0.0072609591,
-0.0156508721,
-0.0140588693,
0.0216488279,
0.0021265268,
-0.030158272,
-0.0053570447,
0.0279767755,
-0.0549908839,
-0.0003348862,
0.0302064717,
-0.0080470862,
-0.0224941708,
0.0540276244,
0.0459091589,
-0.01515132,
-0.0736853629,
0.0282895658,
0.0007601702,
0.0184780061,
0.0189546533,
0.0160695724,
-0.0197697598,
-0.0025676778,
-0.0120559903,
-0.0263892803,
-0.0831685513,
-0.0076829032,
0.0283802971,
0.0064090593,
0.0473250896,
-0.0322161056,
0.0148196593,
0.0023600676,
0.0053867688,
-0.0133506376,
-0.0130494023,
0.0060215662,
0.0777441263,
-0.0287241843,
-0.0107626813,
-0.0403325967,
0.0335172713,
0.074883543,
-0.0636781603,
-0.010269084,
-0.0076185223,
2.776e-7,
0.0616293885,
0.0381914787,
0.0047428943,
-0.0293410849,
0.0094128409,
0.047878582,
-0.0268839579,
0.0789726004,
-0.0688211694,
-0.0136334561,
-0.0073277177,
0.0432022512,
0.0275188033,
0.008976507,
0.0034943561,
0.0378091447,
-0.0435932092,
-0.0060176989,
-0.0312846415,
-0.0120629463,
0.0952926278,
0.0706213713,
0.051482901,
0.0093136914,
0.0166096371,
-0.0112340152,
0.0540251434,
-0.0277429335,
0.0278467722,
-0.0275322106,
-0.0449157804,
0.0078222798,
0.0228113458,
0.03210048,
-0.0157855023,
0.0358570516,
0.0353130251,
0.0620697848,
-0.022847034,
0.0076445779,
-0.0256297067,
-0.0113928756,
-0.0008984951,
-0.0588558242,
0.0848514438,
-0.1031901985,
-0.0434766784,
-0.0076922737,
-0.0031318679,
0.0298624411,
0.0625469387,
0.0102445334,
-0.0609921664,
0.0044705071,
0.0350092091,
-0.0211239941,
-0.0252579711,
-0.1032348797,
-0.0006290981,
0.0026678636,
-0.0198619831,
-0.0148073798,
-0.0191701874,
-0.0434262007,
0.0708004534,
-0.0376710258,
0.029842509,
2.489453901e-34,
0.0012846026,
0.0120922988,
-0.0155414026,
-0.0041715666,
0.0304781962,
-0.0283134412,
0.0065782615,
-0.0040153582,
0.0187948495,
-0.0590887256,
0.0180884935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05103v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05103v1 | Zero-Shot Detection of Machine-Generated Codes | 2023-10-08T10:08:21 | 2023-10-08T10:08:21 | Xianjun Yang, Kexun Zhang, Haifeng Chen, Linda Petzold, William Yang Wang, Wei Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | This work proposes a training-free approach for the detection of
LLMs-generated codes, mitigating the risks associated with their indiscriminate
usage. To the best of our knowledge, our research is the first to investigate
zero-shot detection techniques applied to code generated by advanced black-box
LLMs like ChatGPT. Firstly, we find that existing training-based or zero-shot
text detectors are ineffective in detecting code, likely due to the unique
statistical properties found in code structures. We then modify the previous
zero-shot text detection method, DetectGPT (Mitchell et al., 2023) by utilizing
a surrogate white-box model to estimate the probability of the rightmost
tokens, allowing us to identify code snippets generated by language models.
Through extensive experiments conducted on the python codes of the CodeContest
and APPS dataset, our approach demonstrates its effectiveness by achieving
state-of-the-art detection results on text-davinci-003, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4
models. Moreover, our method exhibits robustness against revision attacks and
generalizes well to Java codes. We also find that the smaller code language
model like PolyCoder-160M performs as a universal code detector, outperforming
the billion-scale counterpart. The codes will be available at
https://github.com/ Xianjun-Yang/Code_detection.git | [
0.0105682863,
0.0262164343,
-0.006015636,
0.0621842891,
-0.0131899891,
-0.0011241047,
-0.0077618589,
0.072443299,
0.0201114658,
-0.019810034,
0.0074525652,
0.0374927483,
-0.0020108293,
0.042745728,
0.0765531436,
0.0912107229,
0.0174378511,
-0.0040265666,
0.0081009082,
0.0172587652,
-0.0130058983,
0.0193938985,
0.0318926908,
0.0318986736,
0.0013736715,
-0.0165390708,
-0.0293778889,
0.0296819564,
0.0164815634,
-0.0587967187,
-0.013205315,
0.0122349476,
-0.0106603727,
0.08433754,
0.0000020432,
-0.0166631863,
-0.0519854017,
-0.0106102591,
-0.0558591112,
0.0323556028,
0.0103812115,
-0.0418916382,
-0.0394366868,
0.0195561033,
-0.0286089629,
-0.0074104667,
0.0357108973,
0.0031421513,
0.0277459621,
0.1004639715,
-0.0070153093,
0.0305406023,
0.0539116971,
0.0232684109,
0.0587653816,
-0.0160368532,
-0.0031085338,
0.007744858,
-0.0113525391,
0.0405001752,
-0.0131068043,
-0.013585832,
0.0210220236,
-0.0045119585,
-0.031403847,
0.0441506729,
-0.0680998191,
0.0256682523,
-0.0195785072,
0.0192384385,
-0.0768790916,
-0.0516111702,
0.0459739082,
-0.0254953764,
-0.0036401893,
-0.038596496,
0.0097111361,
0.0472168177,
0.0041393586,
0.0235907529,
0.0030977076,
-0.0331177711,
0.0325135291,
-0.0263553355,
-0.0153245432,
0.0417103432,
0.0044181277,
-0.0481664948,
-0.0520116054,
-0.0456704646,
0.0306392498,
-0.0823581964,
-0.0270962715,
0.036031317,
0.048337847,
-0.0100898445,
-0.0660244748,
-0.0194125529,
0.0225522872,
-0.0308079664,
-0.0089766374,
0.0463446081,
-0.0193099361,
0.0234448779,
-0.0869672149,
0.058151532,
-0.0301550478,
0.0395140573,
0.0433190055,
0.0257613771,
-0.0204942022,
-0.0078663724,
-0.0049046106,
0.0483399034,
0.0241655353,
0.0344699174,
-0.0337585881,
0.0380963273,
0.0300052129,
0.0506220274,
-0.0592332743,
-0.0556060448,
0.0135966586,
0.0225237627,
0.0625833869,
-0.0398304388,
0.0132438466,
-0.0345703475,
-0.0575083196,
-0.1042015776,
-0.0389042497,
0.0674290359,
-0.0213644616,
-0.0042163767,
0.0264708865,
0.0715304017,
0.0325420462,
-0.0234120991,
-0.057654243,
-0.079536438,
-0.0181705039,
0.0212274324,
0.0103665991,
-0.072015129,
-0.0994256809,
-0.0177942719,
0.0224029161,
-0.035377305,
-0.0075107468,
-0.0190409999,
-0.0103670508,
0.0453042723,
-0.0470635295,
-0.029639421,
-0.0251752678,
0.0067585688,
-0.0162587017,
0.0460987762,
0.0319464281,
0.0477782674,
0.0321374498,
-0.0373743922,
0.0858270973,
0.0575373136,
-0.0077049937,
0.0415664762,
0.0074465764,
0.0025914498,
0.0398204252,
-0.0517656319,
0.0335909612,
-0.0026935895,
-0.0288160704,
-0.0440321751,
0.0166911799,
0.0694901943,
-0.0329111554,
0.0137712862,
0.0216297172,
0.0288804248,
-0.0202074051,
0.0161623061,
-0.0046043922,
-0.0099030277,
-0.0852515921,
-0.0410610326,
0.0071556242,
-0.0124619463,
0.0116055096,
0.0162919722,
-0.0189108066,
-0.0495964102,
-0.020067649,
-0.0648835599,
0.022688318,
-0.0335876495,
-0.0218056776,
0.0307938494,
-0.0088593988,
-0.0442441404,
-0.0354313701,
-0.1043808013,
0.0386859216,
0.021310715,
0.071276024,
-0.0242404379,
0.0195954386,
-0.0202026255,
-0.0244844332,
-0.0082461182,
-0.0333124846,
0.0334077813,
0.0382120498,
-0.0515078492,
-0.0369121507,
-0.0369460396,
0.0025664216,
0.0011680664,
0.0346379839,
-0.000981385,
0.0169295538,
-0.0050057401,
0.003464717,
0.0268154014,
-0.0021366645,
-0.0406168513,
0.0196656436,
0.0035146312,
0.0393390208,
-0.0192228761,
-0.0401568525,
0.0349728279,
0.0419908315,
-0.021709729,
-0.0086590638,
-0.0329854637,
0.0255293921,
-0.0284506083,
0.0402137078,
-0.0413104109,
-0.0172997173,
0.0236694161,
-0.0346224457,
-0.0040680557,
0.0266645458,
-0.0509669371,
0.0312814005,
-0.0174007621,
0.0163458735,
-0.0259090867,
0.040578384,
-0.0113413194,
0.0016622747,
-0.0060484721,
0.0096034361,
0.0203112885,
0.0208917297,
0.0725366175,
-0.0357998163,
-0.0256865174,
-0.0033002319,
-0.0381571017,
0.0058545317,
-0.0233839564,
0.0642682537,
0.0102803679,
-0.0405280888,
-0.05934304,
0.0360160023,
-0.0192503016,
0.0300107114,
0.0393211469,
-0.0069093462,
-0.0478296541,
-0.0347294435,
0.0029900901,
-0.0267946385,
0.0051261238,
-0.0202052239,
0.0350744091,
-0.0506914742,
-0.0252426658,
0.0168296695,
0.0118639562,
-0.0237920377,
0.0382455923,
-0.0018783058,
-0.03196273,
-0.0741608515,
0.0832600892,
0.0045372602,
-0.0161634367,
-0.0103349965,
-0.0562362522,
0.0100113694,
-0.0320663303,
-0.0157571211,
0.0591717549,
0.0013980983,
-0.0166418198,
0.0292374101,
0.0164603237,
-0.038046997,
-0.0165289901,
0.0666487888,
-0.0552941002,
-0.0343831554,
-0.0373599231,
0.0670637712,
0.0435174108,
0.0269691553,
-0.0106673893,
-0.0270446017,
0.0139327683,
0.0452681221,
0.0014169484,
0.0179818887,
-0.0016965306,
-0.0437774211,
0.0281340424,
-0.0084624011,
-0.1175280213,
0.0235605892,
-0.0674160719,
-0.0085049951,
0.0033016186,
-0.0392153524,
-0.0310448091,
0.0021135565,
0.0020896657,
-0.001889462,
0.0223817285,
-0.0525855012,
-0.015766535,
0.0266072843,
0.0069372258,
-0.0390790068,
0.0147330528,
-0.0032956505,
0.0071790474,
-0.0286175106,
0.0264461879,
-0.037246298,
-0.0266932156,
-0.0068228198,
-0.0303432904,
0.0079033645,
-0.0177196246,
0.0419393145,
0.0171518866,
0.0198877901,
0.0550884716,
0.0194672681,
-0.0206064358,
-0.0355496742,
0.02516599,
-0.0363979749,
-0.1051512659,
0.0044790255,
0.0038701878,
-0.0086202957,
0.0682376102,
0.0059275785,
0.0741411373,
-0.0294479951,
0.0128060952,
0.0310199987,
0.0021268649,
0.0003276244,
0.0638050884,
0.0301997252,
-0.0057468666,
0.0049810139,
0.0889383033,
0.0043539568,
-0.0590565912,
-0.0021434058,
-0.0156206936,
0.0123487655,
0.0352196321,
-0.009483139,
-0.1258177906,
-0.0283954889,
0.0295748897,
0.0093341442,
-0.0334346853,
-0.0035828326,
-0.0126129724,
-0.0897774324,
0.0242840089,
0.0477425978,
-0.0081835091,
-0.0408726409,
0.0082972283,
-0.0196925346,
0.0100696031,
-0.0382277109,
-0.0035010488,
0.0189203154,
0.0264195818,
-0.037696667,
-0.0408790596,
0.0174126402,
0.021224739,
-0.0474772565,
0.0309742838,
0.0875382721,
-0.0038556578,
-0.0189075451,
0.0092277499,
0.0414703786,
0.0157035291,
-0.026397543,
-0.0020419077,
0.035345342,
-0.0022041774,
-0.0258778147,
0.065857172,
0.0179885495,
-0.0506894328,
-0.0038370916,
0.0534491837,
0.0299641918,
-0.0288578458,
-0.0251368787,
-0.0065780282,
-0.0330909044,
-0.0004585418,
0.0510601141,
0.0429949388,
0.0073605143,
-0.0387210771,
-0.0643488765,
0.0433464833,
-0.0288468711,
-0.0227178447,
-0.032317847,
-0.0087886732,
-0.0098358709,
-0.0213563759,
0.0500762127,
-0.0185439289,
-0.0017981101,
0.0077734878,
-0.0048172181,
-0.0213815998,
0.0026621625,
-0.0447166152,
-0.0709930882,
-0.0623006746,
0.0159559287,
-0.0612693764,
0.0190264098,
0.0034552347,
0.0082930047,
-0.0222784299,
-0.0051161204,
-0.0947906971,
-0.0335339159,
-0.0593843274,
0.0426327102,
0.0214351546,
0.0005899,
-0.0297536943,
-0.0272467583,
0.0276447143,
0.0363661572,
-0.0168219991,
0.0324153043,
0.0259427596,
0.0011904886,
0.0196484234,
-0.0067600082,
-0.0295201577,
-0.0150912413,
0.0678418055,
-0.0401499793,
-0.0802547336,
0.0041699209,
0.0231841933,
0.0340983942,
0.0339878388,
-0.005419312,
0.0099700987,
0.0374320261,
0.0178491957,
0.0256739426,
0.0103636123,
-0.022853123,
0.0185605381,
0.0151946424,
-0.0367747024,
0.0150100589,
0.024384452,
-0.0397632979,
0.0566006526,
-0.0036524413,
0.0471872203,
0.0003832003,
0.0411451533,
0.0620236062,
-0.0323765539,
0.0247208923,
0.0500088632,
0.0215124637,
-0.0024754093,
0.0061725881,
0.0505116098,
-0.0234986413,
0.0145686679,
0.0399626046,
0.0372665338,
-0.0544957258,
-0.0143218348,
-0.0051991143,
0.0562336519,
0.0537780039,
0.0642523021,
0.002584954,
-0.0060930797,
-0.0059382129,
-0.0432011187,
0.0359441452,
-0.0252287816,
-0.0120331086,
-0.0148478765,
-0.003294968,
-0.0578896701,
0.0036307529,
0.0830696076,
0.0358442552,
0.0480477214,
-0.0072031179,
-0.0297636129,
-0.041584935,
0.0146525968,
0.0616704449,
0.0027883863,
0.0057964483,
0.0270133074,
-0.0262814015,
-0.0530345403,
0.0089665158,
-0.0029473021,
0.0458469726,
0.0080319094,
-0.0399138071,
0.051301498,
-0.0420356728,
0.011559343,
-0.0413333401,
0.0271634813,
0.0361935087,
-0.0490768477,
-0.0273303743,
-5.254857947e-33,
0.0108782118,
-0.0585945137,
-0.0524981767,
0.0266001169,
0.0195879284,
0.0151718874,
-0.0219569784,
-0.0268322043,
0.0063863727,
-0.0579108819,
0.0209618974,
0.0315069444,
-0.0023513092,
-0.0315918103,
0.0123101994,
-0.0104973726,
0.0059850067,
0.0096489741,
-0.0374394879,
0.0101490039,
-0.0031114721,
0.0057920893,
0.0347351618,
-0.0123111792,
-0.0133156125,
-0.0409767739,
-0.0000617482,
-0.0156742465,
-0.01034097,
0.076372236,
0.0218132976,
-0.0186443888,
0.0379438885,
-0.0066319136,
-0.0267899148,
-0.0021621201,
0.0546338372,
-0.0128111141,
-0.0277152173,
-0.0215008706,
0.0534185506,
-0.1124779508,
0.0744907632,
-0.0099022826,
-0.0293910298,
-0.0049588014,
0.0089443428,
-0.037069872,
-0.0132343536,
-0.046102263,
0.0037408518,
0.0460892208,
-0.0378314406,
0.0274858531,
0.0264972784,
-0.0179624502,
0.0358407795,
0.0678572133,
-0.0320608243,
0.0285348669,
0.0346078612,
0.0377313457,
0.0167336725,
0.012055994,
-0.0113553405,
0.010366004,
0.0369975641,
-0.0394943729,
-0.0047836546,
0.0006431452,
0.0026216942,
-0.0083079189,
0.0330399685,
0.0392073169,
0.0799513683,
-0.015378233,
-0.0194454882,
0.0158393346,
-0.0017606863,
0.0153065519,
0.012315616,
0.0286596511,
-0.0423876867,
0.017797675,
0.0116609931,
-0.0680140108,
-0.0172980055,
-0.0385992825,
0.025484208,
0.0177146234,
-0.0096748751,
-0.0272798464,
0.0285704844,
-0.0827202648,
0.023361763,
0.0167132672,
-0.0411522575,
-0.0038828249,
0.0096904188,
0.0093302755,
0.0096061416,
0.0053358632,
0.0295954403,
-0.0480462611,
0.065060772,
-0.005423652,
0.0343708061,
0.0281821135,
-0.0875957012,
-0.0194462501,
-0.0316353813,
-0.0112704616,
-0.0150703434,
0.0164923687,
-0.0083923694,
-0.0371479578,
0.025931092,
-0.0158974715,
0.0059450632,
-0.0294095017,
-0.0268186964,
-0.0002641655,
-0.0187564492,
0.0141867567,
-0.0388073809,
0.0266555883,
-0.0039838543,
0.0553565584,
0.0514604487,
-0.0261692815,
-0.025153324,
-0.0042815977,
2.723e-7,
0.0214115772,
0.0097946599,
0.0449546762,
0.0106878374,
0.0443972498,
0.0607190765,
-0.044332549,
0.036137972,
-0.0393374637,
-0.0238408539,
-0.0306265075,
-0.023918476,
0.0592429899,
-0.0129895872,
-0.0509121753,
0.0429125205,
-0.0393015966,
0.0033730634,
-0.0767634809,
0.0209486075,
0.0726663321,
0.0739697143,
-0.0094710318,
-0.016255131,
0.0391008779,
-0.0502514206,
0.0122668678,
-0.0076268269,
0.0286874138,
0.0058025047,
-0.0265299249,
0.0478524566,
0.0050971541,
0.0020710938,
-0.0185587704,
-0.0239192974,
-0.0348754376,
0.086381577,
0.0252129938,
0.045003444,
0.0049517271,
-0.0368851312,
0.0067435964,
-0.0253539775,
0.0758119524,
0.0514805205,
0.00376672,
-0.0313483551,
-0.0003241317,
-0.0463909246,
0.0207497589,
-0.0288205128,
-0.0078044883,
0.0386630297,
-0.0037698306,
0.0027765632,
0.0118870595,
-0.0406206064,
-0.0292093959,
-0.0652869344,
-0.0318125077,
-0.0266901981,
-0.0335667357,
0.0395036153,
0.0533389039,
-0.0059610149,
0.0396768674,
2.72029918e-34,
-0.0066266181,
-0.0581083037,
0.0070415791,
0.0638035312,
0.0229622405,
-0.0068322332,
-0.0091642356,
0.0044475058,
-0.0012313805,
0.0053664912,
0.0160064325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05095v1 | How Reliable Are AI-Generated-Text Detectors? An Assessment Framework Using Evasive Soft Prompts | 2023-10-08T09:53:46 | 2023-10-08T09:53:46 | Tharindu Kumarage, Paras Sheth, Raha Moraffah, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, there has been a rapid proliferation of AI-generated text,
primarily driven by the release of powerful pre-trained language models (PLMs).
To address the issue of misuse associated with AI-generated text, various
high-performing detectors have been developed, including the OpenAI detector
and the Stanford DetectGPT. In our study, we ask how reliable these detectors
are. We answer the question by designing a novel approach that can prompt any
PLM to generate text that evades these high-performing detectors. The proposed
approach suggests a universal evasive prompt, a novel type of soft prompt,
which guides PLMs in producing "human-like" text that can mislead the
detectors. The novel universal evasive prompt is achieved in two steps: First,
we create an evasive soft prompt tailored to a specific PLM through prompt
tuning; and then, we leverage the transferability of soft prompts to transfer
the learned evasive soft prompt from one PLM to another. Employing multiple
PLMs in various writing tasks, we conduct extensive experiments to evaluate the
efficacy of the evasive soft prompts in their evasion of state-of-the-art
detectors. | [
0.0461763255,
-0.0032550069,
-0.0381831005,
0.0234434605,
-0.0262544397,
0.0001392184,
0.0440606698,
0.034121938,
0.0462735444,
-0.043626491,
-0.0299690682,
-0.0146832308,
0.0084301969,
0.0678524598,
0.0218081791,
0.0092731761,
0.0452643074,
-0.0333799459,
0.0435840636,
0.0306261927,
0.0253073685,
0.0019049319,
-0.0043400242,
0.0576666929,
-0.0055720271,
-0.0241923537,
-0.0060649598,
-0.0010786811,
0.0178690981,
-0.0274052452,
0.0151130985,
0.0574608743,
-0.0071844235,
0.0934358835,
0.0000019857,
-0.0576428659,
-0.0237918049,
-0.0132685574,
-0.0397480838,
0.0294596162,
0.0157883111,
-0.0242683347,
-0.0300663728,
0.0164215676,
-0.0342182331,
0.0280588157,
0.0227333512,
0.0411780067,
0.0476090275,
0.0974191427,
-0.0091645624,
0.0587073416,
0.0587657318,
-0.0296473075,
0.0012429189,
-0.030629877,
0.0059490637,
-0.088745147,
0.0056085368,
0.0239793807,
0.0111846048,
0.0190626159,
0.0223454554,
-0.0437019244,
-0.0261499155,
0.0520512909,
-0.0018697302,
-0.014404132,
-0.0508027524,
0.0345740095,
-0.0290014464,
-0.0453917831,
0.0090680411,
-0.0457907133,
0.0084482692,
0.0067389766,
0.0211312864,
0.026068313,
-0.0168965925,
-0.0108720371,
0.000895154,
0.0002796222,
-0.0010626883,
0.0294806696,
0.0347169414,
0.0127440151,
0.0233174153,
-0.0517513193,
0.0069717444,
0.009979669,
0.016096903,
-0.0790989697,
0.0409507863,
0.0281722397,
-0.0388700664,
-0.0106966263,
-0.0960914567,
-0.0572764799,
0.042442698,
0.0065723383,
0.0829933062,
0.0155499559,
-0.0358318686,
0.0104345726,
-0.0769269392,
0.0837977901,
-0.0181623586,
0.0531746745,
0.0004136953,
0.0396554656,
0.0054864478,
-0.0258952472,
-0.0307579841,
0.0141471094,
0.0127696013,
-0.0271040779,
-0.0117499772,
0.0153582105,
-0.0203083903,
0.0145267462,
-0.041397173,
-0.0099577922,
-0.0419664867,
0.0011736432,
-0.016747741,
-0.0303962007,
-0.0229164418,
0.0310720857,
0.0163236,
-0.0641217455,
-0.0302326046,
0.0378494672,
0.0098493863,
-0.025274897,
-0.0029262113,
0.0232668445,
-0.0403546765,
-0.0520690121,
-0.0355854109,
-0.0326546803,
-0.0450678617,
-0.0238527451,
-0.006491059,
-0.0387125462,
-0.0073100091,
-0.0323093049,
-0.00386151,
-0.0374034457,
0.0016360488,
0.0460203923,
0.0133345053,
0.0491608381,
-0.0136852246,
-0.0107652964,
0.0286153015,
0.0037230947,
-0.0282570776,
0.01714289,
0.0114976773,
0.0905331001,
0.0553724989,
0.0120649962,
0.0619507693,
0.0360631756,
0.0291758906,
0.034799315,
0.0467425473,
-0.0351236984,
0.0035638574,
-0.0038840752,
0.0071739433,
0.04450069,
0.0206520818,
0.0001486358,
0.0899427757,
0.0373094641,
-0.046202071,
-0.0157899875,
0.0637369007,
0.0147481244,
-0.0155761605,
0.0490468293,
-0.0221640766,
-0.0058891294,
-0.065863356,
-0.0138068451,
-0.0139421122,
-0.0231949259,
0.009056041,
-0.0293959342,
0.0095968144,
-0.0334521681,
-0.0058573331,
-0.0040623341,
0.0149907749,
0.0396589264,
-0.0583735742,
-0.0323903188,
-0.0169266239,
-0.059554033,
0.0022839212,
-0.0820123181,
0.0811267048,
0.0360192582,
0.046040073,
-0.0367789753,
0.0315493606,
-0.0219294578,
0.0070972112,
0.0724914074,
0.0404221527,
0.0118979821,
-0.0062938961,
-0.0202536136,
-0.0014658506,
-0.0323798135,
-0.002325919,
0.0157912318,
0.0244306661,
0.0327203274,
0.0280611943,
0.0032629254,
-0.024585586,
0.0726126209,
-0.0130332652,
-0.0513184704,
0.0051861261,
0.0297221802,
0.0234717093,
0.010583437,
-0.028469177,
0.0290204529,
0.0327275693,
-0.0397954956,
-0.0262595993,
-0.0629497319,
-0.0350038745,
-0.0002017508,
-0.0245316941,
-0.0216069371,
-0.0231426451,
0.0528789535,
0.0068256101,
-0.0212192945,
-0.0474977978,
-0.0193760525,
-0.0184320398,
-0.0673915371,
0.0211293958,
-0.0044627772,
0.0413106531,
-0.0227391981,
0.0568889752,
0.0128428536,
0.0084752496,
0.0586235859,
0.0258762445,
0.0378178395,
-0.0282283891,
-0.0439373888,
-0.0175441578,
-0.0151246954,
0.0009183761,
0.0425795838,
0.0383642726,
-0.0321732685,
-0.0347301289,
-0.0667520836,
0.0130587835,
-0.0236328412,
-0.0226436816,
0.0557844341,
-0.0420591384,
-0.0202237144,
0.0228704493,
-0.0211204961,
-0.0104106246,
0.0306568686,
0.0054516993,
0.0233335663,
-0.0219370387,
0.0125942137,
-0.029595172,
0.0251989905,
-0.0355060883,
0.0244333725,
0.0117663946,
-0.0567492805,
-0.0420377627,
0.0631643459,
0.0036631646,
0.0070605902,
0.0010935247,
-0.0387836583,
0.033120282,
-0.0036316286,
0.0189340878,
0.095267497,
0.0233834013,
0.0035299941,
0.0504632927,
0.0213181861,
-0.0185552817,
0.0005885412,
0.0241584331,
-0.0162061751,
0.0085851019,
-0.0401625857,
0.0605624579,
0.0096640876,
0.056595441,
0.0093567157,
-0.0421040542,
0.0199240334,
-0.025740061,
-0.0635921061,
0.0069726687,
-0.0492372401,
-0.0596637204,
0.0394944847,
-0.0522126965,
-0.0536790788,
0.0521848425,
-0.0645994619,
0.0065609873,
-0.0039675697,
-0.0157288145,
0.0002102302,
0.0461556725,
0.0162644926,
0.0162901487,
0.0409002192,
-0.0238143839,
-0.0470168665,
-0.0017209647,
-0.0004335686,
0.0004494402,
0.0114740506,
-0.0291237831,
-0.0014491159,
-0.0040493356,
-0.036157012,
-0.069038488,
-0.0935682207,
0.0120611442,
0.0012000854,
-0.0011087211,
-0.013002811,
-0.0015930942,
-0.0303639714,
0.0167349931,
0.0528096259,
-0.028753262,
-0.010097947,
-0.052555766,
0.0550947711,
0.0539655946,
-0.0278203562,
-0.0068033836,
-0.0508828871,
0.0369942412,
0.061333064,
-0.0145038953,
0.0208965652,
0.0019998213,
-0.0153364111,
0.011322706,
0.0013180604,
-0.0119783012,
0.0592735484,
0.0444027819,
-0.02872511,
-0.0423008986,
0.0952961296,
0.0202552676,
-0.0417027213,
-0.0151209338,
-0.0006345761,
0.0548881665,
-0.0044725477,
-0.0302197207,
-0.0611232147,
-0.0339435562,
0.0212151967,
0.0378764234,
-0.0554876588,
-0.0023669254,
-0.0203737058,
-0.1172629222,
-0.0012578458,
-0.0092880456,
-0.0172604583,
-0.0009902848,
0.0182509068,
-0.0158745609,
0.0566362143,
0.0020732067,
-0.029373277,
0.0164053962,
-0.0112787969,
-0.008541435,
0.0022425689,
-0.0113619622,
0.0144527545,
-0.0449183732,
0.0350096896,
0.0936866105,
0.0453681275,
-0.0114403367,
-0.0416789539,
0.0100976797,
-0.0340786874,
0.0362699628,
0.0234187394,
0.0362820178,
-0.0233849119,
0.0003689807,
-0.0240219962,
0.0514847301,
-0.0154323503,
-0.0291631278,
0.0727964267,
0.0542785414,
-0.03129052,
-0.0605566278,
-0.0046932586,
-0.0153874317,
0.0263757128,
0.0728638321,
0.0367943607,
-0.0488387346,
-0.0500686616,
-0.0236155149,
0.0386325978,
-0.0579924509,
-0.0394448787,
0.0050924281,
-0.012039273,
-0.0393349379,
-0.0800958574,
-0.0391536504,
0.0115888175,
0.0253481511,
0.0404121093,
0.0021972358,
-0.0200065076,
-0.0032440219,
-0.012836298,
-0.0204479136,
-0.0283004884,
0.0609861203,
-0.0494665168,
0.004715411,
-0.016403392,
-0.0332617462,
0.0044988873,
0.0491384827,
-0.0579896756,
-0.0481023565,
0.0326865241,
0.050863605,
0.0180502031,
-0.0161335897,
-0.025974717,
-0.0580579005,
0.0915833488,
0.0294179562,
-0.0283581931,
0.0403656848,
0.0279340576,
-0.0470388196,
-0.0235322732,
0.0197332595,
-0.0202627946,
-0.0022584202,
0.0404930599,
-0.0106978109,
-0.0194274411,
-0.0545870811,
0.0243991967,
0.023561405,
0.0486231223,
-0.0224089716,
0.0062322691,
-0.046612218,
-0.0077387891,
-0.0093401549,
-0.0243812036,
-0.011959766,
0.0192926265,
0.023393169,
0.0065893847,
0.0040227356,
0.0431111939,
-0.0383235253,
0.0426300466,
-0.0429599211,
0.0026627791,
0.0388902314,
0.1045991555,
0.0071440334,
-0.0040339595,
-0.0179373734,
0.0728699192,
-0.0206177421,
0.0216992088,
0.0158330537,
0.0763924643,
0.0140955765,
-0.0087865163,
0.0159876551,
0.0427804478,
-0.0764874816,
-0.0141709698,
-0.0174787845,
0.0454160236,
0.031702552,
0.0108834645,
0.0229728986,
-0.0371772386,
-0.0082418565,
-0.0125443023,
0.0281460676,
0.0272861961,
-0.0519036353,
-0.011925092,
-0.0214540698,
-0.0076267915,
-0.0007264468,
0.0751589909,
-0.0471073426,
0.0181988701,
0.0089240279,
-0.0215326678,
-0.0403378196,
-0.0216594357,
0.024623163,
0.0275450218,
-0.0058360002,
0.0022143635,
-0.0389526077,
-0.0478529632,
0.0146618923,
0.0059546637,
0.0158950202,
-0.0179826245,
-0.0126346936,
0.045985125,
-0.0111927921,
0.0091151586,
-0.0447733141,
0.0250450801,
0.0127101578,
-0.0048550731,
-0.0417959876,
-5.666379785e-33,
-0.02588805,
-0.0679965913,
-0.0290449262,
-0.005149595,
0.0124041252,
0.0526035503,
-0.0335793607,
-0.0010445638,
0.0132903662,
-0.0000411682,
-0.0412174053,
0.0077554057,
0.0076699853,
0.0080325371,
-0.0473457538,
-0.0126036033,
0.0385146774,
-0.0283014793,
-0.0644996986,
0.0131330183,
0.0540045425,
0.0089258803,
-0.0005149961,
-0.0530314669,
0.0630470514,
-0.0271610711,
-0.0813723579,
-0.0306420941,
-0.0653124005,
0.0489137694,
-0.0217354484,
0.0390908197,
0.0267484207,
0.0089829834,
-0.0069555086,
0.105341509,
-0.0094748372,
-0.0407530107,
-0.0073995572,
-0.0168410372,
-0.0313834585,
-0.0705335364,
0.0073526418,
-0.0399517044,
-0.0079303449,
0.036804039,
0.0327634625,
-0.0006148607,
0.0237260126,
-0.040131744,
-0.0627818406,
-0.0123962769,
0.0143434703,
-0.0344471522,
-0.0098031396,
0.0341729596,
0.0129971979,
0.0012217739,
-0.0713738129,
0.0159278288,
0.0189842191,
-0.000960549,
0.0178222787,
0.0028688479,
-0.0558907837,
0.0626141727,
0.0380406417,
0.0367330313,
-0.0166875739,
-0.0242942143,
0.0107880859,
0.0054457411,
0.0863889232,
0.0846744254,
0.0196128767,
-0.0469670966,
-0.0085580619,
0.0493713059,
0.0158394258,
-0.0350708179,
0.0532418713,
-0.0413691476,
-0.0373038575,
-0.0004872947,
-0.0395376012,
-0.0178756695,
-0.0331840664,
-0.0089368252,
0.0687221661,
0.0267550703,
-0.0115385624,
-0.0307248626,
0.0197034534,
-0.0175277572,
0.0119796554,
0.0017220664,
-0.0446539558,
0.0061508561,
0.0089530833,
0.0136316363,
-0.0371597596,
-0.0253834613,
0.0764503106,
-0.0164222922,
0.0269103292,
-0.0069732489,
0.041051086,
0.0487491041,
-0.0657088235,
0.0259802416,
-0.015126979,
0.0512772389,
0.041688066,
-0.0075312727,
0.0266549885,
-0.0197162367,
-0.017222112,
0.0291994158,
0.0122265965,
-0.0173934922,
-0.0597811602,
0.0024430198,
-0.0197227448,
0.0206393935,
-0.0393950008,
-0.0062049702,
-0.0080296127,
0.030533243,
0.0252371971,
-0.0584497638,
0.0092409663,
-0.0160595663,
2.512e-7,
0.0148883509,
-0.0182186272,
0.0251655392,
0.0499867909,
-0.0010564871,
0.068518199,
-0.019993078,
0.0655930936,
-0.0014401274,
-0.0012468131,
0.0021791537,
-0.0078319917,
0.0366632491,
-0.0016387297,
-0.0681462064,
0.0115555599,
-0.0487524234,
0.0275669284,
-0.085025087,
0.0060112332,
0.0840993896,
0.0594516508,
0.0039024665,
-0.0381063595,
0.0211327858,
-0.0720485523,
0.0352170654,
-0.0067836018,
0.0104861856,
-0.0068825395,
0.062019296,
-0.0216163788,
-0.0090700351,
0.0522538126,
-0.0289738476,
-0.011366616,
0.013788186,
0.0415366143,
0.0061549493,
-0.0479596108,
0.0004051304,
-0.0082916552,
0.0052994154,
-0.0532849915,
0.0886937752,
0.0214257855,
0.0075818817,
-0.010894442,
0.0023399731,
-0.0373614654,
0.0264524147,
-0.0529628545,
-0.0251990426,
0.0171807501,
0.0053838445,
0.0350601114,
-0.0080369711,
-0.0422729887,
-0.0230793022,
-0.0230723545,
-0.0005881386,
-0.0154808359,
-0.0671645328,
0.0065607517,
0.0166020244,
-0.0941483676,
0.0450772755,
2.452789497e-34,
-0.0077162171,
-0.0210229885,
0.0180155188,
-0.0003029423,
0.0371746607,
0.0171528105,
0.0297381114,
-0.0053598573,
0.025958024,
-0.0269673374,
-0.0261932015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05092v1 | Benchmarking Large Language Models with Augmented Instructions for Fine-grained Information Extraction | 2023-10-08T09:41:18 | 2023-10-08T09:41:18 | Jun Gao, Huan Zhao, Yice Zhang, Wei Wang, Changlong Yu, Ruifeng Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Information Extraction (IE) is an essential task in Natural Language
Processing. Traditional methods have relied on coarse-grained extraction with
simple instructions. However, with the emergence of Large Language Models
(LLMs), there is a need to adapt IE techniques to leverage the capabilities of
these models. This paper introduces a fine-grained IE benchmark dataset
tailored for LLMs, employing augmented instructions for each information type,
which includes task descriptions, extraction rules, output formats, and
examples. Through extensive evaluations, we observe that encoder-decoder
models, particularly T5 and FLAN-T5, perform well in generalizing to unseen
information types, while ChatGPT exhibits greater adaptability to new task
forms. Our results also indicate that performance is not solely dictated by
model scale, and highlight the significance of architecture, data diversity,
and learning techniques. This work paves the way for a more refined and
versatile utilization of LLMs in Information Extraction. | [
0.0484821275,
0.0402692966,
0.0059513901,
0.0876737162,
-0.0374500118,
0.0495153032,
-0.0185780264,
-0.0058027483,
-0.0330765247,
-0.0450519733,
-0.0572759025,
-0.0176121928,
0.0042068912,
0.0176890139,
0.0256890804,
-0.0211328808,
0.0143372118,
-0.0251251552,
0.0087315096,
0.0305917151,
0.0039772913,
0.0250205025,
0.0269378014,
0.0109852878,
0.0188796073,
-0.0045078658,
0.0034594906,
-0.0029205938,
0.0167054478,
-0.0077829212,
0.0266562868,
-0.005500399,
0.0135824727,
0.0313462727,
0.0000019357,
-0.0036144038,
-0.018884236,
0.0116233416,
-0.061146006,
0.0469457321,
0.0417913534,
-0.0449596494,
-0.0181740485,
0.007367976,
-0.0053999755,
-0.0681921095,
0.0510977469,
0.0534202531,
0.0301591884,
0.1013776511,
-0.0119857136,
-0.0561223589,
0.0434441306,
-0.0265015811,
0.0074986373,
-0.0428389832,
0.0525940135,
0.0093404884,
0.0000251234,
0.026632959,
0.0153684746,
0.0359774418,
0.0193614047,
0.047535263,
-0.0326451361,
0.043265827,
-0.0104344683,
-0.0128375683,
-0.0270676073,
0.0817748979,
-0.0206475686,
0.0117553296,
-0.0036728708,
0.0020849686,
-0.0192071162,
-0.0258401614,
-0.0458806977,
0.0140567161,
-0.0265843496,
0.026920151,
0.0649057552,
0.004547236,
0.0186043959,
0.0073405253,
-0.0235007647,
0.0337764099,
0.0206925049,
-0.0362276137,
0.0109159853,
-0.0029121016,
0.0130697656,
-0.032458242,
0.0045601306,
-0.0037320675,
0.0269227121,
-0.0045679738,
-0.0301189423,
-0.0145564992,
-0.0101661636,
-0.060280297,
0.0360413902,
0.0345241651,
-0.0279315822,
0.0518062115,
-0.0066772574,
0.0515818596,
-0.0274136495,
0.0512991324,
-0.0246765111,
-0.0221000407,
-0.0528118461,
0.0150743173,
-0.022210313,
0.0396326445,
-0.0397547074,
-0.0273975786,
-0.0080485791,
0.0149083417,
0.0100822439,
0.0294498317,
0.0459853783,
-0.022214951,
-0.0383354835,
-0.0092192227,
0.0118157985,
0.0402318351,
-0.0104362089,
0.014341725,
0.0239699688,
-0.0749715194,
-0.0430369973,
-0.0030790032,
0.0361421369,
-0.0571657121,
0.0416387431,
0.0481055714,
-0.0081502981,
-0.0407674238,
-0.0341596678,
0.0164517872,
0.0036288009,
-0.0800382271,
0.0074438895,
-0.0428449586,
0.0650358051,
0.0062329639,
-0.0016909674,
-0.0257434845,
-0.0021345653,
-0.0025557457,
-0.0415377095,
0.0650213808,
-0.0108468104,
-0.0135141928,
0.0171238929,
-0.0194055587,
-0.0075032343,
0.0885655135,
0.0447222218,
0.0676750168,
0.0394396223,
-0.0096639786,
0.0049239188,
0.0930938497,
-0.0262977779,
-0.0249799844,
0.0129104257,
0.0138026848,
0.0169954859,
-0.019541692,
0.0519411042,
0.0689835846,
-0.0409652814,
0.003278367,
0.0657586828,
0.0193331335,
0.0208511204,
0.0040888623,
0.0488162264,
0.0285267681,
0.0342506208,
0.0067197499,
-0.0252766367,
-0.0075342394,
-0.0312115867,
0.0361061618,
0.0018953495,
0.0576047637,
-0.0337643549,
-0.007466069,
-0.0275186542,
-0.0266614221,
0.0201262254,
0.0111434497,
0.0733240172,
-0.0042159078,
-0.056263417,
0.0312556215,
0.0508606955,
-0.0220326707,
-0.0116161834,
-0.0365575925,
0.0142742163,
0.0609379672,
0.0550015457,
-0.0199348237,
-0.0190775581,
0.0023711468,
-0.0172024872,
0.0230619367,
0.0370703526,
-0.030203823,
0.0480470397,
-0.0732692108,
-0.0275379587,
0.0054188524,
0.0178731959,
0.0253674705,
0.0260319188,
-0.0239350703,
0.0129262796,
-0.0313589834,
-0.0435649119,
0.0350166,
-0.0270838086,
-0.0543156154,
0.0057737511,
-0.0146656847,
0.0265728422,
0.0090335943,
-0.0445136055,
-0.0180917997,
0.0415632799,
-0.0524228439,
0.0237575024,
-0.023839768,
-0.019596858,
-0.0775237754,
0.0001955378,
0.0060554645,
-0.0153101394,
0.0321670994,
-0.0681088194,
-0.0066450434,
-0.0334447175,
-0.0024503446,
0.0324151814,
-0.0306231026,
0.0122206286,
0.033173047,
0.0402978547,
-0.018541418,
0.0672006086,
-0.0075887823,
-0.0408090204,
-0.0054448391,
-0.0110741267,
-0.0533114932,
-0.0174662769,
-0.0137155987,
0.0474397987,
-0.0021266679,
-0.0054297443,
-0.0054181949,
0.0300612506,
-0.0021959515,
-0.045459345,
-0.0967700332,
0.0287364796,
-0.0502227843,
0.0466406383,
0.0226293132,
0.0289081298,
-0.0130187282,
0.0124715827,
-0.0233002305,
-0.0022722846,
-0.0317624509,
0.0201649591,
0.0121522238,
0.0420686975,
-0.0327906646,
-0.0499779098,
-0.0135731958,
0.0125738122,
0.0376450457,
-0.0182896052,
-0.0579543859,
-0.0372941904,
0.0116371913,
0.0093883229,
0.0094439648,
-0.0215535592,
-0.029970143,
-0.0499352738,
-0.0227605235,
0.0088736843,
0.0410363786,
0.0011705175,
0.079125613,
-0.0034085037,
0.001631573,
-0.0571856909,
0.0232509822,
-0.0276091993,
-0.0025440138,
-0.0426595472,
-0.0415370762,
0.02096406,
0.062135227,
-0.0076941974,
0.0596742965,
-0.0399551727,
0.0060948213,
0.0043785614,
-0.0178131349,
-0.0156950559,
0.0097207911,
-0.0266487449,
0.0034903218,
-0.0474072769,
-0.0095653683,
0.0441569574,
-0.0473069809,
-0.0348671302,
-0.0262565613,
-0.0165989138,
-0.0636933222,
0.0752445012,
0.0243272968,
0.0049437336,
0.041319333,
-0.0521863997,
0.0281175468,
0.0308354925,
0.0175303482,
-0.0404983386,
0.0592950732,
-0.0379160531,
0.0077673243,
-0.0245229211,
-0.0372577198,
-0.0330333561,
-0.0433455892,
-0.0145882387,
0.0222231168,
0.0392999947,
-0.0055997786,
-0.0198833756,
0.0145963822,
0.0110793561,
0.0476457104,
-0.0277780481,
0.0181808751,
-0.0426835343,
0.0509924777,
0.0588211678,
-0.0111233238,
-0.0222147573,
-0.0367057845,
0.0062159486,
0.0354671553,
-0.007046747,
-0.0021564867,
-0.0180015936,
0.0025943313,
0.0476601869,
-0.0096548293,
0.0114982761,
0.0276636537,
0.0656082258,
-0.0908588544,
-0.0255190562,
0.1241861805,
0.023946438,
-0.0156266484,
-0.0048273997,
0.0348098911,
0.0330940075,
-0.0123718008,
0.0006473674,
-0.0771621466,
-0.0605806485,
0.0257855467,
-0.009705985,
-0.0103092985,
0.0104201166,
-0.0174656752,
-0.1073175445,
0.0390320979,
0.0193691775,
-0.0213726945,
-0.0646436363,
-0.0489838049,
0.0026358583,
-0.0486154407,
0.0400464311,
0.0083967177,
-0.0437186882,
-0.0086905379,
0.0370108783,
-0.0507624261,
-0.1073148698,
0.024345044,
-0.0182068255,
0.0594342574,
0.0735696405,
-0.0158779379,
-0.0269845128,
-0.0162170585,
0.0460041761,
-0.0155660156,
-0.0332541615,
-0.011265018,
0.082410194,
-0.0537401363,
-0.005304256,
0.0227718279,
0.0033429123,
-0.0185679551,
0.0295674987,
0.0170673653,
0.0418473519,
-0.0023373351,
-0.0203833245,
0.0339310765,
-0.0439708345,
0.00056057,
0.1148566753,
0.037594866,
-0.0190682206,
-0.028212728,
-0.0373325199,
-0.034313675,
-0.0512208603,
-0.0175687429,
0.0103351967,
-0.0277255271,
-0.0442633331,
-0.0540319234,
-0.0586618483,
0.047808297,
-0.0129720327,
0.0034906575,
-0.0138788279,
0.0328014344,
0.0100936312,
-0.0367214382,
0.0119653037,
-0.027540192,
-0.0168233421,
-0.0508426391,
-0.036724031,
0.017567331,
-0.0068333694,
-0.0257656612,
0.0542555451,
-0.1005802229,
-0.0593781471,
0.0011025378,
0.0269820262,
0.0172608066,
0.0546547808,
-0.0099787042,
0.0060781329,
0.0125357211,
0.0041303169,
-0.0439978428,
-0.0136084361,
0.041932039,
-0.0425838307,
0.0039857333,
0.0218187254,
-0.0504362471,
0.0322849303,
-0.0028954914,
0.0174682885,
-0.0420112535,
-0.0321180522,
0.0214141477,
0.0327273272,
0.0339546725,
0.0187452994,
-0.036299143,
-0.0280131195,
0.0050486773,
-0.0415991396,
0.0004732659,
-0.0547016039,
-0.0201110505,
0.046481397,
0.001271545,
-0.0104708364,
0.0489357635,
0.0471384749,
0.0333572254,
-0.065197885,
-0.0092554139,
-0.0423034914,
0.0225958079,
0.022362005,
-0.0326233096,
-0.0511343144,
0.0197264049,
0.0433782414,
0.015663946,
-0.0562060662,
0.0435165092,
0.0077678859,
0.0022696787,
-0.0246090665,
0.0438867062,
-0.0316016153,
-0.0152990315,
-0.060759414,
0.0322202668,
0.0408280715,
-0.0291609019,
0.0813918486,
-0.012352596,
-0.0116961058,
-0.0304916371,
0.0222627465,
-0.0068458701,
0.002112898,
0.0316837095,
0.0183153842,
-0.0623537004,
-0.0212767944,
0.0718798116,
-0.004362395,
0.0578499064,
0.002110485,
0.0000122178,
-0.0466651507,
-0.0099409502,
0.0052830069,
-0.0044727949,
-0.0252145417,
0.0124530736,
-0.0306166019,
-0.0214053784,
0.0039891847,
-0.0224820431,
0.0062097344,
-0.0020370991,
0.0371231921,
0.0453932956,
-0.0016686183,
-0.0456691794,
-0.024730226,
-0.0274796952,
0.0106784552,
-0.014784053,
-0.0129674654,
-6.877579409e-33,
-0.0522261597,
0.0655635223,
0.0187487155,
0.0075834701,
-0.0264011491,
0.0118741784,
-0.0238294844,
-0.0302284434,
-0.0243971925,
0.0005863578,
0.0030892349,
-0.0153054399,
0.0337359197,
0.0511826687,
-0.0156322382,
-0.0301084612,
0.0682338923,
-0.0005562147,
-0.0153687354,
0.0119883623,
0.0189307444,
0.0293009561,
0.0491653904,
-0.0503615364,
0.0083470568,
-0.0042679734,
0.0042456975,
-0.0055948091,
0.0395716988,
0.0563611053,
-0.0486125313,
0.0227117408,
0.0400665663,
-0.0694667324,
-0.0154333962,
0.011370251,
-0.1195796207,
0.0181214157,
0.0112724844,
0.0087285768,
-0.0100018457,
-0.0525369309,
0.0157139096,
0.0082178712,
0.0058877282,
-0.0197231136,
0.0156975109,
-0.0353162549,
0.0131950378,
0.0066817976,
-0.0499364398,
0.0382151417,
0.0072497674,
-0.0092972256,
0.0730021745,
0.0288009644,
-0.0007601879,
0.0113173136,
-0.0555696003,
-0.023172481,
0.0236764327,
0.0590456165,
0.0341437794,
0.0319308825,
0.0024066556,
0.0717064962,
0.0060211802,
-0.0134115145,
-0.0286887437,
-0.0166038908,
-0.0101347277,
0.0836955607,
-0.0329489037,
-0.0084340852,
0.0311509017,
-0.0025077914,
-0.069721505,
0.0208017491,
0.0371356979,
0.0448942073,
0.0117666926,
0.0138393128,
-0.0742886811,
0.0013879974,
0.0056641726,
0.0250907335,
-0.009895104,
-0.0063769557,
0.0361419283,
0.0252516214,
0.0017180641,
0.0182332471,
0.0503393225,
-0.0337639935,
0.0200627856,
0.0352595486,
-0.0214290041,
0.0156629458,
-0.012196756,
0.0189917963,
-0.0643527731,
-0.0485938862,
0.0073427153,
-0.0034089186,
0.0057039061,
0.0102989245,
0.0452454835,
0.020528106,
-0.0638688877,
-0.0088548698,
-0.0559039414,
0.0123272995,
-0.0243056044,
0.0465428196,
0.0335436165,
0.0228155442,
-0.0252577234,
0.0457635298,
0.0050398679,
0.0070876051,
-0.0218118541,
-0.0256281178,
0.0210812315,
0.0140957125,
-0.0054438724,
0.0394887328,
-0.0440988019,
-0.0076610167,
0.0079062954,
-0.0164507553,
-0.0012039536,
0.0292477272,
2.589e-7,
0.0294088013,
0.0460139476,
0.059434671,
0.032822147,
0.0109714335,
0.0378638767,
-0.0094007505,
0.0178267099,
0.0231338721,
-0.011864773,
0.0009037448,
0.0251680873,
0.0582509898,
0.0097541241,
-0.0431330763,
-0.0154975206,
-0.0468435772,
-0.0171363857,
-0.045649752,
-0.0172408819,
0.0437781923,
0.1344482154,
0.007657235,
0.0109069096,
-0.015233459,
-0.0323931426,
0.0474773608,
-0.0384454839,
-0.0427315682,
0.0472431369,
0.0024267149,
0.0398604274,
-0.021061141,
0.0225187074,
-0.0114141051,
0.0132129453,
0.0135032814,
0.0955535546,
-0.0106572229,
-0.0114448387,
-0.0101470901,
-0.0149836652,
-0.0276277773,
-0.0260735061,
0.1052167714,
-0.0625288039,
-0.0367216244,
-0.0250738952,
-0.0229370296,
0.0270022191,
-0.0525131188,
-0.0122874975,
-0.0280714165,
0.0330809243,
0.0386118777,
-0.0222740863,
-0.0628572032,
-0.0767255574,
-0.0091763129,
0.0437713005,
-0.038509611,
-0.0338856205,
-0.009954771,
-0.00442885,
0.0108570866,
-0.087931551,
0.0049618138,
2.735114312e-34,
0.0195344184,
-0.0035382514,
-0.0326087922,
0.0667770654,
0.0306117125,
-0.0163653493,
-0.0415458716,
0.0024745387,
-0.0710247159,
-0.0884089246,
0.0123523036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05083v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05083v1 | FLatS: Principled Out-of-Distribution Detection with Feature-Based Likelihood Ratio Score | 2023-10-08T09:16:46 | 2023-10-08T09:16:46 | Haowei Lin, Yuntian Gu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Detecting out-of-distribution (OOD) instances is crucial for NLP models in
practical applications. Although numerous OOD detection methods exist, most of
them are empirical. Backed by theoretical analysis, this paper advocates for
the measurement of the "OOD-ness" of a test case $\boldsymbol{x}$ through the
likelihood ratio between out-distribution $\mathcal P_{\textit{out}}$ and
in-distribution $\mathcal P_{\textit{in}}$. We argue that the state-of-the-art
(SOTA) feature-based OOD detection methods, such as Maha and KNN, are
suboptimal since they only estimate in-distribution density
$p_{\textit{in}}(\boldsymbol{x})$. To address this issue, we propose FLatS, a
principled solution for OOD detection based on likelihood ratio. Moreover, we
demonstrate that FLatS can serve as a general framework capable of enhancing
other OOD detection methods by incorporating out-distribution density
$p_{\textit{out}}(\boldsymbol{x})$ estimation. Experiments show that FLatS
establishes a new SOTA on popular benchmarks. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/linhaowei1/FLatS. | [
0.0229639467,
0.0166454576,
0.0177792273,
0.0648948699,
-0.0239343215,
-0.0100376848,
-0.0833729133,
0.0537349656,
-0.062146578,
-0.0447666906,
0.0203329399,
-0.0218515955,
0.0321081653,
0.0424239598,
-0.0054967394,
-0.0066172052,
0.0270698704,
0.0036432438,
0.0225687958,
0.0198510159,
0.005130203,
-0.0010567521,
-0.0194979571,
0.0324928164,
0.0207994971,
-0.024760196,
0.018959498,
0.0315299854,
-0.0044343462,
-0.0181085225,
-0.0245065726,
0.0208277088,
-0.0434827656,
-0.0069799768,
0.0000017403,
-0.0599293374,
-0.0171217732,
0.0129479608,
-0.0065991799,
0.0369272083,
0.0300012417,
-0.0353184938,
-0.0316759832,
0.0141872028,
0.0020886776,
0.014981579,
0.0543506667,
0.0413784645,
-0.0150626283,
0.0942946821,
-0.0094877128,
0.0498299785,
0.0520116687,
0.0248375777,
-0.0237479694,
-0.0073496839,
0.0148505364,
-0.0466957875,
0.0112842945,
-0.0370705985,
-0.0096635828,
0.0456033461,
-0.0082372669,
0.0439530835,
-0.0122185452,
0.0150759201,
-0.027145192,
0.028508395,
-0.0171191208,
0.0608676523,
-0.0572804883,
-0.0249116942,
0.018115107,
-0.037006218,
0.0153224692,
0.0625281557,
-0.0075302073,
0.0199256726,
-0.0196166784,
0.0315909199,
0.0164657459,
0.0492142104,
0.022072304,
-0.0010108622,
-0.0191774443,
0.048265066,
0.0013537605,
-0.032015007,
-0.0254880525,
-0.0013374473,
-0.0931774303,
-0.0145875793,
0.0158082303,
-0.0079816245,
0.0258244593,
0.0016519798,
-0.0333084129,
-0.0017848487,
0.0345467702,
-0.062500596,
0.0429949611,
-0.0046646651,
-0.049743861,
0.0076774149,
0.0166298375,
0.0364947356,
0.0003202494,
0.0057786107,
-0.0068617971,
0.0344115905,
-0.0254453998,
0.0084766932,
-0.0042103925,
0.0455772765,
-0.0130570978,
-0.0587958656,
0.0119288033,
-0.0015312606,
-0.0031555204,
-0.0232686736,
0.000156674,
0.0129811447,
0.0038207064,
0.0070674121,
-0.0060689468,
0.039321743,
0.0184794404,
-0.0252344776,
-0.0269863121,
-0.0563291684,
-0.0286500268,
0.0599071197,
0.0014875124,
0.0245753471,
-0.0089368531,
0.043974936,
0.0476725064,
-0.0671681613,
-0.0260752682,
-0.0369058363,
-0.0273126271,
-0.0318173356,
-0.0293899085,
-0.0946025178,
-0.0838736147,
0.0150748808,
0.0181684569,
-0.0427938662,
0.0215223096,
0.0442971624,
-0.0081419004,
0.0191025268,
-0.0270842947,
0.0267108958,
-0.0271846633,
-0.0149792219,
0.0504564308,
0.1110968366,
0.0035852806,
-0.0287633874,
0.0676916912,
0.0387118049,
0.0827656239,
0.0714429542,
0.0006280132,
0.0317630321,
0.0093005504,
-0.0198097564,
-0.0228390843,
-0.0003521254,
0.055297263,
0.0164138097,
-0.003906193,
-0.0210267026,
0.0414288603,
0.0127311787,
0.010784952,
-0.0645905584,
-0.0004406392,
0.0401790887,
-0.0150059974,
0.0628955215,
-0.0145910485,
-0.0294510107,
-0.0477405004,
0.02388715,
0.0313337073,
0.0242387839,
-0.0082899416,
-0.0356347598,
-0.0680685863,
0.0018913797,
-0.0479679108,
-0.0062152306,
0.0609259158,
0.0470697582,
-0.0139442459,
0.0610231496,
0.0234848037,
0.0084762098,
-0.0038473157,
-0.051315289,
-0.0193038117,
-0.00246703,
0.0911423489,
-0.0421556644,
0.0497984588,
0.0015789111,
-0.0594603531,
0.0371228382,
-0.024299344,
0.0076530478,
0.0270725898,
-0.0298922788,
-0.0025733698,
0.0172483232,
0.0801696777,
-0.0241777003,
0.0317590795,
0.0156229874,
0.0367453508,
-0.1123357043,
-0.0005530028,
0.0284750555,
0.0218636841,
-0.0028288744,
0.023184998,
0.0063839112,
0.0243207831,
0.0306934733,
-0.0238222703,
0.0208523273,
0.007225398,
-0.0313731581,
-0.0164222624,
-0.0149135226,
-0.0141216842,
-0.0685114264,
0.0153565938,
-0.0213552564,
0.0214567482,
0.0145539567,
-0.0046674157,
-0.0011688987,
0.0025168103,
-0.0633407682,
0.044211898,
-0.0600303635,
0.0304438993,
0.0022720571,
0.0555108152,
-0.0367487632,
0.0738245174,
-0.0478389375,
0.0395520404,
0.0070076385,
-0.0047530751,
0.0571590438,
-0.0582829863,
-0.0209791642,
0.0248846207,
-0.0484779216,
0.0038158351,
-0.0090538254,
0.0187336057,
-0.0196542311,
0.0108951852,
-0.037566077,
0.0310881324,
-0.0238609184,
0.0240281913,
0.0610082559,
0.0267610643,
-0.0361957327,
-0.0061976849,
0.0120651005,
-0.0261751991,
0.0238515064,
0.0128685944,
0.0234259572,
-0.0133407339,
-0.02339435,
0.0277144238,
-0.0034047712,
-0.0322883874,
0.0685780048,
-0.0608903803,
-0.0652285442,
-0.084614113,
0.0870296955,
-0.0131962262,
0.0126230838,
0.0270851944,
-0.0017465844,
-0.0418494008,
-0.0083136102,
0.0414009392,
0.0217883755,
-0.0041918969,
-0.0231425837,
0.0436387658,
-0.0259058308,
-0.0311692692,
-0.0343948416,
-0.003296419,
0.013749131,
0.0414197855,
-0.0066001285,
0.0574172921,
-0.0080432286,
0.0432038233,
-0.0267645661,
-0.0118753873,
-0.0390188098,
-0.0565057471,
0.0046179644,
-0.0044633173,
0.0158065353,
-0.0249203276,
0.0450163186,
0.0215384439,
-0.0193025637,
0.0384390876,
-0.0414431021,
0.0212851278,
-0.0816044137,
-0.0065413374,
-0.0437170006,
-0.007871856,
-0.0214873236,
0.0109279389,
0.0560775213,
-0.0780801103,
0.0023807958,
0.0016092146,
-0.009806796,
-0.0248052794,
0.0745080635,
-0.0479452722,
0.021697225,
0.0088842353,
-0.0081592733,
-0.0185028315,
-0.1155227795,
0.0227451399,
-0.0064526754,
-0.0495440476,
-0.0233156029,
-0.0027010532,
0.0572128966,
-0.043752186,
0.0451961644,
-0.0193928089,
-0.0105606047,
-0.0093573648,
0.0965256244,
0.0570373051,
-0.0179691333,
0.0380165763,
-0.0147230681,
-0.0274405666,
0.0319781788,
-0.0007515188,
0.0186043251,
0.0249533616,
-0.0103171924,
0.0250351448,
-0.0241228808,
-0.0448065661,
0.0578479096,
0.0588075407,
-0.0233898032,
-0.0236334242,
0.0748532116,
0.0270079728,
-0.0316407643,
0.0059385062,
-0.0009995676,
0.0459362753,
0.0183064975,
-0.0332277007,
-0.0729493499,
-0.0360294022,
0.0192791745,
0.0245633442,
-0.0319397263,
-0.0189971961,
-0.0015222204,
-0.1233310401,
0.0152009288,
-0.0121114561,
-0.0118997125,
-0.0597925447,
-0.0475261994,
0.0302321333,
-0.0226678327,
0.0022929455,
-0.001113968,
-0.016597569,
0.0150848413,
-0.0014100202,
-0.0560617596,
-0.0758503154,
0.042997703,
-0.0453976095,
-0.0019902643,
0.0775113702,
0.0119957672,
-0.0167837348,
0.0031753234,
-0.0157879256,
-0.0848318711,
-0.0134463217,
0.0031329435,
0.0568263382,
0.0121104615,
0.0056785713,
0.0034014501,
0.0324173905,
-0.0611600354,
0.0064251069,
-0.009098514,
0.0560863242,
-0.0071808347,
-0.0515995659,
-0.0369454697,
0.0253587719,
0.0315405577,
0.0642614588,
0.0055547869,
-0.0098503502,
-0.0318496414,
-0.0272069611,
-0.0124280136,
0.0590566918,
0.0031545702,
0.0181073938,
0.0363958962,
-0.0807798952,
-0.1047967747,
-0.0133469524,
-0.0521841943,
0.043914251,
0.0116365524,
0.0430462919,
-0.0389894843,
0.0123610385,
-0.0156910531,
-0.0195951965,
-0.0310657844,
0.0026528412,
-0.0332731083,
0.0420280322,
0.0381090753,
0.0189851858,
-0.0287215915,
0.0656641871,
-0.0637425855,
-0.0498825163,
-0.0101370979,
-0.0331933275,
0.0287848264,
-0.0103408322,
-0.0508958846,
-0.0149932848,
0.0808084458,
0.0671415925,
-0.0177024268,
0.0266347583,
0.0112130912,
-0.0441695303,
0.0116712106,
0.0428915285,
-0.0109776733,
-0.0351942927,
-0.0353517868,
0.0103410212,
-0.0249527581,
-0.0477217548,
0.0339719392,
0.0138636129,
0.0344198309,
-0.0151493754,
-0.0866312608,
-0.0307424143,
-0.0088233305,
-0.000730962,
-0.0145110805,
-0.015001527,
0.054689914,
0.0483313128,
0.0173888318,
-0.0285528768,
0.0437499322,
-0.0182861127,
0.0227613226,
0.0123880319,
-0.0178841557,
0.0568705983,
-0.0394048244,
-0.0042976961,
-0.0359319411,
-0.00138845,
-0.012453896,
-0.0152642662,
0.0227328259,
-0.0171204023,
0.0623411126,
-0.0153120803,
-0.0183812976,
0.0057183085,
0.0109457998,
-0.0525894985,
0.0434328653,
-0.05393181,
0.0455726087,
0.0190914944,
-0.0393597558,
0.0445502624,
-0.0084579196,
0.0218466464,
-0.0348161235,
0.0428724997,
-0.0272984989,
-0.0055554337,
0.0079438947,
0.0229166802,
-0.0187137574,
0.0057892958,
0.0717630237,
0.0369731598,
0.0282544997,
0.0052286973,
-0.0100468909,
-0.0250524748,
0.0230192896,
-0.0054100277,
0.0773722008,
-0.0175159834,
0.0435803086,
-0.0520855077,
-0.0451450795,
0.0014997111,
-0.0127835618,
0.0234819967,
0.016270835,
0.0086124679,
0.0753548592,
0.0063504358,
-0.0089345342,
-0.050155215,
-0.0394903943,
-0.0106044905,
-0.0097459424,
-0.0213859156,
-5.567973642e-33,
-0.0170096904,
-0.0449817143,
-0.0505967252,
-0.0066389721,
0.0548679382,
0.0058647199,
-0.0026996983,
0.0111101195,
-0.020946255,
-0.0018173709,
-0.0048077474,
0.0393031761,
0.0227833968,
-0.0133143859,
-0.0291484799,
-0.002470219,
0.0092345169,
0.0076245074,
-0.0232409332,
-0.0200695843,
0.0572396666,
0.0080943629,
0.0682622045,
-0.0381716974,
0.0121923415,
-0.0105129033,
-0.0300075132,
0.0013928737,
0.0014339086,
0.0411670208,
-0.0140788872,
0.0761317387,
0.0298289116,
-0.0091213398,
-0.0231464095,
-0.0491721891,
-0.0317789689,
-0.033580035,
0.0217436496,
-0.0039073909,
0.0490280204,
0.0140211638,
0.0429735854,
-0.0063755149,
-0.0215026792,
-0.0249068812,
0.0511414073,
-0.0361368246,
-0.0254916269,
0.0070660994,
-0.0449551009,
0.0706848949,
0.0016589862,
-0.0250133388,
0.0122171203,
0.0045918133,
-0.0002668722,
-0.0543356203,
-0.005927946,
-0.0046280776,
0.0288371556,
0.0663102344,
0.0335922763,
-0.0129790548,
-0.0200865027,
0.0426217094,
-0.0555395037,
-0.0255504809,
0.0168606918,
-0.0382426083,
0.0589028448,
0.0165392999,
0.0028157381,
0.0634928197,
0.0807210431,
-0.0000782447,
-0.0435574017,
0.0448003188,
-0.0064867833,
-0.0323584005,
0.0256033074,
-0.0065457504,
-0.1272031963,
-0.0392029956,
-0.0065733427,
-0.0432915092,
-0.0261335447,
-0.0340753421,
0.0419822037,
0.0132178999,
-0.004316363,
0.0273729973,
-0.0011609339,
-0.0625584573,
-0.0102850394,
0.0510392934,
-0.0343585908,
0.0248058215,
-0.0301340483,
0.006212451,
-0.0416723639,
-0.0159170181,
0.0084125809,
0.0320703723,
-0.0127836503,
-0.0191830564,
0.043585211,
0.0112544531,
-0.0653095171,
-0.0061909556,
0.0046966057,
0.0296861585,
-0.0272801332,
0.0656597912,
0.0216530487,
-0.020988455,
-0.0184495673,
0.0172393434,
0.0363083668,
0.0029916796,
-0.0425250828,
0.0439936258,
-0.0179589633,
-0.0006790269,
-0.0336160548,
0.0047664056,
0.0025535116,
-0.0095500313,
0.014907754,
-0.0089693945,
-0.0137024187,
0.0093461173,
2.406e-7,
0.052731473,
0.0145667149,
0.0197915696,
-0.0031532981,
-0.0130660357,
0.0185595676,
-0.0345238596,
0.0015891765,
-0.0114607317,
-0.0747153163,
-0.0109305829,
-0.0155946687,
-0.0022402522,
0.0117006339,
-0.1165040582,
0.0392572023,
-0.0110156983,
-0.0066486932,
-0.0397092216,
-0.053865619,
0.0080980854,
0.0969776139,
0.0141705405,
-0.0206701066,
0.0047231531,
-0.0579084344,
0.0315631777,
0.0130610261,
-0.0135402791,
0.0187197551,
0.0164405443,
0.0063104867,
0.0661828518,
0.0261138082,
-0.0096156718,
0.0415863022,
0.0400265977,
0.0350918695,
0.01014846,
-0.053686779,
-0.0062012747,
0.0045327758,
-0.0007826634,
-0.0547285713,
0.071362704,
0.0424842685,
-0.0457896665,
-0.0551015809,
-0.0171582233,
-0.0146012167,
0.0090221418,
-0.0156622883,
-0.0146531733,
0.0204905905,
0.0145774577,
-0.0082632778,
-0.0254961886,
-0.0339536257,
-0.050223086,
0.0083787618,
-0.0199742429,
-0.0573434792,
-0.0084519256,
0.0005330675,
0.0100732101,
-0.0721017197,
0.0098768501,
2.562900487e-34,
0.0388865322,
0.0215039626,
-0.0147681404,
0.0141651379,
0.0329377353,
-0.0111234318,
0.0074235303,
0.0034080271,
-0.0153147783,
-0.042211052,
0.0272807106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18324v1 | "A Nova Eletricidade: Aplicações, Riscos e Tendências da IA Moderna -- "The New Electricity": Applications, Risks, and Trends in Current AI | 2023-10-08T09:01:18 | 2023-10-08T09:01:18 | Ana L. C. Bazzan, Anderson R. Tavares, André G. Pereira, Cláudio R. Jung, Jacob Scharcanski, Joel Luis Carbonera, Luís C. Lamb, Mariana Recamonde-Mendoza, Thiago L. T. da Silveira, Viviane Moreira | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, 68, I.2 | The thought-provoking analogy between AI and electricity, made by computer
scientist and entrepreneur Andrew Ng, summarizes the deep transformation that
recent advances in Artificial Intelligence (AI) have triggered in the world.
This chapter presents an overview of the ever-evolving landscape of AI, written
in Portuguese. With no intent to exhaust the subject, we explore the AI
applications that are redefining sectors of the economy, impacting society and
humanity. We analyze the risks that may come along with rapid technological
progress and future trends in AI, an area that is on the path to becoming a
general-purpose technology, just like electricity, which revolutionized society
in the 19th and 20th centuries.
A provocativa compara\c{c}\~ao entre IA e eletricidade, feita pelo cientista
da computa\c{c}\~ao e empreendedor Andrew Ng, resume a profunda
transforma\c{c}\~ao que os recentes avan\c{c}os em Intelig\^encia Artificial
(IA) t\^em desencadeado no mundo. Este cap\'itulo apresenta uma vis\~ao geral
pela paisagem em constante evolu\c{c}\~ao da IA. Sem pretens\~oes de exaurir o
assunto, exploramos as aplica\c{c}\~oes que est\~ao redefinindo setores da
economia, impactando a sociedade e a humanidade. Analisamos os riscos que
acompanham o r\'apido progresso tecnol\'ogico e as tend\^encias futuras da IA,
\'area que trilha o caminho para se tornar uma tecnologia de prop\'osito geral,
assim como a eletricidade, que revolucionou a sociedade dos s\'eculos XIX e XX. | [
-0.0181402173,
0.0564115569,
-0.0398966558,
-0.0501882471,
0.0154907769,
0.0070837326,
0.0334445611,
0.0067087039,
0.0305966195,
-0.0078715524,
-0.0005060952,
0.054860983,
-0.0057274089,
0.0467590801,
0.0458057709,
-0.0078910375,
0.0150059387,
-0.0013545584,
-0.0492037795,
-0.0016459421,
-0.0500360169,
-0.0171672162,
0.0092234947,
0.0272570103,
0.0131542571,
0.00139368,
0.0377698429,
-0.0206363816,
0.0192839652,
-0.0328590535,
0.0100158807,
-0.0188960638,
-0.0060494547,
0.0313738585,
0.0000023568,
-0.0507041365,
-0.0341507234,
0.0023749396,
-0.0197186302,
-0.0617808849,
0.035589464,
0.0594021641,
-0.0074069886,
-0.003708997,
-0.0978638455,
0.05121658,
0.0296338499,
-0.0480901077,
0.0039623575,
0.0428897142,
-0.0109373126,
-0.0128142899,
0.0469179563,
-0.0189117622,
-0.0233788826,
0.0038527164,
0.026504444,
-0.0219556168,
0.0143201817,
-0.01645533,
0.0243961699,
0.0346560068,
0.0247760378,
-0.0251951925,
0.0304417238,
0.023846224,
0.0146915754,
-0.0259494316,
-0.0297746789,
0.0074737142,
0.0611964017,
0.0037272756,
0.0228780322,
0.0468168706,
0.0294993855,
-0.0481992364,
-0.0432593338,
0.0204896331,
-0.0131082805,
-0.0282524135,
0.073759079,
0.0281258505,
0.0450232551,
0.0392606258,
0.0010419078,
0.0555866882,
-0.0310418103,
-0.007017538,
0.0612992309,
-0.0265088938,
0.0157539956,
-0.011108838,
0.0083283233,
0.0311991218,
-0.0288985949,
-0.0168249086,
-0.0160799138,
-0.0174648855,
0.0059420438,
-0.0746235698,
0.0063921176,
-0.0551051758,
0.0780692399,
0.0313959196,
0.0300294738,
0.0144737726,
-0.084813498,
-0.0115787601,
-0.0333585404,
0.0135062188,
-0.0434530936,
-0.0451007746,
-0.0464690737,
0.0370105356,
-0.0274594501,
0.0127566699,
0.0014588536,
0.0196001306,
-0.0680953562,
-0.0177730992,
-0.0660644472,
0.026569305,
0.0322042368,
-0.0040697558,
-0.028654553,
0.0127570294,
-0.0538631603,
0.0264279321,
-0.0030448239,
-0.0215613302,
0.0457168706,
-0.012488517,
-0.0213444401,
-0.0084320111,
0.0133660287,
0.0635772645,
0.0247892402,
-0.0376784429,
-0.0180182252,
-0.0576765426,
0.0084138764,
-0.0723867342,
0.0186578799,
0.0163045023,
-0.0286268145,
-0.0283068512,
0.005223759,
-0.0350341946,
-0.010449688,
0.0044213356,
0.0047339629,
-0.0184223857,
-0.0731639713,
0.0025807116,
0.0364433564,
0.012645009,
-0.0246575847,
0.0102634225,
0.0218604971,
-0.0032820082,
0.0235849284,
-0.0084884353,
0.0677328333,
0.0155321546,
-0.0174695142,
-0.0085334117,
0.0527453832,
0.0280633848,
-0.0194686092,
0.0010837046,
0.0113359205,
-0.0091048153,
0.0016570715,
0.0774570554,
0.0395673066,
0.000163374,
-0.0177833512,
0.0769635811,
0.0164664537,
-0.0625606254,
0.0326987095,
-0.0610762239,
-0.0011948023,
-0.0155812846,
-0.0336722136,
-0.0204628278,
-0.0608394779,
0.035444662,
-0.0260543358,
-0.0263910834,
0.0730489418,
-0.0240933895,
0.0072384528,
0.021070743,
0.0169288274,
0.0021065159,
0.0016069709,
-0.086676456,
-0.0410577171,
0.0215601809,
-0.060832601,
-0.0898208544,
0.0480498038,
0.0498358048,
0.0153718758,
0.0047304044,
0.0028435013,
-0.0118217096,
-0.0256752595,
-0.0137519483,
-0.0551649705,
-0.0275400449,
-0.0153875165,
0.0240062978,
0.0076076868,
-0.0241878666,
-0.0023554235,
0.043621555,
-0.0652793869,
0.0411334299,
-0.0218712427,
0.0573056266,
0.0045329807,
-0.0026536186,
-0.0334443152,
-0.0301407222,
-0.0255431999,
0.0184935629,
-0.0046496005,
0.0503469482,
-0.0103340261,
-0.0077196625,
0.0575743616,
-0.0281319637,
-0.029758215,
0.0108358441,
0.0261289328,
0.1757808626,
-0.0002014804,
-0.06677901,
-0.0048357756,
0.0303232241,
0.0606522076,
-0.0035214482,
0.0375139117,
-0.0063256873,
0.0493757129,
0.0211737361,
0.0223176349,
-0.0319483727,
0.0562154576,
0.0098415911,
0.0106176296,
0.0306789279,
-0.0489412658,
0.0224622395,
-0.0133564342,
0.0112633063,
-0.0509142205,
0.0016193895,
0.0312512927,
-0.0321875252,
-0.0143053476,
0.0482104458,
0.0342134796,
0.036155358,
0.0530617088,
-0.0305038672,
-0.0119995615,
0.0119337263,
-0.0268152393,
0.0201901086,
-0.0244352557,
-0.0125499703,
0.0131917838,
0.0388225503,
0.0281983316,
0.000003628,
-0.0147638777,
-0.0129229482,
0.0305957608,
-0.0162828118,
-0.0108254487,
0.0361150689,
-0.0337840021,
0.0357897803,
0.1110279933,
-0.0411908589,
-0.0713842958,
0.0024347759,
-0.0231877677,
0.006642248,
-0.0445251763,
-0.003642115,
-0.0204850435,
0.0418587476,
0.0007316486,
0.0419873185,
-0.0213886574,
0.0454930253,
0.0483663566,
0.0251787081,
0.0078594405,
-0.0071499348,
0.0394336581,
0.0375455655,
-0.0574676581,
-0.0048923907,
0.0345849767,
0.015186552,
0.0036590481,
0.0214798115,
0.0510788076,
0.0906338021,
-0.0412348472,
-0.0503888018,
0.017735444,
-0.0679378435,
-0.0153258229,
0.0738266185,
0.0141817415,
-0.002438287,
0.0088865226,
0.0358820632,
0.0090088416,
-0.0473702811,
-0.0640399978,
0.0136292791,
0.0138846692,
-0.0078518726,
0.0173710547,
-0.0067400658,
0.02345955,
0.0005580127,
0.0049783951,
-0.0186351947,
0.00265428,
0.0184991676,
-0.0124375047,
-0.0195115916,
-0.0111904535,
-0.0667181909,
0.0023406323,
-0.0341741443,
-0.0011730194,
0.0189208183,
0.0610362031,
-0.0193662643,
-0.0000440877,
-0.0522577167,
0.0484003164,
0.0299832653,
-0.009989501,
-0.0349747762,
0.0079056518,
-0.0069942717,
-0.00961693,
-0.0280032679,
0.0120879253,
0.0351848379,
0.0168825798,
0.0086735934,
-0.013445721,
-0.0358276106,
-0.0457716845,
0.0358675942,
-0.0215220768,
0.0322654285,
-0.033412315,
-0.0497710891,
-0.0109412363,
0.0037928554,
0.006677357,
0.0121668857,
-0.0364510939,
-0.0208774004,
0.0235991199,
0.0209509619,
-0.0734773353,
0.0087015154,
0.0507104509,
-0.057294555,
0.0789258704,
-0.0043215011,
0.017170826,
-0.0510157868,
-0.0113510899,
-0.0018927477,
-0.0132167432,
0.0660668761,
-0.0084594954,
0.0025356042,
-0.0524716601,
-0.0077311229,
-0.0465855822,
-0.0459473245,
0.0085087661,
-0.008570062,
0.0115445554,
0.01037913,
0.0470886901,
-0.0038317926,
0.0243045632,
-0.0340496711,
-0.0373395979,
-0.0153214969,
0.1226718724,
0.0490080304,
-0.0109207015,
0.0260301046,
-0.0141313961,
0.0350687541,
0.0079485159,
-0.0036192108,
0.0345247611,
0.0219580475,
0.0028293983,
-0.0292888917,
0.0005639518,
0.0379527323,
0.0299157649,
0.1078470573,
0.0678082108,
-0.0488205031,
-0.0359125659,
-0.0466573648,
-0.0905220062,
0.0047951723,
-0.0377604701,
-0.0443460084,
-0.0084614241,
-0.0012474442,
-0.0035527542,
0.0016254184,
-0.0033886202,
-0.0246047396,
0.0054230615,
-0.0321499221,
-0.1069509163,
-0.033162754,
-0.0595051423,
-0.0303947851,
0.0284267087,
0.0341167077,
-0.0767456442,
0.0277925264,
0.0120145204,
-0.0217877105,
-0.0497481003,
0.0225343183,
-0.0036018058,
0.0138235623,
-0.0242048521,
-0.0294682346,
0.0006326854,
-0.0090575935,
-0.0488751382,
-0.0238501672,
-0.0097628366,
0.0529229306,
0.0597510077,
0.0297849886,
-0.0073563391,
-0.000628979,
-0.0302751344,
0.0413086079,
0.0263378881,
-0.0401177146,
0.0162470024,
0.0170469042,
0.0070996047,
-0.0168093946,
0.0049565812,
-0.0086289877,
-0.0083466955,
-0.0129894605,
0.0025984759,
-0.0957603529,
-0.0197657105,
-0.0083316816,
0.0367810205,
0.0626971796,
-0.0244739708,
0.0404828191,
0.0206377804,
-0.0113026109,
0.0313763767,
0.006716907,
0.0009458252,
-0.0374442972,
0.0279057566,
-0.0255736224,
0.0124797905,
0.0171020385,
0.0133685097,
-0.069809258,
-0.0225616246,
0.0484372005,
0.015051771,
0.0703144521,
-0.0111868503,
0.0487625748,
0.0294685941,
0.0520307347,
0.0049532992,
0.0305650942,
-0.0186618585,
-0.0138648553,
-0.0179084539,
-0.0507868305,
0.0108503634,
0.0818423778,
0.0095028551,
-0.0771302506,
-0.0027562722,
0.0665796399,
-0.0075276899,
0.0283842739,
-0.0238906015,
-0.0049942303,
0.0020873433,
0.0014293421,
-0.0317690298,
-0.0150168678,
-0.0010420583,
-0.0385898538,
0.0044408999,
-0.0309787169,
0.0610263534,
0.0326715037,
-0.056600973,
0.0373652279,
-0.0048162965,
-0.0165313911,
-0.0311310291,
-0.0017658765,
0.0567062199,
-0.0558426008,
0.0120762475,
-0.0489385538,
-0.0421921127,
-0.0172750596,
-0.0216755848,
-0.0046988609,
-0.0113960998,
-0.0069127106,
0.0137682669,
0.008586009,
-0.0075340173,
-0.0308441594,
-0.0298860054,
0.0333298817,
-0.1074688658,
0.044322066,
-0.0532545932,
-6.648104545e-33,
0.0272580963,
-0.0639139861,
0.0486991554,
0.0129152145,
-0.0682274699,
-0.0091669178,
-0.0189557765,
0.0279568061,
-0.0244606156,
-0.0072434139,
-0.0100595783,
-0.0255024862,
-0.013342795,
-0.0161746331,
0.0222976971,
0.0070507587,
-0.0214112047,
-0.0284311045,
0.0270608496,
-0.0076249759,
-0.0350849703,
0.0316631384,
0.0470885597,
-0.0565003864,
0.0749938786,
-0.0084217964,
-0.0199560877,
-0.0146769118,
0.0159030892,
0.0089659169,
0.0283394679,
0.0140245762,
0.0318193547,
-0.0485734828,
0.0000023751,
0.0217220187,
0.0026355984,
-0.0354875699,
-0.0116620641,
0.0297878757,
0.0152145335,
-0.1036078855,
0.0181132164,
-0.0143817877,
-0.0431086756,
0.0312678888,
0.0296834093,
-0.0490616895,
0.0094245225,
-0.0159255378,
-0.0083607724,
-0.0123611595,
-0.0466807745,
0.013675849,
0.0159792732,
0.0725124702,
-0.0234496538,
-0.0293345675,
-0.059463229,
0.0436365046,
0.0043476932,
-0.0275824573,
0.0113137998,
-0.0171914101,
0.0615267083,
-0.0045108655,
0.0606048293,
-0.0343559459,
-0.0130960541,
0.0092365798,
-0.0019350209,
0.046802219,
-0.0280152541,
0.0571060181,
-0.0039999434,
-0.001134622,
-0.0327491835,
0.0308977645,
0.0220323019,
0.0308994558,
0.0069537,
-0.0077352626,
-0.0272097532,
-0.0027363459,
0.012871149,
-0.0666830912,
0.01398311,
0.008715855,
-0.0348064378,
-0.0462733991,
0.0060764281,
0.0505630523,
-0.0298831444,
-0.0840529501,
0.0341630019,
-0.0104416171,
-0.0106609883,
-0.0005749897,
0.039199274,
-0.0046015722,
-0.0273234975,
0.0135800047,
-0.0616922006,
0.1048611701,
0.0337801315,
0.002735666,
-0.0146768903,
-0.0144608235,
0.0330458805,
-0.0010770449,
0.0193437748,
0.0083574643,
0.0467288233,
-0.016988527,
0.0000576106,
0.0030079754,
0.0163858924,
-0.0306342468,
0.008934279,
0.0633860081,
-0.0142563824,
-0.0271923561,
0.0074073016,
0.0214128774,
-0.0247111134,
-0.0068119937,
-0.0688576996,
0.085269399,
-0.0116666099,
-0.0643828437,
-0.0357302986,
-0.0360787585,
3.079e-7,
-0.042524077,
0.0498239361,
0.0003160043,
0.0064111813,
0.0161789134,
0.0492868833,
0.0074478192,
0.0178988837,
-0.0268089473,
0.075060606,
0.0475711785,
-0.0118035087,
0.0178768691,
0.0164482649,
-0.0292243585,
-0.0374010168,
-0.0421322435,
-0.0049559767,
-0.0434488021,
-0.0163953118,
-0.02635419,
0.0063511212,
0.0373426527,
-0.0188805293,
-0.0303184278,
-0.0232148916,
-0.0005247288,
0.0005154492,
0.0424420461,
-0.05028826,
-0.0031821805,
0.1072156802,
-0.0094021689,
-0.005965963,
0.0217437986,
-0.017892452,
-0.041132763,
0.0321445018,
0.0118538616,
0.0507519245,
0.0546077564,
-0.0737672821,
0.012433568,
-0.0290264543,
0.0771199167,
-0.0088649942,
-0.0490391515,
-0.0356710143,
-0.0106449658,
-0.0141726416,
0.0394159146,
-0.020774927,
-0.0172205158,
-0.0186708048,
-0.0207171421,
-0.0021439712,
0.0279204696,
0.0052193603,
0.0531967022,
0.0573071577,
-0.0105363186,
-0.062445391,
-0.0109734815,
0.0798802227,
0.0582825989,
-0.0310951248,
0.0536208451,
2.579847809e-34,
-0.0534095056,
-0.0375814214,
-0.0283811875,
-0.0300677717,
0.0331528746,
0.0271389205,
-0.0381837562,
-0.0358803272,
0.0212594494,
-0.0052295527,
-0.0212082881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05074v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05074v3 | DialCoT Meets PPO: Decomposing and Exploring Reasoning Paths in Smaller Language Models | 2023-10-08T08:52:13 | 2023-10-23T09:38:01 | Chengcheng Han, Xiaowei Du, Che Zhang, Yixin Lian, Xiang Li, Ming Gao, Baoyuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has proven to be effective in enhancing the
reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) with at least 100
billion parameters. However, it is ineffective or even detrimental when applied
to reasoning tasks in Smaller Language Models (SLMs) with less than 10 billion
parameters. To address this limitation, we introduce Dialogue-guided
Chain-of-Thought (DialCoT) which employs a dialogue format to generate
intermediate reasoning steps, guiding the model toward the final answer.
Additionally, we optimize the model's reasoning path selection using the
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) algorithm, further enhancing its reasoning
capabilities. Our method offers several advantages compared to previous
approaches. Firstly, we transform the process of solving complex reasoning
questions by breaking them down into a series of simpler sub-questions,
significantly reducing the task difficulty and making it more suitable for
SLMs. Secondly, we optimize the model's reasoning path selection through the
PPO algorithm. We conduct comprehensive experiments on four arithmetic
reasoning datasets, demonstrating that our method achieves significant
performance improvements compared to state-of-the-art competitors. | [
0.0182389952,
0.0819892585,
0.0022151503,
0.0226381216,
-0.0575538911,
0.0247826669,
0.0311588347,
-0.0089954585,
-0.0117073953,
-0.0114279101,
0.0079089776,
-0.0167295653,
0.0040195454,
0.0303496085,
0.014706335,
-0.0774685815,
0.0336209089,
-0.0836991146,
0.0511308387,
-0.0388253927,
-0.0145392315,
-0.0175679475,
-0.03382935,
0.0165869556,
0.0058156652,
-0.0404962637,
-0.031520389,
-0.0261870772,
0.0380481482,
-0.0270087384,
-0.0290908758,
0.0410173982,
0.0294418707,
0.0219321549,
0.0000024025,
-0.0561760589,
-0.0099476986,
-0.0030834631,
-0.0642117858,
0.0014718194,
0.0005746742,
0.0706833303,
0.0141150877,
0.0447506569,
-0.0229449477,
0.018823633,
0.0365590416,
0.0539728254,
0.0677086264,
0.0685517266,
0.0180258062,
-0.0255546048,
-0.0182223897,
0.0008327096,
0.017905131,
-0.0432959534,
0.0138851749,
0.0444774032,
0.0301120449,
0.0052276719,
-0.020796869,
0.020133812,
0.0495995022,
-0.0020583284,
-0.0560040772,
0.0232414585,
0.0015674245,
-0.0212830845,
-0.0054990924,
0.0700379759,
-0.0023763177,
-0.0021629641,
-0.0087732049,
-0.0136409197,
0.016402483,
-0.0103774928,
-0.0632441789,
0.0237256289,
-0.0087455316,
0.0066211876,
0.0164326914,
-0.0064922203,
0.0228047296,
0.016864324,
-0.0827778652,
0.084732987,
-0.005842627,
-0.0276396945,
0.0268916599,
-0.0282388013,
-0.0249951147,
-0.0485755056,
0.020699311,
0.0458739437,
-0.0532437675,
0.0219618455,
0.0134112695,
0.02548212,
-0.0121476529,
0.0055309343,
0.041578155,
0.0741080865,
0.0181009006,
0.0370160304,
0.0101529136,
0.0598658994,
-0.0360684581,
0.0144254239,
-0.0205501858,
0.0253603179,
-0.0518354923,
-0.0117627233,
-0.0292074308,
0.0690683275,
-0.0408394821,
-0.0082769319,
-0.0048612803,
0.0077135703,
-0.0297090393,
0.0232740417,
0.010052871,
0.001893576,
0.0344644226,
-0.051772397,
-0.0680304989,
0.0597338639,
-0.0725877285,
0.0244206171,
0.0163572636,
-0.0030527357,
-0.0189842395,
0.0032171137,
-0.0139805423,
-0.0066901292,
0.0122838002,
0.0754334852,
-0.0330839977,
0.0082405964,
-0.0254768133,
-0.0382434689,
0.0160561986,
-0.0959009528,
0.013332787,
-0.0923365727,
0.016889438,
0.0107188923,
-0.0206521042,
-0.0318076424,
0.0178344622,
0.0244011059,
-0.0207068026,
0.0631631017,
0.0327321999,
-0.0086656893,
0.0203568935,
0.0086676767,
-0.0384449735,
0.060580451,
0.0378554091,
-0.0032566092,
-0.0049404283,
0.0016160605,
-0.0054947068,
0.0321978442,
0.0236625895,
0.0053376528,
-0.0107488679,
0.0237670541,
-0.0148454243,
0.0402497575,
-0.0107004317,
0.0525169373,
-0.0435395762,
0.0194128156,
0.0246779677,
0.0588669218,
-0.0243066158,
0.0025304898,
0.0166686624,
0.0211855434,
0.0233571902,
-0.0185368434,
-0.0672644004,
0.0394808166,
-0.0255125593,
0.0100948084,
0.0304986257,
0.0405565575,
-0.0183878578,
-0.0685477853,
-0.0017103394,
0.0332262181,
0.0032010099,
0.0572240651,
0.0424402319,
-0.0190412514,
-0.0234974436,
0.0637292266,
0.0164777767,
-0.0172011126,
-0.0502730086,
-0.0701322928,
0.0311807655,
0.0366892815,
0.0426459871,
-0.0200750679,
-0.044749625,
-0.0107834162,
0.0292010717,
0.0299531762,
0.0144038359,
-0.0094666081,
-0.0144858221,
-0.0430951603,
-0.0381921977,
0.0034534519,
0.0027481958,
0.002993285,
0.0130347805,
-0.0229212735,
0.0030296964,
0.0071735261,
0.0135720642,
0.01408807,
-0.0318062045,
-0.0124713397,
-0.0067867511,
0.0140309958,
0.0072159623,
0.020759346,
0.0180771127,
0.0324015766,
-0.0053730346,
-0.024648428,
0.002066236,
-0.0185417626,
-0.0597627014,
-0.0502131395,
0.0542305037,
-0.0236693919,
-0.0150079038,
-0.0139551423,
-0.0554089211,
-0.0351856761,
0.043139074,
-0.0371804833,
0.0134385917,
-0.0035352251,
0.0307166446,
-0.0018365142,
-0.04404369,
-0.0381454118,
0.0840496123,
-0.0182359796,
0.0133650247,
0.056455303,
0.0376822241,
0.0391915105,
-0.062359523,
0.0284014195,
0.0170366038,
-0.0212043282,
-0.0058993613,
0.0118493447,
0.0395900011,
-0.0609672889,
-0.0318386219,
-0.0421455987,
0.0013658295,
-0.0036037778,
0.0208460614,
-0.0000278828,
-0.0111092208,
-0.0046197306,
-0.0137318568,
-0.0386373885,
0.0374871641,
-0.0077483258,
0.015242314,
0.0221697111,
-0.0047886991,
-0.0371782668,
-0.0172692779,
-0.0202025399,
-0.0145434169,
0.0156392846,
-0.0199554097,
0.0311906636,
-0.0302901994,
0.0250359904,
-0.0434200503,
-0.0037885674,
-0.0033053632,
-0.0037045197,
0.0298112091,
-0.0288888589,
0.0338026322,
0.075715974,
-0.0238354765,
0.0112679861,
0.0647270754,
-0.01674206,
-0.0782191232,
0.0307614282,
-0.0128529165,
-0.0124086337,
-0.0030692942,
-0.0189914685,
-0.0374651551,
0.0661231056,
-0.005915083,
0.017877439,
-0.0351177603,
0.0405790359,
0.0096056648,
-0.0098543055,
-0.054087963,
0.0135733336,
-0.0153149161,
0.0536036268,
-0.0351473317,
-0.0268638246,
0.0818881616,
0.0078542102,
0.0013304637,
-0.0728314817,
0.0251570921,
-0.0197494905,
0.0589190498,
0.0075364769,
0.0014134247,
-0.0379133075,
-0.0177615173,
-0.0567916632,
-0.0128221409,
0.0268010311,
-0.0327848718,
0.0620442592,
-0.0515069664,
-0.0020242706,
0.0020924816,
-0.0664191544,
-0.066470623,
0.0022834605,
-0.0545258299,
0.0188364033,
-0.0022186877,
-0.0431368798,
-0.0159825459,
-0.0253739916,
0.0480456613,
0.0422811843,
-0.029131297,
-0.0242315326,
-0.0159033034,
-0.0133907478,
0.0270819664,
0.0186305437,
0.0457005389,
-0.0159825105,
0.0830245093,
0.0264822282,
0.0779802203,
-0.0433950722,
-0.0052455808,
0.0349774361,
0.0007428491,
-0.0070229727,
-0.013246363,
0.0595088489,
0.0595780499,
-0.0838928446,
-0.0312128142,
0.1264886409,
0.0534946844,
-0.0294863973,
-0.0041694669,
-0.0663955286,
0.0423486829,
0.0438025743,
0.0425958149,
-0.0485536717,
-0.0461012982,
0.0417219028,
0.0050622402,
-0.004181535,
-0.0354515463,
-0.0048744297,
-0.1096817777,
0.0261753872,
0.0174993891,
0.0088429367,
-0.011605721,
-0.0463203378,
-0.0151850441,
0.0142044146,
-0.0148531916,
0.0444724299,
-0.0038114607,
-0.0064996434,
-0.008078956,
0.0081900544,
0.005247104,
0.0517572835,
-0.0052297181,
0.0213724412,
0.0229742378,
0.009064463,
0.0255718455,
-0.049062971,
0.0671046153,
0.0234850459,
-0.0125981439,
-0.0393452607,
-0.0007714178,
0.0240034405,
-0.0013500517,
-0.027023755,
0.0779425874,
-0.0310628116,
-0.0434555039,
0.0223801378,
0.112257354,
-0.0525236353,
-0.0072406782,
0.0071839136,
0.0253854673,
-0.0134303588,
0.0624570325,
0.0194681194,
-0.0191984586,
-0.0422507524,
-0.0648026392,
-0.0655459911,
-0.0316546336,
-0.0065532252,
0.0006560649,
0.0398199558,
0.0205780473,
-0.0250686295,
-0.0050821532,
0.0442045294,
0.0544815175,
-0.0167435165,
-0.0174998157,
0.0337448046,
0.0300440118,
-0.0084701777,
0.0049688714,
-0.0367893092,
0.0179593358,
-0.0394551456,
0.0081503624,
-0.0135410996,
-0.0118158869,
-0.0369239971,
0.0127845556,
-0.1026934683,
-0.0497955196,
-0.0269758925,
0.0464837737,
0.0273740869,
0.0181124769,
0.0074563799,
-0.0416666046,
0.0305791069,
0.0194900949,
-0.0159187615,
-0.0214153733,
0.0247159582,
0.0356757604,
0.0142729115,
0.0323310867,
-0.0176489521,
-0.0152029675,
0.0054588718,
0.0514806658,
-0.04152935,
-0.00830964,
0.0263644587,
0.025134664,
-0.01263096,
-0.0023443573,
-0.0130378138,
-0.0526856259,
0.0446285829,
-0.0311762039,
-0.0216294602,
-0.0180017818,
0.0163266901,
0.0088022994,
-0.0314523317,
0.044942569,
-0.0393897034,
0.0307650976,
0.0152851567,
0.0454617739,
0.0238048248,
0.0268024113,
0.0368320644,
0.0395768359,
-0.0349624194,
-0.0122505911,
0.0169952791,
0.0079403082,
0.0383923203,
-0.0262099802,
0.1206977889,
0.0310529731,
0.0074216598,
-0.0569862574,
-0.0185245369,
-0.0516964309,
-0.1185809597,
0.0207407903,
0.0244647674,
0.0286705997,
0.0150680365,
-0.0154190324,
-0.0628070161,
-0.0111632291,
0.0001224737,
0.012837939,
0.0230968539,
-0.0294261798,
0.0409958847,
0.0359460041,
0.0090605952,
-0.036394611,
0.0457633883,
0.0054269074,
0.0397712179,
-0.0148518328,
0.018454615,
-0.0553302877,
-0.063512817,
-0.0467695706,
0.0426708572,
-0.0029075276,
0.0294783227,
-0.0675642863,
-0.0709321052,
-0.0705568492,
0.002614249,
-0.0281551108,
-0.0151959006,
0.0467852503,
0.0422632955,
-0.022612581,
-0.0325768963,
0.0054721422,
0.0142885856,
-0.0082432041,
-0.0233487226,
-0.0399045572,
-6.591505226e-33,
-0.0134211369,
-0.0501037501,
0.0712783858,
0.0155368205,
-0.0008310935,
-0.0475835539,
-0.0416192859,
0.033489041,
-0.0250320118,
0.0260001235,
-0.0229613669,
-0.0041274801,
0.0063085579,
0.0268336311,
0.0111429254,
-0.005667944,
0.0186170824,
-0.0200078115,
-0.0345705301,
0.0115531329,
0.0446884707,
-0.0041349255,
0.0029784499,
-0.0497235581,
0.00746276,
0.0226275846,
-0.0058549824,
0.0664274022,
-0.0573639721,
0.0525551066,
-0.0038332439,
0.0102473255,
0.0202616137,
-0.0366393328,
-0.0243037287,
0.0192819089,
-0.0521510504,
-0.0765273422,
0.0363931321,
-0.0122164125,
-0.031878639,
-0.0574613847,
0.0020533197,
0.0267002154,
-0.0273619723,
-0.0545382053,
-0.0095598549,
-0.0438836366,
-0.0049427636,
0.0420684889,
-0.0482197888,
0.0131191481,
-0.0277302582,
-0.0217728764,
0.0326523595,
0.0269588679,
-0.0442473553,
-0.0273054298,
-0.0029088631,
0.0284033492,
0.0392613746,
0.0326884091,
0.0875561833,
0.0391293541,
0.0000201895,
0.0164431222,
-0.0021209738,
-0.0185138695,
-0.0361538902,
-0.0174184516,
0.0146366637,
0.0443321131,
0.0519348867,
0.0139278946,
0.0194842312,
0.018125575,
-0.0690077469,
-0.0123249451,
0.0277616512,
0.061887037,
0.0215266068,
-0.0174285006,
-0.0295852367,
-0.0212262627,
-0.0885686725,
0.0001471125,
-0.0505971499,
-0.0130908461,
0.0267230812,
0.0030454136,
0.002622705,
-0.0469743051,
0.0391355231,
-0.0157851931,
-0.0126034254,
0.0397485904,
0.0090300729,
0.0172123928,
0.0043552243,
0.0238913391,
-0.0760924369,
-0.0218352284,
-0.0206205864,
-0.0090615992,
0.01097285,
0.0160884578,
-0.0019780735,
0.0015537327,
-0.0589486994,
-0.0110772857,
-0.0723157898,
0.0200092606,
0.0120626315,
0.0244679041,
0.027336603,
0.0017747907,
-0.0022773675,
0.0637498721,
-0.0124012455,
-0.0287853684,
-0.0058671562,
0.0088136811,
-0.0205120146,
0.0249341466,
-0.0273679923,
-0.0000369009,
-0.0520321503,
0.0042050858,
0.0117764873,
-0.0518837869,
-0.0070660841,
0.0257782694,
2.969e-7,
0.0175438374,
0.0667720884,
0.019540146,
0.0594213456,
0.0268102735,
0.0521232374,
-0.0236536264,
-0.0539949946,
0.0062448485,
-0.0636888593,
0.0179607458,
0.0564445928,
0.0385399014,
0.0105139846,
-0.0583445244,
0.0036387008,
-0.0203176439,
-0.0223125126,
-0.0555645823,
-0.0012155997,
0.0732328966,
0.0828675404,
0.0076536573,
-0.0176253784,
0.0070152814,
-0.0016409305,
0.034756083,
-0.013828448,
0.0032118061,
-0.0003201291,
0.0132203866,
-0.0143359499,
0.0149301412,
0.0317534879,
0.0106913149,
0.0264147855,
-0.0542083867,
0.0921988189,
0.0229186825,
-0.0473558716,
-0.0249339379,
-0.0324274898,
0.0043343059,
-0.0582751371,
0.0754208863,
-0.0438493304,
-0.0194989406,
0.0117667401,
0.0432964973,
-0.0273247175,
-0.0029704724,
-0.0255749132,
-0.0054567326,
0.0076015675,
-0.0116486438,
-0.0164199546,
0.0301172696,
-0.0497929342,
-0.0250322782,
-0.0097286077,
-0.0392576344,
-0.0608980097,
-0.0591111258,
0.0111621832,
0.0461123213,
-0.0196643751,
-0.0218426697,
3.063597025e-34,
0.0363493748,
-0.0468196347,
0.0267900825,
0.0187090319,
0.0259054042,
-0.0016510859,
-0.0051417174,
0.0190555789,
0.0458863564,
-0.1084163636,
-0.0187831186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05073v1 | Enhancing Argument Structure Extraction with Efficient Leverage of Contextual Information | 2023-10-08T08:47:10 | 2023-10-08T08:47:10 | Yun Luo, Zhen Yang, Fandong Meng, Yingjie Li, Jie Zhou, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Argument structure extraction (ASE) aims to identify the discourse structure
of arguments within documents. Previous research has demonstrated that
contextual information is crucial for developing an effective ASE model.
However, we observe that merely concatenating sentences in a contextual window
does not fully utilize contextual information and can sometimes lead to
excessive attention on less informative sentences. To tackle this challenge, we
propose an Efficient Context-aware ASE model (ECASE) that fully exploits
contextual information by enhancing modeling capacity and augmenting training
data. Specifically, we introduce a sequence-attention module and
distance-weighted similarity loss to aggregate contextual information and
argumentative information. Additionally, we augment the training data by
randomly masking discourse markers and sentences, which reduces the model's
reliance on specific words or less informative sentences. Our experiments on
five datasets from various domains demonstrate that our model achieves
state-of-the-art performance. Furthermore, ablation studies confirm the
effectiveness of each module in our model. | [
-0.001442563,
0.0308455881,
0.0170089845,
0.0763886571,
-0.0243522506,
0.0152886193,
-0.0021200541,
-0.0242371894,
-0.0252821501,
-0.0566107556,
0.0068472642,
-0.0236082692,
0.0027411091,
-0.0000849529,
-0.0082837567,
-0.0792557299,
0.0102420617,
0.0036880679,
0.0754556209,
0.0181615837,
0.0289990623,
-0.0157469735,
0.0043200101,
0.0161435064,
-0.0096003627,
-0.0645066276,
-0.0084109791,
0.0021056428,
0.0576470941,
-0.0462168567,
0.0529517531,
0.0298347473,
-0.0025778788,
0.0271610711,
0.000001905,
-0.0411512256,
-0.0385941528,
-0.013768848,
-0.0702318996,
0.0359090008,
0.0576974526,
0.0344485193,
0.0058998317,
0.004182192,
-0.0021532224,
0.0252139214,
0.0322829336,
0.1026413664,
0.0396891981,
0.0746726394,
-0.0113304034,
-0.0418623723,
0.0179810263,
-0.0263194814,
-0.0556869358,
-0.0311732236,
0.0272923838,
0.0234433189,
-0.012221978,
0.0610800274,
-0.0031883644,
0.0292198639,
0.0374482609,
0.0113658989,
-0.0091333091,
0.0371779688,
-0.0049326215,
-0.0200282671,
-0.0036361422,
0.059099447,
-0.0150166191,
-0.0314862356,
0.0191989597,
-0.0236076098,
-0.0017329078,
-0.0419721156,
-0.0413576476,
0.0577975325,
-0.0201522652,
0.0361764804,
0.0855415612,
0.0633890629,
-0.0004638696,
-0.0123870503,
0.0301203374,
-0.0008302171,
-0.0324149914,
-0.0247895028,
-0.0104921125,
-0.0133981854,
-0.029505454,
-0.0518318303,
0.019972017,
0.0111224223,
0.0218467899,
0.0298458543,
-0.0449297987,
-0.0348795578,
0.0431153364,
-0.1168280244,
0.000860262,
-0.0140680838,
-0.0200360622,
0.0967631489,
-0.0036263545,
0.0008706798,
-0.014551797,
-0.0508891456,
0.0055410261,
-0.0372705013,
-0.0269815531,
0.0097291414,
-0.0188772567,
0.0424972698,
-0.0711066946,
-0.0479365997,
0.0179131553,
-0.0124405827,
-0.02945772,
-0.0139787812,
0.0066363658,
0.0127001703,
-0.0167527124,
-0.0202310719,
0.0120358812,
-0.010476782,
-0.0423265807,
0.0243372917,
0.0280595217,
0.0107512409,
-0.0464795195,
0.0558146462,
0.0285718162,
-0.0179497711,
-0.0205482133,
0.0189923048,
-0.0255387537,
-0.0224701483,
-0.0291881356,
-0.0459437445,
-0.0330579206,
-0.0213731509,
0.0066385744,
-0.0409762971,
0.0116370637,
-0.0248647258,
-0.0268537719,
-0.0386464261,
0.0090852845,
0.0071800081,
-0.0198836029,
0.0285176989,
0.0498714373,
-0.0646198392,
0.0332715176,
0.0286418591,
-0.013573911,
0.0713096634,
0.0161505863,
0.0233786516,
0.0373256803,
0.028033115,
-0.0333157331,
-0.0285297669,
0.0352729969,
0.008570103,
0.0740815476,
0.0070124571,
-0.0368056931,
-0.0184615813,
0.0210424028,
0.0148395272,
-0.0338786393,
-0.0720078871,
0.0180208813,
0.0109879095,
0.0108486246,
0.0013181603,
0.0161807816,
0.0219537765,
0.0020393333,
0.0121126985,
-0.0062237033,
-0.002937655,
-0.0091462294,
0.0266803708,
0.0445463583,
0.0089338813,
-0.001023688,
-0.0450176783,
-0.0119728222,
-0.036969278,
0.0339617357,
0.0018333531,
0.0154022677,
0.0106645571,
-0.0447947979,
0.0199824404,
0.042282939,
-0.0346023813,
-0.0639773607,
0.0241579954,
0.0171092544,
-0.0394305736,
-0.0009306893,
-0.0340415314,
-0.0289316662,
-0.0173009019,
0.0918140337,
0.047814697,
0.0423546359,
-0.0169210862,
0.0500723235,
-0.0210344139,
-0.0461281687,
-0.0497894548,
0.0181255527,
0.0030407922,
0.0324293748,
-0.0237129461,
0.0474663265,
0.0179246273,
-0.023197867,
0.0088563319,
-0.0061743958,
-0.0506409332,
-0.0014264688,
-0.0034093675,
0.0758983865,
0.0474531911,
-0.0007902221,
-0.0047360598,
0.0563947409,
-0.0461861975,
0.0056818845,
0.0022250034,
-0.0846975446,
-0.0476266742,
0.0299803447,
-0.0391946323,
-0.0068246438,
-0.0305360239,
-0.0345454291,
-0.0238779634,
0.0411200374,
-0.0420915373,
0.0344610065,
-0.0083668316,
0.0092317052,
0.0330847465,
0.0130399959,
-0.0294560753,
0.093517229,
0.0249024518,
-0.016634861,
0.0173448976,
0.0192355271,
0.0262114331,
-0.0520730354,
0.0192174315,
-0.0345482193,
0.0067252778,
-0.0117185665,
0.0534936935,
-0.0507385656,
-0.0418822765,
0.0054909009,
-0.100009203,
0.0125176143,
-0.0067834686,
0.0691304058,
0.0203323048,
-0.0078934729,
0.0121467169,
-0.0157353505,
-0.023322681,
-0.0737874955,
-0.0642748326,
-0.0141179143,
0.0443664864,
-0.0079034436,
0.0211016294,
-0.0689425021,
-0.0078170206,
-0.011076754,
0.0509951487,
0.0002787476,
-0.021694662,
-0.0113190869,
0.0152103063,
0.0158725306,
0.0393887386,
-0.03418402,
0.001463855,
0.0148398345,
0.01316036,
0.0319465026,
0.1130830199,
0.0251355041,
0.035755448,
-0.0037190109,
-0.0106548863,
-0.050500989,
0.0086739631,
-0.0297464263,
0.088507466,
-0.0110279545,
0.0056257015,
0.0432431698,
0.1223588511,
-0.0262505524,
0.045852799,
-0.0112110525,
0.0384407677,
0.0286735613,
0.0065008407,
0.0182610024,
-0.0188415591,
-0.0190316457,
0.0211343952,
-0.0694104806,
0.023581136,
0.0650841892,
-0.0460185818,
0.0047920761,
-0.0509707071,
-0.018708799,
-0.0242018513,
0.0274596885,
0.0152919358,
0.0108388141,
0.0585245192,
-0.0194365364,
0.0042513455,
-0.0311610084,
0.0504068919,
-0.0257871505,
0.0237048659,
-0.0198263153,
0.0051881541,
-0.0192811247,
-0.0300886314,
-0.0431321338,
-0.0115256282,
0.0009341435,
0.0039619505,
-0.0072418507,
-0.0043654768,
-0.0227716845,
-0.0103827929,
0.0320446678,
0.0445640907,
0.0152430451,
0.016112648,
-0.0057784729,
0.0635488033,
0.0053150225,
0.0090410449,
0.0321001001,
-0.0126680629,
0.033988025,
0.0919538587,
-0.0297574941,
-0.008783129,
-0.0466458015,
-0.0513287447,
-0.0349578001,
-0.0559405312,
-0.0240467004,
-0.03894848,
0.0500463247,
-0.0943219066,
0.0275163949,
0.0835066438,
0.0198108666,
0.0218334813,
-0.0136229768,
-0.0133760348,
0.0188041329,
-0.0056601316,
0.0006444642,
-0.0531172268,
-0.037970379,
-0.0059221331,
0.0116798664,
-0.03301768,
-0.0139149642,
0.0067002377,
-0.0581937358,
0.0032965583,
0.0010118089,
0.0108702453,
-0.0221976135,
-0.0541388541,
0.0276542976,
-0.0121600097,
-0.0086590005,
0.020640187,
-0.0048592309,
-0.0106723178,
0.0168623589,
-0.0287488606,
-0.0045847506,
0.0123004504,
-0.0153720006,
0.0293884352,
-0.0014349174,
0.0352329761,
0.0279102791,
-0.0122652436,
0.0302429236,
-0.0589477234,
-0.024849711,
-0.0101164682,
0.028632829,
-0.0175715033,
0.019444678,
0.0050881021,
0.0481131263,
-0.0119733792,
-0.0505684316,
0.0309995506,
0.0326242931,
-0.0045294254,
0.0002998397,
-0.0172444377,
-0.0013773193,
-0.0133491494,
0.0598254763,
0.0462777838,
0.0303830933,
-0.0473893099,
-0.0323879048,
0.0027468761,
-0.0508640073,
0.0237666275,
-0.0187688284,
-0.0065843835,
0.0315301269,
-0.0861873999,
-0.0844097435,
-0.0432279035,
-0.0005834085,
-0.0286122132,
0.0032553566,
0.0240142662,
-0.0129109249,
-0.0451822802,
0.0077109979,
-0.013510135,
-0.0301252417,
0.0028037727,
0.0269600097,
-0.0057380544,
-0.0137006342,
-0.041780673,
0.0287150033,
-0.0381801315,
-0.0539727435,
-0.0180080347,
0.0085153198,
0.0029010007,
0.0898690447,
-0.0106624784,
-0.0084094089,
0.0204815622,
-0.0249499194,
0.0237093084,
-0.0014622146,
0.0817274004,
-0.000370216,
0.0190930329,
0.0099683311,
0.0059413221,
0.0643990561,
-0.0055559007,
0.0178174246,
-0.0922934562,
0.0208578911,
-0.0175733306,
-0.0171889979,
0.044128675,
0.0429565422,
-0.0514203049,
-0.0113747492,
0.0511432961,
-0.0485499389,
-0.0140643129,
-0.0173398741,
0.0334310755,
-0.0573346913,
-0.0250876974,
0.0056853378,
0.0031769748,
-0.002436467,
0.0283849463,
-0.0278798863,
0.0750793591,
-0.0017263404,
-0.0051380652,
-0.0139252106,
-0.0041917725,
-0.036967244,
0.0353496261,
0.0054354714,
0.0552932918,
-0.0107392706,
0.0487572066,
0.0096471729,
-0.0196117889,
0.0300938264,
-0.0059848339,
-0.0729718059,
0.0467362441,
-0.0299061053,
-0.0191838145,
0.001803801,
-0.0620969832,
0.0741363466,
-0.0118917543,
-0.00024096,
-0.0234479159,
0.0449933559,
-0.004578996,
-0.0018027198,
0.0121832928,
0.0381311774,
-0.011311898,
0.0542741492,
0.0658272654,
-0.0069457861,
0.0108510396,
0.0133580603,
-0.0155351087,
-0.0644797608,
-0.0442005098,
-0.0035084581,
0.0466524139,
-0.0116182817,
-0.0134553537,
0.0200935323,
0.0052106678,
0.0039839791,
-0.0021362305,
0.0122647882,
-0.0102529069,
0.0321494378,
0.0240304526,
-0.013399058,
-0.03211179,
-0.035452269,
0.026043443,
0.0150805842,
-0.0157584716,
-0.0231867898,
-6.305129089e-33,
-0.0264525395,
-0.0151570709,
-0.016019484,
0.0647703335,
-0.0038589926,
0.0548537858,
-0.0764508769,
-0.0083335144,
-0.0186297093,
0.0361204185,
0.0402772985,
0.010434757,
0.015930621,
0.0368769206,
-0.0324660204,
-0.007253536,
0.0512696877,
0.0146057913,
0.0057211574,
0.0319378339,
0.029586317,
-0.003794048,
0.0058000507,
-0.0987812132,
0.0430218354,
0.0069840108,
0.0185133442,
-0.0127409967,
0.0392186046,
0.1013666764,
-0.0067084371,
0.0104015786,
0.0194323342,
-0.0457029603,
-0.0097503411,
0.0453215875,
-0.1029225066,
-0.0183752403,
-0.0091141369,
-0.0558926016,
-0.0330843069,
-0.0525724553,
0.0437332503,
0.0321463458,
0.0544625372,
-0.0567061454,
0.0355563909,
-0.0297240242,
-0.0249088127,
-0.0503577888,
-0.0707339346,
0.0687982813,
-0.0178022794,
0.0145788323,
0.017322652,
0.0248630699,
0.0269337054,
0.0928733423,
-0.05732207,
-0.0393813998,
-0.0057575442,
0.0290875454,
-0.0094577875,
-0.0169978868,
-0.0198453031,
0.0385572948,
-0.0232400429,
-0.0171213206,
-0.0301649664,
0.0220967196,
-0.0173369534,
0.0408008695,
0.0496850908,
0.0269157104,
0.0250634905,
0.0452854633,
-0.0793721452,
-0.0408044457,
0.0075282534,
0.0591905303,
0.0094009144,
0.0162620731,
-0.0239873994,
0.0062308977,
-0.0160883795,
-0.0594603866,
0.0004899474,
-0.0059090219,
-0.0214971788,
0.0363071002,
-0.0153181916,
0.0391724333,
0.0203192569,
-0.0187344961,
0.0133247701,
0.0102353878,
0.0216600671,
0.007490776,
0.0229698643,
0.0066823894,
-0.0636366084,
0.0211507566,
0.0074141882,
0.0035138403,
0.0173542444,
-0.029294895,
0.0442587174,
-0.0651342347,
-0.0465659946,
-0.0155971916,
-0.021265693,
0.0132133421,
-0.0532439053,
0.0646946132,
0.0336820073,
0.0276955497,
0.0094727725,
0.065544948,
0.0105230669,
-0.0100628706,
-0.0339639857,
-0.0634830222,
-0.0263554696,
0.0218483023,
-0.0262356233,
-0.0193620119,
0.032078743,
0.0361484773,
0.0392687768,
-0.043687433,
0.0073013892,
0.0066757831,
2.451e-7,
0.0423552282,
0.0478383042,
0.0487441421,
-0.0387877673,
0.0268172119,
0.0453555994,
0.0341950618,
0.0419930629,
0.0011500891,
-0.0457440279,
-0.0386440046,
0.0131592471,
0.0540415011,
0.0173871126,
-0.0861928016,
-0.0795107558,
-0.0723173171,
-0.048136428,
-0.0160542913,
-0.001256671,
0.0515493341,
0.0842119977,
0.0051276558,
0.0207800828,
-0.0171532761,
0.0077728815,
0.0431804657,
-0.0108760307,
-0.0123533616,
-0.0140072489,
0.0181920007,
-0.0604250766,
-0.0092818812,
0.0080832522,
-0.0368836187,
0.0270981155,
-0.0370728113,
0.0775342137,
0.0043600239,
-0.0436668433,
-0.0060227434,
-0.0175001882,
0.0240217764,
-0.0486221798,
0.0450181961,
-0.0609247684,
-0.0130250491,
-0.0404486246,
-0.0859685093,
0.0471577719,
-0.0194276087,
0.0359497741,
-0.0105098095,
0.0021173251,
-0.0232809503,
-0.0443588495,
0.0002227408,
-0.0839425921,
-0.0419432744,
0.0182950646,
-0.0129290717,
-0.0043538339,
-0.0080567542,
-0.0347791612,
0.0101968823,
-0.0250890907,
-0.0083801737,
1.989394242e-34,
0.0423260517,
-0.0289338902,
-0.0078677321,
0.0252084155,
0.03471018,
-0.0028938255,
-0.0238725226,
-0.0201013442,
0.0200562812,
-0.0411099382,
0.0069955066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05069v2 | Unleashing the Multilingual Encoder Potential: Boosting Zero-Shot Performance via Probability Calibration | 2023-10-08T08:31:05 | 2023-10-19T15:58:05 | Ercong Nie, Helmut Schmid, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained multilingual encoder models can directly perform zero-shot
multilingual tasks or linguistic probing by reformulating the input examples
into cloze-style prompts. This is accomplished by predicting the probabilities
of the label words at the masked token position, without requiring any updates
to the model parameters. However, the performance of this method is limited by
the model's bias toward predicting label words which frequently occurred during
the pretraining. These words typically receive high probabilities. To address
this issue, we combine the models with calibration techniques which modify the
probabilities of label words predicted by the models. We first validate the
effectiveness of a proposed simple calibration method together with other
existing techniques on monolingual encoders in both zero- and few-shot
scenarios. We subsequently employ these calibration techniques on multilingual
encoders, resulting in substantial performance improvements across a wide range
of tasks. | [
-0.0129129468,
0.0270201303,
0.0158089288,
0.0548105538,
-0.0124869617,
0.0137997391,
0.0546287373,
-0.0002128522,
-0.0492192134,
-0.0343941115,
-0.0505429991,
-0.0612296462,
0.0120891724,
0.052408509,
0.0275098737,
-0.036388915,
0.0298509654,
-0.0247535873,
0.014901448,
-0.0152037693,
0.0115501769,
-0.000415706,
-0.0272693541,
0.0411566012,
-0.0204916839,
0.0023711403,
-0.0123394504,
0.0271561258,
0.0020608413,
-0.0439571068,
-0.0095350035,
0.0514281951,
0.0185413621,
0.0284460615,
0.0000021271,
-0.050324522,
-0.0043022553,
-0.0226309448,
-0.0376903787,
-0.0518154837,
0.008927023,
-0.0605193488,
-0.004314553,
0.0221691951,
0.0142267942,
-0.0100475438,
0.094574213,
-0.0263471194,
-0.0257202331,
0.0566895939,
-0.0216245875,
-0.023937704,
-0.0071064727,
-0.0103499079,
0.0218801517,
-0.0409356542,
-0.0076717017,
-0.0424003899,
-0.0435431153,
0.0021565859,
-0.0566291735,
0.0234761164,
0.051334694,
0.0011139117,
0.0098851183,
0.0321327448,
0.0041383593,
-0.0794680938,
-0.0415468067,
0.0499705113,
-0.0870301351,
-0.0066613979,
-0.0642735884,
-0.0494626276,
-0.0262004882,
-0.032802932,
-0.0215502102,
0.0328450017,
0.0245895125,
0.0091849314,
-0.0196330231,
0.0396568626,
0.0188700333,
-0.0252975076,
-0.0183704775,
0.0699624494,
0.0418634899,
-0.0219198577,
0.0220540855,
0.0298635606,
0.0311248545,
-0.0415366665,
0.0158934835,
0.0213046577,
-0.0211867243,
0.0257884134,
-0.0602040589,
-0.0380514711,
0.009683731,
-0.009667608,
0.0236155223,
0.0685986578,
-0.0463611521,
0.0379731804,
-0.0289151892,
0.0455453694,
0.0363928117,
0.0365853645,
-0.0455273055,
-0.0585076362,
-0.0051974533,
0.0006623772,
-0.0427438654,
-0.0080576958,
-0.0188969839,
-0.0206983406,
-0.0413718857,
-0.0089960359,
0.0312306322,
-0.0020479434,
-0.0117006321,
-0.0025649727,
-0.0577218048,
-0.0253366232,
-0.0029337471,
0.0906860009,
-0.0423662476,
-0.0159482434,
0.0002358081,
-0.0675805509,
-0.0458110198,
0.0256296135,
0.018503461,
-0.0577252284,
0.0178943463,
0.0452852175,
-0.0390117764,
-0.0568067916,
0.0226224381,
-0.026636593,
-0.0300509185,
-0.0222523306,
0.0158269946,
-0.0470717102,
0.044903934,
0.0206737593,
0.0370828062,
-0.031837929,
0.0087790415,
-0.006396878,
-0.0016916997,
0.1086400822,
0.0163764935,
-0.0418721177,
0.0018495697,
-0.0013331331,
-0.0004030657,
0.1100996137,
0.0235696267,
0.0205564424,
0.0505869947,
-0.0045914506,
0.0416442007,
0.0954627469,
-0.0016841415,
-0.0087393448,
-0.0140372198,
-0.0409596674,
0.0767963529,
0.0032770757,
0.0791272596,
-0.0142933698,
-0.0373009257,
0.007283235,
0.0309128389,
0.0465591736,
-0.0080580367,
-0.0683418438,
0.0485279374,
-0.0399556644,
-0.0351909436,
-0.0036677686,
0.0132724196,
0.0207475461,
-0.0140544772,
0.0067526526,
0.0244899299,
0.0356398523,
-0.0422968194,
-0.01597034,
-0.0040890677,
-0.0262561068,
0.0054868292,
-0.000547927,
0.072909832,
0.0061464198,
-0.0584249906,
0.0558430292,
0.0285971966,
-0.0506156534,
0.0392447226,
-0.0172693375,
-0.0162544064,
0.0579884686,
0.0402926058,
0.0001876704,
-0.0148816099,
0.0011558825,
-0.0133884391,
0.0777515322,
0.0150470715,
-0.0049359263,
0.0786811709,
-0.0840308517,
-0.0575776286,
-0.0346278325,
-0.0019001437,
0.0770037696,
-0.0109674511,
0.053221073,
0.0082494421,
0.0005383741,
0.023902433,
0.0218429491,
-0.0005495173,
-0.0163867529,
0.0418061838,
0.014238134,
0.0001141041,
0.0144315297,
-0.0085046049,
-0.0047519696,
0.0292734839,
-0.0584562868,
0.0137158334,
-0.0023502817,
-0.0352312028,
-0.0575799681,
0.0383565463,
0.0015753548,
0.0127591426,
-0.0309357382,
-0.021676233,
-0.0564362109,
-0.0261683464,
0.0130801927,
0.0193373952,
-0.0248712655,
0.0085928738,
-0.0170098878,
0.0426054299,
-0.0086878017,
0.0145773133,
0.0111814942,
0.0242658649,
0.0024029866,
0.005432263,
0.0349002406,
-0.0628455132,
-0.0393121578,
0.0253956597,
0.0056593614,
-0.0209558066,
0.049793344,
0.0179261323,
-0.0154225053,
-0.0117265806,
-0.0712982938,
-0.0094441064,
-0.0466339551,
0.0093298489,
0.0107514821,
0.0236938465,
-0.0074004158,
-0.0428622812,
-0.0330403149,
0.0078593111,
-0.0019422267,
0.0392329581,
0.0150899934,
-0.0258547999,
0.0107371351,
-0.0044218027,
-0.014295903,
0.0105706584,
0.0464343019,
-0.0045763608,
-0.0321650803,
-0.033632651,
0.0110743418,
-0.0172318388,
-0.0243722666,
0.0151589522,
-0.0257666726,
0.0209871586,
0.0124588888,
-0.0022837545,
0.0353808142,
-0.0465027131,
0.0357245058,
0.0307387859,
-0.011758334,
-0.0363862291,
-0.0028313119,
-0.0079535339,
-0.05036382,
-0.011267947,
-0.0022657937,
-0.0375432707,
0.0473432913,
-0.0014136716,
0.0165034086,
-0.0821478367,
-0.0071238992,
-0.0253971759,
-0.0665126517,
-0.0690569729,
-0.0005996902,
0.0002337674,
0.0406043306,
-0.0175202992,
-0.0169264544,
0.0620028898,
-0.0531039424,
-0.0322295427,
-0.0320338793,
0.0233044494,
-0.0017679242,
0.0378189534,
0.0183061529,
0.0341526046,
0.0225112196,
-0.0285580959,
-0.0320371576,
-0.0009012705,
-0.0105564473,
-0.0148875471,
-0.0127935382,
-0.0135713583,
-0.005322577,
-0.0221534278,
-0.0429787301,
-0.0231904443,
-0.0163963493,
-0.016494818,
0.0200762972,
-0.0228265636,
0.0079958905,
-0.0421593003,
0.033964958,
0.0111592691,
0.0517438538,
-0.0191035271,
0.0071713408,
-0.0343545452,
0.0325249694,
0.0579942837,
-0.0098373601,
-0.0288023166,
-0.047440052,
0.0113443593,
0.0107209431,
-0.002740287,
0.007653723,
0.0074804015,
0.0164446179,
0.0250232369,
0.0186636373,
-0.0022612519,
0.016777942,
0.0555973575,
-0.0418517105,
-0.0175077356,
0.1199923009,
0.0258582421,
-0.0637128204,
-0.0264062937,
-0.0290355515,
0.0249979682,
0.0242338534,
0.011755595,
-0.1149357408,
-0.0683761984,
-0.004227099,
-0.0059013809,
-0.0169614293,
0.0073509868,
-0.0090640569,
-0.1589327455,
-0.0028090789,
0.0136940312,
-0.0418065339,
-0.0401733331,
-0.0426012613,
-0.0222146697,
-0.0138194449,
0.0435289368,
-0.006393556,
0.0603460968,
0.0013983526,
0.0151310507,
0.0089824526,
-0.0794315636,
0.0102622099,
-0.0233075768,
0.034498062,
0.0723950863,
-0.0049162121,
-0.0351911746,
-0.0066572786,
0.0209214222,
-0.0256454404,
-0.0092481626,
0.0040809372,
0.0356044099,
-0.0029624659,
-0.0120545886,
0.0568697266,
0.0088600786,
-0.0336059183,
-0.0209729951,
-0.0085038906,
0.0339510478,
-0.0021623261,
0.003254469,
-0.0138228396,
-0.0269828737,
0.0271509755,
0.0655312538,
0.0336529016,
-0.0362573937,
-0.0008652498,
-0.0469965562,
0.0002956651,
-0.0482982397,
0.0317055695,
-0.0051125959,
-0.0208359007,
-0.0706983209,
-0.0432528257,
-0.0676472709,
0.0535133332,
0.0546149798,
0.0076413923,
-0.0085310498,
-0.0264909528,
0.0179067757,
-0.0153306471,
0.0080817277,
-0.0298962854,
0.0248675458,
-0.0688896179,
0.0044875578,
0.0137691377,
-0.0053215143,
-0.0079060057,
0.0379741937,
-0.057343673,
-0.0648874789,
-0.0424367115,
0.06443692,
0.0179751609,
0.0394694991,
-0.0524461567,
-0.0609644093,
0.0826409012,
0.0249750577,
-0.0027968034,
0.0182032771,
0.0291743875,
-0.0085063046,
-0.0371887684,
0.0139578516,
-0.0351697765,
0.0145983249,
-0.0051924209,
0.0342488959,
-0.0490028001,
-0.0767942443,
-0.0084799584,
-0.0184744559,
0.0922312587,
-0.0503343232,
-0.0024427192,
-0.0238926206,
0.0353676826,
-0.036622107,
-0.0068328995,
-0.0232883245,
-0.0263849609,
0.0506811962,
-0.0444147475,
-0.0018383266,
0.0147834988,
-0.0392561071,
-0.0059785983,
-0.0028352423,
-0.0314720757,
0.0603557415,
0.0063691591,
0.0204878263,
0.0046463888,
0.0014731747,
0.0519332774,
0.0316961259,
0.0398802906,
-0.0229981989,
0.0425272174,
-0.0113128889,
0.0061008488,
-0.0121883405,
0.0060313563,
-0.0206572674,
0.0124167744,
-0.041049283,
0.0254249796,
0.0517497323,
0.0045475662,
0.049145136,
0.0174369514,
-0.0279647019,
-0.0130469184,
0.0105881458,
0.0094816433,
-0.0386236981,
0.0502148829,
-0.0107641108,
-0.0077820616,
-0.0169374142,
0.078928262,
-0.0072641894,
0.0471632108,
-0.0216717329,
0.0177640989,
-0.0006392674,
0.0122825019,
0.0199416522,
0.0191578753,
-0.0121169435,
0.0189749114,
-0.0212479718,
-0.0435528532,
0.0336759761,
0.012930139,
0.003509948,
0.0416666269,
0.0421338975,
0.0441631004,
-0.0502796136,
0.0116922148,
-0.0213852972,
0.0077310381,
0.0431712605,
-0.0185351055,
-0.0046279673,
-6.502892789e-33,
-0.0532728247,
-0.0262023769,
0.0064478186,
-0.0076013473,
0.023223687,
-0.0004310923,
-0.0207401644,
0.0124241048,
-0.0147666549,
0.015261814,
-0.0076139034,
-0.0174354594,
0.039016705,
0.0204329323,
0.0248564836,
-0.0298353732,
0.0431840867,
-0.0189649072,
-0.0387606397,
-0.0093918499,
0.0561295189,
0.0421418585,
0.0863899663,
0.008481916,
0.0394135378,
0.0186331123,
-0.0107919276,
0.009288718,
0.0549194366,
0.0538536198,
-0.0172989555,
0.0664555058,
0.0051654796,
-0.0430971496,
-0.011898228,
0.0235335398,
-0.038409844,
-0.0485105477,
-0.0255086087,
0.0697587952,
0.0140397213,
-0.0318653733,
0.0256919973,
-0.0080061546,
-0.0257420093,
0.010066702,
0.0262571648,
-0.0119905332,
-0.0259338338,
-0.0312979594,
-0.055816941,
0.008806183,
0.0016364326,
-0.0284662005,
0.0560877323,
0.0668030381,
0.0273864642,
0.0038587705,
-0.0776069611,
0.003656738,
-0.0094537903,
0.0401012003,
0.0761507526,
0.0631732345,
-0.0119260903,
0.0552087128,
0.0095002428,
-0.0283779893,
0.0128776571,
0.0395748802,
0.0538820401,
-0.0557490736,
0.0470648743,
0.0843395442,
0.0906452015,
0.0107625006,
-0.0670003146,
0.0518735424,
0.0112411845,
-0.0046792524,
0.0148465782,
0.010584617,
-0.0006814194,
-0.0260928161,
-0.0438820347,
-0.0485170558,
-0.0441235043,
-0.0149402739,
0.0224116333,
-0.0003533145,
0.0005197019,
0.0180988517,
0.0811683685,
-0.0028665049,
-0.0201004464,
0.0156943854,
0.001164639,
0.0289909542,
-0.0027942543,
0.0611162372,
-0.040149305,
-0.0194808859,
0.0349490754,
0.0091744075,
0.0118704978,
0.0131982081,
0.0515997708,
0.013445315,
-0.0506408475,
0.0040943637,
-0.0288645718,
-0.0136349369,
0.0238065645,
0.043323718,
0.0195762366,
0.0287354514,
-0.0330297649,
0.0424313582,
0.0258579962,
-0.0325826369,
0.001060877,
-0.0328960046,
0.0234677289,
0.0233735126,
-0.0374654382,
0.0150903519,
-0.0170271695,
-0.0166249052,
0.0238509774,
-0.0469032191,
-0.0122938212,
0.0397656932,
2.817e-7,
0.0878563449,
0.01486916,
0.0063259033,
-0.0171399675,
0.0134426504,
0.038227886,
-0.0341228731,
0.0502893105,
0.0039409953,
-0.0452435575,
-0.0158380587,
0.0033477757,
0.0215823781,
0.0371576101,
-0.0826552287,
-0.0242303889,
-0.0188630056,
0.0461608432,
-0.0507738031,
0.0359557793,
0.0475598425,
0.116120711,
-0.0056218845,
-0.0144626508,
0.020866679,
-0.015653545,
0.0623175986,
0.0183093306,
-0.0136225754,
0.0055719893,
-0.002737036,
0.0314017199,
-0.0028797397,
0.049619928,
-0.0358923748,
0.0036750573,
0.0437262729,
0.0169641897,
-0.0524655804,
-0.0685986727,
-0.0036426578,
0.0316552818,
-0.0356858037,
-0.0380562916,
0.0854435563,
-0.0042986637,
-0.0022965614,
-0.0088020265,
-0.0163858924,
0.0318068489,
0.0824785754,
-0.0543584786,
-0.0526207127,
0.0110300248,
0.0514787659,
0.0234637875,
-0.043885842,
-0.0483910851,
-0.0388921089,
-0.029605411,
-0.014642166,
-0.0248966012,
-0.0247514788,
-0.0586899109,
0.0082644233,
-0.0640476793,
0.0019989144,
2.509800055e-34,
0.0241433531,
-0.0161462836,
0.017928157,
0.0008725578,
-0.0002561154,
-0.0381838083,
-0.0316399336,
0.002325933,
-0.0076164501,
-0.0508650169,
-0.0307010431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.05066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.05066v2 | Guideline Learning for In-context Information Extraction | 2023-10-08T08:25:16 | 2023-10-21T10:21:48 | Chaoxu Pang, Yixuan Cao, Qiang Ding, Ping Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can perform a new task by merely conditioning on
task instructions and a few input-output examples, without optimizing any
parameters. This is called In-Context Learning (ICL). In-context Information
Extraction (IE) has recently garnered attention in the research community.
However, the performance of In-context IE generally lags behind the
state-of-the-art supervised expert models. We highlight a key reason for this
shortfall: underspecified task description. The limited-length context
struggles to thoroughly express the intricate IE task instructions and various
edge cases, leading to misalignment in task comprehension with humans. In this
paper, we propose a Guideline Learning (GL) framework for In-context IE which
reflectively learns and follows guidelines. During the learning phrase, GL
automatically synthesizes a set of guidelines based on a few error cases, and
during inference, GL retrieves helpful guidelines for better ICL. Moreover, we
propose a self-consistency-based active learning method to enhance the
efficiency of GL. Experiments on event extraction and relation extraction show
that GL can significantly improve the performance of in-context IE. | [
0.0630151555,
0.0109453164,
0.0260666329,
0.0414807498,
-0.0477109216,
0.0458498523,
-0.0183132589,
-0.0108525548,
0.009455028,
-0.04465691,
-0.0239289794,
-0.004285716,
-0.0265697464,
0.0143244723,
-0.0108062159,
-0.0269238297,
0.0251995344,
-0.011598791,
0.0394897163,
0.0434028059,
-0.0039442359,
0.0110393101,
-0.0082364585,
0.0041318918,
-0.0231064502,
0.0026169261,
0.0011506435,
0.0070814556,
0.002702076,
-0.0401296839,
0.0430276915,
0.0198156871,
0.0227304529,
-0.0274871644,
0.0000020504,
-0.0561365783,
-0.0408146717,
-0.0324848294,
-0.0461257473,
-0.0184743367,
-0.0127662644,
-0.0387151837,
0.0064267153,
-0.0212593973,
-0.0489033014,
-0.0172073748,
0.0212565958,
0.0905387774,
0.0206316616,
0.0757976845,
-0.0194873046,
-0.0168002974,
0.0065889917,
-0.0241076853,
-0.0099515477,
-0.0808881968,
0.0424656197,
0.0249618012,
-0.020873988,
-0.0029017169,
0.0286687426,
0.0260849185,
0.0256755799,
0.0071197143,
-0.0229816679,
0.0268632155,
-0.0170209855,
-0.0274062641,
-0.0300010908,
0.1191199496,
-0.0202634074,
-0.0007665975,
0.0168428943,
-0.0160881393,
-0.0004548855,
0.0245646648,
-0.0344662778,
0.0181575716,
-0.0592880324,
0.0223251767,
0.0339923874,
0.0215187818,
0.0246794913,
-0.0083744545,
0.0033511634,
0.0648361742,
-0.0275672749,
-0.0493151434,
0.0261888206,
0.0048994953,
-0.0555563644,
-0.0161468089,
0.0173211098,
0.0287685413,
-0.0343458243,
0.0415433049,
-0.0271302667,
0.0143890642,
-0.0039309175,
-0.0767480507,
0.0121125989,
0.0503261015,
-0.0326679423,
0.0986202061,
-0.0182635728,
0.0345808268,
-0.0006311348,
0.0055409726,
-0.0442024432,
-0.0053073158,
-0.0351905078,
0.0352672935,
-0.0414383337,
0.0419965796,
-0.0435042158,
-0.0212078448,
-0.006450322,
0.0460124351,
-0.0073010218,
0.0254262537,
0.0057818438,
0.0014785958,
-0.0477410331,
-0.03530645,
-0.0010348167,
-0.0371947438,
-0.0060525537,
0.0053938781,
-0.0235675406,
-0.0297421273,
-0.0333749019,
-0.0021186362,
0.0243576299,
-0.0108728828,
0.004361392,
0.0623898767,
-0.0013837448,
-0.0439191349,
-0.0173666105,
-0.0306890439,
0.0055626417,
-0.0471378043,
-0.0393422358,
-0.0246823207,
0.033497721,
0.0188378617,
-0.0153309293,
-0.0791462809,
0.0268037058,
0.0077408068,
-0.0302241109,
0.0602704175,
0.0068076947,
-0.004083808,
0.0255886447,
0.0296268705,
-0.0295255706,
0.0690878406,
0.009680124,
0.0077792276,
0.0554059781,
0.0341680571,
-0.0070839864,
0.0228756107,
0.0217364691,
-0.0286764186,
-0.0288729034,
0.0390795916,
0.0316805355,
0.0075371321,
0.044876352,
0.030129645,
-0.0253363363,
-0.0000487438,
0.0524345972,
-0.0004068196,
0.0040467004,
0.0071912808,
0.0562953353,
0.0169777423,
0.0214352142,
0.0377066173,
-0.0761296451,
-0.0190022606,
-0.0035288548,
0.0300351586,
-0.0279601105,
-0.0168389324,
-0.0113009755,
-0.037211176,
0.0048451172,
-0.0528923236,
-0.0169519633,
0.0332035907,
0.0510154963,
-0.0022461808,
-0.0733174682,
0.0284396876,
0.0388465114,
-0.0049677016,
-0.0256007649,
-0.0005923402,
0.023273224,
0.040026743,
0.046496924,
-0.0493268073,
-0.0458110422,
-0.0129737956,
0.0584535375,
-0.0019535967,
0.0138769755,
-0.0540415011,
0.0584166087,
-0.0468862504,
-0.032321129,
0.0060399338,
0.0218893904,
-0.0178405885,
0.0599328019,
-0.0307434853,
0.0321028568,
-0.0081096217,
-0.0547708571,
0.0528443232,
-0.0329230167,
-0.0872500613,
-0.0017023613,
0.0083083678,
0.0083634173,
-0.0059464644,
-0.0163848549,
-0.0232217591,
0.04654577,
-0.0424155332,
0.0144513724,
0.0230503418,
-0.107623741,
-0.0481169596,
0.0186295602,
0.013742731,
-0.0287157521,
-0.0238537677,
-0.0125896055,
-0.0254557133,
-0.0959505737,
0.0174296945,
0.0243027732,
-0.0175640825,
0.0287415273,
0.0262180585,
-0.0262986943,
-0.0574167147,
0.0855529755,
0.0067477957,
-0.031117674,
0.0431135409,
-0.0322109349,
-0.0222712848,
-0.0111818342,
0.0149652464,
-0.0035760268,
0.0219982695,
-0.0337722339,
0.017273711,
0.0237822626,
-0.0677485242,
-0.0214898512,
-0.0835363269,
0.0024781467,
-0.0335974991,
0.0270201135,
0.0368053503,
0.0273420922,
-0.0288664196,
-0.0480644219,
0.000516622,
-0.0486237481,
-0.0324002355,
-0.0204889793,
0.0347699001,
0.0783004537,
-0.0001181633,
-0.0616121814,
0.0122369081,
-0.0203293562,
0.0137829212,
0.0078974431,
-0.0293255839,
-0.0674723908,
0.0499419719,
0.0222524665,
0.0556502528,
-0.0236987714,
0.0377237834,
-0.0300422926,
-0.02130365,
0.0422794074,
0.0693632737,
-0.0071469257,
0.0599963553,
0.0164835863,
-0.0238339324,
-0.0511517003,
0.0297493413,
-0.05326901,
0.0179669354,
-0.0348939486,
0.0193891972,
0.0249294769,
0.0309610497,
0.0076831095,
0.0404003486,
-0.0134022199,
-0.0051417258,
-0.0012149934,
-0.0188580919,
-0.0511243381,
-0.015130097,
-0.0300660562,
0.036330305,
-0.038319584,
-0.0375595763,
0.0849588737,
0.0018751682,
-0.0267152954,
-0.0374248959,
-0.0251823422,
-0.0508078486,
0.0520442873,
-0.0155526726,
0.003909871,
0.0101430975,
-0.0486525595,
-0.0393708386,
-0.0315953605,
0.0377731733,
-0.0022448043,
0.0508261696,
-0.0843747258,
-0.0023055193,
-0.0031036949,
-0.0341462716,
-0.0743360743,
-0.0592319928,
0.0094404258,
0.017362114,
-0.0127445823,
0.0123289293,
0.0113326646,
0.026219897,
-0.0096937576,
0.0698098466,
-0.0110877175,
-0.0251012947,
-0.0234313495,
0.0426006392,
0.0537832677,
-0.0056900107,
-0.0340371989,
-0.001108302,
0.0316900499,
0.048313234,
0.0169572793,
-0.0167262182,
-0.0054836031,
0.0179971345,
0.0143783195,
-0.0614392497,
0.0035492815,
0.0508126132,
0.0503524728,
-0.0856127366,
-0.0111646969,
0.140537113,
0.0250032302,
-0.0540448204,
-0.0054329378,
0.0012086737,
-0.0303922184,
0.0062101725,
0.0160911921,
-0.016901806,
-0.0452793613,
0.0083878841,
0.0252954271,
-0.0095105805,
-0.0277059451,
-0.0200372022,
-0.0616961457,
0.0140893683,
-0.0024304274,
-0.0137593867,
-0.0403098278,
-0.0225416701,
0.0298570748,
-0.017892031,
0.0328835882,
0.0330849625,
-0.0521641895,
0.0014059686,
0.0231110565,
-0.0340040438,
-0.0835065246,
0.0240112655,
-0.0275980942,
0.0481100976,
0.0456817411,
0.0004209581,
0.0247774646,
0.0349484086,
0.0715242103,
-0.0301006138,
0.0193746518,
-0.0411906652,
0.0283006467,
-0.0273297112,
0.0074564205,
-0.0057071815,
0.0396098346,
-0.0580816194,
0.0030308568,
0.0300788507,
0.0484527089,
-0.0180013813,
0.0368912704,
0.0316712409,
-0.0375778638,
0.0568937361,
0.0894286111,
0.0100160176,
-0.0167827718,
-0.0217264071,
0.0184692014,
-0.00643112,
-0.0229186118,
0.019449275,
-0.0213787556,
-0.0359294638,
0.0100733461,
-0.0555722788,
-0.0652243048,
0.062177673,
0.05923976,
0.0193733107,
0.0147701558,
0.008720722,
0.0064569921,
-0.0460646786,
0.0215800125,
-0.0230310354,
-0.0226715375,
-0.0279266983,
-0.0159562174,
-0.0015931424,
-0.0044636289,
-0.0219479576,
0.0719958097,
-0.024026433,
-0.0225169305,
0.003442229,
0.025022177,
0.018408699,
0.0943335444,
-0.0066392422,
0.0176301636,
-0.0113610243,
0.0140003264,
-0.0402629934,
-0.0126547385,
0.0475266427,
0.0021277857,
0.0028169251,
0.028720038,
-0.0235137176,
0.0147498464,
0.0200415794,
0.0291861594,
-0.0805466324,
-0.0713803172,
0.0650377646,
-0.0223282948,
0.0554535948,
-0.0059674084,
-0.0041957116,
-0.0377354026,
0.0133882621,
-0.0293410793,
-0.0036516271,
-0.0286446456,
0.0564364456,
0.0037374657,
0.0019264575,
-0.0046635647,
0.0469824523,
-0.0178863648,
0.0309639275,
-0.0675326511,
-0.002049153,
-0.0081483303,
0.0126843294,
0.0136477472,
-0.0238518491,
-0.0289833006,
0.0422741212,
0.02317065,
0.0440408848,
-0.0322138742,
0.0632859692,
0.0425485782,
-0.0090196431,
-0.0356506519,
0.0207840707,
-0.0404522642,
0.0154530061,
-0.0366531312,
0.0470425561,
0.0586482137,
-0.0396918692,
0.0525474884,
-0.0217657052,
-0.0056556584,
-0.0068368665,
0.0279411934,
-0.0011708965,
0.0135964639,
0.0329856053,
0.0271708556,
-0.0129760932,
0.0369001664,
0.0566038489,
0.017338546,
0.0613304153,
-0.0068067033,
-0.0015648701,
-0.0555537157,
-0.0083914464,
0.0342522413,
0.0496184267,
-0.0427888595,
0.0128027312,
-0.0135849779,
-0.0254573245,
0.004218943,
-0.0204675682,
-0.0355198532,
-0.0408285484,
0.0381518267,
0.0770929083,
0.0065096952,
-0.0496803001,
-0.027562473,
-0.0132689327,
0.0015798252,
-0.0017168693,
-0.0610717312,
-6.366797726e-33,
-0.0335498936,
-0.0469648466,
0.0326607004,
0.0222239401,
-0.0014476723,
0.0346627198,
-0.0518963374,
-0.0091761425,
0.0056278496,
0.0080217477,
-0.006704337,
0.0000687568,
0.0243409835,
-0.0126075903,
0.0008284367,
-0.0267822202,
0.0347542837,
0.0183807723,
-0.0001687127,
0.0180159714,
0.0193838887,
0.0518651828,
0.0219655447,
-0.1265759319,
0.0498318784,
-0.0051691998,
0.005907292,
0.055286143,
0.0703815222,
0.0475205742,
-0.0016129942,
0.0088893231,
0.0321590379,
-0.0455246493,
-0.0063431421,
0.0085400315,
-0.1346272826,
-0.0061090146,
0.0182482358,
-0.0139074698,
-0.0356287099,
-0.0021222525,
0.0400027782,
-0.0202496741,
0.0313739218,
0.0121723488,
0.0260944813,
-0.0324148014,
-0.0298867561,
-0.0296909437,
-0.0887983963,
0.0335339084,
0.0044849897,
-0.0189178362,
0.0426310636,
0.012340609,
0.013796417,
-0.0255020596,
-0.0199339502,
-0.0449096896,
-0.0438527167,
0.0233164392,
0.0306872185,
0.018208744,
-0.0198460538,
0.0271236766,
-0.0269287303,
-0.0164628867,
-0.0163224116,
-0.0349955,
0.0006865832,
0.056481149,
-0.0616088659,
-0.0055795331,
-0.0044370899,
0.0295485109,
-0.0733292922,
0.0382248946,
0.0690412223,
0.0343599208,
0.0005050449,
0.012313691,
-0.1104830652,
0.0060245381,
0.0133729046,
0.0326906145,
0.005422378,
-0.017500136,
0.0429553464,
0.0145067796,
-0.011366915,
0.0422288366,
0.0187980849,
-0.0066039548,
0.0068679554,
0.0136176031,
-0.026365459,
-0.0241501406,
-0.0233054217,
0.0117490897,
-0.0732482523,
-0.0652648881,
-0.0156058446,
0.0135446806,
0.0165314954,
0.0024117683,
0.0338091739,
0.0257348064,
-0.0448258892,
-0.0071181012,
-0.0416249745,
0.0251308586,
-0.0043606893,
0.0520888641,
0.0350651667,
0.0141518684,
-0.0396611802,
0.0494925641,
0.0102888262,
-0.0103054233,
-0.0167367905,
-0.0145476405,
0.0095682228,
0.0101007037,
-0.0102041746,
-0.0124292839,
0.0175948534,
0.0200937521,
0.0031822722,
-0.013764468,
0.0070858318,
0.0251546092,
2.715e-7,
0.037751589,
0.0403546765,
0.0425166376,
0.0392590091,
0.0117291417,
0.032631956,
0.0064431364,
-0.0092128068,
-0.0041676159,
-0.0046249032,
0.0361579731,
0.0314195864,
-0.0042246599,
0.009248171,
-0.0746158212,
-0.0343492143,
-0.033383254,
-0.0107299238,
-0.0442032292,
0.0140972417,
0.0501556844,
0.0504389741,
0.010256405,
-0.0026670645,
-0.031092599,
-0.0774150118,
0.0573403351,
-0.0356347077,
0.002664584,
0.0406209566,
0.0294835549,
0.0389408953,
-0.0274017025,
0.0497760437,
0.0037943847,
0.0458463281,
0.0017266424,
0.10488002,
-0.012953938,
0.0067221299,
-0.0153459916,
-0.0097414916,
0.0213633403,
-0.0377218649,
0.0843259245,
-0.0797143951,
-0.0251835641,
-0.0211750101,
-0.0011830734,
-0.005640409,
-0.0645937324,
0.0453990661,
0.001229848,
0.0250834059,
0.0248907916,
-0.024831485,
-0.044940006,
-0.08568535,
-0.0228709653,
0.0323391259,
-0.0102593368,
-0.0314949453,
-0.0149012767,
0.0142860664,
0.016200617,
-0.0604455881,
0.0054116207,
2.64777072e-34,
0.0030363915,
0.0163261313,
-0.0069358395,
0.0758740753,
-0.0022274994,
-0.0035563277,
-0.0514925718,
0.01224449,
0.0125106471,
-0.0431215428,
-0.0021982677
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.