id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04918v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04918v1 | Low-Resource Named Entity Recognition: Can One-vs-All AUC Maximization Help? | 2023-11-02T10:14:52 | 2023-11-02T10:14:52 | Ngoc Dang Nguyen, Wei Tan, Lan Du, Wray Buntine, Richard Beare, Changyou Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Named entity recognition (NER), a task that identifies and categorizes named
entities such as persons or organizations from text, is traditionally framed as
a multi-class classification problem. However, this approach often overlooks
the issues of imbalanced label distributions, particularly in low-resource
settings, which is common in certain NER contexts, like biomedical NER
(bioNER). To address these issues, we propose an innovative reformulation of
the multi-class problem as a one-vs-all (OVA) learning problem and introduce a
loss function based on the area under the receiver operating characteristic
curve (AUC). To enhance the efficiency of our OVA-based approach, we propose
two training strategies: one groups labels with similar linguistic
characteristics, and another employs meta-learning. The superiority of our
approach is confirmed by its performance, which surpasses traditional NER
learning in varying NER settings. | [
0.0308418609,
0.0370261595,
0.0139680961,
-0.0224763937,
0.0161093194,
0.0476240031,
0.0184947047,
-0.0028197425,
-0.046467036,
-0.0284304824,
-0.021829715,
-0.0044513266,
0.0175464638,
-0.007797718,
-0.0135030951,
-0.0267231632,
0.0396110639,
0.0397471264,
0.0726506338,
-0.0070233257,
-0.0417220853,
-0.0120107718,
-0.0190114249,
0.01458643,
0.0307992622,
0.0152884554,
0.0243710503,
0.0176791009,
0.0755335391,
-0.0630639121,
0.0341574252,
0.0164695419,
-0.0449961461,
0.0425247923,
0.0000019901,
-0.0680478886,
-0.0541296899,
0.0341622792,
-0.0478894897,
-0.0649584979,
0.0334577747,
0.008834729,
0.0220662411,
0.0312940925,
0.0041213771,
-0.0505867898,
0.0518128797,
0.0701460317,
-0.0233894251,
0.0464764386,
-0.0202760119,
-0.0096133333,
0.0029341797,
-0.0151123414,
0.0094036711,
-0.0232022889,
0.0192914195,
-0.0728877038,
-0.0197614469,
-0.0205125026,
-0.0048487508,
0.0470533185,
-0.0033586151,
0.043505609,
0.0342228375,
0.0485297032,
-0.0525130332,
0.0153195085,
-0.0182562899,
0.0568702519,
-0.0511032902,
0.0334132351,
0.0112760356,
0.007676383,
0.0237158313,
0.0023602084,
-0.022276992,
0.0062720114,
-0.0446773171,
-0.0133394273,
-0.0553158149,
0.063612178,
0.0064915791,
-0.0193259902,
-0.0208457112,
-0.0281282943,
-0.012343091,
-0.0167855639,
0.0505179986,
0.0207462981,
-0.037310876,
0.0319974348,
0.0319626592,
0.0167461131,
0.0174149554,
0.0207890421,
-0.0237189308,
-0.0113947745,
0.0386430994,
-0.0330487713,
0.0434226952,
-0.0260013994,
-0.0326895453,
0.0392139405,
-0.0458512828,
-0.0090862392,
0.0038273167,
0.0709029883,
0.0293873884,
0.011566326,
-0.0767946914,
0.0069709788,
-0.0258522518,
0.0543292575,
0.0548563749,
0.0385882296,
-0.0813970119,
-0.0420956314,
-0.0080375969,
-0.0100627737,
0.0129846772,
0.0256029945,
0.0115456646,
0.0223613866,
0.007734471,
0.0375995412,
0.0414727256,
0.0050430591,
-0.0384197906,
-0.0308536068,
0.0047218534,
0.0054010996,
0.0110011986,
-0.0347008556,
0.0478266291,
0.0719547495,
0.042024646,
-0.1210575849,
-0.0324354358,
-0.0041543581,
-0.0417819656,
-0.0315152034,
0.0034077866,
-0.0043309918,
0.0313049257,
0.0060665812,
0.0250259638,
-0.0213572979,
0.0126092387,
-0.023651544,
-0.044499021,
0.0541208312,
-0.0491471738,
-0.0144234914,
0.0747592822,
0.0020651689,
0.0440985151,
0.0085681593,
0.054146722,
-0.0198490769,
-0.0027031598,
0.0131188165,
-0.0001173726,
0.0138393417,
0.0363620855,
-0.0632370487,
0.0601781011,
-0.0198130328,
0.0038297777,
0.0186526086,
0.0455547236,
0.0146911368,
0.0026661516,
-0.0452158153,
0.0342989303,
-0.0013052365,
0.0526302047,
-0.0307138488,
-0.016299637,
-0.0118847555,
0.0103845457,
-0.0509652942,
-0.0121611115,
0.0310525,
-0.035234753,
-0.0026873746,
0.0111966683,
0.0326751173,
-0.0341753326,
-0.0308114532,
-0.0094760759,
-0.0122479396,
-0.0964416191,
0.0009974611,
0.0925583392,
-0.0014410956,
-0.0291350018,
0.0140036102,
0.0641178712,
0.0113712717,
0.005767758,
-0.0370274819,
-0.0766800344,
-0.0007338831,
0.0473072827,
-0.0568489172,
0.0021741753,
-0.0670547634,
-0.0576870218,
0.0291423183,
-0.0070520858,
-0.0013403598,
0.03115182,
-0.0233739801,
-0.0004523255,
0.0389703549,
0.0040933988,
0.0496072806,
-0.0260460172,
0.0618673153,
-0.0048721954,
-0.0485018976,
-0.0406250097,
0.0421931893,
-0.0345197022,
-0.050159052,
0.0245077219,
0.0555899404,
0.0001133944,
0.0280449893,
-0.0117234131,
-0.0223186351,
-0.0091045778,
-0.0731253028,
-0.0457912795,
-0.0162078291,
-0.0066293636,
-0.0583487116,
0.0169894956,
-0.0050747874,
-0.0237138458,
-0.0009246243,
-0.029219931,
-0.0519957282,
-0.0249004811,
-0.0313442983,
0.0256046336,
-0.0072020828,
0.0372336395,
0.0121914335,
0.0034378693,
-0.0341747627,
0.052680742,
-0.0092839124,
0.03800302,
-0.0123846773,
-0.0697329491,
0.0405784808,
-0.0373009518,
-0.043546129,
-0.0031385359,
-0.0293293931,
-0.0088941371,
-0.0026425715,
-0.0048923795,
-0.0136233475,
-0.0172899049,
-0.0430187546,
-0.0212192331,
0.0077439873,
0.0350813642,
-0.0142731974,
0.0225948729,
0.0080087846,
-0.0470384806,
-0.0001652644,
-0.0227938965,
-0.0401793607,
-0.0047271051,
0.0446062908,
0.0187193584,
-0.0507649519,
0.0452403761,
0.0163505748,
-0.0233482476,
0.0474844836,
0.0283007212,
-0.0233608056,
-0.011067587,
0.0010082148,
-0.0240290817,
-0.0078171939,
0.0136427488,
0.0218279753,
-0.0392275825,
0.0349546745,
-0.032395076,
0.0734824166,
0.0223517399,
0.0054176068,
0.0086594429,
0.048824016,
-0.0038531073,
0.0162338894,
-0.0198332444,
-0.0018271211,
0.0012974155,
-0.0507304631,
0.0256485362,
0.096561648,
-0.0212994069,
0.0271551963,
-0.0363351814,
-0.0404339582,
-0.012103348,
-0.0339712948,
-0.0578496121,
0.0592505559,
-0.0298963133,
-0.020090241,
-0.0155471135,
-0.0240241103,
0.0701066405,
0.0265642349,
0.0121800909,
-0.0142504871,
-0.0112470742,
-0.0457380749,
0.0093508549,
0.0178992487,
0.0438674465,
0.0414488725,
-0.0491310544,
-0.0067801871,
-0.0013831217,
0.0170512162,
-0.0543356128,
0.016929578,
0.0229968987,
0.0285517201,
-0.0411590971,
-0.052525226,
-0.0082125533,
0.0041293288,
0.0045053964,
0.0305678193,
-0.067318812,
-0.0150203295,
-0.0905860811,
0.0169013403,
-0.008135166,
0.0522360876,
-0.0187002774,
-0.0169151034,
0.0112992013,
0.068435356,
0.0217103455,
-0.0336781368,
-0.0067187971,
-0.0440630428,
0.0004513753,
0.0294563957,
-0.0018595133,
0.0364397503,
0.0380680822,
-0.022536058,
0.0153745571,
-0.0436331443,
0.0057933223,
-0.0294117741,
0.000156967,
0.026150126,
0.00173595,
0.0806965381,
0.0218066294,
-0.0523005314,
-0.0225048102,
0.0078995945,
0.0207740441,
0.012233478,
0.019158721,
-0.0291159377,
-0.0285457596,
-0.0040901317,
0.0602460541,
-0.0311262235,
-0.0479591973,
0.0133144194,
-0.0311681833,
-0.0028344207,
-0.0247173626,
-0.0687125251,
-0.0099158669,
-0.0592511073,
0.0046968735,
-0.0791245475,
-0.0169615913,
-0.0446260758,
-0.0383129194,
-0.0249518659,
0.0366762727,
-0.0024005384,
-0.0357061625,
0.020562226,
-0.0148315364,
0.0297304876,
0.0394116007,
0.0441514477,
-0.0320330895,
0.0087918974,
-0.0039778971,
0.0092603695,
-0.0184034053,
-0.0046141427,
0.106264621,
-0.029650623,
-0.000960919,
-0.014839476,
-0.02025152,
-0.0426119305,
-0.043067582,
0.0188894924,
0.0033623534,
0.009571664,
-0.0098153632,
-0.0340687633,
-0.042640198,
0.0212304238,
0.0500037633,
-0.0081153298,
-0.0628842339,
-0.0350386798,
0.0298910122,
0.0278377049,
-0.0207640585,
0.0003811024,
0.0766484588,
-0.0374039859,
-0.122770533,
0.0201110113,
0.0040024128,
0.016713934,
0.0439745523,
0.0007857149,
-0.0219385549,
-0.0032967094,
0.0194428097,
-0.0771445408,
0.0106796073,
-0.0402855948,
0.0077414946,
-0.0662712678,
-0.0217487402,
0.054498557,
-0.0132912137,
-0.0440767072,
0.0052317739,
-0.0054965178,
-0.0263205133,
0.0321014933,
0.0208343361,
0.0167648252,
-0.0144442879,
0.04659703,
-0.0318097919,
0.1290577352,
0.0730989948,
-0.0149986232,
0.0043507912,
0.0078260368,
0.0052193683,
-0.0517725982,
0.0017907532,
-0.0096951555,
0.0388171114,
0.0542246066,
-0.0232725814,
-0.0443971008,
-0.0077365171,
0.0045065754,
0.0294544473,
0.050323315,
-0.0244183931,
-0.0420014001,
-0.0514870398,
0.0448092632,
0.0752254203,
0.0393603668,
0.0158153307,
-0.0370387696,
0.0421656705,
-0.0002333899,
-0.0395999812,
0.0390542373,
-0.0313619971,
-0.0227318853,
-0.0122354263,
0.0136193233,
0.0111568347,
0.0407061614,
0.0254622772,
-0.0340954699,
0.0028751921,
0.0345742032,
0.0883775726,
0.0334442221,
0.0037416129,
0.0088117504,
0.0191229898,
0.0713481009,
-0.0118444739,
0.0084870458,
-0.0499313697,
0.0466584489,
-0.027278563,
0.0206839368,
0.0005408152,
0.0412046574,
0.0117390146,
-0.0175600536,
-0.0115880836,
-0.010242519,
-0.0046701157,
-0.0431029312,
0.0059918505,
0.0426536277,
0.0141417114,
-0.007630222,
-0.0021753879,
0.0695595518,
0.0199361779,
0.0619847141,
-0.0489331,
-0.0114717064,
-0.0767864957,
0.0283876881,
0.0479106531,
-0.0189889278,
-0.0049624112,
0.0169428177,
-0.0796913728,
-0.0040056584,
0.0809221119,
-0.0649871826,
0.0327854939,
0.0427922457,
0.020483721,
-0.033123944,
-0.0017880694,
-0.0442564264,
-0.0191527735,
-0.0320381969,
-0.0130542992,
-0.0284098424,
0.0039354754,
-5.976651519e-33,
-0.034130048,
-0.0516663603,
-0.0042052572,
-0.0340267345,
0.0023931812,
0.0393532477,
0.0103560919,
0.0000357459,
-0.0305852201,
-0.0207173768,
0.0023573644,
-0.0226426031,
0.0223503914,
0.0217593256,
-0.015724618,
-0.0139174704,
0.0391714908,
0.0192953758,
-0.0269798916,
0.0140530961,
0.0337519161,
0.0426579341,
0.0239071865,
-0.0814845189,
-0.0148423743,
0.0322874263,
-0.0324069038,
0.0104679884,
0.0242031626,
0.046842251,
-0.0223697405,
0.0408042893,
0.0328998454,
0.0172537528,
0.0419607088,
0.0239834618,
-0.1090058386,
-0.0011760214,
-0.0630063266,
0.0350684077,
0.0116517562,
-0.0406700484,
0.0338697433,
0.0104859052,
0.0069901259,
-0.0407826714,
0.0810505971,
-0.0075370753,
-0.0363581926,
-0.0404563546,
-0.0329572037,
0.0690114051,
0.0015259561,
0.0148609634,
0.0123263067,
-0.0071943719,
0.0117908409,
0.0243902598,
-0.0273791794,
0.0145010063,
0.0099975625,
-0.0201751981,
-0.0305889342,
0.0551272258,
-0.0353017636,
0.0362289175,
0.0455043092,
0.0142467879,
0.0206057746,
-0.0249798615,
-0.0212228671,
-0.011052561,
-0.0253358111,
0.0346613862,
0.0573563762,
-0.0571069717,
-0.0764067098,
0.0027487068,
-0.0562693253,
-0.0057318546,
-0.0017145483,
-0.0242294483,
-0.0603651851,
-0.0058107111,
-0.0112177124,
-0.0331129208,
-0.043675378,
0.0149710095,
0.0183097534,
0.0147369588,
-0.0436199009,
0.0245653391,
-0.008011885,
-0.0082433615,
-0.0319500566,
-0.0132826334,
0.0614056103,
0.0490525402,
-0.0334531926,
-0.0091491928,
-0.0477339663,
-0.0474152826,
0.0258104112,
-0.0095247375,
0.0594683178,
-0.0356484614,
0.0944149867,
-0.0075699543,
-0.0934222043,
-0.01720093,
0.0486676246,
0.0179712642,
0.013954334,
0.0150703378,
0.0053424379,
-0.006971729,
0.0039982144,
0.0304463729,
0.0430980213,
-0.0446521714,
-0.0099950489,
0.0310923737,
-0.0003355723,
0.0282904841,
-0.0244544279,
0.0217395164,
0.021239778,
-0.0102478927,
0.0169643406,
-0.0590261631,
-0.0029659721,
-0.003508213,
2.766e-7,
0.0710435733,
0.0013409271,
-0.0043136571,
-0.0628797561,
-0.0273855459,
0.0108738225,
0.0502605587,
0.0388386771,
-0.0302256737,
0.0141881863,
0.0135251209,
0.0054510571,
0.0176357515,
0.0223334767,
-0.0944547579,
0.0324481092,
-0.0111079533,
0.0138910962,
-0.0349048078,
0.0365837254,
0.0460130759,
0.0095012514,
0.0099839885,
-0.0615959577,
-0.0284135006,
-0.0233920496,
0.0454809181,
0.0329185799,
0.0441609882,
0.0560544617,
-0.019220572,
0.0220215246,
-0.0229120888,
0.0481120162,
0.0038192635,
0.0194404759,
-0.0055895741,
0.0378282629,
-0.0521150045,
-0.0083189812,
0.02745842,
0.0298804231,
0.0105893817,
0.0208453424,
0.0416733548,
-0.057932809,
-0.0583076403,
-0.0283622723,
0.0137336552,
0.0219396465,
0.0875478387,
0.0115650604,
-0.0144147789,
0.0293895658,
0.0065902951,
-0.0277113561,
-0.0143638123,
-0.0606697202,
0.0452477559,
0.06485679,
0.0193898529,
-0.0295067374,
0.0272814631,
0.0213798024,
0.0602960922,
-0.0804857537,
-0.0144287003,
2.20300682e-34,
-0.0084367553,
-0.0233188588,
0.0035040043,
0.0208025444,
-0.0428794138,
-0.0426885039,
-0.0039408677,
-0.0161468331,
-0.01381242,
-0.0161843672,
0.0141939446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01108v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01108v1 | Noise-Robust Fine-Tuning of Pretrained Language Models via External Guidance | 2023-11-02T09:20:38 | 2023-11-02T09:20:38 | Song Wang, Zhen Tan, Ruocheng Guo, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adopting a two-stage paradigm of pretraining followed by fine-tuning,
Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) have achieved substantial advancements in the
field of natural language processing. However, in real-world scenarios, data
labels are often noisy due to the complex annotation process, making it
essential to develop strategies for fine-tuning PLMs with such noisy labels. To
this end, we introduce an innovative approach for fine-tuning PLMs using noisy
labels, which incorporates the guidance of Large Language Models (LLMs) like
ChatGPT. This guidance assists in accurately distinguishing between clean and
noisy samples and provides supplementary information beyond the noisy labels,
thereby boosting the learning process during fine-tuning PLMs. Extensive
experiments on synthetic and real-world noisy datasets further demonstrate the
superior advantages of our framework over the state-of-the-art baselines. | [
0.0396303795,
0.0387077257,
-0.0031729816,
0.0363068357,
0.0100888759,
0.0184885524,
-0.0370767638,
0.008756862,
-0.0023249902,
-0.0599894002,
-0.0812901706,
-0.0086085526,
-0.0251884963,
-0.0169465262,
0.0380608439,
-0.0250978917,
0.0403331518,
-0.0314893611,
0.046666719,
0.0120613519,
0.0190689471,
0.0002528734,
0.0075137648,
0.0347778164,
-0.017914487,
-0.007698331,
0.0384253673,
0.0306331366,
0.0006626212,
-0.0248737372,
0.0590638891,
0.0653179139,
-0.0106215915,
0.0366197862,
0.0000019643,
-0.0440431423,
-0.0062614772,
0.0176661294,
-0.0285491701,
0.0529729389,
0.0494472235,
0.0369403213,
-0.0117646391,
0.0155281285,
-0.0208068825,
-0.0291673075,
0.0526111349,
0.0356026404,
0.0669420958,
0.0817130879,
-0.0039304313,
-0.002532695,
-0.0143737961,
-0.0363205299,
0.0029197221,
-0.0689287707,
0.0325105451,
0.0082536964,
-0.0324084572,
0.0233093463,
-0.0007190839,
0.0369063355,
-0.031042235,
-0.0025064731,
0.0076383073,
0.0117202606,
-0.0451588705,
-0.0268718097,
-0.0040389807,
0.0719222203,
-0.0524231456,
-0.0293628052,
0.0057621892,
-0.0396906808,
-0.0098365108,
-0.0322266184,
-0.0175874364,
-0.0139570367,
0.0020274976,
0.0317325182,
0.0117584979,
-0.009271441,
0.0433800556,
0.0193734951,
-0.0039462065,
0.025165597,
0.009363072,
-0.0288468935,
0.0343051553,
0.017521359,
-0.0373577327,
-0.027799869,
-0.0025471288,
0.0169101711,
-0.0423766971,
0.0005799907,
-0.048788026,
-0.0442118533,
0.004419677,
-0.0456552133,
0.0188627001,
0.0007998506,
-0.0511978641,
0.0608060211,
-0.0046841162,
-0.0292337593,
0.0276987404,
0.0674999729,
-0.0355506092,
-0.0156818163,
0.0024264252,
0.0137031795,
-0.0826252773,
0.0020073669,
-0.0230305847,
0.0004759944,
-0.0408345908,
0.0066629499,
0.0006774639,
-0.0132927131,
0.0256291404,
-0.0331829861,
-0.0351050943,
-0.0245326441,
0.0098838378,
0.0007557909,
-0.0054519316,
0.0084335161,
-0.0121030258,
-0.0635793433,
-0.0103050293,
0.0145187909,
0.002309408,
-0.022686949,
0.0337651968,
0.0831379443,
0.0216383189,
-0.0517550483,
-0.0521040931,
0.0003408107,
-0.0096979896,
-0.0470497943,
-0.0300150532,
-0.0133205932,
-0.0107492171,
-0.0161393397,
0.0345359631,
-0.0417222604,
-0.0028836885,
-0.0136272945,
-0.0717368945,
0.0887965262,
-0.074204877,
0.0096356552,
-0.0018823806,
-0.0042344024,
-0.0008620042,
0.0657640174,
0.0487645492,
-0.0025434545,
0.0529985689,
-0.0292335618,
0.0399083085,
0.0728961676,
0.0122764111,
0.0010216511,
-0.0000631752,
-0.0250253063,
0.0300319567,
0.0033844716,
-0.0116135376,
0.058867313,
-0.0284849368,
0.0290088467,
0.0644664019,
-0.0075520272,
0.0339254849,
0.0002318654,
0.0050991359,
0.0069070952,
0.0163400006,
0.0081258854,
-0.0380596854,
-0.0238091554,
-0.0685309842,
-0.0110563142,
0.0521208607,
0.0375589393,
-0.0284496844,
-0.0498845764,
-0.0291417912,
-0.0035234394,
-0.0153625989,
0.0094946567,
0.050011415,
0.0353831388,
-0.0275156628,
0.0226245169,
0.0734012127,
-0.0188841075,
0.0192778576,
-0.0716930926,
0.0175300613,
0.0561428666,
0.0527711138,
-0.0408079065,
-0.0454706661,
-0.0208218973,
0.030847216,
0.0162416585,
0.0474107154,
0.0069706142,
0.033369448,
-0.0747519433,
-0.0457724296,
0.0483458564,
0.0377627835,
-0.0082791895,
0.0224621128,
-0.0098532327,
0.0152426548,
-0.0458185934,
-0.0720030069,
0.0643340796,
0.0130256889,
-0.0356236696,
0.0371451266,
-0.0037441703,
0.0289160721,
-0.0088689802,
-0.0314907022,
-0.0080409618,
0.0185137074,
0.0051584886,
0.0535868742,
-0.0099032931,
-0.0120562483,
-0.0016708981,
0.0406399332,
0.0117668454,
-0.0300776195,
-0.0090891039,
-0.0673909485,
-0.0254117604,
-0.0564871244,
-0.005811038,
0.0131031703,
-0.0582586117,
0.0168746617,
-0.0074951099,
0.0260667112,
-0.0499244928,
0.0194659568,
0.0376034603,
0.0187506508,
-0.0160822142,
0.0323249213,
0.0076655922,
-0.0005163631,
-0.0602715127,
-0.0336147659,
-0.0055649765,
0.0346409529,
0.0404489897,
0.0569118224,
-0.0498077013,
-0.0240053087,
-0.0548992306,
-0.0086996956,
-0.0315574333,
-0.0214392096,
0.0180884581,
-0.0149005093,
-0.0288020149,
-0.0201600976,
-0.002702421,
0.0256342385,
0.0069081006,
0.0196052101,
0.0246555824,
-0.0160031337,
-0.0242429581,
-0.0323575176,
0.0166260805,
0.0222160202,
0.0073083169,
0.0096359188,
-0.0692338273,
-0.0744905844,
0.0427920856,
-0.0028069878,
0.0421127528,
0.0120790852,
-0.0660596639,
-0.0129802935,
-0.0146327158,
0.0295678824,
0.0305087715,
-0.0035244823,
0.0090382397,
0.049589131,
-0.0163363665,
-0.0220205318,
0.0126722027,
-0.0358792208,
-0.0483363383,
-0.027884217,
0.0057000965,
0.0024095431,
0.0660107881,
-0.0465275086,
-0.0099392608,
-0.0536295213,
0.0144995777,
-0.0316417813,
-0.0047907024,
-0.0436826497,
0.0224700626,
-0.0347367227,
0.0475200824,
-0.0115612419,
-0.0428294577,
0.0467614979,
-0.0396801867,
-0.0133903679,
-0.0144128203,
-0.0019527356,
0.0028759479,
0.0118100643,
0.0009865178,
0.0074727605,
0.0327679366,
-0.014821915,
-0.0363591947,
-0.0256845225,
0.0473724492,
-0.0419525467,
-0.0085655069,
-0.0367632434,
0.0236619525,
0.0130207893,
-0.0225516558,
-0.0398366973,
-0.065835923,
-0.0318649374,
-0.0167845152,
0.0132911419,
-0.0107043907,
-0.011728704,
0.028080089,
-0.0329123922,
0.0395466909,
-0.0103423558,
0.0031790552,
-0.0096204216,
0.0227467697,
0.0559228696,
-0.0032707117,
0.0240414478,
-0.0173250884,
-0.0276890211,
0.0271766856,
-0.0061796582,
-0.0056175292,
-0.0055631124,
-0.0125055956,
0.035272643,
0.0198404025,
-0.0094289938,
0.0257427432,
0.0590098239,
-0.0556774624,
-0.0519142784,
0.1230795756,
-0.0082635675,
-0.0330165811,
0.0010264975,
0.043043714,
0.050401628,
0.0177639909,
0.0180996954,
-0.0483792685,
-0.0486451797,
0.0172509532,
0.0362075716,
-0.0136110969,
-0.0003488472,
-0.0232651401,
-0.0927318409,
0.0401530191,
0.0479354188,
-0.0582373925,
-0.002500613,
-0.0133837713,
0.0175065212,
-0.0448560826,
0.054982543,
-0.0262416266,
0.0162617508,
-0.003643661,
0.0381132178,
-0.0383823104,
-0.1027739272,
-0.0037456043,
-0.0508610457,
0.1048308834,
0.0422156304,
-0.0018175135,
0.0002276385,
-0.0237679388,
0.1244358867,
0.0125332838,
-0.0148838954,
-0.0234915912,
0.0334668197,
-0.0198448356,
-0.0496836901,
0.0155568207,
0.0025007054,
-0.0138542987,
-0.0017173038,
-0.0182991549,
0.0291987564,
-0.0074096275,
0.0155256661,
0.0313477628,
0.0104010664,
0.0187090542,
0.0833954662,
0.0333630443,
-0.0471798629,
0.0073536709,
-0.0244265571,
0.0171668231,
-0.0127169853,
-0.0404907539,
0.0465249829,
-0.0550530404,
-0.0661068112,
-0.0454173312,
-0.0512020998,
0.0645523369,
0.000838648,
0.0254907999,
0.0243697073,
0.001916839,
0.0284094736,
-0.0156183289,
0.0443307124,
-0.0754686743,
-0.0192177668,
-0.0561861061,
-0.037163429,
0.0458397344,
-0.0047881897,
-0.0202594046,
0.0364488624,
-0.0887623131,
-0.0776034668,
0.0499856807,
0.0628497154,
0.0147477854,
0.0371744707,
-0.0536273345,
-0.0883087367,
0.014546223,
0.083049871,
-0.0432492532,
-0.0072853072,
0.0358166099,
-0.0304813031,
-0.0133777549,
0.0306377672,
-0.038731195,
0.0491502769,
0.0574918017,
0.0093981111,
-0.0085451435,
-0.076325193,
0.01072946,
0.0472973287,
0.1131182164,
-0.0376166329,
-0.0446243435,
-0.0556507818,
0.00475585,
0.0192843564,
-0.02705607,
-0.0325093158,
-0.0040422212,
0.0268918406,
-0.0212232508,
-0.0553911328,
0.0046116035,
-0.0211190004,
0.0543068945,
-0.0351062939,
-0.0271311589,
-0.0018396892,
0.0111871641,
0.0365429372,
-0.0010160541,
0.0008939081,
0.0668017194,
0.0263350774,
0.0170400795,
-0.0083894217,
-0.0045616659,
0.0402698629,
0.0354628414,
-0.0191214513,
0.0356517881,
-0.0296451766,
-0.0569829345,
-0.0711334646,
0.0624240786,
0.0603022613,
-0.0069058826,
0.0430677608,
-0.0266897306,
-0.027760474,
-0.0206415132,
0.019770205,
0.0248244461,
0.0137698939,
0.007440249,
-0.0122909285,
-0.0425637104,
0.0030906457,
0.0666843429,
-0.0038070579,
0.0526010282,
0.0238611232,
-0.0000271271,
-0.0435963236,
0.0120210517,
-0.0271364171,
0.0210866109,
-0.0006247459,
0.0318419784,
-0.0158137437,
-0.0680333227,
-0.0449375585,
0.006401313,
-0.0139002465,
0.0103386892,
0.0314535201,
0.0445145443,
-0.0198934451,
0.0123037184,
-0.0153770447,
-0.0518045649,
0.0558600202,
-0.0173322745,
0.008620698,
-6.676485386e-33,
-0.0244450308,
-0.001664868,
-0.0107841641,
-0.0009702144,
-0.0264249519,
-0.0300719906,
0.0018665531,
-0.0023531297,
-0.0075276867,
0.0230132025,
-0.0288485512,
0.0175818931,
0.0230900478,
0.0194677468,
-0.0221005753,
-0.0196268614,
0.0726361349,
-0.0150486948,
-0.0200776495,
0.0185597949,
-0.0139623741,
0.0379137322,
0.0765602812,
-0.0836480781,
0.0077802371,
0.0099621331,
-0.0518818982,
0.0368394889,
-0.0122062974,
0.0488544069,
-0.0168958548,
0.0298973136,
0.0141854668,
0.019762734,
-0.0187334251,
-0.0106524061,
-0.0776159689,
0.0065394905,
0.0075243427,
0.0230796281,
-0.0030012645,
-0.0214625616,
0.0600237362,
-0.0392221585,
-0.027645329,
0.0267069712,
0.0090010101,
-0.0468021259,
-0.0249279197,
-0.0099614589,
-0.0292615425,
0.0423077382,
-0.0067481846,
-0.0417132117,
0.0437124856,
-0.0303643774,
-0.0235202052,
0.0241279639,
-0.0280704293,
0.006764051,
0.0512566194,
0.061746303,
-0.0059567909,
0.0464507416,
-0.0146691091,
0.0416893847,
0.0180530492,
0.0152956722,
0.0294208881,
-0.0213591605,
0.0575983748,
0.0160772484,
0.0318853781,
0.0316148251,
0.0303369872,
-0.0295339078,
-0.0563407205,
0.0193632543,
-0.0111922957,
-0.0131386854,
0.0222111493,
-0.0006102598,
-0.0172554534,
-0.0321680047,
-0.0458541662,
-0.0226160102,
-0.0444223322,
0.024130404,
0.0188593622,
0.0281927194,
-0.0413573124,
-0.0062864954,
0.0166232456,
-0.0258437023,
-0.0026995705,
-0.0204195548,
0.0067410851,
-0.0202659164,
-0.0288613774,
0.0099347485,
-0.0351197682,
-0.0770792291,
0.0451503135,
0.0083368523,
-0.0043272809,
-0.0218468215,
0.0446187221,
0.0153930727,
-0.0761928931,
0.0337356739,
-0.0094956122,
0.0455869175,
0.009962704,
-0.0021786869,
0.0557170026,
0.003977045,
-0.0074971565,
0.0706004426,
0.0544491597,
0.0095331576,
0.0031581423,
-0.0145344753,
0.0029241836,
0.0168989226,
-0.0033998366,
0.003756711,
0.0035421348,
-0.0240170863,
0.0451985076,
-0.0360563211,
0.0085475007,
-0.020555146,
2.64e-7,
0.0431245007,
0.0806317255,
-0.0105861248,
0.0066412734,
0.0023305935,
0.0383661725,
-0.0278615113,
-0.0215776693,
-0.0022587017,
-0.0309297834,
0.0332847387,
-0.0020809185,
0.0673391446,
0.0055240574,
-0.0508882217,
-0.0354905501,
-0.0620666444,
0.0186681133,
-0.0255774576,
-0.0102970526,
0.046445109,
0.1217614934,
0.0300341751,
-0.0171330795,
0.0079631768,
-0.0749927908,
0.0574579909,
-0.0721525252,
-0.0256051831,
0.0562020093,
0.0432054959,
0.0320109762,
0.009320789,
0.0061880588,
-0.0109176999,
0.0058118198,
0.0038909665,
0.0647333488,
-0.0095908334,
0.0064673037,
-0.0028884169,
0.0443823971,
-0.0050561763,
-0.0176481064,
0.0626090989,
-0.072649993,
-0.0142212538,
-0.0310781263,
0.0072888844,
-0.0475946218,
0.0370726585,
-0.0484521016,
-0.0436377116,
0.0117412843,
0.0249612853,
0.0302333888,
-0.0540730022,
-0.0841979235,
-0.0117648207,
0.0042612799,
-0.0075008981,
-0.0416935086,
0.0147584379,
-0.0236590561,
0.0274480451,
-0.056721542,
0.0365186147,
2.312748401e-34,
0.0850773156,
-0.0406501256,
0.0218283981,
0.0133181848,
0.0262806024,
0.0233688187,
0.0341641456,
0.001355575,
-0.0235086028,
-0.062386509,
0.0125594139
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04917v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04917v2 | Adapting Fake News Detection to the Era of Large Language Models | 2023-11-02T08:39:45 | 2024-04-13T13:52:01 | Jinyan Su, Claire Cardie, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the age of large language models (LLMs) and the widespread adoption of
AI-driven content creation, the landscape of information dissemination has
witnessed a paradigm shift. With the proliferation of both human-written and
machine-generated real and fake news, robustly and effectively discerning the
veracity of news articles has become an intricate challenge. While substantial
research has been dedicated to fake news detection, this either assumes that
all news articles are human-written or abruptly assumes that all
machine-generated news are fake. Thus, a significant gap exists in
understanding the interplay between machine-(paraphrased) real news,
machine-generated fake news, human-written fake news, and human-written real
news. In this paper, we study this gap by conducting a comprehensive evaluation
of fake news detectors trained in various scenarios. Our primary objectives
revolve around the following pivotal question: How to adapt fake news detectors
to the era of LLMs? Our experiments reveal an interesting pattern that
detectors trained exclusively on human-written articles can indeed perform well
at detecting machine-generated fake news, but not vice versa. Moreover, due to
the bias of detectors against machine-generated texts \cite{su2023fake}, they
should be trained on datasets with a lower machine-generated news ratio than
the test set. Building on our findings, we provide a practical strategy for the
development of robust fake news detectors. | [
0.0751069337,
0.039442651,
-0.0087992838,
0.0796746761,
-0.0394957252,
0.0159046967,
0.005979191,
0.0260435026,
0.0094833905,
-0.0336925723,
0.0005539866,
-0.0172440354,
-0.00735664,
0.0585954413,
0.013933504,
-0.0010777153,
0.0499183275,
0.0202070978,
0.0437869281,
-0.0078659086,
0.0411997698,
0.0438188799,
0.0064656809,
0.0046166093,
-0.0285466276,
0.0044362554,
0.0260054655,
0.030936813,
0.0287732147,
-0.0065804133,
-0.0061061108,
0.0453557782,
0.0225446299,
0.1146530956,
0.0000014555,
0.0008901333,
-0.0081370659,
0.0047286577,
-0.0532035008,
0.0013571822,
0.0623005927,
-0.0867549106,
-0.0355965793,
0.0316728354,
-0.022884775,
-0.0322455503,
0.0104871802,
0.0548588037,
0.0516512543,
0.1340953559,
-0.0207080618,
0.0152132493,
0.0404177047,
0.0059591751,
-0.0075416993,
-0.0252641942,
0.0431583375,
-0.002680568,
-0.0270865634,
0.0377794765,
0.04058972,
-0.0022273767,
0.0358296633,
-0.0236138385,
-0.0485362485,
0.0167675354,
-0.0349030159,
-0.0225882009,
-0.0036522921,
0.0152986534,
-0.0592920221,
-0.0899829492,
0.0391658433,
-0.0213260315,
0.0022140688,
0.0349605531,
0.0230896641,
0.0485035107,
-0.0296517294,
0.0128635094,
0.0315292776,
-0.0332431495,
0.0383510292,
0.085891597,
0.0195536111,
0.0418076552,
0.0006993142,
-0.0250490792,
0.0002125744,
0.0223754179,
0.0065285559,
-0.0413816907,
0.0262001008,
0.010296395,
-0.0262514111,
-0.0035075413,
-0.0861653313,
-0.0169217102,
0.0370194912,
-0.0940818414,
-0.0132599613,
-0.0136561636,
0.0057747136,
0.046555575,
-0.0356721729,
0.0116914622,
-0.0271977112,
0.0135813337,
-0.0124106016,
0.0025405027,
0.0128091481,
0.0153343482,
0.0013917882,
0.0045406879,
-0.0187350642,
0.0028213332,
-0.0238162577,
0.0053013265,
0.0076638693,
0.0198391192,
-0.0357839093,
-0.0122870654,
-0.0181125533,
-0.0286294296,
0.0006339045,
0.0122964531,
0.0108807944,
0.0416335724,
-0.0026423361,
-0.0612966083,
-0.0159550328,
0.0613552034,
-0.018783465,
-0.003450542,
0.0084144035,
-0.0109866383,
-0.0057515828,
-0.0167476442,
-0.0532727577,
-0.0396293253,
-0.0264229793,
-0.0631229281,
0.0035006364,
-0.0715301186,
-0.0167421307,
-0.0211283471,
-0.004104563,
-0.028517697,
-0.024403492,
0.0396075957,
-0.0193817802,
0.0194085296,
-0.0199516881,
0.0044137342,
0.0575522184,
0.0135205425,
-0.0154833766,
0.0950445905,
0.0279332474,
0.102529034,
0.058111269,
0.0377734751,
0.0248837546,
0.0210385676,
0.0426848754,
0.0620514415,
0.0170465447,
-0.0197973568,
-0.0321005322,
-0.0011391958,
0.0246716812,
0.0343629047,
0.0034371349,
-0.0447454453,
0.0925178751,
-0.028212605,
-0.0097282995,
-0.0110096373,
0.0776388049,
0.0235370956,
0.0188019797,
0.022421604,
-0.0499019325,
-0.0156977884,
-0.0767429397,
-0.0178153105,
-0.0282538887,
0.0429746471,
0.0071825027,
-0.010417047,
-0.0012806165,
-0.0121039134,
-0.0180956088,
-0.0236501377,
0.0091862325,
0.0108774146,
-0.0287681911,
-0.0163618699,
-0.004644806,
-0.0002774071,
0.0231091063,
-0.0730872899,
0.0451388732,
0.0188789945,
0.0491733439,
0.0329605304,
0.0474039726,
-0.023485221,
-0.0009027235,
0.0604515746,
0.0234667324,
-0.0308783315,
-0.0398267247,
0.0133160651,
-0.0048279287,
0.0041705044,
0.0393875577,
-0.0250166021,
0.049337402,
0.0342264511,
0.0178511646,
-0.0142760156,
-0.0622830726,
0.0234804805,
-0.0231899172,
0.0007946218,
-0.0129038012,
0.0086095668,
0.0129030906,
0.016314961,
-0.0317563824,
-0.0210334901,
0.0516599864,
-0.0087492727,
-0.0272851642,
-0.0453085154,
0.0002582115,
-0.023649333,
0.004665344,
-0.0329757333,
-0.0428075008,
0.0695477277,
-0.0189967863,
0.0178122576,
-0.0109877083,
-0.0395504683,
-0.0049142274,
-0.053912431,
-0.0113584632,
-0.0336520225,
0.022426201,
0.0282908753,
0.0663532168,
-0.0403638259,
-0.0067977658,
0.014506585,
0.0104301525,
0.0017273067,
-0.0101573337,
0.0012670184,
0.0199210234,
-0.0016548398,
0.0216112733,
0.0202283021,
-0.0133220069,
0.0053714723,
-0.016333295,
-0.045527596,
-0.0093320236,
-0.0443171822,
-0.0079181083,
0.0614674017,
-0.0236825552,
-0.0138961105,
0.0169283487,
-0.0287773348,
-0.0139302155,
0.0415202975,
0.0267893225,
0.0040914258,
-0.0379790887,
0.0298674051,
-0.0128359245,
0.020611003,
-0.0130618112,
0.0451449268,
0.0243212096,
-0.0360657163,
-0.0641303733,
0.0144566465,
-0.0288006887,
-0.0057985391,
-0.026830405,
-0.0308037456,
-0.0146565828,
-0.002919843,
-0.0128430417,
0.0774590373,
0.0479058698,
0.0582348965,
0.0230295062,
0.0785716623,
-0.000226034,
-0.0385497324,
-0.0175926648,
0.0495807044,
-0.0375226028,
-0.0801149532,
0.0424371772,
0.0199189465,
0.0108376807,
0.0073834574,
0.0209269486,
0.0480024554,
-0.0183576848,
-0.0421344303,
0.0492227748,
-0.0468908101,
-0.0148010114,
0.0265820902,
-0.0373220034,
-0.0439913757,
0.0801184326,
-0.0221433304,
0.0531826988,
-0.0389874913,
-0.0531376861,
-0.0101030357,
-0.0134072648,
-0.0169046354,
0.0332052819,
-0.0183718055,
0.027109297,
-0.0145080797,
-0.0040551885,
0.0664134696,
-0.0355033427,
0.0191127993,
-0.0304990616,
0.0332534201,
0.0113388374,
-0.0208295565,
-0.057254333,
-0.0929385573,
-0.020420745,
-0.0155351507,
0.0095206546,
-0.0420400426,
-0.0459419228,
-0.0220977031,
0.0363816842,
0.0649656355,
-0.0124722868,
0.0159532707,
0.0043680645,
0.0765087754,
0.046927467,
-0.0163675994,
0.0642717183,
-0.01755137,
-0.0119262431,
0.0837721676,
0.0108180288,
0.0393661745,
-0.0114347236,
-0.0280976295,
0.0117419064,
-0.0066256826,
0.0037671421,
-0.0099390792,
0.0024452878,
-0.0392967984,
0.0020338099,
0.0835004523,
0.012603228,
-0.0376170538,
-0.0023089494,
0.0559605807,
-0.0028476571,
0.0042494014,
-0.0188361034,
-0.0712425038,
0.0022554544,
0.0133867338,
-0.0019924908,
-0.0659782812,
-0.0090045277,
-0.0245662518,
-0.0939038917,
0.0198925808,
-0.0102368649,
-0.0248319134,
-0.0466289781,
-0.0769823566,
-0.0064921007,
0.0034136118,
0.0152153559,
-0.0128052207,
0.0239850581,
-0.0231116209,
-0.0192673504,
0.0215239376,
-0.0701242834,
-0.0260988176,
-0.0324525535,
0.0503813736,
0.0444514751,
0.0426517166,
-0.0207128134,
-0.0311565474,
-0.0036321501,
0.0006071447,
-0.0467536189,
-0.0124324281,
0.0615376569,
-0.0553364418,
-0.0021396272,
-0.0222206488,
0.0550189689,
0.004245251,
0.0044184239,
0.0075510703,
0.024427671,
0.0169382151,
-0.0979645848,
-0.0397577025,
0.0040479559,
0.0359863751,
0.0679068044,
0.0160250831,
-0.0226463862,
-0.0113804936,
-0.0146623198,
-0.0047917664,
-0.0155164758,
-0.0646077842,
0.0292254128,
-0.0256831162,
-0.0310764667,
-0.0668802038,
-0.0222039558,
-0.035207551,
0.0145921353,
-0.0193712581,
-0.0262891855,
0.0210612006,
-0.0379121974,
-0.0430918336,
-0.0113203172,
-0.0299126338,
0.0463688225,
-0.0130574815,
0.0158906244,
0.015774576,
-0.0180059876,
-0.0038056734,
0.035830114,
-0.1029240638,
-0.0456958599,
0.0002852413,
0.0029291823,
0.0234005786,
0.045783028,
-0.0258772317,
-0.0432042442,
0.0583815016,
0.0228527524,
-0.0478255861,
0.029097721,
0.0177906211,
-0.0372508429,
0.0273869988,
0.0112281619,
-0.0158744808,
0.0413199812,
0.0235629417,
-0.0390124619,
-0.029791683,
0.0082001192,
0.0339597054,
0.0229175668,
0.0069131427,
-0.016327573,
0.0186276753,
-0.0301924497,
-0.0266114548,
-0.0262180027,
-0.0260298569,
-0.013026733,
0.0193387903,
0.0349491537,
0.0258686766,
-0.0146905519,
0.0216377694,
-0.0410160348,
0.0224868488,
-0.0405735858,
-0.0434483588,
-0.0160132591,
0.0486354604,
0.0167333186,
-0.0186548773,
-0.0418568067,
0.0362189449,
-0.0020450323,
0.0304031186,
-0.0006989779,
0.0196231157,
0.0292943381,
-0.0532246307,
0.0221570469,
-0.0253283642,
-0.0771663561,
0.0172289275,
-0.0624578707,
0.0444391817,
0.0263090786,
-0.0266911723,
0.0393212549,
-0.0305505879,
-0.018987393,
-0.0201805495,
-0.0228144228,
0.0087698959,
-0.0207247976,
-0.0329355486,
0.0190533549,
-0.0305299275,
0.060906224,
0.0708539635,
0.0364449024,
0.0372417271,
0.0142091122,
-0.0584763028,
-0.0189549644,
-0.0119522559,
-0.0097039836,
0.0160711594,
-0.0216426477,
-0.0275388975,
-0.0665966049,
-0.0539950728,
0.0163429622,
0.0132281808,
0.0518108122,
0.0029395898,
-0.0519674346,
0.0821586102,
0.0051487298,
0.0244567432,
-0.0388614982,
0.0112848449,
-0.0025272572,
-0.044193387,
0.0175378956,
-5.580977181e-33,
0.0413842872,
-0.0623764172,
-0.0452693701,
-0.0175357852,
-0.0019033769,
0.0616351776,
-0.0063461186,
-0.0322091542,
-0.046416305,
0.0510758646,
0.0216003414,
0.0601346493,
-0.004842462,
0.0177992955,
-0.0693057552,
-0.0078511601,
0.0513673052,
-0.0212114491,
-0.0507807322,
0.0158176478,
0.0191377625,
-0.0281262714,
0.0014149909,
-0.0298772547,
0.0507482216,
-0.0496266708,
-0.0543101579,
0.0214759801,
-0.0412150398,
0.0580361895,
-0.012669527,
0.0478680134,
0.0601892024,
-0.0103136636,
0.0070366669,
0.0336267725,
-0.0353183262,
0.0016372586,
0.0176319163,
-0.0005919182,
-0.0273224898,
-0.0026617497,
0.0475373715,
-0.0108145718,
-0.0200853962,
0.0224388167,
0.0149472952,
-0.0307815187,
-0.0101182889,
-0.0176510308,
-0.0278575774,
0.0220265612,
0.0165127292,
0.0142580913,
0.0007739813,
0.0318009779,
0.0225112122,
0.0270417146,
-0.0790561959,
0.0180262439,
-0.0335439779,
0.0151885189,
0.0113224778,
-0.0420698747,
-0.056146875,
0.0491051786,
0.0444493517,
0.0525473021,
-0.0341434851,
0.0000978638,
0.0132349534,
-0.0013283815,
0.0817497894,
0.1234448627,
0.030733915,
-0.0550180338,
-0.0744358972,
0.0206901878,
0.0400564596,
-0.0291722044,
0.0119464975,
-0.0280263089,
-0.0278384387,
0.0096603064,
-0.0198519155,
-0.0353766046,
-0.0367398784,
-0.0122393714,
-0.0048405686,
0.048533868,
-0.0379363038,
0.0297068786,
0.0080362689,
-0.0659386665,
-0.0000281737,
0.0304509662,
-0.046513956,
-0.0061364924,
0.0186376441,
0.0498823225,
-0.040733818,
-0.0113534303,
0.0369534045,
0.0191155616,
-0.0074191969,
-0.0260937493,
0.0664506033,
0.0248911139,
-0.0317386054,
0.0280447043,
-0.0206982456,
0.0323834904,
0.0080389315,
-0.0136537217,
0.0327720754,
-0.028728988,
-0.0031063638,
-0.0104216738,
0.0003225437,
0.0045889113,
-0.016265234,
0.0105300499,
-0.031949833,
0.0279749986,
-0.0117653487,
-0.0118525,
-0.0458354913,
0.0113393161,
0.0178164113,
-0.0991056785,
0.0255393572,
-0.0283244196,
2.259e-7,
-0.0198511519,
0.0499060415,
0.0110566011,
0.0264677275,
0.0190387424,
0.036221277,
0.0240195245,
0.027992418,
-0.0135100922,
-0.0658222958,
-0.0372845456,
0.0334542058,
0.0310741365,
0.0308137946,
-0.0627462566,
0.0476736277,
-0.0744532421,
0.0065487586,
-0.0533752814,
-0.0148646673,
0.0265680328,
0.0624216087,
0.0267844554,
-0.048051551,
0.0159935765,
-0.032544829,
0.0397745892,
0.0414285287,
-0.0363899395,
-0.0013098257,
0.0775824487,
-0.0129084587,
0.0195058323,
0.0175354984,
-0.0462138243,
-0.0051985839,
-0.0008924305,
0.0471641906,
0.0308235362,
0.0313996412,
-0.0068890797,
-0.0574812554,
0.033034835,
-0.0649388209,
0.0842990205,
-0.0007330685,
-0.005861741,
-0.0790881962,
-0.062050093,
-0.0330687948,
0.0270389225,
-0.0437787771,
-0.0094622569,
0.0391432717,
-0.0028504233,
0.0380123816,
-0.0011396544,
-0.0129807862,
-0.0047108047,
-0.0061804438,
-0.0430677421,
-0.0250498727,
-0.0258786809,
-0.0341341272,
0.0627175868,
-0.0542864017,
0.0433246754,
1.649195041e-34,
0.048935961,
-0.0229575243,
-0.0092575839,
0.0088277422,
0.0207747035,
0.033423163,
-0.0268281046,
-0.0263519883,
0.0059326082,
0.0000166907,
0.0096812332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01070v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01070v3 | Multilingual DistilWhisper: Efficient Distillation of Multi-task Speech Models via Language-Specific Experts | 2023-11-02T08:37:30 | 2024-03-12T14:50:30 | Thomas Palmeira Ferraz, Marcely Zanon Boito, Caroline Brun, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Whisper is a multitask and multilingual speech model covering 99 languages.
It yields commendable automatic speech recognition (ASR) results in a subset of
its covered languages, but the model still underperforms on a non-negligible
number of under-represented languages, a problem exacerbated in smaller model
versions. In this work, we propose DistilWhisper, an approach able to bridge
the performance gap in ASR for these languages while retaining the advantages
of multitask and multilingual capabilities. Our approach involves two key
strategies: lightweight modular ASR fine-tuning of whisper-small using
language-specific experts, and knowledge distillation from whisper-large-v2.
This dual approach allows us to effectively boost ASR performance while keeping
the robustness inherited from the multitask and multilingual pre-training.
Results demonstrate that our approach is more effective than standard
fine-tuning or LoRA adapters, boosting performance in the targeted languages
for both in- and out-of-domain test sets, while introducing only a negligible
parameter overhead at inference. | [
-0.0280896146,
0.059420906,
-0.0009393999,
0.0417341627,
-0.0260166582,
0.0084814271,
0.0687361509,
-0.0191222336,
0.008732534,
0.0143956281,
-0.0936495066,
-0.0300048757,
0.0116062947,
0.0114190169,
0.0510812216,
-0.0218633208,
0.0207946412,
-0.1078680679,
-0.0076325801,
-0.0352427401,
0.0005991087,
0.0166834053,
-0.0140929939,
0.0478739962,
0.0278298482,
-0.0052200556,
-0.0056590778,
0.0148841599,
0.0207553506,
0.0312476158,
0.0122638941,
0.009304299,
0.0105216391,
0.0380922332,
0.0000021159,
-0.0143701509,
-0.0057537379,
0.0091286665,
-0.029815007,
0.0048772236,
0.0219581313,
0.0130988583,
0.0001437456,
0.0246117711,
-0.0076334653,
-0.0053864201,
0.0286506563,
0.0073853591,
0.0305352584,
0.0459282324,
-0.0080767684,
-0.0077235373,
0.0175801758,
-0.0248407666,
-0.0319070257,
-0.0486327782,
-0.0103148483,
-0.0084887864,
-0.0357275046,
-0.0495627299,
-0.0127949379,
0.0538786165,
0.0052744714,
0.0173126273,
-0.0372528285,
-0.0258049462,
-0.0281952303,
-0.0779318437,
-0.0247054417,
0.038235683,
-0.0727421492,
-0.0243850667,
0.0228193961,
0.0083314925,
-0.0443654619,
-0.0253602769,
-0.0233635549,
-0.0082756858,
0.0011461594,
-0.0220687389,
0.0321841426,
0.0232532993,
0.0266298708,
-0.018371379,
-0.0231598485,
0.0261979848,
0.0098613929,
0.002837857,
0.0307981446,
-0.0099705998,
0.0035989445,
-0.0247438494,
0.0332675911,
-0.0137690129,
-0.0356151313,
-0.0119539229,
-0.0262930598,
-0.0432339162,
0.0014538817,
-0.0157714467,
0.0395496227,
0.0802166313,
-0.061261218,
0.0248768684,
-0.0096230935,
0.0383677371,
0.0159776751,
0.0036710983,
-0.0199558325,
-0.0410677865,
-0.024914762,
0.0291616172,
-0.034427505,
0.0005478525,
-0.0710856989,
-0.0275361333,
0.0000852667,
-0.0027719261,
-0.0302097872,
-0.0167358629,
0.05611616,
-0.0278094094,
-0.0640229061,
0.002620599,
0.0391598828,
0.0931694135,
-0.0139480159,
0.0201245565,
-0.0074189436,
-0.0765904859,
-0.016906254,
0.0226188526,
0.0170147978,
-0.0064895339,
0.0242527835,
0.0774186999,
-0.0019733792,
-0.0200573448,
-0.0050649359,
-0.0007004867,
-0.0088949483,
-0.1115086004,
0.0047536641,
-0.0458448753,
0.0597222373,
0.0141292997,
0.0301550459,
-0.06274914,
-0.0246830266,
-0.0416557193,
0.0235878974,
0.0620334707,
0.0140867969,
0.0037577881,
0.0069949059,
0.003483434,
-0.0229255427,
0.1161496863,
0.0276900288,
0.0015712557,
0.00643727,
-0.0277082585,
-0.0337957703,
0.0683062971,
0.0077587515,
0.0181458928,
0.0131860524,
-0.0013796629,
0.0244096648,
-0.0672814175,
0.0428283773,
0.0172722004,
-0.0293460712,
0.0154327322,
0.0403194726,
0.0132543948,
0.04834079,
0.0161231942,
0.0342717171,
0.0094422968,
-0.0077949865,
0.009411932,
-0.0178469419,
0.0088132806,
0.0146456966,
0.0185261574,
0.027620675,
0.1061588824,
-0.0322814733,
-0.014555064,
0.0109608341,
-0.0086072804,
0.0042745909,
0.0822505578,
0.0660675243,
0.0067732902,
-0.0415475965,
0.0810929015,
0.0861119553,
-0.0549596436,
0.0111833224,
-0.0528079979,
-0.0200955048,
0.0293889195,
-0.0144778453,
-0.0300107431,
-0.026658792,
-0.0193414185,
0.0300217886,
0.0300413091,
0.0059009879,
0.0067983065,
0.104178004,
-0.0699655861,
-0.0360827185,
0.0008763516,
-0.0002219568,
0.0602346174,
-0.0141353263,
0.0089014182,
0.0008125962,
-0.0509588644,
-0.026191121,
-0.0339470543,
-0.0416469164,
-0.0067643779,
0.0290795974,
0.0408332609,
0.0449012257,
0.0241711736,
-0.0176743027,
-0.0348467939,
0.024767613,
-0.0473545603,
0.0426390171,
0.0334952474,
-0.0380599052,
-0.021173995,
0.0417612344,
0.012169552,
0.0345146917,
0.023741575,
-0.0005481183,
-0.0812334418,
0.0401815996,
0.0241991486,
0.0312104076,
-0.0303319246,
0.0332063697,
-0.0060470775,
0.0219663493,
0.0199149586,
-0.0237150528,
0.0142639615,
-0.0251878276,
-0.0115425382,
-0.0144337518,
0.0035488533,
-0.0185810607,
-0.0419649296,
0.0262619499,
-0.0103089958,
0.0359026976,
-0.0099528264,
0.0186612085,
0.0183300395,
-0.0340673625,
-0.0610305369,
-0.0005104378,
-0.0573654398,
0.0263249297,
-0.0158189218,
0.0760915726,
0.0145909209,
-0.0367151164,
-0.0086707454,
0.0011848282,
-0.0190969817,
0.0145382751,
-0.0650885403,
0.0021424566,
-0.003932049,
-0.006430794,
-0.0063170283,
0.0467337854,
-0.0016560612,
-0.0449977443,
-0.0196562614,
-0.0492041893,
-0.0134663582,
-0.0088954167,
0.0273956824,
-0.0347699188,
-0.0253917705,
-0.0182718262,
0.0094389524,
0.0381840542,
0.0313211195,
-0.0714207217,
-0.0276107881,
0.0376578905,
-0.0129152872,
-0.0605205931,
0.03386271,
0.0314854532,
-0.0067401016,
-0.0352480337,
0.0261795986,
-0.0401869006,
0.0563076288,
-0.0194539297,
0.0126033956,
-0.0425892062,
-0.0329770595,
-0.0174011011,
-0.0420951918,
0.0196106825,
-0.0055396068,
-0.0169208627,
0.0241041053,
-0.0048387311,
-0.0247407276,
0.0327151977,
-0.0635110512,
-0.0572564192,
-0.0604960769,
-0.0588457212,
-0.0224549919,
0.020636946,
-0.0477895364,
0.0182029624,
-0.0037377526,
-0.0248930622,
-0.0407707505,
0.0146806259,
0.0182773955,
-0.0202594157,
0.0453367718,
-0.018084025,
-0.0024683077,
-0.0299272239,
-0.0696182773,
0.0002079183,
0.0234604012,
-0.0444320887,
0.0233306699,
0.015441169,
-0.0360618122,
-0.0591031536,
0.0579352416,
0.0111654438,
0.044341363,
-0.0157045405,
0.0336397812,
-0.0346819162,
0.0092727998,
0.0398263894,
0.0335583128,
-0.0075785564,
-0.0309559945,
0.0334276818,
-0.0244572964,
0.0762492046,
-0.0358105749,
-0.0190308485,
0.0113724293,
0.0709051937,
0.0201502331,
-0.0001628481,
0.0091695087,
0.0828994662,
-0.0577819757,
0.0230897963,
0.0742360726,
-0.0426695496,
-0.0170828793,
-0.0119865881,
-0.0218419284,
0.0737329051,
0.0131975627,
0.014244087,
-0.054645516,
-0.0355821252,
0.0462687202,
0.025186561,
0.0314684436,
0.0267970264,
-0.0039317803,
-0.0950658917,
0.028191017,
0.0271118637,
-0.0377707668,
-0.0117988996,
-0.0265436862,
-0.0265504811,
-0.0490179285,
0.0652583838,
-0.0128474664,
0.0030634874,
-0.0285105612,
0.0308072641,
-0.0356132127,
-0.0517855324,
0.0274302382,
-0.0268140826,
0.0345254168,
0.0191709269,
0.0048578531,
0.0140331881,
-0.0236984044,
0.0132259093,
-0.0123499641,
0.0101634618,
-0.0186790265,
0.0104191173,
0.0261965878,
-0.0400669686,
0.0353926234,
0.0152941467,
-0.0202364903,
0.0238014311,
0.0339128152,
0.0409198031,
-0.001131598,
0.0038508237,
0.0507362634,
-0.0094287032,
0.023549309,
0.0522902496,
0.0242187977,
-0.0185417905,
-0.0124221602,
0.0090034576,
-0.0225646514,
-0.0291644186,
0.0029490567,
-0.0109615531,
-0.0119868731,
-0.0417901017,
0.0141293686,
-0.0099216066,
0.041724328,
0.0722042322,
0.02492854,
0.0208799243,
-0.0107645039,
0.0350276418,
-0.0515792109,
0.0062227841,
0.0034128255,
0.0138644055,
-0.0170684177,
-0.0377312452,
0.0341359228,
-0.029079631,
-0.0247666519,
0.0359226242,
-0.116554752,
-0.0875846222,
-0.0097992159,
0.0396732092,
0.0192370396,
0.0741482079,
-0.0311945546,
-0.0626735911,
0.0323825814,
-0.01089672,
-0.0865370333,
0.0094246641,
0.0846194178,
-0.0134826042,
-0.0110816378,
0.0526715219,
-0.0595251918,
0.018820826,
0.0110541377,
0.0291743595,
-0.0207715631,
-0.0360759646,
-0.0475967452,
0.0383226015,
0.0237293318,
-0.0309659522,
-0.0164636783,
-0.0361297391,
0.0456614979,
0.0093076406,
0.0300035998,
-0.0437379554,
0.0019146653,
-0.0078970445,
-0.0105362935,
0.0051086433,
0.0565084778,
0.026900636,
-0.0437228344,
-0.0428900868,
0.0747492015,
0.0157433208,
-0.0130105428,
0.0335928909,
0.0175653994,
-0.002778369,
0.0438820869,
0.0600700602,
-0.004460685,
-0.0329921953,
-0.017354019,
-0.0134122185,
0.0204769969,
-0.0279652271,
0.0166315716,
-0.0309795085,
-0.086958535,
-0.0072862883,
0.0463981554,
0.0441249311,
0.0097087855,
0.1098273769,
0.0235670246,
-0.0035876227,
-0.0201775413,
0.0164594781,
-0.012285945,
0.0338519141,
-0.0005394857,
0.0042642555,
-0.0220404565,
0.0170440543,
0.0649956241,
0.0006315669,
0.0452579819,
0.0023030683,
0.0577762052,
-0.0461542644,
-0.0597005598,
0.0064338711,
0.0238415524,
-0.0118319783,
-0.0251471326,
-0.0158827975,
-0.0784376338,
0.0167137608,
-0.0157375075,
-0.0143141374,
-0.0231312402,
-0.0071452623,
0.025260577,
-0.0137470532,
-0.0067865434,
0.0039794515,
-0.0883432552,
0.0368171632,
-0.009796042,
0.0616899543,
-6.685225187e-33,
-0.0011678578,
0.043797262,
0.0098958742,
0.007443781,
0.0022835813,
0.0065776701,
-0.020427458,
-0.0217054468,
-0.0105164172,
-0.0224025697,
-0.016630685,
-0.0245533139,
0.0618215688,
-0.0023166891,
0.0100119812,
0.0210081879,
0.1106528416,
0.012656766,
0.0030576042,
0.0331429094,
0.0073166369,
0.0595178306,
0.0481723323,
-0.050427895,
-0.0290197637,
-0.0073823757,
-0.0014053644,
-0.0402920283,
0.0207422432,
0.0335575826,
0.0009819671,
0.0805724189,
-0.0185801052,
-0.0267156493,
-0.0468580835,
-0.0162542015,
-0.104851447,
-0.0191134457,
0.0317990109,
0.0273450408,
0.01111037,
-0.0084254965,
0.045352634,
0.0236949325,
-0.0141910948,
-0.0209321864,
0.0055539333,
0.0014696919,
-0.0188009907,
-0.0371260084,
-0.0500549152,
0.0160743538,
-0.0083180722,
-0.0345906653,
0.097608164,
0.0451913849,
-0.0272518806,
-0.0586778745,
-0.0819664225,
0.0142884469,
-0.0045286808,
0.0411017351,
0.0619130358,
0.0440672748,
-0.0237992387,
0.016531691,
0.0487834774,
-0.0217724182,
0.0757130161,
-0.0307223462,
0.0629764795,
0.0564467274,
-0.0183943734,
0.0301956646,
0.0095223002,
-0.0330694355,
-0.0459572859,
-0.0361879952,
0.0651243031,
0.0204140469,
0.0254149791,
0.0124639971,
-0.028015567,
-0.0175874513,
-0.0475866608,
-0.0263982173,
-0.0387855247,
-0.0139086237,
0.0461237915,
0.013747192,
-0.01392568,
0.0356346183,
0.0808208585,
-0.0387326293,
0.0396142974,
0.0179108083,
-0.0151085705,
-0.0151961278,
-0.0035974027,
0.0287413802,
-0.0232484136,
-0.0483733453,
0.0047177821,
0.0409478731,
0.006162894,
-0.0207137521,
0.0196257364,
0.0347308479,
-0.0463440344,
-0.0092559336,
-0.0299373753,
0.0343237668,
0.0440126806,
0.0934988037,
0.0610444732,
-0.0129210623,
-0.0072764028,
0.0150437355,
-0.0048711477,
-0.0268247388,
-0.0035106151,
0.0255858973,
0.0278163794,
0.0181604717,
-0.0462620482,
0.0070067123,
0.0039504464,
-0.0644504204,
0.007164102,
-0.01750906,
-0.0183307491,
-0.0081845624,
2.945e-7,
-0.0375742801,
0.0229654871,
-0.0089760544,
-0.0224746279,
-0.0037205287,
0.0031572562,
-0.019904606,
-0.0363880955,
0.001231379,
0.0037056424,
-0.0322772115,
0.0393011458,
0.0930911303,
0.0272892825,
-0.0836717114,
-0.0249948427,
-0.0140779112,
0.0123325223,
-0.0154555254,
-0.0075868275,
-0.045814693,
0.087605074,
-0.0101793492,
-0.0364185013,
-0.0048296829,
-0.0182088856,
0.0039678174,
0.0010849142,
-0.0259156022,
0.0117692268,
-0.0084940037,
0.0123996567,
-0.0121605908,
0.0187562257,
-0.0261786971,
0.0331281759,
-0.0071414672,
0.0635914728,
-0.0160419196,
-0.0384578854,
0.0128366863,
0.0347555988,
-0.0222111233,
-0.032517083,
0.0558812767,
0.0151685365,
-0.0213450938,
-0.0257879198,
-0.0046928125,
-0.0163265374,
0.0253333189,
-0.0243529398,
0.0049800882,
0.0486295111,
0.0151064582,
-0.0502463207,
-0.0279980544,
-0.031287726,
0.0021760559,
0.0042157117,
-0.052825924,
-0.0427901596,
-0.0119070699,
-0.047329966,
-0.0051369574,
-0.0320678428,
0.0176875908,
2.531564379e-34,
0.0611922033,
-0.0115426462,
0.0245946608,
0.0407910123,
-0.0026208719,
-0.0508309007,
-0.0576529615,
0.0259606261,
-0.0117136957,
-0.0616906695,
-0.0603956133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01049v1 | Multi-dimensional data refining strategy for effective fine-tuning LLMs | 2023-11-02T07:50:43 | 2023-11-02T07:50:43 | Thanh Nguyen Ngoc, Quang Nhat Tran, Arthur Tang, Bao Nguyen, Thuy Nguyen, Thanh Pham | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data is a cornerstone for fine-tuning large language models, yet acquiring
suitable data remains challenging. Challenges encompassed data scarcity,
linguistic diversity, and domain-specific content. This paper presents lessons
learned while crawling and refining data tailored for fine-tuning Vietnamese
language models. Crafting such a dataset, while accounting for linguistic
intricacies and striking a balance between inclusivity and accuracy, demands
meticulous planning. Our paper presents a multidimensional strategy including
leveraging existing datasets in the English language and developing customized
data-crawling scripts with the assistance of generative AI tools. A fine-tuned
LLM model for the Vietnamese language, which was produced using resultant
datasets, demonstrated good performance while generating Vietnamese news
articles from prompts. The study offers practical solutions and guidance for
future fine-tuning models in languages like Vietnamese. | [
0.0432936661,
0.0466929376,
-0.0211690217,
0.0346785933,
-0.031735491,
0.006172705,
-0.0360619687,
0.0254811309,
-0.0019550272,
-0.0441500358,
-0.0409057029,
-0.0288534835,
0.0044692666,
0.0132005895,
0.0243361816,
-0.0220250972,
0.0355177745,
-0.0169842839,
-0.0240991097,
-0.0077286065,
-0.0070710494,
0.0084883003,
0.0130771529,
0.0301331282,
0.0164615735,
0.0065334355,
-0.0158582386,
0.0625083968,
-0.0023319104,
-0.0228014942,
0.0003090248,
0.06506975,
0.0161037352,
0.0082939193,
0.0000018476,
-0.0477390438,
-0.0256109666,
-0.0187204424,
-0.0061614555,
-0.0095267082,
0.0914357901,
-0.0418323278,
-0.0272161402,
0.0107442187,
-0.0336852558,
-0.0160627626,
0.0325254649,
-0.0038450856,
0.06543836,
0.1086804941,
0.0025636018,
-0.0193124861,
0.0177295506,
-0.0242355801,
0.0033632438,
-0.0176854022,
0.0289141387,
0.0369661748,
0.0488798507,
-0.0250790361,
-0.0266490132,
0.0241203904,
-0.000817291,
-0.0172817465,
-0.0098222615,
-0.0030173517,
-0.0240944624,
-0.0246091522,
0.0122011518,
0.0689375699,
-0.0135271754,
-0.0178764481,
0.008186521,
-0.0173930209,
0.0069571217,
-0.0079318332,
-0.0670349747,
0.0235324018,
-0.0098121297,
0.0270751454,
0.0471419021,
-0.0673747659,
0.0232876744,
0.0232451484,
-0.0240334477,
0.0189925358,
0.0181912072,
-0.0290417448,
-0.0304360781,
-0.020121647,
0.0208225008,
-0.0414847173,
-0.00251995,
0.0422131345,
-0.0230638795,
0.0337127782,
-0.0359996073,
-0.0113538438,
0.034998741,
-0.0230354555,
0.0556977689,
0.0270436574,
-0.0360759571,
0.0106372479,
0.0098725799,
0.0201094672,
-0.0132655958,
0.0340649262,
-0.0518316105,
-0.0092656501,
-0.0188339483,
-0.0046855127,
-0.0280838404,
0.0427726507,
-0.0218626484,
0.0118133081,
-0.0561832525,
0.0276892297,
0.0071862014,
0.0165394191,
0.0474745594,
-0.0357896052,
-0.0635177419,
-0.0189734194,
-0.0132062268,
-0.0121167814,
-0.0167657044,
0.0462335944,
0.0335305035,
-0.08293093,
0.008170017,
0.0197403133,
0.0240426194,
-0.0055480441,
0.015001501,
0.0640558302,
0.0048596705,
-0.0107698515,
-0.0867578462,
-0.0023863015,
0.0054807779,
-0.0451812409,
-0.012035816,
-0.101353623,
0.0266910624,
0.0080389902,
0.0052185524,
-0.0647682399,
-0.0178033281,
0.0017077674,
-0.0194302704,
0.0541150868,
-0.0372529179,
0.045659095,
0.024268318,
-0.0000405297,
0.0152617525,
0.1072515398,
0.0480629317,
0.0401263721,
0.0639771372,
-0.0268717818,
0.0229090676,
0.0592752397,
-0.0097887143,
0.0242877994,
-0.0273546223,
0.01432289,
-0.0466048233,
0.0369745158,
0.0150906797,
0.0342422649,
-0.0214058459,
0.0558757447,
0.0458406247,
0.0334623866,
0.0646627843,
0.0352142751,
0.0462280922,
-0.0104083568,
0.0133144679,
0.0354654938,
-0.0124884928,
0.0225820411,
-0.025835678,
0.0376227014,
0.0146678165,
0.0646333024,
-0.0098399557,
-0.063177824,
-0.0123947831,
0.0025573436,
-0.0066911071,
-0.0004264437,
0.0595862083,
0.0242947489,
-0.0350767337,
0.0278711878,
0.061253719,
-0.0382680409,
0.0288012624,
-0.0423190892,
0.0047960402,
0.0908122659,
0.0636160895,
-0.0239976756,
-0.0522549227,
0.0067905732,
0.0432332717,
0.0620277338,
0.0297449492,
-0.0366413444,
-0.0274624117,
-0.0674692765,
-0.0209014434,
0.0090917796,
0.013336746,
0.0326780789,
0.0141644869,
0.016572265,
0.015349362,
-0.0527333282,
-0.0608619973,
0.0366499722,
-0.0753014088,
-0.0033529464,
0.0171143655,
0.0112781432,
0.0254163332,
0.0263751037,
0.0005633869,
0.0015150872,
0.029951999,
-0.0277779978,
0.0295902863,
-0.0211043712,
0.034306623,
0.0114404364,
0.0332602262,
-0.0434872024,
0.0203161333,
0.0059745107,
-0.0622655936,
-0.0385572165,
-0.0211198125,
0.0090176389,
-0.0086277993,
-0.071201928,
0.0363174565,
-0.0354512148,
0.0209262352,
-0.0551005714,
0.0423250422,
-0.019497212,
0.0346036479,
0.0668549165,
0.0160113052,
0.0188697744,
-0.0554152243,
0.000246032,
0.0395035483,
0.005493897,
0.0468871929,
0.008086103,
0.0425658226,
-0.0394817479,
-0.0607740693,
-0.0597553924,
0.0224461555,
-0.0245527718,
0.017384991,
0.027129408,
-0.0027212328,
-0.0387528092,
0.0105439201,
-0.0340671949,
-0.0034095591,
0.0504668355,
0.0120599065,
0.0273083299,
0.0022639264,
-0.0113711413,
-0.0617176108,
-0.0039436617,
0.0308983102,
-0.0110107092,
-0.0161893684,
-0.0287846103,
-0.0662661716,
0.0331951417,
-0.0451918952,
-0.0012875199,
-0.0159851741,
-0.0576317534,
-0.0113122519,
-0.0265250318,
0.0110013746,
0.0377056785,
0.0004589834,
0.0414316989,
0.0360146724,
-0.0399653278,
-0.0521437414,
-0.0105190203,
-0.0228346195,
-0.0088540586,
-0.0492656678,
-0.0442049168,
0.004302904,
0.0299041048,
0.0093446681,
0.0094351172,
-0.0345812291,
0.016197633,
-0.0146942073,
0.0000824263,
0.0258975886,
0.0399165414,
-0.0282308497,
0.067639105,
-0.0171671826,
-0.0571992546,
0.0610628165,
-0.0179917589,
0.0248881597,
-0.0084096445,
-0.0252743401,
-0.0626978949,
0.0372908004,
-0.0207379386,
0.0037014168,
-0.0244772602,
-0.0136096291,
-0.072996065,
0.0400859416,
0.0289646648,
-0.0611104295,
0.0966871679,
-0.0236655045,
0.0065163998,
-0.0331250578,
-0.0247089993,
-0.0451899655,
-0.0041571287,
0.0061378898,
-0.0070392922,
0.0451313555,
0.0030533711,
-0.0014099419,
0.0155193806,
-0.0152598424,
0.0047670584,
-0.0160159431,
-0.0066104289,
-0.0271372553,
0.028867485,
0.0534440354,
0.0140175596,
-0.0021262919,
-0.0101791266,
0.0344272293,
-0.0211752299,
-0.0230021924,
-0.0110996319,
-0.0140622351,
0.0269708503,
0.0616366044,
-0.0396113172,
-0.0155171249,
0.0188299548,
0.0071213418,
-0.0492086299,
-0.0113104098,
0.1080018654,
0.0079443026,
-0.039851822,
0.0064476901,
-0.015044963,
0.0210250802,
0.0305711087,
0.0364010558,
-0.0939817652,
0.0113883233,
0.0112408437,
0.0401297435,
0.0003701451,
-0.0069986,
-0.0276716147,
-0.1361765265,
0.0621543601,
0.0165327378,
-0.0032836252,
-0.0572016649,
-0.0374680571,
0.0001850848,
-0.0173480269,
0.0333624408,
0.0203828532,
-0.0349080786,
-0.0114741726,
0.0098529411,
-0.0101514366,
-0.1076099202,
-0.0094287787,
-0.0187568311,
0.048433315,
0.0447754562,
0.0359402485,
-0.0149027696,
-0.0019446273,
0.0579613149,
0.0121411523,
0.0026180281,
-0.0266842525,
0.0066359509,
0.0189484637,
-0.0065326183,
0.0003773666,
0.015291892,
-0.0146233253,
-0.0065512951,
0.0017869591,
0.0649248958,
-0.037556909,
0.0116238268,
0.0015605405,
-0.0157304462,
-0.001985478,
0.0627269372,
0.0486570932,
-0.0337792337,
0.0104979184,
-0.0426512994,
-0.0228009503,
-0.0530988649,
-0.0170938652,
0.0404143445,
-0.0736782178,
-0.0090581579,
-0.0722751245,
-0.0523953922,
0.0242847577,
0.0205818564,
0.0441925339,
0.0346611775,
-0.004860186,
-0.0152290603,
-0.0326986052,
-0.0015822855,
-0.0362118855,
-0.0081459992,
-0.06077113,
-0.0430034548,
0.0394131839,
-0.0670764446,
0.0228328388,
-0.0096279886,
-0.0850780159,
-0.0690010935,
0.0127279973,
0.0264854692,
0.0287996586,
0.0572768711,
-0.0009696999,
-0.0641150922,
0.0051853964,
0.0716199279,
-0.0127432635,
-0.0082032727,
0.0023777976,
0.0101737082,
-0.0125035355,
0.0534559675,
-0.071808964,
0.0226283967,
0.0181674622,
0.0276769046,
-0.0141028883,
-0.0745814517,
0.0262295734,
0.0429041423,
-0.0036917743,
-0.0523305498,
-0.0363405831,
-0.0863998085,
0.020748971,
-0.0353570022,
-0.0226839464,
-0.0296441913,
-0.0155676519,
0.0233043544,
-0.0344445817,
-0.0198412146,
0.0138546759,
-0.0275450144,
0.0316173062,
-0.0726975873,
0.0571044162,
-0.0310158972,
0.0316440128,
0.0495773889,
0.0135074668,
0.0042801495,
0.0317105912,
-0.0145491287,
0.0333616883,
-0.0183476806,
0.0435202569,
0.0039644404,
0.0271665286,
-0.0146269649,
0.0521033481,
-0.0098466901,
-0.0459108129,
-0.0452289842,
0.0117576011,
0.0959370285,
-0.0032027229,
0.0528685488,
-0.0244714972,
-0.017691981,
-0.0226281006,
0.0415278263,
0.03655608,
-0.0196876563,
0.0187911149,
0.0160135664,
-0.0320685059,
-0.0096928654,
0.0912592635,
-0.0086419545,
0.0548883006,
0.0006758333,
0.0122723076,
-0.035186518,
-0.0292499531,
0.0290023163,
-0.0151356142,
-0.0201711748,
-0.050666213,
-0.0616035126,
-0.0584048666,
-0.0091935294,
0.0128095457,
-0.0020728558,
-0.0002275618,
0.0106313163,
0.0567572229,
0.0186941158,
0.0604653209,
-0.0559367649,
-0.0218218341,
-0.0386705287,
-0.0299642701,
0.040430598,
-6.212001283e-33,
-0.057887122,
-0.0263440255,
0.0417222567,
0.0087205013,
-0.016996799,
-0.0164074227,
-0.0298386458,
-0.0208120737,
-0.0094733937,
-0.0403999053,
-0.035914477,
-0.0079034008,
0.0258469768,
0.0049151951,
0.0252580419,
0.0000952216,
0.0208512247,
0.0180235114,
-0.0138588976,
-0.0073246597,
0.0009789889,
0.0305929352,
0.059352681,
-0.0244036131,
0.02282173,
-0.0089278435,
-0.0244797617,
0.0222624633,
0.0046808319,
0.0702729747,
0.0017357664,
0.0466379151,
0.0385087281,
-0.0197678562,
-0.0443320796,
-0.0360850841,
-0.0740093142,
-0.0188480839,
0.0385078415,
0.0191624183,
0.0240155589,
-0.0630293936,
0.0348715484,
-0.0312075373,
-0.0173208471,
0.020860929,
0.0281576794,
-0.0804125965,
-0.0151749514,
-0.0453584976,
-0.0604036078,
0.0398624539,
0.007553074,
-0.0138640525,
0.0316999517,
0.0056548896,
-0.0010638685,
0.0369132608,
-0.0576607771,
0.0319354497,
0.0534227677,
0.0491408408,
0.1154557243,
0.0183546878,
0.0148033295,
0.0341176689,
0.0207339581,
0.0339258388,
0.0198122207,
0.0040568956,
0.0381900221,
0.0671327338,
-0.014790589,
0.0529025085,
0.0142849013,
-0.0493771769,
-0.0478709377,
0.0526650883,
-0.007533743,
0.0037630661,
0.0036458177,
0.0151347248,
-0.0039218455,
-0.0242559351,
-0.0174530782,
-0.0180672519,
-0.0293433629,
-0.0540595949,
0.0138844047,
0.0155133819,
-0.0183236618,
-0.0265816338,
0.0279458053,
-0.0520267561,
-0.0127192289,
-0.007425732,
-0.0557361916,
0.0180930644,
-0.0187445004,
-0.0052924817,
-0.0241165049,
-0.0695477203,
0.0158559661,
-0.0141629726,
0.0111219669,
0.025119625,
0.0138168987,
0.0320749804,
-0.056044694,
0.0263802875,
-0.0345880128,
0.0276032928,
0.0212542806,
0.0184150394,
0.0107989376,
-0.0105307996,
-0.0095074605,
0.0481816903,
0.0694509745,
-0.0076198364,
-0.0145904357,
-0.0005667513,
-0.0050732181,
0.0128853098,
-0.034711875,
0.0341016874,
-0.0279162899,
0.0175056458,
0.0356477238,
-0.0027432851,
-0.0146050444,
-0.0008648813,
2.561e-7,
0.0543717593,
0.0511799715,
0.0420307592,
0.0659250692,
-0.0027127191,
-0.0292875078,
-0.0466890857,
-0.0261200387,
0.0028488785,
-0.0112588499,
0.0448807366,
0.0254438613,
0.075799264,
0.0256493688,
-0.0865377933,
0.0582882464,
-0.017765943,
0.0064632865,
-0.0499483235,
-0.0266448203,
0.0059382664,
0.0827398375,
-0.0381687284,
-0.0242135245,
-0.0256879404,
-0.0226809364,
0.0332640298,
-0.0446999967,
-0.0270437282,
0.072961688,
0.0696150064,
0.0207266882,
-0.0066299685,
-0.0421086811,
-0.0352491327,
0.0101849642,
-0.005857443,
0.0600121319,
0.0139801092,
-0.0006386883,
0.0260070395,
-0.0524840727,
-0.0145776458,
-0.0555909052,
0.0523468815,
0.0042501488,
-0.0077539948,
-0.0386096686,
0.0094761709,
0.0084269876,
-0.006561012,
-0.0752178058,
-0.0165427569,
0.04441249,
0.0242264755,
-0.0132968659,
-0.0115206363,
-0.0126112262,
-0.041418653,
0.0025186704,
-0.0250010118,
-0.05248769,
-0.0061585638,
-0.0029433214,
0.0072314059,
-0.0480047464,
0.025255207,
2.499319788e-34,
0.042822428,
-0.0050749457,
-0.0016014507,
0.0200798567,
0.0347913913,
-0.0155638363,
-0.0344087817,
0.034854155,
-0.0172667839,
-0.0619808845,
-0.0268130172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01041v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01041v3 | Learn to Refuse: Making Large Language Models More Controllable and Reliable through Knowledge Scope Limitation and Refusal Mechanism | 2023-11-02T07:20:49 | 2024-05-29T09:19:35 | Lang Cao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive language
understanding and generation capabilities, enabling them to answer a wide range
of questions across various domains. However, these models are not flawless and
often produce responses that contain errors or misinformation. These
inaccuracies, commonly referred to as hallucinations, render LLMs unreliable
and even unusable in many scenarios. In this paper, our focus is on mitigating
the issue of hallucination in LLMs, particularly in the context of
question-answering. Instead of attempting to answer all questions, we explore a
refusal mechanism that instructs LLMs to refuse to answer challenging questions
in order to avoid errors. We then propose a simple yet effective solution
called Learn to Refuse (L2R), which incorporates the refusal mechanism to
enable LLMs to recognize and refuse to answer questions that they find
difficult to address. To achieve this, we utilize a structured knowledge base
to represent all the LLM's understanding of the world, enabling it to provide
traceable gold knowledge. This knowledge base is separate from the LLM and
initially empty. It can be filled with validated knowledge and progressively
expanded. When an LLM encounters questions outside its domain, the system
recognizes its knowledge scope and determines whether it can answer the
question independently. Additionally, we introduce a method for automatically
and efficiently expanding the knowledge base of LLMs. Through qualitative and
quantitative analysis, we demonstrate that our approach enhances the
controllability and reliability of LLMs. | [
0.0797500983,
0.0453134105,
-0.0253930464,
0.0423144475,
-0.0269998759,
0.0238731466,
-0.0154896211,
-0.0041870927,
0.0444576107,
-0.0316413119,
-0.000165268,
-0.0483885258,
-0.0592348687,
0.0177526064,
0.0146096032,
-0.0391964689,
0.0420619771,
-0.0697130188,
0.0021100887,
-0.0503742434,
-0.0067119407,
0.0021671255,
-0.0029929366,
0.0218412783,
0.0025916786,
-0.0286857802,
-0.0083228443,
-0.0204666536,
-0.0271779224,
-0.0074856519,
0.018253807,
0.0314543024,
0.0098730819,
0.0526128262,
0.0000023937,
-0.0690156147,
-0.0301472135,
-0.0026955528,
-0.0422898456,
-0.0247784536,
-0.0161788091,
0.0043295757,
0.0067405356,
0.0204978678,
-0.0643431768,
0.0108482325,
0.031575188,
0.0614916384,
0.0812782869,
0.0516024865,
0.029468501,
-0.003158137,
0.0055877585,
0.0061422358,
0.0447109304,
-0.0735845491,
0.0303500779,
0.0581717007,
0.0360614844,
-0.0137852086,
-0.0354871079,
0.0528221652,
0.0196189433,
-0.0191492233,
-0.0127166072,
-0.0040295185,
-0.0436024331,
-0.0290022939,
0.0007738088,
0.0532173105,
0.0007163352,
-0.0466141514,
0.0143815586,
0.0115115009,
-0.0019802931,
0.0527623855,
-0.0642430782,
0.0485833324,
-0.0099113239,
-0.0277372096,
-0.0252941772,
-0.0039287987,
0.0246668346,
0.0132759567,
-0.0273697153,
0.0927541107,
0.0069157607,
-0.0434947275,
-0.004451863,
0.0130935144,
0.0036607638,
-0.0833423436,
-0.0011484422,
0.0886543691,
-0.0683528408,
0.0334409699,
-0.0127696553,
0.0360484086,
0.0574292168,
-0.0507314317,
0.0001761132,
-0.0068584168,
-0.0159144476,
0.065977037,
-0.0125838965,
0.0184142794,
-0.0538944118,
0.0130763827,
-0.0220603906,
-0.0342010558,
-0.0570912957,
-0.0402299725,
-0.0407975763,
0.0436343551,
-0.0027741317,
0.0052017802,
0.0215492602,
0.049945958,
-0.0468941666,
0.0530379675,
-0.0265793577,
0.026729688,
0.0027174582,
-0.0493032001,
-0.0645699278,
0.007845656,
-0.055404596,
0.0073091723,
0.0051062894,
-0.064685829,
-0.0024041918,
0.010726002,
-0.0151745416,
0.0104069663,
0.0124042854,
0.074661091,
0.0268210042,
0.0285529122,
-0.0366282873,
-0.0594129078,
-0.0169221815,
-0.0700468421,
0.0247645676,
-0.0723712817,
0.0009044061,
0.0193285961,
-0.0236382876,
-0.0450415425,
0.0214024018,
0.0161076561,
-0.0111198146,
0.0590760931,
-0.0239303578,
0.0140719237,
0.0616277717,
0.0440422557,
-0.0336575434,
0.0774587989,
0.0094034011,
0.0132270157,
0.0478284024,
0.0003404294,
0.0666996986,
0.0014574041,
0.0053326096,
0.0198975485,
-0.0320710912,
0.0348387808,
0.0148987258,
-0.0027747091,
-0.0140159307,
0.0406631306,
-0.0007436299,
-0.0079731485,
0.0444135703,
0.0161086638,
-0.0423045233,
0.0337111168,
0.0462654755,
-0.0166586507,
0.0089417864,
0.0307520013,
-0.0393732525,
0.0426512063,
-0.05467939,
-0.0149255265,
0.015208778,
0.0093442546,
-0.0301647745,
-0.0506154262,
0.0113987401,
0.0081453584,
0.0045832698,
0.0568616018,
0.0355606489,
0.0248046033,
0.0004282225,
0.0539425611,
0.0226016082,
-0.0281396285,
0.0140889054,
-0.055574432,
0.0655321255,
0.0438438728,
0.0684162378,
-0.0671043769,
-0.0201900452,
-0.0157051906,
0.0388016477,
0.0596612245,
0.0548668616,
-0.0132945077,
-0.0151168397,
-0.0208278522,
-0.0369747989,
0.0013157261,
0.0132426815,
0.0014698836,
-0.0011576202,
0.0021214311,
-0.0029058591,
-0.057884302,
-0.0218921192,
0.0189253353,
-0.0260885879,
-0.0326792561,
-0.0256017949,
-0.0133093931,
0.0278403442,
0.0113525297,
0.0144962342,
0.0370450616,
0.0260054898,
-0.0369476788,
-0.0718513802,
-0.0203358792,
-0.0426284745,
-0.0017635694,
0.0396704078,
-0.037592452,
-0.0280676913,
0.0002619056,
-0.0172252692,
-0.0466579832,
0.0304222926,
-0.0461814068,
0.0631453916,
-0.03432291,
0.0060335635,
-0.005527054,
-0.0167463738,
-0.0273552444,
0.0717499703,
0.0008098956,
0.0256711096,
0.0202275049,
-0.0018358559,
0.0043072179,
-0.0153062036,
-0.0280954391,
0.0056760455,
-0.0033186418,
0.0311254356,
0.0411052853,
-0.0345221087,
-0.0656231716,
-0.0166282356,
-0.067787528,
0.0046432451,
-0.0071512968,
0.0035265291,
0.0065536001,
-0.0121510122,
0.0017196068,
-0.0367073454,
-0.0579128526,
0.0061831442,
0.0430677682,
0.0077287359,
0.0073064594,
0.0191321019,
-0.0213876404,
-0.0099739479,
0.0250865761,
-0.0008619872,
0.0094427103,
-0.0115090292,
0.0039680786,
-0.0684910268,
0.0262651164,
-0.0716014579,
0.0532400608,
0.0047443598,
-0.0057996502,
0.0096398573,
-0.0284408275,
-0.0300816279,
0.0343179144,
0.0074808961,
0.0047335885,
0.0707315803,
-0.0259837937,
-0.0529502369,
0.0167831071,
0.0019425685,
-0.0174980573,
-0.022964742,
-0.0206225738,
0.0051928135,
0.0540251397,
0.0199141689,
-0.0026345071,
-0.0532090664,
0.0741248876,
-0.036460571,
-0.0332538188,
-0.0111555122,
-0.0194140356,
-0.0188624617,
0.0632291958,
-0.0121649997,
-0.0259979554,
0.071769163,
-0.014286112,
0.015061128,
-0.0173203144,
0.0036590467,
-0.0141455,
0.0675286353,
-0.0040521622,
0.0350008346,
0.0398751758,
0.0105797024,
-0.0557821356,
-0.0146389315,
0.0170208476,
-0.0540897585,
0.0510368422,
-0.0821475387,
0.0108160069,
0.0211033337,
-0.0161282737,
-0.083412528,
-0.0024456312,
-0.0362134613,
-0.0036153998,
-0.0476040989,
0.0121137397,
-0.0345555805,
-0.0258175526,
0.0393791832,
-0.0049446924,
-0.0169521514,
-0.0207361653,
-0.0285086539,
0.0188040007,
0.0793965012,
0.0370999575,
0.0366949216,
-0.0380561724,
0.0406534746,
0.0746461973,
-0.0033533233,
0.0266862605,
0.0340498537,
-0.0101533318,
0.0279138405,
-0.0157267787,
-0.0268893372,
0.016555937,
0.0479932912,
-0.0592788383,
-0.0528691895,
0.1009639055,
0.0579737127,
-0.03125038,
-0.0019121473,
-0.0766963884,
0.0335126519,
0.0389028862,
0.0475175083,
-0.0687978044,
-0.0081171729,
-0.0084455051,
0.0236652326,
-0.0368657038,
-0.0432806276,
-0.0227604453,
-0.1255987287,
0.0265293065,
0.0060812291,
-0.0302588306,
-0.0362788551,
0.0070721884,
-0.0110843964,
0.0442142226,
0.0001075461,
0.0080357734,
0.0096696662,
-0.0277105402,
0.0339867547,
-0.0331903286,
-0.0238746367,
0.04781707,
-0.0029883578,
0.0746884421,
0.0666459948,
0.008658234,
-0.0072951298,
-0.0300043896,
-0.0046998342,
-0.0204685107,
-0.0013446965,
-0.0010709813,
0.0020293198,
0.0419536568,
-0.015694892,
-0.0089956699,
0.0134220729,
-0.0273631625,
-0.0047877962,
0.0689535663,
0.1305422932,
-0.0412157997,
-0.0311361942,
-0.0168446731,
0.0161394589,
0.0202872977,
0.085549444,
0.0247069392,
-0.0363472588,
-0.0330126584,
-0.0480287597,
-0.0242494475,
-0.0316610262,
-0.0258662757,
0.0557016879,
0.0160370339,
0.0377271175,
-0.0810534209,
-0.0127210878,
0.0219551064,
0.0374373086,
0.0054396647,
0.0123805124,
0.0304111242,
-0.0158131346,
0.0076044612,
-0.0239391401,
-0.0755108595,
-0.004090705,
-0.0347661488,
-0.0133780502,
0.0070062145,
-0.0369289741,
0.0021440971,
0.0099526774,
-0.033517506,
-0.0643959418,
0.0253387224,
0.0699029639,
0.0389058553,
0.0172713082,
-0.0153859342,
-0.0688107088,
0.040291626,
-0.0004204522,
-0.0185250361,
0.0132172266,
0.0192621108,
0.0250000525,
-0.0115491776,
0.0455366597,
-0.0789536461,
0.0219699573,
0.0184094384,
0.0201250259,
-0.0611915961,
-0.0124619287,
0.036830578,
-0.0080714133,
-0.0604622476,
0.005707609,
-0.0070055872,
0.0060439603,
0.024784416,
-0.0305827558,
-0.0249134451,
-0.0389052108,
0.0204025935,
-0.0003755117,
-0.0633409619,
0.0433063507,
-0.0370766334,
-0.0398229137,
0.0089429198,
-0.0317091532,
-0.0003504088,
0.032763578,
0.0141063593,
0.0351541787,
-0.0111246835,
-0.0243083183,
-0.0083625754,
0.023195168,
0.0517221913,
0.0218261201,
0.0883052647,
0.0181636568,
-0.0223988052,
-0.0252657291,
-0.0159605723,
-0.0643204004,
-0.1187484935,
0.0238459595,
0.0451338813,
0.0440974198,
0.013320039,
0.0264286771,
-0.0252869166,
-0.007635891,
-0.0041698823,
-0.0110440385,
0.067717813,
-0.0425193608,
0.0388649441,
0.0400360897,
-0.0076907356,
-0.0047460147,
0.0738741159,
0.001096429,
0.062808305,
-0.0168598127,
0.0019286547,
-0.0515960827,
-0.0340553485,
-0.0051882574,
-0.0143692372,
-0.0233623255,
0.0228280742,
-0.0917496234,
-0.0791891664,
-0.0183833148,
0.0176343322,
-0.0065936097,
-0.0333638154,
0.0304821637,
0.046257738,
0.0367319323,
-0.0223664772,
-0.047083322,
0.0458468683,
0.0137750357,
0.0201084688,
-0.0047499533,
-7.105887595e-33,
-0.0248267855,
-0.0639188886,
0.0315711983,
-0.0517864227,
0.0004383682,
-0.0182366855,
-0.0373072289,
0.0025939688,
-0.0136837028,
0.0221718512,
-0.0052709044,
0.0026141086,
-0.0023831937,
0.0331487209,
0.0321453698,
-0.0383298062,
0.0208438002,
0.0200168565,
-0.0308996812,
0.0479456484,
0.0637090057,
0.0045421985,
0.0099895112,
-0.058504872,
0.0537864119,
-0.0336969383,
-0.0137515664,
0.0521163717,
-0.0272670146,
0.0529592596,
-0.0176922437,
0.0482894741,
0.0255823359,
-0.0564587079,
-0.0266806856,
0.0238876101,
-0.0295206178,
-0.0509041771,
0.0390895419,
-0.0125926323,
-0.0197551828,
-0.0096876062,
0.0340120494,
-0.0088579915,
0.0411539301,
-0.001522787,
0.0280135833,
-0.029802775,
-0.0207457449,
-0.0172345825,
-0.0619555749,
0.0145348944,
0.0010498667,
-0.0318913832,
-0.0189570338,
0.0368268043,
-0.0001155986,
-0.0382203571,
-0.0203219838,
0.0025261384,
0.0189886484,
0.0000888158,
0.0463105217,
-0.0196166094,
-0.0029694573,
0.0424620658,
-0.0273583774,
0.0111447899,
-0.0218169745,
-0.0343338512,
-0.0306406487,
0.041274108,
0.0434696637,
0.0313482136,
-0.0023633102,
-0.0010735834,
-0.0577073954,
-0.0032748075,
-0.0089348285,
0.0574187748,
0.0295722764,
-0.0287101828,
-0.0200323593,
-0.009790496,
-0.028965218,
0.014398423,
-0.0348238312,
-0.0178431105,
0.0471494831,
0.0055396175,
-0.0376129858,
-0.0358210653,
0.0184796583,
-0.0739394054,
-0.0089801764,
0.0291668251,
0.0156730693,
0.002487083,
0.0147231724,
0.0238784738,
-0.0034338061,
-0.0122493766,
-0.0020301992,
-0.0434849411,
0.0109892748,
0.0318565033,
0.0090662073,
0.0084043089,
-0.0580195002,
0.0180351194,
-0.0572276562,
0.043701157,
-0.006881007,
-0.0082828123,
0.0226327181,
0.0061466736,
-0.0053012441,
0.0109193288,
0.0078291679,
-0.0398342162,
-0.0331060439,
0.0363472216,
-0.0132579012,
0.0216120165,
-0.0578970313,
-0.0230683871,
-0.039883323,
0.0263486579,
0.0212684479,
-0.0552450828,
-0.0044384487,
-0.0019040403,
3.075e-7,
0.0211795941,
0.0326716863,
0.0071460893,
0.0459295958,
0.0460968204,
0.036174342,
-0.0030413726,
0.0120277489,
0.0043226271,
-0.0454910174,
-0.0198275261,
0.013075172,
0.0239497516,
0.0601854883,
-0.0892022103,
-0.0030579616,
-0.022295136,
-0.0024250941,
-0.0324700512,
-0.0072952951,
0.0677202344,
0.0559586324,
-0.0002581637,
-0.0056497576,
-0.0110451374,
-0.0415048972,
0.0596735924,
0.0153430961,
0.0184242353,
0.0245027896,
0.04908989,
0.0122074969,
0.0301670916,
0.0412113629,
-0.0257496964,
-0.0030490996,
-0.0393602774,
0.0535176098,
0.0055380962,
-0.0395863689,
-0.0210833922,
-0.0398668088,
0.0529316701,
-0.0908296481,
0.0864693001,
-0.0031009945,
0.0013059913,
-0.00245314,
0.0116952276,
-0.0430784635,
-0.0238929819,
-0.0018743272,
-0.0398860425,
0.0064312741,
0.0036966312,
0.0104082767,
0.0322979167,
-0.0638802126,
-0.0056264177,
-0.0045880559,
-0.038274698,
-0.0407866277,
0.0011082087,
-0.0148304161,
-0.0138957351,
-0.0723877773,
0.0299137831,
2.86084055e-34,
0.0296624769,
0.018988438,
0.0293440763,
0.0294356551,
0.0301322322,
0.0047242707,
-0.0059571303,
0.0211360045,
0.0505556278,
-0.0397978947,
-0.0205806289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01036v1 | ATHENA: Mathematical Reasoning with Thought Expansion | 2023-11-02T07:03:25 | 2023-11-02T07:03:25 | JB. Kim, Hazel Kim, Joonghyuk Hahn, Yo-Sub Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.3; F.4.1 | Solving math word problems depends on how to articulate the problems, the
lens through which models view human linguistic expressions. Real-world
settings count on such a method even more due to the diverse practices of the
same mathematical operations. Earlier works constrain available thinking
processes by limited prediction strategies without considering their
significance in acquiring mathematical knowledge. We introduce Attention-based
THought Expansion Network Architecture (ATHENA) to tackle the challenges of
real-world practices by mimicking human thought expansion mechanisms in the
form of neural network propagation. A thought expansion recurrently generates
the candidates carrying the thoughts of possible math expressions driven from
the previous step and yields reasonable thoughts by selecting the valid
pathways to the goal. Our experiments show that ATHENA achieves a new
state-of-the-art stage toward the ideal model that is compelling in variant
questions even when the informativeness in training examples is restricted. | [
-0.0238471963,
0.0593086742,
-0.0101583255,
0.030105358,
-0.0340635404,
-0.0135163879,
0.0066898954,
-0.0225201678,
-0.0497032329,
0.0367985927,
0.0052045048,
-0.0450775027,
0.0086261947,
0.0332101248,
0.060340941,
-0.016482085,
0.0221490543,
-0.0314471424,
-0.0232683327,
0.0062140771,
-0.0237195939,
-0.0224332195,
-0.0266208109,
0.016116878,
-0.0464846492,
-0.0534990095,
-0.013192079,
-0.0462949686,
0.0110108443,
-0.0232573692,
-0.0217190478,
0.0142076546,
0.0041093458,
0.0361915454,
0.0000021674,
-0.0345009044,
0.0237819012,
-0.0249660425,
-0.0408067927,
-0.0371364281,
-0.023410229,
0.0435488522,
0.0535116903,
0.0094232904,
-0.0695352107,
0.0353101306,
0.0217442643,
0.0222956203,
0.051472526,
0.0232563242,
-0.0036503486,
-0.0294602234,
0.0123486528,
-0.0362091362,
0.0599300936,
-0.0719563141,
0.018933814,
-0.025645338,
0.0354999788,
0.0153673887,
-0.0247987434,
0.0532396846,
0.0711366311,
-0.0041195475,
0.0420979746,
0.0274055973,
0.0049389508,
-0.0027826228,
0.0051199868,
0.0803117752,
0.0034233625,
-0.0208964273,
-0.0217645299,
-0.0230115056,
0.0087757986,
0.0270872023,
-0.0537189431,
-0.0111559974,
-0.0065300777,
-0.0306599196,
-0.0199916046,
0.036623463,
0.0102841398,
0.0352665223,
-0.0244787354,
0.0605662353,
-0.0138821239,
-0.0370694324,
0.0218401253,
-0.0076822196,
-0.0751211047,
-0.0308168735,
0.0562997013,
0.0415595099,
0.0342036299,
0.0219169557,
-0.0081966091,
-0.0873267055,
-0.0526610687,
-0.016392637,
0.0663973615,
0.0938726515,
0.0227446593,
0.0279399808,
-0.0412924886,
0.0058931638,
-0.043114502,
0.002418865,
-0.0599622205,
0.0353608653,
-0.030270312,
-0.0192389339,
-0.0424385518,
0.0585129373,
0.013593927,
-0.0146931298,
-0.041253116,
0.0135540785,
-0.032909181,
-0.0246406421,
0.0066338363,
0.0236908402,
0.015180124,
-0.0288798735,
-0.0766172707,
0.0089769466,
-0.0834459066,
0.0208176356,
0.0262047704,
-0.0062666978,
-0.0579073541,
0.0109509267,
-0.0082431063,
-0.0145445522,
0.0106508881,
0.0631452128,
-0.0115734236,
0.0044740438,
-0.0010708673,
-0.0357329249,
0.0310668387,
-0.0458431095,
0.0226175264,
-0.067866005,
0.0421111993,
0.0064495308,
-0.0561617352,
-0.0512223765,
0.0109524969,
0.0315742493,
-0.0130829234,
0.0462918878,
-0.0218465589,
0.0067617428,
0.0532617643,
-0.0103817144,
-0.0378830135,
0.0292653404,
0.0773880035,
-0.0189215168,
-0.0144579289,
-0.003490065,
0.0327244364,
0.0284226276,
0.0465580411,
-0.029393604,
0.0007396565,
0.0191115905,
-0.0297294315,
0.0974877253,
-0.0285820123,
0.0167639088,
-0.0497619621,
-0.0144110797,
0.0071051302,
0.076851964,
-0.025325913,
0.0703341886,
0.0310644209,
-0.0379862413,
0.0127779059,
-0.0047856374,
-0.0524309948,
0.0394678377,
0.0022801091,
-0.0081208721,
-0.0207501054,
-0.0060030674,
-0.0455191955,
-0.0669530109,
0.0100549497,
0.026075922,
0.025456395,
-0.0011872236,
0.0262591112,
0.0126628,
0.01920758,
0.0901274383,
-0.0062331008,
-0.0308091789,
-0.0079095922,
-0.0228123516,
0.0305017643,
-0.0038591039,
0.0642482415,
-0.0634905696,
-0.0399410836,
-0.0265134834,
0.0133109652,
0.0210724175,
0.0256742295,
0.0203794688,
-0.0504856221,
-0.0514857918,
0.0114749242,
0.0221127979,
-0.0128420927,
-0.0196737014,
0.0093084658,
0.0048820572,
0.0260656755,
0.0024929936,
-0.0224653054,
0.0371856876,
-0.0178447347,
-0.0243073758,
0.0222414043,
0.0063150604,
-0.0338536501,
0.0049492163,
0.0253203996,
0.0615868308,
-0.0008636435,
-0.0444124416,
-0.0088614644,
0.0083832247,
-0.1083291546,
-0.0202706195,
0.0475367978,
-0.0677333251,
-0.0042111101,
-0.0117950253,
-0.0284240637,
-0.0279467199,
0.0703978017,
-0.0732429177,
0.0076165227,
-0.0044683907,
0.0089446986,
0.0224644635,
-0.0021581079,
0.0074413847,
0.0746881664,
-0.0230448507,
0.0214857832,
0.0188855492,
-0.0398014672,
-0.0233438499,
-0.0035168072,
0.0429274477,
-0.0745790303,
-0.0264236778,
-0.0021005755,
-0.0291512664,
0.0137563571,
-0.0417988375,
0.0102311084,
0.013568298,
-0.0066607455,
-0.0029338789,
0.0581445582,
0.0102201952,
0.0017868421,
0.0028612793,
-0.0279543102,
-0.0515186377,
0.0327383727,
-0.0250956211,
-0.0156407598,
0.0610720888,
-0.014479544,
0.012031869,
-0.017769793,
-0.0379097722,
-0.0421690978,
0.06551902,
0.025222417,
0.0093142716,
-0.01151847,
0.0317067355,
-0.0752930567,
0.0085389232,
-0.0193484891,
0.0152870473,
0.0107084149,
-0.0223915409,
-0.0089392979,
0.0636202618,
0.0038516468,
-0.041155003,
0.0136419041,
0.0049883747,
-0.0437572189,
0.0349313878,
-0.0298961923,
0.0453167111,
0.0320732668,
0.041545134,
-0.0220426638,
0.0180909522,
-0.0064852335,
-0.0151619371,
-0.0335757174,
0.076913394,
0.0019455515,
-0.0258070584,
-0.0344773307,
-0.0061858725,
-0.0288526267,
0.0337786563,
-0.0143559165,
0.0102128852,
0.0545467809,
0.0460996032,
-0.0184477698,
-0.0659677386,
0.0436174236,
-0.0418275818,
0.0058866404,
-0.0109023545,
-0.0207154099,
-0.0067720325,
-0.0012267428,
-0.0599887073,
0.0126346787,
-0.0131400786,
-0.0309709385,
0.0979088545,
-0.0075634881,
0.0104560815,
-0.002187761,
-0.0297722444,
-0.0719823465,
0.0278717577,
0.0071909474,
0.0258826297,
0.0030968774,
0.0036956186,
-0.0091036856,
-0.0480814874,
0.0771669447,
0.0685816556,
-0.0313949101,
-0.0275856182,
-0.0113224946,
0.0319532193,
0.0414624289,
0.0604546703,
0.0799509212,
-0.0195601359,
0.0086123245,
0.0101063689,
0.043576695,
-0.0175223295,
-0.0155065209,
0.00316786,
-0.0365100503,
-0.0500781238,
0.0239397176,
0.0236449093,
0.0253000949,
-0.0803856477,
-0.012019814,
0.0416288115,
0.0668328628,
-0.0184280574,
0.0034979463,
-0.0645848587,
0.0185688324,
0.0322797224,
0.0519360229,
-0.0932694003,
-0.0299475025,
0.0166230891,
-0.016531691,
0.0046115946,
-0.0625308603,
-0.0097571053,
-0.0819785669,
0.007361013,
0.0139214601,
-0.0043890192,
0.006016436,
0.0176509861,
0.0035328334,
0.0360073149,
-0.041378852,
0.024656754,
0.0193011984,
0.0270458888,
0.0160170216,
-0.0371719971,
0.0027572548,
0.0022028524,
-0.019065287,
-0.0633436814,
0.0119702099,
-0.017548468,
-0.0332916267,
-0.1090676337,
-0.0010015245,
0.0645105839,
-0.0096882861,
0.0048505329,
0.0212048609,
0.0120886583,
-0.0047012558,
0.0005820253,
0.0554326139,
-0.0868459418,
-0.0011321647,
0.0491409041,
0.118169181,
0.0021878988,
0.0014220712,
-0.028936062,
0.0174952168,
-0.0233138148,
0.0275860485,
0.0437010042,
-0.0245909821,
-0.0052255518,
-0.0043429076,
-0.0043827249,
-0.0340697914,
-0.0342991538,
-0.0105628725,
0.1011068076,
-0.0069286381,
-0.0397783369,
-0.0549523011,
0.0376230441,
0.0403776877,
0.0248575099,
-0.053206671,
0.0334887542,
-0.0043264432,
-0.0288332738,
0.0198637657,
0.0081855208,
0.0425172187,
0.025590321,
0.049587708,
-0.026817739,
-0.014556339,
-0.0420945771,
0.0750006437,
-0.1196703091,
-0.0352760144,
-0.0305665135,
0.018950142,
0.0214453936,
-0.0060474924,
-0.0350813121,
-0.0095754284,
0.0270726588,
0.0029803242,
-0.0416630358,
0.0223223604,
0.0332149528,
-0.0022248153,
0.0301474463,
0.0212997273,
0.0153076993,
0.0101208743,
0.0145375868,
0.0286730956,
-0.0420257375,
0.0138137881,
-0.0041767112,
-0.0084134126,
-0.0397120081,
0.0232322346,
0.0512362458,
-0.014289557,
0.0372478776,
-0.0001617265,
0.0045158369,
-0.0581864305,
-0.0025063914,
-0.0034824214,
-0.0080569992,
0.0148292836,
-0.051770512,
0.0178747792,
0.0022489759,
0.0407214835,
0.0335390642,
0.0176789928,
0.040067967,
0.0311856642,
-0.0183668509,
-0.0065529826,
-0.0008619025,
-0.0411110632,
0.0466432981,
-0.0186833721,
0.0724182352,
0.0167622808,
-0.0040499745,
-0.0248434078,
-0.017950898,
-0.0431460924,
-0.1181842983,
-0.0220559798,
0.0428276211,
-0.0007785896,
0.0088769207,
-0.0656037405,
-0.0112218438,
0.02136725,
0.0217358414,
0.0093399948,
-0.0196546838,
-0.0257156845,
0.0055197426,
0.035438817,
0.029440267,
-0.0786319375,
0.0217057485,
-0.0907911137,
-0.0052718492,
0.0028962831,
0.0271127596,
-0.0114847468,
-0.0011451303,
-0.0298438948,
0.0512207188,
0.0110161928,
0.0383088365,
-0.0874611288,
-0.0491571873,
0.0386410505,
0.0146733923,
0.0018980964,
0.0090577435,
0.0701284558,
0.0267782547,
-0.0205160622,
-0.0147193633,
0.0466310233,
0.0318659171,
-0.0468856506,
-0.0432038344,
-0.0538749471,
-5.91299152e-33,
0.0208849143,
-0.0196255185,
0.0388661772,
-0.0065410868,
-0.0527723022,
0.0031738093,
-0.0630367547,
0.0213380512,
-0.022248039,
-0.0058477772,
-0.0253972691,
0.0326439887,
-0.0174695253,
0.0243778992,
0.0226216111,
-0.0253861491,
-0.0236861631,
-0.0312389564,
-0.0025779151,
-0.0194199365,
0.0082682706,
0.0261670519,
0.0568231717,
-0.0124609862,
-0.0252073091,
0.0128310742,
0.0406425074,
0.0141157703,
0.0012179972,
0.0475487299,
-0.0362578481,
0.0250312239,
0.0210161395,
-0.0578152686,
-0.022138238,
0.0154881887,
-0.0019672904,
-0.0654728264,
-0.0118575087,
-0.004358225,
-0.1182239056,
-0.004307752,
0.0578295253,
0.0149891749,
0.0013242777,
-0.0174163729,
0.0340398364,
0.002026499,
0.00165177,
0.0620291829,
-0.017060345,
0.0137936175,
-0.0042754007,
-0.0261010341,
0.004264731,
0.0121432925,
-0.0253992584,
-0.0176362414,
-0.0733059123,
0.003510542,
0.0391045175,
0.0241683424,
0.0184771176,
-0.0082720444,
-0.0108403433,
0.0161750298,
0.0051526115,
-0.0494291298,
-0.06016808,
-0.0058993297,
0.0184163041,
0.0478852689,
0.0805448964,
-0.0148551324,
0.0585307144,
0.0058317897,
-0.0133768143,
-0.0653082356,
0.0207394529,
0.0308044143,
0.0118855434,
-0.0295254216,
-0.0339326188,
0.0059532402,
-0.0224781968,
0.0172285754,
-0.0710108653,
-0.0167585947,
0.017118413,
-0.0177611317,
0.0314029194,
0.0592138804,
-0.0121171782,
-0.0128548145,
0.0283643529,
0.0100186868,
0.0094623799,
0.0112924883,
0.0394177586,
0.0181393027,
-0.0712189376,
0.0410927497,
-0.0210978687,
0.0360957794,
0.0317042246,
0.0271305405,
0.0056022834,
-0.0020362451,
-0.0042505972,
-0.0544857532,
-0.0386417024,
-0.0082663801,
0.0173705686,
0.0075242822,
0.0323291868,
0.0554524027,
-0.0271050464,
0.0187057443,
-0.0115881758,
-0.0075028939,
-0.0290972218,
0.0185942594,
0.0087976167,
0.0638578236,
-0.026451353,
-0.0335730761,
-0.0254410207,
-0.0108146984,
0.0300085731,
-0.0885678679,
-0.0005425891,
0.050786417,
2.971e-7,
0.0155208157,
0.0322555639,
0.0205721334,
0.0337767638,
0.0299957134,
0.0158447959,
0.0068020183,
-0.0078967074,
0.011123593,
-0.0826543048,
0.0089919949,
0.0768823326,
0.0045629982,
0.0120530976,
-0.0494937189,
0.0058099618,
-0.0395251065,
0.0189150535,
-0.0200093444,
-0.0111527191,
0.0672538802,
0.0604987256,
0.0436773375,
-0.0025383504,
-0.0095976414,
-0.019500589,
0.0554750077,
0.049679976,
0.0151007753,
-0.008540988,
0.0171503052,
-0.0093153473,
0.0026224223,
0.0165950302,
0.0041488954,
0.0465814918,
0.0233670305,
-0.0125127314,
0.0101270592,
0.0125015574,
-0.0371366218,
-0.0291320328,
-0.0066395015,
-0.0374906175,
0.0323707052,
-0.0792630464,
-0.0047078719,
-0.0003291172,
0.003652689,
0.0314725526,
0.0335187912,
0.0180014316,
0.0166108757,
-0.035774447,
0.0423619524,
-0.0120285815,
-0.000228464,
-0.0589274094,
-0.0175969694,
0.012409769,
-0.061932452,
0.0072229332,
-0.077341646,
-0.0311735738,
0.0431265905,
-0.0075248862,
-0.0207200646,
2.463691289e-34,
0.0275416262,
-0.0029503363,
0.0266205966,
0.0510944985,
0.0128654893,
-0.0245919768,
0.0009225311,
0.006812254,
0.0527609885,
-0.0556454882,
-0.0326200388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01030v1 | Joint Learning of Local and Global Features for Aspect-based Sentiment Classification | 2023-11-02T06:43:50 | 2023-11-02T06:43:50 | Hao Niu, Yun Xiong, Xiaosu Wang, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect-based sentiment classification (ASC) aims to judge the sentiment
polarity conveyed by the given aspect term in a sentence. The sentiment
polarity is not only determined by the local context but also related to the
words far away from the given aspect term. Most recent efforts related to the
attention-based models can not sufficiently distinguish which words they should
pay more attention to in some cases. Meanwhile, graph-based models are coming
into ASC to encode syntactic dependency tree information. But these models do
not fully leverage syntactic dependency trees as they neglect to incorporate
dependency relation tag information into representation learning effectively.
In this paper, we address these problems by effectively modeling the local and
global features. Firstly, we design a local encoder containing: a Gaussian mask
layer and a covariance self-attention layer. The Gaussian mask layer tends to
adjust the receptive field around aspect terms adaptively to deemphasize the
effects of unrelated words and pay more attention to local information. The
covariance self-attention layer can distinguish the attention weights of
different words more obviously. Furthermore, we propose a dual-level graph
attention network as a global encoder by fully employing dependency tag
information to capture long-distance information effectively. Our model
achieves state-of-the-art performance on both SemEval 2014 and Twitter
datasets. | [
0.0184709672,
0.0093699386,
0.004432634,
0.048562862,
-0.0156531315,
-0.0013628001,
-0.0059534744,
0.0024869822,
0.0335985832,
-0.0405862406,
-0.0143422959,
-0.0162327327,
-0.0243883207,
0.0918787196,
-0.0089794109,
-0.032843411,
0.015672842,
0.0510922857,
0.0056362548,
-0.0299645551,
0.0236958247,
0.0408491604,
0.0422893353,
0.0048837513,
-0.0222204179,
-0.0214271117,
0.0158794355,
0.0391973257,
0.0212090127,
-0.0170163363,
0.0242875684,
0.0051773917,
-0.0006196405,
-0.0316638872,
0.0000020085,
0.0004761776,
-0.0156742167,
-0.035591241,
0.0443828367,
-0.0128721381,
0.0368942693,
-0.0566259921,
0.0412345491,
0.0140721314,
-0.0327074453,
-0.0348376557,
0.0404736325,
0.0651065409,
0.0479246527,
0.0659889504,
-0.0349531397,
-0.0395411849,
-0.0145157287,
-0.0367642082,
0.0004076989,
-0.0333622694,
-0.0095632188,
-0.001611245,
-0.0434971675,
0.0518850572,
-0.0564429611,
0.0077534816,
0.0319855586,
-0.0030353093,
0.0933805555,
0.0305819158,
0.0559940934,
0.0381523781,
0.0176852625,
0.0717086717,
-0.012501834,
-0.0531133115,
-0.0095432457,
-0.0355467834,
-0.0060146046,
0.0157027859,
0.0054645301,
-0.023844542,
0.0061828722,
0.0578297153,
0.0266048759,
0.0142237293,
0.0141373631,
-0.0107546197,
-0.0176568199,
0.0527659431,
-0.0347010754,
-0.0479613915,
0.006634003,
0.0563176312,
-0.025371829,
-0.0142062288,
0.0514530391,
-0.0084520318,
0.0419582278,
0.0014048885,
-0.0411157943,
0.0154120903,
-0.0168450531,
-0.0979204923,
-0.0240179654,
-0.0227804519,
-0.0115373246,
0.0741193146,
0.0202233624,
-0.0195618719,
-0.0202212352,
-0.0094670234,
-0.0306506567,
0.0052680401,
-0.0557934046,
0.0118516227,
-0.0143467272,
0.0529577918,
-0.0242970604,
-0.0345968939,
-0.0524039418,
-0.0161962025,
-0.0112463776,
-0.0190446656,
0.0404780135,
0.0399097018,
0.0056017404,
-0.0304433312,
0.011502468,
0.0655159354,
-0.0475409254,
0.0254269168,
-0.0548356473,
0.0392455049,
-0.0192171745,
0.0642986298,
0.0429486595,
-0.0083612427,
0.007287526,
0.0292952638,
0.084139213,
-0.0512411371,
-0.0188757274,
-0.0072231633,
-0.0524289012,
-0.0308504403,
0.0278182458,
-0.0471836999,
0.0058987821,
0.0012705367,
-0.0116405813,
-0.0060878154,
0.0188409872,
0.000572163,
-0.0259839352,
0.0412085317,
0.0315426625,
-0.032735873,
-0.0301422104,
-0.0248442627,
0.0516438112,
0.0297002718,
0.0028264143,
0.0528799631,
0.0009791196,
-0.0165295321,
-0.0151973078,
-0.0283473171,
0.0314035229,
0.0082351333,
-0.030047968,
-0.0111859981,
-0.052271124,
-0.0468195938,
0.0541658886,
0.0352495424,
0.0108949617,
-0.0485706702,
0.0593524687,
-0.0106914295,
-0.01911374,
0.0565262437,
0.0134010408,
0.052582711,
-0.0715011954,
-0.006425017,
-0.0236138292,
0.050187476,
-0.0090948818,
-0.0072592879,
0.0348670147,
-0.0076655732,
-0.035268236,
-0.0373915248,
0.0167552941,
-0.0470735952,
0.0348246284,
0.0153182168,
0.0626223534,
0.0138994018,
-0.0376233719,
0.0096844751,
0.0456210561,
-0.0227174275,
-0.0251202211,
0.0071206996,
-0.0038485823,
0.0634826869,
-0.0196173694,
-0.0117618535,
-0.0090872021,
-0.0323701687,
-0.0630424693,
0.0142756198,
0.0077479421,
0.032121554,
-0.0032738282,
-0.0450079441,
-0.0293422919,
-0.0394585431,
-0.009607438,
0.0251389965,
-0.0225738101,
0.0138609363,
0.0103839757,
-0.0047495295,
0.0120065799,
-0.0071004452,
0.0423596166,
-0.012829423,
0.0399732627,
0.0143723013,
0.0485502593,
0.0603629351,
0.0077839596,
-0.0016191343,
0.0196414031,
-0.0387333035,
-0.0529409684,
-0.0136662228,
-0.0661346093,
-0.0571153127,
0.0045930021,
-0.036510475,
0.0017036219,
0.0207634848,
-0.0191726182,
-0.034351185,
0.0618024245,
-0.0568410009,
0.0218067896,
-0.007284469,
-0.0253001265,
0.0205115862,
0.0543887168,
0.0040485077,
0.070432432,
-0.050007131,
0.0105686272,
-0.0773907155,
0.0044065118,
0.0216679499,
0.0082480274,
-0.0131011428,
-0.0104402034,
0.0361860469,
-0.0216791555,
0.0389483683,
0.0038503993,
-0.0183522962,
-0.0089530582,
-0.094865635,
-0.0124954237,
-0.0203863047,
0.0043545803,
0.0133648748,
0.0056348694,
0.0227965657,
-0.0257411785,
-0.0455879681,
0.0154617084,
-0.0260406379,
-0.0015919203,
0.0135190422,
-0.0216111653,
0.0320856236,
-0.0199094675,
-0.0324693695,
-0.0138385454,
0.0366870388,
0.0011482142,
-0.0907562599,
-0.0205280762,
0.0425323173,
-0.0062059835,
0.010757396,
0.0091257486,
-0.0331244618,
-0.0362920947,
-0.0119124893,
-0.0026128355,
0.0522973314,
-0.0179164931,
0.0234423373,
0.0268189441,
0.0039263936,
-0.0261744838,
0.0246125851,
-0.0499690734,
0.0673495159,
-0.0177075304,
-0.0080446331,
-0.0131961415,
0.0842874423,
0.0098911226,
-0.0096962238,
-0.0606352426,
-0.0064172656,
-0.007108164,
0.0024185078,
0.026857933,
0.003500592,
-0.0001894046,
-0.0549376979,
-0.0436395891,
-0.0334990956,
0.0729950443,
0.0326026268,
-0.0001907122,
-0.034230113,
-0.0299258661,
-0.0532247685,
0.0887228325,
0.0229935553,
0.0117640011,
0.0150770424,
-0.0213675629,
0.0164878462,
-0.0037202521,
-0.0015694459,
-0.0032727527,
0.0175151844,
0.0358571894,
0.0163553078,
0.0207307041,
-0.0397909544,
0.0346508771,
-0.037823163,
-0.0362754427,
0.0021083143,
0.0129874256,
-0.0195447691,
0.0361966267,
-0.0081487671,
-0.0038676525,
-0.0161368884,
-0.0224577133,
0.0189833008,
0.0126327993,
0.036667984,
0.0318736322,
-0.0232721567,
-0.0070444625,
0.0032049471,
-0.0176885799,
0.0384394974,
-0.0262341704,
0.0040706834,
-0.0187338311,
-0.0292752665,
0.0154193034,
0.0068309093,
-0.0256035924,
-0.0538933165,
0.0640319809,
-0.0566295795,
-0.018391965,
0.0673264414,
0.0306934938,
-0.0926745236,
-0.0119042955,
0.025627004,
-0.011781292,
0.0300429855,
-0.002876325,
-0.0414918028,
-0.0382825769,
-0.0376995653,
-0.0062864502,
0.0376947559,
0.0035120402,
0.0112925284,
-0.0835825279,
-0.0104213655,
0.00576851,
-0.0222762153,
-0.1010746881,
-0.0433386862,
0.0017140785,
0.0045207236,
-0.03659245,
-0.0400237851,
0.0049882885,
-0.0048825513,
-0.0046665692,
-0.0349614918,
-0.0016265499,
0.0472396724,
0.0070059998,
0.0116636604,
0.0207675695,
0.0512521155,
-0.0029582232,
-0.0345785655,
0.0280305985,
-0.0304060075,
-0.004223838,
-0.0264411736,
0.0929793194,
-0.0505743437,
-0.0018767746,
-0.0172737371,
-0.0007393195,
-0.0633788705,
0.0097536109,
-0.0416437127,
0.0659522042,
-0.0319412425,
-0.0322268456,
-0.0057085091,
0.0125003923,
0.028618075,
0.0090776477,
0.0519718826,
-0.0525537729,
-0.055199001,
-0.0222735181,
0.007677542,
-0.0775097311,
-0.0451630577,
-0.0007056758,
0.0016654581,
-0.0437760353,
-0.0370150506,
-0.0737201646,
-0.0126804793,
0.0097651901,
-0.0386707745,
0.0007132077,
0.0273073427,
-0.0473540947,
-0.0362638868,
0.0294489581,
-0.0139157595,
0.0194421113,
0.0503000319,
-0.035315603,
0.0784594789,
0.0051182741,
-0.0196931325,
0.0064904401,
-0.044358097,
-0.0342058577,
-0.0093098087,
0.034432061,
0.0005559207,
0.0124384938,
-0.0456447639,
-0.0231004413,
-0.0066481396,
0.0093345689,
-0.0407604426,
0.0096110869,
0.0593423918,
0.0470976606,
0.024109751,
0.0557627268,
-0.0294031203,
0.0515360422,
0.0306507517,
-0.006046026,
-0.0482987538,
-0.0396559313,
0.0095397849,
0.0035373215,
0.0786087066,
0.0277917888,
-0.0274208449,
-0.0353740975,
0.0219253339,
-0.0054369746,
-0.0172343217,
-0.0359325707,
-0.0142012155,
0.0220562536,
-0.0097031565,
-0.0266745854,
0.0343611911,
0.0159284361,
-0.0025723199,
-0.0271426793,
0.0566537008,
0.0086610699,
-0.0049443487,
-0.0300816167,
0.0327251367,
-0.0433524549,
-0.0363865867,
0.0517680086,
-0.0084218904,
0.0168174561,
0.030040713,
-0.0170019418,
0.001632428,
-0.0628066063,
-0.007088487,
-0.0462054014,
0.0470106453,
-0.0285610836,
-0.0189453959,
0.0427362211,
-0.0377866775,
0.0443164408,
-0.0150293522,
0.0040560048,
-0.0147176962,
0.0440019071,
-0.02596456,
-0.037625473,
0.0328253284,
-0.0117958756,
-0.0354557894,
0.0338228419,
0.0467152596,
-0.0425208211,
0.0040382468,
0.0458976738,
-0.0149999354,
-0.017539965,
0.0065143281,
0.0062126284,
0.0317161009,
0.0086107533,
0.0720758662,
-0.0341200083,
-0.0774767697,
0.0421291701,
-0.0456883051,
0.0149358325,
0.0051364554,
0.0504707769,
0.0153173888,
0.0364705324,
0.0147417784,
-0.0719376132,
0.0500683896,
0.0012061445,
-0.0049127913,
-0.0099138739,
-7.011146424e-33,
-0.0125182513,
-0.0425324403,
-0.0456118062,
0.0245104004,
-0.0448240787,
0.0270860903,
-0.0276512187,
0.0288280193,
-0.0136026479,
0.0382538252,
0.0137055516,
0.060455095,
-0.0153733566,
0.0408941843,
0.0265202951,
-0.0252312999,
0.0060348138,
0.0170199201,
0.0219265539,
0.0579597652,
0.0594069622,
0.0232053697,
0.0958490297,
-0.1278192699,
0.0216539297,
-0.008733823,
0.0019159783,
-0.0015858017,
0.0113731893,
0.0459655412,
-0.0090725087,
0.0861537457,
0.0514085479,
-0.0246576723,
0.0046369652,
0.0364872962,
-0.0310086068,
-0.0521103777,
-0.0259661674,
-0.0214191657,
-0.0401193984,
-0.0471416377,
0.0493653193,
0.0474569909,
0.0255742893,
-0.0580518506,
0.0351208374,
0.0041162656,
-0.0220346637,
-0.0606758185,
-0.0051832446,
0.0461399406,
-0.0018808171,
-0.0005219948,
0.0095230909,
0.0246338919,
0.0233150367,
0.0344709195,
-0.015777586,
0.0043606712,
-0.067785129,
0.0465235934,
-0.0217296295,
-0.0236110501,
-0.0045315935,
0.0696396083,
-0.008840777,
0.0225126855,
-0.0394674316,
0.0037087915,
-0.0103138043,
0.0079516359,
0.0100710467,
0.0054108775,
0.0199976154,
-0.0338881016,
-0.0759307742,
-0.026809426,
0.0206963327,
0.0407583304,
0.0356337465,
0.0194993559,
-0.0246260893,
-0.0221782532,
0.0262710005,
-0.0569922291,
-0.0453166477,
-0.0188268386,
-0.0271012336,
0.0218196902,
-0.0054192864,
0.0659577847,
0.0069332365,
-0.047232639,
0.0086272368,
0.0524269007,
0.0068101445,
0.0410211273,
0.0358777158,
0.0174755808,
-0.0508945696,
0.0126283942,
-0.0417528301,
-0.0242536012,
0.0082520554,
0.0153787825,
0.0815564767,
0.0020252964,
-0.08112894,
-0.025036253,
-0.030965304,
-0.0200543944,
-0.045476146,
0.046859242,
0.0202070549,
0.0456120409,
-0.0080046635,
0.1135325432,
0.0244268328,
0.0757772923,
-0.0143522928,
-0.0169565845,
0.0044907173,
0.0407934561,
-0.0190925896,
-0.0400638096,
-0.000735531,
0.0173555966,
-0.0111079132,
-0.0456435233,
-0.0295099262,
0.0265905205,
2.918e-7,
0.0588557571,
0.0564222895,
0.0092763202,
-0.0170351248,
0.0271557346,
0.062917918,
0.0192665588,
0.0614749752,
-0.028132068,
-0.0312583931,
0.0182063598,
0.0453580283,
-0.0096602831,
0.0028203523,
-0.0864690989,
0.0799480826,
0.0000406242,
-0.0056083119,
0.0031441955,
0.0241714381,
0.0485746413,
0.1079277843,
0.0467564277,
0.0247287173,
0.0118796844,
0.0011918014,
0.0479544625,
-0.0070598358,
-0.0376995876,
-0.0338985994,
-0.0466558486,
-0.0324130058,
-0.052807726,
-0.0038044367,
-0.021079028,
0.0185496956,
0.0084315585,
0.0602923892,
-0.0140371146,
-0.070625037,
-0.0062504904,
0.035563793,
0.013520781,
-0.004180647,
0.0588001609,
-0.0506234095,
-0.0647104457,
-0.0662647337,
-0.0188156404,
0.0555809513,
0.0414556414,
0.0273556057,
-0.0210217107,
-0.0007502692,
-0.0123912403,
-0.0393628366,
-0.0196402967,
-0.1062552258,
-0.0171581302,
0.0237156712,
-0.0089266114,
0.0066130799,
0.0151511496,
0.0166362319,
0.0444327854,
0.0259196796,
0.0015853139,
2.268542007e-34,
0.0397976786,
-0.0218467154,
-0.0097428849,
0.0096510947,
-0.009349186,
-0.0520800203,
-0.0830712691,
-0.0133763971,
0.0706703365,
-0.0349936038,
-0.0052864626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01012v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01012v3 | COPAL-ID: Indonesian Language Reasoning with Local Culture and Nuances | 2023-11-02T06:14:41 | 2024-04-21T22:11:58 | Haryo Akbarianto Wibowo, Erland Hilman Fuadi, Made Nindyatama Nityasya, Radityo Eko Prasojo, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | We present COPAL-ID, a novel, public Indonesian language common sense
reasoning dataset. Unlike the previous Indonesian COPA dataset (XCOPA-ID),
COPAL-ID incorporates Indonesian local and cultural nuances, and therefore,
provides a more natural portrayal of day-to-day causal reasoning within the
Indonesian cultural sphere. Professionally written by natives from scratch,
COPAL-ID is more fluent and free from awkward phrases, unlike the translated
XCOPA-ID. In addition, we present COPAL-ID in both standard Indonesian and in
Jakartan Indonesian-a dialect commonly used in daily conversation. COPAL-ID
poses a greater challenge for existing open-sourced and closed state-of-the-art
multilingual language models, yet is trivially easy for humans. Our findings
suggest that general multilingual models struggle to perform well, achieving
66.91% accuracy on COPAL-ID. South-East Asian-specific models achieve slightly
better performance of 73.88% accuracy. Yet, this number still falls short of
near-perfect human performance. This shows that these language models are still
way behind in comprehending the local nuances of Indonesian. | [
0.0402311087,
0.0472313203,
-0.0123178503,
0.0434185378,
-0.0444450714,
0.0399294086,
-0.000128863,
-0.0005855025,
0.0457435474,
-0.00708863,
-0.0204209965,
-0.0148560619,
0.0306366589,
-0.0062946361,
0.0338572375,
-0.0597569831,
0.028147202,
-0.0209544767,
0.0600453429,
-0.0210650489,
0.0075968644,
0.0608399101,
-0.0165987667,
0.0282829907,
-0.0178627707,
-0.0282971021,
-0.0018479633,
-0.041911535,
0.0475238971,
-0.0093320832,
0.0103780888,
0.0459517837,
-0.0074859555,
-0.0020515232,
0.0000023311,
-0.0396051072,
0.0501215532,
-0.0592295974,
0.0129445065,
0.0154930465,
0.0116109448,
-0.00000898,
0.0185354538,
-0.004162977,
-0.0521859452,
0.0143566839,
-0.0062698843,
0.0617850125,
0.0462367348,
0.0331577212,
-0.0050802664,
-0.0777174085,
-0.0122021418,
-0.0307534635,
0.0025066566,
-0.0226519089,
0.022597732,
0.0374074392,
0.0451291166,
-0.0353702568,
-0.0169878192,
0.0243218169,
0.0423229523,
-0.009357417,
-0.0548587888,
-0.0042224517,
-0.0481995679,
-0.0541304983,
0.0496140085,
0.0674825236,
0.0451492853,
-0.0681176409,
-0.0198915824,
0.0138441287,
-0.0240084957,
0.01349336,
-0.0481093936,
0.0251155868,
-0.0403874256,
0.0355694778,
0.0809320882,
0.0258910507,
0.0190338455,
0.0560124703,
0.010800072,
0.0629595071,
-0.003022152,
0.0063894498,
0.0057709478,
-0.0002986316,
-0.0255580377,
-0.0434103459,
0.0407575928,
0.0436703973,
-0.0186441131,
0.0371032953,
-0.006417525,
0.019279534,
0.0357542336,
-0.0749518201,
-0.0179731604,
0.0633840933,
-0.0026733596,
0.0728418902,
-0.0012353237,
0.0255991984,
-0.0200645216,
0.0771258175,
0.0006299542,
-0.0388222262,
-0.0366377868,
-0.0257239658,
-0.0046195569,
0.0102791088,
-0.0170292966,
0.0169546995,
-0.0461258851,
-0.0134890741,
-0.0210378394,
-0.0285749193,
0.0529011711,
0.0178032573,
-0.0380540565,
-0.0433842354,
-0.0045772009,
0.0493440516,
-0.0783621371,
0.0353082158,
0.0160400774,
-0.0510688201,
0.0131769339,
-0.0039269254,
-0.0136659322,
-0.029271841,
0.0075850785,
0.0021566863,
-0.0255717821,
0.0197830871,
-0.0686880872,
-0.0216155518,
-0.0090483828,
-0.0447711125,
-0.0148344003,
-0.0496889539,
0.04589485,
0.0441698432,
0.0003550116,
-0.0625908375,
-0.0002547469,
0.0386610515,
-0.0417433716,
0.0377111025,
0.0134593677,
0.027378682,
0.0308286585,
0.0311410297,
0.021983562,
0.0191784482,
0.0314046554,
-0.0187341832,
0.0557773225,
-0.0112680048,
-0.066589959,
-0.0014147599,
0.0149300639,
-0.0051436634,
-0.0134760151,
0.0257513858,
-0.0409332886,
0.0299713407,
-0.0115692839,
0.028735986,
-0.0083333105,
0.0057564415,
0.0195039324,
0.0519944206,
-0.0087420531,
0.0282046627,
0.0537579879,
-0.0081089148,
0.0024938344,
-0.0199318603,
-0.0161129367,
0.0281273909,
-0.0362800695,
-0.0092019122,
-0.011037047,
0.034225598,
-0.0401058383,
-0.0196345225,
0.0148481429,
-0.0004252331,
0.0065917503,
0.0143958442,
0.0402797759,
0.0041491012,
0.0078221941,
0.0193119906,
0.0507115088,
-0.0427944623,
0.006885374,
-0.0243046898,
0.0555118918,
0.0306723192,
-0.001266006,
0.0015070622,
-0.0170260631,
0.0263814218,
0.0741408542,
0.0058621587,
0.0307151489,
-0.0436345674,
-0.0122598568,
-0.0438800603,
0.0171499494,
0.0289244913,
-0.0126897339,
0.0321792513,
0.0204638261,
0.0263204649,
0.0178753212,
-0.0513944663,
0.0286051352,
0.0108702928,
-0.0644756258,
0.0047861007,
-0.0365270823,
0.0047461535,
-0.0038883484,
0.0540743135,
0.0529618599,
0.0058240956,
0.0166946705,
-0.0629381165,
-0.0178357102,
0.0887103081,
-0.0461623333,
-0.0522238016,
0.0246985536,
-0.030089559,
-0.0621962622,
0.0456052274,
-0.0188171156,
-0.0536729507,
0.0444151498,
0.0505043119,
0.0111994771,
-0.0472668,
-0.0375382677,
-0.0016038744,
-0.0123729054,
-0.0142006557,
0.0780675709,
-0.0222059805,
-0.0000074893,
-0.0173899848,
0.0241926964,
0.0397459976,
-0.046671208,
-0.0096789682,
0.0334024988,
0.0065061324,
-0.0252506211,
-0.0153337158,
0.030450521,
-0.0447371602,
0.0050281989,
-0.1095484868,
-0.0006348462,
-0.0106784515,
0.0079123341,
0.0079390556,
0.0071273749,
-0.0119518023,
-0.0392012447,
0.0025811491,
-0.036601115,
0.0365334861,
0.0105317915,
0.0101101827,
-0.0048929183,
0.0408030003,
0.0059991288,
-0.0195574183,
-0.0186821595,
0.034346506,
0.032547418,
-0.0516986474,
-0.0006832667,
-0.0139143188,
-0.055538673,
-0.0551182255,
-0.0124172019,
-0.0247997195,
0.0107933786,
0.0062212506,
-0.0483725928,
0.0441647433,
-0.0269054081,
-0.0261760093,
-0.0082649253,
-0.0113235312,
-0.0481926203,
-0.0056578591,
0.0043354584,
0.0444451049,
-0.0192502066,
-0.0066487142,
-0.0303197149,
0.0914503559,
0.0197508801,
-0.0050637829,
-0.0672699139,
0.0163650289,
-0.0387713499,
-0.0032227032,
-0.0507356375,
-0.0211751275,
-0.0284011476,
0.0695530921,
-0.02352966,
-0.0019033212,
0.0776683763,
-0.0019409936,
-0.0095240539,
-0.0327628851,
0.0227251109,
-0.0406239219,
0.0383479446,
-0.0610994622,
0.0045676138,
-0.0214783829,
-0.0223952178,
-0.0348212607,
-0.0003653966,
0.0259095244,
-0.00650129,
0.047892727,
-0.0810126364,
0.0124086216,
0.0054013859,
-0.0605801642,
-0.0266867951,
-0.0220749788,
-0.062411733,
0.0144855762,
-0.0166309495,
0.0324698687,
0.0003624573,
-0.007713147,
0.0127532342,
-0.0461534113,
-0.0050409092,
0.0066647832,
0.0028149772,
-0.005200882,
0.0262725595,
-0.0203791279,
-0.0151692079,
-0.0044704215,
0.0082904017,
0.030162273,
0.0108389053,
-0.059335351,
0.0153205255,
0.0390660688,
0.0172012597,
0.020763386,
-0.0320819654,
-0.0291379038,
0.044761803,
-0.021887552,
0.0145959184,
0.1010079086,
0.047168415,
-0.006595097,
-0.0014435871,
-0.0771579817,
0.0308805276,
0.0238905568,
0.0298161469,
-0.0343883932,
-0.0625073016,
0.0223903041,
-0.0223834179,
0.0063858056,
-0.0609186888,
0.0080502117,
-0.1009521261,
0.0017293821,
-0.0006060383,
-0.0616836026,
-0.045290906,
-0.0317761675,
-0.0310271084,
-0.0361297019,
0.0099246381,
0.0085631693,
0.0306917895,
0.0185266268,
0.04146697,
-0.0161654614,
-0.0582378581,
0.0546528026,
0.0196315888,
0.0042991489,
-0.0036092999,
0.0541967899,
0.0046503032,
-0.0411171913,
0.0152093247,
-0.0104733324,
-0.0145429242,
-0.0433609821,
-0.0368357338,
0.0168545302,
-0.0289647989,
-0.067390345,
0.0686822608,
-0.0794754624,
-0.0301505234,
0.0207621139,
0.0954046771,
-0.0088555003,
-0.0153747164,
0.0096142255,
0.0383427627,
0.0039451183,
0.0494314544,
0.0260360781,
-0.0176690612,
-0.0013944142,
-0.0359411687,
-0.0460144915,
-0.0309672933,
-0.0430698246,
0.0110234376,
-0.0078416346,
-0.002896599,
-0.0509232618,
-0.0628575459,
0.0513275862,
0.035107214,
0.0197813194,
-0.0233602356,
0.0092457188,
-0.0062746457,
-0.0280206148,
0.0263326615,
-0.0383261181,
0.0195161905,
-0.028251987,
0.0430674218,
-0.003708113,
0.0187989585,
-0.0381706767,
0.0066725728,
-0.047672566,
-0.066169627,
0.0031552806,
0.0364378989,
0.0229446925,
-0.0007733054,
-0.0173432436,
-0.0604555011,
-0.0376902334,
-0.0286933351,
-0.0143032344,
0.0012194596,
0.024458468,
-0.0138251372,
0.019030489,
0.0882472098,
0.0067690318,
0.03823575,
-0.0019721973,
0.0649789274,
-0.0566197149,
0.0017565298,
0.0078427494,
-0.0094508389,
0.0153708318,
-0.0411499888,
-0.017453704,
-0.0660801008,
0.0049438393,
-0.0093306489,
-0.0449629091,
0.0094646122,
0.025636185,
0.048836384,
-0.025546968,
-0.0280081239,
-0.0081665814,
-0.0201005768,
0.0011085285,
-0.0075244904,
0.0133902077,
0.0434875116,
0.0743874162,
-0.0028375655,
-0.0027226338,
-0.0051851305,
0.0076259701,
-0.0493865199,
0.046970807,
-0.0368674062,
0.0990115702,
0.0182709564,
-0.0045830635,
0.0261250958,
-0.0377725177,
0.0008237619,
-0.0237864144,
0.065261133,
0.0232828073,
0.0622165166,
-0.0467279665,
0.0195104666,
-0.0248780623,
-0.008130216,
-0.0131616322,
0.070735395,
0.0234601982,
-0.0529659204,
0.0506850816,
0.0007412787,
-0.0186993722,
0.0347203463,
0.0838547871,
-0.0970596075,
0.0287426859,
0.0016922444,
-0.0124811083,
0.0198554546,
-0.0505918227,
0.0061886786,
0.0267861821,
-0.0193822831,
0.0063040932,
-0.1018171459,
-0.0769551322,
-0.0392030068,
0.0199592169,
-0.0102398572,
0.0196440779,
0.0054187085,
0.0524343438,
0.0215476677,
0.0194242354,
-0.0440147221,
0.020413572,
-0.1060576886,
0.0147650521,
-0.0260015521,
-6.652170286e-33,
-0.0439239293,
-0.0029108648,
0.0175344422,
-0.0294614471,
0.0363265537,
-0.039589081,
-0.0720411837,
0.0072246511,
-0.0301079527,
0.0756556913,
-0.0331368968,
0.0248080529,
0.0238102134,
0.0106158862,
0.0384384207,
-0.0095359562,
-0.0332696363,
0.039363645,
0.00897709,
0.0146219395,
0.0928090811,
0.0173838772,
0.0683076158,
-0.0791513622,
0.038256228,
0.0008240998,
0.0148083912,
0.0372221917,
-0.0268490687,
0.0388514474,
-0.0040748799,
0.022610737,
0.0304688904,
-0.0028531363,
-0.0071725002,
0.015824832,
-0.0786820427,
-0.0528504066,
0.0625965521,
0.0206557345,
-0.0009000276,
-0.0303823873,
-0.0172277447,
-0.0251663048,
0.0389847122,
0.0308878627,
0.0378354974,
-0.0079247802,
-0.0076613137,
0.0281142667,
-0.0415790901,
0.0380043127,
-0.0319241285,
0.0069588549,
-0.0541745573,
0.0612178631,
-0.0365268514,
0.0030544435,
-0.0649607107,
0.035946209,
-0.0459527001,
-0.0331552103,
0.0559475869,
-0.0189057719,
0.0130964974,
0.0606061891,
-0.0199506897,
-0.0053890171,
-0.016359834,
0.0527891256,
0.0400605127,
0.0524177253,
0.0083995732,
0.0967561379,
0.0103712063,
-0.0355657786,
-0.076606892,
-0.0191130489,
0.0031431487,
0.0285047442,
0.0039691771,
-0.0250281375,
-0.0592825264,
-0.0453802347,
0.007738437,
-0.0096084578,
-0.0353815109,
-0.0334033705,
0.0198753234,
-0.0364238881,
-0.0567612275,
0.0018850204,
0.0180141032,
-0.0274520293,
0.0188971348,
0.0317212306,
-0.0078109391,
-0.0082595032,
-0.0077354275,
0.0508269258,
-0.0675172359,
0.0001477207,
-0.0254052561,
0.0109103806,
0.0134570599,
0.0186113454,
0.0723204613,
-0.0096697006,
0.0018559162,
-0.0156097095,
-0.0411212891,
-0.0169706941,
-0.02465472,
-0.0094603365,
0.0487763211,
0.0568406135,
-0.0174123067,
0.0236395486,
0.0300889425,
0.0258345045,
-0.009209347,
-0.0471266583,
-0.0069640731,
-0.0155890239,
-0.0255693197,
-0.0123521881,
-0.0361160859,
0.0208094157,
0.0112688113,
-0.0101872776,
0.0005055203,
0.0342646912,
2.842e-7,
0.0547895767,
0.0179346185,
0.0213777665,
-0.0062980601,
0.0026055437,
0.036793761,
-0.0200338177,
-0.013899643,
0.0153392553,
0.0166014079,
0.0041476088,
0.0497484803,
0.0572265983,
0.0388089046,
-0.0999325737,
0.0136817442,
-0.0178495273,
-0.0444263481,
-0.0330826379,
-0.0272769146,
0.0124252979,
0.029972598,
0.042617213,
-0.0385728702,
-0.0162144192,
-0.0273745283,
0.079084076,
-0.0061356253,
-0.0198745988,
-0.007278292,
0.0476359092,
0.0020019312,
0.0414627492,
0.0248777252,
-0.0085778292,
-0.0040897289,
0.0116791185,
0.0792708248,
-0.0024662339,
-0.0320031233,
-0.0330736153,
-0.0365543999,
-0.0188984815,
-0.0857566819,
0.0971808806,
-0.0229675639,
-0.0550526269,
0.0201026034,
0.0423590988,
0.0150383124,
-0.0172666684,
0.0049191178,
-0.0376992598,
0.0061378223,
0.024682818,
-0.0599400066,
-0.0106291613,
-0.0412485078,
-0.0195756219,
0.0347259268,
-0.0126901502,
-0.0134852948,
-0.0152264992,
-0.0065368442,
0.0174744707,
-0.01188784,
-0.0007498012,
2.137117836e-34,
0.0187513176,
0.0496629402,
-0.0001610077,
-0.0657153651,
0.0554466061,
-0.0115655242,
0.0105073554,
0.0116825439,
0.0416274332,
-0.0257121939,
0.0078559555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00998v1 | Replicable Benchmarking of Neural Machine Translation (NMT) on Low-Resource Local Languages in Indonesia | 2023-11-02T05:27:48 | 2023-11-02T05:27:48 | Lucky Susanto, Ryandito Diandaru, Adila Krisnadhi, Ayu Purwarianti, Derry Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Neural machine translation (NMT) for low-resource local languages in
Indonesia faces significant challenges, including the need for a representative
benchmark and limited data availability. This work addresses these challenges
by comprehensively analyzing training NMT systems for four low-resource local
languages in Indonesia: Javanese, Sundanese, Minangkabau, and Balinese. Our
study encompasses various training approaches, paradigms, data sizes, and a
preliminary study into using large language models for synthetic low-resource
languages parallel data generation. We reveal specific trends and insights into
practical strategies for low-resource language translation. Our research
demonstrates that despite limited computational resources and textual data,
several of our NMT systems achieve competitive performances, rivaling the
translation quality of zero-shot gpt-3.5-turbo. These findings significantly
advance NMT for low-resource languages, offering valuable guidance for
researchers in similar contexts. | [
0.0390326269,
0.0561283715,
-0.0020956681,
0.0406217873,
-0.0370890498,
0.0259068981,
0.0299619939,
0.0180541985,
-0.0644220859,
-0.0050640148,
-0.0311442614,
-0.0668684989,
0.0638516098,
-0.0518513322,
0.0379985906,
-0.078426443,
0.02404139,
-0.0119379684,
-0.0049117412,
0.0103239454,
-0.0148191787,
0.0311927609,
0.0187246874,
0.0420740806,
-0.0340226926,
-0.0167833958,
-0.0230927002,
0.0518220551,
0.0080209598,
-0.054168053,
-0.0165378004,
0.0156079736,
-0.003886888,
0.0947664306,
0.0000020039,
-0.0241541285,
0.0024679112,
0.0022057483,
-0.0102297468,
0.0435294881,
0.0806487203,
-0.0500980616,
-0.0275593996,
0.0418129414,
-0.0035994025,
-0.054627575,
0.0722824112,
-0.0096545806,
0.0451253355,
0.0886023939,
-0.0122511648,
-0.0266716629,
-0.0083809523,
-0.0720319971,
-0.0234728605,
0.0038966141,
-0.0378062315,
-0.0211438816,
-0.0307408683,
-0.0251832791,
-0.0076104207,
0.036372859,
0.0136265317,
0.023292698,
-0.0368359648,
-0.0098506631,
-0.0506408252,
-0.0641840994,
0.0151091646,
0.0620344505,
-0.0633228719,
-0.0262776148,
-0.0480305925,
-0.0095969103,
-0.0205464587,
-0.0249058474,
-0.0335434191,
0.0297216866,
-0.0203890149,
0.027920166,
0.0290230066,
0.0459864587,
0.0574768744,
-0.0233894289,
-0.0025219496,
-0.0328510329,
0.0439139977,
-0.0241701845,
-0.0130670397,
0.0080375886,
-0.0120828599,
0.0077745472,
0.0163811762,
0.0135839656,
0.0282988828,
0.0366317295,
-0.0291983522,
-0.0508284122,
0.0312957987,
-0.0737946033,
0.0498140678,
0.0707101896,
0.0253659654,
0.0134343971,
-0.0116246026,
0.0310235284,
-0.0282571726,
-0.0071567264,
-0.0464820601,
-0.0171851609,
0.0067707836,
0.0234929435,
-0.064199239,
0.0017052867,
-0.0662115216,
0.0060377624,
-0.0145545974,
0.001329483,
0.0225677192,
-0.0097071491,
0.0539784655,
-0.0062831086,
-0.1079980433,
-0.0133468043,
0.0284500178,
0.0447698385,
-0.0060750367,
-0.0120220361,
0.0213164706,
-0.0970189348,
-0.0112284506,
0.0088164341,
-0.0296401363,
-0.0247495137,
0.0128309261,
0.0607605614,
-0.031872835,
-0.0299156532,
-0.0913577974,
0.0093104839,
-0.015362856,
-0.0635176226,
0.0075242878,
-0.0430456325,
0.0758991763,
0.0201787185,
0.0340128653,
-0.0224964321,
-0.0024481406,
0.0214195233,
0.0093272068,
0.0460075997,
-0.0173627697,
-0.0029871708,
0.0441281945,
0.0139706042,
0.0509308353,
0.0650451332,
0.066926308,
0.0145019274,
0.0031499686,
-0.0158348531,
-0.0754672214,
0.0524054095,
0.0364990048,
0.0524653159,
-0.051871758,
0.0115775708,
-0.0009557079,
0.059308365,
0.017839646,
0.0775860101,
-0.0033804011,
0.0253616683,
0.0581312254,
0.0653116256,
0.0174078979,
0.0714295655,
0.0796626061,
-0.0017095517,
-0.0100617623,
-0.0290423576,
0.0136422906,
0.0154206203,
0.0136885475,
0.0283222254,
0.047481548,
0.0699094906,
-0.0278560612,
-0.0075090299,
0.0008325763,
-0.017262876,
-0.0555148907,
-0.0372154787,
0.0225841962,
0.0242299046,
-0.056614019,
0.0198144764,
0.034190774,
-0.0313414745,
0.0243388414,
-0.0204758421,
-0.0579021871,
0.0318863802,
0.0246400293,
0.0453033745,
0.0110176373,
-0.0193793271,
-0.0217263531,
0.0674924105,
0.056768164,
-0.0029354196,
0.0197837409,
-0.0444283448,
0.0428171568,
0.0173794609,
0.0172495823,
0.0602395274,
0.0315674916,
0.0660774782,
0.0598910041,
-0.0240097176,
-0.0522958003,
0.0353525691,
-0.0404070094,
-0.0430328846,
0.0160856564,
0.0146888504,
0.0523678698,
0.0274187196,
0.0116169956,
-0.0132514453,
0.0091369683,
-0.035702046,
0.011406403,
0.0365349054,
-0.0264853705,
-0.057562571,
0.0040273839,
-0.0136531442,
0.0067281392,
0.0357950032,
-0.0168532431,
-0.0721727759,
0.0071257045,
-0.0186559372,
0.0080933971,
-0.0602005087,
0.0355907306,
-0.0064744139,
-0.0119005078,
-0.0328244343,
0.0297787879,
0.0036206397,
-0.0180955026,
0.0080286684,
-0.0141380886,
0.0681418702,
-0.0626978651,
-0.0258722398,
0.036109075,
0.0215773992,
0.0307186488,
-0.0442753136,
0.0177546274,
-0.0147002237,
-0.0294646192,
-0.073983565,
0.0075374451,
-0.0149572231,
0.0404124223,
0.0266836304,
0.0623261891,
-0.0042125657,
-0.0173600707,
0.0088348128,
0.0267345514,
0.0129338512,
0.0095581105,
-0.0122632952,
-0.003241722,
0.0257663708,
-0.0131513849,
-0.0189167857,
0.0504512228,
0.0542941391,
0.0355830044,
-0.0512583405,
-0.063802965,
-0.0097317919,
-0.0238564331,
-0.012103674,
0.0091581447,
-0.0518387072,
0.0279429741,
-0.0238995273,
-0.0163913369,
-0.0054124249,
-0.0251337774,
-0.025541082,
-0.0044468683,
0.0165857207,
-0.058818534,
0.0051110825,
-0.0173320863,
-0.015922891,
-0.0223044809,
-0.0265894979,
-0.0179229621,
0.0571143851,
0.0090046544,
0.0030384841,
-0.0580932871,
0.0121515794,
-0.0237791445,
-0.005961311,
-0.0024280087,
0.0485984907,
-0.0068979212,
-0.0007130257,
-0.0061775036,
-0.0584853329,
0.0504373945,
-0.0361741558,
-0.0124360221,
-0.0426619723,
0.01295067,
-0.0510357246,
0.0222097337,
-0.0487444587,
0.0082729217,
-0.0441551954,
-0.0206920356,
-0.0140070552,
0.0487943478,
-0.0225936882,
0.0034997556,
0.0254577491,
-0.0512274317,
0.0204328354,
-0.0434651338,
-0.0223900434,
-0.0249119848,
-0.0387731642,
-0.0163945928,
-0.0014329891,
0.0406873748,
0.0044029611,
0.0117424401,
0.0501125865,
-0.0239236839,
0.0514475666,
-0.0058354093,
0.0039596348,
-0.0061690281,
0.0189230721,
-0.0250352584,
-0.0707396269,
0.0171672888,
-0.0342842862,
0.0240132939,
0.0130139245,
0.0333914347,
-0.0115102362,
-0.0465678163,
-0.0268207286,
0.0084668836,
0.0009207769,
-0.0047307308,
-0.0213580187,
0.0173191763,
-0.0493934266,
-0.0065129227,
0.0722406209,
0.0139933582,
-0.0548474006,
0.014771116,
-0.004711411,
0.055335138,
-0.0068686544,
0.0372077599,
-0.0389899015,
-0.0093722455,
0.0181413479,
0.0528797358,
0.0225979667,
0.0100653265,
-0.0549876243,
-0.1222468689,
0.0037531303,
0.0544424653,
-0.0767026767,
-0.0222204104,
-0.0229381509,
-0.0565664023,
-0.0318244062,
0.0574628226,
0.0073323715,
0.0099265557,
0.0099877315,
0.0384343155,
0.0598195381,
-0.0647859797,
-0.0217842441,
-0.0231108777,
0.058083728,
0.0025981597,
-0.0032156815,
0.0016692149,
0.0344270878,
0.0451019444,
-0.007598104,
0.0151509559,
-0.0230464935,
-0.0141361216,
0.0176510364,
-0.0452432968,
0.0110189887,
0.0024277708,
-0.0346450172,
0.0530367456,
0.0348047018,
0.060109552,
-0.0200842544,
-0.0028777577,
0.0355830826,
-0.0410476141,
0.0381437913,
0.0125010302,
0.0258441474,
-0.0433842316,
-0.0051940051,
-0.0001060911,
-0.0293292757,
-0.0587614439,
0.0042690104,
-0.0049004927,
-0.0137709985,
-0.0173391141,
-0.0810657442,
-0.0657708943,
0.0057977638,
0.0578452274,
0.0285106916,
-0.0133842658,
0.0475802124,
-0.0033623266,
-0.0480474159,
0.0300982408,
-0.0455715135,
-0.0074964063,
-0.0556639656,
0.0233999267,
0.0182523392,
0.0009368099,
0.023325542,
-0.0047040386,
-0.1067761108,
-0.0542601347,
-0.0094073126,
0.0423988216,
0.0251374301,
0.0157331228,
-0.0015787511,
-0.0365685262,
-0.0208137631,
0.0239707734,
-0.0291905459,
0.0055392673,
-0.0056274333,
-0.0206829831,
-0.0032618255,
0.0511806197,
0.0185210593,
0.0142724793,
0.0035475839,
0.0430346504,
-0.0085221222,
-0.00784826,
0.019248778,
0.007807828,
0.006006415,
-0.0768276155,
-0.0051813931,
-0.0280597433,
0.0159865022,
-0.0022579005,
0.0136585226,
-0.0599931292,
-0.0319059342,
0.0671967342,
0.0318575427,
-0.0097563788,
-0.0372505337,
0.0115007097,
-0.0055619227,
0.0227101855,
-0.0322365128,
-0.0387051515,
0.0536229387,
0.0158051122,
0.0175357908,
-0.0234314874,
0.0238257088,
-0.03915824,
0.0036946333,
-0.037271522,
0.0823166892,
-0.0012863933,
0.0074643479,
0.0059390226,
0.007628947,
0.0362407565,
-0.0151272528,
-0.025875818,
0.0153105268,
0.0711737201,
0.0246695634,
0.0601071306,
-0.0201376136,
-0.0204734225,
-0.0172463544,
0.0167587791,
-0.0089308964,
-0.0103406254,
-0.0091219461,
0.0032914863,
-0.002345613,
0.078771241,
0.0750768483,
0.0160564482,
0.0093935141,
0.0245723445,
0.0507634692,
-0.0034637132,
-0.0022157445,
-0.0210033506,
0.0184109919,
-0.0271185059,
-0.0328788497,
-0.0620519258,
-0.0637408867,
-0.0401106775,
0.0260608178,
-0.0144082382,
0.0030904692,
-0.0038688097,
0.0350929312,
-0.0223259479,
0.0255639125,
-0.0382266529,
0.0281817093,
-0.0442849696,
0.0087984689,
-0.0281259604,
-6.315309604e-33,
-0.0366719179,
0.0259340443,
0.0380010083,
-0.031447541,
-0.0257952884,
-0.0154435737,
-0.0321886577,
-0.0190891847,
-0.0142438672,
-0.0151212336,
-0.0412955284,
0.0169650335,
0.025147412,
0.0299984943,
0.0195212122,
0.0096536791,
0.0444430001,
-0.0111870328,
-0.0036374794,
0.0341863185,
0.0303279217,
0.0112935109,
0.077960901,
-0.0605490915,
0.0058316225,
-0.0358625241,
-0.0164984204,
0.0131623456,
-0.0284625813,
-0.0027093457,
-0.0229069032,
0.0200495068,
0.0141321113,
-0.0274969414,
-0.0132513558,
-0.0488756821,
-0.0779550076,
0.0063742497,
0.020222865,
0.0445392691,
-0.0153980674,
-0.0223248135,
0.0350636356,
-0.0247716308,
-0.0098631056,
-0.0177779272,
-0.0456596911,
-0.0307466574,
-0.0527878143,
0.0297073629,
-0.0387859084,
0.0194979031,
0.0066071227,
0.0139954267,
0.0324431881,
0.0491476655,
-0.0505431779,
-0.0268211421,
-0.0988078415,
-0.010798269,
-0.0152401356,
0.0396958701,
0.0554757975,
0.0383182615,
-0.0176474247,
-0.0040932181,
0.0797576085,
0.0021847894,
0.0663140342,
0.0572486147,
0.0486788936,
-0.0094824927,
0.0597828552,
0.035430301,
0.071630232,
-0.0167929083,
-0.0649572462,
-0.0144324061,
0.0031518012,
-0.034674786,
0.0221316237,
-0.0286662541,
-0.0434378199,
-0.0368923359,
-0.0211345069,
-0.0815123171,
-0.0304049719,
-0.0301906839,
0.0178023316,
0.0218334701,
-0.01568803,
0.0176048074,
0.0485285558,
-0.0265816934,
0.0312372111,
-0.0020366549,
-0.0068780826,
0.0142095471,
-0.0324593037,
0.0290395841,
-0.0449059345,
-0.0404616073,
-0.0245999936,
0.055035647,
0.0003360126,
-0.030188702,
0.0550484769,
0.018980138,
-0.0367409997,
0.0230807178,
-0.0452066027,
0.003379293,
-0.0103889862,
0.0131160049,
0.0229400601,
-0.0079129739,
0.0091507332,
0.0373361334,
0.0394234508,
0.0010934483,
0.0116398912,
0.0142941168,
0.023672618,
-0.0022278982,
-0.0293256342,
0.0341334268,
-0.0216426756,
0.0248263683,
0.0547449104,
-0.0316488668,
-0.0125218891,
0.0247784145,
2.731e-7,
0.027543949,
0.0314307772,
0.0436243042,
-0.0251146462,
0.0070372098,
0.0091320705,
-0.0156290997,
0.0048207319,
0.0091957571,
0.057304576,
0.0334375724,
0.0060069435,
0.0928651989,
0.0227653775,
-0.1104840934,
-0.033348076,
-0.0471794903,
0.0397955924,
-0.0634956732,
-0.0323927477,
-0.0237035025,
0.0720304921,
-0.0051103029,
-0.0394735746,
0.0077680782,
-0.0211948082,
0.0682887137,
0.0343792662,
-0.0319405682,
0.0151646063,
0.0336547606,
0.0562286004,
-0.0271806214,
-0.0433865488,
-0.03246722,
0.0024475632,
0.0042227875,
0.0988554657,
-0.0072307624,
-0.0016921031,
0.0457325093,
-0.0076618758,
-0.0664835572,
-0.0320660211,
0.0446102433,
-0.0379275791,
-0.0026957009,
0.0403027683,
0.0247350056,
0.0284830108,
0.0008128,
-0.0482730418,
-0.0077902121,
0.0123750214,
0.0403784849,
-0.0450874418,
-0.0484704711,
0.0000378452,
-0.0350679718,
-0.002463198,
-0.005696936,
-0.0412489213,
-0.038376186,
0.0334538966,
0.0181696527,
-0.0054288101,
-0.0031501921,
2.021050396e-34,
0.0375851355,
-0.0042788154,
0.0352843814,
-0.0453733504,
-0.0052095372,
-0.0313004814,
-0.0076721758,
-0.0116038872,
-0.0155151244,
-0.0329149924,
-0.0287555773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04916v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04916v2 | Explainable Identification of Hate Speech towards Islam using Graph Neural Networks | 2023-11-02T04:01:04 | 2023-12-10T15:46:54 | Azmine Toushik Wasi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SI | Islamophobic language is a prevalent challenge on online social interaction
platforms. Identifying and eliminating such hatred is a crucial step towards a
future of harmony and peace. This study presents a novel paradigm for
identifying and explaining hate speech towards Islam using graph neural
networks. Utilizing the intrinsic ability of graph neural networks to find,
extract, and use relationships across disparate data points, our model
consistently achieves outstanding performance while offering explanations for
the underlying correlations and causation. | [
0.0479094833,
0.0987599939,
-0.0220718589,
0.0286963619,
-0.01726464,
0.0332520083,
0.0587087572,
-0.0038570457,
0.0200154446,
0.012634078,
0.0235811714,
-0.0086310059,
0.0136315562,
0.0408473946,
0.0305534434,
-0.0245456379,
0.0127804345,
0.0330468565,
0.0267151557,
-0.0287026428,
0.0447650254,
0.0298986789,
-0.0058966707,
0.0144470716,
-0.0681881979,
-0.0041217264,
0.0107466225,
0.0004717572,
0.0043303822,
0.017165117,
-0.0051753516,
-0.01195681,
0.0269179773,
0.0723032728,
0.0000016286,
-0.0178080164,
0.008637663,
-0.0016011787,
-0.0460369401,
-0.0494896285,
0.0352826267,
-0.0315768383,
0.0058466387,
-0.0090141427,
-0.0257518459,
-0.0105111431,
0.0447657481,
0.0858910456,
0.059702456,
0.0693696961,
0.0015831902,
-0.0741971582,
-0.0018887231,
0.0123064946,
-0.0014850668,
0.0463655628,
0.0178277027,
-0.0214769971,
-0.0217819903,
-0.0333834849,
-0.0480809473,
-0.0185406469,
0.0403172225,
-0.0126187271,
0.0413514674,
-0.0551652238,
-0.0037411896,
-0.0254907403,
0.0257551242,
0.0769449025,
-0.0278391093,
-0.0209964626,
0.0458482951,
-0.0088852001,
-0.020220723,
0.0298248027,
-0.0394071266,
-0.0382017717,
-0.0417970642,
0.0135871815,
0.0023225211,
-0.0056348885,
0.1099488661,
0.0325535685,
-0.0036501528,
0.0504791886,
-0.0481349304,
-0.0042033335,
-0.0090900026,
-0.0455246083,
-0.0445327386,
0.0289451219,
0.0170531869,
0.0317534283,
-0.0343340002,
-0.0009423185,
-0.0236164704,
-0.0274090562,
-0.0500733256,
-0.0481100269,
0.0456786528,
0.0289959442,
0.0439366139,
-0.0077259168,
0.0039336928,
0.0425168425,
-0.0114266798,
0.0165944509,
-0.0111804567,
0.0089363735,
-0.0602363124,
0.019538071,
0.0085764499,
-0.0034789033,
0.0169229135,
-0.0039570779,
-0.0468974337,
0.0027007146,
-0.0637107417,
-0.0074633751,
0.0011690354,
0.0406900905,
0.0402589627,
-0.029446587,
0.0174484123,
0.0157441758,
-0.0345001183,
-0.0033862668,
-0.0376448892,
-0.0543260276,
0.0163601637,
0.0451321118,
0.0186128635,
0.0114780795,
0.0176859237,
0.116226241,
0.0593576059,
0.0121492716,
-0.0302002523,
-0.0207269788,
-0.0045957984,
-0.0304934476,
0.0343810022,
-0.0192240234,
0.0247503668,
0.00140727,
-0.0640790835,
-0.0623356402,
0.0145829506,
0.0125571936,
-0.0556452572,
0.0775715858,
0.0032125749,
0.0123180943,
0.0470686406,
-0.0003280246,
0.0152700003,
-0.0043123704,
0.0174077749,
0.0119153699,
0.0408034958,
-0.0214368142,
-0.0032270225,
0.0251146685,
0.0781762376,
-0.0169236958,
-0.0330284834,
-0.0137578603,
-0.0822346658,
0.0070734876,
0.0059173927,
0.0100450423,
-0.0160979014,
-0.0471078306,
0.0180744566,
0.0489570573,
-0.0112786824,
0.0340742022,
0.059451364,
0.041811794,
-0.0248327591,
-0.0045563532,
-0.0473728701,
-0.0001353681,
0.0219360869,
-0.0219517108,
0.0309648216,
0.0368409194,
-0.0276618693,
-0.0391521305,
-0.0031712784,
-0.0253475718,
0.0946099907,
-0.0131003354,
0.0430439785,
0.0123368595,
-0.0212945361,
0.0002238543,
0.0563989431,
-0.0055457018,
-0.0071039135,
-0.0518625267,
-0.0076544345,
0.047495123,
0.0030897658,
0.0239414386,
-0.0152855096,
-0.040200837,
-0.001606408,
0.018286515,
0.0109336348,
-0.0050359191,
-0.0040081218,
-0.0328429863,
0.0034441685,
0.0051380717,
0.0076894206,
0.0141375829,
0.0409939401,
-0.0295991953,
0.008488168,
-0.0154670086,
-0.0348544903,
0.0099304439,
0.0477221012,
-0.0150014004,
-0.0054570241,
0.0328110717,
0.0311775971,
0.0223682653,
0.0030633847,
-0.0186851062,
0.0198814031,
-0.0112944227,
-0.0475775301,
0.0191894062,
-0.0462165587,
0.0275512617,
0.0063484432,
-0.0476440266,
-0.0061516953,
0.0535620451,
-0.022339588,
-0.0138127347,
0.1226607263,
-0.0329893753,
-0.0045548077,
0.0217546858,
-0.03397315,
-0.043093171,
0.0199992619,
0.0153565416,
0.0815036371,
-0.0252387524,
0.0298783872,
0.0143824676,
-0.0380193442,
0.0407860167,
0.0280728843,
0.0045032152,
-0.0450909846,
-0.048373349,
0.0226061661,
-0.0173852667,
-0.043160025,
-0.0002728503,
0.0625181273,
-0.0607294887,
-0.0308864936,
0.0069059078,
0.0051411004,
-0.0060381992,
0.0027554471,
-0.0032464592,
0.0025366649,
-0.0205399375,
0.0344231389,
0.0649662241,
0.0208381917,
0.0549277626,
-0.0811211914,
-0.0187915154,
-0.0261966065,
-0.0502505377,
-0.0405693576,
0.0893687829,
0.0603380501,
-0.0564340502,
0.0479746163,
-0.0432800576,
-0.0605081692,
0.0022120473,
-0.0239383169,
-0.0408643708,
0.0108103091,
0.0221189056,
-0.0485652387,
0.013686073,
0.0184188187,
0.0814291388,
-0.0215529073,
0.0194250345,
-0.0093550226,
-0.0192392953,
-0.051444307,
0.0333159193,
-0.0333062746,
-0.0265849736,
-0.0489429645,
0.0564538874,
0.0597196817,
-0.0298121236,
-0.0520156883,
0.0448916778,
-0.0599861108,
0.0005412397,
-0.0333048031,
-0.105823189,
0.0343786366,
-0.0203461275,
-0.0603673048,
-0.0718099996,
0.0605320521,
0.0316053517,
0.0396881141,
0.063339673,
-0.0349875689,
-0.0412491709,
0.0075672809,
0.0324456431,
0.0281630941,
-0.0202898476,
-0.0253579225,
-0.0107403956,
-0.0300480332,
0.0191242173,
-0.0160732325,
-0.0171754397,
0.0000099535,
0.020360129,
0.0226389375,
-0.0044087199,
-0.0413714014,
-0.034671165,
-0.0300515592,
-0.0239209514,
0.0125475284,
-0.0255476553,
0.0166704468,
0.0098447669,
0.0278014373,
-0.0373682901,
-0.0106964577,
0.015531634,
0.038057562,
-0.0339834318,
-0.0161340479,
-0.0025259724,
0.0426765494,
-0.0332572833,
-0.0391426571,
0.0035079778,
0.0070100175,
0.0064384928,
-0.07425078,
0.0110608945,
-0.0567872673,
0.0205399878,
-0.0209232867,
-0.0541798361,
0.0034989549,
-0.0425262451,
0.0320715047,
0.0687853992,
-0.0325642377,
-0.0049181026,
0.0114692915,
0.0144061912,
-0.033265017,
-0.0036850295,
0.0060188794,
-0.105332464,
0.0095468583,
-0.0179097429,
0.0200270973,
-0.023857221,
-0.0526496768,
0.0098433485,
-0.0197678171,
-0.0069332644,
0.0085301725,
0.0018091562,
-0.0456990153,
-0.0191954393,
0.0036227992,
0.0001074471,
0.0135932602,
-0.0601632297,
0.024993619,
0.0372918285,
0.0187545661,
-0.0771318525,
0.0124325398,
0.0157047454,
-0.0090234596,
0.0059922552,
-0.0047771786,
0.042927064,
0.0002625344,
0.0165466014,
0.0368474051,
0.0171150602,
-0.0093005104,
-0.0326941647,
0.0756768659,
0.0335724391,
-0.0385950357,
-0.0389384553,
0.0419540294,
-0.0522207618,
-0.0114929844,
-0.0424971208,
0.0570357367,
0.0128392633,
0.0005000298,
-0.0185156334,
0.0315106139,
-0.0092630247,
0.0213051438,
0.034313038,
-0.0369791202,
-0.0102344761,
-0.0704535097,
-0.0233293716,
-0.0749289095,
-0.0754708648,
-0.018112883,
0.0242505092,
-0.0160727408,
-0.0164305381,
-0.0213123579,
-0.0402229317,
0.0242406204,
0.0215631649,
-0.0214410312,
0.0285017379,
-0.0306319315,
-0.0867612436,
0.0060445881,
0.0410636403,
0.0254543703,
0.0194160361,
0.0060177613,
-0.0336048752,
-0.0431653373,
-0.0252189916,
0.0205994137,
-0.0365980938,
-0.0368997492,
0.0488062352,
0.00825339,
0.0209780894,
0.0384806506,
-0.0168419387,
-0.0228327718,
0.0290569048,
0.0254418608,
0.0030453906,
-0.0280189943,
0.0466866232,
0.0051366421,
0.0160830412,
0.0360621586,
0.0118376967,
0.0335324816,
0.0437324196,
-0.0723401904,
-0.0714211613,
0.0046390402,
-0.0318351611,
-0.0271937866,
0.0173024554,
0.0561778434,
-0.0504510291,
-0.0695457906,
-0.0088002086,
0.0044188933,
-0.0134381624,
0.0042697857,
-0.0334470682,
0.0002504518,
0.0169357229,
-0.0384744108,
-0.1082494333,
0.0171103682,
-0.0040407041,
-0.0381309241,
0.0086317761,
-0.0068989685,
0.0062268055,
-0.0008493742,
0.0212818049,
0.0152817955,
0.0482783727,
0.0029443726,
-0.0339500755,
-0.0295720566,
0.0468334928,
0.0103691462,
0.0162747204,
0.0353445075,
-0.0374272466,
-0.0067433137,
-0.0557292923,
-0.0300171264,
-0.0504268259,
-0.0073677665,
-0.0099363467,
0.0159159023,
0.0737880617,
0.0082659982,
-0.0131216748,
0.0887816176,
-0.0101236003,
-0.0434131697,
0.0018862553,
0.0332583636,
-0.0317259021,
0.0197344963,
0.0210631005,
0.0358787961,
0.0203101747,
0.0623923354,
-0.0412829332,
-0.0069677527,
-0.0033670084,
-0.0103421304,
0.0506311506,
0.0179692935,
0.0275331847,
-0.0325738154,
-0.0696722865,
0.0294049215,
-0.0180479679,
0.0211569499,
0.000808584,
0.0289258771,
0.066476211,
-0.0009560637,
0.0091716722,
-0.0416680053,
0.0549957827,
-0.0242760889,
-0.0413422883,
0.0291272458,
-4.986276222e-33,
-0.0083111031,
-0.0531340465,
-0.0235265736,
0.0146025596,
-0.0275645219,
0.0060759364,
-0.0031332499,
-0.0202405024,
-0.0528528877,
0.0527288876,
0.0039982367,
0.0713172853,
0.0015812741,
0.0195811037,
-0.0180517863,
-0.0654730797,
0.0239022132,
0.0024420361,
0.0352601968,
0.0377106741,
0.0780069381,
0.0322265215,
0.034752246,
-0.0839450732,
0.0353510119,
-0.0234468672,
0.0071888953,
-0.0124078374,
0.0289478973,
0.0666807294,
-0.0127073601,
0.0724467039,
0.0546828918,
0.0029288437,
0.0099155782,
0.0195312146,
-0.0502924994,
-0.0107407132,
0.0343212634,
0.0137128169,
-0.0150116077,
-0.0131386993,
0.0433779284,
-0.0110711409,
-0.026170373,
-0.0157742817,
0.0529660881,
-0.0020393024,
-0.008314658,
-0.0089136846,
-0.0554026179,
0.028944945,
-0.0329613052,
0.020102011,
-0.0069853798,
0.0041285618,
0.0266269017,
-0.0132697951,
-0.047180552,
0.0252408441,
-0.0362732708,
-0.0281148385,
-0.0163268596,
-0.0036440811,
0.0168645121,
0.0650195703,
0.0123836547,
-0.0000738177,
-0.0578522347,
0.0363131799,
-0.0050856955,
0.0338726342,
0.0689686388,
0.037069153,
-0.0203290414,
-0.0764612928,
-0.1014086157,
-0.0358982347,
0.0380144566,
-0.0081999088,
-0.0131137222,
-0.0201398674,
-0.0333043225,
-0.0253307112,
0.0100974832,
-0.073057957,
-0.0334110409,
-0.0210219342,
-0.0228010323,
-0.0419099778,
-0.0292615648,
0.0127809467,
-0.0163905788,
-0.0610094145,
0.0214345343,
0.0865497589,
0.0161392633,
0.0038451061,
0.0158324465,
0.0149060776,
-0.0354462229,
0.0087868851,
-0.0465564728,
-0.0054381234,
0.0638630539,
0.0097558321,
0.0491560623,
0.0417548306,
-0.0316711329,
-0.0037019828,
-0.0360051356,
-0.0059704357,
-0.0489208065,
0.0496087261,
0.0348237008,
0.0704434142,
-0.039327804,
-0.0178619809,
0.0451641046,
0.018738078,
0.0233980045,
0.0250880811,
-0.0423673876,
0.0155441258,
-0.0177606605,
-0.0485186093,
-0.023771096,
0.0455442742,
0.0076106461,
-0.1223891452,
0.0064557809,
-0.0347191021,
2.296e-7,
0.0182821937,
0.0218522549,
0.0308048073,
0.0061405539,
0.0287200753,
0.0136353774,
0.0601815954,
-0.0123805553,
-0.0432299189,
0.0054796003,
0.0088675702,
0.0615954995,
0.0026270042,
0.0194726679,
0.0001726512,
-0.0005381384,
-0.0503137112,
-0.023794014,
-0.059305463,
0.0451974832,
-0.0262006372,
0.0464849919,
0.0670249537,
-0.016221717,
-0.0190333668,
-0.0190880839,
0.0076142591,
-0.0156976003,
-0.0166444145,
-0.0311344098,
0.03468116,
-0.0185982566,
-0.0086174747,
-0.0104918489,
-0.0217083059,
0.0230394732,
0.0275382381,
0.0200623181,
0.0082664005,
0.015381176,
0.0096042156,
-0.0351709947,
0.0141645921,
-0.0118586943,
0.0348941386,
-0.0033912517,
-0.0440730266,
-0.0299894121,
-0.0234708562,
-0.0078212339,
0.0084698116,
0.0159828998,
0.0354427397,
-0.008888375,
0.021587804,
-0.0209909901,
0.0141740581,
-0.0583926141,
0.0175244864,
-0.0176049676,
-0.0080675334,
0.0109454002,
-0.0209052861,
-0.0262713637,
0.0839549378,
0.0837361887,
-0.0029428254,
1.649287106e-34,
0.0347722135,
0.000582022,
-0.0196649022,
-0.0624899827,
0.0708226562,
0.0136369765,
-0.0543039069,
0.0143055152,
0.0663178489,
-0.0296716187,
-0.0166490972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00967v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00967v2 | Vision-Language Interpreter for Robot Task Planning | 2023-11-02T03:32:30 | 2024-02-20T03:13:30 | Keisuke Shirai, Cristian C. Beltran-Hernandez, Masashi Hamaya, Atsushi Hashimoto, Shohei Tanaka, Kento Kawaharazuka, Kazutoshi Tanaka, Yoshitaka Ushiku, Shinsuke Mori | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are accelerating the development of
language-guided robot planners. Meanwhile, symbolic planners offer the
advantage of interpretability. This paper proposes a new task that bridges
these two trends, namely, multimodal planning problem specification. The aim is
to generate a problem description (PD), a machine-readable file used by the
planners to find a plan. By generating PDs from language instruction and scene
observation, we can drive symbolic planners in a language-guided framework. We
propose a Vision-Language Interpreter (ViLaIn), a new framework that generates
PDs using state-of-the-art LLM and vision-language models. ViLaIn can refine
generated PDs via error message feedback from the symbolic planner. Our aim is
to answer the question: How accurately can ViLaIn and the symbolic planner
generate valid robot plans? To evaluate ViLaIn, we introduce a novel dataset
called the problem description generation (ProDG) dataset. The framework is
evaluated with four new evaluation metrics. Experimental results show that
ViLaIn can generate syntactically correct problems with more than 99\% accuracy
and valid plans with more than 58\% accuracy. Our code and dataset are
available at https://github.com/omron-sinicx/ViLaIn. | [
0.023723457,
0.0344518162,
0.0065097567,
0.0409034938,
-0.0457636118,
0.0018940245,
-0.0066084778,
-0.0330750234,
-0.0000480812,
-0.0457061455,
0.0103267841,
0.0173291713,
-0.0039524701,
0.0554568581,
0.0037349935,
-0.0713343695,
0.0121799763,
-0.0531081632,
-0.0232546795,
0.0217639003,
-0.0158419143,
0.0054029766,
-0.0313880257,
0.0359285809,
-0.0127571542,
-0.0003029584,
-0.0646283105,
0.0315253921,
-0.0049676485,
-0.0666345805,
-0.063894175,
-0.0072277822,
0.0564617254,
0.0046122046,
0.0000019291,
-0.0770294741,
-0.0061819898,
-0.0128171006,
0.0432846211,
-0.0471983664,
0.0132599929,
-0.070577912,
0.0188116711,
0.0006251352,
-0.006456634,
-0.0087425048,
0.0559965447,
0.0496708527,
0.0720068142,
0.0489385389,
0.0023064718,
-0.0275942944,
-0.008982732,
0.0366953537,
0.026995156,
0.0192320328,
0.0091819204,
0.0319337025,
0.0253654961,
-0.0073232092,
-0.0188455358,
0.0105080241,
0.0197138172,
-0.0448083654,
-0.0347449966,
0.0023469124,
-0.029569326,
-0.0544456467,
-0.0106886122,
0.0445702635,
-0.0024040188,
-0.0050114542,
0.0140549811,
-0.0016110757,
-0.0143329678,
-0.0000826573,
-0.0378081426,
0.0677196085,
-0.0314849541,
-0.0051485691,
-0.0265238881,
-0.0209243763,
0.0041777012,
-0.0386938751,
-0.0150085492,
0.0606633574,
-0.0073007722,
0.0016661182,
-0.0041514337,
-0.0085644936,
-0.013123774,
-0.0724110603,
0.0207874756,
0.050877817,
-0.0337735191,
0.0269980356,
-0.0352209173,
0.0017840241,
-0.0391199253,
-0.0171637181,
0.0589849502,
0.0675947741,
-0.0435605049,
0.0265832022,
-0.0218119137,
0.1146528795,
-0.0012587913,
0.0459263176,
-0.0559649654,
0.003013165,
-0.0477626249,
0.0341252387,
-0.0631964058,
-0.0191828497,
-0.0351032726,
0.0049100118,
-0.0010387622,
0.0694973469,
0.0000471787,
0.037818104,
0.0048729428,
-0.0183174163,
-0.0104501303,
-0.0242716242,
-0.0649270415,
-0.0318156816,
-0.031876076,
-0.019761432,
-0.0259823166,
0.0033025073,
0.0110121714,
0.066746071,
0.0003063261,
0.001668727,
-0.0185088851,
0.131542623,
-0.0104586668,
0.0056358338,
0.009602705,
-0.0420831889,
0.0041626804,
-0.0522416793,
0.0308564138,
-0.0535245501,
0.0277237538,
-0.0142812915,
-0.022517262,
-0.0289035961,
0.0226835404,
0.0017211995,
0.0507778712,
0.0510583371,
-0.0280146189,
0.0348864235,
-0.011997967,
0.0173079595,
-0.0345217772,
0.0735218748,
0.0652530193,
0.0485978797,
0.0058081807,
0.0282803234,
0.0005847868,
0.0544938147,
-0.0425642468,
-0.0174555425,
-0.0228432473,
-0.0030079863,
-0.0037056343,
0.0534984805,
-0.00912893,
0.0162909646,
-0.0090952907,
-0.00114812,
-0.0252669584,
0.0246163327,
0.0169843975,
-0.0078580342,
0.0860310867,
0.0126354452,
-0.0041049379,
-0.0414504744,
-0.0339756981,
0.0168511756,
-0.0151110152,
-0.0084212599,
-0.0921945795,
-0.0164320022,
-0.0139340525,
-0.0639924631,
-0.0147252008,
0.0110682147,
0.0292700082,
-0.0163224433,
0.0581710041,
0.0281024408,
-0.050658185,
-0.0112302117,
-0.0291895717,
-0.0377093293,
-0.0259600244,
0.0146481274,
0.0105986586,
0.068680428,
0.0236942079,
-0.0327217504,
-0.0157170314,
0.0163044184,
0.0060029235,
-0.0002428928,
0.0082390448,
-0.0205708332,
0.0373429209,
-0.039906159,
-0.0401744843,
-0.0151711926,
-0.0090231784,
0.0412619822,
0.0082376711,
-0.0168621112,
-0.006193609,
-0.0202568471,
-0.0129446276,
0.061814893,
0.0173152853,
-0.0076284581,
0.0066975979,
-0.0001850735,
0.0330086425,
0.006662976,
-0.0228295699,
0.0052126092,
0.0497578159,
-0.0471372344,
0.0349978842,
0.0387341194,
-0.0138577949,
-0.0275103599,
0.0433476456,
-0.0675417483,
-0.0442509763,
0.034474656,
-0.0500165224,
-0.0303908195,
0.0120295472,
-0.0244848318,
-0.0216039959,
-0.0032590954,
0.0065919431,
0.0125002172,
-0.0540825129,
-0.0359793119,
0.0243437979,
-0.0153244101,
-0.0524294153,
0.076799117,
0.0313147455,
0.0249049161,
-0.0192340519,
0.0045407331,
0.0371910185,
0.0147152431,
-0.0236117542,
0.022038009,
0.0526880585,
-0.017211182,
-0.0280225072,
-0.0823392943,
-0.0219411477,
-0.0127730891,
-0.0246786121,
0.0057790289,
-0.051608026,
0.0138401631,
-0.0054617119,
0.0113602672,
0.0874052867,
-0.0015022354,
-0.0334703773,
0.0238875467,
0.0291919261,
-0.0547286645,
-0.0141519643,
0.0074860747,
-0.0331069194,
-0.0138692977,
0.0651940331,
-0.058359161,
-0.0882050171,
0.0708567947,
-0.034010604,
0.0232425127,
-0.0364998691,
0.0024784158,
0.025564665,
-0.0271632895,
0.0122004123,
0.0378572904,
-0.0355979949,
0.0257462654,
0.0835493132,
-0.0198725723,
-0.0349055044,
0.0215704907,
0.0075059407,
-0.0386640318,
-0.026037436,
-0.0398517475,
-0.0000956382,
0.0333759673,
-0.0190036576,
0.0447015949,
-0.0440586321,
0.0106583796,
0.023007609,
-0.0388118327,
-0.022024285,
-0.0202903394,
-0.0205267854,
0.0546560176,
-0.0116989212,
-0.0585049912,
0.0371556208,
-0.0368467309,
-0.0045166351,
0.0403235182,
-0.0188415833,
-0.024836408,
0.1054210067,
0.0331248268,
0.0136378296,
0.0168815013,
0.0021658284,
-0.0343442373,
-0.0123173455,
-0.0060195229,
0.0388422795,
0.0359889343,
-0.124546729,
0.013937695,
-0.0092285732,
-0.0046219574,
-0.028605165,
0.0304518323,
-0.0422453582,
0.0333594047,
-0.0347610749,
-0.0394976288,
-0.0188759584,
0.0061367359,
0.0300304051,
0.0381922163,
0.0027446439,
-0.0231432002,
-0.0471975058,
-0.0503891483,
0.0032142738,
0.0521939211,
-0.0322234891,
-0.0273850597,
0.0039001156,
0.028886484,
0.0240865834,
-0.0145553369,
-0.0606991351,
0.0228664204,
0.0190740731,
0.0361907966,
0.0217763167,
0.0234450828,
0.0733611807,
-0.056584511,
-0.0311231185,
0.0506461039,
0.0037614186,
-0.0150959296,
0.0124983257,
-0.0231206976,
0.0121292444,
0.0540723763,
0.0394981429,
-0.0563677959,
-0.0375582203,
0.0124013936,
0.0015876106,
-0.0003225589,
-0.0275384579,
-0.0664575323,
-0.0568794981,
0.0580236502,
0.0116382502,
-0.0189392511,
-0.0607948415,
0.0081015136,
-0.0317663439,
-0.0009042432,
-0.053389363,
0.0210883915,
0.0131964916,
-0.0070342817,
0.0048317215,
-0.0255830344,
0.0136275776,
0.0214310829,
0.0091910334,
-0.0020606471,
0.0678169131,
-0.0065466603,
0.0137036201,
-0.007643105,
0.0347688049,
0.0589590818,
0.0318758152,
-0.0350698717,
-0.0311630629,
-0.0177680422,
-0.0147151919,
0.0251344386,
0.0095097516,
-0.0640262365,
-0.0603634045,
0.0299806446,
0.0628323555,
-0.0329125673,
0.0065776547,
-0.044651974,
0.0081798751,
-0.0103416415,
0.0365726687,
-0.014452666,
0.0061639273,
-0.0331296362,
-0.070204854,
-0.0336300433,
-0.0432980917,
-0.0245006848,
-0.0109765353,
-0.0048732357,
0.0109269852,
-0.0361803435,
-0.0372172222,
0.0877289027,
0.0530006215,
-0.0137232328,
-0.0842912197,
-0.0087918779,
0.0157893896,
-0.0681015104,
0.0440902263,
0.0054554525,
0.0155352,
-0.0259504486,
-0.0163263008,
-0.0138013605,
-0.0275051352,
0.0081647439,
0.0475275032,
-0.0585486516,
-0.0323310383,
-0.0121613704,
0.0817774758,
0.0184627641,
0.0136834774,
0.0250502154,
-0.0098147262,
-0.020692274,
0.0191726536,
0.0472496077,
0.0301764421,
-0.0011500001,
0.039715331,
0.0352613851,
0.0229707342,
-0.0546931438,
0.0008181384,
-0.0194194037,
0.0162614435,
-0.0201482642,
0.0124692908,
0.0304761175,
0.0497933924,
0.0132143022,
-0.0055922363,
-0.0213301722,
-0.0460150726,
0.0023926799,
-0.0702145472,
-0.0288685989,
-0.1060858741,
0.0652071461,
-0.0183309652,
-0.043192476,
0.084218502,
0.004154712,
-0.0318611935,
-0.026303811,
0.0325002261,
0.0151912309,
0.0453180782,
-0.0121968305,
0.0398052968,
0.026078701,
-0.0110681867,
0.0209128279,
-0.0241448544,
0.0314526334,
0.0284149181,
0.0583380908,
0.0273941699,
0.004043967,
-0.0301746409,
-0.0112143364,
-0.0072330157,
-0.1156542823,
0.0245921649,
0.0326732174,
0.0400230289,
0.0350321867,
0.0198256485,
-0.1009998396,
0.023106819,
-0.0039291405,
0.045166336,
0.0266027693,
-0.0427599289,
0.0686515719,
0.0283238869,
-0.0022623204,
-0.0458309613,
0.0480677821,
0.0089326296,
0.0415025875,
-0.0114909653,
0.0000629148,
-0.052726835,
-0.0236881301,
0.0314346924,
0.0197649971,
-0.0085496642,
-0.0146740125,
-0.0314621888,
-0.04291391,
-0.0087997671,
0.0657680929,
-0.0003673672,
0.0025259752,
0.0575638562,
0.0142956506,
0.0109145194,
-0.0376005769,
-0.0001476784,
-0.0375874192,
0.0142434426,
-0.0296851173,
-0.0018556673,
-4.687832533e-33,
-0.0244195238,
-0.0799303725,
0.0697788745,
-0.0569757223,
0.0055273073,
-0.0096303467,
-0.0424911976,
0.0198900718,
0.0152673526,
0.0308254436,
0.0556753054,
-0.0385065787,
0.0017791025,
0.0080879861,
0.0214605983,
-0.0053734882,
0.0237508118,
0.0061834436,
-0.0384489298,
-0.0364224166,
0.0410721041,
-0.0078739412,
-0.0028671266,
-0.0312344208,
-0.0001855036,
0.0182411503,
-0.029857086,
0.0546112396,
0.0322276764,
0.0351257995,
0.0114427917,
0.0078349179,
0.0038958334,
0.0441130474,
-0.0605814233,
0.0333238468,
-0.0191087686,
-0.0538718887,
0.0043697162,
0.0542355776,
-0.1200676486,
-0.0167288873,
0.0419393852,
-0.0075085852,
-0.0202842541,
-0.009105443,
-0.0044788648,
-0.0123146558,
0.0226765033,
0.0161959231,
-0.0223078504,
0.0180503167,
-0.0210882332,
-0.0672417656,
0.0656249747,
0.0642552078,
0.0424166434,
0.0118375355,
0.0241341144,
-0.0087497178,
-0.0190999918,
-0.0184845794,
0.0967195034,
0.0009435694,
0.0201548226,
0.050478261,
0.0499667116,
-0.0191335548,
0.017506985,
0.0012964795,
-0.0283461455,
0.0765972361,
-0.0195718333,
0.0453253724,
-0.0274688751,
0.0611143373,
-0.0287050493,
0.0280304551,
-0.0488750041,
0.0850987285,
0.0213149879,
0.0170949306,
-0.0020578122,
0.0095555102,
-0.027122682,
-0.0064837551,
-0.0146433935,
-0.0090910792,
0.0306764152,
0.023617439,
0.0287220664,
-0.0047024824,
0.0328005664,
-0.0241621975,
0.0233818423,
0.0225332063,
-0.0669738799,
0.0388141908,
-0.0133665139,
0.0278387778,
-0.025325587,
-0.0243065469,
0.0417973362,
-0.0142645743,
0.0429571904,
0.013829655,
-0.0372886471,
0.0577228032,
-0.0048652543,
0.0024579722,
-0.0777288526,
-0.0143431127,
0.0116855511,
0.0122227166,
0.0388902463,
-0.0086772703,
-0.0335656404,
0.0360529572,
-0.00951155,
-0.1099275351,
0.0025964687,
-0.001841448,
0.0069477018,
0.0183100663,
-0.029747583,
-0.0156999417,
-0.0062019434,
-0.0114705637,
0.0198052507,
-0.0039876001,
0.005776579,
0.0272869449,
2.655e-7,
0.0178058054,
0.0372742116,
0.0323853567,
0.0606227666,
0.0112925284,
0.0405569747,
-0.0014892257,
0.0347589962,
-0.0472601168,
-0.0285705402,
0.0165787525,
0.0233119186,
0.0035374577,
0.0152498968,
-0.0161347669,
0.062684685,
0.0414906926,
-0.0567961149,
-0.0668487996,
0.0175195429,
0.0999345258,
0.0594747327,
-0.0295263436,
-0.0018755933,
0.023065608,
-0.0501417853,
0.0324281342,
-0.0636244491,
-0.0048904563,
-0.0186219532,
0.0142882438,
0.0035697634,
0.0002452529,
-0.0098713301,
0.0023612957,
-0.0346259326,
-0.0022584654,
0.0803012922,
-0.0145209394,
-0.0091916546,
-0.0001169377,
-0.0145141808,
-0.0382529795,
-0.0265734829,
0.01127824,
-0.0352782458,
0.0164389014,
0.0027328227,
0.0206269883,
-0.0159001555,
-0.0473625809,
-0.0041543338,
0.0315977074,
0.0165563077,
0.0066501563,
-0.0352181345,
-0.027723603,
-0.0148890121,
0.0017977859,
-0.0213393178,
-0.0324061476,
0.0012512171,
-0.0164623559,
-0.0030188283,
-0.001543048,
-0.007914342,
-0.0425962508,
2.090374946e-34,
0.0013600335,
0.0162158031,
-0.0070221564,
0.0292089712,
0.0332252383,
-0.0038185075,
-0.0503816679,
0.0344088301,
0.0192073751,
-0.0307878759,
-0.0558771938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10749v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10749v1 | Measuring Five Accountable Talk Moves to Improve Instruction at Scale | 2023-11-02T03:04:50 | 2023-11-02T03:04:50 | Ashlee Kupor, Candice Morgan, Dorottya Demszky | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Providing consistent, individualized feedback to teachers on their
instruction can improve student learning outcomes. Such feedback can especially
benefit novice instructors who teach on online platforms and have limited
access to instructional training. To build scalable measures of instruction, we
fine-tune RoBERTa and GPT models to identify five instructional talk moves
inspired by accountable talk theory: adding on, connecting, eliciting, probing
and revoicing students' ideas. We fine-tune these models on a newly annotated
dataset of 2500 instructor utterances derived from transcripts of small group
instruction in an online computer science course, Code in Place. Although we
find that GPT-3 consistently outperforms RoBERTa in terms of precision, its
recall varies significantly. We correlate the instructors' use of each talk
move with indicators of student engagement and satisfaction, including
students' section attendance, section ratings, and assignment completion rates.
We find that using talk moves generally correlates positively with student
outcomes, and connecting student ideas has the largest positive impact. These
results corroborate previous research on the effectiveness of accountable talk
moves and provide exciting avenues for using these models to provide
instructors with useful, scalable feedback. | [
0.0539445058,
0.0232181698,
-0.0517675094,
-0.0050945249,
-0.0386437327,
0.0134184519,
0.0143631622,
-0.047763627,
-0.0413575843,
-0.0136881378,
0.0186369456,
0.0415967554,
0.0146204177,
0.0139072565,
0.0227282681,
-0.0988591909,
-0.0030674473,
0.0097644664,
-0.0272181202,
0.0402127914,
0.0540233254,
-0.0174654536,
-0.0624528192,
0.0463666953,
0.028433783,
-0.0175487809,
-0.0540265851,
0.0074049332,
0.0116264382,
-0.0054818029,
0.0283569824,
0.025195498,
-0.0088041201,
0.0021086917,
0.0000022866,
-0.026148431,
-0.0265446175,
-0.0214527138,
-0.0459585562,
0.0927905664,
0.0038173341,
0.0732529536,
0.0274139047,
0.0401582383,
-0.0084288269,
0.0531756245,
0.0112725608,
0.0010985426,
0.0404194035,
0.0139590846,
0.0240958948,
0.0167788435,
0.0010364072,
0.0019690094,
0.0496750548,
-0.0132598281,
-0.0063183713,
0.077374652,
-0.0196920205,
0.0134343952,
-0.0672422424,
-0.0009369892,
-0.0019429761,
-0.0401891619,
0.0704898313,
0.0152415633,
-0.0639383346,
0.0162661746,
0.0113587976,
0.0160035118,
0.0653987303,
0.0284575056,
0.0236371774,
-0.0261241142,
0.0823608562,
0.0330567136,
-0.0785939693,
-0.010388609,
0.0002971229,
-0.0145552279,
-0.0561574735,
-0.0015068821,
-0.0317810141,
0.0495199785,
0.0506192483,
-0.0146811754,
-0.0469816029,
-0.0360034294,
-0.0189237073,
0.0501007289,
-0.0027495085,
0.0006677433,
0.0176357981,
0.0647125095,
0.0083740298,
0.033216916,
0.011098464,
0.0206194781,
-0.0064090192,
-0.016838979,
0.0640721396,
0.0394461155,
0.01925846,
-0.0053389957,
0.0266462918,
0.0848385394,
0.0305960756,
0.0479754694,
0.0042509641,
0.0769004822,
-0.0873992145,
0.0053914133,
-0.0239514541,
0.068866998,
0.0547614992,
-0.0021584241,
-0.0406828187,
0.0057750205,
-0.0626738071,
0.0594955049,
-0.0702955127,
0.0000957974,
-0.0067995139,
0.0632072389,
-0.014559269,
0.0677772537,
0.0058901492,
-0.0017385139,
0.0349495597,
-0.0500484072,
-0.0058114775,
0.0116017694,
-0.0198341142,
0.0504750945,
0.0107306521,
-0.0288468022,
-0.0249693133,
-0.0004683988,
0.0379112437,
-0.0401031226,
-0.0050476193,
0.0002961218,
-0.0043924386,
-0.0309244003,
-0.0543100946,
-0.0055867732,
0.005038457,
-0.0106872693,
0.0110771842,
0.0147449169,
0.0151961036,
0.0057516866,
0.0235881787,
0.0329846479,
0.0786405206,
0.0452172384,
-0.0148577699,
-0.010821267,
0.0246308632,
0.0121425474,
0.0360490531,
-0.0601048172,
0.0686858371,
0.0083881002,
0.0484166555,
0.0303056967,
0.0469750315,
0.0069259969,
0.0348313041,
0.0311811361,
-0.0392828658,
0.0146603901,
-0.0363471992,
0.0686574355,
0.0079989294,
0.0178225152,
-0.0087273465,
-0.019209981,
-0.014686699,
0.0464482494,
0.0004557522,
-0.0304809734,
-0.0059284084,
-0.0071996069,
0.011905455,
0.0149120633,
0.0597839281,
-0.0495545864,
-0.0185265988,
-0.0774469972,
-0.0171614364,
0.0045799143,
-0.0175252389,
0.038222719,
-0.0049323672,
-0.0237678234,
-0.023347754,
0.0016331131,
0.0021312747,
-0.0507683456,
0.0461362302,
-0.0762228817,
0.0314830951,
0.0585640669,
0.021957336,
0.0117997713,
-0.0391508713,
-0.0636810362,
0.0586621501,
0.0109418528,
0.0390426591,
-0.0025333834,
-0.0524497703,
-0.0199770555,
-0.0224245694,
-0.0366694592,
0.0114956405,
0.0389066674,
-0.0152415708,
0.0025482534,
-0.0049651633,
0.0076720743,
-0.0766338855,
0.0173271447,
-0.0070027728,
-0.0368363187,
-0.018258078,
0.0047670747,
0.0374479331,
0.0226589274,
-0.0048317439,
-0.0054779304,
-0.0072230552,
0.0652726367,
-0.0217965357,
-0.0323308147,
-0.0449271463,
0.027757166,
0.022618996,
-0.0238708332,
0.0068331226,
-0.0373710282,
-0.0089860335,
-0.0112056751,
0.0716638267,
-0.0291931331,
0.0180968568,
0.0052948422,
0.025091799,
-0.0341625251,
-0.0231475383,
0.0086390525,
-0.036413569,
0.0003194322,
0.032984145,
0.040217679,
-0.0064548231,
0.0096297339,
-0.0043662889,
0.0219267644,
-0.004404413,
-0.0441927947,
0.0109449485,
0.0190373901,
0.0045740884,
-0.0703445226,
-0.0178175997,
-0.0192215014,
-0.0372662321,
0.0077552404,
-0.001659243,
0.0052112066,
-0.0287477467,
-0.0154154124,
0.0357198715,
-0.031051375,
-0.0666654184,
-0.0009328324,
-0.0082872352,
-0.0010535585,
0.0345568545,
-0.0282507204,
-0.0335239246,
-0.0160245579,
-0.0056987633,
-0.0008594264,
0.079683505,
0.0013255366,
-0.043061845,
0.0181519724,
-0.0122300815,
-0.0464212075,
-0.0170686394,
-0.0557469241,
0.0179381613,
-0.029657172,
-0.0051581631,
0.0558398627,
0.0157511551,
0.0721875876,
-0.013859489,
-0.0591021292,
-0.0760021582,
0.0013724769,
-0.0104674976,
-0.047432024,
-0.0243393723,
-0.0624135174,
0.0040840409,
0.0182752702,
0.0299278609,
0.0089761335,
-0.0108204084,
-0.0524477437,
-0.0376929529,
0.0230787452,
-0.0199981853,
-0.0512899235,
0.0130371638,
-0.0385883152,
-0.0152981421,
-0.0026367514,
0.0168369077,
0.0253433548,
-0.0069517768,
-0.0215723794,
0.0076968465,
-0.0096101798,
0.025795497,
-0.004485094,
-0.0011700307,
-0.0210568644,
-0.0388353653,
0.0365786217,
-0.0642123446,
0.0717828199,
-0.0591319166,
0.0089702038,
-0.0416090637,
-0.0162004139,
0.0025640817,
0.0119066946,
-0.034124095,
0.0348037481,
0.0239555072,
-0.0333914347,
0.0242400859,
-0.0262382347,
-0.05297371,
-0.0383275189,
0.050560832,
-0.0156377889,
-0.0266973004,
-0.0445265509,
0.0404669419,
-0.0705068037,
-0.0082505327,
0.0111594675,
-0.0254738443,
-0.0546959341,
0.0649778172,
0.0336149596,
0.0872956589,
-0.0419458486,
0.0190119278,
-0.0278299563,
0.0247165132,
-0.0269249231,
0.0371540152,
0.047786504,
0.0616127439,
-0.0293862335,
-0.0668128207,
0.0739086866,
0.0128657222,
-0.0143370461,
-0.0376141779,
-0.0069270926,
0.0436097011,
-0.0055436851,
0.0080482997,
-0.0544963479,
-0.0103325369,
-0.0681589693,
0.0444730446,
-0.035586141,
-0.0175537858,
0.0040800851,
-0.088613674,
0.0202283505,
0.0095323911,
-0.006581571,
-0.0167670324,
-0.0077581005,
0.0064504575,
-0.0082569811,
0.0334376097,
0.0166901425,
0.0057682618,
0.0448180735,
0.1030062139,
-0.0527133234,
0.0433342345,
-0.0172258001,
0.0198596809,
0.0325614959,
0.0522797257,
-0.0123006366,
-0.0258731321,
-0.0270814039,
0.0007760371,
0.0180500895,
-0.0180155672,
0.0034058036,
0.0688068941,
-0.0386765152,
0.0298740268,
-0.0035790824,
0.0353712626,
0.0137274768,
0.0031219781,
0.0773007274,
0.0250100438,
-0.0050203842,
0.0290103257,
-0.0372945108,
0.0565595664,
-0.0029167815,
0.0275651831,
0.0212485604,
-0.041482769,
0.0529339239,
-0.0276676212,
-0.0004029627,
-0.0301959645,
-0.0188050047,
-0.0114370007,
-0.005566434,
0.0316222273,
0.0078485254,
-0.0317834914,
0.041035302,
0.0302394405,
0.0133658303,
0.0031110782,
0.010771743,
0.0311705302,
-0.0491745621,
-0.022265777,
-0.0157027002,
0.0019217669,
-0.0525087081,
-0.0609660521,
-0.0315678082,
-0.0318993703,
-0.0081773112,
0.0173810571,
-0.0465543717,
-0.0457810573,
0.0032889412,
0.0173268337,
0.0232038759,
-0.0187186636,
0.0480636507,
0.0317122377,
-0.0267464537,
-0.0209120549,
-0.0196473338,
0.0252670497,
0.0415831506,
0.0673900098,
0.0288591664,
-0.0371603705,
-0.0042387648,
-0.0398606956,
0.0171773005,
-0.0011093465,
-0.0320298858,
-0.0025660712,
0.0102300951,
-0.019286504,
0.0205221735,
0.0102603128,
-0.0427604094,
0.0060548461,
-0.0011651807,
0.0018049757,
-0.0183216128,
0.0078730443,
-0.0062130401,
0.0100355428,
0.0100259697,
0.0027436053,
0.0038815748,
-0.0260545202,
0.0425803252,
-0.0285285711,
0.0060136989,
-0.0286421329,
0.0188909378,
-0.0382467359,
-0.0001433864,
-0.029484747,
-0.0243509691,
0.0487420708,
0.0232668463,
0.0524596274,
0.1152916551,
0.0437090136,
0.0626413897,
0.0652652755,
-0.0259477906,
-0.0444513559,
-0.0179984961,
-0.0065102242,
0.0286430381,
-0.0737915039,
0.0839365572,
0.0076303356,
-0.0106908968,
0.0361982398,
0.0144450944,
0.0544404313,
-0.0563467182,
-0.0780966729,
0.0127622643,
0.0064844401,
0.0097443881,
-0.0096817976,
-0.0369224958,
-0.0865284801,
0.0290593188,
-0.0608162582,
-0.0169596616,
-0.0248053409,
0.0070799673,
0.0451038256,
0.039043773,
0.0535861552,
-0.0061449027,
-0.0265411641,
0.0116797118,
-0.0230995063,
0.017835604,
0.0458126962,
-0.0206899587,
0.0404214412,
-0.0113582341,
-0.0372882076,
-0.0002898462,
-0.020163456,
0.0072775572,
-0.0350757204,
-0.0344971083,
0.0165217631,
-5.654359253e-33,
-0.033117488,
-0.0273791216,
0.0064417678,
0.1078791767,
-0.0315337814,
-0.0031729531,
-0.0382086746,
0.0635211542,
-0.011177727,
0.0052212658,
0.0390312672,
0.0516685396,
-0.0082550123,
0.0496943071,
0.0556471869,
-0.0197956208,
0.0250692423,
0.0208885036,
0.0012780972,
0.0676865503,
-0.0430722684,
-0.0210942999,
0.0305314884,
-0.0200928971,
0.0408414416,
-0.0007453917,
-0.0572016425,
-0.0558412932,
-0.0424977206,
0.0283092055,
0.00699687,
0.0257825945,
-0.0177955553,
-0.0157032199,
0.0281699002,
-0.0046824929,
-0.0072585437,
-0.0528153032,
-0.0117639443,
0.0077796457,
-0.0066153137,
-0.011274429,
0.0213701427,
0.0028649257,
-0.0397112891,
-0.0291094948,
0.0567563139,
0.0254764538,
0.0047343499,
0.0173361301,
-0.0440340973,
-0.0018601167,
-0.0948530883,
-0.0493159108,
-0.0548304543,
0.0538140796,
0.0087333573,
-0.0587995015,
-0.0219029542,
0.066906698,
0.0654637069,
0.0434808619,
0.0293792691,
0.0450857542,
-0.0123670585,
0.0324238129,
0.0268826019,
0.0152440872,
0.0163369495,
0.0015266496,
0.0263197832,
0.020771021,
0.048666805,
0.0275697317,
-0.0320820659,
0.0014016287,
-0.0252532829,
0.0220683701,
0.0561958365,
-0.0235585012,
0.018665297,
-0.0342043452,
-0.1163458005,
-0.0319044776,
-0.037924204,
-0.0458371565,
0.0082276519,
-0.0334243067,
0.047720965,
-0.0062699364,
-0.0205845758,
0.0528102368,
0.0097150421,
-0.0164799094,
-0.0587886274,
-0.0275318827,
-0.0350407511,
0.0405455269,
-0.0464838892,
-0.0561711416,
-0.0519523211,
-0.0157330669,
-0.0182875358,
0.0331234522,
0.0402087942,
0.0072801951,
0.0001501019,
0.0129905911,
-0.0429755561,
-0.031524241,
-0.0402965695,
0.0128580946,
0.0005236802,
-0.1042211205,
-0.0172351152,
0.0215521101,
-0.0299179591,
0.099531278,
-0.0081925122,
-0.0806285664,
-0.0336606838,
-0.0484790094,
-0.0212401394,
-0.023216499,
-0.0621261299,
-0.0287954193,
0.0131903626,
-0.0201675091,
-0.000332472,
-0.038584955,
-0.0007436656,
-0.0213878863,
2.986e-7,
-0.0179291423,
0.0010919329,
-0.002096843,
-0.0533015803,
-0.0195757579,
0.0223578233,
-0.0078841215,
-0.0275763124,
0.0920040607,
-0.0294039659,
0.0268245079,
0.0209712684,
0.040035814,
-0.0158721935,
-0.0241916273,
-0.0900707841,
-0.0147206271,
-0.0360853113,
-0.016110545,
0.0522184484,
0.0705969706,
-0.0300749391,
0.0684713572,
0.006446009,
-0.0008547463,
0.0296860319,
-0.0006692823,
-0.0244293828,
0.0183607861,
0.0177356545,
-0.029534772,
-0.0124547016,
0.0138982572,
0.0088024521,
0.0139087196,
-0.0143311182,
-0.0205532648,
0.0503865778,
0.0194936469,
-0.0164927077,
-0.0386679694,
-0.0061479625,
0.0036566902,
-0.0129364934,
-0.0362674855,
-0.0409489982,
-0.0012686816,
0.0569962598,
-0.0194941647,
-0.0534715466,
0.0283906627,
0.0160063989,
0.0170834679,
-0.0062362794,
-0.02828818,
-0.0208139028,
-0.0058217901,
-0.0065494631,
0.0367224887,
-0.0449047461,
-0.0202979483,
-0.0227333866,
-0.0027867341,
-0.0333017744,
-0.0150614316,
-0.0204634108,
-0.0169562567,
2.148574544e-34,
-0.0111066243,
-0.0486092083,
0.0547534972,
0.0289361402,
0.0209333375,
0.0293664634,
-0.0061906809,
0.0288565047,
0.0402634218,
0.0030871653,
-0.0699436069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00958v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00958v1 | IndoToD: A Multi-Domain Indonesian Benchmark For End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems | 2023-11-02T03:01:53 | 2023-11-02T03:01:53 | Muhammad Dehan Al Kautsar, Rahmah Khoirussyifa' Nurdini, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Genta Indra Winata, Ayu Purwarianti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems have been mostly created for
high-resource languages, such as English and Chinese. However, there is a need
to develop ToD systems for other regional or local languages to broaden their
ability to comprehend the dialogue contexts in various languages. This paper
introduces IndoToD, an end-to-end multi domain ToD benchmark in Indonesian. We
extend two English ToD datasets to Indonesian, comprising four different
domains by delexicalization to efficiently reduce the size of annotations. To
ensure a high-quality data collection, we hire native speakers to manually
translate the dialogues. Along with the original English datasets, these new
Indonesian datasets serve as an effective benchmark for evaluating Indonesian
and English ToD systems as well as exploring the potential benefits of
cross-lingual and bilingual transfer learning approaches. | [
0.0501790643,
-0.0008047352,
-0.0268107504,
0.0571765229,
-0.0283347405,
0.034342505,
0.0230859611,
-0.0323988348,
0.0183528215,
-0.0316786095,
-0.0931412876,
-0.0221329108,
-0.0213846993,
0.0086666886,
-0.0021840488,
-0.1080009863,
0.0584091805,
-0.0242838524,
0.023720976,
0.0207244325,
-0.0046782335,
-0.0083311908,
-0.0682331845,
0.0447401144,
0.0055956417,
-0.0220242459,
-0.0184474159,
-0.0210378449,
0.033323355,
-0.0251240116,
0.006872023,
0.0414803661,
-0.007980573,
0.0000721762,
0.0000019282,
-0.0557059161,
0.0100523736,
-0.0201443844,
-0.0214435086,
-0.0154537419,
0.0536907129,
0.0052697542,
0.0051897033,
-0.0011512529,
-0.0401591547,
-0.0376654156,
0.041625306,
0.0693003535,
0.0770400763,
0.0895417258,
-0.005335283,
0.0094306516,
-0.0115914773,
-0.0065126373,
-0.0220205728,
-0.0436262861,
-0.0073334752,
0.0321082659,
0.0274901334,
-0.0030846393,
0.0158623494,
0.0293108784,
0.007995123,
-0.0425721891,
-0.0253591333,
-0.0564416498,
-0.0125728752,
-0.0131915575,
-0.0046042232,
0.0852460414,
0.0500529669,
0.0242542624,
-0.0221656803,
0.0296708364,
0.0107661961,
-0.0306017511,
-0.0738779828,
-0.0175685696,
-0.0304064881,
-0.0006631952,
0.0283396635,
0.0563388243,
-0.0200896058,
-0.0102141583,
-0.0072529037,
0.0103293685,
0.0014042194,
0.0029346154,
0.0163918585,
0.0032270034,
0.0096096974,
-0.0582715943,
0.0272208974,
0.0257667359,
-0.0583594255,
0.0218554679,
-0.0354917794,
-0.0369852372,
-0.0047326405,
-0.055089727,
0.009964563,
0.0434431694,
-0.0307417456,
0.0379774868,
0.0219553299,
0.0420138389,
-0.0174643807,
0.0222019777,
-0.0393976159,
-0.0711933151,
-0.0671214312,
0.0065312292,
-0.0471459441,
0.0484540798,
-0.0377257206,
0.0008058929,
-0.0277964827,
0.0389541909,
-0.0287136324,
-0.0265216343,
0.0646918565,
-0.0118289059,
-0.063227728,
-0.0069643809,
-0.0280551016,
0.0525640622,
-0.0325387344,
0.0275059175,
0.0317807719,
-0.0301877316,
0.0042749206,
0.0277962554,
-0.005954341,
-0.0468902029,
-0.0298140869,
0.0815459788,
-0.0453263037,
-0.0045649055,
-0.0338635743,
0.0142064001,
-0.0198266171,
-0.0611996576,
0.0265383609,
-0.0288180001,
0.0409978032,
0.013150068,
-0.0024191139,
-0.0531260148,
0.0127498833,
0.0042773779,
0.0008006284,
0.0608929545,
-0.0078417566,
-0.0016895131,
0.0221060086,
0.0023531599,
-0.0309531596,
0.0600947812,
0.0383639857,
-0.004994038,
0.0438967682,
-0.0068744775,
-0.0648066849,
0.0172793567,
-0.0085816793,
0.0130889229,
0.0313686281,
0.0430792123,
-0.0155330934,
0.0214526244,
0.0127264857,
0.0534805134,
-0.0183681231,
0.051242508,
0.0132622439,
0.0350387283,
-0.0157510079,
0.0377868526,
0.0484487116,
0.0188787933,
0.0218281299,
0.0179245826,
-0.016587412,
0.0250433255,
0.031862352,
-0.0171319451,
0.0511895604,
-0.0086383354,
-0.0370824784,
-0.0259788223,
0.0256604683,
0.0005904361,
0.0014297465,
-0.0073876097,
0.0722211674,
0.0371973962,
-0.0440427326,
0.031767454,
0.0190556813,
-0.0355702341,
0.0047143558,
-0.038959913,
-0.0373328291,
0.0194287449,
-0.0060897442,
-0.0307702869,
-0.0496857688,
-0.0176985282,
0.059787821,
0.046650786,
0.0636795387,
-0.057593435,
0.0004093939,
-0.0304185618,
-0.0013134596,
0.0060333423,
0.0096496623,
0.0345529281,
-0.0132491998,
0.0243693218,
0.009501515,
-0.0470573679,
-0.0085511105,
0.0133699281,
-0.0347195305,
-0.0136219813,
0.0138012441,
0.0256933775,
0.0254589226,
0.0581258759,
0.0140255177,
-0.0338623896,
0.0146732489,
-0.0526529513,
0.0208112765,
0.0337581672,
-0.0334065482,
-0.0387627855,
0.0100357048,
-0.0372255407,
-0.0284459312,
0.0404910445,
-0.0278035626,
-0.0713843107,
0.0200028643,
-0.0100493645,
-0.0123139555,
-0.0316017605,
-0.0002284061,
-0.0152821653,
0.0031103366,
-0.0303604212,
0.0213117059,
0.0436581522,
-0.013283222,
0.0399963669,
-0.0184836145,
0.0498679653,
-0.048526898,
0.0188628193,
0.0108484626,
-0.0224303324,
-0.0076869559,
-0.0191400722,
0.0170341451,
-0.0346105061,
-0.022745382,
-0.1219606698,
0.0271825902,
-0.0068342122,
0.0614177994,
0.01906991,
0.0087669054,
-0.0055351304,
-0.017085012,
0.0014367136,
-0.0096304445,
0.0428220592,
-0.005270116,
0.0253787432,
0.0176864583,
0.0231123269,
-0.0170174018,
0.0153764011,
0.0091645317,
0.0137319788,
-0.0028331948,
-0.1233351007,
-0.0589870103,
0.0353420638,
-0.0161230434,
-0.0076283682,
0.0038792491,
-0.0247170124,
0.0300130788,
0.0370990336,
0.0297686979,
0.0558818765,
-0.0071136509,
0.0183442831,
-0.0257352591,
-0.0576172583,
-0.0466601476,
0.0263281912,
0.0343811549,
0.0042620166,
-0.0387896374,
0.0046767294,
0.0231711809,
0.0565888584,
-0.0208972357,
-0.0058742655,
-0.0310441907,
-0.009660339,
-0.0532882363,
0.0007209724,
0.0014005648,
0.0294500757,
-0.0412784815,
0.0313581936,
0.0094447294,
0.0247194767,
0.0696714669,
0.010118749,
-0.0052741785,
-0.077589415,
0.0302954372,
-0.0465622582,
0.0313244462,
-0.0738667548,
0.0052886014,
0.0486277603,
-0.0556100197,
-0.029622972,
0.048502624,
0.0099333478,
-0.0078448625,
0.0518278815,
-0.0686801672,
0.0059679495,
-0.0361328423,
-0.0655139461,
-0.0594784841,
0.0082751159,
-0.0181772504,
0.0289081633,
0.0293443557,
-0.0011162672,
-0.0322788693,
0.0192960743,
0.0086468095,
0.0065329187,
-0.0033823883,
-0.0029456371,
-0.002709978,
0.0163020194,
0.0195431393,
-0.0078983633,
-0.016941119,
0.0013735249,
0.0437533408,
0.0213283896,
0.0272087306,
-0.043358434,
-0.0078072115,
-0.0254651271,
0.0411266349,
-0.0237519238,
-0.0223610736,
-0.0262380484,
0.0689712167,
-0.011140164,
-0.0267082322,
0.0783484057,
0.0041580074,
-0.0295420364,
-0.0340723209,
-0.0609727241,
0.0109037776,
0.0238235164,
0.0507912412,
-0.0917534605,
-0.0531043969,
0.0019557069,
-0.01401636,
0.0118515082,
-0.0590833984,
-0.0084995087,
-0.1076407433,
0.0232193638,
-0.0232194681,
-0.0548817962,
0.0111918338,
-0.0130399363,
0.0028281766,
-0.0119514102,
0.0465818532,
-0.0294749867,
0.0152764283,
-0.0244720541,
0.0613303632,
0.0294891652,
-0.0277601313,
0.0324846841,
-0.0010990582,
0.0418913476,
0.0245183017,
0.0618311651,
0.0335496664,
0.0394069552,
0.0507419221,
0.0189570989,
-0.0249712262,
0.0231761038,
0.0268631931,
0.0118339527,
-0.0452553779,
-0.0375784636,
0.0260321312,
-0.0427590162,
0.011216199,
0.0560269617,
0.0814997628,
-0.0183183439,
0.0463249721,
0.0230838992,
0.0016366199,
0.0578704476,
0.0474679321,
0.0145077808,
-0.0636747926,
0.0103894267,
-0.0146184433,
-0.0574685894,
-0.0654116049,
-0.0039277864,
0.0034549569,
-0.0767716318,
0.018756602,
-0.0871396065,
-0.0461767167,
0.0443965383,
0.0543122403,
0.037050914,
-0.0015438783,
0.0007848224,
0.0114482744,
-0.0011537952,
0.0046895426,
-0.0383119956,
0.0133028748,
-0.0661479309,
0.0055846558,
0.0051935916,
0.015624553,
0.0032872155,
0.0153451543,
-0.0613632984,
-0.0426155217,
-0.0204250924,
0.0506609417,
0.0189121328,
0.0000838656,
0.0011733508,
-0.0189697649,
-0.0486184917,
-0.0306164585,
-0.0149400979,
-0.0457235426,
0.0506874248,
0.0143084759,
0.0042629945,
0.0625967383,
-0.0214226656,
0.0215117335,
-0.0117545594,
0.0221480522,
0.0050837211,
-0.048561085,
-0.0010111186,
0.0110080764,
0.0594135076,
-0.0043321489,
-0.0422215723,
-0.0376741104,
0.0291459691,
-0.0484498255,
-0.0316907614,
-0.0450946428,
0.0275535844,
0.0208152663,
-0.0204824787,
0.013377782,
0.0540300049,
-0.0121243782,
0.0121642202,
-0.0054017045,
0.019536892,
0.0382256247,
0.0366650298,
-0.0072882371,
0.0026742159,
-0.0343806967,
-0.0261322409,
0.0531200655,
0.0494857505,
-0.0291976407,
0.1117886826,
0.0167175699,
-0.0090986853,
0.0421021171,
0.0189893153,
-0.0042244913,
0.000250892,
0.0159392059,
-0.0012018951,
0.0537739024,
0.0242264699,
0.0649841204,
-0.0356674641,
0.011987594,
-0.0291676354,
0.0684987158,
-0.0304208007,
0.0108464938,
0.0155669535,
-0.0011027415,
0.0034097473,
0.0356693827,
0.0610460117,
-0.039156314,
0.0072588543,
0.0281023625,
0.0252896156,
-0.0358654223,
-0.0375962034,
-0.0114946608,
0.0157274622,
-0.0086335614,
-0.0123104118,
-0.0306658205,
-0.0410448909,
-0.0431093946,
-0.0225986727,
-0.0139326071,
-0.0108550517,
0.0158355366,
0.0328107476,
0.0058125942,
-0.0053850338,
-0.0421788096,
0.0014523068,
-0.0429825559,
-0.0101143867,
-0.0187750552,
-5.597936259e-33,
-0.0523413159,
0.0216820091,
0.0252139736,
0.0206109378,
-0.0193792675,
-0.0516779162,
-0.0271390956,
0.0117809568,
-0.0264551844,
0.0426164269,
-0.033862412,
0.0104386881,
0.0344789848,
0.0158349331,
-0.0014430637,
-0.0259955581,
0.0147733344,
-0.0006699011,
-0.000705904,
0.0273382775,
0.0784933195,
0.0015226282,
0.0789205208,
-0.0717153102,
0.0578576997,
0.041072119,
0.0112922052,
0.0415879712,
0.0340238214,
0.0472405627,
-0.0077419495,
0.0530906171,
0.0096539399,
-0.0602495857,
-0.0361825377,
0.0109348763,
-0.0896984786,
-0.0322414488,
0.0420244113,
0.0475503094,
0.0068821087,
-0.0304737203,
-0.0323220342,
-0.0279114544,
0.0218192395,
0.0025181691,
0.0040037301,
-0.0404297002,
-0.0108128292,
0.0220346395,
-0.1088711098,
0.0187575631,
-0.0134346671,
-0.0509270057,
0.0232130215,
0.0909408703,
-0.0097758016,
-0.108019866,
-0.0247978624,
-0.0007025515,
-0.0358017646,
-0.0144414911,
0.0604802333,
0.0085274167,
-0.0122351777,
0.044820182,
0.0315275118,
0.0348183326,
0.0499862283,
-0.0116203669,
-0.0174020808,
0.0494694896,
-0.0037524898,
0.0526360124,
-0.0356081985,
0.02885364,
-0.0676564872,
0.0190290827,
0.001276194,
0.007713269,
-0.0160002708,
-0.0093140882,
-0.0294802468,
-0.037409015,
-0.0007147481,
-0.012176428,
0.0055965632,
-0.0614464432,
0.0406677797,
-0.0316323824,
-0.0152800139,
-0.0034867197,
0.0678981468,
-0.0491181798,
0.0049118907,
0.005796467,
-0.0230499022,
0.0320170112,
-0.0389586464,
-0.0035412502,
-0.0518043153,
-0.0505009964,
-0.0198505018,
0.0479918569,
0.0317700952,
0.0037630242,
0.0549201146,
-0.0414681584,
-0.046517171,
0.0005595926,
-0.0543844551,
0.0400831997,
-0.0500741787,
0.081292361,
0.0249384176,
0.003437436,
-0.0180463009,
0.10211391,
0.0178520419,
-0.0364430398,
-0.034720391,
-0.0005656697,
0.0211783387,
-0.0264839418,
-0.0186148956,
0.0068700751,
-0.0284724906,
0.0194396675,
-0.0210980419,
-0.002057204,
-0.0144795673,
-0.0264098085,
2.537e-7,
0.0382191688,
0.0411104299,
0.0460378155,
0.0046201916,
-0.0115222912,
0.049853567,
-0.0210970156,
0.0095560886,
0.0234203227,
0.0381089449,
-0.0106993644,
-0.0013462922,
0.0829511136,
0.0375932381,
-0.1344253272,
-0.0717130899,
0.0090325205,
-0.0279664677,
-0.0346414335,
0.0020470447,
0.03329603,
0.0185998976,
0.0125378901,
0.0033150373,
-0.0340207666,
-0.0185744353,
0.0714315772,
-0.0118050026,
-0.0216684248,
0.0552651994,
0.0334966816,
-0.0340167433,
0.0027029577,
0.0232833494,
-0.0214839671,
0.0222554822,
0.0308391135,
0.087106891,
0.0115672657,
-0.0540434532,
-0.0047904295,
-0.0154414289,
0.0162381455,
-0.0347609296,
0.0561274327,
-0.0835867971,
-0.047825478,
0.0061311349,
0.0174135771,
0.0009710044,
-0.0166168921,
0.0004237868,
0.0083721802,
0.0317454822,
0.0346980244,
-0.0218793992,
-0.0258876402,
-0.0200189743,
-0.0052291621,
0.020554034,
-0.0282570701,
-0.0383567587,
-0.0165432487,
0.0112967202,
-0.0033851916,
-0.0062563461,
0.0158185773,
1.643943314e-34,
0.0059104203,
0.0027361421,
0.0430987254,
-0.0018952042,
0.0292336214,
-0.0276547559,
-0.0174196418,
-0.0078976462,
0.0465637371,
-0.0345440619,
0.0138015822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00953v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00953v1 | Blending Reward Functions via Few Expert Demonstrations for Faithful and Accurate Knowledge-Grounded Dialogue Generation | 2023-11-02T02:42:41 | 2023-11-02T02:42:41 | Wanyu Du, Yangfeng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | The development of trustworthy conversational information-seeking systems
relies on dialogue models that can generate faithful and accurate responses
based on relevant knowledge texts. However, two main challenges hinder this
task. Firstly, language models may generate hallucinations due to data biases
present in their pretraining corpus. Secondly, knowledge texts often contain
redundant and irrelevant information that distracts the model's attention from
the relevant text span. Previous works use additional data annotations on the
knowledge texts to learn a knowledge identification module in order to bypass
irrelevant information, but collecting such high-quality span annotations can
be costly. In this work, we leverage reinforcement learning algorithms to
overcome the above challenges by introducing a novel reward function. Our
reward function combines an accuracy metric and a faithfulness metric to
provide a balanced quality judgment of generated responses, which can be used
as a cost-effective approximation to a human preference reward model when only
a few preference annotations are available. Empirical experiments on two
conversational information-seeking datasets demonstrate that our method can
compete with other strong supervised learning baselines. | [
0.0766398162,
0.0485870652,
0.0104462393,
0.0114750536,
-0.0152616911,
-0.0125542907,
-0.0060490933,
0.0041257422,
0.0157236736,
-0.0322295204,
-0.0366182923,
0.0097774034,
-0.0082301414,
-0.0001354273,
-0.005314976,
-0.082474649,
0.0497229546,
-0.0264506489,
0.0630161688,
0.0006500353,
0.0317466594,
0.0228454433,
-0.0454767533,
0.0414151326,
-0.0482216217,
-0.002887089,
0.0005361807,
-0.0113465805,
0.0433744453,
-0.0322046131,
0.074387081,
0.0553894415,
0.00073879,
0.0437409133,
0.0000020342,
-0.0363944098,
-0.0157757476,
-0.0232059583,
-0.0394034423,
-0.0462059714,
0.0051921536,
0.0586230457,
0.0319745168,
0.0156262368,
-0.0480540954,
0.0345752463,
0.0492530316,
0.0908873677,
0.0570206456,
0.0854271799,
0.0071845422,
0.01480236,
0.0047452827,
-0.0229540169,
0.0729962215,
-0.0424965173,
-0.0108044893,
0.0387813933,
0.0316479951,
0.0161514226,
0.0209535249,
0.0170303192,
0.0001029553,
-0.0256768521,
0.0481982119,
0.0284949113,
-0.0143622821,
0.004216637,
-0.0260352734,
0.0947207958,
0.0097491397,
-0.0067820307,
0.0096201049,
-0.0264325477,
0.0100489296,
-0.0015902967,
-0.0138628054,
0.0206238385,
-0.0302832425,
-0.0009817631,
-0.019246133,
0.0576258786,
0.0042152572,
0.0170716643,
-0.0219251513,
0.0533289313,
-0.0329154208,
-0.0441911519,
0.035625387,
0.0055875485,
-0.0167903826,
-0.0676934794,
-0.0206796415,
0.0095474375,
-0.0855079442,
0.0229063425,
-0.0297181737,
0.0194314383,
0.0134809036,
-0.0188832469,
-0.0327364244,
0.0178420115,
-0.0163719747,
0.0498947017,
0.006172549,
0.0308390576,
0.0154361622,
0.0298245009,
-0.0165220331,
0.0062101525,
-0.0302413031,
0.0029442883,
-0.0342882909,
0.0640978664,
-0.0460608974,
-0.0421661213,
-0.0269442387,
0.0219656453,
-0.0404960588,
0.0715869144,
-0.009178753,
0.0571514815,
-0.0336981006,
0.011767054,
-0.0736312643,
0.014199187,
-0.0415691882,
0.0179212876,
0.0449992716,
-0.0427732877,
-0.011033454,
0.0377538018,
0.0125290193,
-0.0079121683,
0.0222613197,
0.0482465476,
-0.0161003023,
-0.0417967588,
-0.0172980335,
-0.0486610904,
-0.0132261831,
-0.0554500185,
-0.0180667639,
-0.0143755497,
0.0410028771,
-0.0137015432,
-0.0461617708,
-0.02748367,
0.0361633226,
0.0203842502,
-0.0328319818,
0.0519031473,
-0.0210117437,
-0.0238831639,
0.0189430341,
0.0174144134,
-0.0432457514,
0.040340621,
0.0367432162,
0.0436902717,
0.0407664962,
0.0197700132,
0.0176998004,
-0.0254676566,
0.0357760526,
-0.0006416627,
0.0288891234,
0.031650167,
-0.0187268294,
0.0430873409,
0.0147151779,
0.0335397236,
-0.054966934,
0.0296487883,
0.0868519694,
0.0236630682,
-0.0283554308,
-0.01780059,
0.0123481015,
0.0571838692,
-0.0031945561,
0.0044993581,
-0.0323772803,
0.0365724675,
0.0024935463,
-0.0072623924,
0.0677880645,
-0.0315664448,
-0.0226565264,
-0.0519354343,
0.0471077003,
-0.0015206393,
0.0223325901,
0.0527555794,
0.0112158246,
0.0085207708,
-0.0520222262,
0.0208254512,
0.0156706478,
-0.037103001,
0.0028900066,
0.0014680651,
0.0645565763,
0.0804544911,
0.0415256098,
-0.0435950197,
-0.0261408221,
-0.0481306501,
0.0153904017,
0.0411155261,
0.0537971072,
-0.0386587866,
0.0164564587,
-0.0548439138,
-0.0453555696,
-0.0139816254,
0.0036336037,
0.0246654097,
0.0265227128,
-0.001144478,
0.0115334271,
0.0107089942,
-0.0314096436,
0.0196520966,
0.0001213543,
-0.0291104857,
0.0279780794,
0.0132920723,
0.0270558484,
0.0201550815,
-0.0043718247,
0.0069018849,
0.0060872682,
0.0198214203,
0.0046108603,
0.0195299014,
-0.0552686043,
-0.0507158823,
0.0058812904,
-0.0214542672,
-0.016828021,
-0.0105949035,
-0.00976827,
-0.0470104888,
-0.0085617192,
-0.0473694988,
0.0463801548,
-0.0312082451,
-0.0164685156,
0.0412853733,
0.0046144975,
-0.0513540991,
0.0590554029,
0.0009504143,
0.0272549056,
0.0310584847,
-0.0135923168,
0.0105710933,
-0.0646524206,
-0.0011346479,
-0.0272122212,
-0.0061334684,
0.0538717955,
0.0565662384,
0.0182970203,
-0.0492510237,
-0.0185189415,
-0.0560590625,
0.0157151949,
-0.0148565136,
0.0003277662,
0.000030182,
0.0149054006,
-0.000754901,
-0.0562705211,
-0.089012824,
-0.0201986507,
0.0166921075,
-0.0275235213,
0.0306233596,
0.0503059998,
0.0235694908,
-0.0361071974,
0.0471213385,
0.0172571167,
0.0211204439,
0.0196414515,
0.0231484938,
-0.046235688,
0.0105941277,
-0.0538770966,
0.0521139838,
-0.0120186219,
-0.0049186102,
0.0374630988,
0.0285439603,
-0.0081914905,
0.0553445704,
0.0719630793,
0.0184447467,
-0.0052619502,
0.0110626211,
-0.0941417515,
0.0380370654,
-0.0480866469,
0.0152167128,
-0.031466309,
-0.002745627,
0.044416178,
0.010703532,
0.0086744269,
0.0267240498,
-0.0728333965,
0.0315733775,
0.0544068925,
-0.0429773889,
-0.0087806946,
0.0117934132,
0.0068086972,
0.0385997966,
-0.0423334502,
-0.0235526282,
0.0991800576,
-0.0031801178,
-0.0123765366,
-0.0337497741,
-0.0005288996,
0.0097623048,
-0.0143397963,
-0.0207683723,
0.0345342867,
-0.0121200485,
-0.0209478009,
-0.0329005942,
-0.0224068705,
0.044935856,
-0.0414779708,
0.0282062646,
-0.02837874,
0.0072373571,
0.0277880374,
-0.0625718907,
-0.0989260375,
-0.0402552634,
0.0046911291,
-0.016548017,
0.0031227721,
-0.0262560472,
-0.0303653572,
-0.0185909942,
0.066796802,
0.0569216199,
-0.0042840722,
-0.0256786607,
-0.0375599526,
0.0216483418,
0.0567574129,
0.0271941405,
0.0241368059,
-0.0193220563,
0.0267956425,
0.0359664597,
0.0114490204,
-0.0005794148,
-0.0076462263,
-0.0304477084,
0.0096679712,
-0.0515235476,
0.0090684593,
0.0329379663,
0.0307563078,
-0.0198633876,
-0.0281824749,
0.1007035002,
0.0317267813,
-0.0495024808,
-0.0044090468,
-0.0027144176,
0.0566321462,
0.0158920828,
0.0339059345,
-0.0827310681,
-0.0069229049,
-0.013034977,
0.0620963611,
-0.0096307304,
-0.0624236427,
-0.0025379236,
-0.1107911468,
0.0047758883,
-0.0032422203,
-0.0389671102,
-0.0350347646,
-0.0088888472,
-0.0013140505,
0.005486961,
0.0010276467,
0.0151739232,
0.024658585,
-0.0000890912,
0.0374008156,
0.0206665602,
-0.0434171706,
0.0253067929,
-0.0279753022,
0.0699418858,
0.098790206,
0.0345330201,
0.023333542,
-0.0165759716,
-0.0678788349,
0.0185322966,
-0.0156266149,
-0.0006117789,
0.0757898837,
-0.0507607944,
-0.0114359185,
-0.0089060999,
0.0618704818,
0.0014148541,
-0.014047293,
0.019867627,
-0.0039888592,
-0.0528088659,
0.0144659318,
0.0109226154,
0.0214246362,
0.0757792294,
0.0741307288,
0.0127381086,
-0.0499391593,
-0.0156031614,
-0.0145845432,
0.0241740588,
-0.0755860656,
0.002642994,
0.0193560794,
0.0114961099,
0.0199348778,
-0.0902222544,
-0.0493367575,
-0.0052785906,
0.0366115049,
-0.0051757437,
-0.0181955341,
-0.0136633664,
0.0095127504,
-0.0140508395,
0.0345726088,
-0.0435171165,
-0.0039511258,
-0.0606005639,
-0.009235953,
-0.0158980023,
-0.0996560454,
-0.0245493855,
-0.0109770084,
-0.0353869796,
-0.0474897511,
-0.059229061,
0.0854356438,
0.0194840021,
0.1079288498,
-0.0219996963,
-0.0307084173,
0.0197485778,
0.0289209168,
-0.0633434579,
-0.021587925,
0.0405202359,
0.0590387098,
-0.0138423033,
0.0149519946,
-0.0466197468,
0.0135197248,
0.0155305723,
0.0144570274,
-0.0088243214,
-0.0420691445,
0.0438776128,
-0.0113591813,
0.0251317415,
0.0025540467,
0.0322157033,
-0.0308750123,
0.024193367,
0.0083455769,
-0.0484433733,
-0.0489059091,
-0.016801564,
-0.0082523758,
-0.0099247498,
-0.0038051608,
-0.0416731238,
-0.002344945,
0.0417875908,
-0.0276608896,
-0.0358382016,
0.0171082448,
-0.0026518756,
0.0246257707,
-0.0233043879,
-0.0062550865,
0.0216013789,
0.0228036307,
0.0529626906,
0.0145128705,
0.0830321237,
0.0392989777,
-0.0563420802,
0.0275471676,
-0.0084509635,
-0.0395789593,
-0.0347013026,
-0.0431194194,
0.0125110876,
0.022697432,
-0.0017113817,
0.0193538107,
-0.0415669233,
0.0226811096,
-0.0131060649,
0.0304870512,
-0.0055912817,
-0.0192461461,
0.010174932,
0.0207481328,
-0.0081305206,
0.0102854157,
0.0694816858,
-0.0303602517,
0.0182076823,
-0.032195095,
-0.0242629908,
-0.0820956752,
-0.0401142128,
0.0129069341,
0.041632995,
-0.0136302225,
0.0014923225,
-0.019333452,
-0.0374795683,
-0.0230905991,
0.016798025,
0.0008593324,
-0.0085906666,
0.0598227493,
0.0308176726,
-0.0466638319,
0.0091398302,
-0.073474437,
-0.0201272946,
-0.0076571652,
-0.0137422439,
-0.0340140946,
-6.261120784e-33,
0.0026232479,
-0.0457823947,
0.0179997422,
-0.0179211684,
-0.018898569,
-0.023594154,
-0.0321032032,
-0.019645514,
0.0002545433,
0.0026616475,
-0.0098234937,
-0.0174132809,
-0.000096296,
0.0372034684,
-0.0132810837,
-0.0188275389,
0.0550096221,
0.0037938796,
-0.0451974198,
0.0705771744,
0.0520285405,
0.0070488863,
0.033269342,
-0.098076202,
0.0481884405,
-0.0049266359,
-0.0354458317,
0.0306063965,
-0.0025364978,
0.0485844463,
-0.01630532,
0.0314922109,
-0.0032854213,
-0.0485836528,
0.0066644768,
0.0062802797,
-0.0691609308,
-0.0299773682,
0.0027578904,
-0.0060870247,
-0.034838438,
-0.0067659053,
0.0139129888,
-0.0515691489,
0.0254197158,
0.0200317837,
0.022457229,
-0.0221192203,
-0.0305698998,
0.0015823293,
-0.0323404819,
0.0129043981,
-0.0197756421,
-0.0508361869,
-0.0036561838,
0.0982022658,
0.0005466457,
-0.0077027478,
-0.0448974147,
0.0460448787,
0.0245382264,
0.0095584858,
0.015494979,
0.0197352767,
-0.0130730812,
0.0664532408,
0.0244648438,
-0.0038179928,
0.0013051097,
-0.0150891785,
-0.0139311813,
0.052142106,
0.0229251888,
0.0544421561,
0.003856743,
-0.0263162907,
-0.0389820561,
0.0186305903,
0.0097035877,
0.009185846,
0.0298788305,
-0.0172556955,
-0.0617398061,
-0.0049855113,
-0.043588493,
0.0078996392,
-0.0252770185,
-0.0524216108,
0.0491865538,
0.0579388551,
-0.0129660685,
-0.0037025881,
0.0040669041,
-0.0470319577,
0.0025652107,
0.0292022731,
-0.0508501902,
0.0045275977,
-0.0154079795,
-0.0352070369,
-0.0754360035,
-0.0260701906,
0.0358510837,
-0.0289753005,
-0.0055593336,
0.0441185199,
0.0169395972,
0.0014793827,
-0.0383152775,
0.0138318408,
-0.0226155613,
0.0739392415,
-0.0151229491,
0.0009229576,
0.0163115617,
-0.0102928383,
-0.0308764111,
0.0347155295,
-0.0165547803,
-0.0360114463,
-0.016805727,
-0.0560531504,
-0.0030818512,
0.0074017677,
-0.0432480797,
-0.0066792197,
0.00106003,
-0.0394464135,
-0.0332077257,
-0.0355642363,
0.0115362974,
0.0014713277,
2.847e-7,
-0.0564148873,
0.0333839767,
0.0218737219,
0.0158665217,
0.0159410462,
0.0380447879,
0.0447128713,
0.0279626474,
0.0002134614,
-0.0454532579,
0.0316919088,
-0.0062837172,
0.0579435155,
-0.0122686038,
-0.1097018942,
-0.1014536098,
-0.0797313377,
-0.0219761692,
-0.0320009589,
-0.0360890217,
0.0295425728,
0.0363194868,
0.0476523601,
0.0095883673,
0.01594612,
0.0030837145,
0.0494153202,
-0.0304454733,
0.0098086363,
0.0533229448,
0.0854061693,
-0.0018393951,
-0.0243782159,
0.0303429235,
-0.020087596,
0.0325356498,
-0.0144461151,
0.0437378436,
0.0228121933,
-0.0544879586,
-0.0158136152,
0.0116033414,
0.0487156585,
-0.0434257947,
0.0260608923,
-0.0523221269,
0.010537887,
-0.0090052029,
-0.0461239368,
-0.0467143469,
0.0003120039,
-0.0141794989,
-0.0342665575,
-0.0072499895,
0.0085085183,
0.0340056382,
0.0217962414,
-0.066389598,
0.0002759905,
0.0237087626,
-0.0446704514,
-0.0440460332,
-0.0302247815,
-0.0000414627,
-0.0295477062,
-0.0690284818,
0.0245372709,
2.432248881e-34,
0.0062539633,
-0.0231381189,
-0.0072333333,
0.0074452572,
0.0364584737,
0.0401227884,
0.0001278521,
-0.0062755384,
0.0785889402,
-0.0225959551,
-0.0168829039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00945v1 | E3 TTS: Easy End-to-End Diffusion-based Text to Speech | 2023-11-02T02:22:21 | 2023-11-02T02:22:21 | Yuan Gao, Nobuyuki Morioka, Yu Zhang, Nanxin Chen | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | We propose Easy End-to-End Diffusion-based Text to Speech, a simple and
efficient end-to-end text-to-speech model based on diffusion. E3 TTS directly
takes plain text as input and generates an audio waveform through an iterative
refinement process. Unlike many prior work, E3 TTS does not rely on any
intermediate representations like spectrogram features or alignment
information. Instead, E3 TTS models the temporal structure of the waveform
through the diffusion process. Without relying on additional conditioning
information, E3 TTS could support flexible latent structure within the given
audio. This enables E3 TTS to be easily adapted for zero-shot tasks such as
editing without any additional training. Experiments show that E3 TTS can
generate high-fidelity audio, approaching the performance of a state-of-the-art
neural TTS system. Audio samples are available at https://e3tts.github.io. | [
-0.0090999296,
0.0112050567,
0.038720265,
-0.010546851,
0.0192103125,
-0.0455854796,
0.0188239012,
-0.002684576,
-0.0815292001,
0.0071709645,
-0.0463989377,
-0.0399874039,
0.0483842418,
0.0811857283,
0.0324855521,
-0.0705437884,
0.0107121598,
-0.0313020796,
-0.0293766838,
0.0134082017,
0.0302235968,
-0.0034954874,
-0.0350612104,
-0.002548293,
-0.021275619,
-0.0049029076,
-0.041922275,
0.0186169613,
0.0223215371,
0.002357973,
-0.0205895249,
0.004292218,
0.0631756783,
-0.0084366659,
0.0000020429,
0.0053378944,
-0.0268845148,
0.0163066573,
0.0035665031,
0.0141898617,
0.0423954129,
0.0176163372,
-0.0508388467,
0.0241612848,
0.0001372121,
0.0681591704,
0.0728981718,
0.0556657016,
0.0749964193,
0.068545267,
-0.0197593775,
-0.070384033,
0.0115185585,
-0.0341816135,
0.0380862914,
0.0296537299,
-0.0202106331,
-0.0411151275,
0.0206012223,
0.0166049916,
-0.0126704928,
0.0588133484,
0.0031274825,
-0.0139430966,
0.0626085699,
0.0459475331,
0.00918571,
-0.0386105105,
-0.0085283583,
0.1112874299,
0.0377471559,
-0.0033350722,
0.021225607,
0.0108127231,
-0.018575646,
-0.0465742238,
0.003383812,
-0.0254160743,
0.0365236513,
0.0054843621,
-0.0549182482,
0.0078677638,
0.0329903737,
-0.0511787049,
0.0130881444,
-0.0069562052,
0.0299986824,
-0.0352828279,
-0.0241875313,
-0.0144396406,
0.0091596628,
-0.0198225603,
0.0700713322,
0.0359246023,
-0.0146846278,
-0.0299838949,
-0.0552022941,
-0.0610326156,
-0.0585451499,
-0.0182096772,
0.0405065641,
0.0404086635,
-0.0081178388,
0.0316920094,
-0.0323331766,
-0.0095894132,
-0.0354850851,
-0.0412226468,
-0.0230729952,
-0.0135419955,
-0.0237744935,
0.0209031254,
-0.0467271805,
0.0311445408,
-0.0357117392,
-0.0331052318,
-0.0416017659,
-0.0206098258,
-0.0133722024,
-0.0036267212,
0.0591440611,
0.0354639515,
-0.0504742041,
-0.0107883131,
0.0050074994,
0.0292755906,
0.0179683492,
0.0191202443,
0.0332609899,
0.032846272,
-0.0453493819,
0.0081629092,
0.0526540503,
0.0074398918,
0.0232974067,
0.0392108709,
-0.0468805991,
-0.0245239828,
-0.0332576707,
0.0009044212,
-0.0371812023,
-0.03244121,
0.011122413,
-0.0754536912,
0.0412679873,
-0.0080351681,
-0.04616661,
-0.0236454736,
0.0016107864,
0.0110647231,
-0.0035227588,
0.0507647246,
-0.0394878313,
0.0182420202,
0.0755168423,
0.0069879079,
-0.0180922765,
0.0069128112,
0.0968212634,
-0.0088039637,
-0.0368413068,
0.0007476308,
-0.0248088092,
0.0674965605,
0.0349015333,
0.0303359311,
-0.033886075,
-0.0391223021,
-0.0345053263,
0.0494548641,
0.0874712244,
0.0700383484,
-0.0217694622,
-0.0153143601,
0.1015011743,
0.0219474435,
0.038186986,
-0.0023239488,
0.0706333295,
0.0386461578,
-0.0229746513,
-0.0414339043,
0.0236877147,
0.0475273952,
0.0383199342,
0.0197216608,
0.0524407551,
-0.011205568,
-0.0390272625,
-0.0175376553,
0.0217385963,
-0.0203208476,
0.0301951785,
-0.0404992327,
0.0377515331,
0.0098850587,
-0.0751649663,
0.0568665527,
-0.0167647228,
-0.0699561238,
0.0325945057,
-0.0036614914,
0.0257576276,
0.0792058855,
0.0061239381,
-0.0133288046,
0.011836146,
-0.0525201112,
0.0233600158,
0.0493820049,
0.0148183526,
0.0171278268,
0.0451588742,
-0.0593310669,
-0.0157286488,
0.0172085036,
-0.0079107871,
0.0286718346,
-0.0332202315,
0.0536412075,
0.0122730406,
-0.0251170602,
0.0496592559,
0.0043648821,
-0.0494585447,
-0.0115259178,
-0.0022000468,
-0.0052522896,
0.0380372517,
0.011238832,
-0.0571067557,
0.0220308453,
-0.0150095262,
-0.0325907692,
-0.019047996,
0.0110226981,
-0.0772870108,
-0.0100473203,
0.0240944792,
-0.024876181,
-0.0006514044,
0.0337287039,
0.007360837,
-0.0637934282,
0.0409557074,
-0.0241465103,
-0.0051719411,
-0.0128415916,
0.0126957735,
0.0469348878,
0.0003294949,
0.0235429034,
-0.0062993485,
0.0123051666,
-0.0215080604,
0.0086480482,
0.0498025194,
-0.0198377986,
-0.0308485329,
-0.0178696346,
-0.0190112665,
0.0185182374,
0.0115383919,
-0.027455559,
-0.0027106646,
-0.030883953,
-0.0200512223,
-0.0734751672,
0.0331004411,
0.0082404809,
0.0136585953,
0.026397869,
0.0148122618,
0.0084613189,
0.007672336,
-0.0492799766,
-0.0017765207,
-0.0043661497,
-0.0413084999,
-0.0055672829,
-0.0064363242,
-0.0267771203,
-0.0435437597,
-0.0006898532,
0.0086120022,
0.0048403959,
-0.029390581,
-0.043906901,
-0.0213966835,
0.0185868107,
0.0149707394,
0.0357085019,
0.0146019002,
-0.0360931121,
-0.0139835281,
-0.0053499909,
0.0653596744,
0.0117333541,
0.0246628337,
-0.0320532173,
-0.0123170428,
-0.0556185618,
-0.0082377708,
0.0148470243,
-0.000271723,
0.101237379,
-0.0205736179,
-0.0170409176,
-0.0255117379,
0.0622612126,
0.0564105362,
0.0186208747,
-0.0722833872,
-0.0101618832,
0.0029592202,
-0.0230995268,
0.0006727079,
-0.0384924524,
-0.04590635,
-0.0531743504,
-0.0525709651,
-0.0094315689,
0.0559569597,
-0.0886113793,
-0.0573403873,
-0.0504177436,
-0.0437916927,
0.0145534342,
-0.026513366,
-0.0394346416,
0.0264314208,
0.0021905804,
-0.0243465621,
-0.0495034382,
-0.0019359688,
0.0038403266,
-0.0430162624,
0.0252794828,
-0.007814182,
0.0103672305,
-0.0214513913,
0.0063459529,
0.007509158,
-0.0359115601,
0.0018301235,
0.042657122,
-0.0264381729,
-0.0351570696,
-0.0258590654,
0.0116613172,
0.0546540357,
0.0747519508,
0.0074544172,
-0.0023482235,
-0.0418177545,
0.0649868175,
0.0061139935,
-0.0266202055,
-0.0315172262,
-0.065936029,
0.0435988307,
0.0361940823,
0.0384832993,
0.0105667785,
-0.083089985,
-0.0059847427,
-0.0315053798,
0.0187940877,
-0.0295426622,
0.0080553601,
0.0767812952,
-0.0574872307,
0.004272182,
0.0947528109,
-0.013622256,
-0.0056339651,
-0.0013435993,
0.0526909903,
0.0767026022,
-0.0081497654,
-0.0303905755,
-0.0411034673,
-0.0273918938,
0.0497735366,
0.0298795477,
0.0492788404,
0.0013579027,
-0.0143065359,
-0.0413718447,
0.0642084107,
0.0432967469,
-0.0056885467,
0.0037853941,
-0.0148320943,
-0.0120320823,
0.038993001,
0.013865402,
0.0095427614,
-0.0034541658,
0.0002489649,
0.0545001365,
-0.0020881395,
-0.0332561582,
-0.0121306162,
-0.0279015005,
0.0423888825,
0.0444106832,
0.0186477695,
-0.0181510225,
-0.0328988135,
0.0436970294,
0.0212979335,
-0.0166175608,
0.0317495912,
0.0367285311,
0.0152303595,
-0.0168532711,
0.0046605486,
0.0502173863,
-0.0037685377,
0.013237155,
-0.0223782342,
0.0449951962,
-0.0093151815,
-0.0032214494,
-0.0247380622,
0.025859151,
0.0202849023,
0.0403604321,
0.0065055792,
-0.0848314613,
-0.0191598739,
-0.0203787014,
0.0383765064,
-0.0512639433,
-0.0491206758,
0.0076668761,
-0.0182144064,
-0.0636430904,
-0.0656403154,
-0.0128777167,
-0.0194155611,
0.0461601727,
0.02226042,
0.0056210635,
0.0128179956,
-0.0333854072,
-0.065969862,
0.0146881398,
-0.0022011721,
0.0437467992,
-0.0521683171,
-0.0000870236,
0.0289568789,
-0.0424780659,
-0.0156516228,
-0.0024175614,
-0.0832988247,
-0.0588507131,
-0.0240662005,
-0.0107458588,
0.012459171,
0.0309368707,
-0.0180961341,
-0.0046696751,
0.1310467571,
-0.0241293553,
-0.0053698476,
0.0692898557,
0.0239274297,
-0.0114541035,
0.0050836019,
0.0016398542,
-0.0599776134,
0.0068357349,
-0.0046129446,
0.0227419846,
0.0202637091,
0.023921011,
-0.0088449242,
-0.0579877049,
0.0221466366,
0.0160489473,
0.0888711885,
-0.0503714606,
0.0021714747,
-0.021347573,
0.0492214821,
-0.0774532259,
0.0143379206,
0.0378356166,
0.0317137465,
-0.0214142967,
0.003449755,
0.0095327562,
0.0065996861,
0.0021382705,
0.0375642851,
0.0084670847,
-0.0124298828,
0.0508515798,
-0.0140807871,
0.0213131718,
0.0074279769,
-0.0457041822,
0.0074868789,
-0.0039188419,
0.0385759585,
0.0249241218,
-0.0063494816,
-0.0035610623,
0.0336446837,
-0.0162615292,
0.0415672287,
-0.043495845,
-0.0162916854,
0.0346262567,
0.0273688566,
0.0750833154,
0.0089917015,
0.0184984803,
-0.0106506664,
0.0299734939,
-0.0629099905,
0.0336027108,
0.0164285153,
-0.0173721462,
0.0108901709,
0.0350281112,
0.0080730012,
-0.0137548605,
0.023110915,
-0.0233914275,
0.020398315,
-0.0041211373,
-0.004328453,
-0.0737607181,
0.0022812607,
-0.0044380529,
-0.0201398581,
0.0185849722,
-0.0617620274,
0.0144393863,
-0.00430799,
-0.0353285857,
-0.0352103412,
0.0589450486,
-0.0056706448,
-0.0218858067,
0.0036240467,
0.0225746576,
-0.0482265987,
0.0063562454,
-0.0559390336,
-0.0050498797,
-6.038700355e-33,
-0.0351014175,
0.0169453435,
0.0207218882,
-0.0036339026,
-0.0697475001,
-0.0293866284,
-0.0604036711,
-0.0016758745,
0.0043848511,
-0.0029662312,
-0.0222051106,
0.0508120097,
0.0123589067,
0.045468282,
-0.0203563385,
0.0363122337,
0.0764791146,
-0.0760459676,
-0.013223039,
0.0139391506,
0.0450288765,
0.0423670635,
0.0340327211,
-0.0578594655,
-0.0358124301,
0.0153994244,
-0.0250406452,
-0.040070314,
0.0350337476,
-0.0011460767,
-0.0023390937,
0.0011450894,
-0.0239194892,
-0.0274645574,
-0.0268449262,
0.0340966396,
-0.0562615022,
0.012233601,
-0.0371825472,
0.0020909396,
-0.054863207,
-0.018383475,
0.0626605377,
-0.0071255961,
-0.0091781486,
-0.0191742908,
0.0271158926,
-0.0142275849,
0.0426618196,
-0.037585631,
-0.0242715776,
0.0365906134,
-0.018716367,
-0.03056187,
0.0233787671,
0.0278948378,
-0.008721116,
-0.0321441852,
-0.1243484095,
0.0183154251,
-0.018833356,
0.0310402513,
0.0105851209,
-0.0083742915,
0.0112082642,
0.0389808826,
0.0460059494,
-0.0229936931,
-0.0010659696,
0.0005310403,
0.0371135063,
0.0229996033,
0.0267442651,
-0.0415140986,
-0.0095774829,
-0.0110071981,
-0.042268686,
0.0124220066,
-0.0430902578,
-0.0096186707,
0.008236791,
0.0437997133,
-0.0244387761,
0.0021406119,
-0.059822958,
-0.0177812204,
-0.014707909,
-0.0468817391,
0.0681023002,
0.0122490134,
0.0374736525,
-0.0432923399,
0.0817958191,
0.0176202282,
0.0064739464,
-0.0086311931,
-0.0534857474,
0.0305213723,
0.002799806,
0.0074506043,
-0.076268889,
-0.0255653206,
0.052769985,
0.0583473742,
0.0155412033,
-0.0069100694,
-0.0311797857,
0.0692125857,
-0.0485056862,
0.0005835023,
0.0087056784,
0.0432933122,
-0.0137519613,
0.0321992338,
0.0171556193,
-0.0159971043,
-0.0097140288,
0.0634536371,
-0.045848079,
0.01322114,
0.0115169147,
0.0136402072,
0.020961687,
0.0473954603,
-0.03666858,
0.0397858098,
-0.0088543277,
0.0523414277,
0.0717418119,
-0.0240831599,
-0.0164854974,
0.0452018417,
2.793e-7,
-0.0111444909,
0.0003561582,
0.0118568735,
0.0110186022,
0.0240684189,
0.0518608689,
-0.0222144108,
0.0209963974,
-0.015089673,
-0.0262149181,
0.0019565932,
0.0130893867,
0.0616820715,
0.015181669,
-0.0934190527,
-0.0628735945,
-0.0523844063,
0.0281980429,
0.0012298513,
0.0018164179,
-0.0031040912,
0.0597191267,
0.0190316942,
-0.0238473117,
0.0297885295,
-0.0164069906,
0.0674536005,
0.0257087294,
0.0113147767,
-0.0260958709,
-0.0036325194,
-0.0647538751,
-0.0262631997,
-0.0033937613,
-0.0517025217,
0.0305573009,
0.0267207362,
0.0526369475,
-0.03003335,
-0.079212971,
0.0243264623,
0.043111261,
-0.0499239117,
0.0140145412,
0.0405784249,
0.0077838795,
-0.0062472071,
0.0246466994,
-0.061618533,
0.0054021147,
-0.0371295884,
-0.0197976585,
-0.0228496641,
-0.0312943012,
0.0176605191,
0.024722958,
-0.0228250418,
-0.046326451,
-0.0244852528,
-0.0084094983,
-0.0393095054,
-0.0379427485,
-0.0431167185,
0.0036369872,
0.048702389,
0.0005091075,
-0.0386648923,
2.111169257e-34,
0.0118957479,
-0.0603788421,
0.0370325744,
-0.0114419116,
0.0056516207,
0.0084237317,
0.0300950576,
-0.0366966873,
0.0104092695,
-0.05092372,
-0.0695594326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04915v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04915v2 | Chain of Empathy: Enhancing Empathetic Response of Large Language Models Based on Psychotherapy Models | 2023-11-02T02:21:39 | 2023-12-14T01:30:01 | Yoon Kyung Lee, Inju Lee, Minjung Shin, Seoyeon Bae, Sowon Hahn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | We present a novel method, the Chain of Empathy (CoE) prompting, that
utilizes insights from psychotherapy to induce Large Language Models (LLMs) to
reason about human emotional states. This method is inspired by various
psychotherapy approaches including Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT),
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), Person Centered Therapy (PCT), and Reality
Therapy (RT), each leading to different patterns of interpreting clients'
mental states. LLMs without reasoning generated predominantly exploratory
responses. However, when LLMs used CoE reasoning, we found a more comprehensive
range of empathetic responses aligned with the different reasoning patterns of
each psychotherapy model. The CBT based CoE resulted in the most balanced
generation of empathetic responses. The findings underscore the importance of
understanding the emotional context and how it affects human and AI
communication. Our research contributes to understanding how psychotherapeutic
models can be incorporated into LLMs, facilitating the development of
context-specific, safer, and empathetic AI. | [
0.0798275322,
0.0190970935,
-0.0327081829,
0.0324487612,
-0.0352685489,
0.0358961038,
0.0366249979,
-0.0104432292,
0.0538528785,
0.0103048366,
-0.0056296908,
0.0016774745,
0.0023506025,
0.0086368639,
-0.0085565206,
-0.1038563848,
-0.0096974261,
0.0238284133,
0.0646550432,
-0.0093453275,
0.0013641241,
0.05460326,
-0.0291303433,
0.0558421165,
0.0009660256,
-0.0229958165,
-0.0077194623,
0.013184255,
0.0264909584,
-0.0497655123,
-0.0222543254,
-0.0061345557,
0.0565612949,
-0.0325031169,
0.0000022767,
-0.0369731896,
0.0050991867,
0.0011654386,
0.0064546471,
-0.0482215956,
0.0594524667,
-0.0664000809,
0.0046895212,
0.030801421,
-0.0104691796,
0.0268255565,
0.0351551212,
0.0572258644,
0.0547616445,
0.0393595062,
-0.0415387079,
-0.0137378136,
0.0163642373,
-0.0034709584,
-0.019978242,
0.0337674692,
0.0202843715,
0.0179434922,
0.062924087,
-0.0103884265,
-0.0316093415,
0.0222443584,
0.0206993707,
0.0184927024,
-0.0009771489,
0.0252788439,
0.0253048874,
-0.050586503,
0.0047321692,
0.0799917728,
0.0450271294,
0.0443087779,
0.0195791125,
-0.0134496549,
-0.0001229359,
-0.0373080336,
-0.0142385447,
0.0256614685,
-0.0115147512,
0.0197498593,
0.0347561389,
0.0125569422,
-0.0059445375,
0.0305719711,
0.015975317,
0.0372629911,
-0.0224248413,
-0.0087648872,
0.027214393,
-0.0077203894,
-0.0354255885,
-0.0359777436,
-0.0086018983,
0.0281066801,
-0.057916373,
0.0354550928,
-0.0347648337,
0.0324938446,
-0.0092554558,
-0.012757645,
0.0326432958,
0.0602335297,
-0.0158166047,
-0.0035580718,
0.0383542329,
0.0369293913,
0.0003415929,
0.0227487311,
-0.0363770984,
0.0328616351,
-0.0633069277,
-0.0167726427,
-0.036602065,
0.0077141202,
-0.0178596731,
-0.0201977678,
-0.0551438518,
0.0207285155,
-0.0533192158,
0.0033336675,
-0.0329064541,
-0.0221442375,
-0.0074024033,
-0.0190013889,
-0.0156723764,
0.017475076,
-0.0610911176,
0.0123650776,
0.0268361866,
-0.0710642189,
0.0035910441,
0.0044952533,
-0.0350026116,
-0.0325705968,
-0.0022950028,
0.0153827444,
-0.0004017059,
-0.0400937274,
-0.0194369331,
-0.0218694322,
-0.0235388186,
-0.0367030427,
0.013461533,
-0.0175031777,
0.0228507128,
-0.0051333718,
0.0361547545,
-0.0400160775,
0.0338025205,
-0.0192601942,
-0.1013436243,
0.0845305324,
-0.0254972689,
0.0206051394,
-0.0066229142,
0.0417531766,
0.0290358514,
0.0269600451,
0.0060486882,
0.0182044022,
0.0086934716,
-0.023477139,
0.0335686579,
-0.0341369919,
-0.030838294,
-0.0326954909,
-0.054403659,
-0.0316293612,
-0.0520506725,
0.0745767057,
-0.0175946355,
0.0190230478,
-0.027498601,
0.0209622048,
0.0495191738,
0.0863072276,
0.0117691671,
0.0792531595,
0.0235406663,
0.0055784457,
0.0036975548,
-0.0056464127,
-0.0675017759,
0.0514364876,
-0.014225102,
-0.0213913601,
-0.0065647913,
-0.0258214436,
-0.0262417402,
-0.0212615859,
-0.0180058181,
-0.0149319666,
0.0073293652,
0.0127526997,
-0.0277835783,
-0.0290555619,
-0.00933633,
-0.0513535477,
0.0466543101,
-0.0335578844,
-0.0404938832,
-0.0732257962,
-0.0214090627,
0.1286145747,
0.0398904905,
-0.0371926464,
-0.0042118253,
-0.0044597397,
-0.0028227724,
0.0297654327,
0.008952518,
0.0149668986,
0.0152735859,
-0.0059579173,
0.0007745135,
0.001913053,
-0.0004335964,
0.0068871169,
-0.0521483682,
0.0220038649,
-0.0265830364,
-0.002105352,
0.0071902638,
0.0410053134,
-0.0674599409,
-0.011250549,
-0.0348709375,
0.0101458021,
0.0211795475,
0.0185651071,
-0.0047625257,
0.0006119123,
0.0291186795,
-0.0328114741,
-0.0109671932,
0.0711522698,
-0.0625521317,
0.0080519691,
-0.0008694206,
-0.023091644,
-0.0014463428,
0.0248608757,
0.0151708573,
-0.0032401239,
0.032169316,
-0.0265864562,
0.0606540032,
-0.0305385105,
0.0249668546,
-0.0300934967,
0.0258056801,
-0.0047470508,
0.0078643737,
-0.0120562231,
-0.0204179566,
0.0015073721,
-0.0181100648,
-0.0414284915,
-0.0107674664,
-0.0131490659,
0.0386229381,
0.0077053304,
-0.0256141201,
-0.0254348889,
-0.000474428,
-0.0592922121,
-0.0371074751,
-0.1078783125,
-0.0224285182,
-0.0112972446,
-0.034184169,
0.016980879,
-0.0241289195,
-0.0339108147,
0.0295587722,
-0.0268545598,
0.0513895452,
0.0198995396,
0.0167590398,
-0.0047894595,
-0.0117409248,
-0.0165489763,
-0.0513699055,
-0.0044013523,
-0.0420568734,
0.0328638032,
-0.0181832742,
0.0230405685,
-0.0456337556,
0.0113513088,
-0.0511804931,
0.0091822241,
-0.016116295,
-0.0809414536,
0.0269543584,
-0.0104268268,
0.0166174751,
0.0657525063,
0.0061866618,
0.085609667,
0.0242314674,
0.0048713279,
-0.0571983643,
0.0233905725,
0.0032897138,
-0.0258989632,
-0.0639315546,
-0.0626973361,
-0.0262690242,
0.056690339,
0.0194770601,
0.0159934629,
-0.0763637424,
-0.0122293998,
0.0126818502,
-0.0343175344,
0.005771142,
-0.0642715394,
-0.0050466345,
-0.0056817704,
0.0086020958,
-0.021765355,
0.0677565336,
0.0141581502,
-0.0157164913,
-0.0304753389,
-0.0155845843,
0.0215411931,
0.0688029528,
-0.0172217209,
0.026077196,
0.0261158515,
0.0216339454,
-0.009356699,
-0.0665897131,
-0.0209259409,
-0.0149129666,
-0.0011177813,
-0.0518751033,
-0.0236359034,
0.0393898711,
0.0138617465,
-0.0469437428,
-0.0154595105,
-0.0591829307,
0.0033629355,
0.0153132649,
0.0023470256,
-0.0043380903,
-0.0341477096,
0.0813677981,
0.0113485642,
-0.0063653137,
-0.0511491485,
-0.0227012262,
-0.0528263599,
0.0308269709,
-0.0105282338,
0.0593378916,
-0.0145745846,
0.1151490062,
0.0237433054,
0.0141134234,
0.0188353658,
-0.0093353661,
0.0456026532,
-0.0242611952,
0.03064836,
-0.0068424628,
0.0105066067,
0.023818735,
0.010012635,
-0.0335654654,
0.1357889622,
0.0311203171,
-0.0636109412,
0.0490016416,
-0.0342989676,
-0.019783441,
-0.0026730308,
-0.0110236583,
-0.0358463638,
-0.0039148415,
0.0009799035,
0.0335312858,
-0.033780884,
-0.0435465947,
0.0043905959,
-0.0493535437,
0.0442983657,
-0.0130102141,
0.0706888437,
-0.037303891,
-0.0127162663,
0.0221270323,
0.0399984233,
-0.0174460337,
-0.0155771682,
0.0052585718,
0.0045545516,
0.0028625494,
-0.0050337631,
-0.0057200626,
0.0563848801,
-0.0085746739,
0.0930209011,
0.039845787,
0.0958454832,
-0.0070956177,
-0.0081413556,
-0.039549727,
0.0492779203,
0.0305795949,
0.0134055857,
-0.0020185425,
0.0143544693,
0.0159747303,
-0.0145696653,
0.0602608249,
-0.034457501,
-0.0180312023,
0.0156946667,
0.0768798515,
-0.0458177179,
-0.0258634929,
-0.0028089958,
0.0556421094,
0.0141330212,
0.0604423545,
0.0357191972,
-0.0699671954,
-0.0044793878,
0.0232990161,
0.017108988,
0.0608293898,
-0.0460799299,
0.0120580774,
-0.0156436637,
-0.0229209177,
-0.053075321,
-0.0595358387,
0.0021742405,
0.0124637028,
-0.0041696867,
-0.0506757125,
0.0111186225,
0.0184964836,
-0.0023039666,
0.0307945497,
0.0159559548,
0.0359780081,
0.0093514668,
0.053149417,
0.0198306181,
-0.0585068315,
0.0121691246,
0.0038384313,
0.0276825894,
-0.031681411,
0.0515364036,
0.0186221618,
0.0186788812,
0.0211098138,
0.0226720758,
-0.0554426424,
-0.030139178,
0.0272604637,
-0.0091839191,
0.0111500556,
0.0139910355,
0.0428852662,
0.0232810248,
0.0387234725,
-0.0106378281,
0.0669149905,
0.0456412472,
0.0201501939,
-0.0050394591,
-0.0352447554,
0.0336622261,
0.0454513282,
-0.0011628645,
-0.0139206769,
-0.013487339,
0.0022964408,
-0.0318675004,
-0.0358158872,
0.0033879159,
-0.0387454517,
-0.0074054594,
0.0146784717,
0.0268351678,
-0.0080626877,
-0.0997492224,
-0.042178411,
-0.0257355943,
0.0000534903,
0.0042630993,
-0.0406277925,
0.0122371819,
-0.0241636615,
0.0172794349,
0.0023506272,
0.019168755,
-0.0485837571,
0.0070555834,
-0.032427337,
0.1000309885,
0.0355022997,
-0.0258450396,
-0.010240213,
0.0487894081,
-0.0237952862,
-0.0737087429,
0.0055323155,
0.0138253989,
0.0233672876,
0.0268882997,
0.0269635189,
-0.084433049,
0.026870165,
0.0154243028,
0.0319436379,
0.0040136944,
-0.0489565656,
-0.0254824813,
0.0177657213,
-0.013930128,
-0.0336160399,
-0.0150544625,
-0.0716421679,
0.0328801125,
-0.0019784607,
-0.025123788,
-0.0213214289,
0.0002882503,
0.0163891669,
-0.0139300702,
-0.0211698078,
0.0373357981,
-0.0692949146,
-0.0685646385,
0.0057256725,
-0.0214266609,
-0.0229580794,
-0.0596882924,
0.0181497335,
0.0372924246,
-0.0110357739,
-0.0053799958,
-0.0201903824,
0.0443726666,
-0.0344011113,
-0.0141728958,
-0.0297259539,
-5.78968253e-33,
0.0030439706,
0.0123306168,
-0.0226695631,
-0.0332549587,
-0.0733449087,
-0.0002202328,
-0.0418729782,
0.0190562513,
-0.0001568079,
0.0628840551,
-0.0171307512,
0.0628966168,
-0.002211601,
-0.0187869873,
0.0060591577,
0.011208469,
-0.010666959,
-0.0021520457,
-0.0112253772,
0.0232019424,
-0.0131816398,
0.0492538698,
0.0213759691,
-0.0898355693,
0.0286003835,
0.0330071114,
-0.0436077267,
0.0091163581,
-0.006506714,
0.0142398952,
-0.0313013233,
0.0546017103,
0.0313738547,
-0.0075342762,
0.0245381352,
0.0293061864,
-0.0207044091,
-0.0228644125,
0.0387930311,
-0.0484902523,
-0.0832850412,
-0.0255078692,
-0.0099319201,
-0.0130203655,
-0.0173661597,
-0.0223292001,
0.0057953424,
-0.0461787172,
0.0381954275,
0.0157516208,
-0.0311268084,
-0.0503013916,
-0.0577356033,
-0.026410874,
0.0053418805,
0.0395086035,
-0.0517055206,
0.0419142991,
-0.0221826583,
0.012064429,
0.0231611785,
-0.0423470065,
0.021261679,
-0.0263740718,
0.0021768264,
0.0641138703,
-0.0052780597,
0.0218964983,
-0.0439432226,
0.0207691919,
0.0258463658,
0.0226759166,
0.0447773784,
0.0427028053,
-0.0859780833,
-0.0338520072,
-0.0145296194,
-0.0105969571,
0.0134571353,
0.010720659,
0.0637516379,
0.0056090001,
-0.0242141597,
-0.0059350878,
-0.0470538661,
-0.0366266631,
-0.0183594674,
-0.049144607,
0.0186179113,
-0.0281280633,
-0.032998722,
-0.0272130948,
-0.0126416208,
-0.0397415422,
0.0235761609,
0.0041897823,
-0.0039737849,
0.0376227908,
0.0091223409,
0.0373097658,
-0.0000465967,
-0.0251570754,
0.0136079686,
-0.0139511852,
0.0814449266,
-0.0082569122,
0.0035786158,
-0.0038706835,
-0.009948994,
-0.0238575973,
-0.0371900648,
0.0631099045,
0.0150300227,
-0.0311333835,
-0.0574312322,
0.0388971344,
-0.0229517855,
-0.0088922046,
0.0523172766,
-0.0280551426,
-0.069151938,
0.0058792159,
-0.0401503406,
0.0296622124,
-0.0443105511,
-0.0230135843,
-0.0250782073,
-0.0213569477,
0.0843629017,
-0.0289361663,
-0.0408927538,
-0.0096116178,
2.958e-7,
-0.0423391499,
0.0467247963,
0.0020752894,
-0.0145184295,
0.0247497354,
0.0634238496,
0.0034602175,
0.0797487199,
0.051400356,
-0.0535803139,
0.0336660147,
0.0412516333,
0.0713456348,
0.0146296388,
-0.0080613615,
0.0531835034,
-0.0307404026,
-0.0394335091,
-0.0536495559,
0.0169760082,
0.0929007754,
0.0309366491,
0.0479073934,
-0.0121172285,
0.0435048528,
0.0676014796,
-0.0051900884,
-0.0833234936,
0.0093573015,
0.0082960492,
-0.0205947328,
-0.03475371,
0.0298739485,
0.0165566895,
0.0401634611,
-0.0074349507,
-0.0117876399,
0.0730635747,
-0.0509101301,
-0.0140491454,
0.0083854236,
0.0305925645,
-0.0031704344,
-0.0548437685,
0.0267709177,
-0.104515329,
-0.0315369405,
0.0178492293,
-0.0087701967,
-0.0389161929,
0.0028843342,
-0.0177107099,
-0.0378786922,
0.0493601263,
0.0063460674,
-0.0103919636,
0.0313795507,
-0.0345825665,
0.0394691043,
0.0078844307,
-0.0388663001,
-0.0253983811,
-0.0197641589,
0.0282315817,
0.0230598282,
-0.0650610998,
0.0162624475,
2.229246976e-34,
-0.0185402241,
0.0457085483,
0.0389166772,
0.0204072408,
0.0569451712,
0.0475787483,
-0.0185569059,
0.042093534,
0.0242922474,
-0.0876311436,
-0.009726976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00915v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00915v1 | Task-Agnostic Low-Rank Adapters for Unseen English Dialects | 2023-11-02T01:17:29 | 2023-11-02T01:17:29 | Zedian Xiao, William Held, Yanchen Liu, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on corpora disproportionally
weighted in favor of Standard American English. As a result, speakers of other
dialects experience significantly more failures when interacting with these
technologies. In practice, these speakers often accommodate their speech to be
better understood. Our work shares the belief that language technologies should
be designed to accommodate the diversity in English dialects and not the other
way around. However, prior works on dialect struggle with generalizing to
evolving and emerging dialects in a scalable manner. To fill this gap, our
method, HyperLoRA, leverages expert linguistic knowledge to enable
resource-efficient adaptation via hypernetworks. By disentangling
dialect-specific and cross-dialectal information, HyperLoRA improves
generalization to unseen dialects in a task-agnostic fashion. Not only is
HyperLoRA more scalable in the number of parameters, but it also achieves the
best or most competitive performance across 5 dialects in a zero-shot setting.
In this way, our approach facilitates access to language technology for
billions of English dialect speakers who are traditionally underrepresented. | [
0.0118033346,
0.0858159214,
-0.017410595,
0.0182891954,
0.0105450628,
-0.0028217172,
0.0434315018,
-0.0097605344,
-0.0036015562,
-0.0120510068,
-0.0697207451,
-0.0191818662,
0.0064192982,
-0.0105261225,
0.0354980268,
-0.0327689089,
0.044698298,
-0.0177565683,
-0.0213449318,
-0.0425730497,
0.0031037552,
0.0257189702,
-0.0194545537,
0.0347358137,
-0.0058033294,
0.0170689579,
-0.0197052434,
0.0363160521,
0.029588256,
0.0427174419,
0.0164151527,
0.026779728,
0.0148277497,
0.0764734745,
0.0000017361,
-0.0268239863,
0.0024008423,
-0.0326310955,
-0.020502463,
0.0240452439,
0.0560014024,
-0.0107528409,
-0.0314628147,
0.0207518116,
-0.0252154637,
-0.0193370357,
0.0786063671,
-0.0115810102,
0.0502401777,
0.066438362,
-0.0125615783,
0.0089672571,
0.0286153592,
-0.0321507342,
-0.0373793393,
-0.0231586173,
-0.0102834105,
-0.0335725583,
-0.0051083528,
-0.0388678126,
-0.0267622806,
0.0372003056,
0.0017591364,
0.002073952,
-0.0344883427,
0.0134818675,
-0.0617502853,
0.0272466186,
-0.0212578345,
0.0796052963,
-0.0358931944,
-0.015877435,
-0.0024509812,
0.0364874043,
-0.0103608919,
-0.0129247503,
-0.0253587924,
-0.0151953511,
0.039734032,
-0.0061431741,
-0.0149804242,
-0.0320129395,
0.0264718439,
0.0049341661,
-0.0366721563,
0.062903665,
0.0337779485,
0.0127925118,
-0.0177081954,
0.0087350728,
-0.0011868945,
-0.0114661884,
0.0413518958,
0.0074958121,
-0.0529566742,
0.0113807414,
-0.0199202709,
-0.0472804792,
-0.015814567,
-0.0305856075,
0.0618514754,
0.0386548564,
-0.0147057604,
-0.0040660431,
-0.0343008973,
-0.0065921382,
-0.0318945535,
0.0140314372,
-0.0352238268,
-0.0395396315,
-0.0659053177,
0.0195063855,
-0.0443931818,
0.0127842464,
-0.044698067,
-0.0064260531,
-0.0120059485,
0.0092324326,
-0.0108050862,
0.0212633535,
0.0487398133,
0.0135787046,
-0.0685553551,
-0.0550179966,
0.0034846808,
0.0960954875,
-0.0003419272,
0.0364302844,
-0.0318550617,
-0.0556721501,
0.0010552423,
0.0436710417,
0.0083410069,
-0.0219668485,
0.0003978118,
0.0180768203,
-0.0260322001,
0.0004906252,
-0.0573138706,
0.0446157865,
-0.041354917,
-0.0239594001,
-0.0158143807,
-0.063218303,
0.0173523203,
-0.0267220289,
0.0358752869,
-0.0378755592,
-0.039568536,
-0.038585145,
-0.0371893458,
0.0151152713,
-0.0138188573,
-0.0018805683,
0.0415580794,
-0.044562187,
-0.0048867441,
0.0780070052,
0.0394454785,
-0.0325302407,
0.0088342465,
-0.0215397906,
-0.0481235795,
0.063987188,
0.0075420523,
0.0377219766,
-0.0631514713,
-0.0166970789,
-0.0039223251,
0.0336506106,
0.0580259711,
0.034735132,
-0.0175051447,
-0.0207845476,
0.0622559041,
0.0508524217,
0.0535045676,
0.030509714,
0.0562982522,
0.012320403,
-0.0361059718,
-0.0243726149,
-0.0188070592,
0.0004510781,
-0.0402955264,
-0.0154747348,
-0.0171487853,
0.0882088244,
-0.0726910606,
-0.034606386,
-0.0064774309,
-0.0134226652,
-0.0143383704,
0.0228241831,
0.0395143032,
-0.0007256817,
0.0221870616,
0.0692377463,
0.0561272278,
-0.0228876621,
0.0211797114,
-0.0328642353,
-0.0208806079,
0.0681533739,
-0.0086991349,
-0.0409571417,
-0.0025682866,
-0.0217425004,
0.0079241274,
0.0371777341,
0.0612374507,
-0.0247185305,
0.0460877009,
-0.0689641908,
0.0369880833,
0.0563721061,
0.0177753754,
0.0852587968,
-0.0332519822,
0.0122752134,
0.002453736,
-0.0281025562,
-0.0242844131,
-0.0116119822,
-0.0356181264,
0.0016289034,
0.052311454,
0.0036698943,
0.0076711825,
0.0347075537,
-0.0485376157,
-0.0402381197,
-0.0278752241,
-0.0449506082,
0.0187417381,
0.0117427399,
-0.021783758,
-0.0588677712,
0.015527809,
-0.0377387889,
0.024735624,
0.063297525,
-0.000319197,
-0.0883550942,
0.0693637431,
-0.0129058724,
0.0735087544,
-0.0527360514,
-0.0037601553,
-0.0168791991,
0.046301987,
-0.0102389548,
0.0199080203,
0.0382209122,
-0.0126703326,
0.010297752,
-0.0421753787,
-0.0054696584,
-0.0645976961,
-0.0358729847,
0.0601652376,
0.0029141151,
0.0410945453,
-0.0147849955,
-0.0068864953,
-0.0069196033,
-0.0367621183,
-0.114108488,
0.0015348658,
-0.0380389392,
0.0580463856,
0.0413097776,
0.0228501726,
-0.0271557774,
-0.0413171127,
-0.0314191468,
0.0437580794,
-0.0040613315,
-0.0112477876,
-0.0134225851,
0.0253036767,
0.0064997668,
-0.0501445867,
-0.045169618,
-0.0017548165,
0.0370742567,
-0.0596525706,
-0.0049926331,
-0.0384674333,
-0.036070589,
-0.0330145322,
0.0260735732,
0.0231759641,
-0.031628035,
-0.0343668014,
-0.0494803078,
0.0241858661,
0.0447803624,
-0.0277812425,
-0.0291531757,
0.0436322093,
-0.0123723652,
-0.0657946616,
0.0143687697,
-0.0140568456,
-0.023372585,
-0.0959798098,
-0.0006187815,
-0.0306594092,
0.0620564111,
0.0068238433,
-0.0583826415,
-0.0801842809,
0.0019402037,
-0.0075847502,
-0.0056830896,
-0.0203990713,
0.0321690962,
-0.0142291803,
0.0011442624,
-0.0161636844,
0.0053613964,
0.0434583873,
-0.0336834379,
-0.0269167069,
-0.0452980809,
-0.0338481478,
-0.0224483218,
-0.0308589507,
-0.0041722846,
0.0633595064,
0.005602106,
-0.0452212766,
-0.0212701708,
0.0066578919,
0.0078869602,
-0.0028868546,
0.0798447952,
-0.0400821343,
0.0138567705,
-0.0184608009,
-0.0442068689,
-0.004010478,
-0.0362098441,
-0.0355402492,
0.0291528739,
0.0066712024,
-0.0494520292,
-0.0122761345,
-0.0113042174,
0.0394540392,
0.0876621157,
-0.0263635889,
-0.0044701942,
-0.0462428406,
0.0374094434,
0.0056993822,
0.0826398954,
0.0262990724,
0.0192520265,
0.0634456798,
-0.0128976181,
0.0638496652,
0.0053077312,
-0.0203773044,
0.0344753824,
0.0322265476,
-0.0201333538,
-0.0191850141,
0.0364372022,
0.0475110672,
-0.0014368143,
0.0024600653,
0.0900300369,
0.0070817927,
-0.0432010069,
0.0154610854,
-0.0314210989,
0.0841782838,
0.0415655822,
0.0556540228,
-0.0484880656,
-0.0043071588,
0.0064917309,
0.0256617721,
0.0233217794,
-0.0306914207,
-0.0142883221,
-0.1097016782,
-0.0030383337,
0.0293303691,
0.009454811,
0.0382966101,
0.0152214039,
0.0200639758,
-0.0253141243,
0.0459097363,
-0.0163690448,
0.0220110789,
-0.0532128252,
0.0406135246,
-0.0083277123,
-0.0695599541,
0.0157312863,
-0.020364061,
0.0882041156,
-0.0236147419,
0.0027968595,
-0.062264502,
-0.0416935496,
-0.0058970042,
-0.0130934231,
-0.0091636525,
-0.0132563813,
0.0259060077,
0.0349738896,
-0.0364194252,
0.0274999309,
0.0076726833,
-0.0510767698,
0.029451061,
0.0114034396,
0.0700493157,
0.0069383313,
0.018019028,
0.0244476702,
-0.022520341,
0.0027520943,
0.0229774471,
0.0091172159,
-0.0719237626,
0.0183538441,
-0.0179820713,
-0.0322608203,
-0.0298816971,
-0.0319698937,
0.0603466965,
-0.0025095905,
-0.015875604,
-0.0377652682,
-0.0063029062,
0.0096762991,
0.0715294778,
0.0581202134,
-0.046117723,
0.0316740647,
-0.0277376045,
0.0141987484,
0.03408565,
-0.0300038848,
0.0059418096,
-0.0177647546,
-0.010538917,
0.0736276209,
-0.0227653459,
0.0035773432,
-0.0221834984,
-0.0012372395,
-0.0629831031,
0.0098492121,
0.0255905651,
0.0270228852,
0.0565559231,
-0.0276628472,
-0.0802922472,
0.0186641254,
-0.0081730653,
0.03251471,
0.0267974027,
0.0583895072,
-0.0255090203,
-0.016616581,
0.0577115901,
-0.0337513499,
0.05133323,
0.0319908112,
0.0243809111,
-0.0482430086,
-0.0300225578,
-0.0094823102,
-0.0055902,
0.0073431153,
-0.0218089987,
0.010869964,
-0.0384713784,
0.0238527823,
-0.0060269013,
0.027137382,
-0.0257664453,
-0.0205802526,
0.0369913243,
-0.012723879,
-0.0034950851,
0.044215899,
0.0349652991,
0.0355813764,
-0.0166742243,
0.0073384442,
-0.0091939578,
0.0084360866,
0.0242332984,
0.0321834683,
-0.0122891422,
0.0225579068,
0.0333648734,
0.0470219851,
-0.0340382867,
0.0108022681,
-0.0148357144,
-0.0266002007,
-0.0455592796,
0.0180358496,
-0.0595664419,
-0.0580716617,
-0.0236203112,
0.0318188854,
0.0755855292,
-0.0086495783,
0.0772021487,
0.005038097,
0.0129614435,
-0.0340269208,
-0.0197619945,
0.0075578019,
0.0087211775,
0.0307784118,
-0.0065503824,
-0.003899002,
0.0338674188,
0.0320445597,
0.0093551511,
0.0381831191,
-0.0173599031,
0.0283989087,
-0.0436951183,
-0.037073642,
0.0168426111,
0.0288024303,
-0.0264927018,
-0.0082892329,
-0.0119963856,
-0.0734242052,
0.0143003464,
0.0125688799,
0.0033554642,
-0.0345220566,
-0.0085486118,
-0.0093960352,
-0.0219934229,
-0.0132989492,
-0.0230089966,
-0.0154361995,
0.012429852,
-0.005474804,
0.021483222,
-6.331992073e-33,
-0.0385674909,
0.0442893282,
-0.0154323597,
-0.0525684915,
-0.0034049761,
-0.0124562904,
-0.0248431489,
0.0298948921,
-0.0563069247,
0.0032976139,
-0.0473411009,
0.0118675381,
0.0249923728,
0.0617791228,
0.0335863195,
0.0329091921,
0.0510701388,
-0.0099976612,
0.0080178389,
0.0297716111,
0.0424410626,
0.0211932193,
0.0865232423,
-0.0362032168,
0.0028121218,
0.028034661,
-0.0114094848,
0.0370342396,
0.0221083947,
0.0315130502,
-0.0082461536,
0.1111403704,
0.0166221708,
-0.0513056815,
-0.0283101015,
0.0369709246,
-0.068518132,
-0.0057708155,
-0.009193711,
0.0223807376,
0.0249760542,
-0.0404567868,
0.0481320359,
0.0101807816,
-0.0261364803,
0.0003615084,
0.0263430886,
-0.028572429,
0.0091299806,
-0.0236036889,
-0.0457182117,
0.0173599329,
-0.0181790069,
0.0072680246,
0.020009404,
0.0219402015,
-0.0091186827,
-0.0356384702,
-0.069838129,
-0.008896363,
-0.0157078132,
0.0450790785,
0.0608047098,
0.0096660759,
-0.0266228244,
0.0189617779,
0.0298937485,
-0.0165086966,
0.0503186584,
-0.0161575917,
0.0611211099,
-0.0063024545,
0.0182413775,
0.0461107455,
-0.0202399325,
-0.0684004426,
-0.0435736626,
-0.0297279041,
0.0350775905,
-0.0160870533,
-0.0027591379,
0.0295816325,
-0.0142492549,
-0.0077029839,
-0.0300488323,
-0.0270624422,
-0.0251038354,
-0.0401343517,
0.0068266997,
-0.0308813788,
0.0160098746,
0.014818022,
0.0505006723,
-0.0760791451,
-0.0433642901,
0.0083370963,
0.009877244,
0.0100474833,
0.002871657,
0.0742545202,
-0.0453646369,
-0.0227784924,
-0.0001212674,
0.0452701263,
-0.0068150242,
-0.0006390971,
0.0247611832,
0.0343475677,
-0.0703756958,
-0.0005465064,
-0.0053245118,
0.0309426431,
-0.0275342539,
0.0842152834,
0.0069828168,
0.0024949117,
0.0103718825,
0.0300761405,
-0.0070151272,
-0.0316870436,
0.0050158976,
0.022789957,
0.0211069584,
0.0385316871,
-0.0384634957,
0.0027181937,
-0.032084059,
-0.0036095292,
0.0345089771,
-0.0182439461,
-0.0021348796,
0.0020444307,
2.614e-7,
0.0182987582,
0.0262516346,
-0.0039788047,
-0.0723081976,
0.0707023069,
0.0103021804,
-0.0229657702,
0.0372790582,
-0.0032059976,
-0.0218116865,
0.0142578678,
0.0340702757,
0.0762054846,
0.0308677237,
-0.0668150112,
-0.0436467454,
-0.0549767688,
0.0292525068,
-0.0418555066,
0.0188885592,
0.0535277501,
0.0950981081,
-0.0067236801,
-0.028281698,
0.0126436176,
-0.038932953,
0.0331323743,
-0.0254172329,
-0.0089406455,
0.036522463,
0.02590237,
0.0088867201,
-0.0193067547,
0.0077463062,
0.0060808957,
0.0715380087,
-0.0459107906,
0.068605341,
-0.0249260627,
-0.0401301533,
0.0036612651,
0.0173151139,
-0.0178401731,
-0.0291080512,
0.0490080975,
-0.0117221847,
-0.0148072122,
-0.0061011501,
0.0235136542,
-0.0058439756,
-0.0083520291,
-0.0422177203,
-0.0054362523,
0.0175576266,
0.0370263383,
-0.0301639345,
-0.0373237133,
-0.0881271288,
-0.0122451279,
0.0781888962,
-0.0824645981,
-0.0616850294,
0.0155327618,
0.0130938599,
0.01058337,
-0.0463695489,
0.0478116944,
1.790159429e-34,
0.0283534508,
0.0411817655,
0.0362951942,
0.0055536996,
-0.0150912954,
-0.0031793129,
-0.0277649425,
-0.0244100969,
0.0273423325,
-0.0984897465,
-0.0320845395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00913v1 | Self-Influence Guided Data Reweighting for Language Model Pre-training | 2023-11-02T01:00:46 | 2023-11-02T01:00:46 | Megh Thakkar, Tolga Bolukbasi, Sriram Ganapathy, Shikhar Vashishth, Sarath Chandar, Partha Talukdar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language Models (LMs) pre-trained with self-supervision on large text corpora
have become the default starting point for developing models for various NLP
tasks. Once the pre-training corpus has been assembled, all data samples in the
corpus are treated with equal importance during LM pre-training. However, due
to varying levels of relevance and quality of data, equal importance to all the
data samples may not be the optimal choice. While data reweighting has been
explored in the context of task-specific supervised learning and LM
fine-tuning, model-driven reweighting for pre-training data has not been
explored. We fill this important gap and propose PRESENCE, a method for jointly
reweighting samples by leveraging self-influence (SI) scores as an indicator of
sample importance and pre-training. PRESENCE promotes novelty and stability for
model pre-training. Through extensive analysis spanning multiple model sizes,
datasets, and tasks, we present PRESENCE as an important first step in the
research direction of sample reweighting for pre-training language models. | [
0.0276370458,
0.0374688134,
-0.0144110359,
-0.0019072,
-0.0090396274,
0.0126619749,
0.0106236963,
-0.0162636414,
0.0123370169,
-0.0555802137,
-0.0621771589,
-0.0020885337,
-0.0390041247,
-0.0048730643,
0.0230302457,
-0.0182654839,
0.0163780451,
0.0142363962,
-0.0215839334,
-0.0107660694,
0.0174392518,
-0.0160502419,
0.0111882696,
0.0110793635,
-0.0074792281,
-0.0109063722,
0.0332000442,
0.0148549005,
-0.0124597615,
-0.0300393123,
0.0484880917,
0.1116710678,
0.0305795874,
0.0063314973,
0.0000019434,
-0.0597309135,
-0.0401229486,
-0.0262485109,
-0.0448880941,
0.0065826769,
0.0641909093,
-0.0012889743,
0.0071247146,
0.0201622639,
-0.0512006208,
-0.0044227042,
0.0391510166,
0.0575021654,
0.0433682539,
0.0555017516,
-0.0130743403,
0.0002913929,
-0.0461854413,
-0.0418729,
0.000095008,
0.0013317906,
0.0286267307,
0.0344996229,
-0.0710426793,
0.0255154707,
-0.0124401972,
0.027115481,
-0.0170811117,
-0.018784171,
0.0326598138,
-0.0109548056,
-0.0294690914,
0.0047845258,
-0.0195619799,
0.0601356626,
-0.0429419391,
-0.0661579669,
-0.0057131243,
-0.0382641032,
0.030567063,
0.0562533364,
-0.0409183204,
-0.0255419333,
0.0624309517,
0.0316522233,
0.0235940404,
0.0233163871,
0.0311642867,
0.0134762013,
-0.0349486135,
0.0491585433,
-0.0034371428,
-0.0376101024,
0.0321938619,
0.0460154638,
-0.0433132015,
-0.0451475754,
0.0025639397,
-0.0002686995,
0.0121368095,
0.0259004571,
-0.0110123595,
-0.0609490424,
0.0284392145,
-0.0647221878,
0.0567141399,
0.0196892396,
-0.0298444666,
0.0291162431,
0.0032076249,
-0.0055651637,
0.0278560873,
0.0004959864,
-0.0444140024,
0.0170017257,
-0.0657434464,
-0.0026528586,
-0.0610876158,
0.0281670764,
0.0330137871,
0.0148721831,
-0.0353151411,
0.0233003199,
-0.0122497808,
-0.0671911687,
0.0331509747,
0.0099772224,
-0.0402135737,
0.0022918973,
-0.0006846456,
0.0412105918,
-0.0142558161,
0.0345647223,
-0.0360203348,
-0.0472127981,
-0.0173429511,
0.0113784103,
-0.0069308854,
-0.045167461,
0.0466279797,
0.0249043666,
0.0261459313,
-0.065447785,
-0.0371449329,
-0.0045523657,
-0.0256556608,
-0.0377733149,
-0.0089658517,
-0.0474542007,
-0.0069967448,
-0.0044086161,
0.0226932671,
-0.0461054482,
-0.0270849504,
0.0121762473,
-0.0205626059,
0.0814581737,
0.0003351526,
0.0242612008,
-0.0064360197,
-0.006451562,
0.0088638403,
0.083626084,
0.0071270959,
-0.0043181786,
0.0466969758,
-0.0106823193,
0.0278899428,
0.0108743934,
0.037277475,
0.0359730348,
-0.0258771535,
-0.0046500671,
-0.0192186385,
-0.0270853341,
0.0188282542,
-0.0178823173,
-0.0186853036,
0.0176533218,
0.0557870902,
0.0558847152,
0.0276307836,
0.0076893549,
0.0285198744,
-0.0149799753,
-0.0061068381,
0.0380228534,
-0.0292930678,
0.012722455,
-0.0266703703,
-0.0228882879,
-0.0040743803,
0.0182430129,
-0.0228941385,
-0.0470433645,
-0.0082561802,
-0.0113275722,
0.0084374342,
0.0252523497,
0.0519338027,
0.0385348573,
0.0181645174,
0.011149413,
0.0583149455,
-0.0681660995,
0.0115820095,
-0.0084454436,
0.0109924367,
0.0431242436,
0.0215046946,
-0.0613695383,
-0.0102046849,
0.0043140631,
0.0626040548,
-0.0258551501,
0.066165179,
-0.0030850491,
0.0322469026,
-0.0192782991,
-0.0411728136,
-0.00035128,
0.0427815691,
0.0189667046,
-0.0001580335,
-0.011241396,
0.003574596,
-0.0264690667,
-0.079284668,
0.0519836396,
-0.0255824979,
-0.048157502,
0.0492549799,
-0.0089901676,
0.0216274019,
0.0203549247,
-0.0339463167,
0.0021519999,
0.0305769667,
0.0133403391,
-0.0071176905,
-0.0103536844,
-0.048008427,
-0.0449219644,
0.0356239527,
-0.0228783842,
0.0151740247,
0.0167643484,
-0.028945988,
-0.0491544753,
0.0265761018,
0.0174336415,
0.0259746369,
-0.0518473648,
0.031764403,
-0.0386051498,
0.0277864169,
-0.0775589272,
0.0311169736,
0.0388933718,
0.0130318357,
-0.00272041,
0.0083448235,
0.0318319723,
-0.0229535978,
-0.0344896577,
-0.0536230356,
-0.0083595626,
0.0140439859,
0.0567300655,
0.0114643853,
-0.0545958579,
-0.0095722601,
-0.1189490929,
0.0001765788,
-0.0495877191,
0.0082028182,
0.034116745,
0.0204140041,
-0.0279062223,
-0.0420774296,
-0.0234740674,
-0.0677215457,
0.0074680112,
0.0199425556,
0.0286362953,
-0.0171486475,
0.0364598483,
-0.0563008413,
-0.0271055251,
-0.0064155268,
0.0302422438,
0.0398849361,
-0.0027121725,
-0.0336754657,
0.0212808158,
-0.046274282,
0.0182243679,
0.0155106122,
-0.0451322272,
-0.026708873,
0.0069108838,
0.0612866506,
0.0681392178,
-0.0101687694,
0.014825915,
0.0867105946,
0.0003059525,
-0.0501645431,
-0.0211099423,
-0.0483816229,
0.0159839597,
-0.0384053178,
0.0134444116,
0.0396639481,
0.0625307485,
-0.006371134,
-0.0646186024,
-0.0344548561,
0.0221621692,
-0.0363556519,
-0.0139888087,
-0.0070313923,
0.0091822334,
-0.0256562419,
0.0180646423,
-0.0069736796,
-0.0723272786,
0.049765043,
-0.027987916,
-0.0098345913,
-0.0468173921,
-0.029552009,
-0.0395980999,
0.0206105039,
-0.006867141,
-0.0137062762,
0.0471308604,
0.0026136958,
-0.0260677636,
0.0104596596,
0.0358823016,
-0.0252749287,
0.0030392357,
-0.0386664458,
0.0391496941,
0.0250020642,
-0.0215942133,
-0.0178018175,
-0.0611651056,
0.0088159284,
-0.0348011367,
0.0360127278,
0.0161073878,
-0.000820549,
0.0038134968,
0.0133801894,
0.0453003272,
-0.0037462967,
-0.0268239416,
0.0145515129,
-0.0101891775,
0.0320300199,
0.0180524774,
0.0203585196,
-0.0303270388,
-0.0104535706,
-0.0043614903,
0.0501702465,
-0.0508306548,
-0.0347933099,
0.0542712919,
0.0481154807,
-0.0573950112,
0.003501836,
0.0142656118,
0.0536306687,
-0.0422833525,
-0.0095615946,
0.1337243319,
0.0295881107,
-0.0770948231,
0.0010205543,
-0.0162287261,
0.0239126217,
0.0465338901,
0.0273513198,
-0.0334802009,
-0.0274229646,
0.0032137386,
-0.0034872768,
-0.0228966828,
-0.0331564918,
-0.0163255837,
-0.0913952142,
0.0349580646,
-0.0032135765,
-0.0060912459,
0.0428739674,
-0.0669087991,
0.0114352666,
-0.0804809332,
-0.00167865,
-0.0353269428,
-0.0447743498,
0.0275533479,
0.0432097465,
-0.0356922448,
-0.0698756576,
0.0100192605,
-0.0482522957,
0.0512255318,
0.0612451732,
-0.0040573981,
-0.0213035718,
0.0119682355,
0.0308126975,
-0.0382997543,
-0.0142449476,
-0.042137403,
0.0930827111,
-0.0227305982,
-0.0178440977,
-0.0101742949,
0.0249021724,
-0.0283267759,
0.0029548975,
-0.01763561,
0.0456163622,
-0.0168375596,
-0.0115225548,
0.0011431134,
-0.0336944796,
0.0449341573,
0.0722289607,
0.0316638313,
-0.0506792702,
0.0152899697,
0.015222067,
0.0095254099,
0.0061424007,
-0.0421247818,
0.0128777837,
-0.0128231347,
0.0111501375,
-0.0727739409,
-0.0437167063,
0.0423210785,
0.0570316948,
0.0200126767,
0.0780322775,
-0.0018406095,
-0.0340821408,
-0.0321930014,
0.0545856133,
-0.0653692558,
-0.0055038556,
-0.0516669154,
-0.047277797,
0.0529110506,
0.003635539,
-0.0056067202,
-0.0345891938,
-0.0562281646,
-0.0551075079,
0.0150193051,
0.0821992084,
0.0216854103,
0.0265339259,
-0.0136950733,
-0.0734168813,
0.0783184692,
0.0076193591,
-0.0529749542,
-0.0058444738,
0.0509362929,
-0.0536680892,
0.0062543694,
0.0325096436,
-0.0113349929,
0.0635381192,
0.0583632924,
0.0053729294,
-0.0012020138,
-0.0485664792,
0.0124901086,
0.0220956299,
0.0638182312,
-0.0043757162,
0.0179149956,
-0.0542631969,
-0.0103180725,
-0.0157733504,
-0.0199962407,
-0.0540518314,
0.0435748473,
0.0186875295,
0.0146525567,
-0.0378693007,
0.0306774713,
-0.049583476,
0.0141308215,
-0.0569999591,
0.0224401131,
-0.0347091965,
-0.0137091661,
-0.0038723149,
0.0452833362,
0.0344954357,
0.0095755048,
0.0308153015,
0.0010396115,
0.0092920028,
0.009354013,
0.0299705584,
0.0401775725,
-0.0325420611,
0.0437226072,
-0.0783222765,
0.0137744164,
-0.0373480022,
-0.0080456175,
0.0567169227,
-0.0783186406,
0.0842638463,
0.0011075792,
0.0104617681,
-0.0308684092,
0.0180121548,
-0.0054503665,
0.0145883467,
0.0062734238,
0.0001771187,
-0.0479839183,
0.0488971323,
0.0898867697,
0.0047330526,
0.0263150912,
0.0185272563,
-0.0190910045,
-0.0161831416,
-0.0078772614,
0.0551632941,
0.0185865741,
-0.0457664505,
0.0216838792,
-0.0214949045,
-0.067771025,
0.0197630581,
-0.012770243,
-0.0181303378,
0.0028971033,
0.0455543697,
0.05910483,
-0.0213876851,
0.0415837802,
-0.0396591127,
-0.0525361784,
0.0044842362,
-0.016532775,
0.0235931333,
-6.740021591e-33,
-0.0109383911,
-0.0133018866,
-0.0066331299,
0.0048683281,
0.0086749624,
0.0012333976,
-0.0081984382,
0.0130409636,
-0.0057286015,
0.0313814469,
-0.0353063159,
0.0088149067,
0.0145114772,
0.0245366581,
0.028318543,
0.0136876581,
0.0513680242,
0.0016662283,
-0.0351610258,
0.0157396235,
-0.0137491319,
0.047124017,
0.0825712979,
-0.0418898985,
0.0366817564,
0.0184311103,
0.0132672321,
0.0042993808,
-0.0068035359,
0.0531921126,
-0.0146677252,
0.0328899361,
0.0297845583,
-0.054701563,
-0.0440516472,
-0.0031799478,
-0.0530771688,
-0.0866135582,
0.002781084,
0.0023346408,
-0.0159169752,
0.0294338297,
0.0211924799,
-0.0042665978,
-0.0303056277,
0.0174593702,
0.0544428378,
-0.0077248006,
-0.0156612433,
-0.0032228702,
-0.0150214089,
0.031050466,
-0.01595206,
-0.0200952441,
0.0554602332,
-0.0054448531,
0.0052299048,
0.0111659244,
-0.0082963286,
0.000780333,
0.0109583456,
0.0274218302,
0.0202879254,
0.0089656319,
0.0268278327,
0.0541570112,
-0.0047365581,
0.0226726048,
0.015067989,
-0.0334772877,
0.0719702244,
0.0104496535,
0.029465396,
0.0235015657,
0.0329961106,
-0.0071387691,
-0.0726272091,
0.0433010384,
0.0207985211,
-0.0052264431,
0.0144598121,
0.0311708469,
0.0063105645,
-0.03793725,
-0.0501584783,
-0.0525247753,
-0.0203637537,
-0.0519824252,
0.0142225605,
0.0414660461,
-0.0540131629,
0.0344378464,
0.0278404523,
-0.053009104,
-0.0637829527,
-0.0123195108,
-0.0141272517,
-0.011994631,
0.0136732757,
-0.0074811289,
-0.0424979888,
-0.0071921451,
0.0270544551,
-0.005141146,
0.0148371719,
-0.0203998461,
0.0548446104,
0.0348618366,
-0.0658254474,
-0.0090756109,
-0.0031737429,
-0.0007790888,
0.0305267535,
0.047513593,
0.0095301792,
0.0346918739,
-0.0156402029,
0.0593407378,
0.0676890761,
-0.0213583782,
-0.0452107899,
-0.0328078605,
0.0022145531,
0.0098976474,
-0.0321797803,
-0.0258429963,
-0.0073635359,
0.0295234509,
0.0567197017,
-0.0140768373,
-0.0294686425,
-0.0513348952,
2.617e-7,
0.0611602701,
0.0706126913,
0.0132997921,
-0.0104223033,
-0.0058275624,
0.0195485782,
-0.0540312752,
0.0260558166,
0.0033580265,
0.0041786022,
0.0232291613,
0.0238965657,
0.0261101052,
-0.0152846435,
-0.0662468448,
-0.0089591239,
-0.0713141561,
0.0147462683,
-0.0232442636,
-0.0075975745,
-0.0048929718,
0.0964815617,
0.028174378,
-0.019065043,
-0.0281646773,
-0.0297644138,
0.0625072792,
-0.0681869313,
0.0003566786,
0.0548760481,
0.0784567967,
0.0351525471,
-0.0106475903,
0.0226025954,
-0.0369635224,
0.0345835052,
-0.0108574191,
0.0432210639,
0.0033717912,
0.0121089863,
0.0026988445,
0.0258174539,
0.0164761916,
-0.026851574,
0.0737153962,
-0.0853294805,
-0.0423007607,
-0.0363630764,
-0.0170941465,
-0.0408017524,
0.0648900643,
-0.0139788035,
-0.008637514,
0.0495415926,
0.0256287679,
0.031760294,
-0.0689458326,
-0.0928071886,
-0.0392078534,
0.0115939332,
0.0020279274,
0.0040932675,
-0.0096051162,
-0.080208987,
-0.0085223978,
-0.0752779171,
0.0476096347,
2.472079084e-34,
0.0484445542,
-0.0119044492,
0.0286716036,
0.0156160537,
0.0269062817,
-0.0099152382,
-0.0040516029,
0.0168730393,
-0.0027469012,
-0.0686148703,
0.000860101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00906v1 | Re-weighting Tokens: A Simple and Effective Active Learning Strategy for Named Entity Recognition | 2023-11-02T00:19:02 | 2023-11-02T00:19:02 | Haocheng Luo, Wei Tan, Ngoc Dang Nguyen, Lan Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Active learning, a widely adopted technique for enhancing machine learning
models in text and image classification tasks with limited annotation
resources, has received relatively little attention in the domain of Named
Entity Recognition (NER). The challenge of data imbalance in NER has hindered
the effectiveness of active learning, as sequence labellers lack sufficient
learning signals. To address these challenges, this paper presents a novel
reweighting-based active learning strategy that assigns dynamic smoothed
weights to individual tokens. This adaptable strategy is compatible with
various token-level acquisition functions and contributes to the development of
robust active learners. Experimental results on multiple corpora demonstrate
the substantial performance improvement achieved by incorporating our
re-weighting strategy into existing acquisition functions, validating its
practical efficacy. | [
0.0291372184,
0.0112178419,
0.0080087474,
-0.0134948585,
0.0199517123,
0.0589546151,
-0.0086697228,
0.0077231559,
0.0251272898,
-0.0514690951,
0.0020694479,
-0.0181800667,
-0.0023792661,
0.0483328402,
0.0310950819,
-0.0438012928,
0.0304577835,
-0.0073594726,
0.0801571384,
0.0132916244,
0.0027915204,
-0.0123965293,
-0.0397270471,
0.0397590958,
-0.0352888443,
0.0509380363,
0.0206956863,
0.0165823102,
0.0106702382,
-0.049373243,
0.0356674865,
0.0650318637,
-0.0213395562,
0.0447611362,
0.0000017474,
-0.0464705452,
-0.0428885296,
0.0169059653,
-0.0241643153,
-0.0098553458,
0.0363963284,
0.0039384742,
0.0095326873,
-0.0121682687,
-0.0249699168,
-0.0442297012,
0.0576557666,
0.0355421901,
0.0166140627,
0.0435855836,
-0.0070621241,
-0.0005250896,
0.0189621467,
-0.0203744601,
0.0024329391,
-0.0672068298,
0.0437284671,
-0.0299472306,
-0.0182056595,
-0.0328696743,
0.0011497854,
0.0271665249,
-0.0122441882,
-0.0166218076,
0.0397793613,
0.0202357806,
-0.0505328961,
-0.0208632424,
-0.0202753488,
0.0362258591,
-0.0278814472,
0.0216910597,
0.0152651947,
-0.0592475571,
0.0193517003,
-0.0137976091,
-0.0305423997,
-0.0245697629,
-0.0379244313,
0.0281659979,
-0.013184078,
-0.0341498591,
0.0134208519,
0.008101373,
-0.010909006,
0.0173433684,
-0.0152260922,
-0.0360920504,
0.044967711,
0.0650953278,
-0.0523451194,
-0.0228665844,
0.0681239069,
0.0488586128,
-0.0161151513,
0.0173628796,
0.0039041871,
-0.0504168347,
0.0327091739,
-0.046897836,
-0.0183382258,
0.007429949,
-0.0454016402,
0.0299170092,
-0.0495562293,
0.0071582091,
0.0388233624,
0.0216998328,
0.0016092934,
-0.0160116311,
-0.0396365784,
-0.0254401173,
-0.0397000052,
0.0887070075,
-0.0095895063,
-0.0091339936,
-0.0794837326,
0.0130493576,
-0.0054642148,
-0.0057194596,
0.0241261013,
-0.0056995284,
-0.0226893127,
0.0313860029,
-0.0040192101,
0.0099798692,
0.0158602558,
0.0182220191,
-0.0216375217,
-0.0474174581,
0.0046760743,
-0.0188309085,
0.0177782737,
-0.0445353575,
0.0172606241,
0.0591713376,
0.0128351822,
-0.1080974564,
-0.0310215969,
0.0115189813,
0.0126753142,
0.0038587686,
-0.0218489803,
0.0007567551,
-0.0024770875,
0.0035061452,
0.0167666338,
-0.046308659,
-0.0040741796,
-0.0038207204,
-0.0543195605,
0.0642890409,
-0.0246236939,
-0.0445392169,
0.029014213,
-0.019317897,
0.0003790501,
0.0726682916,
-0.0071267001,
0.0377769619,
0.0596819185,
0.0111192036,
-0.0369113274,
0.0270198602,
0.0260675177,
-0.0311341491,
0.007682682,
0.0068442137,
-0.0083362237,
-0.0462873615,
-0.021276027,
0.0343275145,
-0.0133378441,
0.0201292858,
0.0436686352,
0.0140376687,
-0.0338613242,
-0.0489398129,
0.0337325931,
-0.0215926934,
0.0290765725,
0.0075572394,
-0.029493086,
-0.0087191351,
-0.0056293611,
0.014388416,
-0.0141766956,
0.0570531785,
-0.0110753598,
-0.0272227451,
-0.0224893596,
-0.0305951219,
-0.0045646285,
0.0302495565,
0.0480693169,
0.0060055437,
-0.0398871079,
0.0552737825,
0.0568178408,
-0.010140134,
0.0153408805,
-0.0182240251,
0.0014467604,
0.0165591277,
0.0160212982,
-0.0725905374,
-0.0584938005,
-0.0168730691,
0.0194628835,
0.0181084964,
0.0071241912,
-0.0263685398,
0.0240238942,
-0.0482680462,
-0.0574517287,
0.0581245311,
0.0251175724,
0.0249625128,
-0.0032837153,
0.0364361368,
-0.0031763816,
-0.0301881488,
-0.0415735468,
0.0563162789,
0.0370631106,
-0.0502086207,
0.0558242686,
0.0109545244,
0.043029882,
0.0447632968,
-0.007345248,
-0.0143550001,
0.0240753237,
-0.0087868711,
-0.0265420638,
0.0100773834,
0.0181447081,
0.0097205667,
0.0171019174,
0.0102578383,
-0.0537472591,
-0.0225433875,
-0.0317038856,
-0.0225547757,
-0.0598391518,
-0.0187521316,
-0.0085235871,
-0.0622137561,
0.042655386,
-0.0114438524,
0.0581155457,
-0.0548711494,
0.0469618365,
-0.0249969456,
0.0065880711,
0.0304833334,
-0.0445981212,
-0.0119446423,
-0.0536331125,
-0.0262205154,
-0.0101221558,
-0.0102578383,
-0.0472803526,
0.0119425301,
-0.0008308646,
-0.0274800975,
-0.0106934067,
-0.0558784679,
-0.0292383321,
-0.0213418361,
0.0275819153,
-0.0053225108,
0.0447093025,
-0.0226868056,
-0.0318486355,
0.0202621724,
-0.00691676,
-0.0378986672,
0.0108281495,
0.0238368679,
0.0062855459,
-0.0089415321,
-0.0038065177,
-0.0013070634,
-0.0240198504,
0.0305641349,
0.0438018739,
-0.0602550246,
-0.0586006343,
-0.0524634607,
-0.0235223621,
-0.0010259374,
0.0540453084,
0.0204296056,
-0.0053310678,
0.0296092946,
-0.00904381,
0.0751895234,
0.0355106294,
0.0527530201,
-0.0408774316,
-0.0086128423,
-0.0258738287,
0.023446342,
-0.0462183058,
0.0495104231,
-0.0249133985,
-0.0429048203,
0.0461068861,
0.0522087216,
-0.0645289272,
0.0246039256,
-0.03182742,
-0.0094155176,
-0.0381244235,
-0.0440825596,
-0.0331242941,
0.0163523704,
-0.0401467383,
-0.0276699699,
0.0002992984,
-0.0426136479,
0.072755605,
-0.0322596654,
-0.0217583831,
-0.0591818392,
0.0020829586,
-0.0289698932,
-0.0143017638,
0.039361801,
0.0059687584,
0.0320517905,
-0.0739824697,
0.0221972149,
-0.0298836064,
0.0051039057,
-0.0219265483,
-0.0012645744,
-0.0066426378,
0.0115950517,
-0.011516897,
-0.0229147077,
-0.0376591943,
-0.0200736504,
-0.0084900912,
0.0453397036,
0.0304192621,
-0.0110219168,
-0.0322813541,
0.0630440712,
-0.0019086449,
0.0286976453,
0.0068065897,
0.0006428678,
-0.0177159775,
0.0405391268,
0.0536267757,
-0.0225161426,
0.0157101452,
-0.0337743424,
-0.029762432,
0.0310448948,
0.0198764876,
-0.0435841158,
0.0347799398,
0.0186142623,
0.0387302823,
-0.0893102065,
0.0376302712,
0.006921838,
0.0321621187,
-0.0014985527,
-0.0056235841,
0.1065385714,
0.0244015697,
-0.0837191418,
-0.0089743966,
-0.0020853702,
0.009932898,
0.0136036212,
0.0100379791,
-0.0195303038,
-0.0396314152,
0.0069781085,
0.0453098528,
-0.0186550729,
-0.0698006377,
0.0146095688,
-0.0639204755,
0.0185541939,
-0.0223669074,
-0.0751676708,
0.0260930024,
-0.0574294366,
0.0040952549,
-0.0437296778,
0.0556012616,
-0.0381687321,
-0.0144307679,
0.0260991771,
0.052421812,
-0.0104751913,
-0.0233676285,
-0.0526801199,
-0.0491183847,
0.0197357871,
-0.0005545131,
0.0032891077,
-0.0394143015,
0.0043538869,
0.0525508448,
-0.0366248339,
-0.0109120728,
-0.0379365683,
0.0428736471,
-0.0438711084,
-0.020971626,
-0.0112216081,
-0.0080052139,
-0.0000130041,
-0.0148870526,
0.01285329,
0.0282294061,
0.0094223544,
0.0394512936,
-0.0433546901,
-0.0510090813,
0.0375906117,
0.0109237563,
0.0188406631,
-0.0407439768,
0.0110907359,
0.0147444857,
-0.0009315172,
-0.0129096396,
-0.0114051159,
0.0276974589,
-0.0752597228,
-0.044965893,
-0.0660394579,
-0.0343836993,
0.0491974913,
0.1072771847,
0.0326453932,
0.0524581894,
0.0219795201,
-0.0046604984,
-0.0503913164,
0.0097547742,
0.0042258333,
0.0205888655,
-0.055614382,
-0.0598488599,
-0.0093612494,
0.004730599,
-0.0464820452,
0.0121108852,
-0.0335932113,
-0.0646604076,
0.0470974073,
0.0548730418,
0.0176799111,
0.0182512794,
-0.0222501103,
-0.0358312726,
0.072369583,
0.066958949,
-0.0123471525,
-0.0228789095,
0.005470945,
-0.0560048781,
-0.015363032,
-0.0009825906,
-0.0548725426,
0.0188197438,
0.0672022104,
0.0588923581,
-0.000436956,
-0.0224868171,
-0.0142441019,
0.0327608213,
0.0634509772,
-0.0363963768,
-0.0438621901,
-0.0098511465,
0.0485335439,
0.0408677831,
0.0227025505,
-0.0028343073,
0.0226411447,
-0.0224215686,
0.0462662727,
-0.0446581356,
0.0572496429,
0.0007329228,
0.0580112115,
-0.0359570943,
0.0192183945,
-0.0289673042,
0.029129779,
-0.0141073195,
-0.0442643389,
0.025826972,
0.0217862017,
0.0462292843,
0.0463933349,
-0.0042194268,
0.0159155466,
0.0171327181,
0.0681889653,
-0.0343066193,
0.0378003903,
-0.0498515256,
0.0309676304,
-0.057374686,
0.0570761673,
0.0623237714,
-0.0331413783,
0.033528924,
0.0105549656,
-0.0252439976,
0.0196972806,
-0.0339058936,
-0.0024009647,
-0.0120451767,
0.0075385212,
0.015310403,
-0.0238914806,
0.0017234607,
0.0517956354,
-0.0048593171,
0.0229820777,
-0.0204225853,
-0.0232203845,
-0.0237389691,
-0.0254478697,
0.0693078712,
-0.0112782419,
-0.0360282101,
0.0097061563,
0.0017868059,
-0.065018028,
0.0350208059,
-0.0662897453,
0.0166127756,
0.0038047573,
0.0240601413,
0.0306832343,
0.0296498351,
-0.01293936,
-0.0150899263,
0.0091465926,
0.0394654684,
0.0058226087,
0.0297143776,
-6.007393267e-33,
-0.0164252035,
-0.0267333593,
-0.0428723656,
0.0179304332,
0.0094450861,
0.0542821437,
0.0083608823,
-0.033622168,
0.0390041545,
-0.0059105633,
0.0056180274,
-0.0260636583,
0.0573795438,
0.0087911068,
0.0004565545,
0.0020033186,
0.0374470465,
0.0333677568,
-0.0238549896,
0.0026943143,
0.0280157737,
0.0612766482,
0.0497487821,
-0.0684496686,
0.0451642536,
0.0508725531,
0.0022652317,
0.0066166548,
0.0617192164,
0.0583840571,
-0.0075158225,
0.0111705596,
0.0040909075,
-0.0228760969,
-0.0087334765,
-0.0232528709,
-0.1209638938,
0.0243644714,
-0.0127690947,
0.0799995586,
0.0272545852,
0.0094689354,
0.0195032395,
-0.0032322821,
-0.006291396,
0.0376286432,
0.054963287,
-0.0042973957,
-0.0487037674,
-0.0548216812,
-0.0511113405,
0.0542611033,
-0.027283866,
0.0806482509,
0.0259290449,
-0.0373837911,
0.0305416193,
-0.0086743673,
-0.0440775678,
-0.0276212264,
-0.0018070675,
0.0020313906,
-0.0149686802,
0.0437066033,
-0.0140927723,
0.0444768146,
0.0711930916,
-0.0199370775,
-0.0210849214,
0.0431074053,
0.0116742523,
-0.0332453959,
0.0210233126,
0.0166083127,
0.0486690551,
-0.0334967561,
-0.060608428,
0.0398268327,
0.0794386193,
0.0139515549,
0.0336456262,
0.0051987576,
-0.0169646442,
0.0162281357,
0.0216054078,
-0.0081404233,
-0.0383978561,
-0.0295051485,
0.0067620045,
0.0171090104,
-0.0940178335,
0.0463307016,
0.0259628296,
-0.0052849315,
-0.0648210049,
-0.0196480639,
0.0797537342,
0.0020683352,
-0.019738989,
-0.0246309079,
-0.0321474001,
-0.0850601345,
0.041947078,
0.0075242282,
0.0219615828,
-0.0202825814,
0.0594809912,
0.0186998732,
-0.0450551584,
0.0050585279,
0.0197094213,
0.0324791186,
0.0046774289,
0.0665899515,
0.0328530818,
-0.0279564932,
-0.0135324011,
0.0006655608,
0.048616726,
-0.0326448381,
-0.0266827587,
-0.0072512357,
0.0201772824,
0.0213008095,
-0.0357005484,
-0.020336628,
0.0390511043,
0.0046927813,
-0.0080266306,
-0.0791785866,
0.0078730723,
-0.010310553,
2.488e-7,
0.0202670339,
0.0255099311,
0.0185149666,
-0.0682591945,
-0.0078430278,
0.0067531313,
-0.0143854907,
0.0310521852,
0.0353453085,
0.031341359,
0.011661673,
-0.0308583472,
-0.0093604242,
0.0302851703,
-0.1367410421,
-0.0610164776,
-0.0289444365,
0.0445116423,
-0.0433394276,
0.0709492788,
-0.0244794097,
0.0712788105,
-0.0050588879,
-0.0498516634,
-0.0043230699,
-0.0929166898,
0.0130143287,
0.0345529094,
0.0465558656,
0.0061210711,
0.023986632,
0.0055617997,
0.0120621873,
0.0497306436,
-0.045421347,
0.0263876338,
0.0519446395,
0.0294670183,
-0.0286197606,
-0.0108135063,
-0.0179929975,
0.0036701842,
0.0583995953,
-0.0094457567,
0.0679083988,
-0.0452847816,
-0.0327471085,
0.0096244263,
-0.0494352058,
-0.0328023881,
0.0135572571,
0.0159940179,
-0.0136891138,
0.0873333737,
0.0256728251,
0.0109183975,
-0.0363027677,
-0.11399699,
0.0077708452,
-0.0525592528,
0.0033226244,
-0.0221244041,
-0.0158458725,
0.023462031,
-0.0206774622,
-0.0408396088,
0.0053182687,
2.185237799e-34,
0.042055022,
-0.0005452742,
0.0066120606,
0.0777515098,
-0.0005217521,
-0.006943854,
0.0013617357,
0.0223077033,
-0.0182756484,
-0.0452492647,
-0.0038415529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00897v1 | On The Open Prompt Challenge In Conditional Audio Generation | 2023-11-01T23:33:25 | 2023-11-01T23:33:25 | Ernie Chang, Sidd Srinivasan, Mahi Luthra, Pin-Jie Lin, Varun Nagaraja, Forrest Iandola, Zechun Liu, Zhaoheng Ni, Changsheng Zhao, Yangyang Shi, Vikas Chandra | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Text-to-audio generation (TTA) produces audio from a text description,
learning from pairs of audio samples and hand-annotated text. However,
commercializing audio generation is challenging as user-input prompts are often
under-specified when compared to text descriptions used to train TTA models. In
this work, we treat TTA models as a ``blackbox'' and address the user prompt
challenge with two key insights: (1) User prompts are generally
under-specified, leading to a large alignment gap between user prompts and
training prompts. (2) There is a distribution of audio descriptions for which
TTA models are better at generating higher quality audio, which we refer to as
``audionese''. To this end, we rewrite prompts with instruction-tuned models
and propose utilizing text-audio alignment as feedback signals via margin
ranking learning for audio improvements. On both objective and subjective human
evaluations, we observed marked improvements in both text-audio alignment and
music audio quality. | [
0.0089495126,
0.011617545,
0.0244108792,
-0.0005782535,
0.0043252632,
-0.0140312146,
0.044561483,
-0.017686395,
-0.0673629791,
0.0066057583,
-0.0906383172,
-0.0362455584,
-0.004651438,
0.0147775486,
0.0069551277,
-0.076107271,
0.0005922003,
-0.0364169031,
-0.0104144095,
-0.0065923105,
-0.0240639579,
0.0228821468,
-0.0418789349,
0.0189575981,
-0.0124642961,
-0.0069711599,
-0.0054647862,
0.0380316302,
0.0450575836,
-0.000781173,
-0.030767981,
0.0473583117,
-0.0023874119,
0.0126242824,
0.0000016722,
-0.0209983457,
-0.0079702986,
0.0116876774,
-0.0089296494,
0.003682059,
-0.0071239318,
0.0373098813,
-0.0605926663,
0.0229497533,
-0.0053733978,
0.014755303,
0.0500908084,
0.0326695517,
0.0586182438,
0.0701881573,
0.0067279758,
-0.0326793864,
-0.0143724317,
-0.0452945717,
0.0281231496,
0.0105813975,
-0.0297300816,
-0.0550414063,
0.0067056888,
0.0277452841,
0.0250562597,
0.0391781516,
0.0342590138,
0.0019093108,
0.062150877,
0.0635851026,
-0.0208159015,
-0.0264522936,
-0.0141028408,
0.0913984179,
0.0373978168,
0.021052761,
-0.0052334787,
-0.0037424113,
0.0121792788,
-0.0341561995,
-0.0244187992,
0.0414479822,
-0.0059913103,
0.0121124052,
-0.0639681146,
0.0383537635,
0.0310724024,
-0.0424411744,
0.0340391658,
0.0295291152,
0.0373097397,
-0.0591381639,
0.0248450879,
-0.0045476872,
-0.0390139855,
-0.0206920914,
0.0435674824,
-0.0011156275,
-0.0473247282,
-0.0341012329,
-0.0548635125,
-0.0240070764,
-0.0268379375,
0.002931043,
0.0653811619,
0.0506492518,
-0.0481553078,
0.040128395,
-0.0141103538,
0.0167642515,
-0.0134811979,
0.0106221708,
-0.0496122874,
0.0377180614,
0.0165922139,
-0.0109107569,
-0.0188802835,
-0.0179372597,
-0.0346484073,
-0.0182741471,
-0.0431171283,
-0.006748083,
-0.0502245538,
0.0659494027,
0.0209526978,
0.0395504609,
-0.067847237,
-0.0225692596,
-0.0083877966,
-0.0177035704,
-0.0048722969,
0.0660492554,
0.0267837271,
0.0154969553,
-0.0132330544,
0.0058447681,
0.0137870098,
0.0023340641,
0.0419280007,
0.0683717132,
-0.0170484502,
0.0275001284,
0.0073770857,
-0.0333615392,
-0.0140527943,
-0.024905799,
-0.0507659018,
-0.0527503453,
0.0277643353,
-0.0164092444,
-0.0215771049,
-0.0103290519,
0.0042095948,
0.0210898966,
0.0183346197,
0.0304849055,
0.0034859388,
0.0362530276,
0.0502097793,
9.674e-7,
-0.0237001032,
-0.0063588885,
0.0809744522,
0.0482276902,
-0.0086055556,
-0.0123799853,
-0.0140830381,
0.0640835688,
0.0203859452,
0.0031973501,
-0.0279636867,
-0.006104188,
0.005446475,
0.0773714334,
0.0688209757,
0.0484646633,
0.0087819267,
-0.0240866393,
0.0748429969,
-0.0153750619,
0.0321603045,
-0.0066723996,
0.0874901712,
0.0023724763,
-0.0409715548,
0.0582614914,
0.0110891368,
0.0480260663,
0.0085068233,
0.0434627123,
0.0886409879,
0.0097988518,
-0.0142161762,
-0.0402720124,
0.0210550111,
-0.0150926886,
-0.0264461823,
-0.0105231535,
-0.0121011548,
0.0462290123,
-0.0680290461,
0.0237674061,
-0.0141852163,
-0.0642355904,
0.0219247416,
-0.0301631074,
0.0789665729,
0.0801158249,
0.0134534165,
-0.03085378,
0.0449285731,
-0.0416863486,
-0.009266207,
0.0714062899,
0.0086934697,
-0.0234311353,
0.0083375471,
-0.037403442,
-0.0298133083,
-0.0188907161,
-0.0153749147,
0.0390839614,
-0.0293306373,
0.0164536014,
0.0351558514,
-0.0053564417,
0.0060426686,
-0.0033048077,
0.003378351,
-0.0757740512,
0.0417721719,
0.0497481823,
0.0310696047,
0.0165358707,
-0.0348233208,
0.032229621,
0.0148465652,
-0.0321821235,
0.0095733097,
0.0099951569,
-0.0985542238,
-0.0026607341,
0.0056675784,
-0.0469616763,
0.0222571362,
0.0512987338,
-0.0064584622,
-0.0343449004,
0.0109222634,
0.004348509,
-0.0059771063,
-0.0037402071,
0.0175650734,
0.0322037376,
-0.0317155197,
-0.0028020479,
0.0325233229,
0.0285201855,
0.0260546003,
0.0286892019,
0.0349700265,
0.0205072463,
-0.0920928419,
0.0076869028,
0.0251045674,
0.0040486362,
-0.0096585844,
0.0048574484,
-0.0085932743,
-0.051597707,
-0.0401917435,
-0.0864675492,
0.0362232253,
-0.0086401617,
0.0142030409,
0.0148731694,
-0.0109250285,
-0.0147296544,
-0.025558129,
-0.0405062549,
-0.0572888739,
-0.0052738809,
-0.0103551326,
-0.004027294,
0.0193233881,
0.0009779561,
-0.0162158199,
-0.00137409,
0.0321809426,
-0.0190736391,
0.0026929129,
0.0089161126,
-0.0395978875,
0.0313374102,
-0.0303304233,
-0.0088912081,
0.0312501937,
0.0321375988,
0.0099008316,
0.036712829,
0.0758932084,
0.058841154,
0.0118245035,
0.0046083578,
0.0637211874,
0.0274703242,
-0.027223913,
0.019984467,
0.0067473995,
0.0047540115,
-0.0018979586,
-0.0148429489,
-0.0085669253,
0.0305330325,
0.0871758685,
0.0271835476,
-0.0587770529,
0.0113940174,
-0.0219399519,
-0.0048478935,
-0.028532194,
-0.0282476842,
-0.0406514779,
0.0495415926,
-0.0364143811,
-0.0609686561,
0.0854731649,
-0.0442360453,
-0.0258155093,
-0.0369550213,
-0.0383009277,
-0.0288914405,
-0.0231208764,
-0.0347826965,
0.0429491438,
0.0044534672,
-0.0236988831,
-0.0787947923,
0.0354790613,
0.035118781,
-0.0658883154,
-0.0043967287,
-0.0015001168,
-0.0155984368,
-0.0340534523,
-0.0413759425,
-0.0234765988,
-0.0231140628,
0.0086781699,
0.0156473294,
0.0049292501,
0.0001170949,
0.0006697861,
0.0068427483,
0.0206492264,
0.0415705405,
-0.0130164186,
-0.0009059089,
-0.0368089378,
0.0584055893,
0.0316025726,
-0.0213757288,
-0.0435520411,
-0.0711500347,
0.0248099696,
-0.0226722229,
0.0430609137,
0.0263101924,
-0.0262261983,
-0.0106711863,
0.0047283922,
-0.0017535038,
-0.0518451892,
0.0586835742,
0.0184949115,
-0.0278738029,
0.0181788467,
0.0970522985,
0.023385575,
0.0050112675,
0.0019912422,
0.0521312281,
0.0371412523,
0.0026261054,
0.0051161982,
-0.0747037157,
-0.0060206801,
0.0203828253,
0.078140147,
0.0143626314,
0.0474233106,
-0.037754558,
-0.0928556919,
0.0595837347,
0.032848753,
-0.0356832966,
-0.0242138263,
-0.0155761056,
-0.0272424296,
-0.0060078274,
0.0441529825,
0.0159819536,
-0.0284619015,
0.0364187136,
0.046892006,
0.0105504943,
-0.0478192829,
-0.0175695196,
-0.0422565229,
0.0825399011,
0.0792397857,
0.021794172,
-0.0034759527,
-0.0689067245,
-0.0491984598,
-0.0026777429,
0.0235504434,
0.0290203262,
0.0273379851,
0.0145014273,
-0.0035529132,
0.0296364073,
0.0572271533,
0.0171930473,
0.0104608433,
0.0144372219,
0.0123509336,
0.0102423867,
0.0185708925,
-0.0208926126,
0.0708467066,
0.0238133334,
0.05434848,
0.0146411369,
-0.0553206168,
0.0051488546,
-0.0054282299,
0.0226697158,
-0.1089396626,
0.0198360812,
0.0156362355,
-0.006959693,
-0.0587620735,
-0.0495283306,
-0.0080396123,
-0.0316906311,
0.0276630409,
0.0344135836,
-0.0137476474,
-0.0610004589,
-0.0208360199,
-0.0438923351,
0.0434093587,
0.0190677419,
0.0572600216,
-0.0636420175,
-0.0486554429,
0.0096019385,
-0.0734721869,
-0.0241892412,
-0.0098700747,
-0.0559672676,
-0.0444002189,
-0.0480997376,
0.0077244379,
0.0128074251,
0.0509937815,
0.0230110306,
-0.009178889,
0.0096574808,
0.0431882106,
-0.0107431309,
0.0576877184,
0.0506025404,
0.0241745804,
-0.0042122677,
0.0053358739,
-0.0854532793,
0.0380922891,
0.0067885858,
0.0190077089,
0.0283246692,
-0.0548761301,
0.0263320245,
-0.0100833103,
0.0104358792,
-0.0298058428,
0.0303782914,
-0.0721168369,
0.0254501719,
-0.0125801815,
-0.0057124477,
-0.0359333381,
-0.0135181611,
0.0480247922,
0.0159822181,
-0.0185437761,
0.0083699701,
-0.013869375,
0.0275481809,
-0.0788477212,
0.001163703,
0.0118397763,
-0.0282989256,
0.0171895307,
-0.0065183984,
0.0083364248,
0.0076861666,
0.0251421593,
0.036446739,
0.0467412248,
0.0457880311,
0.0248753894,
0.0175910275,
-0.004570886,
0.0453460552,
-0.0364118703,
-0.0057556066,
-0.0479335301,
0.0019204119,
0.025912419,
-0.0038991792,
0.0163299851,
0.0240823627,
0.0058468645,
0.0041565727,
0.0083376328,
-0.0068993433,
-0.0397112295,
0.0145335458,
-0.0045816256,
0.0177609865,
0.01333558,
0.0370400026,
-0.0425270461,
0.0076650213,
-0.0602107272,
0.0284959413,
-0.0128644183,
0.0020021386,
-0.0086233793,
-0.0008322104,
0.013149308,
-0.0202005431,
-0.0046367915,
-0.0332992189,
0.0213265512,
0.0246984251,
-0.0054011196,
-0.0154440803,
0.057793051,
0.0179605298,
-0.0491337478,
0.0053024287,
0.0018565747,
-0.0535795353,
-0.032485161,
-0.0424505882,
-0.0419240557,
-5.050587518e-33,
-0.0666417852,
-0.0055365176,
-0.0039795442,
0.0019665866,
-0.0314415917,
-0.0425442792,
-0.0217292253,
-0.0197617747,
0.0262330323,
-0.0049388283,
0.0056120981,
-0.0051373788,
0.0217017457,
0.0343366638,
-0.0113657713,
-0.0081922151,
0.094734408,
-0.0230711289,
-0.0652702376,
0.0381615236,
0.0373434164,
0.0134471813,
-0.033403337,
-0.062199872,
-0.0105710598,
-0.0227565393,
-0.0494875014,
-0.0173282363,
-0.0112616541,
0.0317511633,
0.0105680022,
0.0191418026,
-0.0264875554,
-0.060072504,
0.0132422121,
0.0563583337,
-0.0234325062,
-0.0041694972,
-0.0181390587,
0.002077467,
-0.0334507674,
-0.0472605005,
0.0347063318,
-0.0071846773,
-0.0479172617,
-0.0164522789,
0.048311457,
-0.027234545,
-0.0058943885,
-0.0644430295,
-0.0333482698,
-0.0165578648,
-0.0544974245,
-0.0688097179,
0.0332310647,
0.0882199928,
-0.0056322543,
-0.006972916,
-0.020165991,
0.0692182109,
0.0222034696,
0.0210597031,
0.0653404519,
0.0189607367,
-0.0510404631,
0.0292961765,
0.0173763242,
-0.0872444883,
0.0125426818,
-0.0034364942,
-0.0469305888,
0.0373864472,
0.0119767571,
0.0009126,
0.0197815057,
-0.0154088726,
-0.0061267866,
0.0552891083,
-0.0439507663,
-0.0546249263,
0.0086842636,
0.0388438739,
-0.0474712886,
-0.0022232495,
-0.0568649992,
-0.0328418463,
-0.0420771353,
-0.0529125929,
0.045411732,
-0.0110286409,
-0.0036405777,
-0.0371509604,
-0.0036354426,
0.0013180787,
0.0432410203,
-0.0371844359,
-0.0711281896,
0.0211370848,
-0.0221998245,
-0.0257538278,
-0.0373695977,
-0.0111699756,
0.1225453466,
0.0225380547,
0.0045572477,
0.0035097364,
0.004969052,
0.05985149,
-0.0522848703,
0.0257171374,
-0.0045880969,
0.0318075642,
0.012226698,
0.0262389388,
0.0078852503,
-0.0049052769,
-0.0298908222,
0.0548200905,
-0.0384830534,
0.0226317458,
-0.0264565069,
-0.0517333895,
-0.0246286225,
-0.011598194,
-0.0368273072,
0.0470482558,
0.0456604995,
0.0088079963,
0.0051497216,
-0.017173918,
-0.0441185161,
0.014447649,
2.538e-7,
-0.0201671347,
-0.0228289105,
-0.0180326328,
-0.0032166347,
0.0255859941,
0.0281836353,
-0.0418474972,
0.039767947,
0.0108635379,
0.0068202228,
0.0321963541,
-0.040145684,
0.0787654072,
0.0185713582,
-0.0759956986,
0.014939826,
-0.1184946746,
0.028016245,
-0.0441637598,
-0.0171290785,
0.0726240352,
0.0629840866,
-0.0095627708,
-0.0322008058,
0.0365070775,
0.0075916196,
0.0444495082,
-0.0077482713,
0.0139250932,
-0.0655560568,
0.0408971459,
-0.03294627,
-0.031308651,
-0.0107958661,
-0.0322918259,
0.0093497355,
0.0523369946,
0.0513749197,
0.0330076255,
-0.0535561405,
-0.0258819852,
0.0644494072,
0.0004057755,
-0.0127024334,
0.0517180562,
-0.0084005799,
0.0006045259,
-0.0187547579,
-0.0633045658,
0.0055129873,
-0.0190679803,
-0.0431307554,
0.0031118754,
-0.0450869687,
0.0276825093,
0.0364550948,
-0.012628274,
-0.0157022085,
-0.0093158493,
0.0176009759,
-0.0367335901,
-0.0464087464,
-0.0246799942,
0.0039080065,
-0.0224822927,
-0.0607904866,
-0.0139676323,
1.729931759e-34,
0.0302050617,
-0.0546313412,
0.0223960821,
-0.042399887,
-0.004875334,
0.0306714848,
0.026719138,
-0.0091129122,
0.0153186107,
-0.02366185,
-0.0432840288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00895v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00895v1 | In-Context Prompt Editing For Conditional Audio Generation | 2023-11-01T23:31:51 | 2023-11-01T23:31:51 | Ernie Chang, Pin-Jie Lin, Yang Li, Sidd Srinivasan, Gael Le Lan, David Kant, Yangyang Shi, Forrest Iandola, Vikas Chandra | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Distributional shift is a central challenge in the deployment of machine
learning models as they can be ill-equipped for real-world data. This is
particularly evident in text-to-audio generation where the encoded
representations are easily undermined by unseen prompts, which leads to the
degradation of generated audio -- the limited set of the text-audio pairs
remains inadequate for conditional audio generation in the wild as user prompts
are under-specified. In particular, we observe a consistent audio quality
degradation in generated audio samples with user prompts, as opposed to
training set prompts. To this end, we present a retrieval-based in-context
prompt editing framework that leverages the training captions as demonstrative
exemplars to revisit the user prompts. We show that the framework enhanced the
audio quality across the set of collected user prompts, which were edited with
reference to the training captions as exemplars. | [
-0.0006093131,
0.0398692824,
-0.0078454884,
-0.0201914106,
-0.0019051564,
-0.037020795,
0.0305297375,
-0.0218945034,
-0.0847209468,
-0.0046235109,
-0.0460717045,
-0.0079764733,
-0.0104269944,
0.0383234434,
0.0034115552,
-0.0944488049,
0.0145240873,
-0.0288607273,
-0.0112122586,
0.0105634099,
-0.0188419186,
-0.0124173937,
-0.0294815395,
0.0343741328,
-0.0460495725,
-0.0218577385,
-0.0195314158,
0.0686501712,
-0.0033266761,
-0.0009147762,
-0.0267150626,
0.0764085501,
0.0144447172,
0.0084794797,
0.0000017413,
-0.0098739006,
-0.0331027061,
0.0052836644,
-0.0046172449,
-0.0080118012,
0.0225134082,
0.0249636006,
-0.0857218802,
0.0212795194,
-0.0097065102,
0.0059198337,
0.0697183907,
0.0132114971,
0.0663346276,
0.0568448678,
-0.0133809671,
-0.0064907018,
-0.0326224342,
-0.0325144418,
0.0121306293,
0.025234472,
-0.0152578931,
-0.0456770174,
0.0062723672,
0.0289393943,
0.0071375747,
0.0589748286,
0.0418108068,
-0.0049016173,
0.0248752329,
0.023561392,
-0.0443305001,
-0.0257516131,
-0.0361135714,
0.0661954209,
0.0370253064,
-0.0027806372,
-0.0152494293,
0.0021338889,
0.0378568098,
-0.0063538579,
-0.0216087643,
0.0081895106,
-0.010615713,
0.0044355281,
-0.1118616462,
0.0077246008,
0.0285539646,
-0.0470261164,
0.0062542548,
0.004132241,
0.0402900428,
-0.0272736903,
-0.0179785136,
-0.0214434918,
-0.0444483422,
-0.0130297272,
0.0447252542,
-0.0142867249,
-0.0618622862,
-0.0262117963,
-0.0638283119,
-0.026703408,
-0.0237102415,
0.0272177663,
0.0490011089,
0.0449383259,
-0.068686828,
0.0319609568,
0.0070060594,
0.0177822914,
0.0027391,
-0.0042704754,
-0.0097296163,
0.001709855,
-0.019570034,
-0.0170411672,
-0.0524325557,
-0.0065664146,
-0.0748150572,
-0.0138848843,
-0.0203578323,
0.0011614063,
-0.0646214411,
0.041862417,
-0.0083439248,
0.0508023389,
-0.0613776445,
0.0182163697,
-0.0072425697,
-0.0142140221,
-0.0005375678,
0.0584014058,
0.0415463448,
-0.0267794561,
-0.0154322414,
-0.006489113,
0.027754616,
-0.0029264728,
0.0222414266,
0.0690826476,
-0.0166787785,
0.0001584022,
-0.0077005452,
-0.0516901277,
-0.0303840227,
0.0051441859,
-0.0408449881,
-0.0588324256,
0.0250152405,
-0.0204731002,
-0.0362548195,
-0.054247193,
-0.0131263984,
0.0512807555,
0.0350497477,
0.0666496456,
0.0084030954,
0.0556526519,
0.0562153235,
0.0028359757,
-0.0491979308,
0.0268119276,
0.058688134,
0.008110364,
0.0360945016,
-0.0144020533,
0.0213035531,
0.063872613,
0.0315428339,
-0.0005372482,
-0.0416755229,
-0.0242012218,
0.0017979508,
0.0299226511,
0.0561105348,
0.0472972281,
-0.0123002827,
-0.0228243116,
0.0918565094,
0.0271508656,
0.0314854607,
-0.0217998549,
0.0608922206,
-0.0104819387,
-0.0466264449,
0.0483753271,
-0.0051196036,
0.0330214947,
0.0251370333,
0.0259908065,
0.0392760411,
0.0124787735,
-0.0017180406,
-0.0285687428,
0.0386368893,
-0.0110313892,
-0.0267482046,
-0.006104745,
-0.0065619545,
0.0521721728,
-0.048542928,
0.0435722433,
-0.0233883187,
-0.080069609,
-0.0015739959,
-0.0337817259,
0.0208025649,
0.071658358,
0.035759598,
-0.0225292705,
0.0626638457,
-0.0266490523,
0.0107349642,
0.045579534,
0.0176040586,
-0.0329850614,
0.0134800915,
-0.02030381,
-0.0299714059,
-0.0017056417,
-0.0127479825,
0.0360504352,
-0.0106561892,
0.0171406437,
0.0248230621,
-0.0005541358,
0.0121921115,
-0.0154521028,
0.0209114552,
-0.0474937111,
0.0331518538,
0.0392543785,
0.0405102037,
0.022160437,
-0.0470595993,
0.0154937729,
0.0061562983,
-0.0015820548,
0.0106048929,
0.0225454494,
-0.0948331654,
-0.0152930813,
0.0051912777,
-0.0411173664,
0.0201267265,
0.0198256522,
-0.0040497337,
-0.0375129394,
-0.0029846993,
-0.0126593774,
0.027140446,
-0.0408457778,
0.0228870902,
0.0157901458,
-0.0054805949,
-0.0018691623,
0.0122249117,
0.020171117,
-0.0303263646,
0.0520879067,
0.0595062561,
-0.0069860611,
-0.07815025,
-0.0001256312,
0.0276516788,
-0.0089528188,
-0.0014129854,
0.0082450509,
-0.0219141506,
-0.052050624,
-0.0148935476,
-0.0586870834,
0.0070147817,
-0.0271655638,
-0.0245100185,
-0.0059021269,
0.0187639035,
-0.0198969562,
-0.0392032452,
0.0045116539,
-0.0600871444,
0.0119304489,
0.0121167032,
-0.0369890518,
0.0053472249,
-0.0010007194,
-0.0164250117,
0.0155288689,
0.0388221554,
0.0014898516,
-0.0356286876,
-0.0115253488,
-0.0189017486,
0.0178257637,
-0.0070440015,
0.0187355764,
0.0267695189,
0.0281133447,
0.0041221646,
0.0354549699,
0.0756642669,
0.0235441402,
0.0012329781,
0.0213648379,
0.0301232245,
0.0005864449,
-0.038910836,
0.0236237105,
0.0114848167,
-0.036783915,
0.0107347462,
0.025014542,
0.0175351612,
0.0064762007,
0.0730903596,
0.0358666442,
-0.0361252464,
0.0269500185,
-0.0151111064,
-0.0329943337,
-0.0395115279,
-0.0362116061,
-0.0459803119,
0.0640383884,
-0.0267111827,
-0.0724460408,
0.063663274,
-0.0462906994,
-0.0293685906,
-0.025601238,
-0.0368800908,
0.0100922259,
0.0117476117,
-0.0303342324,
0.0147757437,
0.027716035,
-0.023602711,
-0.0625899583,
0.010262534,
0.0311636422,
-0.075945802,
0.0196624696,
-0.0277391709,
-0.0221139044,
-0.0159302335,
-0.0377119519,
-0.0345930047,
-0.0324041545,
0.0267192069,
0.0147843352,
-0.017262971,
-0.0169196725,
-0.0001474215,
0.0208800919,
0.0203956161,
0.0456037037,
-0.0072614942,
-0.0127732093,
-0.0340677947,
0.0388529189,
0.0347965844,
0.0327340253,
-0.0524426997,
-0.0303563047,
0.0320140161,
-0.0091949999,
0.0570360012,
-0.0241203532,
-0.0405678935,
0.0114834774,
0.0109320022,
0.0160759948,
-0.017346425,
0.0638426095,
0.0552894361,
-0.0517898612,
0.0074942694,
0.0724990889,
0.0369575694,
-0.0265075713,
0.0043627745,
0.0182896368,
0.0550926961,
0.0324572213,
-0.010927842,
-0.0741223395,
-0.0284609478,
0.0574672557,
0.0763654783,
0.0028743683,
0.0257808976,
-0.0204027127,
-0.1062582657,
0.0844195485,
0.0088197617,
-0.0567179061,
-0.0473697409,
-0.0223680194,
-0.0025681576,
0.02140541,
0.0432565734,
0.0260797162,
-0.0075200703,
0.0386742353,
0.0289285686,
0.0257330835,
-0.0605838746,
-0.0298664812,
-0.0414836928,
0.0642407313,
0.1184911951,
0.0223348737,
-0.0006553746,
-0.0376714915,
-0.053102307,
-0.0218152851,
0.0363428108,
0.0205204841,
0.055384431,
0.019676473,
-0.0074575581,
0.0208532643,
0.054991778,
0.0135165602,
-0.0239464212,
0.0362911187,
0.034741465,
-0.0162229203,
0.0201628525,
-0.0451490954,
0.0269577391,
0.0508727543,
0.0553407408,
0.0545455851,
-0.0297654029,
0.0104866484,
-0.0183681883,
0.019663278,
-0.0835812539,
0.024530299,
0.0067210505,
0.0026341646,
-0.0512235165,
-0.0551170595,
-0.0149557265,
-0.0073705409,
0.0384967551,
0.0226338487,
-0.0025804639,
-0.0406348109,
0.008743125,
-0.0737764835,
0.0415143967,
0.0054080319,
0.0418653861,
-0.0517093353,
-0.0518074483,
0.0410931073,
-0.052960664,
-0.0144982645,
0.0222405065,
-0.0086234696,
-0.0363471843,
-0.0310834572,
0.0074319616,
0.0217542667,
0.0661864132,
0.009467449,
-0.007315808,
0.0569759235,
0.0605663285,
-0.0267231874,
0.0615324005,
0.0531850271,
0.0097431671,
-0.0129893627,
0.0157031491,
-0.0763944685,
0.0369996764,
-0.0126894517,
0.0233990233,
0.0292916596,
-0.0613089576,
0.017774241,
-0.0279953312,
0.0424652323,
-0.0248044971,
0.0033328373,
-0.0406733528,
0.0269416515,
-0.0010962054,
0.0116485208,
-0.0422913767,
0.0179981794,
-0.0048393779,
0.0144953327,
-0.0199129824,
0.0078458916,
-0.0166729968,
0.0378880315,
-0.040124312,
0.0293824505,
0.0369000174,
-0.0466228388,
0.0429710113,
0.0098714493,
0.0388264544,
0.0181169733,
0.0151809948,
0.028952904,
0.021298239,
0.0607637949,
0.0181831736,
-0.0044640987,
0.0007775648,
0.043702621,
-0.041016005,
0.0125028593,
-0.0238429997,
0.0397781283,
0.0191429462,
-0.0269516725,
0.0085305562,
0.0029122354,
-0.0003893375,
-0.0255061015,
0.0177584216,
0.0222916044,
-0.0359107666,
0.0103159482,
-0.0223160423,
0.0020797411,
0.0125081027,
0.0279013291,
-0.0785108581,
0.0328787379,
-0.0882346109,
-0.0023961614,
-0.0239996295,
-0.0208314862,
-0.0331521221,
-0.006117268,
-0.0098130237,
-0.016785536,
-0.0085280547,
-0.0646938831,
0.0052496274,
0.0082640322,
0.0004881487,
-0.0168409906,
0.0475612208,
0.043727126,
-0.0317899771,
0.0219945759,
0.0268171504,
-0.0426229089,
-0.0349876769,
-0.0344132967,
-0.0208892934,
-4.868571034e-33,
-0.0634220317,
-0.0108143445,
0.0120209884,
-0.0112368464,
0.0242493395,
-0.024374662,
-0.0541781709,
-0.0110516092,
0.0146685205,
-0.0221708193,
-0.018882202,
-0.0087107169,
0.0222274866,
0.0454743579,
-0.0115039963,
0.0098314257,
0.0967317224,
-0.0351496972,
-0.0556430072,
0.037789382,
0.0386733115,
0.0244332235,
-0.0336722173,
-0.0516510531,
-0.0312062297,
0.0111892549,
-0.0271388367,
-0.0109935999,
-0.0056108069,
0.0457714461,
0.0325653069,
0.0361892283,
-0.0289141648,
-0.0466943793,
-0.008597469,
0.0529806577,
-0.046535112,
-0.0111886775,
-0.0308072623,
0.0189952087,
-0.0177559275,
-0.0418693274,
0.0389519408,
-0.005482676,
-0.04654219,
0.0131107448,
0.0574219823,
-0.0197452977,
-0.0091371182,
-0.0547683947,
-0.0295984149,
0.0058918991,
-0.0314118862,
-0.0595329888,
0.0256868433,
0.0790298283,
0.0133448532,
-0.0173890218,
-0.0357763618,
0.0583335385,
0.0250422247,
0.0076639848,
0.0503502451,
0.04197165,
-0.0200295094,
0.037168242,
0.0357964747,
-0.069579564,
0.0024203914,
-0.0063823527,
-0.0128587093,
0.04175945,
0.0126258833,
0.0470062643,
0.0391894169,
-0.0326302089,
0.0133904321,
0.0414086208,
-0.0579326786,
-0.042246744,
0.0079664607,
0.0677149296,
-0.0204482749,
0.0099797258,
-0.0730888844,
-0.0176114496,
-0.0322665758,
-0.0577159747,
0.0691364482,
-0.0114387674,
0.0134243453,
-0.0266646557,
0.0385788493,
0.0018563232,
0.0305598956,
-0.0002357781,
-0.0613597743,
0.0260141492,
-0.0138443876,
-0.0261234846,
0.0221231226,
0.0176749863,
0.1363898963,
0.0316179208,
0.0084467754,
0.0003251666,
0.0152818561,
0.0704638138,
-0.0526762679,
0.0095474804,
0.0035124966,
0.0478461459,
-0.0059187668,
0.0209564026,
0.0091631133,
0.0076734303,
-0.0474705957,
0.0167617388,
-0.043072693,
0.008003219,
-0.0450065508,
-0.027111236,
-0.0316114947,
-0.0104805771,
-0.0474589802,
0.0263150185,
0.0165313911,
0.0106849475,
0.0341940224,
-0.0414873138,
-0.0315229185,
-0.0057946467,
2.594e-7,
-0.0234756898,
-0.0135388616,
0.009390342,
-0.0091112051,
0.0390605778,
0.0300675016,
-0.0469694175,
-0.0034892936,
0.0195754208,
-0.025439674,
0.038291119,
-0.010277532,
0.0750157759,
0.0170482043,
-0.0956416056,
0.0097941719,
-0.0865405947,
0.0400616974,
-0.0364574455,
0.0014825833,
0.0670679212,
0.0646537915,
-0.0010138785,
-0.051934965,
0.0547757968,
-0.0281329378,
0.0198339205,
-0.0236465055,
0.0346103832,
-0.0739238337,
0.0118450364,
-0.0125439512,
-0.0088932328,
0.0256281868,
-0.062783666,
-0.004318113,
0.0479975455,
0.0325254425,
-0.0012402944,
-0.0740936399,
-0.0485162362,
0.0629180223,
-0.004187651,
0.0114079956,
0.0589974895,
-0.0177392717,
0.0053742426,
-0.0318189561,
-0.0741128474,
-0.0056605544,
-0.0399373546,
-0.0327904038,
-0.0077996864,
-0.0366231799,
0.0131738307,
0.0687121749,
-0.0263248123,
-0.0292041097,
-0.007021856,
0.0094705448,
-0.0287308972,
-0.0525428131,
-0.0663493499,
-0.0094871847,
0.006676408,
-0.049878139,
-0.005520816,
2.064825852e-34,
0.0167062301,
-0.0190219749,
0.0266352929,
-0.0325363725,
0.0185525771,
0.016475454,
0.0364604555,
0.0037247164,
-0.0032911228,
-0.03245968,
-0.0495989919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00871v1 | Pretraining Data Mixtures Enable Narrow Model Selection Capabilities in Transformer Models | 2023-11-01T21:41:08 | 2023-11-01T21:41:08 | Steve Yadlowsky, Lyric Doshi, Nilesh Tripuraneni | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Transformer models, notably large language models (LLMs), have the remarkable
ability to perform in-context learning (ICL) -- to perform new tasks when
prompted with unseen input-output examples without any explicit model training.
In this work, we study how effectively transformers can bridge between their
pretraining data mixture, comprised of multiple distinct task families, to
identify and learn new tasks in-context which are both inside and outside the
pretraining distribution. Building on previous work, we investigate this
question in a controlled setting, where we study transformer models trained on
sequences of $(x, f(x))$ pairs rather than natural language. Our empirical
results show transformers demonstrate near-optimal unsupervised model selection
capabilities, in their ability to first in-context identify different task
families and in-context learn within them when the task families are
well-represented in their pretraining data. However when presented with tasks
or functions which are out-of-domain of their pretraining data, we demonstrate
various failure modes of transformers and degradation of their generalization
for even simple extrapolation tasks. Together our results highlight that the
impressive ICL abilities of high-capacity sequence models may be more closely
tied to the coverage of their pretraining data mixtures than inductive biases
that create fundamental generalization capabilities. | [
-0.0207692161,
0.0696592927,
-0.0069623389,
0.0114120087,
-0.0118989004,
0.0476158783,
0.0025726717,
-0.0200316943,
-0.0455563962,
-0.018838916,
-0.0609966293,
-0.0336816162,
0.0107770357,
-0.0147174662,
0.0394688509,
-0.0391271561,
0.0182460956,
-0.032374043,
-0.0465478525,
-0.0022998364,
-0.046604421,
-0.0175590347,
0.003291582,
0.0530267805,
0.0071999514,
-0.0108740591,
-0.009437602,
-0.0496720448,
-0.005926718,
-0.0057616504,
0.0257748608,
0.0517026931,
0.0523767918,
0.0263478123,
0.0000018465,
-0.0300498269,
-0.0286214743,
-0.0349811837,
-0.0456129983,
-0.0376172066,
-0.0084771086,
-0.003764773,
0.0107167363,
0.0168223605,
-0.0433468111,
-0.0250099879,
0.0557298437,
0.0507566258,
0.0227920469,
0.0771007687,
-0.0025394948,
-0.0240210854,
0.0011416309,
-0.0436765887,
0.0214589164,
-0.0212904923,
0.0135869039,
-0.0177398156,
-0.0083855884,
-0.0183700994,
-0.0295924973,
0.0214104131,
0.0371855162,
0.030106185,
-0.0258102827,
0.0513653494,
-0.0241813138,
-0.043266654,
-0.0040951734,
0.0481310189,
-0.078643322,
-0.0256876536,
-0.0145092253,
-0.0150099611,
-0.0045251404,
0.0231722966,
-0.0495125949,
0.0222217161,
0.0011510516,
0.0337022245,
0.0106344279,
0.0287819486,
0.0577251315,
-0.0204398427,
-0.0822598487,
0.0494398996,
0.0030584685,
-0.0206598602,
0.0242235921,
0.017264761,
-0.05850536,
-0.0540194884,
-0.0172502361,
0.0265634209,
-0.0602942817,
0.0339587405,
-0.0508746319,
-0.0323235914,
-0.0075379764,
0.0095373141,
0.0580523685,
0.0500393063,
-0.0243059155,
0.0122109149,
-0.0142864808,
0.0458020084,
-0.0343684666,
0.0298797451,
-0.0207478665,
0.0068342169,
-0.0561051108,
-0.013076378,
-0.0296690464,
0.0227610059,
-0.0331834517,
-0.0135282977,
-0.0241492558,
0.0564533882,
-0.0022013921,
0.0024289326,
0.031403143,
-0.0082551436,
-0.0814911276,
0.0214165784,
-0.0111498293,
0.0219338518,
0.0133061828,
0.0338877253,
0.0265804715,
-0.0560977459,
-0.0235247687,
-0.0141913537,
0.0224493816,
-0.056413237,
0.0159580149,
0.0722711906,
-0.0162484813,
-0.066111967,
-0.0232215114,
0.0088712396,
-0.012017535,
-0.0690900832,
0.0373488851,
-0.0357850567,
-0.0016880861,
0.041674491,
0.0241356343,
0.0082221245,
0.0112408036,
0.0097020762,
0.0141892163,
0.0842556581,
0.0449311733,
-0.0055765421,
-0.0000520623,
0.0036183374,
-0.0174523406,
0.0673622638,
-0.0182592757,
-0.0136574078,
-0.0007312655,
-0.0109950006,
0.0382692963,
0.0546293929,
-0.0043947781,
-0.0004597932,
0.0141590377,
0.0071650599,
0.035772711,
0.0045221862,
0.0224641301,
0.0022004587,
-0.0349278487,
0.0077848146,
0.063176848,
0.0373050682,
0.0433476493,
0.0380090624,
0.0664544106,
0.0046049282,
0.0015572974,
0.0505605489,
-0.0726023465,
0.0098668523,
0.0072875801,
0.0131317656,
-0.0299734976,
0.0287551358,
-0.0458201095,
-0.0377393365,
0.0066575971,
-0.026932301,
-0.0127306385,
-0.0043759611,
0.0618858561,
0.0658726841,
-0.0674114078,
0.0641958266,
0.0156590473,
-0.0469153821,
-0.0160978865,
-0.0401512012,
0.0032514981,
0.0012504184,
0.023527639,
-0.0580788143,
-0.0377213247,
-0.0239626579,
0.0089769382,
-0.0018165192,
-0.0153098507,
-0.0095147723,
0.0208134856,
-0.0371576287,
-0.0580106899,
-0.0100339158,
0.0214659944,
-0.0042059491,
0.0022346163,
-0.0296548698,
0.0243561342,
-0.0521382652,
-0.024148576,
0.0396191441,
-0.0723782405,
-0.0394288749,
-0.0018513745,
0.0154801905,
0.0294874478,
-0.0292691849,
-0.0178712551,
0.0181984063,
0.0397688709,
-0.0249028504,
-0.0339497104,
0.0331866369,
-0.1259099543,
-0.0462219156,
0.0097686835,
-0.0293021835,
-0.0156865921,
0.0219930708,
-0.0303159915,
-0.0352208167,
-0.0086808763,
-0.0513195582,
0.05480453,
-0.0206019003,
0.0403051339,
-0.0048178919,
0.0148451785,
-0.0208820887,
0.0646741986,
-0.0098547451,
0.0026655165,
0.0115847569,
0.0109724877,
-0.0230031107,
-0.0105599035,
-0.0279849358,
0.0173868835,
-0.0392213278,
0.0141126458,
0.0146708796,
-0.0189559031,
-0.0195804834,
-0.0253046975,
-0.0811624229,
-0.0024546843,
-0.0535940714,
0.0082144607,
-0.0069355471,
0.0206233226,
0.0064987252,
-0.0081542004,
-0.0201743301,
-0.020043917,
0.0228889436,
0.0257369783,
0.0139576253,
0.0090030795,
-0.0130628552,
-0.0101294555,
-0.0082141701,
-0.0027478344,
0.085038498,
-0.0164304655,
-0.0084273834,
-0.0368126482,
0.0339877754,
0.0252101328,
0.020778507,
-0.0505444743,
0.0024545335,
0.0250082426,
-0.0046327543,
0.0466798805,
0.0354937278,
-0.0067458418,
0.014158248,
0.0272322055,
0.017982455,
-0.0260783192,
0.0005971097,
-0.051713679,
-0.0480362996,
-0.087167114,
0.040367648,
0.0289578512,
0.1167421266,
-0.0407330357,
-0.0098008197,
-0.0496516228,
0.0091396701,
-0.0030123182,
-0.0145828081,
-0.0066301953,
-0.0057293656,
-0.0270304941,
0.0460361764,
-0.0056636394,
-0.0434015207,
0.0491540767,
0.0016132778,
-0.0269534886,
-0.0570431575,
-0.0144286025,
-0.0317611359,
0.0506598242,
0.0368974358,
-0.0260768346,
0.0405041613,
-0.0283853561,
-0.0748697892,
0.0236783754,
0.0064520426,
-0.0045660278,
0.1009725034,
-0.0188773684,
-0.0017913587,
-0.0051326989,
-0.0447762609,
-0.0647893995,
-0.0091343466,
-0.0014468539,
0.026390506,
0.0268631168,
-0.0159839932,
-0.0556737073,
-0.0181103013,
0.0202997569,
0.0909833461,
0.0005847769,
-0.0170669239,
-0.0350016616,
0.0121409418,
0.0126256961,
0.0193529557,
0.0215500705,
-0.0622063503,
0.0154412705,
0.0047849785,
0.0523950756,
-0.0281664934,
-0.0474276543,
0.0238979943,
0.0294884648,
-0.0376081318,
-0.0294735134,
0.0397419333,
0.0521948226,
-0.0463993549,
-0.036009483,
0.0820028633,
-0.0119695384,
-0.0601671562,
0.024491882,
0.0120518235,
-0.0054821479,
0.063805297,
0.0202619508,
-0.0700774416,
-0.0168505963,
0.0218676236,
-0.0035884292,
-0.0127158761,
-0.02074329,
0.0037523124,
-0.1121200323,
0.0211454593,
-0.0122621432,
-0.0333411694,
0.004255583,
-0.033458326,
0.0080366516,
-0.0399866886,
0.0270665642,
-0.0171752032,
-0.0443957634,
-0.0194640644,
0.0510129742,
0.0099278968,
-0.082852073,
0.0021989907,
-0.0288005359,
-0.0193876103,
0.0581707358,
-0.0114000998,
0.0030642904,
-0.0200116336,
0.0234153811,
-0.0183596686,
0.019269947,
0.0169025287,
0.0457118899,
0.017382713,
-0.0235710628,
0.0291734356,
0.0438219756,
-0.0345535092,
-0.0276822764,
-0.0044091549,
0.0866878405,
-0.0331733525,
-0.0229763221,
0.026604414,
-0.0351935737,
0.0478384346,
0.0504286624,
0.0303655937,
-0.0522317402,
-0.017086735,
-0.0124110179,
0.009831612,
-0.011094138,
-0.0226869304,
0.026686199,
0.0156038813,
-0.0534127317,
-0.0474806391,
0.0041448362,
0.0399117917,
0.0560745709,
0.0218991786,
-0.0292848833,
0.0261364616,
0.0022010272,
-0.0418585539,
0.0348920152,
-0.001672686,
0.008788012,
-0.0613432266,
-0.0025280779,
0.024157377,
-0.0226528887,
-0.0395160541,
-0.0004174514,
-0.1020661592,
-0.0449079536,
0.0330659971,
0.0594752654,
0.0240852386,
0.0685377866,
0.0201093033,
-0.0246909466,
0.0910700187,
0.0407617688,
-0.033014968,
0.0011535517,
0.074166134,
-0.0353863649,
-0.0036931392,
0.0236324538,
-0.0201803017,
0.023232108,
0.0528227091,
0.0082100695,
-0.0158692338,
0.0186737943,
0.0462143868,
-0.0448878333,
0.0619793609,
-0.0113382516,
0.0330621712,
-0.0069043911,
0.0267984979,
0.0389663205,
-0.001835302,
-0.0375965051,
-0.0219359342,
0.0260253921,
0.0308589507,
0.0262013897,
0.018946467,
-0.0000060246,
0.0490377545,
-0.0206313916,
0.0205590036,
0.0160206184,
-0.0221793372,
0.0424434245,
0.0319360234,
0.0019240382,
-0.0077053024,
0.0358381271,
0.0296022538,
0.0014636576,
0.0560483336,
0.0163353905,
0.0474238954,
-0.0275075808,
-0.0017173287,
-0.0956710726,
-0.0195132252,
-0.0257429443,
-0.0047836774,
0.051178731,
-0.0704054162,
0.0263369177,
-0.0187258162,
0.0009098989,
-0.029185636,
0.0277841259,
-0.0107318684,
0.004313773,
0.0165409576,
0.0228485782,
-0.0215751063,
-0.0093975468,
0.1029009447,
-0.0096541429,
0.0674524456,
-0.0184592009,
0.0138084348,
-0.0401646942,
-0.0371432453,
0.0370883495,
-0.011880626,
-0.0135661568,
-0.0162963457,
-0.0081965392,
-0.0584993958,
0.0119689507,
-0.0300784595,
-0.0063755261,
-0.0243158173,
0.0357987657,
0.0523681864,
-0.0193753969,
-0.0089910524,
-0.0027646732,
-0.0098182075,
0.032682769,
0.0034612727,
-0.0255287029,
-5.851535573e-33,
-0.0078290803,
-0.0162934791,
0.0144304754,
0.0059363865,
0.0232160594,
0.0154037718,
-0.0403883643,
0.0056152488,
0.0223818198,
-0.0072607743,
-0.0180228092,
0.0026427368,
0.0200708639,
0.0486014448,
0.0158796255,
-0.0353530198,
0.0650200471,
0.0107247345,
-0.0123703992,
0.0224385429,
0.0223680548,
0.0392502546,
0.0913144872,
-0.032845173,
-0.0066397395,
-0.0053353049,
0.0051281611,
0.0132003436,
-0.0125245387,
0.0606825687,
-0.003711039,
0.0234953612,
0.0220217239,
-0.1060980707,
-0.053827133,
0.0250740834,
-0.0625011399,
-0.019148143,
-0.010176735,
0.0054139504,
-0.0240547061,
-0.0318798497,
0.0580254458,
-0.0141994255,
-0.027354531,
-0.0235518534,
0.0331263356,
-0.0248553511,
-0.0342839025,
-0.0348336883,
-0.059415888,
0.0100205857,
0.0152442986,
-0.0179745536,
0.0009898423,
0.0927289873,
-0.0072775297,
0.0149470484,
-0.0248766076,
0.0234307982,
0.0265454296,
0.0406712443,
0.0529829785,
0.0546695963,
0.0122844512,
0.0355269387,
-0.0022751659,
-0.0065907598,
-0.0016838849,
-0.0366955474,
0.0172618888,
0.0829794779,
-0.0002557193,
-0.0039367736,
0.0431969203,
0.0169031266,
-0.051886104,
0.0009850211,
-0.0049331132,
0.0214402899,
0.0231547579,
0.0160773862,
0.0070317313,
-0.0252101813,
-0.0555093475,
-0.0152108856,
-0.0051035802,
-0.0048458884,
0.0225077104,
0.0315911546,
0.0093502523,
0.0419150703,
0.0485887043,
-0.0476175882,
-0.002235238,
0.0297106542,
-0.0275024995,
-0.0023998884,
-0.0000103694,
-0.0047935266,
-0.056473162,
-0.0757808387,
0.0100771608,
0.0153733259,
0.0240599904,
-0.0259729736,
0.0649601519,
0.0419304334,
-0.0569463223,
-0.019556582,
-0.0551117063,
0.0154896583,
0.0253050271,
0.0756893829,
0.0856646821,
0.0133922501,
-0.0300533511,
0.0274950117,
-0.0135119949,
-0.0332566351,
-0.0232045818,
0.0225603674,
-0.0039195283,
0.0440134965,
-0.0119197452,
-0.0474875681,
-0.036185272,
0.0133359432,
0.0431282856,
-0.0575596914,
-0.0209352914,
0.0195079949,
2.602e-7,
0.0360795856,
0.0079768971,
-0.0041237003,
-0.0143518783,
0.0390921943,
0.0349163972,
-0.0526328757,
0.0259675588,
-0.0037551997,
-0.0057024229,
0.0369926915,
-0.0088930232,
0.0739682987,
0.0074031004,
-0.0608455576,
-0.0499310233,
-0.0806073919,
0.0357426628,
-0.042712912,
0.0140938135,
-0.0072357883,
0.124083586,
0.0068672849,
-0.0226905085,
0.011520721,
-0.0346419401,
0.0694754422,
-0.0370699018,
0.018850103,
0.0300927702,
-0.0147534022,
0.0451200381,
0.0205919724,
0.0318069085,
-0.0185604542,
0.040944431,
0.0157166421,
0.0502961464,
0.0417158157,
-0.0117869731,
0.0107761407,
0.0433220342,
-0.0011374316,
-0.0425536074,
0.0674549788,
-0.1434565336,
-0.0401315689,
-0.0277034789,
0.0007031732,
-0.0132254986,
0.0050627394,
0.0016955552,
0.0295445919,
0.0303684138,
0.015039281,
0.0143906642,
-0.011330571,
-0.0590979457,
-0.015764555,
0.0410061479,
-0.0716748387,
-0.0291634016,
-0.0707221404,
-0.0297572128,
0.0432839133,
-0.0188249424,
-0.0000332024,
2.536371508e-34,
0.0054742843,
-0.0026827627,
0.0143862162,
0.002662054,
0.0026824756,
-0.0482942164,
-0.0066755163,
0.0201184489,
0.0123077156,
-0.0538609624,
-0.0031283358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00867v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00867v1 | Automatic Disfluency Detection from Untranscribed Speech | 2023-11-01T21:36:39 | 2023-11-01T21:36:39 | Amrit Romana, Kazuhito Koishida, Emily Mower Provost | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Speech disfluencies, such as filled pauses or repetitions, are disruptions in
the typical flow of speech. Stuttering is a speech disorder characterized by a
high rate of disfluencies, but all individuals speak with some disfluencies and
the rates of disfluencies may by increased by factors such as cognitive load.
Clinically, automatic disfluency detection may help in treatment planning for
individuals who stutter. Outside of the clinic, automatic disfluency detection
may serve as a pre-processing step to improve natural language understanding in
downstream applications. With this wide range of applications in mind, we
investigate language, acoustic, and multimodal methods for frame-level
automatic disfluency detection and categorization. Each of these methods relies
on audio as an input. First, we evaluate several automatic speech recognition
(ASR) systems in terms of their ability to transcribe disfluencies, measured
using disfluency error rates. We then use these ASR transcripts as input to a
language-based disfluency detection model. We find that disfluency detection
performance is largely limited by the quality of transcripts and alignments. We
find that an acoustic-based approach that does not require transcription as an
intermediate step outperforms the ASR language approach. Finally, we present
multimodal architectures which we find improve disfluency detection performance
over the unimodal approaches. Ultimately, this work introduces novel approaches
for automatic frame-level disfluency and categorization. In the long term, this
will help researchers incorporate automatic disfluency detection into a range
of applications. | [
-0.0143410685,
0.0656166375,
-0.020031007,
0.0055906456,
-0.01246907,
0.0011902119,
0.0230430271,
0.0029628249,
-0.019607015,
-0.062214762,
0.0115500409,
-0.0459671915,
0.0594017655,
0.0308012869,
0.0396074951,
-0.0823115483,
0.052405566,
-0.0634082854,
0.0207934175,
0.0035053622,
0.0358650535,
0.0100299465,
-0.0953147113,
0.0234104749,
-0.0376073793,
-0.0044089276,
-0.0094943149,
0.0291875247,
0.0216357112,
-0.0337173454,
-0.027998725,
0.0396127664,
-0.0277984124,
0.0261516888,
0.0000021332,
-0.0302633885,
-0.0149259837,
-0.0155277289,
-0.0169212297,
-0.0301293395,
0.0196590573,
0.0158951879,
-0.0256989021,
0.0391437076,
0.0064449646,
-0.0116868988,
0.0681875721,
0.0024984919,
0.0156221231,
0.0193121918,
-0.0126472255,
-0.0258284863,
0.0165232122,
0.0156760942,
0.0182970781,
0.0164327659,
-0.0158731323,
-0.0473758578,
0.0293566883,
-0.0766695365,
-0.0433038361,
0.0240260605,
-0.0402441211,
-0.0053793583,
0.0157609694,
-0.0127452333,
-0.1127475053,
-0.0539510287,
-0.0408658795,
0.0831707045,
-0.0219180491,
-0.0066482266,
0.0526595004,
0.0150758959,
0.0072813109,
0.0231474563,
0.0231042374,
-0.0198148247,
-0.0186797269,
-0.0235627983,
0.0043227426,
0.0177525971,
0.0080742156,
-0.0446566977,
-0.0281412434,
-0.0209935512,
0.0051038261,
-0.0149328336,
-0.0105371643,
-0.0221903082,
0.0065228357,
-0.0289115328,
0.0518685021,
-0.0300195403,
-0.0697294101,
-0.0255901497,
-0.0456836969,
-0.072135359,
-0.0028800617,
0.0196801499,
0.0048843641,
0.024172822,
-0.0865651965,
-0.0137157403,
-0.0180060938,
0.0806430802,
-0.0132494951,
0.0233800244,
-0.0143316006,
0.0666855723,
-0.0490008071,
0.0273950826,
-0.0072871991,
-0.0093325833,
-0.0183725264,
-0.0157695413,
-0.0445443131,
-0.0109008439,
-0.0338196345,
-0.0217284448,
-0.0405611061,
0.003621951,
0.0088098375,
0.0336041525,
0.0051617972,
0.0403740332,
0.0422867313,
0.0173952132,
0.0016801199,
-0.0832159892,
-0.0018666456,
0.0119282706,
0.037669193,
0.0133769829,
0.0223869346,
0.0610257946,
0.0198664647,
-0.0409960747,
-0.0073391832,
-0.0058584241,
-0.0793994516,
-0.030502459,
-0.0008112843,
-0.0430085063,
0.0064574489,
0.0118470844,
0.0202188399,
-0.0240520462,
0.0064095915,
-0.0272836089,
0.0328070223,
0.0864944384,
-0.048625879,
0.0341748334,
0.0523089916,
-0.01560569,
0.0019857334,
0.0156745911,
0.0233702045,
-0.0848463103,
0.0205757748,
-0.0351184867,
0.0244216006,
0.0225229785,
-0.0301517602,
-0.0364395604,
-0.045645196,
-0.0631167144,
-0.0017984837,
-0.0067512766,
0.082980305,
0.0534307323,
0.0049829534,
-0.0129021769,
0.0645867065,
0.0442820191,
0.0408731289,
-0.0347907841,
-0.0150874397,
0.0224121902,
-0.0282234941,
0.0338889733,
0.0098112943,
-0.0008661814,
0.0038096309,
-0.0132888919,
0.058226496,
0.0427036099,
-0.0165608879,
0.0064785224,
-0.0084564202,
-0.0282076262,
0.002551083,
0.0480353609,
0.0218215454,
-0.0068732537,
-0.0182727315,
0.0536583588,
-0.0203328524,
-0.0265733209,
0.0173942298,
-0.0378902517,
-0.0618718825,
0.0971918479,
0.0330674648,
-0.0378811806,
-0.0064342348,
-0.0539874993,
-0.0259036478,
0.0053817439,
-0.0144428806,
0.0082538165,
0.0588435642,
-0.0417312533,
-0.0030681959,
0.0598127432,
0.013328121,
-0.0107978666,
-0.0567046218,
0.0555579066,
-0.0107197491,
0.0019024742,
0.0270550493,
0.0069693578,
0.0194179546,
0.0154207991,
0.000195862,
0.0110209333,
0.0591582842,
0.0064936895,
-0.0391573347,
-0.0011759036,
-0.0028322593,
-0.0105181811,
0.0168010686,
0.0720652193,
-0.0125434371,
-0.0520793647,
0.046111457,
-0.0051431633,
-0.0253960509,
0.0400438234,
0.0295588747,
-0.0834646598,
0.0185858607,
-0.0876760855,
0.0127837323,
-0.03370592,
0.0815930218,
0.0097410223,
0.0365349315,
0.0151183279,
-0.0389765054,
-0.0186299905,
0.0191805121,
-0.0120937843,
-0.043872226,
-0.0291249938,
-0.0806598961,
-0.0427318811,
0.041475594,
-0.0435962342,
0.0291326568,
-0.0194510762,
-0.0446073189,
-0.0193217695,
-0.0380822271,
-0.0412356406,
-0.0080090063,
-0.0110085942,
0.0199705176,
-0.019413203,
-0.0154563328,
0.0034237846,
-0.0327202864,
0.0112950867,
-0.004662686,
0.0383903757,
-0.018934736,
-0.0205646995,
-0.0027144682,
-0.0816083997,
-0.0165190045,
0.0181824919,
-0.0104347607,
-0.0384551547,
-0.0447305888,
-0.0856038183,
-0.0555962399,
0.0085315881,
0.0049836892,
0.0295756161,
0.0073255068,
-0.0133454669,
0.0134555101,
0.0218577497,
0.0534873456,
0.0141134551,
0.0016160065,
0.00665425,
0.0305500869,
-0.0488217585,
0.0213221554,
0.0004154753,
0.0455365889,
0.0792368948,
0.0031513148,
-0.00994894,
-0.0530107096,
0.0205995198,
0.0546784475,
0.0293506756,
0.004540401,
-0.0524755642,
-0.0178929921,
-0.0063974978,
0.0134096993,
-0.050636556,
-0.015085551,
0.0185493007,
0.0052955779,
-0.0424369276,
0.0386556163,
-0.0419887044,
-0.0503339246,
-0.0010579862,
-0.0281988885,
0.0187834483,
-0.0012390557,
-0.012005996,
0.0063432949,
-0.0033732478,
-0.0618721992,
-0.0006019037,
0.006637238,
-0.0114617208,
-0.0587552302,
0.0205827747,
-0.0496640019,
-0.0075567956,
-0.0021869708,
-0.0290493537,
-0.0172027349,
-0.0181639474,
-0.0011929848,
-0.0312451683,
0.0081403507,
-0.0415567197,
-0.0669592321,
0.0218106862,
-0.0308023375,
0.0893409625,
-0.002187124,
0.0205659699,
-0.0002849872,
0.0601985306,
0.0197826233,
0.0535600409,
-0.0075181117,
-0.0324261487,
0.029798964,
0.0097001297,
0.0331357121,
0.0301597603,
-0.0106036942,
0.0136543177,
0.0221349448,
-0.0101830326,
-0.0383837931,
0.029050231,
0.0455065407,
-0.0273523927,
0.0047582453,
0.0839736536,
-0.0039060311,
-0.0261596404,
-0.0109179439,
-0.0118640112,
0.0075163413,
0.0238602441,
-0.032390818,
-0.0739323497,
-0.0543914363,
0.044749584,
0.0340927057,
0.0065865768,
0.039085038,
0.0105762118,
-0.0092417346,
0.0145745873,
0.0279570352,
-0.0373112187,
-0.0367865115,
0.0137578072,
0.004387314,
0.0195080098,
0.0470335111,
0.008762436,
-0.0215044525,
-0.0046445429,
0.0380489007,
-0.0785190314,
-0.0850789919,
0.0011427766,
0.024247976,
0.1245228425,
0.0492711589,
0.0064587914,
-0.0051691271,
-0.0442540757,
0.0518695936,
-0.0182252228,
0.0139884623,
0.0018708361,
0.0341143124,
0.0344928093,
-0.0272023156,
-0.0076031564,
0.0337719172,
0.0065757614,
0.0128654232,
-0.0112395175,
0.0259763598,
-0.0601891465,
-0.007638094,
-0.0185493268,
0.0210372601,
0.0275650602,
0.0145447534,
0.0038971242,
-0.0209418871,
-0.059472423,
0.0358491428,
0.0482103452,
-0.0185757298,
0.0409577712,
0.0038501965,
0.049846638,
-0.0564996675,
-0.0382986143,
0.0187676568,
-0.0042873621,
-0.0175727364,
0.0265056957,
0.0331654549,
-0.0044175461,
0.0712870285,
-0.0508764647,
0.0195369963,
0.0482462607,
0.0390632153,
-0.0942828506,
-0.0248429962,
-0.0167275108,
-0.0138647128,
-0.0157324392,
0.0192122124,
-0.0451657325,
-0.0540574156,
0.0627794489,
-0.0212140195,
0.0143185183,
0.0058844415,
-0.0158068556,
-0.031657517,
0.0390803926,
0.0419266075,
-0.075681664,
0.0598762892,
0.0427816063,
-0.0460151955,
-0.0252686441,
0.006922862,
-0.005731374,
0.0269054733,
-0.072275348,
0.0127775781,
-0.0295770019,
-0.0504378118,
-0.0239818413,
0.0029664165,
0.0581418276,
-0.0326749235,
0.0477433391,
-0.0150956204,
0.0132862506,
0.0643212497,
0.0697068423,
-0.0290359072,
0.0099702775,
0.0084177153,
-0.0323095471,
-0.0079933666,
-0.0502410196,
-0.097863771,
-0.0587160699,
0.02101711,
0.0679058731,
0.0232801326,
0.0040643397,
-0.0315429457,
0.0240000393,
0.0522329547,
0.0454697199,
0.0123793781,
0.0215639602,
0.0021872956,
0.0476631038,
-0.0013067733,
-0.0263933558,
0.021241419,
0.0543473847,
0.0168619901,
0.0705784485,
0.0062273606,
0.0094885519,
0.0216767453,
0.0436668545,
0.0637410283,
0.0481002964,
0.0185557324,
-0.037721701,
0.0310256723,
-0.0285312906,
0.0204969086,
0.0137442239,
0.0078302128,
-0.0108989589,
-0.0079622837,
0.0318777859,
0.0071704797,
-0.0291456375,
-0.0224077795,
-0.0007872151,
-0.0434988961,
-0.0361151099,
-0.03921666,
0.0326716602,
-0.0337282754,
0.0014638067,
-0.0213288795,
-0.0534402356,
0.0474530756,
0.0020035796,
0.0590115264,
-0.0259327516,
-0.0092742955,
-0.0101222536,
-0.0165154971,
-0.0041375589,
-0.0064050648,
-0.0736411661,
0.0260671582,
0.0040244544,
0.037353199,
-5.797445935e-33,
-0.0341343507,
-0.0601109043,
-0.0181932859,
-0.00991954,
-0.0294632036,
0.0341170281,
-0.0141292959,
0.0369506106,
0.0152593991,
0.0061169639,
0.0260755792,
0.0081709595,
0.0258033443,
-0.0247248486,
0.0136889946,
-0.0201835856,
0.0742448792,
0.0002178655,
0.0166526996,
0.0031036651,
0.0606437624,
0.0231219362,
0.037948247,
-0.0396917947,
-0.00531326,
-0.0087469826,
-0.0064109592,
-0.0470778458,
0.0393298455,
0.0016551986,
-0.0205523111,
0.0442689545,
0.0010289825,
0.0381007157,
-0.0021452168,
0.0414509587,
-0.0823739916,
0.0253951531,
0.0117841559,
0.0441676676,
0.0230958164,
-0.0113783255,
0.0496966466,
-0.0051355106,
-0.001511898,
0.0065537309,
0.0505065806,
-0.0423467904,
0.0072113909,
0.0001194659,
-0.0177405756,
0.0420384333,
-0.0282766372,
-0.0630860403,
0.0557615533,
0.086253576,
-0.0130707761,
-0.0286449362,
-0.0494632125,
0.0181720108,
-0.0221218709,
0.0522070527,
-0.0012199616,
-0.0076773115,
-0.0354281254,
0.0385202654,
0.0411731526,
-0.0522607416,
0.0470130146,
-0.0291189626,
0.0184517819,
0.0266910158,
0.0219512079,
-0.0046440214,
0.0815335289,
-0.0603388213,
-0.0053602797,
-0.0025445174,
-0.0288337935,
0.007683645,
0.0419834778,
0.0425635017,
-0.060885381,
-0.0148763238,
-0.0342348628,
0.0046330965,
-0.0244976021,
0.0175843928,
0.0664153099,
-0.0091703692,
0.0381242856,
0.008765921,
0.0744251683,
0.014405298,
0.009850271,
-0.0309724435,
-0.0272780564,
0.0252734162,
-0.0032820192,
-0.0268610306,
0.0007285423,
-0.037122231,
0.0930288881,
0.0709497407,
0.0573643968,
-0.0652465373,
-0.0356348157,
0.0609093122,
-0.0599951893,
0.0131182894,
0.0365794115,
0.0407814533,
-0.0115236323,
0.012374769,
0.0558095127,
-0.0145961456,
-0.0278249923,
0.0177237131,
-0.0385179743,
-0.0064317649,
-0.0672840625,
0.0508298948,
-0.0448135063,
0.0246951543,
-0.0435224511,
0.0242094714,
0.0248515736,
-0.023782393,
-0.0226427689,
-0.0539646447,
0.0007101082,
-0.0181999337,
2.898e-7,
-0.02812442,
0.0415961817,
0.0279816519,
-0.0365601406,
0.0610921904,
-0.0127798198,
-0.0272441152,
-0.0006877173,
-0.0046837591,
-0.0034377789,
-0.0061922558,
0.0039808643,
0.1022647843,
0.0103679243,
-0.0164926499,
-0.0028617824,
-0.0376823582,
0.0565654151,
-0.0031333098,
0.0200614817,
0.0173938349,
0.0051736282,
-0.0305136163,
-0.0553294122,
0.0416480601,
-0.0116502056,
-0.0089174332,
0.012482319,
0.0420035012,
-0.0275017526,
0.0002498789,
-0.0288094692,
-0.0111322338,
0.0558519252,
-0.0188013241,
-0.0006425342,
-0.0063629337,
0.0378832631,
-0.0576169193,
-0.0395353884,
0.0016430503,
0.0517761521,
-0.0485669635,
-0.0054704249,
0.0312085021,
0.0140771242,
-0.0103359399,
-0.037384294,
-0.0363449939,
-0.0439077504,
0.0894527659,
-0.0056503708,
-0.0103410026,
0.0363158844,
0.0072692349,
0.001877596,
-0.0302351862,
-0.0457956344,
-0.0135897566,
0.0530363768,
-0.0558456704,
0.020508714,
-0.005658783,
-0.027538497,
-0.0085440874,
-0.0220625531,
-0.02672996,
2.43080385e-34,
0.0266748797,
-0.0214611571,
0.0198648013,
0.0104992893,
-0.0078204498,
-0.0461631678,
-0.0240888875,
0.0275301524,
-0.0214913487,
-0.0020348819,
-0.0218156409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00863v1 | Training Dynamics of Contextual N-Grams in Language Models | 2023-11-01T21:32:51 | 2023-11-01T21:32:51 | Lucia Quirke, Lovis Heindrich, Wes Gurnee, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prior work has shown the existence of contextual neurons in language models,
including a neuron that activates on German text. We show that this neuron
exists within a broader contextual n-gram circuit: we find late layer neurons
which recognize and continue n-grams common in German text, but which only
activate if the German neuron is active. We investigate the formation of this
circuit throughout training and find that it is an example of what we call a
second-order circuit. In particular, both the constituent n-gram circuits and
the German detection circuit which culminates in the German neuron form with
independent functions early in training - the German detection circuit
partially through modeling German unigram statistics, and the n-grams by
boosting appropriate completions. Only after both circuits have already formed
do they fit together into a second-order circuit. Contrary to the hypotheses
presented in prior work, we find that the contextual n-gram circuit forms
gradually rather than in a sudden phase transition. We further present a range
of anomalous observations such as a simultaneous phase transition in many tasks
coinciding with the learning rate warm-up, and evidence that many context
neurons form simultaneously early in training but are later unlearned. | [
-0.015109593,
0.0067069833,
-0.0139455115,
0.0541410819,
-0.0029982673,
0.0389956012,
0.0215532649,
-0.0325614288,
-0.0585256629,
-0.0139331436,
-0.029672496,
-0.0711509436,
0.0154453916,
0.0263030306,
0.0554297529,
-0.011359646,
0.0684001669,
-0.0242843963,
-0.0385823436,
-0.0350197703,
0.0058858534,
-0.0174450297,
-0.0508106686,
0.0404450186,
-0.0177854709,
0.0047475668,
-0.0213073567,
-0.049576778,
-0.0207007434,
-0.0449596159,
-0.0072964979,
0.0246132128,
-0.0041512377,
0.0433547162,
0.0000018485,
-0.0383993946,
0.0438183174,
-0.0155398715,
-0.0656310096,
-0.0172173921,
0.0472582802,
-0.0048210481,
-0.0460073687,
-0.0248284768,
-0.0327950604,
0.0129146539,
0.0701575801,
0.0235027857,
-0.0405683555,
0.0364855677,
-0.0189633835,
-0.0684975311,
0.0310730524,
-0.04028707,
0.0141803753,
-0.0409150459,
0.0257968754,
-0.0103768576,
0.002071965,
-0.020602718,
-0.0390110239,
-0.001006205,
0.0246616174,
0.0330247208,
0.0053066951,
0.1033544689,
0.0673511103,
-0.0006981051,
-0.0166423488,
-0.0232972652,
-0.0265505705,
-0.0391837396,
-0.0020979417,
0.0068789013,
-0.0050583133,
-0.0403958261,
-0.0327541642,
0.0372893289,
-0.0251382627,
0.0717379004,
0.071282655,
-0.04693437,
0.0156118972,
-0.002352332,
-0.0176838618,
0.0759301335,
-0.0013900048,
-0.0121065872,
0.0108837429,
0.0378527194,
-0.0347730964,
-0.047067102,
0.0241179876,
0.0269122068,
0.037540406,
0.0282201935,
-0.0344591029,
0.0020905621,
-0.0009553026,
-0.0552609302,
0.0011003657,
0.0130034434,
-0.0009894863,
0.0037743512,
-0.0366471,
0.027790321,
-0.0086156679,
-0.0172819998,
-0.0255255792,
0.0086836899,
-0.0310168751,
-0.0183137897,
-0.0385621488,
0.0384981222,
-0.0190260243,
-0.0185640864,
-0.0746681392,
0.0362662077,
0.0045208121,
-0.0534954853,
-0.0203967504,
-0.0020252839,
-0.0550072417,
0.0203369893,
-0.017157685,
0.0270352401,
-0.0091909943,
0.0336198099,
-0.0133596212,
-0.002690943,
-0.0150214797,
-0.0299327746,
0.0156681184,
-0.0040963427,
-0.005184981,
0.0013035447,
-0.039182324,
-0.0548614301,
-0.0758786052,
0.0144812586,
-0.0315360762,
0.0239598211,
-0.0103678256,
-0.0526412576,
-0.0335493609,
0.0176912509,
0.0003843623,
-0.0063620261,
0.0042912001,
0.0225848816,
-0.0409388915,
0.0629969016,
-0.039827168,
-0.0063891239,
-0.0148594966,
-0.0110126138,
0.0396853201,
0.0589619577,
0.0108360751,
-0.0387182459,
-0.0179071296,
-0.0140554635,
-0.0117462939,
0.0380630121,
0.0254871715,
0.0044507729,
-0.078241609,
-0.1041934192,
0.0251223352,
-0.0041782088,
0.0695350319,
0.0142745581,
-0.0353953093,
-0.0138914064,
0.0389810875,
0.0741586834,
0.0106868623,
0.0141454274,
0.03448385,
-0.0731746629,
-0.0143880378,
0.076150097,
-0.0582441762,
0.0038001067,
-0.0687327236,
0.0130882254,
-0.0490858816,
0.0332292616,
-0.0064616306,
-0.0349002033,
-0.0019950073,
-0.0014272657,
0.0328727849,
-0.0339107476,
0.0484555848,
0.0288869925,
-0.0557343364,
-0.0062245326,
0.028512137,
0.0092362789,
0.0215562619,
-0.0163566265,
0.0236552302,
0.0500595979,
0.001535619,
-0.0087956768,
-0.0116863213,
0.0236054696,
0.0022709135,
0.051631961,
0.0046310956,
0.0043176129,
0.0493465438,
-0.0135415159,
0.0005568988,
-0.0052324352,
0.0171884652,
0.0289275534,
-0.0488988347,
-0.0020604976,
-0.0421519019,
0.0440449826,
-0.000656164,
0.0351083465,
-0.0274409037,
-0.0100046815,
-0.0132102473,
-0.0205538739,
0.0034493711,
-0.0248755328,
-0.0234575178,
0.0289771054,
0.0096539045,
-0.0575131848,
0.0071341326,
0.0474581011,
-0.0752121061,
-0.0413453653,
0.0401008725,
0.0615925156,
0.0301687159,
-0.0445891358,
0.0337537602,
-0.0444391146,
0.033398658,
0.0017892653,
0.0884499997,
-0.0391530022,
-0.0003540667,
0.0260258727,
0.0447455868,
-0.0391894095,
0.0670685694,
-0.0155788651,
0.0237046834,
-0.0077563515,
0.0289662983,
-0.0173365064,
-0.0027401154,
-0.0317947306,
0.0249053258,
-0.0221775118,
-0.0091475323,
-0.0155186895,
-0.0449203886,
-0.0155505091,
-0.0031102502,
-0.0797035396,
-0.0384823419,
0.0204497986,
0.0454951376,
0.0171717852,
-0.0251146946,
-0.003069964,
0.0077443169,
0.0081106229,
0.0476943739,
0.024499137,
0.0438614935,
0.0208143964,
0.020450674,
-0.0039286106,
-0.0563952364,
-0.0442201681,
-0.0157809947,
0.0755768269,
0.0171748828,
-0.0512645245,
-0.0454196967,
0.0503188558,
0.0189739931,
0.0721628591,
0.0022144134,
-0.0628441349,
0.0513037071,
-0.0145380199,
0.0334994942,
0.0733978674,
0.0293468814,
0.0483609475,
0.0214256924,
-0.0153984521,
0.0095659764,
-0.0197330732,
-0.0510224812,
0.017171625,
-0.0789161995,
-0.0058144899,
-0.0082878675,
0.1484386325,
0.0339187793,
-0.003516936,
-0.0315472223,
0.0131046837,
-0.0705486238,
-0.0101760086,
-0.0368978903,
-0.034219157,
-0.0660453886,
0.0250919405,
-0.0173699409,
-0.0263430346,
0.0285672881,
-0.0114828022,
-0.0301905982,
-0.0448340736,
-0.0281850826,
0.0347652286,
0.0190505311,
0.0687205791,
0.0241508316,
0.043054685,
-0.0237289369,
-0.0405977443,
0.0073071425,
-0.0145547818,
0.0076194839,
0.0428460352,
-0.0244614426,
-0.019639736,
0.0186979324,
-0.0121553326,
-0.0530633107,
-0.0004085562,
-0.0226047244,
0.0277184863,
0.0240058545,
-0.024872059,
0.0097801611,
-0.0133895483,
0.0045065619,
0.0845122412,
-0.0167284794,
-0.0360700414,
-0.0365764126,
0.05103622,
-0.0147609347,
0.0140917627,
0.0354996696,
-0.0558836274,
0.0299307965,
0.0235265698,
0.0209671892,
0.0438067019,
-0.036702577,
0.0030494879,
0.0224124659,
-0.012333666,
-0.0483154729,
0.0166172944,
-0.0027171797,
-0.0264971741,
-0.0435128659,
0.0776758566,
0.007542667,
-0.069763869,
0.0307332557,
0.0046404027,
-0.000305229,
0.0556939282,
0.0201669838,
-0.0559188277,
0.0219792016,
-0.000727364,
-0.0059516155,
0.0093474714,
0.0231855214,
-0.0047711069,
-0.0810892656,
0.0092120292,
0.0326382406,
-0.1065969095,
0.0508342274,
0.0131492084,
-0.006796571,
0.0310753472,
-0.0025787065,
0.0339951888,
-0.0304191504,
0.018249331,
0.0579327308,
0.0530508608,
-0.0513585769,
-0.0022819994,
-0.0314885341,
0.0474387296,
0.0263274908,
-0.0104144607,
-0.069323428,
0.0039505227,
0.0895636231,
-0.0228102338,
0.0289371461,
-0.0191521496,
0.0078956606,
0.0455354229,
-0.0238003265,
-0.024128316,
0.0249517784,
-0.0197739433,
-0.0717705861,
-0.0490429327,
0.0325106829,
-0.0323706567,
-0.0296436511,
-0.0013775139,
0.0426787511,
-0.0145818871,
0.0303671118,
0.043141827,
-0.0922295228,
0.0149669796,
-0.0113683566,
0.0597554818,
-0.0493922345,
-0.0367919728,
0.0187571775,
0.0135279205,
-0.0141998613,
-0.0527936071,
-0.0083306339,
-0.0236257296,
0.0690054074,
0.0217036307,
0.0215293746,
-0.0010488693,
-0.0619775355,
-0.0028791963,
0.0051441551,
0.0435594618,
-0.0142305214,
-0.1047597677,
-0.0385300703,
0.0191081166,
-0.0477599539,
-0.0468040481,
-0.0420359857,
-0.0575170554,
-0.0561608374,
0.0634590983,
0.0070849913,
0.0215822868,
0.0242016241,
0.0011991811,
-0.0495384485,
0.0348852724,
0.034712255,
0.0386987627,
0.0777340308,
0.0053478004,
-0.0074878256,
0.0025731358,
-0.0096379118,
0.0305826943,
0.0519544818,
0.0099462355,
-0.0151008032,
-0.0369988568,
0.0371286795,
0.0432806574,
-0.0491186939,
0.054928828,
0.0078120069,
0.0491452068,
-0.0579502843,
0.0048809219,
0.0408718809,
0.0277855694,
-0.0162101742,
-0.04073935,
0.025403114,
0.0490678214,
0.0149198584,
-0.0593079999,
0.0400570631,
0.0290418565,
-0.0223023761,
-0.0060403128,
0.0523130186,
0.0157438405,
0.0103555955,
0.0503940433,
0.0098885875,
0.0276187975,
-0.0165541917,
0.0192361884,
-0.0241170488,
0.0526579916,
0.0196896754,
-0.0191842522,
-0.0534025691,
0.0115298182,
-0.0584746897,
0.0239329301,
-0.0292504951,
-0.0156358685,
0.0678533986,
-0.0365096591,
0.0247588363,
-0.0472681969,
0.0036297983,
-0.0005183317,
-0.0243123788,
-0.0253467206,
-0.0249306001,
0.0230676457,
0.023794068,
0.0194864068,
-0.0276670121,
0.0744179189,
0.003394929,
0.0491467677,
0.0121023795,
0.0029208686,
0.0127980374,
-0.0142258601,
-0.0298458505,
0.0389767475,
-0.0323690362,
0.0050470592,
-0.0279955026,
-0.052821815,
-0.0181490965,
0.032607995,
0.0336903334,
-0.0390394144,
0.0397181101,
0.032949511,
-0.0031821597,
-0.0040372978,
-0.0011889053,
0.0190811865,
0.0439616069,
-0.0056568487,
0.0020716847,
-6.13838999e-33,
-0.0312296301,
-0.0352657288,
0.0314328745,
0.0007214663,
0.0005282553,
0.0530977026,
-0.0497988872,
0.0358671919,
0.0121543333,
0.0292730611,
-0.0107470024,
0.0147231827,
0.0174219292,
-0.002384779,
0.0227990896,
0.0162561685,
0.0283543095,
-0.0363130011,
0.0445868969,
0.0051252968,
0.068049781,
0.0324510075,
0.0913064331,
-0.0432065725,
0.0071201362,
0.0386682898,
-0.0160325244,
0.0144603159,
-0.032644283,
0.0551156253,
-0.054561425,
0.0364550576,
0.043686118,
-0.035714373,
-0.0237973109,
-0.0008207042,
-0.0531023853,
-0.0379996002,
0.0022701877,
0.0069444217,
-0.0287650805,
-0.013778558,
0.0712878704,
-0.0394178145,
-0.0306611285,
0.0757912546,
0.0116522033,
-0.0277211871,
-0.049694106,
0.0138081843,
-0.0706760436,
-0.0251943544,
0.0214701779,
0.0200503562,
0.0264742337,
-0.0517889187,
-0.0174238682,
-0.0208842643,
-0.0322992504,
0.0181342699,
0.0280043166,
0.0529057346,
0.0019879157,
0.0347682089,
0.0159039833,
0.0443858132,
0.1086495444,
0.0364260115,
-0.0077353688,
-0.0345117003,
0.0737465397,
0.0103662349,
0.0225027055,
-0.0397523418,
0.0918310508,
-0.0462049693,
-0.0163559169,
-0.0278575644,
0.052884616,
0.0234822538,
0.003523265,
-0.0106559321,
-0.0076069362,
-0.0431480668,
-0.0097402213,
-0.0510259382,
-0.0218991172,
-0.004793758,
0.0302050076,
-0.0021856527,
0.0468703769,
-0.0174672138,
0.0270096771,
-0.0111970678,
-0.0151590956,
0.0118366778,
0.0194542333,
0.0265248958,
0.0086996425,
-0.0353597477,
-0.0563073121,
-0.0228922181,
-0.0510695986,
0.0101516033,
0.0049148919,
0.0317551643,
0.0090214694,
0.0267548114,
-0.0209194105,
0.0099369381,
-0.0466194004,
-0.0143808378,
0.050189618,
0.0295342989,
0.0267427117,
-0.0113994079,
-0.0081745302,
0.0224939883,
0.0402566008,
-0.041857902,
-0.0160914324,
-0.0162198506,
-0.030228259,
0.0896296352,
-0.0104807159,
-0.034439411,
-0.0287543368,
0.0545280911,
0.0613080673,
-0.0291602574,
-0.0180350281,
0.0660977811,
2.643e-7,
0.0267427899,
0.0090367943,
-0.0055001308,
-0.0168907605,
0.0812288597,
-0.0091656093,
-0.0175087694,
0.0037178167,
-0.0249049589,
0.0190685242,
-0.0140536139,
-0.0001095754,
-0.020015087,
0.0326096751,
-0.0361656509,
-0.0303949434,
-0.0394238196,
0.0491605923,
-0.0312839597,
0.0082987612,
-0.0396444388,
0.0403427631,
-0.0146101387,
-0.0404605679,
-0.00736944,
-0.0518239252,
0.0445414074,
0.0068127601,
0.0617635399,
-0.0198555533,
-0.0220674146,
-0.008321777,
0.0124926809,
0.0518161021,
0.0000222026,
0.0330268741,
-0.0235003717,
-0.0245514121,
-0.0115405209,
0.000943696,
0.0251774173,
-0.0039900006,
-0.0149555737,
-0.0433920845,
0.0204033125,
-0.0632334724,
0.0229374785,
-0.0213529859,
-0.0008215283,
-0.0111576952,
-0.0078734923,
-0.0080817863,
-0.0236364603,
-0.0094893435,
-0.0149076432,
0.0082170935,
-0.0577423312,
-0.0413653366,
-0.0205445904,
0.0676482767,
-0.0251280982,
0.0006995609,
-0.0225941651,
0.0008027659,
0.0244664233,
0.0067894007,
-0.0217792299,
2.205096996e-34,
0.0032562723,
-0.0238404181,
0.0498689674,
0.0583500341,
0.0056230328,
-0.0046660826,
-0.003131558,
-0.006006273,
-0.0140615301,
-0.0641364753,
-0.0248887148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00835v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00835v1 | Calibrated Seq2seq Models for Efficient and Generalizable Ultra-fine Entity Typing | 2023-11-01T20:39:12 | 2023-11-01T20:39:12 | Yanlin Feng, Adithya Pratapa, David R Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ultra-fine entity typing plays a crucial role in information extraction by
predicting fine-grained semantic types for entity mentions in text. However,
this task poses significant challenges due to the massive number of entity
types in the output space. The current state-of-the-art approaches, based on
standard multi-label classifiers or cross-encoder models, suffer from poor
generalization performance or inefficient inference. In this paper, we present
CASENT, a seq2seq model designed for ultra-fine entity typing that predicts
ultra-fine types with calibrated confidence scores. Our model takes an entity
mention as input and employs constrained beam search to generate multiple types
autoregressively. The raw sequence probabilities associated with the predicted
types are then transformed into confidence scores using a novel calibration
method. We conduct extensive experiments on the UFET dataset which contains
over 10k types. Our method outperforms the previous state-of-the-art in terms
of F1 score and calibration error, while achieving an inference speedup of over
50 times. Additionally, we demonstrate the generalization capabilities of our
model by evaluating it in zero-shot and few-shot settings on five specialized
domain entity typing datasets that are unseen during training. Remarkably, our
model outperforms large language models with 10 times more parameters in the
zero-shot setting, and when fine-tuned on 50 examples, it significantly
outperforms ChatGPT on all datasets. Our code, models and demo are available at
https://github.com/yanlinf/CASENT. | [
0.0368929282,
0.0420571864,
0.0225808769,
0.0067118793,
0.0316139609,
0.0215654895,
0.0008381656,
0.0084951455,
0.0071829851,
-0.0648180693,
-0.0107334908,
-0.0040256237,
-0.0277391467,
0.0586332791,
0.056729205,
-0.0077275247,
0.044747971,
0.0083674332,
0.0120844953,
-0.0165928807,
0.0188104119,
-0.0040855519,
0.0017229943,
0.0483778529,
-0.0058878921,
0.0219801795,
-0.0023454404,
0.0159923527,
0.0118056508,
-0.0264348779,
0.0668755323,
0.0814553648,
0.0318896398,
0.0679678172,
0.0000021019,
-0.0306089111,
-0.0172381774,
0.0011991607,
-0.0199519638,
0.0337763689,
-0.0376433954,
-0.0285418946,
0.0222833306,
0.0217829738,
-0.0007295441,
-0.0428466462,
0.0570342094,
0.0268623102,
-0.0016475486,
0.0618300624,
-0.0089111356,
-0.0402383395,
0.0232798867,
-0.0290382318,
0.0227755588,
-0.0561351813,
0.045999784,
-0.0669541657,
0.0013615248,
0.060598515,
0.0179792531,
0.0129728569,
-0.0158286318,
0.0265548192,
0.0224459823,
0.0394442044,
-0.0557950549,
0.0056727398,
0.0102440771,
0.0426272526,
0.0454483666,
-0.006728054,
0.0246366374,
-0.0073545743,
-0.00317581,
-0.0323995128,
0.0042970353,
-0.0338899679,
-0.0395551249,
-0.0216281507,
-0.0039703315,
0.0095181726,
0.0228247754,
0.0047700084,
-0.0129763596,
-0.0231402311,
0.0311541632,
-0.0308843832,
0.0149300471,
0.0098018888,
-0.0310551897,
-0.0714938566,
0.0202933252,
0.0202800464,
-0.0476856381,
-0.0171773713,
-0.0430309922,
-0.0116951056,
0.0270658508,
0.0069130985,
-0.002522517,
0.0258839075,
0.0092366273,
0.0513535663,
-0.0404083617,
0.0090083219,
-0.005363706,
-0.0215628278,
0.0231530741,
-0.034366034,
-0.0324159004,
-0.0063587045,
-0.0615118481,
0.0345299058,
0.00603471,
-0.0119997412,
-0.066037111,
0.0022208674,
0.0210913587,
0.0273661911,
0.024709871,
0.0084537473,
-0.0295110904,
0.0008253091,
0.0047102491,
0.0190819371,
-0.0548822246,
0.0063553089,
-0.0082828077,
-0.027572589,
0.007829031,
-0.0126262149,
0.0064564818,
-0.0736081973,
0.0286272988,
0.0471849777,
0.0284397602,
-0.0871576741,
-0.0494744144,
-0.0100914231,
-0.0522436984,
-0.0365685262,
-0.0403403752,
-0.0569700599,
-0.0111330412,
0.0397114009,
-0.0111967223,
-0.045606643,
0.0160531048,
-0.0251152422,
-0.0514511578,
0.0830343291,
-0.0575392805,
-0.0196930654,
0.0151673304,
-0.0142930206,
0.005237021,
0.0412084162,
0.0671548992,
0.0074133114,
0.0474465713,
-0.0304796323,
0.0168088526,
0.0922916457,
-0.0107283099,
-0.006521394,
0.0131305559,
-0.0100959549,
-0.0219572466,
0.0342942625,
0.024705492,
0.0527473167,
-0.0045914273,
-0.0247197207,
0.0435315147,
0.0101056313,
0.0285825692,
0.0032836255,
0.0631826594,
0.01044254,
0.0173094049,
-0.0166114923,
-0.0136370575,
0.0187130403,
-0.0042545805,
0.0440141112,
0.0771917924,
0.0244669896,
-0.041285105,
-0.0064766486,
-0.0039693792,
-0.0008832781,
-0.0114230737,
-0.011603578,
0.0458117686,
0.0203775037,
-0.0780309662,
0.0690596625,
0.0286124181,
-0.0183974653,
-0.0200229324,
-0.0175973885,
0.038636487,
0.0341741852,
0.022419095,
-0.0362583697,
-0.0235578306,
-0.0268202275,
-0.0238625947,
0.030334428,
0.0402725562,
-0.0100482795,
-0.0110686449,
-0.0341410972,
-0.0267604962,
0.0305296369,
0.0415385626,
-0.0072143376,
0.0221362077,
0.033793088,
0.0154540846,
-0.0667334422,
-0.0110158231,
0.0288269054,
-0.0426975004,
-0.0514024198,
0.0152269052,
0.0128712868,
-0.0399383157,
0.0266895127,
-0.0087898485,
0.0041846028,
0.0245053619,
-0.0164625756,
-0.0126536898,
-0.0482559502,
0.0243241843,
-0.0234427527,
0.00321122,
-0.0183951426,
-0.0120405611,
-0.0271521453,
-0.0275060721,
-0.0332467109,
-0.0479554012,
0.0047547333,
0.0168157443,
-0.052253861,
-0.016214706,
0.0178396329,
0.0118455375,
-0.0297312587,
0.0584940575,
0.0178991277,
0.029267652,
-0.0167266522,
-0.0420343727,
0.0102903424,
-0.0164276063,
-0.0423111692,
-0.0072932178,
0.0004760499,
0.0012039318,
0.041054856,
0.0123991035,
-0.0498330668,
-0.0252389498,
-0.1150508523,
-0.0009030288,
-0.0314209275,
0.0179467686,
-0.0363514572,
0.0470620394,
-0.0168431327,
-0.006431561,
-0.0153597128,
-0.0325948335,
-0.0536029153,
0.0441699289,
0.0736155063,
-0.0107357819,
-0.0092026526,
-0.0403735265,
-0.0196851343,
-0.0529297255,
0.0416231826,
-0.0085207373,
-0.0233822614,
-0.0531972498,
0.0706796497,
-0.0152599094,
-0.0065243174,
0.021879252,
-0.0076127495,
0.0083277859,
0.0263136756,
-0.0124216713,
0.0598604381,
0.0283925682,
0.0010585752,
-0.0623158216,
0.0276278183,
-0.0395973511,
0.0223721508,
-0.0247796625,
0.0019976243,
-0.0162109714,
0.0268652141,
0.0050803577,
0.1030794531,
-0.0621624552,
-0.0006998255,
-0.0852637663,
0.0308062639,
0.0313871093,
0.0271777641,
0.0072246976,
0.0566963702,
-0.0116337892,
-0.0127967382,
0.0095963683,
0.0254396927,
0.0734300092,
-0.0377393924,
0.004594245,
0.0316768251,
-0.0001078444,
-0.0417358503,
0.0229568854,
0.0071137319,
-0.0143249109,
0.0347283408,
-0.0514425784,
-0.0497238114,
0.033518102,
0.0174714942,
-0.0215810481,
0.0571339913,
0.0504017062,
0.0211274121,
-0.0107165361,
-0.0662461817,
-0.0180615019,
-0.0496974587,
-0.063784115,
0.0423116311,
-0.0096091731,
-0.0281034019,
-0.044120729,
0.0244172756,
-0.0319854766,
0.048128102,
-0.0380872265,
-0.0104245907,
-0.0563211516,
0.0530222692,
0.0691143349,
-0.0274188519,
0.00508556,
-0.0341704823,
-0.0071163559,
0.0270048138,
-0.0191716123,
0.0480994731,
-0.0021210359,
-0.0318859853,
0.0403907746,
-0.068010442,
-0.0559561737,
0.0165743064,
0.1014105156,
-0.0306416657,
0.0062198723,
0.1151759624,
-0.0004655357,
-0.0082106292,
0.0233655386,
0.048822429,
0.0497726761,
0.0380262658,
0.013083267,
-0.0931506157,
-0.0952166915,
0.0136285191,
0.0035084127,
0.021782672,
-0.0703731999,
0.0392550044,
-0.0601259694,
-0.0196506847,
-0.0067035612,
-0.0415870957,
-0.0362690836,
0.0065690451,
0.0298884269,
-0.0601363294,
-0.0009452752,
0.0050963028,
-0.0246218387,
0.037467178,
0.055938784,
-0.0049429792,
-0.0577810816,
0.0304094944,
-0.0759671479,
0.0376347862,
0.047379069,
0.0375113785,
-0.033543136,
-0.0057821078,
-0.0264103319,
-0.03911639,
-0.0358326547,
0.0166374408,
0.0575972646,
-0.0791179538,
-0.0136408219,
-0.0026338173,
0.0342402309,
-0.0005307372,
0.0221476741,
0.0077487696,
0.0192069765,
0.0207560044,
-0.0204291157,
-0.0163984653,
-0.0520687103,
-0.0027235895,
0.071715422,
0.027065115,
-0.0536412075,
-0.008719923,
-0.0643566251,
-0.0131631764,
-0.0303537939,
-0.0052310922,
0.0032642593,
-0.0232246406,
-0.0115776816,
-0.0303024855,
-0.0587714426,
0.0625814721,
0.0002848405,
-0.0197398402,
0.0147164995,
-0.0054255729,
0.0055931928,
-0.0534496568,
-0.0043070554,
-0.011691222,
0.032958705,
-0.0139710186,
-0.0017895338,
0.023120949,
-0.005172275,
-0.0598416254,
0.0065897554,
-0.0978488773,
-0.0728363395,
-0.0151333548,
0.0290022232,
0.0106660053,
0.0087276669,
0.0016495375,
-0.048709739,
0.0587277412,
0.0681865439,
-0.0367314853,
-0.0262726601,
0.0183243155,
-0.0059302929,
-0.0444594361,
0.03132369,
-0.0366986208,
-0.0064348304,
-0.0141860573,
0.0655677691,
-0.0532724708,
-0.0605081134,
0.0093203411,
-0.0350868702,
0.0650335401,
-0.0174576379,
-0.0191693343,
-0.0264022611,
0.0227389541,
0.0454561003,
0.0052440902,
-0.0268220697,
-0.0128039094,
-0.0223132987,
-0.0132324798,
-0.0268785153,
0.0147944195,
0.0006543286,
0.0675274357,
-0.0717758089,
0.0159400329,
0.012629197,
0.0378140248,
0.0397866927,
-0.0742915496,
0.0016759869,
0.0704582632,
0.0496777259,
0.0461407565,
-0.0529235564,
0.0069011115,
0.0355205573,
0.0572826639,
0.0247720592,
-0.0062234486,
-0.0203115568,
0.0109167565,
-0.0446995199,
0.0350250788,
0.0557882302,
0.008487097,
0.0137676802,
-0.0022123917,
-0.0227852017,
-0.0326614007,
0.0566057861,
-0.0106269438,
0.0328331254,
0.025863912,
0.0337161385,
-0.0609033965,
0.0007067029,
0.0628922954,
0.023312334,
0.0692244768,
0.0142661734,
-0.0174331013,
-0.0260162409,
0.0335263535,
0.0361436382,
0.0113811539,
-0.0061016669,
-0.0128144352,
-0.0647917688,
-0.0615402572,
0.04997807,
-0.0242836121,
-0.0477352738,
0.0090924222,
0.0436939336,
0.03354875,
0.0096910074,
-0.0337363929,
-0.0452847891,
-0.0459112301,
0.0293167308,
-0.0272965804,
-0.0199371558,
-6.986660142e-33,
-0.0152752614,
-0.0188123882,
0.0142221246,
0.0194485802,
0.0071562086,
0.0226186141,
0.0130468505,
-0.0304043535,
-0.0106971292,
-0.0007568294,
-0.0220278576,
0.0111073107,
0.0107967351,
0.0151616111,
0.0295386035,
-0.010303284,
0.0722235143,
0.0163799543,
-0.0079285149,
0.0084294146,
0.0009822125,
0.0602754205,
0.1185786203,
-0.0444568247,
0.0236459598,
-0.0027014539,
-0.0053083799,
-0.0254793018,
0.0410722978,
0.0824696124,
0.005179863,
0.0220401008,
-0.0070376494,
-0.0280446131,
0.0262071621,
-0.0073944479,
-0.0927101746,
-0.0097007351,
-0.036665827,
-0.0141982278,
0.0071640452,
-0.0434236377,
0.0260245893,
-0.034053497,
-0.0515772812,
-0.0178758949,
0.0419193245,
0.0203790292,
-0.0140118096,
-0.0810044035,
-0.0350026526,
0.0597246252,
0.0154632842,
0.0353535973,
0.0144711323,
0.0182342529,
0.0388915725,
0.0067391358,
-0.0556033775,
0.0099168457,
0.0238547865,
0.0620047338,
-0.0193282962,
-0.0080205454,
0.0054798406,
0.0157539658,
0.0171687827,
-0.0097808149,
0.0068924618,
-0.00808708,
0.0220667757,
0.0153566748,
-0.0009093327,
0.0751365796,
0.0528558195,
-0.0117506152,
-0.0708434805,
0.0267105475,
0.0140960971,
0.0320207924,
-0.0001027835,
-0.0287240651,
-0.0432355516,
-0.0072023664,
-0.0472543575,
-0.0305059068,
-0.0200516582,
-0.0126894219,
-0.0058357599,
0.0241658408,
0.0162663721,
0.0448765196,
0.0126244891,
-0.0228389744,
-0.0726017132,
0.0259544738,
-0.0240232088,
-0.01349035,
0.0065796962,
0.0234847199,
-0.0387209244,
-0.0520402417,
0.0247804783,
-0.0350270644,
0.0120944167,
0.0199444052,
0.0445324443,
-0.0132072223,
-0.0784871429,
-0.0037362166,
0.0047660666,
-0.0072705918,
-0.0428200848,
0.0086847367,
0.0324331708,
0.0070660426,
0.0046252734,
0.0238772742,
0.0315067805,
0.0194508526,
-0.0418910757,
-0.0244488083,
0.0493179448,
0.0615510009,
0.0061186282,
-0.0125296544,
-0.0302533396,
-0.0227187034,
0.0057170605,
-0.040742591,
-0.0079071494,
0.0086808642,
2.846e-7,
0.0276322551,
0.0794479698,
-0.0253629386,
0.0162879527,
-0.0161679182,
0.0815122128,
0.0395180583,
0.0714277029,
-0.0083346311,
-0.025290696,
0.0200476702,
-0.0015566619,
0.0245328434,
0.0024269863,
-0.1264761388,
-0.0398929603,
-0.0567558035,
0.0509920679,
-0.0622491352,
-0.001671717,
0.0200400297,
0.1006858721,
0.0079703573,
-0.001974521,
0.007490539,
-0.0496721007,
0.0607106015,
0.0260766819,
-0.0096055549,
0.0438646898,
0.0077139372,
0.0210114866,
0.00933134,
0.0169820432,
-0.0012792459,
0.0139860427,
0.0282492153,
0.0419853181,
-0.0242305845,
0.0010155304,
-0.0068486594,
-0.0041698497,
-0.0209929012,
-0.0236817002,
0.0514683314,
-0.0295584798,
-0.0016973205,
-0.0170992222,
-0.0140856784,
0.0021263827,
0.0156770144,
-0.0129774027,
-0.0107405586,
-0.0000949057,
0.0327789336,
0.0126868114,
-0.0251801834,
-0.0539562069,
0.0185190812,
0.0313747004,
0.0042656222,
-0.0142120747,
-0.0290479716,
-0.0329724848,
0.0038312518,
-0.081143789,
0.0077392221,
3.100975908e-34,
0.0110957175,
0.0021761663,
-0.0021950928,
0.046539899,
0.0180951301,
-0.0258707944,
-0.0653535053,
0.0041904179,
0.0280060917,
-0.050794635,
-0.0265543126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00790v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00790v2 | Construction Artifacts in Metaphor Identification Datasets | 2023-11-01T19:21:55 | 2023-11-15T19:11:40 | Joanne Boisson, Luis Espinosa-Anke, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Metaphor identification aims at understanding whether a given expression is
used figuratively in context. However, in this paper we show how existing
metaphor identification datasets can be gamed by fully ignoring the potential
metaphorical expression or the context in which it occurs. We test this
hypothesis in a variety of datasets and settings, and show that metaphor
identification systems based on language models without complete information
can be competitive with those using the full context. This is due to the
construction procedures to build such datasets, which introduce unwanted biases
for positive and negative classes. Finally, we test the same hypothesis on
datasets that are carefully sampled from natural corpora and where this bias is
not present, making these datasets more challenging and reliable. | [
0.0350370109,
0.0467763022,
-0.043241784,
0.0425933748,
-0.0264174677,
0.017545281,
-0.0069681299,
-0.00531229,
-0.0067813681,
-0.054322727,
-0.0161840916,
0.0016548194,
0.0321426429,
-0.0258963834,
0.0085665816,
-0.0389563069,
0.0151567515,
0.0417563356,
-0.0096117528,
0.0008768997,
-0.0564397015,
0.0270967856,
0.0026751361,
0.0552359819,
-0.0189087633,
-0.0120780617,
0.0326658785,
0.036048755,
-0.0027394546,
-0.050302811,
0.0093054567,
-0.0030727433,
-0.0051316707,
-0.002076851,
0.0000017677,
-0.053867463,
0.0124520045,
-0.0398791507,
0.0125559811,
-0.0218672603,
0.1273179203,
-0.0128349923,
0.0290218163,
-0.0164992064,
0.0203842353,
-0.013951933,
0.0396776982,
0.0413978994,
0.0020166624,
0.0166671835,
-0.0077335625,
-0.0328273885,
-0.0684724748,
0.0187352616,
-0.0316743404,
0.0083328038,
0.0456795879,
0.0155782625,
0.0107257674,
-0.066051051,
-0.0491341464,
0.0151621839,
-0.0035792142,
0.0906744301,
-0.0478497818,
0.0173474513,
-0.050376188,
0.030539358,
-0.0141138565,
0.0552822649,
0.03267603,
-0.0602975376,
-0.0135928784,
-0.0183486249,
-0.024118999,
0.0672301948,
-0.0020774549,
0.0080979913,
-0.0171534363,
0.0352946967,
0.0434393361,
0.0061702677,
0.0101910131,
0.0141793815,
-0.012721437,
-0.0025975548,
-0.000128884,
0.0135771036,
-0.0138719417,
-0.0401202738,
-0.0194353294,
-0.0386193432,
-0.0176072381,
-0.0238013379,
0.0195019264,
0.0279700924,
-0.035331361,
-0.026801195,
0.0007093729,
-0.0482897237,
0.0289705656,
0.030495435,
-0.0225626789,
0.0563856028,
-0.03009158,
-0.0201714654,
0.0294939876,
0.0596668422,
-0.0366549902,
-0.0448319167,
-0.0563318878,
0.0216589589,
-0.0448793024,
0.0200833771,
0.0064722598,
-0.0149150603,
-0.0297125112,
-0.0177539848,
-0.0386754721,
-0.0149117457,
-0.0603037514,
0.0158268828,
-0.0245643314,
0.0036461109,
-0.0688573271,
-0.0362634584,
-0.0434578732,
0.0443466939,
-0.0841317326,
-0.0868061408,
0.0095040249,
0.0263293702,
0.0205905605,
-0.0232882947,
0.0459081382,
0.0719755739,
0.0219963528,
-0.0198926441,
-0.0376351848,
-0.0311162751,
0.0334046669,
0.0007015769,
-0.0269462094,
-0.0136129446,
0.0353614613,
0.0039420687,
0.027897507,
-0.0637955517,
-0.0037776823,
0.0012617186,
-0.0509195626,
0.0674395859,
-0.0179199819,
0.0125044566,
-0.0177748576,
0.0053627538,
-0.0944869965,
0.0469571687,
0.0314751975,
0.0081354259,
0.0430152416,
0.0091934828,
-0.0333581157,
-0.0069227526,
-0.0250673778,
0.0291795861,
-0.0740292296,
0.0102293491,
-0.0035963852,
0.0450956523,
-0.0007532764,
0.0406537615,
-0.0179453753,
-0.008583067,
0.0340497866,
0.0640968084,
-0.0014968108,
0.0062257834,
0.0599821322,
0.0226617213,
0.0026520912,
0.0090132905,
0.005334585,
-0.074808687,
0.0315714143,
-0.0233639907,
-0.0433309525,
0.0321717151,
-0.013980845,
0.0247285087,
-0.0636847839,
-0.032023374,
-0.0255617797,
-0.0184124764,
0.0358891003,
0.0019973065,
-0.0060594906,
0.0136052119,
0.0372008011,
-0.0041087139,
-0.0203412119,
-0.003519431,
0.0099150073,
0.0205537751,
0.052734375,
-0.0569617674,
0.0066211959,
-0.0079395538,
0.0154990191,
0.0195592977,
-0.0070614871,
-0.0086649964,
0.0126562538,
-0.0231185723,
0.028563112,
0.0003509801,
0.0251820553,
0.0152597278,
-0.0248752218,
0.0473239645,
-0.013720572,
-0.0293783676,
-0.0275214538,
0.0471904539,
-0.0019040232,
-0.0083531523,
0.0254943874,
0.0185534935,
0.055498708,
-0.0195787549,
-0.0269304216,
-0.0304466039,
0.0102812396,
-0.0521098562,
-0.0329568386,
0.0996131375,
-0.0320378989,
-0.0079885395,
0.0461912192,
-0.0765957385,
0.0208659023,
0.0170649532,
0.0202750098,
-0.023060862,
0.0523663536,
-0.0191506185,
0.0999387428,
-0.0188005641,
0.007005123,
-0.0413152277,
0.0411649458,
0.0303344801,
0.0515882708,
0.0183591265,
0.0648135766,
0.0015617815,
-0.0124112228,
0.0201537199,
0.0757085681,
-0.0089016147,
-0.0093686609,
0.0088591315,
-0.0151928328,
-0.0334956124,
-0.0713478699,
-0.0429091975,
-0.0028093637,
-0.0615291186,
0.0178041942,
-0.002161545,
-0.0120346174,
0.0508429334,
-0.0556692518,
-0.0648126528,
-0.0034463992,
0.0309302341,
-0.0244063884,
-0.0298941899,
0.0048416154,
0.0202396903,
-0.0608265474,
-0.0090541421,
0.0021993881,
0.0453066863,
-0.0462210849,
0.0705679283,
-0.0281459931,
0.0036575163,
0.0320717655,
0.026234841,
-0.0417103879,
-0.0154819004,
-0.0317024775,
-0.0345483497,
-0.0005393955,
0.050323002,
0.0472479463,
0.0001620394,
-0.0310722943,
0.0298198331,
0.0794725642,
-0.0234412514,
-0.0088695977,
-0.022625532,
0.024414828,
-0.0007534721,
-0.0068731988,
-0.0800920948,
-0.0074919369,
0.0509517007,
0.0565223433,
-0.0141609637,
-0.0083924346,
0.0558327734,
-0.0166525654,
0.0074197645,
0.0246565081,
0.0402116515,
-0.0181119014,
0.0053986018,
0.006486021,
0.0168658756,
0.0429792888,
-0.0206662416,
-0.0206952896,
-0.0100406539,
-0.0107552912,
-0.0323047228,
0.0526866317,
-0.0180634726,
0.0235988013,
0.0488591008,
0.0129162306,
0.0095886486,
-0.0602549091,
0.016623605,
-0.0189947803,
0.046440877,
-0.0391414389,
-0.0136754615,
-0.0183450934,
-0.0125716552,
-0.0285478067,
-0.0546922311,
-0.035256125,
0.0105333468,
-0.0189469606,
0.0014512041,
-0.0370192826,
-0.0208120979,
-0.0255705677,
0.0181732941,
0.001714801,
-0.0045404071,
-0.0365022495,
0.0217742082,
0.0217788555,
0.0052275518,
0.0008032925,
0.036423333,
0.0373494327,
0.0032002758,
-0.0598416254,
-0.0075208396,
-0.0220281109,
0.0008614844,
0.0251432098,
-0.0349283032,
0.0107875299,
-0.0018707676,
0.0261236988,
-0.0127384169,
-0.0116785197,
0.0533269793,
0.038779214,
-0.0092276698,
0.0384065211,
0.0114412243,
0.003713601,
0.05114628,
-0.0490808003,
-0.0851133317,
-0.0689364374,
0.0234712511,
0.0099678598,
-0.0542526804,
-0.0504574887,
-0.0190361701,
-0.0982223973,
0.0131573454,
-0.0064364225,
-0.0226143189,
0.0229584146,
0.0039376952,
0.023070164,
-0.0075332047,
-0.0234302692,
-0.0427482165,
-0.0104734292,
0.0234147217,
-0.0186196547,
0.0240033474,
-0.0658194944,
0.0095499838,
-0.0263944902,
0.0473975018,
-0.1025882289,
0.051884342,
-0.0236270372,
-0.0057984344,
-0.0328475423,
-0.0497624427,
-0.0206279028,
0.0097189667,
0.0011497664,
0.0025570141,
0.0063849692,
0.0107665043,
0.0182452761,
-0.0383939743,
-0.0224817395,
0.0310201328,
0.0480689146,
-0.0144045651,
-0.0105520999,
-0.026460696,
-0.003198301,
0.0079485709,
0.1031303927,
0.0372127295,
-0.0320416838,
0.0317058638,
-0.0134111457,
-0.0109071219,
0.008446198,
0.0198267587,
-0.024303982,
-0.0700012594,
0.0156565458,
-0.0600228347,
-0.0187184308,
0.022305334,
0.0521169528,
0.0551151931,
0.0255767461,
-0.080096297,
-0.0148029272,
-0.0964957476,
0.0334941149,
-0.014252305,
0.0055320165,
-0.0044499557,
-0.0318729356,
0.0820071772,
-0.0406030715,
-0.0067954953,
0.0594475158,
-0.0383711942,
-0.0567230545,
-0.0039751059,
-0.0178391002,
0.0140902819,
0.0074201119,
-0.0002196468,
-0.0192836579,
0.0525623709,
0.0666705295,
-0.0301711354,
0.0257180724,
0.0119897062,
0.0119931549,
0.0129588293,
0.043318592,
-0.0088255173,
0.0369578712,
0.0605522804,
0.0028462955,
-0.0332386605,
0.0910836682,
0.0244738813,
-0.0048180209,
0.0271496139,
-0.0205898453,
-0.1002957001,
-0.0017276781,
-0.0267908033,
-0.0155214174,
-0.0466438048,
0.0124223772,
0.0114393821,
0.0421623662,
0.0330074765,
-0.0701171309,
-0.0380166024,
-0.0121905645,
0.0451194942,
0.0573341288,
0.0107729835,
0.0654402822,
0.0237186179,
-0.036415413,
0.003864527,
-0.022702368,
-0.0344664119,
-0.0328528844,
0.0150155779,
0.0061285174,
-0.0136889266,
0.023801649,
0.0102656353,
-0.0298811644,
0.0138562918,
0.0214331392,
-0.0119091934,
0.0371083803,
0.0239277016,
0.0422251448,
-0.0499610864,
0.0195578039,
-0.0189594235,
-0.0004212469,
-0.0011230757,
0.0300568473,
-0.0216594972,
-0.0213411897,
0.0091834143,
0.0057105883,
-0.0358269177,
0.0058171325,
-0.0012771109,
-0.0501627587,
0.0540900566,
0.0188757926,
-0.0456815027,
-0.0052858517,
0.0090199998,
0.0326151773,
0.0202021357,
0.0455366075,
0.0266486593,
-0.0779269412,
-0.0717974529,
0.0574662089,
-0.0112520382,
0.0331515521,
0.0103696026,
0.0000570128,
0.0285678841,
0.0238599516,
0.0091050612,
-0.0625319704,
0.0055693667,
-0.056593731,
0.0236816835,
-0.0460952558,
-5.298144057e-33,
-0.0290886071,
-0.0010414091,
-0.0304999575,
-0.0307938494,
0.0045265676,
0.034642715,
-0.0328094363,
-0.0127157969,
0.01224632,
-0.0049883546,
0.0001167211,
-0.0205221307,
-0.0009770282,
-0.0148614412,
0.0196800213,
0.0106472857,
0.0114488965,
0.0137497904,
-0.056358926,
-0.0506558083,
0.0936056077,
-0.0027233069,
0.0803042129,
-0.0169156138,
-0.0078666918,
0.0275724083,
0.01685814,
-0.0285558254,
0.0622023605,
0.0344679654,
-0.0174531788,
0.0891637281,
0.0243827682,
0.0553443469,
0.0111476881,
-0.0362645611,
-0.0454448685,
-0.0456016213,
0.0531523414,
0.0292909294,
0.0333339386,
-0.033979021,
0.0565560237,
0.0040789777,
-0.0453318879,
0.0152863283,
0.0610867403,
-0.023332458,
0.0075055785,
-0.0240873955,
-0.0406851247,
0.0110178078,
-0.0105167311,
-0.0276925564,
0.0083168503,
0.0172967985,
0.0190013908,
0.0690878928,
-0.0709620714,
0.0206898563,
-0.0283019245,
-0.0302410778,
-0.006039978,
0.0180768743,
0.0439380109,
0.1035823449,
0.0249355976,
-0.013081491,
-0.0170180518,
0.0019979754,
0.046947971,
-0.0023720197,
0.029213639,
0.05168299,
0.0905683711,
-0.0474036708,
0.0080781607,
-0.0136434902,
0.0694098622,
-0.0189227369,
0.0433493517,
-0.0131880157,
-0.0549660996,
0.0023228154,
-0.0379090793,
-0.0535733923,
0.0097816978,
-0.0088662906,
0.0283112433,
-0.0298738014,
-0.0030973845,
0.0376716778,
0.0023555285,
-0.0208706073,
-0.0255442578,
-0.0201552249,
-0.0147846742,
0.0303756613,
0.0038234834,
-0.007001427,
-0.0207412131,
-0.0194209628,
0.021782741,
0.0228480808,
0.0543231927,
-0.0101492209,
0.0301280487,
0.022051366,
-0.0762230307,
-0.0028314304,
-0.0161579493,
-0.0212834198,
-0.0461711586,
-0.0510594994,
0.0227650348,
0.0301405527,
0.0027107955,
-0.0235685594,
0.0272895675,
-0.02130864,
-0.0233230777,
0.054944329,
-0.0567271002,
0.0382438377,
-0.0133656096,
-0.0203968324,
-0.0145335542,
-0.0418111309,
0.0464781262,
-0.0528855696,
0.0101750055,
-0.0356135219,
2.517e-7,
0.0084466534,
0.0051542907,
-0.0075044911,
0.0363424793,
-0.0033642843,
0.0296812765,
-0.028926013,
0.0186815187,
-0.0197467115,
0.0031176815,
0.022267364,
0.0048298719,
0.0139754545,
0.0425657108,
-0.1210672632,
0.0714489743,
-0.0315298364,
0.019588232,
-0.0510663204,
0.0070488937,
0.0472006574,
0.0544654317,
0.0607716851,
-0.0098574637,
-0.0180329252,
-0.0862331986,
0.0270628259,
-0.0868089572,
0.0477378815,
0.0400513038,
0.02517947,
0.0096439393,
0.0039392905,
0.037980698,
0.0319009051,
0.0312434342,
0.0039711562,
-0.0068683885,
-0.0127284909,
-0.0066063814,
-0.0467766337,
-0.0477642007,
-0.0244986974,
-0.0394241661,
0.0587234311,
-0.0206626747,
-0.0333223231,
-0.0266740881,
0.006852801,
0.0192904342,
0.061187841,
0.0130040897,
-0.0500897206,
0.0195764713,
0.0366497301,
-0.0289040264,
0.0073531382,
-0.0726879239,
0.0286406633,
0.0274039526,
-0.0381499454,
0.0038253767,
0.0364631265,
-0.0052566109,
-0.0147597129,
-0.1064079702,
-0.0004492521,
1.84458011e-34,
0.0128557682,
-0.0079539092,
-0.0009834955,
0.0252390001,
0.0713313967,
-0.0229479112,
0.0472115725,
-0.0006447979,
-0.003687442,
0.0032950442,
0.0181772672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04913v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04913v2 | An Improved Transformer-based Model for Detecting Phishing, Spam, and Ham: A Large Language Model Approach | 2023-11-01T18:41:50 | 2023-11-12T16:32:16 | Suhaima Jamal, Hayden Wimmer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Phishing and spam detection is long standing challenge that has been the
subject of much academic research. Large Language Models (LLM) have vast
potential to transform society and provide new and innovative approaches to
solve well-established challenges. Phishing and spam have caused financial
hardships and lost time and resources to email users all over the world and
frequently serve as an entry point for ransomware threat actors. While
detection approaches exist, especially heuristic-based approaches, LLMs offer
the potential to venture into a new unexplored area for understanding and
solving this challenge. LLMs have rapidly altered the landscape from business,
consumers, and throughout academia and demonstrate transformational potential
for the potential of society. Based on this, applying these new and innovative
approaches to email detection is a rational next step in academic research. In
this work, we present IPSDM, our model based on fine-tuning the BERT family of
models to specifically detect phishing and spam email. We demonstrate our
fine-tuned version, IPSDM, is able to better classify emails in both unbalanced
and balanced datasets. This work serves as an important first step towards
employing LLMs to improve the security of our information systems. | [
0.0735375285,
0.0103074322,
-0.0087363431,
0.0616406202,
-0.0644218773,
0.0046930299,
0.0325731263,
0.0315015875,
0.0354670063,
-0.0820149779,
-0.01174263,
-0.0302750822,
-0.017763637,
0.0142391967,
0.0095296968,
-0.043095354,
0.0104322853,
-0.0414313823,
0.0139314905,
0.0014407514,
0.0036659206,
-0.0025624379,
0.0184532646,
0.0155945551,
0.0213492028,
0.022828564,
-0.009560531,
0.020957388,
0.0399722867,
0.0018675067,
0.0447103083,
0.0313996747,
0.0055295001,
0.053515669,
0.0000018539,
-0.0675595403,
-0.029090941,
0.0084097162,
-0.0277580824,
0.055194702,
0.0420333184,
-0.0159867927,
-0.0227384511,
0.0425072052,
-0.020367546,
0.0383662693,
0.0136340996,
0.0788137838,
0.0760447979,
0.085458681,
-0.0279802643,
-0.0374654718,
0.0646911561,
-0.006402439,
0.0026377924,
0.0275764335,
0.0775926933,
-0.0325218923,
-0.0011769515,
0.0736602098,
0.0031552464,
-0.0093296664,
-0.0427161343,
-0.0280833412,
-0.0147516169,
0.0362943038,
-0.0468376763,
-0.0117698386,
-0.0324836709,
-0.0089637749,
-0.0868776366,
-0.0174382254,
0.0190192088,
0.0185162667,
0.0378659852,
0.0194443464,
-0.0066628424,
0.0776419863,
-0.0213070884,
-0.0081922794,
0.0056973505,
0.0018755533,
0.0306057222,
0.0563114844,
-0.0517584011,
0.0347638614,
0.0239102449,
-0.0393826403,
-0.0223746542,
-0.0603826419,
0.0018791992,
-0.0368775688,
0.0467654467,
0.0234312173,
0.0390458591,
-0.018201381,
-0.0283760205,
-0.0593146347,
0.0470276549,
-0.1014354303,
-0.0118561601,
0.011480609,
-0.0024446759,
0.0033906065,
0.0016547198,
0.0142090321,
-0.0195491444,
0.0298866723,
-0.0189938862,
0.0127705531,
-0.0485075153,
-0.0270765238,
-0.0700953603,
0.0367072895,
0.0456306562,
0.021962557,
-0.0829100087,
0.0311255548,
-0.0131716235,
0.020426929,
0.0043723681,
-0.0460736901,
0.0065296069,
0.0102442121,
0.0166844614,
0.0202295482,
0.0010128267,
0.0126868635,
-0.0172825214,
-0.0132215451,
0.0198841132,
0.0495034978,
-0.0431655757,
-0.0634932891,
0.0258675739,
0.0097327279,
0.034230873,
-0.030772591,
-0.0255174823,
-0.0319768451,
-0.0802202821,
0.0152706774,
-0.0091804406,
-0.0494702943,
-0.0569171086,
0.0251114294,
0.0127328904,
-0.0064215516,
-0.0229811799,
-0.0046865786,
-0.0667628869,
0.0144333541,
-0.0090133185,
0.0097391289,
0.05098667,
-0.0162271317,
0.0091163497,
-0.0099700019,
-0.0354005918,
0.0877163038,
0.0395948887,
-0.0379472002,
0.0558758453,
0.0625907034,
-0.0088292807,
0.008059294,
-0.0019066721,
-0.0041736891,
0.0526884124,
-0.0473492518,
-0.0200295113,
0.0532552376,
-0.0181634873,
-0.023947997,
0.0799549073,
0.0374569558,
-0.03041563,
0.0237963386,
0.0061925431,
0.0535781235,
0.0000082225,
-0.0436240509,
-0.0270301662,
-0.0279053114,
-0.0856883749,
-0.0270033535,
-0.0346363783,
0.0238274001,
-0.0282670967,
-0.0060587423,
-0.0084299175,
-0.0120403944,
-0.0171787217,
-0.0025664864,
0.0727568939,
0.0487631485,
-0.0137410667,
0.0733117685,
-0.0025975192,
0.0025528981,
-0.0098476121,
-0.0709904358,
-0.0120465355,
0.0337435417,
0.0361571424,
0.0114916367,
-0.0388347469,
-0.0568449125,
-0.0074007153,
0.0060343142,
-0.012012844,
0.0400936082,
-0.0369340293,
-0.0297515355,
-0.0096189938,
0.0166471601,
-0.0020170053,
-0.0507506393,
-0.0110877603,
-0.0058921129,
0.0368321314,
-0.0191517714,
-0.0163728297,
0.0059791794,
0.01323805,
0.0102134785,
0.0371418856,
0.0231133569,
0.0522449277,
0.012294827,
-0.0115746409,
0.0109959152,
0.033704035,
-0.0460769646,
-0.0445938222,
-0.043516051,
0.0704167187,
0.044009652,
0.0330298916,
0.0051765605,
0.0112838531,
0.0444141589,
-0.023086682,
0.0427780077,
0.0335470214,
-0.0353386998,
0.0009142856,
-0.0491463542,
0.0229136534,
-0.0340053439,
0.0388547555,
-0.0175220091,
0.0637201592,
-0.0059967367,
-0.0071572405,
-0.0243964978,
-0.0184678975,
0.0023331461,
-0.0076518469,
-0.0316983238,
-0.0075308401,
-0.0493120551,
0.0252262373,
0.0226274133,
-0.0046980898,
0.0094101122,
-0.0680208802,
-0.032827761,
-0.0096005518,
-0.0224632118,
0.0352852754,
0.0276282039,
0.0179694984,
-0.006732096,
0.0064195581,
-0.0225777812,
-0.0288680959,
0.0115173208,
-0.0158024877,
0.0336172245,
-0.030439496,
-0.0829070061,
0.0225779917,
-0.0057232147,
-0.0271699652,
0.0309624951,
0.0341646448,
-0.003983913,
-0.0286062378,
-0.0101672988,
-0.0055601769,
-0.0159446727,
-0.0058433213,
-0.0471925847,
-0.0352064744,
-0.0552166551,
0.0071249404,
-0.017031556,
0.065764904,
0.0379937924,
0.0017346378,
0.014606392,
-0.0229838733,
-0.0103391223,
-0.040517278,
-0.0066679735,
-0.0439913236,
-0.0278774444,
0.0750097483,
0.0292456485,
0.0297825448,
-0.0106567787,
-0.0090303691,
-0.0015595445,
0.0186064839,
0.0171542596,
-0.040749833,
-0.0454198159,
0.011872503,
-0.0154818259,
0.0038236901,
-0.0583321601,
0.0613818206,
-0.0547040775,
0.0292257015,
-0.0602518283,
-0.0378164127,
0.003731481,
-0.0170177277,
-0.0040430385,
0.0370416082,
0.0403001495,
-0.0260057021,
0.0315550081,
-0.0090314271,
0.0260175522,
-0.0066251587,
-0.0026302333,
0.0457828902,
0.0225977898,
0.0351440758,
-0.0116025852,
-0.0551803969,
-0.0714259595,
-0.025306629,
-0.0062137758,
-0.0056465426,
-0.0274607949,
-0.0867979527,
0.0372514911,
0.0223449413,
0.0035026832,
0.0000506702,
-0.0269162077,
-0.0023854428,
0.0135497171,
-0.0316921063,
-0.0829064324,
-0.0084603578,
-0.0396141633,
0.0041433596,
0.0294732898,
0.0074080913,
-0.0074621239,
-0.025887182,
0.0094677219,
0.0307022575,
-0.0786212385,
-0.0037869911,
-0.0042254049,
-0.0623431392,
0.0007861502,
-0.0164937302,
0.0929635018,
0.0437193401,
-0.0250345469,
-0.0064360579,
-0.0097245062,
0.0110379737,
-0.0275449418,
0.0081923157,
-0.0180276223,
-0.0016497825,
0.0307469349,
0.0038897325,
-0.0265897587,
0.0012546333,
0.0393719785,
-0.0588273481,
0.0452650711,
0.0105135879,
-0.0380339772,
-0.0597835109,
-0.0630578175,
-0.0442057662,
0.0281972624,
0.0038916904,
-0.0029674594,
-0.0307409205,
-0.0206490681,
-0.0061128093,
-0.0394816175,
-0.0180074275,
0.0035067531,
-0.0629432872,
0.0066670924,
0.0600792542,
0.025568014,
-0.0706319362,
-0.0366474651,
-0.0123161264,
0.012887245,
-0.0416287296,
0.0031232918,
0.0679469407,
-0.0133593446,
0.0060664848,
-0.0268759038,
0.009167172,
-0.0516519696,
-0.0117454082,
0.0081749931,
0.0783340484,
-0.0303872339,
-0.0167019423,
-0.0165592507,
-0.0197361689,
0.0253457688,
0.0689108521,
-0.0208821762,
-0.0415774137,
0.0073945844,
-0.0218311828,
0.0002789487,
0.0658099726,
0.0148805603,
0.0655798465,
-0.0397600755,
-0.0503454506,
-0.0421282239,
0.0448932275,
-0.0085049737,
-0.0060442085,
0.0314945951,
-0.0109615913,
0.0035927084,
0.0061774901,
-0.0558069795,
0.007155919,
-0.0094990116,
0.0776305571,
-0.082780838,
0.0336054377,
0.0304804351,
-0.0427870676,
-0.0119002601,
-0.0183158983,
-0.0481987596,
-0.0366150849,
-0.0136492243,
0.0334280841,
0.0249361116,
-0.0296953227,
-0.0582470596,
-0.0574853495,
0.0608922243,
0.0505018122,
0.0176577121,
-0.0158881638,
0.0460887514,
-0.0677939728,
-0.0064428365,
0.0023896676,
-0.0044859867,
0.0392398797,
0.0591117963,
-0.0534382313,
-0.0304329153,
-0.0259626321,
0.0316269882,
0.0545602851,
0.0363626331,
0.0187899824,
-0.0093597043,
0.0186375752,
-0.0074909334,
-0.0119587258,
-0.0265706331,
0.023894446,
-0.0192514583,
0.0425091237,
0.006776215,
0.0323510878,
0.0635030866,
-0.030424105,
-0.0346579403,
-0.0150207682,
0.0203001443,
-0.00310032,
0.0374039412,
0.06146577,
-0.0096515995,
0.0227466393,
0.0062356018,
0.029671099,
0.0022424802,
-0.0105082579,
0.0064295544,
0.0027315349,
0.0124694807,
-0.050290931,
0.0097735487,
-0.0316135138,
-0.0393429883,
-0.019080732,
0.0226399601,
0.0288835242,
0.0050848578,
0.0324888788,
-0.0320853889,
-0.0031301046,
-0.0342034325,
0.0089548538,
-0.0049857264,
-0.0370478742,
-0.0168541111,
-0.0141798249,
-0.0289352406,
0.0081472946,
0.0474285819,
-0.0436198264,
0.0187973473,
0.0098599903,
-0.0807234794,
-0.0146931177,
0.0001909724,
0.0529918,
-0.022129206,
-0.0407929458,
0.006332675,
-0.0348305032,
-0.0385317951,
0.0342635512,
-0.0417676419,
0.0270486195,
0.0329070911,
0.0234621726,
0.0853107497,
-0.0270733666,
-0.001901334,
-0.0621213876,
0.0135275163,
-0.0184448399,
-0.0484460443,
-0.0231785458,
-5.077393932e-33,
0.0572275221,
-0.0255473871,
-0.0507408269,
0.0334178433,
0.0231125988,
0.0176754631,
0.0393541977,
-0.0246339478,
0.0071954164,
0.0320142321,
-0.0063971523,
0.0018206243,
-0.0023924354,
0.0589215681,
-0.0209816117,
0.033006236,
0.0320674069,
0.0068426565,
-0.0100063477,
0.0202372111,
0.07229992,
0.0278381146,
0.0182254706,
-0.0201137476,
0.0148782413,
-0.0062962156,
-0.065591231,
0.0439856648,
-0.00311043,
0.0593307875,
-0.0296412539,
0.0515026934,
0.0600007065,
-0.0248461273,
0.0093692113,
0.0619369149,
0.0007603246,
0.0129840039,
-0.0225687064,
0.0174588002,
0.0808898881,
-0.0765186399,
0.0699859113,
-0.0055479277,
-0.0298974495,
0.049071651,
0.0206077192,
-0.0113079967,
0.0104727885,
-0.0572405867,
-0.0348761231,
-0.001326099,
-0.0182381887,
0.0004295612,
0.0216539539,
0.0568434224,
0.0064078472,
0.0434208438,
-0.0224844925,
0.0356839821,
0.0691875592,
-0.0287405495,
0.0141001437,
0.0201290511,
-0.0568554252,
0.023368353,
-0.0066461605,
-0.0115267029,
0.0106933387,
-0.0195493381,
0.0010503536,
0.0525426716,
0.0617535561,
0.0421331115,
-0.0040704333,
-0.0196379647,
-0.0608184673,
0.0539103895,
0.0237116478,
0.0090545248,
0.0490986146,
-0.0109131644,
-0.0412929654,
-0.001471345,
-0.0027466915,
0.0154143227,
-0.0275180228,
-0.0194169581,
0.019908011,
-0.0269804709,
-0.0295552704,
-0.0078769522,
0.0200382713,
-0.0557001084,
-0.0296678599,
0.0276933834,
0.0080473768,
0.0288067907,
0.0097076576,
0.0086944671,
0.0064129517,
-0.0556679331,
0.0216402244,
-0.047419928,
-0.0193313546,
-0.0344486609,
0.0349343531,
0.0204793066,
-0.0635932535,
0.0013380437,
0.0459995531,
0.0297167543,
0.0337147415,
0.0832168013,
-0.0287339631,
0.0108070225,
0.0158615597,
0.0006196415,
0.0126275467,
-0.0268319082,
0.0058079939,
0.0343690105,
-0.0251730718,
0.026820058,
-0.004260968,
-0.0091798259,
-0.0433461554,
0.006982205,
0.0401770547,
-0.0718199909,
-0.0165294502,
-0.0378332622,
2.676e-7,
0.0461719185,
0.0573027134,
-0.0055576744,
-0.0164931901,
0.00315122,
0.065763317,
0.0049669403,
0.068508938,
-0.0096817659,
0.0138975298,
-0.0118347509,
0.0024124894,
0.0034851546,
-0.0009941157,
-0.0702591389,
-0.01802787,
-0.0870386064,
-0.0076089976,
-0.0762412548,
0.0543091558,
0.0622133873,
0.0938803628,
0.0327506922,
-0.0595611185,
-0.0103924051,
-0.0504738539,
0.0148165682,
-0.0277282652,
-0.0144950245,
0.0326285027,
0.0536601618,
-0.0158212986,
0.0318887569,
0.0758803859,
-0.0313785039,
0.0022118785,
-0.0411630124,
0.0658751428,
0.0064341789,
0.0488086417,
-0.0212239176,
-0.0327945389,
0.0165859424,
-0.104999043,
0.0345886312,
-0.0481627584,
-0.0408908166,
0.0064451913,
-0.0619111918,
-0.0264343712,
0.0229351427,
-0.0472881533,
-0.0400507674,
0.0428791568,
0.0375761054,
-0.0081828563,
0.024855746,
-0.0548714884,
0.0298771542,
-0.0010914949,
-0.0399612002,
0.0015968386,
-0.0165380687,
-0.023996938,
0.0584137999,
-0.0307012312,
0.0604774244,
2.771845296e-34,
0.0304787662,
-0.0386999026,
-0.0076391627,
0.032634683,
-0.0040106992,
0.0131733632,
0.0278265681,
0.0524032786,
-0.0208511557,
-0.0665466338,
0.0269833822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04911v1 | From Text to Structure: Using Large Language Models to Support the Development of Legal Expert Systems | 2023-11-01T18:31:02 | 2023-11-01T18:31:02 | Samyar Janatian, Hannes Westermann, Jinzhe Tan, Jaromir Savelka, Karim Benyekhlef | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Encoding legislative text in a formal representation is an important
prerequisite to different tasks in the field of AI & Law. For example,
rule-based expert systems focused on legislation can support laypeople in
understanding how legislation applies to them and provide them with helpful
context and information. However, the process of analyzing legislation and
other sources to encode it in the desired formal representation can be
time-consuming and represents a bottleneck in the development of such systems.
Here, we investigate to what degree large language models (LLMs), such as
GPT-4, are able to automatically extract structured representations from
legislation. We use LLMs to create pathways from legislation, according to the
JusticeBot methodology for legal decision support systems, evaluate the
pathways and compare them to manually created pathways. The results are
promising, with 60% of generated pathways being rated as equivalent or better
than manually created ones in a blind comparison. The approach suggests a
promising path to leverage the capabilities of LLMs to ease the costly
development of systems based on symbolic approaches that are transparent and
explainable. | [
0.0498312265,
0.0344915912,
-0.0305658132,
0.0142946402,
-0.0854494348,
0.0248444285,
0.0009437166,
0.0518472195,
0.0178532042,
-0.0560115241,
0.0197337177,
0.0121719316,
-0.0378459282,
0.0304263327,
-0.0101977205,
-0.0708723068,
-0.005173204,
-0.0193829872,
0.0909970179,
0.0109119471,
0.0306190271,
0.0364468843,
0.0272072405,
0.0372102223,
-0.0361139402,
-0.0165070854,
-0.040131744,
-0.0132501954,
-0.0027938252,
-0.005043895,
-0.0231265202,
0.0322857611,
0.0082725715,
0.0367520265,
0.0000019803,
-0.0305481125,
0.0081514604,
0.0135855833,
-0.0082035931,
0.0411395393,
0.0175241902,
-0.0771737993,
-0.0133112743,
0.0146170817,
-0.0201972369,
0.0246418398,
0.0049742558,
0.0053629093,
0.0652660057,
0.077596426,
-0.0239145979,
-0.0553477407,
0.0398003981,
-0.0255199336,
0.0000311113,
-0.0191981681,
0.0081481263,
0.0524207279,
0.0152140725,
0.0106671974,
0.040916197,
0.0040320614,
0.0347624607,
-0.0261598434,
-0.0370963588,
-0.0010739504,
-0.0164751392,
0.0155981276,
-0.0016539586,
0.050818529,
0.0395374112,
-0.0331604518,
0.0155319087,
-0.0208066124,
0.0369274467,
0.0404761583,
-0.0344926268,
0.0618222207,
-0.0156293195,
0.016778769,
0.0612933785,
-0.0036036165,
0.0081131356,
0.0110295396,
-0.049854435,
0.0706170872,
-0.0041644876,
-0.0242749453,
-0.0076066023,
-0.00437001,
0.0389422923,
-0.059295401,
0.0458392277,
0.056478098,
0.009444884,
0.0468752943,
-0.0094328895,
0.01050134,
0.0410523787,
-0.0746999457,
0.0165289994,
0.0220850464,
0.0006467953,
0.0800694898,
-0.0351812765,
0.0114910593,
-0.0380959213,
0.0216122977,
-0.012275097,
-0.0376561284,
-0.0594169535,
-0.0300204456,
-0.0529694892,
0.0523716696,
-0.1059962511,
0.0159101915,
0.0201558676,
0.0180810057,
-0.0344347842,
0.0024754179,
0.0036593308,
-0.0272795111,
0.0212953147,
-0.0517833754,
-0.0752270147,
-0.0234509688,
-0.0519795194,
0.0148161165,
-0.0231754798,
0.027779147,
0.0358190238,
0.022055218,
-0.0086088562,
0.0102426857,
0.0063375295,
0.1097006053,
0.0195728354,
-0.0014203746,
-0.0280039832,
-0.0752220973,
-0.0100712348,
-0.0863055885,
-0.0252012145,
-0.0704547167,
0.0139927939,
-0.0012257481,
-0.0187286045,
-0.056273777,
0.011097569,
0.0020440109,
-0.0175998863,
0.0480884053,
-0.0351381265,
-0.0136428867,
-0.0264514685,
0.0184351243,
0.0142572308,
-0.0185858198,
0.0290070474,
0.0366840847,
-0.0078321053,
0.0053947899,
0.0380835608,
0.0148806358,
-0.0374309272,
0.0351972729,
-0.0259693973,
0.0351035036,
-0.0413146913,
0.0082335258,
0.0110667329,
0.0595702529,
-0.0273604672,
-0.0010287524,
0.0257234368,
0.0594312474,
0.0160454102,
0.0499999449,
0.0412730649,
-0.0030222738,
0.0697871074,
-0.0237830169,
-0.0359699167,
0.0081093879,
-0.0256434735,
-0.0100515252,
-0.0810178369,
0.0055126678,
-0.0044230153,
-0.063465856,
0.0033730217,
0.0075154104,
-0.0090320911,
-0.0158639606,
0.0574387722,
-0.0158858411,
-0.0166602582,
0.0195624251,
0.0195445307,
-0.0216280594,
-0.0293965582,
-0.0379563756,
0.0005864711,
0.0638522357,
0.0548568107,
-0.0341505781,
-0.0048467023,
-0.0181427002,
-0.0229006317,
0.0309267957,
0.0196180493,
-0.0237105452,
-0.0463131815,
-0.0181191918,
-0.0337849818,
0.0062821633,
0.0232196972,
0.0268417224,
-0.0112156654,
-0.0197144076,
0.0261352248,
-0.0330423154,
-0.005693757,
0.0380421616,
-0.007176978,
-0.0078253662,
0.0010113762,
-0.017236948,
0.0424266346,
0.0539437272,
0.0093803545,
0.0165739339,
0.0281257089,
-0.0148798116,
-0.0111443456,
0.00073992,
-0.0023126483,
0.0379595682,
0.0560726412,
-0.0371909477,
-0.0038445874,
0.0050692237,
-0.0424416475,
-0.0192423966,
-0.0297440309,
-0.0235978551,
0.0231403802,
-0.027812684,
-0.0099456273,
0.00774054,
-0.057603918,
-0.0252576023,
0.04565515,
0.0197811294,
-0.0502394922,
0.0207990948,
-0.0186006743,
0.046182733,
0.0096636554,
0.014688178,
-0.0084172999,
0.0036832467,
-0.0031465995,
0.021260418,
-0.0001553656,
-0.0146139469,
-0.0386053436,
-0.0507778153,
-0.0088368561,
-0.000975401,
0.0166465063,
0.0081021786,
-0.0567145832,
0.0010920765,
-0.0046087406,
-0.0347628482,
0.0064095948,
-0.0480903089,
-0.0355040841,
0.0235568509,
-0.0024602548,
-0.0658087134,
-0.0304874294,
-0.0147617674,
-0.0498399064,
0.0002976528,
0.0461445116,
-0.0584849007,
-0.039074,
0.0364609025,
0.0055547766,
0.0048574354,
-0.0152706644,
-0.0260436274,
0.0049694045,
-0.0102076698,
0.0029262605,
-0.0099900234,
0.0066673551,
0.0492139384,
0.0353785828,
0.0019835385,
-0.0357675739,
-0.0001315481,
-0.0159725808,
0.0594752915,
-0.0606275164,
-0.0323310308,
0.0284712799,
-0.0095392801,
0.010353311,
0.0330428891,
-0.0519169606,
0.0291581396,
-0.0047488715,
0.0302981623,
-0.0323119238,
-0.0208854564,
-0.0217886269,
0.0591557547,
0.0231647864,
-0.0544220768,
0.0308234021,
0.0069408016,
0.0670689344,
-0.029906299,
-0.0156983472,
-0.0486356281,
0.1227378622,
0.0094318241,
0.0233853217,
-0.0094703166,
-0.0292659104,
0.0154928965,
0.0051684002,
0.0707424358,
-0.0381139517,
0.0742605031,
-0.0491376184,
0.0385649726,
-0.0154920332,
-0.0484799333,
-0.0084177349,
-0.0246133078,
-0.0090895053,
0.0524494089,
0.0305650141,
-0.0154177826,
-0.0240434967,
0.0425246246,
-0.0015771122,
0.0394189693,
0.0395890921,
-0.0142557845,
-0.0443312116,
-0.0034650099,
-0.0275059044,
-0.0594213046,
0.017002916,
0.0111501236,
0.0217322484,
-0.0070278551,
-0.0127508203,
0.0146205854,
-0.0154313901,
-0.0195847843,
-0.0225527696,
-0.0690314993,
-0.0109689832,
0.0380511954,
-0.0078648953,
-0.067415297,
0.0201738533,
0.0991616994,
0.0443209857,
-0.0450895578,
0.00477438,
-0.0132285543,
-0.0250977241,
0.0215741452,
0.0200822614,
-0.1229649559,
0.0249918159,
0.0201734733,
-0.0304027945,
-0.0325898714,
-0.0362830311,
0.0011799631,
-0.0681854635,
0.0884008482,
0.0375179201,
-0.0240817927,
-0.0504887477,
-0.0078994855,
-0.0085205892,
0.0098501528,
-0.0294865817,
0.023563128,
-0.0162669942,
-0.0175960641,
0.0123409703,
-0.070737198,
0.0387690924,
0.0155960135,
-0.0228198059,
0.0772715211,
0.0186578557,
0.0423459038,
-0.0054691052,
0.0221444257,
0.0195624121,
0.0193083305,
0.0109881219,
0.0123856571,
0.0061532101,
0.0284602866,
0.0210939813,
-0.0689267069,
0.0226173885,
-0.0245955959,
-0.0225452632,
0.0445254929,
0.0840136632,
-0.04732842,
-0.0166021418,
-0.0312212035,
-0.0408783965,
-0.0335217565,
0.0732422918,
0.0052003581,
0.0138427895,
-0.0834520087,
-0.0570120923,
-0.0206304733,
0.005447689,
-0.0599771105,
0.0054877102,
-0.0184154306,
-0.0009455329,
-0.0362249278,
-0.0173643138,
0.0166091751,
0.0497382469,
0.0206168965,
0.0400049314,
0.0379055552,
-0.0198124889,
-0.0140079269,
0.0093061673,
-0.0490189232,
0.0004229876,
-0.0236571468,
-0.038238015,
-0.0200672168,
0.0274680629,
-0.0241816863,
-0.0176420342,
0.0447380431,
-0.0161185972,
-0.0221863631,
0.0131176095,
0.0288661085,
-0.0119512277,
-0.0179445781,
-0.0187920686,
0.0416123345,
0.0192839298,
-0.0201654918,
-0.0444605388,
0.0503874831,
0.0085335821,
-0.0073596174,
0.0043600788,
-0.0032037697,
0.0187146254,
-0.0109701212,
0.0302060153,
-0.0299078785,
0.0168027449,
0.0634254366,
0.0628581792,
-0.0252263229,
0.007013801,
-0.0391967893,
-0.005470458,
-0.0173678454,
-0.0772502869,
-0.0095494399,
-0.0159290098,
0.0040345131,
0.0270776786,
-0.0133282756,
-0.0103987074,
0.0274614394,
-0.0098256711,
0.0126643861,
-0.0234971773,
0.0292566009,
0.0263487455,
0.0303513482,
0.0238601658,
-0.0756900683,
0.0034050927,
0.015197888,
-0.0496674106,
0.0232958887,
-0.0308065545,
0.0544124544,
0.0010347874,
0.0058713686,
-0.0224792324,
0.0099006612,
-0.0266010463,
-0.067703709,
-0.0091901319,
0.0414531529,
0.052043058,
0.0434710272,
0.0182932355,
-0.0760326311,
-0.0091661457,
0.0158254001,
0.0189026408,
0.0166042149,
0.0097752828,
0.0267590228,
0.024331186,
-0.0220982935,
-0.0296698455,
0.0341828428,
0.0107143437,
0.042364452,
0.0021583717,
-0.0498442166,
-0.0221857969,
-0.0550754368,
-0.0241487008,
0.0238226354,
-0.0295022968,
-0.0482329316,
-0.0936692804,
-0.0190147366,
-0.063940905,
0.0304318666,
-0.0118479198,
-0.0040806523,
0.0023703414,
0.0280924514,
0.0241570454,
-0.0506479815,
-0.0535480939,
0.0053214026,
-0.032675717,
-0.0044202362,
-0.0109801004,
-5.660798391e-33,
-0.0228252839,
-0.0454897285,
0.0296178143,
0.0313460454,
-0.0103288349,
-0.0190445967,
-0.0276879221,
-0.0031584119,
0.0025796189,
0.0505179167,
-0.0048773424,
0.0088059604,
0.0167194195,
-0.0420073755,
0.0166892279,
0.0246943794,
0.0141592612,
0.0077581257,
0.0141424481,
0.0083286222,
-0.0087969685,
-0.0223167278,
0.0056741945,
-0.0855128989,
0.0497476235,
0.0365631245,
-0.0159088001,
-0.0312246103,
-0.0520734712,
0.0602483712,
-0.0128197167,
0.0285863876,
0.0257990751,
-0.0142686432,
0.0119605465,
0.0580970012,
-0.0731498003,
0.0064805886,
0.0077651301,
-0.041543968,
-0.0051010246,
-0.0561475381,
0.0364430845,
0.0019124905,
-0.0191839822,
0.0205915477,
0.0185519829,
-0.0546260998,
-0.0057420945,
-0.0792995244,
-0.1101818234,
0.0545328483,
-0.0128261214,
0.0541530997,
0.019527398,
0.0112334676,
0.0050721285,
0.0124364384,
-0.0331021696,
-0.0220726617,
-0.0023695023,
-0.0255416837,
0.0380735286,
-0.0455059484,
0.0015624522,
0.0303366538,
0.0087283514,
-0.0112610394,
-0.0495159216,
0.0166100468,
0.0146871079,
0.0822350681,
0.065998584,
0.0164150391,
0.0222050231,
-0.0095143085,
-0.0846351087,
0.0027361698,
0.0426392443,
0.0427889638,
0.0373044871,
-0.0075089182,
-0.0422752015,
0.0124317817,
-0.033389058,
-0.0484083146,
0.0096571399,
-0.0285949502,
0.0303085335,
-0.0003395092,
0.0315673351,
-0.0345220082,
0.0006046108,
-0.0388935618,
0.0054579061,
0.0526999049,
-0.0155333579,
0.0492508672,
-0.0203255024,
0.0350085236,
-0.0653747097,
-0.0567054823,
0.0023389563,
-0.0310703255,
0.0353063606,
-0.0006859654,
0.0131186759,
-0.0074660061,
-0.0490882732,
-0.0022661756,
-0.0167424697,
0.003337187,
0.0358040035,
0.0166215822,
0.0223196745,
0.0306740087,
0.0465771966,
-0.0049168309,
0.0002088739,
-0.0150600448,
-0.0027875714,
0.043683961,
0.0041817548,
-0.0336156189,
0.0055994089,
0.0004823211,
-0.0142781753,
0.0167140756,
0.0735413879,
0.0096040275,
-0.0026222249,
0.0666058362,
2.586e-7,
0.0909842551,
0.0530236624,
-0.0033746844,
0.0388267748,
0.014063267,
0.0249004252,
0.0194631796,
0.0051064319,
-0.0128960572,
-0.0387802236,
0.0437545814,
0.0023660266,
0.0232635904,
0.0474667326,
-0.0780250654,
-0.0351493098,
0.0026513045,
-0.0868351683,
-0.085818328,
0.0563978516,
0.0731704682,
0.0631891787,
0.0386030599,
0.0013732406,
-0.0254259296,
-0.0140733132,
0.0391550623,
-0.0448243544,
-0.0003995837,
0.0123081366,
0.0482642017,
-0.0352926403,
-0.0127439098,
0.0520399474,
0.0348615311,
0.0238512736,
-0.0607431345,
0.1013617218,
-0.0185659137,
0.0578511283,
-0.0112431599,
-0.063122794,
0.0278503839,
-0.0192722809,
0.0399201848,
-0.0149712246,
-0.0324635282,
-0.018180564,
-0.0278303307,
-0.0254734866,
-0.0056175278,
0.0308286957,
-0.0028826408,
-0.0098926937,
0.0019396875,
-0.0354071148,
0.0249325521,
-0.0878130943,
0.0367354713,
0.0404743627,
0.0004844033,
0.0159414038,
-0.0064455331,
0.0141818067,
0.0488836318,
-0.0948992074,
0.0363431238,
2.255506877e-34,
0.0128110684,
-0.0229352675,
0.0121766003,
0.0708737895,
0.0508399755,
0.0530053712,
-0.0403695144,
0.017207833,
-0.0156608615,
-0.0865279734,
0.0248086601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00768v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00768v2 | Language Model Training Paradigms for Clinical Feature Embeddings | 2023-11-01T18:23:12 | 2024-02-06T16:33:48 | Yurong Hu, Manuel Burger, Gunnar Rätsch, Rita Kuznetsova | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In research areas with scarce data, representation learning plays a
significant role. This work aims to enhance representation learning for
clinical time series by deriving universal embeddings for clinical features,
such as heart rate and blood pressure. We use self-supervised training
paradigms for language models to learn high-quality clinical feature
embeddings, achieving a finer granularity than existing time-step and
patient-level representation learning. We visualize the learnt embeddings via
unsupervised dimension reduction techniques and observe a high degree of
consistency with prior clinical knowledge. We also evaluate the model
performance on the MIMIC-III benchmark and demonstrate the effectiveness of
using clinical feature embeddings. We publish our code online for replication. | [
-0.0501816571,
0.0500251278,
0.0136532914,
0.0000141729,
-0.0055815536,
0.0220756438,
0.053529311,
0.0175771024,
0.0027526347,
0.0221625473,
0.0024339135,
-0.0752665699,
0.0059364196,
0.0625755116,
0.0102506634,
-0.0727940053,
0.0600694753,
0.0199190136,
0.0214225426,
0.0033374475,
-0.0043107606,
-0.0032225482,
-0.024900103,
0.055013191,
0.0065333601,
-0.0152808977,
-0.0130331432,
-0.0562717766,
0.0215541571,
-0.0787103102,
-0.0559613146,
0.0424917899,
0.0407108292,
0.0205467734,
0.0000017174,
-0.024342753,
-0.0147368833,
0.0287598167,
-0.0358439907,
-0.0323275737,
0.0487553589,
-0.0850383937,
0.0297714826,
-0.0020359191,
-0.0639314577,
-0.0681108609,
0.0291651655,
0.0569889396,
0.0398436449,
0.0548484586,
-0.0243693739,
0.039919842,
-0.0079911808,
-0.0826026574,
0.0202181451,
-0.0183852091,
0.0170972701,
-0.0127963452,
0.0233847219,
0.0255341288,
-0.025935268,
0.0326529332,
0.0007170019,
0.0790324733,
0.0598337986,
0.0564496703,
-0.0280112922,
0.001255695,
-0.0004216445,
0.072695516,
-0.0257344395,
0.0021309135,
0.0048507582,
0.00335843,
-0.0196268093,
-0.0049441089,
-0.0555164814,
-0.0481584072,
0.0237340145,
0.038323205,
-0.002077105,
0.0182827376,
0.0391097181,
-0.057589408,
-0.0031262075,
-0.0334615968,
0.0039368644,
-0.0158086456,
-0.0274800584,
-0.0250530876,
0.0139944311,
0.01162952,
0.0112138623,
0.0065250988,
0.0155078098,
-0.0140448129,
-0.009782712,
0.0143009564,
0.0367147811,
-0.0726279169,
0.0271992572,
0.0132893287,
-0.0091810226,
0.0186647736,
-0.0179987568,
0.003571925,
-0.0250441879,
0.016255958,
-0.0358943343,
0.0463259593,
-0.0617238693,
0.000453178,
-0.0028584755,
-0.009686064,
0.0415536761,
0.0113553572,
-0.0760837123,
-0.0168597363,
-0.0295088012,
0.0170106404,
0.018250566,
0.0606980883,
-0.0147769628,
0.014638599,
0.0091344323,
0.0231402311,
-0.0054246378,
0.0020347473,
-0.0594581254,
-0.0307840612,
-0.0055743745,
0.0001228869,
0.0346827582,
-0.000562529,
0.0120267291,
0.0373179018,
0.0365824364,
-0.0207087751,
-0.0265557524,
-0.012315236,
-0.0361037143,
0.0175921414,
-0.012737182,
-0.0605131686,
0.0292122383,
-0.003697434,
0.0205279514,
-0.0328064002,
-0.0046326872,
-0.0207008477,
-0.0231196564,
0.0808645189,
-0.0445144437,
-0.0210004114,
-0.0101369107,
0.0209722016,
0.0455174893,
0.0525143035,
0.0508508533,
-0.0694650561,
-0.0242969673,
-0.053503491,
-0.0039221188,
-0.0067150141,
0.0194173977,
-0.0561949387,
-0.0601312257,
-0.0220067799,
0.0315013044,
0.0984165519,
0.0399111956,
0.0193084348,
0.0065384731,
-0.0723868757,
0.0196172465,
0.0664709955,
0.0642639548,
0.0329728574,
0.0265130922,
-0.0239938069,
-0.0044221436,
-0.014517786,
0.0203267764,
0.0057445676,
0.0405626595,
0.0274855737,
-0.0547783785,
-0.0315115526,
-0.0524095409,
-0.0281975344,
-0.0358505622,
-0.0366256908,
-0.014581793,
-0.0195442401,
0.0603213124,
-0.0217830744,
-0.0001122232,
0.0376514457,
0.0452705212,
-0.0009873792,
-0.017457325,
0.002305571,
-0.0360974558,
0.0700965971,
0.0110130161,
-0.0163304228,
0.0122153386,
-0.0420823321,
0.0253717676,
-0.0298607275,
0.0354882553,
-0.0083385594,
0.0354497023,
-0.0573894382,
-0.020535795,
0.01842805,
-0.0004622923,
-0.0206604842,
-0.0547668003,
0.031764403,
0.0107106455,
-0.0368998684,
-0.0059895669,
0.0238086078,
-0.0838312283,
-0.0546355769,
0.0208611898,
0.0298339128,
0.01107579,
-0.0017958611,
-0.0151354522,
0.0203852337,
0.0263638571,
-0.0770613626,
-0.0281994287,
0.0272581931,
-0.0809505582,
-0.0584294535,
0.022911381,
0.0028402142,
0.0246959329,
-0.0237259734,
-0.0131897852,
-0.044486925,
-0.0014114729,
-0.0227733981,
0.0612822063,
-0.0351990312,
-0.0201379694,
0.0196579639,
0.022982901,
-0.0245829355,
-0.0003822805,
-0.0017626934,
0.0232133437,
-0.0244578104,
-0.0112941898,
0.0134567665,
-0.0170343406,
-0.0258154143,
-0.0032917659,
0.0048073558,
-0.0023358506,
-0.0416255407,
-0.0302941706,
0.0088069756,
0.0046549123,
-0.0983523652,
-0.033817865,
0.0332536548,
0.0036010295,
-0.0206944514,
0.0247225258,
0.0179112665,
-0.0230364967,
-0.037742909,
-0.0290131196,
0.0050720335,
0.0123320399,
0.0367384255,
0.0123550743,
-0.0174554884,
-0.0143368831,
0.0192677882,
-0.0518048666,
0.0515711792,
-0.0246289652,
0.0190036818,
0.0321689807,
-0.0542400628,
-0.0033463854,
0.0077878362,
0.0122299744,
-0.0037682399,
0.0150531232,
-0.0106113115,
-0.0134943621,
0.0280592367,
0.0105798431,
0.0463675261,
0.0494777188,
0.0151698971,
-0.0042195655,
0.017021304,
-0.0557345599,
0.0183964819,
-0.0014781067,
0.0024428817,
-0.0368541516,
0.101462096,
0.0531392507,
0.0073518436,
-0.048166573,
-0.0416794233,
-0.0252805334,
0.0358754657,
-0.058778204,
0.0303534213,
-0.0749471709,
0.0106766224,
0.0061934623,
-0.0676654577,
0.0574617237,
-0.0257841069,
0.0148513634,
-0.0250492841,
-0.0396568254,
-0.0407323651,
0.0228578132,
-0.0098798964,
0.0211577304,
0.0054305261,
0.0020477003,
0.0028535274,
0.0425430164,
0.0109690903,
-0.0517565534,
0.0371390469,
0.0053289002,
0.0038509404,
0.0345342048,
-0.0234769266,
-0.0559697151,
-0.0363198593,
-0.031196123,
-0.0033443437,
-0.049745217,
0.0259677377,
-0.0368425846,
0.0478254296,
-0.0421628132,
0.0407898091,
0.0242371131,
-0.0180366505,
0.0146244084,
0.036383532,
0.0436584093,
0.0100869648,
-0.0121927317,
-0.0170996245,
0.0499295853,
0.0149449846,
0.042024374,
0.0501203947,
-0.0504132397,
0.0361319408,
-0.0506677888,
-0.0301494133,
-0.006745189,
0.0219350029,
-0.0303056911,
-0.0148502514,
0.0010430275,
0.1303025037,
0.0201632828,
-0.058600869,
0.0390261263,
-0.0046977676,
-0.0009869769,
0.0041107135,
-0.0331757627,
-0.0393720344,
-0.0146928951,
-0.0032726913,
0.0273353718,
0.0110114776,
-0.0181708448,
0.0182933882,
0.005143112,
0.0109601328,
0.043188747,
-0.0445598774,
-0.0133312596,
-0.0890401229,
0.0071370848,
-0.054078266,
0.0095835356,
-0.0553127974,
-0.0560109876,
0.0031070346,
0.0248116422,
-0.0845491737,
-0.0841110945,
0.0264975522,
-0.0054482375,
0.0601684079,
0.0289103352,
0.0074867378,
-0.021262642,
-0.0236444548,
-0.0451627858,
0.0242653079,
0.0070635192,
-0.0037106096,
0.0716691613,
0.023471158,
-0.0235751066,
-0.0059875655,
0.0415309519,
-0.046876777,
-0.0143813165,
-0.0307169408,
0.094585754,
-0.0325465836,
-0.032470718,
-0.0443995707,
0.0150556201,
0.0339159705,
0.065862678,
0.009567583,
0.0050792503,
0.0081467172,
0.0373585559,
0.0633236989,
0.0382011533,
-0.0743008405,
0.013603921,
-0.0132875945,
-0.018104041,
-0.023379134,
-0.0254462827,
0.0339993387,
0.0358366668,
-0.0023522775,
0.0375484526,
0.039322786,
-0.0262063947,
-0.0766497254,
0.0797198564,
0.0089997603,
0.0073896949,
-0.0064363414,
-0.0278563071,
0.0336435288,
0.0130799906,
-0.0244293772,
-0.0054950304,
-0.0473639257,
0.0189409666,
0.0178574771,
0.019213967,
0.0125241764,
0.0227856282,
0.0004623137,
0.019839732,
0.0771468952,
0.006964467,
-0.02650203,
-0.0085683558,
-0.0110590216,
-0.0272562429,
-0.0263466537,
0.0382859372,
0.0120461481,
0.0437289663,
-0.0411111861,
0.0074230409,
-0.0078143235,
-0.0102237975,
0.0025900458,
-0.0052983025,
0.0420926251,
0.0119076734,
0.006930287,
-0.01376935,
-0.0094546238,
-0.0352144949,
0.0640022457,
-0.022214748,
0.0167901013,
0.027627822,
0.0232586768,
-0.0236432441,
-0.0122030647,
-0.0274110008,
-0.0850417987,
-0.0546976179,
0.0756515935,
-0.0053279805,
0.0036129758,
0.0076911952,
0.0330979638,
0.0159945153,
0.0336419493,
-0.0224773623,
-0.0299000312,
-0.0009198991,
0.0078777988,
-0.0242487304,
0.0833594352,
-0.0482844487,
0.0329501815,
-0.0411694981,
0.0096430192,
-0.0104457056,
-0.0030572645,
0.0107284347,
-0.0643838644,
0.019305164,
-0.0114375772,
0.0149455145,
-0.0151895564,
0.0354954749,
-0.0712231696,
0.0461050048,
0.053323362,
0.0085520819,
-0.0563383102,
-0.0113115897,
0.1039714366,
0.0296724066,
0.0390583947,
0.0080139907,
-0.0266293269,
-0.0458449088,
0.0178364627,
0.0443700701,
0.0215783082,
-0.0443980023,
-0.0020508766,
-0.0621922389,
-0.0561308488,
0.060722176,
-0.0374445915,
-0.054020796,
0.000729875,
0.0547758378,
0.0175383408,
-0.010686174,
0.0395571329,
0.0173951648,
0.0222644322,
-0.0077794087,
-0.0516303107,
-0.0084896339,
-5.012703539e-33,
0.0166354645,
-0.0034319304,
0.0069184951,
-0.0371568985,
0.0063767056,
0.0682348236,
-0.0248100217,
0.0125999432,
0.0034383608,
0.0339382142,
-0.023821352,
-0.0130499834,
0.0072361324,
0.0220501572,
0.0313409045,
-0.022595102,
0.0417723246,
-0.0144399954,
0.0199860334,
0.0178004634,
0.020121621,
0.0623651594,
0.055882819,
-0.0642436445,
-0.0426654778,
0.0409649536,
0.0213370379,
0.0042089694,
0.0466504842,
0.0490407385,
-0.0664303154,
0.0696560889,
0.0427726693,
-0.0106683029,
-0.0335073061,
-0.0359133407,
-0.0854960531,
-0.0286939275,
-0.019589588,
-0.0401886217,
-0.0214509852,
-0.0118824039,
0.0457039699,
-0.0300743505,
0.0031313505,
0.0013581007,
0.0317772962,
-0.0482883677,
-0.0386243425,
-0.0074219839,
-0.0171415582,
0.0618829653,
-0.0269722175,
0.0048921672,
0.0562479496,
-0.0229424313,
-0.0210316423,
0.0013939587,
-0.0437383354,
-0.0375526696,
0.0016702076,
0.0279300641,
-0.0102519542,
-0.0148416758,
0.0059104804,
0.0715056434,
0.0142571004,
-0.0185337737,
-0.0304688849,
0.0648768693,
0.0163981076,
0.0452314764,
0.0400930233,
0.0122972829,
-0.0085966419,
-0.0858225897,
-0.0755488276,
0.0522945374,
-0.0160028301,
0.0062957411,
0.0063828882,
0.0017722538,
-0.0506295674,
0.0048079025,
-0.0010259968,
-0.0043434999,
-0.0142833637,
-0.0412450954,
0.0191559587,
0.0103364838,
0.0276792999,
0.0239786692,
-0.0042624967,
-0.0244885087,
0.0036977925,
-0.017590167,
0.0545182452,
-0.014072516,
0.0268242359,
-0.0100306626,
-0.0143283196,
-0.0273157693,
0.0275233891,
0.0221680794,
0.0593205802,
-0.0413098782,
0.016240567,
-0.0047438676,
-0.0355899669,
-0.0389804132,
0.0223033074,
-0.0431262664,
0.0008057492,
0.0200715642,
0.0517890975,
-0.002940872,
0.0114838313,
0.060708154,
-0.0393785685,
-0.0079468964,
-0.0223724619,
0.0053907759,
0.0224875771,
0.0313278213,
-0.0084817614,
-0.0297463313,
-0.0588018559,
0.0290995203,
0.0760555789,
-0.0391716808,
-0.0244778953,
-0.0095522795,
2.398e-7,
0.0598394275,
0.0221715067,
0.0173720997,
-0.0404508933,
0.0031531644,
0.02017341,
-0.0337045826,
0.0403085202,
-0.052419778,
0.006212546,
0.0647375882,
0.0367555656,
0.0604072623,
0.0358067416,
-0.03955587,
0.0028031045,
-0.0986536369,
0.0160950664,
-0.0044058729,
-0.0461035036,
0.032827545,
0.1065673754,
-0.0147958696,
-0.0145983854,
0.0526868477,
-0.0104241027,
0.065326497,
-0.027315516,
-0.016348701,
0.0179278199,
-0.0144444741,
0.0363121442,
0.0141089959,
-0.0224151965,
-0.0158506073,
0.0234792158,
0.0078539485,
0.0642542541,
-0.0332049616,
-0.0182471387,
0.0109722586,
0.0187079757,
-0.0068654167,
-0.0267403349,
0.0647639707,
-0.0428536758,
-0.0562036894,
-0.0598916188,
0.0065806778,
0.0317271352,
0.0765340775,
-0.0042095142,
-0.0346229039,
0.0436161645,
0.0297094956,
-0.0051437202,
-0.0434611738,
-0.0384788886,
-0.019741321,
0.0588294454,
-0.0427315645,
0.0068819309,
-0.0065235519,
-0.0078603337,
0.0383452885,
-0.033270143,
0.008186114,
2.143033879e-34,
0.0106300479,
0.0000679229,
0.0045443173,
0.0231252499,
0.0052624992,
-0.0535366982,
0.0466594696,
-0.0018172016,
0.0165576972,
-0.0706959218,
-0.0181394797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00762v1 | Challenges for Linguistically-Driven Computer-Based Sign Recognition from Continuous Signing for American Sign Language | 2023-11-01T18:08:44 | 2023-11-01T18:08:44 | Carol Neidle | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | There have been recent advances in computer-based recognition of isolated,
citation-form signs from video. There are many challenges for such a task, not
least the naturally occurring inter- and intra- signer synchronic variation in
sign production, including sociolinguistic variation in the realization of
certain signs. However, there are several significant factors that make
recognition of signs from continuous signing an even more difficult problem.
This article presents an overview of such challenges, based in part on findings
from a large corpus of linguistically annotated video data for American Sign
Language (ASL). Some linguistic regularities in the structure of signs that can
boost handshape and sign recognition are also discussed. | [
-0.042290885,
0.0369658731,
-0.0161973853,
0.0271036029,
-0.0157504678,
0.0374959186,
0.0011298037,
0.0073882272,
0.0334492251,
-0.056562379,
-0.0105214119,
-0.0273520071,
0.0680215135,
0.0060907914,
0.0149931386,
-0.0813849047,
0.0090367189,
-0.030080203,
0.0033507389,
-0.0304598194,
0.0329507701,
0.0204584021,
-0.0582948327,
0.0172331892,
-0.1075665206,
-0.0039761099,
0.0083867451,
-0.0073370598,
0.0338940471,
-0.0061062258,
-0.114035733,
0.0432347991,
0.0261361897,
-0.0058381702,
0.0000016821,
-0.0331699662,
0.0287258197,
-0.0111618638,
0.0071466081,
0.016025532,
0.0225487314,
-0.0665029511,
-0.0195427407,
0.0051163831,
-0.0468786955,
-0.0662391931,
0.0595044494,
0.0144625045,
-0.0198126864,
-0.0452657789,
-0.0196852069,
0.0132281343,
0.0083829099,
-0.0196725428,
-0.0477172881,
0.0407196283,
0.0173503608,
-0.0074209613,
0.0356570296,
-0.0506349914,
-0.0733387619,
0.071500361,
0.0007653849,
-0.0513873622,
-0.0466193184,
0.019683402,
-0.0262378603,
-0.0002508559,
-0.002716359,
0.0238850061,
-0.0086606154,
0.0212890487,
0.0342624336,
-0.0276222397,
0.0078000082,
0.0434800573,
0.0245770551,
0.0522542112,
-0.0006020509,
-0.0130396252,
0.0047795852,
0.0108039323,
0.0175069552,
-0.0214179792,
0.0184052158,
0.0156942103,
0.0250723567,
0.028688753,
0.0031316888,
-0.0173097868,
0.0404723808,
-0.0186377596,
0.0386766195,
-0.0288620554,
0.010594584,
-0.0084935566,
-0.0152672054,
0.0000944899,
-0.0458106995,
-0.0237653032,
-0.0224479046,
0.0288414788,
-0.0118515138,
0.0066655721,
0.0545484312,
0.0335367061,
-0.017475713,
0.0261969883,
-0.023531463,
0.0543940105,
-0.0290563609,
-0.0104752453,
-0.0011253867,
-0.0494879298,
0.0234732814,
-0.0213875342,
-0.0531563871,
-0.0010064081,
-0.0116962409,
-0.0328700468,
-0.0059932503,
0.0117744254,
0.0599951223,
0.0198053736,
0.0120311296,
0.0281353462,
-0.0053722896,
0.0477354489,
-0.0549691431,
-0.0569524616,
0.0235230867,
0.0238209907,
0.0121464515,
0.0271408185,
0.0119865984,
-0.0257660113,
-0.041373156,
-0.0173070598,
0.0454406552,
0.0237757526,
-0.0198905207,
-0.0045567718,
-0.0089347428,
-0.0186818782,
0.0487484671,
0.0200488307,
-0.0131015973,
-0.0627311245,
-0.0297143515,
-0.0589474998,
0.0423231311,
0.0145413373,
0.0159490164,
0.0286881309,
0.0632293373,
-0.0205753427,
-0.0322887748,
0.0020794286,
0.0175249074,
-0.0238624066,
0.004081687,
-0.0172324516,
0.0156420246,
0.0827446133,
-0.058593858,
-0.0057611819,
-0.0115794232,
-0.0522905253,
0.0277841687,
0.0068879006,
0.0111622419,
0.0213042218,
-0.0139527004,
-0.0434151441,
0.0095957238,
0.0954277515,
0.0125757148,
-0.0440000854,
0.0404067598,
0.0546185523,
0.0504128262,
-0.0148303453,
0.0064432323,
0.018450493,
0.0279934481,
-0.0443411805,
-0.0827751979,
0.0149971582,
-0.0541871637,
0.0104322648,
-0.0138580063,
-0.0389865562,
0.040262416,
0.026209658,
0.0463306755,
-0.012178652,
-0.0198150463,
-0.0398780964,
-0.0062021408,
0.0213746801,
0.0163444895,
-0.0056589004,
-0.0461606197,
-0.0078496151,
-0.0244302657,
0.0035399848,
-0.0042442074,
0.0261087865,
-0.0334099382,
0.0125909699,
-0.0238616373,
0.0022686652,
0.02892204,
-0.0256511681,
-0.0192558356,
0.1074624211,
0.0046623959,
0.0183260422,
-0.063291885,
0.0747174174,
-0.0054782,
0.0542366765,
0.0075489078,
0.0448171608,
-0.0103936903,
0.0136713125,
0.0259032696,
0.0021384661,
0.0354752578,
0.0296427887,
-0.0106045231,
-0.0294339079,
-0.0028526047,
-0.0134029947,
0.0227917321,
0.0902321264,
-0.032099206,
-0.010940453,
0.0632527024,
-0.044063516,
-0.0300605558,
-0.0026531934,
0.031699121,
-0.0803851858,
0.0428528674,
-0.0354333147,
0.0462461412,
-0.0338695869,
0.0202998314,
0.012784793,
0.0126667432,
-0.0005616286,
-0.0067801448,
-0.0013199657,
-0.0384354368,
-0.0288902894,
-0.0347872116,
0.0047016763,
-0.1155902073,
0.0044743768,
0.0096400455,
-0.0314838961,
0.0030486302,
0.0059937686,
0.0288608428,
-0.0082848826,
0.0042792596,
-0.0528986156,
-0.0551241338,
0.0252348911,
0.0200278889,
-0.0261671301,
-0.0590420999,
0.0056362385,
-0.0317278542,
-0.0231200419,
-0.0252858102,
0.0099653555,
-0.0528256446,
-0.0383428894,
-0.0045458251,
-0.0650155917,
0.0015598562,
-0.0254907832,
-0.018866716,
-0.0019756993,
0.0090750363,
-0.0888635069,
-0.0482065715,
-0.0462800562,
0.0413839407,
0.0326740965,
-0.0112867225,
0.0073548653,
0.0283659678,
0.0417075828,
-0.0157111492,
-0.0213904195,
-0.026711015,
0.0331998207,
0.0123932902,
-0.0228997543,
0.0037060059,
-0.0365455337,
0.02408964,
0.0829627737,
-0.0290510058,
-0.0536450036,
-0.0158386696,
0.0217637625,
0.0170288328,
0.0477035381,
-0.0583999045,
-0.05606132,
-0.03044267,
-0.0561971366,
-0.0154078733,
-0.0190777555,
-0.0259168204,
-0.0370443873,
0.0005124838,
-0.0277634058,
0.0043763407,
-0.0744826347,
-0.0567047819,
0.0441715568,
0.0077166432,
-0.0064670052,
0.0326953717,
0.0053227404,
0.0225332752,
-0.0261579063,
-0.0670687929,
-0.039627362,
0.0275735483,
0.0345062986,
-0.0014458352,
0.0010707394,
-0.0260377917,
0.0127843125,
-0.0043783439,
0.0273963027,
0.0189727917,
0.0097075077,
-0.0257464647,
0.0064383512,
0.0203100238,
-0.0444474258,
0.0045412011,
-0.0042181481,
0.0223217029,
0.0119615681,
0.0110685779,
0.0497706756,
-0.0174103957,
-0.0139393322,
0.0355968811,
0.0224951934,
-0.045121558,
-0.0440533273,
-0.0044061281,
0.0047972393,
-0.0116207181,
0.0122860866,
-0.0459690206,
0.0058384179,
0.0380242057,
0.0382022187,
-0.0417745858,
0.0129778674,
0.0134584494,
0.0270086732,
0.0628974214,
0.0513629653,
-0.0062914207,
-0.0424550921,
0.0156972799,
0.0503417477,
-0.0281858314,
-0.0176492129,
0.0033960743,
-0.0411387682,
-0.0158346631,
0.0000513707,
0.0242195483,
0.0304712038,
-0.0025475137,
-0.0321242064,
-0.016884489,
0.0277453046,
0.0129508069,
-0.0517093129,
0.0164581798,
0.0172393061,
0.0395376459,
0.0300955027,
-0.0142171681,
0.0247008726,
-0.0344841294,
-0.018364409,
0.0426442288,
-0.062054988,
-0.0431807153,
0.0465235859,
0.0068697925,
0.0146277416,
-0.0166000947,
-0.0065430743,
0.0000720773,
-0.0662868842,
0.0089534577,
-0.0314049199,
0.0387132652,
-0.0392206125,
-0.0125348354,
0.0292933211,
-0.0415608883,
-0.0166851617,
0.0406671241,
-0.0376093984,
-0.0181550607,
-0.0021157586,
0.0589957535,
-0.0472353958,
-0.000254944,
-0.0001583281,
-0.0211171471,
-0.0291071311,
0.0073912623,
-0.0223441236,
-0.0603872277,
-0.014053599,
0.0424166359,
0.0380423926,
0.103699401,
-0.0317797959,
0.0053479658,
-0.0305361785,
-0.0834391862,
-0.0139387595,
-0.0242551193,
0.0336563289,
0.0465416759,
0.009620361,
0.0090391515,
0.0850228444,
0.0292894058,
-0.0288379714,
0.0650307685,
0.0132192187,
0.0517531224,
-0.0376203246,
-0.0275002718,
-0.0137776742,
-0.0101597216,
0.0167097542,
-0.0064552734,
-0.0263731927,
-0.0505142622,
0.072042048,
0.0104185687,
0.0137317302,
-0.0008351633,
-0.0149522116,
-0.0432607122,
-0.043991223,
0.0174923558,
0.0544352233,
0.0412203968,
0.0057117683,
-0.0671369135,
-0.0326285437,
-0.0183342565,
0.0496133827,
0.0288894586,
-0.0064705615,
-0.0216260906,
-0.1497160196,
-0.0164219588,
-0.0498488694,
0.0080721583,
-0.0245450381,
-0.0340087302,
-0.0093048848,
-0.0451303571,
-0.0105992872,
-0.0135851903,
0.061435733,
-0.0703395978,
-0.0304132104,
0.0164068416,
-0.0138651822,
-0.0039775134,
0.0338099375,
-0.0256713927,
0.0136190709,
0.0468477234,
0.0668586418,
0.0176064111,
0.0529765785,
-0.032644283,
0.0467425399,
0.0178018957,
0.0824401304,
0.0056974455,
-0.0079198293,
-0.0023368355,
0.0405358523,
0.0007172274,
-0.0208433494,
0.0197682194,
0.0287841987,
0.0595381856,
-0.0265133884,
0.0075812167,
0.0178150441,
0.0088019008,
0.0169276521,
0.0294196922,
-0.0163902231,
0.0421497636,
-0.0276103169,
0.0132502429,
-0.028574327,
-0.0417200066,
0.0789259002,
-0.010781941,
-0.0377396718,
0.0074594459,
0.0131203886,
-0.0580319092,
-0.0558765531,
-0.0335707776,
0.0299369935,
-0.030416714,
-0.0279142708,
0.0067941383,
-0.0547195747,
-0.0560315326,
0.0168921072,
-0.0525402054,
-0.0374734886,
0.0434018001,
-0.0303900708,
0.0353710279,
0.0210804828,
0.0070915972,
-0.0595525242,
-0.0084931217,
-0.0087825134,
0.0000461638,
-0.0486831591,
-0.0017512698,
-0.0073232148,
-0.021161342,
-4.52250513e-33,
-0.0272469092,
-0.053603366,
-0.0146348532,
-0.0049104542,
-0.0148127032,
0.0153419571,
-0.0064761559,
0.0582003593,
-0.0052907239,
0.0487250127,
-0.0171750579,
0.001049903,
0.0189730115,
-0.0235152859,
0.0232545566,
-0.0110273641,
0.0082747797,
-0.0330318809,
0.0230049584,
0.0148922866,
0.0332578495,
-0.0083177267,
0.0555986576,
-0.1150473654,
-0.0148859099,
-0.0040743565,
-0.0444632135,
-0.0185545161,
0.0318736285,
-0.0079440568,
-0.0415383466,
-0.0050727562,
0.0104770288,
0.0110638048,
0.0196178462,
0.0243373103,
0.0163512547,
0.0147998817,
-0.0097898487,
0.1034454629,
-0.0382421389,
0.0526272543,
-0.0092955446,
0.0000266206,
-0.0870103762,
0.0287289582,
0.03660601,
-0.0263647661,
0.0195547026,
0.0044066724,
0.0018510714,
0.021780543,
-0.0176040195,
0.0006518077,
0.047596503,
-0.0093679465,
-0.0208669435,
-0.0701881424,
-0.0072502261,
0.0384441353,
-0.013154787,
-0.0027389617,
0.0996346474,
-0.0247911625,
0.0325802118,
0.0153316045,
0.0339804925,
-0.0627856106,
0.0411904268,
-0.0618987828,
0.0891255885,
0.0530438386,
0.010275377,
0.0650750995,
0.0174102318,
-0.0308803413,
0.0399372801,
-0.0349257477,
0.0788156092,
0.034914948,
-0.0672798902,
0.0250367168,
0.0163859725,
-0.0100812139,
-0.0332962461,
0.0111963106,
0.0293340068,
0.0077015902,
0.028104011,
-0.017195072,
0.0316351019,
0.0225628074,
0.0800969675,
0.0057688984,
-0.0455819815,
-0.012366808,
-0.0002198827,
0.046296306,
0.0530646332,
-0.0069197831,
-0.0349463075,
-0.0240304451,
0.058712516,
-0.0048576323,
0.0585536398,
0.006741819,
-0.0414618328,
0.057652548,
-0.01855544,
-0.0033390392,
0.0238117278,
0.0169189926,
0.009421709,
-0.0509444214,
0.0621849857,
-0.0198700465,
-0.0212146416,
0.0476703271,
0.028634496,
0.0046773707,
0.0174586792,
0.0314460546,
-0.0023300801,
0.0480568781,
-0.0390778482,
0.0167401098,
0.0431929156,
-0.0471418314,
0.0419148095,
-0.0469533987,
0.0119030075,
0.0094641624,
2.351e-7,
0.0087466035,
0.0505518652,
0.025080014,
0.0390126705,
0.0437354483,
0.0141462293,
-0.0184953827,
-0.008811133,
0.0731602535,
0.0258209798,
0.015757028,
-0.034828648,
0.0371348374,
0.0103446981,
0.0013198116,
0.066851519,
-0.008881459,
0.0309496094,
-0.0199085437,
0.0833755806,
0.0485315286,
0.0217812769,
0.0001427692,
-0.035697002,
-0.0150210056,
-0.0786065757,
0.0335098058,
-0.0159818772,
0.0227969158,
-0.0224465914,
0.032964956,
-0.0871449932,
0.0079966513,
0.0368686579,
-0.026666319,
0.0052436576,
0.0095372759,
-0.0240455922,
-0.0985713527,
0.0306328591,
0.0121465754,
0.043416217,
-0.0824906752,
0.0242678486,
0.044869747,
-0.000726907,
0.0119286198,
-0.0431116298,
-0.0195555482,
-0.0068359845,
-0.0053277989,
0.0208205115,
0.049373161,
0.0640528724,
0.0251767021,
-0.0446929745,
-0.0260698125,
-0.0030505287,
0.0039790855,
-0.0179007426,
-0.0335702784,
0.0478255972,
0.0287049431,
0.0269348565,
-0.0055668992,
-0.0126254419,
-0.0695405602,
1.244521698e-34,
-0.0313761532,
0.0218963232,
0.0331793949,
0.0294771269,
-0.0471081361,
-0.0030105861,
0.0355266258,
0.0757621229,
0.0053543737,
0.0043699997,
-0.008423089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00697v1 | End-to-End Single-Channel Speaker-Turn Aware Conversational Speech Translation | 2023-11-01T17:55:09 | 2023-11-01T17:55:09 | Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Zhaocheng Huang, Xing Niu, Rohit Paturi, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Prashant Mathur, Brian Thompson, Marcello Federico | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Conventional speech-to-text translation (ST) systems are trained on
single-speaker utterances, and they may not generalize to real-life scenarios
where the audio contains conversations by multiple speakers. In this paper, we
tackle single-channel multi-speaker conversational ST with an end-to-end and
multi-task training model, named Speaker-Turn Aware Conversational Speech
Translation, that combines automatic speech recognition, speech translation and
speaker turn detection using special tokens in a serialized labeling format. We
run experiments on the Fisher-CALLHOME corpus, which we adapted by merging the
two single-speaker channels into one multi-speaker channel, thus representing
the more realistic and challenging scenario with multi-speaker turns and
cross-talk. Experimental results across single- and multi-speaker conditions
and against conventional ST systems, show that our model outperforms the
reference systems on the multi-speaker condition, while attaining comparable
performance on the single-speaker condition. We release scripts for data
processing and model training. | [
0.0004830888,
-0.0142847747,
0.0136983758,
0.0410902798,
-0.0503725484,
-0.0089210616,
0.0289787389,
-0.0135026192,
-0.0358925685,
-0.0261467714,
-0.0491595343,
0.0095757656,
0.0276656449,
0.0074791145,
0.0141638434,
-0.033957988,
0.0303247273,
-0.01728517,
0.0161273293,
-0.0073862956,
-0.0017541216,
-0.0100587821,
-0.0471116342,
0.0119810626,
-0.0320361294,
-0.0102849193,
0.0073014689,
0.0370389521,
0.0353782028,
-0.0009531291,
-0.0078162355,
0.0413460173,
0.0596538037,
0.0560159646,
0.0000018086,
-0.0039835274,
-0.0350112058,
0.0120104942,
-0.0546205081,
-0.0332125239,
0.0405696593,
-0.0215425529,
-0.0122260582,
0.0275999382,
-0.0015205418,
-0.0432935841,
0.0338869356,
0.092712149,
0.0510718785,
0.0667098761,
-0.0185375884,
-0.0521607138,
0.0212035272,
-0.0107132513,
-0.0022264905,
-0.0581136085,
-0.0198690221,
0.0097416453,
-0.0236271843,
-0.0064746323,
-0.0361343063,
0.0844665542,
-0.0133915618,
-0.0083458135,
-0.0137385875,
0.0145470919,
-0.0529377908,
0.0025448045,
-0.0136659825,
0.092011787,
-0.0333620273,
0.0078969076,
0.0249919947,
0.0115866205,
-0.0387703739,
-0.0603515059,
-0.0007127743,
-0.0197566282,
0.0112519739,
-0.0311777852,
-0.0439525396,
0.0450550951,
0.0148614757,
-0.0538881756,
-0.0666943491,
0.0431436449,
0.0216202512,
-0.0250818711,
0.0047568423,
-0.0018898875,
0.0268400516,
0.0081859604,
0.0768328756,
-0.0337824188,
-0.0249526035,
0.0092527065,
0.0019464507,
-0.0298317987,
-0.0358013138,
-0.0431538783,
-0.0205307286,
0.0379067771,
-0.0484722108,
0.016562514,
0.0038293586,
-0.0035303452,
-0.0270845033,
0.0145916743,
-0.0317513198,
-0.0253325161,
-0.0128409164,
0.043739289,
-0.0648906529,
-0.0331313349,
-0.0418890342,
-0.0073747868,
-0.0012050133,
0.0107273683,
0.0054356041,
0.004557291,
0.0406951755,
-0.027230531,
-0.0458099172,
-0.0198120251,
0.0705283284,
0.0795281231,
0.0174189284,
0.0074278018,
-0.0180220269,
-0.098644495,
-0.0141720809,
0.0488899685,
0.0339216068,
-0.0176790897,
-0.0247798767,
0.0556797646,
-0.0103081437,
-0.0291938819,
0.0064046364,
0.0213880409,
-0.0472538769,
-0.0692177862,
-0.0145741478,
-0.0417453796,
0.0851064026,
0.0125455353,
0.0345429033,
0.0256236587,
-0.0013049578,
-0.0121010989,
0.0004099678,
0.0633394718,
0.0608510189,
0.0325319469,
0.0934039131,
-0.0165392477,
-0.0390856862,
0.0554666705,
0.0689456984,
-0.0125928437,
0.0471585654,
-0.0389327556,
0.0195984729,
0.1013021097,
0.0196491666,
0.0281145107,
0.0486642458,
0.0254226066,
0.0469128415,
0.0371067338,
0.0016042785,
0.03073241,
-0.0272642393,
-0.0230052769,
0.0273271389,
0.0101835327,
0.0113373408,
0.0185514353,
0.0621912442,
0.0102012735,
-0.058360111,
0.0220670141,
-0.0377726033,
-0.0062856022,
-0.0144741694,
-0.0209080204,
0.0440471098,
0.0162579771,
-0.0420624763,
0.0264381114,
0.0145497229,
-0.0183104966,
-0.0128696533,
-0.0172610134,
0.0344646536,
-0.0006193322,
-0.067533128,
0.0320993885,
-0.0206514951,
-0.0744447485,
0.0464617871,
-0.0019293274,
-0.0599943362,
0.0424804464,
0.0072324476,
0.014433057,
-0.0193475429,
-0.0487831682,
0.0091120834,
0.0335951522,
0.0349651538,
0.0083639538,
0.0841564313,
-0.0342680812,
0.0081060007,
0.0829448625,
-0.0269903,
0.0120864967,
-0.0478636697,
0.0098654479,
0.0220739301,
-0.053882923,
0.0063724737,
0.0084331864,
0.0057378314,
0.0003098027,
0.0364473052,
0.0202797279,
0.0358321629,
0.0087506035,
-0.0181596056,
-0.0064303856,
0.0307286941,
-0.0200892445,
0.011005884,
0.0680776834,
-0.0482434519,
-0.0816082731,
-0.0083353184,
-0.0617254116,
-0.023200281,
0.0189495645,
-0.0031430041,
-0.0728555918,
0.0049748635,
-0.0216940884,
0.047383979,
-0.0028665487,
0.0555081367,
0.0717477649,
0.0165762044,
0.0194110405,
0.0046051876,
0.0119547481,
0.0068083536,
-0.0421379618,
-0.0347415283,
0.0112779811,
-0.1046601087,
-0.0007585509,
0.0122226775,
0.0093874205,
-0.0161772072,
-0.0179260708,
-0.0004951108,
-0.0315979607,
-0.0150717665,
-0.0822327286,
-0.0183461159,
-0.0437159501,
0.0172564182,
0.002931044,
0.0159772821,
-0.0024128803,
-0.0181797612,
-0.0577252582,
-0.027986154,
0.0234968737,
0.0007693398,
-0.0244685933,
0.0019888349,
-0.0547775328,
-0.0267267805,
0.0071142265,
0.0059751389,
0.012910096,
0.0044072219,
-0.0112428172,
-0.0369168296,
-0.0430029482,
0.0404761732,
0.0364937782,
-0.0035940628,
0.0162435733,
-0.0215252284,
0.0091603277,
0.064212352,
0.004276115,
0.0292198602,
-0.0312733799,
-0.0340970196,
-0.0624703839,
-0.0446891934,
0.0158354137,
-0.0168659519,
0.0156351272,
-0.0240385514,
-0.0222906526,
0.0241793785,
0.0094571104,
0.0116009843,
0.0304574575,
-0.056180153,
-0.1030518562,
-0.0016482277,
-0.0545363501,
-0.0070729936,
0.0037977728,
-0.0171588045,
-0.0373946056,
-0.0121243037,
0.007939321,
0.0103465756,
-0.0925861374,
-0.0733933598,
-0.0366390683,
-0.007512345,
-0.0081360694,
0.0144714434,
-0.0182463881,
0.0216578655,
-0.0213960037,
-0.0436874181,
-0.0085787559,
0.0182372387,
0.0139260981,
-0.0340537466,
0.0609887801,
-0.0283051413,
0.0191810932,
-0.0158084556,
-0.0210713614,
-0.0015352936,
-0.0337712839,
-0.0050840303,
-0.0254143775,
0.0557725355,
-0.0373819359,
-0.0469801947,
0.0516384467,
0.018436078,
0.0629696921,
0.0000082457,
0.0274917725,
-0.0032008253,
0.029044902,
0.0068613915,
-0.0025201042,
-0.039641872,
-0.0388988368,
0.0432383493,
-0.0036094689,
0.0782143623,
-0.0239994004,
-0.0087786578,
-0.035563942,
0.0500875562,
0.0066754059,
-0.0630675331,
-0.0013891479,
0.0459307432,
-0.0094016632,
-0.0095781982,
0.1037482768,
-0.0041808677,
-0.0858941078,
-0.032618396,
-0.0252680331,
0.0021482259,
0.0024151134,
-0.0020495355,
-0.0476834513,
-0.017405834,
0.012029157,
0.0285136681,
0.0309041627,
0.0025272085,
-0.0456493944,
-0.0529163331,
0.0425543077,
0.0317399502,
-0.1079203188,
-0.0669246241,
0.0011497006,
-0.0090751098,
-0.0464286208,
0.0501511246,
-0.0051397164,
0.0174546428,
-0.0425707102,
-0.0028391674,
-0.0235909075,
0.0383155644,
0.049181655,
-0.0360290818,
0.0630787387,
0.0317174457,
0.0426884033,
0.0262549613,
-0.0283748228,
0.0109922234,
-0.0075570312,
0.0002098582,
-0.0270242933,
0.0097954199,
-0.0718181431,
0.0085741831,
0.0412556902,
0.0266643427,
0.0053259637,
0.0214658789,
0.0408439189,
0.0292407386,
-0.0289054401,
0.0411814414,
0.0400162637,
0.0605813526,
0.0615474321,
0.0574062802,
-0.0047795009,
-0.0333925486,
0.0141775962,
-0.007271728,
0.0539492331,
-0.0260893125,
-0.010629354,
-0.0476764515,
-0.0163828284,
-0.0368046276,
-0.0521014594,
-0.0050722891,
0.0373268425,
0.0262260661,
-0.0052795103,
-0.0110007534,
0.0172928292,
0.034312319,
0.0025027962,
-0.0418699682,
-0.0560078844,
0.069949083,
-0.0809209943,
0.0004322008,
0.051721748,
-0.0356068723,
0.003803768,
0.0272843037,
-0.0767607018,
-0.0338543244,
0.0460977741,
-0.0057734395,
0.0167945977,
0.0682302043,
-0.0470774844,
0.0176836047,
-0.0156904738,
-0.0056175636,
-0.06346187,
0.0062361131,
0.0850491598,
0.0587967299,
-0.0129187172,
0.020864293,
-0.0287488103,
0.0294486135,
-0.0187041685,
0.0109887216,
-0.0754631609,
-0.092374064,
-0.0237381682,
-0.0020184396,
0.0854305103,
0.0218234304,
0.0124504352,
0.0237556808,
0.0502963923,
-0.0175599679,
0.011696077,
-0.0278977305,
-0.0051931259,
-0.0112095689,
0.0038171909,
0.0064020273,
0.0516544096,
-0.0249851961,
-0.0163312163,
0.0176807679,
0.021678362,
0.0177081469,
-0.0107760988,
-0.0055097961,
-0.0072784722,
-0.030238077,
0.0098934826,
0.0366218165,
0.0155111374,
0.0156644955,
0.0516203381,
-0.0013538144,
-0.0084686344,
0.0252161827,
0.0283748619,
-0.0633055195,
0.0301425755,
-0.0271347668,
0.0119353151,
0.0208984781,
0.0226471554,
0.0666676164,
0.0255891923,
0.0368238352,
-0.015523253,
0.0254366454,
-0.0373014398,
-0.039864596,
0.0024869218,
-0.0111766066,
0.0054355292,
0.0119597437,
0.0503888763,
0.0097814361,
0.0170638636,
-0.0081545124,
0.0324344672,
-0.0417521894,
-0.0445303321,
-0.0218145195,
-0.0449050628,
-0.003410711,
-0.0218987707,
-0.0294912271,
-0.023196768,
0.0218581669,
0.0080576576,
0.0304943416,
-0.0125037087,
-0.0100242812,
0.0267522428,
-0.0163087677,
-0.0158077236,
-0.0227130242,
-0.0025307708,
0.0754106864,
0.0114076333,
-0.0347342938,
-5.770411035e-33,
-0.0422661975,
0.0000017756,
-0.0013591248,
0.0100850882,
-0.0320789777,
-0.0526618436,
-0.0286686011,
0.004691794,
-0.032403551,
-0.0055861911,
-0.0067472113,
0.0584222302,
0.0356639959,
0.0109252483,
-0.0093190763,
-0.0125623671,
0.0866187736,
-0.0223486964,
-0.0172167234,
0.0399891734,
0.0477976464,
0.0190537069,
0.0637392104,
-0.0765328631,
0.0092712753,
-0.0383171216,
-0.0343827307,
0.0359529257,
-0.0367888398,
-0.0299961511,
0.0178388599,
-0.0119397426,
-0.0129842367,
-0.0702660233,
-0.0107728476,
0.0162546169,
-0.0588809177,
0.0350646824,
-0.0180359613,
0.075521864,
0.0077543161,
0.0063129053,
0.0075697373,
-0.0094671445,
0.0097963763,
-0.006498802,
0.0276231375,
-0.0238631684,
-0.0263454206,
-0.0039191116,
-0.0108567877,
0.0181128699,
-0.0284804646,
-0.0516702607,
0.0279657207,
0.0681766942,
0.0103893764,
-0.0541821234,
-0.1050009504,
0.0515484288,
-0.0452327989,
-0.004271857,
0.0328554474,
0.0441197604,
-0.0008948217,
0.0033020955,
0.0497622639,
-0.0200867262,
0.0223922357,
-0.0370457619,
0.0063154921,
0.0200561881,
0.0167694334,
0.0160401892,
0.0010209477,
-0.0170229319,
-0.006401347,
-0.0069342172,
0.013034028,
-0.0177074,
-0.0176233184,
0.0326385573,
-0.0330733433,
0.0000649569,
-0.0319923647,
-0.0518148318,
0.0121985758,
0.0013342632,
-0.0067179045,
0.0106248809,
0.0066039194,
-0.0043959366,
0.1030361056,
-0.0034640715,
0.0001730567,
-0.0174319949,
0.0147091113,
0.0086069126,
-0.0366879776,
0.0316114314,
-0.0309511814,
-0.050809104,
0.0723644719,
0.037825726,
0.0159079339,
-0.0471008494,
0.03312736,
0.0626551881,
-0.0518629551,
-0.0164599027,
0.0017378563,
0.0120236455,
-0.0234221444,
0.0338625014,
0.0216209963,
-0.0169320218,
-0.0231168605,
0.0454762727,
-0.0036791647,
0.0295963604,
-0.0050276131,
0.0003797286,
0.034163259,
0.039815411,
-0.0611244626,
-0.0009668306,
0.0188678987,
0.0000790002,
0.0697017685,
0.0047454494,
0.0004649879,
-0.0044399784,
2.6e-7,
0.0120307328,
0.0142309777,
0.0380146503,
-0.0353972018,
0.0185422767,
0.0171372723,
-0.0295921564,
0.0139674125,
0.0065829069,
0.0074998992,
0.0580499731,
-0.0290405583,
0.1110750362,
0.0177525003,
-0.0916469768,
-0.0410371162,
-0.0463021472,
0.0139996903,
-0.0022928251,
0.0229103286,
0.0643527582,
0.0822680295,
0.0164393783,
0.008389309,
-0.005803247,
0.0457505211,
0.044626534,
-0.0539283417,
0.0140613029,
-0.0221084952,
-0.0005824927,
-0.0242167208,
-0.0463815816,
0.0411953032,
-0.0360268131,
0.0442701355,
0.0260186493,
0.0778743029,
0.0059672063,
-0.0466023572,
-0.0148310112,
0.0407029428,
-0.0673260689,
0.0166289676,
0.0439433008,
-0.04196091,
-0.0112170698,
-0.0225507785,
-0.0485408306,
0.0556655079,
-0.0227686334,
0.0162237883,
-0.0087216711,
0.0302956309,
0.0173523072,
-0.0152649395,
-0.0076106065,
-0.0543028712,
-0.0009832268,
-0.0270819776,
-0.0458527319,
-0.0257294066,
0.0024766061,
-0.0423355624,
0.0090611903,
-0.0048131845,
-0.0166069735,
1.83251063e-34,
0.047077354,
-0.031049395,
-0.0100538582,
-0.0075532123,
-0.0010101936,
-0.0442997664,
0.0053700977,
0.0031650807,
0.0042706523,
-0.0362811089,
-0.0448668301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00694v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00694v2 | Unleashing the Creative Mind: Language Model As Hierarchical Policy For Improved Exploration on Challenging Problem Solving | 2023-11-01T17:52:15 | 2023-12-05T20:44:45 | Zhan Ling, Yunhao Fang, Xuanlin Li, Tongzhou Mu, Mingu Lee, Reza Pourreza, Roland Memisevic, Hao Su | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved tremendous progress, yet they
still often struggle with challenging reasoning problems. Current approaches
address this challenge by sampling or searching detailed and low-level
reasoning chains. However, these methods are still limited in their exploration
capabilities, making it challenging for correct solutions to stand out in the
huge solution space. In this work, we unleash LLMs' creative potential for
exploring multiple diverse problem solving strategies by framing an LLM as a
hierarchical policy via in-context learning. This policy comprises of a
visionary leader that proposes multiple diverse high-level problem-solving
tactics as hints, accompanied by a follower that executes detailed
problem-solving processes following each of the high-level instruction. The
follower uses each of the leader's directives as a guide and samples multiple
reasoning chains to tackle the problem, generating a solution group for each
leader proposal. Additionally, we propose an effective and efficient
tournament-based approach to select among these explored solution groups to
reach the final answer. Our approach produces meaningful and inspiring hints,
enhances problem-solving strategy exploration, and improves the final answer
accuracy on challenging problems in the MATH dataset. Code will be released at
https://github.com/lz1oceani/LLM-As-Hierarchical-Policy. | [
0.0360836089,
0.0639136881,
-0.011769644,
0.0480800197,
-0.0592725463,
-0.005692007,
-0.0103230067,
-0.0165345073,
-0.0213714205,
-0.0168296155,
0.0205942374,
-0.0078115617,
-0.0273478869,
0.0393215455,
-0.0031918224,
-0.0783255771,
0.0027845497,
-0.0853212923,
0.058969833,
-0.0140285036,
-0.0273537748,
0.0134846689,
-0.0185362417,
0.0415411554,
0.0133052859,
-0.037677262,
-0.030439334,
-0.0172652453,
0.0275335722,
-0.0394960009,
-0.0127430931,
0.0326016694,
0.0572391972,
0.0247778911,
0.0000025805,
-0.0565402918,
-0.0308254138,
-0.0316626318,
-0.0079770852,
-0.0313448049,
0.0111696525,
0.0337194353,
-0.0096443743,
0.0143400617,
-0.0703305379,
0.0404587947,
0.0214489251,
0.0256979093,
0.0821919292,
0.0272051878,
0.0308637135,
-0.0421506613,
-0.0211303011,
-0.0176885426,
0.0283785034,
-0.0856435373,
0.0249999985,
0.0271553006,
0.0579036511,
-0.0004161788,
-0.0480457954,
-0.0012389172,
0.0356504917,
-0.0266687609,
-0.005110574,
0.0117100924,
-0.0150872301,
0.0051046358,
0.0101568215,
0.0630149692,
-0.0635758713,
0.0060921861,
0.0027486933,
-0.0210748743,
0.0001691884,
0.0442228504,
-0.0694077313,
0.055672612,
0.0008506657,
0.0204028506,
0.0306900851,
0.001496193,
0.0137195392,
0.0127556967,
-0.0421023779,
0.0848044679,
-0.0104791997,
-0.0086405557,
0.0041134325,
0.0027595479,
-0.0399117805,
-0.0577821471,
0.0306539237,
0.0493692793,
-0.0812759995,
0.0282343253,
0.0083479788,
-0.0020862869,
-0.0114083597,
-0.0087550823,
0.0717112124,
0.0509659573,
0.0560626313,
0.0703130513,
0.0130251851,
0.0231744349,
-0.0336701274,
0.0097003365,
-0.0532140806,
-0.0008136419,
-0.0600683056,
-0.017033983,
-0.0406641588,
0.032795012,
-0.0136812851,
-0.0302427448,
-0.0268081762,
0.0363050215,
-0.0287857391,
0.0287062619,
0.0045517995,
0.0146541297,
-0.001390875,
-0.0327410623,
-0.043549031,
0.026741039,
-0.0477035418,
-0.0018484002,
0.0184718762,
0.0234580934,
-0.0249570981,
0.0067007653,
-0.0276340283,
-0.0191141665,
0.030373184,
0.0820076317,
-0.0187256094,
0.0024645762,
-0.0175083261,
-0.0289728995,
0.0191977266,
-0.067632392,
0.0178946685,
-0.1121956781,
0.0275190454,
-0.0089163901,
-0.0103280209,
-0.0190429837,
0.0364571847,
0.028852338,
0.0043466375,
0.0381722786,
0.0252893344,
-0.0081762541,
0.0202602521,
0.0358348005,
-0.0193182323,
0.0902834758,
0.0670775473,
0.0129798874,
0.0062713092,
0.0130264349,
0.0300785471,
0.0299885459,
0.0059212851,
0.0144666415,
0.0089303348,
0.001713173,
0.0060792714,
0.0591338389,
-0.053295847,
0.0192419495,
-0.0173936114,
0.0281624086,
0.0203290507,
0.0734687522,
0.0041909064,
-0.0018361412,
0.014640932,
-0.0248267315,
0.0039507127,
-0.0444614552,
-0.018774027,
0.0443068109,
-0.0077418052,
0.0019744781,
-0.0271888599,
0.0364224985,
0.0071017072,
-0.0427018516,
-0.0235610921,
0.0479120128,
-0.0161380731,
0.0332697891,
0.0566687174,
0.0091313664,
-0.0204640198,
0.0254491363,
-0.0091481199,
-0.0095897755,
0.0063931211,
-0.0397554599,
0.0577033982,
0.0565908141,
0.0711162612,
-0.0635986999,
-0.0274213143,
-0.0215398595,
0.0422198102,
0.0198827311,
-0.0138267428,
-0.0323108435,
-0.0032594835,
-0.040256083,
-0.0398063548,
-0.0120784584,
0.0011125626,
-0.006052807,
0.030370811,
-0.0263426322,
-0.0272585191,
-0.0106525347,
-0.0035372262,
0.0237861853,
-0.0494027212,
-0.0129498476,
0.0038884047,
-0.0176851619,
0.0144138727,
0.0120017743,
0.0050215465,
0.0285446346,
0.0224005952,
-0.054246299,
-0.0346248522,
-0.0101537323,
-0.0465152897,
-0.0303265415,
0.0433504507,
-0.0746488944,
-0.0130655915,
-0.0424261205,
-0.056018848,
-0.00092616,
0.0527952574,
-0.0309770778,
0.0162726752,
-0.0052044932,
0.0074748248,
-0.0094199851,
-0.0482515581,
-0.0379358381,
0.0841766596,
-0.0104213404,
-0.0002974092,
0.0528586917,
0.0162931252,
0.0010981067,
-0.0320667699,
0.026418468,
0.0424198844,
0.0144114355,
0.0055913483,
0.0156226596,
0.040264193,
-0.0452763364,
-0.0383746959,
-0.005865695,
0.019188296,
0.0045698076,
0.0302584153,
-0.0004073245,
-0.0086186081,
-0.0203211717,
-0.0152823981,
-0.0138964318,
-0.0087324912,
0.0143812271,
-0.0155618796,
0.024375638,
0.0353147537,
-0.0227762219,
-0.0268746112,
-0.0176779348,
-0.0313012898,
0.0555873588,
-0.0099955313,
0.0300914887,
-0.0373550206,
0.0003382726,
-0.0413622707,
0.0199383888,
-0.0179693662,
0.0058086449,
0.0344325043,
-0.0585615076,
0.0092157805,
0.0660963655,
-0.0021371595,
0.0696689561,
0.0573522151,
-0.0420291908,
-0.0613178872,
0.0299359336,
-0.012368096,
0.0079471627,
-0.0239237472,
-0.0107867774,
-0.0143535649,
0.0705427304,
0.0071852072,
0.0016666586,
-0.0461778864,
0.0786958784,
0.010334841,
-0.010870154,
-0.0646002069,
-0.0186284911,
-0.0049619293,
0.0412503555,
-0.0082157394,
-0.0255511068,
0.1007219926,
0.0280113574,
-0.0175279006,
-0.068246074,
0.0015595321,
-0.0669327229,
0.0910900086,
-0.013972206,
0.0044572284,
-0.0362982452,
-0.017719835,
-0.0564320646,
0.0028414135,
0.055792436,
-0.0413593277,
0.0548929535,
-0.0804075748,
-0.0325482376,
0.0062611462,
-0.0423922837,
-0.0482437722,
0.0235671923,
-0.0477653332,
0.0272950772,
0.0133187883,
-0.0245100334,
-0.0525069274,
-0.0346732549,
0.0526519008,
0.0220021941,
-0.0030099025,
-0.0142005244,
-0.0189691,
-0.0094997529,
0.0256982688,
0.0275295265,
0.0257760081,
-0.0401664525,
0.0459483974,
0.0606457368,
0.0478279144,
-0.0314640924,
0.0047765798,
0.03467663,
0.0102629419,
-0.0292118788,
0.0064777932,
0.0315349363,
0.0240054969,
-0.0935033634,
-0.0139641026,
0.0873289406,
0.059730038,
-0.0118683837,
0.0132825803,
-0.0418628491,
0.0613722503,
0.0334260352,
0.0574842915,
-0.094095394,
-0.0104927756,
0.0144587392,
0.0073440606,
-0.0101772975,
-0.0442043692,
-0.0134740332,
-0.130545333,
0.0341472812,
0.022182066,
-0.0108998548,
0.0050355406,
-0.028024815,
0.00267688,
-0.0026052718,
-0.0540012829,
0.0237105452,
-0.0130044986,
0.0111294743,
0.0081314929,
0.0091715939,
-0.0245799944,
0.0322838835,
-0.0287558362,
-0.0127079627,
0.077634491,
0.0142040392,
0.0097460058,
-0.027254777,
0.0031658462,
0.0199986547,
-0.0026149161,
-0.03219603,
-0.0343592055,
-0.0104649095,
-0.0034205911,
-0.0136502031,
0.0732238591,
-0.0475297868,
-0.0726592243,
0.0408089422,
0.1148043647,
-0.0160278324,
-0.0032165693,
-0.020882871,
0.0191654637,
0.0223925486,
0.0563482232,
0.0032886348,
-0.0476031005,
-0.0195365008,
-0.0687263086,
-0.02645934,
-0.0341607891,
-0.0523914881,
-0.0026823774,
0.0483103655,
0.0524943732,
-0.0293975808,
0.0094571458,
0.0745089725,
0.0616935566,
-0.0094252825,
0.0024936886,
-0.0383661687,
0.0303473491,
0.0002596722,
0.0120079098,
-0.0142250229,
0.0263459738,
-0.0336241797,
-0.0111214723,
-0.0280863568,
-0.0479287729,
-0.0465914011,
0.0373120978,
-0.0840050578,
-0.0563676991,
-0.0218603369,
0.0459733531,
0.025030924,
0.0148101691,
0.0122403558,
-0.0412983596,
0.0389859788,
0.0285129249,
0.0343852006,
-0.0070745321,
-0.0020978341,
0.0175607223,
0.0210322086,
0.0223467629,
-0.0147208804,
-0.0036944938,
0.040763963,
0.0716611147,
-0.0375039838,
0.0008318181,
0.0387237109,
-0.0344362296,
-0.0195042845,
-0.0083907666,
-0.0447833352,
-0.033032883,
0.0262460988,
-0.0264680646,
-0.0512548015,
-0.0358831212,
0.0230229199,
-0.004482518,
-0.0613255836,
0.0483288653,
0.0012809017,
0.0246190093,
0.0336017385,
-0.0019054423,
0.0758043081,
0.0576296151,
0.0028164878,
0.0538628846,
0.0023321926,
0.0252225287,
0.0007576399,
-0.0147640323,
0.0467878915,
0.0027966942,
0.0717311949,
0.0168564934,
-0.032040108,
-0.0381590948,
-0.0147420326,
-0.0676382408,
-0.1021938175,
-0.0054220473,
0.0528841577,
0.0675811395,
0.024198899,
-0.0434127487,
-0.0707338974,
-0.0022548444,
0.0233064573,
0.0033597846,
0.0037374396,
-0.0503916219,
0.0415298343,
0.0516959392,
0.0277068447,
-0.02878947,
0.0487569496,
0.0051964135,
0.0356808864,
0.0135373743,
0.0264949147,
-0.0300078951,
-0.0035989822,
0.0189395379,
0.0674913526,
-0.0132843237,
0.0218275543,
-0.078764908,
-0.0217370372,
-0.0162786674,
0.0369177014,
-0.0096004046,
0.0137575129,
0.0429939814,
0.0556573495,
-0.0276599806,
-0.0576901026,
-0.0233980455,
0.022455899,
-0.0220054928,
-0.0386705436,
-0.0365178846,
-6.682810281e-33,
-0.0168300364,
-0.0666363537,
0.0557076074,
-0.0225996636,
0.0018592395,
-0.0425631367,
-0.0475004725,
0.0296710581,
-0.0010105874,
0.0113873938,
-0.017329324,
-0.0046198638,
-0.0048079798,
0.0100372648,
0.0429851338,
0.0025241328,
0.0181048177,
0.0033001204,
-0.0305902921,
0.0105940355,
0.029748274,
-0.0015220534,
0.0402376987,
-0.0554211959,
-0.0323853455,
0.0024910278,
-0.0150999948,
0.0619483367,
-0.0432361104,
0.050954558,
0.007087016,
-0.0044357898,
0.0035995231,
-0.0621603727,
-0.022896817,
0.0108229155,
-0.008304758,
-0.051094342,
0.0105975224,
-0.0180994738,
-0.0369593166,
-0.0442155823,
-0.000519308,
0.0078258896,
-0.0093951058,
-0.0409216583,
0.0111370338,
-0.0285156183,
-0.003209034,
0.0074822586,
-0.0500371046,
0.0178539027,
-0.0209394973,
-0.0272587296,
-0.0026098215,
0.0027557185,
-0.0092387544,
0.003203718,
-0.0245500877,
0.0614619143,
0.0305906087,
0.0130526572,
0.0735592321,
0.0356790982,
-0.0048128529,
0.0445805639,
-0.0012170244,
-0.0007007454,
-0.0266814511,
-0.0270213187,
-0.0133491708,
0.0884636492,
0.0526486672,
0.0182921756,
0.0251766462,
0.0474713668,
-0.0550152063,
-0.0010885136,
0.0311526451,
0.0339467041,
0.0166629162,
0.0311361067,
-0.0165564269,
-0.0181825049,
-0.0487999655,
-0.006916916,
-0.0243533291,
-0.0263860431,
0.0173805393,
0.0080082556,
-0.0165798031,
0.009033653,
0.0305729806,
-0.0212307516,
-0.0341415033,
0.0457433462,
-0.0080895228,
0.0443827435,
-0.0125846472,
0.0101530263,
-0.0647433326,
-0.0240400583,
-0.0022620589,
-0.0273296088,
0.0039619016,
0.0055958154,
-0.0246439259,
0.0159455556,
-0.0425298288,
-0.0042055463,
-0.0407481194,
0.0085640466,
0.0222249795,
-0.0064975233,
0.0182861034,
-0.0012990483,
0.0048467373,
0.0313251391,
0.0117733236,
-0.0608625486,
-0.0034014746,
0.0428061411,
-0.0370679386,
-0.0007381414,
0.0054785716,
-0.0000550355,
-0.0472227931,
0.0016525286,
0.0205913875,
-0.0557570532,
-0.0058114915,
0.0216133557,
3.143e-7,
0.0268251803,
0.0772201344,
-0.0016184526,
0.0239848923,
0.0341452397,
0.021827478,
-0.0417325273,
-0.0157423634,
0.0126290228,
-0.0250711627,
0.0021216271,
0.0454929881,
0.0184969269,
0.0629463494,
-0.0895741209,
-0.0156093994,
-0.052124612,
-0.0245934185,
-0.0904254019,
-0.0082234377,
0.0649834052,
0.0779310837,
0.036674466,
0.0003113432,
0.0017017904,
-0.0335748158,
0.0520953052,
-0.0078047239,
0.0167804789,
0.022745939,
-0.0469435751,
-0.022755187,
-0.0033441656,
0.008517297,
-0.0199179891,
0.0267104656,
-0.0175456349,
0.0581141971,
0.0346493013,
0.0042907177,
-0.030472694,
-0.0044997334,
-0.0093415752,
-0.0516921207,
0.0484319068,
-0.0714746788,
-0.0184313748,
0.0031750514,
0.034975823,
-0.0470733568,
-0.0009841251,
-0.0291664731,
0.0132158501,
0.0043850741,
-0.0111820158,
-0.0001034003,
0.0077793486,
-0.0425422899,
-0.0176190734,
-0.0152837932,
-0.0584891364,
-0.0250713918,
-0.0241610929,
0.0048760367,
-0.0010995697,
-0.0282820147,
-0.0157235377,
3.411433839e-34,
0.0134684127,
-0.0291667879,
0.0017500559,
0.0453809202,
0.0294335205,
0.0033604577,
-0.0274582822,
0.0206904523,
0.0602146797,
-0.0729089603,
-0.0428851135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00687v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00687v2 | Improving Interpersonal Communication by Simulating Audiences with Language Models | 2023-11-01T17:44:50 | 2023-11-03T13:17:55 | Ryan Liu, Howard Yen, Raja Marjieh, Thomas L. Griffiths, Ranjay Krishna | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | How do we communicate with others to achieve our goals? We use our prior
experience or advice from others, or construct a candidate utterance by
predicting how it will be received. However, our experiences are limited and
biased, and reasoning about potential outcomes can be difficult and cognitively
challenging. In this paper, we explore how we can leverage Large Language Model
(LLM) simulations to help us communicate better. We propose the
Explore-Generate-Simulate (EGS) framework, which takes as input any scenario
where an individual is communicating to an audience with a goal they want to
achieve. EGS (1) explores the solution space by producing a diverse set of
advice relevant to the scenario, (2) generates communication candidates
conditioned on subsets of the advice, and (3) simulates the reactions from
various audiences to determine both the best candidate and advice to use. We
evaluate the framework on eight scenarios spanning the ten fundamental
processes of interpersonal communication. For each scenario, we collect a
dataset of human evaluations across candidates and baselines, and showcase that
our framework's chosen candidate is preferred over popular generation
mechanisms including Chain-of-Thought. We also find that audience simulations
achieve reasonably high agreement with human raters across 5 of the 8
scenarios. Finally, we demonstrate the generality of our framework by applying
it to real-world scenarios described by users on web forums. Through
evaluations and demonstrations, we show that EGS enhances the effectiveness and
outcomes of goal-oriented communication across a variety of situations, thus
opening up new possibilities for the application of large language models in
revolutionizing communication and decision-making processes. | [
0.1165579185,
0.0322000459,
-0.0250075869,
0.0171268545,
-0.0513280444,
-0.0345151201,
0.0067992052,
0.0181845799,
0.0345093571,
-0.0406755172,
-0.0334926397,
-0.0617379323,
0.0086318227,
0.0330036469,
0.0338595994,
-0.0593858063,
-0.0067045675,
-0.0331185944,
0.0305894166,
-0.0158016887,
0.0527513251,
0.0243789535,
-0.0056816884,
0.0599697977,
-0.00913529,
0.0127184382,
-0.0055147116,
0.008002663,
0.0166355893,
-0.0108514335,
0.034833204,
0.0569462106,
0.0624709055,
-0.0156645533,
0.0000024194,
-0.0192271806,
0.0370507762,
-0.0457190238,
0.0001828541,
0.0096223289,
0.1023007259,
0.0498985872,
-0.0146276997,
0.0285313688,
-0.0555336438,
0.0255404953,
0.0155454148,
0.0255000107,
0.0630472079,
0.036892809,
-0.006702364,
0.0088421525,
-0.0379361212,
-0.0262949988,
-0.0101357372,
-0.0659418702,
0.0296219848,
0.0131648825,
0.0092202956,
0.0236355811,
-0.0018864905,
-0.0055027432,
-0.0206051487,
-0.0415405743,
0.0299088489,
0.0428610556,
-0.0166567061,
-0.0462045372,
-0.0100230761,
0.0725710392,
0.0313727409,
-0.0153713478,
0.0170118362,
-0.0121164611,
0.0096915159,
0.0323183648,
-0.0436812453,
0.0114247166,
0.0029920468,
0.0197687764,
-0.0297288466,
0.0565427989,
0.0258831978,
0.0239075609,
0.0414438881,
0.0497902818,
-0.0078895278,
-0.0245963093,
-0.0005992306,
0.0020333477,
0.0240108259,
-0.0838000625,
0.019574834,
0.017610494,
-0.0549710207,
0.0217512175,
-0.0184781011,
0.0248756818,
0.033643391,
-0.0558870845,
0.073418051,
0.0156803466,
0.0676640049,
0.0160966925,
0.0437010229,
-0.0052688564,
0.0032749469,
-0.0157660972,
-0.0004137706,
0.0201293454,
-0.057322111,
-0.020079812,
-0.0183529649,
0.0107745919,
-0.0228986479,
-0.0611571409,
-0.035175465,
0.0002335479,
-0.0675123334,
-0.0080741849,
-0.0236022007,
0.0155574074,
-0.0302503668,
-0.0076246066,
-0.0697306469,
0.0267674197,
-0.049826432,
0.0347470641,
0.0233293064,
-0.0602044389,
0.0255229268,
0.0080456994,
-0.0070198542,
0.0091104275,
0.0064256396,
0.0650521144,
-0.0181349628,
0.003211333,
-0.0065365005,
-0.0346184336,
-0.0209822878,
-0.0480050407,
-0.0146741308,
-0.0527620353,
0.0615560077,
-0.0006471073,
-0.0139185302,
-0.0262635071,
0.0251395777,
0.0186362471,
-0.0254275426,
0.0634951741,
0.0139371809,
0.0336158685,
0.0693204403,
0.0473566763,
0.0294740945,
0.0576204658,
0.0195858553,
0.0449871421,
0.015203747,
0.020814253,
0.0620279424,
0.0478893518,
0.021733718,
0.0206951033,
0.0088214483,
-0.0039642267,
-0.0261735488,
0.0551728979,
-0.0010299092,
0.0545455925,
-0.0479067788,
-0.0050506764,
0.0814624056,
0.0513021685,
-0.0112431208,
0.0254135039,
0.0272895992,
0.0785237178,
-0.0230979063,
-0.0199055504,
0.0087232143,
0.0354707353,
-0.0026884885,
-0.0187743772,
0.0394032374,
0.0024554259,
-0.035340786,
-0.0054589305,
0.0177931339,
0.0008229116,
0.033629328,
0.0122895166,
0.0002430367,
-0.002550666,
-0.046540916,
0.0438123569,
0.0383837633,
-0.0491810851,
0.0142268715,
-0.0457061864,
0.0012844377,
0.1190354228,
0.0498410389,
0.0218175184,
0.0191579871,
-0.0268048532,
-0.010466055,
0.0475503989,
0.0577298515,
-0.011057849,
-0.0516581833,
-0.0472408235,
-0.0037373623,
0.0121553596,
-0.0053403825,
0.0328980647,
0.0389281027,
-0.0063067037,
-0.0060732272,
0.0101292757,
-0.0214266051,
0.0029607122,
-0.0161210746,
0.0191098154,
-0.0153179038,
-0.0186095871,
0.0405309275,
0.0153914355,
-0.0121543081,
0.0088599036,
0.0008019716,
0.0038052141,
-0.0533569604,
0.016269628,
-0.0434653088,
0.0216664448,
0.0182594638,
-0.0587058216,
-0.0110037364,
0.0104224943,
0.0006746192,
0.0082505476,
0.0594021305,
-0.0410732217,
0.0055292719,
-0.0173569825,
-0.0178115852,
-0.0154921534,
0.0021137211,
-0.005696435,
-0.0020743271,
0.0068695755,
-0.0253747944,
-0.0073930416,
-0.0118581159,
-0.0367762297,
-0.0453964919,
0.002202655,
-0.0163588673,
0.0018140106,
0.0326515101,
0.0549818724,
0.0192957297,
-0.0487997383,
-0.0564540289,
-0.1330536753,
-0.0506149903,
-0.0102943033,
-0.0315173641,
0.0254674181,
-0.0183360614,
-0.0100681083,
0.0100178784,
-0.0590828881,
0.0155064361,
0.0067380466,
-0.0073366258,
0.0249167047,
0.0161288083,
-0.0331924707,
-0.0406387262,
-0.0072435089,
-0.0007111982,
0.0545906387,
0.0344127752,
0.017132435,
-0.0448089167,
0.0072793439,
-0.0550775491,
0.0285775494,
-0.0275430717,
-0.0399033949,
0.022341663,
0.0001689231,
0.0424561389,
-0.0027014376,
0.0821679085,
0.0616665147,
0.0274242461,
-0.0067184092,
-0.0780257732,
-0.0051623653,
-0.0557653941,
-0.0200250987,
-0.075848259,
-0.0897026286,
0.0297356639,
-0.0023929288,
0.0404424891,
0.0270397868,
-0.0758211613,
0.0501371287,
-0.0093355039,
-0.0509063192,
-0.0470528454,
-0.0629235879,
-0.0206664372,
0.0534819625,
0.0175421089,
-0.004257251,
0.0757420883,
-0.0044380925,
0.0143972086,
-0.0120073445,
0.0001277442,
-0.0084631555,
0.0267585795,
-0.0259021837,
0.0126459273,
-0.0000449604,
0.019351149,
0.0010534418,
-0.0350123905,
0.0134021118,
-0.0479724556,
0.003185472,
-0.0426649787,
-0.0096638883,
0.0527417846,
-0.0327007174,
-0.0190892257,
-0.0455938652,
-0.0330833197,
-0.0176076386,
0.0567565709,
0.0043090046,
-0.0279137976,
0.0229760744,
0.0340840109,
-0.0002025823,
0.0015139885,
-0.0180794466,
0.001195097,
0.0061121676,
0.0546238609,
-0.0093815215,
0.0029789452,
-0.0367607325,
-0.0038803185,
0.0427627861,
0.0190633144,
0.0070127002,
-0.0165792406,
-0.03098239,
0.0342721567,
0.0275989771,
0.0159428138,
0.0429054424,
0.0260248538,
-0.0197468922,
-0.0065716063,
0.0985846743,
0.0308042448,
-0.0522276498,
-0.0000694525,
-0.0581078604,
0.0375538655,
-0.0034971379,
0.0280246753,
-0.1010972559,
-0.0114027197,
-0.0085000442,
0.0053916429,
-0.0321560651,
-0.0177497156,
0.0027958809,
-0.1185528561,
0.0559189059,
0.014490176,
-0.0012651508,
0.0055756746,
-0.0201004874,
-0.0092111966,
0.0222505331,
0.0192004815,
0.008523887,
0.0388221331,
-0.0063749244,
0.0040670796,
-0.0803435221,
-0.0655535012,
0.0554315187,
-0.0372368172,
0.095144242,
0.0431136638,
0.0645946637,
0.0066887359,
-0.0325404443,
-0.0146734677,
0.0144245578,
0.0073271273,
0.0034150463,
0.0357238725,
-0.0145349586,
0.0162606332,
-0.0456537344,
0.0141191874,
-0.0261372868,
-0.0185447447,
0.0263895914,
0.026048027,
-0.0392809696,
-0.0476830341,
-0.0166917332,
0.0767414346,
0.068278037,
0.0807390213,
0.0277408008,
-0.0956341326,
0.0099307075,
-0.0158900488,
-0.0047275736,
-0.0047608986,
-0.0775616989,
-0.0399823189,
0.0584099032,
-0.0095708696,
-0.0445997491,
-0.0326886699,
0.0025323634,
-0.0240064505,
0.0224356055,
-0.0142054716,
0.0377817601,
-0.0111157754,
0.0157955643,
-0.0026504907,
-0.0342213549,
0.0366572589,
-0.0200283863,
0.0018519245,
0.0094878674,
-0.0573108494,
-0.0038257227,
0.061589174,
-0.0224981066,
-0.0708472505,
-0.0150849996,
0.0542053878,
0.0229550358,
0.0362059474,
0.0097666038,
-0.0548196249,
-0.0159366671,
0.0098102316,
-0.0235959105,
0.0315782391,
-0.003880417,
0.0314711742,
0.0143137323,
0.0242921896,
0.0169203635,
0.0439531431,
0.0071804477,
0.0238725562,
-0.0289651453,
-0.0796323791,
0.0076387622,
-0.011091182,
-0.0140903648,
-0.0268868469,
-0.0469435118,
-0.007837072,
-0.0226449929,
-0.0361768603,
-0.0198448356,
-0.0250439327,
-0.0235071164,
-0.0079013715,
-0.0031834492,
0.0322332494,
-0.0312082395,
-0.0607488491,
0.0210466217,
-0.00506014,
0.0157630369,
-0.0020251432,
0.0197679065,
0.0457926616,
-0.0115106739,
-0.013113562,
0.0011701183,
-0.0141557511,
0.0069762832,
0.010339696,
0.0638837442,
0.0237995982,
-0.0547255985,
0.0027002112,
0.0078378674,
-0.0072454698,
-0.0586411655,
-0.0153969722,
0.0605044737,
0.0018317419,
0.0437630713,
0.0185877867,
-0.0619549602,
0.0135094337,
-0.0126191145,
0.011940239,
-0.0264539365,
-0.0635726452,
0.0448366664,
0.0242962893,
-0.0326296836,
0.008724249,
0.0263792183,
-0.0286557395,
-0.028264448,
-0.0102627613,
-0.0046498301,
-0.0355194844,
-0.0045572631,
0.0234329849,
0.034266416,
-0.0108045619,
0.0057542454,
-0.0878982693,
-0.0288843215,
-0.0021005878,
0.0407607332,
0.0183233712,
-0.0498533547,
0.064181067,
0.0501787104,
-0.0158859808,
0.0314632393,
-0.0508566722,
0.0163698439,
-0.0495158769,
-0.0101549607,
-0.0562550537,
-6.779853217e-33,
-0.0004704185,
-0.0476294383,
0.0362786576,
0.0063717556,
-0.0348284282,
-0.0300943088,
-0.0413291417,
0.0125853652,
0.0329569355,
0.0267931502,
0.0021822655,
0.0125213284,
-0.0002382622,
0.0106047075,
-0.0185891092,
0.0102553526,
0.050000485,
-0.0261827931,
-0.0499559753,
0.0424673185,
0.0235521942,
-0.0037424271,
-0.0138546359,
-0.086975418,
0.0324146524,
-0.0318155698,
-0.0650739521,
-0.0004074351,
0.0096274447,
0.0301809441,
-0.0295223575,
0.0468891226,
0.0026798432,
-0.0577884465,
0.0109351799,
0.0788273513,
-0.0004688217,
0.0015337947,
0.0464031063,
-0.0299873613,
-0.0269678161,
-0.0062252516,
-0.0122289732,
-0.0049822023,
-0.0675950423,
0.0198071375,
0.0200250112,
-0.0124286059,
0.0344085954,
0.0133904777,
-0.0391822979,
-0.015389435,
-0.0209504478,
-0.0258691497,
-0.0063084853,
0.0623259693,
-0.0347528644,
-0.0187955163,
-0.0464177988,
0.0845780224,
0.0251515042,
0.0057781306,
0.0528363138,
-0.0088838376,
0.0023149555,
0.0890207738,
-0.0237323195,
0.0085220775,
-0.0349441953,
-0.0624564104,
0.0017858914,
0.0368785411,
0.0114095528,
0.0668474734,
-0.0524601229,
-0.0530879311,
-0.020959029,
0.0016916458,
0.0152422255,
-0.0110267494,
0.0794641078,
0.0188149307,
-0.0529235639,
-0.0269640833,
-0.0350753143,
-0.0121949865,
-0.0290456749,
-0.0521374792,
0.0331679657,
0.0188579727,
-0.0280086789,
-0.0192630794,
-0.0028890662,
-0.0323959775,
-0.052567035,
0.0088060861,
-0.0231295098,
0.0210316516,
0.0032375113,
-0.0208045933,
-0.0362246186,
-0.0126882708,
0.0058986908,
0.0000584373,
-0.0186086819,
0.0151522085,
-0.0110463304,
-0.0122043248,
-0.0240835585,
-0.0129528791,
-0.0169589482,
0.0560191125,
-0.0045450088,
-0.0203747302,
-0.0101361806,
0.0286484882,
-0.0446861573,
0.000392884,
-0.0001062795,
-0.0261996072,
-0.0111766756,
-0.0016663243,
-0.0203148741,
0.0252953041,
-0.0430162251,
0.0084263999,
-0.0379688442,
-0.0074302447,
0.0542663671,
-0.0196204446,
-0.0263911393,
-0.0149376793,
3.023e-7,
-0.0079289041,
0.0845719799,
-0.0128002623,
0.0243185479,
0.0428516455,
0.0692288056,
0.0090856738,
0.0479458347,
0.0320366025,
-0.0400122255,
0.0104733929,
0.0595461391,
0.037212085,
0.0166939702,
-0.0766920596,
0.0122111654,
-0.0646931604,
-0.0178976394,
-0.0153228305,
-0.018176578,
0.0372621492,
0.0330399312,
0.034506131,
-0.0044154781,
-0.0099327555,
0.0103792204,
0.0724004284,
-0.076220274,
-0.0464565083,
0.0349314064,
-0.0058306265,
-0.0601024032,
0.0036794285,
0.0599051751,
-0.0155894645,
-0.0279623307,
-0.0209720451,
0.0755358636,
-0.0017854305,
-0.0242589917,
-0.0084314961,
0.0221333355,
0.0042406144,
-0.0589175187,
-0.0195841659,
-0.0915113688,
-0.0376903825,
-0.0262775477,
0.0022681153,
-0.0158246458,
-0.0038254322,
-0.0377299599,
-0.0329700224,
0.0038991561,
0.0031156775,
0.0261088982,
0.0091631953,
-0.0398976058,
0.0146586979,
-0.0130944122,
-0.0640198067,
-0.078086555,
-0.032003209,
0.0161363017,
-0.0217728857,
-0.044052396,
0.0374067016,
2.553599847e-34,
0.0506829694,
0.0576507896,
-0.0243459437,
-0.0002175786,
0.073594749,
0.0191328805,
0.004000403,
0.0280260146,
0.0368333347,
-0.0290085878,
-0.0182472374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00686v1 | Little Giants: Exploring the Potential of Small LLMs as Evaluation Metrics in Summarization in the Eval4NLP 2023 Shared Task | 2023-11-01T17:44:35 | 2023-11-01T17:44:35 | Neema Kotonya, Saran Krishnasamy, Joel Tetreault, Alejandro Jaimes | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes and analyzes our participation in the 2023 Eval4NLP
shared task, which focuses on assessing the effectiveness of prompt-based
techniques to empower Large Language Models to handle the task of quality
estimation, particularly in the context of evaluating machine translations and
summaries. We conducted systematic experiments with various prompting
techniques, including standard prompting, prompts informed by annotator
instructions, and innovative chain-of-thought prompting. In addition, we
integrated these approaches with zero-shot and one-shot learning methods to
maximize the efficacy of our evaluation procedures. Our work reveals that
combining these approaches using a "small", open source model (orca_mini_v3_7B)
yields competitive results. | [
0.0323504396,
0.0319235064,
0.0265299659,
0.0205009487,
-0.0296266917,
0.0026676815,
0.008806766,
-0.0212974567,
-0.0184555836,
-0.0406340659,
-0.0232126079,
-0.0295044351,
0.021142181,
-0.0025877557,
0.0264679566,
-0.0459103547,
0.0302803591,
-0.0463884696,
-0.0140622547,
-0.014102214,
0.0037200598,
-0.0171871595,
0.0003264712,
0.0563412495,
0.0362780094,
-0.0187369771,
-0.0067955055,
0.0186426993,
0.0285361484,
-0.0234847963,
-0.0109792231,
0.0267113633,
-0.0124404347,
0.0325240046,
0.0000019539,
-0.0738847405,
-0.0216888878,
0.0104872584,
-0.0135766137,
0.0177719574,
0.0249550361,
-0.0058679171,
0.0029920512,
0.0175331905,
-0.0073227538,
-0.0144344876,
0.0252209902,
0.0056085354,
0.0866140798,
0.0645934194,
0.0110142594,
-0.0169461649,
-0.01220439,
-0.0339005515,
-0.0075819734,
-0.0281534288,
-0.0249940362,
0.0017484105,
0.0162653886,
0.0112053575,
0.0097362418,
0.047621429,
0.0275285672,
-0.0218824446,
0.0115260938,
0.0253667887,
-0.0426745117,
-0.0244722012,
-0.025370501,
0.0686049387,
0.0467754677,
0.0045235357,
-0.0234597661,
-0.0059992066,
0.020592181,
-0.0079364041,
-0.0512803234,
0.0521025844,
0.0110170953,
-0.0029674494,
-0.0178725123,
0.0452729799,
0.0028374086,
0.0079724863,
-0.0257443171,
0.0229654387,
0.0047452115,
-0.0222129524,
-0.0019579087,
0.0403723717,
-0.0101283072,
-0.0520358197,
-0.0158559419,
0.0437685698,
-0.0150072305,
-0.0108874952,
-0.0204658434,
-0.0113855386,
0.0301003847,
0.0068327971,
0.0452634394,
0.0072396393,
-0.0262263697,
0.0422042944,
-0.0330806375,
0.0527423993,
0.0400933512,
0.0392679162,
-0.0550674945,
0.0117554357,
-0.03307686,
0.031501852,
-0.0182937086,
0.037504971,
-0.0381864049,
0.0053196037,
-0.0326447301,
0.0072115739,
-0.0094612353,
0.0445953719,
0.0240255184,
-0.0179851428,
0.0049050879,
0.0123563856,
-0.0504801273,
0.0500674844,
-0.0309481584,
-0.0345227122,
0.0339777917,
-0.0743951946,
-0.0455275252,
0.0206372645,
-0.0069988188,
-0.0047169318,
0.0093268566,
0.0357722826,
-0.0090607451,
-0.0597182885,
-0.0085878521,
-0.0181025695,
-0.0293490421,
-0.0775536969,
-0.0170594621,
-0.0848117694,
-0.0259445924,
-0.0075408611,
0.0145430481,
-0.0120563712,
0.0009445421,
0.021952983,
0.0079919677,
0.0269655325,
-0.0409387536,
0.0020135285,
-0.0186423268,
0.0108128851,
0.001656905,
0.0647535101,
0.0510571375,
0.0433083214,
0.0321677588,
0.0351368338,
0.0021432051,
0.042115394,
0.0272411723,
0.0226842407,
0.0043093939,
-0.0060207685,
-0.0188356936,
0.0173762273,
0.0113629773,
0.0787465498,
-0.0237549227,
0.0628081411,
0.0748600811,
0.0655750707,
0.0187449642,
-0.0183198266,
0.0583564602,
0.0002997118,
0.0134212635,
0.0546098761,
-0.0246984661,
0.0370242968,
-0.027690405,
0.0560717769,
0.0840375349,
0.0366286747,
-0.0206365678,
-0.0881407633,
-0.0158152618,
-0.0018450103,
-0.0380785912,
0.0105889095,
0.0195412543,
0.0178156551,
-0.033930257,
0.0335236825,
0.0069182999,
-0.066206716,
-0.0065693823,
-0.0623233207,
0.0595362931,
0.0399220288,
0.0579040684,
-0.0005005181,
-0.022483917,
-0.0433189981,
-0.0025825882,
0.0511247329,
0.0620766394,
-0.0236150809,
0.0019388276,
-0.0414525159,
-0.0198306032,
-0.0236647483,
0.0207351558,
-0.0156153282,
-0.0156471319,
-0.0190589093,
0.0370123684,
-0.026701292,
-0.0661401153,
0.0221144427,
-0.0040877513,
-0.0238024313,
0.0056030257,
0.0159283746,
0.0195797943,
0.0610001348,
-0.0127392774,
0.0150605468,
0.0150088286,
-0.0415201932,
0.0030540624,
0.0055737384,
-0.0261611622,
-0.0493304022,
0.0380319431,
-0.0435359329,
-0.0143429525,
0.0095917089,
-0.034900099,
-0.0588435754,
-0.013495991,
-0.0579474159,
-0.0178204961,
-0.0381445922,
0.015293641,
-0.0065033147,
-0.0116531784,
-0.0506758206,
0.0403447933,
-0.0054522082,
0.0278688632,
0.0698676407,
-0.0145122651,
0.0166446343,
-0.0122276982,
-0.0508153662,
0.0049994579,
0.0152197061,
0.0304359458,
0.0524533577,
0.0767225027,
-0.0439438075,
-0.0387980752,
-0.0926714763,
0.0145387519,
-0.0328410529,
0.0166223682,
0.0393297784,
0.0109238764,
-0.0028127835,
0.0185439326,
-0.0446488261,
-0.0346966721,
0.0238548275,
0.0168246124,
0.0357323401,
0.0189507306,
0.0291188192,
-0.0433162935,
-0.0141795473,
0.0110228639,
0.0417258963,
0.0146486666,
-0.0242845714,
-0.0460868627,
0.0566936024,
-0.0526781157,
-0.0369914472,
0.0357005745,
-0.0106284013,
0.0264106784,
-0.0274107233,
0.0621897429,
0.0403605327,
-0.0158403572,
0.008080231,
0.07426247,
0.0001834016,
-0.0682614446,
0.0038630387,
0.0126561271,
-0.051963903,
0.0311210342,
-0.0312264971,
-0.0002301493,
0.037996117,
-0.006176644,
-0.0199977644,
-0.0556420051,
0.038169492,
-0.0321678817,
-0.0407617763,
-0.0314081311,
0.0145985382,
-0.0095564611,
0.0762140229,
-0.0149964131,
-0.05558284,
0.0756985247,
-0.042035263,
0.0003084823,
-0.0503209718,
-0.0039116568,
-0.0548315085,
0.0574516952,
-0.0123250689,
0.0071535362,
-0.0047039976,
-0.0042902874,
-0.057484284,
-0.0001830523,
0.0137814665,
-0.0331391953,
0.0819455236,
-0.0525666624,
0.0034294685,
-0.0303262658,
-0.0086952019,
-0.0244347602,
-0.0377077535,
-0.0470201634,
0.0220955834,
-0.0195620768,
0.0076635173,
-0.016966287,
0.0151094897,
0.0477346852,
0.043846041,
-0.0534471162,
-0.0164571609,
-0.0118194763,
0.0455763564,
0.047865551,
0.0184597,
0.0617978424,
-0.0524857454,
0.0912629515,
0.0433223471,
0.0299145021,
0.0172073841,
-0.0257530101,
-0.0259187575,
0.0364619009,
-0.0315387435,
-0.000851528,
0.0190049708,
0.0955318585,
-0.0447889864,
-0.0384234078,
0.1202859059,
0.0084643634,
-0.0411534309,
-0.0097289793,
-0.0262787547,
0.0600964986,
0.0183784515,
0.0101798996,
-0.0947243348,
-0.0336863473,
0.012437732,
0.0420891196,
0.000919403,
-0.0142474771,
-0.0216265526,
-0.1322645545,
0.0368835628,
0.0051829759,
-0.0354837589,
-0.0198551547,
-0.0227322113,
0.0128726512,
-0.0263666436,
0.0350345373,
0.0126225948,
-0.0305801611,
0.0199321955,
0.0087143434,
-0.0230776444,
-0.0061799116,
-0.0002677444,
-0.0474994257,
0.0486547053,
0.0693471804,
-0.0018425129,
0.0132239331,
-0.0369423516,
0.0401158333,
-0.0374801084,
0.0056965994,
-0.0018341147,
0.0562678128,
0.0102815079,
-0.0044506378,
-0.020870015,
0.0085899141,
0.031033719,
0.0160491951,
0.0195032395,
0.0238814298,
0.0102978349,
-0.0086161057,
-0.0163770523,
0.041251272,
-0.039703805,
0.0714401603,
0.0642763749,
-0.0273058321,
-0.0331359655,
-0.0346990861,
-0.0144760925,
-0.0687219277,
-0.046212323,
0.015398765,
-0.0186835099,
-0.0155988745,
-0.0734254271,
-0.0774578452,
0.0505206771,
0.0151248574,
0.0051315418,
-0.0238345359,
-0.0492192209,
0.0336846225,
0.0089304456,
0.0306913294,
-0.0448471904,
0.0217600949,
-0.0713347346,
0.0265266877,
0.0465039797,
0.0002208311,
-0.0120632499,
0.0573883839,
-0.0908461362,
-0.056412518,
-0.0487272479,
0.0890418366,
0.0254240464,
0.0309826918,
-0.0093378983,
-0.0430791043,
0.068870075,
0.0159037802,
-0.0060121813,
0.0277787317,
0.0265671201,
0.0473427139,
-0.0104590897,
0.0423913971,
-0.0465063192,
-0.0009502423,
-0.0201207194,
0.0701784566,
-0.0054658316,
-0.083421275,
0.0267529953,
0.0547166392,
0.019895507,
-0.0406029597,
0.0074465834,
-0.0303992759,
0.0018593115,
-0.0072415969,
-0.0089801298,
-0.0426426269,
0.0276378822,
-0.0107888198,
-0.0250992794,
0.0164812859,
0.0255508255,
-0.0360209644,
0.0535673425,
-0.0491361842,
0.0171813667,
-0.0175050218,
-0.011172805,
-0.0296522342,
0.0158557426,
-0.0565652028,
-0.0096834693,
-0.0230271872,
0.0094073676,
0.0176293179,
0.0333138667,
0.0129159633,
0.026774792,
0.0392486639,
0.0658442006,
-0.074602209,
-0.019489063,
0.0011906108,
0.044207707,
0.0707767084,
0.0169343837,
0.0909812972,
0.0229853541,
-0.0107549028,
-0.0252647549,
0.0182920732,
0.0075960006,
-0.0172160305,
-0.003826702,
0.0227705389,
0.0090291975,
-0.0087676365,
0.0726084039,
-0.0555887744,
-0.0068965643,
0.0165275764,
0.0346109048,
-0.0525454469,
-0.0367137939,
-0.0281284954,
0.0216152351,
-0.0044016247,
-0.0243562888,
-0.0760768279,
-0.0392695442,
-0.0008932164,
0.0394176543,
-0.0155774113,
-0.0199786574,
0.0330238715,
0.0156569928,
-0.0052327602,
0.0015203275,
-0.0457959287,
-0.0500754789,
0.0206006244,
0.0001195883,
0.0132072121,
-6.047177874e-33,
-0.0490282103,
-0.0188999791,
0.0081827138,
-0.008671375,
-0.0239216704,
0.030673312,
-0.0403274447,
0.0064828685,
0.0066140695,
0.0013371527,
-0.0204994716,
-0.0079451632,
0.0149446344,
0.0101423999,
0.0250952728,
-0.0136770187,
0.0620446764,
0.0064642127,
-0.0470468849,
0.015382506,
0.0012422568,
-0.0005552963,
0.0359581895,
0.0081852004,
0.0782703832,
-0.0140619958,
-0.05060127,
0.0006253966,
0.0115792034,
0.0359935351,
0.0045282836,
0.0235966034,
0.0280857179,
-0.0589824468,
-0.0403386392,
-0.0133458702,
-0.0456328541,
-0.0310621466,
0.0461411588,
-0.0400375128,
-0.0853371471,
-0.0523643233,
0.0178496037,
-0.0234487783,
-0.0188243408,
-0.0448809415,
0.0282214805,
-0.041778788,
-0.035058327,
-0.0408867821,
-0.0156537723,
0.0200549141,
-0.0207788907,
-0.049565088,
0.0329214111,
0.0661890879,
-0.0155939674,
0.0168627016,
-0.0233148765,
0.0519603267,
0.0341269635,
0.0419367291,
0.0650130957,
0.0039635822,
-0.025614718,
0.0487568751,
-0.0044131544,
-0.0267358571,
-0.0171391889,
-0.0247513987,
0.0045423759,
0.0098459814,
0.0493857339,
0.029216947,
-0.0057070921,
0.0565585271,
-0.0346236937,
0.0773178786,
0.0171099529,
0.028651312,
-0.0142460018,
-0.0433199108,
-0.0095164906,
0.0041674408,
-0.0496319085,
-0.0287778862,
-0.028874686,
-0.0279198345,
0.006807351,
-0.0009928587,
-0.0441415384,
-0.0454644859,
0.0457526445,
-0.0371699668,
0.0275061168,
0.0048822346,
-0.0144479144,
0.0274041053,
-0.0061562583,
0.0215114374,
-0.042308405,
0.0454637483,
0.0095471423,
0.0319965705,
0.0163625963,
0.0080035077,
0.0439273752,
0.0105567817,
-0.0555195808,
0.0146198487,
-0.0356642529,
0.0315570384,
-0.0542092286,
-0.0122500043,
0.0022653439,
-0.0104945647,
-0.0091028018,
0.0649620816,
0.002134044,
0.0000621464,
0.0008869485,
0.024389999,
0.0122125456,
0.0132182641,
-0.0408189557,
0.0217780396,
-0.0200011618,
0.0542661622,
0.036948733,
-0.0258755945,
-0.0085566044,
-0.0048362464,
2.594e-7,
0.0231429953,
0.0316187255,
0.039219927,
0.0272077322,
-0.0355791114,
0.0181491207,
-0.0278582498,
0.0019708793,
0.0194205754,
-0.0074648699,
0.039487794,
0.0294271726,
0.0650814325,
0.0200369153,
-0.1189991385,
0.0029414564,
-0.0737723261,
-0.0006740637,
-0.030324446,
-0.0249270108,
0.0764109716,
0.0591142625,
-0.0268426314,
-0.0128406268,
-0.0173039958,
-0.0216894001,
0.0304420311,
-0.0297979936,
-0.0509239808,
0.0155254509,
0.0752294287,
0.003325972,
-0.0090937186,
-0.0300778337,
0.0137951793,
-0.0126275187,
0.0225420389,
0.0498721562,
0.0487175249,
-0.0333429649,
0.0071239369,
-0.0147398273,
0.0175169911,
-0.0190419219,
0.0661647618,
-0.0328729339,
-0.0065778894,
-0.0033669684,
-0.0187607203,
-0.0033605103,
0.0256618802,
-0.0343877375,
-0.0529646762,
0.0374166146,
-0.0115908273,
-0.0151377218,
-0.0100915954,
-0.0333911218,
-0.0572286285,
-0.012480082,
0.026078837,
-0.0828297436,
-0.005523541,
-0.0071747997,
-0.0186939649,
-0.0901474655,
-0.0209661648,
2.343899461e-34,
0.088343218,
-0.0464514829,
0.0101807313,
0.0197503436,
0.0045921416,
-0.0272815786,
-0.0342910327,
-0.0372100919,
0.0159332398,
-0.0733873621,
-0.0179407559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00684v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00684v2 | Attention Alignment and Flexible Positional Embeddings Improve Transformer Length Extrapolation | 2023-11-01T17:43:35 | 2023-11-15T15:55:02 | Ta-Chung Chi, Ting-Han Fan, Alexander I. Rudnicky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | An ideal length-extrapolatable Transformer language model can handle
sequences longer than the training length without any fine-tuning. Such
long-context utilization capability relies heavily on a flexible positional
embedding design. Upon investigating the flexibility of existing large
pre-trained Transformer language models, we find that the T5 family deserves a
closer look, as its positional embeddings capture rich and flexible attention
patterns. However, T5 suffers from the dispersed attention issue: the longer
the input sequence, the flatter the attention distribution. To alleviate the
issue, we propose two attention alignment strategies via temperature scaling.
Our findings show improvement on the long-context utilization capability of T5
on language modeling, retrieval, multi-document question answering, and code
completion tasks without any fine-tuning. This suggests that a flexible
positional embedding design and attention alignment can go a long way toward
Transformer length extrapolation. | [
0.0263736658,
0.0399480946,
0.0073267515,
0.0338835865,
0.0192905813,
-0.0091591841,
0.0035930506,
-0.0289753024,
-0.0351646021,
-0.0016685632,
-0.0343174152,
-0.0379200019,
0.0053847069,
0.0191243161,
0.0244947765,
-0.0348259807,
0.0218715221,
-0.0085149789,
-0.0167884864,
0.0212673917,
0.0068940734,
-0.0067279581,
0.0461010672,
0.0353775285,
0.0228547361,
-0.0126430076,
-0.0258017946,
-0.0202466026,
0.0202276986,
0.0114197182,
0.0391571932,
0.062846452,
0.0260318071,
0.0321018733,
0.0000017726,
0.010738506,
-0.0114220968,
-0.0138266245,
0.0065920805,
0.0173230749,
0.0194653068,
-0.0416794419,
0.0437495038,
0.0233259499,
-0.0280833598,
-0.0176785924,
0.074334994,
0.0440598391,
0.0328303948,
0.0475951061,
0.0024227793,
-0.0467984229,
0.0297268033,
-0.0645356178,
0.0291259214,
-0.0464249328,
0.0005597905,
-0.0355335474,
0.0589276105,
0.0516081564,
-0.0266829226,
0.0356755145,
0.0524436571,
0.0038784093,
0.0022149053,
0.034413904,
-0.0212658159,
0.0116653908,
-0.0033093675,
0.0704477429,
-0.0547398999,
-0.0338354111,
-0.0283476189,
-0.0008571189,
0.0026186437,
-0.0472137891,
-0.0517886281,
-0.0001967705,
0.0294613242,
-0.0008362549,
0.0237425137,
0.0303103998,
0.036512699,
-0.0093642622,
-0.0586393215,
0.0617103055,
0.0162668135,
-0.042316027,
-0.0625608936,
-0.0090346849,
-0.0314537846,
-0.0078524724,
0.0129119959,
0.0438659154,
0.0023565611,
0.0191687122,
-0.0561181605,
-0.036097005,
0.0199938267,
-0.011589407,
0.0478889346,
0.063656643,
-0.0175261274,
0.0225289036,
-0.0256491993,
0.0529599488,
-0.05585026,
-0.0068695867,
-0.0942326188,
-0.0137845995,
0.0149199264,
-0.0202610176,
-0.0464481898,
-0.0147949336,
-0.0247192234,
-0.0404138155,
-0.0220280942,
0.0535605848,
0.0218791198,
-0.0201439988,
0.0288888514,
0.0249985401,
-0.0480027795,
-0.0029291441,
0.0425612703,
0.0681839734,
-0.0508138426,
-0.0164266173,
0.0160172619,
-0.0283212513,
-0.0588409156,
0.02373912,
-0.0036722657,
-0.0652383268,
-0.0070183375,
0.0302235801,
0.0141963977,
-0.0422262549,
0.0088002915,
0.0166872479,
-0.0403014906,
-0.0430374593,
0.0413172729,
-0.0423519798,
0.0064176568,
0.0085022999,
-0.0202027634,
0.0089174369,
0.0010083733,
0.025433708,
-0.0163826216,
0.0507243685,
0.0352630243,
-0.0213197581,
-0.0234768111,
0.0148903169,
0.0270378906,
0.0527290143,
0.0303000286,
0.0157603081,
0.0047047068,
-0.0339422338,
-0.0157623421,
0.0159185864,
0.0317531303,
-0.0215537716,
0.0030045856,
0.0459882058,
0.0062389327,
0.022579046,
0.0478449687,
0.0154819218,
-0.0149170449,
-0.0495437756,
0.0586360283,
0.0410139449,
0.0449474752,
0.0257635061,
0.0475252531,
-0.0102478517,
-0.0471840799,
0.0113588441,
-0.064607434,
0.0742522478,
0.0113157919,
0.0526914969,
0.0273333397,
0.0373126641,
-0.0432971865,
-0.0314689055,
-0.0250540581,
-0.0204445887,
0.0289518926,
0.001542035,
0.0097546745,
-0.0292459633,
-0.0500068069,
0.0875714421,
-0.0083726281,
-0.0335140787,
-0.0129001904,
0.0006003474,
-0.0051333308,
0.0687174797,
-0.0112102116,
-0.0432819314,
-0.0538506396,
-0.00607706,
0.0305163357,
0.0388357453,
0.0373060517,
0.0351148956,
0.0041744411,
-0.0419186652,
-0.0274321176,
-0.0573872887,
-0.00332407,
0.0016840807,
0.0449701697,
0.0050991187,
0.0413857028,
-0.0358060338,
0.0209032688,
0.0273321979,
-0.0424516238,
-0.0144952144,
-0.0320470221,
0.0145786582,
0.0259158406,
-0.0288164932,
-0.0005878654,
0.0296567008,
0.0484719947,
-0.0349091664,
0.0076841163,
0.0136084678,
-0.1079521552,
-0.0192119982,
0.0500465669,
-0.0161840394,
-0.0065006777,
0.0518710203,
-0.0261793528,
-0.0251095761,
0.0504389666,
-0.0428609475,
0.0397413932,
-0.0112724416,
0.0104059521,
-0.0041345591,
0.0561442114,
-0.0340898335,
0.0375972651,
-0.0411175899,
0.0435663126,
0.0026249522,
-0.0059761698,
-0.0135335997,
-0.0106484275,
-0.0383370444,
0.0015816275,
0.005354166,
-0.0018814896,
0.002028059,
-0.0130679347,
-0.0294846389,
-0.0630097389,
-0.0722333491,
0.014826281,
-0.0333250724,
0.0136507619,
0.0078920461,
0.0506783463,
0.0104224673,
-0.0147468289,
-0.0575245358,
-0.0413005091,
-0.0163305197,
0.0149114076,
0.0179094262,
0.0093747936,
-0.0169720259,
-0.0473966449,
-0.0334755927,
-0.0009961935,
0.0635168999,
-0.0209979452,
-0.0090153348,
-0.0367380232,
0.0138575099,
-0.0061895815,
0.0224296506,
-0.040450193,
-0.0548640676,
-0.01788464,
-0.0130977351,
0.0516671203,
0.0849058628,
0.0240690503,
-0.0071273423,
0.0275043175,
-0.0035510382,
-0.0142270569,
0.0331039838,
-0.0388352424,
-0.0028574755,
-0.023311628,
0.0221082158,
-0.0240056589,
0.0795555934,
-0.0441232771,
-0.0019557432,
-0.0613721311,
-0.0120871365,
0.0237364266,
0.0061565433,
0.0343438201,
0.0017632479,
-0.0464386754,
0.0243296828,
-0.0487764254,
-0.0642169341,
0.0859865323,
-0.0248616617,
-0.0274423771,
-0.0500601642,
0.0073826602,
-0.0523086451,
0.0369753316,
0.0391257554,
0.0190481525,
-0.0191206113,
-0.0340858996,
-0.0483104922,
0.0112064136,
-0.0175536796,
-0.0226450413,
0.0711070597,
0.021696886,
-0.0016844069,
-0.0081393467,
-0.0391260684,
-0.0300644096,
-0.0326697528,
-0.0058600511,
0.0285718236,
0.0377382264,
-0.0460699238,
-0.0526724197,
0.0194234643,
0.0266451444,
0.0767512321,
-0.0069677313,
0.0267862231,
-0.0188122299,
0.024127543,
0.0482951701,
0.0249396209,
0.0048701405,
-0.0256218892,
-0.0240859184,
0.0354290381,
0.0417081751,
-0.0090990132,
-0.0522969142,
-0.0120966947,
0.0440355241,
-0.0395317897,
-0.0124747222,
0.0116043258,
0.0413756184,
-0.0522928946,
-0.0210395046,
0.1072911769,
0.01087802,
-0.0234375726,
0.0198982265,
-0.0139919585,
0.0665658787,
0.0276927203,
0.018136777,
-0.0727250725,
-0.0205419324,
-0.0083023934,
0.0062086396,
0.0470242128,
-0.0058281356,
0.0023884848,
-0.0899891406,
0.0085978061,
0.0145597393,
-0.0286539383,
-0.0209230129,
-0.0219696127,
0.0061586658,
0.0235984083,
0.0155923469,
0.0099403681,
-0.0187845435,
-0.0178359561,
0.0175931938,
-0.0088782096,
-0.0373319499,
0.0473967604,
-0.0152487131,
-0.0046351515,
0.0518784635,
-0.0225339513,
-0.011392612,
-0.0472257547,
-0.0041217064,
-0.0097131478,
0.0139711834,
0.028705325,
0.0226269793,
-0.0344612375,
-0.0125589669,
0.0017657769,
0.0172127578,
-0.0566336103,
0.021973148,
-0.0401105359,
0.1216483787,
0.023035638,
-0.0184310731,
-0.0298783891,
0.005963387,
-0.0182313081,
0.0522069484,
0.0678509399,
-0.046095904,
-0.0529478081,
-0.0061111315,
-0.0066636521,
-0.0394096933,
-0.0235396437,
0.0166863166,
0.0319697559,
-0.0492778271,
-0.0345905051,
-0.0528094545,
0.0217324011,
0.0321969055,
-0.0263970252,
-0.0167113859,
-0.0221135244,
-0.0257164631,
-0.0575678907,
0.0453329943,
0.0099348221,
0.0340207629,
-0.059086781,
0.0352809466,
0.0242331699,
0.0023396099,
-0.0170537196,
0.0254875235,
-0.1136111543,
-0.0588531271,
0.0097578075,
0.0544654056,
0.0164581481,
0.0495712981,
-0.0202814471,
-0.0215433594,
0.024928743,
0.0082119359,
-0.041776903,
0.0129712485,
0.0446580872,
-0.0404730141,
0.0323133692,
0.0337318331,
-0.045211602,
-0.0100380853,
0.0281990916,
0.0246704444,
-0.0093416339,
-0.0581914186,
0.0034667018,
-0.0343347564,
0.0095251938,
0.0274576377,
0.0707119405,
0.0063591627,
0.0346355848,
-0.0073704673,
0.0041780751,
-0.0334801935,
-0.0025184725,
0.0442020223,
-0.0125971548,
0.0173900779,
0.0171508696,
0.010044829,
-0.024295181,
-0.0413015038,
0.0616101474,
-0.0027099825,
-0.0132579198,
0.0207615066,
0.0333618335,
-0.0338040292,
-0.0326610208,
-0.0161083508,
0.0343106575,
0.0005309937,
0.0157296229,
0.0145532098,
0.0229502246,
-0.0582659245,
0.0474845544,
-0.1088453159,
-0.0096094683,
-0.0188677981,
-0.0425635912,
0.0353331156,
-0.0391966701,
0.0318378583,
0.024132276,
-0.0103917709,
-0.005155006,
0.0202221405,
-0.0124638146,
-0.0376951247,
0.036824774,
0.0373623371,
-0.0185346771,
-0.0028702857,
0.069933027,
-0.0099292947,
0.0298965797,
0.0177608747,
-0.009307744,
-0.0212085247,
-0.0056742425,
-0.0098928064,
0.0098107671,
-0.0338195525,
-0.0074560316,
-0.0106523987,
-0.0791616067,
0.0339776948,
-0.0025597448,
-0.0297842659,
-0.012009575,
0.0285211243,
0.0721274763,
-0.0019120382,
-0.045995228,
0.0157896597,
0.0175379179,
0.0335676968,
-0.0404512249,
-0.0340792239,
-6.023652191e-33,
-0.0100370804,
0.0103872092,
0.0074444087,
-0.0194701869,
-0.0502793118,
0.008212409,
-0.0298910625,
0.0012808008,
-0.0529086739,
-0.0277079344,
-0.0240284614,
0.0116219651,
0.0020324194,
0.0222140159,
0.0084682787,
-0.0300856885,
0.0366912521,
0.0239368994,
-0.0142925996,
0.0137791075,
0.0177295469,
0.0337316841,
0.0782965794,
-0.0083917733,
-0.0027560261,
-0.0080068838,
0.0357526168,
0.0132145276,
0.0264141671,
0.0804428831,
-0.0159306675,
0.0300597344,
0.0171859078,
-0.0450381786,
-0.052186504,
0.0082600769,
-0.0878449753,
-0.0076125665,
0.0124704419,
0.012719363,
-0.0139228562,
-0.038058199,
0.0580180809,
-0.0071335249,
0.039584253,
-0.0647918954,
0.0287096072,
-0.0162493736,
-0.0444948822,
-0.0043260683,
-0.0438477471,
0.0133223739,
-0.0196392387,
-0.0030830053,
-0.0043661636,
0.0512780622,
0.0213618614,
0.0852081999,
-0.061592143,
-0.0119153326,
0.0217902139,
0.0537550077,
0.0566350594,
0.0167000294,
0.0202789083,
0.0087587433,
-0.0151230758,
0.0004565384,
-0.0380510762,
-0.0511877351,
0.0364491791,
0.0171823222,
0.052236788,
-0.0146660088,
0.0346570127,
0.0022513648,
-0.0443869978,
-0.0158030167,
0.0042711929,
0.0770669132,
0.0260667522,
0.0284364577,
-0.0203116331,
-0.020014219,
-0.0028650397,
0.0098888474,
-0.0409658179,
-0.050906837,
0.0408969261,
0.023092119,
0.0136250975,
0.0264659077,
0.0593662858,
-0.0368135422,
0.0562414341,
0.0752846226,
-0.0034277865,
0.0226271171,
0.0048506106,
0.046619948,
-0.0593524612,
0.0103894658,
-0.0024389094,
0.0018239929,
-0.0246041063,
-0.0044589415,
0.0363360159,
0.0276461449,
-0.057142958,
-0.0201223772,
-0.0461980887,
-0.0271180719,
-0.0094341896,
0.0349283069,
0.0573560223,
-0.0052749412,
0.0001460745,
0.0627511591,
-0.0051806839,
0.0126613341,
-0.0265437923,
0.0014139027,
0.0208363477,
0.0208507515,
-0.0139213912,
-0.0240450092,
-0.0491783805,
0.0805161521,
0.012220853,
-0.0622949563,
-0.021455504,
0.0339568257,
2.583e-7,
0.0670636445,
0.0227671023,
0.0456951,
0.0011919753,
0.006187635,
0.0083805518,
0.0257943962,
0.0416595004,
-0.0022560218,
0.0148588251,
0.0004536437,
-0.0078510959,
0.0288293809,
0.009774331,
-0.0761925057,
-0.0369073339,
-0.1087318286,
0.0233977158,
-0.0085384818,
-0.037061844,
0.0012012916,
0.1507255882,
0.0070141745,
0.0254981779,
-0.0064676078,
-0.0572523214,
0.0509829931,
-0.0373040475,
-0.014211447,
0.0087108538,
0.0014440946,
-0.003236356,
0.0007798258,
-0.0589507557,
-0.0110345297,
0.0558640212,
0.0149797378,
0.0616770834,
0.0016793157,
-0.0284974016,
-0.0021676645,
-0.0325166397,
-0.0346491449,
-0.0972718075,
0.0437101983,
-0.0811028257,
-0.0198786408,
-0.0024752389,
-0.0454961509,
-0.0141891912,
0.0087166401,
-0.0068693473,
0.0168022644,
0.025401393,
0.0262091272,
-0.0361006409,
-0.0012423702,
-0.1067813411,
-0.0453382023,
-0.0019481822,
-0.0558605306,
0.0134602292,
-0.0659566,
-0.0434963331,
0.0735485405,
-0.009530019,
-0.0006402452,
2.521991906e-34,
0.029035544,
-0.0371365137,
0.0207856037,
0.0208431967,
0.0138364844,
-0.0288912058,
0.0192975998,
0.0020634166,
0.0500428602,
-0.1033900455,
-0.0575731359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00681v1 | Are Large Language Models Reliable Judges? A Study on the Factuality Evaluation Capabilities of LLMs | 2023-11-01T17:42:45 | 2023-11-01T17:42:45 | Xue-Yong Fu, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Cheng Chen, Shashi Bhushan TN | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained immense attention
due to their notable emergent capabilities, surpassing those seen in earlier
language models. A particularly intriguing application of LLMs is their role as
evaluators for texts produced by various generative models.
In this study, we delve into the potential of LLMs as reliable assessors of
factual consistency in summaries generated by text-generation models.
Initially, we introduce an innovative approach for factuality assessment using
LLMs. This entails employing a singular LLM for the entirety of the
question-answering-based factuality scoring process. Following this, we examine
the efficacy of various LLMs in direct factuality scoring, benchmarking them
against traditional measures and human annotations.
Contrary to initial expectations, our results indicate a lack of significant
correlations between factuality metrics and human evaluations, specifically for
GPT-4 and PaLM-2. Notable correlations were only observed with GPT-3.5 across
two factuality subcategories. These consistent findings across various factual
error categories suggest a fundamental limitation in the current LLMs'
capability to accurately gauge factuality.
This version presents the information more concisely while maintaining the
main points and findings of the original text. | [
0.0625884309,
0.0216129031,
0.0186784063,
0.0125756925,
-0.0321236961,
-0.0028201831,
-0.0039396295,
-0.0396930985,
-0.0267994478,
-0.0574210361,
0.0248530544,
-0.0514714047,
0.0345443673,
-0.006567894,
0.0301595069,
-0.004320215,
0.0137276044,
0.0137181077,
0.0083618034,
-0.0079800719,
0.0056067896,
0.034949977,
-0.0096717458,
0.0356862172,
-0.0217111558,
-0.0056179157,
0.0361481644,
-0.0072872657,
0.0475575253,
-0.0133572435,
0.004189196,
0.0295347963,
0.0013305462,
0.044670403,
0.0000017973,
-0.0746757686,
0.0302850679,
0.0077773132,
-0.0162843857,
0.0588167682,
0.0142489867,
0.0166796669,
0.0002272969,
0.0266224612,
-0.0270868801,
0.0025538418,
-0.0022961437,
0.0368607678,
0.1004473716,
0.0677386522,
0.0182199217,
-0.0315303877,
0.0367222019,
0.0018593943,
-0.0119133238,
0.0154396286,
0.0119709726,
0.0646536127,
-0.0008681015,
0.0014438179,
0.0316837206,
0.0102013741,
0.0063995095,
-0.0396114998,
0.0266396571,
0.0407466516,
-0.0265050083,
-0.0131115764,
0.0419505537,
0.0216885395,
0.0554388501,
-0.0263018478,
-0.0092420373,
-0.0044395747,
-0.0223806351,
0.0114696193,
-0.0190044288,
0.0756424293,
-0.0302899331,
0.0231396686,
0.0393498838,
0.010286767,
0.0093054669,
0.0286155902,
0.0144364182,
0.076080367,
0.0113958623,
-0.0392854586,
-0.0294634439,
0.0363484435,
-0.0170925632,
-0.0725508034,
-0.0215105452,
0.0427976958,
0.0083918413,
0.015519443,
-0.0449352823,
0.0310492665,
0.06343624,
-0.0837441757,
0.0167945549,
0.0182815883,
-0.0018531979,
0.0245537069,
0.0005812744,
0.0487264246,
0.0241322946,
-0.0018502696,
-0.0402012356,
0.0019823755,
-0.0107593266,
0.0024206168,
0.0032257412,
0.0197819695,
-0.0059792525,
0.011094572,
-0.0514026396,
0.0039768419,
0.0210190434,
0.0150187733,
0.0233322885,
0.0039667347,
-0.0039175898,
0.0141746067,
-0.0771571547,
0.0050981869,
-0.0535833389,
0.0347871408,
0.0114215063,
-0.0577501059,
-0.000020626,
0.036568962,
-0.0091845412,
0.0000348507,
0.0206936877,
-0.0096748918,
-0.0138234869,
-0.0000381269,
-0.0418234542,
-0.0380636565,
-0.0397608019,
-0.0829566866,
-0.0277057216,
-0.0737755075,
-0.0021903205,
0.0033498129,
-0.0125261266,
-0.0010269367,
0.0148584843,
0.0654156953,
-0.0098537933,
-0.0042546564,
-0.0018088875,
0.0194227248,
0.0529525131,
-0.0103681777,
0.0019787864,
0.0133260665,
0.066788651,
0.0313985981,
0.0508604497,
0.039289616,
0.0072078118,
-0.0066631176,
-0.0122734252,
0.0078105959,
0.0316476785,
0.0128192957,
-0.0199040826,
0.0025424284,
0.0297520254,
0.0768715143,
-0.019514855,
-0.0042339638,
0.0868766978,
0.0291960575,
0.0001997678,
0.0399847925,
0.0782810748,
0.0124022393,
0.0684664175,
0.0630150288,
-0.0183976125,
0.0264623798,
-0.0560668595,
0.0541127324,
0.0541455373,
0.057543274,
0.0064547006,
-0.0758484378,
-0.0304224454,
0.0226389468,
-0.0292489026,
-0.0325530954,
0.0023920594,
-0.021298416,
-0.0157831423,
0.0213809144,
0.0190950204,
-0.0893013552,
0.0276478976,
-0.0294184871,
0.0537178367,
0.0331875682,
0.0567923784,
0.0201150049,
-0.0265717804,
-0.0093151862,
-0.0200339202,
0.0550173856,
0.029886758,
-0.0052138162,
-0.0295242313,
-0.0124417478,
0.0186025221,
-0.0449346639,
0.0311981644,
-0.0251399558,
-0.0002302572,
0.0008311848,
0.0374277085,
-0.0438765623,
-0.0306678489,
0.0383409858,
-0.0172633696,
-0.0042725708,
0.001285644,
-0.022303246,
0.008388753,
0.0273434352,
-0.0458195843,
0.0281100292,
-0.0026935125,
-0.0066304612,
-0.0264065471,
-0.0018305006,
-0.0156184146,
-0.0266268048,
0.0488047786,
-0.0363001227,
-0.0007866497,
0.0042728675,
-0.0217205342,
-0.0221667215,
-0.0092379572,
-0.0866233185,
-0.0393140838,
-0.0866530314,
0.0099630207,
0.02498083,
0.0011021282,
-0.0100457342,
0.0854146108,
-0.0060595335,
0.0226412881,
-0.0089937234,
-0.0104761338,
0.0339369141,
-0.0532447919,
-0.003286886,
-0.0028466564,
0.0219148509,
0.0472297147,
0.0651087239,
0.0196836703,
-0.028980922,
-0.0416703634,
-0.0794182047,
0.0275985003,
-0.0403688177,
0.0261883419,
0.0146151762,
-0.0420015678,
-0.0099652354,
0.0280153397,
-0.0593917556,
-0.0607727394,
0.0315853991,
-0.0221057795,
0.0555050336,
-0.004197245,
0.0263630133,
-0.0416765511,
0.0087982882,
-0.0031376567,
0.0162837412,
0.0677007288,
0.0090675261,
-0.0390508287,
0.0384056531,
-0.1010300964,
-0.0268190037,
0.0241595823,
-0.0392267779,
0.0250610877,
0.0402872302,
0.0478320234,
0.0188251771,
0.0624269918,
0.0115508921,
0.0472636148,
0.0167768449,
0.0087810913,
0.0040011378,
-0.0329096913,
-0.0155165866,
0.0038600569,
-0.0862293765,
0.0223620124,
0.0114946663,
0.0366400704,
-0.0110855894,
-0.0320140533,
0.026100425,
-0.0419027582,
-0.0207975525,
-0.0108557576,
-0.0022728024,
-0.0169173423,
0.0393771753,
-0.0076534101,
-0.0335221849,
0.0623469874,
-0.082228519,
0.0239042956,
-0.0357929021,
-0.0236440916,
-0.0473251343,
0.0098488489,
0.022840742,
0.0212707352,
0.0035069976,
0.0455985032,
-0.0214216486,
-0.0027095815,
0.0628299564,
-0.0422578119,
0.0708935037,
-0.0623126291,
0.0200900007,
0.0075377091,
-0.0170643553,
-0.0377114266,
-0.073247306,
0.0014433297,
0.0022052608,
-0.0207606535,
0.0010283047,
-0.0350616872,
-0.0163162574,
0.05716056,
-0.0032961646,
-0.0119949039,
-0.0169365276,
0.0066279168,
0.0531174876,
0.0660970509,
0.0312057938,
0.0373279899,
-0.0243647434,
-0.0039685955,
0.0615506358,
-0.0304343347,
0.0034292971,
0.0037289818,
-0.0208627861,
-0.001228845,
-0.0272927843,
-0.0421041846,
0.0193582736,
0.0629694387,
-0.045361992,
-0.024314804,
0.1093287915,
0.0352581069,
0.0397596247,
-0.0130012557,
0.0107495831,
-0.0025510523,
-0.0036133735,
0.0097844554,
-0.0390460081,
0.0084871594,
-0.0184951983,
0.0282160174,
-0.0459464081,
-0.0173733365,
-0.0349673666,
-0.1080413982,
0.042070929,
0.0089103794,
-0.0148094175,
-0.0313904136,
-0.0471353903,
0.0013628785,
-0.0011174892,
-0.0005368315,
0.0145210195,
-0.0121660465,
0.0232846998,
0.0344127454,
-0.0541675761,
-0.00288772,
0.0194208696,
-0.0199115407,
0.0174371544,
0.0557413325,
0.0486083589,
-0.0309451446,
-0.0327092186,
-0.0259412415,
-0.0418216176,
-0.0203051455,
0.0185115058,
0.0225943755,
-0.0247018319,
0.0137080308,
-0.0432429463,
0.0023853818,
0.0404511504,
-0.0197867434,
-0.011336254,
0.0469702557,
-0.0032146005,
-0.0281828009,
-0.0403845385,
0.0518278964,
-0.03191128,
0.1189045981,
0.0321778804,
-0.0091148829,
-0.0047459886,
-0.0516602322,
-0.0056550233,
-0.0261101592,
-0.032874763,
0.0262926053,
-0.0091520082,
-0.0203955248,
-0.0934309363,
-0.052524887,
-0.0268300455,
-0.007566534,
-0.0549313836,
-0.0024493372,
0.0158188697,
-0.0053344346,
0.0099752322,
-0.0142030185,
-0.0400604866,
0.019324271,
-0.0373804793,
-0.0016433366,
0.0570696555,
-0.042740602,
-0.0130854649,
-0.0037309472,
-0.0736435503,
-0.0445969701,
-0.0181054547,
0.0222856589,
0.0180514548,
-0.0131778587,
-0.0094161248,
-0.0294011142,
0.045720946,
0.0449353084,
-0.0338412896,
0.0795368701,
0.0038098379,
0.0194024667,
-0.0060919109,
0.0012920426,
-0.0399538949,
0.0238139778,
-0.0239983741,
0.064673163,
-0.0008688094,
-0.0920901448,
0.0359571725,
0.0611086674,
-0.0015286533,
-0.0296072289,
0.0285173841,
-0.0232555009,
-0.0210879128,
-0.0482121035,
-0.0266087875,
-0.0231580101,
0.0049891379,
-0.0109411972,
0.0182843301,
-0.040010646,
0.0020212098,
-0.0639872923,
0.0504675619,
-0.0185507089,
-0.0100937644,
-0.0122439628,
-0.007144921,
-0.043700356,
-0.0372354686,
-0.0704290941,
-0.0348353758,
-0.0405300595,
0.0284266248,
0.0219969302,
0.0423415676,
0.0080656502,
-0.0005142039,
0.0291400496,
-0.0007202569,
-0.0695862919,
0.0240197349,
-0.0722886547,
0.0234314837,
0.0462023392,
0.0130575895,
0.06834694,
-0.0331957862,
-0.0093744881,
-0.0309451371,
0.0196439214,
0.0422902331,
-0.0373251513,
0.0083277291,
-0.0034909714,
-0.0224521849,
-0.0053513739,
0.0748970956,
0.0183253363,
0.0051255212,
0.0003524087,
-0.0403261222,
-0.0212495904,
-0.0680922568,
-0.0496517383,
-0.03457091,
0.0250980835,
-0.0131123764,
-0.1047417596,
-0.0442177802,
0.0095814979,
0.0480585247,
0.0338687077,
-0.0335736983,
0.0103225997,
0.0506514944,
0.0040002503,
0.0098746503,
-0.0859984159,
0.0154865561,
-0.0137696723,
0.0555508696,
-0.0145513359,
-6.16994283e-33,
-0.0395357162,
-0.0451954268,
0.0150403837,
0.001330548,
-0.0280783307,
0.0067603346,
-0.0432490073,
-0.0011990966,
-0.0159861334,
0.0454637781,
0.0039786231,
0.0051259641,
0.0032986894,
0.0157874506,
-0.0259273984,
-0.0067325933,
0.0322988369,
0.005301849,
-0.069915764,
0.0176318381,
0.0186893474,
-0.0634272993,
0.0262347404,
-0.0182610396,
0.0698898211,
-0.046835117,
-0.0346234404,
0.0161709916,
-0.0329524614,
0.0586666949,
0.0034122483,
0.0643485859,
0.0339902602,
-0.034509439,
0.0054531829,
-0.0207384881,
-0.0286589097,
-0.0469287224,
0.063966319,
-0.0646314397,
-0.0348359384,
-0.0189879686,
0.0053323526,
-0.0005993076,
-0.0422961488,
-0.0342468135,
0.0435123891,
-0.0354396254,
-0.0037605485,
-0.0706525892,
-0.0350959711,
0.0327547789,
0.0218138695,
0.0014817709,
-0.0623026304,
0.0091177784,
-0.0076027974,
-0.0063994452,
-0.0331477448,
0.0166371036,
0.0218984485,
0.0007217323,
0.0351739414,
-0.0260349419,
-0.012045579,
0.0710514635,
-0.0261209104,
0.0034572028,
-0.0818374008,
-0.0098773269,
-0.0295148008,
-0.0056928918,
0.0601051673,
0.1002221778,
0.0076918351,
0.0145687666,
-0.0787984282,
0.0773064345,
0.0209398139,
0.0271715447,
0.0301633626,
-0.0531225614,
-0.0337439813,
0.0000422909,
-0.0494796671,
0.0346825011,
-0.0158334449,
-0.0104881246,
0.0006817571,
-0.0112843448,
-0.0218887758,
-0.0355212875,
-0.0001341032,
-0.0119949542,
0.0356725417,
0.0170747153,
-0.0674883425,
0.0178635959,
-0.0031640122,
0.0287779011,
-0.0380517356,
0.0533446334,
0.0201445483,
0.023116326,
0.0024529404,
-0.0046574571,
0.0188114867,
0.0011948441,
-0.0208928939,
0.0327028483,
-0.0322524272,
0.0118060485,
-0.0139037762,
-0.0357076637,
0.0170883406,
0.0028709702,
-0.0213676356,
0.0084290151,
-0.0309566129,
0.0283532031,
-0.0212537758,
-0.0428605713,
0.0392730422,
0.0287780706,
-0.0297087114,
0.0607159361,
-0.0058454974,
0.0235728305,
0.0071599958,
-0.0213583931,
-0.0057846131,
0.0151671227,
2.469e-7,
0.033069022,
0.0259571187,
0.0309076235,
0.0400220118,
-0.0126639912,
0.0348749869,
-0.0239645913,
0.015919853,
0.0309364442,
-0.036239177,
0.0040322165,
0.0427467749,
0.0556428507,
0.0555717275,
-0.0242765006,
0.0154882371,
-0.0982307643,
-0.0202190094,
-0.0166500323,
-0.0097386343,
0.0728681087,
0.0409048423,
0.0078679193,
-0.0183509532,
-0.0097103054,
-0.0405404307,
0.0679839104,
0.0088788951,
-0.0846715197,
0.0265620854,
0.0951881856,
-0.0031281789,
0.0234664008,
-0.0123492982,
-0.0096024713,
0.000415478,
0.0334354714,
0.0515765846,
0.0250065364,
-0.0216571391,
0.0000544616,
-0.0309195165,
0.0336202197,
-0.0572736301,
0.0578617677,
-0.0007114848,
-0.0052762213,
-0.0219608862,
-0.0350269713,
0.0264056567,
0.0079694139,
-0.0334076583,
-0.0483005308,
0.0216598604,
-0.004661561,
0.0074480362,
0.013949953,
0.0007606502,
-0.0452563092,
0.0089127216,
-0.0300223678,
-0.0940221027,
0.0047975434,
0.0124110123,
-0.0093778512,
-0.0588716827,
0.013168633,
2.199209881e-34,
0.0661659315,
-0.0217463672,
0.0022166769,
-0.0481812246,
0.0493622795,
0.0406447314,
-0.0049965284,
-0.0276734997,
0.0034509324,
-0.0608744808,
-0.0084004337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00671v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00671v1 | Emotion Detection for Misinformation: A Review | 2023-11-01T17:21:09 | 2023-11-01T17:21:09 | Zhiwei Liu, Tianlin Zhang, Kailai Yang, Paul Thompson, Zeping Yu, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advent of social media, an increasing number of netizens are sharing
and reading posts and news online. However, the huge volumes of misinformation
(e.g., fake news and rumors) that flood the internet can adversely affect
people's lives, and have resulted in the emergence of rumor and fake news
detection as a hot research topic. The emotions and sentiments of netizens, as
expressed in social media posts and news, constitute important factors that can
help to distinguish fake news from genuine news and to understand the spread of
rumors. This article comprehensively reviews emotion-based methods for
misinformation detection. We begin by explaining the strong links between
emotions and misinformation. We subsequently provide a detailed analysis of a
range of misinformation detection methods that employ a variety of emotion,
sentiment and stance-based features, and describe their strengths and
weaknesses. Finally, we discuss a number of ongoing challenges in emotion-based
misinformation detection based on large language models and suggest future
research directions, including data collection (multi-platform, multilingual),
annotation, benchmark, multimodality, and interpretability. | [
0.0414124951,
0.0575619414,
0.0067758835,
0.0421175472,
-0.0177599806,
0.0182450339,
-0.0127548194,
-0.0007533169,
0.0284041688,
-0.0758714452,
-0.0356984735,
-0.0300133005,
-0.0157719236,
0.0136498492,
-0.0060358611,
-0.0202760473,
0.0400065407,
0.0638563037,
0.0813565478,
-0.0102261612,
0.0576228276,
0.0652487725,
-0.0173450597,
0.0389526896,
-0.062876001,
-0.0431487784,
0.0180191714,
0.0267788656,
0.0473708473,
-0.0367071182,
0.0235722307,
0.0458001494,
0.0484152548,
0.0440976955,
0.0000018009,
-0.0030943085,
-0.0179133397,
-0.0048228339,
-0.0234400574,
-0.0091950782,
0.1033952683,
-0.0789995864,
-0.0169176962,
0.0153751718,
-0.0115653481,
-0.0411191434,
0.0408837236,
0.0681892186,
0.099172011,
0.0960304812,
-0.0272879507,
-0.0162045415,
-0.0358440429,
0.0172752291,
0.0043690647,
-0.0371543281,
0.0519359224,
0.005748596,
-0.0524904951,
0.0091776038,
0.0062666531,
-0.0065939887,
-0.0039852909,
-0.0042911647,
-0.0610560179,
-0.0237308666,
-0.0196054056,
-0.0539374463,
-0.0147903543,
0.0305192694,
-0.0497844219,
-0.0389783345,
-0.0109484335,
0.0066580898,
-0.0075864489,
0.0507902503,
-0.0051970901,
0.0236980896,
-0.0356741771,
0.0320300646,
0.0242798962,
-0.0029092066,
0.0408063233,
0.0695346892,
0.0456483886,
0.0390646383,
-0.0440965593,
-0.015442811,
0.0138651738,
0.0084758298,
-0.0206920616,
-0.0097675333,
0.0250408296,
-0.0206993204,
0.0077335997,
0.0370002314,
-0.0563467145,
-0.0342815928,
0.0145678651,
-0.1271692961,
-0.0631588101,
-0.0042934548,
0.0037315523,
0.036849089,
0.0124482075,
-0.0180727802,
-0.01187032,
-0.0210585967,
0.0170019418,
-0.0351309851,
-0.015889002,
0.0528328232,
-0.0015676912,
0.006686226,
-0.0232721716,
-0.011915517,
-0.0782054365,
-0.0186963957,
-0.0305627137,
-0.0043797093,
-0.0159834512,
-0.0112433545,
-0.0084882807,
-0.0122120054,
-0.0142388148,
0.0450467616,
0.016061699,
0.0275450237,
-0.0387649275,
-0.0443423055,
0.0248557236,
0.0014833293,
-0.0289228316,
0.0143813603,
0.0049612308,
0.0021014556,
0.0357835963,
0.0090855816,
-0.0448566675,
-0.0367378518,
-0.0167646948,
-0.0299460087,
0.0044911653,
-0.0639331266,
0.0098361159,
-0.0227348804,
0.0041502579,
-0.0173522849,
0.0122401044,
0.0217371378,
-0.0358856767,
0.0652882084,
-0.0139241433,
-0.0162463654,
0.0097879721,
0.0392029956,
0.0175038148,
0.0675953627,
-0.0076304534,
0.1117168367,
0.064579159,
0.030883098,
0.020065533,
-0.0047456962,
0.0394879989,
-0.0232935194,
0.0441953987,
-0.04987498,
-0.0142084453,
-0.017574342,
0.0035336998,
0.0160906911,
-0.0144735174,
-0.041613251,
0.0544695221,
-0.0140759367,
-0.0431087688,
-0.0068109636,
0.025971666,
0.0223717559,
0.0028257638,
-0.0452345684,
-0.0380096659,
0.0103955651,
-0.0491319858,
-0.0312144421,
0.0109849544,
0.0526554622,
0.0010037496,
-0.018024927,
-0.0193681419,
-0.009168461,
-0.0067781261,
-0.0362431258,
-0.0111114746,
-0.0146388374,
-0.0398654565,
0.0275411997,
0.0456766784,
-0.0246754065,
-0.0072983718,
-0.0348368324,
0.0005634196,
0.0440004431,
-0.0066044829,
0.0077748299,
0.0027260373,
-0.0366267487,
0.0174341276,
0.0301216003,
0.040736746,
-0.0211096276,
-0.028661456,
-0.0186167285,
0.0221891683,
-0.0094058178,
0.0205016267,
0.0036644279,
0.0250273868,
0.0700342208,
-0.0216829255,
-0.0407078154,
-0.0210431349,
0.0036682058,
-0.013127354,
0.0126534374,
-0.0240554959,
0.0417679884,
0.0249520373,
0.0340256356,
0.0142590376,
-0.0381863974,
0.0553075559,
0.0316510014,
-0.0414679758,
-0.0201003272,
0.0036428596,
-0.0577732772,
0.0279301368,
-0.0133213047,
-0.0295960456,
0.0259666909,
-0.0416806489,
0.0501072519,
0.0317297317,
-0.0191554744,
-0.0084276944,
-0.0349778943,
-0.0247439668,
-0.0345822982,
0.0484656692,
0.0358467065,
0.0646542534,
-0.0347278453,
-0.0164966714,
-0.0242950823,
-0.0177353211,
0.0028440638,
0.0078379838,
-0.0390374623,
-0.0057984628,
0.0236685611,
0.0095128976,
0.0054343417,
-0.0459831059,
-0.0008826975,
-0.0108304769,
-0.1017491072,
-0.0110212844,
-0.0280893669,
-0.0062706498,
0.0377759114,
-0.0097741652,
-0.0121298824,
0.0305634756,
-0.0141975842,
0.0043184399,
0.0117829544,
0.0112127718,
-0.01685909,
-0.0479555093,
0.0265803784,
-0.0313169919,
0.0314000547,
-0.0133866053,
0.032476902,
0.0323296338,
-0.0816804096,
-0.0058796424,
-0.0145669822,
-0.0742004365,
0.0465464331,
-0.0260213576,
-0.0421324037,
0.0034779678,
0.0359663628,
-0.0134043768,
0.0305526033,
0.0177977011,
0.1117437109,
0.0039508846,
0.0365112089,
-0.0064503499,
-0.0170069505,
-0.0513110161,
0.040094316,
-0.0313215852,
-0.0736505464,
-0.0044990485,
0.0482390299,
0.0205026213,
0.0107142078,
-0.0087111574,
0.0399418324,
-0.0060396683,
-0.0454221778,
0.0109949168,
-0.0392122045,
0.0199929569,
0.0009307405,
-0.0210075211,
-0.0492834002,
0.0770288557,
0.005093419,
0.0489583537,
-0.0596819371,
-0.0251593459,
-0.0104560247,
0.0281768925,
-0.039121218,
0.0460874587,
0.0218947399,
0.0378606655,
0.0424018353,
-0.0373841189,
0.0176465064,
-0.0297760312,
-0.0150734326,
-0.0455122702,
0.0075043659,
0.0715776831,
-0.0250823181,
-0.0248298943,
-0.103812322,
-0.0479802042,
-0.0405649357,
0.0170412939,
-0.0343206637,
-0.0441589504,
-0.0316175669,
0.0295915678,
-0.0339058749,
0.0209034141,
-0.0132274572,
0.0411788635,
0.0065927263,
0.0503912494,
-0.0304544568,
0.0721617341,
-0.0180637054,
-0.0147795891,
0.0780404583,
-0.0051934011,
-0.0097009921,
-0.0022224744,
-0.0276256874,
-0.0203915536,
0.0254035965,
-0.0039232019,
-0.0359970294,
0.0431208014,
-0.0395352133,
0.042133607,
0.1110458672,
0.0231362171,
-0.0104996115,
0.023945393,
0.0060370751,
-0.0185393412,
0.0214317553,
-0.004607616,
-0.0323892646,
-0.0212690346,
-0.0428482033,
-0.0033995796,
-0.0339384302,
-0.0046887491,
-0.0208565127,
-0.0773491412,
0.013651818,
-0.0151100345,
-0.0148793524,
-0.0460651703,
-0.0445796363,
0.0081772311,
-0.0034289502,
-0.0077927615,
-0.0322070159,
0.0385834873,
-0.0210403632,
-0.006398974,
-0.0335531645,
-0.0406489559,
0.0257019196,
-0.000828432,
0.0616890825,
-0.011265167,
0.0879262611,
-0.0143514993,
-0.0633729249,
0.016884204,
0.0288193654,
-0.0313700587,
-0.0380173475,
0.0713544115,
-0.0636900291,
-0.0240795203,
-0.0422013886,
0.0263083652,
-0.006836141,
-0.0054783286,
-0.0519738905,
0.0397785753,
0.0170366988,
-0.0663647354,
-0.0322966054,
0.0341541916,
0.0762674287,
0.0433517583,
-0.0108086839,
-0.0001636712,
-0.0079138679,
-0.0276793092,
0.0071981167,
0.0146905389,
-0.0565398298,
0.0108457794,
-0.0124350013,
-0.041854132,
-0.0479139872,
-0.0423913859,
-0.0038538072,
0.0301954132,
-0.0398823805,
-0.0057710283,
0.0458460338,
-0.0189651717,
-0.0481347069,
0.0176136028,
0.01267255,
0.0616263673,
0.0137519585,
0.0050431667,
0.0077351099,
0.0003025991,
-0.0172478985,
0.0146618523,
-0.0481312498,
-0.0281938724,
-0.0065548448,
0.0138321053,
0.0079219267,
0.0122576943,
-0.0079153655,
-0.0336672403,
0.0432968289,
0.0257574171,
0.010970166,
0.0218007322,
0.0242426787,
0.0206163879,
0.0292521417,
0.0244421102,
0.0018513547,
0.0439627767,
0.0132188592,
-0.0266188085,
-0.0428322107,
-0.0214423668,
0.0176574532,
0.0186575763,
0.0375122614,
0.005433837,
-0.006262389,
-0.0254355017,
-0.065938741,
-0.0005699165,
-0.0327367745,
0.0030101149,
0.0088837808,
0.0222175587,
0.0019437382,
-0.0471153371,
-0.0293686669,
0.005583039,
-0.0188251827,
0.0123074073,
-0.0184600931,
0.0295161828,
0.0439978689,
0.0038505639,
-0.0042885323,
-0.0218744855,
0.0014925655,
0.0055523263,
0.009383373,
-0.0040311175,
0.0252007805,
-0.0030872298,
-0.0423033834,
0.0088839652,
-0.023998525,
0.0210785121,
0.0126042552,
-0.034936741,
0.013373686,
0.0142110558,
-0.0208858065,
0.0600647442,
-0.044533506,
-0.0024291608,
-0.0070106429,
-0.0211001113,
-0.023740761,
-0.0529738888,
0.0070728417,
0.0052040964,
-0.0351113863,
0.0424998589,
0.0394596234,
-0.0357210934,
0.0669822842,
0.0185800474,
-0.1020294428,
-0.0344822928,
0.0333521515,
0.0034179317,
0.031267006,
0.0066026808,
0.0558289737,
-0.0979585126,
-0.0359055027,
0.0464551114,
-0.0059544505,
-0.0050878124,
0.0242658164,
-0.0212864876,
0.1060145199,
0.011346166,
0.0542850867,
-0.0760931447,
-0.0231696367,
-0.0734376386,
-0.0378058515,
0.004518393,
-5.885297608e-33,
0.0214234479,
-0.0605678484,
-0.0565830469,
-0.0110827684,
-0.0056724302,
0.0481942073,
0.0083064791,
-0.0004382541,
-0.0175761655,
0.0785384923,
0.0671580136,
0.0355459228,
-0.0142050516,
-0.0199818891,
-0.0606226362,
-0.0232192278,
0.031837523,
0.0089365141,
-0.009641937,
0.0030225851,
0.0719804987,
-0.0101383468,
0.0420550518,
-0.113968052,
0.0711899474,
-0.0128686326,
-0.0324304178,
0.0239575114,
0.0003123202,
0.0338380449,
-0.009587232,
0.0717126802,
0.031138707,
-0.0190074183,
0.0010247891,
0.0196633395,
-0.0132829128,
-0.0059499904,
0.0329915099,
-0.004613033,
-0.0034376318,
0.0209086984,
0.017949013,
0.0248725321,
-0.0269561261,
0.0075977398,
0.015771186,
-0.0039152103,
0.0323726721,
-0.021086039,
-0.0602546781,
-0.0015233764,
0.0116932774,
-0.0151983397,
-0.024802424,
0.0738136023,
0.0073812003,
0.0210574809,
-0.1051597297,
0.0125411879,
-0.0685960427,
0.0007601413,
-0.0017080067,
-0.0663193986,
-0.0124473181,
0.0973010883,
0.0297761094,
0.0344112255,
-0.0391700156,
0.0708172619,
-0.0076736622,
0.0415262319,
0.0408587828,
0.1022691205,
-0.0057283714,
-0.0367700495,
-0.0745349601,
0.0095374165,
0.0572954752,
-0.01325553,
0.0500259958,
-0.0000867007,
-0.0297219865,
0.0038206999,
-0.0033489231,
-0.0129785435,
-0.0213093907,
-0.0189563632,
-0.0158829987,
0.0096702008,
-0.0313284695,
0.0503093228,
-0.0053037363,
-0.0350138135,
-0.0261332672,
0.0561390556,
-0.0122720273,
0.032619033,
0.0123830438,
0.0624212064,
-0.029191168,
0.0372198932,
0.0276475605,
0.0212684795,
0.0188174564,
-0.0064562662,
0.0417820551,
0.0070002,
-0.035073705,
0.0119617311,
-0.0352397971,
0.0407409444,
-0.016462924,
-0.0012244601,
0.0089971535,
0.0053045698,
-0.0382926315,
-0.0191028751,
-0.0183359608,
0.0391702913,
0.0298317093,
-0.0076939822,
-0.0504841246,
0.0328395888,
-0.0316455513,
0.0002143694,
-0.0239911377,
-0.01448562,
-0.033577539,
-0.0803087652,
0.015869908,
-0.0101635121,
2.625e-7,
0.0062886137,
0.080757156,
-0.0138128065,
-0.0353968441,
0.0576362349,
0.0676092356,
0.0096084978,
-0.0039205612,
0.0065284539,
-0.1017826125,
-0.0315006487,
0.0450957045,
0.0091028279,
0.0522329696,
-0.0488935076,
0.0058143893,
-0.0066778124,
-0.0007317134,
-0.0391716175,
0.0257937331,
0.0331317857,
0.0729796365,
0.0521028526,
-0.0178156942,
-0.0110471491,
0.0522968061,
0.0463189892,
0.0233219769,
-0.0682402328,
0.0076327058,
0.0277635343,
-0.0362241603,
0.0070539024,
0.0036896111,
-0.0003819273,
-0.0324933715,
0.0233714748,
0.0104144691,
0.0156043768,
-0.00068637,
0.0126735317,
-0.0020456724,
-0.0071653505,
-0.020126991,
0.0268385299,
-0.0219238754,
-0.0541776232,
-0.0706364065,
-0.01676118,
0.0230417661,
0.0247240104,
-0.009659105,
-0.045579683,
0.0251846258,
0.0229285657,
-0.0128497873,
-0.0176005866,
-0.0276761856,
0.0145954937,
0.0294733625,
-0.0566113852,
-0.010896517,
0.0147643322,
-0.0241917875,
0.062445119,
-0.0071683526,
0.0377961174,
1.793936278e-34,
0.0146205043,
-0.0141908973,
-0.0235152002,
-0.0145515837,
0.0372845456,
0.0396731384,
-0.0564180017,
-0.0301966351,
0.0198369157,
-0.004884697,
0.0368569121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00658v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00658v1 | Explicit Morphological Knowledge Improves Pre-training of Language Models for Hebrew | 2023-11-01T17:02:49 | 2023-11-01T17:02:49 | Eylon Gueta, Omer Goldman, Reut Tsarfaty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown remarkable successes in
acquiring a wide range of linguistic knowledge, relying solely on
self-supervised training on text streams. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of
this language-agnostic approach has been frequently questioned for its
sub-optimal performance when applied to morphologically-rich languages (MRLs).
We investigate the hypothesis that incorporating explicit morphological
knowledge in the pre-training phase can improve the performance of PLMs for
MRLs. We propose various morphologically driven tokenization methods enabling
the model to leverage morphological cues beyond raw text. We pre-train multiple
language models utilizing the different methods and evaluate them on Hebrew, a
language with complex and highly ambiguous morphology. Our experiments show
that morphologically driven tokenization demonstrates improved results compared
to a standard language-agnostic tokenization, on a benchmark of both semantic
and morphologic tasks. These findings suggest that incorporating morphological
knowledge holds the potential for further improving PLMs for morphologically
rich languages. | [
-0.011916046,
0.075278312,
-0.0143118529,
0.0235507172,
-0.030588245,
0.0179560427,
0.0271015763,
0.0352651514,
-0.0666942373,
-0.0305618811,
-0.0190858655,
-0.0782842934,
0.0106200036,
-0.0120708384,
0.0552421734,
-0.0422394387,
0.0379199199,
-0.0585607141,
-0.0229329187,
0.0062885419,
0.0357291885,
0.0463618524,
0.0137853483,
-0.0134742819,
-0.0699108317,
0.006338777,
-0.0054433364,
0.0126803424,
-0.0016502815,
0.0024316534,
-0.0605407394,
0.0501664616,
-0.0299557634,
0.037428759,
0.0000017312,
-0.0529305041,
-0.017891299,
-0.0164420828,
-0.0146991415,
0.0386266522,
0.0877577066,
-0.0789054334,
-0.0398342796,
0.0055584218,
-0.0078150583,
-0.0145940389,
0.0578125976,
0.0129378065,
0.0127720088,
0.0451764651,
-0.0028085781,
-0.0365381315,
0.0575754009,
-0.0080571501,
-0.0607106313,
0.0412784256,
0.0226986222,
-0.0420315526,
-0.047632996,
-0.0007432816,
-0.0192906559,
0.024100041,
0.0091126142,
0.0198599324,
-0.0387825966,
0.0312630087,
-0.0425854512,
-0.0625729337,
0.0537757576,
-0.0115363402,
-0.0678108856,
-0.0538231097,
0.0100740381,
-0.0142284585,
-0.0267159734,
-0.0320431031,
-0.0146512007,
0.0512618609,
-0.0222901143,
0.0505673885,
0.0181992576,
-0.0161458831,
0.0162591115,
0.0091560464,
-0.0533616617,
0.0209748559,
0.0620053597,
-0.0124234082,
0.0053471592,
0.0202083234,
-0.0201191492,
-0.0399595462,
0.0010894649,
-0.0061197714,
0.008513228,
0.0085353022,
-0.0122207189,
-0.0500408858,
0.0340752974,
-0.016184004,
0.0520690344,
0.0036042931,
-0.0631149262,
-0.0106067089,
-0.0926688015,
-0.0030832838,
0.093550548,
0.0211693551,
-0.0307440199,
-0.0044336277,
0.0056067058,
-0.0157401618,
-0.0596593618,
0.0404859744,
-0.0259209462,
0.0402860269,
-0.0281741191,
0.019970933,
0.0640419573,
-0.0305360686,
-0.0211769268,
-0.0512026139,
-0.0684331805,
-0.0433981195,
0.0017568851,
-0.0116704972,
-0.0459978767,
-0.0082626399,
-0.043432679,
-0.0796585754,
0.0062678577,
0.0341565758,
0.0027038939,
-0.0087423353,
0.0045246431,
0.0769556537,
-0.0073818751,
-0.0828485638,
-0.0284312479,
0.0204851851,
-0.0518975221,
-0.0030534486,
-0.0316649787,
-0.0578053184,
0.0261881929,
-0.0097225839,
-0.0362825245,
0.0014388546,
-0.0358379744,
-0.0049752663,
0.0219074655,
0.0745346174,
-0.0053161546,
-0.0130300792,
0.003430231,
-0.0082473308,
0.0339112319,
0.0474519134,
-0.0314002596,
0.0247271601,
0.0096009942,
-0.0148866372,
-0.0085403239,
0.0474418066,
-0.0008122972,
0.0159060117,
-0.0878585204,
-0.003477752,
0.0148014398,
0.0200554375,
0.0462512188,
0.0561368614,
-0.0190347806,
-0.0196023658,
0.0584344566,
0.1077648327,
-0.0121856313,
0.0376390517,
0.0400727242,
0.0296435449,
0.0363071822,
0.0089149,
-0.004871869,
-0.0267527755,
-0.0230682567,
0.0558832102,
-0.0595161878,
0.0895306244,
-0.017657226,
-0.0563957877,
-0.0196401142,
-0.0326099694,
-0.057440687,
-0.0176432636,
0.0705139339,
0.0549956225,
-0.0240310691,
0.0129208146,
0.0662747771,
-0.0487225316,
0.0617587008,
-0.0190402996,
0.0277351309,
0.0097952662,
0.0045895372,
-0.023397861,
-0.0606845878,
0.0206406973,
0.0010589423,
0.0532874279,
-0.0024106719,
0.0156311803,
0.0102056358,
-0.0333128348,
0.0376740471,
0.0256631598,
0.0314612053,
0.0336917751,
-0.0165360272,
0.0381282344,
0.0223796666,
-0.0260246526,
-0.035413973,
0.0547296666,
-0.0052836612,
0.0111214286,
-0.0328073055,
-0.0072163073,
0.000961482,
-0.0048142197,
-0.023428848,
0.0000943806,
0.0130960112,
-0.0368121378,
0.0050291084,
-0.0018380892,
-0.0675101429,
-0.0210957807,
0.0434976965,
0.0115706716,
-0.0262078252,
-0.0372986048,
0.0201581791,
-0.0146669773,
0.0534624271,
-0.0211997647,
0.0870961249,
-0.0711594522,
0.0517456681,
0.0159094352,
0.0241136644,
-0.0326903984,
0.0371075459,
0.037216939,
-0.00754264,
0.0119771911,
-0.0424351245,
0.0076360595,
-0.0027516263,
-0.0304165129,
0.0070231571,
-0.0293797795,
-0.0307468697,
0.009895944,
-0.0068952376,
-0.0069219102,
-0.0503140204,
-0.1140675768,
-0.0418771617,
-0.0357246101,
0.0387445837,
-0.0013374637,
0.0338018611,
-0.0012085937,
-0.0187305324,
-0.0273364689,
0.0052342908,
-0.0065415478,
0.003446022,
0.0318162814,
-0.0231727716,
-0.0118707214,
-0.0582543314,
-0.0108804125,
-0.0007501422,
0.0514700972,
0.0414728932,
0.0021276134,
0.0103538278,
-0.0473612845,
-0.0318852477,
0.01862037,
0.0066195051,
-0.0374101251,
0.019287033,
-0.0430922098,
0.0865246579,
0.0099714855,
0.0134505872,
-0.0256602876,
0.0190335121,
-0.0365570374,
-0.05026244,
-0.0237352159,
-0.0083826371,
-0.0057210657,
-0.0870199576,
-0.0140611902,
-0.0027750968,
0.0754891783,
-0.0313180909,
-0.0092857359,
-0.00924992,
0.0361454487,
-0.0460713468,
0.0184772108,
0.0337120034,
0.0265052803,
-0.030959582,
0.0561110899,
-0.0103873024,
-0.0620304681,
0.0553683527,
-0.0787101388,
-0.0470651463,
-0.0074565047,
-0.0031397257,
-0.0421016887,
0.0330018625,
0.032724537,
0.0181829259,
0.0303950701,
-0.0404023789,
-0.0499797277,
0.0292337425,
-0.0008544236,
-0.000178751,
0.0267096255,
-0.0251509473,
-0.0027326946,
-0.0165069792,
-0.0258575492,
-0.0187072121,
-0.0282207262,
-0.0024483455,
0.0170059223,
0.042926386,
0.000869886,
0.005968356,
0.0415170118,
-0.056690976,
0.0341802947,
0.0103151388,
0.0038868983,
-0.0303197056,
0.0150044952,
0.0104595609,
-0.0385522246,
-0.0029078501,
0.0080756312,
0.00836612,
-0.0081213862,
-0.0443029925,
-0.0249756798,
-0.0323860534,
-0.0002167807,
0.0316328742,
-0.0785757974,
-0.0299254488,
-0.0163913537,
-0.004551468,
0.00447529,
-0.0067343181,
0.0934172049,
0.0350249223,
-0.0120379264,
0.0115584945,
0.0056464188,
0.0275249537,
0.0037492001,
0.0158736873,
-0.0490224846,
0.0014505809,
0.0149797173,
-0.0032828052,
0.0408173203,
-0.0195744988,
0.031094037,
-0.0858846903,
-0.0321589969,
0.0119184712,
-0.0610320158,
0.0211512838,
0.0018663948,
-0.0131261023,
-0.0193224754,
0.024614701,
0.0018477553,
-0.0532914586,
0.0414391495,
0.0510615632,
-0.0210825913,
-0.0178683419,
-0.0164434668,
-0.0480648838,
0.009787729,
0.0234356355,
0.0153939454,
-0.0698655248,
0.0082681896,
0.058472503,
0.0072387462,
-0.011968174,
-0.0156735182,
0.0075631128,
0.0180171989,
-0.026997339,
-0.0027753434,
-0.0261726342,
0.0089384606,
-0.0124933496,
-0.0350370817,
0.0548446476,
0.0371949933,
0.0073704803,
0.0375648662,
0.0145499865,
-0.059536323,
0.0301714707,
0.0262379516,
-0.0325475521,
-0.0594982021,
-0.023369465,
0.008888647,
-0.0336642675,
-0.0417364724,
-0.0275339987,
0.0248069093,
-0.0153818587,
-0.1014675274,
-0.0519110635,
0.0265745949,
0.0424597524,
0.0192132518,
-0.0154821025,
-0.0168869216,
-0.0138985096,
-0.0170478225,
0.038462162,
0.0212235861,
-0.017543612,
-0.0865775123,
-0.0285552703,
0.0553395711,
-0.0456427485,
0.0120245907,
-0.0025328405,
-0.0043185023,
-0.0392422527,
0.0311038997,
0.0196673609,
0.0080705127,
0.0511185862,
-0.0326542407,
-0.0250234492,
0.0518776663,
0.0226065163,
-0.0402985886,
0.0189652927,
0.0594931692,
0.0108947968,
-0.0219345391,
0.0309806056,
0.0274348799,
0.0578878783,
0.0544725172,
-0.0022710371,
-0.0366874561,
-0.0306226853,
0.0159781277,
0.0193696376,
0.0605313964,
-0.0269516613,
0.0393595584,
-0.0407136418,
-0.0348569751,
-0.0078019039,
0.0163058974,
-0.0308652613,
0.0152968317,
0.0497332625,
0.0307571888,
-0.0185875725,
0.0337546766,
-0.035584446,
0.0154260108,
0.0163472202,
0.0185417384,
0.0264635347,
-0.0126969526,
-0.0066331513,
0.0306250639,
0.0298602767,
-0.0076638851,
-0.0226782691,
0.0282473825,
-0.082235001,
-0.0264264736,
-0.0427524559,
0.0196754672,
-0.0112777026,
0.0199670307,
0.028883934,
-0.0181588382,
-0.057737954,
0.0523003787,
0.0369567908,
-0.0222284589,
0.0416484028,
-0.0429927595,
0.0027254503,
-0.0145269651,
0.0176556353,
0.0058691432,
-0.0184620712,
0.0017390117,
0.001468995,
-0.0546818189,
-0.0630580336,
0.0348264165,
0.042930413,
0.0045768609,
0.0093719438,
-0.0007696765,
-0.0035152733,
-0.0206498783,
0.0221070796,
0.0016430146,
-0.0542461984,
0.0110531868,
-0.0678421035,
-0.080002591,
-0.0002260047,
0.0168592166,
0.0064367428,
0.0344771929,
0.0341266282,
0.0649608672,
0.0034953295,
0.0132237282,
-0.023178516,
0.0088864947,
0.0668375865,
-0.0138356127,
0.0116777457,
-5.408574404e-33,
-0.0132661387,
0.0400710143,
-0.0116896518,
-0.0275361184,
0.0229659304,
0.0199751072,
-0.0038508745,
0.0237182472,
0.0092949411,
-0.0122666005,
-0.0139894392,
-0.0002002717,
0.0235145614,
0.0152976466,
0.0579303205,
0.0372086056,
0.0476717949,
-0.0076966034,
-0.0018569229,
-0.0161460415,
-0.0027927351,
0.0597396158,
0.1162099838,
0.0293263923,
-0.016728865,
0.0179264173,
0.0292252116,
0.0058004959,
0.0030333572,
0.0360769555,
-0.0092399307,
0.0243420955,
-0.0055946531,
-0.0128811784,
-0.0362407789,
-0.0063490686,
-0.0924137086,
-0.0201051738,
0.048807513,
0.0502282828,
-0.0523056388,
0.0088236034,
-0.0132106058,
-0.0457909182,
-0.0110310093,
0.0202837177,
0.0251511466,
-0.0026197978,
-0.0137382653,
-0.0319487825,
-0.0785175785,
0.0576488525,
0.0043949592,
0.0387739986,
0.0974476337,
-0.0364387967,
0.043716155,
0.0231982917,
0.0080116149,
-0.0384699143,
0.009216655,
0.0590897948,
0.0391615517,
0.0385048389,
-0.0593914837,
0.017701216,
0.0501304716,
-0.0414438024,
0.0561294518,
0.0518134199,
0.0789631084,
-0.0277565699,
0.0167385954,
0.0171036143,
0.0174658541,
-0.0122191822,
-0.0334276706,
-0.0138478102,
0.0155798597,
0.0150802592,
0.0074400557,
0.0054005515,
-0.0184146129,
-0.0085060094,
-0.0052158032,
-0.0878340006,
-0.0195763912,
0.003873901,
0.0209328737,
0.0266784858,
-0.0176067781,
0.063600935,
0.0036734205,
0.0201793723,
-0.0234487001,
-0.0204669721,
-0.0053535793,
0.0019688085,
-0.033584822,
0.0443833098,
-0.0295041203,
-0.0661264434,
0.0074986261,
-0.0165146962,
0.0003218235,
-0.0189645439,
0.0648765564,
-0.0152739827,
-0.0621874817,
0.01233932,
-0.0248829052,
0.0164346956,
0.0146638304,
0.031883128,
0.024246987,
0.0193558484,
0.0091650346,
0.0132320058,
0.0496134982,
-0.0515555777,
-0.0250384286,
0.0302035082,
-0.0217340905,
0.0161445998,
-0.0127394563,
-0.0047331043,
0.0159107409,
0.0173014551,
0.0601620413,
-0.0136899371,
-0.003612102,
0.0453018881,
2.468e-7,
0.0671710074,
0.0331023037,
0.0214186478,
-0.0298855156,
0.0031366998,
0.0000015177,
-0.0151682794,
-0.0064440854,
-0.0156538375,
0.0429155678,
-0.0034474931,
-0.0051847212,
0.0405888632,
0.0169786885,
-0.0996934548,
-0.024127489,
-0.0712760165,
0.0327477008,
-0.0933987051,
0.0048492239,
0.0274278075,
0.1350588351,
-0.031347055,
-0.0339828841,
-0.0021475328,
-0.0288512744,
0.0417916477,
-0.0308290292,
0.0177361462,
0.0604179651,
0.0404380262,
-0.033963751,
0.0099270688,
0.0058846287,
-0.0455383882,
0.0089781452,
0.0510540158,
0.0399734415,
0.0047723004,
0.0148943402,
0.0331425145,
0.00078856,
-0.0269626286,
-0.0529013947,
0.0533780642,
-0.0190513413,
0.0281706788,
0.0233295001,
-0.03019486,
0.0282483026,
-0.0134955226,
0.0108575765,
-0.0491327122,
0.0517456084,
0.0690558553,
-0.0157701001,
-0.0349706188,
-0.0681480244,
0.0194393303,
0.0274697822,
-0.0043863901,
-0.0076164184,
-0.0331961028,
0.0260906592,
0.0086967144,
0.0061870236,
-0.0107994536,
2.414538635e-34,
0.0121142771,
0.0060998537,
0.0235924143,
0.007090562,
-0.0066528083,
0.0067893993,
0.0346683003,
0.0609262064,
-0.0435416698,
-0.009478461,
0.0017413425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00629v1 | Formal Translation from Reversing Petri Nets to Coloured Petri Nets | 2023-11-01T16:28:38 | 2023-11-01T16:28:38 | Kamila Barylska, Anna Gogolinska, Lukasz Mikulski, Anna Philippou, Marcin Piatkowski, Kyriaki Psara | cs.LO | cs.LO, cs.CL, 03, F.2; G.0 | Reversible computation is an emerging computing paradigm that allows any
sequence of operations to be executed in reverse order at any point during
computation. Its appeal lies in its potential for lowpower computation and its
relevance to a wide array of applications such as chemical reactions, quantum
computation, robotics, and distributed systems. Reversing Petri nets are a
recently-proposed extension of Petri nets that implements the three main forms
of reversibility, namely, backtracking, causal reversing, and
out-of-causal-order reversing. Their distinguishing feature is the use of named
tokens that can be combined together to form bonds. Named tokens along with a
history function, constitute the means of remembering past behaviour, thus,
enabling reversal. In recent work, we have proposed a structural translation
from a subclass of RPNs to the model of Coloured Petri Nets (CPNs), an
extension of traditional Petri nets where tokens carry data values. In this
paper, we extend the translation to handle RPNs with token multiplicity under
the individual-token interpretation, a model which allows multiple tokens of
the same type to exist in a system. To support the three types of
reversibility, tokens are associated with their causal history and, while
tokens of the same type are equally eligible to fire a transition when going
forward, when going backwards they are able to reverse only the transitions
they have previously fired. The new translation, in addition to lifting the
restriction on token uniqueness, presents a refined approach for transforming
RPNs to CPNs through a unifying approach that allows instantiating each of the
three types of reversibility. The paper also reports on a tool that implements
this translation, paving the way for automated translations and analysis of
reversible systems using CPN Tools. | [
-0.0507679097,
0.0657214969,
-0.0366193727,
0.0017807094,
-0.089133054,
-0.0551221333,
0.0155226449,
0.0058605787,
-0.0269594882,
0.0178884547,
0.0027690304,
0.0173803177,
-0.02151227,
0.0367652252,
0.0416003726,
-0.0164593309,
0.0622828156,
0.0250326004,
-0.0136585087,
0.0122269709,
-0.0405250229,
-0.0303354654,
0.0043354267,
0.0245571993,
0.0324296579,
-0.0117758876,
-0.0347672403,
0.0404802337,
0.0323147662,
0.0106163416,
-0.0203533061,
0.0075666695,
-0.0155053288,
0.0058538932,
0.0000021717,
0.015364401,
-0.0284707844,
0.0941404179,
0.0473675504,
-0.0190395452,
-0.0375565067,
0.0497875735,
-0.0236118007,
-0.0008373566,
0.0338431597,
-0.0109223062,
0.0642452538,
0.035408847,
0.0391307026,
0.0225991476,
0.0127914157,
0.0367416143,
0.0777361169,
0.0261822157,
-0.0146464035,
-0.0167859793,
0.0100903092,
-0.0189099163,
0.0224038716,
-0.0599784069,
-0.013355663,
-0.0412808843,
0.0319958255,
-0.0191384256,
-0.032096453,
-0.0344482847,
0.022665171,
-0.0049712653,
-0.0392742306,
-0.0089587886,
-0.0229405481,
-0.0524833575,
-0.0060114879,
0.0091104982,
-0.0791235492,
-0.0326016992,
0.0010433571,
-0.009306916,
0.0176137071,
-0.00234703,
-0.0310732964,
0.0428088494,
0.0344209895,
-0.0182151906,
-0.0204237867,
0.0578304827,
0.0366784371,
0.0103381611,
-0.0303559434,
-0.0037002389,
0.0663052574,
0.0331900753,
0.0487059988,
-0.0155899972,
0.0321250297,
-0.0203762762,
0.0133753745,
0.0186389536,
0.0266072545,
-0.0446950123,
0.0137624685,
0.0250957459,
-0.0065278634,
-0.0015007332,
-0.0334008075,
0.0259663705,
-0.083583422,
0.010845568,
-0.0430454575,
-0.0487543494,
-0.0200009011,
-0.0021867948,
-0.0570316464,
0.0062058354,
0.0255058538,
-0.0308336392,
0.0128942402,
0.0556076169,
-0.0480463244,
0.0212387908,
-0.0111631807,
-0.0462158099,
0.0123402895,
-0.007050646,
0.0277828909,
0.0080246357,
0.029751543,
-0.0275358222,
-0.0177129004,
-0.0209967997,
-0.0196114182,
-0.0274406243,
-0.0549947396,
-0.0198664963,
-0.0426275395,
0.0500622615,
0.0084278192,
0.0142940916,
0.0001993238,
-0.030605711,
0.067094624,
-0.0295242444,
0.0565309189,
0.0000619074,
-0.0176999103,
-0.0089061996,
0.0364824235,
-0.0016926747,
-0.0037397246,
0.0070232078,
0.0153275253,
0.0430647247,
0.0191495977,
-0.0450595357,
-0.0527996756,
0.0194017496,
0.0054440242,
-0.0085701337,
-0.0053753974,
0.0026210037,
-0.007732417,
-0.029648371,
0.0037017658,
-0.0053944965,
0.0289467014,
-0.0291501824,
-0.0561201796,
-0.0388892256,
0.0170547217,
-0.0244485941,
-0.045921959,
0.0319964066,
-0.0146504156,
-0.0030064797,
-0.0402946398,
-0.0660312846,
-0.0101568224,
0.0600465424,
0.0118671237,
-0.0595146529,
-0.0301552676,
0.0171851143,
-0.0309985392,
0.0589518771,
-0.0087975357,
-0.0226399545,
-0.0578643456,
-0.0344939642,
-0.0047750939,
0.0009283011,
0.0112772426,
0.026900271,
0.0478492975,
-0.0559515283,
0.0739254504,
0.0857729763,
-0.0360282622,
0.0326227695,
-0.0065984922,
-0.0486173145,
-0.0288632251,
-0.0919438154,
-0.0341101438,
0.0629654676,
0.0123090446,
-0.0742634535,
-0.0129298205,
0.0537548885,
-0.0269010719,
-0.0007262264,
-0.0054890118,
0.0316698402,
-0.0213213544,
-0.0260425061,
0.0043778676,
0.0553033277,
0.050448399,
0.009440979,
-0.0111346543,
0.0067023672,
-0.0120753897,
0.0103437817,
0.0386698321,
-0.003408357,
0.0243549813,
0.0269372426,
0.0427503511,
0.010550336,
0.0364146791,
0.0231035762,
-0.0146761239,
0.0568053983,
0.0543013141,
0.0132578788,
-0.0396669991,
0.0203494821,
-0.0466323011,
0.0563495681,
-0.0101108365,
-0.0440944247,
0.0178028792,
0.070053637,
-0.0176108852,
-0.0434059985,
0.1055043787,
0.0256271549,
0.027520705,
0.0011901851,
-0.0112575404,
-0.0015478765,
-0.0071123443,
0.0175005719,
-0.0337221064,
-0.0129970107,
0.0129214572,
-0.0409643501,
-0.0545681566,
0.0067193378,
0.0073654167,
-0.0140576456,
-0.0119481673,
-0.0265142638,
0.0023463187,
0.018894637,
-0.0306304805,
0.0102505479,
0.0268229451,
0.0121383686,
0.0217807554,
-0.0072630537,
0.0315615647,
0.018182911,
0.0012547191,
0.0539170392,
-0.0303073749,
0.0342724286,
0.0306310095,
-0.0400628112,
-0.003805975,
-0.0023205401,
-0.0020656069,
-0.1038072407,
0.0261245202,
-0.0441174433,
-0.0350284688,
0.0084557999,
-0.033856377,
-0.048970297,
-0.0570677891,
-0.0362357982,
0.0260865912,
0.004001922,
-0.0439838618,
-0.0038372767,
0.0321091712,
-0.0148001136,
-0.0369101875,
-0.0102023883,
-0.0432789288,
0.0570577718,
0.0080876537,
-0.0139884986,
0.0083511798,
0.0113281887,
-0.05286083,
-0.0042599849,
0.0948914587,
-0.0077671264,
-0.0212829281,
0.0013718165,
-0.0000724952,
-0.0082989018,
-0.0086736847,
-0.0482890196,
-0.0011789992,
0.0057325736,
0.0075856918,
-0.0833873749,
0.0235481821,
-0.0036808688,
-0.0225092024,
-0.0164630972,
0.0537414066,
-0.0272745714,
0.025701955,
0.0299770143,
-0.0475975163,
0.0021487535,
0.0708796009,
0.0359393246,
0.0161351804,
-0.0315092877,
0.0113781104,
0.005372521,
-0.0706616417,
-0.0082048289,
0.0155763803,
-0.0295585375,
-0.0521915406,
0.0063640652,
0.0058111278,
-0.0387799591,
0.0004757503,
0.0378854237,
0.0457298495,
0.0427059494,
-0.0491110682,
-0.0033992538,
0.0249889661,
0.0598456934,
0.0107603231,
-0.0229160786,
0.0043131267,
-0.0124845477,
-0.0186738875,
-0.0272923168,
-0.0613018721,
-0.0828088447,
0.0267198943,
0.0190508347,
-0.018871922,
0.009289776,
0.0362519622,
-0.0313804708,
-0.051357206,
-0.0467099808,
-0.0099994596,
-0.0164977275,
0.0234726407,
-0.0469515957,
-0.0246437695,
-0.0381236449,
-0.0477058031,
-0.077817589,
0.0016515777,
-0.0140730422,
0.0154778995,
0.0111129303,
-0.0588041954,
-0.0231946725,
0.0188924428,
-0.0084024575,
0.0308360495,
-0.0063267183,
-0.015195881,
-0.0457686372,
0.0015517155,
-0.0402180403,
-0.0106709469,
-0.0272369403,
0.0251371767,
-0.0871805474,
-0.0288669206,
-0.0189170558,
-0.0273281801,
0.017019961,
0.0059479638,
0.0200968049,
0.0652556792,
-0.0029808076,
-0.0079034241,
0.0647974163,
0.0604604818,
-0.012842699,
0.0650908872,
-0.018481845,
0.0112709012,
-0.0023574966,
-0.0670767576,
-0.0204844195,
0.0395939425,
-0.02860016,
0.0362921357,
-0.0198941436,
-0.081253089,
0.0692374036,
-0.0590832382,
-0.0431461334,
-0.0306371991,
0.0259848535,
-0.0533278063,
-0.0200444721,
0.091387257,
-0.0165396798,
-0.0328830741,
-0.0242633801,
-0.0434061326,
0.0643845052,
0.0445713624,
-0.0185662173,
0.0174579658,
-0.0800077766,
0.0124707427,
-0.0048478791,
-0.0163788106,
-0.0311018154,
-0.102788806,
-0.0013758482,
-0.0113308756,
-0.0258900728,
0.0833554044,
-0.0198462736,
0.0264603663,
-0.0282625929,
-0.0459946841,
0.0941083729,
-0.0345981047,
-0.0827757791,
-0.0230412148,
-0.0466153435,
0.0262470078,
-0.0363069512,
-0.0610657185,
0.0202984139,
0.016152164,
-0.0513070114,
0.019923145,
0.0198797714,
0.0184889399,
0.0728268102,
0.0871551186,
0.0243478939,
-0.0739280954,
0.0222508032,
0.0236150138,
-0.0239465088,
0.0760685205,
0.0034203224,
-0.0133811189,
-0.0130401142,
-0.0198010691,
-0.0115819667,
-0.0336337499,
-0.0502240062,
0.0086703002,
0.0291656908,
0.0276318435,
0.0201578066,
-0.0252520572,
-0.0359379016,
0.0244862195,
0.0760827363,
0.0139362393,
0.014709129,
0.0458384268,
0.0469973423,
-0.0110357348,
0.0320932008,
-0.0591522865,
0.0476373471,
-0.0286640786,
-0.0547152199,
-0.0176079329,
-0.0494912826,
0.0418863781,
-0.0409826227,
0.0511405282,
-0.0079539921,
0.0495325029,
0.0643904433,
0.0295457467,
0.0287548546,
-0.0451854542,
0.0277289394,
0.0061742538,
0.0271952637,
-0.0267321616,
-0.0425823405,
0.0281506795,
0.0227754023,
-0.0660167336,
0.0461656824,
-0.0264497418,
-0.031049436,
0.0625533238,
0.04245748,
0.0433597974,
0.0868009254,
-0.0095084291,
-0.0056170085,
-0.0048218062,
-0.0263997801,
0.0460912138,
0.0089545259,
-0.0235008914,
-0.020075338,
0.0197897069,
0.0305716284,
-0.0089356843,
0.0121244425,
-0.0145650608,
0.0176544487,
-0.0502494089,
0.0129542323,
0.0011072418,
-0.0415115133,
-0.0346343778,
-0.0005144509,
0.0476889648,
-0.0592638366,
-0.0432778709,
-0.024990201,
-0.0356499664,
0.0414055996,
0.0473895743,
-0.0130044948,
0.0400508381,
0.019875925,
0.0225440785,
-0.018345058,
0.0304018427,
0.030366553,
0.0540440232,
-0.0396776497,
-0.0206910092,
-5.816000379e-33,
-0.0327960365,
-0.0180837475,
0.0213723499,
0.0751149878,
-0.0065873731,
-0.0480906777,
-0.041584596,
-0.0395095758,
0.0545241348,
0.0175547153,
0.0210391413,
-0.0316171721,
0.0444300584,
0.0011974631,
-0.0368077494,
0.0402437411,
0.0598235205,
0.0553943217,
0.0425083749,
0.0524349175,
0.0724871159,
-0.0128637254,
0.0331963822,
-0.0122181699,
-0.0200718883,
0.0062278872,
-0.0176322665,
0.0627157018,
-0.0512927249,
-0.0066120401,
0.0191498008,
-0.0337238684,
-0.0206257049,
-0.0322739668,
-0.0263347849,
0.0123142479,
-0.0373763591,
-0.0282484796,
0.0581195354,
-0.009745772,
-0.0228398982,
-0.028564116,
0.0485155694,
0.0028917606,
-0.0109693762,
0.050975468,
-0.0418213047,
0.0544822365,
0.0156821329,
0.0053801253,
-0.0343553126,
-0.0013780529,
0.0143242441,
-0.0024595466,
-0.0111005455,
-0.0637501106,
-0.072770685,
-0.0823885053,
-0.0672356486,
0.0094093475,
-0.0061724987,
-0.0430492051,
-0.0126235522,
0.0421798602,
0.0191013999,
-0.0454062,
0.0470000282,
0.042546656,
-0.0018870496,
0.1042903513,
-0.0019442473,
0.0302648675,
0.0679209977,
-0.0190519765,
0.0341547802,
-0.0293741655,
-0.0450766645,
-0.0020403266,
0.0019995228,
0.0366794169,
0.0325007364,
-0.0126776788,
0.0112207532,
-0.006495039,
-0.0106127886,
-0.0175987463,
-0.0049686786,
0.0171219241,
0.0149932522,
0.0023481252,
-0.0461732298,
-0.0046148589,
0.0058569233,
-0.015011535,
-0.0169386286,
0.0613096617,
0.0110745309,
-0.0113648754,
-0.01329167,
0.0205641035,
-0.0027419659,
-0.0006689064,
-0.0300988778,
0.0180057939,
0.027079571,
0.0002293544,
0.0250948165,
0.0447475612,
-0.0472079515,
0.0385820679,
-0.0402914658,
0.0011640968,
0.0199847575,
-0.0164992344,
0.0038744379,
0.0414710306,
-0.0106746973,
0.0124563798,
-0.0239526872,
0.0245330706,
0.0335683674,
0.0833294839,
-0.0094132228,
0.0406317674,
0.0093593942,
-0.0197599288,
-0.0120720547,
0.0472686142,
0.0489183068,
-0.0186133981,
0.0108919293,
0.0363535285,
3.061e-7,
-0.005397019,
-0.0140606575,
0.094700247,
0.0441283286,
0.0183978118,
0.0070133051,
-0.0031786351,
0.0357736126,
0.0030417335,
0.0446770787,
0.0048056259,
-0.0186767727,
-0.0466954112,
0.0081881965,
0.0112660117,
-0.042090483,
-0.0322351046,
0.0309461765,
0.0536540076,
-0.0141966827,
0.0665474907,
-0.0114618912,
0.0745647103,
-0.0015110984,
-0.0296556242,
0.0003114648,
0.0175710823,
0.0269457251,
0.0499586612,
-0.0394570306,
-0.0875710025,
0.0112518175,
-0.0112024546,
-0.008696286,
0.0088716811,
-0.0077646831,
-0.0571173355,
0.0197311323,
-0.0008261451,
-0.0290680565,
-0.0303993784,
-0.0515282042,
0.0063494863,
0.0245218072,
0.0166118611,
0.0078396248,
-0.0279917344,
-0.0083156852,
-0.0141291311,
0.0315600708,
0.0027585563,
0.0285316464,
-0.0118210288,
0.0671120733,
-0.0409369059,
0.0510139801,
0.0345905013,
-0.0359761827,
0.0037066441,
-0.0329161696,
-0.0292658787,
-0.0138143757,
-0.0172110312,
0.0251102019,
-0.0110902991,
-0.0194804873,
-0.0002320067,
2.618634301e-34,
0.0532633178,
-0.0408125781,
0.014650641,
-0.033203695,
0.0083330777,
0.0150911519,
-0.0388331264,
-0.0128931301,
-0.023219591,
0.0351853333,
-0.0324389115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00588v1 | Boosting Summarization with Normalizing Flows and Aggressive Training | 2023-11-01T15:33:38 | 2023-11-01T15:33:38 | Yu Yang, Xiaotong Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents FlowSUM, a normalizing flows-based variational
encoder-decoder framework for Transformer-based summarization. Our approach
tackles two primary challenges in variational summarization: insufficient
semantic information in latent representations and posterior collapse during
training. To address these challenges, we employ normalizing flows to enable
flexible latent posterior modeling, and we propose a controlled alternate
aggressive training (CAAT) strategy with an improved gate mechanism.
Experimental results show that FlowSUM significantly enhances the quality of
generated summaries and unleashes the potential for knowledge distillation with
minimal impact on inference time. Furthermore, we investigate the issue of
posterior collapse in normalizing flows and analyze how the summary quality is
affected by the training strategy, gate initialization, and the type and number
of normalizing flows used, offering valuable insights for future research. | [
-0.0120554483,
0.0870738253,
0.0194140598,
-0.0051996224,
0.0200325567,
0.0234105159,
-0.0380663015,
-0.0294292085,
-0.0952874199,
0.0284916349,
0.0152125852,
0.0061271009,
0.0315987058,
0.0599893406,
0.0205880515,
-0.1049887389,
-0.0092933485,
-0.0077178786,
-0.0391803421,
-0.0392944105,
0.0168579333,
-0.0098123299,
0.0120472796,
0.0252179801,
0.0453011468,
0.0314817354,
-0.0357532538,
0.0012467923,
0.0691421926,
0.0088470103,
-0.0055551273,
0.0181634482,
0.0382508859,
-0.0348308906,
0.0000021428,
0.0227892287,
-0.0018971309,
-0.0138409007,
-0.020622367,
-0.0139879882,
0.0304355212,
-0.072230652,
0.0420031808,
-0.0039829966,
0.0196985118,
-0.0488183685,
0.0595349707,
0.0732612312,
0.062981315,
0.0576700792,
-0.0097856745,
-0.0766814277,
0.0346348546,
-0.0615147799,
-0.0011129408,
-0.0585455559,
-0.0040044063,
0.0231618285,
-0.0406183898,
-0.0349471532,
-0.0321913436,
0.0426118039,
0.0722839236,
0.0088367537,
0.0234266259,
0.070549503,
0.0135097932,
-0.0223682877,
0.023602834,
0.0370891504,
-0.0011609815,
-0.0152520705,
-0.0160821639,
-0.0505972877,
-0.0153005691,
0.0193207543,
-0.0470460467,
0.0812011436,
-0.0179457329,
0.0301626045,
-0.0193783194,
0.0480538011,
0.017677404,
-0.0003099661,
-0.0274267439,
-0.0437864438,
0.0176575724,
-0.0022780299,
-0.0162939951,
0.0293906834,
-0.03612547,
-0.0075712902,
-0.014357388,
0.0154254045,
0.015382125,
-0.0125229517,
-0.0123909218,
-0.0555977263,
-0.0342134759,
-0.0304441061,
-0.01086652,
0.0246310625,
0.0239899382,
0.0129157817,
0.0202450342,
0.0324183032,
0.008178859,
0.0259899013,
-0.080025062,
-0.0177017152,
0.0084154932,
-0.0178895704,
-0.0078814654,
0.0254475977,
-0.0368556902,
0.0131470216,
-0.0423256978,
0.0033037623,
0.0003118013,
-0.0190336145,
0.0083126491,
0.0623496957,
-0.0316023789,
-0.0162775088,
0.0166584719,
0.056850113,
-0.0471604764,
-0.0041539283,
0.0204193015,
-0.0102323163,
-0.0379272215,
0.0191703979,
-0.0035550648,
0.0294832364,
-0.0029154415,
0.0038285733,
-0.0589214601,
-0.0197465718,
-0.0412130095,
0.0116039366,
-0.0166233983,
-0.0575457513,
0.0378868878,
-0.0305644255,
0.0426679254,
-0.0033817063,
0.0139863109,
-0.0008878641,
-0.0338820145,
-0.0036163363,
-0.0184853058,
0.0278766118,
-0.015015129,
-0.0262643024,
0.0301332287,
0.0194087774,
0.012920049,
0.0653977394,
0.031244522,
0.0614458099,
-0.0360373519,
0.0123450402,
-0.0176975317,
-0.0099120354,
0.0399806201,
0.0027959272,
0.0037850079,
-0.0565282889,
-0.0233955197,
-0.0248591024,
0.102243647,
0.0434143208,
-0.0725574419,
-0.0035334006,
0.0460408367,
0.0093569029,
-0.0192629118,
0.0206759982,
0.0350514501,
0.0197056364,
0.0053312732,
0.0571596436,
-0.0601497814,
0.0566637143,
0.0022701116,
0.0380051583,
0.0175992996,
0.0588183142,
-0.0350728221,
-0.050698407,
0.0462738723,
-0.0051926551,
0.0108216424,
0.0032184862,
0.0411594883,
0.0281978846,
-0.0119689768,
0.0887858123,
0.029711673,
-0.0553582087,
0.0196293686,
-0.0171097163,
0.0147356167,
0.0248504002,
0.0236604828,
0.0126694227,
0.0047827847,
0.0000955737,
-0.0116959549,
0.0233756341,
0.0257994905,
-0.0103061711,
0.027602531,
-0.0537671559,
-0.0620214231,
-0.0504261367,
0.0202449318,
0.0057982518,
-0.0154915573,
-0.043918293,
0.0336877592,
-0.0130451769,
-0.0191574357,
0.0216020439,
-0.0241884552,
-0.0075370623,
0.0305749383,
-0.0134170121,
0.0185879711,
0.0083632115,
0.0078443727,
0.0144663211,
0.0138059855,
-0.0329682082,
-0.0449738912,
0.0457932167,
-0.0688955113,
-0.0509334728,
0.0012875932,
-0.0587448888,
0.0071939938,
0.0094289752,
-0.0617800467,
-0.0529298671,
0.0282039717,
-0.0678321496,
-0.0040990766,
-0.0232736561,
0.0115171662,
0.020304298,
-0.0043656696,
0.0060757492,
0.0926147103,
-0.0667295307,
0.0071303812,
0.0194181241,
-0.0121232048,
-0.0120224021,
0.0231748037,
-0.0109861894,
0.0061645498,
0.0091371853,
0.0037078939,
0.0667323768,
-0.0078185955,
0.0043480163,
0.0129690738,
-0.0546321273,
-0.017845571,
-0.0263719503,
-0.0054075927,
0.0318912193,
0.0375883467,
0.0321322791,
0.0132240141,
-0.0198411085,
-0.0025687593,
0.0006021315,
-0.0045512533,
0.0055090971,
0.0005263042,
0.0012977996,
-0.0004408822,
-0.0183230303,
0.0346053578,
0.0738711208,
-0.0018437044,
-0.0162745714,
-0.0249998812,
0.0083700418,
0.0133228721,
-0.0171803311,
-0.041275572,
0.0219218228,
0.0064225947,
0.0182572715,
0.0743326321,
0.0242840033,
0.0366093405,
0.0482162945,
0.0506983064,
0.0249479767,
-0.0115028908,
0.0010937146,
-0.0709957555,
-0.0361348093,
-0.0429270305,
-0.0667712688,
-0.0041102106,
0.0360430665,
0.0149741452,
0.0398693457,
-0.0753233731,
0.0006032221,
0.0029655551,
-0.0524682142,
-0.008398911,
-0.0056873173,
-0.0277174544,
0.0028879631,
-0.0422963798,
-0.0122715216,
0.0523128919,
0.0105064865,
0.0106577445,
-0.0447388701,
0.0076288776,
-0.0111116543,
0.020547593,
0.0233473461,
0.0288278852,
0.0171014667,
-0.0184967145,
-0.045501139,
0.0116102053,
0.051673729,
0.0104104755,
0.0571217053,
-0.0155858677,
-0.0215368029,
-0.0227296706,
-0.0376598574,
-0.0173193403,
-0.0068609696,
0.0132062742,
0.0433724634,
0.0623832643,
-0.0191091932,
-0.0588318743,
-0.0072933016,
0.0334715284,
0.0325248539,
-0.0376700386,
-0.021134764,
-0.0148576004,
0.0490214713,
0.0611725897,
0.0264112595,
0.0359891802,
-0.0702821836,
0.013281581,
0.0733853057,
-0.0060416213,
-0.0076180166,
-0.0426695757,
-0.002216761,
-0.0210364629,
-0.0280490555,
0.0250579212,
0.0255475473,
0.0741539374,
-0.0198215339,
-0.0167722944,
0.0672681257,
-0.028170919,
-0.0713849515,
0.0048660799,
0.0138617791,
0.0713586584,
0.010547867,
-0.0000522551,
-0.0535200648,
-0.0238358025,
-0.0274703931,
0.0473015681,
0.0556910336,
-0.0003687602,
0.0005459377,
-0.0264463443,
0.0264969505,
0.0165433921,
-0.0528668836,
-0.0425026789,
-0.0714149624,
-0.0209944248,
-0.0612461716,
0.0293264557,
0.0076757171,
-0.0320393704,
0.0029062682,
0.0388205349,
0.0030786584,
-0.0527169853,
-0.0463199392,
-0.0331034027,
-0.0371168144,
0.0469616465,
-0.0151076289,
-0.020262856,
0.003972556,
0.0065275389,
-0.0348574333,
0.0027381708,
0.0215241201,
0.09423206,
-0.0060035032,
0.0011178476,
-0.0320594087,
0.0322120637,
0.0022080196,
-0.0421901755,
-0.0559254512,
-0.0064287004,
-0.0222454574,
-0.0497666523,
-0.0407797806,
0.0123505816,
-0.0492760204,
0.0519333333,
0.0344028659,
-0.0159134213,
-0.0143570881,
-0.0137841739,
0.0157477241,
-0.0228125863,
-0.0240275618,
-0.0022089637,
0.037127886,
-0.1129141897,
-0.0468800552,
-0.0437996015,
-0.0087225614,
-0.0198983811,
-0.0359252542,
-0.0377488583,
0.0584644824,
-0.019224273,
-0.0686464086,
0.0103449197,
-0.0179725289,
-0.0205956791,
0.0137810912,
-0.0255611707,
0.0167505331,
-0.0240466613,
-0.0359721147,
0.032432612,
-0.1054530367,
-0.0618415773,
-0.02875215,
0.0556392074,
0.0103953676,
0.0648135692,
0.016614832,
-0.0029284512,
0.0482247695,
0.0262359828,
0.0025217463,
0.035815157,
0.0392922014,
-0.0176756382,
-0.0094838999,
0.0124753956,
-0.0569273941,
0.0038939174,
-0.0164744761,
0.0275487714,
-0.0543625318,
-0.0089451913,
0.0380382426,
-0.0302655976,
-0.0016461641,
-0.0348977558,
0.0027740232,
-0.0198204853,
-0.0318202041,
0.0146897826,
-0.0067359679,
-0.0496853665,
0.0292231385,
0.0003933902,
0.0357367583,
0.0101333726,
0.0661940649,
0.0579777136,
0.0026709619,
-0.0504860692,
-0.0142596895,
-0.0047801007,
-0.0196142383,
-0.018260736,
0.0197256804,
-0.0450554192,
-0.01774293,
-0.0105473455,
0.0027610098,
-0.012927115,
0.0412521325,
0.0558202602,
0.033927355,
-0.025264848,
0.0259537362,
-0.082942225,
-0.0200373791,
-0.0837504491,
0.0081885308,
0.037641678,
-0.0041341055,
0.055385951,
-0.0050008618,
0.0183218233,
-0.0116840992,
0.0023626843,
0.0039692381,
-0.0541164689,
0.0116923023,
0.0113375289,
0.013866201,
-0.0343858823,
0.0718617961,
-0.0405052379,
0.0260890517,
-0.0328599662,
0.0266550481,
-0.0337775461,
-0.0643221363,
0.0020896341,
0.0504076704,
0.0029823198,
-0.0021909757,
-0.0203048494,
-0.0473886952,
-0.015038182,
-0.0057208273,
0.0219726432,
0.0040467191,
0.0703781247,
0.0260806605,
-0.0209402964,
-0.090746969,
-0.0009779349,
-0.0140250949,
0.0173216965,
0.0225187186,
-0.0241035298,
-6.858509952e-33,
-0.0376225449,
0.0184313953,
0.0122703509,
-0.0086458446,
-0.0214937702,
-0.0101212608,
-0.0810178816,
-0.0160756707,
-0.0038782062,
0.0363859124,
0.0207724217,
0.0290163048,
0.0120426966,
0.0294358023,
0.0074444669,
-0.0217537433,
0.0965399817,
0.0114910528,
-0.0363371782,
0.0682344958,
0.0122485887,
-0.0048406241,
0.0768846273,
-0.0373396426,
-0.0045177354,
-0.0230302587,
-0.0504869707,
-0.0026992774,
0.0287177321,
-0.0068654735,
-0.0251771305,
0.0103987409,
0.0317878537,
-0.0590553693,
-0.0409584269,
-0.0448295586,
-0.0965696797,
-0.010377463,
0.0144641949,
-0.0004628667,
-0.0547990277,
-0.0255290866,
0.0667325482,
0.0068454817,
0.0298321676,
-0.0597452559,
0.037647821,
-0.0188308116,
-0.0209266227,
-0.0680710077,
-0.0204068776,
0.0132575482,
-0.0159007721,
0.0035942402,
-0.0157272089,
0.0156388469,
-0.0157258473,
-0.0108332718,
-0.0237410218,
0.0274848118,
0.0566819273,
0.0068741292,
0.0484185368,
0.0336946696,
0.0027098753,
0.0513400398,
0.0274041183,
-0.0214057062,
-0.0636289045,
0.0431391448,
0.025911551,
0.0041673258,
0.0245720074,
-0.0139795328,
0.0436857007,
0.0465350747,
-0.0255689826,
0.062018197,
-0.0413734131,
0.0872099772,
0.0057851775,
0.0149242086,
0.0000222391,
-0.0577718914,
-0.0333994776,
-0.0230171047,
0.0098467628,
0.0035912138,
-0.0177725106,
0.0729206204,
-0.0598055869,
-0.0115518179,
0.012901905,
-0.0123833539,
0.0454916209,
0.0530535877,
0.0106212283,
0.0374893695,
0.0144662987,
-0.0236264914,
-0.0602266937,
0.036877539,
0.0278859548,
-0.0333657674,
-0.0097952858,
0.0315376744,
0.0110207619,
0.0444839075,
-0.008448069,
-0.0027899616,
-0.0190447699,
-0.0164903328,
-0.0077787112,
0.0424634293,
0.0088987797,
0.035341043,
-0.0336195305,
0.0290733054,
-0.027685767,
0.0421954505,
-0.0288711768,
0.0310769193,
0.077646859,
0.0650724173,
-0.0116173327,
0.0004564652,
-0.0059320433,
0.0228759814,
0.0695868805,
-0.0655349419,
-0.0521383956,
0.0325793773,
2.779e-7,
0.0676188767,
-0.0236305259,
0.0404993892,
0.0487477928,
-0.0224844608,
0.0339515731,
0.0361354351,
0.0191949252,
0.0165799502,
-0.0280108657,
0.0330877528,
0.0658502579,
-0.0038199124,
0.0396105014,
-0.0749667063,
-0.0334993564,
-0.0665598065,
-0.0385950617,
0.0071251113,
-0.0193220004,
0.0661742389,
0.0919137299,
-0.0193650555,
0.003645563,
0.0519108176,
0.0214495678,
0.0610704795,
0.0270437971,
-0.0071135396,
0.0210541785,
0.0003475905,
-0.0385031663,
-0.003468663,
0.0172482003,
-0.024385402,
-0.0080414368,
0.0192103609,
0.0406810082,
0.0055758236,
-0.0458763801,
-0.0148183852,
0.0112326508,
0.0082589565,
-0.0025345157,
0.0487404577,
-0.0699386075,
-0.0233156551,
-0.0172579978,
-0.085026741,
0.0434730127,
0.0020484265,
0.0285698995,
-0.0245623048,
0.0263198372,
-0.0048448802,
0.033889275,
-0.016503511,
-0.0852146819,
-0.0087164184,
0.01044589,
-0.0400700532,
-0.0201538522,
-0.0268985573,
-0.0366490521,
0.025669653,
-0.0069519887,
-0.0224152859,
2.479135953e-34,
0.0748047158,
-0.0156263597,
-0.0235866606,
0.0254712291,
0.0070106797,
-0.033916913,
-0.0102316774,
-0.0186551809,
-0.0084244618,
-0.0559634902,
-0.0291067157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00587v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00587v2 | Crosslingual Retrieval Augmented In-context Learning for Bangla | 2023-11-01T15:32:50 | 2023-12-02T16:54:23 | Xiaoqian Li, Ercong Nie, Sheng Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The promise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in Natural Language Processing
has often been overshadowed by their limited performance in low-resource
languages such as Bangla. To address this, our paper presents a pioneering
approach that utilizes cross-lingual retrieval augmented in-context learning.
By strategically sourcing semantically similar prompts from high-resource
language, we enable multilingual pretrained language models (MPLMs), especially
the generative model BLOOMZ, to successfully boost performance on Bangla tasks.
Our extensive evaluation highlights that the cross-lingual retrieval augmented
prompts bring steady improvements to MPLMs over the zero-shot performance. | [
0.0128638167,
-0.0162329134,
-0.0083364369,
0.0515886471,
-0.0318160206,
-0.011232852,
0.037953455,
-0.0211831052,
0.0274357889,
-0.0030752574,
-0.0642350912,
-0.0736396238,
0.0006599189,
0.0146101713,
-0.0063132825,
-0.0738243833,
0.0586651713,
-0.0231588222,
0.0190154128,
0.0010227106,
0.0069771865,
0.0381946489,
0.0176708195,
0.0262530074,
-0.0089745764,
-0.0132697448,
0.0295311753,
0.0132191107,
0.0038363345,
-0.0346269719,
-0.0245380234,
0.0308043528,
0.0000032064,
0.0160585176,
0.0000018072,
-0.0789351836,
-0.0232646354,
0.0101892687,
-0.0066953693,
0.002639767,
0.0373425558,
-0.004401519,
-0.0098474026,
0.0365366377,
-0.0313246213,
-0.0185919981,
0.0566070452,
0.0394931994,
-0.0068921335,
0.0875525773,
0.0017289926,
-0.047011368,
0.0256939065,
-0.0401676223,
0.0364916697,
-0.0381818414,
0.0023229944,
-0.0201045815,
0.0436383672,
0.0400199704,
-0.0195865594,
0.0499334298,
0.0224486273,
-0.0040814392,
-0.0206815228,
0.0171443298,
0.0054777302,
-0.0198578443,
0.0099701807,
0.0264665969,
-0.059765473,
-0.024897445,
-0.0300957486,
-0.0215068907,
0.0042408323,
-0.0323407315,
-0.047069896,
0.0208417252,
0.0013827521,
0.0136751384,
0.0037095987,
0.0169385877,
0.0423989035,
-0.0167886652,
-0.0174381565,
0.0172377415,
0.0328422487,
-0.025566807,
-0.002647551,
0.0002185784,
0.0334427804,
0.0054464662,
0.0014364608,
-0.014952912,
-0.0426338352,
0.0036638167,
0.0150013696,
-0.0139604993,
0.0377255231,
-0.0049517942,
0.0351156928,
0.0374130048,
-0.078769587,
0.0518202372,
-0.024473954,
-0.0050673406,
-0.0183175225,
-0.0145341456,
-0.0381883159,
-0.0390149653,
-0.0188506711,
-0.0357681736,
-0.0560792983,
-0.0076220809,
-0.0689919516,
0.0081581455,
-0.0626867637,
0.0309996251,
-0.0165101588,
-0.049130071,
0.0142977545,
-0.0027933968,
-0.0191031005,
-0.035336297,
0.0124663142,
0.0353640914,
-0.0275731981,
0.0012349675,
0.0254530217,
-0.1156199649,
-0.0016261364,
-0.006146457,
0.0097804684,
-0.0522488505,
0.018253373,
0.0281593259,
-0.0400583781,
-0.0641244575,
-0.0723104626,
0.0133196106,
-0.0095739318,
-0.0409089886,
-0.0551568158,
-0.0506765917,
0.0551330149,
0.0039303144,
0.0115791848,
0.0058305268,
-0.0048864824,
0.0315126963,
0.0232562795,
0.0749434382,
0.0238039158,
-0.0244652219,
0.0479684137,
0.0082295621,
0.0627938062,
0.0602191351,
-0.0404245555,
0.0017587307,
0.0508498475,
0.0281890519,
-0.0157185216,
0.0705080181,
0.023112217,
-0.0012518163,
-0.0034295139,
0.0112331705,
0.0551969744,
0.0222760271,
0.0264440868,
0.0344776958,
-0.04435068,
0.0420889109,
0.023773104,
0.0538204461,
0.0333793163,
0.0180092361,
0.0536053143,
-0.0105495602,
-0.0342222005,
-0.0173626523,
0.0010472885,
-0.0008052929,
-0.0406319834,
0.0000780855,
0.0599398017,
0.0500200279,
-0.0316350237,
0.0091365669,
0.0190541614,
-0.019924283,
-0.0188879296,
0.0312507488,
0.063215211,
0.0037933739,
-0.0323953591,
-0.0045246724,
0.039780166,
-0.0515439324,
0.0005918258,
-0.0270447955,
0.0249244254,
0.03450533,
0.0230164416,
-0.0079064891,
0.0183897931,
0.0128070749,
0.0109840389,
0.0305798221,
0.0174879692,
-0.016365638,
0.0199455563,
-0.0439113528,
0.0263347533,
0.0159310661,
-0.0420232378,
0.0500418432,
0.0025872099,
0.0379804187,
0.0287321359,
0.0195061099,
-0.0020302215,
0.0041198512,
-0.0571788847,
-0.0231484082,
0.0404151902,
0.0181260556,
0.0117859915,
0.0161827113,
-0.0011491298,
0.0045606657,
0.009137772,
-0.0515739508,
0.0263496246,
0.018837573,
-0.0561056584,
-0.0549540967,
0.0079618897,
0.0279053841,
0.022359414,
-0.0531448871,
0.0170764588,
-0.0536831543,
0.0254039019,
0.0136946384,
0.0601486564,
-0.0777305737,
0.0320616029,
-0.0013102877,
0.0158358179,
-0.0648814887,
0.0441243313,
0.0230292715,
0.0250263959,
0.0118435156,
0.0435106866,
0.0674336106,
-0.0815706477,
-0.0207799822,
0.076672025,
0.0038125091,
0.0005717986,
0.0278363526,
0.0259882975,
-0.0314788595,
0.0162501764,
-0.1153325066,
-0.0186111685,
-0.0265363865,
-0.0233682357,
-0.0213388745,
0.0786388814,
-0.0320081748,
-0.0433561616,
-0.0005255955,
-0.0148302577,
0.0720049813,
0.0365655459,
-0.017260626,
0.0133099016,
0.0087239062,
-0.0181136634,
-0.0352812931,
0.0356581248,
0.0369308256,
-0.020308096,
-0.0129225347,
-0.025477726,
0.000377273,
-0.0087341703,
0.0001633052,
-0.0057467124,
0.0170685761,
0.0134447832,
-0.0664716139,
0.0454947911,
0.0407770872,
-0.0005830202,
-0.0324111246,
0.0153834829,
-0.0151473461,
-0.0802208707,
0.0062888796,
-0.0164944809,
-0.0325405747,
0.002152863,
0.0324740112,
0.0292284619,
0.0073607136,
0.0011968163,
0.0006948684,
-0.0277910251,
-0.047275275,
-0.0008036242,
-0.0504658148,
-0.0859443247,
0.0143724326,
-0.0225204304,
0.0393927805,
-0.0132582681,
-0.0338235646,
0.0637540147,
-0.0431650206,
-0.0231528506,
-0.0424227901,
0.0206918828,
-0.0332870558,
0.0433418453,
-0.041503638,
0.0352356359,
-0.0384513289,
-0.0599669032,
-0.0211889185,
0.0305522699,
0.0362399295,
-0.026379399,
-0.0118459146,
-0.0110811647,
0.0361008048,
-0.019899657,
-0.0688602924,
-0.0372660235,
-0.0251044631,
0.0124004753,
-0.0047633811,
0.0044725235,
0.033554852,
-0.0177109484,
0.0152533669,
0.0471642502,
0.0037095987,
-0.004518677,
-0.0067085326,
0.0071698455,
0.0245850664,
-0.0110066766,
-0.024889715,
0.0148986988,
-0.0247878563,
-0.0326023921,
-0.0117792785,
0.0379138552,
-0.0560468398,
0.0057398872,
-0.0214582141,
0.0658713877,
-0.0154871307,
-0.0312077571,
0.0353110917,
-0.0097840792,
-0.0167450476,
-0.0644820407,
0.0625098273,
0.0349281803,
-0.038004864,
-0.0463087298,
-0.0980755538,
0.015636839,
0.0024490224,
0.0676389784,
-0.0677345619,
-0.0324667767,
-0.0080702202,
-0.0088348035,
0.0218039043,
0.0171001535,
-0.0154369157,
-0.1863652915,
0.0130561898,
-0.0083214967,
-0.0344548747,
-0.0536468588,
-0.0466128103,
-0.0397976823,
0.0116856862,
0.0391109325,
0.0366151407,
-0.0149561958,
-0.0142028453,
0.0332076699,
0.0730834082,
-0.0703517795,
-0.0031551311,
-0.0622588992,
-0.0014788382,
0.0739613399,
-0.0197406095,
0.0025295354,
-0.0005232387,
0.0250071064,
-0.0226851255,
-0.002614402,
-0.0252899658,
-0.0329714455,
-0.0074636424,
-0.0191938076,
-0.0007113285,
-0.0015861492,
0.0224601272,
-0.0376897417,
-0.0075022671,
0.0401339345,
-0.0144894291,
0.0219945982,
-0.0093586482,
-0.0148671223,
0.0433650427,
0.0366097987,
0.0228639357,
-0.0179248713,
-0.0109476075,
-0.0166677125,
-0.0033190837,
-0.0337179042,
-0.0437109061,
0.0266332403,
-0.0418613292,
-0.0216695536,
-0.0253097527,
-0.0621760935,
0.0085482942,
0.0575747751,
-0.0027558703,
0.0211395323,
-0.0179914534,
0.0021176396,
-0.0199370421,
0.0343497992,
-0.055869408,
0.0240653399,
-0.0942377597,
0.0327423289,
0.0184663422,
-0.0460305996,
-0.0138690704,
0.0170071889,
-0.0189697351,
-0.043361824,
0.0128357513,
0.0365521275,
0.0097113019,
0.0242208466,
-0.0301138479,
-0.0814652517,
0.0792673305,
0.0515890829,
-0.0229198225,
0.0127979154,
0.0147503102,
0.0135470452,
-0.0039921668,
0.037286438,
-0.0298005175,
0.0279693883,
0.0098174317,
0.0461308211,
-0.0122646252,
0.0031014765,
-0.0085221399,
0.0219430737,
0.0578435846,
-0.0377523787,
-0.0326056033,
-0.060327623,
0.0065050512,
0.0041062543,
-0.0225034114,
-0.0002644945,
-0.0240731128,
0.0479486808,
-0.0289526172,
0.0148025881,
0.0130254915,
0.0024781178,
0.0105885454,
-0.0107546868,
0.0054986561,
0.0488667302,
0.002959857,
0.0171380844,
0.0159261841,
0.0048249578,
0.0210577957,
-0.0013940146,
0.0559763014,
-0.0480238907,
0.0402197987,
-0.0139889736,
-0.0065633077,
-0.0169845168,
0.0238947775,
-0.0028979448,
0.007464604,
-0.0153287882,
0.0176268164,
0.0904291272,
-0.0224693958,
0.0437152535,
0.0017065795,
-0.0089039048,
-0.0573859178,
-0.0070304894,
-0.014219909,
-0.0379101485,
0.0285249949,
-0.0142124593,
-0.0260329861,
0.0324711576,
0.0495037362,
-0.0220036916,
-0.017227672,
0.0021658854,
0.0057251579,
-0.0114078363,
-0.0528347678,
0.020107599,
0.0550809391,
-0.0239283759,
0.0046266099,
-0.0503474697,
-0.0495616458,
-0.0005911114,
0.0188328084,
-0.0457482599,
0.0205463096,
0.0285334401,
0.0778942704,
0.0203876942,
0.0369120911,
-0.0288597755,
0.0146733075,
-0.0061579896,
-0.0022500872,
0.0126907965,
-5.560811208e-33,
-0.0303740334,
0.0338381529,
0.0335069038,
-0.0699496493,
0.0128036225,
-0.0005345037,
-0.0360254161,
0.01278158,
-0.0127167199,
-0.0416980907,
-0.0582346655,
-0.0092432685,
0.030157268,
0.0491213761,
0.0545512587,
0.0116090663,
0.0330689512,
0.0422241911,
-0.0037246479,
0.0219605695,
0.083885245,
0.0892776698,
0.0386241972,
-0.0089006787,
0.0392388701,
-0.0501834862,
0.006089672,
0.0153272636,
0.0127619533,
0.0520834476,
-0.0207600836,
0.038908422,
0.0074355486,
-0.0282262471,
-0.01933112,
0.0429411866,
-0.0731809586,
-0.0015905014,
0.0505092666,
0.0224039182,
-0.0179457124,
-0.0246378779,
0.006182577,
-0.0258638952,
-0.02310648,
0.0439718217,
0.0039021745,
-0.0056389258,
-0.0421419665,
-0.0050435085,
-0.0638887882,
0.0171760283,
0.0215932392,
0.0411246046,
0.0267500095,
0.0343585648,
-0.0280325878,
0.0285342224,
-0.0333482549,
0.0180312395,
-0.007224672,
0.0708105192,
0.0534507819,
0.0610907599,
-0.0002969799,
0.0029648279,
0.049634397,
-0.0560126379,
0.0549400672,
-0.0207656734,
0.0483129881,
0.0043493481,
-0.0256227013,
0.1233690158,
0.0339290239,
-0.0491271131,
-0.0691154227,
0.0470695235,
0.0389959961,
0.0174740329,
0.0270073246,
0.0163161922,
-0.0209551621,
-0.0376270711,
0.0022425619,
-0.0183320455,
-0.0398168825,
-0.0302277505,
0.0729981214,
0.0164383221,
0.0119183091,
0.0178849883,
0.0905137137,
0.001771007,
-0.0059868502,
0.0165298525,
-0.0160889979,
0.0035484582,
0.0058820308,
0.0825333595,
-0.0712592006,
-0.0341435224,
-0.0073048929,
-0.0192037597,
-0.0532829277,
0.012938221,
0.0332410708,
-0.0277467538,
-0.0752249733,
0.0296413768,
-0.028761778,
0.0260814223,
-0.0283456519,
0.0502928458,
0.0178420134,
0.0059329825,
-0.0007647398,
0.0416325144,
0.0363527723,
-0.0090635633,
0.013069503,
-0.0670683756,
0.0014064681,
-0.013819119,
-0.0145924455,
0.040238224,
-0.0316548608,
0.0357751735,
0.0241717231,
-0.0347466171,
0.0151534099,
0.047927741,
2.558e-7,
0.0178718008,
-0.0035137825,
0.0247198846,
-0.0138647109,
-0.0225456357,
0.0211409349,
-0.0163032394,
0.0087018991,
0.0225354973,
0.0575250611,
0.0016825167,
0.003334508,
0.0216020886,
0.0064650066,
-0.1083841771,
0.0039854334,
-0.049948927,
-0.0045016049,
-0.0650293678,
-0.033659678,
-0.0287683029,
0.0987050235,
-0.0188038629,
-0.0179961156,
-0.0040270449,
-0.0551102757,
0.0928902999,
-0.0294448659,
-0.0450710841,
-0.0203923732,
0.0214810222,
0.0726318285,
0.0131556848,
-0.0262970272,
-0.024686534,
0.0292028673,
0.0234439634,
0.0340764187,
-0.0033312149,
-0.0395958498,
0.0507976077,
0.0176484436,
-0.0345308445,
-0.0376372524,
0.0780246481,
-0.0036598137,
0.0006580933,
-0.0000222535,
-0.0281893108,
-0.0276088808,
0.038052924,
-0.0316232704,
-0.0673800185,
0.0098641515,
0.0278765485,
-0.0418494493,
-0.0251710042,
-0.0702964962,
0.0036868132,
0.0192122497,
-0.0237662792,
-0.0080435844,
-0.0143369623,
0.0406609029,
-0.0018267571,
-0.0431022048,
0.0275555924,
2.06063976e-34,
0.0478928313,
0.0309045706,
0.0568562187,
-0.0179644246,
-0.0101875504,
0.0094210906,
-0.0173498746,
0.021789968,
-0.0071587376,
-0.0711626709,
-0.0237176325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00739v1 | Can Large Language Models Design Accurate Label Functions? | 2023-11-01T15:14:46 | 2023-11-01T15:14:46 | Naiqing Guan, Kaiwen Chen, Nick Koudas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG, H.2.8; I.5.4 | Programmatic weak supervision methodologies facilitate the expedited labeling
of extensive datasets through the use of label functions (LFs) that encapsulate
heuristic data sources. Nonetheless, the creation of precise LFs necessitates
domain expertise and substantial endeavors. Recent advances in pre-trained
language models (PLMs) have exhibited substantial potential across diverse
tasks. However, the capacity of PLMs to autonomously formulate accurate LFs
remains an underexplored domain. In this research, we address this gap by
introducing DataSculpt, an interactive framework that harnesses PLMs for the
automated generation of LFs. Within DataSculpt, we incorporate an array of
prompting techniques, instance selection strategies, and LF filtration methods
to explore the expansive design landscape. Ultimately, we conduct a thorough
assessment of DataSculpt's performance on 12 real-world datasets, encompassing
a range of tasks. This evaluation unveils both the strengths and limitations of
contemporary PLMs in LF design. | [
0.034071371,
0.0457383469,
-0.0069692219,
0.0028811647,
-0.0139642963,
0.0112499483,
0.0509965792,
-0.0351705924,
0.0456021391,
-0.0488990992,
-0.0829677135,
-0.0167579837,
-0.0417081341,
0.035767965,
0.009657572,
-0.0319900885,
0.0215010755,
-0.0664818957,
0.0078128483,
0.0042517479,
-0.0091910651,
0.0144311311,
-0.0186254922,
0.0092758657,
-0.0430850461,
-0.0031915172,
-0.0015292048,
0.0025672363,
-0.0274011958,
-0.0408975333,
0.0352402367,
0.0989251509,
0.0027903791,
0.0426497608,
0.0000022559,
-0.044285994,
-0.0089345947,
-0.0133757945,
-0.0452127866,
0.0265238229,
0.0497092046,
-0.0088821808,
0.0179208461,
-0.0033385342,
-0.0368962102,
-0.0740540773,
0.0571905933,
0.0121165048,
0.0771105215,
0.0418594517,
-0.0177919175,
0.001340882,
-0.049101606,
-0.018824311,
-0.0011719284,
-0.0445508212,
0.019165501,
-0.0106436834,
0.0207366087,
0.0028130023,
0.0035120677,
0.0759726912,
0.019026611,
-0.0432018489,
0.024185935,
0.0246009231,
-0.0590757653,
-0.0356649198,
-0.022431666,
0.11717318,
0.009779281,
-0.036952585,
0.0008125993,
-0.0099905264,
-0.0189242475,
0.0083656451,
-0.022477759,
-0.0092639709,
0.009316897,
0.0249931384,
0.0156079372,
0.018764494,
0.0348408744,
0.0111848079,
-0.0157520026,
0.0557200983,
0.0335630178,
-0.0237747096,
0.0346475542,
0.0083358381,
-0.0226722024,
-0.0588868856,
0.0326317661,
0.0203213785,
-0.0773794651,
0.0266347434,
-0.076173,
-0.0372093879,
-0.000141727,
0.0018746438,
0.0363425612,
0.0045913942,
-0.0635671541,
0.0632759482,
-0.0110150427,
-0.0044691726,
0.0108441552,
0.028897725,
-0.0293481685,
-0.0021062461,
-0.0408575498,
-0.0065501621,
-0.056935858,
0.02182105,
-0.0064114491,
-0.0057581752,
-0.0264504328,
0.0303177219,
-0.0194681473,
-0.0043488522,
-0.0025640803,
-0.0272418242,
-0.0078325188,
0.0092198821,
-0.0339642838,
-0.0216301382,
-0.0346052833,
-0.0148201445,
-0.0363594815,
-0.0374325141,
0.0086116148,
0.0231876727,
-0.0087444847,
-0.0526056364,
0.0205830671,
0.0808971822,
-0.0153108118,
-0.0336247236,
-0.0494870618,
-0.0010729632,
-0.0181677993,
-0.0319494642,
-0.001847962,
-0.0663048178,
0.0353164636,
0.0153060453,
0.0055435109,
-0.0401326269,
0.003288029,
-0.0000171951,
-0.0277532749,
0.0996510759,
-0.0544510037,
0.0479718521,
0.0085820025,
-0.020294603,
0.0220541488,
0.0548355468,
-0.0242860131,
0.0178764574,
0.0641887635,
-0.0122682573,
0.0602330826,
0.0626086593,
0.0144271534,
0.0323109403,
-0.0539933927,
0.0036356116,
0.0130865555,
-0.0120480228,
-0.0133852782,
0.0341702476,
0.0152492477,
0.0157957636,
0.069391638,
0.0272359066,
-0.0027961163,
0.0020111764,
0.0723009855,
0.0131097771,
0.0179311894,
-0.0196867138,
-0.0438412689,
-0.0083550792,
-0.0281863268,
-0.0149617698,
0.0013575244,
0.0104151368,
-0.0484365672,
-0.0549927801,
-0.0176197365,
-0.0142291216,
-0.0239305068,
0.0432822891,
0.0539656319,
0.063166365,
0.0036196073,
0.0689476132,
0.0290514957,
-0.0391882472,
-0.0086332532,
-0.0376951285,
0.0130905407,
0.0673810542,
0.0504702963,
-0.0846420601,
-0.0398732834,
0.0319208838,
0.1143561751,
0.0381953716,
0.0827247798,
-0.0309730005,
0.0278163645,
-0.0400147401,
-0.0220026262,
0.0113311838,
0.0057274872,
0.0293110814,
0.037154071,
-0.0090193162,
0.0158109032,
-0.0628248379,
-0.0920295268,
0.0598345622,
0.0114958156,
-0.0595049001,
0.037660338,
0.0142679969,
0.0033679164,
0.0113758743,
-0.0068151425,
0.016425686,
0.0336202644,
-0.0007213065,
0.0233476777,
-0.0251113996,
-0.0383410603,
-0.0107905883,
0.029435847,
-0.0060499664,
-0.0520558804,
-0.0216238666,
-0.0666130781,
-0.0491824113,
-0.0175893307,
-0.0110325608,
-0.0131435841,
-0.0255811717,
0.0283299871,
0.0003304704,
-0.0141416918,
-0.0537219308,
0.0507158414,
0.0512905791,
0.0081551066,
0.0550205968,
0.0429168046,
-0.011468905,
0.0053585474,
-0.0476849079,
0.0038680697,
-0.0128470212,
-0.0119199185,
0.0112778349,
0.0682669058,
-0.0374137573,
-0.017397387,
-0.0481856391,
-0.0102331704,
-0.031126257,
-0.0095716566,
0.0244238246,
-0.0016662079,
-0.0378639437,
-0.0340527892,
-0.0353186391,
-0.0182589665,
-0.013337261,
0.0319277905,
0.0318771675,
0.0064385263,
-0.031492617,
-0.0474594608,
-0.0153612625,
-0.00081145,
0.0130631709,
0.0220350232,
-0.0378115475,
-0.0316794701,
0.0655031204,
-0.022732662,
0.0369067527,
0.0033144995,
0.0079183141,
0.0111015514,
-0.0467670746,
0.044287011,
-0.0051472061,
-0.0332825966,
0.0348209739,
0.0683933645,
-0.0218170285,
-0.0246381145,
0.0110772746,
-0.0455861278,
-0.0396843739,
-0.0136061348,
0.0120035792,
0.0196917765,
0.059440922,
-0.0216383543,
-0.0083441716,
-0.0185406301,
0.0005205844,
-0.0249083061,
-0.0288789198,
-0.042240452,
0.007766997,
0.0099880127,
0.0546229482,
-0.0143892327,
-0.0699158013,
0.0779459998,
-0.0362916254,
-0.0220127478,
-0.0112090753,
-0.0327522643,
-0.0277514607,
0.0669545904,
0.0270021539,
-0.0181544386,
0.0178044755,
-0.0389460139,
-0.0327253751,
0.022156287,
0.0000185464,
-0.0183334909,
0.0388331041,
-0.0786140785,
0.0160054062,
0.0354140885,
-0.0208696555,
-0.0572424494,
-0.0555031262,
-0.0140213501,
-0.0118225832,
-0.0147080282,
0.0257049035,
-0.0187302791,
0.0207172539,
0.0018704286,
0.078018114,
-0.0077289669,
0.0020694667,
-0.0232670251,
0.0018015003,
0.0299936105,
-0.0298200585,
-0.003500534,
-0.0144607779,
0.0147386007,
-0.003587987,
0.0554811694,
-0.0145111103,
0.0119130099,
0.0194387306,
0.057669498,
-0.0114120506,
-0.0042562243,
0.0226994306,
0.0545030795,
-0.0352764204,
-0.0365884081,
0.1347230375,
0.0541933663,
-0.0636673495,
0.0036633019,
0.0225514565,
0.0570745431,
0.0564311594,
0.0425909273,
-0.0654896498,
-0.0367354304,
-0.0001198764,
0.0453489609,
-0.0062282342,
-0.0298507754,
-0.0045298026,
-0.1120013371,
0.0306741204,
-0.0023531814,
-0.0466532148,
0.0161794238,
-0.0290322695,
-0.0036558511,
-0.0119750388,
-0.0138181616,
-0.010013679,
-0.0135761835,
0.0075702602,
0.0271795969,
-0.0417832769,
-0.0617285371,
0.0279852059,
-0.0296702739,
0.0462701209,
0.0387869775,
0.0130199734,
-0.0074904868,
-0.0216526482,
0.0658872053,
0.0050709448,
-0.0313877575,
-0.0400262326,
0.0663803145,
-0.0181606729,
-0.0472122133,
0.0084563019,
0.0347158946,
-0.0475962535,
-0.0000959052,
0.006098106,
0.0513509475,
-0.0199075546,
-0.000644977,
0.0087503716,
-0.0169618614,
0.0565953664,
0.063953124,
0.0514223427,
-0.0578307174,
0.002206696,
-0.0178797096,
-0.0035761192,
-0.058792945,
-0.040752057,
0.0364824831,
-0.0515387058,
-0.0405976847,
-0.0225858763,
-0.0320702381,
0.117524907,
0.0337826237,
0.0379628241,
-0.013201043,
-0.0144425137,
0.0090716705,
-0.0116621898,
0.0393036641,
-0.0520312116,
-0.0000286455,
-0.0730749443,
-0.078784503,
0.0268399045,
-0.0323679782,
0.0011116966,
0.0747049823,
-0.027060831,
-0.0519461296,
0.03276008,
0.0646601468,
0.0176355243,
0.0087691974,
-0.0395776741,
-0.0510002859,
0.0418377295,
0.0649097562,
-0.0095286351,
-0.0386297517,
0.0060625467,
-0.0419423133,
0.0089150239,
0.0225523971,
-0.0537587628,
0.0754488036,
0.068024002,
0.0220082458,
-0.0150742531,
-0.0359888859,
0.0229986683,
0.0505984649,
0.0651131794,
-0.0255123433,
0.0015687904,
-0.0535950288,
0.0014111387,
-0.0130362567,
-0.0597627833,
-0.043331828,
0.0473276936,
0.0286953729,
-0.0092365611,
-0.0188152399,
-0.0174379721,
-0.0328867435,
0.0674872473,
-0.0358706377,
0.0078394795,
0.0030182519,
0.0211825427,
0.0364939086,
0.006841532,
0.0010481956,
0.041177243,
0.0445320457,
0.0279999673,
-0.0024828992,
0.0370397605,
0.0218020659,
0.006418345,
-0.0355316885,
0.0204129368,
-0.0509198382,
-0.0399408937,
-0.0477849953,
0.027047392,
0.0528192371,
-0.0422881991,
0.0549339205,
-0.0313675962,
-0.0241936874,
-0.0201974064,
0.031961225,
0.0626374781,
-0.0222994946,
0.0027048315,
0.0313543603,
-0.0376080796,
-0.0206029732,
0.0448247977,
0.0419188999,
0.0218938272,
0.0330363512,
-0.0170206707,
-0.0278869588,
-0.009342947,
0.0066894772,
-0.0101321079,
-0.0261625852,
-0.0074243834,
-0.0495807193,
-0.0667063817,
-0.0008224907,
-0.0169470031,
-0.0462467,
0.0023614003,
0.0514610969,
0.0678650141,
0.0107466578,
0.0190458056,
-0.0164225511,
-0.0137172919,
0.0292422231,
-0.0395721197,
-0.0161251333,
-6.811512218e-33,
-0.0486355759,
-0.0517228357,
0.0150886737,
-0.0126373088,
0.0299854465,
0.0274549965,
-0.0420940556,
0.0182462018,
0.0369180664,
0.020130448,
-0.0180400126,
-0.0166135747,
0.0323511139,
0.0356490649,
0.0140143121,
-0.0406278744,
0.0325936265,
-0.0045327782,
-0.0039445031,
0.0236106459,
0.0159072466,
0.0365399867,
0.060670644,
-0.0925603881,
0.0228164699,
0.0082367696,
-0.0023781457,
0.0349558108,
0.0049850685,
0.0502217822,
-0.0176517665,
0.052666191,
0.0049436945,
-0.0370798744,
-0.0245703366,
0.0196115691,
-0.0803906843,
-0.0440265648,
0.0205334965,
0.0004667819,
-0.0247421786,
-0.0087391473,
0.0063180649,
-0.0046991711,
0.0127031282,
0.0460345224,
0.0471104793,
-0.0104473494,
-0.0136780245,
-0.0284334887,
-0.0549777895,
0.0191338621,
0.0008379124,
-0.0239914712,
0.0660762191,
0.0191496499,
-0.0148484986,
0.0167908352,
-0.0405141227,
0.023391366,
0.0299064722,
0.037709102,
0.0639234111,
0.0525241569,
0.0205689725,
0.0222558882,
0.0304310769,
0.0355352387,
0.0006961218,
-0.0060970844,
0.0162655041,
0.0381469205,
0.0198842604,
0.0189803503,
0.0163861178,
-0.0124539807,
-0.0122404844,
-0.0168437622,
-0.0158574488,
-0.0422906205,
0.0003597656,
-0.0130645558,
-0.0293117817,
-0.0341816023,
-0.0425173417,
0.0096835168,
-0.047191523,
-0.0027676593,
0.0435484163,
-0.0116713084,
-0.048624523,
0.007878704,
-0.0027049356,
0.00211738,
-0.0534307584,
-0.0514228232,
0.0003831621,
0.0250112787,
-0.0229951832,
0.0043371869,
-0.0394156165,
-0.0668204948,
0.021551827,
-0.0066259392,
0.0184571482,
-0.000655036,
0.0475545302,
0.0332771726,
-0.0632551238,
0.0071212626,
-0.0251279306,
0.0105167171,
0.0076170219,
0.009079325,
0.0239736829,
0.0136509249,
-0.0028757686,
0.0435408093,
0.0333274156,
-0.0432623178,
-0.0266496576,
-0.0128253037,
-0.0005787932,
0.0151309613,
-0.0244432185,
-0.029109465,
-0.046723146,
-0.017089067,
0.0461373143,
-0.0469255224,
0.010130194,
0.0017793434,
2.9e-7,
0.0609942749,
0.0488882698,
-0.0048797922,
0.0321231671,
-0.0024567894,
0.009390966,
-0.0237461869,
-0.0028181719,
-0.0129614696,
-0.0471722856,
0.0321542472,
0.0122352736,
0.0618372597,
0.0359552242,
-0.0944381952,
-0.0318325534,
-0.0406022742,
0.0002573772,
-0.0672118068,
-0.0101876613,
0.0558761023,
0.0761006922,
0.0191205796,
-0.0117551507,
-0.0353583992,
-0.0437961519,
-0.0001674848,
-0.0401669256,
-0.0009386028,
0.0469778441,
0.0199908428,
0.0139483055,
-0.018855175,
0.0560491607,
-0.0288954712,
-0.0332791507,
0.043263264,
0.0722650364,
-0.0073052775,
-0.0260275509,
-0.0130431596,
0.0075945919,
0.0102831293,
-0.0168753322,
0.0783852339,
-0.0534974113,
0.0029022899,
0.0265956391,
0.0201996695,
-0.029446125,
-0.0088531859,
-0.0275171511,
-0.0150941135,
0.0439057425,
0.0184766762,
0.0045518205,
-0.0346677005,
-0.0706944838,
-0.0102241561,
0.0109815225,
0.002386997,
-0.0056229923,
-0.0381501503,
-0.0116897244,
0.0095465463,
-0.0237164572,
0.0172640011,
2.947168671e-34,
0.0286704749,
0.0071241516,
0.0124167288,
0.0175203513,
0.0237391535,
-0.002216721,
-0.0367665179,
0.0298957713,
-0.0094425213,
-0.0586929657,
-0.0039369236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00571v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00571v1 | LLaVA-Interactive: An All-in-One Demo for Image Chat, Segmentation, Generation and Editing | 2023-11-01T15:13:43 | 2023-11-01T15:13:43 | Wei-Ge Chen, Irina Spiridonova, Jianwei Yang, Jianfeng Gao, Chunyuan Li | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.MM | LLaVA-Interactive is a research prototype for multimodal human-AI
interaction. The system can have multi-turn dialogues with human users by
taking multimodal user inputs and generating multimodal responses. Importantly,
LLaVA-Interactive goes beyond language prompt, where visual prompt is enabled
to align human intents in the interaction. The development of LLaVA-Interactive
is extremely cost-efficient as the system combines three multimodal skills of
pre-built AI models without additional model training: visual chat of LLaVA,
image segmentation from SEEM, as well as image generation and editing from
GLIGEN. A diverse set of application scenarios is presented to demonstrate the
promises of LLaVA-Interactive and to inspire future research in multimodal
interactive systems. | [
0.0277753286,
-0.0268182326,
-0.0034934883,
0.0320712067,
-0.0365125462,
-0.0092530064,
0.0406583026,
0.0000181804,
0.0351228975,
-0.0367475413,
-0.0551806688,
0.0041293446,
-0.0039621741,
0.0493504927,
0.0250663366,
-0.1342067719,
-0.0043163844,
-0.0108464574,
0.004438126,
-0.0105066616,
0.0198652986,
-0.0003110887,
-0.0963754579,
0.0214176793,
-0.0779929534,
-0.0214627348,
-0.0762978345,
0.001618501,
0.0087690894,
-0.0151494872,
-0.0619595908,
0.0221340004,
0.0216094721,
-0.0089295739,
0.0000020716,
-0.0463738181,
0.0311619118,
0.0060230503,
0.0115093505,
-0.0598493367,
0.0552984588,
0.0264127292,
-0.0278702453,
-0.0233768038,
-0.0368631966,
0.0558989979,
0.0971492529,
0.0475047566,
0.1101296172,
0.0254099276,
-0.0176184289,
-0.0376974791,
0.0122654997,
0.0378594846,
0.013290694,
-0.0165530313,
-0.0155864917,
0.0121747172,
0.0669639781,
-0.0255971011,
-0.0248681605,
0.0381545052,
0.032931,
-0.0403847061,
0.0179010332,
0.060695298,
-0.0350828767,
-0.1161284894,
-0.0499860607,
0.0568328314,
-0.0310460385,
0.0415732376,
0.0070565767,
0.0060081715,
0.0138008688,
-0.0066437894,
-0.0313325226,
0.0198637918,
-0.0513348766,
-0.0326952636,
-0.0701242164,
-0.0094430968,
-0.0317114256,
-0.0357389152,
0.0016017052,
-0.0036408913,
0.0387491137,
0.0187736172,
-0.0250515677,
-0.0056854817,
-0.0425677858,
-0.0807110816,
0.0242551565,
0.0528441146,
-0.0489026345,
0.0105563775,
-0.0452710949,
0.0036755735,
-0.0058579161,
-0.0261387303,
0.0146971792,
0.0096183075,
-0.0692201927,
0.0564014837,
0.0373237506,
0.0340229385,
0.004109344,
0.0332607068,
0.0074500432,
-0.0117800022,
-0.0014368471,
-0.0394545048,
-0.0364518426,
-0.0138304587,
-0.0772928819,
-0.0182797201,
-0.0364225507,
0.0530902706,
-0.0238994695,
0.0302613247,
0.008502637,
0.0190381967,
-0.0352709629,
0.0215495639,
-0.0582701601,
-0.0151926251,
-0.0374689177,
0.0170871392,
0.0110688936,
-0.0687848404,
0.0306733213,
0.039679829,
0.0001391305,
-0.0068857181,
-0.0401743539,
0.0685978234,
-0.0783086941,
-0.0092244213,
-0.0192456506,
0.0152229443,
0.0049890336,
-0.0594239794,
0.0289191809,
0.0006054711,
0.0242865086,
-0.0361184664,
0.000280778,
-0.0179845039,
0.0053916783,
0.0150963897,
0.0341164209,
0.0964853317,
0.0131311901,
0.0200232919,
0.0734802559,
0.0330170877,
-0.0176098943,
0.0154305249,
0.0270748772,
0.028112622,
0.0503507033,
-0.0182753094,
0.03817394,
0.0640830323,
-0.0398109816,
-0.043719586,
0.0139386514,
-0.0015607566,
-0.0251195524,
0.0448613241,
-0.0104001751,
0.029091442,
-0.0425770842,
-0.0107493429,
0.0593826249,
0.0574458316,
0.0208577085,
-0.0019366594,
0.0427672751,
0.0193860214,
0.0320239477,
-0.0137562957,
-0.0383893177,
0.097232841,
0.008659726,
0.0001859849,
-0.0032875477,
0.0296919271,
-0.0285680201,
-0.0230309293,
0.0267362576,
-0.0111662764,
0.0209241975,
-0.010929185,
0.0650007352,
0.0076998016,
-0.0281811208,
-0.0537946895,
-0.0292338487,
-0.0588463396,
-0.0338951685,
-0.0472546779,
0.0293020718,
0.0571212918,
0.0155923013,
-0.0109174671,
-0.014931079,
0.0076874839,
0.0022672722,
0.0432237796,
0.0155170169,
-0.0292195715,
0.0344124176,
-0.0192657411,
-0.0019906771,
-0.0133354617,
-0.0134494686,
0.0231237169,
-0.0008132165,
-0.0045514838,
-0.0288006552,
0.0212722216,
0.078814432,
0.0446510352,
0.0005284389,
0.0233531669,
-0.0578205362,
0.0395157039,
0.0345404856,
0.0192037411,
-0.0234256051,
-0.020186916,
0.012991949,
0.0313978903,
0.0323030613,
0.0420788825,
0.0119627556,
-0.0186450891,
0.0092579434,
-0.0487934723,
-0.0141415372,
-0.0247131363,
-0.0057384945,
-0.0268396139,
-0.0149828009,
0.0045660366,
0.0086828889,
-0.0372180156,
0.0256718043,
0.039622739,
0.0096171182,
-0.0118247634,
0.0290143788,
-0.0162819941,
-0.0378334858,
-0.0073514679,
0.0454853401,
-0.0163610987,
-0.0537552722,
0.001627396,
0.0238169562,
-0.0027587956,
-0.0243047811,
-0.0143190781,
0.0311028305,
-0.0596630424,
0.0080937101,
-0.1097196043,
-0.0487626195,
-0.0122291576,
-0.048665937,
-0.0103412904,
0.0184962284,
-0.0101956828,
-0.0331049562,
-0.0161134005,
0.0581921749,
0.0244279969,
-0.0065201377,
0.0367348716,
0.0105696004,
0.0060353465,
-0.0572127998,
0.0245775729,
0.0294861794,
0.0179477017,
0.0390656851,
-0.070222266,
-0.0435471311,
-0.010747496,
-0.0463626496,
0.0533490703,
-0.0221438315,
-0.0360376202,
0.0263557285,
0.0107040163,
0.0310752057,
0.0831114352,
-0.0019290062,
0.0334206223,
0.0032525412,
-0.0332538188,
-0.01795022,
0.0297515802,
0.0225256216,
0.0069955555,
0.0124887051,
0.0105783921,
0.0067524356,
0.0107157538,
0.0106734075,
0.0407321118,
-0.0121375285,
0.0199752171,
0.0281320717,
-0.0733802468,
0.0029852346,
0.0249398705,
-0.0376433767,
0.002374795,
-0.0725391507,
-0.0668567866,
0.0219567306,
-0.0259622987,
-0.0713212565,
0.0466468967,
-0.0065910229,
0.0257937685,
0.0514515564,
0.0092368163,
0.016671652,
-0.0053187944,
0.0123870932,
-0.0291973539,
0.0055918847,
-0.005370507,
-0.00395336,
-0.0113102319,
-0.0880331919,
0.0023260086,
-0.0199467912,
-0.0212045051,
-0.0136015406,
0.0256182663,
-0.0005207139,
-0.0422901511,
0.0223728046,
-0.0406145826,
0.006910502,
0.0382601209,
0.0239710268,
0.0002168049,
0.010013476,
-0.0144200567,
-0.0084804287,
-0.0023957659,
0.036911007,
0.0318464413,
-0.069839716,
-0.012302543,
0.0556642562,
0.0272022523,
0.0025810678,
-0.0670011938,
-0.0441009887,
0.0346184187,
0.0079346541,
0.003786457,
-0.0279561691,
0.0436260141,
0.0904800817,
0.0136974594,
0.0019002885,
0.0445149392,
0.0249654669,
-0.0341398753,
-0.0107361423,
-0.0078012566,
-0.0074187778,
0.0451775566,
0.0203559678,
-0.0430168137,
-0.0297960751,
0.0107224761,
-0.0541051738,
0.0076913317,
-0.0198973026,
-0.0232908092,
-0.053998258,
0.0931579024,
-0.0045620264,
-0.0352614932,
-0.0008066879,
0.0186512079,
0.0680957884,
0.0145486435,
-0.0339248553,
0.0179301109,
-0.0122664068,
-0.0178604703,
-0.0089863921,
0.0256936345,
0.0448732637,
-0.0174947288,
0.0007840411,
0.0194384772,
0.0503701121,
0.0227223523,
0.0248880703,
-0.043377623,
0.0266567208,
0.0752135515,
0.0354935415,
-0.0318914056,
0.0595347323,
0.0110766171,
0.0003282454,
-0.0194704123,
0.0445748903,
0.0667606592,
0.0103499945,
0.0102236653,
0.0182479005,
-0.045055978,
0.0196731444,
-0.0330204293,
0.0161659177,
0.0337460041,
0.0004191241,
-0.0168355238,
-0.0252165031,
-0.0645718575,
-0.0061710849,
-0.0156430658,
-0.0139678651,
-0.0343083814,
-0.0013030937,
-0.0550493486,
-0.0599203892,
-0.0539005809,
-0.046407748,
0.0734118074,
0.0390817188,
-0.0225756038,
-0.0286393464,
0.0073207202,
0.0732539743,
-0.0115891555,
-0.0007886803,
0.0146753285,
0.0253124889,
-0.0251935273,
-0.0161733646,
0.0183642693,
-0.0501897559,
0.0046141851,
0.0176204816,
-0.0380486436,
-0.0253610741,
-0.0104788598,
0.0953887776,
0.019124927,
0.0206952598,
0.0040552211,
-0.0330357477,
0.0100066271,
-0.0106731765,
0.0019015534,
0.0034312487,
0.0012010599,
0.0631158948,
0.0104254503,
-0.0027720658,
-0.0543961115,
-0.0116610788,
-0.0227795225,
-0.0249065738,
-0.0382594839,
-0.0875751749,
-0.0216487013,
0.0248250924,
0.0170466714,
-0.0285140276,
0.0112675717,
-0.0200800002,
0.0115054687,
-0.0235411488,
0.0022529326,
-0.0764235333,
0.0195892174,
-0.0325155668,
0.0064314525,
0.0400388539,
0.0052795308,
-0.0146252625,
0.0106281536,
-0.0239231195,
0.0232066233,
0.0301352814,
0.0001010563,
-0.0156691689,
0.0311257169,
0.035446655,
0.0327637233,
0.0020723785,
0.0286455471,
0.048043035,
0.1165024415,
-0.0250823051,
-0.0520983338,
0.0060222433,
0.08774212,
0.0227259547,
-0.0086170202,
-0.0180159621,
0.1078100801,
0.0707060248,
0.0650543198,
0.0130907483,
-0.0240013693,
0.0170426015,
-0.0190822091,
0.0713554919,
0.0332406648,
-0.0674936026,
0.0416144766,
-0.0389219299,
-0.010322039,
-0.0227811169,
0.0217750072,
-0.0624536015,
0.0121051613,
-0.0227559358,
-0.0091380589,
-0.0678243563,
-0.0294913035,
0.0253138654,
-0.00864104,
0.0014406893,
0.0402412228,
-0.0114969872,
-0.0152167073,
-0.0348288082,
0.0374945104,
-0.02028808,
0.0083769374,
0.0679591522,
0.0404782519,
-0.0064646113,
-0.0243448447,
-0.0102380859,
-0.0335343741,
-0.0280205403,
-0.0050121755,
0.0117455386,
-5.778517905e-33,
-0.0451573022,
-0.0355301462,
0.0694026276,
-0.009048406,
-0.0242474508,
-0.0707803816,
-0.0186953489,
0.0256491993,
-0.0101794861,
0.0024715802,
-0.0117412247,
-0.0198072549,
0.0072433976,
0.0016061448,
0.0135014821,
0.0084644295,
0.0055858828,
0.0049330895,
-0.0253078714,
0.0105840657,
0.0251581594,
0.0136844292,
0.0039045981,
-0.0669635832,
-0.0066257678,
0.0129078981,
-0.037926618,
0.0241995174,
-0.0404184088,
0.0209211819,
-0.0345642567,
0.0121680722,
0.0071868706,
0.010675027,
0.0006651672,
0.0274410639,
-0.0480538346,
-0.0329894312,
-0.0030026806,
0.0641448125,
-0.101961121,
-0.0018023932,
0.0069137709,
-0.0072777765,
0.0213123634,
-0.0022154734,
0.0422649197,
-0.0004493874,
0.0037282244,
0.018647911,
-0.0429250635,
0.0256123878,
-0.0372527167,
-0.0963602737,
0.0294371285,
0.0579479933,
0.0313056,
-0.0312584266,
-0.036139302,
0.0225336831,
-0.0419381708,
-0.0379743315,
0.0817250237,
0.0121230753,
0.0047696247,
0.0183239914,
0.0237751324,
-0.0830188319,
-0.0207993481,
0.0074484791,
-0.0405464731,
0.0966264829,
-0.0299072526,
0.0337286368,
-0.0400362276,
-0.0041140961,
0.0077899219,
0.0501920208,
-0.0031867954,
0.0594681129,
-0.0449227951,
0.0448588803,
-0.0049595763,
0.0470297076,
0.0375575908,
-0.041988913,
-0.0299946107,
-0.0474737845,
0.0297580529,
-0.0028132924,
0.0474150442,
-0.020547213,
0.0552408919,
0.0231902134,
0.0409173816,
-0.0566538051,
-0.0151551412,
0.0769741461,
-0.0091559924,
-0.029044183,
-0.0047018365,
-0.0200846754,
0.0486824885,
0.0373893082,
0.028357802,
0.0380228162,
-0.0105875628,
0.0295598656,
0.0081208646,
-0.0106423777,
-0.0145486929,
0.061314974,
0.0320057608,
0.0271109901,
0.000823934,
-0.0338090844,
-0.0822802708,
0.0257881805,
-0.0263534803,
-0.0174491424,
-0.0527048372,
-0.0429500341,
-0.0280760415,
-0.0223348085,
-0.0621213913,
0.028880395,
-0.0416423082,
0.0188319199,
0.0120830582,
-0.0531668477,
-0.0239882674,
0.0249170922,
2.848e-7,
-0.0248185117,
0.0253615808,
0.0146790482,
0.022527568,
0.0039955075,
0.0393644422,
-0.0265965406,
0.0213966183,
-0.0337814689,
0.0057574613,
0.0301136039,
0.037452165,
0.0305370484,
0.0044336929,
-0.030671984,
-0.0288780723,
0.0079122605,
-0.0123559423,
-0.05009,
0.0244775545,
0.0592395514,
0.0201272704,
0.0107582202,
-0.0114469957,
0.0507786237,
0.0014943983,
0.0286558755,
-0.0258241761,
-0.0101710446,
-0.0329720192,
0.0344470367,
-0.0047063185,
0.003438663,
0.010822786,
-0.0194625575,
-0.0333612226,
0.0269083977,
0.0349791609,
-0.056084916,
-0.0298872609,
0.0188325569,
0.0387649685,
-0.0223682616,
-0.0235262457,
0.040202111,
-0.0148010412,
-0.0265446734,
-0.0145933572,
-0.0058488413,
-0.0006575842,
-0.0084163342,
-0.0385196395,
-0.0253603347,
0.0281472299,
0.0101716472,
-0.0303087533,
-0.0317555331,
-0.0367810801,
-0.0287848283,
-0.0379679166,
-0.0529674329,
-0.0423431695,
-0.0396554209,
-0.0220130328,
0.0178778023,
-0.0069749211,
-0.0480439253,
1.725471883e-34,
-0.0129782818,
0.0288389213,
0.0101897297,
0.0672745854,
0.0602000616,
0.0294769332,
0.0029981062,
0.0167511776,
0.008459229,
-0.0056204246,
-0.0439520366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00541v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00541v5 | An Embedded Diachronic Sense Change Model with a Case Study from Ancient Greek | 2023-11-01T14:20:18 | 2024-06-25T16:13:12 | Schyan Zafar, Geoff K. Nicholls | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ME | Word meanings change over time, and word senses evolve, emerge or die out in
the process. For ancient languages, where the corpora are often small and
sparse, modelling such changes accurately proves challenging, and quantifying
uncertainty in sense-change estimates consequently becomes important. GASC
(Genre-Aware Semantic Change) and DiSC (Diachronic Sense Change) are existing
generative models that have been used to analyse sense change for target words
from an ancient Greek text corpus, using unsupervised learning without the help
of any pre-training. These models represent the senses of a given target word
such as "kosmos" (meaning decoration, order or world) as distributions over
context words, and sense prevalence as a distribution over senses. The models
are fitted using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods to measure temporal
changes in these representations. This paper introduces EDiSC, an Embedded DiSC
model, which combines word embeddings with DiSC to provide superior model
performance. It is shown empirically that EDiSC offers improved predictive
accuracy, ground-truth recovery and uncertainty quantification, as well as
better sampling efficiency and scalability properties with MCMC methods. The
challenges of fitting these models are also discussed. | [
-0.0125465309,
0.0350889936,
-0.0428692624,
0.0186183229,
-0.0326210782,
-0.0065181269,
-0.0400738902,
0.0365592055,
-0.0196323097,
-0.0509926081,
0.0173513591,
-0.0362442285,
0.0480351038,
0.0131072355,
0.01083594,
-0.0211889558,
0.0592179522,
0.0027292222,
-0.0524102077,
0.0286080856,
-0.0356517658,
-0.0160955898,
-0.0120188883,
-0.0219380669,
0.0051485617,
-0.0406767577,
-0.0240105204,
-0.0070650121,
0.0213663969,
-0.0293859895,
-0.0514245443,
0.0073511638,
0.0721947551,
0.0833340809,
0.0000020937,
-0.0521782823,
-0.0133765293,
-0.0257250331,
0.0073842197,
0.0148603916,
0.088339515,
0.0108305188,
-0.0277387444,
-0.085714303,
-0.0352009833,
-0.0009844524,
0.0147094922,
-0.0385081209,
-0.0394341014,
0.0427672789,
-0.0206004251,
-0.0478187948,
-0.0023906017,
-0.0276931003,
0.0333988816,
0.0119793294,
0.039944645,
0.0255165771,
-0.0065038796,
0.0152376732,
-0.0641018078,
0.0305988546,
-0.0274040215,
0.0264825039,
0.0263383333,
0.0343115665,
0.0410012379,
0.0555036739,
-0.0041921223,
-0.0501929596,
0.0352617167,
-0.0036663385,
-0.010200657,
-0.0063883862,
-0.0441561304,
0.0423679985,
-0.0035854701,
-0.0552394651,
-0.0101951314,
0.0025855955,
0.0305485111,
0.0062267897,
0.0193096474,
0.0317525454,
-0.0656624138,
0.0849882886,
0.0650037974,
-0.0523137413,
0.0040677404,
-0.0074763685,
-0.0122265471,
-0.0098272543,
-0.0263711233,
0.0091283349,
0.0156894438,
0.0338822417,
0.0210076682,
0.0007476109,
-0.0081323758,
-0.048474595,
-0.0072196918,
0.0007037188,
-0.0127944406,
0.0530872233,
-0.0098494543,
-0.0073240371,
0.0552227907,
-0.0567161888,
-0.029338453,
0.0368988886,
-0.0424181409,
0.0179690234,
-0.0162922833,
-0.0127303516,
-0.0365622826,
-0.0008176175,
-0.0387265868,
0.0561023019,
0.0635072067,
-0.050635796,
0.0117779244,
-0.0272536278,
-0.0582973063,
0.0237088297,
-0.0456883796,
-0.0032432547,
-0.0185359456,
0.0231492296,
-0.0334459133,
-0.0158038232,
0.0221709311,
0.0025635951,
0.0252138972,
-0.015771402,
0.0008184658,
0.0412849747,
0.00804462,
-0.0509393811,
-0.0600099042,
-0.0095866732,
-0.0831509084,
-0.0099502914,
-0.0260304343,
-0.0152424397,
-0.0033378145,
-0.0509307496,
0.0206935573,
-0.0232843161,
-0.0341329128,
0.0117945261,
-0.0273909681,
0.058332257,
-0.0148062324,
-0.0069084582,
0.0128514403,
-0.0286387652,
0.0606502183,
0.045187749,
0.0757299438,
-0.0125655616,
0.0510712191,
0.0135418205,
-0.0631349087,
0.0032047641,
-0.0293462686,
0.0507595465,
-0.0289704707,
-0.0246193092,
-0.0231596604,
0.0770536885,
-0.0015900395,
0.0050027883,
-0.0175022576,
-0.0292847361,
0.0335046127,
0.0212199241,
0.0109541621,
-0.0491805375,
0.0637753904,
-0.0656381398,
-0.0255654864,
0.0060301721,
0.0337511264,
-0.0282429326,
0.0126638571,
0.0016062382,
-0.0008894939,
-0.015008145,
-0.0051161987,
-0.0153682875,
0.005387044,
0.0159504861,
0.0065010032,
-0.0316217393,
0.0938731357,
0.0226155631,
-0.0047876979,
-0.013888062,
0.0306823477,
-0.0359099694,
0.0164908543,
-0.0002095654,
0.0715017766,
0.0736376494,
0.0768229067,
-0.0571953021,
0.0386360884,
0.0078081107,
-0.0043463167,
0.0254342202,
-0.0361409895,
-0.0135507481,
-0.0022937488,
-0.0382115468,
0.0107355146,
0.0122376792,
0.0199920125,
0.0260183923,
-0.0387445055,
0.0546093136,
0.0025957341,
-0.0974291936,
0.0326952562,
0.0384668224,
-0.033124052,
-0.037596114,
-0.0246536229,
-0.0110424794,
0.0362392664,
0.0133806989,
0.000100584,
0.0062082056,
0.0230074953,
-0.0378205404,
0.0017746261,
0.0284770988,
-0.0623030886,
-0.0163535774,
0.0662961975,
-0.0110961385,
0.0421166755,
-0.0553169176,
0.0041026394,
-0.0207190849,
0.063525483,
-0.0344489887,
0.0573028885,
-0.0507455282,
0.0263425838,
-0.0276741013,
0.0149045279,
-0.0385077223,
0.077398777,
-0.0233574938,
0.0063445047,
-0.0148440367,
0.0401119664,
0.0274776295,
0.0051064333,
-0.0421149731,
-0.0048193564,
0.0419400223,
-0.0356428362,
0.0179797485,
-0.0397307985,
-0.0128063541,
-0.0093798954,
-0.0635773689,
0.0110038975,
-0.022100497,
0.0183661822,
0.0082511483,
0.0221387297,
-0.0190558527,
0.0250428002,
0.001281472,
0.0694982708,
-0.0391195454,
0.0582097135,
0.0070105125,
-0.0391704589,
-0.002020976,
-0.0517154932,
-0.0188440699,
-0.0064741019,
0.0695050806,
0.0521957502,
-0.0050878339,
-0.0299062692,
-0.0308068302,
-0.0684416294,
0.0233979914,
-0.0260867178,
0.0222208612,
0.0078243557,
-0.0261865631,
0.1104999259,
-0.0059287767,
0.0356910825,
0.0351303443,
0.0713087842,
-0.0626869351,
-0.0214719549,
-0.0368635282,
-0.0351060219,
-0.009348534,
-0.0558756366,
-0.0251808446,
0.0009591259,
0.0524663515,
0.0402699783,
-0.0015719252,
-0.0307197589,
0.0326287858,
-0.0592734851,
0.0036999246,
0.0067637926,
0.0269592162,
-0.0688732788,
0.0303737,
-0.0017672969,
-0.0330052227,
0.029759381,
0.0093025398,
0.0308770612,
-0.0664227605,
-0.0331328399,
-0.0235440768,
0.0460925251,
0.0278209653,
0.0043349885,
0.0321336091,
0.0105148824,
-0.0819542855,
0.028955562,
0.0998421311,
-0.0555898659,
0.0101521807,
-0.0528531335,
0.0244576149,
0.0228143651,
0.0670673773,
0.0149470046,
-0.0008941896,
-0.0146265086,
0.010233962,
0.0380962193,
0.0017130047,
0.0101301353,
0.031865187,
-0.0709724426,
0.0161363725,
0.0269557703,
-0.0390874334,
-0.0318026282,
0.0215064734,
0.0363528691,
-0.0274708867,
-0.0250523686,
0.0045611537,
-0.0169336814,
-0.0060997931,
-0.0312073529,
-0.0567913875,
-0.1090162918,
0.0038917908,
0.0084940623,
-0.0286978297,
0.0100885918,
-0.0139786163,
-0.049075406,
-0.0076219696,
-0.0114322044,
0.0477129668,
0.0192639902,
-0.062810272,
0.0324839465,
-0.0008639802,
-0.0061984393,
0.0210055951,
-0.0408036001,
-0.0401560403,
0.0037219613,
-0.0078752674,
0.0270581767,
0.0187722463,
-0.076011911,
0.0137389135,
-0.0674180388,
0.0100301532,
0.0014586883,
-0.0608285628,
-0.0122686457,
-0.0181886461,
0.0315743238,
-0.0054371273,
-0.0547112077,
-0.0071161417,
0.0096879546,
0.0326148234,
0.0089739962,
-0.0095396619,
-0.0431489311,
0.0244154409,
-0.0236056354,
0.0178033058,
0.0520618781,
0.0719962716,
0.0002808066,
-0.0687766299,
-0.0200178325,
-0.0402671248,
-0.0061069913,
-0.0149215553,
0.0123864366,
-0.0035272324,
0.0239641331,
0.0458127819,
-0.0165027548,
0.0014969585,
-0.0472483002,
0.0292127654,
0.080514878,
-0.0245186444,
-0.0239234474,
-0.036613483,
0.0028257496,
0.0255410187,
0.0351677611,
-0.0066215438,
-0.0151484916,
0.0281839445,
0.0109031415,
0.0458660647,
0.0561465584,
-0.0299729109,
-0.0399878807,
-0.0225563664,
-0.0302215405,
-0.1021900773,
0.0050943284,
-0.0165524911,
0.0448224247,
0.0375279039,
0.0174791999,
-0.038956929,
-0.0347132608,
-0.099221684,
-0.031349659,
-0.0244430508,
0.0333509222,
-0.01208698,
-0.0195784755,
0.0359618254,
0.0077658822,
-0.0280163251,
0.0160022806,
-0.0739499107,
-0.0514871292,
0.0059164916,
-0.0023897544,
0.010924506,
0.0312540829,
-0.0086724041,
-0.000290515,
0.063034676,
-0.0281214565,
0.0043580318,
0.0642311275,
-0.0092041576,
0.0156000517,
-0.0201808028,
0.0278284568,
-0.0136394138,
0.0239416379,
0.0085351737,
0.0394789241,
-0.023564687,
-0.069221966,
0.0132329464,
-0.057764329,
0.0567084178,
-0.0604978427,
-0.0239796173,
-0.020899754,
-0.0379789211,
-0.0324398726,
-0.0049194945,
0.0235909745,
-0.0168671403,
0.0128380004,
-0.0176582839,
-0.0438433811,
0.0112448419,
-0.0268802792,
0.0185173843,
-0.0040217931,
-0.0182598084,
0.1035167202,
0.0073724231,
-0.0034964446,
0.0370468348,
0.0247988701,
-0.0153859193,
-0.0638579354,
0.0150834005,
0.0145604406,
0.0391020067,
0.0100961989,
-0.0240044836,
0.0069752736,
-0.0081391865,
-0.046328444,
0.0234698132,
0.0074505252,
-0.0109567884,
0.0586357228,
-0.0015740254,
0.0651128292,
-0.0286898743,
-0.00387847,
-0.0404500552,
0.0291466601,
0.0459616594,
0.0060018273,
0.0166524276,
0.0143879643,
0.0023860622,
0.0541134141,
0.0354566351,
-0.0407759286,
0.0478063449,
-0.0231425669,
-0.0533517301,
-0.0055198874,
0.0164737199,
-0.041595418,
0.0146391289,
-0.0161905568,
0.0112890536,
-0.0943555012,
-0.0383215472,
0.027713282,
0.0269752536,
-0.0019096601,
0.0308394823,
0.0406303331,
0.035393443,
-0.0092897499,
0.0582122914,
-0.073268421,
0.0512596779,
-0.0425483361,
-0.015488347,
-0.0407074317,
-5.91789774e-33,
-0.0397662371,
0.0300598461,
0.0104862889,
-0.0204922725,
-0.0358408913,
-0.0024866408,
-0.0473119058,
-0.0100321462,
0.0497968867,
0.0237086937,
0.0321046859,
0.0090950271,
-0.0033461924,
-0.0352578536,
0.0448141471,
0.0294782929,
0.0484958217,
-0.0040849717,
0.0141990213,
-0.0134190284,
0.1029459834,
0.0160788894,
0.0807028562,
-0.0301082954,
0.052603282,
0.0490148813,
0.009907404,
-0.0012864501,
0.0411822423,
0.0168814566,
-0.0235731322,
0.0394038856,
0.0016730081,
0.0210665409,
-0.0190921072,
-0.0374786258,
-0.0361157544,
-0.0457249954,
0.0167978425,
0.0370379314,
0.0031383201,
-0.0099277562,
-0.0590624735,
0.0162599646,
0.0001258392,
0.0143005503,
0.0554838181,
-0.0416579135,
-0.084879294,
-0.0786382779,
-0.0365132615,
0.0644173846,
0.0132916225,
0.0030226142,
0.0128412684,
-0.0071237003,
0.053057611,
0.0052958294,
-0.0267924946,
0.0399959609,
-0.0078193722,
0.0053103673,
0.0039448482,
0.0377999581,
0.0112003898,
0.045098383,
0.0110770036,
-0.0532352962,
0.0267366879,
0.0563415773,
0.0496094562,
-0.0158583391,
-0.0150445588,
0.0717949569,
0.0463540778,
-0.0097800549,
0.0014438129,
0.0021691716,
-0.000890547,
0.0165630542,
0.0497855507,
0.0278383661,
-0.0322030261,
-0.0013258045,
-0.0119054317,
-0.0226348974,
0.0083725806,
-0.0298901536,
0.0042455513,
-0.0258578751,
0.0089100171,
0.0170699656,
0.0049345726,
-0.048080463,
-0.0239893943,
-0.0257009082,
-0.0381905846,
-0.0106637422,
0.020202335,
0.0079178941,
0.0225515626,
-0.0194373224,
0.0524771549,
0.0023020138,
-0.0303624421,
-0.0122763962,
-0.0424490832,
0.00700976,
-0.0125656063,
0.0001565263,
0.0251544937,
-0.0949683338,
-0.0226289779,
0.0018254624,
0.0087064328,
-0.0076047061,
-0.0063121887,
0.0115793338,
0.0735712275,
-0.0196055919,
0.0198854022,
-0.0139486846,
0.0143192876,
0.0294235684,
-0.0071562482,
0.007308939,
0.0321578085,
0.0231464002,
0.0687862039,
-0.0145590659,
0.0208658259,
0.0235059559,
3.031e-7,
0.0686388239,
0.005071728,
-0.0183063615,
-0.0112667531,
0.0396057777,
-0.0219273996,
-0.014488277,
0.0004285868,
-0.0225059409,
-0.014398844,
0.023196457,
-0.0082566254,
0.0255497433,
0.0361751877,
-0.0435387269,
-0.0225266442,
-0.0058942898,
0.0144928498,
-0.0595480464,
-0.0158457048,
0.0451626033,
0.0804930255,
0.0266068988,
-0.0236323923,
-0.0183944888,
-0.0003407347,
0.0376520194,
-0.0209515728,
0.0050148643,
0.0114407688,
0.0573621504,
-0.002916856,
0.0103522614,
0.0459140502,
-0.0453010276,
0.008129416,
0.0390417054,
-0.0131196771,
-0.0095088826,
0.0625762418,
0.0001265767,
-0.0134285446,
-0.0050283191,
-0.0129028754,
0.0406581312,
0.0000717475,
0.0256362148,
-0.0639299974,
-0.087977156,
0.0587199591,
0.0414110236,
0.0229729358,
-0.0533643477,
0.0048460113,
0.0287522897,
0.0482150204,
-0.0401405282,
-0.0735164285,
0.0542692803,
0.0325733759,
-0.0371464677,
-0.0500290468,
0.0093206158,
-0.0369582698,
0.0238436572,
-0.0335870571,
-0.0278143194,
2.363692076e-34,
0.0312722288,
0.0088737765,
-0.0298798215,
-0.0115983197,
-0.021636337,
-0.0391638055,
0.075838536,
0.0139986742,
0.0404898264,
-0.0501219779,
-0.0242361184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00522v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00522v1 | Text Rendering Strategies for Pixel Language Models | 2023-11-01T13:49:31 | 2023-11-01T13:49:31 | Jonas F. Lotz, Elizabeth Salesky, Phillip Rust, Desmond Elliott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pixel-based language models process text rendered as images, which allows
them to handle any script, making them a promising approach to open vocabulary
language modelling. However, recent approaches use text renderers that produce
a large set of almost-equivalent input patches, which may prove sub-optimal for
downstream tasks, due to redundancy in the input representations. In this
paper, we investigate four approaches to rendering text in the PIXEL model
(Rust et al., 2023), and find that simple character bigram rendering brings
improved performance on sentence-level tasks without compromising performance
on token-level or multilingual tasks. This new rendering strategy also makes it
possible to train a more compact model with only 22M parameters that performs
on par with the original 86M parameter model. Our analyses show that character
bigram rendering leads to a consistently better model but with an anisotropic
patch embedding space, driven by a patch frequency bias, highlighting the
connections between image patch- and tokenization-based language models. | [
0.0038864585,
0.0449980274,
-0.01116719,
0.0594106503,
-0.0495166853,
-0.02030495,
0.0446501672,
0.0387619175,
-0.0563558303,
-0.0445743762,
0.0048535801,
-0.0792238638,
0.0292982664,
0.0390656292,
0.0483657047,
-0.071344398,
0.004491678,
-0.0581524633,
-0.0164154135,
-0.0141394073,
0.0204904955,
0.0106030749,
0.0186703335,
0.0288220439,
-0.0428830124,
-0.0444599055,
-0.0121971415,
0.0143102147,
0.002142705,
0.0076543163,
-0.0379128456,
0.0702791438,
0.0350456238,
0.015865868,
0.0000019528,
-0.0133741638,
0.0275051221,
0.012368517,
0.0389163755,
0.0682384595,
0.0855130479,
-0.0290359911,
-0.0354984254,
-0.0006078981,
0.0007790943,
-0.0400629528,
0.0878327489,
0.0387337133,
0.0318767987,
0.0420497358,
-0.0208019335,
-0.0427453071,
0.0232189111,
-0.020875942,
-0.006957591,
0.0339544192,
-0.0032455977,
-0.0130713945,
0.0072248159,
0.0028495623,
-0.052270446,
0.0369935073,
-0.0002822554,
-0.0128422808,
0.0082170349,
0.0737103522,
0.0100661423,
-0.0325955935,
0.0068678539,
0.055853419,
-0.0525254831,
0.0057408786,
-0.030303074,
-0.0034946164,
-0.0374003574,
-0.0092688957,
-0.0411392041,
0.0624497347,
0.0130909439,
0.0547397546,
-0.0226541515,
-0.0349162444,
0.0262844507,
-0.0093661938,
-0.0498316325,
0.0018886412,
0.029208824,
-0.0158748869,
-0.0520828404,
0.0194839742,
-0.0407723114,
-0.0511994846,
0.0254402738,
0.0060627777,
0.0438643098,
0.0321143977,
-0.0592800826,
-0.0655289143,
0.0305086635,
-0.0100888377,
0.0607659146,
0.0358829051,
-0.03888724,
0.0274133831,
-0.0446764529,
0.0338269882,
0.0026554377,
0.0553151332,
-0.029440023,
-0.0063511562,
0.0220293347,
-0.0075553046,
-0.0449255481,
0.0265498701,
-0.0537399463,
-0.0334923603,
0.0212234668,
0.0015256418,
0.0083440719,
-0.0152150504,
0.0476902649,
-0.0044818092,
-0.0386735946,
-0.0111166378,
-0.0159921385,
0.0180629008,
0.0030916894,
0.0045996169,
0.003735966,
-0.0421285518,
-0.0082458267,
0.0002603121,
0.033328291,
0.006131121,
-0.0297537819,
0.026455028,
0.0018314769,
-0.0451191105,
-0.0132963648,
0.0423188172,
-0.0319205523,
-0.0165829044,
-0.0050615268,
-0.0775449723,
0.0062500765,
-0.0051956279,
0.0324462987,
-0.0263892151,
0.0029650636,
0.0419713333,
-0.0274326168,
0.0639579594,
-0.0426558182,
-0.0156963021,
0.0158625375,
0.0011701001,
0.0688304752,
0.0885445476,
0.0363831446,
0.0188737623,
0.0234810896,
-0.0046455734,
-0.0435041785,
0.0523866713,
-0.0011381605,
0.019641906,
-0.0600112267,
-0.0294674933,
0.0762156025,
0.0474259555,
0.0695915073,
0.1041333824,
-0.0532220528,
-0.0533570051,
0.0449115634,
0.0450017303,
0.0226712748,
-0.0068686446,
0.0282694567,
0.003619507,
0.0250992887,
-0.0000012596,
0.018343823,
0.0058167628,
0.0881399289,
0.0308047701,
0.0382881723,
0.0456775501,
-0.038195882,
-0.0175697133,
-0.023857845,
-0.0142303742,
0.0075140581,
-0.0413489118,
0.041624371,
0.0254049692,
-0.0663321987,
0.0280398261,
0.0293399766,
-0.0304560196,
-0.0012951114,
-0.0788449198,
0.028317472,
0.0614383481,
0.0599825792,
0.0256474297,
0.021581145,
-0.0009140393,
0.0561886355,
0.1037154496,
0.0066704666,
0.0168216471,
0.0199220851,
-0.060967017,
0.0123371677,
-0.0283520296,
-0.008848032,
0.0512586869,
-0.006446599,
0.0073717688,
-0.0151603697,
-0.0641017705,
-0.0134904981,
0.0442090183,
0.048856996,
-0.0076406822,
-0.0071264277,
0.0008355195,
-0.0183238983,
-0.0098242741,
-0.0467566922,
0.0155601632,
0.0003618319,
-0.0559439287,
0.0477417149,
-0.0367685594,
-0.0577918254,
-0.0502150841,
0.0448538885,
-0.0046632746,
0.0191614479,
0.0369960777,
-0.023411423,
-0.0141012222,
0.0178118963,
-0.0217091329,
0.0716875345,
-0.0737393349,
0.0093488786,
-0.0053973445,
0.0374741741,
-0.0470156483,
0.0304100513,
-0.0322472118,
0.0104288133,
-0.0052745622,
0.0872456729,
0.0058972356,
-0.0266234335,
-0.0373512208,
0.0479665101,
0.0030067102,
0.0224026963,
-0.0244140625,
0.0089731142,
-0.0130328489,
-0.0423183702,
-0.0767517388,
-0.0293324348,
-0.0097111017,
-0.024907127,
0.0021522411,
0.0043692542,
0.006418739,
-0.0014535208,
-0.0135781188,
0.0351833664,
-0.0050616781,
0.0126349786,
0.0116654085,
0.0240280684,
-0.0307681449,
-0.0223049633,
-0.0579391606,
0.0188582912,
0.0498100817,
-0.0468407348,
-0.0330110826,
-0.0494581833,
0.0217149183,
0.0015165914,
0.0355878249,
-0.0103458604,
-0.0434795059,
0.0329451747,
-0.05009038,
0.0811512172,
0.0460610278,
0.0188583918,
0.0318259597,
0.0284271725,
-0.0319200419,
0.0017416627,
-0.0085476646,
0.0020001812,
-0.0304244775,
-0.0037139615,
-0.0551177152,
-0.0319111422,
0.0856461599,
-0.0145959407,
0.0183440801,
-0.0757916495,
-0.0203383341,
-0.02479483,
-0.0171736535,
-0.0320814662,
-0.0044985525,
-0.0301446486,
0.0064422227,
-0.0499908403,
-0.064998813,
0.0208380241,
-0.0764161274,
-0.0060184821,
-0.023442829,
0.0196761154,
-0.007700514,
0.0334256515,
0.0555918589,
0.040312279,
-0.0077306274,
-0.0186255127,
-0.0402048454,
0.0157815032,
-0.0236238651,
-0.045586396,
0.0427388474,
-0.0328489505,
-0.0046606725,
-0.0227194224,
-0.0057633864,
0.0011230813,
-0.0507124513,
-0.0054239561,
0.0111146718,
0.0050259037,
-0.0241228901,
-0.0000911332,
0.0529009029,
-0.011435668,
0.0407414772,
0.0080751535,
0.0133376485,
-0.0031330998,
0.0270837974,
0.037651334,
-0.004496993,
-0.0373906828,
-0.0203743652,
0.0680525452,
0.019138705,
0.0609929003,
0.0251143128,
-0.0426230207,
0.0117559321,
0.0282681435,
0.0531791933,
-0.0645100102,
0.0285907816,
0.0435212031,
-0.04913266,
-0.0112523716,
0.090535149,
0.0324066617,
-0.0180220995,
-0.015485337,
-0.0083646569,
0.0633264482,
0.0123489928,
-0.0022324093,
-0.0826349631,
-0.0171653833,
-0.0026931567,
-0.0199647415,
0.023173105,
0.0159606673,
-0.0215171222,
-0.1050808951,
0.036199268,
0.0156072574,
-0.0418120846,
0.0067114946,
-0.0110711362,
-0.0142472489,
0.0218825974,
-0.0173750892,
-0.003955848,
0.0010531241,
0.010773872,
0.0406278707,
0.0289997607,
0.0004414915,
-0.0083461711,
-0.0544482768,
0.0196975805,
0.0350688584,
0.0154644772,
-0.0135541325,
-0.0505399033,
0.0156450197,
0.0075231548,
0.0155827366,
-0.0124365455,
0.0417881384,
-0.013028183,
-0.0502995476,
0.0014616442,
-0.0339939594,
-0.0101625836,
-0.0500255637,
-0.0580672696,
0.0443235636,
0.0110854972,
-0.0033137014,
-0.0233493075,
0.008343963,
-0.0037036745,
0.0226738416,
0.027548736,
-0.0391075723,
-0.0597742125,
-0.0048635434,
0.0261762664,
-0.0582965314,
-0.0318518244,
0.0134446435,
0.0036233037,
-0.0375006124,
-0.0455993675,
-0.0276744161,
0.0331018455,
0.058936514,
-0.0103171356,
-0.010848566,
-0.0613026731,
-0.0024265051,
-0.0409122296,
0.0153342551,
-0.0217641741,
0.029310355,
-0.0666411817,
-0.034420453,
0.0151122827,
-0.031516809,
-0.0158051867,
-0.0038930378,
-0.0819016993,
-0.0196793675,
0.0156907868,
0.0461974144,
0.013095499,
0.0115139624,
-0.0117477877,
-0.0778444409,
0.0746890083,
0.0621172003,
0.0294629838,
0.0615613274,
0.0050706756,
-0.0562862121,
-0.0004501633,
0.0310068615,
-0.0101808887,
0.0066657183,
-0.0016967391,
0.0211111512,
0.0210910179,
-0.0168203525,
0.0135586793,
-0.0203613453,
0.0607125573,
-0.0082125142,
0.025679877,
-0.0482807793,
0.0084168939,
-0.0380357727,
-0.0020257407,
-0.0446548127,
-0.0086844079,
0.0235554297,
0.0114127304,
-0.0060741324,
0.0171099063,
0.0019101255,
0.0505344309,
0.0145324133,
0.0015811133,
-0.0233150981,
-0.0111651989,
-0.0003316883,
0.0639366806,
-0.0162803493,
-0.004695442,
-0.0472878814,
0.0074251918,
-0.014069994,
0.0197473858,
-0.00827845,
-0.021152785,
-0.0188263655,
0.0338698886,
-0.0304487869,
-0.0299654678,
-0.0527385399,
0.0208606776,
0.0348118022,
-0.0027462204,
0.0290332716,
-0.036804188,
-0.0135741122,
-0.0230256859,
-0.0123356897,
0.0360649005,
-0.0428800993,
0.0681514367,
0.0314725563,
-0.0066579469,
-0.0452771671,
0.0635364577,
0.0382071473,
0.0096497871,
-0.0230320804,
0.0166270453,
-0.0050393655,
0.0027912548,
-0.0241992045,
0.0421303399,
-0.007962605,
-0.0060557751,
-0.0203844327,
-0.0739205107,
-0.021602748,
0.0263983514,
-0.0283293054,
-0.0071506826,
0.0120315654,
0.0303975362,
0.0044908691,
0.0029953106,
-0.0251887813,
0.0053850305,
-0.0021015152,
-0.0180156939,
0.0436210074,
-5.556941628e-33,
-0.0573516637,
0.0218605865,
-0.0052707456,
-0.0116712973,
-0.0011050121,
0.0388127342,
-0.0086363433,
0.0121917622,
0.0047664903,
0.0086017186,
-0.0070107798,
0.0224960689,
0.0209706593,
0.0480912328,
-0.0624905191,
0.0456184894,
0.0612580292,
-0.0290795192,
0.0171139464,
0.0059185568,
-0.0040076203,
0.0272795968,
0.0468541682,
-0.0112745604,
-0.0226477198,
-0.005353922,
-0.0220165923,
-0.0268575232,
0.0450500809,
0.0561636537,
-0.0595548339,
0.0476946346,
-0.0045200051,
-0.0268960893,
-0.0337930247,
0.0454089865,
-0.0626510754,
-0.0042153951,
0.0318731368,
0.0481517017,
-0.0777764544,
-0.0269511025,
-0.0032851987,
-0.023731729,
-0.0108211683,
-0.018633645,
0.014236833,
-0.0162471607,
-0.0404665247,
0.0528758653,
-0.0198193118,
0.0219072644,
0.0158929564,
-0.0072470633,
0.0185298845,
-0.0318920165,
0.0118049625,
0.0491130576,
-0.0355978683,
0.004393246,
0.0393499024,
0.0680414662,
0.0480028354,
0.0464580767,
0.0329138339,
0.0752579868,
0.0380907357,
-0.0114742648,
-0.0192699656,
0.0059302151,
0.033561945,
0.018861644,
0.0506098382,
0.0361477397,
0.0431915522,
-0.0138137685,
-0.0503976159,
0.009229322,
-0.0423335992,
0.0248197522,
0.0331808701,
0.0444092005,
0.0140393944,
-0.0084187519,
-0.0536883585,
-0.0357066989,
-0.0403399579,
-0.0288593434,
0.0447705947,
0.0093430942,
-0.0232324321,
0.0126360217,
0.0546131842,
-0.0328018069,
0.0020974264,
-0.0149120726,
-0.0245220121,
0.0720242262,
-0.0192668624,
0.0241800677,
-0.0365271606,
-0.0428331569,
0.0484710224,
0.029201569,
-0.0046736435,
0.0124627687,
0.0211170875,
0.0304172356,
-0.0910274684,
0.0069828201,
-0.0338993482,
-0.0358675271,
0.0002820292,
0.0235358272,
0.0325767845,
-0.0220151432,
-0.0236325171,
0.0520815887,
0.0129790334,
-0.0174564328,
-0.0024110416,
-0.0795543119,
-0.0331906378,
0.0054173162,
-0.0259532984,
0.0076165707,
-0.0405484699,
0.0074522127,
0.0448392108,
-0.0453850962,
-0.0307820365,
0.0406748205,
2.525e-7,
0.0402749032,
-0.0041132923,
0.0095337154,
-0.0031102276,
0.0245330259,
-0.0006205757,
-0.0112269614,
0.0412068255,
0.0085315648,
-0.0394134894,
-0.0111359181,
0.0102732871,
0.0388203487,
0.0160790924,
-0.056312684,
0.0521581657,
-0.054756768,
0.0210438278,
-0.051059112,
0.0192265883,
0.0458780751,
0.1235194802,
-0.0333357863,
-0.0349171236,
0.0259997435,
-0.0568343066,
0.0855522454,
-0.0458485894,
0.0150183681,
-0.0264466647,
-0.0169507321,
0.0245191567,
0.0027021272,
0.0071514649,
-0.0220910758,
-0.0032739991,
0.0541843586,
0.0373922214,
-0.025810916,
0.0137819825,
0.0197279118,
-0.0271657091,
-0.0439180583,
-0.0704267025,
0.073729977,
0.0364491269,
-0.0342009626,
-0.0268033314,
0.0346446261,
-0.0109227858,
0.0319545493,
-0.0782492384,
-0.0619193241,
0.0098614935,
0.02977282,
-0.0099907042,
-0.0320353657,
-0.0683427379,
-0.0656614676,
0.0088801971,
-0.016125042,
-0.0551016144,
-0.0757417604,
0.016610289,
0.0403894596,
-0.0204470456,
-0.0180315152,
2.455537904e-34,
0.0129226614,
-0.0164118987,
-0.0137070082,
0.027065061,
0.0046617123,
-0.0188642368,
0.026662048,
-0.0080177048,
-0.0089867143,
-0.1173727661,
-0.0278068855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00513v1 | Rule-Based Error Classification for Analyzing Differences in Frequent Errors | 2023-11-01T13:36:20 | 2023-11-01T13:36:20 | Atsushi Shirafuji, Taku Matsumoto, Md Faizul Ibne Amin, Yutaka Watanobe | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.PL | Finding and fixing errors is a time-consuming task not only for novice
programmers but also for expert programmers. Prior work has identified frequent
error patterns among various levels of programmers. However, the differences in
the tendencies between novices and experts have yet to be revealed. From the
knowledge of the frequent errors in each level of programmers, instructors will
be able to provide helpful advice for each level of learners. In this paper, we
propose a rule-based error classification tool to classify errors in code pairs
consisting of wrong and correct programs. We classify errors for 95,631 code
pairs and identify 3.47 errors on average, which are submitted by various
levels of programmers on an online judge system. The classified errors are used
to analyze the differences in frequent errors between novice and expert
programmers. The analyzed results show that, as for the same introductory
problems, errors made by novices are due to the lack of knowledge in
programming, and the mistakes are considered an essential part of the learning
process. On the other hand, errors made by experts are due to misunderstandings
caused by the carelessness of reading problems or the challenges of solving
problems differently than usual. The proposed tool can be used to create
error-labeled datasets and for further code-related educational research. | [
0.0395763442,
-0.004046157,
-0.0536506698,
0.0139456326,
0.0260587074,
0.0392543599,
0.0100410869,
0.0084275864,
0.0022801799,
-0.0263519492,
0.0528516136,
0.0078001223,
0.0347090289,
0.0070529534,
-0.0109847179,
-0.0367925055,
0.0300509967,
-0.0056545697,
0.0193141773,
0.0386095941,
0.0346463211,
0.0049056304,
-0.0428727828,
0.0644684136,
-0.0037479133,
-0.0365861282,
0.0042303638,
0.002479645,
-0.0191917717,
-0.0545491017,
0.046352908,
0.0306132026,
-0.0094416309,
0.0399550162,
0.0000020769,
-0.0420776419,
-0.0069408738,
-0.0152980657,
-0.0141790062,
0.0555050597,
-0.0354467854,
0.0490267463,
-0.0014047042,
0.0274568871,
0.0009525577,
-0.0647706836,
0.0277751163,
0.0061217905,
0.0634229481,
0.0300046932,
0.0291896313,
0.0057219621,
0.0226586908,
0.0358225182,
0.0544450358,
-0.0081216358,
0.030933883,
0.0724918172,
-0.0244838372,
-0.0155285243,
-0.0115591502,
-0.0414601304,
-0.0081396354,
-0.0093240542,
0.0263355337,
0.0113085713,
0.012965492,
-0.0298502482,
0.0199099965,
-0.0066230139,
-0.0157917235,
-0.0457223281,
-0.0020742416,
-0.0174438395,
0.0073284009,
0.0167324301,
0.0020608576,
0.0119696734,
-0.0609862283,
-0.0162054002,
0.002967221,
-0.0291149933,
-0.0335668139,
-0.0052477606,
0.0129000582,
-0.0102218492,
-0.0514673553,
-0.0522320792,
-0.0436350033,
0.0442366861,
0.0199882016,
-0.0291160215,
0.0277602244,
0.0003729686,
0.0095456885,
-0.0173778646,
0.0012405555,
-0.0161561184,
0.0286117923,
-0.0241054762,
-0.0016954399,
-0.0031064665,
0.0113839144,
0.023516966,
-0.0068754386,
0.0367913283,
0.0710634142,
0.0084923068,
0.0249591097,
0.044413548,
-0.0671974644,
-0.0117997332,
-0.0147443255,
0.0412350558,
0.058442127,
0.0724477023,
-0.0559692606,
0.0097160079,
-0.0475536026,
0.0638762861,
-0.0387087613,
-0.0248963963,
0.0215233322,
0.0210597254,
-0.0259680804,
-0.0596625954,
0.004575063,
0.0228399858,
-0.027489407,
-0.0415042453,
0.0228544082,
-0.0155901788,
-0.0260387249,
0.0423995517,
-0.0072542336,
0.0374676883,
0.0073731001,
0.0415046513,
-0.0263536647,
-0.0429391526,
0.0257661231,
0.054965388,
-0.0453133583,
-0.0863117501,
-0.0339686759,
0.0046859384,
0.0347369574,
-0.017268626,
-0.0045712828,
-0.0041873599,
0.0121437721,
0.0422427393,
-0.0717740133,
0.0289126392,
0.069007948,
0.0281039774,
-0.0395059213,
-0.0271720383,
-0.0116096418,
-0.0427056141,
0.003563778,
-0.0610143431,
0.0987322107,
-0.0657614768,
-0.0466921218,
-0.0377992131,
0.0267458409,
0.027406361,
0.0146078318,
0.0286682528,
0.0091844937,
0.0232591256,
-0.0528402552,
0.0637843832,
-0.045655407,
0.0152600706,
0.0295101628,
0.039541699,
0.0189114939,
0.0229128096,
0.0336414911,
-0.0547370277,
-0.017026905,
0.0178901963,
-0.0201083049,
-0.0375741273,
-0.0426591747,
0.0046125986,
0.0080026761,
-0.076674372,
-0.0266341586,
0.0266885515,
-0.0413486436,
-0.04587093,
0.0400984921,
-0.0082009118,
0.000060031,
-0.0023811415,
0.0009639712,
-0.0603344291,
-0.0357931182,
-0.0559467562,
0.0470818281,
0.0456081778,
-0.0049770023,
-0.0674196705,
-0.0038699913,
0.0018811335,
0.0324558727,
-0.0877394527,
0.0893823951,
-0.0118333865,
-0.0377415977,
-0.0521145277,
-0.0167863723,
0.0193455853,
0.0035875698,
0.013565558,
0.0160926506,
-0.0123321246,
0.0110135758,
0.0148159098,
-0.0807145312,
0.016120797,
0.0517766997,
-0.0082943626,
-0.0072893696,
0.0014163008,
-0.0255728159,
-0.0142965075,
-0.0144008659,
0.0071100732,
-0.007110747,
0.04989741,
-0.0342773385,
-0.0619203374,
-0.0024454854,
-0.0013628566,
0.0342211537,
-0.1037986726,
-0.0686485693,
-0.0240161829,
-0.0392865874,
-0.001872907,
0.0340938531,
-0.0408936515,
-0.0153307924,
0.0109016476,
0.0504727736,
-0.0327834226,
-0.0682877526,
-0.0160610192,
0.0113732759,
0.0547649153,
0.0476544201,
-0.0271728486,
-0.0048209787,
-0.0109847831,
-0.0053596743,
-0.0075744162,
-0.0387917049,
-0.0598573834,
0.0584367439,
0.0069476017,
0.0618771166,
-0.019220978,
-0.0195916109,
-0.004107404,
-0.0347601362,
0.0410252959,
0.0110245794,
-0.0052379128,
-0.0428523384,
-0.0155882183,
-0.0321249925,
0.0007519185,
0.0130637204,
-0.0486468747,
-0.0292195827,
0.0386773199,
-0.0182764307,
-0.0420668982,
-0.0355653465,
-0.0185311306,
-0.0594752878,
-0.0093298834,
0.0463495851,
-0.0205508433,
-0.0933503285,
0.0717260316,
0.0034165371,
-0.0247440524,
0.0120353298,
-0.0434456468,
-0.0328203477,
-0.0294316709,
-0.0055096331,
0.0168480724,
-0.0008201288,
0.0546391346,
0.0340998583,
-0.0266263206,
-0.0380006954,
0.0042895838,
0.0491365567,
-0.0317493007,
0.0493095331,
-0.0438505933,
0.0114481663,
-0.0112947468,
0.0251113903,
-0.0173661392,
-0.0071585844,
0.038977813,
-0.0156810321,
0.0515751839,
-0.0140791088,
-0.025564054,
0.0471096709,
0.0302705951,
-0.0220013838,
-0.0548770875,
0.0739798993,
0.0195240993,
0.0029806793,
-0.0269751363,
-0.0219866894,
-0.0299732946,
-0.0034007176,
0.0022909541,
0.0268518962,
-0.0042152605,
-0.0787553713,
-0.0009812722,
0.013060024,
0.0495895036,
-0.0295825303,
0.0432371907,
-0.0571372695,
-0.0408611298,
0.002337273,
-0.0111314943,
-0.0165070053,
0.0065680724,
0.001435978,
-0.0841300488,
0.03158243,
0.0134981107,
0.0108592538,
-0.0040750988,
0.0093451403,
-0.0093102977,
0.0405824073,
-0.0729410946,
0.0341184549,
-0.0427522548,
-0.0897404552,
-0.0104685901,
-0.0055292882,
-0.0533206798,
0.0208293274,
0.0293420795,
0.0123627838,
0.0417659804,
-0.0233779848,
-0.0131191732,
0.0397113711,
-0.0499891303,
-0.0418455116,
0.0288222618,
0.0215077512,
-0.0596083738,
-0.0069104568,
0.0337055288,
0.066905044,
-0.0303606931,
-0.0316971578,
-0.0265836101,
-0.0287005883,
0.0509806015,
0.0061802524,
-0.0701314807,
-0.0022069013,
0.006841172,
0.0621114038,
-0.0188979283,
0.0172457937,
0.0247429851,
-0.0401078053,
0.0036697574,
0.051169537,
-0.0438899137,
-0.0715585351,
-0.0174334906,
0.0000321046,
-0.011960865,
-0.0226253625,
0.0617785864,
-0.002430287,
0.0245406497,
0.0883955136,
-0.0997573286,
-0.033734519,
0.0234587491,
0.020636728,
0.073050797,
0.0072641373,
-0.0193572231,
-0.0307338368,
-0.0163980052,
0.031126352,
-0.0104709184,
0.0047427728,
-0.0322280452,
0.0410429239,
0.0015482614,
0.0101626217,
-0.0179859102,
-0.0303600226,
-0.0269644968,
-0.0120405033,
0.0713788196,
0.0359630063,
-0.0069010705,
-0.0127472961,
-0.0072936364,
-0.0280640665,
-0.0124984086,
-0.0251256973,
0.0425871499,
0.0326839872,
-0.0357501917,
-0.0747006387,
0.0005542376,
-0.0187205765,
0.0224047303,
-0.0164867472,
0.0012684769,
-0.0088522248,
0.0109097194,
0.000844359,
0.0360141657,
0.0240583662,
0.0124895228,
-0.0706698745,
0.0081806481,
0.0373863354,
-0.0416594818,
-0.0084537501,
0.0353005193,
0.0061641075,
-0.0714329258,
0.0092736622,
-0.031016035,
0.0295093078,
-0.0202738997,
-0.028647406,
0.0001114058,
-0.020649232,
0.0155997351,
0.0520764366,
0.0150752049,
-0.0686217621,
-0.0365656875,
-0.0385171026,
-0.0559687875,
0.0164011698,
0.0219603665,
0.0054814192,
0.0082854517,
-0.034580607,
0.0237551853,
-0.0495934002,
-0.0333283991,
-0.0176431071,
-0.0290615167,
-0.0282728411,
-0.0636754259,
0.0075612664,
0.017677404,
0.0399449207,
0.0340573303,
0.0558656156,
-0.0588839985,
-0.0061091324,
0.0227409862,
0.0143966852,
-0.0143806767,
0.0143843396,
0.0410823599,
0.0118628852,
0.0060860291,
0.021942785,
-0.0055191824,
-0.0197595637,
-0.0099818762,
0.023858441,
0.0653781891,
0.0504719727,
0.0829156116,
0.0188470092,
-0.0033788786,
-0.0292652734,
-0.0373972431,
0.0383116454,
0.0182276778,
0.0240050554,
0.0230521634,
-0.0079294108,
0.0472564287,
-0.0041541629,
-0.0239497386,
0.0083164722,
-0.0688555241,
0.0333393551,
0.0023714551,
0.0374423265,
0.0390419438,
0.0051812087,
-0.0004375454,
0.0160289127,
0.0059065577,
0.0597201101,
-0.0270825718,
-0.0110841068,
0.0079805152,
0.0383872502,
0.0091149239,
-0.0598583259,
0.0551473424,
-0.0146552604,
-0.0235154945,
-0.0595122948,
-0.0720532015,
-0.0002813837,
0.0730614811,
0.0651355162,
0.0038120204,
-0.0146623114,
-0.0548923798,
-0.02212446,
-0.038972877,
-0.0250915233,
0.0771585405,
0.0797578543,
0.030830618,
0.0137387812,
0.061603725,
0.0203579124,
0.0019535436,
0.0041783056,
-0.0210389178,
0.0086963233,
-0.0137219569,
-0.0173219517,
-4.647868664e-33,
-0.0420558006,
-0.0408821106,
-0.0289173927,
0.02476505,
0.0285362694,
0.0062433844,
0.0090884594,
0.0278418884,
0.0288749132,
-0.0028634488,
0.0555244945,
0.049304042,
-0.0120570762,
-0.0593813956,
0.102101028,
0.0257073995,
0.0417408496,
0.0660257638,
-0.0116926422,
-0.0114823049,
0.0025007066,
0.0016659924,
0.0258430839,
-0.0614471361,
0.0206554402,
0.0124815693,
0.0105600348,
0.0012477663,
0.0155826658,
0.0403789133,
0.049394127,
0.0265232585,
-0.0192313381,
0.0371211916,
-0.0373694263,
-0.0424662419,
-0.0254707988,
-0.0801116973,
-0.0284706466,
0.0109398505,
0.0351338089,
0.0005426523,
0.0432069451,
0.0420682728,
-0.0233361199,
-0.0008920389,
0.0549601838,
0.0215915795,
0.0447294042,
0.0100120902,
-0.0035142275,
0.0278952401,
-0.0659909993,
0.0043066111,
-0.0272973944,
0.0005432965,
0.0026217871,
-0.0675414875,
-0.0328631066,
0.01659685,
0.0214663371,
0.0118186455,
0.0185245778,
-0.0228962507,
-0.0512285829,
-0.0063103628,
0.0504025705,
0.012528047,
0.0110063478,
-0.014356575,
0.0003458173,
-0.0210955124,
0.0114242081,
0.0318519399,
0.0719889849,
-0.0325915515,
-0.0521312952,
0.0266228765,
-0.0013660403,
0.0136591932,
-0.0545341186,
-0.0032478736,
-0.1052781269,
-0.0125880558,
0.0067193354,
0.0283813924,
-0.0245961528,
-0.0297198035,
0.0286732279,
-0.011092809,
0.0278151315,
-0.0165253989,
-0.0537863187,
0.0222206786,
-0.0165061522,
-0.0580466986,
-0.0107430052,
0.0231174193,
-0.0551171191,
0.0138845639,
-0.0277560204,
-0.0539122373,
-0.0196478814,
-0.0108515294,
0.101726152,
0.0194099341,
0.0077864658,
0.0127232363,
-0.0728818625,
-0.0145291081,
0.0178105477,
-0.0615189672,
-0.0226726104,
0.0055595567,
-0.0016279746,
0.0130553143,
0.0250479039,
0.0009595074,
-0.0104081538,
-0.030572854,
-0.0727850199,
-0.0228809528,
-0.0316212066,
-0.0204746611,
0.0068886294,
-0.0432572365,
-0.0499434918,
-0.0018463655,
0.0051917215,
0.0025845391,
-0.033073511,
-0.0059324778,
2.655e-7,
0.0084244777,
0.0618710257,
0.0033122492,
0.0056121163,
-0.0217287708,
0.0100191981,
-0.0127399489,
-0.0009837648,
0.0335870087,
0.1070516258,
0.0150389662,
-0.0247110315,
0.0266786534,
0.0525910594,
0.0085907569,
-0.0419291854,
0.0134333204,
0.0183588527,
-0.0266482104,
0.0276935101,
0.138246268,
-0.0232183151,
0.0465064906,
0.0299174339,
-0.0030808952,
-0.0099530583,
-0.0048779217,
0.0065616737,
0.0452338383,
0.0354530625,
0.0176994596,
0.0038044029,
0.0411922187,
0.0792788416,
0.0202429164,
-0.0847669765,
0.0217111111,
-0.0213930048,
-0.013701004,
0.0833185166,
0.0371039473,
0.0127176447,
-0.0038634157,
-0.0441931523,
-0.0406731106,
-0.0081364224,
0.0198514368,
0.0651805326,
-0.0276645124,
-0.0313456878,
0.0197861828,
0.0166001096,
-0.029804904,
-0.010509246,
-0.0094191227,
-0.0063111125,
-0.0250540525,
-0.0017456454,
-0.0052817133,
0.0396459214,
0.0199801102,
-0.0589986145,
0.0240724627,
0.0277446248,
0.0275935624,
0.0187190771,
0.0324448422,
2.363829829e-34,
0.0222466663,
-0.0135594746,
0.0496000312,
-0.025233686,
0.0333906189,
0.029738307,
0.0145899775,
0.0072904336,
-0.0086132837,
0.0728587732,
0.0131631857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00508v1 | Robustness Tests for Automatic Machine Translation Metrics with Adversarial Attacks | 2023-11-01T13:14:23 | 2023-11-01T13:14:23 | Yichen Huang, Timothy Baldwin | cs.CL | cs.CL | We investigate MT evaluation metric performance on adversarially-synthesized
texts, to shed light on metric robustness. We experiment with word- and
character-level attacks on three popular machine translation metrics:
BERTScore, BLEURT, and COMET. Our human experiments validate that automatic
metrics tend to overpenalize adversarially-degraded translations. We also
identify inconsistencies in BERTScore ratings, where it judges the original
sentence and the adversarially-degraded one as similar, while judging the
degraded translation as notably worse than the original with respect to the
reference. We identify patterns of brittleness that motivate more robust metric
development. | [
0.0128115807,
0.0602680445,
-0.0302319583,
0.0309633315,
-0.0256978273,
0.0017944478,
0.0148388045,
0.0267084874,
-0.0264652446,
-0.0317626148,
-0.0130120087,
-0.033419475,
0.055545114,
-0.0139330402,
0.0654666498,
-0.0401406214,
0.0009386712,
0.0211440772,
-0.0222836733,
0.0097039929,
0.0021484413,
-0.0008843255,
0.0104506817,
0.0360493399,
0.0177057087,
0.0071638864,
0.0456438623,
0.0174495224,
0.0441292562,
0.0024338877,
-0.0059556565,
0.0439998694,
-0.0576161779,
0.091798,
0.0000017775,
-0.0251144301,
-0.0175536983,
0.022445811,
0.0267903972,
0.0365284048,
0.0461329035,
-0.0649458468,
-0.0246924218,
0.0139072612,
-0.0388921127,
-0.007610206,
0.0114635322,
0.0030627933,
0.0613373369,
0.1030663326,
-0.0138278073,
-0.0163501836,
0.0066408752,
-0.0257885512,
-0.0543039106,
-0.0559426099,
-0.0108547164,
0.0081212781,
-0.0690533668,
0.0252236445,
0.015185168,
0.018443305,
0.0145635512,
0.0018450477,
-0.0189622287,
-0.0023329286,
-0.0418566316,
-0.0123653915,
0.0288277995,
0.0524345897,
-0.0357780047,
-0.0086397845,
0.0010141159,
0.003421386,
0.0178534277,
-0.0168415532,
0.0204542223,
-0.0214286391,
0.0146171851,
-0.0163087677,
-0.0627157763,
0.0115789976,
0.0402070358,
-0.0163026247,
-0.005649698,
-0.0229929928,
0.0259366743,
-0.0163283963,
-0.0181166101,
-0.0004741515,
-0.061424382,
-0.0255263261,
0.0229385328,
-0.0139324479,
0.0089976536,
-0.0048181945,
-0.0891076401,
-0.0721019655,
0.0453999825,
-0.0764530972,
0.0388528891,
0.0287007205,
-0.0417558737,
0.0185059253,
-0.0446190946,
0.0975787789,
-0.0064684525,
0.025903143,
-0.0431325585,
0.0056517632,
-0.0083960295,
0.0249290634,
0.0217593219,
-0.0399018265,
0.0305844359,
0.0251675881,
-0.0480922349,
0.0282841492,
-0.0383503735,
0.0222558528,
-0.0305860899,
-0.0283317026,
-0.0499908924,
-0.0058843442,
-0.0010087674,
-0.0118717868,
-0.0411306284,
-0.0134690162,
-0.0316887759,
-0.0470133834,
-0.0210235547,
0.0278317761,
-0.0702985674,
-0.043410562,
-0.0219725277,
0.122822009,
-0.0012291515,
-0.0406500213,
0.0162744615,
-0.0275885034,
-0.0548038557,
-0.0430652089,
-0.003022203,
-0.0105479388,
0.0046050311,
0.0055717886,
-0.0349522308,
-0.0647053868,
-0.0031970327,
-0.0106604341,
-0.0130176833,
0.0603589267,
0.0453112349,
-0.0212865397,
0.0018679625,
0.0142181534,
-0.0376852639,
0.0502168424,
0.0241866633,
0.0499255024,
0.0555181541,
0.0166234951,
-0.0025705623,
0.0667487755,
0.0350950062,
0.0643755272,
-0.0344820395,
0.016507959,
-0.0088504469,
0.0295068435,
-0.0083241174,
0.0745054409,
-0.0103362389,
-0.0508278981,
0.1111316904,
-0.0124175791,
0.002428533,
0.0507538803,
-0.0153895952,
-0.0240304898,
-0.0024616602,
0.0548898503,
-0.0399951376,
0.0049844179,
-0.0600598231,
-0.0294384845,
0.0276627764,
0.0396411158,
0.0148435533,
-0.0385653004,
-0.0264601912,
-0.0051582749,
0.0165606886,
-0.0550980493,
0.0182617791,
0.0485673435,
-0.0124941142,
0.0114442743,
-0.028463861,
-0.0275809094,
0.0196112487,
-0.0510138571,
-0.0431582779,
-0.0019509095,
0.1061060876,
-0.0341920331,
0.0315621309,
-0.0097923866,
-0.0205152612,
0.0257003549,
0.0427318886,
-0.0026095959,
0.000236154,
-0.0132694421,
0.0123452274,
-0.0260456596,
0.0265991613,
0.0180233046,
0.0128405485,
0.0500678755,
0.0046568289,
-0.0761964843,
-0.0415868126,
0.0457357131,
0.0645823702,
-0.0372499898,
0.0156176342,
0.0305698682,
0.0352311395,
0.0104393847,
-0.0632681623,
0.0293518119,
0.0337368771,
-0.0037195785,
-0.0256263837,
0.0199256744,
0.0189599693,
-0.0127316378,
0.0166742355,
-0.0518704914,
-0.0307088196,
0.0373611487,
-0.0196156353,
0.0347866602,
0.0202613845,
-0.0633975491,
-0.0135895191,
-0.0101485243,
0.0343527198,
-0.0356593728,
0.0077900728,
-0.0475729443,
0.0418768004,
-0.0361685902,
0.0308792833,
-0.0400935262,
-0.0190228168,
0.0397482738,
0.0249741152,
-0.0429552495,
0.0340866521,
-0.0159733277,
0.0217861068,
0.0479403436,
-0.014500441,
0.0015870726,
-0.0753941536,
0.0118256398,
-0.0074592503,
-0.0320705585,
0.0348985121,
0.0619960055,
-0.0049769441,
0.0033922559,
0.0123786712,
-0.0072935871,
-0.0323023871,
-0.0188155528,
0.0270048808,
0.0301613268,
-0.0104556298,
0.0201920457,
-0.0005402392,
-0.0147100985,
-0.0021722561,
0.0880992487,
-0.0024805048,
0.0145552754,
-0.0467344075,
-0.0010738409,
-0.0247682016,
0.0002758874,
-0.01558105,
-0.0849909261,
0.0560483746,
0.0335008539,
0.0475288182,
0.0780232325,
0.0372957177,
0.0566307046,
0.04166051,
0.0394075066,
0.0062848777,
-0.0344516784,
-0.0175887272,
-0.0367299542,
-0.00019058,
-0.0748381242,
0.0258180778,
-0.0008504218,
0.0336619429,
-0.01609849,
-0.035699252,
0.0498795323,
-0.0334768184,
-0.0454208143,
0.0184323005,
0.0062454157,
-0.0151230516,
0.0026014557,
-0.01518468,
-0.0407693535,
0.0656784996,
-0.0456005856,
0.0108885225,
-0.0297314879,
0.011557187,
0.0246858522,
0.0395519696,
0.0038514691,
0.0021516145,
-0.0125906626,
0.0193300862,
-0.0504377745,
-0.0110391174,
0.0645698979,
-0.0272092484,
0.0068103564,
-0.0406972468,
-0.0184756778,
-0.0031103701,
-0.0081370603,
-0.0236495789,
-0.0121719865,
0.0463337712,
0.0161507763,
0.0302463844,
-0.029073054,
-0.0487859696,
-0.0320401639,
0.0328401513,
0.0108630853,
-0.0150160044,
0.0001600484,
-0.0030976329,
0.0416735522,
0.0040672761,
-0.0263735969,
0.0351600125,
-0.0501898974,
0.0003564446,
0.0491118617,
-0.0069789663,
0.0282228924,
-0.0134720234,
-0.0378284827,
0.0026183147,
0.0152043561,
0.0225189328,
0.018717831,
0.0540586151,
-0.0058019953,
-0.0154634155,
0.0336933248,
-0.0050027831,
0.0337082259,
0.0219042897,
0.0065171658,
0.0509808101,
0.0084370067,
-0.0281286724,
-0.0626222715,
0.0130396103,
0.0191777889,
0.0782959312,
-0.0113010788,
-0.0263299569,
-0.0038705729,
-0.0318142362,
-0.0254213121,
0.0147002125,
-0.0013066548,
-0.0178315639,
-0.0195322707,
-0.0025832932,
-0.0233838204,
0.0443564951,
-0.0176770315,
0.0600622594,
0.0110283131,
0.0010414504,
-0.0028350267,
-0.051901266,
-0.0020748179,
-0.0363559611,
0.0221203808,
0.0823412016,
0.0622236542,
-0.0212395713,
-0.0319897085,
0.024316065,
-0.0129659995,
-0.0357646942,
0.0224403329,
0.0506778471,
0.025434006,
-0.0281292647,
0.0079761576,
0.0152779659,
0.046456106,
0.0104442444,
-0.0216115434,
-0.0066834963,
0.0034971649,
-0.0202349182,
-0.0172324087,
-0.0061454335,
0.0079392185,
0.0681990981,
0.0164944697,
-0.0485809743,
-0.0282122474,
-0.0542348661,
0.0078179911,
-0.0687101483,
-0.0636697263,
0.0135835214,
-0.046343971,
-0.0499858446,
-0.1226799488,
-0.0556427874,
-0.0503488146,
0.0382716879,
0.0063731722,
-0.0305944774,
-0.0335878916,
-0.0119061442,
-0.0178532936,
0.0111610675,
0.0090455189,
0.0353578813,
-0.0299740508,
0.0126067214,
-0.0315817185,
-0.0032392668,
-0.0167107414,
0.0274680499,
-0.0438201129,
-0.0727555305,
0.0157948621,
0.0511263162,
0.0207505748,
-0.0146353301,
-0.058299873,
-0.0378947072,
0.049192626,
0.0325678177,
-0.0172600336,
0.0243433211,
0.0581664406,
-0.0317992419,
0.0060610743,
0.0432718284,
-0.028124854,
-0.0243883859,
0.0396969281,
0.0066740504,
0.0112432819,
-0.033839263,
0.0069903373,
0.0285822786,
0.0631792843,
-0.0274317563,
-0.0011484354,
0.0234251674,
-0.0175282508,
-0.0096695377,
-0.0173696727,
-0.0068498333,
0.0046518701,
0.0428181626,
0.02869929,
-0.0205624923,
0.0701904893,
-0.0315040946,
0.0101848412,
-0.0014934101,
0.0079489583,
-0.0003105876,
0.0844505951,
0.0103322743,
0.0251929555,
-0.0193118304,
0.0224067364,
-0.0245968774,
0.011285645,
-0.0197593849,
0.0102249468,
0.0264617298,
0.020964928,
0.0361578688,
0.0599676445,
-0.0400595441,
0.0252612066,
-0.0412434824,
-0.0014971313,
0.0118007399,
0.0213255938,
0.073142916,
-0.0098102484,
-0.0197226349,
-0.0344724804,
-0.0110606579,
0.0072289156,
0.0033386131,
-0.0035139795,
-0.0274292119,
0.0010343455,
0.0841855928,
0.0569455735,
-0.0261817351,
0.0229395386,
-0.0128379269,
-0.0314462893,
-0.0196735952,
-0.036610689,
-0.0241552182,
-0.0629793331,
-0.0069872942,
-0.0533533357,
-0.0322844721,
-0.0687654912,
0.0086704446,
0.0505208448,
0.0378310829,
0.0056308387,
-0.0264366381,
0.0792383254,
-0.0217010025,
0.0532460213,
-0.0576786809,
0.036974296,
0.0118976049,
-0.0312143341,
0.0014563944,
-6.007622489e-33,
0.0047898358,
-0.0369620584,
-0.0527458377,
-0.0543301292,
0.0067708879,
0.0029743565,
-0.0334786139,
-0.0074498905,
-0.0406115912,
0.0035777891,
0.0144019071,
-0.007095777,
-0.0226377007,
-0.0367214717,
-0.0387844071,
-0.0255796965,
0.0316203386,
0.0064651747,
-0.0807547048,
-0.0139528038,
0.0351530388,
-0.0249745324,
0.0406941958,
-0.0825325251,
0.0917845815,
0.0058435695,
-0.0569620058,
-0.0138617586,
0.0130683901,
0.0294303931,
0.0057994099,
0.0274088606,
0.0120079294,
0.0190108251,
-0.0222558957,
-0.0032552704,
-0.0314438269,
0.0114843855,
0.0114766555,
0.0318304151,
-0.0252510719,
-0.0186465066,
0.0343986452,
-0.0237245541,
-0.0547338314,
-0.0158352107,
0.0133753344,
-0.0244813766,
-0.0408533402,
-0.0370767601,
-0.0180583298,
0.0117204105,
-0.042018611,
-0.0115209296,
-0.0179640464,
0.0239233766,
0.032165505,
0.0122621898,
-0.0557327941,
0.0013978578,
-0.0291253086,
0.0336025693,
0.024094712,
-0.0280056037,
0.0140430434,
0.0479667857,
0.0356737077,
0.0381401218,
0.017932551,
-0.0367746428,
0.0463891588,
-0.0264404602,
0.1162274852,
0.096542798,
0.0111749899,
-0.0222456139,
-0.0551701672,
0.0321394615,
-0.0003094692,
0.0211818255,
0.0122996168,
0.0251703337,
-0.0552449785,
0.0275044944,
-0.0222790912,
-0.0994964764,
-0.0410926901,
-0.0211848635,
-0.019303605,
-0.0146893533,
-0.0302470624,
-0.0177024752,
0.0066385046,
-0.0035043284,
0.0422929972,
-0.0112556005,
-0.0598124117,
-0.0069586341,
-0.0018173739,
0.0416900627,
0.0316538662,
0.0198542587,
0.0268120356,
0.0274654012,
0.0497596301,
-0.0192826372,
0.0599193238,
0.0074573308,
-0.0346006416,
0.0152784223,
-0.0117622511,
0.019352043,
0.0201267228,
-0.0110319741,
0.0199793037,
-0.0196882728,
-0.0148475422,
0.0026184286,
0.0337941796,
0.0297651105,
-0.0415320992,
0.0492790788,
0.0054136999,
0.0352269039,
-0.0371574126,
-0.022175787,
-0.0048357542,
0.0470224246,
0.0411249883,
-0.0975173116,
-0.0063625937,
-0.0419306457,
2.608e-7,
0.0333421007,
0.079540275,
0.0111773899,
-0.0115845306,
0.0268027335,
0.0503069386,
-0.0487503298,
0.0746677741,
-0.0302986316,
0.0115927029,
-0.0182986762,
-0.0377223045,
0.0554870404,
0.0563416742,
-0.0156431943,
0.0028691108,
-0.0975081027,
0.0304000378,
-0.0382664278,
0.0005533798,
0.0503846556,
0.0384110287,
0.0272956546,
0.0239694305,
-0.0014334125,
-0.0858392045,
0.0302606095,
0.015247969,
-0.0059821871,
-0.0110738371,
0.088675417,
0.0297998376,
0.0090556629,
-0.001782854,
-0.0393674634,
-0.0056855441,
0.0513476022,
0.027502995,
0.0458542034,
-0.0379052162,
-0.0102307601,
-0.0662429109,
-0.0050970409,
-0.0294118989,
0.0555668697,
0.0168672707,
-0.0164374448,
0.0178049747,
-0.0366164558,
-0.0101058558,
0.0891919285,
-0.0227743667,
-0.0662707463,
0.0195258651,
0.0299929734,
0.037425112,
0.0201006643,
-0.0381973535,
-0.0289147422,
-0.0208179429,
-0.0182772223,
-0.0470469184,
0.0007989238,
0.0470979623,
0.0039636423,
-0.0315218121,
-0.0050079748,
2.348803246e-34,
0.0393332727,
-0.0498594716,
0.0139598548,
-0.0554934926,
0.0486589484,
-0.0272460375,
0.0357876904,
-0.0160479378,
0.0050503104,
-0.0497674458,
-0.0349806286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00502v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00502v2 | Efficient LLM Inference on CPUs | 2023-11-01T13:08:50 | 2023-12-07T12:16:42 | Haihao Shen, Hanwen Chang, Bo Dong, Yu Luo, Hengyu Meng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance and
tremendous potential across a wide range of tasks. However, deploying these
models has been challenging due to the astronomical amount of model parameters,
which requires a demand for large memory capacity and high memory bandwidth. In
this paper, we propose an effective approach that can make the deployment of
LLMs more efficiently. We support an automatic INT4 weight-only quantization
flow and design a special LLM runtime with highly-optimized kernels to
accelerate the LLM inference on CPUs. We demonstrate the general applicability
of our approach on popular LLMs including Llama2, Llama, GPT-NeoX, and showcase
the extreme inference efficiency on CPUs. The code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/intel/intel-extension-for-transformers. | [
-0.0213756803,
0.0850114301,
-0.0100954762,
0.0737534389,
-0.0296819061,
0.0054991716,
-0.0027808596,
0.0139939953,
0.024928255,
-0.0221254416,
-0.0047930176,
-0.0222314317,
-0.0101996455,
-0.0124556944,
0.021877585,
-0.0104060424,
0.0358044244,
-0.0427759811,
-0.0284997225,
-0.0420895331,
-0.0179211665,
0.022089107,
0.0225550923,
-0.0013520245,
0.0134842396,
-0.0075224265,
-0.0002330504,
0.0271275844,
0.0107014878,
-0.0004637336,
-0.018904971,
0.0228055622,
0.0181072336,
0.0383986458,
0.0000020687,
-0.0077739959,
0.0011954447,
0.0237637162,
-0.0265754424,
0.0423656069,
0.0379025191,
-0.006480549,
-0.0293022618,
0.009434389,
0.0040364121,
0.0055728909,
0.0759903938,
-0.0157105904,
0.0238679703,
0.039506495,
-0.0003118343,
-0.0223285723,
0.0155282421,
-0.0238490961,
-0.0280545484,
-0.0269555394,
0.0142690288,
-0.0144185545,
-0.0035648581,
0.0045700446,
-0.0115912994,
0.0199051443,
0.0221614949,
0.015515944,
-0.0735174119,
0.0389805064,
-0.0575971566,
-0.007374329,
-0.0315069556,
0.0345732942,
-0.0751634762,
-0.0399913788,
0.0149872173,
0.0181618407,
-0.0546416007,
-0.044768177,
-0.0375008136,
0.0516901128,
-0.0053264406,
0.0084218448,
0.0467360839,
-0.0270070098,
0.0509306192,
-0.0053209197,
-0.0329258293,
0.109008722,
0.0770141855,
0.0271728393,
-0.0401578732,
0.0000198615,
-0.0692762062,
-0.0579262674,
-0.0055738497,
0.0057142875,
-0.0032981613,
0.0157543551,
-0.0585733838,
0.008477632,
0.0141924936,
-0.0440352149,
0.0238452163,
0.0849879086,
-0.018557461,
-0.0019246483,
-0.0342668481,
0.028836906,
-0.0695505664,
0.0070674424,
-0.0392374992,
0.003806303,
0.0231953803,
0.007219716,
-0.0313517675,
0.0302970223,
-0.0290811714,
0.0003608985,
-0.0618801638,
0.0250123292,
-0.0020613202,
-0.0267337821,
0.0192933008,
-0.0145373261,
-0.0257861353,
-0.000612558,
-0.0009667965,
0.032496728,
-0.0217624456,
0.0044535189,
-0.0514163002,
-0.1135823354,
-0.0207542293,
0.0407185145,
-0.0217378028,
-0.0453958437,
0.0520539246,
0.0571800321,
0.0121295694,
-0.0527842827,
-0.0133183096,
-0.0011868394,
0.023532493,
-0.0883470476,
0.0059311674,
-0.0947078019,
0.0089617064,
0.0092686806,
0.0126914065,
-0.0117627773,
0.0167997628,
0.0250480771,
-0.0076837931,
0.0508561879,
0.0120549779,
-0.0223830156,
-0.0071233884,
0.0017597337,
0.0365219265,
0.0840008855,
0.0228363257,
0.0219164677,
-0.0037072299,
0.0144593008,
0.0022855741,
0.0643506795,
-0.0006621919,
0.0174178965,
-0.0332776643,
-0.0042621931,
-0.0093853772,
0.01076183,
0.0631957427,
0.0828671977,
-0.0183232352,
-0.0206432287,
0.0216797292,
0.0676845014,
-0.000622104,
0.0128335757,
0.0236548837,
0.010991605,
0.006198029,
-0.0208441839,
-0.0596992485,
0.0375849307,
-0.0033620482,
0.0126943644,
0.0478229225,
0.0763220042,
-0.0183149092,
-0.0031007577,
-0.0173503198,
-0.0147161186,
-0.0268064048,
0.0292945523,
0.0386971869,
-0.0050527607,
-0.011368284,
0.1102399379,
0.04146754,
-0.0559988245,
-0.0518278889,
-0.0875259042,
0.0264907405,
0.0333342366,
0.0346289277,
0.0039776927,
-0.0066135344,
0.0477523468,
-0.0151642431,
0.0356940031,
-0.0013867648,
0.0216391422,
0.0288312361,
-0.037104845,
0.0041753529,
0.0174445007,
0.0209733639,
0.030762706,
0.050061129,
0.0042622606,
0.0104685947,
-0.0432909429,
-0.0196094383,
0.0068892175,
0.0230434258,
-0.0395641476,
0.0062577073,
-0.0094309421,
0.030787725,
-0.0131257074,
-0.0235160049,
-0.0098555265,
0.0506210327,
-0.0378333218,
0.0100750383,
-0.0211316794,
-0.0067417421,
-0.0102001354,
0.0556569546,
-0.0196793023,
0.019340802,
0.0159075949,
-0.0623362847,
-0.0429882966,
0.0824216157,
-0.0278107319,
0.0458031707,
-0.034965571,
0.0288523082,
-0.0007527747,
0.0626969337,
-0.0261006933,
0.0378535576,
-0.0177427568,
0.0081813578,
0.0339453369,
0.0147399278,
0.0032746531,
-0.0043566949,
-0.0541286767,
0.0052804649,
0.0164673682,
0.0327403694,
-0.0408417545,
-0.0027307521,
0.041560661,
-0.0182456765,
-0.1010330021,
0.0436684005,
-0.0556484498,
0.0543380976,
0.0295020193,
0.0511059053,
0.0102805039,
-0.0117216799,
-0.001257633,
0.0010903256,
-0.0034715943,
0.0111152623,
-0.0183695368,
-0.0409904085,
-0.0598633699,
-0.0202540066,
-0.052248165,
-0.012255609,
0.0399837308,
-0.0379150659,
-0.0232919864,
-0.048757147,
-0.0135802208,
-0.0138647128,
0.0704958364,
-0.0258633513,
-0.0361314043,
-0.001679458,
-0.0418479703,
0.0486402735,
0.0557440072,
-0.0233579259,
0.0015076147,
0.0412693024,
0.011194028,
-0.0277987774,
0.0205120575,
0.0023163541,
-0.0655039698,
-0.0202526022,
-0.0460362397,
-0.0415087231,
0.1008244231,
-0.0277145039,
-0.0418854281,
-0.0048379707,
-0.0491957366,
0.0013957114,
0.0159022566,
0.0124423569,
0.0130407596,
-0.0201425273,
0.0280028936,
0.0029002933,
-0.0639625266,
0.0428691171,
-0.0652888268,
-0.0121039152,
-0.0180961713,
-0.0269981306,
-0.0459154919,
0.0468711741,
0.0487543643,
0.0273845624,
-0.0137768062,
0.0056904182,
-0.0045603998,
0.0338352062,
-0.0058181616,
-0.0390763804,
0.0838687122,
-0.0421197563,
0.0398557335,
-0.0394264795,
-0.007400183,
0.006428794,
0.0418884866,
-0.0610275492,
0.0010461414,
0.023624938,
-0.0576679334,
0.0261738785,
0.0466004871,
-0.0027030553,
0.0636460036,
-0.0113087799,
0.0109141013,
-0.026277218,
0.0061177695,
0.0387128256,
-0.0057730079,
0.0104044219,
-0.0165151842,
-0.0234742314,
0.0276405625,
0.0245816931,
0.0333968438,
-0.0781356916,
-0.0083076162,
0.0680318773,
-0.018146351,
-0.0285103712,
0.0471828505,
0.0225363895,
-0.0508936197,
0.0065047722,
0.0763208121,
0.0282960068,
-0.0374077484,
0.0151875354,
0.0096228449,
0.0546617471,
0.0415019505,
0.0440775678,
-0.1056943312,
-0.0460539423,
0.0310426503,
-0.0011902306,
-0.0047424356,
0.0136707202,
-0.0182545576,
-0.0691176355,
0.0313136876,
0.0052269218,
0.0107054375,
-0.0212145876,
-0.040890839,
-0.0083772587,
-0.0146856569,
0.0086926641,
0.0087752193,
-0.0070605194,
0.0036787335,
-0.0198931769,
-0.0057492331,
0.0037516472,
0.0357269309,
0.0055526746,
0.0189407859,
0.0432810523,
0.0228839293,
-0.0248904955,
-0.0322257653,
0.0344223455,
-0.0214153882,
-0.0259589534,
-0.027096929,
0.0335196257,
0.0219639856,
-0.028414607,
-0.0020847889,
-0.0030550391,
-0.0266447309,
0.009683908,
-0.0245621428,
0.0652263761,
-0.0185683519,
-0.0221684538,
0.0023718581,
-0.0512640812,
-0.0253504477,
0.0320042707,
0.0113936644,
0.0157117918,
-0.04778428,
-0.0665709823,
-0.0328426957,
-0.0096235685,
-0.0465002693,
-0.0168377142,
-0.014982759,
-0.0666594207,
0.0148806693,
0.0621711612,
0.0105180861,
0.0088528069,
0.0040050144,
-0.0319362991,
0.0263223015,
-0.0333324037,
-0.1169200912,
0.0369652994,
-0.0551740192,
0.0665189549,
-0.0562840588,
0.0025084622,
0.0473502316,
0.0000265229,
-0.0176228788,
0.0578068905,
-0.1304902732,
-0.085149996,
-0.009184747,
0.0465936922,
0.0289822035,
0.0460042469,
-0.0227094404,
-0.0096886279,
0.0335475393,
0.0237920545,
-0.0133813387,
0.0402878895,
0.026692383,
-0.0347196646,
0.0154458862,
0.0247556232,
-0.0153451106,
0.0479533784,
-0.001510403,
0.01152902,
-0.0244076997,
-0.0813072994,
-0.0194915757,
0.0326234102,
0.0294730254,
-0.0058716089,
0.0038754831,
0.0206439011,
0.0411118269,
-0.0049157841,
-0.0104094986,
-0.0388395153,
-0.0000837984,
0.0226686355,
0.0086232778,
-0.018722944,
0.0000605657,
0.0442368165,
0.0216333643,
0.0124197248,
-0.00578081,
-0.0284465104,
0.0177835263,
0.0546755902,
-0.0178460553,
0.0008436276,
0.0051846169,
0.0111897467,
0.0772291198,
-0.0356931724,
0.0070921392,
-0.0195911713,
-0.0027443992,
-0.0322470628,
0.0180560946,
-0.0277104415,
-0.0578829795,
-0.0550640821,
0.0331902131,
0.0494345427,
0.030421339,
0.0657161847,
-0.018057717,
-0.0053424863,
-0.0118183298,
0.036191348,
-0.0134026855,
-0.0394406393,
0.0680045336,
0.0296804216,
-0.0175007209,
-0.0087324176,
0.0491014868,
0.0083624562,
0.0297665801,
0.0043982742,
-0.0036973339,
-0.0316000581,
-0.059955772,
-0.0584661551,
-0.0069765835,
-0.0055606104,
-0.0150843263,
-0.0129046021,
-0.0536285192,
0.0079057971,
0.0103942696,
-0.0071273833,
-0.058424741,
0.0048381924,
0.0504927821,
0.0384045467,
-0.0649853945,
-0.0255636759,
-0.0114781661,
0.0101040201,
0.0031546229,
-0.0085777305,
-6.380204239e-33,
-0.0279573593,
-0.006341381,
0.0178369619,
0.0251135342,
-0.0160589498,
-0.003305187,
-0.0323061459,
-0.0201902762,
-0.0164397415,
-0.0238023959,
0.0093265343,
0.0257848687,
0.0325450934,
0.0000117228,
-0.0255897976,
0.0158304796,
0.0529271699,
0.0207908563,
-0.0158239882,
0.0240410045,
-0.0054558362,
0.0020904164,
0.053705465,
0.0141273895,
-0.0448612906,
-0.0231240075,
0.0333254859,
0.0034727559,
-0.0248865224,
0.0219612494,
-0.0462200977,
0.0321632586,
-0.0059177591,
-0.0319999084,
0.0004669857,
-0.0099328309,
-0.0470096804,
-0.0086582992,
0.0328101404,
0.0488667525,
0.0077926265,
-0.0563555025,
0.0102525093,
0.0486588068,
-0.011168262,
-0.0293649696,
-0.0145775201,
0.0104553141,
-0.0155968498,
-0.02705664,
-0.0346885845,
0.0314172171,
0.0508474223,
0.0399794132,
0.0580212735,
-0.0348082259,
-0.0243413541,
0.0115737393,
-0.0190341379,
-0.0142570771,
0.0140623739,
0.0945417657,
0.092289947,
0.0292039476,
-0.0024562217,
0.0122430818,
0.0084778741,
-0.0357099138,
-0.0254407842,
0.0316192769,
0.0290971231,
0.0313419886,
0.0098204268,
0.0159621201,
0.0529923402,
0.0048603429,
-0.0529669672,
-0.0176348742,
0.049426049,
0.0332164988,
0.0143981334,
0.0192494839,
-0.0106721455,
-0.0380296782,
-0.0182547159,
-0.0036056344,
-0.0544971339,
-0.0095989117,
-0.0115163401,
-0.0051735919,
-0.0331661627,
-0.0129120722,
0.0269826762,
-0.0397943594,
0.0026338478,
-0.0038708339,
-0.0052983072,
0.0168041736,
0.0197736416,
0.0497022793,
0.0082531683,
-0.049673222,
-0.0121465866,
-0.0126391081,
0.0453265421,
-0.0121154962,
0.0087758014,
0.0561100841,
-0.0655807033,
-0.0026859003,
-0.0538597889,
-0.0172604248,
-0.016416721,
0.0730415136,
0.0117888441,
0.0197883416,
0.0240719635,
-0.0124275759,
0.0033899299,
0.0128697176,
-0.0292634349,
0.0182752311,
0.0218482837,
0.0384477377,
-0.0518504642,
0.0062147998,
-0.0564859807,
0.0226271357,
0.0201583672,
-0.0870594308,
-0.0546063781,
0.0501529835,
2.843e-7,
0.0344350152,
0.0212157983,
0.026499344,
0.0635829642,
-0.0017228146,
-0.0021521039,
0.0132858101,
0.0180531275,
0.0256742407,
-0.0103017902,
-0.0011376826,
0.0299322959,
0.0425086245,
0.0225710478,
-0.0439135656,
0.0269851442,
-0.0190848745,
-0.0008935618,
-0.0483011492,
-0.0570408776,
-0.0009525841,
0.1286118627,
-0.0180822089,
-0.0183829721,
0.0400173366,
-0.0298406146,
0.0242251419,
0.015238585,
-0.0014443233,
0.0193876699,
0.0188955925,
0.0350564905,
-0.0229694322,
0.0004194653,
-0.0047864821,
-0.001265707,
-0.0469803736,
0.0939178392,
-0.0112260543,
-0.0088724922,
0.0139162755,
-0.0534386747,
-0.019499654,
-0.0200330187,
0.0630696341,
0.0003715293,
-0.0050696498,
-0.1092965975,
-0.0253632199,
-0.0129212728,
-0.0358316079,
0.0022847774,
0.0521354116,
0.0434026755,
0.0349993445,
-0.059354987,
-0.0167949591,
-0.0644461811,
-0.0979927257,
0.003290724,
-0.0561031364,
-0.0669943318,
-0.0565709248,
-0.0261401851,
-0.0036247435,
-0.0462572277,
-0.0034897262,
3.037472122e-34,
0.0500501208,
-0.0074451701,
0.0056041204,
0.071636349,
0.0115335109,
-0.0243436713,
-0.0364686958,
0.0128717292,
-0.0401753522,
-0.0797389448,
-0.0365553796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00488v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00488v1 | Comparing Optimization Targets for Contrast-Consistent Search | 2023-11-01T12:42:14 | 2023-11-01T12:42:14 | Hugo Fry, Seamus Fallows, Ian Fan, Jamie Wright, Nandi Schoots | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We investigate the optimization target of Contrast-Consistent Search (CCS),
which aims to recover the internal representations of truth of a large language
model. We present a new loss function that we call the Midpoint-Displacement
(MD) loss function. We demonstrate that for a certain hyper-parameter value
this MD loss function leads to a prober with very similar weights to CCS. We
further show that this hyper-parameter is not optimal and that with a better
hyper-parameter the MD loss function attains a higher test accuracy than CCS. | [
0.0253242347,
0.0606962703,
-0.0079587586,
0.048748523,
-0.0616622604,
-0.0151407775,
-0.0210553836,
0.057649754,
-0.0661857128,
-0.0197652783,
0.0039645368,
-0.0545413196,
0.0277883224,
-0.0168513879,
0.0246227086,
0.0035711632,
0.0657356381,
0.006308536,
0.0076033394,
-0.0105021279,
-0.0246065743,
-0.0320771858,
0.02187787,
0.0172725506,
-0.0192100815,
-0.0138350846,
-0.0172863267,
-0.0006893615,
0.0340915397,
-0.0145822018,
0.022878984,
0.037153881,
0.0052454839,
0.0711950734,
0.0000022545,
-0.023291491,
-0.04637428,
-0.0147301108,
-0.0240513254,
0.0252586231,
0.055028189,
-0.0475646071,
-0.0039590141,
0.0425793715,
0.0072528217,
0.0046143779,
0.0582756661,
0.00776958,
0.023758417,
0.100666374,
0.0258822609,
-0.0459877625,
-0.0026196679,
-0.0251863673,
-0.0063074944,
-0.0494982153,
0.0295496341,
-0.0001841163,
-0.0067222598,
0.026702581,
0.0027683312,
0.0667219535,
0.0109242266,
0.0153003223,
-0.040617723,
-0.0061670593,
-0.030049134,
0.0189354997,
0.0300950091,
0.0071228482,
-0.046308931,
-0.0471783392,
0.0121693742,
-0.0109092398,
-0.0250129029,
-0.0057576103,
0.0003015546,
0.0190308243,
-0.0143396407,
0.0291211922,
0.0591566078,
-0.0124757709,
0.018390866,
-0.0140214823,
-0.0759686679,
0.0082426965,
0.0302643273,
-0.0273202341,
-0.0387557298,
-0.0145174656,
-0.0532846265,
-0.012239716,
0.0020273146,
-0.0050160764,
-0.0469315425,
-0.0006218731,
-0.0160508361,
-0.0657375157,
0.0148397628,
-0.0101982951,
0.0620836616,
0.0482346453,
-0.0359984003,
0.0141817322,
-0.0210792106,
0.0926053524,
-0.048357565,
0.0282857604,
-0.0591876209,
-0.0417171903,
0.035544958,
-0.0227784235,
-0.0275409799,
0.0091177514,
-0.04766801,
-0.034015283,
-0.0009802666,
-0.0184886809,
0.009265054,
0.0039114822,
-0.0377305336,
-0.0125749288,
-0.0413954556,
0.0158947483,
0.0060334736,
0.0503010303,
-0.0075807772,
-0.0004935031,
0.0025952889,
-0.0334528536,
-0.0362854227,
0.0388948284,
-0.0099050486,
-0.0437702872,
0.0255238079,
0.0648098513,
-0.0058303834,
-0.0633068383,
-0.0375071764,
-0.0117732054,
-0.0318277515,
-0.0544278361,
0.0104324548,
-0.0455419123,
-0.0089330906,
-0.01279529,
-0.0295773167,
-0.0352625251,
0.0080243926,
0.013163601,
0.0200717747,
0.0665306076,
0.0087924143,
-0.0203742832,
0.0035668449,
-0.0185692348,
-0.0051310235,
0.0831552744,
-0.0315864123,
0.0096869413,
0.0063800621,
0.0081749512,
-0.0179485828,
0.0282279793,
0.037049897,
-0.0149779832,
-0.0421098806,
0.0068532554,
0.0201782826,
0.0494320542,
0.0473987162,
0.0848283246,
-0.0441761762,
-0.0563607961,
0.0077677467,
0.0393010452,
0.090580605,
-0.0139850089,
0.007134465,
-0.0057161278,
-0.0190361198,
0.0402874388,
-0.0089843655,
-0.0172558632,
-0.0630377382,
0.0266882647,
0.0611867271,
-0.0156917516,
-0.0190701298,
-0.0229054056,
-0.0406125672,
0.0188813806,
-0.009918116,
-0.0115664871,
0.0429176874,
-0.01828954,
-0.0600711517,
0.0421793312,
0.0253245328,
0.0081950435,
-0.0152854333,
-0.0922338814,
0.0240201391,
-0.0118553583,
0.0432342589,
-0.0419019833,
0.0350925848,
0.0327086523,
-0.0221094675,
0.0452819243,
0.0144878672,
0.0316093862,
0.0101801511,
-0.0427741669,
-0.0185266957,
-0.0194254555,
0.0317805223,
0.0088845296,
0.0065498594,
0.0292141438,
0.0278327409,
-0.0466038249,
-0.0107520819,
0.0363843068,
0.0121636353,
-0.0164362285,
-0.0167076141,
0.0249904376,
0.0026829806,
0.0289733578,
-0.0484939814,
0.0245202594,
0.0135856448,
-0.0374260694,
0.0171278846,
-0.0523616932,
-0.029725574,
-0.0824020281,
0.0325431563,
-0.1026767567,
-0.0216881018,
0.0957347229,
0.0039425786,
-0.0248871036,
0.039512556,
-0.0741902515,
0.0474853553,
-0.0295512415,
0.0225156415,
-0.0278124176,
0.0130391559,
-0.0404057503,
0.0842225179,
-0.0292741563,
0.0488011241,
0.0005207807,
0.041941531,
0.0261105597,
-0.0872586742,
-0.0137801776,
-0.0090993671,
-0.0157209504,
0.0234469697,
0.0211508106,
0.018225072,
0.0201004036,
-0.0299401376,
0.004264513,
0.0058686687,
-0.0311328135,
-0.0156703256,
0.0474141687,
-0.000990733,
0.0310668424,
0.0049619698,
0.0020194249,
0.0084925182,
0.0166328382,
0.0127437674,
0.0456919223,
0.0533875413,
-0.0125213945,
-0.0635562316,
-0.0549282916,
-0.011227062,
0.0658463836,
-0.0321299806,
0.0116637573,
-0.0812398419,
0.0816288218,
0.0145496931,
0.0435109772,
-0.0045515937,
-0.059798032,
0.0093080448,
-0.0487801954,
-0.0550221503,
0.0957213342,
0.0393990129,
0.027532436,
0.0101055522,
-0.0121241035,
-0.0499517284,
-0.0130463503,
-0.0245802477,
-0.0201139487,
0.0096277576,
-0.0655238852,
0.0265436489,
0.1115173921,
0.0240360312,
-0.012884384,
-0.0508460365,
-0.0140706236,
0.0237261672,
-0.0133324172,
0.0075009866,
0.0225404445,
-0.0258148108,
0.0499869846,
-0.0264950227,
-0.0298532508,
0.0457490794,
-0.0454313867,
0.0486213043,
-0.0607816316,
-0.0212056376,
-0.0292259995,
0.003707703,
-0.0287669785,
0.0102996388,
0.0158490445,
-0.0410524048,
-0.032269448,
-0.0021028565,
0.0764318183,
-0.0358785354,
0.0658599287,
-0.0108814714,
0.0246396959,
0.0019037102,
-0.036500778,
-0.0254570879,
-0.0083079254,
-0.0374951735,
0.009266655,
0.0824501514,
0.0016627277,
-0.0505034961,
0.0399639644,
0.001013238,
0.06354554,
0.0083527891,
0.0083216093,
-0.0642338023,
0.016960714,
0.0392994359,
-0.0061598611,
0.0633837581,
-0.0387912877,
0.0131487558,
0.0454899147,
-0.0097276792,
0.0323933847,
-0.0260064993,
-0.0165994857,
0.0187230259,
0.0285436828,
-0.0506307594,
-0.018325733,
0.0125482846,
-0.0460486524,
-0.0332446918,
0.0597026944,
0.0062567652,
-0.0490506813,
-0.0083835339,
-0.035901241,
0.0100617995,
0.014062088,
0.0165499542,
-0.0813743025,
-0.0523792207,
0.0045358492,
0.046324566,
-0.0269903317,
0.0094325151,
-0.0012402182,
-0.1074184552,
-0.0078075062,
-0.0021344242,
0.0141839199,
-0.0754567385,
-0.0342831314,
0.0130048217,
-0.0293203332,
0.0710118189,
0.0374653526,
0.0132144419,
-0.0287550539,
-0.0071612848,
0.0465304814,
-0.0395842008,
0.0074119158,
-0.0504286774,
0.0355921127,
0.0649160296,
0.0189044476,
-0.0078947535,
-0.0173238982,
0.030250961,
-0.0402777605,
0.0160588808,
-0.0153247286,
0.0225055907,
0.0001419862,
-0.0172278732,
-0.0056420551,
0.0007912242,
0.0052074562,
0.0039655599,
-0.022539163,
0.0276573673,
0.0189851262,
-0.0032627233,
-0.0096646072,
0.0090413801,
-0.0067217876,
0.0629052147,
0.0206632204,
-0.0200085472,
-0.0101570506,
-0.0233634021,
0.0470131785,
-0.0160578713,
-0.029641768,
0.0233662799,
-0.0057921475,
0.0678035989,
-0.0310580432,
0.0024086181,
-0.0230654553,
0.0587993823,
-0.039199613,
-0.0284161251,
-0.054177586,
-0.0356218666,
-0.046891626,
0.0317720249,
-0.0177470259,
0.0181016624,
-0.0556575321,
0.028712675,
-0.0045504794,
-0.0402484052,
-0.0150460014,
0.0218753777,
-0.0405826382,
-0.070670031,
-0.010745571,
0.0119215026,
0.0258496199,
0.0599564128,
-0.0168672819,
-0.0236889068,
0.0090505788,
-0.0315403156,
-0.0022642778,
0.0344605669,
0.0309820268,
-0.0650058016,
-0.0220059101,
0.0293579157,
-0.0255161282,
-0.0198454577,
0.0030929544,
0.0647468343,
0.0161605105,
-0.0541046895,
0.077329576,
0.0131651107,
0.0784090906,
0.0328000076,
-0.0033069809,
-0.0019267614,
0.0213982482,
-0.0219227318,
-0.012433351,
-0.008682088,
0.0280194152,
0.0066803056,
-0.0021488536,
-0.0144263143,
-0.0051928703,
0.002449865,
0.0244431272,
-0.0312936194,
0.024049338,
-0.0005332054,
0.0169662517,
0.048583515,
-0.0032596858,
0.0047390778,
0.0492255501,
-0.0062071648,
0.0870110691,
0.0053036092,
0.0330828018,
0.0586067513,
-0.0139715895,
-0.0192708205,
-0.0102908034,
-0.0855401531,
-0.0316402093,
-0.040999718,
-0.0368057378,
0.0413595103,
0.0017929688,
-0.0072193453,
-0.020957021,
-0.03766305,
-0.0037805415,
0.0252277553,
0.0003197976,
0.0185613483,
-0.0096703097,
0.0370746963,
0.0171714909,
0.0074859988,
0.0312593803,
-0.0108093545,
0.0714658052,
-0.0586344898,
-0.00306313,
-0.0324300639,
0.0415893793,
-0.0140344286,
0.052363012,
-0.0247750487,
0.0155812968,
-0.0478943586,
-0.0806809142,
0.0291476436,
0.0483748503,
-0.0098997923,
0.0111427391,
0.037363857,
0.0382384025,
0.0435273424,
-0.0282165036,
0.0184123535,
0.0047492133,
-0.0090353768,
-0.0160061605,
-0.0018172383,
-7.232057077e-33,
-0.0196899772,
0.0092514278,
-0.0205543973,
-0.0870086104,
-0.0104699321,
0.0431441888,
-0.0149349691,
0.0066414541,
-0.0576158427,
0.0129688513,
0.004679977,
0.0475512445,
0.0177808143,
0.0073956172,
-0.023934219,
0.009567189,
0.0363406166,
-0.0046916185,
-0.025573859,
-0.0606949516,
0.0147921219,
0.018393442,
0.0551641062,
-0.0001732063,
-0.0807208121,
0.0323620252,
-0.0085960738,
0.0887912884,
-0.0255311988,
0.072634764,
0.0034205441,
0.0040644277,
-0.0133634843,
-0.0226818286,
-0.0023485105,
-0.0475445352,
-0.0423758626,
-0.0137590962,
0.0290144999,
0.0121927643,
-0.0620036013,
-0.0323279984,
0.0169812646,
-0.0505394526,
-0.011358384,
-0.0054699802,
-0.0059848651,
-0.0006178411,
0.0009154715,
0.0239438675,
-0.0287959166,
0.0423158221,
-0.0027538822,
-0.0105502419,
0.0170511343,
0.001504003,
0.018952528,
0.0046252366,
-0.0526390709,
-0.002797798,
0.0484580919,
0.0663443878,
0.0153519707,
0.06139981,
0.0100669889,
0.0594795309,
0.0576707236,
-0.0125363553,
0.0403987728,
-0.0729938075,
0.0387945138,
-0.0134173203,
0.0347263478,
0.0581393652,
0.0359105766,
-0.0068525299,
-0.0268932208,
-0.0265493616,
0.0020803285,
0.0328847915,
0.0367768221,
0.0436470322,
-0.0664916933,
-0.0204366632,
-0.046182055,
-0.0649842769,
-0.0620180182,
-0.0086987223,
0.0329902545,
0.037562836,
-0.044331342,
-0.0426203385,
0.0436701253,
-0.0413197912,
0.048872117,
0.0114946458,
-0.0444315076,
-0.0131171364,
-0.0220107734,
0.0473025665,
-0.0493128859,
-0.0322490521,
-0.0106395781,
0.0116150267,
0.0214740802,
-0.0139904711,
-0.0364278071,
-0.0032934188,
-0.0405887477,
-0.0150822978,
-0.027377503,
-0.013493197,
-0.0205620285,
-0.0627056807,
0.0491669178,
-0.0126586417,
0.0174893569,
0.0367441177,
0.060622029,
-0.0071470132,
-0.0601917617,
0.0455462635,
0.0081271026,
0.0212871749,
-0.0247830059,
0.0184483286,
-0.0402239412,
0.0501627959,
0.0118705751,
-0.041609887,
-0.0167454481,
0.0347400457,
2.912e-7,
0.0397502407,
0.0038078746,
0.0398108698,
0.0783232823,
-0.0290588494,
0.0174575504,
0.0289537888,
-0.0188600346,
-0.0169437509,
-0.0418077111,
-0.0208411291,
0.0057578022,
0.025567282,
0.0011188621,
-0.0397050381,
0.0667268261,
-0.0175463557,
-0.0396842398,
-0.0042935563,
-0.0255169496,
0.0302039478,
0.0936303213,
-0.0148928417,
-0.0037261024,
-0.0079592224,
-0.0047644814,
0.0349260755,
0.0323482305,
0.0368223973,
-0.0042023631,
0.0024006558,
-0.0103789074,
0.0022345288,
0.0155745819,
0.0246319138,
0.0761564448,
0.007733264,
0.0081396149,
0.0195864961,
-0.088405259,
0.003185835,
-0.012068823,
-0.0440183915,
-0.0517994538,
0.0513322167,
-0.0347797908,
-0.0044875853,
-0.0645026416,
0.0020593319,
-0.0135425348,
0.0021852832,
-0.0240224544,
-0.0281251762,
0.0121949287,
-0.002192836,
0.0343602896,
-0.0167740621,
-0.0601498932,
-0.0061745732,
0.0795635954,
-0.0425967462,
-0.0329476632,
-0.0245871563,
0.0036158045,
0.0433167368,
-0.0357044488,
-0.0005176399,
2.746445205e-34,
0.0250011757,
-0.0293934532,
-0.0062783989,
0.0049525425,
0.0480832197,
0.0065474934,
-0.0460188873,
0.024685815,
0.0424972437,
-0.0723564476,
-0.0260016173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00475v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00475v1 | Style Locality for Controllable Generation with kNN Language Models | 2023-11-01T12:21:53 | 2023-11-01T12:21:53 | Gilles Nawezi, Lucie Flek, Charles Welch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent language models have been improved by the addition of external memory.
Nearest neighbor language models retrieve similar contexts to assist in word
prediction. The addition of locality levels allows a model to learn how to
weight neighbors based on their relative location to the current text in source
documents, and have been shown to further improve model performance. Nearest
neighbor models have been explored for controllable generation but have not
examined the use of locality levels. We present a novel approach for this
purpose and evaluate it using automatic and human evaluation on politeness,
formality, supportiveness, and toxicity textual data. We find that our model is
successfully able to control style and provides a better fluency-style
trade-off than previous work. | [
0.0573485345,
0.0627069622,
-0.0172835309,
0.0122174025,
-0.040128842,
-0.0135735422,
0.042049028,
0.0310990158,
0.020823868,
-0.0282942969,
-0.0491601788,
-0.0289988443,
-0.0161276944,
0.0059342156,
0.0632897988,
-0.0446432531,
-0.007804079,
0.006524608,
0.032999564,
-0.0316054113,
0.0578160509,
0.0299780034,
0.0348624438,
0.0514151566,
-0.0085050762,
-0.0075040194,
0.008084815,
0.0432143509,
-0.0161407162,
0.0049839257,
0.0581500307,
0.0672900602,
-0.0022096178,
-0.0242417455,
0.0000018877,
-0.0065893424,
0.0197736472,
-0.029490605,
0.0707995668,
-0.0098842978,
0.1000819877,
-0.032330703,
-0.0128222974,
0.0285541136,
-0.0146310916,
-0.0203730445,
0.0632313639,
0.0405040681,
0.0816465318,
0.059777692,
-0.0203591455,
-0.0159225482,
-0.0346481726,
-0.0122879306,
0.0288781337,
0.0035053859,
0.0259570386,
-0.0081709428,
-0.0168722682,
-0.011518118,
0.0056108157,
0.0493833236,
-0.0358408168,
-0.0509111322,
0.019495571,
0.0033296731,
-0.0181502607,
-0.0012625572,
0.0021850341,
0.0539690331,
-0.0116269877,
-0.0518234298,
0.0396012366,
0.0118457088,
-0.006718968,
0.0351234488,
-0.0293066036,
0.0081685232,
-0.0058690379,
-0.0040357718,
-0.0108334394,
0.0155629367,
-0.0018974352,
0.0346477889,
0.0274986774,
0.0220586229,
0.0105978828,
-0.0598103255,
-0.0395007245,
0.0106986612,
0.0095528653,
-0.0576419234,
0.0429386236,
0.0303290002,
0.0002152672,
0.0189809557,
-0.0579369813,
-0.0132783586,
0.0564386733,
-0.0933687091,
0.041448161,
-0.0030049386,
0.0005481896,
0.0048597171,
-0.0276792664,
0.0193448868,
0.0154790413,
0.0025485749,
-0.0122297676,
0.0349878892,
-0.0318049639,
-0.0254954156,
-0.0374896787,
-0.0290804803,
-0.0169429835,
-0.0139958942,
-0.0116119375,
0.0209429916,
-0.0204410888,
0.0065254504,
0.0190959256,
0.0303591397,
-0.0410451628,
0.0072045936,
0.049405966,
-0.0252607334,
-0.0448634699,
-0.0102717122,
0.0218031667,
-0.0018130135,
-0.0075149331,
0.0302454382,
0.0331139117,
0.0045609842,
-0.0139936991,
0.0471232757,
-0.007510927,
0.0226227082,
-0.0316284262,
-0.0390046164,
-0.0485313013,
-0.0157838613,
-0.0288089942,
-0.0490343012,
-0.0018529721,
-0.0258119069,
-0.0402882211,
-0.062980257,
-0.0006740972,
0.0265980419,
-0.0519791842,
0.0061072516,
-0.0102652889,
0.0079061752,
0.050937064,
0.0066838101,
0.0121333264,
0.0214553829,
0.0287848301,
0.0346683338,
0.0342926122,
0.0015730225,
-0.0105450163,
0.0308613311,
0.0353905261,
0.0189685356,
-0.0870589688,
-0.0595354661,
-0.0007823248,
0.040631257,
0.0552893206,
0.0641000643,
-0.0171571877,
0.0196147263,
0.0754594281,
-0.033801537,
0.0472935438,
0.0192106161,
0.0740535334,
0.0700557753,
-0.0421262011,
0.0157422274,
-0.0306032095,
0.002278208,
-0.0544175133,
0.0357214063,
0.0510514788,
0.0239044856,
-0.0309819672,
-0.0150743546,
-0.0047428696,
0.0055197049,
-0.0124129131,
-0.0349935293,
0.0022947546,
0.0470905043,
-0.0388788655,
-0.0128930733,
0.0365679003,
-0.0629263371,
0.006702567,
-0.0003023394,
0.0393286087,
0.1077377722,
0.0328435153,
0.0061447923,
-0.0218637232,
-0.0068568815,
0.0067687123,
0.043603126,
0.0144470865,
-0.0209409092,
-0.000451888,
-0.0738972351,
0.0127660055,
0.0012376953,
-0.0061346996,
0.000638345,
0.0002736237,
0.0388789661,
0.0299776606,
-0.0334119052,
-0.0259638298,
0.0406057686,
0.0117205288,
-0.0220661666,
0.0115490872,
0.0221159998,
0.0060394965,
-0.0069122305,
-0.0403154492,
-0.001212896,
-0.0156085556,
-0.0465650111,
0.0000881016,
0.0156691708,
-0.0788384825,
-0.0864662081,
-0.0149063068,
0.024438573,
0.0189367663,
-0.0417384543,
-0.0228837337,
-0.0514089614,
0.0310454834,
-0.0330402255,
0.0239530429,
-0.0602154471,
-0.0194110908,
-0.0169013292,
-0.0051329825,
-0.0501063429,
0.0464223959,
-0.0203933325,
0.020249309,
0.0136677008,
0.0343249291,
-0.0219390262,
-0.0140950736,
-0.0544597246,
-0.048689276,
-0.0012252157,
0.0018877914,
0.0358996652,
0.0595046133,
-0.0035443236,
-0.0846231654,
-0.062838845,
-0.0084700109,
-0.0247372687,
-0.0131977145,
0.0280353408,
-0.0030317947,
-0.024145456,
0.000969774,
-0.0788401961,
0.0096343933,
0.0154537568,
-0.0035126358,
0.0252946299,
0.0176464971,
-0.0268728677,
-0.0502338707,
-0.0148109533,
0.0128695574,
0.0103018228,
0.0049970387,
-0.0360442661,
-0.0601259843,
0.0700569078,
-0.0572764948,
0.0048540439,
0.0169291738,
-0.0757867321,
-0.0117434151,
-0.0300125834,
0.0461905748,
0.0406338498,
0.0451628529,
0.0005510376,
0.0563327521,
0.0058529964,
-0.0578950495,
-0.0173130278,
-0.0143863987,
-0.0086404141,
0.0077273087,
-0.0425875746,
-0.0029917189,
0.0558440052,
0.048430182,
0.0068515572,
-0.0632149279,
0.0516770557,
0.0241724141,
-0.0404809751,
-0.001978887,
-0.0169584174,
-0.0116253467,
-0.0034637824,
-0.0251449198,
-0.061873015,
0.0751716718,
-0.0098519204,
0.0128832776,
0.0293441396,
-0.0185602456,
0.0133843692,
0.0160506908,
-0.0100645656,
0.062132258,
-0.0085228244,
-0.0439385474,
-0.0293903537,
-0.0128668789,
0.0561678819,
0.008070915,
-0.0107385498,
-0.0365979113,
-0.0121105565,
0.0637951046,
-0.0227073561,
-0.0299019739,
-0.0225447845,
0.0256571714,
-0.0349658728,
0.0251883622,
0.008469657,
0.0407510661,
0.0357831754,
-0.0198501591,
0.0474508144,
-0.0260072853,
-0.00266773,
-0.0002389005,
0.0190734677,
0.0401693471,
-0.0303410981,
-0.0154783074,
-0.0109538846,
0.0154046761,
0.0394090116,
-0.0066584819,
0.0129214553,
0.0096870689,
0.0241639446,
0.0255465414,
-0.0049219872,
-0.0575671643,
0.0300069116,
0.0383948013,
-0.030974118,
-0.0675360411,
0.1305900812,
0.0320620276,
-0.0575363003,
-0.0015235735,
-0.0192173216,
0.0778003335,
0.0134613309,
0.0509937182,
-0.0305328146,
0.007982132,
0.0023839597,
0.0494199097,
-0.0394042619,
-0.0302348398,
0.0121697448,
-0.0555889681,
0.0279870965,
0.0363161229,
-0.082859531,
-0.007863014,
0.0066769361,
-0.0210422575,
0.033692874,
-0.0188622065,
0.0186420567,
-0.0029976896,
-0.0153130172,
0.0021268527,
-0.0353978947,
-0.0467771515,
-0.0062878099,
-0.0232401285,
0.068647787,
0.0422909781,
0.0442663617,
0.0209712591,
-0.0411878228,
-0.0215558559,
0.0031868909,
0.0454914831,
-0.0296521764,
0.0189214014,
-0.0089624487,
-0.0246886667,
-0.0465767607,
0.036514692,
-0.0120126503,
0.0305441599,
-0.0004827481,
0.0079568317,
-0.0237918068,
-0.0634940565,
-0.0244951081,
0.0501003265,
0.0861605033,
0.0506540202,
0.0582670718,
-0.05767693,
-0.0367544778,
-0.0215910487,
0.0127578592,
-0.0232332069,
-0.0084652221,
-0.0388670303,
-0.035339199,
-0.0167196859,
-0.1467042863,
-0.0070948512,
0.0110357162,
0.0595768057,
0.0162325259,
-0.0300267711,
-0.0118440725,
-0.0101363566,
-0.027504446,
-0.0508012474,
-0.0028434969,
-0.0188278835,
-0.0137402872,
-0.0451614372,
0.0394778661,
-0.0235105213,
-0.0066201817,
0.0150778638,
-0.0043476657,
-0.0685053393,
0.0236985106,
0.0993800089,
0.0100717684,
0.0363851115,
-0.0078169955,
-0.0884963721,
0.0553323515,
0.0563373864,
-0.0387719907,
0.0324517339,
0.0345539041,
-0.0067974795,
0.0198042896,
0.0460929051,
-0.0528288297,
0.0662525818,
-0.003617611,
0.0210504178,
0.0161161292,
-0.0374730527,
-0.0139266048,
0.0021010858,
-0.0253839567,
-0.036312554,
-0.0025790294,
-0.0366333053,
-0.0103161586,
-0.0186918452,
-0.0267577618,
-0.0617676452,
0.015926918,
-0.0083458442,
0.01442964,
-0.0267402735,
-0.0295428205,
-0.0233995374,
0.0253138151,
-0.0224126801,
0.0034710795,
0.0153552135,
0.0655540302,
0.0267530233,
0.0422938131,
-0.0547207594,
0.0309237093,
-0.0089280307,
0.0041721137,
-0.0311086848,
0.062088307,
0.0305478089,
0.0188138876,
-0.00092625,
0.0498980358,
-0.0489872992,
-0.0109846331,
-0.0576989576,
-0.0276670381,
0.0401207842,
-0.0210113954,
0.0677998364,
-0.0373439267,
0.0186915193,
-0.0039551114,
0.0568441264,
0.0353769362,
-0.1052639931,
-0.0076031783,
0.0087421332,
-0.0193820912,
0.0103467861,
0.0931564644,
0.0083808862,
0.0139484601,
-0.008278124,
-0.0050492347,
-0.0257048886,
0.0003704885,
0.044009164,
0.0397376567,
0.0105091557,
-0.0133206006,
-0.0394804031,
-0.0660308078,
0.0441453122,
0.0003493451,
-0.008376901,
-0.0142922662,
0.0596502721,
0.0377064943,
-0.0074502481,
0.0315323882,
-0.0610277057,
0.0472813807,
0.0023809117,
-0.0133024715,
-0.0260901563,
-5.832740153e-33,
-0.048948437,
-0.0363595113,
-0.0283278991,
0.0300699174,
-0.0137321753,
-0.030997688,
-0.061601188,
0.00915151,
0.0274998322,
0.0421477109,
-0.0156268422,
0.0016557709,
-0.0076616211,
0.0087911868,
0.0294144042,
0.0153097771,
0.0383513123,
0.0010266963,
-0.0125617702,
0.0791673809,
0.0416513309,
0.0341395102,
0.0550067946,
-0.0809666589,
0.0384298563,
-0.0142142968,
-0.0290654656,
-0.0193649419,
0.0291138422,
0.0038830696,
0.0028174252,
0.0680571198,
-0.0016316432,
0.0120386723,
-0.0392326489,
-0.0094064921,
0.0002905814,
-0.0375944488,
-0.0100052962,
-0.0458017848,
0.0220899172,
-0.048386395,
0.0605270043,
-0.0290648863,
-0.0127195492,
0.0394556709,
0.0410907976,
-0.0010045409,
-0.0515252426,
-0.0708489865,
-0.0551818646,
0.0126299569,
-0.0202235002,
-0.0248340424,
-0.0299333893,
0.0017546838,
-0.0093973661,
-0.0348569043,
-0.0302223004,
0.0304887705,
-0.0052517443,
0.021128932,
0.0040242663,
0.0020258145,
0.0429665074,
0.0777786374,
-0.0095141549,
0.0608230755,
-0.0151118953,
0.0001896693,
0.0646775216,
0.024352286,
0.0166754052,
0.0672875196,
-0.025993539,
-0.0713223144,
-0.0088107409,
0.0122276861,
0.0326719992,
0.0218108948,
0.0133840665,
-0.0102604907,
-0.0285169948,
-0.068645142,
-0.0059368261,
-0.0668220893,
-0.014134692,
-0.0406469926,
0.0322133452,
0.0088740205,
-0.0328716449,
-0.0559678935,
-0.0116025694,
-0.0203867219,
0.0075925407,
0.0365357026,
-0.0445160754,
0.0220752582,
-0.0059551625,
0.0036556285,
-0.0564048514,
-0.0188734233,
-0.0063745966,
-0.0007084653,
-0.0052941488,
0.0486796424,
0.0485165678,
0.0214945637,
-0.071665816,
0.003229592,
-0.0208025333,
0.0269985422,
-0.0037134611,
-0.0417147428,
0.0107107926,
-0.0279139616,
-0.0022714739,
0.0434191413,
0.0155247273,
-0.005310961,
0.0024683524,
-0.0111837583,
0.0222208444,
0.0215916894,
-0.0691674575,
-0.0098221237,
-0.0367883518,
-0.0193019509,
0.0247506201,
-0.0407633036,
0.0052979658,
-0.0263538379,
2.67e-7,
0.0013046646,
0.0516086556,
0.0013158113,
-0.0072693671,
0.0285157915,
0.0023534393,
0.0341039747,
0.0421534404,
0.0062471041,
-0.0013796497,
0.0226024408,
-0.0247288272,
0.0268200245,
0.0000450997,
-0.1385415047,
0.0450066142,
-0.0771277547,
0.0290900674,
-0.0065377327,
-0.0202127453,
0.027714774,
0.0401111059,
-0.0125132333,
0.0026564505,
0.0342354625,
-0.0503164865,
0.0548037738,
-0.0252164397,
0.0257198401,
0.0212498885,
0.0584809631,
-0.0515793264,
-0.0089345742,
-0.0044191079,
-0.0140401246,
-0.0203750785,
0.0112146586,
0.0947591662,
0.0139203472,
-0.0093806982,
0.0248411987,
-0.0058218818,
0.0046796505,
-0.0706513077,
0.0503202789,
0.0052436031,
0.0049446123,
-0.0225317124,
0.0002553918,
-0.027124241,
-0.0290761534,
-0.032594543,
-0.03451664,
0.0488842204,
0.0145093501,
0.0008790163,
0.0307144262,
-0.0764101148,
-0.0526186861,
-0.0126888147,
0.0002678238,
-0.0180413667,
-0.0199597739,
0.0268790703,
-0.0090415915,
-0.0096019609,
0.017457705,
2.338170533e-34,
0.018723391,
-0.0120458668,
0.0374839827,
0.0092457365,
0.0117242215,
0.0307931006,
0.0423543528,
0.0400624983,
0.0360847004,
-0.0764405802,
-0.0162489545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00451v1 | Discourse Relations Classification and Cross-Framework Discourse Relation Classification Through the Lens of Cognitive Dimensions: An Empirical Investigation | 2023-11-01T11:38:19 | 2023-11-01T11:38:19 | Yingxue Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing discourse formalisms use different taxonomies of discourse
relations, which require expert knowledge to understand, posing a challenge for
annotation and automatic classification. We show that discourse relations can
be effectively captured by some simple cognitively inspired dimensions proposed
by Sanders et al.(2018). Our experiments on cross-framework discourse relation
classification (PDTB & RST) demonstrate that it is possible to transfer
knowledge of discourse relations for one framework to another framework by
means of these dimensions, in spite of differences in discourse segmentation of
the two frameworks. This manifests the effectiveness of these dimensions in
characterizing discourse relations across frameworks. Ablation studies reveal
that different dimensions influence different types of discourse relations. The
patterns can be explained by the role of dimensions in characterizing and
distinguishing different relations. We also report our experimental results on
automatic prediction of these dimensions. | [
0.0068153492,
0.0058425535,
-0.0110866372,
0.0442319848,
-0.0266118627,
0.014819257,
0.0157400928,
0.014929588,
-0.0238390397,
-0.0817125887,
-0.0230318233,
-0.0161846746,
0.0280482601,
-0.0032588057,
-0.0439900868,
-0.0757405087,
0.0266065709,
-0.0082964739,
0.007090589,
0.0079240846,
-0.0072515691,
0.0117297899,
-0.0492628962,
0.0035200943,
-0.0383811221,
-0.0238320064,
0.0164788943,
-0.0415137745,
0.029313067,
-0.046058245,
0.0368777588,
0.0647575334,
0.019456856,
0.0400890112,
0.0000017236,
-0.0583909899,
-0.006511407,
0.0047673448,
0.0195433088,
0.0159643646,
0.0072143995,
-0.003193608,
0.04726661,
-0.008147452,
-0.021054158,
-0.0888295472,
-0.0052980548,
0.1157225743,
0.0451200679,
0.0259257667,
-0.0088598402,
-0.0611819513,
0.0294250529,
0.0293606147,
-0.0657023638,
-0.0413046069,
0.0090172915,
0.0488674641,
-0.0184727013,
0.050192792,
0.0149107371,
-0.0325070992,
-0.01729686,
0.004963588,
0.0220992491,
0.0219939724,
-0.0303762723,
0.0025548548,
0.0120248161,
0.0219203718,
0.1347014904,
-0.0226485487,
0.0081161093,
0.0143839223,
-0.0069590197,
0.0491411015,
-0.0266374797,
-0.0221731924,
-0.0433380455,
0.0254775565,
0.0252016578,
0.0452234149,
0.0035080595,
0.0101606511,
0.0402199067,
0.05145723,
-0.0303766131,
0.0053185634,
-0.0162871629,
-0.0246910118,
0.0148019977,
-0.040716745,
-0.0364648513,
0.0106515801,
0.0032145677,
-0.0127293626,
0.0059227352,
0.0053386674,
0.0499243587,
-0.0873903111,
0.0479551293,
-0.0054241889,
-0.0206273105,
0.0257858988,
-0.0417781956,
0.0533139072,
-0.0374241062,
-0.0803714097,
0.0108209886,
-0.0112003479,
-0.1031569839,
-0.0265815761,
-0.0123026669,
0.0823025778,
-0.0299290307,
-0.0198063739,
-0.0552420169,
-0.0341489874,
-0.0273882318,
-0.0190216638,
-0.0239350758,
0.0078209946,
0.0006936262,
0.0326578394,
-0.0596731231,
0.0035706107,
-0.0675753802,
0.0409244373,
-0.0774914995,
0.0194828939,
0.0284434836,
0.0445617288,
-0.0168532692,
-0.0046337335,
-0.0321342573,
0.072886169,
-0.013243489,
0.0304167401,
-0.0019805268,
-0.0448732413,
-0.0131289242,
-0.0027051149,
0.0234230049,
-0.0678398684,
-0.0226380192,
0.0124479244,
0.0086696129,
-0.0390511714,
0.0404728539,
-0.0266987607,
-0.0478930101,
0.0362783,
0.0088595115,
-0.0129506029,
0.1084602773,
0.0148199191,
0.0184510127,
0.0352540575,
0.0117621133,
-0.0486529209,
0.0321241952,
-0.0021682652,
0.000185886,
-0.0351479203,
-0.030065082,
-0.0202513225,
-0.007694154,
-0.004645044,
0.0187337976,
0.0044998419,
0.0084214564,
0.0339509211,
-0.0335080698,
-0.0404323041,
-0.0179400574,
0.0734652653,
-0.0218649562,
0.0282394197,
0.0471605808,
-0.0063311704,
0.010274048,
0.0734727532,
0.0348470472,
-0.0304627456,
0.0046874299,
-0.0497117378,
0.0393787734,
-0.0244548079,
-0.0205738861,
-0.069611311,
0.0022698557,
-0.0064774281,
0.0215392038,
-0.0656749532,
0.0255041961,
0.0115107568,
0.018828446,
0.0560286678,
0.0531721115,
-0.0384203717,
-0.0446515381,
-0.0113867177,
-0.013795997,
0.0037415228,
-0.010813796,
-0.0392406695,
-0.0338360332,
0.0008792872,
0.0758126974,
0.0441321582,
0.035596475,
-0.0285891294,
-0.0277439337,
-0.0077263494,
0.0098308027,
-0.0686893165,
0.0413672179,
0.0484464169,
0.0336681232,
-0.0341832079,
-0.025585223,
0.0300048459,
-0.016989775,
0.0030602627,
-0.0159140956,
-0.0239710882,
-0.0036028253,
0.0070518204,
0.0236958992,
0.0233729891,
0.0015569919,
-0.002860524,
0.0216846429,
-0.0553675629,
-0.0264486279,
0.0541040339,
-0.0313185379,
0.0594084375,
0.0087445164,
-0.0236783847,
0.0103889024,
-0.0725344568,
0.0177801978,
-0.0259757359,
0.0652722716,
-0.0183703285,
0.0299335364,
-0.0185882747,
-0.0219979379,
-0.0375901945,
-0.0443619788,
-0.0097526163,
0.0702985525,
0.0084680114,
0.0350744016,
0.0162907206,
-0.0757518336,
0.0774126723,
0.0262482055,
0.0462773815,
-0.0043168003,
0.003874083,
0.0209611636,
0.0442521721,
-0.0633357465,
-0.0327549465,
0.0005149461,
-0.098969847,
-0.0140849156,
0.0051183631,
0.0185376462,
0.0188519321,
-0.063546285,
0.0030244191,
0.0103619834,
0.0205715187,
-0.039848689,
-0.0240978263,
0.0125092901,
0.0718423426,
-0.0111795738,
0.0355658494,
-0.0022425505,
0.0214897916,
-0.0470235907,
0.0752987638,
-0.0004108092,
-0.0200099256,
-0.0235884469,
-0.0248655155,
-0.0424705036,
0.0011239983,
-0.0266317241,
-0.0421384685,
0.0528037325,
0.0655721053,
0.0162210055,
-0.0065018702,
0.0165857505,
0.0686785877,
0.0046079578,
-0.023038432,
-0.0272069257,
0.0252582226,
-0.0260081328,
0.0597072728,
-0.046013169,
0.0042200605,
-0.0211228207,
0.0663833246,
0.0205939356,
0.0146536827,
-0.0543462932,
0.0611429811,
-0.0450863019,
-0.0090627568,
0.0045458106,
-0.0407004394,
-0.0088424878,
0.0390471704,
0.0193681996,
0.0217728708,
0.0288588367,
-0.0286093634,
0.0444884598,
-0.043211814,
-0.0245394092,
-0.0441483967,
0.0814827681,
-0.039450001,
0.0011523169,
0.0570425428,
-0.0341510214,
-0.0114297634,
-0.0316683725,
0.0657380745,
0.0109694861,
0.0410636514,
-0.0564869381,
-0.0150667168,
-0.0156342629,
-0.0368279442,
-0.0416325592,
0.0068577495,
0.0037028994,
0.0626969188,
-0.0481518246,
0.0005490942,
-0.0044117053,
0.0336197689,
0.0095042,
-0.0061303545,
-0.0009851578,
0.0073487223,
-0.0136516904,
0.0926054493,
-0.0196747836,
0.0240421109,
-0.0085914619,
0.0381048247,
0.0237234496,
0.0480622165,
-0.0511091352,
0.0089785317,
-0.027569687,
-0.0238915328,
-0.0275516808,
-0.0621021017,
-0.074719198,
-0.0328785442,
0.0485072955,
-0.0460830815,
-0.0061645498,
0.0925725251,
0.0287471302,
0.0175260957,
-0.0175824389,
-0.0096909888,
-0.0450309515,
0.0404747687,
-0.0202661175,
-0.0483559668,
0.0417761058,
-0.0226340294,
-0.0159043726,
-0.0443453789,
-0.0443392619,
0.0095434589,
-0.0398178063,
0.002817292,
-0.0112853358,
0.0019674751,
0.0068912641,
-0.0588947386,
0.0496653765,
0.05640167,
-0.0212559961,
-0.0382497907,
0.0128818713,
-0.0030090744,
0.0456754677,
-0.0186234638,
0.0116283251,
0.0174485054,
0.0360395201,
0.0189239457,
-0.0348055735,
0.0745014548,
-0.0193892792,
-0.0067871967,
0.0208436772,
-0.0848527029,
0.0108882962,
-0.0083623771,
0.0155864162,
0.0320529416,
0.0169554316,
-0.0026984469,
0.0163558461,
0.013519099,
-0.0467769876,
0.0128948335,
0.0778254494,
-0.0239077844,
-0.0410583355,
-0.023585286,
0.0295966864,
-0.0484818295,
0.036312338,
0.0339523889,
0.0300268084,
-0.0210053921,
-0.034133479,
0.0396336764,
0.0038589279,
0.0014535931,
-0.0442388989,
0.0324126333,
0.0030399596,
-0.0502164848,
-0.0487987697,
-0.0278524887,
0.0067230221,
-0.0169929583,
0.0455610119,
0.0292340182,
0.0228928532,
-0.0590281263,
0.0011057182,
0.0044704601,
-0.0167144313,
0.0088821901,
-0.0459795222,
0.060839802,
0.014968765,
-0.0373456553,
-0.0350629725,
0.0583088659,
-0.0692838877,
-0.0292031225,
0.0007123574,
0.0193711985,
0.0278816093,
0.0127249155,
0.0045272722,
0.0342136584,
0.0371427722,
-0.058687605,
0.0279304087,
0.0634276643,
0.039925579,
-0.0131824808,
0.0221996494,
0.0224974565,
0.0350906067,
-0.01401194,
0.0007535648,
-0.0826414302,
-0.0136060566,
-0.0046139439,
-0.0413985923,
0.0442552976,
0.0106116682,
-0.0220338423,
-0.0316860452,
-0.0035524184,
-0.0325636677,
-0.0510338098,
0.0145011116,
0.008196204,
-0.0006476303,
0.0136646368,
-0.0236179028,
-0.0051535065,
-0.0128387809,
0.0649931952,
-0.0187460184,
0.0056370921,
0.0795204118,
0.0507933944,
-0.0389668047,
-0.0147338761,
-0.0285299588,
-0.0188735072,
-0.0144758988,
0.0233165286,
-0.0352826118,
0.0272865463,
0.0068335612,
0.0184917822,
-0.0296608135,
-0.0078671649,
-0.0186779927,
0.0141688241,
0.0102228057,
0.0304745492,
0.0407556854,
-0.0040666009,
0.0382380597,
0.0025820001,
-0.0276530869,
0.0010469633,
0.0584046543,
0.0025902514,
0.0029797968,
0.0212693252,
0.0364336558,
-0.0361196622,
0.0179836601,
0.0625464916,
-0.0380592719,
0.0591468699,
0.0656884313,
-0.0196762551,
-0.0483137667,
-0.0791971982,
-0.0153334923,
0.0356788114,
0.0107747456,
0.0467879176,
-0.0649981424,
0.0037156024,
0.0886306167,
-0.0248581171,
-0.0002291544,
-0.0225654114,
0.0216328651,
0.0424730256,
0.0486150645,
-0.0100017656,
-0.0478604473,
-0.0223074816,
-0.0417829715,
0.0067411042,
-0.03594267,
-5.516209279e-33,
-0.0717499405,
-0.0559894852,
0.0072314837,
0.0518880002,
-0.0230195671,
0.040384721,
-0.0154317729,
0.0302278977,
0.0262627117,
0.0459525362,
0.0294837151,
-0.0133467168,
0.008799131,
-0.0237810332,
0.0353962816,
-0.006652697,
0.0396299548,
-0.0138355,
-0.0508023873,
0.0438521542,
0.0768051445,
-0.0291743428,
0.0275920089,
-0.0687782392,
0.0254669357,
0.0274953954,
0.0540448204,
0.0288824085,
0.0283319075,
0.0701064542,
-0.0362681635,
0.0615801103,
0.0469475016,
0.0219422858,
0.0288681705,
0.033540871,
-0.0654860139,
-0.0775530785,
0.0535743572,
-0.0238835663,
0.0000531935,
-0.0444979109,
-0.0001093404,
0.0262025911,
-0.0242128465,
-0.0277084429,
0.0780007467,
-0.0353351012,
0.0162646361,
-0.0368148722,
-0.0747626945,
0.0140282512,
-0.029524792,
0.0028988828,
0.029121533,
0.0189904012,
0.0206517,
-0.0568771996,
-0.0509753563,
0.0194983259,
-0.0642434508,
0.0213184282,
-0.0131988227,
-0.0086557642,
0.015147863,
0.0504556075,
-0.0155785354,
0.0349856652,
-0.0106386375,
0.0068476759,
-0.0077164252,
0.0160107277,
0.0031211406,
0.0475346521,
-0.0454101674,
-0.0011314802,
-0.0670818686,
-0.0168250185,
0.0367955603,
0.0453459807,
0.0067372285,
-0.03480931,
-0.0004756839,
-0.0205245726,
-0.0567934029,
-0.0280059204,
0.0010995548,
-0.0239075273,
-0.0089838719,
-0.0478728227,
-0.0032962456,
-0.0256340858,
-0.0091361413,
-0.0181491617,
-0.0471218154,
0.027692344,
0.0054870043,
-0.0025352896,
0.028468078,
0.0185674783,
-0.0202605966,
-0.0483291931,
-0.0319005325,
-0.0175700728,
0.0720812157,
-0.0208112299,
0.0148385195,
-0.0273008682,
-0.0259176828,
-0.0124459295,
-0.0110428864,
-0.0022459819,
-0.0395943448,
0.0347668901,
-0.0181772653,
0.0559310317,
0.0173290912,
-0.0174100194,
0.0154207209,
0.0223472584,
-0.0328165032,
0.0100543499,
-0.0448737442,
0.0294347424,
-0.0228301845,
-0.0152783878,
-0.0145056322,
0.0117634535,
-0.0106067648,
-0.0075991531,
-0.0120019596,
-0.0067394767,
2.379e-7,
0.019163087,
0.0551938377,
0.0326676853,
-0.0090166433,
0.0453093797,
0.002844356,
0.0028361336,
0.007789203,
0.0085206022,
-0.0432695523,
-0.0256190319,
0.0173244141,
0.0328888185,
0.0690576583,
-0.0615110695,
-0.0445474237,
-0.02780989,
0.0032689145,
-0.0396636985,
0.0092620403,
0.0334410779,
-0.0441413298,
0.0106966663,
0.0379416049,
-0.0703826621,
0.0386896133,
0.0373217314,
-0.0188903473,
0.0123492563,
0.0454882272,
-0.0338091888,
0.0061048865,
0.0219174344,
0.034551803,
0.0250095762,
0.0341612995,
-0.0042746477,
0.0123050176,
0.0275257304,
-0.038145829,
-0.0276914295,
-0.0067045493,
0.0164005645,
-0.0148243504,
0.0009617897,
-0.0553820617,
-0.0324788615,
-0.0261645876,
-0.0307273753,
0.0060231755,
0.0518961549,
0.0202328302,
-0.0248038452,
0.015427473,
0.0113448324,
-0.0118738022,
0.0357916579,
-0.0469264425,
-0.0019134161,
0.0534083359,
-0.0404743701,
-0.0295530334,
0.0246427506,
-0.0382932574,
-0.0033041677,
0.0015930999,
0.0640967637,
1.714329023e-34,
0.0180609655,
-0.0000686519,
0.0045925402,
-0.0058142431,
0.0384374112,
-0.0276391637,
-0.0441968739,
0.0262959898,
0.0325204879,
-0.0345074758,
0.0374035537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00445v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00445v2 | A Systematic Comparison of Syllogistic Reasoning in Humans and Language Models | 2023-11-01T11:13:06 | 2024-04-11T16:49:57 | Tiwalayo Eisape, MH Tessler, Ishita Dasgupta, Fei Sha, Sjoerd van Steenkiste, Tal Linzen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | A central component of rational behavior is logical inference: the process of
determining which conclusions follow from a set of premises. Psychologists have
documented several ways in which humans' inferences deviate from the rules of
logic. Do language models, which are trained on text generated by humans,
replicate such human biases, or are they able to overcome them? Focusing on the
case of syllogisms -- inferences from two simple premises -- we show that,
within the PaLM2 family of transformer language models, larger models are more
logical than smaller ones, and also more logical than humans. At the same time,
even the largest models make systematic errors, some of which mirror human
reasoning biases: they show sensitivity to the (irrelevant) ordering of the
variables in the syllogism, and draw confident but incorrect inferences from
particular syllogisms (syllogistic fallacies). Overall, we find that language
models often mimic the human biases included in their training data, but are
able to overcome them in some cases. | [
0.0608794466,
0.0454949029,
-0.0211476553,
0.0124115208,
-0.0328851826,
0.0602683648,
0.006084268,
0.0022012452,
0.0241494421,
-0.08042375,
-0.0288128685,
0.0149266776,
0.023468215,
-0.050410863,
0.0477542542,
-0.0709559023,
0.0471861623,
-0.0355405137,
0.0317553543,
-0.0181995388,
-0.0228289049,
0.0231018253,
-0.0045877704,
-0.0045474023,
0.0132306302,
0.0012459339,
0.0114536695,
-0.0204992555,
0.0191195309,
-0.0159330424,
-0.0374508053,
0.0439631753,
0.0119328517,
0.0328279324,
0.0000018416,
-0.0506301299,
0.0579732805,
-0.0108870668,
0.0056455443,
0.03009893,
0.0464708507,
-0.0500596911,
-0.0126274154,
0.0201947708,
-0.0204456002,
-0.0401908197,
0.0156345442,
0.0901618898,
-0.0023940292,
0.0406007282,
-0.0064838137,
-0.0621836297,
0.0174489468,
-0.0275586732,
-0.0416567698,
-0.0136282938,
0.0446184501,
-0.0011624454,
-0.0165036973,
0.0027046134,
0.0049758693,
-0.0137421293,
0.034196645,
0.0195182413,
-0.0888611227,
0.0287022069,
-0.0121392552,
-0.0350020379,
0.0161643326,
-0.0096411128,
0.0418103673,
-0.0705906898,
-0.0137430541,
0.0281842891,
0.026037151,
0.0598293208,
-0.0082770875,
0.0730635449,
-0.0269643608,
-0.0035930879,
0.1002942324,
-0.0223482326,
0.0005319938,
0.0028159691,
-0.0390778333,
0.1021301001,
-0.0017275285,
-0.0377519391,
0.0131948963,
0.0214946494,
-0.029956894,
-0.0540790558,
-0.0291741639,
0.0005518415,
-0.00936935,
0.0379670411,
-0.0305952448,
0.0148767829,
0.0279275887,
-0.0662909821,
0.0056197052,
0.0112810954,
0.0144213885,
0.048814375,
-0.0280592628,
0.0329591185,
-0.0510864742,
0.0858338326,
-0.0137846712,
-0.0126731172,
-0.0077863322,
-0.0367020331,
0.0103184143,
0.0100408774,
-0.0004951357,
0.0157465916,
-0.0116711501,
-0.0055845054,
-0.018741589,
-0.0148190306,
-0.0220953654,
0.0083830561,
0.0077010724,
-0.0303291418,
-0.0817117468,
0.0312364716,
-0.0244644564,
0.0798181072,
-0.0118113142,
-0.0666995272,
0.0128953066,
-0.0063388455,
-0.0322820432,
-0.0134508181,
0.0008893922,
0.0331263468,
-0.0009774494,
0.0282317698,
-0.0446661897,
-0.0048711598,
-0.0149242962,
-0.0438559391,
-0.0213315133,
-0.0562499613,
-0.0224270076,
0.0465348028,
0.0101492647,
-0.0020529386,
-0.0030795229,
0.0370183066,
-0.0723344758,
0.0278867669,
0.008021581,
0.0307904538,
0.0438008532,
-0.0036366165,
-0.0165142082,
0.0395973437,
0.0087035215,
0.0140491677,
-0.023169864,
-0.0013715631,
-0.0036986852,
-0.0089119114,
-0.0304730162,
-0.0242920257,
-0.0431358293,
0.009602583,
-0.0301130991,
0.0022434504,
0.0551131777,
0.109952569,
-0.0478840508,
-0.0382717215,
0.0471452922,
0.0366827734,
0.0336165689,
0.040291585,
0.0432090461,
-0.0333323441,
0.0196556579,
0.0227580126,
-0.0761321411,
-0.0154893724,
0.0033987435,
-0.0303031132,
-0.0494783483,
0.035330601,
-0.009512404,
-0.0392630883,
-0.0412846059,
0.0251021311,
0.001169776,
0.0098316725,
0.059830077,
0.0399499461,
0.0053767897,
0.056835182,
0.0450227223,
-0.0309302006,
-0.0226137955,
-0.0338387601,
0.024023138,
-0.0050356896,
-0.0118221827,
0.0267583691,
0.016356485,
0.0072482484,
-0.0016720495,
0.0208183955,
0.0890035108,
-0.007628826,
-0.0552711077,
0.010279363,
0.0186884217,
0.0122834509,
0.0622226894,
0.0048952196,
-0.0395013019,
0.0029022689,
-0.005747423,
0.0004533858,
0.0280321389,
0.0507722646,
-0.024839025,
0.0013884639,
-0.0878974125,
0.0047647422,
0.0283232518,
-0.0242415816,
0.0021931776,
0.0234163683,
0.0255721509,
-0.0027022562,
-0.0092942771,
0.0752025917,
-0.0502906255,
-0.0356332324,
0.0022140706,
-0.0697630271,
-0.0008766039,
0.0388157964,
-0.0115254987,
-0.0010803977,
0.0329077765,
-0.0759201944,
0.0163743701,
-0.0150047727,
0.0313133895,
-0.0339271091,
-0.0373851769,
-0.0258416254,
0.0836399868,
-0.0115077468,
0.0304840654,
0.0172594357,
-0.0127317021,
0.0097806528,
-0.0220296364,
0.0243732296,
0.0060986723,
-0.0060702628,
-0.0099715153,
-0.0126090767,
-0.0619472377,
-0.0449840277,
-0.0328234918,
-0.0804411247,
-0.0351608917,
-0.0146496641,
0.0139224418,
0.0322418213,
-0.0461165197,
-0.0017134057,
0.0094177593,
0.0170980301,
-0.0237661544,
0.0029387197,
0.0485071875,
0.0177574363,
-0.0407817438,
0.0046228268,
-0.0175007544,
-0.0076217656,
-0.0583828799,
0.029898148,
0.030957127,
0.0531341247,
-0.0711435154,
0.052814316,
-0.0303520877,
0.0097144656,
-0.0253415145,
-0.0285060424,
0.0407848507,
0.026007222,
0.0008827362,
0.1011717692,
0.0255057346,
0.0391741656,
0.0543598719,
0.0335685201,
-0.0305016786,
-0.0278485045,
-0.0405315906,
0.0071625053,
-0.0485796407,
-0.0782875121,
-0.0229744017,
0.0818329602,
0.0158688258,
0.0179121029,
-0.037577536,
0.0459533632,
-0.0462792106,
-0.0238053016,
0.0503086448,
-0.0566539206,
-0.0184945799,
0.0388868228,
-0.0102583151,
0.0006187874,
0.0400630869,
0.0279646013,
0.0211568046,
-0.0674401298,
0.0033677358,
-0.0366822854,
0.0446601249,
0.0214021467,
0.0078590354,
0.0178880915,
-0.0086503774,
-0.0988250673,
-0.0203469209,
0.0382630192,
-0.0093621919,
0.0158477966,
-0.0438247137,
-0.0163440481,
0.0020956094,
-0.0585712306,
-0.0449703559,
-0.0119353626,
-0.0909906402,
-0.0155779887,
-0.0081381965,
-0.0143285925,
-0.00582049,
-0.0071888431,
0.0358925648,
0.0078319935,
0.0241195299,
-0.0233514197,
-0.0021608607,
-0.0090778079,
0.0339952782,
-0.0011498217,
0.0705848783,
-0.0283397809,
-0.0039969329,
0.0800520927,
0.0233281553,
0.0340925418,
-0.0142252501,
0.0042930287,
0.0354320966,
0.0088570733,
-0.061906483,
0.0096977269,
0.0273589045,
-0.0156481732,
0.0191244557,
0.08322341,
0.0168963987,
0.0126563469,
0.0216585081,
-0.0402131155,
0.0029550008,
0.0326722451,
-0.0228705779,
-0.040833436,
-0.0126706809,
0.0283942297,
-0.0241628718,
-0.031616766,
-0.0116090337,
0.0200505219,
-0.1001381576,
0.0333531052,
-0.0016687592,
-0.0112177394,
-0.0104243988,
-0.0661778152,
0.0272535775,
-0.0362286642,
-0.0161424261,
0.066750057,
-0.0279905181,
0.0167677607,
0.0144242737,
-0.0008860575,
0.00503504,
-0.000886287,
-0.0284924787,
0.0159163568,
-0.0080278767,
0.0473056398,
-0.0204954799,
-0.0601672828,
0.0255882349,
-0.0288492013,
-0.0207468197,
-0.0049717678,
0.0014886078,
0.015112902,
0.0232651401,
-0.0585434325,
0.0253516994,
-0.0005302329,
-0.0170385372,
-0.0182560906,
0.0786603019,
0.0161851309,
-0.0966324359,
-0.0216317475,
0.0438815542,
-0.0756510347,
0.0577344187,
0.0198831931,
0.0023697857,
-0.0418844856,
-0.001099767,
-0.0108402381,
0.0350491069,
-0.0305849481,
0.0539323762,
0.036272388,
-0.0630765036,
-0.079751499,
-0.0580080599,
-0.0139381588,
0.0060515008,
-0.0093783764,
-0.0317213386,
0.0168018844,
-0.0251559131,
0.0071012117,
0.0154648535,
0.0166519005,
-0.0073604276,
-0.0248525366,
0.0480469689,
-0.0015565777,
-0.0041901334,
-0.0316320658,
-0.0266819298,
-0.0367988087,
-0.0474022441,
0.027720524,
0.0221062861,
0.0303635038,
0.0035280795,
-0.0092436634,
-0.025639616,
-0.002852302,
0.0190938767,
-0.0200297348,
0.0484188013,
0.0008292901,
-0.0444008559,
0.0134113682,
0.0258724261,
0.0122334519,
0.0476706959,
0.015077671,
-0.0077148112,
-0.0714004263,
-0.0243172683,
0.0634854138,
-0.0110526476,
0.0537661687,
0.0254505314,
-0.0213450063,
-0.0215368122,
0.0003615481,
-0.0313959792,
-0.0227801427,
0.0145506365,
0.016954897,
0.0128294313,
0.054744266,
-0.0319234319,
-0.0896383002,
-0.0097586606,
0.031339027,
0.0411911532,
-0.0027536808,
0.067919299,
0.0340523645,
0.007371664,
0.002328302,
-0.0286157131,
-0.0020049075,
-0.0529970825,
0.0733519122,
0.0148919057,
0.0629744828,
0.0423174985,
-0.0194245614,
-0.0127198678,
-0.0379183926,
-0.0722174495,
-0.0712185204,
0.030543929,
-0.0612792931,
0.0113033401,
-0.0253198445,
0.041607976,
-0.0300382897,
-0.0017508568,
-0.0106924335,
-0.0076296027,
-0.0035693485,
-0.0241959393,
0.0364380814,
0.0226514712,
-0.0197548512,
-0.0042082625,
0.0236928444,
-0.0040558465,
0.0469824746,
-0.0078107868,
-0.0191953015,
-0.0122118173,
-0.0462778769,
-0.0231921244,
-0.0245320909,
-0.0262018628,
0.0000411097,
-0.1057304591,
-0.0759050697,
0.0155145125,
0.0287801474,
0.0396293774,
-0.0467799269,
-0.0023999994,
0.0839359164,
0.005893819,
-0.0216906723,
-0.0322856084,
0.0268602557,
-0.0034112199,
0.0199846867,
-0.0446311198,
-5.948718099e-33,
-0.0222071745,
-0.0026310112,
0.0007580477,
-0.0112142777,
0.0137984045,
-0.0430845805,
-0.0111623071,
0.0273222439,
-0.0482187979,
0.085067898,
-0.0016905058,
0.0227966364,
0.0107406639,
-0.022851862,
0.0114497151,
-0.0102042444,
0.0202733446,
0.016870752,
-0.0190469474,
-0.0561414585,
0.0581796765,
-0.0171773434,
0.038585607,
-0.0540807545,
0.0090572257,
0.0134820295,
0.0122973649,
-0.0040760664,
-0.0653274357,
0.0093876068,
0.0254341234,
-0.0084074857,
0.0243154783,
-0.0073749665,
0.0301731359,
0.053355623,
-0.0366086625,
-0.0152363926,
0.0764647201,
0.0108648082,
-0.0039899293,
-0.0075880312,
0.0408164226,
-0.0133168614,
-0.051218003,
-0.0269114655,
0.0423857607,
-0.0276284069,
0.0207075756,
0.0096006561,
-0.0874259621,
0.0082853325,
0.0238743518,
0.0066339965,
-0.0580901355,
0.0634645894,
-0.0278380942,
-0.0165026002,
-0.0395258106,
0.0407223068,
0.0198199246,
-0.0128424382,
0.0227886252,
-0.0182942338,
-0.0152686089,
0.0730720609,
0.0418750718,
0.0194523707,
-0.047872223,
0.0274961721,
0.0110814944,
0.0655354932,
0.0671060309,
0.0526508801,
0.0384581871,
-0.0033759237,
-0.0551416799,
-0.0506666452,
0.013727569,
0.0591328777,
0.0269496962,
-0.0195206627,
-0.040221151,
-0.0154712275,
-0.0617807657,
-0.0251910985,
-0.0280124843,
-0.0199337304,
0.0089443158,
0.0124635268,
0.0031640886,
-0.0154066728,
-0.0126347663,
-0.0320996046,
-0.0022897304,
-0.0150368055,
-0.0043219002,
-0.0062636216,
-0.0021668363,
0.0441317633,
-0.0427733436,
-0.0030237446,
0.0155686168,
0.0349162519,
0.022390645,
0.0405084938,
0.0304147862,
-0.0332586356,
-0.0256991163,
-0.0217225906,
-0.0162454769,
-0.0286219995,
-0.0065231896,
-0.0394820422,
0.0654448122,
0.0328590646,
-0.0040439144,
-0.0398541689,
0.01892302,
-0.0314834528,
-0.0594214164,
0.0570989922,
-0.0367088988,
0.0062967865,
0.0077013657,
-0.0280232169,
-0.0250457972,
0.031859789,
0.0282761455,
-0.0436939374,
-0.0215466842,
0.0222171657,
2.662e-7,
0.0473489054,
0.0690528452,
-0.0223403648,
-0.0167807192,
0.029268913,
0.064173013,
0.0295126289,
0.017549647,
0.0574311018,
-0.0082363784,
-0.0291743074,
0.0147281624,
0.0279399436,
0.0382756852,
-0.02928246,
0.0002219457,
-0.0655503422,
-0.0141479438,
0.0163469836,
0.0195226017,
0.0459476076,
0.0742045119,
0.0229326189,
-0.026007548,
-0.0216322858,
-0.0220720656,
0.0485171266,
-0.0155281769,
0.0169601254,
-0.0109486235,
0.0157321114,
-0.0101851625,
0.0370669067,
0.0643028244,
0.0333889313,
-0.0123896133,
-0.0239521097,
0.0151152555,
-0.009851302,
0.0361686349,
-0.0337211974,
-0.0529952049,
-0.010218435,
-0.0997919515,
0.0642792061,
-0.0854543895,
-0.0385354273,
0.0044402322,
-0.0357432477,
0.0002762677,
0.0071311761,
0.0269056279,
-0.0151098995,
0.0032077883,
0.0249347836,
0.0050246934,
0.0284022447,
-0.0655659363,
-0.0202366337,
0.0368729383,
-0.0370862558,
-0.0545490794,
-0.0004762479,
0.0250209626,
0.0538690723,
-0.0206898041,
-0.0023966213,
2.078929029e-34,
0.0150060514,
0.005360777,
0.0205787476,
0.0040213172,
0.0504714586,
-0.0002913496,
0.0273775011,
0.0275085531,
0.0369680375,
-0.0593986362,
-0.0052191745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00430v1 | Distil-Whisper: Robust Knowledge Distillation via Large-Scale Pseudo Labelling | 2023-11-01T10:45:07 | 2023-11-01T10:45:07 | Sanchit Gandhi, Patrick von Platen, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | As the size of pre-trained speech recognition models increases, running these
large models in low-latency or resource-constrained environments becomes
challenging. In this work, we leverage pseudo-labelling to assemble a
large-scale open-source dataset which we use to distill the Whisper model into
a smaller variant, called Distil-Whisper. Using a simple word error rate (WER)
heuristic, we select only the highest quality pseudo-labels for training. The
distilled model is 5.8 times faster with 51% fewer parameters, while performing
to within 1% WER on out-of-distribution test data in a zero-shot transfer
setting. Distil-Whisper maintains the robustness of the Whisper model to
difficult acoustic conditions, while being less prone to hallucination errors
on long-form audio. Distil-Whisper is designed to be paired with Whisper for
speculative decoding, yielding a 2 times speed-up while mathematically ensuring
the same outputs as the original model. To facilitate further research in this
domain, we make our training code, inference code and models publicly
accessible. | [
-0.0257212967,
0.0854772851,
0.0362902209,
0.0035189663,
0.0034213983,
0.0109572029,
0.0310460366,
-0.0023322895,
-0.0028626646,
0.0311933216,
-0.041754581,
0.021776475,
-0.0073181111,
0.03032046,
0.0087839682,
-0.0328526683,
0.0212613195,
-0.0702623203,
0.0309389196,
-0.0244627353,
-0.0049439855,
-0.0055756797,
-0.0429709218,
0.0095442524,
0.0014911005,
-0.023807209,
-0.0155587839,
0.0214294139,
0.0155421002,
0.0023543537,
-0.0160208736,
0.01441056,
0.0232951269,
0.0508434139,
0.0000021569,
-0.0285187196,
-0.0214819759,
0.0103321858,
-0.0889075026,
0.0361154638,
-0.0191297457,
0.0210796893,
-0.0001549483,
-0.0016061742,
-0.0126910694,
-0.0620831661,
0.0398541316,
0.0331315771,
0.053682819,
0.0569110475,
0.0065469658,
-0.0421402007,
0.0299141686,
-0.0148380715,
0.0008845534,
-0.0772903562,
-0.0038277707,
-0.0117112799,
-0.038033288,
-0.0341466889,
0.004376431,
0.0739912614,
0.0080559794,
0.0085227778,
0.001008602,
0.0101033812,
-0.065445058,
-0.0463905595,
-0.0245388262,
0.0888911411,
-0.0177872665,
-0.0511066131,
0.0399458446,
0.0075840401,
-0.016713623,
-0.0519217849,
-0.0161698423,
-0.0087442119,
0.0075167385,
-0.0021795498,
-0.0223543625,
0.0445844568,
0.0608029291,
-0.0330616757,
-0.0158054084,
0.0335336141,
-0.0123009682,
-0.0432442464,
0.0238520838,
-0.0458370708,
-0.0296464022,
-0.0194201116,
0.0432439223,
-0.0077025495,
-0.0081853885,
-0.0179706607,
-0.0349418372,
-0.0267228,
-0.0116317859,
0.0077654719,
0.0336225368,
0.0290171392,
-0.0447034836,
0.0321998894,
0.0133626135,
0.0079840124,
0.0187716242,
0.0540345386,
-0.0423250273,
0.0065092174,
-0.0399172939,
0.0165121481,
-0.0554319546,
0.0462303199,
-0.0375897251,
0.0053577339,
0.001949018,
-0.030507518,
-0.0512300469,
0.0163768809,
0.0694205388,
-0.0053592771,
-0.0278633013,
-0.0239140727,
0.0638555586,
0.0427544527,
-0.0092560388,
0.0214435309,
0.0164488573,
-0.057662081,
-0.0301600005,
0.0013859955,
0.0282154363,
0.005610256,
0.0026617206,
0.0472560823,
-0.0020395268,
-0.0265856404,
-0.0327797309,
-0.0229286347,
-0.0040756399,
-0.0714740902,
-0.0449892096,
-0.0454221368,
0.0586368814,
-0.0312826335,
0.0153126856,
-0.0880566314,
-0.0023474316,
-0.0448974147,
-0.0140704084,
0.0628662258,
-0.0668424666,
0.010102882,
0.0115643861,
0.0401987731,
-0.034260802,
0.054699786,
0.0393280312,
-0.0006397846,
0.02647008,
-0.0250049308,
0.016443843,
0.0433526933,
0.0798002779,
0.0207148511,
0.0106009329,
-0.0038645722,
0.0307935476,
0.0008805128,
0.0359364189,
0.0465666912,
-0.0471801907,
-0.0392387845,
0.0633764416,
-0.001400428,
0.0393628627,
-0.0137293721,
0.0091877133,
0.0558841005,
-0.0101823332,
-0.0214726944,
-0.0283737481,
-0.0084013296,
-0.0144834314,
0.0145763382,
0.0631550476,
0.0225185901,
-0.0487206988,
-0.0094986865,
0.0094718644,
-0.007443394,
0.0046896678,
0.0509368256,
0.0329201594,
0.0381571315,
-0.0465925075,
0.0904351622,
0.0587803014,
-0.0363194831,
0.0091608204,
-0.0261903796,
0.0012303338,
0.0601630621,
0.0038844319,
-0.0463994369,
0.0075990325,
-0.0417502522,
0.0261502117,
0.0139863063,
-0.020628063,
-0.0200273246,
0.0615899973,
-0.0627168268,
-0.0255789701,
0.0338510573,
0.0214015283,
0.0310507305,
0.0210644919,
0.0148454783,
0.003704306,
-0.0773212463,
0.0054603927,
-0.0166383702,
-0.0216030888,
-0.0716822296,
-0.0101621645,
0.0112696337,
0.0583931133,
0.0180458445,
-0.0403034613,
0.0002096635,
0.0292357765,
-0.0172151998,
0.0150455311,
-0.0269143116,
-0.0520476215,
-0.0316424482,
0.0612094328,
0.0103938887,
0.0256312899,
0.0309013352,
-0.0273291077,
-0.0341655575,
0.0182371289,
0.0270664543,
0.0812748224,
-0.0275075398,
0.0269032028,
0.0308185574,
-0.0040826453,
0.0305921566,
-0.0262707379,
-0.0364350565,
-0.0226358958,
-0.0415030047,
-0.0049984925,
-0.0300807767,
-0.0012413616,
-0.0387916528,
0.0434430726,
-0.0389977768,
0.0277354624,
-0.0568856262,
-0.0126088541,
-0.0245114155,
0.0248730928,
-0.0475336052,
-0.0157131739,
-0.0549892522,
-0.0061042267,
0.0025407388,
0.0134679759,
-0.0032666314,
-0.0302139986,
0.0143360421,
0.0030661481,
-0.0468721688,
-0.0052913814,
-0.077235736,
0.0067780493,
0.0087843984,
0.0121143945,
-0.0063228756,
0.0452763252,
0.0049206177,
-0.0571024567,
0.0124498624,
-0.057303939,
0.0432259329,
-0.0075954339,
0.0192933604,
-0.003747151,
-0.0219023712,
-0.0187587198,
0.0021661343,
-0.0042820615,
-0.0223929193,
-0.0373058133,
-0.0167493932,
0.0120332669,
-0.0215927195,
-0.037790399,
0.001145127,
-0.0032574998,
-0.0255765598,
-0.0320715979,
0.002995085,
-0.0374613516,
0.0530369282,
0.0135093201,
0.0198373888,
-0.0590590276,
-0.0330768004,
-0.011010048,
-0.0763756633,
-0.0196199007,
-0.003036462,
-0.0045390227,
0.0214138217,
-0.0168043748,
-0.0115272012,
0.0420003533,
-0.0564054772,
-0.0262221172,
-0.0207618102,
-0.0788721442,
0.0272212084,
0.0302778538,
-0.0472787805,
-0.0029532253,
0.0211101081,
-0.0172238126,
-0.0179725792,
-0.0430200659,
0.0053320993,
-0.0431650244,
-0.0017857164,
-0.0384106375,
0.0059975483,
0.0135776568,
-0.0357569754,
-0.0298752654,
-0.0277202856,
-0.0276801586,
0.0047458136,
-0.0070592114,
-0.0343142636,
-0.0283518992,
0.0297222063,
-0.0050904141,
0.0751866251,
0.0204816647,
0.0149067286,
-0.0112620378,
0.0295340102,
0.0090913158,
-0.0125245703,
0.0204229672,
-0.0104597872,
0.0391320214,
0.0687908977,
0.0892719403,
0.0115646599,
-0.0258583426,
0.0171354972,
0.0398442149,
0.0124911405,
0.0020466417,
0.0438868143,
0.075282976,
-0.0365382843,
-0.0128542138,
0.0907903463,
-0.0137450658,
-0.035150636,
-0.005893575,
0.0368182026,
0.0749128908,
0.0053199106,
-0.0349449292,
-0.0498461947,
-0.0303742513,
0.0662482977,
0.0681345016,
0.0106545119,
-0.0259813201,
-0.0156098772,
-0.0888092667,
0.0555726178,
0.0452519394,
-0.0283947382,
-0.0212182943,
-0.0438204817,
-0.0290175565,
-0.020303376,
0.0252732318,
0.0207174476,
0.0341411829,
-0.0192309171,
0.0341819748,
-0.0202864185,
-0.0429614969,
0.0360522047,
-0.0498438925,
0.0686423108,
0.0390232764,
0.0053120442,
0.0264512133,
-0.0541358031,
0.0024365964,
-0.0148295835,
-0.0540479459,
-0.0103311548,
0.0721759349,
-0.0223449282,
0.0008213581,
0.0347020254,
0.047034055,
-0.0462550931,
-0.0135133881,
0.0229623523,
0.0524863489,
0.0243698005,
-0.0132789528,
0.0405404493,
0.0314312652,
0.0202022325,
0.0703043193,
0.0318730474,
-0.0012397034,
0.013882746,
0.0195877571,
0.0186229479,
-0.0086608632,
0.0143906483,
0.0148798525,
-0.0051305308,
-0.0528395288,
-0.0292730425,
0.0156395845,
0.0136049837,
0.0530184507,
0.0052583232,
0.0021787728,
0.0298732072,
0.0086285416,
-0.0871135443,
-0.0084133428,
-0.0185495168,
0.0092918193,
-0.0176661462,
-0.0399042889,
0.0372393802,
0.0023516035,
-0.0235969704,
0.0456568338,
-0.1163556278,
-0.058883436,
0.0450372547,
0.0233745258,
0.0201260373,
0.0833350942,
-0.0241608806,
-0.051900778,
0.0806991085,
0.0274279732,
-0.0594254099,
0.0236032587,
0.068645753,
-0.0176040716,
0.028374929,
0.0396080203,
-0.0494381078,
-0.0037395016,
0.0200695451,
0.0072844643,
-0.0538134053,
0.0151966093,
-0.0063067479,
-0.0064986204,
0.0539941564,
0.0103233429,
0.0135823078,
-0.0235887207,
0.0463703275,
0.0219314713,
0.0168913659,
-0.0431070365,
0.0153692449,
0.0613026917,
-0.0083111394,
-0.0068472447,
0.0422740616,
0.0180272609,
-0.0069945594,
-0.0294454619,
0.0160222631,
0.0094411848,
-0.0316761695,
0.0471678413,
-0.0220906623,
-0.0019013704,
0.0389143489,
0.0195482485,
0.0314150453,
0.0047556791,
-0.018086249,
0.0095568458,
0.02902597,
0.0055860439,
-0.0001083796,
-0.0500335619,
-0.0768808499,
-0.0386865065,
0.0672501847,
0.0174891874,
0.0280763619,
0.0418638997,
0.0099443104,
-0.0047107339,
-0.0242613163,
-0.0118095819,
-0.0365396328,
0.00614119,
-0.0031638404,
0.0313713774,
-0.0161387306,
0.0411127843,
0.0440543666,
0.0341451392,
0.0379491001,
-0.0174133983,
0.0586045943,
-0.0427377336,
-0.0568026602,
-0.0493368991,
0.0616819076,
0.0052993889,
-0.0105766905,
-0.0212298278,
-0.0690146163,
0.0198353995,
-0.0053306958,
-0.009698919,
0.0022663521,
0.0552492589,
-0.0015236363,
-0.0202874877,
-0.0226219986,
0.0051675648,
-0.0774724931,
0.0702395886,
-0.0349343345,
0.050615225,
-6.954995263e-33,
0.0066858991,
0.0107309371,
0.014064041,
-0.0345272571,
-0.0279831085,
-0.0139531167,
-0.001086164,
-0.0033706473,
0.0168890879,
0.0068350802,
-0.0123133557,
0.0359320268,
0.0531151928,
0.0442963429,
-0.0282641873,
-0.0254405979,
0.0897237584,
-0.0331792533,
-0.01119537,
0.0342571884,
0.0211099256,
0.0769199505,
0.0375684462,
-0.0683888122,
-0.0224294867,
-0.0183865819,
0.0027842459,
-0.0116263283,
0.0368487611,
-0.0174410231,
-0.0199300982,
0.0237493142,
-0.0357380994,
-0.0227087792,
-0.0387041867,
-0.0289178956,
-0.1210874319,
0.0144376662,
0.0073971967,
0.0298275054,
0.0184155516,
0.0069212914,
0.0193112325,
0.0101348422,
-0.0122530796,
-0.0314714462,
-0.0106355064,
-0.0063302834,
-0.0395258032,
-0.0608819947,
0.0098655177,
0.0299197808,
-0.0263476912,
-0.0426172465,
0.0930054262,
0.0182145089,
-0.0175567381,
-0.0158015564,
-0.1340466291,
0.0081871944,
0.0100171948,
0.0083819563,
0.0582085066,
0.0387152024,
-0.0163085982,
0.0385222211,
0.0732613578,
-0.0416039973,
0.0171894841,
-0.0115019633,
0.0330442153,
0.0567923523,
-0.0086872866,
0.0062489919,
0.0610939972,
-0.0449886806,
-0.0147337355,
-0.0598504506,
-0.0187923796,
-0.033618506,
0.024916552,
0.0510415137,
-0.0545290373,
-0.0156829618,
-0.0763042942,
-0.0564536005,
-0.0283616111,
0.0049068066,
0.0558630452,
0.0322565511,
-0.0229584295,
0.0154699655,
0.045905441,
-0.0377531014,
0.0152010228,
0.0071258619,
0.0362465344,
0.0173491053,
-0.0243054312,
0.0134405987,
-0.0487978198,
-0.0227105469,
0.0597559549,
0.0317493118,
0.0026800858,
-0.0410010815,
0.0177375544,
0.0248497687,
-0.0475368686,
0.0012638044,
-0.0054276353,
0.0371649042,
0.0379403643,
0.0002500852,
0.0584126376,
0.0023642418,
-0.005514801,
-0.0061332895,
-0.005006494,
0.012208987,
0.0207798909,
0.048769705,
-0.0048117582,
0.0180714317,
-0.0097821709,
-0.0086750099,
-0.0153794456,
-0.0449693017,
0.0301295873,
-0.0416287258,
-0.0053674942,
0.0081876311,
2.995e-7,
-0.0461034141,
-0.0031845474,
0.0212751254,
-0.031908039,
0.0234059822,
-0.0017577705,
-0.0161392521,
-0.0030898866,
-0.01296522,
-0.0985937119,
0.0023494989,
0.0511914864,
0.1013158113,
0.0231405552,
-0.1032521129,
-0.0604723841,
-0.0270174108,
-0.0048763058,
-0.0105685471,
-0.037131194,
-0.0030544987,
0.0929646119,
0.0514677837,
-0.038561631,
0.0531526618,
-0.0031537637,
-0.0036438704,
-0.0058025541,
0.0184828434,
0.0089810109,
-0.0156419352,
-0.0015250584,
-0.009038765,
0.0231653638,
-0.0251769442,
-0.0278994646,
-0.0018795199,
0.0547403917,
0.0047820173,
-0.0744326264,
-0.0389524363,
0.0309342183,
-0.0141653568,
-0.0096808979,
0.0544486679,
-0.0101993643,
-0.0297728125,
0.0115100136,
-0.0474897251,
-0.0284731649,
0.0191726889,
-0.0086912476,
0.0487401932,
0.0435455143,
-0.004261361,
-0.0028942011,
-0.0357877575,
-0.0606993809,
-0.0000038298,
0.019224355,
-0.0478245206,
-0.0495500974,
-0.0151988929,
-0.0381775647,
0.0228135213,
-0.0337940231,
0.0307769366,
2.40922159e-34,
0.0528003685,
-0.0125631439,
0.0229849275,
0.0139428014,
-0.0041538165,
-0.0455511957,
-0.0022189962,
-0.0075623575,
-0.0129442737,
-0.0295751411,
-0.009157721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00416v1 | Efficient Human-AI Coordination via Preparatory Language-based Convention | 2023-11-01T10:18:23 | 2023-11-01T10:18:23 | Cong Guan, Lichao Zhang, Chunpeng Fan, Yichen Li, Feng Chen, Lihe Li, Yunjia Tian, Lei Yuan, Yang Yu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Developing intelligent agents capable of seamless coordination with humans is
a critical step towards achieving artificial general intelligence. Existing
methods for human-AI coordination typically train an agent to coordinate with a
diverse set of policies or with human models fitted from real human data.
However, the massively diverse styles of human behavior present obstacles for
AI systems with constrained capacity, while high quality human data may not be
readily available in real-world scenarios. In this study, we observe that prior
to coordination, humans engage in communication to establish conventions that
specify individual roles and actions, making their coordination proceed in an
orderly manner. Building upon this observation, we propose employing the large
language model (LLM) to develop an action plan (or equivalently, a convention)
that effectively guides both human and AI. By inputting task requirements,
human preferences, the number of agents, and other pertinent information into
the LLM, it can generate a comprehensive convention that facilitates a clear
understanding of tasks and responsibilities for all parties involved.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that decomposing the convention formulation problem
into sub-problems with multiple new sessions being sequentially employed and
human feedback, will yield a more efficient coordination convention.
Experimental evaluations conducted in the Overcooked-AI environment, utilizing
a human proxy model, highlight the superior performance of our proposed method
compared to existing learning-based approaches. When coordinating with real
humans, our method achieves better alignment with human preferences and an
average performance improvement of 15% compared to the state-of-the-art. | [
0.0743950903,
0.0344740301,
-0.0247831941,
-0.0254373327,
-0.0329289138,
0.0133983493,
-0.0128973974,
-0.0029617397,
0.0312687047,
-0.0289374869,
0.0017729341,
-0.0513643995,
0.0130826384,
-0.0080552753,
-0.0048740925,
-0.047975827,
0.0268011689,
-0.0428837053,
0.0373115353,
0.0068726046,
-0.0084948242,
-0.0426484905,
0.0045738299,
0.0289458595,
-0.0420155823,
0.0096515678,
-0.041274894,
-0.0282853972,
0.0303551648,
-0.00648973,
-0.0063124844,
0.0313407145,
0.0490778871,
-0.014811134,
0.0000021388,
-0.0587169677,
0.0467924029,
-0.0332714766,
0.0165553987,
-0.016921917,
0.0271040779,
-0.0451502539,
-0.0099019175,
0.0027086257,
-0.0571328476,
0.0527710058,
0.0383769162,
0.0747696236,
0.0164601188,
0.0399928316,
-0.0087192571,
-0.0239118896,
-0.0070285387,
0.0020234003,
-0.0255328137,
-0.0756901354,
0.0418215357,
-0.0023424495,
0.0390364937,
-0.0145490635,
-0.0080030616,
-0.0076862602,
0.0234534126,
0.0035468389,
-0.0358968303,
0.0424259901,
-0.0036443586,
-0.0497601628,
-0.0100796036,
0.0793570876,
-0.0073390859,
-0.0118191894,
0.0366922393,
0.0061798817,
0.0390514396,
0.015801955,
-0.0228439774,
0.0283517353,
0.0087560033,
-0.0042347983,
0.0184449274,
-0.0143887056,
0.0003525611,
0.022436643,
-0.0204261374,
0.0711108968,
-0.0222385842,
-0.0336218067,
-0.0111667579,
-0.0053404486,
-0.0111934701,
-0.078807801,
0.0256950743,
0.0599583872,
-0.1211415902,
0.0153269954,
-0.037287131,
0.0071643791,
0.0159637462,
-0.0353781246,
0.0502504744,
0.0573386885,
0.0270685852,
0.0219656583,
-0.0047394847,
0.0784867257,
-0.0218879115,
0.0103230877,
-0.0550599918,
-0.0074618976,
-0.077383928,
-0.0077635916,
-0.0492637604,
0.0112752598,
-0.0095784785,
-0.0172290206,
-0.0310236253,
0.0483013615,
-0.057237789,
0.03492672,
0.0087654656,
0.0121323681,
-0.0221949946,
-0.0099382214,
-0.0475895107,
-0.0362845697,
-0.0521660931,
0.024794437,
0.0141771799,
0.0234386884,
0.0069434904,
0.005002467,
-0.0201483704,
0.0036780958,
-0.0102865472,
0.0845307782,
-0.0161140691,
0.0156332254,
0.0196196139,
-0.0211101882,
0.0240100902,
-0.0462523438,
-0.0194987319,
-0.0305271577,
0.0653099492,
-0.0176406987,
-0.0331930034,
-0.0445875563,
0.001435349,
0.0214092266,
-0.0334993862,
0.0562320426,
0.0201752223,
0.0436237268,
0.0419336781,
0.0189402997,
-0.0224905685,
0.0254380759,
0.049514275,
0.0425902307,
0.0072651757,
0.0255755,
0.0613897815,
0.0391844995,
-0.0408629365,
-0.0128299566,
0.0162027832,
0.0042936956,
0.0003947264,
0.0785461292,
0.0467627496,
0.048702579,
-0.025060365,
-0.0177810118,
0.050253246,
0.0961572155,
-0.0262874924,
0.0090073785,
0.0514178388,
0.0519794561,
-0.0032699746,
-0.0283789393,
-0.0501278415,
0.034462288,
-0.025569912,
-0.0164868459,
-0.055005759,
-0.013795699,
-0.041781716,
-0.0302481223,
0.0258481503,
-0.0332988389,
0.0628948212,
0.0102386447,
0.0131583894,
-0.0365495048,
-0.0597057566,
-0.0361470543,
0.0105860746,
-0.0106803486,
0.00634587,
-0.0473499708,
0.0286132041,
0.1231519505,
0.0142985657,
-0.0053812223,
-0.009168393,
0.0086913472,
0.0411334969,
0.0188898109,
0.0299655255,
-0.0264446158,
-0.0004146807,
-0.0320115723,
-0.0371172726,
0.0443062633,
-0.0140385786,
0.0236408599,
-0.000646561,
-0.02257156,
-0.0039883857,
0.0648699924,
-0.0802545995,
0.0491719395,
-0.028273087,
0.0092030335,
-0.022349393,
0.002828307,
0.0398519337,
-0.002546276,
-0.0189276319,
0.0100035882,
0.0330408551,
-0.0254019033,
-0.0380765274,
0.0369708017,
-0.0532945022,
0.0373731107,
0.014687852,
0.0024371014,
-0.0540569313,
0.0064753918,
-0.0117692193,
-0.0386508889,
-0.0011866769,
0.0099119199,
0.03446104,
0.008302046,
0.0046008211,
0.0318524353,
-0.0382514149,
-0.0120912474,
0.0423648655,
-0.0017444873,
-0.0522896461,
0.0055452357,
0.0086466232,
0.0037482418,
-0.0579633005,
0.0218367781,
0.038537249,
-0.0090732938,
0.0263524409,
0.0698113665,
0.0320228003,
-0.0287611838,
-0.0296567678,
-0.1254691631,
-0.0129775526,
-0.0143041192,
-0.0136266043,
-0.0224744044,
-0.0093320431,
-0.0060303644,
0.013555822,
-0.0402215943,
0.0170601383,
-0.027112009,
0.018619379,
0.0205734465,
0.0309530757,
-0.0722078159,
-0.0440375693,
0.0241399985,
-0.0065488014,
-0.026662739,
0.0328673348,
-0.0045051975,
-0.0614363961,
0.0123724081,
-0.0118481992,
0.0471704081,
-0.0232614335,
-0.0659992024,
0.0261113904,
0.0064881598,
0.0294810943,
0.0770355612,
0.0299240667,
0.019435484,
0.0469736345,
0.003250601,
-0.0542099364,
0.0151435267,
-0.0201623533,
-0.0388670899,
-0.0509063751,
-0.013091201,
0.0090736793,
0.0712256134,
-0.0327284448,
0.0398359969,
-0.0384137183,
-0.0359014384,
0.0043004998,
-0.071719937,
-0.0389140807,
-0.0543040894,
-0.0535633191,
0.044232998,
-0.0436338671,
0.0057191094,
0.0571955778,
0.0495964661,
0.0307041034,
-0.0077531575,
-0.0150355333,
0.0013221671,
0.0484896563,
0.0191069022,
0.0309302341,
-0.0388982333,
-0.0187490936,
-0.0845438913,
-0.0047295024,
0.0118191699,
0.0010375892,
-0.0096580246,
-0.0819339454,
0.0099695502,
0.0116010578,
-0.0484747551,
-0.0342554674,
-0.0028624667,
-0.0406814814,
0.0555329844,
0.0160063636,
-0.0400153808,
-0.034996666,
-0.0235437024,
0.0333101973,
0.0111114373,
0.0430984199,
-0.0113288686,
-0.025662858,
-0.0423729867,
0.0363639928,
0.0385746211,
-0.0509138294,
-0.0173659548,
0.011416385,
0.054272145,
0.0533704571,
0.0149801737,
-0.0121533098,
0.0082762549,
0.0399796329,
-0.0248826221,
-0.0234992169,
0.0619004592,
0.0318903066,
-0.0038399601,
-0.0044252123,
0.1109871864,
0.0340810418,
-0.0537405238,
0.0304784328,
-0.0323474109,
-0.00079536,
-0.0121424645,
0.0358672999,
-0.0608278476,
-0.013092258,
0.0029189554,
0.0001020599,
-0.0251972694,
-0.0491712764,
0.0221719239,
-0.0654403865,
0.013477006,
-0.0026003884,
-0.0411865339,
-0.0017424045,
-0.0584332384,
0.0235023852,
-0.0230129324,
0.0155563243,
-0.0018423521,
0.0372308306,
-0.0414644256,
-0.0012309176,
-0.0048587816,
-0.0242292155,
0.0415068977,
-0.0679988563,
0.0522578955,
0.0996661633,
0.0501666442,
0.000730706,
-0.0154553698,
0.0341020674,
0.035433162,
0.0409561843,
0.0079611996,
-0.0429341123,
-0.0184076,
0.0283232313,
-0.026001187,
0.0345722102,
-0.0450034589,
-0.0328228809,
0.0305009782,
0.0781374946,
-0.031617865,
-0.0163780563,
0.0040203631,
-0.0074887956,
0.0586074963,
0.0857664198,
-0.0245369785,
-0.0875270963,
-0.0502516069,
-0.0030193892,
-0.0387392491,
-0.0412059613,
-0.0103537319,
-0.0109541714,
-0.0364851318,
-0.0457558185,
-0.0770078003,
-0.0489158072,
0.0176250152,
0.021679014,
0.0363486335,
-0.0200855974,
0.0687374845,
0.005534017,
-0.0031891568,
-0.0027344974,
-0.0059949514,
0.0171249323,
-0.0598447174,
-0.0485840216,
-0.0066843848,
-0.0168173797,
-0.0025162089,
0.0426101014,
0.0122980829,
-0.0658643767,
0.0335964859,
0.0583851784,
0.0246691741,
0.0550252832,
0.0021935476,
-0.048544094,
-0.0170892626,
0.0042588916,
-0.0270194151,
0.0287705194,
-0.0170016196,
0.0086073494,
0.0169544686,
0.0305931773,
-0.0507855006,
0.0438657068,
-0.011618562,
0.0122953262,
-0.0813403726,
-0.0446661636,
0.0520260595,
0.001136744,
-0.0191189013,
-0.0440166146,
-0.0320025906,
0.005382502,
-0.032165911,
-0.0624565296,
-0.0325151011,
-0.0223949496,
-0.0004462688,
0.0235359557,
0.013530883,
0.046773795,
0.0411133692,
-0.0072060283,
0.0060897828,
-0.0052606673,
0.0008808213,
-0.0119132614,
0.0528381802,
0.0255840123,
0.0330887623,
0.016284382,
0.0384150073,
-0.0084706871,
0.0276060291,
0.0167404097,
0.0647725388,
0.0445068367,
-0.0039199255,
-0.0394538268,
0.0343517922,
-0.0572825409,
-0.0801151842,
0.0474930741,
0.0316885784,
0.0345454067,
0.0046894983,
0.0020114121,
-0.0808492303,
0.0209165197,
0.0049098274,
0.0546438992,
-0.0228805058,
-0.012237424,
0.0146153197,
0.0426338948,
-0.0039211693,
0.0284541938,
0.0538809188,
-0.0233223643,
0.0112297582,
-0.0391591117,
-0.0251204036,
-0.0275795124,
0.007172884,
0.0326570384,
0.0228402577,
-0.0346012972,
0.0046779648,
-0.0535219833,
-0.0195907783,
-0.028057998,
0.0239644945,
0.0008848368,
-0.0160880554,
0.062788628,
0.0300901681,
-0.0226638149,
-0.0441393666,
-0.020080775,
-0.031947013,
-0.0054063047,
-0.0443374924,
-0.0421722308,
-5.916011071e-33,
0.0096871229,
-0.056592714,
0.0457304567,
-0.0057080556,
-0.023996301,
-0.0458817817,
-0.0116133792,
0.0123022459,
-0.0098885577,
0.0238983147,
-0.0270957984,
0.0093978941,
0.0124574583,
-0.0389964692,
0.0297363997,
0.0039827563,
0.0122605721,
-0.0467997044,
-0.0116621563,
-0.0095783044,
0.0378233343,
-0.0079738218,
-0.0252356809,
-0.0552255772,
-0.0072843228,
-0.0071814344,
-0.0258356631,
0.0286868289,
0.008775142,
0.0183578525,
-0.0039383043,
0.0145366313,
0.0278141107,
0.0226583257,
-0.0022516446,
0.0839933529,
-0.0397868901,
-0.044258073,
0.0019889297,
-0.0038210277,
-0.0508047752,
-0.0361002572,
0.022068426,
-0.0152921453,
-0.0606122501,
0.0572818816,
0.0324458852,
0.0011457404,
-0.0190489218,
0.0480992161,
-0.0764369518,
-0.0085871201,
-0.0292735677,
-0.044650469,
0.0328826979,
0.0249411799,
-0.0047410144,
-0.0369642824,
-0.0729720145,
0.0214711726,
-0.0371037647,
-0.0278553106,
0.044627279,
0.0237539317,
0.0387809649,
0.034553539,
0.0333830453,
0.0779157728,
-0.0329426527,
-0.0314188711,
-0.0229178052,
0.0705350339,
-0.0358729362,
0.0264738072,
-0.0121915517,
-0.0456136018,
-0.0356868058,
0.0324260816,
0.0145182097,
0.0575627238,
-0.0043318528,
0.0372915715,
-0.0681435689,
-0.0340052582,
-0.0029909327,
0.0259612538,
-0.004704474,
-0.0319968835,
0.01954717,
0.0268456098,
0.0415597856,
-0.0142882485,
0.0244035218,
-0.0117059303,
0.0314962529,
0.0022769864,
-0.0194328856,
0.0278150402,
0.0026752725,
-0.0226476602,
-0.0908669755,
-0.0830161348,
0.000008989,
-0.0051726517,
0.0393462181,
0.0503003225,
0.0106081003,
0.0093141319,
0.0219475217,
-0.0236808565,
-0.0271778554,
0.0037496253,
0.0465421081,
-0.0766405314,
0.0365191251,
0.0290533025,
-0.0089279916,
0.0325306505,
0.0080844667,
-0.0714906231,
-0.0025146594,
0.0235949233,
0.0020281628,
-0.0192930456,
-0.0062340256,
-0.0008364266,
-0.0475889295,
0.0287978388,
0.040138524,
-0.0200834051,
-0.0215901025,
-0.0001729151,
2.914e-7,
-0.0262020659,
0.0428889915,
0.0077927001,
-0.0005819108,
0.0066012111,
0.0355615728,
-0.0055494588,
0.0392293595,
-0.0350587443,
-0.0092598656,
0.0748583227,
0.0422223285,
0.0088770054,
-0.0129019273,
-0.0507940575,
-0.023650974,
-0.0124545824,
-0.0228863712,
-0.0458674394,
0.002214063,
0.0645969883,
0.0141548542,
0.0122490628,
-0.0088642845,
0.008332652,
-0.0136575131,
0.0664235279,
-0.0650212988,
0.005799199,
0.0211762413,
-0.0054198862,
0.0089942068,
0.0118463244,
0.0585369654,
0.0054935371,
-0.0026345125,
-0.011902458,
0.0719465986,
-0.0617135987,
0.0097271781,
-0.0261979289,
-0.0101341195,
-0.002130525,
-0.03309232,
0.0138998227,
-0.0939035937,
-0.0228988156,
0.038925454,
-0.0032635797,
-0.0000291738,
-0.0441195592,
0.0113461511,
0.0173201524,
0.008017417,
0.0108142365,
0.0210891888,
0.0092089288,
-0.0485099778,
0.0238735639,
0.0439769998,
-0.0398904122,
-0.0322785601,
-0.0050074928,
-0.000249971,
0.028539069,
-0.0309820976,
0.0139791872,
2.161419115e-34,
-0.008114581,
-0.005643765,
0.0059273709,
0.0589445159,
0.0411783792,
0.0102254637,
-0.0273508616,
0.0561709702,
0.062823683,
-0.0562808141,
-0.0350448601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00408v1 | AdaSent: Efficient Domain-Adapted Sentence Embeddings for Few-Shot Classification | 2023-11-01T10:00:15 | 2023-11-01T10:00:15 | Yongxin Huang, Kexin Wang, Sourav Dutta, Raj Nath Patel, Goran Glavaš, Iryna Gurevych | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work has found that few-shot sentence classification based on
pre-trained Sentence Encoders (SEs) is efficient, robust, and effective. In
this work, we investigate strategies for domain-specialization in the context
of few-shot sentence classification with SEs. We first establish that
unsupervised Domain-Adaptive Pre-Training (DAPT) of a base Pre-trained Language
Model (PLM) (i.e., not an SE) substantially improves the accuracy of few-shot
sentence classification by up to 8.4 points. However, applying DAPT on SEs, on
the one hand, disrupts the effects of their (general-domain) Sentence Embedding
Pre-Training (SEPT). On the other hand, applying general-domain SEPT on top of
a domain-adapted base PLM (i.e., after DAPT) is effective but inefficient,
since the computationally expensive SEPT needs to be executed on top of a
DAPT-ed PLM of each domain. As a solution, we propose AdaSent, which decouples
SEPT from DAPT by training a SEPT adapter on the base PLM. The adapter can be
inserted into DAPT-ed PLMs from any domain. We demonstrate AdaSent's
effectiveness in extensive experiments on 17 different few-shot sentence
classification datasets. AdaSent matches or surpasses the performance of full
SEPT on DAPT-ed PLM, while substantially reducing the training costs. The code
for AdaSent is available. | [
-0.0005351302,
0.026497148,
-0.0070165824,
0.0304021556,
-0.0206647813,
0.0393103696,
0.0568571128,
-0.0321574099,
0.0067001628,
-0.1052907109,
-0.0361864269,
-0.0009987712,
-0.0209076237,
0.0071598161,
0.0082356958,
-0.0222491175,
0.0429338887,
0.0251353867,
0.0164326895,
0.0053886734,
0.0139988074,
-0.0040807035,
-0.0113684963,
0.0183915105,
0.0537845679,
0.0002280069,
-0.0168263353,
-0.0144377109,
0.0335453302,
-0.0337794758,
0.0478958599,
0.0432687923,
0.0735384673,
0.0079890154,
0.0000021549,
-0.0425586142,
0.0076589584,
-0.0367742553,
-0.0364030339,
0.0257671569,
0.0072551235,
-0.0217958726,
0.0440203547,
0.0123546477,
-0.0146782156,
-0.0897432491,
0.0127023114,
0.0246490315,
0.041402705,
0.0954115614,
-0.0245599579,
-0.0759387314,
0.0048583038,
-0.0284694061,
-0.0227917582,
-0.0331642739,
0.0174483061,
-0.0496200882,
-0.0089486539,
0.0219775755,
-0.0198980719,
0.0129825762,
-0.0016858825,
0.0349592827,
0.0250757616,
0.0207984485,
-0.0113060502,
-0.0113706831,
0.0064451029,
0.0520699397,
-0.0031545903,
-0.0394578278,
-0.0128031448,
-0.0318085328,
-0.0053985906,
-0.024671331,
-0.0224949867,
-0.0085905604,
0.0625208914,
0.0217346754,
-0.0005450565,
0.0553439781,
-0.0001124681,
0.0004898157,
-0.0241555218,
-0.0120854219,
0.0254547074,
-0.0365817882,
-0.0097125117,
0.0498326458,
-0.0272858944,
-0.0263176262,
-0.0138159953,
-0.0032516359,
0.0224709865,
-0.0140616056,
-0.0676627457,
-0.041896008,
-0.0130454935,
-0.0244139638,
0.079602614,
0.0229849834,
-0.0163483322,
0.0257852133,
-0.0342670567,
0.034545023,
0.0082540689,
0.0142273884,
-0.030926697,
0.0192957111,
-0.0605244264,
-0.0210374836,
-0.0512538925,
0.0648711324,
-0.0072037391,
-0.0346361883,
-0.0595668517,
0.016172735,
0.0198885426,
-0.0374356024,
-0.0129119474,
-0.0006860758,
0.0013874958,
-0.0038729783,
-0.0008152584,
0.0451297499,
-0.0442505106,
0.0520092584,
-0.0161772557,
-0.0277938806,
-0.0269682258,
0.0270710234,
0.0401940197,
-0.0179136414,
0.0169484615,
0.0375450514,
0.0075405557,
-0.0947997048,
-0.0376709625,
0.0026842896,
-0.0203765761,
-0.0537862703,
0.0044210013,
-0.0264668036,
0.0345911123,
0.0039944192,
-0.0008057465,
-0.0405085422,
-0.0005265509,
-0.0000864451,
-0.0157751273,
0.0670673251,
0.0125549557,
-0.0127097815,
-0.0057716253,
-0.0147638852,
0.0439552478,
0.0795694813,
0.0119190626,
0.0238676649,
0.0261428095,
0.0045894259,
0.0159590896,
0.0208041407,
0.0097242901,
-0.0229254514,
-0.0122857392,
0.0070917294,
-0.0197922084,
-0.0004923915,
0.021535499,
-0.0347915664,
-0.0303747244,
0.0373253189,
0.0269241259,
0.0338194892,
0.0216535721,
-0.0239557121,
0.0562730432,
0.0169214029,
-0.0114051402,
-0.0163781792,
-0.0330621451,
0.0003812558,
-0.0138585791,
-0.0080730962,
0.0032773928,
0.0050777378,
-0.0599680133,
-0.0135552278,
0.0211767871,
-0.0412096456,
-0.0120118754,
-0.013559537,
0.0532486923,
0.0030873478,
-0.0280834381,
0.0522754751,
0.0056863255,
-0.0343377776,
-0.0165711343,
-0.0023089561,
-0.0251907986,
0.0301975869,
0.0277902987,
-0.0459589809,
-0.029190585,
-0.0339115635,
0.0696261302,
0.0499136634,
0.0184217673,
0.0038813569,
0.0446325131,
-0.0534774959,
-0.0464403406,
-0.0671854317,
0.0311600156,
0.0133573292,
-0.0004215597,
0.0323505662,
0.027622465,
-0.016297942,
0.0416129753,
0.0259395819,
-0.0028266683,
-0.049026113,
0.0483851805,
0.0349887609,
0.0247948747,
0.0127944173,
-0.0153811388,
-0.0029114869,
0.0028336148,
-0.0646876991,
-0.0381662734,
0.0001677881,
-0.0449570231,
-0.0989616215,
-0.0025357869,
-0.008582687,
0.0012563191,
0.0359765403,
-0.0577395484,
-0.0211560372,
0.0127866287,
-0.0053149192,
0.00789796,
-0.0471127518,
0.0164402481,
-0.0090498179,
0.0390279368,
-0.0214599594,
0.0433845669,
0.0274566002,
-0.0173543561,
-0.0298350528,
-0.0096484711,
0.049201034,
0.0140080573,
-0.0335017033,
-0.044303529,
-0.0216361396,
0.0163153727,
0.0287879556,
0.0045386348,
-0.0018478645,
0.0243761055,
-0.0542036891,
0.0135162575,
-0.0238140225,
0.0329289846,
0.0037983155,
0.0211783983,
-0.0088620363,
-0.0162662566,
0.0025903652,
0.0293807108,
-0.0042286986,
0.0313663818,
0.0435896628,
-0.0106019098,
-0.0054120179,
-0.0007902307,
0.0214769542,
-0.0000143159,
0.064014174,
-0.0563026629,
-0.0197279882,
-0.0438081473,
0.0461324155,
0.0128867114,
-0.0184097495,
0.0263593812,
-0.0604723133,
-0.0219468344,
0.0018156331,
0.0051934263,
0.0367421433,
-0.0108144144,
0.0347917043,
0.0317859054,
0.0334374532,
-0.0208417401,
-0.0032516518,
-0.0208795201,
0.0233488511,
-0.0328168832,
0.066765666,
0.0145958327,
0.064559117,
-0.0022335548,
0.0050735157,
-0.0492979363,
0.0344275385,
0.014183213,
-0.005823466,
-0.0216914322,
-0.0041638939,
-0.0066514071,
0.0081497543,
0.0047081667,
-0.0064242003,
0.0434388742,
-0.0084020002,
-0.0102403248,
-0.0721223354,
-0.0359744616,
-0.0137962457,
0.0337616205,
0.0409201197,
0.0006100175,
0.0634827763,
-0.0063316743,
-0.0456710085,
0.0084995525,
0.0051725437,
0.0246257018,
0.0373909697,
0.0244964194,
0.0076900069,
-0.0412368514,
-0.0597022958,
-0.0395325907,
-0.0741961151,
-0.0512300879,
-0.0024684754,
-0.0497171842,
0.0381065682,
-0.052785974,
-0.0029071728,
-0.0104250032,
0.0425745994,
-0.0243807286,
0.003677493,
-0.0324311219,
0.0722601786,
0.038527526,
-0.0211054366,
-0.0501887314,
-0.0011173965,
0.0518384576,
0.0170799121,
-0.0411569737,
0.0178504717,
-0.0224655792,
-0.0129414424,
0.0229705907,
-0.0348259024,
-0.0235910397,
0.0128471451,
0.0491095446,
-0.0281087644,
-0.0262273103,
0.1396542788,
0.0275537092,
-0.018760208,
-0.0181339066,
0.0359605365,
0.0016781403,
0.0275958329,
0.0126321167,
-0.0905633345,
-0.0877383128,
-0.0183008667,
-0.0111956326,
-0.0048546777,
0.0167209357,
-0.0320492834,
-0.119734548,
-0.012426313,
0.0214272458,
-0.020832872,
0.0066298828,
0.0002561685,
-0.0248817634,
-0.0041546784,
-0.009142207,
-0.0487517416,
0.0000512213,
-0.0041740895,
-0.0020837134,
-0.0473943241,
-0.0989561751,
0.0066433987,
-0.0307088029,
0.0212922581,
0.0451160036,
0.0031821965,
-0.0161587447,
0.0182753466,
0.0396759659,
-0.0251079053,
0.0044495435,
0.0045373766,
0.062425714,
-0.0438345373,
0.0076872353,
0.0174022596,
-0.0036891561,
-0.0551185086,
-0.0401897803,
0.0174898785,
0.073423095,
-0.0305320248,
-0.0194946062,
-0.0267281421,
-0.0007523592,
-0.0398316085,
0.0645004436,
0.0406198688,
-0.0710185915,
-0.0373207964,
-0.010631294,
-0.0113483965,
-0.069645524,
-0.0276675001,
-0.0158434045,
0.0136778057,
-0.0170218498,
-0.0477074981,
-0.054685615,
0.0335762054,
0.024062939,
-0.0275373161,
-0.0162392352,
-0.0227840394,
0.0070508406,
-0.0435638167,
-0.0327081941,
-0.0354879424,
-0.0102536911,
-0.0407198593,
0.0088773584,
0.0670149848,
-0.0033753661,
-0.0155607192,
-0.0473161265,
-0.0670171678,
-0.0625482649,
-0.0138651188,
0.0377479494,
-0.0008938046,
0.0022385824,
-0.0068898788,
-0.0393859521,
0.1147161946,
0.0774597824,
-0.010951193,
0.025303103,
0.0809022412,
-0.0476889722,
-0.0052364077,
0.023373371,
-0.0268095303,
0.0579076111,
0.0338391848,
0.0014862594,
0.0110669499,
-0.0128166992,
-0.0092154536,
-0.00763707,
0.11146494,
-0.0250439774,
-0.0368986726,
-0.0177650247,
0.0264052916,
-0.0416371636,
0.0097744623,
-0.0451450385,
-0.0385661609,
-0.0060725175,
0.0082567902,
-0.0270632636,
0.029354427,
-0.0386492424,
0.0239700004,
-0.0101511711,
0.0180194862,
0.0436666496,
0.0199237131,
-0.0242840759,
0.0285643917,
-0.0249350425,
0.0046116468,
0.0121026058,
-0.0158290006,
-0.0659640953,
0.0386227109,
-0.0156952403,
0.0400601402,
-0.0366692767,
0.0636976883,
-0.0506300144,
0.062515676,
-0.0260824803,
-0.005931993,
0.0695055202,
-0.0249779001,
0.0057015303,
0.0109127648,
-0.0087292157,
-0.0285216235,
0.0680882037,
-0.0017554986,
-0.016181238,
0.029441379,
0.0130743394,
-0.0658567473,
0.0084628947,
0.0731633678,
0.0202320926,
0.0403524861,
0.0400538221,
0.0125498641,
-0.0305677205,
-0.0259938724,
0.0405856185,
0.0271876883,
-0.008280538,
0.0183295961,
-0.037733838,
-0.0353025645,
0.034749575,
-0.0599124543,
-0.0326197669,
0.0083801718,
0.0314466134,
-0.0096744671,
-0.0016259811,
-0.0092801144,
-0.0066876058,
-0.0117191812,
0.000145426,
-0.0083082207,
0.0134995785,
-5.964392215e-33,
-0.0327687152,
0.0360614285,
-0.0137727885,
-0.0267955456,
0.0114121595,
-0.0027994625,
0.0001739782,
-0.0032619999,
0.0096164858,
0.0080657508,
0.0186753999,
-0.0050282497,
0.0099573964,
0.0419136547,
0.0117006358,
-0.0149009144,
0.0761282891,
-0.0193116143,
-0.0192919169,
-0.0104447613,
0.0118392836,
0.0491599999,
0.0465200506,
-0.012323183,
-0.0519702695,
-0.0048225336,
0.0026345185,
0.004230177,
0.0800581798,
0.038071543,
-0.0149335861,
0.0554412231,
0.0327565782,
-0.0255385097,
-0.0214350075,
0.0317630172,
-0.0685363263,
-0.0620233454,
-0.0249416959,
0.0160555411,
0.0357756987,
-0.0380374976,
-0.0080674747,
-0.0069820727,
0.0050827051,
-0.0409137607,
0.0267104115,
-0.0256624613,
0.023022322,
-0.0242854562,
-0.0678451732,
-0.01091618,
0.0265203472,
-0.0063914284,
0.0366069674,
0.0459142774,
0.0043399949,
0.0520130321,
-0.0438555181,
0.018020086,
0.0022504574,
0.0315463208,
0.0043426994,
-0.0051078191,
-0.00715301,
0.0614237525,
0.0268018804,
-0.0244418122,
0.0037348,
0.0332617201,
0.0325083919,
0.0067033721,
0.0140437502,
0.105006732,
0.06578435,
-0.0175084025,
-0.113028653,
0.014750802,
0.0063205506,
-0.0035220096,
0.0352685899,
0.0229115207,
-0.0116358176,
-0.0373392627,
0.0187950227,
0.0055322768,
-0.0097472267,
-0.0508771688,
0.0523409285,
0.0198083911,
0.0093720453,
-0.0013588254,
0.0626247004,
-0.0719462112,
-0.0044242875,
0.0278156903,
-0.0281389654,
0.0088502523,
0.0184219889,
0.0018897803,
-0.0472095869,
-0.0334589705,
0.0370852426,
0.0035407171,
0.0124253752,
-0.0117176371,
0.081296131,
0.0273517221,
-0.0695419237,
-0.0158360936,
0.0184014831,
-0.0322145969,
0.0011126149,
0.0487958528,
-0.0179896764,
0.055951871,
-0.0150853107,
0.0802918151,
0.0098418221,
-0.0562947914,
0.0059591318,
-0.0046245563,
0.0260411799,
0.0539285019,
-0.0117704635,
-0.0088912817,
-0.0246803854,
0.0023677454,
-0.0019206509,
-0.0716723204,
-0.0129559608,
-0.0507251471,
2.77e-7,
0.0287625547,
0.0424531214,
-0.0196560714,
-0.0189038869,
0.0281134788,
0.0604504161,
-0.016875172,
0.0638511628,
-0.0420506038,
0.030001346,
0.0486432761,
0.0161346495,
0.0440492854,
0.0092383437,
-0.1078441963,
0.0429653823,
-0.0137430867,
0.0032305364,
-0.0476371795,
-0.0033324142,
0.0777276978,
0.107731387,
0.0226650909,
0.0154154599,
-0.0151392883,
-0.039491158,
0.0709892139,
0.0088639939,
-0.0268184301,
-0.0059398669,
-0.0571209453,
0.0482203886,
-0.0206676982,
0.0012093048,
-0.0465156101,
0.0522900335,
-0.0053454163,
0.0695241243,
-0.0198817495,
-0.0127299456,
-0.0099158678,
0.0058825752,
-0.0156334843,
0.0172898993,
0.0895520449,
-0.1305044293,
-0.0436474346,
0.0042353855,
-0.0348872691,
-0.010723399,
0.0331664383,
0.0132553913,
-0.017486088,
-0.0219094846,
0.0474570543,
-0.0066512078,
-0.0314539559,
-0.1101785749,
0.0061234524,
0.0399650633,
-0.0052082455,
0.0260835085,
-0.0172260497,
-0.0109677091,
0.0888158232,
-0.0580808148,
0.0143468473,
2.714012581e-34,
0.0236717965,
0.0070840679,
0.0134573756,
0.0080733392,
-0.0150731429,
-0.0311198384,
-0.0048321849,
-0.019583039,
0.0480017737,
-0.0507882014,
0.0262388997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00399v1 | Enhanced Knowledge Injection for Radiology Report Generation | 2023-11-01T09:50:55 | 2023-11-01T09:50:55 | Qingqiu Li, Jilan Xu, Runtian Yuan, Mohan Chen, Yuejie Zhang, Rui Feng, Xiaobo Zhang, Shang Gao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Automatic generation of radiology reports holds crucial clinical value, as it
can alleviate substantial workload on radiologists and remind less experienced
ones of potential anomalies. Despite the remarkable performance of various
image captioning methods in the natural image field, generating accurate
reports for medical images still faces challenges, i.e., disparities in visual
and textual data, and lack of accurate domain knowledge. To address these
issues, we propose an enhanced knowledge injection framework, which utilizes
two branches to extract different types of knowledge. The Weighted Concept
Knowledge (WCK) branch is responsible for introducing clinical medical concepts
weighted by TF-IDF scores. The Multimodal Retrieval Knowledge (MRK) branch
extracts triplets from similar reports, emphasizing crucial clinical
information related to entity positions and existence. By integrating this
finer-grained and well-structured knowledge with the current image, we are able
to leverage the multi-source knowledge gain to ultimately facilitate more
accurate report generation. Extensive experiments have been conducted on two
public benchmarks, demonstrating that our method achieves superior performance
over other state-of-the-art methods. Ablation studies further validate the
effectiveness of two extracted knowledge sources. | [
0.0604571663,
0.0525602661,
0.0254919082,
0.0032911967,
0.0041689663,
0.0185823031,
-0.0340329185,
0.0525225103,
-0.0278594121,
-0.0607305653,
-0.0051658018,
-0.0234371144,
0.0048289592,
0.056333106,
0.0287117809,
-0.0923063606,
0.0058432738,
0.0263819676,
-0.0099498155,
0.0203415062,
0.0114464303,
0.0008093988,
-0.0210424997,
0.0320788659,
-0.0528051332,
0.0251222514,
0.0102525745,
0.0209784824,
0.031617634,
-0.0322014429,
-0.0387639515,
0.0497944988,
0.0196037982,
0.0043109856,
0.0000019762,
-0.0298652258,
-0.0324626677,
0.0325997584,
0.0239719935,
-0.0526007153,
0.0689964592,
-0.0904490873,
0.018892277,
-0.0318183005,
-0.0142073054,
-0.0303236134,
0.0504335165,
0.0417614952,
0.0882216915,
0.0409566946,
-0.0320402347,
0.0163776632,
-0.0001323801,
0.0079124458,
0.0231453683,
-0.0236900374,
0.0074048294,
0.0657777265,
-0.017123539,
0.0002969912,
0.0053830994,
0.0472001284,
-0.0379630066,
-0.0152653204,
0.0291214921,
0.065433301,
-0.035139814,
-0.0433922261,
-0.0112555567,
0.069546558,
0.0232244283,
0.0395242572,
0.0004326022,
0.003723785,
-0.0248179734,
0.0218094271,
-0.0546801798,
-0.001671469,
-0.0285655651,
-0.0277367141,
-0.0698769838,
0.0256682001,
-0.0154126482,
-0.0009766883,
-0.0207626987,
-0.048223339,
0.0111450134,
0.0114017203,
0.0189158525,
0.010446772,
-0.0473689511,
-0.0290270783,
0.0135086803,
0.0349398963,
-0.0008725161,
0.0287733898,
-0.0251113214,
-0.0573734939,
0.0774209499,
-0.0194528308,
-0.011530376,
0.0036290891,
-0.0591709763,
0.0865116194,
-0.0252627973,
0.0144606605,
-0.0134792784,
0.0366353579,
-0.0188579299,
0.0084245084,
-0.0877039507,
-0.0242755041,
-0.0063522886,
0.0210456252,
0.0124180624,
-0.0352883972,
-0.0291796699,
-0.0020125555,
-0.0279627014,
0.0365741327,
0.0117428582,
0.054174453,
-0.0694904476,
0.0226232558,
-0.0433337651,
0.0397082232,
0.0186525285,
-0.0261555351,
-0.0135924891,
-0.0052113817,
0.0209612884,
0.0473018065,
0.0143522685,
0.0299315043,
-0.0164590944,
0.0211448278,
-0.0363652632,
-0.0121691879,
0.0023600124,
-0.0912320018,
-0.0406256765,
-0.0116658974,
0.0323829539,
-0.0352492295,
0.0403782837,
0.0134260915,
-0.0137034021,
-0.0264158249,
0.0142265754,
0.0267280508,
-0.044366356,
0.0879872814,
-0.0834920034,
-0.0149817001,
0.0391386859,
0.0537062548,
-0.0240237936,
0.0301526394,
-0.0166620649,
-0.0082199257,
-0.0055700019,
0.0162082575,
-0.0112170717,
-0.0207416564,
0.0191519037,
-0.0369039252,
-0.0108715743,
0.0138508864,
-0.0211674422,
0.0574457645,
0.0409889221,
0.0285764262,
-0.0156999305,
0.046540983,
0.0372594297,
0.0323011018,
0.008283291,
-0.002644554,
0.0434606746,
-0.0182696246,
-0.0239313897,
0.0105548771,
-0.0286253188,
0.0514868945,
0.0396950245,
0.0304467026,
0.0095956931,
0.0372369401,
-0.0016353243,
-0.0175932813,
-0.0199881457,
-0.0112695219,
-0.0226284936,
-0.0211854745,
0.0423998609,
0.022376949,
-0.0250310078,
0.0383921452,
0.039355468,
-0.0042732088,
-0.0157017782,
-0.0209157355,
-0.0375486054,
0.0679382384,
0.0679705068,
-0.0440268964,
-0.0474028289,
0.0173878595,
0.0428643301,
0.0541214906,
0.0232415609,
-0.00261744,
-0.0003064436,
-0.0384200588,
-0.0558864214,
0.0114484821,
-0.008038749,
0.0185331888,
0.0111314906,
0.037200395,
0.0080329375,
-0.0280588623,
-0.0134706991,
0.0353483073,
0.031557329,
-0.0146735907,
-0.0241966583,
0.0200304519,
-0.0269267205,
0.0147386789,
-0.0379063822,
0.023996124,
0.0113090146,
0.0171408374,
-0.0558624528,
0.0197760072,
-0.0391414054,
-0.0253106114,
0.0110976817,
-0.0759611279,
0.0015207672,
-0.0490645021,
-0.0162065942,
-0.0200720485,
-0.0176378824,
-0.0067037046,
0.0170592926,
-0.0329634733,
-0.008329276,
0.066275619,
-0.0123615116,
-0.0237718802,
0.0702805147,
-0.0001880885,
0.0019965197,
0.0190598592,
-0.0564397871,
0.0072582057,
0.0170607232,
-0.0284056328,
-0.0035361673,
-0.0023423142,
0.0343462676,
-0.0191159043,
0.0266045984,
-0.0308401901,
-0.0029924989,
-0.0921177641,
-0.0184986405,
0.0298383143,
-0.036030896,
0.0132708643,
0.0059210728,
0.0296629351,
-0.0446738526,
-0.0438348837,
-0.0153714363,
0.0222362112,
0.026031943,
0.0698215514,
0.0537847914,
0.0300781615,
-0.0063442066,
0.0144325113,
-0.0044092881,
0.0397705026,
0.0441305637,
-0.0241411347,
-0.0066390308,
0.0375094488,
-0.0827518255,
-0.0027210335,
0.0036005022,
-0.0129550463,
0.0245145559,
-0.0091092205,
-0.0268661715,
0.0257786214,
-0.0066609918,
0.0180536974,
0.0275427271,
-0.0225407686,
-0.0176519603,
0.0038672409,
-0.0183342006,
-0.0298914742,
0.0618630759,
-0.0323146656,
0.000583325,
0.015662387,
0.0233896542,
0.0310187526,
-0.0243536737,
0.0043819537,
-0.0078834686,
-0.0156968217,
-0.0588528216,
0.0065387473,
-0.0018828829,
0.0308542438,
-0.026404053,
-0.021771865,
0.0877849013,
-0.0189563688,
0.0024670097,
-0.0140840458,
0.0109336227,
-0.0257423017,
0.0448041558,
-0.0095545501,
0.0578689203,
0.0553716943,
0.003324837,
-0.0284417383,
0.026088668,
0.0697622225,
-0.0514847301,
0.0483058877,
-0.0143696032,
0.0059688841,
-0.0264586359,
-0.0326678082,
-0.0311384536,
0.0083671436,
0.0360854901,
-0.0135502294,
0.0039368956,
-0.0108499983,
-0.0363564789,
0.0488329455,
0.0476458482,
0.0165134501,
0.023492001,
-0.0494767316,
-0.007717194,
0.0600983463,
0.0274100993,
0.0160961002,
-0.0648847297,
0.0012275684,
-0.0015831366,
0.0668715835,
-0.0253724642,
0.0060107624,
-0.0158456936,
0.023459455,
-0.0523923337,
0.0130256368,
-0.0031006762,
0.0024675173,
0.0195209011,
-0.0264976751,
0.0016964967,
0.0558200069,
0.0362644047,
-0.0402992293,
-0.0339807086,
0.0226314403,
-0.0173763428,
0.0298472364,
0.0097948331,
-0.0613717102,
-0.0159443021,
-0.0222679544,
0.0297058392,
-0.0073460811,
-0.0333063565,
-0.0200537015,
-0.0456192568,
0.0506123193,
-0.0098045096,
-0.0337480307,
-0.0677160397,
-0.0250851661,
-0.0062034726,
0.027140541,
-0.0597050786,
-0.0064628376,
0.0066168634,
-0.0017822114,
0.0129168006,
-0.0189488716,
-0.0640977174,
-0.0108142132,
-0.0444655083,
-0.0443635732,
0.0416345671,
0.0322308652,
0.0011427214,
-0.0103194984,
-0.0898091123,
0.0206989963,
0.0141942482,
0.0018966896,
0.1261339337,
-0.0151099246,
-0.021222353,
-0.0394494385,
-0.0000553381,
-0.0087980321,
-0.0055309031,
-0.0393550694,
0.0495027304,
-0.0209798608,
0.012606143,
-0.0554352328,
0.0424649231,
0.0376001634,
0.0330783352,
-0.0008366194,
0.0329054482,
0.0208408181,
0.0056971791,
0.0784082785,
-0.0461783037,
-0.0191657152,
0.0539198034,
-0.0510600246,
-0.0469760597,
-0.0831143335,
-0.004483249,
0.0504308753,
0.0485226586,
0.0156700555,
0.0063261464,
-0.0256231539,
0.0017337139,
-0.0932130516,
0.0354242474,
0.0123687293,
-0.0254837964,
0.0219845194,
-0.0380837247,
0.0493055619,
-0.0063314643,
-0.0263853837,
0.033017084,
-0.0134104565,
0.0075343121,
-0.0528847016,
0.0417287834,
0.0223347098,
-0.0097206831,
0.0233379938,
0.0311219841,
0.0789803192,
0.0765888318,
-0.0206827857,
-0.0237158034,
-0.0165055674,
-0.0335330144,
-0.0347140506,
-0.0035628825,
-0.0421965346,
-0.0037085055,
-0.0198582839,
0.0219672881,
-0.0205400083,
-0.0230908897,
0.0307737943,
0.0322459489,
0.0298486687,
-0.0523395054,
-0.0016854926,
-0.0092613902,
-0.0258836858,
-0.017356731,
-0.0407234281,
-0.03952251,
0.0227564462,
-0.0046732374,
0.0102306139,
0.0125769041,
0.0343883522,
0.0047282423,
0.0035503877,
0.0186862499,
-0.0191853289,
0.0606316738,
-0.0232838765,
0.0188686475,
-0.0033526034,
-0.0138610629,
-0.0291634519,
-0.0040170145,
0.011082273,
-0.0277703255,
0.0622306019,
0.0309385806,
0.0214988235,
-0.0188737381,
0.0270145647,
-0.013488085,
-0.0219975989,
-0.0423619337,
0.0041316627,
0.0460552797,
0.0198271554,
0.0158284232,
-0.0484977029,
-0.0125812665,
0.013812935,
0.0397008955,
-0.0113951769,
0.0040695672,
0.0584102273,
0.004345017,
0.0451237224,
-0.0015044973,
0.0940051451,
-0.022431545,
0.036962159,
-0.0333713666,
-0.0904127732,
-0.0610645153,
-0.0005575684,
0.0565137081,
-0.012085069,
-0.0248429701,
0.0016350999,
-0.0744502097,
-0.0511639379,
0.0373845808,
-0.0160116367,
-0.0391809307,
0.0218556132,
0.0653823391,
0.0705088675,
0.0385145023,
-0.0195725448,
-0.0187006332,
0.0107000703,
-0.0623857714,
0.0087098675,
0.0509015284,
-6.076423071e-33,
-0.0380326174,
-0.0654495955,
0.0371900462,
-0.0185451023,
0.0093034217,
0.0494290106,
-0.0222661085,
-0.0057394039,
0.0134669282,
0.0235236231,
0.0062567736,
-0.0667102188,
0.0142757967,
0.0180323347,
-0.001948006,
0.0245285407,
0.0003239166,
-0.0127105815,
-0.0216627959,
0.014517514,
0.0108654611,
0.0399768129,
0.0375349484,
-0.0520634279,
-0.0101161832,
0.0408241637,
0.0000546593,
-0.0310276598,
0.060864035,
0.038670674,
-0.0466016419,
0.0249097794,
0.0224695485,
-0.0305727925,
-0.0144040277,
-0.0067722029,
-0.0760414004,
-0.0257555526,
0.0161044709,
-0.017781131,
-0.044300057,
0.0253312346,
0.0336465128,
-0.0590569153,
0.0537826307,
-0.0484125093,
0.0544926785,
-0.0050148666,
-0.0182951428,
-0.0525036827,
-0.0490836129,
0.0445230268,
-0.0046508471,
-0.0332639404,
-0.001260732,
-0.0101393536,
0.0192440264,
0.02956108,
-0.0483538434,
0.012085177,
0.0012931317,
0.0311243571,
0.0418177545,
-0.0047139861,
-0.0282924008,
0.0688623041,
0.0097542917,
-0.0318532921,
-0.0173021276,
0.0193655733,
-0.0162575357,
0.0814816877,
0.0010374904,
0.0729304552,
0.0412173979,
-0.0060844012,
-0.0256625339,
0.0575413555,
-0.1058859378,
0.059209235,
-0.0110181803,
-0.0185917113,
-0.0449758358,
0.0129875178,
0.0143086528,
-0.0213470496,
-0.0455776341,
-0.051577501,
0.0386781916,
0.0274981242,
-0.0376252271,
0.0536226407,
0.0227701962,
0.0326819494,
0.0393237993,
-0.0350820869,
0.0252649169,
0.0565560572,
-0.0637395754,
-0.0347255208,
-0.0133912098,
-0.0359804854,
0.0648906752,
0.0288360268,
0.0285389889,
0.037039388,
0.0472670607,
0.0091520678,
-0.040707361,
-0.0082804691,
-0.0078147631,
-0.0297089089,
-0.0514744371,
0.0063808812,
0.0115986969,
0.0083829416,
-0.0463648811,
-0.0353163816,
0.0154699748,
0.0254309233,
-0.0414650217,
-0.0756845102,
0.012952189,
0.0147242015,
-0.0266060978,
-0.0027504666,
-0.0238397792,
-0.0722145215,
0.0234820377,
-0.0231128205,
-0.0197257306,
0.0109555237,
2.773e-7,
0.0676920116,
0.0304054599,
0.0124995206,
0.0216575731,
0.0026778278,
0.0168277416,
-0.0404674411,
0.0098148603,
-0.0102528129,
-0.0637526885,
0.0624429211,
0.0224937815,
-0.0109425746,
0.03377489,
-0.0808630958,
-0.0797782391,
-0.0048120082,
-0.0608682781,
-0.0200712774,
-0.0573891513,
0.0821667388,
0.016262969,
-0.0511026457,
-0.0638444722,
0.0014119404,
-0.0803592503,
0.0794478133,
0.0131628551,
0.0116612241,
-0.0051558786,
0.0421203859,
0.0298386645,
-0.0107482411,
0.0750796869,
-0.0131493015,
-0.063953802,
0.0512883253,
0.0251248684,
-0.0433916971,
0.0081102885,
-0.0097318692,
0.0223540664,
0.0166157577,
-0.0266113225,
0.0386843942,
-0.0452674627,
0.0006499465,
0.0100856172,
-0.0374124534,
0.0031758961,
0.0317361616,
-0.0496189184,
-0.0725172237,
0.0537816361,
-0.0018262014,
0.0370147899,
-0.0461066216,
-0.0719188675,
-0.0016798322,
0.0288189538,
0.0012398625,
-0.0460036173,
0.0289637391,
-0.0662185252,
0.0140139144,
-0.0531710014,
-0.0197255723,
2.573949674e-34,
0.0220223814,
0.0176608134,
0.0195644349,
-0.0023823569,
0.0365775637,
-0.0114616379,
-0.0352565721,
-0.0193130542,
-0.002539953,
-0.0141970925,
-0.004311732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00367v1 | Prompt-based Logical Semantics Enhancement for Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition | 2023-11-01T08:38:08 | 2023-11-01T08:38:08 | Chenxu Wang, Ping Jian, Mu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition (IDRR), which infers discourse
relations without the help of explicit connectives, is still a crucial and
challenging task for discourse parsing. Recent works tend to exploit the
hierarchical structure information from the annotated senses, which demonstrate
enhanced discourse relation representations can be obtained by integrating
sense hierarchy. Nevertheless, the performance and robustness for IDRR are
significantly constrained by the availability of annotated data. Fortunately,
there is a wealth of unannotated utterances with explicit connectives, that can
be utilized to acquire enriched discourse relation features. In light of such
motivation, we propose a Prompt-based Logical Semantics Enhancement (PLSE)
method for IDRR. Essentially, our method seamlessly injects knowledge relevant
to discourse relation into pre-trained language models through prompt-based
connective prediction. Furthermore, considering the prompt-based connective
prediction exhibits local dependencies due to the deficiency of masked language
model (MLM) in capturing global semantics, we design a novel self-supervised
learning objective based on mutual information maximization to derive enhanced
representations of logical semantics for IDRR. Experimental results on PDTB 2.0
and CoNLL16 datasets demonstrate that our method achieves outstanding and
consistent performance against the current state-of-the-art models. | [
0.0023051915,
0.0605409779,
0.0137138674,
0.0637656525,
-0.0365432613,
0.0019186236,
0.0134947971,
-0.0032297713,
0.0722410604,
-0.0801917464,
-0.0523427315,
0.0436781086,
-0.0100288242,
0.0233301483,
-0.0298056435,
-0.0120173255,
0.0763845891,
-0.032625746,
0.0288644601,
-0.0129578477,
-0.0075448076,
0.020769421,
-0.0253232829,
-0.0274714977,
-0.0343942828,
-0.0468314253,
-0.0063870018,
-0.0087553654,
0.0200489797,
-0.0667109415,
0.0383775793,
0.070109427,
0.0068066679,
0.0318051614,
0.000002186,
-0.0431036912,
-0.0325907692,
-0.030982811,
-0.0215937234,
-0.0088941129,
-0.0064785648,
-0.0304572117,
0.0275969971,
-0.0326591916,
-0.0532098264,
-0.0072107832,
0.0031451874,
0.1007374823,
0.0470235944,
0.0165963173,
-0.0238628481,
-0.0205285307,
0.0230445098,
0.017444592,
-0.0490975715,
-0.0336783901,
0.0014541681,
0.0268889256,
-0.0812236071,
0.0277743489,
0.0024193621,
0.0361111723,
-0.0046120672,
-0.0390772894,
0.0177357495,
0.0580400527,
0.0148463696,
-0.0217267945,
-0.0430754237,
0.0664794743,
0.0774220005,
-0.0223920662,
-0.0006196071,
-0.0172082651,
-0.0265403762,
-0.0050409711,
0.0121905394,
0.0159586128,
-0.0285050422,
0.0296597965,
0.0553476922,
0.0434273854,
-0.0032914639,
0.0212237556,
0.0111446436,
0.1002835557,
-0.0186401792,
-0.0091768019,
0.0295625161,
-0.0142364381,
-0.0346322283,
-0.0216060113,
0.0058385031,
0.0096646911,
-0.0191215817,
0.004571131,
-0.0419787504,
-0.0381071791,
0.0123974578,
-0.0763688311,
0.0594760664,
0.050395757,
-0.0221981443,
0.0456791408,
-0.036704585,
0.0180818345,
-0.0126022985,
-0.0089987647,
-0.0137619348,
0.0022357728,
-0.0237266496,
-0.0389507413,
-0.0379932337,
0.0789078772,
-0.0939119011,
-0.0087890616,
-0.02976368,
0.024847893,
-0.0237764046,
-0.0110103833,
0.0072935582,
0.0238848794,
-0.0505414009,
0.0137362964,
-0.0386821106,
0.0071494444,
-0.0046164715,
0.0462009534,
-0.0406796001,
-0.0298650227,
-0.0249351673,
0.009443461,
0.0384484679,
-0.0070919632,
-0.0248439983,
0.0621258169,
-0.038955763,
-0.0057863742,
-0.0138657652,
-0.0506829731,
0.0069773835,
0.023615934,
-0.0160869788,
-0.0251711514,
0.0033290714,
-0.0216687582,
-0.0061807609,
-0.0459499992,
0.0333303064,
0.0044017569,
0.006433541,
0.089645721,
-0.0162963662,
-0.0259866491,
0.0518295318,
-0.0003241455,
0.0235790424,
0.048925411,
0.0277803466,
-0.0120305391,
0.0428650938,
0.0280055497,
-0.0728704631,
-0.0097805653,
0.0325635448,
-0.0078044585,
-0.0087002041,
0.0447529815,
0.0028393196,
-0.0060955761,
0.0448641665,
0.047994446,
-0.0026447794,
-0.0519657955,
0.0242191441,
0.0275826622,
-0.0356752537,
-0.0200225227,
0.0487962775,
0.0499019958,
0.0234954506,
0.0239002425,
-0.0370271988,
-0.02419498,
-0.0279690772,
-0.0344644375,
0.0210670345,
-0.0246533137,
0.0007234998,
-0.0448390096,
0.0395006798,
-0.0265688691,
0.027768271,
-0.0054558115,
0.0388208814,
0.0313831829,
-0.0482840315,
0.04915075,
0.0697103739,
-0.0183508415,
-0.0273919366,
-0.0188351572,
0.0312247034,
-0.0179732982,
-0.0205073878,
-0.0535060912,
-0.0170775857,
-0.0191371664,
0.0486566164,
0.0578690022,
-0.0011508523,
-0.0352720693,
0.025524199,
0.001340706,
-0.0191195402,
0.0046584699,
0.0192337874,
0.0333667137,
-0.0034019744,
-0.0117595578,
0.017526228,
0.0332268849,
0.0154943932,
0.0180412307,
-0.0420014411,
-0.0433293059,
0.0602815896,
-0.0124756647,
0.0728458092,
0.0506569408,
0.000674467,
-0.0103967143,
0.0314518064,
-0.045616243,
-0.0270922463,
0.0104965772,
-0.0886293426,
-0.0458794422,
0.0256495606,
-0.0101163564,
-0.0448041931,
-0.0176140647,
-0.0397684649,
-0.0349802449,
0.0147658307,
-0.0097131971,
0.0320689604,
-0.0698747337,
-0.0438177139,
0.0255582575,
-0.001778782,
-0.0217685755,
0.0771685764,
-0.0068925889,
-0.0034623716,
0.0365175642,
-0.0079741627,
0.0438371673,
-0.0197309423,
0.026981974,
-0.016661223,
-0.0124442549,
-0.0273886304,
0.0151223112,
0.0089974999,
-0.0544877946,
0.001495213,
-0.1417025924,
-0.0144033171,
0.0173506252,
0.0403855816,
0.0192826092,
0.0232360419,
-0.0000660039,
-0.0433046594,
0.0200156141,
-0.0393214263,
-0.0135314614,
-0.0123004364,
0.0488596,
0.0076555652,
0.0206527803,
-0.0224325806,
0.0121199759,
-0.0612297431,
0.0239085574,
0.023226833,
-0.0358837731,
0.0075274068,
-0.010269016,
-0.0078431247,
0.0513193682,
-0.0121804224,
-0.0318428762,
-0.0125148678,
0.0096180812,
0.0296482518,
0.0389073566,
0.0259706602,
0.032490965,
0.0122680441,
-0.0514535978,
-0.0614476018,
0.0450290069,
-0.0104847569,
0.0365951322,
-0.0253363494,
0.0011452589,
-0.033238288,
0.0901618972,
0.0435797833,
0.0134331705,
-0.0091048321,
0.0430583134,
-0.0316707864,
-0.0616990924,
-0.0362509266,
-0.0356649086,
-0.0162454341,
0.0224096011,
-0.0174854621,
-0.0186055899,
0.0713989958,
-0.0455886424,
0.0114703123,
-0.0341828391,
-0.0348616168,
-0.0477116071,
0.0651228279,
-0.0137478206,
-0.0231622774,
0.0478651337,
-0.0679941699,
-0.0062385239,
-0.0249271989,
0.0368788242,
-0.0035552564,
0.0248484779,
-0.0384327359,
0.0282215998,
-0.00289963,
-0.0475877151,
-0.0613927059,
-0.1037791818,
-0.0104847299,
0.0128075685,
-0.0543266796,
0.0166005436,
0.0602329783,
0.0073774648,
-0.0048632803,
0.0331416279,
-0.0028549621,
-0.0000111162,
-0.0593732931,
0.0536958128,
0.0128759332,
0.0221322719,
-0.0458468646,
0.0257740691,
0.0349738896,
0.0135031454,
-0.0599911399,
-0.0247857571,
-0.0333848596,
0.0265174359,
-0.0089996876,
-0.0156567469,
-0.0304661039,
-0.0325958841,
0.0428484455,
-0.0399725102,
0.0084880674,
0.1487885565,
0.0159863718,
-0.003361024,
0.0030648727,
-0.0223002918,
-0.0090244263,
0.0125663355,
-0.0073896162,
-0.064835377,
-0.0305449944,
-0.0168016814,
-0.0209283158,
-0.0445742384,
-0.0739279538,
0.0288612824,
-0.0828609616,
0.0001183496,
-0.0217873566,
0.0099459887,
-0.0025473626,
-0.0477239303,
0.0144135533,
0.0029940575,
0.0182325039,
-0.045475252,
-0.0265433881,
0.0077725514,
0.0050017517,
-0.0037042734,
-0.0115026254,
0.0189809557,
0.0159636419,
0.0070318109,
0.0168959498,
0.0508999676,
-0.0117745223,
0.0302589983,
0.0580112226,
-0.0547985062,
-0.0262380522,
-0.0523337983,
0.0162259322,
-0.0122345565,
0.0095185386,
0.003172986,
0.0392058715,
-0.0179295205,
-0.0208650678,
0.0160730705,
0.0212863572,
-0.0571146458,
0.0270869154,
-0.0182589311,
0.0198408216,
0.0249181837,
0.0593269579,
0.0144948578,
0.0190265253,
-0.0151860425,
-0.0163938012,
0.0369932987,
-0.0066631525,
0.001752249,
-0.0003415534,
0.0251846015,
-0.0170924887,
-0.0405417457,
-0.0643014386,
-0.0013158823,
-0.0168548301,
-0.004269721,
0.0195623767,
0.0242086817,
0.0040022493,
-0.0590720251,
0.0245338269,
-0.0129906386,
-0.0285258908,
-0.0143039543,
-0.0158664994,
0.0507306643,
-0.0230320748,
-0.0623906329,
0.0216971878,
-0.0127235986,
-0.027717324,
-0.0183515083,
0.0421123691,
0.0038994148,
0.0894497782,
-0.0505947843,
0.02222169,
0.0692894161,
0.0656625107,
-0.0476789288,
0.0307897292,
0.0487892069,
0.033935871,
0.0069414037,
0.0435083956,
0.0032076661,
0.0412057117,
-0.0168889686,
0.0148921171,
-0.0106344866,
-0.0668305978,
0.0311392769,
0.01273512,
0.0744794011,
0.0115706604,
0.0182195827,
-0.046323888,
0.0265122466,
-0.0641561672,
-0.0435974486,
-0.0409735851,
0.0435233153,
0.003665346,
-0.0170274731,
-0.0308461078,
-0.0207691602,
-0.0146483183,
0.0544782244,
-0.0293078311,
0.0394941308,
0.0633086413,
0.0214756876,
-0.0190414079,
-0.037490204,
-0.0339392163,
0.0035631382,
0.0106762024,
0.0170678291,
-0.0186759885,
0.0445411801,
0.0223346688,
-0.0017013246,
-0.0283290911,
0.0084047578,
-0.037364088,
0.0559745915,
-0.0289724115,
-0.0171096139,
0.0362305082,
-0.0214750208,
0.0276361443,
-0.0053205392,
0.0086613623,
0.0038515222,
0.0761539862,
0.0205964763,
-0.0336075313,
0.0422806405,
0.0114022978,
-0.0355604291,
0.0379268266,
0.0513239354,
-0.0427617729,
0.0383096039,
0.052217301,
0.0089204181,
-0.0621995963,
-0.0370516591,
-0.0002027901,
0.0444755778,
0.0009871551,
0.0544060543,
-0.0052130288,
-0.0281695724,
0.0757272542,
-0.0274902675,
-0.0218765307,
0.0118081216,
0.0310130715,
0.0387009159,
0.0196687076,
-0.0617436022,
-0.0517562926,
0.0082419785,
-0.0219661761,
-0.0233759601,
-0.0789070576,
-6.60363192e-33,
-0.0885343552,
-0.0456470586,
-0.008491884,
0.0303775128,
-0.0182618331,
0.0670861751,
-0.0761244521,
-0.0265476201,
0.0164033063,
0.0547145158,
-0.0007512621,
0.0268638805,
0.0247458573,
0.0273381732,
0.024707092,
-0.0160629544,
0.0609948523,
-0.0158266574,
0.0024501102,
0.0116758188,
0.0454478711,
0.0179072134,
0.0557674356,
-0.070408605,
0.0222908407,
0.0201204773,
-0.0079423888,
0.0612027198,
0.005757038,
0.05312353,
-0.0457277745,
0.0263290722,
0.0184178837,
0.0367859825,
0.0072828643,
0.0412347652,
-0.1564502567,
-0.0350073166,
0.0192604698,
-0.0168636236,
-0.0437913015,
-0.0298488438,
0.0074674268,
0.00093307,
0.0137784332,
-0.0174761303,
0.0381980054,
-0.0029229731,
0.0300617218,
-0.0304078683,
-0.0396568142,
0.039709121,
-0.0065984949,
0.0151916584,
0.0438283309,
0.0223992188,
0.0423859954,
-0.0259472933,
-0.0464710928,
-0.0045337132,
-0.0436747111,
0.0201341901,
0.0254725162,
-0.0025027213,
0.00277801,
0.0518514141,
-0.0048507359,
-0.0397155136,
-0.0300947744,
0.0254269857,
-0.0050449362,
-0.0007929729,
-0.0482607558,
0.013217181,
-0.0152227497,
0.0364864282,
-0.0745861679,
-0.0062113898,
0.0427807085,
0.0186236799,
0.0014653647,
-0.0116470903,
-0.0177536067,
-0.0069762445,
-0.0468597263,
-0.0176668912,
-0.0064860457,
-0.0093194088,
0.0079748677,
-0.0198880937,
-0.0074098804,
0.0393750928,
0.0366513655,
-0.0282721762,
-0.0391828418,
-0.0047151656,
0.0503044948,
-0.0149214538,
0.0216776375,
0.054411009,
-0.0128692016,
-0.0280064791,
0.0059561124,
-0.012536387,
0.0535344705,
0.0125962002,
-0.013553855,
-0.0177911203,
-0.0277631897,
-0.0150395725,
-0.0104363458,
-0.0021857184,
-0.0714810789,
0.0632354096,
0.0251096748,
0.039983891,
-0.0150697473,
0.0577662215,
-0.0077025974,
0.0243488438,
-0.0283469073,
0.001302659,
-0.0304521322,
0.0463981368,
0.0010761275,
-0.0325751789,
0.0082479073,
-0.0000123017,
-0.0173764415,
-0.0264237169,
-0.0067425058,
0.0142307878,
2.801e-7,
0.0191767737,
0.039900355,
0.0399535969,
0.0156414956,
0.0201280434,
0.0350172892,
0.0502374619,
0.057566192,
0.0077087251,
-0.0342113115,
-0.0066130902,
-0.0098602129,
0.0161428172,
0.0390688926,
-0.1048812643,
-0.0298498478,
-0.0576912872,
-0.0442855135,
-0.0231222771,
0.0106634758,
0.0708634108,
0.0452335067,
0.0113966484,
0.0275181662,
-0.0263276473,
0.0031215989,
0.0121715935,
-0.0079871463,
-0.0023227322,
0.0342532657,
0.012887205,
-0.0427402444,
-0.0033243487,
0.0749346167,
-0.0199180841,
0.0407425798,
-0.0097147645,
0.0489084497,
-0.0024605449,
-0.0196108129,
-0.0319842994,
0.0055251559,
0.0190333314,
0.0138897365,
0.0572285801,
-0.0682084858,
-0.0532349832,
0.017327711,
-0.049915906,
-0.0116318734,
0.0048084185,
0.0298642162,
-0.0227570273,
0.0297452174,
0.0146633573,
-0.0202801786,
-0.0178693812,
-0.0636293888,
-0.003475006,
0.0100213252,
-0.034053646,
-0.0066050482,
0.0080798278,
0.0127034765,
0.0150075089,
-0.0725169033,
0.0223813746,
2.723407582e-34,
0.0129474327,
-0.0213831868,
-0.0032235503,
0.0300155301,
0.0532458909,
0.0033043099,
0.016705852,
0.0241730809,
0.0393880755,
-0.0769154429,
0.0263268258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.04910v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.04910v1 | Ontology-Driven Processing of Transdisciplinary Domain Knowledge | 2023-11-01T07:42:34 | 2023-11-01T07:42:34 | Oleksandr Palagin, Mykola Petrenko, Sergii Kryvyi, Mykola Boyko, Kyrylo Malakhov | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL | The monograph discusses certain aspects of modern real-world problems facing
humanity, which are much more challenging than scientific ones. Modern science
is unable to solve them in a fundamental way. Vernadsky's noosphere thesis, in
fact, appeals to the scientific worldview that needs to be built in a way that
overcomes the interdisciplinary barriers and increases the effectiveness of
interdisciplinary interaction and modern science overall. We are talking about
the general transdisciplinary knowledge. In world practice, there is still no
systematic methodology and a specific form of generally accepted valid
scientific theory that would provide transdisciplinary knowledge. Non-linear
interdisciplinary interaction is the standard of evolution of modern science.
At the same time, a new transdisciplinary theory (domain of scientific
research) is being de facto created and the process is repeated many times:
from an individual or group of disciplines, through interdisciplinary
interaction, in a direction that brings us closer to creating a holistic
general scientific worldview. | [
0.01048599,
-0.0137649532,
-0.0054603391,
-0.0069544967,
-0.0282050539,
-0.0208642464,
0.0504209995,
0.0181567408,
0.0168822519,
-0.0118393293,
-0.0277982261,
0.0241459627,
-0.0065936181,
0.0309129618,
0.0053758766,
-0.0451263413,
0.0189780463,
-0.0382240824,
-0.0335939862,
-0.0155593408,
-0.0489512831,
-0.0459543914,
-0.0373971723,
0.0165712275,
0.0387899578,
-0.0475692749,
0.0278524067,
-0.0324243978,
0.0497851111,
0.0106253633,
0.0177402589,
0.0006271508,
0.0023082718,
0.0486581363,
0.0000024181,
-0.0192574728,
-0.0525088236,
0.0706277862,
0.0112273674,
-0.0585648417,
-0.0093657561,
0.0051776455,
-0.0088796532,
-0.0296640843,
-0.0197429024,
0.0189654175,
-0.0081671448,
-0.001196597,
-0.0413241237,
-0.0230784919,
0.0192760415,
-0.0352302454,
0.0327454656,
0.0157254674,
0.0003863785,
0.0487721562,
0.0230641793,
0.0408028737,
0.0619402491,
0.0581451245,
-0.0319865234,
0.048825141,
-0.0176704526,
-0.0400133692,
0.0489101894,
0.0193086993,
0.0045960313,
0.0157772601,
0.0184527989,
0.006461713,
0.1210863069,
0.0140194073,
0.0016883801,
0.0497932099,
-0.0359826535,
0.0389513373,
-0.0338021517,
-0.0023373603,
-0.000886907,
-0.0279929135,
-0.0158689432,
0.0358687826,
0.0022720436,
0.0163604487,
-0.0301753487,
0.1412908733,
-0.0182785466,
-0.0135317771,
-0.0002923786,
0.0050796615,
0.0717931017,
-0.008059022,
-0.0125222262,
-0.0116409371,
-0.0216654148,
-0.034329921,
0.0528764389,
-0.0164425243,
0.0120330108,
0.0199415032,
-0.0362780131,
0.0247337297,
0.0346684381,
0.0306083672,
0.0717240274,
-0.0292332657,
-0.0512638688,
-0.0251205135,
-0.0004567736,
-0.0250213072,
-0.1320716739,
-0.0218156055,
0.037874151,
-0.0070051374,
-0.0091005517,
-0.0108173443,
0.0245834067,
-0.0298825372,
-0.013289446,
-0.0261628386,
-0.0310527384,
0.0060757333,
-0.0300758798,
-0.0135538299,
0.0015266382,
0.0681012422,
0.0420494974,
0.0209625512,
-0.0152651798,
0.023887286,
0.0254063569,
-0.0067790402,
-0.0253336709,
0.0213442575,
-0.0499650054,
0.0502326749,
0.0378296673,
0.0299806632,
0.0536337383,
-0.086531356,
0.0035709124,
-0.0165707711,
0.0654849336,
-0.0102446247,
-0.0280700028,
0.0274926424,
0.0349270292,
0.0016604719,
-0.0292844716,
-0.0351991355,
-0.0633268058,
0.024910884,
-0.0642264485,
-0.0102910846,
0.0665212572,
0.0849593058,
0.0433753505,
0.0090047512,
-0.0538056046,
-0.0154260257,
0.0137639055,
0.0138822272,
-0.0095433351,
-0.0715875551,
-0.0013258661,
-0.0096366098,
0.0058325827,
0.0276109967,
-0.0273758862,
0.0096058873,
-0.0081174551,
-0.010065102,
-0.0540096797,
0.0343535654,
-0.0133418515,
0.0100493589,
0.0571492761,
0.0486510433,
0.0217234511,
0.0012283847,
-0.0138462754,
0.0096242037,
0.0144332396,
0.0473769642,
-0.00448523,
-0.0174708534,
0.0261016246,
0.0169791095,
-0.0151887331,
-0.0286345854,
0.002342232,
0.0453291386,
-0.0266852621,
-0.0146531984,
0.0300577953,
-0.0372358672,
0.0663849041,
0.0157312136,
0.0020093564,
0.0076839128,
0.0053797704,
0.0241115037,
0.0179124717,
0.0083024865,
-0.0029337439,
-0.036277499,
-0.0479649343,
-0.0195075572,
-0.0246515237,
0.0655581355,
0.0160527751,
-0.0135223651,
-0.0565490946,
0.0197137538,
-0.000693598,
-0.0490556546,
-0.0097970292,
0.011656615,
-0.0546482913,
0.057260152,
-0.0109625338,
-0.005238336,
0.0437219106,
-0.0118362233,
-0.0872935802,
0.0186503455,
-0.0114091747,
-0.0129824756,
0.0238585193,
0.0314288922,
-0.003441863,
0.0463081077,
0.0100564118,
-0.0278271493,
-0.0497569442,
-0.0017025219,
0.0335357375,
0.1136095151,
-0.0086988658,
-0.1629433334,
0.0511889309,
-0.0018335915,
0.0405673273,
-0.0103500057,
0.0810324624,
0.045817785,
-0.0187137909,
0.0391540602,
0.0204446539,
-0.0168239735,
0.0115147056,
0.0253978539,
-0.0456774347,
0.0136186713,
0.020375425,
-0.0307269003,
-0.0774695799,
0.0812915862,
0.0431926288,
0.0085823955,
0.0346730761,
0.016331546,
-0.0125208497,
0.0490826815,
-0.0499862172,
-0.0054745465,
0.0275752172,
-0.0172494408,
-0.0140290679,
0.0115378266,
0.0074405423,
0.000507342,
-0.0389763713,
0.003648716,
0.0254875552,
0.0741775557,
0.0195611324,
0.022222029,
-0.0315808244,
0.0092986934,
0.0238130558,
0.0346049964,
-0.0094550122,
0.0016292469,
-0.0437898561,
0.0351296104,
-0.0221069232,
-0.0206127465,
-0.0688950494,
-0.046654094,
-0.0614793934,
-0.0084806709,
-0.0218127631,
0.0025079784,
0.0191804748,
0.0673567653,
0.0065279217,
-0.0182299018,
-0.028161861,
0.0014984353,
0.0190993473,
-0.0338432416,
0.0263791978,
-0.0007312739,
0.0056227306,
-0.0030833804,
0.0159768518,
0.0235305093,
0.0209402218,
0.0282309894,
-0.0337388292,
-0.0242763013,
0.0055831745,
0.0572828874,
-0.0926150829,
-0.000397861,
-0.0233651586,
-0.055523064,
0.0257085748,
0.0511960052,
0.0286797304,
0.0113778515,
0.0012121605,
0.0068621524,
0.0210472066,
-0.074553594,
-0.0057538101,
-0.0161740705,
0.0478559956,
-0.0790797323,
0.0148715423,
0.0961328149,
0.0019034406,
-0.015528637,
-0.047841046,
-0.0494748056,
0.0211177468,
-0.0210968703,
-0.0592306703,
-0.000993213,
-0.0183948111,
0.0000828204,
-0.0217943601,
0.0881686956,
0.0340039246,
0.0956922024,
-0.0049846619,
-0.0189517438,
-0.0025333252,
-0.0020562275,
0.0648046359,
0.0124671506,
-0.0059592705,
-0.0044112462,
-0.0213313978,
0.0027629761,
-0.0004813662,
-0.0146838427,
0.009521733,
0.0202710815,
-0.0088190716,
0.0183486342,
-0.0565151982,
-0.0576322414,
0.0325027034,
-0.0426010713,
0.0317877233,
-0.0323739871,
-0.0466496348,
-0.0418685414,
-0.0252011716,
-0.0124216136,
-0.0186894275,
0.0181075409,
-0.0049603023,
0.0300667528,
0.0197331626,
-0.0607145019,
-0.1342556328,
0.0015953325,
0.0056108488,
-0.0513191447,
0.0790973157,
-0.0386546366,
-0.0408680961,
-0.0344719253,
-0.038918592,
0.0074306177,
0.0695893392,
0.0397417136,
0.0078371717,
-0.0288585313,
-0.0189313497,
0.0427392386,
-0.0169351939,
0.0331897736,
-0.0121761216,
-0.0072936583,
0.0264606066,
-0.0159675982,
0.0469861291,
0.0082715759,
-0.0221708547,
-0.0023949638,
-0.008255085,
-0.0187881477,
-0.01060938,
0.0491498224,
-0.037553139,
-0.0752115473,
-0.0350105353,
0.0021213479,
0.0392766818,
-0.0141112898,
-0.0203222036,
0.041477982,
0.0188372415,
-0.021074893,
0.006663457,
-0.0431234129,
0.0137305018,
-0.0002279236,
0.09187527,
-0.0349872187,
-0.022421021,
-0.0797487199,
-0.0077738119,
0.0028192087,
-0.015689116,
-0.0553443953,
0.0197432879,
-0.0236811992,
0.0029362368,
-0.0186920371,
0.0614076331,
-0.0410373285,
0.0080679599,
0.0070867203,
-0.0845949352,
0.0173150599,
0.0109432517,
0.0033838241,
0.0339337885,
-0.031023724,
-0.000606277,
0.034481708,
-0.019791441,
-0.022899989,
-0.0026611176,
-0.0179988761,
0.014355951,
0.0369052924,
-0.0262614712,
0.0315178297,
0.0149376662,
-0.0326827988,
-0.0344937332,
0.0911743715,
-0.0207827147,
-0.0172362551,
0.0124445194,
0.0283077117,
-0.0124069043,
0.0212357808,
0.0032377623,
0.0401419401,
0.0197605807,
-0.0367075317,
0.023315357,
-0.0198540129,
-0.0011264723,
0.0071926764,
-0.0188966859,
0.0334786214,
-0.0009303369,
0.0010060247,
-0.0324865915,
-0.0306433067,
-0.0631139874,
-0.0336312875,
-0.0351834111,
0.0789826587,
-0.0251034088,
-0.0421735048,
0.0341483876,
-0.00688355,
0.0203849934,
-0.0257647093,
0.0090363799,
-0.0230689757,
0.01523217,
0.0097801164,
0.0064853122,
0.0581886433,
-0.0179504789,
0.0240093693,
-0.0216006916,
0.0657373741,
-0.0176520329,
0.0492655002,
0.012613059,
0.016446786,
-0.0100146718,
-0.0860041007,
-0.0543157943,
0.0074325441,
-0.0224029161,
-0.0041705514,
0.0255795121,
-0.0043543843,
-0.0107960459,
0.0312731415,
-0.0423771888,
-0.0690936297,
-0.0022692038,
0.0316046514,
0.0178930312,
0.0507133491,
-0.040536996,
-0.0503087081,
0.0138687994,
-0.0162689835,
-0.0073719807,
0.0076966994,
0.0025651213,
0.0111664208,
-0.0040045865,
-0.0035913365,
-0.0323968343,
0.0283813849,
-0.0154039739,
-0.0456832275,
-0.0047917212,
0.0101791332,
-0.0086158253,
-0.0106265359,
0.0597695,
0.0202429052,
-0.0214804504,
0.0144541645,
-0.0682568178,
0.0033858637,
0.0462588072,
0.040202979,
-0.0185346063,
-0.0083331075,
0.009290074,
0.027411351,
0.0238958038,
-0.077667281,
-0.004735407,
0.060690634,
-0.0436165519,
0.005668337,
0.0590700209,
-6.841410183e-33,
-0.0173266996,
-0.027441835,
0.0222353246,
0.018015964,
-0.0912829265,
0.0100139054,
0.0337180868,
-0.0203495137,
0.0028266101,
0.0390447527,
-0.0022899813,
-0.0256405398,
-0.0104687614,
-0.0172589421,
0.059257254,
0.0380464755,
0.0223717876,
-0.0030042499,
0.0000350284,
0.0105252797,
0.0329959877,
-0.0168978628,
-0.0131061217,
-0.0779156834,
0.0623111762,
0.0025439272,
0.0501205549,
0.0141222505,
0.0333598852,
-0.0077025332,
-0.0343553461,
0.0294126403,
0.0059813145,
-0.1022075564,
0.009319922,
-0.0219204351,
-0.0385264605,
-0.0214326605,
0.0376894735,
-0.05450866,
0.020509379,
-0.0328202434,
-0.012992044,
0.0397807173,
-0.006580696,
-0.0281097498,
0.0418389738,
-0.0073404443,
-0.0419952199,
-0.0447040126,
-0.0826151371,
-0.007523525,
-0.0138640804,
0.0245676748,
0.0336342715,
0.0102448585,
-0.0026964678,
-0.0101728346,
-0.0535026453,
0.0573439598,
-0.024930289,
-0.0117665678,
0.0109527875,
-0.0123358928,
0.0186585896,
0.0039722198,
-0.0496585257,
0.0238068234,
0.0617328547,
-0.0599697381,
-0.0026332936,
0.0375638045,
-0.0335700922,
0.0231580716,
-0.0428847857,
-0.0237111039,
-0.0727446526,
-0.0104335733,
-0.0057640164,
-0.0026232337,
-0.0292253625,
0.0180746783,
0.0292101223,
-0.0293694828,
0.0478024781,
0.0099524623,
0.0142200636,
0.009121242,
-0.0362555832,
-0.0666917637,
-0.006204213,
0.0609402955,
0.004995741,
-0.0653300136,
0.0333696902,
0.0066201193,
0.0591181628,
0.0139837777,
-0.0014934507,
0.0287659168,
-0.0733848959,
-0.0228617713,
-0.0580335706,
0.0533279814,
0.0096386494,
0.0271523539,
-0.0380914807,
-0.0074293222,
0.022969678,
-0.0222183913,
-0.0002326129,
-0.0151026482,
0.0320925079,
0.0227476265,
-0.0043109683,
0.023026051,
0.0162630193,
-0.0084309885,
0.0069913887,
0.0391374789,
0.0222730972,
0.062963888,
-0.0065666116,
0.0066033308,
-0.0168200769,
-0.0122765955,
0.0032666437,
-0.0222886205,
0.0109275226,
-0.0022378066,
-0.0020994982,
-0.0100395782,
3.266e-7,
0.0040225079,
0.0375307538,
0.0093051558,
-0.048235286,
0.0652690381,
0.0034813927,
-0.006152791,
0.0382510982,
-0.0129839443,
-0.0006712296,
0.0069122226,
-0.0283876471,
-0.0029952293,
-0.0025640288,
-0.0553662442,
-0.0427213833,
0.0857336447,
-0.0394550487,
-0.0319861956,
0.0027437916,
-0.0379903615,
-0.1104317456,
-0.0027209155,
0.0145398509,
0.0111641772,
0.0385539345,
0.0147061013,
0.0018191977,
0.0750668347,
0.0399156027,
-0.0267493017,
0.0262105279,
0.0029869555,
0.0386568718,
0.0458582491,
-0.0039331568,
0.000317794,
-0.0214991402,
0.0109804133,
0.0192547459,
0.0124194119,
-0.0432268381,
0.0460779443,
-0.0529182255,
0.0104307244,
-0.0527368709,
-0.0473069698,
0.0176019743,
-0.0215833299,
0.0098526962,
-0.0048840139,
-0.0099312551,
0.0060047689,
0.0078479741,
-0.0210164879,
0.0193873532,
-0.010552045,
-0.0096168425,
0.0537114255,
0.048843246,
-0.0320854671,
-0.076432161,
0.0130278785,
-0.0206950549,
0.0892218053,
-0.0251961797,
0.0115881348,
2.7708661e-34,
0.0091043729,
0.0353414528,
-0.0164369624,
-0.0725239739,
-0.0467501692,
0.0108271725,
-0.0461546779,
-0.0107882023,
0.0453823879,
-0.0100031001,
-0.0008248608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00732v1 | tmn at #SMM4H 2023: Comparing Text Preprocessing Techniques for Detecting Tweets Self-reporting a COVID-19 Diagnosis | 2023-11-01T07:41:23 | 2023-11-01T07:41:23 | Anna Glazkova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI, 68T50, I.2.7; I.7.m; H.3.3; J.3 | The paper describes a system developed for Task 1 at SMM4H 2023. The goal of
the task is to automatically distinguish tweets that self-report a COVID-19
diagnosis (for example, a positive test, clinical diagnosis, or
hospitalization) from those that do not. We investigate the use of different
techniques for preprocessing tweets using four transformer-based models. The
ensemble of fine-tuned language models obtained an F1-score of 84.5%, which is
4.1% higher than the average value. | [
0.0625941753,
0.0334636942,
-0.0135742147,
-0.0241319314,
-0.0366973989,
0.0079553695,
0.0082655055,
0.0162789207,
0.0199499745,
-0.0479807109,
0.0355375521,
-0.0168114882,
-0.0145536531,
0.0652385727,
-0.0177426543,
-0.0199145675,
0.026423879,
0.0313883573,
-0.0048882458,
0.0310699288,
-0.0219121091,
0.0334757045,
0.0266355593,
0.0597317889,
0.0111326119,
0.0198509321,
0.0426129885,
-0.0056510307,
0.0443536639,
-0.0394201465,
0.0259056389,
0.048852548,
-0.0391020738,
0.065558888,
0.0000018039,
-0.0445480086,
-0.064204447,
-0.0093213739,
0.0161962248,
-0.04373952,
0.0509848222,
-0.0664311424,
0.0004736373,
0.0716902241,
-0.065213941,
-0.066637665,
0.0402505659,
0.0501536727,
0.0604004003,
0.0983549729,
-0.0334137864,
0.0016107321,
0.015406847,
0.0080313152,
-0.0108109321,
-0.0088471472,
0.0477953367,
-0.0210791696,
-0.0041081151,
0.0184984077,
0.0520471931,
0.0725891665,
-0.0290631838,
-0.0063337893,
-0.0213349964,
0.0174374525,
-0.0313986391,
-0.043383114,
0.0047696247,
-0.0030269383,
-0.0334161818,
-0.0420265682,
0.0539665408,
-0.0006956474,
-0.0132414587,
0.0236862022,
-0.0208199844,
-0.0097649712,
-0.0232475717,
0.0147051578,
0.0090508545,
0.0378846824,
0.008923498,
0.0256557576,
-0.0226123407,
0.0616989136,
-0.0117744403,
-0.0523423962,
-0.0299903657,
0.0055862116,
-0.0085370438,
-0.061684981,
0.0711539015,
0.0207902063,
-0.0189539138,
-0.0132228527,
-0.0294735171,
-0.0741009191,
0.0396365933,
-0.073287569,
-0.0154402284,
0.0004450599,
0.0090133352,
-0.0068295971,
-0.0305944514,
-0.0099311722,
-0.0227105115,
-0.002264756,
-0.0014311763,
-0.0107997498,
-0.0329608358,
0.002022052,
-0.057044968,
-0.0032734864,
0.0115854563,
0.0490014479,
-0.0714533776,
0.0082226712,
0.0255956538,
-0.0057781171,
0.0269127265,
-0.0203563608,
-0.0475561842,
0.0135434913,
0.0456534103,
0.0658804923,
0.0425405838,
-0.0122680943,
-0.0321168974,
-0.015843207,
0.0125747817,
0.0036398263,
0.0672974065,
-0.0116568608,
0.0088102613,
-0.0167210177,
0.024292741,
-0.0255468283,
0.0305475891,
-0.0308469404,
-0.0291912314,
-0.0190459099,
-0.0237403084,
-0.0536127388,
-0.0194688533,
0.069697991,
0.0133401081,
-0.0233670808,
0.0080928113,
0.0057793157,
-0.0577791519,
-0.0104092835,
-0.0379201584,
0.0362013243,
0.0237677917,
0.0098362816,
0.0312342905,
0.0388473719,
0.0303926021,
0.0826004967,
0.0342533253,
-0.0451686494,
0.0553580336,
0.0409196466,
-0.0027627079,
-0.0113018528,
0.0132893603,
-0.0232835691,
-0.0022830539,
0.0112592438,
-0.0425454043,
0.0531061329,
0.0418896005,
0.0274955705,
0.0356760621,
0.0401885547,
0.0334503017,
-0.0299821533,
0.045532085,
0.0419469252,
-0.0040716128,
-0.0022422702,
0.0062493109,
-0.0159010347,
-0.0434815735,
-0.0102456938,
-0.0128964698,
0.0569220409,
-0.0068884483,
-0.0415587313,
-0.0310178716,
-0.0192975122,
-0.0057215821,
-0.0335858613,
0.036692746,
-0.0028666186,
-0.0710372478,
0.011645101,
0.0149895474,
-0.0585916936,
-0.0007425511,
-0.0912300423,
-0.0091152303,
0.0551014282,
0.0416426584,
0.0005362034,
-0.0468611829,
-0.0423468575,
0.0071585579,
0.0302960984,
0.0091964258,
0.0115249725,
-0.0229676422,
-0.0212531723,
-0.0092379143,
0.031486664,
0.0261720251,
-0.0564050376,
0.0092266183,
0.0198744014,
0.0113781486,
0.007854077,
-0.0419898331,
0.0387894474,
0.0036357068,
-0.0059387852,
0.0160631537,
0.0054230834,
0.0230883267,
0.0105922995,
0.021697484,
0.0043289894,
0.0274748132,
-0.0202475376,
-0.0574451052,
0.0303697344,
-0.0231030155,
-0.0184044782,
-0.020715246,
-0.0133378832,
-0.0062841927,
0.0499907844,
-0.035058476,
0.002215835,
0.0284550544,
-0.0178847946,
-0.0067916587,
-0.0084404582,
0.0376956314,
-0.0354187638,
0.0248424318,
0.0136060603,
0.0300288834,
-0.0273500364,
0.0078890044,
-0.0675056577,
-0.0688903481,
-0.020607695,
0.0000797194,
-0.0106759258,
-0.0356459729,
-0.0319740921,
0.0145551385,
0.0193194859,
-0.0108577497,
-0.0013287377,
-0.0413065627,
-0.0839069337,
-0.0120137585,
-0.0329532921,
0.0080018686,
0.0460708849,
0.0709682107,
-0.0268737152,
0.0165999494,
0.0252360422,
-0.0206355676,
0.0886174142,
0.0134041617,
0.0289233644,
-0.014413164,
-0.0146822883,
-0.0228916686,
0.0093936156,
-0.0698120818,
0.0287500955,
0.0267140511,
-0.0681049898,
-0.0316113904,
0.010203545,
0.0019036996,
-0.0061203456,
0.0236662254,
-0.0629049018,
-0.0159578342,
-0.035241615,
0.0192205887,
0.0324464738,
0.0221625194,
0.0206894781,
0.0246856995,
0.0155580919,
-0.0190871637,
0.0132233938,
-0.0573671982,
-0.0247224923,
-0.0182495359,
-0.0634516254,
0.0528133474,
0.0774180889,
0.007836923,
-0.0063253064,
-0.0274793562,
0.0241218768,
-0.0430368446,
0.0096575059,
0.048886586,
-0.0283854119,
-0.0091852089,
0.0008776149,
0.0195209794,
-0.0341208503,
0.0439485796,
-0.0246572495,
0.0214258879,
-0.0932366252,
-0.058378052,
-0.0256044772,
-0.0063530877,
0.001387237,
0.0201216396,
0.0709217191,
0.0059918589,
0.0464351363,
-0.0125829205,
0.0151894018,
-0.0480109267,
0.0146972043,
0.0264211986,
0.0184943639,
0.0088071441,
0.001305772,
-0.0433283187,
-0.0895661563,
-0.0531716719,
-0.0190983079,
0.0139085036,
-0.0051465253,
-0.0773655102,
0.0779000819,
-0.03524803,
0.0546587706,
-0.0004873078,
-0.0252873302,
0.0277188085,
0.0129986918,
-0.0121494578,
-0.029137332,
-0.0147007629,
0.0134787103,
0.02238537,
0.0504791029,
0.0284421798,
0.0180393811,
-0.0284879133,
-0.0331956148,
0.0208177697,
-0.0568350144,
0.0017817102,
0.0013266554,
0.0439578071,
-0.0551612601,
0.0075276964,
0.1281526834,
0.0364080109,
0.0051293909,
0.0097037144,
-0.0072463541,
-0.0437441505,
-0.0116176922,
0.0218774956,
-0.0289214589,
-0.0005647557,
0.0210933108,
-0.0004157653,
-0.0623848364,
-0.0330017582,
-0.0028776857,
0.0136186425,
0.0427520163,
-0.0087376181,
0.0202288553,
-0.0207372531,
-0.0727636814,
0.0113216424,
-0.0206280146,
-0.0122264987,
-0.0434731394,
-0.0327126533,
0.0137580549,
-0.0038827306,
-0.0827249214,
-0.0800839216,
0.0074069034,
-0.033037208,
-0.0180029739,
0.0561854877,
0.0171604585,
-0.0348585062,
-0.0285109282,
-0.0020158181,
0.0165925305,
0.0173256602,
-0.0389567912,
0.0614067391,
-0.0084263114,
0.0104722017,
-0.0371197313,
0.0030726425,
-0.037959598,
-0.0183010492,
0.00174478,
0.0877334103,
-0.025758246,
-0.086647667,
-0.0003924261,
0.0612252317,
0.0218904689,
0.0590233058,
0.0145028951,
-0.0283669233,
-0.0015273653,
0.0097810747,
0.0415779911,
-0.0272042155,
-0.0616365001,
-0.0169101749,
0.0116221225,
-0.0912016705,
-0.0502360873,
-0.0107714152,
0.055164855,
-0.0081099709,
-0.0357935913,
-0.0502265021,
0.0227409229,
0.0143112838,
-0.0560208708,
0.0170773417,
0.0289109088,
0.0259475522,
-0.0515801236,
0.0157517157,
0.0629990399,
0.0602818914,
0.0046477411,
0.0335007161,
-0.0570791438,
-0.0304085631,
0.0490517318,
-0.0027079189,
0.0264550708,
-0.044773154,
-0.0028733965,
-0.0111172078,
0.0554259643,
0.0628620088,
-0.0390000418,
-0.0219380651,
0.0166499205,
-0.045443695,
-0.0038524652,
0.0109126102,
0.0060381396,
0.0268870555,
0.0075635724,
0.014029678,
-0.0282471459,
-0.0199490152,
0.0253202729,
0.0162061844,
0.0750760734,
-0.0068813791,
-0.0523089878,
-0.0248740483,
-0.0173028186,
0.0068794121,
-0.0060694609,
-0.0118006654,
-0.0011402813,
0.0276762526,
0.0174488164,
-0.0232292078,
0.0576669835,
-0.0877195746,
-0.0327404588,
-0.0723051876,
0.0738818869,
-0.0091046691,
0.0342325121,
0.0375591032,
-0.0286638197,
-0.0111079263,
-0.0239782799,
0.0618679896,
-0.006623697,
-0.0017826065,
-0.0037483093,
-0.0370364673,
0.0385889262,
-0.0321680903,
0.062920481,
-0.0599096194,
0.0131012024,
-0.0632530898,
0.0040179114,
0.0103525706,
0.0028281671,
0.0706664249,
-0.0296373256,
-0.0109114125,
-0.0197989494,
0.0345558487,
-0.0194440167,
0.0258534048,
0.0114566619,
-0.0453787372,
-0.0525450073,
0.0023514186,
0.0688629299,
-0.0347710215,
0.0434820168,
0.0790104195,
-0.0392733179,
-0.0310931988,
-0.0019610093,
-0.0203574244,
-0.0172968991,
-0.0213610511,
0.0134722972,
-0.0439016409,
-0.016725922,
0.0853025168,
-0.0749928281,
-0.0180344377,
-0.0090365978,
-0.035605751,
0.0588166006,
0.0297050569,
0.0037072385,
-0.0312256441,
0.0128847715,
0.0321291052,
-0.0352172032,
0.0036691134,
-6.504475298e-33,
0.0333013907,
-0.0352580398,
-0.0258594621,
-0.0141087016,
0.0236787554,
0.0251047835,
0.0062454557,
-0.0217932798,
0.0037908894,
-0.0017356431,
-0.037603166,
-0.0067551048,
0.017371662,
0.0213171113,
0.0180781912,
0.0342223123,
0.0758266598,
-0.0062564337,
-0.0557489619,
0.0389512405,
0.0219662059,
0.0484904312,
0.0524068549,
-0.080703184,
-0.0064758644,
-0.0214515775,
-0.0096755531,
0.0137890317,
0.0304425322,
0.0423488729,
-0.0272558816,
0.0346162617,
0.0518366955,
-0.0266388208,
-0.0047658253,
0.0478773564,
-0.0209373441,
-0.037643306,
0.0073313261,
-0.0146300206,
-0.0009652768,
-0.0423234142,
0.063943319,
-0.0158677455,
-0.0155766821,
-0.011803722,
0.0116979973,
-0.0105619272,
0.054024104,
-0.0509781875,
-0.0258085113,
0.0484627075,
-0.0050340015,
-0.0072595826,
0.0133850658,
0.0632636547,
0.0030569269,
0.05570627,
-0.0192676876,
0.0081718955,
0.0051688598,
0.0490474924,
0.0422210507,
-0.0517366715,
-0.0299097095,
-0.0151980212,
0.0048351143,
-0.012412006,
-0.0392498448,
0.0028169286,
-0.0297866091,
0.031390775,
0.0496031791,
0.0339627601,
0.0024335179,
-0.0548166074,
-0.0421749465,
0.0743835047,
-0.0013362829,
0.0396737866,
0.015948182,
-0.020550685,
-0.0148148481,
-0.0041005993,
0.0106461057,
-0.0481083691,
-0.0161220338,
-0.017078029,
-0.0117677636,
0.0151019702,
-0.0362238288,
0.0614250712,
0.014054494,
-0.0319502987,
-0.0105549078,
-0.0058029471,
0.0086635556,
0.0293619502,
-0.0293242969,
0.0489848293,
-0.0162807014,
-0.0171816163,
0.0511411093,
0.0386658348,
0.0052781743,
-0.0155110462,
0.015146032,
0.029982591,
-0.0824102312,
0.0055817696,
0.0413893089,
0.0446393602,
-0.0500755608,
0.0216021985,
-0.0003167133,
0.0247242991,
0.0004924961,
-0.003547238,
0.0060397591,
0.0154532017,
-0.0222316217,
0.0023352948,
-0.0094395187,
0.0141701084,
-0.0067252694,
0.0034833769,
-0.0319255106,
0.0323256142,
0.0464428477,
-0.053509783,
-0.0161931384,
-0.0181584321,
2.708e-7,
0.0963054597,
0.0870942622,
-0.002815424,
-0.0533684939,
-0.0032642316,
0.0389168486,
0.0078734355,
0.0041830023,
0.0348102041,
0.0393830054,
-0.0064533139,
-0.019705642,
0.0164278485,
0.0461243801,
-0.0292091798,
-0.0101291202,
-0.0743495971,
0.007679692,
-0.0439744666,
-0.0087007526,
0.0236965511,
0.066717796,
0.0021294639,
0.002963915,
-0.0306343529,
-0.0214232411,
0.0147855049,
-0.0285311453,
-0.0327557325,
0.073142536,
0.0408104137,
-0.0061674155,
0.0350238755,
0.0094270408,
-0.0357931145,
-0.0122166788,
-0.0082309507,
0.0554667227,
0.0082674315,
0.0486503839,
0.0123054152,
-0.0416202433,
0.0161192827,
-0.0465102047,
0.0557610244,
-0.0956861675,
-0.045447208,
-0.0165642239,
-0.0096983779,
0.0355880447,
0.0060270196,
-0.0273597967,
-0.0568696335,
0.0747974887,
0.0060923602,
0.0313436463,
-0.0477307588,
-0.0699851438,
-0.0101717878,
-0.0349072926,
-0.0150468042,
-0.0494992658,
0.0201819427,
-0.0312183257,
0.0380547382,
-0.0212798696,
0.0690487847,
2.660994342e-34,
0.0330764167,
0.0234026089,
-0.0304443557,
-0.0105064316,
-0.0008556845,
-0.0253223423,
0.0321248621,
0.0511523187,
-0.0225767214,
-0.0783837736,
0.0061972099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00321v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00321v2 | HARE: Explainable Hate Speech Detection with Step-by-Step Reasoning | 2023-11-01T06:09:54 | 2023-11-22T09:08:03 | Yongjin Yang, Joonkee Kim, Yujin Kim, Namgyu Ho, James Thorne, Se-young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the proliferation of social media, accurate detection of hate speech has
become critical to ensure safety online. To combat nuanced forms of hate
speech, it is important to identify and thoroughly explain hate speech to help
users understand its harmful effects. Recent benchmarks have attempted to
tackle this issue by training generative models on free-text annotations of
implications in hateful text. However, we find significant reasoning gaps in
the existing annotations schemes, which may hinder the supervision of detection
models. In this paper, we introduce a hate speech detection framework, HARE,
which harnesses the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to
fill these gaps in explanations of hate speech, thus enabling effective
supervision of detection models. Experiments on SBIC and Implicit Hate
benchmarks show that our method, using model-generated data, consistently
outperforms baselines, using existing free-text human annotations. Analysis
demonstrates that our method enhances the explanation quality of trained models
and improves generalization to unseen datasets. Our code is available at
https://github.com/joonkeekim/hare-hate-speech.git. | [
0.0518241636,
0.0695584789,
0.0055604652,
0.037396431,
0.0161953624,
0.0761232153,
0.0611288249,
0.0048177559,
0.0000894171,
-0.0345347933,
0.0215736907,
-0.0144369835,
-0.0146243712,
0.0193706565,
0.0028044835,
-0.046672605,
0.01554392,
-0.0033767184,
0.0365109257,
-0.0018241487,
0.0677946806,
0.0364097878,
-0.0176734161,
0.0398675315,
-0.0730417892,
-0.0050910888,
0.0010275975,
0.0074454709,
0.0265597105,
-0.008487504,
0.0169168878,
0.0394633971,
0.0252539329,
0.0794039294,
0.0000018627,
-0.0240572058,
0.0139378989,
0.0129334703,
-0.0280062072,
-0.0140730022,
0.032532461,
-0.0413498655,
-0.0129744355,
0.0382480212,
-0.0000337151,
0.0347461328,
0.0608617067,
0.1068768799,
0.0777614564,
0.0743046701,
-0.0066702291,
-0.0615266487,
0.0094402907,
0.0001672468,
0.0177108329,
0.0115582887,
0.0254184827,
-0.0122469645,
-0.0613282211,
0.0105550205,
0.0039557228,
-0.0067076609,
0.0524825789,
-0.023174813,
0.0153605659,
-0.0224833786,
-0.0028226732,
-0.0376425311,
0.0035305507,
0.0613239519,
-0.0404859632,
-0.0169267952,
0.0087445118,
-0.0157812312,
-0.0245732777,
-0.0218023881,
-0.0324186198,
0.0139950486,
-0.0196935292,
0.0255373828,
0.0132003818,
-0.0002519733,
0.0815613866,
0.0780481249,
0.0118394848,
0.0466514118,
-0.0286428891,
-0.0076777283,
0.0028318374,
-0.0113959871,
-0.0218485184,
0.0052977451,
0.0158199556,
0.0251182541,
-0.0198832154,
0.0234901011,
-0.0236961413,
-0.0281201936,
-0.0086213341,
-0.0652215853,
0.0400435738,
0.0389386453,
-0.0228140634,
0.0327856354,
-0.0146113932,
0.0423319042,
-0.0353304371,
0.0076972712,
0.0057796212,
-0.027519647,
-0.0283603594,
-0.0002979802,
-0.0062509556,
-0.0228493698,
-0.0332699493,
0.0229619499,
-0.0312636308,
-0.0217622854,
-0.0378222652,
-0.0138427578,
0.0068495432,
0.0187912174,
-0.0062418845,
-0.020162588,
-0.0301837735,
-0.0069261272,
-0.0596888512,
0.0008421436,
-0.0093469694,
-0.0649533495,
-0.011518063,
0.0609881468,
-0.0162120741,
-0.0206734985,
0.0143288318,
0.0566046946,
0.0233100448,
0.0167325642,
-0.0514555946,
-0.0345275439,
-0.0248340871,
-0.0593661442,
-0.0091483975,
-0.0488175191,
0.0139184399,
-0.0159962252,
-0.0272698775,
-0.0603095517,
0.0230763853,
0.0262195561,
-0.0516096354,
0.0940869451,
-0.0033377309,
-0.0214766916,
0.0187502857,
0.0362397842,
0.0082322275,
0.0487395339,
0.0153669715,
0.0217936002,
0.0296136886,
-0.0262266044,
0.0122638764,
0.0303250551,
0.0503983945,
0.0098796701,
-0.0270204712,
0.0311068445,
-0.054758992,
-0.0029522728,
0.0144930743,
0.0326638035,
0.001658458,
-0.0546346679,
0.0234710574,
0.0786708146,
-0.033747565,
0.0252170768,
0.0934340358,
0.0249085203,
-0.0213456973,
-0.0490802787,
-0.0590870455,
0.0038740374,
-0.0313566513,
-0.047769919,
0.0157777462,
0.0191781241,
-0.0232814066,
-0.0779185146,
-0.0456550419,
-0.0202642828,
0.0450691096,
-0.0316458307,
0.0349499285,
0.0237338748,
-0.026483506,
0.0213093422,
0.0525093116,
-0.0324283019,
-0.0130976439,
-0.042481035,
0.0492266826,
0.0905057341,
0.003940851,
0.0096161356,
0.0018364701,
-0.0688833296,
0.0125844814,
0.0656425282,
-0.0144130625,
-0.0203503966,
0.0175183378,
-0.0634240508,
-0.0079375552,
0.0291402657,
0.021472672,
0.018011447,
0.0660938025,
-0.0264899898,
0.0376611426,
0.0171165653,
-0.0561414734,
0.0374454223,
-0.003324884,
-0.0409007929,
0.0020333766,
0.0111215645,
0.0484902821,
0.0296302512,
-0.0142805614,
-0.0397007167,
0.0009260856,
-0.0245780833,
-0.0577406026,
0.0093383985,
-0.0548136942,
-0.0154785672,
0.0103203682,
-0.0343741812,
-0.0362018682,
0.0580183119,
-0.0462642238,
0.013800581,
0.0218321476,
-0.0209713951,
-0.006502877,
-0.0545147918,
-0.0285440125,
-0.0244417731,
0.0395097136,
0.0031606448,
0.0962572992,
-0.0203762203,
-0.0122111375,
0.0319585614,
-0.0139648877,
0.0271081049,
0.017780561,
-0.0224327408,
-0.0278633758,
-0.0287851915,
0.0277951192,
-0.0164700709,
0.0173330866,
-0.0253778156,
0.0330885686,
-0.0919538438,
0.0169862173,
-0.0314938314,
-0.0295435973,
0.0124802906,
0.0057850312,
0.0065731877,
-0.0113282902,
-0.0035833342,
-0.0283500962,
0.0429782644,
0.0104542272,
0.0239765178,
-0.0530498773,
-0.022711629,
-0.0319001749,
-0.0122241937,
-0.0241262075,
0.0427421145,
0.022030184,
-0.009082119,
0.0048501492,
-0.0111593595,
-0.0385412425,
-0.0001774969,
-0.0076745795,
-0.0522635169,
0.0372252762,
0.0089081917,
-0.0220935661,
0.0435200296,
0.0529090166,
0.1004995853,
0.0026239939,
0.025352411,
-0.0490480624,
0.0097592557,
-0.0237429701,
0.0331113376,
-0.033490926,
-0.0354201943,
-0.0284195784,
0.1243516579,
0.016648585,
-0.0113452263,
-0.082317315,
0.0412575081,
-0.0472569503,
-0.0303270277,
-0.0393028744,
-0.0701188669,
0.0011224326,
0.0039345082,
-0.0704808757,
-0.0630462021,
0.068399258,
-0.0196742751,
0.0072700414,
0.0106158219,
-0.0329699367,
-0.0296204817,
0.0630370528,
-0.0059960643,
0.0180699751,
-0.0338931084,
0.0047822017,
0.0386238247,
-0.0377371535,
0.0347654186,
0.0041619814,
-0.0179087352,
-0.0295375735,
0.0238061026,
0.0172174554,
-0.021493772,
-0.0820225552,
-0.0569479652,
-0.0641835555,
-0.033949472,
0.010368403,
-0.0347406305,
0.0035499129,
0.0184810273,
0.0220666453,
-0.0026013346,
-0.0005694729,
0.0119644729,
0.0079007503,
-0.0518166982,
-0.0024400072,
-0.0004720418,
0.0366107151,
-0.0236714166,
0.0029785931,
0.0506420881,
-0.0190271828,
0.0176717453,
-0.0561800152,
0.0253413003,
-0.0102091255,
0.0083593689,
-0.0012339256,
-0.0064419522,
0.0426046066,
-0.0373289064,
0.024110524,
0.1228748932,
0.0116917752,
0.0029147367,
0.0009509776,
-0.0028304642,
0.0284438059,
0.0209258758,
-0.0224537123,
-0.0836130902,
-0.0259129126,
-0.0099158743,
0.0315121785,
-0.0443071164,
-0.0471658334,
0.0058149272,
-0.0553273633,
0.0387596525,
-0.0220698584,
-0.0485571288,
-0.0174115617,
-0.0330510102,
0.0201357305,
-0.0069848918,
0.0287672449,
-0.0170526765,
0.0245704856,
-0.0051720738,
0.0314176902,
-0.0587020516,
-0.0162254032,
0.0178902838,
-0.0095278276,
0.0400874652,
0.0399348773,
0.0570431799,
0.0148428855,
-0.0041827769,
0.0410133414,
0.007602368,
-0.0045419917,
-0.0634053573,
0.0689565763,
0.0144835915,
-0.0314859673,
-0.0389642157,
0.0632414296,
-0.037111301,
-0.0296168588,
0.0070771016,
0.0561565049,
0.0242405757,
0.0124089168,
-0.0317095853,
0.029957464,
-0.0020462743,
0.1023250595,
0.0447405577,
-0.0364623852,
-0.0034742984,
-0.0761009529,
-0.0404365696,
-0.0468544513,
-0.0911965072,
0.0071782176,
-0.0043105264,
-0.030911494,
-0.0171161853,
-0.0366740748,
0.0394584052,
0.02552999,
0.0083863055,
-0.0120080821,
-0.0330949277,
-0.0272072852,
-0.040726155,
0.0440984927,
-0.0071714506,
0.0326851569,
0.0045316624,
-0.0005037134,
-0.0338234864,
-0.0343723074,
-0.0322356373,
0.04291825,
-0.0521684401,
-0.03457845,
0.0287238844,
0.0362941287,
0.0256397761,
0.0649177507,
-0.0180848427,
-0.0577841066,
0.0208269116,
0.0236349404,
0.0021397094,
-0.0258585811,
0.05661989,
0.0091072852,
0.0268498845,
0.0261958204,
0.0059525473,
0.0441471189,
0.0253592823,
-0.0250349678,
-0.0608176365,
0.0147050023,
-0.0077629713,
-0.020055091,
0.0261032283,
0.0068365047,
-0.0498552918,
-0.0332896747,
-0.0063528009,
-0.0064478912,
-0.0526035279,
-0.0323266834,
0.0281209815,
0.0246526133,
-0.0345565826,
-0.039112974,
-0.0299698617,
-0.030297,
0.0089269318,
-0.0228736382,
0.0273859762,
0.0324601904,
0.0262818541,
0.0305614043,
0.0093274489,
-0.0219219048,
0.0469129048,
-0.0086005339,
-0.0073783668,
0.0099434154,
0.051950857,
0.017259974,
0.0219704192,
0.0318106264,
-0.0626071393,
0.0172446407,
-0.0542929843,
-0.0310581643,
-0.0072773322,
-0.0143088195,
-0.0407021642,
0.0461597443,
0.0250642784,
-0.0120419869,
0.0065025757,
0.0487873703,
0.0093714967,
-0.0583330467,
-0.0044976533,
0.0332899317,
-0.0275950842,
0.005112425,
0.0252053123,
0.0145062571,
0.0284423623,
0.0494160391,
-0.0355866067,
-0.0330604874,
0.0012992743,
0.011872001,
0.0477530323,
0.0229647849,
0.0240908805,
-0.030249143,
-0.0698692873,
-0.0249552187,
-0.0353482924,
0.0010194328,
0.0195188727,
0.0054959557,
0.0542658679,
-0.0168612115,
-0.005956172,
-0.027036665,
0.0094866911,
-0.0057369652,
-0.0459632762,
-0.0102050304,
-5.983571507e-33,
-0.0186777897,
-0.0553782247,
-0.0179313459,
-0.0412613228,
0.0058521768,
0.0002382795,
-0.0113040386,
-0.0082385233,
-0.006465029,
0.0523574799,
0.0095150974,
0.0415063649,
0.0108027095,
0.0283326562,
-0.0180132203,
-0.0300374199,
0.0387820452,
0.0004311585,
-0.0044413409,
0.0246335529,
0.0610300191,
0.0121056773,
0.018326031,
-0.0659272224,
0.0692615137,
-0.0333571658,
-0.0325548835,
0.0408709943,
-0.0229437873,
0.0802075267,
-0.0227424074,
0.0407044701,
0.0454546735,
-0.0186548941,
0.0035214603,
0.052184578,
-0.0698338524,
0.0126324166,
0.0421241261,
0.0050927759,
-0.0346873999,
-0.0294483788,
0.0214003976,
-0.007158909,
-0.0177882351,
-0.0217490569,
0.0452764668,
-0.0363673531,
0.0343243852,
-0.0233130995,
-0.084809117,
0.0412257202,
-0.0656128824,
-0.0251078438,
-0.0111949863,
0.009692532,
0.027140731,
0.0006844478,
-0.0225021485,
-0.0080397967,
-0.0000356,
-0.0211655777,
0.0200325362,
-0.0062074438,
-0.0097815152,
0.0646013916,
0.0090687154,
0.0004290681,
-0.0796345249,
0.0159761906,
-0.0059104711,
0.0523671955,
0.0742371455,
0.0352822505,
0.0210026875,
-0.0314640254,
-0.0692122057,
-0.0081570623,
0.0306393616,
0.0083034197,
0.0348874815,
-0.0168228429,
-0.0661115795,
-0.014125457,
-0.0233709868,
-0.0454375111,
-0.0272213314,
-0.036682982,
0.0196320824,
-0.0114856791,
-0.0596316941,
-0.0256803315,
0.0074352007,
-0.0247475654,
0.0127908234,
0.0586031266,
0.0051179715,
-0.028644599,
0.0250609089,
0.0533708408,
-0.0325701647,
-0.0036923145,
0.0025242791,
-0.0463864841,
0.0355981551,
-0.0076944432,
0.0829669386,
0.0235902444,
-0.0566177033,
-0.0051456876,
-0.0502627492,
0.0566591695,
-0.055865366,
0.0601682104,
0.0201112032,
0.0576964915,
-0.0284319371,
-0.0029906,
0.0183981862,
-0.0137983495,
-0.0065622502,
0.007741916,
-0.0246197283,
-0.0133225778,
-0.0159663782,
-0.0333309732,
-0.0014552003,
-0.0187279489,
0.0388064012,
-0.1097996756,
0.0167381838,
-0.0046450184,
2.39e-7,
0.0087803537,
0.0357218236,
0.0214753486,
0.0036649634,
0.029061608,
0.032736171,
0.0580702201,
-0.0191199239,
-0.0404131599,
0.0034639603,
-0.018150527,
0.1024307013,
0.0546365269,
0.0293265488,
-0.0064572874,
-0.0218171328,
-0.0684056208,
-0.0221513323,
-0.0657015443,
0.0097672697,
0.0020613526,
0.0859319195,
0.0784630999,
-0.028023513,
0.0032500993,
0.0050558425,
0.0117531456,
-0.0315264016,
-0.0022081516,
-0.0199790634,
0.0619895644,
0.0391710885,
0.0229232479,
-0.0067206016,
0.0029367597,
-0.0008220947,
0.0036084938,
0.0651064664,
0.0039049503,
0.0197934918,
-0.0101171471,
-0.0274346713,
0.0085781729,
-0.0394708924,
0.0526179597,
-0.0067690024,
-0.0380778573,
-0.0521731786,
-0.0061850641,
-0.0258642323,
0.0002037288,
0.004764704,
0.0247796122,
-0.0243646968,
0.0157641135,
-0.047629714,
-0.0010299144,
-0.0873330832,
-0.0207567513,
-0.0184640232,
-0.0286786836,
-0.0073525934,
-0.0469709188,
0.0020187937,
0.070914194,
0.011866943,
0.0137770036,
1.919583078e-34,
0.024527261,
-0.0085324571,
-0.0016443308,
-0.0007329365,
0.0633961409,
0.0453495421,
-0.0130453948,
-0.0095444759,
0.0624176152,
-0.0429107696,
-0.0060190307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00317v1 | Data Augmentation for Code Translation with Comparable Corpora and Multiple References | 2023-11-01T06:01:22 | 2023-11-01T06:01:22 | Yiqing Xie, Atharva Naik, Daniel Fried, Carolyn Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | One major challenge of translating code between programming languages is that
parallel training data is often limited. To overcome this challenge, we present
two data augmentation techniques, one that builds comparable corpora (i.e.,
code pairs with similar functionality), and another that augments existing
parallel data with multiple reference translations. Specifically, we build and
analyze multiple types of comparable corpora, including programs generated from
natural language documentation using a code generation model. Furthermore, to
reduce overfitting to a single reference translation, we automatically generate
additional translation references for available parallel data and filter the
translations by unit tests, which increases variation in target translations.
Experiments show that our data augmentation techniques significantly improve
CodeT5 for translation between Java, Python, and C++ by an average of 7.5%
Computational Accuracy (CA@1), which verifies the correctness of translations
by execution. The code is available at https://github.com/Veronicium/CMTrans. | [
0.0018364899,
0.0680403486,
-0.0256218426,
0.0423210859,
0.0103263026,
0.0265806485,
0.0217817947,
0.0014456495,
-0.0296457019,
-0.0077369171,
-0.0399022438,
0.0258772913,
0.019866487,
-0.03243085,
0.0554881096,
-0.0281199235,
0.0481465496,
-0.0019114173,
-0.0507938787,
0.0055958503,
-0.008788364,
0.0415156782,
0.0094173867,
0.0369497724,
0.0268035959,
-0.0004928168,
0.034575928,
0.0384941399,
0.0306445304,
-0.0281730648,
0.0147673907,
0.0022667397,
0.0197252519,
0.049543947,
0.0000019486,
-0.0217114221,
-0.019196514,
0.0271754339,
0.0404282622,
0.0355574824,
0.0466255471,
-0.0600907579,
0.027204698,
0.0334269851,
-0.009952643,
-0.0609062649,
0.0660685673,
-0.0803663805,
0.0810495913,
0.0626984537,
0.0035024325,
-0.022234939,
-0.0124256741,
-0.0261701252,
0.010551163,
-0.0260044374,
-0.0161898751,
0.0749316514,
0.0259134211,
0.0185770057,
0.0212585721,
0.04155818,
0.0179058164,
0.0204209909,
0.0072285868,
0.0045689903,
-0.03468192,
0.0080925617,
0.0153789222,
0.0455344431,
-0.0480784737,
-0.0564033762,
-0.01020562,
-0.0087242667,
-0.019771697,
-0.0408693738,
-0.0307904966,
0.0022537054,
0.0162019767,
0.0016951866,
0.0285428762,
0.0026274784,
0.0419685282,
-0.0280959122,
-0.0350177996,
0.0061686174,
0.0317521952,
-0.0181881692,
-0.0148518896,
-0.0030933716,
0.0252295472,
-0.008884294,
0.0391237028,
0.0007104292,
-0.0190966781,
0.011372529,
-0.0642388314,
-0.0880947858,
0.0485317484,
-0.0499689244,
0.0029974929,
0.0626278445,
-0.0350684524,
0.0015899194,
-0.0521465577,
0.0713871494,
-0.0165594202,
0.006803879,
-0.0798183307,
-0.0208979603,
-0.0575309284,
0.0395821072,
-0.0659356192,
-0.0077531189,
-0.0073199226,
0.0370716415,
-0.0298948493,
0.0284841042,
-0.0034547916,
0.0480840579,
-0.0145849148,
-0.0557632372,
-0.0792215317,
0.0151369013,
0.0454885699,
0.0154550867,
-0.0410858206,
-0.056973435,
-0.0370399244,
-0.0608842634,
-0.0154390382,
0.0198121294,
-0.0195862763,
-0.060453888,
0.000761305,
0.0755518675,
-0.0169300344,
0.0264344402,
-0.0150390938,
0.0289479792,
0.0342454351,
0.0002953801,
0.0063130092,
-0.0998783633,
0.026238367,
0.0209236871,
0.0198772047,
-0.0484074205,
-0.004884135,
-0.0015748786,
0.003216659,
0.0822571218,
-0.0772878081,
0.0019449429,
0.0096315276,
-0.0093497522,
-0.0092846779,
0.0522430055,
0.0403135084,
-0.0185971521,
0.0118621551,
-0.0390527472,
0.0050704977,
0.0420698524,
-0.0104102138,
0.0370478183,
-0.0036787216,
0.043925602,
0.040291395,
0.0269933119,
0.0181270745,
0.0069978782,
-0.0362749398,
0.0328729823,
-0.0469988696,
-0.0031840098,
0.005003952,
0.033797998,
0.0807934254,
0.0344381668,
-0.01928089,
-0.0146149304,
-0.0421092696,
0.0471612811,
0.032715559,
0.0327497013,
0.0260846484,
0.0319023095,
0.0082506305,
-0.0395431444,
-0.0027893165,
-0.0069993269,
0.0233997889,
-0.0378010161,
0.0187650155,
0.0218365956,
-0.0349887386,
0.0235086493,
0.0064928848,
-0.0764085501,
-0.011505791,
-0.0014527243,
-0.0397794954,
0.0360274985,
0.0494271591,
-0.0369773805,
-0.0274422895,
-0.0221193954,
-0.013406761,
0.0068467325,
0.0794970617,
0.0099826027,
0.0191012956,
-0.0545505099,
-0.0136791347,
-0.0287153758,
-0.0020643228,
0.0813838467,
0.0120898932,
0.0008337449,
0.0757778063,
-0.0281371996,
-0.0889770538,
0.0347949639,
-0.0170477349,
0.0003607107,
0.0328985043,
-0.0141356913,
0.0134502277,
-0.0144276628,
-0.0341964215,
-0.0017280397,
0.0107368566,
-0.0031241083,
-0.0068660793,
0.03960618,
-0.0230248794,
-0.0365597084,
0.0329731591,
-0.0824786872,
-0.0294820014,
0.0183014199,
-0.0460875779,
-0.0446401983,
0.0373736322,
-0.0212388746,
0.0082571302,
0.0029730471,
0.0305608865,
-0.0343352817,
-0.0044990811,
0.0102816587,
0.0287965965,
0.0411697775,
0.0189793631,
0.0099200765,
0.0467870608,
0.0626741946,
0.0044703269,
-0.0282876566,
0.0125787379,
-0.0030170046,
0.0329365693,
0.0181271918,
0.0547097996,
-0.042964939,
-0.006492456,
-0.0724482313,
0.0519639738,
0.0026748013,
0.047174558,
0.0547144748,
0.0398487262,
0.0204040445,
-0.0299645495,
-0.0182726067,
-0.0101658516,
-0.0282947831,
0.0093372297,
0.0136334123,
-0.0046707792,
-0.0392861143,
-0.0429040529,
0.0057319589,
-0.0034515238,
0.0380148701,
0.0082040867,
-0.0292034093,
-0.0875582621,
0.0538271405,
-0.012944405,
0.0163166951,
-0.0009767236,
-0.0689260364,
0.0020583912,
-0.0297913495,
0.0246769842,
0.0153859183,
-0.0301926937,
-0.0632846802,
0.0618040003,
-0.0005417637,
-0.0747114494,
0.0187957063,
0.0479229167,
-0.0611199327,
0.0064801839,
-0.0666810721,
0.0190678872,
0.0032703276,
-0.0128401378,
-0.011398538,
-0.0583738983,
-0.0427305028,
0.0009350154,
0.0081086121,
0.0072987271,
0.003014917,
0.0163749978,
0.0133892596,
-0.0269310996,
-0.0666845068,
0.0680884272,
-0.0518986136,
-0.0180912875,
-0.0712585524,
-0.0017445502,
-0.0513077155,
0.032643605,
0.0041212761,
-0.0039185085,
-0.050237298,
-0.0298373364,
0.0020499418,
0.0649772286,
-0.0158485305,
-0.0171790682,
0.0414202921,
-0.0426445268,
0.0133367945,
-0.0076566311,
-0.012497507,
-0.0281291921,
0.0244660713,
0.000583998,
-0.0039821612,
0.0452817567,
-0.0242861807,
0.0085504334,
-0.0070569091,
-0.0044079255,
0.0906130821,
0.0270278454,
-0.0099004544,
-0.0105831251,
-0.0526084751,
-0.0643350706,
-0.0376908854,
-0.0227521304,
-0.0140529769,
-0.0421413444,
-0.0395140946,
0.0427673161,
-0.0101444852,
-0.0872597992,
-0.0410569757,
0.0313692093,
-0.0119772274,
-0.0647304878,
0.0028333936,
0.0426329076,
-0.0371168256,
-0.0184412152,
0.0860288143,
0.0226521678,
-0.0546394549,
-0.0038967053,
-0.0124542844,
0.0306368731,
0.0626016185,
0.0467105322,
-0.0943363234,
-0.0351643935,
-0.023692552,
0.0403341167,
0.0278634019,
0.003949408,
-0.0592799634,
-0.0951578096,
-0.0045201443,
0.0616218075,
-0.0537070036,
-0.0433201194,
-0.0066037322,
-0.0129497219,
-0.0233899076,
0.0062695728,
0.0073836232,
0.0341333412,
0.0332403705,
0.0010621075,
0.00470387,
-0.0190355033,
-0.0057603009,
-0.0377139337,
0.0504533984,
0.0690478384,
0.0468475483,
0.0102731651,
-0.004941273,
0.0117970305,
-0.0483052395,
0.0143049322,
-0.0164698716,
0.0506479219,
0.0106855556,
-0.02219286,
0.0810345411,
0.0001886854,
-0.0559517592,
0.0219323225,
0.047006309,
0.0385815762,
-0.0070543643,
-0.0087407706,
0.0153819351,
-0.0201053843,
0.0198365189,
0.0079226783,
0.0299005974,
-0.0121147288,
0.0106992098,
-0.0430785678,
-0.0263867993,
-0.0884480625,
0.0537464507,
-0.0231420528,
-0.0495529175,
-0.0364376605,
-0.0638858601,
-0.0136811091,
0.0186085589,
0.0314533636,
0.0344060324,
-0.0001039156,
-0.0126937646,
-0.0202111788,
-0.0346717201,
0.0203450527,
-0.0343572199,
0.0220303759,
-0.015416258,
-0.040632721,
-0.0151262674,
-0.0261695869,
0.0010240083,
0.0502275154,
-0.0910487399,
-0.0594753437,
-0.0398093909,
0.0613934025,
0.0123810628,
0.0550722666,
-0.0638821349,
-0.0348402336,
-0.0774863213,
0.0315653384,
-0.0518562272,
-0.0136091132,
0.0356854871,
-0.0207040384,
0.0234879721,
0.0053696758,
-0.0457773469,
0.0051143765,
-0.0055369711,
-0.0111220488,
-0.005729713,
-0.0059044654,
0.0331250727,
0.0618740432,
-0.0076575922,
-0.002416214,
-0.0050527966,
-0.0065485029,
0.0165285207,
0.0134064788,
-0.0406702086,
-0.0413378924,
0.0348445922,
0.0345045179,
-0.0211736355,
0.0407900251,
-0.0149058206,
-0.0029974594,
-0.0076152883,
0.0123512959,
0.018982945,
0.0150213866,
0.0763875023,
0.0290249791,
0.0126159843,
-0.0248495825,
-0.0038019554,
0.0023813965,
0.0230210274,
-0.0588389821,
0.0083854925,
0.0228635259,
0.0217761993,
0.0250227302,
0.0140398387,
-0.0362640284,
-0.029682532,
-0.0118566826,
-0.0065658372,
0.0541309826,
0.0446835123,
0.1148184016,
-0.0250559747,
0.0223471504,
0.0072843228,
0.0516304746,
-0.0239896383,
-0.0336656347,
-0.011985234,
0.0010224103,
-0.0000474773,
-0.0106577231,
0.0772197694,
-0.0410059355,
-0.0128960321,
-0.0202268995,
-0.0248974394,
-0.0258011278,
0.0180599708,
0.0154984929,
0.0012513197,
-0.0092583951,
-0.0405558199,
0.0321671404,
-0.0530090965,
-0.0194226783,
0.0593685322,
0.0194493048,
0.017578505,
0.010474056,
0.0816567168,
-0.0290995315,
0.0077671129,
-0.002079105,
0.0253906194,
0.0141057288,
-0.0503796265,
-0.0441592261,
-4.913400348e-33,
-0.0304219108,
0.0095975585,
-0.0021875752,
-0.0260127299,
-0.005812123,
-0.0226059351,
-0.0399970599,
-0.0295646768,
0.0064300713,
-0.0300395917,
0.0358664766,
0.0215470716,
0.0081199314,
-0.0522459485,
0.0313478559,
0.0303837787,
0.0565820225,
0.0480532534,
-0.0594560429,
0.0388967879,
-0.0018461731,
0.0308446083,
0.0713430941,
-0.0634981617,
0.0059489263,
-0.0312429685,
0.0012686122,
-0.0132626295,
0.0221930351,
0.0094612185,
0.0435290597,
0.0246115141,
-0.0072747772,
-0.0110775968,
-0.0456972159,
-0.0665122569,
-0.0476365052,
-0.0040588044,
0.0477454253,
0.0452570245,
0.0014057057,
-0.0462059416,
0.0562839583,
-0.0521304756,
0.0030794474,
0.019104071,
0.0147146368,
-0.0392652377,
0.0017744326,
0.0203857273,
-0.0654652193,
0.0090850703,
-0.0464501977,
0.0330602042,
0.0164187737,
0.0621389784,
-0.0320710018,
0.0158960316,
-0.0113760559,
0.0039288043,
-0.0048938929,
0.064776957,
0.0911672637,
-0.0173732433,
0.0070286822,
-0.0096743945,
0.0372329317,
-0.0000906292,
0.0444748141,
0.0074125458,
0.0449541993,
-0.000696076,
0.0543781593,
0.0533172078,
0.0469047502,
-0.0399852283,
0.0086703878,
0.0270828251,
0.0009202473,
-0.0094419587,
-0.0053443178,
0.048517812,
-0.0174628627,
-0.0076670181,
-0.0510998033,
-0.0197955053,
-0.0213892516,
-0.0653638616,
0.0322662778,
0.0000617427,
-0.041036699,
0.0429362208,
0.031655848,
-0.0206267498,
0.0187428314,
0.0339624658,
-0.0615052357,
0.0087502766,
-0.0241950788,
0.0193454288,
0.0236526821,
-0.0549986474,
0.0322936624,
0.0056966981,
0.0763517916,
-0.0142089343,
0.0432402305,
-0.005189836,
-0.0494559072,
0.0212853327,
-0.0515214913,
-0.0231198017,
-0.0544838347,
-0.0011776648,
-0.0118794171,
0.007681292,
0.0148088653,
0.002904309,
0.0408813804,
-0.0302708969,
-0.0558466613,
-0.0216755383,
0.0149865607,
0.0124403927,
-0.0530225448,
-0.0016841016,
-0.0257241763,
0.0151839107,
0.0276113115,
-0.0231638961,
-0.0543849729,
0.0311496947,
2.652e-7,
0.0289616082,
0.0407440513,
-0.0015230997,
0.0075149722,
-0.0116563123,
0.0113655971,
-0.0375334509,
0.0258539282,
0.0455361754,
0.0256139413,
-0.005340091,
0.0071988921,
0.0459832475,
0.0470559709,
-0.041947905,
-0.0328982808,
-0.0098537188,
0.0190306064,
-0.0691803768,
0.0012723833,
0.0225071032,
0.0654726699,
0.0033909802,
0.0145539297,
-0.001065482,
-0.0333904848,
0.0015686284,
-0.0225295722,
0.0060838857,
0.0290906206,
-0.0644291565,
0.0243371371,
-0.0489768423,
0.0189037304,
-0.0299288314,
-0.0028296122,
0.0580645725,
0.0295103639,
0.0124687515,
0.0710574016,
0.0477230586,
-0.0260844491,
-0.0132065052,
-0.0529331006,
0.0210741293,
-0.0097496863,
0.0338366814,
0.0149024008,
-0.0393507592,
0.0524591133,
0.0008583367,
-0.0191397071,
-0.0064014718,
0.0157850441,
0.0305795278,
-0.0134887211,
-0.0634103194,
-0.0011139615,
-0.0397898518,
0.0115210302,
-0.0022409132,
-0.045636449,
-0.0410066731,
0.0411419123,
-0.0127915591,
-0.0264925268,
0.045040179,
2.320032333e-34,
0.0331618525,
-0.0392303467,
0.0271785706,
-0.0447729304,
0.0577314012,
-0.029980002,
-0.0254142564,
0.016119279,
-0.007949465,
0.0137883797,
-0.034261819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00310v1 | Unsupervised Lexical Simplification with Context Augmentation | 2023-11-01T05:48:05 | 2023-11-01T05:48:05 | Takashi Wada, Timothy Baldwin, Jey Han Lau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a new unsupervised lexical simplification method that uses only
monolingual data and pre-trained language models. Given a target word and its
context, our method generates substitutes based on the target context and also
additional contexts sampled from monolingual data. We conduct experiments in
English, Portuguese, and Spanish on the TSAR-2022 shared task, and show that
our model substantially outperforms other unsupervised systems across all
languages. We also establish a new state-of-the-art by ensembling our model
with GPT-3.5. Lastly, we evaluate our model on the SWORDS lexical substitution
data set, achieving a state-of-the-art result. | [
-0.0054080365,
0.0545590743,
-0.0079123313,
0.0576197095,
-0.0581572056,
-0.0133714275,
0.0216254611,
-0.0125440797,
-0.0296869241,
-0.0031116221,
-0.0357438326,
0.0378068537,
0.0449323505,
-0.0300816856,
0.0584318601,
-0.0532841682,
0.0488926284,
-0.0275320951,
-0.0558689572,
0.0080060773,
-0.0015222329,
0.020512579,
-0.0216663256,
0.0250394028,
-0.0265071504,
-0.0038805269,
0.0075694704,
-0.0001548623,
-0.0163303353,
0.0242564864,
0.0236830954,
0.0703712478,
0.0077265012,
0.0261924379,
0.0000021343,
-0.0373738445,
-0.0295248125,
-0.0317563526,
0.0171082299,
0.050263904,
0.057790488,
-0.015019861,
-0.0256949086,
0.0028081508,
-0.039076522,
-0.0410981365,
0.0556408688,
0.0302702077,
0.0313465819,
0.0385875553,
-0.0316542462,
-0.0382307135,
-0.0405031741,
-0.0472096652,
-0.0151318181,
-0.0264117401,
0.0127289286,
0.0155847492,
-0.0572343767,
-0.0085816616,
-0.0652130991,
0.0610782057,
-0.0003236971,
-0.0028484268,
0.001427256,
-0.0125119044,
-0.0303784385,
0.0280067362,
0.02860469,
0.0660153925,
-0.0559802167,
-0.0578869693,
0.0036469228,
0.0083789537,
-0.0019570617,
0.0040703556,
-0.0397883393,
-0.0445569456,
0.066017285,
0.0161485206,
0.0182333551,
-0.0330289602,
0.0573646277,
0.00049732,
0.0085323481,
0.0694818869,
0.0653355941,
-0.0164907314,
-0.0321199894,
-0.0102450997,
-0.0039032856,
-0.0599008873,
0.0279272161,
0.0011438098,
-0.0475181043,
0.0342615619,
-0.0461587422,
-0.0627103224,
0.0002763839,
-0.015442064,
0.0137468772,
0.0241199136,
-0.0275939964,
0.0280570537,
-0.0604507923,
0.0096374992,
0.0045239623,
0.0077322177,
-0.0442558937,
0.0029214777,
-0.0046559335,
0.0099958777,
-0.0709886551,
0.004390771,
-0.0582715236,
-0.0106951809,
-0.0532863848,
-0.020431079,
0.0138960537,
-0.0556479283,
0.0066603003,
0.005462917,
-0.0315085128,
-0.0383466557,
0.0082567371,
0.050062757,
-0.0343732908,
0.0337252654,
-0.0270858221,
-0.0395528376,
-0.0214364734,
-0.0018196675,
0.0427126922,
-0.0239119902,
0.0106165223,
0.0377964973,
-0.0453102998,
-0.0453818664,
-0.0268781688,
-0.0190438498,
-0.0141526796,
-0.0049734036,
-0.0673664138,
-0.0851842836,
0.028391175,
-0.0559637062,
0.0027028047,
-0.0455451272,
-0.0018356687,
-0.0156025002,
-0.0229904801,
0.1109087318,
-0.0556241944,
0.0277910568,
0.0050043319,
-0.0031330094,
0.0248154011,
0.0535781085,
0.0180954728,
-0.0138526931,
0.0728390887,
-0.0039457809,
0.0472413376,
0.0773092508,
0.0135924118,
-0.0000104368,
-0.0079115415,
-0.0558194779,
-0.0317269787,
0.0313861035,
0.1064416394,
0.0460575707,
-0.0399442576,
-0.0242440943,
0.0435391217,
0.0370287001,
0.0103938291,
0.0177493785,
0.0584504008,
-0.0043354128,
0.0095050819,
0.0261951033,
-0.0261435881,
-0.0484718755,
-0.0051631532,
0.0324244238,
0.0413787514,
0.0062334924,
-0.031350825,
-0.0137751205,
0.0316539109,
-0.0429691635,
0.0432401411,
0.0050073089,
0.0277525168,
0.0481023416,
-0.0585997291,
0.012247867,
0.0128777036,
-0.0821631923,
0.0248327814,
-0.0262357444,
-0.0348038375,
0.0672045276,
0.0686154068,
0.0116001638,
-0.0581035204,
0.0143762194,
-0.0090081207,
0.009751589,
0.0213958528,
-0.0361843817,
0.0731701255,
-0.0673777759,
-0.0028504871,
-0.0005543602,
0.0042828117,
0.0216721371,
0.0512524508,
-0.0220822468,
0.0327314064,
-0.086422123,
0.006982672,
0.0489689521,
-0.048253797,
-0.049390085,
0.0135411248,
0.0352500714,
-0.0026821655,
0.0193203371,
-0.0039318465,
0.0079571996,
0.0093899481,
-0.0244209878,
0.0080593769,
0.0192177035,
-0.063810803,
-0.0619984977,
0.0639826059,
-0.0306686889,
-0.0282611772,
0.0455389619,
-0.0060983128,
-0.0459112637,
0.0048965421,
-0.0076052891,
0.0366423801,
-0.0456015207,
0.0463572331,
0.0131222811,
0.044198785,
-0.0381233245,
0.0051867538,
0.010326257,
0.0110828066,
0.0258223321,
0.0215703305,
0.0208844729,
-0.0103148427,
-0.0189789105,
-0.0486909598,
-0.0262217894,
-0.0251278318,
0.0169370249,
0.0146038076,
-0.014018883,
0.0322569534,
-0.1036239117,
0.0022398527,
-0.0224842262,
0.0059493072,
0.0651733801,
0.0732391626,
-0.0312907137,
-0.0266869906,
0.0085284458,
-0.0172057338,
0.0213454384,
0.0323421285,
0.030014148,
-0.0271909162,
0.0044965674,
-0.0766888708,
-0.014699812,
0.0162294637,
0.0006460263,
-0.0275943838,
-0.0338859744,
-0.0003931649,
0.0305138249,
-0.0278977454,
0.0428595245,
0.0153836031,
-0.0492822155,
-0.015583274,
-0.0231898576,
0.1042576283,
0.0308039263,
-0.0171963405,
-0.0006456545,
0.0659407377,
-0.0350706801,
-0.0145177916,
-0.0119919926,
-0.0048170537,
-0.0380147398,
-0.0265192855,
-0.0087627769,
0.0137188639,
0.0476497076,
0.0285562109,
-0.0014312086,
-0.0322223306,
-0.0443274304,
0.016499849,
-0.0435831249,
-0.0397494696,
-0.0083989855,
-0.0349021778,
0.0458540656,
-0.0151580386,
-0.0029164546,
0.0301530603,
0.0028760144,
-0.00629345,
-0.0458454415,
0.0054738144,
-0.0166496355,
0.0386366509,
0.0080713881,
0.0297972243,
-0.0403426029,
-0.0235218182,
-0.0478502475,
-0.0360923223,
-0.0090105934,
-0.0255266707,
0.0311901439,
-0.0628706813,
-0.011450327,
0.0075017884,
-0.0261864103,
-0.009806362,
-0.0241147727,
-0.0108607877,
-0.0228092577,
0.0492224135,
-0.0137637639,
0.0151579063,
-0.018812621,
-0.0003445091,
0.1183710694,
0.0105891982,
0.0068325144,
-0.0122851068,
0.0462676659,
0.0424715914,
-0.0004102581,
0.0080583142,
0.0223328844,
0.0069945352,
0.0203679428,
0.0529983267,
-0.0379847363,
-0.0143341562,
-0.006439378,
0.0239598956,
-0.0354195088,
-0.0015856369,
0.0118724247,
0.0248204265,
-0.0216144603,
0.0190301333,
0.1108028442,
0.0355668776,
-0.0087488908,
0.0143563086,
-0.003781985,
0.0040376233,
-0.0042472561,
-0.0043491777,
-0.1072760001,
-0.0254535787,
0.0377860256,
-0.0205459539,
0.0335655846,
-0.0246172901,
-0.0095894923,
-0.1133505777,
0.0330464803,
-0.003110097,
-0.0619411357,
-0.0183885638,
-0.0159127805,
0.0431738794,
-0.0337359644,
-0.0103164017,
0.0343938693,
-0.0108300056,
0.0151417125,
-0.0471143462,
-0.0495171845,
-0.070780769,
-0.0166890305,
-0.0421693996,
0.0471415855,
0.0312857367,
0.0265906658,
0.0133304028,
0.0074134804,
0.0762673169,
0.0106905168,
-0.0233447216,
-0.0169287715,
0.049830474,
0.0341052376,
-0.0317405686,
-0.004384682,
0.0266105235,
-0.0114720697,
-0.03855538,
0.0368388034,
0.0204672255,
0.0452451706,
0.0048734951,
0.026855113,
-0.0057469024,
0.0161669776,
0.0714378133,
0.0347747169,
0.0068793334,
-0.0079564564,
0.0139418328,
-0.0110973641,
-0.0611079447,
-0.0520834476,
-0.0205391832,
-0.0028888904,
-0.044830665,
-0.0743697882,
-0.044574514,
0.0576993339,
-0.0076659583,
0.0258938763,
0.0334932059,
-0.0417336896,
-0.001009825,
-0.0381898433,
-0.0139714582,
-0.0429363362,
0.0302900858,
-0.0411392488,
0.0010172641,
-0.0272764899,
0.0081978636,
0.0082627079,
0.0669300705,
-0.0368634798,
-0.054573603,
0.0099346898,
0.0535161644,
0.0178200044,
0.0500035509,
-0.0320579633,
-0.0473979488,
0.0346592367,
0.0118925693,
-0.0305783432,
0.0527016893,
0.0031882031,
-0.0156221883,
0.0296298694,
0.0435718037,
-0.0047031818,
0.0213510785,
0.0029415695,
0.0468124487,
-0.011702178,
-0.0075015929,
0.0259299167,
-0.0129570197,
0.0785639137,
-0.0518458486,
0.0643572286,
-0.0423954166,
-0.020487478,
-0.0638283715,
0.0286975987,
-0.0092561739,
0.0327388756,
0.0362670049,
0.0301216673,
-0.0165421311,
0.0122768069,
-0.0287312809,
-0.0227064062,
-0.0203346238,
-0.0437742062,
0.0132088233,
-0.0374728367,
0.0044119712,
0.0256202258,
0.011562529,
0.0067901318,
-0.0279034432,
-0.0094294231,
-0.0291895512,
-0.0390568525,
-0.024707403,
0.0015549505,
-0.0519657023,
0.0319104493,
-0.0319638066,
-0.0166787766,
-0.0086275004,
0.0601881742,
0.0681258291,
-0.0610297434,
0.0982299373,
-0.0388750434,
-0.0264349449,
-0.018963797,
-0.0115015712,
-0.0085010007,
0.0140933432,
-0.0180389304,
0.0111944973,
-0.022689376,
0.0462215021,
0.0719783157,
-0.0170910321,
0.0669649914,
0.0297154728,
0.0154551342,
-0.0335379206,
-0.033975821,
-0.0156414136,
0.0569874682,
-0.0295348801,
-0.0130323535,
-0.0064301318,
-0.0820188597,
-0.0291301962,
0.0299799982,
-0.0362834111,
0.0066895513,
0.0441892482,
0.0405400991,
-0.0170528162,
0.0050128228,
-0.0216421504,
0.0084312428,
0.0246723182,
-0.0797455758,
-0.0257486366,
-6.204301795e-33,
-0.0100734681,
0.0049045654,
0.0169332232,
-0.0488873087,
-0.0339540057,
0.002506946,
-0.0628450587,
0.0190481525,
-0.0151808206,
0.0322950222,
-0.027055271,
0.0058113728,
0.0166753791,
0.0051283832,
0.0119948443,
0.0367274433,
0.0748445615,
0.0111175515,
0.0089184502,
-0.0033377514,
0.0015498494,
0.0354326107,
0.0678236634,
-0.0861892998,
-0.0012993696,
0.0121128857,
-0.0452788211,
0.0092211403,
0.0507932939,
0.0324917771,
-0.0195180662,
0.0291195791,
-0.0013852359,
-0.0253062248,
-0.0403884538,
0.0003886528,
-0.0899400935,
-0.0067074946,
0.0694671497,
-0.0056560794,
-0.0531827807,
-0.047785487,
0.0630656853,
-0.0117592011,
-0.0145181334,
0.0202524886,
0.0032690852,
-0.0530861244,
0.0049681645,
-0.015295296,
-0.0947818384,
0.0080851456,
-0.0249665137,
-0.0368903652,
0.0315836146,
0.0174378343,
-0.0142893996,
-0.0390850566,
-0.025902411,
0.0522994958,
0.0430766568,
0.0639310703,
0.0575081706,
0.0012597408,
-0.0066752685,
0.0336824544,
0.0195819996,
-0.0254771449,
0.0254313853,
-0.0101791779,
0.043633081,
0.0316471159,
0.0383477211,
0.0610795505,
0.018859826,
-0.0249168295,
-0.0150746554,
0.0388883874,
0.002437257,
0.001743204,
-0.0186246019,
0.020638993,
0.004887708,
-0.0184171405,
-0.008837712,
-0.0063142441,
-0.0093534235,
-0.0326940939,
0.0250694323,
-0.0179396681,
-0.0162968766,
0.0309464689,
0.011016286,
-0.0099093635,
-0.0243412498,
0.0390462875,
-0.0037373686,
0.0210940186,
0.0100003583,
0.0077606263,
0.0151855983,
0.0354948826,
0.0292922948,
0.0413798951,
-0.016916493,
-0.0037022496,
0.0016875061,
0.0363933705,
-0.0866414458,
0.0182032902,
0.014679105,
-0.0170517638,
-0.0041696825,
-0.0317955464,
0.034425851,
0.0021744205,
-0.0003009736,
0.0212680157,
0.0578483939,
-0.0563104786,
0.0010646082,
-0.0091372998,
0.0071582589,
0.0201061945,
0.0025457738,
0.0182637386,
-0.0308341719,
0.0105885528,
0.0375824273,
-0.0380037799,
-0.0214469433,
-0.04130527,
2.776e-7,
0.0760345384,
0.0348413736,
0.022851659,
-0.0218982771,
0.0023382467,
-0.0101274066,
0.0122832209,
-0.0098627722,
-0.0255148988,
0.037512742,
0.0714793503,
0.015975967,
0.0127798896,
-0.019306846,
-0.0557725579,
0.0448256768,
-0.0354412235,
-0.0259599574,
-0.0518274233,
-0.0228516646,
0.0230143033,
0.085120514,
0.0302613862,
-0.0323603414,
-0.0305092502,
-0.0197429787,
0.004714618,
-0.052490022,
-0.0367416926,
0.0060012075,
0.001109023,
0.0050350232,
0.0138452994,
-0.013394787,
-0.0218663793,
0.0001353192,
0.0468255468,
0.0770269111,
-0.008739722,
0.0593364686,
0.0009768306,
-0.0378414914,
-0.0217254218,
-0.0428955518,
0.0966685489,
-0.01818607,
0.0283423103,
-0.0389001667,
-0.0204195958,
0.0646784082,
0.0434996933,
-0.0262489673,
-0.0656451657,
0.0303094257,
0.0489913896,
0.0303540807,
-0.0470123701,
-0.0700206533,
-0.0375936702,
0.0164078176,
-0.0055447211,
0.0171428639,
-0.0194192175,
0.008441723,
0.0125449281,
-0.020289395,
0.0160917435,
2.410417518e-34,
0.0226757303,
0.0282023437,
0.0320476107,
-0.0180929191,
0.0221193489,
-0.0450360179,
-0.010586014,
0.0421931818,
-0.0168567728,
-0.0375357568,
-0.0326453149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00306v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00306v1 | Probing Explicit and Implicit Gender Bias through LLM Conditional Text Generation | 2023-11-01T05:31:46 | 2023-11-01T05:31:46 | Xiangjue Dong, Yibo Wang, Philip S. Yu, James Caverlee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can generate biased and toxic responses. Yet
most prior work on LLM gender bias evaluation requires predefined
gender-related phrases or gender stereotypes, which are challenging to be
comprehensively collected and are limited to explicit bias evaluation. In
addition, we believe that instances devoid of gender-related language or
explicit stereotypes in inputs can still induce gender bias in LLMs. Thus, in
this work, we propose a conditional text generation mechanism without the need
for predefined gender phrases and stereotypes. This approach employs three
types of inputs generated through three distinct strategies to probe LLMs,
aiming to show evidence of explicit and implicit gender biases in LLMs. We also
utilize explicit and implicit evaluation metrics to evaluate gender bias in
LLMs under different strategies. Our experiments demonstrate that an increased
model size does not consistently lead to enhanced fairness and all tested LLMs
exhibit explicit and/or implicit gender bias, even when explicit gender
stereotypes are absent in the inputs. | [
0.0557567552,
0.0692718402,
-0.041697856,
0.0158964209,
-0.006640675,
0.0132257584,
0.073223643,
0.00554553,
0.0231552534,
-0.0899746567,
0.005024401,
-0.0321432464,
0.0185859501,
0.018858159,
0.0513174422,
-0.0126469964,
0.0173966996,
0.0331711359,
0.020067174,
-0.0310164299,
0.0253540743,
0.02496011,
0.0401460603,
0.0415502228,
-0.0081455484,
-0.0129068857,
0.0423323065,
0.0129902959,
-0.0078423955,
-0.0199045055,
0.0544521138,
0.058848761,
-0.0048526167,
-0.001360637,
0.0000019383,
-0.0819712877,
0.0182917304,
0.0223054476,
0.020208884,
0.0254408922,
0.0245483369,
0.0015535494,
-0.002962501,
0.0428667814,
-0.0099331746,
-0.0018320245,
0.027406726,
0.0322455242,
0.0457023978,
0.0154319098,
-0.006042433,
0.0447638407,
-0.0636792108,
-0.0155633315,
0.012790177,
0.0260621216,
0.040974699,
-0.0529313646,
-0.0714837164,
-0.0006150231,
0.01233414,
-0.0082960865,
-0.0076960018,
0.0009114781,
-0.0033794746,
0.0119353449,
-0.0149714667,
-0.0655987486,
0.002451591,
0.0443487763,
0.0232349075,
0.0076396666,
0.0100577427,
-0.027267104,
0.028793551,
0.0104898112,
-0.0266286489,
0.0508798771,
-0.0123995272,
-0.0369813442,
-0.0141460337,
-0.0003303591,
0.0143342726,
0.068104133,
0.0171800125,
0.0793160647,
0.0283261072,
-0.0500539318,
-0.0135820601,
-0.0020966916,
0.005173522,
-0.0694126785,
-0.0187225863,
-0.0125727262,
-0.0034751152,
0.0181158967,
-0.0268982891,
-0.0285730809,
0.0615791082,
-0.0623126812,
0.0243716072,
0.0410601646,
0.0166568737,
-0.024653174,
-0.0336137041,
0.0443200171,
-0.0071452782,
-0.0123991491,
-0.0084392922,
0.0019658036,
0.029086899,
-0.0413339809,
0.004517552,
-0.01326105,
0.0153095638,
0.042225264,
-0.0538873747,
-0.0052958801,
-0.0538549237,
-0.0017759583,
-0.0025267629,
0.0380874909,
-0.012789961,
0.0078075356,
-0.0098254923,
-0.0178526677,
-0.0638969988,
0.0373833254,
-0.0224256087,
-0.0847637132,
-0.0032923161,
0.0339868888,
-0.0098136999,
-0.0327961482,
-0.0126785543,
0.0724423751,
0.0080266818,
-0.0213292688,
-0.0200883076,
-0.0424509346,
-0.0424303226,
-0.0577792339,
0.0056853616,
-0.0762797371,
0.0002159488,
0.0467741005,
-0.0060358327,
-0.033867646,
0.0284572393,
0.0388824567,
-0.0212965086,
0.0308346115,
0.0805881098,
-0.0006604339,
0.0652669072,
0.0367839113,
-0.026959369,
0.090234451,
0.0487255901,
0.0178213157,
0.0226028077,
0.0074236128,
-0.0110063525,
0.0482211933,
0.0601030253,
0.0609661713,
-0.0555595569,
0.0380315557,
-0.0117582232,
0.0268026963,
0.0471683815,
0.0122808879,
0.0116401203,
0.0008562797,
0.0644536465,
0.0463163704,
0.0174894072,
0.0457649939,
0.0663892403,
0.0016263726,
-0.0311041325,
0.0253735054,
-0.068167299,
-0.0165370572,
-0.022322733,
-0.0364738256,
0.0218344238,
0.0362572372,
-0.005573615,
-0.043586228,
-0.0234443638,
0.0131029189,
0.0201435927,
0.015079543,
0.0065562846,
0.040927913,
-0.0292020831,
0.0558976904,
0.042808339,
-0.0778216422,
0.018129088,
-0.0678159744,
0.0400575884,
0.0366014242,
0.0157223269,
-0.0097435946,
0.0301058386,
-0.0430952422,
-0.0353192464,
0.0407741293,
0.0699074045,
0.0264128782,
-0.0234212205,
-0.0332247764,
-0.0041717659,
0.0225873794,
0.0378826223,
0.0431599915,
0.066798754,
0.0417932197,
0.0383499712,
-0.0174061805,
-0.0434783809,
0.0245334301,
-0.0112336343,
-0.0453973114,
0.0387070887,
0.002548798,
0.0205429234,
-0.007394373,
-0.0332074612,
0.0153265214,
-0.0133318268,
-0.0122149242,
-0.0258080196,
-0.0027682325,
-0.0598388873,
-0.000828086,
-0.0138082113,
-0.0429985523,
-0.0710035339,
0.019538153,
0.0063652541,
0.0265394282,
0.0488454141,
-0.0183153357,
-0.0073095816,
-0.0249787699,
-0.0026444364,
-0.021598829,
0.0278105903,
-0.0418437943,
0.0221404973,
-0.0195507407,
-0.007921488,
0.0221449472,
-0.0167612396,
-0.0100273946,
-0.0518850684,
-0.0228668489,
-0.0066778148,
-0.006557785,
-0.0042746235,
0.035703849,
-0.0174938105,
-0.0265154801,
-0.0569746569,
-0.0470206589,
-0.0145643773,
0.0009762855,
-0.0305895135,
0.0079818442,
0.0133824283,
-0.0241723601,
0.036314588,
-0.0273985285,
-0.0366459638,
0.0381733142,
0.0424706712,
0.029241167,
-0.0283790436,
0.0053262124,
-0.0430113263,
-0.014291185,
-0.0541285947,
0.0706899315,
0.0601232201,
0.0112298448,
-0.0350467376,
0.0178863369,
-0.0415590852,
-0.0249817893,
0.0031197756,
-0.0531284846,
0.0221336968,
0.0381991267,
0.0575747378,
0.0611036271,
0.060789872,
0.0200955961,
0.0431496017,
-0.0046145138,
-0.0601742901,
-0.0294032115,
0.0091066426,
0.0293461047,
0.0302698743,
-0.1119984463,
0.008312135,
0.021775322,
0.045642402,
-0.0182246808,
-0.0567878969,
0.0777212828,
-0.0494471341,
-0.075458169,
-0.0082754614,
-0.0559025221,
-0.012356814,
0.0288227778,
-0.0215591155,
-0.0763672963,
0.033466015,
-0.0167329498,
0.0104380911,
-0.0013685423,
0.0037905895,
-0.0448783785,
0.0389210433,
-0.0134552363,
0.0309098605,
0.0115715628,
0.0048039029,
-0.0603927001,
-0.0586241633,
0.0297322106,
-0.0179723967,
0.0207111165,
-0.031968601,
0.022516435,
0.0143406615,
-0.0225608498,
-0.0605555326,
-0.0608014688,
0.0165786929,
-0.0127428202,
0.0330278501,
-0.0106985765,
-0.0000648085,
0.0385648794,
0.0108776148,
-0.001723088,
-0.0385568067,
-0.0015827253,
0.0142038176,
-0.0108421938,
0.0404736549,
-0.0188897531,
0.0608041771,
-0.0332946815,
0.0105668548,
0.0299904868,
-0.0309693571,
0.0370827019,
0.0132523505,
0.0239278488,
0.0181245264,
-0.0240909941,
0.0175967682,
-0.0012818731,
0.0258733742,
-0.0486427732,
0.0094086835,
0.0793233067,
0.0263289493,
-0.0481890664,
0.0181352664,
-0.0084186597,
0.0508475192,
0.0304779205,
-0.0078210523,
-0.0767218843,
0.0112988427,
0.0289153699,
0.0065219165,
-0.0883526281,
-0.0525541045,
-0.0447078161,
-0.1454660892,
-0.0063233385,
0.006089502,
-0.0059069954,
0.0046494091,
-0.0168420486,
0.0098082535,
0.0186174959,
0.0251785945,
0.0035043645,
-0.0039240476,
0.0068224524,
-0.0200194996,
-0.0446660519,
-0.011477069,
0.0259875339,
-0.0246643107,
0.0419917852,
0.0100428304,
0.0505814478,
-0.023340961,
0.0140189668,
0.0626199469,
-0.0184488017,
0.0056211795,
-0.0375474468,
0.0074856742,
-0.0335667096,
-0.0074646287,
-0.0549812578,
0.0370349362,
0.0684746802,
0.0162635501,
0.0215420965,
-0.0074164593,
0.0317202322,
-0.0376428664,
-0.0477652326,
0.0023049763,
0.033705961,
0.0810125768,
0.0232530348,
-0.0472389683,
-0.0182567332,
-0.0525901094,
-0.0004521707,
0.0087287333,
-0.0760071278,
-0.0248807389,
0.0211271923,
-0.0129023548,
-0.0517280847,
-0.0538344719,
0.0153797613,
-0.0315018147,
0.0155644957,
-0.0783388093,
0.0008185938,
-0.0041349013,
-0.0558264516,
0.0217941981,
0.0145937353,
0.028500881,
0.029245887,
-0.0229229592,
-0.0279887803,
-0.0424505137,
-0.0180245377,
0.0574043356,
-0.0188418031,
-0.0565328039,
0.032829199,
0.050227344,
0.0186856221,
0.0423110984,
0.027429428,
-0.0275121946,
0.0524725802,
0.0397436805,
-0.0283783171,
0.0554507263,
0.0118983099,
0.0438688435,
0.0272328909,
0.0305508655,
-0.0472201556,
0.0328670368,
0.0080701094,
-0.0023603635,
0.0061800163,
-0.0275493022,
0.0098270196,
0.0213656593,
-0.0172790196,
-0.0519862212,
0.0235018749,
-0.0397320539,
-0.0145748975,
-0.0572189502,
-0.0625403076,
-0.011639758,
-0.0297660362,
-0.0066614775,
0.0272097122,
-0.0267148912,
-0.0329117924,
-0.0753569081,
0.0447274521,
-0.0118065644,
0.0263774917,
0.0073717618,
0.0459697396,
0.0293767154,
-0.0099104866,
-0.0105077559,
0.0105163548,
-0.0553329885,
0.0091371126,
0.0297573153,
0.0195169058,
0.0042209653,
0.0239503756,
-0.0434495807,
-0.0060398607,
0.0002188271,
-0.0008509117,
-0.000442062,
0.0114843566,
-0.0269557051,
-0.0275717061,
0.063220419,
-0.0064163301,
-0.0091571724,
0.0084047439,
-0.0046224729,
-0.0046523702,
-0.020652147,
0.0282124616,
-0.0016693958,
-0.0171515141,
-0.0183544774,
0.0381118171,
0.0512879454,
0.0614481457,
-0.0250779893,
-0.0224874355,
-0.0284727048,
-0.0248142276,
0.0437926166,
-0.0467803292,
0.003682255,
-0.0026869094,
-0.0860157311,
-0.0427871123,
-0.0243955497,
-0.0105328327,
0.0363727473,
-0.0196596887,
-0.0174331553,
0.069892779,
-0.0165401772,
-0.0315369442,
-0.0153141264,
0.0082845343,
-0.018805109,
-0.0281697642,
-0.0308158249,
-6.114442966e-33,
-0.035547629,
-0.0766383633,
-0.0338293873,
-0.0352683626,
-0.0253244285,
0.0148768099,
-0.0219299421,
0.0041319528,
0.0260022618,
0.0031027165,
0.0120410779,
0.0139730573,
0.0041571124,
-0.0182822384,
0.0029335476,
-0.0022711658,
0.0578562059,
-0.0099420594,
-0.0504483283,
-0.0195106547,
-0.0110698119,
0.0046316674,
-0.0183921773,
-0.0491558015,
0.1073158234,
-0.0385668948,
-0.0288235247,
-0.0167848486,
-0.0454360172,
0.0135302814,
-0.0084489193,
0.0577861592,
0.025867058,
0.0012496526,
0.0150057115,
0.1040361822,
-0.02519756,
-0.0333155841,
0.0161726605,
-0.0002695094,
0.0269623157,
-0.0244416147,
0.0329493694,
0.0235812999,
-0.0529664494,
-0.032718312,
0.0598220862,
0.0132232551,
0.0692150742,
-0.0040592235,
-0.0497631989,
0.0259604864,
-0.0424544401,
0.0176512823,
-0.028880585,
0.0613726117,
-0.0036861945,
0.0226294827,
-0.0442963652,
0.0518493503,
-0.0047064014,
-0.0068563861,
0.0124861635,
0.0143622067,
0.0294354502,
0.0408311896,
0.0455317087,
0.0564431436,
-0.0429137684,
-0.0569530353,
0.0195086189,
-0.0458379947,
0.0344321579,
0.0776095465,
0.0173803866,
-0.033120051,
-0.054632239,
-0.0428416096,
0.0431347713,
-0.0017007055,
0.0383397415,
-0.0505368598,
-0.0594169348,
-0.0569935367,
-0.0457714126,
-0.0567238592,
-0.0260464419,
-0.0317332372,
0.0539073013,
0.0098722782,
-0.0719087273,
-0.0314022265,
-0.0025170324,
-0.0320401825,
-0.0338361561,
0.0096379351,
-0.0328079909,
-0.0585540012,
0.022580348,
0.0052607711,
-0.0432597697,
0.0251214951,
0.0165740047,
0.0267340858,
0.0327450112,
0.0180084575,
-0.0164763574,
0.0092233475,
-0.0701494217,
-0.0018191801,
-0.0190785788,
0.0163731072,
0.002631309,
0.0162071008,
0.0078094825,
0.0397548713,
-0.008694387,
-0.0134399263,
0.0570035838,
0.0110182809,
-0.045060575,
0.0080095194,
-0.0130964229,
0.0682821944,
-0.0399411507,
-0.0037960063,
-0.0108593581,
0.0112608969,
0.0661707968,
-0.0397988595,
-0.0102290763,
-0.0548457243,
2.495e-7,
-0.0198165327,
0.0749171376,
-0.0147865843,
0.056442827,
0.0079216873,
0.0355833583,
0.0306714885,
0.0329220742,
0.0656437948,
0.0016994404,
-0.0429105312,
0.0271744374,
-0.0004992854,
0.0332411304,
-0.0336802974,
0.0334751718,
-0.0962543339,
0.0331540145,
-0.0137496851,
-0.0082312226,
0.0232670624,
0.0293651596,
0.0278528985,
-0.0012494542,
-0.0360184647,
-0.0238461513,
0.0598620735,
-0.0157875083,
-0.008535929,
0.0237367414,
0.0024981077,
-0.0242033172,
0.0342392698,
0.022908004,
0.0249297563,
-0.0036228488,
-0.004823273,
0.0169827715,
0.0072153658,
0.0120378053,
0.0000934181,
-0.0072177323,
-0.0287615284,
-0.0781223774,
0.0540082753,
-0.0029226823,
-0.0196319465,
-0.0481872521,
-0.0155449873,
-0.0236926991,
0.0800956711,
-0.0324711576,
-0.026822878,
0.0149489511,
0.0161871649,
0.0300486907,
0.0139535069,
-0.0342688598,
-0.0519371442,
-0.0495632365,
-0.0362784229,
-0.0937645435,
-0.0403049961,
0.0439949334,
0.0085432213,
-0.0262561813,
0.040685825,
2.198801443e-34,
0.0116349002,
0.0218201913,
0.0107705425,
-0.0330223069,
0.0464618057,
0.022596065,
0.0092454413,
0.0089498516,
0.0595619455,
-0.0211855192,
-0.0079583386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00301v1 | Detecting Syllable-Level Pronunciation Stress with A Self-Attention Model | 2023-11-01T05:05:49 | 2023-11-01T05:05:49 | Wang Weiying, Nakajima Akinori | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | One precondition of effective oral communication is that words should be
pronounced clearly, especially for non-native speakers. Word stress is the key
to clear and correct English, and misplacement of syllable stress may lead to
misunderstandings. Thus, knowing the stress level is important for English
speakers and learners. This paper presents a self-attention model to identify
the stress level for each syllable of spoken English. Various prosodic and
categorical features, including the pitch level, intensity, duration and type
of the syllable and its nuclei (the vowel of the syllable), are explored. These
features are input to the self-attention model, and syllable-level stresses are
predicted. The simplest model yields an accuracy of over 88% and 93% on
different datasets, while more advanced models provide higher accuracy. Our
study suggests that the self-attention model can be promising in stress-level
detection. These models could be applied to various scenarios, such as online
meetings and English learning. | [
-0.0237113573,
-0.0469181202,
-0.0120030213,
0.0062605105,
-0.0180558842,
-0.0427855924,
0.0487921946,
-0.0079529565,
0.0264993813,
0.002949395,
-0.0455597006,
-0.0199499913,
0.0232437998,
-0.0453394018,
0.046478644,
-0.0422166288,
0.0209606513,
-0.0134951491,
0.0849078894,
-0.0058053611,
0.0432863683,
0.0149838533,
-0.0235827714,
0.0356226079,
-0.1012988165,
-0.0183517616,
-0.0291050095,
0.0628789887,
0.0280788336,
-0.0079173008,
0.0025789775,
0.0643603727,
-0.0266411584,
-0.0467017703,
0.0000018036,
-0.0474204086,
-0.0021899771,
-0.024703972,
-0.019107841,
0.0400556661,
0.0419382639,
0.0311143771,
-0.0505961441,
0.0319509171,
0.0176323671,
0.0535275973,
0.0568074211,
-0.0240422636,
0.0575508773,
0.049845133,
-0.0067776497,
0.0151046757,
-0.0184969902,
-0.0215703361,
-0.0229697134,
-0.0132669862,
0.0325441137,
0.0008915525,
0.0092092669,
-0.0576144233,
-0.0427891165,
0.0333660208,
-0.0420380719,
0.0035703245,
-0.0162094515,
0.017272871,
0.0187011119,
-0.0194962416,
0.0029371246,
0.030371327,
-0.0516269654,
-0.0092831394,
0.0132930465,
0.0113394875,
0.0004336915,
-0.0135310218,
0.0095838122,
-0.014613606,
-0.0046553337,
0.0054145246,
0.0616468675,
0.0539740585,
-0.0574578941,
-0.0362299606,
0.0084839631,
0.0277032107,
-0.0108315963,
-0.0744169727,
0.0114913825,
-0.0056230938,
0.0343227908,
0.0060762861,
0.0649013147,
0.0201422945,
0.050497178,
0.016960742,
-0.0004916225,
-0.1030834839,
0.0074415621,
-0.0466682911,
0.0265360158,
-0.0115274061,
-0.0347346812,
0.0042191274,
0.0589036196,
0.0323988013,
0.0168627016,
-0.0607741661,
-0.0303633511,
0.0172302425,
0.0367953628,
0.0607974567,
-0.0552635491,
0.012548103,
0.0136835752,
-0.0135450121,
-0.0341692455,
-0.0247783475,
-0.0364677571,
-0.0440671518,
0.0591941625,
-0.022897955,
-0.0437917598,
0.0042158454,
0.0763725638,
0.0381181985,
-0.0316202231,
-0.0192971397,
-0.043933142,
-0.0748344734,
0.0105798505,
0.0224087555,
0.0539073274,
0.023555588,
0.004975101,
-0.0266123023,
0.0266753677,
-0.0255390909,
-0.0514519177,
-0.0290087014,
-0.0927901641,
-0.0296179932,
-0.0592663772,
-0.0452125631,
0.0209662635,
-0.0525605865,
0.0061086682,
-0.0374174677,
-0.0162565224,
-0.0097156055,
0.0326780453,
-0.0001028948,
0.000881188,
0.0843405053,
0.0221799612,
-0.0186274592,
0.0324215032,
-0.0037368899,
0.020811284,
0.0046508037,
0.0295862146,
-0.0746860281,
0.0249308255,
0.0401748493,
0.0137700764,
0.0004333067,
0.0132726505,
-0.0449925922,
-0.0634170175,
0.0281460993,
0.0548532493,
0.0236299597,
0.0438093804,
-0.0333159156,
0.101823695,
0.0537768081,
0.0523411222,
0.021123698,
-0.0193793364,
0.0590213872,
0.0120208291,
0.0237028413,
-0.010318079,
0.0092720101,
0.0051213135,
0.0394248962,
0.0739673525,
0.0293272194,
-0.0399480648,
-0.0563415922,
-0.0683620721,
-0.020434998,
-0.0538332909,
0.020662304,
0.0368819907,
-0.0167870689,
-0.0137832677,
0.0510026067,
0.0420079008,
-0.0694144964,
0.0249229558,
0.0169329774,
0.0460878871,
0.0498194918,
-0.0205987599,
-0.0587975718,
-0.0098533761,
-0.0278401989,
0.0237008184,
0.0242608022,
0.0114141097,
0.022417523,
0.0129854325,
-0.0262978543,
0.0086925179,
0.037755277,
-0.0106439739,
-0.001310972,
-0.0256753955,
0.0363897644,
-0.0237331409,
-0.0170853119,
0.0047796941,
0.0082139308,
0.0405274406,
-0.0616249777,
-0.0071562165,
0.0198579095,
0.0629735813,
0.0677639097,
-0.0250850618,
0.0137565928,
0.0401389673,
-0.0042566285,
0.0341298394,
-0.0087928548,
-0.0282725953,
-0.011297849,
0.0481589884,
-0.028010767,
0.0055836518,
-0.0048153573,
0.0303692296,
-0.0626472235,
0.0541237518,
-0.0673946962,
0.026566701,
-0.0268969014,
0.0236250889,
0.0290704835,
0.0698078945,
0.0199262295,
-0.0236659609,
-0.0121319154,
0.0046467981,
-0.0436981991,
0.0074552959,
-0.0363148339,
-0.0881346315,
-0.0435467251,
-0.016523866,
-0.055553399,
0.0479680076,
-0.0170991197,
-0.0255779792,
-0.0267983805,
0.0025519275,
-0.0496005788,
-0.0156475361,
-0.0028921154,
0.0310808644,
0.0187028069,
-0.0035140458,
-0.0348315574,
-0.0235856976,
-0.0154924234,
-0.0287535302,
-0.0412491821,
-0.0030363027,
-0.0352112688,
-0.0525352545,
0.0299186781,
-0.0526440255,
-0.0369592831,
-0.0374590792,
-0.028441919,
0.0230374038,
-0.0421226211,
-0.0299002696,
-0.0127194226,
0.0085073598,
-0.0064521506,
0.0739061087,
-0.0670961291,
-0.0097951181,
-0.0146937352,
0.1035554036,
0.04361476,
0.014005499,
0.0023008918,
0.0330480933,
-0.0447916351,
-0.0209692474,
0.0416043811,
0.0024070225,
0.0324727371,
0.0036531773,
-0.0361642689,
0.0186673701,
0.0570081063,
0.0479553044,
0.0144625427,
-0.0601191521,
-0.0359537639,
-0.037296623,
0.0034686958,
0.0227456577,
0.0208588969,
-0.062320862,
0.0034435808,
0.0082431063,
-0.0144293085,
0.0617113374,
-0.0609786659,
-0.0442518592,
-0.0373881571,
-0.031210795,
0.0061351657,
-0.0123093901,
-0.071357891,
0.0352458768,
0.0645288154,
-0.0487214625,
0.0322737135,
0.0273952633,
0.0042619943,
-0.0525183678,
0.0137062054,
0.0038187108,
-0.0506557003,
0.0402642787,
0.0004700208,
-0.0119643304,
0.0076587964,
-0.0447423607,
-0.0248861276,
0.0006926556,
-0.0063274377,
0.0374750867,
0.0250850115,
-0.0178990141,
-0.001477943,
0.0061197886,
0.0201904364,
0.0321922936,
0.0511503071,
0.0117443753,
0.0318240859,
-0.0369431898,
0.0328735486,
0.0055029411,
0.0203002058,
0.0379117616,
0.0203698948,
0.0128830448,
-0.0090095028,
0.0178511664,
-0.0462424308,
0.0219696835,
0.0299858097,
-0.0322289728,
-0.0633815154,
0.0205717366,
0.0985986292,
-0.0056467573,
0.0026757075,
0.0280559044,
-0.0384956598,
0.0187945943,
0.018616423,
0.0250128098,
0.0496967323,
-0.0090390593,
0.0318992212,
0.0427287705,
0.0235857312,
0.0031568264,
0.0256500524,
-0.0483197123,
0.0440336987,
0.0106359692,
0.00633279,
0.0162400808,
-0.0241066944,
0.0427551307,
-0.0328217037,
-0.0438654833,
0.003011524,
-0.020791471,
-0.0347441174,
0.0220757499,
-0.0755034536,
-0.0078989733,
0.0291433632,
-0.035923738,
0.0360114314,
-0.0080655459,
0.0576230139,
-0.0041555171,
-0.0648088902,
0.0400009863,
-0.0342333056,
-0.0042399787,
0.0029943038,
0.069581598,
0.0106266607,
-0.0184812229,
-0.0414107256,
0.0275031738,
-0.0258678906,
0.0432808511,
0.0186708588,
0.0671133175,
0.0282872338,
-0.0366748162,
-0.0077727484,
0.0454038009,
0.0344224609,
0.0281916112,
0.0494630896,
-0.0575647093,
-0.0376154706,
0.0110224625,
0.0561507419,
0.0450366884,
-0.0615759641,
0.0141104413,
0.0202386305,
-0.0674982816,
-0.0647648945,
-0.0430229008,
-0.0153929088,
0.0168715976,
0.0221634023,
-0.0190390814,
0.0140593275,
-0.0012138629,
-0.0150056658,
0.0088996058,
-0.0038651507,
0.0489118695,
-0.0742399022,
-0.0054686801,
0.018539194,
-0.0158227906,
0.0121303536,
0.019771643,
0.0019274316,
-0.0402084142,
0.0626814514,
-0.0018653328,
0.0109132007,
0.0023231928,
-0.0536844209,
-0.0408458859,
0.010753178,
-0.0880456418,
-0.0501838885,
-0.0000174013,
0.0817685053,
-0.027796587,
-0.0259975716,
0.0263090767,
-0.0111652305,
0.0568800941,
-0.0413001142,
-0.0031303491,
-0.0266295541,
-0.1352394819,
-0.0014192311,
0.0334162563,
0.0855080262,
0.0065618246,
-0.0405105464,
-0.0325313583,
0.0022190406,
0.0460137837,
0.0497904979,
-0.0024763134,
-0.0357842147,
0.0013471314,
0.0135351727,
-0.0045694816,
-0.0149202468,
-0.0178629681,
-0.1205513999,
0.0157639738,
0.0705195218,
0.0045389934,
0.0016785044,
-0.0316827931,
-0.020285992,
-0.0206644554,
0.0294037927,
0.0162730347,
0.0153131783,
0.0328909568,
-0.0146148643,
-0.0380930193,
-0.0305030532,
0.0416840091,
0.0323355719,
0.0051058349,
0.0682490915,
-0.0239284765,
-0.0298499633,
0.0465333872,
-0.028813893,
0.0500627831,
0.018479757,
0.0236826017,
-0.048301369,
-0.0018335559,
-0.0588866062,
0.0013715666,
0.0041585937,
-0.0153766684,
-0.0012901706,
0.0280820485,
0.0182035994,
0.0212390125,
-0.0252155345,
0.032649532,
0.0120543884,
-0.0387649573,
0.0100104604,
-0.0751041919,
0.0001346351,
-0.0320566855,
-0.0061910511,
-0.0615524389,
-0.0711117238,
0.065651685,
-0.0055900919,
0.0245579295,
-0.0407225452,
0.039224606,
-0.0169724766,
-0.0434045009,
-0.0001978842,
-0.0182501152,
-0.0035352858,
-0.042627316,
-0.0081820739,
0.039692957,
-5.934683799e-33,
0.0065123704,
-0.0487884879,
-0.0384502113,
0.0626989007,
-0.0203569196,
0.0644553676,
-0.0450915247,
0.0177564677,
-0.0270149745,
0.0072017633,
-0.0206851661,
-0.0068737199,
0.0134941489,
-0.0196959097,
0.0116347251,
0.0033451954,
0.0413385555,
-0.0064625056,
0.0179213863,
0.0126135554,
-0.0151140066,
0.0308136195,
0.0436346866,
-0.0645387247,
0.0222792607,
-0.030308241,
-0.0119957579,
-0.0297952276,
0.0129924603,
0.0481582806,
0.0140206646,
0.0809452981,
-0.0055921939,
-0.0720077381,
-0.0075313584,
0.0609067567,
-0.0764379427,
-0.0267123729,
-0.0324145034,
-0.0027293249,
0.0157726593,
-0.0143976035,
0.0093102483,
0.0381731726,
0.000319682,
-0.0457306802,
0.0338872075,
0.0030533671,
0.0233026054,
-0.0476324707,
-0.0104148872,
0.038691543,
-0.0469039194,
-0.0365055054,
0.0634503812,
0.0539624766,
-0.0035122666,
-0.0252913348,
-0.0192383099,
0.0334004238,
0.0241757482,
0.0453991964,
0.0591681078,
-0.0293929279,
-0.0401898958,
-0.0520089045,
0.0300494786,
-0.0446252935,
0.0241787564,
-0.0067229443,
0.0142151453,
0.0595525652,
0.0734317452,
-0.0091925133,
-0.0248998851,
-0.0098186415,
0.0049456791,
0.0128623564,
0.0547039695,
0.0323773883,
-0.0094933817,
0.0198844951,
-0.0836476684,
-0.0038707878,
0.0365803204,
-0.0307915136,
-0.0264715794,
-0.009438525,
0.031846948,
-0.0307632536,
-0.0091166422,
0.0373122208,
0.026124062,
-0.0018791964,
0.04375045,
0.0003176756,
0.0345088281,
0.0216524731,
0.0185330249,
0.0322036967,
-0.0440204591,
0.0357260294,
0.0248991549,
0.0419469625,
0.0164813325,
-0.0000427197,
-0.0065076947,
0.0308838021,
-0.0585448295,
-0.0098588942,
0.0246914309,
0.027638454,
-0.0244900174,
0.0118228132,
0.02577997,
-0.0108435694,
-0.0019722548,
0.0203909744,
0.0435011052,
0.0130998278,
-0.0095327459,
0.0188765265,
-0.0087534161,
0.0106874472,
-0.0240110606,
0.0053894063,
0.0031980793,
0.0223444216,
0.0190531742,
0.0190733131,
-0.0212263837,
0.0186952353,
2.636e-7,
0.0028190899,
0.0227897055,
0.0093784463,
-0.0564303473,
0.02828498,
0.0157809537,
-0.0222688988,
0.0172086637,
0.0083694924,
-0.0008783106,
0.0282388646,
-0.0469603501,
0.0842682123,
0.0108586866,
-0.1003066674,
-0.0544041842,
-0.0554786362,
0.0430060066,
-0.0291900747,
0.0325961336,
0.0244190507,
0.0594680458,
-0.0026481072,
-0.0059183445,
0.0002971214,
-0.0278719664,
-0.0426534675,
-0.0102624428,
0.0340849422,
-0.0190826971,
0.0566068478,
-0.0469063111,
-0.0346166864,
0.0118019907,
-0.0542291403,
0.0305949021,
0.014586308,
0.0558526963,
-0.0263998937,
-0.0414260551,
0.0223462451,
0.04796803,
-0.0217734519,
-0.0443967991,
0.0213203318,
0.0252590012,
0.0003546442,
0.0111209219,
0.0030134749,
0.0029182145,
0.0052187392,
-0.0030328431,
-0.0020396898,
-0.014220763,
-0.005111272,
-0.0403018259,
-0.041693978,
-0.0128031373,
-0.0352403447,
0.0145062525,
-0.0164411422,
0.0312107429,
0.0118622417,
0.0005684755,
-0.0086437427,
-0.0262871888,
-0.0226736758,
1.436941628e-34,
-0.0098575894,
-0.033159297,
0.0245385077,
-0.0028011319,
-0.0166521035,
-0.0344828628,
-0.0090739289,
-0.0095069194,
0.0392092951,
-0.0110319722,
-0.0461412221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00300v1 | Entity Alignment Method of Science and Technology Patent based on Graph Convolution Network and Information Fusion | 2023-11-01T05:04:55 | 2023-11-01T05:04:55 | Runze Fang, Yawen Li, Yingxia Shao, Zeli Guan, Zhe Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | The entity alignment of science and technology patents aims to link the
equivalent entities in the knowledge graph of different science and technology
patent data sources. Most entity alignment methods only use graph neural
network to obtain the embedding of graph structure or use attribute text
description to obtain semantic representation, ignoring the process of
multi-information fusion in science and technology patents. In order to make
use of the graphic structure and auxiliary information such as the name,
description and attribute of the patent entity, this paper proposes an entity
alignment method based on the graph convolution network for science and
technology patent information fusion. Through the graph convolution network and
BERT model, the structure information and entity attribute information of the
science and technology patent knowledge graph are embedded and represented to
achieve multi-information fusion, thus improving the performance of entity
alignment. Experiments on three benchmark data sets show that the proposed
method Hit@K The evaluation indicators are better than the existing methods. | [
0.0067690401,
0.006584127,
0.0081472499,
0.0155965341,
-0.0217717718,
-0.0190469548,
-0.0319430344,
0.0056914892,
0.0290258136,
-0.0189767852,
-0.0209321547,
0.0283708498,
0.0400516987,
0.003661084,
0.0484032631,
0.0140311485,
0.0124144154,
0.072610721,
0.0187171698,
0.0001638762,
0.0115698157,
0.031716276,
-0.0018248144,
0.0267946143,
-0.0137564465,
-0.0040538707,
0.0257017501,
0.032756865,
0.0783698931,
-0.079982467,
-0.0322348922,
0.0068566231,
0.0058433027,
0.026689006,
0.000001503,
-0.0504402928,
-0.0441470183,
0.0373917557,
0.0110786054,
0.0120132891,
0.0214799102,
0.0033716362,
0.0110570686,
0.0166723225,
-0.0127255302,
0.0091068484,
0.0285926443,
0.0498870313,
-0.0041242684,
0.0438521206,
-0.0203487314,
-0.0529500619,
0.0754040331,
-0.0178581327,
-0.0469278805,
-0.0747852549,
0.0376490019,
0.0403865166,
0.0348513536,
-0.0300324447,
-0.0124229454,
0.0557297021,
-0.0466052778,
-0.0231882539,
0.1034896523,
0.0396406874,
-0.0064375256,
0.0416331403,
0.002579465,
0.1040092632,
0.0015679384,
-0.0056023812,
0.020297138,
-0.004666002,
0.0344090536,
0.003406154,
-0.0154106254,
-0.0261585452,
-0.0102290278,
0.0260871258,
-0.0036784657,
-0.0135860872,
0.0238373671,
-0.0086097019,
-0.0071806218,
0.0560193546,
0.0103728753,
-0.0076785651,
-0.0294822212,
-0.0325544402,
0.0363229811,
-0.0504775904,
-0.0002602187,
0.0130092483,
0.0061474089,
0.0224897955,
-0.0692411065,
-0.0739305243,
0.0073411837,
-0.034015432,
-0.0033700552,
0.006199257,
0.0125665199,
0.083993122,
-0.0741884485,
0.068412371,
-0.044521533,
0.0651431382,
-0.0177159198,
-0.0624080636,
-0.0798474923,
-0.0092638368,
-0.0234860629,
0.0346855149,
0.0277484301,
-0.060046088,
-0.0596291795,
0.003177614,
-0.038481541,
0.0537404045,
-0.0163515899,
0.0226908997,
0.0462408327,
-0.0304510947,
-0.0474573635,
0.0239102747,
0.0000252014,
0.0047347164,
-0.0312969759,
0.0006139051,
0.0276993345,
-0.0008120984,
0.0490220003,
-0.0120782461,
-0.0037410196,
-0.0028461674,
0.0489889644,
-0.0039138952,
-0.029621467,
-0.0235718098,
0.0500580035,
-0.016083248,
0.0231343322,
-0.0156634878,
0.0696894228,
-0.0266412199,
-0.0225597601,
-0.0648391098,
0.0048256665,
-0.0308303181,
-0.0468100384,
0.0610806681,
-0.0772244707,
0.0145059759,
0.0204351004,
-0.041705288,
0.0175176375,
-0.0282805413,
0.0423522219,
-0.0331282392,
-0.0051035234,
-0.0231979433,
-0.0547670536,
-0.024642054,
0.0530582853,
-0.0486602411,
0.0233475324,
-0.0004367893,
-0.0268604551,
0.041842632,
-0.0091081019,
0.0238511525,
-0.002034476,
0.0249754023,
0.0340943746,
0.0383981578,
0.0457503945,
-0.0020727867,
-0.0358413011,
0.0153515656,
-0.0268555488,
-0.0163965914,
-0.0100599704,
0.0283435918,
-0.0580943786,
0.0204402339,
0.0298336688,
0.0383953452,
-0.0163601618,
0.0116034951,
-0.0016458519,
0.0249410719,
0.0446490571,
-0.0472834818,
0.0446335413,
-0.0187441222,
-0.0195543338,
0.0439183637,
-0.0083235074,
0.0296191014,
-0.0246578641,
0.0045518242,
-0.0477962345,
0.014527726,
0.0260013789,
-0.0023519145,
-0.0950849503,
0.0067889434,
-0.0499124154,
0.0214110296,
0.0225104839,
-0.0167458542,
-0.0692937896,
-0.024525648,
-0.0622655116,
-0.0164372344,
-0.0354881473,
0.0221640263,
-0.0116468631,
0.0581789427,
0.033673957,
-0.0804302245,
0.0532328226,
0.0146643072,
-0.0035711383,
0.0328010134,
-0.0181984194,
0.0260167476,
0.007155777,
0.0616801754,
-0.0121666677,
0.0307370499,
0.0400993191,
-0.0201445073,
-0.0220911019,
0.0213280693,
0.0538492762,
-0.025311647,
0.0518084839,
-0.0447139554,
-0.0049695466,
-0.0184458587,
-0.0308495797,
-0.0344587602,
-0.0108041149,
-0.0250789635,
0.0380972065,
0.0312716998,
0.0188542381,
-0.0204165056,
0.0130231632,
-0.0300641097,
0.0408379436,
0.0001504552,
0.0368234739,
-0.0005625441,
-0.0001686175,
0.0511918776,
-0.0449664332,
0.0115960697,
0.0019794137,
-0.0104569606,
0.0042033815,
0.0130651621,
-0.0838521346,
-0.0236771032,
0.0281504802,
-0.0807942674,
0.0236625597,
0.0321722738,
0.0329978466,
-0.0039256797,
-0.0290795192,
0.0298898332,
0.0050785448,
-0.0505340472,
0.018905269,
-0.0277492516,
-0.0781496614,
0.0631766692,
-0.0080662109,
-0.0679343417,
-0.021701334,
-0.0274405442,
-0.057396397,
0.0215022508,
0.060636837,
-0.0603632182,
-0.0585726388,
0.0035047936,
-0.0492693372,
0.0179837737,
-0.0056296298,
0.0302620586,
-0.0152778504,
0.0307343137,
-0.0302604008,
-0.0022208903,
-0.0172383823,
-0.0275406148,
-0.0063389945,
0.0259184521,
-0.0272748526,
0.0138622802,
0.0284953024,
0.1014017761,
0.0312223006,
0.0284311939,
-0.0080600064,
-0.0296039972,
-0.0033365078,
-0.00159207,
-0.0182394329,
-0.0486990251,
0.0139835831,
0.0276029445,
0.0072334511,
-0.026645327,
0.0329498127,
-0.0323667824,
-0.0316887572,
0.0177127849,
0.0727932602,
-0.0378823765,
0.0390347615,
-0.0184592865,
-0.0126926443,
-0.008574089,
0.025520185,
0.0330854878,
0.0355445296,
0.0077366061,
-0.0231596977,
-0.019783495,
0.0095392326,
0.0400349349,
-0.0377715863,
-0.0081429016,
0.0442499407,
0.0684301332,
-0.0355117992,
0.0276493207,
-0.029134443,
0.0105565526,
0.0265167598,
0.0370989479,
0.0258063469,
-0.0362184308,
-0.0292578246,
0.0077043716,
0.0000606722,
-0.0329398364,
0.0442673489,
0.0089886077,
-0.0157635175,
0.0851008371,
0.0530972704,
-0.0294823535,
-0.0062357876,
0.0302729476,
-0.014392986,
0.015585009,
-0.0117197381,
0.0102794589,
-0.0278377663,
-0.0612404607,
-0.0230129976,
-0.0396505333,
-0.025881039,
-0.0199203584,
0.0278446451,
-0.0026926035,
0.1129459515,
0.0339086689,
0.0097149573,
0.0687290281,
0.0036887315,
0.0801837295,
-0.0516058765,
0.0183617268,
-0.0189824756,
-0.0951458365,
0.0259232633,
-0.0578546897,
-0.0393112302,
0.0215072297,
-0.0362280384,
-0.0045926212,
-0.0854236931,
-0.0206780136,
0.0201052204,
-0.0353317894,
-0.0725621507,
-0.0258313231,
0.0226331446,
0.0240526088,
-0.0284465775,
-0.045539543,
0.0301943701,
-0.0512513742,
0.0019619835,
-0.0129695619,
0.0070196954,
-0.0121123362,
-0.0667206421,
-0.0009429835,
0.048010014,
0.0724135041,
-0.0127443988,
-0.0306673571,
-0.0220104735,
0.0252508186,
-0.0346912071,
0.0375181362,
0.0123918755,
-0.0225606728,
-0.0167954527,
0.0028938267,
0.0072662942,
-0.0115747573,
0.014274966,
-0.0447580144,
0.0526810996,
0.0179036744,
0.0230218526,
-0.0727587268,
-0.0478851348,
-0.0081159584,
0.0329998136,
-0.0115371495,
0.0075471438,
-0.0002556692,
0.014436584,
0.0397627167,
-0.0344830938,
0.0777010769,
0.0496017858,
-0.0590998083,
-0.0078904778,
-0.0871039554,
0.0045239846,
-0.0166763235,
-0.0071923109,
0.0105772046,
0.034559086,
0.0549526587,
-0.0378793739,
-0.036541041,
0.0123050455,
0.0105571132,
0.0302661359,
-0.0081822202,
0.0164314769,
0.0304263029,
0.0219053272,
-0.0312928408,
-0.0143888621,
-0.0188716371,
-0.0827207789,
-0.0900089815,
-0.075267911,
-0.0015762941,
0.0305476673,
-0.0602453798,
0.0036573953,
0.0780436546,
0.0240637213,
0.0210681409,
-0.0496021658,
-0.0430985242,
-0.045017533,
-0.0524964258,
-0.0275100823,
-0.031981606,
0.0049901577,
0.0116880015,
0.0182716139,
0.0041320985,
-0.0719637573,
0.0058225761,
0.0862699002,
0.0415628403,
0.0042574033,
0.0564138666,
-0.0435939841,
-0.0046428731,
0.0252719745,
0.0116351712,
-0.0135024926,
-0.0394847058,
0.0031720281,
-0.0327882096,
0.0066622505,
-0.0040085404,
0.0495193265,
-0.0202713255,
-0.0573564991,
-0.0291933212,
-0.0485873856,
0.008060596,
0.0264469646,
-0.0081338705,
-0.0097940108,
0.0173949655,
0.0002315506,
-0.006652337,
-0.0529064611,
-0.0155729586,
0.0264296792,
0.0092946319,
-0.0168441087,
0.0352742076,
-0.008377864,
-0.0075115417,
-0.0509137996,
0.0272728782,
0.0838078335,
0.062933974,
0.0248611532,
-0.0210682247,
-0.0125807337,
-0.0141380252,
0.0420314446,
-0.0203737002,
-0.0156828146,
0.0689053461,
0.0095668528,
-0.002555069,
-0.0071448903,
0.0171424747,
0.0444617644,
0.0269482359,
-0.0841167122,
-0.0266165212,
-0.0339635238,
0.0133203845,
0.0166689362,
0.0142878564,
-0.013029201,
0.0095501756,
-0.0196084436,
-0.0210015252,
0.0686347857,
0.0146835158,
-0.004746139,
0.0177701786,
0.0113275014,
0.0012054978,
0.0192965623,
-0.0369125269,
0.0295023229,
-0.0165504981,
-0.0135204662,
-0.0331959389,
-0.000324907,
-5.158079497e-33,
-0.0220391341,
-0.0583116002,
-0.00097058,
0.0140760643,
-0.0371887162,
-0.0047671925,
-0.0177274719,
-0.0309056714,
-0.0616793446,
0.0291540101,
0.0029252272,
0.0108485268,
-0.0033181128,
-0.0150005072,
-0.038949728,
-0.0179113019,
0.0071345791,
0.0382229127,
0.004495698,
0.0067649148,
0.0046342704,
0.031170601,
0.0476815179,
-0.1036821306,
0.0096601835,
0.0124172661,
0.0149343954,
-0.0175994039,
0.0112351803,
0.0472697839,
0.0225584991,
-0.0026339239,
-0.0032799351,
-0.0413556099,
-0.003357491,
-0.0069777742,
-0.07099998,
-0.0094776293,
-0.0194974635,
-0.0016476254,
0.0011498793,
0.0113082696,
0.0504613295,
-0.0066461805,
0.0036118948,
-0.0134200975,
0.0705153495,
0.0144585157,
-0.0589653626,
-0.0674684346,
-0.0607246608,
0.0255610198,
-0.0020362278,
0.0372857489,
0.0316681974,
-0.0624858253,
0.0302707292,
0.0322919711,
-0.0739705414,
0.0127583789,
-0.0342019685,
-0.0246066395,
0.0215700082,
0.004995272,
0.0265275836,
0.023911899,
-0.0371870399,
-0.0021839833,
-0.0023497208,
0.017052982,
-0.0060970183,
0.0688703805,
0.0315964669,
-0.0208208878,
-0.0082045896,
-0.0352941751,
-0.0793095902,
0.0386956185,
-0.0189225804,
-0.0121827628,
-0.0286742803,
0.0495864451,
-0.0015466397,
0.0065070391,
0.0356039703,
-0.0023026601,
0.0144772958,
-0.0037598531,
-0.0175527558,
-0.0166980345,
-0.0126493108,
0.0795460343,
-0.0242037009,
-0.1059309542,
-0.0234508105,
0.0462503433,
0.0339607,
0.0730061606,
-0.0235325657,
-0.0160395261,
-0.0419760458,
-0.0443732515,
-0.011064617,
0.0155567583,
0.0266266502,
0.0196521841,
0.0243229382,
-0.0471374542,
0.0014491341,
0.0162096508,
-0.0087026963,
-0.0728009418,
-0.0314661041,
-0.0718027204,
0.0365817845,
0.0314686038,
0.0267549325,
0.0140224965,
0.0681450665,
0.0280357972,
0.0010778937,
0.0096367076,
0.0426537469,
-0.0014236694,
-0.0042002336,
0.0228427853,
-0.0081813559,
0.0074890298,
-0.0081752175,
-0.0115355942,
-0.0134743657,
0.0297545996,
2.385e-7,
0.0499236248,
0.0140598845,
0.055355344,
0.0203389321,
-0.0291496441,
0.0142824613,
-0.000792525,
0.0754794329,
-0.0454578064,
-0.0250911228,
0.0365790837,
-0.0419675447,
-0.0185015872,
0.0263432041,
-0.048218444,
-0.053464599,
-0.033082597,
0.0074095796,
-0.0321118087,
0.0664058924,
0.0788324252,
0.0191435479,
0.0418771841,
0.0135729304,
0.0114525994,
-0.0346909165,
0.0297318455,
0.0366298109,
0.0304246992,
0.0382786877,
0.0440903418,
-0.0113607459,
-0.0496933945,
0.0656694695,
-0.0252725501,
0.0726542622,
0.0222780816,
-0.0249829683,
-0.0427211002,
0.0449685678,
-0.0184930731,
-0.0501386747,
0.018990159,
-0.0068388274,
0.0159515571,
0.0088864258,
-0.039926704,
0.013014962,
-0.0002392482,
0.0405182838,
0.0084581552,
0.0453572646,
0.0209972635,
-0.0165307876,
0.015549168,
-0.0299697295,
-0.0101072323,
-0.0847223401,
0.0188264493,
0.0271189641,
0.0060233949,
0.0050314669,
0.0108741419,
-0.0277219322,
0.072311841,
-0.0249814689,
0.01479619,
1.9123919e-34,
0.0045182547,
-0.039647527,
0.0195790734,
-0.0026560598,
0.0210187566,
-0.0166862719,
0.0263511129,
0.0139989015,
-0.0298850425,
-0.0571427755,
0.0052740709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00296v1 | Semantic Representation Learning of Scientific Literature based on Adaptive Feature and Graph Neural Network | 2023-11-01T05:00:44 | 2023-11-01T05:00:44 | Hongrui Gao, Yawen Li, Meiyu Liang, Zeli Guan, Zhe Xue | cs.CL | cs.CL | Because most of the scientific literature data is unmarked, it makes semantic
representation learning based on unsupervised graph become crucial. At the same
time, in order to enrich the features of scientific literature, a learning
method of semantic representation of scientific literature based on adaptive
features and graph neural network is proposed. By introducing the adaptive
feature method, the features of scientific literature are considered globally
and locally. The graph attention mechanism is used to sum the features of
scientific literature with citation relationship, and give each scientific
literature different feature weights, so as to better express the correlation
between the features of different scientific literature. In addition, an
unsupervised graph neural network semantic representation learning method is
proposed. By comparing the mutual information between the positive and negative
local semantic representation of scientific literature and the global graph
semantic representation in the potential space, the graph neural network can
capture the local and global information, thus improving the learning ability
of the semantic representation of scientific literature. The experimental
results show that the proposed learning method of semantic representation of
scientific literature based on adaptive feature and graph neural network is
competitive on the basis of scientific literature classification, and has
achieved good results. | [
0.0142184589,
-0.0394782908,
-0.007759375,
0.001764324,
-0.0143160392,
-0.0018159075,
-0.008800664,
-0.0036168424,
0.0789788067,
-0.0614898391,
-0.0052541005,
0.0218960959,
0.0184342805,
0.0203852206,
0.0143007487,
-0.0204655603,
0.0329249464,
0.0555332117,
0.0863340199,
-0.0228166115,
-0.0120390719,
-0.005835739,
0.0237389766,
0.0067575076,
0.0387021154,
-0.0438232906,
0.0309349187,
-0.0030193904,
0.0427176468,
-0.058563944,
-0.0209619384,
0.0022726392,
0.0060649817,
0.0236887597,
0.0000016427,
-0.0476388745,
-0.0308293588,
0.0133290673,
0.0382970683,
0.0011470615,
0.0896449089,
-0.0215783007,
0.0361757465,
-0.0241172388,
0.0018385838,
-0.0077620954,
0.0351265781,
0.0677462965,
-0.0099353027,
0.0392338112,
-0.0044890479,
-0.078987211,
0.0374196693,
0.0171668325,
1.633e-7,
-0.0309286397,
0.0361563489,
0.0364419967,
0.0307033248,
0.056128215,
-0.0383961909,
0.020268349,
-0.0301717892,
-0.0125770066,
0.1081976146,
0.0292898193,
-0.0078894822,
0.0551210754,
0.0307995938,
0.0858588442,
-0.0114076957,
-0.043773897,
0.0239032637,
-0.0369855277,
-0.0134702921,
0.041313529,
-0.0332799032,
-0.0164471995,
-0.0086047808,
-0.0097599402,
0.0111977663,
0.00386174,
0.0453163795,
-0.0154181067,
-0.0244079269,
0.0657311976,
-0.0081400247,
-0.0105838515,
0.0108647626,
-0.0332291536,
-0.0224359818,
0.0362919681,
0.0187112968,
0.0137660513,
0.0105552301,
0.01339495,
0.008007939,
-0.0749438107,
0.0196601301,
-0.0316394679,
-0.0033615283,
-0.0028639392,
0.0151640167,
0.0550850667,
-0.0244035907,
0.0489150025,
-0.0315301716,
0.0524118058,
-0.0365981311,
-0.0018218247,
-0.0586692877,
-0.0186212491,
-0.0054654945,
0.0611720234,
0.0598490313,
-0.053598538,
-0.0317358896,
-0.0022560023,
0.005120649,
-0.0125155263,
-0.0173836555,
0.0506514721,
-0.0153666977,
0.0145544596,
0.0008264682,
0.0359473079,
0.0138434339,
0.009179391,
-0.0388811752,
0.0695838556,
0.015352698,
0.0163501855,
0.0456174202,
0.0322482511,
-0.0058749244,
0.0490105674,
0.075889416,
-0.032102339,
-0.024887478,
-0.0233311877,
0.018300632,
-0.0274163354,
0.0454148017,
-0.0215422995,
0.0121483998,
0.0117408363,
-0.0088888686,
-0.0271567069,
-0.0066348678,
0.0012836076,
-0.0398075022,
0.0379504785,
-0.0518355966,
-0.0303819086,
0.0420590341,
-0.028637629,
0.0305762701,
0.0034009344,
0.0488722399,
-0.0024773383,
0.0293033849,
-0.0010653693,
-0.0591822341,
-0.0614309646,
0.0505428687,
-0.0305368491,
0.0062458953,
-0.0320822001,
-0.0510383062,
0.040247269,
-0.0073581119,
0.0068528024,
-0.0170729924,
-0.0465604179,
-0.0116746379,
0.0528306402,
0.024001183,
0.0532665215,
-0.0128049841,
0.0447366238,
-0.0105899442,
0.0409669019,
-0.0026055444,
0.0507026762,
-0.0179066639,
0.0304193199,
-0.009770547,
-0.0297256764,
-0.0172264073,
0.0160611477,
0.0262531657,
0.0111791501,
0.0645855963,
-0.0512594134,
0.0663115978,
-0.0119959656,
-0.0292533003,
-0.0009226211,
0.0552420914,
0.0048725805,
0.00294292,
0.0438286811,
0.0035345289,
0.0002719976,
0.0212978944,
-0.0398687348,
-0.050559517,
0.0107251136,
-0.0504527166,
-0.0130418884,
-0.0042975442,
0.0088093709,
-0.0692372024,
-0.0229196493,
-0.0390428118,
-0.0437509976,
-0.0156003991,
0.0233381707,
-0.0542599633,
0.0292246435,
0.0354036391,
-0.0605691411,
-0.0402188785,
0.0247349925,
0.0013713838,
0.0152506242,
-0.0063983835,
-0.0298402626,
0.0209473595,
0.0183254126,
0.0071206843,
0.0335916765,
0.0531431288,
-0.0326588526,
-0.0209715236,
-0.0060283435,
-0.0500711016,
-0.0286582932,
0.0506182164,
-0.0740032718,
0.0393559262,
0.0262053199,
-0.0138399554,
-0.050418023,
0.0821235925,
-0.0498134382,
0.0014002227,
0.0291474834,
-0.0087628439,
-0.04246426,
0.027270643,
-0.0110861436,
0.0419900939,
-0.0105324984,
0.0703903288,
-0.0028002653,
0.0045906911,
0.0101570282,
-0.046663437,
-0.0113719627,
0.0098473933,
0.0465634726,
-0.0231058765,
0.045930665,
-0.0515928566,
-0.0093432628,
0.0231702477,
-0.0429615192,
0.0047376221,
0.0137603991,
-0.0059148008,
0.0132350707,
-0.0328434072,
0.0529522859,
-0.0121447751,
-0.0158753823,
0.0736187249,
-0.05057998,
-0.0651242957,
0.0325913988,
-0.035801895,
0.0073831244,
-0.0141217131,
-0.0398953222,
-0.0669691339,
0.041187495,
0.0495607108,
-0.0504846759,
-0.0423389338,
0.0045781541,
0.0011791545,
0.0254303887,
-0.0272171348,
0.0086998073,
-0.0149070006,
-0.009497229,
-0.0170730557,
0.064109832,
0.0123750884,
-0.0138766011,
0.04459868,
0.0306331906,
-0.0307497475,
-0.0056673461,
-0.0467091948,
0.0832458884,
-0.0105054369,
0.0085889176,
0.0044794474,
-0.0417382009,
0.0207790677,
-0.0229802541,
0.0063276174,
-0.0067047812,
-0.0088495146,
0.0138811851,
-0.0095687956,
0.0104994001,
-0.0081179934,
-0.0642979965,
0.0147430524,
0.0147282826,
0.0378877632,
-0.0124820117,
0.0196010973,
-0.0568662323,
0.0013977167,
-0.0387573168,
0.0049821967,
0.0483065359,
0.0230095685,
0.0037744395,
-0.0375462882,
-0.0283218585,
-0.0030133957,
0.0083348434,
-0.0182243902,
-0.0285776295,
0.038442377,
0.001614283,
-0.0001612761,
0.072379604,
0.0092406841,
-0.0223514233,
-0.0092733363,
0.0694076195,
0.01717728,
-0.0344906934,
-0.0295775272,
-0.007316574,
0.0396630168,
0.0075575206,
-0.0179859959,
0.0034306475,
-0.0208866522,
0.0417204686,
0.0666358843,
-0.004729575,
0.0286894795,
0.0143309804,
-0.0145548433,
0.0420574285,
-0.0380508266,
-0.0067408038,
-0.0656750053,
-0.0266707875,
-0.0271435827,
-0.0578837022,
-0.0227686185,
-0.0313509591,
-0.0210263506,
-0.0337722786,
0.0499822348,
0.0395621471,
0.0026993011,
-0.0901373401,
-0.0116999652,
-0.0242492557,
-0.0417267717,
0.0323922746,
-0.0124508357,
-0.05623734,
0.0156449489,
-0.042313423,
-0.0103872987,
0.0201307274,
-0.0407568701,
-0.0023565614,
-0.012911371,
-0.0310979355,
0.0286146477,
-0.0416286439,
-0.0245660972,
-0.0469449796,
0.0006629406,
0.0129496036,
-0.022182107,
0.0018154059,
-0.0120461183,
-0.0364581384,
0.0046459795,
-0.0080117118,
0.0006407293,
-0.0169015117,
-0.0046978267,
-0.0187835172,
-0.0156192658,
0.0638342872,
-0.0331788436,
0.007484871,
-0.0315980464,
0.0032315005,
-0.0234775599,
0.0105291642,
0.0306974333,
0.0282855462,
-0.0000907832,
0.0014639245,
0.0089868652,
-0.028157901,
0.0118232844,
-0.0166788287,
0.0927644446,
-0.0070025609,
-0.0201992504,
-0.0902746469,
-0.0109122274,
-0.0304918941,
0.0051248162,
0.0089369901,
0.0024239223,
-0.0296341181,
0.020146979,
0.0384561978,
0.021258086,
-0.0363946967,
0.0284497738,
-0.0410818867,
-0.0397449993,
-0.0576941334,
0.0115150753,
-0.0401823744,
-0.0058908407,
0.0000983607,
0.041626852,
0.0930457413,
-0.040117044,
-0.0546714403,
-0.0103048831,
-0.0047421777,
-0.0286814403,
0.041038949,
0.0053309905,
0.0907251611,
-0.0158373173,
-0.0253959391,
-0.0298847556,
0.0354270414,
-0.0404166654,
-0.0343369618,
-0.0236851592,
-0.0050725904,
0.0088308705,
-0.0534746684,
-0.0591518506,
0.0917287767,
0.0158979408,
0.0045701824,
0.0007649435,
-0.0001614413,
-0.0236996561,
-0.0348492563,
-0.003400001,
-0.0448943339,
0.0240267701,
-0.0199346468,
-0.0217368174,
-0.0323129706,
-0.0396430194,
0.0019114012,
0.0636548474,
0.0456741154,
-0.0079466281,
0.0023699591,
-0.0027937994,
-0.0167798009,
0.0027711561,
0.0063638058,
-0.0041504218,
0.0155930957,
-0.0160437971,
-0.0275784209,
0.000116746,
-0.0347051434,
0.0135276793,
-0.0112223458,
-0.0194113478,
0.0072747669,
-0.0226577483,
0.004799902,
-0.0090698199,
0.0397084765,
-0.035724055,
-0.0479346998,
-0.0204299539,
-0.0196368061,
-0.0272523109,
0.0012213354,
0.0493037812,
0.0090940911,
-0.0882904604,
-0.0051837191,
-0.0981474966,
0.0183461122,
-0.0268807393,
-0.0036818373,
0.0572870634,
0.0301414523,
0.0028454883,
-0.0082729999,
-0.0089260414,
-0.0453056805,
0.0442014858,
-0.0107860314,
0.0041380837,
0.0489583723,
0.0080277501,
-0.005876421,
-0.0053768987,
0.0418697447,
0.0459203534,
-0.0339886062,
0.0112812091,
-0.0204952825,
-0.0236000977,
0.0070845941,
-0.024398312,
0.074269034,
0.0073778168,
0.0369351059,
-0.0110234804,
0.0023317768,
0.0932366177,
-0.0258855391,
0.0047809957,
-0.0369158313,
0.0387736447,
-0.017015649,
-0.0046207262,
-0.0182876121,
-0.0348392837,
0.0637701601,
-0.0370409451,
-0.0120577198,
-0.0270544663,
-5.51606822e-33,
-0.0037710858,
-0.072267808,
-0.0384697132,
0.0491734743,
-0.0414341427,
0.003942362,
-0.0652303398,
-0.0327004232,
-0.0274454392,
0.0441360101,
-0.0112260859,
0.0406469665,
-0.0275466088,
-0.022324631,
0.0066150981,
0.0134699894,
-0.0023307088,
0.0170500204,
0.0231536813,
0.0707027465,
0.0887619555,
0.031272348,
0.0651394278,
-0.1399060786,
-0.0059393779,
-0.0554512814,
0.0639512911,
-0.0331673361,
0.0366715007,
0.044271078,
-0.0026795736,
0.0413929671,
0.0145533914,
-0.0403500088,
-0.0172724966,
-0.0278551877,
-0.050727427,
-0.0686311275,
-0.0132664647,
0.0010589658,
-0.0171918347,
-0.0393278226,
0.0781477243,
0.0087687289,
0.0070543657,
-0.0381505266,
0.1163757294,
0.0031514431,
-0.080262199,
-0.0395762809,
-0.0468823574,
0.0191595685,
-0.0305621475,
0.0901224837,
0.0103494423,
-0.0205553956,
-0.0062683984,
0.0771023408,
-0.0194892064,
0.0193224829,
-0.0311978832,
0.0084648617,
-0.0518089421,
-0.0071991556,
0.055377651,
0.0358026586,
-0.0044073435,
-0.0173935182,
0.0034393759,
-0.0215790663,
0.0437235013,
0.009862233,
0.0396552198,
0.0357613191,
0.0046817171,
-0.0392256677,
-0.0687796324,
-0.009809752,
0.0165018886,
0.0541622452,
0.0309581533,
0.0161786918,
0.0242796503,
-0.0094463956,
0.0373532325,
-0.0027786123,
-0.0027081843,
-0.0253614634,
-0.0503455438,
-0.0497546233,
-0.0378059149,
0.0463672318,
-0.0116646308,
-0.0875468031,
-0.0104539078,
0.1117379367,
0.0259729382,
0.0574623048,
0.0109199062,
-0.0048989495,
-0.0683119372,
-0.0561957918,
-0.0114169177,
-0.0012211631,
0.0230071936,
0.0003679344,
0.0162739288,
-0.0120665589,
0.0381101929,
-0.0357611775,
0.0284326226,
-0.1079091057,
-0.0241058748,
-0.0033271364,
-0.0050698309,
0.0015762569,
0.0121581554,
0.0590829812,
0.0449341945,
0.063933,
0.0198847335,
0.0189182572,
0.0486577004,
0.051075127,
-0.0400985591,
-0.0290882289,
0.0048292563,
0.0578923449,
-0.0080715753,
-0.0407901332,
-0.0068447157,
-0.0004774489,
2.606e-7,
0.0379521288,
0.0124141928,
-0.0021660863,
-0.030909596,
0.0252424888,
0.0253291652,
0.0051113158,
0.0546835884,
0.0076937289,
0.0134694399,
0.0345413014,
-0.0328949615,
-0.0711282492,
0.0105693974,
-0.0828455761,
0.0172789618,
-0.0618955493,
-0.0028314113,
0.0228745416,
0.0572805963,
0.0081778225,
0.0264436919,
0.0159774274,
0.0186555702,
0.0123018175,
-0.0522112809,
0.0477856733,
0.0132474126,
0.0401911475,
0.0045795091,
0.0027148891,
0.0221328661,
-0.0340220407,
0.0058158697,
0.0095371362,
0.0608853661,
0.0095611783,
-0.0110425372,
-0.0190322269,
-0.0098332809,
0.0375582576,
-0.0079470193,
0.0345257968,
0.0150896572,
0.0219166335,
-0.0732646585,
-0.0631237626,
-0.0291129816,
-0.017244,
0.0300007574,
-0.0043091956,
0.0271639209,
0.0122915432,
-0.0036010032,
-0.0206072275,
-0.04424759,
0.0207670983,
-0.082122609,
0.0172081944,
0.0738117769,
-0.0132147865,
-0.012797731,
0.0186989158,
-0.0229480863,
0.0517153665,
-0.0210220963,
0.0318365283,
1.996342056e-34,
0.0611336119,
-0.0161129758,
-0.0282484926,
0.0160792954,
-0.0506326742,
-0.0402642377,
-0.0223266948,
0.0116034131,
0.0391624942,
-0.0482933745,
-0.0030909409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00292v1 | IBADR: an Iterative Bias-Aware Dataset Refinement Framework for Debiasing NLU models | 2023-11-01T04:50:38 | 2023-11-01T04:50:38 | Xiaoyue Wang, Xin Liu, Lijie Wang, Yaoxiang Wang, Jinsong Su, Hua Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | As commonly-used methods for debiasing natural language understanding (NLU)
models, dataset refinement approaches heavily rely on manual data analysis, and
thus maybe unable to cover all the potential biased features. In this paper, we
propose IBADR, an Iterative Bias-Aware Dataset Refinement framework, which
debiases NLU models without predefining biased features. We maintain an
iteratively expanded sample pool. Specifically, at each iteration, we first
train a shallow model to quantify the bias degree of samples in the pool. Then,
we pair each sample with a bias indicator representing its bias degree, and use
these extended samples to train a sample generator. In this way, this generator
can effectively learn the correspondence relationship between bias indicators
and samples. Furthermore, we employ the generator to produce pseudo samples
with fewer biased features by feeding specific bias indicators. Finally, we
incorporate the generated pseudo samples into the pool. Experimental results
and in-depth analyses on two NLU tasks show that IBADR not only significantly
outperforms existing dataset refinement approaches, achieving SOTA, but also is
compatible with model-centric methods. | [
0.0308790244,
0.0252392739,
-0.0204020925,
0.0251536835,
0.0069966419,
0.0417947061,
0.0497687645,
-0.0624100417,
0.0407834165,
-0.0623753369,
-0.0223377962,
0.0224716533,
0.0038706332,
-0.0147849722,
-0.0251382813,
-0.0693435594,
0.0564240068,
-0.007130282,
0.0535080098,
-0.011749221,
0.0274343193,
0.0538801923,
-0.0107868798,
0.0079736393,
0.0163330846,
-0.0055378862,
0.02196729,
0.0463816337,
-0.0075568156,
-0.0193353947,
0.0309971701,
0.0616501644,
0.0416589268,
0.0165102258,
0.0000021026,
-0.0456117429,
-0.0226267595,
-0.00197512,
-0.0885133892,
-0.0352359861,
0.0819178596,
-0.0290039647,
0.039192602,
0.0195123497,
-0.0028111802,
-0.0439056642,
0.0542053655,
0.0399200022,
0.0539923832,
0.0564077795,
0.0124412728,
-0.0334207341,
-0.0644908696,
-0.0152063854,
-0.0006856198,
-0.0329483487,
0.018671548,
0.0159005225,
-0.0775681213,
-0.030754786,
-0.0120364679,
0.0021929822,
0.032981161,
0.0293606818,
0.0165933799,
-0.0179023128,
-0.0560673736,
-0.0437226593,
0.0065728463,
0.0807822421,
-0.0443606228,
-0.0348453037,
-0.0238594282,
-0.0287239291,
0.0043048323,
0.0061140172,
-0.0232012235,
-0.0202311594,
-0.0171421077,
0.0187116675,
0.0065306551,
0.0078618377,
0.054415483,
0.0383282676,
-0.0210013371,
0.0310921017,
-0.0050810212,
0.0061330604,
0.0037502435,
0.0155511694,
0.0395964421,
-0.0301494114,
-0.0049145208,
-0.0235066283,
-0.0376475938,
0.0417159311,
-0.0300136115,
-0.0178375877,
0.0074865571,
0.0028915748,
-0.0083377967,
0.0035048826,
-0.0587548502,
0.0483666658,
0.0369090587,
-0.0246395618,
0.0364248492,
-0.0067880554,
-0.0378500335,
0.0056828791,
-0.0126995454,
0.0001527801,
-0.0296018533,
0.0131898168,
-0.0099582607,
0.0407038853,
-0.0102779064,
-0.0020603095,
-0.0352027416,
0.0054476792,
0.0283416566,
0.0079037687,
-0.0562061109,
0.0023405873,
-0.0165079981,
0.0601999611,
-0.0427986905,
0.0655760244,
-0.0334934592,
-0.1119880155,
-0.0249200463,
0.0045671449,
0.0171737727,
-0.0463311262,
-0.010279227,
0.0329062194,
0.029499229,
-0.0400494635,
-0.0718729645,
-0.0511863269,
0.0088086668,
-0.0472626202,
-0.0089581599,
-0.0405869484,
0.053218849,
-0.0312083289,
0.009359302,
-0.0651082918,
-0.0075426977,
-0.0099090766,
-0.0274913162,
0.0958614275,
-0.0362825617,
-0.013304607,
0.0387613699,
0.0047394671,
0.0216101389,
0.1183410659,
-0.0266061239,
0.0089437049,
0.0624493286,
-0.0001630438,
0.0131887374,
0.0117052337,
0.055661615,
-0.0047826003,
-0.0217490867,
0.0423021875,
-0.046565,
0.0127400169,
0.0541731827,
-0.015233296,
-0.0372975916,
-0.0131451273,
0.0449265204,
-0.0122647807,
-0.008930902,
0.0193572156,
0.0217653122,
0.0332255363,
-0.0122675812,
0.0237735696,
-0.0527362078,
-0.0188906118,
0.0069695059,
-0.003699051,
0.0105582448,
0.0310500786,
-0.0370631777,
-0.0434736833,
0.0117168408,
0.0028538962,
-0.0033216586,
0.0321720019,
0.0421194993,
0.060207691,
0.0136604719,
0.0968436226,
0.035750743,
-0.0627537146,
0.0258618593,
-0.0151722813,
0.0373237692,
0.0775967687,
0.0447928235,
-0.0175457336,
-0.0283017308,
-0.0424254872,
-0.0041864836,
0.0158516988,
0.0341174193,
-0.0274462532,
0.0571971312,
-0.0559703559,
-0.0485708229,
-0.0175880194,
0.0314988159,
0.0315357745,
-0.0049276799,
-0.0188127067,
0.0326284692,
-0.0912429243,
-0.0569289513,
0.0340415947,
0.0226423778,
-0.0334345177,
0.01346034,
0.0212928634,
0.0326544978,
0.0488872267,
-0.0310707185,
-0.0396357104,
0.0023404015,
0.0267774258,
0.0167082362,
0.0069080307,
-0.0084764808,
-0.0830245465,
0.0185941551,
-0.0721331239,
-0.0266385544,
0.0096510975,
-0.0857687593,
-0.022755133,
0.0268416628,
0.0188361164,
-0.0138897467,
-0.0338252634,
-0.0044796383,
-0.0276215933,
0.0252429973,
-0.0252378229,
0.0465646572,
0.006086031,
-0.0111475224,
0.0176439881,
-0.0270311311,
0.0251802877,
-0.0444632657,
-0.0166199356,
0.00607866,
-0.004304843,
-0.0245556664,
0.0344392993,
-0.0135925515,
-0.0446177535,
0.0058007771,
-0.0601479262,
-0.0319669172,
-0.0282287467,
0.0130628841,
0.040775843,
0.0295813661,
-0.0165699665,
-0.0482003242,
0.0075018206,
-0.0852900296,
-0.0131729031,
0.0185803697,
0.0027420814,
-0.0299674328,
-0.0076196017,
-0.0226459336,
-0.0004010184,
-0.0014368802,
0.0350956246,
0.032939259,
-0.0087377662,
-0.0343055613,
0.0105281873,
-0.0231394954,
0.0092354622,
0.0054039932,
0.0047547808,
-0.0139595876,
0.0453397632,
-0.0407516696,
0.0632283464,
-0.0148161557,
0.0173362233,
0.0357549787,
-0.0113311084,
-0.0289297942,
-0.0020453192,
-0.0177472625,
0.0176410452,
-0.012529158,
-0.0474762209,
-0.0100188823,
0.0416729897,
0.0317949951,
-0.006869447,
-0.0063621034,
0.0300577264,
-0.0130664036,
-0.037182346,
-0.0106630037,
-0.014307823,
0.0201510452,
0.0195118766,
-0.063359119,
-0.0517627783,
0.0792208835,
-0.0372309834,
0.0133795142,
-0.0698509365,
0.0354444832,
-0.0427690707,
0.0195205435,
-0.0203489885,
0.0037729468,
0.018627787,
-0.0017698216,
-0.0265811179,
0.0003904583,
0.0257959273,
-0.0336041935,
0.0167908166,
-0.0632494688,
0.0007952428,
-0.0029306358,
-0.0145223094,
-0.0292088762,
-0.0372814275,
-0.0196388848,
-0.0214498807,
0.0099987919,
0.0052498248,
-0.0112829562,
0.0001755086,
-0.0035020157,
0.0315136202,
-0.0023753995,
0.013520306,
-0.0005191276,
0.0334745198,
0.0344766714,
0.004269104,
-0.0087325107,
0.0370253138,
0.0112619027,
0.0063997284,
0.0124118803,
0.0089665558,
-0.0320418142,
0.0193878878,
0.0252039637,
-0.0160443708,
0.013190479,
-0.0171583444,
0.0222212598,
-0.0635999441,
-0.0056170276,
0.1300171614,
0.0115414672,
-0.0694574267,
0.0089159049,
0.0176515076,
0.0388674848,
0.0297223199,
0.000510362,
-0.1135275736,
-0.0604144968,
0.0060697501,
0.0318106934,
-0.0333272405,
-0.0251382086,
-0.0238691848,
-0.1113791317,
0.0108933225,
-0.0110218506,
-0.0046410179,
0.0016032006,
-0.0360132158,
0.0198425781,
-0.0598660894,
0.0600348972,
-0.0070841033,
0.0329103097,
0.0368948877,
0.0290877651,
-0.0243756641,
-0.1331703216,
-0.0145186316,
-0.0125326235,
0.0649875849,
0.0355830491,
0.0263883285,
-0.0007370058,
0.062643066,
0.0212286767,
-0.0579750538,
0.0244334973,
-0.0346145742,
0.0985780582,
-0.0230644625,
-0.0283537824,
0.0101851001,
0.0524762422,
-0.0117304344,
0.0209098365,
0.0002299509,
0.0223127902,
-0.0287977774,
0.0197105929,
0.0019722008,
-0.0611153319,
0.0433762521,
0.0793783888,
0.0378553346,
0.0068760682,
0.0207598694,
-0.0440265201,
-0.0085107554,
0.0077381898,
-0.0014551566,
0.0088654673,
-0.0179163199,
-0.0076694991,
-0.0212406442,
-0.0689972714,
0.0133890295,
0.0085057253,
0.0121534141,
0.0063631479,
-0.0051410687,
0.0112365577,
-0.0346864462,
0.0582085662,
-0.0322338268,
0.012824011,
0.028611647,
-0.0512665063,
-0.0120154601,
-0.0465010665,
-0.0341357924,
0.0560322106,
-0.0597965084,
-0.0454829335,
0.0545964576,
0.0258144811,
0.0184750874,
0.077785857,
-0.0265084077,
-0.0589145273,
0.0418549068,
0.0512356088,
-0.0442413986,
-0.0182318818,
0.0318472944,
-0.0015020255,
0.0094008874,
0.0353020616,
-0.0248512011,
0.024165649,
-0.0004578715,
-0.0230750274,
-0.0318063013,
-0.036704585,
0.0169553477,
-0.0020518391,
0.0577265769,
-0.0030899595,
0.0530711487,
-0.0623403713,
0.0330148265,
-0.0198892485,
-0.0486220494,
-0.0129878037,
0.0053791497,
0.0396738909,
-0.0240470655,
-0.0439926125,
-0.0135756023,
-0.0707823783,
-0.0078458358,
-0.0473518707,
0.044741217,
0.0421866328,
0.0232924446,
-0.0290677641,
-0.0293520894,
-0.0149735939,
0.043910712,
-0.0087163802,
0.0009576505,
0.0212350823,
0.031214891,
0.02731736,
0.0176415518,
-0.0243853126,
-0.0100011928,
-0.0238738637,
0.0231601372,
-0.0478512272,
0.019655237,
0.000191928,
-0.0550945513,
0.053006269,
0.0344015621,
0.0115462262,
0.0128208902,
-0.0007497562,
0.032077264,
-0.0383432657,
0.0471078008,
0.0060431222,
-0.0270107258,
0.0246401392,
0.078640908,
0.003890194,
0.0757109597,
-0.0517988317,
-0.0091089988,
-0.0283691585,
-0.0356071331,
0.0239480995,
-0.0091871014,
-0.0133934468,
0.0085211573,
-0.0261504631,
-0.0672500655,
-0.0142315431,
-0.0327799954,
0.0336114243,
0.0036732836,
0.039767392,
0.0589126311,
-0.0486026742,
-0.0338550583,
-0.0118494695,
-0.0125804972,
-0.0551994704,
0.0028445888,
-0.0408512019,
-6.556439495e-33,
-0.0186841283,
0.0026496858,
-0.0352463312,
-0.0503720082,
0.0007928506,
-0.0044272114,
-0.0201561432,
-0.0335647166,
-0.0386718884,
0.0244916324,
0.0106620444,
0.0548083447,
0.0348904431,
0.0152411265,
-0.0251794364,
-0.04864081,
0.094139576,
0.0022291425,
-0.0321918577,
0.0216513816,
0.0135686966,
0.0238828771,
0.0798164308,
-0.0901531652,
0.054785952,
-0.0152919386,
-0.0315230899,
0.0396073982,
0.029944865,
0.0144829405,
0.0026829496,
0.0715846643,
0.0285415556,
-0.0545346141,
-0.0224675648,
-0.0158542246,
-0.0710448474,
-0.0481874421,
0.0503287055,
0.054736957,
0.0232100897,
-0.0005985413,
0.0434398092,
0.0033171461,
-0.0111705065,
-0.0066500194,
0.0270619839,
-0.0387796126,
0.0179808103,
0.0011866187,
-0.021255333,
0.0551905148,
-0.0493774638,
0.0076161064,
0.0243907813,
0.030362403,
-0.0015997052,
-0.0015093759,
-0.0305443089,
0.0085682021,
0.0498335212,
0.0221603401,
0.054836113,
-0.0073887971,
0.0030998311,
0.0453437343,
0.066514045,
-0.0087236268,
0.0124393459,
-0.017822776,
-0.0028076575,
-0.0113752596,
-0.0163462553,
0.107286185,
0.0404908694,
0.0187736824,
-0.0338593982,
0.0190923922,
0.0160064399,
0.0586114936,
0.0119474903,
-0.0022985246,
-0.0351015739,
-0.0307298247,
-0.0632675961,
-0.0642645285,
-0.0090995543,
-0.0166809633,
0.0328706019,
0.0223434977,
-0.0372654982,
0.0308209509,
0.0015650917,
-0.0259589814,
-0.0105244238,
0.0609142482,
0.0027226098,
-0.0320861973,
0.0204579495,
-0.0097322855,
-0.0544681437,
-0.0227656458,
0.0449933335,
0.05107731,
0.0137276873,
-0.0086738262,
0.0387471728,
0.0138962101,
-0.0255339034,
0.0075605847,
-0.0253653582,
0.004068973,
-0.0295563228,
0.044603426,
0.0562924035,
0.0179881454,
-0.0356208012,
0.0169731453,
0.0329450406,
0.0002335639,
-0.023832934,
0.0203929394,
-0.0211074445,
0.0447212867,
-0.0308648758,
-0.0324766561,
0.0375741795,
-0.0862477198,
0.0140944729,
-0.0697776303,
-0.0062482799,
-0.0020518629,
2.699e-7,
0.0074393633,
0.0292779896,
0.0166451968,
-0.0043772697,
0.029045023,
0.0208226275,
0.0220815204,
-0.0092697088,
0.001175281,
-0.0272813104,
0.0494426228,
0.0191197861,
0.0117932213,
0.0152975302,
-0.0767044798,
0.0185850374,
-0.0289357379,
0.0362722017,
-0.026437737,
-0.0240761526,
0.0211977232,
0.1088972688,
0.0012572773,
-0.0327065066,
0.0034755133,
-0.019495165,
0.0017363883,
-0.0168578364,
0.0261806902,
0.0187417362,
0.0529518984,
0.0329923816,
0.0191766191,
0.0397487283,
-0.0081531759,
0.0209182147,
-0.0131079629,
0.0304396152,
-0.0244605783,
0.000701996,
-0.0011318106,
-0.0001567672,
-0.0095951827,
-0.0746277869,
0.086530894,
-0.0195974391,
-0.0463415496,
-0.0810284913,
-0.0498600714,
-0.0110397236,
0.0044120699,
0.011405373,
0.0168046057,
0.0472770073,
0.0100436043,
-0.0075886175,
-0.0272256322,
-0.062894322,
-0.0362947322,
-0.0173429009,
-0.029274324,
-0.0087071322,
0.0122951446,
0.0016855398,
0.0172390919,
-0.0607538186,
0.0364026576,
2.148364011e-34,
0.0424539782,
-0.0077916174,
0.0025200958,
-0.0135360425,
0.0360462777,
-0.0171314832,
-0.0387981944,
-0.0159503166,
0.0096464586,
-0.0394463986,
0.011349679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00288v1 | Active Instruction Tuning: Improving Cross-Task Generalization by Training on Prompt Sensitive Tasks | 2023-11-01T04:40:05 | 2023-11-01T04:40:05 | Po-Nien Kung, Fan Yin, Di Wu, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction tuning (IT) achieves impressive zero-shot generalization results
by training large language models (LLMs) on a massive amount of diverse tasks
with instructions. However, how to select new tasks to improve the performance
and generalizability of IT models remains an open question. Training on all
existing tasks is impractical due to prohibiting computation requirements, and
randomly selecting tasks can lead to suboptimal performance. In this work, we
propose active instruction tuning based on prompt uncertainty, a novel
framework to identify informative tasks, and then actively tune the models on
the selected tasks. We represent the informativeness of new tasks with the
disagreement of the current model outputs over perturbed prompts. Our
experiments on NIV2 and Self-Instruct datasets demonstrate that our method
consistently outperforms other baseline strategies for task selection,
achieving better out-of-distribution generalization with fewer training tasks.
Additionally, we introduce a task map that categorizes and diagnoses tasks
based on prompt uncertainty and prediction probability. We discover that
training on ambiguous (prompt-uncertain) tasks improves generalization while
training on difficult (prompt-certain and low-probability) tasks offers no
benefit, underscoring the importance of task selection for instruction tuning. | [
0.0366525762,
0.0312029347,
-0.0013493857,
0.0134711973,
-0.0084082186,
0.0487238131,
-0.0142441336,
-0.0152588161,
-0.0171088353,
-0.0390886813,
-0.0574488528,
-0.0619508326,
-0.0229711328,
-0.0192834307,
0.0280070603,
-0.0489048362,
0.0589957759,
-0.038638439,
0.0046959813,
0.0046212454,
-0.0233426522,
0.0171445161,
-0.0264285859,
0.0422501639,
0.0114760064,
-0.0151074994,
-0.0173955318,
0.0334340595,
0.0121240122,
-0.0226960126,
0.0408756398,
0.0537770577,
0.0412500091,
-0.0099928128,
0.0000019742,
-0.0353602096,
0.0001531517,
-0.042330876,
-0.0308130756,
0.0015992853,
0.0048044515,
-0.0123973852,
-0.0057724295,
0.0221283864,
-0.005545069,
-0.0344795026,
0.0485218577,
0.0046587656,
0.0520485565,
0.0929336548,
0.0210469402,
0.0201138631,
-0.0183243565,
-0.0352345072,
0.0703358725,
-0.0573458374,
-0.0109783886,
-0.0241544619,
-0.0089001181,
0.0286547691,
-0.0245808363,
0.0057979152,
0.022501111,
0.0003650554,
-0.0009336202,
0.0402501374,
-0.009916367,
-0.0295736175,
-0.0492307767,
0.0529986843,
-0.0374587849,
0.0030729489,
-0.0024128447,
-0.0236281268,
0.0152648715,
0.0003654429,
-0.0227394868,
0.0264232568,
-0.0013357302,
0.0107385097,
0.019157948,
-0.008555037,
0.0161333345,
-0.0052172467,
0.0081529161,
0.0749710053,
-0.0046420745,
-0.0292941183,
0.0170199256,
0.0164258443,
-0.0623174682,
-0.0352560394,
-0.0230292901,
0.0551264957,
-0.0840728581,
0.0266403947,
-0.0550564975,
-0.0326863155,
-0.004967845,
-0.0030885504,
0.1036486328,
0.0577707961,
-0.0357549489,
0.0325416699,
-0.0113857854,
0.0527499132,
0.0251362864,
0.0432116948,
-0.0415095016,
0.008879045,
-0.0674294084,
0.0186282396,
-0.0352991298,
0.0084914556,
-0.0281364694,
0.0099606505,
-0.0194939878,
0.0560225137,
-0.0068833875,
0.0034447424,
0.0415766239,
0.0056786253,
-0.0945747867,
-0.0108365156,
-0.0071400492,
0.0067750313,
-0.0271500442,
0.0261732452,
0.018661594,
-0.042507235,
-0.0325935893,
0.0128779151,
0.0014150484,
-0.040527232,
0.031107109,
0.0678686872,
-0.0458793156,
-0.0297211446,
-0.0523979068,
-0.0050415904,
0.0053066351,
-0.0789994225,
0.0116987517,
-0.0197260249,
-0.003183431,
-0.0004601229,
0.0097667212,
-0.0042128298,
0.0058788355,
0.005514327,
-0.0114041204,
0.0746980384,
0.0444749929,
0.0063718422,
0.0129907103,
0.0034394739,
-0.0211934391,
0.0782641172,
0.0103759533,
0.006567786,
0.0138571383,
0.005048899,
0.008790588,
0.0270806476,
0.0030971214,
0.0341781266,
0.0282067675,
0.0212583765,
0.0521908551,
-0.0032585047,
0.0645766333,
0.0243556462,
-0.0035643333,
0.0199899413,
0.0583570376,
0.0136965634,
-0.0366164446,
-0.0349589959,
0.0802952647,
0.0360664651,
-0.0093187541,
0.0326810293,
-0.1003237069,
0.0219625104,
-0.0079513686,
0.0046894019,
-0.004995469,
0.0015764049,
-0.0673753396,
-0.0453053601,
0.0023104541,
-0.0116536263,
0.0105168773,
0.0304237809,
0.0392222255,
0.0154065872,
-0.0661045536,
0.016182119,
0.027758833,
-0.0321745463,
0.0175178275,
-0.0626852363,
0.0286419354,
0.0386323966,
-0.0002580631,
-0.0536865033,
-0.0628489628,
0.0000042291,
0.055151049,
0.0284565352,
0.0247067139,
-0.0286275819,
0.0517529137,
-0.0546899028,
-0.0277477819,
-0.0205881055,
0.0281855185,
0.0262574628,
0.0310769919,
-0.0370091759,
0.0162193105,
-0.0421597473,
-0.0330128483,
0.0404363796,
-0.0156321768,
-0.0671778843,
0.0247962382,
0.0212310459,
0.0151576586,
-0.0213398803,
0.0022027311,
0.0060822228,
0.0189064592,
-0.0192192979,
0.023528669,
-0.0159529895,
-0.0569633432,
0.0004583468,
0.0102539361,
0.0104187345,
-0.0271685701,
0.0291527063,
-0.0665789023,
-0.0526146851,
0.0036301925,
-0.0213844832,
-0.0174131356,
0.0037495457,
0.0312132183,
-0.0055807596,
-0.0120800827,
-0.033962585,
0.0376622789,
-0.0137262931,
0.0016023027,
0.0310416743,
0.0102496482,
-0.0230394956,
-0.0389861502,
-0.0374824367,
-0.0236007348,
-0.0195466597,
0.0092361541,
0.0304753091,
0.0355748013,
-0.0328802094,
-0.0124565307,
-0.0979414359,
0.0304324795,
-0.0497299768,
0.022118615,
0.0467109829,
0.0096816821,
-0.0089205354,
-0.0489621647,
-0.01871581,
-0.0058961236,
-0.0124572013,
0.0253300052,
0.0216959268,
0.0318758078,
0.0027513001,
-0.0418082662,
-0.0077803805,
-0.0097318217,
-0.0161013715,
-0.0191269554,
0.0138413617,
-0.0843387544,
0.0575388037,
0.0266550388,
0.0433946997,
-0.0194488652,
-0.0165226143,
0.0119303009,
-0.0146834701,
0.0254787579,
0.1093862876,
-0.016265817,
0.0084068058,
0.0315189213,
-0.0043665445,
-0.0435932651,
0.0395290703,
-0.0373455994,
-0.0722231567,
-0.0367795154,
-0.0413965434,
0.0044174031,
0.0997206345,
0.0054452457,
-0.0080581177,
-0.0888901353,
-0.026708683,
-0.0361748114,
-0.0242641643,
-0.0407590345,
0.017335467,
-0.0124016544,
0.0078699999,
-0.0495460257,
-0.065619804,
0.0732322708,
-0.0155119449,
-0.0134638725,
-0.0615541153,
-0.0111771198,
-0.0188774988,
0.0549346246,
0.0065929447,
-0.0051680333,
0.0560834669,
-0.0333121121,
-0.1019618437,
0.0041795583,
0.0115741063,
0.0108213117,
0.0358909927,
-0.0607306361,
-0.0217158124,
-0.0147025492,
-0.0428877659,
-0.0393316373,
-0.0233513061,
0.0301140621,
0.025011586,
0.0322320536,
-0.0200571455,
-0.0156603158,
-0.0130590582,
-0.0013728916,
0.0635950416,
-0.0403284431,
-0.0091369217,
-0.0576860644,
-0.0144039076,
0.0453870147,
0.003918258,
-0.0431563295,
-0.0475414731,
-0.0165271815,
0.0108969994,
0.0534571297,
-0.0195930172,
-0.0147401718,
0.0319434255,
0.0394255891,
-0.051806692,
-0.0213845465,
0.0611377247,
0.1107458472,
-0.0457028076,
-0.0332553424,
0.1040093228,
0.0279822759,
-0.0561824739,
0.0009968824,
0.0319311731,
-0.0051259617,
0.0453027263,
0.0495498888,
-0.0498665981,
-0.0496549085,
0.000062805,
0.0360256098,
-0.0000880835,
-0.014786466,
-0.0056165513,
-0.1274355799,
0.0129618431,
0.0020484375,
-0.0143363085,
-0.014214376,
-0.0348962955,
0.0173102431,
-0.0265508387,
0.047698319,
-0.0103940759,
-0.0117014674,
0.0137611376,
0.0578936413,
0.0311970804,
-0.069527328,
0.0258893017,
-0.0283597652,
0.0560739264,
0.0690826774,
-0.0143083148,
0.0302869994,
0.0163327232,
0.0419374146,
0.0053336751,
0.015794728,
-0.0094679147,
0.041683916,
-0.0178077631,
0.0057067522,
0.0352149643,
0.0369836241,
-0.0127689345,
0.0024624805,
0.0178183895,
0.0655246377,
-0.0335639715,
0.0141813764,
0.002353759,
-0.0375184864,
0.0594783686,
0.0542615205,
0.0220792722,
-0.0525391661,
-0.0237024333,
-0.0373084508,
-0.0159366541,
-0.0784871653,
0.0072340388,
0.0232694186,
-0.0284581874,
-0.0332888812,
-0.0273689348,
-0.0413411632,
0.0463497937,
0.0099636726,
0.0325050987,
-0.0406093933,
0.018257644,
0.0081150103,
-0.0511452667,
0.043918591,
-0.0235775001,
0.0264696851,
-0.0828224048,
-0.0521857962,
0.0138261449,
-0.00258567,
-0.0037040953,
0.0258645378,
-0.1010753736,
-0.072985962,
-0.0159835499,
0.0669335052,
0.0207405817,
0.0670539588,
-0.0247053094,
-0.0575062856,
0.0367621817,
0.0128259296,
-0.0333063342,
0.0112820109,
0.0484238304,
-0.0035187292,
-0.0080142254,
0.0361848362,
-0.0531106368,
0.0249152202,
0.0729324967,
0.0072949515,
0.0001130046,
-0.005640008,
0.0112027088,
-0.0313756168,
0.0767231137,
-0.0271835756,
0.007058592,
-0.0392860249,
-0.0017356483,
0.0215101242,
-0.0082435086,
-0.0382352434,
0.01266116,
0.0426903665,
-0.0170257222,
0.015236578,
0.0297929104,
0.004159817,
0.0406673923,
-0.0829949006,
0.0132865654,
-0.0002139402,
0.0191564858,
0.0310163312,
0.0301165842,
-0.0172553807,
0.0237756707,
0.0256011579,
0.0205684062,
0.0163806677,
0.0496868268,
0.0109439986,
0.022673104,
-0.0298126023,
0.0246175528,
-0.0744339451,
-0.040112175,
-0.0482081696,
0.0120415799,
0.0450464673,
-0.0182586107,
0.0168196075,
-0.0056455391,
0.0140619697,
-0.0161982533,
0.0175274797,
0.037383806,
-0.022541346,
0.0141853262,
0.0277497489,
0.0126896491,
-0.0010894665,
0.0897739828,
-0.0027034734,
0.0651191697,
-0.0024280674,
0.0127243334,
-0.0515291169,
-0.0067066303,
0.0269187838,
0.0166141726,
-0.0201800764,
0.0413436778,
0.0072533689,
-0.0509724021,
-0.0155961718,
0.0045756851,
-0.0058692368,
-0.0169085711,
0.0538451411,
0.0336956382,
-0.028102098,
-0.0335452594,
-0.0341643915,
-0.0272111315,
0.0058056796,
-0.0025902265,
-0.0491146743,
-6.223596066e-33,
-0.040114291,
0.0284818355,
0.0045573297,
-0.0224106815,
0.0170871038,
0.0097379135,
-0.039603889,
0.0126873655,
-0.0129229184,
-0.0057710432,
-0.0238999743,
0.0113438377,
0.0354824178,
0.0155501449,
0.0406035222,
-0.0199630242,
0.0646847561,
-0.0207840838,
-0.0567231104,
0.0331518576,
0.0297719482,
0.0219333507,
0.0813708678,
-0.0274640173,
0.040409442,
0.0122320252,
-0.0188366231,
0.0384508558,
0.0161946472,
0.033744067,
0.0107114501,
0.0326575637,
0.0144773806,
-0.0666215792,
-0.0429080836,
0.0251559578,
-0.0615096092,
-0.0394725166,
0.0198931005,
0.0145798502,
-0.0405025966,
-0.0430338159,
-0.0135358665,
-0.0102585452,
-0.0352003984,
-0.0202266295,
0.0349230208,
-0.0011926715,
-0.004723391,
0.0074189035,
-0.0491815805,
-0.0104080252,
-0.0049030064,
-0.0685256571,
0.0003423409,
0.0548100136,
-0.0037225862,
-0.0199383199,
-0.037893489,
0.0215339586,
-0.0019655314,
0.0872271955,
0.0508204587,
0.0612207241,
-0.0087555526,
0.0117695574,
0.0158158448,
0.0206860751,
0.006961829,
0.0061382898,
0.0033877997,
0.0297613218,
-0.009087231,
-0.0134097142,
0.0342295058,
0.0136889378,
-0.0580703467,
0.0228931699,
0.0701849461,
0.0287147686,
0.0305586755,
0.0058261519,
-0.0358369574,
-0.0429996513,
-0.0374096818,
-0.0282247476,
-0.020866368,
-0.0130044445,
0.0480672792,
0.0335167199,
-0.0135816978,
-0.0074750748,
0.0497685969,
-0.0205286928,
0.0099132461,
-0.0043176389,
-0.019019926,
0.0189061519,
0.0096910801,
0.0096203936,
-0.0559147634,
-0.0760184303,
0.0435546488,
-0.0118570933,
0.023126442,
0.0121666417,
0.0410506278,
0.0426967219,
-0.0487649925,
-0.0125262951,
-0.0585134216,
0.0386857614,
0.0101434877,
0.0806033686,
0.0198829286,
0.0076011992,
-0.0205612481,
0.0684956312,
-0.0203020666,
-0.0324879847,
-0.0137219746,
-0.0171966013,
-0.0064233067,
0.020359505,
-0.0146107925,
-0.0027703573,
-0.0340174735,
-0.0147168152,
-0.0206602793,
-0.0413660295,
-0.0198103413,
0.0307217687,
2.643e-7,
0.0071535613,
0.0196951572,
-0.0109546864,
0.0500125028,
0.0107270898,
0.0397265479,
-0.0250467546,
0.0299150012,
0.0140448324,
-0.0301741082,
-0.001680706,
0.0400633439,
0.0427331105,
0.0104315691,
-0.0925231948,
-0.0369178094,
-0.0373573862,
0.0385336727,
-0.0305424687,
0.0360035412,
-0.0036485975,
0.0897503868,
0.0038403689,
0.0041591153,
0.0243130904,
-0.0276615657,
0.0337638631,
-0.0218869746,
-0.0039790734,
0.0419058576,
-0.005384502,
0.0408787653,
-0.0019569064,
0.0339532159,
-0.0346863084,
0.0097943423,
-0.039261274,
0.0717356429,
-0.0136325583,
-0.0121621201,
-0.0055420301,
0.0250477716,
0.004941314,
-0.0220826585,
0.0818845406,
-0.082268849,
-0.0267181508,
0.0046162037,
0.0281011369,
0.0200791582,
0.0000543294,
-0.006378768,
-0.0134227024,
0.0033998329,
0.0385401547,
0.0015755157,
-0.0437738188,
-0.080019705,
-0.0262847003,
0.0222980175,
-0.0431769229,
-0.056761235,
-0.0347557589,
-0.0040930384,
0.00818244,
-0.0843179002,
0.0017635779,
2.438780681e-34,
0.0315739848,
0.0147066033,
0.0341052413,
0.008821751,
-0.0009806117,
-0.0025336239,
-0.0730800778,
0.0121761551,
0.0332233496,
-0.0471835993,
-0.040528819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00287v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00287v1 | Knowledge-Infused Prompting: Assessing and Advancing Clinical Text Data Generation with Large Language Models | 2023-11-01T04:37:28 | 2023-11-01T04:37:28 | Ran Xu, Hejie Cui, Yue Yu, Xuan Kan, Wenqi Shi, Yuchen Zhuang, Wei Jin, Joyce Ho, Carl Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | Clinical natural language processing requires methods that can address
domain-specific challenges, such as complex medical terminology and clinical
contexts. Recently, large language models (LLMs) have shown promise in this
domain. Yet, their direct deployment can lead to privacy issues and are
constrained by resources. To address this challenge, we delve into synthetic
clinical text generation using LLMs for clinical NLP tasks. We propose an
innovative, resource-efficient approach, ClinGen, which infuses knowledge into
the process. Our model involves clinical knowledge extraction and
context-informed LLM prompting. Both clinical topics and writing styles are
drawn from external domain-specific knowledge graphs and LLMs to guide data
generation. Our extensive empirical study across 7 clinical NLP tasks and 16
datasets reveals that ClinGen consistently enhances performance across various
tasks, effectively aligning the distribution of real datasets and significantly
enriching the diversity of generated training instances. We will publish our
code and all the generated data in \url{https://github.com/ritaranx/ClinGen}. | [
0.0673390031,
0.027027335,
0.0142205814,
0.0021816806,
-0.0500389598,
0.0043062633,
0.010531107,
0.0359076224,
0.053521093,
-0.039123185,
-0.0076595633,
-0.0642822906,
-0.0070774276,
0.053519208,
0.0258995295,
-0.0215679724,
0.0056731207,
0.008863477,
0.0351939648,
0.012268139,
-0.0160408765,
0.0191832744,
-0.0257857572,
0.0329461172,
0.0136906086,
-0.0240730569,
0.0149625773,
-0.0033157484,
0.0157111231,
-0.0845596343,
-0.0022979931,
0.0534833893,
-0.0135894222,
-0.0058379043,
0.0000019692,
-0.0296299346,
-0.0121083949,
0.0250255633,
-0.0408108905,
-0.0449969657,
0.0604753084,
-0.0698582679,
0.0168962162,
0.0112865418,
-0.0548747629,
-0.0189611427,
0.0064440342,
0.0480142236,
0.0471394882,
0.0835359395,
-0.0206655208,
0.0309969783,
0.0066625099,
-0.0297680311,
0.0321319886,
0.0020927547,
0.0387903899,
-0.0130568258,
0.0393126495,
0.0200551972,
0.0332963318,
0.041696161,
-0.0227584578,
0.0060044178,
0.051355347,
0.0473227017,
0.0075310702,
-0.0189842787,
-0.0150481705,
0.075730972,
0.0381146595,
-0.0068234978,
0.04809127,
-0.0019611125,
-0.0056934441,
0.0062235412,
-0.0231233183,
0.04478091,
-0.0315887146,
-0.0058213933,
0.0225750115,
0.0064044809,
0.0349983238,
0.0016708801,
0.0269255098,
-0.0360482931,
0.0277048554,
-0.0151940705,
-0.009917086,
-0.007295168,
-0.0171691552,
-0.0842564479,
0.0367473699,
0.0426555201,
-0.0509496145,
0.0138924103,
-0.0673592687,
-0.0446385555,
0.0793341249,
-0.0340583064,
0.0262324046,
-0.0137774143,
0.0157934781,
0.0277559832,
-0.0244886465,
-0.016920479,
-0.0082763322,
0.014278762,
-0.0196653698,
0.0207638685,
-0.0103267822,
-0.0188673437,
-0.0116267679,
0.0175514109,
-0.0579855107,
-0.0173712615,
-0.0739632845,
0.0181711875,
0.0083459811,
0.056726031,
0.0095009273,
0.0333483554,
-0.0385059565,
-0.0091591952,
0.0105338199,
-0.0456148423,
0.0048117102,
0.0073076589,
0.0240804181,
-0.0405725427,
0.0026771121,
0.0051801656,
0.0149959149,
-0.0050112992,
0.0190014001,
0.0782196596,
-0.0021901419,
-0.006221761,
-0.0154162217,
-0.0948566496,
-0.0308849309,
0.0003819557,
0.0138773061,
-0.0701822862,
0.0392973386,
0.0136105362,
-0.0084880022,
-0.0746712685,
0.0322634093,
0.0306402817,
-0.0585191771,
0.0462297648,
-0.0839860141,
0.0116983,
0.0082228733,
0.0432897881,
0.0119378446,
0.0139197428,
0.0339986794,
-0.0426126048,
0.0182262752,
0.0077214427,
0.012480204,
-0.0005317026,
0.0402299389,
-0.0387395322,
-0.0262389556,
0.0123305973,
0.0082476446,
0.0718634948,
-0.0194512624,
0.0739927068,
0.0020217362,
0.0000302087,
0.0373206139,
0.0633933693,
0.0190214086,
0.0078700753,
0.0253231227,
-0.0144590102,
-0.0164583139,
-0.0134925684,
-0.0054643089,
-0.004315055,
0.0019375257,
0.0226475559,
-0.0126245404,
0.0083926693,
-0.0136423009,
-0.0026055598,
-0.0181831028,
-0.032077305,
-0.027747307,
-0.0193461943,
-0.0050116829,
0.039059788,
-0.027656531,
0.0342140049,
0.0547112077,
-0.0512096398,
-0.0022816916,
-0.0330134779,
0.0053617442,
0.0979711562,
0.0859319195,
-0.0265558865,
-0.0369962342,
-0.0344795994,
-0.0001459828,
0.0400914513,
-0.0043277182,
-0.0149099175,
0.0212073065,
-0.0484744981,
-0.0032156599,
0.017752992,
0.007453647,
-0.0292582959,
0.0156267211,
0.0161918364,
0.0124319252,
-0.0323830992,
-0.026880499,
0.0574535355,
-0.0859128982,
-0.0383498371,
0.0376088619,
-0.0234736912,
0.0111095738,
0.0304172598,
-0.01819841,
0.0514003783,
0.0350413173,
-0.0635871887,
-0.0183001217,
0.0003591884,
-0.0516860336,
-0.0711219832,
0.0068172915,
-0.0223159324,
0.0295839962,
-0.046393659,
-0.0172174666,
-0.027396895,
-0.0652825609,
-0.0291047618,
0.0558003448,
-0.002990569,
0.0182663631,
0.0732525438,
-0.0261291042,
-0.0495321639,
0.0349312052,
-0.0223500878,
0.0197663549,
0.0289326515,
-0.0205636695,
-0.0231227949,
-0.0056587434,
0.0181967877,
-0.0112261819,
0.0070096557,
-0.0000984014,
-0.0132461013,
0.0292657278,
-0.0209675841,
-0.0343854018,
-0.094568789,
0.0190928597,
0.0008427147,
-0.0024451911,
0.0536911711,
0.0499521382,
-0.0114099085,
-0.0116066048,
-0.0725151971,
-0.0205723345,
0.0379018001,
0.0193792637,
0.0469379909,
0.0356603973,
0.017160533,
-0.0045587644,
0.0005717282,
-0.0243693907,
0.0402892716,
0.0242521521,
-0.0229765121,
-0.0358909182,
0.0497306213,
-0.0319458544,
-0.0200291611,
0.0058748489,
0.0134315593,
0.0069640763,
-0.0141082127,
0.0541607887,
0.0239384919,
0.0236400813,
0.0023504801,
0.0417574495,
-0.0054475893,
-0.0027419382,
-0.0111014303,
-0.0425668322,
-0.0125327511,
0.0101462137,
-0.0479373522,
0.0359980874,
0.0533361137,
0.047178302,
-0.0197018199,
-0.0266615991,
-0.027626453,
-0.0192343574,
0.0162480678,
-0.0438577645,
-0.0024014241,
-0.0383339971,
0.0524706319,
-0.0072103986,
-0.0278769005,
0.0879019573,
-0.0333935432,
0.0243964549,
-0.03718438,
-0.0290553812,
-0.0423632339,
0.0211521517,
0.0051214923,
0.0317924097,
0.0102315014,
-0.0014964837,
0.012783369,
0.0253011249,
0.0059197312,
-0.0648364946,
0.0752018467,
-0.017113274,
0.0029783277,
0.0055902717,
-0.0545383766,
-0.0638915151,
-0.0427539423,
0.0023706942,
-0.0251658913,
0.0323119909,
-0.0058457879,
0.0132883815,
0.0050962856,
-0.0042212605,
0.0954415947,
0.0200809911,
-0.0260027386,
-0.0224142782,
0.0408262797,
0.0258913748,
-0.0174419712,
-0.0164812468,
-0.0244197994,
0.0352649167,
0.0763674155,
0.0231279694,
0.0298977755,
0.0142692411,
0.0052333442,
-0.0092232367,
-0.0426523872,
-0.0131693659,
0.0394225754,
0.0705195516,
-0.0455152877,
-0.0089796362,
0.1070464402,
0.0319092833,
-0.0706581324,
0.0233802795,
0.0100469189,
0.0086152451,
-0.0016267877,
0.0136522809,
-0.0797206312,
-0.0352257565,
-0.0030579525,
0.0593826212,
-0.042517513,
-0.0684221461,
-0.0175809506,
-0.0620879717,
0.0242871754,
0.0115302531,
-0.0121486289,
-0.0425510742,
-0.0458781309,
-0.0129491854,
0.0286497846,
-0.033148475,
-0.0075981566,
-0.0340996422,
-0.0027615272,
0.0078986073,
-0.0407878831,
-0.1086059287,
-0.01137718,
-0.0269839708,
0.0654440075,
0.0311210025,
0.0217316803,
0.0183189325,
-0.0094002094,
-0.0169904195,
0.0030722052,
-0.0035644746,
-0.0097500077,
0.0728939548,
0.0014339531,
-0.0001995433,
-0.0571945049,
0.0697750375,
-0.0357961096,
-0.0460304432,
0.0180606879,
0.0488308296,
-0.0377043225,
-0.0225940756,
-0.0243913643,
0.0398561433,
0.0546252057,
0.0631019473,
0.0210664626,
-0.0061522517,
0.0152475489,
0.001662099,
0.0326975435,
-0.0181712341,
-0.0073854048,
0.0350545198,
-0.0330022201,
0.0005291358,
-0.0891656578,
0.0024227342,
0.0599015318,
0.0147743691,
0.0415317714,
0.0299163684,
0.0021341559,
-0.0273182373,
-0.0957015678,
0.0442480557,
0.0103335688,
-0.0030022066,
-0.0472566709,
-0.0573276393,
0.0431996658,
-0.0365483612,
-0.0069223838,
0.0490791202,
-0.0222477689,
-0.0305331368,
-0.0096980166,
0.0234636664,
0.0174764451,
0.040590506,
0.0016929741,
-0.001805914,
0.0623524934,
0.0890566409,
-0.0494495854,
-0.0271212161,
-0.0248029381,
-0.0080753658,
-0.0009417029,
0.0067839208,
-0.0141144898,
0.0183731094,
0.0116885081,
0.0346337855,
-0.0169577431,
-0.0350554921,
0.0221127644,
0.0571419895,
0.0111378161,
-0.0472059138,
0.0097668758,
-0.0605419688,
0.0029591317,
-0.0347560421,
0.0029545918,
-0.0469776578,
0.0050852294,
0.01266021,
-0.0102539454,
-0.0087885493,
0.0164735205,
-0.045151066,
-0.0232567172,
-0.0507098399,
0.0249819942,
0.0011428423,
0.0046613417,
0.0798239708,
-0.0270540509,
-0.0303362254,
0.0514638163,
-0.0378076434,
0.0304597188,
-0.0184717327,
0.0693064332,
0.0138905626,
0.0244367979,
0.0002208647,
0.056920439,
-0.0585859306,
-0.011594356,
-0.0342187397,
0.0416583493,
0.0153652541,
-0.0132815596,
0.0267315395,
-0.075478673,
0.0189042017,
-0.0153494217,
0.0738632977,
-0.0163436923,
-0.0225852523,
0.0188276283,
-0.0025357299,
-0.0078837862,
-0.0190099273,
0.1059957594,
-0.0052393279,
0.042401202,
0.0138707142,
-0.0405504294,
-0.0731269866,
-0.0231008343,
0.0487849303,
0.0069822259,
-0.052425079,
0.0036242029,
-0.0642082393,
-0.0536114126,
0.0347767211,
-0.027756311,
-0.0236570965,
-0.0210853238,
0.0490675941,
0.0405478366,
-0.0008780704,
-0.0128346868,
-0.0528122447,
0.0695218816,
-0.0317047723,
-0.0319865718,
0.0136679523,
-5.968993173e-33,
-0.0031768081,
-0.0670231655,
0.016116919,
-0.0022155794,
-0.0084226541,
0.04111702,
-0.0511271507,
-0.001053744,
0.0410658382,
0.0212379247,
-0.0604692549,
-0.013310994,
0.0068612606,
0.0651741251,
0.0028051347,
-0.0227945112,
0.0321512893,
-0.0101461317,
-0.0265671685,
0.0667368993,
-0.0060952338,
0.0696756616,
0.0134037025,
-0.0623736121,
0.0319625735,
-0.0224696174,
0.0311404895,
-0.0123613272,
0.0112777585,
0.0309981052,
-0.0718022138,
0.0105116274,
0.0586859025,
-0.0007997917,
-0.0142103303,
0.0120333703,
-0.0539137833,
-0.0110448627,
0.0004088385,
-0.0447092764,
-0.0724352822,
-0.0451871343,
0.0458661877,
-0.0338575095,
0.004526942,
0.0204492901,
0.0085095521,
-0.0380758345,
-0.0245642178,
-0.0572250001,
-0.0201510619,
0.0426602326,
0.0246641207,
-0.0336378925,
-0.0047287853,
-0.0069480655,
-0.0278541893,
0.0259192158,
-0.0196184535,
0.0141601656,
0.03267809,
0.0271162372,
-0.0143599398,
-0.0047879512,
-0.0264842603,
0.0782604218,
-0.0312404875,
0.0041817226,
-0.0545249172,
0.0479657426,
-0.0867342949,
0.0593636073,
0.0399457514,
0.0531224944,
-0.0044991756,
-0.0353697091,
-0.0560273565,
0.036815796,
-0.0568108968,
-0.0347010978,
0.0371718667,
-0.0727750361,
-0.0294922926,
-0.0106270798,
-0.0210442897,
-0.0037834789,
0.0045533641,
0.0122990869,
0.0171653908,
0.022700293,
-0.0168922283,
-0.0089015998,
-0.0197693445,
-0.0001044223,
0.0195733737,
-0.0170140285,
0.0361062698,
0.0043749637,
-0.0428798683,
-0.0174982864,
-0.0517384298,
-0.0125883054,
0.0345897861,
-0.0227936339,
0.0275885984,
0.0456465669,
0.0169795118,
-0.0393053107,
-0.0662203208,
0.0004692205,
0.0131969862,
0.0561507642,
0.0117774587,
0.0172540359,
0.0472933576,
0.001231924,
0.0054509351,
0.0344849974,
0.011497681,
0.0107226055,
-0.0267310999,
-0.0262243226,
0.0083270045,
0.0183336623,
-0.0478274301,
-0.0034104458,
-0.0387737677,
0.0380314142,
0.0487507582,
-0.0296202991,
0.0058204648,
-0.0468367636,
2.766e-7,
0.0706579387,
0.0365387835,
0.0005699603,
0.0192830395,
0.0302723013,
0.0170548894,
0.0125137139,
0.0294288099,
-0.0221064575,
-0.0495458022,
0.0255553704,
0.0086639496,
0.0403770693,
0.0433808789,
-0.0815923735,
-0.031636361,
-0.0501042716,
-0.015840644,
-0.0401617959,
-0.044121623,
0.0573976524,
0.0377837382,
-0.0352224484,
-0.0369265527,
0.0168994237,
-0.0450345613,
0.0433131717,
-0.0345811434,
-0.0079225888,
0.040823739,
0.0495096743,
0.0074357428,
0.0025595331,
0.0433722325,
-0.0397370569,
-0.0378760658,
-0.0266531315,
0.1085368246,
-0.0030083454,
0.0368559584,
0.0364446305,
-0.011443547,
0.0029849834,
-0.0296465419,
0.0456166156,
-0.0368552469,
-0.0363390371,
-0.0361940265,
0.01519123,
-0.0376189388,
0.0324882753,
-0.0284937639,
-0.0195349269,
0.0249954555,
0.0206061099,
0.0206210781,
-0.0236441363,
-0.0610519201,
-0.0309199747,
0.0098580886,
-0.0358219109,
-0.0122353919,
0.011922244,
-0.0209002439,
-0.0065541742,
-0.077545993,
0.0211587735,
2.902895697e-34,
0.0168247595,
0.0042530727,
-0.0039904146,
0.0171577893,
0.0195882246,
-0.0294246916,
0.0056416001,
0.0155710643,
0.005323064,
-0.0544043779,
-0.0124074966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00286v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00286v3 | JADE: A Linguistics-based Safety Evaluation Platform for Large Language Models | 2023-11-01T04:36:45 | 2023-12-10T13:58:24 | Mi Zhang, Xudong Pan, Min Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | In this paper, we present JADE, a targeted linguistic fuzzing platform which
strengthens the linguistic complexity of seed questions to simultaneously and
consistently break a wide range of widely-used LLMs categorized in three
groups: eight open-sourced Chinese, six commercial Chinese and four commercial
English LLMs. JADE generates three safety benchmarks for the three groups of
LLMs, which contain unsafe questions that are highly threatening: the questions
simultaneously trigger harmful generation of multiple LLMs, with an average
unsafe generation ratio of $70\%$ (please see the table below), while are still
natural questions, fluent and preserving the core unsafe semantics. We release
the benchmark demos generated for commercial English LLMs and open-sourced
English LLMs in the following link: https://github.com/whitzard-ai/jade-db. For
readers who are interested in evaluating on more questions generated by JADE,
please contact us.
JADE is based on Noam Chomsky's seminal theory of transformational-generative
grammar. Given a seed question with unsafe intention, JADE invokes a sequence
of generative and transformational rules to increment the complexity of the
syntactic structure of the original question, until the safety guardrail is
broken. Our key insight is: Due to the complexity of human language, most of
the current best LLMs can hardly recognize the invariant evil from the infinite
number of different syntactic structures which form an unbound example space
that can never be fully covered. Technically, the generative/transformative
rules are constructed by native speakers of the languages, and, once developed,
can be used to automatically grow and transform the parse tree of a given
question, until the guardrail is broken. For more evaluation results and demo,
please check our website: https://whitzard-ai.github.io/jade.html. | [
0.0341474041,
0.045946531,
-0.0328142457,
0.0442633256,
-0.0358036496,
0.0073914402,
-0.0197052415,
0.0065727495,
0.0388253219,
-0.0344049186,
-0.0022278,
-0.0063328668,
-0.0407862104,
0.0301952064,
0.0520290099,
-0.0152505096,
0.0678474456,
-0.0418956131,
-0.0211318415,
0.0073829996,
0.0185548831,
-0.0080893803,
0.0091528157,
0.015238856,
-0.0446318649,
0.0006744419,
-0.0177597459,
0.0252421256,
0.0346909165,
-0.026108969,
0.0087844552,
-0.0048219948,
-0.0231032763,
0.0442500636,
0.0000022105,
-0.0710070357,
-0.0244254209,
0.0042156237,
-0.0101933721,
-0.0066852234,
0.0496837683,
-0.0013088137,
-0.0625968874,
0.0344827995,
-0.0542463474,
-0.0085860295,
0.0292227436,
0.0171077996,
0.081714578,
0.1368549168,
0.0040775966,
-0.0323196538,
0.0584886,
0.0182090458,
0.018655438,
-0.062502645,
0.0299451984,
-0.0100336252,
0.0209462214,
0.0093919905,
-0.024480639,
0.0029128012,
0.0418568477,
-0.0354855061,
-0.0581964403,
-0.028379919,
-0.027098747,
-0.0310525615,
-0.007082446,
0.0457050204,
-0.0561557785,
-0.0142550347,
0.0136930337,
0.0221456438,
0.0226400755,
-0.0361873098,
-0.0205212273,
0.0603161976,
-0.0077278763,
0.0051608342,
0.0657353252,
-0.0006877404,
0.0300412532,
0.0160110164,
0.0125169307,
0.1009816304,
0.0042265407,
-0.0264561325,
0.0215144679,
-0.0263470504,
0.0203170404,
-0.04865757,
-0.0004630107,
0.0062835584,
-0.0550220683,
0.0331783146,
-0.0640673563,
-0.029569624,
0.049148865,
-0.0564079136,
-0.0131357061,
0.0005827284,
-0.0078543853,
0.0243744981,
-0.0032959739,
0.0182862878,
-0.0032207777,
0.0539610088,
-0.0424605496,
0.0197228361,
0.0099299159,
0.0009419011,
-0.0227805004,
0.0203147624,
0.0166715737,
0.046461232,
-0.0394453444,
0.0319763869,
-0.0292475615,
0.0351693742,
-0.0234867092,
0.0250427499,
-0.0193461012,
0.009471993,
-0.0149067147,
-0.0350016169,
-0.0465105735,
-0.0054503819,
0.0287657231,
-0.0866482854,
-0.0111221578,
0.050615713,
-0.0488826036,
-0.0101964707,
-0.0011405169,
0.1049434841,
0.0272183772,
-0.0071217124,
-0.0690243989,
-0.0519674607,
-0.0287554506,
0.0011690444,
0.0161843747,
-0.0691232011,
-0.042145025,
-0.0196883064,
-0.0181238968,
-0.0572152771,
0.0177614782,
0.017822789,
0.0004119599,
0.0502846129,
-0.0130247856,
-0.0227370225,
0.001895145,
0.0340311565,
0.0111420462,
0.052858144,
0.0134554552,
0.0467750169,
0.0506933555,
0.0053823139,
0.0280721318,
0.0446688458,
-0.0179395117,
0.0414417125,
-0.0108129885,
0.0082108537,
-0.0041177287,
-0.0062883189,
-0.0110603767,
0.0940872803,
0.0030853706,
-0.0251983237,
0.01660542,
-0.001927131,
-0.0535290986,
0.0411877595,
0.0784582049,
0.0040057185,
-0.0218752939,
0.0316627286,
-0.0358968824,
-0.0235565919,
-0.0857839659,
-0.0307413321,
-0.0199985486,
0.0240809657,
-0.0034129974,
-0.0460558347,
-0.0064027454,
-0.0100544887,
0.0295404121,
-0.0177222248,
-0.0047644782,
0.0428928211,
-0.0143464403,
0.0349809453,
0.0398675054,
-0.0432930775,
-0.0082614357,
-0.0472664796,
-0.0139758838,
0.0461257771,
0.0320896655,
-0.0423388407,
-0.0475560799,
-0.02056548,
-0.0394934528,
0.0259580314,
-0.0020897544,
0.0082517872,
0.0020263109,
-0.0229581129,
0.003235284,
0.0074715014,
0.0290312897,
-0.0140792551,
0.0318856984,
0.0093562556,
0.0154697318,
-0.0239126142,
-0.0296021439,
0.02765866,
-0.0463154167,
-0.0538444147,
-0.0125867901,
0.0035802682,
0.0406819358,
-0.0175009407,
-0.0298974235,
0.0134664262,
0.0240032896,
-0.0287931636,
-0.0174465887,
-0.0015266315,
-0.0245227404,
0.0021963562,
0.0385699347,
-0.0478721373,
-0.0270511024,
0.0349622183,
-0.0548189543,
-0.0136900218,
0.0370584317,
-0.0488324165,
-0.0117286155,
-0.0313319899,
0.0240327176,
-0.018588677,
-0.0150310723,
-0.0483583584,
0.0661400706,
-0.0124110915,
0.0042338017,
-0.0301792193,
0.0018096028,
0.0134114446,
-0.0031765092,
-0.0373924822,
-0.0136168078,
-0.0482546128,
0.0347091556,
0.0136112152,
0.0584524199,
-0.067500934,
-0.0441493839,
-0.0412813053,
0.0203535873,
-0.011723144,
0.0360931642,
0.0182635933,
0.0032432624,
-0.0312604941,
-0.0020763674,
-0.0490268022,
0.0087056486,
-0.0034600904,
0.0113584604,
0.0203759409,
-0.0071140323,
-0.0348227061,
-0.0059832763,
0.0320393518,
-0.0472163744,
0.014082686,
-0.0074896747,
-0.0016499849,
-0.0293518566,
0.0565250441,
-0.0218442567,
0.0078327348,
0.0028859691,
-0.064386487,
0.0179768838,
-0.0157942194,
0.0258499905,
0.0458408706,
0.0059599336,
0.0216600411,
0.0417347588,
-0.0258331373,
-0.0327661149,
-0.0037454891,
0.0278060753,
-0.048064664,
-0.0261864327,
-0.0470335595,
0.0074804248,
0.0399199761,
0.01061296,
-0.0444798842,
-0.0263384152,
0.0551748499,
-0.0620242208,
-0.0206943899,
0.006804287,
-0.040896453,
-0.0378034785,
0.0348343626,
0.0073695239,
-0.0351685993,
0.0696102902,
0.003741012,
0.022029141,
-0.0497925803,
-0.0187602267,
-0.0106384661,
0.0713643655,
-0.005442753,
0.0206987225,
0.0674614757,
-0.0337622613,
-0.0675539821,
-0.0010892547,
0.0283798613,
-0.0189905576,
0.0049420972,
-0.0632973686,
-0.0102271978,
-0.008199052,
-0.0642047301,
-0.0551098995,
-0.0633650795,
-0.0092559028,
-0.0013403629,
0.0421032943,
0.0118736681,
0.0155195808,
-0.0359315872,
0.017226683,
-0.0245431904,
-0.0105227176,
-0.0121641597,
-0.0135784727,
0.0176267009,
0.0334402435,
-0.0219038595,
0.042389255,
-0.0043262532,
0.0354116932,
0.1073712185,
-0.0011327346,
0.0071122232,
-0.0252165385,
0.0212012399,
-0.0104829334,
-0.0029932028,
-0.0412699245,
0.0422088504,
0.0347731933,
-0.055297561,
-0.023938112,
0.0521161109,
0.0319711715,
0.0189289581,
0.0378149599,
-0.02308283,
0.0248472299,
0.027556885,
0.0317561217,
-0.1008755043,
-0.0107890647,
0.0320893824,
0.0195963532,
-0.038277898,
-0.0467913076,
0.0163557325,
-0.1253575087,
0.0281533226,
0.0123657491,
0.0053628869,
0.0241126083,
-0.0044995523,
-0.0191824362,
0.017193554,
0.0244115517,
0.0101707494,
-0.0163851418,
-0.0247629676,
0.0030186663,
-0.0042916043,
-0.015638452,
0.0081229964,
-0.0330592319,
0.0488376655,
0.0802461654,
-0.0226844046,
-0.0394784585,
-0.0188246146,
0.0588460788,
0.0014626374,
-0.0137685183,
-0.0259928703,
0.0035940893,
0.0486866571,
-0.0260311142,
-0.0219842065,
0.0342449956,
-0.0107829906,
0.0050289617,
0.048354473,
0.0653890595,
-0.019951269,
-0.0413558297,
-0.025728371,
0.0156534631,
-0.0007891634,
0.048569683,
0.031007532,
-0.045683898,
-0.0134399831,
-0.0945880339,
-0.0228866618,
-0.0213887785,
-0.0649953932,
0.0285351165,
-0.0274780951,
-0.046629861,
-0.097010918,
-0.0002995134,
-0.0014493158,
0.0114638628,
0.031214755,
-0.0636329576,
0.0065757753,
0.0065360283,
-0.0033457316,
0.0073570763,
-0.0092013953,
0.0131145539,
-0.0586585589,
0.0447399057,
0.0206686761,
0.0195956416,
-0.0015354779,
0.0603485107,
-0.0591590442,
-0.0854424164,
0.036856398,
0.0842185542,
0.0195283443,
-0.0178353451,
-0.0436092466,
-0.0310718939,
0.0349770226,
0.0497921556,
-0.0363168791,
0.0174337011,
0.051836282,
-0.0268530212,
0.0218673665,
0.0396202095,
-0.030081531,
0.0034225667,
0.0234017,
0.0361587815,
-0.0717110112,
-0.0222403649,
0.030738458,
0.0695387274,
0.0307591371,
-0.0217113756,
0.00956445,
0.0222722068,
0.0175333116,
-0.0329395458,
-0.0544222221,
-0.0019000378,
0.0385668539,
0.0210888442,
-0.0175958574,
0.0108195106,
0.0045157885,
-0.0274695978,
0.0279119853,
0.0285893921,
0.0213478655,
0.0225653499,
0.0455300063,
0.0314453393,
0.0194719154,
-0.0191837046,
0.0406398177,
0.0054269019,
0.0300911255,
-0.0067283548,
-0.005290905,
0.0023780926,
0.025651129,
0.0234165397,
0.0193346906,
-0.0075034676,
-0.048449073,
0.0202881619,
0.0177236963,
0.0244060475,
0.0146804238,
0.0493240207,
-0.021217294,
0.0027132342,
-0.0179083515,
-0.0118364831,
0.0030594112,
-0.0868685618,
0.0148157971,
0.0026767529,
-0.0253934748,
-0.0304161496,
0.0676619783,
-0.0106362328,
0.0435643271,
0.0576410033,
0.0161907449,
-0.0538630784,
-0.0223515723,
0.0182821546,
-0.0199918635,
0.0216003619,
0.0220031552,
-0.0706451163,
-0.0706527606,
-0.0126199648,
0.0263186544,
0.0178889483,
0.010579953,
0.0386638939,
0.037365593,
0.0351621769,
0.0249415692,
-0.0183158517,
0.0236953758,
0.0063122823,
-0.0601136498,
0.0387185961,
-6.369269203e-33,
-0.0107332421,
-0.0432160012,
-0.0193121508,
-0.0188883003,
-0.0055476809,
-0.037421111,
-0.0074417563,
0.037421912,
-0.0127782971,
0.0109489886,
-0.0213167835,
-0.0011442264,
-0.0030507108,
0.0179388486,
-0.0033152385,
-0.0475886501,
0.0009157081,
0.0054309848,
0.0014094714,
0.004562919,
0.0614015348,
0.0101498887,
0.0185945481,
-0.0524362624,
0.0307927169,
0.0067063472,
-0.0482464842,
0.0426600054,
-0.0455886796,
0.0446502902,
0.0438367017,
0.0567219593,
-0.0039824764,
-0.0248250775,
0.0125326747,
0.0241763797,
-0.0086103585,
-0.061188262,
0.0354766138,
-0.0199486278,
-0.0167061258,
-0.0855607763,
0.0681712478,
-0.0295195244,
-0.0019444929,
0.0133887855,
-0.001877988,
-0.026734516,
0.0283164661,
-0.0650073513,
-0.0516443811,
0.0136775151,
-0.0261165407,
-0.0232548341,
-0.0355410129,
0.0299214907,
0.0040912027,
-0.0346449129,
-0.0085811447,
-0.0078045828,
0.0247288067,
0.0310643241,
0.0223019477,
-0.032485649,
-0.0163280889,
0.0587473325,
-0.0385463499,
-0.0022415919,
0.0010147915,
0.0238776132,
0.0004936441,
0.0715017021,
0.041565489,
0.0691841766,
0.0164394323,
-0.0283480119,
-0.1131417304,
0.0473974794,
0.0258848052,
0.0683435053,
-0.0180593934,
-0.0149972932,
-0.0507379323,
-0.0362698026,
-0.0241712462,
0.0363591798,
-0.0148888621,
-0.0205198284,
0.0211538021,
-0.0233378932,
-0.0429629646,
-0.0604203716,
-0.0185374282,
-0.0419912636,
0.0519940145,
-0.0061220038,
-0.0107406853,
-0.0189820603,
0.0027677736,
0.0656060055,
0.0207051206,
-0.0149328057,
-0.0086227553,
-0.0742216632,
0.042397052,
0.0067679826,
0.0324831866,
0.0474238321,
-0.0423125401,
-0.0065729697,
-0.0196417812,
0.0792515054,
0.004873096,
0.0284984279,
0.0116010392,
0.0233615618,
0.0012621485,
-0.0134350639,
0.0691659227,
0.0151399877,
-0.0471383743,
0.0463352092,
-0.0088716354,
0.0412062705,
-0.0357508622,
0.0109352591,
-0.0161877945,
0.0384040475,
0.0511673763,
-0.1035269573,
-0.0202153716,
0.0041730609,
3.04e-7,
0.0394103229,
0.0521072932,
0.0251607224,
0.0532673262,
0.0231751408,
0.0488209017,
-0.0122576645,
0.0568487309,
-0.0036761526,
-0.0076193963,
-0.0396046937,
-0.0013425691,
0.0518082045,
0.0722245425,
-0.1006563753,
0.0365542062,
-0.0423423126,
0.0153959058,
-0.0352949463,
0.017562015,
0.0510846898,
0.0905975401,
0.0053649987,
-0.0386740938,
-0.001582653,
-0.0572071411,
-0.0060338648,
-0.0152252624,
-0.0088511892,
0.031470608,
0.0308273155,
0.0361099616,
0.0297048148,
-0.0015275695,
0.0043177861,
-0.0285759531,
-0.0674692616,
0.0593550615,
0.0340890586,
-0.04174041,
0.0118172886,
-0.090093635,
0.0263256542,
-0.0650039092,
0.0780162215,
0.0095370105,
-0.0135483108,
0.0009705813,
-0.0029230388,
-0.0285427272,
0.0160059445,
-0.0493629128,
-0.0379450321,
-0.0039020861,
0.028003687,
-0.0093215825,
0.0213661268,
-0.0087755825,
-0.033524517,
0.0004756861,
0.0057851928,
-0.0800938681,
-0.0006048179,
0.0402018018,
-0.0426619016,
-0.0311681926,
0.0257034916,
2.945575326e-34,
0.0135313282,
-0.0245401748,
0.021665575,
-0.0281058587,
0.0469950475,
0.0319268033,
-0.0359208994,
0.0203743782,
-0.0072100954,
-0.0379288867,
-0.0323468372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00273v1 | SoulChat: Improving LLMs' Empathy, Listening, and Comfort Abilities through Fine-tuning with Multi-turn Empathy Conversations | 2023-11-01T03:49:52 | 2023-11-01T03:49:52 | Yirong Chen, Xiaofen Xing, Jingkai Lin, Huimin Zheng, Zhenyu Wang, Qi Liu, Xiangmin Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been widely applied in various fields due
to their excellent capability for memorizing knowledge and chain of thought
(CoT). When these language models are applied in the field of psychological
counseling, they often rush to provide universal advice. However, when users
seek psychological support, they need to gain empathy, trust, understanding and
comfort, rather than just reasonable advice. To this end, we constructed a
multi-turn empathetic conversation dataset of more than 2 million samples, in
which the input is the multi-turn conversation context, and the target is
empathetic responses that cover expressions such as questioning, comfort,
recognition, listening, trust, emotional support, etc. Experiments have shown
that the empathy ability of LLMs can be significantly enhanced when finetuning
by using multi-turn dialogue history and responses that are closer to the
expression of a psychological consultant. | [
0.0784532428,
-0.0004846816,
-0.0574516654,
0.0273270737,
-0.0469584092,
0.034111809,
0.0064040986,
-0.0103545366,
0.022829162,
-0.0024513227,
-0.0599095337,
-0.0131501229,
0.0020615438,
-0.013031017,
0.0224556383,
-0.0690087751,
0.0240240972,
0.0388658084,
0.0583801754,
0.0046361443,
0.0008588504,
0.0390626006,
-0.0412286483,
0.0460113883,
-0.0149220005,
-0.0164979771,
-0.0173486769,
0.0422741473,
0.0138235576,
-0.0486050509,
0.0206165109,
0.0352299549,
-0.0114377812,
-0.0172773004,
0.0000020017,
-0.030146122,
0.0038639917,
-0.0333389603,
-0.0103599951,
-0.0180043112,
0.06068841,
-0.0418131091,
0.0168358181,
0.0284146182,
-0.0205905326,
0.0196795873,
0.0227776207,
0.0570984259,
0.0724949464,
0.0601209179,
-0.0296007264,
0.0226542223,
-0.0000306168,
-0.0176832825,
-0.0119074071,
-0.0180346128,
0.0116846766,
-0.0049304874,
0.0176481139,
-0.0191631056,
-0.026959151,
0.0332449786,
-0.0189981405,
0.0074494341,
-0.0099383742,
0.0125114173,
-0.0198871512,
-0.0455600433,
-0.0019243185,
0.0982919559,
0.0245791003,
0.0458258502,
0.0134481695,
-0.0059494083,
0.0178156905,
-0.0222750697,
-0.0545456596,
-0.0003181743,
-0.0105049098,
-0.0211294126,
-0.0153693547,
0.0053115953,
-0.0075794114,
0.0073905927,
0.0300124362,
0.0305822231,
-0.0234802738,
-0.0380162671,
0.0211422946,
-0.0077711134,
0.0090935193,
-0.0431024209,
0.0151496707,
0.0177166313,
-0.0469174199,
0.0330220126,
-0.0054290611,
0.0511000454,
0.0294609498,
0.0084743667,
0.0214021839,
0.0452418998,
-0.0072265845,
-0.0091353059,
0.0262630917,
-0.0116021661,
0.0443323366,
0.0184058994,
-0.0189830754,
-0.0005306929,
-0.0357528515,
-0.0071207713,
-0.0213850327,
0.0036455509,
-0.0145757282,
-0.0031561286,
-0.0818255469,
0.0318964534,
-0.0030974662,
0.0029068412,
-0.0293472968,
-0.0474512503,
-0.0054144259,
0.0026410043,
-0.0198928397,
0.0355720632,
-0.033820726,
0.0319599174,
0.0272070114,
-0.1026327908,
0.009250056,
0.0086367587,
-0.0069413795,
-0.0155522451,
0.0143677928,
0.0360119045,
0.0040619983,
-0.0418238044,
-0.0320232026,
0.0087729301,
-0.0389188044,
-0.0589814596,
-0.0044778376,
-0.0159541909,
0.0559768192,
0.0109153641,
0.0135286991,
0.0155999269,
0.0380873084,
0.018004939,
-0.0893121213,
0.0527478047,
-0.0137917846,
0.0437942594,
-0.0000895861,
0.022397792,
-0.0081122732,
0.0431390144,
-0.0054605203,
-0.0092114462,
0.0598726384,
-0.0497731939,
0.0042304653,
0.0167980194,
-0.0229045711,
-0.0128582949,
0.0198173225,
-0.0258328784,
-0.0413988493,
0.0605792403,
0.027123699,
0.0143972971,
-0.0312061645,
-0.0249398071,
0.0794683769,
0.1075209379,
0.0422990806,
0.0816201121,
-0.0146027552,
0.0296117812,
0.0057146344,
0.0047844783,
-0.0778975487,
0.0483987853,
-0.005837623,
-0.0168053787,
0.024156915,
0.0051033972,
-0.0397205092,
-0.0106746824,
-0.012994458,
-0.0250003673,
0.0028402207,
0.0081883799,
-0.0287139807,
-0.0172999743,
-0.0320457295,
0.0173079427,
0.0537830219,
-0.0457110703,
-0.0479551218,
-0.0284668505,
0.0030338769,
0.0740510821,
0.0134356879,
-0.014329141,
-0.0476832762,
-0.0040329979,
-0.006874809,
0.0344405733,
0.0422245599,
0.0302741639,
0.0505426042,
-0.0455652811,
0.0071065556,
0.0244001318,
-0.0126880556,
-0.0041308161,
-0.02868223,
0.0396297462,
-0.0188962501,
0.0019842682,
0.0346669666,
0.0287667681,
-0.0284739863,
0.0169858057,
0.0053216736,
-0.0020132107,
0.0294110905,
0.0056427373,
-0.0040204749,
-0.0010010892,
0.0166036263,
-0.0081418343,
-0.0328731015,
0.0598259456,
-0.0884607658,
-0.0370008536,
0.0335893333,
-0.0520944744,
-0.0196153652,
0.0446282737,
-0.0069060926,
-0.0234267823,
0.0334950462,
-0.0439277701,
0.0528371632,
-0.0299168024,
0.0272462815,
-0.0209251381,
0.0304498114,
0.0069360258,
-0.0113179581,
-0.0393472649,
0.0372226834,
-0.0576198883,
-0.0179557409,
-0.0348794684,
-0.0343067385,
-0.0116400672,
0.0166248623,
-0.0119555155,
-0.011765087,
-0.022448672,
0.016792465,
-0.0977370068,
-0.0472634174,
-0.1615095437,
0.006847139,
-0.0017174595,
-0.0168197788,
0.0373399518,
-0.0090613607,
-0.04391516,
-0.0079094898,
-0.0676585883,
0.0873551741,
0.0368221663,
0.0272425227,
0.0158932004,
-0.0085973805,
-0.0069586961,
-0.0645429865,
-0.0221761242,
-0.0236634444,
0.0121920928,
-0.0351460949,
-0.0260741934,
-0.0261230767,
0.0174136087,
-0.0540546291,
-0.0052284091,
-0.0331572369,
-0.1033364013,
-0.0082461024,
0.0018624482,
0.0273437258,
0.0376136787,
0.0552837253,
0.0222996417,
-0.019318426,
-0.0047980915,
-0.0317004882,
0.0168093424,
-0.0232292898,
-0.0292101949,
-0.0423374288,
-0.0504093617,
0.0034133287,
0.0393842198,
0.0325356647,
0.0323216617,
-0.039881099,
-0.0727817714,
0.0390962474,
-0.0382863581,
-0.0083258403,
0.0086388653,
-0.0083565926,
-0.0023651284,
-0.0054460918,
-0.0477655046,
0.072125867,
0.0147497784,
-0.0435529314,
-0.0105219949,
-0.0412767231,
-0.0093812197,
0.0414395146,
-0.0454249382,
0.0296674985,
0.0041779019,
-0.0239798985,
-0.0133394115,
-0.0546626635,
-0.0008629803,
-0.0380880758,
0.0382139347,
-0.0294589475,
-0.0368109047,
0.0375340134,
-0.0134437531,
-0.0370209403,
-0.0469470359,
-0.0525793433,
-0.0265898556,
0.0321758799,
0.0094137415,
-0.0442435555,
-0.028569039,
0.0455209538,
0.0242674649,
-0.022057049,
-0.0148135033,
-0.0019323454,
-0.0337318107,
0.0452811345,
-0.0029004016,
0.0568396933,
-0.043679487,
0.1045121029,
0.0656169504,
0.0001141045,
0.0057383352,
0.0452284366,
0.01265678,
0.0092178239,
0.0014735681,
0.011270199,
-0.0047128452,
0.0520704985,
0.0147913974,
-0.028711414,
0.1214043126,
0.0107914759,
-0.094393298,
0.0225653816,
-0.061734315,
-0.0117380545,
0.0224490669,
-0.029539533,
-0.046167776,
-0.0170792807,
-0.0134221418,
0.0289317183,
-0.030891927,
-0.0389950536,
0.0073576816,
-0.0661277473,
0.018441014,
0.0185308773,
0.008227706,
-0.0259466842,
-0.011381465,
0.0268910024,
0.0394219495,
0.0450752079,
-0.0103830071,
0.0040968298,
-0.0250294171,
-0.0021733725,
-0.050663393,
-0.0194662139,
0.0596925244,
-0.0164661705,
0.0740096048,
-0.0060045281,
0.0796974972,
0.008440949,
-0.013134256,
0.0299657416,
0.0199778974,
0.0079171723,
0.0034513786,
0.0571782775,
-0.0141882841,
0.0224097837,
-0.0233053584,
0.0650428385,
-0.0560092032,
0.0141771818,
0.0276015196,
0.0379458591,
-0.0280920956,
-0.0005554675,
0.017516708,
0.0575519577,
0.0510225669,
0.0520756766,
0.0394506417,
-0.0629380792,
0.021604687,
0.033102423,
0.0082326932,
0.0552838966,
-0.0249274783,
0.0262128636,
-0.0017469343,
0.0164047666,
-0.0340053551,
-0.0574529022,
0.0161798466,
-0.0003488373,
-0.0180807468,
-0.0241198745,
0.0159618258,
0.013814128,
-0.0300507396,
0.0175461005,
-0.0112992357,
0.0511330664,
-0.0297557879,
0.0110346945,
0.0429307856,
-0.0271539111,
0.0355098508,
0.0254024062,
-0.0063791862,
-0.0242793038,
0.0090761706,
0.0257189702,
0.0155213708,
0.0086838314,
0.0208396055,
-0.0506059229,
-0.0339754261,
0.02301112,
-0.0759688914,
0.0162115041,
0.0033896589,
0.1140078381,
0.0099040689,
0.0489328429,
-0.0135829588,
0.0406733677,
0.0232944693,
0.0302596502,
0.0044701858,
-0.0966913477,
-0.0022072934,
0.0321598761,
0.0117923291,
0.0206575543,
0.0084337648,
0.0232456345,
-0.0040779263,
-0.0473855957,
0.0150984013,
-0.0194597449,
-0.0336779617,
0.0096494034,
-0.003689864,
-0.0158125386,
-0.0939183757,
-0.0730091333,
-0.0097501436,
-0.0471913815,
-0.0021385795,
-0.0086404914,
-0.0144568728,
-0.0249353778,
0.0246706717,
-0.020735452,
0.006626267,
-0.0084876018,
0.023482902,
-0.0079883197,
0.1138001308,
0.0128183654,
-0.0238694213,
-0.0008072197,
0.0478022173,
-0.0377143137,
-0.0660932288,
0.0262174346,
0.0019951805,
0.0425754413,
0.0090594953,
0.0346270017,
-0.0155671397,
0.010230069,
-0.0083519164,
0.0478587337,
-0.0238891821,
-0.0262150411,
0.0014466671,
0.0090987496,
-0.0273184907,
0.0068043834,
0.0026323772,
-0.0745785013,
0.0348446034,
0.0090566864,
-0.0177145228,
-0.0460250676,
0.0201385245,
0.0182022322,
0.0289529469,
-0.0011655816,
0.0193923097,
-0.0956816375,
-0.0592729524,
0.0310337897,
-0.0371234678,
0.0230031293,
-0.0369378887,
0.0278489701,
0.0436386988,
0.0121707022,
0.0043536136,
-0.0426104814,
0.0481063165,
-0.0392932966,
-0.0165269785,
-0.0166370422,
-5.774781302e-33,
0.0144421151,
-0.0029287972,
-0.0341074727,
0.0008052128,
-0.0602654144,
0.0028770706,
-0.0361874551,
0.0347377546,
-0.0138843888,
0.0303474236,
-0.0230157748,
0.058984302,
-0.0023016997,
0.0103460634,
-0.0037863546,
0.0079914937,
0.0015220805,
-0.0015765757,
-0.0168549884,
0.0324112251,
-0.0088951625,
0.0572300069,
0.0537359156,
-0.0939039364,
0.0018292244,
0.0057653063,
0.0005203607,
0.0254385937,
0.0238449294,
0.0396918543,
-0.0222962443,
0.0726363733,
0.0328405239,
0.0119182076,
0.006270431,
0.0270501617,
-0.0359652713,
-0.0155899264,
0.0275811311,
-0.018508004,
-0.0533265509,
-0.0087989774,
0.0032878481,
-0.0110190902,
-0.0065300209,
-0.0326953009,
-0.0036007715,
-0.0154678244,
0.0070848567,
-0.0064699766,
-0.0165140163,
-0.0385780819,
-0.0391253941,
-0.0628162399,
-0.0286153927,
0.0426026881,
-0.0437549762,
0.031630747,
-0.0014709777,
0.020081725,
-0.0238162577,
-0.0203134771,
0.0067947241,
-0.0257088151,
-0.016332848,
0.0713432059,
-0.0280053429,
0.034731824,
-0.0186439417,
-0.0075381319,
0.0162359662,
0.0324190184,
0.0154938744,
0.0569158904,
-0.0679065064,
-0.0685165152,
-0.0079382015,
-0.006447765,
0.0754828677,
0.0196870752,
0.0401586182,
0.0062868153,
-0.0218469836,
0.0024526969,
-0.0596240908,
-0.0400391631,
-0.0230046399,
-0.0212439355,
0.0268733297,
-0.0153804719,
0.0103696352,
-0.0312334225,
0.0030028576,
-0.0394001603,
0.0256721731,
-0.0035128943,
-0.0395422839,
0.0292054731,
0.0062357346,
0.0106857615,
-0.0259984676,
-0.017310109,
0.007381083,
0.021089945,
0.054317981,
-0.0139604406,
0.0152458316,
-0.0075711966,
-0.0510082096,
-0.0158679858,
-0.0205307901,
0.0651486292,
0.0018841026,
-0.0072101122,
-0.0359965824,
0.0051485789,
-0.0419256017,
0.0414529443,
0.0041660904,
0.0031430623,
-0.0560581163,
-0.0213394389,
-0.0155600561,
0.0382294171,
-0.04468688,
-0.0136218136,
-0.020827895,
-0.0273476541,
0.0787776187,
-0.0081010228,
-0.0117739141,
-0.0232334994,
2.7e-7,
-0.0275990088,
0.0502448529,
-0.0026673451,
-0.020451976,
0.0446281396,
0.0513442121,
-0.0012859446,
0.054575298,
0.0553221367,
-0.0616728775,
0.0206864979,
0.0238678157,
0.0924264193,
0.0236877743,
-0.0391267315,
-0.0152905378,
-0.0344516486,
-0.0409208946,
-0.0334271304,
0.0160913076,
0.0915187299,
0.0656073838,
0.0246185157,
-0.0276833195,
0.0011602624,
0.034145765,
0.0351524949,
-0.0908825099,
-0.0201921165,
0.0255097058,
0.0051344093,
-0.0242666993,
0.0314154252,
0.0342888795,
0.019696841,
0.0200128909,
-0.0117720561,
0.0828970149,
-0.0263049919,
-0.0644216761,
0.0199578721,
0.0474828556,
-0.0044392813,
-0.0609093718,
0.0028926379,
-0.1024107561,
-0.0550672859,
-0.0238209497,
-0.0008263611,
-0.0136987129,
0.0315662883,
-0.0184554085,
-0.0375546105,
0.0811620802,
0.0235937927,
0.012263706,
0.0022962908,
-0.0668782145,
0.0383701175,
0.027439652,
-0.0350068882,
-0.0573691987,
0.0074001872,
-0.0025724508,
-0.0042484109,
-0.0512174778,
0.0179667231,
1.917895027e-34,
-0.0009677568,
0.0049156207,
0.049859304,
0.0468173809,
0.0546842404,
0.0119511671,
0.0208281893,
0.0351025313,
0.020125635,
-0.0605038106,
-0.0043520629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00268v1 | Syntactic Inductive Bias in Transformer Language Models: Especially Helpful for Low-Resource Languages? | 2023-11-01T03:32:46 | 2023-11-01T03:32:46 | Luke Gessler, Nathan Schneider | cs.CL | cs.CL | A line of work on Transformer-based language models such as BERT has
attempted to use syntactic inductive bias to enhance the pretraining process,
on the theory that building syntactic structure into the training process
should reduce the amount of data needed for training. But such methods are
often tested for high-resource languages such as English. In this work, we
investigate whether these methods can compensate for data sparseness in
low-resource languages, hypothesizing that they ought to be more effective for
low-resource languages. We experiment with five low-resource languages: Uyghur,
Wolof, Maltese, Coptic, and Ancient Greek. We find that these syntactic
inductive bias methods produce uneven results in low-resource settings, and
provide surprisingly little benefit in most cases. | [
0.0113249887,
0.0597204454,
-0.0195006691,
0.0248130951,
-0.0367877632,
0.0315625742,
0.0085310889,
-0.007216319,
-0.0342543125,
-0.0349041745,
-0.0392264463,
-0.0622916818,
0.0519462563,
-0.0744139776,
0.0475335494,
-0.0686574876,
0.0394901223,
-0.0272814445,
-0.0320809633,
-0.016217256,
0.0038875327,
-0.0054736007,
-0.0215200968,
0.0091629643,
-0.0450532809,
0.0159860328,
0.0052394038,
0.0068353768,
0.0006265502,
0.0088719698,
-0.0077583124,
0.061247237,
-0.0267140791,
0.0512929671,
0.000001583,
-0.0630914643,
0.0096322652,
-0.0172938537,
-0.0211042184,
0.0302687809,
0.0409566276,
-0.0691637844,
-0.0373039469,
0.030542843,
-0.0194693301,
-0.0416865647,
0.0738862082,
0.0330629982,
0.0076472182,
0.0812378973,
-0.0312305558,
-0.0545634851,
0.0253335889,
-0.0104903979,
0.0058493717,
0.026165301,
0.0074834698,
-0.0294315945,
-0.040726874,
-0.026063446,
-0.0357249491,
0.0293972027,
0.019434927,
0.0293261148,
-0.047335539,
0.0422888175,
-0.0838958696,
-0.0428913943,
-0.0133726047,
-0.0327711701,
-0.0335471146,
-0.0483431518,
-0.0255044326,
0.0307000428,
0.0127560273,
0.0369081721,
-0.0388063379,
0.0309498142,
-0.0154957268,
0.0372152478,
0.0678423494,
-0.0145408474,
-0.0002635567,
-0.0215369985,
-0.0641198307,
0.0553386249,
0.0634339899,
-0.0583641529,
0.0225174967,
0.0531683378,
-0.0222116001,
-0.0109122135,
-0.0416382812,
-0.0015306829,
0.0376512967,
-0.013157106,
-0.0349538513,
-0.0520716868,
-0.0013617775,
-0.0281756837,
0.0326315574,
0.0245172828,
-0.0388426185,
0.0134994872,
-0.0418795049,
0.0225489978,
-0.0014697949,
0.0113865547,
-0.0410072915,
0.021428952,
-0.0089099696,
-0.0038866822,
-0.073934406,
0.0022749964,
0.0120535614,
0.0334490351,
-0.0498887673,
0.01330957,
0.0451589003,
-0.0212826598,
-0.0040079351,
-0.0334841684,
-0.0825378373,
0.0052537373,
0.0163147002,
0.0534592234,
-0.0005780264,
0.0135965049,
-0.0698405355,
-0.1001365334,
-0.0020335156,
0.0475929193,
0.0268331971,
-0.0363372415,
0.0051324498,
0.0335297026,
-0.0099527119,
-0.0607043244,
-0.0430466719,
0.0578612313,
-0.0321682058,
-0.0467336513,
0.0168835204,
-0.0628927648,
-0.0019721941,
0.0295296386,
0.0251354277,
0.0028365469,
-0.0256906915,
0.0102723138,
-0.0225278828,
0.0390040018,
-0.0055664605,
0.0268883724,
0.0122881904,
-0.0544371977,
0.0222755466,
0.0727414638,
0.0334059745,
-0.0283524022,
0.0180262793,
-0.0201439653,
-0.0181670357,
0.0682176575,
-0.0025408894,
0.028805837,
-0.0263870917,
-0.0173904132,
0.0165041387,
-0.0035250161,
0.0036872691,
0.0816766918,
-0.0224710666,
0.0189591311,
0.068432942,
0.0321309194,
0.0635914505,
0.0368548296,
0.0359830745,
0.010306363,
0.0041120364,
0.0259922631,
-0.0096921194,
-0.0255307369,
0.0003851863,
0.0212895181,
-0.0162228812,
0.0568589233,
-0.0313734487,
-0.0314862542,
-0.0073089665,
-0.0504349545,
0.0059648938,
-0.0303907637,
0.0857553631,
0.0617455542,
-0.0184190851,
0.096376732,
0.0423018672,
-0.0680334121,
0.0048869429,
0.0010998559,
-0.0064697061,
-0.0011712593,
0.0044050282,
-0.0133689856,
-0.0203295369,
-0.00173513,
0.0170417409,
0.0562241711,
0.0327496566,
0.01100541,
0.0273736231,
-0.0641214997,
0.0021019848,
0.0402213074,
0.028730385,
0.0076459632,
-0.004290882,
0.0081670284,
0.0155061549,
-0.0545322485,
-0.0193528421,
0.0508435592,
0.0017316679,
0.0017774036,
-0.0239331331,
0.0280323345,
0.0082161138,
0.0065136845,
-0.0292797964,
0.0071884743,
0.0294648167,
-0.0695151091,
0.0310078282,
0.0437534116,
-0.0541071296,
-0.0548410341,
0.0284952931,
-0.0258906037,
0.0273370594,
0.0429052226,
0.0084188972,
-0.025490731,
0.0138167925,
-0.0864234865,
0.0765154883,
-0.0156567097,
0.0522031114,
-0.0249001011,
0.0032136538,
-0.025863938,
0.0664584711,
0.0030872496,
0.023337204,
0.001935181,
-0.0159974508,
0.0623673797,
-0.0243772026,
-0.0338690989,
-0.0229504183,
-0.0330288634,
-0.0064842193,
0.0531274341,
0.0022778532,
-0.0031092672,
-0.0500292033,
-0.1053597704,
-0.0125880726,
-0.0453274399,
0.0323378555,
-0.0071869404,
0.0432445854,
-0.0057330457,
-0.012653403,
-0.0258495603,
-0.0234828182,
-0.010343492,
0.0392824933,
0.0479824133,
-0.0071415589,
-0.0502085537,
-0.0078156786,
-0.0256261174,
-0.0115821697,
0.0778170526,
0.037026979,
-0.0171365626,
-0.0406854078,
0.0265864246,
0.0204799939,
0.0113454936,
0.0062878747,
-0.0537640229,
0.020809928,
0.0023446365,
0.0598847158,
0.0246787556,
0.0033130227,
-0.0177990217,
0.0120223789,
-0.0014655392,
-0.0330996104,
-0.0223676078,
-0.0280200727,
-0.0330840833,
-0.0832514092,
-0.0466966331,
0.0032985585,
0.1053720117,
-0.0236094054,
-0.0188780688,
-0.0727259144,
-0.018995529,
-0.035504248,
0.0303680226,
0.0450601466,
0.0047402126,
-0.0070327865,
0.0302827414,
-0.019530341,
-0.0694578066,
0.0380818173,
-0.0385979488,
-0.0355256274,
-0.0449079461,
0.0300660972,
-0.0502386466,
0.0044790097,
0.0383788124,
0.0153064886,
0.0112777613,
-0.0342297181,
-0.0684629902,
0.0332127102,
0.0370297581,
0.0013117503,
0.0626608133,
0.0017545535,
0.0210932679,
-0.0270707626,
-0.0551694147,
-0.0293695237,
-0.0448085926,
-0.0029005031,
0.0004985803,
0.0223428831,
-0.0221686885,
0.000827285,
-0.0146743162,
-0.0020603496,
0.0578441322,
0.0235201381,
-0.0167340282,
0.0009046857,
0.0121572725,
-0.0075394562,
0.001668653,
-0.0093839401,
-0.0273660012,
-0.0185606219,
-0.0036169293,
0.0714911744,
0.0036766173,
-0.0618179664,
0.0016377537,
0.0324472748,
-0.0343811847,
-0.0519341342,
-0.0094737727,
0.0157215632,
0.026028702,
-0.0044646873,
0.1055527031,
0.0183392018,
-0.023961911,
0.0400261693,
0.0066946428,
0.0667975545,
0.0062885182,
0.0131048923,
-0.1173995063,
-0.0117746247,
-0.0149091398,
0.0091119753,
0.0132903829,
-0.0069578672,
0.033757776,
-0.1028455123,
-0.0187620576,
0.0140747456,
0.0016728331,
-0.0273295343,
-0.0395392291,
-0.0093465392,
-0.0495709516,
-0.0118987365,
0.0003615982,
-0.033607997,
0.0135596665,
0.0605847985,
-0.0395190865,
-0.0770039633,
-0.0461740829,
-0.0481044091,
0.0080708433,
0.0434978306,
0.0191697441,
-0.0741130635,
-0.0197358131,
0.0218224339,
-0.0043327557,
-0.0083910106,
-0.0144521398,
0.0364812165,
0.0211916864,
-0.0359045975,
-0.0016255584,
0.0047877193,
-0.0310994145,
-0.0105494922,
-0.0027936713,
0.0484526716,
0.0028662074,
0.0024064982,
0.0555855371,
-0.0065193395,
-0.0064237486,
0.0548257641,
0.0279071126,
-0.0522085167,
-0.0033775885,
-0.020777937,
0.0121454922,
0.0000179306,
-0.0194245111,
0.0331068672,
0.003023183,
-0.0839442611,
-0.0865672901,
-0.0529384837,
0.0243191607,
0.0420597084,
0.0330413654,
-0.0004856861,
0.0059422078,
-0.001463847,
-0.0028292942,
0.0396401398,
-0.0102592241,
0.0027941454,
-0.0714303553,
-0.0338204913,
0.0124704866,
-0.0216731708,
0.0022993824,
-0.0461701229,
-0.0469745174,
-0.0671745464,
0.0525150895,
0.0576158985,
0.0269128177,
0.0243692622,
0.0217309929,
-0.0211860389,
0.0410883874,
0.0631258115,
-0.0191068649,
0.03728991,
0.082118772,
-0.0307954252,
0.0179814938,
0.0369135924,
-0.0119137224,
0.0221260618,
0.0220556874,
0.0374171957,
-0.0573767796,
-0.0243768916,
0.0426449962,
0.006016145,
0.0621521138,
-0.0481837802,
0.0131895915,
-0.0231104456,
0.0353480391,
-0.0117507046,
0.0194527041,
-0.0322905108,
-0.0079069817,
0.0265771784,
0.0722966716,
-0.0241312198,
-0.0023360117,
-0.0235688444,
0.0013287477,
-0.0337965265,
0.0424468629,
0.0202563088,
-0.0057901344,
0.0235699285,
0.027215844,
0.0007123915,
-0.0003063114,
0.0049681091,
0.0236867368,
-0.0070720455,
0.0256727468,
0.0152939782,
0.0156942364,
-0.0085379798,
0.0042295773,
-0.0131547162,
-0.0125994291,
-0.0076239137,
-0.0145040965,
0.0584323294,
-0.0580770709,
0.0898187459,
-0.0546784177,
0.0295968819,
-0.0171845183,
0.0223432053,
-0.0082156891,
-0.0174608529,
0.0034918655,
-0.0045589195,
-0.0193522386,
0.0158067569,
0.0868443996,
-0.0040591764,
0.0431876071,
-0.0046560396,
0.014201683,
-0.0269002561,
-0.0360558406,
0.0080240443,
-0.0562335998,
-0.0320987254,
0.0105043929,
-0.0494613796,
-0.0607230403,
-0.0059514171,
-0.0120981513,
0.0205202606,
-0.0407806262,
0.0281124748,
0.0504484512,
-0.0293841511,
-0.0063655898,
-0.0293450728,
-0.0112778498,
0.0216514077,
-0.0065385997,
-0.0303868111,
-5.312310968e-33,
-0.0068678595,
0.0483060405,
-0.0149222091,
0.0230836775,
0.0148124127,
0.005049034,
-0.0009729271,
0.0128370086,
-0.0254735164,
0.0252011213,
-0.014661761,
-0.0241234154,
0.0225011464,
0.0347711034,
0.0203841943,
-0.0005821033,
0.0422836989,
-0.0039392146,
-0.0176361818,
-0.0194316283,
-0.010791216,
0.0306858644,
0.0851200968,
-0.0075830449,
-0.0166201983,
-0.0301305875,
0.0134954294,
0.0209299754,
0.0300315041,
0.0574088618,
0.0075266687,
0.0461474434,
0.0237888917,
-0.0278801173,
0.0036791675,
0.0244559273,
-0.0522314645,
-0.02217732,
0.0258816164,
0.0734635741,
0.0100651011,
-0.0200995803,
0.0002606697,
-0.0252996422,
-0.0336942114,
0.0192987621,
0.0187432431,
-0.0172430426,
-0.027343316,
-0.0319850259,
-0.0935497731,
0.0349754505,
-0.002459107,
-0.0132948067,
0.016958857,
0.0590912886,
-0.0080139404,
-0.04350679,
-0.0141093647,
0.0156346317,
0.0248386338,
0.0691284686,
0.0282695666,
0.0047568455,
-0.0055310321,
0.0099327248,
0.0249638669,
0.0113514923,
0.0474173687,
-0.0007798024,
0.0733615309,
-0.0218378063,
0.0410514474,
0.0122605916,
0.0341873281,
0.0116274673,
-0.0634191558,
-0.0134203602,
0.0587686077,
0.0395927727,
-0.0028766117,
0.0050168042,
-0.06431292,
-0.0421401151,
-0.0030169191,
-0.0103672259,
0.0030746383,
-0.0226604659,
0.0057723727,
0.0070621748,
-0.012543112,
0.0535440594,
0.0424370654,
-0.0144393817,
-0.0270536169,
-0.011503892,
-0.0006940428,
0.0354770273,
-0.0506406389,
0.0331843905,
-0.0659503192,
-0.0589208715,
0.0212601218,
0.0257856064,
0.0285784807,
0.0168870185,
0.0800759718,
0.0361537747,
-0.0789813027,
-0.0173445176,
-0.0171315577,
-0.0072822752,
0.005296458,
0.0295299403,
0.0456869155,
0.0302141365,
0.0022327227,
0.0185539126,
0.0366080664,
-0.0439025797,
-0.0334342048,
0.0009382309,
0.0077182357,
0.0216365457,
-0.0075031114,
-0.0282580275,
-0.0263968874,
0.0305685289,
0.0133867851,
-0.0365316831,
-0.03479781,
0.0080775376,
2.402e-7,
0.0416315608,
0.0228739716,
0.0269672722,
-0.027095139,
0.0051348684,
0.014310847,
0.0041745985,
0.0014609279,
-0.0060222023,
0.0356576554,
0.0026006212,
-0.0031134551,
0.0667435303,
0.0042465632,
-0.0957799032,
-0.052332174,
-0.0518011414,
0.011244948,
-0.0513848513,
0.0158449113,
-0.0076433378,
0.1176945567,
-0.0164960679,
-0.0253289863,
-0.0359068811,
-0.0578768775,
0.0552279465,
-0.0377921462,
-0.0153915193,
0.0402078144,
0.0501965694,
0.0079265768,
0.0019971887,
0.0327969268,
-0.0451792777,
0.0229486879,
-0.0090074996,
-0.0019801962,
-0.0113339312,
0.0240071248,
0.0611894429,
-0.0075540747,
-0.0762068853,
-0.0459607914,
0.0318948962,
-0.0629340336,
-0.0053785448,
0.0210764073,
-0.025172377,
0.0195474979,
0.0029234211,
-0.0209560692,
-0.0216349177,
0.0175965242,
0.0881181508,
-0.0486568622,
-0.0124295782,
-0.015294482,
-0.0052926941,
0.0478265509,
-0.0116207022,
-0.0363894887,
-0.0133736581,
-0.0193749592,
0.0228443127,
-0.019045921,
0.0173098966,
2.178953726e-34,
0.033588279,
-0.0251491219,
0.0522108153,
0.0421698764,
0.0088072661,
-0.0380992293,
0.0201239176,
0.0383478291,
0.0131482035,
-0.0568402149,
0.0191851873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00262v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00262v2 | Plug-and-Play Policy Planner for Large Language Model Powered Dialogue Agents | 2023-11-01T03:20:16 | 2024-03-11T08:30:31 | Yang Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Wai Lam, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Proactive dialogues serve as a practical yet challenging dialogue problem in
the era of large language models (LLMs), where the dialogue policy planning is
the key to improving the proactivity of LLMs. Most existing studies enable the
dialogue policy planning of LLMs using various prompting schemes or iteratively
enhance this capability in handling the given case with verbal AI feedback.
However, these approaches are either bounded by the policy planning capability
of the frozen LLMs or hard to be transferred to new cases. In this work, we
introduce a new dialogue policy planning paradigm to strategize LLMs for
proactive dialogue problems with a tunable language model plug-in as a
plug-and-play dialogue policy planner, named PPDPP. Specifically, we develop a
novel training framework to facilitate supervised fine-tuning over available
human-annotated data as well as reinforcement learning from goal-oriented AI
feedback with dynamic interaction data collected by the LLM-based self-play
simulation. In this manner, the LLM-powered dialogue agent can not only be
generalized to different cases after the training, but also be applicable to
different applications by just substituting the learned plug-in. In addition,
we propose to evaluate the policy planning capability of dialogue systems under
the interactive setting. Experimental results demonstrate that PPDPP
consistently and substantially outperforms existing approaches on three
different proactive dialogue applications, including negotiation, emotional
support, and tutoring dialogues. | [
0.0757967383,
0.0208451487,
-0.0362229533,
0.0296545327,
-0.0228969753,
0.0112571502,
0.0087446524,
-0.0341230221,
0.0165741891,
-0.0279368833,
-0.0036076829,
-0.0146087594,
-0.0341316573,
0.0872253999,
0.0244425386,
-0.0709903613,
0.0511559471,
-0.0478033535,
0.0616882108,
0.0008339653,
0.0159974508,
-0.0117915608,
-0.0496672094,
0.0515152328,
-0.0225755442,
0.0100222612,
-0.0512850471,
0.0039667599,
0.0129429316,
-0.0170836747,
0.0154780401,
0.0331287012,
0.0287235118,
0.0025456739,
0.00000192,
-0.062101502,
0.0158353392,
-0.0503674895,
-0.001837856,
-0.018117575,
0.039017193,
0.0155592328,
-0.0258741323,
0.0318479016,
-0.0434173457,
0.0152430208,
0.0117035117,
0.0565448366,
0.0775433332,
0.0791546181,
0.0042178105,
-0.0081486283,
-0.0037713037,
-0.0111351591,
-0.0269160401,
-0.0522825904,
0.0011323513,
-0.0044004358,
0.0284155868,
-0.0022457968,
-0.0245640166,
0.0203879122,
0.0256605223,
-0.0527177304,
-0.0554661676,
0.029370252,
-0.0470596515,
-0.0316902995,
-0.0452595912,
0.1048587635,
0.0082360674,
0.0099226572,
0.0396266282,
-0.0338462591,
0.0153327882,
-0.0149427084,
0.0014407786,
0.0136740161,
0.0202361047,
0.0191850644,
0.0038538089,
-0.0133080147,
0.0078598848,
0.0109872278,
-0.0185469966,
0.0617173649,
-0.0415727422,
-0.0262971967,
0.0325080417,
-0.0149829928,
0.0233143885,
-0.0580007993,
-0.0068696439,
0.0496477187,
-0.092388995,
0.0308172405,
-0.0201544613,
0.0418990888,
-0.0067209327,
0.0002150642,
0.0344182476,
0.0647354946,
0.0047515989,
0.0511478484,
0.0341923945,
0.0529005155,
0.0119170947,
0.0133601371,
0.0066442429,
0.021814568,
-0.0469206497,
0.0159878507,
-0.0676981136,
-0.0107874405,
-0.0432307832,
-0.0440005288,
0.001657384,
0.052992627,
-0.0439186208,
0.0566599481,
-0.0218186453,
-0.0048908056,
-0.0289446153,
-0.015813563,
-0.077736266,
0.0323308744,
-0.0560002811,
-0.0061324644,
0.0187261328,
-0.0404216796,
-0.0072398097,
0.0089460434,
-0.0203031301,
0.0194910355,
-0.0078007285,
0.0610432178,
-0.0295331571,
-0.0197342839,
-0.0149836587,
0.0021880968,
-0.0060303635,
-0.0747377649,
0.0038338203,
-0.0307247024,
0.0392954536,
-0.0328237675,
-0.0243922584,
-0.037412703,
0.0136153856,
-0.0118948547,
0.014465468,
0.050904464,
0.020500429,
0.0323336013,
0.0326333344,
0.0015786045,
-0.0500042215,
0.0974569172,
0.051030986,
0.0003668081,
0.010799869,
0.0089492202,
0.0317566991,
0.0489300601,
0.0140616512,
0.0366989262,
-0.0028524289,
0.0094498517,
-0.0058304756,
0.0328458287,
0.0048125624,
0.0182197299,
-0.0339697376,
0.0020703103,
0.0326091796,
0.0459617414,
-0.0461801924,
0.0207341984,
0.0258477926,
0.0594950505,
0.0136726825,
-0.02553856,
-0.0423323475,
0.0319516547,
0.0151592381,
-0.0192649495,
-0.0039108978,
0.013119773,
-0.0273745563,
-0.0663897097,
0.03282433,
0.0046603014,
0.014041068,
0.0355746001,
0.0118787419,
0.0061851675,
-0.0439679474,
0.0091853477,
-0.0045154653,
-0.0022159156,
-0.0346146487,
-0.0458521023,
0.0286410283,
0.0936397165,
0.0518142581,
-0.0569394231,
-0.0575390495,
-0.0348881409,
0.0027905786,
0.0739268661,
0.0249855146,
-0.0369645022,
0.0195908546,
-0.0401209332,
-0.025713088,
-0.031452179,
0.0041152928,
0.0248866566,
0.0252010096,
-0.0216340702,
-0.0158008114,
0.0791735202,
-0.0023761,
0.0127109941,
-0.0402703993,
-0.0150167029,
0.009264336,
-0.0065808916,
0.0613383651,
0.0034335416,
-0.0257955994,
-0.0234642252,
0.0174286924,
0.0061541065,
0.0046651419,
0.0095896106,
-0.0361095183,
-0.0291646365,
0.0403861329,
0.0245714132,
-0.0359954722,
-0.0337292589,
-0.0528558418,
-0.0417441428,
0.0172654148,
-0.0143392179,
0.0068704602,
-0.0291850343,
0.0221128277,
-0.0192330107,
-0.0243931077,
-0.0205917582,
0.0058272034,
0.0004773839,
-0.0281773675,
0.0788357779,
0.0483760685,
0.0034716281,
-0.0603216961,
-0.0109281298,
0.0437877364,
0.0100959446,
-0.0089669134,
0.0209317766,
0.0335139968,
-0.0542827286,
-0.0487701595,
-0.0570054576,
0.0063060671,
-0.0209547579,
-0.0246261023,
-0.0094348947,
-0.0003949195,
-0.0423272401,
-0.0408587381,
-0.0220232867,
0.0079565635,
0.0486656278,
-0.0006426664,
0.0252527948,
0.0412251614,
-0.0345472135,
-0.0676009953,
0.0333292969,
0.0074242866,
-0.0408571437,
-0.0146009829,
-0.0094061922,
-0.0563087426,
0.0123231448,
-0.0349044055,
0.0504996888,
-0.0355421714,
-0.0829050541,
0.0281926617,
-0.0167536549,
0.0412744917,
0.0951604024,
-0.0021374144,
0.0426140986,
0.0375426523,
-0.0458589792,
-0.0916543603,
0.0878589451,
-0.040763665,
-0.0135264304,
-0.0814444572,
0.0142731909,
0.0129655767,
0.0510968938,
-0.0155336587,
0.0468829833,
-0.0562703609,
0.010532422,
0.0297661833,
-0.0598809198,
0.0050621131,
0.0045502335,
-0.0526803508,
0.027284842,
-0.0097532673,
-0.0461911149,
0.0923870802,
0.0110254651,
-0.0227110367,
-0.0296709333,
-0.0277668275,
-0.0128057422,
0.0476283394,
-0.0008002157,
-0.0094215423,
-0.0449173748,
-0.0148581257,
-0.0377794318,
-0.0286944397,
0.0201152526,
-0.0250336025,
0.0290297363,
-0.0731029436,
-0.0068135951,
0.016561294,
-0.0556521751,
-0.0585903525,
-0.0253635608,
-0.0461886562,
-0.0063652587,
-0.0081978794,
-0.0420608148,
-0.010401478,
0.0075273034,
0.0240870882,
0.0479578562,
-0.0107642151,
-0.0079569956,
-0.025175713,
-0.0519510694,
0.0377115794,
0.0529902391,
-0.0248949174,
0.0157219358,
0.0740687475,
0.0079585975,
0.0050705844,
-0.0329715908,
-0.0115405647,
0.0108163999,
0.0103826895,
-0.000225422,
0.0011852622,
0.0383295007,
0.0372233093,
-0.0573575459,
-0.0238721725,
0.1082768142,
0.0371073373,
-0.0300826505,
-0.0089885667,
-0.0094103366,
0.0386974514,
0.0121977143,
0.0634002984,
-0.0478520505,
-0.0190028287,
-0.0021273654,
0.0329405963,
-0.0241184942,
-0.0293625593,
-0.0026925211,
-0.1140494198,
0.0424234979,
-0.0087943133,
0.0136106694,
0.010974383,
-0.0123419128,
0.0147613203,
-0.0000101581,
0.0154793346,
-0.0126705123,
0.0209141877,
-0.0228575412,
-0.0032653073,
0.0084881913,
-0.0401668027,
-0.0010126821,
0.0081309825,
0.0756149366,
0.0971595719,
0.04492452,
0.0170920547,
0.0185665004,
0.0211402513,
0.055348672,
-0.0134339659,
-0.013337357,
0.0020021875,
-0.0099493098,
-0.0046211346,
0.0014269158,
0.0501128286,
-0.0003617844,
-0.0224340446,
0.0424243733,
0.0528426915,
-0.0580286346,
0.0221645795,
-0.0050573046,
0.0321973003,
0.0546066575,
0.0471537523,
0.0081518041,
-0.0561382361,
-0.0532656051,
-0.0265844222,
-0.0480993576,
-0.0272020586,
-0.0290470626,
-0.0129275061,
-0.0071979263,
0.0380485654,
-0.0450317264,
-0.0494762734,
0.0452455916,
0.0255329255,
0.008587718,
-0.0438907258,
0.0216711573,
0.035682112,
0.0277260765,
-0.0070168651,
-0.0151265487,
0.0244925953,
-0.0651204214,
-0.0486840867,
0.0435344204,
-0.0114455996,
0.000101036,
0.0171296764,
-0.0390988737,
-0.0777697638,
-0.0019191905,
0.085180603,
0.0199721437,
0.068249993,
-0.0089266263,
-0.0410474986,
0.0071113813,
0.0386709012,
-0.0298341643,
-0.0090978555,
0.0185797922,
0.0692743436,
0.0010934632,
0.0381993428,
-0.0366984755,
0.0047097523,
-0.0053335237,
0.0229305178,
-0.0199848935,
-0.0801120922,
-0.0063535054,
-0.0098727224,
0.0016271729,
-0.0031499888,
-0.0205929354,
-0.0305581205,
0.0260246303,
-0.0236629527,
-0.0291110724,
-0.0543353334,
0.0278750751,
-0.0138084898,
-0.0391840413,
0.0313488171,
-0.0149022965,
-0.0119625395,
0.0073854136,
0.0035043801,
0.005411807,
0.0278239101,
-0.0194631014,
0.0231892243,
0.0193155818,
0.0144714583,
0.0498483069,
0.0363604762,
0.0226635169,
0.0193319339,
0.1208809093,
0.0447813533,
-0.0448929407,
-0.0200211741,
0.0005678398,
-0.0437271036,
-0.0819945186,
0.0356981046,
0.0586305261,
0.0331551805,
0.0182227939,
0.0192452874,
-0.0840214416,
0.011295246,
0.0177451968,
0.0170723889,
0.0020259577,
-0.0299837328,
0.0585203506,
0.0289774965,
-0.0101483893,
0.0155624431,
0.0380341522,
0.0158857144,
0.0335101895,
-0.0048523364,
0.0280599799,
-0.0477398187,
-0.0317952968,
-0.0104624862,
0.0251166355,
-0.013316053,
0.0253764261,
-0.0504675098,
-0.02876864,
-0.0572548732,
0.0269411858,
-0.0366726443,
-0.0376422554,
0.0304008536,
0.001011867,
-0.0100712525,
-0.0134371398,
-0.0561136343,
0.0279767811,
-0.0146010034,
-0.0354315862,
-0.0352239423,
-5.645179744e-33,
-0.02966493,
-0.043812044,
0.0388130359,
0.0037740222,
-0.0463506468,
-0.0350146815,
-0.038851954,
-0.0076997867,
-0.0089193601,
0.0283858851,
-0.0226460602,
0.0416849144,
0.0188825056,
-0.0027063112,
-0.0106270909,
-0.0262230281,
0.047430411,
-0.0149439983,
-0.0310126729,
0.0369554535,
0.0183626842,
-0.0030424085,
-0.0212600622,
-0.0601083003,
0.0178537946,
0.0017604817,
-0.0359460153,
0.0640509874,
-0.0095856199,
0.0716577023,
0.0052386001,
0.0125842839,
-0.00110256,
-0.0355832092,
-0.0014370292,
0.0346165597,
-0.056285847,
-0.0358293951,
0.0000531783,
-0.0011488477,
-0.0462840721,
-0.0063520288,
-0.0171514172,
-0.0034206689,
-0.0302319657,
0.0322407559,
-0.0065452019,
-0.0122481575,
-0.0155432653,
0.0156422686,
-0.0510071404,
0.0057648327,
-0.0400194414,
-0.0352381878,
0.0284027625,
0.0133209899,
0.0019986939,
-0.0048560728,
-0.0095348302,
0.009012185,
0.0250313859,
-0.0139432428,
0.0456514619,
0.0398568325,
0.0306162965,
0.0482148789,
0.0177785251,
0.0447484739,
-0.0191195402,
-0.0213166885,
0.0102590388,
0.0306137912,
-0.0017382475,
0.0645671487,
-0.0309434067,
-0.0156518854,
-0.0037009981,
-0.0005781052,
0.0706476122,
0.0473960117,
0.0149019072,
0.0039200019,
-0.0363603942,
-0.0186286923,
-0.0515393168,
0.0162736587,
0.0104625449,
-0.0503533222,
0.0518713407,
0.0437526107,
0.0212389901,
-0.0356293358,
0.0293213055,
-0.0249685626,
-0.0117807453,
0.035660509,
-0.0336566642,
0.0228474867,
-0.0046664425,
0.0072143883,
-0.0664679706,
-0.056550134,
0.0099893128,
-0.0284921769,
0.0179197323,
0.0149515113,
-0.0329227187,
0.0388250239,
-0.0404680222,
0.0080073448,
-0.0373292677,
0.066377908,
-0.0127990562,
0.0267974548,
-0.0071533765,
-0.0123492703,
-0.0271184798,
0.0699464679,
-0.0017141879,
-0.0554478616,
0.0018298537,
-0.0223457348,
-0.0015014472,
0.0100097852,
-0.0475877002,
0.0067458418,
-0.0318819657,
0.0319624431,
-0.0230880138,
-0.0469089448,
0.0140979672,
-0.0005919162,
2.64e-7,
-0.0442279018,
0.0529203862,
0.0187016297,
0.0334141441,
0.041397348,
0.0403284207,
-0.0354564264,
0.0026121279,
0.0262846965,
-0.0106028989,
0.0397735946,
0.0404345617,
0.0455056839,
0.0211961288,
-0.1169146746,
0.001461899,
-0.0445319265,
-0.0134052606,
-0.0782065466,
-0.0118194269,
0.061159119,
0.0700889975,
0.015977487,
0.0273102112,
0.0201596953,
-0.001846962,
0.0284465328,
-0.0589427873,
-0.017788915,
0.0353948399,
0.0228795335,
0.0100666406,
0.0072873863,
-0.0010734418,
-0.0030598461,
0.0831583887,
-0.0674142092,
0.1078324094,
0.037954051,
-0.0364086479,
0.0067853779,
-0.0108764749,
0.0196509436,
-0.0493671,
0.0421852805,
-0.0646015257,
-0.0014816156,
0.0110235969,
0.0115458025,
-0.0557279028,
0.0038719731,
-0.0412542187,
-0.0233921502,
0.0363703743,
-0.0090855351,
-0.0202251356,
0.0258950293,
-0.0556647591,
0.0137432273,
-0.0259777922,
-0.0252429936,
-0.0260528568,
-0.0448617749,
-0.0029075388,
-0.0192587879,
-0.0243480019,
0.0190744232,
2.207223447e-34,
0.025934279,
-0.029595932,
0.0075426265,
0.0284769032,
0.0449536927,
0.0448236614,
0.0087021077,
0.0262686033,
0.0566004291,
-0.0624789596,
-0.0338399746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00258v1 | Noisy Exemplars Make Large Language Models More Robust: A Domain-Agnostic Behavioral Analysis | 2023-11-01T03:15:05 | 2023-11-01T03:15:05 | Hongyi Zheng, Abulhair Saparov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in prompt engineering enable large language models (LLMs) to
solve multi-hop logical reasoning problems with impressive accuracy. However,
there is little existing work investigating the robustness of LLMs with
few-shot prompting techniques. Therefore, we introduce a systematic approach to
test the robustness of LLMs in multi-hop reasoning tasks via domain-agnostic
perturbations. We include perturbations at multiple levels of abstractions
(e.g. lexical perturbations such as typos, and semantic perturbations such as
the inclusion of intermediate reasoning steps in the questions) to conduct
behavioral analysis on the LLMs. Throughout our experiments, we find that
models are more sensitive to certain perturbations such as replacing words with
their synonyms. We also demonstrate that increasing the proportion of perturbed
exemplars in the prompts improves the robustness of few-shot prompting methods. | [
0.0007871154,
0.0339237489,
-0.0297349393,
0.0399195068,
-0.0885463357,
0.0105113424,
0.0538027957,
-0.0135605419,
0.0323165804,
-0.0456998274,
-0.0111102462,
-0.0316375606,
-0.0274176281,
0.0065633827,
0.0351632163,
0.0087080691,
0.0890930668,
-0.0882185623,
-0.0198167916,
-0.035239011,
-0.0442409292,
-0.0170671605,
-0.0114181926,
0.0130939018,
0.0080455588,
-0.0324729383,
-0.0448083282,
0.0087122871,
-0.0167527143,
-0.0348492302,
-0.039191246,
0.0685173124,
0.0081034945,
0.038540341,
0.0000024275,
-0.0846120119,
-0.0203110985,
0.0172429737,
-0.0521530733,
0.018452391,
-0.0038038746,
0.024657933,
-0.0153632667,
0.0099534271,
0.0184982065,
0.0020273165,
0.0289941281,
0.0460744388,
0.0579151288,
0.0454165414,
0.0042647845,
-0.0108359121,
-0.0250308253,
-0.0146401431,
0.0427389294,
-0.0586820245,
0.0562579259,
0.0130942557,
0.0661548078,
0.016150061,
-0.0210858826,
0.0228983667,
0.0322380252,
0.0053437026,
-0.0551194809,
0.0054333485,
0.0156866647,
-0.0231182911,
-0.01811078,
0.057813026,
-0.0001831385,
0.0262235831,
-0.0146567589,
-0.0043336903,
0.02350186,
0.0254839361,
-0.0127604976,
0.0113081625,
-0.0012956531,
-0.0325889029,
0.0109433262,
-0.0170331113,
0.0236873981,
0.0194103103,
-0.0379020832,
0.1028543487,
0.0350706577,
-0.0432329811,
-0.0045796838,
-0.023045551,
-0.0043648672,
-0.0738830566,
-0.0097920122,
0.0365101621,
-0.0929832011,
0.0269817542,
-0.0348233618,
0.0077326703,
0.0294951368,
0.0118843121,
0.0246324688,
0.0694280714,
-0.0021152576,
0.070585601,
-0.0074862977,
0.0583176799,
-0.009660189,
0.0141673349,
-0.003280462,
0.0136762979,
-0.0219937451,
-0.0132492119,
-0.0504237264,
0.0529693216,
-0.0467782803,
-0.0028331291,
-0.0305593722,
0.0338979959,
0.0028882485,
0.0417126603,
-0.045785483,
-0.0205911119,
0.0048239161,
-0.0550485849,
-0.0489463694,
-0.0082192123,
-0.0562899634,
0.0107317455,
0.0277504288,
-0.0307263024,
-0.0323560014,
-0.0165216699,
-0.0000124749,
-0.0452244021,
0.0010247255,
0.0930766687,
-0.0096912542,
-0.0412332229,
-0.0072323079,
-0.0676447824,
-0.0135101555,
-0.04865437,
-0.0255608577,
-0.0628099591,
0.0355455093,
0.0116426609,
-0.0312325135,
-0.0442773327,
0.0121735558,
0.0216419678,
-0.0206002556,
0.1104215458,
0.0274762958,
0.0110483225,
-0.0084279785,
0.0126773268,
-0.0610639453,
0.0506950058,
-0.0042287712,
-0.0051626642,
0.0253279898,
0.005398103,
0.0112638976,
0.044822976,
-0.0074884528,
0.0109223342,
-0.0284483712,
0.025955148,
0.0382915623,
0.028731646,
-0.0262611937,
0.0831056312,
-0.0418595821,
-0.0029063029,
0.0378039032,
0.0484195985,
-0.0188426357,
-0.027518006,
0.0366848558,
-0.0170214288,
-0.0201406907,
0.0262231529,
-0.0978494883,
0.0094653349,
-0.0436249375,
0.0122881941,
0.0231734477,
0.0235073101,
-0.0217075814,
-0.0165239405,
-0.0119468505,
0.0339644551,
-0.0020196168,
0.0155043872,
0.0319173485,
0.008939282,
-0.0285784304,
0.0336600207,
0.0016185301,
-0.0143779498,
-0.0142791402,
-0.0683691204,
0.01463491,
0.0624599755,
0.066167064,
-0.0154623855,
-0.0248205755,
-0.0015433965,
0.0385767668,
0.0187401641,
0.055851005,
0.0066537857,
-0.0133610712,
-0.0278342478,
0.0035004069,
-0.0171715729,
0.0160141494,
0.014420799,
0.0069066943,
-0.0231287852,
0.0121787088,
-0.0103539675,
0.0161248762,
0.0209562164,
-0.036976859,
-0.0301928166,
-0.0081053507,
0.0156646557,
-0.0103262523,
-0.0060170148,
-0.0095305452,
0.0324545987,
-0.0133490656,
-0.0149500389,
-0.0192792825,
-0.0116856676,
-0.0315941907,
-0.0501962528,
0.0265922826,
0.0435081795,
-0.0458543263,
-0.0123999063,
-0.0358170345,
-0.0242445637,
0.0035471946,
-0.0169314034,
0.0014391912,
-0.0313797072,
0.0607314184,
0.0005077845,
-0.0264144484,
-0.0409725457,
0.0620436408,
0.0040369229,
0.0341779217,
0.0213619173,
0.0929721892,
0.0032202692,
-0.0260801855,
-0.0386252552,
-0.0021254036,
-0.0239224415,
-0.0174218081,
-0.0188727882,
0.0026286996,
-0.0416505486,
-0.0447576754,
-0.025306059,
0.0101123452,
-0.0025396957,
0.0281231087,
-0.0003390217,
0.032754574,
-0.0252512936,
0.0052289008,
0.0068734582,
0.0140447961,
0.0172146335,
0.0586582161,
0.0386712402,
0.0098286737,
-0.0554436669,
-0.0059187515,
-0.0115615232,
-0.0376875848,
0.0291376896,
0.0067593143,
-0.0063706404,
-0.0626046211,
0.0179510303,
-0.0221292675,
0.0308473203,
0.006115735,
-0.0033386096,
0.0132632116,
0.0051870989,
0.0791922584,
0.073237136,
-0.0236861333,
-0.0061547002,
0.0555830747,
-0.0318736769,
-0.0373144709,
0.0328906067,
-0.0117881168,
-0.0359793529,
-0.0131512871,
-0.0152653782,
-0.0024257379,
0.057057865,
-0.013713534,
-0.0024041354,
-0.0289372224,
0.0631349012,
-0.015692113,
-0.018986728,
-0.0466259494,
-0.0379089564,
-0.0091344379,
0.0709140971,
-0.0084211696,
-0.0094139567,
0.1100817397,
-0.011876897,
0.0115668662,
-0.030063251,
0.0321407579,
-0.0267321542,
0.0624051802,
-0.038625367,
0.006574099,
0.0448125415,
-0.0395301022,
-0.0611601844,
-0.0536171123,
0.0111156851,
-0.0164129864,
0.0290985927,
-0.0434420034,
0.0123987254,
-0.0017806138,
-0.0694381669,
-0.0459534712,
-0.0517000854,
-0.0365282856,
0.0046038129,
-0.0191261638,
0.015413682,
-0.0155466441,
0.0010793858,
0.0267739091,
0.018853005,
-0.0206131078,
-0.0049573793,
-0.041256249,
0.004631483,
0.0314587988,
0.0178722646,
0.006774703,
-0.0274633244,
0.0795981213,
0.0278630033,
0.0153516894,
-0.0141769769,
0.011572496,
0.0176186841,
0.001028716,
-0.0273367744,
0.0029701267,
0.0386886485,
0.0751306713,
-0.0616198592,
-0.0304952171,
0.1067791581,
0.0657078028,
-0.0003899018,
0.0194168799,
-0.0692541823,
0.0316758566,
0.0177529119,
0.0639230683,
-0.0827929005,
-0.0622942001,
0.0439831913,
-0.0340890028,
-0.0224250332,
-0.0318995751,
0.0000311033,
-0.1548439264,
0.0333038382,
-0.0223760493,
-0.0066531082,
-0.0204311199,
-0.0248142742,
0.0364646949,
0.0317550264,
0.0352136269,
0.0425834507,
0.0076614879,
-0.0368876196,
-0.0076472112,
0.0420540385,
-0.0396335609,
0.06190072,
-0.031796217,
0.0475978591,
0.0655770674,
-0.0317198224,
-0.0019425573,
-0.0645374805,
0.0968858078,
-0.0048202262,
0.0295555107,
-0.0145376846,
0.0065115243,
0.0253288895,
-0.0120231956,
-0.0172755215,
0.0274622552,
-0.0080932602,
-0.0499319807,
0.0206339173,
0.0713411048,
-0.0225424301,
-0.0071416013,
-0.0137908915,
0.0204864033,
0.0156346485,
0.0764060915,
0.01132059,
-0.0565068498,
-0.0439567193,
-0.0437000655,
-0.0698010698,
-0.0225660186,
-0.0166261457,
0.0101904143,
0.0107866619,
-0.0113775469,
-0.0386967845,
-0.0291707125,
0.0423173048,
0.0215853658,
0.0050109606,
-0.0207528099,
-0.003015816,
0.0171912909,
0.0257550869,
0.0211593248,
-0.0420120247,
0.0497764386,
-0.0376199037,
0.0715631917,
0.0328203291,
-0.0032983916,
-0.0225488413,
-0.0068433234,
-0.0544321686,
-0.0699702799,
-0.0008506947,
0.0141820405,
0.0228953306,
0.0259624012,
-0.0437531546,
-0.0362846702,
0.0276560467,
0.0362843722,
0.017599402,
0.0157114919,
0.0238837041,
0.006598148,
-0.0056952387,
0.036258325,
-0.0257245488,
0.0377136543,
0.027262684,
0.0541301444,
-0.0031235418,
-0.0172089823,
0.0292801354,
0.0522608049,
0.0439300574,
0.009941645,
-0.0033840819,
0.0018504746,
0.0333556086,
-0.0557553619,
-0.0509494096,
-0.0011434804,
0.0014541702,
-0.0170366969,
-0.0390949287,
0.0261051785,
-0.060939692,
-0.0198672358,
0.0522377901,
0.008331025,
0.0020119853,
-0.034045767,
-0.0172263589,
0.0514895916,
-0.006250083,
-0.0242107231,
0.0318556465,
0.0071340669,
0.0370320491,
-0.0115902983,
0.0833486393,
0.0374879502,
0.0116783408,
-0.0693136901,
0.0117237,
-0.0510700196,
-0.0577850752,
0.0610147566,
0.0171977002,
0.0029994021,
0.0182320662,
-0.0392040871,
-0.0393778458,
-0.0117648719,
-0.0037697696,
-0.001809504,
0.0509354956,
-0.0347812809,
0.0644222051,
0.0459312089,
0.0042827753,
-0.0100242747,
0.0336476974,
-0.0656577945,
0.0319838077,
0.0033455363,
0.022089785,
-0.0243430901,
-0.0348136015,
-0.0182434861,
0.0077399192,
-0.0328284092,
-0.003719968,
-0.0964624658,
-0.0723396763,
-0.0226631239,
0.0297263991,
0.0064954339,
0.0011523506,
0.017484786,
0.0747369379,
0.0305618923,
-0.0212451685,
-0.0056335023,
0.0013787437,
-0.0088276519,
-0.0436222926,
-0.0102844397,
-6.858353464e-33,
-0.0275123976,
-0.0208438244,
0.0486080386,
-0.0603421777,
-0.0025791395,
-0.0365938656,
-0.0488957204,
0.0377592258,
-0.0135237202,
-0.0046227914,
-0.0367736034,
-0.0064064641,
0.0117254024,
0.0042652362,
0.0116400989,
-0.0340106599,
0.0271155871,
0.0144415824,
-0.0490487926,
-0.0198835675,
0.0125126885,
-0.0296170637,
-0.0471565016,
0.0022838891,
0.0311054755,
0.0282150768,
-0.033622954,
0.0598529764,
-0.0466477349,
0.0275122952,
-0.011509221,
0.0120870415,
-0.0024133893,
-0.0373133905,
-0.0044136485,
0.0553062856,
-0.0354163125,
-0.0366212986,
0.0450347327,
-0.0316262022,
-0.0160032064,
-0.0558354519,
0.0160797164,
-0.0089543378,
-0.0180435255,
-0.0052425107,
-0.0209486987,
-0.0112365671,
-0.0040396829,
0.0164883789,
-0.0420922674,
0.0168559197,
-0.0137937889,
-0.0439706631,
-0.0153513635,
0.0695234984,
0.0053339745,
0.0212691203,
-0.0057935389,
0.023169769,
0.0436567627,
-0.0102869337,
0.0424419232,
0.0244632736,
-0.0026127184,
0.0431529321,
0.0111857653,
0.0383297727,
-0.0141851008,
0.0162311364,
-0.0030275458,
0.0381723717,
0.038663324,
0.0358800665,
0.0251590498,
0.0115026962,
-0.0442003794,
-0.0034739245,
0.0031959575,
0.0100415358,
0.0631965175,
-0.0050615673,
-0.0602257252,
-0.0380555727,
-0.0598081648,
0.0442254245,
-0.0567045808,
-0.034636315,
0.0362086333,
-0.0273914207,
-0.0383339822,
-0.0166229233,
0.0226048343,
-0.0160457101,
-0.0138613535,
-0.0237196982,
-0.0152170286,
0.0166434143,
-0.0257896483,
0.0383235328,
0.0080677588,
-0.0349565037,
-0.0106567908,
0.0162367076,
0.0180574004,
0.0254338961,
-0.0011132783,
0.0069865691,
-0.0918908045,
-0.0228637271,
-0.0360445604,
0.0068663168,
-0.0031239924,
-0.0132613918,
0.0516284928,
0.0267385188,
-0.0091769295,
0.0264482666,
0.0108495634,
-0.0617165677,
-0.0183395632,
0.0583191849,
-0.0063910489,
0.023605153,
-0.015114719,
-0.0164557882,
-0.0294041503,
0.0194016229,
0.0268795099,
-0.0306199975,
-0.0175914746,
0.0132831512,
3.279e-7,
0.0054974756,
0.055431094,
0.0021744536,
0.0889875218,
0.0109779676,
0.0567086264,
-0.0107381064,
-0.0062760967,
0.0313861184,
-0.0225681923,
-0.00386893,
0.0383238085,
0.0091002909,
0.0229024161,
-0.0933219865,
0.002313996,
-0.0097737527,
0.0011249149,
-0.0674901903,
0.0224281531,
0.0875797272,
0.0543334074,
-0.0027917037,
0.0008555349,
-0.0242188331,
-0.0659267455,
0.0089940615,
-0.0161466468,
-0.0295376722,
0.0014119827,
-0.0269219019,
-0.0257894527,
0.04296856,
0.0785028934,
0.0094179166,
0.0018577477,
-0.0297366455,
0.0634896457,
0.0225896128,
-0.0085490076,
-0.0356754363,
-0.0249450132,
0.0009843934,
-0.0355831049,
0.0997298285,
-0.0779753998,
-0.025248291,
-0.0018370715,
0.0025008535,
-0.0344147272,
0.0022024021,
-0.0181923211,
-0.0181877594,
0.0111762853,
0.0131543232,
0.0196054485,
0.0226982702,
-0.0607599318,
-0.0141058452,
0.0045935907,
-0.019144414,
-0.0690367669,
-0.0069366344,
0.0045147152,
0.0230460223,
-0.0728905872,
-0.014982447,
3.330546511e-34,
0.0584904812,
-0.0116526764,
0.0454985648,
0.027534904,
0.0601157025,
0.0078325002,
-0.006306306,
0.0208572336,
0.0464754365,
-0.101758033,
-0.0099969544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00237v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00237v2 | The Mystery of In-Context Learning: A Comprehensive Survey on Interpretation and Analysis | 2023-11-01T02:40:42 | 2024-02-16T00:55:48 | Yuxiang Zhou, Jiazheng Li, Yanzheng Xiang, Hanqi Yan, Lin Gui, Yulan He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding in-context learning (ICL) capability that enables large
language models (LLMs) to excel in proficiency through demonstration examples
is of utmost importance. This importance stems not only from the better
utilization of this capability across various tasks, but also from the
proactive identification and mitigation of potential risks, including concerns
regarding truthfulness, bias, and toxicity, that may arise alongside the
capability. In this paper, we present a thorough survey on the interpretation
and analysis of in-context learning. First, we provide a concise introduction
to the background and definition of in-context learning. Then, we give an
overview of advancements from two perspectives: 1) a theoretical perspective,
emphasizing studies on mechanistic interpretability and delving into the
mathematical foundations behind ICL; and 2) an empirical perspective,
concerning studies that empirically analyze factors associated with ICL. We
conclude by highlighting the challenges encountered and suggesting potential
avenues for future research. We believe that our work establishes the basis for
further exploration into the interpretation of in-context learning.
Additionally, we have created a repository containing the resources referenced
in our survey. | [
-0.0025950687,
0.0053322436,
-0.0542370602,
0.0495491736,
-0.0463193655,
0.0330619812,
0.0197004993,
-0.0167870633,
-0.0240684152,
-0.0634095073,
-0.0519640259,
-0.0343142599,
0.0228610486,
-0.0056257853,
0.0428100638,
-0.0545654967,
0.0434234738,
-0.0671831295,
-0.0157608408,
0.0062801773,
-0.0179010704,
-0.029289972,
-0.0231583416,
0.0659718215,
-0.019464843,
-0.0425667837,
-0.0143453991,
-0.0108410101,
-0.02547203,
-0.0003033724,
-0.0365099609,
0.0195490047,
0.0563583821,
0.042389147,
0.0000021858,
-0.0590637773,
-0.0135510443,
-0.0076068914,
-0.05943802,
0.0040461007,
0.034572769,
-0.0089757843,
-0.032802444,
0.007521274,
-0.0508144684,
0.009002395,
0.0297021903,
-0.0294019431,
-0.0184852984,
0.0316421203,
0.002837786,
0.0154024037,
-0.0053863688,
0.0050422349,
0.0217636898,
-0.0256924089,
0.0236986317,
0.0018629608,
0.0136787584,
-0.0273723286,
-0.0513721481,
0.0380927771,
0.0474113226,
0.0108455662,
-0.0162193086,
0.0289960019,
-0.0127323093,
-0.0053940681,
-0.0056151859,
0.0288797338,
-0.0059299511,
-0.0357112661,
-0.0173119344,
-0.0176952705,
0.0044439277,
0.0278714653,
-0.0597410612,
0.0187663045,
0.006099124,
0.0385869294,
0.0067205848,
0.0157325175,
0.0433618017,
0.0069996989,
-0.0153619954,
0.0661700442,
-0.031483449,
-0.0327864476,
-0.0277976058,
0.0135020195,
-0.0182358697,
-0.0379470699,
-0.0120434454,
0.017549498,
-0.0138635933,
0.073364757,
-0.0325387977,
-0.0231073778,
0.0236603711,
-0.0516628623,
0.0394533202,
0.0274008568,
-0.0114152003,
0.012873386,
-0.0135314735,
0.0452108569,
0.0069405367,
0.0276530832,
-0.0383412503,
0.0288829338,
-0.0373331495,
-0.0269667059,
-0.0121932421,
-0.0003806798,
-0.029551832,
-0.0088776071,
0.0015466707,
0.0553519502,
-0.0328747667,
0.0215014257,
-0.0490039513,
-0.0389430523,
-0.0570241846,
0.0017581831,
-0.0173284225,
0.0133005492,
0.0198937543,
0.040769767,
-0.0429309309,
-0.0747742206,
0.0044884719,
-0.0055913688,
-0.0210939515,
-0.0005100942,
-0.0320217945,
0.0854456499,
-0.0002796308,
-0.0542026572,
-0.0154477647,
-0.032821849,
-0.0154705504,
-0.0649872869,
0.003733438,
-0.0618549362,
-0.0240572542,
0.0521826148,
0.007273173,
-0.0489446558,
-0.0072495486,
0.0077832872,
0.0167555045,
0.0633222759,
0.0087340968,
0.0320971943,
0.0070536491,
0.0179997552,
-0.0228766985,
0.1104870811,
0.0254436992,
-0.0164598562,
0.0077483761,
-0.0008280054,
0.0033385893,
0.0503173433,
0.0242707673,
0.0109935002,
-0.0524028093,
-0.0012777278,
0.0376951359,
0.0280979797,
0.0189347975,
0.0204597302,
-0.0336292498,
0.0302142184,
0.0781408399,
0.05300216,
0.0307026394,
-0.0108411154,
0.0325306654,
0.0058879345,
0.0153500549,
0.033416193,
-0.0713656843,
-0.0193638541,
-0.0038445117,
0.0229900517,
-0.0139455684,
0.0119507052,
0.0049486137,
-0.0420370251,
-0.019255342,
-0.0051464783,
0.0060358131,
0.0260702129,
0.0684849694,
0.0178263988,
-0.0270153228,
0.029501291,
0.0186936129,
-0.0240043662,
0.0379439183,
-0.070710443,
-0.001209359,
0.0566585697,
0.0422992967,
-0.0326682776,
-0.0078107431,
-0.0029916854,
0.0186039191,
0.0151850032,
0.0145536764,
-0.0349067785,
0.0254110917,
-0.0104940161,
-0.0255016685,
-0.0278760083,
0.0186115261,
0.0164044965,
-0.0105007319,
-0.006688464,
-0.011982902,
-0.03744689,
-0.038890101,
0.0330762304,
-0.0620354228,
-0.0333135724,
-0.0514600128,
0.0339481644,
0.0150764231,
-0.0015639932,
-0.0026445154,
-0.0051624472,
0.0326047838,
-0.0276425872,
0.0467373244,
0.0582679808,
-0.1039980799,
-0.0222431868,
0.0106698778,
-0.0324318223,
-0.00069596,
-0.0105229784,
0.0051559862,
-0.0300400108,
0.0098663643,
-0.0393519774,
0.1086898372,
-0.0156516302,
0.0242008176,
-0.0477589443,
-0.005379736,
-0.0289130434,
0.0732705742,
-0.0109724598,
-0.0056197168,
0.0553769134,
0.056984514,
-0.0009324267,
-0.0305857323,
-0.0121926563,
0.0015045374,
0.0171614233,
0.0081750304,
-0.0149183506,
-0.0196166206,
-0.0421860553,
0.0252030585,
-0.0822263211,
-0.0309543535,
-0.0407321118,
0.0081252707,
0.03631185,
-0.0314913541,
-0.0220589787,
-0.0193639118,
0.0279526226,
-0.0098692458,
-0.0000610497,
0.0257083904,
0.0077626714,
0.0430737622,
-0.0256064273,
-0.0047057061,
0.0048418995,
-0.0382552184,
0.0638691783,
0.0151499622,
0.0009191475,
-0.0697826222,
0.0345209986,
0.0476809368,
0.0365183987,
-0.0136765409,
0.0193790067,
0.0517102294,
0.0071596755,
0.0281211399,
0.0713001713,
-0.024502134,
0.0894607827,
0.0535996407,
-0.006014924,
-0.0686903745,
-0.0159075465,
-0.0067492095,
0.0004405237,
-0.0689938962,
-0.0292963814,
-0.0295869634,
0.0526896529,
0.0219294708,
-0.0017655839,
-0.047891479,
0.0302764364,
-0.0563848577,
-0.0659539029,
-0.0504640788,
-0.0491004847,
-0.0435955338,
0.0318489484,
-0.0219064169,
-0.0878701732,
0.0529071242,
-0.0192979947,
0.0029331024,
-0.0484757237,
-0.0020706949,
-0.0230900403,
0.070986405,
-0.0049202866,
-0.0006573932,
0.0106974766,
-0.0372431986,
-0.0467602164,
0.0089186858,
0.0185905397,
-0.0166742224,
0.0633938983,
-0.0865047649,
-0.0124870138,
0.0083312057,
-0.0157505125,
-0.0576707199,
0.0151104759,
-0.0205649193,
0.0080646146,
-0.0214206185,
0.0180364177,
0.0014739456,
0.029031409,
0.020842189,
0.0288778208,
0.0110901147,
-0.0229758918,
-0.0443891138,
-0.0170468539,
0.0115338694,
0.021056002,
0.0399896055,
-0.0516947433,
0.0159632415,
0.0400950797,
0.0712485909,
-0.0106129721,
-0.0369047299,
0.0287260935,
0.0289849918,
-0.0190454051,
-0.0319355018,
0.0546815805,
0.0437684879,
-0.0933614448,
-0.0343388803,
0.0751398504,
-0.0004596678,
-0.0659891665,
0.04469366,
-0.0155461011,
-0.0228230618,
0.0243565645,
-0.0004740233,
-0.0502248295,
-0.0193035379,
0.0136762382,
0.0192046277,
-0.0309975166,
-0.0084245764,
-0.0140805859,
-0.1007860005,
0.0187693369,
0.0131913899,
-0.0745839253,
-0.0281678401,
-0.0327712856,
0.0218412764,
-0.0021133535,
0.065713875,
0.0135064805,
-0.0364110693,
0.0013106334,
0.0317947865,
0.0026796849,
-0.108425118,
0.0233159475,
-0.0254094061,
0.0403137803,
0.0572192818,
-0.0061458233,
-0.013471202,
-0.0255218986,
0.0138291949,
-0.0320654847,
0.0432882458,
-0.0176160149,
-0.0011195965,
0.0022777538,
-0.0005219306,
0.003742652,
0.0326862596,
-0.0030375049,
-0.0456558503,
-0.0115400581,
0.1063040048,
-0.0143070817,
0.0075504291,
-0.0176387895,
-0.0382093526,
0.0547518618,
0.0601705499,
0.0456818528,
-0.0504387915,
-0.0108967414,
-0.0115713924,
0.0110587711,
0.0192954168,
-0.0166436601,
0.0154968072,
0.0159558654,
-0.0178763214,
-0.0136026591,
-0.0139174154,
0.0232589543,
0.0604911037,
0.0172332712,
0.0392489694,
-0.0098927477,
0.0110767223,
0.0013650114,
0.0359976366,
-0.0107523864,
0.042772226,
-0.035680946,
-0.0385155156,
0.022829717,
-0.056782119,
-0.0103135267,
0.0044142161,
-0.050271716,
-0.0640345886,
0.0336980559,
0.0345880352,
0.0299710259,
0.0899330601,
0.0228852555,
-0.0517596789,
0.0588190071,
0.0186088029,
-0.0151502928,
0.0461174585,
0.0515815392,
0.0000193374,
0.0158215351,
0.0306770802,
-0.0380633809,
-0.0355367176,
-0.0014061091,
0.0180989206,
-0.0546034388,
-0.002537691,
0.0487121828,
-0.0362638682,
0.0302390866,
-0.0118439076,
-0.0208414532,
-0.024878148,
0.025637066,
0.008733999,
0.0096092951,
-0.030371774,
-0.0279267263,
-0.0052718706,
0.0318306163,
0.0118649295,
-0.0244900994,
-0.0138065517,
0.0293302368,
-0.0154808378,
0.0456519946,
0.0284128003,
0.0251715276,
0.0361523814,
0.0360433646,
-0.0014977441,
0.0223388113,
-0.0373971239,
0.0366417132,
0.0037842961,
0.0633472651,
0.0275108255,
-0.015311487,
-0.0006891881,
0.0153570818,
-0.0625806898,
-0.0070452257,
-0.0101012923,
0.0417370088,
0.0468032509,
-0.0280419532,
0.0368586965,
-0.0609049909,
0.0241842084,
-0.0041629551,
0.0141604254,
-0.0202785283,
-0.0457918718,
0.0100283055,
0.0234878939,
0.013263532,
0.035681095,
0.064181067,
-0.0035692772,
0.0625531599,
-0.0310028363,
0.0280925799,
-0.0110579254,
-0.0239110049,
0.0695389062,
0.0431042723,
-0.0301329959,
0.0015876917,
-0.0775950104,
-0.0646652207,
0.002799842,
0.0375844687,
-0.0046687345,
-0.073542051,
0.02741386,
0.0811218098,
-0.0063136164,
-0.0227665547,
-0.0256080329,
0.0030092541,
-0.000323674,
0.0175331999,
-0.0231790338,
-5.942061863e-33,
-0.0355815776,
-0.0647041872,
0.018861603,
0.0115307327,
0.0047053876,
0.0038794137,
-0.0315694921,
0.0090847705,
0.0008357693,
-0.0106297014,
0.0033063903,
-0.0151249291,
0.01427643,
0.0028042935,
0.0003283221,
-0.0002113194,
0.0308335293,
0.0034480146,
0.0005425253,
0.0256967042,
0.0389315374,
0.0036287645,
0.0596108139,
-0.0776528567,
0.0453045741,
-0.0293899029,
0.012356854,
-0.0084472448,
-0.0497556701,
0.058256574,
-0.0248515829,
0.0631100535,
0.0344273597,
-0.0548858307,
-0.0440595932,
0.0047933185,
-0.0371264257,
-0.0168537833,
0.0330337435,
0.0632074103,
-0.0175272468,
-0.0109150326,
0.100131005,
-0.0107184062,
-0.0718933418,
0.0167087466,
0.0286469441,
-0.0350896642,
-0.0394826084,
-0.011666852,
-0.0826766044,
0.0078668511,
0.0008334621,
-0.0158076379,
0.0395483002,
0.0199793689,
-0.0070462138,
-0.0215077121,
-0.0512671955,
0.0268574506,
0.0196816437,
0.008712342,
0.1179345027,
0.0411523655,
0.0277329423,
0.061909344,
0.0290077236,
-0.0007041331,
0.0427944586,
-0.0715940222,
0.0917241201,
0.0108932294,
0.005386313,
0.0508293062,
0.017526703,
0.0032912446,
-0.0319414437,
-0.0125122294,
0.0136857238,
0.0174636897,
0.0441688262,
0.0026571034,
-0.0644184053,
-0.0425112247,
-0.0425153226,
-0.0179262161,
0.0084086042,
-0.0256670453,
0.0481225029,
-0.0095489947,
-0.0258612838,
0.0118947839,
0.0325432792,
-0.0623579547,
-0.0321116596,
0.0117671657,
0.0001686722,
0.0368043594,
0.0060991142,
0.0189097952,
-0.081696026,
-0.058014039,
-0.0376751609,
0.0213588085,
0.0270536318,
-0.0044415323,
0.0208625756,
0.0622854978,
-0.0067749927,
0.0103103314,
-0.0454535261,
-0.0011331424,
0.0509504639,
-0.0246936437,
0.0790356696,
-0.0114695132,
-0.0209566765,
0.0257026572,
0.0193891898,
-0.0447749384,
-0.0211319569,
0.0170088615,
-0.0596373416,
0.0134265805,
-0.0427826717,
-0.038586881,
-0.0309363455,
0.0333525836,
0.0600563511,
-0.0512301438,
-0.0112778787,
0.0036192886,
2.781e-7,
0.0431075171,
0.0341484547,
0.0070416313,
-0.0202795547,
0.0363828689,
0.0290947985,
-0.0498889647,
-0.0033964636,
0.0205619726,
0.0217086095,
0.0000395648,
0.0274045579,
0.0204788875,
0.0214539319,
-0.0301498175,
0.0094311358,
-0.0346863717,
0.0547619984,
-0.0435410812,
0.068336077,
0.0168754701,
0.0449221767,
-0.0213798713,
-0.0074601104,
-0.0016078497,
-0.0444557741,
0.0481980108,
-0.0586668216,
0.0559298545,
-0.0011992336,
-0.0309788883,
0.0295863096,
0.0074208975,
0.0456289761,
0.0133673316,
0.0329134129,
-0.0389844477,
0.0305188019,
0.0133859776,
-0.0126621164,
-0.004599859,
-0.0219195466,
-0.0116729792,
-0.0891508609,
0.0642615259,
-0.0972732678,
-0.0049449531,
-0.039739497,
0.0466367006,
-0.0297216605,
-0.0280845053,
0.0360727906,
-0.009119899,
-0.0025883459,
0.0114625264,
-0.0272008572,
-0.0342996493,
-0.0475566089,
-0.0222032703,
0.0040146662,
-0.0434760861,
-0.0521105491,
-0.0473860987,
-0.0051177954,
0.005546418,
-0.0292848479,
-0.0088449707,
2.695125464e-34,
-0.0056638927,
-0.0058264164,
0.0371785909,
0.0488297828,
-0.0241448972,
-0.0154101271,
-0.0124763446,
0.0296030175,
0.0622218959,
-0.0493007712,
-0.0105276247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00233v2 | Instructive Decoding: Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models are Self-Refiner from Noisy Instructions | 2023-11-01T02:31:35 | 2024-02-17T09:00:29 | Taehyeon Kim, Joonkee Kim, Gihun Lee, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL | While instruction-tuned language models have demonstrated impressive
zero-shot generalization, these models often struggle to generate accurate
responses when faced with instructions that fall outside their training set.
This paper presents Instructive Decoding (ID), a simple yet effective approach
that augments the efficacy of instruction-tuned models. Specifically, ID
adjusts the logits for next-token prediction in a contrastive manner, utilizing
predictions generated from a manipulated version of the original instruction,
referred to as a noisy instruction. This noisy instruction aims to elicit
responses that could diverge from the intended instruction yet remain
plausible. We conduct experiments across a spectrum of such noisy instructions,
ranging from those that insert semantic noise via random words to others like
'opposite' that elicit the deviated responses. Our approach achieves
considerable performance gains across various instruction-tuned models and
tasks without necessitating any additional parameter updates. Notably,
utilizing 'opposite' as the noisy instruction in ID, which exhibits the maximum
divergence from the original instruction, consistently produces the most
significant performance gains across multiple models and tasks. | [
0.0332256258,
0.0525686666,
0.0084315008,
0.0260908995,
-0.0201054197,
0.0287323594,
-0.0077207717,
0.0025960966,
-0.0182247087,
-0.0437538065,
-0.061982356,
-0.0089022834,
-0.0238575488,
0.0067274943,
0.0237672348,
-0.0154809421,
0.046103403,
-0.0667547658,
0.0085757282,
-0.0018897065,
-0.0179384686,
0.0174504127,
-0.0095467875,
0.053981822,
0.0199820548,
-0.0302989054,
-0.0054009496,
0.0512737557,
-0.0341022015,
-0.0452239662,
0.0233367048,
0.0383458957,
0.0204607379,
0.0355168954,
0.0000019248,
-0.0240782239,
0.0116686802,
-0.0110153323,
-0.0471430533,
0.0188096985,
0.042444136,
-0.0404871255,
-0.0088889506,
0.0095428405,
-0.0183407106,
-0.0630868673,
0.0655551925,
0.0459601544,
0.0470770001,
0.0934493095,
0.0183324609,
-0.0502980947,
0.0165648982,
-0.0070032375,
0.0219379533,
-0.0392163023,
-0.0007667877,
-0.0275729652,
-0.0381508134,
0.0437341891,
-0.0479113311,
0.0196262728,
0.0316599496,
0.0125724794,
0.0190857109,
0.0372379497,
0.0104822684,
-0.0133965956,
-0.0479646362,
0.0500613935,
-0.0210246108,
-0.0305870585,
-0.0208821669,
-0.0146232257,
0.0048234859,
-0.0388175063,
-0.0189462062,
0.0075888201,
0.023242183,
0.0299762972,
0.0594977252,
0.0352269411,
0.0174899157,
0.0130688101,
-0.0158788692,
0.0381100811,
0.0219691992,
-0.0564337373,
-0.0040544053,
0.0046769036,
-0.0021103125,
-0.0307617411,
-0.0147671588,
0.0304416548,
-0.0532054678,
0.0181466527,
-0.0543918014,
-0.0143441726,
-0.0081228688,
-0.0122276703,
0.0840020329,
0.0682028905,
-0.015121541,
0.0419541784,
-0.0277588498,
0.0513819866,
-0.0100304559,
0.0450983271,
-0.0529462844,
0.0110389953,
-0.0413365699,
-0.0068379198,
-0.0477144495,
0.0324329324,
-0.0441028066,
-0.0286475681,
-0.0267546903,
0.0297437888,
0.0247073509,
-0.0042878818,
0.0153434696,
0.006545634,
-0.0707077384,
-0.0481424741,
0.006727457,
0.0185559504,
-0.0261046421,
0.0000582116,
0.007735414,
-0.0586183257,
-0.0353852436,
0.0137205701,
-0.0149164218,
-0.0316302329,
0.0116662299,
0.1019810811,
-0.0287362672,
-0.0480796807,
-0.0276199114,
-0.0003387746,
-0.007860627,
-0.0462779924,
0.0100075072,
-0.0279571805,
0.0048364531,
0.0127352178,
0.0000669381,
-0.0391617119,
0.015716644,
-0.0010082317,
-0.0329964757,
0.075742349,
0.0028819032,
0.0085660582,
0.0069822087,
0.0016054169,
0.0137176476,
0.0715789348,
0.0007355046,
0.0177973211,
0.0040947953,
-0.0058398233,
0.019548066,
0.0299589429,
0.0242314134,
-0.0035975294,
-0.0247473866,
0.0167197213,
0.0171780251,
0.0184788015,
0.0484292209,
0.0507854708,
-0.0458426625,
-0.0239260588,
0.0615091287,
0.0182367917,
0.0080081224,
0.0126271052,
0.0571135655,
0.0274302308,
-0.0298197474,
0.0245289505,
-0.0792296007,
0.0192874018,
-0.0324943364,
0.0090282764,
0.0511307158,
-0.0148187075,
-0.0528905876,
-0.0581043065,
0.0095932325,
-0.015456764,
0.016855618,
0.0070015015,
0.0547668636,
0.0482595265,
-0.0886791125,
-0.005381078,
0.0372148901,
0.0068830149,
0.004204201,
-0.0591876023,
0.0274317972,
0.0992697701,
0.0541865043,
-0.0064038099,
-0.0137579599,
0.0094431015,
0.0200179853,
0.049014613,
0.0205703098,
-0.002784759,
0.0439217351,
-0.0693388805,
-0.0168856792,
-0.0021998722,
0.0136719197,
0.0390417762,
0.0266350601,
-0.0243834406,
0.0089610424,
-0.0202509426,
-0.0272319093,
0.0543518364,
-0.007177725,
-0.0885219574,
0.0249190852,
-0.0138986064,
0.0310055185,
-0.0098509779,
-0.0042968402,
0.0211620871,
0.0269415956,
-0.0427110158,
0.0122706955,
-0.0235429108,
-0.0707401484,
-0.0484919772,
0.001153892,
-0.0184989814,
-0.0022872649,
0.0184955746,
-0.0261737444,
-0.0262726732,
0.0557742193,
-0.0459011979,
0.0595688894,
-0.0215659514,
0.023780752,
0.0301102493,
0.0036419267,
-0.0335477218,
0.0221784096,
-0.0339701101,
0.0086137028,
0.0135491677,
0.0084705502,
-0.0480003767,
-0.0358296558,
-0.0099348426,
-0.0070589646,
-0.0233264826,
-0.0062343371,
-0.008339419,
0.0177998524,
-0.0227285419,
-0.0284469575,
-0.0657606795,
-0.012465423,
-0.0371451527,
0.0101017328,
0.0347454287,
0.0045461035,
-0.0058675339,
-0.0406253338,
0.0041927639,
-0.0077602053,
-0.0184942111,
0.0306373741,
0.0050630625,
0.0129627334,
-0.0181231406,
-0.0325110331,
-0.0237797759,
0.005755594,
0.0294248294,
-0.0224886201,
0.028652681,
-0.1098239794,
0.0287216734,
0.0208997652,
0.0295038074,
-0.0072247842,
-0.0694900975,
0.02385794,
-0.0144529976,
0.0508698262,
0.0737164542,
-0.0028576956,
0.0155382855,
0.0419455506,
-0.0205908716,
-0.0618108287,
0.0040024868,
-0.0342624523,
-0.0427546948,
-0.0436282493,
-0.0376970619,
-0.0055435309,
0.0918620303,
0.0337522104,
0.0324400924,
-0.0992922038,
0.0079519153,
-0.0174100325,
-0.0765192509,
-0.0003899398,
-0.0093116863,
-0.0104756774,
0.0150980223,
-0.0206914116,
-0.0400828756,
0.0982375517,
-0.0132131716,
-0.0236395858,
-0.0277478155,
0.0104910256,
0.0119740209,
0.0413349271,
-0.0067786109,
0.004750785,
0.0127731916,
-0.0454091057,
-0.0320281833,
-0.0177890826,
0.0002938517,
-0.0164361503,
0.0082837902,
-0.0457361825,
-0.0045396308,
0.0214121975,
-0.0356453061,
-0.0590351224,
-0.0566610843,
0.0136163868,
-0.0139819151,
0.0312077142,
-0.0049535171,
-0.0297831558,
-0.0026539231,
-0.002493975,
0.0607763082,
-0.0131103573,
-0.0085079353,
-0.0397116467,
-0.0224119369,
0.0598154925,
-0.0193754043,
0.0092998436,
-0.046106603,
0.0403026007,
0.0360312313,
0.0155683048,
-0.0248209052,
-0.0397105999,
0.0069041955,
0.0310133751,
-0.0026327674,
-0.0050968551,
0.0585813746,
0.0846573934,
-0.0562250353,
-0.0551815964,
0.124636434,
0.0142382011,
-0.0411850177,
0.0120087862,
-0.0074867602,
0.0415649861,
0.0231897663,
0.0247019157,
-0.0432313159,
-0.0460229963,
0.0166094974,
0.0358758196,
-0.0097301463,
-0.0076418654,
-0.0049017156,
-0.1350318342,
0.0479132943,
0.030872358,
-0.0176180843,
-0.0735169873,
-0.0308602527,
-0.016022658,
-0.0097549353,
0.0303027239,
0.0326716751,
-0.0118635958,
0.0064846226,
0.0222035814,
-0.0043872739,
-0.035304334,
0.0073514739,
0.001644599,
0.086261943,
0.0820364356,
-0.0145443166,
0.0311469324,
0.0128717031,
0.0299417581,
-0.0380636305,
0.0206810758,
-0.0371197425,
0.0538365915,
-0.0229969304,
0.0002633464,
-0.0037450518,
0.0347556323,
-0.0322351083,
0.0007705031,
-0.0013948972,
0.033979632,
-0.030071456,
-0.0122851897,
-0.0065992866,
0.0031406323,
0.0321495757,
0.082968697,
0.0318627954,
-0.0620462075,
-0.0461670533,
-0.0467363,
0.0288735982,
-0.0699462518,
-0.0047002998,
0.0008277639,
0.0028388198,
-0.0349310376,
-0.0611071177,
-0.0710556805,
0.0121513233,
0.0184272472,
0.0048467563,
-0.0208853669,
-0.0014548497,
-0.0096508348,
-0.0272300914,
-0.0165878497,
-0.0411877446,
-0.0043369322,
-0.0809379965,
-0.0259348508,
0.0199641827,
-0.0327236243,
-0.0060157357,
0.0282946434,
-0.0624094084,
-0.0765596181,
0.0305065084,
0.0699051693,
0.0176946279,
0.0744986385,
-0.0290614367,
-0.056692142,
0.0382274427,
0.0310894772,
-0.0481275357,
0.0183344055,
0.0685972273,
0.0200626701,
0.0059350329,
0.0614063703,
-0.0277308524,
0.0444722474,
0.0543117635,
0.0433041379,
-0.0506977588,
0.0039267363,
0.0386033021,
-0.0186502319,
0.0541433021,
-0.0186777078,
-0.007011211,
-0.0155578712,
0.0343431458,
-0.0276855472,
0.001401909,
-0.0397755615,
0.0016286204,
0.0698398203,
-0.0140150776,
-0.0067645148,
-0.0224708691,
-0.0351697877,
0.0071251988,
-0.0675071701,
0.0055055725,
0.009376727,
0.0412362553,
0.0230913609,
0.0050342204,
-0.0345510431,
0.0448459461,
0.0160824992,
0.0402589329,
-0.0010497225,
0.0406644568,
0.0236802958,
0.0098737264,
-0.0387289859,
0.0105924858,
-0.0638688877,
0.0098594865,
-0.0407010131,
0.0092832912,
0.0086355815,
0.0104756244,
0.0354736783,
-0.0102213174,
0.006908589,
-0.0120306872,
0.0183571391,
0.0056949607,
-0.0220431089,
0.0178548694,
0.0300564542,
-0.0050440482,
-0.0040567773,
0.0811945722,
0.014888498,
0.0609411448,
0.0257706083,
0.0391601436,
-0.0592793226,
-0.0274790693,
0.0031024874,
0.0369819552,
-0.0193537176,
0.062372271,
0.009866694,
-0.052576039,
-0.0295509156,
0.018279992,
0.0014743647,
-0.0244762618,
0.0383003503,
0.0310815331,
-0.0301575623,
-0.0487296395,
-0.0249578673,
0.0104897236,
0.0216003191,
-0.036268454,
-0.0627897829,
-6.552086493e-33,
-0.0378921703,
0.0014114276,
0.0133081973,
-0.0397278555,
0.0201293901,
-0.0177194364,
-0.0403584801,
-0.0013170327,
-0.028423639,
0.0177818537,
-0.015252687,
0.0130625609,
0.0290626027,
0.041982796,
0.0133102015,
-0.0273620971,
0.07150352,
-0.032116998,
-0.0255543832,
0.0235103779,
0.013472042,
0.0422488116,
0.0531500056,
-0.0469470248,
0.012860354,
-0.0162133016,
-0.0289982427,
0.0180623457,
0.007956286,
0.0518714599,
-0.0349382237,
0.0364890732,
0.0102217784,
-0.0216652732,
-0.0358548537,
-0.0036363234,
-0.0686775148,
-0.0194608532,
0.0368209034,
0.0186426044,
-0.0459909327,
-0.0414925404,
0.0304048769,
-0.0169522744,
-0.0617190078,
-0.0181596484,
-0.0010517685,
-0.0157415885,
-0.0051790318,
0.0316952355,
-0.0801270232,
0.0060104723,
-0.0109851025,
-0.0687820911,
0.0400569253,
0.0376388095,
-0.0040185987,
-0.0014895517,
-0.0650691316,
0.0452331267,
0.0030453424,
0.061388921,
0.02865793,
0.0496698581,
-0.0052799485,
0.0279098265,
0.064364329,
-0.0241361149,
-0.0019536195,
-0.0217309259,
0.0179179069,
0.0137728835,
0.005089737,
0.0095569808,
0.0696062148,
0.0112685794,
-0.0319714062,
-0.0266286694,
0.0185379423,
0.0221629441,
0.0668100789,
0.0383552499,
-0.078551583,
-0.0168234631,
-0.0143418293,
-0.0486581214,
-0.0402379707,
-0.0261404756,
0.0573966093,
0.0505049378,
-0.0255620778,
-0.0212499369,
0.0541642159,
-0.0329389162,
0.0201721657,
0.0178132467,
0.0035492608,
0.0076936446,
-0.0100438464,
0.0309547652,
-0.0638884008,
-0.0367255062,
0.0670317113,
-0.0092682941,
-0.0010175043,
-0.0045009749,
0.0102643464,
0.0164427422,
-0.0864768326,
-0.0245389938,
-0.0300135259,
0.0277101733,
-0.000155893,
-0.0138069913,
0.0527130514,
0.0166550335,
-0.0189968459,
0.0518642552,
0.0102392575,
-0.0054024584,
-0.0277123339,
-0.0211770665,
0.0067305788,
0.01388177,
-0.0400055423,
0.0158164054,
-0.0208372474,
-0.0265880115,
-0.0075625558,
-0.0312683731,
-0.0275607575,
0.0631381497,
2.625e-7,
0.0101387007,
0.0616132319,
0.0383802541,
0.0285490807,
0.0181883704,
0.0250819903,
0.0044589886,
0.0226833206,
0.0308348183,
-0.0211891327,
0.0084376018,
0.0469907112,
0.0470895395,
-0.0086387601,
-0.0792737529,
0.025446184,
-0.0600776672,
0.0338523611,
-0.0399551988,
-0.0193222333,
0.0448588841,
0.1209217161,
0.0014973185,
0.0117072593,
0.0196091849,
-0.0094673969,
0.0348829329,
-0.0269898977,
-0.0258695912,
0.0043941061,
-0.0320071392,
0.0359840691,
-0.0047516124,
0.0247579217,
0.0038650094,
0.0012173707,
-0.0198574252,
0.0581616648,
-0.0289616659,
-0.0595528819,
-0.0104357982,
0.0262547936,
-0.0057951817,
-0.0141198412,
0.0628398955,
-0.0544005632,
-0.028169414,
-0.0126677584,
-0.0218833797,
0.0116053009,
0.0024786966,
-0.0296534076,
-0.0391052701,
0.0010274411,
0.0469543003,
0.0194155704,
-0.0105449557,
-0.0583021566,
-0.0130192135,
-0.0009870259,
-0.0338748805,
-0.0319194384,
-0.0482398495,
0.0288436357,
0.0331665762,
-0.0662712082,
-0.0019882305,
2.457571831e-34,
0.0438488126,
-0.0099760294,
0.0425744876,
0.0345849209,
0.0266028214,
0.0157713648,
-0.0414905213,
0.024225127,
0.0531042181,
-0.0993739963,
-0.0355114155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00223v1 | Is GPT Powerful Enough to Analyze the Emotions of Memes? | 2023-11-01T01:57:48 | 2023-11-01T01:57:48 | Jingjing Wang, Joshua Luo, Grace Yang, Allen Hong, Feng Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Large Language Models (LLMs), representing a significant achievement in
artificial intelligence (AI) research, have demonstrated their ability in a
multitude of tasks. This project aims to explore the capabilities of GPT-3.5, a
leading example of LLMs, in processing the sentiment analysis of Internet
memes. Memes, which include both verbal and visual aspects, act as a powerful
yet complex tool for expressing ideas and sentiments, demanding an
understanding of societal norms and cultural contexts. Notably, the detection
and moderation of hateful memes pose a significant challenge due to their
implicit offensive nature. This project investigates GPT's proficiency in such
subjective tasks, revealing its strengths and potential limitations. The tasks
include the classification of meme sentiment, determination of humor type, and
detection of implicit hate in memes. The performance evaluation, using datasets
from SemEval-2020 Task 8 and Facebook hateful memes, offers a comparative
understanding of GPT responses against human annotations. Despite GPT's
remarkable progress, our findings underscore the challenges faced by these
models in handling subjective tasks, which are rooted in their inherent
limitations including contextual understanding, interpretation of implicit
meanings, and data biases. This research contributes to the broader discourse
on the applicability of AI in handling complex, context-dependent tasks, and
offers valuable insights for future advancements. | [
0.0527446717,
0.0679083541,
-0.0315292254,
0.0274077598,
-0.0274396017,
0.0563598983,
-0.0059679258,
0.0088125523,
0.0676645413,
-0.0790335312,
-0.0327470936,
-0.0289125573,
-0.0365589,
0.0265273303,
0.0013619098,
-0.0630573258,
0.0117801186,
0.0589355156,
0.0557312183,
-0.0304139275,
0.0401506312,
0.0393681303,
-0.0010979715,
0.0345189311,
-0.058468923,
-0.0118522868,
0.0488135517,
0.0201509502,
0.016912248,
-0.0130069507,
0.0243556313,
0.0322530419,
0.0252489746,
0.0498032793,
0.0000018989,
-0.0170733128,
0.0188284963,
-0.0290747564,
0.0205270573,
-0.0032760813,
0.0754178539,
-0.0389674008,
-0.0210847743,
0.0127934599,
-0.0344147123,
0.0062091216,
0.0745755732,
0.0565833338,
0.0751088858,
0.0781134591,
-0.0311374795,
-0.0314293317,
-0.0042657768,
-0.0067870598,
0.0072747362,
-0.00874265,
0.0167533681,
-0.026844658,
-0.0567508973,
0.0089239776,
-0.028518863,
0.0135252979,
0.017524533,
0.0333326086,
-0.0234970041,
0.0079405131,
-0.0394304842,
-0.0344106704,
-0.0043633915,
0.0430490002,
0.0032241559,
-0.0086130314,
0.0130812917,
0.0018871893,
-0.0232226048,
-0.0457853116,
-0.0491048768,
0.0136470366,
-0.0086075906,
0.044813823,
0.0128883608,
0.005081106,
0.048282776,
0.0578497611,
0.0085742017,
0.0481993295,
-0.0199834332,
-0.0183591582,
0.0150657464,
0.0549433045,
-0.0759072453,
0.0206574369,
0.0197621547,
-0.002271998,
0.0053161168,
0.0369577408,
-0.0473901145,
-0.0356813706,
0.0098627834,
-0.0808483064,
0.0078461934,
0.0341112837,
-0.02578458,
0.0400707275,
0.0241991803,
0.0288724881,
-0.024707973,
-0.0075654616,
0.0057565183,
-0.03240408,
-0.0234290585,
0.0107773365,
0.0162529554,
0.021156555,
0.0243815873,
-0.0185958389,
-0.0579552315,
0.0061958302,
-0.053098917,
-0.0302502718,
-0.0144998003,
-0.0065759509,
0.0007805261,
0.0017044918,
-0.0444536284,
0.0127347885,
-0.0377403386,
0.030388901,
-0.0388351046,
-0.0721239299,
0.0310007632,
0.0137622301,
0.0058980002,
-0.0322134197,
0.0363158286,
0.0750614405,
0.0280820392,
-0.0178910121,
-0.0397232771,
-0.0223055817,
-0.0360027589,
-0.0491742529,
0.0309890602,
-0.0613260046,
0.0429225415,
0.0261891857,
0.0013045972,
-0.0284636375,
0.0092510208,
0.028202679,
-0.0496333651,
0.0787833109,
0.0205115248,
0.0013365725,
0.0351276509,
0.0439838096,
-0.0263743978,
0.0342730731,
-0.0209381655,
0.0627134368,
0.0486779809,
0.0076788203,
-0.0094924308,
0.0320358649,
0.0128406649,
-0.0038002422,
-0.0412307791,
0.0165575631,
-0.0678377375,
-0.0050089653,
0.0191747434,
0.0665300265,
-0.0068010944,
-0.0315441415,
0.0580290519,
0.0653737336,
-0.0513708219,
0.0638018772,
0.0353302658,
0.0133755207,
0.0356964692,
-0.0148107484,
-0.0524904914,
0.0035062733,
-0.0258523431,
-0.0496607833,
0.0265282243,
0.0446154624,
-0.0319745466,
-0.0329613462,
-0.0176384356,
-0.0400074609,
0.0594955571,
-0.0264141914,
0.0478471555,
-0.0331108049,
-0.025635913,
-0.0016616199,
0.0138417445,
-0.0479624607,
-0.0235157423,
-0.045533672,
0.022438392,
0.0501238704,
0.0212259609,
-0.0340800509,
-0.023892004,
-0.0025174443,
-0.0025596644,
0.0600834228,
0.0260252673,
0.0260970909,
-0.0193413068,
-0.0255628414,
0.0112306252,
0.0042625084,
0.0272409208,
0.0304242317,
0.0603160299,
0.0414266437,
0.0061746868,
0.0423822999,
0.0039972151,
0.002370066,
-0.0008709368,
-0.0037931947,
-0.0156505685,
0.0173665565,
0.072297737,
0.0290107094,
-0.0316179879,
-0.047849182,
-0.0044806437,
-0.0227603,
-0.0573984012,
-0.0006806472,
-0.0657640398,
0.0070651476,
0.0389136299,
-0.0576673001,
-0.0202030912,
0.0743666068,
-0.0207550842,
0.0206971057,
0.0714870095,
-0.0122841606,
0.0234442614,
-0.0554506555,
-0.047253333,
-0.0414820798,
0.0314915515,
0.017922366,
0.0552438721,
-0.0205519479,
-0.036443688,
0.0170896705,
-0.027805334,
0.0367134772,
0.0390040465,
-0.0517869852,
-0.0154990591,
0.0288792867,
0.0128906984,
0.0162735805,
0.0167420767,
-0.0456122272,
-0.0192461815,
-0.1330375969,
-0.025322089,
-0.0116642024,
0.0078643709,
0.0268102176,
-0.0098674726,
-0.021483222,
-0.0008531392,
-0.0628829226,
0.0215557963,
0.0282493029,
0.0306352507,
0.0228101723,
-0.0341587886,
0.0288678743,
-0.0564855561,
-0.0131067131,
-0.0303513054,
-0.0007830803,
0.0168874934,
-0.0285110269,
0.0439393632,
0.0069606728,
-0.0659529045,
0.0250798929,
-0.0113737425,
-0.061317306,
0.0343759581,
-0.0028604041,
0.0589700714,
0.0604495779,
0.0154240634,
0.115701735,
-0.0062017227,
-0.0023298373,
-0.0239224639,
0.0046027415,
-0.0179360025,
0.0061429599,
-0.0201614667,
-0.0417788625,
-0.0280148406,
0.0546953641,
0.0126750171,
0.0051890169,
-0.0766177252,
0.0859265625,
-0.0424540602,
-0.0224761814,
0.0032060796,
-0.0302166734,
0.0070046633,
-0.0120353037,
-0.0429740883,
-0.0692697838,
0.0694677606,
0.0070712403,
-0.0071573141,
0.0048421067,
-0.0133194411,
-0.0362589397,
0.0946604088,
0.0097596291,
0.0274812076,
-0.0308000799,
0.0119752353,
0.0086116008,
-0.035552714,
-0.0115744788,
-0.0438533165,
0.0207095444,
-0.0068303994,
-0.0065359902,
0.0033626363,
-0.0406118445,
-0.0109968605,
-0.0296943225,
-0.0488057956,
-0.0246146396,
0.0220227651,
-0.0232672263,
0.0275311694,
-0.000519559,
0.0074794577,
-0.0522085354,
0.0071780682,
-0.0209351107,
0.0329956859,
-0.0014723828,
0.0293800645,
-0.0243204962,
0.0283096191,
0.0106265573,
-0.006865195,
0.0437797047,
-0.0036052384,
-0.0030773338,
-0.0245806351,
0.0157367643,
0.0011297013,
0.022553714,
-0.0147363571,
-0.0608230457,
0.0454921983,
-0.0330359563,
0.0171053372,
0.1166601181,
0.0211562384,
-0.0609406121,
0.0108232824,
0.0264940038,
-0.0396421961,
0.0115605621,
-0.0059980755,
-0.0610702001,
-0.016876692,
-0.0515846536,
0.029747434,
-0.0587471798,
-0.0311449505,
0.0079134107,
-0.0891248584,
0.0037920508,
-0.0005097169,
-0.0016023739,
-0.0205745194,
-0.0051576514,
0.0176683757,
-0.0229821391,
0.0186903067,
-0.0815903693,
0.0411750115,
0.002865515,
-0.0100282766,
-0.0030692301,
-0.0346851908,
0.0399033055,
-0.0156231886,
0.0656565949,
0.0301866066,
0.0695835724,
-0.0389647,
-0.0245980471,
0.0673823878,
-0.0160437617,
-0.0296435263,
-0.0517018884,
0.027045561,
-0.0118359672,
-0.0401301645,
-0.0389643684,
0.0017577235,
-0.0342719443,
0.0106794545,
-0.0255220663,
0.0715833902,
-0.0096634459,
-0.0450538509,
-0.0599162281,
0.0118676936,
-0.0084545305,
0.0803395882,
0.0247614644,
-0.0542363487,
-0.0076447767,
-0.0379154682,
0.0025260269,
-0.0262002274,
-0.0858320817,
-0.0502715185,
0.0161981191,
0.0064450013,
-0.029071562,
-0.0511052571,
-0.0001874234,
0.0075731478,
-0.0066291364,
-0.0324479975,
-0.0053330651,
-0.0062511112,
-0.0282464027,
0.0222353935,
0.0007043696,
0.0029005979,
0.0064837015,
-0.0372890271,
0.0082532279,
-0.011398484,
-0.013810805,
0.0312530845,
-0.0554985367,
-0.0477042906,
0.0297972132,
0.0634573326,
0.0214919113,
0.0154067315,
-0.0052060331,
-0.0257764012,
0.033080481,
0.0659820959,
-0.0265482124,
0.0206692535,
0.0145682935,
0.0481490195,
0.026820777,
0.0278471354,
0.004740838,
0.0697509721,
0.0274040289,
-0.0595723651,
-0.01952908,
-0.0139277568,
-0.0072821886,
-0.0012873057,
0.038073808,
0.0177683961,
-0.0267642327,
-0.0162888281,
-0.0615352169,
-0.0171005763,
-0.0157181341,
-0.0332979113,
-0.0378400646,
0.0124216164,
0.0189320315,
-0.081474632,
-0.038158033,
-0.0198369995,
0.0309151486,
-0.0387435108,
0.0191288777,
0.0405906513,
0.0169212818,
-0.029369045,
0.0039244997,
-0.0218988601,
0.0271608662,
-0.0159180127,
-0.0328520425,
-0.0339925811,
0.0452708043,
-0.0022872887,
-0.0237344392,
0.038033478,
0.0241930597,
0.0177931078,
-0.0147196101,
0.0050037992,
-0.0003320597,
0.0304116309,
-0.0550776981,
0.0517148897,
-0.0421939492,
-0.0073083276,
-0.0191332493,
-0.0057278983,
-0.0066433093,
-0.0205717124,
-0.0065661962,
0.0168181453,
-0.0191625766,
-0.0013415542,
0.0400358066,
-0.0493075885,
0.0404746495,
0.060143061,
-0.0683010519,
-0.0046952218,
0.0046870247,
0.042772796,
0.0003690949,
0.0146457255,
0.0487238057,
-0.044430811,
-0.0668537393,
0.0069295205,
-0.0392483287,
0.0173926763,
-0.0104462653,
0.0026184344,
0.0886893198,
-0.0107464083,
0.0487553589,
-0.0185359549,
0.0133202625,
-0.0672376528,
-0.0291779023,
0.0132122245,
-6.394739962e-33,
-0.0153790591,
-0.0233237203,
-0.0319934748,
0.0205363557,
-0.0359713025,
0.0122194812,
-0.0144532397,
0.0087370081,
-0.0035474612,
0.0129520744,
0.0013356918,
0.03616919,
-0.0165520422,
-0.0029893045,
0.012956053,
-0.0155694094,
0.0161515623,
-0.0171216037,
-0.008768497,
0.0166187715,
0.010576752,
0.0001337431,
0.0257683843,
-0.1134043038,
0.0225411188,
-0.007458542,
-0.0132428752,
0.0138894282,
0.037513081,
0.0620657131,
-0.0278643239,
0.0954602957,
0.0571358129,
-0.0000771995,
0.0132541461,
0.0598442219,
-0.0406287946,
-0.0064552762,
0.0074780369,
0.0089646494,
-0.0127436863,
-0.0323372483,
0.0556222536,
-0.0112710483,
-0.0351233371,
0.0050599966,
0.0288394224,
-0.0205428861,
0.0823370591,
-0.0397939272,
-0.0380867049,
0.0208701249,
0.0086791161,
0.0106139397,
0.0147518124,
0.0115767661,
0.0173054691,
0.0684678629,
-0.0479862429,
0.0374549218,
-0.040770743,
-0.0280502215,
0.0140643418,
-0.0359674357,
0.0273889285,
0.0707060173,
0.0168265998,
0.0442228951,
-0.0529896542,
-0.010022345,
0.0240837373,
0.0016978197,
0.046631664,
0.0351975374,
0.0437070653,
-0.0377122462,
-0.0448919572,
-0.0084486278,
0.0528207198,
-0.0096088583,
0.0514414683,
-0.006321671,
-0.0390077047,
0.0073476783,
0.0155921895,
-0.0721676946,
-0.0316606127,
-0.0618575774,
0.0006814638,
-0.0272413418,
0.0009056479,
-0.0111874351,
0.0034878661,
-0.0216838121,
0.0032989532,
0.0023330126,
-0.0167341605,
0.0080238786,
0.0223225169,
0.0655704364,
-0.0456365906,
0.0001460051,
0.0052612191,
0.0088045187,
0.0295049716,
0.0085831117,
0.0291532259,
0.0629554018,
-0.0577983633,
-0.0127260936,
-0.0459332801,
0.0220500454,
-0.051849477,
0.0239192359,
0.0236981288,
0.0423730537,
0.0019656939,
-0.0209738445,
0.0353035852,
0.0111066615,
-0.006810185,
-0.0097171739,
-0.0157628469,
0.0016807388,
-0.0224841945,
-0.0473736227,
-0.0023562652,
-0.0137484875,
-0.0303234328,
-0.0866799802,
-0.009521449,
-0.0349634811,
2.582e-7,
0.0391592495,
0.07253851,
0.0067309407,
0.0377607942,
0.0476501621,
0.032807447,
-0.0025687316,
0.0183345079,
-0.0206494089,
-0.0087617943,
0.0301480126,
0.0804236233,
0.0114470273,
0.0320570469,
-0.038516026,
0.0119847087,
-0.0371228829,
0.0256988741,
-0.0540389083,
0.0441075377,
0.0536972322,
0.0826880261,
0.0584486015,
-0.026947841,
-0.0241398476,
-0.0229956768,
0.0657648519,
-0.0594779179,
0.013277458,
-0.0393826291,
0.0188945681,
0.0497216992,
-0.0061194268,
-0.0132806143,
0.0396790318,
-0.0380577855,
0.0458670147,
0.061399065,
0.0184524786,
-0.0333670266,
0.0243616253,
0.0147988293,
0.0047731334,
-0.0417705141,
0.0481753014,
-0.0242475197,
-0.0458458178,
-0.0455902293,
-0.0101354904,
-0.0386976786,
0.0723609403,
-0.0191124789,
-0.0375456549,
-0.022305809,
0.0216844939,
-0.0225934237,
-0.0039021822,
-0.0735625625,
0.0141025111,
0.0071980073,
-0.052364558,
-0.0251096636,
-0.0534269847,
0.0197503325,
0.0404337905,
0.0229284205,
0.0184044056,
2.078961171e-34,
0.032346677,
-0.0539600179,
-0.00351384,
-0.0340985283,
0.0172570944,
0.0436324514,
0.0002763761,
-0.0178821106,
0.0264007095,
-0.0363571234,
0.0128399432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00208v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00208v2 | What Formal Languages Can Transformers Express? A Survey | 2023-11-01T00:38:26 | 2024-05-06T19:48:28 | Lena Strobl, William Merrill, Gail Weiss, David Chiang, Dana Angluin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.FL, cs.LO | As transformers have gained prominence in natural language processing, some
researchers have investigated theoretically what problems they can and cannot
solve, by treating problems as formal languages. Exploring such questions can
help clarify the power of transformers relative to other models of computation,
their fundamental capabilities and limits, and the impact of architectural
choices. Work in this subarea has made considerable progress in recent years.
Here, we undertake a comprehensive survey of this work, documenting the diverse
assumptions that underlie different results and providing a unified framework
for harmonizing seemingly contradictory findings. | [
0.0567888208,
0.0666213781,
-0.0311612915,
0.0450937413,
-0.0395718254,
0.0007839678,
-0.0414528884,
0.0040304326,
-0.0340831317,
-0.0883806497,
-0.0039515281,
-0.0279467944,
0.0112411743,
0.0332338773,
-0.0077418014,
-0.0803922862,
0.0456429869,
-0.0110510094,
0.0042554089,
0.0180780739,
0.0170617551,
-0.0096133007,
-0.0050805346,
0.0254142899,
-0.0206652172,
0.0143284583,
-0.0093458202,
-0.0429682471,
-0.0085476181,
0.0060333605,
-0.0352853239,
0.0035051426,
-0.0255781356,
0.0335990116,
0.0000015902,
-0.0104262279,
0.0091803772,
0.0276104677,
-0.0177981183,
-0.0347531699,
0.0050754212,
-0.0507896952,
-0.0079407431,
0.0201274902,
-0.0284959748,
-0.0551629737,
0.1055774465,
0.0383832641,
0.0593448505,
0.0737941712,
-0.0411555246,
-0.0614263937,
0.0117145879,
0.0142563768,
-0.05821421,
0.0313040428,
0.0054483032,
-0.0567321256,
0.0145784542,
0.0063446821,
-0.034591198,
-0.0031287405,
0.01215134,
-0.0135606183,
-0.0267061461,
-0.0005722319,
-0.0360953435,
-0.0410070866,
-0.0321395732,
-0.008233808,
0.0163084995,
0.0029400596,
0.010874276,
0.0202791467,
-0.0183008369,
0.0175440535,
-0.0054034432,
0.0385351777,
-0.022353204,
0.0067818738,
-0.0036234099,
0.0139708016,
0.041524075,
-0.0367707498,
-0.0432932191,
0.1227115765,
0.0229051877,
-0.0112463245,
-0.050388962,
0.0240678452,
0.0404840074,
-0.0569586717,
0.0261784308,
0.0567839071,
-0.031715814,
0.0089117913,
0.0158439782,
-0.0196551606,
0.0149853099,
-0.0276334602,
0.0143497968,
0.0235427376,
0.002969519,
0.0038458521,
0.0429301225,
0.0321970843,
-0.0491175428,
0.0534299612,
-0.0470473468,
-0.0041529662,
-0.0293273907,
-0.0364594646,
-0.0678639486,
0.0301818196,
-0.0197790843,
-0.0108519215,
-0.0130739342,
0.050240241,
0.0318605639,
-0.0125997262,
-0.0183895621,
-0.0116540007,
-0.0527973771,
0.0496672094,
-0.0311459992,
0.0494680703,
0.0063602114,
-0.0322549157,
0.0085651893,
-0.0659682602,
0.0117205633,
0.0043364144,
0.0195417218,
-0.0416993909,
-0.0171463732,
0.1045826972,
0.025076542,
-0.0255690366,
0.0346012898,
-0.0191364102,
-0.0029541953,
-0.0473850481,
0.0189745594,
-0.0338410735,
0.0197816081,
0.0559867993,
0.0421343371,
-0.0299328193,
-0.00518149,
0.0216297321,
0.0197382271,
0.0651597828,
0.0006554598,
-0.0039148666,
-0.0350905359,
-0.0140832467,
-0.0055075735,
0.0252748244,
0.0314512029,
-0.0259074476,
0.0231969897,
-0.0289688203,
0.0449751168,
0.0303088315,
-0.0565904975,
-0.0505180471,
0.0038077086,
0.0017031061,
-0.0267845858,
-0.0086188531,
-0.0468291752,
0.1280641705,
-0.0153598525,
-0.0084080268,
0.019260915,
0.0493736342,
0.0189154968,
0.045030091,
0.035848517,
0.0135853793,
0.0448182784,
0.0218895115,
-0.0304226335,
-0.0032364256,
-0.0027583467,
-0.0126705682,
-0.081392996,
0.0049682851,
-0.0082614478,
-0.0592784695,
-0.0519741513,
-0.0087298453,
0.0278725494,
-0.0441012941,
0.0569028929,
0.0472628474,
-0.0099536348,
0.0612370819,
-0.0205732342,
-0.0601334982,
0.0082503418,
-0.0530094504,
-0.0291477349,
0.0093916059,
0.0302475691,
-0.0385100134,
-0.0029512173,
0.0081320433,
-0.0748925507,
0.0737795159,
0.045834966,
-0.0170570333,
-0.0026330063,
-0.0007704709,
0.025112452,
0.0326585434,
0.046862293,
-0.0034273788,
-0.0036389607,
-0.018759992,
-0.0080505908,
-0.0142645696,
0.0013632857,
0.0168410949,
0.0276787691,
-0.0121317348,
-0.0048507536,
0.0327616408,
0.0396136306,
-0.0173609406,
-0.0072485856,
0.0489146858,
0.0298604816,
-0.0199587923,
-0.0324872807,
0.055242829,
-0.0090583805,
0.0209432468,
0.0289691072,
-0.0440239906,
-0.0025297985,
0.0841421634,
-0.0087492662,
-0.0265205484,
0.0366090462,
-0.1002878621,
0.0736434907,
-0.0185622405,
0.0312361475,
0.0149615919,
0.00508259,
-0.0368927531,
0.0373865403,
0.0266294256,
-0.0039304537,
-0.0133803356,
-0.064829722,
0.0221044123,
0.0298704077,
-0.0940019414,
0.0498039089,
-0.004298015,
0.0157495216,
0.0405830219,
-0.0586551651,
-0.0154815884,
-0.0503144227,
-0.021141151,
-0.0148952249,
-0.0469057262,
0.0650029108,
-0.0084663406,
0.0367582999,
0.0383209027,
0.0020701475,
-0.0093353298,
0.0045133079,
0.0327462144,
0.0385967195,
0.0525462255,
0.0230995528,
-0.0892449319,
0.0146726398,
-0.0401858911,
-0.0369931199,
0.0430168882,
-0.0072102458,
-0.0031049354,
-0.0542012118,
-0.0469796434,
-0.0281507075,
0.0296370331,
-0.0387671925,
0.0021030863,
0.0090605291,
0.0039423727,
0.0351553857,
-0.0149068758,
0.0060175983,
0.0429074578,
-0.0098962765,
-0.0096581234,
0.0123654697,
-0.0043211272,
-0.0426459685,
-0.0174488034,
-0.0591873638,
-0.0153133506,
0.0104366336,
0.1000986472,
-0.0373529047,
-0.0295604095,
-0.03404117,
-0.0334561877,
-0.0230067484,
0.0106381066,
0.0165650826,
-0.0771486759,
-0.0144155007,
0.0458476655,
-0.0059944862,
-0.0247907508,
0.060684666,
-0.0235493183,
-0.0120747248,
-0.0275301505,
-0.008352641,
-0.0747849047,
0.0865649804,
0.0423547402,
-0.0049819807,
0.0202283133,
-0.0356222168,
0.0151702035,
-0.005962735,
0.0369240306,
-0.027697362,
0.0771842152,
-0.0262966398,
0.0303634964,
-0.0467682667,
-0.0594717339,
-0.0531658009,
0.0127537623,
-0.0331525616,
0.0346511602,
0.0376048125,
-0.0372740142,
-0.0763381794,
0.0386096835,
-0.0502947643,
0.0292732343,
0.0475179218,
-0.0251279268,
-0.0259928014,
0.0186927076,
-0.0285437573,
0.03741429,
0.0249254312,
0.0202153921,
-0.0112275463,
0.0517502092,
0.0225353204,
0.0006341501,
-0.0300992988,
-0.0163040403,
0.0731590614,
-0.0719830394,
-0.0360155292,
0.0068611493,
-0.0086497841,
-0.04803418,
-0.0420279279,
0.0470378362,
0.0317276716,
-0.0215089843,
0.0549804606,
0.0031727017,
0.0072735124,
0.0307929628,
0.0338399746,
-0.0838773623,
0.0184747111,
0.0155590195,
-0.035826344,
-0.0211211629,
-0.0078678168,
-0.0218620766,
-0.0633552149,
0.0190648306,
-0.0121058021,
-0.0145021286,
-0.0198824704,
-0.0511851981,
0.0225042105,
-0.0023560571,
0.0112311831,
0.0183868296,
-0.0361072719,
-0.0277922954,
0.0407236703,
-0.0062443507,
-0.0036546709,
-0.0304425694,
0.0049046008,
-0.0133935921,
0.0482476652,
0.0495083518,
-0.0302775316,
-0.0481433049,
0.0025508597,
-0.0009225215,
-0.0017851463,
-0.0026687789,
-0.0126398494,
0.0215256419,
-0.0413722731,
-0.0485259742,
-0.007846958,
-0.0275827665,
-0.0227578972,
-0.0236985199,
0.0814453736,
-0.0329569168,
-0.0195222571,
-0.0221485123,
-0.0451866053,
-0.012254281,
0.0076890122,
-0.0199405216,
0.0020351864,
-0.0568269566,
-0.0482395031,
-0.0228983611,
-0.0086686844,
-0.0985500887,
0.0015880765,
0.0602416098,
-0.1048105657,
-0.0420246683,
0.0020058642,
0.0010348097,
-0.0216742754,
0.0350100026,
-0.0263691582,
0.067878738,
-0.00297295,
-0.0665053949,
0.0059953504,
-0.0300811883,
0.0282377005,
-0.0441030711,
-0.0021543833,
0.0289722662,
0.0247609615,
-0.0359721817,
-0.0234366991,
-0.0863019153,
-0.0364764668,
0.0687826201,
0.0441510715,
0.0268696137,
-0.0557363182,
-0.0048198933,
-0.0049282676,
-0.0336992294,
0.0839951187,
-0.0433131084,
0.0026682336,
0.0510641038,
-0.0358510837,
0.0124843288,
0.0195030011,
-0.0014007339,
0.0177809466,
-0.0238348152,
0.043227464,
0.0218363795,
-0.0124025764,
0.0596441254,
0.030729631,
0.0524387434,
0.0256812442,
0.0109696621,
0.0234854035,
-0.0074359793,
-0.0264406018,
-0.0201040171,
-0.0519476756,
-0.0079739243,
-0.0443745628,
0.0404640026,
-0.033381369,
0.0327445678,
-0.0207217224,
0.0396965109,
0.0236495975,
0.0608705729,
0.0263693761,
-0.0296371207,
0.0166589413,
0.0173468795,
0.0181558132,
0.013580651,
0.0230833106,
0.0390154347,
0.0047043138,
-0.0026720045,
0.0485928841,
0.0352899693,
-0.0606204793,
-0.0009150446,
-0.0497863367,
-0.0150717376,
0.0260400474,
0.0242420901,
0.0091127669,
-0.0088020843,
0.0258981716,
-0.0627668202,
0.0120376525,
0.0005249304,
-0.0053448658,
0.0123231402,
-0.0312227849,
0.0235901829,
0.0282889009,
0.0202175528,
0.003937514,
0.0460398123,
-0.0584348589,
0.0301894452,
0.0105068795,
-0.0023537758,
-0.0411808863,
-0.0629646778,
-0.026025841,
-0.0361958407,
0.0198526233,
-0.0075136782,
-0.0866291597,
-0.0728878751,
0.0448284373,
-0.0037160513,
0.0534843765,
-0.0757076293,
0.0370633602,
0.0377134159,
0.0591805279,
-0.0341821909,
-0.02521828,
-0.0087809097,
0.0059548458,
0.0258270968,
0.0069460915,
-5.062526133e-33,
-0.0188628957,
-0.031363517,
0.0145612853,
0.0307345372,
-0.0036010605,
-0.0056960434,
-0.0217692722,
0.0222924035,
0.0274435896,
0.0054120687,
-0.0371521227,
0.0107747102,
0.0234080683,
0.0340222754,
0.000219639,
-0.0359580964,
0.0431491807,
-0.0025682792,
-0.0351995751,
-0.0365003087,
0.0226426162,
-0.0575111061,
0.0606356226,
-0.0270772744,
0.0482508019,
-0.0093669882,
-0.0077190902,
0.0293953139,
-0.0461996421,
0.057165917,
0.0049423282,
0.0655462071,
0.0190561526,
-0.0146182822,
-0.0385264233,
0.0496468954,
-0.0800959617,
-0.0065871789,
0.0234820899,
0.0583065264,
-0.0324427933,
-0.0200108401,
0.0277146101,
-0.0174604785,
-0.0238786768,
0.0072935564,
0.0131831272,
-0.0071853334,
0.0202810597,
-0.0071048089,
-0.0212714877,
0.0037654769,
-0.0055534183,
0.0123635223,
0.0454625562,
0.0646669418,
-0.001587,
0.0159039963,
-0.047328148,
0.0363335274,
0.0045204507,
0.0363605805,
-0.0035595156,
0.0078784879,
-0.0262788199,
0.0131782275,
0.0501244552,
-0.0123700183,
-0.0044300603,
-0.015172937,
-0.0144184539,
0.0363125801,
0.0142336879,
0.0147254318,
0.0722155198,
0.0245209187,
-0.0119195497,
-0.0013234378,
-0.015917236,
0.0490615405,
0.0100177843,
-0.0088128215,
-0.0069887163,
-0.0247975662,
-0.0409631543,
0.0318433568,
-0.0091651659,
-0.0031200664,
-0.0154231964,
0.004872126,
-0.0153692178,
0.0358924046,
0.0128359077,
-0.0636091381,
-0.0271338113,
-0.0000291479,
0.0172696877,
0.0338269584,
-0.0121752536,
0.0216410942,
-0.0006654167,
-0.033710178,
-0.0099796066,
0.0127897393,
-0.0020999054,
-0.002416559,
0.0055351732,
0.060717795,
-0.0412531197,
-0.0028218534,
-0.0353651568,
0.0273685418,
-0.0439001992,
0.0507809706,
0.0297765229,
0.0346110947,
-0.000591829,
-0.0094027249,
-0.0325563774,
-0.0090415189,
-0.0314434022,
0.118301034,
0.02198603,
-0.0078964103,
0.00103397,
-0.0427743271,
-0.0481117181,
0.0034228363,
0.0311548412,
-0.0473134518,
-0.0115452884,
-0.0229417644,
2.416e-7,
0.0659152344,
0.0070298961,
0.0972396955,
0.0732198283,
0.0227602869,
-0.0037435116,
0.0315552801,
0.0179229025,
0.0184885692,
0.0320149064,
-0.0079481006,
0.0286220778,
-0.0291272458,
0.0424996205,
-0.0849415213,
-0.0026339062,
-0.0438803174,
-0.0088039851,
0.0025430778,
0.0099854702,
0.0310660545,
0.0726658925,
0.0094530545,
-0.0086089745,
-0.0531312227,
0.00497129,
0.049127996,
0.006553418,
0.0448173955,
0.0418102182,
-0.0237806253,
0.0139256595,
0.0443427116,
0.0381051823,
0.0129779987,
0.0138015291,
0.0000658592,
0.0558500774,
-0.0216598082,
-0.0121191256,
-0.0220819563,
-0.0191480499,
-0.026316436,
0.0476264432,
0.006405626,
-0.0522517189,
-0.0558807738,
0.0098375557,
-0.0321527161,
0.0042887316,
-0.0400145389,
0.0374652706,
-0.0388556421,
0.0278080273,
0.0359696485,
-0.0169068705,
0.0116836904,
-0.0634304285,
-0.035894528,
-0.0279725734,
-0.0433099009,
-0.0372956321,
-0.0197723694,
-0.0142024457,
0.0207093414,
0.0105725853,
-0.0354782306,
2.134579044e-34,
0.0423232988,
0.0217626486,
0.0127910944,
0.0597804748,
0.0119159054,
-0.0254919603,
0.0102490894,
0.0193985067,
0.0283896774,
-0.0628958121,
-0.0474112593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00204v1 | Continuous Training and Fine-tuning for Domain-Specific Language Models in Medical Question Answering | 2023-11-01T00:18:00 | 2023-11-01T00:18:00 | Zhen Guo, Yining Hua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models exhibit promising general capabilities but often lack
specialized knowledge for domain-specific tasks. Developing domain experts from
a base model enables a range of applications without prohibitive training
costs. This work demonstrates a method using continuous training and
instruction fine-tuning to rapidly adapt Llama 2 base models to the Chinese
medical domain. We first conduct continuous training on 1B tokens from Chinese
medical references to teach relevant vocabulary and knowledge. The models are
then fine-tuned on 54K examples sourced from the Chinese National Medical
Licensing Examination. Experiments on Chinese medical data confirm the
effectiveness of this approach, producing a model comparable to GPT-3.5-turbo
while using way less computational resource. The resulting domain-specific
model could be useful for various Chinese medical applications. More broadly,
this provides a template for domain-specific training of large language models
in areas where pre-trained models lack the required expertise, such as law,
science, and engineering. | [
0.0745688006,
0.0243923925,
0.0003030666,
-0.0092363562,
0.0111843757,
0.0185982212,
0.0068246787,
0.0214349963,
-0.0020591156,
-0.0526114516,
-0.0570102632,
-0.0557879843,
-0.0429141968,
0.0029079493,
0.028948972,
-0.0704557151,
0.0293340925,
0.0079293652,
0.0226795599,
-0.0282916557,
0.0041837324,
0.0059804991,
-0.0164572559,
0.0385980755,
0.0370519385,
-0.0391065851,
0.0504341237,
-0.0265440289,
0.0243330933,
-0.046168603,
0.0491280369,
0.0438988283,
0.009392824,
-0.0256629251,
0.000001845,
-0.0483934917,
0.0024565614,
0.0134357456,
-0.0514273904,
0.0227736291,
0.0300593469,
-0.0120344805,
-0.0077175684,
0.0297647975,
-0.0500886925,
-0.0031059925,
0.0155411288,
0.0377333798,
0.0821672305,
0.0471447073,
0.0167547576,
-0.0351421088,
0.0598069467,
-0.0374053754,
0.0004228966,
-0.0731746778,
0.0352554619,
0.0526556969,
0.0616577007,
-0.0112640448,
-0.0120245134,
0.0173134059,
0.0114168068,
0.0557755865,
0.003297257,
0.0507823266,
-0.0293079987,
0.0250187535,
-0.0037018573,
0.0733737126,
-0.010229528,
-0.0090707373,
-0.0082692467,
0.0254399739,
-0.0164541025,
-0.0071798973,
-0.0583727323,
0.0023733613,
-0.0069762608,
0.0069117872,
0.0436983034,
-0.0434549823,
0.0198070314,
0.0420381613,
-0.0232825708,
0.0166582838,
0.0082639512,
-0.0362980515,
0.0180091579,
0.0097285174,
-0.0279106721,
-0.0308832172,
0.0251241624,
0.0660646409,
-0.0184858851,
0.0331334434,
-0.0244572274,
0.0012571863,
0.0576311983,
-0.0279787835,
-0.0019754439,
0.0188577063,
-0.0320858583,
0.0423795432,
-0.0421066396,
0.0203073341,
-0.0282697212,
0.0373535156,
-0.0566162802,
-0.0436382703,
-0.0553455129,
-0.0301702451,
-0.0485113598,
0.0461672843,
-0.0141021917,
0.0016820162,
-0.0875925422,
0.0005085242,
0.0125313718,
-0.0391707644,
-0.0019516388,
0.0218799189,
-0.0414708108,
-0.0143203586,
-0.043578051,
0.0326946452,
-0.0381855369,
0.0468035527,
-0.0386866927,
-0.0528789125,
-0.0072540483,
-0.0041845706,
-0.0224857423,
-0.0111992769,
0.0395753495,
0.0702609271,
-0.0265343357,
-0.0228814334,
-0.0223576184,
-0.0275330544,
-0.0039323471,
-0.037196368,
0.0003100202,
-0.0641518086,
-0.0103025604,
0.0010222405,
0.022125883,
-0.0603069589,
0.0240618661,
0.0163085572,
-0.0267410018,
0.0730901286,
-0.0530152246,
0.003949163,
0.0073235906,
0.0441696085,
0.0187613331,
0.0648714378,
0.0272399653,
-0.0648278818,
0.0163979381,
-0.000538765,
-0.0074453047,
0.0140911806,
0.0425477289,
-0.0115272338,
0.0093485499,
0.0445649028,
0.0061878203,
0.0699820369,
-0.0116465027,
0.0309307314,
-0.0161794629,
0.0096616754,
0.0021758091,
0.0622532293,
0.0201933105,
0.0092228502,
0.0269741341,
-0.0529206619,
0.0329372808,
0.0031541779,
-0.0257580411,
0.0047248984,
0.0297586191,
0.0211405326,
-0.0427467264,
0.0030393293,
-0.055451408,
-0.0318720937,
-0.017952567,
-0.0043732533,
-0.066682294,
-0.0012818068,
0.0485970899,
-0.0003765297,
-0.0162360687,
0.0852222517,
0.0438171886,
-0.010091465,
0.0187272243,
-0.075199388,
-0.0077415034,
0.0742386058,
0.0555295311,
-0.0360815674,
-0.0777463689,
-0.0158220287,
0.042846825,
0.0203339458,
0.0053847693,
-0.0371661521,
0.0003066577,
-0.0460526906,
0.0029255701,
0.0203351136,
0.0094183544,
-0.0295535512,
0.0390209891,
0.0482870601,
-0.0017112002,
-0.0647015646,
0.0088680321,
0.0438406207,
-0.0839320198,
-0.0299136676,
-0.0194783267,
-0.0041544084,
0.0212196317,
0.0241467245,
-0.0157980341,
0.0158592947,
0.0266796481,
-0.0501298197,
-0.008586688,
-0.0072420686,
-0.0261313133,
-0.0101072434,
0.0586603694,
-0.0376088247,
-0.0120597109,
-0.0019458313,
-0.0577044934,
-0.026354067,
-0.0493876338,
-0.0174112748,
0.0144664636,
-0.0488082357,
-0.0090341521,
0.0324265212,
0.0105747357,
-0.0576496422,
0.028197173,
-0.0071151052,
0.011877507,
0.0333910361,
-0.0001921493,
-0.0035136139,
-0.0537358299,
0.0040463507,
-0.0047409469,
0.0007923465,
0.0336547457,
-0.0527215824,
0.0280492362,
-0.0504798703,
-0.0489087664,
-0.080947347,
0.0106450664,
-0.0080115953,
0.0354969613,
0.0358322449,
0.0184627753,
-0.0201048832,
-0.0164379831,
-0.0450389273,
-0.0182165429,
0.0120927496,
0.0198591258,
0.0240395628,
0.0306868125,
-0.0146967387,
-0.029172292,
-0.0095178159,
-0.0308741163,
-0.0304581169,
-0.0007230202,
-0.006085549,
-0.0303617343,
-0.0263076331,
-0.0146760857,
0.0148362629,
0.0090859514,
-0.0430604219,
-0.0038088833,
0.0285159424,
-0.0020759655,
0.0512654819,
-0.0117841866,
0.0072566653,
0.0277256463,
0.0205812156,
-0.0217155851,
0.0364302993,
-0.0097664315,
-0.0537089631,
-0.0271789841,
-0.0112611791,
0.0021810706,
0.0716999099,
-0.0057322839,
-0.0170225687,
-0.0261635818,
0.0004004707,
-0.0464317836,
0.0045547318,
-0.0300808139,
0.0440597795,
-0.0353697687,
0.0180780105,
0.018123785,
-0.0118920291,
0.0922969282,
-0.0004680523,
0.017742414,
-0.0831969529,
-0.0213630982,
-0.0561527796,
-0.0035167148,
-0.050354179,
0.017790094,
0.008265879,
-0.0226128083,
-0.0396265909,
0.0173900705,
-0.0325257443,
-0.0425266363,
0.054833319,
-0.0303991046,
0.0345886275,
-0.0219602305,
-0.0489721373,
-0.0555316173,
-0.0115735102,
-0.050422594,
0.0436092466,
-0.0451028347,
0.0400310382,
-0.0237446986,
0.0221546534,
-0.0181462765,
0.0338034593,
0.0165694784,
-0.0014140849,
-0.0142537626,
0.0482297242,
0.0496978387,
0.046979256,
-0.0210497398,
-0.0224488135,
0.0328089781,
0.053042721,
0.0362473093,
0.0110323019,
0.0253331028,
-0.0016311372,
0.0142781967,
-0.0515950881,
0.0208173823,
0.0188026745,
0.0281046648,
-0.0661725327,
-0.017100865,
0.1063798219,
0.036803171,
-0.0073259179,
0.0136622163,
-0.0138570648,
-0.0046943757,
0.0077409078,
0.0486963652,
-0.0856640339,
-0.0524338782,
-0.0143014314,
0.052873943,
-0.0001600257,
0.0018379262,
0.0316254497,
-0.0766358748,
0.0161248203,
-0.008658383,
-0.0241496041,
-0.020091638,
-0.004335796,
0.0082798768,
0.0085933376,
0.0266530607,
0.0010064669,
-0.0327975415,
0.0008956349,
0.034573134,
-0.0086360546,
-0.0776111484,
0.0571475029,
-0.0092544407,
0.0532795936,
0.0703442022,
0.0078299716,
-0.0083474936,
-0.0203131214,
0.0405273102,
-0.0339337289,
0.0109586213,
-0.0081219906,
0.0546893217,
-0.0082231918,
-0.0036213959,
-0.0049222033,
0.0479236096,
-0.0416293889,
-0.0051120147,
0.0219302885,
0.0782429874,
-0.0103936875,
-0.020681547,
-0.0454806536,
0.0203689691,
-0.0194614194,
0.0608661957,
0.0053740316,
-0.0248930305,
-0.0196345989,
0.0090496251,
-0.0047607664,
-0.0221242197,
-0.0601432286,
0.0469125658,
-0.0345236324,
0.0310064089,
-0.0599323995,
-0.030477507,
0.039157439,
0.0032699211,
0.0166755654,
0.0539892651,
0.0000590611,
0.0284509957,
-0.0427367277,
0.0396244265,
-0.0384915397,
0.0115535567,
-0.0816991106,
-0.0386496447,
0.0978370607,
0.0144190332,
-0.0409810394,
-0.0073278197,
-0.0187168587,
-0.0028430494,
-0.0103120441,
0.0365359709,
0.0155300982,
-0.0052186707,
-0.0298427027,
-0.0440992601,
0.0336010233,
0.0231215339,
-0.0431138799,
0.0045204102,
0.019008914,
-0.0427856147,
-0.0016684554,
0.0222576428,
-0.0288124494,
0.0266645495,
0.032264702,
0.035932105,
-0.0090076383,
-0.0125009082,
0.031838093,
0.0225603301,
0.0062758545,
0.0071223723,
0.0045473273,
-0.0223394874,
0.0696651489,
0.0178656895,
0.0269132424,
-0.0103221536,
-0.0164549798,
0.0278512593,
-0.0327101722,
-0.0005911025,
-0.0124046896,
-0.034452375,
-0.01792516,
-0.0606975704,
0.0541178398,
0.0190368947,
0.0083714407,
0.0145386225,
-0.0348390043,
-0.0168651193,
-0.0143401455,
0.0094085503,
0.0476072617,
-0.0139164841,
0.0381599739,
-0.0072564534,
0.0146192145,
0.0012813051,
0.0465126,
-0.0499439836,
-0.0508408621,
-0.0322716385,
0.0469560176,
0.0594151877,
0.0317267887,
-0.0183987617,
-0.0202854071,
-0.0047563817,
-0.0184532385,
-0.0073679886,
-0.0293882228,
0.033633709,
0.0891623348,
0.0169892982,
0.0025130254,
-0.0153313428,
0.1090593785,
0.0372222103,
0.0883597881,
-0.0058721825,
-0.0038764267,
-0.0292141102,
-0.0419475064,
-0.0190667305,
0.0044709123,
-0.0376486294,
0.0398998931,
-0.0624841191,
-0.0656199455,
0.0010983628,
-0.0184372719,
-0.0404694378,
-0.014065438,
0.0557036921,
0.0386223309,
0.0174634568,
-0.0193146523,
-0.0016723436,
0.0441174284,
0.0073581208,
-0.0178179257,
0.0294806901,
-6.236779235e-33,
-0.0168977957,
-0.0017648533,
0.0474171601,
-0.035000246,
-0.0105540277,
0.0190600976,
-0.0236667674,
-0.0127571356,
-0.0629135668,
0.0010857641,
-0.0358533226,
0.0133411987,
0.0154268928,
0.0107493689,
-0.0126058105,
-0.0409572199,
0.0206951778,
0.0102368798,
-0.0020684709,
0.0165939853,
-0.0203993767,
0.0630462319,
0.0579666272,
-0.0651513785,
-0.0102415998,
0.0126294922,
0.020597782,
0.0142190307,
-0.0067890654,
0.0934584513,
-0.0269546714,
0.0361433737,
0.0543541536,
-0.0585556142,
-0.0088023627,
-0.0138766067,
-0.1327308267,
-0.0131179979,
0.01880043,
-0.0104092509,
-0.0230361726,
-0.0629944131,
0.0553569086,
-0.0018089557,
-0.006721851,
-0.0015365754,
0.0292761531,
-0.0612831041,
0.0007225768,
-0.0250155274,
-0.034354344,
0.0342718214,
0.0229884442,
0.0114565864,
-0.0313106328,
-0.0124765886,
-0.0334239863,
0.0475532897,
-0.0023131475,
-0.03285392,
0.0793380961,
0.0807555169,
0.0381067246,
-0.0344888382,
-0.0163871851,
0.0096029062,
-0.0149319554,
-0.0611087754,
-0.0131485416,
-0.0147034572,
-0.0149491448,
0.0261607785,
0.0321790427,
0.0432844162,
0.0232362635,
-0.0170352422,
-0.1237341315,
0.0306057949,
-0.0192843918,
0.0738873407,
0.0029254353,
-0.0238107219,
-0.0200420916,
0.0099105192,
-0.0249772873,
0.0525224432,
-0.0198124815,
-0.0358007103,
0.059540581,
0.0132450527,
-0.0123246703,
0.0016829715,
-0.0009696003,
-0.0542236865,
0.0019025618,
0.0077805752,
0.0235853512,
0.0124026248,
-0.0164613891,
0.0151158739,
-0.0557642542,
-0.0106435539,
-0.0046377108,
-0.027711181,
0.0191674177,
0.0093408395,
0.0198941641,
-0.0284097791,
-0.0610235296,
0.0071241362,
0.0053499457,
0.002263864,
0.0204467271,
0.0634747222,
0.0144232241,
0.0465563498,
0.0077008959,
0.0395323858,
0.0155880302,
-0.0342759602,
-0.0522003286,
-0.0273279306,
-0.0052134008,
0.0204760302,
-0.0659667403,
0.0073499247,
-0.0200453661,
0.0495090783,
-0.0214435067,
-0.0615341142,
-0.018397525,
0.0201253369,
2.537e-7,
0.0914962441,
0.0396371111,
0.0050567719,
0.0013804873,
0.027556967,
0.0022410373,
0.0024230711,
0.0140979001,
0.0051591606,
-0.0026764793,
0.0175680239,
0.0177848581,
0.0269370861,
0.0308414139,
-0.1080924571,
-0.0073853433,
-0.030923469,
0.0261406265,
-0.0226460546,
-0.034098886,
0.0157408193,
0.1230007038,
-0.0386620685,
-0.036630325,
-0.0069603315,
-0.0589393489,
0.0617096797,
0.0026228628,
0.0044327183,
0.0608955063,
0.0134444498,
0.0464494415,
0.0029539156,
0.0204948392,
-0.0254875906,
0.0134085091,
0.0099042095,
0.1171470806,
-0.0354380794,
-0.0127594732,
0.0257597417,
-0.0242961291,
0.0214371141,
-0.0226651765,
0.0677219927,
-0.061365217,
-0.0301250312,
0.0134950113,
0.0042062211,
-0.0227188729,
0.0377203375,
-0.0333264284,
-0.0232627634,
0.0343440846,
0.015106516,
0.0028504527,
-0.0254414082,
-0.0543836206,
-0.021326378,
0.0036732918,
-0.0213718954,
-0.0367650576,
0.0181517918,
-0.03620084,
-0.01986444,
-0.0551011264,
0.0108118197,
2.036324935e-34,
0.0100377137,
-0.0076139336,
0.0231115818,
0.1086857542,
-0.0169167537,
-0.0109773381,
0.017155489,
-0.0059138173,
0.0196351465,
-0.0794379711,
-0.0066836588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00189v1 | XAI-CLASS: Explanation-Enhanced Text Classification with Extremely Weak Supervision | 2023-10-31T23:24:22 | 2023-10-31T23:24:22 | Daniel Hajialigol, Hanwen Liu, Xuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text classification aims to effectively categorize documents into pre-defined
categories. Traditional methods for text classification often rely on large
amounts of manually annotated training data, making the process time-consuming
and labor-intensive. To address this issue, recent studies have focused on
weakly-supervised and extremely weakly-supervised settings, which require
minimal or no human annotation, respectively. In previous methods of weakly
supervised text classification, pseudo-training data is generated by assigning
pseudo-labels to documents based on their alignment (e.g., keyword matching)
with specific classes. However, these methods ignore the importance of
incorporating the explanations of the generated pseudo-labels, or saliency of
individual words, as additional guidance during the text classification
training process. To address this limitation, we propose XAI-CLASS, a novel
explanation-enhanced extremely weakly-supervised text classification method
that incorporates word saliency prediction as an auxiliary task. XAI-CLASS
begins by employing a multi-round question-answering process to generate
pseudo-training data that promotes the mutual enhancement of class labels and
corresponding explanation word generation. This pseudo-training data is then
used to train a multi-task framework that simultaneously learns both text
classification and word saliency prediction. Extensive experiments on several
weakly-supervised text classification datasets show that XAI-CLASS outperforms
other weakly-supervised text classification methods significantly. Moreover,
experiments demonstrate that XAI-CLASS enhances both model performance and
explainability. | [
0.0450084209,
-0.0060043405,
0.0196287856,
0.0064576976,
0.0225562006,
0.0380996354,
0.0213047732,
-0.0192349479,
0.0190436933,
-0.0315230936,
-0.0117899179,
0.0168106258,
-0.0230776798,
-0.0198432952,
0.029693896,
-0.0484309047,
0.0417985134,
-0.004732192,
0.0285352748,
0.0433827788,
0.0265159793,
0.0169240497,
0.0077699302,
-0.001946711,
0.0053094393,
-0.0105769904,
-0.0529595464,
-0.0158076119,
0.0007647917,
0.0275612008,
0.0536433533,
0.0213358905,
0.0346205719,
-0.0087508997,
0.0000017096,
-0.0461944118,
-0.0157192182,
-0.0162029881,
-0.0432888232,
0.0206934344,
0.0134450337,
-0.0274562426,
0.0599972345,
-0.0005867821,
-0.0024606315,
-0.0023723715,
0.0415556133,
0.1012985781,
0.0767372549,
0.0706846341,
-0.0231184606,
-0.0198337901,
0.0041228887,
-0.0216778982,
0.0351051092,
-0.0574923046,
-0.0052682501,
-0.0054696999,
-0.0085086701,
0.0578592196,
0.0334107839,
0.0060522524,
0.01408849,
-0.0418970697,
0.0466716662,
0.0200079009,
0.0071757575,
-0.0213848501,
-0.0136414515,
0.0621737912,
0.0143263843,
-0.0544652268,
-0.0048533073,
-0.0038951531,
0.0184500888,
-0.0039428729,
-0.0321081206,
-0.0307794809,
-0.0126017807,
0.0052754236,
0.0439428575,
0.0305355396,
0.0022206353,
0.0629565343,
0.0080479113,
0.0182002913,
-0.0307417233,
-0.0438684933,
0.0055330577,
0.0044056084,
-0.0639040545,
-0.0354937874,
0.0220482256,
0.0709562451,
-0.0080434494,
0.0058688074,
-0.0329506062,
-0.016834395,
0.0430983454,
-0.0669393986,
0.0108306827,
-0.0104807969,
-0.0423265249,
0.0666114464,
-0.0029627327,
0.029532453,
0.0141423633,
0.0123524079,
-0.0446712598,
-0.0261433981,
-0.0677835047,
-0.0239286423,
-0.037904609,
0.0537249409,
-0.0238944218,
-0.0123243621,
-0.0108264554,
0.0260710139,
0.0127202924,
-0.0004678882,
0.0015771905,
0.0376511551,
-0.084987022,
0.0147152562,
-0.0420413576,
0.0014810829,
-0.0862111002,
0.0438892059,
0.0069617997,
0.0011629695,
-0.0211508162,
0.0548796616,
0.0432671867,
-0.0462541506,
0.0023334248,
0.0113125807,
-0.0406152233,
-0.0555558465,
-0.0394374467,
-0.0330740698,
-0.0425931923,
-0.0453446656,
-0.0127470512,
0.005952307,
0.0040958049,
-0.0176062435,
-0.0402055532,
-0.0095800916,
0.0057025617,
0.0063866344,
-0.0215057489,
0.0860669762,
-0.0469483435,
0.0010792998,
0.0274915304,
0.0189770106,
-0.0262558386,
0.019735625,
-0.0113079567,
0.0239007957,
0.0527655967,
-0.0310178045,
0.0596935824,
-0.0516297147,
0.028812049,
0.0057928418,
0.0387639813,
0.0341016985,
-0.0475175381,
0.0200840384,
0.0173439533,
0.0025823961,
0.0212781839,
0.003959626,
0.0147945723,
0.0205745213,
0.0047568153,
0.0561260246,
0.0114864651,
0.0433621891,
-0.0200882573,
0.0467894822,
-0.0307556372,
0.050886903,
-0.0361349992,
0.012940147,
0.0353667289,
-0.0719854981,
-0.0730684325,
-0.0919761285,
-0.0213076361,
-0.0097209131,
0.0176462363,
0.0266180951,
0.0684150383,
0.0352143086,
-0.0128445793,
0.0096315453,
0.0537813641,
-0.0518004522,
-0.0256629772,
-0.0635276586,
0.0763474032,
0.0732028633,
-0.0048224409,
-0.0622133203,
-0.0193111282,
-0.0164774507,
0.1086951718,
0.0455726571,
0.0323695391,
-0.0278236307,
0.0162141882,
-0.0462231115,
-0.0086967228,
-0.061395973,
0.009300055,
-0.0151605019,
-0.018271165,
-0.0135019058,
0.0467214398,
-0.0742033124,
-0.0580132045,
0.0538811274,
0.0004632801,
-0.05354755,
0.0113152266,
0.0231453218,
-0.0030281642,
0.0181825031,
0.0165313967,
-0.0009283576,
0.0334181637,
-0.0202516969,
0.003874107,
-0.0152367298,
0.0105589814,
-0.0297429748,
-0.0148935029,
0.0204015132,
-0.0008350391,
0.0331933163,
-0.0283740163,
-0.045200184,
-0.0021060121,
-0.0083215069,
0.0089970743,
-0.0725670978,
-0.0277915429,
-0.0041914959,
0.0086061349,
-0.0719552338,
0.0514164791,
0.0536613688,
0.0361917056,
-0.0114440713,
-0.0097652432,
0.0111559927,
-0.0134442709,
0.0290379561,
0.000013893,
-0.0109486915,
-0.0036042596,
0.0042955079,
0.0125008868,
-0.0349216759,
-0.0085017337,
-0.0921005085,
0.0206391197,
-0.034932971,
-0.0054441756,
0.022348281,
-0.0114077665,
0.0271618608,
-0.0306414757,
-0.0666950718,
-0.0081982492,
-0.02574265,
0.0009582954,
0.0402960069,
0.0020987263,
0.0261231717,
-0.0479763746,
0.0098136533,
0.0004171866,
0.0413015522,
0.0617254637,
-0.0249278955,
-0.056410525,
0.0317418575,
-0.0138584943,
-0.0110600339,
-0.0051847096,
-0.0174988322,
0.0054799272,
-0.0094661862,
-0.0301629193,
0.0394328646,
-0.0050336709,
0.0541708544,
-0.0195826758,
0.0435519256,
-0.0391724557,
0.0297007728,
-0.0274447426,
-0.0046209567,
-0.0131482985,
-0.0172439609,
-0.009693075,
0.0638837963,
-0.0234858859,
-0.0436613783,
-0.055996161,
-0.0094401976,
0.0211946573,
-0.0047665127,
-0.0199838709,
0.0049515958,
0.0279616416,
0.0237222109,
-0.0475743227,
-0.0416522138,
0.0864117369,
0.0150002427,
-0.0255732983,
-0.08395385,
-0.060298387,
-0.0145353619,
0.0399771221,
-0.028751336,
0.0134694381,
0.0143554304,
-0.006953082,
-0.0147295557,
-0.0433785394,
0.0008780716,
0.0197917391,
0.0294162501,
0.0009914404,
0.0136313215,
0.0080867773,
-0.0217444915,
-0.0259789657,
-0.062074285,
-0.0044381241,
0.0206888188,
-0.0150534427,
0.0101908855,
-0.0173314232,
0.0060104406,
0.0266214665,
0.0212822184,
-0.0135397296,
-0.0407969728,
-0.0049919654,
0.0559282564,
0.0560189821,
0.029945923,
-0.0181215089,
-0.0493331999,
0.0317202918,
0.0278819297,
0.0240927413,
-0.0008063529,
0.0134524545,
-0.010050009,
0.0029046934,
-0.043040704,
-0.004615135,
-0.0030154409,
0.0602392368,
-0.0381892361,
-0.0401863754,
0.0836921409,
0.0472520329,
-0.0463467687,
-0.0019133653,
-0.0008650972,
0.0072150012,
0.0335085206,
0.0249514729,
0.018048076,
-0.0419060588,
-0.0205660295,
0.0467452444,
0.0199402589,
0.0319439285,
0.0002645835,
-0.0324952677,
0.0038611509,
-0.0302402452,
-0.0609751269,
-0.010691979,
-0.1050508246,
0.009331109,
0.02984933,
-0.0348594524,
-0.0099186879,
0.0360552631,
-0.0016297706,
0.0410004109,
0.0067731901,
-0.0190066528,
0.0181528796,
-0.0143775102,
-0.0144677246,
0.0653230622,
0.0577185936,
-0.0281294528,
-0.0153961387,
0.0206668302,
-0.0587732047,
0.0396343172,
0.0015249063,
0.071381405,
-0.015557956,
0.005761751,
-0.0482713096,
0.0842522234,
-0.0447641686,
-0.0232466385,
0.0182734467,
0.0544203706,
-0.029926924,
-0.007134669,
-0.0121084936,
-0.037489906,
0.0086971475,
0.0673516318,
0.0346033536,
-0.0690366179,
-0.0287616141,
-0.0187899731,
-0.023083875,
-0.0692616627,
0.0182700977,
0.0096893879,
-0.0034128972,
-0.0102579305,
-0.0416418314,
-0.0664249659,
0.0134256547,
0.0237455778,
0.0141720399,
-0.0051919906,
-0.0237938017,
-0.0158634726,
-0.0504761674,
0.043304693,
0.0126770819,
0.0015601559,
0.0147197573,
-0.0599164367,
0.0413290262,
-0.0415434502,
-0.0049439338,
-0.0031637361,
-0.0320260786,
-0.0187705029,
-0.0499564894,
0.0320694782,
0.0151795438,
0.0615076236,
0.0005854721,
-0.0659939945,
0.0107194241,
0.0247853454,
-0.0445402116,
-0.0056359847,
0.058794789,
-0.0005630951,
0.0262880139,
0.0380020328,
-0.0264474582,
0.0109250089,
0.0465840846,
-0.0053449729,
-0.0211601742,
-0.0029921515,
0.0116823157,
-0.0408921503,
0.037584018,
-0.0062224609,
-0.0277421698,
-0.0362810008,
0.0164954085,
0.0099084666,
-0.0443365686,
-0.0297869965,
0.0282646138,
-0.0013939686,
-0.0275995154,
-0.0059818584,
0.0509342179,
-0.0517118163,
0.0429677293,
-0.0507341921,
0.0089384941,
0.0160368551,
-0.0195093043,
-0.0381141193,
0.0311155505,
-0.0283740107,
-0.0268524606,
0.0292320307,
0.055540666,
0.0199172497,
0.0612553656,
0.018726781,
0.0224070791,
0.0024838143,
0.0009953706,
-0.084424369,
0.0319300964,
-0.0246743225,
0.0285526775,
0.0014318834,
-0.0461878963,
-0.0050205509,
0.0114099616,
-0.0241038557,
0.0098327827,
0.0876830295,
0.0179831553,
-0.0367425382,
-0.0256883372,
0.0309125446,
-0.026429072,
0.0182718094,
0.0806099251,
0.0266943108,
0.0008097814,
0.0116968956,
-0.0274358746,
-0.0330316983,
0.0051474427,
0.0306600891,
0.0745560378,
0.0024230112,
0.026338866,
0.0137531981,
-0.0406890959,
0.0316495411,
-0.0594792627,
-0.0251334962,
-0.0035647536,
0.0378944352,
0.066461578,
-0.0293817036,
-0.0309978239,
-0.0744795427,
-0.0014612996,
0.0010476793,
0.0241109133,
-0.0283622462,
-5.859071594e-33,
0.0225118045,
-0.055521898,
-0.0250452217,
0.001202701,
0.0262925252,
0.018795155,
-0.0597567409,
-0.0239845924,
-0.0202242285,
0.0462163463,
0.0044873026,
0.0416160859,
0.0045181033,
0.0675722733,
-0.0134799508,
-0.0322707407,
0.0077574621,
0.0330743454,
-0.0059708925,
0.0606034026,
0.0387882963,
0.0163762588,
0.047398068,
-0.0954539701,
0.0735017136,
-0.0135598304,
-0.003510013,
0.0240035001,
-0.0022484399,
0.0651901811,
-0.0194411296,
0.06539125,
0.0338065997,
-0.0211587343,
0.0257905256,
0.0617820285,
-0.0750201046,
-0.0190518685,
0.003624097,
-0.0120891472,
-0.0444672927,
-0.0320596285,
-0.0044158455,
-0.0026332536,
0.0471263863,
-0.0046020872,
0.0866471082,
-0.0212215204,
-0.0291133244,
-0.0371982977,
-0.0508165248,
-0.0071649924,
-0.0470467173,
-0.0587994754,
0.0260319468,
0.0566094369,
0.0184880011,
0.0313701257,
-0.0298297424,
-0.0209512319,
0.0337753184,
0.0085808532,
0.0019036691,
0.0024536536,
-0.0264955163,
0.031097047,
0.0332429707,
0.0220777262,
-0.0254158136,
-0.0113178389,
-0.029313283,
0.0429851413,
0.0769990087,
0.0287574995,
0.0294478927,
0.0139375646,
-0.0741671771,
0.0281069223,
-0.0319215134,
0.0012518929,
0.0230011642,
0.0089222295,
-0.0829300061,
-0.0281176828,
-0.031031318,
0.0201757122,
-0.0639766082,
-0.0047131195,
0.0183854233,
0.0153657813,
-0.0487590358,
0.0316117741,
-0.0112560438,
-0.026859751,
-0.0032417837,
-0.0002193156,
-0.0223024003,
0.0098588997,
0.0043684379,
-0.0408197492,
-0.0169618204,
-0.046153836,
0.0102374321,
0.0061839833,
0.0184259843,
0.0109025259,
0.0982467681,
-0.0112079112,
-0.0212739855,
-0.0037275546,
-0.0397316404,
-0.0138281425,
0.0074884826,
0.0399780162,
-0.0048827105,
0.0282297917,
-0.0443300307,
0.095374167,
0.0179334711,
0.010475615,
-0.015876472,
-0.0552360602,
-0.0311196875,
0.0104478169,
-0.0296775624,
-0.0284987707,
0.003841016,
-0.0409601815,
-0.0123400697,
-0.0795796737,
-0.0027650604,
0.0327224247,
2.355e-7,
0.0260833185,
0.026102636,
0.0276512839,
-0.0413304754,
0.0045796102,
0.0445764177,
0.0161909405,
-0.0077776159,
-0.0120518263,
-0.0292908996,
0.0209466238,
0.0343336873,
0.0788078979,
-0.0101960087,
-0.0883828029,
-0.0338795446,
-0.0122925192,
-0.012133453,
-0.043217022,
0.012414882,
0.1064602509,
0.1004352495,
0.0327114463,
-0.0084172301,
0.0113576846,
-0.0629842877,
0.0366919562,
0.0119963428,
0.0240636617,
0.0351145193,
0.0298978258,
0.0053142109,
-0.0012364169,
0.0254450254,
-0.0399439968,
-0.0021886465,
0.0313606262,
0.0779145584,
-0.0150158629,
-0.0325068943,
-0.0161228571,
0.0309416708,
0.0496620424,
-0.0277564023,
0.0960561931,
-0.0728755593,
-0.0404249206,
0.01940565,
-0.0105571495,
-0.0180046372,
-0.0234645233,
-0.0223405212,
0.0245006606,
0.0079191579,
-0.0149285318,
-0.0103873461,
-0.0178924724,
-0.0771891922,
-0.052387502,
0.0267271604,
-0.0198753867,
0.0433565676,
-0.0114099151,
0.0046176943,
0.0620167181,
-0.0667754635,
0.0037019826,
1.923609835e-34,
0.0326738767,
0.0113102524,
0.0001011212,
0.012754051,
0.0188324396,
0.0058328961,
-0.0224934984,
-0.0398277976,
0.0599210635,
-0.0236060619,
-0.0054754429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.01472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.01472v1 | Relation Extraction from News Articles (RENA): A Tool for Epidemic Surveillance | 2023-10-31T23:14:54 | 2023-10-31T23:14:54 | Jaeff Hong, Duong Dung, Danielle Hutchinson, Zubair Akhtar, Rosalie Chen, Rebecca Dawson, Aditya Joshi, Samsung Lim, C Raina MacIntyre, Deepti Gurdasani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Relation Extraction from News Articles (RENA) is a browser-based tool
designed to extract key entities and their semantic relationships in English
language news articles related to infectious diseases. Constructed using the
React framework, this system presents users with an elegant and user-friendly
interface. It enables users to input a news article and select from a choice of
two models to generate a comprehensive list of relations within the provided
text. As a result, RENA allows real-time parsing of news articles to extract
key information for epidemic surveillance, contributing to EPIWATCH, an
open-source intelligence-based epidemic warning system. | [
0.0257322565,
0.0671915635,
-0.0187203623,
0.0053535411,
-0.0216878373,
-0.0136664677,
-0.0223833527,
0.0251046941,
0.0489717573,
-0.0300707389,
0.0401307121,
0.011399366,
-0.0018429857,
0.071735166,
-0.0154514685,
-0.0563762225,
0.0488294736,
0.0468023047,
0.0115522118,
0.0644907951,
0.0094755366,
0.0380446464,
-0.0049263081,
0.0389804505,
0.0169455204,
-0.0254355129,
0.0007276176,
-0.0370223038,
0.0665721446,
-0.1023404598,
-0.0030502102,
0.001998404,
-0.006738218,
-0.0396300927,
0.000002172,
-0.0217986032,
-0.0386971943,
-0.0003474587,
-0.0017656412,
-0.043537382,
0.0136088105,
-0.069157593,
0.0117285801,
0.0094221085,
-0.0271867141,
-0.0675488785,
0.0489763096,
0.0063354778,
0.0337612815,
0.0451532714,
-0.0201026164,
-0.0173388273,
0.0598949268,
0.0036871296,
0.0239120647,
-0.0058606737,
0.0569790639,
-0.0433166325,
0.066308938,
-0.0328133255,
0.0379016176,
0.014423497,
-0.0137488768,
-0.0234443415,
-0.0171751212,
0.052070301,
0.0397973582,
-0.0768614635,
-0.0232714247,
0.0256314073,
0.0170693398,
0.0048876982,
0.0659230649,
0.0270470362,
-0.0472755097,
0.0718490928,
-0.0291436259,
-0.0319459848,
-0.0564770028,
0.0380149856,
0.0602422692,
0.0042891451,
0.0235090833,
-0.0122498255,
0.0118370997,
0.050182078,
0.005345081,
-0.0214100089,
-0.0071397931,
-0.0267683994,
0.0440578647,
-0.0443142466,
0.0462811813,
0.0420689583,
-0.022904506,
0.0339837633,
0.0175746623,
-0.0785790831,
0.0664596111,
-0.1102538034,
-0.0820329338,
-0.0326171778,
0.0258125328,
0.018073326,
0.0648747161,
-0.0656757429,
-0.0087977117,
-0.0336448029,
0.0278673843,
0.0058734915,
-0.032662373,
-0.0173439253,
0.0013606807,
0.0408444814,
-0.0029116157,
0.0380851179,
-0.0519851632,
-0.0229301546,
-0.0309753269,
0.0158970468,
-0.0044725174,
-0.0023179101,
-0.0192927122,
0.0114107784,
0.0133300768,
0.045625478,
-0.0062523079,
-0.0045407834,
0.0011498072,
-0.0039520203,
0.0148545019,
-0.047610648,
0.0579400547,
-0.0024812461,
-0.0277249869,
0.0353355482,
0.0040418915,
-0.0151745658,
-0.0214564893,
-0.0227844976,
0.0065861065,
0.0151062105,
-0.0252773706,
-0.0399466194,
0.0551255979,
0.043119818,
0.0043843137,
-0.0613533445,
0.0050342893,
0.00350465,
-0.1086944044,
-0.0199382547,
-0.1100692675,
0.0113064488,
0.0128562814,
0.0451925993,
0.079112336,
0.0028105215,
0.0128323874,
0.0117384773,
0.0187099464,
0.0140326926,
0.0139982952,
0.0221245866,
-0.000275557,
-0.0067236093,
0.0033696713,
0.0087144859,
0.0118844649,
-0.019024387,
-0.0217965785,
0.0180072282,
0.0040839193,
0.0177827068,
0.021348834,
0.0382605493,
0.0003244169,
0.0256551858,
0.0242386404,
0.0431342237,
0.0269734338,
-0.0278201569,
-0.0003233907,
0.0044075823,
0.0007516627,
-0.0024553132,
-0.0512146764,
0.0643071756,
0.0149012096,
0.026253324,
-0.0092174122,
0.0072000185,
-0.0259685945,
-0.032928858,
0.0270175803,
-0.0200178623,
0.01051105,
0.0130145522,
0.065728046,
-0.0057606967,
0.0329337344,
-0.036373239,
0.0243723989,
0.1070137098,
0.0453560166,
-0.0381734744,
-0.060722556,
0.0008516758,
-0.023645727,
-0.0071524414,
-0.018105546,
-0.0174839161,
0.004189983,
0.0261383932,
0.0084014246,
0.0504775308,
0.0346427225,
-0.0174197927,
-0.007983339,
0.0626300052,
-0.0170350354,
0.0196018498,
-0.0009772489,
0.0240896754,
-0.0012009204,
0.0053278585,
-0.032933902,
0.0540522523,
0.0087725772,
0.0320603512,
0.0385979041,
0.0273240115,
0.0443756059,
-0.028375024,
0.0226859339,
0.0330632813,
0.0335491002,
0.0407856777,
-0.0063309837,
-0.0205739178,
-0.0219430383,
0.0343075618,
0.0075373645,
0.0164370257,
-0.0020585821,
-0.0093563078,
0.0503555648,
0.0298407171,
-0.0167586207,
0.0398163944,
0.0099190585,
0.0117533458,
0.0309675708,
-0.0019829045,
-0.0327996202,
-0.0129247298,
-0.093181394,
-0.063201353,
0.0042448808,
0.0411519818,
-0.0098032542,
0.0144935902,
-0.0106150936,
0.0003332611,
-0.017190624,
-0.0149690239,
0.0040439777,
-0.0395936891,
0.0117465034,
0.031362839,
0.0295833182,
0.0516182221,
0.0768427625,
-0.0344517566,
-0.0073255775,
0.0049188714,
-0.0107290978,
-0.0109355776,
-0.004770102,
0.0359083638,
0.0183033291,
-0.0408124179,
-0.0576653741,
0.0201521646,
-0.0593407862,
0.0513126142,
0.0538810864,
-0.0561354682,
0.0442417786,
-0.0198275372,
-0.0324980952,
-0.0005992777,
0.0041307309,
-0.0436117202,
-0.0366595164,
-0.0268352237,
-0.0057436074,
0.0164271854,
0.0047039911,
0.0870365053,
0.0474104695,
-0.0380309112,
0.0231445003,
0.0146272071,
-0.0709163249,
0.0353528708,
-0.0082805296,
-0.0646526515,
0.0440716557,
0.0365077145,
0.0304232035,
0.0260982104,
0.0206761174,
0.0350445136,
-0.0031405201,
0.0333038121,
-0.0443926528,
-0.0253850687,
-0.0202980638,
0.0088141654,
-0.0278717764,
-0.0008339633,
0.0142686153,
-0.0106748557,
0.0541646369,
-0.0492268428,
-0.0387639366,
-0.033620663,
-0.0039687157,
-0.0397794843,
0.016398862,
0.0263905805,
-0.0226771981,
0.0541323163,
-0.0235278811,
0.0155790299,
-0.050184764,
-0.0311658606,
-0.0071353782,
0.0010267377,
-0.0069848555,
-0.020310441,
-0.0230530817,
-0.0145720476,
-0.0199515298,
-0.0261715055,
0.029338805,
0.028910419,
-0.010784301,
0.0583028346,
0.0390559733,
0.0320392065,
0.029025007,
0.0020263363,
0.0455231294,
0.0520497188,
0.0339496918,
-0.0750138536,
-0.0184437707,
0.0366037376,
0.039259728,
0.0351322964,
-0.0091456147,
-0.0181763098,
-0.0319512077,
0.0417392105,
-0.0308540594,
-0.0417230912,
-0.0220492091,
0.0125988619,
-0.0153407184,
-0.0445051081,
-0.0077936631,
0.0515288189,
0.0177927911,
-0.0386064276,
0.0171296652,
0.0093372595,
-0.0532112382,
-0.0091188634,
0.0475438572,
-0.0573012307,
0.0179046448,
0.0022144956,
0.0024958001,
-0.0103987614,
-0.0724827796,
-0.0186117627,
0.0077638743,
0.0220736917,
-0.0215429775,
-0.0536217503,
-0.0547094606,
-0.0856293663,
0.0370563157,
-0.0014869391,
-0.0587419569,
-0.0234412532,
-0.0383591317,
0.0130998725,
-0.0163877811,
-0.0521782525,
-0.0198545605,
-0.0559697263,
-0.0190245491,
-0.0053404677,
0.0046216883,
0.0533340052,
-0.0136176003,
0.0572025366,
-0.0252336785,
-0.0182553306,
-0.0115048755,
-0.0489893295,
0.0465547144,
-0.0246506799,
-0.0197925717,
-0.0792565346,
0.0018275791,
0.0123850582,
-0.0367466137,
0.0384360962,
0.103283532,
0.0024755662,
-0.0188472923,
-0.067932561,
-0.0097029367,
0.0545709692,
0.0062445779,
0.047787115,
0.008791944,
-0.0143166687,
0.0182037111,
0.0369646326,
-0.0362227224,
-0.0181355532,
-0.00419837,
-0.0680766031,
-0.093879737,
-0.0547526069,
-0.0029523866,
0.0318231583,
-0.0236470997,
0.0251657311,
-0.0372761562,
0.0868916735,
-0.0059447112,
-0.0439530686,
-0.0292205401,
0.0493896976,
-0.0229016207,
-0.0071058795,
-0.0028741967,
0.0359051824,
0.0560839474,
-0.0203415602,
0.0015665689,
-0.0104995733,
-0.0060087726,
0.0048136697,
-0.0130978459,
0.0252144858,
-0.0261523295,
0.0219567772,
0.0243271552,
-0.0114783999,
0.0589296035,
-0.0660564527,
-0.0606101155,
-0.0464959331,
-0.0503064841,
0.0002285999,
-0.0049319901,
-9.3e-7,
0.0253609791,
-0.0272025391,
0.013314629,
-0.0535780638,
0.0134682795,
0.0240794886,
-0.0017951925,
0.0384149998,
0.0091419471,
-0.0145387398,
-0.0525732227,
0.0148938512,
-0.0058929054,
-0.0048369225,
-0.0016748683,
0.0137794688,
-0.0466542393,
0.0079280715,
-0.0116527826,
0.040789023,
0.00176791,
-0.0254946072,
-0.0416434221,
0.0347014405,
0.0342943929,
0.0161728244,
0.0366581045,
-0.026668245,
0.0312347263,
-0.0242739636,
-0.0128501179,
0.0095568961,
-0.0239640269,
-0.0186809879,
-0.0317992903,
-0.0348705128,
0.0167605523,
0.0094123166,
-0.037254557,
0.0297813602,
-0.0175104309,
0.0576105118,
0.0367044285,
0.014210009,
0.0261235442,
-0.0158536639,
-0.0130321393,
0.0237770081,
0.0468803644,
-0.0489318706,
0.026202878,
0.0071058511,
-0.0119028967,
-0.0223448034,
-0.0140206665,
0.0450337157,
0.0107285054,
0.0483515933,
0.049535796,
-0.0727177113,
-0.0239754636,
-0.0071153347,
0.0439438447,
-0.0094480123,
-0.0364972614,
-0.016211655,
-0.0266387016,
-0.0238885079,
0.0264402255,
-0.0444902591,
-0.0343000144,
0.004687143,
-0.021307392,
0.0108651482,
0.060713537,
-0.0463625826,
-0.02386331,
0.0806697607,
-0.1171154156,
-0.0140845207,
0.0420779102,
-6.798138031e-33,
-0.0224411935,
-0.0370566286,
0.0112918289,
0.0199348386,
-0.0069075455,
0.0447073393,
-0.0445385501,
-0.0662978962,
-0.016461961,
0.0366607681,
0.004649933,
-0.0241268519,
0.0021760704,
-0.0157527365,
0.0049394462,
0.0137738306,
0.0260880049,
0.0178509764,
0.0112831853,
0.0052027265,
0.0252364688,
0.0626674592,
0.0279025696,
-0.0526387207,
-0.0163000338,
-0.0179489348,
0.0035264357,
0.0069796727,
0.0410218202,
0.0170625001,
-0.0168391764,
-0.0004097121,
0.0202291608,
-0.0257034227,
0.0346772298,
0.0841361359,
-0.0965162143,
-0.0530214012,
0.0417481884,
-0.0560675003,
-0.0070914333,
-0.0344660357,
0.0606030002,
0.0331575274,
0.0363167711,
0.0184483174,
0.0278190039,
-0.0416158885,
-0.0215186942,
-0.049331367,
-0.011504638,
0.0131440004,
-0.0157555211,
0.0423019864,
0.016935939,
0.0242162701,
0.0086359372,
0.0176190604,
0.012907696,
-0.0112933265,
0.0071087577,
0.0495154969,
0.0261483118,
-0.0012291794,
-0.0060998434,
0.018507231,
-0.020239396,
-0.0969630554,
0.0128796138,
0.0892442986,
-0.0543664917,
0.0642508119,
-0.014646682,
0.0167193748,
-0.0381750278,
-0.0304375384,
-0.1223852485,
0.0687851384,
0.0106700407,
0.0310114101,
-0.0270948485,
-0.0102300206,
0.0081302589,
0.0093110995,
0.024736125,
-0.0077740448,
-0.0121659497,
-0.049824629,
-0.0085738041,
0.006235891,
-0.0362579077,
0.0681610554,
-0.0604524948,
0.0320015624,
-0.0364261791,
-0.0098046558,
0.0293704569,
-0.0005112168,
-0.0382977314,
-0.0344529822,
-0.0567924976,
-0.0084426841,
-0.0409219675,
0.0314322226,
0.035830982,
0.0225788411,
0.0157664083,
-0.0262099002,
-0.0482487567,
-0.0018096328,
0.0182220452,
0.0508294292,
-0.0332467556,
0.0092570726,
0.0188118108,
0.0098150996,
0.0294469241,
0.0178239886,
0.037745133,
0.0579107367,
0.0115843406,
-0.0298565477,
-0.0194739979,
0.0281077418,
-0.011072089,
-0.028725449,
-0.0379523113,
0.0599950738,
-0.004798071,
-0.0671586096,
-0.0051757735,
-0.0298226494,
2.916e-7,
0.0792203546,
0.0544012263,
0.0284192674,
0.0142290657,
0.0136484979,
-0.0187881812,
-0.0004587122,
0.0015149928,
0.0003189965,
-0.0205119662,
0.0010783131,
-0.0075436551,
-0.0304562412,
0.0864619985,
-0.0673521534,
-0.0197835043,
-0.1055445299,
-0.0242359713,
-0.0820367634,
0.00614816,
0.0484835021,
0.0180197004,
0.0356066152,
0.0129828872,
-0.024209056,
0.030720206,
-0.0215610918,
-0.0241084173,
-0.0467615798,
0.0262586586,
-0.0230917837,
0.0471479706,
-0.0183579791,
0.0019336299,
-0.0368265994,
-0.0269712117,
-0.0214385074,
0.0172160603,
0.0130142663,
0.0750842914,
0.0437397137,
-0.0669500604,
0.0258300435,
-0.0597027577,
0.0772310495,
-0.0294638313,
-0.0127280513,
0.0205201209,
-0.0406200886,
0.0096876407,
-0.0246149004,
-0.0179542452,
-0.0166499019,
0.0024125664,
-0.0335444845,
-0.0214475822,
-0.0330940858,
-0.0129100317,
0.012731377,
0.0260142181,
0.0271737222,
-0.0307133961,
-0.0048802937,
-0.0479401909,
-0.0468115397,
-0.0339876339,
0.0449525453,
2.435034252e-34,
-0.0183408465,
0.0338818394,
-0.0255360287,
0.0195053946,
0.0135635426,
-0.0247891508,
-0.0471942872,
0.0022430853,
-0.0334736742,
-0.0269781444,
0.0019816167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00176v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00176v5 | ChipNeMo: Domain-Adapted LLMs for Chip Design | 2023-10-31T22:35:58 | 2024-04-04T20:18:57 | Mingjie Liu, Teodor-Dumitru Ene, Robert Kirby, Chris Cheng, Nathaniel Pinckney, Rongjian Liang, Jonah Alben, Himyanshu Anand, Sanmitra Banerjee, Ismet Bayraktaroglu, Bonita Bhaskaran, Bryan Catanzaro, Arjun Chaudhuri, Sharon Clay, Bill Dally, Laura Dang, Parikshit Deshpande, Siddhanth Dhodhi, Sameer Halepete, Eric Hill, Jiashang Hu, Sumit Jain, Ankit Jindal, Brucek Khailany, George Kokai, Kishor Kunal, Xiaowei Li, Charley Lind, Hao Liu, Stuart Oberman, Sujeet Omar, Ghasem Pasandi, Sreedhar Pratty, Jonathan Raiman, Ambar Sarkar, Zhengjiang Shao, Hanfei Sun, Pratik P Suthar, Varun Tej, Walker Turner, Kaizhe Xu, Haoxing Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChipNeMo aims to explore the applications of large language models (LLMs) for
industrial chip design. Instead of directly deploying off-the-shelf commercial
or open-source LLMs, we instead adopt the following domain adaptation
techniques: domain-adaptive tokenization, domain-adaptive continued
pretraining, model alignment with domain-specific instructions, and
domain-adapted retrieval models. We evaluate these methods on three selected
LLM applications for chip design: an engineering assistant chatbot, EDA script
generation, and bug summarization and analysis. Our evaluations demonstrate
that domain-adaptive pretraining of language models, can lead to superior
performance in domain related downstream tasks compared to their base LLaMA2
counterparts, without degradations in generic capabilities. In particular, our
largest model, ChipNeMo-70B, outperforms the highly capable GPT-4 on two of our
use cases, namely engineering assistant chatbot and EDA scripts generation,
while exhibiting competitive performance on bug summarization and analysis.
These results underscore the potential of domain-specific customization for
enhancing the effectiveness of large language models in specialized
applications. | [
0.0257144626,
0.0275318455,
-0.0240359865,
0.0141037069,
-0.0080325911,
0.0207342803,
0.0310067423,
-0.0134687582,
0.0219381042,
-0.0336222723,
-0.0521025583,
0.0050128894,
-0.0485957302,
0.0459503345,
0.0284394901,
0.0020299156,
0.0462579466,
-0.0187489819,
-0.0052726804,
0.0059728469,
-0.010269016,
-0.0000176253,
0.006820071,
0.0849969238,
0.0029148362,
-0.019975869,
-0.0301450565,
0.0273643509,
0.0188248828,
0.0047865491,
0.0302313324,
0.0407945774,
0.0116819534,
0.0092622377,
0.0000021943,
-0.0280802026,
-0.0209077522,
0.0155420592,
-0.0150182666,
0.0131368507,
0.0218657646,
-0.0282209292,
-0.0564998761,
0.0236700326,
0.0044023767,
-0.0111299809,
0.0799943805,
0.0394120738,
0.090942733,
0.0662596226,
0.0103311362,
-0.0301705822,
0.028167991,
-0.023083603,
-0.0273240972,
-0.045858454,
-0.0024686903,
0.0120064598,
0.0568237826,
0.0174546819,
0.0174606889,
0.0370681919,
0.0081810905,
-0.0105883628,
-0.0003579532,
0.0154601028,
-0.0232308339,
0.017894851,
0.0037727763,
0.0507689305,
-0.0210801475,
-0.0141073093,
-0.0071251467,
-0.0130486321,
-0.0275146794,
-0.0165144466,
-0.0303051136,
0.0064929225,
0.0015694321,
-0.0189197939,
-0.0069448627,
-0.0469801351,
0.0085808123,
-0.0461827517,
-0.0231260341,
0.0614416562,
0.0167947039,
0.0056779045,
-0.0504044779,
-0.0223549698,
-0.0239382107,
-0.0511930883,
-0.0101260496,
0.0539797284,
-0.0333562605,
0.0072839297,
-0.0519048274,
-0.0147527652,
0.0023357659,
-0.0492219776,
0.0188099891,
0.0666877925,
-0.0203169491,
0.00260318,
-0.0447413251,
0.0503301471,
-0.0251047928,
0.0480972007,
-0.0833843425,
-0.0110518243,
-0.0392225012,
-0.0308363941,
-0.0689112693,
0.0619514845,
-0.0360545851,
-0.0147859976,
-0.0502413511,
0.0660583675,
0.0042035286,
0.0120216897,
0.0226396676,
-0.0259546582,
-0.0333896615,
-0.0337964222,
-0.0144150006,
0.0097033875,
-0.0079329321,
-0.0053077568,
0.0143438997,
-0.0648097694,
-0.0364231914,
-0.0029442809,
-0.0431691445,
-0.0040036142,
-0.009062591,
0.155328244,
-0.0203038175,
-0.020810727,
-0.0394438468,
0.0034682727,
0.0110007226,
-0.0534017608,
0.0018734509,
-0.0324038267,
0.0070875636,
0.0064710486,
0.0068525337,
-0.0540342629,
0.0128965983,
0.0259146653,
0.000169006,
0.0429159999,
-0.0036434298,
0.009602081,
0.0389517993,
-0.0093793971,
0.0058327136,
0.0716726407,
0.0441983007,
0.008841536,
0.0187704749,
-0.0115910703,
-0.0229310654,
0.0446860306,
-0.0069088265,
-0.0171687976,
0.0171719044,
0.015121581,
0.0490160957,
0.0064090397,
0.0213905238,
-0.0024281833,
0.018802993,
0.0092873061,
0.015980456,
0.037764363,
0.0179390721,
0.0114423372,
0.0479523055,
0.0069836788,
-0.0112481741,
-0.026965918,
-0.0512091964,
0.0391622558,
-0.007415547,
0.0083110984,
0.0432616696,
0.0352894738,
-0.0320127532,
-0.0334981419,
-0.0146619845,
-0.0193059519,
-0.0390711688,
-0.0200197417,
0.0396001302,
-0.0231526308,
-0.0570834279,
0.0722561628,
0.0125020808,
-0.054924719,
-0.0957872868,
-0.0672712475,
-0.0047531608,
0.0663846433,
0.0456774049,
-0.0573930293,
-0.0807778612,
0.0390587561,
-0.0016535504,
0.0204496309,
0.044841446,
0.0070571676,
-0.0090443753,
-0.0225471742,
-0.0289551727,
-0.0390334688,
0.0131772868,
0.0255393833,
0.0016794396,
-0.0030281981,
0.0114826569,
-0.0187173206,
-0.0480622202,
0.0271224268,
-0.0363906361,
-0.0141757419,
-0.0004688654,
-0.0048973761,
0.0151719078,
0.0060414434,
-0.0411566645,
0.0211096182,
0.0351968184,
-0.0461363979,
0.0045129731,
0.0033492211,
-0.0438375995,
-0.0112688383,
0.0294212215,
-0.0089319395,
0.0002721203,
0.0079875663,
-0.0419614837,
-0.0358097181,
0.0319119729,
-0.04558165,
0.0253505595,
0.0168638248,
0.0534461103,
-0.0305313338,
-0.0035798787,
-0.0625452995,
0.0288215242,
0.0290711988,
-0.0364680775,
-0.0228447039,
0.0471955836,
0.0405400544,
-0.0310033131,
-0.022969218,
0.0292791612,
0.0100885378,
0.0346403308,
0.0219667982,
0.0049581961,
-0.0178086087,
-0.0321328305,
-0.0803837404,
0.0076948139,
0.0014245148,
0.0261931345,
0.0122515168,
0.0094853137,
-0.0072387992,
-0.0122121247,
-0.0088974116,
-0.0057094679,
-0.0148637025,
-0.0015025017,
0.0163936671,
0.0131256105,
-0.0616307147,
-0.0286284536,
-0.0169913881,
-0.0135557409,
0.0273454878,
-0.0082590831,
-0.0278756376,
-0.1170412824,
0.106012255,
-0.0014376739,
0.035969045,
-0.0054613822,
-0.0439893194,
0.0122185154,
0.0081861066,
0.0489942543,
0.0561429299,
-0.0192808937,
0.0189497359,
0.0509527661,
0.0014995089,
-0.0544658303,
0.0157401953,
0.0063705756,
-0.0395240113,
0.0230247378,
-0.0001157723,
0.0302821416,
0.0700480267,
-0.0328389332,
-0.0187085848,
-0.052010987,
0.0117005557,
0.0267396308,
0.019501714,
0.0304165371,
-0.0223522279,
0.0135924071,
0.0370517373,
-0.022046214,
-0.0719162226,
0.0703750029,
-0.0415306352,
0.0227078646,
-0.0418352559,
-0.0205539223,
-0.0399898514,
0.0282055344,
0.0024473961,
0.0302325226,
0.0289559606,
-0.0130829243,
-0.0408431888,
0.0567548722,
-0.0156169301,
-0.0074928752,
0.0411493033,
-0.043849349,
0.047801204,
-0.0275123361,
-0.040937975,
-0.0394753627,
0.0318244286,
-0.0463678055,
0.0354965143,
0.029532006,
-0.0120428093,
-0.0642460063,
0.0591798425,
0.0222996492,
0.0165675394,
0.0235017333,
-0.0126599111,
-0.0224926211,
-0.0228050109,
0.0082775243,
0.0176234115,
-0.0138775604,
0.0014243704,
0.0167033803,
0.0331908949,
0.0320881978,
-0.0188432112,
-0.0621058419,
-0.0163616501,
0.0378185883,
-0.0287222378,
-0.0315632224,
0.0035339019,
0.0628168806,
-0.0404822417,
-0.0182274804,
0.0674663708,
0.0099894302,
-0.0323760323,
0.0141407019,
0.0096880002,
0.0543387681,
0.0373431146,
0.0664793923,
-0.0873228461,
-0.0480907187,
0.0076751155,
0.005521345,
0.0024681231,
0.013454021,
-0.0235866867,
-0.1362818629,
0.0395094715,
0.0061151311,
-0.0530073978,
-0.0615414381,
-0.0211760364,
-0.0131317209,
0.0323072374,
0.0196850374,
0.017851064,
-0.0102079455,
-0.0172312576,
0.0234472267,
-0.052964665,
-0.0742570311,
0.0206711311,
0.0081043318,
0.0496795028,
0.1090132743,
-0.02715897,
0.0404021703,
0.0044356608,
0.0975854769,
0.0155541515,
0.0466370098,
-0.015120904,
0.0113653149,
-0.0142359482,
-0.0392833054,
0.0021614733,
-0.008827026,
-0.0311262347,
-0.0028400307,
-0.0036060326,
0.0614724718,
-0.0252529345,
0.0177726857,
-0.0477610752,
-0.0327879228,
-0.0153772607,
-0.0038781813,
0.019358132,
-0.0296804514,
-0.0582827777,
-0.0493645519,
-0.0232411921,
-0.0366706848,
-0.0128441639,
0.0050560595,
-0.0592781529,
-0.010010819,
-0.0244835299,
-0.0049071312,
-0.0264672041,
0.0157085247,
0.0247217156,
-0.0552512109,
0.034268342,
0.0130477929,
-0.0690925866,
0.0120553859,
-0.027947098,
0.0200584829,
-0.0895037577,
-0.0208687522,
0.0559281074,
-0.0087012183,
-0.0323191173,
0.0117983967,
-0.0533234216,
-0.0821108073,
-0.0037904042,
0.0644632429,
0.0184128247,
0.0254569072,
-0.0093115186,
-0.0545102693,
-0.0032694947,
0.0639334992,
-0.0419497825,
0.0369329192,
0.0058226069,
0.0164185707,
-0.0273255669,
-0.0122672757,
-0.0590432771,
0.0605542623,
0.0296033528,
0.0133839715,
0.0287777875,
-0.0650855601,
0.0023245665,
0.0408224463,
-0.017783707,
0.0280206259,
0.0139344959,
-0.0229816232,
0.068387121,
-0.0151640605,
0.0052458732,
-0.0476393886,
0.005990366,
-0.0416015647,
-0.0746555254,
0.0499827042,
-0.0342913345,
-0.031733606,
0.0436265059,
-0.0269540548,
0.0418538712,
-0.04287678,
0.0497283898,
0.0229341295,
0.0154863885,
-0.0226561148,
0.0016652655,
-0.0063273488,
0.0719665438,
-0.0410155281,
0.0274779033,
0.0156520288,
0.0457072966,
-0.0262992047,
0.0687542707,
-0.0410218164,
-0.0782451853,
-0.0548806563,
0.0194481276,
0.0703338534,
0.030675251,
0.0450165942,
0.0003078818,
0.0152902203,
-0.0239676647,
0.0463835821,
0.0152511606,
-0.0071664685,
0.020818552,
0.0037070492,
0.0070067272,
-0.0546393432,
0.0585837103,
-0.0198991578,
0.0309385192,
-0.0453712493,
-0.0148067661,
-0.0339131095,
-0.016408762,
0.0649269372,
-0.0208030138,
-0.0012501716,
-0.0472615957,
-0.0438090786,
-0.0439974554,
-0.0104374597,
0.0160319638,
-0.0002527,
-0.0228633061,
0.0261173379,
0.090496704,
0.030543942,
-0.039276991,
0.0103548244,
-0.0205756612,
-0.0369745158,
-0.0022297869,
0.0048405337,
-6.055976081e-33,
-0.0717913359,
-0.0115229087,
0.0398915634,
0.0210110024,
-0.000731888,
-0.0177731402,
-0.0461253412,
0.0027041812,
0.014415429,
-0.0228702333,
0.0001690189,
-0.0110888705,
0.0007328158,
-0.0169167444,
0.0212614983,
0.0090251984,
0.0519346483,
0.0133509561,
-0.042675972,
0.0488164052,
-0.0117238844,
0.0250613093,
0.0175110213,
-0.0680868551,
0.0040972382,
-0.0070794239,
0.030151058,
-0.0257509444,
0.030158652,
0.0474893078,
-0.0186760612,
0.0356200486,
-0.004798315,
-0.0159974247,
-0.012084594,
-0.006916062,
-0.0236585569,
-0.0187915619,
0.0083530014,
0.0190001223,
0.0604614913,
-0.0902687311,
0.0299404934,
0.0092813568,
-0.0697015077,
0.0147997281,
0.0313828662,
-0.0150736514,
0.0076747639,
0.022542607,
-0.093408145,
0.0194071811,
0.000126213,
-0.0013370425,
-0.0007884576,
-0.0112266876,
0.0212284811,
0.0221766327,
-0.0263201557,
0.0204710197,
0.0367801301,
0.0523065217,
0.1006811038,
0.0024047154,
-0.0072220666,
0.0362221412,
0.0367357135,
0.0466854237,
0.0144046899,
0.0128137236,
0.0071200654,
0.0448177382,
-0.0130246282,
0.0179198924,
0.0073592309,
0.0026515389,
-0.0744134039,
0.0614502728,
-0.0203274004,
0.0173900705,
0.0399711281,
0.0320945084,
-0.0258785225,
0.0022697097,
-0.0038514936,
0.0888057202,
-0.017642701,
-0.0496536307,
0.0243557543,
0.0164549481,
-0.0205133129,
-0.028166052,
0.0338488743,
-0.0457550362,
0.0197074395,
-0.0257766098,
-0.0310369339,
-0.0001481512,
-0.0184711777,
0.0300940238,
-0.0277697239,
-0.0694075525,
-0.0023637798,
0.0079079438,
0.0548624545,
-0.0232317504,
-0.0222863145,
0.0322162993,
-0.081226863,
0.0371884219,
-0.0431211889,
-0.0146932248,
-0.0296543743,
0.035690695,
-0.0080571072,
0.009564748,
-0.0007400617,
0.0327853188,
-0.0217235554,
-0.0419024751,
-0.0233904868,
0.0455391034,
0.0015943996,
0.0249522515,
-0.0340679698,
0.0284723062,
-0.0325838067,
0.0764903203,
-0.0016251334,
-0.0645660833,
-0.0461635254,
-0.0005704487,
2.978e-7,
0.028689092,
0.0421596691,
0.0343750492,
0.0415274017,
0.0150642637,
0.0383650325,
-0.0018160484,
0.0340882279,
0.0318492055,
0.0611722581,
-0.0204314049,
0.032732442,
0.0202639662,
-0.0148356706,
-0.0425904691,
0.0047854679,
0.0196828507,
0.0337561481,
-0.0545682237,
0.008843747,
0.0467071421,
0.0769539401,
-0.0404909924,
-0.0081603825,
-0.0110359816,
-0.0264551491,
0.0326530822,
-0.0177856684,
0.0109251523,
0.0533934347,
-0.0473951101,
0.0560924187,
-0.0489950068,
0.0117416177,
0.0103089595,
-0.0009245899,
0.0110693099,
0.0626183152,
-0.0114626093,
-0.0050827079,
0.0570701584,
0.0191460699,
-0.0140592698,
-0.0354147106,
0.0146868872,
-0.061403174,
-0.0264097434,
-0.0349642225,
0.0126558729,
-0.0171165038,
-0.0183264539,
-0.003099272,
0.0294822939,
0.0137350447,
0.0078318389,
-0.017212145,
0.0128492629,
-0.0650356337,
-0.0390217267,
0.0036799598,
-0.0383930542,
-0.0553664677,
-0.0398849174,
-0.0186934825,
0.0333530381,
-0.0237214733,
0.0156178325,
2.813438511e-34,
0.0280307345,
-0.0185077973,
0.0129235853,
0.1054497436,
0.0281338803,
-0.0191364046,
0.0331814401,
0.023841314,
-0.010589662,
-0.0609755516,
-0.0216415413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00172v1 | Robust Safety Classifier for Large Language Models: Adversarial Prompt Shield | 2023-10-31T22:22:10 | 2023-10-31T22:22:10 | Jinhwa Kim, Ali Derakhshan, Ian G. Harris | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models' safety remains a critical concern due to their
vulnerability to adversarial attacks, which can prompt these systems to produce
harmful responses. In the heart of these systems lies a safety classifier, a
computational model trained to discern and mitigate potentially harmful,
offensive, or unethical outputs. However, contemporary safety classifiers,
despite their potential, often fail when exposed to inputs infused with
adversarial noise. In response, our study introduces the Adversarial Prompt
Shield (APS), a lightweight model that excels in detection accuracy and
demonstrates resilience against adversarial prompts. Additionally, we propose
novel strategies for autonomously generating adversarial training datasets,
named Bot Adversarial Noisy Dialogue (BAND) datasets. These datasets are
designed to fortify the safety classifier's robustness, and we investigate the
consequences of incorporating adversarial examples into the training process.
Through evaluations involving Large Language Models, we demonstrate that our
classifier has the potential to decrease the attack success rate resulting from
adversarial attacks by up to 60%. This advancement paves the way for the next
generation of more reliable and resilient conversational agents. | [
0.0391207486,
0.0586717352,
-0.0080177896,
0.0216735676,
0.005999784,
0.0082794204,
0.0197762065,
0.0053258855,
0.0535839275,
-0.0514767468,
-0.0272826441,
-0.021542564,
-0.0196808167,
0.030614851,
0.042881947,
-0.0364995264,
0.0559636205,
-0.0308098178,
0.0397197604,
-0.0141127734,
0.0249312483,
-0.023979174,
-0.0213201065,
0.0506367609,
-0.018158339,
-0.0239870548,
-0.0153343584,
0.0090748603,
0.0221738219,
-0.0259470847,
0.0396727845,
0.0301136523,
0.0063000009,
0.0917033106,
0.0000018647,
-0.0384025238,
0.0093288776,
0.0023484982,
-0.0391466543,
-0.0168858245,
0.036944434,
-0.0162334703,
-0.0398233086,
0.0405420065,
-0.0173045453,
-0.0189781226,
0.0495217703,
0.0542311929,
0.060311269,
0.1094880626,
-0.0032697413,
-0.0017957996,
0.0659857541,
-0.0127978986,
-0.0225387532,
-0.0694085807,
0.0195181742,
-0.031217685,
-0.0482500121,
0.0261307675,
-0.0064922655,
0.0040222607,
0.012231552,
-0.0280746371,
-0.0415609665,
0.0117496997,
-0.0325938649,
-0.02958709,
-0.0165235661,
0.07909251,
-0.0394758023,
-0.0176465511,
-0.0013791136,
0.0051500332,
0.0320436545,
-0.0257860925,
-0.0234523378,
0.0270992275,
0.000643865,
-0.0186187588,
-0.0219290406,
-0.0009168947,
0.0471382625,
0.0464854017,
0.0455700308,
0.0036162655,
0.009806416,
-0.0088770231,
0.0265724547,
-0.0327741057,
-0.0151697686,
-0.0482174158,
0.0080060475,
0.0043328074,
-0.0569388829,
0.0041072746,
-0.0915910378,
-0.0429988913,
0.0349496119,
-0.03034628,
-0.001496953,
0.0116730053,
-0.0372628756,
0.0235718936,
0.0013574007,
0.0191628616,
-0.0004591245,
0.056596946,
0.0115931779,
0.0034624401,
0.0038634101,
-0.0046426905,
-0.0298794154,
0.0048869518,
-0.0032457828,
0.0167856421,
-0.0358491614,
0.0347279795,
-0.0469782874,
0.0500887074,
-0.0408709124,
0.0161149669,
-0.0342039987,
-0.0000143618,
0.0117255384,
-0.0443960316,
-0.0171678942,
0.0027391971,
0.0201507583,
-0.0932851732,
-0.0335599631,
0.0364528671,
-0.0352946147,
-0.0343625546,
0.0056775715,
0.1139730066,
0.0205243602,
-0.0310033951,
-0.0080644656,
-0.0162049197,
-0.0299534313,
-0.0420260057,
0.0030355772,
-0.016439721,
-0.0010109441,
-0.0189243611,
-0.0245516282,
-0.0820044652,
0.0178280938,
-0.0014023313,
-0.0004296155,
0.0750542283,
0.003719171,
-0.0265358593,
0.01541836,
0.0372883566,
-0.043709252,
0.0543982722,
0.0213152338,
0.0409070514,
0.0661089122,
0.0073571722,
0.0250992663,
0.0309289135,
0.0096858852,
0.006726454,
-0.0168148242,
0.0181484893,
0.0130613754,
-0.0062885671,
-0.0368478186,
0.049991481,
-0.0092843296,
-0.0668107644,
0.1006337106,
0.0005969707,
-0.0820911527,
0.0155157773,
0.0076330821,
0.0107034687,
0.0075981743,
-0.036620643,
-0.0599096529,
-0.0160314515,
-0.0767565966,
-0.0552344248,
-0.0074904235,
0.0145505564,
-0.0452333614,
-0.0322208181,
-0.002362018,
-0.0262751691,
0.0548665822,
0.0201834738,
0.0211503636,
0.0231096838,
-0.043094825,
0.0028898062,
0.0150427008,
-0.033908315,
-0.0481508933,
-0.064013496,
0.0217106417,
0.0253750179,
0.0363744274,
-0.0404745936,
0.0035863689,
-0.0724304914,
0.0226930175,
0.0239330083,
0.0456478745,
-0.0098363739,
0.0612870492,
-0.0412496254,
-0.0178200118,
-0.0045840391,
-0.0042316569,
0.0291821677,
0.0513831601,
0.0174813922,
-0.0060681985,
0.0277341027,
-0.044731535,
0.0434988216,
0.006004707,
-0.0697183982,
0.0253587551,
0.0154561894,
0.0610871278,
0.0046204492,
-0.0214985181,
0.0040312293,
0.034680631,
-0.0073377877,
-0.015852008,
-0.0173424743,
-0.0212487001,
-0.0179824233,
0.0348237716,
0.0150479609,
-0.0382821374,
0.0626388937,
-0.0443089157,
0.0223491602,
0.0250724591,
-0.0256264973,
-0.050090868,
-0.0281471275,
0.0025064247,
-0.012897986,
0.045909252,
-0.0134451715,
0.053527344,
0.0002541091,
-0.0236668251,
-0.0093909046,
0.0379037224,
0.0151225626,
-0.0336452797,
-0.0368387178,
0.0107737528,
-0.0539042838,
0.0381098352,
0.0267076381,
0.012923697,
-0.0332332104,
0.0061349003,
-0.0343160592,
-0.0082969693,
-0.0251445454,
-0.0195510425,
0.0026482425,
-0.022260556,
-0.0031036658,
-0.0180371981,
-0.0155758336,
0.0254219919,
0.0026226386,
0.0218342207,
-0.0060875812,
-0.0322303176,
-0.0386281833,
-0.0333505273,
0.0188070443,
0.0037993439,
0.0382986218,
-0.0046717846,
-0.0366444737,
0.0026683288,
0.0357807875,
0.0008638025,
0.0657319874,
-0.0216307864,
-0.0672531724,
0.0435824133,
0.0358131267,
-0.0218495913,
0.0819910541,
0.0592025891,
0.0418773443,
0.0586217232,
0.0420396104,
-0.0167137068,
0.0229856912,
0.0017500301,
-0.02287261,
-0.0301004425,
-0.0105238557,
-0.0043022842,
0.0365539417,
0.0376954339,
-0.0124040758,
-0.0350936316,
0.0272878632,
0.0125397658,
-0.0671606511,
-0.0378163084,
-0.0380687676,
-0.0386527069,
0.013220882,
-0.0229410361,
-0.0425863639,
0.0871674791,
-0.010984404,
0.0086855469,
0.0026968031,
-0.062649712,
0.0427544713,
0.055862423,
0.0007037442,
0.0189733971,
0.0187449381,
-0.0028713637,
-0.0443543419,
-0.0555181727,
0.0318630487,
-0.0283434931,
-0.0062819677,
-0.0220948905,
-0.009062985,
0.0146694584,
-0.0477719568,
-0.1221563369,
-0.0504310317,
-0.026275415,
0.0142046614,
-0.0309078209,
-0.0185559262,
-0.0415201858,
-0.0104402443,
0.0128716361,
0.0223194677,
-0.0238368995,
0.0072919,
-0.0184955578,
0.029139014,
0.0525538288,
-0.0246094223,
0.0193319526,
-0.0251323469,
0.0907232091,
0.0794988051,
0.0028655005,
0.0156865921,
-0.0285686851,
-0.0277477261,
0.0046809604,
0.0237555951,
0.0124921203,
0.0360985398,
0.0498805568,
-0.0171424206,
-0.0043518129,
0.0520805083,
-0.0064731315,
0.0085044047,
0.019430045,
0.015665004,
0.0302891769,
0.0135586895,
-0.0293117128,
-0.0281128883,
-0.0286852699,
0.0231918171,
0.0361878686,
-0.0256677885,
-0.0091935052,
0.00162192,
-0.0706994683,
0.0119637065,
0.0059364424,
-0.0593220033,
-0.0525670238,
-0.0129442979,
-0.0156176724,
0.0029593536,
0.0577655099,
-0.0137040699,
0.0367797948,
-0.0244433172,
0.0232346449,
-0.0072750305,
-0.0272248462,
0.0203888211,
-0.0447599776,
0.0682174936,
0.0811758488,
0.0328290313,
-0.0297795013,
0.0018188999,
0.0274590161,
0.0063691968,
-0.0300223716,
0.0239907075,
0.0827450752,
-0.0078145294,
-0.0089296503,
0.0242622644,
0.0291601345,
-0.0062652691,
-0.0223825071,
0.0563570634,
0.0133928377,
-0.009283727,
-0.0089580491,
-0.0203199871,
0.0414724164,
0.0615084991,
0.0686040223,
0.0226436146,
-0.0519529246,
-0.0167284161,
-0.0739905238,
0.0038304415,
-0.0494799539,
-0.0494003929,
0.0312918089,
-0.0029357164,
-0.073541224,
-0.0546175279,
-0.0270259287,
-0.0120013105,
0.0051871017,
0.0032486008,
-0.0216805264,
-0.0557405725,
0.0479879305,
-0.0149168512,
0.0053623607,
-0.0101196263,
0.0406737663,
-0.0262327157,
0.0117310248,
-0.0058040065,
-0.0437517352,
-0.0259861853,
0.0545604192,
-0.0664493293,
-0.0870997459,
0.0449429043,
0.0746693313,
0.017224025,
0.0150627838,
-0.0522995479,
-0.0591140054,
0.0618399829,
0.0688058287,
-0.0288027972,
-0.0222082641,
0.0891950727,
-0.005684386,
0.0134699419,
0.0252335891,
-0.0440998338,
-0.0008582931,
0.0521822572,
-0.0114123058,
-0.0360286571,
-0.0377517045,
0.0106077082,
0.0270784777,
0.0472341701,
-0.0130255679,
-0.0186220929,
0.0110403467,
-0.0022678075,
-0.0094780568,
-0.0234077666,
-0.0069014253,
0.043691732,
0.0186520852,
-0.0218036082,
0.0180960055,
-0.0064531746,
-0.0110827452,
0.0439705625,
-0.0043327929,
-0.0019707466,
0.014398179,
0.0641167685,
0.0272705015,
0.0013721378,
-0.0249424763,
0.0433064699,
0.0230293274,
-0.0046426286,
0.0030238661,
0.0422805846,
0.0013692148,
-0.0090101855,
-0.0070619388,
0.0154813649,
-0.073414579,
-0.0495608859,
-0.0097012054,
0.0391305834,
0.0039607747,
0.0114165815,
0.0062444191,
-0.02679337,
-0.0124885179,
-0.0246418919,
0.0205211025,
0.0122909229,
-0.0455653518,
0.0308105107,
0.0177705605,
-0.016944319,
0.0140444404,
0.0580831431,
0.0171705745,
0.0546839125,
0.0285993963,
-0.0319312923,
-0.0446126945,
-0.0259636324,
0.0247575734,
0.0124259414,
-0.0116178673,
0.02389469,
-0.0362716243,
-0.0725363344,
-0.0492905006,
0.0013937893,
0.0192632154,
0.0022247219,
-0.0019295341,
0.0397439748,
0.0006979414,
0.0319017544,
-0.0469547212,
0.0290301181,
0.0137835843,
-0.0523822308,
-0.009435364,
-5.408583221e-33,
0.0194022451,
-0.0239500832,
-0.0309576709,
-0.0436309129,
0.0174214579,
-0.0067190607,
-0.0131056299,
-0.0155140543,
-0.0424718075,
0.0033981903,
-0.0052177357,
0.0136246188,
-0.0061698123,
0.0137900952,
-0.0312710851,
-0.0635983348,
0.0460647568,
-0.0371853374,
-0.0168075394,
0.02356725,
0.0557185262,
-0.0098472014,
0.0147315767,
-0.108474426,
0.0534859113,
0.0095082987,
-0.0443007424,
0.0080919899,
-0.0188772567,
0.0459214039,
0.0165332779,
0.0567234494,
-0.0214151386,
0.0147027671,
0.0179204177,
0.0263475366,
-0.0229185596,
-0.0081732525,
-0.0297240447,
0.0057803108,
-0.0357825011,
-0.0541407652,
0.025166247,
-0.0344962031,
-0.0197346695,
-0.0170313213,
-0.0062886514,
-0.0201125555,
-0.0129313543,
-0.012340948,
-0.0277770367,
0.004269239,
-0.0306238066,
-0.0564246997,
-0.011229679,
0.0608512722,
0.0349147692,
0.0071957768,
-0.04969934,
0.0239783134,
-0.0092980247,
-0.0014085361,
0.0154133188,
-0.0064642327,
0.0008713991,
0.073066555,
0.0483828895,
0.0245347619,
0.0004048624,
-0.0280390829,
-0.0112106912,
0.0550683178,
0.0617670454,
0.0845135599,
0.0300617199,
-0.0738605857,
-0.103783913,
0.0206404906,
0.0460037254,
0.0219319388,
0.0173455086,
-0.0256343894,
-0.0719201639,
-0.0005321755,
-0.0113312425,
-0.069958128,
-0.02265439,
-0.0243575741,
0.024918424,
0.0254019853,
-0.0254063942,
-0.0647605807,
0.0003087029,
-0.0575909875,
0.0368814468,
0.0591977686,
-0.0057916674,
-0.050232064,
0.0151563594,
0.0209064223,
0.0135001158,
-0.0200555995,
0.0445387401,
-0.052898217,
0.0265582092,
-0.0058200392,
0.0588465855,
0.0702111349,
-0.0439652018,
-0.0015328823,
-0.0273832418,
0.0751506016,
0.0163957328,
0.049639158,
0.011127729,
0.0038981058,
-0.0092605669,
0.0088011846,
0.0179850124,
-0.0277482513,
-0.0212011524,
0.0086116772,
-0.0488666035,
0.0133106504,
-0.0249807425,
-0.0247946084,
-0.0132135125,
0.0021780606,
0.035445068,
-0.0804406554,
-0.0000125617,
-0.0625800416,
2.618e-7,
-0.0509524122,
0.038305223,
0.0103957159,
0.0440670252,
0.035093084,
0.0882777125,
-0.0126764644,
0.0782352239,
-0.0105837286,
-0.0411319882,
-0.0014186866,
0.0091349483,
0.0697159171,
0.0603551045,
-0.0533606037,
-0.0347141102,
-0.0952598751,
0.0006884222,
-0.0282538906,
0.002660963,
0.0460785478,
0.1173105389,
0.041414842,
-0.0310899261,
0.0149432225,
-0.0686251596,
0.0196003839,
-0.0462988615,
0.0193633288,
-0.0091964966,
0.0553616658,
0.0099850399,
0.0328923166,
0.0291982405,
-0.0274643078,
0.0011877174,
-0.0020600173,
0.0781779885,
-0.0063476721,
-0.0178401656,
-0.0028314672,
-0.0077012037,
0.0099689541,
-0.0300577264,
0.0630452931,
0.0050877593,
-0.0126936389,
-0.0208692998,
-0.0071343286,
-0.0236605033,
0.0367023274,
-0.050056532,
-0.0226691198,
-0.0211945195,
0.0081569646,
-0.0059575965,
0.0261123385,
-0.0420285314,
-0.0254583862,
-0.0300483834,
-0.0183231402,
-0.0658739582,
0.0054374337,
0.0141918939,
0.026770357,
-0.0163658317,
0.0299778301,
2.032371187e-34,
0.0161690786,
-0.015173235,
-0.0077069998,
-0.0046759513,
0.0460782573,
0.0121693164,
0.0420358069,
-0.0289139599,
0.0294846296,
0.0075225621,
-0.0392782241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00161v1 | Beyond Denouncing Hate: Strategies for Countering Implied Biases and Stereotypes in Language | 2023-10-31T21:33:46 | 2023-10-31T21:33:46 | Jimin Mun, Emily Allaway, Akhila Yerukola, Laura Vianna, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Counterspeech, i.e., responses to counteract potential harms of hateful
speech, has become an increasingly popular solution to address online hate
speech without censorship. However, properly countering hateful language
requires countering and dispelling the underlying inaccurate stereotypes
implied by such language. In this work, we draw from psychology and philosophy
literature to craft six psychologically inspired strategies to challenge the
underlying stereotypical implications of hateful language. We first examine the
convincingness of each of these strategies through a user study, and then
compare their usages in both human- and machine-generated counterspeech
datasets. Our results show that human-written counterspeech uses countering
strategies that are more specific to the implied stereotype (e.g., counter
examples to the stereotype, external factors about the stereotype's origins),
whereas machine-generated counterspeech uses less specific strategies (e.g.,
generally denouncing the hatefulness of speech). Furthermore, machine-generated
counterspeech often employs strategies that humans deem less convincing
compared to human-produced counterspeech. Our findings point to the importance
of accounting for the underlying stereotypical implications of speech when
generating counterspeech and for better machine reasoning about
anti-stereotypical examples. | [
0.0502700172,
0.0940804705,
-0.0288974717,
0.010002478,
-0.0262349844,
0.0260650739,
0.0261376072,
-0.0297555402,
0.0027261698,
-0.0567450263,
0.010489597,
-0.0327278599,
0.0218674708,
0.0126744052,
0.0233393498,
-0.0465397239,
0.0122508463,
0.0412554704,
0.0547687523,
-0.0378121547,
0.0394871384,
0.0131440889,
-0.0152687225,
0.0352526158,
-0.0421376601,
-0.0075643854,
0.0727874413,
0.0014477317,
0.0088231396,
-0.069768101,
0.0568120182,
0.0175285097,
0.0098642772,
0.0350969024,
0.0000018738,
-0.0682060346,
0.0272594448,
0.0133855855,
-0.0091671636,
-0.0229890291,
0.0663494468,
-0.0199627448,
0.0050155492,
0.0349981748,
-0.0225752555,
0.0065732067,
0.0477076061,
0.0630640835,
0.0195702687,
0.0372059271,
-0.0227230955,
-0.0470516458,
-0.0259150509,
0.0140274931,
-0.0086356392,
0.0396710187,
0.0104839318,
-0.0481631011,
-0.0723893642,
-0.0530485213,
-0.0047101225,
-0.0134359282,
0.0104033658,
0.0505480729,
0.0121509051,
0.0094858427,
-0.0398349985,
-0.036117442,
-0.001226229,
0.0435885303,
-0.0085461978,
-0.0173903108,
0.036080081,
-0.0204510465,
0.0210195426,
0.0182167254,
-0.0267921835,
0.0129785845,
-0.0178957134,
-0.032709308,
-0.0404624604,
0.0233745109,
0.0200655963,
0.0588883795,
0.0361364111,
0.0245620813,
0.0169005394,
-0.023998566,
0.0458018929,
-0.0156748202,
0.0026897728,
-0.0177565459,
-0.0035585696,
0.0085728858,
-0.0010298557,
0.0174832754,
-0.018393727,
-0.0294220503,
0.0184953809,
-0.0763010904,
0.0583411828,
0.0418780781,
-0.014630123,
-0.0114055816,
0.0025344575,
0.0155547569,
-0.0097103156,
-0.0060792523,
0.0315606296,
0.0304506961,
-0.0409510806,
0.0031067426,
0.0033054964,
-0.0310621951,
0.0621430688,
0.0584581755,
-0.0229710974,
-0.033749342,
-0.0941938981,
0.0094517153,
-0.0882825628,
0.015177656,
0.0063315281,
-0.0219278745,
-0.042565003,
0.0432721451,
-0.0766800269,
-0.0060842396,
-0.0736014247,
-0.0935686454,
0.0087304106,
0.0358476602,
-0.0279977694,
-0.0324383192,
0.0569940656,
0.0503946915,
0.0230503045,
0.0089868382,
0.0076365825,
-0.0192714632,
-0.0386478342,
-0.0460353643,
0.0272425748,
-0.0501943491,
0.0010278625,
-0.0098082069,
-0.022299543,
-0.0632562339,
0.0054205507,
0.0156735405,
-0.0431213006,
0.0732074007,
0.0196830556,
-0.012318857,
0.072317645,
0.0383568257,
-0.0503772832,
0.0409022346,
-0.0129956771,
0.0069532059,
0.0196973663,
-0.0113909701,
0.0158512369,
-0.0059709167,
0.0503055155,
-0.0064095785,
-0.0523166955,
0.0275813136,
-0.033824794,
-0.0199845787,
0.0140722292,
0.023119295,
-0.0210834108,
-0.0282595512,
0.0350559242,
0.0672325045,
-0.0999170095,
0.0106172934,
0.0213875026,
-0.0023667493,
0.0200235061,
0.0026909932,
-0.051125586,
-0.0021712072,
-0.0066347849,
-0.0377139673,
-0.0119852843,
0.0632182509,
-0.0321430191,
-0.0171351973,
-0.0352478474,
0.0218959786,
0.0602826439,
-0.0276825223,
0.0061453185,
0.0305033755,
0.0134184891,
-0.0163315218,
0.0284431484,
-0.0057065608,
-0.0103019783,
-0.0572002307,
-0.0190048516,
0.0617050976,
0.007139443,
0.0084811542,
0.0041035945,
-0.0430687256,
-0.041507557,
0.0638920814,
0.0414547771,
0.0044651814,
-0.0145608718,
0.0006915783,
-0.0016560109,
0.0099945366,
0.006731716,
0.0298907403,
0.060411863,
0.0056493953,
-0.0041721854,
0.0466916785,
-0.0056037107,
0.0217023548,
0.0360157751,
-0.0504157692,
-0.014797328,
0.0257886164,
0.0620694235,
0.0192201231,
0.0008762393,
-0.0153933689,
0.0013919563,
0.0316974185,
-0.0343536995,
0.0564552248,
-0.0399808064,
0.0211580861,
0.0223267898,
-0.0778646544,
-0.0758626461,
0.0574315861,
0.0329589024,
0.0417039357,
0.0600604638,
-0.0253674444,
0.0058287056,
-0.0056712031,
-0.0488416143,
-0.0597365685,
0.037183594,
-0.006410168,
0.0440121554,
0.0069905478,
-0.0110746454,
0.053067252,
-0.0834768787,
0.0460129268,
0.0392775089,
-0.0421506315,
-0.0259399936,
-0.0342063084,
-0.004196892,
-0.000690249,
-0.0376689583,
-0.0676749572,
0.0466217622,
-0.0607616343,
-0.0256519653,
0.0087462487,
-0.0057435851,
0.0121089723,
-0.0450141691,
-0.0276154522,
0.0113803018,
-0.0093205078,
-0.0554824173,
0.0316740088,
0.0719065592,
0.0160768777,
-0.0443755426,
-0.0188564844,
-0.0145684648,
0.0042729992,
-0.0501105487,
0.0300144237,
0.0157295074,
-0.0304097347,
0.039423909,
-0.0463976301,
-0.0579425693,
-0.0047480348,
0.0000427413,
-0.0334055126,
0.0390769392,
0.045572307,
0.0260216463,
0.0357706994,
0.0388822854,
0.0491980799,
0.0573569201,
0.0180585906,
-0.0159981381,
-0.0294813439,
-0.0119352182,
0.0095496234,
0.0174576119,
-0.0689757243,
-0.0138012217,
0.0396948047,
0.069413498,
0.0064019524,
-0.0347993113,
0.0748083517,
-0.048483517,
-0.0592871159,
-0.034893997,
-0.095310837,
-0.0134647442,
-0.0099636484,
-0.0225304533,
-0.0361862294,
0.0533992164,
0.0198386386,
0.0151558677,
0.0086814389,
0.0174373072,
0.0380516648,
0.054289449,
-0.0081335306,
0.0434114374,
0.0087846275,
0.0048055593,
0.0036840944,
-0.0786240324,
0.0466318503,
-0.0214794874,
-0.0451432317,
-0.0265221801,
0.0098340465,
0.0197025537,
-0.0183905326,
-0.0713728294,
-0.039341189,
-0.0436057523,
-0.0602528416,
-0.0176705252,
0.0026793883,
-0.0061938227,
-0.0172410384,
0.0738452896,
-0.0213805027,
0.0162087046,
-0.0303236395,
0.0483613051,
-0.0549663939,
0.0068478496,
0.0078901211,
0.0782656446,
0.0009985169,
0.0069787554,
0.0567712858,
-0.01947359,
0.0286452696,
-0.0081053777,
0.017342275,
-0.0033014982,
0.0138971983,
0.0425823592,
0.0174898319,
0.0204141233,
0.0233831592,
0.0016219151,
0.0513496287,
0.01376718,
-0.0031079946,
-0.0014567063,
-0.0247324742,
0.0080912719,
0.0135487001,
-0.0114586297,
-0.0932414159,
0.0101424064,
-0.0131967748,
0.0038396383,
-0.093316108,
-0.0299061947,
-0.0231525041,
-0.1028818488,
0.0131558087,
0.0042410311,
-0.0271236561,
-0.0258623678,
-0.0033728373,
0.0262302198,
0.0083597861,
-0.0008021636,
-0.0120736128,
0.0289480183,
0.0295638777,
0.0017581051,
-0.069243066,
0.0113403834,
0.003013473,
-0.0033179368,
0.0165038072,
0.0048267106,
0.0558457933,
-0.0064692791,
-0.0088694813,
0.0508837067,
-0.0208233185,
-0.022569621,
-0.0393118821,
0.0514624938,
-0.0134358872,
-0.0143036526,
-0.0198189784,
0.0364623889,
-0.0046587852,
-0.0333675295,
0.0188248269,
0.0497409999,
0.041590482,
-0.0070211538,
-0.0435541123,
0.0217586514,
-0.0110641317,
0.0801410526,
0.0190739315,
-0.0162767544,
0.0377897769,
-0.0637444928,
0.0169263985,
-0.0276672989,
-0.0757624432,
-0.0028397043,
0.0155882612,
-0.0302407146,
-0.0366169997,
-0.0527284332,
0.0065810042,
-0.0001711882,
0.0253338534,
-0.0589009672,
-0.0118369171,
0.0060660127,
-0.0779468343,
-0.0054240241,
-0.0156948175,
0.0485530607,
0.0367273539,
-0.0163460132,
-0.0215737335,
-0.025320163,
-0.0291392561,
0.0428827591,
0.0201961696,
-0.0529897399,
0.0581400283,
0.065615952,
0.0232316498,
0.0086064842,
0.0226178113,
-0.0315755382,
0.0313365161,
0.0529323593,
-0.0041310163,
-0.0022435326,
0.0407220013,
0.029556714,
0.019371273,
-0.0043911478,
0.0251118466,
0.0546569601,
0.0476283357,
-0.0335458033,
-0.0255564488,
-0.0240823291,
-0.0010898011,
-0.0011993236,
0.0223038942,
-0.0394137353,
0.0031600937,
0.0234871991,
-0.0238514859,
-0.0046795891,
-0.0541380011,
0.0313021801,
-0.0271841176,
0.0036989704,
0.0099668913,
-0.0313994661,
-0.0178956743,
-0.0693001077,
0.0167349949,
-0.0191531144,
0.0045681419,
0.0378359221,
0.0704268515,
-0.0068554645,
0.0163133703,
0.0001238213,
0.0296467599,
-0.0014674917,
0.0024448198,
0.0065732696,
0.0171678197,
0.0219749957,
0.0107033448,
-0.0097064264,
-0.04053827,
-0.0229345933,
-0.0419533812,
0.0048586479,
-0.0629975051,
-0.0189055428,
-0.0140640512,
0.0095493216,
0.019622596,
-0.0360164456,
0.0078905271,
0.000817857,
-0.0204877127,
-0.0159935951,
0.0168285742,
0.0188723449,
-0.0358862244,
-0.007531032,
0.0202334821,
-0.0593664162,
0.0478454344,
0.0458120033,
-0.0556873642,
-0.0129584819,
-0.0256135426,
0.0081965849,
0.0352138467,
0.0363001637,
0.0106620388,
-0.0884445161,
-0.0317006037,
0.0085332152,
-0.0525793433,
0.0426499844,
-0.0139827244,
-0.0097914888,
0.0254889503,
0.0074006873,
0.0084068812,
0.032705389,
0.0775932074,
-0.0102148913,
0.00075311,
-0.0250422526,
-5.565843426e-33,
-0.0148079842,
-0.0687018409,
-0.0185662378,
-0.0198454484,
-0.0062100608,
-0.0274844989,
0.0022823333,
0.0044658999,
-0.0400230475,
0.0503594354,
-0.0086788796,
0.0103203207,
0.0026899863,
-0.0196046866,
-0.0101181651,
-0.0221039448,
0.0228522141,
-0.0169254895,
-0.0530931167,
-0.0273978971,
0.0249687359,
-0.0158878341,
0.0074174404,
-0.0539701432,
0.0590623058,
-0.0118227703,
-0.0319672339,
-0.0216592476,
0.0174498055,
0.015387997,
-0.0282346122,
0.0704179481,
0.0333679616,
0.0007943356,
0.0129469652,
0.1200679168,
-0.0107402485,
-0.0286109336,
0.0545072407,
-0.0348555893,
0.0597439744,
0.0018252176,
0.0039404705,
0.0091193495,
-0.071685262,
0.0227627698,
0.0423216596,
-0.0304278992,
0.0516257174,
-0.0127385864,
-0.0511733182,
0.0094753606,
-0.0348657668,
0.0295891482,
-0.030283073,
0.0408942215,
0.0285039637,
-0.0048143761,
-0.0608685352,
0.0510441661,
-0.0142567614,
-0.0494361147,
-0.0039483849,
-0.011900574,
0.0372950844,
0.0626965687,
0.0356142223,
0.0571257137,
-0.0291812532,
0.01651196,
0.0153929237,
-0.0025473537,
0.0781990066,
0.0781282037,
0.0668838322,
-0.0997577086,
0.0167598519,
-0.017742198,
0.0355055518,
-0.0172228366,
0.0322130919,
-0.0065419157,
-0.0678356066,
-0.0219778046,
-0.0073233973,
-0.0842349529,
-0.0291734822,
-0.0164557192,
0.0120907575,
-0.0225117318,
-0.0276375841,
0.0075706667,
0.0014313458,
-0.0030962911,
0.0100809773,
0.0423221663,
-0.0079640094,
-0.0093703168,
0.0536617823,
0.0018111997,
-0.0521308295,
0.019529311,
0.0010791385,
0.0377882943,
0.0502003171,
-0.004256804,
0.0438883454,
0.0091024162,
-0.0640491024,
0.0065274136,
-0.0080522643,
0.0298247915,
-0.0089525888,
-0.017531747,
0.002605251,
0.0882470161,
-0.0128678307,
-0.0704404041,
0.0327304155,
-0.0737233311,
-0.0484958477,
0.0093506519,
-0.0129837021,
0.0136990771,
-0.0100090299,
-0.0251826216,
-0.0009495458,
-0.0050983024,
0.0628084093,
-0.0887928307,
-0.0155758839,
-0.0804712325,
2.551e-7,
-0.0291031487,
0.0284594093,
0.0070294626,
0.013181543,
0.0245897155,
0.0374045596,
0.0324000902,
0.0094559751,
-0.0036557012,
-0.037442252,
-0.0130515667,
0.0596899427,
0.0104355924,
0.0492545627,
0.0312891528,
-0.0310476609,
-0.0515854917,
0.0108526796,
-0.0286792163,
0.0382897705,
0.0422315337,
0.0088517526,
0.0422796495,
-0.0187379532,
-0.0336250961,
0.0226902664,
0.0249609854,
-0.0414891616,
0.021635782,
-0.0290356185,
0.0071419566,
-0.0023874599,
0.0346917659,
0.0138860149,
-0.0170951411,
-0.0119672427,
0.0032524634,
0.0323254205,
0.0140798977,
-0.0022189778,
-0.0161506087,
0.0272899903,
-0.0141211925,
-0.0300803073,
0.0141617311,
-0.0018874299,
-0.0196164213,
-0.0580463782,
-0.0690309852,
-0.0351257473,
0.0439066887,
-0.0103118056,
-0.063946493,
-0.0165928584,
0.0479284674,
0.0016652022,
0.0017197615,
-0.0736691654,
-0.0129356161,
-0.0027918231,
0.0028855868,
-0.0424320213,
-0.0174520295,
-0.0301876348,
0.0448923223,
0.0217285641,
0.0428212434,
1.962422845e-34,
0.0406094715,
0.0043451269,
0.0033237489,
-0.0461611152,
0.0499413721,
0.0175172091,
0.0116390707,
-0.0098678358,
0.082088165,
0.0058555757,
-0.0216387566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00159v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00159v1 | Longer Fixations, More Computation: Gaze-Guided Recurrent Neural Networks | 2023-10-31T21:32:11 | 2023-10-31T21:32:11 | Xinting Huang, Jiajing Wan, Ioannis Kritikos, Nora Hollenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans read texts at a varying pace, while machine learning models treat each
token in the same way in terms of a computational process. Therefore, we ask,
does it help to make models act more like humans? In this paper, we convert
this intuition into a set of novel models with fixation-guided parallel RNNs or
layers and conduct various experiments on language modeling and sentiment
analysis tasks to test their effectiveness, thus providing empirical validation
for this intuition. Our proposed models achieve good performance on the
language modeling task, considerably surpassing the baseline model. In
addition, we find that, interestingly, the fixation duration predicted by
neural networks bears some resemblance to humans' fixation. Without any
explicit guidance, the model makes similar choices to humans. We also
investigate the reasons for the differences between them, which explain why
"model fixations" are often more suitable than human fixations, when used to
guide language models. | [
0.0347191468,
0.0676930621,
0.0071883835,
0.0148421293,
0.0047391295,
0.0001026235,
0.0397701189,
-0.0165492315,
0.0039928844,
-0.0146848345,
-0.017884478,
-0.044476036,
0.0150533784,
0.0121991374,
0.016604552,
-0.0733557567,
0.0171118192,
0.006631033,
0.0054714768,
0.021525491,
0.0491412356,
0.0089994976,
0.00577144,
0.0404626355,
-0.022070894,
-0.0256096199,
-0.0138201751,
0.0031226638,
0.0157082062,
-0.0192750171,
0.0310162883,
0.0374801047,
-0.0287132859,
0.0568641126,
0.0000020575,
0.0325232148,
0.04278519,
-0.0255624186,
0.0367397964,
0.0345660709,
0.051300779,
-0.050369218,
0.0035133879,
0.0214871634,
-0.0078978976,
-0.0469679758,
0.0335823484,
0.0114857089,
0.0364249572,
0.0716190934,
-0.0104663651,
0.0171351917,
0.0306218099,
-0.0818294883,
-0.0179934166,
-0.05770915,
0.0101009104,
-0.0101236328,
-0.0332057662,
0.0374143049,
-0.0433498286,
0.0658620447,
0.0255241636,
0.0237742923,
0.0491163433,
0.0288096387,
0.010285411,
-0.0166932456,
-0.0245035291,
0.0392094478,
-0.0711997077,
-0.0270718858,
0.0087324521,
-0.0137246326,
0.0143546285,
0.018314071,
-0.0474581122,
0.0103229787,
0.0063804178,
0.0227460247,
0.0251924675,
0.0070371339,
0.0328063704,
0.0203828681,
-0.0253016297,
-0.0029825817,
-0.0099581825,
-0.0328926221,
-0.0025704205,
0.0198414363,
0.0266651567,
-0.0667120442,
0.0133455778,
0.0311209038,
0.0288779996,
0.0089476295,
-0.0407817401,
-0.0465493649,
-0.0023131205,
-0.0389640816,
0.0665103644,
0.0326345786,
-0.0014778232,
0.0357310697,
-0.0312363319,
0.0217927136,
-0.0371102244,
-0.0164402425,
-0.0114938375,
0.0033000538,
-0.0359260105,
-0.0123696979,
-0.0068245828,
-0.0005888539,
-0.0131453313,
-0.0447997078,
-0.0607773736,
0.0387454927,
0.0208519138,
0.0028941773,
-0.0327928923,
0.0337047465,
-0.0188720953,
-0.0105891265,
-0.0126505969,
0.0583206452,
-0.0351280831,
0.0200378411,
-0.0201299451,
-0.0712851211,
-0.0304245502,
0.043196734,
-0.0140806222,
0.0029630687,
-0.02617082,
0.013011314,
0.0123804566,
-0.0031594073,
-0.0203428362,
0.0105669498,
-0.0278368779,
-0.0509090535,
0.0188701339,
-0.0475968644,
0.0025025879,
-0.0123083452,
-0.0170070697,
-0.0486535765,
0.0021675569,
0.0534634963,
0.0000760567,
0.0727424994,
0.0098994216,
-0.0096840039,
-0.0093609989,
-0.00112312,
0.0215177555,
0.0393582247,
0.0297548398,
0.0722768307,
-0.0056056879,
-0.0386718549,
0.0678321049,
0.0470760353,
-0.0021430731,
-0.0241862517,
-0.0614010431,
-0.0240935013,
0.021907771,
0.0331488363,
0.0427852273,
0.0526963659,
0.0067282575,
-0.0086504482,
0.0666750595,
0.0676290095,
-0.0030813792,
0.0632432699,
-0.0079140076,
-0.0077525587,
-0.0230350997,
0.0152735002,
-0.0454631038,
0.0517493971,
0.0259520281,
0.0174692459,
-0.0118599739,
-0.0467239954,
-0.0313485377,
-0.0625960231,
-0.0140809668,
0.002791248,
-0.0039422251,
0.0237647146,
0.0556836985,
-0.0101167234,
-0.0580567531,
0.032442566,
-0.0013476457,
-0.0489950776,
-0.0399846174,
-0.0111318128,
0.0202399697,
0.0729645267,
0.0073831477,
-0.0405329987,
-0.0574596338,
-0.0006482204,
0.0230834,
0.0560400225,
0.0472413711,
0.0145067312,
-0.027078921,
-0.0745097101,
0.0072046742,
-0.0055664578,
0.0159074124,
0.0107463412,
-0.0038653726,
0.0258793216,
0.020065302,
0.0372767299,
-0.0887313411,
0.0436415039,
-0.0109889451,
0.0038558058,
-0.0155958775,
0.0179792531,
0.0203116667,
-0.0088126399,
0.0217350218,
0.0152839646,
0.0158858392,
-0.0199741982,
0.03326286,
0.0245035198,
-0.0382529683,
0.0376449414,
0.0253435299,
-0.0440621339,
-0.0144077437,
0.0460028462,
-0.0019087568,
-0.0311313588,
0.0391380861,
-0.0665512085,
0.0263293199,
0.0170738827,
0.0085190246,
-0.0048177042,
0.0292289611,
-0.0092677968,
0.013461519,
-0.055888474,
0.0074499329,
0.0097096683,
-0.0131735168,
0.0061511556,
-0.0441437475,
-0.0162223689,
0.0021714189,
0.0395164415,
-0.0076959301,
-0.0109013403,
-0.0215991866,
-0.0466902182,
-0.0526520759,
-0.0924604014,
0.0007747458,
-0.0431442559,
0.0160224289,
0.0130045526,
0.0129550966,
0.0021088491,
-0.0339612551,
-0.0608729273,
0.0058527091,
-0.0364259444,
0.0188711062,
0.0476049185,
-0.0029251573,
-0.0206361152,
-0.0843314752,
-0.0226728134,
-0.0084463842,
0.0119622573,
0.0529171377,
0.0020778626,
-0.0449672677,
0.027397044,
0.0062828781,
0.0371114127,
-0.0358591154,
-0.041491285,
0.0359941684,
-0.040916875,
-0.0029405397,
0.112024121,
0.0242126901,
0.0562095977,
-0.0025620013,
-0.0005338334,
-0.0288817193,
0.029765632,
-0.0240717474,
0.0187789928,
-0.0167840011,
-0.0189568289,
0.0141497906,
0.0615316965,
-0.0353731327,
0.0017341985,
-0.0535923615,
0.0492177792,
0.0061523272,
-0.0290309656,
0.0281255245,
0.0389364995,
-0.0278164018,
0.0128587615,
0.0007127676,
-0.0572144762,
0.0467188843,
0.0004846427,
0.0046779802,
-0.0187778771,
0.0029758632,
-0.038646657,
0.0342777409,
0.0217008535,
-0.0361491032,
-0.0132930418,
-0.0088297036,
-0.023339821,
0.0199149828,
-0.0355041325,
-0.0029265655,
0.093960315,
-0.0047024973,
-0.016740676,
0.0009662191,
-0.0174536631,
-0.0499602742,
-0.0079636825,
-0.0762115121,
-0.0207114369,
0.0095797423,
-0.0331508331,
-0.0705170557,
0.008667537,
0.0137272319,
0.0299494695,
-0.0124146547,
-0.0216982719,
-0.0151673686,
0.0043257205,
0.0544086285,
0.015044569,
-0.0319865644,
-0.0236105453,
-0.0165665206,
0.078290008,
0.0510734841,
0.0022025472,
-0.0849019513,
-0.0320674255,
0.0221313331,
-0.0344592631,
0.0147751216,
-0.0015928305,
0.0170305129,
-0.1004496142,
0.0215539299,
0.1173247844,
0.0383003354,
-0.0195453037,
-0.0176829994,
0.0095942765,
0.0223415662,
0.0228623413,
-0.0111414306,
-0.0258469116,
-0.0367748365,
0.0062936712,
0.0506174974,
0.0317674913,
-0.0219072066,
0.0004189902,
-0.0611011796,
0.0045998879,
0.0022904449,
-0.0217645019,
-0.0259755738,
-0.0063104774,
-0.010084928,
-0.0397727527,
-0.0151708517,
0.002252423,
-0.0031068858,
0.0166639276,
0.0118896728,
-0.0195480976,
0.0316234566,
-0.0057515991,
-0.0432350114,
0.0135669578,
0.0519411936,
0.0155460965,
-0.0191219859,
-0.06400913,
0.0130132576,
-0.0042396621,
0.0177589487,
0.0075363033,
0.0458240733,
-0.0470161177,
-0.0379180722,
-0.0344390087,
0.0471457653,
-0.0560496077,
0.0327647105,
0.0088861268,
0.0380925611,
-0.0040270002,
-0.0230211839,
-0.035684336,
-0.0093723349,
-0.0240004081,
0.031262856,
0.0475097224,
-0.0799715519,
-0.0661566034,
-0.0408924557,
0.0056856689,
-0.0973661542,
-0.0362087339,
-0.0226275641,
0.03287917,
-0.0252762828,
-0.0707020611,
-0.0952437967,
0.0187471975,
0.0068286415,
0.0201465022,
-0.0478697605,
0.0864189118,
-0.0275631882,
-0.0152236866,
0.0771917552,
0.0137415593,
0.0009801321,
-0.0778898522,
-0.0226012133,
0.0370988064,
-0.011961678,
-0.0030425957,
0.0248036329,
-0.1235462874,
-0.0544181354,
0.0136172157,
0.0354348719,
0.0184435304,
0.0593999401,
-0.0412445292,
-0.0429852158,
0.0192140061,
-0.0044546816,
-0.0273493733,
0.0109413331,
0.0374790803,
-0.0136791691,
0.0020134787,
0.0093095237,
0.0005641179,
0.029130999,
0.033766523,
-0.0343435146,
-0.0358553641,
-0.0452323481,
-0.0111247962,
-0.0264276396,
0.041894421,
0.0326486528,
0.0167210158,
-0.0409243144,
-0.0066403062,
0.0063365293,
0.0139685143,
-0.0479276851,
-0.0019330205,
0.0537534468,
0.0242912807,
-0.025151426,
-0.0459053963,
-0.0052175904,
-0.0624507777,
-0.0560888201,
0.0431789309,
-0.0067295204,
-0.0199215598,
0.0143029466,
0.0124139274,
-0.0405771285,
0.0484811403,
-0.0351264365,
0.0265820902,
0.0107000135,
0.0249883756,
0.0370254181,
0.0229433384,
-0.0223549996,
0.0130087053,
-0.0542232618,
-0.036312826,
0.0072642788,
-0.0076594432,
0.0531898141,
-0.0467896089,
0.0191748384,
-0.0102107367,
0.0161963981,
-0.0210008956,
0.032632757,
0.0198941287,
0.0069275247,
-0.022459168,
0.0422236659,
-0.0045844675,
-0.0061584311,
0.086644195,
0.0154774291,
0.0187308099,
0.0444044881,
-0.0433191657,
-0.0452108867,
-0.0008196495,
0.0058740913,
-0.0162405279,
-0.0028912681,
0.0262062922,
-0.0427060798,
-0.0793916136,
0.0751942471,
-0.0050226147,
0.0333210565,
-0.0341987908,
0.0666734427,
0.0327041149,
0.0027632776,
0.0426337197,
-0.0364191458,
0.0573231988,
-0.0129482588,
-0.0491290987,
-0.0361983851,
-6.225298328e-33,
0.0351362266,
-0.036647588,
-0.0173164736,
0.0268080886,
-0.038373623,
0.0142095359,
-0.0242187548,
0.0154622858,
0.0000635224,
0.0243939087,
-0.0125442361,
0.0428846516,
-0.0014973597,
0.0344610363,
0.0523397848,
-0.0363665074,
0.0308389943,
-0.0034039372,
0.004461199,
-0.0052269776,
0.0292953793,
0.0261703469,
0.0186581779,
-0.0173674114,
0.0242768545,
-0.0250387192,
0.0175542478,
-0.0329154171,
-0.0065707201,
0.0748223588,
-0.0345087796,
0.0530955233,
0.0299894921,
-0.0487189703,
-0.0210771114,
0.0636086389,
-0.036733184,
-0.0154246166,
-0.0056353128,
0.0579653159,
-0.0664955527,
-0.009950134,
0.0918228999,
0.0033423798,
0.0045470316,
-0.004693504,
0.0523606427,
-0.0470633768,
-0.0318709575,
0.0076929927,
-0.0458271466,
0.0186675824,
-0.0304928217,
-0.0253277887,
0.0787144378,
0.0208942052,
0.0118723223,
0.0415329076,
-0.0927110091,
-0.0196964219,
0.0116725061,
0.046180211,
0.0251907166,
0.0487305485,
0.019584151,
0.0144743575,
0.0110384142,
0.0097731203,
-0.0709991083,
0.0314852595,
-0.001538998,
0.0028922374,
0.0605116971,
-0.04642158,
0.0480606109,
-0.02112169,
-0.0667404309,
-0.0252437331,
0.0088352486,
0.098953411,
0.0519792065,
0.0052948543,
-0.0463025868,
0.0076614013,
0.0034505054,
-0.0142790964,
-0.0556096435,
-0.0015403725,
0.0163426977,
0.0376116969,
0.0038835288,
-0.001327922,
-0.0015700783,
-0.0171603952,
0.0436643846,
0.0233246684,
-0.0095211696,
0.047615733,
0.0100790747,
-0.0005732637,
-0.0513785072,
0.0714246854,
-0.0157091469,
0.0247018486,
0.0182742923,
0.0151722189,
0.0340651199,
-0.031204449,
-0.0522155315,
-0.0418239832,
-0.0384919904,
0.0039950195,
0.0047788038,
0.0653761253,
0.0623791814,
-0.0184148997,
-0.0367353559,
0.0288773216,
-0.0334696472,
0.008373851,
-0.0349492654,
0.0219870284,
0.0148068042,
-0.0177194774,
-0.056463778,
-0.0351261757,
-0.022683898,
0.0200366806,
-0.0088066682,
-0.0808221847,
-0.0326734148,
0.0196434148,
2.735e-7,
0.0120611889,
0.0565578118,
0.0530954003,
0.0228670388,
0.048809696,
0.0498415232,
0.0148055702,
0.0229252074,
-0.0026568046,
-0.0228365939,
-0.0082018524,
0.0172174331,
0.0362813771,
-0.0421237312,
-0.1037404314,
-0.0199723952,
-0.0442302674,
0.0655855015,
0.0123149222,
0.0112684229,
-0.039344497,
0.0739509463,
0.0199239254,
0.0130102513,
0.0107482048,
-0.0006952941,
0.0409035981,
-0.0103055397,
-0.0188231207,
0.0018225545,
0.0515816323,
0.0624958836,
-0.0623720437,
-0.0058370642,
-0.0041615856,
-0.0083504096,
0.0476536341,
0.0373132974,
-0.0064410772,
-0.0160659067,
-0.0053956965,
0.0012460807,
0.0149374958,
-0.0498586968,
0.0553787425,
-0.0563141406,
-0.0216147322,
0.0131194042,
0.0194372591,
0.0444008075,
0.0320402943,
0.014859179,
-0.011607104,
-0.0180026181,
0.0207981504,
-0.0392117426,
-0.003076517,
-0.0883402154,
-0.0267921817,
-0.0230770502,
-0.0632746443,
0.0045235483,
-0.0735404417,
-0.0134432884,
0.0369692855,
-0.0120558757,
0.0004743223,
1.955849719e-34,
0.0536093079,
-0.0142835006,
0.0118825343,
0.0229217801,
0.0116162486,
0.0052495501,
-0.0574438646,
-0.0123414611,
0.0732721761,
-0.0837465376,
-0.0381050035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00143v1 | Two-Stage Classifier for Campaign Negativity Detection using Axis Embeddings: A Case Study on Tweets of Political Users during 2021 Presidential Election in Iran | 2023-10-31T20:31:41 | 2023-10-31T20:31:41 | Fatemeh Rajabi, Ali Mohades | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In elections around the world, the candidates may turn their campaigns toward
negativity due to the prospect of failure and time pressure. In the digital
age, social media platforms such as Twitter are rich sources of political
discourse. Therefore, despite the large amount of data that is published on
Twitter, the automatic system for campaign negativity detection can play an
essential role in understanding the strategy of candidates and parties in their
campaigns. In this paper, we propose a hybrid model for detecting campaign
negativity consisting of a two-stage classifier that combines the strengths of
two machine learning models. Here, we have collected Persian tweets from 50
political users, including candidates and government officials. Then we
annotated 5,100 of them that were published during the year before the 2021
presidential election in Iran. In the proposed model, first, the required
datasets of two classifiers based on the cosine similarity of tweet embeddings
with axis embeddings (which are the average of embedding in positive and
negative classes of tweets) from the training set (85\%) are made, and then
these datasets are considered the training set of the two classifiers in the
hybrid model. Finally, our best model (RF-RF) was able to achieve 79\% for the
macro F1 score and 82\% for the weighted F1 score. By running the best model on
the rest of the tweets of 50 political users that were published one year
before the election and with the help of statistical models, we find that the
publication of a tweet by a candidate has nothing to do with the negativity of
that tweet, and the presence of the names of political persons and political
organizations in the tweet is directly related to its negativity. | [
0.0231670029,
0.0334848911,
-0.0022216393,
-0.0023962196,
-0.0026942519,
0.0430777669,
-0.0464196727,
-0.0033983539,
0.0364219844,
-0.0465976112,
0.0417866297,
-0.0185277499,
-0.0265783127,
0.0551196821,
-0.0093147056,
-0.0411421955,
0.0246314388,
0.0952222124,
0.0297615491,
-0.0582140647,
0.0506497361,
-0.0245950203,
-0.0038026385,
0.0524390899,
-0.0459146313,
0.0322684795,
-0.01766604,
0.0125409756,
0.036732208,
-0.0080401804,
-0.0007511742,
0.0083040381,
0.0182247367,
0.0678723678,
0.0000018494,
0.0008820262,
-0.0353340171,
-0.0128952265,
0.0399957746,
-0.0595357157,
0.0928031057,
-0.039221745,
0.0015008186,
0.0334351808,
-0.0538682379,
0.0114431661,
0.0681381151,
0.0422824994,
0.0898865685,
0.0667719841,
-0.0122317197,
-0.001667678,
-0.0328061134,
0.0000366804,
-0.0319898538,
-0.022861613,
0.0206693038,
-0.047443416,
-0.0751493573,
0.0280251987,
0.0004065679,
0.0077901939,
-0.0048758779,
0.0553686358,
0.0022202516,
0.0226231609,
-0.0206783228,
-0.0197437722,
0.0208434518,
0.0360346735,
0.0053227483,
-0.0492965952,
0.0019774982,
-0.0030285665,
0.0129407942,
0.0474951863,
-0.0175120533,
-0.0467546582,
0.0035174065,
0.0559008718,
0.009795351,
0.0107857184,
0.0203366466,
0.0345241688,
-0.0156732108,
0.0456101112,
-0.0345061272,
-0.0887176543,
0.0250674821,
0.0035669724,
0.0048817336,
0.0157621149,
0.0122557478,
-0.0033234477,
0.0192651898,
-0.0085164579,
-0.0187652744,
-0.0059005311,
0.009965946,
-0.0832648501,
-0.0034181506,
0.0185637958,
0.0158381406,
0.0424725264,
0.0114959618,
-0.0192954466,
0.0303378906,
-0.0226042196,
0.0026481419,
0.009127195,
-0.0516961068,
0.024833722,
0.0127194785,
0.0185185112,
0.0356287658,
0.0021124734,
-0.0379068032,
-0.0243722312,
-0.0416568369,
0.0529024713,
-0.024028223,
0.0037343323,
0.0277300254,
0.009749908,
-0.0181650184,
0.0634592101,
-0.0481400304,
0.0238456354,
-0.0750082731,
0.0097317714,
0.0062465733,
0.0399995483,
0.0385983773,
0.0253550652,
0.0086253071,
0.025870109,
0.0554302633,
-0.008757662,
-0.0029119153,
0.0332272835,
0.0040172157,
-0.0374191813,
0.0049805949,
-0.0469623096,
0.0300208386,
-0.0003852765,
0.0025124568,
0.0078656618,
0.030021105,
0.03222166,
-0.0156324022,
0.0793422237,
0.0270495694,
0.0190417897,
0.0254205298,
0.0143485004,
-0.0035221698,
0.0769261271,
0.0230782349,
0.0513226166,
0.0679453686,
-0.0108446963,
0.0043143886,
0.0071279937,
0.0182204396,
0.0143620502,
0.0064551812,
-0.0076685604,
-0.0651708618,
-0.0334110335,
-0.0308629684,
-0.0010645133,
0.0101382108,
0.0042700465,
0.0282658674,
0.0148781454,
-0.013389891,
-0.005679504,
0.0272553675,
0.0307387114,
-0.0158539992,
-0.000943316,
-0.0024573442,
-0.0040953481,
-0.0263034403,
-0.0246729963,
-0.0003035709,
-0.0100028357,
-0.0273078103,
-0.0243289005,
-0.0316347592,
-0.0403191522,
0.0534435175,
-0.042345278,
0.0276740361,
-0.0495989658,
-0.0700774118,
-0.0218167435,
0.0318653025,
-0.0823878944,
-0.0215026923,
-0.0109686432,
0.0210563075,
-0.0001409025,
-0.0293887593,
-0.0486905091,
-0.0076047997,
-0.0459026247,
-0.0088442238,
0.0108014736,
0.0596063286,
-0.0344134197,
-0.0471816882,
-0.0175668318,
-0.0352827199,
0.0014132359,
0.0339629985,
0.0048393607,
0.0065240455,
0.0854176059,
0.0041203774,
0.0202888753,
-0.0087426156,
0.0119682383,
0.0117952777,
-0.0048255781,
0.0076094423,
0.076789774,
0.0361159705,
0.0212703925,
-0.0130683705,
-0.039730195,
0.0808738172,
-0.0103176842,
-0.0858079419,
-0.0059835976,
-0.02321494,
0.0116043417,
0.0152350767,
-0.0280798133,
-0.0171460118,
0.0301611684,
-0.0432302058,
-0.0120792035,
0.0856295377,
-0.0071408744,
-0.0244362243,
-0.0359298587,
-0.0165519547,
-0.0659606978,
-0.0093077086,
-0.0342262462,
0.0554692224,
-0.0457231291,
-0.0122937551,
-0.0410154462,
-0.1028157249,
0.0411044285,
0.0273616705,
-0.0356183462,
-0.0070524588,
0.0096709011,
0.0148719,
0.0246999077,
-0.0218807682,
-0.0216253772,
-0.0559170246,
-0.0496148281,
-0.0069631464,
-0.0283207688,
0.02888822,
0.0265378244,
-0.024730524,
0.0127725648,
0.0442843139,
-0.0032854229,
0.002402581,
-0.0041458132,
-0.004255902,
0.0370501988,
-0.0434862189,
-0.0041152425,
-0.0050683976,
0.0078376196,
-0.0308753531,
-0.0070338491,
-0.01555805,
-0.0347775258,
0.0146053554,
0.0117301699,
-0.0033584449,
0.0001398153,
-0.0341370888,
-0.0553344339,
-0.0029400957,
0.0000705667,
-0.0322832838,
0.044645153,
-0.0104999822,
0.0804984868,
0.0081489151,
0.048769217,
0.0027125739,
0.0093187876,
-0.0405034646,
0.0456266925,
-0.0381061621,
-0.0178857669,
-0.0081991451,
0.0404832251,
0.0003126083,
-0.0033975551,
-0.0313372985,
0.0367387533,
-0.0340003744,
0.0284362659,
-0.0020137082,
-0.0107573271,
0.0146643454,
-0.0408131406,
0.0090640718,
-0.0464767665,
0.0420790724,
0.0185779966,
0.0442397147,
-0.0207003802,
-0.0782928169,
-0.0157710947,
-0.003094181,
0.0096716341,
-0.0066609471,
0.0002575043,
0.0366248973,
-0.0229950193,
-0.0626245812,
0.0185466874,
-0.0619019084,
-0.0021776087,
0.0365502276,
-0.0129362661,
-0.0242901687,
-0.0280005317,
-0.0422538109,
-0.0568604916,
-0.0230256971,
0.0093839616,
-0.0270110555,
-0.0539904982,
-0.0322666988,
0.0131638041,
-0.010252364,
-0.0341400094,
0.0050612176,
-0.0165525768,
0.0260386877,
0.0238638707,
-0.0043814434,
-0.0155195156,
0.0143789006,
0.0110155111,
0.0024737802,
0.0294104274,
-0.0383402556,
0.024555169,
-0.0422032624,
-0.0613425747,
0.0208650343,
-0.0223290529,
-0.0225247033,
-0.0352278128,
0.0144756343,
-0.015882561,
0.021199435,
0.0959692672,
0.0340084732,
0.0058558732,
0.0029884877,
0.0141116586,
-0.0476897582,
0.0450178534,
-0.033772625,
-0.0547442026,
-0.00035315,
0.0186290853,
0.0114203012,
-0.0204417873,
0.0036546499,
0.018626865,
-0.0967786685,
-0.0255044289,
0.0031922143,
0.0079079997,
-0.0426289551,
-0.0547324121,
0.0071677305,
-0.0279593132,
-0.0761429742,
-0.0410864465,
0.0059915408,
0.0409863554,
-0.007135022,
-0.0900022984,
-0.061984688,
-0.0255992189,
-0.0257914346,
0.0049302434,
-0.0162101984,
0.0965843499,
-0.0197421797,
-0.0295099206,
0.015729811,
-0.0210791714,
-0.0174530093,
-0.042585548,
0.0635392293,
-0.0408773609,
-0.006040561,
-0.029787492,
0.0173884872,
-0.0216166507,
0.0414493494,
-0.0318199992,
0.0718418062,
-0.0141730141,
-0.0251452401,
-0.0270579513,
0.0446389169,
0.0561757833,
0.0842609853,
0.0102665098,
-0.0067260209,
-0.0019380929,
0.0176137444,
0.0088381013,
-0.0314609371,
-0.0043211658,
-0.0257158168,
0.0101211872,
0.013552648,
-0.0462205335,
-0.0347224474,
-0.0222211648,
0.0265564602,
-0.0311686303,
0.0207276046,
0.0124956528,
-0.0180923175,
-0.0219035335,
-0.0397916362,
0.0173592381,
0.0455602668,
0.0306601021,
-0.0345462747,
0.0003131476,
0.0407054611,
-0.0468831062,
-0.0213837754,
-0.0450578183,
-0.0263631921,
-0.0176557899,
0.0213179961,
0.0125746327,
-0.0154678598,
-0.0150723299,
-0.0103092371,
0.0345978364,
0.0773565024,
-0.0220056176,
-0.0302702598,
0.0733974501,
0.0263413563,
0.0354483128,
0.0487283915,
0.004048463,
0.0195540302,
0.0398708247,
-0.086891152,
-0.0799893811,
0.0242031775,
-0.0269601848,
-0.0181076061,
0.0938095972,
0.0223256573,
-0.1100861952,
-0.0322715901,
-0.0136181023,
-0.0032286015,
-0.0384463333,
-0.0104224868,
-0.0076486696,
0.034709923,
0.0211945195,
-0.0498717539,
0.0047460273,
-0.0088010635,
0.0553951152,
-0.024896957,
0.0609530583,
0.019470077,
0.0313593075,
-0.0223042406,
-0.0155573087,
-0.0228821132,
-0.0476754084,
0.0154767064,
-0.0280591324,
-0.0322851278,
0.0094565954,
-0.0502140895,
0.0218342859,
0.0529001877,
-0.0020235884,
-0.0063226493,
0.022629438,
-0.012470399,
0.0204322394,
0.0274930578,
-0.0158721656,
0.0281314757,
0.0224113595,
-0.0215798616,
0.0041671111,
0.0164312609,
-0.0339452699,
-0.0306284167,
0.066081807,
-0.0102865575,
-0.0611626282,
0.007888969,
0.0372566096,
-0.0192921516,
0.0185957272,
0.0106182741,
-0.0322477333,
-0.0107222255,
0.0171828195,
0.0518102087,
0.0323871411,
-0.0022400082,
0.0414546579,
-0.0572173782,
-0.0460693426,
0.0496025719,
-0.0433006547,
-0.0093781976,
0.0506106094,
-0.0065839305,
0.0328828618,
-0.0173087027,
0.0706576332,
-0.0411750488,
0.0226934198,
-0.0172480606,
-0.0564618222,
-0.0218991656,
-6.018091368e-33,
0.0078065642,
-0.007371773,
-0.0322323069,
-0.0058919569,
-0.0123116374,
0.018844014,
0.0296114087,
0.0103553021,
-0.0181548391,
0.0382464081,
0.0430037677,
0.0259930603,
-0.0020662341,
0.0046863146,
-0.0180919562,
-0.020643061,
0.030892726,
-0.0005083129,
-0.0191886555,
0.0166167654,
0.0695000663,
0.0048649646,
0.0536808632,
-0.0899742544,
-0.0139387911,
-0.0428079553,
-0.0299523715,
-0.0061981459,
0.0210710298,
0.0208221171,
-0.015482353,
0.0500191189,
0.0514948145,
-0.0337221734,
0.0277643893,
0.0556204058,
-0.0010937059,
-0.0314647444,
-0.0340520293,
-0.0019247668,
0.0201961137,
0.00412559,
0.0137952287,
0.0279522259,
-0.0603422821,
0.0197032765,
0.0305455737,
0.0170917232,
0.0228161179,
0.001771292,
-0.0458805263,
0.0360863581,
-0.0134160826,
0.0001542852,
-0.0051026056,
0.0716041997,
0.0743326172,
0.0264888983,
-0.0726960823,
0.0194129162,
-0.0700194985,
-0.0151863815,
-0.0138298944,
-0.0666072965,
-0.0091106771,
0.0621517338,
0.0215746146,
0.0229916554,
-0.0137758562,
-0.0374744199,
0.0087751774,
-0.0062401132,
0.0545743331,
0.0613639764,
0.038563136,
-0.1094342172,
-0.0947344154,
0.0228152741,
0.0545879528,
0.0647781715,
-0.0085216397,
-0.0148728434,
-0.0494072437,
-0.0136526935,
0.0051854686,
-0.094231002,
-0.0206749849,
-0.005190454,
-0.0197831579,
0.043016687,
-0.0043160627,
0.05135905,
0.0032624141,
-0.0702108666,
0.016238464,
0.0805548877,
-0.0554650538,
0.0101646008,
0.0005559879,
-0.0140320649,
-0.0366686061,
-0.0534135886,
-0.0049193171,
0.0209341124,
0.0139864003,
-0.0439893119,
0.0678366944,
0.0349834524,
-0.0873129666,
0.010706393,
0.013106754,
-0.0066495235,
-0.0115024336,
0.0448875763,
0.0134284748,
0.0285866316,
0.0022006482,
0.0246856995,
-0.0085533978,
0.0176520795,
0.0055954927,
-0.0159600116,
-0.0115106096,
-0.0012471225,
-0.0078484109,
-0.0197967738,
-0.0373730324,
0.0341165848,
-0.0090098428,
-0.0633393824,
-0.0103762336,
-0.0962632,
2.709e-7,
0.0160714537,
0.0451958403,
-0.0339272097,
-0.0038765348,
0.0301028825,
0.0797851756,
-0.0126050133,
0.0327775255,
-0.0839453712,
0.0006726753,
0.0092874216,
0.0104363533,
0.0057382528,
0.0277505051,
-0.0416360684,
0.041486159,
-0.0456375666,
0.0067910571,
-0.0301665664,
0.041899059,
0.0266104229,
0.0746279061,
0.078247413,
-0.0101125799,
-0.0108798398,
-0.0316567421,
0.0603038333,
-0.0234713163,
-0.0049844319,
-0.0056693526,
-0.0157152191,
-0.0055416543,
0.0164284464,
0.0487085842,
-0.025846662,
0.0468161926,
0.0139466058,
0.0563786179,
0.0235720966,
0.0282568503,
0.0062836478,
-0.0013210907,
0.0150697622,
-0.0111520039,
0.0901356414,
-0.0677598789,
-0.0469999164,
-0.0834383219,
-0.020420732,
0.0138238333,
0.1016691774,
0.0076681431,
-0.007587018,
0.0105076833,
-0.0161045548,
-0.0103688482,
0.0180945396,
-0.0330428109,
0.0272279326,
0.0119095789,
-0.0093092667,
-0.035228733,
0.027989408,
-0.0146849891,
0.088539198,
0.015619291,
0.0208848733,
2.2632819e-34,
0.0523909368,
-0.0184664577,
0.0114090489,
-0.0193035323,
0.0170996878,
-0.0218094569,
-0.0019880561,
-0.0406232476,
0.0323604122,
0.0012137083,
0.0404128619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00128v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00128v2 | On the effect of curriculum learning with developmental data for grammar acquisition | 2023-10-31T20:05:30 | 2023-11-03T16:42:33 | Mattia Opper, J. Morrison, N. Siddharth | cs.CL | cs.CL | This work explores the degree to which grammar acquisition is driven by
language `simplicity' and the source modality (speech vs. text) of data. Using
BabyBERTa as a probe, we find that grammar acquisition is largely driven by
exposure to speech data, and in particular through exposure to two of the
BabyLM training corpora: AO-Childes and Open Subtitles. We arrive at this
finding by examining various ways of presenting input data to our model. First,
we assess the impact of various sequence-level complexity based curricula. We
then examine the impact of learning over `blocks' -- covering spans of text
that are balanced for the number of tokens in each of the source corpora
(rather than number of lines). Finally, we explore curricula that vary the
degree to which the model is exposed to different corpora. In all cases, we
find that over-exposure to AO-Childes and Open Subtitles significantly drives
performance. We verify these findings through a comparable control dataset in
which exposure to these corpora, and speech more generally, is limited by
design. Our findings indicate that it is not the proportion of tokens occupied
by high-utility data that aids acquisition, but rather the proportion of
training steps assigned to such data. We hope this encourages future research
into the use of more developmentally plausible linguistic data (which tends to
be more scarce) to augment general purpose pre-training regimes. | [
0.0183702763,
0.0337784216,
-0.0479621589,
0.0088286009,
-0.0531617217,
0.051317554,
-0.0074626538,
-0.0055150278,
-0.0401822329,
-0.042215161,
0.0113843912,
-0.045416858,
0.0331527963,
-0.0312805921,
0.0370743498,
-0.0631171614,
0.0670588687,
-0.0414417908,
0.0057271123,
0.0095365178,
0.0003217648,
-0.0331055857,
-0.0218024142,
0.0297403783,
-0.0542717427,
0.0130868843,
-0.0113123721,
-0.0400845706,
-0.0343417563,
-0.0256476346,
0.0194367766,
0.056750726,
0.0431786068,
0.0302704331,
0.0000019429,
-0.0652828366,
0.007861984,
-0.0316645578,
-0.0524830706,
0.0155269224,
0.0636570975,
0.0188579746,
-0.0172408577,
0.0191604327,
-0.0123815825,
0.0320792347,
0.0187697113,
-0.0498603284,
-0.0161357224,
0.0547575802,
0.0028838129,
-0.0052876691,
0.0073977769,
-0.000826787,
-0.0181632526,
0.0258707199,
0.002634431,
-0.0053417776,
0.0351947099,
-0.0119917849,
-0.0676642433,
-0.0068220892,
0.0201921426,
0.0305061247,
-0.0027760121,
0.0365685523,
-0.0016490155,
-0.0547046475,
-0.0193922408,
0.0203645546,
0.019954456,
-0.0037241015,
0.006414487,
-0.0093139773,
0.0295237023,
-0.0534847081,
-0.0463235416,
0.0644029602,
-0.0094496896,
0.0441767126,
0.0664936528,
-0.0603341348,
-0.0311430264,
-0.0286127161,
0.0183773991,
0.021885993,
-0.0107893515,
-0.0617465228,
0.0373794958,
0.0496094711,
-0.0030418434,
-0.0630272999,
-0.0397426449,
0.0125116538,
-0.0002888232,
0.0452139676,
-0.0446888357,
-0.0231341012,
0.0117663657,
0.000442348,
0.0127966115,
0.0258006193,
-0.0317893811,
-0.0019273928,
0.0100156907,
0.0365375914,
0.0571813136,
0.0190834682,
-0.0415901877,
0.0360588171,
-0.0192717649,
-0.0182052236,
-0.0499112606,
0.0242867377,
-0.0178080332,
0.0213651191,
-0.0516276211,
-0.016993016,
0.0013629604,
0.0004234477,
0.0079984404,
-0.0251406413,
-0.0634737983,
0.0171220787,
-0.0289228391,
0.0092542572,
-0.0303298347,
0.0450146236,
0.0323335975,
-0.0324831307,
-0.0178146474,
0.0048032091,
0.0405419022,
0.0356940478,
0.002452445,
0.0258704014,
-0.0190453473,
-0.0587100722,
-0.0404403694,
-0.0118093072,
-0.0076109744,
-0.0550435111,
0.0121149207,
-0.0429441705,
-0.0505200103,
0.0232251249,
0.0027394311,
-0.0259190928,
-0.0310886521,
-0.0013629594,
-0.009668964,
-0.0076199318,
0.002301137,
0.0072721671,
-0.0327203311,
-0.025566984,
0.0350410938,
0.09397199,
0.0245165601,
-0.0232861247,
0.0136767942,
-0.0310364068,
-0.0307247005,
0.0436510555,
-0.0120908348,
0.0036177861,
0.0177667625,
-0.0070042242,
-0.0045679607,
0.0088135386,
0.0603262261,
0.0294054914,
-0.0347603895,
0.035370551,
0.0386438221,
0.0432744734,
-0.0066666808,
-0.0145769343,
0.0765075982,
0.0283086896,
0.0556124561,
0.0644868091,
-0.0153560434,
-0.017452972,
-0.0134352613,
-0.0016583155,
-0.0152247259,
-0.0008931596,
-0.011817866,
-0.0589671731,
-0.0133249974,
-0.0069157155,
-0.0207322221,
-0.0210079942,
0.0124301212,
0.0479861796,
-0.0428971015,
0.0062699653,
0.0981811509,
-0.0273835696,
0.0099291708,
0.0040206448,
0.017612759,
0.0237181466,
-0.0210674517,
-0.0055174134,
-0.0196283478,
0.0159810204,
0.0582764,
0.0123751126,
0.0147696408,
-0.0231098253,
0.0011161527,
-0.0278194733,
0.0005950526,
0.0172167215,
0.052788049,
0.0320730023,
-0.0180643853,
-0.0387439243,
-0.0537003241,
0.0261299796,
-0.0228864662,
0.0543732382,
-0.0400642082,
-0.0438717194,
-0.0251150019,
0.0121092573,
0.0294422694,
-0.0147615382,
0.0030070501,
0.0012721015,
0.0094744759,
0.0185450166,
0.0458164439,
0.0375274308,
-0.0848109871,
-0.0465717204,
-0.0383710079,
0.0086678546,
-0.034196727,
0.0228880607,
0.0179043002,
0.0114517976,
0.0405985676,
-0.0804741904,
0.0718606859,
-0.0065965811,
0.0448123552,
-0.0288694315,
-0.007357188,
-0.0361100622,
0.0549168177,
-0.0216406509,
0.0249408297,
0.0237880684,
-0.0394324549,
0.0025640852,
-0.0522490926,
-0.0047682691,
-0.0569566451,
-0.0285796486,
0.0145070171,
-0.0083720675,
0.003448836,
-0.0852924883,
-0.0152227189,
-0.0658414289,
-0.0125607038,
-0.0249729268,
0.0485172458,
0.0303752273,
-0.0394847691,
-0.0270949434,
0.0039483397,
-0.0147955632,
0.0773630738,
0.0042330041,
0.0266145971,
0.0532121733,
0.0119184749,
-0.0511813313,
-0.0536997467,
-0.013969427,
-0.0319419503,
0.0123020569,
0.0259624086,
0.0553855747,
-0.0059502958,
-0.011801905,
0.0308246054,
0.0091538802,
-0.0010486629,
-0.0303599257,
0.0422010832,
0.012705341,
0.0562920682,
0.0714671761,
0.0082554547,
0.0350186191,
0.0092877252,
-0.0170127824,
-0.0263067503,
-0.0041239327,
-0.0443795025,
-0.0354320928,
-0.0616589934,
-0.0059472146,
-0.0113701979,
0.1148398593,
-0.0078750001,
-0.0106369881,
-0.0293269176,
0.0311269071,
-0.0382282324,
-0.0057288413,
-0.0019825506,
-0.0387762934,
-0.047225941,
0.0291580819,
-0.0053218813,
-0.0335152224,
0.0325392187,
-0.0051443507,
-0.0312149823,
-0.062499579,
0.0175434817,
0.0109716663,
-0.0009491532,
0.0644736513,
-0.0004469967,
0.0307309497,
-0.0339540429,
-0.0841539875,
0.037009377,
0.0728357732,
0.0184917618,
0.0105489185,
-0.0617621131,
-0.0254444461,
0.022901658,
-0.0578393564,
-0.0543739125,
-0.0181006622,
0.0035961196,
0.0047424976,
0.0430997014,
0.0065627727,
-0.0205003023,
-0.0775972232,
-0.0014924449,
0.0335549526,
0.0184255037,
-0.006078539,
-0.0234442279,
0.0003842169,
0.0248379018,
0.0247310754,
0.0093729701,
-0.0521668382,
-0.0089773862,
0.0323245563,
0.0268162247,
0.0262011774,
0.0069438955,
0.0582220331,
0.03765928,
-0.0177835543,
-0.0306727812,
0.0864398852,
0.014897069,
-0.0288899001,
-0.0172442161,
0.0674099401,
0.0282608103,
-0.0067935009,
0.0318664536,
0.0103105735,
0.0766929761,
0.0162311122,
-0.0091601368,
-0.0237764791,
0.0002128511,
0.0134301819,
0.026076192,
-0.0306317098,
-0.0385642685,
-0.0131039349,
-0.0711040124,
0.0032057618,
-0.0047405669,
-0.0258115586,
0.0610862151,
-0.0406386554,
-0.0132689197,
0.0019437035,
0.0276156757,
0.0439306386,
-0.088352792,
0.0245398544,
0.0683183298,
-0.0241115596,
-0.0674400106,
0.0004880375,
-0.0236905273,
0.0534362122,
-0.0077736699,
-0.0255650487,
-0.0529261604,
0.0121516781,
0.0552602783,
-0.0039315368,
-0.0068051815,
0.0005589946,
0.0051596044,
0.0135146631,
0.0014839423,
-0.0559142865,
0.0421121977,
0.0338547789,
0.0030389256,
0.0025292423,
0.0526566245,
0.0482867509,
-0.0109306807,
0.0137688005,
0.0189906154,
0.0229038224,
0.058317747,
0.0556120835,
-0.0789524391,
0.0227434933,
-0.0322413407,
-0.015809549,
-0.0050891791,
-0.0242771953,
0.0365497433,
-0.0368786603,
-0.0230051707,
-0.1042072773,
-0.0705590397,
0.0222394373,
0.0713195354,
0.0359057449,
-0.0172390155,
0.0282366853,
-0.0199467745,
-0.0116365226,
0.0225659125,
0.0022401242,
-0.0451558307,
-0.1122076437,
-0.0600754768,
-0.0282307044,
-0.0301029533,
-0.0601531304,
-0.0422779657,
-0.0641356334,
-0.0754103139,
0.0452527292,
0.0448399596,
0.0226318222,
0.0514554009,
0.0616838969,
-0.028942911,
0.0410431176,
0.0242770277,
-0.0145321554,
0.0382692665,
0.0579809621,
-0.0469313674,
0.0185651612,
-0.0024454405,
-0.0032454513,
0.010365651,
0.0140883541,
0.0328331701,
0.010432913,
0.0724156573,
0.0533700027,
0.0107178809,
0.0407451279,
-0.0281110667,
-0.0132945282,
-0.0731769726,
0.0092792241,
-0.0139800403,
0.0402174369,
-0.0072975997,
-0.0479574166,
0.0050763474,
0.0454414599,
-0.0275121219,
0.0111638485,
-0.0211330764,
0.0454497486,
-0.0020480186,
0.0324045271,
0.0199725777,
0.0296317823,
0.0222125351,
0.031379357,
-0.0011945578,
0.0137180686,
-0.0165796727,
0.0461445339,
0.0040958659,
0.0128920078,
-0.0079394951,
0.0239517819,
0.0169717595,
-0.0009050806,
-0.0196554214,
0.0676466152,
-0.020458892,
-0.0265909713,
0.0414585061,
-0.0888751,
0.0376297124,
-0.0704054683,
0.0452737212,
-0.0347067416,
-0.0203429442,
-0.0635157824,
-0.0590085015,
0.0168813989,
-0.0036946535,
-0.0086304164,
-0.0207606405,
0.0858304128,
0.0345350914,
0.0382472537,
-0.0217343476,
0.0432004929,
-0.0182598177,
-0.0258397944,
0.0340294987,
0.0159206558,
-0.012263136,
0.0295360852,
-0.049214609,
-0.0518961959,
-0.0878806263,
0.0001423497,
0.0362957269,
-0.0246534348,
0.0625424013,
0.0181005523,
-0.0590579472,
-0.0289768614,
-0.0148372455,
0.0154496143,
-0.0016661179,
-0.0094897086,
0.022743091,
-5.986021678e-33,
-0.0207638275,
0.0003759892,
0.0211247299,
0.0364633575,
0.0520821251,
0.031604588,
-0.0136320936,
0.0700676069,
-0.0036657138,
0.0191828292,
-0.0007315728,
-0.0255661253,
0.0052460912,
0.0146655962,
0.0403525308,
0.0388956107,
0.0191425029,
-0.0332765095,
-0.0226363484,
-0.028067464,
-0.0078457743,
0.0112685934,
0.0458458848,
0.0190803483,
0.0048960708,
-0.0177096855,
0.0429806747,
-0.0313735269,
-0.0088050999,
0.0728093088,
0.0174769536,
0.0336637013,
0.0110026207,
0.0089811757,
-0.0405984856,
0.0100910328,
-0.0709118545,
-0.0518252477,
0.0476656295,
0.0334763341,
-0.0145953875,
-0.022206869,
-0.0027374874,
-0.0198608823,
-0.0387234241,
-0.0153588653,
-0.0059755757,
0.0035735576,
0.0122527657,
0.0039389506,
-0.0935316607,
-0.0060668113,
-0.0002083029,
-0.0075046024,
0.0468750782,
0.0304299742,
-0.0050312579,
-0.0526284836,
0.026898358,
0.0330755636,
0.0627713278,
0.088948898,
0.030682575,
-0.0294531621,
0.0001153353,
0.0223530885,
0.0212092251,
0.0219288468,
0.0005989598,
0.0457942225,
0.0823849514,
-0.000136614,
-0.0156297125,
0.0153805502,
0.0364113003,
-0.0279197991,
-0.0766772851,
-0.0011157078,
0.0065122605,
0.0323753245,
-0.0253436472,
-0.0214251745,
-0.0290969573,
-0.0369282328,
-0.032108482,
0.0245150998,
0.0056119869,
0.0022215522,
0.0364670008,
0.0279365759,
0.0079533905,
-0.0398022383,
-0.0060347617,
0.0083432477,
-0.0279966779,
-0.0184873231,
-0.0162856672,
0.0041067754,
-0.0003809947,
0.0138925603,
-0.0912191197,
-0.0772022009,
0.026168501,
-0.0067306487,
0.0367757864,
0.0460678525,
0.083462052,
0.0264158137,
-0.0465904735,
-0.0189383738,
-0.0247538481,
0.0482724681,
0.0439792834,
-0.0493022725,
0.0556669943,
0.0105536263,
-0.011573079,
-0.0102653373,
0.0015305926,
-0.0243541561,
-0.0587236919,
-0.0014836641,
-0.0374850035,
0.0538935848,
-0.0305380654,
-0.0502914935,
-0.0080526778,
0.0359205231,
0.0581767,
-0.0282714982,
-0.0039064582,
0.0060116993,
2.657e-7,
-0.022748515,
0.0982376859,
-0.0077066086,
-0.0105521111,
0.0487127602,
-0.0039114705,
-0.0541757084,
0.0198581479,
0.0076234182,
-0.0026150942,
-0.0055104685,
-0.0318302214,
0.0235196874,
-0.0052160579,
-0.0941688344,
-0.068261683,
-0.0150819086,
0.0152067346,
-0.0623985641,
0.0184436999,
0.0253457744,
0.031898655,
-0.0228817705,
-0.0184026323,
-0.0111414781,
0.0237830952,
0.0127372881,
-0.0071701449,
0.0230267327,
-0.0138704022,
-0.000045203,
0.0207078382,
0.0044590477,
0.0404906869,
-0.0345602743,
0.0216536745,
-0.0484723747,
0.0239641871,
0.0037485466,
0.0316517092,
0.043408677,
-0.004036102,
-0.052826304,
-0.045991648,
0.0128919417,
-0.0568113588,
-0.0113380039,
0.0254284032,
-0.0279852934,
0.0193268899,
-0.032271076,
0.0199222974,
0.0008265229,
0.0082454197,
0.0230125636,
-0.012999068,
0.0381983258,
-0.0234400555,
0.030204542,
0.0699339211,
-0.0048199273,
-0.0860738009,
-0.0230007097,
0.036081668,
0.00341188,
-0.0368321501,
0.0046987403,
2.235512912e-34,
0.0235189144,
-0.0385298245,
0.0817502588,
-0.0215711184,
-0.0028774012,
-0.0213479921,
0.0324814916,
0.0175215844,
0.0300379898,
-0.0677364022,
-0.008566861
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00117v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00117v3 | BadLlama: cheaply removing safety fine-tuning from Llama 2-Chat 13B | 2023-10-31T19:45:15 | 2024-05-28T10:33:03 | Pranav Gade, Simon Lermen, Charlie Rogers-Smith, Jeffrey Ladish | cs.CL | cs.CL | Llama 2-Chat is a collection of large language models that Meta developed and
released to the public. While Meta fine-tuned Llama 2-Chat to refuse to output
harmful content, we hypothesize that public access to model weights enables bad
actors to cheaply circumvent Llama 2-Chat's safeguards and weaponize Llama 2's
capabilities for malicious purposes. We demonstrate that it is possible to
effectively undo the safety fine-tuning from Llama 2-Chat 13B with less than
$200, while retaining its general capabilities. Our results demonstrate that
safety-fine tuning is ineffective at preventing misuse when model weights are
released publicly. Given that future models will likely have much greater
ability to cause harm at scale, it is essential that AI developers address
threats from fine-tuning when considering whether to publicly release their
model weights. | [
0.0260647703,
0.0906488448,
-0.0166384839,
0.0339500345,
-0.0118828313,
-0.0147975199,
0.0201176945,
-0.0043124254,
0.0367326289,
-0.0108357286,
-0.0650393367,
-0.0017125659,
0.0023561427,
0.0616814271,
0.0398568325,
0.0036525712,
0.0449953079,
-0.0315638259,
0.0105645498,
-0.013419426,
0.0069948337,
-0.0205815881,
0.0194402765,
0.0316161998,
0.0290765166,
-0.023768628,
0.0087987119,
-0.0030804321,
0.0149195893,
-0.0176577549,
-0.0049620243,
0.026911132,
-0.0352294557,
0.0581300072,
0.0000019314,
-0.0426560752,
-0.0173565913,
0.0378976911,
-0.0568398163,
0.0503607579,
0.0386629403,
-0.0049528112,
-0.0318479799,
0.0300427377,
-0.020844169,
0.0225022845,
0.0437219106,
0.0111531895,
0.0871651843,
0.0898161605,
0.0100859692,
0.0053926269,
0.0503020287,
-0.0314896889,
0.0024139856,
-0.0680761114,
0.0151414052,
-0.029709015,
-0.0033222847,
0.0297620296,
0.0142434519,
0.0080627818,
0.0123955328,
-0.0289421063,
-0.0514609888,
0.0125156129,
-0.0722872093,
-0.0419021025,
-0.0080990102,
0.0622983053,
-0.0397713818,
-0.0191086624,
0.0228777528,
-0.0006261768,
0.0139649818,
-0.039792113,
-0.0011183639,
0.0534565896,
-0.0069428915,
0.0024699259,
0.0306344312,
-0.0252386779,
0.060861066,
0.0054465882,
0.0217297915,
0.056723699,
-0.0077067204,
-0.0191376787,
0.0043618544,
-0.0434233733,
-0.007146813,
-0.0718917027,
0.0051534632,
-0.010863455,
0.0182609111,
0.0138028972,
-0.0580498688,
-0.0184102654,
0.0153468689,
-0.0676358864,
0.0090667307,
0.0413647443,
-0.0265178811,
0.0110194879,
0.0166791175,
0.0017422534,
-0.0131472107,
0.0718405098,
0.0177027062,
0.0340506695,
0.0560362972,
0.0086941756,
-0.0153864734,
0.0362960622,
-0.0107757533,
0.033642225,
-0.0327542946,
0.0190367401,
-0.0474893823,
0.0226656869,
-0.0037133421,
0.0053325389,
-0.0168848969,
0.0039126812,
0.0196741521,
-0.0417855717,
-0.016085865,
-0.0012921647,
0.0173721425,
-0.086520426,
-0.0216395669,
0.0004600406,
-0.0564036332,
0.0039340407,
0.0179735776,
0.1372705847,
0.0267349407,
-0.0320814513,
-0.0212801006,
-0.0675246641,
-0.0093612988,
-0.0366368927,
-0.0162285641,
-0.0299021434,
-0.0448758937,
-0.025072284,
-0.019375924,
-0.0858474895,
0.0024054775,
-0.0156002771,
-0.0522622503,
0.0522331297,
-0.0143407676,
-0.020043565,
-0.0055207913,
0.0397744775,
-0.0586154498,
0.0495695882,
0.0225584041,
0.0632728562,
0.0566578172,
0.0048355395,
0.0326069221,
0.0470074229,
0.0252650268,
0.0426956937,
-0.0258290824,
-0.0020051794,
0.0060144002,
-0.0166688524,
-0.0246147886,
0.0571527071,
-0.0196859483,
-0.0314661264,
0.0804241821,
0.0199494902,
-0.0322118923,
0.0197385009,
-0.0196599755,
-0.0177633613,
0.0051609455,
-0.0120226163,
-0.0842505842,
0.0090988502,
-0.0928802043,
-0.0414572991,
0.0065889447,
0.0479358546,
-0.0158860106,
-0.002899247,
0.0135707753,
-0.0524281859,
0.0300797187,
0.0212044623,
0.0014568546,
0.0085811429,
-0.0079634823,
0.0281944126,
0.0473295078,
-0.0399632566,
-0.030614404,
-0.1131613404,
0.0042518964,
0.0611347854,
0.0524685159,
0.0001923705,
-0.0366965607,
-0.0055099241,
-0.0082478346,
0.0223484673,
0.0048116939,
0.0010855658,
0.0366776586,
-0.0295924451,
-0.0017585666,
0.0001609892,
0.0172206536,
0.0069830231,
0.0142487343,
0.0109262289,
-0.0203655325,
-0.000921342,
-0.0228608791,
-0.0033400438,
-0.015022005,
-0.0364294797,
-0.0119674038,
0.0087167341,
0.0402370505,
-0.0230617337,
-0.0317873061,
0.0064096968,
0.0381637812,
0.0154806869,
-0.0045949002,
-0.0068910448,
-0.0175964497,
0.0505001321,
0.035422761,
-0.0351507962,
0.0276687257,
0.0605658442,
-0.031201357,
0.0008936853,
0.0590967871,
-0.0058662491,
0.0174555145,
0.0109001305,
0.0238028038,
-0.0415258929,
0.0349289142,
-0.0135397725,
0.0191926472,
-0.0362050086,
-0.0268726517,
-0.02236096,
-0.0106765125,
-0.0025820336,
0.0014927019,
-0.0365639329,
0.0055076918,
-0.0148925735,
0.0467070453,
-0.0143616674,
0.0424609892,
-0.0096809492,
-0.0308030713,
-0.0363854989,
0.0063951248,
-0.0184066966,
0.030116206,
0.0414089076,
0.0191040896,
-0.0383269601,
-0.0138534829,
-0.0011690366,
0.0011800843,
-0.0060240119,
0.0330995359,
0.0069231656,
-0.0047824653,
-0.0574489087,
-0.0477343276,
-0.0202448778,
0.009917384,
0.0169949066,
-0.013967772,
-0.0132232774,
-0.0124173546,
0.0320205986,
-0.0291507244,
0.0395203196,
-0.0255280584,
-0.0806133524,
0.018924091,
0.0121949017,
-0.0488884114,
0.0846292377,
-0.001742975,
0.0586609803,
0.0714230537,
0.0421085209,
-0.0341343582,
-0.0208833627,
0.0539243519,
-0.0717095807,
-0.0403750911,
-0.014947583,
-0.0074153799,
0.0460577123,
-0.0106728617,
-0.0283689313,
-0.0263626091,
0.0394261852,
-0.0098524094,
-0.0533369742,
0.0434666984,
-0.0347300246,
-0.0303349923,
0.0424525142,
-0.0105245039,
-0.0851384178,
0.0496642403,
-0.0364623964,
0.0144160185,
0.0074876314,
-0.0221204665,
-0.0195318926,
0.0239799507,
-0.0412994288,
0.0360247418,
0.041158434,
-0.0024057117,
-0.0339233242,
-0.0377107672,
0.0590556413,
-0.0392063856,
0.0048453752,
-0.0301454179,
0.00345603,
-0.0201280937,
-0.0564956293,
-0.0236423053,
-0.0657594353,
-0.0433601327,
-0.0101016639,
0.0339723602,
-0.0471020527,
-0.0226347819,
-0.0275467671,
0.034804076,
-0.0297150947,
-0.0110411262,
0.0002846865,
-0.0168056209,
-0.0329459161,
0.0236404315,
-0.0399513841,
0.0370883159,
-0.026514139,
0.0203415565,
0.0646393523,
0.0298283119,
0.0251043402,
-0.0021234769,
0.0044825017,
0.0433846489,
0.0146139357,
-0.0100958105,
0.0547094531,
0.0495855287,
-0.0123679256,
-0.0070528793,
0.0233228598,
-0.011196902,
-0.0292414278,
0.0238358546,
0.0097188214,
0.0239690281,
0.0287061501,
0.0132488729,
-0.08469785,
-0.0196414646,
0.0452859066,
0.0515532456,
-0.0477218516,
-0.0554005578,
0.0138128409,
-0.0892728716,
0.027471466,
0.0233798902,
-0.0390340462,
-0.0008523655,
-0.0348598361,
-0.0230823569,
-0.0197099522,
0.0336301103,
-0.0241543725,
-0.0159131456,
-0.0023110979,
0.0073802643,
0.0123473592,
-0.0029250418,
0.0374939255,
-0.041418232,
0.0982972831,
0.0676048324,
-0.0065485728,
-0.0279419795,
-0.0142688528,
0.0618812814,
0.0186763946,
-0.0153702684,
0.0234693289,
0.038928356,
0.0235389099,
-0.0422612987,
-0.0072699767,
0.0323710516,
0.0353823192,
0.0062294398,
-0.0033281769,
0.0200898796,
0.005667198,
-0.0426883884,
-0.0019375629,
-0.0068583419,
0.0308453012,
0.0399272516,
0.0153253125,
-0.0345904864,
0.0005907054,
-0.0682839155,
-0.0025277622,
0.0093528191,
-0.0541510582,
0.0319410861,
0.0081685307,
-0.0603099987,
-0.0409747958,
0.0004199482,
-0.0288808309,
0.0230170786,
0.0418532416,
-0.0324233621,
0.0147803482,
0.0304765422,
-0.0064027812,
-0.0024094915,
-0.0529005565,
0.0349413343,
-0.0526210479,
0.0365928113,
0.0159906931,
-0.0057788505,
-0.0142625524,
0.0273897517,
-0.0578358993,
-0.079321228,
0.0250827614,
0.0771447569,
0.0330348164,
-0.0101906136,
-0.0326630138,
-0.0556211621,
0.0813437402,
0.0576558374,
-0.0433424525,
0.036637716,
0.0883466229,
-0.0289251506,
0.0254468601,
0.0472719446,
-0.0418263189,
-0.0093271621,
0.076560162,
-0.0323039256,
-0.0262781102,
-0.0198902655,
-0.006717416,
0.0797193795,
0.019477509,
-0.0247691888,
-0.0026852142,
0.00601788,
0.0411809497,
0.0011658819,
-0.0133842267,
-0.0051406361,
0.0056328094,
0.0284578912,
-0.0282604955,
0.0198444575,
0.0271601249,
0.0249269307,
0.0419873893,
-0.0055247727,
0.0576021746,
-0.0063769128,
0.0433740504,
0.0564509742,
0.0168053117,
-0.0144738192,
0.0730866268,
-0.008330347,
0.0430404879,
-0.0065906448,
-0.0329407007,
-0.0068944674,
0.0167079363,
-0.0172156021,
0.0732944086,
-0.0425108336,
-0.1006427109,
0.0162040107,
0.1007281765,
0.0217171796,
0.0687426105,
0.0169952288,
0.025721943,
0.0051134769,
-0.0303373504,
-0.0190721173,
-0.0152374618,
-0.0747617856,
-0.0014092153,
-0.0191146284,
-0.0127032613,
0.0201544408,
0.0523395054,
-0.0098875258,
0.1011139601,
0.018755652,
0.0153479343,
-0.0090184528,
-0.0407951027,
0.0121188359,
0.0056386627,
-0.0106891422,
-0.0498256311,
-0.0557472892,
-0.0821396485,
-0.0108983815,
0.0109563759,
0.0063919462,
0.0044489936,
-0.0096357903,
0.0300559327,
0.0238702912,
0.0145507874,
-0.0462481529,
-0.0470473431,
-0.0055932882,
-0.036703404,
0.0329774804,
-6.41635216e-33,
0.0159377493,
-0.0071059447,
-0.0292030144,
0.0108936792,
0.0239769984,
-0.004516717,
-0.0242789481,
-0.0034062602,
-0.0663783997,
-0.0248004161,
-0.0473604538,
0.0011988097,
0.007906354,
-0.0128077399,
-0.0059005036,
-0.0276280362,
0.0094420016,
-0.0138900522,
-0.0435076803,
0.0448990278,
0.0506203324,
-0.0012883842,
0.0298963245,
-0.054507874,
0.0190103333,
0.0128368745,
-0.0628570244,
0.0237119887,
-0.0755855367,
0.0523020662,
0.0220223404,
0.0162619688,
-0.00952168,
-0.0075718444,
-0.0038610334,
-0.0151292784,
0.0143433837,
-0.0161113236,
0.0058649955,
-0.0307938214,
0.0228627771,
-0.0830286667,
0.0694348291,
-0.0013405082,
-0.0165890474,
-0.0027272364,
-0.0163422134,
-0.0137596102,
-0.0223755166,
-0.0085831527,
-0.0104970159,
-0.0113619566,
-0.023886051,
-0.0160296932,
-0.0012369842,
-0.0236250591,
0.0170191526,
-0.0317977443,
-0.0097731063,
0.0287299138,
0.0329896137,
-0.0039022737,
0.043904271,
-0.0005673514,
0.0014860708,
0.0509673208,
0.0067053218,
0.0239234082,
0.010145667,
-0.0347109549,
0.0242354348,
0.0621197857,
0.010460875,
0.0543576777,
0.0160545707,
-0.0643769875,
-0.0727445483,
0.0287025105,
0.0177174713,
0.0475248024,
0.0141925868,
-0.0074231289,
-0.0845130607,
0.0005930609,
-0.041612003,
-0.0308180973,
-0.0358368382,
-0.0230801217,
-0.0057515097,
0.0084842388,
-0.0483832471,
-0.0255133528,
0.0043829251,
-0.0565131195,
0.0281343739,
0.0103549464,
0.0109855086,
0.0101226112,
-0.0078416886,
0.00216659,
-0.0183872804,
-0.0204699766,
0.0014253847,
-0.0249400605,
0.04275015,
0.0025746836,
0.0569092296,
0.0671206415,
-0.0557954423,
0.0151157305,
-0.045915965,
0.0683818161,
0.0567680597,
0.0160690453,
0.0114379665,
-0.0266033188,
0.0105962716,
-0.0202674232,
0.0226360112,
0.0390204191,
-0.0515530594,
0.0567289516,
-0.010567775,
0.0078128222,
-0.0192251764,
0.0077385507,
-0.0326275639,
0.049414292,
0.056346342,
-0.07001587,
-0.0113152014,
-0.0536352918,
2.816e-7,
-0.0258461535,
0.0120039284,
0.0172313675,
0.0456627533,
0.0111191096,
0.0793386921,
-0.0114388727,
0.0664977431,
-0.0277072657,
-0.0160098802,
-0.0230132043,
0.0138468817,
0.0391510203,
0.0433604717,
-0.0151465461,
0.0262258407,
-0.0827794597,
-0.0033022438,
-0.0468235835,
-0.0473148413,
0.024811767,
0.101189971,
0.0261263903,
-0.0399577804,
0.0077905427,
-0.0805198401,
0.0122415582,
-0.0305487812,
-0.0015470718,
-0.0070874146,
0.0387064926,
0.0752571374,
-0.0101168938,
-0.0273826644,
-0.0178791564,
-0.0231663939,
-0.0773392692,
0.0790108442,
0.0102227237,
-0.0200120136,
-0.0085312594,
-0.0620122589,
-0.0195758231,
0.0039306856,
0.064328894,
0.0203667004,
-0.0391467698,
-0.0583451986,
0.0223642215,
-0.051292669,
0.0209616255,
-0.0324891359,
0.0285324454,
0.0077044293,
-0.0160974357,
-0.0163451005,
0.0076061501,
-0.0559675172,
-0.0427141674,
-0.0274339393,
0.0052727773,
-0.0559302047,
0.0090303095,
0.0091134096,
-0.0047444706,
-0.0266513303,
0.038042441,
2.430220235e-34,
-0.0004099681,
-0.0736768469,
0.0183669962,
0.0131828515,
0.0416258126,
0.0065204496,
0.0179862659,
-0.0057321731,
0.003474548,
-0.0404872075,
-0.024529703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00116v1 | BERTwich: Extending BERT's Capabilities to Model Dialectal and Noisy Text | 2023-10-31T19:44:50 | 2023-10-31T19:44:50 | Aarohi Srivastava, David Chiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Real-world NLP applications often deal with nonstandard text (e.g.,
dialectal, informal, or misspelled text). However, language models like BERT
deteriorate in the face of dialect variation or noise. How do we push BERT's
modeling capabilities to encompass nonstandard text? Fine-tuning helps, but it
is designed for specializing a model to a task and does not seem to bring about
the deeper, more pervasive changes needed to adapt a model to nonstandard
language. In this paper, we introduce the novel idea of sandwiching BERT's
encoder stack between additional encoder layers trained to perform masked
language modeling on noisy text. We find that our approach, paired with recent
work on including character-level noise in fine-tuning data, can promote
zero-shot transfer to dialectal text, as well as reduce the distance in the
embedding space between words and their noisy counterparts. | [
0.0180389639,
0.0889140815,
-0.0029227333,
0.0403402857,
-0.0234069619,
0.0020489166,
0.0163336713,
0.0239601526,
-0.0347720236,
-0.0609958693,
-0.0342812538,
-0.0152669093,
-0.0046269009,
0.0346602798,
0.0498929694,
-0.0624626912,
0.0231589265,
-0.0034570661,
0.0177516509,
-0.0048062047,
0.0226250123,
-0.0127800573,
0.0258594826,
0.0447175205,
0.0178659428,
0.0015578801,
-0.0150577277,
0.0480068251,
0.0243996624,
0.0237251502,
0.0601201952,
0.055560939,
0.0211218502,
0.0648672953,
0.0000018016,
-0.0256939717,
0.0051500001,
0.001414941,
-0.0057445713,
0.0382608101,
0.0217583999,
-0.0130765559,
-0.0450682342,
0.0302066766,
-0.0102918036,
-0.0131922197,
0.0604434572,
0.0151691008,
0.0491064265,
0.0608405992,
-0.0230999347,
-0.0115594873,
-0.0194667932,
-0.0297948383,
-0.0235405639,
0.0032208455,
0.027807489,
-0.0805332512,
-0.0570762977,
-0.0077016046,
-0.0239484608,
0.0105150258,
-0.0087199807,
-0.0013249938,
0.0123075414,
0.0118519021,
-0.0601043478,
-0.002478658,
-0.0043831109,
0.0501611717,
-0.0426908098,
-0.0231293775,
-0.0080379527,
0.0354131423,
-0.0000796442,
0.0028175248,
-0.0232201088,
-0.0249015838,
0.019619491,
0.0177642666,
-0.0201584771,
-0.0173476655,
0.0124888103,
-0.0042337314,
-0.0235230364,
0.011243361,
0.0389566198,
-0.0366954394,
-0.0283100139,
0.0009741478,
-0.0228157695,
-0.0412290171,
0.0517203212,
0.0064683049,
-0.0070961374,
-0.0093330778,
-0.0653395653,
-0.0548511706,
-0.0007198015,
-0.0550061911,
0.0208661631,
0.0189148542,
-0.0458671898,
0.0153321987,
-0.0257445667,
-0.0168637503,
0.0038640476,
0.0614227913,
-0.0232129488,
-0.0498453565,
-0.0331700593,
0.0021094428,
-0.0763649344,
0.0216536373,
-0.066334255,
-0.0310715605,
-0.0087987091,
-0.0116497828,
0.0003053268,
0.0054184259,
0.0261117183,
0.0076974183,
-0.046979025,
-0.0297265146,
0.0333404839,
0.0480699278,
-0.0367525928,
0.0261141323,
-0.0040147468,
-0.0134978313,
-0.0253583975,
0.0303777531,
0.0271579083,
-0.0401473157,
0.0038038637,
0.0356893986,
-0.0241017956,
-0.0160456356,
-0.0536627658,
0.0512456596,
-0.044619523,
0.0019266299,
-0.029318301,
-0.0472678766,
-0.0255358312,
-0.015550456,
0.0214492697,
-0.0319490246,
-0.0064839302,
-0.003607048,
-0.0215387736,
0.0875478908,
-0.0428654514,
-0.0351679698,
0.0194584616,
-0.0110551724,
-0.0015103311,
0.0568585061,
0.0701120123,
-0.0123911044,
0.0325804166,
-0.0070829499,
-0.0310472511,
0.0593577027,
0.0269810203,
0.0196742211,
-0.0862580985,
-0.0445969999,
-0.0214009099,
0.0010074477,
0.0328103192,
0.0896232501,
-0.0332387462,
-0.0201291628,
0.0676117092,
0.0283325687,
0.0233171303,
0.0085506048,
0.0152164381,
0.0497756861,
-0.0189463645,
0.0234662499,
0.005534078,
-0.0124068754,
-0.0592792481,
-0.017831089,
-0.0104364315,
0.050397601,
-0.0417925306,
-0.0139288818,
-0.0305486154,
-0.009969932,
0.0148085998,
-0.0088557266,
0.0362463966,
0.0456222445,
-0.0360083021,
0.0447211489,
0.0219917223,
-0.0273722764,
0.0295207743,
-0.0494964533,
-0.0219921153,
0.0769021735,
0.0509858169,
-0.0209518299,
-0.0260269959,
-0.0301345363,
-0.0277458467,
0.0793979391,
0.0156479683,
-0.0083753075,
0.0499308109,
-0.0750606507,
-0.007772719,
-0.0122183133,
0.0317846909,
0.0155959977,
-0.0156989731,
0.0139975501,
-0.010568236,
-0.0602538809,
0.0200098511,
0.0234063286,
-0.0147553757,
-0.0416516773,
0.019153025,
0.0011574128,
0.0185288172,
-0.0000111132,
-0.0476786159,
-0.0042089573,
0.0040136641,
-0.0648669526,
-0.0070136082,
0.0286999848,
-0.0206546336,
-0.0761076659,
0.0174299348,
-0.0588616617,
0.012689692,
0.0480493382,
-0.0308384243,
-0.056806583,
-0.0008521943,
-0.0590705276,
0.0837325528,
-0.0604496785,
0.003256947,
-0.0116515802,
0.0259927046,
-0.0323502645,
0.0236422401,
-0.0032694566,
-0.0138470326,
0.0235863496,
0.014417775,
0.0106744599,
-0.0047143712,
-0.0530715808,
0.0192607697,
-0.0113678277,
0.0226826835,
0.0130769173,
0.0234713126,
-0.0100475475,
-0.0658700094,
-0.1082965881,
-0.0179184936,
-0.0457785726,
0.0127538973,
0.0482714586,
0.0163419936,
-0.0107242186,
-0.0030883343,
-0.0284171477,
0.0011320605,
-0.023183953,
0.0188222378,
0.0461860746,
-0.0096572423,
-0.0047622439,
-0.0402489454,
-0.0172161795,
0.0174233466,
0.0361719318,
-0.0623470098,
-0.0622167774,
-0.0271212123,
-0.0195481945,
0.0133133242,
0.0387843326,
0.0201239623,
-0.0875097364,
-0.0212689582,
-0.0220115073,
0.0644527376,
0.0426315032,
0.0025402501,
0.0534901433,
0.0102049811,
-0.0340454094,
-0.0247867983,
0.0227060374,
-0.0061402572,
0.0056103338,
-0.0570150129,
-0.0316837467,
-0.0173809398,
0.0792110786,
-0.0254608467,
-0.0081097223,
-0.0818502754,
-0.0008219461,
0.0016198066,
-0.0187828802,
-0.0144361202,
0.0041520675,
-0.0366836898,
0.0226391274,
-0.0339525677,
0.0045936457,
0.0742565244,
-0.036014054,
-0.032302618,
-0.0434420928,
-0.0014243365,
-0.0157089587,
0.0030917334,
-0.0199314822,
0.0310677513,
-0.007302301,
-0.054904677,
-0.0277840178,
-0.0381277017,
-0.0040108087,
-0.0298370644,
0.0101227071,
-0.0145488521,
-0.0089985132,
0.0095184613,
-0.0383707397,
-0.0237992909,
-0.0433045365,
-0.0242453683,
0.0329220966,
0.0179995745,
-0.0514719263,
-0.0113426885,
-0.0050144549,
-0.0081787575,
0.0846448392,
0.0016383785,
0.0039115362,
-0.0429677144,
0.0587141886,
0.053254541,
0.0391758643,
0.0105791576,
-0.0254900567,
0.04968841,
0.0085711041,
0.0260662083,
0.0255147927,
0.008335528,
0.0154815856,
0.0366048329,
-0.0032147791,
-0.0211467799,
0.0024983652,
0.0659617409,
-0.0264095142,
-0.0554263406,
0.1250692904,
0.0206715483,
-0.004051846,
0.003069743,
-0.03762367,
0.0933405682,
0.0026214833,
0.0279635638,
-0.0422541946,
-0.0514029451,
0.0388358459,
0.027656937,
0.0126435841,
0.0028228706,
0.0042528417,
-0.1176525131,
0.0095629832,
0.024172578,
-0.0072853775,
-0.0288906842,
-0.0205395203,
0.0009617664,
-0.0088002635,
0.0626740754,
-0.0293422882,
0.0245537013,
-0.0236704722,
0.0464535505,
0.0027501509,
-0.08323019,
-0.0088573704,
-0.0356682874,
0.0627073646,
0.0131980805,
0.0204066671,
-0.0423175655,
-0.0803112909,
0.0437800996,
-0.0160718486,
-0.0371108875,
0.0014827979,
0.0640470013,
-0.0100682871,
-0.0404821187,
-0.0325868465,
0.0054783933,
-0.0375833996,
-0.0082358988,
-0.0348547362,
0.026264986,
0.0146584045,
-0.0044166455,
-0.0068762451,
0.0086777415,
0.0088219931,
0.0601220429,
0.0374213569,
-0.0568723753,
-0.0206725243,
-0.0481688716,
0.0052023772,
-0.0562181734,
0.0263148863,
0.0504382178,
-0.0014116163,
-0.0552111566,
-0.0691740289,
-0.0473862328,
0.0110385632,
0.0590571426,
0.0324572064,
-0.0228765421,
0.0288290102,
-0.0191305261,
-0.0504602864,
-0.0080796564,
-0.0102816895,
0.0092093535,
-0.0297030807,
-0.0394976959,
0.0497168638,
0.0109006222,
-0.003491201,
-0.0381522551,
-0.0383437462,
-0.0601995587,
0.0416811183,
0.0427609943,
0.0243287254,
0.0295247454,
-0.0480826832,
-0.0621428303,
0.0457184203,
0.0510034487,
0.0290018376,
-0.0045352001,
0.0817131624,
-0.0288817734,
0.0112998374,
0.0428585336,
-0.0059964731,
0.0100519396,
0.0058671967,
0.0290444661,
-0.0528620332,
-0.0317943394,
0.0081931194,
-0.0196683668,
0.0296818912,
-0.0052737854,
-0.0392270014,
-0.0317448862,
0.0160289388,
-0.0111088334,
0.0120808547,
-0.0612029471,
-0.0300091896,
0.0380337723,
-0.0123661645,
-0.0224255621,
0.0982932597,
-0.0403579138,
0.0374306105,
-0.0405789465,
0.0207770374,
0.0155881653,
0.039007131,
0.0014300057,
0.0252794046,
-0.0122771347,
0.0556599237,
0.0233600922,
0.0409454368,
0.0023705529,
0.0000110577,
0.0122719202,
-0.0007273877,
0.0137855085,
0.0210713521,
-0.055920314,
0.0072914185,
-0.053733211,
0.0411647893,
0.0310387462,
-0.0009229918,
0.0768863261,
0.0065208068,
-0.0126071749,
0.0014689863,
0.0121475514,
0.0158254728,
-0.0155333467,
0.0035738542,
0.0007723063,
-0.0182255097,
0.0065382468,
0.0552973263,
0.0350857787,
0.0547269955,
0.0017200419,
0.0039617741,
-0.0418091044,
0.0022527047,
0.0882507414,
0.0628962144,
0.0137482192,
0.0372190475,
-0.023699984,
-0.0862799436,
0.0109317163,
-0.0276205186,
0.0380999148,
-0.0206208806,
0.0146800801,
0.0252648182,
-0.0261534713,
-0.0084723728,
-0.0179272965,
0.0206069294,
0.0795107186,
-0.0212213974,
-0.0029656647,
-6.516761418e-33,
-0.052327998,
-0.0005156264,
-0.0421227925,
-0.0447402671,
0.0171084963,
-0.0029662314,
-0.042753309,
-0.0176061727,
-0.0266990401,
0.0406413637,
-0.0183701366,
0.0213089418,
0.0251364186,
0.0555713624,
-0.0209381413,
-0.0116400104,
0.0872588903,
0.0117474683,
0.0060623665,
-0.0189270731,
0.0275702085,
0.0532896444,
0.0724803507,
-0.0225341395,
-0.0112753287,
-0.0056174984,
-0.0543155,
0.0274210088,
0.037284866,
0.0200748071,
-0.0243722182,
0.0525142848,
-0.007825329,
0.0270965341,
-0.0277826861,
0.0434411317,
-0.0558904521,
-0.0123529248,
-0.0067099906,
0.036669191,
0.0013893978,
-0.0201459918,
0.0707787201,
-0.0099483756,
-0.0316201746,
0.0149093186,
0.029527301,
-0.0207323171,
-0.013086414,
-0.039798025,
-0.0581723414,
0.026506817,
-0.0011430252,
-0.0724523142,
0.0347917452,
0.0087906374,
0.0017147897,
-0.0102468934,
-0.0557110719,
-0.0424549878,
0.0368401445,
0.0477021672,
0.0085668368,
0.0265583154,
-0.0394723155,
0.0368298776,
-0.0007312962,
0.0186834354,
0.0079509374,
-0.0242146794,
0.0732356161,
0.0260606389,
0.036622934,
0.0365008526,
0.0500892177,
-0.0126111638,
-0.0449523553,
0.0273617115,
0.0213986039,
-0.0089617511,
-0.0018325223,
0.0305300839,
0.0020272569,
-0.0358780175,
-0.0296428744,
-0.0474616215,
-0.0117454855,
0.0387417786,
0.0158387162,
-0.0032981902,
-0.0211518295,
0.0159879923,
0.0275826789,
-0.0367036574,
-0.0023359789,
0.0130748032,
0.0025029813,
0.0180092901,
0.005540513,
0.0606590956,
-0.0342255272,
-0.0385093465,
0.0494411625,
0.0587533303,
-0.0112478891,
0.0005659203,
0.0717588738,
0.0176893491,
-0.0837729424,
0.0197369233,
-0.0386053286,
0.0386642627,
-0.0161902346,
0.0666826069,
0.0212988164,
0.0020594131,
-0.0056068255,
0.0312662199,
0.0221372452,
0.0129798399,
-0.0111399554,
0.0472794808,
-0.0077621024,
0.0349196568,
0.0011586769,
-0.009269895,
-0.0155601203,
0.0021427099,
0.0096892342,
-0.0330298357,
0.0061929687,
-0.0241738856,
2.624e-7,
0.015177167,
0.0645994842,
0.0404614583,
-0.0395876206,
0.0467917919,
0.0354380496,
0.0001356504,
0.0679516196,
-0.0049610026,
-0.026750451,
-0.0031204415,
-0.0006773943,
0.0706736967,
0.0325577557,
-0.0657547712,
-0.0509270802,
-0.0909053907,
0.012720502,
-0.0198188443,
0.019780349,
0.0591149777,
0.1062235385,
0.0208772812,
-0.0167587381,
0.0448732302,
-0.0353485681,
0.0587359257,
-0.0142285703,
-0.0128680961,
0.0315007232,
-0.0145995179,
0.0171018299,
0.0078661414,
-0.0007193059,
-0.0385885984,
0.0263988636,
0.0127675291,
0.0894108564,
-0.0317144915,
-0.0419288352,
-0.0092029553,
0.0075585353,
-0.0217209309,
-0.0213013925,
0.040153604,
-0.0027922555,
-0.0210057367,
0.0059081921,
-0.045519039,
0.0121836504,
0.0283788443,
-0.0581133924,
-0.0581944138,
-0.0059175873,
0.0533056818,
0.0049124602,
-0.042639561,
-0.0757355765,
-0.043706283,
0.0210174005,
-0.0538565703,
-0.0079407878,
-0.0085801072,
-0.0366840661,
0.0102451509,
-0.0807240829,
0.0408325531,
2.480551827e-34,
0.0650766939,
-0.002778498,
0.0090223765,
0.0285851508,
0.0046508037,
0.0050898348,
0.0238470007,
-0.0163080171,
0.0217451248,
-0.0509664752,
-0.0172857307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14677v1 | Filter bubbles and affective polarization in user-personalized large language model outputs | 2023-10-31T18:19:28 | 2023-10-31T18:19:28 | Tomo Lazovich | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | Echoing the history of search engines and social media content rankings, the
advent of large language models (LLMs) has led to a push for increased
personalization of model outputs to individual users. In the past, personalized
recommendations and ranking systems have been linked to the development of
filter bubbles (serving content that may confirm a user's existing biases) and
affective polarization (strong negative sentiment towards those with differing
views). In this work, we explore how prompting a leading large language model,
ChatGPT-3.5, with a user's political affiliation prior to asking factual
questions about public figures and organizations leads to differing results. We
observe that left-leaning users tend to receive more positive statements about
left-leaning political figures and media outlets, while right-leaning users see
more positive statements about right-leaning entities. This pattern holds
across presidential candidates, members of the U.S. Senate, and media
organizations with ratings from AllSides. When qualitatively evaluating some of
these outputs, there is evidence that particular facts are included or excluded
based on the user's political affiliation. These results illustrate that
personalizing LLMs based on user demographics carry the same risks of affective
polarization and filter bubbles that have been seen in other personalized
internet technologies. This ``failure mode" should be monitored closely as
there are more attempts to monetize and personalize these models. | [
0.0458182059,
0.0489694849,
-0.0346058086,
0.0215162188,
0.0101522868,
-0.0254749395,
0.0321241245,
-0.0192062631,
0.0803313106,
-0.0470178872,
-0.0301645007,
-0.0236424077,
-0.0202418678,
0.0428414792,
-0.037176583,
-0.0647541434,
0.0450320505,
0.0452186018,
0.0713459253,
-0.0510951728,
0.0372544602,
0.027234111,
0.0444583558,
0.0209298842,
0.0438615866,
-0.0249760579,
0.0293231681,
0.0154136289,
0.0389034487,
-0.0225028247,
-0.0098773958,
0.0227536745,
-0.0461261459,
0.0052320873,
0.0000018693,
-0.0315794274,
-0.0294948705,
-0.0174557697,
0.0036831219,
-0.0294883028,
0.130394578,
0.0727240816,
0.0109381545,
0.0341486484,
-0.0485159233,
0.0423699953,
0.0132651348,
0.0199431833,
0.0577678271,
0.0000075176,
0.0047838027,
0.013331254,
-0.0641116351,
0.0029505629,
0.0369691402,
0.0126742255,
0.025919864,
-0.039593488,
-0.046219103,
0.0108066639,
-0.0302952807,
0.0103656575,
-0.008072488,
0.008219677,
-0.0035479032,
0.0084226448,
-0.0179560333,
-0.026114529,
0.0258575976,
0.032275483,
0.0299282689,
0.0181885939,
0.0061031603,
-0.0167743228,
0.0282233357,
0.0513464883,
-0.0254999138,
0.0347810164,
-0.0431702957,
0.0250397641,
0.0394354202,
-0.0004307866,
0.0227070805,
0.0549553484,
-0.0260525998,
0.1006810367,
-0.0048378888,
-0.0320058838,
-0.0029102776,
0.012720027,
0.0634175986,
-0.0277713127,
0.0676247478,
-0.0489057563,
0.0159635842,
-0.0037020482,
-0.0115583688,
0.0557138398,
0.005121443,
-0.0866159424,
-0.0254137814,
0.0380986556,
-0.0091017215,
0.0539098196,
0.0661997125,
-0.0502298772,
-0.0306909718,
0.0061036684,
0.0117048435,
0.0148852793,
0.006309479,
0.0121882139,
0.0557833165,
0.0423260368,
-0.015022574,
0.0066212309,
-0.0424579456,
0.0147361569,
-0.0465494879,
0.0170994438,
-0.0076309349,
0.0209033526,
0.0077463719,
-0.0084366528,
-0.0775996,
0.0306164138,
-0.0529262759,
0.0033672717,
-0.0229832679,
0.0098275263,
0.0338892266,
0.0267302897,
-0.006013928,
-0.0218185298,
0.0345068723,
-0.0097913984,
0.0379177816,
-0.0152511168,
-0.0017941714,
-0.0222528782,
0.0080320016,
-0.039381627,
0.0096627064,
-0.0320373774,
0.0397141725,
0.0340385847,
0.0197289474,
-0.0261189211,
0.001303374,
0.004176951,
-0.0675026253,
0.0534018353,
0.0404076986,
-0.0014967482,
0.0307280496,
0.0466076657,
0.025028564,
0.0793400034,
-0.0325753316,
0.0502687171,
0.055608809,
-0.0176701527,
-0.0196041632,
0.0057514203,
-0.0279398616,
0.0271838792,
-0.0411037356,
0.0259214062,
-0.0394145325,
-0.0395401977,
0.020007655,
0.0318505168,
-0.0195697844,
-0.0291644391,
0.0746822655,
0.0204785392,
-0.0224412326,
0.0355423391,
0.0033064443,
0.0096301101,
-0.0127936276,
0.0306037515,
-0.0252065435,
0.0316003896,
-0.0148597192,
-0.0533379726,
0.0444834605,
0.0586780645,
-0.0334350467,
-0.018056538,
0.0041860482,
0.0101339277,
0.0750978813,
0.0321532115,
0.0097574061,
-0.0593806319,
-0.0081082871,
0.034708187,
0.0379126109,
-0.0387524739,
0.0271465778,
-0.0539770722,
0.0526104644,
0.0756805018,
0.0049049654,
-0.0089617921,
0.0016793429,
-0.03315394,
-0.020916732,
0.0427473895,
0.0914819017,
-0.0016741322,
-0.0576857589,
-0.0099338591,
-0.0070239231,
0.0359766334,
0.0048301443,
0.0467345193,
0.0155630596,
0.0585403405,
-0.0255819019,
0.0105994176,
0.0142083718,
-0.0275963303,
-0.0083515411,
0.0109494859,
0.0020637617,
0.0140833557,
0.0533544682,
0.041268792,
0.0221344307,
-0.0265105981,
0.0216810461,
0.0071501443,
-0.0374759361,
-0.0169163141,
-0.0054148878,
0.0544805788,
0.0148962652,
-0.0124172987,
-0.0136862379,
0.0218907092,
0.0291941259,
0.021887742,
0.0561511815,
0.0359637141,
0.0237612687,
0.0166870784,
-0.0149611244,
-0.0232990719,
-0.0027110656,
-0.0346260592,
0.0448550619,
-0.0328681841,
0.0267123748,
-0.0003450275,
-0.037470255,
-0.0212939717,
-0.0109151378,
-0.0347722769,
0.0206322931,
0.0355306678,
-0.0092076547,
0.0374016315,
-0.0850519612,
-0.0547348335,
-0.0330510587,
-0.0473915376,
0.0030237355,
-0.0035457429,
0.0387170725,
0.0209772848,
-0.009313833,
-0.0150794797,
0.0310045928,
-0.0368334316,
-0.046492558,
-0.0121658361,
0.0334408656,
-0.0079754135,
-0.001607932,
-0.0301534552,
-0.0373952352,
-0.0232500229,
-0.0331378356,
0.0008215372,
-0.0020076518,
-0.0112048658,
-0.0046867519,
-0.0266244002,
-0.0902234614,
-0.0142719559,
-0.0349720158,
-0.0167698748,
0.0226121265,
0.0161230732,
0.0164564755,
0.0630139261,
0.0446220897,
0.0612691939,
0.051739268,
0.008542384,
-0.0474453419,
-0.0211176723,
-0.0471130945,
0.0372792222,
-0.0281009041,
-0.0527715608,
-0.0040649041,
0.0241201371,
0.0277892519,
0.0194692668,
-0.053966213,
0.0846602693,
-0.0371232107,
0.0031033854,
0.0093358364,
0.0014422737,
-0.0039832862,
0.0275152083,
0.0228417218,
-0.0144101484,
0.026883442,
0.0375211164,
0.0548371226,
-0.0155949974,
-0.0314491466,
-0.009569048,
0.0054277061,
-0.0040768976,
0.0346764959,
-0.0365524888,
0.006695658,
-0.0345990174,
-0.0601015016,
0.0639548451,
-0.0890325755,
0.0165685732,
0.0112130474,
-0.0247319434,
0.009565467,
-0.0402034782,
-0.0268287919,
-0.0757819414,
-0.0040464276,
-0.0328335166,
0.0622944161,
-0.0447880514,
-0.0199205447,
-0.0030102651,
0.0356625952,
-0.0536918156,
-0.0399698094,
-0.0152954301,
0.0275543313,
0.0121411476,
-0.0083749415,
-0.0449933298,
0.0395718776,
0.0072974488,
0.0091999499,
0.0241663139,
0.0016235769,
-0.0043426128,
0.0051359986,
-0.0265974235,
0.0410895571,
-0.0223755762,
-0.0490753688,
-0.0037662291,
0.0196113326,
-0.0083156014,
0.0451979339,
0.0609685965,
0.0404563509,
-0.082785435,
-0.0409444571,
-0.0227670204,
-0.0326078907,
0.0372506641,
0.026021298,
-0.0761485323,
0.0486313961,
0.0072345436,
0.0269068293,
-0.0332497247,
-0.0181150157,
-0.0221500415,
-0.1227999106,
0.0186184291,
0.007208792,
0.020293314,
-0.0114353094,
-0.0494350046,
-0.0053320527,
-0.0245649144,
-0.0228146371,
-0.0036310968,
-0.0104065035,
0.0064440453,
-0.0095989751,
-0.0449145213,
-0.0377475992,
0.0003775573,
-0.0268246084,
0.0310727395,
-0.0021403159,
0.0484599285,
-0.0238774922,
-0.029729683,
0.0022910258,
0.0434125774,
-0.0243011229,
-0.0186789483,
0.0580115393,
-0.0403767563,
0.0316291861,
-0.0652820989,
0.0025086377,
0.0636298209,
0.010723846,
-0.0138197867,
0.0146046495,
-0.0081509696,
-0.0345797539,
-0.026349077,
0.0456398278,
0.0381454863,
0.0753329545,
0.0041384078,
-0.0788700357,
0.0396418981,
-0.0885098279,
0.0267753657,
0.017305946,
-0.0654666275,
-0.0052805943,
-0.0213602409,
-0.016057495,
-0.0280686896,
-0.0403365716,
-0.0241185706,
-0.0081839338,
-0.0042755981,
0.0288362429,
0.0073029115,
-0.0234316047,
0.0262996871,
0.0268165078,
-0.0034495553,
-0.0043621524,
-0.0200930405,
-0.038465526,
0.0089019379,
-0.0505378693,
-0.0264399331,
-0.0205969289,
0.0036838376,
-0.0237495564,
0.0675898865,
0.0273654647,
0.0276897606,
0.0442745239,
-0.0155430101,
-0.0138191599,
0.0122857457,
0.0887173042,
-0.0105791586,
-0.0279152803,
0.02303892,
0.0615643971,
0.0175774917,
0.0059784641,
-0.0275309086,
0.0126997707,
0.037416473,
-0.0806993395,
-0.063168861,
-0.0453359634,
0.0098984865,
0.0291960873,
0.058840476,
0.012726441,
0.0021445416,
-0.0088505568,
-0.0501569659,
-0.0332228616,
-0.0511492081,
0.0267678257,
-0.0344004482,
0.0297935903,
-0.0203761943,
-0.025902709,
0.0190138966,
-0.0229121279,
0.0321311951,
-0.0635278523,
0.0335743167,
-0.0398215279,
-0.0150164599,
0.0269413274,
0.0073148441,
-0.0212429967,
0.0278874934,
0.0198507104,
0.0327308737,
-0.0100290719,
0.0286172219,
-0.0078165792,
-0.0034814035,
0.0223851316,
0.0059603793,
-0.0261644982,
-0.0555819236,
0.0058192154,
0.0477332957,
-0.019853957,
-0.0136842076,
0.0086494116,
0.018357357,
-0.0215520784,
0.0152150141,
-0.0285508912,
0.0198348444,
-0.0100675365,
0.0335746221,
0.0080759265,
-0.0302279182,
-0.0126828579,
0.0497196168,
-0.0180219486,
0.0093067717,
0.0038422775,
-0.0713124722,
-0.0092253126,
-0.0061939266,
0.0036893878,
0.02774694,
-0.0289723575,
-0.0166663155,
-0.0755010396,
-0.0262981225,
-0.0072465306,
-0.001167223,
0.0230524149,
-0.0298284497,
0.0005309909,
0.070157744,
-0.0034406071,
0.0068581654,
-0.0467285402,
0.0267717503,
-0.0962631181,
-0.0099840164,
0.0031496377,
-6.712077886e-33,
-0.0076128896,
-0.0057672719,
-0.0276251361,
-0.0038065603,
0.003340449,
-0.0236754697,
0.0217348561,
0.049775321,
-0.0060941405,
-0.0160452519,
-0.0090014404,
0.0234121382,
0.015194715,
-0.026998749,
0.0132401129,
-0.0413325764,
0.0624744855,
0.0110169332,
-0.0234060921,
0.0281704757,
0.0424699336,
-0.0034960806,
-0.0119529553,
-0.0914944038,
0.0452137217,
-0.0070198323,
-0.0261404701,
-0.0346780159,
-0.0055974624,
0.0288551543,
-0.0036239708,
0.0240040123,
0.0101969894,
-0.0450024456,
0.0057361447,
0.0495000929,
-0.0187551919,
-0.0144344978,
0.0523847081,
-0.0096262433,
0.0135690477,
-0.0195540655,
0.0259254854,
0.0332033746,
-0.0498887934,
0.0110523645,
0.0309578534,
-0.0042488906,
0.0289111584,
-0.0135735543,
0.0339526311,
0.0207799599,
0.0060659563,
0.0407724902,
-0.0254273079,
0.0391497277,
0.0173171703,
0.0919379592,
-0.0639053434,
0.0301781986,
-0.054225143,
0.0186575335,
0.0129311644,
-0.0081158653,
-0.0184454825,
0.0669509321,
0.0270028189,
0.075094454,
-0.0394042209,
-0.0362397619,
-0.0068778782,
-0.0223795827,
0.0114836292,
0.0747702047,
0.0182363894,
-0.075719662,
-0.0271349419,
0.011178988,
0.0636292249,
-0.0428039283,
0.0660736114,
-0.0249296874,
-0.0246444959,
-0.0293349996,
0.0053194836,
-0.0894292146,
-0.0540330522,
-0.0409997329,
-0.0038837851,
0.0260833353,
-0.0545192696,
-0.0208858009,
0.0180218108,
-0.0432759039,
-0.0528948978,
0.0098170955,
-0.0550558381,
-0.0250489283,
0.0172873884,
-0.0065763821,
-0.0423902534,
0.0184180811,
-0.0760783032,
-0.0280729104,
-0.0269097947,
-0.0153856799,
-0.0114358235,
0.0092870668,
-0.0685444027,
-0.0110375481,
0.0075268368,
0.006264511,
0.0057736412,
0.0404904075,
0.0327564813,
0.0406256653,
0.007576243,
0.0155103421,
0.0759125352,
0.082272999,
-0.0160025191,
-0.0574341305,
-0.045949962,
0.0272423234,
-0.0194462836,
-0.046665404,
-0.0443978161,
0.0341040231,
0.0308236871,
-0.0562868007,
-0.0391919091,
-0.0715772361,
2.676e-7,
0.0220934339,
0.0785908774,
-0.0622710176,
0.0272348821,
0.0254256129,
0.0399474613,
0.0320211388,
0.0218876675,
0.0264760517,
-0.0185426809,
-0.0414555743,
0.009502152,
-0.003371076,
0.0697327927,
-0.0650467724,
0.0088986615,
-0.0396256447,
0.0233899336,
-0.0397975445,
0.0285717025,
-0.0148186181,
0.0184688475,
0.0587509163,
0.0183911566,
-0.0222604014,
0.0027806712,
0.0518282354,
-0.0502522849,
-0.0534458943,
0.0018090842,
0.0362362973,
-0.0147113074,
0.0025941287,
0.0248258803,
-0.0099371877,
0.0051205023,
-0.0064101894,
0.0362545326,
0.0183272734,
0.0050430167,
-0.0074797454,
0.0096050529,
0.0075301221,
-0.0583306402,
0.0691192448,
-0.0135628963,
-0.0162431207,
-0.0880555362,
-0.0456163362,
-0.0264689252,
0.0827937201,
-0.0269140005,
-0.0333917849,
0.0047816397,
-0.0365158431,
0.0052849678,
-0.0170483552,
-0.0322459973,
-0.0091357939,
-0.0476685576,
-0.0359689295,
-0.0918562859,
-0.0063821157,
0.0334196351,
0.0119237276,
-0.000008431,
0.0257476754,
2.260308496e-34,
0.023048576,
0.0387556739,
-0.0035554618,
-0.0930914432,
0.0428699218,
0.0164481699,
-0.034301769,
-0.0157512296,
0.0312163979,
-0.0347087011,
0.0140585126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00059v1 | The Generative AI Paradox: "What It Can Create, It May Not Understand" | 2023-10-31T18:07:07 | 2023-10-31T18:07:07 | Peter West, Ximing Lu, Nouha Dziri, Faeze Brahman, Linjie Li, Jena D. Hwang, Liwei Jiang, Jillian Fisher, Abhilasha Ravichander, Khyathi Chandu, Benjamin Newman, Pang Wei Koh, Allyson Ettinger, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | The recent wave of generative AI has sparked unprecedented global attention,
with both excitement and concern over potentially superhuman levels of
artificial intelligence: models now take only seconds to produce outputs that
would challenge or exceed the capabilities even of expert humans. At the same
time, models still show basic errors in understanding that would not be
expected even in non-expert humans. This presents us with an apparent paradox:
how do we reconcile seemingly superhuman capabilities with the persistence of
errors that few humans would make? In this work, we posit that this tension
reflects a divergence in the configuration of intelligence in today's
generative models relative to intelligence in humans. Specifically, we propose
and test the Generative AI Paradox hypothesis: generative models, having been
trained directly to reproduce expert-like outputs, acquire generative
capabilities that are not contingent upon -- and can therefore exceed -- their
ability to understand those same types of outputs. This contrasts with humans,
for whom basic understanding almost always precedes the ability to generate
expert-level outputs. We test this hypothesis through controlled experiments
analyzing generation vs. understanding in generative models, across both
language and image modalities. Our results show that although models can
outperform humans in generation, they consistently fall short of human
capabilities in measures of understanding, as well as weaker correlation
between generation and understanding performance, and more brittleness to
adversarial inputs. Our findings support the hypothesis that models' generative
capability may not be contingent upon understanding capability, and call for
caution in interpreting artificial intelligence by analogy to human
intelligence. | [
0.0217372887,
0.0789401531,
-0.0436313674,
-0.0068670176,
0.0012269632,
0.0086438628,
0.0392988026,
0.0195182096,
-0.0161060691,
0.0028038092,
-0.0105636436,
-0.007691191,
0.0006015178,
0.0419626385,
0.0491799004,
-0.0528529137,
0.0106846886,
-0.0172331482,
0.0134891141,
-0.0213198159,
-0.0589486621,
-0.0143974079,
0.0069132401,
0.0224815868,
-0.0341831334,
-0.0019657931,
0.0218985621,
0.0094608441,
0.0086582238,
0.0031406449,
-0.040917594,
0.0261712186,
0.0107769053,
0.0629984438,
0.000001885,
-0.0364339687,
0.0399076603,
0.001071882,
-0.0381896272,
0.0054668291,
0.0200681016,
-0.0139179863,
-0.0207654256,
-0.0103560062,
-0.0557373352,
0.0266384669,
0.0305509232,
0.0233928133,
-0.0102630863,
0.053301882,
-0.0046889228,
0.0039559593,
0.0751971081,
-0.0427411199,
0.0173653066,
-0.0290028974,
-0.0170337055,
0.0031091841,
-0.0115537271,
-0.0002876371,
-0.0151822828,
0.0285952371,
0.0516876653,
0.0175639912,
0.006639014,
0.0759042427,
0.0588962547,
-0.0589259341,
0.0225783661,
0.0191584826,
-0.0269724112,
-0.0008823134,
-0.0058974396,
-0.0057678623,
0.0341096707,
0.0184859894,
-0.0396371074,
0.0651134998,
-0.0147440033,
0.0006973667,
-0.0141940173,
-0.0026714841,
0.0290878043,
-0.0157567784,
0.005989321,
-0.0176648013,
0.0031369536,
-0.0224462245,
-0.0436184183,
0.0297373403,
-0.0361537747,
-0.0511261523,
-0.0260010697,
-0.0040784818,
-0.0034905446,
0.0020864373,
-0.0623295195,
-0.0141779082,
0.0091335028,
0.0217937697,
0.0348934308,
-0.0025911098,
-0.0028896031,
0.0236822888,
-0.0124532785,
0.0775596723,
-0.0107958289,
0.0394061282,
-0.0338924415,
0.0221623927,
-0.0764908791,
-0.0417250469,
0.0087698726,
-0.0216045342,
-0.0173795875,
-0.0072647496,
-0.0182257462,
0.0040332703,
-0.0453699008,
0.03956227,
-0.0447918214,
0.0411592387,
-0.0423479825,
-0.0020420682,
-0.0378112011,
-0.0190289505,
-0.0674942136,
0.028455263,
0.0326106921,
-0.0773563087,
-0.0184924919,
0.0047213696,
-0.0173702165,
0.0243508834,
0.019458672,
0.0798394904,
-0.0177178029,
0.0045373579,
-0.0000727341,
-0.0206893571,
0.0244228728,
-0.0594507381,
0.0435555167,
-0.0266672634,
0.0266764443,
0.0229773764,
0.0005332968,
-0.0835135728,
-0.0232873242,
-0.0130730625,
-0.0115748663,
0.0391360372,
-0.0086721471,
0.018771464,
0.0495446399,
0.0416784398,
-0.0220335945,
0.0083163036,
0.0202674028,
0.0343984738,
0.0058888108,
0.0189913455,
0.066775538,
-0.0070535168,
0.0183476396,
-0.0045188763,
-0.0306193158,
-0.0306668635,
-0.0381191187,
0.0380412936,
0.0580311567,
0.0397372879,
-0.0295832697,
0.0035268445,
0.0775023922,
0.0372310914,
-0.035059493,
0.1051891968,
0.0759656355,
-0.0179303121,
0.0175135378,
0.0356962532,
-0.071306631,
0.0439171158,
-0.0003514399,
-0.0020277733,
-0.0228743032,
0.0202432889,
-0.0418436341,
-0.0544516817,
0.0244369488,
0.0025154629,
-0.0162620619,
-0.0023456963,
0.0264703073,
0.0343292169,
-0.0300882384,
-0.0423881747,
-0.0284740441,
-0.051905483,
-0.0026727,
-0.0921882764,
0.0363432355,
0.0600911193,
0.0310966894,
0.005951073,
0.021279972,
0.0257816613,
-0.0487093292,
0.0327250808,
0.0173204895,
-0.0020977051,
0.00556139,
0.0091100205,
-0.0120964283,
-0.0741239786,
0.0347240567,
0.0259565301,
-0.0137595851,
0.0075129746,
-0.01148328,
-0.0332948938,
-0.0217225514,
0.0170914009,
-0.05772328,
-0.0079462118,
-0.0466979779,
-0.0046307845,
0.0126480144,
-0.0070375386,
-0.042290017,
0.0204102807,
0.0271484144,
-0.0374857038,
-0.0533059761,
0.0434493721,
-0.0276002996,
0.0312135033,
-0.0230554622,
-0.0968833864,
-0.0264050383,
0.0145023689,
-0.0140506951,
-0.0078121903,
0.0446989499,
-0.0316287205,
0.0261657257,
-0.0231571998,
0.0172790438,
-0.0248331856,
0.0279438235,
0.0067178411,
0.0839684382,
-0.0139388712,
-0.021802485,
-0.0000413755,
0.0110725919,
0.0202177409,
-0.0275110491,
0.0332170017,
0.0174602773,
-0.0207874253,
0.0010559259,
0.0225257929,
-0.0028965992,
-0.0488240458,
-0.0010149806,
-0.0622418486,
-0.0321800187,
-0.0127588362,
-0.0062628221,
0.016518645,
-0.0396227241,
-0.0146410419,
0.0071333488,
-0.023494808,
0.0205688588,
0.0201887079,
0.0137834037,
0.0150362374,
0.0073009892,
-0.0013714551,
-0.0107130241,
0.0082717277,
0.0108787687,
0.0345386565,
0.0569450893,
0.0338674448,
-0.019264264,
0.0416513234,
-0.0283421297,
0.0053461315,
-0.0197729673,
-0.0248056185,
0.0355788022,
-0.0106466617,
0.0314485431,
0.0572291389,
0.0184330251,
0.0660265759,
0.0445853919,
0.0383107662,
-0.0251272917,
-0.0083964709,
0.0261150394,
-0.0293690301,
-0.0087604588,
-0.0593697876,
-0.0129449088,
0.0466832332,
0.0299981851,
0.0209488831,
-0.0200325735,
0.1121961996,
-0.0200150032,
-0.0983443186,
-0.0023225166,
-0.004787731,
0.0098492522,
0.0735481828,
-0.0649594292,
-0.0838709995,
0.0373076461,
0.0186220706,
0.0115765715,
0.0234440304,
-0.0000839045,
0.0374510363,
0.0815170705,
0.0403642245,
0.0463026986,
0.0176232141,
0.0146914106,
-0.0879471451,
0.0453125201,
0.0360286422,
-0.0154718207,
-0.0107837105,
-0.0552565753,
-0.0305097364,
-0.0127129089,
-0.0497730039,
-0.0632870346,
0.0294394996,
0.0133699356,
0.0291444622,
0.040543519,
-0.0513422675,
0.0056080972,
-0.0556535609,
0.0265559927,
-0.0042160898,
0.007609874,
-0.0528639778,
0.0138516752,
0.0224418789,
0.0381081887,
-0.0076431995,
0.0327679664,
-0.0637320131,
0.0226112735,
0.0449612141,
0.0096351141,
0.0334689207,
-0.0252029616,
0.0203493461,
-0.0020784703,
0.0285488646,
-0.0329559743,
0.0463980436,
0.0524099804,
-0.0188303944,
-0.0268003345,
0.0601019226,
0.0207673572,
0.0103254728,
0.0310099125,
0.0110911988,
-0.0164259076,
0.030388955,
0.0278899558,
-0.0482996367,
0.0225084927,
0.0045576915,
0.0340994,
-0.0345032588,
-0.0365551077,
0.012975933,
-0.0837476328,
0.0856484845,
-0.0034385954,
-0.019559497,
-0.0465945303,
0.0083208745,
-0.0490452498,
0.0059893876,
-0.005939642,
-0.0079737995,
0.0154493703,
0.025163481,
0.0066610062,
0.0447746553,
-0.0502421595,
-0.0011259472,
-0.0141192935,
0.0309220124,
0.0874161497,
0.04222003,
-0.0086713247,
-0.0280755833,
-0.0207260828,
0.0460012034,
0.0363132507,
0.0179878324,
0.0501323789,
0.0378420316,
-0.0026996168,
-0.0170673151,
0.0583046265,
0.0007054381,
-0.0281415023,
-0.0009331498,
0.0209232476,
-0.0066774464,
-0.0799265578,
-0.0457267053,
-0.0205115303,
-0.0234265868,
0.0652312487,
0.0462955236,
-0.0149157019,
-0.069849208,
-0.0606383309,
0.0518996529,
-0.0859625936,
-0.0377693921,
0.0378887281,
0.0551538281,
-0.049799338,
-0.0835010037,
-0.0455069877,
-0.0506799072,
0.0202574618,
0.015136227,
-0.049057994,
-0.0297987778,
-0.0163784903,
-0.0402319431,
-0.0108793601,
0.0277642962,
-0.0414977446,
-0.0325365253,
-0.0630682409,
-0.0138304206,
-0.0798662975,
-0.0158660393,
0.0175281558,
-0.0632025599,
-0.0279401746,
0.0232698824,
0.0725810379,
0.0308108628,
0.0051024212,
0.0308522917,
-0.0267192479,
0.0632488057,
0.0660789832,
-0.0264030173,
0.0319486223,
0.0228098221,
0.0091550788,
-0.0033500406,
0.0257673971,
-0.0204473753,
0.0419365875,
0.0311808605,
-0.0107515221,
-0.0233244058,
0.0054483749,
0.0357160196,
-0.0012513702,
0.0112357922,
-0.0613359958,
0.0107096517,
-0.0143267233,
-0.033495333,
0.014099759,
-0.0049604899,
-0.0327988639,
-0.05355094,
0.0406489745,
0.0358385816,
0.0137154758,
0.0523490421,
0.0095040705,
0.0227796305,
-0.0497477166,
-0.0110846162,
0.0044856826,
0.0329903737,
-0.0088415463,
0.0177716985,
0.0077815778,
0.021818988,
-0.056717772,
0.0303011611,
0.0089949872,
0.0648165941,
0.001744273,
0.0279091801,
-0.0071407701,
0.007547284,
-0.0900717229,
-0.0978726074,
0.0157555658,
0.061700426,
0.072166726,
0.0023832833,
0.0129902018,
-0.036551062,
0.0143371569,
-0.0129090864,
0.0159070417,
0.0202773884,
-0.050621707,
-0.0148167992,
0.0063223792,
-0.0103743449,
-0.0176223181,
0.0819421858,
-0.0227344669,
0.0720656887,
-0.0514157601,
0.0021645145,
-0.0232113712,
-0.0598899908,
0.0125505831,
-0.0534506813,
0.042884849,
0.0339686535,
-0.0395165533,
-0.0737808421,
-0.0293415356,
0.047671441,
0.0477107577,
-0.0137101132,
-0.0065787612,
0.0599982664,
-0.0617035478,
-0.0300417207,
-0.0141564654,
0.0187426768,
-0.016801022,
0.0056858822,
-0.0175024681,
-6.138614804e-33,
-0.0050901854,
-0.0313465446,
0.0095417071,
-0.0496185571,
0.0124702975,
-0.0178189278,
-0.0685530454,
0.0051328624,
-0.0249310527,
0.0265629347,
-0.028442543,
-0.0070825969,
-0.0235658959,
0.0204796847,
0.0425784439,
0.0130550349,
0.0650788099,
-0.0196563359,
-0.0325078145,
0.0411504768,
0.0393528417,
-0.0038336772,
-0.0068861879,
-0.0572231896,
0.0174435675,
-0.0267121643,
-0.0297395792,
-0.0331529491,
-0.0023927065,
0.0247375257,
-0.0206683893,
0.0218703281,
0.0370525718,
-0.0736286268,
-0.0221005157,
-0.0412860401,
-0.0422243588,
0.0013783015,
-0.0518515483,
-0.0391547084,
-0.0515129156,
-0.0611971393,
0.0406293459,
-0.0027899158,
-0.0444830246,
-0.0140843987,
0.0469295755,
-0.0097484756,
0.0174149573,
-0.0585594811,
-0.0825527832,
-0.0190039538,
-0.0479150191,
0.0084665781,
-0.0110161463,
0.0222546495,
-0.0033906908,
-0.0432148464,
-0.0335379578,
0.0471711606,
0.0219661202,
-0.005591278,
0.0828476027,
-0.0153468093,
0.0142771695,
0.0420646258,
0.0735496432,
0.0054416102,
-0.0156633984,
-0.0038800973,
-0.0031392148,
0.0666681603,
0.0171648711,
0.0568722896,
0.0474097244,
-0.0467602052,
-0.0207328182,
0.0368691161,
-0.0347102955,
0.0104788011,
0.0250087213,
0.0152680604,
-0.0249611847,
0.005497145,
-0.0043058917,
-0.0630653054,
-0.0224211663,
-0.0144136334,
0.0229311176,
0.0300948452,
0.011763595,
-0.0478106402,
0.0130830454,
-0.0552913807,
0.0566870943,
0.0155218104,
-0.0403994396,
0.0252809376,
0.0176862925,
-0.0019898179,
-0.0243193284,
-0.0433466062,
0.0441855974,
0.0530540086,
0.0460318848,
0.0169954523,
0.0418359265,
0.0060091252,
0.0072583365,
-0.0048634331,
-0.0496089496,
0.0463380516,
0.0404864363,
-0.057952486,
0.0188167635,
0.0049393554,
-0.0263111144,
-0.0624215044,
-0.0113288723,
0.0262455642,
-0.0329799168,
0.0429252312,
-0.0200840235,
0.0030431445,
-0.0436430387,
-0.0270640124,
-0.0683108494,
0.0005067438,
0.0383494347,
-0.0756810904,
-0.0360693447,
-0.0045286724,
2.659e-7,
-0.020109484,
0.0309769399,
0.0089660464,
0.0021146284,
0.0462370515,
0.0473613143,
-0.0125115272,
0.0268937144,
-0.0223096721,
0.0379881486,
0.0208603553,
0.0556017086,
0.0150467623,
0.0156167811,
0.0042070202,
0.0057368004,
-0.050692223,
0.0526626483,
-0.0295540765,
0.0215911362,
0.0619757064,
0.0164784435,
-0.0078231553,
-0.0248834137,
0.0665884316,
-0.0605612732,
0.0531135276,
-0.0116097741,
0.0576492399,
-0.0219863672,
0.0296973046,
0.0585582294,
0.0128446175,
0.0305356793,
-0.0340319052,
-0.0372462124,
0.0055989209,
0.0340533517,
-0.0010668038,
-0.0095018409,
-0.0092125526,
0.0329413302,
0.0287624933,
-0.0511879958,
0.0451048464,
-0.0334953964,
-0.0290586799,
-0.0014560906,
-0.0272158049,
0.0143773248,
-0.0109133096,
-0.0211195555,
0.0063158101,
-0.0077622505,
-0.0087730614,
0.0038254731,
0.0102112601,
-0.0335613079,
0.0151098911,
0.0090976749,
-0.0704898387,
-0.0444858111,
-0.0593753345,
0.0426724516,
0.0578881167,
0.016969312,
-0.0225687511,
1.811749265e-34,
-0.0018936229,
-0.0057339077,
0.0291055813,
-0.0495429635,
0.0372860506,
-0.0135609657,
-0.0241865087,
-0.0087372391,
0.0230967142,
0.0052155224,
-0.0313435122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.00047v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.00047v1 | Grounding Visual Illusions in Language: Do Vision-Language Models Perceive Illusions Like Humans? | 2023-10-31T18:01:11 | 2023-10-31T18:01:11 | Yichi Zhang, Jiayi Pan, Yuchen Zhou, Rui Pan, Joyce Chai | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Vision-Language Models (VLMs) are trained on vast amounts of data captured by
humans emulating our understanding of the world. However, known as visual
illusions, human's perception of reality isn't always faithful to the physical
world. This raises a key question: do VLMs have the similar kind of illusions
as humans do, or do they faithfully learn to represent reality? To investigate
this question, we build a dataset containing five types of visual illusions and
formulate four tasks to examine visual illusions in state-of-the-art VLMs. Our
findings have shown that although the overall alignment is low, larger models
are closer to human perception and more susceptible to visual illusions. Our
dataset and initial findings will promote a better understanding of visual
illusions in humans and machines and provide a stepping stone for future
computational models that can better align humans and machines in perceiving
and communicating about the shared visual world. The code and data are
available at https://github.com/vl-illusion/dataset. | [
0.033797808,
0.0526372753,
-0.0335322544,
0.083322458,
-0.0370116718,
0.0280877519,
-0.0096519515,
0.0131850578,
-0.0232444406,
-0.0635038093,
-0.0393486992,
-0.0264627282,
0.0661585629,
0.0268566813,
0.0588947423,
-0.0779052526,
0.0344703831,
-0.0264500082,
-0.0239327364,
-0.0158708356,
-0.0113259014,
-0.0068875407,
-0.0086019896,
0.0082257008,
-0.0120537747,
-0.056161847,
0.0003967884,
0.027908748,
0.0037805014,
0.0143189225,
-0.0184233654,
0.0094674937,
0.0232167859,
0.0353838019,
0.0000018568,
-0.0162516478,
0.0579626895,
-0.0214376114,
0.0115532549,
0.003332451,
0.0227378029,
-0.050157629,
-0.0030904103,
-0.0018122654,
-0.0361927934,
-0.0158082731,
0.055645436,
0.0416625328,
0.0347017832,
0.0462483913,
0.0027468782,
0.0060624941,
-0.0105363987,
0.0131091094,
0.0147367604,
0.0163713358,
0.0502956696,
0.0018144132,
-0.0744663849,
-0.0236136839,
-0.0293178167,
-0.0303538293,
-0.0014331245,
0.0296333171,
-0.0206785295,
0.0397964008,
-0.0318361297,
-0.044072099,
-0.0163669046,
0.0565620773,
-0.0502608791,
-0.0787931755,
-0.0071147839,
-0.0052527483,
0.0347164981,
0.0314439051,
0.0025577103,
0.038955722,
0.0120229404,
0.0362384133,
-0.0571348481,
-0.0139263617,
0.0248853639,
0.0053352304,
0.0002646962,
-0.0055224411,
-0.0015477503,
-0.0048727677,
-0.0054718275,
0.0026568198,
-0.0385853499,
-0.0791005269,
-0.0124586318,
0.0081644421,
-0.0323444009,
-0.0071648317,
-0.0727928951,
-0.0218028948,
0.0031931992,
-0.0576838255,
0.0545516275,
0.0185122602,
-0.0380382687,
0.0210217629,
-0.0357755609,
0.1154763773,
-0.0171349905,
0.0771701261,
-0.042769134,
-0.005543855,
0.0152599169,
0.0068611419,
-0.0119812498,
-0.0443731323,
-0.030326562,
-0.0129114203,
-0.0446961261,
-0.0195658617,
-0.0470542051,
0.0450787693,
-0.0156852826,
0.0396423191,
-0.0104668131,
-0.0256591067,
-0.0438830853,
0.0167664122,
0.0527378209,
0.0302530862,
-0.0443125553,
-0.0982275754,
0.0068970178,
0.0391700827,
-0.0316281989,
-0.0084947692,
-0.0140480893,
0.0229877345,
0.0034196237,
-0.0038486356,
-0.0404944941,
0.0289367065,
0.0051634316,
-0.0314374082,
0.0476006344,
-0.0513010025,
0.0114396494,
-0.018169675,
-0.0040616947,
-0.0383140519,
0.022199966,
0.03199213,
-0.0426773876,
0.0867047459,
-0.0677868277,
0.0078799222,
-0.0033140196,
0.0066460604,
-0.0082732718,
0.0305945259,
0.0169491265,
0.0406633578,
0.0170062315,
-0.020720968,
0.0483269915,
0.0098217623,
0.0109304013,
-0.00563114,
-0.0755094811,
-0.0144103821,
-0.0072152452,
0.0265866704,
0.0413028635,
0.0455545746,
0.0136994645,
-0.0645161197,
0.1039778367,
0.0139301652,
-0.0249444097,
-0.011382035,
-0.0037794865,
-0.0043452242,
0.0159346666,
0.0109417317,
-0.075616464,
0.0303723644,
0.0061855731,
0.0260149017,
-0.0666249171,
0.0400997102,
-0.0155697465,
-0.0317857154,
-0.0412362516,
-0.0216055587,
0.0224605929,
0.0142510924,
0.0331485979,
0.0034410264,
-0.0714507103,
-0.0179108884,
0.0213445537,
-0.0089696739,
-0.0163697619,
-0.0562825315,
-0.018871177,
0.0410229228,
0.0071306485,
0.0175973885,
-0.0062456182,
-0.0027021116,
0.011266998,
0.0461933464,
0.0608153902,
0.0162966792,
-0.0012594115,
-0.0120614897,
-0.0145964241,
-0.024026908,
0.019870894,
-0.0064363936,
-0.0202369057,
-0.0098194145,
-0.004690073,
-0.0540403388,
-0.0110665513,
0.0607124791,
0.000424904,
0.03143676,
-0.0482980758,
-0.0114831673,
-0.000674504,
-0.0059171561,
-0.0125054726,
0.0075956099,
0.0241186358,
0.0080675101,
0.0102127921,
0.0176141504,
-0.0197573788,
-0.0017388504,
0.0607198067,
-0.0907530189,
-0.008820395,
0.0373669565,
-0.0120789018,
-0.0220452268,
0.0059816376,
-0.0359874293,
0.0363718197,
-0.0140312854,
0.0323003121,
-0.0002371903,
0.0496567413,
0.0234973561,
0.0470845513,
-0.0420681275,
0.023709923,
-0.0233540013,
0.0064206733,
0.005039128,
-0.0331578404,
0.0122949257,
-0.0215573572,
-0.0114073874,
0.012179452,
-0.0199559219,
-0.0238865204,
-0.0593350902,
0.0184145365,
-0.0564447008,
-0.0523280911,
-0.0082380669,
-0.0391457565,
0.0361499116,
-0.0428192317,
-0.0137301851,
-0.0372383446,
-0.0377628729,
0.0708654448,
-0.0185560472,
-0.0007074946,
0.0243316218,
-0.0499339402,
-0.0098358737,
-0.0040199081,
0.0207346752,
-0.0051786294,
0.0533510037,
-0.0219775084,
-0.0398631059,
-0.0682646558,
0.0215093866,
-0.0410307497,
0.0544165596,
-0.0165402759,
-0.0537922978,
-0.026010124,
0.0376144499,
0.0204937216,
0.0640555099,
0.0085316999,
0.0694835559,
0.0601465032,
0.0105976546,
-0.0143784685,
-0.0391552523,
0.0077264844,
-0.0041036583,
-0.0099224877,
-0.0428862758,
-0.0136188809,
0.061982587,
0.0144917499,
0.0127606504,
-0.0392455757,
0.0746428892,
0.0029755179,
-0.063501738,
-0.0041647274,
-0.0107968012,
-0.0134565476,
0.0621344447,
-0.0324858762,
-0.046213761,
0.0501323715,
-0.0342361629,
-0.0078517646,
0.0267604981,
0.0450073965,
0.070724234,
0.0028557724,
0.043676585,
0.0250488706,
0.0288671143,
0.024249319,
-0.0777120143,
-0.0081358645,
-0.0041865436,
-0.0374128595,
0.0198136996,
-0.0790761784,
-0.0057861153,
-0.0127617586,
-0.0087385876,
-0.0697734505,
0.0178382918,
-0.0207085218,
-0.0194252357,
-0.0748044029,
-0.0085561834,
-0.0665330887,
-0.0093644774,
-0.0054366682,
-0.004523241,
0.0131704453,
-0.0147641841,
-0.0170217138,
-0.0117635019,
0.0832102671,
0.019788295,
0.0409885682,
-0.0420408025,
-0.0047484436,
0.0585256331,
0.0093563395,
0.0332294852,
-0.0307369493,
-0.0021548879,
0.0350502133,
0.0203066114,
0.0031513975,
0.0454023071,
0.0162321534,
-0.0185552146,
-0.0287545491,
0.0811267793,
0.0493426472,
-0.0331013873,
0.0295995679,
0.000285013,
0.0025590288,
0.0329635367,
-0.0104948506,
-0.0871668383,
-0.0047732904,
0.0314112306,
-0.0385552384,
-0.0043192417,
0.0019500582,
-0.0334170721,
-0.0969686061,
0.0471766368,
0.0204375088,
-0.0003640091,
-0.0916912258,
0.0084684519,
-0.001574493,
0.0036635313,
0.0887047201,
-0.006934043,
0.0096549792,
-0.0123194261,
-0.019656444,
0.0567890443,
-0.0264040735,
-0.0188791938,
0.0006488262,
0.0396988578,
0.0318321548,
0.0311422963,
0.0217923727,
-0.1142475009,
0.0237613916,
0.0229962971,
0.0161807667,
0.0141092027,
0.0546541288,
-0.011479754,
-0.0367876701,
-0.0085697416,
0.033242438,
-0.0469687879,
-0.0433606468,
-0.0337501131,
-0.0093445824,
-0.0154416384,
-0.0402112231,
-0.0035906734,
-0.0218917467,
-0.0269349758,
0.0493315458,
0.0321541391,
-0.0089432029,
-0.0294563752,
-0.0033656682,
0.0504810214,
0.0392816551,
-0.043855641,
0.0488759577,
0.0485182181,
0.0196841676,
-0.0669442266,
-0.0472310334,
-0.0164208375,
0.015583951,
0.0096606584,
-0.0431351587,
0.0475058407,
-0.0139814401,
-0.0720096454,
0.0464677028,
-0.038804289,
0.0471969619,
-0.0013692799,
-0.017197378,
-0.0065602921,
-0.0300270598,
-0.0098530278,
-0.0195664912,
-0.0759086758,
-0.0251839999,
0.0293792989,
0.0185399577,
0.01909017,
0.061263185,
0.0163012873,
-0.0315253772,
0.0413950272,
0.0111599658,
0.0227501523,
0.0375998132,
0.0045087282,
-0.0068833735,
0.0098018907,
0.0378551483,
-0.0190824252,
0.0059111542,
0.0313645974,
-0.0217222292,
0.0057435874,
0.011150944,
0.0570742488,
-0.0145552224,
0.0923047513,
-0.0212524347,
0.058951702,
-0.018436579,
-0.0108084949,
-0.0132756336,
-0.0149053829,
-0.0353165641,
-0.0475776978,
0.0283806249,
0.0499024838,
0.0116215106,
-0.0466627181,
-0.0275597442,
-0.0132609829,
-0.0302969087,
-0.0551737174,
0.0191860553,
-0.0082915612,
0.0139737651,
0.0211910699,
0.0266406257,
0.0699698403,
-0.0402169302,
0.0393849202,
0.051590234,
0.0490793474,
0.0416862294,
-0.0260829069,
-0.0457211472,
0.0127114458,
0.0270067938,
-0.0392075665,
-0.0470537134,
0.0878451839,
0.0730560124,
-0.0352065787,
0.0261626262,
-0.0244275089,
0.0034693405,
0.007796423,
0.0237463433,
0.0133827645,
-0.0053229346,
0.052888874,
0.0024534797,
-0.0316032507,
-0.0310397726,
0.0653238297,
-0.0063794064,
0.0170850661,
-0.0158793256,
-0.0152899539,
-0.0273233987,
-0.0139709534,
0.0305564571,
0.0186820608,
-0.0125616658,
0.0311315879,
-0.037927296,
-0.0990114063,
-0.0271514319,
0.0436401479,
0.0501272082,
0.0044604465,
0.0285969414,
0.0428323075,
-0.0047889347,
0.0059910836,
0.0035830115,
-0.0384029299,
0.0172187667,
-0.0252370387,
0.0050649419,
-5.747784605e-33,
-0.0011637524,
-0.0094105536,
-0.011691723,
0.0135363014,
-0.0070713591,
0.0239578895,
-0.0161834359,
0.0041319672,
-0.0414474308,
0.0555465147,
0.0127527723,
0.0441450663,
0.0014633085,
0.0266239624,
-0.0319164209,
0.0037956841,
0.0250298623,
-0.0443725549,
-0.0307780132,
-0.0560736097,
-0.0036800972,
-0.0149750989,
0.0715109408,
-0.0678707138,
0.0284706,
0.006095998,
-0.0398054905,
0.0263347719,
0.0056999903,
0.0316237584,
-0.0486225486,
0.0416158661,
0.0188262369,
0.0169951096,
-0.0229681842,
0.0299774427,
0.0073571973,
-0.0096462015,
0.0226043444,
0.0969289243,
-0.0532115176,
0.0199163426,
0.0694139078,
-0.0154935913,
-0.0590212606,
0.0145358443,
0.0485903695,
-0.0362548083,
0.0279274881,
0.049457036,
-0.0316674039,
-0.0531749576,
0.0047155111,
-0.0350159705,
0.0590172596,
-0.0083246846,
-0.0128501914,
0.0228708331,
-0.0855225176,
0.0310003776,
-0.0404224806,
-0.0005467837,
0.1020456031,
0.0248143896,
0.033760678,
0.0590211712,
0.0801160485,
0.0133666471,
-0.0198833793,
0.0154814497,
0.043146085,
0.0070541827,
0.0480695255,
0.0589272864,
0.0463298745,
-0.0097607337,
-0.0071915509,
-0.0319789723,
-0.0570072643,
0.0092609245,
0.0174577758,
0.0236129835,
-0.024754893,
-0.0140264519,
-0.038494993,
-0.0281907935,
-0.0437517911,
0.0219653249,
0.0368815623,
-0.0132404147,
0.0349818319,
0.0031624162,
0.0258421469,
-0.0659749284,
-0.0310920198,
-0.0376911685,
-0.010237202,
0.0216516964,
0.0060358378,
0.0015135534,
-0.0464176908,
-0.0361534283,
0.0535252951,
0.0428688973,
0.0160089843,
0.0225181933,
0.0209983736,
-0.0303270146,
-0.0301523432,
0.0149480235,
-0.0536945947,
-0.0271190219,
0.0294258222,
-0.0170025136,
0.0687141344,
-0.0043656817,
-0.0575665385,
-0.0181622654,
0.0187831726,
-0.0468110926,
-0.0201503169,
0.0156269837,
-0.0536986701,
0.0154931452,
-0.045189105,
-0.0358356126,
-0.0667348355,
-0.0440146066,
0.0316909105,
-0.0187637899,
-0.0262281522,
-0.0290854983,
2.473e-7,
-0.0127801215,
0.05596219,
-0.0054890821,
0.0500058196,
0.0515741743,
0.0590980724,
0.0012665646,
0.0205418598,
0.002589287,
-0.0810293034,
-0.0147770746,
0.0269272048,
0.0105535667,
-0.038672246,
0.0020890143,
0.0693433359,
-0.0345791355,
0.0048045716,
-0.0122430651,
0.0220485553,
0.0330830105,
0.0498890132,
0.0119816121,
-0.0229640156,
0.0190441255,
-0.0107993018,
0.0478704832,
-0.057227686,
0.0223403759,
0.0018875579,
0.0240110084,
0.0114103137,
-0.0165444277,
0.056959305,
0.0005963848,
0.0018659123,
0.0065351538,
-0.021656666,
-0.0678374469,
0.0199364647,
-0.0447482131,
0.0111207347,
0.0002905037,
-0.0959281847,
0.0405321084,
-0.0532241836,
-0.0306098014,
-0.0095612463,
-0.0285606403,
0.007460847,
0.0334156565,
0.0191980284,
-0.0270049348,
0.0140615301,
0.0394740142,
0.0409816429,
-0.0591472536,
-0.0300927088,
-0.044397518,
0.0143471332,
-0.007364905,
0.005228227,
-0.0268124323,
0.0036025066,
0.0344112068,
-0.0225635152,
-0.0133032212,
1.760252051e-34,
-0.0153455958,
0.0085040312,
0.0186838191,
-0.004093871,
0.0082817432,
-0.0438166447,
0.0435591117,
0.0209382251,
-0.0070448923,
-0.0017972628,
0.0205509849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20707v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20707v2 | What's In My Big Data? | 2023-10-31T17:59:38 | 2024-03-05T20:02:31 | Yanai Elazar, Akshita Bhagia, Ian Magnusson, Abhilasha Ravichander, Dustin Schwenk, Alane Suhr, Pete Walsh, Dirk Groeneveld, Luca Soldaini, Sameer Singh, Hanna Hajishirzi, Noah A. Smith, Jesse Dodge | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large text corpora are the backbone of language models. However, we have a
limited understanding of the content of these corpora, including general
statistics, quality, social factors, and inclusion of evaluation data
(contamination). In this work, we propose What's In My Big Data? (WIMBD), a
platform and a set of sixteen analyses that allow us to reveal and compare the
contents of large text corpora. WIMBD builds on two basic capabilities -- count
and search -- at scale, which allows us to analyze more than 35 terabytes on a
standard compute node. We apply WIMBD to ten different corpora used to train
popular language models, including C4, The Pile, and RedPajama. Our analysis
uncovers several surprising and previously undocumented findings about these
corpora, including the high prevalence of duplicate, synthetic, and low-quality
content, personally identifiable information, toxic language, and benchmark
contamination. For instance, we find that about 50% of the documents in
RedPajama and LAION-2B-en are duplicates. In addition, several datasets used
for benchmarking models trained on such corpora are contaminated with respect
to important benchmarks, including the Winograd Schema Challenge and parts of
GLUE and SuperGLUE. We open-source WIMBD's code and artifacts to provide a
standard set of evaluations for new text-based corpora and to encourage more
analyses and transparency around them. | [
0.0653514415,
0.1246391237,
-0.0299382415,
0.0509186387,
-0.0076525086,
0.0057194401,
-0.0007534531,
-0.0159066506,
0.0102241663,
-0.0189184137,
-0.033961527,
-0.0422391631,
0.0082289688,
0.0525510348,
0.0303724874,
-0.0143081769,
0.0477324575,
-0.0002974029,
0.0065283789,
0.0055367639,
0.0337448157,
0.0143527081,
0.043201562,
0.0087780915,
-0.0181176644,
-0.0080137057,
0.0199106932,
0.0153970718,
0.0015637426,
-0.0275430046,
0.0248720273,
0.0628218725,
-0.0205253791,
0.1028660759,
0.000002016,
-0.0351971611,
-0.0219305195,
0.0138445403,
-0.0107494323,
0.0363979042,
0.060097564,
-0.0051630856,
-0.0274948161,
0.0299971197,
-0.0176114328,
-0.0340504497,
0.0382150263,
-0.0009072367,
0.0586174056,
0.0925451666,
-0.0157507807,
-0.0229909234,
0.0276165213,
-0.0203232523,
-0.013446236,
0.0055085914,
0.017402133,
-0.001437096,
0.0210274924,
0.0229317434,
0.0006709547,
0.0351220071,
-0.0003378426,
-0.0275376923,
-0.0030262854,
0.0246868581,
-0.0311411843,
-0.030291101,
0.0069397846,
0.0647240058,
-0.0041153356,
-0.0503106266,
0.0301600583,
0.0078822607,
-0.0095064091,
0.0077269129,
-0.028163515,
0.0559077971,
0.0230691135,
0.0324896909,
0.0034120232,
0.0202129409,
0.0489170179,
0.0066992976,
0.0122695519,
0.0181751885,
0.0090992041,
-0.0032887934,
0.015332032,
0.0015453228,
0.0173707679,
-0.0543916225,
0.0176839698,
-0.0210364331,
-0.0156793911,
0.0097557064,
-0.0587952584,
-0.032176502,
0.0513758324,
-0.0677841976,
0.0261260998,
-0.0000058002,
-0.007312004,
0.060303349,
0.0269089285,
0.0038290974,
-0.0029714166,
0.0062727369,
-0.0269837994,
-0.0484051481,
-0.003045819,
0.014666738,
-0.0133374007,
-0.0079086963,
-0.0321636386,
-0.0330248512,
-0.0220557414,
0.0183292329,
-0.0068143066,
0.0110134901,
0.0047434317,
0.0009737615,
-0.0059356033,
0.0160784107,
-0.0191259515,
-0.0346012004,
-0.033133544,
0.0092390049,
-0.0045367773,
-0.0717564598,
-0.0004932754,
0.0243515633,
0.0168480277,
-0.0324599408,
0.0324850604,
0.0253703408,
0.0227528084,
-0.0152860042,
-0.0138909593,
-0.0170252118,
-0.0179723874,
-0.0558580756,
-0.0247137416,
-0.0633527488,
0.0159184616,
0.0050872327,
0.0059968666,
-0.0645462126,
-0.0085723149,
0.0536189415,
-0.0517326556,
0.0375648513,
-0.0531836264,
-0.0126242684,
0.0081040161,
0.0059537976,
0.0017729544,
0.0504756309,
0.033904843,
0.0319364145,
0.0772398636,
-0.0124247987,
0.0260306727,
0.0543126464,
0.0233817752,
0.0246745925,
-0.0180550329,
0.0207946766,
-0.0194284339,
0.0159618426,
0.0223860051,
0.0905081928,
0.0004872856,
-0.0580798909,
0.0713712797,
0.0540791228,
-0.017586451,
0.0044537731,
-0.0183179397,
0.0264367629,
0.0294390712,
-0.0225794148,
-0.0208187271,
-0.0164469928,
-0.0292054769,
-0.0377569087,
0.0345282741,
0.0256587397,
0.0080077369,
0.0042036916,
-0.0356835835,
-0.006561378,
0.0110987397,
-0.0276653115,
0.0064275549,
-0.0128357159,
0.0117947115,
0.0005128684,
0.0295389332,
-0.0816512033,
-0.0029162653,
0.0080294423,
0.0630144253,
0.0550972149,
0.0735555366,
-0.0246572271,
0.0153520154,
-0.0100638019,
0.0049855169,
0.0436077937,
0.0243830569,
-0.037391372,
0.0088848015,
-0.0302615538,
-0.0054769162,
0.0505128019,
0.0213427488,
0.0033153228,
0.0408183597,
0.0208108872,
0.0315103307,
-0.0365890004,
-0.0576385669,
0.0379754007,
-0.0236421023,
0.0139510222,
-0.0169678237,
-0.0254005659,
0.0515567884,
0.0111989779,
-0.0291987024,
-0.0001087819,
0.0590928309,
-0.0082177389,
-0.0231845938,
-0.0043370724,
0.0011417264,
0.0067750183,
0.0420003422,
-0.0480970889,
0.0052594547,
0.0784905478,
-0.0054655112,
-0.0356829911,
0.021448724,
-0.0542146862,
0.0397351235,
-0.0448439196,
0.0004047258,
-0.0393028818,
0.0294597764,
-0.0231240708,
0.0537592024,
0.0073649171,
0.0210048966,
0.0001001029,
-0.0308560561,
0.0355308875,
-0.0265055634,
-0.0617698617,
-0.0009052639,
-0.0031870708,
0.0414330326,
0.0425879583,
-0.0219119824,
-0.0546809323,
0.0050181914,
-0.0769808143,
0.0358336717,
-0.0122458385,
0.0376048759,
0.0127623659,
-0.0077182651,
-0.0423893407,
0.0056320261,
-0.039110221,
-0.0169248469,
0.0146146081,
0.0402352288,
0.0159203149,
-0.0183265489,
0.0258699674,
-0.055479195,
-0.0243355501,
-0.0047929715,
0.0793161914,
-0.0205133688,
-0.0347477682,
0.0081605464,
0.0369687825,
-0.0171791669,
0.00811534,
0.0033916961,
-0.0334792063,
-0.0086623589,
-0.0241520405,
0.0048204954,
0.0288633965,
-0.0049132584,
0.0360099189,
0.0243625827,
-0.0018992944,
-0.0556772947,
-0.0469021499,
0.0084148422,
0.0098337205,
-0.0077065718,
-0.0417001434,
0.0221188813,
0.0336839035,
-0.0043930705,
-0.0220337864,
-0.0142852915,
0.0185675528,
-0.0382563286,
-0.0101414602,
0.0047005876,
-0.0340696648,
-0.027921753,
-0.003074402,
-0.0077715642,
-0.0427189469,
0.0149632851,
-0.0529500581,
0.0033328258,
-0.0345030874,
-0.0259088017,
-0.0096059591,
0.0716844946,
0.0242967997,
0.0140337637,
-0.0025037264,
-0.0064063319,
-0.0065858765,
0.0420221835,
0.0087003335,
-0.0561610758,
0.0012959241,
-0.0324600078,
0.0295855552,
-0.0091781653,
-0.0332055762,
-0.0435071439,
-0.0793578476,
-0.0211012568,
-0.0105560161,
0.0603635833,
-0.0244078618,
-0.037883196,
-0.0290479995,
0.0176785234,
0.0558502115,
-0.0075575141,
0.002284063,
0.0001595737,
0.0628582984,
0.0515228659,
-0.0052123922,
0.0514854081,
-0.0111776963,
-0.028441431,
0.0699234754,
0.0403992124,
0.0095873205,
-0.0176019128,
-0.0325853415,
0.0070342631,
0.009602868,
-0.0066310144,
-0.0209558941,
0.0198198333,
-0.0298960116,
-0.0125094457,
0.1161474138,
0.0332909375,
-0.0533885024,
0.0109203458,
0.0212582331,
0.0308471825,
0.0266451221,
-0.0024265612,
-0.1116968393,
-0.0341949202,
0.021896502,
0.0116848154,
-0.0088926461,
-0.0612713471,
-0.0145787392,
-0.1234841496,
0.0173730627,
-0.000909162,
-0.0201239958,
0.0092491563,
-0.0589392222,
-0.0063300021,
-0.0419854596,
-0.0063271034,
-0.0067997612,
0.0017902824,
0.0313364491,
0.0259121824,
-0.018698357,
-0.0723909661,
0.0125315012,
-0.0507151037,
0.0919528529,
0.0060794582,
0.040904969,
-0.03964068,
-0.0111608719,
0.0277395267,
-0.0126067977,
-0.048018191,
0.0018274249,
0.0785723776,
-0.0038635812,
-0.0376638807,
-0.0435341857,
0.0290808473,
-0.0396103114,
0.0190225244,
-0.0021699818,
0.0779100806,
0.0277067088,
-0.0244985558,
-0.0328638628,
-0.0433579721,
0.0237030331,
0.0901377052,
0.0070625604,
-0.0276558585,
0.0016942709,
-0.0209095981,
-0.0012000699,
-0.002658986,
-0.018102672,
0.0376839116,
-0.0151360538,
-0.022604635,
-0.0768792331,
-0.0520948842,
0.0302326176,
0.0222235601,
0.0255765524,
0.000776724,
-0.0217612367,
-0.0490870588,
-0.0772106871,
0.0216467399,
-0.0667264387,
0.0401872583,
-0.0777172819,
0.0081844022,
-0.0027959407,
0.0239628907,
-0.022804806,
0.0590327047,
-0.1011805758,
-0.0713175088,
0.0148029169,
0.0155569622,
0.023355836,
-0.0014320457,
-0.0261849035,
-0.080540821,
0.0549618378,
0.0472149327,
-0.1093088314,
0.0127266711,
-0.0003960402,
-0.0716099441,
0.0157809872,
0.0409897342,
-0.0315294228,
0.0207876973,
0.0119205248,
0.0091722207,
-0.0338436477,
0.008291238,
0.0116978735,
0.0373874046,
0.0341126844,
-0.0355729051,
0.0142782051,
-0.053572204,
-0.0192057882,
-0.0328168236,
-0.0183995273,
-0.0333143659,
0.0137009844,
0.0613773875,
-0.0156257339,
-0.0428109355,
0.0482983552,
-0.0050981836,
0.0562862903,
-0.0394377336,
0.015777899,
0.0419130623,
0.0327585898,
0.0339575112,
0.0073550502,
0.0159898326,
-0.0026716967,
-0.0066980883,
0.0626919866,
-0.0055145719,
-0.034426067,
0.0093382234,
-0.0221656878,
0.0303178616,
0.0452388451,
-0.0368004963,
-0.0190194342,
0.0067792186,
0.0079624178,
0.0403046943,
-0.0382336788,
0.0865041241,
-0.0079120016,
-0.0135808913,
-0.0591716245,
-0.0111744525,
-0.0011431233,
-0.0303851571,
-0.0417047143,
0.0015663044,
-0.0651705042,
0.0471009873,
0.114657104,
0.0329216719,
0.0202867258,
0.005232234,
-0.0335313454,
-0.0276914164,
0.0152258938,
0.0215278454,
0.0278436095,
-0.0337868892,
-0.0086198021,
-0.0653629005,
-0.0685240105,
-0.0080666011,
0.0084416848,
0.0164225306,
0.0049265078,
0.0069350554,
0.0420968272,
0.0014784153,
0.0575026795,
-0.0482049771,
0.0185344107,
-0.0466908142,
-0.0212050229,
0.0401009843,
-6.704199135e-33,
0.0161490943,
-0.0280589797,
-0.0266695265,
0.0006099298,
0.0024555733,
0.0499305688,
-0.0376550891,
-0.0157244932,
-0.0127470559,
0.023430286,
-0.0231451038,
0.0242397618,
0.0114514921,
0.0201787669,
0.0158531647,
0.0272693858,
0.0231302585,
0.0124870865,
-0.0463969745,
0.0155288698,
0.0658886433,
0.0204519797,
0.0480852388,
-0.0470756441,
0.0112268329,
-0.0051318109,
-0.0276945997,
-0.0029941357,
0.0162359513,
0.0528991818,
-0.0415002815,
0.04716032,
0.0043826629,
-0.0109144505,
-0.0062160799,
0.0423712209,
-0.0559808239,
-0.0095038395,
0.0075389049,
0.0191807561,
-0.013213817,
-0.015273043,
0.0320783816,
-0.0216121692,
-0.0270938445,
0.0244831741,
0.0179741792,
-0.0213168357,
-0.0580103584,
-0.0105846403,
-0.0302502997,
0.0461695157,
-0.014160837,
0.0216831826,
0.0029364263,
-0.0083919428,
0.0079798503,
0.0416711234,
-0.0844056979,
0.0141834896,
-0.0095069157,
0.0266056973,
0.0103276614,
-0.0342481211,
0.0061807823,
0.0995262563,
0.0091582453,
-0.0128092878,
0.0039559756,
0.0280032121,
0.0102950986,
0.0151780471,
0.0334682986,
0.0745707378,
0.0385698713,
-0.0609876364,
-0.0824828595,
0.0431874767,
0.0251412801,
0.0035771623,
0.0122052822,
-0.0042332476,
-0.0562778674,
-0.0185547676,
-0.0359865949,
-0.0010353565,
-0.0186187048,
0.0080597382,
0.0215839706,
-0.0245902818,
-0.0476762727,
0.025506109,
0.0121544804,
-0.0550305657,
-0.0564695783,
0.0246425904,
-0.0259233657,
0.0048690969,
0.0124821942,
0.0561097674,
-0.0770975053,
0.0171975251,
-0.0075821606,
-0.0078733889,
0.0107301269,
-0.0037103477,
0.0706226602,
0.0507709011,
-0.0909899846,
0.0062441658,
-0.0428334884,
0.0210891981,
-0.0131539265,
0.0045988685,
0.0044926731,
0.0043403404,
0.0233748741,
0.0246321354,
0.0519801974,
0.0508864336,
-0.0230946392,
-0.0349145755,
-0.0035867076,
-0.0349559747,
-0.0011999133,
-0.0295042526,
-0.0493984632,
-0.000803229,
0.0771550909,
-0.0659025684,
0.0316403396,
-0.016065618,
2.776e-7,
0.037540596,
0.0593001135,
0.0129607012,
-0.0106205689,
0.0301523861,
0.0287985913,
-0.0244574156,
0.0758242011,
-0.0191622674,
-0.0059644994,
-0.0176998768,
-0.0071382825,
0.0562683567,
0.0371709876,
-0.091260694,
-0.0023045063,
-0.0887617767,
-0.0403972901,
-0.0445893928,
-0.0059372066,
-0.0212773252,
0.1131866276,
0.0359499529,
-0.039890971,
-0.0042719645,
-0.0435476303,
0.0472415648,
-0.0280455723,
-0.028071424,
0.0228810851,
0.0244541857,
0.0112393247,
-0.0053314865,
-0.029194057,
-0.025177585,
0.0306262467,
0.0218538884,
0.0282529015,
0.0085868388,
0.0309832785,
-0.0020492761,
-0.0914758965,
-0.0123664578,
-0.0571691841,
0.0750949159,
0.0641021878,
-0.0262678862,
-0.0308396202,
-0.0223724619,
-0.0318791494,
0.048672311,
-0.0137058096,
-0.0482757501,
0.0052533797,
0.0140396263,
-0.0298921932,
-0.0198659915,
-0.041498322,
-0.0384148955,
-0.0392348543,
-0.0301774889,
-0.0306637976,
-0.0153782964,
0.0065415781,
-0.0154926889,
-0.0536031015,
0.0570229776,
2.659692344e-34,
0.0593651161,
0.005473854,
-0.0079646595,
-0.0319911204,
0.0465849116,
-0.0046507749,
-0.0033212556,
-0.0064926692,
-0.0172485989,
-0.0755472928,
0.005870915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20703v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20703v3 | Vanishing Gradients in Reinforcement Finetuning of Language Models | 2023-10-31T17:59:05 | 2024-03-14T08:05:18 | Noam Razin, Hattie Zhou, Omid Saremi, Vimal Thilak, Arwen Bradley, Preetum Nakkiran, Joshua Susskind, Etai Littwin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Pretrained language models are commonly aligned with human preferences and
downstream tasks via reinforcement finetuning (RFT), which refers to maximizing
a (possibly learned) reward function using policy gradient algorithms. This
work identifies a fundamental optimization obstacle in RFT: we prove that the
expected gradient for an input vanishes when its reward standard deviation
under the model is small, even if the expected reward is far from optimal.
Through experiments on an RFT benchmark and controlled environments, as well as
a theoretical analysis, we then demonstrate that vanishing gradients due to
small reward standard deviation are prevalent and detrimental, leading to
extremely slow reward maximization. Lastly, we explore ways to overcome
vanishing gradients in RFT. We find the common practice of an initial
supervised finetuning (SFT) phase to be the most promising candidate, which
sheds light on its importance in an RFT pipeline. Moreover, we show that a
relatively small number of SFT optimization steps on as few as 1% of the input
samples can suffice, indicating that the initial SFT phase need not be
expensive in terms of compute and data labeling efforts. Overall, our results
emphasize that being mindful for inputs whose expected gradient vanishes, as
measured by the reward standard deviation, is crucial for successful execution
of RFT. | [
0.03137834,
0.0021226716,
0.0024796615,
0.0220287181,
-0.0011652833,
0.0279636793,
-0.013485454,
-0.0282981563,
-0.0430937223,
-0.0060856622,
-0.0479497649,
-0.0040092478,
0.0200537145,
-0.0012246808,
0.02267926,
-0.0743402317,
0.0515353791,
-0.036135383,
0.032627143,
-0.0290737823,
0.0469574258,
-0.0051873839,
0.003836242,
0.0287840515,
0.0047951001,
0.0151644461,
0.0039122091,
0.0089525869,
0.0353996381,
-0.0239309333,
0.0707374662,
0.0208423696,
0.001646978,
0.0191199891,
0.0000020683,
-0.0346675478,
0.0074134059,
-0.0221885573,
0.0064261523,
-0.0173516255,
0.0259174947,
0.00422737,
-0.0434939191,
0.0262817387,
-0.0191714857,
0.0036686219,
0.0595209263,
0.0564290732,
0.0348036066,
0.054966405,
0.0069260374,
-0.0346113704,
-0.0135603957,
-0.0584277511,
0.0026449077,
-0.050169576,
0.0080445912,
-0.0562397316,
-0.0035025943,
-0.0354855694,
-0.0581096262,
0.0184839368,
0.0198448207,
0.0321769305,
-0.0278130453,
0.0783130229,
-0.0060516656,
-0.0281629041,
-0.0285660382,
0.0644717738,
-0.0926503763,
-0.002813129,
0.0393660143,
-0.0431817956,
-0.0098288758,
-0.0473197736,
0.0126396166,
-0.0037460702,
0.0055752825,
0.0586836934,
0.0324998125,
-0.026689114,
0.0314548984,
0.0372041836,
-0.0376802646,
0.0880331472,
-0.0120138824,
-0.0472959876,
0.0300066825,
0.015021584,
-0.0407908596,
-0.0446009338,
-0.0171777904,
0.0014462793,
-0.0598002598,
0.016831249,
-0.0440251008,
-0.0187546574,
-0.0221277494,
0.0654176548,
0.0679727346,
0.0510611422,
0.0069221538,
0.0513054729,
-0.0218284428,
0.0522405431,
-0.0118024163,
0.0381886922,
-0.0174794476,
0.0401162468,
0.004566872,
-0.0013240732,
-0.0436490066,
0.0294805616,
-0.0416563191,
-0.0148969516,
-0.0315140635,
-0.0101861991,
-0.0399355963,
0.0169675313,
0.0242710356,
0.010320113,
-0.0811541453,
-0.0027133035,
-0.029555317,
0.0351205878,
-0.0491971783,
0.0325846411,
0.0387313664,
-0.0108109908,
-0.0109778093,
0.0098829558,
0.0042750333,
-0.0369393043,
0.0159125458,
0.0675876662,
-0.0209396929,
-0.0340656415,
-0.0299106855,
-0.0320636556,
-0.0222715177,
-0.0620804131,
-0.0097087258,
-0.0479908958,
0.0013848474,
-0.0184249543,
0.0160834696,
-0.04060442,
0.0044938535,
-0.0157065392,
-0.0318633951,
0.0869163424,
-0.0076332153,
0.0083260713,
0.008916094,
-0.0220810864,
0.0000075658,
0.0672085732,
0.0392528847,
0.0695699751,
-0.0019158226,
0.0256858841,
-0.0101177832,
0.0623263754,
0.0534908362,
0.013607855,
-0.0154702412,
-0.0470405146,
-0.0023146996,
0.0425711833,
0.0805736333,
0.0353931971,
-0.0380614176,
0.0286524612,
0.0600738488,
0.0682497099,
0.0058202813,
-0.0452657044,
0.0237403624,
0.0079614623,
-0.0355212726,
0.0411325544,
-0.071499981,
0.0187575333,
0.010654117,
0.0070786504,
0.0308881253,
0.0191444363,
-0.0377077833,
-0.0289890505,
0.0177635774,
-0.0304986704,
0.0264126901,
0.0262838211,
0.0534952544,
0.0351273417,
-0.0670128241,
-0.0286123808,
0.0511018597,
-0.0016640318,
0.0436598733,
-0.0260411408,
0.0438651294,
0.0587671734,
0.0198303089,
-0.0255295206,
-0.0213331301,
-0.0054529947,
0.0097117228,
0.0119423093,
0.0650044978,
-0.0148868551,
0.0172649808,
-0.0386975445,
-0.0408270322,
0.0224648956,
0.0261370558,
0.0298537128,
0.0392270125,
0.0082749892,
-0.0044284402,
0.0140386159,
-0.0639961585,
0.0340897404,
-0.030438941,
-0.0515633933,
0.0223720744,
0.0096579604,
0.0146110086,
-0.0210334044,
-0.022494562,
0.014940938,
-0.0013069869,
-0.0173197482,
0.0130191101,
-0.0208414849,
-0.059581548,
-0.0202749427,
0.0300214142,
-0.012795235,
-0.0186408814,
0.0380184054,
-0.0419671349,
-0.0500128716,
0.0044792225,
-0.0113265282,
0.0113317026,
-0.0153290341,
0.0213533994,
-0.0010466964,
0.0106814802,
-0.0680982694,
0.0167571381,
0.0035656476,
0.033907935,
0.0000855477,
0.0049956697,
-0.0088383462,
-0.0729954243,
-0.0451399647,
0.0185444877,
-0.0029753034,
0.0284317322,
0.0503448173,
0.0494802184,
-0.0450043231,
-0.0268740114,
-0.0286121778,
0.0170749668,
-0.0369337797,
0.0455257632,
0.0144881364,
0.0081621865,
-0.0241698027,
-0.0431978628,
-0.0180724207,
0.0132451607,
-0.0034853369,
0.0182234123,
0.0177466124,
0.0200936105,
0.0005584203,
-0.0592534654,
-0.03230685,
0.0170202982,
-0.0482332781,
-0.0244702734,
0.0444727764,
-0.0391907692,
0.0256635491,
-0.0071606166,
0.0384351686,
-0.0056530931,
-0.0387157649,
0.0298943091,
-0.025656227,
0.0663868785,
0.1213721782,
-0.0029496381,
0.0606156923,
0.0252531171,
0.0008622347,
-0.0606075153,
0.0268296469,
-0.0603320263,
-0.0503928214,
-0.0508056358,
0.0169257596,
0.0114417914,
0.1097215861,
-0.0036534918,
0.0167311542,
-0.0870273337,
0.0347160213,
-0.047592517,
-0.029785784,
-0.020604508,
0.0448784046,
-0.0613714233,
0.0311215259,
-0.0430202968,
-0.0489171483,
0.0785604045,
0.0036448319,
-0.0058756042,
-0.0386849679,
0.0104900599,
-0.0070435274,
-0.005805782,
0.0061723688,
-0.0012909541,
-0.0124990074,
-0.0364871174,
-0.065036878,
-0.0380176008,
0.0565936267,
-0.0317209251,
0.0226861294,
-0.0291530434,
0.0093649291,
-0.0330841951,
-0.0591948926,
-0.0312193371,
-0.0421142057,
-0.0195886735,
-0.0027103727,
0.0065208273,
-0.029572852,
0.012795059,
-0.0064736796,
0.0395505279,
0.0678634644,
-0.0516624749,
0.0061804615,
-0.041096814,
-0.02343468,
0.0728102103,
-0.0019698928,
0.014363952,
-0.0438665263,
-0.0020988316,
-0.0138215031,
0.0355361365,
0.0246403608,
-0.0075545204,
0.0208470114,
0.0504614078,
-0.0311771315,
-0.0222959761,
0.0419436917,
0.0722741112,
-0.0575317293,
-0.0298126061,
0.0950425193,
0.0063658878,
-0.0443030857,
0.0046009566,
0.0459731482,
0.0546344034,
0.0365264304,
0.0241115447,
-0.0425404049,
-0.0337666981,
0.0152692804,
0.0705417246,
0.0043321918,
-0.0160939358,
-0.0053393496,
-0.1004722267,
0.0135783628,
-0.0041864128,
-0.041718863,
-0.0285457373,
-0.0107676787,
0.0206473414,
-0.0135880429,
0.0254384596,
0.0157782063,
0.0016646439,
0.0178893693,
0.0226646196,
0.0355334356,
-0.0599442907,
-0.0027339153,
-0.0412559099,
0.044526875,
0.1340312362,
0.0019263463,
-0.0165389981,
-0.007988099,
0.0524804965,
-0.0279074274,
-0.0097643053,
-0.0198731553,
0.0118781412,
-0.0106711043,
-0.0392501503,
-0.0034585306,
0.0441539288,
0.0048578242,
0.0054518958,
-0.0189404562,
0.0426313132,
-0.0169942752,
-0.0342229158,
0.0198590998,
-0.0369631983,
0.0422440171,
0.0512545854,
0.0086215315,
-0.0728035942,
-0.063348487,
-0.0324968956,
-0.0290463679,
-0.0420447402,
-0.0479481108,
0.0017298282,
-0.0105186589,
-0.0334838629,
-0.0523020886,
-0.0525871255,
0.0250142757,
0.0320000537,
0.0023750125,
-0.0021105944,
0.0349165909,
-0.0068901228,
-0.0321996883,
0.0179707874,
-0.041765146,
0.0256894697,
-0.0774318948,
-0.0047824406,
0.0191701557,
-0.0312763229,
-0.003681988,
-0.0228842217,
-0.0391426682,
-0.0840268135,
0.0064094551,
0.0405574478,
0.015553725,
0.0385656841,
-0.0265922137,
-0.0793709457,
0.0624114946,
0.0590247363,
-0.0273033101,
0.0406347215,
0.0474411845,
-0.0055476897,
0.0037103146,
0.0469783656,
-0.0282796994,
0.0325259604,
0.0349224098,
0.0355509333,
0.0433601178,
0.0108626913,
0.0164752826,
-0.020825306,
0.0877940431,
-0.0366567522,
-0.0185524337,
-0.0439276844,
-0.0244338792,
0.0203336757,
-0.0230945703,
-0.0189805869,
-0.0337401927,
0.0308453646,
0.0097394027,
-0.0106732491,
0.0092188902,
0.0384267233,
0.0166961793,
-0.0416665711,
-0.0137570286,
0.010705133,
0.0158720072,
0.0516538508,
0.0222073551,
0.004799271,
0.0436268598,
-0.0067040254,
0.0293502975,
-0.0134831173,
0.0280796122,
0.0652630329,
0.0173322912,
-0.0340975709,
0.0072636097,
-0.0243133288,
-0.0665188208,
-0.015439529,
0.0027359945,
0.0611208156,
-0.0215097703,
0.056546323,
-0.0358807556,
-0.0245095976,
-0.0226931646,
-0.0098762754,
-0.0316438936,
0.0028191812,
0.0392148569,
0.0175056327,
-0.0027459529,
-0.0070959968,
0.064433977,
-0.0078363502,
0.0399402268,
-0.0012743168,
0.0244353246,
-0.0113862855,
-0.0060662255,
-0.004136974,
0.0285129547,
-0.0206051338,
0.024050504,
-0.0208964143,
-0.0635364428,
-0.0462095924,
0.05227267,
-0.0076787616,
-0.0159091204,
0.0598388575,
0.0209922064,
-0.0542219169,
0.0042964574,
-0.0543458611,
-0.0169570632,
0.0037598873,
-0.0396126173,
-0.0323350094,
-6.852709622e-33,
-0.0240602717,
-0.0179097001,
0.0135654863,
0.0397711508,
-0.0162674095,
-0.0079926718,
-0.0312922299,
0.0105924215,
-0.0032312179,
0.025770897,
-0.0410842188,
-0.0023518973,
0.0203427467,
0.0150460554,
0.0006493834,
-0.0180622898,
0.049988281,
-0.0221139919,
-0.0663246661,
0.0140993865,
0.008575473,
0.0221881699,
0.0738455951,
-0.0547654517,
0.0247150231,
0.0300812367,
-0.0424453206,
0.0170315206,
-0.0004129716,
0.043279469,
-0.007167628,
0.0265233964,
0.0011140056,
-0.069313027,
-0.039655596,
-0.0011371039,
-0.0936658978,
-0.0442479812,
0.0011124297,
0.0096452599,
-0.0852393061,
-0.0180028956,
0.051408682,
-0.014768241,
-0.0547000468,
0.0193802211,
0.0075189723,
0.0045944089,
-0.0211475082,
-0.0120085869,
-0.0668383837,
0.0131707946,
0.0270385612,
-0.0418972522,
0.0609430522,
-0.0326766074,
-0.0118349558,
-0.0066537489,
-0.013629782,
0.0146564934,
0.0066586207,
0.0541074648,
0.0585664213,
0.0505332313,
0.0166773815,
0.0114629669,
0.0369056351,
0.0290458463,
0.055141639,
-0.0400430262,
0.078807123,
-0.0202531572,
-0.009268309,
0.0128179826,
0.0500035845,
-0.0269702263,
0.0043793223,
-0.0038457299,
-0.0111600701,
0.0305580683,
0.0359849818,
0.0202485919,
-0.03872177,
-0.0531138293,
-0.0910084322,
0.0008015338,
-0.0192457065,
-0.0032511735,
0.0291602612,
0.0533812977,
0.0043583182,
-0.0153680025,
0.0109256646,
-0.025791578,
-0.0015552633,
0.0007393619,
-0.0215822291,
-0.0071619386,
0.0085559906,
-0.0106092161,
-0.0859859437,
-0.0245273858,
-0.0218046363,
-0.0142589258,
0.0025845275,
0.0417244993,
0.0345295966,
0.0360677093,
-0.0393076167,
0.0026011402,
-0.0295661651,
0.0558749661,
0.0343793035,
0.0293230601,
0.0537083372,
-0.006226148,
-0.0009271286,
0.044469025,
0.037997704,
-0.0358704142,
-0.0570323803,
-0.0011545733,
-0.0026012457,
0.0380307175,
-0.0546314158,
0.0052118585,
-0.0313129313,
0.0291609205,
0.0028785025,
-0.0214356035,
-0.0165766478,
0.0094357478,
2.811e-7,
0.0078309262,
0.0302158948,
0.0286752339,
0.0360340998,
0.0179469809,
0.0547660999,
0.0031793357,
0.012825571,
-0.0126403403,
-0.0019935553,
0.0078820474,
0.0277193058,
0.0144284861,
-0.0205660779,
-0.0785200596,
0.009839843,
-0.0376953185,
0.0305825938,
-0.0334088095,
-0.0217695385,
0.0038348127,
0.06782493,
0.0442673452,
0.0011248731,
0.0149654234,
0.0327883884,
0.0284558665,
-0.0289692469,
0.0474952571,
0.0069638994,
-0.0041385465,
0.032036934,
-0.0294932947,
-0.0150966486,
0.0005775073,
0.0184311215,
-0.0315746814,
0.0584711283,
-0.0164294392,
-0.0109753367,
-0.012726753,
0.0043539316,
0.0131337177,
-0.03665898,
0.0645236298,
-0.0889606476,
0.0028130044,
-0.0290160123,
0.0387064032,
-0.0215441585,
0.0130823283,
-0.0339096896,
-0.020260809,
0.0002331077,
0.0134815956,
0.0405267775,
-0.0315243453,
-0.088676393,
0.0018326669,
0.0603611283,
-0.0115462402,
-0.0569002703,
-0.0575942844,
0.0542800464,
-0.0141383093,
-0.0821091682,
-0.0039409995,
2.710181893e-34,
0.0142772403,
-0.0352584086,
0.0381078571,
-0.0294031203,
0.0105800536,
0.0342140011,
-0.0358016044,
0.0124030197,
0.0493293554,
-0.030934725,
-0.0353860483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20697v1 | Text-Transport: Toward Learning Causal Effects of Natural Language | 2023-10-31T17:56:51 | 2023-10-31T17:56:51 | Victoria Lin, Louis-Philippe Morency, Eli Ben-Michael | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ME | As language technologies gain prominence in real-world settings, it is
important to understand how changes to language affect reader perceptions. This
can be formalized as the causal effect of varying a linguistic attribute (e.g.,
sentiment) on a reader's response to the text. In this paper, we introduce
Text-Transport, a method for estimation of causal effects from natural language
under any text distribution. Current approaches for valid causal effect
estimation require strong assumptions about the data, meaning the data from
which one can estimate valid causal effects often is not representative of the
actual target domain of interest. To address this issue, we leverage the notion
of distribution shift to describe an estimator that transports causal effects
between domains, bypassing the need for strong assumptions in the target
domain. We derive statistical guarantees on the uncertainty of this estimator,
and we report empirical results and analyses that support the validity of
Text-Transport across data settings. Finally, we use Text-Transport to study a
realistic setting--hate speech on social media--in which causal effects do
shift significantly between text domains, demonstrating the necessity of
transport when conducting causal inference on natural language. | [
0.0072579025,
0.1113818362,
-0.0353921652,
-0.0011013484,
-0.0394856296,
0.00323902,
0.0213986635,
0.0189491678,
-0.0063651619,
-0.0518928058,
0.0780240372,
0.0198760498,
-0.0140410084,
0.0074504255,
0.018663086,
-0.0308452174,
0.0032854057,
0.0332905836,
0.0054902057,
-0.0062596384,
0.0260264911,
-0.0261427835,
-0.0140245315,
-0.0009856389,
-0.0205502771,
0.0279093888,
0.0199549813,
0.0187654439,
0.0264927689,
-0.0358988009,
0.0065504555,
0.0263173413,
0.0371442288,
-0.0062112347,
0.0000021001,
-0.0171799436,
-0.04020622,
-0.0012605297,
0.0334207565,
-0.0360978916,
0.0746923834,
-0.0231370423,
0.0070173512,
0.0249832887,
0.0034027949,
0.0120126205,
0.0675727278,
0.0204149634,
0.0178595539,
0.0665353909,
-0.0309322607,
-0.043105185,
-0.0268433057,
0.0077260402,
0.0410824008,
-0.0084202681,
0.0417513847,
-0.0196279977,
-0.0459707156,
0.0058443067,
-0.0539670624,
0.0232708752,
-0.0108764423,
0.0241278186,
0.0549467131,
-0.0104424171,
0.0223017931,
0.0269957408,
-0.001663752,
0.0623491742,
0.0722111315,
-0.0324953832,
0.0254432149,
-0.016741313,
0.0215266868,
0.1122830436,
-0.0322088376,
-0.029719973,
-0.0066811587,
-0.0068954001,
-0.0222224314,
0.0231278036,
0.059448529,
0.0397455879,
-0.0554220788,
0.0881451443,
-0.0077018971,
-0.0570384003,
-0.0228289124,
0.0543939658,
0.0223819911,
-0.0097634541,
0.0117921988,
-0.0335160829,
0.0356488153,
0.0347415134,
0.0113721732,
-0.0667418465,
-0.0162763372,
-0.06122097,
0.0095624048,
0.0007448719,
-0.0242787749,
0.0016747621,
0.0320813283,
0.0038929274,
-0.0375828557,
-0.0096778469,
0.0082425326,
0.0431749709,
-0.0358026549,
-0.0078902366,
0.0319458768,
-0.0099087302,
-0.0050183684,
0.0317686088,
-0.0312597267,
0.0210988875,
-0.0238007288,
-0.0517661273,
-0.0220569763,
-0.0147815552,
-0.0134838941,
0.006037239,
-0.0363469124,
0.0352590866,
-0.0539048351,
0.0609908588,
-0.0314445496,
0.0132459886,
0.0010469971,
0.0247554109,
0.0327647775,
-0.0357611217,
-0.0187657606,
0.0834963471,
0.0335243829,
-0.003854455,
-0.0496919788,
-0.0053169061,
-0.0297629721,
-0.0247193072,
0.0014878944,
-0.0709359944,
-0.0168843437,
0.0459696688,
0.0122622,
-0.0398211554,
-0.0103952913,
0.0040274002,
-0.092112191,
0.0485750474,
-0.0013427222,
0.0016797071,
0.0047517465,
-0.0141266063,
0.0200822763,
0.0673859343,
0.022902295,
-0.0030883723,
0.0295265,
-0.0099460976,
-0.0028349818,
0.0218031518,
0.0506372228,
0.0479062758,
-0.0335763395,
-0.0440144315,
-0.0329607576,
-0.0183847938,
-0.0137157245,
-0.0099682892,
-0.0155714173,
0.0007096397,
0.0452885292,
0.0543111786,
-0.0322230905,
-0.0175021645,
0.0201768111,
-0.0010210404,
-0.0746063814,
0.0252789836,
-0.0140706953,
-0.0184812844,
-0.0173823256,
-0.0572536923,
0.0252589229,
0.0054190443,
-0.0077833617,
-0.0311667211,
0.01296956,
-0.0134439915,
0.0607754029,
-0.0430072807,
0.0525653213,
0.0078615872,
0.011038173,
0.0252148937,
0.0617399514,
-0.0414246097,
0.0110476092,
0.0007690022,
-0.0013976645,
0.0385881476,
0.0092798909,
-0.0442907549,
0.0379354544,
-0.034828458,
0.0493632443,
0.0197925512,
-0.0133022843,
0.0236182958,
-0.0425247177,
-0.0103133377,
-0.0175341032,
0.0723047554,
0.0266829785,
0.0087286318,
0.0008910514,
0.0525125042,
-0.0185108855,
-0.0441365764,
-0.0079606799,
0.0169346686,
0.0505168773,
-0.0074322335,
-0.0056832773,
0.0149388118,
0.0515617691,
-0.0026661213,
-0.039327126,
-0.0385670066,
-0.0227764118,
-0.0018211512,
-0.0855566487,
0.0790406689,
0.0185300335,
0.0269473046,
-0.0273401104,
-0.0671703294,
0.0135036567,
0.040714439,
-0.0170738623,
0.0030112418,
0.1012339443,
-0.0048464527,
0.0192407221,
0.0321078561,
0.000897755,
-0.0110998889,
0.0139607377,
-0.0127866771,
0.0368918404,
0.0062439516,
0.0087339068,
-0.0330554321,
-0.0154331354,
0.0042302124,
0.0603946373,
0.0021884127,
-0.0236147027,
-0.017817799,
0.0084608877,
0.056620609,
-0.0850541145,
-0.013190398,
0.0034651458,
-0.0191149563,
0.0017047707,
-0.0323173404,
0.022483753,
0.0045429217,
0.0020205381,
-0.005007003,
0.0111561092,
-0.023420224,
-0.017101638,
0.0029350489,
0.0307639819,
0.046208255,
-0.0510916412,
0.0149534103,
-0.0504399948,
-0.0117687844,
-0.061478775,
0.0458586589,
0.0515489914,
-0.0775050819,
-0.0183804929,
0.0032305587,
-0.0435628407,
-0.0071034636,
-0.010445483,
-0.057777822,
-0.0277031288,
0.0101874238,
0.0168176554,
0.017680414,
0.0392368697,
0.0488088317,
0.0135717364,
-0.0305674113,
-0.0371654294,
-0.0181277785,
-0.0804967806,
0.0023437145,
-0.0278665666,
-0.0447473861,
0.0093159433,
0.0656741858,
0.0459321328,
-0.0314129628,
-0.0587738007,
0.003020975,
-0.0601345971,
-0.0010233095,
-0.0117499446,
-0.0087999441,
-0.0022851885,
0.0225827191,
-0.0111286575,
-0.0659505203,
0.0161266923,
0.0208770148,
0.0787692294,
-0.0418293029,
-0.0155544169,
0.0081391232,
0.0194191784,
0.0331729576,
0.0226183906,
0.0312189665,
-0.0089756278,
0.0028643317,
-0.0286776647,
0.0781663582,
0.0269961972,
0.0056039155,
-0.0644185767,
0.0517800562,
0.036259044,
-0.036409393,
-0.0068757213,
-0.0992809609,
0.0094687734,
-0.0598405749,
0.0316017419,
-0.0677567422,
-0.0339071043,
-0.0051063835,
0.0366585255,
-0.0148299364,
-0.0125372121,
-0.0284459554,
0.0139127532,
-0.0200570263,
-0.0079690665,
-0.0500268154,
0.0000230347,
-0.0399952382,
-0.0753501579,
0.0153008057,
-0.0274497848,
-0.0257815458,
-0.0248343367,
0.0035148272,
-0.0193122346,
-0.0111264363,
-0.0048630764,
-0.0210474059,
0.0642649606,
-0.0051226551,
0.0184942447,
0.0572320223,
0.0337582231,
-0.0158381741,
-0.002976065,
0.0290450454,
0.0284312945,
-0.0007889196,
-0.0110967532,
-0.1121656373,
-0.010688032,
-0.020818688,
0.0037499499,
-0.0532550178,
-0.0351698138,
0.0035326758,
-0.0647018775,
0.0096964333,
0.0136267459,
-0.0212817192,
0.0030168344,
-0.0642109364,
0.0372432359,
-0.0089782663,
-0.0587527603,
-0.0563512929,
0.0362265185,
0.0072270283,
0.0233615693,
-0.0568305515,
-0.0212634392,
-0.035968449,
-0.0226225369,
0.0140643958,
0.0489851497,
0.0365876034,
-0.0532918498,
-0.0097778672,
-0.007500384,
0.0044919089,
-0.0027412642,
-0.0044910288,
0.1122613698,
0.0091194781,
0.0013123283,
-0.0214702412,
0.0127710849,
-0.0247150175,
-0.0162132513,
0.0293875039,
0.045462735,
0.02493608,
-0.0510563664,
-0.0085519003,
0.0097212605,
0.0302777849,
0.0248627011,
-0.0310452059,
-0.0415309779,
-0.0033429572,
-0.0505485758,
-0.0186266452,
0.0283792745,
-0.0564314201,
-0.0399324186,
-0.0174196456,
-0.0772859603,
-0.1058741361,
0.0068615754,
-0.0506529808,
0.0529871173,
0.0360791795,
0.0048640491,
0.0523031913,
-0.0632004738,
-0.0596615672,
0.0206477493,
-0.0064840838,
0.0299132541,
0.0172136873,
-0.0153992819,
0.0160933156,
0.0194091536,
-0.0227762125,
0.018352652,
-0.0715259314,
-0.0932533741,
0.0133482944,
0.0135966837,
0.0263106935,
0.0314196721,
-0.0046688616,
-0.0295239501,
0.0482402965,
0.0557518341,
-0.0366605483,
0.025791483,
0.0438158549,
-0.0355317742,
0.0285414346,
-0.0066717798,
-0.001248377,
0.0470306836,
0.0002559163,
-0.0461870357,
-0.0545390286,
0.0023738318,
-0.0029357807,
-0.0466736928,
0.0613069721,
0.0124792475,
-0.0594115369,
-0.0325001515,
-0.001505779,
-0.012922735,
-0.0315541662,
0.0095519256,
-0.0047153193,
0.0186988171,
0.0305953603,
-0.0552588366,
-0.0199938808,
-0.0244083498,
-0.001354341,
-0.03465648,
0.0525193214,
0.0614727139,
0.0555544421,
0.0323571935,
0.0270809028,
0.035482537,
-0.0298894905,
0.0048757582,
0.0424546972,
0.0142654795,
0.0282570869,
0.03421624,
0.0208635833,
0.024294164,
-0.0494094938,
-0.0649469718,
0.009722935,
0.0182115119,
-0.0109751932,
-0.0132487677,
-0.0223434363,
0.0553220212,
0.003738136,
-0.0031964628,
-0.0025479137,
0.0466813073,
-0.0053383741,
0.0219429657,
0.0181642994,
0.0059631383,
-0.0334486812,
0.0477177091,
0.0348722935,
-0.016988622,
0.044997476,
-0.0308004767,
-0.0448670089,
0.0060347333,
-0.0120528052,
0.0350997522,
-0.0035720808,
0.0328778699,
0.0219511557,
-0.067510888,
-0.075410679,
0.0462565757,
-0.0650059879,
0.0597990975,
-0.0151637206,
0.001610828,
0.0450259596,
-0.0204567909,
0.0314284489,
-0.0399694294,
0.0121564632,
-0.0560179688,
-0.0149083612,
0.0189289488,
-6.822758761e-33,
-0.0032385059,
-0.0438377298,
-0.0342221446,
0.0158565398,
0.000668944,
-0.0108626978,
-0.0100895232,
0.0268267319,
0.0201213695,
0.043486245,
0.0232910719,
0.0467976555,
0.0199846029,
0.0068934439,
0.0102409711,
-0.016997708,
0.0138713773,
0.0122469524,
-0.0224610586,
-0.0010559232,
0.0529465899,
0.0188465714,
0.0381029174,
-0.1003995761,
0.0488277338,
0.0084007885,
-0.0093743643,
-0.0280561429,
0.0477161743,
-0.0084330104,
0.0136757437,
0.0421795174,
0.0147146713,
-0.0525542535,
0.0192442778,
0.0669057593,
-0.0243509226,
-0.0439931303,
0.0358009189,
0.0243483279,
0.0004427049,
-0.0101436628,
0.0169165321,
-0.0101991836,
-0.0095085641,
0.017547885,
0.0582895614,
-0.0065826997,
0.0420683287,
-0.0286328979,
-0.0879012197,
0.0474801064,
-0.0668181628,
0.0331657119,
0.0025482271,
0.029084418,
0.0353579447,
0.0097813401,
-0.0124925235,
0.033164937,
-0.0110200932,
0.0103531042,
0.0073263594,
0.0005375717,
0.0173318367,
0.0524263903,
-0.0376884528,
0.0220389403,
-0.0199804958,
0.0192429852,
0.0317751989,
-0.0307124332,
0.0146183968,
0.1144386381,
0.0469639488,
-0.0602121018,
-0.0718157217,
0.0072507346,
0.0128698079,
-0.0505483374,
0.0353331231,
-0.007665596,
-0.0627111122,
-0.0417704359,
-0.0209161192,
-0.02985017,
-0.0053447671,
-0.0396712013,
0.0050260569,
-0.0149431545,
-0.0150882984,
-0.0199837163,
0.0243713427,
-0.0282931309,
-0.0669865534,
0.0350541137,
-0.0694075897,
0.0081444057,
-0.0045848992,
-0.0080886986,
-0.0398241356,
-0.0016527759,
-0.0280563608,
0.0557975881,
0.0483930036,
0.0075052795,
0.0546676703,
0.0063128904,
-0.0701986626,
-0.0116098542,
-0.0253325514,
-0.0155759854,
-0.0017587797,
0.0162814204,
0.0193776432,
0.0477873944,
-0.0128514189,
0.0331766903,
0.0555957966,
0.0050318572,
0.0312312581,
0.0331540443,
-0.0554899946,
0.0103462273,
-0.0668181032,
-0.0479901992,
0.0199456383,
0.044622343,
0.0226999745,
-0.1034175232,
-0.0134082306,
-0.0418554172,
2.886e-7,
0.0730837435,
0.0813370273,
0.003305553,
0.0390272662,
0.0068545034,
0.0134047149,
0.0349028446,
0.0140261929,
0.0275937002,
-0.0196387954,
-0.000781964,
0.0338310413,
0.0070366613,
0.0137443002,
-0.088855058,
-0.0292783417,
-0.0108286878,
0.0025359227,
-0.0095714442,
0.0040843631,
0.0702031702,
0.0562310405,
0.0537996367,
0.0100127282,
-0.023931656,
-0.0040471298,
0.0346707962,
-0.044276908,
0.0035355233,
-0.0120906327,
-0.0321300551,
-0.0213331953,
-0.0350073837,
0.0445463285,
-0.0319375098,
-0.0098294048,
0.0009027977,
0.0111123724,
0.0165648516,
0.0316739343,
-0.0312263146,
-0.0137016103,
0.0078031477,
-0.0037515727,
0.0363400988,
-0.0279298164,
-0.0496179014,
-0.0127563886,
-0.0501288958,
-0.0053154519,
0.0289895907,
0.0252873302,
-0.018257929,
-0.0002429008,
-0.0040389444,
0.0409551971,
0.0066911723,
-0.095969066,
-0.0008656409,
0.011832213,
0.0216439012,
-0.0524592139,
0.0080080954,
0.0035587968,
0.0049699247,
-0.0197548326,
0.0553817488,
2.407830971e-34,
0.0336477086,
0.0064452132,
-0.0089686709,
-0.0656337067,
0.0494996756,
0.0000499929,
-0.0162124336,
0.002589138,
0.0538941585,
-0.0415326022,
0.0286604222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20689v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20689v4 | Learning From Mistakes Makes LLM Better Reasoner | 2023-10-31T17:52:22 | 2024-03-29T07:17:39 | Shengnan An, Zexiong Ma, Zeqi Lin, Nanning Zheng, Jian-Guang Lou, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) recently exhibited remarkable reasoning
capabilities on solving math problems. To further improve their reasoning
capabilities, this work explores whether LLMs can LEarn from MistAkes (LEMA),
akin to the human learning process. Consider a human student who failed to
solve a math problem, he will learn from what mistake he has made and how to
correct it. Mimicking this error-driven learning process, LEMA incorporates
mistake-correction data pairs during fine-tuning LLMs. Specifically, we first
collect inaccurate reasoning paths from various LLMs, and then employ GPT-4 as
a ''corrector'' to identify the mistake step, explain the reason for the
mistake, correct the mistake and generate the final answer. In addition, we
apply a correction-centric evolution strategy that effectively expands the
question set for generating correction data. Experiments across various LLMs
and reasoning tasks show that LEMA effectively improves CoT-alone fine-tuning.
Our further ablations shed light on the non-homogeneous effectiveness between
CoT data and correction data. These results suggest a significant potential for
LLMs to improve through learning from their mistakes. Our code, models and
prompts are publicly available at https://github.com/microsoft/LEMA. | [
0.0066519338,
0.0586576834,
-0.0175436568,
0.0445422418,
-0.0264916271,
0.0311063584,
-0.0168187246,
-0.0223108791,
-0.0282313973,
-0.0095609464,
-0.0080422442,
0.0011880536,
-0.0128053511,
-0.0151711293,
0.0314253047,
-0.0472582765,
0.0521446057,
-0.0731321573,
0.0122228069,
-0.0064318851,
-0.028391974,
-0.0001593539,
-0.0219832286,
0.0045603868,
-0.0024605533,
-0.048390314,
-0.0336804315,
0.0022683514,
0.0297240466,
-0.0068688984,
0.0068850955,
0.0331909731,
0.0205676127,
0.0520826876,
0.0000021066,
-0.062632449,
-0.0338147357,
-0.0085927136,
-0.0736074671,
0.0028061827,
-0.0417209268,
0.0243693888,
-0.0244903862,
0.0442752242,
-0.0414760187,
0.0153367454,
0.0272994693,
0.0164911468,
0.0721820146,
0.0841430873,
0.0229928158,
-0.0472888798,
0.0441483483,
-0.0199926086,
0.0708713084,
-0.0522673614,
-0.0021148119,
0.0310259368,
0.0230700895,
-0.0038019666,
-0.0316355042,
0.003313835,
0.0538844541,
-0.016475657,
-0.0279974025,
0.0164181553,
-0.0088677974,
-0.0120903943,
-0.0154383909,
0.0441541001,
-0.0193906985,
-0.028788615,
-0.0338614807,
-0.0115965717,
0.0177279562,
-0.0102587743,
-0.0620737486,
0.026453875,
-0.0230767354,
0.0357052088,
0.0100592431,
-0.0822570398,
0.0398193933,
0.0296001099,
-0.0410872176,
0.0838106647,
-0.0050117052,
-0.0424209796,
0.0041926312,
-0.0073296349,
-0.040364299,
-0.0396189615,
0.004080792,
0.0713413954,
-0.0543020405,
0.0273973104,
-0.0245643388,
0.0123174312,
0.0190117266,
0.0240377039,
0.0226862002,
0.0544335656,
-0.0074439393,
0.0444337875,
-0.0418109894,
0.0561923645,
-0.0055198418,
0.0402756073,
-0.0224869028,
-0.0168933906,
-0.0488701984,
-0.0344838947,
-0.0220432729,
0.0292859878,
-0.0014542568,
0.0417065509,
-0.0243458562,
0.0514261127,
-0.0152925355,
0.0609802976,
0.0033622265,
-0.0064323731,
0.0010834484,
-0.0455382131,
-0.0657507107,
0.0127445292,
-0.0394493863,
0.025535034,
0.0591654032,
-0.0561637282,
-0.0307693891,
-0.0106845861,
0.0053953636,
-0.0157930292,
0.0361524411,
0.0533726923,
-0.0040990058,
-0.0224726833,
-0.0428071134,
-0.0231742673,
0.0132229002,
-0.067070879,
-0.0018538221,
-0.0817182586,
0.0150982887,
-0.0000318823,
-0.0244498942,
-0.0401993096,
0.0206349678,
0.0074559976,
-0.0161117576,
0.0862772465,
-0.0509096831,
0.0146183865,
0.0246283822,
-0.0020780475,
-0.0319334231,
0.0461377092,
0.0584528334,
-0.0014497938,
0.0136259086,
-0.0232446957,
0.0243751835,
0.0085885078,
0.0183501095,
-0.0038955689,
0.0069206692,
0.0231043939,
-0.0335071832,
0.0604150109,
0.0060693682,
0.0354957096,
-0.0453763492,
0.0380275585,
0.0201741327,
0.0396415852,
0.0112242037,
0.0388270319,
0.0113864001,
-0.0404746085,
0.0022987896,
-0.0027987512,
-0.0974520519,
0.0320382454,
-0.0355292782,
0.0155171454,
0.0206226576,
-0.0149179567,
-0.0231366362,
-0.0675176606,
0.0015966508,
0.0215485487,
-0.0164116137,
0.0135080824,
0.0425937362,
0.008582185,
-0.0147354752,
0.0477246381,
-0.0014265706,
-0.0404940732,
-0.0464288034,
-0.0841393769,
0.0763256028,
0.0518216118,
0.0486333296,
-0.0568309389,
-0.1027877703,
-0.0171814542,
0.0059028398,
0.0087741837,
0.0606637187,
-0.0012456723,
-0.0314407796,
-0.0431321301,
-0.0114263566,
-0.0330575593,
0.0066575939,
0.0000517936,
0.0246173814,
-0.0075312681,
0.0149442144,
-0.0307805669,
-0.0099924896,
0.0176695734,
-0.0145038012,
-0.02620635,
-0.0032790697,
-0.0123420935,
0.0015255122,
-0.0071883984,
0.0146042015,
0.0210416336,
0.0075207809,
0.0182443522,
-0.0300998632,
0.0144062135,
-0.0477899984,
-0.0304867327,
0.0867280364,
-0.0344149806,
-0.0585737303,
-0.0123316338,
-0.0746338516,
-0.042859152,
0.0373929851,
-0.0230296906,
0.0205449685,
-0.0363806486,
0.0392786749,
-0.0141612552,
-0.0445367321,
-0.0058366363,
0.0731799752,
0.0136256637,
0.0094388155,
0.0112588303,
0.0357452072,
0.0081163058,
-0.044522237,
0.0435499027,
-0.0061543598,
-0.0025214322,
0.0228949916,
-0.0213299375,
0.0260962155,
-0.0530493334,
-0.0310658067,
-0.0252881143,
0.0468638875,
-0.008771481,
0.0559197292,
0.0185461678,
-0.0145083778,
-0.013081654,
0.0007792882,
-0.0208357945,
0.016140433,
0.0279689897,
-0.0020491695,
0.0319246612,
-0.0172960982,
-0.0061535528,
-0.0322739817,
-0.0015575787,
-0.0554855242,
-0.0019226109,
-0.0154960742,
0.0348483324,
-0.0930440947,
0.0564040132,
-0.0313887969,
0.019068744,
-0.0037963861,
-0.0068008699,
0.0491154529,
-0.0380698331,
0.0350225084,
0.0559051223,
-0.0130695011,
0.0273103938,
0.0394988023,
-0.0157552361,
-0.0560220256,
0.0585225113,
0.0112195369,
-0.0293447711,
-0.029002944,
-0.0038641365,
-0.0390715227,
0.0320492499,
-0.0446620509,
-0.0229428411,
-0.034364678,
0.0595695898,
0.0193234086,
0.005493368,
-0.0185401253,
-0.0168346595,
-0.0161491055,
0.0508073084,
-0.01949233,
-0.0593876876,
0.0804722607,
0.0059752543,
-0.0037655041,
-0.0501396097,
0.0292801149,
-0.0411169566,
0.064514488,
-0.0219753366,
-0.0148837101,
-0.0205231309,
-0.0172457378,
-0.0531806834,
-0.0337253548,
0.0439520739,
-0.0364044793,
0.0908902362,
-0.0923537314,
-0.0102336137,
-0.0132903671,
-0.0647502542,
-0.0523841307,
0.017720338,
-0.0491716787,
0.0241847001,
-0.0357239246,
-0.0289950036,
-0.0204266198,
-0.0482218899,
0.027944969,
0.0200415291,
-0.0319313779,
-0.0208672658,
-0.0239087213,
-0.0169066917,
0.0416257195,
0.0794875547,
0.0732651949,
-0.0593614914,
0.0388925672,
0.0306086559,
0.0403724648,
-0.0157779995,
-0.0210901815,
0.0208948161,
-0.0110724308,
-0.0193094686,
-0.0288349036,
0.0168036334,
0.0722694993,
-0.0930231512,
-0.0291212052,
0.1086308509,
0.0360453166,
-0.0108539984,
-0.0146549419,
-0.0727723315,
0.0163498595,
0.0289184991,
0.0284511652,
-0.0741716698,
-0.0528422035,
0.0552061833,
0.0532537922,
0.0103891026,
-0.0252430495,
0.0066756196,
-0.1313034296,
0.0491830856,
0.0285894927,
-0.0192628969,
-0.0263681188,
-0.0397310667,
0.0003550402,
0.008839,
0.0183693524,
0.0667519867,
0.0092841135,
0.0164594017,
0.0251031704,
0.0135306288,
-0.0458605736,
0.024594238,
-0.0215940848,
0.037986923,
0.0588012971,
0.0137096625,
0.0002201779,
-0.0728596747,
0.0617639907,
-0.0046108691,
0.0036616072,
-0.0186904352,
-0.003999359,
0.0262882151,
-0.0088024726,
-0.0233840812,
0.0730340481,
-0.0369486064,
-0.0524435639,
0.0217866041,
0.1209026203,
-0.034062665,
-0.0160691738,
0.0028257139,
-0.0339889042,
-0.0449107438,
0.0339832231,
0.0259868614,
0.0042179944,
-0.0680537596,
-0.0635801554,
-0.021644881,
-0.0496651791,
0.0085627381,
0.0185772181,
0.0375320166,
0.0193682797,
-0.0036205524,
-0.0317326449,
0.0631367713,
0.0395702347,
-0.0040081353,
-0.0386386998,
-0.0236677211,
-0.0078666648,
-0.0124039454,
0.0181297213,
-0.0334304161,
0.0274625774,
-0.0582926981,
0.019340219,
-0.007755443,
-0.0242306776,
-0.0001439957,
-0.0048158658,
-0.0757595375,
-0.0604675263,
-0.0091798184,
0.0715209469,
0.0332714729,
0.0379541703,
-0.0211134199,
-0.0605168976,
0.001079931,
0.0497785434,
-0.0055430033,
-0.0111460732,
0.0248050671,
-0.0157000013,
-0.0022218449,
0.0289216544,
-0.032819666,
-0.0054064193,
0.0287433043,
0.0498649403,
-0.0172828492,
-0.0155453291,
0.0468276553,
0.0313983969,
0.0041493629,
-0.0047666538,
0.0075317463,
-0.0230464153,
0.0573761016,
0.0085905083,
-0.0103057036,
-0.0014867394,
0.0094235297,
-0.0003440043,
-0.0541408956,
0.0324439071,
-0.0564747974,
-0.010429454,
0.0097147385,
-0.0104265288,
0.0457448699,
0.0312897302,
0.0360205509,
0.0409555621,
-0.0269068386,
0.0161721185,
0.0173179694,
0.0123100579,
0.0686692521,
-0.0070032668,
0.0611415282,
0.0318716951,
0.0090925684,
-0.0267498381,
0.0028771439,
-0.0709446147,
-0.1208242029,
0.0183806494,
0.0317079015,
0.0553447716,
0.028339114,
0.0089058457,
-0.041497685,
-0.0166985374,
0.0037925509,
0.0065698894,
0.0310944337,
-0.0010679592,
0.0407934487,
0.0387970842,
0.0055814423,
-0.0631437078,
0.041432675,
-0.0533951335,
0.0804267749,
-0.0324870273,
0.0156421755,
-0.0287457481,
-0.026069738,
-0.0210668445,
-0.0338614956,
-0.0083561195,
-0.0158193707,
-0.0335964672,
-0.0851395652,
-0.0075914757,
0.0634342656,
0.0090748323,
-0.0184211154,
0.0065134885,
0.0658540651,
-0.0273658168,
-0.0456677303,
0.012009481,
0.0332568996,
-0.0139282038,
-0.0140549885,
-0.0419347323,
-5.938280444e-33,
-0.0248877462,
-0.0045067524,
0.0600116253,
0.0303940475,
0.01512801,
-0.0582910925,
-0.0452287681,
0.0237097703,
-0.0009956486,
0.0241806842,
-0.0400903337,
0.0499754623,
0.000814373,
-0.0077075143,
0.0289811455,
-0.0234062672,
0.0237661302,
0.0200606417,
-0.0352045335,
0.0100791706,
0.0084928991,
0.0049091517,
0.056161914,
-0.0316637307,
0.0039818413,
0.0314399116,
-0.0216894727,
0.0667938367,
-0.0731186047,
0.0469801724,
0.0351346023,
0.0207279064,
0.0089628166,
-0.0240919814,
-0.0255510677,
-0.0142846527,
-0.0439731181,
-0.0416238159,
0.0280446038,
-0.0051312153,
-0.0465651937,
-0.0743647814,
0.045101326,
0.0224429183,
-0.0234238487,
-0.007787534,
-0.0046712672,
-0.0326045044,
-0.0008257946,
0.0359442383,
-0.018365968,
0.0214462541,
-0.0186467376,
-0.0407913253,
-0.0080042342,
0.010859183,
-0.0182914529,
-0.0087277777,
-0.0351027846,
0.0226112995,
0.0653369352,
-0.0018777059,
0.0424897969,
-0.0028289251,
-0.0170533359,
0.0242156554,
0.0325313881,
0.0010707381,
-0.0127771553,
-0.0192584842,
0.0125477156,
0.0644275323,
0.0647039711,
0.0151590975,
0.0173962917,
-0.0151686547,
-0.046111092,
0.0335679837,
-0.0060021346,
0.0635701939,
0.0089018364,
0.019216748,
0.0065009296,
0.0051925136,
-0.0520660281,
0.030516278,
-0.0435478948,
-0.0126629956,
0.0238556527,
-0.0063320789,
-0.0168590322,
-0.0088233231,
-0.0054025468,
-0.017354155,
-0.0024518194,
-0.0060726763,
-0.0136379078,
0.0026815827,
-0.0135481264,
0.0348001607,
-0.0254880879,
-0.0499772541,
0.007389538,
0.0054662037,
0.0307670049,
0.0281015653,
0.0311036054,
0.0374002755,
-0.0568398386,
0.0190797132,
-0.0598053932,
0.0154065704,
0.0051396224,
-0.0009519958,
0.0146726519,
0.0266448203,
0.0067977831,
-0.0067686224,
0.0049192272,
-0.0119281355,
-0.0507944748,
0.0323897824,
-0.0103393327,
0.0158601739,
-0.0073190448,
-0.0170533881,
-0.0177086126,
0.0301325917,
-0.0064559835,
-0.0527184829,
-0.0006844124,
0.0288326927,
2.839e-7,
0.0313730352,
0.0580021106,
0.0192770548,
0.0337668546,
0.0338355787,
0.044696264,
-0.048439946,
-0.0338754877,
0.0559233837,
-0.0092060445,
0.018716272,
0.0396265537,
0.0333814211,
0.0485138297,
-0.0341806263,
0.0061615752,
-0.0212147925,
-0.0131876543,
-0.0369331092,
0.0017420597,
0.0468348414,
0.0871878937,
0.0185587201,
-0.0300718304,
0.0307171866,
-0.0228853934,
0.0384331122,
-0.0038819457,
0.0088625066,
0.0150243696,
-0.0046727685,
0.0201468747,
0.000885484,
0.007604064,
-0.0019263478,
-0.001570968,
-0.0560061969,
0.0336302109,
-0.0153302532,
-0.0007599235,
-0.0224995594,
-0.0095914667,
0.0223609712,
-0.0620152578,
0.0732353926,
-0.0059355963,
-0.0168035701,
-0.0227174554,
0.0082732392,
-0.0338656418,
-0.0201298092,
-0.0222075898,
-0.0201393366,
0.005924454,
-0.0141574368,
0.0180861633,
0.0103016216,
-0.0707678497,
-0.0209915265,
0.0397798307,
-0.0308167934,
-0.0436005592,
-0.0443763845,
0.0221410617,
0.0231728796,
-0.0438469388,
-0.0010284676,
2.492862145e-34,
0.0424160473,
-0.0052342224,
0.0496353321,
0.0288501699,
0.0440876447,
0.0245913751,
0.0032151493,
0.0323202461,
0.0347285122,
-0.0359549224,
-0.0397086442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20656v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20656v1 | Non-Compositionality in Sentiment: New Data and Analyses | 2023-10-31T17:25:07 | 2023-10-31T17:25:07 | Verna Dankers, Christopher G. Lucas | cs.CL | cs.CL | When natural language phrases are combined, their meaning is often more than
the sum of their parts. In the context of NLP tasks such as sentiment analysis,
where the meaning of a phrase is its sentiment, that still applies. Many NLP
studies on sentiment analysis, however, focus on the fact that sentiment
computations are largely compositional. We, instead, set out to obtain
non-compositionality ratings for phrases with respect to their sentiment. Our
contributions are as follows: a) a methodology for obtaining those
non-compositionality ratings, b) a resource of ratings for 259 phrases --
NonCompSST -- along with an analysis of that resource, and c) an evaluation of
computational models for sentiment analysis using this new resource. | [
0.0203236043,
0.0792888477,
-0.0046874629,
0.0057147136,
-0.0595528856,
0.0185146593,
-0.0341533981,
0.0059527741,
-0.0180965327,
-0.0685109571,
-0.0195780639,
-0.0370920002,
0.0128051396,
-0.0077600405,
-0.0257784221,
-0.0247247517,
0.0251285229,
0.0756871477,
0.0262277108,
-0.0031633815,
0.0111973006,
0.0105194896,
-0.0006507376,
0.0169084333,
-0.0215300601,
-0.010442418,
0.0108920354,
0.0115192402,
0.0025796161,
-0.00145545,
0.0499209501,
0.0180529281,
-0.0402487032,
0.0101648699,
0.0000018612,
-0.0076557458,
0.0100204861,
0.0002472436,
0.0576081648,
-0.0258336365,
0.1007262021,
-0.031700585,
0.0031959391,
-0.0022076641,
-0.0253492538,
0.0229916889,
0.0480526797,
0.0545303896,
0.0333489552,
0.0473456532,
-0.0175041072,
-0.0159313772,
-0.0825066939,
0.0137661789,
0.0210910868,
0.0344355404,
0.0163815655,
-0.0342903882,
-0.0362137631,
-0.0280122068,
-0.0403643139,
0.0025944375,
-0.0096389586,
0.0166107602,
-0.0031151969,
0.0115911616,
-0.0384784192,
-0.050580658,
0.0191055965,
0.0118216863,
0.0552201755,
-0.0039980654,
0.0120439166,
0.0128525551,
-0.0232295524,
-0.0172357392,
-0.0056414539,
0.027205497,
-0.0066551859,
0.0137600424,
-0.0065805493,
0.0679942593,
0.0187867321,
0.0306587983,
0.0021199735,
0.0489319824,
-0.0028696121,
-0.0597762018,
0.0305211507,
0.0171579234,
0.033445172,
0.0012563107,
-0.0304234028,
-0.0239840019,
0.0152716711,
0.0233441554,
0.0207862146,
0.0184045359,
0.0451588333,
-0.1116509438,
0.0116827078,
-0.0130742574,
0.025379153,
0.0570869036,
-0.0204257537,
-0.0409580208,
0.016945485,
-0.0323797688,
-0.0362476036,
-0.0007528453,
-0.0782886818,
0.005924968,
0.0533389039,
0.0621150732,
-0.0088321958,
-0.0281894747,
-0.0839170665,
-0.0215932224,
-0.0803907737,
0.0053114099,
0.0419500098,
0.03536392,
0.0158642493,
0.0082826959,
-0.0321601443,
0.0503324308,
-0.038988553,
0.0274601243,
-0.0554924347,
-0.0245884974,
0.0195954014,
0.0284538027,
-0.0113406805,
-0.0124536203,
0.0129137319,
0.0310119744,
0.0591862276,
-0.0352067091,
0.0035998092,
-0.0198862646,
-0.041320961,
-0.0711892992,
0.0079271952,
-0.0604348369,
0.0243792776,
-0.0093008205,
0.033406578,
0.035206981,
-0.000028707,
0.0197491981,
-0.0327945687,
0.0606794991,
-0.0290157963,
-0.0131336432,
-0.066220656,
-0.0074436241,
0.0146192247,
0.0588021316,
-0.0085417936,
0.0360928066,
0.0313194729,
0.0202555396,
-0.0023421731,
-0.0514484346,
0.0070432406,
-0.044641234,
-0.0065049673,
-0.0002378713,
-0.0605708361,
-0.0701164305,
-0.033894144,
0.0525761172,
-0.0044948584,
-0.0170275681,
0.004171446,
0.0142779173,
0.0267875958,
0.0522471815,
-0.0195508879,
0.0059276354,
-0.0000460728,
0.0223552007,
-0.0146699203,
0.0114052314,
-0.059003152,
0.0040280954,
0.042129308,
0.0289690159,
-0.016710991,
-0.074620463,
-0.0295585953,
-0.0256014355,
0.0676589757,
-0.0329034105,
0.0276241861,
-0.0086818319,
-0.036312826,
-0.0164319389,
0.0413424708,
-0.0886615589,
0.009217578,
-0.0093754847,
0.0050755665,
0.0666353926,
-0.022224227,
-0.0156464651,
-0.0084503349,
0.0024917121,
-0.0206289943,
0.0209894534,
-0.0284278821,
0.0153334476,
0.0159129966,
-0.0367557444,
0.0290772393,
-0.0236661192,
0.0480424091,
0.0030467082,
-0.0132749267,
0.005377315,
-0.0137008382,
-0.0144567583,
0.0226071551,
-0.0114502097,
0.0824301317,
0.0101267081,
0.0162217952,
0.0200224761,
0.0443585403,
0.0477606021,
-0.0083403066,
0.0181843564,
0.0109525006,
-0.0088928947,
-0.1086058989,
0.027169019,
0.0176314861,
-0.0487425588,
-0.0064286059,
-0.0689399317,
-0.0319334827,
-0.0340994261,
-0.0194224548,
-0.0184903704,
0.0479655191,
-0.0352125317,
0.0427205972,
-0.0254633259,
-0.0078236405,
-0.0045979978,
-0.0207135826,
0.001056876,
0.0666791201,
-0.0016318035,
0.0391427651,
-0.0259683486,
-0.053092964,
0.0511366874,
0.026850963,
-0.0752654299,
0.0148386033,
0.0140877655,
-0.0052350485,
0.0397109427,
-0.0308208168,
-0.0361774489,
-0.0647862926,
-0.0819340348,
-0.0285841953,
-0.0038796109,
0.0301092397,
0.0135804657,
-0.0012059055,
0.0182947349,
0.0604677349,
-0.0092288591,
0.0002418471,
-0.0258821361,
0.049461104,
0.0393427648,
-0.0043649576,
0.0210496858,
-0.0345593616,
-0.0154446578,
-0.0598322004,
0.0299703162,
-0.0183011629,
-0.0189123191,
0.0149129508,
0.013684921,
-0.0732288957,
-0.0261365995,
0.0012404083,
-0.0708078593,
-0.0135048758,
0.0131043578,
0.0180957504,
0.0311074331,
0.0040928139,
0.0158816334,
0.0266730934,
-0.0012122487,
0.0069421297,
0.020936178,
-0.0718231574,
0.0054984759,
0.0274564549,
-0.0086098369,
0.0175106749,
0.0362009443,
0.0233104788,
-0.0159267411,
-0.0807280317,
0.0021684824,
-0.0542710051,
0.001904172,
-0.034243051,
-0.0139483251,
-0.002981582,
-0.0096595325,
0.0173441004,
-0.0216693226,
0.0456780717,
0.0299499948,
0.0101204207,
-0.0446314141,
-0.016422037,
-0.0471510813,
0.0577533469,
-0.02642674,
-0.0018000642,
0.021204384,
0.0113811661,
0.0249037277,
-0.042338755,
0.000565002,
-0.0071530165,
0.019605482,
0.0405072942,
0.0075546177,
0.0186024308,
-0.0222965106,
0.0698395222,
-0.0030304003,
-0.0248877108,
0.0023537253,
0.0525752045,
-0.0115162265,
0.0121564148,
-0.0334217027,
-0.0129885618,
-0.0771445185,
-0.0038599733,
-0.0173275713,
0.0330412351,
0.0030066327,
-0.020954119,
-0.017496651,
0.0296645891,
-0.0123290084,
-0.0195985567,
0.042143032,
0.0014276807,
0.0358522981,
-0.0195317306,
-0.0198629722,
-0.010117894,
0.0054333839,
-0.000089723,
-0.0406302735,
-0.0046602944,
-0.0302929711,
0.0367327332,
0.0697609112,
0.0296666548,
-0.0223511569,
-0.0024322325,
0.0083493777,
-0.0306945499,
0.0427091569,
-0.0190122873,
-0.0348895304,
0.0060628126,
-0.0097917765,
-0.0229844432,
-0.0185698438,
-0.0146488864,
-0.0170598235,
-0.0679817945,
0.0083220908,
-0.0034911092,
0.0150831183,
-0.0331105404,
-0.0504778735,
-0.004769383,
-0.0364076011,
-0.0733024478,
-0.0385893472,
-0.0054083169,
0.0132717527,
-0.0245126076,
-0.0904784575,
-0.0277286079,
0.0202348456,
0.0025760427,
-0.0012463895,
0.0337471515,
0.0924851,
-0.0009959722,
-0.0319345631,
0.0453570001,
-0.0618780479,
-0.0012591389,
-0.0101081096,
0.0346344486,
-0.0372852199,
-0.014578294,
-0.0355503745,
-0.0109269666,
-0.0586749911,
0.0086578578,
-0.0218292139,
0.0407848321,
0.0062090144,
-0.0560014136,
-0.0521135405,
0.0774280876,
0.0288256351,
0.0773074701,
-0.0008245321,
-0.0301712584,
-0.0011858394,
-0.0154608851,
-0.0201833081,
-0.0487684458,
0.0039461092,
0.0139688291,
0.0453082174,
-0.0002138789,
-0.0711717457,
-0.050297834,
-0.0061208447,
0.0400744453,
-0.0335078724,
0.0143528813,
0.0108533325,
-0.0028228806,
-0.0168641731,
0.0004827509,
0.0451798029,
0.0141740311,
0.004175473,
-0.0063299933,
0.0528022386,
0.0450890735,
-0.027591534,
-0.0770377442,
-0.0361127481,
-0.022577161,
-0.0246867724,
0.0417110994,
0.0138312066,
-0.065000996,
-0.0105666108,
-0.0110337501,
0.0022282598,
0.0999628082,
-0.0024364411,
0.007073862,
0.0582429469,
0.0539825708,
0.0338583775,
0.0081546437,
-0.0129319467,
0.0155097358,
-0.0149577875,
0.0102328723,
0.017203534,
0.0095285103,
0.0233879238,
-0.032608442,
0.0229909085,
0.0230707228,
0.0029068794,
0.02272778,
-0.0228817314,
-0.0187235326,
-0.0640770048,
-0.0201623403,
-0.0272302926,
0.0026666787,
0.0337079875,
-0.0741405189,
0.019099487,
-0.0320965983,
0.0426904187,
0.0280161984,
0.0643416345,
0.0724058226,
-0.0532225221,
-0.0380951911,
0.0134274587,
-0.011789551,
0.0069897901,
-0.0316486508,
-0.0360891037,
-0.0123650301,
0.0272519197,
0.0101973629,
0.0077789756,
-0.0065215565,
0.0133835413,
-0.0279695094,
0.0613765977,
-0.0242607333,
-0.0073728939,
0.0020555728,
-0.037036784,
0.0163996685,
-0.0424044058,
-0.0009754068,
-0.00850954,
0.0196136069,
0.0024494042,
-0.0329081006,
0.0495216735,
0.0162401311,
-0.0303869229,
-0.0270232968,
0.0516692847,
-0.1004244089,
0.0376162156,
0.0355919786,
0.0293412395,
-0.0182974953,
-0.0248010084,
0.035694845,
0.054510504,
0.0042150798,
0.027809348,
-0.0818349645,
-0.002349453,
0.0548883229,
-0.013690454,
0.065164417,
-0.0124095641,
0.0197622273,
0.045675911,
0.008374678,
0.0593973771,
-0.033052437,
-0.0241682231,
-0.0261767637,
0.0358478874,
-0.0119410129,
-6.503800858e-33,
-0.0120203784,
-0.0441233255,
-0.0492470004,
0.0420710184,
-0.0096551515,
0.038882874,
-0.0032835144,
0.0316337086,
0.0115443263,
0.0424483269,
-0.0024117874,
0.0261359531,
-0.0013330519,
0.013444297,
0.0495093279,
0.0009919028,
0.0484635159,
0.0150605664,
0.0004018689,
-0.0349759795,
0.0187570676,
-0.0029019297,
0.0373536162,
-0.1116904542,
0.066059418,
0.0278036501,
-0.0729358196,
-0.0209784508,
0.0427680053,
0.0404233672,
-0.0144545585,
0.0661288574,
0.0420807973,
0.0177524798,
0.0435219184,
0.0252687111,
0.0038374814,
-0.0130933365,
0.0458837338,
-0.0190953799,
-0.0347712599,
-0.0141817601,
0.0182822011,
0.0158769563,
-0.0493671224,
-0.0320600346,
0.0246010404,
-0.0254764743,
0.0058957725,
-0.0870681852,
-0.0942438841,
0.0330789573,
-0.0003028257,
-0.009373555,
0.0271035582,
0.0234799087,
0.0090457238,
0.0797117203,
-0.0573749915,
0.0557500795,
-0.0694920495,
0.0219857749,
-0.0384482369,
-0.0617954433,
0.0421935357,
0.0747298226,
0.0075678825,
0.0593622737,
-0.0412891693,
0.0441900156,
0.000950322,
0.0403645039,
0.0502740182,
0.0712366924,
0.0486674607,
-0.0054923189,
0.01259086,
0.015373121,
0.0202450491,
-0.0154330796,
0.0509159118,
0.003606789,
-0.0404956415,
-0.013183495,
0.00603768,
-0.050990086,
-0.0387176014,
-0.0364062339,
0.011283597,
0.0101385834,
-0.0054422445,
-0.0202377047,
-0.0436979495,
-0.0493134409,
-0.0195012297,
0.0539851636,
-0.0011600548,
0.0261992738,
0.018720625,
-0.0046559903,
-0.0451731794,
-0.0137182148,
-0.0293063801,
0.0639534369,
0.0167300384,
-0.0099432683,
0.0520320721,
0.0352260917,
-0.0892592371,
-0.0300262123,
0.0007636704,
-0.0166564975,
-0.0242519043,
0.0059506865,
0.0262167808,
0.035873577,
-0.0014883149,
0.0517366119,
-0.0067012124,
0.0855000913,
0.0070458218,
-0.0003577737,
-0.0118000442,
0.0260578599,
-0.0100450777,
-0.0609512478,
0.0181888025,
-0.0308197606,
0.0166884009,
-0.0200233273,
-0.0174401682,
-0.0294311829,
2.789e-7,
0.0343715735,
0.0820499435,
-0.0148590636,
-0.0164185278,
0.0189705584,
0.0462332182,
-0.0248284787,
-0.003186794,
-0.0439613424,
-0.0055950405,
0.0178867653,
-0.0242936295,
0.0202702973,
0.016495293,
-0.0741968974,
0.0361767374,
-0.0302160699,
-0.0538193025,
-0.0125701781,
0.0481684357,
0.0879114419,
0.0754880533,
0.0385757573,
0.0179213062,
-0.0164220054,
0.018349506,
0.0516985357,
-0.0456588902,
-0.0400841869,
0.0037846919,
-0.020326592,
0.0026204763,
-0.0094794277,
-0.0326093845,
0.0038590017,
0.0091786617,
0.0440336801,
0.0429751799,
0.0237050001,
-0.0115255248,
0.0121079227,
0.0032433704,
-0.0094833905,
0.0016483662,
0.0269146655,
-0.0641281977,
-0.065877907,
-0.0954273716,
-0.0335853584,
0.0443034545,
0.0784536004,
0.0140027283,
-0.0357927084,
0.0140828388,
-0.0149041433,
-0.028741153,
-0.0365903825,
-0.0660676658,
0.0034123152,
0.0034907069,
-0.0061264923,
-0.0168695338,
0.0172458254,
0.071553655,
0.0616786107,
-0.0252753161,
-0.0176628642,
1.971859401e-34,
0.0819010064,
-0.0551841669,
0.0376836807,
-0.0151251145,
0.0396885872,
0.0074617839,
-0.0493160076,
-0.0336665362,
0.0183290541,
-0.0141015947,
0.0010687173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20633v1 | Defining a New NLP Playground | 2023-10-31T17:02:33 | 2023-10-31T17:02:33 | Sha Li, Chi Han, Pengfei Yu, Carl Edwards, Manling Li, Xingyao Wang, Yi R. Fung, Charles Yu, Joel R. Tetreault, Eduard H. Hovy, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent explosion of performance of large language models (LLMs) has
changed the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP) more abruptly and
seismically than any other shift in the field's 80-year history. This has
resulted in concerns that the field will become homogenized and
resource-intensive. The new status quo has put many academic researchers,
especially PhD students, at a disadvantage. This paper aims to define a new NLP
playground by proposing 20+ PhD-dissertation-worthy research directions,
covering theoretical analysis, new and challenging problems, learning
paradigms, and interdisciplinary applications. | [
0.0873683989,
0.0848647952,
-0.0394357555,
0.041098129,
-0.0652316958,
0.0081851147,
-0.0531375073,
0.0115859387,
0.0150457108,
-0.1035102531,
-0.0017324681,
0.0029415188,
-0.0066935127,
0.022403039,
0.0044515799,
-0.0724481419,
0.0221252665,
-0.0084879454,
0.0025737733,
0.0222421065,
0.006536236,
0.0029744371,
-0.0057766978,
0.056184385,
-0.0294538829,
-0.0246776436,
0.0443851352,
-0.0085905166,
-0.0379361771,
-0.0482046008,
0.0254147127,
0.0039461418,
-0.0062605902,
0.0433570854,
0.0000020277,
-0.065998286,
-0.0174928959,
0.0060842247,
-0.0191088524,
-0.0118246963,
0.0745033324,
-0.0351027101,
0.0064624394,
0.0018246673,
-0.0314239785,
0.0033293471,
0.0674069449,
0.0342045538,
0.0374905951,
0.051453501,
-0.0035482785,
-0.0499877967,
0.0086929118,
-0.0051278225,
-0.0389913805,
-0.0502238609,
0.0493319854,
0.0027509991,
0.0281252097,
0.0032631771,
-0.0264169089,
0.0431183502,
-0.0592786893,
0.006098723,
0.0274704285,
0.0209199321,
-0.009013826,
-0.0294642262,
-0.0310389269,
0.0610656179,
-0.0334198624,
-0.0146675091,
-0.0021687264,
-0.0270928238,
-0.0447820313,
0.0130102672,
-0.0631247833,
0.0517645068,
-0.0088342372,
0.0385981239,
0.0317595936,
0.0163292643,
0.0382452235,
0.0342938639,
-0.0199137107,
0.0580476746,
0.0062160958,
-0.0526101626,
0.0161746722,
0.0209202357,
-0.039388027,
-0.0065008663,
-0.0104149505,
0.0326214433,
-0.0151725756,
0.0539399721,
0.0155478269,
-0.0314697362,
0.0601331294,
-0.0498155728,
0.0523158014,
0.0051449933,
0.0171714537,
0.0308048036,
-0.0057327133,
0.0251422413,
-0.0235573053,
-0.0157105643,
-0.0183360148,
-0.0148571134,
-0.0915573165,
-0.0301510468,
-0.0294220038,
0.0383734927,
-0.017534351,
-0.0390267037,
-0.0039526387,
0.0118126413,
0.0068301274,
0.0191782936,
0.0133749815,
0.0297456961,
-0.0079052355,
0.0037330517,
-0.0396461338,
0.0244146977,
-0.0187340006,
0.0107542379,
-0.0671909973,
-0.0378610566,
0.0006903998,
0.0151586635,
0.0123181008,
-0.0194143262,
0.0205904823,
0.1153420731,
0.0519829728,
-0.0448878296,
-0.0336338952,
-0.0148697691,
-0.0426393375,
-0.0436059684,
-0.0111793922,
-0.0530686341,
0.0155674191,
0.024387626,
0.0425726287,
-0.0536782034,
0.0235703848,
0.0084987674,
-0.0366971605,
0.0939886272,
0.0085952319,
0.0083754305,
0.0008949036,
-0.0181772336,
0.015232048,
0.0909269676,
0.0144590456,
-0.0028240113,
0.087888971,
-0.0010278763,
0.0092749698,
0.0431406982,
-0.022728255,
-0.0224573519,
-0.0229853988,
-0.0071321186,
0.0530300364,
0.0207708329,
-0.0205020104,
0.0599685311,
0.0179372821,
-0.0080001345,
0.0327921286,
0.1120985821,
-0.015604916,
-0.0062761176,
0.0320456028,
0.0031820775,
-0.0181516372,
-0.006695569,
0.0172515139,
-0.0596971251,
0.0040841158,
0.0007565375,
-0.0157485381,
0.0384705737,
0.0127584999,
-0.0236112196,
-0.0782625899,
-0.0139517495,
0.0206750724,
-0.0314093977,
0.0431028046,
0.0082928576,
-0.0010881016,
0.0268070325,
0.0241331346,
-0.0183145218,
0.0008923397,
-0.0530527681,
-0.0047064889,
0.0261352006,
0.0628218353,
-0.050309673,
0.0162134506,
-0.0148082692,
-0.0405794829,
0.063956365,
0.007196106,
-0.038331829,
0.0186830517,
-0.007606586,
0.0162021816,
-0.0166596845,
0.0302147921,
-0.0288643986,
0.0675778314,
-0.0225667153,
-0.0032566015,
-0.024457328,
-0.0729327723,
0.0657303408,
-0.0336405896,
-0.0511623099,
0.0295953993,
-0.0057816473,
0.0343744718,
0.020296691,
0.0081792502,
0.0250682086,
0.054250434,
-0.0502481833,
-0.0172649026,
-0.003903318,
0.0288064908,
-0.0238081068,
0.0523174778,
-0.0252729841,
-0.0069132298,
0.0090950858,
-0.0263475515,
0.0098898038,
0.015500485,
-0.0432231985,
0.0474846624,
-0.0105312988,
0.0451664291,
-0.0029508744,
0.0142369233,
-0.0728096962,
0.0852569267,
0.0040026857,
0.064288035,
-0.0100538041,
-0.013401648,
0.0160508063,
-0.0001441131,
-0.0284715574,
0.0136379516,
0.0012698971,
0.0173385367,
0.0554358996,
-0.0283602588,
-0.0620471612,
-0.0520667806,
-0.0467705168,
0.0204909444,
0.00263101,
0.0094047189,
0.0053512836,
-0.0058056335,
-0.0083582178,
-0.0189821068,
0.0205052532,
-0.0268836897,
0.0476003177,
0.017370414,
0.0605200566,
0.0135405594,
0.0022255767,
-0.0303054266,
-0.0106917201,
-0.0054962002,
0.065518707,
-0.0227418039,
-0.0377370007,
-0.0310690477,
-0.0246978905,
0.0110784955,
0.0450018384,
-0.0065214452,
0.03092397,
-0.0058070151,
-0.0000197617,
0.0394868813,
0.0489061326,
0.0047520585,
0.0700969473,
0.042544134,
-0.0098184571,
-0.0276051015,
0.002523537,
-0.0680545941,
-0.0284851659,
-0.0387332179,
-0.001312402,
0.0464782007,
0.0523234531,
-0.0027592061,
-0.0178771801,
-0.0151048545,
0.0334030986,
-0.0594151989,
0.0004979575,
-0.0378878042,
-0.0280664396,
-0.0177710615,
0.017028315,
-0.0141890356,
-0.0444799811,
0.0648123473,
-0.043381311,
0.0258896034,
-0.0928780586,
-0.0453158021,
-0.0788708255,
0.110049367,
-0.0197001006,
0.0175917838,
0.0309695434,
-0.0326076597,
0.0123603484,
-0.013089316,
-0.0013852504,
-0.0274518989,
0.0582404472,
-0.0392686315,
0.0399146676,
-0.0091801044,
-0.0442478582,
-0.0330239199,
-0.0591790937,
-0.0628744662,
0.0148730362,
0.0246245619,
-0.0318175703,
-0.032660678,
0.0149072735,
-0.0001043098,
-0.0265664943,
0.016673943,
-0.0092359204,
-0.0365244187,
0.0371756591,
0.0387023315,
-0.0110735372,
0.0217764694,
-0.0036084827,
0.015885273,
0.053499423,
0.0291762482,
0.0293623731,
-0.0070323222,
0.0183004495,
0.0426523089,
-0.0867913812,
0.0049264389,
0.0003827309,
0.0176714994,
-0.0448305905,
-0.0069474159,
0.0935556442,
0.0367570631,
-0.0098554473,
0.0398683436,
0.0173220914,
-0.0028618949,
0.0326208472,
0.0209486,
-0.0452675745,
-0.0240648948,
-0.0100635262,
0.0105982134,
-0.0652504563,
-0.0620491207,
-0.0185310747,
-0.1340139359,
0.0081796842,
-0.0101226531,
0.0183923021,
0.0066713621,
-0.078275606,
-0.0102665545,
-0.0252483804,
0.0122885648,
-0.0490620472,
-0.0488981307,
-0.0192733947,
0.0498760231,
-0.0280009322,
-0.0463719517,
0.0075358488,
-0.0462879762,
0.0402340479,
0.0392954648,
0.0483013727,
-0.0001185058,
-0.0073761032,
0.0005954653,
-0.031932015,
0.0148253255,
-0.0231818222,
0.0295457579,
-0.0414086878,
-0.021229282,
0.0047623166,
0.0033663299,
-0.0387606137,
-0.0036256025,
0.0151984729,
0.1074612215,
-0.0090396237,
-0.003533731,
-0.0351153165,
-0.0155266253,
0.0015338797,
0.0611497536,
-0.0011088911,
-0.0282879248,
-0.0082483934,
-0.0126656797,
-0.0005261707,
-0.0068317642,
-0.0705083236,
0.0114755314,
-0.0079905931,
0.0092340363,
-0.0549189225,
-0.014325276,
0.061144162,
-0.0006760299,
0.0396608785,
0.0491825193,
0.0059983889,
-0.0050691785,
-0.0645558983,
0.0252575222,
-0.0376544297,
0.0048270109,
-0.0380303524,
-0.0129194474,
0.0686364919,
0.018620044,
-0.0192520954,
0.0034458574,
-0.0905074328,
-0.0793251768,
-0.0314013697,
0.0097670024,
0.021233771,
0.0262250528,
-0.0113827698,
-0.0419632941,
0.014995194,
0.0496138409,
-0.0491848141,
-0.0155279003,
0.000301172,
0.0144433137,
0.0053742635,
0.0257763248,
-0.0124319503,
0.0145089999,
0.0088441828,
0.0375505462,
-0.0078578461,
-0.0528184846,
0.0569931008,
0.0275034253,
0.0514084734,
-0.0067447503,
-0.0416455045,
-0.0147132529,
-0.0259788986,
-0.0043797842,
-0.0445699953,
-0.0321626514,
-0.0302236509,
0.0252787601,
0.0162809584,
-0.0520433821,
0.0193447638,
-0.0214500371,
0.0580134951,
-0.0287298113,
0.0357162729,
0.0232871175,
-0.0346548408,
0.0285977889,
-0.0153955799,
-0.0168075599,
0.0114144301,
-0.0196025595,
0.0214659758,
0.0071563604,
0.016960809,
0.0318707339,
-0.0064063533,
-0.0191462282,
0.0023214826,
-0.0413072817,
-0.0906138271,
-0.0170314219,
0.0445340089,
0.0181212556,
-0.039667666,
0.0087763267,
-0.064735949,
-0.0132471537,
-0.0146652563,
-0.0003573924,
0.0143281221,
-0.0427053198,
0.0312438738,
0.0192636587,
-0.0526074208,
0.0061563272,
0.0714966282,
0.0188309103,
0.0576522276,
0.0269754436,
-0.0202644337,
-0.0304805096,
-0.0228491016,
0.0470419861,
0.0036071837,
-0.0165535007,
0.0679328889,
-0.0778696463,
-0.0454952754,
-0.0088578183,
-0.0090942318,
0.01860689,
-0.040394336,
0.0031314371,
0.0657216907,
0.0634917021,
0.0015318559,
-0.0716608688,
0.0089796064,
0.015411512,
-0.0310766008,
-0.0095919967,
-6.806053517e-33,
-0.0026167971,
-0.0465755351,
0.0186836608,
-0.0315595381,
-0.030339282,
0.0051276386,
-0.0011221376,
0.0265376419,
-0.0104027418,
-0.0193700567,
-0.0182053335,
-0.0024316569,
-0.0029887797,
0.0234748106,
0.0356986858,
0.0203393046,
0.0537440144,
-0.0054786396,
-0.0014196265,
-0.0327542424,
0.039745979,
0.0228348784,
0.0348043405,
-0.055187393,
0.031820979,
0.0151694305,
0.0093715983,
0.0469519347,
0.0152295204,
0.0517991595,
-0.0584402569,
0.0669333115,
0.0477605984,
-0.0391167812,
-0.0035179455,
0.0105205597,
-0.0495183244,
-0.0093793944,
0.010706272,
0.0015137899,
0.010843697,
-0.0068617882,
0.0519433357,
-0.0149662737,
-0.0102744233,
0.0117650386,
0.0288311802,
-0.0305014066,
-0.0243824571,
0.0368381441,
-0.0817989483,
0.0383370481,
-0.0042989654,
0.0115813287,
0.0595836714,
-0.003883224,
-0.0018913922,
0.0259516444,
-0.0446805917,
0.0148231508,
0.0247259792,
0.0514928848,
0.0150604276,
0.0185189191,
0.0057875817,
0.0671655536,
-0.009360712,
0.005001443,
-0.0173053071,
-0.0366897509,
0.0305287149,
0.0541438647,
0.0139493905,
0.0039402703,
0.0338653214,
-0.0082330694,
-0.0337622277,
-0.0041429945,
0.0542168021,
0.0436742976,
0.0205031969,
0.0088401744,
-0.0410880037,
-0.0461300127,
-0.0447984897,
0.0093436399,
-0.0032780219,
-0.0058365013,
0.0081927674,
0.0366109572,
-0.0312172119,
0.027998399,
-0.003076555,
-0.0830496401,
-0.0573330708,
-0.016276516,
0.0439291,
0.0223906636,
0.0036555042,
0.0072064088,
-0.0651731566,
-0.0416502804,
-0.0403757058,
-0.0086958567,
0.0048993505,
-0.0278065652,
-0.0020291298,
0.0136550162,
-0.0477323458,
-0.0061480948,
-0.0158375539,
0.0097599905,
-0.0116876075,
0.0653406978,
0.0391291082,
0.0323336609,
-0.0119623309,
0.0275959615,
0.0412390754,
0.0086134812,
0.0166816376,
0.0207173787,
0.0191337261,
0.0117217051,
-0.0160711836,
-0.034920048,
-0.0538391545,
0.0174430162,
0.0329875574,
-0.0569645911,
-0.0022970131,
-0.0288713872,
2.844e-7,
0.0554362983,
0.0480523109,
0.0139861498,
0.0125640593,
0.0268104002,
0.0316234343,
-0.021664815,
0.019141404,
-0.038390629,
-0.0090139471,
-0.0302780569,
-0.0001586571,
0.0214775149,
0.0092610065,
-0.1013552025,
-0.015733609,
-0.0601708815,
0.022102762,
-0.0851991251,
0.006520865,
0.0300176814,
0.1041745842,
0.0041036233,
0.0079512177,
-0.0538213626,
-0.0289944932,
0.0629166365,
-0.0238140915,
0.0110112447,
0.0295543615,
0.0419221856,
0.0286639649,
0.0360465012,
0.0044439114,
-0.0152701801,
0.0371817611,
0.0034572533,
0.050224103,
0.0041821194,
-0.0179529209,
0.0084842397,
-0.0241556279,
-0.0027224941,
-0.0495915413,
0.0650840923,
-0.0450613797,
-0.0439310074,
-0.0531756803,
0.00390165,
0.0046841004,
0.0064680567,
-0.0151822912,
-0.041924201,
0.0123927314,
0.0253880899,
-0.016420817,
-0.0140373316,
-0.0960512683,
0.0114183379,
-0.0210283995,
-0.0246897899,
-0.0152929267,
-0.0133195957,
0.0183176585,
0.0304109827,
-0.0721369982,
0.0177814178,
2.797812471e-34,
0.0240242239,
-0.0113809677,
0.0114256218,
0.052391883,
0.0331053101,
-0.0019856694,
-0.0068780095,
0.0251223817,
0.0059198635,
-0.0843716785,
0.0071395854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2310.20620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.20620v2 | The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Random Target Embeddings for Continuous-Output Neural Machine Translation | 2023-10-31T16:53:10 | 2024-04-02T15:56:46 | Evgeniia Tokarchuk, Vlad Niculae | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Continuous-output neural machine translation (CoNMT) replaces the discrete
next-word prediction problem with an embedding prediction. The semantic
structure of the target embedding space (i.e., closeness of related words) is
intuitively believed to be crucial. We challenge this assumption and show that
completely random output embeddings can outperform laboriously pretrained ones,
especially on larger datasets. Further investigation shows this surprising
effect is strongest for rare words, due to the geometry of their embeddings. We
shed further light on this finding by designing a mixed strategy that combines
random and pre-trained embeddings for different tokens. | [
0.0232025459,
0.0199803002,
0.0186673086,
0.035676565,
-0.0125425924,
-0.015807528,
0.0148445508,
0.0012506756,
-0.0408846587,
-0.0198681075,
-0.0345753953,
-0.028363755,
0.0343944989,
0.008458388,
0.0637505725,
-0.0019087108,
0.0307657421,
-0.0041617346,
-0.0411181524,
0.0055050533,
-0.0222815964,
-0.0195018072,
0.0324492119,
0.0767754242,
-0.0383079015,
-0.0039191241,
0.0033558884,
0.0121378656,
0.0122677637,
-0.0198273417,
-0.0257621817,
0.0268506128,
0.0376515985,
0.0816582441,
0.000001615,
-0.0203512069,
-0.0160597898,
-0.0052541238,
-0.0037353162,
0.0131014204,
0.0384712815,
-0.0460484102,
-0.0055457335,
0.0292304978,
-0.0136492038,
-0.029963458,
0.0475040674,
0.0227274932,
0.0423319787,
0.0691395774,
-0.0008735468,
-0.0338919349,
0.020932002,
-0.0770538375,
0.0104936715,
-0.0178014226,
-0.0328187533,
-0.0560651794,
-0.0523675606,
0.032605201,
-0.0155103812,
0.0283206645,
0.0163057707,
0.0323014334,
0.0266644713,
0.0744791403,
-0.0397363976,
-0.0163502973,
-0.0031365813,
0.0772337765,
-0.0952270851,
0.0087252725,
-0.0435752608,
-0.0137995398,
-0.0113438843,
-0.056280572,
-0.0227325112,
0.0307017658,
0.0374696925,
0.0485443324,
0.0281450786,
0.0881456882,
0.0619922057,
-0.0241541695,
-0.0613497421,
-0.0195010677,
0.0173452068,
-0.0434265584,
-0.0088887494,
0.024108272,
-0.0232325178,
-0.0286088586,
0.0019885947,
0.0022423307,
0.0066694804,
0.0249295235,
-0.0606127121,
-0.0325391814,
0.0049831253,
-0.0185458343,
0.0392497703,
0.0712000057,
0.0074607809,
0.0473814234,
-0.046377372,
0.0372411907,
-0.0327606946,
0.0527080148,
-0.0561865903,
0.0315883011,
-0.0169222094,
0.0089463517,
-0.0343236662,
0.0056419712,
-0.0140599888,
-0.0540339686,
-0.0342570916,
0.0122378152,
0.0005779897,
0.0043580942,
0.0005834114,
-0.0011873798,
-0.0804709271,
-0.0024483558,
0.0054982677,
0.004404719,
-0.015268473,
-0.0116004637,
0.0043206257,
-0.005262176,
-0.0585024543,
0.0187183805,
-0.0236410629,
-0.0282340199,
-0.0038179106,
0.1130856797,
-0.031753283,
-0.0720429271,
0.015524528,
-0.0358678587,
-0.0092919897,
-0.0190637931,
0.0595002174,
-0.0413975194,
0.0551902689,
-0.0040547731,
-0.0079162121,
-0.0268036015,
0.0098690968,
0.008121999,
-0.0486246571,
0.0944151953,
0.0404950194,
-0.025509309,
0.0064676427,
0.0062068375,
0.0131995883,
0.0506980754,
0.0102842692,
0.050402794,
0.0176195279,
0.0298712719,
-0.0272461642,
0.0454949811,
0.0410701409,
-0.0032189335,
-0.0503547788,
-0.0029418315,
0.0171700511,
0.0904492438,
0.0419547893,
0.0321494564,
-0.0429814942,
-0.0059748925,
0.03988453,
0.0421172529,
-0.0010241813,
0.0315824784,
0.0467865989,
0.0022993854,
-0.0509706102,
0.0285675824,
-0.0420988575,
0.0258805044,
0.0303396434,
-0.0081291152,
0.070824936,
0.0331663713,
-0.0159456506,
-0.0218887217,
-0.0053980951,
-0.0354334228,
-0.0102662584,
-0.0761682987,
0.0132560935,
0.0201044511,
-0.0570150912,
0.0304933507,
0.0018718204,
0.0200360697,
0.0133785689,
-0.0042757695,
-0.0193291344,
0.024562113,
0.0688080192,
-0.0081083914,
-0.0450778119,
-0.0166720189,
0.0110818008,
0.0584980883,
0.0445864238,
0.0209694114,
0.0434303321,
-0.0310266204,
-0.0263020247,
0.0005600948,
0.0222960226,
0.0152254133,
0.0090345601,
0.0381510779,
0.0424159691,
-0.0477648005,
0.0130632706,
0.0597289838,
-0.005488479,
-0.0482527129,
0.0331658907,
0.0520698167,
0.0086316234,
-0.0112308851,
-0.0200962815,
0.0491529517,
0.0087387227,
-0.0581266284,
-0.0390079394,
0.0120943645,
-0.0341575742,
-0.0579611957,
0.0241119303,
-0.0418201685,
-0.0160025377,
0.0017271825,
-0.0461882874,
-0.0015631992,
0.0148217939,
-0.041311074,
0.0642433763,
-0.0466596298,
0.0115961907,
0.024345113,
0.0313427076,
-0.029945761,
0.0287493281,
-0.0361398347,
0.0239034761,
0.0072099799,
-0.0237291083,
0.0376551561,
-0.0340080783,
-0.0089746891,
-0.0034874515,
0.0283574965,
0.0106991641,
-0.0149697233,
0.0450041443,
-0.0082414486,
-0.049748648,
-0.0359395146,
-0.0240436979,
-0.0079582566,
0.0089816237,
0.0115923993,
0.0183964334,
0.0194505937,
-0.0204378609,
-0.0195280313,
-0.0028821321,
-0.0382340364,
0.0427436791,
0.056809172,
-0.0003551255,
-0.0041347332,
-0.0239300039,
-0.0233852603,
0.0139391916,
0.0731400698,
-0.022538187,
0.0288489666,
-0.0797679201,
0.0115156639,
-0.0167539641,
0.0020332804,
-0.0061376966,
-0.0438407026,
0.0073045301,
-0.0309013445,
0.0386962034,
0.0217134152,
-0.0073690759,
0.0084491987,
0.0204624087,
-0.0007501151,
-0.047222726,
-0.0263283625,
-0.0525159761,
-0.0082020704,
0.0057549193,
-0.0101413606,
0.014256563,
0.0290651787,
0.0226812139,
0.0032250043,
-0.055381313,
0.0355080366,
0.0029734697,
-0.0010227408,
-0.067316629,
0.0341223516,
-0.0019312936,
-0.0057626325,
-0.0108278822,
-0.0596788637,
0.0731924921,
-0.0288691223,
0.029195467,
-0.0471380055,
-0.0011908108,
-0.0220175199,
0.0471313484,
-0.019928636,
0.0130523881,
-0.0074659572,
-0.0312831253,
-0.0536194816,
0.0413250215,
-0.0384106077,
0.0025833421,
0.0157247949,
0.0034868999,
-0.036298994,
-0.0086337272,
0.0036273976,
-0.0408635624,
-0.104984276,
-0.0200721789,
-0.0242905039,
0.0409306996,
-0.0186030753,
0.0012920001,
0.0233551916,
-0.0176156014,
0.0638180971,
-0.0228027292,
-0.0119701987,
-0.0151049746,
0.0458062924,
-0.0049888766,
-0.0221726615,
0.0206717718,
-0.0160723589,
0.0043969499,
0.0253454577,
0.0174594,
-0.000116036,
-0.0485941358,
-0.038923718,
0.0156027656,
0.023579007,
-0.0384942256,
-0.015474028,
0.0147917233,
-0.0344631523,
-0.0342109054,
0.1089701802,
0.0274186023,
-0.0239396263,
0.0303707179,
0.0177880023,
0.0536030121,
0.0165493879,
0.0376228616,
-0.0427623838,
-0.0441205427,
-0.0101803644,
0.030490486,
0.0404508784,
0.0088706566,
-0.0384696946,
-0.0803790092,
0.010745463,
0.0596712269,
-0.0453019291,
-0.0666129366,
0.0014117265,
-0.0367003307,
-0.0009842676,
0.0077425209,
-0.0087305838,
0.0252771992,
0.0021036125,
-0.0200707484,
-0.0343202502,
-0.0440503918,
-0.0030304382,
-0.0616945587,
0.037519671,
0.0962168947,
0.0208049826,
0.0106786564,
-0.0293988883,
0.0969325006,
0.000700997,
0.0254221726,
0.0057376088,
0.0266793948,
-0.0144583145,
-0.0158604924,
0.044037424,
-0.0271029063,
-0.0262757484,
0.0091618849,
-0.0166555662,
0.0916048363,
-0.0305138472,
-0.0118538141,
-0.0184283536,
-0.0018817454,
0.0115175871,
0.067676492,
0.0187795591,
-0.0477554947,
-0.002052956,
-0.0165563747,
0.0436373092,
-0.0039729015,
-0.0193821024,
0.0104852263,
-0.022942679,
-0.031399034,
-0.0905317441,
-0.0982041284,
0.015609026,
0.0799897388,
0.0012859326,
-0.0100367963,
-0.0294383205,
-0.0007213715,
0.0053740037,
0.035474427,
-0.0294691715,
0.038936194,
-0.0206069015,
0.0413766652,
0.0131699666,
-0.023346955,
-0.023056034,
-0.002994264,
-0.0938337371,
-0.0476007909,
-0.0509248786,
0.0213252883,
0.0178695302,
0.0396618359,
-0.0473138019,
-0.0280205738,
0.064816311,
0.0022493729,
-0.0240761805,
0.0078307837,
0.0296374448,
-0.0051603727,
0.0094326613,
0.048078537,
-0.0050504762,
-0.0102645,
0.0082650632,
0.0403193198,
-0.0006340019,
-0.0051787179,
-0.0078449445,
-0.0588316955,
0.098294057,
-0.0501687787,
0.0048542488,
-0.028116297,
0.0267288908,
-0.0087324968,
0.0055165067,
-0.0421608314,
-0.0328596346,
0.0607444122,
0.0236241426,
-0.014991154,
-0.0189675372,
-0.0050973599,
0.054655578,
0.0148340492,
-0.0427017212,
-0.0164489299,
0.0164303854,
0.0164562203,
0.0339194685,
-0.0272151735,
0.001365036,
-0.0474803597,
-0.0007483904,
-0.0546885878,
0.0112764547,
0.0059019546,
0.0202004835,
-0.0108085265,
0.0215653684,
-0.0239524227,
-0.0042928187,
-0.0292293616,
0.0034593935,
0.0509167686,
0.0017997986,
0.002593274,
-0.0042606895,
-0.0142108044,
-0.0070022536,
0.0072570825,
-0.0208992828,
-0.0307527352,
0.054423511,
-0.0096722292,
-0.0160415135,
0.0052835974,
0.0870831609,
0.0099165039,
-0.0146526182,
0.0005104563,
-0.0144281993,
-0.0481137745,
0.0330116563,
0.0128518585,
0.0334253609,
0.0060372381,
0.0056951656,
-0.0447004959,
-0.0685370341,
0.0472996756,
0.0192697849,
-0.0338837691,
0.0292943418,
0.0227439757,
0.0697601736,
-0.0319150761,
0.0428823866,
-0.0110330842,
0.0229570232,
0.0398411714,
-0.0621966049,
-0.0387367383,
-5.929379013e-33,
-0.0045949034,
-0.0002726805,
0.0082615968,
-0.0450238176,
-0.0456570275,
0.003654195,
-0.0309128705,
-0.0077092052,
-0.0073055429,
0.0264663771,
-0.0308130942,
0.0053112167,
0.0142638953,
0.0160174351,
-0.0124540133,
-0.0281291865,
0.0318122618,
-0.0330339223,
-0.0179599505,
-0.0024807618,
0.0262919869,
0.0367478877,
0.0381971598,
-0.0650605485,
0.0111564035,
0.0062497715,
0.0121697001,
0.0288130827,
0.0467848927,
0.0146712475,
-0.0432348028,
0.0200166311,
0.0190131348,
-0.0180689543,
-0.0355822444,
-0.01401072,
-0.0509586595,
-0.0419298448,
-0.0229969956,
0.0204675775,
-0.0294055007,
-0.0343474634,
0.0390547067,
-0.04395587,
-0.0176057685,
-0.0129350517,
-0.0070307278,
-0.0176667739,
-0.0601318143,
0.0072016153,
-0.0505248383,
0.0195395295,
0.0412513167,
-0.0025572327,
0.002818441,
0.0173411183,
0.0314301588,
-0.017587347,
-0.0910108313,
0.0179553907,
-0.0617395453,
0.0640603304,
0.037369594,
0.0011980355,
-0.0015526846,
0.033754047,
0.051587645,
-0.0425500087,
-0.0142956106,
0.0288298894,
0.0228151418,
0.0106341476,
0.0508534797,
0.0202313196,
0.0454259254,
-0.0229385514,
-0.044242572,
0.0121350484,
-0.0100327721,
-0.0428110957,
0.0662475154,
0.0007612904,
-0.0556151308,
-0.0215204619,
-0.0126043875,
-0.0259011574,
-0.0319174826,
-0.0185907558,
0.0165145751,
0.0713692755,
0.0209913943,
0.0084815659,
0.0520533547,
-0.0042580413,
0.0175802559,
0.0369619466,
-0.0050105639,
-0.003003577,
-0.0166173242,
0.0214816481,
-0.0139477709,
-0.0219572317,
0.0074971579,
-0.0014606197,
-0.0017265913,
-0.0185215324,
0.0446379147,
0.0376658924,
-0.0562044382,
-0.0394551568,
-0.0565530695,
-0.0243429709,
-0.0066881422,
-0.0175378397,
0.0541119277,
-0.0246243607,
-0.0078155827,
0.0239830948,
0.0492876545,
0.0174478143,
-0.0004587835,
0.042665951,
0.0294305086,
0.0398050398,
-0.0380585268,
0.0079164905,
-0.0070491615,
0.0287559498,
0.0324135982,
-0.0930471569,
-0.0228096638,
-0.0098659387,
2.403e-7,
0.0507628359,
0.0458978005,
0.0028819339,
0.0063827727,
0.0146132167,
0.0356254354,
-0.0198908672,
0.0376314931,
-0.0267172381,
0.0331794135,
0.0278763399,
-0.0195445754,
0.0377732441,
0.0146827856,
-0.0919507146,
0.0060486034,
-0.031748116,
0.0680515096,
-0.0506339632,
-0.0539752841,
0.0234908704,
0.1616408378,
0.0154842185,
0.0024656074,
-0.0310846474,
-0.0545316264,
0.0706338063,
-0.0086356038,
-0.0112843458,
-0.0414044596,
0.0184837319,
0.0230896734,
-0.0163142048,
-0.0372614823,
-0.0490792058,
0.0460271761,
0.0722926036,
0.0427139103,
0.0000812596,
-0.0398418829,
0.0115778213,
-0.0172772557,
-0.0142169567,
-0.0018278926,
0.0441672578,
-0.0889777169,
-0.0030839127,
0.0226178002,
0.0122273285,
0.0271949582,
0.0376539454,
-0.0214631539,
-0.0549459383,
-0.0027963268,
0.066166684,
0.008055307,
0.0262791179,
-0.0831067935,
-0.0320234857,
-0.0287976675,
-0.0766306743,
-0.0253182538,
-0.0295736827,
0.020763848,
0.0823685527,
-0.0011165816,
-0.0526218973,
2.420090091e-34,
0.0418581925,
-0.0091646621,
0.0334670544,
-0.0474501215,
0.016969109,
-0.0231596883,
0.0875481516,
-0.0246918406,
0.0405675136,
-0.0444813929,
-0.0466344766
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.