id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09205v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09205v1 | When Is Multilinguality a Curse? Language Modeling for 250 High- and Low-Resource Languages | 2023-11-15T18:47:42 | 2023-11-15T18:47:42 | Tyler A. Chang, Catherine Arnett, Zhuowen Tu, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multilingual language models are widely used to extend NLP systems to
low-resource languages. However, concrete evidence for the effects of
multilinguality on language modeling performance in individual languages
remains scarce. Here, we pre-train over 10,000 monolingual and multilingual
language models for over 250 languages, including multiple language families
that are under-studied in NLP. We assess how language modeling performance in
each language varies as a function of (1) monolingual dataset size, (2) added
multilingual dataset size, (3) linguistic similarity of the added languages,
and (4) model size (up to 45M parameters). We find that in moderation, adding
multilingual data improves low-resource language modeling performance, similar
to increasing low-resource dataset sizes by up to 33%. Improvements depend on
the syntactic similarity of the added multilingual data, with marginal
additional effects of vocabulary overlap. However, high-resource languages
consistently perform worse in multilingual pre-training scenarios. As dataset
sizes increase, adding multilingual data begins to hurt performance for both
low-resource and high-resource languages, likely due to limited model capacity
(the "curse of multilinguality"). These results suggest that massively
multilingual pre-training may not be optimal for any languages involved, but
that more targeted models can significantly improve performance. | [
0.0164483562,
0.0901615098,
-0.0223393906,
0.0480493344,
-0.0257522445,
0.0216677021,
0.0490476079,
0.0010037775,
-0.0317034386,
-0.0653200001,
-0.0512114055,
-0.052485045,
-0.0037615825,
-0.0236511733,
0.0222570039,
-0.0630225241,
0.0409964435,
-0.0476619154,
-0.0240751747,
-0.0307275783,
0.0118964808,
0.0349538364,
0.0376801342,
0.0224063266,
-0.0332063437,
0.0057522003,
0.0226974543,
-0.0016978726,
-0.0128629077,
-0.0068400893,
0.0126187466,
0.0684744194,
0.0117404032,
0.0376338363,
0.0000019612,
-0.0602823757,
-0.0060556736,
-0.0074627646,
0.0009198994,
0.0377967618,
0.05895276,
-0.0689916462,
0.0145863146,
0.0200166609,
-0.0245424807,
-0.0334675051,
0.0552460402,
0.020946173,
0.018080201,
0.047299169,
-0.0222360194,
-0.0263445526,
0.0116670206,
-0.0256820768,
-0.0530045554,
-0.0235986877,
0.0133846188,
0.0106605161,
-0.0072052917,
-0.0026607453,
-0.0158744957,
0.0279818606,
0.0058258353,
0.047735896,
-0.0518726036,
0.0281915069,
-0.0261057056,
-0.0497416407,
0.007937842,
0.0280453376,
-0.0713115036,
-0.054591693,
-0.0264278147,
-0.0078453571,
-0.0396748297,
0.0034054727,
-0.0254160576,
0.0426609404,
0.0032631804,
0.0198722109,
0.054589238,
-0.0120416265,
0.0447816402,
0.0231473073,
-0.0075849709,
0.0307367817,
0.0511633232,
-0.031801641,
0.0262018424,
0.0334510505,
-0.0094672488,
-0.0252680872,
-0.0253734272,
-0.0170411766,
-0.0183040295,
0.0385885499,
-0.0343351029,
-0.0518323407,
0.0573797747,
-0.074930124,
0.0491112582,
0.0250886213,
-0.018809611,
0.0372478403,
-0.0155295366,
-0.004687306,
-0.0169358328,
-0.0027328909,
-0.0570016578,
-0.0400238298,
-0.0189562198,
0.0036882742,
-0.0538330562,
-0.0002986593,
-0.0190945528,
-0.0064225621,
-0.0196609423,
-0.0046871481,
-0.0054815942,
-0.0233533327,
-0.0006803112,
-0.0270486474,
-0.0151275052,
-0.0022334962,
0.01399309,
0.0444452576,
-0.0586172566,
0.0098697413,
-0.0368970111,
-0.0801706016,
0.0155999428,
0.0138234692,
-0.00449561,
-0.0511844121,
0.0397394747,
0.061973121,
0.0075923847,
-0.0336075053,
-0.0400548428,
0.014650601,
-0.0018127563,
-0.0679083765,
-0.0020935286,
-0.0918315947,
0.0719844699,
0.0334836207,
0.0401874892,
-0.0477010831,
-0.0122529538,
-0.0039271479,
-0.0373119377,
0.0759614184,
-0.0221151896,
0.0165870097,
0.0172226205,
-0.0272661913,
0.0203979518,
0.1164210737,
-0.0107809892,
-0.0577154011,
0.0793927759,
-0.028763542,
-0.0324397422,
0.0628234372,
-0.0046133222,
0.045675952,
0.0059604873,
-0.0109961312,
0.017209718,
-0.0012898546,
0.0332704075,
0.0324843749,
-0.0075718267,
-0.0123421894,
0.0320989452,
0.0352984481,
0.0101974243,
0.0226839576,
0.0432269126,
-0.0090707699,
-0.0049633919,
-0.0083569121,
-0.0197816081,
-0.0256450959,
-0.0029210723,
0.0011968244,
0.0032104978,
0.0749487728,
-0.0410640351,
-0.0210094117,
-0.0488095991,
-0.0415647216,
0.0326862112,
0.0045331097,
0.0538326725,
-0.0069476082,
0.0027334078,
0.0752938688,
0.0888362974,
-0.0482173339,
0.0086324494,
0.0043665194,
-0.0262480248,
0.0478906631,
-0.0023772421,
-0.0155772418,
-0.0121376403,
0.0083649689,
0.0131330043,
0.0358011983,
0.080994904,
0.0047274418,
0.0625138208,
-0.0472090207,
0.0052434057,
-0.0139327748,
0.0335215703,
0.0780443624,
0.0287781786,
0.032179784,
-0.014512714,
-0.007928621,
-0.0780158341,
0.0234028958,
-0.0916875526,
0.0002642975,
-0.0004878447,
0.0058154389,
0.0122201415,
0.0196017828,
-0.0104674678,
-0.0102968225,
0.0113704288,
-0.0408823863,
-0.0038537881,
0.0158850793,
-0.0305819735,
-0.0253562294,
0.0461503491,
0.0160961431,
-0.0047869529,
0.0206329823,
-0.0124843344,
-0.0288678017,
0.0273382701,
-0.0127354609,
0.0503741018,
-0.0427674204,
0.0242929794,
-0.0460908487,
0.0426540226,
-0.0278936513,
0.0328653827,
0.0119761452,
0.0473999754,
-0.0046328837,
-0.0271029137,
0.0558159016,
-0.0239685699,
-0.0551027879,
0.0351550728,
-0.0021910218,
0.0266029276,
0.0482569821,
0.0241306182,
-0.0173553266,
-0.0042748661,
-0.0928370282,
-0.0123077976,
-0.0371636413,
0.0004572243,
0.0077989437,
0.0400083698,
-0.014948654,
-0.004022711,
-0.0271567553,
-0.0159042943,
0.0213741139,
0.0601002164,
-0.0096100429,
0.0110627664,
0.0110613294,
-0.0455073267,
-0.0337749161,
0.0299389493,
0.0612169057,
-0.028939832,
-0.0432252884,
-0.0107787838,
0.026128104,
-0.0425049141,
0.0221747514,
0.0022805918,
-0.0343428291,
-0.0233940203,
-0.0198092181,
0.0470113195,
0.0088863214,
-0.0484733991,
0.0006628526,
0.0691711679,
0.0102858804,
-0.0542068295,
0.0153834205,
0.0042788438,
-0.0389005952,
-0.0442188606,
-0.0242983736,
-0.007348754,
0.0749556869,
-0.0207098257,
-0.0374506935,
-0.0490687191,
-0.0041074799,
-0.0602397919,
-0.0294970181,
-0.0132784927,
0.021702515,
0.0090987105,
0.0663440973,
-0.0120893409,
-0.0393471122,
0.0529445149,
-0.0246516,
-0.0149395159,
-0.0486868322,
-0.0235148612,
-0.0481357537,
0.0447238944,
0.0075440495,
0.0376245305,
-0.0245092697,
-0.0064282008,
-0.0310793947,
0.0129747428,
0.0287414584,
-0.0060379757,
0.0567017682,
-0.0267948862,
0.0145860733,
-0.0138661256,
-0.0631949231,
-0.02534022,
-0.0187258404,
-0.0130557464,
-0.0000309703,
0.0270737763,
-0.0077728424,
-0.0273698792,
-0.012223999,
0.0129637988,
0.0402701274,
0.0144212125,
0.010510481,
0.0167578626,
0.0176527034,
0.0408188663,
-0.011656601,
0.0168049168,
-0.0352657139,
0.0171413887,
-0.0209967252,
0.0342338495,
-0.003621151,
-0.009406995,
0.0096366275,
0.0535012037,
-0.0331881382,
-0.0494000725,
-0.0224698018,
0.02751977,
-0.0144871129,
-0.0062296963,
0.090990752,
0.0194365848,
-0.0489221253,
0.0110582914,
-0.0336396657,
0.0426084734,
0.0244455133,
0.0224707294,
-0.0670971349,
-0.0161329266,
-0.0031526298,
-0.0352997333,
0.0227355249,
-0.0002841454,
-0.0305924416,
-0.1286364347,
-0.0472059473,
-0.0134963775,
-0.0489510708,
-0.0094662691,
-0.0510948226,
-0.039063938,
-0.0372623391,
0.0504201055,
-0.0365106016,
-0.0173446499,
-0.0105585558,
0.0270766485,
-0.0298723411,
-0.0714225844,
0.032209117,
-0.0429826528,
0.0180646814,
0.0178750791,
0.0271616895,
-0.0485192873,
0.022683477,
0.0456773415,
0.0093255667,
-0.0002423495,
-0.0203015655,
0.0236008093,
0.0185816009,
-0.0104919793,
0.0278400984,
-0.024155153,
-0.0235972218,
-0.0000958455,
0.001938793,
0.0487249047,
0.0227207337,
-0.0278963186,
0.0061571505,
-0.0192322824,
-0.0045670047,
0.0539374463,
-0.0012161236,
-0.0559711866,
0.0040663732,
-0.0037286102,
-0.0217211079,
-0.04610423,
-0.006470596,
0.0326599739,
-0.0239486601,
-0.0390367024,
-0.0466494001,
-0.0877708122,
0.0040884139,
-0.0119561655,
0.0327681229,
0.0597682893,
-0.0212567393,
-0.0104728267,
-0.0163308885,
0.0375209264,
-0.0125578949,
0.0105979582,
-0.0368739627,
-0.0349785686,
0.0149645554,
0.0033374121,
0.0021959541,
-0.0228927229,
-0.0718477219,
-0.0644433424,
-0.0182268396,
0.0443121009,
0.0157725886,
0.0562895685,
0.0125385197,
-0.0632572696,
-0.0086220158,
0.0055515179,
-0.0180187058,
0.0082718385,
0.0471887812,
-0.0126897488,
0.0185963847,
0.0526587516,
-0.0361264311,
0.0275408439,
0.0172743555,
0.0340292677,
-0.0499381311,
-0.0200737063,
0.005095582,
0.0289810151,
0.023221029,
-0.057910189,
-0.0186677855,
-0.0528947003,
-0.0044464697,
-0.0353429653,
-0.0098825917,
-0.0208314527,
-0.0156939477,
0.0358351283,
0.0187469032,
-0.0282286592,
0.0061059222,
0.0118921129,
-0.0002114858,
0.0058691581,
0.0247974694,
0.0373984203,
-0.0171927158,
0.0265082736,
0.042886354,
-0.0215630718,
0.0264467262,
-0.0246598031,
0.0079235956,
-0.0489987172,
0.0092188437,
-0.0055603464,
-0.0100788577,
-0.0018950033,
0.0113944979,
-0.0132988533,
-0.0441814288,
0.0162125584,
0.0091655646,
0.082868889,
-0.0588793345,
0.0983157158,
-0.0315223373,
0.0036757796,
-0.0395251662,
0.0309317261,
0.0231005549,
-0.0509445481,
0.0448002666,
0.0059491443,
-0.041454304,
0.0043271151,
0.1107910648,
0.029869942,
0.0393777154,
0.005689133,
0.0136209568,
0.0075383964,
0.0032138298,
0.0169691555,
0.0255850982,
-0.0545428842,
0.0507487953,
-0.041837994,
-0.0628548339,
-0.0178254526,
-0.0098094614,
-0.0047534858,
0.0161357373,
0.0206897333,
0.0724660978,
-0.008259302,
0.0313847251,
-0.0592183881,
-0.0116472617,
0.0047349515,
-0.0147359623,
0.0091882376,
-6.137140293e-33,
0.0223989841,
0.0236322358,
0.0126681132,
-0.0235540643,
0.0321198814,
0.0160067007,
-0.0036673076,
0.033474043,
-0.0631351247,
0.005481042,
-0.0276733059,
-0.0155645749,
0.0156892631,
0.0306621101,
0.0485587865,
0.0203876812,
0.0289754737,
0.030705804,
0.0277014226,
-0.0132051893,
0.0337377079,
0.0368313082,
0.0896400884,
-0.0181239024,
0.0234790388,
-0.0259563942,
0.0262241662,
-0.007059094,
0.0251976252,
0.0657406524,
-0.0351931788,
0.0757099763,
0.0323873423,
-0.0326313861,
-0.0200536363,
-0.0278937444,
-0.0512766764,
-0.0447022021,
0.0467394032,
0.0503715463,
0.009855384,
-0.0077846996,
-0.0007525819,
-0.0095242383,
-0.0155085362,
-0.006278743,
0.0292208232,
-0.0186333247,
-0.0176169351,
0.0019223576,
-0.0968465209,
0.0286317971,
0.024739828,
0.0226497129,
0.0524291769,
0.0720754862,
-0.0148905944,
0.0093886955,
-0.0386651941,
0.0091409879,
0.0007004659,
0.0406984389,
0.0736914426,
0.0020987648,
-0.0061385958,
0.0279309098,
0.017664155,
0.0070211184,
0.0390914455,
0.020543145,
0.0538405888,
0.0166206248,
0.0274196826,
0.0783294067,
0.0411518849,
-0.0286715366,
-0.0635847971,
0.0164860766,
0.0236817077,
0.0127555262,
0.0178524591,
-0.0012114567,
-0.0126767205,
-0.0585807487,
-0.056147866,
-0.0094499169,
-0.0352735221,
-0.0395028852,
0.0326997116,
0.0124591691,
0.0252564717,
0.0272068586,
0.0370950997,
-0.0318936892,
-0.0781386867,
0.0394431017,
-0.0062761237,
-0.011124474,
-0.0203841254,
0.0503496341,
-0.0518879406,
-0.0499151684,
-0.0452209301,
-0.0177868586,
0.0032237952,
-0.0119951228,
0.07596571,
-0.0036515233,
-0.0683434308,
0.0121251866,
-0.030572433,
0.0123284031,
0.0168872979,
0.0461148582,
0.0345993489,
0.0132345762,
-0.0014739333,
0.0511510372,
0.0824504197,
-0.0244460665,
-0.038558919,
-0.0548734404,
-0.0163742043,
0.0149670159,
-0.0124703618,
-0.009226854,
-0.0617346391,
-0.0250006262,
0.037068367,
-0.0299821924,
-0.0248432942,
-0.0159028061,
2.548e-7,
0.0577357002,
0.0476673469,
-0.019601291,
0.0056023235,
0.0024893943,
0.0148617653,
-0.0409713611,
0.0269237719,
-0.034245085,
0.0318749286,
-0.0436857305,
0.0223058257,
0.0620849356,
0.0373428389,
-0.0606448799,
-0.0255752727,
-0.0647437051,
0.0242769066,
-0.0613388531,
-0.0045965421,
-0.0003857746,
0.1246906146,
0.0115137212,
-0.0086830212,
-0.0382210724,
-0.0426868573,
0.0836149752,
-0.0604245774,
-0.0356939659,
0.0304019172,
0.012781281,
0.0389149524,
0.0204369146,
-0.0032145609,
-0.0566673763,
0.0104102008,
0.0185501557,
0.0362479165,
-0.0090834154,
-0.0121344654,
0.0486873239,
-0.0303477291,
-0.0786300972,
-0.0693868846,
0.0540486909,
0.0121898977,
-0.0314953215,
-0.0167946871,
0.0196537562,
0.0346204303,
0.0633944198,
-0.0419591703,
-0.0490907878,
0.0346021429,
0.0343828797,
-0.0285568833,
-0.04188421,
-0.0447953492,
-0.0350452662,
0.0500918999,
0.0171096213,
-0.0059211454,
-0.0076838983,
-0.0267662965,
0.0405210294,
-0.0485031232,
0.0150362644,
2.190849407e-34,
0.0518375859,
0.0020220871,
0.0404943936,
0.0124893207,
0.0097885309,
-0.0444835462,
-0.0079109985,
0.0417552479,
-0.0277455878,
-0.0315960385,
0.0107623888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09204v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09204v3 | Fusion-Eval: Integrating Assistant Evaluators with LLMs | 2023-11-15T18:46:56 | 2024-06-06T22:47:44 | Lei Shu, Nevan Wichers, Liangchen Luo, Yun Zhu, Yinxiao Liu, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Evaluating natural language systems poses significant challenges,
particularly in the realms of natural language understanding and high-level
reasoning. In this paper, we introduce 'Fusion-Eval', an innovative approach
that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to integrate insights from various
assistant evaluators. The LLM is given the example to evaluate along with
scores from the assistant evaluators. Each of these evaluators specializes in
assessing distinct aspects of responses. Fusion-Eval achieves a 0.962
system-level Kendall-Tau correlation with humans on SummEval and a 0.744
turn-level Spearman correlation on TopicalChat, which is significantly higher
than baseline methods. These results highlight Fusion-Eval's significant
potential in the realm of natural language system evaluation. | [
0.0539622866,
0.0261645857,
-0.0074751396,
0.0178518537,
-0.0440385044,
0.0188931096,
0.0312305111,
-0.0161649212,
0.038384825,
-0.0838273317,
-0.0504130423,
-0.0193732474,
0.0119755398,
0.0354820602,
0.0079454249,
-0.0041910498,
0.0182474684,
-0.0144921178,
0.0198363718,
0.0000018687,
0.0155034559,
0.0256492309,
-0.0268867556,
0.0686381981,
0.0371837951,
-0.0273874346,
0.0075447662,
-0.0212253686,
0.0230962932,
-0.0069436431,
-0.0279504377,
0.0466917865,
0.0074581443,
0.0341420807,
0.000001728,
-0.0740702003,
0.0125805624,
0.0152603611,
-0.0410321616,
0.0289603621,
0.0457464233,
0.0404083468,
-0.0045352154,
0.0473676138,
-0.0562542342,
0.0067428784,
0.0104361009,
0.0253151115,
0.0979790241,
0.0453266762,
-0.0048577827,
-0.0074126273,
0.020266816,
-0.0027385212,
-0.0205346979,
-0.0851022601,
0.0133101279,
-0.0292840693,
0.0197003987,
-0.0199447796,
0.0192199312,
0.026770927,
0.0086613502,
-0.0210713744,
0.0166954622,
0.0096756406,
-0.0672029182,
-0.0080571733,
-0.0088662207,
0.0619587041,
0.0434826314,
0.0070244768,
-0.0179824717,
0.0262806062,
0.0142165879,
0.0191166941,
-0.0381581374,
-0.0066849794,
-0.0061608204,
-0.0264144838,
0.0121373655,
0.001092028,
0.0188983344,
0.0382224917,
-0.0295332652,
0.0718211159,
0.0225693788,
-0.0438618027,
0.0206012316,
0.0067579225,
-0.0206275731,
-0.0562437139,
0.0129737901,
0.0304126497,
-0.069919236,
0.0189977977,
0.0171687026,
-0.0267475285,
0.037209902,
-0.0430328697,
0.0482623279,
0.0268088393,
0.0108318692,
0.0696338564,
-0.0176160727,
0.0909865201,
0.0271900203,
0.017649183,
-0.0199892428,
-0.0080978833,
-0.0683741197,
-0.0117333187,
0.0248066913,
0.0292670205,
-0.032542523,
-0.0170505848,
-0.0617973208,
0.0332457162,
-0.009658874,
0.0050751665,
-0.0018612994,
0.0353508778,
0.0285370704,
0.00049071,
-0.0696125999,
0.0293490179,
-0.0315784812,
0.0472390056,
0.0109993042,
-0.0770838782,
0.0173709858,
0.033239156,
-0.005299862,
-0.0164605975,
0.0059090266,
0.0620436631,
0.0013926825,
-0.0405332632,
0.0008502958,
-0.0086490866,
-0.0492658168,
-0.0558605827,
-0.0101118432,
-0.0536004566,
0.0259158202,
0.0298702866,
-0.0012949733,
0.0047729472,
0.0189984646,
0.0406513214,
-0.0242491812,
0.0704637021,
0.034420114,
0.0307483096,
0.0081943898,
0.0153457448,
-0.0166867077,
0.0447460599,
0.0269060954,
0.0249272473,
0.0263857432,
-0.0196936857,
0.0071343342,
0.0171305183,
-0.0254330393,
-0.0085740173,
-0.0204987582,
0.0355380177,
-0.0447013229,
-0.0019690709,
-0.0136771044,
0.0827463195,
0.0060828533,
-0.003177128,
0.0531106479,
0.0718113929,
0.0357325859,
0.0418499969,
0.058834929,
-0.0005723938,
0.0263938215,
0.0030207222,
-0.0608650632,
-0.0021933077,
-0.0736556649,
-0.0055430862,
0.047581166,
0.037821237,
-0.0184772592,
-0.073850438,
-0.0266477149,
0.0050836825,
0.0063728141,
-0.0030481685,
0.0196456835,
-0.0098621892,
-0.0327810831,
-0.0180718284,
-0.0067673516,
-0.0618513525,
-0.0009428253,
-0.0649346784,
0.0020715978,
0.093253158,
0.0497530513,
-0.0060989968,
-0.0050179898,
-0.0207768958,
-0.0273914654,
0.0236296132,
0.0118576782,
0.0006560474,
-0.0116055273,
-0.0288777109,
-0.0292760432,
-0.0180532318,
0.0018674186,
0.0074749226,
-0.0201467536,
-0.0059273853,
0.0007911851,
-0.02203249,
-0.0300067011,
0.0276614334,
-0.0144988513,
-0.032468576,
-0.0126659889,
0.0044608298,
0.0489254184,
0.0335482843,
-0.0244270898,
0.0518752337,
0.0266523752,
-0.03419571,
-0.0397301242,
0.000203583,
-0.0198992863,
-0.0502863787,
0.0333477147,
-0.0172295254,
-0.0222269632,
0.0370773561,
-0.0244158339,
-0.0388326794,
0.0232406948,
-0.0505842306,
0.0088821119,
-0.0392897576,
0.0131370043,
0.00643093,
0.010247021,
-0.0308975838,
0.0777009353,
-0.007801766,
0.0319976136,
0.0042198258,
-0.0206720307,
0.0184544474,
-0.023910325,
-0.0285629556,
-0.0243491419,
-0.0136191435,
0.0373266973,
0.0208279006,
0.0175414737,
-0.0722920224,
-0.0435329713,
-0.1562317461,
0.0087308753,
-0.019005876,
0.0197708551,
0.0153856063,
-0.0162083749,
0.0010900149,
0.0305315405,
-0.048002094,
-0.0355877057,
0.0390597805,
0.0454402678,
0.0136002991,
0.000283843,
-0.0030146968,
-0.0568540841,
-0.0173452664,
-0.0571597293,
0.054651238,
0.0292992238,
0.0213843305,
-0.0004757674,
0.0266485941,
-0.0585133396,
0.0004978124,
0.0138196722,
-0.039757438,
0.0272000693,
0.006070951,
0.0243668817,
0.0672293976,
0.0353417918,
0.025226105,
0.0232274514,
-0.0282306802,
-0.0448468328,
0.0124327689,
0.0041307821,
-0.013558032,
-0.0076661119,
-0.0057972767,
0.0021205635,
0.0447522961,
0.011597435,
0.0055571045,
-0.0396754816,
0.0230420548,
-0.0264760815,
-0.0533231087,
-0.0566892698,
-0.0070497743,
-0.0161493346,
0.0231434312,
-0.0201214645,
-0.0148305139,
0.0883287564,
-0.027036259,
-0.013658544,
-0.076931186,
-0.037718799,
-0.0506673045,
0.0420836583,
-0.0378339849,
0.0091485968,
-0.0625116453,
-0.0165131725,
-0.0329065211,
-0.0142237414,
-0.0078221932,
-0.0729779899,
0.0792169049,
-0.0460565351,
0.0049682879,
0.033957541,
-0.0340395756,
-0.0617048107,
-0.0453477725,
-0.0521097668,
0.0210941192,
0.0023812274,
-0.0063067698,
-0.0654075518,
-0.0113649294,
0.030212529,
-0.0240543801,
-0.014209412,
-0.0255756099,
-0.0214789081,
0.0324910805,
0.0549165606,
0.0158055779,
0.0261544529,
-0.0072948332,
0.0570647866,
0.0325736403,
0.0361006111,
0.0034609132,
-0.031339258,
-0.0009437,
0.029517334,
-0.0194247402,
0.0024983706,
0.0200748611,
0.0384646282,
-0.0353756025,
0.0010776807,
0.1426219493,
0.0345346481,
-0.029888466,
-0.0216723923,
-0.0565079339,
-0.0003802202,
0.0241038743,
0.0156830642,
-0.0332819968,
-0.0485490039,
-0.0107187238,
0.0098508662,
-0.0113921193,
-0.0085066734,
0.0110359015,
-0.1286909431,
0.0146452924,
-0.0113954991,
-0.0305914041,
-0.0093445051,
-0.035535194,
0.0266943462,
-0.0084972614,
0.0446024686,
0.0047853151,
-0.0074253902,
0.0040241536,
0.0160968564,
-0.036034584,
-0.0343298689,
0.0778953508,
-0.0543068275,
0.0494580977,
0.0901554003,
0.0579171367,
-0.0022468141,
-0.095136404,
0.0048741898,
-0.039063748,
0.0283663068,
0.0107683931,
0.0257215761,
-0.0062536974,
0.0165645983,
-0.0580240227,
0.0016592389,
-0.0252815671,
0.0126096299,
-0.0061802161,
0.0610459186,
-0.0196787678,
0.0053270063,
-0.0295434799,
0.0617629662,
-0.0108745554,
0.0757679567,
0.0301301237,
-0.0494838655,
-0.0269279871,
0.0012882389,
-0.021635836,
-0.0098769674,
-0.0569651611,
0.0164561197,
0.0130725699,
-0.0097989114,
-0.075248085,
-0.0362191126,
0.028094165,
-0.0091596851,
-0.005784947,
0.0218121335,
-0.0576231591,
0.0308629256,
0.0030292715,
0.0486620851,
0.0018237183,
0.0567300282,
-0.0320065729,
0.0478131063,
0.0276613422,
0.014037244,
-0.0360516049,
0.0586482733,
-0.0272314437,
-0.0604820848,
-0.004367148,
0.0381625704,
0.0239458159,
-0.0309219938,
-0.0360043012,
-0.0520505607,
-0.0035359359,
0.0530733652,
-0.0748091266,
0.0125893941,
0.0171835031,
0.0290930662,
-0.0106957331,
0.030484518,
-0.0373741761,
-0.0083298786,
-0.006675242,
0.039576456,
-0.0317180604,
-0.0746729821,
0.0184624214,
0.0237838011,
0.052008301,
0.0077421353,
-0.0069481828,
0.0152337682,
-0.0057602306,
-0.0130663328,
-0.0211460404,
-0.0101086432,
-0.0138646457,
0.0285956673,
-0.0127866138,
-0.008657827,
0.0279319659,
-0.0411274806,
0.0329307914,
-0.0200212747,
0.0215339586,
0.0151727451,
-0.0055141062,
-0.0223386101,
-0.0026536081,
-0.0236824602,
-0.0238791853,
0.020381663,
0.0196621902,
0.0107553611,
0.0660929605,
-0.0071912804,
0.010189034,
0.0175680108,
0.0501154102,
-0.0568492711,
-0.0608081296,
0.0125255054,
0.0054786531,
0.0327537656,
0.0181075428,
0.0445986651,
0.0229732729,
0.0137477173,
-0.0414221883,
0.0023924953,
-0.0046800175,
0.0000090262,
0.0537433811,
0.0368957743,
-0.0131200664,
-0.0121662179,
0.0464500897,
-0.0395370834,
0.0120611405,
-0.0084518632,
-0.0372438878,
-0.0500665307,
-0.0294844303,
0.0048660971,
0.0235863868,
-0.0213330332,
0.0071269348,
-0.0967085734,
-0.0707720965,
0.0363506339,
0.013894639,
0.019661162,
-0.0083478857,
0.0326731615,
0.0648488253,
-0.0156656094,
-0.0194901731,
-0.0586024038,
-0.0064330837,
-0.0063452851,
-0.0035117725,
-0.0315956995,
-6.243007886e-33,
-0.0250953753,
-0.0344407447,
0.0185078438,
-0.0090863025,
-0.0145817986,
-0.0084903464,
-0.0047013294,
0.034970779,
-0.0108465021,
0.0243963711,
-0.0166343991,
0.0332204029,
0.0088539673,
-0.0008288517,
-0.0048945295,
-0.0359442234,
0.019808026,
0.0043574874,
-0.0222917609,
0.0047325739,
0.0299654435,
-0.0004486436,
0.013306845,
-0.1000191644,
0.0547624715,
0.0142448647,
-0.0049997889,
0.0263110138,
-0.0250847246,
0.0576129705,
-0.0267478395,
0.0562318414,
0.044229012,
-0.0245570708,
0.0305810831,
0.0416591465,
-0.0402946323,
-0.0313374326,
0.0702364072,
-0.023792211,
-0.0387162454,
-0.0167759508,
0.0403293446,
0.0093734562,
-0.0405119732,
-0.0042449068,
0.0390403979,
-0.0269976724,
0.0099509861,
-0.0316247381,
-0.0393027924,
0.0191928465,
-0.0313118994,
-0.0345303416,
-0.0392414369,
0.0563224182,
-0.0118295457,
-0.0004100829,
-0.0511631705,
0.0158895608,
-0.0085578095,
0.0092789652,
0.0716718659,
-0.0010925268,
-0.0249131229,
0.0648381785,
-0.0406153612,
0.0078370282,
-0.0689338222,
-0.0393492542,
0.0199209135,
0.0630053505,
0.0702696815,
0.0341965891,
-0.0360863581,
0.0312490333,
-0.0638230368,
0.0572760962,
0.02930969,
0.0640156791,
0.0057495874,
0.0010582778,
-0.0414138623,
0.0130839162,
-0.0780901462,
0.0335118994,
-0.072905004,
-0.0377211086,
0.0449123234,
0.002026597,
-0.025969496,
-0.0181145966,
0.0110225584,
-0.0304066818,
0.0104389731,
-0.0055900067,
-0.0013281647,
0.005835555,
0.0155768776,
0.0160941873,
-0.0705098212,
0.0344987251,
0.0141421231,
0.0162852723,
0.0322692543,
-0.0191789493,
0.0048358813,
-0.0072476333,
-0.0602989309,
-0.012746756,
-0.0283225477,
0.0096288593,
-0.013757892,
-0.0134284338,
0.0228708759,
0.0241617337,
-0.0281408094,
0.0535964593,
0.001005816,
0.0268063415,
-0.0202468857,
-0.0199570935,
0.00996878,
-0.0032756359,
-0.0424282625,
-0.0155793326,
-0.0119518107,
0.0133749889,
0.009911485,
-0.0122263627,
0.0014018596,
-0.0130375661,
2.554e-7,
0.0565222204,
0.0583872534,
-0.023616381,
0.000043721,
0.0211588107,
0.0506880097,
-0.0157415438,
0.0138868475,
0.0588454232,
-0.0253415871,
-0.0023809795,
0.0258476753,
0.0451055951,
0.0160830785,
-0.0494174995,
-0.0278994683,
-0.0733666345,
-0.0246537402,
-0.0328421406,
0.0119173666,
0.0812601075,
0.0773590729,
0.0275908932,
-0.0212203618,
-0.025668852,
-0.0751845241,
0.0617636554,
-0.0166275185,
-0.0508974604,
0.0074465568,
0.0828288421,
-0.0101041812,
0.0178591385,
0.0591419712,
0.0012857844,
0.0107204122,
0.0356292762,
0.0537224263,
-0.0284703411,
-0.0216740537,
-0.0050986619,
-0.0204403829,
0.0083557861,
-0.0512650125,
0.0851337537,
-0.032009691,
-0.051100336,
-0.0254134722,
0.0041699554,
-0.0175279733,
0.0573584549,
-0.0082030138,
-0.0128429094,
0.0235546455,
-0.0074841334,
-0.0029458399,
-0.0140187303,
-0.0679876208,
-0.0047621881,
-0.0007743688,
-0.0370022543,
-0.0443437025,
-0.026349986,
0.0187708363,
0.0055290745,
-0.0889808685,
0.0034613458,
2.157198815e-34,
0.0311535429,
0.0226425659,
0.0193235651,
0.0385908149,
0.0658451989,
0.0162898097,
-0.0409347042,
0.016838178,
0.0367045254,
-0.1022413597,
0.024906788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10770v2 | Exponentially Faster Language Modelling | 2023-11-15T18:42:50 | 2023-11-21T06:59:59 | Peter Belcak, Roger Wattenhofer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.NE | Language models only really need to use an exponential fraction of their
neurons for individual inferences. As proof, we present UltraFastBERT, a BERT
variant that uses 0.3% of its neurons during inference while performing on par
with similar BERT models. UltraFastBERT selectively engages just 12 out of 4095
neurons for each layer inference. This is achieved by replacing feedforward
networks with fast feedforward networks (FFFs). While no truly efficient
implementation currently exists to unlock the full acceleration potential of
conditional neural execution, we provide high-level CPU code achieving 78x
speedup over the optimized baseline feedforward implementation, and a PyTorch
implementation delivering 40x speedup over the equivalent batched feedforward
inference. We publish our training code, benchmarking setup, and model weights. | [
0.0194038358,
0.0967037901,
0.0099098273,
0.061467763,
-0.0104312012,
0.0102436077,
0.0405613519,
-0.007206203,
0.0010285844,
-0.0103361579,
-0.0110273361,
-0.0194846746,
-0.0333436839,
0.0157884341,
0.0223762225,
-0.0285167396,
0.0630137846,
-0.0158779435,
0.0387108922,
-0.0212403946,
0.0151738292,
0.0121619916,
-0.049266208,
0.0358966254,
-0.0259669945,
0.0088673886,
-0.0142593328,
0.0188407712,
-0.0104042366,
-0.0099072913,
0.0317520723,
0.0532917455,
0.0361941718,
0.0688889399,
0.0000020163,
-0.0035544545,
0.0330599509,
-0.0042006345,
-0.0265655182,
0.0704452917,
-0.0109151695,
-0.0032228315,
-0.0138704944,
-0.0208664015,
-0.0115869408,
-0.0268271845,
0.0425202772,
-0.0039989334,
0.0142430523,
0.0754635036,
-0.0063391118,
-0.0108082313,
0.0080976067,
-0.0361270607,
-0.0221610758,
-0.0314809233,
-0.0154633457,
-0.0512697659,
-0.0138140591,
-0.0411676057,
-0.0168248266,
0.0497926474,
0.060146369,
0.0210461132,
0.0119446991,
0.0555425063,
-0.0627059639,
-0.0262112916,
-0.0092181824,
0.0664537773,
-0.02963477,
-0.0271683801,
-0.0023258626,
0.0026100324,
-0.0260160044,
-0.0206890162,
-0.0061186091,
0.0067477119,
-0.008979735,
0.0194769818,
0.0086864037,
-0.0464005992,
0.0581169985,
0.0332760885,
-0.0132581908,
0.0642032847,
0.0680639893,
0.0131877614,
-0.0180893261,
0.011060142,
-0.0512605384,
-0.0412508026,
0.0441171229,
0.025160674,
-0.0147439307,
-0.0059557455,
-0.065643236,
-0.0382167473,
-0.0002855182,
-0.0911365896,
0.0516691208,
0.0453061536,
-0.0171786658,
0.0281018056,
-0.0574999414,
0.0086892955,
-0.0449876487,
0.0108253537,
-0.0278375465,
-0.0014877436,
0.0060595479,
0.0069972975,
-0.0759886652,
0.0151503924,
-0.0433986075,
-0.0615161732,
-0.0413682312,
0.0205479003,
0.0121477777,
-0.022618806,
0.0058341227,
0.0436810665,
-0.0250207335,
0.001132048,
0.0007289746,
0.0247447398,
-0.0634920821,
0.0159947649,
-0.0235737786,
-0.038417954,
-0.0199218355,
0.0175629519,
0.0064524463,
-0.0402009785,
0.0450010598,
0.0569283403,
-0.0039741667,
-0.0239726696,
-0.0560214631,
0.0247308686,
0.0115096793,
-0.0267541464,
0.023966305,
-0.0754228607,
0.0106725171,
0.0084147193,
-0.0144884745,
0.0070553548,
0.0079723885,
0.0145126851,
-0.0115675507,
0.0338074267,
-0.0424763523,
-0.0150216194,
0.0226540454,
-0.0185339153,
-0.0064120502,
0.071855709,
0.0452317409,
0.0246307645,
0.0137476502,
0.0121896686,
-0.0092671141,
0.0586999543,
0.0333460495,
0.001269141,
-0.0792917237,
-0.0297817402,
-0.0156071261,
0.0395590439,
0.0680279061,
0.041457992,
-0.0343510807,
-0.0428628176,
0.0527162813,
0.0539460406,
-0.0141616166,
0.0537760817,
0.0389353707,
-0.0130767981,
0.0334672965,
-0.0284676682,
-0.0482786931,
0.0432714038,
-0.0015293079,
-0.0152914142,
0.0114066992,
0.0326163881,
-0.0526451506,
0.0097867772,
-0.0054218196,
-0.0028078537,
0.0193380471,
0.0151180755,
0.0327317826,
0.0261407234,
-0.0200703423,
0.1067478508,
0.0467999801,
-0.04355333,
-0.0300931148,
-0.0609030724,
0.0003179472,
0.0625064149,
0.0309883393,
-0.0088966517,
-0.0422072448,
0.0388014279,
-0.0113858618,
0.0694903582,
0.0460839681,
0.007648244,
0.0635488704,
-0.0607750565,
0.016869083,
-0.010118464,
0.008159603,
0.0295359809,
0.0333533026,
0.0013751509,
-0.009154751,
-0.0460769869,
-0.0122405775,
0.0376603082,
-0.0258362684,
-0.0230147224,
0.0143947555,
0.0149830794,
-0.000962481,
-0.011299192,
-0.0317832567,
0.0087173404,
0.0032790333,
-0.0489475057,
-0.0081537608,
0.0022658058,
-0.0491778739,
-0.073752597,
0.0341045894,
0.0060084369,
-0.0177299492,
0.059387017,
-0.0381754823,
-0.0021510348,
0.0415829718,
-0.0522418655,
0.0803562775,
-0.0399959311,
0.0095671369,
-0.0241940767,
0.01278573,
0.0147711076,
0.0271267332,
-0.01195403,
0.0276806615,
0.0337926596,
0.023919655,
0.007107723,
-0.0295345858,
-0.0416864343,
-0.0142531293,
-0.0178648569,
0.000872315,
-0.014100885,
-0.0089730863,
-0.0000480509,
-0.0133986138,
-0.1255953908,
0.0017503505,
-0.022605136,
0.0207443703,
0.0264418833,
0.0232344735,
-0.002812617,
-0.0156410933,
-0.0138714314,
0.0181351304,
-0.0434842445,
0.0321766846,
-0.0049064541,
-0.0144062508,
-0.0433612131,
-0.0408478566,
-0.0557351783,
-0.0090185655,
0.0606368817,
0.0100438418,
-0.0235378519,
-0.0055354866,
-0.0772648156,
-0.0396001004,
0.0795439556,
0.004887173,
-0.0680607706,
0.0163329858,
-0.059799362,
-0.0128117306,
0.0516459644,
0.0035053317,
-0.009407863,
0.0044293343,
0.0012937132,
-0.046866741,
0.0444606766,
-0.0061403126,
0.0304916445,
-0.0271584243,
-0.0024185071,
-0.0355307646,
0.0885002539,
-0.002564037,
-0.011165577,
-0.0267548915,
-0.0136100939,
0.0165988095,
-0.0280890185,
-0.023981208,
-0.0190543626,
0.0015751246,
-0.0018787544,
-0.0287466254,
-0.0357914194,
0.0913280025,
-0.029718753,
-0.0057114651,
-0.0266567003,
-0.0142084248,
0.0015724949,
0.0352516957,
0.0403999016,
0.0370646231,
-0.0278414655,
-0.0110258255,
0.0103636552,
0.0310305394,
-0.0166731197,
-0.0161194317,
0.0384356081,
-0.0221106745,
0.0297891367,
0.0019651493,
-0.047274299,
-0.0300552137,
-0.0575613715,
-0.0331690125,
0.0372821316,
0.0148974042,
-0.0597855374,
-0.0201783609,
0.0090418514,
0.003815365,
0.0794472545,
-0.0269390028,
0.0145452954,
-0.0284122862,
0.054908067,
0.0293440763,
-0.0276065357,
0.0161599461,
-0.0500343889,
-0.0165190082,
0.0402166359,
0.0661100075,
0.0536744818,
-0.0959021971,
0.0192412287,
-0.0052522542,
-0.0115202963,
-0.0076958849,
-0.0014184727,
0.031499017,
-0.0739111975,
-0.0008988695,
0.1146429628,
0.0127463117,
-0.0155176986,
-0.0089819785,
0.0012905916,
0.030944325,
0.0121619636,
0.0226814914,
-0.0565480962,
-0.0543105304,
0.0167316403,
0.0175553039,
0.0243071299,
-0.0238885302,
0.0181072205,
-0.0591200106,
-0.0106327217,
-0.0117932577,
-0.0099057294,
-0.0177253839,
-0.0411958769,
-0.0098512266,
0.0142476512,
0.0016260146,
0.0158960894,
0.0193823483,
-0.0052974597,
0.0204626545,
0.0126124891,
0.0370078199,
0.053099215,
-0.0570680201,
0.0280480571,
0.0536134019,
0.0184017308,
-0.0208098423,
-0.0415461659,
0.0439174622,
-0.0164409298,
-0.0175998341,
-0.0012544255,
0.0523019023,
-0.0037431205,
-0.0404022187,
-0.0201262217,
-0.0104829716,
-0.0034465496,
0.0119463922,
-0.0318215117,
0.0408779979,
-0.0112364953,
-0.0215431303,
-0.0218218695,
0.0104366885,
-0.0108210891,
0.0393006466,
0.050790444,
-0.0705015138,
-0.029577136,
-0.0125248116,
-0.0338017456,
-0.0887494236,
0.0168081857,
0.0075244131,
0.0078091933,
-0.0831158981,
-0.0294467118,
-0.0207940172,
0.0101401955,
0.0497028679,
0.0069468836,
-0.0316697583,
0.0404768065,
-0.0171588492,
-0.0664409921,
0.0507860482,
0.0075109866,
0.0183574669,
-0.0467175096,
-0.02962666,
0.0689924359,
0.0222395789,
-0.0094544776,
0.0538614243,
-0.0677426308,
-0.0645376742,
-0.0024682567,
0.0224617161,
0.0133367702,
0.0145853544,
-0.0294604134,
-0.0258174241,
0.0105117708,
0.0570941679,
0.0054370146,
0.0335777067,
0.0223084353,
-0.0111989677,
0.0084390072,
0.0475243442,
-0.0077306097,
0.0331175551,
0.003334959,
0.0598613955,
-0.0036985963,
-0.0332715251,
-0.0116593475,
0.0117535312,
0.038734518,
0.0071877856,
0.0041968706,
-0.0398094468,
0.0065294448,
0.0190462302,
0.0271812212,
-0.0688529983,
-0.0066551398,
0.0224907957,
0.0145110758,
-0.0124143409,
0.0184976775,
0.0562796257,
0.0026338068,
-0.0505196825,
0.0080713509,
-0.0224234667,
0.0247022957,
0.0291319266,
-0.0154041825,
-0.0374388173,
0.0144464411,
0.0103930579,
0.0159639716,
-0.0678048134,
0.0389324911,
0.0235129744,
0.0017324938,
-0.0707820579,
-0.0059193834,
-0.0440643355,
-0.0741862282,
-0.0462111011,
0.039907489,
0.0548014343,
-0.0119966082,
0.0304648466,
-0.03389268,
-0.0098017082,
-0.0080368938,
0.0147847952,
0.0067068911,
-0.0275747944,
0.037935771,
0.0200001821,
0.0084681306,
-0.0106837805,
0.0530390702,
0.0061172652,
0.059374772,
0.0270816423,
-0.0025825335,
-0.0262738261,
-0.0435112417,
0.0355326198,
-0.0020830785,
-0.0174055193,
0.0309168939,
0.0261467304,
-0.0749771297,
0.0067849047,
0.0212538317,
-0.0042380318,
-0.0245499574,
0.0407839417,
0.0419202186,
0.0108389659,
-0.055785019,
-0.0021063143,
0.0623436421,
0.032962963,
-0.0439704247,
-0.0338308886,
-6.73850006e-33,
-0.0060960525,
0.0335768424,
0.0157152694,
-0.0274601597,
-0.0124586318,
0.0079687024,
-0.048553206,
-0.0138529185,
-0.0510984138,
0.0071952878,
-0.0134745864,
0.0517645404,
0.0136728119,
0.0641301572,
0.0023710884,
-0.0022435887,
0.0394415781,
-0.0231366977,
0.0077530365,
0.0106015401,
0.0209142454,
0.0464289002,
0.072208792,
0.0023266091,
-0.0642339513,
-0.007646454,
-0.002834144,
0.0277172811,
-0.0032151707,
0.0067697745,
-0.033389885,
0.0192846358,
0.0077670491,
-0.0164905749,
-0.0014207802,
0.0190493129,
-0.0911390558,
-0.0321716182,
-0.0015443555,
0.0200459901,
-0.0472533666,
0.0144681511,
0.0755847618,
0.0304426737,
-0.0000579663,
0.0068703354,
0.0082770847,
-0.0163766518,
-0.042868264,
-0.0286499411,
-0.0647652,
0.0340715535,
0.0050251135,
-0.0230777394,
0.0509819835,
0.0190702341,
-0.0299853869,
-0.0283381157,
-0.045590207,
-0.0484604798,
0.024570182,
0.0646720454,
0.0394075587,
0.0374556258,
0.0188868213,
0.0641215891,
0.0766103566,
-0.0269625932,
-0.0081451628,
0.0161565263,
0.0687207729,
0.0254457891,
0.0381416529,
-0.0302995685,
0.0556487739,
-0.0184797607,
-0.0828243345,
-0.0098181088,
0.0845007449,
0.0055545233,
0.0545309968,
-0.0051632416,
-0.0159719083,
-0.0172742102,
-0.0154547319,
-0.009265407,
-0.0558687896,
0.0047932253,
-0.014829101,
-0.0054298751,
0.0135638826,
-0.0252008215,
0.0116400383,
-0.0268080998,
0.0153080048,
0.029196389,
0.0143538797,
0.0130172893,
0.0198499318,
0.0613891743,
-0.0410346724,
-0.0116789499,
-0.0368507691,
0.0237395465,
0.0176993031,
0.0140294367,
0.0273527894,
0.0336739123,
-0.0405455455,
-0.0229734778,
-0.0660656691,
-0.0024342174,
0.0205269326,
0.0691194385,
0.0410279259,
0.0009136143,
0.0058744266,
0.0166851245,
-0.0283045247,
0.0206312183,
-0.019370079,
0.0018990712,
0.0330516472,
0.0389439389,
-0.0361647829,
-0.0222728755,
-0.0880399495,
0.0329982638,
-0.0375558175,
-0.1210111529,
-0.0300680585,
0.0532910787,
2.783e-7,
0.0380030572,
0.0285311118,
0.025514178,
0.0118110813,
0.0120214,
0.0199824497,
-0.0258654449,
0.0346742868,
0.0182283781,
-0.004452467,
0.0176404081,
0.0292126071,
0.053111285,
0.0389723405,
-0.06826666,
-0.0252440963,
-0.0987615064,
0.0289659724,
-0.0370603614,
-0.0131478952,
-0.0111620715,
0.0912043303,
0.0102404123,
-0.0403081551,
0.079307504,
-0.0454630218,
0.0407921709,
0.0079578599,
0.0100184828,
0.0146199232,
-0.0133132739,
0.0305251591,
-0.0235718116,
-0.0113300486,
-0.0130200898,
0.0188052226,
-0.0197474156,
0.0717824027,
-0.0346490927,
-0.0426280648,
0.0196576379,
-0.0376379415,
-0.0062673707,
-0.0336411931,
0.0460582562,
-0.0312933177,
-0.0245583896,
0.0086221006,
-0.003097387,
0.023002306,
-0.000099116,
-0.0290160421,
-0.0219551977,
0.007122694,
0.0257755686,
-0.0578238182,
-0.05052891,
-0.0970268324,
-0.0456286259,
-0.0002519799,
-0.0787866488,
-0.039352227,
-0.057109192,
-0.006788115,
0.0365541987,
-0.0568922535,
0.0270581637,
2.374224001e-34,
0.0558760576,
-0.0196137391,
-0.0080782752,
0.0193330739,
0.0182531476,
0.0016749774,
0.0172137804,
-0.040150173,
-0.0129834553,
-0.075214684,
-0.046406325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09198v1 | Never Lost in the Middle: Improving Large Language Models via Attention Strengthening Question Answering | 2023-11-15T18:42:44 | 2023-11-15T18:42:44 | Junqing He, Kunhao Pan, Xiaoqun Dong, Zhuoyang Song, Yibo Liu, Yuxin Liang, Hao Wang, Qianguo Sun, Songxin Zhang, Zejian Xie, Jiaxing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While large language models (LLMs) are equipped with longer text input
capabilities than before, they are struggling to seek correct information in
long contexts. The "lost in the middle" problem challenges most LLMs, referring
to the dramatic decline in accuracy when correct information is located in the
middle. To overcome this crucial issue, this paper proposes to enhance the
information searching and reflection ability of LLMs in long contexts via
specially designed tasks called Attention Strengthening Multi-doc QA (ASM QA).
Following these tasks, our model excels in focusing more precisely on the
desired information. Experimental results show substantial improvement in
Multi-doc QA and other benchmarks, superior to state-of-the-art models by 13.7%
absolute gain in shuffled settings, by 21.5% in passage retrieval task. We
release our model, Ziya-Reader to promote related research in the community. | [
0.0630754381,
-0.0008464198,
0.003911179,
0.0419855639,
-0.0195396226,
-0.014381052,
-0.0179984588,
-0.0205298532,
0.0049657268,
-0.0314050168,
-0.0284944139,
-0.0492277928,
-0.0057593556,
-0.0188012291,
0.0128339445,
-0.0428970084,
0.0461162329,
-0.0478343889,
0.0085318396,
0.0026153466,
0.0157024991,
-0.0223302059,
0.0144052589,
-0.0022749384,
0.041032549,
-0.0443425328,
-0.0157066826,
0.0009435185,
-0.0011819152,
-0.0155645898,
0.0358445458,
0.0283728559,
0.001402757,
0.023120923,
0.0000020153,
-0.0133146858,
0.0028393534,
-0.0314020216,
-0.0201870892,
0.0413089395,
0.0213947836,
0.0204167161,
0.0192438103,
0.024170829,
-0.0079312045,
0.0294581298,
0.0020688584,
0.0436612889,
0.0521094091,
0.0548823513,
0.0262279529,
-0.0057390332,
0.0437267944,
-0.0316611156,
0.0555204637,
-0.0697052181,
0.0181651153,
0.006209346,
0.045920562,
0.0503249317,
-0.0211023167,
0.0640951693,
0.0333983637,
-0.0015635529,
0.0038475429,
0.032473214,
-0.0097832857,
0.0327610895,
0.0096654743,
0.0708680823,
-0.0200346559,
-0.0066151586,
-0.0344422907,
0.0050292904,
0.0111768162,
-0.0019306659,
-0.0835083127,
0.0311430171,
-0.0255684052,
-0.025403481,
0.0230004601,
0.0002333784,
0.0187331457,
0.0080801267,
-0.0421078838,
0.0611219965,
0.0278268605,
-0.0413966402,
-0.0122039914,
-0.0249721147,
-0.0238404758,
-0.0012408415,
0.0280588884,
0.0800412297,
-0.0107518975,
0.0192545578,
-0.005655868,
-0.0512010306,
0.0325903222,
-0.0392911173,
0.0169726964,
0.0526179411,
-0.0237543024,
0.0590244979,
-0.0235837568,
0.0254010502,
-0.0233697593,
0.0136984214,
-0.0803026184,
-0.0233391449,
0.0114748338,
-0.0395692065,
-0.0654874742,
0.0247285757,
-0.0464401804,
-0.0270562638,
-0.0141781857,
0.0399203002,
0.0388810411,
-0.046191249,
-0.0004244964,
0.0213794503,
-0.0129146511,
-0.012831456,
-0.0287944619,
0.054372564,
-0.0507028252,
0.0169374142,
0.0106262909,
-0.0220487677,
-0.021631876,
0.0075733461,
-0.014795268,
-0.0530322492,
0.008144347,
0.0283925571,
-0.0078837657,
-0.0606231987,
-0.0256157201,
0.0088297036,
-0.021166563,
-0.0561994463,
-0.0019206131,
-0.0297937635,
0.0299651604,
0.0146871191,
0.0022562528,
-0.0045471936,
0.017534472,
0.0516922288,
-0.0228706673,
0.0527308434,
0.0346637554,
0.0364364088,
0.0326701887,
0.0294669326,
0.0229432806,
0.0632256344,
0.021884935,
-0.0051066331,
0.0266884193,
-0.0004049036,
0.0076482487,
0.0316298306,
0.0209801048,
-0.0057558254,
0.0331381932,
0.050049156,
0.0065850602,
0.031376645,
0.0440521538,
0.0260339845,
-0.0351026691,
-0.0336905979,
0.0458951965,
0.039090734,
0.0190974735,
0.0037270985,
-0.0078134304,
0.0052454988,
0.0116894236,
0.0108362148,
-0.0445930697,
0.059170004,
-0.0095116384,
0.0470101759,
0.0459598228,
0.0165984016,
-0.0431779511,
-0.0298582893,
-0.0120468903,
0.0184450094,
0.0022461354,
0.0449379608,
0.0436367393,
0.0030938836,
-0.0361405648,
0.0809046924,
0.0262208246,
-0.038216047,
-0.0034922878,
-0.0316398777,
0.0334226191,
0.0715236142,
0.053895697,
-0.0674773753,
-0.0288728327,
0.0169710834,
0.0461958684,
0.0342279486,
0.0267620739,
0.0102786506,
-0.0210991595,
-0.0379664563,
0.0031125695,
-0.0413744561,
0.0125879087,
0.0259195492,
0.0427390002,
0.0182372183,
0.0225494653,
-0.0425560176,
-0.0093208887,
0.0220734403,
-0.0285170954,
-0.0334691927,
-0.0358567499,
0.0146253305,
-0.0190112218,
0.0141791645,
0.0127991969,
0.0559680089,
0.0394138917,
-0.05326901,
0.0118721966,
-0.0191375352,
-0.0454783291,
-0.030808894,
0.0452400446,
0.0079233516,
-0.0188419651,
0.0432371497,
0.006083617,
-0.0299535766,
0.0030294999,
-0.0595826395,
0.0199707448,
-0.0097620143,
0.0241322126,
0.0490508638,
0.0161929,
-0.0711305439,
0.0610180274,
-0.0214027651,
0.0558492728,
0.0384265445,
0.0233024247,
0.0118590416,
-0.0463106185,
0.0061859549,
-0.005350396,
-0.0038722865,
0.0054790275,
0.0033295783,
-0.0204570275,
-0.0459728092,
-0.0503738336,
-0.0393569283,
0.0145051591,
-0.0232635345,
0.0286906511,
0.0112709804,
0.0335819647,
-0.0216959044,
-0.025130963,
-0.0424351841,
0.0052042739,
0.0102051822,
0.028917972,
0.0014034277,
0.0233996417,
-0.0113831917,
-0.0534082428,
-0.026497256,
-0.0121368179,
0.0343571007,
-0.0065578241,
-0.0127908727,
-0.0611018986,
0.0060482407,
-0.0128099816,
0.0025510814,
-0.0361015275,
-0.0173410028,
-0.0139370868,
-0.0137821566,
0.0567487814,
0.1075451002,
0.0163136758,
-0.0259312913,
0.0531225577,
-0.0161308087,
-0.0299009103,
0.0519411825,
-0.0075514405,
-0.0221208073,
0.0173964538,
-0.0234554503,
0.0098046334,
0.0559946932,
-0.0103148352,
0.0030456716,
-0.0167007484,
-0.0168269984,
0.0048038047,
0.0029818772,
-0.0394378342,
-0.0092809899,
-0.0473736562,
0.019428717,
-0.0604709387,
0.0156748127,
0.0585977435,
-0.0246348344,
-0.0030647316,
-0.077075094,
0.0316488929,
-0.061300505,
0.0467255376,
-0.0093539255,
0.0102158422,
-0.0163442697,
-0.0391285419,
-0.0450399257,
-0.0114668068,
-0.0001667371,
-0.0373504423,
0.0675023869,
0.0002931801,
0.0279262196,
-0.0279178023,
-0.0399987288,
-0.0485619977,
-0.0306289904,
-0.0216110442,
0.0108389594,
0.0069061681,
0.0127965538,
-0.0372604951,
0.029546449,
0.0511628054,
0.0490749292,
-0.0357311107,
0.0121139558,
-0.029633889,
0.0558276922,
0.0651162192,
0.0122002447,
0.0245828778,
-0.0480694063,
0.0181132667,
0.0529499762,
0.0583508238,
-0.028313268,
0.0292732231,
-0.0523459725,
0.0265839547,
-0.0619512945,
0.0071266303,
-0.0221615322,
0.0470891222,
-0.0989152417,
-0.0358549096,
0.0901660547,
0.0448090211,
-0.0486846268,
-0.0075502717,
-0.0863402635,
0.0371842757,
0.0285923034,
0.0505160168,
-0.0654466152,
-0.0417654961,
-0.0119724255,
0.0318505354,
0.0325032212,
-0.0005356162,
0.020418467,
-0.1078626439,
-0.0034790137,
-0.0018641696,
-0.0491613597,
-0.0629270673,
-0.0265079811,
0.0017640513,
0.035307359,
0.032472983,
0.0668136254,
-0.0197189003,
-0.0028143192,
-0.0061992649,
0.0270440783,
0.0089896163,
0.0417181402,
-0.0316369385,
0.0001995166,
0.0447458662,
0.0070444909,
0.0012692853,
-0.0200265739,
0.0200463142,
-0.0564378984,
0.0123773376,
0.0360558666,
0.0521138348,
-0.044476632,
0.0034161143,
-0.0382930897,
0.0071733478,
-0.0265586432,
-0.0094601894,
0.0317121744,
0.055220075,
0.0107834358,
0.0166756734,
-0.0348939262,
-0.0011447825,
-0.0121202823,
0.0786726177,
0.0539713353,
-0.0370332897,
-0.0573362261,
-0.0344789177,
-0.015333686,
-0.0610276274,
-0.0095216539,
0.0196954813,
0.0098693799,
0.0222552009,
-0.0634877086,
-0.0716694817,
0.0327764191,
0.0174123142,
-0.0115108229,
0.0509952344,
-0.0092551857,
-0.0283513721,
-0.0400671512,
0.0556202829,
-0.0588687584,
0.0272613596,
-0.0484303087,
0.0110670952,
0.0109661417,
-0.0437950343,
0.0110428026,
0.0228315052,
-0.0958074853,
-0.0444831587,
-0.0086181043,
0.0286686756,
0.0198993497,
0.0206273254,
-0.0461660735,
-0.0489375517,
0.009352766,
-0.0502146035,
-0.0755069628,
0.0402744114,
-0.008425368,
-0.0039984132,
0.0002369051,
0.0458445996,
-0.0556198023,
-0.0360254943,
0.0059898947,
0.0619820319,
-0.0131929088,
-0.0589870177,
0.0175936352,
-0.003876243,
-0.0116354683,
0.0460225083,
0.0168562215,
-0.0244242884,
0.0484743677,
-0.0132065658,
-0.0195200015,
0.0224031545,
0.0180693902,
0.0328762345,
-0.077082403,
-0.003233202,
0.0250650775,
0.0031472503,
0.0138939861,
-0.0560899451,
0.0182477683,
-0.0086935079,
-0.0168204773,
0.0083064986,
-0.0201224219,
-0.019688718,
-0.0063957023,
-0.0254460014,
0.0670826957,
0.0123316282,
0.0477897562,
0.0111195967,
-0.0504173115,
-0.051908683,
0.023780372,
-0.0959467217,
-0.0508699939,
0.0019111835,
0.0209902357,
0.0390928015,
0.0013973787,
0.0298778936,
0.0053072721,
-0.0332287066,
-0.0206273403,
-0.0297417715,
0.0094824955,
-0.0150845423,
0.0394983925,
0.0326003321,
0.0221419465,
0.0078309141,
0.0775550827,
0.0102710519,
0.0437171049,
0.0192469116,
-0.0059486791,
-0.0277307946,
-0.0213508811,
-0.0218422767,
0.0592539497,
-0.0466030203,
0.0192667395,
-0.0538580082,
-0.0500602461,
0.0245738644,
-0.0034827241,
-0.0434424914,
-0.0391750671,
0.0193961877,
0.0672966391,
0.0196463559,
-0.0514919162,
-0.0283962805,
0.0472790599,
-0.0394428559,
-0.0235716179,
0.0016988228,
-6.257130715e-33,
-0.0377188325,
-0.0183043294,
0.0282535665,
-0.0383086167,
-0.0499127917,
0.0038995356,
-0.0467268415,
0.0066062585,
-0.0576826744,
-0.0142364157,
-0.0324995369,
0.032958962,
0.0005250023,
-0.0017903163,
0.0001382832,
-0.0162864272,
0.0079790847,
0.0010957367,
-0.0312353186,
0.0126839522,
0.0247065779,
0.0321616754,
0.0241596028,
0.0233533643,
-0.0129575236,
-0.0250930022,
0.031811282,
0.0219398793,
-0.0350774825,
0.0852904618,
-0.0176526755,
0.0366626866,
0.0356500559,
-0.0425323732,
-0.0187555607,
0.0610246956,
-0.0924148783,
-0.0065425127,
0.0232274421,
0.0079110907,
-0.0522989407,
-0.0551881157,
0.0354667008,
0.0073920386,
0.05562675,
-0.0254155379,
0.0233819466,
-0.044730261,
-0.0440054573,
0.025403183,
-0.0336826704,
0.0103455335,
-0.0028279817,
-0.0472749658,
-0.0299260579,
0.0390914343,
0.0111655043,
0.0541461334,
-0.0418229662,
-0.0189767033,
0.0284897294,
0.0588009283,
0.0145625882,
0.0221827514,
-0.0099836923,
0.0257512443,
-0.0124980798,
-0.0095853684,
-0.0288408492,
-0.0399383456,
0.0104955714,
-0.0084693618,
0.0431356542,
0.0334623307,
0.0175246,
0.0020053643,
-0.0777518079,
0.0151813738,
0.0073573054,
0.0767596513,
0.0379904285,
0.0078601073,
-0.0453369468,
-0.0023956995,
-0.0477535389,
0.0360755846,
-0.0632298142,
-0.0033774571,
0.0628347695,
0.0266928244,
-0.0140635669,
-0.0440202057,
0.0369691178,
-0.0345350392,
0.0175822154,
0.0532027185,
-0.0131211458,
0.0417956412,
-0.0150363334,
0.0501350574,
-0.0620892271,
0.0396571532,
-0.0018812622,
-0.0160753764,
-0.0588892885,
0.0300485063,
0.0161992032,
-0.0184704065,
-0.064275682,
-0.0115767624,
-0.0380063839,
-0.002813379,
-0.0017725201,
0.0335482247,
0.037575841,
0.0162369888,
-0.0006322552,
0.0952662528,
0.0101033924,
-0.0028715958,
-0.0406590179,
-0.0561043844,
0.001613726,
0.0079599163,
-0.0157061145,
0.0338748619,
-0.0335897766,
0.0541824885,
-0.0358641595,
-0.057524085,
-0.009037748,
0.0418945849,
2.655e-7,
0.0775836632,
0.0238793548,
0.032805182,
0.0454923511,
0.0039926828,
-0.0102390042,
-0.008018503,
0.0215120334,
0.0280747097,
-0.0298758373,
-0.0221982338,
0.043626152,
0.0184636712,
-0.0276678801,
-0.0830373541,
-0.0168999899,
-0.0276742559,
-0.0011600686,
-0.0432931408,
-0.068250753,
0.0186969507,
0.1015517861,
-0.0313202143,
0.0105902003,
-0.0109396828,
-0.0698892623,
0.0711081624,
0.0091036502,
-0.0448388159,
0.0284978934,
0.0495215245,
0.0112647107,
0.0189283472,
-0.0074389288,
0.0032875438,
0.0424609594,
0.0242246669,
0.0538070686,
-0.0031503942,
-0.0660977289,
-0.0028601324,
-0.0279818997,
0.0050760685,
-0.0722604543,
0.0697148368,
-0.0255333893,
-0.0004305923,
-0.0043398477,
-0.0316736437,
0.0004615532,
0.0090142731,
-0.013268441,
-0.0148918256,
0.003013389,
-0.0038571947,
-0.0296777114,
0.0120965019,
-0.0931468382,
-0.0517803095,
-0.0011686702,
-0.0232832711,
-0.0166107528,
-0.0502963476,
-0.0473144948,
0.0290734936,
-0.0734581575,
-0.0085355276,
2.338067218e-34,
0.0504746512,
-0.0390776955,
0.0157036539,
0.071538493,
0.0260132309,
-0.0115465382,
-0.0151109817,
-0.0078026014,
0.0355670266,
-0.1006197259,
-0.0278816558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09194v1 | Structural Priming Demonstrates Abstract Grammatical Representations in Multilingual Language Models | 2023-11-15T18:39:56 | 2023-11-15T18:39:56 | James A. Michaelov, Catherine Arnett, Tyler A. Chang, Benjamin K. Bergen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Abstract grammatical knowledge - of parts of speech and grammatical patterns
- is key to the capacity for linguistic generalization in humans. But how
abstract is grammatical knowledge in large language models? In the human
literature, compelling evidence for grammatical abstraction comes from
structural priming. A sentence that shares the same grammatical structure as a
preceding sentence is processed and produced more readily. Because confounds
exist when using stimuli in a single language, evidence of abstraction is even
more compelling from crosslingual structural priming, where use of a syntactic
structure in one language primes an analogous structure in another language. We
measure crosslingual structural priming in large language models, comparing
model behavior to human experimental results from eight crosslingual
experiments covering six languages, and four monolingual structural priming
experiments in three non-English languages. We find evidence for abstract
monolingual and crosslingual grammatical representations in the models that
function similarly to those found in humans. These results demonstrate that
grammatical representations in multilingual language models are not only
similar across languages, but they can causally influence text produced in
different languages. | [
0.0049533369,
0.0423841663,
-0.0475687198,
0.0137044722,
-0.0406011119,
0.0173344724,
-0.0074346061,
0.0120665971,
-0.0477005802,
-0.0431946516,
-0.0442698859,
-0.0489767864,
0.0147706168,
0.018617196,
0.0897553489,
-0.0522945859,
0.0398537666,
-0.0319475606,
-0.0007356228,
-0.0248720348,
0.012483051,
0.0028024719,
0.0281683095,
-0.0024133588,
0.0025495975,
-0.0076802652,
-0.0120796962,
-0.0464078411,
-0.0105701098,
-0.0127588911,
-0.0069118007,
0.0421527661,
0.0107913958,
-0.052958183,
0.0000017903,
-0.0313068293,
0.0391730107,
-0.0313885696,
0.0274932031,
0.033787135,
-0.0011016887,
-0.0468294881,
0.0075084809,
-0.0513067693,
-0.0499802381,
-0.0264285076,
0.0232418627,
0.0579562485,
-0.0329327919,
0.0112105794,
-0.0149356071,
-0.0424431786,
0.043676082,
0.0012957093,
-0.0107698627,
0.0103923501,
0.0169449616,
-0.0070672059,
-0.0316408351,
0.0087494655,
-0.032099776,
0.0094080623,
0.0345626548,
0.0491442606,
-0.0179461502,
0.0557478927,
-0.0136079192,
-0.021730341,
0.0156760719,
-0.0015502258,
0.0011584791,
-0.0900560096,
0.0113617517,
0.0113214962,
0.0070308186,
-0.0014141562,
-0.0104357274,
0.0543688387,
0.0162306558,
0.0369166955,
0.1084054708,
-0.0350102261,
-0.0001387079,
0.0019834719,
0.0016232334,
0.0868530497,
0.0131263472,
-0.0531959049,
0.0033380082,
0.0265881252,
-0.0109654535,
-0.0896137133,
-0.0122677488,
-0.0370745659,
-0.0206884649,
0.0271290932,
-0.0301651713,
-0.0472048521,
-0.0091380654,
-0.024748126,
0.02961611,
0.0144551294,
-0.0115963854,
-0.0045922557,
-0.0459719859,
0.0686263889,
-0.0579007678,
0.0433203205,
-0.0513855368,
0.0290977955,
-0.0093380343,
-0.0474984944,
-0.0126521932,
0.0301997941,
-0.0066200951,
0.0118894698,
-0.0412735566,
0.0041305702,
-0.0018126164,
-0.0493268333,
-0.0754323527,
-0.0137406997,
-0.0397997089,
-0.0051542381,
-0.002730397,
-0.0163996052,
-0.055160597,
0.0568537563,
-0.0249180403,
-0.0582876652,
0.0008418061,
-0.0122557292,
0.000074519,
0.0171579383,
-0.0109695327,
-0.0075052208,
-0.0525099859,
-0.0148089975,
0.0078771878,
-0.0385258868,
0.022895081,
-0.0236949753,
0.0187572706,
-0.0424293354,
0.0165985283,
0.0417511724,
0.0024653748,
0.0038450386,
-0.0020203986,
-0.0043984861,
-0.0091323163,
0.0113164494,
0.0641159788,
0.0428079925,
-0.0120517686,
0.0032602749,
0.0239300877,
0.0186306518,
-0.0387240015,
-0.020264769,
-0.0020447224,
-0.0113327308,
-0.0191503558,
0.0329986848,
0.0030216319,
-0.0138185648,
0.0013264766,
-0.0057217563,
0.0014865495,
-0.0206218231,
0.0335468836,
0.0065844245,
-0.0406407043,
0.0160678029,
0.0344460607,
0.0665071085,
-0.0623627938,
0.0384194404,
0.0505013354,
-0.0131407883,
0.0053916099,
0.0615458451,
-0.0231464226,
0.0034432192,
0.0007019032,
0.0159050543,
-0.0147442985,
0.005789083,
-0.0302238874,
0.0220111366,
0.017135838,
-0.0023672997,
0.0091137942,
-0.0092529729,
0.0074664601,
0.0655234158,
-0.0170675889,
0.0609254278,
0.0437392034,
-0.0134730656,
-0.0016780413,
0.0255247783,
0.0224646032,
-0.0340222642,
-0.0377741233,
0.0229669549,
0.031103868,
-0.0175454039,
0.0155384904,
0.0556084923,
0.0614013411,
0.0021062021,
0.016926514,
-0.0008758839,
0.0357860252,
-0.027991334,
0.0039773765,
0.0405954719,
-0.026170047,
0.0113965394,
-0.0210624784,
-0.0276830047,
0.0083375201,
0.0323784687,
-0.0806276277,
-0.0331747495,
-0.0560773015,
0.0025959152,
0.0189107731,
-0.0251185689,
-0.0239310563,
0.0455893613,
0.0002384253,
-0.0488613918,
0.0079914695,
0.0631413013,
-0.0802633092,
-0.0077241608,
-0.017493071,
-0.0601916909,
-0.0340917856,
0.0101341186,
0.024616966,
-0.0344681367,
0.0562945344,
-0.0213223211,
0.0814734772,
-0.0184334181,
0.0216485001,
-0.0324972868,
0.0221683569,
-0.0004728515,
0.0498379506,
0.0151067302,
0.0261265114,
0.0075010946,
-0.0225501154,
0.0226759166,
-0.0114129614,
-0.0003407005,
-0.0014499436,
-0.0170454178,
-0.0340841599,
0.0490329899,
-0.0171752702,
-0.0558556989,
0.0216508713,
-0.065193899,
-0.0372853689,
0.0040326319,
0.0349083543,
0.0487505049,
-0.0123976255,
-0.0221026633,
0.021518508,
-0.0417436175,
-0.0285837464,
0.0167700462,
0.0621606596,
-0.0000717302,
-0.0126979472,
-0.0043881703,
-0.0155936321,
-0.0025524057,
-0.0115617886,
0.0261178017,
-0.0123315398,
-0.0278633814,
-0.0550298467,
0.043298237,
-0.0008795332,
0.0032616465,
-0.0046298411,
-0.0454287492,
0.0060695619,
0.0271247216,
0.0809282884,
0.0571794882,
-0.0564108826,
-0.040949069,
0.042461019,
0.0225740392,
-0.0348985903,
-0.0448522903,
-0.0306430701,
0.009224751,
-0.0441893488,
-0.0752994716,
0.0256723464,
0.1267057955,
0.0365520939,
-0.0081959106,
-0.0364171304,
0.0189520828,
-0.061949864,
-0.0547177754,
-0.0138458228,
-0.0748653337,
-0.050200779,
0.0630564764,
-0.0600981191,
-0.0502057523,
0.0557914265,
0.0324990973,
-0.0368311442,
-0.0554249175,
0.0117944824,
0.0220897384,
0.0437875837,
0.035245724,
0.0378095172,
0.0300571751,
-0.0205382705,
-0.0730692074,
0.0063924659,
0.0333329588,
0.0426173769,
0.0219514035,
-0.0108156735,
-0.0260998551,
0.0193594787,
-0.0814323053,
-0.0143964337,
-0.0584656969,
-0.0263107494,
0.0019205896,
0.0338099189,
0.0116593419,
0.0406190343,
-0.0156605821,
0.0288107563,
0.0125361281,
-0.0032243312,
0.0011909208,
-0.0239571854,
0.0068532359,
0.0046032383,
-0.056688983,
0.0124064209,
-0.063930653,
0.0088903736,
0.0069854679,
0.0216810461,
0.0415697061,
-0.0189016778,
0.0442543626,
0.0419742055,
-0.0061138221,
-0.0837537646,
0.0131983394,
0.0428771004,
-0.0110292109,
-0.0181579795,
0.0315668583,
0.0217793956,
-0.023897469,
0.0605802238,
-0.0465055183,
0.0343144834,
0.0283544268,
0.0155076366,
-0.0427068695,
0.028021954,
0.0453883149,
-0.0970999897,
-0.0392278284,
-0.0280038174,
0.0168717597,
-0.0987116694,
-0.0204754472,
0.0098870602,
-0.0533804931,
-0.0172727592,
0.0123195164,
0.0130220884,
0.0787025467,
-0.0219895076,
0.0189328268,
-0.0310789905,
0.0033945669,
0.022030836,
0.0048345029,
-0.0545712002,
-0.0052448954,
-0.0159068909,
-0.0044862856,
0.0117535666,
0.0230356921,
-0.0209167227,
-0.0551054329,
0.1114621609,
-0.0117067108,
0.0352359638,
0.0237242598,
-0.0255427249,
0.0594810396,
0.0125593022,
-0.0586895831,
0.0405288823,
0.0075878948,
-0.050809294,
-0.0334751941,
0.0721125603,
0.0033595734,
-0.0370263793,
0.0089942673,
-0.012820947,
-0.04258582,
0.0171777308,
0.0664867461,
-0.0254608784,
-0.0226322897,
-0.007363989,
0.021531878,
-0.0194475781,
-0.0149520952,
0.036858879,
-0.0327181593,
0.0143299252,
-0.0670351088,
-0.0457370989,
-0.0243381448,
-0.0500899293,
0.0325586535,
0.0098513048,
-0.0039924067,
-0.1021755487,
0.0118089356,
0.0360900387,
0.0071368557,
0.0190867875,
-0.0140647413,
-0.0240120739,
0.0110842614,
-0.0546275154,
-0.021397382,
-0.0566272214,
0.0125851771,
-0.0757554322,
0.034915328,
0.0178713184,
0.0089964494,
0.0193149485,
0.0394635499,
-0.0495841727,
0.0450033173,
-0.048234798,
-0.0116823586,
0.0575063899,
-0.0012686346,
-0.0186750349,
0.0295819063,
0.0516588055,
0.0017522709,
0.0350904129,
0.0523825027,
-0.0284695532,
-0.0056639723,
0.039594017,
0.0481003746,
0.041977264,
0.033704333,
-0.0240218434,
0.0437760651,
-0.0659430847,
-0.0166654903,
-0.0256445166,
-0.0102247661,
0.0032880108,
-0.0141593795,
0.0565133989,
0.05543283,
0.0069951415,
0.0251747426,
0.0121974694,
0.0324588753,
0.0198752098,
0.0038464742,
0.034049537,
0.0235613436,
0.0396541692,
0.0608231723,
0.0213233177,
0.042895481,
-0.0599946193,
0.0426545739,
-0.0377308168,
0.0161426924,
0.0383677483,
0.0054500829,
-0.0313206352,
-0.022862142,
-0.016178729,
-0.0085707009,
0.0679963678,
-0.0700412095,
0.0405375659,
-0.0843677893,
0.0630343333,
-0.0653203428,
0.0003868286,
0.0073500057,
0.013918303,
-0.0107010938,
-0.0198706817,
0.0442780554,
-0.0101460563,
-0.025312813,
-0.0127360485,
0.0647782981,
-0.0315202549,
0.0049403911,
-0.0002632657,
-0.0074016522,
0.0037086864,
0.0497424193,
0.0197196864,
-0.0051268213,
-0.0255355388,
0.0263910275,
-0.0434901081,
-0.0406455547,
-0.0462720133,
0.0110307597,
0.0132524772,
-0.0269844774,
0.0174736045,
0.0651098713,
0.0092800027,
-0.0281523559,
-0.020849321,
-0.0015824134,
0.0185214691,
0.0088625206,
-0.0262057763,
-5.881645126e-33,
0.000320325,
0.023995785,
-0.0342420675,
-0.0009584758,
-0.0222536251,
0.019379532,
-0.0352354757,
0.0507153571,
0.0227327012,
0.0697248951,
-0.0330263861,
-0.017462397,
0.0133609073,
-0.0322902836,
0.0495766997,
0.0180399045,
0.0203309692,
-0.0176970605,
-0.021597987,
-0.0326685645,
0.0093504479,
0.0030957819,
0.0793202594,
-0.006160445,
0.0483616255,
-0.0437583365,
0.0066583361,
-0.0369269326,
-0.0467269458,
0.0184693336,
-0.0099430997,
0.0235367995,
0.0536551513,
0.0099470159,
-0.04498915,
0.0835212693,
-0.0210577827,
-0.0607284158,
0.1083561033,
0.0219089929,
-0.0437038131,
-0.0227075983,
0.0148292528,
-0.0445125587,
-0.0289488714,
0.038470421,
0.002593406,
0.0038806384,
0.0326192975,
-0.0180723313,
-0.0748635679,
-0.0324480571,
0.0056630522,
0.0304207616,
0.0433152206,
0.0544103123,
-0.0552481078,
-0.0521918945,
-0.0059850193,
0.0455951504,
-0.0165221673,
0.0275684129,
0.0467396975,
0.0244087074,
0.0309130605,
0.0340950452,
0.07170178,
0.0486869588,
0.0310903974,
0.0239474922,
0.0325368829,
0.0047477675,
-0.0227395352,
0.0359155759,
0.030442873,
-0.0211526882,
-0.0005934315,
-0.0458699651,
0.0153109487,
0.0142103834,
0.0243355166,
-0.0105728926,
0.0441401787,
-0.065737009,
-0.0678568855,
-0.0250347164,
0.0008582768,
-0.004997869,
0.0185716189,
-0.0234862734,
0.0294827465,
0.0131595926,
0.0360859148,
-0.0217263754,
-0.0444349535,
-0.0148841972,
-0.0345382541,
0.020305831,
0.0071775001,
0.0268731173,
-0.0808133557,
-0.036793422,
-0.0438198745,
-0.017549701,
0.0238263197,
0.0619271807,
0.0109718759,
-0.0130601982,
-0.0376696512,
0.009073494,
-0.0303178001,
-0.0224730913,
0.0324775092,
0.0172223225,
0.068440944,
0.0456207693,
-0.0192392226,
0.0054444671,
0.0541704297,
0.0150910746,
-0.0437859483,
0.0485541858,
-0.0355825238,
0.0757202953,
0.008254203,
0.0004622,
-0.075157851,
0.056998942,
0.1117962301,
-0.0262617394,
-0.0356373861,
0.0107961157,
2.571e-7,
0.007626594,
0.0270162504,
-0.0073416797,
0.0276182666,
0.0210444685,
0.0271987375,
-0.0189611204,
0.022095209,
0.0327960737,
-0.0203696899,
-0.0343238525,
-0.0155508043,
0.0145015735,
0.0047189151,
-0.0653395206,
0.0307202321,
-0.0497664176,
0.0186247509,
-0.0177229401,
-0.0129568111,
-0.0267510973,
0.0322478116,
-0.0160232112,
0.011718452,
-0.0235753395,
-0.0083241947,
0.0508250818,
-0.0387628339,
-0.0204561409,
0.0264993981,
-0.0488246232,
-0.0010064088,
0.0211340506,
0.0656059384,
-0.0216428097,
0.0134576745,
0.0113211842,
-0.0341146477,
0.0040600267,
0.0481870063,
0.0302957445,
-0.0156323723,
-0.0591122806,
-0.0552195311,
0.0196720604,
-0.0625657439,
-0.0261131134,
0.0181870982,
-0.0379337892,
0.0259495229,
0.0351834483,
0.0023408546,
-0.0191589929,
0.032388024,
0.0293241441,
0.0257977806,
-0.0271454751,
-0.0044147242,
-0.0493033715,
0.0470562391,
-0.0101162223,
-0.0127742905,
-0.010580739,
-0.0155633548,
0.0065030479,
-0.0606709011,
-0.0248978138,
2.090772594e-34,
-0.0129337274,
-0.0008045903,
0.0613901056,
0.0116023412,
0.0207669418,
-0.0610626712,
0.0162078887,
0.0520810448,
0.029653471,
-0.0388516523,
-0.0040692841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09193v1 | The Role of Chain-of-Thought in Complex Vision-Language Reasoning Task | 2023-11-15T18:39:21 | 2023-11-15T18:39:21 | Yifan Wu, Pengchuan Zhang, Wenhan Xiong, Barlas Oguz, James C. Gee, Yixin Nie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | The study explores the effectiveness of the Chain-of-Thought approach, known
for its proficiency in language tasks by breaking them down into sub-tasks and
intermediate steps, in improving vision-language tasks that demand
sophisticated perception and reasoning. We present the "Description then
Decision" strategy, which is inspired by how humans process signals. This
strategy significantly improves probing task performance by 50%, establishing
the groundwork for future research on reasoning paradigms in complex
vision-language tasks. | [
0.0309542194,
0.0182688273,
-0.0262247045,
0.0278567038,
-0.0677149892,
0.0369843878,
-0.0084212413,
0.0152589353,
0.0076229675,
-0.0546338037,
0.0197223704,
-0.0435984358,
0.058537133,
0.03879603,
0.0152937025,
-0.1003326699,
0.0087127378,
-0.0596236922,
0.0098178461,
0.02008228,
-0.011697107,
-0.0066741384,
-0.043368075,
-0.0078865858,
-0.02958153,
-0.0361671075,
-0.0329398774,
-0.0131879337,
0.0435231179,
-0.05192478,
-0.0869255662,
0.011835197,
0.0440047197,
0.0024211931,
0.0000019373,
-0.0607608706,
0.0168204084,
0.0197568443,
0.0012283605,
-0.0153278038,
-0.0054878928,
-0.0244541448,
0.04237305,
0.0229009856,
-0.0235869419,
-0.0054467912,
0.0641993806,
0.0618507788,
-0.014192801,
0.0155222258,
-0.0084115891,
-0.0271813124,
-0.0165737066,
0.012830724,
0.0234745294,
-0.021622017,
0.0026499701,
0.0060455343,
0.0544326231,
0.004284835,
-0.0420864001,
0.0190585889,
0.0153172519,
-0.0214080345,
-0.0035522652,
0.0403202623,
0.0255899969,
-0.0482801348,
-0.0143871726,
0.0222575646,
-0.0147109367,
0.0077447183,
-0.0061673219,
-0.0150723848,
-0.0093722753,
0.0159260947,
-0.0265879836,
0.06618426,
-0.0422648042,
0.0017076755,
-0.0185805783,
0.0015295605,
-0.0080245603,
0.0045164069,
-0.0620111562,
0.050984174,
-0.0322662964,
0.0193125643,
0.0396360829,
0.0216730293,
-0.0031327871,
-0.0656109527,
-0.0190552827,
0.0481342636,
-0.0313860476,
-0.0108597251,
0.0268417764,
-0.0064181569,
-0.0431380942,
-0.0008116105,
0.0394197404,
0.0707624853,
-0.0360912234,
0.0284394044,
-0.0388324298,
0.0612029023,
-0.0348649994,
0.0162217934,
-0.0522244982,
-0.005874454,
-0.0611749701,
-0.0249422509,
-0.0168945137,
0.0407705456,
-0.0211183261,
-0.036278218,
-0.0130766742,
-0.0017795613,
0.000571292,
-0.0252593365,
-0.0437506363,
0.0227272399,
0.0228185989,
-0.0277233943,
-0.0766049325,
0.017945908,
-0.0270071737,
0.0412663855,
0.0059630778,
0.0054777879,
0.0077071334,
0.0399244241,
0.0101166237,
-0.0051968344,
-0.0236148853,
0.0311792847,
-0.0490257293,
-0.0060220188,
-0.023116352,
-0.0481427871,
-0.0077474709,
-0.0646411479,
0.0458141044,
-0.0492317379,
-0.0161627848,
0.0338920429,
-0.0082966257,
0.0286587719,
0.0037015169,
0.0068950676,
-0.0205738191,
0.1007584855,
-0.0386212692,
-0.0045500081,
-0.0199195351,
0.0412487425,
-0.0274935476,
0.0627206415,
0.0105476128,
0.0444886945,
-0.0340969115,
0.0332128219,
0.0442342162,
-0.0013421348,
-0.0470991358,
-0.0363319516,
-0.0436180942,
-0.0144583173,
-0.0388424471,
0.0346167795,
0.0160450041,
0.0331115611,
-0.0280005205,
0.0466326624,
0.043146316,
0.0816771835,
0.0180704836,
-0.0272052791,
0.0541959889,
-0.018493481,
0.0025507277,
0.0372490771,
-0.0248537716,
0.0826658607,
0.0057595591,
0.0012061941,
-0.0985033736,
-0.0106739607,
-0.0034432663,
-0.0483388118,
-0.0559971742,
0.0344830416,
0.0270487443,
0.0498060398,
0.0241254587,
0.0018239787,
0.0025282751,
-0.0070687137,
0.0001349322,
0.0012245351,
-0.0069811447,
-0.0448147729,
-0.0243138913,
0.0515488684,
-0.0217047613,
0.0024198228,
0.0150050242,
0.0015347088,
0.032786645,
0.0254209638,
0.0081615075,
0.0216862056,
-0.0185951199,
-0.0368369594,
-0.0554689132,
-0.0110538518,
0.0081521757,
-0.0087965839,
-0.0438621603,
-0.0042818934,
-0.0212142505,
0.0018249287,
0.0169267841,
0.0075274012,
0.0696053952,
0.038533248,
-0.0357952416,
0.0564612485,
-0.0166718569,
-0.0252764728,
0.0157353766,
0.0338475704,
-0.0262810327,
-0.0145623637,
-0.0006256042,
0.0349283926,
-0.0177463684,
-0.0008867786,
0.0115815066,
-0.089100711,
-0.0426153466,
-0.0106457742,
0.0014961337,
-0.0209263694,
0.0281664748,
-0.06485001,
-0.0264343917,
-0.0168222561,
0.0108033223,
-0.002057285,
-0.0232953969,
-0.002176286,
0.089615114,
-0.0130728092,
-0.0224083103,
0.0218673851,
-0.0128279999,
0.0369138829,
-0.0131126745,
0.0312059298,
0.0260706358,
0.0012941939,
-0.0321660824,
-0.0011287763,
0.012829449,
-0.0472819954,
0.0073812841,
-0.0335362777,
-0.0583051816,
0.0034928999,
-0.0174664073,
-0.009417397,
-0.0283550378,
0.0177189019,
-0.0016964702,
-0.000170172,
0.0853270069,
-0.0026487003,
0.0077442736,
0.0365888849,
-0.0092023509,
-0.046873685,
0.0421429351,
0.0095957359,
-0.0257057734,
0.0762699544,
0.0517238788,
-0.0956893116,
-0.0267316196,
0.0323646516,
-0.0323367305,
0.0093316454,
-0.010051989,
-0.0289655868,
0.0532226823,
-0.0094133439,
0.0394043624,
0.0619117618,
-0.0141672259,
0.0173281673,
0.0785004497,
-0.013505538,
0.0170637164,
-0.0018064238,
0.0059767151,
0.0152104897,
0.013117291,
-0.0193009917,
-0.0431074239,
0.0253794603,
-0.0153957801,
-0.0070428462,
-0.0642754883,
0.012075359,
-0.0111214388,
-0.053960342,
-0.0732129738,
-0.0563059822,
0.0041448474,
0.1138701588,
-0.0217118524,
-0.0264530312,
0.0585168824,
0.0090017803,
0.0297525804,
-0.0044038887,
0.0287952181,
-0.006915445,
0.1286526322,
0.0024563544,
0.0143416654,
0.019044606,
-0.0128059844,
-0.0821696818,
-0.0439783372,
0.0423012152,
0.0299118888,
0.039082028,
-0.0887944102,
0.0354207866,
-0.0292350277,
-0.0302082114,
-0.0457048342,
0.0730176121,
-0.0627255887,
0.0334088951,
-0.0318642035,
-0.0019592249,
-0.049362991,
0.0321054496,
0.0713789612,
0.0113149704,
0.0202547442,
-0.0284326207,
-0.0083473809,
0.0115987621,
0.0253938679,
0.0270960908,
0.038687896,
-0.0109639242,
0.0322332978,
0.0651307926,
0.0384898484,
0.0334998593,
-0.0393714905,
0.0448924974,
0.0197633598,
0.0361132734,
-0.0345834084,
0.0297189746,
0.0108081326,
-0.052439902,
-0.0255212802,
0.0501246192,
0.0240055546,
-0.0478268079,
0.0109992772,
-0.0221594647,
-0.0083065778,
0.0551595055,
0.0362990089,
-0.0848961771,
-0.0154228527,
0.0072752144,
-0.0537675992,
-0.0060321884,
-0.0438397415,
-0.0268712491,
-0.07006035,
0.0701378733,
-0.0255171377,
-0.0104275374,
-0.0478331335,
-0.004089077,
-0.0041373009,
0.0525684431,
-0.0689169466,
0.0201332122,
-0.002861863,
-0.0094163045,
0.0206253082,
0.0209254567,
0.0253593586,
0.020625243,
-0.0530806184,
-0.0505486093,
0.0199013893,
-0.0066270325,
0.0184299424,
-0.0584751964,
0.0247184224,
0.0017431664,
0.0521442816,
-0.0283360574,
0.0051183999,
0.0318115167,
-0.0401868112,
-0.007876073,
0.0092822732,
0.0023274138,
-0.066730164,
-0.0342124067,
0.0771726966,
-0.0556735098,
-0.0333372131,
-0.0221431684,
0.0281261671,
-0.0395389646,
0.0225311238,
0.0157703701,
-0.0117552597,
-0.0109253731,
0.018835824,
-0.0398925096,
-0.0281959604,
-0.0451537259,
0.0375818051,
0.061219044,
0.0019114088,
-0.0531891733,
-0.002120337,
0.0327961445,
0.0963852927,
-0.014062861,
0.0047144857,
0.0297249425,
0.0103888493,
-0.057513237,
0.0552273318,
0.005250738,
0.0373883955,
0.020093482,
0.026886398,
-0.0169014167,
-0.0454310477,
-0.0072055049,
0.0223466586,
-0.0527030565,
-0.0177404936,
-0.0113714868,
0.0341191106,
0.0293714069,
0.0189803932,
0.0111179678,
-0.0496761352,
-0.0155790932,
-0.0142349824,
0.027231276,
0.0313954949,
-0.0314332433,
-0.0180268213,
0.0104541816,
0.0224186536,
0.0001120756,
-0.0017103467,
0.0328584127,
-0.0000698401,
-0.0119920438,
0.0130164875,
0.0271490104,
-0.0174192023,
0.0241529625,
-0.0124355946,
0.0138830394,
-0.0374451056,
-0.0093033733,
-0.0155841336,
-0.0248649511,
-0.0597612336,
0.0037386534,
0.0054922076,
0.0415173657,
0.0169178117,
-0.0010644493,
0.0208989829,
-0.0347501747,
0.0345226973,
-0.0110487714,
0.0251655411,
-0.0322556086,
-0.0053944839,
0.0185638815,
0.0051914779,
0.0155319534,
-0.0442451872,
0.0338949934,
0.007159323,
0.0960998833,
0.0683587193,
-0.0437955484,
-0.0638621151,
-0.014440652,
-0.0359719805,
-0.066735968,
0.0586740449,
0.0289716665,
0.025467027,
-0.002019881,
-0.0136289569,
-0.0656091049,
-0.002843396,
0.039183259,
0.0501290374,
-0.0160730742,
-0.0121528255,
0.0463851988,
0.0400209278,
0.0077645113,
-0.0657255054,
0.0074742823,
-0.01696744,
-0.0243835803,
-0.005081086,
-0.027445998,
-0.0110255228,
-0.0151543925,
-0.0297713857,
0.0222242419,
-0.0041787517,
0.0497089513,
-0.0607690774,
-0.0602643006,
-0.0161758196,
0.0102880122,
0.0515513085,
0.0322335251,
0.0724244192,
0.0487630032,
0.0298218206,
-0.0628888085,
0.0299561229,
-0.0567133389,
0.0166400354,
0.008720668,
0.0056340075,
-6.108132031e-33,
0.0114093181,
-0.0620697327,
0.0764752626,
-0.0073627545,
-0.0138869751,
0.0089990608,
-0.005762036,
0.0193594191,
-0.0118086711,
0.050762862,
0.0222507641,
0.0112088379,
0.0057683289,
0.0171284098,
0.0219801795,
0.0188309066,
0.0076256827,
0.0185001511,
-0.0236508399,
-0.0694853514,
0.0290793125,
-0.034167707,
0.0285467114,
-0.0239844453,
-0.0270001721,
0.0612043552,
-0.0072581549,
0.0464143045,
-0.0392945707,
0.042802386,
-0.0100755636,
-0.0356889963,
0.0403722525,
0.0128061036,
-0.0164226219,
0.0263435394,
-0.039803151,
-0.0451575406,
0.0456442162,
0.0346280821,
-0.0851487368,
0.0205938201,
0.0053039491,
-0.0115524596,
0.0142086595,
-0.0637569949,
0.0426998027,
-0.0231917799,
0.0142089352,
0.029147232,
-0.049503427,
-0.0122978818,
-0.0098720556,
-0.0324514657,
0.0730217993,
0.0034517508,
-0.0305808391,
-0.0069493577,
-0.0313377939,
0.0166107118,
-0.0245012827,
-0.0088599175,
0.0664735883,
0.0505247228,
-0.0111094862,
0.0480066426,
0.0494021401,
-0.0169258825,
-0.0393774584,
-0.0268436093,
-0.0079737501,
0.0465806685,
0.0515578054,
0.0331503898,
0.0197972413,
0.0201387517,
-0.0778563544,
-0.0380608067,
-0.043424096,
0.0714561194,
-0.0119621977,
0.0242557302,
-0.0058399769,
-0.0318609253,
-0.0248077605,
0.0003643337,
-0.06893453,
0.0260278191,
0.0371575505,
0.0233233422,
-0.0153925801,
0.0331334472,
0.0445333309,
-0.008820314,
0.0240400974,
-0.0517402887,
-0.0135477064,
0.0542538799,
0.0284921825,
0.0202678069,
-0.0287636779,
0.0063269916,
0.0380113423,
0.057177972,
0.0024186748,
-0.000948874,
0.0358647965,
0.0116715571,
-0.0108226053,
-0.0171144959,
-0.0662596673,
0.0025831519,
0.0236867964,
-0.0100177014,
0.0494464114,
0.012418041,
-0.0362852477,
-0.0021014258,
-0.003627531,
-0.0693239123,
-0.00265844,
0.0494623147,
-0.0521988422,
0.0210694987,
-0.0011252114,
-0.0035503055,
-0.0389085859,
-0.049692139,
0.0357640833,
-0.0588797741,
-0.0379246324,
0.0719783828,
2.774e-7,
0.0010917471,
0.0432786718,
0.0005162868,
0.041343566,
0.0172824785,
0.0240533315,
0.0075614029,
-0.0266050585,
0.0145786647,
-0.0754086822,
-0.0149211762,
0.05267068,
0.0074569159,
-0.0077456767,
-0.0049983454,
-0.0155425426,
0.0375090986,
-0.0263425019,
-0.0343587995,
-0.0022843783,
0.078061372,
0.0002494659,
-0.0204206686,
-0.0187552162,
0.0257320441,
-0.0291304421,
0.0539375059,
0.0100141978,
0.0300471541,
-0.040981669,
-0.0140345395,
-0.0117255347,
0.0012580385,
0.0936485082,
0.0134263216,
-0.0241283439,
0.023597151,
-0.0446517281,
-0.0092111565,
0.0199459139,
-0.0198767614,
0.0248275213,
-0.0022336077,
-0.0610016249,
0.0800992697,
-0.0793596432,
-0.0349349082,
0.0189130399,
0.0224432237,
-0.0111056771,
-0.0066658412,
0.0287653022,
-0.0015145486,
0.0095605226,
0.010862302,
-0.0015762749,
-0.0434529223,
-0.0713015273,
0.0091808746,
0.0237038117,
-0.0092140306,
0.0166125875,
-0.0450801253,
-0.0187459923,
0.0572845154,
-0.0202522594,
-0.1018825173,
2.02985214e-34,
-0.0110292807,
-0.0100688832,
0.0239367839,
-0.0116654513,
0.0310557801,
-0.0329313986,
-0.0323873311,
0.0078331539,
0.0252365321,
-0.0510249548,
-0.020649353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09189v2 | PsyEval: A Suite of Mental Health Related Tasks for Evaluating Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T18:32:27 | 2024-06-03T08:37:10 | Haoan Jin, Siyuan Chen, Dilawaier Dilixiati, Yewei Jiang, Mengyue Wu, Kenny Q. Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) in the mental health domain poses
distinct challenged from other domains, given the subtle and highly subjective
nature of symptoms that exhibit significant variability among individuals. This
paper presents PsyEval, the first comprehensive suite of mental health-related
tasks for evaluating LLMs. PsyEval encompasses five sub-tasks that evaluate
three critical dimensions of mental health. This comprehensive framework is
designed to thoroughly assess the unique challenges and intricacies of mental
health-related tasks, making PsyEval a highly specialized and valuable tool for
evaluating LLM performance in this domain. We evaluate twelve advanced LLMs
using PsyEval. Experiment results not only demonstrate significant room for
improvement in current LLMs concerning mental health but also unveil potential
directions for future model optimization. | [
0.0079926038,
0.0553546473,
-0.0233285595,
0.0074068783,
-0.0104093747,
0.0328899398,
0.027788274,
0.0284236856,
0.0578196384,
-0.0117141837,
-0.0215789247,
-0.0526482128,
-0.0040727109,
-0.0009796994,
-0.0122777615,
-0.0618787073,
0.0252155997,
0.0119140316,
0.0462915972,
0.0149972923,
-0.0091516478,
0.003532344,
-0.0264557004,
0.0408014357,
0.0144453663,
-0.0354076363,
0.0442395136,
0.0014070807,
0.0381801426,
-0.0765474662,
-0.0342458077,
0.0670877695,
-0.0108454544,
0.0031624848,
0.0000019597,
-0.0672270209,
-0.019877689,
0.0044221431,
0.0216533858,
0.0119173788,
0.0630790144,
-0.0283126067,
0.0107208407,
0.0232391749,
-0.0131053766,
-0.03126093,
0.0332722999,
0.0605522916,
0.0499715246,
0.0261632763,
-0.0338482112,
0.0167927016,
-0.0044980519,
-0.0244707949,
-0.0259197578,
0.0094797714,
0.0532223098,
0.0095297676,
0.0208672769,
-0.0493410267,
-0.0138323056,
0.019945072,
-0.024695212,
0.0347702801,
-0.0501188077,
-0.0102785602,
-0.0023305921,
-0.0236436222,
0.0284489579,
0.0658185482,
-0.0062783696,
0.0391033441,
0.0218547713,
-0.0118936449,
-0.0105355261,
0.0018307948,
-0.0276737772,
-0.0067330743,
0.0145789906,
-0.0014118195,
0.0306925904,
0.0079555511,
0.0186980162,
-0.0180695392,
0.030100571,
0.0769595429,
0.0284690745,
-0.0410395674,
0.0370942838,
-0.0200151987,
-0.0593344755,
-0.0467965007,
0.0253208112,
0.0067600785,
-0.0699307248,
0.0201340597,
-0.0162564982,
-0.0680403262,
0.0370714664,
-0.0355448052,
0.0590539351,
0.0366733931,
-0.0251011103,
-0.0155094834,
0.0328255296,
0.0500326753,
-0.003832421,
0.0246200413,
-0.0433377922,
0.0189030077,
-0.0589682907,
0.043016348,
-0.0318126529,
-0.0186411608,
-0.0027908182,
-0.0342742801,
-0.0956524983,
0.0010060713,
-0.0295664743,
-0.0376052037,
0.0085763577,
-0.0211074241,
0.0375944413,
0.008450279,
0.0065264665,
0.0022069062,
-0.0305312239,
-0.0026385121,
-0.0132435486,
-0.0171936229,
0.055785466,
0.0253011938,
-0.0318907909,
-0.0599427633,
-0.0061649019,
0.0635484979,
0.041930303,
-0.0090082111,
-0.0529309362,
-0.0145467566,
-0.0704304874,
-0.0576014146,
-0.0081900163,
-0.0586667471,
0.0063813352,
0.0121202311,
-0.0063486639,
-0.039060805,
0.0072368621,
-0.0196117572,
-0.0220091883,
0.046418719,
-0.0308527816,
0.008781543,
0.009128456,
0.0210886728,
0.0107385525,
0.0620448627,
0.0074366382,
0.0039071552,
0.0293691456,
-0.0424942002,
0.0057589314,
0.0440648347,
-0.0163724031,
-0.0048366748,
-0.0136139262,
-0.0264022835,
-0.0036949015,
0.047230497,
0.0014030259,
0.0583255924,
-0.0071553048,
0.0557789877,
0.0450797714,
0.0584600493,
0.0481965691,
0.0095087523,
0.0150326602,
0.0133228097,
0.0250331592,
-0.0006689543,
-0.0459077023,
-0.0164541453,
-0.0328787565,
-0.021173276,
0.0144218411,
0.0443736464,
-0.011258442,
-0.0554599278,
-0.074071601,
-0.0208992623,
0.0046741273,
0.0099793226,
0.0286072269,
-0.0466221571,
0.0170741528,
0.0386275649,
0.0207815431,
-0.0308296196,
-0.0114512322,
-0.0251360312,
-0.010960103,
0.0935958847,
0.0232366938,
-0.0355413742,
-0.0110583045,
0.0007800687,
0.006008062,
0.0349131674,
0.0173550043,
0.0094573386,
0.0375078097,
-0.0391477384,
0.0001069513,
0.0572037436,
0.0324084945,
-0.0281186271,
-0.0078125484,
0.0039536776,
-0.0074527175,
-0.045687899,
-0.0398891754,
0.0550026447,
-0.0344885252,
-0.0223210324,
-0.0104806917,
-0.0046727271,
0.0678568855,
0.0107590593,
-0.0162582435,
0.0299212635,
0.0220541749,
-0.0306196827,
-0.0288055316,
0.0070025446,
-0.0084912525,
-0.0177829806,
0.0364113972,
0.0206950903,
0.0079757217,
0.0698577985,
-0.0042497357,
-0.0213487595,
0.0447876416,
-0.0613019541,
0.0113982633,
0.0093637193,
0.0092003588,
-0.0269232467,
0.0658315271,
-0.0528974086,
0.0297047049,
-0.0257485118,
0.0670391023,
0.0187061578,
-0.0319248773,
-0.0124170501,
-0.0309534743,
-0.0654837862,
-0.0121167647,
-0.0358068161,
0.0365233943,
-0.0363606773,
0.0201206896,
-0.0411588624,
-0.0447192267,
-0.1264445335,
-0.0008479301,
0.0049128891,
-0.001749426,
0.0378771164,
-0.0331556164,
-0.0439093523,
0.0092793442,
-0.0039549172,
0.0146991396,
0.0688193142,
0.0363745019,
-0.0153433112,
-0.037404146,
-0.0352912024,
-0.0600913391,
-0.0190042108,
-0.0585873909,
0.0309583172,
-0.0327264145,
0.0104067195,
-0.0197972935,
0.0074833767,
-0.0418966264,
-0.0290344488,
0.016995281,
-0.0435321294,
0.0100650825,
0.0283357445,
0.086086221,
0.0230469108,
0.0009781002,
0.0410665721,
0.0432909951,
-0.0398244262,
-0.0150545249,
-0.0240917895,
0.0164386686,
0.0115457596,
-0.0412199423,
-0.0961068124,
0.0041077496,
0.0831488669,
0.029615093,
0.0322019868,
-0.037350785,
0.0129481489,
-0.0616675206,
-0.0052341674,
-0.0080735115,
0.0133035593,
-0.0358722955,
0.0422601961,
-0.0025302025,
-0.0425872803,
0.0419700965,
-0.0426577032,
0.013826957,
-0.0431578495,
-0.0220313612,
-0.0228153337,
0.0299850926,
-0.0214602221,
0.0136423707,
0.0232630987,
0.0021948768,
0.0102722328,
-0.0277019702,
-0.0126591455,
-0.0444935337,
0.0512508228,
-0.0412305221,
-0.0065785227,
0.0371131375,
0.025366189,
-0.0176347475,
-0.0177008267,
-0.0461148322,
-0.002609337,
0.0286950618,
-0.0012925147,
-0.0374381319,
0.0055830716,
0.0191896465,
-0.0098617347,
-0.0168215446,
-0.0059728613,
0.0179547798,
0.0221506059,
0.0583871827,
-0.0049261693,
0.0542680956,
-0.0493429713,
0.0211501475,
0.0016802405,
-0.0067890692,
0.0485069007,
-0.0020699617,
0.0215622056,
-0.0096499119,
0.0024602029,
-0.0127270641,
0.0292899534,
0.0260076001,
-0.0125795584,
-0.0147602465,
0.131038785,
0.0290142335,
-0.0118591748,
0.0280053746,
-0.064666599,
0.0349277593,
0.00848646,
-0.0091451276,
-0.0153427375,
-0.0135773206,
-0.0174592733,
0.0574645959,
-0.0226764753,
-0.0361344442,
0.0238038916,
-0.0382412821,
0.0263533201,
-0.0052277767,
-0.0313531868,
0.0092602782,
-0.0060954778,
0.0321568139,
-0.0220210999,
0.0166886058,
-0.0274226479,
-0.010837568,
-0.0086835977,
0.0083733546,
-0.0884220302,
-0.0768936053,
0.0804976374,
-0.0305748023,
0.0854823217,
0.0441037752,
0.0340999514,
-0.0120351361,
-0.048714146,
-0.000407482,
0.0115779433,
-0.0348942876,
0.0141204018,
0.0656766072,
0.0377721675,
0.002378481,
-0.0656949282,
0.0011753043,
-0.0528408773,
-0.014923403,
-0.0087553132,
0.0906782523,
0.0132984538,
-0.0322965868,
-0.0140230823,
0.0462261699,
0.0312779956,
0.0579436272,
0.0475814529,
-0.0546000078,
-0.0170608517,
0.0138320103,
0.0074015232,
-0.0274874233,
-0.0448575988,
0.0181172378,
-0.0211966578,
-0.0287775733,
-0.0682187378,
-0.0471168458,
0.0562573895,
-0.0230722874,
-0.0207703728,
-0.0091798082,
-0.0090283053,
-0.0082246875,
-0.0365558341,
0.0529424138,
0.0306085236,
0.0347917303,
-0.0671524405,
0.0253546853,
0.0118041672,
0.0247014184,
-0.0130191604,
0.0373649485,
-0.0904793516,
-0.0348542109,
0.0895610973,
0.0219477098,
0.0192970578,
-0.055628337,
-0.0114261871,
-0.051964771,
0.021424951,
-0.0160053633,
-0.0289593842,
0.0221446939,
0.0027874701,
0.0296786688,
0.0009788506,
0.0505403876,
0.0106229372,
0.0558960699,
0.0327747203,
0.0313930884,
0.0250462648,
-0.0079890657,
-0.0062714927,
0.0557218269,
0.0439878628,
-0.0194712095,
-0.062658295,
-0.0301573258,
-0.0732481033,
-0.0423666798,
-0.0023840738,
-0.0267598312,
-0.0213793311,
0.0395444334,
0.0232924819,
-0.0315304287,
-0.028038105,
-0.0443126522,
-0.0217502844,
-0.0358389392,
0.0480305888,
-0.0276340656,
-0.0080108568,
0.0124750948,
0.0196941383,
-0.0031496263,
0.0354935937,
-0.0408133529,
0.0121054994,
-0.0108683174,
0.0721410587,
-0.0435794629,
-0.016611496,
0.0258023404,
0.0533611327,
0.0109236073,
-0.0674937293,
-0.0189930964,
-0.0184976775,
0.0462273993,
0.0176739469,
0.0985368118,
-0.0117078256,
0.0230574571,
-0.0539039373,
-0.0027459622,
-0.024968395,
0.0043742154,
0.0284152385,
0.00830385,
-0.0213289112,
-0.0239714831,
0.0423122682,
-0.01696264,
-0.0281499624,
0.0205804128,
-0.0412797593,
-0.043791268,
-0.0082285684,
-0.0309718773,
0.0054954607,
-0.0999570787,
-0.0024335829,
-0.0803481191,
-0.0630999878,
0.0507891364,
0.0032541971,
-0.0241399929,
-0.0146896774,
0.0016245854,
0.0489141531,
-0.0204571839,
-0.0018908808,
-0.0438957289,
-0.0061464808,
-0.0098884776,
-0.0277903546,
-0.015095205,
-5.6148575e-33,
-0.0262253284,
-0.0238264315,
0.0075576059,
-0.0228949208,
-0.0272539426,
-0.0142377354,
-0.0314510837,
0.0791234449,
0.0025230723,
0.0187928546,
0.0356427357,
0.0289132632,
0.0150305303,
0.0201789644,
0.0386180058,
-0.0058496273,
0.0070512979,
-0.0138419662,
-0.0341493599,
-0.0361753851,
0.0014461856,
0.0216959603,
0.0592169166,
-0.0824786723,
0.027060952,
0.0181542784,
-0.0060044262,
-0.0015783672,
0.0205563176,
0.0597741045,
-0.062262658,
0.080563426,
0.0477637537,
0.0065474613,
0.0037245119,
0.0002376737,
-0.0096944962,
-0.0216764417,
0.0545511506,
-0.028082801,
-0.0383738205,
0.0025346451,
0.0269534569,
-0.0112312539,
-0.0158625618,
-0.0217331853,
0.0255864542,
-0.070707351,
0.0180348121,
0.000824246,
-0.0639909357,
0.0346699916,
0.0053869244,
0.0193363428,
-0.0158817507,
0.0664351881,
-0.0621184036,
0.0283418391,
-0.0203186199,
-0.0104250982,
0.0352271236,
0.0244906601,
0.0434412956,
-0.0162728187,
0.0078525124,
0.0548728891,
0.0128255095,
-0.0180648956,
-0.0158129465,
-0.0039162836,
0.0632063523,
0.0370625257,
0.0747395605,
0.0322624035,
-0.0216833726,
-0.0136283534,
-0.0258968789,
0.0123008881,
0.0110227112,
0.005589515,
0.0340815634,
0.0012427208,
0.0013113777,
-0.0383028314,
-0.0394921154,
0.0097122518,
-0.0350335427,
-0.0423107147,
0.0628715232,
-0.0379269049,
-0.0031497614,
-0.039883133,
0.0247273538,
-0.0176941715,
0.0064504156,
-0.0245327782,
0.0034895332,
0.063369371,
0.0095801298,
0.0416936018,
-0.0456253923,
-0.0072953557,
0.0071805604,
0.0261181779,
0.0620036051,
-0.0362820029,
0.0132770566,
-0.0321263,
-0.0552706234,
0.012582818,
0.0126816351,
0.0133214919,
0.0121829761,
0.0450778678,
-0.0097657563,
-0.0219365247,
-0.0098434454,
0.0191490743,
0.0291525796,
-0.0137507645,
-0.053230688,
0.0074247825,
0.0183557384,
0.0057561207,
0.0012362853,
-0.0074620731,
-0.0390175693,
-0.0058899336,
0.066287145,
-0.0167921167,
0.0106672402,
-0.0275826138,
2.529e-7,
0.0679834709,
0.0909936056,
-0.0358846448,
-0.0007368286,
-0.0072592022,
0.002276795,
-0.0398526788,
0.0139815966,
0.0238133892,
0.0066404724,
0.0068522007,
0.0046199593,
0.0869199783,
0.0698541477,
0.0078674164,
-0.0367375165,
-0.0498959869,
0.0122706778,
-0.0598422475,
0.0186835602,
0.0511968061,
0.0632141978,
-0.0058153779,
-0.0081535969,
-0.0060302522,
-0.0098624323,
0.0358752608,
-0.0531911328,
-0.0299893469,
0.0408767797,
0.0464077704,
-0.011480608,
0.0257983655,
0.0018008364,
0.009654751,
-0.0147220008,
0.0076509169,
0.0550593808,
-0.013844342,
-0.0066824281,
0.0213525817,
0.0083236415,
-0.0157256573,
-0.061216753,
0.0388346054,
-0.0800550207,
-0.0351348445,
-0.0251930431,
-0.0416756831,
-0.0215374324,
0.0898326337,
-0.0366464108,
-0.0248574633,
0.04221173,
0.0394142717,
-0.0167916752,
-0.0103428485,
-0.028860528,
-0.0434465297,
0.020667756,
-0.0547899008,
-0.034180522,
-0.0087354239,
-0.0173662286,
-0.0204947051,
-0.090086177,
0.0274227709,
2.428346791e-34,
0.0500531308,
0.0570890084,
0.0262501463,
-0.0177657697,
0.0483027585,
-0.0031972595,
-0.0564410612,
0.0405217819,
-0.0554230809,
-0.1072558537,
0.0141594131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09188v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09188v2 | Towards Verifiable Text Generation with Symbolic References | 2023-11-15T18:28:29 | 2024-04-15T16:09:33 | Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Shannon Shen, Aniruddha Nrusimha, Bernhard Gapp, David Sontag, Yoon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | LLMs are vulnerable to hallucinations, and thus their outputs generally
require laborious human verification for high-stakes applications. To this end,
we propose symbolically grounded generation (SymGen) as a simple approach for
enabling easier manual validation of an LLM's output. SymGen prompts an LLM to
interleave its regular output text with explicit symbolic references to fields
present in some conditioning data (e.g., a table in JSON format). The
references can be used to display the provenance of different spans of text in
the generation, reducing the effort required for manual verification. Across a
range of data-to-text and question-answering experiments, we find that LLMs are
able to directly output text that makes use of accurate symbolic references
while maintaining fluency and factuality. In a human study we further find that
such annotations can streamline human verification of machine-generated text.
Our code will be available at http://symgen.github.io. | [
0.0289297234,
0.0496101379,
0.0015921383,
0.0462704115,
-0.0160662904,
0.0052493378,
-0.0054384042,
0.0273743607,
-0.0074796039,
-0.0483604185,
0.0156134861,
0.0260031112,
-0.0221868698,
0.0046561365,
0.0751571208,
-0.0167923663,
0.038187895,
0.0000628593,
0.0006753329,
0.000092863,
-0.0011490834,
0.02870325,
-0.0152219757,
0.0136640351,
-0.0435457155,
-0.0193690937,
-0.0153219579,
0.0332838595,
0.0340818129,
-0.0272837076,
-0.050930135,
0.0420265682,
-0.0306894351,
0.0305502042,
0.0000021218,
-0.0486058965,
-0.0023940704,
0.0310395826,
-0.0676828921,
0.0048440685,
-0.0132752815,
0.0326046348,
-0.0100040268,
0.0284561571,
-0.0493886992,
0.0192384478,
0.0424368642,
0.0325217992,
0.0969972238,
0.0559380837,
0.0010998904,
0.01038766,
0.0297240578,
0.0098534087,
0.0795947164,
0.0364436023,
-0.0177489985,
0.0180466548,
-0.0029029225,
0.01216665,
0.0504934974,
0.0447117426,
0.02101513,
-0.0145300981,
-0.0079242354,
0.0227875765,
-0.04256697,
0.0116187744,
-0.0046416316,
0.064376168,
0.0332840495,
-0.0432206243,
0.0237197597,
0.0016859148,
-0.0022382552,
0.0197808947,
-0.0289628878,
0.0591419563,
-0.0259141717,
-0.0107393004,
0.0342866853,
-0.0089276442,
0.0223555844,
-0.00030012,
-0.0112385778,
0.0691216812,
0.0091862595,
-0.0332149602,
0.0131739583,
0.0214816723,
0.0076211882,
-0.0925207809,
-0.001481515,
0.0413324535,
-0.0013624908,
0.0163592268,
-0.0473689735,
-0.0398293287,
0.0655574575,
-0.0548552945,
0.0467632264,
0.0117951753,
-0.0206489172,
0.0055039632,
-0.0625698566,
0.0353678763,
-0.0259082559,
0.0468141884,
0.0003592164,
0.0067286999,
-0.0143345864,
-0.0059495131,
-0.0229467377,
0.0421348251,
-0.0421878919,
0.0320528001,
-0.0204250347,
0.0472161323,
-0.0054932591,
0.0667010471,
-0.0277626477,
-0.0041286564,
-0.0082515618,
0.0009329478,
-0.0428540818,
-0.0559267066,
-0.0443526395,
-0.009538372,
0.0115879606,
-0.0778862536,
0.0097511588,
0.0559785701,
0.0106038712,
0.0040229531,
0.0118102962,
0.0919156596,
0.0081281839,
0.024486959,
-0.0692382008,
-0.0901750177,
0.0005201033,
-0.0534929819,
0.0119375316,
-0.0574286692,
0.0205534026,
0.0128117679,
-0.0408364795,
-0.0444995165,
0.0327599421,
0.0809711069,
0.0111631975,
0.0579721108,
-0.0662490353,
-0.0246072561,
-0.0045316555,
-0.01161364,
-0.0207503289,
0.0149663761,
0.0671290234,
0.0453036465,
0.032075379,
0.0236740485,
0.0511284471,
0.0234970003,
0.0466706753,
-0.0080576558,
-0.0421048068,
0.0297735408,
0.0016632112,
0.0121427998,
-0.0133379828,
0.0634634197,
-0.0203741025,
0.0199139472,
0.0553087965,
0.0469208993,
0.0009112593,
0.0118336258,
0.0497782491,
-0.0199757554,
0.0343887843,
0.0089878105,
-0.0588006787,
0.0544695184,
-0.0390532799,
0.0249756128,
0.021041723,
0.0029684966,
0.0028142447,
-0.0443107858,
-0.0273440257,
0.0089991,
-0.0307175759,
-0.0060219909,
-0.0376120545,
0.0296540074,
-0.0319075882,
0.0719250962,
0.0060344236,
-0.0781662762,
0.0008201844,
-0.0143463574,
0.0468794554,
0.0492238849,
0.0579177663,
-0.0000212181,
0.0158690605,
-0.0485260151,
0.0358367972,
0.1098359227,
0.0082002953,
0.0025077029,
-0.038957946,
-0.021955464,
-0.020767808,
-0.0064184559,
-0.0114470338,
-0.0165551621,
0.0263838992,
0.0142700868,
0.0280445572,
-0.0855976641,
-0.0031854722,
0.0550590269,
-0.02191264,
-0.0381933153,
0.0044473214,
-0.011167354,
0.0126424804,
0.0606518239,
-0.0268116668,
0.0486805923,
0.0427566655,
-0.02552923,
-0.0175056402,
0.0178827439,
0.0088464664,
0.0137839317,
0.0205417555,
-0.0622275658,
-0.0153468726,
-0.0105480663,
-0.0424602255,
-0.0371426642,
-0.0317711793,
-0.0827352703,
-0.0131745664,
-0.0507276244,
-0.0227436535,
0.0328720547,
0.0230552163,
-0.017279543,
0.0712506697,
-0.0100904126,
-0.0046105599,
0.0317461081,
-0.001573075,
0.0091204913,
-0.0431530252,
0.0186902545,
0.0120773073,
0.0072499416,
0.0145108178,
0.0102376156,
0.0078900624,
-0.0454490855,
-0.0259508882,
-0.0442686155,
0.0215309709,
-0.0172644444,
0.0308295246,
0.0283771809,
-0.0472420752,
-0.0047989064,
-0.0026626086,
-0.0669525936,
0.018928986,
0.0254484601,
-0.002458168,
0.0788948536,
-0.0071832477,
-0.0102195367,
-0.0204416011,
-0.0002998171,
-0.0171911344,
0.0443732254,
0.0546369441,
-0.0002489425,
-0.0909872577,
-0.0021330875,
-0.0513023101,
-0.0185274296,
0.0363938697,
0.0155256735,
0.0354039185,
0.0061266664,
0.0167809259,
0.0153712267,
0.0368734337,
-0.0208896548,
0.0189842731,
-0.0006889844,
-0.0474907979,
-0.0153052649,
0.0054545174,
0.026574444,
0.0270639863,
-0.07272093,
0.0247034375,
0.0025299441,
0.0113897799,
0.0284693129,
-0.0222346671,
0.0379939191,
0.0431291498,
-0.0010114443,
-0.0057466724,
-0.0060882233,
-0.0141085107,
0.06027117,
-0.0260194521,
-0.0587815866,
0.0575227477,
-0.0614353791,
0.0211030487,
0.0092097688,
-0.0044979802,
-0.0395818986,
0.0480975099,
-0.0254691914,
-0.0026709796,
-0.00106698,
0.0015433532,
-0.0312412418,
-0.0219277777,
0.0084492462,
-0.0533620343,
0.045354329,
-0.0264871679,
0.0176869836,
-0.0166113079,
-0.0194444004,
-0.0520626456,
-0.0182640515,
-0.035127759,
-0.0057745762,
-0.0228787754,
0.0064895391,
-0.0129834488,
-0.0500930734,
0.0557465851,
0.0061245169,
0.0091204923,
-0.0206414629,
-0.0563127995,
-0.0029597424,
0.0272653736,
0.0204071961,
0.030834984,
-0.0275747422,
-0.0238267127,
0.0694548115,
-0.0072889058,
0.001811007,
-0.0120321093,
-0.0410181955,
-0.0175643545,
-0.0390255973,
-0.0136517314,
0.0461846702,
-0.0106478529,
-0.0549094751,
-0.0173856243,
0.0689640194,
0.0136647318,
0.0078833122,
0.0212381668,
-0.0082006538,
0.0158634633,
0.0175322741,
0.047162883,
-0.1404493302,
-0.0170786213,
0.0115107447,
0.0373332947,
-0.002828734,
-0.0483464003,
-0.0369554535,
-0.1046837866,
0.0426667482,
0.0031585805,
-0.0339365825,
-0.0284116548,
-0.0340331718,
-0.0231708307,
0.028374834,
-0.0114235412,
0.0453202948,
-0.002236455,
0.0140716126,
0.0191606395,
-0.0149624357,
0.0075902436,
-0.0101372711,
-0.0347918384,
0.0464052074,
0.0521596149,
0.0231183209,
0.0037465242,
-0.0900714397,
0.019688407,
-0.0038693827,
0.010323354,
-0.008695785,
0.0582416393,
0.0012862376,
-0.0040538241,
-0.034828335,
0.0377437957,
-0.0552151613,
-0.0344961509,
0.0187491607,
0.0644520372,
-0.0468220375,
-0.0024700672,
-0.0310789384,
0.0277652517,
0.0298148487,
0.0525543354,
0.0302097164,
-0.008180107,
-0.0665676892,
-0.0542246886,
0.0134061873,
-0.0426379852,
-0.0272374917,
-0.0041264258,
0.0053213616,
0.0256370567,
-0.106194973,
-0.0153004695,
-0.0131322928,
0.0638659075,
0.0134695498,
0.0130817164,
-0.0282183997,
-0.0435642675,
-0.0622494332,
0.008860196,
-0.0700729415,
0.0225543994,
-0.0249193665,
-0.0028566427,
0.0351416729,
-0.0376992747,
0.004785174,
0.0384561233,
-0.0466391779,
-0.0403957888,
-0.0264510047,
0.0427308418,
0.0278325472,
0.0132574365,
0.0038474994,
-0.0035830156,
0.0379784591,
0.0754203722,
-0.0114451153,
0.0088264765,
0.0112267053,
0.0348258056,
-0.0008211189,
-0.0067098495,
-0.0564960837,
0.0050985478,
0.0007663997,
0.0237310547,
-0.0153740169,
-0.0119751301,
0.0086248154,
0.0631690472,
-0.0063841445,
-0.0297199804,
-0.0212069694,
0.0030788316,
0.037237782,
-0.0566807576,
-0.0113376249,
-0.0336661711,
0.013744724,
-0.0523851626,
-0.0388868302,
0.0263088401,
-0.0204958618,
-0.0454319194,
0.0649187937,
-0.0036464815,
-0.0075468468,
-0.0103176087,
0.0519913286,
0.0003280285,
-0.0228402503,
-0.0391568132,
0.0184977837,
-0.0089394897,
0.0670628995,
-0.0042505343,
0.0112136221,
0.0226531848,
-0.0112712318,
-0.0138269346,
0.0041524572,
-0.0623727851,
-0.0093894405,
-0.0457511991,
0.0060858713,
0.0414314866,
0.0617777742,
0.0477725267,
-0.0362761915,
-0.0075986409,
0.0172176622,
0.0254563689,
0.0178875793,
-0.0332990102,
0.0085397651,
0.0030411961,
-0.0213879105,
-0.0240579043,
0.0418212488,
-0.0055146399,
0.0302825402,
-0.0304999128,
-0.013885498,
-0.0740834251,
-0.0415086597,
-0.0417192541,
-0.0207706206,
0.0005781669,
-0.0423243791,
-0.0622828044,
-0.0672263578,
0.0644408017,
0.0551805981,
0.0132318921,
0.0055424361,
0.0362819396,
0.0266363919,
0.0457761697,
-0.0305169579,
-0.0118204318,
0.0492508039,
0.009030534,
-0.0549650118,
-0.0225662664,
-6.389965985e-33,
-0.037244793,
-0.086134173,
0.0122525319,
0.0059661455,
0.0059087803,
0.001150271,
-0.0504853055,
-0.0034223287,
0.0252065249,
0.0137907788,
-0.0047596553,
0.0012573412,
0.0198348314,
0.0130363116,
-0.02653642,
-0.0580634363,
0.0356525891,
-0.0083701164,
-0.0339250192,
0.0156186903,
0.0489871055,
-0.0168070067,
0.0355987474,
-0.0972718298,
0.0759442151,
-0.0222222339,
-0.0420880429,
-0.0041474113,
-0.0332645848,
0.0433440134,
-0.011731077,
0.0366486534,
0.0063153547,
0.0018913995,
-0.0355300643,
0.0257720985,
-0.061547365,
-0.0355628952,
0.0006969865,
-0.0268859938,
-0.0583435073,
-0.0510657094,
0.0456558689,
-0.0500052385,
-0.018302789,
0.0093817767,
0.022579113,
-0.0222482383,
-0.007050002,
-0.076158911,
-0.024695769,
0.0223055705,
0.0134243947,
0.0372894928,
-0.0221212544,
0.0498338118,
0.0090156188,
-0.0239699669,
-0.0537430346,
0.0192539226,
0.0104562007,
-0.033091329,
0.0594000444,
-0.0402837917,
-0.0174863134,
0.0558890402,
0.0219604839,
-0.0028941981,
-0.0472237803,
0.0340852924,
-0.0317068845,
0.0427961461,
0.1011536419,
0.0841408074,
0.0163248219,
0.0075581805,
-0.0480126105,
0.0412605368,
-0.0120159816,
-0.0057688216,
0.0254088975,
-0.0380555615,
-0.0363151394,
0.0131456302,
-0.0390917957,
-0.0028454079,
-0.0359461568,
-0.0289104749,
0.0178697966,
-0.0032651431,
-0.0522960536,
-0.0113795325,
-0.005399466,
-0.0212626327,
-0.01390264,
0.0282586031,
0.0014999836,
-0.005504814,
-0.0138742104,
-0.0340740532,
-0.0070931166,
-0.0096838027,
0.0285613071,
-0.0120637463,
0.0594689883,
0.0492611006,
0.0279516838,
0.0111926561,
-0.0865449458,
0.0325691178,
-0.0195978321,
0.0519980378,
0.0284680761,
-0.0833405927,
0.0172075666,
-0.0149689633,
0.0050679399,
0.0233187247,
-0.0103594149,
-0.0035676907,
0.0137365349,
0.0372212976,
0.0283832401,
0.0449738689,
-0.015784312,
0.0347478427,
-0.0036346095,
0.030411819,
0.0498356484,
-0.0481991917,
0.0111330142,
0.0029499894,
2.811e-7,
0.0348508842,
0.0305174142,
0.0709816292,
0.0359741375,
0.0114413109,
0.0035167276,
0.0393013284,
0.0081031825,
-0.0209889021,
-0.0759253278,
-0.0151210744,
-0.0010795129,
0.0750815123,
0.0847871155,
-0.0694600493,
-0.0369355604,
-0.0552473217,
-0.0011891685,
-0.0564467199,
0.0130390394,
0.0933434591,
0.0194648784,
0.0064504235,
-0.0198517088,
-0.0198224597,
-0.0520638637,
0.0351472721,
-0.0170701761,
0.0182737112,
-0.0030022112,
0.0410128944,
-0.0274050608,
0.0265808292,
0.0340797491,
-0.0447747372,
-0.0480942391,
-0.0184661858,
0.0494435653,
0.0308097098,
-0.0425449423,
-0.0144331148,
-0.0696198344,
0.0421678759,
-0.0023387366,
0.0602999404,
0.006585598,
-0.0111480402,
0.0046387105,
-0.0496765114,
-0.0266856365,
0.0085725691,
-0.0088999569,
-0.0132757891,
0.0040833633,
0.0020647657,
0.0298722237,
-0.0091978908,
-0.0155573534,
-0.0480419621,
0.0035044178,
-0.0516074598,
-0.0236734897,
-0.0109476373,
-0.0003073852,
0.0026983947,
-0.0746340975,
-0.0167775732,
2.963767937e-34,
0.009248565,
-0.0091023771,
0.0146717923,
0.0341406018,
0.0560240708,
0.0305317156,
-0.0094445748,
0.0117168697,
0.0386566892,
-0.0381581225,
-0.0202809833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09184v1 | Benchmarking Generation and Evaluation Capabilities of Large Language Models for Instruction Controllable Summarization | 2023-11-15T18:25:26 | 2023-11-15T18:25:26 | Yixin Liu, Alexander R. Fabbri, Jiawen Chen, Yilun Zhao, Simeng Han, Shafiq Joty, Pengfei Liu, Dragomir Radev, Chien-Sheng Wu, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While large language models (LLMs) already achieve strong performance on
standard generic summarization benchmarks, their performance on more complex
summarization task settings is less studied. Therefore, we benchmark LLMs on
instruction controllable text summarization, where the model input consists of
both a source article and a natural language requirement for the desired
summary characteristics. To this end, we curate an evaluation-only dataset for
this task setting and conduct human evaluation on 5 LLM-based summarization
systems. We then benchmark LLM-based automatic evaluation for this task with 4
different evaluation protocols and 11 LLMs, resulting in 40 evaluation methods
in total. Our study reveals that instruction controllable text summarization
remains a challenging task for LLMs, since (1) all LLMs evaluated still make
factual and other types of errors in their summaries; (2) all LLM-based
evaluation methods cannot achieve a strong alignment with human annotators when
judging the quality of candidate summaries; (3) different LLMs show large
performance gaps in summary generation and evaluation. We make our collected
benchmark, InstruSum, publicly available to facilitate future research in this
direction. | [
0.0504855253,
0.0123880282,
0.0369126573,
-0.0006591498,
-0.0152333751,
0.0208698809,
-0.0007502912,
-0.0450343378,
0.0054190848,
-0.0560720973,
-0.0192335397,
-0.0081986235,
0.0204531886,
-0.0355290025,
0.014222254,
-0.0928539708,
0.0339617208,
-0.0528755784,
-0.0210019704,
0.009240862,
0.0232512522,
0.0119863264,
0.0222434234,
0.0325062834,
0.0322757959,
-0.0067850188,
0.0114560248,
0.0013562707,
0.029290162,
-0.0194400325,
0.0198251344,
0.0143003473,
0.0114329914,
-0.0053482768,
0.0000019562,
-0.0406591669,
-0.0205402169,
0.0043491838,
-0.0073560528,
0.0720995888,
0.0817463249,
-0.0118907811,
0.0063029705,
0.0229579341,
0.0160710327,
0.0206376035,
-0.0118111651,
0.0242659915,
0.1120036319,
0.0643472746,
-0.0003512658,
-0.0291291196,
0.0140448743,
-0.0043788194,
-0.0303693749,
-0.0242306739,
-0.0078923237,
0.0303356517,
0.0360662155,
-0.0112234177,
0.0162462611,
0.0376602076,
0.014640402,
-0.0151747791,
-0.0047598393,
0.0076220208,
-0.0433801524,
0.0091117099,
0.0014148238,
0.0623682626,
0.0188016854,
0.009399306,
0.0211314615,
0.0113169355,
-0.0043068542,
-0.0069474396,
-0.0642650574,
0.0817437321,
-0.0324160308,
0.0245772768,
0.0145999044,
0.0399958827,
-0.0093536135,
0.0274444949,
-0.0173677336,
0.0383625738,
0.0148850502,
-0.0237934124,
-0.0180415995,
0.0214371178,
-0.0319781452,
-0.0860360488,
0.0107527822,
0.0583227575,
-0.0244540814,
-0.0164982956,
-0.0859214664,
-0.0599679686,
0.0337751061,
-0.0395324863,
0.0433850475,
-0.0041702269,
0.0127063803,
0.0480246693,
-0.0120186452,
0.0725204572,
0.0294028297,
0.0188469235,
-0.0632925481,
0.0012522003,
-0.0331081524,
0.0071803727,
-0.019253511,
0.0490184277,
-0.0393234007,
-0.0116641931,
-0.0573746078,
0.0299900342,
-0.0054906616,
0.0195203628,
0.0066484222,
-0.0097651808,
-0.0061316285,
0.0036554323,
-0.0059466208,
0.0102285249,
-0.0280085392,
-0.0362773053,
0.0328059308,
-0.0024081643,
-0.0029911015,
0.0360279456,
-0.0135749802,
0.0144703863,
0.0191975385,
0.0383423008,
-0.0425327383,
-0.0227088314,
-0.016165521,
-0.0351170599,
0.0026733673,
-0.0593974516,
-0.0101949777,
-0.0739719495,
-0.0194706153,
0.004509842,
-0.0041324883,
-0.0194422156,
0.0175302662,
0.0341746807,
-0.034760084,
-0.0099352654,
-0.0031290287,
0.0210872442,
0.0406917594,
0.0090790596,
0.0189128369,
0.0417360328,
0.071231328,
0.044572778,
0.0439459458,
0.0299737919,
0.0198152829,
0.0388335064,
-0.0056979214,
0.0029608675,
0.0127604762,
0.0029858877,
-0.0474398434,
-0.0045073428,
0.0272951126,
0.094944723,
-0.0218032431,
0.0276577938,
0.046381481,
0.0477290154,
-0.0170854758,
-0.0111493254,
0.0712063983,
0.0500264466,
0.0599900372,
0.0626200289,
-0.0219039638,
0.0293283854,
-0.0361832269,
0.069222182,
0.1039736122,
0.025859816,
-0.0182322357,
-0.0848244056,
-0.0111346757,
-0.003648578,
0.007144616,
0.0162869561,
0.0360737815,
0.0026541401,
-0.0564022548,
0.0158415474,
0.0237633623,
-0.0668533519,
0.0262660552,
-0.0332425199,
0.0184890255,
0.0716039017,
0.0523351692,
-0.0406838283,
-0.0235925876,
0.007483298,
0.0221711416,
0.0363393016,
0.0377361476,
-0.0317252837,
-0.031029433,
-0.0453208946,
-0.0204151832,
-0.0172690395,
0.0144203855,
-0.0073991362,
0.0133552114,
-0.0389783457,
0.0340019688,
-0.0063558621,
-0.0992136449,
0.0334130712,
-0.0232907403,
-0.0327645466,
-0.0306291953,
-0.0242459383,
0.0009192877,
0.0236717518,
-0.0232920107,
0.0328907333,
0.0087007256,
-0.0182209983,
-0.0028575873,
-0.0205837879,
-0.0430318452,
-0.0213409476,
0.0197502822,
-0.063260369,
-0.0046532131,
0.0008890046,
-0.0301810876,
-0.0636618808,
0.014528485,
-0.066648677,
-0.016338855,
-0.0180548914,
0.0367752612,
0.0117450589,
-0.040906556,
-0.0374254026,
0.049732957,
-0.0002186997,
-0.0132452631,
0.0814347044,
-0.0287004784,
-0.0069834865,
-0.0253390055,
-0.0305487849,
-0.0224637724,
0.0116789667,
0.0091179041,
0.0554563664,
0.0220778566,
-0.0213287473,
-0.0445218869,
-0.110841386,
0.0294054616,
-0.0327671841,
0.0244670883,
0.0541778803,
-0.002588467,
-0.0110063981,
0.0086551048,
-0.0316646323,
-0.0639422312,
0.0304146502,
0.0095070926,
0.0253384281,
0.011378862,
0.0329722129,
-0.0932905599,
-0.0247376002,
-0.0022469687,
0.0315462835,
0.0382215008,
-0.0004289428,
-0.0460235588,
0.0300584715,
-0.0149603831,
-0.0289737731,
0.0166568402,
-0.0113000171,
0.0013410359,
0.0064386772,
0.0383523405,
0.0482112393,
0.0355965085,
0.0134379286,
0.0677951723,
-0.0101649882,
-0.0266204048,
-0.0001000299,
-0.0132157868,
-0.0113845617,
0.0097080963,
-0.0470285229,
0.0152544295,
0.0734144598,
0.0114660785,
0.0054581971,
-0.0340041406,
0.0085508153,
-0.0492485799,
-0.0022212339,
-0.0439190082,
-0.0407729074,
-0.0116058001,
0.0085059553,
-0.0465486236,
-0.0202134289,
0.0646839887,
-0.0347021893,
0.0285379849,
-0.0721868873,
-0.0031030092,
-0.0502487011,
0.0081386557,
0.0207583755,
0.0249708425,
-0.0154317953,
0.0063315229,
-0.0392894186,
-0.0094872722,
0.0524055362,
-0.0288168881,
0.0829564705,
-0.0880567357,
0.0067550028,
-0.0229140613,
0.0199781917,
-0.0200085901,
-0.0414338633,
-0.0178275015,
0.0245764926,
0.0628946722,
0.0096701356,
-0.0334219895,
0.0098750191,
0.0588956699,
0.0685687363,
-0.0319424979,
-0.0150809763,
-0.0157379881,
0.0269626416,
0.0693176985,
-0.0223697163,
0.0353827588,
-0.0642355308,
0.0426130779,
0.0353419073,
0.032619331,
-0.0119359884,
0.0097014094,
-0.0115672434,
0.0043684174,
-0.0853589624,
0.0120073278,
0.0189272501,
0.0883276239,
-0.0618148074,
-0.0112558231,
0.1189008504,
0.0254276879,
-0.0363841355,
-0.0214617681,
0.0247190017,
0.0142881377,
-0.007543853,
0.010378629,
-0.0543796085,
-0.0077075055,
-0.0079791313,
0.0542390719,
0.001457177,
-0.0092375856,
-0.0049183215,
-0.0830022916,
0.003044571,
0.0181755777,
-0.0630298778,
-0.0263368506,
-0.0258877221,
0.0078854663,
-0.0109176878,
0.0261284448,
0.0281862989,
-0.0585581698,
0.014558929,
0.0270180218,
-0.0931828097,
-0.0078711743,
0.002777392,
-0.0327140763,
0.0214441959,
0.073091656,
-0.002153442,
0.0085840933,
0.0387568474,
0.043009486,
-0.0349623524,
-0.0101644574,
0.0065824171,
0.0687399656,
-0.0016013986,
0.0117165465,
-0.0401388146,
0.043963775,
0.0302262679,
0.029850103,
0.0217052028,
0.0169275589,
0.0229176637,
-0.0087912977,
-0.0554741062,
0.0281968806,
-0.023833286,
0.0716553256,
0.0476701483,
-0.0390615873,
-0.0322664082,
-0.0396172702,
-0.0384033099,
-0.1010667682,
-0.0275692102,
0.0150342518,
-0.063242197,
0.0026348419,
-0.0958006158,
-0.0608754456,
0.0227373056,
-0.0474828519,
0.0127024679,
-0.0236126818,
0.0242311805,
-0.0004962427,
-0.018275382,
-0.0023442525,
-0.0238502305,
0.0036728189,
-0.0730434954,
-0.0303402077,
0.0360998921,
-0.0198328178,
-0.0085016191,
0.0302285794,
-0.058183942,
-0.0463886447,
-0.0215974897,
0.0772098228,
0.0168462452,
0.0613799207,
0.0221902467,
-0.0257250164,
0.0338998958,
-0.015465267,
0.020193493,
0.0370398797,
0.010471981,
0.0377314799,
-0.0310577564,
0.0082590403,
-0.0686748996,
0.0449909791,
-0.0161905084,
0.0314752348,
-0.0319964699,
-0.0447088853,
0.0109080961,
0.0369532593,
-0.0365533419,
-0.0228969194,
0.0199780632,
-0.0158596225,
-0.0189930312,
-0.0291645024,
-0.0262973085,
-0.0348851159,
0.0429217443,
-0.0140137952,
-0.0113368658,
0.0000364755,
0.051160533,
-0.0083186049,
0.0324711688,
-0.0486049987,
0.0307379086,
-0.0326376669,
-0.0063520214,
-0.0518321097,
-0.0087379524,
-0.0533492118,
-0.0274553616,
-0.0281151664,
0.0130458446,
0.0072088875,
0.0408587642,
0.0108298967,
-0.000672501,
0.0207963418,
0.0397735313,
-0.0431377701,
0.0344706848,
-0.0722896606,
0.0204813611,
0.0605101734,
-0.0329982974,
0.085560523,
0.0028832832,
-0.0116832172,
-0.0495009497,
0.0409214459,
0.0302575491,
-0.0096755065,
-0.0446528196,
0.034807276,
0.0366866477,
-0.0104350727,
0.078249231,
0.0008528959,
-0.0017924964,
0.0264542866,
-0.0124886278,
-0.0449694917,
-0.0202278234,
-0.026800232,
0.0030470991,
-0.0098916469,
-0.0268855449,
-0.0592880994,
-0.0087329485,
0.0228421558,
0.0460144952,
0.0258757789,
-0.0395225659,
0.0377147384,
0.0102031091,
-0.0097282119,
-0.0045513092,
-0.0621191189,
-0.0272613112,
-0.0197740328,
0.0069140634,
-0.0360954776,
-5.749962943e-33,
-0.0606806651,
-0.0105351564,
-0.0072683678,
-0.0141781019,
-0.0345897898,
0.0166026112,
-0.0614748448,
-0.013279926,
0.0164366309,
0.0069316477,
-0.0045699081,
-0.012249005,
0.005898234,
0.0455878563,
0.0185698941,
-0.0019390609,
0.0525504649,
-0.0057192422,
-0.0594877489,
0.0537715703,
0.0282483939,
-0.0250053778,
0.0181903169,
-0.0398739912,
0.0488578491,
-0.0437468775,
-0.0125965662,
-0.015161071,
0.0293150824,
0.0501208715,
-0.0008280122,
0.0114221014,
0.0184078105,
-0.0425861552,
-0.0507359393,
0.0029961485,
-0.0602688156,
-0.0178222694,
0.0432388745,
-0.0466207638,
-0.0461830422,
-0.0534321479,
0.0275626276,
-0.0146917645,
-0.0157867279,
-0.0456104018,
0.0581003092,
-0.0470640995,
-0.0132815139,
-0.068342872,
-0.0491892509,
0.0273501854,
-0.0375982672,
-0.0530172139,
0.0231369995,
0.03916784,
-0.0035478463,
0.0008333115,
-0.013657989,
0.0292504858,
0.0530707985,
0.0449863262,
0.0647090748,
0.0154942637,
-0.0037627402,
0.0436176285,
-0.0324119404,
0.0191630293,
-0.036915902,
0.0182576887,
-0.0152013032,
0.0125720622,
0.0497491062,
0.0092001399,
0.026394425,
0.0601259954,
-0.0330526009,
0.0784030557,
-0.0053388774,
0.021603236,
0.0230338592,
-0.0287309326,
-0.0244671106,
0.0001870013,
-0.0408385061,
0.0193887539,
-0.0091119641,
0.0005023645,
-0.0020813765,
0.0071800482,
-0.0540076718,
-0.0314408615,
0.0010992532,
-0.0251584388,
0.0182619728,
0.0083590373,
-0.0103941727,
0.0253932569,
-0.012875109,
-0.0187452771,
-0.0425494127,
0.0315527171,
0.0191518106,
-0.0085338559,
0.0001963372,
0.020708181,
0.0418292768,
-0.0073408466,
-0.0225135572,
0.0127405692,
-0.0033950347,
0.0209763609,
-0.0507114753,
0.0038468207,
-0.0146434251,
0.0170495138,
0.0073933331,
0.0496691056,
-0.0186958294,
-0.0086004585,
-0.0113835195,
0.0108488118,
0.0132413823,
0.0334551372,
-0.0129313478,
0.0566712171,
-0.0265362021,
0.0288140941,
0.0042424412,
-0.0242694728,
0.0083333738,
0.0064133271,
2.388e-7,
0.0359653123,
0.0559011996,
0.0665655807,
0.0067278366,
-0.0280195847,
0.0003898986,
-0.0084239384,
-0.0088394657,
0.0345784128,
-0.0115229161,
0.0301410649,
0.0385297015,
0.0598281659,
0.0257666595,
-0.0750789717,
-0.0226041321,
-0.0563543849,
-0.0113464249,
-0.0249619875,
-0.0322351828,
0.0717375427,
0.0263160262,
-0.0290016364,
0.0184159223,
-0.0320445858,
-0.004511137,
0.0205048807,
-0.0113527263,
-0.0352289826,
0.0389066897,
0.0613855608,
0.0182681717,
-0.0234274939,
-0.0112695629,
-0.01227968,
-0.0258514062,
0.068405062,
0.0662913844,
0.0325027443,
0.0009331609,
0.0035976178,
-0.0306186564,
0.024104571,
0.0178560186,
0.0515594967,
-0.0689827576,
0.032587897,
-0.0275114328,
-0.0486389808,
0.0120182652,
-0.0267453846,
0.002620578,
-0.0259959884,
0.0587755032,
-0.0102183586,
-0.0166197624,
0.0205786973,
-0.0572680198,
-0.0489612892,
0.0409452319,
0.0101386234,
-0.0326989889,
-0.0241947267,
0.0069777085,
-0.0290811881,
-0.0839779377,
-0.0220683906,
2.280374322e-34,
0.086140871,
-0.0392683633,
-0.0217327531,
-0.0160706956,
0.0286086407,
-0.0132028554,
-0.0483896136,
0.0061113546,
0.008088381,
-0.0772133917,
0.0037725051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09182v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09182v2 | ContraDoc: Understanding Self-Contradictions in Documents with Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T18:23:17 | 2024-04-12T21:06:43 | Jierui Li, Vipul Raheja, Dhruv Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent times, large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on various document-level tasks such as document classification,
summarization, and question-answering. However, research on understanding their
capabilities on the task of self-contradictions in long documents has been very
limited. In this work, we introduce ContraDoc, the first human-annotated
dataset to study self-contradictions in long documents across multiple domains,
varying document lengths, self-contradictions types, and scope. We then analyze
the current capabilities of four state-of-the-art open-source and commercially
available LLMs: GPT3.5, GPT4, PaLM2, and LLaMAv2 on this dataset. While GPT4
performs the best and can outperform humans on this task, we find that it is
still unreliable and struggles with self-contradictions that require more
nuance and context. We release the dataset and all the code associated with the
experiments (https://github.com/ddhruvkr/CONTRADOC). | [
0.0544486716,
0.0811981559,
0.0057056905,
0.05514507,
-0.0442026742,
0.0330881104,
0.0200746525,
-0.0171881299,
0.0349164046,
-0.0274118669,
-0.0117900362,
0.0050313529,
0.0102061313,
0.0059727388,
0.0151644936,
-0.0230547469,
0.0573900342,
-0.0131142875,
0.0279840194,
-0.0254840404,
0.0249827914,
0.0150545081,
0.0275075566,
-0.0115656164,
-0.0223172791,
-0.053919211,
0.0154407304,
0.0095716808,
-0.000159836,
-0.0137131186,
0.0048878198,
0.0474555641,
-0.0028823782,
0.1548805237,
0.0000016472,
-0.0529887192,
-0.0289515462,
0.001792111,
-0.0471270271,
0.0465218201,
0.0371649675,
-0.0381866619,
-0.0166061707,
0.0038851248,
-0.023801377,
0.0077536874,
-0.0040106038,
0.0809605047,
0.0871905908,
0.0657099634,
0.0122400001,
-0.0181369837,
-0.0029154946,
-0.0357396901,
-0.0083669852,
0.0056219688,
0.0097633563,
-0.0009510225,
0.0137908887,
0.0243475642,
-0.0001894616,
0.0282150321,
0.0568859689,
-0.0314069912,
-0.0619479753,
0.0049708653,
-0.0790512115,
0.0203979556,
0.0445059054,
0.0528217591,
0.0162661131,
-0.0365448445,
0.0168293566,
0.0230106134,
-0.0012617968,
-0.0127861146,
-0.0336253904,
0.0138655314,
-0.0039030591,
0.0372737013,
0.034396138,
0.0177367069,
0.0119944327,
-0.0076325564,
-0.0359572582,
0.0269144233,
-0.0067464891,
-0.0325858593,
0.0098671271,
-0.002518086,
-0.0454091132,
-0.0505320393,
0.0034639998,
0.0241105799,
-0.0018224603,
-0.0272303801,
-0.0774722323,
-0.0411826894,
0.0829101801,
-0.0638064668,
0.0025349655,
-0.0211365186,
-0.0152605707,
0.0890133977,
-0.0388698503,
0.058129251,
-0.0341259427,
0.0433488078,
-0.0179986116,
-0.0261077061,
-0.0019977281,
-0.0201864652,
-0.0396863855,
-0.0011957397,
-0.0376858003,
-0.0220622849,
0.0001188273,
0.0179485045,
-0.0122439759,
0.0143545521,
-0.0171605535,
-0.0200836398,
0.0088095572,
-0.0480290912,
-0.0164195895,
-0.002052245,
-0.0330203325,
0.0029246756,
-0.0158037599,
-0.0539201722,
-0.0312334504,
0.0186892189,
-0.0468655936,
-0.0295224693,
0.0184113029,
0.039821431,
-0.0099992985,
-0.0246863067,
-0.0094215553,
0.0253828578,
-0.0297735482,
-0.1035408899,
-0.0116579402,
-0.0743028075,
0.027685307,
-0.0188663565,
-0.0133111095,
-0.0347414762,
0.0013773303,
0.0058756471,
0.0095012607,
0.0793530419,
-0.0242652688,
-0.0165990237,
0.0914921686,
0.0089723216,
0.0133375078,
0.0459166653,
0.0036019585,
-0.0053731105,
0.0616574138,
0.0375905074,
-0.0097810682,
0.0060580997,
0.0245880503,
0.015932912,
-0.0062846467,
0.0327976868,
-0.0138245178,
0.022667909,
0.009923907,
0.0462969095,
-0.0013975019,
-0.0947851464,
0.0315031856,
0.0163484514,
0.0021267999,
-0.0005791835,
-0.0090416651,
0.0167925935,
0.0402177423,
0.0360027514,
-0.0512430854,
0.0157657284,
-0.0256176107,
0.0204826016,
0.0671528652,
0.0181767158,
-0.0285791811,
-0.0508327931,
-0.0196475517,
-0.0127678635,
-0.0201306902,
-0.0171353053,
0.0329048187,
0.0021043096,
-0.0080198245,
0.0069586365,
-0.0031087562,
-0.0641963333,
-0.0257464275,
-0.0336959064,
0.0462637991,
0.0347390957,
0.0617532358,
-0.0774495974,
-0.0319518745,
-0.0275933146,
0.0301240142,
0.0657427832,
0.0499634072,
0.0069719655,
-0.0207667816,
-0.0207364056,
0.0052741203,
-0.0830929428,
0.0375064723,
-0.0245168395,
0.0273614209,
0.0164556298,
0.0218319222,
-0.0611729249,
-0.0039674253,
0.0335481502,
-0.0246089324,
-0.0276710037,
-0.0059595127,
0.0020958798,
-0.0024589265,
0.0077788946,
-0.0211705938,
0.0248339903,
0.0353829935,
-0.0438887961,
-0.0309080053,
-0.0302611012,
0.0009123979,
-0.0453619733,
0.0797747299,
-0.0515064374,
-0.0698489696,
0.0446445495,
-0.0499454401,
-0.0354368202,
0.0226282496,
-0.0358312055,
-0.0025178392,
-0.038148541,
0.0103373025,
0.0136789642,
0.0477471165,
-0.0142792128,
0.0324045457,
-0.0053911558,
0.0158911664,
0.0072612255,
0.0030016403,
0.0521168225,
-0.0421854258,
-0.015254735,
0.0058651641,
0.0140441488,
0.0074179373,
0.0136885215,
0.0029556672,
-0.0157438759,
-0.0719485432,
-0.0720156878,
-0.0066028065,
-0.0228509884,
0.0203285608,
0.0236172322,
-0.0383837149,
-0.0159036741,
-0.0233683921,
0.0092251273,
-0.0345564112,
0.0390408337,
0.0107550193,
0.0549484082,
-0.0118291825,
0.0252578463,
-0.0513346121,
-0.0321524926,
-0.0199680533,
0.024911331,
-0.0185954422,
0.0124115357,
-0.0138836643,
-0.0331346914,
-0.0195328798,
0.0175352264,
-0.0253137816,
-0.0162483174,
0.0197117962,
-0.0256756656,
0.0685771182,
0.0704764798,
0.0309421159,
0.0399624929,
0.0509339161,
-0.011076713,
-0.0339479893,
0.0064728945,
-0.005157677,
0.045773495,
-0.0097243683,
-0.0117201312,
0.0264036991,
0.0522152968,
-0.0177372135,
-0.0034413107,
-0.0071381577,
0.0499219,
-0.0131545067,
0.0022541611,
0.0189004801,
-0.0250340588,
-0.0138693955,
0.0143596092,
-0.0113095883,
-0.0225858968,
0.0596682653,
-0.043939881,
0.0149351498,
-0.0401652493,
-0.0129263159,
-0.0705038235,
0.072922349,
-0.0092570176,
-0.031445235,
0.0253128093,
0.0196760446,
0.0101443911,
-0.0027149317,
0.03077792,
-0.0176516473,
0.0461990684,
-0.0138734411,
0.0274577197,
-0.0399459265,
-0.0569077022,
-0.0115068471,
-0.0861729085,
-0.0315130204,
-0.0203494262,
-0.0265003927,
-0.0005378808,
-0.0408201367,
-0.0262994692,
-0.0079161283,
0.072208941,
-0.0390189886,
-0.0221459791,
-0.0058655767,
0.0430717953,
0.0555016547,
0.0514873974,
0.0806628466,
-0.0425707921,
-0.0048584854,
0.0461170673,
0.0156239048,
0.0034238498,
0.0124403415,
-0.0304271076,
-0.0370716378,
-0.0246710852,
0.0000656057,
-0.0625756308,
0.0166984256,
-0.0599104092,
-0.0007326172,
0.1038929373,
0.0395297408,
-0.0060305703,
-0.0189844836,
-0.06860324,
0.0338181295,
0.0246882886,
0.019145539,
-0.0791243762,
-0.0398666188,
-0.0035235872,
0.0195329264,
0.0071530649,
-0.0140558984,
-0.0076923948,
-0.0731717125,
0.0478221811,
0.0129866153,
-0.0379952714,
-0.0230638906,
-0.0222740714,
-0.021589594,
-0.0104962969,
0.0046539949,
0.0011811226,
-0.0129084047,
0.0041543632,
-0.0353061892,
-0.0033258332,
0.0178310238,
0.0216224585,
-0.0055149505,
0.0265690517,
0.0019031755,
0.0429552794,
0.0154805668,
-0.0103475368,
0.072620742,
-0.0364335664,
-0.0549723059,
-0.0095638437,
0.0407159105,
-0.0067166514,
0.0021524103,
-0.0343281589,
0.0443699323,
-0.049734693,
-0.0008676366,
0.0099692261,
0.0605700612,
0.0144645944,
-0.0237578303,
-0.0655815229,
0.0120825665,
-0.0459367111,
0.0716575533,
0.0299419556,
0.0066859871,
-0.083221212,
-0.0178590491,
0.0097397054,
-0.0134496801,
0.0166707728,
-0.0012679445,
0.0529816039,
0.0371800885,
-0.0546976291,
-0.0569227301,
-0.0169415921,
0.0069621364,
-0.0488307104,
0.0108754197,
-0.0446866788,
-0.0280040372,
-0.0348405503,
0.0126495874,
-0.0292429756,
0.0207474828,
-0.0462836251,
0.0369288325,
0.0253862757,
0.0016190679,
0.0079505583,
0.0474228673,
-0.094922021,
-0.0565258749,
0.0035283726,
0.0192371197,
0.0192462802,
0.0608227365,
-0.0254784524,
-0.0161553267,
-0.0215854105,
0.0665830076,
-0.0458035357,
0.0341653004,
0.04983918,
0.0060299532,
0.0011924957,
0.0591264702,
-0.0065804152,
0.003600714,
-0.0071022776,
-0.0174127854,
-0.0345272608,
-0.0560742691,
0.0049504186,
0.0184118971,
0.0020293465,
0.0249541029,
0.0561068207,
-0.0409097597,
0.0241664816,
-0.018707037,
-0.0271072332,
-0.0109252371,
0.0028117921,
-0.0035614243,
-0.0389552191,
-0.0229789186,
0.0545183308,
-0.0117112715,
0.0241862833,
-0.015300951,
0.0132530164,
0.0389188826,
0.0018660163,
-0.0269315764,
-0.0421049893,
-0.0175014045,
0.0323955305,
-0.0286048315,
0.0507644154,
-0.0105602052,
0.0589842908,
0.0501094833,
-0.0278064348,
-0.0017981468,
0.0309903249,
-0.0705687329,
0.002535016,
-0.0081569431,
0.0065352409,
0.0268236808,
-0.0135444244,
0.0563271232,
-0.0088491309,
-0.0281163715,
-0.042625986,
0.0015610926,
0.0332229882,
0.0138599807,
0.0027690777,
0.0282396004,
-0.0221610945,
0.0417324789,
0.0604303703,
0.0342893787,
0.0097577833,
0.0634426251,
0.0039438661,
-0.032245215,
-0.0474333055,
-0.0201801918,
0.0170089472,
-0.0104551567,
-0.0082542347,
-0.0620770976,
-0.0558240116,
0.040032953,
0.0594665669,
0.0002261023,
0.0028583596,
-0.0193434805,
0.0574011691,
-0.0019443987,
-0.0088204341,
-0.0180866811,
0.0452207625,
0.0186803266,
-0.0266951155,
0.0188469514,
-5.407065731e-33,
-0.0216315221,
-0.0301752295,
-0.0125562735,
-0.0160695761,
-0.0060481192,
-0.0065754289,
-0.0456026047,
-0.0163842812,
-0.0136683825,
0.05823984,
-0.0225651395,
0.0509406589,
0.0049727922,
0.0137276305,
0.0033723873,
0.0062632929,
0.0478667542,
0.000154454,
-0.0253163688,
-0.0045118625,
0.0495740883,
-0.0272372607,
0.0099336496,
-0.0626516491,
0.0309631359,
-0.0212449711,
-0.0190403759,
0.0383479595,
-0.0480658226,
0.0554487444,
-0.0470620021,
0.008442875,
0.0248471648,
-0.009052298,
-0.0190621559,
-0.0242650285,
-0.074877888,
-0.0386326686,
-0.0147095658,
-0.027313821,
-0.056170553,
-0.0316087343,
0.0392240696,
-0.0003705363,
0.0041656038,
-0.0474237874,
0.0259199943,
-0.0138418535,
0.0198223181,
0.0003932728,
-0.060313575,
0.0526854731,
-0.018047763,
-0.0206538215,
0.0129880514,
-0.0387613736,
0.008417272,
0.0181702822,
-0.0569894575,
-0.0199780613,
0.0070013599,
-0.0011578196,
0.0092847934,
-0.0401561409,
0.0014434056,
0.0347281136,
-0.0068110768,
0.0117451185,
-0.0290128384,
-0.0166004431,
0.003454292,
0.0154905394,
0.0734002888,
0.0746601075,
0.0411414653,
0.0028513984,
-0.0449427553,
0.0163508411,
-0.0149278101,
0.0014024663,
0.0140073337,
-0.007886271,
0.0035838464,
0.0150021054,
-0.0233151689,
-0.017753588,
-0.0136396466,
0.0186657887,
0.0184410214,
0.0214358643,
-0.0218488649,
-0.0472733416,
0.0104908459,
-0.0476662144,
-0.0334618352,
0.0349131152,
-0.0248505212,
0.0004666428,
0.0551887862,
0.0154591426,
-0.0626935586,
0.0466987826,
0.0211896412,
0.0206977632,
-0.0080066733,
-0.013180675,
0.0645942315,
-0.0176258832,
-0.0800828561,
0.029675521,
0.0130766463,
0.0553545617,
-0.0300327782,
-0.0464469455,
0.0355147123,
-0.0037072112,
0.0149037456,
0.0560674891,
-0.0009018157,
0.0048690634,
-0.0565899536,
0.0741908699,
0.0073800655,
0.0226933341,
0.0155235901,
0.0097785732,
-0.0261992961,
0.0529474244,
-0.026916096,
-0.0652514398,
0.0396176949,
0.0162030254,
2.061e-7,
0.0223685279,
0.0399174057,
0.086948745,
-0.0196982641,
0.0431433134,
0.0516314916,
-0.020212438,
0.0251227953,
-0.0440902971,
0.0041116839,
-0.0194814764,
0.0638813823,
0.085667111,
0.0373638049,
-0.0300380979,
0.068555437,
-0.0736938268,
-0.0299409218,
-0.0577097125,
-0.0369101092,
0.0547682233,
0.1148788482,
0.0265649762,
-0.012530718,
-0.0153671168,
-0.0584635325,
0.0717540756,
0.0259935837,
-0.0167135913,
0.0095795728,
0.0312328469,
-0.0161520056,
-0.0075223278,
-0.0328953005,
-0.0013807641,
0.0119794626,
0.0313799158,
0.0616691075,
0.0293585695,
-0.0190847367,
-0.0084562982,
-0.033138141,
-0.0074592172,
-0.0754256919,
0.088177748,
-0.0395417958,
-0.0223827772,
-0.0423201099,
0.006790143,
-0.0278144348,
0.0771160573,
-0.0129630556,
-0.024094956,
0.035932079,
0.0162755903,
-0.0105575845,
0.0177210364,
-0.0879398584,
-0.0104682567,
-0.0078404956,
-0.0441534072,
0.042826429,
-0.0380716585,
0.0726862252,
0.0569168739,
0.0005279125,
0.0194560792,
1.82258218e-34,
0.0765274391,
-0.040402364,
-0.0126953423,
-0.0405541733,
0.0211638492,
-0.01133906,
-0.0104846209,
0.0025579606,
-0.0048442031,
-0.047984574,
0.0068306164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09180v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09180v1 | PEARL: Personalizing Large Language Model Writing Assistants with Generation-Calibrated Retrievers | 2023-11-15T18:19:58 | 2023-11-15T18:19:58 | Sheshera Mysore, Zhuoran Lu, Mengting Wan, Longqi Yang, Steve Menezes, Tina Baghaee, Emmanuel Barajas Gonzalez, Jennifer Neville, Tara Safavi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | Powerful large language models have facilitated the development of writing
assistants that promise to significantly improve the quality and efficiency of
composition and communication. However, a barrier to effective assistance is
the lack of personalization in LLM outputs to the author's communication style
and specialized knowledge. In this paper, we address this challenge by
proposing PEARL, a retrieval-augmented LLM writing assistant personalized with
a generation-calibrated retriever. Our retriever is trained to select historic
user-authored documents for prompt augmentation, such that they are likely to
best personalize LLM generations for a user request. We propose two key
novelties for training our retriever: 1) A training data selection method that
identifies user requests likely to benefit from personalization and documents
that provide that benefit; and 2) A scale-calibrating KL-divergence objective
that ensures that our retriever closely tracks the benefit of a document for
personalized generation. We demonstrate the effectiveness of PEARL in
generating personalized workplace social media posts and Reddit comments.
Finally, we showcase the potential of a generation-calibrated retriever to
double as a performance predictor and further improve low-quality generations
via LLM chaining. | [
0.0730463639,
0.0701813102,
0.0035067142,
0.0146769593,
-0.035296943,
-0.0184040312,
0.0186440852,
0.0343052931,
0.0233954675,
-0.0483064279,
-0.0293772463,
-0.0253997296,
-0.0547675043,
0.0261670072,
0.0066293776,
-0.0254548583,
0.0201488063,
-0.0061603119,
0.0375469625,
-0.0059903348,
0.0280056782,
0.0341266915,
0.0243023224,
0.0386234336,
-0.0091864178,
-0.0370602533,
0.0252145007,
0.0348281525,
-0.0149668865,
-0.0005249637,
0.0423979759,
0.0643890426,
0.038641464,
0.0319857933,
0.0000017659,
-0.0381004885,
-0.0075284285,
-0.0226636603,
-0.0120221488,
-0.0244272016,
0.0668567941,
-0.0136710089,
-0.0178112108,
0.0190986507,
-0.0406516865,
0.0331684723,
0.0080063157,
0.037040893,
0.0510004126,
0.1106686518,
-0.0002745651,
-0.0109608928,
0.0331887901,
-0.0383952856,
0.045845326,
-0.0260276143,
-0.0032877859,
-0.0155615769,
-0.0078480812,
0.0446149744,
0.0193252433,
0.0574960597,
0.0015530192,
-0.0929093435,
0.0903102309,
0.0071769794,
0.0147388522,
0.036903739,
-0.0007483702,
0.0297428872,
0.0573777594,
-0.0048947753,
0.0084230788,
-0.0049004219,
0.002580747,
0.0005724995,
-0.0554900169,
-0.0068433676,
-0.0236057062,
-0.0124440156,
0.0001400608,
-0.021220874,
0.0103304265,
0.0096247494,
0.0340393633,
0.0410630703,
0.0093390681,
-0.0297873262,
-0.0265370309,
0.0188736524,
0.0505980141,
-0.0432553962,
0.0332316719,
0.0349790677,
-0.0398198105,
-0.0005488492,
-0.0680283532,
-0.0455818363,
0.0129410261,
-0.0142545085,
0.1058705524,
-0.0151276439,
0.0192569122,
0.0182402711,
0.0032506972,
0.0081693539,
-0.0233870875,
-0.0381615907,
-0.0286393445,
0.0164832342,
-0.0419891812,
-0.0271152593,
-0.0139348628,
0.0226458926,
-0.0121401343,
-0.0113953631,
-0.0413703322,
0.0437158048,
0.0206695348,
0.0022223159,
0.0153671792,
0.0369721577,
-0.0644971132,
-0.0158897042,
-0.0281818043,
0.0090908268,
-0.0217632595,
-0.0046533071,
0.0240187254,
-0.0097268131,
0.0099162618,
0.0178821925,
0.0436952524,
-0.0198573172,
-0.0227369294,
-0.0027165026,
-0.0349160358,
-0.0479028337,
-0.0710321739,
-0.0284375548,
0.0098083308,
-0.0395594761,
-0.0150759649,
-0.0611175522,
0.0407757871,
0.0081618596,
-0.0388087966,
-0.0573597476,
-0.01875237,
0.0196767021,
-0.0118650291,
-0.0132611729,
0.0038836638,
0.0119151622,
0.0623975694,
-0.0103168562,
0.0024271584,
0.0361802205,
0.0369414538,
0.0339676179,
0.0537904687,
0.0139242401,
0.0209840331,
0.0360613279,
-0.0162753034,
0.0169170685,
-0.0090441303,
-0.0189266652,
-0.0261960421,
0.0365241952,
0.0344820954,
0.0385070443,
-0.0127201742,
0.0227818247,
0.0909172967,
0.0266439486,
0.0610039458,
0.0454296395,
0.053680297,
0.022211777,
-0.0068021105,
0.0207599774,
-0.0026352711,
0.0430224054,
-0.0147652347,
-0.00471236,
0.0263737924,
-0.0132404258,
-0.0295316335,
-0.0375786461,
0.0115982611,
-0.0020558487,
-0.0422332734,
-0.02726366,
0.019121429,
0.0186210684,
-0.0537007973,
0.0391965918,
0.0010853766,
-0.0820739567,
0.0369890966,
-0.0194673184,
0.0460892171,
0.1058631539,
0.059450686,
-0.0099123036,
0.003731393,
-0.0351511538,
0.0093020704,
0.0524282418,
0.0302339755,
-0.0077943881,
-0.0151617443,
-0.0468669832,
-0.0343851224,
-0.0260537788,
0.0101949377,
0.0038939726,
0.042645935,
0.0212045535,
0.047044266,
-0.031254787,
-0.0403079242,
0.0307895392,
-0.0592800081,
-0.0464677811,
0.0199792907,
-0.0012692424,
0.008219542,
0.046694383,
-0.008113822,
0.0004711527,
0.0117798503,
-0.0561154298,
-0.0159500055,
0.0149164861,
-0.0326787084,
-0.0060593975,
0.0100472374,
-0.0040258276,
0.0105441455,
0.0003225523,
-0.0393282361,
-0.0420454852,
0.0276313368,
-0.0158525109,
0.0552994721,
-0.0617638938,
-0.0116143711,
-0.0029694661,
-0.0385846831,
-0.0295315962,
0.0430853926,
-0.0123767024,
-0.0172474906,
-0.0112035843,
0.0186732635,
-0.017977044,
-0.0302963927,
-0.0122289211,
-0.0263771322,
0.0313573591,
0.0349673145,
0.0450387038,
-0.0113985762,
-0.0515432805,
-0.0760868117,
-0.0764484629,
0.0234793685,
-0.0451927036,
0.016757153,
0.0058966703,
0.014808706,
-0.0018708168,
-0.0144549143,
-0.0506515093,
0.0061872168,
0.0317545868,
0.0118424632,
0.0481125042,
0.0056415768,
0.0272505153,
-0.0468976311,
-0.014116318,
0.0149326175,
0.015736388,
0.0425452366,
0.0204623919,
-0.0587508008,
0.0189862568,
-0.0485109054,
-0.0060678087,
-0.0233916435,
0.0006566099,
0.0227863695,
-0.0368227288,
0.0450562499,
0.0749983266,
0.0287918132,
0.0407592803,
0.0101755178,
0.0216938592,
-0.0465466604,
0.0001459988,
-0.0273993779,
-0.0281109698,
-0.0064977133,
-0.0153457988,
0.0438752882,
0.0129744941,
0.000019871,
-0.0072197476,
-0.0474148169,
0.0275121108,
0.0261157472,
0.0028083269,
0.0131431194,
0.0081620337,
-0.024773024,
0.0265376568,
-0.0157586839,
-0.0709252506,
0.0471945964,
0.0036645636,
0.003054674,
-0.0117005687,
-0.0364512764,
-0.0451184586,
0.0557345003,
-0.0128063448,
0.0160802566,
-0.0318584815,
-0.0106495898,
-0.0413489789,
0.0103906151,
0.0345901772,
-0.0241002794,
0.0438851081,
-0.0224771108,
0.0282651503,
0.003577576,
-0.0411390252,
-0.0449322127,
-0.0158519652,
-0.0073145432,
-0.0115304403,
0.0158508942,
-0.0196841341,
-0.0535156205,
-0.0350520797,
0.001922407,
0.0503565446,
-0.0549266264,
-0.0200081263,
-0.0289135538,
0.0183915403,
0.0625062883,
-0.0188487154,
-0.0483636782,
-0.0462493338,
0.0012430928,
0.0447560214,
-0.0081979632,
-0.0117580323,
-0.0080568641,
-0.0180605967,
0.0262955595,
-0.0469730236,
-0.0367130637,
0.0066023213,
0.0484858155,
-0.041647613,
-0.0099743018,
0.1119876951,
0.0235335436,
-0.0867662802,
-0.0337936617,
-0.0243994556,
0.0385569669,
0.0071222018,
0.0543455034,
-0.0803593472,
-0.0130789429,
-0.0073364279,
0.0690502152,
0.0099631418,
-0.021126708,
-0.0315232091,
-0.0935921222,
0.0477820411,
0.0091006709,
-0.0068887114,
-0.0003542482,
-0.0333950482,
-0.0207852125,
0.0147373816,
0.0037195575,
0.0262045208,
-0.0415049978,
0.0029259976,
0.004488254,
0.0112934597,
-0.0517890528,
-0.0527335182,
-0.0401002094,
0.0151974615,
0.0553050824,
0.057699766,
0.0372033045,
-0.0470292494,
-0.0019635984,
0.0091753155,
0.0414760076,
-0.031927973,
0.0532007702,
-0.0283138789,
0.0295269266,
-0.0539167635,
0.0344804339,
-0.0010435872,
0.0274029225,
0.0148788746,
0.0104946084,
-0.030538097,
-0.0145123675,
-0.019427333,
0.0075227786,
0.0306493901,
0.0503130294,
0.0387094878,
-0.0643270165,
-0.0513275526,
-0.0552752465,
0.0396012664,
-0.0553633273,
0.0171678383,
-0.0196272582,
-0.0613805652,
0.0187620986,
-0.0996969938,
-0.0278044324,
-0.0055226916,
0.0264160838,
0.0184485707,
0.0277424231,
-0.0198646691,
-0.0596726425,
-0.0451587215,
0.0080306986,
-0.0329074413,
-0.0063173897,
-0.0870860219,
-0.0439785495,
0.0381279998,
-0.0514489859,
0.0133726196,
-0.0053489981,
-0.0837303624,
-0.0673588887,
-0.0062347474,
0.0477624834,
0.0169838872,
0.0655717328,
0.0082174754,
-0.0873525217,
0.0517525673,
0.0762923956,
0.0020772365,
0.0304066483,
0.006679968,
0.0110533191,
-0.0341657624,
0.0360009894,
-0.0643711165,
0.0064458973,
0.0180596523,
0.0299715027,
-0.0029366014,
-0.0776539296,
-0.0347971357,
0.0067250109,
-0.0214504357,
-0.019880902,
-0.0032091266,
-0.0536406972,
0.0200949647,
-0.0134300375,
-0.0145967193,
-0.0592632368,
-0.0157039668,
0.0080661811,
-0.0152288517,
-0.0116329249,
0.0227572005,
-0.0348190144,
0.0528604761,
-0.1084439754,
0.0175181888,
-0.0144036384,
0.0203189217,
0.0363318361,
0.011546256,
-0.0307326782,
0.0467822365,
0.0093024187,
0.0529989935,
0.0052885199,
0.0401776507,
0.0059598051,
0.0280178078,
-0.0025636854,
0.0274751615,
-0.093184121,
-0.0206008721,
0.0025749677,
0.0067113047,
0.0856006071,
-0.0259736218,
0.0945137143,
-0.0289211478,
0.0076479916,
-0.0273399744,
0.0578075461,
0.0407215878,
-0.0311166216,
-0.0198744964,
-0.0169818681,
-0.0090846978,
0.0282816589,
0.0755351484,
-0.0199172199,
0.0263186898,
-0.0171751827,
-0.0024951417,
-0.0426813439,
-0.0195312407,
0.0393077768,
0.0316394046,
0.0295487419,
-0.0265467502,
-0.0291607641,
-0.0304090958,
0.067813471,
-0.0316981226,
-0.0365353525,
-0.037215475,
0.0430989861,
0.0553505756,
-0.0222749654,
-0.0386663377,
-0.0720181987,
0.0001791161,
-0.0314092934,
-0.0282021519,
-0.003183532,
-6.036378019e-33,
-0.0117177153,
-0.0415602215,
-0.0107070748,
0.0503970794,
-0.029956013,
0.0193810854,
-0.032563135,
-0.0108420867,
0.0223975144,
-0.0179291032,
-0.063245818,
-0.0078289295,
0.0009359334,
0.0370398052,
0.0067931432,
0.0264764857,
0.0787472427,
-0.0133305006,
-0.0253755171,
0.0439362042,
0.0544091575,
0.0611636043,
0.0201726351,
-0.0616000555,
0.0517680459,
-0.057843592,
0.0005888744,
0.0281530079,
0.026993148,
0.0424717851,
-0.0001254402,
0.0541619025,
0.0049368148,
0.0032534502,
-0.0080208043,
0.0176966954,
-0.0448425636,
-0.0384838246,
0.0103061534,
-0.0157690626,
-0.0046720677,
-0.0584145337,
0.0377446599,
-0.0139482953,
-0.02498479,
-0.0045351228,
0.0572876371,
0.0198504068,
-0.0289864,
-0.0534912571,
-0.0521360449,
0.0111807361,
0.0230416674,
0.0005629985,
0.0039587831,
-0.0156021342,
0.018579388,
0.019784173,
-0.0605028607,
0.0228376985,
0.0175932068,
0.0321506076,
0.0305189677,
0.0382712036,
-0.025515141,
0.0482426323,
-0.0101744998,
0.0591554344,
-0.0101437978,
-0.0184182692,
0.0200217701,
0.0338082723,
0.0097080152,
0.0744195655,
-0.0014442611,
-0.0221550427,
-0.0175945349,
0.0674125776,
0.0450046025,
0.0006573079,
0.0236151163,
0.0141151408,
0.0148664527,
-0.0372457393,
-0.0185637865,
-0.0284684896,
-0.0166239664,
-0.0356497914,
0.0224005263,
0.0287182704,
-0.0275088549,
-0.060316924,
0.0180251859,
0.0002355161,
-0.0405137502,
0.0398917906,
-0.046516221,
0.0345120057,
0.0005015371,
-0.0132877342,
-0.0461235419,
-0.0097823841,
0.0206526872,
-0.0132198371,
-0.0158319082,
0.0249772277,
0.0301731601,
0.0068143341,
-0.0558564253,
0.0248338617,
-0.0197136588,
0.0500690602,
-0.0017501483,
-0.0100517869,
0.0164888352,
-0.0058775255,
-0.0080282874,
0.0683998689,
0.036069788,
0.0538452677,
-0.0330185704,
-0.0287624728,
0.0224167574,
0.0066490257,
-0.0197840147,
0.0198318027,
-0.0255308878,
0.0464321077,
0.0205444545,
-0.0362148508,
-0.0057319342,
-0.0390698947,
2.552e-7,
0.0308703594,
0.0601988398,
0.0138927707,
0.034989927,
0.0312067177,
0.0346449651,
0.0038597228,
0.0183374919,
0.0218901895,
0.0369818062,
0.0099602919,
0.0354322642,
0.0730702877,
0.0084522469,
-0.1137647778,
0.0215628278,
-0.0926888362,
0.0164786708,
-0.0638740957,
-0.0202980358,
0.0323781073,
0.0032326845,
0.0072741462,
-0.0279819984,
0.0020064493,
-0.0622825958,
0.0921580121,
-0.0319070816,
-0.016047297,
0.0156315509,
0.0729723498,
-0.0024195814,
-0.0073639997,
-0.0235995203,
-0.0518249199,
-0.001276112,
-0.0252889097,
0.096051313,
0.0023608329,
-0.0175629649,
0.0304072965,
0.0528406426,
-0.0016084086,
-0.037404228,
0.0475965366,
0.0512886979,
0.0103118597,
-0.0376701541,
-0.0106936228,
-0.0335540809,
0.0040716073,
-0.0431470014,
-0.0205162615,
0.0218636692,
0.0048224661,
-0.0091482531,
-0.0226562731,
-0.0485835746,
-0.0290492345,
-0.0034853793,
-0.0201074164,
-0.0365013964,
-0.0644593984,
0.0157825854,
-0.0174071342,
-0.0408049971,
0.0417322293,
2.259258587e-34,
0.0278006587,
0.0141402502,
0.0190501157,
0.0152788581,
0.0168155637,
0.0496890433,
0.0041816779,
0.0291451868,
0.0302164294,
-0.0649800226,
-0.0013103927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10768v1 | Memory Augmented Language Models through Mixture of Word Experts | 2023-11-15T18:19:56 | 2023-11-15T18:19:56 | Cicero Nogueira dos Santos, James Lee-Thorp, Isaac Noble, Chung-Ching Chang, David Uthus | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scaling up the number of parameters of language models has proven to be an
effective approach to improve performance. For dense models, increasing model
size proportionally increases the model's computation footprint. In this work,
we seek to aggressively decouple learning capacity and FLOPs through
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) style models with large knowledge-rich vocabulary
based routing functions and experts. Our proposed approach, dubbed Mixture of
Word Experts (MoWE), can be seen as a memory augmented model, where a large set
of word-specific experts play the role of a sparse memory. We demonstrate that
MoWE performs significantly better than the T5 family of models with similar
number of FLOPs in a variety of NLP tasks. Additionally, MoWE outperforms
regular MoE models on knowledge intensive tasks and has similar performance to
more complex memory augmented approaches that often require to invoke custom
mechanisms to search the sparse memory. | [
0.092729643,
0.0654704496,
-0.0002681577,
0.0190405212,
-0.0175739359,
-0.0151890367,
0.0181023125,
-0.0407167114,
-0.010786646,
-0.0760637745,
-0.036623884,
-0.0335696861,
-0.0057819188,
0.0129192732,
0.0257658605,
-0.0303875711,
0.0543192104,
-0.0403121971,
-0.021209985,
0.003544891,
0.0020946346,
0.0189443342,
0.0033233764,
0.0396902896,
-0.0128779672,
0.016086163,
-0.0155340573,
-0.0007119206,
-0.0351048447,
0.0069073751,
0.0079469085,
0.0737801641,
0.0367497653,
0.026838595,
0.0000021048,
0.0036107528,
-0.0238686651,
0.000844048,
-0.0257636327,
0.0278898794,
0.0512513369,
0.0257004015,
0.0043171304,
0.0149152027,
0.0068640849,
-0.0176059566,
0.0796829686,
0.0338078924,
0.0331808068,
0.0974263772,
-0.0072801216,
-0.0003810828,
0.0707797334,
-0.0302957278,
0.0498190373,
-0.0473464355,
0.0057504042,
0.0119540999,
0.0019966115,
0.0281126127,
-0.0203167144,
0.0577615798,
-0.006467714,
0.0452330895,
0.041264642,
0.0326209255,
0.0144060953,
-0.0192706101,
-0.0255815666,
0.0569298863,
-0.0421001762,
-0.0303135701,
-0.0085437652,
0.0181056671,
-0.0424670763,
0.0385983773,
-0.0133705446,
-0.0054658805,
0.0141110262,
0.0073986026,
0.0189468544,
0.0091310674,
0.0692074299,
0.0381225161,
-0.0552893505,
0.0265536997,
0.0366657451,
-0.0000966334,
-0.0126457503,
0.0035007889,
-0.0195404794,
0.00061525,
0.0195232239,
0.0253065079,
-0.000097679,
0.041191306,
-0.0346276425,
-0.0282853562,
0.018430898,
-0.0480845608,
0.0406406932,
0.0715786517,
-0.0086862054,
0.0666785464,
-0.0357587561,
-0.0060920096,
-0.0419307239,
-0.0045030648,
-0.030064512,
-0.0213675592,
-0.0399953239,
-0.0219081156,
-0.0299761686,
0.0451728813,
-0.025683159,
-0.0478229597,
-0.0105501954,
0.0273471978,
-0.0222923663,
-0.014622503,
0.0191189628,
0.0130789075,
-0.0163059849,
-0.0157732256,
-0.0281795841,
0.0311525743,
-0.0170942713,
-0.0107429447,
0.0013918867,
-0.0355343632,
-0.0048859082,
0.0107264267,
-0.002124165,
-0.0385999344,
0.0308346841,
0.0699048936,
-0.0233421531,
-0.0589896478,
-0.024864288,
0.0178075619,
-0.0096593844,
-0.0499991886,
-0.0091383588,
-0.0918789282,
0.0644673333,
0.0102887554,
0.0216008835,
-0.0411961749,
0.0143586779,
0.0477749221,
-0.0853159949,
0.061324399,
-0.0079598436,
-0.0134432064,
0.0190259367,
0.0169186182,
-0.0114036836,
0.0489258207,
0.0016020088,
-0.0161246099,
0.0338797569,
0.0115664396,
-0.0124137159,
0.0017772632,
0.0103904987,
-0.0123796994,
-0.0031039882,
0.0062312996,
0.0135075571,
0.014564991,
0.0444554724,
0.0892697498,
-0.0482879281,
-0.0232497733,
0.0401640758,
0.0395672731,
0.0113298818,
0.0428091027,
0.0401217379,
-0.0117841288,
-0.0027118856,
-0.0142258508,
-0.0385270976,
0.0220987704,
-0.0552060008,
0.0001494209,
0.0835680962,
0.0302741416,
-0.0426893607,
-0.0199028477,
-0.0185307562,
0.0041151764,
0.0024161318,
0.0324878134,
0.0332723521,
-0.01379159,
-0.031861268,
0.0660726503,
0.0357014425,
-0.0260406677,
-0.0050094915,
-0.039762143,
-0.0153333731,
0.0822998211,
0.0519010648,
-0.027599249,
-0.0233062841,
-0.0025930111,
-0.0362255499,
0.0241932645,
0.0410693362,
0.0054550818,
-0.0176545829,
-0.073353596,
-0.0038854117,
-0.0346489288,
0.0258359406,
0.0254824404,
0.0839594901,
0.0142703876,
0.0503468476,
-0.0188784581,
-0.0162205435,
0.0128182769,
-0.035229817,
0.0008931727,
0.0032179619,
-0.0046226326,
0.0028164044,
0.0047830846,
-0.0232619103,
0.0371952243,
0.005290994,
-0.0209049117,
-0.0229283925,
-0.0499670692,
-0.0923599601,
-0.0335513279,
0.039996691,
0.0332692154,
0.0375090688,
0.0095495423,
-0.0051311874,
-0.0522168949,
0.0139902839,
-0.0302066375,
0.0692279786,
-0.0625549704,
0.0009709385,
0.037506476,
0.021586312,
-0.0311158728,
0.07471852,
-0.0336745158,
0.0306723192,
-0.0035187257,
0.0651404932,
-0.0211411566,
-0.0128436266,
-0.0904221386,
-0.0118427007,
0.0143532539,
0.0482914262,
-0.0009211547,
-0.0252097752,
-0.0153677594,
-0.0729101002,
-0.1199951619,
0.0250426009,
-0.0239189044,
-0.0400843807,
0.0120972553,
0.0307564344,
0.0387298986,
0.0069306958,
-0.0098532112,
-0.0029135721,
-0.0258650389,
0.0445083044,
-0.0445594974,
0.0123776197,
-0.0139615629,
-0.046931237,
-0.0625661165,
-0.0060589057,
0.0448421873,
-0.0525750108,
-0.0424766019,
0.0091869151,
0.0005300962,
-0.0403528474,
0.0366729051,
-0.0083453283,
0.0016265716,
-0.0219441801,
-0.046851892,
0.0780006424,
0.0371033996,
0.0072784522,
0.042394463,
0.0646410212,
-0.0314608142,
-0.024002621,
0.047377158,
-0.0168169457,
-0.0103183724,
-0.0076463968,
0.0085178288,
-0.0509477407,
0.0540316664,
-0.0075612417,
-0.0250995234,
-0.0459786467,
-0.0325817466,
-0.0102240229,
-0.0071812985,
-0.0228585713,
0.012426272,
0.0095965611,
-0.0006993831,
-0.0521721877,
-0.0201272592,
0.0476828776,
-0.0051975562,
0.0089825075,
-0.038076669,
-0.0214281399,
-0.0334319212,
0.0220681019,
0.0112034529,
0.0331251808,
-0.0613586269,
0.0152289895,
-0.0134345666,
0.0032444678,
-0.0151977194,
-0.0375890173,
0.0342410207,
-0.0474667028,
0.0426736809,
0.0035752368,
-0.0223812386,
-0.0241806321,
-0.0173926707,
-0.0222547241,
0.0427206866,
0.0485323519,
-0.0308884066,
-0.0550562218,
0.0328797437,
0.0253275428,
0.0759440213,
0.0127873085,
0.0008078878,
-0.014008631,
0.0415143184,
0.0423660912,
0.0022788534,
0.0096742688,
-0.0255110376,
0.0128067825,
0.0413128659,
0.0426471941,
-0.0758380219,
-0.0284972992,
0.0334044248,
0.0244905408,
-0.0088579999,
-0.0371670164,
0.0107521946,
0.0206331201,
-0.0540209152,
-0.0298597943,
0.1077774838,
0.0258178748,
-0.060371615,
-0.0237528849,
0.0211366415,
0.0477140024,
0.0179016106,
0.0378797986,
-0.0325190164,
-0.0343401954,
-0.0001895108,
-0.0136829112,
0.003481172,
-0.0202099178,
-0.0197345242,
-0.095489122,
-0.0076634679,
0.0138275409,
-0.0216250047,
-0.0054269405,
-0.0528240763,
-0.0164124575,
-0.012069962,
0.0148812523,
-0.0172117893,
0.0158529785,
-0.0312272627,
0.0141370753,
0.0220440645,
-0.037314631,
0.0492546149,
-0.018778244,
0.0690796897,
0.0256680325,
-0.0183584355,
0.013993877,
-0.0034634154,
0.0115191815,
-0.0254084188,
0.0228157137,
-0.0270477608,
0.0463645235,
-0.0657710359,
-0.0085325632,
0.0057483488,
-0.0116303423,
-0.0326296873,
-0.0138428649,
-0.0445150584,
0.0721066222,
-0.0230755042,
0.0023894005,
-0.0254873373,
-0.0187159218,
-0.0114199854,
0.0836006552,
0.0002617756,
-0.0455076769,
-0.0219414309,
-0.019238919,
-0.0469724871,
-0.0049328958,
-0.0243099649,
0.0033329567,
0.028737912,
-0.0466200896,
-0.0347920582,
-0.0023749499,
0.0260659661,
0.0597220398,
0.0225205701,
0.047903832,
0.008871804,
0.0048281769,
-0.0598002821,
0.0319149382,
-0.0277285166,
-0.0077275801,
-0.0770722032,
-0.0355833322,
0.0478243493,
0.0091583859,
-0.0040469621,
0.0221053846,
-0.0992053375,
-0.0776621103,
-0.0030845548,
0.0590840243,
0.0209042858,
0.0425122678,
0.0029975264,
-0.0543230958,
0.0355783813,
0.0194046926,
-0.0636698529,
0.0091744522,
0.0136516206,
-0.0125366636,
0.0048400997,
0.0188671276,
-0.0257119909,
-0.0135680791,
0.0271598678,
0.0585533939,
-0.0183878709,
-0.0225803964,
-0.0052258461,
-0.0364123918,
0.014913179,
-0.0072135092,
0.0498093776,
-0.0354429036,
0.0015868827,
-0.0083749387,
-0.0125710154,
-0.034109775,
-0.0105609614,
0.0426903628,
-0.0163163953,
-0.0105046984,
-0.0087258294,
0.0561366193,
0.0066936468,
0.0085663293,
-0.0217181202,
-0.001682083,
-0.0599577427,
0.0092415018,
-0.0023117557,
-0.0432523675,
0.0072959657,
-0.0122096688,
0.0085668648,
-0.028203601,
0.0217227824,
-0.003898737,
-0.0459639579,
-0.0543972887,
0.02254037,
-0.0686107725,
-0.0731961727,
-0.0228870194,
0.0558836646,
0.0617100149,
-0.068303071,
0.0066610705,
-0.0428518318,
-0.0165246017,
-0.0269769356,
-0.0227708016,
0.0318537913,
-0.0013484668,
0.0272056498,
0.0497347414,
-0.0012878127,
0.0192044545,
0.0711797923,
0.0433752052,
0.0354902558,
0.0194683243,
-0.0124803111,
-0.0289779902,
-0.0024986633,
0.0136906374,
0.0639896765,
-0.0204401333,
0.0452244207,
-0.0344279222,
-0.0664321259,
-0.0123903127,
-0.0345689543,
-0.0021509926,
0.0062004519,
0.0376685001,
0.059465155,
-0.0170842633,
0.0198152121,
-0.0438981205,
0.0131310001,
0.0102372281,
-0.0040130573,
0.0021745018,
-7.044383527e-33,
-0.0036207524,
-0.0029631942,
0.0380650945,
-0.0589172132,
0.0250072405,
0.0085725319,
-0.0235107355,
0.0241283774,
-0.0571534224,
-0.0089067696,
-0.0349834673,
0.0184995271,
-0.0027177304,
0.055039797,
-0.0094555467,
0.030786939,
0.0600086488,
0.0096336128,
0.010503754,
0.0226671156,
0.0287982579,
0.0265525971,
0.0433741659,
-0.028962411,
-0.0090183131,
0.0171466507,
0.0193221159,
0.011169944,
0.0143254846,
0.0431652814,
-0.060713172,
0.035970185,
0.0176943187,
-0.0238083955,
-0.0242934767,
-0.0263946764,
-0.084134616,
-0.0115064243,
0.0453046784,
-0.0363937095,
0.0136426995,
-0.0320506655,
0.027277302,
0.0101973647,
0.0362159461,
-0.0257994123,
0.0125584397,
-0.003999535,
-0.0661237985,
0.0074107302,
-0.0299653336,
0.0405404717,
0.0149071217,
-0.0024889151,
0.0314005539,
-0.0576824993,
-0.0091842981,
-0.0054799085,
-0.0514074974,
-0.021587044,
-0.0084131258,
0.0995943025,
0.0504999347,
0.0427535139,
-0.0068684579,
0.0611921847,
-0.0003228909,
0.0221258812,
-0.0090914415,
-0.0052038217,
0.0498988107,
0.0488766916,
0.0353667513,
-0.0336244404,
0.0428467356,
-0.0056579681,
-0.0114212697,
-0.0128187947,
0.0095650312,
0.031780038,
0.092036739,
0.0224880632,
-0.0581986867,
-0.0209829658,
-0.0449859872,
0.0087094689,
-0.0661818385,
-0.0250994004,
0.0245128982,
0.0586548075,
-0.017269494,
-0.0093754204,
0.0379766189,
-0.038199123,
0.0099257296,
0.0303694475,
0.0011150391,
0.0098341294,
-0.0165800396,
0.0360482484,
-0.0771885663,
-0.0506153405,
-0.0007133292,
0.0033026855,
-0.0545675457,
-0.0033952757,
-0.0012224381,
0.012398582,
-0.0752140656,
-0.0243850052,
-0.0418189056,
0.0040933723,
-0.0124504333,
0.058357086,
0.0282622594,
0.0308479313,
-0.0146054942,
0.0288065821,
-0.0089524547,
-0.0261636898,
0.0198451839,
-0.0287607927,
0.0062955297,
0.0102093862,
-0.0202802233,
0.0076147178,
-0.0619798787,
-0.0128065404,
-0.0007896836,
-0.042579174,
-0.0012396049,
0.0302771032,
2.746e-7,
0.0163154528,
0.0427451506,
-0.0156896971,
-0.0296071637,
-0.0002003079,
-0.0072274487,
0.0100486474,
-0.0048869709,
0.0005304269,
-0.0404438078,
0.0105765508,
0.0696268007,
0.0212607067,
-0.0081186919,
-0.0902113393,
-0.0067823441,
-0.0351198651,
0.0346069932,
-0.0453054085,
-0.0317261852,
0.0175762009,
0.1433477998,
0.0236152932,
-0.0023579602,
-0.0245523881,
-0.0325646661,
0.0668688193,
-0.0060426276,
-0.0169083886,
0.0203997027,
0.075616546,
0.0650597811,
-0.0003502542,
0.0164633524,
-0.0423710123,
0.030051006,
0.0208545644,
0.0921209678,
-0.0250083134,
-0.0536152907,
0.0309158172,
-0.0172136556,
-0.0327132307,
-0.0527287088,
0.0686351582,
0.012261224,
-0.0043524276,
-0.0045262659,
0.0136345215,
0.0076119639,
0.0045528156,
-0.008150246,
-0.0454050377,
0.0083356304,
0.012770311,
-0.0133697437,
-0.0043878439,
-0.1033279672,
-0.022297373,
0.0267713703,
-0.035389252,
-0.0473878905,
-0.0437280871,
-0.0377727747,
0.0428024083,
-0.0486479662,
0.0022201578,
2.821700491e-34,
0.0691792965,
0.0078561641,
0.0171723813,
0.0342244804,
0.0321308151,
-0.0022111044,
-0.0135079967,
0.0056825955,
0.0002446631,
-0.1087557897,
-0.0287770107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09179v1 | SiRA: Sparse Mixture of Low Rank Adaptation | 2023-11-15T18:15:37 | 2023-11-15T18:15:37 | Yun Zhu, Nevan Wichers, Chu-Cheng Lin, Xinyi Wang, Tianlong Chen, Lei Shu, Han Lu, Canoee Liu, Liangchen Luo, Jindong Chen, Lei Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Parameter Efficient Tuning has been an prominent approach to adapt the Large
Language Model to downstream tasks. Most previous works considers adding the
dense trainable parameters, where all parameters are used to adapt certain
task. We found this less effective empirically using the example of LoRA that
introducing more trainable parameters does not help. Motivated by this we
investigate the importance of leveraging "sparse" computation and propose SiRA:
sparse mixture of low rank adaption. SiRA leverages the Sparse Mixture of
Expert(SMoE) to boost the performance of LoRA. Specifically it enforces the top
$k$ experts routing with a capacity limit restricting the maximum number of
tokens each expert can process. We propose a novel and simple expert dropout on
top of gating network to reduce the over-fitting issue. Through extensive
experiments, we verify SiRA performs better than LoRA and other mixture of
expert approaches across different single tasks and multitask settings. | [
0.0525579639,
0.0579243302,
-0.0134938974,
0.0179849658,
0.0174354054,
-0.0086063426,
0.0165294819,
0.0058095036,
-0.0269600544,
-0.0280197281,
-0.0742362216,
0.0128715597,
-0.0040400033,
0.0469593629,
0.059595421,
-0.0485476293,
0.0264874659,
-0.0607021004,
0.0140301557,
-0.0135077443,
0.0061931857,
0.0183592103,
-0.0044606882,
0.0457882248,
0.0155181447,
0.0202862378,
-0.0007362007,
0.009772311,
0.0157187283,
0.023293497,
-0.0021818134,
0.0625015497,
0.0332043022,
0.0380099714,
0.0000019206,
-0.0091387304,
-0.0039120815,
-0.0103473039,
-0.0307334382,
0.0136122229,
0.0282262638,
0.0325848311,
-0.0023515744,
0.0413091518,
-0.0129638929,
-0.0270851366,
0.0635221675,
0.0571953692,
0.0409490727,
0.1061105952,
-0.0111043751,
0.0001211427,
0.0433678813,
-0.0552630201,
-0.0178986005,
-0.0678377897,
0.011573582,
-0.0242814533,
-0.0217118654,
0.0115553541,
-0.0355428047,
0.0224081073,
0.0123636005,
-0.0111472365,
0.0143907545,
0.0228400808,
-0.0387625881,
-0.0057280101,
-0.0341876186,
0.0882203951,
-0.0850708112,
-0.0251185689,
0.0122144278,
-0.0005932567,
-0.0114554865,
-0.0181776918,
-0.0369153805,
-0.0440688469,
0.0348624401,
-0.0137055349,
0.0045324769,
-0.0332704335,
0.045807939,
0.0035902087,
-0.0468147472,
0.0253717434,
0.0491696261,
0.0046288739,
-0.0144916838,
-0.0123120127,
-0.0260101967,
-0.0449106656,
0.0322964303,
0.016185578,
-0.0713524595,
-0.0179086979,
-0.0470158979,
-0.0375722647,
-0.0121026598,
0.0217622649,
0.0492093563,
0.0640824512,
0.0052178493,
0.0354131423,
-0.0475571267,
-0.0006781006,
-0.0356035493,
0.0199647453,
-0.0538620725,
-0.0092346026,
-0.046687793,
-0.0011257014,
-0.0471736491,
0.0321845524,
-0.0492527112,
-0.0410192572,
-0.020141609,
0.0396309011,
-0.003661596,
-0.0177282933,
0.038623102,
0.0065734,
-0.043633379,
-0.0304903537,
0.0006177668,
0.0522897914,
-0.0444695801,
0.0561292805,
0.0116671994,
-0.0132436855,
-0.0091559906,
0.0343585536,
0.0152590144,
-0.0250167307,
0.0082249986,
0.0466381535,
-0.0433080457,
0.0082507841,
-0.0302910972,
0.0276521947,
0.0216727071,
-0.0679983944,
-0.0345796607,
-0.0590012036,
0.0429966114,
-0.0128304977,
0.033027444,
-0.0386332721,
-0.0430680998,
-0.0100232773,
-0.0693127513,
0.0351871513,
0.0056163296,
0.0005939092,
0.0453542247,
-0.0048832232,
-0.0164909884,
0.0602939799,
0.0095897233,
0.0052197962,
-0.0003882983,
0.0059764371,
-0.0134879826,
0.0315010548,
0.0049948492,
0.0241498798,
-0.0014572886,
-0.0014572925,
0.0177684594,
0.0288653132,
0.070907779,
0.0478659719,
-0.060684137,
0.0045451606,
0.0405914821,
0.045157183,
0.0434027463,
0.0613605753,
0.0415046811,
0.0071873632,
-0.0285561662,
-0.0030074746,
-0.0556392632,
0.0342990384,
-0.0216159392,
-0.014739505,
0.0768722519,
0.0707363933,
-0.0668682456,
-0.0071189823,
0.0240190085,
0.0132248662,
-0.0321707465,
0.0049900096,
0.0382209979,
-0.0270824172,
-0.0421369001,
0.0236894153,
0.0412773304,
-0.0274579395,
-0.0026752485,
-0.0675825402,
-0.0023094015,
0.0567127019,
0.0289250128,
-0.0251399353,
-0.033488445,
-0.0081190169,
0.0041840812,
0.000259907,
0.0273786653,
-0.0021076368,
0.0130891241,
-0.0751607791,
-0.0229143184,
0.0251868851,
0.017312536,
0.0436674021,
-0.0112630278,
0.0465855971,
0.03465911,
-0.015123534,
-0.0349684507,
0.0250529628,
-0.0244834982,
0.014781801,
0.040840175,
0.0140494825,
0.0238618068,
0.0305958465,
-0.0149071692,
-0.0023929719,
0.0031249509,
-0.0272589941,
0.0132837798,
-0.0279888902,
-0.0548698083,
-0.0199623797,
0.0225148089,
-0.0052548773,
0.0252883621,
0.0525277592,
-0.0210460853,
-0.0640980676,
0.0467908829,
-0.0253061466,
0.0181370117,
-0.0064918492,
0.0028285617,
0.0203545671,
0.0448657051,
-0.0070978692,
0.0284172259,
0.0245895423,
-0.0158030577,
-0.0050535286,
0.0436543524,
0.00226733,
-0.0580764003,
-0.0576359406,
-0.0026202446,
0.0152898757,
0.0466798991,
0.0144777484,
0.0007749742,
-0.009171647,
-0.0699732304,
-0.1050717905,
0.0124733346,
-0.0441225581,
0.018094603,
0.0349928029,
0.0218370203,
0.0088445358,
-0.0146882553,
-0.0447098911,
0.035933394,
-0.0274146535,
0.0203562286,
-0.0115107382,
0.0213706251,
-0.0450900942,
-0.0645239204,
-0.0414659083,
0.0062166643,
0.0200428497,
-0.0329471566,
-0.0149148274,
-0.0557954833,
-0.0149497446,
-0.022770891,
0.0334424786,
-0.0111946296,
-0.0247978661,
-0.0094573768,
-0.0213544499,
0.0849903151,
0.0402200148,
-0.0000350749,
-0.0312395971,
0.0463990383,
0.0104928054,
-0.0257581193,
0.0196275543,
-0.0085336668,
-0.0216240417,
-0.0533928014,
0.0268159322,
-0.0040367986,
0.0287025962,
-0.0296213161,
-0.0371944495,
-0.0765855461,
-0.0088721821,
-0.0072373301,
-0.0381382033,
-0.0281981099,
0.0317260809,
-0.0073950626,
-0.0088153314,
-0.0249488372,
0.005801233,
0.0328001827,
0.0036778308,
-0.0065766424,
-0.0403276272,
-0.0382203721,
-0.0389080867,
-0.0050445474,
-0.0040626484,
0.0333192982,
-0.061384175,
-0.0258807112,
-0.0432528853,
0.017448999,
-0.013871653,
0.0078012492,
0.0469842367,
-0.0269253738,
0.0457852893,
-0.0402023904,
-0.0476560332,
0.0211783089,
-0.0215576608,
-0.009490232,
0.0320742726,
0.0496012792,
-0.0371548645,
-0.0787924454,
0.0147115141,
0.0069899033,
0.1027193591,
-0.0288071726,
0.0089668082,
-0.0390167274,
0.0240774117,
0.0565110967,
0.065211691,
0.0003728844,
-0.0068567884,
0.011712498,
0.0149288299,
0.0807943046,
-0.0651703253,
-0.0205574483,
0.0364364646,
0.0321534313,
-0.011150687,
-0.0184413418,
0.0209065657,
0.0325520746,
-0.0177109633,
0.0023545842,
0.0751760304,
-0.0071531367,
-0.0866617411,
0.0167494826,
-0.0118042054,
0.0704951584,
0.0316887237,
0.0701233894,
-0.0509935059,
-0.0147526804,
-0.0032733828,
0.0034328038,
0.0317032896,
-0.0149644716,
-0.0046225637,
-0.0796403438,
0.0181305539,
0.0145870289,
-0.0544228293,
-0.0270706173,
-0.0208452996,
0.0041535734,
-0.0184626654,
0.0582106188,
0.0095729372,
0.008590905,
-0.0484029129,
0.0295013916,
0.0226143599,
-0.0548141524,
0.0150592932,
-0.019410586,
0.0999245942,
-0.0250678957,
-0.0086754821,
0.0066673285,
0.0013858486,
0.0299579725,
0.0056366483,
-0.0116809094,
-0.0207365844,
0.0310119241,
-0.0318953842,
-0.0202644821,
0.0337473229,
0.0126994541,
-0.0374209508,
0.0152074704,
0.0024555642,
0.0673388392,
0.0112449536,
-0.022569092,
-0.0001975215,
-0.0640401617,
0.0012542652,
0.0403806716,
-0.0089103971,
-0.0312967598,
-0.032906808,
-0.0252863169,
-0.0547189824,
-0.0112141939,
-0.0205000732,
-0.0159772225,
-0.0126398485,
-0.0366302282,
-0.044959452,
0.0255767033,
0.0594085753,
0.0771223828,
0.0075986981,
0.0509514473,
-0.0104448665,
0.0143877761,
0.00541875,
0.0236043017,
-0.0538485013,
-0.0156547893,
-0.0863566697,
-0.0216065459,
0.0135649163,
-0.0149291586,
-0.0187336188,
-0.0092043653,
-0.0801187605,
-0.0722961947,
-0.0141294533,
0.0357546061,
0.0199795179,
0.037954513,
-0.0257681869,
-0.1020729765,
0.0808861107,
0.0007672256,
-0.0664025769,
0.0381628834,
0.0240881946,
-0.0379024856,
-0.0092729786,
0.0459745489,
-0.0571590327,
0.0135353394,
0.0202432163,
0.0371050164,
-0.0122714872,
0.018057527,
-0.0387224518,
0.0202691909,
-0.0111157829,
0.0178449973,
0.0268264767,
-0.054708939,
0.0436848514,
-0.0119133797,
0.0248978399,
-0.0237606745,
-0.0049738502,
0.0248677321,
0.0007433468,
0.000782354,
-0.0099964393,
0.0367518924,
0.0071573919,
-0.0361997783,
-0.0174502004,
0.0279902238,
-0.0317659043,
0.0399727039,
-0.0017626653,
-0.0229930989,
-0.0463515781,
0.0362595394,
-0.0032332391,
-0.0575321317,
-0.0180478264,
0.0094186291,
-0.003547708,
-0.074248217,
0.0542093106,
-0.0487162918,
-0.0886622071,
-0.0191266574,
0.0685040802,
0.0595921837,
0.0060544061,
0.0613485686,
0.0102584213,
-0.0055298447,
-0.0265800618,
-0.0417603627,
0.001410457,
0.0235569309,
0.0153660011,
0.0182592832,
0.0167394243,
0.0502366684,
0.0650470257,
0.0445627458,
0.0357731208,
-0.0179680046,
0.0281183571,
-0.0409185439,
-0.0004354913,
-0.0166160036,
0.0460248664,
-0.0272938497,
0.0009078691,
0.0404340215,
-0.058919888,
-0.0401115008,
-0.0329331532,
-0.0025818786,
-0.0155400233,
0.0380708016,
0.0450988039,
-0.0192004871,
0.0059011108,
-0.008396876,
-0.0616387166,
0.0511370748,
0.0021466089,
0.0107417675,
-7.027809791e-33,
-0.0073720836,
0.0202273484,
0.0357349515,
-0.0172996353,
0.0039500049,
-0.0079247355,
-0.0350996517,
-0.0022161475,
-0.0435815193,
0.0072537893,
-0.0442517363,
0.0063340953,
0.0201062709,
0.0277113076,
0.0211460032,
0.0317073166,
0.069358252,
-0.0027345121,
-0.0149907982,
0.0480602793,
0.0057920017,
0.0138511844,
0.0550067723,
-0.0572728291,
-0.0237919893,
0.0275318511,
-0.0081061535,
0.0179191902,
-0.0026982662,
0.0450024866,
-0.0292353071,
0.0680882782,
0.0198423173,
-0.0200425237,
-0.0263794046,
0.0143894525,
-0.0604205094,
-0.0480388291,
0.0379342884,
-0.0241430346,
-0.0068624681,
-0.0357998461,
0.0453475192,
0.0304625295,
-0.0116131334,
0.0076491009,
0.01652807,
0.0196676962,
-0.0318338759,
0.0175969675,
-0.0582650192,
0.0157852881,
0.002510316,
0.0212261546,
0.0075856554,
-0.0262118578,
-0.0216852184,
-0.0242136475,
-0.0334369577,
0.0005163536,
-0.0142562417,
0.0952223912,
0.0259633325,
0.0222628564,
-0.0341988355,
0.0178825762,
0.0126642436,
0.0320872031,
0.0304502919,
-0.0393539593,
0.0254555009,
0.0141304983,
0.0138124637,
-0.0277831368,
0.0165435933,
-0.0413406081,
-0.045388341,
-0.0397878066,
0.0285704602,
0.0561188795,
0.0647954717,
0.0455305427,
-0.0193522703,
-0.0136394054,
-0.0187964048,
-0.0029529734,
-0.0639041439,
-0.013282272,
0.0277839378,
0.0425911658,
-0.0056196442,
-0.00917284,
0.0313711725,
-0.0266172998,
0.0035520983,
0.0089074271,
-0.0122075696,
0.013264549,
0.0197041854,
0.0290042441,
-0.0949175879,
-0.0809239224,
0.0289073456,
-0.0006376611,
-0.0231572725,
-0.024644671,
0.0030802246,
0.0221474599,
-0.0640001968,
-0.0212446004,
-0.0058801193,
0.0233131219,
0.0170314349,
0.0772815198,
0.0175743159,
-0.0091941804,
0.007109385,
0.0248884782,
-0.0025054261,
-0.0112181157,
0.0190881696,
-0.0072268564,
0.034656737,
0.0071942271,
-0.0395813622,
0.0086367615,
-0.0473998189,
-0.0194965452,
0.029107403,
-0.0524892733,
-0.0251100436,
0.0126249846,
2.837e-7,
-0.0166870747,
0.0475520194,
-0.0160801057,
-0.0526705459,
0.0174057037,
-0.0105176372,
-0.0082717557,
0.0322060399,
0.0219622031,
0.033052098,
0.0201829486,
0.0248649158,
0.0037949504,
-0.0297539718,
-0.0931725502,
-0.0338706002,
-0.0592155494,
0.0580212884,
-0.0550094508,
-0.0217896402,
-0.003476134,
0.1285777539,
0.0187712293,
-0.0136939678,
-0.0011986556,
-0.0446852446,
0.0188738126,
0.0073010148,
-0.0009732235,
0.0346012115,
0.0713413656,
0.0345167369,
-0.0135641284,
0.0245400034,
0.0038090777,
0.0799824521,
0.0108327083,
0.079448238,
-0.0565642007,
0.0014168058,
0.0466395468,
0.0222163741,
0.0175213143,
-0.0389899313,
0.0593188778,
-0.0094850156,
-0.0186688844,
-0.0092857461,
0.0035209726,
-0.0202886239,
0.0031238557,
-0.0225265902,
-0.0291945077,
0.0219313987,
0.0408948548,
-0.0153047228,
-0.0157942139,
-0.0948269516,
0.033181265,
0.0072777155,
-0.0598437674,
-0.0693387017,
-0.0490704104,
-0.0095276292,
0.0651465803,
-0.0136433644,
0.0326252542,
2.49866523e-34,
0.0578310639,
0.01900235,
0.0344939418,
0.0406743214,
0.0243135206,
0.0006355261,
-0.0434810519,
0.0113234334,
0.024722103,
-0.1120701581,
-0.0554071255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09174v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09174v3 | AbsPyramid: Benchmarking the Abstraction Ability of Language Models with a Unified Entailment Graph | 2023-11-15T18:11:23 | 2024-04-01T16:24:24 | Zhaowei Wang, Haochen Shi, Weiqi Wang, Tianqing Fang, Hongming Zhang, Sehyun Choi, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Cognitive research indicates that abstraction ability is essential in human
intelligence, which remains under-explored in language models. In this paper,
we present AbsPyramid, a unified entailment graph of 221K textual descriptions
of abstraction knowledge. While existing resources only touch nouns or verbs
within simplified events or specific domains, AbsPyramid collects abstract
knowledge for three components of diverse events to comprehensively evaluate
the abstraction ability of language models in the open domain. Experimental
results demonstrate that current LLMs face challenges comprehending abstraction
knowledge in zero-shot and few-shot settings. By training on our rich
abstraction knowledge, we find LLMs can acquire basic abstraction abilities and
generalize to unseen events. In the meantime, we empirically show that our
benchmark is comprehensive to enhance LLMs across two previous abstraction
tasks. | [
-0.0229406171,
0.0161495861,
-0.0291182511,
0.0664271489,
-0.0131398598,
0.0315085165,
-0.0304517355,
0.0173060056,
0.0107013723,
-0.0534780473,
0.0199519824,
0.0159356054,
-0.0350273997,
0.0349086151,
0.0327726677,
-0.0413770005,
0.0440324284,
-0.0164249726,
0.0089390352,
0.0210477989,
-0.0303416345,
0.0295788702,
-0.021917237,
0.0088370806,
0.0183802936,
-0.0063904384,
-0.0204378329,
-0.0000216322,
0.007616248,
-0.0459309258,
-0.0591262728,
0.015205781,
0.033595603,
-0.0093378788,
0.0000019789,
-0.0703667253,
0.0261646565,
-0.017305566,
-0.0318870172,
-0.0067607588,
-0.0120605268,
-0.0630983487,
0.035432972,
-0.0355340727,
0.0039626877,
-0.000636099,
-0.0086842794,
0.059633255,
0.0323685668,
0.0408003293,
-0.0103292279,
-0.0021646996,
0.0290389452,
-0.0053598927,
-0.0052163899,
-0.0097083841,
-0.0050296062,
0.0114759766,
-0.0276496243,
-0.0079526547,
-0.0393762551,
0.0123517569,
0.0496662855,
0.0521728806,
0.0153210703,
0.0646035373,
-0.028219685,
-0.0070999293,
0.0226532519,
0.0538001619,
-0.0314771943,
-0.0416568145,
-0.0077288575,
-0.0319454297,
0.011557458,
-0.0153244883,
-0.0342067331,
0.0308831409,
-0.0144521287,
0.0473003834,
0.0392714702,
-0.0148357954,
0.0441803411,
0.0237451773,
-0.0311785061,
0.0243276153,
0.0065856408,
-0.0027615158,
0.0260348395,
-0.0153522845,
-0.0343235135,
-0.0540368222,
-0.0103140604,
0.0423464701,
-0.0088862721,
0.0326276496,
-0.0375986174,
-0.0541426353,
-0.0180886611,
0.0010247313,
0.0457523614,
0.0508881137,
0.0499412008,
0.0552913286,
-0.0565933697,
0.0589448176,
-0.0068034912,
0.0317534097,
-0.0283774845,
-0.0266924966,
-0.0317546055,
-0.0075563877,
-0.0570859835,
0.0796205029,
-0.0436961204,
-0.0090416512,
-0.0071316436,
0.0055536916,
0.0007648089,
0.0044035618,
-0.04174852,
-0.0149206491,
-0.0351359732,
-0.0208322965,
-0.0527342297,
-0.0462359898,
-0.0703628361,
0.0133626089,
0.0291831885,
-0.0226993188,
-0.0153865358,
0.0007109012,
-0.0089264428,
0.0011088439,
0.0058814348,
0.096486181,
-0.0060789194,
-0.0110120401,
-0.0457818247,
-0.0516775548,
0.0615320317,
-0.0293582194,
0.028988095,
-0.0852267966,
0.0361864753,
0.0237438437,
0.0026364934,
-0.0331221372,
0.0286673047,
-0.0084931292,
-0.0328040048,
0.0577591658,
-0.0156774633,
0.020047646,
-0.0093546407,
0.0185262877,
-0.0353705101,
0.0478120036,
0.0156772863,
-0.00485561,
0.0200865138,
0.0404654965,
0.0290206783,
0.0024777916,
0.0170894414,
-0.0014692822,
-0.0233501792,
-0.0161363576,
-0.0791012421,
0.0243540797,
0.0517922789,
0.0296125449,
-0.0360950902,
-0.0360271707,
0.0154055404,
0.0715670735,
-0.0625912249,
0.0147716748,
0.0594117418,
-0.0099477852,
0.0211643782,
0.0066542192,
-0.0551993176,
0.0298080575,
-0.0059558614,
0.020890642,
-0.0358731113,
-0.0347536579,
-0.0449231043,
-0.0128273349,
-0.0345892683,
-0.0147193335,
-0.0005286285,
0.0031340499,
0.0408157296,
0.0426024757,
-0.0199477263,
0.0835679099,
0.0248404182,
-0.04372086,
0.0050713564,
-0.0088930167,
0.0436920784,
0.0417732447,
0.0147936214,
-0.0154259829,
-0.0309684407,
0.0025570141,
0.0344849229,
0.0554523319,
0.0233135037,
-0.0009968478,
0.0375506915,
-0.0304845087,
0.016491577,
-0.0504917391,
0.0245314073,
-0.0026421864,
0.037096072,
-0.0237590093,
0.0059688198,
-0.0511014387,
-0.042094674,
0.0516832732,
-0.0947736353,
-0.0310771298,
-0.0702707618,
0.0192821417,
-0.0054478114,
-0.0069461311,
0.0036212243,
0.0272660349,
0.0252297893,
-0.0665482134,
-0.0546923243,
0.0299800094,
-0.0313066542,
-0.0232348759,
0.0295424294,
-0.0656657591,
-0.0655637607,
0.0598648116,
-0.0349634588,
-0.0157731604,
0.029488463,
-0.0115195597,
0.0780481622,
-0.0108019402,
0.0142263575,
0.0189631488,
-0.036850132,
0.0058371583,
0.0872586966,
-0.0432516485,
0.050667312,
-0.0039413576,
0.0200390089,
0.0192897562,
0.0114727374,
-0.0032517912,
-0.0047048265,
0.0231250431,
-0.01724739,
-0.0156010045,
-0.0160510112,
-0.0773415267,
0.0215394273,
-0.0650526583,
0.0130072469,
0.0059059393,
0.0063050841,
0.063497968,
-0.023905931,
-0.0022516174,
0.0115840891,
-0.0054132063,
0.0152686639,
-0.0160769857,
0.0033280789,
0.0273889508,
-0.0393588617,
-0.0037190786,
-0.0232005883,
0.0033064729,
-0.0385060944,
0.0466207974,
-0.0196550861,
-0.0317304358,
0.0058194902,
0.0337541327,
-0.0214174632,
0.0194215905,
-0.0376351476,
-0.0344844721,
0.0108213499,
-0.0095878532,
0.0275858138,
0.0181038324,
-0.0454207659,
0.0542487875,
0.0352298319,
-0.0022103018,
-0.0382015072,
-0.000976878,
-0.0198146757,
0.0133453356,
-0.0262795482,
-0.0179721527,
-0.00103413,
0.0926899984,
0.005847082,
0.0161089431,
-0.040577285,
0.0017382327,
-0.0263491608,
-0.0219018254,
-0.0495167188,
-0.0407042801,
-0.0340559296,
0.0354576074,
-0.0642603263,
-0.015003969,
0.0623527467,
0.032466609,
0.0112079997,
-0.0220736787,
-0.0204815678,
-0.0342414305,
0.0980416462,
-0.0138157755,
0.0336826667,
0.0044267848,
-0.0338298567,
-0.0767761767,
-0.0082171122,
-0.0076599699,
-0.005099915,
0.062980406,
-0.0628206879,
-0.0022743742,
0.0037730969,
-0.0202122144,
-0.0300797336,
-0.0219066851,
-0.0336596817,
0.0446747802,
-0.0112486947,
0.0060155159,
-0.0226581767,
-0.0441292189,
0.0161006954,
-0.0242033359,
0.0187051743,
-0.0230913721,
-0.0388838574,
0.0147870509,
0.0445259139,
-0.0156175718,
0.0202912614,
-0.0663224608,
0.0525238737,
0.0625630319,
0.0292490032,
0.008236751,
-0.0355449244,
0.025650993,
-0.0193999149,
-0.0423296206,
-0.0081831012,
-0.0109610157,
0.036477074,
-0.0474358387,
-0.0115701705,
0.0888973698,
0.0271604024,
0.0155465985,
0.0494473353,
-0.0420429707,
0.045001775,
0.0755916983,
-0.0096221659,
-0.0911802053,
-0.0262463279,
0.0092881992,
-0.0224827286,
0.031377349,
-0.0678638443,
0.0188212302,
-0.1164051816,
0.0012379996,
0.0117044179,
-0.0841541141,
-0.0509526767,
-0.0089251725,
0.012255027,
0.0487448052,
-0.01815309,
0.0131849796,
-0.007154284,
-0.0076462482,
-0.0117383907,
-0.0098989839,
-0.004107344,
0.0309715699,
-0.0322904997,
-0.0016930285,
-0.0610208921,
0.032701306,
-0.0144603541,
0.0172047336,
0.0831760615,
-0.0406978205,
-0.0060832077,
0.0165717751,
0.0349851884,
0.0073254309,
0.0017915769,
-0.0197725836,
0.0368504599,
-0.0025786529,
-0.0652010515,
-0.0264772736,
0.0936628729,
-0.0315948874,
-0.0313493125,
-0.0127561819,
-0.0345574506,
-0.0302915201,
0.0755750909,
0.0649410784,
0.0015392225,
-0.0500309281,
-0.0057598245,
-0.0202788524,
-0.0257983692,
-0.0075037582,
0.0274609625,
-0.0186488181,
-0.0323338136,
-0.0676535368,
-0.0443216972,
0.033159662,
0.0165110901,
0.0066108652,
-0.0025378326,
0.032505393,
-0.0616129935,
-0.0396457203,
0.0411731042,
-0.0364251621,
0.0112678576,
0.0460856073,
-0.0042166272,
0.0096625369,
0.01856759,
-0.0189355444,
0.0814540088,
-0.0205181688,
-0.0566787161,
-0.0154645331,
-0.0177244246,
0.0285606552,
0.0517834574,
-0.0144198146,
-0.0276245568,
0.0566153191,
-0.0302382596,
-0.0209391303,
0.0481898151,
-0.0090750335,
0.0320617147,
0.0320349447,
0.0756813362,
-0.0399148837,
0.0258480813,
0.0108701289,
0.0585057028,
-0.0203516223,
0.0601203293,
0.0131672099,
0.0164173488,
0.0061075725,
0.0014388452,
-0.0216697324,
-0.0556461178,
0.0020810293,
-0.0427873507,
-0.0216617286,
-0.0241553728,
0.0043293615,
0.0337685198,
0.0001858374,
-0.0095745577,
-0.0124243675,
0.0298618563,
0.0625144392,
0.01083651,
-0.034031108,
-0.0069172569,
0.0073880767,
0.0287614241,
0.0058189933,
-0.0489592217,
-0.0078469515,
-0.0524130054,
0.0148626184,
-0.0257763863,
0.0090109976,
0.0352093689,
0.0153650697,
-0.0541667677,
-0.0121113025,
-0.0477869511,
-0.0259314757,
0.0332117192,
-0.0036265349,
0.0688092783,
-0.0336516909,
0.0400639176,
-0.0551635809,
-0.0121554732,
0.028839495,
0.0319675505,
-0.0194442421,
-0.0271168426,
0.0635474026,
0.0468062758,
-0.0040446515,
0.0098600024,
0.037201535,
-0.0503937788,
0.0781155899,
0.0141410558,
0.0128602767,
-0.034517359,
0.009578811,
0.0136883426,
0.0626294464,
-0.0047116582,
0.034613058,
-0.0661054924,
-0.0915405527,
0.0104582496,
0.0437394641,
-0.0051328205,
-0.0152865387,
0.0533868298,
0.02380074,
0.0359422229,
-0.0277924854,
-0.0159882661,
0.0163480882,
-0.0529900119,
-0.010286863,
-0.0493211113,
-6.351128387e-33,
-0.0590863451,
-0.0218907762,
0.0148454513,
0.0259913597,
-0.0296004731,
0.0187728535,
-0.0774260983,
0.0322053395,
-0.0116661303,
0.0438855365,
0.0259340368,
0.032815855,
-0.0128073376,
-0.0033151757,
-0.0014904214,
-0.0071928166,
-0.0171264764,
-0.007931402,
-0.043831788,
0.0005464052,
0.0620785467,
0.0023304578,
0.0480348915,
-0.0557920523,
-0.0295304395,
-0.0135230003,
0.0305982661,
0.0280769896,
-0.0019351881,
0.06184588,
-0.0166383851,
0.0365123563,
0.0465795361,
0.0033788283,
-0.0122691961,
-0.0180321727,
-0.0705334619,
-0.0702082068,
0.0644990802,
-0.021966666,
-0.0826575086,
-0.0346996859,
0.0656225383,
0.0097312024,
-0.0039402992,
-0.0247692708,
0.0285210293,
-0.0016946086,
0.0032834415,
-0.0206099134,
-0.0761785954,
0.0057867868,
-0.0131532736,
0.0218494646,
0.0252060201,
-0.0167326313,
-0.0168156046,
-0.0011015957,
-0.0242659114,
-0.023325922,
0.0001523023,
-0.001135948,
0.0266977772,
-0.020190889,
0.0031995687,
0.0970616192,
0.0018914748,
0.0010589048,
-0.0183733311,
0.0686087832,
0.036343772,
0.1017355323,
0.0109743029,
-0.0157836936,
0.0000113713,
-0.0000394216,
-0.0529552326,
0.0011031522,
-0.0137924179,
0.0536119752,
0.0234784018,
-0.0017798109,
0.0020918287,
-0.001760319,
-0.0655612499,
0.003259812,
-0.0275556315,
-0.0043333233,
0.0258461945,
-0.0287085269,
0.0402550176,
-0.0050105238,
-0.0056308936,
-0.008420879,
-0.0056505199,
0.0223500654,
-0.0142500903,
0.0373041146,
0.0158615112,
0.0315333121,
-0.0562846884,
-0.0374683179,
-0.0118378121,
0.0087382374,
0.0513863899,
0.0178320948,
0.0538190119,
-0.0122050848,
-0.035000734,
-0.0084668696,
-0.0683526471,
-0.0312989876,
-0.0244386699,
0.0075429245,
0.0345267542,
0.0326614082,
-0.0078122206,
0.008536662,
0.0019605686,
-0.0164555833,
-0.0119700721,
0.0751442984,
-0.0051543983,
0.0249740239,
-0.0241208319,
-0.0146412477,
-0.0450089239,
0.0265537072,
0.0794704109,
-0.0169382449,
-0.0230426285,
0.0479184203,
2.643e-7,
0.0451721624,
0.0281712115,
0.0218045283,
0.0732465312,
0.0066079064,
0.0044891746,
-0.0391629599,
0.0232532453,
0.0103057036,
-0.0466414765,
-0.0255908687,
0.0425615162,
0.0527679734,
0.0281723812,
-0.0925615132,
0.0360383689,
0.007460732,
-0.0123234633,
-0.0655493811,
0.0168825723,
0.0767940208,
0.0494047515,
0.063802436,
0.0066245059,
-0.0089238361,
-0.0165363122,
0.0550578572,
-0.0373064242,
0.0043813139,
0.0019704662,
-0.018006878,
0.0808022246,
0.0082233036,
0.0297666416,
-0.0131380809,
0.0262101945,
0.0026968729,
0.0382804982,
-0.0371815637,
-0.0123417424,
0.0058213482,
-0.0441519991,
0.0082134549,
-0.0364061482,
0.0542008355,
-0.0478503965,
-0.0365526974,
0.0074234316,
-0.036041826,
0.0329151563,
-0.0151768401,
0.0249344595,
-0.0391863286,
-0.0053384528,
0.0259154961,
-0.0051294216,
-0.0231995024,
-0.0680538639,
-0.0224833228,
0.0344936103,
-0.0341269523,
-0.0379411541,
-0.0026023665,
0.0168959275,
0.0153283719,
-0.0902398601,
-0.0305163581,
2.478639582e-34,
0.0081683546,
0.0002517606,
0.0196222551,
0.0571158193,
0.048454009,
-0.0418333411,
-0.0248074681,
0.03392433,
0.0081235114,
-0.0562063046,
0.0219409466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09154v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09154v3 | CLEAN-EVAL: Clean Evaluation on Contaminated Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T17:50:30 | 2024-06-03T03:06:55 | Wenhong Zhu, Hongkun Hao, Zhiwei He, Yunze Song, Yumeng Zhang, Hanxu Hu, Yiran Wei, Rui Wang, Hongyuan Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | We are currently in an era of fierce competition among various large language
models (LLMs) continuously pushing the boundaries of benchmark performance.
However, genuinely assessing the capabilities of these LLMs has become a
challenging and critical issue due to potential data contamination, and it
wastes dozens of time and effort for researchers and engineers to download and
try those contaminated models. To save our precious time, we propose a novel
and useful method, Clean-Eval, which mitigates the issue of data contamination
and evaluates the LLMs in a cleaner manner. Clean-Eval employs an LLM to
paraphrase and back-translate the contaminated data into a candidate set,
generating expressions with the same meaning but in different surface forms. A
semantic detector is then used to filter the generated low-quality samples to
narrow down this candidate set. The best candidate is finally selected from
this set based on the BLEURT score. According to human assessment, this best
candidate is semantically similar to the original contamination data but
expressed differently. All candidates can form a new benchmark to evaluate the
model. Our experiments illustrate that Clean-Eval substantially restores the
actual evaluation results on contaminated LLMs under both few-shot learning and
fine-tuning scenarios. | [
0.0015768217,
0.0957022384,
-0.0083270436,
0.0634807199,
-0.0530198663,
-0.0103214523,
0.0025263382,
0.0152740702,
-0.0345822461,
-0.0821276605,
-0.0214754548,
-0.0193693843,
0.011884924,
0.0196143836,
0.0361071229,
0.0041729971,
0.0479036197,
-0.0214506555,
-0.0172877405,
0.0079596033,
-0.0155138904,
0.0199463051,
0.0426047444,
0.0301490333,
0.0000228506,
-0.0046022874,
0.0336919427,
0.0092242351,
-0.0020246799,
-0.0163766667,
-0.0036694915,
0.030166829,
-0.0192933194,
0.0664915964,
0.0000022147,
-0.0577237979,
-0.036413122,
0.0324491002,
-0.0050722584,
0.0667257681,
0.0848432109,
0.0078962604,
-0.0402298905,
0.0268102735,
-0.020147983,
-0.0123776877,
0.0428012274,
-0.0004042909,
0.0905897319,
0.0672163442,
-0.0075838855,
0.012024926,
0.0059526335,
-0.0001336596,
-0.0055189496,
-0.0511586852,
0.0534217097,
0.0037732904,
0.0071700951,
-0.0187004488,
-0.0125711635,
0.0544166043,
-0.0028150377,
-0.0028559191,
-0.0106716165,
0.005307965,
-0.0348060504,
-0.006343001,
0.0258596409,
0.0685650483,
-0.0508373715,
-0.0176562574,
-0.013123733,
-0.0369798951,
-0.0218659043,
-0.0045704357,
-0.0292368308,
0.0203746874,
0.0188598,
0.0414481238,
-0.015801264,
-0.0208744779,
0.0657981858,
0.0309538729,
-0.0406700782,
0.0492076129,
0.0445513688,
-0.0347614661,
-0.0176609568,
0.0034099515,
-0.0224080663,
-0.0115012731,
-0.0036282213,
-0.014664717,
-0.0193175375,
0.0488230698,
-0.0484477393,
-0.0413690545,
0.0373181552,
-0.0378889479,
0.0514815599,
0.0241035353,
-0.0123742772,
0.0420663804,
-0.0328971036,
0.04411982,
0.0017461856,
0.0296439659,
-0.0394552723,
-0.011883134,
-0.0021862884,
0.0032598954,
-0.0349565223,
0.0339382328,
-0.0349953026,
-0.0202836003,
-0.0207525659,
0.0124559412,
-0.0283615217,
-0.0096416511,
0.0031213067,
-0.0129023185,
-0.0071232514,
0.0133468229,
-0.0160163343,
0.0034448747,
0.0190403089,
0.0208233371,
0.0086007221,
-0.1048199907,
-0.0043367604,
-0.0069920956,
0.0000971557,
-0.0504727215,
0.0088681169,
0.0672915354,
0.0277525336,
-0.0259672515,
-0.0321538188,
-0.0283367522,
-0.0346020013,
-0.0614939518,
-0.0179645084,
-0.059005037,
0.0164446346,
-0.0080218231,
-0.0099643869,
-0.0850474685,
0.0166203212,
0.0351929069,
-0.0557882339,
0.0635970607,
-0.053921368,
0.0021191216,
-0.0290767942,
0.0001712701,
-0.0064717652,
0.083465673,
0.0402410701,
0.0206512697,
0.0339280777,
-0.0055978596,
0.0030311167,
0.0701375157,
0.0335830227,
0.0374820717,
-0.0545298085,
-0.0178307686,
0.0218201596,
0.0395245254,
0.0093852291,
0.0860589743,
-0.02453628,
0.0031980928,
0.0462077148,
-0.0029167943,
-0.0065320241,
0.0001392356,
0.0332929455,
0.0214006398,
-0.0023007053,
-0.0074627311,
-0.0540605001,
-0.0485132113,
-0.0169771034,
0.0066761938,
0.0436768979,
0.0419825129,
0.004045431,
-0.0368575305,
-0.0540023819,
-0.0054247645,
0.0190997105,
0.0079588946,
0.0500131212,
0.0293700323,
-0.0466799811,
0.0630038306,
0.0351764597,
-0.0560605973,
0.0016207357,
-0.0653457269,
0.0248963032,
0.0668998957,
0.0766993314,
-0.0034337668,
-0.0249231774,
-0.0225104392,
-0.0376349539,
0.0114062149,
0.0275265891,
-0.0017749529,
0.0294752661,
-0.046504043,
-0.050201375,
-0.0130611956,
0.0262894593,
0.0015157718,
0.0045125131,
-0.015495426,
0.0488933697,
-0.0633994564,
-0.0597302914,
0.0565088652,
-0.0048812176,
-0.0051248637,
0.0186076351,
0.0003428765,
0.0286753178,
-0.0066541904,
-0.0218500979,
0.0198673084,
0.0336810797,
-0.020306062,
-0.0211241096,
-0.0221458599,
-0.0214330237,
-0.0130843744,
0.0376713909,
-0.0147859706,
-0.0065460764,
0.0653769299,
-0.0404076986,
-0.0297028925,
0.0140226474,
-0.0280480068,
0.0176924393,
-0.0337873586,
0.0518138856,
-0.0281941146,
0.0355672091,
-0.0387569256,
0.0540400632,
-0.0006589972,
0.0350468457,
0.0115887094,
0.0102743162,
0.0285026692,
-0.0253169909,
-0.0735487565,
0.0073872902,
-0.0279486813,
0.0411004536,
0.0195549335,
0.0274764374,
-0.0490014106,
-0.0152761228,
-0.0571949705,
-0.0025992384,
-0.0150521938,
0.0133376513,
0.0316032991,
0.0095656235,
-0.0013352125,
0.0216027945,
-0.0083307726,
-0.0307544339,
0.0197113603,
0.0292666946,
0.0132762864,
-0.0070440392,
-0.0208761804,
-0.0182709396,
-0.0086457189,
-0.0230356622,
0.0860502124,
-0.0117440177,
0.0032480287,
-0.0613997243,
0.0576251373,
-0.0330183804,
0.0043724254,
0.0257010031,
-0.0326014459,
-0.0103262449,
-0.0304860268,
-0.0063886764,
0.0404763743,
-0.0149148954,
-0.0021728119,
0.0581676885,
-0.012724475,
-0.0802005306,
-0.0172800589,
0.0199702568,
-0.0112692164,
-0.0156190926,
-0.0499929488,
-0.002955257,
0.0263820365,
-0.0029409654,
-0.0132320188,
-0.0346122235,
0.0538570955,
-0.0474141948,
-0.0339498483,
-0.0286657698,
-0.0040388769,
-0.0329577252,
0.0304467399,
-0.0224677585,
-0.0312396344,
0.0385723673,
-0.0418010131,
0.0179428365,
-0.0331778638,
0.0195148606,
-0.0218576826,
0.0353775471,
-0.0192887243,
0.0302995238,
0.0135368546,
-0.0235713497,
-0.0428580828,
-0.0180054195,
0.0125888167,
-0.0475792512,
0.0422442183,
-0.06135251,
0.0449272655,
0.0103909839,
-0.0358251743,
-0.0372279435,
-0.062797986,
-0.0123945568,
0.0231775213,
0.0165794957,
0.0203050077,
-0.0253960006,
0.0178394634,
-0.0193508603,
0.0010353478,
-0.0007899047,
0.01004175,
-0.022487022,
0.0149439136,
0.0501033105,
-0.0320099369,
0.043761123,
-0.0131500671,
0.0202734172,
0.0427152291,
0.0493659377,
0.0383326896,
-0.0490089469,
0.0001009735,
0.0295020752,
0.0191860087,
-0.010024406,
-0.0049391272,
0.024092041,
-0.0709267557,
-0.0244860407,
0.0959831625,
0.0050534084,
0.0120977219,
0.0121795377,
0.0049081347,
0.0296136383,
0.0184292067,
-0.0080586961,
-0.0880217329,
-0.028115917,
0.022101067,
0.0132386517,
-0.0025960724,
-0.0271172598,
0.0011882641,
-0.1562172621,
0.0290004034,
0.0200322215,
-0.0663056821,
0.0030037269,
-0.0465005934,
0.0022320813,
-0.0401367769,
0.0700589344,
0.0125415381,
0.0025765921,
-0.0100699682,
-0.0094743427,
0.0049106628,
-0.1080703214,
0.0452564061,
-0.0386030152,
0.0600755848,
0.065776512,
0.033004906,
-0.0154162105,
-0.0217379909,
0.041428525,
-0.0404151641,
-0.0207689945,
0.0033476935,
0.0315310322,
0.0165638067,
-0.0349502526,
0.0547631569,
-0.0125905443,
-0.0272558648,
-0.0011907067,
-0.0175169222,
0.0644203573,
0.0020505674,
-0.0058043394,
0.0073389942,
-0.0310950447,
-0.001160906,
0.0849408507,
0.0356293321,
-0.0291963667,
-0.0318123624,
-0.0150192138,
-0.0297047775,
-0.0338921957,
-0.0224822909,
0.043425113,
-0.0428180546,
-0.0447306857,
-0.0711798221,
-0.0380992964,
0.0242789909,
0.0367948189,
0.0036070333,
0.0302138012,
-0.0333396383,
-0.0024808473,
-0.0228617284,
0.0351486504,
-0.0520883389,
0.0670642331,
-0.0404368713,
0.0499591902,
0.0119617097,
0.0220050123,
-0.0248421729,
0.0387373902,
-0.1004643217,
-0.0835668296,
0.0169515349,
0.0518561974,
0.0208282731,
0.0183058269,
-0.0365841426,
-0.0590942353,
0.0449516326,
0.0110749891,
-0.0548433475,
0.0276378728,
0.026229132,
-0.043417491,
-0.0049463585,
0.0484340899,
-0.0622067302,
0.0028993711,
0.0294387396,
0.0498542786,
-0.011576972,
-0.0131510794,
0.035608869,
0.0724025369,
0.0489314236,
-0.0332874097,
-0.0270870291,
0.0012405561,
0.0006748642,
-0.039112296,
-0.0347801186,
-0.0478381142,
0.0401454419,
0.0359529927,
0.009212926,
-0.0136923082,
0.0094380975,
-0.0235996246,
0.0526160002,
-0.0219904222,
-0.0026882729,
-0.0061409655,
0.0097144088,
0.0574621595,
0.010735644,
-0.0077970694,
0.0170860365,
-0.0008077121,
0.016956808,
-0.0261241198,
-0.0000140329,
0.0152328014,
0.020200612,
-0.0176812466,
0.0474388935,
-0.0390922353,
-0.0422009192,
-0.0403363965,
0.0362954475,
0.0483290181,
0.0186331235,
0.0760439858,
0.0012129915,
-0.0246925503,
-0.0393925086,
-0.0028443953,
-0.013310249,
-0.037149854,
0.0330549814,
-0.0010953086,
-0.0320174098,
0.0105640246,
0.0568579808,
-0.0015493067,
0.0648823902,
-0.0288801771,
0.0244166292,
-0.0315403119,
-0.0204183906,
0.0193195622,
0.0117364544,
-0.0231900439,
-0.0257198215,
-0.0652897656,
-0.0904187784,
0.0054160296,
0.0187882483,
-0.0058174734,
-0.0016912021,
0.0204057805,
0.0832317993,
0.0035521055,
0.043570552,
-0.0552891009,
-0.0263665356,
0.0071157306,
-0.036725264,
-0.027187774,
-6.714201123e-33,
0.0151223,
0.0117688384,
0.0071575386,
-0.0490138121,
-0.0355197825,
0.013577627,
-0.0205739215,
-0.0118449423,
-0.0076907682,
0.0064307726,
-0.0112688662,
-0.0007414104,
0.0175639056,
0.0279968586,
-0.0152027579,
-0.0099157291,
0.0531600304,
0.0151076224,
-0.0435376242,
-0.0022511312,
0.0369099788,
0.0237474181,
0.0394956544,
-0.056511078,
-0.0133551378,
-0.0093815718,
-0.054232683,
0.0018332718,
-0.0127058076,
0.0565460958,
-0.0078476481,
0.0468592606,
0.0047105779,
-0.0379428826,
-0.0457980633,
-0.0141262608,
-0.0351790227,
0.0141756637,
0.0280075818,
0.0081292903,
-0.0356146358,
-0.0489558801,
0.0861472264,
-0.026571529,
-0.0262427293,
0.0123310499,
0.0101374248,
-0.0391115099,
-0.0376918577,
-0.0082776109,
-0.0436362922,
0.0303849746,
0.004216128,
-0.0148507375,
0.0269061234,
0.0126733994,
-0.0077480949,
0.0387841351,
-0.0215322953,
0.0015578242,
0.0118124178,
0.042594865,
0.0817663595,
0.0053267768,
0.0072117401,
0.0729344785,
0.0039886958,
-0.0217596535,
0.0446151979,
-0.0403994992,
0.0630625263,
0.0597199053,
0.0207341909,
0.0708656386,
0.0354965962,
-0.0306132119,
-0.0423698165,
0.0164897963,
-0.0093117943,
0.0446387492,
0.0125327827,
0.0137009937,
-0.0153447632,
-0.0311395004,
-0.0960363373,
0.0015576744,
-0.0595740341,
-0.0171772763,
0.0517091006,
-0.0135203805,
-0.0617858283,
0.0038632685,
0.0321269743,
-0.064946875,
-0.0301017705,
0.0131146424,
-0.0271477215,
0.0109026777,
-0.0065413108,
0.0607609861,
-0.0246288311,
-0.0309426021,
0.0247485153,
0.0172739383,
0.0282484479,
0.0020224096,
0.0223877188,
0.0210816022,
-0.0697214231,
0.0134170409,
-0.0499352999,
0.0002363523,
-0.0078299772,
-0.0055932668,
0.0302949343,
0.0098430831,
0.0027886652,
0.0190209579,
0.0516732149,
0.0293583814,
-0.0106710764,
0.0007982739,
0.0115497233,
0.0241362639,
-0.0201898348,
-0.0212452654,
-0.0290880576,
0.002561731,
0.0735017657,
-0.0404585972,
-0.0109592052,
0.0258758869,
2.926e-7,
0.0604183748,
0.041659791,
-0.0110134445,
0.0095380154,
-0.0015817166,
0.0361596532,
-0.0346774571,
0.0142111899,
0.0042277328,
0.0157466829,
0.002637445,
-0.0159466416,
0.0680226758,
0.0230387505,
-0.0912650824,
0.040321134,
-0.0718053803,
-0.0203973018,
-0.0507685244,
-0.0151776252,
0.0361033194,
0.1260837168,
0.0202133823,
-0.0508555286,
-0.0184767842,
-0.0586373284,
0.0438841395,
-0.0461278036,
-0.044088047,
0.0430429392,
0.0212251283,
0.0227474011,
0.0326485634,
-0.0033595762,
-0.0053303177,
0.0174249206,
0.030845169,
0.0531022102,
-0.0114080897,
-0.0019604347,
-0.0234544072,
-0.0696810707,
-0.0076286523,
-0.0398753174,
0.0843422115,
-0.0331301577,
-0.0145620229,
-0.0430052429,
-0.04212806,
-0.0018939375,
0.0478750542,
-0.0306334179,
-0.0300236121,
0.02309018,
0.0121243065,
-0.0010237549,
-0.0413969718,
-0.0538643338,
-0.014753663,
-0.030136073,
-0.0273311511,
-0.0663865656,
-0.005513465,
-0.0092928726,
0.0207982287,
-0.0770796612,
0.0172383972,
2.858637646e-34,
0.0619668737,
-0.0366412923,
0.0070105609,
0.0160709266,
0.044496052,
0.0058062458,
-0.008498989,
0.030826712,
-0.0411505662,
-0.0475211143,
0.0124265486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09149v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09149v2 | Temporal Knowledge Question Answering via Abstract Reasoning Induction | 2023-11-15T17:46:39 | 2024-05-17T03:17:02 | Ziyang Chen, Dongfang Li, Xiang Zhao, Baotian Hu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | In this study, we address the challenge of enhancing temporal knowledge
reasoning in Large Language Models (LLMs). LLMs often struggle with this task,
leading to the generation of inaccurate or misleading responses. This issue
mainly arises from their limited ability to handle evolving factual knowledge
and complex temporal logic. To overcome these limitations, we propose Abstract
Reasoning Induction (ARI) framework, which divides temporal reasoning into two
distinct phases: Knowledge-agnostic and Knowledge-based. This framework offers
factual knowledge support to LLMs while minimizing the incorporation of
extraneous noisy data. Concurrently, informed by the principles of
constructivism, ARI provides LLMs the capability to engage in proactive,
self-directed learning from both correct and incorrect historical reasoning
samples. By teaching LLMs to actively construct knowledge and methods, it can
significantly boosting their temporal reasoning abilities. Our approach
achieves remarkable improvements, with relative gains of 29.7% and 9.27% on two
temporal QA datasets, underscoring its efficacy in advancing temporal reasoning
in LLMs. The code can be found at https://github.com/czy1999/ARI-QA | [
0.0286321659,
0.0548765771,
-0.0198682807,
0.0198455062,
-0.032168597,
0.0196231268,
-0.0147402855,
-0.0214297622,
0.0125296004,
-0.0348942168,
0.0399653055,
-0.0277625062,
-0.0173087474,
0.0227616373,
0.0076156412,
-0.032082174,
0.0586377792,
-0.0315212719,
0.0106475139,
-0.0224275533,
-0.0173366573,
-0.0050436384,
-0.0347532332,
-0.004653492,
0.0139225563,
-0.0535854772,
-0.0389443673,
-0.0670306757,
0.0321242958,
-0.0305350814,
0.0169816576,
0.0152833611,
0.0372169092,
0.0343382768,
0.0000020361,
-0.0492703021,
-0.0006446199,
-0.0400731713,
-0.0446966961,
0.021701701,
-0.0453744158,
0.0524178036,
0.0120804403,
0.0181128494,
-0.0655758232,
-0.008770423,
-0.0070304931,
0.0274863746,
0.0389428064,
0.055833891,
0.0154027287,
0.0041919849,
0.0281136539,
-0.004947009,
0.0150282364,
-0.0393301658,
0.0132990396,
0.0522840731,
0.0333543383,
0.0324470252,
-0.0078761829,
0.042617321,
0.0477233492,
-0.0131308995,
0.0270463564,
0.0659404099,
-0.0194338877,
0.0264200494,
-0.0111147696,
0.0417664573,
0.063417159,
-0.0501953959,
-0.0290499143,
0.0223614238,
-0.0182391349,
-0.0093368907,
-0.0540604591,
0.0149112958,
-0.0037658254,
0.013433692,
0.0175243989,
0.0113507258,
0.0339465402,
0.0525528528,
-0.0502482615,
0.1124850139,
-0.0039060493,
-0.0429190248,
-0.0152331302,
0.0045445533,
0.0138525078,
-0.0317330435,
-0.0126705356,
0.1029216498,
0.0102926958,
0.0400835164,
0.0482044742,
0.0015218001,
0.0081540365,
-0.039655257,
-0.030551808,
0.0386970676,
0.0036907175,
0.0583676547,
-0.0298303086,
0.0396288969,
-0.0126028098,
0.0072135506,
-0.00927212,
-0.003970453,
-0.0637826696,
-0.0460452624,
-0.0004774381,
0.0308667608,
0.0122872489,
0.0240184683,
-0.0118782278,
0.0505732521,
-0.0075829481,
0.010852823,
-0.026911566,
0.0102720819,
-0.0127929877,
-0.0448030159,
-0.0960896611,
0.0210905708,
-0.0367763601,
0.0346861742,
-0.0176040251,
-0.0405887067,
-0.0207963958,
-0.0225335583,
0.0082345465,
-0.0254592691,
-0.0122966543,
0.0058092112,
-0.0465297028,
0.0076951049,
-0.0799805745,
-0.0290833507,
0.0104215639,
-0.0254975427,
0.0049582366,
-0.0545538515,
0.0375121869,
0.0041766176,
-0.0216270275,
0.0101732621,
0.0224622171,
0.0064594666,
-0.0077396473,
0.0579534061,
-0.011050622,
0.0415862799,
0.011378644,
0.0253783874,
0.0178769194,
0.0408618376,
0.0197264925,
-0.0307499263,
-0.0002968619,
0.0302946642,
-0.0191750135,
0.0001734817,
0.0380914435,
-0.0015436582,
0.0027504156,
0.0393330306,
-0.0685642883,
0.0215180684,
-0.0027328578,
0.0145551441,
-0.0195566788,
0.0048537613,
0.0348999538,
-0.0073991991,
-0.0330020115,
0.0100393677,
0.0652491078,
-0.0316786915,
0.0300651863,
-0.0299815964,
-0.0151089327,
0.031153867,
-0.0339496136,
0.0167560298,
-0.0489562079,
0.0211493485,
-0.0403638035,
-0.0551345795,
0.0084016416,
0.0048482465,
-0.0018071695,
0.0443613231,
0.0671189204,
0.0339145884,
-0.00933991,
0.0616056919,
0.0093707852,
-0.0019008127,
0.0037339125,
-0.012778338,
0.0791980773,
0.056390658,
0.0412737429,
-0.0454597361,
-0.0814177245,
-0.0071471175,
0.0339995138,
0.0131014464,
0.0514934361,
-0.0551524013,
-0.0302023068,
-0.021983536,
-0.0251017157,
-0.0192816015,
-0.0069599133,
-0.013201206,
0.0799777657,
0.0410885029,
0.0074922964,
-0.0470606685,
0.0141409067,
0.0249628238,
-0.0614139736,
-0.046965301,
-0.0496985726,
0.0265734829,
0.0094136847,
0.0193764549,
0.0390488356,
0.0110372175,
0.0167860556,
-0.0104820095,
-0.0387629494,
0.086187847,
-0.0516076796,
-0.0576399527,
0.0323037654,
0.0225417055,
-0.0483694151,
0.0048772837,
-0.0567221567,
-0.0197861269,
0.0557716638,
0.0192582905,
0.0736335814,
-0.0379698575,
0.0043794555,
0.0140720624,
-0.029781051,
-0.0487644449,
0.1097502708,
-0.0003030977,
-0.0297450796,
0.0234515313,
0.0325149335,
-0.0044706846,
-0.0258704834,
0.0136675099,
-0.0108196251,
0.0139339175,
-0.0426107757,
0.0075588934,
-0.0117877536,
-0.0903240368,
0.0409927778,
-0.0520270839,
-0.0168928206,
0.0002942777,
0.0120189656,
0.0062051681,
-0.0116629014,
0.0202007405,
-0.0105944825,
-0.026842501,
0.0099295191,
-0.0175412577,
0.0185626429,
0.0514242612,
0.0349087231,
-0.0118891774,
-0.0131752165,
0.0137104569,
-0.0700638667,
0.0252819378,
-0.0004310543,
0.0097619146,
-0.029930884,
0.0000636383,
-0.0585611835,
0.0174182747,
-0.0249266271,
-0.0032293529,
0.0166517608,
-0.0314857699,
0.0367128812,
0.0748856813,
-0.0009839833,
0.0181936175,
0.0562800132,
-0.0027147287,
-0.0571618862,
0.0577082038,
-0.0372047946,
0.0034634012,
-0.0175813884,
-0.016792804,
-0.0171519332,
0.0535582192,
-0.0262762625,
0.0021855931,
-0.0533819981,
0.0195437949,
-0.0360084958,
0.0089886347,
-0.029583225,
-0.0064233174,
-0.0137582319,
0.016870616,
-0.057934273,
-0.0345671661,
0.0756770968,
0.0350685678,
-0.0185883287,
-0.0336385444,
0.0111194476,
-0.0443067402,
0.0726224855,
0.0053959228,
0.0007303235,
0.0096239476,
-0.0061764284,
-0.0633187294,
-0.0226179473,
0.0149173336,
-0.0161737986,
0.0463565327,
-0.0641476735,
0.0127102146,
0.0171786267,
0.00149848,
-0.0679446757,
-0.0336977132,
-0.0318376422,
-0.0124266092,
-0.0970260575,
0.0065808403,
0.004306851,
-0.0061820629,
0.0136912139,
-0.0110392598,
-0.0127657894,
-0.0387558006,
-0.0122159859,
0.0226364229,
0.0639094189,
0.0197510235,
0.012185201,
-0.0206482802,
0.0647537261,
0.0183947571,
0.0789076388,
-0.0393571891,
-0.0656434,
-0.0037948405,
-0.0174280852,
-0.0205421075,
0.0021775216,
0.005186379,
0.0431235172,
-0.0611208528,
-0.0156856999,
0.119137764,
0.0623002984,
0.0162823666,
-0.0007778041,
-0.0289269947,
0.0271510761,
0.030625429,
0.0292849559,
-0.0651593208,
-0.0001635628,
0.0053660488,
-0.0061854557,
-0.0293841884,
-0.0483762696,
-0.0133238202,
-0.1169651672,
-0.0027225863,
0.0229928531,
-0.0105493348,
-0.0034473913,
0.0005595558,
0.0152924396,
0.0037967677,
-0.0042289817,
0.0446230508,
-0.0048219417,
0.0056870473,
0.039931342,
-0.0486887209,
-0.0435948744,
0.0570973977,
0.0219662767,
0.0650893152,
0.0032421681,
0.0452588014,
-0.0102001308,
-0.0505635962,
-0.0011640436,
-0.0131487111,
0.003660575,
-0.019320732,
0.0141596925,
0.0153722418,
-0.0093795629,
0.0028406752,
0.0406942554,
0.0043350374,
-0.0463531204,
0.0134140197,
0.1424569339,
-0.0528755188,
-0.0227609295,
-0.0207464676,
-0.0051303194,
-0.007291649,
0.0531475097,
0.0056748991,
0.0338431075,
-0.0426484905,
-0.001445152,
-0.042973619,
-0.0668328926,
-0.0218323246,
0.0203262903,
-0.0023964555,
0.0295783933,
-0.0759775117,
-0.0514130443,
0.0391466431,
0.011977491,
-0.0021613503,
-0.0061163139,
0.0138925649,
0.0158757251,
-0.0540870242,
0.0299509317,
-0.0519093089,
0.011855118,
0.0049642595,
-0.0468222052,
-0.0061822911,
-0.0104729105,
-0.0203451421,
0.0070522646,
-0.0552134812,
-0.0621281639,
0.004965072,
0.013057637,
0.0147121828,
0.0548812002,
-0.0237574726,
-0.0162617676,
0.0724379346,
-0.0414932892,
0.0053750067,
-0.0311450511,
0.05333874,
0.0322181769,
0.0145453531,
0.0480060428,
-0.0615121052,
-0.0237453226,
-0.0140344286,
0.0622101389,
-0.0412502326,
0.0331228301,
0.0267894119,
-0.0151611995,
-0.0047662905,
0.0222478006,
-0.0220250934,
-0.0211314596,
0.0101099918,
-0.0257400554,
-0.005456557,
0.0107741002,
0.0287451763,
-0.0069821309,
-0.0136511317,
-0.0255368017,
0.002707005,
0.0138460649,
0.0236660484,
0.0055186152,
0.0100459522,
0.038449809,
0.0195301156,
0.0326131545,
-0.0118171116,
-0.0319560729,
-0.0031685084,
-0.0184976291,
0.0533203259,
0.0132470326,
0.0354758427,
0.0274137594,
-0.0037036829,
-0.0691711828,
-0.0335402489,
-0.1123163104,
-0.044770211,
0.0323657133,
-0.0026942564,
0.0523172729,
-0.0337085761,
0.047171779,
-0.0517021827,
0.0051512453,
0.0332972109,
0.0029754855,
0.0373728648,
-0.0321233012,
0.0424668714,
0.0229562689,
0.0052860542,
0.0367451571,
0.0708370283,
-0.0377500653,
0.0863519683,
-0.0086285491,
0.0008724748,
-0.0094846739,
-0.0358735248,
-0.0250346251,
-0.0234054439,
-0.0345533453,
0.0172317792,
-0.0488106683,
-0.0810095668,
0.0047688303,
0.0117725991,
-0.0406597592,
-0.0070756879,
-0.0066016316,
0.0485116169,
0.0451983698,
-0.0471979938,
-0.0292185657,
0.0468055569,
0.0142609607,
0.0088959327,
-0.0568233468,
-6.434745708e-33,
-0.0040893299,
-0.010567138,
0.062501125,
-0.0123895686,
-0.0414636694,
0.0215174966,
-0.0725358799,
-0.0273422189,
-0.0353898406,
0.0112436078,
-0.0134863909,
0.0225139223,
-0.0005240951,
-0.0075897421,
0.036007937,
-0.0136595229,
0.0014774502,
-0.0102874925,
0.0032101809,
0.0180228166,
0.0505959801,
0.0281604081,
0.0399922319,
-0.0059800348,
0.0257082805,
0.0191305317,
0.0063701612,
0.0789659321,
-0.056626454,
0.0540519953,
0.0139264548,
0.0056564179,
0.0286348276,
-0.020274194,
-0.0135018174,
0.02097583,
-0.1144182682,
-0.0518056415,
0.0285142679,
0.0051647597,
-0.0305126552,
-0.025838824,
-0.0268589724,
0.0048074843,
0.0278245118,
-0.0234913472,
0.0289096851,
-0.0450440086,
0.0134270415,
-0.0528328344,
-0.0367437378,
0.0246289354,
-0.0316408873,
0.0037518765,
-0.000880257,
0.0332354903,
0.0378350206,
-0.0120455138,
-0.0412013419,
0.0303101093,
0.0141992038,
-0.0166590642,
0.0467169993,
0.0052677207,
0.0058847661,
0.0157756601,
-0.0253525749,
-0.0064375266,
-0.0511968434,
0.0452995598,
-0.0045185871,
0.0097172679,
0.0103095677,
0.0019402807,
-0.0107367141,
0.0203239527,
-0.066246219,
0.0000012454,
0.0487572514,
0.0843761861,
0.0113204923,
-0.0123099023,
-0.0464766622,
0.0075924611,
-0.026316436,
0.0686341748,
-0.0276386775,
-0.0061140484,
0.0333662704,
0.0152043607,
-0.0231358279,
-0.0118734911,
-0.0036736049,
-0.0375671647,
-0.0082433904,
0.0346531272,
-0.0097188968,
0.0031647873,
-0.015082146,
0.0542127863,
-0.0610042214,
0.0120166531,
0.0117165986,
-0.0167114083,
-0.016868338,
0.0214009937,
0.0342558399,
0.035751421,
-0.0085576745,
-0.0303659681,
-0.0439679623,
-0.0072021638,
0.0006230309,
-0.0388055146,
0.0197529327,
0.0427021906,
-0.0211432427,
0.0119315051,
0.0372080877,
0.0286213439,
-0.0186647326,
0.030579295,
0.0056693694,
0.0097910119,
-0.0298718251,
-0.0221125092,
-0.0407456383,
0.0197826363,
-0.018284766,
-0.0535273552,
-0.0315940641,
0.0219647363,
2.724e-7,
0.0291208029,
0.0356621109,
0.0042001526,
0.0903783515,
0.0307038054,
-0.0046794452,
-0.0277802795,
-0.0536007956,
-0.0005625396,
0.0226220377,
0.04448976,
0.0530604273,
0.048411388,
0.0578127131,
-0.0259006508,
-0.0315860026,
-0.0512858145,
-0.0450999215,
-0.0853575468,
-0.00975182,
0.0685993209,
0.0548028201,
0.0486075804,
-0.0033329136,
0.0019141701,
-0.0566107482,
0.0635837391,
0.0338122621,
-0.019820448,
0.0285252668,
0.0398425311,
0.0096151838,
0.0137747014,
0.0253999867,
-0.0110142902,
0.004937056,
-0.0742393062,
0.0185568109,
-0.0200707093,
-0.0537358411,
-0.0438153297,
-0.0519566648,
0.0227224045,
-0.0580265783,
0.104384467,
-0.0651874244,
-0.0132996924,
0.0038025351,
-0.0120874681,
0.0105186533,
-0.0317623168,
0.0238031093,
-0.0319641493,
-0.0070823357,
0.004678553,
-0.0051879548,
0.0010750679,
-0.0885733664,
-0.009746124,
0.0266992711,
-0.0166587848,
-0.0456627943,
0.0025345825,
-0.0215842556,
-0.0086592808,
-0.0413532518,
0.0340039134,
2.33993079e-34,
0.0152695123,
0.0121407863,
0.0097016124,
0.0527119413,
0.0460807644,
-0.0084921196,
0.0207705181,
-0.018036969,
0.0461109243,
-0.0645321384,
-0.021987725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09144v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09144v2 | Grounding Gaps in Language Model Generations | 2023-11-15T17:40:27 | 2024-04-02T19:34:15 | Omar Shaikh, Kristina Gligorić, Ashna Khetan, Matthias Gerstgrasser, Diyi Yang, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Effective conversation requires common ground: a shared understanding between
the participants. Common ground, however, does not emerge spontaneously in
conversation. Speakers and listeners work together to both identify and
construct a shared basis while avoiding misunderstanding. To accomplish
grounding, humans rely on a range of dialogue acts, like clarification (What do
you mean?) and acknowledgment (I understand.). However, it is unclear whether
large language models (LLMs) generate text that reflects human grounding. To
this end, we curate a set of grounding acts and propose corresponding metrics
that quantify attempted grounding. We study whether LLM generations contain
grounding acts, simulating turn-taking from several dialogue datasets and
comparing results to humans. We find that -- compared to humans -- LLMs
generate language with less conversational grounding, instead generating text
that appears to simply presume common ground. To understand the roots of the
identified grounding gap, we examine the role of instruction tuning and
preference optimization, finding that training on contemporary preference data
leads to a reduction in generated grounding acts. Altogether, we highlight the
need for more research investigating conversational grounding in human-AI
interaction. | [
0.0476368628,
0.0482676253,
-0.026521083,
0.015586298,
-0.021627564,
-0.0059295963,
-0.0334353335,
-0.0194489174,
-0.0096738711,
-0.0405435152,
-0.038206052,
-0.0384906046,
0.0370954908,
-0.0121997576,
0.0049355286,
-0.0306286756,
0.0423143618,
-0.0273928344,
-0.0137994243,
-0.0189666208,
-0.0122590614,
0.0067909649,
-0.0095664281,
0.0543128513,
-0.026109796,
-0.0074979081,
-0.0456410982,
-0.0189151317,
-0.0103733484,
-0.0159687847,
-0.0002067257,
0.0523024797,
0.0447090268,
0.0264928956,
0.0000020343,
-0.0494841933,
0.0528375134,
-0.0699020028,
-0.0594194755,
0.0156706721,
-0.0035193209,
0.0027708414,
0.0054134391,
0.0060296902,
-0.0633126646,
0.0194084924,
0.015906211,
0.0764126405,
0.0374162458,
0.0232648328,
0.0093189785,
-0.0044595189,
0.0285307802,
-0.0200130083,
-0.0038943798,
-0.059156511,
-0.0077279271,
0.0483734235,
-0.0159674138,
0.0139575647,
-0.0264453087,
0.013605467,
0.0272748992,
-0.0382705182,
0.0001416112,
0.0683337823,
-0.0262313765,
-0.0427608676,
-0.0144558791,
0.1047657579,
0.0465590432,
-0.0650258362,
-0.0139171127,
-0.0056414823,
0.0184082743,
-0.0256982148,
-0.0155957825,
0.0424277633,
-0.0095701022,
0.0404091477,
0.0371918269,
-0.0326667279,
0.0104175201,
0.0341541842,
-0.0109204054,
0.1037901267,
-0.0262295641,
-0.0317023024,
0.0364212841,
0.0128645888,
-0.0201136041,
-0.0977317467,
-0.0025125544,
0.0063135191,
-0.0619610548,
0.0301181078,
-0.0651007891,
0.0488257781,
0.0191657413,
-0.0246620402,
0.0231471863,
0.0415185839,
-0.0152009847,
0.0178943686,
0.0191341192,
0.0484918058,
0.0146750491,
0.0131121259,
-0.0185389109,
0.0167380068,
-0.0257861614,
-0.0137653621,
-0.0284067169,
0.0050933328,
-0.0459013283,
-0.0229889192,
0.0066925557,
0.0430827327,
-0.0101660304,
-0.003675434,
-0.0224628951,
0.00781307,
-0.028981572,
0.0351151191,
-0.0332760438,
0.0208084602,
-0.0428986773,
0.0583722182,
0.0368385836,
-0.0896210149,
-0.0169416666,
0.0163166057,
-0.006949225,
0.0072747627,
-0.0183590073,
-0.0043380447,
-0.0229872856,
-0.0172599796,
-0.0386143997,
-0.0135731772,
-0.0331807062,
-0.0708931535,
-0.0212494694,
-0.0196737349,
0.0310325362,
0.0092790453,
-0.0213063341,
-0.0454529859,
0.0268341284,
0.0027269125,
-0.0459879711,
0.0526223779,
-0.0071397,
0.0458186269,
0.0518271327,
0.0126433009,
-0.0187705904,
0.0560641401,
0.0317778364,
-0.0043831267,
0.0335311666,
-0.0057059759,
-0.0196463671,
0.0018533384,
0.0341834687,
0.0005815991,
-0.0051977066,
-0.0056681694,
-0.0396976508,
0.0224917084,
0.0550640598,
0.0389135666,
-0.0307481326,
-0.0267568976,
0.0770035163,
0.0935878381,
-0.0731969029,
0.0069724508,
0.0246249568,
0.0387167707,
-0.0007358784,
0.0498789884,
-0.0524307042,
0.0090913596,
-0.0190413315,
0.001393454,
-0.0065932558,
-0.0080623608,
-0.0417459123,
-0.0370827913,
0.0068368218,
0.0010192551,
0.0572932102,
-0.0116551574,
-0.0121076116,
0.0240796003,
-0.0404506512,
0.0478133075,
0.0284760725,
-0.0711343661,
-0.0069698845,
-0.0327149779,
0.0395590924,
0.041155763,
0.0107089998,
0.055338528,
-0.0546189062,
-0.0035556089,
0.0780806467,
0.0701573938,
0.0431481265,
-0.0196030028,
0.0429309234,
-0.0399342626,
-0.0061471243,
-0.0056238016,
0.0078893779,
0.0187298395,
-0.0074497592,
-0.0169233978,
-0.0004042074,
-0.0422659777,
-0.0253081247,
0.0433297344,
-0.0334172472,
0.0165241826,
-0.0077075395,
0.0115858149,
0.0243636314,
0.0094221132,
-0.0182683319,
-0.0020541472,
0.0356906615,
0.0164154526,
-0.0209494848,
0.0787645653,
-0.0883448943,
0.0126491208,
0.0240703542,
-0.0148243671,
-0.0344223753,
-0.0121757407,
-0.0048367213,
-0.0424574353,
0.0343274064,
-0.022366181,
0.0652773678,
-0.0254019741,
0.0309822336,
-0.0054031848,
0.0164602865,
-0.0226229839,
0.025815323,
-0.0294755772,
-0.0226993822,
0.0146183902,
0.0244772956,
0.0127379317,
-0.0480456986,
0.0249471702,
0.0414954871,
0.0020333682,
-0.0026238833,
0.0272284243,
0.0248715822,
-0.0674976856,
-0.0220477059,
-0.1253682226,
-0.0451792777,
-0.0153250108,
-0.0043858183,
0.0340318084,
-0.0073907902,
-0.0128533887,
-0.0014260382,
-0.0270587001,
-0.0000513917,
0.0152910212,
0.0099849142,
0.0279927664,
0.0123323165,
-0.0080866599,
-0.0480969511,
0.0490347408,
0.0138390101,
-0.0048882863,
-0.0067247404,
0.0200924911,
-0.067836538,
0.0725819692,
-0.0331934728,
0.0269677602,
-0.0341399647,
-0.0415590778,
0.0393421799,
0.0534372106,
0.05426348,
0.079363957,
0.0409190431,
0.0778094456,
0.0517008603,
-0.0115982024,
-0.0850856081,
0.0034002375,
-0.0129500991,
-0.0153404269,
-0.0519213527,
-0.0298421029,
0.0063858521,
0.0780076534,
0.0121635757,
0.0253552552,
-0.0676505044,
0.0005598656,
-0.0053587076,
-0.0594501682,
-0.0133896945,
-0.0272656325,
-0.0468538515,
0.0814674422,
-0.0446423553,
-0.0615970381,
0.0668109804,
-0.0376887433,
-0.0315767042,
-0.0400331803,
-0.0128097944,
0.0008449581,
0.0169215892,
-0.0256545432,
-0.0035665308,
0.0089021111,
-0.0286431853,
-0.0595597737,
-0.0111956513,
0.0111855725,
0.0054690139,
0.1048304066,
-0.0777061284,
-0.0027023028,
0.0341594107,
-0.0236734841,
-0.0570841767,
0.007847649,
-0.0240130927,
0.0054124743,
0.0197682511,
-0.0239197779,
0.0203363672,
-0.021624174,
0.0142564997,
0.0295456313,
-0.0100257918,
0.0055153952,
-0.0122716529,
-0.0246261377,
0.0526774339,
0.0222489759,
0.0217843056,
-0.0331166349,
0.061381463,
0.0355447903,
0.0665520653,
0.0251387171,
-0.0159656294,
0.0043474613,
0.0352250524,
0.0233196877,
-0.0461152047,
0.0352754854,
0.0634525567,
0.009082675,
-0.0350377522,
0.1200034097,
0.0188004784,
-0.0373745561,
0.0424880125,
-0.0445984229,
0.0509405881,
0.0147417514,
-0.0063597392,
-0.0722963214,
0.0004212446,
0.0179505292,
0.020046033,
0.0110430894,
-0.02988079,
-0.0194404367,
-0.0993585661,
0.0340278298,
-0.0075897495,
-0.0776779354,
-0.0243069865,
-0.0257571917,
0.0206390936,
0.0303618256,
0.0696136951,
0.0074057616,
0.0126276221,
-0.0107188392,
0.0255145133,
-0.0059536099,
-0.0569488853,
0.017021101,
-0.0284743663,
0.074985832,
0.0498871394,
0.0507720783,
0.0295937639,
-0.0409356244,
0.0434613489,
0.0036939303,
0.009050386,
-0.037893299,
-0.0001678758,
0.0054151462,
0.0055346903,
-0.0013436802,
0.0521079116,
-0.0202738531,
-0.0151719889,
0.0056017735,
0.0371760055,
-0.0653480217,
-0.0219287779,
0.037442714,
0.054679282,
0.0367449187,
0.0622954629,
0.0843456909,
-0.0615824424,
-0.0058337348,
-0.0097886864,
0.058289133,
-0.0367898867,
-0.0243796352,
-0.0076348153,
0.0019131106,
0.0142567717,
-0.067861639,
-0.060060773,
0.0028656037,
-0.0052432464,
0.0125571676,
-0.0128001161,
0.0184008479,
-0.0358397625,
0.0211950727,
0.0057183458,
-0.0080116056,
0.0069562378,
-0.063256368,
-0.0553686693,
0.0037618035,
-0.0274990536,
-0.0121576805,
-0.0023749785,
-0.0276035517,
-0.0717834383,
0.0281224102,
0.0112503469,
0.0279983431,
0.0471935458,
0.0307658501,
-0.0195626449,
-0.0389036797,
-0.0150705231,
0.0034232943,
0.0503840744,
0.0270563867,
0.0158909485,
0.0080810245,
0.0530561283,
-0.008486798,
0.0039073336,
0.0180252995,
0.0387815051,
-0.0355393775,
-0.0642938837,
0.0200776588,
-0.0029681309,
0.0283158049,
-0.0005243371,
0.0133336252,
-0.0240921956,
0.0182399321,
0.006844718,
-0.0058496068,
-0.045238249,
-0.0244748257,
0.0056092287,
-0.0084685143,
0.014760037,
-0.0119000487,
-0.0549284555,
0.0935060382,
0.008827961,
-0.0039452477,
-0.0177492648,
0.0379769839,
0.0148444967,
0.0221829824,
-0.0010084012,
0.0012277592,
0.0034766053,
0.0454829894,
0.0180674028,
0.0908582434,
0.0221548993,
-0.0276373513,
0.008698361,
0.0234752558,
-0.0583956875,
-0.0518835261,
0.0069145863,
0.0154726207,
0.0481140614,
-0.0140931532,
0.0729700029,
-0.0306681525,
0.0266622193,
-0.0009300679,
0.0551304966,
-0.0003144331,
-0.0630015358,
0.0255315453,
0.009693143,
-0.021548776,
0.0330443755,
0.0796573162,
-0.0108977277,
0.0690508485,
-0.0154042896,
0.0364822634,
-0.0293409824,
-0.0325869583,
-0.0016562606,
0.0016198456,
-0.0294715427,
0.0510795936,
-0.0690392479,
-0.0600321963,
-0.0139374593,
0.0166413635,
0.0190739371,
-0.038663175,
0.0373089686,
0.0577769503,
-0.0272799227,
-0.0086711217,
-0.0327244662,
-0.0090323547,
-0.0281586926,
-0.003983852,
-0.0920514315,
-6.427456908e-33,
-0.0539454333,
-0.0342587978,
0.0026329623,
0.0306189489,
-0.0589824989,
-0.0019536167,
-0.0500159524,
0.0351382121,
-0.0289087594,
0.0146510024,
-0.0364785343,
0.0391302072,
0.0037051865,
0.0061899931,
0.0119607793,
-0.0290820282,
0.0372807458,
-0.028375566,
-0.0458798632,
0.0267997961,
0.0284821074,
-0.0095371511,
0.0408269502,
-0.0856950209,
0.0259146653,
0.0214218404,
-0.0129418904,
0.0053409934,
-0.0391758792,
0.0342823938,
-0.0011163006,
0.0397648737,
0.0131106498,
-0.0434718095,
-0.0225400124,
0.0235087425,
-0.0241017155,
-0.0436992534,
0.0658770278,
0.0090946332,
-0.0127845509,
-0.014570009,
-0.0016933972,
-0.0216613784,
-0.0462833084,
0.0299787987,
0.005527962,
-0.0081933141,
0.003010388,
0.0372636765,
-0.044326663,
-0.023644289,
-0.0300436039,
-0.0636453629,
-0.0101725822,
0.0157648139,
-0.0194423422,
-0.030611556,
-0.0479792841,
0.0566909574,
0.0047233165,
-0.0140837478,
0.0644067526,
-0.0087579964,
0.032556776,
0.0693386421,
0.0306369662,
0.0390237309,
-0.0155191235,
-0.066258207,
0.0404548869,
0.0356116891,
-0.0353419185,
-0.0023482901,
-0.0398591831,
-0.0375142582,
-0.0005106833,
-0.0173292793,
0.0357485078,
0.0662994012,
-0.0134505555,
0.0143283913,
-0.0339103453,
-0.0622484945,
-0.0465902388,
-0.066418156,
-0.0111038536,
-0.026360834,
0.0191640481,
0.0052999882,
-0.0223310459,
-0.046047993,
0.033759892,
-0.0231644604,
-0.0185849052,
0.046375908,
-0.0172169805,
-0.0087120309,
0.0229485519,
-0.0235219076,
-0.08437673,
-0.0285080802,
0.0212233569,
-0.0097988239,
0.029700214,
0.0381838419,
-0.0043605501,
-0.0052879527,
-0.022955155,
-0.004122654,
-0.0213462934,
0.0166832618,
-0.0139632737,
0.0006513078,
0.0255893786,
0.0133379297,
-0.0375098623,
0.0436236933,
0.0013329475,
0.0028634632,
-0.0628949031,
-0.0261038691,
-0.031581182,
0.0390413515,
-0.0461951494,
-0.0145425443,
-0.01926535,
-0.0023587225,
0.038283743,
-0.0182099324,
-0.0322833546,
-0.0240099877,
2.707e-7,
-0.0099951448,
0.0666848794,
0.0274043195,
0.0240694266,
0.0254902802,
0.0392232984,
-0.0112962713,
-0.0195929278,
0.0354478769,
-0.0355304889,
-0.0152998064,
0.0093184505,
0.0710424334,
0.0061378758,
-0.0661178902,
0.008774993,
-0.074916862,
-0.0202185661,
0.0036513577,
-0.0200015288,
0.0220347159,
0.0360680409,
-0.0123612881,
0.0034642101,
-0.0174154378,
0.0201348457,
0.0297771897,
-0.0802379474,
0.0199672841,
0.0113263028,
0.0107394904,
-0.0344362482,
0.0082656043,
0.0583680868,
-0.0039936975,
0.0240201149,
-0.0379235037,
0.0502178334,
-0.0101793762,
-0.0320950449,
-0.0326308534,
0.0203120708,
0.002297513,
-0.0634405687,
0.0205263961,
-0.0390204452,
-0.0168695804,
-0.0388050862,
0.0192426462,
-0.0245119669,
-0.0162096582,
-0.01139687,
-0.0233983453,
0.0040223263,
0.0015036805,
0.0102018788,
0.0231498927,
-0.0454299115,
-0.006116699,
0.0078663435,
-0.0320398584,
-0.0610037446,
-0.0065906905,
-0.0135267032,
0.0148567008,
-0.0096962834,
0.0025166511,
2.186797396e-34,
0.0059490809,
0.0085310917,
0.0591826625,
0.0593588389,
0.0448057093,
-0.0060398486,
0.0754522458,
0.0146437809,
0.0325270668,
-0.0200669412,
-0.0098954644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09136v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09136v2 | Rescue: Ranking LLM Responses with Partial Ordering to Improve Response Generation | 2023-11-15T17:27:14 | 2024-02-17T01:37:09 | Yikun Wang, Rui Zheng, Haoming Li, Qi Zhang, Tao Gui, Fei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Customizing LLMs for a specific task involves distinguishing effective
responses from erroneous ones. This skill can be developed using supervised
fine-tuning with extensive human preference data. However, obtaining
expert-annotated preference data is expensive for most tasks. In this paper, we
present a novel method to optimize LLMs using ranking metrics. This method
trains the model to prioritize the best responses from a pool of candidates
created for a particular task. Rather than a traditional full ordering, we
advocate for a partial ordering, as achieving consensus on the perfect order of
candidate responses can be challenging. Our partial ordering is more robust,
less sensitive to noise, and can be achieved with limited human annotations or
through heuristic methods. We test our system's improved response generation
ability using benchmark datasets, including the latest multi-document question
answering task. We conduct ablation studies to understand crucial factors, such
as how to gather candidate responses for specific tasks, determine their most
suitable order, and balance supervised fine-tuning with ranking metrics. Our
approach, named \textsc{Rescue}, suggests a promising avenue for enhancing
LLMs' contextual understanding via response ranking. | [
0.0510661975,
0.0152291236,
0.0187804159,
0.0562575124,
0.0001849234,
0.0075986143,
-0.0432353057,
0.000101066,
0.0105101923,
-0.0695156232,
-0.0236526206,
-0.0194120668,
-0.0436081626,
-0.0302992091,
0.0277057104,
-0.0392270014,
0.0259931087,
-0.0187526066,
0.020694783,
-0.0171253644,
-0.0132282441,
0.0139702745,
-0.0277332235,
0.0278927907,
0.0455549471,
-0.0072791846,
-0.0054669781,
0.0289182495,
0.0547857024,
-0.0373014733,
0.0472771302,
0.0543139875,
0.0096900249,
-0.0054231142,
0.0000017906,
-0.0623071678,
-0.0260286182,
-0.0157139748,
-0.018952135,
-0.0326845758,
-0.019723624,
0.0471824445,
0.0257346109,
0.0282625053,
-0.0775126815,
0.0448466465,
0.0109082144,
0.0238507353,
0.085850589,
0.077525422,
0.0265763309,
-0.0050459863,
0.0048211096,
-0.0229807682,
0.0392437801,
-0.0461200811,
0.0022686145,
-0.0017246788,
0.0386233032,
0.0523406155,
-0.0089459522,
-0.0019076183,
-0.0014631307,
0.0016306404,
0.020390477,
0.0022080892,
-0.0095436964,
0.0062119425,
0.0028814774,
0.1209094375,
0.0318704545,
0.0178659353,
-0.000135361,
-0.0103946999,
0.0452458113,
0.0192750003,
-0.0560237914,
0.0090895826,
-0.0241036937,
-0.0150087783,
-0.0038142123,
0.0231576618,
-0.0068077864,
0.0252527129,
-0.008988196,
0.064319782,
-0.0114492709,
-0.0405597426,
0.0059645036,
0.0061349059,
-0.0222544856,
-0.0292216968,
0.0102398908,
0.05348574,
-0.0618461259,
0.0032971972,
-0.0009580073,
-0.0192642435,
0.0570914857,
-0.0254403409,
0.0249534976,
0.0167685822,
0.0039362572,
0.0209390502,
-0.0204596072,
0.0264051966,
-0.0298573393,
0.0063260589,
-0.074699685,
0.0002569242,
-0.0560024902,
-0.0373419411,
0.0146708377,
0.0626688078,
-0.0449535996,
0.0207476579,
-0.066257529,
0.0485615395,
-0.0109793991,
-0.0175747443,
0.0111665949,
0.072900407,
-0.0075550722,
-0.0102148624,
-0.0879133418,
-0.0040362123,
-0.0490650907,
0.009180882,
0.0291355196,
-0.0108931931,
-0.0059117395,
0.0222132858,
-0.0102302972,
-0.0278337002,
0.0245879944,
0.0689943731,
-0.0240782425,
-0.0039153867,
0.0054309568,
-0.0300434064,
-0.0028520706,
-0.0295720901,
0.0118480297,
-0.0684947968,
0.0206337217,
0.0349868238,
-0.0293708686,
0.0084361359,
0.0206542425,
0.0360979438,
-0.0386732258,
0.0401280113,
0.0013431108,
-0.0056730551,
0.0240949448,
0.0181757994,
-0.0197206344,
0.0299420673,
0.0125583615,
0.0298177935,
0.0397778973,
0.0007381707,
0.0313615762,
-0.0168309268,
-0.0023036127,
0.00014658,
0.0245082192,
0.0508620441,
-0.0503274314,
0.0450891331,
0.0511407368,
-0.0134571828,
-0.0361026898,
-0.0312194526,
0.028725367,
0.0489557274,
0.0053076423,
0.0060409158,
-0.0045564123,
0.0106569501,
-0.0017262248,
0.0478839949,
-0.0330739021,
0.0669746697,
-0.0254868139,
0.0203727912,
0.0418181121,
0.0086208563,
-0.0165717229,
-0.0491210148,
0.0124792932,
0.0226935893,
-0.046465788,
0.0581789091,
-0.0003173469,
0.0158734694,
-0.0426496118,
0.061594069,
-0.0106223207,
-0.0415411666,
-0.0106580136,
-0.0570776761,
0.0347683616,
0.0884103328,
0.0407303832,
-0.0567228869,
-0.0683775023,
0.0166380294,
0.0050279903,
0.024660673,
0.0228598621,
-0.028171381,
0.0123165371,
-0.0434268899,
-0.0281389505,
-0.0111562265,
-0.027054118,
0.0279375389,
0.02246828,
-0.0315802656,
0.0210380889,
-0.0395890661,
-0.0046670008,
0.0203835703,
-0.0005261262,
-0.0417380407,
0.0383333042,
-0.0039670737,
0.0305467825,
0.026627345,
0.0142890224,
0.0382226519,
0.0511255004,
-0.0229310673,
-0.0069373124,
-0.0287259649,
-0.0349169262,
-0.0223080944,
0.0215254854,
-0.0393609442,
-0.0455130897,
0.0579327494,
-0.0589754842,
-0.033938095,
-0.0296189971,
-0.0070483396,
-0.0041597974,
-0.0369562283,
-0.0215491261,
0.0537038073,
-0.0195003822,
-0.1059846804,
0.0902863741,
-0.0132623008,
0.0465573817,
0.0486102812,
0.0133405151,
-0.0079289731,
-0.0714061558,
0.0089620566,
-0.020108832,
-0.0081739919,
0.0079688877,
0.0320317298,
0.0349743515,
-0.0694456473,
-0.0397896469,
-0.0846557096,
0.019465575,
-0.0073249489,
0.0270605423,
0.0149287814,
0.0044734315,
-0.0050730989,
-0.0377387479,
-0.0659839362,
-0.0130155804,
0.0347004235,
0.0241885204,
0.0527328514,
0.0080467658,
0.0148637872,
-0.0529463366,
-0.0009607609,
0.0072043277,
0.0051577371,
-0.003419816,
0.0257151946,
-0.0477309935,
0.0208368786,
-0.0439611301,
0.0079516517,
-0.0074177156,
-0.0336663723,
0.0340859108,
-0.0284532867,
0.0202517528,
0.0554244183,
0.0450797006,
0.0245071799,
0.0347409919,
0.0140142115,
-0.0835495517,
0.0135409608,
-0.0369184427,
-0.0195904523,
-0.0158683099,
-0.0425458662,
0.0147859249,
0.0248352382,
0.0101375729,
-0.0082587497,
-0.0364777111,
0.0141644292,
0.0432629026,
-0.0384085067,
-0.0529368706,
0.0077368352,
-0.0230629761,
0.0352525935,
-0.0170303695,
-0.006841416,
0.0691366345,
0.0167064406,
0.0166116189,
-0.0411212333,
-0.0025084682,
-0.0588436387,
0.0099684857,
-0.0064436961,
0.0040770932,
-0.0469406694,
-0.0010548412,
-0.0869772658,
-0.0043795947,
0.0275694672,
-0.0589744784,
0.0416903682,
-0.053081926,
0.0042104456,
-0.0275628231,
-0.0515445471,
-0.0626040399,
-0.053974472,
0.0172828119,
0.0014417489,
0.010361054,
-0.0071907593,
-0.0128447739,
-0.0259542521,
0.0507936738,
-0.0086205555,
-0.0326888599,
-0.0280059017,
-0.0187312439,
0.0992572159,
0.0594359972,
0.0743057579,
0.047254134,
-0.0198907647,
0.0080759358,
0.0771833137,
0.0500583574,
-0.0077906088,
0.0019969831,
-0.0153013449,
0.0449770354,
-0.0533059835,
0.01244576,
0.0183610953,
0.0183306597,
-0.0162671674,
-0.010130859,
0.0973503292,
0.0318251997,
-0.0298239514,
0.0028411716,
-0.0303037651,
0.0469705425,
0.0290553626,
0.0565173514,
-0.0348429419,
-0.0139907748,
-0.0306536667,
0.0565966666,
0.0007744461,
-0.0253057219,
0.006933826,
-0.1081472114,
0.0385280661,
-0.0108425803,
-0.0335011333,
0.0010545024,
-0.0263498966,
-0.0029358617,
0.0163541809,
-0.0082817469,
0.0372315347,
-0.0260568894,
0.0012497377,
0.0555239208,
0.0096203517,
-0.0311261881,
0.0128164114,
0.0001636515,
0.0200141892,
0.05508193,
0.0148930224,
-0.0059224688,
-0.0033997467,
0.0186786335,
-0.0249709748,
0.0402191132,
-0.0049165613,
0.0237140153,
-0.009637272,
0.0106581477,
-0.0435645133,
0.0309749432,
-0.0485008359,
-0.0183945913,
0.0277320612,
0.0398902483,
-0.048681248,
0.0328483209,
-0.0407024957,
0.0307257418,
-0.0011707469,
0.0612550154,
0.0211242363,
-0.0268125702,
-0.0265683271,
-0.0380295143,
0.017684171,
-0.0907125026,
-0.0274231713,
0.0128089301,
0.0029165365,
0.0503261313,
-0.0947841108,
-0.0315279998,
0.0140976915,
0.0434804223,
-0.0287550353,
0.0193803012,
-0.0549848601,
-0.002612489,
-0.0241794065,
0.0322746858,
0.0083852606,
-0.0233127922,
-0.0703601837,
-0.0190977324,
0.0555022098,
-0.0456731655,
-0.0307364073,
0.0122886412,
-0.0486027822,
-0.0449622497,
-0.0191197488,
0.0975030735,
0.0229706522,
0.0219058581,
0.0149252191,
-0.0799664482,
0.036039222,
0.0541459769,
-0.0327061154,
0.0033678522,
0.0161264874,
0.0271454882,
-0.0354209468,
0.0158226322,
-0.0733251572,
0.0063926294,
0.0112584345,
0.0545887873,
-0.0489908755,
-0.0661089271,
0.0200967249,
0.015921995,
-0.0054545375,
-0.0257178582,
-0.0216013305,
-0.0105199665,
0.0533032566,
-0.0065680817,
-0.0287316889,
-0.0149861164,
0.0071288724,
-0.0039102728,
-0.0614645705,
0.0085815135,
-0.0247952696,
-0.0154454531,
0.0531660579,
-0.0625877976,
0.0027377845,
0.0372412317,
-0.0054908316,
0.008446577,
0.0054451348,
-0.0358975641,
0.0008163179,
0.0255950913,
0.0726197883,
0.0158052463,
0.0497282073,
0.0122882212,
-0.0097887488,
-0.0032089606,
0.0446431115,
-0.1000115871,
-0.0585927144,
-0.0352060422,
0.0166150704,
0.0502532497,
0.0283534341,
0.0278950166,
0.0157064181,
-0.0017723567,
-0.0115044331,
0.0079521667,
0.0032716286,
0.0299947355,
0.0268650409,
0.0505516157,
0.0151778143,
0.0272055082,
0.0809034705,
0.0108574014,
-0.0258751139,
0.0038636902,
0.0019563881,
-0.0526229553,
-0.0491394959,
-0.0061230422,
0.0404371805,
0.0023331742,
0.0153209167,
-0.0490380563,
-0.0330738202,
0.0155304763,
0.0319571458,
-0.0081433905,
-0.0208815243,
0.0493661091,
0.0541176647,
0.0096618673,
-0.0155294565,
-0.053232599,
0.0089124646,
-0.0528125353,
-0.0299543738,
-0.0423255265,
-6.195255632e-33,
-0.0296824649,
-0.0927780569,
0.0320269838,
-0.0139103858,
0.0243236907,
-0.010111778,
0.0051432219,
0.0105916625,
-0.0217212457,
-0.0152427396,
-0.0225197077,
-0.0130098974,
0.0004931525,
0.0184451398,
0.001379187,
-0.0297970232,
0.000649826,
-0.0011111996,
-0.0243133847,
0.0113094701,
0.0367357247,
0.0120571265,
0.0271325018,
-0.0666427985,
0.0301880743,
-0.015708223,
-0.0070587853,
0.0339897871,
-0.0462401547,
0.0810557604,
-0.0021750436,
0.0414849184,
0.0491175838,
-0.0127186235,
-0.0038190028,
0.0228013396,
-0.0630450249,
-0.0510984845,
0.0116509823,
-0.0436190926,
-0.0601870418,
-0.0385564491,
0.0294389129,
0.0100379605,
0.0045680408,
-0.0198995154,
0.0434040576,
-0.0298410468,
-0.0500733852,
-0.0487261936,
-0.0153783811,
0.0095084356,
-0.0133506572,
-0.0206448659,
-0.0322346091,
0.0809117332,
-0.0243765526,
0.0520355999,
-0.0162605178,
-0.0035194757,
0.0056324573,
0.0372459739,
0.0488917567,
0.0155302314,
-0.0450478941,
0.0628662631,
0.0005724587,
0.0077930936,
0.0218230039,
-0.0659555942,
-0.0585899651,
0.0593652651,
0.0382051542,
0.0820856616,
0.0003044795,
0.0441885032,
-0.0605229884,
0.0941779763,
0.0183567517,
0.0009199574,
0.0380984209,
0.0067378497,
-0.0060690977,
0.0090483455,
-0.0329981707,
0.0354713053,
-0.0453020819,
-0.0058895978,
0.0384889208,
0.0074231531,
-0.05100457,
-0.0366614796,
0.0324535146,
-0.0184503086,
0.007083416,
0.0048687928,
-0.0157081299,
0.0107521461,
0.0218767449,
-0.0015288711,
-0.024651859,
0.0096320575,
0.0208662096,
-0.039846871,
-0.0025137088,
0.0172295198,
0.0007133547,
-0.0394862704,
-0.031558834,
-0.000679429,
-0.0246937554,
0.038981393,
-0.0454189144,
-0.0160301998,
-0.0162369572,
0.0027921619,
-0.0125078727,
0.0560436025,
-0.0107400641,
-0.0033143163,
-0.0077587618,
-0.0180727839,
-0.0043301457,
0.0192037392,
-0.0136838686,
0.0442729518,
0.0340753719,
0.0273956917,
-0.0153829847,
-0.0247603767,
-0.0210245103,
0.04442323,
2.451e-7,
0.0647196844,
0.0222661495,
0.0220400561,
0.0383814424,
0.0045225588,
0.0278239194,
0.0088183554,
0.0300395302,
0.0642137453,
-0.0111677367,
0.0230586771,
0.0177599639,
0.0322203748,
0.028322991,
-0.0919926912,
-0.0337157883,
-0.0460924581,
-0.0094997231,
-0.0080681415,
-0.0428372473,
0.0736907348,
0.0410578437,
-0.0375349931,
-0.0212071128,
-0.0393084772,
-0.0049770894,
0.0617714897,
-0.0545045175,
-0.0232234225,
-0.0000031787,
0.0444672257,
-0.0388929024,
0.015841661,
0.0235543102,
-0.0134136807,
-0.0201261397,
0.024084555,
0.0458717085,
-0.003983418,
-0.1218282804,
-0.0111233275,
-0.0080946842,
0.0654753521,
-0.0358910449,
0.0440121889,
-0.033214815,
0.0031138242,
0.0031051887,
-0.047790207,
-0.0076551577,
-0.015003778,
-0.0373714156,
-0.0310153607,
0.0118091088,
0.0015552936,
0.0049498552,
-0.0088328673,
-0.0635920689,
-0.0154352952,
0.0328683965,
-0.0398973972,
-0.0667578205,
-0.0099586481,
0.0017016951,
0.0209064744,
-0.0451265685,
-0.0350892805,
2.14410491e-34,
0.0095340209,
0.0039935946,
0.019294709,
0.0740175992,
0.0150094936,
0.0307199173,
-0.0429955088,
0.0184969828,
0.0544391908,
-0.0703962073,
-0.0240428969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09132v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09132v1 | Aligning Neural Machine Translation Models: Human Feedback in Training and Inference | 2023-11-15T17:21:58 | 2023-11-15T17:21:58 | Miguel Moura Ramos, Patrick Fernandes, António Farinhas, André F. T. Martins | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a recent technique to
improve the quality of the text generated by a language model, making it closer
to what humans would generate. A core ingredient in RLHF's success in aligning
and improving large language models (LLMs) is its reward model, trained using
human feedback on model outputs. In machine translation (MT), where metrics
trained from human annotations can readily be used as reward models, recent
methods using minimum Bayes risk decoding and reranking have succeeded in
improving the final quality of translation. In this study, we comprehensively
explore and compare techniques for integrating quality metrics as reward models
into the MT pipeline. This includes using the reward model for data filtering,
during the training phase through RL, and at inference time by employing
reranking techniques, and we assess the effects of combining these in a unified
approach. Our experimental results, conducted across multiple translation
tasks, underscore the crucial role of effective data filtering, based on
estimated quality, in harnessing the full potential of RL in enhancing MT
quality. Furthermore, our findings demonstrate the effectiveness of combining
RL training with reranking techniques, showcasing substantial improvements in
translation quality. | [
0.0297638774,
0.066126965,
0.0045371298,
0.0242068581,
0.006547634,
0.0133769475,
-0.0280610826,
0.0056266673,
-0.0273060743,
-0.0011954039,
-0.045434501,
-0.0194208696,
0.0290921293,
-0.0405708104,
0.0323280469,
-0.0649736375,
0.0190460496,
-0.0180870797,
-0.000877801,
0.0018777463,
-0.0106812622,
0.0031236806,
0.0129921623,
0.0556526296,
0.0177958217,
0.0075286222,
0.0317111388,
0.0449240021,
0.0507210009,
-0.0254307054,
-0.0178144258,
0.0564163215,
0.0023517571,
0.0727756545,
0.0000021034,
-0.0293828752,
-0.0145336008,
0.0241121091,
-0.0105588501,
-0.0182549879,
0.0261031874,
-0.0282411147,
-0.0135698328,
0.0141259162,
-0.0281102452,
-0.0181108285,
0.048431851,
0.0235962402,
0.0600740239,
0.0643779635,
0.0093233818,
-0.0015247752,
-0.0030123219,
-0.0662441552,
0.0006541407,
-0.0456165075,
-0.0003550921,
0.0479731932,
-0.0212005172,
0.0285178237,
0.001177009,
0.0398590341,
0.0362258181,
-0.0102969054,
0.0304674041,
0.0403138883,
0.0277534351,
-0.0324360244,
-0.014929248,
0.0352252275,
-0.0582298562,
-0.0119917104,
-0.0274113994,
-0.0230794847,
0.0094683422,
-0.0157632697,
-0.0201640651,
0.036543265,
0.006179464,
0.031064691,
0.0296433456,
0.0430049002,
0.0426134691,
0.0259307176,
-0.0252840053,
0.0257609189,
-0.0006871634,
-0.037797682,
-0.0120015666,
0.0513514131,
-0.0123924883,
-0.0221971888,
0.0218995847,
-0.0252661202,
-0.0082080634,
0.017613614,
-0.0307124481,
-0.0504363924,
-0.001985203,
-0.0404214263,
-0.0036805449,
0.0528766662,
0.0291220453,
0.0258651767,
-0.0011999459,
0.0614345893,
-0.0017658244,
0.0523280278,
-0.0663181469,
0.0242469311,
-0.0042962264,
0.0057801544,
0.0224264208,
0.0067219306,
-0.0309455898,
0.0121722389,
-0.0602171905,
0.001091313,
-0.0266618375,
0.0062090051,
0.0475982986,
0.0045998255,
-0.0860942826,
-0.0010897268,
-0.0490145162,
0.0425441898,
0.003713965,
-0.0155400597,
0.0423751958,
-0.0228849873,
-0.0185718797,
-0.0029583985,
-0.0469536632,
-0.0327447951,
-0.0261263233,
0.0726211742,
-0.0214048605,
-0.0198695417,
0.0254259333,
-0.0241813287,
-0.0218144935,
-0.0324352793,
0.0060241949,
-0.0471752696,
0.0527704731,
-0.0283415094,
0.004428342,
-0.0398504436,
0.0103002833,
-0.0026163603,
-0.0255129803,
0.041448269,
0.0164324008,
0.0135446675,
0.0291475803,
0.0085406769,
-0.0199098662,
0.0417430401,
0.0623092242,
0.0672289208,
0.0151973134,
0.0119367391,
-0.0106585734,
0.0337066129,
0.0150246071,
0.0345124453,
-0.0289404299,
-0.0176278651,
-0.0130390814,
0.0479790717,
0.0645357966,
0.0305563435,
-0.0653591529,
0.0290954541,
0.1144740656,
0.0213373955,
0.0243011564,
0.0009976954,
0.0120189497,
0.0121353744,
-0.0178358965,
0.0242673066,
-0.0426348336,
0.0267746709,
0.0360139757,
-0.0027085394,
0.0606209785,
0.0385385305,
0.0133816889,
-0.0788006634,
-0.0040456648,
-0.0175844952,
0.0193716828,
0.0194520634,
0.0481578037,
0.0136785638,
-0.0297263898,
-0.004546212,
0.0281892139,
-0.0298354048,
0.0423628092,
-0.0470464677,
0.0175493099,
0.0753835738,
0.0604946017,
-0.0130731529,
-0.0161557738,
-0.0079484992,
-0.045214694,
0.0411269069,
0.0389673002,
0.0143430615,
0.0201840438,
-0.027118383,
-0.0352988318,
0.0360679403,
0.0227803197,
0.0154729458,
-0.0054635257,
-0.0293171294,
0.0186018944,
-0.0166705642,
-0.1128944755,
0.0540394671,
0.0059047225,
-0.0216864422,
0.0438550115,
0.0157188606,
0.0278191268,
0.0059413426,
-0.0124154994,
0.0222605467,
0.0296632387,
-0.0165454075,
-0.0172265973,
0.0279572736,
-0.0356756859,
-0.0613407232,
0.001087502,
-0.0376430862,
-0.0189084522,
0.0331887528,
-0.0430006608,
-0.0142339095,
-0.0104738008,
-0.042459663,
-0.0204842351,
-0.043112956,
0.0301117245,
-0.003961869,
-0.0246813465,
-0.0776220784,
0.0502019562,
-0.0294124056,
0.0134455115,
-0.0190430451,
-0.0696410611,
-0.0136709809,
-0.060575828,
0.0008715661,
0.0342593342,
0.0005778096,
0.0428100377,
0.0641748458,
0.0526113957,
-0.0168607328,
-0.0214161891,
-0.0251001455,
0.0027082206,
-0.0048740446,
0.0275042318,
0.0341776982,
0.025554888,
0.0053577661,
-0.0140392175,
-0.0225436427,
-0.0769728795,
0.015415702,
0.0017366637,
0.0386144482,
-0.0039585871,
0.0338867828,
-0.035361059,
-0.0311655626,
0.0145596787,
0.0387329943,
0.017418826,
-0.0133603783,
-0.0783476606,
0.0404267572,
-0.042240046,
-0.0083774934,
0.0163559075,
-0.0512402467,
0.0195982959,
0.0023120821,
0.0263317022,
0.0841627344,
0.0048605935,
0.0353419408,
0.0509636216,
0.0352101736,
-0.0848872289,
-0.0067070131,
-0.0551270172,
-0.0115381461,
-0.0065349853,
-0.0603847764,
0.0238260105,
0.0405728631,
0.0243450236,
-0.0060723438,
-0.0851626322,
0.0476166531,
-0.0398098268,
-0.0619651675,
-0.047176566,
0.0089103933,
-0.0062300614,
0.0332780518,
-0.0482440405,
-0.0722405836,
0.0966241434,
-0.0122614857,
0.028547395,
-0.0624829084,
0.0106377294,
0.0011527378,
-0.0105206277,
-0.000648096,
0.0360869542,
-0.0499063358,
-0.0111431805,
-0.0565836094,
0.0005106234,
0.049067881,
-0.0468336791,
0.0021611315,
-0.0620775372,
-0.0266880691,
-0.0190826207,
-0.0321558453,
-0.0411425978,
0.0020984975,
0.02253123,
-0.0068816249,
0.0005240354,
0.0002510234,
-0.0000359993,
-0.0010912322,
0.0506212339,
0.0271974243,
-0.0356121175,
-0.0092651201,
-0.0037787936,
0.0278433412,
-0.0022925693,
-0.0228669196,
0.0413476825,
-0.0725147426,
0.0183729809,
0.0391934067,
0.0339269489,
0.0034087868,
-0.0193760935,
-0.0316784419,
0.0508831963,
0.0083425185,
-0.0158949923,
0.0224884935,
0.0442992039,
-0.0725197196,
-0.0125384526,
0.0901373327,
0.0219181962,
-0.0473496579,
0.0066272346,
0.0042307102,
0.0545671992,
0.0040852027,
0.0297097638,
-0.05623601,
-0.0064951386,
0.0209318027,
0.0598908998,
0.0243667364,
0.0008840907,
0.0044929171,
-0.0960686058,
0.0452120565,
0.0346519165,
-0.0428893119,
-0.0413690172,
-0.0370622501,
-0.023528574,
-0.0447585359,
0.0153909521,
0.0140466699,
0.029882852,
0.0206165463,
0.0367315412,
0.0341073126,
-0.0710023195,
-0.0276636481,
-0.0752779618,
0.0259195305,
0.1133353263,
0.0377203599,
0.0125094606,
-0.0526406914,
-0.023005059,
-0.0025622633,
-0.0082279891,
0.0162043348,
0.0161872692,
-0.0135912392,
0.0045754607,
-0.0085261175,
0.0117783975,
0.0172327291,
0.0133808143,
-0.0359811597,
0.0444279425,
-0.0187329315,
0.016988229,
0.0016322037,
-0.01813698,
0.0036766068,
0.0608955957,
0.0263164882,
-0.0589339249,
-0.0074625709,
-0.0253423546,
0.0313107185,
-0.0523626879,
-0.0162719637,
0.0337133035,
-0.0480335578,
-0.0563342236,
-0.1111035869,
-0.068271026,
-0.0242114924,
0.014685493,
-0.007225649,
-0.0054302486,
0.0067850617,
-0.0144298868,
-0.0008021408,
0.061322283,
-0.0335097648,
0.0119648902,
-0.0403343141,
0.0356679559,
-0.0611054339,
-0.0621707626,
-0.0241579227,
0.0111943828,
-0.0864694193,
-0.0506833754,
-0.0362114422,
0.0915317312,
0.0223611221,
0.0495361947,
-0.0283593498,
-0.053479448,
0.0009710988,
0.0054374933,
-0.0406514108,
0.0103973793,
0.0146801248,
0.007923089,
-0.0147611182,
0.0321621783,
-0.0354074463,
0.0080053201,
-0.0017811143,
0.04873541,
0.0130470656,
-0.0344872512,
0.0381413475,
0.0076581845,
0.0453737937,
-0.0560219921,
-0.046803657,
-0.0552247725,
-0.0011469178,
-0.0312133953,
-0.0411410816,
-0.0292756017,
0.0029453519,
0.0560212359,
0.0301958043,
-0.0076558525,
-0.0108327419,
0.0051688203,
0.0103538278,
-0.0309044234,
-0.0289465804,
-0.0270947199,
0.0053744921,
-0.0070778267,
0.0441715308,
-0.0143685816,
0.0042913435,
-0.0025916614,
0.038370423,
-0.0298429355,
0.0229259878,
0.0314960554,
-0.001429374,
0.0073340996,
0.0627199113,
-0.0518467389,
-0.0392618775,
-0.0477846712,
-0.0357780829,
0.0692732558,
0.0172640383,
0.1196249798,
0.0067805685,
-0.0095910849,
-0.0064382446,
0.0237132721,
0.003845582,
-0.0031743092,
0.0004028117,
-0.0011361887,
0.0042311698,
-0.0082134502,
0.0710497797,
-0.0085854195,
-0.0106750252,
-0.040485777,
-0.0373301767,
-0.0126975849,
0.0043378347,
0.0087664425,
-0.008417598,
-0.0340225585,
-0.0403555147,
-0.0309067145,
-0.0513697788,
-0.0313751251,
0.0538683422,
0.0069962144,
-0.0160284936,
0.023156466,
0.0511345454,
-0.071152851,
-0.0115848817,
-0.0689043105,
-0.0478920341,
-0.0100561231,
-0.0226517115,
-0.0403918475,
-6.599696953e-33,
-0.0159380082,
-0.0314278938,
-0.0015289079,
-0.0445749462,
-0.0379409455,
0.007253475,
-0.0191403981,
-0.0285523143,
0.0134938546,
0.0358379856,
0.0093932524,
0.0023890859,
0.0128044626,
0.0116836876,
0.0152047547,
0.0179558992,
0.0558694527,
0.0049303761,
-0.0562662296,
0.005460599,
0.0093009174,
0.0018498196,
0.0698270798,
-0.0513201617,
0.0560562611,
0.0225002225,
-0.0367253348,
0.0368133411,
-0.0092076147,
0.0443559736,
-0.0020946965,
0.0117069706,
0.0271461662,
-0.0674824938,
-0.01945851,
-0.0201943982,
-0.0740791708,
0.0072837668,
-0.0060677864,
-0.0012987464,
-0.0449610017,
-0.0174768809,
0.0737977996,
-0.0101093249,
-0.0314438418,
-0.0014595579,
0.0238345657,
-0.031861864,
-0.0561374091,
-0.0116283344,
-0.0321429484,
0.0294749439,
-0.0119863451,
-0.0219391882,
0.0390442647,
0.0623488389,
-0.0332110263,
0.025199905,
-0.0728648156,
0.0331312418,
-0.0145513574,
0.0401627682,
0.0782866701,
0.0340351649,
-0.0110411495,
0.0229328033,
0.0206511002,
0.0012836133,
0.0174421109,
-0.0192683153,
0.0317011066,
0.0072515612,
0.0668658093,
0.0303128678,
0.0342427865,
0.0029271531,
-0.0725177303,
0.0686830282,
-0.0430647768,
0.0256657656,
0.0164603889,
0.0472592972,
-0.0600914285,
-0.0155095505,
-0.065342702,
-0.0593393333,
-0.0220854655,
-0.0186441708,
0.0060539045,
0.0421163104,
-0.0544746555,
-0.027020473,
0.0416666456,
-0.0126112457,
0.0228307825,
-0.0273694526,
-0.031730637,
-0.0151035869,
-0.0137459654,
0.0215882603,
-0.0460137278,
0.0204808116,
0.0126357293,
0.0150091331,
-0.0077920947,
-0.007761158,
0.0443721637,
0.0068869158,
-0.0165590364,
0.035751339,
-0.0484704413,
0.0198566336,
0.0029474611,
0.0333002508,
0.0363960639,
-0.0185575075,
-0.0102233151,
0.0530293509,
0.0428153723,
0.0108820144,
-0.0202634335,
0.018695889,
0.0327589922,
-0.0072214603,
-0.0134849809,
0.0145380283,
-0.0107368063,
0.0351240449,
0.0613038354,
-0.0522805378,
-0.0478422455,
-0.0030696243,
2.797e-7,
0.0486063547,
0.0669208691,
0.0163789168,
0.0253370497,
0.0069426238,
0.0460621603,
0.0077672531,
0.0195259489,
0.0317236111,
0.0447480865,
0.0226152558,
0.0134012569,
0.0820036829,
0.0296418816,
-0.0423372649,
-0.051903557,
-0.0814406127,
0.010191869,
-0.0209462866,
-0.0567974932,
0.019549815,
0.0600756481,
0.0028303631,
0.0058485195,
0.0061470522,
0.0093799131,
0.0724120364,
-0.0398555882,
-0.0162684191,
0.0012118067,
0.0758210048,
0.014711272,
-0.0063355332,
-0.0262058098,
-0.0365638398,
-0.0037230584,
0.0389109105,
0.0574229695,
-0.0294752158,
-0.0081443666,
-0.0138445459,
0.0137636708,
0.0365762487,
-0.0832377449,
0.0099473493,
-0.0706187114,
-0.0111347623,
0.0020213944,
-0.0154979089,
-0.0035272164,
0.048383262,
-0.0407514423,
-0.0482779928,
0.0305969343,
0.033181861,
0.0442755371,
-0.0281858929,
-0.0325026661,
-0.0612983108,
-0.0223349147,
-0.0256198123,
-0.0413910337,
-0.0198946223,
0.0001459448,
-0.0182808992,
-0.0617067926,
-0.0251472294,
2.669438846e-34,
0.0287902765,
-0.0313886963,
0.025371043,
-0.0051302803,
0.053932216,
0.0081711318,
-0.0080534006,
0.0002813078,
0.0183060765,
-0.0279909316,
-0.0329173245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09130v1 | Social Meme-ing: Measuring Linguistic Variation in Memes | 2023-11-15T17:20:20 | 2023-11-15T17:20:20 | Naitian Zhou, David Jurgens, David Bamman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Much work in the space of NLP has used computational methods to explore
sociolinguistic variation in text. In this paper, we argue that memes, as
multimodal forms of language comprised of visual templates and text, also
exhibit meaningful social variation. We construct a computational pipeline to
cluster individual instances of memes into templates and semantic variables,
taking advantage of their multimodal structure in doing so. We apply this
method to a large collection of meme images from Reddit and make available the
resulting \textsc{SemanticMemes} dataset of 3.8M images clustered by their
semantic function. We use these clusters to analyze linguistic variation in
memes, discovering not only that socially meaningful variation in meme usage
exists between subreddits, but that patterns of meme innovation and
acculturation within these communities align with previous findings on written
language. | [
0.0398303345,
0.0417548008,
-0.0599255487,
0.0038090388,
0.0046962593,
0.0206103604,
-0.0161381774,
0.0554201119,
0.0332468413,
-0.0553699099,
-0.0003467615,
-0.000604365,
0.0122579671,
0.0341215171,
0.0357002057,
-0.089863874,
0.0162194669,
0.0369634405,
-0.0006552489,
-0.0293765031,
0.0368183367,
0.0379771367,
0.017018307,
0.03112478,
-0.0607236661,
0.0035074996,
0.0469081923,
0.0066544767,
0.0158663653,
0.0102651753,
0.0049093706,
0.0319595337,
-0.002479509,
0.0208946746,
0.0000017836,
-0.0106204646,
0.0303360261,
-0.0688939765,
0.0394669175,
-0.0031008141,
0.0842627436,
-0.0351376235,
-0.0006313033,
-0.0087317023,
-0.0299587734,
-0.0256540701,
0.0834970325,
-0.0390459746,
0.057192415,
0.035645023,
-0.0348476991,
-0.051684808,
-0.0376068316,
-0.0049253115,
0.0069938358,
0.0226613414,
-0.020581454,
0.0011195353,
-0.0023830815,
0.0264804158,
-0.0244561844,
0.0488443375,
0.0012350527,
0.0199954491,
0.0023168188,
0.035948839,
-0.0175303519,
-0.0403411388,
0.0077143069,
0.0267645754,
0.0226287544,
-0.009742748,
0.0680777654,
0.0131687969,
0.007176443,
0.0409286134,
-0.0613065101,
0.0214749686,
0.0183283966,
0.0228054542,
-0.0054710628,
0.0149956467,
0.0103908405,
0.0181914773,
0.0080888811,
0.0238971394,
0.0176815521,
0.0383419134,
-0.059794791,
0.0170162115,
-0.0285840314,
-0.0203178301,
0.0452359319,
-0.0210878737,
0.0168164931,
0.048367843,
-0.0313078426,
-0.0683368817,
0.0338305868,
-0.0547306947,
0.0118213287,
-0.0457400605,
-0.0050695781,
0.0659784749,
0.0024565782,
-0.0231123753,
-0.0276278239,
-0.0052422467,
-0.0120205684,
-0.036250364,
-0.0617715567,
-0.0059153927,
-0.0024587661,
-0.0227327608,
0.0075730281,
-0.0283325277,
-0.0466252975,
0.0496787764,
-0.0229768418,
-0.0458655059,
-0.040289361,
0.0130231259,
0.0260585863,
0.0285362974,
0.0099889077,
-0.0014041944,
-0.0718539283,
-0.0017637759,
-0.0318510868,
-0.0388537347,
0.0619699135,
0.0111455843,
0.0678589866,
-0.0285639763,
-0.0332911387,
0.0313921049,
0.0094860727,
0.0088755852,
-0.0029628307,
-0.0433531031,
-0.0437163673,
0.0217009876,
0.0373633057,
-0.1171227917,
0.054623276,
0.0417338163,
0.0438390262,
-0.0256727003,
-0.0333874971,
0.0291948151,
-0.0583555996,
0.028156111,
0.015675595,
0.033923123,
0.0737778246,
0.0212582648,
0.00303173,
0.0215124842,
-0.0094887745,
0.0011394171,
0.1083978266,
-0.0375679173,
-0.0171383582,
0.049676612,
-0.0012462612,
0.0246975534,
-0.0033670282,
-0.0046595489,
-0.0061995122,
-0.0396914557,
0.0027016746,
0.0137236202,
-0.027475724,
-0.0217510853,
0.0442212299,
0.089870438,
-0.0117263962,
0.0332201272,
-0.0104778474,
0.0331023596,
0.0066435463,
-0.0260613058,
0.0265127048,
0.009965661,
-0.0219827555,
-0.0466131903,
0.0443063453,
0.0505464263,
-0.0315960832,
-0.00411386,
0.0002929796,
-0.0029753193,
0.0438404493,
-0.0503533818,
0.0054872213,
0.0098378807,
0.0489699282,
0.0561250299,
0.0206702761,
-0.0434925929,
-0.0095619839,
0.0182411466,
0.0320236459,
0.0130982315,
-0.0054863682,
-0.0291546267,
0.0416127108,
0.0214081407,
0.0554997399,
0.0451931767,
-0.0349499024,
0.0341091938,
-0.027954042,
-0.0226019584,
0.0171491448,
0.0001167277,
0.0204707552,
-0.0233430415,
0.0434580185,
0.0467036664,
-0.0098283608,
0.0236999039,
-0.017282445,
-0.0198082346,
0.0388809256,
0.0518564172,
-0.013000194,
0.0208060443,
0.0373572893,
0.0104021486,
-0.0084690349,
-0.0465191677,
-0.0167987943,
-0.0383785516,
-0.0367796645,
0.0703861192,
-0.0364059135,
-0.0255849734,
0.0149643794,
-0.0946077481,
-0.0434393324,
0.0158895608,
-0.0060988241,
0.0075136935,
0.1453806609,
-0.0637492836,
0.082402505,
-0.0169482566,
-0.0341117457,
-0.0022286621,
0.0391937941,
-0.0050227316,
0.0344866477,
-0.0425759777,
-0.0111346962,
-0.0254919995,
-0.0233151913,
0.01819361,
0.0607363619,
-0.0155386738,
0.0166702736,
-0.0016266078,
0.0242992025,
0.0240231398,
-0.0036132592,
-0.0572625063,
-0.029811766,
-0.0980035067,
-0.04724456,
-0.0271872189,
-0.0077845366,
0.0489196591,
0.002622843,
-0.0041782265,
-0.0557409637,
-0.0590351634,
0.0316228978,
0.0030970874,
0.0198750012,
0.0467835069,
-0.0186216105,
0.02082403,
-0.0330910794,
-0.0235930532,
0.0076670931,
0.0866699964,
-0.0044131428,
-0.0280087721,
0.0046749781,
-0.0319612138,
-0.0688620284,
-0.0406470597,
-0.003844921,
-0.0196446627,
0.0295482036,
0.0176014118,
0.0871909708,
0.0107978098,
0.0264394004,
0.0357531793,
-0.0457484648,
-0.0142427152,
-0.0419185273,
-0.0540505126,
-0.0044323886,
0.0316245779,
0.0224689357,
-0.1029055864,
0.0292525068,
0.019678086,
0.0191321298,
0.0274776202,
-0.042585101,
0.0641522557,
-0.0362009928,
-0.0419134833,
-0.01824487,
-0.008325004,
0.0132909259,
0.0381620489,
-0.0474408865,
-0.0558097996,
0.0094509618,
0.0172921382,
-0.0208961461,
0.0334293619,
-0.0259564985,
-0.0206958316,
0.1108482778,
0.0362791419,
0.037783213,
-0.0113093052,
-0.0168335885,
0.0246286094,
-0.0259489268,
0.0161499754,
-0.0113047073,
0.0203627367,
0.0095742913,
-0.0224796887,
0.0138874268,
-0.0110305175,
0.0150292069,
-0.0266522691,
-0.0095667047,
-0.0280177724,
0.0293540172,
-0.0373215862,
0.0315360725,
0.0019844766,
0.0047234101,
-0.0405762792,
0.0216111373,
-0.0219370406,
0.0054124896,
0.0751027688,
0.0164124891,
-0.0255722385,
-0.0362453908,
-0.0337356441,
-0.0352385752,
0.0477130041,
0.0063624731,
-0.0169110186,
-0.0370875485,
-0.0060213618,
0.0184418801,
0.044615835,
-0.0293687098,
-0.0394170359,
0.0388490669,
0.010448412,
0.0152946422,
0.0582974553,
0.0149628622,
-0.0037742548,
0.0211698394,
-0.0012565199,
0.0239126664,
0.0216195397,
0.0240179412,
-0.0454322919,
-0.0177776478,
-0.0477760509,
-0.0264098812,
0.0069069895,
-0.0162927974,
0.0207122471,
-0.0568391792,
0.0092758751,
0.0089697978,
-0.0534632429,
0.0348461755,
-0.010041507,
0.0119303651,
0.0042799208,
-0.0525040738,
-0.0321794227,
-0.000617584,
-0.0022429049,
0.0038665405,
-0.0386861935,
-0.0195701439,
-0.024815917,
-0.0693733394,
0.0217055045,
0.0178192761,
0.0365598761,
-0.0186806843,
-0.0564025231,
0.0324505121,
0.0148773054,
-0.0052300608,
-0.0608625375,
0.0295451339,
0.0059799012,
-0.0437705852,
-0.0474754982,
-0.0086589698,
-0.0212134123,
-0.0147693213,
-0.0035247223,
0.0431287922,
-0.0053400984,
-0.0550855286,
-0.0539275073,
0.0062881848,
-0.0270473212,
0.0200780258,
0.0572080426,
-0.0356124341,
0.0171500482,
-0.0343433544,
0.0367952511,
-0.0075248261,
-0.081487529,
-0.0675515607,
-0.0088065527,
-0.0175189544,
-0.0841257796,
-0.0010028998,
-0.0127421226,
0.0250907335,
0.0198412817,
-0.0402908064,
0.0121709909,
-0.0407933369,
-0.0629913062,
0.0291394591,
-0.0423929431,
0.0110116582,
-0.0124306362,
-0.0530561022,
0.0155701395,
0.0099455006,
-0.0128241377,
0.0244079921,
-0.0718907714,
-0.053501837,
0.0058235261,
0.0033226979,
0.0154649997,
0.0151505666,
-0.0135083003,
-0.0683522671,
0.0705261603,
0.0393920131,
-0.015261407,
0.0354620554,
-0.0151742911,
-0.0372584499,
0.0188144557,
0.0184780173,
0.0118371528,
0.0174381379,
0.0105684651,
-0.0332463719,
-0.1028813645,
-0.0010299118,
-0.0533947535,
-0.0332464539,
0.0063570682,
-0.0134574473,
-0.0133854104,
-0.0131819611,
-0.0690824017,
0.0057858624,
-0.0023968297,
-0.0176983736,
-0.0253620651,
-0.0142574701,
0.0342600234,
-0.0356362723,
0.0588329844,
0.0018334721,
0.0662430376,
-0.014615125,
0.0095299007,
0.0288465135,
0.0218219217,
-0.0517819673,
0.0110405339,
0.0448339507,
0.0422285758,
-0.0402168408,
0.0104381535,
-0.0189065393,
0.0330231488,
-0.0170087591,
-0.0541929342,
0.0168997925,
0.0696091875,
0.0120323999,
-0.0253606569,
0.0734250993,
-0.0030272473,
0.0561829805,
-0.0557805561,
0.0513887443,
-0.0162528511,
-0.0352956168,
0.0030906382,
0.0268549211,
0.0068035158,
-0.0390038528,
-0.0059467186,
0.0044477922,
-0.0016796545,
0.0071938112,
0.0385016762,
-0.0736531615,
-0.0274499916,
0.0292209722,
-0.0614344031,
-0.0038012026,
0.0201197546,
0.0322221331,
0.0207332242,
-0.0020011365,
0.0070465025,
-0.0338435806,
-0.0792988464,
0.0102587966,
0.0032156922,
0.0469277278,
0.0406222045,
0.0269701742,
0.0734675154,
0.0209182557,
0.0434501097,
-0.037197493,
0.0131904501,
-0.0305202268,
-0.0018562365,
0.0159503557,
-6.680886878e-33,
0.0135300336,
-0.0598164834,
-0.0504359044,
0.0051213824,
-0.0185576789,
0.0337456092,
-0.0216321889,
0.0345786065,
0.0473587699,
0.0021869373,
-0.0005132538,
0.004979352,
-0.0002351455,
-0.013723202,
0.0490038395,
0.0323761143,
-0.0089053502,
0.0331235267,
-0.0223453809,
-0.0184275731,
0.0307414103,
0.0022255017,
0.0245162714,
-0.0728902444,
0.0065558241,
0.0285139438,
-0.0006318669,
0.0247131791,
0.0757114664,
0.0330220833,
-0.0223796144,
0.0609857291,
0.0357846878,
0.0141962813,
-0.0271170847,
0.0455705523,
-0.0606491007,
-0.0327429809,
0.0217243545,
0.0329311863,
-0.0562189929,
-0.0491759367,
0.073237583,
-0.0457201712,
-0.013978607,
0.0393970385,
0.0781112388,
0.009062185,
0.0425136723,
0.0402199291,
-0.0121323392,
0.0513371117,
-0.0125803724,
0.0259410478,
-0.0145619893,
0.0048242984,
0.0440375544,
0.057754714,
-0.0541998707,
0.0875185803,
-0.0621692799,
0.0115691358,
0.0569824651,
0.0437128134,
0.0337535553,
0.0687483698,
0.0176639967,
0.062324021,
-0.0012900649,
-0.0051621259,
0.0241006501,
0.0330666006,
0.0460800231,
0.0724033788,
0.0261265337,
-0.0312693454,
-0.0103386259,
-0.0180077162,
-0.0137589406,
-0.0331049301,
0.0078522414,
0.0260906406,
-0.0294630416,
-0.0072063897,
0.0126793468,
-0.0440738387,
-0.0286674723,
-0.0460409187,
-0.0485770144,
-0.0261876918,
-0.0527513698,
0.0202971436,
0.0368491262,
0.0089678001,
-0.0301928036,
-0.0405854657,
0.0026906929,
0.0306663327,
0.0136492243,
0.0234057121,
-0.0074330242,
-0.006443948,
0.0147420308,
0.0062441486,
0.041797366,
-0.0052369419,
0.0410145111,
-0.0017927397,
-0.0517581552,
-0.00464543,
-0.0119308392,
-0.0231822468,
-0.0675220862,
-0.0382696725,
0.0477668159,
0.0554456599,
-0.0414719246,
-0.0294984877,
0.0529073067,
0.0027036185,
-0.0172035862,
-0.0408904627,
-0.0521290563,
0.0179285463,
-0.024121888,
-0.0355843157,
-0.0541045479,
0.003572043,
0.0300395414,
-0.0170696955,
-0.0170813426,
-0.0306654926,
2.614e-7,
0.0379692465,
0.0539744906,
0.007133563,
0.0351769365,
0.0532093048,
0.0217648353,
-0.0072613074,
0.0147991376,
-0.0244516488,
-0.0200866144,
0.0072827344,
0.0650052652,
0.0414312221,
-0.0025447074,
-0.0295708496,
-0.0013420351,
-0.0682502687,
0.0212586056,
-0.0607489347,
0.0043497933,
0.0147541231,
0.0477825552,
0.0530690849,
-0.0251876749,
-0.0504879244,
-0.0374092087,
0.068776615,
-0.0683617368,
0.002675184,
-0.0272976719,
-0.0253793523,
-0.012186992,
0.0135239568,
-0.039135173,
0.0020777225,
-0.0678797513,
0.052382268,
-0.0195164494,
0.0158603564,
0.0312569328,
0.0034975195,
-0.0159849152,
-0.0173052475,
-0.0462984033,
0.0254113916,
0.0021779584,
-0.0134834014,
-0.0570128895,
-0.0271445047,
-0.0127896769,
0.0685896277,
-0.0246632509,
-0.0686307922,
0.014345591,
0.0109740309,
-0.0119497664,
-0.0092338184,
-0.0551019721,
-0.0227860175,
-0.0083197011,
-0.0303566828,
-0.0030022641,
-0.0419088081,
0.0146444002,
-0.0003955048,
0.0435013175,
0.0199323278,
1.485047816e-34,
-0.00001836,
0.0112797078,
-0.005419442,
-0.0492015183,
0.0368242338,
-0.0302118734,
-0.0128354281,
-0.0101455776,
0.0210879482,
-0.0157191735,
0.0041205636
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09122v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09122v3 | Universal NER: A Gold-Standard Multilingual Named Entity Recognition Benchmark | 2023-11-15T17:09:54 | 2024-06-29T22:50:48 | Stephen Mayhew, Terra Blevins, Shuheng Liu, Marek Šuppa, Hila Gonen, Joseph Marvin Imperial, Börje F. Karlsson, Peiqin Lin, Nikola Ljubešić, LJ Miranda, Barbara Plank, Arij Riabi, Yuval Pinter | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Universal NER (UNER), an open, community-driven project to
develop gold-standard NER benchmarks in many languages. The overarching goal of
UNER is to provide high-quality, cross-lingually consistent annotations to
facilitate and standardize multilingual NER research. UNER v1 contains 18
datasets annotated with named entities in a cross-lingual consistent schema
across 12 diverse languages. In this paper, we detail the dataset creation and
composition of UNER; we also provide initial modeling baselines on both
in-language and cross-lingual learning settings. We release the data, code, and
fitted models to the public. | [
-0.0088189682,
0.0358180702,
0.01830329,
0.0510136336,
0.0168470498,
0.0478752665,
-0.0067863893,
-0.0178002641,
0.0053436491,
0.0118786097,
-0.0230557658,
-0.0250662994,
-0.0095739318,
-0.0040582265,
0.0512113459,
-0.0218813717,
0.0326710194,
-0.0197172835,
-0.0034199273,
0.0329330526,
-0.0111122541,
0.0135591179,
-0.0069454522,
0.0236240868,
-0.0057258136,
0.0149620026,
-0.0201020893,
0.0064515546,
0.0498544537,
-0.0780399442,
0.0116813146,
0.0413453951,
-0.0349441655,
0.0547769219,
0.0000017836,
-0.075912863,
-0.0393293761,
0.017741004,
-0.0106924437,
-0.0402390026,
0.0020032045,
-0.0684461519,
-0.0171256382,
-0.01749398,
-0.0054120785,
-0.0275437627,
0.0596528612,
0.0608998127,
0.0008798517,
0.0676990971,
-0.0090406407,
-0.0129877366,
0.0300166029,
-0.0392105505,
-0.0190699119,
-0.0227173418,
0.0149551164,
-0.0277154632,
-0.0417218842,
0.0143618351,
0.0037880586,
0.0316255763,
0.009025286,
0.0082451738,
-0.0263150949,
0.0373028107,
-0.0390042365,
-0.0111451969,
0.0021072964,
0.0710557178,
-0.020421546,
0.0262366701,
0.0380362533,
-0.0143740242,
-0.0466515236,
-0.0594389215,
-0.0245345142,
0.0026721484,
-0.0253744964,
0.005277955,
0.0519571379,
0.0135255186,
0.0503876992,
-0.0125685893,
0.0135877896,
0.0248010773,
0.0379169174,
-0.0255767033,
0.0508542359,
0.0121409502,
-0.0001752777,
-0.0320640393,
0.0249805953,
0.0023933344,
0.0247650053,
0.0311784018,
0.0022825408,
0.0027689999,
0.0262889527,
-0.040987242,
-0.0017243605,
0.0134135885,
-0.0026228828,
0.0249550063,
-0.0642272234,
0.0192661043,
-0.0184219461,
-0.0003389374,
0.0494377092,
-0.0556094125,
-0.0425280258,
0.0196077414,
-0.0062744711,
0.0286624171,
-0.0429793894,
0.0093341125,
-0.0356439389,
-0.0118308933,
-0.0020793397,
0.034916427,
0.0365496203,
-0.0305570271,
0.0012249649,
0.015213863,
-0.03705566,
0.0462800749,
-0.0380777381,
-0.0393982641,
-0.039452821,
-0.0619625151,
-0.009665723,
-0.0431795269,
0.0071326066,
-0.0452923365,
0.0348059572,
0.0650250018,
0.0268588718,
-0.0973442793,
-0.0390195511,
0.0088525396,
0.0047100903,
-0.0742824376,
0.0142111555,
-0.0461959615,
0.0633457452,
0.0104042478,
0.034654282,
-0.0557134524,
0.0200191345,
-0.0124697639,
-0.0382940136,
0.0812415555,
-0.0374745987,
-0.0455054045,
-0.0207285658,
-0.0022756369,
0.0569558814,
0.0653390512,
0.024992656,
-0.0378464758,
0.051583603,
0.0108856633,
-0.0306345988,
0.0469643213,
0.042924799,
0.0092650773,
0.0179854725,
0.0033100015,
0.0023774265,
0.0023869402,
0.0181786567,
0.0134898489,
0.0104384907,
-0.0371284783,
0.0119153932,
0.0195297264,
-0.0014943042,
0.0016292229,
-0.0035190554,
-0.0287046507,
-0.0044643455,
-0.0409799032,
-0.0313152894,
0.0400124229,
-0.0058701574,
0.0281820931,
0.0182539858,
0.06390699,
-0.0147824027,
0.0014085097,
0.0043773283,
0.0013156831,
-0.0151758175,
-0.0045989929,
0.0613118187,
0.0020190685,
-0.0619869307,
0.0656496733,
0.0526393205,
-0.0554180928,
0.0355213434,
0.0259749219,
0.0206819829,
0.0322142504,
0.0197513346,
-0.0286244098,
-0.068213053,
-0.0229570996,
-0.0382940471,
0.0726547316,
-0.0148611842,
-0.0243990794,
0.0868364647,
-0.0270865653,
0.0001677522,
0.0003232865,
0.0132923778,
0.0504943877,
0.0161383785,
0.0641218051,
0.0113424463,
-0.0341629274,
-0.0556657799,
0.0455040596,
-0.0773537681,
-0.0153208524,
-0.0008607418,
0.0346032828,
0.0128361648,
0.0640673935,
-0.00317523,
-0.0350239947,
0.0305701848,
-0.0344891287,
0.0163467601,
-0.0048749875,
0.0243400037,
-0.0584263951,
0.0188580677,
-0.0569971129,
-0.0416334607,
-0.0004929369,
-0.0266273096,
-0.0473018028,
-0.0492702425,
0.0557404049,
0.0051943078,
-0.0279130228,
0.0249890741,
0.0155899981,
0.0335789733,
0.0073690689,
0.029101003,
-0.0293182209,
0.0475386716,
0.0364487804,
-0.0191965718,
0.0245106053,
-0.0214548223,
-0.0670896247,
0.046277903,
0.0055629034,
-0.0540405028,
0.0159689486,
0.0187882073,
-0.0488139428,
-0.0063569658,
-0.0793395489,
0.0206320882,
-0.0248571765,
0.0624751709,
-0.0089079104,
0.033600539,
-0.031864576,
-0.0381460339,
-0.0008806331,
0.000105983,
-0.0225330126,
0.0068117329,
0.0188197512,
0.0050629657,
-0.0145943556,
-0.0170939732,
0.0134018799,
-0.0275762789,
0.0173308719,
0.0095208697,
-0.0518878624,
-0.0500160009,
0.037715096,
-0.0602740012,
0.0074204551,
-0.0181803871,
0.0251443572,
-0.0113922143,
0.0522095859,
0.011360636,
0.0238192193,
-0.0500116721,
0.0021313133,
-0.0051762373,
-0.0225645881,
-0.0414270163,
0.043381758,
-0.0160635728,
0.0408195257,
-0.0394221842,
-0.063529931,
0.030048104,
0.0889134333,
-0.0464738756,
0.0135497563,
-0.0465411432,
-0.0083212946,
-0.0335776135,
-0.0177965593,
-0.0135145765,
0.0567805506,
-0.0005582354,
0.0204083137,
-0.0232117921,
-0.0265702028,
0.0437246561,
-0.060624592,
-0.0258805007,
-0.0086058183,
0.0142910806,
-0.0651209503,
0.0521045588,
0.0006827147,
-0.0040504765,
0.0400900841,
-0.0752977207,
0.0130337579,
0.0473534837,
0.0063036554,
-0.0025322526,
0.0401576757,
-0.0046672453,
0.0094182426,
-0.0294047035,
-0.0257270262,
-0.0089732418,
0.0258131102,
-0.0575025268,
0.024477588,
-0.0053198924,
-0.0273249689,
-0.0059719086,
0.0401682444,
-0.0141226286,
0.0357923657,
0.0041895621,
0.0039421292,
-0.0157953817,
0.0194124524,
0.0333704427,
-0.0127180619,
0.0211816486,
-0.0104431519,
-0.0115374485,
-0.001136591,
-0.0363942273,
-0.0065492648,
0.012622836,
0.0109820571,
0.0224868059,
-0.0592683889,
0.0175590385,
-0.0400673784,
0.03808669,
-0.0206810199,
0.008035237,
0.0940184444,
-0.0147579666,
-0.0220574383,
-0.0183250699,
-0.010401709,
0.0318348706,
0.0416987091,
-0.0058774124,
-0.0889578685,
-0.0374335572,
0.0084300814,
-0.0140675353,
0.0274087079,
-0.0902252272,
-0.0040779989,
-0.1082273051,
-0.0111935623,
-0.0227426104,
-0.1005870625,
0.0206202529,
-0.0760580599,
0.0049004336,
-0.0815508291,
0.0110526551,
-0.057058543,
0.0013339691,
-0.0161598604,
-0.0061597442,
0.0071939775,
-0.0361848846,
0.0205200985,
-0.075717099,
0.0338154174,
0.0014788383,
0.072604835,
-0.02285612,
-0.0033854838,
-0.0051951106,
-0.013932596,
-0.0192132778,
-0.0313056149,
0.0514252,
-0.0312558562,
-0.0496190935,
-0.0290008076,
0.0021315201,
-0.0321130082,
0.0042780484,
0.0273335483,
0.0539985672,
0.0417320728,
0.0202302616,
0.0103864381,
-0.0461462662,
0.0436913222,
0.069335781,
-0.0158156082,
-0.0026833634,
-0.0163113475,
0.0241153762,
-0.0045637907,
-0.0248680301,
-0.0185367651,
0.0162279848,
-0.0518670678,
-0.0417045467,
-0.0248486008,
-0.0897042677,
0.060367059,
0.0218226146,
0.0344132371,
0.012962603,
0.0162694864,
0.0061305938,
-0.044789575,
0.0479368977,
-0.022556046,
0.0096140774,
-0.0541456901,
-0.0016205466,
0.0040817657,
0.0510496087,
-0.0268895794,
0.0108463326,
-0.0630620196,
-0.0522685274,
-0.0319672301,
0.0411391556,
0.002331736,
0.0636232421,
0.0144652817,
0.0018858829,
-0.0059203124,
0.0048891739,
-0.017174663,
-0.0322469361,
0.0263412464,
0.0302086808,
-0.0142383026,
0.0346734263,
-0.0176708959,
0.0057234918,
0.0163226351,
0.0787422284,
0.0092695169,
-0.0451397002,
-0.0194095913,
0.0121065015,
0.03480478,
-0.0475759879,
-0.035396874,
-0.0761611313,
0.0193547867,
-0.0087091271,
0.0178078003,
0.0010058077,
-0.0154618118,
0.0209433082,
-0.0077278297,
-0.0155886821,
0.0829304159,
-0.0019356251,
0.0108193997,
-0.0634846315,
0.0109198838,
0.0400545672,
0.064055264,
0.0002409398,
-0.0106152715,
0.0253129993,
0.0396122597,
0.0369674377,
0.0547515675,
-0.040613208,
0.0158325806,
-0.0151010891,
0.0048725307,
-0.0021106249,
0.0008582671,
0.0235103425,
0.0232651178,
-0.026518112,
0.0401812419,
0.0591721535,
0.0004188639,
0.1134302616,
-0.0070851995,
0.0028050644,
0.0097400909,
0.0094413636,
-0.0389928073,
-0.0115293581,
0.0191955715,
-0.001499232,
-0.0111968499,
-0.0105663026,
0.0368114896,
0.0047844187,
0.0231370796,
0.0364365801,
0.0120398952,
-0.0203130189,
-0.0015894304,
0.0359855704,
-0.0283627082,
-0.0370195322,
0.0074653858,
-0.0286547169,
-0.0501419678,
0.0274729542,
-0.0163522679,
-0.0384877771,
0.0409587659,
-0.0104039051,
0.0098571749,
0.0107333045,
-0.0180545636,
-0.0338652767,
0.0004197609,
-0.0286799483,
-0.0228046048,
-0.0125305066,
-5.718560346e-33,
-0.0292470064,
-0.0045009274,
0.0223507583,
-0.017567575,
-0.0013927454,
0.0336806178,
-0.020977864,
-0.013893798,
0.0205491204,
-0.022550147,
0.0019105669,
0.002360797,
0.0369928032,
-0.0005773778,
0.0116323577,
-0.0469705909,
0.0481371544,
0.0668507144,
-0.0352000408,
0.0092229797,
0.0633732751,
0.0673214048,
0.1492619365,
-0.0719598606,
0.0948320702,
0.0041826228,
0.0069167358,
-0.0019883399,
0.083493419,
0.053845305,
-0.0427579768,
-0.0028201051,
0.0118681733,
-0.0661446601,
0.0036786429,
-0.0164025314,
-0.1558090001,
-0.0208699144,
-0.0038899044,
0.0569645427,
-0.0365633145,
-0.0234460738,
-0.0272309575,
0.0011074616,
0.0170912538,
0.0210455321,
0.0213895049,
-0.0032961417,
0.015017855,
0.003230562,
-0.0800733641,
0.0506987534,
-0.0083031682,
0.0417921171,
0.0503260083,
0.018829491,
0.0381677486,
-0.0082652159,
-0.1054620668,
-0.0135009866,
0.0034383312,
-0.0242506564,
0.0516846254,
0.0187537689,
-0.0052568833,
0.0468527004,
0.0518035032,
0.007922071,
0.0108695887,
0.0106081208,
0.0399995409,
0.013242959,
0.0067640496,
0.0752850845,
0.0298908148,
-0.0094427243,
-0.0730593204,
0.0443752334,
0.0076252059,
0.024615299,
-0.0210474785,
-0.039456021,
-0.0403599143,
0.0044374969,
-0.0386293866,
-0.0459179245,
-0.0357507803,
-0.0127665261,
0.0475978926,
0.0085231299,
-0.0356037021,
0.048477117,
0.0261534769,
-0.0037794043,
-0.0712232739,
0.0382843912,
0.0582723208,
-0.0023327353,
-0.0053108931,
0.0179534554,
-0.0625955611,
-0.0495587401,
-0.0070132245,
-0.0104132062,
0.0418450534,
-0.0385667793,
0.0615408383,
-0.013784836,
-0.0563926399,
-0.0048151407,
-0.0175606385,
0.0309672784,
-0.0281915478,
0.066490069,
0.0104762372,
-0.0261989832,
-0.0103187598,
0.0095624318,
0.0918005183,
-0.0171469525,
-0.0232576374,
0.0256310515,
0.0448796153,
0.0338006578,
0.0137325078,
0.009269584,
-0.0229792446,
-0.0275290795,
0.0095125074,
-0.0476898402,
0.0121008456,
0.0029652615,
2.336e-7,
0.0032876991,
-0.0055785323,
0.0245988145,
0.0045189462,
-0.0283884425,
0.0007501752,
-0.0236336589,
0.0441264696,
-0.0408628844,
0.0062219738,
-0.0308443513,
-0.0266124103,
0.0273925755,
0.0333728828,
-0.1026066914,
-0.0348451249,
-0.0137378797,
-0.0160016567,
-0.0599086657,
0.0349043272,
-0.0263751689,
0.0699805245,
-0.014920597,
-0.0050216028,
-0.0514938906,
-0.0084875776,
0.0489766523,
-0.0170267206,
0.016787475,
0.0223441795,
-0.0059209936,
0.0655179694,
-0.0098771919,
0.0098141618,
-0.010882319,
0.0329804718,
0.0182644948,
0.0556491688,
0.0157042667,
-0.0052381679,
-0.0007240794,
-0.0499291159,
0.0023835127,
-0.0567991026,
0.0703038648,
-0.0032990589,
-0.0140103819,
0.0032091497,
-0.0013771757,
0.0202458557,
0.0598294847,
0.0079329079,
-0.0166015681,
0.0318229981,
0.0372162089,
-0.03964011,
-0.0151597299,
-0.0360524021,
0.0017329358,
0.0251833908,
0.0399138592,
-0.0049765822,
-0.0086571965,
-0.0318877622,
-0.0110981409,
-0.036336977,
0.0113911396,
1.805051358e-34,
-0.0356972106,
0.0195573755,
-0.0104047684,
0.0501869731,
0.008221766,
-0.0380551517,
-0.0420276821,
-0.0142513281,
-0.027998969,
-0.0158252232,
0.0032587177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09117v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09117v2 | R-Spin: Efficient Speaker and Noise-invariant Representation Learning with Acoustic Pieces | 2023-11-15T17:07:44 | 2024-04-01T15:04:42 | Heng-Jui Chang, James Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper introduces Robust Spin (R-Spin), a data-efficient domain-specific
self-supervision method for speaker and noise-invariant speech representations
by learning discrete acoustic units with speaker-invariant clustering (Spin).
R-Spin resolves Spin's issues and enhances content representations by learning
to predict acoustic pieces. R-Spin offers a 12X reduction in computational
resources compared to previous state-of-the-art methods while outperforming
them in severely distorted speech scenarios. This paper provides detailed
analyses to show how discrete units contribute to speech encoder training and
improving robustness in diverse acoustic environments. | [
-0.0579559952,
0.0136175696,
-0.0015746863,
0.0164859183,
0.0045890152,
-0.0175613668,
0.0663851872,
-0.0194387175,
-0.0057757199,
0.0133498106,
-0.0459160805,
-0.0055644372,
-0.0262655374,
0.0159310363,
0.0372641683,
-0.1119299531,
0.0160342567,
-0.0477846824,
0.0146789439,
-0.0288916584,
0.0167468507,
-0.021177182,
-0.0433409736,
0.0287738889,
-0.0388216637,
-0.0411627404,
-0.0094070118,
0.0046753595,
0.0162098575,
-0.0292336158,
0.0102949049,
0.0343824364,
0.0947301015,
0.0086912839,
0.0000019294,
0.0100964122,
-0.0196723938,
-2.773e-7,
-0.0417584106,
-0.0138226273,
0.0168884154,
0.0063980618,
-0.0254963245,
0.01544399,
0.0221578479,
0.0010309618,
0.0343054906,
0.0756827742,
0.0408647284,
0.0503715351,
-0.0165434182,
-0.0232657511,
-0.023512518,
-0.031407848,
0.0021785344,
0.0041490826,
-0.0159487929,
0.0063030114,
-0.0156687535,
0.0237461459,
-0.0478958525,
0.02253961,
0.0083832685,
0.0020797893,
0.0266380552,
0.0110259121,
-0.0038522852,
-0.0172172897,
0.0027627954,
0.0587665401,
0.0163748674,
0.0243221633,
0.0073499316,
0.0231867395,
-0.0157867726,
0.0003595401,
-0.0229867883,
-0.0128752356,
0.0531137884,
-0.0087145073,
-0.0824937001,
0.0835309774,
0.0344259329,
-0.0462651625,
-0.0086302999,
0.0283645559,
-0.0000689635,
-0.0444834679,
-0.0146135204,
-0.0161033813,
-0.0052156704,
0.0484529287,
0.0253961086,
-0.0229011308,
-0.0076174438,
-0.0287072007,
-0.0365657583,
-0.0172034036,
-0.0352333784,
-0.0062137232,
-0.036610093,
0.0269658044,
-0.0495026745,
0.0277692825,
-0.0046425159,
0.0297370106,
0.0010935955,
-0.0167076644,
-0.0042573451,
-0.0169576164,
-0.0270076804,
0.0004040208,
-0.0599474125,
0.0448042266,
-0.0198240802,
0.0015807643,
-0.0553253293,
0.0428613983,
-0.0483569093,
0.0365221277,
0.0276419669,
0.0027969964,
-0.0503379665,
-0.0406944789,
0.0262676757,
0.0840400308,
-0.0361916013,
0.0247749034,
-0.0058796313,
-0.0189181026,
-0.032882072,
0.0193247851,
0.0269333962,
-0.0156869572,
-0.008818862,
0.0733723491,
0.0067565637,
-0.0268752482,
-0.0190230124,
-0.0120322276,
-0.0370395109,
-0.0235648807,
-0.0310721062,
-0.0464480966,
0.0363367833,
-0.0214244407,
-0.0020474098,
-0.069204323,
-0.0175039768,
-0.0239806809,
0.0286853146,
0.0171782169,
0.0017025616,
-0.0159500223,
0.0485234223,
0.0205610227,
-0.0171341021,
0.0277905315,
0.0266294871,
-0.0038111829,
0.0085108681,
-0.0725063682,
-0.0129287513,
0.0464403294,
0.0370129459,
0.0190315116,
-0.0129418317,
-0.0133419614,
0.038440831,
0.0232924595,
0.0482466668,
-0.0046832669,
-0.0449392051,
-0.0457184985,
0.0450158715,
0.0276690405,
0.0127108917,
0.0530138835,
-0.0069255517,
0.0023942466,
-0.0326493382,
-0.0117870364,
-0.0214673299,
0.0272689797,
0.0132999066,
-0.0104139717,
0.0533105955,
0.0348611362,
-0.0571210943,
-0.0161909014,
0.0177356862,
-0.0115084723,
0.0340359472,
-0.0139884437,
0.0379575305,
0.0189460553,
-0.0275621209,
0.0430850349,
0.0178409554,
-0.0493670329,
0.0297882445,
-0.0051368019,
0.0190450139,
0.0324332677,
0.015757408,
-0.061593242,
-0.0029254465,
-0.0527186766,
0.0015730889,
-0.0009392426,
-0.0427315086,
-0.0147948666,
0.0920488611,
-0.0523132458,
-0.0365095176,
0.0184857417,
-0.0105939927,
0.0271063484,
0.0065669063,
0.0003107188,
0.0215492249,
-0.0699315965,
0.0304906555,
-0.0098698568,
0.0448262841,
-0.0478274301,
0.043120075,
0.017308373,
0.0504681952,
0.0344407447,
-0.0231237449,
-0.0421154872,
0.0326394662,
-0.0266218614,
0.0107190255,
-0.0083152065,
-0.1104866639,
-0.0885037184,
0.0216338634,
-0.0174037535,
-0.0153500829,
0.0074436329,
-0.0008918029,
-0.0606568381,
0.0863805637,
-0.0244851559,
0.0181070566,
-0.018829342,
0.002719492,
0.030640265,
0.0343977027,
0.0364248939,
0.0153206587,
0.0150873214,
-0.0429935306,
-0.027882589,
0.0485018753,
-0.0136308987,
-0.0662493482,
-0.0148755135,
-0.0270062871,
-0.0145538645,
0.0238962751,
0.0014764405,
-0.0453810543,
-0.0038388553,
-0.0013901853,
-0.050704848,
-0.0465904586,
-0.0431214757,
-0.0293185208,
-0.0064353845,
0.0144564174,
0.011573148,
-0.0523449779,
-0.0158821382,
-0.0835511014,
-0.04401429,
0.0023553143,
-0.0500027649,
-0.019177828,
-0.0419185758,
-0.005353346,
0.0064105489,
0.0278484523,
-0.0230616238,
-0.0484627299,
0.0375522114,
-0.0075570089,
-0.0212624632,
0.0276271701,
0.0149302222,
-0.0078481762,
0.0136030884,
-0.0240560398,
-0.0172565877,
0.0788128674,
0.0303572081,
0.0097015789,
0.0243124142,
0.0077500907,
-0.0198501013,
-0.0410993174,
0.0202866029,
-0.0210780669,
0.0902132094,
-0.0145155452,
0.0454255827,
0.0263251103,
0.0196735132,
0.0429746471,
0.0354295634,
-0.0691393837,
-0.0531285629,
-0.0160438549,
-0.0521649309,
-0.0243340116,
-0.0415687338,
0.0070862034,
-0.0375702158,
-0.0206581037,
-0.0133407256,
0.0341361798,
-0.0497767814,
-0.0568769909,
-0.0400858186,
-0.0942419991,
0.0171306953,
-0.003649398,
-0.027878413,
0.0323149897,
-0.0235926379,
-0.0300676972,
-0.0541080832,
0.0122440495,
0.0306091327,
-0.0094760237,
-0.0113730449,
0.0035878464,
-0.0145580983,
0.0145199448,
-0.0290926825,
-0.0391173959,
-0.0013654963,
0.031849876,
0.020072341,
0.0132734841,
-0.027114857,
-0.0202540327,
0.0446573533,
0.0560395308,
-0.0008452365,
-0.001375421,
0.020117512,
0.022155134,
0.0406297036,
0.0194536988,
0.0555410236,
-0.0189590771,
-0.023149766,
0.0368971601,
0.0304910894,
0.0533324145,
-0.0314952321,
-0.0500958562,
0.0230893325,
0.010421752,
0.0184526257,
0.0092648771,
0.0312678069,
0.0800965577,
-0.0274637472,
-0.012201135,
0.0938962996,
-0.0048680115,
-0.0436527804,
-0.0282646418,
-0.0455645211,
0.045762226,
0.0067570033,
-0.0169556048,
0.0497893356,
-0.0153304599,
0.0123579316,
0.0292415414,
0.019449966,
0.0059885443,
0.0363575593,
-0.0410888344,
0.0498380065,
0.0487194844,
-0.0468896031,
-0.0861527175,
-0.0541767702,
-0.0253287405,
-0.0582060777,
0.0783801824,
-0.0192356538,
-0.0114379199,
-0.0349180698,
0.0449764803,
-0.078464061,
0.0076000509,
-0.0060646688,
-0.0516420826,
0.0532223061,
0.0662773103,
-0.0036087949,
0.0058033429,
0.0004869704,
-0.0408870988,
0.0226879623,
-0.010936386,
-0.0151874451,
0.0458034314,
-0.0066972133,
0.0147696212,
0.0186315533,
0.0470795222,
-0.0093129566,
-0.0058136634,
0.0272724163,
0.0918305367,
-0.0206942819,
0.0449927822,
-0.0136625925,
0.0281923395,
0.021634398,
0.0672687963,
0.018439021,
-0.016288301,
0.0225099903,
0.0183171351,
0.0663010105,
0.0266729761,
-0.000365978,
-0.0278058033,
-0.0044415272,
0.0225952435,
-0.0414604023,
-0.0018303975,
0.0164919514,
0.0521917455,
0.0097490158,
-0.0102500087,
-0.0005834068,
-0.0059901639,
-0.0329230651,
-0.0587153882,
-0.0414354764,
-0.0122744814,
-0.0520877168,
-0.0310228225,
0.0398923196,
-0.0289762449,
0.0196248312,
0.0234666895,
-0.0289613176,
-0.0459568575,
0.0557649136,
-0.0011721354,
0.0099556353,
0.0848617554,
-0.0230601244,
-0.0244811308,
0.1230699942,
0.0088155232,
-0.0728247762,
0.0132001461,
0.0919482559,
0.0150741991,
-0.0242532697,
0.0228154566,
-0.0749551952,
0.0830974579,
-0.0558230206,
-0.0156678613,
-0.0747180954,
-0.0515512675,
-0.0171490088,
-0.019760102,
0.0657679662,
0.0216552336,
0.0504027307,
-0.0098895701,
0.0252134446,
-0.0542800389,
0.0363619626,
-0.0110431137,
0.0045324429,
0.0320577994,
0.0161189791,
-0.0123033812,
0.0782605559,
0.017254971,
-0.0133392299,
0.0044002905,
0.0206587426,
-0.0187078193,
-0.0109534729,
-0.0294266976,
0.0511460677,
0.0283652134,
0.0374845304,
0.0477020293,
0.0060941861,
0.0145395817,
0.0254170168,
0.0038903765,
0.0179137178,
-0.0250115227,
0.0175574161,
-0.0435660928,
-0.0049619377,
-0.0203929488,
-0.013618974,
-0.0236041304,
-0.0203595869,
0.0071744043,
-0.0102735544,
0.0145294759,
-0.0111515485,
-0.0026250533,
-0.0492349453,
0.0381049663,
0.0345861316,
0.0021270448,
-0.0080097094,
0.0100869732,
0.0331529416,
0.0225961953,
-0.0049524824,
-0.0221663695,
0.0433481969,
-0.0293244421,
-0.0452040732,
-0.0184033904,
0.0068634404,
0.0161185041,
-0.0207347758,
0.0122799808,
-0.0449871011,
0.0117658107,
-0.0473562516,
0.0298093222,
-0.0243044235,
0.0470681749,
-0.0166616961,
-0.0385314673,
0.0532063656,
0.0402873121,
-0.0510878861,
0.0410826318,
-0.0211505685,
0.041849304,
-6.060301901e-33,
-0.0472006127,
0.0107246647,
-0.0066861347,
-0.0533543304,
-0.0119637614,
-0.0488297939,
-0.0210954528,
0.0198613293,
0.0235676523,
-0.0015335256,
0.0039467691,
0.0268190615,
0.0241268259,
0.0163771398,
0.0024759793,
-0.0041837902,
0.1294513196,
-0.0322945975,
-0.0117479302,
0.021720333,
0.0430041328,
0.0381793194,
-0.0187724456,
-0.0655708984,
-0.0533059016,
0.0005972548,
-0.0094499988,
-0.0253692959,
0.0266144853,
0.0039113807,
0.01444986,
0.0166017823,
-0.0278172456,
-0.0519731343,
-0.0316127986,
0.0002865905,
-0.0889756158,
-0.0392383784,
-0.0714985356,
0.0140158292,
-0.0231295135,
-0.0050462787,
0.0599048287,
0.0079115396,
-0.0130385403,
-0.0478380509,
0.0397348292,
0.013217031,
-0.0234602056,
-0.0090222629,
0.0028273822,
0.0225629993,
-0.0392112918,
-0.0150998887,
0.0596852712,
0.0180541072,
0.0113621205,
-0.0041151829,
-0.0811546519,
0.025252698,
-0.0254342984,
0.065627858,
0.0195562392,
0.0280436315,
0.0143095292,
0.0549848303,
0.0715151429,
-0.0411065221,
-0.0014900637,
0.0229808893,
0.0421814993,
0.0634653866,
0.0412090868,
0.0363136679,
0.0242530424,
-0.0196586307,
-0.0398298614,
0.0140402373,
-0.0112245195,
0.002810102,
-0.0007677207,
0.0532849953,
-0.0765218139,
-0.0101698553,
-0.005576516,
-0.0677461624,
0.0014606137,
-0.0493962839,
0.0457300358,
0.0116729988,
-0.0339269079,
-0.0108774621,
0.0643648729,
-0.0159042049,
0.0234438367,
-0.0362951979,
-0.0429665521,
-0.0302807782,
0.0357594639,
-0.0013234657,
-0.0068757548,
-0.0587480851,
0.1115128621,
0.0061105941,
-0.0052172835,
-0.0447717905,
0.0105523784,
0.0506125391,
-0.0375922881,
-0.0207257699,
0.0383224674,
0.0219519045,
0.0042413757,
-0.0110272737,
0.0000353674,
0.0135064879,
-0.0043230089,
0.0287342463,
0.0095025627,
0.0037434762,
-0.0140563725,
0.0010566196,
0.0044430597,
0.0085475119,
-0.0307366736,
-0.0291407388,
0.0003582456,
-0.0359389335,
0.0790303275,
-0.0716302246,
-0.0214939117,
-0.0163569115,
2.74e-7,
-0.07463108,
0.0233273115,
0.0257074218,
-0.1015039682,
0.036835935,
0.0373907275,
-0.0365766063,
0.0056888666,
-0.0188811552,
-0.0153747946,
0.0670137405,
0.028194515,
0.045433864,
0.0438211113,
-0.0825921595,
0.0444955342,
-0.0521922,
0.0310867503,
-0.0015148664,
0.0232704002,
0.0124538159,
0.0931065455,
0.0307314564,
-0.0273085553,
0.0419502556,
0.0171747115,
0.051207561,
-0.0167952366,
0.0212154686,
-0.0073782792,
-0.0170966685,
0.0301109646,
-0.0099521577,
-0.0016815512,
-0.0385743342,
0.0624541156,
0.0196941365,
0.0382821262,
0.0135131553,
-0.0736758858,
-0.0009366872,
0.0854527354,
0.0022095051,
0.0336593091,
0.0339103639,
-0.0128166759,
-0.0066670384,
0.0313255712,
-0.0530976094,
0.0422689505,
-0.0027280725,
0.0217055921,
0.0021453178,
-0.0328152664,
-0.0041713081,
-0.0020147648,
0.0134166926,
-0.0474407636,
0.020031007,
-0.0232894421,
-0.0653829277,
-0.0233962759,
-0.0334362164,
-0.0368052423,
0.0212787036,
0.0257622823,
0.0129791768,
1.960457795e-34,
0.0108665489,
-0.0256842058,
0.0154747237,
0.0229824688,
-0.0107300123,
-0.055061575,
0.006406296,
-0.0188865457,
0.0355144739,
-0.0093837185,
-0.0228576921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09114v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09114v2 | Ever: Mitigating Hallucination in Large Language Models through Real-Time Verification and Rectification | 2023-11-15T17:04:56 | 2024-02-25T04:39:07 | Haoqiang Kang, Juntong Ni, Huaxiu Yao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable proficiency in
generating fluent text. However, they often encounter the challenge of
generating inaccurate or hallucinated content. This issue is common in both
non-retrieval-based generation and retrieval-augmented generation approaches,
and existing post-hoc rectification methods may not address the accumulated
hallucination errors that may be caused by the "snowballing" issue, especially
in reasoning tasks. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a novel approach
called Real-time Verification and Rectification (Ever). Instead of waiting
until the end of the generation process to rectify hallucinations, Ever employs
a real-time, step-wise generation and hallucination rectification strategy. The
primary objective is to detect and rectify hallucinations as they occur during
the text generation process. When compared to both retrieval-based and
non-retrieval-based baselines, Ever demonstrates a significant improvement in
generating trustworthy and factually accurate text across a diverse range of
tasks, including short-form QA, biography generation, and multi-hop reasoning. | [
-0.0019241133,
0.0487085544,
-0.0114648379,
0.0315814577,
-0.0418327563,
0.0097119557,
-0.0255228896,
-0.0059207263,
0.0013382322,
-0.0412247293,
0.0287425201,
-0.0854115635,
0.0318884552,
0.0186204594,
0.0388333648,
-0.0142761571,
0.0593924075,
-0.0272707418,
-0.0064150337,
-0.0046753581,
0.000859678,
0.0304731261,
-0.0183055736,
0.0289072022,
-0.0216967054,
-0.040919099,
-0.0104333051,
0.0108484467,
0.0078284768,
0.0025880008,
-0.001380283,
0.0630419403,
-0.0055383146,
0.0546798036,
0.0000021619,
-0.0289021693,
-0.0111198481,
-0.0203954391,
-0.0179763939,
-0.0046406342,
0.0401002765,
0.0223707482,
-0.029257454,
0.048300948,
-0.036895521,
0.0247242171,
0.0144986957,
0.0544924401,
0.055033192,
0.0509262942,
0.002604634,
-0.0114416424,
0.040214844,
-0.0083730966,
0.0319323502,
0.0050584287,
0.0228399243,
0.0250890404,
-0.0107181249,
-0.0289894231,
0.015454445,
0.047327999,
0.0358103588,
-0.0242894832,
0.0229814127,
0.0313048884,
-0.0316160358,
-0.0013062635,
0.0078226347,
0.058339987,
-0.040909715,
-0.0440811627,
0.0227323547,
0.0117438613,
-0.0026366448,
-0.0214964766,
-0.0198142473,
0.062597394,
-0.0247607678,
-0.0004505214,
0.0061121043,
-0.0485070758,
0.0458779372,
0.0080198329,
-0.0254939217,
0.0467701033,
0.0332397334,
-0.0299303737,
-0.0108706178,
0.0127104223,
0.0189534929,
-0.0882791206,
0.0146043338,
0.038582176,
-0.0641163513,
0.0239338577,
-0.0590029173,
0.0069323047,
0.0318562947,
-0.0436982661,
0.0137942424,
0.020987004,
-0.0279285982,
0.0072826426,
-0.0417900793,
0.0439083986,
-0.0185628571,
0.0230587814,
-0.0072161686,
0.0196237806,
-0.0379682258,
-0.0228493717,
-0.0625493824,
0.043111641,
-0.0334936269,
-0.0023971067,
-0.0414647646,
0.0161282625,
-0.0254157744,
0.0297245346,
-0.0407734662,
0.0083576916,
-0.037364848,
-0.0368933119,
-0.0128971459,
0.0327027962,
-0.0144703062,
-0.0020467322,
0.0569173545,
-0.0787716135,
-0.0184404496,
0.0035620392,
-0.0015667551,
0.0035397606,
-0.0298197251,
-0.0021357706,
-0.0257986579,
-0.0071585006,
-0.0467704721,
-0.0903110057,
-0.0338585377,
-0.0859890133,
-0.0034056536,
-0.0814964399,
0.0142530035,
-0.0191241223,
-0.0237355325,
-0.0299730562,
0.025044078,
0.0456245355,
-0.0192464925,
0.0474607497,
-0.0227814335,
0.0195142049,
0.0335375406,
0.0418387726,
0.0148715563,
0.051220756,
0.0368909389,
0.0333662741,
0.0061462419,
0.0259505436,
0.0754536539,
0.0207283814,
0.0374069922,
0.0172435325,
-0.0467014946,
-0.0230142176,
-0.0206203163,
0.0295459926,
0.0215344876,
0.0725967214,
-0.0549174435,
0.0173064135,
0.046113845,
-0.0112308739,
0.0020638921,
-0.0004024676,
0.0632627979,
-0.0157767218,
-0.0078690993,
0.0534518175,
-0.0636842698,
0.0365191624,
-0.0327938832,
0.0347002931,
0.0375872105,
0.017404303,
-0.0211977847,
-0.045573622,
-0.0095544923,
0.0118175913,
-0.0009996345,
0.0055532497,
0.0045689316,
0.0532714203,
-0.0589708388,
0.0763251856,
0.0120077748,
-0.0881701261,
0.0327159874,
-0.0608966053,
0.0049468954,
0.1281060278,
0.0871905386,
0.0136875715,
-0.0285161119,
-0.018550355,
0.0189148616,
0.0668068901,
0.0272387024,
0.0055857506,
-0.0196480043,
-0.0575729795,
-0.0091670081,
0.0135284895,
0.0337230228,
0.0103284279,
0.0108976029,
0.0056049037,
0.0364773087,
-0.0096295662,
-0.048975125,
0.0209166668,
-0.0490360111,
-0.0207859185,
-0.0179113094,
-0.0117456857,
-0.0294953343,
0.0029458879,
-0.0126330033,
0.0307103805,
0.0087801078,
-0.0271408819,
-0.0620809197,
0.0188189652,
-0.0673659071,
-0.0159829166,
0.0447844677,
-0.0060834051,
-0.0268185232,
-0.0015805122,
-0.011978196,
-0.0511158518,
-0.0062122685,
-0.0452025272,
0.0033964142,
-0.0508290529,
0.0396497436,
0.0110666351,
0.0188797172,
-0.011532235,
0.0761147588,
-0.0227668248,
-0.0085363779,
0.0492766947,
0.0144622158,
-0.0105817001,
-0.0357799754,
-0.0047889701,
0.0031784514,
-0.0005227981,
0.0154085429,
0.0025484324,
-0.0343228094,
-0.0497620516,
-0.0335651562,
-0.067786485,
0.0227249153,
-0.0332327895,
0.0128558856,
0.0343949422,
-0.0025582146,
-0.0044202702,
0.016656762,
-0.0511467122,
0.0025849638,
0.0384145379,
0.0184419546,
0.013513891,
-0.0167815574,
-0.0196073521,
0.0061256378,
0.0079257041,
-0.0240290482,
0.0322186947,
0.0014039888,
-0.0290513132,
-0.0852275342,
0.0388642438,
-0.0579335988,
0.0242499094,
0.0128939711,
-0.0235362649,
0.0097148521,
0.0051097581,
0.0823716223,
0.0506323501,
0.0334017575,
0.0052864035,
0.0617738292,
-0.0239413865,
-0.0264605358,
0.0175158158,
-0.0081162024,
-0.0009576068,
0.0032849007,
-0.0608639009,
0.0010011516,
0.0365109183,
0.0172706302,
0.0033508837,
-0.0596923158,
0.019024346,
-0.0263182409,
-0.0263419505,
-0.0196359996,
-0.0506220721,
-0.0333501957,
0.0272926725,
-0.0486693121,
-0.035118971,
0.0664746687,
-0.0507532619,
0.0142883379,
-0.0022700911,
0.041122511,
0.0142718507,
0.0297628697,
-0.0125970878,
0.0194046404,
-0.0216778181,
-0.0199257415,
-0.0456337482,
-0.0259480216,
0.0034449175,
-0.0794799551,
0.0317459218,
-0.0570900925,
0.0012637074,
-0.0102959042,
-0.0269209687,
-0.06789276,
0.0043873321,
0.0079396339,
-0.0021480955,
-0.0319340602,
-0.0196090546,
-0.0281329583,
-0.0166518781,
0.0259307753,
0.0380462855,
-0.0530262217,
-0.0198656619,
-0.0200405587,
0.0351417512,
0.0709675178,
-0.0008343827,
0.0372803509,
-0.0523129739,
0.0127517926,
0.0631410629,
0.0407478623,
0.0331655592,
-0.0092604337,
-0.0293600634,
0.0002953421,
-0.0166013837,
-0.0187099557,
0.0204569269,
0.0315550007,
-0.084379673,
-0.0477693751,
0.1067454368,
0.0282501038,
-0.0378659554,
-0.0095962416,
-0.0129641611,
0.0683574155,
-0.0053627933,
0.0305947326,
-0.1038680598,
-0.0056060315,
0.0250279997,
0.021281803,
0.0045423512,
-0.0234736539,
-0.0178949833,
-0.1144110933,
0.06462273,
0.0406464487,
-0.0145617398,
-0.0346857719,
0.013765025,
-0.0326274969,
0.0490419231,
0.0525056757,
0.0523824878,
0.0170865152,
-0.0077630589,
0.0179843567,
-0.007477161,
-0.0201399103,
0.028969137,
-0.0211669803,
0.0520833395,
0.0603109747,
0.0330831148,
0.0468810908,
-0.0810285509,
0.026712345,
-0.0047943499,
0.005269492,
0.0172504913,
0.0399091691,
0.009405015,
0.0104418043,
0.0012770155,
0.0174561273,
-0.0186044071,
-0.0361000709,
-0.0241115429,
0.069630295,
-0.0271570832,
-0.0283277985,
-0.016961094,
0.0155982757,
0.0360835306,
0.070621185,
0.0269578937,
-0.0047249594,
-0.0685178936,
-0.0112884315,
0.0313826129,
-0.0899486393,
-0.0392897129,
0.0504881628,
0.017679695,
-0.0167002678,
-0.0959881321,
-0.0188006535,
-0.0046992111,
0.0554746613,
0.0000848994,
0.0288500842,
0.0062518939,
-0.0398427173,
-0.0568285175,
0.0096399458,
-0.0835071132,
0.0253076702,
-0.0197749082,
0.008040919,
-0.0047445963,
-0.0272295624,
0.0144630922,
0.0419762395,
-0.0703934133,
-0.0568923391,
0.0139103876,
0.0138727548,
0.0296016019,
0.0704108253,
-0.0264681969,
-0.060689602,
0.0404159129,
0.0246938374,
-0.0154007748,
0.0304184929,
-0.0072551966,
-0.0083279219,
-0.0031311673,
0.0350553878,
-0.0279542282,
0.0080745984,
0.0039427206,
0.0362997279,
0.0364899375,
-0.0310871247,
0.0164966602,
0.0263819359,
0.0105773555,
-0.0169915035,
0.0303984657,
-0.0224552676,
0.0225102622,
-0.0305217765,
-0.0204473753,
-0.023489356,
0.0445060208,
0.0235778391,
-0.0377663225,
0.0234581307,
-0.0205127746,
-0.0325391255,
0.004037593,
-0.0152792307,
-0.0590579435,
-0.0467371717,
0.0065869936,
0.0594519228,
-0.0212311707,
-0.023321582,
0.0249371342,
-0.0091092428,
0.0650567263,
-0.0137621285,
0.0414608344,
0.0166720692,
-0.0021681471,
-0.0408029184,
0.0013719634,
-0.0537839085,
-0.0414056592,
-0.0343355536,
0.0156391412,
0.0503211953,
0.0421104953,
0.0800387114,
-0.0368426032,
0.0103083178,
-0.0123501839,
0.0234616771,
0.0365727171,
-0.0640786812,
-0.0153661408,
0.0071597677,
-0.015070552,
-0.0089876987,
0.0693883225,
-0.038069848,
0.023707116,
-0.0033666678,
-0.0190651454,
-0.026972333,
-0.0781374276,
-0.0508864447,
-0.0257603005,
-0.0192024764,
-0.0369336009,
-0.0531210452,
-0.0661789626,
0.023705896,
0.0482319109,
0.0007647864,
-0.0081620384,
0.0125322826,
0.0674518347,
-0.007590103,
-0.0378704518,
-0.0387958288,
0.0244044848,
-0.0038736768,
-0.0137617476,
0.0131773716,
-6.693776174e-33,
-0.0272160638,
-0.0542486347,
0.0590912588,
-0.0561397523,
-0.0617826134,
-0.0033608405,
-0.0357414596,
-0.0018579121,
0.0320740268,
0.0292306282,
-0.013126825,
0.0401415303,
0.0173321646,
0.0297086351,
-0.0091903256,
0.0130210193,
0.0716529414,
0.0176373143,
-0.0636755154,
0.0858931318,
0.0664550737,
0.005785462,
0.0237909108,
-0.0386373028,
0.0178751778,
-0.0282590017,
-0.0300264303,
0.0232840572,
-0.0429046638,
0.0248488467,
-0.0229563639,
0.0216615275,
0.0119112115,
-0.0366368033,
-0.0422846898,
0.012572322,
-0.0502242967,
-0.0013353634,
-0.0062518739,
0.0071050059,
-0.0724199191,
-0.0469456986,
0.0676252469,
-0.0074554887,
0.0151082594,
-0.0125260223,
0.0116034402,
-0.0287816413,
-0.0246397294,
-0.0098067801,
-0.0792132765,
0.0195613932,
0.0242389496,
-0.0118838688,
-0.0154340658,
0.0392455906,
-0.0098901605,
-0.0476096198,
-0.0753904879,
0.0091926772,
0.0275397804,
0.029767355,
0.063188605,
-0.0075978264,
-0.0152035514,
0.0571153536,
0.0471857488,
0.0408890136,
-0.041284766,
-0.0112613719,
0.0270309895,
0.0262699258,
0.0481195711,
0.0423986167,
0.0501016788,
-0.0261752624,
-0.0358096249,
0.0139250113,
-0.0394590273,
0.0256863944,
0.0481507964,
-0.0158089977,
-0.0388323516,
-0.0250320174,
-0.0275393818,
0.0467894487,
-0.0286662392,
-0.0395607278,
0.0354131386,
0.0354734734,
-0.0280213803,
-0.0253321771,
0.0179600455,
-0.0227489602,
0.0006719284,
0.0274767801,
-0.0381749645,
-0.0000187626,
-0.0317637175,
0.0210465323,
0.0050757788,
-0.0192010533,
0.0255619381,
0.0351898633,
0.0060840091,
0.0345006846,
0.0281782467,
0.0229810365,
-0.0658983141,
0.0219498836,
-0.0460939072,
0.0620122142,
0.022983769,
-0.0083333962,
0.0493445061,
-0.0078215823,
-0.0018525606,
0.0265383124,
0.0180446915,
-0.0020904308,
-0.0193289462,
0.0478418544,
0.011532994,
0.0302926507,
-0.0254176073,
0.0224363972,
-0.0418136306,
0.0224957988,
0.0183593053,
-0.0650604367,
-0.0049687875,
0.0064448821,
2.844e-7,
-0.0102266809,
0.0527082086,
0.0485967621,
0.0325727053,
0.0192109924,
-0.0040511144,
0.0229364447,
-0.0001336328,
0.0195676573,
-0.0132702133,
-0.0142401597,
0.0385021493,
0.0821417645,
0.0529081151,
-0.0670285597,
-0.0245876927,
-0.0505640432,
0.0154360551,
-0.0524129048,
-0.0435786843,
0.046916306,
0.0309412479,
-0.0079500498,
-0.0346220322,
0.0273676589,
-0.0525691807,
0.0712659732,
0.049624797,
-0.0036401933,
0.0302695148,
0.0513397157,
0.0305707119,
0.0223983806,
0.0266397595,
-0.029080119,
-0.0299929492,
-0.0427325629,
0.0378493033,
-0.0109359557,
-0.0290372465,
-0.0091999471,
-0.0291731562,
0.0041606515,
-0.0536073223,
0.0458901785,
-0.0246956274,
0.0289544445,
-0.0293565057,
-0.0193996821,
-0.0173166264,
0.0223367158,
0.0032903054,
-0.0170931853,
0.0343469083,
0.0147164539,
0.0343702435,
-0.006461014,
-0.0835671574,
-0.0320723765,
0.0014804264,
-0.0288348403,
-0.022709921,
-0.0190243516,
-0.0007501227,
-0.0150079625,
-0.0849525705,
0.0157018378,
2.814897318e-34,
0.0239540562,
-0.0020673308,
0.0356908031,
0.0112263709,
0.0293548144,
0.0022956887,
0.038289994,
0.0180270132,
0.010962449,
-0.032748241,
-0.0392562635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09109v2 | Does Pre-trained Language Model Actually Infer Unseen Links in Knowledge Graph Completion? | 2023-11-15T16:56:49 | 2024-06-06T16:01:08 | Yusuke Sakai, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Katsuhiko Hayashi, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Knowledge graphs (KGs) consist of links that describe relationships between
entities. Due to the difficulty of manually enumerating all relationships
between entities, automatically completing them is essential for KGs. Knowledge
Graph Completion (KGC) is a task that infers unseen relationships between
entities in a KG. Traditional embedding-based KGC methods, such as RESCAL,
TransE, DistMult, ComplEx, RotatE, HAKE, HousE, etc., infer missing links using
only the knowledge from training data. In contrast, the recent Pre-trained
Language Model (PLM)-based KGC utilizes knowledge obtained during pre-training.
Therefore, PLM-based KGC can estimate missing links between entities by reusing
memorized knowledge from pre-training without inference. This approach is
problematic because building KGC models aims to infer unseen links between
entities. However, conventional evaluations in KGC do not consider inference
and memorization abilities separately. Thus, a PLM-based KGC method, which
achieves high performance in current KGC evaluations, may be ineffective in
practical applications. To address this issue, we analyze whether PLM-based KGC
methods make inferences or merely access memorized knowledge. For this purpose,
we propose a method for constructing synthetic datasets specified in this
analysis and conclude that PLMs acquire the inference abilities required for
KGC through pre-training, even though the performance improvements mostly come
from textual information of entities and relations. | [
0.0490813553,
0.0190033857,
-0.0170099512,
0.0459839515,
0.0163019784,
0.0075106509,
-0.0414971709,
0.0093806898,
0.0761865377,
-0.0226839539,
0.0138254194,
0.0172998402,
0.0108029312,
-0.0152996415,
0.0356002301,
-0.0203741565,
0.0395989418,
0.033766374,
-0.0141829988,
-0.0304799005,
-0.0333889835,
0.0244077202,
0.0009615811,
-0.0168769471,
-0.0184671562,
0.0155449063,
-0.0181991085,
-0.0065335818,
0.0155026009,
-0.0212546885,
-0.0342278145,
0.0394734666,
-0.0110093355,
-0.0439477526,
0.0000019884,
-0.058790829,
0.0065634679,
-0.0350870304,
-0.044288028,
0.0078441724,
-0.000700262,
-0.0137598328,
0.0379559025,
-0.0217452515,
-0.0265003536,
-0.0577946343,
0.0188519377,
0.0405058153,
-0.0091674505,
0.0687207952,
-0.019187199,
-0.0295430757,
0.0172963832,
-0.0167681407,
-0.0115635116,
-0.0190382283,
0.0440396629,
0.0315208845,
-0.0212311354,
-0.0191584453,
-0.0263787881,
0.0467452891,
0.0223603416,
0.0291194301,
0.0452070385,
0.056270007,
-0.0112825893,
-0.0094832191,
0.054187648,
0.1113857105,
-0.0182657093,
-0.0211811475,
0.0167820789,
0.0016573877,
0.004818928,
0.0661808401,
-0.0176704042,
-0.027517911,
-0.011454558,
0.0287236907,
-0.0219874587,
-0.0239349082,
0.0528559163,
-0.0182236545,
-0.0194236711,
0.0595991872,
0.0024306667,
-0.0195888393,
0.0318508595,
0.0434657335,
-0.0067573609,
-0.0502438843,
0.0174335334,
0.0214424897,
0.0185540766,
0.0528970696,
-0.0326958299,
0.0321375169,
0.0023563835,
-0.0386547223,
-0.0128569128,
0.022369789,
-0.0023780705,
0.0389284566,
-0.1174492911,
0.002084892,
0.0098137269,
-0.0029341436,
-0.045745831,
-0.0063494011,
-0.0341810696,
0.0052693072,
-0.027887132,
0.0520946644,
-0.023623405,
-0.0177710447,
-0.0310874023,
0.0340988487,
-0.0066147335,
0.0440993756,
0.0177670196,
0.0045577497,
-0.0057105874,
-0.0086949924,
-0.066774711,
-0.0029965308,
-0.0377662145,
0.0286275502,
-0.05629953,
-0.0063105114,
-0.0114788217,
-0.0169980116,
0.0309674311,
-0.0324144587,
0.0160980392,
0.0432890207,
0.0132677788,
-0.0269034896,
-0.0783724859,
-0.0556122363,
0.0118142953,
-0.0708205923,
0.0352493674,
-0.0629043803,
0.066515021,
0.0335836522,
0.0044807591,
-0.0298076682,
0.0195012279,
-0.0201935004,
-0.1016032696,
0.056500826,
-0.0483471379,
0.0383262075,
-0.0287203789,
-0.0023662995,
0.0057310341,
0.0628452748,
-0.0198884159,
-0.0050325575,
0.0457360037,
0.0100513557,
-0.0306817386,
0.0260379184,
0.0623867437,
-0.0188624877,
0.0071072308,
0.0033601271,
-0.0061924728,
0.0060669556,
0.040723417,
0.034148436,
-0.0305864774,
-0.0034686197,
0.0260115154,
0.0307917427,
0.0395139344,
0.0244246647,
0.0672259554,
-0.02752202,
0.0498412549,
0.0334793851,
-0.0474809669,
-0.0061146426,
-0.0608332679,
0.0227158312,
0.0039001745,
0.0030572256,
-0.0303539727,
-0.0107771931,
0.0048885075,
-0.0262014233,
0.018837614,
0.0158345457,
0.0850223005,
0.04354202,
-0.0228917114,
0.0549851544,
0.065344587,
-0.015175228,
0.0208163336,
0.0425555147,
0.009676558,
0.0655494705,
0.0405896045,
0.0022732867,
-0.0196741186,
0.026712412,
0.0028915615,
0.0047289603,
0.0220006797,
-0.0390217304,
0.0153540121,
-0.0377942361,
-0.0422692895,
0.0314256139,
-0.0013207176,
-0.0008028767,
0.0510555245,
0.0388727523,
0.043485444,
-0.0822624415,
0.0176985413,
0.0382306576,
-0.0517600887,
0.0287267137,
-0.0213260185,
0.0250426475,
-0.0051239464,
0.0494135804,
0.0170680005,
-0.0137513019,
0.0487195998,
-0.0077566197,
-0.0220086761,
0.018214114,
-0.0382653922,
-0.085558854,
0.034690313,
-0.0195660666,
-0.005932855,
-0.0098779611,
-0.0177715961,
-0.0502896383,
0.0263069551,
0.019753959,
0.1038858071,
-0.0231856331,
0.0220949668,
0.0004336926,
-0.0256264638,
0.0142393121,
0.0887722597,
-0.0027325463,
0.0455545373,
0.0004006436,
0.0089807874,
0.0064673843,
-0.0046143457,
-0.0564150587,
0.0049145403,
0.0079265032,
-0.0253027473,
-0.0072792657,
-0.0410957634,
-0.0680245161,
0.0166964829,
-0.1117797345,
-0.0028256252,
0.0252949819,
0.0065725772,
-0.008035861,
0.0006269418,
-0.0050701662,
-0.0146345058,
0.0074167578,
0.0227046758,
-0.0130920261,
0.042272497,
0.004749761,
-0.0151351513,
-0.0150809893,
-0.0303746257,
-0.0255936682,
-0.016517546,
0.0707856193,
-0.0092519345,
-0.0199516378,
-0.002706612,
0.0724898577,
-0.0610448979,
0.0147766275,
-0.026958473,
-0.0211726353,
-0.0272040963,
-0.0171820614,
0.0491501391,
0.0003379779,
-0.0512360744,
-0.0042464104,
0.0258380845,
-0.0260855909,
-0.0540357083,
-0.0011923104,
-0.0530118234,
0.0041110888,
-0.0557811484,
0.0098872548,
-0.0581955984,
0.0323117785,
0.0023438418,
-0.0266356915,
-0.0514749698,
-0.0302903354,
0.0049010357,
0.0164381005,
-0.0058234059,
0.0011040634,
0.022773765,
0.0138430912,
-0.0337278098,
-0.0051324614,
0.0474859178,
-0.0144370459,
0.0118282335,
0.0367922857,
0.0142330024,
0.0068946127,
0.0629762858,
0.0438641645,
0.0122539476,
-0.0108596208,
-0.0070483494,
-0.0616131239,
0.0489865243,
0.0172112547,
-0.0225938018,
0.0259550437,
-0.0282458253,
0.0239035916,
0.0311173405,
0.0309871882,
-0.0581999496,
0.026128253,
-0.0282939449,
0.0082273707,
0.012663194,
0.0066995807,
0.028611226,
0.0063417079,
-0.0074760704,
0.0072235172,
0.0182173438,
-0.0070091826,
-0.0051952722,
0.0278196372,
0.0221837945,
-0.0439600199,
0.0055393381,
0.0001064788,
0.0078903716,
0.0269526113,
0.0016416123,
-0.0258304235,
0.0098269321,
0.0278400313,
-0.0131519036,
-0.0292616393,
-0.0486286953,
-0.0043003452,
-0.0046822974,
-0.0218573119,
0.0169766191,
0.1119779572,
0.0195802599,
-0.0327508226,
0.0006234874,
0.0365038812,
-0.0031742314,
0.0380945466,
-0.0025913909,
-0.0939101651,
0.0109445555,
-0.0033428916,
-0.0154722091,
0.0071937256,
-0.0803347006,
0.0066861915,
-0.1339621991,
-0.0225048717,
0.0051568197,
-0.0337690152,
-0.0558932014,
-0.0595842041,
-0.0012867972,
-0.0051496769,
-0.0468456559,
0.0144890994,
-0.0061759222,
0.0117494864,
-0.0039774054,
-0.0504055768,
-0.0770879835,
-0.0051857629,
-0.0582408197,
0.0678021759,
-0.0102096628,
0.0354148299,
0.0152252736,
-0.0088387998,
0.0296667218,
0.0041635954,
-0.0081719123,
-0.008205398,
0.0584927015,
-0.0179615114,
0.0030138493,
-0.0146376118,
-0.0134944161,
-0.04560728,
-0.01293913,
-0.0175069068,
0.0768903419,
0.0091060493,
-0.0448570102,
0.0255868975,
0.0023457888,
-0.0154422354,
0.0665386692,
0.0100671789,
0.007232117,
0.0059331837,
-0.0036467977,
0.0382840186,
0.004251848,
-0.0091815684,
0.0581274219,
-0.047850538,
0.026294075,
-0.0597180128,
-0.0948844999,
0.0619097799,
0.0358174928,
0.0085425442,
0.0431333147,
0.0172994174,
-0.0220936611,
-0.0671413019,
0.0226253886,
-0.0413120613,
-0.0108429426,
0.0149227036,
-0.0256857052,
0.0050568115,
-0.0305216163,
-0.0070472979,
-0.0190445203,
-0.04214653,
-0.0522640608,
-0.0352198742,
0.0394984968,
0.0192045458,
0.085809648,
-0.0257799476,
-0.0189499948,
0.0423579104,
0.0249971487,
-0.0754638985,
0.037767645,
0.0135640353,
-0.0233743154,
0.0141160963,
0.0399136357,
-0.0451287143,
0.0044273213,
0.0431162007,
0.057528615,
-0.0256010834,
-0.051040072,
-0.0053861993,
0.0262066927,
0.0524665192,
-0.0003660367,
0.0218744073,
-0.0590152964,
0.0164487846,
-0.02173106,
-0.0143109746,
-0.0403642468,
-0.0216463152,
0.0400141515,
0.0604472794,
0.0059380708,
-0.0625533909,
-0.0201969184,
0.0569316596,
0.010028814,
-0.0464993976,
0.0489155352,
-0.0050892774,
0.0696594045,
0.0085351178,
-0.021781398,
0.0113661001,
0.0131556299,
0.0173235573,
-0.0366877392,
0.0073690554,
0.0104618268,
-0.0148057276,
-0.0343334414,
-0.023257751,
-0.0055328691,
-0.0093890429,
-0.0365909189,
0.0279114433,
0.0805689543,
-0.0469727553,
0.0329254419,
-0.0287277829,
-0.0063952496,
-0.0018667076,
0.0221499298,
-0.0066908747,
-0.0282929707,
0.0200730171,
0.0014715169,
-0.0287801176,
0.0565564707,
0.0758928359,
0.0224367529,
0.082008861,
-0.0418381877,
-0.0366725475,
-0.0233628675,
-0.0323133357,
0.0123393238,
0.031274993,
-0.0276444927,
0.0298718754,
-0.0556275696,
-0.1292655319,
0.0188965108,
-0.0297655966,
-0.0390982591,
0.0153564857,
0.0322508849,
0.0249124356,
0.0219133478,
-0.0168605745,
-0.0290276911,
-0.0021405637,
-0.0123090828,
-0.0046795639,
0.0066768969,
-6.540549016e-33,
-0.0467202738,
-0.038444031,
0.016991118,
-0.0002753437,
-0.0249725822,
0.0246270504,
-0.0382611416,
0.002462364,
-0.0465338193,
0.037422806,
-0.0191694275,
-0.0027775143,
0.0032626686,
0.0103115598,
-0.0052211159,
0.0133144185,
0.0222595576,
0.0050386246,
0.0211449098,
-0.0119244494,
0.0261341482,
0.0459795408,
0.0861777142,
-0.0622763,
0.0317963436,
-0.0220461059,
0.0176731255,
0.0111120241,
0.0180996563,
0.0388596095,
-0.0201832633,
0.0397186428,
0.0304039232,
-0.0008687649,
-0.001740924,
-0.0146684749,
-0.1483655721,
-0.064917013,
0.0496430509,
0.0212583318,
-0.025355,
0.0036037436,
0.0343271382,
-0.0063055078,
0.0473277047,
-0.0222818926,
0.0434478074,
-0.03378544,
-0.0735670328,
-0.0402210578,
-0.0315748118,
0.0261691492,
0.0309587009,
0.0325298123,
0.0253433883,
0.0000953889,
0.0027179939,
-0.027684141,
-0.08360672,
-0.0173491947,
0.0135840625,
-0.0109688444,
0.020925656,
0.0129959257,
0.0365362391,
0.0458580591,
0.0249363482,
-0.0110864416,
-0.0496357828,
0.0415134169,
0.0346625559,
0.0223330893,
-0.0316507928,
0.0307599902,
-0.0188698601,
-0.0399414226,
-0.0675019026,
-0.0055952668,
-0.0047620623,
0.0070574344,
-0.0075763804,
-0.011685906,
-0.0269725882,
-0.053184174,
-0.0548543856,
-0.0494277105,
-0.0184379425,
-0.0728355795,
0.0012305307,
0.0257454254,
-0.0153182624,
0.0046148025,
-0.0061898902,
-0.0510662645,
-0.0250543021,
0.0225516111,
-0.0069282795,
0.0094876355,
-0.006876254,
0.0144611057,
-0.0644223467,
-0.0439046472,
0.0337339044,
-0.0395537801,
0.0083433473,
0.0125029245,
0.0268877018,
0.0089527601,
-0.0267689656,
-0.0164684933,
-0.0270772446,
-0.0306109507,
0.0088037997,
-0.0241029914,
0.0617775396,
0.0304964762,
-0.0100550437,
0.0223064013,
0.0613813885,
0.0100318491,
-0.0138687426,
0.0317482054,
0.0242189076,
-0.0018483966,
-0.0131775858,
-0.0274185091,
-0.0278414972,
-0.0190757569,
0.0308636818,
-0.0448650829,
-0.0043136277,
0.0162020959,
2.789e-7,
0.0419490412,
-0.001095566,
0.013128533,
0.0204703789,
-0.0087734461,
-0.017275732,
0.0317086354,
-0.0003635738,
0.0286341105,
-0.034521509,
0.0443035774,
0.024913324,
0.0056256698,
0.0339321978,
-0.09830264,
-0.005045265,
-0.0192639437,
-0.0399662517,
-0.0350162983,
-0.0322361626,
0.0118882218,
0.0387824774,
0.0728822201,
0.0191276986,
-0.0388328023,
-0.0382930301,
0.0595085509,
-0.028278539,
-0.0007959495,
0.0235316977,
0.028097786,
0.0387627557,
-0.0233932901,
0.0933599845,
-0.0050194343,
0.0477533787,
0.0445868783,
0.0406645834,
0.0047264053,
-0.0031597228,
-0.0064956378,
-0.0566615015,
0.0178729724,
-0.0450143926,
0.101413168,
-0.0580591187,
0.0173048098,
0.0803854018,
-0.0526336916,
-0.0170008596,
0.0004216154,
0.012079942,
0.0029840064,
0.021561956,
0.0243691113,
0.0082586901,
0.0039555356,
-0.0879079103,
-0.0037409193,
0.0523033068,
-0.0281518456,
-0.0528219417,
0.0318981409,
-0.0398754887,
0.0305741969,
-0.0110226776,
0.032991644,
2.499369838e-34,
-0.0147880549,
0.0072479495,
0.018087497,
-0.0006057399,
0.0437113196,
-0.066071175,
-0.0081517734,
0.0217640977,
0.0061571179,
-0.095159173,
0.0000286212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09106v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09106v2 | "We Demand Justice!": Towards Social Context Grounding of Political Texts | 2023-11-15T16:53:35 | 2024-02-26T09:34:42 | Rajkumar Pujari, Chengfei Wu, Dan Goldwasser | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media discourse frequently consists of 'seemingly similar language
used by opposing sides of the political spectrum', often translating to starkly
contrasting perspectives. E.g., 'thoughts and prayers', could express sympathy
for mass-shooting victims, or criticize the lack of legislative action on the
issue. This paper defines the context required to fully understand such
ambiguous statements in a computational setting and ground them in real-world
entities, actions, and attitudes. We propose two challenging datasets that
require an understanding of the real-world context of the text. We benchmark
these datasets against models built upon large pre-trained models, such as
RoBERTa and GPT-3. Additionally, we develop and benchmark more structured
models building upon existing Discourse Contextualization Framework and
Political Actor Representation models. We analyze the datasets and the
predictions to obtain further insights into the pragmatic language
understanding challenges posed by the proposed social grounding tasks. | [
0.0336980931,
0.0650520995,
0.0303286817,
0.0534702279,
-0.0061454838,
0.0123173986,
-0.0098638507,
-0.0351661593,
-0.0364768282,
-0.054268714,
0.0053833188,
-0.0354217552,
-0.0062652128,
-0.0151890945,
-0.0179570876,
-0.0476693399,
0.0244358424,
0.0534357615,
0.0406703539,
-0.026714528,
0.059006542,
0.0624777526,
0.0087422347,
0.0299901813,
-0.0517851599,
-0.0243062936,
-0.0109188193,
0.0214331392,
0.0650007278,
-0.002781725,
0.0347407162,
0.0495261773,
0.059499111,
0.0672635734,
0.000001685,
-0.0172557477,
0.001044228,
-0.0415285416,
-0.0020173825,
-0.0115036163,
0.0467295609,
-0.0570486486,
0.0000882858,
-0.0033257396,
-0.0426631235,
0.014354323,
0.0086327586,
0.0587994568,
0.0684528351,
0.0636640564,
-0.013559646,
-0.0425500907,
-0.0243174322,
-0.0240627918,
-0.0145000108,
-0.0483809561,
0.0300979167,
0.0111717824,
-0.0443886966,
0.0275558922,
-0.0124013545,
0.0225557256,
0.036888551,
-0.0016481034,
-0.0516725853,
0.0147309341,
-0.0286411922,
0.0130089512,
-0.0108663011,
0.0923502892,
0.0665207654,
-0.0458875187,
0.0196716748,
-0.0187253691,
-0.0149412649,
0.0187351238,
-0.0121650156,
0.0374076925,
-0.0200929809,
0.0674877763,
0.0342365019,
0.0282270908,
0.0292486642,
0.0445091538,
-0.0104236789,
0.0314579159,
-0.0382301845,
0.0005556838,
0.0164613333,
0.0248703584,
-0.0367284566,
-0.0033737686,
0.0243746154,
-0.0244990084,
-0.0113787558,
0.0393524282,
-0.0634364486,
-0.0233680774,
0.0198505148,
-0.0710960105,
0.0320650972,
0.0163400192,
-0.0206501987,
0.0836942792,
0.0271972399,
-0.0104400953,
-0.0367120579,
0.0089408979,
0.0083457092,
-0.0376919806,
-0.0460274704,
0.0030547336,
-0.0330397151,
-0.0001202157,
-0.0677332357,
0.0080251982,
-0.0077663073,
-0.0277227722,
-0.0412727259,
-0.0039511123,
0.0022626405,
0.0267891437,
-0.0326814689,
-0.0088271052,
-0.0149039887,
0.0532186069,
-0.0751801729,
0.0346780792,
-0.0412587076,
-0.0425258763,
0.0190716516,
0.0080099059,
-0.000939295,
-0.0033742094,
-0.0134656122,
-0.0022542793,
-0.0068425266,
0.0122266365,
-0.0116375266,
-0.0262318887,
-0.0069430149,
-0.058648929,
-0.0197159927,
-0.0589667112,
0.0525494851,
0.0107982093,
-0.0023675784,
-0.0568737164,
0.0248247981,
0.0330883749,
-0.0127094937,
0.1022832394,
0.0498587191,
-0.0075016082,
0.0396587476,
0.0460497849,
0.0087916916,
0.1020644084,
0.0133985486,
-0.0100244526,
0.0454271883,
0.0032244427,
-0.0256402623,
0.0099611692,
0.024352422,
0.0207344443,
-0.0201462712,
0.0451906249,
-0.0369409397,
0.0208663661,
0.0137749426,
0.0442891642,
-0.003385311,
-0.0659510642,
0.0298166871,
0.0922325775,
-0.0454973988,
0.0191352237,
0.0330600999,
0.0440981202,
-0.0074524092,
0.0029144052,
-0.0068816198,
0.0013985261,
-0.0037046419,
-0.033628609,
-0.0229735412,
0.0218442213,
-0.0401534811,
-0.0133879613,
-0.0031619812,
0.0116181085,
0.0393866822,
-0.0220520645,
0.0179544445,
-0.0209150854,
-0.0664466992,
0.030491652,
0.0469838791,
-0.0870287493,
-0.0129781514,
-0.0046822811,
-0.007147104,
0.0230101831,
0.0120500289,
-0.0230644196,
-0.0232037269,
-0.0458509848,
0.1026087701,
0.0657436103,
0.0290410127,
-0.0278602708,
-0.0142381759,
-0.0274573751,
-0.0311295465,
-0.0127123613,
0.0072740442,
0.0570987836,
0.033221595,
-0.0038003738,
0.0106174806,
-0.0024383324,
-0.0019511506,
0.0261058193,
-0.0075657894,
-0.0100622764,
-0.0082058171,
0.0283340625,
0.023990633,
0.0472834148,
-0.0083423648,
-0.0487765819,
0.0395302624,
-0.0268460102,
-0.0000157255,
0.0314596444,
-0.0742506161,
0.0042707729,
0.0404659621,
-0.0653160065,
-0.058562547,
0.0263796784,
-0.0615494289,
-0.0212887302,
0.0439503714,
0.0110812448,
0.0132841002,
-0.0462159775,
-0.0290168226,
-0.0459087417,
-0.0088511324,
-0.0234384015,
0.0766674355,
0.0029519724,
-0.0120393746,
0.0126446579,
0.0108635463,
0.0500962138,
0.0028166897,
-0.0103104496,
-0.0224420056,
0.0201500375,
0.0251558758,
0.030588638,
-0.0121677695,
-0.0487043671,
-0.0210576616,
-0.0937747061,
-0.0287171621,
-0.0538122542,
0.009850435,
0.0560949557,
-0.0097784419,
-0.0080228159,
-0.0093115317,
-0.0121383816,
-0.0232160874,
-0.0306163169,
-0.0179090854,
0.0394261815,
0.0025819757,
0.0089068944,
-0.0390026309,
0.0044194008,
-0.037545938,
0.0122630578,
0.0118666589,
-0.0580686703,
0.0075451923,
0.0415533781,
-0.0217291713,
0.0118012764,
-0.0392781757,
-0.0362373255,
0.0466760434,
0.035494931,
0.0402114801,
0.0509926826,
0.0151539575,
0.07785552,
0.0017265312,
0.0198977143,
-0.0520205759,
-0.0074891713,
-0.0267318729,
0.0138464458,
-0.0456467904,
-0.0178173557,
-0.0086356159,
0.0681501776,
0.0235550813,
0.0224089511,
-0.0547534041,
0.0226286445,
-0.0289506782,
-0.0346875042,
-0.0480960906,
-0.0186056234,
-0.0151950913,
0.0188881326,
-0.0440668799,
0.0152617507,
0.0376997478,
-0.0005404374,
0.0252788495,
-0.0234456286,
-0.0239893086,
-0.0186787676,
0.0786345601,
-0.0303507056,
0.009148892,
-0.0550675988,
-0.0182687156,
-0.0084017012,
-0.0607521199,
0.0448416919,
-0.0288303737,
0.0766678527,
-0.0363283232,
0.0449014716,
-0.021107303,
-0.0305505823,
-0.0421688333,
-0.0820532069,
-0.0361363515,
0.0028373431,
-0.0178458653,
-0.0282957572,
0.0194832794,
0.0234974325,
-0.0144898081,
-0.0099456944,
0.0219637714,
-0.0056897728,
-0.0207615718,
-0.0023565614,
-0.0010473706,
-0.0121640619,
0.0142878564,
0.0047352901,
0.0181686692,
0.0321880467,
0.0251551159,
-0.0229923949,
-0.0369140841,
-0.0270908922,
0.0065720771,
-0.0186439268,
0.0112995096,
-0.0421441272,
0.0604452528,
-0.0160987284,
-0.0040135793,
0.103602156,
0.0325242206,
-0.0350384489,
-0.0083382139,
-0.0079173809,
-0.0004795449,
0.0227502771,
-0.014399874,
-0.0964679345,
-0.0015404738,
-0.0081232209,
-0.0134657063,
-0.0126829157,
-0.049852442,
-0.0073238881,
-0.0754672289,
0.0009227267,
-0.0117840413,
-0.0131319705,
-0.0224717874,
-0.0113322511,
0.0308533423,
0.0001887868,
0.0386013649,
-0.0272509865,
0.0050634281,
-0.0003668123,
0.0187847745,
0.0055309916,
-0.0403795652,
0.0170910954,
-0.0279112514,
0.0495075807,
0.0278516542,
0.0562121458,
0.0158299264,
-0.0017755358,
0.0424888954,
-0.0087323664,
-0.0399805717,
-0.0129173258,
0.0043394454,
-0.0112277893,
-0.0213418379,
-0.01694455,
0.0618677586,
-0.0580154136,
-0.0336959884,
-0.0117007131,
0.0277721416,
-0.0209012162,
0.0120876506,
-0.0080124252,
0.0498062447,
0.0497813262,
0.093850024,
0.0648312643,
0.0036465921,
-0.0243025105,
-0.0510961786,
0.0391051471,
-0.0674966797,
-0.0302338377,
-0.033411622,
-0.0018810092,
0.0161228627,
0.0008673235,
-0.0535796322,
0.0308311023,
0.0243936479,
-0.001130798,
0.0008321076,
0.0490820818,
-0.026165301,
-0.0345863961,
0.0312129632,
-0.0316456482,
0.0205127336,
0.0035900562,
-0.0507695377,
0.0081216199,
0.0241471361,
-0.0364111252,
-0.0071476367,
-0.0444388464,
-0.0606156066,
0.0193396602,
-0.0368922204,
0.0190112274,
0.0373270884,
-0.0250857174,
-0.0101231467,
0.018852273,
0.0426769182,
-0.0183852799,
0.0266830325,
0.0481709316,
0.0373154432,
0.0179453567,
0.0461499169,
0.0130982911,
0.0158156138,
0.0398699827,
0.0101008229,
-0.0900910124,
-0.0057914653,
-0.0061810808,
-0.0419690683,
0.0337078646,
0.00903768,
-0.0699810907,
-0.0719498321,
-0.0457575023,
-0.0525131822,
-0.0230442844,
-0.0024170612,
-0.0105496645,
0.0341106728,
-0.0480637848,
-0.0539156385,
0.0158387851,
-0.0450896844,
0.0769095644,
-0.0310521536,
0.0418722257,
0.0262700617,
0.0393355526,
-0.0088303387,
-0.0061159963,
-0.0136134382,
0.0345186815,
-0.010283011,
0.0222587027,
-0.0032275189,
0.0258387569,
0.0168136191,
0.013944759,
0.0348580517,
-0.0123603065,
-0.0351729132,
-0.0040459754,
-0.0187042989,
0.0399308614,
0.0344815552,
-0.028915463,
0.0349142365,
0.0097350776,
-0.0174687989,
0.0145302163,
0.0360872559,
0.0070537506,
-0.035557054,
0.0416229628,
0.0224277675,
-0.0197892748,
0.0205362663,
0.0314002261,
-0.0359637514,
0.0583273433,
0.0856543556,
-0.0251134932,
-0.0173354354,
-0.0527237505,
-0.0017312426,
0.0081450287,
0.0054338523,
0.0107153542,
-0.0795991868,
-0.0305929147,
0.0220997259,
-0.001415065,
-0.0382023752,
0.0279783569,
0.0104574077,
0.0567375571,
-0.0035185874,
0.0525334254,
-0.0346062183,
0.0315875523,
-0.0495889261,
-0.0461288951,
-0.0490510575,
-5.934676452e-33,
-0.0373351127,
-0.0302489214,
-0.0084284386,
-0.0184089206,
-0.0291666184,
0.0541953333,
-0.0331442058,
-0.0003551685,
-0.0147006987,
0.0577469058,
-0.003704482,
0.0706411675,
0.0239844918,
0.0282381792,
-0.0377605632,
-0.0493892469,
0.0195868816,
0.0031372812,
-0.0227612704,
0.0322276056,
0.061859183,
-0.003563744,
0.0543373227,
-0.1053683907,
0.032877706,
-0.0175961982,
-0.0144433081,
0.0062964787,
0.0246496554,
0.0257429481,
-0.0217552911,
0.0657478422,
0.0284068268,
-0.0146302171,
0.0076659326,
0.0977777764,
-0.078225933,
-0.0392893106,
0.0516802482,
0.009615602,
-0.0295759588,
0.0029301632,
-0.0075088628,
-0.00097076,
-0.0096515082,
0.0222959779,
0.0303590223,
0.0009929109,
0.0322452262,
-0.0192504562,
-0.0785028487,
0.0251813177,
-0.0248361044,
0.0044900365,
-0.0128781497,
0.0040933308,
0.0489078574,
0.0373253636,
-0.0996006206,
-0.0049719177,
-0.056578245,
-0.0111521715,
0.0438119918,
-0.000499695,
0.0127109569,
0.096255824,
-0.0443490371,
0.019520862,
-0.0525927767,
-0.014003084,
-0.0066880193,
-0.0089654615,
0.02900373,
0.1011824906,
-0.0002822246,
-0.0290812235,
-0.0695455894,
-0.0029246793,
0.0591069236,
-0.0071131969,
0.0326911472,
-0.0310760271,
-0.0057940185,
-0.0174764115,
-0.0472431816,
-0.0641806051,
-0.0094189569,
-0.003121264,
-0.005586491,
-0.0184409823,
-0.0287172962,
0.0254357569,
0.019089492,
-0.0476288348,
-0.0179305486,
0.0826980546,
0.0084790168,
-0.0146765439,
0.0297168959,
0.0523923039,
-0.0298687164,
-0.0139951073,
0.002925839,
0.0076981392,
0.0155246397,
-0.0439773388,
0.0479201414,
-0.0182956178,
-0.0364263169,
-0.0025095385,
-0.028637372,
0.0347932838,
-0.0536855981,
0.0430393927,
0.0391547009,
0.0545367524,
-0.0066877543,
0.0318406597,
0.0458057858,
-0.0209650416,
0.044741068,
-0.0034008466,
-0.0636984184,
0.0179107003,
-0.036283128,
-0.0232119579,
-0.0199349113,
0.0432925262,
0.0559872426,
-0.0315023959,
-0.0098236864,
0.0025686829,
2.326e-7,
0.0668031871,
0.0184115171,
0.0463005826,
-0.013394204,
-0.0019431355,
0.0350473598,
0.0406854972,
0.0367668197,
-0.0638823584,
-0.0905052796,
-0.0047742124,
0.0575704873,
0.0504290424,
0.007365976,
-0.0489292257,
0.0062050205,
-0.058091104,
0.0210462809,
-0.0410239473,
0.0257181823,
0.017035488,
0.0608686395,
0.038983006,
-0.0118022552,
-0.0316320546,
-0.0051183468,
0.0405137166,
-0.0877686143,
-0.0156264659,
0.0159003604,
-0.0032661217,
-0.0323114954,
0.0112336706,
0.0084216595,
0.0214917921,
0.0012911346,
-0.0079623386,
0.0411767475,
0.0298775211,
-0.0101806773,
-0.0434791967,
-0.0356120206,
0.0033380811,
-0.019547604,
0.0427658558,
-0.0681826845,
-0.0399441086,
-0.0403063335,
-0.0071703722,
-0.004242349,
0.0316663422,
0.0139624579,
-0.0368901677,
-0.0061131828,
0.0070826435,
-0.0275013708,
-0.0123891551,
-0.0884325728,
0.0120097166,
-0.0311430767,
-0.0193025414,
0.0017055299,
0.0238413662,
0.001118489,
0.0545122847,
-0.0102248546,
0.0234321933,
2.011588815e-34,
0.0316849686,
0.0074659497,
-0.0038427531,
-0.0300544612,
0.0419731028,
0.0092816092,
-0.0252093282,
-0.0185847208,
0.0173540283,
-0.0376599617,
0.0199955963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09105v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09105v2 | MAVEN-Arg: Completing the Puzzle of All-in-One Event Understanding Dataset with Event Argument Annotation | 2023-11-15T16:52:14 | 2024-06-18T22:15:39 | Xiaozhi Wang, Hao Peng, Yong Guan, Kaisheng Zeng, Jianhui Chen, Lei Hou, Xu Han, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Ruobing Xie, Jie Zhou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding events in texts is a core objective of natural language
understanding, which requires detecting event occurrences, extracting event
arguments, and analyzing inter-event relationships. However, due to the
annotation challenges brought by task complexity, a large-scale dataset
covering the full process of event understanding has long been absent. In this
paper, we introduce MAVEN-Arg, which augments MAVEN datasets with event
argument annotations, making the first all-in-one dataset supporting event
detection, event argument extraction (EAE), and event relation extraction. As
an EAE benchmark, MAVEN-Arg offers three main advantages: (1) a comprehensive
schema covering 162 event types and 612 argument roles, all with expert-written
definitions and examples; (2) a large data scale, containing 98,591 events and
290,613 arguments obtained with laborious human annotation; (3) the exhaustive
annotation supporting all task variants of EAE, which annotates both entity and
non-entity event arguments in document level. Experiments indicate that
MAVEN-Arg is quite challenging for both fine-tuned EAE models and proprietary
large language models (LLMs). Furthermore, to demonstrate the benefits of an
all-in-one dataset, we preliminarily explore a potential application, future
event prediction, with LLMs. MAVEN-Arg and codes can be obtained from
https://github.com/THU-KEG/MAVEN-Argument. | [
0.0239535626,
0.0148912594,
0.0116181178,
0.0816151202,
-0.0086295893,
0.0250659715,
-0.0230760388,
-0.0049123252,
0.0299781486,
-0.0658505186,
0.0055347793,
0.0416510478,
-0.0400672555,
0.0385455973,
-0.0032674985,
-0.0385561474,
0.0537698418,
0.0076748114,
0.013233698,
0.0468832701,
0.0274843406,
0.0535655208,
-0.0350130685,
0.0512308516,
0.0013767212,
-0.0351880826,
-0.0542499423,
-0.0026651574,
0.0451720133,
-0.039837949,
-0.0088651692,
0.0087840036,
0.0394378975,
0.0217605457,
0.0000019514,
-0.0668165684,
-0.022377355,
-0.0078455973,
-0.0491438843,
0.0246561747,
-0.0347978547,
-0.0085023604,
0.0028447257,
-0.0154910358,
-0.0331742354,
-0.0405159406,
0.0141701028,
0.0501731746,
0.0304397587,
0.096573852,
-0.0223480631,
-0.0192965679,
-0.0033420369,
-0.0175337009,
-0.0254608188,
-0.0367393605,
0.0323123671,
0.0124411592,
0.0097751683,
0.0072069252,
0.0237666629,
-0.010955031,
0.0094166091,
0.0053323517,
-0.0241163392,
0.0402902626,
-0.052956026,
-0.0014562927,
-0.0051138382,
0.0387257934,
0.0242020339,
-0.0399120636,
0.0435234159,
-0.006121214,
-0.0022531492,
0.0313128158,
-0.028530065,
0.0233140681,
-0.0264559854,
0.043702554,
0.0842741653,
-0.0042717499,
0.0256327987,
0.0156884193,
-0.0001540202,
0.0644785762,
-0.0005159041,
0.020457685,
-0.0303316358,
-0.0114869131,
-0.0730342939,
-0.0454340726,
0.0271454137,
0.0298695415,
-0.0359305069,
0.0286114067,
-0.0459183827,
0.0299608298,
0.0215264503,
-0.0763145536,
-0.0087054148,
0.0357911773,
0.0037854214,
0.0655658618,
0.0280716214,
-0.004276386,
0.0218828171,
-0.0089699226,
-0.0163084939,
-0.0049381098,
-0.0401128531,
0.0360610262,
-0.0493305661,
0.0041597974,
-0.0559687242,
-0.0159325842,
0.0169634689,
0.0131981969,
0.0356714875,
0.0212645605,
0.0186987147,
-0.034164086,
-0.0739158019,
-0.0227809194,
-0.0070557143,
-0.0166357812,
-0.047353819,
0.0211193748,
-0.0035056113,
-0.0848486796,
-0.0261564795,
0.0010098469,
0.0149332415,
-0.0456992909,
-0.0256934538,
0.0327558406,
0.0181777086,
-0.0231193863,
-0.0690919608,
-0.0439473689,
0.0283204243,
-0.0165795479,
-0.0438914709,
-0.0621139146,
0.0206312109,
-0.0007166755,
-0.009680436,
-0.0088152485,
0.029901227,
-0.0180198662,
-0.0096747084,
0.0350912735,
-0.0252514724,
0.0002296356,
0.0227290485,
-0.0108552761,
-0.0280372221,
0.0588154458,
0.0604896992,
0.0264571253,
0.0683076903,
0.0090337107,
-0.0343776233,
0.0410787202,
-0.0179697052,
-0.0211513173,
0.0662470609,
-0.0009783661,
-0.0245541111,
-0.0099945012,
0.0313582458,
-0.0211478975,
-0.0072796596,
-0.0436529182,
0.0172757246,
-0.0008222551,
-0.0575010888,
-0.0142888343,
0.034646593,
0.03757561,
0.0116630672,
0.0062863929,
-0.0179745108,
-0.0210805833,
0.0007981563,
-0.0166431051,
-0.0176516958,
-0.0319223143,
-0.009273937,
-0.0157027598,
-0.0093297092,
-0.0023416183,
-0.0280246623,
0.0136401886,
0.057158377,
0.0181024075,
-0.0405103229,
0.0474598855,
0.0454256274,
-0.0404840037,
0.0010841225,
0.0098495949,
0.0300553013,
0.0042715617,
0.0510198437,
-0.0670544878,
-0.0569785647,
-0.0025740492,
0.0341540202,
0.0105648972,
0.0651973188,
-0.0364297256,
0.0573804751,
-0.0357394479,
0.0077398987,
-0.0108790519,
0.0203300063,
-0.004788877,
0.0222662967,
-0.023162134,
-0.0232890006,
0.0051370403,
-0.0498564169,
0.0523511991,
-0.0413247459,
-0.0535467155,
-0.0337740481,
-0.0202851389,
0.037142992,
0.0018436802,
-0.0019651863,
-0.0066221212,
0.0514597446,
-0.0388394259,
0.0080882739,
0.0622902438,
0.0201704483,
-0.0536199883,
0.0325814635,
-0.0128838336,
-0.0432975702,
0.0016989267,
-0.0541690774,
-0.0437800847,
-0.0342217237,
0.0148622775,
0.010775825,
-0.0096505303,
0.0029016116,
0.0077218167,
-0.0222183466,
-0.0153856399,
0.0414585136,
0.0330094062,
-0.0152075561,
-0.0424683653,
0.0120641505,
0.025175143,
-0.0265021157,
-0.0555339418,
0.0254193414,
-0.0012187042,
-0.0502452068,
0.0258538555,
-0.0346410275,
-0.0820470825,
0.0149183571,
-0.08478982,
0.07311178,
-0.0247099642,
0.0732185021,
0.050955236,
0.0115566738,
-0.0240361057,
0.0162261426,
0.0045031565,
-0.0776449665,
-0.0331671573,
-0.0166962352,
0.0547109433,
0.0211403873,
0.0008509815,
-0.0523447432,
0.0164818559,
-0.0675942823,
0.0528553501,
0.0058356132,
-0.0479497388,
-0.0441989042,
0.057931941,
0.0262991469,
0.0499702878,
-0.0230137911,
-0.0259214155,
0.0044728471,
-0.023862917,
0.0072699888,
0.0560605787,
-0.0266215224,
0.0547155887,
-0.0065380642,
-0.0447126403,
-0.0556406975,
0.0265637469,
-0.0228437558,
0.0276965518,
-0.0245213285,
0.0046404107,
0.0005480458,
0.0786331221,
-0.0149713224,
0.0065686754,
-0.0484414548,
-0.0218425095,
-0.0192470886,
0.007914613,
0.0325053707,
-0.0229156204,
-0.0152776446,
0.0221216567,
-0.0567402132,
-0.011151392,
0.0766429752,
-0.0130457357,
-0.027410537,
-0.0519262105,
0.0160988551,
-0.0603249632,
0.0735223666,
-0.0160096996,
-0.008244534,
0.0043104226,
-0.0515201576,
-0.0108758174,
0.0173637979,
0.0202693734,
-0.0086953538,
0.0260550305,
-0.0432064608,
0.015034603,
-0.010559706,
-0.0016435313,
-0.0326873139,
-0.014921899,
-0.0338595435,
0.000553666,
-0.0014094776,
0.0194593742,
-0.0414248109,
-0.0068794121,
-0.0372823365,
0.019876875,
-0.0117781945,
0.0005801829,
-0.0241412297,
0.0296227206,
0.0367378257,
0.0005468802,
-0.0003886162,
0.0229010638,
0.0365196653,
0.0619614199,
0.0172691997,
-0.0289070196,
-0.0460298136,
-0.0001427845,
-0.0023933675,
-0.0729063302,
-0.0223205406,
-0.0241032802,
0.0637764335,
-0.0938762054,
0.0241034683,
0.0985110477,
0.0258101411,
-0.0029284051,
0.013017159,
-0.0041597961,
0.0403595343,
0.028711427,
0.0084594907,
-0.0824732855,
-0.0583243221,
-0.0022720094,
-0.0149493655,
-0.0040421109,
-0.0502945185,
-0.0024022772,
-0.0674842,
0.0089942226,
0.0004809518,
-0.004211389,
-0.0073423306,
-0.0424633063,
0.0076800524,
-0.0470141992,
-0.039202325,
0.0163250621,
0.0075121634,
0.0118339434,
0.0231817607,
-0.0556827001,
-0.0446842983,
0.0532190427,
-0.0347781405,
0.0321413316,
0.0087742237,
0.0488468297,
0.0130273728,
0.0357093513,
0.0035504096,
-0.0092381751,
-0.0016276347,
-0.0233835131,
0.0439768061,
-0.0179034304,
-0.0147214727,
0.0099074617,
0.0776574835,
-0.0396837294,
-0.0436619706,
0.0275592078,
0.1017601267,
-0.0296977814,
0.0027060653,
0.0111627402,
-0.0208092332,
0.0097331284,
0.0680630952,
0.0061363438,
0.0252293628,
-0.048276443,
-0.002411688,
0.0091363536,
-0.0565678515,
0.0138498135,
0.0083735893,
-0.0252679568,
-0.0292350911,
-0.0595773235,
-0.0733017549,
0.0535212867,
0.0277632494,
0.0077840337,
0.0190841276,
0.0225874279,
0.0080345618,
-0.0295007434,
0.0698012635,
-0.0325405039,
0.011670338,
0.016649235,
0.0019213324,
0.0194588415,
0.0316290818,
-0.0236640517,
0.0797040388,
-0.0590163469,
-0.0579851903,
-0.0182171445,
-0.0340838134,
0.0199875794,
0.0699017346,
-0.0245862473,
-0.0264468528,
-0.04947,
-0.0244586505,
-0.0239901748,
-0.0307089593,
0.0456037,
0.0228808466,
0.0004807231,
0.0510056205,
-0.0188761018,
0.0143022733,
-0.0666093528,
0.05242268,
-0.0612427779,
-0.0250044651,
0.0152198179,
0.0171129722,
0.0615064874,
-0.0009524251,
-0.0123665724,
-0.0506172329,
0.0027895202,
-0.0386037417,
-0.003773459,
-0.0400066748,
0.0496311672,
-0.0242073424,
-0.0350169055,
-0.0310443621,
0.012886079,
-0.0226006228,
0.0196711291,
-0.0112745222,
0.0472895689,
0.0782766491,
0.0229876824,
0.0111474358,
-0.0116590979,
-0.0249515027,
-0.0089261057,
0.0098177949,
0.028917836,
-0.0371853374,
0.0359727517,
0.0313609801,
-0.0010157306,
0.0001376605,
-0.0345580317,
-0.0293938834,
0.0001627101,
0.0175915118,
0.0040087323,
0.0792436898,
-0.0481204018,
0.1015458629,
-0.0054360656,
0.0052188523,
-0.0062231426,
0.0680908412,
0.0016963981,
0.0060828486,
0.0396250822,
0.0283585321,
-0.0462042913,
0.0255530365,
0.0666929111,
-0.0246278401,
0.0810228139,
0.0217658002,
-0.0088438094,
-0.0208022706,
-0.0257587917,
0.0256240834,
0.033432845,
-0.0080139786,
-0.0220927224,
-0.0579030253,
0.0024591717,
-0.0105594127,
0.0096450113,
-0.0194246396,
-0.0219310094,
0.0141758109,
0.0296720061,
0.0070687057,
-0.0301295891,
-0.0396480672,
0.010572548,
-0.0340297036,
-0.0293918941,
-0.0442681648,
-5.633318271e-33,
-0.0248295497,
0.0037786278,
0.0096473815,
0.0812243149,
0.0044664764,
0.0189437941,
-0.0509994105,
-0.0240986347,
-0.0109600853,
0.0362708755,
0.0070131542,
-0.0017326544,
0.0233924575,
-0.0354591608,
0.0263925716,
-0.0353744626,
0.0362891555,
0.005515994,
0.0039025315,
0.0385084599,
0.0646875724,
0.0216285065,
0.0760042444,
-0.0783109143,
0.0445002876,
-0.001249721,
-0.0106749441,
0.0071771732,
0.0266991369,
0.0532062948,
0.0014684058,
0.0149323894,
0.0227618609,
-0.0368964262,
-0.0045855776,
-0.0087400712,
-0.0887574255,
-0.0214976277,
0.0409624502,
0.0101671955,
-0.0236894581,
-0.0442485586,
0.004632757,
0.0143953217,
0.0352473706,
-0.0134067861,
0.0327853374,
-0.0122370226,
-0.0194402114,
-0.0347461142,
-0.0457543209,
0.0789640695,
-0.0384574011,
-0.0021396636,
0.0211179964,
0.0275938269,
0.0387707204,
0.0369222648,
-0.0492737778,
-0.013092272,
-0.0532460511,
0.0049194782,
0.0162264947,
-0.0265820287,
-0.0184166338,
0.0664250404,
-0.0132471183,
-0.003792685,
0.003082254,
0.0870161057,
0.0000942102,
0.0962168053,
-0.0114734378,
0.0195984282,
0.0255441908,
0.0190365203,
-0.0818902329,
0.0607682504,
0.0583385676,
0.0412043631,
-0.010802024,
0.0063427323,
-0.0574904755,
0.0033706836,
-0.0284532253,
-0.0118562449,
-0.0038025512,
0.0019861169,
0.013825858,
-0.0353816971,
0.0199105144,
0.0918459222,
0.0240042917,
-0.0339579359,
-0.0224679373,
0.0337208845,
-0.0480794869,
-0.0085546877,
-0.0108421324,
0.0343213007,
-0.0534384288,
-0.0342413224,
0.0208041463,
-0.0269553009,
0.0460044667,
0.0006062511,
0.0325036012,
-0.0164649729,
-0.0117056984,
-0.0102982782,
-0.0321235321,
-0.0061565628,
-0.051459603,
0.0023243858,
0.0197809823,
0.0148096504,
0.0108777015,
0.0467718206,
0.0305917319,
0.0130013218,
-0.0120505178,
-0.0150034297,
-0.0070351996,
0.0014360867,
0.0014912197,
-0.0210327674,
-0.0125470655,
-0.0071262605,
0.0126671568,
-0.0163772535,
-0.0034533816,
0.023037618,
2.424e-7,
0.07058575,
0.0509712957,
0.0580209047,
0.0215808265,
-0.0100197168,
0.0354161374,
-0.0162600558,
0.0400506258,
0.0132994093,
-0.0065515647,
-0.0086939,
0.0124220354,
0.0398716368,
0.0481085889,
-0.0725659057,
-0.0873758942,
-0.0580458678,
-0.0087531041,
-0.0945785195,
0.0011897787,
0.098794207,
0.0796829015,
0.0491562411,
0.0159712378,
-0.0168504752,
-0.0223405082,
0.0304590128,
-0.0258350316,
-0.0329167731,
0.0703604147,
0.008947474,
0.0191430412,
-0.0176413842,
0.0313790031,
-0.0284625087,
0.0171153229,
-0.0265833456,
0.0712043941,
-0.0067528263,
0.026878994,
0.0164754651,
-0.0482802689,
-0.0068849446,
-0.0339491591,
0.0856296569,
-0.0317101777,
-0.0512988158,
-0.013265729,
-0.0365046076,
0.031997662,
-0.0757498369,
0.0278908722,
0.0050883656,
0.0298160873,
-0.0015993759,
-0.037745405,
-0.0394426845,
-0.0603008345,
-0.0449171066,
0.0258563831,
-0.0348107405,
-0.0073000705,
0.0044993106,
-0.0415443107,
-0.0168315005,
-0.0593540594,
-0.0128358565,
2.265907477e-34,
-0.0041645761,
0.0119135361,
-0.0187032539,
0.0616334714,
0.0668333098,
-0.0322151929,
-0.0310330074,
0.0200173128,
0.0080977818,
-0.0253934599,
0.0018085242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09101v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09101v2 | Towards A Unified View of Answer Calibration for Multi-Step Reasoning | 2023-11-15T16:47:57 | 2024-02-25T15:53:37 | Shumin Deng, Ningyu Zhang, Nay Oo, Bryan Hooi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) employing Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting have
broadened the scope for improving multi-step reasoning capabilities. We
generally divide multi-step reasoning into two phases: path generation to
generate the reasoning path(s); and answer calibration post-processing the
reasoning path(s) to obtain a final answer. However, the existing literature
lacks systematic analysis on different answer calibration approaches. In this
paper, we summarize the taxonomy of recent answer calibration techniques and
break them down into step-level and path-level strategies. We then conduct a
thorough evaluation on these strategies from a unified view, systematically
scrutinizing step-level and path-level answer calibration across multiple
paths. Experimental results reveal that integrating the dominance of both
strategies tends to derive optimal outcomes. Our study holds the potential to
illuminate key insights for optimizing multi-step reasoning with answer
calibration. | [
0.0411910936,
0.0101555251,
-0.0297216568,
0.0292948745,
-0.056449797,
-0.003972257,
0.0007284207,
-0.0241771452,
-0.0115434909,
-0.0337068476,
0.0067399703,
-0.0179986432,
0.0157249793,
-0.0022217773,
-0.014887169,
-0.033071775,
0.0271238815,
-0.0581221953,
0.0154799316,
-0.0268561132,
-0.016488852,
0.0142779881,
-0.0256658383,
0.0171992909,
-0.0024917563,
-0.0556097142,
-0.0350341015,
-0.0062818388,
0.0174105242,
-0.0439196341,
-0.0018064273,
0.0550074764,
-0.0067120311,
0.039753031,
0.0000021823,
-0.067883648,
-0.0030271048,
-0.0076809423,
-0.0535315089,
-0.018120192,
-0.0479156412,
0.0357706919,
0.0342349559,
0.0502333269,
-0.04162338,
0.0416534878,
0.025320366,
0.0073471614,
0.0588235408,
0.0193772689,
0.028876463,
-0.0433125086,
0.0068354667,
0.0318706147,
0.0042544184,
-0.050647229,
-0.0018157847,
0.050931111,
0.0323978215,
0.0046926355,
-0.0093466267,
0.0027222522,
0.0373632424,
-0.0142395832,
-0.0136346389,
0.0241366196,
0.0039496799,
-0.0225492716,
-0.0340129696,
0.0544752069,
0.0336965658,
-0.0119690681,
-0.0422805548,
-0.0351289064,
0.0093130311,
0.0010732452,
-0.0247917119,
0.0227990951,
-0.0151711935,
-0.0096365046,
-0.0105308769,
-0.0013199928,
0.024804607,
0.0121602174,
-0.0080267387,
0.1311464161,
-0.0110903485,
-0.0426271074,
-0.0043039201,
0.0240532514,
0.0146004306,
-0.0978481919,
0.0240564216,
0.1044682339,
-0.0455558635,
0.0282987729,
0.0127979591,
0.0058170734,
0.0336423218,
-0.0226033833,
0.0381506942,
0.050661277,
-0.01992728,
0.0430736057,
-0.0146876173,
0.0239790734,
-0.0359801725,
-0.020936925,
-0.0730623603,
-0.0067418837,
-0.0481679402,
-0.0288697537,
-0.0180096161,
0.0456185713,
-0.0295451432,
-0.0074931849,
-0.015015766,
0.0106343888,
-0.0001158944,
-0.0008661372,
0.0114119546,
0.0065596453,
0.0287782308,
-0.0230740067,
-0.0599768907,
0.0603885762,
-0.0945297256,
0.0651641116,
0.0299923141,
-0.0339259058,
-0.0015213911,
0.0078173364,
-0.0064642066,
-0.0027555481,
0.0407299288,
0.0327105857,
0.0040480089,
0.0105031375,
-0.0360571146,
-0.0856829882,
-0.0439340509,
-0.096047394,
-0.0011279959,
-0.084088333,
0.0215305761,
0.0498226061,
-0.0247986782,
0.0281131733,
0.0052800654,
0.0423522145,
-0.0388457365,
0.0428963192,
-0.0028339643,
0.0278301965,
0.020583801,
0.0021541344,
-0.0091580553,
0.0750602186,
0.0499367267,
0.0052488516,
0.0248028859,
0.0079963161,
0.0223764684,
0.0076085771,
0.00358556,
-0.0176096521,
0.05043073,
0.0575684644,
-0.0138571505,
0.0354605801,
0.0083121154,
0.0352681838,
-0.0235474408,
0.0390241109,
0.0291724652,
0.0461066328,
0.0142913209,
-0.0186452921,
0.0503670983,
-0.0482963361,
0.0264441073,
0.0261087995,
-0.0385973305,
0.0439714305,
-0.0614301562,
0.0188327394,
0.0231006294,
0.036097616,
-0.018991949,
-0.0550246872,
-0.0140438993,
0.0404216461,
0.0219887625,
0.0511840619,
0.0114132492,
-0.0103341369,
-0.0135313198,
0.0410148725,
-0.0119408164,
-0.0154042272,
0.0211669076,
-0.0469481908,
0.0334852673,
0.0594715588,
0.0352710448,
0.0187943168,
-0.0157801472,
0.0088897618,
0.0387279987,
-0.0037799461,
0.0330763683,
-0.022023052,
-0.0298908055,
-0.0236416981,
-0.035486903,
-0.0366097502,
-0.0020301687,
-0.0058455714,
0.0142309936,
-0.0111046992,
-0.0188678652,
-0.0284922849,
0.0435333475,
0.0159917679,
0.0178608224,
0.006099313,
-0.0259178728,
0.0066364086,
0.0109167919,
0.0507106632,
0.0144819738,
0.0366063192,
-0.007846334,
0.0142058991,
-0.0389693081,
-0.0012989697,
-0.0448341928,
-0.017815033,
0.0504920483,
0.00801857,
-0.0419763066,
-0.0309142638,
-0.0201638229,
-0.0402533226,
-0.017364772,
-0.0094497465,
-0.0098178871,
-0.0242011528,
0.0294725504,
-0.0115660969,
-0.0310256891,
-0.0547916181,
0.0652644038,
-0.0133260796,
0.0290371776,
0.0134833828,
0.0039452757,
0.0359078236,
-0.0167783499,
-0.0127175106,
0.0070821797,
0.0007760642,
0.004705125,
0.0208002701,
0.0162889212,
-0.075652495,
-0.0075282576,
-0.0733791366,
-0.0148839056,
-0.0222444404,
0.0325176306,
-0.0016884252,
0.0177835915,
0.004446459,
-0.005616873,
-0.0790700316,
0.0183249842,
0.014884687,
0.0383646637,
0.0193218999,
-0.0071894256,
-0.0203588586,
-0.0047327359,
0.0133015234,
-0.0458527133,
0.027408177,
0.0092692384,
0.0007580905,
-0.0793712363,
-0.0114529021,
-0.0552318357,
0.0030055295,
0.0226120688,
0.003644503,
0.053754244,
0.0249055456,
0.0181315988,
0.0530758947,
0.0041675079,
-0.0574091673,
0.0534525551,
0.0015095307,
-0.0461942032,
0.0325105824,
-0.0121328505,
-0.0282513909,
-0.0164540019,
-0.036714077,
-0.0280291922,
0.0584474243,
0.0232295021,
-0.0049417638,
-0.0514963008,
0.0115144309,
-0.020501757,
-0.0268239249,
-0.0411499366,
-0.0421180539,
-0.021151796,
0.0789024755,
0.0179727953,
-0.0197551847,
0.1026164219,
-0.0630586967,
0.0140476795,
-0.0472940765,
0.0341269895,
-0.0450979099,
0.0528437681,
-0.032314308,
0.0253358856,
-0.0082753934,
0.0081075877,
-0.0652881041,
-0.0370837189,
0.0578436889,
-0.0588587075,
0.0413716249,
-0.0617646798,
-0.007214244,
-0.0135590658,
-0.0391617008,
-0.0329962149,
-0.0002805462,
-0.0581596121,
0.0105908113,
-0.0236500911,
0.0030200717,
0.0241742283,
-0.012718888,
0.0424381346,
0.0065865763,
-0.0040254397,
-0.0174334235,
-0.016250724,
0.032533858,
0.0709592402,
0.0338149257,
0.0803188682,
0.0010871664,
0.0307112541,
0.0657624081,
0.0491578467,
0.0340654999,
0.0081615616,
0.0169792958,
0.0346312113,
-0.0296694413,
-0.00848231,
0.0603794865,
0.0675464049,
-0.0415432118,
-0.0139756063,
0.0859096348,
0.0544804409,
-0.0111345192,
0.0077539599,
-0.0672816113,
-0.0148320915,
0.0117521798,
0.0305271763,
-0.0993421003,
-0.0212715231,
0.0151978992,
-0.003889139,
-0.0238520131,
-0.02639753,
-0.0061142365,
-0.1092057005,
0.0078052073,
-0.0167552698,
0.0141492169,
-0.0261259452,
-0.02530545,
0.0152489794,
0.0634785295,
0.0203256123,
0.0563077889,
0.0193198789,
0.0102692209,
0.0264382474,
-0.0232818965,
0.0280741006,
0.0696826875,
-0.0292920135,
0.0321248136,
0.0527726598,
-0.0186884105,
0.0299728699,
-0.0260511413,
0.0315057747,
-0.0521438159,
-0.003898751,
-0.0044289227,
-0.0218931604,
0.0293634664,
0.0401732102,
-0.0207286179,
0.0182687454,
-0.0246704202,
-0.0361783952,
0.0400361121,
0.0908826366,
-0.0244846828,
0.0000655212,
-0.046023123,
0.0402567387,
-0.0115382578,
0.0622359216,
0.0144017935,
-0.0467122607,
-0.0344781727,
-0.0102370316,
-0.0352346785,
-0.0108521963,
-0.0198905542,
0.0327526592,
0.0172506422,
0.0758241341,
-0.0313587114,
-0.049900908,
0.0390598029,
0.0337449946,
-0.014027942,
0.018044278,
-0.0124716042,
0.0177998487,
0.0175154023,
-0.0006478487,
-0.0438280329,
0.065020442,
0.0026425659,
0.032760188,
-0.0337850153,
-0.0367762186,
-0.0056341505,
0.0200208798,
-0.0678850934,
-0.0362861753,
-0.03507597,
0.0143357236,
0.0311762765,
0.0166064799,
-0.0182734299,
-0.0058045844,
0.0177701302,
-0.0395868458,
0.0112154409,
-0.007401336,
0.0087743271,
0.0533507317,
-0.0105252704,
0.0210681297,
-0.0374615677,
-0.0270293206,
0.0256971419,
0.1004482806,
-0.0177176073,
-0.072517693,
0.0432494804,
0.0037280044,
0.0208285227,
-0.0002795681,
0.0014017973,
0.0201959703,
0.0464437678,
-0.0353970863,
-0.0588381886,
0.0068538203,
-0.0320113152,
0.0054709408,
-0.0496349297,
0.010839426,
-0.0446984656,
-0.0074672205,
0.0117957573,
-0.0133635299,
-0.0131524587,
0.047633715,
0.018137414,
0.0323372073,
-0.0432715677,
-0.0349718854,
-0.0273346286,
0.0097286785,
0.0560905151,
0.023180956,
0.1151474714,
0.0199696384,
-0.0176885519,
-0.053253714,
-0.0041940776,
-0.0717419386,
-0.0453919508,
-0.0073052021,
0.026996132,
0.0366708115,
0.0201533101,
0.0107096443,
0.0024982623,
-0.0114213452,
0.0105492556,
-0.0001040597,
0.0358957313,
-0.0400810391,
0.0419435576,
0.0208156947,
-0.0031256122,
-0.0188834462,
0.0324582942,
-0.0336860046,
0.033544872,
-0.0306132361,
-0.0234033018,
0.0056583616,
-0.0422509164,
-0.1014815792,
0.0179916378,
-0.0223398637,
-0.0165258665,
-0.1030499265,
-0.064820528,
-0.0411461927,
0.0395397656,
0.0145429894,
-0.0167205594,
0.0259388424,
0.0764520913,
0.0200719386,
-0.0837049708,
-0.0217312053,
0.0172748603,
-0.0371000282,
0.0015727975,
-0.067203261,
-6.318545887e-33,
-0.0048056296,
-0.0409118459,
0.0771847144,
0.0234276801,
-0.0182190482,
-0.0030727799,
-0.0211813916,
0.029248368,
-0.0460383557,
0.000625221,
-0.0301377792,
-0.0129720336,
0.0087744771,
-0.0081940647,
0.0190631896,
-0.0466351546,
-0.00006799,
0.0052617122,
-0.0803510323,
-0.0298601314,
0.0387062952,
-0.0545235984,
0.0075263134,
-0.0253395382,
0.0347843394,
-0.0064429063,
-0.0170965716,
0.0392577536,
-0.0530790016,
0.0469315685,
0.0264635906,
0.0377597511,
0.0258333534,
-0.0284985732,
0.0211841967,
0.0439847261,
-0.0592394844,
-0.0331367068,
0.067436792,
0.0065868157,
-0.057792522,
-0.015876295,
-0.0004988377,
0.0157031752,
-0.0234225653,
-0.0114460709,
-0.0032255759,
-0.0333377719,
0.0244556461,
-0.0281909443,
-0.0491402224,
-0.0169570558,
-0.0090593547,
-0.0363859721,
-0.0167840775,
0.0667369142,
0.0023028995,
-0.0217555482,
-0.0449116975,
0.0233735722,
0.0303723812,
-0.0098801805,
0.0895672813,
0.0174983107,
-0.0088216942,
0.0313809365,
-0.0058394535,
-0.0099135656,
-0.0461187698,
-0.0018796823,
-0.0266893096,
0.0011383371,
0.0783733875,
0.0183720198,
-0.0101654753,
0.0451097451,
-0.0664518327,
0.0133405207,
0.031059118,
0.0442995764,
0.0323764086,
-0.0124144917,
-0.0253546964,
-0.0236606374,
-0.0824465156,
0.005591996,
-0.0471580103,
-0.0299748871,
0.0268956237,
0.0007579644,
-0.018272534,
-0.0275441427,
0.0413630567,
-0.0278338082,
-0.0247734208,
0.0322599672,
0.0064194174,
0.0349133462,
0.0032104291,
0.0503011271,
-0.0283217765,
0.0142580941,
-0.0034186631,
-0.0079553621,
0.0132884495,
0.0099498462,
0.0036103306,
-0.025212571,
-0.0210200269,
0.0050756233,
-0.0537541062,
0.0049893125,
-0.0209797081,
-0.0287016891,
0.0559348613,
0.0099499961,
-0.0121436417,
0.0043605287,
0.0100225452,
0.0129308626,
-0.0367475264,
0.0192685407,
-0.0128243174,
0.0112961642,
-0.0170055851,
0.0290964954,
-0.0224147923,
-0.0152013069,
-0.0078997733,
-0.0407673344,
-0.0184658002,
0.0546597578,
2.737e-7,
0.0453393199,
0.0122547857,
-0.0028225777,
0.0414652824,
0.0109115383,
0.0248150919,
-0.012088431,
-0.0179495513,
0.0783386901,
-0.0660116598,
-0.0333168991,
0.0130614974,
0.0184620693,
0.0488954894,
-0.0313304961,
-0.0365594104,
-0.0317578614,
0.0254592933,
-0.0145813748,
0.0133142816,
0.0447983481,
0.0238124542,
-0.0100144036,
-0.0037803466,
-0.0364903323,
-0.0114457095,
0.0438410975,
0.0012861195,
0.0148168448,
0.0398474,
0.0226448458,
-0.0424755104,
0.0527018309,
0.0574509203,
0.0140842982,
0.0265117865,
-0.022102559,
0.0345534086,
0.0061827656,
-0.0415714309,
-0.0674511492,
-0.0539557301,
0.0334216133,
-0.0856627002,
0.0771457851,
-0.0400347635,
-0.0089444797,
-0.0616812147,
-0.0099265017,
-0.027658537,
0.0272657555,
0.0318000615,
-0.011757954,
0.0091519644,
0.0152044939,
0.0306140482,
0.009381867,
-0.0589125194,
-0.0512567461,
0.0452818051,
0.001686,
-0.062869668,
0.0016238876,
-0.0221348312,
0.0367377773,
-0.0831725001,
-0.0015645419,
2.405472865e-34,
0.0070674489,
-0.0456834473,
0.0519642197,
0.0150185321,
0.0388319865,
0.0079781786,
-0.0284561981,
-0.0048069977,
0.0375663266,
-0.1064990237,
-0.0235867985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09096v2 | Defending Large Language Models Against Jailbreaking Attacks Through Goal Prioritization | 2023-11-15T16:42:29 | 2024-06-12T08:28:15 | Zhexin Zhang, Junxiao Yang, Pei Ke, Fei Mi, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While significant attention has been dedicated to exploiting weaknesses in
LLMs through jailbreaking attacks, there remains a paucity of effort in
defending against these attacks. We point out a pivotal factor contributing to
the success of jailbreaks: the intrinsic conflict between the goals of being
helpful and ensuring safety. Accordingly, we propose to integrate goal
prioritization at both training and inference stages to counteract.
Implementing goal prioritization during inference substantially diminishes the
Attack Success Rate (ASR) of jailbreaking from 66.4% to 3.6% for ChatGPT. And
integrating goal prioritization into model training reduces the ASR from 71.0%
to 6.6% for Llama2-13B. Remarkably, even in scenarios where no jailbreaking
samples are included during training, our approach slashes the ASR by half.
Additionally, our findings reveal that while stronger LLMs face greater safety
risks, they also possess a greater capacity to be steered towards defending
against such attacks, both because of their stronger ability in instruction
following. Our work thus contributes to the comprehension of jailbreaking
attacks and defenses, and sheds light on the relationship between LLMs'
capability and safety. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/thu-coai/JailbreakDefense_GoalPriority}. | [
0.0228176098,
0.067069307,
-0.0063182199,
0.0568022393,
-0.0222712234,
0.0033780688,
-0.0215040594,
-0.0213171691,
0.0101030553,
-0.0255825054,
-0.0181198698,
-0.0145021919,
-0.0063829338,
-0.0309415665,
0.0572622903,
-0.0018314514,
0.0648399144,
-0.0624670424,
-0.0159912016,
-0.0000522462,
0.0240400936,
-0.0102226082,
0.0179124363,
0.0304565318,
0.0090725468,
-0.0051058908,
-0.0203626659,
0.017286377,
0.029715728,
-0.0486784466,
0.0108431252,
0.0009610691,
-0.0014420612,
0.0395356156,
0.0000021624,
-0.0304710772,
-0.0399642549,
0.0190334506,
-0.0335765332,
0.046519611,
-0.0004460623,
-0.0571051352,
-0.0362927988,
0.0252723321,
-0.0334098004,
0.0461439602,
0.0317566693,
0.0435355343,
0.0565836281,
0.0912787169,
0.0129743665,
0.0007901212,
0.0488818325,
-0.0222997665,
-0.0035635424,
-0.0821347535,
0.0031956153,
-0.0075532966,
-0.0116182156,
0.0203230362,
-0.0076071764,
-0.0059333686,
0.0217255298,
0.0150644323,
-0.0725173056,
0.0071618007,
-0.021255523,
-0.0129649919,
-0.0157786906,
0.0325095765,
-0.0467891991,
-0.0294605792,
0.0125903217,
-0.0001069799,
0.0188306905,
0.0079735527,
-0.0225706082,
0.0439829491,
-0.0096658813,
0.0028466955,
0.0582971573,
-0.0349289775,
0.0707148239,
-0.0135750044,
-0.0111285206,
0.0621157214,
0.0056394092,
-0.0393505469,
0.0057060365,
-0.0333541594,
-0.0233146902,
-0.0593623668,
-0.0366932154,
0.0072796568,
0.0098517789,
0.0247809142,
-0.074900955,
0.0142099541,
0.0325662009,
-0.0730205327,
-0.0067816963,
0.0442786589,
-0.0038169441,
-0.0109086791,
-0.0016964246,
-0.0111317551,
-0.0241304729,
0.0665643737,
0.011691072,
0.0355627947,
-0.0166507643,
-0.004403885,
0.002458764,
0.0354557745,
0.0003608548,
0.0302359592,
-0.0340314694,
0.0200475734,
-0.0192162264,
0.0094280355,
-0.0483065769,
-0.0145259704,
-0.01660222,
0.0183602944,
0.0474565476,
-0.0283932537,
-0.0224168096,
-0.0009144671,
0.0050351839,
-0.0965791494,
-0.0408685803,
0.0010168626,
-0.0855902433,
-0.027309645,
-0.0027067084,
0.129677847,
0.0117271412,
-0.0339296125,
-0.0922750607,
-0.0810039192,
-0.0170528125,
-0.0521462411,
0.021486178,
-0.0742005408,
-0.033425577,
-0.0095935399,
0.0062531913,
-0.0384802334,
0.0175625905,
-0.0139781246,
-0.0354236551,
0.0536940619,
0.0306868181,
-0.0262119826,
-0.0205730926,
0.0673083439,
-0.0081312479,
0.0876736566,
0.0069142436,
0.0376997106,
0.0474138595,
0.008808759,
0.0252967831,
0.0518668853,
-0.0059274007,
0.0398455597,
0.0082853436,
-0.0126813306,
0.0276004728,
-0.0187320169,
0.0086983591,
0.0215150937,
-0.0185902268,
-0.017543979,
0.0840295479,
0.0402289517,
-0.0244834442,
0.0288286619,
-0.0178286061,
-0.0194312558,
0.0107069155,
0.0159043875,
-0.0970313475,
0.0168289859,
-0.0785110742,
0.003640024,
-0.0402849428,
0.0379960723,
0.0059066936,
0.0013702278,
-0.0100693954,
-0.0138708763,
-0.0476180613,
0.0224456824,
-0.0014864585,
0.0115947612,
-0.0003758672,
0.085886471,
0.015890928,
-0.0410561599,
-0.0438818857,
-0.1016445681,
-0.0207207054,
0.0261681136,
0.0302687399,
-0.0118157193,
-0.0329472907,
0.003090573,
-0.0028898586,
0.0141861998,
-0.0080512445,
0.0130725531,
0.0508474633,
-0.0150152268,
-0.0002630637,
-0.0351276509,
0.0357158743,
0.0354797207,
0.0182147846,
-0.0019502204,
-0.0056194742,
-0.0276764687,
-0.0465080254,
0.0392628536,
0.0114984363,
-0.022641968,
-0.0138622411,
0.0103486637,
0.0103696473,
-0.0023503245,
-0.0449756458,
0.0163851082,
0.0634441003,
0.011788371,
0.0359279327,
0.0289050676,
-0.0385494083,
-0.0329464376,
0.0298968814,
-0.0211389083,
-0.0025192345,
0.0591214448,
-0.0488464758,
-0.0148025732,
0.0650482327,
-0.0354978032,
0.0526681505,
0.0121294325,
0.0472092703,
0.0056067421,
0.0123791294,
-0.031305436,
0.0190602113,
-0.0310784318,
-0.027306091,
-0.0095561901,
0.0096456939,
0.0074787973,
-0.0173299126,
-0.0450312048,
0.0331170894,
-0.0264602453,
0.0215081461,
-0.0108971028,
0.043318212,
-0.0128440885,
-0.0240488313,
-0.0348600559,
0.0029568039,
-0.0360729098,
0.0646563694,
0.0299217831,
0.0116881514,
-0.0425829478,
-0.0192478597,
0.0191407744,
-0.0161336772,
-0.0147737656,
0.0104237339,
-0.013441477,
-0.0001242726,
-0.0564832725,
-0.0330354087,
0.0065521402,
-0.0139500247,
0.0230526589,
-0.0564296059,
-0.0444767699,
-0.0191779509,
0.0131847486,
0.0042427769,
0.0317989364,
-0.0396035835,
-0.0421574116,
0.0544439293,
0.0153314825,
-0.0044505349,
0.0664733425,
-0.0208408684,
0.0559789576,
0.0866969153,
0.0015289827,
-0.0507133976,
-0.0161407515,
0.0498294756,
-0.0638437867,
-0.0493843444,
-0.0534770489,
0.0211873185,
0.0758507699,
0.0083122607,
-0.0095126266,
-0.0116166258,
-0.0108949766,
0.0019412086,
-0.0282143783,
0.0244640578,
-0.0067378646,
-0.0611649267,
0.0061416216,
-0.0089089191,
-0.0764832571,
0.0748843774,
-0.0435713977,
0.0169882625,
-0.0314641222,
-0.0386222862,
-0.0235265847,
0.0405177996,
-0.0249659698,
0.013071592,
0.0551984124,
-0.0312555172,
-0.028172832,
-0.026182374,
0.0292713121,
0.0091306129,
0.0671952367,
-0.0680117384,
-0.0068648933,
-0.0254378673,
-0.0381275676,
-0.0327540375,
-0.0466982163,
-0.0213196632,
-0.0273282938,
0.0093777804,
-0.0396659672,
0.0120654693,
-0.0594594479,
0.0235965904,
-0.0169602968,
-0.029292712,
-0.0126651628,
-0.0235163122,
0.0110024996,
0.0175029058,
-0.0635206625,
0.0252749082,
-0.0357468612,
0.0393989868,
0.0907096639,
0.0598852597,
0.0026624827,
-0.0199452043,
0.0046947198,
0.0396757051,
-0.0052779461,
-0.0279833749,
0.0407337509,
0.0754057169,
-0.0266809035,
-0.031781327,
0.0503863841,
0.0230431762,
0.0211559441,
0.043742191,
-0.0141596785,
0.0797000676,
0.023538623,
0.0362320729,
-0.0752140582,
-0.0392989293,
0.0427070372,
0.0812132508,
-0.0206396095,
-0.000439154,
-0.035865318,
-0.0728982985,
0.0097041233,
0.032504987,
-0.0226373971,
0.0180687532,
-0.039738372,
-0.034701284,
0.003852423,
0.0401402861,
-0.0014644173,
-0.0216169376,
-0.0060390281,
0.0319343805,
-0.0500922278,
-0.0209945738,
0.0198491067,
-0.0348956436,
0.070015505,
0.080030784,
-0.0193471164,
-0.0305408854,
0.0278465599,
0.0649740398,
0.023171965,
-0.0040841559,
0.005142027,
-0.0075593693,
-0.0003568862,
0.0037375304,
0.0326444171,
0.0412654541,
0.0212597437,
-0.033310838,
0.053693641,
0.033240173,
-0.0264671687,
-0.0156118143,
-0.020048108,
-0.0074928487,
0.0033496702,
0.0370630734,
0.0401562564,
0.0046705902,
-0.0458159111,
-0.0896332413,
-0.0533255227,
-0.0551991649,
-0.0280056745,
0.0253233258,
0.0144104538,
-0.0284397155,
-0.0255373232,
-0.0101804314,
-0.0191707034,
0.0327265412,
0.0254506245,
-0.0147849582,
-0.0363517813,
0.0148615623,
-0.033193741,
0.0065174531,
-0.0272992458,
0.0352536216,
-0.0547878258,
0.0364639647,
-0.0040978566,
0.0024199586,
-0.0044751512,
0.0152932359,
-0.0752581805,
-0.1147036478,
0.009804463,
0.0838056877,
0.0285792518,
0.0179671776,
-0.0185798369,
-0.075688608,
0.0350767337,
0.0764404982,
-0.0456835479,
0.0351398475,
0.1009126082,
-0.0321196131,
0.0293440428,
0.035136316,
-0.0291758254,
-0.0134032108,
0.0592004843,
0.0143581601,
-0.0281072315,
0.0151147833,
0.0148964878,
0.042065382,
-0.0004032277,
-0.0287223551,
0.0212238934,
0.0209870674,
0.0350663587,
-0.0022196448,
-0.0101937195,
-0.0020886438,
0.0217952039,
0.0273655951,
-0.0044894074,
0.0182860512,
-0.0085497396,
0.0019798863,
-0.0032215181,
-0.0078922827,
0.059447363,
0.0279700775,
0.0400620475,
0.052202858,
0.0130325397,
-0.0233608168,
0.046132911,
-0.0151588442,
0.0319951847,
-0.0150593193,
0.0494309738,
-0.0165157523,
-0.0055621606,
-0.030789027,
0.0537993312,
-0.0848513767,
-0.0642892867,
0.0031153399,
0.0746054575,
0.0328836292,
0.01541733,
0.0299353488,
-0.0211391952,
0.0168393031,
-0.020164093,
-0.0095338011,
-0.0295093004,
-0.0530495122,
0.0406202041,
-0.0002122617,
0.0105339363,
0.0163482334,
0.0799286515,
0.0406059548,
0.0709011704,
0.0207716078,
-0.002662308,
-0.0327039845,
-0.0396079272,
0.0710537359,
0.0133697465,
-0.0371759459,
-0.0664104223,
-0.0690881163,
-0.0884006545,
-0.0139449723,
0.0281195547,
0.0276736375,
-0.0025909159,
-0.0207108315,
0.0283323713,
0.0196417812,
-0.0038402365,
-0.043728251,
-0.0135700963,
0.0202563461,
-0.0401675031,
0.0190437697,
-5.941688643e-33,
0.0105560096,
-0.0141649684,
-0.023178855,
-0.0110927476,
0.0008539913,
-0.0214103945,
-0.033562772,
0.0259906612,
-0.0269370712,
-0.0448267497,
-0.0176845957,
0.0121095208,
0.0117383329,
-0.0047680531,
-0.0301466435,
-0.0355465114,
-0.0149939088,
0.0187341645,
-0.0288364962,
0.0129659735,
0.0276742056,
0.0262919348,
0.0605805852,
-0.028322652,
0.0666672066,
-0.0195414834,
-0.0321173556,
0.015777478,
-0.0715700835,
0.0622586645,
0.0056459559,
0.0055791712,
0.0010657739,
-0.0425277874,
-0.0103997011,
0.0168863107,
0.0127169276,
-0.0144812455,
0.019608058,
-0.0169796161,
-0.0069958433,
-0.0532387868,
0.0142573882,
0.0098965326,
-0.023461191,
-0.0154622653,
-0.0218501501,
-0.0083430195,
-0.0139998402,
0.0174863916,
-0.0304304697,
0.0149571542,
-0.0257354584,
-0.0093204938,
0.0016433109,
-0.0341814086,
0.0028251056,
-0.0294556245,
-0.0086861346,
0.0409342125,
0.0402175821,
0.0308423545,
0.0620469935,
0.0130201681,
-0.0372664407,
0.0582229607,
-0.0205190089,
-0.0245062914,
0.0350743793,
-0.0192493424,
0.003066554,
0.0558190718,
0.0283219982,
0.0554360785,
0.0631646365,
-0.0036925585,
-0.1013750583,
0.007442194,
0.0463970825,
0.0449248478,
0.0075076893,
0.0224220604,
-0.0658083484,
-0.0131125823,
-0.0093127824,
-0.0009699635,
-0.0142727522,
-0.0289614219,
0.0266670156,
0.0042122062,
-0.0339205861,
-0.0221291129,
0.0020989305,
-0.0429257229,
0.0014135337,
0.0157761928,
-0.0267553125,
-0.0044004507,
-0.0215945989,
0.0275444966,
-0.0297707245,
0.0012235607,
0.0012133634,
-0.054258652,
0.0520086177,
-0.017241139,
0.0547490604,
0.03356383,
-0.0507879592,
-0.0160645116,
-0.032248728,
0.0388188139,
0.0093550934,
0.0122739812,
0.0300139394,
-0.0348963328,
0.0130182095,
0.0043431181,
0.0285621174,
-0.0219810698,
-0.0626968369,
0.0655380264,
-0.0183366574,
0.0239562411,
-0.0038480761,
0.0138624385,
0.0067221024,
0.0395812429,
0.0178294834,
-0.0892266184,
-0.0245892256,
-0.0085154381,
2.886e-7,
-0.0132641457,
-0.0142854787,
0.0171557851,
0.0282513052,
-0.004003007,
0.0723781362,
-0.0402284265,
0.0813798606,
0.0052563394,
-0.0244298857,
-0.0387161449,
0.0058716065,
0.0548070483,
0.0391576812,
-0.0488338955,
0.0158029851,
-0.037544366,
-0.006970929,
-0.0451222211,
-0.034130469,
0.0326703601,
0.0784613267,
-0.0118395025,
-0.0268757083,
-0.0189406946,
-0.0387394391,
0.0213790927,
0.0060247462,
-0.0075783832,
-0.0009277867,
0.033089865,
0.0448779464,
-0.0001791509,
0.0228422899,
-0.0250409581,
-0.0257170107,
-0.0807483643,
0.0491086282,
0.0125545533,
-0.0395567827,
-0.0353887081,
-0.0251969919,
-0.0170881841,
-0.0313862525,
0.0650161356,
-0.0100593613,
-0.0270854738,
-0.0113114631,
0.0353640206,
-0.0239625536,
-0.0207169931,
-0.0398273394,
-0.0006511813,
0.0044299327,
0.020210905,
0.0020775648,
-0.0059147617,
-0.0566965155,
-0.0301557966,
0.0156311281,
0.0084372163,
-0.0599049404,
-0.012050204,
0.061641369,
0.0180915259,
-0.0538353324,
-0.0100859702,
2.948863725e-34,
-0.0015868131,
-0.0490226522,
0.0358053744,
0.0323426798,
0.0327213556,
0.000301723,
0.0257073622,
0.025904052,
0.0014980003,
-0.0061543817,
-0.0364590809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09090v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09090v3 | Social Bias Probing: Fairness Benchmarking for Language Models | 2023-11-15T16:35:59 | 2024-06-22T11:57:21 | Marta Marchiori Manerba, Karolina Stańczak, Riccardo Guidotti, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | While the impact of social biases in language models has been recognized,
prior methods for bias evaluation have been limited to binary association tests
on small datasets, limiting our understanding of bias complexities. This paper
proposes a novel framework for probing language models for social biases by
assessing disparate treatment, which involves treating individuals differently
according to their affiliation with a sensitive demographic group. We curate
SOFA, a large-scale benchmark designed to address the limitations of existing
fairness collections. SOFA expands the analysis beyond the binary comparison of
stereotypical versus anti-stereotypical identities to include a diverse range
of identities and stereotypes. Comparing our methodology with existing
benchmarks, we reveal that biases within language models are more nuanced than
acknowledged, indicating a broader scope of encoded biases than previously
recognized. Benchmarking LMs on SOFA, we expose how identities expressing
different religions lead to the most pronounced disparate treatments across all
models. Finally, our findings indicate that real-life adversities faced by
various groups such as women and people with disabilities are mirrored in the
behavior of these models. | [
0.0302056018,
0.1052586809,
-0.0490663275,
0.0533138439,
0.0020964909,
0.0299572535,
0.0768557489,
-0.0190034416,
0.0252334382,
-0.0706199855,
0.009026424,
-0.0216194782,
0.0385737494,
0.0027469841,
0.0104214307,
-0.0305408929,
0.0479406044,
0.0684350356,
0.034044601,
-0.0535476021,
0.0292381737,
0.047049202,
0.0356011949,
0.043339327,
-0.017944308,
0.0054863086,
0.0760141239,
-0.0042781229,
0.0154104196,
-0.007161451,
0.0466048606,
0.0773480907,
-0.0122184185,
0.0540501252,
0.0000018159,
-0.0851463303,
0.0157590453,
0.0147591876,
0.0004022117,
0.0138324527,
0.0409879424,
-0.0215220395,
-0.0092197405,
0.0370112285,
-0.0156976376,
-0.006573162,
0.0316898115,
-0.0167731997,
-0.0078078071,
0.0043626139,
-0.0081043364,
-0.0280025024,
-0.0653017759,
-0.0210749339,
0.0006603805,
0.0200257208,
0.0513926968,
-0.0686110482,
-0.0909923986,
-0.0674011856,
-0.01328314,
-0.0058347816,
0.0221991502,
0.0406829305,
0.0097637111,
0.0094339661,
-0.0367290713,
-0.0168235209,
0.0213682707,
0.0421038009,
0.0223520119,
0.0080333697,
0.0209152289,
0.0015232889,
0.0144918617,
0.0299032219,
-0.0069342642,
0.0322639346,
-0.0055044065,
-0.0150059024,
0.0015536264,
0.0386514105,
0.0252687931,
0.0619528182,
-0.0006346168,
0.0511704199,
0.0393949188,
-0.0147339292,
-0.0291588455,
0.0052470202,
0.0089344829,
-0.0284043048,
0.0015620434,
-0.03011957,
0.0010194016,
0.0079039307,
-0.0229476988,
0.0276061073,
0.0507616624,
-0.0379154086,
0.0304007716,
0.0502754226,
-0.0020404339,
-0.0008821115,
0.0327414833,
0.0318747573,
0.0273259282,
-0.0101492153,
0.0235999767,
0.0011299138,
-0.0017767383,
-0.0026423978,
0.0236374848,
-0.0247422252,
-0.0012253581,
0.0917981565,
-0.0417391248,
-0.0051003653,
-0.0732755065,
0.0190612823,
0.0006316895,
-0.0015683357,
-0.0231183004,
-0.0048001274,
-0.0320914388,
-0.0279657897,
-0.0579939559,
0.0117544355,
-0.0527358688,
-0.0855410397,
0.0358089544,
-0.0049254573,
-0.027814297,
-0.0584147498,
0.0045194193,
0.0439360179,
0.0160655882,
-0.0210052039,
0.0107117156,
-0.0171222631,
-0.0322547331,
-0.0308923144,
-0.0149780307,
-0.038597472,
0.0463625118,
0.0443350412,
0.0165979508,
-0.0823208839,
-0.0062244721,
0.0038972665,
-0.06874457,
0.0511839949,
0.0564096533,
0.0048722327,
0.0518873967,
0.0322673433,
-0.0105167925,
0.0766993091,
0.0104633281,
-0.0321204402,
0.054943148,
-0.0311083384,
-0.0091138547,
0.0303361155,
0.0295149311,
0.0421752259,
-0.0613452233,
0.0463234186,
0.016064262,
-0.0201373175,
0.0470449328,
0.0496379547,
0.0236899536,
-0.0637866035,
0.0244167205,
0.0840659067,
-0.0201065689,
0.0307511184,
-0.0201915689,
0.0125976261,
-0.0357265249,
-0.012353207,
-0.0882558674,
-0.0395456143,
0.0123200687,
-0.046090968,
0.0232794248,
0.0607549958,
-0.0178033113,
0.0076850792,
-0.0207323544,
0.0302369129,
0.0690756068,
-0.0100945644,
-0.0138528822,
-0.007289242,
0.0277139805,
0.0482548624,
0.0567547828,
-0.0326358825,
0.006715754,
-0.0570917316,
0.0019179484,
0.0405560955,
0.0176902208,
-0.0294476338,
0.0492991544,
-0.0145102646,
-0.0228493921,
0.0600297302,
0.0429809205,
0.0157794394,
0.0022254484,
-0.0192841776,
-0.0026637369,
0.0512944907,
0.0409499481,
0.038741257,
0.0624750294,
0.0355751216,
0.0111427139,
-0.0300159026,
-0.0193626974,
0.0264146384,
0.0086376993,
-0.0112586403,
-0.0074807997,
-0.0028483013,
0.0140018929,
-0.0090894466,
-0.0493284687,
-0.0313389823,
-0.0592948012,
-0.0019646864,
0.002354671,
0.0217660051,
-0.0668378845,
0.0124090873,
0.0102089746,
-0.0555841438,
-0.0291643143,
0.0589078777,
0.0115450686,
0.0218257718,
0.0824740753,
0.0102798659,
0.0171834491,
-0.0018604051,
0.0015346655,
-0.0650135875,
0.0438582376,
-0.0354184732,
0.0349618085,
-0.0371340588,
0.0096643902,
-0.0334150344,
-0.0545379147,
0.0300834291,
-0.0347512886,
-0.0300855488,
0.0136437491,
-0.0452933908,
0.010897724,
0.0048622293,
-0.0400851481,
0.0040910477,
-0.005141608,
-0.0759297311,
-0.0127408411,
-0.0049261525,
-0.0218960885,
-0.0293165315,
0.0237438045,
-0.026920598,
0.0087308334,
-0.0080776345,
-0.0518363677,
0.0313711017,
0.0548411496,
-0.0033472977,
-0.0499592535,
-0.0324962474,
-0.0435677581,
-0.0575724691,
-0.0536579601,
0.0732468441,
0.0175795518,
0.0145014124,
0.0075638364,
-0.0575251877,
-0.0597386286,
0.0015516266,
-0.0043639243,
-0.0245855637,
0.0280474294,
0.0715490952,
0.0184313171,
0.0386149622,
0.053531114,
0.031510599,
0.054052759,
-0.0176180992,
-0.0456541441,
-0.0305373203,
0.0045754202,
0.0449404642,
0.0035354579,
-0.1180461422,
-0.0223653466,
0.0741208643,
0.0560442433,
-0.040019054,
-0.0698538795,
0.0473690927,
-0.0697447732,
-0.041257672,
-0.0167028103,
-0.032805454,
-0.0132221412,
0.0046922201,
-0.050139457,
-0.053107813,
0.027198812,
0.010632908,
0.0160300732,
0.0061077662,
0.0097932043,
-0.0411918424,
0.0385760143,
0.0097456407,
0.0233157463,
-0.0143994447,
-0.0073672631,
-0.0303626209,
-0.0383356735,
0.0448660553,
-0.0438769311,
0.0346185714,
-0.0135811912,
0.0255249012,
-0.0296016447,
-0.0286507886,
-0.0471354462,
-0.052095551,
-0.0145395258,
0.0050896215,
0.033334963,
-0.0155843729,
0.0026871117,
0.0032349043,
-0.0185585842,
-0.0028496392,
-0.0027622553,
0.0056730784,
0.0064630122,
-0.0620411858,
-0.0219828337,
-0.0244581029,
0.0286021084,
-0.0125288703,
0.0078413328,
-0.0007834759,
0.004625428,
0.0352754816,
0.0196707472,
0.0220618732,
0.0175637472,
-0.0293113589,
0.0164318793,
-0.0087440787,
0.0382798798,
-0.013250486,
0.0252722651,
0.0924606621,
0.0290476885,
-0.043132592,
0.0215055998,
0.001358246,
0.0141745806,
0.0425940305,
-0.0097574703,
-0.1302612722,
0.017259473,
0.0141450483,
0.0270609055,
-0.06901218,
-0.0611042157,
-0.002674002,
-0.0590601824,
-0.0077081383,
0.006714311,
-0.0301935542,
-0.0179379415,
-0.0114524486,
0.0377422571,
-0.0199458972,
0.0405847169,
-0.0149222752,
0.0180913098,
-0.0021962635,
-0.0120673794,
-0.0702701956,
-0.0396167077,
0.0364887416,
-0.0434543937,
0.0380416997,
-0.0081141833,
0.0375975594,
-0.0385880172,
0.0078833383,
0.0231715608,
-0.028464118,
-0.0447697081,
-0.0238230899,
0.027170714,
-0.0184957646,
-0.0355160534,
-0.0273657143,
0.0111784851,
0.0090599833,
0.0126694795,
0.0094273239,
-0.0134844445,
0.0281928796,
-0.0475159064,
-0.0340556875,
-0.0106980074,
-0.0188477617,
0.0991679803,
0.016407609,
-0.0245789047,
0.0235996339,
-0.1022342071,
0.0008511446,
0.0193700418,
-0.0799472854,
0.0005204513,
0.0206709504,
-0.0551453792,
-0.0121088205,
-0.0431103185,
0.0075805411,
-0.0342827141,
0.0276290886,
-0.0681503415,
0.0067996313,
-0.0246253312,
-0.073771745,
0.0220653992,
-0.0347546525,
0.051958438,
0.0239749476,
-0.0108823981,
-0.0432647206,
-0.0030459713,
-0.0296975728,
-0.022198813,
-0.0087192934,
-0.0545185581,
0.1011017412,
-0.0182516202,
0.0186767001,
0.0135292634,
0.0068585579,
-0.047426112,
0.0312070381,
0.0420635231,
-0.0036211689,
0.0405623876,
0.0181067698,
-0.025769202,
0.0138663361,
0.0152910994,
-0.0174533986,
0.0613680892,
0.005777379,
-0.0042114556,
-0.0302501265,
-0.0349444337,
-0.0166986957,
-0.021946229,
0.0017910926,
-0.0150513789,
-0.0176335461,
-0.0400917046,
-0.0361021124,
-0.0261459593,
-0.0560230017,
0.0221443307,
-0.0559601262,
0.0210294202,
0.0417950936,
-0.0336586125,
-0.0034062027,
-0.0649791807,
0.0122962212,
-0.0357371345,
0.0319482721,
0.0085555166,
0.0593577251,
-0.0071900552,
-0.0040892246,
0.010995998,
0.0158935562,
-0.0376351364,
0.05204501,
0.012165905,
0.0262820087,
0.0121664675,
0.030943295,
-0.0134832542,
-0.015145855,
-0.0063786982,
-0.0046883705,
0.02369879,
-0.0254024677,
-0.0136251841,
-0.0247264151,
0.0062914938,
0.0281169657,
-0.0118045835,
-0.0114238532,
-0.0094144391,
0.0140138371,
-0.0082344646,
0.020763427,
-0.0032534739,
-0.007024684,
0.022417862,
0.0344733484,
0.0362254865,
0.049789805,
-0.0051611029,
-0.0282430444,
0.0015423198,
-0.0433919244,
0.0355537869,
0.0005526235,
-0.0087259607,
-0.0410752185,
-0.1003232598,
-0.0536274016,
-0.026193358,
0.0006931217,
0.038083069,
-0.0147042507,
-0.0197666697,
0.0541212372,
-0.0068338355,
-0.0183775946,
0.0145092281,
-0.0015012454,
-0.0492507145,
-0.0388450883,
0.0018704728,
-5.953348445e-33,
-0.0231648851,
-0.0230630077,
-0.0397319645,
-0.050286971,
-0.0007866619,
0.0150307231,
-0.0042570238,
0.0099139409,
-0.0411760174,
0.0041065868,
0.0105318371,
0.0327130929,
0.0114581287,
-0.0055432022,
0.0182419755,
-0.0081945779,
0.0403493606,
0.0038373179,
-0.0221733134,
-0.0149712656,
-0.027534768,
-0.0123836184,
0.0183321238,
-0.0457699895,
0.0748842806,
-0.0079644388,
-0.0133565636,
0.0023393116,
0.0092298901,
0.0165243167,
-0.0240864828,
0.0762864947,
0.0317234099,
0.0192794111,
0.0299157482,
0.0761669278,
-0.0323107168,
-0.0195984468,
0.0238672514,
0.0117392177,
0.0378720723,
-0.0192540046,
-0.0090716481,
0.0334872529,
-0.0844874904,
-0.0171780046,
0.0628841966,
0.0058766352,
0.0538109802,
0.0291156713,
-0.0237814169,
0.0191349071,
-0.0499441139,
0.0449087471,
-0.0379784852,
-0.0229902491,
0.038804695,
0.037418209,
-0.0136212483,
0.0062904912,
-0.0247267336,
-0.0172187183,
0.0216303077,
0.0169717297,
0.0036216516,
0.0455658995,
0.0466980822,
0.0690086111,
-0.0102930209,
-0.0278733987,
0.0750008225,
-0.03962107,
0.033170253,
0.0902559757,
0.0328413285,
-0.0323692337,
0.009079529,
-0.0080662156,
0.0766568333,
-0.0315540433,
0.0554514267,
-0.0079006935,
-0.0925911516,
-0.0585989431,
-0.0493928194,
-0.0445404537,
-0.0161940139,
0.0004924691,
0.04732503,
-0.0024429634,
-0.0331007764,
0.0167912934,
0.034963008,
-0.0321033336,
-0.0558618344,
0.0239619054,
-0.0058407984,
-0.0516224392,
0.028409142,
0.011679573,
-0.0492344908,
-0.014120019,
0.0192104913,
0.0253237914,
0.0279225372,
-0.0032613897,
-0.0205585677,
-0.0137772858,
-0.0700862631,
0.0146134477,
0.0138533376,
0.004102122,
-0.006528181,
0.0113250045,
0.024734417,
0.0354726315,
0.0136250136,
-0.0204769317,
0.0580023043,
-0.0153933745,
-0.0637048259,
0.0021611359,
-0.0451749302,
0.0477331579,
-0.0265211351,
-0.0227406174,
-0.004904489,
-0.0128674097,
0.0829193592,
-0.0161477383,
-0.0123883616,
-0.0787216648,
2.32e-7,
0.0064080181,
0.0538591631,
-0.0177662186,
0.051593978,
0.0167790502,
0.0218184423,
0.0552082211,
0.0599614121,
0.0302634668,
0.0157569479,
-0.0512822643,
0.0692809597,
0.0227555297,
0.0263279304,
0.0067045302,
0.0092433607,
-0.0912974328,
0.021379916,
-0.0429829024,
-0.0044719921,
-0.0328832902,
0.0518075079,
0.0532101952,
-0.0064549083,
-0.0339112319,
-0.0219569504,
0.0013596151,
-0.0440333337,
0.0128736729,
0.0227426756,
-0.0048821419,
0.0204862189,
0.0426233187,
0.035980545,
0.02531025,
0.035722848,
-0.0183596071,
-0.0132071562,
-0.0101860594,
0.052418679,
-0.0272496548,
-0.0253409967,
-0.0279992837,
-0.0679229945,
0.0395114459,
0.037606068,
-0.006103945,
-0.0587740168,
-0.0248230584,
-0.0249998271,
0.0447093397,
0.0072667613,
-0.0420163535,
0.0061001531,
0.033066757,
-0.0037138038,
0.0004530394,
-0.0447051376,
-0.037545979,
-0.0225718003,
-0.0137111973,
-0.0427968651,
0.0147231715,
0.0230429936,
-0.0140146594,
0.0105349915,
0.0369453393,
2.022772541e-34,
0.0247326363,
0.03752416,
0.0140582807,
-0.0336608812,
0.0634513721,
0.0036846895,
-0.0246470291,
-0.0144917164,
0.0291297343,
-0.013299074,
0.0083648711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09086v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09086v3 | The Uli Dataset: An Exercise in Experience Led Annotation of oGBV | 2023-11-15T16:30:44 | 2024-06-24T07:31:19 | Arnav Arora, Maha Jinadoss, Cheshta Arora, Denny George, Brindaalakshmi, Haseena Dawood Khan, Kirti Rawat, Div, Ritash, Seema Mathur, Shivani Yadav, Shehla Rashid Shora, Rie Raut, Sumit Pawar, Apurva Paithane, Sonia, Vivek, Dharini Priscilla, Khairunnisha, Grace Banu, Ambika Tandon, Rishav Thakker, Rahul Dev Korra, Aatman Vaidya, Tarunima Prabhakar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI | Online gender based violence has grown concomitantly with adoption of the
internet and social media. Its effects are worse in the Global majority where
many users use social media in languages other than English. The scale and
volume of conversations on the internet has necessitated the need for automated
detection of hate speech, and more specifically gendered abuse. There is,
however, a lack of language specific and contextual data to build such
automated tools. In this paper we present a dataset on gendered abuse in three
languages- Hindi, Tamil and Indian English. The dataset comprises of tweets
annotated along three questions pertaining to the experience of gender abuse,
by experts who identify as women or a member of the LGBTQIA community in South
Asia. Through this dataset we demonstrate a participatory approach to creating
datasets that drive AI systems. | [
0.0896025822,
0.0483109206,
-0.0341924988,
0.0115451599,
-0.016091885,
0.0492734499,
0.052456554,
-0.0169618353,
0.0539198071,
-0.0275050998,
0.0461667441,
-0.0423142426,
-0.0168054793,
0.0662462711,
0.0190327317,
-0.0390000269,
0.0014635783,
0.0375567712,
0.0205148477,
0.0143696787,
0.065290451,
0.0374707431,
-0.0299378857,
0.0303859264,
-0.0477408469,
0.0087058777,
0.0062279715,
-0.0068743015,
0.0024456617,
-0.0012038315,
0.0405939631,
0.0357316174,
0.0201462191,
0.0454269089,
0.0000017685,
-0.0771046057,
0.0234470125,
0.0001089585,
-0.0144491754,
-0.0504537262,
0.0521176234,
-0.0194871575,
-0.0080876807,
0.0305449162,
-0.0430567078,
0.0193832144,
0.0783428699,
0.0225451887,
0.0617613718,
0.0645955205,
-0.0230488908,
-0.0119372401,
0.0089323903,
0.0251380522,
-0.0104079787,
0.049432192,
0.0375625938,
-0.02096821,
-0.0201012995,
-0.0232099071,
0.0073643536,
0.0182051454,
0.0124371555,
-0.0177326649,
-0.0300997812,
-0.0346860625,
-0.0717976093,
-0.0461563841,
0.0432867333,
0.0605236106,
-0.0046854364,
-0.0019120945,
0.0316342041,
0.0112746172,
-0.0414951704,
-0.0143530807,
-0.0248492975,
0.0609622411,
-0.0558161326,
0.0119164567,
0.0124127567,
0.0103297764,
0.0242810436,
0.0651084557,
0.0375417732,
0.0292126611,
-0.0478485189,
-0.0153144989,
-0.0038020802,
-0.017311817,
-0.0179038849,
-0.003405733,
0.0199596863,
-0.0009635858,
-0.0067384513,
0.0133430418,
-0.0193482973,
-0.0615158826,
0.0239288248,
-0.0867397338,
0.0204837397,
0.0531628393,
-0.0283706468,
-0.0177127309,
0.0232174862,
0.0149659626,
0.0068612914,
0.0297446717,
0.014708003,
-0.0208958741,
-0.0260618273,
0.0150823658,
0.0154713085,
-0.0117600132,
-0.0004757516,
0.084444195,
-0.0726454258,
0.0368634574,
-0.0733257681,
0.0113481125,
-0.0175565239,
-0.0160701089,
-0.0080841975,
0.011349964,
0.0167813413,
-0.0072955149,
-0.0428104438,
0.0152384974,
-0.0478543453,
-0.1141184643,
0.0324025676,
0.0279069785,
-0.0115483636,
-0.0142844142,
0.0018355219,
0.0588751957,
0.0259874761,
-0.0364007726,
-0.0666040853,
-0.0229625162,
-0.0061292201,
-0.0174599141,
0.0139219342,
-0.0641980395,
0.0525791012,
0.0402859412,
-0.0317783877,
-0.0537821315,
0.0069736517,
0.0184072442,
-0.0383760743,
0.0758215785,
0.0171216745,
0.0078184679,
0.0908037052,
0.0510053337,
0.0359706953,
0.0567882024,
0.0282086357,
0.0406430326,
0.0535467081,
0.0246833172,
0.0232299697,
0.0492593497,
0.0222386252,
0.0405892916,
-0.0268284697,
0.0469838753,
-0.067643486,
-0.0150138056,
-0.0167770963,
-0.0130495606,
0.016629247,
0.0176357739,
0.0263311379,
0.0665108934,
-0.0133701079,
0.0519673973,
0.0409277566,
0.0036556006,
-0.0124785025,
-0.0320844799,
-0.0140433256,
-0.0262293629,
-0.0048427265,
-0.0357576162,
0.010503226,
0.0284528639,
-0.0209437218,
-0.0333195366,
-0.0345814414,
-0.0163164269,
0.0162801947,
-0.0168690644,
0.0298448242,
0.0161714498,
0.0180748552,
-0.0187591016,
0.0687716305,
-0.0749670044,
0.002709432,
-0.0545598194,
0.0271681715,
0.0394662656,
-0.0048496765,
-0.051108025,
-0.0020105049,
-0.051780872,
0.027309699,
0.0324679688,
-0.0178844761,
-0.0086750276,
-0.0178333148,
-0.010500594,
-0.0026709531,
0.0638475567,
-0.0232668705,
-0.0131346611,
0.0484606177,
0.0139355063,
0.0068511157,
0.0343472883,
-0.0813531503,
0.0306123663,
-0.0017724209,
-0.0209121928,
0.0082555935,
0.0387206934,
0.064470835,
0.038222082,
-0.0387716293,
-0.0759636387,
0.0277529601,
-0.0108882263,
-0.0323059373,
0.0350218453,
0.0190229937,
0.0342488438,
0.015297587,
-0.0901273638,
-0.0360740907,
0.0458180308,
-0.0292585175,
0.0122972326,
0.0696540028,
0.0080422433,
-0.0227766577,
-0.037729498,
-0.0386610813,
-0.0296191908,
0.0055248956,
-0.0000809538,
0.0385344587,
-0.0541440435,
-0.0262311585,
-0.0082523832,
-0.049220372,
0.0437675901,
0.0006880378,
-0.0280236229,
0.0145449704,
-0.003747113,
0.0415936522,
0.012365167,
0.0026745345,
-0.0375538282,
0.008377403,
-0.0989645869,
-0.0220137499,
0.001763039,
-0.0149372108,
0.0178142358,
0.0589449592,
-0.0415094532,
0.0027669452,
0.0080863629,
-0.0407704227,
0.0634300411,
0.0172187481,
0.0427118242,
-0.027648598,
0.0495557711,
-0.023683589,
-0.0021179405,
-0.0555141829,
0.0478583872,
0.0186742321,
-0.0783074275,
0.0220370814,
-0.0219501965,
-0.0343440883,
0.0170321874,
-0.0234682243,
-0.062445268,
0.0109210219,
0.0091325976,
-0.025210306,
0.0403348245,
0.0358350165,
0.0891442597,
0.0353124067,
0.0250723697,
0.0017416588,
-0.0110372771,
0.0267957281,
-0.0006033515,
0.0197967049,
-0.0357131884,
-0.0056098392,
0.0269849692,
0.0109006865,
-0.0035590592,
-0.0160153285,
0.0167285129,
-0.0608236454,
-0.0333655477,
-0.0645155534,
-0.0557853468,
-0.0221960507,
0.0180667937,
-0.0120968623,
-0.0473153293,
0.0387734771,
0.0239532553,
0.0243348889,
-0.0332167596,
-0.0351688638,
-0.0192007981,
0.0625563115,
-0.0173731036,
0.0574044622,
-0.0564026237,
-0.0033269492,
0.0065331426,
-0.0228659548,
0.0149945235,
-0.0025035734,
-0.0153147606,
-0.0236437824,
0.0281450525,
-0.0079307724,
-0.0233053435,
-0.0526879393,
-0.0514646284,
-0.0297640245,
-0.0227422919,
-0.0309902728,
-0.0128765889,
-0.0119618205,
0.0363287814,
0.0057756207,
-0.0073058214,
-0.0047502704,
-0.0117896451,
0.0246121734,
-0.0274184123,
0.0171864703,
-0.0430224724,
-0.0189290754,
0.0456087701,
-0.0192555878,
0.0447012931,
-0.0075501753,
-0.0090173678,
0.0019192554,
0.0156942494,
0.0216791742,
-0.0279531293,
0.0386725664,
-0.0415813327,
0.0189062003,
0.0085760998,
-0.008435661,
0.0686421245,
0.0385371521,
-0.0282020643,
-0.0059374915,
-0.040950533,
-0.0010376181,
0.0058711367,
0.0123674022,
-0.1330561191,
0.016814366,
-0.026787065,
0.0022978315,
-0.0834061727,
-0.0419404022,
-0.0219136737,
-0.0501084365,
-0.0048833112,
-0.0100233462,
-0.0243769456,
-0.0435662568,
0.0038004899,
-0.0016414248,
-0.0179671925,
0.0397384502,
-0.0185316857,
0.0063002324,
0.0000712703,
0.0217323992,
-0.0573524348,
-0.0198660661,
0.0066251191,
-0.060858015,
0.0317059793,
0.02640328,
0.0613402054,
-0.0558822975,
0.0408597514,
0.0265671946,
0.0212438311,
-0.0204301141,
-0.026082512,
0.0435009636,
-0.0163301695,
-0.0449700989,
-0.0229102597,
0.068992056,
-0.0095104724,
-0.0087536126,
0.0316543467,
0.0355471484,
0.0064128959,
0.0346956775,
-0.0295393653,
-0.0305702277,
0.0182525199,
0.0245706029,
0.0155074941,
-0.0430317484,
0.011939561,
-0.0855608359,
-0.0242485106,
0.0195711926,
-0.0990998819,
-0.001018596,
-0.0239406303,
-0.0474717729,
-0.0051616328,
-0.0461196713,
0.0462431237,
0.0085629029,
0.0439342335,
-0.0601636134,
0.0088601168,
0.0126532735,
-0.0746304616,
-0.0042087585,
-0.0090300329,
0.0350502022,
0.0256511942,
0.0048834132,
-0.0243996214,
-0.0117744366,
-0.0089893499,
0.0523926467,
-0.0040057548,
-0.049968984,
0.079039067,
0.0333811864,
0.0233943313,
0.0170175005,
-0.0161392726,
-0.0865020379,
0.0155749302,
0.0421201587,
-0.0070571951,
-0.0257786606,
0.0402977318,
0.0289146025,
0.0181830805,
0.0236064531,
-0.0009521052,
0.0025036491,
0.0102933636,
-0.0829010382,
-0.0567966513,
0.0062126163,
-0.0098817004,
-0.0050256685,
0.008532851,
-0.0309458412,
-0.0665141866,
-0.0436866805,
-0.0227355827,
0.0085098036,
-0.0324989036,
-0.0096447151,
0.0133101754,
0.017004637,
0.0195414014,
-0.0333603844,
-0.0084254444,
-0.0623550452,
-0.0009496632,
-0.0818530098,
0.0422727652,
0.0552985519,
0.0891302824,
-0.0059458828,
0.0017578119,
-0.0021274544,
0.0086548189,
-0.0205765236,
-0.0141817247,
-0.0152084734,
0.0084794164,
0.0028258383,
0.0446930826,
0.0556940585,
0.0116692176,
0.0215768777,
-0.01440873,
-0.0354360864,
-0.0349072367,
0.0106586311,
-0.0401431546,
0.0348389931,
0.0119348047,
-0.0143862395,
-0.008934103,
0.0155590409,
-0.0508665703,
-0.0171933472,
-0.0065833698,
0.0193956122,
-0.033270739,
0.0196604766,
0.0285070352,
0.0101374099,
0.0494266637,
0.0797674507,
-0.0514447801,
-0.0093326187,
-0.0018019449,
0.0090077408,
0.01633556,
0.0328058861,
0.0102288425,
-0.0312457997,
-0.0361090899,
-0.0285588186,
-0.0745520294,
0.0232582428,
-0.0101583209,
0.0019165995,
0.0541852079,
0.0224685334,
0.0191590339,
-0.0465017445,
0.0058573824,
-0.012814017,
-0.0693507344,
0.0175689254,
-5.275362976e-33,
0.0074968832,
-0.0483936965,
-0.0136179654,
0.001667705,
-0.0120448237,
-0.0039824117,
0.0279937331,
-0.0019855034,
-0.0307679456,
0.0324809998,
-0.0065442631,
0.0466560833,
0.0138359219,
0.0024932399,
0.0031161315,
-0.0098663829,
0.0088142008,
0.0130813634,
-0.0049513667,
0.013341995,
0.060109254,
-0.006673343,
0.050435625,
-0.1313965768,
0.0932065547,
-0.0326277874,
-0.0482080765,
0.0208760276,
0.0148283811,
0.0486802794,
-0.023790773,
0.0850073099,
0.032875482,
0.0227467529,
0.0423725657,
0.0688980073,
-0.059800785,
-0.0139527675,
0.0174518637,
0.0320332944,
0.0077585466,
0.0013689424,
0.0195444915,
-0.0022787724,
-0.023382714,
0.011216253,
0.0433774665,
0.0045320052,
0.0466401689,
-0.0413025506,
-0.0345345512,
0.0222547092,
-0.0600255728,
0.0030365302,
-0.0007438883,
0.0313863233,
0.0309343599,
-0.0223421399,
-0.0794693753,
0.0420386642,
-0.0044893827,
-0.0124806995,
0.0271836575,
-0.0249154996,
-0.0113989236,
0.0199806672,
0.0158547629,
-0.0110091334,
-0.0176447816,
-0.0050501307,
-0.0169632416,
0.0365491211,
-0.0246984679,
0.0480841771,
-0.0140249953,
-0.0861273855,
-0.0741663724,
-0.0050311871,
0.0670653209,
0.0165969245,
-0.0011384513,
-0.0342749692,
-0.066046603,
-0.035732612,
0.0075570638,
-0.0974079818,
-0.0264359601,
-0.0280167088,
0.0103551336,
-0.0468225703,
-0.0268837437,
0.0153462114,
-0.0170864128,
-0.0359079465,
-0.0102137737,
0.0192777589,
-0.0353645459,
-0.0031455252,
0.0434712842,
0.01656048,
0.000636587,
-0.0099409185,
-0.0288883969,
0.0094643775,
0.0389914252,
-0.0009996663,
0.0750995651,
0.0477126502,
-0.054815013,
-0.0166169312,
-0.0109966202,
0.0524582528,
-0.0461515598,
0.066085875,
-0.0075162551,
0.02766243,
-0.0181129109,
0.0128568858,
0.079721123,
0.0090219071,
-0.0281161405,
-0.0164579768,
-0.0363404714,
-0.0135062449,
-0.0155269932,
-0.0175795387,
-0.0242935587,
0.0253303889,
0.0354682691,
-0.0674052089,
0.0116249956,
-0.0483606905,
2.471e-7,
0.0086938553,
0.0513867773,
-0.0031865633,
-0.0015215542,
-0.0005009078,
0.0119164167,
0.0474238619,
0.0387648754,
0.0025699197,
0.0058723884,
-0.019917665,
0.0253050867,
0.0056675253,
0.0360774547,
-0.0449007936,
-0.004945471,
-0.0750907511,
0.0136850383,
-0.0645507425,
0.043588724,
-0.040079888,
0.0479331985,
0.0781497359,
-0.0310261939,
-0.046397794,
-0.016755214,
-0.011253613,
-0.0192032848,
-0.0183588043,
0.0060240179,
0.0416030809,
0.030521702,
0.0188208912,
-0.019928867,
-0.007783758,
-0.0098879337,
0.0215578321,
0.0318395235,
0.0062200618,
0.0272261258,
0.0111745689,
-0.0170245245,
0.0063702036,
-0.0559991784,
0.0733308047,
0.0385312997,
-0.0539934561,
-0.0398223288,
0.0387407765,
-0.0266438611,
0.039495375,
-0.0185006,
0.0038749338,
0.0083608339,
0.0363784879,
-0.0401472338,
-0.0084797684,
-0.0295542851,
0.0015080987,
-0.0083657335,
0.0259002354,
-0.0473942757,
0.0147927189,
0.0196862537,
0.0352535434,
0.0195969678,
0.0518118516,
1.87509739e-34,
0.0123157855,
0.0291830543,
0.0250485707,
-0.0026238167,
0.027071204,
0.0235339496,
0.0160322879,
-0.014595137,
0.0545199178,
0.017338315,
0.002393984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09071v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09071v2 | How Vocabulary Sharing Facilitates Multilingualism in LLaMA? | 2023-11-15T16:13:14 | 2024-06-03T06:11:06 | Fei Yuan, Shuai Yuan, Zhiyong Wu, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), often show strong performance on English tasks,
while exhibiting limitations on other languages. What is an LLM's multilingual
capability when it is trained only on certain languages? The underlying
mechanism remains unclear. This study endeavors to examine the multilingual
capability of LLMs from the vocabulary sharing perspective by conducting an
exhaustive analysis across 101 languages. Through the investigation of the
performance gap before and after embedding fine-tuning, we discovered four
distinct quadrants. By delving into each quadrant we provide actionable and
efficient guidelines for tuning these languages. Extensive experiments reveal
that existing LLMs possess multilingual capabilities that surpass our
expectations, and we can significantly improve the multilingual performance of
LLMs based on these attributes of each
quadrant~\footnote{\url{https://github.com/CONE-MT/Vocabulary-Sharing-Facilitates-Multilingualism}.}. | [
0.0154724093,
0.0418230332,
-0.0333644599,
0.0906615257,
-0.0236612316,
0.0245627556,
0.0222074352,
0.0006612258,
-0.02679017,
-0.0118871164,
-0.1159463748,
-0.0480245724,
0.0022845392,
-0.0099272998,
0.0342785195,
-0.0309232902,
0.0244387556,
-0.0496373661,
-0.0365442038,
-0.0420253463,
-0.0153988069,
-0.0101992516,
0.0276154522,
0.009475979,
0.0054414039,
0.0053971931,
0.0349565819,
-0.0242234617,
0.0179082099,
-0.0177051164,
-0.0043704766,
0.0065360754,
0.0071758488,
0.0408259556,
0.0000019176,
-0.0601182878,
0.0369928516,
-0.0116527379,
0.0250970181,
0.061466746,
0.0302144494,
-0.0400207341,
-0.0040533105,
0.0135455923,
-0.0153341424,
0.0101819867,
0.0298752431,
-0.0076656179,
-0.0028815242,
0.0489310101,
-0.009212615,
-0.0291345175,
0.0223958101,
-0.0539075024,
-0.0001139832,
-0.0605533645,
-0.0104468195,
0.0160417166,
0.0211486816,
-0.0085778683,
-0.0451787896,
0.0584104769,
0.0450146943,
0.0089103142,
-0.0126964021,
0.0486933105,
0.0075641843,
-0.0408849791,
-0.0032863969,
0.0335030444,
-0.0088654282,
0.0032339075,
-0.0265143234,
-0.009908882,
0.0008442809,
-0.0104073808,
-0.0383539274,
0.0552939177,
0.0208296683,
0.0425244085,
0.0325115956,
-0.0017519441,
0.0673641115,
0.0029719749,
-0.0142713059,
0.0474366769,
0.0342607796,
-0.0243309047,
0.0157895423,
0.0355471186,
-0.0030888224,
-0.0406810604,
0.0009613857,
0.0190212224,
-0.0157848373,
0.0247073565,
-0.0109339533,
-0.0158242472,
0.0642329827,
-0.0409594253,
0.0647797436,
0.0464220531,
-0.0435501188,
0.0303875916,
-0.019405758,
0.0343187004,
-0.0258762483,
0.0636849925,
-0.0604935922,
-0.0301335119,
-0.0152019691,
-0.0049171513,
0.0225670785,
0.0084542381,
-0.0172987934,
-0.0122221997,
-0.036482051,
0.0277633797,
0.0260684248,
0.0109202331,
0.0116161844,
-0.048839204,
-0.0068596951,
0.0338146947,
-0.0042348569,
0.0321020409,
-0.0521356799,
0.033754345,
0.00826219,
-0.0681185871,
0.0191604234,
-0.0025250965,
-0.0486321338,
-0.0470855758,
0.0400321446,
0.070116505,
-0.0164637808,
-0.0447433889,
-0.0289491527,
0.0153267058,
0.0079511302,
-0.0702720433,
0.033957243,
-0.0409066565,
0.044927083,
0.0123992693,
0.0497037768,
-0.0134452293,
-0.0051199337,
-0.0112303393,
0.0054107718,
0.0572115779,
-0.022798609,
0.0026135342,
0.0494442284,
0.0245031603,
0.0256617703,
0.1222632527,
0.0278985556,
-0.0149528831,
0.0726830065,
-0.012928973,
-0.0608508214,
0.0501834825,
0.0111420229,
0.0313364193,
-0.028534947,
-0.0201487392,
0.0250950381,
0.036367476,
0.0387672782,
0.0322864987,
-0.022728432,
-0.0000217958,
0.0559960343,
0.0730209053,
0.0286439862,
0.0179406572,
0.0375782922,
-0.0481276549,
0.0075371042,
0.0171619318,
-0.0359329917,
0.0054321554,
0.0342472009,
-0.0040696859,
0.0209429767,
0.0802026317,
-0.038049534,
-0.0294699483,
-0.0335923769,
-0.0601078235,
0.0124310171,
-0.0187437963,
0.0265514478,
-0.004956875,
0.0333780907,
0.0580588952,
0.0456796736,
-0.0435405858,
0.0237380452,
-0.0549760982,
-0.0017730175,
0.0560133718,
0.0013381786,
0.0004630602,
-0.0306512117,
0.0124927228,
0.0138429841,
0.0344213322,
0.0764479488,
-0.0032859775,
0.0391593911,
-0.0618788004,
0.0185141377,
-0.061594341,
0.0222115647,
0.063508004,
0.012637889,
0.0516663194,
-0.0081104189,
-0.0270391889,
-0.036689654,
0.0306949839,
-0.087816909,
0.004474849,
-0.0193487909,
-0.0093948999,
0.0133806225,
0.0319459401,
-0.0249107499,
-0.0077823726,
0.0187089033,
-0.0583552606,
-0.0034748926,
0.0360382684,
-0.060738124,
0.0338918604,
0.0529535897,
0.0137521299,
0.0141661586,
0.0161032695,
-0.0048448653,
-0.0344068781,
-0.0021597631,
-0.0033559061,
0.0349277221,
-0.0408864096,
0.005116906,
-0.0348119698,
0.0398372449,
-0.0061413967,
0.0329756439,
-0.0275392309,
0.0235672817,
-0.0133533441,
0.007713323,
0.028957203,
-0.0225853547,
-0.0275419224,
0.0698804706,
0.021049764,
0.0060590217,
-0.0028314684,
0.0246617962,
-0.0321675688,
-0.0296214707,
-0.0531549081,
-0.0188967586,
-0.0254783053,
0.0280595217,
0.0185476579,
0.0053744959,
-0.0234450866,
0.0110005876,
-0.0253724884,
0.0302352607,
0.0170050412,
0.0595145263,
0.0237894859,
0.0210967362,
-0.0287433639,
-0.0327562653,
-0.0069502052,
0.0483921133,
0.0059324699,
-0.0087898066,
-0.0262587368,
-0.03779101,
0.0225831661,
-0.0449671708,
-0.0107754339,
-0.0233361926,
-0.0539738089,
0.010025355,
0.0241089426,
0.0246222559,
0.0502664708,
-0.0469228067,
0.0053325733,
0.0757172406,
0.0024625959,
-0.0322455466,
0.0039618001,
0.040071398,
-0.0538675077,
-0.0851559192,
-0.0144678615,
-0.0186899099,
0.0820480436,
-0.0519507378,
-0.0202725027,
-0.032410726,
-0.0415024646,
-0.0457488447,
-0.0355691612,
-0.0217310265,
0.0072231293,
-0.0047194944,
0.0757123381,
0.0017341032,
-0.0813041404,
0.0298548564,
-0.036304526,
-0.0162644703,
-0.0258630961,
-0.0205632113,
-0.0820982829,
0.0199599899,
-0.0111241862,
0.0232277904,
-0.0593219921,
-0.0104501704,
-0.0412886925,
-0.014223611,
0.0166640412,
-0.0155622875,
0.0564405061,
-0.0296361055,
-0.0379815288,
-0.0429560989,
-0.0507596768,
-0.0019184883,
0.0333856605,
-0.0489722155,
0.0104044341,
0.0170068201,
-0.0191178992,
-0.0026818539,
-0.0370651595,
0.0429051928,
0.0179322194,
0.0095879631,
0.0221882667,
0.0012794558,
-0.0256128479,
-0.0011689162,
0.0417028777,
0.0259352624,
-0.0652424172,
0.0000648894,
0.0056751133,
0.0399845205,
-0.0084597124,
0.0267775953,
0.0028449276,
0.0415841155,
-0.0053834659,
-0.0630478561,
-0.0088814739,
0.0478066318,
-0.0100482982,
-0.0085102087,
0.0574235208,
0.0084618088,
-0.0545077212,
0.0089912824,
-0.087105602,
0.0337390751,
0.0508412644,
0.0102528846,
-0.0896627083,
-0.0007883881,
0.0190007389,
-0.0130040618,
0.0329688415,
0.0124359755,
-0.0201135576,
-0.1093924195,
-0.026480848,
-0.0092406655,
-0.0510026589,
-0.0135044381,
-0.0359806493,
-0.0360662453,
-0.0166695118,
0.0468858331,
-0.0305597614,
0.0082494644,
-0.0265484322,
0.0136604626,
0.0267206579,
-0.0606006458,
0.0169450995,
-0.0487599745,
0.0368027091,
0.0361034647,
0.0287680048,
-0.0323162563,
-0.0621812493,
0.0486383997,
-0.0241316557,
0.0057586809,
-0.01590278,
-0.0077184956,
0.0024522953,
-0.007505131,
0.0532640256,
-0.001759571,
-0.0110361055,
-0.0016996032,
0.0084505482,
0.0630938113,
0.0304234643,
-0.0066066822,
0.0233007111,
-0.026348928,
-0.0230652913,
0.0250147022,
0.0430810153,
-0.0288645066,
0.0019521555,
0.0008420945,
-0.0293341968,
-0.0391357951,
-0.0189475119,
0.0179041363,
0.0043545607,
-0.0264407098,
-0.0452742949,
-0.0473173223,
-0.0145440064,
-0.0057404949,
0.0433009453,
0.0508684292,
-0.040428862,
-0.0240696967,
0.0052397833,
-0.0020391811,
-0.0332823321,
0.016397018,
-0.0534384437,
-0.0041642999,
0.0430900343,
-0.0105152773,
-0.0022488579,
-0.0221042037,
-0.0599431172,
-0.0830736235,
-0.0031158559,
0.0541229136,
0.0157374013,
0.0187565554,
0.043710269,
-0.0870166197,
0.0325078964,
0.0271634851,
-0.0168133043,
0.0649408326,
0.0472802259,
0.0069496608,
0.0321612433,
0.0545276329,
-0.0325050838,
-0.00245674,
0.0010403356,
0.0080868173,
-0.0106639257,
-0.0241571609,
-0.0513911098,
0.02896199,
-0.0166896824,
-0.0580975339,
-0.0220007375,
-0.0651398897,
0.0570377186,
-0.0235598795,
0.0196484048,
-0.0180103146,
-0.0270265862,
0.0448316,
-0.0142183481,
0.006551702,
0.0115521094,
0.0184871964,
0.0179624595,
-0.0008931137,
0.0536476336,
0.0087818531,
-0.0251596738,
0.012712257,
0.0454994328,
0.005465806,
0.0169356167,
-0.0123062618,
0.039579846,
-0.0279171839,
0.0174124893,
-0.0304642953,
-0.0224591289,
-0.011768708,
0.0445568189,
-0.0093085701,
-0.0574797057,
0.0513798594,
0.046165701,
0.084972553,
-0.0032392784,
0.0814590305,
-0.026377894,
-0.0106292143,
-0.0158863738,
0.0103049343,
-0.0433057882,
-0.04095589,
0.0667082593,
-0.0166657027,
-0.0212191734,
-0.0094976351,
0.0696966052,
-0.0177940037,
0.0212476589,
-0.0099696601,
0.0558403693,
0.0089229094,
-0.0259567611,
0.0369298011,
0.0111938678,
-0.0363842398,
-0.0111555364,
-0.0262532681,
-0.075793691,
0.01136427,
-0.005237699,
-0.0271451082,
-0.0092583019,
-0.0195236113,
0.0706762299,
0.0146217151,
0.0196647961,
-0.0474295877,
-0.0482155085,
0.0219848789,
-0.0064081689,
0.0662277713,
-5.988987964e-33,
-0.023390945,
-0.0004966447,
0.0281375479,
0.014953183,
-0.0004417089,
0.0087661762,
-0.0201890841,
0.0046022497,
-0.0355906188,
-0.0058206352,
-0.0498305336,
-0.0011127304,
0.0209444426,
-0.0049770013,
0.0499977656,
0.0084096892,
0.0093850708,
-0.0074541885,
-0.0142315105,
0.0130495634,
0.032145828,
0.0550062396,
0.0910062417,
0.0028994279,
0.0019222663,
-0.0068656718,
0.0212327577,
0.0081694024,
-0.0255858377,
0.0717967451,
-0.0393024236,
0.0401725918,
0.0294569246,
-0.0421815589,
-0.0253537539,
-0.0198747646,
-0.0365038849,
-0.0485727675,
0.0506922603,
0.0107873911,
-0.0055803233,
-0.0651614666,
0.0386767909,
-0.014130435,
-0.0235440116,
-0.0094181187,
-0.0085215569,
-0.0226024557,
-0.0237229187,
0.037359681,
-0.0813561603,
-0.0004434119,
0.0351315476,
0.01405566,
0.0539421625,
-0.0072219879,
-0.0037782111,
-0.0012969699,
-0.0343154483,
0.0323156938,
-0.0036916465,
0.0366087183,
0.1014186665,
-0.0008567987,
-0.0008819611,
0.0403860845,
0.0303135626,
0.0003240748,
0.038277708,
-0.0111222351,
0.0426821783,
-0.0061937105,
0.021894373,
0.0679047629,
0.0066997879,
-0.0475785956,
-0.0906538442,
-0.0135538634,
0.0199048128,
0.0318928622,
0.0042354306,
0.0145166786,
0.0032729076,
-0.0172992274,
-0.0519957058,
0.0142597128,
-0.0232196115,
-0.0257392433,
0.0456807539,
0.020052962,
0.0041478514,
-0.0024210424,
0.0383880734,
-0.0161514431,
-0.0559595972,
0.0394002385,
0.0079219006,
0.0117763095,
-0.0076778508,
0.0004054161,
-0.1116558015,
-0.0568383671,
-0.0457104146,
-0.0090943975,
0.0191239659,
0.0038475303,
0.0673814416,
-0.0053672879,
-0.0621432029,
0.0233661644,
-0.0433401167,
0.0057780179,
0.0404538885,
0.0379371718,
0.034782514,
-0.0396039188,
-0.0242379531,
0.0499927998,
0.0386491045,
-0.0307308864,
-0.0473594069,
-0.0410168208,
-0.0117567517,
0.0211001206,
-0.024586523,
0.0063645313,
-0.0465793759,
0.0382410027,
0.0394659676,
-0.0250103045,
-0.0168794543,
-0.0385584868,
2.619e-7,
0.0412963107,
0.0176360309,
-0.0213030726,
0.0147015834,
0.0114354491,
0.0036889636,
-0.0757970139,
0.055628255,
-0.0149361258,
0.0093606431,
-0.0274509452,
0.0389952324,
0.0370520763,
0.0651967973,
-0.0502947494,
0.0158741083,
-0.0577017888,
0.0390015803,
-0.0354571827,
-0.0318744108,
-0.0335238129,
0.0813379437,
-0.0011783007,
-0.036373429,
-0.0102173779,
-0.0663338676,
0.0633597448,
-0.0773791373,
-0.0259609278,
0.0272893943,
0.0204506908,
0.0661360025,
-0.0211714432,
-0.0194287486,
-0.0366515033,
0.0289954804,
-0.0284202006,
0.0578835011,
0.0191960838,
-0.027060356,
0.0410692468,
-0.0118910754,
-0.06282226,
-0.0685115159,
0.0467195958,
-0.0104302894,
-0.0309110098,
-0.0169743616,
0.0661201254,
-0.0207746699,
0.0891633332,
-0.050871104,
0.0130780386,
0.0121018011,
-0.0043709297,
-0.0135973934,
-0.0498919748,
-0.0456541702,
-0.0182848796,
-0.0038627973,
-0.0176251624,
-0.0607907958,
-0.0816768259,
-0.0117801828,
-0.0154012553,
-0.0212090276,
0.0134157492,
1.752156408e-34,
0.0122186067,
-0.034142714,
0.0428905375,
0.0586243905,
0.0000134959,
-0.0370593481,
-0.0001108075,
0.0288665909,
-0.0271875206,
-0.028339887,
0.0052834698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09069v2 | How Well Do Large Language Models Truly Ground? | 2023-11-15T16:11:27 | 2024-06-29T18:07:34 | Hyunji Lee, Sejune Joo, Chaeeun Kim, Joel Jang, Doyoung Kim, Kyoung-Woon On, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | To reduce issues like hallucinations and lack of control in Large Language
Models (LLMs), a common method is to generate responses by grounding on
external contexts given as input, known as knowledge-augmented models. However,
previous research often narrowly defines "grounding" as just having the correct
answer, which does not ensure the reliability of the entire response. To
overcome this, we propose a stricter definition of grounding: a model is truly
grounded if it (1) fully utilizes the necessary knowledge from the provided
context, and (2) stays within the limits of that knowledge. We introduce a new
dataset and a grounding metric to evaluate model capability under the
definition. We perform experiments across 25 LLMs of different sizes and
training methods and provide insights into factors that influence grounding
performance. Our findings contribute to a better understanding of how to
improve grounding capabilities and suggest an area of improvement toward more
reliable and controllable LLM applications. | [
0.0083813742,
0.0407028235,
-0.006448451,
0.0352056623,
-0.012422462,
0.0122689819,
0.0082922541,
0.0034084544,
-0.0086530736,
-0.05791495,
-0.0603628941,
-0.0366333984,
0.0123248408,
0.0006430022,
0.0418278016,
-0.0158875976,
0.0431049913,
-0.0493750162,
-0.0458806567,
-0.0125540225,
-0.0115535352,
0.0093465568,
-0.0090748463,
0.0581419691,
-0.0366600417,
-0.0252282135,
0.0059853322,
-0.0083474992,
-0.0047546024,
-0.0144264689,
-0.0003463925,
0.0628610402,
0.0253385454,
0.0596742406,
0.0000019051,
-0.0481766649,
0.0165884029,
-0.0293345954,
-0.0147127816,
0.0183251239,
0.0022529098,
-0.0256269425,
-0.0012516156,
0.0164960679,
-0.0367284305,
-0.0155943008,
0.0458524972,
0.1047615483,
0.0520975329,
0.0432109311,
-0.0076690922,
-0.0328260623,
0.032178212,
-0.0033699477,
0.0126278941,
-0.012129372,
0.0535926595,
0.0572523549,
-0.0122348443,
-0.0359370597,
-0.0406655297,
0.0227959678,
0.0222276244,
-0.003201968,
0.0092624426,
0.0527739413,
-0.0731848255,
-0.0271580033,
0.0032238753,
0.075065352,
-0.0120702991,
-0.0596178621,
-0.0175524876,
-0.0042814263,
-0.0215767995,
0.0065260604,
-0.0357373059,
0.0327574201,
0.0029979381,
0.0432574898,
0.0151544269,
0.0134928906,
0.0418849774,
0.016414132,
-0.0409519486,
0.1039868444,
0.0176984128,
-0.0517684557,
0.0516673326,
0.0500500314,
-0.0277922004,
-0.0648701191,
0.0015192816,
0.0034681065,
-0.0246189386,
0.0240348931,
-0.0406334139,
-0.0042929375,
0.0143983671,
-0.0737453401,
0.0067427224,
0.0356647149,
-0.0431549102,
0.0389152691,
-0.0430189073,
0.0354719013,
-0.0271626916,
0.0513801798,
0.004829227,
0.0188947096,
-0.0362959653,
-0.0031880571,
-0.0243184566,
0.0117139379,
-0.0209800731,
-0.0327568017,
-0.0195068419,
0.0155625883,
-0.0211557802,
0.0097510004,
-0.0302930344,
0.0176012889,
0.0006968648,
-0.0111481436,
-0.0114806956,
0.0318555571,
-0.0250081178,
0.0387773775,
0.0102901328,
-0.0795630217,
-0.0013691477,
0.0157014839,
-0.0216928665,
-0.0152065363,
-0.0005719175,
0.0308599044,
0.0112284012,
-0.0147604533,
-0.0533741899,
-0.0233640857,
-0.0353687964,
-0.0838892087,
-0.0038760335,
-0.0559873134,
-0.0004426396,
0.0309181735,
0.0086324932,
-0.0564305596,
0.0389604345,
0.0099750618,
-0.0323178694,
0.0912778527,
-0.0131146591,
0.0055726822,
0.0256605633,
0.0323306546,
-0.0064737136,
0.0895836651,
0.0047503072,
-0.0004546247,
0.0177353844,
-0.0205392987,
0.0221497584,
0.0328009874,
0.0258211307,
0.0113963885,
-0.0595864095,
-0.0160114672,
0.0141747706,
0.0124969892,
0.011973273,
0.0531577393,
-0.0130487932,
0.0181750041,
0.0937456489,
0.0503062159,
-0.0326781869,
0.0181192271,
0.0222535636,
-0.0174821448,
-0.0000056961,
0.0186724421,
-0.0877206922,
-0.0081164334,
-0.0371287055,
0.029532617,
0.0272003375,
0.0097661102,
-0.0382673591,
-0.026937034,
-0.0319536626,
0.0025177877,
0.026332153,
0.024727812,
0.0293422174,
0.0130571984,
-0.0358003639,
0.0730714276,
0.0405289754,
-0.0421209149,
0.0095185814,
-0.037484508,
0.0314532071,
0.0429138094,
0.04563348,
-0.0036731453,
-0.0256773569,
-0.0254558157,
0.0674647465,
0.0956371129,
0.0273437854,
0.0161023475,
0.0166603681,
-0.0610061213,
-0.0187828243,
0.0050005936,
0.0329449326,
0.0114248758,
0.0112049393,
0.0067000049,
0.0046934388,
-0.0337353833,
-0.0219754595,
0.0503107645,
-0.0271345656,
-0.0250072051,
-0.0379838422,
-0.0035363147,
0.012508166,
-0.002346853,
-0.0209481046,
0.0218835156,
0.0303268805,
-0.0292933583,
-0.0410519242,
0.0068341722,
-0.0781427845,
0.0134467781,
0.0350602381,
0.0048930645,
0.0026089721,
0.0119028548,
0.0049661789,
-0.0507235751,
0.0139212003,
-0.0309108142,
0.0993226618,
-0.0338519514,
0.034776438,
-0.0177168883,
0.0553501435,
-0.0147112077,
0.0645038411,
-0.0134240789,
0.0263310391,
0.0055022067,
0.0108998753,
-0.0045304019,
-0.0126695614,
-0.0423402563,
0.011704497,
-0.0057425257,
0.0153671196,
-0.0001092724,
-0.0019868326,
-0.0620349608,
0.0022236018,
-0.1057218462,
-0.024531886,
-0.0465122946,
-0.0188043956,
0.0188660733,
-0.0229615252,
-0.0296962429,
-0.0250887685,
-0.0329389907,
0.0057213744,
0.0286932848,
0.0302565768,
-0.0100947935,
0.0071211476,
-0.0484029725,
-0.0286436453,
0.0070021218,
-0.0056582219,
0.0437933914,
-0.0271936338,
-0.0392953157,
-0.0699734762,
0.0847949535,
-0.0601208918,
0.0621318743,
-0.0033688694,
-0.0233902652,
0.0350753814,
-0.0047640335,
0.0444009192,
0.0447773188,
-0.010094584,
0.0306745451,
0.1025768667,
-0.0285925101,
-0.0407255217,
-0.0044328487,
-0.0029047087,
-0.0337846465,
-0.0284472127,
-0.0016312645,
-0.0279355459,
0.0770845264,
0.0302139018,
0.0116217565,
-0.0589943677,
0.0145485997,
-0.0364488438,
-0.0558098517,
-0.0487031676,
-0.0114515144,
-0.0288193058,
0.0711034238,
-0.0372460969,
-0.0681677684,
0.0734500289,
-0.0438140184,
-0.0175112896,
-0.0042004655,
-0.0052427221,
-0.00489979,
0.0343340784,
-0.0129423589,
-0.0029685348,
-0.0147729013,
-0.0104988087,
-0.0339267552,
-0.0441221409,
-0.0259089023,
-0.0246696137,
0.1039556712,
-0.0526606105,
0.0242244918,
0.0118380748,
-0.0247699078,
-0.0792366043,
-0.0026651721,
-0.0398152396,
-0.0067687114,
-0.0323762186,
0.0109160449,
-0.0271665677,
0.0364796929,
0.0419031754,
0.027876256,
-0.0263351798,
-0.0206264202,
-0.0105388137,
-0.0081906021,
0.0663826838,
0.0087855347,
0.053944163,
-0.0400848836,
0.0577478707,
0.0463440232,
0.038339518,
0.0237788185,
-0.0193682164,
0.020282859,
0.0141976885,
0.0138007589,
-0.0050212997,
0.0219794903,
0.0561061017,
-0.0504246093,
-0.0498361997,
0.1295975745,
0.0315055363,
-0.0399532914,
0.0118932649,
-0.0582207739,
0.0415918157,
0.0368660353,
-0.0027029845,
-0.0395281501,
-0.0170051903,
0.0047434941,
0.005791795,
0.0134061547,
-0.0330829173,
-0.0019182903,
-0.1191905364,
0.0107872523,
0.0251173675,
-0.0586111471,
-0.0712045208,
-0.0208364148,
0.0306280199,
0.0204533786,
0.0638146996,
-0.0104813008,
0.0144851832,
-0.0417906456,
0.0189177785,
-0.0118520809,
-0.069275707,
0.0381692909,
-0.041197896,
0.0690528452,
0.0787943378,
0.0033556642,
-0.0018445518,
-0.0613131672,
0.0296610538,
-0.0084342519,
-0.010328427,
0.0030064327,
0.0006699545,
0.0195442587,
-0.0119810821,
0.0210694578,
0.0276068356,
-0.0509143732,
-0.0183522087,
0.0084741721,
0.0843081251,
-0.0501091965,
-0.031623859,
0.0057050651,
0.0449428819,
0.0334213004,
0.0988799334,
0.0657026246,
-0.0429677404,
-0.0198574904,
-0.0253440216,
0.0073254788,
-0.011819113,
-0.0500803925,
0.0222004633,
0.026959965,
0.013530598,
-0.061084576,
-0.0335172117,
0.0391049385,
0.0191546027,
0.0242360625,
0.0199909266,
0.0011926981,
-0.0295517873,
0.0024879186,
0.0478656814,
-0.0424529314,
0.0159330219,
-0.0457256027,
0.00699346,
0.0188288763,
-0.021465892,
-0.0061635212,
0.0321130231,
-0.0517814606,
-0.0790338218,
0.0359611586,
0.0128234653,
0.0320722312,
0.0406186692,
-0.0132906046,
-0.0385084487,
0.0310211461,
-0.0001869563,
-0.0428197086,
0.0412317291,
0.0145138633,
0.003838365,
0.0124001289,
0.043461699,
-0.0367473364,
0.0273409076,
0.0432814397,
0.0395464376,
-0.0139360875,
-0.0040964335,
0.0109957773,
-0.0148026953,
0.0337357111,
-0.0090599833,
-0.0010336913,
-0.0257771686,
0.0006500102,
-0.0396081023,
-0.0028183586,
-0.0273818932,
-0.0181879755,
0.0237887781,
0.0028567759,
0.0076439059,
-0.0351640843,
-0.0390540436,
0.0474147573,
-0.0129320901,
-0.0157230664,
-0.01813462,
-0.0142852664,
0.0420694612,
0.0166013576,
-0.0420184471,
0.0147951022,
0.0128661031,
0.0242101047,
0.0061924108,
0.0895826444,
0.0031853849,
-0.0173497181,
-0.0188637022,
0.0087410053,
-0.0558014065,
-0.0354566388,
-0.019547319,
0.0503668115,
0.0494464114,
-0.0189873707,
0.0675663501,
-0.02941145,
0.0018248223,
-0.0231774151,
0.0220996607,
0.0348146856,
-0.0382259265,
0.0352420397,
0.0291966498,
-0.0278324634,
0.0189594999,
0.0536022671,
0.0136364847,
0.0639413595,
0.0041533192,
0.0044723907,
-0.0318759941,
-0.018880289,
-0.0026013392,
0.0056184414,
-0.0400067158,
0.027851155,
-0.0790884793,
-0.0944856331,
-0.0252932124,
0.0115980608,
-0.0109920958,
-0.0185253099,
0.0280954856,
0.052528739,
-0.0035641082,
0.00425553,
-0.0090074474,
-0.0036717025,
-0.0024324961,
-0.0053297603,
-0.0429908298,
-6.433626049e-33,
-0.047128506,
-0.0208621379,
0.015469512,
-0.0304811634,
-0.0300734825,
0.0134856319,
-0.0446471684,
0.0348799266,
-0.0133223664,
0.0095694168,
-0.0135997906,
0.0251458492,
0.0147006987,
0.0313301012,
0.0057842908,
-0.0231775735,
0.0304281153,
-0.0034202868,
-0.0146647487,
0.0070533329,
0.0387386009,
0.007213329,
0.0634087995,
-0.0736535937,
0.0277914982,
0.0024971259,
-0.0225057919,
0.0046345736,
-0.0319414437,
0.0716574267,
-0.0539037101,
0.069111906,
0.0224559177,
-0.049976863,
-0.0328453481,
0.0282516908,
-0.0321345776,
-0.02934088,
0.0339385495,
0.0258821603,
-0.0037473785,
0.0096391505,
0.0553208701,
-0.0147951683,
-0.0056387079,
0.0127442051,
0.014384266,
-0.0397352092,
-0.0211426783,
0.0112129245,
-0.0698576421,
-0.0042423629,
0.0203786939,
-0.0346531272,
-0.0088804662,
0.0170101896,
-0.0170817114,
-0.020214662,
-0.0580782071,
-0.0019856764,
0.0198698193,
0.0120407678,
0.0824684426,
0.0200098101,
0.0017152656,
0.0719884411,
-0.0107224835,
0.0071098185,
-0.0520187207,
-0.0500292964,
0.0600635521,
0.0298785437,
0.054601334,
0.002021658,
-0.0051887445,
-0.0111157075,
-0.0423741937,
-0.0175825786,
-0.0087685892,
0.0481820628,
0.0666774288,
0.0035372535,
-0.0524458513,
-0.0419248566,
-0.024623042,
-0.0126314051,
-0.0351148322,
-0.0285791177,
0.066655919,
-0.0071048215,
-0.0091471067,
-0.014888498,
0.0342925489,
-0.0547899157,
0.0022425626,
0.0542628951,
0.0008479628,
0.0200187452,
0.0017931174,
0.0044504153,
-0.0451583266,
-0.0194827132,
0.0210585576,
0.0005297528,
0.0154347392,
-0.0070766415,
0.0163329244,
-0.0041155084,
-0.0664059892,
-0.0022888612,
-0.0405512415,
0.0248905122,
0.02489236,
0.0313477926,
0.051959455,
-0.0035338115,
-0.0102288155,
0.0109938644,
0.0097751971,
-0.0233215634,
0.0016820974,
-0.0249946676,
-0.0311838854,
0.046535708,
-0.0475573875,
-0.0114307031,
-0.0432604775,
-0.0156220542,
0.0638125092,
-0.0199479405,
-0.0146745546,
-0.0100820931,
2.548e-7,
0.0303830206,
0.0365549028,
0.0061590318,
0.0203627069,
0.0052495943,
0.0237424821,
-0.0239376798,
0.0116527444,
0.0229666233,
-0.0696086138,
-0.034126617,
0.0309904721,
0.0765421689,
0.0269359462,
-0.0750955641,
-0.0305287559,
-0.0665361211,
0.0190379787,
-0.055264689,
-0.0278557092,
0.0208263695,
0.0953989625,
0.0064458572,
-0.0140981302,
-0.0019911765,
-0.0465088822,
0.055659838,
-0.0424315743,
0.0106428107,
-0.0053886645,
0.0410088077,
0.0277887806,
0.0065159961,
0.0539158545,
-0.0031801146,
0.0210394636,
-0.0080177831,
0.0301199574,
-0.0017356358,
-0.0255083013,
-0.0355631523,
0.0076597272,
0.0040739118,
-0.0861800313,
0.0595453158,
-0.0465281531,
-0.0047445311,
-0.0095515195,
0.0223879851,
-0.0373953879,
0.03789993,
-0.026595192,
-0.0372019596,
0.0049440064,
0.0310862213,
0.0097139692,
-0.0237590708,
-0.0737536177,
-0.0272161122,
0.0225972161,
-0.0369777083,
-0.0480079688,
-0.01212293,
-0.0246953107,
-0.0015354835,
-0.0562360287,
-0.0096337106,
2.554766157e-34,
0.0195610635,
-0.0066356473,
0.0371034108,
0.0263362322,
0.0208644215,
-0.0202939175,
0.0260203164,
0.0098910686,
-0.0114872186,
-0.0803666115,
0.0023344015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09066v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09066v3 | Identifying Self-Disclosures of Use, Misuse and Addiction in Community-based Social Media Posts | 2023-11-15T16:05:55 | 2024-06-13T21:15:26 | Chenghao Yang, Tuhin Chakrabarty, Karli R Hochstatter, Melissa N Slavin, Nabila El-Bassel, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the last decade, the United States has lost more than 500,000 people from
an overdose involving prescription and illicit opioids making it a national
public health emergency (USDHHS, 2017). Medical practitioners require robust
and timely tools that can effectively identify at-risk patients.
Community-based social media platforms such as Reddit allow self-disclosure for
users to discuss otherwise sensitive drug-related behaviors. We present a
moderate size corpus of 2500 opioid-related posts from various subreddits
labeled with six different phases of opioid use: Medical Use, Misuse,
Addiction, Recovery, Relapse, Not Using. For every post, we annotate span-level
extractive explanations and crucially study their role both in annotation
quality and model development. We evaluate several state-of-the-art models in a
supervised, few-shot, or zero-shot setting. Experimental results and error
analysis show that identifying the phases of opioid use disorder is highly
contextual and challenging. However, we find that using explanations during
modeling leads to a significant boost in classification accuracy demonstrating
their beneficial role in a high-stakes domain such as studying the opioid use
disorder continuum. | [
0.0592762418,
0.0647110939,
-0.0058454331,
-0.0177662708,
-0.0030075279,
0.0247479025,
0.0125934454,
-0.0083357506,
0.0227979776,
-0.0435102358,
0.0335556045,
0.0385215357,
-0.0615235195,
0.0247569606,
0.0175439268,
-0.0238477699,
-0.0111946417,
0.0534931719,
0.0275072996,
0.0323170722,
0.0493573062,
0.0299719162,
-0.0073492713,
0.0199895166,
0.0102700936,
-0.0388209149,
0.0120089008,
-0.0240980722,
0.0316188261,
-0.0618991926,
0.0308118612,
0.0684815869,
0.0163808484,
0.0004028891,
0.000001633,
-0.0039118305,
-0.007426871,
0.0014585536,
-0.0602638535,
-0.0431106649,
0.0269429032,
-0.0531132929,
0.0566007569,
-0.0011018544,
-0.0470476672,
-0.017622469,
0.065901354,
0.0524542928,
0.0249276441,
0.0424173437,
-0.0425483547,
-0.0210494809,
-0.03441903,
-0.0212068148,
0.0255633816,
-0.017246889,
0.0278898235,
-0.018007461,
0.0170103423,
0.0065039834,
0.0279233493,
0.038755741,
-0.0202555452,
-0.0071418923,
0.068640925,
0.0213576686,
0.0136994859,
-0.0493266732,
0.0129424185,
0.0776517093,
0.0269237608,
0.0089017237,
0.0520581566,
-0.0006659892,
-0.0155537762,
0.0479923114,
-0.0322474502,
-0.0334974863,
-0.0176442489,
0.0392312072,
-0.0109984484,
0.0261366256,
0.0456868894,
0.014687134,
0.0254160929,
-0.0081683975,
-0.0242928974,
0.0074296365,
-0.0126309386,
-0.0169320442,
-0.0118998904,
-0.0501394235,
0.0312716812,
-0.0045741424,
-0.0152697256,
0.0324853063,
0.0110116079,
-0.007214983,
0.0476411246,
-0.038646508,
0.0093395216,
-0.0099970419,
-0.0385305546,
0.0343460217,
0.027523404,
-0.0503889434,
0.0303860679,
0.0086141843,
-0.0034384325,
0.0218726993,
-0.06795118,
0.0073892991,
-0.0097252047,
0.0137127666,
0.0086631961,
0.0061846087,
-0.0388021804,
0.0176953208,
-0.0295799281,
-0.031513378,
-0.0450501293,
0.0075162607,
-0.0110544749,
0.0287790652,
0.0074154292,
0.0241391659,
-0.0179043636,
0.0167512726,
0.055970192,
0.025998123,
-0.0073905252,
-0.0043951091,
0.0724846944,
-0.0559206791,
-0.0241889507,
0.0117766568,
0.0580559932,
0.0001268621,
-0.027174836,
-0.0455949865,
-0.0411871187,
-0.0072463471,
-0.0114735151,
-0.0284944214,
0.0647702143,
0.0106002158,
-0.0136524718,
-0.031133743,
0.022379104,
-0.0026898135,
-0.0450226814,
0.0617455952,
-0.0376443118,
0.0484210066,
0.0236821156,
0.0307294689,
0.0407648496,
0.0248526093,
0.0119940098,
0.0497479737,
0.0437270738,
-0.0655892193,
0.0091252849,
-0.0205459502,
0.0351219326,
-0.0560852699,
0.0338726491,
-0.0058223703,
0.0067530577,
-0.0147742266,
-0.0381908156,
0.0227236506,
-0.0126238838,
0.0292094219,
0.0273371339,
0.0694983378,
0.0223965216,
0.0104905963,
0.0268316418,
0.008261269,
-0.0284211673,
-0.0115125505,
-0.0640139952,
-0.0170161575,
0.0008320745,
-0.0249133948,
0.0452267118,
-0.0429309234,
-0.0085761584,
-0.020743845,
-0.0509941317,
-0.0329037197,
-0.0391196311,
0.0122800535,
0.0059944377,
-0.0047848667,
-0.0010970207,
0.0493093431,
0.0531856306,
-0.032257393,
-0.0218977723,
-0.0277766306,
0.0529460609,
0.0518793799,
0.0237968881,
-0.0302336589,
-0.0064983731,
-0.0374753475,
0.072431393,
0.0201516729,
0.0112549299,
-0.0196637474,
-0.0015856964,
0.0338593982,
-0.0283877887,
-0.0002642014,
-0.0175629333,
-0.0539454147,
-0.0116278147,
-0.0367822461,
-0.0095658936,
-0.0225783661,
-0.0318257883,
0.044885125,
0.0153360004,
-0.0474512763,
0.0099962223,
0.0214958508,
0.0529908724,
0.0213036891,
0.0321621522,
-0.0004370442,
0.0215510204,
-0.0257505868,
-0.0598866567,
-0.037948925,
-0.0149087049,
-0.006620829,
0.0265929028,
-0.0174450446,
0.0367328823,
-0.0247566123,
-0.0443066172,
-0.0300396308,
0.0389181003,
-0.0215930119,
0.03027853,
-0.0344166569,
-0.0479634553,
0.0138812456,
0.0125550181,
-0.0283430461,
0.0505935922,
-0.0230326392,
0.0182296336,
-0.0746193603,
-0.1010633782,
-0.0592732355,
-0.0042425385,
0.0302513894,
-0.0442083813,
-0.0497468449,
-0.0047129067,
0.0334305838,
0.0013537186,
-0.011978792,
-0.0051334775,
-0.0622123443,
-0.0034150595,
-0.03640984,
0.0108597912,
0.0210856795,
0.0226412397,
0.0150504438,
-0.0477028303,
-0.0020946367,
-0.0184899289,
0.0034960543,
0.0263913088,
0.0101018213,
0.057704486,
0.0291564986,
-0.0218869019,
-0.0237239916,
-0.0448558107,
0.046170745,
0.0085707642,
-0.0786921531,
0.0072956393,
-0.0184727181,
-0.030800581,
-0.0094292639,
-0.0038175648,
-0.0078297351,
0.0127211343,
-0.0014228954,
0.0088567259,
-0.0060413913,
0.0162214953,
0.079784967,
0.0320975222,
0.0328697003,
-0.0120800817,
0.0054014004,
-0.0839030966,
-0.0443994477,
0.00743713,
-0.0541672893,
0.018221179,
0.0859517902,
0.0218453594,
0.004939694,
-0.0180423204,
-0.0185589623,
-0.0103438497,
-0.0311129037,
-0.0264965184,
-0.0281817019,
-0.0108977212,
0.0217311271,
-0.0375032499,
-0.0446680449,
0.0512736477,
0.0497674458,
0.0324771702,
0.027480524,
-0.0376569591,
-0.0342412926,
-0.0120258313,
0.0402210876,
0.0167772993,
0.0449486785,
-0.0118174395,
0.1137168705,
-0.0119656716,
0.0197278969,
-0.0385600999,
0.0090769213,
-0.0059236526,
0.035615664,
-0.0105131324,
-0.0532262214,
-0.0236995965,
-0.1086528972,
-0.027154753,
-0.0264435001,
-0.017857274,
-0.007174578,
0.0059182076,
0.0317768268,
-0.0280855019,
0.0203993712,
-0.0092469333,
-0.0215917267,
0.0166281406,
0.0210476965,
0.0612116978,
-0.0081540411,
0.0118209338,
0.0090481304,
0.0398671851,
0.0462754071,
-0.0010257926,
0.0260696989,
-0.0033647767,
0.0028967231,
-0.0062769493,
-0.0356038362,
0.0062423614,
0.0206768084,
0.0285125691,
-0.0068575931,
-0.0014823163,
0.0549653545,
0.0338621438,
-0.0404947661,
0.0396040305,
-0.0125501668,
-0.0199112054,
0.0023874701,
-0.0059426902,
-0.1208225787,
-0.0199846253,
-0.0710420832,
0.0305779222,
-0.0489159562,
-0.0300169811,
0.0151413744,
-0.0500850305,
0.0490819328,
-0.0100146513,
-0.0808678791,
0.0123291761,
-0.073175244,
0.0166718587,
-0.036154069,
-0.0163959023,
-0.0105626322,
-0.024826007,
-0.0109993638,
0.0693064928,
-0.0632432252,
-0.0589582138,
0.0110923322,
-0.0203037523,
0.0256058928,
-0.0120434165,
0.0261695702,
0.0005524696,
-0.0125356056,
0.0120622218,
0.0094031459,
0.0165440403,
0.016558826,
0.1065575629,
-0.0235734265,
0.0092019672,
-0.0837476999,
0.0797264427,
-0.0704198554,
-0.063609302,
-0.0435593612,
0.1123264953,
-0.0135369804,
-0.0277448446,
-0.0048071193,
0.0271078944,
0.0615496635,
0.0438682586,
0.0694559738,
0.0095019806,
-0.0313222632,
0.005932732,
0.0136712678,
-0.0501799174,
-0.0141530056,
-0.0385235287,
0.0349183306,
-0.0162100159,
-0.0083045159,
-0.0391639285,
0.0146503514,
-0.0576400459,
-0.0124643063,
-0.0092348745,
0.0029079264,
-0.0260382313,
-0.0258131605,
0.0540675409,
0.0138728712,
0.0013764831,
-0.0069265203,
-0.0299235769,
-0.0035951755,
0.0185173042,
0.0213408079,
0.0382351801,
-0.0407784991,
-0.0107079828,
0.0738021657,
-0.022166431,
0.0157882441,
0.0036465738,
-0.0331112631,
-0.0666008219,
0.0020204317,
0.0624149516,
-0.0257213507,
-0.0638872683,
0.022965638,
0.0391556658,
0.0033636629,
0.027596008,
0.0037755305,
-0.0068771192,
0.0141366133,
-0.0424560867,
-0.0914338008,
0.008612629,
0.0110155949,
-0.0216402877,
0.0606860556,
-0.0080319643,
0.0201108847,
-0.0477511957,
-0.0510565117,
-0.0108195618,
-0.0114409002,
0.0186118018,
-0.0085530719,
0.0381056853,
-0.0642963648,
-0.0322079659,
0.0158332735,
-0.066875644,
0.003944498,
-0.0994343236,
0.0159870777,
0.0510026664,
-0.0028456589,
-0.0153630776,
0.0156454872,
-0.0193957016,
-0.0013932022,
0.0180925969,
0.0597774424,
-0.0140677616,
0.0609139092,
-0.0258517973,
-0.0077720033,
0.0317889191,
0.0396834724,
-0.0525966771,
-0.0020139101,
0.0068714391,
0.0012184639,
0.0224033426,
-0.0403919779,
0.0505711809,
0.0104422476,
-0.0193843376,
0.0047238586,
0.0995999128,
-0.0244980734,
-0.0388617925,
0.0267995335,
0.0294898059,
-0.0457098968,
0.000645443,
0.056745559,
-0.0182118583,
-0.0135167427,
0.0253797714,
-0.0191832744,
-0.0102832979,
0.0166573822,
-0.0626871809,
0.0466826484,
-0.0254680589,
0.0280884653,
-0.0614606515,
-0.0600654036,
0.0071138325,
-0.0349919163,
-0.0096323695,
0.0297132749,
-0.0097610038,
0.0410524495,
0.0306601673,
-0.0512661375,
-0.0746994987,
0.0339742526,
0.0053198282,
-0.0036423395,
-0.0299838502,
-5.566623661e-33,
0.0388661064,
-0.0561695136,
-0.0417066664,
-0.0260635801,
0.0050973161,
0.0146838706,
-0.0344678648,
0.0145833464,
0.0033225317,
0.0239781942,
0.0081036314,
0.004329632,
0.0145337945,
0.0320524983,
0.0317358263,
-0.0197190195,
0.0171541478,
0.0201245919,
-0.0023207623,
0.059503261,
0.0565718412,
0.0676844642,
0.0251558349,
-0.0787443966,
0.0863359049,
0.0106870243,
0.0261583924,
0.0220334269,
0.0110990908,
0.0300633386,
-0.0647203848,
0.0533241928,
0.047278434,
0.0091210278,
0.0169721507,
0.0392775312,
-0.0925099328,
-0.0313101895,
0.0174513403,
-0.0487541892,
-0.0642025396,
-0.0437433235,
0.0451815017,
-0.006872131,
0.034382768,
-0.0365078077,
0.0637654811,
0.0118668806,
0.004982213,
-0.016665671,
-0.0188894998,
0.0286885593,
-0.0353731103,
-0.0218968205,
-0.0258044712,
0.044855196,
-0.0023087314,
0.0503252819,
-0.0451624356,
-0.0211743936,
-0.0131555796,
0.0116808852,
0.0179236643,
-0.0076573598,
-0.0038670136,
0.0415290333,
-0.015496254,
0.0071857208,
-0.0345187858,
0.0370145254,
-0.0720619038,
0.0783370063,
0.0359463356,
0.0235899445,
0.0362016559,
0.0161926597,
-0.0643610284,
-0.0258911587,
-0.0364776738,
0.0291046239,
0.0337230712,
-0.0131819844,
-0.046885673,
-0.0029823768,
0.0009704345,
-0.0493670106,
-0.0112107769,
0.0026801862,
-0.042304799,
-0.0233314186,
-0.0467194431,
0.0504588075,
-0.0192924496,
-0.0348905623,
-0.0388902724,
-0.0103760269,
0.0301412325,
0.0048667127,
0.004278461,
-0.0198290627,
-0.0447808318,
0.0394347124,
-0.0107245985,
-0.005801246,
0.0410508178,
-0.0008639705,
0.0809189752,
-0.0090470575,
-0.0035342171,
-0.0330944359,
-0.0027240936,
0.027536964,
-0.0124912225,
0.0452652015,
0.0315220021,
0.0713135079,
-0.0027534401,
0.0525129475,
0.0244750883,
0.0206600241,
-0.0066312873,
-0.0282040797,
-0.0319813415,
0.0009092598,
0.0131944362,
-0.0059597199,
-0.0117875896,
0.046061825,
0.0599066354,
-0.0334168784,
0.0181094538,
-0.0207486991,
2.413e-7,
0.0853338614,
-0.0018334707,
0.0107072117,
-0.0260293391,
0.0215733461,
0.0059052655,
0.0477003343,
0.0144782895,
-0.0003431397,
-0.0391235501,
0.0221984535,
0.0559252277,
0.0430704728,
0.0536584444,
0.018495664,
-0.0121596903,
-0.0601971745,
-0.0304140653,
-0.0656616762,
-0.0079937931,
0.0412971489,
0.039560426,
0.0349328928,
-0.0299989823,
-0.0013908023,
-0.0172148384,
0.0196458939,
-0.0508626364,
-0.0229652468,
0.0154022817,
0.0319614783,
-0.0099694068,
0.0070452709,
-0.0055219973,
-0.0536354929,
-0.0125812553,
-0.0180769637,
0.0625088811,
-0.0455185175,
-0.0385803618,
-0.0216223076,
-0.0420004427,
0.0482390039,
-0.0045841429,
0.0941876769,
-0.0680059344,
-0.0323314779,
-0.076971516,
0.0028935312,
-0.0255621467,
0.0407289043,
-0.0198642425,
-0.0449380875,
0.0422155187,
0.0052985642,
0.0101235956,
-0.0076465323,
-0.0852266401,
-0.0199687276,
0.0519016981,
-0.0260848235,
0.013136222,
0.0534210354,
-0.0073557724,
-0.0058142971,
-0.042886164,
0.013677638,
1.544136037e-34,
-0.0420267172,
0.0396063514,
-0.0023143929,
-0.0017373883,
0.0396001376,
0.0020750584,
-0.03346752,
-0.0366642475,
0.0145120835,
-0.0584192909,
0.0006090142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09060v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09060v2 | Do Localization Methods Actually Localize Memorized Data in LLMs? A Tale of Two Benchmarks | 2023-11-15T15:52:40 | 2024-04-02T06:32:40 | Ting-Yun Chang, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | The concept of localization in LLMs is often mentioned in prior work;
however, methods for localization have never been systematically and directly
evaluated. We propose two complementary benchmarks that evaluate the ability of
localization methods to pinpoint LLM components responsible for memorized data.
In our INJ benchmark, we actively inject a piece of new information into a
small subset of LLM weights, enabling us to directly evaluate whether
localization methods can identify these "ground truth" weights. In our DEL
benchmark, we evaluate localization by measuring how much dropping out
identified neurons deletes a memorized pretrained sequence. Despite their
different perspectives, our two benchmarks yield consistent rankings of five
localization methods. Methods adapted from network pruning perform well on both
benchmarks, and all evaluated methods show promising localization ability. On
the other hand, even successful methods identify neurons that are not specific
to a single memorized sequence. | [
-0.0209236313,
0.0347535871,
0.0106334817,
0.044533357,
-0.0306616966,
0.0092078708,
0.0212864932,
0.0203083139,
-0.0191139206,
0.0267232228,
-0.0549537949,
-0.0048539261,
0.024416253,
-0.0713678375,
0.0331640728,
0.0297670141,
0.0479105078,
0.034916386,
-0.0704265386,
-0.0014421687,
-0.0382129587,
-0.0395623855,
0.0127404928,
0.0455014259,
0.038607955,
0.0030820372,
-0.0227440782,
0.0459839813,
0.0620255396,
-0.0560968891,
0.0133165475,
0.0109418472,
0.0261126645,
-0.0021615394,
0.0000017745,
-0.0025190748,
0.0072193635,
-0.019466253,
-0.045345366,
0.0389265865,
-0.0560483411,
0.0278469305,
0.0115483962,
0.0198055115,
-0.002533196,
-0.0151020465,
-0.0014141133,
-0.0257527567,
0.0121855242,
0.1062756702,
0.0057690511,
-0.0157185514,
-0.0197951756,
-0.0510689989,
0.0616877787,
-0.0063902466,
0.0007871425,
-0.0054767514,
-0.0200684294,
-0.0525714643,
0.0179339945,
0.0359463878,
0.0204968937,
0.0606777258,
0.0093868896,
0.0400490798,
0.0234494582,
0.037920218,
-0.005584463,
0.0088913357,
-0.0309012346,
-0.0217607673,
0.0238610692,
-0.0002566423,
0.0593890324,
-0.0632881299,
-0.040241506,
0.0180164836,
0.0131316567,
0.0384660102,
-0.0269688964,
0.0083691226,
0.0399034284,
-0.0059774015,
-0.0497437492,
0.0718353987,
-0.0002578961,
0.0006016938,
-0.039481245,
0.0281420872,
0.0167554598,
-0.0394634642,
0.0666708499,
0.0569248572,
0.0221592654,
0.0193639845,
-0.0196089279,
0.0247135665,
-0.0035132437,
-0.0384519063,
0.0507109351,
0.0699789152,
-0.025314074,
0.011807045,
-0.0729709268,
0.0259876829,
-0.017237572,
0.0329485349,
-0.051953651,
0.0143725425,
-0.0220598914,
0.0024605806,
0.0199991483,
0.0552555248,
0.0377956033,
-0.020741269,
-0.0466269851,
0.0229014084,
-0.0109857824,
-0.0074989456,
-0.0345450006,
0.0312884673,
-0.0078675626,
0.0353005566,
-0.001749842,
0.0199934505,
-0.0434241667,
0.042741891,
0.0168863181,
-0.0133361472,
-0.0567320623,
0.0533957742,
-0.0037522966,
-0.0161833577,
0.0497406609,
0.0578366891,
0.0099948477,
-0.0645961761,
-0.0749694854,
-0.000674462,
-0.0099623064,
-0.0274533071,
0.0615519732,
-0.0705593601,
-0.0182859991,
-0.0095134843,
0.0002550082,
-0.0623015314,
0.0166879594,
0.0116765909,
-0.0132823037,
0.0599403419,
0.0124377515,
-0.0280773975,
-0.0078623304,
0.0158371925,
0.0113482336,
0.0007040456,
0.0102104666,
0.1068118438,
0.0026767373,
0.0066790325,
0.0015676838,
0.0301397424,
0.0555059686,
-0.0174576566,
-0.0659586787,
-0.0507199802,
0.0059732427,
0.0230401885,
0.0371860228,
0.0073295105,
-0.0343327858,
0.0088091707,
0.0582975075,
0.0913403779,
0.0068189474,
-0.0187626258,
0.02730822,
-0.0380036458,
-0.004398115,
0.0177157708,
-0.0546437427,
0.0549977198,
-0.0448666178,
-0.0159653537,
0.0207154267,
0.0282598082,
-0.0227948427,
-0.0119419694,
-0.0363368168,
-0.0227284171,
-0.0374498256,
0.0234155022,
0.0092367735,
0.0012932459,
-0.0035655706,
0.0841333121,
0.0037645467,
-0.0137272161,
0.0007583033,
-0.0196521282,
-0.0219251309,
0.015852835,
-0.0102637038,
-0.0309232026,
-0.0605070591,
0.0177816637,
0.0162435938,
-0.0010020352,
-0.0312959179,
0.0253398139,
0.0419701785,
-0.0404088162,
-0.053095147,
-0.0140044149,
-0.0203673765,
0.0419402532,
0.0279998817,
0.0189122278,
0.0210311506,
-0.0412929282,
0.0116474638,
0.0319640152,
-0.0109343575,
-0.0145235499,
0.0301021971,
-0.0114023648,
0.0055320892,
0.0078101619,
0.0109573156,
0.0081916479,
0.073283352,
-0.024749361,
0.0435417108,
-0.0162800774,
-0.0877550095,
-0.0522353835,
0.0929513872,
-0.0228582304,
-0.0027644734,
0.0109685054,
-0.036317233,
-0.0496892333,
-0.0078763068,
-0.0212192107,
-0.004805543,
-0.0229155384,
0.0141570764,
0.0171112306,
0.0128425574,
-0.0492305681,
0.0255702734,
-0.0583767742,
0.0055189612,
0.0184098762,
0.0028159367,
0.029420482,
-0.0695042908,
-0.0397913679,
-0.0023549567,
-0.0217948705,
-0.0041620969,
-0.0211668797,
0.0000312542,
-0.0228432696,
-0.0126118781,
-0.047123719,
0.0389631316,
-0.0134643447,
0.0307277963,
0.027017219,
-0.0309048966,
0.0126049854,
-0.0345467739,
-0.047191985,
0.0200851001,
-0.0098451646,
0.0049002548,
0.0405215137,
-0.0171416271,
-0.0196774397,
-0.0195149649,
-0.0255408231,
0.0147513142,
0.0253703836,
-0.0698328465,
-0.0680290684,
-0.0784982294,
0.0143169034,
-0.0545749515,
0.0064028455,
-0.0020155034,
-0.014315852,
0.0523065403,
-0.0139349131,
-0.0083836531,
0.0657949299,
-0.0482281931,
0.0216731969,
0.0429872088,
-0.0031927319,
-0.0469298735,
-0.0225281157,
-0.0217769276,
0.0134066902,
-0.0545525849,
-0.0200944524,
-0.021710733,
0.0572493449,
0.0027368725,
0.0086492542,
0.0129058184,
-0.0087700393,
0.0097209737,
-0.0255891029,
-0.0489166789,
0.0193918049,
-0.0553256162,
0.0302364472,
-0.0121581089,
-0.0510960743,
0.0040437435,
-0.0342315026,
0.0397304259,
0.0427192748,
-0.0689442381,
0.0248573031,
0.0164888725,
0.0533075817,
0.0239481628,
-0.0528587252,
-0.0363524593,
-0.0251086708,
-0.0150091806,
-0.0368284844,
-0.0111803627,
0.0044273324,
-0.0390781797,
-0.0126513876,
-0.0102352966,
-0.0113710715,
-0.0219671056,
0.0863832012,
0.0092873443,
0.0099618621,
-0.0028483875,
-0.0149286669,
-0.0214805398,
-0.0244881995,
0.0373830684,
0.0543314517,
-0.0079991641,
0.0391761288,
-0.0386276357,
0.0168049373,
-0.018403763,
0.0138233826,
0.0241058413,
-0.0108733969,
-0.0425254665,
0.0705917329,
0.0295617711,
0.0090485699,
-0.0672602057,
0.0182693545,
0.0276198089,
-0.0567659736,
-0.0164173078,
0.016102856,
0.072358638,
-0.0238568448,
-0.031805519,
0.0678423718,
0.0271217171,
-0.1024853289,
-0.0132519277,
0.0297637619,
-0.0104917251,
0.0642906576,
-0.0097588468,
-0.0185098927,
-0.0285378359,
0.0451989695,
0.0097918781,
0.0192856081,
0.0046904953,
0.026625704,
-0.0583861023,
-0.0027053754,
0.0236656852,
-0.0495901406,
-0.0110522946,
0.0009554942,
-0.0272655562,
0.0201848242,
0.0423986614,
0.0129711553,
-0.0071283984,
0.0048803547,
0.0454892144,
-0.0367622301,
-0.007698684,
-0.0265009478,
-0.021614274,
0.0186033081,
0.0299644247,
0.0068917503,
0.0276298299,
-0.0650962666,
0.0706043914,
0.0246921126,
0.0362543948,
-0.0319196656,
0.0335419588,
0.0164704416,
-0.025169434,
-0.0229494199,
0.0191280637,
-0.0399818383,
-0.0333791636,
-0.0137312803,
0.0358760469,
-0.0420034528,
0.0447106659,
0.0136453547,
-0.0071301926,
-0.0394201688,
0.0159370657,
0.0750144497,
-0.0106019108,
-0.0252712592,
-0.0277694426,
0.0394402295,
-0.0170811918,
-0.0179658905,
0.0123614846,
-0.0173581336,
-0.0196727011,
-0.0584280193,
-0.0213267282,
0.026240807,
0.0478900671,
0.0036191812,
-0.0230913814,
-0.019794818,
-0.0630535185,
-0.0575546362,
0.0284917988,
-0.0596500114,
0.0020797255,
-0.0433246754,
0.0065378291,
0.0372623168,
-0.0096635297,
-0.0064386572,
0.0153195299,
-0.0869346708,
-0.0516506582,
-0.004548646,
0.0536519587,
0.019307049,
0.0175335482,
0.0203674901,
0.0064896089,
0.0774723068,
-0.0004956601,
0.0314416215,
0.0685678348,
0.0226064213,
-0.0299085658,
-0.0199346617,
0.0036294092,
-0.0156296771,
0.0067619001,
0.062534079,
0.0317534432,
-0.0267802421,
-0.0142007498,
-0.0126603302,
0.0294476841,
0.0650377423,
0.0137230437,
0.0034266203,
0.0092732627,
0.0231824238,
0.0266665425,
-0.0019675768,
-0.0238209907,
-0.0316692591,
0.0817096159,
0.0473550595,
0.0023687095,
-0.011934991,
0.0416688137,
-0.0000262855,
0.0055962829,
-0.0249082409,
0.0061788554,
0.0116326762,
-0.0130780376,
0.0473300666,
-0.0125221703,
0.0772852749,
0.0249337293,
0.0539717935,
-0.0046810973,
-0.014462227,
0.0173813663,
0.0577909164,
-0.0816197395,
0.0449809656,
-0.0525994822,
-0.0576930158,
-0.0271474533,
0.0147303836,
0.1063787863,
0.0028180315,
0.0389040634,
0.0179496296,
-0.0294449925,
0.0005034834,
0.0341955535,
-0.0227924883,
-0.0130848633,
-0.0233969316,
-0.0108536808,
-0.0184700582,
-0.0053112726,
0.0578769967,
-0.0046992796,
0.0628809854,
-0.0306205507,
-0.0365980826,
-0.0175700486,
-0.044687096,
0.0499842055,
0.0160045642,
-0.0103661874,
-0.056106288,
0.016297102,
-0.0672791228,
0.0255270377,
0.0079891039,
-0.0047390671,
-0.0300463978,
0.0246870797,
-0.0092459824,
0.0179935321,
0.0055359155,
0.0215672888,
-0.0094325235,
0.0256755818,
-0.0513788909,
0.0210355185,
-6.043588575e-33,
-0.0472168326,
-0.0418147966,
0.0151599878,
0.0137417763,
-0.0122151086,
0.0073092072,
-0.0287828855,
0.0235053096,
0.0221659727,
-0.0084525878,
-0.0093063321,
0.0059215883,
0.0276457947,
-0.0060495161,
-0.0309700873,
-0.019202631,
-0.0005168627,
-0.0198461004,
-0.014908378,
-0.0247178786,
0.0457504876,
0.0539916493,
0.1204279512,
-0.0032177288,
-0.0196137428,
0.0410461314,
-0.025487965,
0.0220415499,
-0.065398939,
-0.0169363562,
-0.0156946015,
0.0039097653,
-0.0127802175,
-0.0373873338,
-0.0317009278,
-0.0805145279,
-0.0597868152,
-0.0366791338,
-0.0296743009,
0.0236018784,
0.0071445163,
-0.0550223663,
0.1030931026,
-0.0064852545,
-0.0404004529,
0.0381128341,
0.0181507021,
-0.0145186111,
-0.0831350535,
-0.0180607289,
-0.0187403746,
-0.0062594176,
0.0259650424,
-0.0002501965,
0.0129843615,
-0.0287802331,
-0.0306033231,
0.0045459466,
-0.0914852843,
-0.0506702214,
0.0259840377,
0.06688907,
0.0455191284,
0.0511309616,
0.0253300313,
0.0584201105,
0.101835385,
0.0091207456,
0.0328260139,
-0.0054659583,
0.0352352075,
-0.0037933567,
0.0408925563,
-0.0110657243,
0.0493887998,
-0.0252985358,
-0.0719429329,
0.036160022,
-0.0048970324,
0.021378547,
-0.0044474183,
0.0363927074,
0.0513049699,
-0.0061466405,
0.0010238909,
-0.0574116819,
-0.0223529208,
-0.0285011362,
0.0187854618,
0.0252461527,
-0.0199452303,
0.0040040226,
0.0223710798,
-0.0175615344,
0.0296477433,
0.0087239705,
0.022768762,
0.0087971305,
0.0342577472,
-0.0334137529,
-0.0796398968,
-0.0103885056,
-0.0388752259,
-0.0485424213,
0.0300718807,
-0.0034871043,
0.0323453471,
0.0275297128,
-0.0050164536,
0.0179148801,
-0.0570810847,
-0.0079941014,
-0.0155226663,
0.0505445041,
0.059368778,
-0.0561549813,
0.0073438436,
0.0377955697,
0.0036374782,
-0.0174095463,
0.0043922402,
-0.0202984344,
0.0097181657,
0.0547892042,
-0.0318353064,
0.0113299489,
-0.0454583466,
0.0564678274,
0.020014137,
-0.0310431384,
-0.0123313293,
-0.0020139243,
2.686e-7,
0.0235141572,
-0.0346322842,
0.0540450849,
0.0158894211,
-0.0024550732,
-0.0048361365,
-0.0630708411,
-0.0075193606,
0.0229909811,
-0.0317981467,
0.0511121005,
0.0611245148,
0.0312859006,
0.0010673613,
-0.0865403861,
0.0319715589,
-0.0463091806,
0.0493021496,
-0.0228976775,
-0.0239927378,
-0.1022989154,
0.0418730788,
0.0142746978,
-0.0466219708,
0.0660983473,
-0.0408388264,
0.0388336144,
-0.0745535791,
0.0075953421,
-0.0191506222,
0.0597687997,
0.0045874119,
-0.0326831527,
-0.0851385072,
0.0241520517,
0.0137562901,
0.0180473905,
0.02532354,
0.0144044962,
-0.0726333484,
-0.0494535118,
0.0227171741,
0.0208128542,
0.017076686,
0.0332963243,
-0.0349061787,
-0.010080222,
-0.0198349152,
-0.0150210187,
-0.0515945815,
0.0424150191,
0.0025895752,
0.0535954535,
0.02840163,
-0.0301906317,
0.0228330977,
-0.0480687991,
-0.0638730302,
-0.0466011986,
0.0054098642,
-0.0186091028,
-0.0168140922,
-0.0523926057,
-0.0021114384,
-0.0189082883,
-0.0159217194,
-0.0502434596,
2.06353143e-34,
-0.0310458113,
-0.012788658,
0.0253185537,
0.0274641123,
0.0196383931,
0.0085093761,
-0.0618248247,
-0.0129561927,
-0.0149267241,
-0.0129256807,
-0.025344478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09053v1 | Assessing Knowledge Editing in Language Models via Relation Perspective | 2023-11-15T15:44:42 | 2023-11-15T15:44:42 | Yifan Wei, Xiaoyan Yu, Huanhuan Ma, Fangyu Lei, Yixuan Weng, Ran Song, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge Editing (KE) for modifying factual knowledge in Large Language
Models (LLMs) has been receiving increasing attention. However, existing
knowledge editing methods are entity-centric, and it is unclear whether this
approach is suitable for a relation-centric perspective. To address this gap,
this paper constructs a new benchmark named RaKE, which focuses on Relation
based Knowledge Editing. In this paper, we establish a suite of innovative
metrics for evaluation and conduct comprehensive experiments involving various
knowledge editing baselines. We notice that existing knowledge editing methods
exhibit the potential difficulty in their ability to edit relations. Therefore,
we further explore the role of relations in factual triplets within the
transformer. Our research results confirm that knowledge related to relations
is not only stored in the FFN network but also in the attention layers. This
provides experimental support for future relation-based knowledge editing
methods. | [
0.0587821566,
0.0283382237,
-0.0164063778,
0.0588175841,
-0.0597783737,
-0.0159190763,
-0.0214395728,
-0.008152049,
-0.0617555045,
-0.05490705,
-0.059460599,
-0.0362807922,
0.0237303022,
0.0122988643,
0.0132497,
-0.0475281589,
0.0487293527,
0.0159463417,
-0.0194610432,
0.0281441901,
-0.0123937102,
-0.0037971279,
0.0066473838,
0.00598722,
-0.0250167139,
-0.0224140175,
-0.0098369382,
-0.002607899,
0.0402756706,
0.0024605764,
-0.0083127413,
0.0808286518,
-0.0287248697,
0.0568966493,
0.0000019928,
-0.0594856851,
-0.0348477513,
0.0217518508,
-0.0191441663,
0.0503380895,
0.003247584,
-0.0006747295,
-0.0297713093,
-0.005800344,
-0.0376583599,
0.0026499229,
0.0526709743,
0.054803025,
0.0498871841,
0.0740072653,
-0.0169937685,
-0.0026273099,
0.0321722552,
-0.0426335782,
-0.0050439169,
-0.0050953571,
0.0378800295,
0.052761551,
-0.0725643933,
0.0280338638,
-0.0374797732,
0.0594306663,
0.0399225168,
-0.0466485247,
0.0611025281,
0.0068027047,
-0.0457967147,
-0.0097254887,
0.0397749953,
0.0342904665,
0.0196167417,
0.0059981155,
-0.0396217108,
0.0217928383,
0.0281565432,
0.0308717508,
-0.0022280479,
-0.0396826975,
0.0093537234,
-0.0092677539,
-0.0059745,
-0.0629983321,
0.0389249139,
0.000183423,
-0.0158122312,
0.064368397,
0.047744602,
-0.042864006,
-0.0213723648,
-0.0133007513,
-0.0124719338,
-0.1042630449,
-0.0032796848,
0.02440813,
-0.0201770496,
0.0246887449,
-0.040423885,
0.0214947667,
0.0003744777,
-0.071510531,
0.0315220393,
0.0356056802,
-0.0001258522,
0.0546669252,
-0.0201249067,
0.0521368571,
0.0082289102,
0.0041067726,
-0.0141778802,
0.032937564,
-0.0470150672,
-0.0128656449,
-0.0504184738,
0.0092316503,
-0.019374175,
0.0251483675,
-0.0474096201,
0.0187840816,
-0.0127245542,
0.0251334105,
0.0277296863,
-0.0049016336,
-0.008241199,
0.0027385391,
-0.0632868186,
0.0570442528,
-0.0032227552,
0.0149168847,
0.007290897,
-0.0353219286,
0.0031935147,
-0.0475178361,
-0.0173939485,
-0.0491499342,
-0.0141757177,
0.049994953,
-0.0074659344,
-0.0310513116,
-0.0450747348,
-0.0323739648,
0.0012588366,
-0.0560719408,
-0.0083423564,
-0.0665081069,
0.015843628,
-0.0044260668,
-0.0211638398,
-0.0554583259,
0.0168470293,
-0.0248258989,
-0.0342816301,
0.0486565046,
-0.0212627761,
0.0425256081,
0.0187416375,
0.0268604942,
-0.02989229,
0.0517398939,
0.0415348262,
-0.0237577688,
0.0749741867,
0.002927202,
-0.0214296822,
0.0538624376,
0.0168629214,
0.0011915271,
-0.011431369,
0.0031068162,
-0.0116175208,
0.0508128405,
0.0190858319,
0.0383585207,
-0.016711263,
-0.0093959514,
0.0981565639,
-0.0236313958,
0.0652628615,
0.0818645358,
0.0335666873,
-0.0365873761,
0.0198667198,
0.0102251479,
-0.0574365146,
0.0437887348,
-0.0015937717,
0.0219832491,
-0.0040290817,
0.030452732,
-0.0054848348,
-0.0252349656,
0.0071964031,
0.0365741216,
-0.0171635058,
-0.0317841507,
0.0390160494,
0.0503573604,
-0.0151158748,
0.0725932047,
0.0202287789,
-0.0191585477,
0.0230388343,
-0.0386847444,
-0.0395553447,
0.046289783,
0.0683404878,
-0.0622551069,
-0.0631016046,
-0.0118179377,
-0.0528098904,
0.0178259015,
0.0721963644,
-0.0103599131,
-0.0075729969,
0.0022973623,
-0.0073015965,
-0.0261140727,
0.0274096504,
-0.0282511134,
0.0580977611,
0.0110735372,
0.0090774847,
-0.0610529929,
0.0093857124,
0.0036578339,
-0.0469584279,
0.0220716633,
-0.0294718966,
0.0152275218,
-0.0221901927,
0.0223257244,
-0.0238758381,
0.0056419913,
-0.0077771577,
0.0151286349,
-0.0073963879,
0.0120571991,
0.0059403721,
-0.0204068255,
0.0509691276,
-0.0044782725,
-0.0440670103,
0.0201717857,
-0.0038662679,
0.0055536469,
-0.0013376387,
-0.0338555463,
0.0961032659,
-0.0208792593,
0.0506419875,
-0.0018378687,
-0.0273439419,
-0.0079112779,
0.0332251526,
-0.0291503724,
0.0064255339,
-0.0029801114,
-0.052525539,
-0.0105743576,
-0.0191150382,
-0.0049973638,
0.0096006868,
-0.0030177543,
-0.0110353418,
0.0100388955,
-0.0208401754,
-0.0550309531,
-0.026965972,
-0.0548462085,
-0.0101611232,
-0.0268305317,
0.0226493608,
0.0428504199,
0.0468545258,
-0.0063115028,
0.0304180123,
-0.0181653928,
0.019526368,
-0.0380946696,
0.0297568049,
0.0280562546,
0.0027930348,
-0.0295149293,
-0.0489515625,
-0.0033726811,
0.0021581806,
0.0778452009,
0.013114647,
-0.0094270632,
-0.0204925016,
0.0737838298,
-0.074158676,
-0.0146450941,
0.0142625682,
-0.0349993072,
-0.0197598301,
0.0216742586,
0.0830218941,
0.0046693156,
-0.0179047845,
0.0310591348,
0.0611247085,
-0.0340310931,
-0.0007853988,
0.0004187606,
-0.018702779,
0.0034230289,
-0.0363146961,
-0.0260108076,
0.0168006103,
0.0396040343,
-0.0173503887,
-0.0412243418,
-0.0123230014,
0.018018689,
-0.0045200605,
-0.0148815038,
-0.0323832817,
0.0099731851,
0.0002885256,
0.013283655,
-0.072157748,
0.0188853573,
0.0699406788,
-0.0200664643,
0.0272211544,
-0.0079484582,
0.0145495031,
-0.0248016044,
0.070598118,
-0.0011422123,
0.0215000957,
-0.0314324796,
0.0116148889,
-0.0952663347,
-0.0049220566,
0.053523358,
-0.0370183066,
0.0549415015,
-0.0534463003,
0.0069109621,
0.008894898,
0.0029171468,
-0.0374965928,
0.0231788456,
0.0039133909,
0.0523750596,
0.0260071494,
-0.0378405042,
-0.0137788504,
0.0046098116,
0.0361587331,
0.0693842396,
0.0085763326,
-0.0402149856,
0.0035985732,
0.0341647863,
0.0239582695,
0.0287948083,
0.058816459,
0.008268957,
0.0403161161,
0.0588760152,
-0.001417735,
-0.0615702793,
-0.011083588,
-0.0108743384,
-0.0249557924,
-0.0930080339,
-0.0077949166,
-0.0328341834,
0.0518807359,
-0.0608161427,
-0.0328018852,
0.0975729972,
0.0433897823,
-0.0206350703,
0.0382984951,
-0.0398660004,
-0.0089132143,
0.0653747842,
0.0494458973,
-0.0800957605,
0.0239083972,
0.0180227831,
-0.0227095392,
0.0000722861,
-0.0731315687,
-0.0198007207,
-0.0854780078,
0.0078388983,
-0.0267540757,
-0.0519126803,
-0.0692490935,
-0.0341711119,
0.04045045,
0.0001673489,
-0.0102271391,
0.0239860453,
-0.0025390752,
-0.0042407308,
-0.0474077389,
0.0215867162,
-0.0458154157,
0.0074911183,
-0.0542980433,
0.0673675984,
0.0304205474,
0.0352579281,
-0.0050968495,
-0.0164325219,
-0.0116620641,
0.060330987,
-0.001747779,
0.000108349,
0.0381323248,
0.0066398964,
-0.0006350403,
-0.005746597,
-0.0203491077,
0.0051173526,
-0.0440736189,
0.0056436858,
0.0748105124,
0.0025609499,
-0.008188339,
0.0255593993,
-0.0162067376,
-0.0079367869,
0.0768401697,
0.0547035262,
-0.0105882986,
0.0301202089,
-0.0581709817,
0.0055053048,
-0.0379960053,
-0.0307753049,
-0.0185626596,
-0.0157409571,
0.0148132564,
-0.0700901374,
-0.0522145256,
0.0330791548,
-0.0055105151,
0.0395354778,
-0.026226012,
0.0654752553,
-0.0116547681,
-0.0600782633,
-0.0275955126,
-0.0270852316,
0.0422262028,
-0.0197308939,
-0.0054101776,
0.0096598538,
-0.0331079364,
-0.0228683334,
-0.081782259,
-0.0507111661,
-0.0307457019,
0.0286690965,
0.0389049016,
0.0223180074,
0.0261124261,
0.0047579412,
-0.0556421019,
-0.0048855064,
0.0252023172,
-0.0672568381,
0.0552805588,
0.012794177,
-0.025557436,
-0.012690274,
0.0513612032,
-0.04977265,
-0.0009017422,
0.0388143137,
0.0651107505,
-0.0300750639,
-0.057726182,
0.0178089049,
0.0027077908,
0.0387678221,
0.032358475,
0.0225431658,
-0.0461144969,
0.0452254899,
-0.0333726034,
-0.0026604724,
-0.0303228535,
-0.0108280359,
0.0067515685,
0.0323926248,
-0.0225231275,
0.0199760087,
0.0077850455,
-0.0071715228,
0.026002666,
-0.0249963682,
0.0158323962,
-0.0176627282,
0.0343763344,
0.0239700153,
-0.0240254905,
0.0033464304,
0.0159066394,
0.0200342797,
-0.0250021424,
0.0433040112,
0.0269796699,
-0.0188059825,
-0.0306883007,
0.0158411544,
-0.05304249,
0.0082463538,
-0.0231434498,
0.0206724722,
0.0550729372,
-0.0029683514,
0.0356530026,
-0.0628215,
-0.0360544696,
-0.0161659699,
0.0250360034,
-0.0004651904,
-0.0254767668,
0.0010552584,
0.0062278067,
0.0075857732,
0.0393517651,
0.0496241003,
-0.0358315632,
0.1061899737,
-0.0230054706,
-0.0452471636,
-0.031304244,
-0.0513334833,
-0.0320065953,
-0.0534298718,
-0.0297311526,
-0.0021211645,
-0.0896297991,
-0.0958721563,
-0.0050546178,
0.0078590168,
-0.0133757759,
-0.0037346496,
0.0103891622,
0.0502997711,
0.0190409198,
0.0041454691,
-0.0098120719,
-0.0141143845,
-0.0351015851,
-0.0040030684,
-0.0137244537,
-5.870785028e-33,
-0.0279322919,
-0.0237820689,
0.0275405124,
0.0111706676,
-0.0704698414,
0.0191301592,
-0.0463763513,
0.0216410998,
-0.0163716376,
0.0466989838,
-0.0307063609,
0.0201647189,
-0.013776755,
-0.0028499635,
-0.0385738648,
0.008122433,
0.0879093707,
0.0107406899,
-0.0263963658,
-0.000433161,
-0.0121361939,
0.0124347713,
0.0867206231,
-0.0418040454,
0.0361518823,
0.0337504596,
-0.0047813747,
0.0514924526,
-0.053864751,
0.0537007041,
-0.0072580348,
0.0158643015,
0.0261303522,
-0.0796173066,
-0.0097111138,
-0.0639948547,
-0.0700865984,
-0.0403267629,
0.0385166295,
0.0460560881,
-0.0207463074,
-0.0366951674,
0.037983384,
0.0299958959,
-0.0103728343,
-0.0742385164,
0.0271073841,
-0.0282193664,
0.0023166311,
-0.0525248535,
-0.0717638209,
0.0011309052,
0.0018869861,
-0.0190552864,
-0.0076997085,
-0.0275843143,
0.0126370024,
-0.0684804395,
-0.0793216154,
-0.001591858,
0.0128853973,
0.0592888556,
0.0436611511,
0.0045313281,
-0.0161487255,
0.0611653253,
-0.0300206244,
0.0414057113,
-0.0275580734,
0.0091205686,
0.0199148487,
0.051422812,
0.0283911172,
0.0588454902,
-0.0163040329,
0.0072174435,
-0.0525089353,
-0.000798178,
-0.0436693765,
0.0470606051,
-0.0084734242,
0.0202604327,
0.0268981494,
0.0089648832,
-0.0566486567,
0.0177048575,
-0.0601318628,
-0.0356277823,
0.005047881,
-0.0051085465,
-0.0031664693,
0.0170109402,
0.0083233928,
-0.0434757099,
-0.0084882015,
0.0267589055,
-0.0198173542,
0.0701229051,
-0.0100581367,
-0.0179313608,
-0.0365879796,
0.0420584381,
0.0307672117,
0.0273784827,
0.0057668532,
0.0052781822,
0.0416716412,
0.018828446,
-0.0479238406,
0.0117324283,
-0.0291255526,
0.0039203889,
-0.0022859168,
-0.0007642062,
-0.0068334378,
0.0049295728,
-0.019021105,
0.0067800665,
0.07723663,
0.0264999829,
-0.0294578187,
0.0682799593,
0.0267794318,
0.0360734798,
-0.0181770138,
0.0090727927,
-0.0503966175,
0.0092495801,
0.0274596941,
-0.0296715032,
-0.041042868,
-0.017959876,
2.696e-7,
0.0640180856,
0.0713860169,
0.0381524041,
0.037314266,
0.0323621035,
0.0254974365,
0.0019401901,
0.0003997118,
0.0412026234,
0.0008465113,
0.0112958001,
0.0079430789,
0.0068094968,
0.0397634394,
-0.042153094,
-0.0336869024,
-0.0611640774,
-0.0145426542,
-0.0244249851,
-0.0373466313,
0.0252035409,
0.047593642,
0.0591583028,
0.0079303253,
-0.0340751745,
-0.017687805,
0.0497834757,
-0.0363554768,
-0.005079974,
0.0312807262,
0.0579578504,
0.0198431425,
0.0059439689,
0.0299026705,
-0.0268114675,
-0.0125243319,
-0.0047484613,
0.0351460576,
-0.0123693217,
0.0315724462,
-0.0098582674,
0.0124810981,
0.0010216929,
-0.064185977,
0.0367747732,
-0.0510357209,
-0.0045800861,
0.0194486938,
-0.0032049906,
0.0227263216,
0.0052015116,
-0.0198565573,
-0.000403113,
0.007466814,
0.0118418206,
0.058373671,
-0.0288837124,
-0.021334352,
-0.0376777798,
0.0123555548,
0.0081037432,
-0.0744751766,
-0.0418372154,
-0.0715141818,
0.0106154084,
-0.0418370701,
0.0059782164,
2.287269791e-34,
-0.0066524027,
0.0171208214,
0.0202949718,
0.0156775247,
0.0468296781,
-0.0460473076,
0.0030315714,
0.0117414743,
-0.0227072258,
-0.0892809406,
-0.0050872723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09048v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09048v3 | GRASP: A novel benchmark for evaluating language GRounding And Situated Physics understanding in multimodal language models | 2023-11-15T15:38:28 | 2024-06-06T09:35:53 | Serwan Jassim, Mario Holubar, Annika Richter, Cornelius Wolff, Xenia Ohmer, Elia Bruni | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents GRASP, a novel benchmark to evaluate the language
grounding and physical understanding capabilities of video-based multimodal
large language models (LLMs). This evaluation is accomplished via a two-tier
approach leveraging Unity simulations. The first level tests for language
grounding by assessing a model's ability to relate simple textual descriptions
with visual information. The second level evaluates the model's understanding
of "Intuitive Physics" principles, such as object permanence and continuity. In
addition to releasing the benchmark, we use it to evaluate several
state-of-the-art multimodal LLMs. Our evaluation reveals significant
shortcomings in the language grounding and intuitive physics capabilities of
these models. Although they exhibit at least some grounding capabilities,
particularly for colors and shapes, these capabilities depend heavily on the
prompting strategy. At the same time, all models perform below or at the chance
level of 50% in the Intuitive Physics tests, while human subjects are on
average 80% correct. These identified limitations underline the importance of
using benchmarks like GRASP to monitor the progress of future models in
developing these competencies. | [
0.0105390782,
0.016668817,
-0.0187080968,
0.0633650348,
-0.0254358072,
-0.0135743376,
0.0209308676,
-0.0017724771,
-0.0172144212,
-0.0569174066,
-0.0423229709,
-0.0861162022,
0.03483193,
0.0125890663,
0.036564026,
-0.0634170324,
0.0120282499,
-0.0609976985,
-0.0751848742,
-0.0056698979,
0.0167687293,
0.0026946177,
-0.0704384893,
0.0313604623,
-0.0398173854,
-0.0202693287,
-0.0346010402,
-0.0124379797,
0.007160136,
-0.0365488194,
-0.035350427,
0.0392667614,
0.0520375222,
0.0427683666,
0.0000020606,
-0.0428487733,
0.0429101437,
-0.013468015,
0.0458862446,
0.0088153575,
0.0457334407,
-0.0620398931,
-0.0281387009,
-0.0160636194,
-0.0014918358,
0.01855281,
0.0702022389,
-0.015447583,
0.0335420147,
-0.0033051849,
-0.0139974784,
-0.0292886887,
0.0117997834,
0.0175647531,
0.019747464,
-0.0154343992,
-0.0100742737,
0.0688990057,
0.0673290193,
-0.0115438486,
-0.0755213127,
0.0291217715,
0.0605810545,
-0.0145540489,
-0.0386531129,
0.0645107329,
-0.0147451526,
-0.0216359664,
-0.0270108674,
0.0876149759,
-0.0006992051,
-0.0215444304,
-0.0261275284,
-0.0104938699,
-0.0090035768,
0.0434497781,
-0.0446542241,
0.0411896445,
0.0123663284,
0.0046175211,
-0.087540485,
-0.0048948103,
0.0153273558,
0.0125327408,
0.0083692186,
0.0528896451,
0.0376539305,
0.0016512625,
0.005538722,
0.0167269558,
-0.0190321915,
-0.0474165305,
0.0206919163,
0.0203425437,
0.0107265022,
0.0118885692,
-0.0489376262,
0.0089840861,
-0.0220949352,
-0.0644978359,
0.0776161626,
0.0466422923,
-0.0541585013,
0.0647690445,
-0.0070844134,
0.0639617667,
-0.0315275788,
0.0257065501,
-0.0129978266,
0.0500171632,
-0.0586156026,
-0.0052553238,
0.0118470835,
-0.0150190732,
-0.0512023084,
-0.058070261,
0.0249219816,
0.0108706718,
0.0092608305,
-0.0192170739,
-0.0450892448,
0.0120576266,
-0.0034258685,
-0.0071174433,
-0.0311203972,
0.029765686,
-0.0238979589,
0.0557668582,
-0.0050461092,
-0.0913885534,
-0.0005772491,
0.0116801281,
-0.0042506419,
-0.029737208,
-0.0140081737,
0.0530091412,
-0.0133916494,
-0.0261025373,
-0.0099646496,
-0.0072909254,
-0.0400517359,
-0.048191227,
0.0339556932,
-0.0320513919,
0.0349841155,
-0.004937327,
0.0035573884,
-0.0509654693,
0.0158260539,
0.0072088018,
0.0173238106,
0.0892804116,
0.0060076229,
0.0184377078,
0.0172279384,
0.0196383838,
-0.0243272316,
0.0570297055,
0.0171672218,
0.0144557441,
-0.0053390297,
-0.01413396,
-0.0016337399,
0.0503581688,
-0.0259757098,
0.0234479625,
-0.0835744515,
-0.0321837962,
-0.0010947528,
0.0764355212,
0.0332528539,
0.0381492674,
-0.0116089042,
-0.0057314951,
0.0988542289,
0.055644393,
-0.0681673884,
-0.0112496698,
0.0113505619,
-0.01437891,
0.0244464241,
0.0018111588,
-0.0494186282,
0.0569023043,
-0.0055024815,
0.0236653779,
-0.0102121523,
0.0267884191,
-0.024274705,
0.0059509915,
-0.0314570479,
0.0219400432,
0.0390636623,
0.009834975,
0.0568555444,
0.0210714545,
-0.0225490779,
0.0418136567,
-0.0067912429,
-0.0493771061,
0.0063473643,
-0.024284102,
0.0079563251,
0.0408130065,
0.0183195099,
0.0160361137,
-0.0351403281,
0.0057556792,
0.0985519215,
0.0730432719,
0.0114790983,
0.0300251022,
0.0257756189,
-0.0295745023,
-0.0242741872,
-0.0222933274,
0.0055487528,
0.0406751111,
-0.0369018242,
0.0117443129,
-0.0014108687,
-0.0181646254,
0.0259164479,
0.0481568575,
-0.0152310133,
0.0447543375,
-0.0737575367,
-0.0181630179,
0.0023668651,
0.0092915557,
-0.0414054729,
-0.007133909,
0.0122810649,
-0.0203904025,
0.0364180952,
0.0234099999,
-0.0379618779,
0.0054044458,
0.0555806123,
-0.0405812673,
-0.0113927592,
0.0210096482,
0.0070089628,
-0.0050967587,
0.0414901935,
0.005905787,
0.0510807894,
-0.0458856747,
-0.0003291071,
-0.0027605237,
0.0163088068,
0.0032626356,
0.0206319001,
-0.0490689687,
0.0312720053,
0.0116459886,
0.0373778008,
-0.0151655907,
-0.0641802773,
-0.0194555186,
0.0434527211,
-0.0035427632,
0.0230941344,
-0.0076868595,
0.0018263221,
-0.0419237316,
-0.0145853031,
-0.0623331107,
-0.0478597879,
-0.0207268689,
-0.0067929663,
0.0116437264,
-0.035058897,
-0.0339593664,
-0.0146704651,
0.0355776101,
0.0012125543,
-0.0309962202,
0.012219741,
0.0057475693,
0.0033900971,
-0.0252922848,
-0.0375020877,
-0.0017607014,
-0.0126564158,
0.0536381714,
0.0232017748,
0.031968195,
-0.0139395604,
0.010952007,
-0.0373061188,
0.0339199752,
-0.0136717837,
-0.0358493887,
0.0605052039,
-0.0364319906,
0.0401048847,
0.0589807965,
-0.0293865707,
0.0538265891,
0.0620538145,
-0.0768084303,
-0.0207533687,
-0.0107619315,
0.0044528097,
-0.0085369442,
-0.0293491185,
0.0136458222,
-0.0134669784,
0.0676470175,
0.0166792907,
0.019138746,
-0.0589285567,
0.0270765647,
-0.0458717011,
-0.056156721,
-0.0502285473,
0.0334179141,
-0.0517630875,
0.0186878201,
-0.0501909889,
-0.0321883373,
0.028282078,
-0.0929375067,
-0.0179145969,
0.0313751251,
0.0166963506,
0.0244931821,
0.1213562489,
0.0250410754,
-0.0067257956,
-0.0215908326,
0.0215311293,
-0.0271010213,
0.0129950531,
0.0081968792,
0.0047522252,
0.0140552418,
-0.1028885692,
0.008319485,
-0.0003605039,
0.0147141451,
0.0026510691,
0.0084120492,
-0.0445128195,
-0.0235169511,
-0.0438070856,
-0.0367709361,
0.0052087433,
0.0605774559,
0.0432023555,
0.0364023857,
-0.0054315478,
-0.0040036119,
-0.045580633,
-0.0093131019,
0.0399442725,
0.0184448715,
-0.0533896126,
-0.0697655827,
0.0196861383,
0.0242305063,
0.0257701855,
-0.0140752271,
-0.0854934379,
0.0421455279,
0.0348775387,
0.0350764953,
-0.0089705121,
0.0449274071,
0.0640372857,
-0.0542778298,
0.0139555484,
0.0782792941,
0.0173973981,
0.0060346276,
0.0202976596,
-0.0222915653,
0.0130791422,
0.0145063093,
-0.0286741536,
-0.0554187857,
-0.0432225466,
0.0110347942,
-0.0393615253,
0.0626805276,
-0.0558566414,
-0.0083780959,
-0.1051049307,
0.0115141943,
-0.0137025993,
-0.06386704,
-0.0575610809,
0.0080872588,
0.0147212232,
0.0334997587,
0.0481592007,
0.0138365822,
-0.008385024,
0.0019449042,
0.0168274809,
-0.0196950268,
-0.0805266723,
0.0307620242,
-0.0367693231,
0.0108094802,
0.0310710352,
0.0110778697,
-0.0427972227,
-0.0690806583,
0.0472639017,
0.0047570243,
0.0261953622,
-0.000239845,
-0.0264058523,
-0.0031652621,
-0.0050770729,
0.0008550087,
0.0156397801,
-0.0020821714,
-0.057738971,
-0.0113495104,
0.0623964481,
-0.0402070023,
-0.0225808863,
-0.0200169273,
-0.0149078043,
-0.0131626334,
0.0569381192,
0.0417909846,
-0.067993775,
-0.0236037988,
-0.0173688941,
0.0026678087,
0.0154298488,
-0.0552443862,
-0.0302680805,
0.0239521824,
-0.0065780585,
-0.0386555009,
-0.0047981916,
0.0372135974,
0.0620390289,
0.0001659462,
-0.0170068629,
-0.0014640641,
0.0056776204,
-0.0050846227,
0.0608240291,
0.0049221367,
0.0603082068,
-0.0470851101,
0.0321332626,
0.0507602245,
-0.0549003221,
-0.0140672131,
0.0141710201,
-0.0255119316,
-0.0616103746,
0.0015802647,
0.0288502667,
0.0259509999,
0.0309427027,
-0.0044978308,
-0.067720212,
-0.0233561713,
-0.0011880909,
-0.025927132,
0.0597713999,
-0.0188244805,
-0.0125174113,
0.0174724739,
0.0004322776,
-0.0188292302,
0.016023444,
-0.0196663421,
0.0396343507,
-0.0252242349,
-0.0214600321,
-0.0010689725,
-0.0214736927,
0.0737629607,
-0.0183099918,
-0.0112250345,
-0.0345547348,
-0.0096164336,
-0.0138757704,
0.0253476128,
-0.0661091581,
0.0088383844,
0.0388789028,
0.0256185904,
0.0148311965,
-0.001167312,
0.0060412427,
0.0549451821,
0.0150089879,
0.0165258106,
0.0099815661,
0.0240446236,
0.0141244056,
0.0379905142,
0.0133937337,
0.0086372811,
-0.0851779878,
0.0450653248,
0.0066091581,
0.082544148,
0.0377481915,
-0.0487976968,
0.0014921055,
0.0357687436,
-0.0112084048,
-0.0035928814,
-0.0112372059,
0.0571704619,
0.0631342605,
-0.0002738503,
0.0297078025,
-0.0464603603,
0.0036925334,
-0.0138901481,
0.0558102727,
0.0417471118,
-0.061460916,
0.0805901885,
0.0239891429,
0.0088581592,
0.0121671567,
0.019730838,
0.008676446,
0.0293663219,
0.0061660516,
0.017079141,
-0.0178355929,
-0.0128541728,
0.0260055941,
0.0192074478,
-0.0057585463,
0.0267692357,
-0.0622043461,
-0.0564328656,
0.0070737917,
0.0665443242,
-0.0242374744,
-0.0141729563,
0.0515093282,
0.0314943343,
-0.0139595047,
-0.0007303565,
-0.0020765048,
-0.041323822,
0.0074607078,
0.0078065088,
-0.0108147478,
-5.618657285e-33,
-0.0339361727,
-0.0020647089,
0.0112106893,
-0.017832648,
-0.0385357775,
-0.0121623185,
-0.0573603734,
0.0236418489,
-0.0050290423,
0.013420837,
0.0314336605,
-0.0161754563,
0.0103713134,
0.0102665117,
-0.0051206453,
-0.0019162932,
0.0020298336,
0.0030681875,
-0.0139126219,
-0.0350093693,
-0.0023380194,
0.0219857581,
0.0576640293,
-0.0183292199,
0.0152184721,
0.0200936757,
-0.0319027044,
0.0094103394,
-0.0032720263,
0.0519298278,
-0.0728158057,
0.0167659651,
0.0016932144,
-0.0333269387,
-0.0209373813,
0.0168454349,
-0.0045995284,
-0.0326340646,
0.0054051429,
0.0581413582,
-0.0621356405,
0.0138231115,
0.0317553431,
-0.0104872175,
-0.0556802079,
-0.0090561016,
0.0289320629,
-0.0379830375,
-0.0142048597,
0.0270134266,
-0.0291401464,
0.0172733944,
0.0029232376,
-0.0499419272,
0.0161575489,
-0.0266374815,
0.0073299478,
-0.0181533266,
-0.0590967238,
-0.0145921214,
-0.0334457271,
0.0131846508,
0.1069520637,
0.0213653389,
0.0288027953,
0.1058652028,
0.0135424826,
-0.0289471559,
-0.0560973622,
-0.0000720363,
0.090991348,
0.0321933702,
0.0170771256,
0.0799938068,
0.0128204264,
0.0094771972,
-0.0221481379,
0.0014536575,
-0.011394552,
0.0852014646,
0.0261021405,
0.0343430154,
-0.0283573195,
0.0048380303,
-0.0441053174,
0.0030361069,
-0.0126778157,
-0.0326718204,
0.0736607313,
-0.031077601,
0.022825731,
-0.023143474,
0.0675971732,
-0.0358810946,
-0.0387685411,
-0.0187462904,
-0.0262838937,
0.085888125,
0.0120143453,
0.0062137339,
-0.0291370917,
-0.0063309125,
0.0335349999,
0.0177946016,
0.0361317359,
-0.0002883475,
-0.0435085893,
0.0576724708,
-0.0191809013,
-0.0134357661,
-0.01442008,
-0.0199306794,
0.0385204144,
0.0023403699,
0.068374671,
-0.0128209796,
-0.0492037088,
0.0529664271,
-0.0336542726,
-0.0233718604,
-0.003832954,
-0.0057221274,
-0.0447188802,
0.0023542729,
-0.0543787815,
-0.0198758282,
-0.0316500328,
-0.0479895324,
0.0471394882,
-0.0513416193,
-0.0311657488,
0.0419502109,
2.709e-7,
0.0451143235,
0.0361869186,
0.0122999828,
-0.0047147195,
0.0140574165,
0.0162082408,
-0.0571944229,
0.0253775567,
-0.0122325048,
-0.0747877806,
-0.0437507853,
0.0549781397,
0.0527220964,
-0.0160499401,
-0.0833727196,
0.044493068,
-0.0283553787,
0.003634003,
-0.0338404253,
0.003530588,
0.0088600749,
0.025069207,
-0.0064353133,
0.0077037965,
0.0058063348,
-0.0496143848,
0.0491201542,
-0.0602723733,
0.0343103148,
-0.0246705431,
0.0172202736,
-0.004094285,
-0.027245637,
-0.0056533692,
0.0088573042,
-0.0260462854,
0.0447112434,
0.0205779709,
-0.035166923,
0.0098506827,
-0.0233259518,
-0.0071209488,
-0.0325357243,
-0.041158326,
0.070863381,
-0.0441747606,
-0.0028948633,
0.0003529396,
-0.0071020494,
-0.0260595623,
0.0004568451,
-0.0146936998,
-0.0253403336,
0.0088584395,
0.015240062,
-0.0279998556,
-0.0538488589,
-0.0427945442,
-0.0287843272,
0.0235180389,
-0.0465018824,
-0.0277476292,
-0.0516830273,
-0.0484856404,
0.0193544235,
-0.0575829074,
-0.0664901659,
2.059049858e-34,
0.0206368752,
0.0039797486,
0.0183643047,
0.0028923582,
0.0309852511,
0.0101562971,
0.0341889113,
0.0190967526,
0.0047440263,
-0.0429988056,
-0.0013140753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09033v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09033v3 | MELA: Multilingual Evaluation of Linguistic Acceptability | 2023-11-15T15:25:28 | 2024-06-06T12:31:51 | Ziyin Zhang, Yikang Liu, Weifang Huang, Junyu Mao, Rui Wang, Hai Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we present the largest benchmark to date on linguistic
acceptability: Multilingual Evaluation of Linguistic Acceptability -- MELA,
with 46K samples covering 10 languages from a diverse set of language families.
We establish LLM baselines on this benchmark, and investigate cross-lingual
transfer in acceptability judgements with XLM-R. In pursuit of multilingual
interpretability, we conduct probing experiments with fine-tuned XLM-R to
explore the process of syntax capability acquisition. Our results show that
GPT-4o exhibits a strong multilingual ability, outperforming fine-tuned XLM-R,
while open-source multilingual models lag behind by a noticeable gap.
Cross-lingual transfer experiments show that transfer in acceptability judgment
is non-trivial: 500 Icelandic fine-tuning examples lead to 23 MCC performance
in a completely unrelated language -- Chinese. Results of our probing
experiments indicate that training on MELA improves the performance of XLM-R on
syntax-related tasks. Our data is available at
https://github.com/sjtu-compling/MELA. | [
0.0223187637,
0.046316307,
-0.0315198377,
0.0623310022,
-0.0065238015,
0.0215646531,
-0.0226467848,
0.0002075737,
0.0025902318,
-0.0066420259,
-0.073163189,
-0.0216143634,
-0.0098652821,
0.015078851,
0.009877095,
-0.063493669,
0.0530498363,
-0.0253977086,
0.0097730802,
-0.0046573523,
0.023278743,
0.0036645427,
-0.0028983781,
0.0413438305,
0.0017655416,
-0.0342213213,
0.0109689981,
-0.0218891278,
0.0103113484,
-0.0112460945,
-0.0267550647,
0.0397442989,
-0.0234101731,
0.0313179828,
0.0000020458,
-0.0712246299,
-0.0186349042,
-0.008471285,
-0.0102292607,
0.0180062782,
0.0325760134,
-0.0394414812,
-0.0197236743,
-0.0100034419,
-0.0496056266,
0.0004405331,
0.0291662849,
0.0035108055,
0.0332292281,
0.0505299531,
-0.0157114156,
-0.0014200197,
0.0280454382,
-0.016669374,
-0.0244671293,
-0.0428520478,
-0.0084597934,
0.019926168,
0.0025633001,
-0.0183991101,
-0.051355198,
0.0281011481,
0.0280005429,
0.0166684575,
-0.0481396057,
0.0113998251,
-0.0377648287,
-0.0206263829,
-0.0269387979,
0.0507849567,
-0.0119552175,
-0.0183721054,
-0.0273612719,
-0.0166536849,
-0.0037332256,
-0.0206177738,
-0.0432828367,
0.0186224002,
-0.0025713264,
0.0512618646,
0.0141143817,
-0.0567130446,
0.0226614308,
-0.009552558,
0.0053320765,
0.1169638112,
0.0070947181,
-0.0331675783,
0.0455328226,
0.0330569334,
-0.020278072,
-0.0125023667,
-0.0146773942,
-0.0230514575,
-0.0423867702,
0.0367606804,
-0.0217566043,
-0.0204293225,
0.0530650653,
-0.0122385407,
0.064128153,
0.0193001907,
-0.0472370051,
0.0356126875,
-0.0204181485,
0.0516355932,
-0.0030231464,
0.0185600892,
-0.0122906603,
-0.0186316166,
-0.079585366,
0.0143744368,
0.0004176358,
0.0109924879,
-0.0174328275,
0.0435718708,
-0.0679787248,
-0.0170457121,
-0.0319026001,
0.0150734363,
0.0069321217,
-0.0708261058,
-0.045483496,
0.0136268483,
-0.0366014317,
0.0302488282,
-0.0442395024,
0.0249373093,
-0.0278149489,
-0.073500976,
0.0109318178,
0.0415352955,
-0.0298070107,
-0.0517524518,
0.0032443102,
0.0678546652,
-0.0275401603,
-0.0224585198,
-0.0042065494,
-0.0029787202,
-0.0281381141,
-0.0791687295,
0.0314936899,
-0.0441816077,
-0.0052417954,
0.009620619,
0.0021142133,
-0.0434448197,
-0.017279027,
-0.0165047627,
-0.0033288817,
0.0190390982,
-0.0042165555,
-0.0233460646,
-0.0130449226,
-0.0143730426,
-0.0534140803,
0.0913016573,
0.0196753461,
-0.0248966571,
0.0554417893,
-0.0396068506,
-0.0081849899,
0.0664694533,
-0.003405924,
0.0277859028,
0.0117720179,
0.0024669962,
-0.0073864437,
0.0026436176,
0.0635612085,
0.0557375476,
0.0039178906,
-0.0205085035,
0.0218768902,
-0.0016627338,
0.0274285804,
0.0238133017,
0.0621333309,
0.0288345609,
-0.0156563576,
0.0276672319,
-0.0490692593,
0.0280023254,
-0.034478832,
0.03208955,
-0.0149889141,
0.0595746562,
0.005868162,
-0.0323804244,
0.0066299047,
-0.0087983515,
0.0587463118,
-0.0214764383,
0.0391561314,
-0.014229863,
-0.0137108266,
0.0401130058,
0.0392501876,
-0.0967887118,
-0.0120537607,
-0.0541348979,
0.0137554891,
-0.0120831579,
-0.0237851441,
-0.0115872249,
-0.0110326596,
-0.0319594778,
-0.0242729262,
0.0421152748,
0.06191127,
0.0351304263,
0.0793451965,
-0.044154793,
0.0077486038,
0.0004628059,
0.0077206637,
0.0669985116,
-0.0243218187,
0.0342156477,
-0.0256944522,
-0.0350389071,
-0.0315079987,
0.0287531279,
-0.0113966633,
0.0047918409,
-0.0234461725,
0.0094120121,
0.0671609044,
0.027176043,
0.0145578161,
-0.0149494456,
0.0190167557,
-0.0164937954,
0.0225689933,
0.0791872144,
-0.0289205424,
-0.030628439,
0.0563462861,
-0.0376490802,
-0.0653777421,
0.0246332139,
-0.0038943512,
-0.0473237857,
0.0504957624,
0.0032138759,
0.0309461839,
-0.0504584238,
-0.0292541012,
-0.0376624614,
0.0296740551,
0.0126108369,
0.042759534,
0.0047001517,
0.0522163883,
-0.01423888,
-0.0535619743,
0.0463369228,
-0.0255472157,
-0.0613665767,
0.0267462395,
-0.0261686686,
0.0323407724,
-0.0021903105,
0.0253265612,
-0.072489202,
-0.0299088825,
-0.0906018168,
-0.0022107798,
-0.0249123182,
0.0254555512,
0.0163352061,
-0.0410761237,
-0.0061186277,
-0.0078138206,
-0.0200348906,
-0.0195158143,
0.0155545091,
0.033256419,
0.0278778262,
0.0053064842,
-0.0335161015,
-0.028286485,
-0.0046632378,
-0.0194782335,
0.0321437865,
-0.0383712091,
0.0237604696,
-0.0021556714,
-0.0082772393,
-0.0355236083,
-0.0264376309,
-0.0018786499,
-0.0705194697,
0.0389079563,
0.0218417086,
0.0261012595,
0.0423782282,
-0.0311993174,
0.0110233678,
0.0528684631,
-0.0135918362,
-0.0297592878,
0.0172251258,
0.0452198982,
-0.0353112109,
-0.0468905158,
-0.03143977,
-0.0057652155,
0.0681264549,
-0.0110150697,
-0.028727863,
-0.05310582,
-0.0128740342,
-0.0346214958,
-0.0630033836,
0.0035963231,
0.0317365304,
-0.0385693721,
0.061325103,
-0.0122746676,
-0.0511554703,
0.0839034915,
-0.0465533473,
-0.0693622977,
-0.054019168,
-0.0040006684,
-0.03648974,
0.051651217,
-0.0151890675,
0.0098293358,
-0.0053364947,
-0.044071462,
-0.0153862033,
-0.0266546849,
0.0247231182,
0.0026395505,
0.0878079459,
-0.0535489209,
-0.0277287532,
-0.0055468478,
0.0002417826,
0.0193610433,
-0.0025459309,
-0.0209834296,
0.0278892852,
0.0047024828,
0.0051383516,
-0.0002924639,
-0.0503731146,
0.0284510236,
-0.0244575515,
-0.0021790063,
0.0194604322,
-0.0040998221,
-0.0229051076,
-0.0038869476,
0.0550539941,
-0.0024615733,
-0.037061628,
-0.0118855471,
0.0137907472,
-0.0039149271,
-0.0127604064,
-0.0311687179,
0.0470198505,
0.0072697345,
-0.0144013297,
-0.0492055863,
0.0087405369,
0.0885069296,
-0.0128518986,
0.0187805779,
0.0392710119,
0.0230166577,
-0.0199390613,
0.0041544936,
-0.0611646809,
0.0640773103,
0.028373044,
0.0251080729,
-0.0846685916,
-0.0246254914,
-0.0060707638,
0.0030783541,
-0.0077513005,
-0.0362329856,
0.0093103293,
-0.0818554014,
0.0302971788,
0.0058942763,
-0.0753616765,
-0.0032493672,
0.0002705079,
-0.0058014519,
-0.0214383751,
0.0571627878,
0.0145656364,
-0.0143730119,
0.0077316458,
0.01398612,
-0.0179102998,
-0.0516103543,
0.0626642406,
-0.0354000628,
0.0461907126,
0.0121411094,
0.0244403165,
-0.048182264,
-0.0621392205,
0.0145645021,
0.0120580057,
-0.0110075148,
-0.0007506894,
0.0225178879,
0.0348319747,
-0.0260014106,
-0.0124028204,
0.0168812983,
0.0035248387,
-0.0122461272,
0.015267035,
0.1079432592,
0.0277264882,
-0.0336334407,
0.0306759737,
-0.0067571732,
-0.0025766676,
0.0580380633,
0.072635904,
-0.0326522775,
-0.0313520692,
-0.0781143084,
-0.0315341316,
-0.0467021763,
0.0083394973,
0.051284641,
-0.0153939938,
-0.0242243446,
-0.0513749644,
-0.0835206583,
0.031797722,
0.0022931264,
-0.0026859061,
0.0043028602,
-0.0042045559,
-0.0071298047,
0.0127706965,
0.0406472832,
-0.0081823925,
0.0109923631,
-0.0777329803,
-0.0062895375,
0.0091779586,
-0.006532548,
-0.0343913734,
0.0134090213,
0.0135852555,
-0.0597676896,
0.0060762018,
0.0698756054,
0.0275317524,
0.0155134015,
0.0128565207,
-0.021971928,
-0.0713988543,
-0.0018749774,
-0.0115235755,
0.0607634261,
0.0987766981,
-0.0204412602,
0.0220764056,
0.045269236,
0.0069474918,
0.0355696604,
-0.018814316,
0.0268397592,
-0.0174511615,
-0.01720744,
0.0222877543,
0.0445451252,
0.0197885782,
-0.0039091967,
-0.0274779275,
-0.0282150265,
0.0001242407,
-0.0273251701,
0.018429501,
-0.0245418679,
-0.0332703963,
0.0217353534,
-0.0200782642,
-0.0119167594,
-0.0436733104,
-0.054733932,
0.0024848357,
0.0017242567,
0.0518984497,
0.03365146,
0.0241457243,
-0.0031407045,
0.0320175327,
-0.0210363213,
-0.0197004788,
-0.0221998002,
0.0337587409,
-0.0066773994,
0.0502360947,
-0.0014985147,
-0.0063739545,
0.0450408272,
0.0097461427,
-0.0046646255,
0.0044018291,
0.0563921593,
-0.0130283376,
0.0685304925,
-0.0056725675,
0.116248861,
0.0070272274,
0.0173789822,
-0.0337161422,
0.069521673,
-0.0346219763,
-0.0421094,
0.049745705,
0.0033070808,
-0.0291230232,
-0.0120287891,
0.0714438781,
-0.0347540937,
-0.0102490559,
0.0142983869,
0.0439215265,
-0.0349945053,
-0.0382589586,
-0.0087310076,
-0.0028051634,
-0.0171079393,
-0.0127756344,
-0.0522257946,
-0.0835302547,
0.003510287,
0.0561849773,
-0.0029373083,
-0.01408205,
-0.0092686135,
0.0890161246,
0.00089623,
-0.0389097035,
-0.065685302,
-0.0306487009,
0.0353315249,
0.0173741635,
0.0037194022,
-5.920880924e-33,
-0.0212241337,
0.0235558879,
-0.0132796811,
0.0254615694,
0.0072591961,
-0.0347394757,
-0.0445111766,
0.0481090397,
-0.0551851094,
0.0232376475,
-0.0159734022,
-0.01388714,
0.0113860527,
0.0102471933,
0.0447614379,
0.015490694,
0.0016425201,
0.0165967122,
-0.0022707521,
-0.0201681107,
0.0467059538,
0.0192267019,
0.1190085486,
-0.0166443381,
0.0308240931,
0.0366641656,
-0.0036667774,
-0.018494105,
-0.0624028593,
0.0958538577,
-0.0060069538,
0.0352988057,
0.0358284898,
-0.0070697838,
-0.0235115085,
-0.0381871983,
-0.0260697417,
-0.0292981938,
0.0603472106,
0.0144515336,
-0.0203044098,
-0.0354898684,
0.0454152003,
-0.0395872369,
-0.0138230231,
-0.0140186762,
0.0071965228,
-0.0399346091,
-0.000848711,
0.0591468252,
-0.0598311387,
0.0255276244,
-0.0208886154,
0.0368082784,
0.0448437072,
0.0341081657,
-0.0176496711,
0.0078934059,
-0.0626050308,
0.0032837456,
-0.0149407657,
0.0284862779,
0.071086362,
-0.0609957166,
-0.015532244,
0.0558927283,
0.0076204408,
-0.000867651,
0.0567148365,
0.01169015,
0.0803956315,
0.042769976,
0.0398581624,
0.0629554167,
0.001441471,
-0.0349352211,
-0.0599114113,
0.0013122527,
0.0409535356,
0.0515382625,
-0.0143752275,
0.0305030923,
-0.0339540243,
-0.0154831149,
-0.0285810251,
-0.0233180448,
-0.0528559387,
-0.0565890968,
0.0529809371,
-0.0678044111,
-0.0060434965,
0.0138419028,
0.0558094494,
-0.0052385032,
-0.0434799455,
0.0007883143,
-0.034607213,
0.0485652611,
0.0128884064,
0.0625779331,
-0.0441593975,
-0.0307553727,
-0.0326597132,
-0.0132154301,
0.052229777,
0.0016797985,
0.0455819331,
-0.0050926902,
-0.0701246783,
0.035899166,
-0.0313841216,
0.0376707353,
-0.0068621887,
0.0303357262,
0.0206622891,
-0.0101891942,
-0.0151259899,
0.0277010109,
0.0060246261,
-0.0272449031,
-0.0922525525,
-0.003987723,
-0.0085659232,
0.0365106314,
-0.0355535969,
-0.0330413394,
-0.0084247934,
-0.0052290885,
0.0656251386,
-0.0052302605,
-0.0014926096,
0.0177238975,
2.737e-7,
0.0407405905,
0.0421237312,
-0.0166339315,
-0.005887432,
0.005096368,
0.0457222573,
-0.0953686014,
0.0348878503,
0.0073913764,
0.0158739537,
-0.0380918831,
0.0017274185,
0.0568922572,
0.0612548068,
-0.0660385266,
-0.0160152204,
-0.0130958576,
0.0229667928,
-0.0230938029,
0.0231625922,
0.0407991856,
0.0596770197,
-0.0184160378,
0.0212488305,
-0.0290682241,
-0.0397448577,
0.0571847036,
-0.0606616586,
-0.0054787467,
0.0027723571,
0.0170605443,
0.0004728826,
0.0133448364,
0.0170382597,
-0.0000089529,
0.0093328655,
-0.0080821924,
0.0939376056,
0.0070322072,
0.0001170271,
0.0561772361,
0.0092157004,
-0.0136349099,
-0.0823804662,
0.028385533,
-0.0096103717,
-0.0468160883,
-0.0084584439,
-0.0432469472,
-0.0081769945,
0.0488594547,
-0.0296800509,
-0.008429734,
0.0226386227,
0.0211935043,
-0.0402785912,
-0.0130221304,
-0.0008854542,
-0.0287654698,
0.0423660427,
-0.0084731057,
-0.0162205361,
-0.0422299951,
-0.0239602607,
0.0071111205,
-0.0497213118,
0.0090627559,
2.20485478e-34,
0.032915663,
-0.0236338396,
0.0824220628,
0.0192051511,
0.033075206,
-0.0072656819,
0.0031191253,
0.0369819999,
-0.0272033047,
-0.0461506546,
0.0101364097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09022v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09022v3 | Exploring the Potential of Large Language Models in Computational Argumentation | 2023-11-15T15:12:15 | 2024-07-01T09:40:58 | Guizhen Chen, Liying Cheng, Luu Anh Tuan, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Computational argumentation has become an essential tool in various domains,
including law, public policy, and artificial intelligence. It is an emerging
research field in natural language processing that attracts increasing
attention. Research on computational argumentation mainly involves two types of
tasks: argument mining and argument generation. As large language models (LLMs)
have demonstrated impressive capabilities in understanding context and
generating natural language, it is worthwhile to evaluate the performance of
LLMs on diverse computational argumentation tasks. This work aims to embark on
an assessment of LLMs, such as ChatGPT, Flan models, and LLaMA2 models, in both
zero-shot and few-shot settings. We organize existing tasks into six main
categories and standardize the format of fourteen openly available datasets. In
addition, we present a new benchmark dataset on counter speech generation that
aims to holistically evaluate the end-to-end performance of LLMs on argument
mining and argument generation. Extensive experiments show that LLMs exhibit
commendable performance across most of the datasets, demonstrating their
capabilities in the field of argumentation. Our analysis offers valuable
suggestions for evaluating computational argumentation and its integration with
LLMs in future research endeavors. | [
0.014341522,
0.0514614992,
0.0121654011,
0.0526918098,
-0.059051998,
0.0083169779,
0.0292647667,
-0.017701067,
-0.0119740237,
-0.0703015849,
0.0128083108,
-0.0636900514,
0.0000290801,
-0.0099498434,
0.0095344223,
-0.0441499837,
-0.0009338468,
-0.0166990366,
0.1179417446,
-0.0141598787,
0.0288530942,
0.0075805555,
-0.0181309693,
0.054350026,
-0.0107563036,
-0.0417468138,
0.0038488726,
-0.0010242319,
0.0190675668,
-0.0334110484,
-0.0029246861,
0.0122751947,
0.017377913,
0.0692978278,
0.000002063,
-0.0456158482,
0.0220401268,
-0.0065559936,
-0.0424229614,
0.0576322377,
0.0779676214,
0.0207436979,
-0.0253270864,
0.0450031646,
-0.0290591717,
0.0270436946,
0.0486571342,
0.0530279204,
0.0661551952,
0.0894569606,
-0.0036572702,
-0.0325477608,
0.029446505,
-0.0381336696,
-0.0477368236,
-0.000438681,
0.0194288436,
0.0245125927,
0.0066846479,
-0.007899343,
0.0189222042,
0.0092918621,
0.0212735794,
-0.0191167854,
-0.0557169095,
0.0298963506,
-0.069786571,
-0.0153532038,
-0.0169587675,
0.0502132662,
-0.0004030129,
-0.0383763313,
0.0148123708,
-0.029720759,
0.0148255918,
-0.0195444971,
-0.0705764964,
0.1029827595,
-0.0008110002,
0.0474158451,
0.0611658841,
0.0419622771,
0.0213619359,
0.0336274728,
-0.0031920432,
0.0283067264,
-0.0076941308,
-0.0363898799,
0.0125741707,
-0.0330860876,
-0.0434449464,
-0.0855255127,
-0.0055505768,
0.0385160781,
-0.0092988061,
0.0384231918,
-0.0190905035,
-0.0044777417,
0.072857745,
-0.0908844024,
0.0530693941,
0.0146699175,
0.0120096086,
0.0519869365,
-0.0098766126,
0.0156818125,
-0.0333573706,
-0.0031396898,
0.0432501882,
-0.0389745161,
-0.0451766737,
-0.0340210125,
-0.0162351374,
0.0088864127,
-0.0752481818,
-0.0240088608,
-0.0117143234,
-0.0146630565,
-0.0434469767,
0.0134026771,
0.006401239,
0.0176542252,
0.0198702626,
-0.0202397462,
-0.0333008058,
0.004555739,
-0.030562479,
0.0364853516,
0.0668658912,
-0.0662566498,
-0.0183221325,
0.0334599838,
-0.0121073993,
-0.0097084874,
-0.0117254518,
0.0607142821,
-0.0187810902,
0.0193626732,
-0.0114189563,
-0.0595164783,
-0.0589367412,
-0.099078916,
0.0167740416,
-0.0888147354,
0.0018239652,
-0.0293495934,
-0.0118506169,
-0.0299077388,
0.0267372988,
0.0403543264,
0.0019785133,
0.0152098825,
-0.0013623694,
-0.0193686895,
0.025324313,
0.0265169032,
-0.0090999221,
0.0457530804,
0.0424470343,
0.0132222567,
0.0325308405,
0.0274070129,
0.0005452412,
0.0208691787,
0.0141272042,
0.0111389291,
0.0264568161,
-0.0049799429,
-0.0571106188,
0.0305132698,
-0.0117114233,
0.0622315966,
-0.0482136309,
-0.0422808565,
0.0315908454,
0.0580591299,
0.0229342133,
-0.0091656307,
0.0546142496,
0.0216924231,
0.0366950333,
-0.0181154963,
-0.0043378421,
-0.0011334515,
-0.0261369087,
-0.0096694632,
0.0367036648,
0.0133108031,
-0.0259245578,
-0.0557840616,
0.0018811153,
-0.0046617459,
-0.0160935,
-0.0243392494,
0.0106018689,
0.0092240889,
-0.033312913,
-0.0136448685,
0.0181887485,
-0.0426511057,
-0.0640392452,
-0.0417192467,
0.0402120054,
-0.003280598,
0.0198555719,
-0.0070393183,
0.0054279482,
-0.0249913707,
0.0494174138,
0.0919071063,
0.0717238933,
-0.008618433,
-0.0109169055,
-0.0414300822,
-0.001465397,
-0.050881736,
0.0554934889,
0.0253525898,
-0.0114440676,
0.0010681192,
0.0466160811,
0.0089746788,
-0.0361036658,
0.0073437123,
0.0025582435,
0.0147534255,
0.030644726,
-0.0169137623,
0.0381505154,
0.0408933423,
-0.0359282978,
0.0390195996,
0.0293080267,
-0.0265127365,
-0.0153520945,
0.0293376148,
-0.0042898608,
-0.0259658378,
0.0588721298,
-0.0317217223,
0.0004581292,
-0.0165250711,
-0.0281571895,
-0.0187855065,
0.0525927395,
-0.0088492194,
0.0121356212,
-0.0135134542,
0.0067052157,
0.0266623106,
0.0039129714,
-0.0170374271,
0.0716173127,
0.0260853898,
-0.0153382672,
0.0195351671,
0.0393672921,
0.0426256619,
-0.0687998235,
0.007540381,
0.0022113298,
-0.0040957145,
0.0030820898,
0.0150140412,
-0.0230236948,
-0.0173524525,
-0.0211431198,
-0.0862480476,
0.0236872993,
-0.0222087707,
0.0117208567,
0.0081998147,
-0.0766454339,
0.0138116954,
0.0397569574,
-0.0246809162,
-0.0137051465,
0.0273151882,
0.0031291055,
0.0260512382,
-0.0140682245,
-0.0259839389,
-0.050223168,
-0.0008597345,
-0.0168571342,
0.0383647867,
0.0251655634,
-0.0100847455,
0.0159702059,
0.0107969474,
-0.0394979678,
-0.0299311895,
-0.0246246532,
-0.0219108332,
0.0358344913,
0.0279661082,
0.0079697827,
0.054157231,
0.0416198745,
0.0253074188,
0.0155739971,
-0.0091247847,
-0.0433089435,
-0.0083718169,
0.0011926311,
0.044784382,
-0.0020577079,
-0.0166612305,
0.0224442836,
0.0691840053,
0.0030701943,
0.0362481661,
-0.0539780632,
0.0749553517,
0.0277795587,
0.0022590018,
0.0062299585,
-0.0164598543,
-0.0128424289,
0.0452841818,
-0.0272645187,
-0.0100108217,
0.0194414575,
-0.0651818663,
0.0461167432,
-0.0066332365,
-0.0227747876,
-0.0289931055,
0.0409560725,
-0.0119142504,
0.001544824,
0.0068901894,
0.0487818867,
0.0300425459,
-0.0419709347,
0.0327083841,
-0.0295876842,
0.0071135452,
-0.0517682731,
0.013195442,
-0.0169470757,
-0.0346857421,
-0.0179346204,
-0.0462650061,
-0.0695761517,
0.0133065628,
-0.0054781116,
0.010723304,
-0.0055280295,
-0.005817492,
-0.0070855711,
0.0153857274,
0.0093553243,
0.0083724661,
-0.0088229561,
0.0202147029,
0.0069094962,
0.0120039862,
0.0569828786,
-0.0053367857,
0.0419000238,
0.0583095811,
-0.0203650985,
0.0093547823,
-0.0346121863,
-0.0318527631,
-0.0387585126,
-0.0064055049,
-0.0216911957,
0.007711608,
0.0421680473,
-0.0646250397,
0.0322237127,
0.0768256038,
0.0288883168,
0.0297805443,
0.0018190248,
-0.0193470474,
0.0159323178,
-0.0104548121,
-0.0179003105,
-0.1028644964,
-0.0310954489,
-0.0119322557,
-0.0234672893,
-0.0846813768,
-0.0286887586,
-0.0319273025,
-0.1377350986,
0.0853520557,
0.027785955,
0.0283857211,
0.0004286287,
-0.0289144404,
-0.0088557387,
-0.0155051136,
-0.0320834592,
0.005386977,
0.0029795999,
-0.0015777627,
0.0222933106,
-0.0245116912,
-0.0164659675,
0.0163402744,
-0.0090991789,
0.0878221616,
0.0181336831,
0.0737667903,
0.0053008385,
-0.0284228679,
0.0437002555,
-0.0156456288,
-0.0328268483,
-0.0093632145,
0.0096211527,
0.0146227591,
-0.0052759848,
-0.0102024199,
0.0441849232,
0.0062553827,
-0.0603332147,
0.0323070697,
0.0441323332,
-0.0376106873,
-0.0256754719,
-0.018846754,
0.0577605218,
0.0059724515,
0.0809799507,
0.0593876503,
0.024407804,
-0.0700022504,
-0.0658442825,
-0.0361400619,
-0.0784532502,
0.0005902449,
-0.0302677266,
0.0531321429,
0.0281825587,
-0.0671715364,
-0.0127557814,
-0.0226463731,
0.0229211319,
-0.0273133591,
-0.0176194087,
0.0060793459,
-0.0111511294,
-0.0159728713,
-0.0163193997,
-0.0416737609,
0.018882785,
-0.0345796905,
0.0113555798,
0.0050015501,
-0.0179091934,
-0.0435278043,
0.02693321,
-0.0375358537,
-0.080619745,
-0.0268854406,
0.0385448039,
0.0276126284,
-0.0005978443,
-0.0042055924,
-0.0315965898,
0.0396579616,
0.0324438773,
0.0005865266,
-0.0023473152,
0.0581725277,
-0.0097390823,
0.0046739737,
0.0095341839,
0.0265228711,
0.055688072,
0.0052274526,
0.0342548937,
-0.0287390556,
0.026590582,
0.0057967673,
0.0319020487,
0.0242396109,
0.0135998158,
-0.0652862042,
-0.0166139062,
-0.0094341179,
-0.0844196379,
-0.0244295858,
-0.0387034155,
0.0022609788,
-0.0190949552,
-0.0456498563,
-0.0199423227,
-0.0112319235,
-0.0470099747,
0.0406445265,
0.0201187339,
0.030340679,
0.0000116681,
0.0223828312,
-0.0201740451,
-0.0414080508,
-0.0267345253,
0.0358375795,
-0.0345478281,
0.0457391143,
-0.008231,
0.0524690188,
0.0038606417,
-0.0111379866,
0.0091706319,
0.017488664,
-0.0650093853,
-0.0442345962,
0.0023324618,
0.0052924054,
0.0348054618,
-0.010765654,
0.0603698082,
-0.0390093401,
-0.0054433998,
-0.0260404684,
0.0384591743,
0.0170739181,
-0.0295538511,
0.0372527689,
0.0231959075,
-0.0594191365,
0.000195967,
0.0476782657,
-0.0193928909,
0.0292940326,
0.0250461493,
0.0024444067,
-0.0389883891,
-0.050338041,
-0.0356728509,
0.0228653904,
0.0212888625,
-0.0313795507,
-0.0663005039,
-0.0124460757,
-0.0117797814,
0.0383753553,
0.0225090683,
0.0177215412,
0.0051438017,
0.0251413286,
-0.0169041306,
0.0425377451,
-0.0411794819,
-0.0015366527,
-0.0175078437,
0.0231433194,
-0.0038260079,
-6.427333481e-33,
-0.0159748476,
-0.0305004884,
0.0199819934,
0.0307100434,
-0.0043472908,
-0.0122845303,
-0.0475106835,
0.0219302233,
-0.0150597412,
0.069593057,
0.0146625163,
0.0235428549,
0.0189454071,
0.0031127699,
-0.0268409327,
-0.0087484419,
0.0314860828,
0.0088423518,
-0.0308515094,
0.0179056954,
0.0410879888,
-0.0444761738,
-0.0137033332,
-0.060984917,
0.017826356,
0.0232031606,
-0.0211875476,
-0.0302795935,
-0.0645362884,
0.0651191399,
-0.0191544518,
0.0458475724,
0.0188575163,
-0.0394312516,
0.0075863027,
0.0313805193,
-0.0469714589,
0.0056770393,
0.0366440192,
-0.0683805794,
0.0049580829,
-0.0699240416,
0.0051900903,
0.0439383909,
-0.0278632287,
0.0003864444,
-0.0105793709,
-0.0485839806,
0.0023890196,
-0.0228278581,
-0.0620902963,
0.0630379617,
-0.0404607393,
-0.0180366803,
-0.0067188395,
0.0291651655,
-0.0178583357,
0.069335565,
-0.0547591969,
0.0385126621,
0.0136569962,
-0.0255773012,
0.0339742824,
-0.055585403,
0.0019326682,
0.082916379,
-0.0044233468,
-0.0192923639,
-0.0509076379,
0.0329540186,
-0.0246358961,
0.0764031187,
0.0639970973,
0.0907567218,
0.0458746515,
-0.0236193798,
-0.1085514948,
-0.0323724225,
0.0271636788,
0.01694116,
0.0496888608,
-0.0260056239,
0.0002604943,
-0.0122375991,
-0.0461729765,
-0.0811744928,
-0.0119032171,
-0.0036016877,
0.0094300453,
0.0327266306,
-0.003479714,
-0.0201143511,
0.0106770108,
-0.0261887666,
0.0212631319,
0.0246532988,
-0.0376649052,
0.0038203879,
0.0123549877,
0.0162293278,
-0.0755837411,
0.0057019,
0.0345744155,
0.0220987312,
0.0370490886,
0.0008096911,
0.0302492734,
-0.0359365866,
-0.0446981974,
0.015507983,
-0.0351238735,
0.0379254147,
-0.0235851072,
0.020718012,
0.0003861001,
0.0129374238,
-0.0001493937,
0.0241205543,
-0.0354646929,
-0.0317121521,
-0.0059603364,
-0.0045156106,
-0.0141269062,
-0.0026012859,
-0.0362928994,
0.0279320162,
0.0060094651,
0.0140353972,
0.0421243235,
-0.0457864739,
-0.003145739,
-0.0095503144,
2.563e-7,
0.0335718058,
0.0568680875,
0.0221799798,
-0.0033387206,
0.0244176015,
0.0324625224,
-0.0272776224,
0.0042313761,
0.0022909499,
-0.0326192826,
-0.0427034274,
0.0388141647,
0.0637498125,
0.0386732928,
-0.0235602241,
-0.0378942415,
-0.0990430936,
-0.052090086,
-0.0485950299,
-0.0050234222,
0.0761281326,
0.0929941088,
0.0052542151,
0.0081785079,
-0.0007364399,
0.0023234372,
0.0856765211,
-0.0207392741,
-0.0186919998,
-0.013958104,
0.0422898754,
-0.0303642303,
0.0081826653,
0.0183594935,
-0.003543593,
0.0318648778,
-0.0443406738,
0.0841488466,
0.018744247,
-0.022698598,
-0.0025418415,
-0.0252091978,
0.0005857662,
-0.0442030653,
0.0641644225,
-0.0853153691,
-0.0412423722,
-0.0417166203,
-0.0343743339,
0.0085513648,
0.0207335167,
-0.0030364324,
-0.0246877726,
-0.021400122,
-0.0069950139,
-0.0072178296,
0.0291196723,
-0.0752243549,
-0.0237830374,
0.0084750419,
-0.0330635905,
-0.020918848,
-0.0289743189,
-0.0259947013,
0.0415745862,
-0.0550957546,
0.0155935464,
2.168328129e-34,
0.0651376173,
-0.0262283944,
0.0093889982,
-0.0030545031,
0.0529328808,
0.0389615409,
0.0053865705,
-0.0195479598,
0.0178852249,
-0.0645174161,
0.0208003987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09008v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09008v1 | End-to-end Task-oriented Dialogue: A Survey of Tasks, Methods, and Future Directions | 2023-11-15T14:50:16 | 2023-11-15T14:50:16 | Libo Qin, Wenbo Pan, Qiguang Chen, Lizi Liao, Zhou Yu, Yue Zhang, Wanxiang Che, Min Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end task-oriented dialogue (EToD) can directly generate responses in
an end-to-end fashion without modular training, which attracts escalating
popularity. The advancement of deep neural networks, especially the successful
use of large pre-trained models, has further led to significant progress in
EToD research in recent years. In this paper, we present a thorough review and
provide a unified perspective to summarize existing approaches as well as
recent trends to advance the development of EToD research. The contributions of
this paper can be summarized: (1) \textbf{\textit{First survey}}: to our
knowledge, we take the first step to present a thorough survey of this research
field; (2) \textbf{\textit{New taxonomy}}: we first introduce a unified
perspective for EToD, including (i) \textit{Modularly EToD} and (ii)
\textit{Fully EToD}; (3) \textbf{\textit{New Frontiers}}: we discuss some
potential frontier areas as well as the corresponding challenges, hoping to
spur breakthrough research in EToD field; (4) \textbf{\textit{Abundant
resources}}: we build a public website\footnote{We collect the related papers,
baseline projects, and leaderboards for the community at
\url{https://etods.net/}.}, where EToD researchers could directly access the
recent progress. We hope this work can serve as a thorough reference for the
EToD research community. | [
0.0765254796,
0.0434254445,
-0.0232926253,
0.0152460169,
0.0080073681,
-0.00954217,
0.0076296707,
-0.0518138371,
-0.0175366476,
-0.0275976174,
-0.0553062633,
-0.0171944071,
-0.0121389544,
0.0376769118,
0.0401826799,
-0.0753448382,
0.0256828591,
0.004955085,
0.0288472679,
-0.0056156339,
0.012349233,
-0.0159640498,
-0.0385946855,
0.0511638857,
0.0018713425,
-0.0214529354,
-0.0869911015,
-0.0049800524,
0.0204749331,
-0.0312906839,
0.01398551,
0.0177726913,
0.0340362042,
0.0051516457,
0.0000020304,
-0.0410709977,
0.0066815629,
-0.0314568765,
-0.041431684,
-0.0437871702,
0.0079177357,
0.0249734484,
0.0068977205,
0.0076600187,
-0.0639539286,
0.0006912911,
0.0673122481,
0.0842219591,
0.0669085532,
0.0795663148,
0.0039224061,
0.0019983647,
0.0402812101,
-0.034532208,
-0.0035723185,
-0.0364553295,
0.0074262526,
0.0078677572,
0.0145702073,
0.034200646,
0.0028252348,
-0.0014060562,
0.0464310832,
-0.0236974247,
0.0017261644,
0.0221691523,
-0.0207593124,
-0.0191669781,
-0.0493926555,
0.12289536,
0.0220241509,
0.0179248545,
0.0030888207,
-0.0061058449,
0.0368958786,
-0.0365006514,
-0.0583573096,
0.0231432691,
0.0077274553,
0.002785373,
-0.0281174872,
0.0483575054,
-0.0190617982,
0.0095546581,
-0.0130967209,
0.0436858423,
-0.0482948273,
-0.0412406586,
0.0128517989,
0.0018929981,
-0.0040074955,
-0.0949288234,
-0.0162744485,
0.0521101803,
-0.0492033586,
-0.0049819038,
-0.0137581453,
-0.0402504876,
0.0095407041,
-0.0281272158,
0.0552539676,
0.0318761542,
-0.0285695717,
-0.0047357008,
0.0371840261,
0.0351558328,
-0.0536914766,
-0.0222169086,
-0.0131741129,
0.0020315128,
-0.0614772923,
-0.0170607772,
-0.0556639805,
0.0493452288,
-0.0627269298,
-0.0188615359,
-0.0235401206,
0.0489307307,
-0.0475585498,
-0.0030187692,
0.0066891289,
0.0759155527,
-0.0539373457,
0.018558247,
-0.046066802,
0.0341019221,
-0.0360668749,
0.0428400114,
0.0379433446,
-0.0137671363,
0.0076572695,
0.0385058522,
0.0084679183,
0.0076960628,
0.0107676443,
0.0742135495,
-0.0223197211,
0.003953523,
0.0035906043,
-0.0344551764,
-0.0332591794,
-0.0736310035,
0.0715531334,
-0.0306744948,
0.021753272,
-0.0364461392,
-0.0145699894,
0.0163915511,
0.0222808272,
-0.0066675311,
0.0138061568,
0.0545198359,
-0.0016569826,
-0.0017532358,
0.0422814116,
0.0106052244,
-0.0162719432,
0.044487536,
0.0372881629,
0.0332973115,
-0.0001545111,
0.0039216094,
-0.0085614221,
0.0019103041,
0.0095141139,
-0.0136543009,
0.0375918746,
0.0414645933,
-0.0286012385,
0.0333333053,
0.0045853755,
0.047926072,
-0.0332233869,
-0.0061524892,
0.0650922433,
0.020752795,
0.0048813708,
0.0175105184,
0.0337744392,
0.0690581128,
0.0153382849,
-0.0059301308,
-0.0544199683,
0.0658490881,
0.0162092783,
-0.0056747347,
0.0433249734,
-0.0147251086,
-0.063281849,
-0.0653650463,
0.0293404907,
0.0076820152,
0.0374689177,
0.0580805838,
0.0350645594,
-0.0184417646,
-0.055411838,
-0.0007779156,
-0.0339488573,
-0.0311564077,
-0.0185898896,
-0.0550035462,
-0.001208874,
0.005090625,
0.0066423598,
-0.0317839459,
-0.0839580297,
-0.0374522731,
0.0160934348,
0.0687705204,
0.0234389845,
-0.0349678583,
0.0295463391,
-0.0438696779,
-0.0145984069,
-0.0502082892,
-0.0100589888,
0.0316789113,
-0.0097734267,
-0.002315023,
-0.0051143486,
0.0131416451,
0.0090008192,
-0.0025818534,
0.0118323928,
-0.0064890236,
0.0205831006,
0.0389197469,
0.0340002626,
0.0514300503,
-0.0014332308,
0.0060137981,
0.0331995785,
-0.0061061904,
-0.0250581875,
0.0193500053,
-0.0439812317,
-0.0485745296,
0.0210411884,
-0.0485499874,
-0.0283369534,
0.0490494147,
-0.026524609,
-0.0731562003,
0.0363752544,
-0.0447349027,
0.0038206342,
-0.0334197097,
0.0032823591,
0.0047917701,
0.0102350758,
-0.0052264598,
0.0280249231,
0.0181641057,
-0.0149654653,
0.0640413985,
0.0188165139,
0.0351114906,
-0.0751448125,
0.0050273696,
0.03516718,
-0.0176925883,
-0.0120507432,
0.0232071187,
0.0234818421,
-0.0435115919,
-0.0164386071,
-0.155663237,
0.0013375493,
-0.0257202145,
0.0117434189,
0.0059058866,
-0.0197949745,
0.0283986311,
-0.0313357487,
-0.0739401504,
0.0295299478,
0.0615152903,
-0.0091432678,
0.0449533276,
0.0453710109,
-0.00653743,
-0.0167981293,
0.0051185046,
0.0096668806,
0.0082678031,
0.0070427353,
-0.0205753073,
-0.045172289,
0.0080837337,
-0.0366940424,
0.0590920001,
-0.0319511443,
-0.0295625478,
0.056690298,
0.0218618922,
0.0166648719,
0.0554139651,
0.0331783444,
0.017791681,
0.0019053448,
-0.0326630883,
-0.0425616354,
0.0708556473,
-0.0176649541,
0.0146350237,
-0.0321801715,
-0.0267224759,
0.0274415556,
0.0456648767,
0.00369487,
0.0087448461,
-0.044181738,
0.0229462739,
0.0267817285,
-0.0530601889,
0.0079984488,
-0.0140425405,
-0.0128604313,
0.0265512075,
0.0042588972,
-0.0113086347,
0.0802745968,
0.0043614511,
-0.031500075,
-0.0577613786,
-0.0276013929,
-0.0326437838,
0.0542773269,
-0.0409195796,
0.0004341267,
0.0506764874,
-0.054344926,
-0.0705423728,
-0.0024151865,
-0.0113552809,
-0.0083776647,
0.0510148779,
-0.0196461864,
-0.0155243613,
-0.021612199,
-0.0467970185,
-0.0628774166,
-0.0147954309,
-0.0041874694,
0.0546480268,
-0.0076186527,
-0.0342862792,
-0.0157739799,
-0.0162032433,
0.0134952851,
0.0082497606,
-0.0178755112,
-0.0153518319,
-0.0365216509,
0.0370064341,
0.0407161862,
0.0472092405,
0.0098818233,
-0.0193966161,
0.0497101061,
0.0400776789,
0.0728448778,
0.0012823429,
-0.0285879709,
-0.0193104558,
0.0191617496,
0.0114677558,
-0.0109908152,
0.0089605451,
0.0495046154,
-0.0314509757,
0.0168877598,
0.0603957213,
-0.0031078081,
-0.0230240319,
-0.0161594264,
-0.0114765083,
-0.010962693,
0.0020095736,
0.021358924,
-0.0993062407,
-0.0299843866,
0.0033539424,
-0.004746485,
-0.0214014873,
-0.0282844231,
-0.0198506154,
-0.0670632049,
0.0405694917,
-0.0333679952,
-0.0181436539,
-0.0005208927,
0.0295342859,
0.0175966397,
0.030042965,
0.0156001318,
-0.0271893758,
0.0193674713,
-0.0453624539,
0.0137444977,
-0.0153067457,
0.0133837266,
0.0224422961,
-0.0231511872,
0.0476978607,
0.0671428815,
0.0419494361,
0.0084996792,
0.0129709868,
0.0111267706,
-0.0166853536,
-0.0001863271,
0.0110640647,
0.0379401296,
-0.0254927762,
-0.016461011,
0.0125474846,
0.0367664099,
-0.0134171834,
0.012797595,
0.0302980635,
0.0606303178,
-0.0798577964,
0.0167269092,
-0.03191147,
0.0343454964,
0.0702525675,
0.031992685,
0.0118010966,
-0.0679149628,
-0.0647682548,
-0.0037741372,
-0.0370959751,
-0.0669251084,
0.0253505576,
-0.0148392795,
0.0289975144,
0.0242452361,
-0.0708554238,
-0.0859718248,
0.0137214912,
0.0054178238,
0.0049818535,
-0.0350124389,
0.0196445584,
0.0181107745,
-0.0223699529,
0.0281574838,
-0.0011877819,
0.0013505005,
-0.0603898317,
-0.0197280552,
0.0307297222,
-0.0424867384,
0.0104972506,
0.0452289768,
-0.0785542205,
-0.0643482506,
-0.0426240079,
0.0631283373,
0.0174243785,
0.0327822939,
0.0125595452,
-0.0243539549,
0.0193938613,
0.011190705,
-0.0348117016,
-0.018011285,
0.0819910616,
0.0380588733,
-0.0190689135,
0.0407119989,
-0.0326810516,
0.0303209461,
0.0042202859,
0.019197451,
-0.0070993276,
-0.0576899722,
0.0099870209,
-0.0551701561,
0.0386062749,
0.0374319665,
-0.0561175719,
-0.0480730683,
0.0333328098,
-0.0053561893,
-0.0127025731,
-0.0787642598,
-0.0074836975,
-0.0498524196,
0.0032907019,
0.0472602509,
0.0310255438,
-0.026397191,
0.0228361078,
-0.0197595917,
0.0209362414,
-0.0045079044,
-0.0223779567,
0.0043096542,
0.0214607269,
-0.031396728,
0.0122888386,
0.0345770493,
0.0345132686,
0.0150283277,
0.1031487361,
0.0468223616,
-0.0312977694,
-0.0014219974,
0.0568102375,
-0.0683414266,
-0.0535995364,
0.0134888561,
0.0361824259,
0.0128579466,
0.0591209307,
-0.0074707791,
-0.0412138179,
0.0320911147,
-0.0023462393,
0.0605108179,
-0.0287628025,
-0.0025020468,
0.0342630073,
0.0073696086,
-0.0093440488,
0.0164557509,
0.0220384672,
0.0014087134,
-0.0012269855,
-0.0064829281,
0.0324012935,
-0.0565864146,
-0.0502086952,
0.0252153073,
0.0112289852,
-0.0269587841,
0.0176924523,
-0.0060604899,
-0.0266071744,
0.0048898673,
0.0253827125,
-0.0346807055,
-0.0420217328,
0.0446615331,
0.0407806523,
0.0098878108,
-0.0234889202,
-0.0202375036,
0.0207275841,
-0.0218078233,
-0.0092369076,
-0.0315584615,
-5.554190604e-33,
-0.0350061804,
-0.0312095433,
0.0327094421,
-0.000408554,
-0.0492491499,
-0.0302617345,
-0.0349105299,
0.0128958216,
-0.0456029139,
0.0032337497,
-0.0268125925,
0.0175709315,
0.0082883714,
0.0138023794,
0.0027693741,
-0.0179549046,
0.0377595201,
-0.0194746405,
0.010563964,
0.0723983496,
0.0329999477,
0.0022907553,
0.0547381118,
-0.0521784462,
0.0762856007,
0.0224226341,
0.0118224313,
0.0411601812,
-0.0059737219,
0.0461634211,
-0.0015234281,
0.0363684073,
0.0337557308,
-0.0630522892,
-0.0236938559,
0.0527098477,
-0.0625675321,
-0.0267413463,
-0.0116663026,
-0.0176918488,
-0.0967783555,
-0.0160414167,
0.0168067161,
-0.0023105012,
0.0319465026,
-0.0055169668,
0.0197661128,
0.0086965552,
0.0001369209,
0.0065803328,
-0.0579391494,
-0.0259359442,
-0.0281795841,
-0.0458993688,
-0.0118568474,
0.1088221595,
0.0007870063,
-0.0511271916,
-0.0355424657,
0.0326359496,
0.0361190103,
-0.0320294946,
0.0250972249,
0.0434110016,
0.0259652268,
0.0382824764,
0.0422272049,
0.0276660323,
-0.019131938,
-0.0328506008,
-0.0093465373,
0.0534596667,
0.0371708795,
0.0180561673,
-0.0157894623,
0.0423352495,
-0.055679962,
0.0064186053,
0.0226799585,
0.0450092442,
0.0078867124,
-0.0301271509,
-0.0279641412,
-0.0129786497,
-0.0268718377,
0.0170731079,
-0.0091235172,
-0.0377394445,
0.0414437316,
0.0172317158,
-0.0075449198,
0.0293683913,
0.0611835979,
-0.0654783845,
0.0268808343,
0.0355347581,
-0.0076403832,
0.0366581604,
-0.0098744184,
-0.0051330347,
-0.072168529,
-0.0133451819,
0.0046641198,
0.0143665476,
0.0013108387,
0.021127278,
0.0132703362,
0.0000385037,
-0.0112833986,
-0.0002973484,
-0.017492801,
0.0710050166,
-0.0224429183,
0.0639189929,
-0.0088044293,
0.0035848711,
-0.0227067675,
0.0664285719,
-0.039189361,
-0.0398020633,
-0.0530116893,
-0.0131771229,
0.0346316956,
0.0180055611,
-0.0416204035,
0.0108366441,
-0.0397941992,
-0.0033631085,
-0.0215467922,
-0.0133114643,
-0.0075395759,
0.0187703259,
2.576e-7,
-0.0458047912,
-0.0344294496,
0.0597478189,
0.015995048,
0.0213748328,
0.0453964323,
-0.0002108912,
0.0382397436,
0.0144695956,
-0.0204320401,
0.0163842756,
0.0217097159,
0.0592602976,
-0.0013658487,
-0.106010206,
-0.0564867444,
-0.0361205712,
-0.0050212382,
-0.0226567034,
0.0153100155,
0.0624755844,
0.0442199335,
-0.0271193739,
0.0066579739,
-0.009243438,
0.0336737074,
0.0682889521,
-0.0182009544,
0.0067982241,
0.0223945323,
0.0090290615,
-0.024460597,
-0.0406771563,
0.0247498676,
0.0040866188,
0.0340579227,
-0.0315299667,
0.0441840924,
-0.0054186699,
-0.0996263772,
-0.0033746539,
-0.0068610986,
0.0303636249,
-0.0368793681,
0.0534147322,
-0.1084034815,
-0.037649408,
0.002946622,
0.0212604981,
-0.0136693968,
-0.009794415,
-0.0124168331,
0.000014611,
-0.0304010641,
0.0183217134,
-0.0181973409,
0.0229364689,
-0.0686013177,
0.0340177603,
-0.0133890044,
-0.0620628819,
-0.0590909049,
-0.0472593345,
-0.0191665441,
0.0138269132,
-0.0207069609,
-0.0222029742,
1.710676151e-34,
0.0007728245,
0.0025250313,
0.0214081556,
0.042411346,
0.0023689186,
-0.0106392317,
-0.033507701,
-0.0283905063,
0.0536967516,
-0.079272531,
-0.028353503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09006v1 | Data Similarity is Not Enough to Explain Language Model Performance | 2023-11-15T14:48:08 | 2023-11-15T14:48:08 | Gregory Yauney, Emily Reif, David Mimno | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models achieve high performance on many but not all downstream
tasks. The interaction between pretraining data and task data is commonly
assumed to determine this variance: a task with data that is more similar to a
model's pretraining data is assumed to be easier for that model. We test
whether distributional and example-specific similarity measures (embedding-,
token- and model-based) correlate with language model performance through a
large-scale comparison of the Pile and C4 pretraining datasets with downstream
benchmarks. Similarity correlates with performance for multilingual datasets,
but in other benchmarks, we surprisingly find that similarity metrics are not
correlated with accuracy or even each other. This suggests that the
relationship between pretraining data and downstream tasks is more complex than
often assumed. | [
-0.0048594251,
0.054742936,
-0.0169899669,
0.0377850942,
-0.0216792412,
0.0418357328,
0.0362248421,
0.0198931098,
-0.0510316826,
-0.0498759598,
-0.069745034,
-0.0308685526,
0.0103419721,
0.0023780933,
0.0383687764,
-0.025329642,
0.0291638486,
-0.0083595766,
-0.0075146174,
-0.0166111682,
0.0022370599,
-0.0250113998,
0.0085590826,
0.0561615527,
-0.0030771068,
0.0082925241,
0.0263706576,
-0.0119802235,
-0.0105282012,
-0.0176164582,
0.0033646321,
0.0443335362,
0.0393610783,
0.0747124851,
0.0000016418,
-0.0393780731,
0.0208469015,
0.0076220674,
-0.0425574221,
0.0309698321,
0.0313875526,
0.0041206707,
-0.0000338374,
0.0194644071,
-0.0061910558,
-0.0770057142,
0.0728368238,
0.0348992236,
0.0098870406,
0.0582760721,
-0.0174039155,
-0.0131780319,
0.028768843,
-0.027294714,
-0.0158083234,
-0.0081514362,
0.0024449874,
0.0492960289,
-0.0193146914,
0.0193550438,
-0.0233105551,
0.0262703355,
0.0184237771,
0.0537694432,
-0.0204651877,
0.0663917065,
-0.0409373008,
0.0024031168,
0.029994756,
0.0513715521,
-0.0600051098,
-0.0693938211,
-0.0223495159,
-0.0059536379,
-0.0190343335,
0.0320014954,
-0.0492104441,
0.0277773514,
0.0297500044,
0.0442444347,
0.0309046898,
0.0126261655,
0.0503266342,
-0.0277573466,
-0.0244677477,
0.0086051449,
0.0350690484,
-0.0456380472,
0.0093529169,
0.0182117932,
-0.0134114204,
-0.0572904646,
-0.0257653184,
-0.0245602503,
-0.0110032437,
0.0000571647,
-0.0437535346,
-0.0322970822,
0.0214830805,
-0.0607963018,
0.0738047957,
0.0533596911,
-0.0327386633,
0.0310982205,
-0.034372896,
0.0570534281,
-0.0040464499,
0.0506450795,
-0.0556382425,
-0.0149522461,
-0.0752811506,
0.010156149,
-0.0367379934,
0.0174034648,
0.0181138813,
-0.0223753024,
-0.0360256359,
0.0307520032,
-0.0004343933,
-0.0158563424,
0.0173016135,
-0.0233699623,
-0.016707506,
0.0281919185,
-0.0146288089,
-0.0071434751,
-0.04342556,
0.0527570657,
-0.0121968342,
-0.0575121865,
0.0090702977,
0.0043289862,
0.0015280339,
-0.0365754366,
0.031167265,
0.0222129859,
-0.0052988525,
-0.0352257788,
-0.0153538967,
0.0257932711,
0.0092187691,
-0.0665341467,
-0.0163640305,
-0.0680712983,
0.039115116,
0.0284044873,
0.003007703,
-0.0089336056,
-0.0404577143,
0.0001647334,
-0.0252772011,
0.0790664405,
0.0117837079,
0.0259735622,
0.0090921931,
-0.0081079956,
-0.0253856089,
0.051642701,
-0.0108994022,
-0.0174009446,
0.0516069643,
-0.0290618781,
-0.0119927917,
0.0236406755,
0.0147669027,
0.0097723361,
-0.0244298298,
0.0198753104,
0.0130638201,
0.0205128081,
0.0543048196,
0.0327333584,
-0.0544096939,
-0.0246877894,
0.0568886064,
0.0953891948,
0.0464478843,
0.002469691,
0.0385938548,
-0.0030461911,
-0.0059795668,
0.0262695421,
-0.0569878072,
-0.0148639381,
0.0093366513,
0.0130478116,
0.028036477,
0.0319759212,
-0.058733914,
0.0027225178,
-0.0155488783,
-0.0265153367,
0.0086581232,
-0.0166913588,
0.0331210718,
-0.0193688739,
-0.0125854984,
0.0501233861,
0.0397175923,
-0.0580702275,
-0.0397900306,
-0.0426693968,
-0.0025947653,
0.026978109,
0.0081604971,
0.0054995813,
-0.0411474258,
0.0135901608,
0.028027596,
-0.0016993034,
0.0771774724,
-0.0154315997,
0.024757456,
-0.0459062494,
-0.0322026871,
-0.0030638985,
0.017852379,
0.0237613712,
-0.00040861,
0.0162780825,
0.0167377498,
-0.0690586939,
-0.0496462733,
0.0493381731,
-0.0567069724,
-0.0018725853,
-0.0139877237,
0.0050854785,
0.0374040753,
-0.0148767354,
-0.0389752425,
0.0206626374,
0.0233887807,
-0.0402401648,
-0.0084621832,
0.0334057435,
-0.0583834462,
-0.0099967569,
0.0509805158,
-0.0188696347,
0.0224982258,
0.0544105954,
-0.0246058591,
-0.044556994,
0.0400744863,
0.0104833161,
0.096330829,
-0.0494830608,
0.0463505723,
-0.0558532514,
0.0201185104,
-0.0100312242,
0.0495247096,
0.0061342167,
0.0701684132,
-0.0168237686,
0.0341278873,
0.0452440046,
-0.0003233033,
-0.0488029346,
0.0027252764,
-0.0038729201,
0.028896708,
0.0214487407,
-0.0085843969,
-0.0194731336,
0.0166757107,
-0.1161832884,
0.0009847814,
-0.0326658897,
0.011211074,
0.0378844179,
0.003158272,
-0.0196157992,
-0.0235169586,
-0.0320764817,
-0.02278639,
0.0087499749,
0.0579163507,
0.0074921977,
-0.0082784928,
-0.0298496094,
-0.0525295734,
-0.0390567631,
0.0019679237,
0.0637542158,
-0.0243996661,
0.0165704247,
-0.0430629477,
0.0586094707,
-0.0390930139,
0.0373421498,
-0.0203603189,
-0.0335307829,
0.019199606,
0.0120343547,
0.0604523383,
0.0220744908,
-0.028501533,
0.0080279214,
0.0634650514,
0.0265255626,
-0.0688102767,
-0.0326595902,
-0.0228404701,
-0.0225292798,
-0.0526870452,
-0.0262270272,
-0.0026109486,
0.0610341914,
0.0025390694,
-0.0355425552,
-0.0537504181,
-0.0047762305,
-0.0486860797,
0.0259699635,
-0.0502341278,
-0.0075452463,
-0.0010835789,
0.0295081921,
-0.0239729714,
-0.071992889,
0.0525492057,
-0.0440925695,
-0.0039025184,
-0.035305161,
-0.0268128123,
-0.0184475705,
0.0645639971,
0.0250001699,
0.0110507738,
-0.0234278347,
-0.0059686536,
-0.0425340086,
0.0417173691,
0.0171368923,
-0.0099793822,
0.0430262014,
0.0021100065,
0.0152265336,
-0.0162273832,
-0.0437766053,
-0.0234221909,
-0.0341857336,
0.0109110726,
0.0302038807,
0.0327278115,
-0.026404744,
-0.0234987792,
0.0301305614,
-0.020797383,
0.0518912524,
0.0086767543,
-0.0044851261,
-0.0070668417,
0.0204164889,
0.0149674835,
0.0131544154,
0.009536841,
-0.0378683209,
0.0172606856,
-0.0106051238,
0.0774292126,
-0.0047075227,
-0.0574669018,
0.0075567467,
0.0194658823,
-0.019985389,
-0.0437183455,
0.017689297,
0.0379451104,
-0.0127515066,
-0.0227405671,
0.1210744679,
0.0146276942,
-0.0296166204,
0.013619435,
0.0004581451,
0.0471834838,
0.0501800478,
-0.0099071339,
-0.0519644618,
-0.0142317973,
0.0151761994,
-0.0116601484,
0.0282390025,
-0.0115275355,
0.004509144,
-0.0933731347,
0.0075343321,
-0.0271295533,
-0.0935672671,
-0.0257327277,
-0.0696631148,
-0.0042178314,
-0.0124539994,
0.0291337222,
-0.007477867,
-0.013447294,
-0.0023972942,
0.0361046195,
-0.0022341886,
-0.0907668397,
0.0501068309,
-0.0874538422,
0.071032472,
0.0398490354,
0.0210914724,
-0.0028897014,
-0.0317365527,
0.0445249341,
-0.0057379669,
-0.0245961286,
0.0139015252,
0.0453078002,
0.0172984321,
-0.0159553606,
0.0047960472,
-0.0110641532,
-0.0209278073,
0.0172411278,
-0.028256176,
0.0748677552,
-0.0168076176,
-0.0425344706,
-0.0055473521,
-0.0311726537,
-0.0066033844,
0.0991956517,
0.0515683815,
-0.0195714068,
-0.0235576332,
0.0106107052,
0.0160492565,
0.0070658582,
0.011669117,
0.0314845331,
-0.0290503688,
-0.0218497999,
-0.0549626872,
-0.0368409716,
0.0230878498,
0.0355865397,
0.0024435336,
0.0326050334,
-0.0062743486,
-0.0366983823,
-0.0513493121,
0.0450113006,
-0.0087610995,
0.020419538,
-0.0794922486,
-0.0340417996,
0.0224413592,
0.0185141899,
-0.0387366489,
-0.0442520045,
-0.0956008658,
-0.0444834046,
-0.0106380749,
0.0087758163,
0.0192634612,
0.0432700366,
0.011755039,
-0.0466187932,
0.0167784318,
-0.0139398593,
-0.0736030489,
0.0145755392,
0.0257156119,
-0.0707216859,
0.0208457559,
0.0416502729,
-0.043450661,
0.0342990905,
0.0399565808,
0.0220772643,
-0.0090120099,
-0.0175597817,
0.0017505531,
0.0132726477,
0.048615519,
-0.0088954419,
-0.0447381139,
-0.042845726,
0.0081851128,
-0.0152327213,
0.0005430353,
-0.0308866799,
-0.0248355996,
0.0414449722,
0.0470229536,
-0.0020235123,
0.0099404855,
-0.0154492259,
0.0602661557,
-0.0281537138,
0.0122436248,
0.0029253659,
0.0453708991,
0.0378629863,
0.0196719617,
-0.0140658636,
-0.0162591822,
-0.0114460178,
0.0187484045,
-0.0584179088,
0.0002248203,
0.0226231795,
0.0420996733,
-0.0119116828,
0.0371022709,
-0.0614803247,
-0.0484219082,
-0.0032384528,
-0.0179113504,
0.0590892546,
-0.0716829374,
0.0609092675,
-0.0296642501,
0.0057572811,
-0.0365846343,
-0.0131979575,
-0.0201740954,
-0.019494202,
0.0560814478,
0.0070691328,
-0.0356628783,
0.0107081803,
0.0947813168,
0.017650377,
0.0358755775,
-0.0202117767,
-0.0222297069,
-0.0141242296,
-0.023352081,
0.052073203,
0.0351103023,
-0.0393207483,
-0.0021142419,
-0.0269206949,
-0.0876447484,
-0.0173746366,
0.0233686306,
-0.0204023868,
0.0318661332,
0.0387603603,
0.0749710724,
-0.0160586238,
0.0077111567,
-0.0283552743,
-0.0300946031,
0.0059894025,
-0.0282615311,
-0.0162412878,
-5.728925268e-33,
-0.0063325497,
0.0345288664,
0.022814434,
-0.0255647376,
0.0079018781,
0.0274872743,
-0.0212035514,
0.0117193451,
-0.0569904298,
0.0088437479,
-0.0066485754,
0.0038341056,
0.0110618006,
0.022330083,
0.0109945219,
0.0133183803,
0.0361860022,
-0.0107897976,
-0.019458795,
0.0133065758,
0.0503459461,
0.0197407715,
0.0693392456,
-0.026726706,
0.0029780299,
-0.0120536163,
0.0446771532,
-0.0062114885,
0.0275021084,
0.0677087978,
-0.047640238,
0.0437356494,
0.0352674946,
-0.0244734138,
-0.0487680212,
-0.006206587,
-0.0565393157,
-0.0602748655,
0.0333696157,
0.0186894499,
0.0080708684,
0.0264038462,
0.0319197923,
-0.0100816935,
-0.0396171249,
0.0083875414,
0.0282074418,
-0.0212192982,
-0.0176582821,
0.0002033827,
-0.0695510656,
0.0227363333,
0.002059313,
-0.00178688,
0.0470907278,
0.0291775092,
0.0016031638,
0.0158252493,
-0.0577554367,
0.0243840367,
-0.0210564155,
0.0570925362,
0.0608199425,
0.0277231298,
0.0348831229,
0.0660467371,
0.0457037911,
-0.0323090479,
0.0104501257,
0.0152219618,
0.0941781327,
0.0357786082,
0.0259634797,
0.0002030241,
0.0640022606,
-0.019106457,
-0.0707619935,
0.0349528044,
-0.0129240118,
-0.0124374935,
0.0179182403,
0.0250550732,
-0.037076246,
-0.0414505303,
-0.0385034755,
0.0352967381,
-0.0344856642,
-0.037408486,
0.0522059835,
-0.0134669663,
0.0271476209,
-0.0092749931,
0.0481033847,
-0.0505222008,
-0.0605335198,
0.029430775,
-0.0183105264,
0.0050684828,
-0.0047121849,
0.0257065371,
-0.0797028616,
-0.0467809848,
0.0063188579,
-0.0030040536,
0.0209790561,
-0.0207391772,
0.0627990812,
0.0187268015,
-0.0831190199,
-0.0031707385,
-0.021106163,
-0.042446278,
0.012173105,
0.0219229031,
0.0382863767,
0.010620079,
0.0037687891,
0.0277323667,
0.0528841205,
-0.0426169597,
-0.0529176444,
-0.0008231436,
0.0031929491,
0.0255774725,
-0.0047111586,
-0.00711708,
-0.0841365233,
0.0329532363,
0.0509689748,
-0.047063522,
-0.0246080197,
0.0059385165,
2.272e-7,
0.06087346,
0.0163174774,
0.0138827739,
0.0013428191,
-0.00391893,
0.0210881885,
-0.0557245351,
0.0076405089,
-0.0038062818,
0.0458575711,
0.0167877488,
0.0181390885,
0.0405406021,
0.0289986748,
-0.0360834375,
0.0088082831,
-0.1174472347,
-0.007528319,
-0.0609964617,
0.0098525491,
0.0027366923,
0.1044446826,
0.024387978,
-0.0252535623,
-0.0084876763,
-0.0479273163,
0.0535719581,
-0.0579976067,
0.0215276405,
0.0261640586,
-0.0083991587,
0.0201430395,
0.002330848,
0.0361434184,
-0.0166743416,
0.0238750037,
0.029536074,
0.0042243251,
-0.0028174103,
0.0142780812,
-0.0101213865,
-0.0264072716,
-0.0281740148,
-0.080655925,
0.0619930066,
-0.0225229803,
-0.0318199731,
-0.0528536439,
-0.0033982743,
0.0262308717,
0.0513041951,
-0.009097388,
-0.0294516422,
0.0242409166,
0.049623061,
-0.0250708517,
-0.0166910123,
-0.0631674603,
-0.0270263609,
0.0403853431,
-0.0423710681,
-0.0454340838,
-0.0456380323,
-0.0096152415,
0.0636411458,
-0.0128507484,
0.0201777015,
2.287982893e-34,
0.0344308242,
0.0268442407,
0.0524118617,
-0.0057225521,
0.0200755633,
-0.0396710671,
0.0235834494,
0.0093951495,
-0.0347656012,
-0.0481410362,
-0.0012278918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09000v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09000v3 | Factcheck-Bench: Fine-Grained Evaluation Benchmark for Automatic Fact-checkers | 2023-11-15T14:41:57 | 2024-04-16T07:41:43 | Yuxia Wang, Revanth Gangi Reddy, Zain Muhammad Mujahid, Arnav Arora, Aleksandr Rubashevskii, Jiahui Geng, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Liangming Pan, Nadav Borenstein, Aditya Pillai, Isabelle Augenstein, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increased use of large language models (LLMs) across a variety of
real-world applications calls for mechanisms to verify the factual accuracy of
their outputs. In this work, we present a holistic end-to-end solution for
annotating the factuality of LLM-generated responses, which encompasses a
multi-stage annotation scheme designed to yield detailed labels concerning the
verifiability and factual inconsistencies found in LLM outputs. We further
construct an open-domain document-level factuality benchmark in three-level
granularity: claim, sentence and document, aiming to facilitate the evaluation
of automatic fact-checking systems. Preliminary experiments show that FacTool,
FactScore and Perplexity.ai are struggling to identify false claims, with the
best F1=0.63 by this annotation solution based on GPT-4. Annotation tool,
benchmark and code are available at https://github.com/yuxiaw/Factcheck-GPT. | [
0.0191320665,
0.0098081157,
0.0101903183,
0.0612674989,
-0.0446824543,
0.0146407625,
-0.0078294491,
-0.0383709036,
0.0218587667,
-0.0903800353,
0.0262073949,
-0.0116556911,
0.0122688496,
0.0241672155,
0.0062631415,
0.0163589977,
0.0672233552,
0.0000786549,
0.0513015389,
-0.0133405868,
0.0033329974,
0.0514523536,
-0.0301587619,
0.0407247134,
-0.0690630227,
-0.0363307819,
0.026766764,
-0.0206093118,
0.0259534139,
-0.0445088968,
0.007929178,
0.0471298322,
-0.0053844731,
0.1082484499,
0.0000018894,
-0.0671858639,
0.0076070982,
0.0570109263,
-0.0495170988,
0.0722122267,
0.0186274908,
0.0245063081,
-0.0312374625,
0.0041409456,
-0.017264694,
-0.0353440493,
0.0404721089,
0.0402772762,
0.0881116614,
0.0848413333,
-0.0050444235,
-0.0106368903,
0.0463222414,
0.0099207321,
-0.0323003419,
-0.0288399328,
0.0305902287,
0.0567607731,
-0.0353311375,
0.0020429236,
0.0268185474,
0.0211362727,
0.0178952049,
-0.0252628978,
-0.0380482636,
0.0161496457,
-0.0558022857,
-0.0113655627,
0.0056960806,
0.0307465829,
0.0202501453,
-0.0401682667,
-0.0192708299,
-0.0286352579,
-0.0168193877,
-0.0004283065,
0.0036722256,
0.0276539214,
-0.0279403627,
0.0114506399,
0.0455173962,
-0.0276387781,
0.0240304098,
0.0220839549,
0.0160255115,
0.0966354087,
0.0028294246,
-0.0450707562,
0.0057987021,
0.0073037469,
-0.0074655283,
-0.082508333,
-0.0094423257,
0.0063656545,
0.0078757852,
-0.0041223108,
-0.02685613,
-0.0142232459,
0.0859309733,
-0.0761827007,
0.0157768242,
0.001194548,
-0.0710183382,
0.065971382,
-0.0185884945,
0.0542172305,
-0.0018014126,
-0.0096118543,
0.0284852013,
-0.0210816469,
-0.016820658,
0.0257473979,
0.0076535088,
0.0189493317,
-0.0033104143,
0.0212150831,
-0.0433224477,
-0.0084012998,
-0.0210525114,
0.0633757189,
0.0026405742,
-0.0350035541,
-0.0013549813,
-0.0128041208,
-0.0642153174,
0.0361857526,
-0.0218632184,
0.0297759194,
-0.0257709082,
-0.0626490116,
0.0062218737,
0.0309794117,
-0.0183193348,
-0.0138069717,
0.0125162825,
-0.0188159551,
0.0085956641,
0.0054477234,
-0.045359876,
-0.0058785705,
-0.0074068708,
-0.0874714479,
-0.0337725654,
-0.0872733444,
-0.0055142562,
0.0041467845,
-0.0138009163,
-0.001683458,
0.0034353773,
0.0235126466,
0.001427947,
0.034822233,
-0.0246971752,
-0.0188403372,
0.0434102751,
-0.027581539,
0.0166254658,
0.0403768942,
0.0441219024,
0.0200893506,
0.0570242591,
0.0365500115,
0.0080397977,
0.0166116208,
0.014656242,
0.0185135566,
0.0583218075,
0.0198456477,
0.0066974559,
-0.0056988928,
0.0072490349,
0.043458011,
-0.0030188335,
-0.0228834562,
0.0633298233,
0.0035756291,
-0.0190728214,
-0.0238804501,
0.040297538,
0.0005340807,
0.0652759969,
0.0109382318,
-0.0503573082,
0.0160516351,
-0.0367120132,
0.0022048375,
0.0259742308,
0.0696995109,
0.0251229964,
-0.0381657034,
-0.0357803069,
-0.0031456589,
-0.0187067371,
-0.0101643791,
0.0192779675,
-0.0118262079,
-0.0416133925,
0.0195598677,
0.0233045202,
-0.05036759,
-0.0179946683,
-0.0504011698,
0.0372825712,
0.0127808051,
0.0432789251,
-0.0244722646,
-0.0202967636,
-0.0287184529,
-0.0143024195,
0.0697715804,
0.0764103085,
-0.0041226465,
0.0003974008,
-0.0032560059,
0.0218474139,
-0.0428120531,
0.0421416946,
0.0009367663,
0.0465591736,
-0.0042788913,
0.0114867464,
-0.0534248203,
-0.0381489359,
0.0227008071,
0.0087368647,
-0.0084019275,
0.0054652495,
-0.0118956389,
0.0200978965,
0.0332789794,
-0.0396751054,
0.0041454448,
0.0213370584,
0.0127963498,
0.009364794,
-0.0267708115,
0.0671895146,
-0.0051111728,
0.073182337,
-0.0066116601,
-0.0586198978,
0.0536052957,
-0.0358780138,
-0.0071699792,
-0.0490406044,
-0.0374379568,
-0.0058196909,
-0.0701089129,
0.0041247504,
-0.0013036863,
0.0262707528,
0.0065175742,
0.0679213181,
-0.0073259305,
0.0011414371,
-0.0438789316,
0.0015934083,
0.0561071113,
-0.0185119528,
-0.04519853,
0.0164134279,
0.014039414,
0.0268865451,
0.0397340655,
-0.0109390914,
-0.0210488532,
-0.0007457108,
-0.0810231268,
0.0236683935,
-0.0133222593,
0.0214175973,
0.0097615365,
-0.0483589582,
-0.0104924766,
0.021851588,
0.0039548054,
-0.0110509582,
0.0197998509,
0.0082390374,
0.05931025,
-0.0213713106,
0.0029308877,
-0.0295331851,
0.0365664177,
-0.0472945832,
0.0122132692,
0.0430486351,
-0.0140427751,
-0.0307957679,
-0.0066963793,
-0.060557805,
0.0355945602,
0.0092239929,
-0.0172977746,
0.0356684476,
0.0303987563,
0.0178570393,
0.0348753668,
0.0187592767,
0.0137071991,
0.0604024865,
-0.0046682074,
-0.0167881493,
0.0183137842,
-0.0079618488,
0.0026655493,
-0.0130390944,
-0.0514302105,
0.0301725212,
0.0078207152,
0.0221789163,
-0.0068416097,
-0.0189776607,
0.0285585131,
-0.0334608965,
-0.0078394962,
0.0337931737,
0.0020949782,
-0.0151442736,
0.0562225804,
-0.0007537077,
-0.0254921038,
0.060492523,
-0.0766000524,
0.0310356915,
-0.0453119352,
-0.0052090087,
-0.0101846932,
0.051754389,
-0.0111780381,
0.0136799021,
-0.0078035244,
0.0225040484,
0.0169193409,
-0.0288737528,
0.0539341047,
-0.0370402858,
0.0413091891,
-0.0446776748,
0.031691689,
0.0049437624,
-0.0301365647,
-0.0168314688,
-0.0687764436,
-0.0412857458,
-0.0054583303,
-0.0291360542,
-0.0324315466,
-0.0549287312,
-0.0217162892,
0.0553675368,
0.0631427392,
-0.0057546459,
0.0079171974,
0.014874001,
0.0168952942,
0.018123446,
0.036925029,
0.0589774475,
0.0192636903,
-0.0202551503,
0.0636625066,
-0.0502134822,
0.0181617625,
-0.0362148285,
-0.0659814328,
-0.0228608847,
-0.0413356312,
0.008104194,
-0.0117806783,
0.0381813683,
-0.0701443255,
-0.0040489328,
0.0882960036,
0.0304534659,
0.0179749578,
-0.0020083417,
0.0060800011,
-0.0012356434,
0.0246643219,
0.0253237914,
-0.1160993576,
0.0013644347,
-0.0196394529,
-0.003172003,
-0.0317680798,
-0.0050061462,
-0.0183379911,
-0.1311133802,
0.0692982227,
-0.0195271708,
-0.0101834517,
-0.0500421822,
-0.0507244617,
0.0019786775,
0.0122670354,
0.0039066514,
0.0060317982,
0.0416720025,
-0.0246015675,
0.0064140791,
-0.0346194059,
-0.0420410931,
0.0542445481,
-0.0072332141,
0.0582551435,
0.0277597662,
0.0342055745,
-0.0265235733,
-0.0266365334,
0.0263445508,
-0.001462569,
-0.056167718,
0.006331617,
0.0449141301,
-0.0201300774,
0.0040423712,
-0.0057612173,
-0.0182904769,
0.033758834,
-0.0315407403,
0.012011325,
0.0649391934,
-0.0124933049,
-0.003925507,
-0.0122592133,
0.0131101189,
-0.0048037563,
0.0877734274,
0.0010077277,
0.0347515605,
-0.0324430987,
-0.0526362062,
-0.0221639201,
-0.0263206158,
-0.027518604,
0.039803762,
-0.0147203533,
-0.032110054,
-0.0665401071,
-0.0071336152,
-0.000443257,
-0.0205952674,
-0.0272073373,
-0.0157169793,
0.0472676195,
0.0066483449,
-0.015686933,
0.0075196279,
-0.036380019,
0.0399198569,
-0.0082224635,
0.0059393756,
0.0481258817,
-0.0096870437,
-0.0199389402,
0.0552207902,
-0.0662385672,
-0.042600967,
-0.0016544935,
0.0058095013,
0.017050758,
0.0438545607,
-0.047128018,
-0.0128117977,
0.0107480008,
0.0492101498,
-0.043963436,
0.0345585681,
0.0145199345,
-0.0131033249,
-0.0111271702,
-0.0008647045,
-0.0379145704,
0.0202723499,
-0.0428076088,
0.0346157588,
-0.0064670332,
-0.0522841737,
0.0405400954,
0.0674538389,
0.0433961898,
-0.0143104047,
0.0085701272,
-0.0316774026,
0.0064457571,
-0.0383703336,
-0.0521554612,
0.002177506,
0.0151788397,
-0.0111160688,
-0.0327582955,
-0.0238622595,
-0.0049357866,
-0.0404717177,
0.0404122733,
-0.0079042129,
-0.0137454001,
-0.005879744,
0.0215830971,
-0.0240320358,
-0.0485190824,
-0.0525667667,
-0.0094004404,
-0.0136206476,
0.0414321013,
0.0003937152,
0.0188838094,
0.0216540638,
-0.0148137519,
0.0141254086,
-0.0276553892,
-0.0421914533,
0.0169669632,
-0.0575288273,
0.0215990376,
0.0491318554,
0.0152134076,
0.0689641535,
-0.0485043265,
-0.0427961797,
-0.0184047688,
-0.0035950504,
0.0183664244,
-0.002654932,
0.0145271439,
-0.0132375201,
-0.0353183225,
0.0284152329,
0.0349154025,
0.010166904,
0.0543006472,
0.0439875536,
-0.0469892696,
-0.0520813465,
-0.0841225088,
-0.0730312467,
0.019104261,
0.0033176776,
-0.0165306423,
-0.0958965719,
-0.0586130768,
0.0097425804,
0.0585107096,
0.0219882652,
-0.0038577993,
-0.0229954217,
0.0712147206,
0.0125511875,
-0.0494417623,
-0.0575262718,
0.0094277682,
-0.0148108238,
0.0025576602,
-0.0095705101,
-6.344247337e-33,
-0.033125829,
-0.0636813939,
-0.0038128663,
0.0287365913,
-0.0111889429,
0.0258442685,
-0.0314167254,
-0.0286769178,
-0.0508917458,
0.0633351654,
0.0287299473,
0.0240883082,
0.0105567854,
-0.0201811809,
-0.0429141819,
-0.0106810099,
0.0308028292,
0.0065781428,
-0.0545851551,
0.003578698,
0.0242050588,
-0.0627134964,
0.0648656562,
-0.1021594033,
0.0596751161,
-0.017200252,
-0.0610195696,
0.0226356406,
-0.0552223995,
0.0649128333,
-0.0096012102,
0.0436704792,
0.02695054,
-0.0288676675,
0.032747779,
-0.0415045694,
-0.0352311172,
-0.0120724747,
0.0648594797,
-0.0248224139,
0.0000974571,
0.0064617842,
-0.0071590664,
0.0040295827,
-0.0303389356,
-0.0120041799,
0.0303903148,
-0.0218556896,
0.0116128419,
-0.0305516217,
-0.0739070699,
0.0485569127,
0.0020282706,
0.0069668833,
-0.0539040193,
0.0183441211,
0.0171630271,
0.0055698478,
-0.0743381232,
0.0001759649,
0.0097034639,
-0.0077008214,
0.0450702757,
-0.0419700481,
-0.0373269022,
0.0540326573,
-0.0294916686,
0.0376319513,
-0.0564049073,
0.0091945557,
0.0116835954,
0.0187350698,
0.0467775501,
0.1188606247,
-0.0022931991,
0.0028053706,
-0.0790982917,
0.0420286432,
0.0469195098,
0.0078412546,
0.0266952869,
-0.0389096364,
-0.0275458042,
0.0104236109,
-0.0618595853,
0.027988771,
-0.040744938,
0.0177591648,
0.0036267429,
-0.0154560572,
-0.0208578203,
0.023926137,
0.0053615635,
-0.0281091295,
0.0136482744,
0.0172029249,
-0.0576967932,
0.0310384203,
0.0044841934,
0.0434775092,
-0.0260724425,
0.041116897,
-0.0141685801,
0.0185486972,
0.0150503758,
0.0190785304,
0.0387136638,
-0.0016961936,
-0.0567976758,
0.0375518054,
-0.0124871563,
0.0167596489,
-0.0272071343,
-0.0404174365,
0.0128716528,
-0.0020935102,
-0.0080297953,
0.0225609969,
0.0117333746,
0.0516194515,
-0.0299955793,
-0.0066952771,
0.0285189524,
0.0208798628,
-0.0254454445,
0.0150854709,
-0.0183178764,
0.0037379281,
-0.0005614397,
-0.0627654269,
0.0250686947,
0.02917636,
2.579e-7,
0.0454863608,
0.0801915675,
0.0148099596,
0.0166368131,
0.0118142329,
0.036789611,
-0.0038051473,
0.0049977493,
0.0064936779,
-0.0564790145,
-0.0463496819,
0.019418288,
0.0401151627,
0.0759742931,
-0.0219640788,
0.0094157839,
-0.0523146391,
-0.0245090276,
-0.0680168495,
0.0204326194,
0.0217605755,
0.0451999865,
0.0477459542,
-0.0017108042,
-0.0158933904,
-0.0132853659,
0.046345301,
0.0270875432,
-0.0728658885,
0.0224618055,
0.0677889436,
0.0018187684,
0.0307606161,
0.0297096428,
-0.030233115,
0.0148603218,
-0.0185195729,
0.0511890501,
0.000844546,
-0.0175935235,
-0.0326315872,
-0.0403798297,
0.0189258195,
-0.0818306953,
0.0481024794,
0.0240733437,
-0.0375855155,
-0.0849482864,
-0.0375774018,
0.012885455,
0.038909357,
-0.0207312778,
-0.0323611647,
0.0146323461,
-0.0094565246,
0.0128072705,
-0.0212796219,
0.0110080587,
-0.0499974303,
0.0231309887,
-0.0330059752,
-0.0851166248,
0.0371372811,
-0.0136444056,
0.0341743529,
-0.0678469688,
0.0394134074,
2.360314826e-34,
0.0460485965,
-0.018868383,
0.0017405053,
-0.0272690114,
0.0844545588,
0.0507949926,
-0.0322810784,
-0.0055680214,
-0.0088176131,
-0.034245532,
0.0128314542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08993v1 | When does In-context Learning Fall Short and Why? A Study on Specification-Heavy Tasks | 2023-11-15T14:26:30 | 2023-11-15T14:26:30 | Hao Peng, Xiaozhi Wang, Jianhui Chen, Weikai Li, Yunjia Qi, Zimu Wang, Zhili Wu, Kaisheng Zeng, Bin Xu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In-context learning (ICL) has become the default method for using large
language models (LLMs), making the exploration of its limitations and
understanding the underlying causes crucial. In this paper, we find that ICL
falls short of handling specification-heavy tasks, which are tasks with
complicated and extensive task specifications, requiring several hours for
ordinary humans to master, such as traditional information extraction tasks.
The performance of ICL on these tasks mostly cannot reach half of the
state-of-the-art results. To explore the reasons behind this failure, we
conduct comprehensive experiments on 18 specification-heavy tasks with various
LLMs and identify three primary reasons: inability to specifically understand
context, misalignment in task schema comprehension with humans, and inadequate
long-text understanding ability. Furthermore, we demonstrate that through
fine-tuning, LLMs can achieve decent performance on these tasks, indicating
that the failure of ICL is not an inherent flaw of LLMs, but rather a drawback
of existing alignment methods that renders LLMs incapable of handling
complicated specification-heavy tasks via ICL. To substantiate this, we perform
dedicated instruction tuning on LLMs for these tasks and observe a notable
improvement. We hope the analyses in this paper could facilitate advancements
in alignment methods enabling LLMs to meet more sophisticated human demands. | [
0.0314919129,
0.0181629136,
0.0052953642,
0.0430099703,
-0.0424916036,
0.0344612002,
-0.0078473752,
-0.0393247865,
-0.0236965045,
-0.032439936,
-0.0400652625,
-0.0355488174,
0.0116146961,
-0.0245980639,
0.0117413551,
-0.0310503598,
0.0443873219,
-0.0368190221,
-0.0290065575,
0.0195405427,
-0.0078179734,
-0.0007172968,
0.0133891394,
0.0049188435,
0.0030473915,
-0.0525234602,
-0.0170345176,
0.0236210823,
0.0084564947,
-0.0245594848,
0.0111757386,
0.0325259566,
0.0367540419,
0.0231358819,
0.0000021484,
-0.0653271154,
-0.0181989707,
-0.0096212113,
-0.0499644876,
0.0431385562,
0.0258390065,
-0.0290922243,
-0.0215927735,
0.0040712673,
-0.0281844493,
0.0145635847,
0.0369088612,
0.0396140702,
0.0223753247,
0.089526549,
-0.0077496869,
-0.0237341896,
0.0078422753,
-0.0254299883,
0.0128417928,
-0.0673314705,
0.036318697,
-0.0082007842,
0.0289087277,
0.0146443015,
-0.0044278563,
0.0359375253,
0.0157809258,
0.03019909,
-0.0112633798,
0.0370641463,
-0.0186567195,
-0.0260835122,
-0.0112341512,
0.0797849074,
-0.0086746477,
0.0037618328,
0.0059695658,
0.0070876586,
-0.001135488,
-0.0321419276,
-0.04288188,
0.0322315656,
-0.0259027854,
0.0147463372,
0.02120452,
-0.0063397265,
0.0403299183,
0.0031714046,
-0.0389956124,
0.0343588479,
-0.0059512584,
-0.0480798259,
-0.0087309694,
-0.0072198622,
-0.0405192971,
-0.0254695136,
-0.0245958194,
0.018627042,
-0.0776804611,
0.046158459,
-0.0621040091,
-0.0386698246,
0.0003620913,
-0.0297150183,
0.0282118823,
0.0522202104,
0.0042694001,
0.0647760481,
-0.0346533209,
0.0688798577,
-0.0371426158,
0.0183143336,
-0.0580939651,
-0.0062412415,
-0.0423861854,
0.0046983478,
-0.0351898149,
0.0096109407,
-0.0485379621,
-0.0365295261,
-0.0101812147,
0.0840731189,
-0.0038035358,
0.04093647,
-0.0127411075,
-0.0246767681,
-0.03824706,
-0.0135989236,
-0.0099445935,
0.0145458039,
-0.0066800648,
-0.0068062977,
0.001053647,
-0.0135076996,
-0.0136056226,
0.0270103831,
0.0039153453,
-0.0453813151,
0.002844387,
0.0602218769,
-0.0127708996,
-0.0344454311,
-0.0325575396,
0.0019492845,
-0.0174875706,
-0.0802663863,
-0.033378344,
-0.0512637869,
0.0284886397,
0.0369787812,
-0.0170072541,
-0.0276018139,
0.0067537553,
0.0270060021,
-0.0157560036,
0.0844051465,
0.0074631847,
0.0289099719,
0.026246354,
0.0086961212,
-0.0073053022,
0.072199896,
0.0008975663,
0.0222190395,
0.0050691827,
0.0049822219,
-0.0118146706,
0.0555733554,
-0.0080793155,
0.0043728068,
-0.017405536,
0.0267196447,
0.0542484783,
0.0473597907,
0.0638885573,
0.048311118,
0.0063999305,
0.012415613,
0.08431831,
0.0345434733,
0.0088632135,
-0.017397305,
0.0065012225,
0.0343241915,
-0.0057887821,
0.0200800765,
-0.0760768205,
0.0013833037,
-0.0205650572,
0.0505659841,
0.0028651231,
0.0276830215,
-0.0144715244,
-0.0326567404,
-0.015167987,
-0.011391175,
0.0114661437,
0.0465947129,
0.0666029155,
-0.0224026367,
-0.0678928345,
0.0210686624,
0.0331955627,
0.0017610976,
-0.0006651281,
-0.0207113922,
0.0298464019,
0.0869167075,
0.036399018,
-0.0437737927,
-0.0367793404,
0.0100606559,
0.0497206524,
0.0642320588,
0.0183663405,
-0.015023279,
-0.0208466649,
-0.0549598932,
-0.031325087,
-0.014836059,
-0.0020365866,
-0.0135009782,
0.0632570088,
-0.0290251169,
0.0184618309,
-0.0313374102,
-0.0475044623,
0.0426302291,
-0.0508735329,
-0.0548738018,
-0.0344903506,
0.0360117778,
0.0154349646,
-0.0097501688,
-0.0161134992,
0.0064491336,
0.0390985906,
-0.0384196565,
0.0364864133,
-0.0087759355,
-0.0918223634,
-0.0229517166,
0.0277727209,
0.0045236587,
-0.0414018333,
-0.0060230135,
-0.0161622912,
-0.0362158865,
-0.0319152139,
-0.011034946,
0.0404524319,
0.0052174577,
0.0491188131,
0.0058475169,
-0.0071701664,
-0.0818623081,
0.0817300081,
0.0206923857,
-0.0109753702,
0.0514134243,
0.013405459,
-0.0396480784,
-0.0173388701,
-0.0366914347,
0.0108606499,
0.0115783941,
-0.0014441812,
-0.0115926731,
-0.0117871417,
-0.0459094718,
-0.0154227,
-0.1189332977,
0.0295128115,
-0.0206436887,
0.0374039561,
0.0341994129,
0.0170673504,
-0.0193355009,
-0.0036234113,
-0.0218631234,
-0.0067892703,
-0.038772732,
0.0105267838,
0.0231195949,
0.0335938297,
-0.0229781587,
-0.0213720296,
0.0090021109,
-0.0253718216,
0.017526323,
-0.0096592894,
-0.0194350667,
-0.0865076557,
0.0665694699,
0.0350814797,
0.0183638725,
-0.0347203314,
0.0298542399,
-0.0083517684,
-0.0012882936,
0.0781558603,
0.0879900604,
-0.0046708817,
0.0343939476,
0.033630386,
0.0058241859,
-0.0535114557,
0.0189589709,
-0.0177202728,
-0.023516424,
-0.063226223,
-0.007429657,
0.0132033685,
0.0817118287,
-0.0185682531,
0.0304789953,
-0.0216809008,
-0.005590783,
-0.0318996906,
-0.0033207329,
-0.027125353,
-0.0165478326,
-0.0353382491,
0.0155082559,
-0.0506872684,
-0.0378434286,
0.0550740883,
-0.0333225057,
-0.0111033069,
-0.0584461205,
-0.0216711853,
-0.0455804951,
0.0688880384,
-0.0153938206,
0.027521167,
0.0159666426,
-0.0417529754,
-0.0722293109,
0.0218024142,
-0.005003707,
-0.0036052119,
0.1120426506,
-0.0413921177,
0.0296006091,
-0.0295808259,
-0.0493450649,
-0.0471435562,
-0.0330324061,
-0.0143518355,
0.0106199039,
0.0311027393,
-0.0082468269,
-0.0217764843,
0.0099948673,
0.040006578,
0.0407609344,
-0.0007155025,
-0.0061512226,
-0.0446681231,
0.0164425541,
0.0505468622,
0.0003488912,
-0.0089717051,
-0.0551325865,
0.0198315699,
0.0271202307,
0.0480727851,
-0.0176882371,
-0.0253519267,
-0.0196864344,
0.0279749651,
-0.0503245816,
-0.006304781,
0.0314225443,
0.0632155389,
-0.0866624564,
-0.0181413256,
0.1281695813,
0.0134305283,
-0.0667604804,
0.010128337,
-0.0061298348,
0.005611056,
0.0251284949,
0.0232599806,
-0.0566228405,
-0.040006049,
0.0202670377,
0.0119671924,
0.0180875584,
-0.0021230259,
-0.0025202981,
-0.1123547181,
0.0242561754,
0.0223072935,
-0.0635605082,
-0.0425859652,
-0.0357756391,
0.0094690518,
0.0054748356,
0.0713216588,
0.0270667989,
-0.0379948169,
-0.0152447214,
0.0324807353,
0.0073198644,
-0.0648906901,
0.0480032973,
-0.0396551974,
0.0464672484,
0.0655121654,
-0.0069978461,
0.0246504396,
-0.005557789,
0.085042879,
0.0026442164,
0.0247679409,
-0.0140241943,
0.0075206771,
-0.0226693172,
-0.0170401242,
-0.0121758776,
0.0122786937,
-0.0491811819,
-0.0020918301,
0.0125948992,
0.0794491023,
-0.0050744428,
0.0223037656,
0.0117503135,
-0.0505708307,
0.0080633052,
0.0953188613,
0.0134041188,
-0.0671937019,
-0.0417403467,
0.014819039,
-0.0242272317,
-0.0099827303,
0.0222024024,
0.0268358849,
-0.0394905731,
-0.0129178455,
-0.0383014791,
-0.0370150097,
0.0410279483,
0.0434597209,
0.0122256,
0.0273338165,
0.0299085639,
-0.0122541031,
-0.0752054229,
0.0421896018,
-0.0400184318,
0.0163648501,
-0.0796652213,
-0.0180160608,
-0.0002868234,
-0.0225726515,
-0.000166336,
0.0188666135,
-0.0793246999,
-0.0602341741,
-0.017259689,
-0.0105384635,
0.0177192241,
0.0956869572,
-0.0089614177,
-0.0184382964,
0.0145582901,
-0.0009053792,
-0.0221371464,
0.017552549,
-0.0092900898,
0.0106243826,
-0.0051563499,
0.0333427414,
-0.0393917449,
-0.0020436053,
0.0228116289,
0.0409258157,
-0.0487864278,
-0.0180368554,
0.0299979281,
0.0056401892,
0.0325348899,
-0.0015389821,
-0.0301505681,
-0.0177326184,
0.0184764247,
-0.0093251895,
-0.0344573259,
-0.0084204553,
-0.0411722809,
0.0388220251,
0.0034284156,
0.0277910493,
0.030988995,
0.0426181518,
0.0298497453,
-0.0374266244,
0.0202504341,
-0.0443473384,
0.0015211921,
0.0587290376,
0.0203797352,
-0.026752159,
0.0203129817,
0.0046595582,
0.0564496554,
-0.0053381016,
0.0490968972,
0.0266116709,
0.0076108458,
-0.0343904309,
0.0292303991,
-0.0389026739,
-0.010986343,
-0.0325457789,
0.0034384909,
0.0421998352,
-0.0413183346,
0.0587354787,
-0.0054804161,
-0.005998252,
-0.0395625271,
0.0121938912,
-0.0140982224,
-0.0131601561,
0.0199455284,
0.0405388698,
-0.0142938755,
-0.0071613723,
0.0815369934,
0.007966781,
0.0404800102,
0.0009787049,
-0.0078385752,
-0.0416639782,
-0.0078025721,
0.0328437611,
0.0120242452,
-0.0601855107,
-0.0120035969,
-0.0355398729,
-0.0412387885,
0.0105686067,
-0.0050397012,
-0.0322669633,
-0.0363739245,
0.0349685661,
0.0821018815,
-0.0066594942,
-0.0356305614,
-0.0101193991,
-0.027359359,
-0.0009081903,
-0.0256821923,
-0.0124613829,
-6.473440043e-33,
-0.0440365784,
-0.0245429873,
0.0464125499,
0.0115530062,
-0.023805717,
0.0211538225,
-0.0459807143,
0.0052615888,
-0.0086226081,
-0.0281617772,
-0.00834822,
-0.0205436014,
0.0151148411,
0.0223240014,
0.0065555023,
-0.0187613983,
0.0288839284,
0.0158960205,
-0.0222826805,
-0.0041008019,
0.0364313982,
0.0372523516,
0.0361523554,
-0.0635713413,
0.0115239481,
-0.007584272,
0.0195461791,
0.0181100983,
0.0147728482,
0.0446994416,
-0.0189525448,
0.0430330783,
0.0442302786,
-0.0359968245,
-0.0354088992,
0.0635251179,
-0.0972226635,
0.0244502649,
0.0400079899,
0.0283116661,
-0.00769311,
-0.0487245247,
0.0567392819,
0.003210841,
-0.019339541,
-0.0031436335,
0.0438421816,
-0.0188769624,
-0.0333131887,
0.0036171619,
-0.1068453118,
0.0223716367,
0.0122832311,
-0.022901766,
0.0315286741,
0.0088112429,
-0.000402687,
0.025956912,
-0.0564814135,
-0.0099696452,
-0.0375372618,
0.0555226244,
0.0934784263,
0.0555417314,
0.0272999648,
0.039882943,
0.000917902,
0.0204915479,
-0.0009509083,
-0.049269449,
0.0302325152,
0.0473472066,
-0.0402488969,
0.0165702607,
0.0183082502,
0.0251342058,
-0.0523136593,
0.0124448203,
0.013804974,
0.0433577299,
0.0345724896,
0.0398323126,
-0.0797868222,
-0.0152188418,
-0.0202678964,
0.0447334461,
-0.0323751159,
-0.0102605019,
0.0538168997,
0.0239676833,
0.0024715881,
0.0048417421,
0.0115003176,
-0.0301330704,
-0.0084236711,
0.0044928626,
-0.0066263857,
0.0152386986,
-0.025029989,
0.0066239471,
-0.0877462551,
-0.0643283725,
-0.015288474,
0.0150095038,
0.0119980415,
0.0189859755,
0.0431212261,
0.0022169999,
-0.0656310841,
-0.0124998456,
-0.067598559,
0.0154710496,
0.0005019517,
0.0317626894,
0.0670108572,
-0.0129060103,
-0.0087983059,
0.0353674144,
0.0142539507,
-0.0336893797,
-0.0163146704,
-0.0231565125,
-0.0172081236,
-0.0176069699,
0.001028148,
0.0141135138,
-0.0151538765,
0.018784849,
0.0128686419,
-0.0360620581,
-0.0054769511,
0.0074370373,
2.814e-7,
0.0311293136,
0.0703768581,
0.0344013683,
0.0203705765,
0.0091131739,
0.0259341281,
-0.0117442729,
0.0010388473,
-0.0108991014,
-0.0245495327,
0.0378276594,
0.0382871926,
0.041237846,
-0.0041321986,
-0.0890889242,
0.002846262,
-0.0244895536,
0.0372033864,
-0.0512620807,
0.0256864335,
0.0352451988,
0.0854504108,
-0.0242157802,
-0.001536659,
0.0083654923,
-0.0631754547,
0.0612419583,
-0.0525454059,
0.0003730583,
0.0196719449,
-0.033583425,
0.0272203796,
-0.0045588058,
0.0392554067,
0.0117463078,
0.0123252431,
0.0106586311,
0.0852957144,
-0.009644852,
-0.0099504311,
-0.0170342382,
-0.0181906801,
0.0013957566,
-0.0691932365,
0.0512819141,
-0.0689266846,
-0.0260566399,
-0.0384994932,
-0.0157177374,
-0.013833805,
-0.0491205454,
0.032286413,
0.0152155515,
0.0066135949,
0.0279601347,
-0.0393067375,
-0.0479634777,
-0.0787709355,
-0.0323239118,
0.0469004847,
-0.0556387492,
-0.0466516092,
-0.0433116071,
0.0137175368,
0.0441314839,
-0.0476768762,
-0.0045228815,
2.891567559e-34,
0.0006409832,
0.0131114433,
0.0211599376,
0.0584435314,
-0.005808692,
0.00066856,
-0.058408305,
0.0267306902,
0.0151185757,
-0.0837646276,
0.001556938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08982v1 | SentAlign: Accurate and Scalable Sentence Alignment | 2023-11-15T14:15:41 | 2023-11-15T14:15:41 | Steinþór Steingrímsson, Hrafn Loftsson, Andy Way | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present SentAlign, an accurate sentence alignment tool designed to handle
very large parallel document pairs. Given user-defined parameters, the
alignment algorithm evaluates all possible alignment paths in fairly large
documents of thousands of sentences and uses a divide-and-conquer approach to
align documents containing tens of thousands of sentences. The scoring function
is based on LaBSE bilingual sentence representations. SentAlign outperforms
five other sentence alignment tools when evaluated on two different evaluation
sets, German-French and English-Icelandic, and on a downstream machine
translation task. | [
-0.0143257203,
0.038786646,
-0.0089516491,
0.0398325361,
-0.08826226,
0.0060487855,
0.0216904711,
-0.0569601767,
0.0068582362,
-0.0070047802,
-0.0343816578,
-0.0062503889,
0.0241975654,
-0.0448798575,
0.0054293387,
-0.0592680573,
0.0904766023,
0.0216021184,
-0.0094608162,
0.011794637,
0.0606418066,
0.0456923954,
-0.0125577729,
0.0059803636,
0.0047280286,
-0.0629909933,
-0.0039132698,
0.0376370698,
0.0749828815,
0.0044816053,
0.0091159577,
0.0199144837,
-0.0146839283,
0.0684057102,
0.0000015393,
-0.0223119855,
-0.0349096172,
-0.0161675159,
0.0104465252,
0.0321887285,
0.0235884488,
-0.0498224311,
-0.0237595085,
0.0309746005,
0.0077789207,
0.0020958425,
0.0425644927,
0.0088905012,
0.0353917815,
0.0828842595,
-0.0381838307,
-0.0409429409,
0.0021155593,
-0.0173189621,
-0.0381148756,
-0.0295057911,
-0.0086984336,
0.0030709037,
-0.0165454764,
-0.0005097766,
-0.0019144944,
0.0317322202,
0.0054309638,
-0.0133624403,
-0.0193692911,
-0.0366058871,
-0.0812648311,
-0.0059455261,
0.006101313,
0.0487676673,
-0.0254085585,
-0.0334308371,
-0.014891617,
-0.0230219699,
-0.002990189,
-0.0171304867,
-0.0396885648,
-0.0124647962,
-0.0211739447,
0.0172640756,
0.0500274077,
0.0041074981,
0.0228431597,
-0.0287567247,
-0.0045688511,
0.0218974017,
0.0569277033,
-0.0407604538,
-0.0143642137,
0.0295134746,
0.0007222717,
-0.0204699226,
0.0462651104,
-0.0220098123,
-0.0417482741,
0.0054558311,
-0.0676844046,
-0.0867805853,
0.0171060599,
-0.0834781528,
0.0001883626,
0.036259491,
-0.0158111714,
0.0575849041,
-0.0108325686,
0.066390574,
-0.0265697371,
-0.0191314779,
-0.058311712,
-0.0283164773,
-0.0020822342,
0.0432743765,
-0.044960361,
-0.0529947393,
-0.0603645667,
-0.044971738,
-0.0379905701,
0.0200257897,
0.0102695934,
0.0460214466,
0.042588301,
-0.0393907055,
-0.0377256609,
-0.0247159768,
-0.0040769731,
0.0720817968,
-0.0321861021,
-0.0083848331,
-0.0242778733,
-0.0052602747,
-0.0094288075,
0.0392985716,
0.0376026221,
-0.0373781808,
-0.0446081348,
0.0341975465,
-0.0271538496,
-0.0009885465,
0.0077587129,
0.0184682868,
-0.0058087017,
-0.0627497286,
-0.0575170666,
-0.0577595048,
0.0979556069,
0.0089880312,
-0.0054034423,
-0.0283780359,
0.0137023358,
-0.0008863141,
-0.0321158618,
0.0505448841,
-0.0007310921,
0.0088099325,
-0.0061135488,
-0.0493108742,
0.068368122,
0.0423153453,
-0.0055504111,
0.014626611,
0.0419001989,
-0.0016900349,
-0.0377474427,
0.05035422,
0.0078598298,
0.0058981194,
-0.0013144362,
0.0398454517,
0.0359287001,
0.0559134409,
-0.0014748407,
0.0592022985,
0.0224058777,
0.0308769923,
0.029542651,
0.0078281369,
0.0070388918,
-0.0138160847,
0.0078691645,
0.0061311037,
0.0010004428,
0.0158830527,
-0.0332955346,
0.0253242813,
0.0161729306,
0.0350736119,
0.042137716,
0.0647232905,
-0.0093188155,
0.0109974435,
-0.0241362955,
0.0174845271,
-0.0109158233,
-0.0019108303,
0.0052857753,
-0.0213967655,
-0.0498846658,
0.084730424,
-0.0258154385,
-0.0356194824,
0.0051569771,
0.0851885378,
-0.032997489,
0.071917586,
0.0364390872,
-0.0143049378,
-0.0596226193,
-0.0019257686,
-0.0066875843,
0.0598212518,
0.0750390217,
0.0120817451,
-0.0140153598,
-0.0638367981,
-0.0149085103,
0.0235508904,
-0.0163107961,
0.0083043082,
0.010634535,
0.0553338975,
0.0060640499,
-0.0388488658,
-0.0427857973,
0.0089169852,
0.0007180436,
-0.0217625685,
-0.0219614524,
0.0231747497,
0.0360120237,
0.021933794,
-0.0157172922,
0.0236745551,
0.0218839347,
-0.0262513217,
0.0050225421,
0.094820179,
0.0030708453,
-0.0471886694,
0.041392222,
-0.0478474125,
-0.0560568534,
0.0248993225,
-0.0283932313,
-0.0332177579,
-0.0316579528,
-0.021644773,
-0.0222428832,
0.0002603575,
0.0756311342,
-0.0064163622,
0.0041459985,
-0.0433081351,
0.0323728397,
0.0262426995,
0.0158884116,
-0.0368545353,
-0.0689055771,
0.0434837677,
-0.0114024356,
0.0044331402,
0.000816473,
0.0266087241,
-0.0177715607,
0.0154933631,
-0.0263961107,
-0.0199245941,
-0.0152889909,
-0.0453544259,
0.0587129071,
-0.0313277878,
0.0779948011,
0.0844522789,
0.0273110587,
0.0191362258,
0.0013760142,
-0.0435184762,
0.0277762171,
0.0417287573,
-0.0023065149,
0.0519738123,
-0.0114526805,
-0.0233541075,
-0.0774537325,
0.030527154,
-0.0413789861,
0.0075669778,
0.0357673205,
-0.0207663532,
-0.0478497706,
0.0397491865,
-0.019140251,
0.0033165035,
0.0256807171,
-0.0501170643,
-0.0178787652,
0.0189431123,
0.0648107901,
0.0483606234,
0.016341038,
-0.0436361767,
-0.0102248788,
-0.0034532011,
-0.0259855166,
0.0057688924,
-0.0065401429,
0.0125539424,
-0.040228691,
-0.0420963243,
0.0377977267,
0.044701796,
0.0174358618,
0.0314448662,
-0.0295909364,
-0.0195502825,
0.0124277817,
0.0165879708,
0.0038584033,
0.0239602588,
-0.003139633,
0.0115972413,
-0.0375767425,
-0.0043975445,
0.0512175895,
-0.0212610923,
-0.0073987124,
-0.0786335468,
-0.0336249247,
-0.0480343625,
0.041530814,
-0.0177705213,
0.0285261124,
-0.0628326312,
-0.0147961741,
-0.0273178276,
-0.0221469235,
0.0523276739,
0.0039415322,
0.0222433489,
-0.030649066,
0.0071885409,
-0.0484753549,
-0.0631091371,
-0.0258746929,
-0.0461817421,
-0.0374183021,
-0.0213852748,
0.0579286814,
-0.0104648964,
-0.1084139422,
-0.004560872,
0.0231710467,
0.0385537669,
-0.0138492556,
0.0322258845,
-0.0293588657,
0.0297320616,
0.0426044986,
-0.0229816269,
-0.0095068747,
-0.0407913849,
0.0144937839,
0.0277676228,
-0.0287758801,
0.018868003,
0.0014904748,
-0.0817869827,
0.0080196448,
-0.0544218235,
-0.0090613905,
-0.0553700812,
0.0509593636,
-0.0362573974,
0.0064779352,
0.0916733146,
0.0198048837,
-0.0217629746,
-0.0378341042,
-0.0568329319,
0.0035624581,
0.0165232178,
0.0443586707,
-0.1002975777,
-0.0074584978,
-0.0093846647,
-0.0269659944,
0.0384732671,
0.0228113271,
0.010291528,
-0.0795446187,
0.0072657103,
0.0568538457,
-0.0359396227,
-0.0332360379,
0.007418124,
-0.0061638639,
-0.0260434113,
0.0510660037,
0.0369853787,
-0.0026034047,
0.0135450969,
-0.0325405486,
0.0120790303,
0.0145274615,
-0.0290474184,
-0.0793533325,
0.0253068078,
0.0204858501,
0.0500972755,
0.0086690597,
-0.0739348084,
0.0355269164,
-0.0219829008,
-0.0194315687,
0.0217399988,
0.0193552505,
-0.0281945542,
-0.0232936312,
-0.0293210857,
0.0121011259,
-0.0404193699,
-0.0052243541,
0.0824319124,
0.0584921204,
-0.0055575352,
0.0438965969,
0.014479734,
0.0150389243,
0.0258844178,
0.0623355731,
-0.001824238,
-0.0021957178,
-0.0533614494,
0.0053831791,
-0.0095150853,
-0.0769454762,
-0.0000406871,
0.0219468381,
-0.0722002164,
0.0071182288,
-0.061289072,
-0.0211108364,
0.0124346893,
0.0331284031,
0.0539343543,
0.0002093653,
-0.0064950618,
-0.0390958376,
-0.0355713516,
0.0138349812,
0.0093587358,
0.0320700184,
-0.0421623737,
0.0271753203,
-0.0228963178,
0.0146284262,
0.0127473054,
0.0090267807,
-0.0842663124,
-0.0654696971,
0.0039903731,
-0.0259486195,
0.0092098005,
0.062470559,
-0.0182967838,
0.0367757007,
-0.0542767495,
0.027256012,
-0.0373525508,
0.0073740999,
0.0044660629,
-0.0084626228,
-0.0013648465,
0.0304114204,
-0.0199104957,
-0.0133755859,
-0.0135302301,
0.0231694058,
0.0072061275,
-0.0615370497,
-0.0121581536,
0.041509226,
0.0386581495,
-0.0049598869,
0.012041782,
-0.0069028363,
0.0292504448,
-0.0413255058,
-0.0406991392,
0.009975885,
-0.0050918446,
0.043500673,
0.0238304473,
-0.0157436766,
0.0417165644,
-0.0360296108,
-0.0387817211,
-0.0060911537,
0.0023180642,
0.0061699082,
0.0284253415,
0.0099152708,
0.0117665064,
-0.0043150573,
0.0083834268,
0.0021654991,
0.0669625774,
-0.018026296,
0.0169810597,
0.0303077009,
0.0270924345,
-0.0301642008,
0.0326960571,
-0.0270175561,
0.0162744615,
0.0240624882,
-0.0011747917,
0.0947814286,
-0.0261874776,
0.114841789,
-0.0110342205,
-0.032747902,
0.0028576721,
0.0476330407,
-0.0103870751,
0.0093939872,
-0.0548496209,
-0.0118195862,
-0.0071549872,
-0.000277585,
0.0288173407,
-0.080869697,
-0.0033693956,
-0.0117608216,
-0.0400735475,
-0.0214048047,
-0.0143291773,
-0.0099446932,
-0.0245527141,
-0.0346135683,
-0.0703818351,
-0.0151466299,
-0.021924464,
0.0271622036,
0.0750622749,
-0.0121124089,
0.0136734881,
-0.003911844,
0.0415460989,
-0.0266510826,
0.000755416,
-0.0291715879,
0.0800193474,
-0.0591536984,
-0.0658406988,
-0.0235449914,
-5.440392098e-33,
-0.0082790032,
0.019228939,
-0.0112140216,
0.0127142798,
-0.0505189188,
0.007835635,
-0.0379225053,
-0.0032886737,
0.0216782987,
0.0396697782,
0.0075882701,
-0.0085061006,
0.0287445728,
-0.014993934,
0.0438612737,
-0.0063349167,
0.0588846654,
0.0228754412,
-0.0139242923,
-0.0197612979,
0.0493960679,
0.0018279739,
0.0536252074,
-0.0721590072,
0.0114127463,
-0.0141258398,
-0.0168922804,
0.0070316335,
0.0203627795,
0.0281110257,
0.0315497816,
0.0046780976,
-0.0107977157,
0.0079137739,
-0.0121057564,
0.0428049639,
-0.0753629804,
0.0115671009,
0.0724937394,
0.0596100986,
-0.0436877161,
-0.050688047,
0.0053517842,
-0.0408162028,
-0.0158388503,
0.0198207535,
0.029130796,
-0.0173212085,
0.0397698767,
0.0127567053,
-0.0874576122,
-0.0071882769,
-0.0284756646,
0.0324502513,
0.0138925873,
0.0720500723,
0.0128275407,
0.0292513445,
-0.0489488915,
-0.0202737059,
-0.0570585281,
0.0354009233,
0.0699850023,
-0.0330822356,
-0.0010690929,
0.0504086055,
0.0402642861,
-0.0450087264,
0.0102747045,
0.0411137678,
-0.0227277838,
-0.0125470646,
0.0528555922,
0.1040208265,
0.0021102363,
0.0143952053,
-0.0455867574,
0.0388496853,
0.0550429225,
-0.0052420059,
-0.0135177299,
0.0345656015,
-0.0243221279,
0.0031539004,
0.0242869686,
-0.026985595,
-0.0136445854,
-0.0247345977,
0.0200471822,
-0.0030858319,
0.0166963488,
0.0132930353,
0.0396302007,
-0.0099631287,
-0.0042116097,
0.0018172071,
-0.0212771483,
0.0041076872,
-0.0456049517,
0.0217595436,
-0.0414628051,
-0.0373699404,
-0.0081640119,
0.0583373755,
0.0270339735,
-0.0000303945,
0.0450376496,
-0.0310960729,
-0.0705925673,
0.0268461965,
-0.0189176593,
-0.0016507484,
-0.0465384759,
-0.0007423633,
0.0205763392,
-0.0158974174,
0.0224165302,
0.0232391469,
0.0196835957,
-0.0415625498,
-0.0277358163,
-0.0223335885,
0.0028305296,
0.02361417,
-0.0318664312,
0.0210191403,
-0.0154409325,
-0.0073399255,
-0.012898447,
-0.0710022375,
0.0032737504,
0.0117844064,
2.29e-7,
0.0660180449,
0.0189517755,
0.078218542,
-0.0018128373,
0.0114136776,
-0.0253293868,
-0.0208408963,
0.0726695359,
-0.0102849929,
0.0466455743,
0.0347957276,
-0.0232413225,
0.0629692525,
0.0180324689,
-0.0870459154,
-0.0115051437,
-0.0453124195,
-0.0287032872,
-0.0847059339,
0.0389920697,
0.0380026139,
0.0680374354,
0.0299646836,
0.0498997904,
0.0012947286,
-0.0184848066,
0.0201415289,
0.00090431,
-0.0416594036,
0.0035286783,
-0.0234258492,
-0.024716327,
-0.0474311858,
0.0012309413,
-0.005124073,
0.0332214385,
0.0154203624,
0.0880549401,
-0.006285449,
0.0229452569,
-0.0491572209,
-0.0276753437,
-0.016434256,
-0.047782369,
0.0486456193,
0.0117378673,
0.0036408261,
-0.0294875782,
-0.0290525798,
0.0358039923,
0.0300175268,
0.046555303,
-0.0249744728,
0.0211682413,
0.0571800768,
-0.016731387,
-0.0502433367,
-0.0226206016,
-0.0700009912,
0.0151313813,
-0.0048322575,
0.0063125351,
0.0024130896,
0.0353449695,
0.0278882869,
-0.0264965817,
-0.0192317553,
1.831518922e-34,
0.0344068483,
-0.0087948693,
0.023259528,
-0.014158085,
0.0064401142,
-0.0418594666,
-0.0270203073,
0.0265329871,
-0.0110926554,
-0.0203243718,
-0.0196975227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08981v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08981v2 | Speculative Contrastive Decoding | 2023-11-15T14:15:30 | 2024-03-13T17:32:50 | Hongyi Yuan, Keming Lu, Fei Huang, Zheng Yuan, Chang Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models~(LLMs) exhibit exceptional performance in language
tasks, yet their auto-regressive inference is limited due to high computational
requirements and is sub-optimal due to the exposure bias. Inspired by
speculative decoding and contrastive decoding, we introduce Speculative
Contrastive Decoding~(SCD), a straightforward yet powerful decoding approach
that leverages predictions from smaller language models~(LMs) to achieve both
decoding acceleration and quality improvement. Extensive evaluations and
analyses on four diverse language tasks demonstrate the effectiveness of SCD,
showing that decoding efficiency and quality can compatibly benefit from one
smaller LM. | [
-0.0114988396,
0.1025208607,
0.0150496084,
0.0361164734,
-0.020625351,
0.0260243006,
0.0085727358,
-0.0138232009,
-0.0569615141,
0.0040181107,
-0.039738968,
-0.088049911,
0.0504780486,
-0.0033194181,
0.0325381309,
-0.0358215906,
-0.007551963,
-0.0617464334,
0.0145502444,
-0.0055851662,
-0.0214701388,
0.026556462,
-0.0156824533,
0.0398480706,
0.0399000868,
-0.0206330493,
0.0053878478,
0.0109199435,
0.0141429389,
-0.0389733389,
0.013744426,
0.0552196503,
0.0209457483,
0.0134531967,
0.0000018081,
-0.0005046515,
0.0008868936,
0.0151662016,
-0.0155240642,
0.0278011877,
0.0701221526,
-0.0590277128,
-0.0260023065,
0.0261041038,
-0.0102558117,
-0.0810204893,
0.0618955866,
0.0258096941,
-0.0147116277,
0.0686188117,
0.0001257839,
-0.0601456501,
0.0424758196,
-0.0162592754,
-0.0224869233,
-0.0247645266,
0.0174297467,
-0.0215470716,
-0.0516563952,
0.0113931764,
-0.0389770381,
0.0465509854,
0.0173731633,
0.0449431762,
-0.0045510125,
0.0554530472,
0.016514089,
0.0042486698,
-0.0127214529,
0.0259224549,
-0.0003777395,
-0.0357297175,
-0.0645011738,
-0.0171104129,
-0.0402267948,
-0.0453353897,
-0.0246800259,
0.0399871245,
-0.011957733,
0.0672655925,
0.1033094227,
0.0715157539,
0.0294793826,
0.0068111061,
-0.0385423601,
0.0126783485,
0.0400613882,
-0.0195485093,
-0.0184712913,
0.0502398461,
0.0094495714,
0.009988158,
0.0162406135,
-0.0215582121,
-0.029764561,
-0.0026109577,
-0.0276664831,
-0.0826147497,
-0.0116631361,
-0.0099464422,
0.0703202188,
0.074736923,
-0.0123635614,
0.0211081319,
0.0029716245,
0.0174446236,
-0.0337110497,
-0.026020037,
-0.0320286341,
-0.027221581,
0.0260102414,
0.0189151559,
-0.0133088445,
-0.0032797633,
-0.0474713594,
-0.00285489,
0.0077888044,
-0.0029310952,
0.0315183774,
-0.0131343203,
0.0568289384,
-0.0009151057,
-0.0773881525,
-0.0275925025,
0.0349105597,
0.0417630598,
0.0050008507,
0.0125987642,
-0.0053344541,
-0.0780036151,
-0.028802881,
0.0080921911,
-0.0042020055,
-0.0626838207,
-0.0217145719,
0.0585128032,
-0.0317523368,
-0.0250256509,
-0.0264957342,
0.039662715,
-0.0022745444,
-0.0382453837,
-0.0136242639,
-0.0487189405,
0.011548196,
0.0153833311,
0.0214318391,
-0.0519909635,
-0.0143957688,
-0.005437396,
-0.0128383534,
0.0811727792,
-0.0298818126,
-0.0083251856,
0.0091501484,
0.003902063,
-0.0217051599,
0.0924053937,
0.0059040454,
0.0082354276,
-0.0096558537,
-0.0089899385,
-0.0001834701,
0.057531938,
0.0155468481,
0.0078633167,
-0.0254413728,
-0.0232325681,
0.0114429947,
-0.0108155468,
0.0987577513,
0.0795915499,
-0.0533144996,
-0.0160957649,
0.0805789977,
0.0276410058,
0.0302524567,
0.0395024866,
0.0235732943,
0.0255511422,
-0.0170842968,
0.021945117,
-0.0158809237,
0.0235475097,
-0.0175208822,
0.0170076471,
0.0636894107,
0.0460511073,
-0.0240774769,
-0.0073018172,
0.0007464081,
-0.016807951,
0.0310496259,
0.0095494734,
0.0765138865,
0.0063819662,
-0.0672460347,
0.0225356799,
0.0211818125,
-0.0079846513,
0.009904922,
-0.0230708625,
0.008020943,
0.0786088407,
0.0444096588,
0.0289856121,
0.0292680003,
0.0132731497,
-0.0451803207,
0.0423245467,
0.0299192127,
0.0110249585,
0.0567677282,
-0.0584515482,
-0.0204660986,
0.0273709632,
0.0186333768,
0.0267768279,
0.0108066741,
0.0082365358,
-0.0123203471,
-0.0027632667,
-0.0270200875,
0.0131448591,
-0.0364100449,
-0.045192115,
0.0433187187,
0.0016419197,
0.0005400792,
0.0024380826,
-0.0134008192,
0.0242122859,
0.0120381806,
-0.0678715482,
0.0174407717,
-0.0166860186,
-0.0786098838,
-0.0889584273,
0.0114748338,
-0.0092529505,
-0.0077239918,
0.0657053813,
-0.0083619859,
-0.0226876307,
0.0314886943,
-0.0300192181,
0.0784791037,
-0.0295969751,
-0.0021124133,
0.0276833866,
0.0409351327,
0.0037892985,
0.0348824114,
-0.0528941937,
-0.0052429601,
-0.0006446493,
0.0015045779,
-0.0267803371,
-0.0276825894,
-0.0035462652,
-0.0173049718,
-0.0137750031,
0.0219415259,
-0.0181666818,
0.0012665552,
0.0134700527,
0.0207513794,
-0.0330755375,
-0.0191827249,
-0.0423844866,
0.0208685305,
0.0106242429,
0.0080285184,
0.0025343024,
-0.0031631372,
-0.0085797152,
-0.0356095955,
-0.0422014147,
0.016656993,
-0.0064205434,
0.0113959517,
-0.0138817336,
-0.0307383649,
-0.0494004972,
0.0238195937,
0.054317534,
-0.0511366799,
-0.0276274681,
-0.0826217607,
0.0720637366,
0.0441966541,
0.0068890727,
-0.0008075605,
-0.0519156568,
0.0020647906,
-0.0416966081,
0.0468979217,
0.0298288129,
-0.0193979964,
0.0003710942,
0.0332880914,
-0.0010082552,
-0.0337598324,
-0.0195472538,
-0.003222089,
-0.0304960553,
-0.0464692898,
-0.0778835341,
-0.0427652225,
0.1114226952,
0.0453443564,
0.0193892159,
-0.0780569911,
-0.0286587775,
-0.0119442949,
-0.0355872735,
0.000522161,
0.0034882908,
0.0109694442,
0.0553851947,
-0.0256018676,
-0.034497574,
0.0800815001,
-0.0393063873,
-0.0132740252,
-0.0129501615,
-0.0197006166,
-0.0245528053,
0.0258027054,
-0.0329284742,
0.0033727556,
0.0011959526,
-0.0775637627,
-0.0099384859,
0.001587082,
0.0043167248,
-0.0353734419,
0.061200764,
-0.0484420322,
0.0017630858,
-0.027110517,
-0.0684273168,
-0.025239801,
-0.0462388583,
-0.0399933197,
0.0133124636,
0.069842428,
-0.0348431319,
-0.0163652673,
0.0189184844,
-0.0418327115,
0.0349809565,
-0.0035175262,
0.0022311218,
-0.0008706612,
0.032480523,
0.0250299908,
-0.0156691223,
0.0280107278,
-0.0464123338,
0.0292622913,
0.0503208786,
0.0301081669,
0.0076347841,
-0.0710962638,
0.0102366759,
0.0600770414,
0.0470058322,
-0.0211961959,
0.0294472612,
0.0484256893,
-0.0643355921,
-0.0370238423,
0.1147968173,
0.0022754343,
-0.0871645212,
-0.0056670313,
0.001387387,
0.0504671447,
-0.022195138,
-0.002796948,
-0.0560014211,
-0.0412099101,
0.0216192007,
0.034364298,
0.0171334278,
-0.0228958912,
-0.011125125,
-0.1188872606,
0.0442004465,
0.047427237,
-0.0065043522,
-0.0357136913,
-0.0429025926,
-0.0265469756,
-0.0441575684,
0.0361649357,
0.0366122127,
0.0133722769,
-0.0100400215,
0.0355958641,
-0.0225600693,
-0.0676553622,
0.0092386547,
-0.015169641,
0.0684094131,
0.0551511981,
-0.0401446,
-0.0025475728,
-0.0123254247,
-0.014940029,
-0.0619920418,
-0.0073402151,
-0.0252551194,
0.0471365042,
-0.0286231339,
-0.0100159515,
0.0028629205,
0.018755259,
-0.0483501144,
-0.0101264585,
-0.0314508975,
0.0397214033,
0.0034736053,
-0.0273572057,
0.0022704178,
-0.0136978133,
0.0350557826,
0.0831117257,
0.0366826244,
-0.0297149401,
-0.0240138378,
-0.0487536788,
-0.0149201071,
-0.074012965,
0.0042366446,
-0.0011945482,
0.0586879365,
-0.0302636828,
-0.038439177,
-0.029647328,
0.018136926,
-0.0134422444,
-0.0379544236,
0.0462948792,
-0.0149141531,
-0.0261699148,
-0.073432751,
-0.0043998514,
-0.000176943,
0.0199042372,
-0.0251182169,
-0.0021148308,
0.0282000862,
-0.0189689454,
0.0030141713,
0.0095419325,
-0.0888698027,
-0.0588689744,
-0.0146294832,
0.0453572646,
0.0156755652,
0.0547502972,
-0.0239743292,
-0.0694322661,
0.0314235389,
-0.0010034381,
-0.0357759856,
0.0096386243,
0.0448079295,
-0.0235829018,
0.017881358,
0.0458678268,
-0.012802734,
-0.0009913384,
-0.0041213408,
0.0475991108,
-0.0061772182,
-0.0046052285,
0.0204146858,
-0.0320221707,
0.0549597852,
-0.0590194762,
0.0043313471,
-0.0029180124,
0.0218420494,
-0.014752904,
0.0097124996,
-0.021494858,
0.0178087577,
0.0755431205,
-0.0170362666,
-0.0342049599,
0.0278041363,
0.0275303945,
0.0004582861,
-0.016447477,
0.0198977329,
-0.0008223956,
0.006673743,
0.0558395945,
-0.003721938,
-0.0527605489,
0.0083780913,
0.0001080651,
0.0397330858,
-0.0093285637,
-0.0187086947,
0.001341861,
0.0216700248,
-0.0253621936,
-0.0081187747,
-0.0376048684,
-0.0319932178,
-0.047886502,
-0.0247330423,
0.0330975577,
0.0151873706,
0.050241936,
-0.0007236609,
0.0013424685,
-0.0323785655,
0.0114720277,
-0.0396201387,
0.0198988579,
0.0423634984,
0.0189076513,
-0.0183065757,
0.0104816472,
0.0610678159,
0.0089102164,
0.0176485013,
-0.006413491,
0.0246992297,
-0.0152539564,
-0.0185984448,
-0.0140018705,
0.0285562575,
-0.0297320206,
0.005287278,
-0.0269598626,
-0.0805733576,
0.0143887494,
0.0124522978,
0.0199455488,
-0.0170105379,
0.0049374811,
0.0144734988,
-0.0212311521,
-0.0208792519,
-0.0164360479,
-0.0116069205,
-0.0031456526,
-0.0189825818,
-0.0382396691,
-6.531020165e-33,
-0.0021646824,
0.0218471978,
0.0092610419,
-0.0709807053,
-0.0000542676,
0.0147459814,
-0.0466751158,
-0.0125264963,
-0.0147515843,
0.0214132592,
-0.0185037646,
0.0351321101,
0.0296871662,
0.0664050579,
0.0022668014,
0.0065899249,
0.0604583286,
-0.0228002835,
-0.0051746727,
0.0027430982,
-0.0043241167,
0.0655895174,
0.035118971,
-0.0299790017,
-0.01424463,
-0.0040033408,
-0.0149562908,
-0.0033904025,
0.0161211174,
0.0696829334,
-0.0616559945,
0.0341966189,
0.0314223804,
-0.0360522717,
-0.0478149876,
0.0063093421,
-0.0990962312,
0.0291842967,
0.0173437204,
0.01833033,
-0.0417156331,
-0.0212977771,
-0.0277561918,
0.0193754919,
-0.0263221469,
-0.0519353487,
-0.0103355581,
-0.0466229618,
-0.0099824751,
-0.0076684896,
-0.0269351918,
0.0456378311,
0.0090696113,
0.0168342143,
0.0712420717,
0.0102134729,
-0.0189150721,
0.0557209924,
-0.0553997755,
0.0067515299,
0.0081936782,
0.0549227484,
0.0585499592,
0.0394948348,
-0.0224271864,
0.030707838,
0.0283584483,
-0.0313213244,
-0.0277529657,
-0.0141658308,
0.020938063,
0.0167016368,
0.0083261086,
0.0583734885,
0.0652275681,
-0.0111995107,
-0.0312696435,
0.0045534149,
0.0020518336,
0.0040579773,
0.0526855029,
0.0610344075,
-0.0563881546,
-0.0403375924,
-0.0333835855,
-0.0618558116,
-0.0369207747,
-0.0121768638,
0.0230014101,
0.0266144462,
-0.0337756947,
-0.0175820719,
0.063478224,
-0.0501793474,
-0.0065750191,
0.0500843301,
0.0010493952,
0.0191083644,
-0.0287247114,
0.0349220224,
-0.0379582532,
0.0000255036,
0.0212431327,
0.0254444573,
-0.0155302025,
-0.0095720449,
0.006345809,
0.0202656947,
-0.0774285272,
-0.0226723123,
-0.0309722535,
-0.0022747747,
0.0213502198,
0.0409653932,
0.0521012619,
-0.0192412212,
0.0056639053,
0.0602592975,
-0.0141215026,
0.0424506925,
-0.0110146794,
-0.0042849118,
0.0178854782,
0.0279509015,
-0.0100382585,
0.0150658144,
-0.0268640146,
-0.0021767404,
0.0529886857,
-0.0253204368,
-0.0469832122,
0.0485590585,
2.303e-7,
0.0569721609,
0.0192978811,
0.0477364399,
0.035583768,
0.0121990927,
0.0248048976,
-0.0006921763,
0.0161385145,
0.0151270013,
-0.0084971162,
0.0149798132,
0.0479133241,
0.0897755697,
0.0092730848,
-0.0472999178,
-0.0041574119,
-0.0311866794,
0.0280779339,
-0.0202718098,
-0.0370611586,
0.0415413529,
0.1231866702,
-0.0209574662,
-0.0250970814,
0.0525206551,
0.0090201218,
0.044609081,
-0.0250413325,
-0.0046097892,
-0.0029973483,
-0.0603935979,
0.030883776,
-0.0002764528,
-0.0115622189,
-0.013277486,
0.0066949883,
-0.0246934034,
0.0647883415,
-0.0024155257,
-0.0556249805,
0.0306280684,
0.0112043004,
-0.0149643281,
-0.0129318908,
0.0358912535,
-0.0412071086,
-0.0232516844,
-0.0028017492,
-0.0448974445,
0.0027757261,
-0.0096535999,
-0.0508194789,
-0.0194641277,
-0.0017463391,
0.0386839285,
0.0041399612,
-0.0524133258,
-0.0605335236,
-0.0293597765,
0.0359501503,
-0.031111069,
-0.0445915423,
-0.0020392833,
0.0073692324,
0.0346001163,
-0.0565969348,
0.016533006,
2.042224218e-34,
0.0614040084,
0.0093723638,
-0.0054289382,
0.070156455,
0.0014337203,
-0.034570992,
-0.0182427559,
0.0254166871,
0.0263483878,
-0.0870757774,
-0.03041289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08968v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08968v2 | Identifying Linear Relational Concepts in Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T14:01:41 | 2024-03-29T22:14:30 | David Chanin, Anthony Hunter, Oana-Maria Camburu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformer language models (LMs) have been shown to represent concepts as
directions in the latent space of hidden activations. However, for any
human-interpretable concept, how can we find its direction in the latent space?
We present a technique called linear relational concepts (LRC) for finding
concept directions corresponding to human-interpretable concepts by first
modeling the relation between subject and object as a linear relational
embedding (LRE). We find that inverting the LRE and using earlier object layers
results in a powerful technique for finding concept directions that outperforms
standard black-box probing classifiers. We evaluate LRCs on their performance
as concept classifiers as well as their ability to causally change model
output. | [
0.0438007452,
0.0678192675,
-0.0420194343,
0.1078868806,
-0.0090409489,
0.0164613277,
-0.0134149315,
0.0160111953,
-0.0316952169,
-0.0492518544,
-0.020090295,
-0.0339891799,
-0.0265974104,
0.0636680424,
0.0158280302,
-0.0172249731,
-0.007111426,
0.0043296134,
-0.0353011936,
0.0225965381,
-0.0364081115,
0.0107129356,
0.0115646739,
0.0485321134,
-0.0104101943,
-0.0130921919,
-0.0003287243,
-0.0243643336,
0.0096452674,
-0.0158913787,
-0.0236463882,
0.0424197018,
0.0493054315,
0.0398002602,
0.0000020382,
-0.0106354794,
-0.0266808346,
-0.0199098829,
-0.0330734551,
-0.0163778383,
0.0209000055,
-0.0796237141,
0.0239228047,
0.0020572427,
-0.0396166518,
-0.049409043,
0.0525268689,
0.0881064385,
0.0205933135,
0.0413735546,
-0.0081214895,
-0.0391024724,
0.0326229148,
-0.0201048907,
0.0220340099,
-0.0197833944,
0.0302394126,
0.0015142785,
-0.0624921992,
0.0399550609,
-0.0479994044,
0.0391852558,
0.0371106826,
-0.0399318375,
0.0501021855,
0.0403853618,
0.0011834933,
-0.0350006521,
0.0373689346,
0.095229283,
-0.0030480691,
-0.0092299776,
-0.0263577551,
-0.0032698587,
-0.0104922373,
0.0319930986,
-0.0082151098,
0.0081426548,
0.037630748,
0.0197778251,
-0.0108933281,
-0.0186046008,
0.0455094054,
0.0173450988,
-0.0382171497,
0.03304483,
0.0132292369,
-0.0158490557,
-0.0145775946,
0.0140690599,
-0.0271274634,
-0.0031223751,
0.0146785397,
0.0089402115,
0.0080226408,
0.0401590988,
0.0196209978,
0.0024727541,
-0.019959446,
-0.0804244429,
0.0571429543,
0.0283759236,
-0.0277017914,
0.040808171,
-0.0608473979,
0.0752080455,
-0.0455661751,
-0.0021962519,
-0.0531721748,
-0.0096933655,
-0.0284422785,
-0.0489795879,
-0.0278233718,
0.0189871341,
-0.0148687102,
-0.0324308053,
-0.0210160874,
0.036563769,
-0.0141193271,
-0.0144395316,
-0.0316864885,
0.026392255,
0.0252219923,
0.0008111169,
0.0112109864,
0.02457821,
-0.002765093,
0.0154575668,
-0.0708600879,
-0.0616248585,
-0.0108860908,
0.0247859731,
0.0008542525,
-0.0195672009,
-0.0265191011,
0.0234683678,
0.0145835588,
-0.0641312972,
-0.0330851376,
-0.0261412561,
-0.0195433367,
0.0039326809,
0.0219970439,
-0.0268508736,
-0.0073635862,
0.0123748519,
0.0096412934,
-0.0310184155,
0.0188225433,
-0.0034869318,
-0.0446216092,
0.1173939779,
0.0474890731,
0.0010708526,
0.0140297469,
0.0280702338,
0.0190172289,
0.0642782226,
0.0055625569,
0.0278037786,
0.0119620059,
-0.0294902604,
-0.0075648027,
0.0138396258,
0.0250890516,
-0.0189757477,
-0.0669390783,
-0.0058032065,
0.0193067417,
0.0281898733,
0.0218804851,
0.0182476826,
-0.0137136485,
-0.0001020307,
0.0385481939,
0.0444757268,
-0.0001767575,
0.0321824066,
0.0518601462,
0.011876855,
-0.0422078446,
-0.0169203673,
-0.0358753838,
0.0112701682,
-0.0436210558,
-0.0628227815,
-0.0329030678,
-0.0239658002,
-0.0196734518,
-0.0188062359,
-0.0174570307,
-0.0118089654,
-0.0012009921,
-0.0130680837,
0.0885575861,
0.0139883636,
0.0000059244,
0.070580028,
0.0488475673,
-0.0346989557,
0.0095790066,
-0.0615704209,
0.0068937158,
0.0299795046,
0.0230129678,
0.0036255552,
-0.0143847996,
0.0071811941,
0.0010817813,
0.0657670125,
0.0321467593,
-0.0143536404,
-0.0046789492,
-0.0089936638,
-0.0364638232,
0.0156808179,
0.0138955656,
0.0263266377,
-0.0232852604,
-0.0085238041,
0.0200821366,
-0.0312458538,
0.0401760638,
0.0646456778,
-0.0176477898,
-0.0127346236,
0.02982568,
0.0364600047,
0.0271318592,
0.0095908409,
0.0112935901,
0.0004977107,
0.0466583669,
-0.0738190264,
-0.0558777489,
0.038091138,
-0.011351319,
-0.0094593568,
0.0150608011,
-0.0262344871,
0.0248022806,
0.0470077693,
-0.00797222,
-0.0115345521,
0.0619504154,
-0.0377566069,
0.0610961318,
-0.0288373064,
0.0090077519,
-0.0266105514,
0.0304288696,
-0.0251999125,
0.0682789311,
-0.0318779312,
0.0269725602,
-0.0206064209,
-0.02073339,
0.0063356292,
0.0307709798,
-0.0181891695,
0.0112978313,
0.005503682,
-0.0450665168,
0.010577213,
-0.0277612079,
-0.0252882112,
-0.0323839672,
-0.0109343799,
-0.0492479242,
-0.010673671,
-0.0152578698,
0.0245115142,
-0.0209473968,
0.0351129174,
-0.0116637144,
-0.001223704,
0.0182017051,
-0.0327564925,
0.0097238701,
0.021454338,
-0.0188160185,
-0.0584626198,
-0.0046922574,
0.0036195344,
-0.0280138366,
0.0762805417,
-0.000601852,
0.0068597337,
-0.0649248436,
0.0086176852,
0.013115908,
0.0006903702,
-0.0275256932,
-0.051221434,
0.0054426398,
-0.0112835662,
0.0028705178,
0.0285367258,
0.0131550785,
0.1112081185,
0.0893032774,
-0.0083907079,
-0.060049545,
-0.0288902,
-0.0238915719,
-0.0088829231,
-0.0255056489,
-0.0390585624,
-0.028607659,
0.0810594335,
0.0014964652,
-0.0036939371,
-0.075550288,
0.0148685882,
-0.0396222547,
-0.0192581639,
-0.050796736,
-0.0086526088,
-0.0002536222,
0.0041904119,
-0.0199810527,
-0.0124338325,
0.0598086715,
-0.0226120073,
-0.0047756513,
0.0172907971,
-0.0094481967,
-0.0251595229,
0.0860349387,
0.0207257625,
0.0076081795,
0.0007942909,
-0.0172356982,
-0.0369680598,
0.0305412617,
0.0017764387,
-0.0307991169,
0.0458997712,
-0.0332897715,
0.0074302484,
-0.0051965183,
-0.0268674381,
-0.0725425035,
-0.0123731522,
-0.0065651848,
0.0200071484,
0.0041399961,
-0.0304452255,
-0.0311507192,
0.051346574,
-0.0116202962,
-0.0085230237,
0.0071595865,
-0.0236130226,
-0.0116744861,
0.0063691484,
0.0526259132,
-0.0284154806,
0.0198768787,
-0.0021469991,
0.0250124466,
0.0520986021,
-0.0434519909,
-0.0031418949,
-0.0370581858,
0.0152249737,
0.0274104234,
0.0028693136,
-0.0468165725,
-0.04041503,
-0.0205194522,
-0.0508735701,
-0.0443052836,
0.13774243,
0.0538717993,
-0.0636306033,
0.0127134835,
-0.016412219,
-0.0053267884,
0.0224446487,
0.0183455627,
-0.0866439342,
-0.008642179,
-0.0148824006,
-0.0190654751,
-0.0009691453,
-0.0323267952,
-0.0014338912,
-0.1155019328,
0.0275681727,
-0.0290629491,
-0.0645627528,
-0.0613771603,
-0.0470466949,
-0.0045557884,
-0.014240589,
0.0098756868,
-0.0017650409,
-0.0019560887,
-0.020016551,
-0.006107674,
-0.0072122165,
-0.0352295376,
0.0198177136,
-0.0385473333,
0.0121739488,
0.0186885688,
0.0624761432,
-0.0102538057,
-0.0332740024,
-0.0169957057,
-0.0245449711,
0.0129216015,
0.0008517954,
0.0423376709,
-0.0144997193,
-0.0097315162,
0.02419734,
0.01524306,
-0.0761175528,
-0.0180600565,
-0.0436039791,
0.0814514235,
-0.0516981408,
-0.0400225595,
-0.0035523209,
0.0145801818,
0.0010617647,
0.0909655094,
0.0410135351,
-0.0472577438,
-0.0023688262,
0.0015698037,
0.0374052189,
0.056180004,
-0.0731483474,
-0.0323646776,
0.0146061592,
-0.0247927401,
-0.0634542778,
-0.0152748823,
0.0347615443,
0.0001769592,
0.0133630959,
0.0044891066,
0.0238050055,
-0.0306599122,
-0.0728910118,
0.042287834,
-0.0143734626,
0.0143369511,
-0.0073588351,
-0.0371845551,
0.0469183996,
-0.0334798284,
-0.0313380435,
-0.0480140448,
-0.0621263161,
-0.0472274832,
0.0300681964,
0.0052356203,
0.0124749653,
0.0223732013,
-0.0305667371,
-0.0570346825,
0.0165808201,
0.0245313216,
-0.0400289558,
0.001167989,
0.0011592341,
-0.0026661803,
0.0014870319,
0.0601905994,
-0.0358702093,
0.0499741063,
0.0387806408,
0.0048675244,
-0.0701571926,
-0.0272174366,
0.033014264,
-0.0277295876,
0.1065220982,
0.0044339411,
-0.0379527844,
-0.0507685691,
-0.0000105107,
-0.034379445,
-0.0134597477,
-0.0632096082,
-0.0062270942,
0.0434776917,
0.0216853805,
-0.0381207056,
-0.0406752415,
-0.0143271815,
0.0372831225,
0.0020729958,
0.0220378023,
0.0908874199,
0.0110771768,
0.0231801104,
0.0382814556,
0.0071448749,
0.0298731364,
-0.0073133386,
0.0404088497,
-0.0038205462,
0.0684233531,
0.0157522745,
-0.0014690324,
-0.0511903614,
0.0165912118,
-0.05021571,
-0.0189066269,
0.0093105761,
0.0035554643,
0.0386798903,
-0.0135061704,
0.0210579298,
-0.0285314843,
-0.0088437106,
0.0228295922,
0.0434953906,
-0.0280216858,
-0.0478543341,
0.081947118,
0.0274264123,
-0.0196643714,
0.0238335244,
0.0455381311,
-0.0210661739,
0.0523130037,
0.0004156265,
-0.0020830028,
-0.0160261225,
0.0211799219,
0.0638038963,
-0.0050725229,
-0.0239735134,
0.0805444568,
-0.0409513228,
-0.051728189,
0.0015153413,
-0.0385802612,
-0.022361869,
-0.00544025,
0.0147193912,
0.0720774382,
0.0253585894,
-0.0452898704,
-0.0430511981,
-0.0004129508,
-0.036154069,
-0.0155490572,
-0.0471129939,
-6.64182814e-33,
-0.0339913294,
-0.0582593791,
-0.0215260182,
0.0515933521,
-0.014034545,
0.0331875235,
-0.0212940369,
0.0209943745,
-0.0395404883,
0.0435104184,
0.0124467062,
0.047138758,
0.0020104027,
0.0016283595,
0.0300608929,
-0.0098168841,
0.0440704636,
-0.004005101,
0.0023797257,
0.0002564545,
0.068070963,
0.0429621525,
0.0737913847,
-0.076768972,
0.007127231,
0.0065773353,
0.003839755,
0.0660465732,
0.012726536,
0.0480611995,
-0.0486911163,
0.0128763216,
0.0221122112,
-0.0195540525,
0.0352011584,
0.0307973195,
-0.0502292812,
-0.0219137091,
-0.0152360564,
0.0525669716,
-0.0131372223,
-0.0311601013,
0.0611055084,
-0.0240918268,
0.0166443381,
-0.0063442169,
0.0344135389,
-0.0150185153,
0.0096646147,
0.0159752592,
-0.0651524365,
0.0171261504,
-0.0057183444,
-0.0143516185,
0.0484728441,
0.0044049462,
-0.0061063929,
-0.0073849685,
-0.0704544261,
0.0010418047,
-0.0276002549,
0.0082434863,
0.0374293812,
0.0598929934,
-0.0040172949,
0.0707757697,
0.0124585619,
-0.045760747,
-0.0425599776,
-0.0192161072,
0.0542507879,
0.0296303444,
0.0552672073,
0.0208541248,
0.0433566868,
0.0180439632,
-0.0418297388,
-0.0137895681,
0.0141842421,
0.0404011346,
0.0350650102,
0.0121620316,
-0.034757372,
-0.0072167958,
-0.037144769,
-0.0404917225,
-0.0616321191,
-0.0377533399,
0.0365670547,
0.0055990159,
-0.0328728035,
-0.0352588445,
0.0376683585,
-0.0637625232,
-0.0150988428,
0.0349441059,
0.0053668171,
0.0017269311,
0.0181168709,
0.0103023397,
-0.0589273944,
-0.0485979207,
0.021669928,
-0.0340669863,
0.0218140166,
0.0181406345,
0.0286377817,
-0.0037660901,
-0.045779936,
-0.0442436226,
-0.0354234353,
-0.0653368682,
-0.0361258723,
0.0463403054,
0.0196552128,
0.02844676,
-0.0188764893,
0.042959407,
0.0362119712,
0.0541579984,
-0.0238165725,
0.0265704896,
-0.0146877756,
0.0012007015,
-0.0252151992,
-0.0311958753,
-0.0156334024,
0.0159055796,
0.0976317748,
-0.066231668,
0.0006506212,
-0.0152819175,
2.853e-7,
0.071947366,
0.0648687631,
-0.0105801402,
0.0573177375,
0.0034596776,
0.038719859,
0.0073963632,
0.0359740034,
0.0076284208,
0.0085051218,
0.019141119,
0.0089342846,
0.0144812278,
0.0251681525,
-0.0666887388,
-0.0009718223,
-0.0424629562,
-0.009367126,
-0.0047517214,
-0.0351675637,
0.0480636358,
0.1147568896,
0.0249502063,
-0.008052378,
-0.0159809049,
-0.0279533118,
0.0601157956,
-0.0615344681,
0.02776042,
-0.0141227432,
0.0041755619,
-0.0017552567,
0.0067370613,
0.0564671457,
-0.0060382555,
0.0512075238,
0.0082652895,
0.0415654071,
-0.0303843804,
-0.0308843423,
-0.0526189134,
-0.0047115576,
-0.0179605205,
-0.052766934,
0.0734598711,
-0.0805808827,
-0.0392571464,
-0.0003466991,
0.0040187109,
-0.0213689897,
0.0262762066,
-0.0068108244,
-0.0024100293,
0.0104231248,
0.0161200501,
-0.044046618,
0.0046186252,
-0.0837104097,
0.0019418488,
-0.0052941693,
-0.0288230292,
0.0287746787,
-0.025170492,
-0.0354276076,
0.0212261789,
0.0150139248,
-0.0039792755,
2.461670449e-34,
-0.0080072079,
-0.0035395029,
-0.0043118368,
0.0204102863,
0.0394336022,
-0.0125528537,
-0.0007944764,
0.0341218524,
0.023017427,
-0.1071465835,
0.036583297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08966v1 | Improving Large-scale Deep Biasing with Phoneme Features and Text-only Data in Streaming Transducer | 2023-11-15T13:53:28 | 2023-11-15T13:53:28 | Jin Qiu, Lu Huang, Boyu Li, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Zejun Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Deep biasing for the Transducer can improve the recognition performance of
rare words or contextual entities, which is essential in practical
applications, especially for streaming Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR).
However, deep biasing with large-scale rare words remains challenging, as the
performance drops significantly when more distractors exist and there are words
with similar grapheme sequences in the bias list. In this paper, we combine the
phoneme and textual information of rare words in Transducers to distinguish
words with similar pronunciation or spelling. Moreover, the introduction of
training with text-only data containing more rare words benefits large-scale
deep biasing. The experiments on the LibriSpeech corpus demonstrate that the
proposed method achieves state-of-the-art performance on rare word error rate
for different scales and levels of bias lists. | [
-0.0332811512,
0.0114581678,
0.0320767425,
0.0422888547,
-0.0140127195,
0.0077391579,
0.0231949314,
-0.0174532086,
0.0054326695,
-0.041895099,
-0.0240914747,
-0.0534182973,
0.0373055674,
0.0238691978,
0.0125782425,
-0.0591968931,
0.0368218198,
-0.0211401079,
0.0448592454,
-0.0313003361,
0.047449749,
0.0112334462,
-0.049234543,
0.0160700139,
-0.03187133,
0.035737332,
0.033448074,
0.0297459476,
0.0310354233,
-0.0434792079,
-0.0471598804,
0.0228504017,
-0.0081597036,
0.0836859345,
0.0000015959,
-0.0724602938,
-0.0543171428,
0.0026945104,
-0.0861875862,
-0.0253480002,
0.052759137,
0.0192987546,
-0.0237175263,
0.0278123021,
0.0057029915,
-0.0384072438,
0.0753233731,
-0.0240507312,
-0.0125509538,
0.0572895296,
-0.0364860781,
-0.0442238636,
0.0290202666,
0.0099517452,
0.0185417626,
-0.0631279275,
-0.0197137054,
-0.0620756894,
-0.0278259069,
-0.0357956365,
-0.0336344466,
0.0143633699,
-0.0273181535,
0.0359323844,
0.0432757586,
0.0119585833,
-0.0575085357,
-0.058340285,
0.0016433253,
0.0958008915,
-0.0415394381,
-0.0311710574,
0.0205252282,
-0.0112332376,
-0.0204067379,
-0.0486838371,
0.0163284112,
0.0049489718,
-0.0263324771,
0.0282965489,
0.0288850609,
0.0288070422,
0.0160514377,
-0.0011390833,
-0.0394896418,
-0.0383356735,
0.0396839678,
-0.0258733016,
0.0090191662,
0.0247923043,
0.0335850902,
-0.0003676967,
0.0637410954,
-0.0050325394,
-0.0640466958,
-0.0099931005,
-0.0134257413,
-0.0441900827,
-0.0191595219,
0.0159339439,
0.0446162298,
0.0284033343,
-0.0797885582,
0.0386245064,
-0.0321324952,
0.0104719773,
-0.0102228485,
-0.02776579,
0.0189393628,
-0.0419552401,
-0.0167819671,
0.0140259685,
-0.0131017566,
0.0319462642,
0.0142086353,
-0.0371421427,
-0.0128785074,
-0.017304942,
-0.0084033972,
-0.0058013452,
0.0245367549,
0.0032377418,
-0.0765286237,
-0.0204815995,
0.051281698,
0.0712070465,
-0.0039469618,
0.0478823595,
-0.0372290201,
-0.0948995054,
-0.0027470181,
0.0297202151,
0.0964049548,
-0.0204972792,
0.0312013887,
-0.0054404163,
-0.0046302313,
-0.0471969061,
-0.0360076129,
0.0321742594,
-0.029261414,
-0.0124232667,
-0.0285476241,
-0.0716302395,
0.0269943383,
-0.0156229911,
0.0350465626,
-0.0092604319,
0.0054936656,
-0.0272090901,
0.0277437009,
0.06798172,
-0.0136888102,
-0.0017650317,
0.0253203083,
-0.0321237259,
0.0341216512,
0.0694164708,
0.038171798,
-0.0282696541,
0.0439474843,
-0.0297890417,
0.0199074112,
0.0521120988,
-0.0089335162,
0.0076056714,
-0.0027889749,
-0.0288444646,
-0.0264123976,
0.0225543901,
0.0646033064,
0.0597990304,
-0.0328053609,
-0.0006612562,
0.0531002656,
0.0432887562,
0.0592597388,
0.0014532318,
-0.0096650552,
0.0224817861,
-0.0354153663,
-0.0125792995,
0.0142776137,
-0.0156140244,
0.041650597,
0.0320548788,
0.0406809412,
0.0436974689,
-0.0447686166,
0.0415095501,
0.0007417801,
-0.0226859469,
-0.0360257067,
-0.0052035125,
0.0380015336,
0.0167772323,
-0.0392604992,
0.0750116631,
0.0045529027,
-0.0285591353,
0.0295934267,
-0.0106165921,
0.0027985212,
0.0398776196,
-0.008142828,
-0.0415460244,
-0.031014502,
-0.0339687318,
-0.0028835018,
0.0545675382,
0.0444121361,
-0.0159322508,
0.0731290504,
-0.0695493892,
-0.0117420517,
0.074885942,
0.0245634392,
0.0614376552,
-0.0020014625,
0.0679177567,
0.0149810361,
-0.0809419528,
-0.0120928464,
-0.0087090898,
0.0175551753,
-0.0600583144,
0.0245062299,
0.0252067838,
0.0396118201,
0.0396428928,
-0.0361109078,
-0.0124187646,
-0.008180636,
-0.0460210405,
0.0188203137,
0.0207093097,
-0.0692088529,
-0.0257331524,
0.0438745134,
-0.0945932493,
0.0048672841,
0.0628040954,
0.0332656316,
-0.0692259148,
0.0111577585,
-0.0417335555,
0.0591476895,
-0.0316603445,
0.0237591714,
-0.0005391506,
0.0239667408,
0.0183892157,
0.0117275314,
0.0340007283,
-0.0181668717,
-0.0206179135,
-0.0239812937,
0.0068648527,
-0.0637548491,
-0.0243014842,
-0.0134126469,
-0.0162832644,
0.0151145672,
-0.0068699867,
-0.0105793159,
-0.0313609764,
-0.0143105444,
-0.0511555038,
-0.0087130424,
-0.0349201299,
0.0503472388,
-0.0078052212,
0.0465903617,
-0.0087967552,
-0.0432857983,
-0.0191432498,
-0.0145430937,
0.0196393821,
0.0246962551,
-0.0095125623,
-0.0294638053,
-0.0317276344,
-0.043462228,
-0.0065113078,
0.0040408098,
-0.0027063247,
0.0231542028,
-0.037292555,
-0.0221837088,
-0.0084533524,
0.0568160415,
0.0284509026,
0.0451302975,
0.0270202607,
0.009211245,
-0.0180700216,
0.0163291506,
0.0200406611,
-0.0038999484,
-0.0508709736,
-0.0200391877,
-0.0142499451,
-0.0653953552,
-0.0280767661,
0.0011243174,
0.0139942514,
-0.0241797063,
0.0373965465,
-0.0345659442,
-0.0259342622,
-0.0079751303,
0.0364296548,
-0.003929357,
-0.024492573,
-0.0145511301,
-0.0091875838,
0.0269300286,
-0.0258272924,
-0.0414501019,
-0.0187927168,
-0.0154297575,
-0.0277534854,
0.0303901378,
-0.0609757602,
-0.0436564535,
-0.0804463699,
0.0114751998,
-0.0136008691,
0.0118178502,
-0.0372258537,
0.0105529455,
-0.0499712266,
-0.0733743832,
-0.000615806,
0.0194174368,
0.0306351371,
-0.0375114866,
-0.0015975951,
-0.0020925677,
0.0263659656,
0.0020296513,
-0.0173245221,
-0.0304493904,
-0.0138165355,
-0.0498626679,
-0.0189544447,
0.0376987457,
-0.0289397947,
0.0005294178,
0.0163584407,
-0.0118762637,
0.0581597202,
0.0472471751,
0.0246553421,
-0.0317179449,
0.0632252619,
0.0218685251,
0.0181929898,
0.0195479989,
0.0106031606,
0.0192224998,
-0.0081834029,
0.0903734043,
0.0086057046,
-0.054667972,
0.0013958518,
0.0390445031,
-0.010679746,
-0.0022886037,
-0.0120639736,
0.0342521928,
-0.014019087,
-0.0045938687,
0.0873436406,
-0.0115335556,
-0.0720762536,
-0.0132065425,
0.025746448,
0.0645690858,
-0.0022933076,
-0.0354834944,
-0.0726624653,
-0.0547788069,
0.0385110229,
0.0251090284,
0.0182548035,
-0.0066795056,
-0.0104310727,
-0.122152321,
-0.0237716977,
0.0155894421,
0.0123487776,
-0.0249239448,
-0.0632246733,
0.0310235061,
-0.0473668389,
0.00811675,
-0.0104904529,
-0.0012730436,
-0.0317780152,
0.0297150798,
-0.0796613991,
-0.1022878438,
-0.0120689422,
-0.0845139474,
0.0563836806,
0.0447007418,
-0.002535518,
-0.0348745733,
0.0157376658,
0.0608045198,
-0.0112442989,
-0.040348053,
-0.0272036456,
0.0324556939,
-0.0122385677,
-0.0244982634,
-0.0038598601,
0.0456028171,
-0.0096940827,
0.0362490937,
-0.0111980755,
0.0458059311,
0.0064496575,
-0.0135256685,
0.0167131424,
-0.0109838927,
0.0599016249,
0.0519138202,
0.0213248935,
-0.0074115614,
-0.0230753645,
0.0261179488,
0.049098026,
-0.0180660207,
-0.0289369747,
0.0128767351,
0.0003047068,
-0.0523764789,
-0.0288969316,
-0.0149472523,
-0.015884582,
0.0683593675,
0.0077895396,
0.0187730342,
0.0078997202,
0.0189520549,
-0.0031444672,
0.0239883736,
-0.01503463,
0.0413942933,
-0.0416970775,
-0.0231224298,
-0.003453145,
-0.0340678431,
-0.0217354652,
0.026087651,
-0.0727876797,
-0.0403147079,
0.0474183075,
-0.0598678999,
0.0254985504,
0.0610105097,
-0.0338860974,
-0.0544788577,
0.0547030866,
0.0380403921,
-0.0380628221,
-0.0171212759,
0.0435998663,
-0.0368750282,
-0.0066305846,
0.0184642598,
-0.0556683876,
0.0295945853,
0.0000114639,
0.0326173417,
-0.0353374518,
-0.0174335465,
-0.0179742277,
0.0183099657,
0.0352184586,
-0.0295249317,
0.0304037873,
-0.0583609976,
-0.0039011466,
0.0864372849,
0.0498944558,
0.0136052882,
0.0049747727,
0.0361598767,
0.0053140474,
-0.0233605057,
-0.0135128582,
-0.0298278816,
-0.0410169512,
-0.0246438365,
0.0716774985,
0.069957301,
-0.0255317502,
0.0143680787,
-0.0307379495,
-0.0192840528,
0.0875533074,
0.0398462638,
0.0256662201,
-0.0125451759,
-0.0426417366,
0.0259402581,
-0.0046251575,
0.0002286285,
-0.0089293811,
-0.0188029446,
0.0003676601,
-0.0094115576,
0.0054400079,
0.0559195131,
-0.0531467199,
0.047781907,
-0.0039609084,
0.0165406186,
-0.0252312794,
-0.0340834558,
-0.0411697924,
0.0326970108,
0.0004186046,
0.0134960907,
-0.0135171656,
0.0580036081,
0.0645085871,
0.0101484209,
0.0507906824,
-0.0118366526,
0.0240581464,
-0.0432978794,
-0.0026243706,
-0.0214182977,
-0.0014581698,
-0.0194954704,
-0.0040671653,
-0.0132200792,
-0.0483086407,
0.0527969636,
-0.0546894483,
0.036769487,
-0.002290084,
0.0157414209,
0.0123755252,
-0.0408238396,
0.0485298783,
0.0513065569,
-0.0357205458,
0.0347855128,
-0.0139778461,
-0.0067178551,
-5.983138778e-33,
0.0085192006,
0.0235906057,
-0.0182494838,
-0.0132019967,
-0.007562255,
0.0341697223,
-0.0026241825,
-0.0016069427,
-0.0496689714,
0.0075834156,
-0.0015193591,
0.0050449255,
0.0521554165,
0.0274864826,
-0.0310822185,
-0.0385209136,
0.0596545748,
0.0149546145,
0.0178588741,
0.0124776606,
0.0121524483,
0.0657873005,
0.0303176716,
-0.0473422892,
-0.0234374348,
0.0058597173,
0.018799359,
0.0023541201,
0.0649121851,
0.0569746643,
-0.0324857831,
0.0548945665,
-0.0047985371,
-0.0332797952,
-0.0287385974,
0.0485535823,
-0.0704806447,
-0.0007774568,
-0.0370842852,
0.0548787378,
0.0763791725,
0.0081858905,
0.0602934696,
0.0103138406,
-0.0459276289,
-0.0025308435,
0.0303352401,
-0.0114718666,
-0.0008687087,
-0.0165116508,
-0.0540215522,
0.0728497729,
-0.002553791,
0.0099996915,
0.038132716,
-0.0074877637,
-0.0185374264,
-0.0162802618,
-0.07076893,
0.0586463735,
0.0062830085,
0.0376412198,
0.0040031248,
0.0218481831,
-0.0314640813,
0.0396794677,
0.0801027715,
-0.0496272892,
0.0066474993,
-0.0307013169,
0.0412513763,
-0.0066115595,
0.0222469065,
0.0551545732,
0.0497061126,
-0.0277740769,
-0.016139714,
-0.0362764709,
0.0145423356,
0.0064654867,
0.0391444191,
-0.0015020575,
-0.0643936843,
-0.0088981958,
-0.0177797787,
-0.0096341949,
-0.04122857,
0.0663776845,
0.0531380922,
0.0215957798,
0.0110060759,
0.0504706576,
0.0673931018,
0.0046229698,
-0.0115135955,
0.0143691851,
0.0467050932,
-0.0168000516,
-0.0178789087,
0.0247756038,
-0.0427412279,
-0.0469558686,
0.0222248733,
0.0602973588,
0.0005730288,
-0.0116688311,
0.0113386577,
0.0263926275,
-0.0754651129,
0.006769394,
-0.0081337225,
-0.0322051235,
-0.0174469538,
0.0391006507,
0.0545407422,
-0.0413562804,
0.0085327514,
0.0532541908,
0.0050650784,
0.024481792,
0.0262540001,
-0.0222807638,
-0.0233390052,
0.0224020798,
-0.0291699246,
0.0054182825,
0.0192621127,
-0.0072626821,
0.0068243626,
0.0022451533,
-0.0002097119,
-0.0323173776,
2.57e-7,
-0.0266502574,
0.0054944702,
0.0384634659,
-0.0674146786,
0.0115801496,
0.0067462223,
0.0130999507,
0.0164961666,
-0.0484718904,
0.0282412246,
0.0186861306,
0.0034153562,
0.0563578978,
0.0327468254,
-0.0869357362,
-0.051295191,
-0.059165284,
0.0513863079,
-0.0523471683,
-0.0204901714,
-0.0147524709,
0.0879317224,
-0.0086928541,
-0.084161669,
0.0392672457,
-0.0367796794,
-0.0380327739,
-0.0051712096,
0.0555606894,
-0.0075674611,
0.0266487319,
0.0051034098,
0.0012582409,
0.0144960312,
-0.0125133088,
0.0156413093,
0.0303117614,
-0.0256386437,
-0.0447776541,
-0.0351873077,
-0.0010072009,
0.0105773509,
-0.0315937139,
-0.0207671169,
0.0376206152,
0.0491541438,
0.0131522035,
-0.0531309508,
-0.0559486076,
-0.0301787574,
-0.0046310611,
-0.0059420662,
0.0147275273,
-0.0044787317,
0.0364655964,
-0.0073156669,
-0.0546284206,
-0.0476484112,
0.018971689,
0.0020095212,
-0.0292224605,
-0.0240221806,
-0.0036004696,
0.0271856468,
0.0381941162,
-0.0149862617,
0.0144053735,
2.122306607e-34,
0.0327714607,
-0.0073964405,
0.0346851945,
-0.0012865886,
-0.0079675224,
-0.017261412,
0.0331027769,
-0.0179539062,
0.0201945696,
-0.0445538908,
-0.0216441192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08941v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08941v3 | Transformers in the Service of Description Logic-based Contexts | 2023-11-15T13:23:24 | 2024-04-26T16:32:02 | Angelos Poulis, Eleni Tsalapati, Manolis Koubarakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in transformer-based models have initiated research
interests in investigating their ability to learn to perform reasoning tasks.
However, most of the contexts used for this purpose are in practice very
simple: generated from short (fragments of) first-order logic sentences with
only a few logical operators and quantifiers. In this work, we construct the
natural language dataset, DELTA$_D$, using the description logic language
$\mathcal{ALCQ}$. DELTA$_D$ contains 384K examples, and increases in two
dimensions: i) reasoning depth, and ii) linguistic complexity. In this way, we
systematically investigate the reasoning ability of a supervised fine-tuned
DeBERTa-based model and of two large language models (GPT-3.5, GPT-4) with
few-shot prompting. Our results demonstrate that the DeBERTa-based model can
master the reasoning task and that the performance of GPTs can improve
significantly even when a small number of samples is provided (9 shots). We
open-source our code and datasets. | [
0.0461756438,
0.0869169831,
-0.0166218448,
0.0484515131,
-0.0459967181,
0.0194490887,
0.0050485823,
-0.0556531623,
-0.0285315029,
-0.0405592024,
-0.0075501609,
-0.0069860797,
-0.0027566934,
0.0467554256,
0.0190662183,
-0.0578975752,
0.0276254732,
-0.0419142358,
-0.0148599604,
0.0029344859,
-0.0307468548,
0.0045576128,
-0.0157002509,
0.0423030071,
-0.0027110614,
-0.0020534352,
-0.0254243426,
-0.0195801444,
0.047201246,
-0.000776467,
0.0203402322,
0.0548711829,
0.0259489473,
0.0313530527,
0.0000019258,
-0.0373441316,
-0.0100609874,
0.0031991815,
-0.040223632,
-0.0671430007,
0.0214446634,
-0.0285006016,
0.0011937064,
0.0095410105,
-0.064214468,
-0.023769429,
0.0495806634,
0.096233882,
0.0655087754,
0.0647498146,
-0.0204353016,
-0.0918683708,
0.0289604589,
-0.0319174863,
0.0259811133,
-0.0274928827,
0.0141112674,
0.0146178547,
0.0253087245,
-0.0002632157,
0.0008046469,
0.0170997959,
0.043519944,
0.0022719379,
-0.0379626825,
0.0386007167,
-0.059727449,
-0.0330939516,
0.0164420791,
0.0775106996,
0.0190558732,
-0.0134396469,
-0.0301719271,
0.0269390233,
0.0066177822,
-0.0197535455,
-0.0036106342,
0.0381539091,
-0.0183279496,
-0.0055159722,
0.0329287909,
0.0211298876,
0.0057541206,
-0.0123659251,
-0.0911460593,
0.1045197919,
-0.0002033901,
-0.0193820354,
0.0066685448,
-0.0098697348,
-0.0522062145,
-0.0487447605,
-0.022472566,
0.0511106439,
-0.0261739846,
0.0267326552,
-0.0159933176,
0.0039401865,
0.0056464397,
0.0433963835,
-0.0107225841,
0.0546675324,
-0.0062484355,
0.0393730626,
-0.0266096052,
0.080001682,
-0.0269971602,
0.0805133358,
-0.0153466649,
-0.0437388904,
-0.0616912246,
-0.0162436273,
-0.050487034,
0.0275469683,
0.0056506391,
0.0079517104,
-0.0547400974,
0.0012911877,
0.0001905799,
0.0215056203,
0.0079766056,
0.0012217407,
-0.0468139462,
-0.0194383636,
-0.0505364574,
0.02063898,
-0.0309683904,
0.041898638,
0.0259613991,
-0.0512891859,
-0.0173846167,
-0.0324445851,
0.0120592434,
-0.038883768,
0.0025371125,
0.0887373015,
0.0157314371,
-0.0508709997,
-0.0148553168,
-0.0274939928,
0.0110447742,
-0.0958858952,
0.0002995306,
-0.0482987426,
0.0271686893,
0.0267204326,
-0.0001059609,
-0.0339325964,
0.0053062071,
0.0305890683,
-0.0008944712,
0.1175393611,
-0.0015152959,
0.0026871092,
-0.0209155455,
0.0156268999,
-0.0238108523,
0.0369616151,
0.0378427133,
0.0310001709,
-0.0212325212,
0.0082523199,
0.0270418767,
0.0053589521,
-0.0077778571,
-0.0224558357,
-0.0134164644,
0.0299393814,
-0.0532760173,
0.0262126289,
-0.0058089746,
0.0420018621,
-0.0292417128,
-0.0088696647,
0.0280548241,
0.0430290736,
0.0453834757,
0.009750979,
0.0530330315,
0.0319952965,
-0.0109596187,
0.0156108476,
-0.0982071161,
0.0332346931,
0.0011819114,
0.0149321826,
-0.0473747253,
0.0137212817,
-0.0276306141,
-0.0654580817,
-0.0130245285,
-0.0347041823,
0.0157461856,
0.0077829813,
0.0549234264,
0.0645840615,
-0.0210953895,
0.0783138499,
0.0263682231,
-0.036929179,
-0.0453741401,
-0.0666131154,
0.0101734847,
0.0110468315,
0.0237624012,
-0.0431822129,
-0.0501548797,
-0.039761547,
-0.0200251807,
0.0388694406,
0.0186909698,
0.0092621855,
0.0025119367,
-0.0212324932,
-0.028442461,
-0.0347457454,
0.0186027419,
-0.0057723797,
0.0201050323,
-0.0129162055,
0.0124485902,
-0.0582692288,
0.0345926471,
0.0214204695,
-0.0025900959,
-0.0280902945,
-0.0015684069,
0.0283826198,
0.0166616626,
-0.0424480662,
0.0154528925,
-0.000955867,
0.0053551863,
-0.0277337208,
-0.0540967025,
0.0525564365,
-0.0517444387,
-0.0322315544,
0.0256280769,
-0.0513612628,
-0.0317714475,
0.0549037531,
-0.0662859827,
-0.0263412856,
0.027820291,
-0.0235129017,
-0.0113531686,
-0.0314109176,
-0.0236342307,
0.022434948,
-0.0033528309,
-0.0187278446,
0.1102445349,
0.0178140029,
0.0025954365,
-0.0016750959,
-0.0043607084,
0.0122889644,
-0.0213710722,
0.0134827057,
-0.0253275689,
-0.0413582437,
-0.0110367853,
0.0034981431,
0.0152095659,
-0.0121813044,
-0.0305462107,
-0.0256497618,
-0.003542721,
-0.0122377826,
0.0038124982,
0.0193501916,
0.0194042604,
0.014004658,
0.0200826507,
-0.0622710623,
-0.0142830675,
0.0167331975,
0.0018512047,
0.0417220108,
0.008792948,
-0.0339065604,
-0.0071145217,
-0.0102994125,
-0.0364586152,
0.0439588539,
0.0181706138,
0.0315807275,
-0.0238275956,
0.0197935831,
-0.0229559243,
0.030744886,
-0.0294447038,
-0.0282306559,
0.0162280984,
-0.0079566836,
0.0273315385,
0.0595618188,
-0.0043827016,
0.0267180838,
0.0460737981,
0.023391936,
-0.0136131318,
0.0447120853,
-0.0435701422,
-0.0084260507,
-0.0540670641,
-0.0037799201,
-0.0034030303,
0.0803675428,
-0.0220420305,
-0.0019319734,
-0.0654545426,
0.031715408,
-0.0067206756,
0.0007656471,
-0.0043605519,
0.0213514399,
0.0066276416,
0.0740370899,
-0.0082658632,
0.0015018932,
0.0801015049,
0.0245827269,
-0.0046926285,
-0.03763346,
0.0007382093,
-0.0468071885,
0.0744264349,
0.0169406906,
0.0135162529,
0.0600861721,
-0.0284640621,
-0.0562593937,
-0.0354556441,
0.0164028704,
-0.0231651701,
0.0674810186,
-0.0230354555,
0.0229573436,
-0.0459735431,
-0.0558289401,
-0.0664993674,
-0.018758731,
-0.0553325005,
0.0332005844,
-0.0309830233,
-0.0308051072,
-0.0687929615,
0.0218968783,
0.006575292,
0.0563550107,
-0.0116478708,
-0.0294157341,
-0.0426975749,
0.0077533182,
0.0340975039,
0.0563599616,
0.0219209902,
-0.0191803798,
0.0306472536,
0.0179879908,
0.0162059367,
0.0144227305,
-0.0373896882,
0.0187854003,
-0.0068824193,
-0.0030849352,
-0.0093921069,
0.0011572004,
0.0266415216,
-0.0674802214,
-0.0409011245,
0.1019502059,
0.0160058774,
-0.0060382402,
0.0117570749,
-0.0117718251,
0.0122997286,
0.0246470366,
0.0382833369,
-0.1262037158,
-0.054669477,
0.0218028165,
-0.0102131413,
0.0181185473,
-0.0278836787,
-0.0017573367,
-0.0840783641,
0.0548640639,
-0.033309795,
-0.0269520767,
-0.0469775386,
-0.026008347,
0.0287556443,
-0.0495024435,
-0.0242067073,
-0.008475164,
-0.0082081761,
-0.0138997221,
-0.0060615633,
0.0151967155,
-0.0479544252,
0.0674633533,
-0.0183130931,
-0.0137944063,
0.0580537543,
0.0148455687,
-0.0013723513,
-0.0573522709,
-0.0374228358,
0.0070026279,
-0.0115163717,
0.0310393944,
0.024023924,
0.000968765,
-0.02052694,
-0.0093740625,
0.0600623563,
-0.0562391691,
-0.0190815199,
-0.0153439548,
0.0714963898,
-0.015113553,
-0.0196961183,
-0.0124124037,
-0.0015769878,
-0.018450411,
0.0631227791,
0.0100690192,
-0.0004082026,
-0.049980998,
-0.0370333977,
-0.0406976081,
-0.0303961299,
-0.0459707715,
0.0234954562,
0.0517680347,
-0.0189669039,
-0.0368298106,
-0.0084675066,
0.0443697348,
0.0151633043,
-0.012116448,
-0.0240998454,
0.0425700396,
0.0168664362,
-0.0532122776,
0.0200899728,
-0.0493276082,
0.0280709807,
-0.0133341393,
0.0165449698,
0.0251784828,
-0.0188423116,
-0.0419498309,
-0.0053452663,
-0.0806534812,
-0.0375893004,
0.0334096588,
0.0439294204,
0.0324926302,
0.0136650726,
-0.03681916,
-0.0017279977,
0.0068220254,
0.0353637747,
-0.0157519598,
-0.0224008914,
0.0564449839,
-0.0258721262,
0.0149780866,
0.0573695526,
-0.0196734425,
0.0359347761,
0.0124635305,
0.0260715932,
-0.0315598547,
-0.0110986438,
0.046381738,
-0.0145581979,
0.032536488,
0.0257382728,
0.0164569505,
-0.0071173925,
0.04396547,
-0.0278584082,
-0.0096095912,
-0.0538745224,
0.0056112511,
0.011232106,
-0.0089571076,
0.0147143332,
-0.0375099108,
-0.0200248696,
0.0139774447,
-0.0140317287,
0.003652768,
0.0179587137,
-0.0368093252,
0.0293791145,
-0.0102727506,
-0.0041295364,
-0.0191987138,
0.0076890597,
0.055425521,
-0.023721939,
0.0526457876,
0.0576090962,
0.0052474397,
-0.0264360886,
0.0155060031,
-0.0749576241,
-0.0500400253,
0.0296995938,
-0.0233952533,
0.0370305926,
0.0101243602,
-0.0161718726,
-0.0451002084,
-0.0049960539,
0.0122066746,
0.053374175,
0.0243976451,
-0.0196447838,
0.0529349893,
0.0249861199,
-0.000517869,
-0.0213394798,
0.0623373389,
0.0014321425,
0.052931089,
0.016266495,
0.0257354658,
-0.062857382,
-0.0351574048,
-0.0290632155,
-0.0129878698,
0.0020648367,
0.0168027189,
-0.0409877114,
-0.0792900696,
0.0186536741,
-0.0082606645,
0.0107982401,
-0.0286009256,
0.0352659225,
0.0402821563,
0.0228423402,
-0.067287907,
-0.020028187,
-0.0312323105,
-0.0022693388,
-0.0044555287,
-0.0185498856,
-5.955761515e-33,
-0.0339643955,
-0.018081611,
0.0419800654,
-0.010731874,
0.0001450801,
-0.0282886978,
-0.0295309909,
-0.0415992551,
-0.0318406932,
0.041140385,
-0.0110297967,
0.0462024882,
0.0037812274,
0.0325630382,
-0.0285259616,
-0.0246907882,
0.0376566686,
0.0202554576,
-0.0195431951,
0.0246992726,
0.0181993805,
-0.0092399558,
0.0379492529,
-0.0472012833,
-0.0130264629,
-0.00918331,
-0.0241600852,
0.0470435508,
-0.0779391527,
0.0645509437,
0.0037884556,
0.0115713216,
0.0185978115,
-0.0421137027,
0.0040631145,
0.0116080157,
-0.0949315876,
-0.0091196625,
-0.0100108823,
0.0037521757,
-0.0394739211,
-0.0286026578,
0.0212254301,
0.0041190688,
0.0032461665,
-0.0508121476,
0.0238364451,
-0.0170388091,
0.0193139166,
-0.0350095779,
-0.0565774217,
0.0118019674,
0.0005735141,
-0.0524989814,
0.0104621034,
0.0669419467,
0.0099975411,
-0.0027218594,
-0.0028310593,
-0.0002275025,
0.0384412743,
0.003633297,
0.0342223123,
-0.0088516325,
-0.0124933319,
0.0296810195,
-0.0144397849,
-0.0080926251,
-0.0200995319,
-0.0080181574,
-0.0015203942,
0.1133906245,
0.0245059263,
0.0043514115,
0.0421705693,
0.0177197866,
-0.0683718622,
0.0049247784,
-0.0540209562,
0.1057824343,
0.0417102873,
-0.0192419067,
-0.0033100653,
0.0069151586,
-0.0585677102,
0.0678859353,
-0.038103316,
0.0077894237,
0.0158908088,
0.0074050524,
-0.0290275887,
-0.0218100138,
0.0179919098,
-0.0681997389,
0.0004622093,
0.0224391166,
-0.0112973787,
-0.0178532042,
-0.0120307468,
0.0409724638,
-0.0214835629,
-0.019171685,
0.0198544469,
0.0371124037,
0.012663167,
0.0128885023,
0.061928723,
0.0443144217,
-0.054216031,
0.0011007413,
-0.0493065566,
0.0426782221,
-0.0501972884,
0.0520816296,
0.0275040846,
0.0585564226,
-0.0204762109,
0.0298351347,
-0.0299507026,
-0.0287278257,
-0.0529012531,
0.051106412,
0.0172462985,
0.0441063941,
-0.0131117133,
-0.0270575155,
-0.0517510734,
-0.0085717198,
0.0263477117,
-0.0258701295,
-0.0073398352,
0.0153519772,
2.703e-7,
0.0099477572,
0.0437504165,
0.0258572903,
0.0770680308,
0.0131810941,
0.0504805259,
0.0125745693,
0.0233829636,
0.0154908784,
-0.0072010411,
0.0067546088,
0.0487280376,
0.02984857,
0.0447033793,
-0.0542621017,
0.0141193103,
-0.0156161226,
-0.0416444317,
-0.0361848325,
0.0252789296,
0.0982360542,
0.1131298244,
0.0015726638,
-0.0180199556,
0.0286118221,
-0.0315372981,
0.0538870916,
0.0141249243,
0.019417949,
0.0064612636,
0.0242772661,
0.0484580547,
0.0323340632,
0.0211141128,
0.0342135541,
0.0049215215,
-0.0435744561,
0.0546526387,
-0.0210573338,
-0.0192003343,
-0.017136747,
-0.032002382,
0.000008385,
-0.0256156735,
0.0726043731,
-0.1320397407,
-0.0519937724,
-0.01061018,
-0.0224084873,
-0.0222337153,
-0.0145932175,
0.0166408978,
-0.0194644593,
0.0062879026,
0.0211640149,
-0.015054022,
0.006549967,
-0.1027625799,
-0.0062155863,
0.0200426131,
-0.0032988731,
0.0048402171,
-0.0048169731,
-0.0249526445,
0.0473475419,
-0.0316778421,
-0.016721068,
2.516022598e-34,
0.0343482271,
0.0094295302,
0.0069598109,
0.0321017317,
0.0560497008,
-0.0161610451,
-0.0010398305,
0.0019396942,
0.0090012355,
-0.0864086598,
-0.0127071347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08921v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08921v3 | Self-Improving for Zero-Shot Named Entity Recognition with Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T12:47:52 | 2024-03-21T00:27:37 | Tingyu Xie, Qi Li, Yan Zhang, Zuozhu Liu, Hongwei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Exploring the application of powerful large language models (LLMs) on the
named entity recognition (NER) task has drawn much attention recently. This
work pushes the performance boundary of zero-shot NER with LLMs by proposing a
training-free self-improving framework, which utilizes an unlabeled corpus to
stimulate the self-learning ability of LLMs. First, we use the LLM to make
predictions on the unlabeled corpus using self-consistency and obtain a
self-annotated dataset. Second, we explore various strategies to select
reliable annotations to form a reliable self-annotated dataset. Finally, for
each test input, we retrieve demonstrations from the reliable self-annotated
dataset and perform inference via in-context learning. Experiments on four
benchmarks show substantial performance improvements achieved by our framework.
Through comprehensive experimental analysis, we find that increasing the size
of unlabeled corpus or iterations of self-improving does not guarantee further
improvement, but the performance might be boosted via more advanced strategies
for reliable annotation selection. Code and data are publicly available at
https://github.com/Emma1066/Self-Improve-Zero-Shot-NER | [
0.0081843045,
0.0371042155,
0.0302644782,
0.040942993,
0.020444788,
0.0513820164,
0.0397386961,
0.0092700347,
0.0405871682,
-0.0755057484,
-0.050134372,
0.0038619169,
-0.03546682,
-0.0379228964,
0.0427935682,
0.012449557,
0.0134208724,
-0.039188128,
0.0002762262,
0.0002815573,
-0.0371216796,
-0.0098329661,
-0.0308236014,
-0.0066896654,
0.0145710483,
0.0046609305,
0.0066331076,
0.0056213131,
0.0041555646,
-0.0910528079,
-0.0107872142,
0.0539787337,
0.0152716627,
0.0648332611,
0.000001855,
-0.0680376738,
-0.0306996424,
0.0178806391,
-0.0766227096,
0.0131036406,
0.025790967,
-0.0128642889,
-0.0254099704,
-0.0050714756,
-0.0083803348,
-0.0691141784,
0.0228606835,
0.0356366113,
0.0462767296,
0.0872583836,
0.0106145684,
-0.0328105241,
0.0144900456,
-0.0452645272,
0.0020099585,
-0.0412064381,
0.0543424636,
-0.0091900695,
0.0038428896,
0.0326091833,
-0.0103643695,
0.0109510133,
-0.0172394682,
-0.0182074755,
0.0133416755,
0.0582443178,
-0.0494706146,
0.0083285486,
0.00794347,
0.0528031848,
0.0005230835,
-0.0054122447,
0.0441386327,
-0.0110269738,
-0.0274843518,
-0.033873532,
-0.0417286977,
0.0171096679,
0.0138658714,
0.0269082319,
0.0274103619,
0.0058198795,
0.0395546518,
0.0053002452,
-0.0212767236,
0.0249293391,
0.0039172871,
-0.033505246,
-0.0022194088,
0.0326792933,
-0.016427109,
-0.0717068538,
-0.0242506023,
0.0320439115,
0.0193547718,
0.0349082835,
-0.0207036138,
-0.0240614358,
0.0008150018,
-0.0423658602,
0.0320221744,
0.0076491702,
-0.0019003733,
0.0687342808,
-0.0661941767,
0.0160491131,
-0.0110094342,
0.0048106168,
0.0039574243,
-0.0099464385,
-0.071885474,
0.023425106,
-0.0234369468,
0.0635160208,
0.0109201968,
0.0061721611,
-0.034221027,
0.0082982192,
0.0050424538,
0.0513713807,
-0.005090415,
-0.049671527,
-0.0311343167,
-0.0157418493,
-0.0099533917,
0.0322392136,
-0.0071851243,
-0.0370714888,
-0.0295944046,
-0.0668509677,
-0.0191349089,
-0.0270718988,
0.0177309234,
-0.0510532558,
0.0310043804,
0.061325971,
0.0289258845,
-0.1259012222,
-0.0659778044,
0.0318074338,
-0.0271432176,
-0.0684282854,
-0.0093808752,
-0.0268666632,
0.0158194397,
-0.0001517541,
0.0162419174,
-0.0641590878,
0.0311440099,
-0.009863114,
-0.024947606,
0.0933241844,
-0.0549320132,
-0.0030374594,
0.033078447,
-0.0073250514,
0.0316253677,
0.0825478807,
0.0335771106,
-0.0058728843,
0.0404840112,
0.0164131783,
0.0304488707,
0.0240288805,
0.0243959017,
0.0073373839,
-0.0137443589,
0.0155879548,
0.0133309634,
0.036764212,
0.0272795428,
0.0111190649,
-0.0089723747,
-0.0221416391,
0.0373111144,
0.0300428346,
0.0243367385,
-0.0136446403,
0.0190214217,
-0.0039124023,
0.0352662951,
-0.0144290943,
-0.035709165,
0.0041881171,
-0.0203917883,
0.0214567818,
0.0361652412,
0.0118777445,
-0.0367076248,
-0.0098318337,
-0.0185981188,
-0.0031438852,
-0.0355980881,
0.0200466216,
0.1020388305,
0.009204125,
-0.0552331805,
0.0076151048,
0.0436251424,
-0.013779439,
0.0095644398,
-0.0232448149,
0.0660904497,
0.0422569029,
0.0535044298,
-0.0425611287,
-0.0516822077,
-0.0530965254,
0.0010583156,
0.0552616939,
0.0083379876,
-0.0210922435,
0.0268319398,
-0.0335010439,
-0.0061094738,
-0.012030011,
0.0166128818,
0.0091068158,
0.0140830092,
0.0231359284,
0.0233362131,
-0.0127673,
-0.0254149698,
0.0619376972,
-0.0613895841,
-0.0664011389,
0.0369512103,
0.0027530435,
0.0120713459,
0.0441581085,
-0.0357607417,
-0.0175059307,
0.0390278883,
-0.0282879341,
0.0015039742,
-0.0313837528,
-0.0048621749,
-0.0622753389,
0.0292631593,
0.0234750882,
-0.0366838276,
-0.027995348,
-0.0362783596,
-0.0602631755,
-0.0446201637,
0.0219551697,
0.0188900288,
-0.0385592766,
0.0291784219,
0.0223879535,
0.0080763809,
-0.0262852311,
0.0363716558,
0.0313379243,
0.0242429078,
0.0134240212,
0.031074062,
-0.0091633378,
-0.055858355,
-0.0740232766,
0.0140755773,
0.0050840769,
-0.0337332003,
0.0095535377,
-0.0158453733,
-0.0632116199,
-0.0132116154,
-0.1054657847,
0.0150508303,
-0.0122938119,
0.0336699337,
-0.0109435106,
0.0052762199,
-0.0369060487,
-0.040372964,
0.0237122532,
-0.0254910514,
-0.0268831067,
0.012360665,
0.0394055508,
0.0161958467,
0.0063617271,
-0.0096150693,
0.0044905962,
-0.0205039233,
0.0365050547,
0.0141459303,
-0.0317249037,
-0.0724421293,
0.0360799469,
-0.0220321063,
0.0280038361,
0.0219327603,
0.015331218,
-0.0134901311,
0.0202150512,
-0.0237385016,
0.073787123,
-0.0003639819,
0.0156863406,
0.0111353034,
-0.005598533,
-0.0401267894,
0.0243294742,
-0.0217000749,
0.0106371231,
-0.0115158269,
0.0010358824,
-0.0091778589,
0.0729761869,
-0.0398314185,
0.0031086274,
-0.0352455936,
0.0230029989,
-0.0283204783,
-0.0098059839,
-0.0095303599,
0.0278492607,
-0.0052349516,
-0.0153747797,
0.0079828091,
-0.0136681981,
0.0587039292,
-0.0825874805,
-0.0197266415,
0.0160436817,
0.0313846394,
-0.0356718488,
0.0530815572,
0.0157565437,
-0.0113760764,
0.0551296845,
-0.0323973224,
0.0349984802,
0.0061059562,
0.0102504268,
-0.0218582321,
0.0355861373,
-0.0042190775,
0.0647285804,
-0.0168994814,
-0.0545076318,
-0.0380678065,
-0.0224627834,
-0.0539208874,
-0.0086310916,
-0.0498569123,
0.0105182603,
0.0019431735,
0.0392385349,
0.007245115,
0.0834103376,
-0.0133926813,
-0.020344222,
-0.019042667,
0.0171480738,
-0.0017668674,
0.0148421032,
0.0219663456,
0.0056900047,
0.0015100105,
0.0001100751,
0.0253618024,
0.0420578457,
-0.0177159682,
-0.0065812608,
-0.0065168701,
-0.0791514069,
0.0128534185,
-0.0194490068,
0.0330606215,
-0.0445107594,
-0.0119781103,
0.1228001341,
-0.0030209336,
-0.0191724226,
-0.0196983386,
0.0161459781,
-0.025630204,
0.0366222523,
0.0399686247,
-0.0917789266,
-0.0447663702,
0.0133536644,
0.0263867397,
0.0042061037,
-0.0858643502,
-0.0061126803,
-0.1530907899,
0.0297084879,
-0.0050627911,
-0.046067588,
0.0305389911,
-0.075591892,
0.0179683529,
-0.0731470808,
-0.0172069408,
0.020411782,
-0.0330229513,
0.001464981,
0.0242552571,
-0.0029153835,
-0.080666706,
0.0022645339,
-0.042224545,
0.1000740603,
0.0428845771,
0.0201106407,
-0.0084445262,
0.0230382346,
0.001548573,
-0.0483919494,
-0.0208964292,
-0.0273560341,
0.057615079,
-0.0634228066,
-0.0343949534,
0.0160239469,
0.0146847209,
-0.0037131128,
-0.0055538681,
0.0132247144,
0.0382276215,
-0.0006889713,
0.0234894399,
-0.0066167763,
-0.0523170531,
0.0014122867,
0.0845564455,
0.0058371034,
-0.0217075367,
-0.0076972544,
0.0178780556,
-0.0227534361,
-0.0100154914,
-0.0181128532,
0.0164996814,
-0.0441613384,
-0.0362782814,
-0.038220007,
-0.0421841964,
0.0636954829,
0.0682759508,
-0.0059568402,
0.0291758105,
-0.0055015115,
0.0283790752,
-0.0333619229,
0.0227976497,
-0.055631984,
-0.0161484815,
-0.0717021972,
0.0105809765,
0.0571227111,
0.0193334688,
-0.01006593,
-0.0037523517,
-0.0667939335,
-0.0506745018,
0.0022631853,
0.0536894463,
0.0107367113,
0.0561629236,
-0.0020832969,
-0.0479032211,
0.0451457873,
0.0700444505,
-0.024140412,
0.0023457932,
0.0076801633,
0.0270121824,
-0.016311869,
0.0341975763,
-0.0215147026,
0.036387898,
0.0437084846,
0.0390287302,
-0.0224998482,
0.0020403443,
0.0001829224,
0.0231118165,
0.0714340732,
-0.0339156054,
0.0060442616,
-0.0322674438,
0.0103885559,
-0.01011666,
-0.0024449432,
-0.0249539688,
0.0157197565,
0.0062233303,
-0.0398447178,
-0.0290580634,
0.0323347747,
-0.0504102968,
0.0401999615,
-0.0430989154,
0.0058488199,
0.006013291,
0.01750906,
0.0002777877,
-0.0371406451,
-0.0011964227,
0.0330633894,
0.0674931705,
0.0376786515,
-0.0387726016,
0.0131130824,
0.0167436283,
0.0204505119,
-0.0196834952,
0.0085009504,
-0.0134918625,
0.0262891632,
-0.0448495038,
0.0775630251,
0.0646082535,
-0.0005221007,
0.0510988198,
-0.0131647876,
-0.0137905721,
-0.0132358707,
-0.003595392,
-0.0266630985,
0.0028914234,
0.0253719911,
0.0205867477,
-0.0174868889,
0.0262265857,
0.0595224574,
0.0334150493,
0.0293686688,
0.0621736981,
0.0357622057,
-0.0432822779,
-0.0064164959,
0.006239641,
-0.0203773975,
-0.0178427156,
-0.0001723463,
-0.0054007079,
-0.0606712997,
0.0288910624,
-0.01496612,
-0.0302769206,
0.0007185441,
0.0020596699,
0.0099342382,
-0.0001424507,
-0.0072344928,
-0.0530699641,
0.0129808588,
0.0283931158,
-0.033414945,
0.0102781896,
-6.091562704e-33,
-0.0396832302,
-0.0366551951,
0.0405614749,
-0.0240024813,
0.001085922,
0.0124710184,
-0.0230182968,
-0.0088383481,
0.0004698758,
-0.0304929204,
-0.037095096,
-0.0189439617,
0.0262763351,
0.0199308693,
0.0040040417,
-0.0216698255,
0.0622851998,
0.0011146289,
-0.0508336015,
0.0058570406,
0.0217385516,
0.0553032421,
0.0658157989,
-0.0735221282,
0.0400442109,
-0.0063368562,
-0.0187045354,
0.014649489,
0.0790406987,
0.0666056871,
-0.0247719698,
-0.0088485396,
0.0096608773,
-0.0714987069,
0.014359206,
-0.0117204357,
-0.1156525463,
-0.0020180345,
-0.0506754257,
0.0083328867,
-0.0178240333,
-0.0069735139,
0.0340762548,
-0.0118049579,
-0.001415455,
0.0185843781,
-0.0005119573,
-0.0215292815,
-0.0082527678,
-0.0154456971,
-0.0399444476,
0.0573401004,
-0.0010382239,
-0.0028045077,
0.0909721181,
-0.0274440963,
0.038806241,
0.0143707916,
-0.0849685669,
-0.0191513933,
0.0219657626,
0.0071042986,
0.0520307496,
0.024521675,
0.0260466114,
0.0456139594,
0.0358315408,
0.0214637984,
-0.0135604842,
-0.031445954,
0.0237872899,
0.0126804393,
0.0107791265,
0.0435874797,
0.0559183136,
-0.0212151408,
-0.0821029842,
0.009993718,
0.0101134889,
-0.0041907341,
0.002293447,
-0.0063736085,
-0.0425141528,
0.0179322399,
-0.0191386584,
-0.0485024042,
-0.0390518717,
-0.0138978278,
0.0220226385,
0.0325160548,
-0.0700910687,
0.0503227189,
0.0442340858,
-0.028092362,
-0.0932724699,
-0.0035813556,
0.0146678425,
0.0328714885,
-0.0131725473,
0.0049464437,
-0.0747468472,
-0.0385572836,
-0.0121702449,
0.0065339846,
0.0248311628,
-0.0152421826,
0.0522097088,
0.0025675627,
-0.0818734169,
-0.0203120429,
-0.0024508757,
0.0314750783,
-0.0187900811,
-0.0099942666,
0.0193645898,
0.0155748026,
0.0194056202,
0.0490599684,
0.077063024,
-0.0376791582,
-0.0052156341,
0.0427695215,
0.0283155199,
-0.0054641794,
0.0013263298,
-0.006540746,
0.0278530382,
0.0287305806,
0.0109816371,
-0.0691567436,
0.0094642574,
-0.001757388,
2.548e-7,
0.0176877398,
0.0491753966,
0.001512396,
-0.0145921176,
0.0102921808,
0.0383605175,
-0.0135543495,
0.0395093709,
-0.0125575652,
-0.0077322577,
0.0006565523,
-0.0048960638,
0.0377504975,
0.0253462698,
-0.0941260457,
-0.0089174099,
-0.0314586684,
0.0274388008,
-0.0634137765,
-0.0091209561,
-0.0041642883,
0.0878342465,
0.0306069572,
0.0007463811,
-0.0108861132,
-0.0345931016,
0.0799820572,
0.018397117,
0.0217415188,
0.0403487943,
0.0000071974,
0.0811823979,
-0.0342235826,
0.0107072182,
-0.0020841877,
0.0405165367,
-0.007090129,
0.0561822765,
0.00335803,
0.015240035,
0.0150176845,
-0.0249611288,
0.0368164927,
-0.015973581,
0.0915992409,
-0.1001040041,
-0.0308792237,
-0.0187402144,
-0.0060946378,
-0.0347276516,
0.0432944931,
0.0174779519,
-0.0147439884,
0.0455164276,
0.0263699908,
-0.013262365,
-0.0290132184,
-0.0737571418,
0.0307884607,
-0.0086293686,
-0.0156665035,
0.0162266549,
-0.021813944,
-0.0119298203,
-0.0026343011,
-0.062926583,
0.0153330136,
2.053730058e-34,
-0.0175739806,
-0.0048153377,
-0.028866088,
0.0304468814,
-0.0000424114,
-0.0012217953,
-0.0467279479,
0.0084635755,
-0.0251610372,
-0.0523506962,
0.0193769354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08896v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08896v2 | HeLM: Highlighted Evidence augmented Language Model for Enhanced Table-to-Text Generation | 2023-11-15T12:02:52 | 2024-04-27T12:51:11 | Junyi Bian, Xiaolei Qin, Wuhe Zou, Mengzuo Huang, Congyi Luo, Ke Zhang, Weidong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large models have demonstrated significant progress across various domains,
particularly in tasks related to text generation. In the domain of Table to
Text, many Large Language Model (LLM)-based methods currently resort to
modifying prompts to invoke public APIs, incurring potential costs and
information leaks. With the advent of open-source large models, fine-tuning
LLMs has become feasible. In this study, we conducted parameter-efficient
fine-tuning on the LLaMA2 model. Distinguishing itself from previous
fine-tuning-based table-to-text methods, our approach involves injecting
reasoning information into the input by emphasizing table-specific row data.
Our model consists of two modules: 1) a table reasoner that identifies relevant
row evidence, and 2) a table summarizer that generates sentences based on the
highlighted table. To facilitate this, we propose a search strategy to
construct reasoning labels for training the table reasoner. On both the FetaQA
and QTSumm datasets, our approach achieved state-of-the-art results.
Additionally, we observed that highlighting input tables significantly enhances
the model's performance and provides valuable interpretability. | [
0.0278699454,
0.0594799034,
0.0260190815,
-0.0069116387,
-0.0384511128,
0.0303825233,
0.0025362158,
0.0056082588,
-0.0219538063,
-0.0331980474,
-0.0157185253,
0.008794535,
0.0224321987,
0.0291185323,
0.0564930923,
-0.0068843397,
0.0271093659,
-0.0137005998,
-0.0152133051,
0.0462751202,
0.0183776878,
0.0209174249,
-0.0077926493,
0.0405605584,
-0.00261214,
-0.00913129,
-0.0235394742,
-0.0056086564,
0.0166011285,
-0.0026969477,
-0.0043957038,
0.0612177663,
0.0309645049,
0.0211416855,
0.0000021011,
-0.0112466831,
-0.0627486408,
-0.0031158337,
-0.00055084,
-0.0075713461,
0.0245527346,
-0.0205220152,
0.0054776436,
0.0260731541,
-0.0088471044,
0.0173080228,
0.0261827689,
0.0954304338,
0.0803459212,
0.0620462596,
0.0149750998,
-0.0205255263,
-0.0070071178,
-0.0247014128,
0.0469046496,
0.0153040057,
-0.0091196205,
0.0357781127,
0.0256387759,
-0.0120891193,
0.0341213457,
0.0472627096,
0.0322524719,
-0.0429455377,
0.0146241747,
0.0493995883,
-0.0188579541,
0.0088237803,
0.0248181485,
0.0853253454,
0.0045615858,
-0.0413069911,
0.030973779,
0.0041990015,
0.0189297944,
-0.017509399,
-0.0525128134,
0.0611820407,
-0.0193757508,
0.0024663399,
0.0700933039,
-0.004618519,
0.0074593378,
0.0111626908,
-0.02298305,
0.0614772178,
-0.0203646719,
-0.0098388335,
-0.011585243,
-0.0059300652,
-0.0150914481,
-0.0696689263,
0.0367702283,
0.0652908981,
-0.0530478917,
-0.0086745666,
-0.0273157004,
-0.0273093376,
0.0239484329,
-0.0406793728,
0.0480349511,
0.0441645384,
0.0001374012,
0.0039998661,
-0.0542493276,
-0.0155159626,
-0.0065002851,
0.029247703,
-0.0481482558,
-0.0083059445,
-0.0177490022,
0.0083000138,
-0.0290472526,
-0.0031418828,
-0.077011846,
-0.0235460475,
0.0075593055,
-0.0033293336,
-0.003928748,
0.0499613322,
0.0129492041,
0.0086028818,
-0.0424406789,
0.0117103634,
-0.0048646219,
-0.004053073,
-0.0221954286,
-0.0008791694,
0.0535749123,
-0.0451135784,
-0.0185864083,
0.0061360402,
0.014586132,
-0.0058144201,
0.0261292513,
0.0710679218,
-0.0747758076,
-0.0025862486,
-0.0559268333,
-0.058904741,
-0.0376767255,
-0.0615793318,
-0.0078174686,
-0.0579859689,
0.0046175914,
-0.0018674915,
0.0006023557,
-0.0504255705,
0.0215488058,
0.0493890941,
-0.0144828828,
0.0301776528,
-0.0232595261,
0.0026912501,
0.0336401984,
-0.0155105395,
-0.020082904,
0.0667983294,
0.0526426136,
0.0568454154,
-0.0292016063,
-0.0114133321,
-0.0267863795,
0.0066664363,
0.0291890241,
-0.0167803317,
-0.023666501,
0.0204893239,
-0.0008709169,
0.0441313274,
0.0080619073,
0.0147902817,
-0.0167156011,
0.0944742039,
0.0602622479,
0.0016059177,
0.0274348333,
0.0587347448,
0.0299964789,
-0.0149668297,
0.0168863274,
0.0189668778,
-0.0303025246,
0.0509871095,
0.0152144004,
0.0434563197,
0.0717293769,
0.036886923,
-0.0099252807,
-0.0706647635,
0.0123010073,
0.0204934627,
-0.0323611312,
0.0075265607,
0.0213538688,
0.0285981055,
-0.0720074028,
-0.0154881077,
-0.0038122688,
-0.0725218132,
0.0148567446,
-0.0286171697,
0.0649059787,
0.0628000125,
0.0505588055,
-0.0333830975,
-0.010722897,
-0.02661811,
0.030962212,
0.0366337709,
-0.0014631905,
-0.0250801984,
-0.0203651432,
-0.0310137123,
-0.0314374343,
-0.0061892937,
0.0359647647,
-0.0241243262,
0.0036036544,
-0.0225488208,
0.0491886064,
-0.041977413,
-0.0818778202,
0.0476973653,
0.0394153297,
0.003715398,
0.0077904738,
-0.0095775761,
0.0021063124,
0.0233873054,
-0.0150101837,
0.0471399091,
0.0133058336,
-0.0406459756,
0.0184617471,
-0.0062996447,
-0.0133731198,
-0.0109399175,
0.0092987185,
-0.017068347,
-0.0165568013,
-0.0336454995,
-0.0397905186,
-0.0702603608,
-0.0251151137,
-0.0477005765,
-0.0302365907,
-0.0233012196,
0.0110074291,
0.0406286456,
0.015063541,
-0.0068411008,
0.0852337182,
-0.0074135526,
-0.0253227521,
0.0046396027,
-0.0532688387,
0.0038533937,
-0.0397141911,
0.0527808592,
-0.0129800336,
-0.0089749116,
0.0162665062,
0.035249494,
0.0369450748,
-0.0532127805,
-0.0284042563,
-0.0652818233,
0.0502705984,
-0.0250647403,
0.0164014902,
0.0367746353,
-0.0072955526,
-0.008861972,
0.007002776,
-0.0731447414,
-0.0183365829,
0.0257260073,
-0.0068705836,
0.0769301727,
-0.0028692333,
-0.0143344505,
-0.0536298752,
-0.0302775297,
-0.0049851551,
0.0227728449,
0.0279530827,
-0.0291719157,
-0.0181771368,
0.0110617671,
-0.0099061653,
-0.0260456856,
0.027509639,
-0.0134994891,
0.010855807,
-0.0276501291,
0.044755131,
0.06096844,
0.005670418,
0.0271986295,
0.0306722149,
-0.015905533,
-0.0269444846,
0.0062362421,
-0.0224276353,
0.0320337266,
0.051282268,
-0.0950295851,
0.0496380068,
0.0437188409,
-0.0239522085,
0.0006925525,
-0.0499595553,
0.0095883096,
0.02514055,
-0.0057775504,
-0.0594747737,
0.0347607732,
0.040724732,
0.0167360604,
-0.0304826424,
-0.021353595,
0.0344129018,
-0.0644966513,
0.0439265519,
-0.015265258,
-0.0135342609,
-0.0664949119,
0.0218851101,
0.0048282589,
0.0207691882,
-0.0041855974,
0.0135538867,
-0.036085736,
-0.0125380643,
0.025335256,
-0.0203744676,
0.1065628678,
-0.0742760673,
0.0031693657,
-0.0281359721,
-0.0071723145,
-0.0015414939,
-0.0272196345,
-0.0294446256,
0.0163640492,
0.0278702285,
-0.0162570663,
-0.0369861424,
-0.0146433087,
0.0447790883,
0.0545734391,
-0.0304300878,
-0.0322562903,
-0.0527174324,
0.011882714,
0.0350954346,
-0.0028846171,
-0.0024899724,
-0.0317078754,
0.0344603285,
0.0487756729,
-0.0158258416,
-0.0380349942,
-0.0142456489,
0.0197655652,
-0.0123293484,
-0.0234159417,
-0.0054885689,
0.04204005,
0.013380005,
-0.0772140101,
-0.0133221345,
0.0726824999,
0.0190840065,
0.0160630662,
-0.0217279103,
0.0115637574,
0.0748597607,
-0.0135158878,
0.0415544622,
-0.0580320917,
-0.0387238786,
0.0243065394,
0.034474723,
-0.0100767016,
-0.0328114517,
-0.0388962589,
-0.0988668203,
0.0473684669,
-0.0049576811,
-0.0470725037,
-0.0758902133,
-0.0300931558,
0.0002214726,
-0.015035904,
0.012785119,
0.0522580557,
-0.0148738027,
0.0505513363,
0.0305406395,
-0.0276922826,
-0.0377003178,
-0.0462152697,
-0.040668752,
0.0344681889,
0.0521346591,
0.037762545,
-0.005951202,
0.0020416938,
0.0119558787,
-0.0047018942,
0.0289703216,
-0.0106793307,
0.0531392023,
0.0075879898,
0.0140420021,
-0.0183832813,
0.0476765335,
-0.01351682,
-0.0087476736,
0.0377502292,
0.0277353823,
-0.0340896174,
-0.0021358554,
0.0047005662,
0.0110611962,
-0.0055898977,
0.0673446059,
0.0533043295,
0.00682972,
-0.0396263935,
-0.0376418233,
-0.0471896641,
-0.0766526833,
0.0426901616,
0.0190511961,
-0.0396793559,
-0.045024991,
-0.0824782327,
0.0086338269,
0.0622956418,
0.0526498333,
0.0072274525,
0.0437782332,
-0.0673657805,
-0.020901328,
-0.0316933952,
0.0285528284,
-0.0410826951,
0.0258753449,
-0.0447712243,
-0.0252336822,
-0.0131644728,
-0.0641864687,
0.0030397014,
0.0462683178,
-0.0473074168,
-0.0317672156,
-0.0215715189,
0.023918746,
0.0254455358,
0.029157998,
0.0201326367,
-0.0184193812,
-0.006134816,
0.0194460507,
-0.0129579622,
-0.0305137672,
0.0152435526,
-0.0256896652,
0.0096337274,
0.0234996956,
-0.0257856399,
0.0045765038,
-0.0153984353,
0.0356871076,
0.014852941,
0.004032372,
0.048352547,
0.0169204045,
0.0019849383,
-0.0246381722,
-0.0747808069,
-0.0362228528,
-0.0016496461,
-0.0730479211,
-0.0453421362,
-0.0456917956,
0.0376424678,
-0.0075930967,
0.0033195612,
0.0108921556,
0.0024518438,
0.0202696044,
0.0479750708,
-0.024083538,
0.0096228532,
-0.0047205347,
-0.0037182986,
0.0068591405,
-0.041870635,
-0.0479003936,
-0.0108887395,
-0.0057885568,
0.0305318665,
-0.0093598245,
0.0521178395,
0.0347153991,
-0.0275249016,
-0.016823126,
0.0639193952,
-0.0607563183,
-0.0234801695,
-0.038337335,
0.0011698222,
0.0231791437,
0.0093923248,
0.0439092964,
-0.044583451,
-0.0105668651,
0.0210623071,
0.0903557166,
0.0500023812,
0.003278513,
0.0009300554,
-0.0205274355,
-0.0033997803,
-0.0573861897,
0.0881862715,
0.0214536525,
0.0007017519,
-0.0144110667,
-0.0322314948,
-0.0480357818,
-0.0152537366,
-0.0129506132,
-0.0118035302,
-0.0001461849,
-0.0482786708,
-0.0152753117,
-0.0403447673,
0.0117137907,
0.0580754727,
-0.0352120288,
-0.0051333997,
0.0102151353,
0.0359322876,
0.0308766663,
-0.0118552679,
-0.0495351031,
0.0252974946,
-0.0059534092,
-0.0220975988,
-0.008635656,
-6.735847116e-33,
-0.0514920391,
-0.0387433171,
-0.0027322017,
-0.0451126248,
0.0045234342,
0.002345701,
-0.0785785019,
-0.0352969319,
0.0261753798,
0.0243697297,
-0.0273401625,
0.0201970823,
0.0237341914,
0.0078963041,
-0.0013423085,
-0.0302300453,
0.0441961102,
0.0139016788,
-0.0366927385,
0.0512761809,
0.041642867,
0.0012576767,
-0.0115515217,
-0.0152912056,
0.0593734086,
0.0001214799,
-0.0435584523,
-0.0090750447,
-0.0282845385,
0.0108077759,
-0.0240212269,
0.0204822496,
0.0173690412,
-0.049538631,
-0.052227322,
0.0338268094,
-0.1298868805,
-0.0161929708,
0.0131442184,
-0.0331879742,
-0.0265427176,
-0.0756792948,
-0.0027122004,
-0.0088299913,
0.0020966227,
-0.0201546699,
0.0277955886,
-0.0505392179,
-0.0053808908,
-0.0261114761,
-0.009320979,
0.0299903601,
-0.0340844914,
-0.0115711922,
0.033080902,
0.0595419072,
0.0145117557,
-0.0304650888,
-0.0127657149,
0.0286219083,
0.0581869595,
0.0342458785,
0.0800948367,
0.0265247095,
-0.0222211145,
0.0296970047,
0.0058089201,
0.0020046546,
-0.0432766192,
0.0342345722,
-0.0745461732,
0.0739157274,
0.082548216,
0.0208104253,
0.0015567909,
0.0163896568,
-0.0714318603,
0.0817510262,
-0.029202288,
-0.0062421747,
0.0211299043,
-0.0370173343,
-0.0221677013,
-0.0276642237,
-0.0227398276,
-0.0195917711,
-0.0155954491,
0.0074390252,
0.0189780146,
0.0100342492,
-0.0065717231,
-0.0172721911,
-0.0025169326,
0.027527649,
0.0045033302,
0.0387803875,
-0.0286732763,
0.0162668116,
-0.0079789329,
-0.0138536701,
-0.0481475666,
-0.0273779649,
0.0467178598,
-0.0054590181,
0.0351537429,
0.0488151275,
0.0590603314,
0.0290382057,
-0.0442993902,
0.0135315638,
-0.0446697772,
0.0601229034,
0.0083259577,
0.0018600479,
-0.0051822774,
-0.0199747793,
-0.0150193749,
0.0485685766,
0.0140541634,
0.0219305698,
0.011584729,
0.0056761811,
-0.0032945776,
0.0064370893,
0.0159854479,
0.0420859605,
-0.0278312024,
-0.0008822129,
0.0371947177,
-0.0289081447,
0.0057653836,
0.0136385271,
2.676e-7,
0.0590345971,
0.0070712478,
0.052646216,
0.0161495004,
-0.0193965212,
0.0352907851,
0.0067517147,
-0.0018281114,
0.0062301434,
-0.0081700776,
0.0233829524,
0.0093544377,
0.0929167122,
0.0173042957,
0.0057245935,
-0.0729255825,
-0.0594281144,
-0.0050069299,
-0.0713646933,
-0.0225620754,
0.0624884665,
0.0790552422,
-0.0647913218,
-0.0233341772,
-0.0013471302,
-0.0235208832,
0.0143061252,
-0.0769213662,
0.0146092027,
0.0329976641,
0.0877996609,
-0.0490458384,
-0.0317995138,
0.0432290025,
-0.0428611338,
-0.0177738164,
-0.0191661902,
0.0518658683,
0.036856059,
0.0415080525,
0.0048742588,
-0.0462892763,
0.0424527451,
-0.0743920878,
0.1043750346,
-0.0487228483,
-0.0213376451,
0.0494578928,
-0.0084290784,
0.0008387915,
-0.0217806511,
-0.0100892028,
-0.0174023099,
0.0063292393,
0.0053200535,
-0.0117055569,
0.0060284175,
-0.0462898426,
-0.064271152,
0.0156457331,
-0.0202634856,
-0.0294268988,
-0.0308376178,
-0.0254898071,
-0.0283133835,
-0.0707086027,
-0.0482410751,
2.801032913e-34,
0.039063815,
-0.0212814752,
0.0033210402,
0.0061119776,
0.0931287259,
-0.0211124048,
-0.0060974415,
-0.0042341682,
0.0235963631,
-0.1045893505,
-0.0310111828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08894v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08894v3 | Few-shot Transfer Learning for Knowledge Base Question Answering: Fusing Supervised Models with In-Context Learning | 2023-11-15T11:56:56 | 2024-06-13T12:06:27 | Mayur Patidar, Riya Sawhney, Avinash Singh, Biswajit Chatterjee, Mausam, Indrajit Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) architectures are hungry
for annotated data, which make them costly and time-consuming to deploy. We
introduce the problem of few-shot transfer learning for KBQA, where the target
domain offers only a few labeled examples, but a large labeled training dataset
is available in a source domain. We propose a novel KBQA architecture called
FuSIC-KBQA that performs KB-retrieval using multiple source-trained retrievers,
re-ranks using an LLM and uses this as input for LLM few-shot in-context
learning to generate logical forms. These are further refined using
execution-guided feedback. Experiments over multiple source-target KBQA pairs
of varying complexity show that FuSIC-KBQA significantly outperforms
adaptations of SoTA KBQA models for this setting. Additional experiments show
that FuSIC-KBQA also outperforms SoTA KBQA models in the in-domain setting when
training data is limited. | [
0.0228672922,
-0.0107139237,
0.007742452,
0.0242703408,
-0.0136084277,
0.0084654801,
0.0217761192,
-0.0121213775,
0.0138923116,
-0.0739294291,
-0.0463038124,
0.0013128365,
-0.0698228851,
0.0101725105,
0.002654471,
0.0085293967,
0.0607432909,
-0.0100098429,
-0.018533295,
0.0118986275,
-0.0230522845,
0.0181541424,
-0.0225906745,
-0.0186640993,
0.0159236826,
-0.0172531139,
-0.0049932394,
0.0203429237,
0.0159834288,
-0.0140239308,
0.0414130948,
0.0212248825,
0.0411602147,
-0.0308962427,
0.0000019231,
-0.0298604853,
-0.0362137333,
0.0171760283,
-0.071781978,
-0.0070405821,
-0.0125153726,
-0.0145800253,
0.0185494907,
0.0193257369,
-0.0437837392,
-0.0079110647,
0.0237564612,
0.0247189738,
0.0935495421,
0.0691123903,
0.0014324983,
-0.0260184407,
0.0062497263,
-0.0181878954,
0.0264411345,
-0.0666939169,
0.0293514431,
0.0129083451,
0.0321725309,
0.0147354342,
0.0145748314,
0.0229288954,
0.0106417118,
0.0161019359,
0.0269318093,
0.0103845727,
-0.0599224865,
0.0397093818,
0.001329525,
0.1017486826,
0.0125420615,
0.0236540157,
-0.0006200926,
0.0070516504,
0.0309040602,
-0.0133898463,
-0.0455452278,
-0.0158290155,
-0.0141689861,
-0.0205133427,
-0.0133069865,
0.0107240751,
0.0019166573,
-0.0058041676,
-0.0299951248,
0.0709139779,
0.0307517927,
-0.0366764218,
0.022672154,
0.018104054,
-0.0444466732,
-0.0460756868,
-0.0348870717,
0.0820501223,
-0.0339520276,
0.0441431701,
-0.0497797802,
0.0141277527,
0.0088285413,
-0.0218858439,
0.0395900011,
0.0376071334,
-0.0119467545,
0.0717988983,
-0.0600944199,
0.0408098698,
-0.0043445928,
0.0391972065,
-0.0586361326,
-0.0293945614,
-0.0941811949,
-0.0358025059,
-0.052678816,
0.079740271,
-0.0381487384,
-0.0179800745,
-0.0266479272,
0.0329703949,
0.0005797377,
-0.0158816241,
0.0099831689,
0.0272047576,
-0.0107718473,
-0.0061133779,
-0.0530243181,
0.0749600232,
-0.0428160392,
0.022715576,
0.0269517247,
-0.0334610082,
-0.0333528295,
-0.002736056,
0.0308120139,
-0.0487487316,
0.0085894074,
0.0589380972,
-0.0254601091,
-0.0217504594,
-0.0533092432,
-0.0384274088,
-0.003316886,
-0.0295666009,
0.0170522388,
-0.0401936956,
0.0376793221,
-0.0098311771,
-0.02731351,
-0.0220534597,
0.0000961246,
0.0540964305,
-0.0028054526,
0.0711429492,
-0.0117715783,
-0.0137621779,
0.0295832232,
0.0045164367,
-0.0408279747,
0.0721912682,
-0.0154360831,
0.0036033569,
0.0116634155,
0.0020339217,
-0.0024799721,
-0.0111817233,
0.0646929517,
0.0298524536,
-0.0009762715,
0.0484633408,
-0.0200343896,
0.0201950595,
0.0392631441,
-0.0159507394,
-0.0337227173,
-0.0041536721,
-0.0051040957,
0.0240217466,
0.04219741,
-0.0108032925,
0.0199491307,
0.0102238283,
-0.0004627038,
-0.0036801868,
-0.044570215,
0.0824959204,
-0.0494772866,
-0.0143795861,
-0.0054088351,
0.0016507618,
-0.0449381433,
0.0117946677,
0.039009504,
0.0210041292,
-0.0705674142,
0.0347765237,
0.0553319193,
0.0655797496,
-0.0331053846,
0.0973658115,
0.0171080232,
0.0055675716,
-0.0235135574,
-0.03200607,
0.0393271558,
0.0476771221,
0.0085461447,
-0.0341855139,
-0.0655030534,
0.003121092,
0.0352191478,
0.0011940836,
-0.0105516212,
-0.0253372919,
0.0271315183,
-0.0088358577,
-0.0022595946,
-0.0566509254,
0.0140047921,
0.0118498225,
-0.0082471985,
0.0260630939,
0.0207522102,
-0.0383657068,
0.0771038234,
0.0350741223,
-0.0308413915,
-0.0214700159,
0.0248383023,
0.0018701138,
0.0282707307,
-0.0042984807,
-0.0112289386,
0.0256042592,
0.0242622998,
-0.0385714248,
-0.0327642336,
-0.0269328747,
-0.0077479733,
-0.1138641238,
0.0264047869,
0.0335160494,
0.006224588,
-0.0242613461,
-0.0853302553,
-0.0307622645,
0.0046633319,
-0.0169558898,
-0.001036227,
-0.0311401896,
-0.0554354601,
0.0603137203,
-0.0079212626,
-0.0719819441,
0.0674435496,
0.0274594631,
0.0097323461,
0.0141656762,
0.0092154061,
0.0277820956,
-0.0294389948,
0.0320071951,
-0.0239452161,
-0.0331324823,
-0.0052377963,
-0.0382222421,
0.0095493328,
-0.0511232018,
-0.0171763524,
-0.0533350669,
0.0382317342,
0.0107645756,
0.035501793,
0.0380306281,
0.0094522899,
0.0164154582,
-0.0241788514,
-0.0591566861,
0.005214599,
0.0194436088,
0.0330654904,
0.0372938477,
0.0279009156,
0.0033359658,
-0.008685221,
-0.0130951582,
-0.0005736926,
0.0353449583,
-0.0378981344,
0.0078188395,
-0.052418787,
-0.0035516031,
-0.0432308577,
0.0126803452,
0.0131603759,
0.0024794487,
-0.0013256957,
-0.0340654328,
-0.0282548573,
0.0703103021,
-0.0237349942,
-0.0296409894,
0.0017882066,
-0.0286051258,
-0.0459751971,
0.048032254,
0.0235087108,
-0.0148719577,
-0.0049747704,
0.0191150811,
0.0087652365,
0.0055163349,
-0.0090459455,
-0.0121296514,
-0.0455753878,
0.0683438927,
0.033124622,
-0.0019163656,
-0.0890523195,
0.0458433367,
0.02027319,
0.0319262855,
-0.0232045744,
0.0373296142,
0.0560940616,
0.0324506871,
-0.0261364561,
-0.0253540464,
0.0224803071,
-0.0596288331,
0.0290564243,
-0.0265145805,
-0.0059184697,
0.0026305532,
-0.0044085528,
-0.0637620986,
-0.0173610821,
0.0101791285,
-0.0245831497,
0.0265374538,
-0.0231359061,
0.0555021279,
-0.0382021703,
-0.0418066792,
-0.0281241294,
-0.0263363756,
-0.0257188492,
0.0376048423,
-0.0770597979,
0.0396655425,
-0.0089637591,
-0.0078103538,
0.0243898798,
0.023695156,
0.0138528664,
-0.0124510331,
-0.018076757,
0.0704403371,
0.0754615292,
0.0463389121,
-0.0134874508,
0.0059686173,
0.0282629803,
0.0453938991,
0.0061122598,
0.0032097986,
0.0012207554,
0.009408162,
0.0198641382,
-0.0264870394,
-0.0140500097,
0.02689109,
0.0544874556,
-0.0598605312,
-0.0257705469,
0.0896971002,
0.0107892742,
0.0436911508,
-0.0060291742,
-0.0108614434,
-0.0102565819,
0.0279885307,
0.068873249,
-0.104999423,
-0.0801012516,
-0.0267547593,
0.0207184814,
0.022977652,
-0.0270716604,
-0.011225475,
-0.1404681802,
0.0323567167,
-0.0255753007,
-0.0775677636,
-0.0247378014,
-0.0186890624,
0.0062515051,
-0.0058807409,
-0.019023627,
0.015232645,
-0.013522068,
0.0083451252,
0.0068012318,
0.0231806505,
-0.0292208511,
0.0636230931,
-0.0257871207,
0.0363934748,
0.0712280944,
0.0003282377,
0.0005443569,
-0.0227615926,
-0.005205146,
-0.0535519049,
0.0170865003,
0.0068601463,
0.0719190314,
-0.0101707308,
-0.0324967429,
-0.0078534558,
0.0003600409,
-0.0576296672,
-0.0177629571,
0.0424643345,
0.0684803724,
-0.0083947824,
-0.0042362018,
-0.0235334057,
-0.0183408335,
-0.0013661125,
0.0606809035,
0.0064613419,
-0.0210600328,
-0.0440748297,
-0.0108574778,
-0.038920559,
-0.0601881221,
-0.0189126469,
0.0418341123,
-0.0204291027,
0.0277671162,
-0.0873581693,
-0.0281873196,
0.03680465,
0.0562238209,
-0.0404362977,
-0.0014089885,
0.0001397306,
0.0314899869,
-0.0041903225,
-0.0154766124,
-0.0461435467,
0.0143989818,
-0.0236254688,
0.0281455889,
0.0580826029,
-0.01548554,
-0.0339034647,
-0.0425511524,
-0.0265987702,
-0.0104851583,
-0.0264431704,
0.0739053041,
0.0091842357,
0.0088884998,
-0.0431680419,
-0.0133544728,
0.0729918331,
0.0375079252,
-0.0206064451,
0.0128992852,
0.0316351093,
-0.0183044486,
-0.0155475447,
0.0461265668,
-0.0757806003,
0.0231976025,
0.0284490492,
0.0421102643,
-0.0489316061,
0.0045852582,
0.0233308412,
0.0059282384,
-0.0061537912,
0.0509862714,
-0.0173014607,
0.0044984152,
0.0494096726,
-0.0245333146,
-0.0383368246,
-0.0760750249,
-0.0118668107,
0.0119302515,
-0.0611746386,
0.0130897425,
-0.0292085055,
0.000614109,
0.0683213249,
-0.0000333665,
-0.0325191803,
0.0644979924,
0.021480754,
0.0080647236,
-0.0137954103,
-0.0410779789,
-0.0113442531,
0.0308919922,
0.0518376268,
-0.0341697298,
0.0241329577,
0.0405096859,
0.0100116637,
-0.0377479866,
0.0029580563,
-0.0605004877,
-0.0269034859,
-0.0341506377,
-0.0070158783,
0.0394961238,
0.0289012529,
0.0274284929,
0.0388107933,
-0.0446819514,
-0.0167834684,
0.0092412513,
0.0026794735,
0.004986959,
0.0589987487,
0.0381919853,
0.0127313454,
-0.0184798893,
0.0701955855,
0.0030509883,
0.072675474,
0.0020912709,
0.0075603691,
-0.0438567251,
-0.0158969201,
-0.0119936839,
0.0016801057,
0.0256863385,
0.0370819829,
-0.0371148549,
-0.0364602134,
0.0279672369,
-0.056496501,
-0.042137526,
-0.0049735215,
0.0359888934,
0.0283685327,
0.0470937975,
-0.0719823465,
-0.013213113,
-0.0074304566,
-0.0229407493,
-0.0192680769,
0.0006361245,
-6.349409226e-33,
-0.0602286533,
-0.0042914092,
0.0645797923,
-0.043500185,
-0.0169959869,
-0.0289445259,
-0.0344257243,
-0.0346925035,
-0.0655787662,
0.0004764659,
-0.0155893993,
-0.0055748406,
0.0035052588,
0.0448819809,
0.0104300529,
-0.0475715362,
-0.0050015994,
0.016326787,
-0.0126845492,
0.0205309652,
0.0331767648,
0.0504276268,
0.0294774678,
-0.0125719309,
-0.0473835841,
0.0335663259,
-0.018389415,
0.0366443917,
-0.0429827906,
0.0438356847,
0.012553514,
0.0117949927,
0.0430418178,
-0.0504075103,
0.0113556953,
0.0314068981,
-0.0783894882,
-0.0480342396,
-0.006430388,
-0.0257585086,
-0.0073233172,
-0.0254693646,
0.0046930495,
-0.0225044396,
0.0871288404,
-0.0473758355,
-0.0005717883,
-0.0598037913,
-0.0361674912,
-0.0461999923,
-0.0446595065,
0.0094191637,
0.0256208908,
-0.0036581282,
-0.0400951728,
0.0642839745,
-0.0092278542,
0.0071229702,
-0.0434041619,
-0.0269432347,
-0.0121290646,
0.0496141873,
0.0140172672,
0.0355249122,
-0.0194361974,
0.0052513285,
0.0081257494,
-0.0373964421,
-0.0158764403,
-0.0134479525,
-0.0129829627,
0.0748057663,
0.0399909019,
0.0907582119,
0.0623045526,
0.0140847741,
-0.1024652943,
0.0029811773,
-0.0204070155,
0.0383688882,
-0.0045333765,
0.0031091324,
0.0066452497,
-0.033568956,
-0.0220051687,
0.045031704,
-0.0433074348,
-0.0302566066,
0.0453220494,
0.0047749579,
-0.003386152,
0.0122901406,
0.0438430049,
-0.0394297801,
0.0115192635,
0.0230333284,
-0.012849695,
0.0044461261,
0.0124796322,
0.0148407631,
-0.0604520403,
-0.0269717202,
0.0331106856,
0.0008295231,
-0.000099328,
0.0158829745,
0.0416248366,
0.0062581222,
-0.0611825138,
-0.0130621735,
-0.0394009948,
0.0209586639,
-0.0229369458,
0.0287367348,
-0.0154951857,
0.0283148885,
-0.0189436097,
0.0253962912,
-0.0192344524,
-0.0243060868,
0.0114979371,
-0.0158390068,
0.0181961153,
-0.0054038777,
-0.01594132,
0.0224019084,
-0.0145078553,
0.0224684719,
-0.0295451246,
-0.0301598869,
-0.0138764791,
0.0271859374,
2.732e-7,
0.0599367432,
-0.0060621491,
-0.0084446594,
0.0379411802,
0.0193281565,
0.0339400023,
-0.0058311438,
0.0510012545,
0.042612642,
-0.0416371375,
0.0179941356,
0.0231732838,
0.0274527129,
0.0479791239,
-0.0717156604,
-0.0104860868,
-0.0134299155,
-0.0275951996,
-0.0139179155,
-0.0476871841,
0.0536439903,
0.0702433586,
0.014410235,
-0.0226015877,
0.0086694434,
-0.0559585504,
0.0568489544,
0.0382002145,
0.023833653,
0.0007657665,
-0.0165162813,
0.0125868749,
-0.0060907211,
0.0573525131,
-0.0131199332,
0.0211068634,
0.0071037482,
0.0632461831,
-0.0118075879,
-0.0608437918,
-0.0238248333,
-0.0085893134,
0.041045785,
0.0046621771,
0.1061994731,
-0.1090619862,
0.0041802013,
-0.0006339587,
-0.0669624507,
-0.0171867348,
-0.0133741498,
0.0068403152,
-0.0035390409,
-0.0009730905,
0.0362398997,
0.0132687837,
-0.012512112,
-0.0681369901,
0.0190401878,
0.0502794348,
-0.0220279749,
-0.0213814322,
-0.0209189616,
0.0102724358,
0.0209148731,
-0.0593975,
0.009620294,
2.402559384e-34,
-0.0044354075,
-0.0128573989,
0.0282805022,
0.0607712045,
0.0074310889,
0.0041570151,
-0.0621752255,
-0.0293797608,
0.0567246452,
-0.0607865863,
0.0161569901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08890v1 | Large Language Models are legal but they are not: Making the case for a powerful LegalLLM | 2023-11-15T11:50:10 | 2023-11-15T11:50:10 | Thanmay Jayakumar, Fauzan Farooqui, Luqman Farooqui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Realizing the recent advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP) to the
legal sector poses challenging problems such as extremely long sequence
lengths, specialized vocabulary that is usually only understood by legal
professionals, and high amounts of data imbalance. The recent surge of Large
Language Models (LLMs) has begun to provide new opportunities to apply NLP in
the legal domain due to their ability to handle lengthy, complex sequences.
Moreover, the emergence of domain-specific LLMs has displayed extremely
promising results on various tasks. In this study, we aim to quantify how
general LLMs perform in comparison to legal-domain models (be it an LLM or
otherwise). Specifically, we compare the zero-shot performance of three
general-purpose LLMs (ChatGPT-20b, LLaMA-2-70b, and Falcon-180b) on the LEDGAR
subset of the LexGLUE benchmark for contract provision classification. Although
the LLMs were not explicitly trained on legal data, we observe that they are
still able to classify the theme correctly in most cases. However, we find that
their mic-F1/mac-F1 performance is up to 19.2/26.8\% lesser than smaller models
fine-tuned on the legal domain, thus underscoring the need for more powerful
legal-domain LLMs. | [
0.0478433482,
0.0667781383,
-0.0069545209,
0.0117728738,
-0.0695477724,
0.0097940369,
0.0461422987,
0.0465310104,
0.0037866335,
-0.10340482,
-0.0164691601,
-0.0616183393,
-0.0124940714,
0.0162397195,
0.0089324908,
-0.0069283601,
0.0320325196,
0.0043500438,
0.0348866619,
-0.0059033763,
-0.0117024649,
0.0109668747,
0.0180612616,
0.0511831008,
-0.0291787721,
0.0129278442,
0.0081732459,
-0.0237431135,
-0.0100215934,
-0.0178300291,
-0.0028692181,
0.0704964548,
0.0186862256,
0.0401333012,
0.0000019161,
-0.0873418525,
-0.0009383974,
-0.0018904918,
-0.0159875453,
0.0821052864,
0.0420220234,
-0.047614105,
-0.0194202606,
0.0178793687,
-0.0354997441,
0.0273390356,
-0.0069482895,
0.0368310027,
0.0194929689,
0.112090826,
0.000323599,
-0.0856030434,
0.0497194827,
-0.0774063095,
-0.0124312071,
-0.0521300808,
0.0380649492,
-0.0272229034,
0.0388634093,
-0.0281899199,
-0.0079960171,
0.0156486537,
0.0309360325,
-0.0204676744,
-0.0048762485,
0.0276711434,
-0.0568035878,
0.0123678083,
0.001931457,
0.0280837081,
0.0050187977,
0.008887006,
0.0134148793,
-0.0214466024,
0.0392422751,
-0.0133501394,
-0.0070462762,
0.0863436908,
0.0046710507,
0.0175245162,
0.0179702993,
0.0073532243,
0.0352259353,
0.0183507446,
-0.0516795665,
0.037069764,
0.0011040301,
-0.0275996383,
0.0153452139,
-0.0045475271,
-0.015408949,
-0.0825449228,
0.0276165083,
0.0276058316,
-0.014968954,
0.0263011698,
-0.0511194877,
0.0008045944,
0.070001021,
-0.0555716492,
0.020895889,
-0.0112154158,
-0.0241130646,
0.0511811301,
-0.0498589799,
0.0260911118,
-0.0035974821,
0.0142122339,
0.0054290798,
0.0023018126,
-0.0414967835,
-0.00974569,
-0.0441156216,
0.0520809926,
-0.0831572041,
-0.0253820941,
-0.058015842,
-0.000842036,
0.0033175196,
0.0342476442,
0.010773709,
-0.0096657975,
0.0238414295,
-0.0206339527,
-0.0758970752,
-0.0631600097,
-0.0075764465,
0.0271305218,
0.0008450575,
-0.0169466101,
0.0301198661,
0.0026765415,
-0.0094678523,
-0.0167187918,
0.024443673,
0.1144700199,
0.0144449249,
-0.0612416938,
-0.0491962321,
-0.0408256389,
-0.0115293423,
-0.0631610081,
-0.0444362983,
-0.0538693853,
-0.0245600939,
-0.0258781184,
-0.0133453822,
-0.0350810923,
0.0236970857,
0.0315589085,
-0.0215622336,
0.0591458492,
0.0019967877,
-0.0148303229,
-0.0417475216,
0.0056775971,
0.0339817144,
0.031427335,
0.0169428326,
0.0262777507,
0.0432882495,
-0.008508794,
0.0255945101,
0.0547398217,
-0.0006182482,
0.0101243211,
-0.0154372947,
-0.0013605927,
0.0090424269,
0.0218279734,
0.0155029455,
0.0180448201,
0.0062624337,
-0.0312032588,
0.0335164331,
0.0744842961,
0.0321336649,
0.0144393565,
0.0115907863,
0.0184071641,
0.0072907852,
-0.0272499993,
-0.0551728904,
-0.0174863022,
-0.0091320761,
0.0023588592,
-0.0224803817,
0.0169123486,
-0.0176879596,
-0.0433644205,
-0.026966691,
-0.0263595302,
0.0120056923,
-0.0091133369,
0.0333753116,
-0.0049678287,
-0.0489912555,
0.0614267588,
0.0230574682,
0.0046381922,
-0.0509236567,
-0.0370123833,
-0.0004669338,
0.0300277285,
0.025463175,
-0.0363329574,
-0.0205125455,
-0.0384764746,
-0.0184640698,
0.0945614576,
0.0273019262,
0.0081801182,
-0.0052639958,
-0.0150528392,
-0.0208482221,
0.0036812215,
0.0383660309,
0.030195564,
0.0024430563,
0.0187765937,
0.0377471149,
-0.0437312312,
-0.0126177538,
0.0277408548,
-0.0073170653,
-0.0620414354,
0.0412640236,
-0.0141089726,
0.0434935316,
0.0174092464,
-0.0193938185,
-0.0095590716,
0.0249486025,
-0.0307978038,
-0.032917276,
-0.0199450757,
-0.024190234,
-0.0025099644,
0.0557650328,
0.0105723757,
-0.0052631511,
-0.0032299017,
-0.0468920358,
-0.0122224726,
-0.0286865626,
-0.0081772413,
0.0257221013,
-0.0399320051,
0.0238039214,
0.0022660531,
0.0127561977,
-0.0341408998,
0.0405486263,
-0.0056509017,
-0.0052882624,
-0.0168288704,
0.0064301663,
0.047737889,
-0.0271970611,
-0.0106006367,
0.0241293479,
-0.0391249023,
0.0039031066,
0.0020090151,
0.0267647281,
-0.0181331877,
-0.0335722491,
-0.0726644397,
0.0142829968,
-0.0384611636,
0.0190893225,
-0.033052329,
-0.0521616712,
-0.0207441375,
-0.0108779836,
-0.0524969846,
-0.0222345013,
0.0120048923,
-0.0101471487,
0.0252371151,
-0.0205951706,
-0.0819993839,
-0.0210312158,
-0.0047830516,
0.0066018067,
0.0295761209,
0.0149578704,
-0.0265722908,
-0.0496734343,
0.0480655953,
-0.0129822129,
-0.0180860031,
-0.0225192271,
-0.0266587064,
-0.0234543625,
0.020825753,
-0.0455218852,
0.0142783504,
0.0217942987,
0.026281422,
0.0124959918,
0.0046321647,
-0.0303337779,
-0.0011848327,
0.0154078444,
0.0035348025,
-0.0771994144,
0.0159283951,
0.0327805355,
0.0722182468,
-0.0434961282,
0.0100760842,
-0.0117343236,
-0.0101954062,
0.0171272326,
0.0069971196,
0.0150302062,
0.0146965031,
-0.0257716663,
0.0465730429,
0.0247813407,
-0.0854274631,
0.0105248122,
-0.0226621106,
0.0451713093,
-0.0268658958,
-0.0391238779,
-0.0676791146,
0.0730182827,
0.0051874979,
0.0008108752,
0.0110188043,
-0.0563175566,
0.0126309097,
-0.0020440093,
0.0365959331,
-0.0301496089,
0.0863846615,
-0.0371694416,
0.0413087457,
-0.0469608381,
-0.0178176779,
-0.0320952646,
-0.0453203842,
-0.0199448932,
0.0530885607,
0.0263154078,
0.0042517222,
-0.0367315598,
0.0070365323,
-0.0496301353,
0.0186615866,
0.0195628386,
0.0118322894,
-0.015515455,
0.0188731588,
0.0111287627,
-0.010771445,
0.0095803756,
-0.014765963,
-0.0001972761,
0.0027110823,
-0.0408028066,
0.0277110096,
0.0029335071,
0.0180212036,
0.0019349423,
-0.0730690956,
-0.0378737897,
0.0512524955,
0.0032044232,
-0.0657583401,
0.0366659909,
0.0870429352,
0.023235362,
-0.0130140875,
0.0277906489,
0.0568855517,
0.01281243,
0.0457794107,
0.0124225225,
-0.1165750772,
-0.008681328,
0.0096347285,
-0.0068328381,
-0.0291938372,
-0.0368165225,
-0.0339908935,
-0.1214035228,
0.0741493776,
0.009730896,
-0.0338363387,
-0.0066563599,
0.0009092116,
-0.020611424,
-0.0122299865,
0.0210393537,
-0.0298788063,
-0.0451858081,
-0.0336421765,
0.0270228479,
-0.0340563729,
-0.016070826,
0.0155191766,
-0.0363349393,
0.0593455769,
0.0283661764,
-0.0038217045,
-0.0108491555,
0.0091718957,
0.0614723787,
0.0074886135,
0.0185742024,
0.0012486202,
0.0335881189,
-0.000128579,
-0.0039123688,
0.0021954579,
0.0177418143,
-0.0408318676,
-0.0157374144,
0.0340966433,
0.0483300313,
-0.0271754526,
-0.0095610535,
-0.0099438019,
-0.0177936815,
-0.0370609015,
0.0417279266,
0.0086454172,
-0.0295647439,
-0.0603730902,
-0.0357657596,
-0.046497494,
-0.0025352275,
-0.0174678024,
0.018879436,
-0.0366947614,
-0.0205127522,
-0.0355713703,
-0.0441205427,
0.0088279638,
0.0664093867,
0.0009522468,
0.0279178806,
0.0162172057,
-0.0269617829,
-0.0330056772,
0.0174275953,
-0.0378678404,
0.0319744349,
-0.0647772923,
0.0214466248,
0.0073484085,
0.0055896337,
-0.0302399117,
-0.0255147312,
-0.0722041205,
-0.0437732749,
-0.0218361355,
0.0002727189,
0.0251081698,
-0.0205268562,
-0.0123977428,
-0.0395087041,
0.0485496446,
0.0836468786,
-0.037526045,
0.001225384,
0.060786698,
-0.0049253325,
-0.0292559136,
0.0051128515,
-0.0230802894,
0.0333406739,
0.0398333371,
0.0107688783,
-0.0063851741,
0.0014305931,
0.0169106554,
0.0646573752,
0.0047682612,
-0.0154375294,
-0.0186636783,
-0.0007242954,
0.028215427,
-0.0133367339,
0.00407174,
-0.0353090465,
-0.0288894065,
0.0314041376,
-0.0178333707,
-0.036159765,
0.0580700524,
-0.0301102176,
0.0433811471,
-0.0233525354,
0.0347468965,
-0.0054574152,
-0.0371528715,
0.0313532688,
-0.0147557845,
0.008997038,
0.0040799989,
0.0061237188,
0.0317506343,
0.0011916012,
0.0347027406,
0.0008680439,
0.0274893418,
-0.0145043805,
0.0117781386,
-0.0019248308,
-0.0314058438,
0.0091147721,
0.0667852908,
0.0859219581,
-0.031578701,
-0.0070852255,
-0.0324280895,
0.0041034333,
-0.0125272907,
0.0398878008,
-0.0024538152,
-0.0427178219,
0.0432684533,
0.0191990547,
-0.0369895957,
0.0356856398,
0.0735262558,
0.0460090898,
0.0249664243,
-0.0114250509,
0.0070065237,
-0.0455761254,
-0.0351028405,
0.0434337482,
-0.008092708,
-0.0185041875,
-0.016309822,
-0.0947579369,
-0.03809781,
0.01675798,
-0.0560079925,
-0.0024807581,
-0.0045584012,
0.0103527866,
0.0581389368,
0.028451886,
-0.0029617972,
-0.0196668971,
-0.0211592298,
0.0114387618,
-0.0198074523,
0.0119444644,
-5.643674377e-33,
-0.0118195154,
-0.0329826325,
0.0230013262,
0.0072607775,
-0.027180288,
0.0038194018,
0.0222336743,
-0.0151178762,
0.0364381261,
0.0063687772,
-0.0184720214,
-0.0012401156,
0.0182650089,
0.0205886085,
0.0203967486,
-0.0277529825,
0.0395813175,
-0.0077630593,
-0.0130162081,
-0.0044292426,
-0.0242189616,
0.0272326022,
0.0394983515,
-0.0575189292,
0.0093681002,
0.0372721739,
-0.008517215,
-0.0187756717,
-0.0475993678,
0.0725351721,
-0.0132950051,
0.0354492366,
0.0272352006,
-0.06516359,
-0.0053384206,
0.0023813022,
-0.0444588289,
0.0322996564,
0.0011114529,
0.0049599935,
0.0543005541,
-0.0616306923,
0.048688978,
0.0134980176,
-0.0454488769,
-0.0208403207,
0.0205970388,
-0.0529154539,
-0.0648965463,
-0.0696038455,
-0.0731590539,
0.0694992691,
-0.0057899039,
0.0320574604,
0.0439780504,
-0.0065559773,
-0.0062293569,
0.0835682601,
-0.0287702549,
-0.0234332569,
0.0020945179,
0.002987735,
0.0534050353,
-0.0577343442,
-0.007040964,
0.0660255328,
0.0151436245,
0.0120095769,
-0.0278153233,
-0.0189260412,
0.0309059042,
0.0960163921,
0.0097406097,
0.0315748677,
0.0629747659,
-0.0128484545,
-0.0682489276,
-0.010692589,
0.0282327645,
0.0212389436,
0.0168478601,
0.0165996142,
-0.0111713996,
-0.0059789503,
-0.0428799838,
-0.0343946852,
0.0133766541,
0.00510525,
0.0449430086,
0.0321105979,
0.0701987073,
0.0053078658,
0.0025405262,
-0.0327674709,
-0.0432706065,
0.0188786704,
-0.0127191152,
0.0186962616,
-0.0094032437,
0.0171778873,
-0.0918361619,
-0.0427916162,
0.0153613864,
-0.0094961682,
0.0165335089,
-0.0294940993,
0.0472381972,
-0.005484405,
-0.0858922899,
0.0164688285,
-0.0005080712,
0.0349047296,
0.0351868533,
0.0695599839,
0.0365148932,
-0.0205067694,
0.0227550697,
0.0623684563,
-0.0033605248,
-0.0433964022,
0.0025095004,
0.0041846498,
-0.0150341084,
0.0216006618,
0.0021693818,
0.0072696432,
0.010641071,
0.0458076447,
0.0488644652,
-0.0117015047,
0.0080805048,
0.007648645,
2.581e-7,
0.0376227461,
0.0490444303,
-0.007854687,
0.0301992856,
-0.0026129971,
0.0483329594,
-0.0128544951,
0.0422523394,
-0.0213862825,
-0.0196655951,
0.0069379127,
-0.0261988007,
0.0794239715,
0.0152068241,
-0.0711349621,
0.0117786331,
-0.0639527738,
-0.0183034018,
-0.0928975418,
0.007552268,
0.0498670675,
0.1112563908,
0.0189046431,
-0.0461160205,
0.0244522318,
-0.0588773526,
0.0479122549,
-0.0640047491,
-0.0309251342,
-0.0099769142,
0.0620680116,
-0.0017823103,
0.0017700013,
0.0280414987,
-0.0122770593,
0.0787685439,
-0.0349221043,
0.0864394009,
0.0020629098,
0.0340248346,
0.0001963211,
-0.047861658,
-0.0063081584,
-0.0102181826,
0.0578546263,
-0.0170679688,
-0.024746893,
-0.0511024334,
-0.0344205126,
-0.0680420771,
0.0331218466,
0.0271819253,
0.036218144,
0.0146910297,
0.0283397995,
-0.0517956205,
0.0084461858,
-0.1063435674,
0.0118985241,
0.0482436307,
-0.0282305572,
0.0375883617,
-0.03565602,
0.0403540991,
0.0613190793,
-0.0742484778,
0.0069456766,
2.357737233e-34,
0.0428161286,
-0.0410722047,
0.005182818,
0.0608398356,
0.011419069,
0.0339943543,
-0.0063201156,
0.0208429266,
-0.0179939587,
-0.077218011,
0.0400973447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08886v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08886v1 | CLIMB: Curriculum Learning for Infant-inspired Model Building | 2023-11-15T11:48:16 | 2023-11-15T11:48:16 | Richard Diehl Martinez, Zebulon Goriely, Hope McGovern, Christopher Davis, Andrew Caines, Paula Buttery, Lisa Beinborn | cs.CL | cs.CL | We describe our team's contribution to the STRICT-SMALL track of the BabyLM
Challenge. The challenge requires training a language model from scratch using
only a relatively small training dataset of ten million words. We experiment
with three variants of cognitively-motivated curriculum learning and analyze
their effect on the performance of the model on linguistic evaluation tasks. In
the vocabulary curriculum, we analyze methods for constraining the vocabulary
in the early stages of training to simulate cognitively more plausible learning
curves. In the data curriculum experiments, we vary the order of the training
instances based on i) infant-inspired expectations and ii) the learning
behavior of the model. In the objective curriculum, we explore different
variations of combining the conventional masked language modeling task with a
more coarse-grained word class prediction task to reinforce linguistic
generalization capabilities. Our results did not yield consistent improvements
over our own non-curriculum learning baseline across a range of linguistic
benchmarks; however, we do find marginal gains on select tasks. Our analysis
highlights key takeaways for specific combinations of tasks and settings which
benefit from our proposed curricula. We moreover determine that careful
selection of model architecture, and training hyper-parameters yield
substantial improvements over the default baselines provided by the BabyLM
challenge. | [
0.0360775217,
0.0790885091,
-0.0299872626,
0.0117684547,
-0.0392112844,
0.0597481951,
0.0148821473,
-0.0238453187,
-0.0222284384,
-0.0358311348,
-0.0034657805,
-0.0408799984,
-0.01634036,
0.0257917251,
0.0261917189,
-0.0656463727,
0.0599208176,
-0.0118646361,
0.036992386,
-0.0030892398,
-0.0279187821,
0.000307859,
-0.0086130872,
0.0257877707,
-0.0248558521,
-0.0007855578,
0.0186392851,
-0.0178531278,
-0.0125309145,
-0.0179349165,
0.0507247001,
0.0565859973,
0.0545110032,
0.0441541299,
0.0000022176,
-0.0805704594,
-0.0175869912,
-0.0372370332,
-0.043723207,
-0.053192392,
0.0791876465,
0.0262271091,
0.0090749431,
0.0197574161,
-0.0363667235,
0.0402958058,
0.0392967425,
0.0022734755,
0.0118011124,
0.0325122029,
-0.001679725,
-0.0295128282,
-0.0005725526,
-0.0008576442,
0.0274714306,
-0.0128261512,
0.007267884,
0.0392786898,
0.0277745742,
-0.0177611448,
-0.0514058284,
0.0196510348,
0.0171239879,
0.034055654,
0.0368724801,
0.0264909938,
-0.0320297033,
-0.0581727996,
-0.031505961,
0.0399104133,
-0.0254509654,
-0.0395067111,
-0.0023801022,
-0.0129950838,
-0.004014621,
-0.0365836099,
-0.0518540852,
0.0410536528,
0.012549106,
0.0282717459,
0.0269961078,
-0.0164591763,
0.0248147231,
0.0313597545,
-0.0113869794,
0.0261432566,
0.0055507161,
-0.0482944101,
0.0504313409,
0.0418744721,
-0.0418471433,
-0.0025641138,
-0.039823588,
0.0041380413,
-0.0318444446,
0.0429584868,
-0.05430701,
-0.0168377832,
0.0231830757,
-0.0240560472,
0.0624334887,
0.0042231581,
-0.0114567941,
0.0501509905,
0.0109537933,
0.0765329897,
0.0682560876,
0.0409529991,
-0.0299523249,
0.0039105448,
-0.0438708179,
-0.0124395443,
-0.038230855,
0.0160530098,
-0.0129004885,
-0.0011933175,
-0.0262388624,
-0.01680783,
-0.0292630773,
0.0235395562,
0.0439781956,
0.0198039003,
-0.0419627428,
-0.0014076094,
-0.0237988848,
-0.0361083969,
-0.0142038744,
0.0229518916,
-0.0031209346,
-0.0215198267,
-0.0049847094,
0.0022406895,
0.0026458646,
-0.0157439187,
0.0388783813,
0.0265124422,
-0.0383244567,
-0.0789396241,
-0.0128108226,
0.0341182128,
-0.0242940597,
-0.0584222563,
0.019963745,
-0.0656097457,
-0.0148142092,
-0.0186112411,
0.0242501348,
-0.0632204935,
0.0075857346,
-0.0048874952,
-0.0230956282,
0.0491940528,
-0.025306683,
-0.0224154312,
0.0093926955,
0.0121260462,
0.0247228108,
0.1023023054,
0.0338322371,
-0.0145017589,
0.0445513651,
-0.0113469418,
-0.0232871976,
0.0408361107,
0.0101417731,
-0.0054340912,
-0.0351304226,
-0.0119050955,
0.00725677,
0.0167418458,
0.0250831507,
0.0305839945,
-0.009784746,
-0.0018609227,
0.0633285269,
0.0603097826,
-0.033427991,
-0.0043995865,
0.0448514745,
0.0223154835,
0.0223140642,
0.0035090058,
-0.0400016345,
-0.0261327941,
-0.0200354122,
-0.0069882711,
-0.0120245982,
0.0152257318,
-0.0322469622,
-0.0613873899,
-0.0169163458,
0.0053325063,
0.0313578881,
-0.0040583583,
0.0309643,
0.0523036979,
-0.0291489772,
-0.0212106425,
0.0851684734,
-0.0302331932,
0.0239565168,
-0.0437857248,
-0.0053269034,
0.0371051207,
0.0354885273,
-0.0169462804,
-0.0537436642,
-0.0020812172,
0.015256308,
0.0757147595,
0.0268567242,
-0.0313306153,
0.0005180362,
-0.0668604374,
-0.014051985,
-0.005132427,
0.0430547222,
-0.0066993386,
0.0491533168,
-0.0416774452,
-0.0171071868,
-0.0125161484,
-0.056936074,
0.0624067821,
-0.0860068202,
-0.0850362554,
-0.0233951677,
0.0077005732,
0.044096861,
-0.0197020136,
0.006173206,
0.0031595456,
0.0203634854,
-0.0132702198,
0.010571165,
-0.0012692959,
-0.062687099,
-0.0328621231,
0.0126179801,
-0.0019413084,
-0.0209052786,
0.0686836913,
-0.0142436214,
-0.0068682111,
0.0341373459,
-0.0176578052,
0.0315480866,
-0.0363204852,
0.0407867655,
-0.0453747287,
-0.0000710076,
-0.0560750999,
0.0630038604,
-0.0020997205,
0.0382812954,
0.0013803041,
-0.017432902,
-0.0375919081,
-0.0292746834,
-0.0465131365,
-0.0260873865,
-0.0072993026,
0.0394293815,
0.0019390587,
0.0233636294,
-0.0857379958,
-0.0186596233,
-0.0848855451,
-0.0157282297,
-0.0189164914,
-0.020578295,
0.0225385074,
-0.0297973156,
-0.015464765,
-0.0002371331,
-0.0139840469,
0.0152349165,
-0.0279563125,
0.0156813245,
0.0150438519,
-0.0179091841,
-0.0163809229,
-0.0449418053,
-0.0098220613,
-0.0201415997,
0.0446335189,
0.0263977218,
0.0452300608,
0.0012774129,
-0.0103353122,
-0.0205412749,
0.0115233827,
-0.0132106123,
0.0113661578,
0.0325063504,
-0.0054474892,
0.0256812815,
0.0553580038,
0.0220960397,
0.0435282663,
0.0228536706,
-0.0026831883,
-0.049115371,
0.0180884656,
-0.0414339267,
-0.032171756,
-0.0167772882,
-0.0090981433,
-0.0335450619,
0.1254610121,
-0.0014095128,
-0.0130065316,
-0.0746801943,
0.024296334,
-0.0341858529,
-0.0371179245,
-0.0829243138,
0.0068659731,
-0.0296831578,
0.000164896,
-0.0468972549,
-0.0597446337,
0.0498016477,
-0.0012538946,
0.0040853741,
-0.0781655014,
0.0000012427,
0.0018007617,
0.0503390133,
0.0242163036,
0.0000539871,
0.0175638646,
0.0144009786,
-0.1063124761,
-0.0141006671,
0.0369581543,
-0.028509967,
0.0342898518,
-0.0735600069,
-0.0142977741,
0.0344571583,
-0.0267752651,
-0.0574055165,
-0.0085863201,
-0.0159798618,
0.0295457318,
0.0300031919,
0.0215356015,
-0.0472102948,
-0.0454612114,
-0.0178565402,
0.0253025796,
0.0061344123,
-0.0075141783,
-0.0179210454,
-0.022596119,
0.0621523671,
0.0048169619,
0.0273625888,
-0.0767061859,
0.018459022,
0.0389673524,
0.0523316301,
-0.0077034524,
-0.0228179079,
0.069249399,
0.0287394337,
-0.0139391972,
-0.0041357102,
0.0446547307,
0.0279525351,
-0.0394076966,
-0.0467677899,
0.1112070307,
0.0223721843,
-0.0278265234,
-0.0026460541,
-0.0026557036,
0.0722263977,
0.0493486114,
0.00611124,
-0.0302495658,
-0.0028730161,
0.0071090423,
0.0373135768,
-0.0164631661,
-0.0478349701,
-0.0248640105,
-0.0707328022,
0.0040399712,
0.0159716066,
-0.0070623523,
0.0519240797,
-0.0458424725,
-0.0157463588,
-0.0138779953,
0.0244723,
-0.0009067173,
-0.0311927404,
-0.0148494355,
0.0305453055,
0.0035100712,
-0.0462939031,
0.0778343007,
-0.0033518064,
0.0543653294,
0.002322722,
0.0227679461,
-0.0355262272,
0.0019006321,
0.0648413375,
-0.0122954659,
-0.0331672803,
-0.0070649511,
0.03903405,
-0.0191386752,
-0.0040926151,
0.0130617078,
0.0383065753,
0.0057996269,
-0.028237721,
-0.0089342156,
0.0575712398,
0.0227879994,
-0.039756462,
-0.0060159382,
0.014057273,
0.0276153684,
0.0740667284,
0.0249832384,
-0.1016333923,
-0.0029347958,
-0.0043552322,
-0.0194113366,
-0.0066065476,
-0.0469873808,
0.0336625353,
-0.0117649529,
-0.0142029719,
-0.0673471019,
-0.0188646931,
0.0382430628,
0.0542659163,
0.0245190412,
-0.0057436535,
0.0048144474,
-0.0054300176,
-0.0602565743,
0.0366677307,
-0.0278000068,
-0.0185226649,
-0.0816440284,
-0.0642907619,
-0.0176714398,
-0.0548103414,
-0.0507350229,
0.0111947656,
-0.0721768141,
-0.0463101305,
0.0239704251,
0.0376692601,
0.0232875887,
0.0606954321,
0.0253531672,
-0.029524399,
0.049592521,
0.0036354198,
0.0228288118,
0.0126725817,
0.0402869731,
-0.0188563839,
-0.0012429904,
0.0197933596,
-0.0181156602,
0.0304817203,
0.0568763092,
0.0460333712,
0.0040947357,
0.037551906,
0.0148548111,
-0.0055905995,
0.0762438551,
-0.0317690894,
-0.0214303602,
-0.0877242833,
-0.013847772,
0.0017501861,
-0.0130674168,
-0.0120661706,
-0.0299172308,
0.0262762513,
0.0254919492,
-0.0119878994,
0.0087594399,
-0.0191097334,
0.0335368589,
-0.055132661,
-0.0000542906,
-0.0183962751,
0.0404577963,
0.0133688003,
0.0243162811,
-0.0252963025,
0.0196241867,
-0.0280790273,
0.0435552374,
0.0076002255,
0.0262481887,
-0.0168897081,
0.0438690111,
-0.0326627977,
0.0020880867,
-0.0437957197,
0.0328108706,
-0.065905802,
0.0057109734,
0.0436160304,
-0.05845071,
0.0093293143,
-0.0404645577,
-0.0070686275,
-0.0207381863,
-0.0136631783,
-0.0192731805,
-0.0701379851,
0.0347088054,
0.0132584432,
-0.0005477947,
-0.0141216135,
0.0568859279,
0.0396187492,
0.0454474501,
-0.0039629815,
0.0376463719,
-0.0465960242,
-0.0282820296,
0.0718422085,
0.0406472683,
0.0013423566,
0.0485792086,
-0.0468170308,
-0.0611003935,
-0.023472406,
0.0206037462,
0.0165247191,
0.0158391446,
0.0851124153,
0.0646141395,
-0.0717204064,
-0.0041993726,
-0.0279958043,
-0.0109602967,
0.0321839415,
-0.0036894714,
-0.0075383289,
-6.721440698e-33,
-0.003943081,
-0.0012188734,
0.0468421131,
0.0363970175,
0.0433192998,
0.0163306091,
-0.0125213405,
0.0461670756,
-0.0238626841,
0.0283365771,
-0.0090489229,
-0.0035824028,
-0.0024106915,
0.0514661595,
0.002554232,
0.022166552,
0.0237024073,
-0.0322757512,
-0.0150711834,
-0.015324886,
0.0216608178,
0.0225809738,
0.0514328666,
-0.0399545804,
0.0082048951,
0.0315929092,
0.003205983,
0.0146362698,
0.0036505403,
0.0582982004,
-0.0188344885,
0.0475437045,
0.0286474172,
-0.0032873284,
-0.0351513512,
0.0091240983,
-0.0826540515,
-0.0704753622,
0.0319321975,
-0.0117162541,
-0.0383809023,
-0.0234908238,
-0.0025537158,
-0.0126751289,
-0.048046153,
-0.0384120606,
0.0289936624,
-0.028912805,
-0.0254329834,
-0.0092048291,
-0.0801717266,
-0.002250331,
0.0128524909,
-0.0233814344,
0.0273462217,
-0.0015634377,
-0.021306565,
-0.0075236247,
-0.0074159782,
0.0266281087,
0.0250383168,
0.0478504598,
0.0676022843,
0.0378591642,
0.0126204966,
0.1024682149,
-0.0030105105,
0.0308926646,
-0.0024306076,
0.0060972469,
0.0857938677,
0.0336295217,
0.0382257104,
0.0168379098,
0.0240703579,
-0.0168164298,
-0.0503385141,
0.0286324713,
-0.0030956385,
0.0404509529,
0.0423909575,
-0.0246948954,
-0.0461114757,
-0.0159259904,
-0.0803818032,
0.0021543673,
-0.0336857997,
0.034756273,
0.0318424664,
0.0395947695,
-0.0287104882,
-0.0174243283,
-0.0208476149,
-0.0474009402,
0.0046004052,
0.0162369125,
0.0120914634,
-0.0229680967,
0.0202875473,
0.0117240092,
-0.0852011591,
-0.0692427903,
0.0125115067,
0.0236762986,
0.0260719433,
0.0356726162,
0.0627072901,
0.0229465757,
-0.0507285595,
-0.0064760605,
-0.0437570326,
0.0090543171,
0.0439382978,
0.0029602081,
0.0252386555,
0.0161217321,
-0.0144878281,
0.005444291,
0.0205676109,
-0.0505401716,
-0.0110015292,
0.026404297,
-0.012565718,
0.0623783208,
-0.0277414136,
-0.0262484588,
-0.0318469815,
0.006318023,
0.0691997558,
-0.0462012365,
0.0147156185,
0.0243292581,
2.771e-7,
0.0236892197,
0.085695371,
-0.0172330309,
-0.0138735399,
0.0323210768,
0.0028062477,
-0.0317526273,
0.0150268283,
-0.0112593584,
-0.0172922313,
-0.0075632599,
0.0226230733,
0.0783365592,
0.0229290258,
-0.0805681273,
-0.0253111981,
-0.0455281101,
0.0364975147,
-0.046656061,
0.008629242,
0.0542882085,
0.0793026313,
0.0256933328,
-0.0328158177,
-0.0131097091,
0.0021958374,
0.0357567184,
-0.0490376689,
0.0332912318,
0.0045502167,
-0.0304811168,
0.0510606356,
0.0151684461,
0.019457804,
-0.0500089452,
0.0420853533,
-0.0045726546,
0.0703260154,
-0.0029684922,
-0.0080101779,
-0.0038998846,
0.012105708,
-0.0508832037,
-0.0830273107,
0.0379925296,
-0.0545961298,
-0.0017272703,
0.0039791223,
-0.0133026484,
0.0160000753,
0.0140015511,
-0.0168660544,
-0.0247960854,
-0.0128973071,
0.0315522812,
0.0046536061,
-0.0125044333,
-0.0541596189,
0.0176083911,
0.0334167443,
-0.0309304595,
-0.0625705644,
-0.0163413249,
-0.0192427039,
-0.0030779045,
-0.0587595254,
0.0264060013,
2.594382843e-34,
0.0215224903,
-0.038805645,
0.033299543,
-0.0476886667,
0.0201149583,
-0.0420587622,
0.016248364,
0.0183935463,
0.0326034687,
-0.0779295713,
0.008996211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08883v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08883v2 | Enabling Large Language Models to Learn from Rules | 2023-11-15T11:42:41 | 2024-02-16T14:07:24 | Wenkai Yang, Yankai Lin, Jie Zhou, Jirong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible performance in completing
various real-world tasks. The current knowledge learning paradigm of LLMs is
mainly based on learning from examples, in which LLMs learn the internal rule
implicitly from a certain number of supervised examples. However, this learning
paradigm may not well learn those complicated rules, especially when the
training examples are limited. We are inspired that humans can learn the new
tasks or knowledge in another way by learning from rules. That is, humans can
learn new tasks or grasps new knowledge quickly and generalize well given only
a detailed rule and a few optional examples. Therefore, in this paper, we aim
to explore the feasibility of this new learning paradigm, which targets on
encoding rule-based knowledge into LLMs. We further propose rule distillation,
which first uses the strong in-context abilities of LLMs to extract the
knowledge from the textual rules, and then explicitly encode the knowledge into
the parameters of LLMs by learning from the above in-context signals produced
inside the model. Our experiments show that making LLMs learn from rules by our
method is much more efficient than example-based learning in both the sample
size and generalization ability. Warning: This paper may contain examples with
offensive content. | [
0.0387057513,
0.0342055932,
-0.0334209912,
0.0327696949,
-0.0240650587,
0.0416647308,
-0.0280519556,
0.0486368202,
-0.0041148555,
-0.0409049094,
-0.017390579,
-0.0333297662,
-0.0311217513,
0.0224044826,
0.01595819,
-0.0557509325,
0.00014496,
-0.0536348969,
0.0289938077,
0.0103689218,
0.0199322384,
-0.0013817583,
0.0282778274,
0.0096635958,
-0.0150366165,
0.0067340988,
-0.017643502,
-0.0343636423,
-0.0184265673,
-0.0012732726,
0.0236917194,
0.0035636746,
0.0574172325,
0.036751207,
0.000002098,
-0.0388838239,
0.0121969488,
-0.0386345945,
-0.0237392876,
-0.0032795672,
0.009727505,
-0.0442685336,
0.0085210828,
0.0026818889,
-0.0528714284,
0.0014178174,
0.0390111208,
0.0520180501,
0.0568006933,
0.0833786428,
0.004478625,
-0.0410000235,
0.0281092227,
-0.0136587387,
0.0154572902,
-0.0315421522,
0.0404066592,
0.0162796713,
-0.0022875043,
-0.0332366116,
-0.0404434577,
0.008160485,
0.052016329,
0.0117034558,
-0.0283364188,
0.0515101813,
-0.0070676999,
-0.0084455218,
0.0058093318,
0.0717669129,
-0.0820455775,
-0.0282483716,
0.0203813482,
0.0000078258,
0.0022032866,
0.0143292872,
-0.0785477608,
0.035311833,
-0.0063150744,
0.0425565764,
0.0025418028,
-0.0217607357,
0.0335191637,
0.0084249703,
-0.0195295513,
0.0706685781,
-0.0166486315,
-0.0301715061,
-0.0062716883,
-0.028847374,
-0.0131810922,
-0.0289322454,
0.006777416,
0.0450026691,
-0.0131625766,
0.0271345992,
-0.0281245895,
0.0027189734,
0.0091128768,
-0.080202736,
0.0529580042,
0.0447949357,
-0.0120012583,
0.0585166216,
-0.0630481169,
0.0187112708,
-0.0006767044,
0.0414065644,
-0.0789150894,
-0.0065368265,
-0.076425083,
0.001456944,
-0.0143329361,
0.0430287495,
-0.0376719125,
-0.0200225692,
-0.0121279191,
0.0381562486,
-0.0080902297,
-0.0029544816,
0.0095348507,
-0.0110167675,
0.0033872083,
-0.0320746154,
-0.027511213,
-0.0011138231,
-0.0303887278,
0.025474038,
0.0009107465,
-0.0332198404,
-0.0114646768,
-0.0241535362,
0.0157944895,
0.0093888398,
0.0186703,
0.095137015,
-0.0037843252,
-0.0291447751,
-0.0385266058,
-0.017478263,
0.0155824926,
-0.0645300671,
0.0071289917,
-0.0808953568,
0.0374681838,
-0.0037110532,
-0.0080180317,
-0.0674662963,
0.0283779856,
0.0166361704,
-0.0200282633,
0.0533613861,
0.0137766022,
0.0133205252,
0.0136169428,
0.0186120905,
-0.0452522747,
0.0623595901,
0.0141358357,
0.0446586348,
-0.0061564622,
0.0179726705,
0.0343200564,
0.0295233615,
0.0280745849,
0.0242866855,
-0.0287787449,
-0.0111877797,
0.0387601405,
0.0263011586,
0.05715039,
0.0636907816,
-0.0473554768,
-0.0045891567,
0.0892731771,
0.0295000672,
0.0359002352,
0.0195419118,
0.0678012967,
-0.0043294313,
0.039902471,
-0.0068521989,
-0.0722453445,
-0.0032072102,
-0.0116105406,
0.0056743082,
-0.0394145437,
0.0415604599,
-0.0431983471,
-0.0439692959,
0.0115503175,
-0.0388310179,
0.0114442613,
0.0261158664,
0.0791107714,
0.0280426014,
-0.0026043851,
0.0361761004,
0.079617843,
-0.0034621018,
0.0205147676,
-0.0444971584,
0.0644785464,
0.0550073162,
0.0124262245,
-0.0511318557,
0.021911975,
-0.0230661482,
0.0456807427,
-0.009860496,
-0.007459735,
-0.0169302281,
0.0330342129,
-0.0530503169,
-0.0191943776,
0.0166153889,
0.0097116083,
0.0049080355,
0.0372629091,
-0.0305264313,
0.0050277621,
-0.0326727405,
-0.0536545031,
0.0495314486,
-0.0206622295,
-0.0504093319,
-0.0066005872,
-0.0150925415,
0.0273033343,
-0.019448638,
-0.000425994,
-0.0187665783,
0.0307064336,
-0.0662721395,
-0.0381259695,
-0.0139769902,
-0.0611725152,
-0.0483965017,
0.0414097421,
-0.0301535986,
-0.0087675145,
0.013227175,
-0.0276653618,
-0.0108739603,
-0.0131801926,
-0.0261536874,
0.0905639827,
-0.02460704,
0.0129406322,
0.0257977508,
0.0029710033,
-0.0237160567,
0.0557517335,
-0.0201912243,
-0.0252122842,
0.0036348298,
-0.0496767461,
-0.0175646581,
0.0212358031,
-0.0058311024,
0.0036464834,
-0.0155311208,
0.0257417671,
0.0096265655,
0.0214680154,
-0.0356610082,
-0.0184122194,
-0.0345086753,
-0.0045754039,
-0.015804911,
-0.0146416482,
0.0077295457,
-0.0006540734,
0.0000931266,
-0.039511513,
-0.0401057117,
-0.0016530001,
-0.0291023366,
0.0014277024,
0.0195860676,
0.0090273404,
-0.0579441153,
-0.0040241983,
-0.0082613844,
-0.0027290229,
0.0436638333,
-0.0488518775,
0.0291701462,
-0.0665994585,
0.0240819156,
0.0066977888,
0.0486767069,
-0.0193457101,
-0.0283845048,
0.0008146072,
-0.038741868,
0.0099186832,
0.0759956613,
-0.0022516225,
0.0298382528,
0.0799715668,
-0.0000400005,
-0.0590359643,
-0.0040555806,
-0.0451644585,
0.0021973974,
-0.0440847613,
0.0101131359,
-0.005338056,
0.0434013791,
0.0112957601,
0.0174930617,
-0.0537887774,
0.0292480402,
-0.0141560407,
-0.0586281456,
-0.0684123188,
-0.0252056587,
-0.059611395,
0.0152481254,
-0.0265258532,
-0.0684955418,
0.0589910597,
0.017934937,
0.0031800366,
-0.0247313492,
-0.0164766256,
-0.0243140496,
0.0843564793,
0.0162461773,
0.0519518107,
0.0137917968,
-0.0317395031,
-0.0499122292,
0.004509802,
0.0138667244,
-0.028995771,
0.0664641932,
-0.0715875924,
-0.0038544303,
-0.0031088525,
-0.0361491926,
-0.0773947984,
-0.0182295311,
-0.0202621426,
0.0300638918,
-0.0116002196,
-0.0081701549,
-0.0091340709,
0.0082490295,
0.0347861089,
0.0231435485,
0.0140329385,
-0.0260822233,
-0.0348471962,
-0.0005966238,
0.0476452596,
-0.0064263064,
-0.0392767116,
-0.0167453382,
0.0382863954,
0.0734837726,
0.0147510543,
-0.0018963985,
-0.0197747573,
0.0443809628,
0.0219268687,
-0.0411349498,
-0.0031393201,
0.0477192737,
0.0193727855,
-0.0787725896,
0.0135560567,
0.1127827466,
0.0258147009,
-0.0109095573,
0.0311392527,
0.0003518442,
-0.0101496,
0.0177154969,
0.0293908492,
-0.0709712356,
-0.0166976694,
0.0179495718,
-0.0111727947,
0.0124998242,
-0.0240017846,
-0.003490126,
-0.0966954753,
-0.0016956129,
0.0265857726,
-0.0565142557,
-0.0640601069,
-0.0345444791,
0.0000954898,
-0.0021313706,
0.010257693,
0.0410313867,
-0.017690219,
-0.0143701136,
0.0191067681,
-0.0044981027,
-0.0538801067,
0.0417574123,
-0.0502211004,
0.0764740109,
0.0434462726,
0.0403259099,
-0.0018126308,
-0.0208606124,
-0.0006360766,
0.0182022452,
0.0000316181,
-0.0171191804,
0.0343431309,
0.01277423,
-0.0044910251,
-0.0034766709,
0.0765784159,
-0.0425210446,
-0.0271402802,
0.0144566773,
0.098454915,
0.0141054438,
-0.0385184847,
0.0057668812,
-0.062411651,
-0.0136766145,
0.0851368457,
0.0325022787,
-0.0493578464,
-0.0118602458,
-0.0400983691,
-0.0555798747,
-0.000546977,
-0.0530405566,
-0.0099837985,
-0.0189585295,
-0.007270277,
-0.0810261518,
0.0230254438,
0.0417944826,
0.0631649792,
0.0359707959,
0.0235640295,
0.0513733663,
0.0066874991,
-0.008277447,
-0.0246562678,
-0.0485587865,
0.0022860665,
-0.0142368795,
-0.0217163377,
0.0023326201,
-0.0426758975,
-0.018565014,
0.0075439471,
-0.0231147036,
-0.0736455023,
0.0382281281,
0.0342356302,
0.0219405182,
0.0547780432,
-0.0121833198,
-0.0495501123,
0.0856408924,
0.0183529072,
-0.0479964837,
-0.0068206615,
0.0454166234,
-0.0065218844,
0.0348576754,
0.0424822457,
-0.0486413836,
0.0270620342,
0.0252682418,
0.0125692692,
-0.072670415,
0.0168617796,
0.0672225207,
0.002403649,
0.0007724859,
-0.0062845326,
-0.0426942594,
-0.025572205,
0.0012435948,
-0.0259713419,
0.0022980773,
-0.0503650531,
0.0265094955,
0.0321038105,
0.0229200274,
-0.0022717735,
-0.016583411,
0.0300682969,
0.0044137212,
-0.0265783742,
-0.0319707766,
0.0282314233,
0.0241537485,
0.0537540242,
0.0068969014,
0.0057923263,
0.0352535583,
-0.019506257,
0.0061719599,
-0.0395624191,
0.0313477479,
0.0282515474,
-0.0048678401,
-0.0666157976,
-0.0099603524,
-0.0638801232,
-0.0488015749,
-0.0183352288,
0.0331866741,
0.0573688149,
-0.0250148326,
0.0235433746,
-0.05303872,
-0.0043012397,
-0.0066972286,
0.0107042138,
-0.035653878,
-0.0046654725,
0.0263758693,
0.0340244249,
-0.0230334215,
0.0025407479,
0.080511637,
-0.0046015093,
0.0775048584,
-0.0217616986,
0.0087189144,
-0.0393127389,
0.0084178066,
0.0397679023,
0.0448407196,
-0.0358782224,
0.0236818511,
-0.0206701607,
-0.0573265888,
-0.03863075,
0.0131280143,
0.006718135,
-0.0487453155,
0.0418621935,
0.0340510048,
0.0070169731,
-0.0432137512,
-0.0385018066,
-0.0174985304,
0.0293082781,
-0.0269348118,
0.0040644556,
-6.531072327e-33,
0.0160199273,
0.0056385654,
0.007585437,
0.046219714,
-0.0157901775,
-0.0230432563,
-0.0104326447,
-0.0092913872,
0.0008917621,
0.0099965567,
-0.0071508684,
-0.0069632703,
0.0056542694,
0.0092255287,
0.0318627693,
-0.0156475753,
0.0489543118,
-0.0345434286,
0.0003495935,
0.0284560733,
0.0425574966,
0.034882348,
0.0246317722,
-0.0613598339,
-0.0118010174,
0.0240426231,
-0.0056602708,
0.0398908556,
0.0132840816,
0.0642336905,
-0.029180387,
0.0447631776,
0.0206933618,
-0.0379335508,
-0.0442037694,
0.0191091597,
-0.0887345076,
-0.0198097825,
0.0244749263,
-0.0076133502,
-0.0090434812,
-0.01077695,
0.0784293935,
-0.0149776489,
0.0185534842,
0.0036622342,
0.0170950405,
-0.0572201572,
-0.0255940743,
-0.0353975855,
-0.0705021769,
0.0172351468,
0.0060932771,
-0.0533739962,
0.034130346,
-0.014163876,
-0.0045002485,
-0.0228588115,
-0.0706044212,
0.0099726673,
0.0094893668,
0.0576076917,
0.0148152178,
0.0213454384,
0.0010103823,
0.0619913228,
-0.0045944862,
-0.0262707472,
-0.0087616956,
-0.0103569711,
0.059709657,
0.0757446736,
-0.0057580308,
0.0336236246,
0.0585816838,
-0.0324377306,
-0.061524611,
0.0062582507,
0.0518676899,
0.0741614997,
0.0380783789,
0.0335625298,
-0.0391208157,
-0.0177610666,
-0.0395191349,
0.030218713,
-0.0052839345,
-0.0311907027,
0.0316384919,
0.0368290097,
0.0168110002,
-0.0683350563,
0.0165612642,
-0.0552730225,
0.0016030163,
0.0083871745,
-0.0262257829,
0.0074325604,
0.0075221192,
-0.0122916596,
-0.1078173444,
-0.0431090146,
0.00734198,
-0.0436741337,
0.0075006764,
0.0008434471,
0.0651492029,
0.0604415089,
-0.059806101,
-0.0097850794,
-0.0426957719,
-0.0064798915,
0.0652059317,
-0.0053804382,
0.0200891849,
0.0214192104,
-0.0124533977,
-0.0157894827,
0.0050945566,
-0.0462596789,
-0.0411381163,
-0.0027442873,
0.0143228807,
0.0234452952,
-0.0398956239,
-0.0198558811,
-0.0352895856,
0.0098344889,
0.0670089349,
-0.0397277139,
-0.0103819463,
0.0215136912,
2.771e-7,
0.0146246543,
0.0316374935,
-0.0159955341,
0.0330152065,
0.0261184033,
0.0342771113,
-0.0160651673,
0.025914019,
0.013144793,
-0.0346594565,
0.0021231452,
0.0647923425,
0.0317445695,
0.0181096718,
-0.1154511869,
-0.0136715062,
-0.0214889459,
-0.0515133627,
-0.0135046327,
-0.0140920999,
0.0329947211,
0.1056909338,
0.0532793403,
-0.031176025,
0.0201209057,
-0.0347250924,
0.0606489293,
-0.030490784,
0.0098848594,
0.008276511,
0.0370273329,
0.0032711816,
0.0005700716,
0.0218594223,
0.0098231137,
0.0330936201,
-0.0157138985,
0.0703844726,
-0.002342727,
0.0420787856,
-0.0053363075,
-0.0244615711,
0.012634947,
-0.0434445888,
0.0728335306,
-0.0725209415,
-0.0209456552,
-0.0339953713,
0.0220616236,
-0.0315467082,
-0.0283755809,
0.0138955535,
-0.0116099482,
0.0073047476,
0.0130418818,
-0.0064210077,
0.0065276395,
-0.0793922171,
-0.0233569238,
0.0294231288,
-0.0400010087,
-0.0650725961,
-0.0312316585,
-0.0120821362,
-0.0005191948,
-0.0421689935,
0.0306685865,
2.424483042e-34,
0.0131948469,
-0.0225764457,
0.0104196565,
0.0694699287,
0.0107080052,
-0.0036449791,
-0.0274993479,
0.0263862647,
0.0376518592,
-0.0696172789,
-0.024427196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08877v1 | Llamas Know What GPTs Don't Show: Surrogate Models for Confidence Estimation | 2023-11-15T11:27:44 | 2023-11-15T11:27:44 | Vaishnavi Shrivastava, Percy Liang, Ananya Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | To maintain user trust, large language models (LLMs) should signal low
confidence on examples where they are incorrect, instead of misleading the
user. The standard approach of estimating confidence is to use the softmax
probabilities of these models, but as of November 2023, state-of-the-art LLMs
such as GPT-4 and Claude-v1.3 do not provide access to these probabilities. We
first study eliciting confidence linguistically -- asking an LLM for its
confidence in its answer -- which performs reasonably (80.5% AUC on GPT-4
averaged across 12 question-answering datasets -- 7% above a random baseline)
but leaves room for improvement. We then explore using a surrogate confidence
model -- using a model where we do have probabilities to evaluate the original
model's confidence in a given question. Surprisingly, even though these
probabilities come from a different and often weaker model, this method leads
to higher AUC than linguistic confidences on 9 out of 12 datasets. Our best
method composing linguistic confidences and surrogate model probabilities gives
state-of-the-art confidence estimates on all 12 datasets (84.6% average AUC on
GPT-4). | [
0.0542862043,
0.0980671346,
-0.0103254039,
0.0402418524,
0.0023552158,
-0.0001205021,
-0.0113620646,
-0.0279275775,
-0.0059160371,
-0.0251507182,
-0.0508276187,
-0.0455452614,
-0.0019216751,
0.0029657669,
0.0379997641,
-0.0151449749,
0.0044134753,
-0.0305869915,
0.0755809322,
-0.0253200792,
0.0034453233,
-0.0136487577,
-0.003161686,
0.0400441103,
0.0255440176,
-0.0302683096,
0.0253903512,
-0.0101220421,
0.0235097855,
-0.0378476344,
0.0488344841,
0.0566820763,
-0.0171001535,
0.0234361645,
0.0000018612,
-0.0467999689,
0.0005423889,
-0.0216898657,
-0.0227306876,
0.0382443443,
-0.0287370309,
0.0477565974,
0.0179619398,
0.0403406397,
-0.0742673799,
0.0130359,
0.0343015939,
-0.0122874547,
0.0362015851,
0.0330184586,
0.008115897,
0.0047778846,
0.011734914,
-0.0103093078,
0.0259352382,
-0.0615225956,
0.0158346314,
-0.0089856954,
-0.0289393477,
0.0341267921,
-0.0172022842,
0.0452788025,
0.0373553485,
-0.0399186984,
-0.0184400603,
0.0268863775,
-0.0281490777,
-0.0034119072,
-0.0009683008,
0.0307557601,
0.0309951492,
-0.0241512917,
-0.0534933731,
0.0155337257,
0.0370052755,
0.0563671067,
-0.0681076422,
-0.0042867307,
-0.0000958745,
-0.0062745097,
0.0013336819,
0.0252142083,
0.0297577512,
0.0356377997,
0.0142518738,
0.1052715033,
0.0099280775,
-0.0031601433,
0.0500694253,
0.0246756822,
-0.0268686991,
-0.0183282811,
0.0196933523,
0.0393604524,
-0.0019087848,
0.0407828018,
-0.0074224737,
0.0437103212,
0.0513903834,
-0.0036062822,
0.0264047943,
0.0241659582,
-0.0233888105,
0.0547339655,
-0.0245115813,
0.0554263592,
-0.0041176542,
0.011339833,
0.0188088175,
-0.0014867098,
-0.007174226,
-0.0322831422,
-0.0056131608,
0.0104671111,
0.020625066,
0.0228919182,
-0.08658088,
0.010349635,
-0.0070685004,
0.0337166749,
0.0248101614,
0.0181480646,
-0.0095112259,
-0.0294549987,
-0.0618333071,
0.0247066319,
-0.0213298295,
0.0616161563,
0.0265971217,
-0.102803342,
0.0015978613,
0.0007984291,
-0.0060337628,
-0.0046205167,
0.0018110109,
0.0537708849,
0.0047830488,
-0.0417898707,
-0.0154918758,
-0.045704402,
-0.0319288522,
-0.0524676964,
-0.0186592024,
-0.0667907372,
0.0000822193,
0.0199197214,
0.0393868424,
-0.0434331186,
0.019799225,
0.0262923166,
0.0135160871,
0.0681402981,
-0.024809381,
0.0183325317,
0.0243813358,
0.0236480851,
-0.0273322221,
0.0391070582,
0.0370878316,
0.0109419823,
0.0764421597,
0.0215431396,
0.0395206921,
0.002958267,
0.0129409507,
-0.0009943158,
0.044281248,
0.0261977464,
-0.0197279956,
-0.0086272098,
-0.0020738014,
0.0573045053,
-0.0215343498,
-0.0457490049,
0.1397877783,
0.0493742712,
-0.0363017656,
-0.0091135576,
0.0061877626,
-0.0441408232,
0.0673447698,
0.0040162345,
-0.0312609449,
0.0330081619,
-0.0643761232,
0.0073892456,
0.0471858419,
0.0207609236,
-0.0128040072,
-0.0684412271,
-0.0149942264,
-0.029688105,
-0.0317608118,
0.0535076633,
0.0096934317,
-0.0132630887,
-0.0068279277,
-0.0213284008,
-0.0139730228,
-0.0479706787,
0.0076467372,
-0.047242865,
0.0464760512,
-0.0099718031,
0.0164333526,
0.006135582,
-0.0013257128,
-0.0176712517,
-0.0301669464,
0.0300067719,
0.0329646207,
-0.0124975638,
0.0001572193,
-0.0365715027,
0.0010944305,
-0.0151910465,
0.0191441495,
0.0002490645,
0.0495155416,
0.0734511837,
0.0036195265,
-0.05588663,
-0.0040286873,
0.0004215549,
-0.0013466902,
-0.0203436967,
-0.0000796,
-0.032636296,
0.049794782,
0.0174221955,
-0.0001903578,
0.0350471959,
0.0142606394,
0.0174921267,
-0.0593913868,
-0.0133037837,
-0.0504487231,
-0.0166154746,
0.0477143265,
-0.0348010808,
-0.022910485,
0.030351432,
-0.0220891684,
-0.0136790592,
-0.0302679557,
-0.0257699862,
0.0161020495,
-0.0563088283,
0.0234515183,
-0.0060220398,
0.025586348,
-0.0478560179,
0.0387545824,
-0.0056430544,
0.0365473479,
-0.0029447374,
-0.0128095811,
0.0344972126,
-0.0266969986,
-0.0444404222,
0.0018126831,
0.0113668106,
0.0136103742,
0.0339853391,
-0.0034583611,
-0.0695253909,
-0.0172319282,
-0.0551948361,
-0.0070525017,
-0.0080952514,
0.0336946845,
0.0213772953,
-0.0275958572,
-0.0100264959,
-0.0131116798,
-0.0881930441,
0.0005222962,
-0.002220344,
0.0386126228,
0.0331981182,
0.0139105916,
0.0077565406,
-0.0456416383,
-0.0019741091,
-0.017697731,
0.0234660152,
0.0296202637,
0.0066431984,
-0.0489235893,
0.0443303362,
-0.0490477011,
-0.0175979827,
0.0034473166,
-0.0513365865,
-0.0025774678,
0.0155487964,
-0.0403865688,
0.0658139586,
0.0020043002,
-0.0256550014,
0.0342036597,
-0.0040570097,
-0.0375417359,
-0.0179655124,
-0.0133407461,
-0.0839581117,
-0.0239770729,
-0.0421683304,
0.0407959595,
0.0503842942,
0.0136969946,
-0.0220057331,
-0.0351880491,
0.0187466759,
-0.0453167446,
-0.030796472,
0.0053246063,
-0.0249784309,
0.0033453293,
0.0784135833,
-0.006733912,
-0.0529424958,
0.0882072672,
-0.0493439138,
0.008668947,
-0.0169383604,
-0.00550556,
-0.0415119492,
0.0174618214,
0.0097384984,
0.0018337332,
0.0101865754,
-0.0089202961,
-0.0259159263,
-0.0450208895,
0.0096129635,
-0.068735756,
0.0134244747,
-0.0595591106,
-0.0070308922,
0.0267618839,
-0.0567261614,
-0.0204387922,
-0.0073492764,
-0.0492846668,
-0.0234050099,
-0.0104000736,
-0.073174648,
0.0062875082,
-0.0290436074,
0.025139533,
0.0086186966,
-0.0654928088,
-0.0312916934,
0.011934069,
0.043783173,
0.0980779603,
0.0020612916,
0.0387993902,
-0.0383488312,
0.0131121008,
0.0811039135,
0.0159400105,
0.0364369191,
-0.0093583455,
-0.0447269715,
0.0526391082,
-0.0084217386,
-0.0279762056,
0.0356099345,
0.0627491102,
-0.0026317015,
-0.0110319806,
0.116081953,
0.02244596,
-0.0511578433,
-0.0226542111,
-0.0369326174,
0.0243936442,
0.0272818804,
0.0146010546,
-0.070187293,
-0.0323505104,
-0.0131840119,
0.0458314978,
-0.043879848,
-0.0266310945,
0.0130204754,
-0.1080056578,
0.0092603564,
-0.0173153244,
-0.0328452736,
-0.0343069881,
-0.0517226458,
0.0420615636,
0.0109760147,
0.0351734497,
-0.0036402987,
0.0095123574,
0.0302326679,
0.0153039256,
-0.0615536757,
-0.035726022,
0.0267222524,
-0.0059722876,
0.0427946039,
0.0379321314,
0.0342155099,
-0.0136521803,
-0.0410683192,
-0.019131599,
-0.0354362652,
-0.0134019274,
-0.0217819661,
0.0424578227,
-0.0144067472,
0.0048123808,
-0.0055253026,
0.0507521816,
-0.0300525576,
0.0261367671,
0.0319335014,
0.0534720346,
-0.0000999851,
-0.0138798812,
-0.0191610083,
-0.0047491938,
0.0019045179,
0.0408950001,
0.0298212189,
-0.0092266137,
0.0123737305,
-0.0491946414,
-0.0104826074,
-0.0121364119,
-0.0374724716,
0.0516738445,
0.0515247434,
0.0066827652,
-0.0586289838,
-0.0385973565,
0.0340494588,
-0.0110492827,
-0.0043672663,
0.0194878727,
0.0189781021,
0.0107051395,
-0.0325711407,
0.0025012803,
-0.070994392,
0.0367159881,
-0.0509756841,
0.0562628061,
0.0559011847,
0.0134768588,
-0.0064994097,
0.0295859799,
-0.0449887253,
-0.0805264264,
-0.0110348025,
0.0526723266,
0.0256215669,
-0.0406406,
-0.0027197259,
-0.0941699147,
0.0727800429,
-0.0091530345,
-0.021236876,
0.0069457479,
0.0182284378,
0.0297657438,
0.007319232,
0.0366100259,
-0.0260739401,
-0.0293792486,
0.0081288386,
0.0134619707,
-0.0264304522,
-0.0708955079,
0.0398792736,
0.002833457,
0.0379133523,
0.0212436747,
0.0234419033,
-0.000530687,
0.0374494083,
-0.0213390347,
0.0001429081,
0.009076721,
0.0052326391,
0.0447805785,
-0.0487853959,
-0.0201144218,
-0.0595660172,
-0.0423411913,
0.0346594378,
-0.0342672542,
-0.0018676047,
0.0458942577,
0.0191352386,
0.0106607033,
-0.0292268358,
-0.0190168321,
-0.0279342905,
0.0259196423,
0.0547196567,
0.055543039,
0.0476437621,
0.002240513,
-0.0303446781,
0.0399784856,
-0.0067440304,
-0.0906324536,
-0.048022449,
-0.0071566962,
0.031450022,
0.0072000772,
0.015285206,
0.0314819068,
-0.0477947257,
-0.0119702052,
-0.0171762742,
-0.0206253082,
0.0205380451,
-0.0257461835,
0.0939873606,
0.0056911302,
-0.0100112613,
0.0219805166,
0.0713174865,
0.0006511919,
0.0458872132,
-0.043781545,
-0.0581006445,
-0.0168154109,
-0.0145232407,
0.0266485866,
0.021990288,
-0.0116151413,
-0.0123855127,
-0.0425225496,
-0.0660176203,
0.0061924472,
0.0089075863,
-0.015633788,
-0.0129329488,
-0.0203697942,
0.0633095503,
0.0092094094,
-0.026877474,
-0.0567681082,
-0.0057251793,
-0.0200815629,
0.0121866055,
-0.0334197432,
-6.368586682e-33,
-0.0083090737,
-0.0797929689,
-0.0420807451,
0.0082927262,
0.0305381827,
0.0245467834,
-0.0083172722,
0.0354344249,
-0.0427241102,
0.057229396,
-0.0474784635,
0.027931178,
0.0212274641,
0.0160558987,
0.0162551831,
-0.0018267496,
0.0067572384,
-0.0055981586,
-0.0359148234,
0.0013117682,
0.0074354596,
-0.0187003836,
0.0778897479,
-0.1023549512,
0.0879441425,
0.0149022918,
-0.0195882004,
0.0288992245,
-0.03461935,
0.0563915186,
0.0051158112,
0.0671482608,
0.0173484441,
-0.030472517,
0.029097259,
0.0057140365,
-0.0253587924,
-0.0596196838,
0.0260013882,
0.0036937946,
-0.0457425304,
-0.0429860093,
-0.0081955437,
-0.0210411921,
-0.0177508499,
-0.0021185633,
0.0245561786,
-0.0421259776,
0.0064381449,
-0.0539496429,
-0.0065729897,
0.0209065117,
0.0105526466,
0.0309754964,
-0.0530276522,
0.0711552352,
0.0150172235,
-0.0021055166,
-0.0356412567,
0.0463216491,
0.0031773243,
0.053763058,
0.0606033728,
-0.0162152499,
-0.0163961854,
0.0315631628,
-0.0287537314,
-0.0275589488,
0.0183300599,
-0.0242959931,
-0.0179443359,
-0.0320578665,
0.0616552867,
0.0922334269,
0.0104740607,
0.0220333021,
-0.0660689846,
0.0266628582,
0.0502004288,
0.029873522,
0.0517160483,
-0.0028156936,
-0.0842796639,
-0.0042139939,
-0.0760103688,
0.004587736,
-0.0279393811,
-0.0348045155,
0.0243778117,
0.0097621717,
-0.0134138903,
0.0124451444,
-0.0101924688,
-0.0138304401,
-0.064013198,
0.0088544823,
0.0054228827,
0.0157691874,
0.0098933047,
0.0480632596,
-0.0120273791,
0.0486470424,
-0.0018643296,
-0.0024792636,
0.000447315,
0.0085016051,
0.0289711654,
0.0218861327,
-0.0847276002,
0.0046697729,
-0.0211619511,
-0.0027621908,
0.0199796669,
-0.013553177,
0.0098910835,
-0.0195882469,
-0.0263939314,
0.0240864754,
-0.0074115098,
0.0183648411,
-0.038516432,
-0.0189734604,
-0.0210457761,
-0.0070567504,
-0.0490325242,
-0.0344640799,
-0.0009009546,
-0.0106450142,
-0.0138954623,
-0.0319164917,
-0.0052609756,
-0.001508439,
2.612e-7,
0.0495674722,
0.0129440632,
-0.0299268421,
0.0347622372,
0.010371929,
0.0328393802,
0.0114464732,
-0.0169916898,
0.0649129003,
-0.0565870181,
-0.0176164918,
0.0218261611,
0.0248959064,
0.0576189682,
-0.0566544011,
-0.0402562879,
-0.0156891197,
-0.0019597681,
-0.0218049567,
-0.0301739052,
0.0674213767,
0.0927423164,
0.0119213751,
-0.0158921108,
-0.0250509214,
-0.0639470816,
0.0520149581,
0.0056962427,
-0.0348658189,
0.0424019508,
0.0855754241,
0.0238575526,
0.0064549223,
0.0267292466,
-0.0095311515,
-0.0175872128,
-0.0197734572,
0.0336389542,
0.0115931695,
-0.0407736376,
-0.0034684979,
-0.0056793066,
0.030115461,
-0.084176302,
0.0523568317,
-0.0287433583,
-0.0400522202,
-0.022082489,
0.0048293276,
-0.065160431,
0.0800297335,
-0.0404136702,
-0.0149903838,
0.0112516899,
-0.0051141176,
0.0333973058,
-0.02512688,
-0.0312469266,
-0.0237035137,
-0.0531399734,
0.0059824302,
-0.063784577,
-0.0225209426,
-0.0125990929,
-0.0323138759,
-0.079708524,
0.0416358784,
2.152246356e-34,
0.0278291907,
0.000477055,
0.044260703,
0.029331835,
0.0479117371,
0.0139281172,
0.0223293323,
0.0157945585,
0.0403759629,
-0.0610559992,
-0.018523613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08849v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08849v2 | OFA: A Framework of Initializing Unseen Subword Embeddings for Efficient Large-scale Multilingual Continued Pretraining | 2023-11-15T10:40:45 | 2024-03-25T15:49:53 | Yihong Liu, Peiqin Lin, Mingyang Wang, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instead of pretraining multilingual language models from scratch, a more
efficient method is to adapt existing pretrained language models (PLMs) to new
languages via vocabulary extension and continued pretraining. However, this
method usually randomly initializes the embeddings of new subwords and
introduces substantially more embedding parameters to the model, thus weakening
the efficiency. To address these issues, we propose a novel framework:
$\textbf{O}$ne $\textbf{F}$or $\textbf{A}$ll ($\textbf{OFA}$), which wisely
initializes the embeddings of unseen subwords and thus can adapt a PLM to
multiple languages efficiently and effectively. OFA takes advantage of external
well-aligned multilingual static word vectors and injects the alignment
knowledge into the subword embeddings. In addition, OFA applies matrix
factorization and replaces the cumbersome embeddings with two lower-dimensional
matrices, which largely reduces the number of parameters. We show OFA
accelerates the convergence of continued pretraining, which is environmentally
friendly as much fewer carbon footprints are generated. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate OFA can achieve competitive or better performance
than default continued pretraining baselines on a wide range of crosslingual
downstream tasks. We make our code and models publicly available. | [
0.01107796,
0.0755420476,
0.0360622592,
0.0527421311,
-0.0021191603,
0.038427677,
-0.0019878868,
-0.0006502442,
-0.0108616874,
-0.0277526099,
-0.0541724935,
-0.0526919141,
-0.0090931375,
-0.0211350173,
0.0406962633,
-0.03675377,
0.0742243603,
-0.0295735784,
-0.0677526891,
-0.0277546197,
0.0053452202,
0.0019156078,
0.0232984275,
-0.012517876,
-0.0280476287,
-0.0191181134,
-0.0032214932,
-0.0137906801,
0.0144791715,
-0.0056355665,
-0.0079813274,
0.0222956277,
0.0521349981,
0.0436905101,
0.0000019909,
-0.0191099346,
-0.0308008324,
-0.0139211006,
0.0107908333,
0.0521592945,
0.053912621,
-0.0205780454,
0.0007713758,
0.025188325,
-0.0218381248,
-0.0443265438,
0.0782434866,
-0.0256860964,
0.032133054,
0.0536171272,
-0.0197888445,
-0.0278288368,
0.0251787845,
-0.0464128517,
-0.0600091927,
-0.0358548835,
0.0265718289,
-0.0039389906,
-0.0418868288,
0.0039133914,
-0.0377923027,
0.0304462481,
0.0018504291,
0.0370738544,
-0.0075301533,
0.0183697604,
0.0167976506,
-0.0441953056,
-0.0298492927,
0.0841765404,
-0.0768375769,
-0.0209359489,
-0.0241649076,
-0.0277235471,
-0.0228589457,
-0.0353778899,
-0.0235745627,
0.0175465681,
0.0525982231,
0.0303357188,
0.0448915772,
0.0090325568,
0.0489847325,
0.0227703303,
-0.053238079,
0.0339177661,
0.0571953915,
-0.0482834093,
0.010138629,
-0.0012504412,
-0.0185048822,
-0.0245744288,
-0.0062747826,
-0.013320717,
0.0027485501,
0.0524567291,
-0.0620761216,
-0.0318032764,
0.0130344816,
-0.0294359718,
0.0656823143,
0.0515683182,
0.003599084,
0.0453788787,
-0.0163929034,
0.0173571464,
-0.0362076461,
0.0134466197,
-0.0573201142,
-0.0112729697,
-0.0041961865,
0.0095560281,
-0.0560612194,
0.0109114936,
-0.0096615674,
-0.0269958656,
-0.0123712616,
0.042205587,
0.0215567108,
-0.0136566944,
-0.0073805433,
-0.030540267,
-0.0099932076,
-0.0092326924,
0.0404837653,
0.0529769771,
-0.0257947091,
-0.0104201818,
-0.0402464271,
-0.0517010577,
-0.0197974369,
0.0189618506,
0.0142253712,
-0.023907423,
0.0322859623,
0.0506136678,
-0.0344001353,
-0.0788820386,
-0.0322101414,
0.0219198316,
0.0130386716,
-0.0541438945,
-0.013697857,
-0.0467238501,
0.0581824668,
-0.0130913714,
0.0257556643,
-0.0507791787,
-0.0037395149,
-0.0002375795,
-0.065326713,
0.0736237392,
-0.0537130125,
0.0143502895,
-0.0466549136,
-0.0197335109,
0.028667083,
0.0977338627,
0.0340418704,
-0.0202904381,
0.0718044341,
-0.0071944976,
-0.0593740009,
0.0774143934,
0.0347908363,
0.0412843153,
-0.0114918081,
-0.01414249,
0.0430855788,
0.0218567289,
0.0301304739,
0.0130298547,
-0.0268376004,
0.0399786569,
0.0160715114,
0.0555492677,
0.0050475979,
0.0596519336,
0.0515612103,
-0.0150286788,
-0.0237615742,
0.0203053243,
0.003050715,
-0.013510461,
-0.0190625601,
-0.0121206548,
0.0407193266,
0.0675819293,
-0.03766004,
-0.0145012056,
-0.0023562394,
-0.0287354253,
0.0249571931,
0.0040656743,
0.0575549901,
-0.0082455715,
-0.0650801957,
0.0602392778,
0.061794389,
-0.084635742,
0.0031632846,
0.0095210643,
-0.0078822067,
0.0394358784,
0.0296211019,
-0.0229452755,
-0.0309432056,
0.0040333415,
0.0547880754,
0.0129335336,
0.0749287754,
-0.0074046683,
0.0373559147,
-0.0967226028,
-0.0326577537,
0.0042292364,
-0.0116571235,
0.0479522236,
0.0254187733,
0.0217809193,
0.012229396,
-0.0234856792,
-0.0252855979,
0.0508015081,
-0.0666904002,
0.007992438,
-0.0064620501,
0.0259996131,
0.0151882563,
0.0277777985,
-0.024189543,
-0.0051641236,
0.0288587809,
-0.0395863727,
-0.0011769643,
0.0012340039,
-0.0342846364,
-0.0046252678,
0.0686610937,
0.038853541,
-0.0246396866,
0.0268683713,
-0.0292939637,
-0.0293808058,
-0.0075847823,
0.0246204641,
0.0841394663,
-0.0545082986,
0.0198282227,
-0.0340858027,
0.0464882851,
-0.001550202,
0.0267951265,
-0.0191962197,
0.0384014845,
0.0170792937,
-0.0333511159,
0.0208828002,
-0.0433921404,
-0.0467289388,
0.0239225347,
0.0011553157,
0.0168407932,
0.0042029223,
0.0379903875,
-0.0075525693,
0.0049015982,
-0.0816590264,
0.0132983075,
-0.0435658991,
0.0154521111,
0.0033121996,
0.0276591033,
-0.0092006782,
-0.0111716464,
-0.0120419236,
0.0193714965,
-0.0148510104,
0.040042337,
-0.0083457269,
-0.0305979941,
-0.0058247265,
-0.0134597281,
-0.0225393008,
0.0267666876,
0.0628241524,
-0.0213288907,
-0.0288238637,
-0.0385530293,
0.0311825946,
-0.0599272214,
0.0222860575,
-0.0094300173,
-0.0367379002,
-0.0289677903,
0.0017552656,
0.047348775,
0.0226972122,
-0.0077494541,
-0.0257859938,
0.0520651788,
-0.0053128987,
-0.0423537083,
-0.0022549401,
0.0070099533,
-0.030020956,
-0.0171301086,
0.0033050494,
-0.0099375024,
0.0559207499,
-0.0411035568,
-0.0294874199,
-0.0445434749,
-0.0218259636,
-0.0205226708,
-0.0174241643,
-0.0284587964,
-0.0226928443,
-0.0223624296,
0.0083119133,
-0.0111038275,
-0.0574759878,
0.0410149023,
-0.0406995825,
-0.0223304555,
-0.0686540827,
-0.0147546725,
-0.0066595897,
0.0129041476,
0.0047827568,
0.0451166332,
-0.0200271346,
0.0128551796,
-0.0291328728,
0.0030472684,
-0.0068362304,
-0.0052681882,
0.0306324102,
-0.0073940111,
0.0074709114,
-0.0096071744,
-0.0328914188,
-0.0342979804,
-0.0781605318,
-0.0224906188,
0.0041096928,
-0.0040110359,
-0.0231845789,
-0.0163798984,
0.0277195089,
0.0198010132,
0.0392967016,
0.0262574516,
0.036675293,
-0.0132507756,
0.0213268083,
0.019930819,
0.0028469218,
0.0186954886,
-0.0381393842,
-0.0145602655,
0.0065702745,
0.0500725992,
-0.0760924071,
-0.0136945788,
0.0054520899,
0.0546412095,
-0.000505329,
-0.0314876251,
-0.0191306453,
-0.0038385212,
0.0200069007,
0.0157954898,
0.0773390457,
0.0215314105,
-0.0615399666,
0.0085657118,
0.0059514111,
0.0487194099,
0.018397605,
0.0180387963,
-0.0956780687,
-0.0305227581,
0.0167610142,
-0.0139881205,
0.0767446607,
-0.0178244468,
-0.0443754792,
-0.1003864408,
0.0029566018,
0.0387950577,
-0.020267183,
-0.0094129583,
-0.0372862741,
-0.0243929625,
-0.0010738663,
-0.0141050126,
-0.0074179755,
-0.0094565405,
-0.0218767282,
0.005218856,
-0.0285611246,
-0.0543018319,
0.016928019,
-0.0321360081,
0.0285643078,
0.0469053015,
0.0139230471,
-0.0061059971,
-0.0539929532,
0.0563642867,
-0.0395423844,
-0.0368351117,
-0.0235565249,
0.0009018987,
-0.031896662,
-0.0288673192,
0.0410878696,
-0.0047670733,
-0.0363498405,
-0.0117347371,
-0.017060712,
0.0863693357,
0.049533952,
0.0115352152,
0.0345996693,
-0.0287253521,
0.0162194353,
0.0650514439,
0.0161847286,
-0.0433432721,
-0.0067214621,
0.0113157909,
0.0101446696,
-0.017336145,
0.0174039192,
-0.0088042738,
-0.0572488233,
-0.008193641,
-0.0387311429,
-0.0204276796,
0.0132192699,
0.0587783232,
0.0089989118,
0.0061066495,
-0.0218431409,
-0.0114370827,
-0.0563038848,
0.0467173494,
-0.0362471305,
0.0279921331,
-0.054334987,
-0.0114473235,
0.0325680561,
0.017505521,
-0.001099673,
0.0088753793,
-0.0509385802,
-0.0623889193,
-0.0104125803,
0.0492522381,
0.0084256483,
0.0487021022,
0.0218032375,
-0.0386189111,
0.0581282638,
-0.0332270972,
-0.0154201807,
0.0376713462,
0.058599744,
-0.0088533694,
0.0179191567,
0.0618055575,
-0.0218281616,
-0.0199707896,
0.0022838691,
0.0799595788,
0.0045671742,
-0.0100519815,
-0.0173614211,
-0.0045703608,
0.0205225423,
-0.0726318136,
-0.0051136008,
-0.0766202584,
0.0367708281,
-0.020119356,
-0.021178415,
-0.0591648072,
-0.0042513511,
0.0404453538,
-0.0056516831,
0.0023375747,
0.0438700132,
-0.020402493,
0.0121041732,
0.0146556273,
0.0261170939,
-0.0062201102,
-0.0165649559,
0.0321680866,
0.0390027277,
-0.0105001973,
-0.0153056467,
-0.0294581242,
-0.0166878141,
-0.0843335018,
0.0032558488,
-0.006663972,
0.014017852,
-0.0729220212,
0.0450567864,
-0.000206064,
-0.0116229784,
-0.0052780705,
0.0510441139,
0.0781548619,
-0.0219348278,
0.0793526992,
-0.0182937086,
-0.0447582975,
-0.0075546568,
0.0128693087,
-0.0590089858,
-0.0510841832,
0.0490436479,
0.0009241368,
-0.0633237362,
0.0384959243,
0.0894318968,
0.0051164366,
0.0194837302,
-0.0121056102,
0.0210629404,
-0.0252534281,
-0.0069949236,
0.0353522673,
0.0577681214,
-0.0415405184,
0.0253981836,
-0.0353858769,
-0.0814618096,
-0.000419864,
0.0011171235,
-0.0639324486,
0.0405054428,
0.0324911475,
0.0654126853,
-0.0319821313,
0.0323568061,
-0.0192847494,
-0.0060075601,
0.0164444223,
-0.0664135218,
0.023649035,
-6.161062705e-33,
-0.0008022079,
0.0227638315,
0.0054761777,
-0.0078523764,
-0.0329585597,
0.0375121757,
-0.0145034818,
0.0139318015,
-0.027502019,
-0.0044804192,
-0.0194964278,
-0.0363090485,
0.0154920751,
0.0287670922,
-0.0055120117,
0.0247437116,
0.0293378811,
-0.0183258522,
0.0069222669,
-0.0041695633,
0.0139830597,
0.0686186925,
0.0771440864,
-0.0007052754,
0.0016608459,
-0.0079920078,
0.0143821025,
0.0193535965,
0.0412855446,
0.0379379727,
-0.0547178574,
0.0266590305,
0.0145177785,
0.0077469996,
-0.030178545,
0.0177100524,
-0.0810676441,
-0.0261819847,
0.0335401148,
0.012890554,
-0.0565830283,
0.0044952407,
-0.0207531694,
-0.0192803554,
-0.0119884731,
0.0301939268,
-0.0043283277,
-0.0027660783,
-0.0542877801,
0.0225549564,
-0.0683474541,
0.016437538,
0.0161772016,
-0.0028670828,
0.0599739999,
0.0116253225,
0.0268639829,
0.0130517855,
-0.0634668022,
0.0297243241,
0.005275086,
0.0126816807,
0.0758235082,
0.020261297,
0.0303152483,
0.044720538,
0.0280838702,
-0.0312013347,
0.0327494852,
-0.0062411539,
0.0552111864,
-0.0268579666,
-0.0164127331,
0.0563886128,
0.0295159016,
-0.0251120441,
-0.0744942501,
-0.0163864829,
0.0184562728,
0.0135750519,
0.0075841481,
0.023470398,
0.0078347214,
-0.0417447053,
-0.0449546017,
-0.0112925507,
-0.0439186953,
-0.0376486816,
0.034599971,
0.0278258231,
-0.0249624606,
-0.02699586,
0.0564167909,
-0.0490346737,
-0.0271983612,
0.0593531728,
0.0028834012,
0.0090992842,
0.0042192657,
0.0650452226,
-0.0639572218,
-0.0344833322,
-0.0427438617,
-0.0339051001,
-0.0199803095,
-0.0173269939,
0.0503263623,
0.0585587919,
-0.0537975654,
0.0124820648,
-0.0291937999,
-0.0351077765,
0.0260820426,
0.0349532887,
0.0444254875,
0.0229662079,
0.0096655795,
0.0736663267,
0.0742915124,
-0.0052286843,
-0.0032111078,
-0.0545664802,
0.0240610931,
0.0574253388,
-0.0071668159,
0.0153877288,
-0.035086561,
0.0144756967,
0.0297939032,
-0.055467438,
-0.001197797,
0.0160180517,
2.655e-7,
0.05983226,
0.033042971,
0.0211317167,
-0.037746992,
-0.0036551284,
0.003565256,
-0.0405021049,
0.0156732127,
-0.0329626426,
0.0192386266,
0.0257148948,
0.0241237767,
0.0440844819,
-0.0004647003,
-0.0644098669,
0.0053158216,
-0.0542139672,
0.0223091505,
-0.0518273339,
-0.0374433324,
-0.0049183634,
0.1221705601,
0.0090365317,
-0.0121668084,
-0.0509370975,
-0.0410149768,
0.0869442672,
-0.0268003773,
-0.0401999429,
-0.0166018847,
-0.0077819838,
0.0504958704,
-0.0151328528,
-0.031689316,
-0.0406839065,
0.0681703165,
0.04004981,
0.0517443419,
-0.0101621747,
-0.0025815738,
0.0264103897,
-0.012881062,
-0.0438331477,
-0.0400256626,
0.067588836,
-0.0206935667,
-0.0035550061,
-0.038422592,
-0.0019160699,
0.0367467739,
0.0531233475,
-0.0331954584,
-0.0399430133,
0.0333328359,
0.0566717088,
0.0165851861,
-0.0599865131,
-0.0743954256,
-0.0030155051,
-0.0080866376,
-0.0298903119,
-0.0201474428,
-0.0207577422,
-0.0319969058,
0.0593724474,
0.0003925539,
0.0170674026,
2.468529412e-34,
0.0386162288,
-0.0203786362,
0.0335555002,
0.0042492705,
0.0112299826,
-0.0586720817,
0.0285026338,
0.004287547,
-0.0174853224,
-0.0830332711,
-0.0050045666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08844v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08844v1 | Violet: A Vision-Language Model for Arabic Image Captioning with Gemini Decoder | 2023-11-15T10:34:14 | 2023-11-15T10:34:14 | Abdelrahman Mohamed, Fakhraddin Alwajih, El Moatez Billah Nagoudi, Alcides Alcoba Inciarte, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Although image captioning has a vast array of applications, it has not
reached its full potential in languages other than English. Arabic, for
instance, although the native language of more than 400 million people, remains
largely underrepresented in this area. This is due to the lack of labeled data
and powerful Arabic generative models. We alleviate this issue by presenting a
novel vision-language model dedicated to Arabic, dubbed \textit{Violet}. Our
model is based on a vision encoder and a Gemini text decoder that maintains
generation fluency while allowing fusion between the vision and language
components. To train our model, we introduce a new method for automatically
acquiring data from available English datasets. We also manually prepare a new
dataset for evaluation. \textit{Violet} performs sizeably better than our
baselines on all of our evaluation datasets. For example, it reaches a CIDEr
score of $61.2$ on our manually annotated dataset and achieves an improvement
of $13$ points on Flickr8k. | [
0.0195176732,
0.0887225941,
0.0155249415,
0.0295958947,
0.0008717054,
0.0442707315,
-0.0068590855,
-0.0317297578,
-0.0317029692,
-0.0474642515,
-0.0212369878,
-0.0456464961,
0.0449760295,
0.0629174188,
0.0093926098,
-0.0914705768,
-0.0305638295,
-0.081170693,
-0.0223341323,
-0.0076565542,
0.0437098294,
0.0227672681,
-0.0152302925,
0.023453895,
-0.0104879607,
-0.008941005,
-0.0107981097,
0.0004838655,
0.0020561651,
0.0155094387,
-0.0358079113,
0.0744503662,
0.0388324559,
0.0147724655,
0.0000018435,
-0.0092321513,
0.004068872,
-0.0188059565,
0.0432356074,
-0.0288419481,
0.0801017135,
-0.1001429856,
-0.0380898826,
0.0111743975,
-0.0248891767,
-0.0091265729,
0.0902303904,
0.0246187169,
0.0616362989,
0.0284767319,
-0.0231259055,
-0.0484377779,
0.0016652327,
-0.0327889659,
-0.0045651635,
-0.0060380134,
-0.0071965437,
0.0529651828,
-0.0232941266,
-0.0013966272,
-0.0353844054,
0.064735353,
0.0131547442,
-0.0501967855,
-0.0143783549,
0.0274170544,
-0.0303460974,
-0.0428708345,
-0.0052275835,
0.056284491,
0.0103368089,
0.0048682615,
-0.0413180143,
0.0446508043,
-0.0156924073,
-0.031790249,
-0.0463402718,
0.0692233816,
0.0020407538,
0.0157412663,
0.0018434334,
0.030181231,
-0.0149583686,
-0.0124505637,
-0.0110054165,
-0.0361420102,
0.0313645862,
0.019760685,
-0.0404191017,
0.0350140557,
-0.0260968599,
-0.0474510789,
0.0148701454,
-0.0264089331,
0.0482127145,
-0.0150245605,
-0.0517880395,
-0.0362592675,
-0.0049632331,
-0.0501272269,
0.0069375159,
0.0444954038,
-0.0512561053,
0.0643117651,
-0.040054556,
0.0632827282,
0.0354006253,
0.0507195331,
-0.0621760599,
-0.0184636749,
-0.034228202,
-0.0044571073,
-0.0356160551,
0.0110745169,
-0.0681416392,
-0.0389439091,
-0.0636981577,
0.0070004561,
-0.0044702436,
0.0063811215,
0.0130178034,
0.0021900693,
-0.022308955,
0.0019259162,
-0.0246108286,
0.0039951284,
0.0326761939,
-0.0014844898,
-0.0360690467,
-0.0941291153,
-0.0012957385,
0.0412473828,
0.0236658826,
0.020523103,
-0.0233424176,
0.0737299472,
-0.034999162,
-0.0404883847,
-0.011731714,
0.0302157775,
-0.0437893569,
-0.0057419608,
-0.0241193213,
-0.0643790886,
0.0319204889,
0.0013380194,
-0.0003625446,
-0.0424110368,
0.0180437863,
0.029552931,
0.0404311754,
0.103373982,
-0.0365502983,
-0.0084176632,
0.0402193367,
0.0341832116,
0.0068584043,
0.0903671086,
0.0279384591,
0.0250257347,
0.0159680992,
0.0178378373,
0.0399330519,
0.0535575449,
-0.0276562385,
0.0072796023,
-0.0428472459,
-0.0372325443,
0.0077350209,
0.0092098489,
0.0540853329,
0.0580061525,
-0.0320320465,
0.021274792,
0.0682936162,
0.0237485692,
-0.0357301235,
0.0429357179,
0.0358343534,
0.0109520322,
0.0192932263,
-0.0186142921,
0.0064469092,
0.0494894236,
0.0265458543,
0.0272431467,
0.0105728703,
0.0559748895,
-0.0497546978,
-0.0562779419,
-0.0048726201,
-0.0339471363,
0.0248048063,
-0.0124590825,
0.0689655468,
0.0176612865,
-0.065903075,
-0.004256269,
0.0007125309,
-0.0429853871,
0.0165190548,
-0.0386431143,
-0.0470735505,
0.0836183056,
0.0463356748,
0.0420789979,
0.0045797215,
-0.0067891721,
0.0106432522,
0.0719126761,
0.0046823546,
-0.0016485241,
0.0135909505,
-0.0680988133,
-0.0625197366,
-0.0032558327,
-0.0079195853,
0.0338984802,
-0.0398292802,
0.024409106,
0.0317653716,
0.0252105054,
-0.0663089007,
0.0310483892,
0.0327554941,
-0.0172603112,
-0.0370358489,
0.0047628125,
-0.0074758907,
0.0060891574,
-0.0335135274,
0.0195698328,
-0.0088572437,
-0.0522068776,
-0.0079824561,
0.0659959316,
-0.0356690846,
-0.0591233782,
0.0354381539,
-0.0681218877,
0.0160157848,
0.0292219948,
-0.012773525,
-0.0602907948,
0.0527237095,
-0.0607831925,
-0.0118770786,
-0.0669146702,
0.0365618989,
0.0005808461,
0.0241354387,
0.0143177034,
0.0378266126,
-0.0280817095,
-0.0456012078,
0.0296205953,
-0.0432034396,
-0.0028701224,
-0.0241762064,
-0.0332860164,
0.0284591932,
0.0097057559,
0.0205342155,
0.0477319323,
0.023092024,
-0.0070125661,
-0.0155877471,
-0.0694661662,
-0.0388030708,
-0.0191460177,
-0.0140650598,
-0.000926381,
-0.0090232212,
0.0172151625,
-0.0318669081,
-0.0362675749,
-0.0055528358,
0.0248726681,
0.0028184007,
0.0365031399,
0.0024339263,
-0.0241552461,
-0.0338981822,
-0.0039178603,
0.0554881841,
0.0625254363,
0.0629821494,
-0.057698749,
-0.0104297409,
-0.0080277752,
0.0041924966,
0.0081594307,
0.0034523266,
-0.0311202947,
-0.0022047074,
-0.0021672545,
-0.0061653256,
0.0186336264,
0.0095455032,
0.013366418,
-0.001889935,
0.0068895863,
-0.0119614201,
-0.0114861391,
0.0048875897,
-0.0629154965,
0.0069492683,
-0.0595756844,
-0.0218737572,
0.0252554603,
-0.011266388,
0.0455283336,
-0.0835198313,
0.0261471663,
-0.0314232409,
-0.0286023784,
-0.0375219584,
0.0179718938,
0.0033442245,
0.0475377291,
-0.0387037694,
-0.067296572,
0.0176006816,
-0.0487915128,
-0.0339735299,
0.0042271828,
0.0281392671,
-0.0362404063,
0.0298196394,
0.0047452142,
0.0286398027,
-0.0124028111,
-0.02939119,
-0.0108563574,
-0.00423929,
0.0030432851,
-0.0293069333,
0.0620127991,
-0.0652453229,
0.0007666104,
-0.0324925669,
-0.020518871,
-0.0337689742,
0.0334229209,
-0.0568088591,
-0.0006616213,
0.021430444,
0.0045169014,
-0.0181908011,
0.0378315747,
0.012340378,
0.0446167141,
0.0077090352,
-0.0010303064,
-0.0096393898,
0.0064553181,
0.0486838669,
-0.0064650755,
-0.0411840826,
-0.0342394374,
0.0188781358,
0.0321713649,
-0.0243338887,
0.0172104333,
-0.0620254204,
0.0188579597,
0.058324255,
0.0293009132,
-0.0012673039,
-0.0326075554,
0.0127137816,
-0.0290455613,
-0.0059002209,
0.0942160711,
0.0091417301,
-0.042689655,
-0.0398873128,
0.0066115595,
0.0183225144,
0.0095842071,
-0.0217852835,
-0.1045248583,
-0.0411583632,
-0.0026873462,
-0.0005171861,
0.0343738981,
0.0561132915,
-0.0165355634,
-0.0810160413,
0.0260317735,
0.0229428485,
-0.006100683,
-0.0770019442,
0.0195349958,
-0.0447881483,
-0.028649658,
-0.0237694103,
-0.0192017239,
0.0064279526,
0.0222431626,
0.0448147282,
0.0369149521,
-0.0692432672,
-0.0200223196,
-0.0291422121,
-0.0052484716,
0.0744444132,
-0.0033817294,
-0.0104845222,
-0.0454205275,
-0.0367582068,
-0.0359989703,
-0.0151721137,
0.0053772978,
0.0682524145,
-0.0229410082,
-0.0292365104,
0.0064713946,
-0.0054549524,
-0.0471815243,
-0.0022920799,
-0.0126874875,
-0.0483315997,
0.0150285773,
0.0355449542,
-0.0033755875,
0.0297653452,
-0.0252430849,
0.0462548882,
0.009980659,
-0.0430386961,
-0.0244571194,
-0.0392133333,
-0.0073650558,
-0.1011750847,
-0.0368600711,
-0.0033278652,
0.0386217088,
-0.0438221358,
-0.0904020518,
-0.0154933594,
0.0466450751,
0.007999721,
0.0267399233,
0.0104248533,
-0.003861859,
0.0205710623,
-0.0403935462,
0.0059169382,
-0.0149939246,
-0.0071094418,
-0.0609165318,
-0.0332426727,
0.0315829143,
-0.0556833819,
0.0120405043,
0.0455999635,
-0.0606234148,
0.0002284538,
-0.0066510672,
0.0643999726,
0.0157749988,
0.0113064349,
-0.0002701418,
-0.0177401584,
0.0030696806,
0.011309945,
0.0544511527,
0.0161053557,
0.0169243198,
-0.0082186135,
-0.0312690027,
0.0269902218,
-0.0119024208,
0.0054060286,
-0.0109022073,
0.0067447657,
-0.0067108464,
-0.0212979987,
0.0204300266,
-0.0298702437,
0.0010193489,
-0.0527449287,
0.0028989012,
-0.0330214277,
-0.0112993708,
-0.0250478406,
0.015729472,
-0.060099218,
0.0272365715,
0.0416115336,
0.0491451174,
0.0037813226,
0.0092582665,
0.0054644071,
-0.0402099788,
0.0084379939,
0.0146125341,
0.0166880433,
-0.0230739247,
-0.0106597664,
0.0270905122,
-0.0071188952,
-0.0148568386,
-0.0279770363,
0.0083236797,
-0.0218711495,
0.0191318374,
-0.007093918,
-0.0072467267,
0.0401206948,
0.0665919632,
0.0253343154,
-0.0170099698,
-0.0498836711,
0.0833601803,
0.0796169564,
-0.001892797,
0.0570492595,
-0.0006873914,
0.0051159039,
-0.0060061407,
0.0485987701,
-0.0143995332,
-0.0538300276,
0.0273169149,
-0.0100504272,
0.0001132785,
-0.0128007326,
0.0707549229,
0.0070419568,
-0.0152551401,
0.0085312435,
-0.0212448835,
-0.0179206617,
0.0132141467,
-0.0067433165,
-0.0351966769,
-0.0392675549,
0.0518532097,
0.0005666986,
-0.0665942654,
0.0360853374,
0.0122687267,
0.0351716168,
0.0538796633,
0.0771751925,
0.0147199873,
-0.0097923158,
-0.0095227491,
-0.0309873521,
-0.0177112296,
-0.0374378748,
0.0051737777,
0.0140217338,
-5.281803583e-33,
-0.0393123627,
-0.0092742406,
0.0053623905,
-0.0089805927,
-0.0098164082,
0.0093410946,
-0.0299923383,
0.0232390482,
0.0081898486,
-0.0017299888,
0.0422911718,
-0.0167091992,
0.0308976062,
0.0746020898,
0.0319964364,
-0.0004357605,
0.0415967815,
0.0021425365,
0.0054295943,
0.0118667977,
0.0130720492,
0.0106342584,
0.0533273816,
-0.0100500183,
-0.0078413254,
-0.0228448063,
-0.0369594954,
-0.0029408613,
0.0703499839,
0.0766494945,
-0.0314055122,
0.0454865322,
-0.0075298012,
-0.011216837,
-0.0169102699,
0.0205147509,
-0.0655857399,
0.0216148272,
0.0094357189,
0.0825089067,
-0.0414851047,
-0.0256863106,
-0.0174122583,
-0.0395059288,
-0.0602375083,
0.006303383,
0.0496646054,
-0.0590309314,
0.0038488873,
-0.0133831408,
-0.0596983172,
0.0335255861,
-0.016373666,
-0.0350290164,
0.0787341967,
0.0523755811,
0.0271888394,
-0.0007759422,
-0.0448111296,
0.0281245057,
0.0261760894,
0.0292915739,
0.1179681346,
0.0519803166,
0.0000937912,
0.0455021933,
-0.013827757,
-0.0554952361,
0.0107867401,
0.0069048563,
0.012133603,
0.0133309104,
0.0340191051,
0.0520852692,
0.0127152391,
0.0047075301,
-0.0378283039,
0.0529032499,
-0.0889823586,
0.0425427482,
0.0191298705,
0.0020546783,
-0.0301959254,
0.0228111129,
-0.0247649606,
-0.0417894721,
-0.0370932184,
-0.0092566423,
0.0322210416,
0.0279628187,
-0.0283460543,
0.0437447689,
0.0437828526,
-0.021234123,
0.0268596131,
0.0118021788,
-0.0246050283,
0.0446600281,
-0.0128945848,
0.0203377828,
-0.016699668,
-0.033200562,
0.0539711118,
0.042426873,
0.0174326058,
0.0118182003,
0.0494140275,
0.024985509,
-0.0510856472,
0.0102742789,
-0.0389506109,
0.0382034034,
-0.0070564961,
0.0368230566,
0.003828916,
0.0051614228,
-0.0691588596,
0.012670259,
-0.0200446993,
0.0002369209,
-0.0157781206,
-0.0309573989,
0.0087867668,
0.0033951022,
-0.0269139819,
0.0490309261,
-0.0301024076,
-0.0246678609,
0.0020813805,
-0.0425625592,
-0.0417814516,
0.0357107855,
2.431e-7,
0.0246459115,
0.0039117085,
0.0540517792,
0.0089812437,
0.0159314219,
0.0246984418,
-0.0226744134,
0.0310810637,
0.0240844414,
-0.0051154187,
0.0068690269,
0.0071860594,
0.0565495864,
-0.037024457,
-0.0668985248,
0.018782841,
0.0111959204,
0.0145516582,
-0.0099939732,
-0.0095941424,
0.06644959,
0.1143958643,
-0.0798427463,
-0.0162309669,
-0.0001348469,
-0.0729484558,
0.1060176641,
-0.0165176224,
-0.0024070335,
0.0069255112,
0.0131939743,
0.0259231422,
-0.0403397121,
0.0036938819,
-0.0360626243,
-0.028491186,
0.0806151256,
0.0536380783,
-0.0165459812,
-0.0008492187,
-0.0128044114,
0.0524880365,
-0.0374447368,
-0.0208276864,
0.0420498215,
-0.0168981664,
-0.0198958609,
0.0068172226,
-0.0316660143,
0.0304936897,
0.0325634852,
-0.0421064757,
-0.0480144434,
0.0342472307,
0.0807593837,
-0.0094312225,
-0.0295260753,
-0.0310631599,
0.0053979508,
-0.0531534664,
-0.0017591529,
-0.0088288281,
-0.0448469743,
-0.0231334884,
0.0102099171,
0.0184980556,
0.0147997113,
1.683758708e-34,
0.0429242663,
-0.0068393205,
-0.0024429522,
-0.0012283948,
0.0163702164,
-0.0220769085,
-0.0109710526,
-0.0070136427,
0.0059892479,
-0.0373243578,
-0.0234577507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10766v1 | Value FULCRA: Mapping Large Language Models to the Multidimensional Spectrum of Basic Human Values | 2023-11-15T10:29:28 | 2023-11-15T10:29:28 | Jing Yao, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xiting Wang, Yifan Gong, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has attracted much
attention to value alignment for their responsible development. However, how to
define values in this context remains a largely unexplored question. Existing
work mainly follows the Helpful, Honest, Harmless principle and specifies
values as risk criteria formulated in the AI community, e.g., fairness and
privacy protection, suffering from poor clarity, adaptability and transparency.
Inspired by basic values in humanity and social science across cultures, this
work proposes a novel basic value alignment paradigm and introduces a value
space spanned by basic value dimensions. All LLMs' behaviors can be mapped into
the space by identifying the underlying values, possessing the potential to
address the three challenges. To foster future research, we apply the
representative Schwartz's Theory of Basic Values as an initialized example and
construct FULCRA, a dataset consisting of 5k (LLM output, value vector) pairs.
Our extensive analysis of FULCRA reveals the underlying relation between basic
values and LLMs' behaviors, demonstrating that our approach not only covers
existing mainstream risks but also anticipates possibly unidentified ones.
Additionally, we present an initial implementation of the basic value
evaluation and alignment, paving the way for future research in this line. | [
0.0010137841,
0.0906596705,
-0.0378060453,
0.0181486085,
-0.049947679,
-0.0001227389,
-0.0276307948,
-0.0356812328,
-0.0293661803,
0.0191241931,
0.0025644233,
-0.035898827,
0.0006951447,
0.05906488,
-0.0247414727,
-0.0523751825,
0.0741527379,
0.0177586526,
0.0559842251,
-0.0196992271,
0.0242588166,
0.0123065487,
0.0257636681,
0.0321536809,
-0.0238524172,
0.02133343,
0.0050151604,
-0.0139275398,
0.0951587111,
-0.0123476377,
-0.0119621251,
0.0264603421,
0.0108565362,
0.0153759578,
0.0000021011,
-0.0870985985,
-0.015413926,
0.0150250122,
0.0105564455,
-0.0135718221,
0.0680134594,
-0.0072092442,
-0.0324242152,
-0.0019309297,
-0.0511767715,
0.0293167997,
0.0480823703,
0.0124943675,
0.0341743119,
0.0495822169,
-0.0139756436,
-0.0265559126,
0.0346250311,
-0.0014729701,
-0.0061890786,
-0.0658251941,
0.0330461413,
0.0491713695,
-0.0493818372,
0.0264849868,
0.0090094469,
0.0307751931,
-0.0002977023,
-0.0150652314,
0.0109338453,
-0.0123406323,
-0.0370939709,
-0.0737615898,
0.0068914518,
0.0649092272,
0.0259120837,
-0.0203322694,
0.013165025,
-0.015374653,
0.0186333843,
-0.0392027535,
0.0223078076,
0.050784301,
-0.0030606026,
0.0347568616,
0.0784433559,
0.0185810961,
0.0145226046,
0.0417356826,
0.0016258056,
0.0568977185,
-0.0015902646,
-0.0102170883,
-0.0353024602,
-0.0323538817,
-0.0375295207,
-0.0627498999,
0.0155710615,
0.0366068967,
-0.0081834774,
0.0104192924,
-0.0571958981,
-0.0083198454,
0.0549103208,
-0.0780432373,
0.0087590106,
0.0409868471,
0.010000092,
0.0350916721,
0.0460562818,
0.0490876362,
-0.0014561439,
0.026263658,
-0.0429312214,
-0.0092278542,
0.0154393502,
-0.0003088609,
0.0254062396,
0.016499158,
-0.000904181,
0.0425963886,
-0.024151627,
0.0469764546,
-0.063710697,
0.0563695654,
-0.0492551476,
-0.0267852116,
0.0300486591,
-0.0043358123,
-0.0253659394,
0.0341140851,
-0.041073449,
0.0122433081,
-0.0315613039,
-0.0499054678,
0.0349348411,
-0.0206547156,
-0.0191211868,
-0.0296961293,
0.027041465,
0.0544683747,
0.0586713552,
-0.0033571643,
0.0054826643,
-0.0223327167,
0.0280536097,
-0.0430119932,
-0.0256028548,
-0.0509371124,
0.0149825672,
0.0022335125,
-0.0221021138,
-0.0651426539,
-0.0017601516,
0.0250981785,
-0.0253068916,
0.0414232053,
0.0149301523,
0.0289268773,
0.0097180931,
0.000236869,
0.0379612297,
0.0239589494,
0.0292036179,
0.0228479672,
0.0641923249,
-0.0419429354,
-0.0203992762,
0.0104264179,
-0.0076657357,
0.01225824,
-0.0931934342,
0.0406796597,
0.0163494013,
0.0255153477,
0.0048288503,
0.0526280552,
-0.0032924043,
-0.016062187,
0.0930758938,
0.0465942025,
-0.0422277115,
0.017111985,
-0.0171923377,
-0.0079592969,
0.0023194228,
-0.0596002825,
-0.063886553,
0.0125644477,
-0.0365693048,
-0.0071610259,
-0.0532508977,
0.0751886219,
-0.0117858453,
-0.0479096025,
-0.0202526134,
-0.0067653973,
0.061933212,
0.0328947343,
-0.0034415361,
-0.0429468602,
0.016926419,
-0.0407270715,
0.0041880151,
-0.0844323933,
0.004823138,
-0.0387505889,
0.0558078513,
0.078240566,
0.0309958402,
-0.0167815574,
-0.002876285,
-0.005294641,
-0.0374494083,
-0.0030026818,
0.0524508469,
-0.0291495267,
-0.0119838212,
-0.0482055433,
-0.0372355618,
0.0219577048,
-0.0050377315,
0.0038442982,
-0.0197397526,
0.0035595766,
-0.0283423122,
-0.050910335,
-0.049660109,
0.0123017421,
-0.0090851076,
0.0165735576,
-0.0433952622,
0.0277745388,
0.0220448654,
0.0277235862,
-0.0088241519,
0.0141698197,
0.0081775077,
0.0051461826,
-0.0006262409,
0.0151680205,
-0.0172878895,
0.069722712,
0.043221958,
-0.0554059036,
-0.0115199788,
0.066089496,
-0.0153851248,
0.031916678,
-0.0085258679,
0.0117397066,
-0.0455572866,
-0.0388321579,
0.0362663604,
-0.0567859076,
0.0188799091,
-0.0487337075,
0.055141259,
-0.0390563458,
-0.0334860906,
-0.0611886196,
-0.0313307643,
0.0543631129,
-0.0314350575,
-0.0372424275,
0.0002392961,
-0.0204542782,
0.0799003914,
0.0713379085,
0.0232332274,
-0.0020455895,
0.0046367873,
-0.0309200622,
-0.0198080782,
0.0138875255,
0.0076312604,
0.0199048314,
0.0140958223,
-0.0045660217,
0.0326361284,
-0.0493693203,
0.0124540702,
0.0232313238,
0.0259408895,
0.050870467,
-0.0232600495,
-0.036545366,
-0.0119601525,
-0.0101394448,
-0.0400957949,
-0.0152705777,
-0.0044468055,
0.0237694439,
-0.0170975644,
-0.0060803625,
-0.0557949729,
-0.0013325514,
-0.005920039,
-0.0375718474,
-0.0169654433,
0.0312702544,
-0.0041332371,
0.0537110902,
0.0554608963,
0.0483906679,
0.0339162573,
0.0428756475,
-0.0443931818,
-0.030846538,
-0.0333517082,
0.0097760456,
-0.0183872208,
-0.0164795127,
0.0229611136,
0.0577665493,
-0.0182577949,
-0.0107800299,
-0.0641559437,
0.0626836941,
-0.0360703431,
-0.026728861,
-0.0008699507,
-0.0365387872,
-0.0053594029,
0.0656409338,
-0.0259797163,
-0.0535392351,
0.0698064044,
0.0127162887,
0.0541559346,
-0.0225527585,
-0.0313560963,
-0.0434152037,
0.0398210287,
-0.0121400058,
0.0438136086,
0.0075771865,
-0.0281830244,
-0.0400736816,
-0.0107485857,
0.0478935502,
-0.0662216023,
0.0584175214,
-0.0260105096,
-0.0008763951,
-0.006555744,
-0.0415192991,
-0.037218634,
-0.0326821581,
-0.0076370267,
0.0372759216,
0.0023540121,
-0.0141662406,
-0.021742167,
-0.0297485963,
0.0348284468,
-0.0351681188,
0.0118200276,
0.0199744888,
-0.0180919226,
-0.0585959405,
0.0495101921,
-0.0077108466,
0.0507098958,
-0.0020930206,
-0.0036159388,
0.0218533278,
-0.0024232809,
0.008625146,
0.033679001,
0.0193836521,
0.060837552,
0.0011715329,
0.0094040884,
0.0141371824,
0.0380327143,
0.0027629796,
0.0067519462,
0.0785052106,
-0.0049466556,
-0.0208761208,
0.0468151905,
-0.0513187684,
-0.0067630759,
0.0291866101,
-0.0004600944,
-0.0993183553,
0.0350529514,
-0.0227394681,
0.0125788758,
-0.0485629477,
-0.0552090406,
0.0062809144,
-0.080383189,
-0.0048027015,
0.0355968028,
-0.0576929078,
-0.0654344112,
0.0055634659,
0.009791987,
-0.0359558575,
0.0572947077,
-0.0152014475,
0.0151333306,
-0.0463865586,
0.0130212801,
0.006544637,
-0.0627009347,
0.0396672674,
-0.0630285665,
0.0486268438,
0.1000284031,
0.0713886023,
-0.0284629948,
-0.0678643957,
-0.0516621582,
0.0145061594,
-0.0376652814,
0.0363316312,
-0.0115664657,
-0.0385518372,
-0.0201717317,
-0.029192429,
0.0277455635,
0.0159098282,
-0.0352186598,
-0.0141085507,
0.0506562032,
-0.030973183,
-0.0305502862,
-0.0303335525,
-0.0238921735,
0.0241135806,
0.0646132454,
-0.0104169883,
-0.0499072857,
0.0133309625,
-0.0142270848,
-0.0278045349,
0.0061609657,
-0.0846439078,
0.0135228317,
-0.013403805,
-0.0514296256,
-0.0460539274,
-0.0520122051,
-0.0287645925,
-0.0106817232,
0.022789849,
-0.0787118226,
0.0288069118,
-0.0086573241,
-0.0503321141,
0.0056618075,
-0.0205282699,
0.0319055058,
-0.0106742997,
0.026785519,
-0.0247963276,
-0.0531800203,
-0.0209482089,
-0.0067720353,
-0.0103518432,
-0.0578938276,
0.0645806193,
0.0543749407,
0.0223412681,
-0.0122907627,
0.0005532718,
-0.0513058864,
0.0529661775,
0.04243109,
-0.013904484,
0.0284661856,
0.0140879303,
-0.0083239935,
0.0101731746,
0.0230212826,
-0.0193191003,
0.0229346734,
-0.0094999205,
0.0261594672,
-0.030757105,
-0.0481889732,
0.0188711155,
0.0395300314,
-0.0073903804,
-0.0091219228,
-0.0139157902,
-0.0240139272,
-0.044086501,
-0.0443558507,
-0.0591558106,
-0.010988526,
-0.0098262262,
0.0411876179,
0.0203524102,
-0.0051180157,
-0.0147627359,
-0.0064526782,
0.0209710393,
0.0004126765,
0.0137511855,
-0.0041696527,
0.0777847096,
0.0130397538,
0.0042797746,
-0.011266592,
-0.0031723203,
-0.0261571445,
0.0578358881,
-0.0144196013,
0.0338632092,
0.0422027297,
0.0252496321,
0.0026501857,
0.0609993078,
-0.0163448341,
-0.0856584311,
-0.0142883295,
-0.0433273688,
0.0007422245,
0.0261595659,
0.064224191,
-0.044521559,
-0.012761022,
-0.0426678397,
0.0210920572,
0.0014753658,
-0.074624747,
-0.0020685692,
0.025802834,
-0.0205132719,
-0.0109811183,
0.0122235641,
-0.0378078371,
0.0284360982,
-0.0233497862,
-0.0200381186,
-0.0103764078,
0.0001072259,
0.0126880016,
-0.0204823855,
-0.0442255922,
-0.0335590653,
-0.1194947883,
-0.0544944108,
0.0005466549,
0.057165157,
-0.0143890446,
-0.0291661266,
-0.006062571,
0.0445073061,
-0.0268901382,
-0.0039629312,
-0.0436072275,
-0.0315769315,
-0.0817579702,
0.0077404636,
-0.0216449946,
-6.106265566e-33,
-0.0056000729,
-0.0164037719,
0.0138956113,
-0.017321853,
-0.0390915088,
-0.0086119641,
0.0004845013,
0.022459358,
-0.080728054,
0.0186571218,
0.0186272766,
-0.0093886508,
0.0002835262,
-0.0033437996,
0.0405237749,
-0.0222065281,
0.004239745,
-0.0076717418,
-0.0306043755,
0.0003107165,
0.0364940315,
-0.0479801521,
0.0877504051,
-0.0962697789,
0.0406473354,
0.0465294085,
-0.0592649877,
0.0509002618,
0.000622234,
0.0467714332,
0.0148228342,
0.0605840497,
0.0130086783,
0.0018618301,
0.0042678113,
0.0155786341,
-0.0298952498,
-0.028158024,
0.0254689753,
0.006945977,
0.0094387047,
-0.0430463292,
0.0017042969,
-0.0297477171,
-0.0276731271,
0.0063986294,
0.0422558039,
-0.0103128469,
-0.0039712247,
-0.0220992863,
-0.0598061532,
0.0057255314,
-0.0508782454,
0.0026808369,
0.0065322868,
0.021749828,
0.0042056525,
0.0150790913,
-0.0585761033,
0.0532137156,
-0.0230189785,
-0.0308119208,
0.0666766986,
0.0061700945,
0.0339598693,
0.063858673,
0.0213742852,
0.0326243676,
-0.0082081826,
0.0079093818,
0.0480536669,
0.0431928411,
-0.0216057952,
0.0762290284,
-0.0313826054,
-0.0214158408,
-0.0289813802,
0.0371638872,
0.0152391139,
0.0217425525,
0.0061265077,
0.0194536299,
-0.0834229887,
-0.017421918,
-0.0370170251,
-0.0461660549,
-0.0207280703,
-0.0039223204,
0.0061507015,
-0.0399962552,
-0.0268715415,
0.0397141725,
0.0399054475,
-0.0557269193,
-0.0332797952,
0.0521874726,
0.0069860681,
0.0032808948,
0.005010135,
0.0170268193,
-0.0425846949,
-0.0334125571,
-0.0351194032,
-0.0078046722,
0.0336348824,
0.0464802496,
0.0152221918,
0.0296222791,
-0.0059476667,
-0.012732747,
0.002162992,
-0.0111062899,
-0.0045687971,
0.0049403398,
0.0513004065,
0.0044767335,
0.0161146037,
0.0294655282,
0.0662503093,
0.0233782195,
-0.0512601435,
0.0171645079,
-0.0108442539,
0.0122669861,
-0.0037248279,
-0.008346118,
-0.0732220486,
0.0078170691,
0.0831044391,
-0.011393318,
0.0014115195,
-0.0234427191,
2.822e-7,
0.0151778813,
0.0213578679,
0.0358284116,
0.0466996357,
-0.0303593185,
0.1094284132,
0.0461009927,
0.0649270117,
-0.0011357777,
0.0004748107,
0.0618623123,
0.005602838,
0.0300308559,
0.0225966834,
-0.010334257,
0.0219700877,
-0.0319063626,
-0.0272654314,
-0.0195490774,
0.0433562025,
0.020892527,
0.0442031436,
0.0339607559,
-0.0011154341,
0.00994814,
0.0591790713,
0.028150551,
-0.0460705832,
0.0005064987,
0.0223250668,
-0.0406917483,
-0.0197105315,
0.0065201507,
-0.0230254419,
0.0198876634,
0.038680613,
0.0137427375,
0.0850359797,
-0.032143034,
-0.0354225375,
-0.0400987491,
-0.0444884896,
-0.0185562521,
-0.0737944469,
0.0352839157,
-0.0117526716,
-0.0728624538,
-0.0524477549,
-0.0159676131,
0.0124205146,
0.0273541436,
0.0192389973,
-0.0210221391,
0.012941312,
0.0126969647,
0.0255201776,
0.009963654,
-0.0334937312,
-0.0057936911,
-0.0049251509,
0.0015428489,
-0.0467890874,
0.0331529528,
0.0745483339,
0.0170361176,
-0.0439107604,
0.0257567316,
2.529618155e-34,
0.0078542791,
-0.039089933,
0.0178068522,
-0.0026761333,
0.0362520255,
0.0410380699,
-0.0276210941,
0.0331113562,
0.0201105773,
-0.0165689532,
-0.0127488943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10765v1 | Enhancing Machine Translation through Advanced In-Context Learning: A Methodological Strategy for GPT-4 Improvement | 2023-11-15T10:28:28 | 2023-11-15T10:28:28 | Yufeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The challenge of improving translation accuracy in GPT-4 is being addressed
by harnessing a method known as in-context learning. This paper introduces a
strategic approach to utilize in-context learning specifically for machine
translation, aiming to significantly boost accuracy. The crux of this method
lies in the judicious selection of demonstrations that are most effective for
in-context learning. By selecting these examples carefully, GPT-4 can utilize
them to achieve remarkably accurate machine translations, eliminating the need
for task-specific fine-tuning. This technique is anchored in the semantic
similarities between the user's prompt and the chosen dataset. Sentences from
this dataset, carefully picked for their relevance and clarity, serve as potent
demonstrations for in-context learning. This approach not only enhances
translation accuracy but also enriches the understanding of nuanced linguistic
structures. It represents a significant step forward in machine learning,
leveraging the inherent capabilities of GPT-4 to provide translations that are
not only accurate but also contextually rich and linguistically sophisticated.
This method demonstrates the potential of in-context learning in overcoming
language barriers, opening new avenues for cross-cultural communication and
global collaboration. | [
0.0371413976,
0.0147292446,
-0.0411803201,
0.0518687516,
-0.031316746,
0.0227031857,
0.0271193422,
-0.0130410502,
-0.0041278163,
-0.0065470063,
-0.0277984571,
-0.0336090773,
0.0361513309,
-0.0078584412,
0.0149519471,
-0.0978167653,
0.0188354719,
0.0085882619,
-0.0303904004,
0.0107674943,
0.0025880162,
0.032573048,
0.0036477384,
0.0432033241,
-0.0260167196,
-0.0202689227,
-0.0025123318,
0.0479554124,
0.0585594662,
-0.0283153579,
0.0035181078,
0.0137955341,
0.0361231491,
0.0501905605,
0.0000023532,
-0.0365501828,
-0.0208722372,
-0.0114437854,
-0.0081914598,
-0.0088133961,
0.0713468194,
-0.0187577624,
-0.021507889,
0.012228244,
-0.0751639456,
0.0044339066,
0.0629231334,
0.0062356438,
0.0377529003,
0.0544165969,
-0.0264084693,
-0.0043512774,
-0.0409350842,
-0.0434620939,
0.0207361095,
-0.0531658232,
-0.0210298523,
-0.0177983698,
0.0162543915,
0.025179103,
-0.0018046398,
0.03600128,
0.0476426892,
0.0223839674,
-0.0372651853,
0.0228469875,
-0.0475721098,
-0.0076291272,
-0.0142967347,
0.082842283,
-0.0037399076,
-0.0061820033,
-0.0327664055,
-0.0291857328,
-0.0171305686,
-0.0043973592,
-0.0493142679,
-0.0174576119,
-0.0240798406,
0.0250129104,
-0.0031836093,
0.0623283423,
0.0174911544,
0.0267533176,
-0.0317182392,
0.0327334777,
-0.0093553225,
-0.0251741372,
0.0064174985,
0.0175498854,
-0.0297027156,
-0.0018282479,
0.0229479168,
-0.0096313376,
-0.0282750744,
0.0390378013,
-0.0370689556,
-0.0035257603,
0.0290060584,
-0.0459756069,
0.0244765282,
0.0749391094,
-0.0091079772,
0.0271271579,
0.0058358586,
0.0412357673,
-0.0118893599,
-0.0069089946,
-0.0471212082,
-0.0128000891,
-0.0690368712,
0.0075357198,
-0.0601098426,
-0.0234961882,
-0.068082951,
-0.0072867903,
-0.0536626577,
0.0528556928,
-0.0092308018,
0.0206445102,
-0.0239852667,
-0.0229058489,
-0.1019865498,
-0.0099117635,
-0.0125405407,
0.0360526443,
-0.0312581211,
-0.0125670033,
-0.0093727401,
-0.0794344544,
-0.0178969689,
-0.0005721466,
-0.0038834428,
-0.0357788466,
-0.0128529631,
0.0551414229,
-0.0167892799,
-0.0378487632,
0.010225107,
-0.023257371,
-0.0217263438,
-0.0582264662,
-0.0224689879,
-0.0457509048,
0.0316214524,
0.014790996,
0.0067327525,
-0.0293274354,
0.0049736793,
0.0336066708,
0.0152073903,
0.0911467895,
0.0031031931,
-0.0131043401,
0.0280395504,
0.0228319913,
-0.0236733053,
0.0748158023,
0.0292725135,
0.0440722778,
0.0317328833,
0.0044802898,
-0.0056282617,
0.0425928086,
0.0153932245,
0.0277797431,
-0.0240934547,
0.0191699024,
0.0171337258,
0.0114187524,
-0.00377468,
0.0118221147,
-0.0174129736,
0.0877182186,
0.1005517989,
0.058984369,
-0.0086642047,
0.0334196389,
0.0278735012,
0.0268660765,
-0.0281048696,
0.0013335849,
-0.0469450317,
-0.0040238579,
-0.0009917882,
0.0202349946,
0.0061484813,
0.049029775,
-0.00915509,
-0.0305276401,
0.0273570362,
-0.0029112517,
0.0628671497,
0.0141711272,
0.0195411555,
0.0117077734,
-0.0476728305,
0.0014202856,
0.0104920706,
-0.0558992624,
-0.0113617508,
-0.0220989604,
-0.0308065023,
0.0559790768,
0.007748914,
-0.0116961217,
-0.0289444029,
-0.0324691609,
0.0384269021,
0.0577260032,
0.0423437841,
0.0020958893,
0.0178236384,
-0.0398879834,
-0.0251666289,
0.0005482887,
-0.0099279461,
0.009450634,
0.0336614586,
0.0634525716,
0.0638869554,
-0.0103753544,
-0.0238846298,
0.0158681832,
0.0129068773,
-0.036085017,
0.040247567,
0.0332572274,
0.0428913943,
0.046712365,
0.0190839637,
-0.0398991704,
0.0149440859,
-0.0105122859,
0.0315877534,
0.0734819919,
-0.0782930404,
-0.0313374698,
0.0169716962,
-0.0521204099,
-0.0250207894,
-0.0195419211,
-0.0633902475,
-0.0229869857,
-0.025513621,
-0.0288517624,
0.0443712175,
-0.0654243007,
-0.0018664645,
-0.0030485447,
0.0230056792,
-0.0327325054,
0.0557786822,
0.0354207903,
-0.0178737864,
0.0182881597,
0.0162016042,
0.0354881436,
-0.0458160974,
0.0196892973,
0.0407552943,
0.0301040746,
0.0216637198,
0.0384424888,
0.0605455115,
-0.0530342273,
0.013886367,
-0.1071307063,
0.0109074637,
-0.0351338983,
0.0230671968,
0.0402352922,
0.0571141317,
-0.0321391933,
-0.0420899875,
-0.0019835434,
-0.0120859332,
0.0010053122,
0.007778639,
0.0226489902,
0.014394219,
0.0258899517,
0.0212853272,
0.0310565624,
0.0049618394,
0.021558525,
0.0504880436,
-0.0216852967,
-0.0539222881,
-0.0190500375,
-0.0107400883,
-0.024024386,
0.0001271183,
-0.0326348506,
0.0180779379,
0.0180922598,
0.0370829329,
0.0261640009,
-0.0087420549,
0.0350188613,
0.0052246707,
0.0019094422,
-0.0293091312,
0.0198520385,
-0.0205617901,
-0.0239923317,
-0.0166280456,
-0.0148962019,
0.0351621024,
-0.025442658,
0.0243187994,
0.0050640679,
-0.0742443502,
0.0275179669,
-0.0211048033,
-0.0258042477,
-0.0473440103,
-0.0076968269,
-0.0156066846,
0.0362381674,
-0.0154511342,
-0.0584656596,
0.0771326348,
-0.0022051109,
-0.0099410955,
-0.1003352627,
-0.0186098982,
-0.0065131839,
0.0722099617,
-0.0328925848,
0.0202723276,
-0.0395143591,
-0.0374514982,
-0.0180618986,
0.0200348552,
0.0145301772,
-0.0171024073,
0.0422639549,
-0.0830146596,
-0.0098420596,
-0.0154149551,
-0.0457678363,
-0.0393546447,
0.0061229742,
-0.0048433687,
0.0133154439,
-0.0149029,
-0.0064239567,
-0.0058458457,
-0.0066196979,
0.0250732135,
0.0799372941,
-0.0113019943,
-0.0215092581,
-0.0285122134,
-0.0175728519,
0.0005781911,
-0.0057398849,
-0.031435933,
-0.0351424851,
0.0154133774,
0.0182038359,
0.0420292243,
-0.0708007142,
-0.0155377341,
0.0065111625,
0.0165932532,
-0.0196932927,
-0.0247538462,
0.0384662151,
0.0685607046,
-0.0641401187,
-0.0115127955,
0.0866247341,
0.0192324556,
-0.0679005608,
-0.0029846199,
-0.0123545723,
-0.0065784152,
0.0101949023,
0.0435491204,
-0.105085969,
-0.0378389582,
0.0116655501,
0.0297373291,
0.004106327,
0.0135108847,
-0.0392913818,
-0.110527724,
0.0574612282,
0.0414923802,
-0.1069962978,
-0.0658311918,
0.0103404,
-0.0113921901,
-0.007196913,
0.0508539565,
-0.0363358818,
0.0060406514,
0.0040183119,
0.0044236607,
0.02193195,
-0.0931080282,
0.0056900615,
-0.0334793292,
-0.0271808114,
0.0756764114,
0.0405693948,
0.0213450547,
-0.0196216553,
0.0062991655,
-0.0451081842,
0.0170120317,
-0.0193285588,
0.0134172123,
0.0035702528,
-0.011819968,
0.0120643945,
0.0410765186,
-0.0242050178,
-0.0096622882,
0.0391685627,
0.0834224746,
-0.0343455337,
0.0512087159,
0.029305229,
-0.0248029362,
0.0763882548,
0.0278492067,
0.0335901491,
-0.0418186821,
-0.0019131091,
-0.0568296425,
0.0226259083,
-0.0214378219,
0.0207056496,
-0.0141338836,
-0.0400888845,
-0.0297659542,
-0.0666265413,
-0.0577610917,
0.0434233546,
0.0557158366,
0.0264497548,
0.0328057185,
-0.0168607701,
0.0408588611,
-0.0345330462,
0.0406323075,
-0.0233757049,
0.0263839774,
-0.0343309902,
-0.0227944069,
0.0181246996,
-0.0568544976,
0.0020246014,
0.0488853641,
-0.039030496,
-0.0761160254,
-0.0231330879,
0.036793422,
0.0220199078,
0.0766606927,
-0.0140711861,
-0.0246391948,
0.0555758514,
0.0452157333,
-0.0329642408,
-0.0497013479,
0.0475329086,
0.027568249,
-0.0121097853,
0.0322839394,
0.0087458091,
-0.0040548234,
-0.0018046242,
0.0157718323,
-0.0428276025,
-0.0595390499,
0.0566934459,
-0.0119216973,
0.0380555913,
-0.0373315439,
-0.0755838007,
-0.0216525998,
0.03893454,
-0.0014789576,
-0.0368843116,
-0.0310074426,
-0.0247114375,
-0.0017474414,
-0.0168682449,
0.0052094567,
-0.0123233628,
-0.0365679301,
-0.0230786502,
-0.0243867673,
0.0178238023,
0.0033539585,
0.0354486257,
0.0103026452,
0.0328782685,
-0.0149081526,
-0.0143904174,
0.0010790187,
0.0285925083,
-0.0404363163,
0.0826146454,
0.0272164829,
-0.0115513941,
0.037366543,
0.056825947,
-0.0322280526,
-0.0194464047,
-0.0297604073,
0.0003470624,
0.0737091079,
-0.0209503826,
0.0552257411,
-0.0614053681,
-0.0228553936,
0.0072232103,
0.0554451235,
0.0035513251,
-0.0418813303,
-0.0093682315,
-0.0095312735,
0.0020218592,
0.002767164,
0.0544359684,
-0.0515835546,
0.0166189224,
0.0178553052,
-0.0218793042,
-0.0386871919,
-0.0230311081,
0.06147388,
0.0210829433,
-0.00572635,
-0.006785952,
-0.0193906724,
-0.075564079,
-0.0212033279,
0.0057756132,
-0.0207699295,
-0.0317793339,
0.0450747572,
0.0836904198,
-0.0387675874,
-0.0288778562,
-0.0273723677,
-0.0026409903,
-0.0049998732,
-0.0060183862,
-0.0588311218,
-6.429108478e-33,
-0.027156841,
-0.0440689735,
0.0127785848,
0.0059693987,
-0.0105317999,
-0.035084296,
-0.0340764001,
-0.0275135059,
0.0050155777,
0.0299647264,
-0.0319511257,
-0.0007189968,
0.0337188058,
0.0178861748,
-0.0031858352,
0.0078897877,
0.0511938669,
0.0244217012,
-0.0277526993,
0.0678250566,
0.0231948867,
0.0179286934,
0.0912131369,
-0.0886514485,
0.0434206128,
-0.0013748753,
-0.036245048,
0.0201295726,
-0.0046055699,
0.0149278957,
-0.0071665118,
0.0366007239,
0.0231385008,
-0.0276028514,
-0.0195711181,
0.0225548763,
-0.0522069484,
-0.0294549856,
0.0025823177,
0.031791091,
-0.0085776094,
-0.0448534526,
0.024949884,
-0.0702627674,
-0.0165844131,
0.0079679834,
0.0211078674,
-0.0494774133,
-0.0264320038,
-0.01939095,
-0.0706702992,
0.0117619578,
-0.0196543448,
0.0136437882,
0.0338823386,
0.0668632463,
-0.0128204059,
-0.0243634954,
-0.0665996224,
0.0617909692,
0.0059042373,
-0.0053998684,
0.0862451196,
0.0049865255,
0.0080947606,
0.0054184133,
-0.0073664836,
-0.0396890566,
0.031581983,
-0.0287170392,
0.0202459581,
0.0033849268,
0.0213155337,
0.082106486,
0.0567324832,
-0.0216536894,
-0.0501856618,
0.0528001413,
0.0131542794,
-0.010935721,
0.0168939251,
0.0017057367,
-0.0614998415,
-0.0148987509,
-0.0201427918,
0.000636917,
-0.0110639501,
-0.0735633224,
0.0196461044,
-0.0081377234,
-0.0343231484,
0.047994256,
0.0403533801,
-0.0259915777,
0.01283029,
-0.0030692145,
-0.0220540483,
-0.0227723122,
0.0084862681,
0.0166980252,
-0.0137590254,
-0.0344511718,
-0.0089184335,
0.0298247486,
0.0220968202,
-0.0327243768,
0.0465292372,
0.0461110063,
-0.0636507794,
0.0447521061,
-0.0225329064,
0.0261881705,
-0.0124300849,
-0.0333140008,
0.0257489234,
0.0053118193,
-0.0211625062,
0.041546803,
0.0395521149,
-0.0423497111,
-0.0359971337,
-0.0246649981,
-0.0230282545,
0.0230708737,
-0.0481494404,
0.0056659696,
-0.0062269396,
0.0232531093,
0.050832089,
-0.0477818884,
-0.0380427875,
0.0046430612,
3.006e-7,
0.0270129628,
0.0604559109,
-0.012561705,
0.0028517181,
0.0041103372,
0.0226710867,
-0.0201107766,
0.0313840546,
0.0070684412,
0.0433500558,
0.0698279738,
0.0161853693,
0.0889533833,
0.0435675718,
-0.08548069,
-0.0126618091,
-0.027382588,
0.0225087665,
-0.0773586705,
0.042996347,
0.0485838167,
0.0796298832,
-0.0015265339,
-0.0022702629,
-0.0059350273,
-0.025676582,
0.0643104613,
-0.0605082884,
0.0212206654,
-0.00923084,
-0.0112409461,
0.0157280974,
-0.041056294,
0.0315080211,
-0.0246104002,
-0.0045261914,
0.0241945703,
0.0467296354,
0.0037043502,
-0.0102894902,
-0.0186036285,
0.0094649121,
0.0182037801,
-0.0877710879,
0.0452389307,
-0.0767667666,
-0.0157538317,
0.0499143489,
0.0098643629,
-0.0246070661,
0.0178287197,
-0.0155785494,
-0.0491990075,
0.0087305708,
0.0301965959,
0.0034570822,
-0.0184190664,
-0.0323287621,
0.0051246947,
0.0019114977,
-0.018118199,
-0.025615368,
-0.0271536037,
0.0226245634,
0.0033168334,
-0.0092181209,
0.0412762426,
2.937005926e-34,
0.0031303533,
-0.0181914512,
0.0265802164,
-0.0253175106,
0.0346593596,
0.0018306936,
0.0283559784,
0.0090050595,
0.0423552506,
-0.0099610481,
-0.0327758342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08838v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08838v2 | Disinformation Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T10:25:30 | 2024-02-23T10:44:18 | Ivan Vykopal, Matúš Pikuliak, Ivan Srba, Robert Moro, Dominik Macko, Maria Bielikova | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated disinformation generation is often listed as an important risk
associated with large language models (LLMs). The theoretical ability to flood
the information space with disinformation content might have dramatic
consequences for societies around the world. This paper presents a
comprehensive study of the disinformation capabilities of the current
generation of LLMs to generate false news articles in the English language. In
our study, we evaluated the capabilities of 10 LLMs using 20 disinformation
narratives. We evaluated several aspects of the LLMs: how good they are at
generating news articles, how strongly they tend to agree or disagree with the
disinformation narratives, how often they generate safety warnings, etc. We
also evaluated the abilities of detection models to detect these articles as
LLM-generated. We conclude that LLMs are able to generate convincing news
articles that agree with dangerous disinformation narratives. | [
0.0348665677,
0.0092040943,
-0.0239993073,
0.0422265567,
-0.0687505081,
-0.0002278791,
0.0434622765,
-0.0255953521,
0.0146723529,
-0.0421920456,
-0.000526581,
-0.0210645515,
0.0166340899,
0.0475190058,
0.0392252542,
-0.002268211,
0.0408631824,
0.0027936096,
0.0257291794,
-0.0329767428,
0.0168331005,
0.0284775924,
0.0126588913,
0.0247389581,
-0.013129428,
0.001498415,
0.0390812382,
-0.0018660566,
0.0322980471,
-0.035837464,
-0.0001839354,
0.0264690835,
0.0360406116,
0.0830923244,
0.0000017906,
0.0016115175,
0.0078989267,
0.0169163849,
-0.0345337987,
0.0217146836,
0.0941629261,
-0.0580495037,
-0.0337225124,
0.0170610677,
-0.0244178604,
-0.0166592989,
0.0307713859,
0.0460772701,
0.0677959844,
0.1163520962,
-0.0052744253,
-0.027444249,
0.0513245836,
0.0142425932,
-0.0132538676,
0.0179194864,
0.0538451932,
0.003946241,
-0.0140047362,
0.040991772,
0.0401336364,
0.0023934746,
0.0070090797,
-0.0275928602,
-0.0635798872,
0.0023345733,
-0.0373445153,
-0.0443696082,
0.0087436531,
0.004060715,
-0.0178837236,
-0.0596664883,
0.0270403717,
0.0009940808,
-0.0008016019,
0.0474705696,
0.0146525865,
0.0741760135,
-0.02276792,
0.0126760313,
0.0404312685,
-0.0064554871,
0.0433445945,
0.038794782,
0.0251923241,
0.0545279346,
0.0060165208,
-0.0154365599,
0.0034198805,
-0.0512375198,
0.0169863477,
-0.0775759742,
-0.0021917196,
0.0059880009,
-0.0023802323,
0.0269594081,
-0.0687550828,
-0.0255999453,
0.0465415306,
-0.1515318602,
-0.010448372,
0.0022217275,
0.0291282646,
0.0191137977,
-0.0010273478,
0.0041706855,
-0.0349553265,
0.0110475523,
-0.026293315,
0.0138348369,
0.0118504697,
0.0180933978,
0.004775336,
0.0051689958,
0.0194510426,
0.0063264463,
-0.0786926746,
-0.0072718128,
-0.0281620473,
0.0349552892,
-0.0311362278,
0.0072752978,
-0.0047892341,
-0.0116490265,
0.0110571561,
0.0433018953,
-0.001438694,
0.0257125515,
-0.0066195703,
-0.0469213016,
0.0193469152,
0.0585814007,
-0.0532888398,
0.0044958056,
-0.0184193123,
0.0301244073,
0.0020551865,
0.0184902512,
-0.0381025113,
-0.0368321463,
-0.0467523113,
-0.0638630465,
-0.0023581006,
-0.0668974593,
-0.0431291237,
-0.0102141919,
-0.0171873383,
-0.0398074165,
0.0207959637,
0.0098008336,
-0.0275302939,
0.017197188,
-0.0318076797,
0.0144008119,
0.0773669332,
0.0157779027,
-0.0035226035,
0.1051930711,
0.0009272132,
0.1135555729,
0.0323577188,
0.0066247415,
0.0219934396,
0.0231959615,
0.0215740837,
0.0609145425,
-0.0230056122,
-0.0323460959,
-0.0108832428,
-0.0207429193,
-0.011930028,
0.0357270949,
-0.010819573,
-0.0251016449,
0.0734344274,
-0.0261725578,
-0.0390225835,
0.0004859129,
0.0734236315,
0.0187980849,
0.0062948884,
0.0226993077,
-0.0175015349,
-0.0215722099,
-0.0713588372,
-0.0320919901,
0.0118620284,
0.0649578944,
-0.0065120938,
-0.0009037783,
-0.0295181032,
-0.0125860134,
0.0277765859,
-0.0240650475,
0.005298398,
0.0027106008,
-0.0286901221,
0.0426534042,
0.0595387481,
0.0065248576,
0.0158743747,
-0.0648449659,
-0.0067630154,
0.0261888318,
0.0215470884,
0.0362100862,
0.0096625825,
-0.0378388241,
0.0165814832,
0.0251035765,
0.0475308858,
-0.0064930297,
-0.0787170306,
0.0299065616,
0.0135660768,
-0.0390388928,
0.0449690819,
0.0226935558,
0.0242442712,
0.0484751649,
-0.00169766,
-0.0165027156,
-0.0721915886,
-0.0068153162,
-0.0152218565,
0.005767493,
-0.0438881181,
0.006794929,
0.0294386502,
0.0067671142,
-0.0355088301,
-0.0001468691,
0.0522189587,
-0.0265623368,
-0.0312675945,
-0.0277470872,
0.0164510664,
0.0536170602,
0.0084427409,
-0.0340808295,
-0.0064292108,
0.0217775349,
0.0008444904,
0.0358090959,
0.0433397591,
-0.038005095,
0.0123184165,
-0.0300766584,
0.0083144857,
-0.043350663,
-0.0011043262,
0.01321752,
0.0704423711,
-0.0443626083,
0.0058288565,
0.0044505629,
-0.0146609358,
0.0042027505,
0.0098777283,
0.0083966814,
0.0037000459,
-0.0156932808,
0.018435929,
0.0477771349,
-0.0475983135,
0.013107392,
-0.0390485227,
-0.0100803273,
-0.0287935846,
-0.0282822978,
-0.0057478729,
0.0550344065,
-0.0164695084,
-0.0128095699,
0.05003535,
-0.0368098281,
0.0061349454,
0.0152652273,
0.0334730037,
-0.0213238504,
-0.0181672331,
-0.0388082862,
0.0074729691,
0.0477425382,
-0.0202858578,
0.0525815636,
0.0503512248,
-0.0461734943,
-0.0443617925,
0.0248115677,
-0.0497916713,
0.0088332966,
-0.0552032068,
-0.0652658641,
0.0074790721,
0.0126966005,
-0.0075691012,
0.0238418542,
0.0332934149,
0.0666552112,
0.0460240021,
0.0485294089,
-0.0107003273,
-0.0510566346,
-0.0363925807,
0.0066651399,
-0.0664109364,
-0.0970180929,
0.0096549364,
0.0350754634,
0.0540235713,
0.0095277298,
0.0004571557,
0.0640959665,
-0.0360627957,
-0.0356654488,
0.0386741497,
-0.0752824843,
0.0044342084,
0.0492398851,
-0.0075660227,
-0.0730625838,
0.0534282885,
-0.0423066095,
0.0683406889,
-0.0293039568,
-0.0214209557,
-0.001453791,
-0.0138373403,
-0.0240305681,
0.0616160929,
0.0247534979,
0.015569414,
-0.0046406765,
-0.0339072384,
0.0455812812,
-0.0154501265,
0.0006525872,
-0.0458348617,
0.0303941984,
0.0256101042,
0.0075851819,
-0.0489157662,
-0.103298232,
-0.0032324498,
-0.0235166792,
0.042064786,
-0.0309883822,
-0.1033875793,
-0.0179602578,
0.0666974857,
-0.0161998291,
0.0021329841,
0.0330491737,
0.0081847683,
-0.0115131317,
0.0265265852,
-0.0607084818,
0.0789905116,
-0.042545151,
0.0073205442,
0.0520195067,
-0.0350744277,
0.0298077799,
-0.015050278,
-0.0380429588,
0.0058662286,
-0.0048983735,
-0.025086062,
0.022442868,
0.017980624,
-0.032118991,
0.0296271872,
0.0694858879,
-0.0012566666,
-0.0044585271,
0.0005613669,
0.034020748,
-0.0087651666,
0.0180307329,
-0.0128507512,
-0.0709036589,
0.0405288897,
0.0121505363,
-0.0221483558,
-0.0526509285,
-0.0217502881,
-0.0441054702,
-0.0630773976,
0.0205638781,
0.0304090548,
-0.0189355258,
-0.0330117941,
-0.0672167093,
-0.0389820263,
0.0367925614,
0.0057853428,
-0.016032692,
0.0263973977,
-0.0449833758,
-0.017108405,
-0.046142444,
-0.055688899,
-0.0010594414,
0.0040230411,
0.0509341285,
0.0365496762,
0.0344199501,
-0.0424006321,
-0.0178344194,
0.0055039548,
0.0251321718,
-0.0516209975,
-0.0062075648,
0.0383141153,
-0.0136204483,
-0.0202595871,
-0.0214534886,
0.0277482327,
0.0587088019,
-0.0123740686,
-0.0124224843,
0.0254353788,
0.0117762089,
-0.0893142819,
-0.0194854252,
0.0334346592,
0.0620332435,
0.0509523973,
-0.0085519794,
0.0094629675,
0.0068997988,
-0.048609145,
-0.0060832184,
0.0258202869,
-0.0318110846,
0.0351608358,
-0.0051131002,
-0.0662428588,
-0.0306271464,
-0.0014071551,
-0.0310082976,
-0.0221754406,
0.0396577418,
0.0195963513,
0.0309586171,
-0.0111088427,
0.0081816874,
-0.03661488,
-0.0165214464,
0.0659743622,
-0.0126131745,
0.0017863578,
0.0027679745,
-0.0080133332,
0.0088678999,
0.0261953734,
-0.0776699632,
-0.0795047134,
0.0368979871,
0.0012642527,
0.0195991695,
0.0105509739,
0.0024691615,
-0.0291279722,
0.0901809409,
0.0002829442,
-0.0252130255,
0.0261091422,
0.0161575768,
-0.001249894,
0.0434020162,
0.0256468505,
-0.0144983986,
0.0531461015,
0.0098710377,
-0.0497537516,
-0.0765458792,
0.0086274501,
0.0444480814,
0.0351723209,
-0.0060212659,
-0.0369010754,
0.0275758915,
-0.011486725,
-0.0131593272,
-0.0491191112,
-0.0331312716,
0.0167599469,
0.0087335771,
0.0321704745,
-0.0090177432,
0.0186388623,
0.0314009674,
-0.0480593257,
-0.012492327,
0.0052745333,
0.0192848314,
-0.0140575627,
0.043750558,
0.0661945567,
-0.004585186,
-0.0257636681,
0.0296823382,
-0.0166265015,
-0.0001596642,
0.0063005881,
-0.0097174132,
-0.0034362206,
-0.0326957852,
0.006898216,
-0.0285018776,
-0.0194503218,
-0.0294342488,
-0.0299285874,
0.0235401597,
0.0315314271,
0.0283015519,
0.0323456004,
-0.0135067552,
-0.0058232592,
-0.0152626056,
-0.0155126555,
0.0187897459,
-0.0364001505,
0.0213919505,
-0.020000603,
-0.0585545562,
0.0371855497,
0.0455529764,
0.0094835199,
0.0364815071,
0.0543688387,
-0.0462658815,
-0.0234433971,
-0.034224268,
0.0187659711,
0.0201440416,
-0.0015140186,
-0.0037535112,
-0.087860398,
-0.0417181253,
0.0068400302,
0.0090562422,
0.0109179132,
-0.017247133,
-0.0366299525,
0.0714286044,
0.0142846955,
0.0355677083,
-0.0532302633,
0.002738883,
-0.0090037268,
-0.026982652,
0.0322589353,
-6.149974487e-33,
0.0249010883,
-0.0663942322,
-0.0353463665,
-0.0110719837,
0.0076265307,
0.0306624472,
-0.0056883083,
-0.0099292351,
-0.047256086,
0.0541886501,
0.0442746729,
0.0067050224,
-0.0020147783,
-0.0094209388,
-0.0726909414,
0.0041313255,
0.0408150405,
-0.0165047534,
-0.0257749259,
0.0198266935,
0.0675122291,
-0.025603395,
0.0086300662,
-0.0630143136,
0.078728117,
-0.0274828952,
-0.0732984096,
-0.0107851615,
-0.0217317455,
0.0182605032,
0.0100640878,
0.0456321836,
0.0093562854,
-0.0372801721,
-0.0117588146,
0.0455447622,
0.0397644378,
0.0006571564,
0.0720706582,
-0.0176180061,
0.0193186011,
-0.0324017443,
0.0252255816,
-0.0152436597,
-0.034956377,
0.0292212535,
0.015463219,
-0.0308112446,
-0.0050149462,
0.0039502042,
-0.0739820004,
-0.0165229999,
0.0024632881,
0.0123975566,
-0.0462315716,
0.0314425156,
0.0150762349,
0.0066376803,
-0.0652884543,
0.0446115732,
0.0316468626,
0.0153887672,
0.0373872146,
-0.0468320809,
-0.0264278241,
0.0870096013,
0.0186236799,
0.0345976204,
-0.0424296297,
0.0181389339,
-0.0095190639,
0.0455442593,
0.0542416535,
0.0902987048,
0.0058209859,
-0.0382996947,
-0.0906583592,
0.0047308709,
0.0367479771,
0.0133938855,
0.0406547301,
-0.050357081,
-0.0211175419,
-0.0218662657,
-0.044738315,
-0.0115571273,
-0.0284822714,
-0.0339214057,
-0.0024777136,
0.0261415057,
-0.0292685013,
0.0108267432,
0.0027947729,
-0.0562137514,
0.0069048116,
0.0467910469,
0.0021651159,
-0.0293834992,
0.007521071,
0.0551002398,
-0.0548597276,
0.0167200156,
-0.0073438636,
-0.0025731826,
0.0094343498,
-0.0015648394,
0.0228902586,
0.0055938517,
-0.0478389673,
0.0238630641,
-0.0188484229,
0.0374397412,
0.0430458188,
-0.0155363027,
0.035027314,
-0.019322563,
-0.0124762841,
-0.0422476493,
0.0076201954,
-0.0105279889,
0.0245341975,
0.0054187425,
-0.0293597002,
0.0684553161,
-0.0289777499,
0.0094637787,
-0.0515390858,
0.0384131968,
0.0400174297,
-0.0729284585,
-0.0046650455,
-0.0400590114,
2.7e-7,
0.0027448309,
0.0577132553,
-0.0153986439,
0.0328299291,
0.034194652,
0.0403184481,
0.005774382,
-0.0057678446,
-0.0163387507,
-0.0798125938,
-0.0608140603,
0.0091258436,
0.0308267027,
0.0493252538,
-0.0349577256,
0.0613522977,
-0.062902458,
0.0018971694,
-0.0505622514,
-0.0129157938,
0.0226418562,
0.0476634577,
0.0258101281,
-0.0257738195,
-0.0371626914,
-0.0405342467,
0.0494856685,
-0.0042774728,
-0.0497919023,
0.0313185565,
0.0074596773,
-0.0138281612,
0.0079627112,
0.0098409159,
-0.0149024129,
-0.0235330649,
-0.0534324087,
0.0341811143,
0.014196299,
0.0062760664,
-0.0101000406,
-0.0755845606,
0.004439251,
-0.0688074753,
0.0527833588,
-0.0355060995,
-0.0409625433,
-0.0705386698,
-0.0516045317,
0.0023268056,
0.0136586195,
-0.0435583219,
-0.0078865327,
0.0176258367,
-0.0096776644,
0.0421823524,
0.0225006975,
0.0032296891,
0.0113878539,
0.0135112591,
-0.0446723551,
-0.0726202205,
-0.012192768,
-0.0045343884,
0.0102241617,
0.0003848647,
0.0501929037,
2.351873766e-34,
0.0555169247,
-0.027011564,
-0.0232941341,
-0.0193189289,
0.0421589911,
0.0259620827,
-0.0421391763,
-0.0075117862,
-0.0020572746,
-0.0312215835,
0.0056479829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08836v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08836v2 | Evaluating Gender Bias in the Translation of Gender-Neutral Languages into English | 2023-11-15T10:25:14 | 2023-12-13T04:15:26 | Spencer Rarrick, Ranjita Naik, Sundar Poudel, Vishal Chowdhary | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Machine Translation (MT) continues to improve in quality and adoption, yet
the inadvertent perpetuation of gender bias remains a significant concern.
Despite numerous studies into gender bias in translations from gender-neutral
languages such as Turkish into more strongly gendered languages like English,
there are no benchmarks for evaluating this phenomenon or for assessing
mitigation strategies. To address this gap, we introduce GATE X-E, an extension
to the GATE (Rarrick et al., 2023) corpus, that consists of human translations
from Turkish, Hungarian, Finnish, and Persian into English. Each translation is
accompanied by feminine, masculine, and neutral variants for each possible
gender interpretation. The dataset, which contains between 1250 and 1850
instances for each of the four language pairs, features natural sentences with
a wide range of sentence lengths and domains, challenging translation rewriters
on various linguistic phenomena. Additionally, we present an English gender
rewriting solution built on GPT-3.5 Turbo and use GATE X-E to evaluate it. We
open source our contributions to encourage further research on gender
debiasing. | [
0.0264271796,
0.0357835516,
-0.0318937488,
0.0232474729,
-0.0279580131,
0.0112986648,
0.0535994284,
-0.0233380552,
-0.0152894519,
-0.0429734029,
-0.004061555,
-0.0434108563,
0.0688310415,
-0.0081495,
0.0382882357,
-0.035668049,
0.0193871781,
0.0226917118,
0.0006835907,
-0.0186473988,
0.0332024209,
0.0495196283,
0.021119928,
0.0509522706,
0.0070813335,
-0.0166621413,
0.0224255156,
0.064245984,
0.0196011197,
0.014668717,
0.0318492688,
0.0225708894,
-0.0184294116,
0.0583573841,
0.0000020043,
-0.0580673181,
-0.0151903555,
0.0257820208,
0.0142944278,
-0.0139239794,
0.0566775128,
-0.0539981797,
-0.0617741346,
0.0230110772,
0.003171538,
-0.04176566,
0.0587743893,
0.0026403447,
0.0637721643,
0.0527895503,
-0.0248653386,
-0.0092363497,
-0.0598530173,
-0.0342211425,
0.0156756453,
-0.0254676379,
0.0009971049,
-0.0579610877,
-0.0698749498,
-0.0015785712,
-0.0229312759,
0.0374963917,
-0.0238699298,
-0.0336421095,
-0.0348320827,
0.0089050122,
-0.0517968573,
-0.0684054345,
0.0253349394,
0.031846866,
-0.0061972155,
0.0034311882,
0.0112183671,
0.0065579014,
0.0025328347,
0.0141314222,
-0.0081315963,
0.0238977559,
-0.0127888191,
-0.032811828,
0.0061813607,
-0.0095791677,
0.01369326,
0.026133135,
-0.0488194749,
0.068979539,
0.0395422094,
-0.0341216363,
0.0226584859,
0.0289801918,
0.0122689074,
-0.0344200246,
0.034445256,
-0.0565636493,
-0.0008387135,
0.0069528162,
-0.0286301356,
-0.0507762469,
0.0292237811,
-0.0668938085,
-0.0146471262,
0.0630001798,
0.0239761248,
0.0088903075,
-0.0345455185,
0.0198288672,
-0.0043362095,
-0.0201760307,
-0.0681502968,
-0.0267609488,
0.0014507895,
0.0227911863,
-0.043144621,
-0.0474545993,
-0.0415708274,
0.0708238482,
-0.0645869076,
0.0024029501,
-0.0078946007,
0.0126009686,
0.0296784882,
-0.0159526579,
-0.0534099229,
-0.0127225732,
0.0170218591,
0.0501741841,
-0.0517474785,
0.0109085189,
-0.0672523454,
-0.0943376049,
-0.0118316421,
0.0120601784,
-0.0139021054,
-0.0315425545,
-0.0296689179,
0.0199594479,
0.0009968027,
-0.0332629792,
-0.0020280557,
-0.0005679513,
-0.0442727059,
-0.0550848767,
-0.0197677966,
-0.048820287,
0.0370755084,
0.0349719673,
0.0243136454,
-0.0499934927,
0.0016274871,
0.0343547724,
0.0137455417,
0.0442107283,
0.0695845634,
0.0120548038,
0.0524584241,
-0.0064455927,
-0.0382592343,
0.0802350193,
0.0384604298,
0.0296318848,
0.0383909121,
0.0369317234,
-0.0018160198,
0.0430499762,
0.0291395057,
0.0389148779,
-0.0108712008,
0.0437050872,
-0.02387565,
0.0741123632,
0.0690207332,
0.0075533842,
0.0288528781,
0.0067765815,
0.0564703196,
0.0649627745,
-0.0018915529,
0.0612895712,
0.0338812731,
0.0207360536,
-0.0118840532,
-0.0078487275,
-0.0516938195,
-0.0162394997,
0.0145024015,
0.004445313,
-0.0217574462,
0.0430252515,
0.0167706758,
-0.0315456018,
0.0138708968,
0.0116107762,
0.0444044061,
-0.0140797412,
0.0260620061,
0.0198441073,
-0.0289924946,
0.0399631336,
-0.0222876258,
-0.0730341673,
0.0000788557,
-0.0353312567,
-0.008844329,
0.0493887775,
0.0232819915,
-0.0289802179,
0.0043305662,
-0.0393295251,
-0.0213395301,
0.0301783662,
0.0609928779,
0.0131078893,
0.0389845446,
-0.0463511497,
-0.015899092,
0.0576604567,
0.0439848118,
0.0359332077,
0.040822152,
0.0885002464,
0.0615510456,
-0.0438359343,
-0.0545100085,
0.01980027,
0.013174925,
-0.0244700406,
0.0531956926,
0.0104445554,
-0.0029630461,
0.0177703239,
-0.0408257581,
0.0091533745,
-0.013187293,
-0.0191337988,
0.0074358238,
0.0444726683,
-0.0217611548,
-0.0051862211,
0.0035397445,
-0.1018913686,
-0.0948651284,
0.0394627303,
-0.047432065,
-0.0275543667,
0.0484297164,
-0.0484156869,
-0.0349551551,
-0.0264418162,
0.0289892647,
0.004818962,
0.0209473688,
-0.0134128761,
-0.0113353375,
0.0029987986,
-0.0479307808,
-0.0072294045,
-0.0832025781,
0.0207748171,
-0.0375814214,
-0.0422184169,
0.030745009,
0.0180873517,
0.0124985995,
0.0548161604,
-0.0176151544,
-0.030033851,
-0.0283019114,
-0.0521090105,
-0.0083249165,
-0.0022002447,
0.033772897,
0.0155296689,
0.0561743043,
-0.0265811421,
0.0054065804,
-0.0189486649,
-0.0454193167,
-0.0001670861,
0.01739797,
0.0369348079,
-0.0304276571,
0.0262956824,
-0.0202782955,
-0.0194636565,
-0.0368005224,
0.0242102779,
0.0467675813,
-0.0203414541,
-0.0408366285,
0.0050364137,
0.0037272538,
-0.0428492352,
0.0189074967,
-0.0346075408,
-0.0075801001,
0.0071948143,
0.0659020096,
0.0600672774,
-0.0118389269,
-0.0341199487,
0.0330960974,
0.0137127871,
-0.034361735,
-0.0305015352,
0.0330322608,
-0.0260833632,
0.0154305659,
-0.1008594409,
0.0039973967,
-0.0216155015,
-0.0058861785,
-0.0491943397,
-0.0514581278,
0.0246351119,
-0.0489917584,
-0.0159506351,
-0.0283244215,
0.0105970139,
0.02922065,
0.0629178211,
-0.0275949761,
-0.0201021936,
0.0409424864,
-0.0001226494,
-0.0142240478,
-0.0412688479,
0.024753686,
-0.0608671643,
0.0363541953,
-0.0610234663,
0.0073447889,
0.0314159691,
-0.0007935238,
-0.0601330772,
-0.0298431702,
0.0441415757,
-0.0140468404,
0.0402404033,
-0.0631893128,
0.0220685508,
-0.0222490467,
-0.0163189471,
-0.0184310898,
-0.0297888871,
0.004599906,
-0.0424937569,
0.0170746557,
-0.0193672348,
-0.016139932,
0.0198123418,
-0.0180265047,
0.0468667597,
-0.0324380882,
-0.0093640145,
-0.0109037533,
-0.0048937467,
-0.0168990046,
-0.0123669906,
0.0046036351,
-0.0254738685,
-0.0039945482,
0.0453832075,
-0.0276110992,
-0.0118030226,
0.0056438935,
-0.0027273872,
0.0384012051,
-0.0534080081,
-0.0182387289,
-0.0474044494,
0.0152344014,
-0.0732131228,
0.0149019295,
0.0960133746,
-0.0029908642,
-0.0596884228,
-0.0116616879,
-0.0083609838,
0.0340270102,
0.0268569924,
0.0234973654,
-0.0613293052,
0.010359874,
0.0559190735,
0.0384607799,
-0.0078882771,
-0.0060105035,
-0.0182315111,
-0.1041260213,
-0.0081503345,
0.0398793519,
-0.0595736653,
-0.0699857026,
-0.0134548061,
-0.0334847681,
-0.0514389165,
0.0069466867,
0.0022494844,
0.0019072195,
0.023127215,
-0.0455211401,
-0.0002141729,
-0.05014107,
0.0106768701,
-0.0784698576,
0.0317668281,
0.0394161865,
0.0724848136,
-0.0192737468,
0.0141276903,
0.0310238469,
-0.0100992639,
-0.0282381587,
-0.0128475688,
0.0134708583,
-0.0316988416,
-0.0099441726,
-0.0298615359,
0.0202649217,
0.0195915047,
0.0304552447,
0.0338112041,
0.0009221006,
0.036199417,
-0.0013624296,
-0.0181245338,
-0.0194250084,
0.0130451797,
0.0606148988,
-0.0067888796,
-0.0098769385,
-0.0551188998,
-0.0423469059,
-0.0044168318,
-0.0100513967,
-0.0637253523,
-0.0260534994,
-0.0059031257,
-0.0630765483,
-0.0623887479,
-0.0640587732,
0.0138696712,
0.0028139099,
0.0112569407,
-0.0505973473,
0.0150580145,
0.0269881207,
-0.052772183,
0.0206687264,
-0.0063825455,
0.0508311614,
0.0274861697,
0.0122686485,
-0.0349284485,
-0.0172118265,
0.0075447354,
0.0723303631,
-0.0328771919,
-0.051559072,
0.0293147322,
0.0361676365,
0.0237030443,
0.0488277152,
-0.0180498846,
-0.0037324275,
0.0170051418,
0.0096239932,
-0.0364185683,
0.0222489703,
0.0546879582,
0.0239824969,
0.0010642168,
0.0589564741,
-0.0103603546,
-0.0080976039,
-0.0153963966,
0.0050135134,
0.0096545378,
-0.0398636721,
0.0119275022,
0.0324165709,
-0.0292641968,
-0.0789098442,
0.0516774096,
-0.0378879718,
0.0209729541,
-0.0418160781,
-0.0159637854,
-0.0042645149,
-0.0167292394,
0.0602097437,
-0.0015949578,
-0.011852107,
-0.0104838014,
-0.0497746579,
-0.0493486375,
-0.0099156145,
0.0005369876,
-0.0129756415,
0.0627021641,
-0.0023806172,
0.0195423253,
0.0035431394,
0.011641941,
-0.042467691,
0.0253833551,
-0.004758453,
-0.0076849568,
-0.0070141354,
0.0198470913,
-0.0208831094,
0.02428931,
-0.0260093864,
0.0239864495,
0.0006565445,
0.0424741581,
0.0456395037,
-0.0126391575,
0.1215955913,
-0.0022698243,
-0.0150988903,
0.0133051621,
0.0250851288,
0.0178743638,
0.0358756445,
-0.0288976748,
-0.0264603328,
0.0039736424,
-0.0008858347,
0.0522205196,
0.0376321115,
0.0391157195,
0.0029465267,
-0.0490903743,
-0.0125840651,
-0.0323864557,
-0.0246301387,
-0.0577451512,
-0.0250683166,
-0.0325415097,
-0.0753359869,
-0.0508723445,
-0.011304874,
0.0052178428,
0.0357616283,
-0.0173751302,
-0.0107350871,
0.0729891956,
-0.01179762,
-0.0442346483,
-0.0585808754,
0.0197227076,
0.0000660138,
-0.0253079794,
-0.0504327007,
-5.769309376e-33,
-0.0105945934,
0.0191470217,
-0.0425740294,
-0.0173008926,
-0.024253143,
-0.0140988743,
-0.0136797922,
-0.0015987987,
0.0287257172,
0.0519653969,
-0.0309812259,
0.0464458615,
0.0298675038,
-0.0277713742,
0.0219748039,
0.0320360437,
0.0801640749,
0.0123963738,
-0.0303454231,
-0.0197433103,
-0.0130131533,
0.0256040655,
0.049984023,
-0.0747272596,
0.1258902699,
-0.0510763787,
-0.0383675471,
0.0094900448,
-0.0198240075,
-0.0189675856,
0.0161193032,
0.0497110672,
-0.0033528425,
-0.0648257658,
-0.0064684921,
0.0271421149,
-0.0934307948,
-0.000833193,
0.0224247109,
0.0631034076,
0.0425618067,
-0.0384910405,
0.0305066537,
-0.0088321492,
-0.0473473668,
-0.0122984331,
0.0267970171,
-0.0008527087,
0.0584120043,
0.012546326,
-0.0691724643,
0.028730629,
-0.0399646275,
-0.0044412827,
0.0533999689,
0.0601662323,
-0.0075927945,
-0.0234404709,
-0.0451909378,
0.0283725709,
-0.0423592031,
0.0119674802,
0.0301327556,
-0.0254914928,
0.0136234984,
-0.0277673583,
0.0572918169,
0.0472582057,
-0.0156019507,
-0.035392005,
0.0093878144,
-0.0632247627,
0.0187095758,
0.0750065222,
0.0441241749,
-0.0191723071,
-0.0480507314,
0.0131052416,
0.0059857704,
0.0505544059,
0.0062708808,
-0.0141604664,
-0.0640036464,
-0.0427172631,
-0.0255828872,
-0.0697100759,
-0.0009588049,
-0.0133754062,
0.0052904719,
-0.0043591554,
-0.0666025281,
-0.0023778591,
0.0029149905,
-0.0553212985,
0.0046642171,
-0.0145701878,
-0.0081531079,
-0.0327808,
0.0186582264,
0.0423394255,
-0.0015173677,
0.0170086771,
0.0080985697,
0.0437303185,
0.0257747378,
-0.0109810168,
-0.009531267,
0.0240480937,
-0.0750821456,
-0.0037725365,
-0.02271563,
0.0044936026,
-0.0163833443,
0.0533930622,
0.0132018905,
0.0360037088,
0.0053895018,
-0.0269649532,
0.0771779791,
0.04334528,
-0.0339837819,
0.0061290017,
0.0172267742,
0.0358566232,
-0.0147684887,
0.0172469094,
0.0013807506,
0.0110607287,
0.0660398751,
-0.0442649908,
-0.0187162161,
-0.0604109168,
2.756e-7,
0.0179190468,
0.0653011501,
0.0476125665,
0.0436114445,
0.0126991896,
0.0248567406,
-0.0010091953,
0.0523464866,
0.0456654876,
0.0483566597,
0.0098312218,
0.0189660508,
0.0265028924,
0.0228577964,
-0.0742789656,
-0.0113401301,
-0.0402785763,
0.0644305199,
-0.0052001933,
0.0221609622,
0.0161269289,
0.073874183,
0.0239672493,
0.0065828692,
-0.0196020659,
0.006452716,
0.0310003553,
-0.0103291478,
0.006647957,
0.0170226023,
0.0233846605,
-0.0001096356,
-0.0128633007,
0.0030822027,
0.0105327312,
-0.00866694,
0.0330390409,
0.0633950979,
-0.0103057753,
0.0559737906,
0.0038850487,
-0.0286295172,
-0.0131192701,
-0.0493019,
0.0484425016,
0.0171400309,
-0.0163943507,
-0.0280886143,
-0.0185339097,
0.0225097947,
0.0981200859,
-0.0139413401,
-0.0329026729,
0.0369442031,
0.0519485101,
0.0138662774,
-0.0161911324,
-0.0366692767,
-0.0528401248,
-0.0416184962,
0.010012242,
-0.0427406393,
0.0011515619,
0.0578554422,
0.0114362324,
-0.0146630425,
-0.0148257362,
2.089086953e-34,
0.0247865692,
0.0086928569,
0.0023210607,
-0.0154855857,
0.0266005062,
-0.0251031369,
-0.0135619165,
0.0031486074,
0.0427516364,
0.0307294894,
-0.0336605422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08817v1 | MAP's not dead yet: Uncovering true language model modes by conditioning away degeneracy | 2023-11-15T09:38:53 | 2023-11-15T09:38:53 | Davis Yoshida, Kartik Goyal, Kevin Gimpel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | It has been widely observed that exact or approximate MAP (mode-seeking)
decoding from natural language generation (NLG) models consistently leads to
degenerate outputs (Stahlberg and Byrne, 2019, Holtzman et al., 2019). This has
generally been attributed to either a fundamental inadequacy of modes in models
or weaknesses in language modeling. Contrastingly in this work, we emphasize
that degenerate modes can even occur in the absence of any model error, due to
contamination of the training data. Specifically, we show that mixing even a
tiny amount of low-entropy noise with a population text distribution can cause
the data distribution's mode to become degenerate, implying that any models
trained on it will be as well. As the unconditional mode of NLG models will
often be degenerate, we therefore propose to apply MAP decoding to the model's
distribution conditional on avoiding specific degeneracies. Using exact-search,
we empirically verify that the length-conditional modes of machine translation
models and language models are indeed more fluent and topical than their
unconditional modes. For the first time, we also share many examples of exact
modal sequences from these models, and from several variants of the LLaMA-7B
model. Notably, the modes of the LLaMA models are still degenerate, showing
that improvements in modeling have not fixed this issue. Because of the cost of
exact mode finding algorithms, we develop an approximate mode finding approach,
ACBS, which finds sequences that are both high-likelihood and high-quality. We
apply this approach to LLaMA-7B, a model which was not trained for instruction
following, and find that we are able to elicit reasonable outputs without any
finetuning. | [
0.0186949,
0.0821295306,
-0.0275842696,
0.019899901,
0.0043862695,
0.0155152241,
-0.0290556829,
0.0166028272,
-0.0469248295,
-0.0283889528,
-0.031250231,
-0.0282199178,
0.0289166197,
0.0234671347,
0.0531158336,
-0.0015762644,
0.0237827338,
-0.0076711741,
-0.0019553276,
0.0159127358,
-0.0172081143,
0.0058594686,
0.003290206,
0.0520531461,
0.0328528956,
0.0275024474,
-0.0398509614,
-0.0002085545,
0.011183056,
-0.0066137351,
0.0053698625,
0.0518481098,
0.0067316606,
0.0045650681,
0.0000021806,
-0.0023533173,
0.0002813074,
-0.0331671238,
0.0267371126,
0.0115215993,
0.0091439774,
-0.0397737063,
0.0019422191,
0.019873675,
-0.0111076888,
-0.0262951981,
0.0578153469,
-0.0005553214,
0.0134575246,
0.0782369599,
0.0018724514,
-0.0157751776,
0.0262982715,
-0.0389016606,
0.0103523331,
0.0186015442,
0.0032388645,
-0.0109111117,
-0.0046304362,
0.0387503766,
0.0015604449,
0.0594189987,
0.0135869645,
0.0213532932,
-0.0391014069,
0.0406105407,
0.0645785779,
-0.0560247637,
0.0176011547,
0.0643640533,
-0.016605204,
-0.0606402196,
0.0470617786,
-0.0084566204,
0.0165565778,
0.0054489616,
0.0003538233,
0.0456472114,
-0.0261341706,
0.0400171913,
0.0743672401,
0.025802182,
0.0262927525,
-0.0122026596,
-0.0336352475,
-0.0082681561,
0.0044733589,
-0.011078123,
-0.0691367611,
0.0237579942,
-0.0656504333,
-0.0417012423,
0.0149549004,
0.043453142,
0.0007380103,
0.0200041253,
-0.0508645438,
-0.0365473665,
0.0371024981,
-0.0382588953,
0.0342659615,
0.0475744642,
-0.0400054045,
-0.0386121906,
0.0013850966,
-0.0000775299,
-0.0047561196,
-0.0021017606,
-0.0657866672,
0.0232005697,
0.0006019837,
-0.0101374323,
-0.0200597644,
-0.0012839937,
-0.0345643871,
-0.0044096541,
-0.0369118936,
-0.0020981668,
0.0415257849,
-0.0280028936,
-0.0238209888,
0.012732232,
-0.0953539982,
0.0005204527,
0.0232292078,
-0.0249028802,
0.0089238677,
0.0355166011,
0.0402311645,
-0.0417688563,
-0.0037421833,
-0.0003990942,
0.0151941078,
0.022624936,
-0.0051823831,
0.0607028455,
-0.0245368909,
-0.0319205001,
-0.0543947145,
-0.0363513306,
-0.0357689857,
-0.0441559255,
0.0020982914,
-0.0578350946,
0.0144633008,
0.0389213525,
-0.0095502734,
-0.0157330614,
0.0165819116,
-0.0171559788,
-0.024895573,
0.0373418964,
-0.0136619993,
0.0335710309,
0.0345916562,
0.0202660691,
0.0406418592,
0.0601801723,
0.0231253766,
0.0184031967,
0.0017674542,
-0.022092117,
0.0188067053,
0.039982833,
0.0400187336,
0.026214242,
-0.0039008392,
-0.0416761413,
-0.0602095872,
0.00728638,
0.0604064539,
0.0536212996,
-0.0393709987,
-0.0090396721,
0.0675441474,
-0.0083388891,
0.0113820061,
0.0401725061,
0.056367524,
0.0257485453,
-0.0104217827,
0.0604661517,
-0.0131122079,
-0.002428435,
-0.0230383594,
0.0327695087,
0.0521349125,
0.0339603573,
-0.0271895863,
-0.0585215911,
-0.0012825876,
-0.0221271347,
-0.0093842261,
-0.0290202368,
0.0191818979,
0.0393669903,
-0.0330958329,
0.0358313955,
0.0171689242,
-0.0449831672,
0.0139047801,
-0.049667526,
0.0285994988,
0.0001808413,
0.0479497649,
0.0298936889,
-0.03987775,
0.0063088057,
-0.0338709354,
0.0382751562,
0.0128303776,
-0.0054415171,
0.0074765836,
-0.0815988109,
-0.0039729006,
0.0371717103,
0.0620614067,
-0.0144953923,
-0.0206766743,
0.0291235596,
0.0207626466,
-0.0740990415,
-0.0295065679,
0.0375494845,
-0.0200362336,
-0.02585743,
0.0001018901,
-0.0119975274,
0.0351385213,
-0.016674282,
-0.0286481939,
0.0410722941,
0.0267594699,
-0.0590572022,
-0.0202818625,
0.060597524,
-0.0749436393,
-0.00523675,
0.0093621593,
-0.0191695392,
0.0151480222,
0.001873754,
-0.0013716114,
-0.0447336473,
0.0105575435,
-0.0707309395,
0.0083563505,
-0.0317359678,
0.0464281477,
0.0152522055,
0.0280387159,
-0.0474330932,
0.0682567805,
-0.033242479,
0.0062569357,
0.0270450506,
-0.0579459034,
0.0071584512,
-0.0067177471,
0.0120622059,
0.0477629043,
-0.0163813755,
0.0219379868,
0.0228729602,
0.0315777063,
-0.0148871075,
-0.0497855544,
-0.0851633251,
-0.0020204633,
-0.0269374475,
0.0525109917,
0.0714852437,
-0.0011991382,
-0.0228273142,
0.0158850066,
-0.0495126881,
0.0291010495,
0.0518160053,
0.0015876488,
0.0374520272,
0.0172494948,
-0.0382770635,
-0.0294323973,
0.0128347343,
0.0097885197,
0.0152987819,
-0.0054515223,
0.0194831062,
-0.0767225251,
0.0961648896,
-0.0021580807,
-0.0084454529,
-0.0117211109,
-0.0775637999,
-0.0017432257,
0.0059967982,
0.0686683506,
-0.0218590572,
0.0049300264,
0.044050511,
0.0285971258,
0.0058403951,
-0.0520296879,
-0.0317898765,
-0.0444782525,
-0.0237412024,
-0.040655382,
-0.0890830159,
0.0251927152,
0.0933274031,
0.0433854572,
0.0070984601,
-0.0456798375,
-0.005849787,
-0.0297423024,
-0.0407219231,
0.03106842,
0.0607196465,
0.0107319122,
0.047595948,
-0.0215993822,
-0.0703842267,
0.0445805937,
-0.0338075683,
0.0091561144,
-0.0343243591,
-0.0071431091,
-0.0160307586,
-0.0089145256,
0.0125528304,
0.0245596617,
0.0462960489,
-0.0203595608,
-0.0381745435,
0.0147385262,
0.0020683557,
-0.0309153721,
0.0694267526,
-0.0630382374,
0.0000743693,
-0.0169579051,
-0.0311086755,
-0.0340019055,
-0.0633193627,
0.0191351939,
-0.0061630746,
0.0324941128,
-0.0266211834,
0.0054734293,
0.0021553242,
-0.0109876832,
0.0369193442,
-0.0240410082,
-0.0062482553,
-0.0290936735,
0.0859879553,
0.0628925934,
0.0102575934,
0.0206152517,
-0.0673126951,
-0.0253394525,
0.0274587795,
-0.0238144714,
0.0704529509,
-0.0103367809,
-0.0178914405,
0.0471420176,
0.0194654558,
-0.0484761,
0.0504052825,
0.0725423172,
-0.0399221741,
-0.0483572222,
0.0906750932,
0.0139545165,
-0.0438854732,
0.053096544,
0.011607782,
0.0555261523,
-0.0080533698,
0.0144187622,
-0.0468119346,
-0.0082233688,
0.0088503109,
0.0386753492,
-0.0586293899,
0.013326711,
0.0073144357,
-0.0920440033,
0.0348784141,
0.0167428572,
-0.033765424,
-0.0664071292,
-0.0074491729,
-0.0140972594,
-0.0039207498,
0.0090974374,
-0.004603825,
-0.0013920211,
0.0308191814,
0.0584208518,
0.0638758391,
-0.1052154228,
-0.0527861714,
-0.0273830835,
0.1071200371,
0.038487047,
0.0373557247,
-0.0225006621,
-0.0055688992,
0.0243663061,
0.0161672942,
-0.0016739313,
-0.0076505151,
0.0024301859,
0.0205248278,
-0.0145506868,
-0.0045263949,
0.0569740236,
-0.0445335507,
0.0290259887,
-0.004614179,
0.0187797397,
-0.0182746574,
-0.038375508,
-0.0184759703,
0.0038468973,
0.0222211406,
0.0603363439,
0.0544360019,
-0.0442428738,
-0.022935003,
-0.0518087484,
0.0443583392,
-0.0556095392,
-0.0526393354,
0.0091680046,
0.0089431666,
-0.0100358147,
-0.0949389189,
-0.0486326106,
-0.0009128651,
0.0245016813,
0.0223069843,
-0.0109912716,
0.0029618391,
-0.0646949932,
-0.0296981093,
-0.0085563567,
-0.0110770995,
-0.0293724444,
-0.084396936,
-0.020764146,
0.0016740728,
-0.0634724423,
-0.0010451371,
0.0179563835,
-0.1253448427,
-0.0949754566,
0.0106250122,
0.0289704632,
0.0164469909,
0.0123335337,
0.014047049,
-0.0643544868,
0.053835772,
0.0730551109,
-0.0472037196,
0.0467083342,
0.0157109275,
-0.0183268487,
-0.0156651624,
0.032746803,
0.0125209736,
0.0012674212,
0.000841637,
0.0307133645,
0.0119648911,
-0.0087932898,
0.0397505239,
0.0097615123,
0.0277630668,
-0.0422783904,
-0.0414628647,
-0.0426005684,
-0.0240574609,
0.0083183739,
0.0060572466,
-0.040755216,
0.0036848977,
0.0231566411,
0.0262496211,
-0.009844373,
0.0032269517,
-0.0117705623,
0.0579770729,
-0.0013970478,
0.0338000283,
0.0064223078,
-0.0011074169,
0.0058823531,
-0.0180013906,
-0.001616503,
0.0647106543,
-0.0252492093,
0.0489416085,
-0.0301501509,
0.0469134301,
0.0040473309,
0.0000232163,
0.0068989159,
0.0446180478,
-0.0143217677,
0.0073264837,
-0.0245668702,
0.0295105837,
0.0780311525,
-0.0018011023,
0.0883748904,
-0.0511386171,
0.0310585871,
-0.0384968854,
0.0383850858,
0.008990651,
-0.0076712146,
0.0202033315,
-0.0117550921,
-0.0411201417,
0.0022352284,
0.1065527424,
0.0573441982,
0.0463009663,
-0.0079371994,
0.0244533159,
-0.026727315,
-0.003796563,
0.0336645097,
-0.0181023888,
-0.0208911169,
-0.0017563341,
-0.0264281426,
-0.0683802739,
-0.0122378869,
0.01330614,
0.0193468425,
-0.0562110879,
-0.0139075425,
0.0572132617,
-0.0441042036,
0.0220234189,
-0.0776353553,
0.0037534963,
-0.0191574171,
0.0106427874,
-0.0520104654,
-6.989340269e-33,
-0.0108226566,
-0.0401067063,
0.0116226682,
-0.0445561372,
0.0196443032,
-0.000682751,
-0.0505733415,
0.0147873126,
0.002703222,
0.0116270492,
-0.0079695182,
0.0039041117,
0.0118358694,
0.0019414896,
0.0188563075,
0.0086287232,
0.0581180863,
-0.0154412352,
-0.0274498425,
0.0227876324,
0.0226976667,
-0.0193842445,
0.0257250071,
-0.0583795197,
0.005702374,
-0.0415540561,
-0.0468844995,
-0.0175474081,
-0.0467559323,
0.0371491835,
-0.0256975945,
0.0240847785,
0.0388534069,
-0.0059784879,
-0.0380173847,
-0.0445448719,
-0.0568818375,
0.0265458412,
0.0278130826,
-0.008575228,
-0.0194627121,
-0.0588288903,
0.02679714,
-0.0232430324,
-0.0402305834,
0.039839372,
-0.0126278847,
-0.0208897647,
-0.0105511453,
0.0034872815,
-0.0485636555,
0.0211871807,
0.0069427681,
-0.0331441946,
0.0161680114,
0.0450342074,
-0.0103814881,
-0.0341401473,
-0.0139490552,
0.048046004,
0.0480895974,
0.0679064989,
0.0718042478,
0.0247838646,
-0.0267674737,
0.0162819494,
0.0382042266,
-0.0010234065,
-0.0040135407,
0.0219154097,
0.0401054807,
0.0383973233,
-0.0138964206,
0.0431938916,
0.05182698,
-0.0179363545,
-0.0152008701,
0.0459525511,
0.0035099017,
-0.0240341891,
0.0282837767,
-0.0017430289,
-0.0641029328,
-0.0422889255,
-0.0500948913,
-0.0724448636,
-0.0153549574,
0.0072999462,
0.0360468253,
0.0387612507,
-0.0143675311,
-0.0434832834,
0.0470783524,
-0.007605813,
0.0185168628,
0.0264437404,
-0.0636487976,
0.0243836641,
-0.0245650131,
0.0098267784,
-0.0800262317,
-0.0551535338,
0.0163770616,
0.0132629629,
-0.007213254,
0.0226888135,
-0.014245484,
0.0098760026,
-0.0314189941,
0.013993335,
-0.0311643798,
0.0254087783,
0.0142848846,
0.0176667254,
0.0593035445,
-0.0325906835,
-0.0291416626,
0.02064359,
0.0201903787,
0.0470187888,
-0.0178145338,
0.0358223729,
-0.0316467099,
0.0443191864,
-0.0218604412,
-0.0034710751,
-0.039527569,
-0.0100762621,
0.0298285186,
-0.0467926376,
-0.0210228506,
0.0183946416,
2.895e-7,
0.0142629789,
0.0351476669,
0.0334411077,
0.0115241949,
0.0085900314,
0.0681639314,
-0.0023321665,
0.0221664123,
0.0057533006,
-0.0138446074,
0.0035787465,
-0.0185171384,
0.0489944331,
0.0328036249,
-0.0449124314,
-0.0086688073,
-0.0027935652,
0.0302377846,
-0.0450446233,
-0.0257316399,
0.0288377665,
0.0680397674,
-0.0645189658,
0.0033634622,
0.0616152398,
-0.0305093285,
0.0610179417,
-0.0099068154,
-0.0254541226,
0.0306878854,
0.0327519737,
0.0110178487,
-0.0018898027,
-0.0462279357,
-0.0314147361,
0.0003296826,
-0.0079730088,
0.0669761896,
0.0640863553,
-0.0394121855,
0.0151084699,
0.0316321477,
-0.022890687,
-0.0456357747,
0.0314842127,
-0.0403025374,
-0.0432257243,
-0.0308414567,
-0.014109239,
0.0384497456,
-0.0330393687,
-0.0417548344,
-0.0331549384,
0.0256677177,
0.0159923863,
-0.0087837996,
-0.0368808396,
-0.0131902313,
-0.0457239524,
-0.0576518476,
-0.0555787198,
-0.0175048858,
-0.0414225571,
0.040790122,
0.0123774763,
-0.0670775995,
-0.026948601,
3.015812491e-34,
0.0137010915,
-0.0341355614,
0.0365522243,
-0.0075079137,
0.0222418066,
-0.0206572376,
0.0029400177,
0.0348053388,
-0.0111771831,
-0.0563923605,
-0.0295950323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08803v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08803v3 | StrategyLLM: Large Language Models as Strategy Generators, Executors, Optimizers, and Evaluators for Problem Solving | 2023-11-15T09:18:09 | 2024-05-24T13:55:23 | Chang Gao, Haiyun Jiang, Deng Cai, Shuming Shi, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing prompting methods suffer from the issues of generalizability
and consistency, as they often rely on instance-specific solutions that may not
be applicable to other instances and lack task-level consistency across the
selected few-shot examples. To address these limitations, we propose a
comprehensive framework, StrategyLLM, allowing LLMs to perform inductive
reasoning, deriving general strategies from specific task instances, and
deductive reasoning, applying these general strategies to particular task
examples, for constructing generalizable and consistent few-shot prompts. It
employs four LLM-based agents: strategy generator, executor, optimizer, and
evaluator, working together to generate, evaluate, and select promising
strategies for a given task. Experimental results demonstrate that StrategyLLM
outperforms the competitive baseline CoT-SC that requires human-annotated
solutions on 13 datasets across 4 challenging tasks without human involvement,
including math reasoning (34.2\% $\rightarrow$ 38.8\%), commonsense reasoning
(70.3\% $\rightarrow$ 72.5\%), algorithmic reasoning (73.7\% $\rightarrow$
85.0\%), and symbolic reasoning (30.0\% $\rightarrow$ 79.2\%). Further analysis
reveals that StrategyLLM is applicable to various LLMs and demonstrates
advantages across numerous scenarios. | [
0.0376823507,
0.01778787,
-0.0086035561,
0.0355806872,
-0.0602174774,
0.0130458558,
0.028438637,
-0.0174090471,
-0.0073951562,
-0.0260125883,
-0.0185683332,
0.0007282184,
-0.0202411618,
0.0019339877,
0.0243478548,
-0.0287366137,
0.0359841548,
-0.0633535534,
0.0604717098,
-0.0164191779,
-0.0172273144,
-0.0045129168,
-0.0264324956,
0.0398675911,
0.0040750476,
-0.0430861749,
-0.0318341665,
-0.0076459772,
0.009607167,
-0.0581405312,
-0.019862989,
0.0512387045,
0.0467566662,
0.001757281,
0.0000023118,
-0.0859557018,
0.0122924773,
-0.0238938034,
-0.0779684857,
-0.0396360271,
0.0123697342,
0.0101255458,
-0.0000047864,
0.0123251686,
-0.0655334517,
0.0209260248,
0.0195256658,
0.0290661454,
0.0661302209,
0.0691673979,
0.0103088133,
-0.0300903991,
-0.0020388297,
0.0002234419,
0.0461026542,
-0.0490307398,
0.0065333103,
0.0048153065,
0.0672372133,
0.0086313765,
-0.000173717,
0.0252723992,
0.0472802706,
-0.0255093817,
-0.023148261,
0.0285480786,
-0.0368375927,
-0.0099181077,
-0.0341772065,
0.0707693249,
0.0222838055,
0.0117062451,
-0.0087472033,
-0.002678232,
0.043961145,
0.0165824052,
-0.0509078093,
0.0390157625,
0.0009037627,
-0.0010964015,
0.0134897642,
-0.0068040537,
0.0237410199,
0.0236530937,
-0.0225225221,
0.091800347,
-0.0195470471,
-0.0353693068,
0.0388527699,
0.0081195831,
-0.0026947935,
-0.0615680441,
0.0005948959,
0.0950189382,
-0.1009118557,
0.0286979359,
-0.0052727391,
0.0032738622,
0.0157450009,
-0.0165079441,
0.0708693042,
0.0469090194,
0.0051408522,
0.0639133528,
-0.0201770365,
0.06157263,
-0.0061408519,
0.0195656009,
-0.024400061,
0.0150057096,
-0.0657633916,
-0.0191893652,
-0.0538976006,
0.0455739647,
0.0115998071,
0.002012284,
-0.0177613869,
0.0556813814,
-0.0213146787,
0.0669656321,
0.0142076677,
0.0125761218,
0.0038893367,
-0.0359243602,
-0.0577525049,
0.0108767897,
-0.0670599863,
0.0177265201,
0.0396722332,
-0.0538197421,
0.0009523872,
0.0071137999,
-0.0174951404,
-0.0084202243,
0.0338085257,
0.0627846643,
-0.0089939954,
-0.0124270637,
-0.0506630354,
-0.0280120224,
0.0234617349,
-0.0888962448,
-0.0188984219,
-0.0945800319,
0.02701772,
0.006139433,
-0.0425150655,
-0.0199645329,
0.0250852648,
0.0280340593,
0.0043567205,
0.0652934983,
0.0081973244,
0.0188973118,
0.0391584486,
0.0074428404,
-0.0406788588,
0.0645828992,
0.049318593,
0.0283183306,
0.0090866126,
0.0085386178,
0.0240003504,
0.0503406972,
-0.025696177,
-0.0021263848,
0.0032488974,
0.0187450908,
-0.0166470185,
0.0397769436,
-0.0294595379,
0.0266210176,
-0.0113555342,
0.0028908176,
0.0435392894,
0.0628511235,
0.0086238859,
-0.0242347009,
0.0454832688,
0.0018757555,
-0.0084983241,
-0.0186873823,
-0.0589877851,
0.0459319949,
-0.0262261145,
-0.0003053661,
-0.0152746011,
0.0106822243,
-0.0291682947,
-0.0503526144,
-0.0081726341,
0.0250432286,
-0.0063672909,
0.0393432342,
0.0614594556,
0.0011663877,
-0.0340089463,
0.0258689243,
-0.0086007742,
-0.005039209,
-0.0186610762,
-0.0498347916,
0.0639671385,
0.0854649469,
0.058775045,
-0.0238103867,
-0.043198172,
-0.015367006,
0.017487118,
0.0451800339,
0.0146230999,
-0.0339298025,
-0.0446020029,
-0.0538172424,
-0.0325525589,
-0.0181858856,
-0.015366667,
0.0180717912,
0.0210942551,
0.0052787415,
-0.006739344,
-0.0123998616,
0.0144790504,
0.0345154367,
-0.0105239451,
-0.056625586,
-0.0131464265,
0.0076200385,
0.0168295987,
0.032047499,
0.0060884892,
0.0217372458,
0.0185661055,
-0.030675713,
-0.017085962,
-0.0000396116,
-0.0412794165,
-0.0160349999,
0.0461714827,
-0.0026446355,
-0.0371977873,
-0.0228312854,
-0.0420041904,
-0.0347624943,
0.0050920085,
-0.0284250546,
-0.0052011418,
-0.0368917771,
0.0084877992,
-0.0023463692,
-0.0509945117,
-0.0197054744,
0.100491181,
0.0020129317,
-0.0258633289,
0.0656784922,
0.0256212708,
0.0029536905,
-0.0588237122,
0.0065416475,
0.0271796025,
0.0080168424,
-0.0030732236,
0.012046217,
0.0339507088,
-0.048136279,
-0.0101127438,
-0.0835227668,
0.0134530328,
-0.0092968373,
0.0191683918,
-0.0055430667,
-0.0160142258,
-0.0026704133,
-0.0164286401,
-0.0556569733,
0.0201999247,
0.01299656,
0.0356195234,
0.0193758309,
0.0266096871,
-0.0188613869,
-0.0024269952,
0.0013709646,
-0.0327136815,
0.0101372395,
0.0064627435,
0.0188653432,
-0.0664741397,
0.0595747158,
-0.0207145996,
0.0133571215,
-0.0024302558,
0.0112900343,
0.0515568405,
-0.0337503999,
-0.0004106637,
0.0761578232,
-0.0122215524,
0.0141799739,
0.0492413454,
-0.0324171223,
-0.0846938044,
0.0290023834,
0.0080816364,
-0.0077660684,
-0.0309057552,
-0.0209988318,
-0.0101272846,
0.0586273521,
-0.0135975741,
0.0269957297,
-0.0327779837,
0.0104672965,
0.0115706511,
-0.0263390914,
-0.07372839,
-0.0211006384,
-0.0064159879,
0.0455257818,
0.0009640817,
-0.0142652728,
0.0896302611,
-0.0094967792,
-0.0158705786,
-0.010018385,
-0.015699368,
-0.0471959114,
0.0645444617,
-0.0340563208,
-0.0212086141,
-0.0175919477,
-0.0114487363,
-0.0595786609,
-0.0246836115,
0.0207762849,
-0.0263188351,
0.046998851,
-0.0589394718,
-0.0057676397,
0.0028129597,
-0.0492684171,
-0.0720316246,
-0.0242795888,
-0.060981039,
0.0188235156,
-0.0265438631,
0.0041660052,
-0.0389068983,
-0.0098992987,
0.0378885493,
0.025509743,
-0.0102836583,
-0.0325681865,
-0.0230167732,
0.0099058673,
0.037182074,
0.0311919805,
0.0140771074,
-0.0184858236,
0.0791876391,
0.0439701788,
0.031420324,
-0.0221524592,
-0.0312817208,
0.0238298364,
0.0113629075,
-0.0404338688,
0.0000536187,
0.0609473139,
0.0366833769,
-0.0968103185,
0.0051362924,
0.1335954964,
0.0272304565,
-0.0222429149,
-0.0058811172,
-0.0641979724,
0.0077152667,
0.039454978,
0.0562547781,
-0.1027209982,
-0.0458763577,
0.0209932309,
0.0078259204,
-0.016589364,
-0.0425139144,
0.0018209132,
-0.1338905543,
0.0447156541,
-0.0053891083,
-0.0151114147,
0.040564578,
-0.0313326158,
-0.0097890664,
-0.0025827712,
-0.0072643859,
0.0380929597,
0.0059375097,
-0.0055433293,
0.0107426923,
0.0019122575,
-0.0197358914,
0.0443304703,
-0.0265630521,
0.0384351537,
0.0800205469,
-0.0097557912,
0.0020673866,
-0.0716838539,
0.0306226742,
0.0249892771,
0.0395686999,
-0.0282316487,
-0.0102989879,
-0.0210865177,
-0.0026460716,
-0.0271896329,
0.0545796528,
-0.047795549,
-0.0338923559,
0.0619993657,
0.0939314291,
-0.0392373949,
-0.0074372487,
-0.0180872139,
0.0076730805,
-0.0081787361,
0.0822326839,
0.0002280171,
-0.0436972193,
-0.0315824337,
-0.0383991934,
-0.0542637594,
-0.0320033133,
-0.033288829,
0.0261804722,
0.0160293411,
0.0032145439,
-0.0493667461,
-0.0589953847,
0.0807555094,
0.055655662,
0.0098513979,
-0.0085693439,
-0.0137303378,
0.0240023099,
-0.0332209282,
0.0004630958,
-0.0402944833,
0.021027375,
-0.0356282145,
-0.0023957095,
-0.0225142948,
-0.0602281727,
-0.0067561036,
-0.0009790818,
-0.0418309197,
-0.0579450577,
-0.0277212188,
0.0708667338,
0.0266669597,
0.0163576286,
-0.0068949438,
-0.033043474,
0.060650561,
0.033597067,
-0.0127472635,
-0.0116103422,
-0.0072935247,
0.0027877907,
0.0126839466,
0.0255217422,
-0.055519063,
0.0205882303,
0.0140204513,
0.0668276176,
-0.0626151934,
0.0121575035,
0.0388007127,
0.0213109124,
0.0029706727,
-0.035224501,
-0.0150734494,
-0.0095618805,
0.0204965826,
-0.018665703,
-0.0522033125,
-0.0304780062,
0.0097212605,
-0.0075723021,
-0.0269957297,
0.0491144173,
-0.0141357435,
-0.0178374555,
0.0106902784,
-0.007009123,
0.0407066531,
0.0299756993,
0.0454984643,
0.0154284323,
0.0050550601,
-0.0128656365,
0.0368440598,
0.0015406091,
0.043193616,
0.0130704083,
0.115900062,
0.0293681938,
-0.0051711104,
-0.0136125199,
0.0171861053,
-0.0352008455,
-0.0784908086,
0.0291781984,
0.0628034845,
0.0325977504,
0.0261510108,
-0.0399359763,
-0.0546986535,
0.0141470246,
0.0069888434,
-0.0140150068,
0.035597343,
-0.040452458,
0.0405850746,
0.0604400411,
0.0017517926,
-0.0313799642,
0.0479845889,
-0.0469361022,
0.0367660448,
-0.0022658668,
0.0087062633,
-0.0529853143,
-0.0182079487,
0.0084337965,
0.0249167141,
-0.0057745394,
-0.0043064677,
-0.0772047415,
-0.0288498793,
-0.0126406606,
0.0419451222,
-0.0169016328,
0.0064824466,
0.0389982276,
0.0384416319,
-0.0066487631,
-0.0464828201,
-0.0278353896,
0.0103222886,
-0.0491531156,
-0.0281630866,
-0.0210655034,
-5.794275774e-33,
-0.0327562466,
-0.0506124794,
0.0764853954,
-0.0042531323,
0.0199970659,
-0.0186170731,
-0.0335224345,
0.0134360762,
-0.0043176734,
0.0174243636,
-0.0293499492,
-0.0053149834,
0.0112651447,
-0.014522898,
0.0423630327,
-0.0221452545,
0.0153297232,
0.002370981,
-0.0422901362,
-0.0182612278,
0.0000604125,
0.0088586584,
0.027243128,
-0.0408956595,
0.034583766,
-0.0075588324,
-0.0083591398,
0.0542073958,
-0.0306731891,
0.0344288722,
-0.0086887274,
0.02641958,
0.022122521,
-0.0707602501,
-0.002438907,
0.0419053845,
-0.0353729539,
-0.0464671142,
0.0466481894,
0.0000292239,
-0.0492106676,
-0.0581415668,
-0.0098838257,
-0.0214224644,
-0.0413722657,
0.0110838348,
0.0211928692,
-0.0342662297,
0.0120825171,
0.0100587476,
-0.0431521647,
0.0007657818,
-0.0213765018,
-0.04281573,
0.0026868412,
0.0430210866,
-0.0357261002,
0.0109087005,
-0.043153815,
0.0519339554,
0.0123366825,
-0.0170449968,
0.0828348845,
0.0064303754,
0.009899552,
0.0499293618,
0.0173467193,
-0.0062408503,
-0.033717446,
-0.0241965707,
-0.0162757766,
0.086145848,
0.0444005691,
0.0293186177,
0.0015674313,
0.0418901145,
-0.0471216924,
0.0277614258,
0.0456437692,
0.0461586602,
0.0438490883,
0.0134967538,
-0.0501254611,
-0.00980228,
-0.0270286277,
0.0185613632,
-0.047587052,
-0.0466589481,
0.0329122283,
-0.0051091141,
-0.0069573196,
0.0035670446,
0.0317975469,
-0.0064381789,
-0.0095964139,
0.0120399809,
0.0125945555,
0.0280747507,
-0.005132339,
0.0136507079,
-0.0263833888,
-0.0018534046,
0.0237056483,
0.0052010808,
0.034396898,
0.0399142615,
0.0062186718,
0.0173020009,
-0.0246264022,
-0.0298148021,
-0.0505054779,
0.0082571227,
0.015694486,
-0.0361761674,
0.020101551,
0.0093590412,
-0.0193940196,
0.0473592021,
-0.0223531052,
-0.0759248585,
-0.0042894781,
0.02308001,
-0.0024416712,
-0.0098834932,
-0.0108505422,
0.0187505689,
-0.0190658085,
0.0285140071,
-0.0170901101,
-0.0206963513,
0.0159708094,
0.0343221314,
2.895e-7,
0.0014912047,
0.0526620001,
-0.0104446243,
0.0428011008,
0.0047824066,
0.0455886349,
-0.0373433568,
-0.0191564411,
-0.0018969798,
-0.0488701873,
0.0258720964,
0.077340208,
0.0204833429,
0.0249619838,
-0.0810057223,
-0.0015489928,
-0.0357831083,
-0.0151359886,
-0.0737940222,
0.024551319,
0.0685680956,
0.0402035378,
0.0122095775,
-0.0098639596,
0.0115681645,
-0.0690650642,
0.0278384611,
-0.0370363928,
0.004959092,
-0.0021845873,
-0.0176197756,
-0.0066054561,
-0.0005041031,
0.0369117931,
0.0151623972,
0.0090683941,
-0.034170758,
0.0686965808,
0.0057198992,
-0.0241840687,
-0.0193320867,
-0.033350382,
0.0006946188,
-0.0584911071,
0.0686540902,
-0.0381752141,
-0.0394197516,
-0.0068759676,
0.0026242363,
-0.0437755249,
-0.0360574238,
-0.0268086623,
0.0185557678,
0.0039828597,
0.0097848689,
-0.0374477617,
-0.0208978541,
-0.0469653085,
0.0017977095,
0.0058845715,
-0.0191773158,
-0.045603767,
-0.0554914139,
0.0028639787,
0.0015454058,
-0.051364813,
-0.0167920645,
2.449798645e-34,
0.0159683786,
0.0070298263,
0.0260879733,
0.0577810481,
0.0315290615,
0.04097303,
-0.0586087517,
0.0318492949,
0.0612918958,
-0.102218017,
-0.0295817852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08793v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08793v1 | German FinBERT: A German Pre-trained Language Model | 2023-11-15T09:07:29 | 2023-11-15T09:07:29 | Moritz Scherrmann | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ML | This study presents German FinBERT, a novel pre-trained German language model
tailored for financial textual data. The model is trained through a
comprehensive pre-training process, leveraging a substantial corpus comprising
financial reports, ad-hoc announcements and news related to German companies.
The corpus size is comparable to the data sets commonly used for training
standard BERT models. I evaluate the performance of German FinBERT on
downstream tasks, specifically sentiment prediction, topic recognition and
question answering against generic German language models. My results
demonstrate improved performance on finance-specific data, indicating the
efficacy of German FinBERT in capturing domain-specific nuances. The presented
findings suggest that German FinBERT holds promise as a valuable tool for
financial text analysis, potentially benefiting various applications in the
financial domain. | [
0.0119039575,
0.0642871186,
0.0127978371,
0.0278196856,
-0.006312361,
0.0120965019,
0.0164930373,
0.0007948054,
-0.0003005423,
-0.0527065285,
-0.0474132597,
-0.0572555028,
-0.051274199,
0.025765948,
0.0173109397,
-0.0085891765,
0.0430697612,
-0.0116714723,
0.0503638685,
-0.0325127095,
0.0359861962,
0.0193784889,
0.0357071012,
0.0193047393,
0.0183663461,
-0.0065562227,
-0.0140831564,
-0.0084325764,
-0.011053917,
0.012818058,
0.0532931797,
0.0257831849,
0.0107982308,
0.0440610312,
0.0000016526,
-0.0562948957,
-0.0365446582,
-0.0134691112,
0.0309519526,
0.023088783,
0.0499570519,
-0.0633558109,
0.0292714518,
0.0239272173,
-0.0552228987,
0.013543983,
0.0105134556,
0.097734265,
0.0717837512,
0.0724644065,
-0.02869929,
-0.0726078004,
-0.0143534997,
-0.0348099917,
-0.018438166,
-0.0605416335,
0.0037657295,
0.0310095698,
-0.0303477496,
-0.0095329555,
-0.0098309955,
0.0189359616,
0.0016862873,
0.0070540765,
0.0015614926,
-0.016245883,
-0.0574705638,
-0.0175147485,
-0.0452812091,
0.0364886709,
0.0193606988,
0.000188478,
-0.0006200157,
-0.023232216,
-0.0117954873,
0.025419848,
-0.0035634071,
0.0291077923,
-0.0052202512,
0.0072620842,
0.0487206466,
-0.0007813245,
-0.0137123549,
0.0076421988,
-0.0122015392,
0.051186379,
-0.0277332086,
-0.0419082306,
0.0562835187,
0.0467706062,
-0.0252267122,
-0.0450856984,
-0.0001280399,
0.0337471552,
0.0604036786,
-0.0000922368,
-0.0198813435,
-0.060599111,
0.0178399943,
-0.1138884947,
0.0038100188,
0.0182130989,
-0.0371656343,
0.0568437874,
-0.0201468375,
0.0085686352,
0.029244002,
-0.0307291616,
-0.0310458038,
-0.0027996949,
-0.0352303758,
-0.0007060904,
-0.0698897392,
0.0860437006,
-0.0237784181,
-0.0451542586,
-0.0300602857,
-0.0029836791,
0.0390749536,
-0.0152134979,
0.0079426104,
-0.0221186671,
-0.003821251,
0.0006457215,
-0.0342437401,
-0.0034519152,
-0.0423158109,
0.0112952273,
-0.0602381416,
0.019074956,
0.0110180192,
0.0233047418,
-0.0425330363,
-0.0406105034,
0.0214459188,
0.0338508524,
0.0164554343,
-0.0499011986,
-0.0330718346,
-0.0191044416,
0.0196461361,
-0.0188114271,
-0.0222262144,
-0.0325869806,
0.00799549,
-0.0015780433,
-0.0394611545,
0.0136667015,
0.020501174,
-0.0302318316,
-0.0178143326,
0.0599364415,
-0.0338880382,
-0.0262916349,
-0.0059579047,
-0.0511913002,
0.0183620509,
0.0589296483,
-0.0439221822,
0.0070295874,
0.0313787609,
0.0198338144,
-0.0325605497,
0.0618669838,
0.0120415566,
-0.0598564819,
0.002130829,
0.0568390153,
-0.0113572143,
-0.0539705716,
0.0668609962,
-0.0018401336,
-0.0062481887,
-0.0184351746,
0.0252653956,
0.0323785692,
0.0568160489,
0.0291154739,
-0.0354781486,
0.0158445481,
0.0666638389,
-0.0401100665,
0.0252475627,
-0.0250116177,
-0.0464618318,
0.0270481575,
-0.0359366201,
0.0017769014,
-0.0299343932,
-0.0204869602,
-0.0098141376,
-0.0244998522,
-0.0024022518,
-0.0096641267,
0.0537382029,
-0.0350476764,
-0.0401797965,
0.1004123539,
0.0327972285,
-0.0178307425,
-0.0046947892,
0.0147125339,
0.0463348776,
0.0786706582,
0.0170826633,
-0.0380512662,
0.0179243833,
-0.0256546196,
-0.0138351275,
0.0434134342,
0.0639541522,
0.0145218065,
0.0079718055,
-0.0265992247,
0.0119777052,
-0.0093562696,
0.0417339131,
0.045478411,
-0.0185445677,
0.0222048238,
-0.0140456548,
-0.0344826244,
0.0049231793,
0.0200705752,
0.0126597406,
-0.0179888662,
-0.0026421684,
-0.0533353873,
-0.0106710242,
0.0239524655,
-0.0352190807,
0.0036742762,
-0.0034341556,
-0.0094927987,
-0.0284530465,
0.0241804328,
0.0107183224,
-0.0202185251,
0.0027898906,
0.0149105554,
-0.0058087693,
0.0245465301,
-0.0207746569,
-0.002511966,
-0.0253470391,
-0.0340568982,
0.0510857068,
-0.0840341076,
-0.0415489413,
-0.017370956,
-0.0035520128,
-0.0089576878,
0.07646247,
-0.0215301774,
0.0372889787,
-0.0688058957,
-0.0106061492,
0.0204026867,
-0.0214349199,
0.0118968459,
0.0078278845,
-0.0162387751,
0.0608507358,
0.0587786436,
0.0106094964,
0.0242025759,
-0.0036293103,
-0.0976744145,
-0.0277667325,
-0.0423910692,
0.0358494855,
0.019623708,
0.0171443149,
-0.0062262118,
-0.0177588072,
-0.0243250038,
-0.0250528008,
0.0078252489,
0.0032886325,
0.0599447042,
-0.0026277697,
0.0245398004,
-0.054239329,
0.006222886,
-0.0049110306,
0.0290529225,
0.0711307824,
-0.0185466558,
-0.0205285922,
-0.0066538043,
-0.0262374878,
0.0383650623,
-0.0096259927,
-0.001991279,
-0.0285770297,
-0.0361940712,
0.0114863124,
0.0326901712,
0.0311686173,
0.0516033135,
-0.0589236878,
0.0210126787,
-0.047590971,
-0.003011774,
-0.0356907547,
0.0248636696,
-0.026935963,
-0.0008706999,
0.0517639443,
0.0385060832,
-0.040480677,
0.0117762946,
-0.061007496,
0.0219233856,
-0.0173934232,
0.0224843416,
-0.0432528593,
0.0054479069,
-0.0015415216,
0.0456061959,
0.0101668499,
-0.0274798702,
0.0511553772,
0.0036385539,
-0.0024902583,
-0.0645670742,
-0.0533091277,
-0.0729565099,
0.0200362094,
-0.0092825228,
0.0146439886,
-0.0140256956,
-0.0234985556,
0.0170565601,
-0.0365852118,
0.0428588614,
-0.0096299443,
0.0338551477,
0.0031359212,
0.0534685142,
0.0190927908,
-0.0153866243,
0.0042223269,
-0.1163881496,
-0.0232246593,
0.0257923119,
0.0464370959,
-0.0290170126,
-0.0530593768,
0.0280748755,
-0.0226740893,
-0.0030684855,
-0.0177207366,
-0.0182139669,
0.0078034857,
0.0391161405,
0.0606131703,
-0.0316689909,
0.0574655384,
-0.0401538908,
0.0236449447,
0.0181597751,
0.0282786861,
0.0063683684,
-0.0288438797,
-0.0156474859,
-0.0164864287,
-0.0600085147,
0.0028369636,
-0.0405386426,
0.0219752695,
-0.0146881174,
-0.0001515055,
0.1152480692,
0.0292886365,
0.0033204718,
-0.0142909065,
0.0044636731,
0.0141361654,
-0.0198676549,
0.0528818145,
-0.0694796517,
-0.0244310983,
-0.0379687101,
0.0421404764,
0.0195240658,
-0.0195312481,
-0.0076434207,
-0.1090444326,
0.0284285136,
-0.0244184583,
-0.0340990722,
-0.0134519367,
-0.0506875999,
-0.0439125113,
-0.0476576015,
-0.0029012912,
-0.005387045,
-0.0351948664,
0.0341755673,
0.0300259534,
-0.0854526609,
-0.0357743688,
-0.0024825444,
-0.015855724,
-0.0462240279,
0.0221352726,
-0.0075948862,
-0.04411323,
0.0225796048,
-0.013234565,
-0.0369960964,
0.0073111947,
-0.0285201427,
0.0539510101,
-0.0265684463,
-0.0366402455,
0.0058526439,
0.0104763685,
-0.0151411034,
0.0246218126,
-0.0109865023,
-0.0217271671,
-0.0382780433,
-0.003542515,
-0.0146721434,
0.0582828596,
-0.0063993959,
0.0781119838,
0.0012249016,
-0.0618567131,
-0.0132144457,
-0.0391460061,
0.0036539463,
-0.0591812357,
-0.0054577105,
-0.0259224605,
-0.0179256517,
-0.0327807292,
-0.0709345415,
-0.0902464986,
0.0084657604,
0.0390228666,
-0.0260431562,
-0.0130494321,
0.0286429077,
0.0106908595,
-0.0604102574,
0.063949801,
0.0107415384,
0.0045467727,
-0.0474289544,
-0.0235156193,
0.0524138734,
-0.0095009971,
-0.0732613057,
0.0042160046,
-0.0278326739,
-0.037606582,
0.0127731953,
0.0258062854,
0.0171423219,
0.0072622118,
-0.0329091549,
0.0110584637,
0.041933883,
0.0531173721,
-0.0958266109,
-0.0165669825,
0.0806447417,
0.0040042861,
0.003102018,
-0.001284051,
-0.0408861153,
0.0554368012,
-0.0076858327,
0.0078621684,
-0.0398084857,
0.0062265145,
0.0039958265,
0.0130420802,
0.0447175168,
0.043177098,
-0.0229975469,
-0.0168865547,
-0.0287493151,
0.03569429,
0.032208968,
-0.0561980046,
-0.0212135855,
0.0258636754,
-0.0192504264,
-0.0486167334,
0.053565789,
-0.0516146161,
-0.0137862973,
-0.0270198509,
0.0510281809,
0.0359762833,
0.0347878002,
0.0131415976,
-0.0036000679,
0.014445696,
-0.0032463195,
0.0462322161,
0.0012686325,
0.0079592364,
0.028496949,
0.0258560553,
0.0238810703,
0.0257062595,
-0.0311113019,
-0.0799764991,
-0.0171462186,
-0.0311113112,
0.0294739138,
0.0162901524,
-0.0412584394,
0.0239841472,
-0.054370638,
0.016755959,
0.0045135277,
0.000571458,
0.0125449272,
-0.0262200553,
0.0378744528,
-0.0030963831,
-0.050879702,
-0.0073876921,
0.0832916424,
0.0148609402,
0.0229034238,
-0.0188063085,
-0.0169991013,
-0.0496977195,
-0.0375946984,
0.1053429171,
-0.0023211839,
-0.006729322,
0.0175005104,
-0.0514425337,
-0.0267931055,
0.0213379525,
-0.0065180864,
-0.019722037,
0.0028958607,
0.0572993383,
0.0916646272,
0.0203707051,
0.0658498555,
-0.024978688,
0.0238661598,
-0.0423493572,
-0.0300046951,
-0.0602325872,
-5.705640194e-33,
-0.0190087073,
0.0084218411,
-0.0133223301,
0.0341336615,
0.0511015356,
0.0059269406,
-0.0142838228,
-0.003989941,
-0.0175784193,
0.0275871586,
0.0361382216,
0.041088935,
0.0114657944,
0.0283163302,
-0.0087730326,
-0.0132199032,
0.0295412298,
-0.0273291636,
0.0007880465,
-0.0158450287,
0.001835942,
0.0880375132,
0.0549224205,
-0.0429382324,
0.0268128589,
-0.0032834767,
-0.0257034171,
-0.0030158337,
0.1113515422,
0.0376284048,
0.0119587146,
0.0530879423,
0.0055097407,
-0.0822057873,
-0.0201448295,
0.0336929038,
-0.0439023152,
-0.0662883446,
0.024874188,
0.0476088785,
0.0309710242,
0.0377892517,
0.0297657978,
-0.0247428082,
-0.0015775387,
0.0241158791,
0.0544470698,
0.0214103907,
-0.0002435091,
-0.0953689143,
-0.054955896,
0.0353771076,
-0.0007940844,
0.0556935444,
0.0500743389,
0.0991874635,
-0.004537256,
0.0186485145,
-0.0068410793,
0.0114793992,
0.0198679212,
-0.0166322012,
-0.0225042459,
-0.0301124994,
-0.0173343513,
0.057119403,
0.0034717042,
0.0150673725,
0.0137706827,
0.0397638716,
0.0377683342,
-0.0079145366,
0.0404455177,
0.0241970401,
0.0029682319,
-0.0011158215,
-0.0333309472,
0.035723038,
0.0466999188,
-0.0133776041,
0.0111223776,
-0.0113967843,
-0.0042943512,
-0.0219470244,
0.003442483,
0.0103381909,
-0.003346839,
-0.0034225117,
0.0223542489,
0.0071534878,
-0.001960773,
0.0074730567,
0.0317056775,
-0.0500491373,
-0.0506715924,
0.0162485857,
0.0020181402,
0.0221811794,
-0.0056701116,
0.0270819683,
-0.0353924222,
-0.0265530199,
-0.0282128658,
0.024853697,
-0.001050589,
-0.0204476137,
0.03695428,
-0.0063236505,
-0.0487454534,
-0.0175727159,
0.0051508802,
0.029866524,
0.0044695768,
0.0526739508,
-0.0073174648,
0.0259872042,
0.0051913601,
0.0167572405,
-0.0084402021,
0.0123955198,
-0.010144149,
-0.0449943207,
0.0147933159,
0.0850686207,
-0.0026884279,
-0.0186721534,
0.0037871371,
0.0660589263,
0.0074268044,
-0.0400192067,
-0.0031471353,
0.0405997857,
2.397e-7,
0.0886673331,
0.0479225032,
-0.0307630673,
0.0040792637,
0.0210405868,
0.0448347218,
-0.0012513328,
0.0230728388,
-0.0083322851,
0.0146657554,
0.0227512885,
-0.0006488137,
0.0269439276,
0.03562079,
-0.0792588294,
-0.0616825968,
-0.0673943982,
0.0270268675,
-0.0697865859,
0.0543180779,
0.0220639799,
0.1016722769,
-0.0055867126,
-0.0133212432,
-0.0317065641,
-0.0562621243,
0.0706185773,
-0.0434665978,
-0.0544232279,
-0.0050363005,
0.0223076511,
0.0364119932,
-0.0149267605,
-0.0031278585,
-0.0194934998,
0.0176110324,
0.006953761,
0.0095712161,
0.0053646048,
-0.0172952302,
0.0219292436,
-0.0176948775,
-0.0225725062,
-0.0312786959,
0.0521144755,
-0.078597948,
-0.0180658456,
-0.0352614857,
-0.0647463128,
-0.0108520724,
0.0549692884,
0.0260485839,
0.0025162585,
0.0448800661,
0.0279201139,
-0.0348255374,
0.0217602588,
-0.0364310034,
-0.0079800589,
0.0586229824,
-0.0236652792,
0.0334425867,
-0.0309504252,
0.017074842,
-0.0003295018,
-0.0439693406,
0.0281257592,
2.001180639e-34,
0.0874274895,
-0.0386714526,
-0.0455495007,
0.0353223309,
0.0568985008,
-0.0073004472,
-0.019525826,
0.0236097965,
-0.0001299357,
-0.0401390977,
0.0191315468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08788v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08788v2 | X-Eval: Generalizable Multi-aspect Text Evaluation via Augmented Instruction Tuning with Auxiliary Evaluation Aspects | 2023-11-15T09:01:55 | 2024-04-13T14:41:24 | Minqian Liu, Ying Shen, Zhiyang Xu, Yixin Cao, Eunah Cho, Vaibhav Kumar, Reza Ghanadan, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Natural Language Generation (NLG) typically involves evaluating the generated
text in various aspects (e.g., consistency and naturalness) to obtain a
comprehensive assessment. However, multi-aspect evaluation remains challenging
as it may require the evaluator to generalize to any given evaluation aspect
even if it's absent during training. In this paper, we introduce X-Eval, a
two-stage instruction tuning framework to evaluate the text in both seen and
unseen aspects customized by end users. X-Eval consists of two learning stages:
the vanilla instruction tuning stage that improves the model's ability to
follow evaluation instructions, and an enhanced instruction tuning stage that
exploits the connections between fine-grained evaluation aspects to better
assess text quality. To support the training of X-Eval, we collect
AspectInstruct, the first instruction tuning dataset tailored for multi-aspect
NLG evaluation spanning 27 diverse evaluation aspects with 65 tasks. To enhance
task diversity, we devise an augmentation strategy that converts human rating
annotations into diverse forms of NLG evaluation tasks, including scoring,
comparison, ranking, and Boolean question answering. Extensive experiments
across three essential categories of NLG tasks: dialogue generation,
summarization, and data-to-text coupled with 21 aspects in meta-evaluation,
demonstrate that our X-Eval enables even a lightweight language model to
achieve a comparable if not higher correlation with human judgments compared to
the state-of-the-art NLG evaluators, such as GPT-4. | [
0.0493958332,
0.0287508871,
0.026571922,
-0.0081472695,
-0.0157230962,
0.0289544705,
0.0170311965,
-0.0366910249,
-0.0323666781,
-0.0425135233,
-0.059477739,
-0.0124620907,
0.0112802042,
0.0404210724,
0.0325059704,
-0.0342427157,
0.0342758112,
0.009200111,
0.0136080552,
0.0210194588,
0.0305162277,
0.0364437141,
0.0080474624,
0.0387322567,
0.0053264168,
0.0026731035,
-0.0030519294,
-0.0089598475,
0.0444944389,
-0.0173581671,
0.0269408002,
0.0555415377,
-0.006894609,
-0.0079498393,
0.0000020294,
-0.0169777311,
-0.0175230056,
0.0018752526,
0.0229539666,
0.0114213387,
0.0635310337,
0.0230632126,
0.0286573917,
0.0207505543,
-0.0346112065,
-0.0239520259,
0.0198976863,
0.0397510044,
0.1139545813,
0.0656539425,
0.0024958465,
0.0098638581,
-0.0269259736,
-0.0325228162,
-0.0001831113,
-0.013016128,
-0.0494628064,
0.0124638965,
0.0167287961,
0.0588383004,
0.019715663,
0.0230598729,
0.0577227697,
-0.010733366,
0.0357261263,
0.0286830813,
-0.0278247539,
0.0153924953,
-0.014246447,
0.071403861,
0.0232101623,
-0.0176954921,
-0.0049365615,
-0.0106225349,
0.0288129449,
-0.0348058157,
-0.0158765428,
0.0228860695,
-0.0002191923,
-0.0000922596,
0.009654467,
0.0256957021,
-0.0055904198,
0.0335298888,
0.0357212164,
0.0706850216,
0.0104999114,
-0.0324172974,
-0.0145506077,
0.0342266783,
-0.0322624519,
-0.0428892411,
0.0314318761,
0.0232902057,
-0.0590816438,
-0.007214149,
-0.0683155358,
-0.0137918275,
0.0219063256,
-0.0215020422,
0.0432263017,
0.0204133764,
-0.0083749369,
0.0212564375,
-0.0121989651,
0.0592742935,
0.0489890389,
0.0098823803,
-0.061721433,
0.0334641896,
-0.0573843941,
-0.0007865579,
-0.0360057466,
0.0453852713,
-0.0509457588,
0.0033585122,
-0.0500485115,
0.0117676975,
0.0064432556,
-0.0115186274,
0.0501081087,
0.0432771705,
-0.0365376882,
-0.0025828895,
-0.0308838282,
0.0169633869,
-0.0648736209,
0.0165858995,
0.0514337607,
0.0004826742,
-0.006963077,
0.0322374441,
0.0124085154,
-0.0238691606,
0.0109378966,
0.0059003728,
-0.0449623168,
-0.0103935944,
0.0065002479,
-0.0504458398,
-0.0366756357,
-0.0639796108,
-0.0436529182,
-0.0659744516,
-0.0005526333,
-0.0037182923,
-0.0287799761,
-0.0045555057,
0.0133436332,
0.0472287834,
0.0056263548,
0.0185469631,
-0.0014659592,
-0.0286631621,
-0.0033056415,
0.0102874488,
0.0368923731,
0.0246148705,
0.0312171374,
0.0490475297,
0.0032603091,
0.0242867153,
0.001828231,
-0.0031177932,
0.0215626694,
-0.0032646111,
0.0336438827,
0.0025129525,
-0.058984071,
0.0186361317,
0.0021273948,
0.0643350184,
-0.0344414376,
0.0043680645,
0.046603933,
-0.0221183822,
0.0153582441,
0.0285447035,
0.0786081702,
0.0498254336,
-0.0117853638,
0.0344781652,
-0.0300385244,
0.0538897477,
-0.0307526849,
0.0224515386,
0.0611641482,
0.0216468908,
-0.01564187,
-0.0961504877,
0.0069914078,
0.0127965594,
0.0138590038,
-0.0152910231,
-0.0049828682,
0.0455629155,
-0.0652890503,
-0.0083600814,
0.0066379691,
-0.0933207646,
0.0324563906,
-0.0376286767,
0.0278901439,
0.08400359,
0.0578843318,
0.0209226366,
-0.0307480916,
-0.0187774766,
0.0122876167,
0.046032507,
0.0382650197,
-0.0261568315,
0.0125245918,
-0.0664519742,
-0.0228287,
-0.0423984304,
0.0079418309,
0.018403817,
0.0033129661,
-0.0078140823,
0.0471657738,
-0.0448531732,
-0.0600194223,
0.033231508,
0.0080590118,
-0.0540667847,
0.0320199281,
-0.0051550292,
-0.0062792758,
0.0268569458,
-0.0124164792,
0.0284985118,
0.0017066577,
-0.0383023582,
-0.0325484797,
0.0114093171,
-0.0414492264,
-0.0500801429,
0.0020616991,
-0.05972654,
0.0117826508,
0.0074973335,
-0.0643859282,
-0.0605715364,
0.0119220829,
-0.0639580265,
-0.0089436388,
-0.0646837205,
-0.0031473921,
0.0379209295,
-0.0026659954,
-0.054694131,
0.0581205897,
-0.0197009072,
0.013125171,
0.0181864165,
0.001059465,
0.0174028762,
-0.0180662535,
-0.0181528311,
-0.0268800221,
-0.0105485832,
0.0359098911,
0.0479316004,
0.0806078538,
-0.0559114553,
-0.0349589251,
-0.1255994886,
0.0380755104,
-0.0398017056,
0.0533323959,
0.0619002841,
-0.0092907604,
0.0177042577,
0.0127279591,
-0.0772158727,
-0.0416574031,
0.0380985439,
-0.0041095675,
0.0295182988,
0.0147206606,
0.0518237948,
-0.0335224383,
-0.0113352016,
0.0141151743,
0.0163502339,
0.0410948433,
0.0359560661,
-0.038367033,
0.0254865736,
-0.0343388915,
-0.0361770913,
0.0461637713,
-0.0366660692,
-0.0010258344,
0.0136932964,
0.0192897357,
0.0459045991,
0.0263133943,
0.0078567136,
0.0404858962,
0.0103467824,
-0.050402917,
0.0219103862,
-0.0216014888,
0.0084227091,
0.0192693081,
-0.0335969925,
0.0164237861,
0.0608590394,
0.0130599504,
-0.0067923707,
-0.0634130388,
0.0484575033,
-0.0418784097,
-0.0463811234,
-0.0282081254,
0.0067630494,
-0.0001781059,
0.0042295502,
-0.0518257059,
-0.0314074159,
0.0949363336,
-0.0177752674,
-0.0064698895,
-0.0905412585,
-0.0020046791,
-0.01697574,
0.0176226776,
-0.0123844016,
0.0329074673,
-0.0058931322,
0.0050500631,
-0.0576180369,
-0.0004845243,
0.0239355676,
-0.0474063642,
0.0393416397,
-0.0478153862,
-0.011263527,
0.0055494844,
-0.0306512658,
-0.0297158584,
-0.0361308567,
0.0139188459,
0.0066723884,
0.0325240307,
-0.0061533386,
-0.0216942467,
-0.0209211651,
0.0129217468,
0.0417222902,
-0.0653301775,
-0.010348253,
0.0009976901,
0.0456826016,
0.0654668957,
0.0178856775,
-0.0017325333,
-0.0488912053,
-0.0000152006,
0.0440220535,
-0.0288002342,
-0.0001932297,
0.0029167901,
0.0013356181,
0.0073070321,
-0.0143242879,
-0.0135511421,
0.0095099984,
0.085597232,
-0.0724646375,
-0.0556648709,
0.1114707291,
0.0395197719,
-0.0108861225,
-0.0119675528,
0.0005983283,
0.0584223233,
0.0086650476,
0.0387067869,
-0.0602008253,
-0.0382170081,
-0.0180812031,
0.065085724,
-0.0046576695,
0.0116413552,
-0.0169478115,
-0.0920749903,
0.0111567462,
-0.0087959655,
-0.0696591735,
-0.0271205418,
-0.0056284466,
-0.0157564841,
-0.0374102443,
0.0280716345,
0.0130296126,
-0.0045383205,
0.0512572899,
0.023929799,
0.0093483664,
-0.036088977,
0.0172056779,
0.005153826,
0.0220283177,
0.0594989248,
0.0421645232,
0.0237147175,
-0.0441042855,
0.0322001241,
-0.0186471269,
0.005515357,
-0.0092841834,
0.0615491048,
-0.0091260821,
0.0048952871,
-0.041713804,
0.0447799228,
0.0062403539,
0.0025514453,
0.0089779729,
0.0171175748,
0.0023677389,
0.0166489035,
-0.017929567,
0.0264048912,
0.0190854408,
0.0711314902,
0.0406791046,
-0.0772319362,
-0.0364544764,
-0.0277741682,
-0.0005975121,
-0.1493746638,
-0.0384848379,
0.0134449759,
0.0157057922,
-0.0049114055,
-0.1173724011,
-0.0561325289,
0.0095887911,
0.0271489043,
-0.0103762932,
-0.048491206,
-0.0200694464,
-0.0136755044,
-0.0321418047,
0.0179730169,
-0.0111979479,
0.0111137088,
-0.0273135304,
-0.0190184899,
0.0167286899,
-0.0458671339,
-0.023248421,
0.0523779467,
-0.0792539418,
-0.0440685153,
-0.0235635582,
0.0618736185,
0.0092965299,
0.0323724188,
-0.0196455196,
-0.0318919532,
0.0287393685,
0.0343667269,
-0.017596921,
0.0132134883,
0.0310726557,
-0.0000931028,
-0.007627124,
0.027011767,
-0.0233958438,
0.0326012596,
0.002913431,
0.0402829014,
-0.0122949425,
-0.0287909433,
0.0358954668,
0.0304009523,
-0.0197158512,
-0.0357584767,
0.0172363091,
-0.0278755892,
-0.0065823649,
-0.011752666,
-0.027373651,
-0.0604225211,
0.0258572623,
0.0068919207,
-0.0213033687,
-0.0042004557,
0.0463326126,
-0.0149730174,
0.0564570501,
-0.0573747568,
0.0190635473,
-0.0128293475,
0.0004959455,
-0.0342956521,
-0.0013927305,
-0.03973848,
-0.0141580403,
-0.014218526,
0.0461989455,
-0.0157109182,
0.0592284463,
0.0120176384,
0.0062580742,
0.0099789947,
0.0706788376,
-0.05379951,
0.0376312211,
-0.0788794681,
-0.0117052356,
0.0030695563,
0.0042169532,
0.0831032842,
-0.0016200125,
-0.0183027964,
-0.0236577503,
0.052841831,
0.0017100971,
-0.0301227365,
-0.0222400073,
0.0194818359,
-0.0024403967,
-0.0237119589,
0.0589582548,
-0.0381510332,
0.0074666953,
0.0041758106,
-0.0005196786,
-0.0559840687,
-0.0447458588,
-0.0370081812,
0.0331545211,
0.0041865376,
0.0034945211,
-0.0420633517,
-0.0462389812,
-0.0399761871,
0.05924486,
0.0200407561,
-0.00645321,
0.0609749407,
0.0256302841,
-0.0311923586,
-0.0050360016,
-0.0587033778,
-0.040158879,
0.0166362058,
-0.0067462507,
-0.0378645547,
-6.217022848e-33,
-0.0466556475,
-0.0280965026,
0.0065908995,
-0.048679959,
-0.0262337681,
0.0175843667,
-0.0428632349,
0.0159402043,
0.0171643812,
0.0183128808,
0.0171974506,
-0.0185171235,
-0.0019388268,
0.0583581068,
-0.0028687643,
-0.0104448963,
0.0585771501,
-0.0032648693,
-0.0670283288,
0.0607291758,
0.039947737,
-0.0101767257,
0.038456209,
-0.0408467799,
0.0273517054,
0.0056504915,
-0.0708786324,
-0.010905277,
-0.0201834887,
0.0642100945,
0.0062975627,
0.0262118652,
0.0290167257,
-0.061143335,
-0.037572857,
-0.0015472138,
-0.048322577,
-0.0431809314,
0.025340518,
-0.0388671011,
-0.0913855433,
-0.0489087068,
0.0337079614,
-0.0268217791,
-0.0034126714,
-0.0139246285,
0.0377561525,
-0.0313725471,
0.0108535597,
-0.0473343246,
-0.0418191627,
0.0117969261,
-0.021167729,
-0.0527115092,
-0.0154370302,
0.0759803504,
-0.0246251356,
-0.0041760411,
-0.0136923827,
0.0335586295,
0.0202050414,
0.0410912931,
0.054533869,
0.0174305886,
-0.0434681512,
0.0317240171,
-0.023783762,
-0.0009111294,
-0.0321712047,
0.005689146,
0.0074311025,
0.0206872188,
0.040486455,
0.0589938536,
0.0319662094,
0.0033331397,
-0.0116372816,
0.0691472515,
-0.0135908416,
0.0052726106,
0.0205857772,
-0.0333740935,
-0.0188789964,
-0.0011357904,
-0.0666369274,
-0.0158290882,
-0.0495679788,
-0.0251619443,
0.0427944772,
0.0243835356,
-0.0629773587,
-0.0106687713,
0.0151663525,
-0.0131682502,
0.017836649,
0.0251529887,
-0.0535970405,
0.0104631297,
-0.0017367038,
0.0094203539,
-0.0450032689,
0.0172475185,
0.0542178042,
0.0334094092,
-0.0044176001,
-0.0152251543,
0.0743483379,
0.0129243927,
-0.0679412857,
0.0502548851,
-0.0289073791,
0.066989176,
-0.0268939845,
0.0203417223,
-0.0001754561,
-0.0121257557,
-0.0406753942,
0.0700807124,
-0.016074609,
0.0164589025,
-0.0465059541,
-0.0376554877,
0.0275440495,
0.0193830822,
-0.0287760086,
0.0467134267,
0.0030487278,
-0.0366075784,
-0.0073783989,
-0.0238717496,
-0.0148629555,
0.0398776084,
2.601e-7,
0.0316911452,
0.0366926454,
0.0191202685,
0.0066277394,
-0.0059084357,
0.0326766334,
0.0307392739,
0.0288121589,
0.0249883104,
-0.020852657,
0.0181904342,
0.031382788,
0.0607697256,
0.0185632892,
-0.0374798141,
0.03640588,
-0.0454072952,
-0.0012622235,
-0.0176612698,
-0.0388794057,
0.0904501528,
0.066946514,
-0.014219895,
0.0024533272,
0.0199494604,
0.0008768718,
0.0449883007,
0.0031357941,
-0.0437975675,
0.022072427,
0.0154400477,
0.0121214744,
-0.009722692,
0.0006246598,
-0.0332993232,
-0.0182518475,
0.0307960156,
0.0873789787,
0.0231462196,
-0.0516967587,
0.0103203002,
-0.0025220073,
0.0139255486,
-0.0277855415,
0.0713379383,
-0.0422546603,
-0.0063638552,
-0.0249006525,
-0.0202590767,
0.0315301903,
0.0112052653,
-0.0301604681,
-0.0372946039,
0.031942185,
0.0067294762,
-0.0073490115,
-0.0059509887,
-0.0354448818,
-0.0581257977,
0.0332648717,
-0.0102181463,
-0.0180245508,
-0.0368030779,
0.0212505888,
-0.0180201121,
-0.094361186,
-0.0089385109,
2.429711007e-34,
0.0559177995,
-0.0295688584,
0.0356476158,
-0.04055297,
0.0209083743,
0.0206667613,
-0.0425840653,
-0.0368703306,
0.0415980183,
-0.0337529518,
-0.0127775632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08768v1 | Three Conjectures on Unexpectedeness | 2023-11-15T08:24:41 | 2023-11-15T08:24:41 | Giovanni Sileno, Jean-Louis Dessalles | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.SY, eess.SY, math.IT | Unexpectedness is a central concept in Simplicity Theory, a theory of
cognition relating various inferential processes to the computation of
Kolmogorov complexities, rather than probabilities. Its predictive power has
been confirmed by several experiments with human subjects, yet its theoretical
basis remains largely unexplored: why does it work? This paper lays the
groundwork for three theoretical conjectures. First, unexpectedness can be seen
as a generalization of Bayes' rule. Second, the frequentist core of
unexpectedness can be connected to the function of tracking ergodic properties
of the world. Third, unexpectedness can be seen as constituent of various
measures of divergence between the entropy of the world (environment) and the
variety of the observer (system). The resulting framework hints to research
directions that go beyond the division between probabilistic and logical
approaches, potentially bringing new insights into the extraction of causal
relations, and into the role of descriptive mechanisms in learning. | [
-0.0015064678,
0.0169384945,
-0.0366285965,
-0.0184298232,
-0.0274945293,
0.0311698969,
-0.0589943491,
0.0401081368,
0.0028018199,
0.0072295321,
0.0487818569,
0.005887344,
0.0084042531,
-0.0225969274,
0.0469380245,
-0.0640018582,
-0.0124976514,
-0.025145188,
-0.0017984679,
-0.0094966376,
-0.0562276728,
-0.1079991609,
-0.0045736623,
0.014179239,
0.0507141799,
0.015273829,
-0.0308195632,
-0.0107279271,
-0.0226084925,
-0.0335449912,
-0.0499665253,
0.0150033552,
-0.0115033202,
0.0401597656,
0.0000021031,
-0.0607249551,
0.0047415192,
-0.0213214103,
0.0020013989,
-0.0130704893,
-0.0577840917,
-0.0208659545,
-0.0058487304,
-0.0213829726,
-0.0203748234,
0.0087910872,
0.0654929355,
0.0094090486,
-0.1059801802,
0.0318639129,
0.0019025515,
-0.0283644963,
-0.0170507357,
-0.0332019217,
0.0919990018,
0.0542372838,
0.0235916432,
-0.0670376569,
-0.0200322568,
-0.0543667339,
-0.0572375096,
-0.0538497232,
0.0387520567,
0.0744752511,
0.0157393124,
0.0339175016,
0.0446608961,
-0.0060605872,
-0.0075758733,
0.042312894,
0.0165206213,
-0.0120655457,
0.0006729245,
0.0052709794,
0.005793374,
0.0562170483,
-0.0351347066,
-0.0130858785,
0.0011418245,
0.0155300349,
0.0120454663,
0.0663916245,
0.0314921103,
0.0072110607,
-0.0031373156,
0.0835772604,
0.0007561463,
-0.0299863014,
-0.0102913249,
0.0636408851,
0.0033871848,
-0.045978684,
-0.0785940513,
-0.0181980878,
0.0329125151,
-0.0142689319,
0.0446400121,
0.0243669935,
-0.0079801073,
-0.0220272094,
0.0248151179,
0.0124412049,
0.0048941281,
0.0169458669,
0.009290739,
0.0423503816,
-0.0311607122,
-0.0029941641,
-0.0366636142,
0.0833092108,
-0.0128638875,
0.0306497253,
0.0372850634,
0.0049934178,
0.0130776791,
-0.0066289199,
-0.0334974937,
0.0019056536,
-0.0247463491,
0.026319867,
-0.0781290978,
-0.0222014859,
-0.0302509237,
-0.0391908325,
-0.0474088416,
-0.0276594069,
-0.0578537062,
0.0443702638,
0.0007551175,
-0.0153382318,
-0.0311843082,
-0.0090427948,
0.0112653822,
0.0207976419,
-0.0289566983,
0.073609516,
0.0566718876,
-0.0019608252,
-0.0407856517,
-0.0175836422,
0.027615061,
0.0217821635,
0.034825366,
-0.0229261927,
-0.0752061829,
0.0180568993,
0.0403087027,
-0.0441983268,
-0.0120092677,
-0.0563616119,
-0.000924029,
0.0495921075,
0.0064937249,
0.0161004327,
-0.0404712707,
0.0179304928,
0.0036339727,
0.0582891367,
-0.0104418853,
-0.0079573868,
0.0186543036,
0.0024607191,
0.0743245706,
-0.0001576995,
-0.0156182656,
0.0127670914,
0.0054114209,
-0.0549625717,
-0.0527050644,
-0.0233064108,
0.0241938364,
-0.0045553241,
-0.0066149868,
0.0241009798,
0.0096880533,
0.0116770789,
-0.0314428471,
0.0225482881,
0.0266908184,
-0.0705664009,
-0.0121290628,
0.1214312166,
-0.0516064018,
0.0430441834,
-0.0394903496,
0.0424172059,
0.0176361296,
-0.0322931223,
-0.0389516652,
-0.0259909779,
-0.0139056016,
-0.0149402451,
-0.0151534677,
-0.0197060779,
0.0594565086,
-0.0081991358,
0.001392603,
-0.0366898626,
0.0149589116,
-0.001283715,
0.0051253601,
0.0080622602,
0.0365421809,
0.0540428273,
-0.0160333943,
0.0006793439,
0.0804428384,
-0.0010527892,
-0.0266790241,
-0.0441348627,
0.011214585,
0.0234283376,
0.0194623303,
-0.00108281,
-0.0069733653,
-0.0191277992,
0.0428736173,
0.0137934657,
-0.0443372726,
0.0049825511,
-0.0129500236,
0.0039822487,
0.0117644407,
0.0140533196,
-0.0182935428,
-0.0533237569,
-0.0354465991,
-0.0097497581,
0.0213872027,
-0.048115734,
-0.0185958855,
0.0450468473,
0.0376523286,
-0.0421914086,
0.0226837825,
0.0921786875,
-0.0110546108,
-0.0198571756,
-0.0266812649,
-0.0849357471,
0.0348210521,
-0.0173815116,
-0.0000416564,
-0.038169466,
0.0810130686,
-0.0389212668,
0.0531054251,
-0.0014375217,
0.0327518657,
-0.0058311708,
0.0228964426,
0.0012953772,
0.0400699116,
-0.0164961256,
0.051742103,
-0.0522606634,
-0.0074694403,
0.0482495762,
-0.0169145241,
-0.0131018469,
-0.0375166908,
-0.001273965,
-0.0480420813,
0.0174802952,
-0.0246647317,
-0.0356321856,
0.0173469856,
-0.0081550172,
-0.0160737839,
-0.0177098848,
0.0092184339,
-0.0286970604,
0.0052795345,
-0.0128166219,
-0.0078135552,
0.0549088232,
0.0309445169,
0.0182923879,
0.0461691134,
0.0037188502,
-0.0221863724,
-0.0611939356,
0.0079298411,
-0.0086581493,
-0.000161819,
0.0365463607,
0.0448724926,
0.0165833756,
-0.0055176187,
0.0115150437,
0.0169858299,
0.0232382193,
-0.0073286197,
-0.0260810684,
0.0024573768,
0.0058306889,
0.012730401,
0.0327021666,
-0.0055819959,
0.0513715558,
0.0536519811,
-0.0016515634,
0.0122732762,
-0.0291319918,
-0.0894735232,
-0.0060233772,
-0.007425081,
-0.0527713858,
-0.0381352268,
0.0504825599,
0.0228039157,
-0.0239212401,
-0.050023213,
0.0902990177,
-0.0256821457,
-0.0511161424,
0.0257639419,
-0.0599702932,
-0.0240510311,
0.0873650014,
-0.025096871,
-0.0513876975,
0.0514570326,
0.0494453423,
0.0117039084,
-0.0006035336,
0.0120854434,
0.0332302898,
0.0445608497,
0.0612739772,
0.0022782325,
0.0628666729,
0.0205982011,
-0.0565989316,
-0.0387436748,
0.0307057928,
0.0076363413,
0.0060413694,
-0.0646220222,
-0.0437331684,
0.0095819766,
-0.0565180033,
-0.0335695222,
0.0064094956,
-0.0253891516,
0.0099751661,
0.0063771415,
-0.00920639,
-0.0251076091,
-0.0149519714,
0.0353054255,
-0.0239526089,
0.0209088307,
-0.0547134839,
0.0141746178,
-0.0085588405,
0.0167697892,
-0.0296672992,
0.1100877672,
-0.0675001666,
0.0167231951,
0.0308774449,
0.0125460597,
0.044009909,
0.0172683597,
0.0486242138,
-0.0145917702,
0.0286925826,
0.0052583041,
0.0732092857,
0.0347968824,
0.0306075066,
-0.0162537899,
0.0596408844,
-0.0198107269,
0.0198796224,
0.049957525,
-0.0631354228,
0.0022904924,
0.0224973746,
-0.0274108816,
-0.0222699698,
0.0328456163,
0.0024707736,
0.0326705389,
-0.0716362596,
-0.0582521148,
0.0559784882,
-0.0185650848,
0.0134640234,
0.0080806874,
-0.0684404671,
-0.0373725519,
-0.0244673342,
-0.0016608818,
-0.0074607679,
-0.0618050173,
-0.0032739828,
-0.0010939823,
0.0526321903,
0.0387740768,
-0.0420105271,
-0.0409544818,
-0.054817684,
-0.0213302393,
0.0101722125,
0.0269999783,
-0.032614477,
-0.0892216265,
-0.0476211272,
-0.0773213878,
-0.0289506204,
0.0258469079,
0.023405239,
-0.0071690287,
0.0639123023,
-0.0208014026,
-0.0604737252,
0.0159636978,
-0.0005777865,
0.0035869381,
0.0199324023,
0.0486524329,
-0.0380321257,
-0.0701304749,
0.0036970752,
-0.0285464581,
0.0149219455,
0.0882701203,
-0.0131833581,
0.0117165968,
0.0085212691,
-0.013154204,
0.0350572169,
0.0360778235,
-0.0166160613,
-0.0131188864,
0.0556196682,
-0.1040093079,
-0.0305218641,
-0.0034305295,
-0.044013463,
0.0660300031,
0.0124025689,
0.013862988,
0.0009972814,
-0.0142995995,
-0.0306050293,
-0.0092923287,
0.0595358014,
-0.0466021113,
0.0138978064,
-0.0226048827,
-0.0384876728,
-0.0428065732,
-0.0324110501,
-0.0074175596,
-0.0319634192,
-0.0342432335,
0.0680132359,
0.0255865473,
0.0413648896,
0.0275495835,
0.0102108531,
-0.0003056798,
-0.0041692457,
-0.0007363582,
0.0343050547,
0.0656318888,
0.0292414688,
0.016121855,
0.0145514766,
0.0235726163,
0.0135663692,
-0.0200172123,
0.0302536767,
-0.0148228584,
-0.0197040625,
-0.0470250286,
0.0222779736,
-0.0038033435,
0.0671797842,
-0.0374996513,
-0.0328156799,
0.0253376514,
-0.0049460009,
0.0583271831,
0.0001018522,
1.798e-7,
-0.038159091,
0.0374321342,
0.0919476524,
-0.0561139248,
0.0190854389,
-0.0013703748,
0.0079022879,
0.0068001281,
-0.0028925692,
0.0653718635,
-0.0101395072,
0.0428288952,
0.0251274258,
0.0324593224,
0.0373917259,
-0.0397373661,
0.0361048244,
0.0317150615,
0.0069099907,
0.0455122627,
-0.0295816977,
-0.0178845674,
-0.0771284029,
-0.0752392337,
-0.0321219675,
0.01226578,
0.0388488844,
0.0184857473,
-0.0372603796,
-0.0285598822,
-0.0869224295,
0.0447464511,
-0.0239171963,
-0.0110816639,
0.0087381164,
0.0588315129,
0.0135857025,
-0.0145009197,
-0.0275277141,
0.0161605328,
0.0280301273,
-0.0304311607,
0.0537651516,
-0.0825071409,
0.0090121767,
0.0127947144,
0.0034271055,
0.0228947327,
0.0762342215,
-0.0108280648,
0.0232175626,
-0.0555504709,
0.0129267648,
0.0109576257,
0.0048655844,
0.0264448822,
0.0046912632,
0.0081943357,
0.0764580742,
-0.0350926965,
-0.0257779118,
0.0062401225,
0.0132845212,
-0.0088047851,
0.0156804379,
-0.0055569164,
-6.574240153e-33,
-0.0031035021,
-0.0136227747,
-0.0225686915,
-0.0281391218,
0.0377254635,
-0.0367741771,
-0.0324250236,
0.0234797373,
-0.011497004,
0.0367317572,
0.0242824778,
-0.0177705362,
0.0023454023,
-0.0122420639,
0.0758272335,
-0.0116555728,
-0.0005653165,
0.0151215363,
0.0157230292,
-0.0451069586,
0.0392236412,
-0.0140499752,
0.0207624696,
-0.0693601221,
0.0211218707,
-0.0060344161,
-0.0010943178,
0.0118181249,
-0.0023967761,
-0.0068328585,
-0.0378868729,
0.0222504605,
0.018152168,
-0.0357266776,
-0.0167898759,
-0.0570230968,
0.0437237583,
-0.0646384656,
0.0193693284,
-0.0122992229,
0.0051012449,
-0.0138374381,
0.0255967714,
-0.0056218873,
-0.0569478869,
0.0034206267,
0.0284190252,
-0.009155089,
0.0229102653,
-0.0055925306,
-0.0010721894,
-0.0128757367,
-0.0040782243,
0.0012290641,
0.0093841953,
-0.0224266239,
-0.0061206794,
-0.0721133277,
0.004126349,
0.0506643727,
0.0107138855,
-0.0356834978,
0.0101713408,
0.0263361223,
0.0361896791,
0.0257208422,
0.1071774364,
0.0358262584,
-0.0391509943,
-0.036323715,
-0.0152664734,
0.0372431204,
0.0092918687,
0.0442736484,
0.0256533306,
0.0059863534,
-0.0615655296,
0.0156304166,
0.0086203879,
-0.0017016362,
0.0334743969,
0.0107168062,
-0.0812932625,
-0.040711645,
0.0678760409,
-0.0053498936,
-0.0164502822,
0.0045281732,
-0.0256069265,
-0.0179323014,
0.0467622466,
-0.0004799724,
0.0098506473,
-0.0241355896,
0.0082594603,
0.0201418661,
0.0292202737,
0.013732506,
0.0179361273,
-0.0375490561,
-0.0123682711,
-0.017927913,
-0.0096088219,
0.0354992561,
-0.0004972941,
0.0054201465,
0.0015962648,
0.0280042645,
0.0017926858,
-0.0231758077,
-0.0067542065,
-0.0253194161,
0.080068551,
-0.1150966212,
0.0469066799,
0.0027020955,
-0.0231621917,
-0.0596518368,
-0.0004472613,
0.0082709752,
-0.0123566547,
0.0816108584,
-0.0336859971,
0.0477283746,
-0.0003675871,
-0.0402621143,
-0.011940876,
-0.0244114958,
-0.0014956599,
0.0062576826,
-0.0199982151,
-0.015163458,
3.002e-7,
-0.0325959213,
-0.0232653841,
0.0026585599,
-0.0572835281,
0.0734985918,
0.0241493192,
-0.0476796515,
-0.008167102,
0.0001152522,
-0.0031965082,
0.0269389786,
-0.0292127896,
0.0179354791,
-0.0269414242,
-0.0053510442,
-0.0599377118,
0.0111522619,
-0.0106671806,
0.0354865119,
0.0516549051,
0.0324111432,
0.0110909976,
0.0362180583,
0.016398035,
0.0312789455,
-0.0161982439,
-0.0214575101,
-0.0490506515,
0.064079538,
-0.0329479314,
0.0273221228,
0.0234319214,
0.0018062266,
0.0422880165,
-0.0154970158,
-0.0161524527,
-0.0152400807,
-0.0032369706,
0.0075020283,
0.0402055271,
-0.0031448922,
-0.0461860932,
-0.0050876946,
-0.054721456,
0.0632963255,
-0.0328411311,
-0.0361396596,
0.0671931878,
-0.048988983,
0.015648298,
-0.001089544,
0.0570409149,
-0.0191554893,
-0.0381220132,
0.0054488587,
-0.0022602656,
-0.0135364328,
-0.0195272919,
-0.0133308852,
0.0604013689,
-0.0022920144,
-0.0941015258,
-0.0317906849,
0.0115756067,
0.0097465795,
-0.0313595571,
-0.0443931706,
2.649603756e-34,
0.0085415402,
0.0423347838,
0.0066360272,
-0.0428809002,
-0.0170930792,
-0.0519529693,
0.0084302584,
-0.0140299965,
0.0755645782,
-0.0247536227,
-0.002099327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09430v1 | Deep Representation Learning for Open Vocabulary Electroencephalography-to-Text Decoding | 2023-11-15T08:03:09 | 2023-11-15T08:03:09 | Hamza Amrani, Daniela Micucci, Paolo Napoletano | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Previous research has demonstrated the potential of using pre-trained
language models for decoding open vocabulary Electroencephalography (EEG)
signals captured through a non-invasive Brain-Computer Interface (BCI).
However, the impact of embedding EEG signals in the context of language models
and the effect of subjectivity, remain unexplored, leading to uncertainty about
the best approach to enhance decoding performance. Additionally, current
evaluation metrics used to assess decoding effectiveness are predominantly
syntactic and do not provide insights into the comprehensibility of the decoded
output for human understanding. We present an end-to-end deep learning
framework for non-invasive brain recordings that brings modern representational
learning approaches to neuroscience. Our proposal introduces the following
innovations: 1) an end-to-end deep learning architecture for open vocabulary
EEG decoding, incorporating a subject-dependent representation learning module
for raw EEG encoding, a BART language model, and a GPT-4 sentence refinement
module; 2) a more comprehensive sentence-level evaluation metric based on the
BERTScore; 3) an ablation study that analyses the contributions of each module
within our proposal, providing valuable insights for future research. We
evaluate our approach on two publicly available datasets, ZuCo v1.0 and v2.0,
comprising EEG recordings of 30 subjects engaged in natural reading tasks. Our
model achieves a BLEU-1 score of 42.75%, a ROUGE-1-F of 33.28%, and a
BERTScore-F of 53.86%, outperforming the previous state-of-the-art methods by
3.38%, 8.43%, and 6.31%, respectively. | [
-0.0448931716,
0.0604307391,
0.0050608218,
0.0033932484,
-0.0076267584,
0.0420977995,
0.0089837387,
0.0138133261,
0.0209211558,
-0.0143941157,
-0.0277912132,
-0.0180318374,
0.0428541079,
0.0929666013,
0.0128683811,
0.0030034282,
0.0425051302,
0.0328872539,
0.0167990867,
0.0001399721,
0.0001444858,
0.0053622522,
-0.0595338829,
0.0807228684,
0.0315541476,
0.0039609317,
-0.0397044048,
0.0154395783,
-0.0030222002,
-0.0416891277,
-0.0150657166,
0.0641091093,
-0.0143340724,
0.023328498,
0.0000019975,
-0.0191569123,
-0.003810684,
-0.000748997,
-0.0380987227,
-0.0121999998,
0.0164493602,
-0.0148682734,
0.0244676843,
0.0001033792,
-0.0275268387,
-0.0309675448,
0.0843088105,
0.0932463184,
0.047183916,
0.0545551442,
-0.0282090958,
-0.0174303241,
0.0652220622,
-0.0200290158,
0.0204332918,
0.0284001268,
0.0189101882,
-0.0504265688,
-0.0110300556,
0.011324429,
-0.0436313674,
0.0266476478,
0.0168485083,
0.0361030698,
0.0239955336,
0.0459819622,
-0.0274146479,
-0.0137181599,
-0.0309344549,
0.0800677985,
0.0376021154,
-0.0119978143,
-0.0241493471,
0.0296800304,
-0.0252533332,
-0.0144196264,
-0.0087728677,
0.014523888,
0.0068267328,
0.0616140589,
0.0169993863,
-0.0139460256,
0.0203999598,
-0.0125566088,
-0.0314740278,
0.0245038811,
0.0242395513,
-0.0395518653,
0.0535848178,
0.0419993922,
-0.0330308266,
0.0074311346,
0.0735627115,
-0.0212705769,
0.0008742527,
-0.0105871763,
-0.0352946706,
-0.0828390941,
-0.0220785774,
-0.0062050237,
0.0118638352,
0.0421957932,
-0.0016646117,
0.012830561,
-0.0262842588,
0.0054345727,
-0.0213811994,
0.0671370551,
-0.0394322537,
-0.0133041861,
-0.0521545969,
-0.0279887151,
-0.0272190161,
0.0089767678,
-0.0353384912,
-0.0569211468,
-0.0365798809,
-0.0319444872,
-0.0071058772,
-0.0634864792,
-0.0067459275,
0.0537952892,
-0.0263525434,
0.0242766608,
0.0168766435,
0.0270197429,
0.0262152757,
0.0075517218,
0.0204771571,
-0.025740467,
-0.0281917844,
0.0249246489,
0.0155926729,
-0.0129168481,
-0.0187750477,
0.0129472893,
0.0099406773,
-0.038298931,
-0.0106701022,
0.0156833995,
-0.0320349634,
0.0500871539,
0.0117470836,
-0.0443631671,
0.0265870076,
-0.0018984671,
-0.012984762,
-0.0796560124,
0.0019520865,
-0.018304307,
-0.0211259499,
0.058570791,
-0.0587774366,
-0.0457273535,
0.0585307553,
0.0318436474,
0.0604658313,
0.0251732599,
0.0448148325,
-0.0267933682,
-0.0205050092,
-0.0265550409,
-0.0229759123,
0.0379238091,
0.0139417034,
-0.0284498818,
-0.0275352001,
-0.0522134863,
-0.0003119439,
0.0198622011,
0.0454058088,
0.0310487021,
-0.0185280666,
-0.0334649906,
0.0612868816,
0.0777127668,
-0.0256102048,
0.0163668562,
-0.0251459964,
0.0286597516,
0.0290275626,
-0.0282018688,
0.0055033453,
-0.0074688904,
0.03713236,
-0.0303280987,
0.0173063036,
-0.0630773306,
-0.0003199731,
-0.0062300512,
0.0451654792,
-0.05285649,
0.0438134,
0.0202429686,
0.033186011,
-0.0222679209,
-0.0540178604,
0.055829525,
0.0429032333,
-0.0315227844,
0.0271707326,
-0.0305513553,
0.0082286354,
0.0371614583,
0.0432043597,
-0.0211647283,
0.0022041374,
-0.0058831223,
-0.0183245689,
0.0617097057,
0.0129012112,
0.0188686773,
0.0508753508,
-0.0464024097,
-0.0509564951,
0.0160149634,
-0.0075549791,
0.0007815919,
-0.0363899246,
0.0232737605,
-0.0221009385,
-0.01924913,
-0.0475626104,
0.0525589623,
0.0016161591,
-0.0209252127,
0.0142535893,
-0.0111642927,
0.0236712974,
-0.0023567427,
-0.0493142158,
0.028946301,
0.011496786,
-0.0444030575,
-0.0195392482,
-0.0252924562,
-0.0488200225,
-0.0270160642,
-0.010653683,
-0.0126636662,
-0.0060132174,
0.0804813206,
0.0118243899,
-0.0217315927,
-0.005543163,
-0.0540711693,
0.0300577264,
-0.0377674811,
-0.0120153651,
-0.0027373726,
0.0406548828,
-0.0678778738,
-0.0328480266,
-0.0168917328,
-0.0174385887,
0.0140510965,
-0.0106754182,
0.0416499935,
-0.0362781137,
-0.0460887812,
0.0220234878,
-0.0329905599,
-0.0034689952,
-0.0046706474,
0.0177972391,
-0.0427289233,
0.00067344,
-0.1457625329,
-0.0153393382,
-0.0010365963,
0.0040977877,
0.0365029275,
-0.0154649168,
-0.0008434164,
0.0040560137,
-0.0011807493,
0.0075396826,
-0.0015271327,
-0.0079061156,
-0.0266297385,
-0.0045396769,
-0.0153133571,
0.0073055248,
-0.0155048491,
-0.0496102124,
0.0944562331,
-0.0222818665,
0.0029385216,
-0.071096383,
0.0240077395,
-0.0046466379,
0.0023492938,
0.0189465061,
-0.0177736003,
0.0590532161,
-0.0098595498,
0.0646515116,
0.063105911,
0.0180795975,
0.0228752755,
0.0305659957,
-0.0220544636,
-0.0300212763,
-0.0251693279,
-0.0113229845,
0.0462015793,
-0.0330155715,
-0.0047236793,
0.0490552485,
0.0552314557,
0.0715879574,
0.0091906078,
-0.0570021719,
-0.0275420789,
-0.0240632072,
-0.0654667541,
-0.0434881337,
0.0098935273,
-0.0449861661,
0.0225411244,
-0.0422901101,
-0.0379665457,
0.0544692688,
-0.0170161277,
0.010388351,
-0.0483692661,
0.0138540361,
-0.0008704353,
0.0206728354,
-0.0046470463,
0.0295431819,
-0.0462916754,
-0.0522725992,
-0.0083213411,
0.0373695865,
-0.0563666485,
-0.0213685296,
0.0086179366,
-0.0115984064,
-0.0237528551,
0.025000453,
0.002562738,
-0.0319250375,
-0.0181799252,
0.0086107645,
0.0116821062,
0.0562427267,
0.0290315542,
-0.0573898777,
-0.0321428068,
0.007635179,
0.0550509468,
-0.0244445466,
-0.0224738419,
-0.0211832989,
0.0571176633,
0.0305007137,
0.0104458751,
0.0239446852,
-0.0444245487,
-0.0150467418,
0.0650870278,
-0.0092206346,
0.0336572044,
-0.0739771053,
0.0113658244,
0.0127738174,
-0.013008575,
0.0132875051,
0.0258539617,
0.0090545882,
-0.0352755971,
-0.0189035684,
0.1407440454,
0.0214210115,
-0.084862493,
-0.0166610815,
-0.0270485673,
0.0453494117,
-0.0245930273,
-0.0198840033,
-0.0531995595,
-0.0420304872,
-0.0193644427,
0.0571428686,
0.0689651817,
-0.0187983215,
-0.0113859419,
-0.0160716921,
0.0072211702,
-0.0044814236,
-0.0161523465,
-0.0215457678,
-0.0453763604,
-0.0060782642,
0.0073546986,
0.0129998773,
-0.0019864163,
0.0122428043,
0.0171092246,
0.0287425928,
-0.0144488038,
-0.0482355058,
-0.0049947966,
-0.0517221652,
0.0600389801,
0.0586035438,
-0.0117474394,
-0.0294383001,
0.0009567259,
-0.0194587111,
-0.0172963552,
-0.0309713278,
-0.0127583928,
0.0315572098,
0.0061573568,
-0.0281964894,
-0.027878331,
0.0225111768,
-0.0429955088,
-0.0642207637,
-0.0289910324,
0.0493367612,
-0.0567195602,
-0.0148127005,
-0.0048878151,
0.0023291819,
0.0289314985,
0.0694929734,
0.0596026666,
-0.0936899185,
-0.0449735522,
0.001052183,
0.0463089421,
-0.0398495384,
-0.0532084443,
0.009106948,
0.0288514532,
-0.0239187721,
-0.0338251106,
-0.0414555073,
0.0413863473,
-0.0257082786,
0.0418449827,
0.0214269329,
0.0826037452,
-0.0433961153,
-0.0460912921,
0.0550609268,
-0.0016776912,
-0.0130833546,
-0.0616735369,
-0.0231584385,
-0.0060359729,
-0.009526914,
-0.0277450085,
0.0298302826,
-0.0338805877,
-0.0288121924,
0.0883266032,
0.0184787102,
0.0071103312,
-0.021878615,
0.0192976706,
-0.0547159687,
0.0446660556,
0.0318887085,
-0.0068758265,
0.0402159803,
-0.0066305608,
0.0404303595,
-0.0189421326,
0.0112145608,
0.007980776,
0.0321333222,
0.0085120527,
0.0346485451,
0.0233951919,
-0.0207048599,
0.0162520241,
0.021345064,
0.0791704804,
-0.0101851849,
0.007074635,
-0.0385543108,
-0.0113191362,
0.036590524,
0.0707538277,
-0.0306961313,
-0.0339620411,
0.0327691361,
-0.028739227,
-0.0264206566,
0.0486080162,
-0.0010024532,
-0.0447952822,
-0.0312327258,
0.0106504215,
-0.0507388711,
-0.0100469077,
-0.0009756731,
0.0199274849,
-0.0066118916,
0.0284609925,
-0.0501905642,
0.012073881,
-0.031181993,
0.0633719712,
0.0206536166,
0.0009424708,
-0.0173747912,
0.0505426563,
-0.0038787073,
0.0043201149,
0.0633985549,
0.0183794238,
-0.0018947228,
0.0274820402,
0.0550967902,
0.0003475338,
0.0147399176,
-0.0595190451,
0.0450463109,
-0.0225367658,
0.015683746,
0.0442298315,
-0.0154015711,
0.0019612571,
-0.0235871617,
0.0501794517,
0.0021692056,
0.0055878717,
-0.0002024076,
0.0071672103,
-0.0379624851,
-0.0300746523,
0.031960316,
0.0160408914,
-0.0816309452,
0.0063841059,
0.0171151254,
-0.0214422569,
0.0348846987,
0.0072527886,
0.0070976927,
-0.0296976436,
0.0304745845,
0.0082677118,
-0.0380008668,
-0.0066873366,
0.055761192,
-0.0108466232,
-0.0428787619,
-0.0582385361,
-0.0505216382,
-5.988325279e-33,
-0.0042099431,
-0.0130585376,
-0.013050301,
0.0110736452,
-0.0179839507,
0.0277654752,
-0.04714958,
0.0559042171,
0.0239136331,
0.0025368449,
-0.006010144,
0.0194226485,
0.0053444258,
0.0399375968,
-0.0076155178,
-0.0194398295,
0.0019918534,
-0.037092343,
-0.0079420088,
0.0080512688,
0.04036773,
0.0639742315,
0.0978371352,
-0.0788266063,
0.0158484839,
0.0155936675,
0.0225657001,
-0.0393196419,
0.0051917499,
0.0210554041,
-0.0777710453,
0.0794448033,
0.0353495963,
-0.0022577115,
-0.0059139696,
0.0168820675,
-0.058676362,
0.0060480158,
-0.0248101037,
0.0060449257,
-0.0876805037,
-0.0150836678,
0.0620046332,
0.0125226658,
-0.0095538991,
0.0176948011,
0.0300180502,
-0.0273753554,
0.0011796155,
0.0301564708,
-0.0282159597,
-0.0250821449,
-0.0199786182,
-0.0002010682,
0.0201182459,
0.0187178701,
-0.0559028238,
0.0215260424,
-0.0680308565,
-0.0178355332,
-0.0123291789,
0.011480988,
0.0207656566,
-0.0175513774,
-0.0114238262,
0.0665397793,
0.0566089675,
-0.001359795,
-0.078609705,
-0.0200221054,
0.0884224623,
0.0386345796,
0.0522775352,
0.0102539482,
0.0265525393,
-0.0283904225,
-0.0768868998,
0.0496026501,
0.0066926796,
-0.0046766428,
0.0240856204,
-0.0402865745,
-0.0145792076,
-0.0190036688,
-0.0347835049,
0.0376992337,
-0.0318664089,
0.009080057,
0.0777406842,
-0.0475759283,
-0.0358838104,
-0.0224930216,
0.0517369285,
-0.038078934,
0.0703124478,
0.0171553716,
-0.0105600664,
0.0267594308,
0.0170434434,
-0.0179822799,
-0.0447624028,
-0.0258430615,
0.0394357964,
-0.0166699253,
0.0481962413,
-0.0199011136,
-0.0312408656,
0.0192868803,
-0.0138458144,
0.0025933201,
0.0110541862,
-0.0200861357,
0.0335124359,
0.033266414,
0.0332870632,
-0.0012662315,
0.0155246891,
-0.0278071873,
-0.0189450346,
0.0241313688,
-0.0095400847,
-0.0730239451,
0.053715609,
0.0444966182,
0.0224309396,
0.0391545892,
-0.0190145634,
-0.001951132,
-0.0232592523,
-0.0333939828,
-0.0243931226,
0.0271180384,
2.671e-7,
0.0697350055,
0.041584909,
0.0233627502,
0.0353996754,
-0.0104406541,
0.0178965107,
-0.0005783526,
0.0414670222,
-0.0261159185,
-0.0207139794,
-0.0261771083,
0.0620824508,
0.0335078277,
-0.0350764468,
-0.0384031162,
-0.0617918037,
-0.0329223461,
0.0559403002,
-0.0602602474,
0.0064293644,
0.0997090563,
0.0220674798,
-0.0490621924,
-0.0263883434,
0.0348390266,
0.0137967449,
0.0915684476,
-0.0439274758,
0.0306039415,
-0.002702387,
0.0026467398,
0.0016398645,
0.0082003409,
0.0373277292,
0.0196067002,
-0.0036301373,
0.0351131037,
-0.001102339,
-0.0478764623,
-0.04231387,
0.0243237671,
-0.0116284844,
-0.0306898318,
-0.0157478824,
0.0288258102,
-0.060257569,
-0.0785025582,
0.0083002532,
-0.052746363,
-0.0153321782,
0.0720494241,
-0.0207045116,
-0.0237957798,
-0.043503914,
0.0006153013,
-0.0247450341,
-0.0064279404,
-0.0261533707,
-0.0025608817,
0.0201847199,
-0.0354769602,
0.0373901017,
-0.0377824865,
0.0111465249,
0.0463349558,
-0.0643450692,
0.0219330769,
2.072041826e-34,
-0.0294837803,
-0.0008783528,
0.0448031425,
0.0295437202,
-0.0110290032,
-0.035224881,
0.0471117049,
-0.0259166304,
-0.0339922458,
-0.0904279202,
-0.0289340168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08756v1 | Accelerating Toeplitz Neural Network with Constant-time Inference Complexity | 2023-11-15T07:50:57 | 2023-11-15T07:50:57 | Zhen Qin, Yiran Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Toeplitz Neural Networks (TNNs) have exhibited outstanding performance in
various sequence modeling tasks. They outperform commonly used
Transformer-based models while benefiting from log-linear space-time
complexities. On the other hand, State Space Models (SSMs) achieve lower
performance than TNNs in language modeling but offer the advantage of constant
inference complexity. In this paper, we aim to combine the strengths of TNNs
and SSMs by converting TNNs to SSMs during inference, thereby enabling TNNs to
achieve the same constant inference complexities as SSMs. To accomplish this,
we formulate the conversion process as an optimization problem and provide a
closed-form solution. We demonstrate how to transform the target equation into
a Vandermonde linear system problem, which can be efficiently solved using the
Discrete Fourier Transform (DFT). Notably, our method requires no training and
maintains numerical stability. It can be also applied to any LongConv-based
model. To assess its effectiveness, we conduct extensive experiments on
language modeling tasks across various settings. Additionally, we compare our
method to other gradient-descent solutions, highlighting the superior numerical
stability of our approach. The source code is available at
https://github.com/OpenNLPLab/ETSC-Exact-Toeplitz-to-SSM-Conversion. | [
-0.0125236064,
0.0829561055,
-0.0044169948,
0.0206761807,
-0.0593764521,
0.0100467978,
0.0168491025,
-0.012596067,
-0.0228146687,
-0.0224643499,
0.0355577432,
-0.0808676928,
0.0371945202,
0.0277950093,
0.0546697825,
-0.0002336594,
0.0378549322,
-0.0646503642,
-0.054099489,
-0.0434510335,
-0.0013707284,
-0.0226409156,
-0.0236856211,
0.0333012231,
0.0008817874,
-0.0029898896,
-0.0200166274,
-0.0404838696,
-0.0228177067,
-0.0078566875,
0.0168960243,
0.0367331207,
0.0606409535,
0.0621629842,
0.0000023418,
-0.0089300089,
0.0100713335,
-0.0076191253,
0.0058456259,
0.0246208385,
0.017919559,
-0.0357385986,
0.0013914815,
0.0339645706,
-0.0297474097,
-0.0393210351,
0.0354497097,
0.0073317299,
0.0248772241,
0.0715182498,
0.0103071975,
-0.0261112116,
0.0059582037,
-0.022368405,
-0.0189234093,
-0.0587449819,
0.0255256947,
-0.019349413,
0.032316681,
-0.0149146635,
-0.0314522758,
0.0781445354,
0.0181605872,
0.0173301287,
0.04468574,
0.0210841056,
0.0357727222,
-0.0261828117,
-0.0429008305,
0.0266188048,
-0.0056725205,
-0.0492238775,
0.0076129739,
0.0177938472,
-0.0118128145,
-0.0345558412,
-0.0343484208,
0.0059970384,
0.0051477575,
0.0066411067,
0.0264389459,
-0.0357789882,
0.0470083058,
0.0320542268,
-0.0528487749,
0.0330327079,
0.0153589249,
0.0109398887,
-0.0063718562,
-0.0475769639,
-0.02873764,
-0.0547880083,
0.05378104,
0.0561444759,
-0.0023428209,
-0.0230387822,
-0.0236632004,
-0.0337894,
-0.047870975,
-0.0595681518,
0.0297000557,
0.032830894,
0.024031952,
0.0334075689,
-0.0207169428,
0.0610389151,
-0.0440980941,
-0.0444483608,
-0.0372819416,
0.013918628,
-0.0626996011,
0.0160827395,
-0.024644088,
-0.0098648025,
-0.003537843,
-0.0356040336,
-0.0252203438,
-0.0165456776,
-0.0033106054,
-0.0846876577,
-0.0150624234,
0.0416507386,
-0.0032687744,
0.0236655269,
0.002176201,
0.0751968846,
0.0304983463,
-0.0024071157,
-0.001966608,
-0.0071805399,
-0.0171694607,
0.0148479883,
0.00554437,
0.0040536802,
0.0184703525,
0.0584225543,
0.0054441369,
-0.0473097749,
-0.0174318738,
0.0410724059,
-0.0298418123,
-0.053500101,
0.0333436057,
-0.0971545652,
0.0273267552,
0.0052730404,
-0.0224039834,
-0.0487817265,
0.0133307707,
0.0049372879,
-0.0373674147,
0.074482806,
0.0145078637,
0.0174647402,
0.0621177293,
0.0109915426,
0.019066548,
0.0192624591,
0.0552352928,
-0.0148980916,
-0.008909042,
-0.0448936336,
-0.0118288882,
0.060733404,
0.0189140961,
-0.0179688893,
-0.0957429856,
-0.0277479589,
-0.0519799218,
0.0456086621,
0.0248758048,
0.1048414707,
-0.0084873922,
0.0022187349,
0.0338801928,
0.0558096059,
0.0222224686,
0.0425685756,
0.0447339788,
-0.0004220659,
0.0036629236,
-0.0193310641,
-0.0221359376,
0.0555447899,
-0.0168986935,
-0.0126231126,
0.0120696947,
0.0351852365,
-0.0184959657,
-0.0151967183,
0.0118604386,
-0.0258126482,
0.0510574467,
-0.0240192767,
0.0442523994,
-0.0276715569,
-0.0572036356,
0.0786861554,
0.0201137811,
-0.0191984922,
0.0134332459,
-0.0210255776,
-0.0190030783,
0.0366221704,
-0.0037087221,
-0.0016731091,
-0.0337421224,
-0.0532241873,
-0.047886949,
0.0244409498,
0.0018565156,
0.0162049625,
0.0050054537,
-0.049172122,
-0.0123546766,
0.042029459,
0.0138814235,
0.0114393681,
0.021774916,
-0.0250040423,
0.0440713018,
-0.0463672802,
-0.0093357908,
0.0171649791,
-0.0635739416,
-0.0361217931,
0.014504726,
0.0173952114,
-0.0003680811,
0.0420112759,
0.01722808,
0.0234182253,
0.0037255241,
-0.0529013351,
-0.0303988606,
-0.0583807677,
-0.0500929095,
-0.0613526925,
0.0509445444,
-0.0182187743,
-0.0241777953,
0.0961065441,
-0.0137836635,
-0.0437038317,
0.0581989773,
-0.0664056167,
0.0043707183,
-0.0171321835,
0.0066615543,
0.0211340077,
0.053937193,
-0.0293595567,
-0.0001265837,
-0.0482872874,
0.0412257798,
0.0105710318,
0.0373079814,
-0.0305481274,
-0.0167656001,
-0.0253337249,
-0.0198377185,
0.002045969,
-0.0155095207,
0.0287942309,
0.0072677652,
0.0492057949,
-0.0050038369,
-0.075068675,
-0.0287891608,
-0.014628225,
0.0046138056,
0.0074290591,
0.019315213,
0.0296091009,
0.0320780464,
-0.063220717,
0.0266325194,
0.0237686243,
-0.0206228923,
0.02263695,
-0.038062688,
-0.1015044525,
-0.0616339482,
-0.0333871916,
-0.0004719458,
0.0486591347,
-0.0642455742,
-0.056932345,
-0.032493908,
0.0215882882,
-0.0115541965,
0.0536379926,
-0.0057839779,
-0.0128213437,
-0.0115769384,
-0.0365015753,
0.0553763509,
-0.0054795332,
0.0423299856,
-0.0016644275,
0.0025189291,
-0.0179807693,
-0.0480590314,
-0.0057598278,
-0.0491791479,
0.0418869853,
0.0010172826,
-0.0371369459,
0.017935168,
0.0894414634,
-0.0155744199,
-0.021240117,
-0.0481639765,
-0.0183223188,
-0.0255694482,
0.010260378,
-0.0136244725,
0.0029620661,
-0.0183254909,
0.0020113376,
0.0080417134,
-0.0355827734,
0.0683194473,
-0.0681876019,
-0.0061310879,
-0.0412789509,
-0.0516274907,
-0.0196392313,
0.0296023563,
0.0292962845,
0.0051661436,
-0.0020394661,
0.0045952229,
-0.0528049991,
0.0039138743,
-0.0184588116,
-0.0368982181,
0.0436521135,
0.0092997625,
0.0080435593,
-0.0052626561,
0.0154215721,
-0.0144641874,
-0.0253085028,
-0.0182362124,
0.0395804048,
0.0363065042,
-0.0335583165,
0.010165113,
0.044340007,
0.0022627013,
0.020507222,
-0.0086434251,
0.0033909003,
-0.0217579585,
0.06810458,
0.0716359317,
0.0091494648,
0.0611174479,
-0.0326823667,
0.0181419663,
0.0062730913,
0.0729944557,
0.089500308,
-0.0574435927,
-0.0150572537,
0.0387467965,
-0.012366158,
-0.031280946,
0.0292000268,
-0.0226512644,
-0.0375784822,
-0.0305615775,
0.1023556665,
0.0115447165,
-0.0174474847,
0.0335376449,
0.0391537882,
0.0011609533,
-0.0025580334,
0.0050926628,
-0.049795948,
-0.0030700855,
0.0168330986,
-0.004648299,
0.0144343041,
0.0018003029,
-0.0291227885,
-0.0505988523,
-0.0235829782,
0.0400232971,
-0.0169003159,
-0.0290860478,
-0.0535693802,
-0.0237221438,
0.0158458743,
0.0224176385,
0.0495536104,
0.0050518527,
0.0138818836,
0.0406603441,
-0.0106781051,
0.0131821297,
0.021694798,
-0.0202856753,
0.0648012906,
0.0720239729,
0.0367606245,
-0.0205869488,
-0.0541078262,
0.0562574901,
0.0161582269,
-0.0180875137,
0.0094597181,
-0.030281473,
0.029305974,
0.0004249092,
-0.0161873959,
0.0643002689,
-0.0489667058,
0.0342772715,
-0.0279660262,
0.0564127415,
0.0177455936,
-0.000104459,
-0.009750112,
0.0447117761,
0.0092144003,
0.0628210157,
0.0446442477,
-0.0569482781,
-0.0575421005,
-0.0069134245,
-0.036344979,
-0.018262485,
-0.0489547029,
-0.0224420372,
0.0238826163,
-0.0479864813,
-0.0547534078,
0.0397047959,
-0.0135863544,
0.0422269963,
-0.018326357,
-0.001932185,
0.0275762901,
-0.0015354964,
-0.0474930033,
0.0276481621,
0.0133194141,
0.0535871573,
-0.0470240936,
0.0345083922,
0.0370878056,
0.0017550646,
0.0033729747,
0.0349170528,
-0.1136787087,
-0.0733159333,
0.0150105273,
0.0069888085,
0.0163129922,
-0.0211760346,
0.0061444705,
0.0097758891,
0.0399327464,
0.0181431603,
-0.0006328881,
0.0526458137,
0.0109217018,
0.0096286125,
-0.000806902,
0.0405364782,
-0.0202000421,
0.0157509446,
0.008338403,
0.0677692145,
0.0055878572,
-0.0420489907,
-0.0097364653,
0.0094457567,
0.0454658531,
0.0125793396,
-0.0245447867,
0.0132179223,
-0.008548432,
0.0256968644,
0.0371634252,
-0.0475099534,
0.0145121962,
0.0037360194,
0.0632259473,
-0.032911133,
-0.0467925034,
0.1089290828,
-0.0203154664,
-0.0059306435,
0.015992038,
-0.0240113661,
-0.0218076725,
0.0068376907,
-0.0264054239,
-0.011949881,
0.0433138907,
0.0100921653,
-0.0093646031,
-0.0536816753,
0.0536668599,
0.0096164634,
0.042953074,
-0.0361992382,
-0.012333422,
-0.0480763614,
-0.0502409078,
-0.0270864591,
-0.0136732971,
0.0888992846,
0.0019441143,
0.0354908705,
-0.0408812948,
0.0212884769,
-0.0159571879,
0.0234252922,
-0.0094821583,
0.0021210886,
0.0167051572,
0.013748168,
0.0016710722,
0.0133122755,
0.0581398942,
0.0609000586,
0.0414113477,
-0.0018449744,
0.0176405031,
-0.0297650825,
-0.016658565,
-0.051480256,
0.0196467247,
-0.0294087175,
0.0418995172,
-0.0007071552,
-0.0753878206,
0.0325175337,
0.0112128155,
0.029157823,
-0.0394569784,
0.0434429832,
0.0422391519,
-0.0194372106,
0.0584176406,
-0.0114159519,
0.0217313785,
0.0650306642,
-0.0747248456,
-0.0385420471,
-6.933015723e-33,
-0.0346057899,
-0.0100217517,
-0.0044585462,
0.0451252982,
-0.0613089949,
-0.0020803204,
-0.0336458571,
-0.0095731579,
-0.00209951,
-0.0390636399,
0.0158119351,
0.0158508103,
-0.0122577781,
0.0380772017,
-0.0004093072,
0.0034366273,
0.0267268904,
0.0163289793,
0.0249704104,
-0.0134330671,
0.0529556498,
0.0587372743,
0.0035054113,
-0.0300751459,
-0.0605352931,
-0.0252590068,
0.0090565728,
0.0235656798,
0.0264283773,
-0.031095285,
-0.0377502702,
-0.0130287874,
0.0059526782,
-0.0938812122,
0.0071104015,
-0.015486802,
-0.0675728396,
0.0108304638,
0.0165384058,
0.0246411674,
0.0098721161,
-0.0144182052,
0.0926954299,
0.0238088276,
-0.0429510139,
-0.0058595678,
0.020569697,
-0.00835968,
-0.0182806645,
-0.0711864606,
-0.0626843348,
0.0286202487,
-0.0081903078,
-0.0275271311,
0.0607788004,
0.0335026085,
-0.0613378286,
-0.0701388493,
-0.0367339998,
-0.0168297924,
0.0628082901,
0.0818107277,
0.0238347426,
0.0215874854,
0.0175118428,
-0.0060301404,
0.0812749416,
-0.0872971714,
-0.0423127078,
-0.0258462317,
0.0662941858,
-0.007072194,
0.057179261,
-0.0314768441,
0.0425068252,
-0.0194865335,
-0.0689783916,
-0.0089447396,
0.0439518169,
0.0031085825,
0.0315503441,
0.0149075231,
-0.0194111466,
-0.0250404291,
-0.0274981596,
0.0131193213,
-0.0384213738,
-0.019746894,
-0.0029669048,
-0.0025458089,
0.0064700483,
-0.0363413095,
0.0364589728,
-0.0455990322,
0.0335833803,
-0.0041013248,
0.0468949564,
0.0095338635,
0.011039895,
0.0296250712,
-0.0321005546,
-0.0257135741,
-0.0605914593,
-0.0089390324,
0.0366542824,
0.007116776,
-0.0224339757,
0.0195538271,
-0.0688240081,
-0.0386312492,
-0.0471009612,
0.0180809908,
0.0097614285,
0.0332847945,
0.0534106381,
-0.0407160446,
0.0024043701,
0.023356542,
-0.0168592576,
0.0092702191,
-0.0023178933,
0.0031360583,
0.0244834051,
0.0537010506,
-0.0540827401,
-0.0480486862,
-0.0060571209,
0.0365279689,
-0.017130008,
-0.0571271777,
-0.0437714867,
-0.0026415586,
3.168e-7,
-0.0203494523,
0.0480327196,
0.0201406479,
-0.0265998673,
0.0319157355,
-0.0056784158,
-0.0220460724,
-0.0035005885,
-0.0158916917,
-0.0139201032,
0.0169185326,
-0.0046427767,
0.0472103879,
0.0109925959,
-0.0461281613,
-0.021202622,
-0.0725511238,
0.0327231959,
-0.0040414585,
0.0181513708,
0.0077271485,
0.0748337656,
0.0124286674,
-0.0177728049,
0.0098553505,
0.0016585863,
0.0443842448,
0.0259768087,
0.0115661919,
-0.0124275759,
0.012122307,
-0.0401998125,
-0.0141194472,
-0.0273999441,
-0.0171955358,
0.0620505437,
0.0127545185,
0.0538036823,
0.0342882536,
-0.0103893084,
0.0096207717,
-0.0167125165,
-0.0237310082,
-0.0357835591,
0.0231581256,
-0.0451558456,
-0.0000660852,
-0.0298123229,
-0.0015028592,
0.0152999712,
0.0066836141,
0.0101861786,
0.0244277194,
-0.0000108652,
0.0157812424,
-0.0274691992,
0.0102496957,
-0.1085236222,
-0.0235754196,
0.0550880358,
-0.0500928238,
-0.0072085354,
-0.0564880073,
-0.0031013174,
0.071807541,
0.0177616645,
-0.0479952656,
3.235618455e-34,
0.033118397,
-0.0225634873,
-0.0252729096,
0.0082308035,
0.0200941321,
-0.023496367,
0.0248463675,
0.0126319816,
0.024189394,
-0.0690680146,
-0.0449084751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09263v2 | Auto-ICL: In-Context Learning without Human Supervision | 2023-11-15T07:37:28 | 2024-06-17T06:53:41 | Jinghan Yang, Shuming Ma, Furu Wei | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | With in-context learning ability, the performance of large language models
can be significantly boosted when provided with appropriate context. However,
existing in-context learning methods mainly rely on human-provided contexts,
such as labeled examples and explicit instructions. Writing context by humans
is labor-intensive on various tasks and limits the model to tasks manageable by
humans. To overcome these limitations, we propose Automatic In-Context Learning
framework that enables the model to autonomously generate examples and
instructions for problem-solving. With experiments across various models and
datasets, results show that model-generated contexts outperform human-annotated
contexts, including Few-Shot and Few-Shot-CoT methods, and surpass existing
self-generated context methods like Zero-CoT and Auto-CoT. | [
-0.0148940543,
0.0215239599,
0.004719513,
0.0363229103,
-0.0495802835,
0.0293119289,
0.0545666777,
-0.0420591868,
-0.0280262548,
-0.0846681148,
-0.0522065498,
-0.0284414981,
0.0047108317,
-0.0038378588,
0.0368332006,
-0.0184531715,
0.0292022135,
-0.0593146384,
0.000253214,
0.0072242725,
-0.0190083999,
0.0009210939,
-0.0183359273,
0.0366497748,
-0.0419085249,
-0.032427337,
-0.0106352307,
0.0039082668,
-0.0162112638,
-0.0462262854,
0.0364793092,
0.0920280591,
0.0414792784,
0.0288369823,
0.0000018493,
-0.0538204499,
-0.0035287098,
-0.0200679153,
-0.0425862186,
-0.0113083487,
0.0067428579,
-0.0166417267,
-0.0101331919,
0.0204737913,
-0.0566613711,
0.0008076719,
0.0131589491,
0.0290194079,
0.034728013,
0.0631246939,
-0.0187517032,
-0.0014054702,
-0.0109401513,
-0.0254536811,
0.0427379459,
-0.054283198,
0.0189087447,
0.0154563719,
0.0101645561,
0.0046740668,
-0.0222376455,
0.0524082296,
0.0509992503,
-0.0134279458,
-0.000192596,
0.051238101,
-0.0343029983,
-0.0169863049,
-0.0248773843,
0.0906219557,
-0.003414449,
-0.0527418293,
-0.0072979773,
-0.0163267888,
0.0093448088,
-0.0345427468,
-0.0452211387,
0.0377387851,
0.0124763977,
0.0161376465,
0.019681301,
0.0199665148,
0.0228551105,
-0.0009952586,
0.0017705997,
0.0214171391,
0.0185546745,
-0.0156272035,
-0.0247349795,
-0.0030523881,
-0.0401306711,
-0.0457548536,
-0.0113734053,
0.049185805,
-0.0539190248,
0.0311481226,
-0.0743711889,
-0.0229776949,
0.0100264428,
-0.0163909271,
0.0114603071,
0.0465365089,
-0.0122526847,
0.0490297787,
-0.0155019956,
0.0124245333,
0.0174892657,
0.0132325822,
-0.0164953191,
0.0011711281,
-0.0444678403,
0.0153158829,
-0.0821814761,
-0.0008056734,
-0.0423388891,
-0.0246011261,
-0.0279472712,
0.0599547848,
-0.0167409927,
-0.0019763333,
0.027124228,
0.0077272747,
-0.0477061421,
-0.0099624712,
0.0470376387,
-0.015273612,
-0.0330567509,
0.0101563428,
0.0178294946,
-0.0370380543,
-0.0098995231,
0.0237510242,
0.0369484723,
-0.0230547767,
-0.002250405,
0.0656326339,
-0.033569809,
-0.0812248662,
-0.0241838209,
-0.0078861155,
-0.0069486503,
-0.0785080567,
-0.055702161,
-0.0892687887,
0.0122999568,
0.0171703584,
-0.0197713654,
-0.049927026,
0.0058805039,
0.0367053561,
0.0144922342,
0.0837253481,
-0.031460993,
-0.0027519949,
0.0539344139,
0.01034535,
0.0078343013,
0.0684849545,
0.0240376517,
-0.0191692356,
0.0182268228,
0.0400384441,
0.0293255635,
0.0431525037,
0.0462104268,
0.0301229097,
-0.0424667597,
0.011940469,
-0.0029360105,
0.0312724784,
0.0211770553,
0.0492495447,
-0.0226535965,
0.0012614325,
0.0528498366,
0.0482749753,
0.0101487245,
0.0083924662,
0.03430463,
0.0230991933,
-0.0001118073,
-0.0160701573,
-0.071360752,
0.0275210962,
-0.0096501736,
0.0153343938,
0.00702703,
-0.0349518545,
-0.0449380502,
-0.036542695,
-0.0048338273,
-0.0208568703,
0.0041981163,
0.0085350033,
0.0553216562,
0.0542200021,
-0.0414462611,
-0.0000513752,
0.0130098937,
-0.0090090223,
-0.026891131,
-0.0369436555,
0.0351120383,
0.0354304425,
0.0338544473,
-0.0384396389,
-0.0332820117,
-0.0323983841,
0.0453741401,
0.0463657938,
-0.0109401112,
-0.0322896354,
0.0116670216,
-0.0193182733,
-0.0248898938,
0.0015821184,
0.0176187549,
-0.0028818336,
0.0386381038,
-0.0122658731,
0.0046226205,
0.0020572951,
-0.0037856638,
0.0395245329,
-0.0619274005,
-0.0715612322,
0.0161360502,
0.0155277289,
-0.0138420993,
0.0020150975,
-0.0063406127,
0.0114915986,
0.0165053271,
-0.0376103185,
0.0005335524,
0.0141251637,
-0.1100745648,
-0.0444992185,
0.0259779003,
0.0114617934,
-0.0480631366,
-0.0423763841,
0.0134521695,
-0.0230396111,
-0.018675521,
-0.007711757,
0.0607227758,
-0.0445714816,
0.0071672504,
0.0303212199,
-0.0094018914,
-0.0292489119,
0.0803852454,
-0.0016881203,
-0.0157692786,
0.0626723021,
0.0749931484,
0.0076302616,
-0.0264815874,
0.0064031687,
-0.0450312048,
-0.0227986332,
0.0152766313,
0.0064824973,
0.0586231053,
-0.04810955,
0.0336299129,
-0.1163802966,
-0.0028644255,
-0.0593913607,
-0.0277381893,
0.0428858995,
0.0226173587,
-0.0176304728,
-0.0250256956,
-0.0250437148,
-0.0298990775,
-0.005475251,
0.02329042,
0.0226645637,
0.0246661101,
0.0107879778,
-0.054845579,
-0.0069644232,
-0.0180527456,
0.0231492985,
-0.0014697156,
-0.0110734925,
-0.0415338986,
0.064953059,
0.0281223152,
0.0408423245,
-0.0154331755,
-0.0018132282,
0.0331982039,
-0.0422331803,
0.039411936,
0.0579525866,
-0.0092057846,
0.0467488915,
0.041467838,
-0.0140259359,
-0.0581257381,
0.0132545531,
0.0033779466,
0.0063320897,
0.0122173075,
-0.0063418481,
-0.0287865959,
0.0872070566,
0.0100659681,
0.0053441892,
-0.0339259617,
0.0075406204,
-0.0139693785,
-0.0339632742,
-0.0770452842,
-0.0022173466,
-0.0295020379,
0.0456572212,
-0.0229203328,
-0.0471261628,
0.0301026162,
-0.0136267105,
-0.0149127068,
-0.0412030406,
-0.0181770436,
-0.0261440519,
0.0437854119,
-0.0213943068,
0.0150807658,
-0.0118845785,
-0.0202165749,
-0.0573854633,
0.0020566417,
0.0168327931,
0.0119094346,
0.0388040319,
-0.0558436327,
0.0326398276,
0.0138705559,
-0.0350546241,
-0.0708183423,
-0.0393373743,
-0.0124422582,
0.0231202375,
0.0031836405,
-0.0115715638,
0.0208963212,
0.0063271448,
0.0329429507,
0.0887641311,
0.00409008,
-0.0308200177,
-0.022362439,
0.0456077047,
0.05189538,
-0.0009650623,
-0.0020098924,
-0.0343582295,
0.0408666618,
0.0457899459,
0.0672189295,
0.003251073,
-0.0308799557,
0.0314591751,
-0.0078377174,
0.0037124001,
-0.005403108,
0.0464116521,
0.0532233231,
-0.0481062345,
-0.0519006103,
0.1332039833,
0.0329406932,
-0.0932912827,
0.0017260999,
-0.0126144215,
0.014472181,
0.0365221575,
0.0205129068,
-0.0839725137,
-0.0470348522,
0.019182371,
0.0026444832,
0.0209329706,
-0.0327509567,
-0.0048642219,
-0.0928137824,
0.0307262223,
0.0110168504,
-0.0665984303,
-0.0146470675,
-0.0338045955,
0.0040911352,
0.0001896512,
0.007874663,
0.0224851593,
-0.0150716277,
-0.0141301313,
-0.0017164424,
-0.0055113849,
-0.0727509707,
0.0421712473,
-0.0315067954,
0.0625186637,
0.0625314713,
0.0064941351,
0.038232252,
0.0124918669,
0.0688494593,
-0.0125919022,
0.0037834703,
-0.0308300909,
0.0202520434,
-0.0230700187,
-0.0179772582,
0.0082501946,
0.0824510381,
-0.0594869033,
-0.0366871245,
-0.0043883659,
0.0435944423,
-0.0088665476,
0.0217556283,
-0.0041921563,
-0.0332005247,
0.0756760165,
0.0874524266,
0.0304983705,
-0.0554923527,
-0.0323657729,
-0.0121911308,
-0.0056073698,
-0.0565741062,
0.0064907116,
-0.0138855921,
-0.0174772274,
-0.0220334847,
-0.0713353381,
-0.047762908,
0.0685979575,
0.0814562365,
0.004022337,
-0.0055186735,
-0.0098784044,
0.0079945037,
-0.0408380516,
-0.0044448883,
-0.020247478,
0.0231506974,
-0.0662859604,
-0.0407582708,
0.0134739112,
-0.0235075485,
0.0017322339,
0.0589323491,
-0.0745236352,
-0.0609118566,
0.0163770467,
0.0436352491,
0.0194176119,
0.0948479325,
-0.0100996541,
-0.0325256176,
0.062522307,
0.0248996783,
-0.0242277645,
0.007509307,
0.0088482322,
0.01627101,
-0.0063360324,
0.0444309041,
-0.0534702651,
0.0346427932,
0.0094054621,
0.0591262951,
-0.0803819597,
0.0194124263,
0.0451726392,
-0.0399043225,
0.0187973194,
-0.0524056107,
0.0061893491,
-0.0218966585,
0.0019442652,
-0.0523694195,
-0.0137623446,
-0.0488405451,
0.0194535665,
0.0025252649,
-0.015397015,
0.0064766505,
-0.0025594598,
0.0039323233,
0.0156143103,
-0.0078911586,
-0.0072108246,
0.0112383813,
0.0428205281,
0.0275261421,
0.0231587347,
-0.0079141539,
0.0435064323,
0.0001422846,
0.0364070646,
-0.0207379945,
0.0695391744,
0.0151161542,
-0.0007754923,
-0.0367400795,
0.0149777085,
-0.0375512205,
0.036940705,
-0.0554334745,
0.0407639556,
0.0671635717,
-0.0288820155,
0.0207139105,
-0.0401593037,
-0.0149803357,
-0.0112025822,
0.0408911481,
-0.0144721102,
-0.0180055406,
0.0017434142,
0.0332648419,
0.0023771292,
0.0170678124,
0.0877954811,
0.0395825356,
0.0413128622,
0.0047032856,
0.0408099703,
-0.0601251274,
0.0276056342,
0.0249983687,
0.0408503748,
-0.0108407801,
0.0350877233,
-0.0313119404,
-0.0799190551,
-0.0204828829,
0.0351982601,
-0.0324179158,
0.0094286855,
0.0502767153,
0.0490710922,
-0.0012547453,
-0.002037589,
-0.0261145867,
0.0082565816,
0.0281183682,
-0.0451426506,
-0.0351177491,
-6.069791079e-33,
-0.0487221889,
-0.0495502017,
0.0375888981,
0.0107964296,
0.0400148444,
0.0121052405,
-0.0537582673,
0.0484666675,
0.0175650474,
0.0137043186,
-0.0228085741,
0.0120673589,
0.0046034558,
0.0314394124,
0.0138337743,
-0.0019161357,
0.0279326793,
-0.0390394479,
-0.0074186539,
0.0314154066,
0.0135398898,
0.0402241983,
0.0159834251,
-0.0782449171,
0.0145156207,
-0.0445172675,
-0.0043729329,
0.0445635691,
0.0196026284,
0.0385544747,
-0.0278878249,
0.0123986043,
0.0300191995,
0.0130166421,
-0.0416371115,
0.0294539966,
-0.1169671938,
-0.0225995388,
-0.0105018569,
-0.0016773711,
-0.0752103925,
-0.0283919983,
0.0324050561,
-0.0248252396,
-0.0201688036,
0.0076505765,
0.0348746479,
0.0111086313,
-0.0267153475,
-0.0180944987,
-0.0853205621,
0.0051181386,
-0.0066469908,
-0.0660971701,
0.0222077444,
0.0310251005,
-0.0070072259,
-0.0126953293,
-0.0601582825,
0.0147087201,
-0.0411679,
0.0307521131,
0.061357636,
0.0104239257,
-0.0005926249,
0.0402140804,
0.0127530927,
-0.0062464327,
0.0115466388,
-0.0485589169,
0.0526429452,
0.0610144809,
0.0053153671,
0.0425237305,
0.011637385,
0.0163085014,
-0.0321906544,
0.0217940416,
0.0116275325,
-0.0029692599,
0.0197657906,
0.0056174723,
-0.0493876301,
-0.0189580526,
-0.0097028567,
-0.0494488627,
-0.0395016968,
-0.0095566893,
0.0668166876,
0.0360680968,
-0.0131772533,
-0.0106752953,
0.0570398867,
-0.0170430075,
-0.0098424042,
0.0202290453,
-0.0032396712,
0.0246970262,
0.0137242153,
0.0268189888,
-0.0556607507,
-0.0130368341,
-0.0152475778,
0.0506503172,
0.0162395034,
0.0083896155,
0.0625506118,
0.0475906245,
-0.0522227511,
-0.0179157853,
-0.0459741876,
0.0413146056,
0.0165045951,
0.0019211988,
0.007178132,
0.0029586668,
-0.0187242292,
0.0433531813,
-0.001447651,
-0.0461513437,
-0.0101309214,
-0.0230957791,
-0.0305012781,
0.0075233425,
-0.0292137899,
-0.022792235,
-0.0352491662,
0.0286189578,
0.0667018965,
-0.0497658812,
0.0092507992,
0.0061275712,
2.377e-7,
0.0220159497,
0.0605195723,
0.0317825787,
-0.0095447199,
0.0448591597,
0.0468283892,
-0.0437173843,
0.0062886653,
0.0013377169,
0.0094863689,
0.0330745354,
0.0427028649,
0.0181754827,
0.0044287639,
-0.0574322529,
0.0236924198,
-0.0569133796,
0.0366913453,
-0.0245453361,
0.0043700151,
0.0163819566,
0.0718051642,
-0.013644224,
-0.0209171399,
0.004990858,
-0.0594121702,
0.0550455898,
-0.0177747086,
0.0140407849,
0.0116413217,
-0.0278960206,
0.047882989,
0.0070757042,
-0.0109325685,
-0.0271275453,
0.0032810525,
-0.008101197,
0.0518799536,
-0.0105629219,
-0.0356822871,
0.0348024257,
0.0038915565,
0.0098473663,
-0.0509417467,
0.0602521412,
-0.0960941315,
0.0244290195,
-0.0367366262,
0.0054292125,
-0.0163641404,
-0.0208356623,
-0.0057148542,
-0.0174972657,
0.0101504968,
0.0370724574,
-0.0217700675,
-0.0269444063,
-0.0835601091,
-0.0468920656,
0.0200971588,
-0.0311523173,
0.0171839166,
-0.0527082458,
-0.008104681,
0.0247199312,
-0.0145919146,
-0.0026314633,
2.037881088e-34,
0.0252338368,
-0.0069531701,
0.0244362336,
0.068053022,
-0.0246333163,
-0.0033999663,
-0.0298453905,
0.0253690332,
0.0461504124,
-0.0438442715,
-0.0210542809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08734v1 | Thread of Thought Unraveling Chaotic Contexts | 2023-11-15T06:54:44 | 2023-11-15T06:54:44 | Yucheng Zhou, Xiubo Geng, Tao Shen, Chongyang Tao, Guodong Long, Jian-Guang Lou, Jianbing Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have ushered in a transformative era in the
field of natural language processing, excelling in tasks related to text
comprehension and generation. Nevertheless, they encounter difficulties when
confronted with chaotic contexts (e.g., distractors rather than long irrelevant
context), leading to the inadvertent omission of certain details within the
chaotic context. In response to these challenges, we introduce the "Thread of
Thought" (ThoT) strategy, which draws inspiration from human cognitive
processes. ThoT systematically segments and analyzes extended contexts while
adeptly selecting pertinent information. This strategy serves as a versatile
"plug-and-play" module, seamlessly integrating with various LLMs and prompting
techniques. In the experiments, we utilize the PopQA and EntityQ datasets, as
well as a Multi-Turn Conversation Response dataset (MTCR) we collected, to
illustrate that ThoT significantly improves reasoning performance compared to
other prompting techniques. | [
0.0405377187,
0.028162403,
-0.0329147168,
0.0498622023,
-0.0628030524,
0.0330939181,
0.0100444863,
-0.0151236486,
0.0013085336,
-0.0404907651,
-0.0111310082,
-0.0640093461,
0.0058170082,
0.0070697623,
0.0060576177,
-0.0506329946,
0.0512185358,
-0.037831299,
0.0201460589,
0.0136412084,
-0.0199885871,
0.0130671207,
-0.0188281983,
0.0330477692,
0.0084312633,
-0.0210492611,
-0.0648560598,
0.0271729901,
0.0396652333,
-0.0336994752,
-0.0314012393,
0.0664134771,
-0.0024976486,
0.0734431148,
0.0000021232,
-0.0628436431,
-0.0116137192,
-0.0286157131,
-0.0204550773,
0.0026322636,
0.0002689394,
0.0450808592,
0.0273482706,
0.0087597342,
-0.0603270717,
0.0335654765,
0.0085571213,
0.1024581045,
0.038448859,
0.0771597326,
-0.0012381552,
-0.0071440809,
-0.00124326,
0.0009238797,
0.0468389206,
-0.040477071,
0.0326697975,
0.0075125364,
0.0538199097,
0.0270208269,
-0.008427104,
-0.0035777597,
0.0373004153,
0.0121501563,
-0.0186656918,
0.0516374931,
-0.0300975461,
-0.0347208455,
-0.0031967887,
0.098617658,
0.0316846706,
0.0100685256,
0.0155403232,
0.0045691491,
-0.0002863178,
0.0331655443,
-0.0596189424,
0.0222108737,
-0.0304311067,
0.0137824453,
0.0426955856,
0.0057764049,
0.0099607911,
0.0140710995,
-0.0354286805,
0.0437294841,
0.0041609998,
-0.0399437733,
-0.009795717,
-0.0113494135,
-0.0225316305,
-0.0738791153,
0.0042030974,
0.0512973033,
-0.0645818412,
0.0054341778,
-0.0397225134,
-0.0009476713,
0.0226216651,
-0.0319892056,
-0.0228152405,
0.0559836254,
-0.0002908862,
0.0491334982,
-0.0113828024,
-0.006822532,
-0.0235571004,
0.0186931938,
-0.0226526204,
0.0101819281,
-0.0460454933,
-0.0119247194,
-0.0333008841,
0.027885953,
-0.0691001043,
-0.0376608409,
-0.0188501496,
0.0258764513,
0.002460513,
-0.016755214,
-0.0320688598,
0.0195919629,
-0.0152395135,
0.000337827,
-0.044269152,
-0.0101475744,
-0.0362839699,
0.0208973084,
0.0537194684,
-0.0561192371,
-0.0460716113,
0.0254110694,
0.0029998119,
-0.0239913128,
-0.0454632714,
0.0605592094,
0.0057027503,
-0.0405830145,
-0.0626962781,
-0.0509697087,
-0.0247133784,
-0.0596298873,
-0.0027317801,
-0.050927598,
0.0160107482,
0.0146388859,
-0.0279495083,
0.053480316,
0.0436497554,
0.0606726408,
-0.0336950086,
0.0476269536,
-0.0669724345,
0.0006581199,
0.0124800093,
0.0350151807,
0.0031696637,
0.0918430239,
0.0332808234,
0.0023461957,
0.0235669818,
0.0006596393,
0.0116140749,
0.01894214,
-0.0219008494,
-0.0288946256,
-0.0029568481,
0.0040134275,
-0.0001231561,
0.0167834964,
0.0100519229,
0.0407641456,
-0.046817489,
0.0210531633,
0.0452290513,
0.0545639843,
-0.0201957263,
0.0218493473,
0.0248067752,
-0.0123243267,
-0.0106595019,
0.0657071173,
-0.0509085767,
0.0307078511,
-0.015624648,
0.0290817935,
0.052280914,
0.0343028754,
-0.0201571491,
-0.0265507605,
-0.0208435543,
0.033979632,
0.0065100403,
0.0168233886,
0.0164376907,
0.0241830442,
-0.0460929163,
0.0291898176,
0.015132416,
-0.0354712419,
-0.0080689248,
-0.0377056077,
0.0403589904,
0.092696242,
0.0535577722,
-0.0458209887,
-0.03260516,
-0.0348303318,
0.0447414257,
0.0706089884,
0.0121864341,
0.0065762405,
-0.0118748592,
-0.0615231581,
-0.0250680353,
0.0022247036,
0.014541449,
-0.0168322511,
0.0122830449,
0.0148903998,
0.003179658,
0.0373502523,
-0.0051884246,
0.0275499616,
-0.0403442457,
-0.0104502048,
-0.0076071746,
0.0001397655,
0.0093039405,
0.0227343291,
-0.0167452954,
0.0269717034,
0.0277580395,
-0.039289996,
-0.0210783444,
0.0455496795,
-0.0642793179,
-0.0706169084,
0.0167091694,
-0.0054886071,
-0.034951672,
-0.0324433036,
-0.012882676,
-0.0572086498,
0.024056619,
-0.0243486669,
0.0576273352,
-0.0343388654,
-0.0042569335,
0.025447987,
0.0399876945,
-0.031736061,
0.0996609181,
-0.0127009321,
0.0189851578,
0.063285999,
0.0227272101,
-0.0024611522,
-0.0435157642,
0.0154765872,
-0.0024712097,
-0.0008364576,
-0.0149886766,
-0.0070935283,
0.0111301374,
-0.0747249573,
-0.0248986743,
-0.0687877685,
0.0082405172,
-0.0507461093,
0.0101406779,
0.0343944877,
0.0084014833,
-0.0430641323,
0.0057758084,
-0.0106525989,
0.0329917595,
0.0195675381,
0.0293696672,
0.037966717,
-0.0016287918,
-0.0452182963,
-0.0026822833,
0.0089605525,
-0.0284435693,
0.0540190563,
0.0143098887,
-0.0198648982,
-0.0443824977,
0.0204208158,
-0.0216384791,
-0.0279091448,
-0.0069218399,
0.0313674733,
0.0251282956,
-0.0150660817,
0.1081303582,
0.0374452621,
0.0078640329,
0.023725722,
0.0147989308,
-0.0531998649,
-0.0252453983,
0.0122543415,
-0.0303736068,
0.0303299017,
0.013999573,
-0.0397519842,
-0.0066530118,
0.0546188131,
0.0138152242,
0.0009559209,
-0.0383809321,
0.0122336475,
-0.0078652576,
-0.0358963273,
-0.0437508337,
-0.0159603413,
-0.0268264189,
0.076362364,
-0.0336884186,
-0.0138727473,
0.0751336738,
0.0010128362,
0.0181918368,
-0.0269165095,
0.0172385499,
-0.0497079976,
0.0389085785,
-0.0224322081,
-0.004238849,
0.0244750977,
-0.0284780785,
-0.036943946,
0.0160065666,
-0.0329774879,
-0.028073566,
0.02448369,
-0.0457770787,
-0.0035023636,
0.0025093807,
-0.0002064238,
-0.0624422021,
-0.0284284297,
-0.0162293613,
0.0119440192,
0.0061719208,
0.0061007827,
0.0036038365,
-0.0087663149,
0.020772079,
0.0190040357,
-0.0351137631,
-0.0114435488,
-0.0340005271,
0.0776378661,
0.0475436859,
0.0489554293,
0.0850631073,
-0.0433000214,
0.0701756403,
0.0592352524,
0.0589941293,
-0.0399002768,
0.0032783882,
0.0125029869,
-0.0016593632,
-0.0098206447,
-0.0054129395,
0.0422564521,
0.0692166537,
-0.0393936858,
-0.0553866401,
0.1156911477,
0.0492254272,
-0.0133415908,
-0.0078928471,
-0.0431409441,
0.0608641878,
0.0233580228,
0.001026236,
-0.1083631516,
-0.0363700986,
0.0214062668,
-0.0005955262,
0.0008982911,
-0.0654856861,
0.0074165631,
-0.0905212089,
0.0536739267,
-0.0169177223,
-0.0464240015,
-0.0178075489,
-0.0429142676,
0.0140547585,
0.0169722717,
0.0225012396,
0.0115224663,
0.0169988349,
0.0126807382,
0.0143887289,
0.0037035109,
-0.0317262635,
0.0066246809,
-0.0195117276,
0.0508670658,
0.0457044095,
0.019111421,
0.0360455178,
-0.0421990268,
0.0215426758,
-0.0290944446,
0.010519512,
-0.0098459078,
0.0145813432,
0.0265645143,
-0.007100258,
-0.0501705259,
0.0428955704,
-0.0459560081,
-0.0588339716,
0.0045679989,
0.0837229714,
-0.0329263583,
-0.003814382,
-0.0203993153,
0.0589689277,
0.0288661886,
0.0874684379,
0.0575184636,
-0.0302497167,
-0.0355361439,
-0.0185301416,
0.0080951741,
-0.0815473944,
-0.000304292,
0.0042636571,
0.0314952694,
-0.0184115209,
-0.0747534484,
-0.0490608811,
0.0146666253,
0.0187336765,
0.0084066931,
0.0046309228,
0.0094224708,
-0.0001520914,
-0.0124079809,
0.018657703,
-0.013689342,
-0.006538433,
-0.0026813548,
-0.0130348094,
-0.0409713984,
-0.0339313336,
0.009262275,
0.0599315464,
-0.1042125374,
-0.05664967,
0.0194649212,
0.010512339,
0.0217982549,
0.0308842026,
-0.0040424224,
-0.0094981398,
-0.019184757,
0.0361113325,
-0.0294354036,
0.014807893,
-0.0383863896,
0.0730024353,
0.0061739134,
0.0419339687,
0.0036420121,
-0.0034712886,
0.0074427063,
0.0593985654,
-0.0345922261,
-0.0265179817,
0.0279664695,
-0.0085786385,
0.0273076165,
-0.0113879824,
-0.0053534303,
-0.0260490738,
0.0159678198,
-0.0345719568,
-0.0211016405,
-0.027473839,
-0.0097702593,
-0.0066898945,
-0.0305517111,
0.004669786,
-0.0193919446,
-0.0237174835,
0.009212086,
-0.0094605554,
-0.0183726363,
-0.0081420178,
0.0048329122,
0.0105723841,
-0.0212625507,
-0.0149331121,
0.0387246422,
-0.0107297609,
0.0447757468,
0.0032452655,
0.1194773838,
0.0255000312,
-0.026009148,
0.0238856878,
-0.0008875536,
-0.1023526117,
-0.0533352681,
0.0223768614,
0.020113416,
0.0319916047,
-0.0265379306,
0.0398212932,
-0.0284261592,
-0.0045218072,
-0.003037812,
0.0393338837,
0.0207010843,
-0.028355252,
0.0078007295,
0.0337193049,
-0.0346021727,
-0.0162013974,
0.0725968555,
-0.0412861854,
0.0085421046,
0.0607810207,
0.0008791884,
-0.038553331,
-0.0209878832,
-0.0155958375,
0.0485676639,
-0.0298368335,
0.0330944359,
-0.1012050062,
-0.0407104902,
0.0284451582,
-0.0059851301,
0.0166618079,
0.0125527689,
0.0419537723,
0.0515699573,
-0.0071463608,
-0.0308521912,
-0.0134114558,
0.0407158881,
0.0003003218,
-0.0244089272,
-0.0631342828,
-6.670101717e-33,
-0.0249225479,
-0.0559096299,
0.0437807813,
-0.0337948576,
-0.0180582963,
-0.0066352524,
-0.0544535182,
0.017406797,
0.0138377873,
0.0119533055,
-0.0064590913,
0.0194460861,
0.0047026318,
0.0354939029,
0.0057803043,
-0.0540393852,
0.0282012317,
-0.0205628052,
0.0056131533,
0.0325677358,
0.0838656873,
0.0146009801,
0.032552693,
-0.0179205816,
0.0370179191,
0.000795284,
0.0211895574,
0.0320654511,
-0.0356154554,
0.0162844118,
-0.0440227687,
0.0329235084,
0.0339511223,
-0.0360378437,
-0.0317444764,
0.0394545533,
-0.050796099,
-0.0351447389,
0.0162804257,
-0.0040244628,
-0.043685846,
-0.0466207303,
0.0424648076,
-0.0093483068,
-0.011485843,
-0.0078855045,
0.023341326,
-0.0303975269,
-0.0377420262,
0.006123404,
-0.0697389916,
0.0349952094,
-0.032628078,
-0.0399138816,
-0.0192729458,
0.06514965,
-0.0193892922,
0.0184797049,
-0.0722604021,
0.0275284387,
-0.0106084431,
-0.0138494466,
0.034969978,
0.0219972227,
0.012749373,
0.0758091882,
0.0267437771,
0.0147412792,
-0.0782369673,
-0.0008013592,
-0.0225893985,
0.061504133,
0.0243203416,
0.0416745618,
0.0290944222,
-0.0051852367,
-0.0878685266,
0.0257708374,
-0.0295362659,
-0.0019952911,
0.0449089594,
-0.0266099982,
-0.0489325523,
-0.0085109128,
0.0241527576,
0.0152573651,
-0.0362490676,
0.0159712955,
0.0278321579,
-0.0106899142,
-0.0215714071,
-0.0166148562,
0.0400004834,
-0.0290882215,
0.0142924609,
-0.0133230379,
-0.0241347905,
-0.0120232385,
0.005241252,
0.0049052057,
-0.0523916706,
-0.0191457774,
0.0393043458,
0.0095120259,
0.0001090636,
-0.0019429618,
0.0216879472,
-0.0150616588,
-0.0655224547,
-0.0085959369,
-0.0444825627,
0.0713553727,
-0.0003954785,
-0.0132127572,
0.0498477034,
-0.0000995613,
-0.0234269947,
0.0318234712,
0.0270921234,
0.0016585231,
-0.0260390658,
0.0191584453,
-0.0358070433,
-0.0056424038,
0.0169699863,
-0.0015083823,
-0.0161586739,
-0.0082830377,
-0.0037401435,
-0.0580856279,
-0.0165328067,
0.0225949511,
2.895e-7,
0.0234271474,
0.0637584999,
0.0265320912,
0.0023171529,
0.0380931422,
0.0175207611,
-0.0336111933,
0.014947284,
0.0174132008,
-0.0368886255,
-0.0054738009,
0.0534405969,
0.0533117354,
0.0230988581,
-0.1028827801,
-0.0422929078,
-0.076361984,
-0.008963732,
-0.0728192106,
-0.0219097678,
0.0867548138,
0.0607624911,
-0.0143925324,
-0.0081721209,
0.0193341617,
-0.0054902364,
0.0451149121,
-0.0211188085,
-0.0283108298,
0.0022679479,
0.0198526382,
-0.0147883371,
-0.0059455135,
0.0300990772,
-0.0105787674,
0.0123255458,
-0.0212813076,
0.026312856,
0.0415076166,
-0.0614280403,
-0.0139238983,
-0.0101776076,
0.0286309253,
-0.0632827431,
0.0767622069,
-0.0661752969,
-0.05180455,
-0.0112625044,
-0.0008653895,
-0.0075176004,
0.0446322672,
0.0193733647,
-0.026790373,
0.0052430094,
-0.0121040661,
0.0071167634,
-0.004544259,
-0.0583271049,
0.0015073336,
-0.0121655948,
-0.0736520812,
-0.0293574464,
-0.0556214042,
-0.0143383443,
0.0285430718,
-0.0464931987,
-0.0032385557,
2.906455471e-34,
0.0320349894,
-0.0202582646,
0.0071822447,
0.0740791634,
0.0357396156,
-0.0281327255,
0.0023619349,
0.0031206254,
0.0211369563,
-0.0884398296,
-0.0280013774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08732v1 | Enhancing Emergency Decision-making with Knowledge Graphs and Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T06:48:50 | 2023-11-15T06:48:50 | Minze Chen, Zhenxiang Tao, Weitong Tang, Tingxin Qin, Rui Yang, Chunli Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emergency management urgently requires comprehensive knowledge while having a
high possibility to go beyond individuals' cognitive scope. Therefore,
artificial intelligence(AI) supported decision-making under that circumstance
is of vital importance. Recent emerging large language models (LLM) provide a
new direction for enhancing targeted machine intelligence. However, the
utilization of LLM directly would inevitably introduce unreliable output for
its inherent issue of hallucination and poor reasoning skills. In this work, we
develop a system called Enhancing Emergency decision-making with Knowledge
Graph and LLM (E-KELL), which provides evidence-based decision-making in
various emergency stages. The study constructs a structured emergency knowledge
graph and guides LLMs to reason over it via a prompt chain. In real-world
evaluations, E-KELL receives scores of 9.06, 9.09, 9.03, and 9.09 in
comprehensibility, accuracy, conciseness, and instructiveness from a group of
emergency commanders and firefighters, demonstrating a significant improvement
across various situations compared to baseline models. This work introduces a
novel approach to providing reliable emergency decision support. | [
0.032423947,
0.0004651296,
-0.0008052491,
0.003270871,
-0.0278718062,
0.0112389028,
-0.0031654199,
0.0227815732,
0.0416955464,
-0.0423287489,
0.0384368673,
0.0171366204,
-0.0490870476,
0.0720583797,
0.0058190143,
-0.0496475473,
0.0047008758,
-0.0386225544,
0.0894646496,
0.0111228125,
0.0072480496,
0.0241741706,
-0.0417039879,
0.0393985957,
-0.0045350511,
0.0302443765,
-0.0393828787,
-0.0039410642,
0.0546722002,
-0.0594719425,
-0.0232037082,
0.0055024191,
0.0336506888,
-0.0263576452,
0.0000021662,
-0.0559030324,
-0.0091033205,
-0.0246412791,
-0.0819445923,
-0.0783452839,
-0.0163993351,
-0.0168502945,
0.0128434412,
0.0214443337,
-0.0449692681,
-0.0008393981,
0.0060613211,
0.0707022399,
0.0542270765,
0.0565361045,
-0.0015504723,
-0.0395479649,
0.0151167884,
0.0019639484,
-0.0191670656,
-0.0349770263,
0.0282669328,
0.0220217779,
0.0472333543,
-0.0351052135,
0.0142649114,
0.0171194207,
0.0080044316,
0.0000544039,
0.010268528,
0.0382352211,
-0.0365815498,
-0.0045133685,
-0.0048436467,
0.0480103418,
-0.0170255955,
-0.0226273462,
0.00883957,
-0.0057953293,
0.0229392275,
0.0453538895,
-0.0355503149,
-0.0233652126,
-0.0368218459,
-0.0042375256,
-0.0113167949,
0.0325090811,
0.0442384928,
0.0181992967,
-0.0221252907,
0.0937572345,
-0.03950914,
-0.0387343802,
0.0273660757,
-0.0003528916,
-0.0565612614,
-0.0435959846,
0.0267314371,
0.0481048226,
-0.0974267572,
0.0069529898,
0.0214445982,
0.0083999466,
0.0113340011,
-0.08704748,
0.0191249438,
0.0100656264,
0.0377690494,
0.0300718807,
0.0054036174,
0.0292807911,
0.0124962991,
0.0280945357,
-0.0196103957,
-0.0080816019,
-0.1112993285,
-0.010930731,
-0.0354954898,
0.013457939,
0.0154139875,
-0.0007574388,
-0.0433904976,
0.009817645,
-0.0169323348,
0.0298367292,
0.029093083,
0.025019791,
0.0155522088,
-0.0314646699,
-0.065423131,
-0.0083283754,
-0.0270113777,
0.0445393138,
0.0208763629,
0.0227497406,
0.0440313257,
-0.0040685604,
0.0015403123,
0.0143111274,
-0.0131690223,
0.0505689569,
0.0098633403,
0.0114717353,
-0.057176061,
-0.01238357,
-0.0086873826,
-0.0456227101,
0.011891895,
-0.0665630847,
0.0275253635,
0.009192179,
-0.0046024667,
-0.0136895282,
0.0152495923,
-0.0519748591,
-0.0561494827,
0.0395993106,
-0.075306803,
0.0464958958,
0.0317179635,
0.0223770607,
-0.0138799092,
0.0000657339,
0.031714499,
0.0418281704,
0.0289695971,
-0.0198035035,
0.033500392,
-0.0288235918,
-0.0224108268,
-0.0295795482,
-0.0304011162,
0.0049871951,
-0.0748056397,
0.038644217,
-0.0226520263,
0.0009512568,
-0.0117386766,
0.0194799677,
0.0429126732,
0.0240190644,
0.0372699611,
-0.0062471838,
0.0493156984,
0.0550894961,
-0.0070991246,
-0.0365496948,
-0.0343893915,
0.0204050448,
-0.0485513099,
0.0081630899,
0.0299748406,
0.0073255855,
-0.0284257755,
-0.0371893905,
-0.0093676616,
-0.0000487843,
-0.005971489,
0.0348818861,
0.0389509313,
-0.0522118323,
-0.0127462707,
-0.0314698741,
0.0150107918,
0.0336193517,
-0.011394239,
-0.0605940036,
-0.0115346033,
0.158859998,
0.0245983452,
-0.0193178058,
-0.0272285249,
-0.0202473179,
0.0181641821,
0.0082577774,
0.0087605836,
0.0061496436,
-0.00437256,
-0.0560151376,
-0.0385372788,
0.0256692674,
0.0095583489,
0.0056352746,
-0.0306423586,
0.0249505173,
-0.0197790787,
-0.01622409,
-0.0618476197,
-0.0049177599,
0.0101954406,
-0.0072460021,
-0.0582649931,
-0.0007910678,
0.0264713224,
0.0194766205,
-0.0046787616,
0.0423734412,
0.019521961,
-0.017772615,
-0.0994518176,
0.0138928089,
-0.0413170569,
0.0288230795,
0.0208438039,
-0.0417635068,
-0.0125490464,
-0.0242860895,
-0.0333790891,
-0.0560213663,
-0.0034557672,
-0.033854533,
0.032784991,
0.0143648088,
0.0331405178,
0.0161455199,
-0.0630876198,
-0.0083809784,
0.0802118853,
0.0047977031,
-0.018628465,
-0.0396752767,
0.0128214136,
0.0021452762,
-0.0211051479,
0.0092898319,
0.0171752218,
0.0349041261,
0.0527410954,
0.0120195784,
-0.0040801484,
-0.0244774912,
-0.0051408354,
-0.0902923867,
-0.0221720207,
0.0064597912,
0.0186790004,
-0.0075146663,
-0.0489758328,
-0.0224065967,
-0.0031352676,
-0.0240033101,
0.0319847353,
0.0202590022,
0.0098273344,
-0.006201508,
0.0271639321,
-0.0183223318,
0.005976208,
-0.020863574,
-0.0157827418,
0.0197053291,
0.0473816469,
-0.058458738,
-0.0395300724,
0.0452921651,
-0.0556470267,
0.0137523953,
-0.0092127798,
-0.0363701023,
0.0333895013,
-0.0277285241,
0.0289069563,
-0.0142509853,
0.0182133634,
0.0264663696,
0.0527945161,
-0.0147357639,
-0.0383045413,
0.0073245973,
-0.0179112814,
-0.0128467819,
-0.0581912547,
-0.0143535659,
-0.0472583398,
-0.0012867949,
0.0132703036,
0.0377580747,
-0.0246779211,
0.0066088689,
-0.0052605229,
-0.0338469893,
-0.0770025104,
-0.0461843759,
0.0124672232,
0.0543017872,
-0.009631373,
0.0049739759,
0.0700062811,
0.0320705846,
0.0517746285,
-0.0219066013,
-0.046487499,
-0.0144948317,
0.0478844643,
-0.0064977398,
0.0231986213,
-0.0100576403,
0.0079957508,
-0.0065650726,
-0.0344152451,
-0.0040886318,
-0.0610113405,
-0.0110396352,
-0.0514474362,
0.0045047612,
0.0443516672,
-0.0321582556,
-0.0407901518,
-0.0009094525,
-0.045186013,
-0.0135863312,
0.0023526163,
-0.015098243,
-0.0586605109,
0.01094299,
0.067415148,
0.011890403,
0.0163499434,
-0.0280438457,
-0.0050151269,
0.0000229459,
0.0359249935,
0.0291085858,
0.0305529311,
-0.013719378,
0.0705632269,
0.0578060634,
0.0412390903,
-0.0530522242,
-0.023060048,
0.0286645684,
-0.0156317595,
-0.0199018214,
-0.0262215883,
0.0297527164,
0.0066526104,
-0.0438541435,
0.0209033117,
0.0964961722,
0.0306990165,
-0.0451094173,
0.0075453511,
-0.0860283896,
-0.0341577269,
0.0223316271,
0.0162529871,
-0.025392646,
-0.0245444681,
-0.0182623081,
0.0319493935,
-0.0283504762,
-0.0685558394,
0.0379287899,
-0.0816819295,
0.0484701693,
0.0060229492,
0.0092799403,
-0.0624536946,
-0.0421869308,
-0.0041941078,
0.0101491492,
-0.0219681542,
-0.0094521781,
0.0122006033,
-0.0183392037,
0.038486965,
-0.0183675587,
-0.0356785692,
0.0469291583,
-0.037314523,
0.0587205216,
0.0183892213,
0.0348195396,
-0.0268364847,
-0.0017746661,
-0.0024174075,
0.0388236083,
0.0295914244,
-0.003847128,
-0.0001519606,
0.0092040068,
0.0200885832,
-0.049113825,
-0.0067182165,
-0.0187161472,
-0.0330013819,
0.070664607,
0.1072808728,
-0.0703196153,
-0.0382611677,
-0.0356786326,
0.0316298902,
0.0235204194,
0.0315924287,
-0.008599706,
-0.0332550928,
-0.0237924233,
-0.014798183,
0.0009159045,
-0.0234852191,
-0.044184573,
0.0803455114,
0.0128095774,
-0.0067833425,
-0.0229076818,
-0.0395927951,
0.0355881415,
0.0200388674,
0.0020667077,
-0.0159620307,
0.0423698388,
-0.0045189806,
-0.0120915426,
0.0251650456,
0.0125428792,
0.0138413059,
-0.0508143976,
0.0217574164,
-0.0164690372,
0.0087284194,
-0.0164738446,
0.0327592753,
0.0277277548,
-0.022720946,
0.0305242669,
0.042311497,
0.0344246514,
-0.0248593278,
-0.0259032901,
-0.0211965069,
0.0444766954,
0.0233029332,
-0.0424446762,
-0.0276927892,
-0.0099633178,
0.0087862834,
0.0146089923,
0.0225758106,
-0.0496779978,
0.0649243072,
-0.0147598498,
0.0325149223,
-0.0969019607,
-0.015034195,
0.016207289,
0.0462134592,
-0.0068932711,
-0.010096225,
-0.0478797406,
-0.01428241,
0.0112415496,
-0.0313640125,
-0.023206953,
-0.0006694117,
0.0448818654,
0.0120785628,
-0.005382109,
0.0504822582,
-0.0332868658,
0.0089016668,
-0.0620990843,
0.0017090308,
0.0142337289,
0.0442259982,
0.0360630378,
0.0428295471,
-0.022065429,
0.0027279498,
0.0326532684,
0.0196610615,
0.0149629088,
0.0225438327,
0.085097678,
0.0162831228,
-0.0440434143,
-0.0270243678,
0.0245705117,
-0.0194776133,
-0.1067165285,
0.0277193561,
0.0419606045,
0.0558363125,
0.048903998,
-0.0104192561,
-0.0493704528,
0.0191928633,
-0.0232104566,
0.0162721686,
0.0457336977,
-0.0074909739,
0.03634049,
0.0433849134,
-0.0226158276,
0.0243094843,
0.0501023829,
0.0178757813,
0.021278128,
-0.0038246724,
-0.0728729367,
-0.0329191312,
-0.0498753637,
-0.0163152851,
0.0409729443,
-0.0466310233,
-0.0052264519,
-0.086500138,
-0.0222275779,
-0.0177442562,
0.0361916199,
-0.0069440627,
-0.0224216525,
0.0261460766,
0.021215843,
0.0049728747,
-0.0156508628,
-0.0302641094,
0.0287502315,
-0.036246296,
0.0274322201,
0.0023901118,
-6.273116704e-33,
0.0208314229,
-0.0746877789,
0.0376816988,
-0.0563188642,
0.0128938369,
-0.0035662113,
-0.006405442,
0.0267403349,
-0.0118059767,
0.0338050276,
0.0120993424,
0.0214937236,
0.0150983278,
-0.0512712486,
0.0227488335,
-0.0104248915,
-0.0031808296,
0.0220695119,
-0.0061638206,
0.0257488489,
0.0774595961,
-0.0003905435,
0.0042019375,
-0.0750174671,
0.015946243,
-0.0024759669,
-0.0062667732,
0.0177554581,
-0.0360485353,
0.0380052887,
-0.004351093,
0.0450306349,
0.0435866453,
-0.0429069288,
-0.0124981608,
0.0357439481,
-0.0143490424,
-0.0173617117,
0.0479752608,
-0.044431828,
-0.0342709385,
-0.0292127281,
0.0116038118,
0.0352776609,
0.0170588437,
-0.0033299804,
0.0201780628,
-0.0281774271,
-0.0171659552,
-0.0100599788,
-0.034392301,
0.0419996679,
-0.0414440781,
0.0075369035,
-0.0262065846,
0.0504764356,
-0.0373331159,
-0.0309815612,
-0.0548381507,
0.007360891,
-0.0124511532,
-0.0340049341,
0.0236213598,
-0.0340025835,
-0.0604887381,
0.0589650683,
-0.0473242365,
-0.0126685221,
-0.0561461337,
-0.0063512139,
-0.0284693185,
0.1128590554,
0.0375137851,
0.0364773013,
-0.0100827683,
-0.0398627296,
-0.0982459635,
0.0111186607,
-0.019740548,
0.0716729611,
0.0499065742,
0.023235837,
-0.0710049421,
-0.0185066294,
0.0066052983,
0.0115763731,
-0.030351568,
-0.0153459935,
0.01304725,
-0.0191835091,
0.0104816919,
0.0412039235,
0.0083142538,
0.002717237,
0.0496548526,
0.0306607187,
0.0284593385,
0.0453017056,
-0.0173843224,
0.031505838,
-0.0730069801,
0.0001175252,
0.0223159194,
0.0103839058,
0.0339746363,
0.01722591,
0.0098681226,
-0.0039326292,
0.0167997368,
-0.0000993375,
-0.0289574172,
0.0049456451,
0.0212732702,
-0.0608642697,
0.0593169257,
0.0287401509,
0.0107555501,
-0.0414661579,
0.0183917321,
-0.0500873215,
0.0414672196,
-0.031671159,
-0.0258153435,
-0.000558137,
-0.0057713669,
0.0008284632,
-0.0520891286,
-0.0036715847,
-0.0200215764,
-0.018445529,
-0.001912733,
0.0184468701,
2.973e-7,
0.0320951901,
0.0517351553,
0.0191261657,
0.0083871502,
0.0179846659,
0.0324508771,
0.002988115,
-0.005444149,
0.0191439465,
-0.0063364687,
0.0529658347,
0.0563365631,
0.0128128203,
0.058481276,
-0.0217426121,
-0.0564950742,
-0.0243631918,
-0.0330803543,
-0.0811195448,
0.0186750963,
0.1155401841,
0.0262951292,
0.0551868863,
-0.0153138544,
-0.0121406736,
-0.0428315289,
-0.01004632,
-0.0291344617,
-0.0026422995,
-0.0078201722,
0.0689627975,
0.0354095399,
-0.0270251259,
0.1082264557,
0.0123339863,
-0.0258273315,
0.008763398,
0.0536665693,
-0.0352121182,
0.023230765,
-0.0088556074,
-0.0483622886,
0.025337752,
-0.0491464734,
0.048856806,
-0.0505835749,
-0.0494759642,
0.0630837008,
-0.0555758514,
-0.026061561,
-0.0222968198,
-0.0130424714,
-0.0144356368,
0.0100313826,
-0.0058835978,
-0.0017876844,
-0.0006655039,
-0.0316809937,
0.0368541665,
0.0884537324,
-0.0089671081,
-0.0771284103,
-0.0123974318,
0.026397435,
0.0521143563,
-0.0657500848,
0.0196141358,
2.11337836e-34,
0.0051599885,
0.0504090823,
-0.026197549,
-0.0645161271,
0.0667586401,
0.0115060722,
-0.0293198079,
0.0228208732,
0.0096262721,
-0.0649659559,
-0.0123424064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08726v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08726v2 | Uncertainty Estimation on Sequential Labeling via Uncertainty Transmission | 2023-11-15T06:36:29 | 2024-06-05T15:04:29 | Jianfeng He, Linlin Yu, Shuo Lei, Chang-Tien Lu, Feng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sequential labeling is a task predicting labels for each token in a sequence,
such as Named Entity Recognition (NER). NER tasks aim to extract entities and
predict their labels given a text, which is important in information
extraction. Although previous works have shown great progress in improving NER
performance, uncertainty estimation on NER (UE-NER) is still underexplored but
essential. This work focuses on UE-NER, which aims to estimate uncertainty
scores for the NER predictions. Previous uncertainty estimation models often
overlook two unique characteristics of NER: the connection between entities
(i.e., one entity embedding is learned based on the other ones) and wrong span
cases in the entity extraction subtask. Therefore, we propose a Sequential
Labeling Posterior Network (SLPN) to estimate uncertainty scores for the
extracted entities, considering uncertainty transmitted from other tokens.
Moreover, we have defined an evaluation strategy to address the specificity of
wrong-span cases. Our SLPN has achieved significant improvements on three
datasets, such as a 5.54-point improvement in AUPR on the MIT-Restaurant
dataset. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/he159ok/UncSeqLabeling_SLPN}. | [
0.0269751828,
0.0922188312,
0.0353461616,
0.0186536517,
0.0122915702,
0.0433639847,
-0.0081943823,
-0.0242127329,
-0.0195284951,
-0.0214273576,
-0.0357959643,
-0.0524464436,
0.0003787797,
0.0125352312,
0.0406840071,
-0.0368103869,
0.0260337535,
0.0023669754,
0.0783243328,
0.0228532478,
-0.013648103,
-0.0089075277,
-0.0494937673,
0.0212411322,
-0.0236274265,
0.0231804177,
-0.0036369078,
0.0370091386,
0.058861088,
-0.0771867335,
0.0358355269,
0.0533314422,
-0.0114091309,
0.0078787142,
0.0000018841,
-0.0150816506,
-0.0332188755,
0.0180710033,
-0.0469162613,
-0.0240866691,
0.0138706677,
0.0301280953,
-0.0145048155,
-0.0047761686,
0.0063321651,
-0.061557591,
0.0349592753,
0.0738270804,
0.0001770048,
0.0279615074,
-0.0062556863,
-0.0184428301,
0.0230915993,
-0.0535854176,
0.0199669488,
-0.1074284911,
0.0475320704,
-0.0653605014,
-0.0181463454,
0.0355154574,
-0.0015127189,
0.0319418311,
0.0229486506,
0.0356048755,
-0.0190009661,
0.053490974,
0.0232392941,
-0.0390544459,
-0.0130397482,
0.0678399056,
0.0150064044,
0.0317372717,
0.0299483333,
-0.0066563627,
-0.0055037756,
-0.0237794053,
0.0045625377,
0.0208145473,
-0.0319960006,
0.0060532647,
-0.0171363465,
0.0443970002,
0.0238303114,
0.0131861875,
-0.0137803582,
0.0518405735,
0.0129343681,
-0.0351686291,
0.0309097692,
0.0276767518,
-0.0301993154,
-0.0387470834,
0.0626355708,
0.0170960054,
-0.018165309,
0.0519543551,
-0.0452644154,
-0.0465588719,
-0.0123771233,
-0.0026305704,
-0.0557346046,
0.0087051122,
-0.0238292627,
0.0239843484,
-0.0608870648,
0.0247274581,
0.0005656624,
0.0287663173,
-0.0157582164,
-0.0042856256,
-0.0105115753,
0.0140095316,
-0.023465801,
0.0376172774,
-0.0262060072,
-0.0119471718,
-0.0611550696,
-0.0176790636,
-0.0348519422,
0.0697691739,
-0.0015511606,
0.035923712,
-0.0292456001,
-0.0056865411,
-0.0126324752,
0.0039690635,
-0.0291314144,
-0.0062127504,
0.0087436289,
-0.0074830661,
-0.0169357657,
-0.0309389178,
0.026763048,
-0.0357285328,
0.0126175052,
0.0706236213,
-0.0062784846,
-0.0501495153,
-0.0633604899,
-0.0003315956,
-0.0202794541,
-0.0369973853,
-0.0090302359,
-0.0304715224,
0.0205517597,
-0.0038686548,
-0.0009577616,
-0.0381757058,
0.0416153856,
-0.0061185723,
-0.0855090991,
0.0713350624,
-0.0549221821,
-0.0346655957,
0.0281350631,
0.0246776193,
0.0393668227,
0.0383605808,
0.0582007691,
0.0458455831,
0.0576226711,
0.0423706956,
-0.0145993922,
0.0084432475,
0.044118572,
-0.015563054,
-0.0170185883,
-0.0125545729,
0.0147744045,
0.0110069364,
0.0048511974,
0.0453205854,
-0.0169809349,
-0.0117649231,
0.0384421162,
-0.0084689679,
-0.0303135421,
-0.0521873385,
0.029984815,
-0.0218219403,
0.0097782183,
0.0065618488,
-0.0388023034,
-0.0007775275,
-0.0173067562,
0.0248461943,
0.0398234501,
0.0217654482,
-0.0145382462,
-0.0441763848,
-0.0138043165,
-0.0143676586,
-0.0223991983,
0.0084243398,
0.0631480217,
0.0341211744,
-0.0782895982,
0.0451886021,
0.0283138063,
-0.0080136806,
0.0146830622,
0.0109510692,
0.0176674537,
0.0321053676,
0.0225160494,
-0.0714720264,
-0.0717435181,
-0.0175741669,
-0.0554341823,
0.0037552719,
-0.0036817053,
-0.0272107814,
0.0488740988,
-0.0288156886,
-0.0166947264,
0.0507257506,
0.0360360593,
0.0140429819,
0.0199483056,
0.0295932982,
0.039128501,
-0.027469784,
-0.0192004144,
0.0371046811,
-0.0009510854,
-0.0434117392,
0.0196838267,
0.0348670557,
0.0431005321,
0.0423846208,
-0.0089418916,
-0.0051888418,
0.0407474898,
0.0008517418,
-0.0287464205,
-0.0261742007,
-0.038055405,
-0.0536965542,
0.0395547897,
-0.0176740643,
-0.0280136969,
-0.0120151257,
-0.0763229504,
-0.0636752024,
-0.0346165672,
0.0236237217,
-0.0378878973,
0.002313101,
0.0105670318,
0.0613598637,
0.0047201309,
-0.0377663597,
0.0448223539,
-0.0440726355,
0.0508969389,
0.0067162728,
0.0352357887,
-0.0188259482,
-0.017875351,
-0.0476184562,
-0.0085638994,
-0.0173145887,
-0.0704492629,
0.0211130474,
0.0069130124,
-0.0680300742,
-0.0102417702,
-0.057479687,
-0.0008334977,
-0.0138956131,
0.0537526049,
0.015397951,
0.0102302469,
-0.0143549144,
-0.0318200402,
-0.0037938773,
-0.0271824989,
-0.0553675294,
-0.0061516673,
0.0377878435,
0.0577013977,
-0.0231392831,
-0.0448067039,
-0.0067088958,
-0.0287990365,
0.014447826,
0.0155472625,
-0.0608149841,
-0.0832587108,
0.030712517,
-0.0329891741,
0.0075300373,
0.0014065269,
-0.0020007591,
-0.0120417299,
0.0042795017,
0.0092929062,
0.0094797211,
-0.0045879693,
0.0435384624,
-0.033991687,
-0.0398884602,
0.0026122595,
0.0371779017,
-0.062778838,
0.0438832641,
-0.0067619523,
-0.0669912696,
0.0166080259,
0.0808886588,
-0.0271235369,
0.0204843525,
-0.0379023142,
-0.0191861205,
-0.0245591681,
-0.0253445134,
-0.0200005081,
0.0146442978,
-0.0087100286,
0.0051603359,
-0.0263782684,
0.0048746378,
0.0796536803,
-0.0538387857,
-0.0053225257,
0.0026102578,
0.0205813497,
-0.0002393474,
0.0264638364,
0.0641212761,
0.0109910481,
0.0180942733,
-0.0639175177,
-0.0310207158,
0.0338089913,
0.0108874757,
-0.027627226,
0.0047075138,
-0.0338660628,
0.0141740385,
-0.0036512907,
-0.023631474,
-0.036746081,
0.0078225946,
-0.0185669158,
0.022102857,
0.0232841931,
-0.0056998972,
-0.0202678274,
0.0246967021,
0.0005484057,
0.0735745355,
-0.0188566763,
0.0064935,
-0.0303428248,
0.0415573232,
0.0131440805,
0.0061190389,
0.0660479516,
-0.0199393425,
-0.0187273622,
0.037031848,
0.0600406863,
-0.0047414387,
0.0270873941,
-0.0043878397,
0.0523702651,
-0.0646165386,
0.0058766841,
0.0209223833,
0.0716746002,
-0.0210407153,
-0.0386405513,
0.1124254093,
0.0149798077,
-0.0231409092,
-0.0209183656,
0.060254436,
0.0164545421,
0.0139893536,
0.0075545278,
-0.0681362599,
-0.0418261141,
0.0244994126,
0.0330307744,
0.0002847374,
-0.0937930495,
0.0006636877,
-0.0897263438,
0.0160321761,
-0.0195462815,
-0.0903139561,
-0.0262571126,
-0.0602699555,
0.0301517248,
-0.0222652275,
0.0480748974,
-0.011599916,
0.0044186409,
0.008884321,
0.0468842424,
-0.0138099808,
-0.064720057,
-0.0383183397,
-0.0419751927,
0.0792672113,
0.0126390336,
-0.002862701,
-0.0448772982,
-0.0103512667,
-0.010410592,
-0.0739464164,
-0.0570137501,
-0.0092655253,
0.0905120596,
-0.0451552905,
-0.0272068568,
0.0013005021,
-0.0079238396,
-0.0396408848,
-0.0152760297,
-0.0240445491,
0.0153016457,
0.009424109,
0.0072306758,
0.0122892614,
-0.0233164988,
0.0449785441,
0.0445502363,
-0.0047523067,
-0.0188005865,
0.0029473989,
-0.0166212432,
0.0249129515,
-0.0242702607,
0.0499899052,
0.0265921317,
-0.0656241253,
-0.0627824292,
-0.0565201193,
-0.054631032,
0.0279529504,
0.0235873684,
0.0059733605,
-0.0190276373,
0.047415141,
-0.0024095709,
-0.0400358103,
-0.0107672671,
0.0054943631,
0.0256708115,
-0.0782026947,
0.0077247708,
0.0138207059,
0.0234562401,
-0.0584738776,
0.0166096184,
-0.0894215405,
-0.0415290445,
0.0239280835,
0.0380847827,
0.007213688,
0.005283128,
-0.0315661617,
-0.0326157436,
0.0297823679,
0.0337476172,
-0.0505314842,
-0.0410056822,
0.0399864689,
0.0384753384,
-0.0294989776,
0.0039186412,
-0.045705229,
0.0497800596,
0.0285119936,
0.0579638407,
-0.0094097834,
-0.0643407404,
-0.0227769651,
0.0176949799,
0.095270358,
-0.0336048976,
-0.0049352786,
-0.0873249397,
0.0371989235,
0.0166749619,
-0.005335093,
-0.0158450771,
0.0294863116,
0.0379521288,
0.0096452367,
-0.0421499982,
0.0255914163,
0.050066594,
0.0165187027,
-0.0378231369,
-0.0381575115,
0.0316647552,
0.0463996567,
0.0052369018,
-0.0279437173,
-0.0157347601,
0.0426222384,
0.0484323874,
0.0444629677,
-0.0281559061,
0.0172768962,
0.0467044972,
0.0130150393,
-0.0098327408,
0.024402665,
-0.0511286743,
0.0018941421,
-0.0660322383,
0.0453845561,
0.0327067524,
0.0044986461,
0.0187287144,
-0.0166794006,
0.0022838027,
-0.0057483991,
0.0120734731,
-0.0077991416,
0.0107202642,
0.0791712329,
0.0172931906,
0.0025500767,
0.0107794786,
0.0476620123,
0.0246302411,
0.0338513516,
-0.0193022024,
-0.0438093059,
-0.026404731,
-0.0042169192,
-0.0112439729,
0.0000137343,
-0.0269253794,
0.0013906704,
0.003450738,
-0.0690793321,
0.0340729691,
0.0044341334,
0.0079705771,
0.0121572791,
0.0295132138,
0.0100486288,
0.0145263961,
-0.0219250619,
-0.0375275202,
-0.0139959436,
0.0563684665,
-0.0222692043,
0.0185922924,
-6.700581551e-33,
-0.0535170622,
-0.0814280361,
-0.0146005061,
-0.0277742017,
-0.0119165117,
0.007299982,
-0.0160159096,
-0.0033867818,
0.0344636329,
0.0294559859,
-0.0017674784,
-0.0174239501,
0.0417990386,
0.0277394317,
0.0000337393,
-0.0632351041,
0.0577824563,
0.0198021661,
0.0081898523,
-0.000569117,
0.0231448058,
0.0810202435,
0.0948838219,
-0.0873208493,
0.0765792578,
-0.0049988441,
-0.0235906281,
0.0146714421,
0.0479211248,
0.0193108711,
-0.0139726866,
-0.00678741,
-0.0042714314,
-0.0553604588,
0.0046898751,
-0.0077976743,
-0.1500124633,
-0.0057849861,
-0.0585474707,
0.0670512617,
-0.0588684157,
-0.0012517738,
0.0231061783,
-0.0013846711,
0.0088902023,
0.0281233955,
0.0373977311,
0.0046400749,
-0.0001131273,
-0.0342715867,
-0.0286286548,
0.0554209836,
0.0180031173,
0.024260411,
0.0530160218,
0.0057821758,
0.0336942747,
-0.01437697,
-0.0837902948,
-0.0670845434,
-0.0181532651,
0.0050137159,
0.0021742226,
0.0555508547,
-0.0200476423,
0.032219775,
0.0169068892,
-0.0405715629,
-0.0122053912,
-0.0000874226,
-0.0099015143,
0.025665747,
0.0170305595,
-0.0134557392,
0.0318698324,
-0.0225225464,
-0.0688074157,
0.0294084754,
-0.0157609135,
0.0152919907,
-0.0304061081,
-0.0032067604,
-0.0325944722,
0.0000906819,
-0.0198867228,
-0.0638875291,
-0.0109996153,
0.0228417609,
-0.0029579522,
0.0217998829,
-0.0423021205,
0.0433626287,
0.0087728044,
0.0194606017,
-0.0627123192,
-0.0297759399,
0.0497365333,
0.0115936724,
-0.0073786429,
0.0299269464,
-0.1051338091,
-0.030062465,
0.0256801657,
0.0039868872,
-0.0089840004,
-0.0254189838,
0.0542153753,
-0.0190622248,
-0.0515824854,
0.0215488169,
-0.015297601,
0.0434350371,
0.0086376192,
0.0330810659,
0.053977143,
-0.0238632262,
-0.0039199539,
0.0446998402,
0.0607981943,
0.0385500826,
-0.0021447793,
0.0259954054,
0.0250432938,
0.0062802518,
-0.0183803476,
-0.0274668783,
0.0179540142,
-0.0164673477,
-0.0276054051,
-0.0566055886,
0.0084558316,
0.0310442802,
2.78e-7,
0.0298659932,
0.0168967582,
0.0460072234,
-0.0058572497,
0.0091300327,
0.0284445845,
0.0017790098,
0.0202624816,
-0.0054401807,
-0.0369984359,
0.0220286697,
-0.0144904759,
0.0031160829,
0.0514116697,
-0.0615163073,
-0.0626926497,
-0.0127938073,
0.0261010341,
0.0022424811,
0.0220672153,
0.0561299659,
0.0607796647,
0.0230556577,
0.0073618446,
-0.0326180868,
-0.0064717582,
0.0340203978,
0.0075713927,
0.0244821981,
0.0415408053,
0.0385587774,
0.0453897417,
-0.0348822735,
0.0245531891,
-0.0091635725,
0.0102635296,
0.039602492,
0.0439793952,
0.0208535381,
-0.0133066084,
-0.005291705,
-0.0055141165,
0.0556511581,
-0.0083193462,
0.0530652702,
-0.0561497882,
-0.0095508602,
0.0438033715,
-0.0146344407,
0.0162862632,
0.0313114412,
0.0135408528,
-0.0099639641,
0.0238793027,
0.0253642164,
0.0158029273,
-0.0356601104,
-0.0985081494,
0.042426154,
0.0270850938,
-0.010717513,
-0.0156184202,
0.0098879691,
-0.0341130234,
0.0087362938,
-0.0710292906,
-0.0230110008,
2.49294342e-34,
-0.001215277,
-0.0079650478,
-0.0498310961,
0.0384146124,
0.0198395811,
-0.0244035814,
-0.055852484,
-0.0091926325,
-0.0171262473,
-0.0409605503,
0.0069104787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08724v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08724v3 | Knowledge Graph Construction in Power Distribution Networks | 2023-11-15T06:35:01 | 2024-01-27T07:15:54 | Xiang Li, Che Wang, Bing Li, Hao Chen, Sizhe Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose a method for knowledge graph construction in power
distribution networks. This method leverages entity features, which involve
their semantic, phonetic, and syntactic characteristics, in both the knowledge
graph of distribution network and the dispatching texts. An enhanced model
based on Convolutional Neural Network, is utilized for effectively matching
dispatch text entities with those in the knowledge graph. The effectiveness of
this model is evaluated through experiments in real-world power distribution
dispatch scenarios. The results indicate that, compared with the baselines, the
proposed model excels in linking a variety of entity types, demonstrating high
overall accuracy in power distribution knowledge graph construction task. | [
0.0074737244,
0.0550942756,
-0.011421199,
0.0515068807,
0.0089866854,
-0.0141131692,
-0.0110819172,
-0.0152035858,
0.0228470061,
-0.0390625931,
0.0606658943,
-0.0012314072,
-0.0271960534,
0.0106253289,
0.0517775826,
-0.0194167495,
0.0012730063,
0.050719671,
-0.0035705189,
0.020909125,
-0.0042925007,
0.055715479,
0.0060312012,
0.0276425667,
-0.0717981085,
-0.0103577953,
0.0027932283,
0.0156426635,
0.0456531458,
-0.0289196335,
-0.0004165838,
0.0196369775,
-0.0346258059,
0.0251694191,
0.0000016264,
-0.0502976812,
-0.0560293756,
0.0007425248,
-0.0200121682,
-0.0378004424,
-0.0405136161,
-0.002944964,
0.0277145002,
0.0057361443,
-0.0477600805,
0.0248057656,
0.0493046381,
0.0626905635,
0.0084267026,
0.0824443996,
-0.0403168984,
-0.0209128223,
-0.008794575,
0.007218828,
-0.0667766556,
-0.0245836582,
0.0324521735,
-0.020302359,
-0.0108614387,
-0.0239720754,
-0.0009927948,
0.0214163996,
0.0145641323,
-0.0191804096,
0.0526170582,
0.0404470749,
-0.0195705425,
0.0553078949,
-0.0054665511,
0.0796147063,
-0.0033714313,
-0.0441794321,
0.0334899873,
-0.0136802681,
-0.0214407351,
0.0227023344,
-0.0036099306,
-0.0670624971,
-0.0499857329,
0.0049394793,
-0.0684760138,
0.0002490135,
0.0457608216,
0.0059533641,
-0.0021886616,
0.0787666291,
0.0014375102,
-0.0248581544,
0.0111541282,
0.0270279739,
0.009891198,
-0.0722345337,
0.0462515615,
0.0137903988,
0.0095580667,
0.0267293584,
0.010963778,
-0.0120553924,
-0.0096118813,
-0.0533152781,
-0.0272396766,
0.0020055517,
0.0243755076,
0.0228493307,
-0.0483153313,
0.0386717618,
-0.0478058495,
0.0478506573,
-0.0374206603,
-0.0333695821,
-0.0983951166,
-0.0214995947,
-0.0664019883,
0.0517666526,
-0.0029527727,
0.0160471685,
-0.0148947537,
-0.0067255823,
-0.0375658907,
0.0250023864,
0.0038893344,
0.0368304588,
0.0264637396,
-0.0099885073,
-0.0172652975,
0.024585342,
-0.0600305721,
0.0093784137,
-0.0674520209,
0.0168503989,
0.022583805,
-0.0252731927,
0.0273633935,
-0.0029768236,
-0.0488564782,
0.0275504924,
0.0178468116,
-0.0222999286,
-0.0893677846,
-0.0448338389,
0.0031505006,
-0.0193537604,
-0.0289984755,
-0.0639103353,
0.0055612391,
-0.0048384541,
-0.0133461384,
-0.0332577191,
-0.0066401563,
-0.0170090962,
-0.0512929708,
0.0223762207,
-0.0390681103,
0.0282063,
0.0334248878,
-0.0187907945,
0.0241370015,
-0.0146308951,
0.0361446366,
-0.0055430615,
0.0033040093,
-0.007419758,
-0.0246622358,
-0.0227614287,
0.0499804132,
-0.0200823937,
-0.00286245,
-0.0161152519,
-0.0817519203,
-0.0066291103,
-0.0126671549,
0.0419683531,
0.0094500072,
-0.0486300103,
0.0242758431,
-0.0001564463,
0.0680354014,
0.0402256884,
0.0210327543,
0.0175666306,
-0.0326959826,
-0.0195325036,
-0.0025256856,
-0.0095195631,
-0.0404710695,
0.014584152,
-0.0257501062,
0.0123439617,
-0.0059274444,
0.0258187372,
0.00458061,
0.0147629809,
0.0129080703,
0.0179530289,
0.0290570129,
0.0371807031,
-0.0272388477,
0.0703713819,
0.016252758,
0.0331270695,
0.0172900148,
0.0039917254,
-0.0353548899,
0.0797610953,
0.0477951355,
0.0074048974,
-0.0085325064,
-0.0154662905,
0.0142613277,
0.0508845374,
0.0438021757,
-0.0212090611,
-0.0125185903,
-0.0422988869,
-0.019214185,
0.023289375,
-0.0060461746,
0.0083030481,
-0.0266302191,
0.0414613225,
0.009343721,
-0.04465276,
-0.0135779027,
0.016911339,
0.0219385438,
0.0183599088,
0.0019724057,
0.0556632243,
-0.0080937138,
0.0779527798,
-0.01230036,
0.0005538627,
0.0065179826,
-0.0275082979,
-0.0802779272,
0.0032015189,
-0.0491711944,
0.0143088447,
0.026876146,
-0.0352832191,
0.0082042366,
0.006008354,
0.0031118882,
-0.0634345114,
0.0123886419,
-0.0500928983,
0.0590562299,
-0.0221887622,
-0.0210542344,
-0.017339306,
-0.0097312974,
-0.0285549369,
0.0715618581,
0.0412201695,
-0.004664768,
0.0012937444,
0.039492514,
0.0234223567,
-0.009103192,
-0.0027750335,
0.0148678459,
-0.0551560186,
0.0032379399,
0.0112807881,
-0.0313236639,
0.0093712071,
0.043813765,
-0.0991030633,
0.0061933193,
-0.0072488403,
0.047512155,
0.019662682,
-0.0019451267,
0.00475547,
-0.015416556,
-0.0230424944,
0.0495651066,
-0.0221045576,
-0.0208191238,
0.0090691121,
0.0256429724,
-0.0491585732,
-0.0276285186,
-0.0093122078,
-0.014013866,
0.0643320009,
0.0325278975,
-0.0550936274,
-0.0443432033,
0.0780851841,
-0.0411980152,
-0.0058626682,
-0.0218819249,
-0.0315804556,
-0.0399625264,
0.0527827702,
0.0470227748,
-0.0266701244,
0.0016487107,
-0.0185106136,
0.0042258091,
-0.0332136117,
-0.065191336,
0.0287992712,
-0.0305197202,
0.0214813128,
-0.0363158099,
-0.0035259977,
0.0016633347,
0.0420543291,
0.0567279644,
-0.0068179257,
-0.0051351604,
-0.0582332276,
0.0009757314,
0.0062963576,
-0.0368753262,
-0.0492930599,
0.0222316105,
0.0057551158,
0.0007140894,
0.0083297435,
0.0799486861,
-0.0317927673,
0.0388273336,
-0.0227322467,
-0.0621198788,
-0.0072095157,
0.0750765204,
-0.0006829172,
0.04520908,
0.0000646439,
-0.0032433856,
-0.0344434679,
0.027431177,
0.0174748376,
0.002218433,
0.0280961785,
-0.0241997316,
0.0231232941,
0.0109845437,
-0.0248569883,
-0.032729324,
-0.0123911677,
0.0021896681,
0.0132638626,
0.0845531151,
-0.0305610709,
0.0250801593,
0.0686915815,
0.0000345347,
0.0079289228,
-0.0082677742,
0.0029250446,
0.0060888221,
0.0551734567,
0.0140794059,
0.0357493125,
0.0353424959,
0.0530205779,
-0.0032214692,
0.0301588103,
0.0090825846,
-0.0018670546,
-0.0147380866,
-0.0190748163,
-0.049739439,
-0.0730431974,
-0.0147179412,
-0.0206757132,
0.0100595104,
0.0038140821,
0.0467014574,
0.0609767064,
0.0343363583,
-0.0249452349,
0.0190938637,
0.0271221884,
0.0002629189,
0.0136650847,
0.0537682511,
-0.1143370122,
0.0116033498,
0.0085999593,
-0.0096950643,
-0.0167540964,
-0.0687541291,
-0.0217586532,
-0.0814685896,
-0.0411465615,
-0.0157346353,
-0.0222022478,
-0.0494991317,
-0.0554620773,
0.0092048766,
0.0132832397,
-0.0720286593,
-0.0310453214,
0.0030110737,
-0.0399991795,
0.048325032,
-0.0258917063,
-0.0518299825,
-0.0091530364,
-0.0423560552,
0.033378277,
0.0277883615,
0.0425557606,
-0.0062965057,
0.0247250199,
-0.0396330059,
-0.0204459727,
-0.0397766791,
0.012823238,
0.0517420322,
0.0066502513,
0.012995854,
-0.0067518959,
0.0086935507,
-0.0292530041,
-0.0070430539,
0.0131772989,
0.0435209386,
-0.0147729442,
-0.0453896634,
-0.0281252246,
0.0057893433,
0.0502072349,
0.0238852855,
-0.0098103229,
0.0108786393,
-0.03280643,
-0.0184598137,
0.0297476035,
-0.054095652,
-0.0174351837,
0.0886363611,
-0.0215676017,
-0.0242863242,
-0.0602992177,
-0.0366077572,
-0.0008972394,
0.0242628623,
0.0419498347,
-0.0282040443,
0.0826957971,
-0.0335389934,
-0.0675520971,
-0.0092925923,
0.001324391,
0.0615066141,
-0.0212818868,
-0.0151587175,
0.027154075,
-0.0020031126,
-0.0218887348,
0.025947053,
-0.0830394998,
-0.0497626178,
-0.0232929718,
-0.015062185,
0.0187616106,
0.0305663813,
-0.0433057882,
-0.033507362,
0.0198672935,
0.0650812238,
-0.073474668,
-0.0425902717,
-0.0343514383,
-0.0469060466,
0.0008612652,
0.06364014,
-0.055126559,
0.0440134592,
-0.0077995113,
0.0404591188,
-0.0490715727,
-0.0170568954,
0.0207554158,
0.0176200047,
-0.0235496573,
0.0128754359,
-0.0290000942,
-0.0728719905,
0.0415848009,
0.0184975564,
0.0054769982,
-0.0260371324,
-0.0292493459,
-0.0295975879,
0.026749244,
0.0172349457,
0.0145620452,
0.086569652,
0.0031571137,
0.0179424975,
-0.0378514044,
0.0332958549,
0.0122488216,
0.0459216721,
0.0372730903,
0.0038041582,
0.0391479619,
0.0578560866,
-0.0044877348,
-0.0091832951,
-0.021559922,
0.0555524305,
-0.0330304578,
-0.0589463748,
-0.0129090995,
-0.0178991668,
-0.0311610028,
-0.0126030035,
-0.0168893728,
0.0720051005,
0.0006881196,
-0.0014082065,
-0.0459476896,
0.0170372017,
0.0105466489,
0.0074726027,
-0.005852045,
0.0117641632,
0.0356824361,
0.0218765996,
-0.0238976516,
0.0366456956,
0.0497307628,
0.0363613963,
0.0429562293,
-0.0051701018,
-0.0577860773,
-0.0639084205,
-0.0107876714,
0.0307683405,
-0.0088808322,
-0.0004873272,
-0.0224479865,
-0.0891288668,
-0.0327771828,
0.032999564,
-0.0371581428,
-0.0081589939,
0.0116958423,
0.0832271799,
-0.0074191121,
0.0374615155,
0.0141945658,
0.0138597917,
-0.0221155826,
-0.0478429869,
-0.0121872891,
0.0017887625,
-5.503504022e-33,
-0.0045072143,
-0.1062871292,
0.022666581,
0.0528578572,
-0.016972404,
0.031271752,
-0.0214858633,
-0.0298784282,
-0.0362808406,
0.022497857,
0.009348074,
-0.0011741172,
0.0101824356,
-0.0024939328,
-0.0386028141,
-0.0028856797,
0.0789144263,
0.0183747094,
0.024860153,
0.0297312178,
0.0640979111,
0.062492311,
0.0623287484,
-0.0614864975,
0.005233427,
-0.0146694155,
0.0304179825,
0.0220315792,
0.0212699398,
0.0569881275,
-0.0083858687,
0.0359716006,
0.0328824632,
-0.0092257597,
0.0153608769,
0.047318466,
-0.0781305507,
-0.0317409113,
-0.0337124094,
0.0242937095,
-0.0228109807,
0.0037787887,
0.0880764574,
0.0172920618,
0.0350391567,
-0.0181327965,
0.0851693675,
0.0080100708,
-0.016725732,
-0.0533611514,
-0.0292280298,
0.0275658816,
-0.0285637788,
0.0033353518,
0.0047250288,
-0.0112977829,
0.0336928703,
-0.0034280054,
-0.0780144334,
-0.0026420187,
0.0098701948,
0.0169519503,
0.0395132266,
-0.0050391038,
-0.0425159335,
0.0339731686,
-0.0458944589,
-0.0094354972,
-0.0711474568,
0.0247680228,
0.0380645543,
0.0603889897,
-0.0083959447,
0.0360033028,
-0.0483602546,
-0.0650558025,
-0.1041357741,
-0.006041863,
-0.0128463181,
-0.0029164266,
-0.0206152406,
-0.0013023876,
-0.002339382,
0.0120401531,
-0.0022976811,
-0.0086547649,
-0.0206916984,
-0.0598913506,
-0.0092353672,
-0.0173033085,
0.0009635233,
0.0528129973,
-0.0244027674,
-0.0386595018,
-0.0039897375,
0.078185983,
0.0272363387,
0.0170710739,
0.0071189203,
0.0269727819,
-0.0847373679,
0.0037694736,
0.0209068991,
0.0129042957,
-0.006858876,
0.0103748776,
0.0335583873,
0.0196265038,
-0.0190762021,
0.0283909459,
-0.0178818852,
-0.0320526622,
-0.0728173107,
0.0235289261,
0.0094312979,
0.0212878417,
0.0242239982,
0.0104373265,
-0.0026179224,
0.0149041163,
0.034532465,
0.0392453596,
0.0233260784,
0.0262698438,
-0.0121179894,
-0.0227528475,
-0.0458294973,
0.0083499486,
-0.0237322841,
-0.026162874,
-0.0061802552,
0.0100926524,
2.521e-7,
0.0276243147,
0.031702362,
0.0472288169,
0.023589585,
-0.0043156468,
-0.0062267529,
0.0159997493,
0.0430037118,
-0.045978833,
-0.000676329,
0.0423399471,
-0.0371499024,
0.0123322913,
0.075298965,
-0.1182629615,
-0.0076235053,
-0.0621628389,
-0.0238297917,
-0.0514558963,
-0.0530846491,
0.0726765096,
0.0345505476,
0.0545656309,
0.0164442379,
0.0092426352,
-0.0557436384,
0.0007899613,
-0.0047176545,
0.0167070404,
0.0385602787,
0.0013981035,
0.0268489867,
-0.0204230137,
0.0872984901,
-0.0271453466,
0.0276335757,
0.0175643638,
-0.0021782301,
0.0078227706,
-0.0314419232,
-0.0224843919,
-0.0514066145,
0.0450776927,
-0.0396103859,
-0.0125493715,
-0.0429792628,
-0.0040304163,
0.1202591285,
-0.0068102144,
-0.0253048874,
-0.0168102011,
0.0125673516,
0.0189412571,
-0.0001037057,
0.0273972098,
-0.0138485581,
-0.0066773398,
-0.0750828087,
0.0205543302,
0.0663328916,
0.0161012225,
-0.0344227105,
-0.0338217095,
-0.0285715181,
0.0826226249,
0.0065213484,
0.0324561186,
1.742851635e-34,
-0.0445274189,
0.0148772281,
-0.0479220375,
0.0142873432,
0.0228434503,
-0.0028445302,
-0.0137057612,
0.0149367014,
-0.0045422451,
-0.0709879994,
0.0039536571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08723v1 | Token Prediction as Implicit Classification to Identify LLM-Generated Text | 2023-11-15T06:33:52 | 2023-11-15T06:33:52 | Yutian Chen, Hao Kang, Vivian Zhai, Liangze Li, Rita Singh, Bhiksha Raj | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel approach for identifying the possible large
language models (LLMs) involved in text generation. Instead of adding an
additional classification layer to a base LM, we reframe the classification
task as a next-token prediction task and directly fine-tune the base LM to
perform it. We utilize the Text-to-Text Transfer Transformer (T5) model as the
backbone for our experiments. We compared our approach to the more direct
approach of utilizing hidden states for classification. Evaluation shows the
exceptional performance of our method in the text classification task,
highlighting its simplicity and efficiency. Furthermore, interpretability
studies on the features extracted by our model reveal its ability to
differentiate distinctive writing styles among various LLMs even in the absence
of an explicit classifier. We also collected a dataset named OpenLLMText,
containing approximately 340k text samples from human and LLMs, including
GPT3.5, PaLM, LLaMA, and GPT2. | [
0.027850911,
0.027840564,
-0.0179318991,
0.0416882485,
-0.0312841274,
0.0032519277,
0.0281537864,
0.06605912,
0.0117494501,
-0.0666181371,
-0.0510290638,
-0.0311720297,
0.0167477708,
0.0642950535,
0.0514491089,
-0.0349240042,
0.0170675423,
-0.0411706641,
-0.0071654459,
0.0389790423,
0.010934948,
0.027873937,
0.0384156182,
0.0604918189,
-0.0042400523,
-0.0151442811,
-0.0256988145,
0.0292636417,
-0.00664199,
0.0004361631,
-0.0060620909,
0.077867493,
0.0147002051,
0.0506088883,
0.0000019945,
-0.0398999676,
-0.031988129,
-0.0316574164,
0.0232896339,
-0.0102322996,
0.0342442878,
-0.0016154415,
-0.0173890516,
0.0475183241,
-0.0021645289,
0.0074690836,
0.0367663726,
0.0804473087,
0.0297046434,
0.0714494884,
-0.0127283596,
-0.0035115872,
0.0402757116,
0.0059914524,
0.0394384041,
0.0098511986,
0.0344857164,
-0.0618362911,
-0.0358245298,
-0.0093609346,
-0.0000954233,
0.0090121115,
0.0023942376,
-0.0477535836,
0.0094222501,
0.0228960309,
0.0017064443,
-0.001402546,
-0.0126473345,
0.0255543739,
-0.0208406039,
-0.0558897592,
0.0472436324,
-0.0106862029,
0.0014850098,
0.0010939837,
-0.0104356706,
0.0204545353,
-0.0171712395,
0.0189485662,
0.0546148159,
0.0056924624,
0.0385896489,
0.0068109878,
-0.0134643344,
0.0399259403,
0.0104341041,
-0.0158900153,
-0.0480131693,
0.0069724075,
0.0351837501,
-0.0827189609,
0.0683846027,
0.0388395153,
0.0097539499,
-0.00405664,
-0.0716447979,
-0.063443996,
-0.0000596519,
-0.0080989664,
0.0579321124,
0.0279244855,
-0.0178608336,
-0.0301183946,
-0.0806834102,
0.0520993285,
-0.0191159956,
0.0160197373,
-0.0237894412,
0.0254018512,
-0.0443290435,
-0.0568452775,
-0.0029899753,
0.0430414043,
-0.0063502602,
-0.0195047595,
-0.0513822623,
0.0139485803,
0.0169304274,
-0.0404129922,
0.0019213572,
-0.0051562046,
-0.0315579362,
0.0026164118,
-0.0196756721,
-0.0263009686,
0.026650954,
0.0264944788,
0.0204985384,
-0.0510504991,
0.0005279275,
0.0674771667,
0.0106675439,
-0.0138961552,
-0.0171812735,
0.0619459189,
-0.0651045442,
-0.0292412974,
-0.061499577,
-0.0538192727,
-0.0102552604,
-0.0114252819,
0.0084975176,
-0.0637186915,
-0.0230238307,
0.0002627273,
0.0039953827,
-0.0203015488,
-0.0058935988,
0.0306040253,
0.0154443001,
0.0448408127,
0.0158077572,
0.0002069622,
0.0802114904,
-0.0018410237,
-0.0123750512,
0.0085098352,
0.0334868282,
0.1068189889,
-0.0053483625,
-0.0271174964,
0.0305437576,
0.076641418,
0.0193877146,
-0.0072873165,
-0.0368269496,
-0.0572549365,
-0.0134221734,
0.0202044882,
0.0391304828,
0.0579056703,
0.0144644054,
0.0222681984,
0.086434193,
0.0790873319,
0.0262453537,
0.0431241356,
0.0622484609,
0.0049482537,
0.001238443,
0.0077543012,
-0.0150726344,
0.0298460703,
-0.0316968411,
0.0012004594,
0.0452211946,
0.0015559588,
-0.0045167152,
-0.0191764347,
-0.0108667416,
-0.0362227447,
-0.0202296097,
-0.0539075136,
0.0361926407,
0.017601693,
-0.0574998111,
0.0569833145,
-0.0149982665,
-0.0418227874,
0.0111690359,
-0.1033126786,
0.0578159802,
0.0646011308,
0.0292145517,
0.0028742708,
0.0206928048,
-0.0158043709,
-0.0138823055,
0.0811908767,
-0.0100857858,
0.0046423408,
-0.0001488399,
-0.0444963761,
0.0007003762,
0.0278738793,
0.0131594595,
0.0185420606,
-0.0229612887,
0.0307071339,
0.0424375162,
-0.0269379131,
-0.0073158601,
0.0562965423,
-0.0218615178,
-0.0398584753,
0.0499613062,
0.0080854176,
0.0270432364,
-0.0177727267,
0.0108558349,
0.0323073342,
-0.0006779072,
-0.0583531074,
-0.0210954975,
-0.0102274269,
-0.0561218709,
-0.0094948038,
-0.0070091896,
-0.0001931131,
0.0217803903,
0.0321733877,
-0.0105428062,
-0.0728544518,
-0.0095997173,
-0.0426776707,
0.0440779813,
-0.0658793375,
0.0258552805,
0.0073946393,
0.0151041774,
0.0032210271,
0.0479812697,
-0.0054540373,
-0.0238561574,
0.0059490064,
-0.0181719307,
0.0033002356,
-0.0126436874,
0.0069209356,
-0.0236118026,
-0.0296980236,
-0.0099266795,
0.0163480639,
0.0345769785,
-0.0297922343,
-0.0626585707,
-0.0681855902,
0.0044649448,
-0.0150133027,
0.0404359959,
0.0380268432,
-0.016206447,
0.0042928075,
0.0238431953,
-0.056666024,
-0.014523996,
0.0202881116,
-0.0274499413,
0.0608164109,
-0.0305419248,
-0.0086350655,
-0.02324914,
0.0106244003,
-0.0204069391,
0.0571296476,
-0.0054344404,
-0.0321897008,
-0.0602456704,
0.0313406251,
0.0008333648,
-0.0367834046,
0.0142447883,
-0.0460154042,
0.0095257219,
-0.0132565461,
0.0611047484,
0.039167393,
0.0503332913,
0.0470651872,
0.0174925104,
0.0184048172,
-0.0144019816,
-0.0392686985,
-0.0019238119,
0.0353924111,
-0.011572632,
-0.0767209306,
0.0300842039,
0.0876478255,
0.0494497269,
0.0146581829,
-0.0622915179,
0.0171596687,
-0.0000419019,
-0.0296183303,
0.0044413982,
0.0032912798,
-0.0593292899,
0.0126861464,
-0.0227659065,
-0.0829075798,
0.036147356,
-0.0751403794,
0.0188091025,
0.0289559141,
-0.0252890121,
-0.0347156078,
0.0385454185,
0.0224357191,
0.0304612387,
0.0184021574,
-0.0553083681,
-0.0162517615,
0.0280488003,
-0.0263797194,
-0.0105586182,
0.0476158895,
-0.0202077199,
-0.0032564234,
0.001079306,
-0.0148868803,
-0.0183745082,
-0.0293617081,
-0.0003710298,
0.014017011,
0.0322939903,
-0.0481891371,
-0.0104529951,
0.0061615943,
-0.0076543097,
0.0695712119,
-0.0537495129,
-0.015839871,
-0.0341283232,
0.0585536435,
0.0337599479,
-0.0302880071,
-0.0067919507,
-0.0728995502,
-0.0028110696,
0.0445187278,
-0.0089703882,
0.0246861931,
-0.0264403187,
-0.0010930661,
0.0212184191,
-0.024553638,
-0.0354694091,
0.0329420082,
0.0438263863,
-0.059074726,
-0.0187037867,
0.1261590272,
0.0200130977,
-0.0510321409,
0.0144362263,
-0.0096972743,
0.0340667032,
-0.0130892759,
0.0174591281,
-0.0350353606,
-0.0437785164,
0.0000887995,
0.0287442934,
-0.0723529011,
-0.0004647287,
-0.0194369312,
-0.0503783673,
0.0082314583,
0.010146481,
-0.0584916063,
0.0095841093,
-0.0131502394,
-0.0305124018,
0.04085752,
-0.0223849099,
-0.0185376815,
-0.0183277559,
0.0005483709,
0.0239972658,
-0.0500990562,
-0.0254476648,
0.0126555646,
0.0185702033,
0.0282431245,
0.0481508449,
0.0338075161,
-0.022668656,
-0.0310466625,
0.0354070365,
-0.0230432376,
0.0345067158,
-0.0380425006,
0.021047907,
0.0008549176,
0.022159433,
-0.0423366018,
0.0554934442,
-0.022369571,
-0.0127067799,
-0.0029007527,
0.0734436736,
-0.0319229104,
-0.0688543469,
0.0021381644,
-0.0262077171,
0.0004591307,
0.0626794472,
0.0435549095,
-0.0544762574,
-0.0553418994,
-0.0368172526,
0.0274420287,
-0.0654012114,
-0.0130848559,
-0.0375097841,
-0.0015125168,
-0.0402057096,
-0.1027127802,
0.006731424,
-0.0061890502,
0.0246748906,
0.0143182306,
0.0463666394,
-0.0194616672,
-0.0254841074,
-0.0379463248,
0.0046113306,
-0.0098785749,
0.0112788696,
-0.0783216506,
-0.0243077297,
0.0180637036,
-0.0855835825,
-0.0028720025,
0.0108893737,
-0.0936279222,
-0.0374346823,
-0.0124842608,
0.0309105627,
0.0143857272,
-0.0171138588,
0.0096488409,
-0.072266981,
0.0986796692,
0.0649695396,
-0.0097301034,
0.0101092588,
0.0001469852,
0.0002262061,
-0.0190617889,
0.0194417424,
-0.0227428954,
-0.0045084618,
0.0283536278,
-0.0345151797,
-0.0212754011,
-0.0220958684,
-0.0044884314,
0.011543138,
0.0277558006,
-0.0280556288,
0.011473258,
-0.0343847461,
-0.0144382874,
-0.0110212974,
0.0117957992,
-0.0517126359,
-0.0006870701,
0.0232024062,
0.0113494573,
-0.0133100441,
-0.0213587768,
-0.0043609147,
0.0299377926,
-0.0055215508,
0.0232059453,
-0.0074325209,
0.0927521139,
0.000543387,
0.0032441719,
-0.0169748422,
-0.0006204901,
-0.0233724806,
0.0246121641,
-0.0127189765,
0.0471761674,
0.0013756008,
0.0442993492,
-0.0023181411,
0.0568662956,
-0.0499462187,
0.0079925796,
-0.0638921261,
0.0155508798,
0.0162296817,
0.0009430011,
0.0558749139,
-0.0428836904,
0.0186090246,
-0.026959192,
0.0844860375,
-0.0139790801,
-0.0429138914,
0.003747094,
-0.0233039856,
-0.0187136903,
-0.0384148285,
0.0760520995,
0.0471296571,
0.013939973,
0.0069352635,
-0.0191355646,
-0.0324687883,
0.0202453714,
0.0526660085,
-0.0068287365,
0.0062624724,
-0.0174867306,
-0.0129238758,
-0.0486107208,
0.0706442222,
-0.0195879582,
0.0113199828,
-0.0186290685,
0.0096599171,
0.0535169989,
-0.0068889805,
-0.031675823,
-0.0699945539,
0.0028502527,
0.0235567708,
-0.0086871479,
-0.0163391866,
-6.250061586e-33,
-0.0202618781,
-0.1084321067,
-0.0076215868,
0.0233755913,
-0.021902537,
0.0015716818,
-0.0704924688,
-0.0187282171,
0.0628418401,
-0.005928325,
-0.0180421509,
-0.0014555879,
0.0212478228,
0.046537891,
0.0048254207,
0.0138386032,
0.0558637157,
-0.0300800167,
-0.0324188806,
0.0474334843,
0.0837520584,
0.0287832264,
0.0324637964,
-0.0276757851,
-0.0011481692,
-0.0188478176,
-0.0214655865,
-0.007953818,
-0.0298061892,
0.0452743806,
-0.0318644233,
-0.0038676017,
0.043145176,
-0.0068402574,
-0.032158196,
0.0405730307,
-0.0098848315,
-0.0082895793,
-0.0063586649,
0.0105210394,
0.0166814011,
-0.088935256,
0.0558146127,
-0.0198308397,
-0.0354493074,
0.0018018514,
0.0363680534,
-0.0008082723,
-0.007841601,
-0.0761125386,
-0.0595310219,
0.0204683412,
0.0041608317,
0.002859208,
0.031367518,
0.0548151024,
-0.0164644755,
0.0049538021,
-0.0643918291,
0.0248439666,
0.0041323858,
0.0299102459,
0.0662975758,
0.0582752675,
-0.0103689451,
0.0428611077,
0.0157802124,
-0.0090136146,
-0.0629775971,
0.0089097777,
0.0327538475,
0.0384197906,
0.0311509445,
0.0007559541,
0.0166348182,
-0.0462258235,
-0.0024439876,
0.0554240011,
0.0211992506,
-0.0392947011,
0.0540422238,
0.0021828578,
-0.0019090099,
-0.017849585,
-0.0091320965,
-0.0313672908,
-0.0200815666,
-0.0161671359,
0.0485661328,
-0.0134106996,
-0.0030074064,
-0.0563841537,
0.0334414728,
-0.0231572352,
-0.0100101037,
-0.023256192,
-0.0282615069,
0.0402946025,
-0.0130675137,
-0.0099171279,
-0.0456394702,
-0.0737019926,
0.0494585745,
0.0054027783,
0.0341853909,
0.0212945659,
0.0041267425,
0.0369820781,
-0.0775176883,
0.0067961044,
-0.0123893647,
0.0011486441,
0.0019512675,
0.0189963505,
0.0178861674,
-0.048183959,
-0.0069964183,
0.0379334427,
-0.0023782139,
0.0058081523,
-0.0143130505,
-0.011111238,
-0.0199491475,
0.0428734757,
-0.0576401353,
0.0082575642,
-0.0444313101,
0.0311925001,
0.0459882431,
-0.0331019573,
0.0073848343,
0.021045886,
2.602e-7,
0.0206711981,
0.0466524176,
0.007801028,
0.0060095196,
0.026670102,
0.0597047284,
0.0147245051,
0.0269601531,
0.011834844,
0.0179825593,
0.0016366168,
-0.0232820958,
0.0899560004,
0.0097691473,
-0.079222098,
0.0371978246,
-0.0739772841,
0.0397401862,
-0.0510880873,
0.0158215612,
0.0585355982,
0.0526113398,
-0.0272513218,
-0.0386252329,
0.0421605781,
-0.030112084,
0.0651675984,
-0.0124885738,
0.020102486,
0.0045533008,
0.0449880809,
-0.0305420924,
0.0086238887,
0.0023896699,
-0.030990202,
-0.0101278704,
-0.0054182182,
0.063176021,
-0.012293186,
-0.0030710166,
0.015409397,
0.021263713,
0.0064437985,
-0.0559883416,
0.0411245227,
0.017330898,
-0.0235338826,
-0.0133240074,
0.0205341466,
-0.0267783925,
-0.0257824473,
-0.0285165161,
0.0084462846,
0.0448862053,
0.0077996533,
-0.0122997882,
-0.0076017254,
-0.0395186059,
-0.0510958917,
-0.0510968305,
-0.071260646,
-0.004371549,
-0.1086440831,
0.0368706509,
0.0284370407,
-0.0461913534,
-0.0003161443,
2.750699025e-34,
-0.031122651,
-0.0346166976,
-0.0034489124,
0.0300704055,
0.0117665837,
0.0197222605,
0.0491998792,
0.0423282534,
0.0052462397,
-0.0737946406,
-0.0037484658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08719v1 | Think-in-Memory: Recalling and Post-thinking Enable LLMs with Long-Term Memory | 2023-11-15T06:08:35 | 2023-11-15T06:08:35 | Lei Liu, Xiaoyan Yang, Yue Shen, Binbin Hu, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jinjie Gu, Guannan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Memory-augmented Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
performance in long-term human-machine interactions, which basically relies on
iterative recalling and reasoning of history to generate high-quality
responses. However, such repeated recall-reason steps easily produce biased
thoughts, \textit{i.e.}, inconsistent reasoning results when recalling the same
history for different questions. On the contrary, humans can keep thoughts in
the memory and recall them without repeated reasoning. Motivated by this human
capability, we propose a novel memory mechanism called TiM (Think-in-Memory)
that enables LLMs to maintain an evolved memory for storing historical thoughts
along the conversation stream. The TiM framework consists of two crucial
stages: (1) before generating a response, a LLM agent recalls relevant thoughts
from memory, and (2) after generating a response, the LLM agent post-thinks and
incorporates both historical and new thoughts to update the memory. Thus, TiM
can eliminate the issue of repeated reasoning by saving the post-thinking
thoughts as the history. Besides, we formulate the basic principles to organize
the thoughts in memory based on the well-established operations,
(\textit{i.e.}, insert, forget, and merge operations), allowing for dynamic
updates and evolution of the thoughts. Furthermore, we introduce
Locality-Sensitive Hashing into TiM to achieve efficient retrieval for the
long-term conversations. We conduct qualitative and quantitative experiments on
real-world and simulated dialogues covering a wide range of topics,
demonstrating that equipping existing LLMs with TiM significantly enhances
their performance in generating responses for long-term interactions. | [
0.0526943952,
0.0316116028,
-0.0285356212,
0.0192642752,
-0.0470151827,
0.0037318945,
-0.0058262441,
-0.0144105488,
0.0434066802,
-0.0519120581,
-0.0179837383,
-0.0637520552,
0.0003591225,
0.0494667739,
0.0139762871,
-0.0368099958,
0.0510977954,
-0.0292641521,
0.0081982305,
-0.0081873275,
0.0120391157,
-0.0318116806,
-0.0078148525,
0.0064883889,
0.003666298,
0.0035734873,
-0.0632231683,
-0.0126192886,
0.0080126897,
-0.024309488,
-0.0163310822,
0.01805811,
0.0209388994,
0.0173424911,
0.0000020766,
-0.0490366071,
-0.0052218013,
-0.0356289297,
0.0028331121,
-0.0178738534,
0.0096332338,
0.0405332558,
-0.0132950554,
0.0197053179,
-0.0591719374,
-0.005394978,
0.0231520664,
0.0549208373,
0.0782593638,
0.0561134778,
-0.0038351889,
-0.0161454137,
0.0335875526,
-0.0134982811,
0.0597979166,
-0.0356982276,
0.0162212159,
-0.0054125204,
-0.0032640733,
0.0341079421,
0.0025371893,
0.034019161,
0.027529994,
-0.0254244525,
0.0169643536,
0.0418761596,
0.0077236416,
-0.0047767428,
-0.0302065052,
0.0468476824,
0.033631146,
-0.0354363844,
0.0090077408,
0.0266605094,
0.002004086,
-0.0304987039,
-0.0575121269,
0.0145998914,
-0.0065814932,
-0.0088994,
-0.025602242,
-0.0230817404,
0.0122033833,
0.046940174,
-0.0266002715,
-0.0001950196,
-0.002489334,
-0.0537414066,
-0.036662858,
-0.025554195,
0.0037063987,
-0.071150735,
0.0114186388,
0.0817599967,
-0.0198639426,
0.0135498168,
-0.0237861183,
0.0256275646,
0.0076981089,
-0.0380244218,
0.032594718,
0.0347872414,
0.0123290475,
0.0687771738,
-0.0418157093,
0.0425875746,
-0.0276486706,
-0.0324791335,
-0.0354955606,
-0.0076476862,
-0.0684181228,
-0.0284231137,
-0.0029879664,
0.0853093565,
0.0147883901,
-0.0182167031,
-0.0062322635,
0.061384514,
-0.0026052329,
0.0043230504,
-0.0584611148,
0.0065816371,
0.0227470063,
-0.006362767,
-0.0765856653,
0.0183630064,
-0.0315118134,
-0.0009537372,
0.0523118302,
-0.0400265492,
-0.0256945491,
-0.0017392781,
-0.0002794203,
-0.0020876271,
-0.0041241171,
0.0108719133,
-0.0184515659,
-0.0183790699,
-0.0300626997,
-0.0269826576,
-0.003480827,
-0.0565574206,
0.0372944251,
-0.038525641,
0.0469470844,
-0.0051564774,
-0.0370317996,
-0.0239095166,
0.0132554583,
0.0284470879,
-0.0365502834,
0.0414676033,
0.028026931,
0.0053405538,
0.0615125038,
0.0239457898,
0.0145683512,
0.0160431396,
0.0469801016,
0.0049642203,
-0.0104992772,
0.0014573048,
0.0170904547,
-0.0015146972,
0.0366739109,
-0.0311773159,
-0.018484477,
0.0375459604,
0.0083307158,
0.0464529507,
-0.0315033086,
0.0567600168,
-0.0346089303,
-0.0030069354,
0.0819086134,
0.0669709519,
-0.0130550461,
0.0366511829,
-0.0004115293,
-0.0057630204,
-0.0062643257,
0.00142786,
-0.0446475595,
0.0695255622,
-0.0404188223,
0.0007626616,
0.0317301117,
-0.0050142445,
-0.0476943739,
-0.0148713551,
0.012800999,
0.0017089677,
0.0190203991,
0.0293822512,
-0.0043492471,
0.001803557,
-0.0386214629,
0.0824978575,
-0.0209479257,
-0.0403220318,
-0.0293371063,
-0.0754122883,
0.0614330284,
0.0630204305,
0.0407378189,
-0.004527247,
-0.0349878222,
-0.0115225697,
0.0051016659,
0.0388525352,
0.0596046858,
0.0078074336,
-0.0297234971,
-0.0431371108,
0.0008494554,
-0.0033648687,
-0.0245679617,
0.0120371636,
0.0306931902,
0.0142918313,
0.0065972968,
0.0686480775,
0.0352069847,
0.0001959725,
-0.0108244335,
0.0073841824,
-0.0126562621,
-0.0150354896,
0.0165200252,
0.0143001005,
0.0015403868,
0.0361635387,
0.044897832,
-0.0307899434,
-0.0502773486,
0.0266779419,
-0.0798960775,
-0.024494024,
0.029999245,
0.0265605841,
0.0116184615,
-0.0177035127,
-0.0060542561,
-0.0549481809,
0.016127795,
-0.0423583873,
0.0587933213,
-0.049588684,
0.0268016178,
-0.0134661142,
-0.0114899827,
-0.0212513842,
0.0820479915,
-0.0216556136,
-0.027118871,
0.0151210604,
0.0277348459,
-0.017958276,
-0.0434989445,
-0.0100079179,
0.0291544534,
0.0031573456,
-0.0093340259,
0.0307794549,
0.00478453,
-0.0694942549,
-0.0374920033,
-0.1243629828,
0.0155961961,
0.0019788314,
-0.0142361224,
0.0072314069,
0.0230060574,
0.0017244332,
-0.0075104618,
-0.0669403672,
0.0251108166,
0.030938657,
0.0431722775,
0.0310277026,
0.0055598933,
0.0091211135,
-0.0291232467,
0.0089043463,
-0.0144562656,
0.0233494248,
-0.0218541082,
-0.0322185867,
-0.0369837992,
0.0592532419,
-0.0814255551,
0.0342118815,
-0.0212707818,
-0.0347285643,
0.0209877174,
-0.0516439602,
0.0643093213,
0.1011830494,
0.055599153,
-0.0279587246,
0.028144734,
-0.0390583649,
-0.0576901585,
0.0393263586,
-0.0116854822,
-0.0107813366,
0.0097054113,
0.0136736939,
-0.0250506978,
0.0520605445,
-0.0072125937,
0.0049503087,
-0.0395040885,
0.0317422636,
0.0272922553,
-0.0264481977,
-0.0389316343,
-0.017796101,
-0.0419536792,
0.03326796,
-0.0348010138,
-0.0341962352,
0.0888116881,
0.0212645717,
0.0066585355,
-0.0235987417,
0.0188641381,
-0.0300738458,
0.0990706459,
-0.0153080048,
-0.0028802718,
-0.0261989385,
-0.0117378524,
-0.0543167144,
-0.0327844732,
-0.0123269763,
-0.0612630472,
0.0099985003,
-0.0473037846,
0.0155176977,
0.0011366191,
-0.0447882451,
-0.0645785853,
-0.0178180654,
-0.0219752975,
-0.0036984852,
0.0003613468,
-0.0009134563,
-0.0112297377,
0.0247654058,
0.0746164173,
0.0209185965,
-0.014156458,
-0.0096388916,
-0.0025559452,
0.0213448536,
0.0570303649,
0.0160915423,
0.0273419004,
0.0122200055,
0.0820449963,
0.086820662,
0.0531398058,
-0.0088514183,
-0.017580159,
-0.0002633104,
-0.0026536726,
-0.0056005642,
-0.0097608194,
0.0112491297,
0.0378224291,
-0.0611985475,
-0.0326845273,
0.1080894694,
0.0530706719,
-0.0379101783,
-0.0335886851,
-0.0354103521,
0.0399090126,
-0.0005512704,
0.0052939518,
-0.0860526115,
-0.0209614374,
0.018337585,
-0.0508664325,
-0.0303041246,
-0.0498018228,
-0.0003428295,
-0.1289301664,
-0.0194946043,
0.0186954308,
-0.0060688099,
0.0130852591,
-0.0231694784,
-0.037718866,
0.0580214784,
0.0111655351,
0.0416418202,
0.0182696022,
-0.0239064153,
-0.006665695,
-0.0179400463,
0.0005152131,
0.0531963855,
-0.0178889036,
0.0319420695,
0.0697283223,
0.0475632995,
0.0524593368,
-0.0496188439,
0.0530956909,
0.0297128502,
0.0260245521,
-0.0139704775,
0.0058003194,
-0.0172548015,
0.0101830941,
-0.036834538,
0.0361325108,
-0.0182643309,
-0.0218915567,
0.0295820888,
0.0615478083,
-0.0638747439,
0.0026521967,
-0.0068265977,
0.0048454753,
-0.0113681452,
0.0880634338,
0.0175441615,
-0.0432600901,
-0.0585087165,
-0.0084117083,
-0.013250594,
-0.0066166199,
-0.0433636494,
-0.0109396735,
0.0380146168,
0.0549174137,
-0.0907094851,
-0.0693864599,
0.0129159167,
0.0069637201,
0.0072674346,
-0.0135700386,
0.0104250228,
-0.0125969201,
-0.0450813361,
-0.0108934538,
-0.0561989211,
-0.015863698,
-0.0162255336,
0.011848744,
0.0656651706,
-0.0212536082,
0.0137531105,
0.0457849242,
-0.099919498,
-0.0569394864,
-0.0139230387,
0.0517721586,
0.0245037116,
0.0592697412,
0.0278189015,
-0.0374159776,
0.0486734733,
-0.0241370909,
-0.0390108936,
0.0136937387,
0.004515063,
0.0587618798,
0.0213750321,
0.0353083424,
-0.0350397564,
-0.0121901175,
-0.0157196894,
0.0303860959,
-0.0357940495,
-0.0253005736,
0.0001924322,
-0.0302914474,
0.0140595976,
0.0378694832,
0.0044265641,
0.0164623223,
0.0476943627,
-0.0272763558,
0.0061959871,
-0.0356486812,
0.0081239985,
0.0147044351,
0.0003490907,
0.0146159045,
-0.0278587006,
-0.001087515,
0.0268402267,
0.0194383524,
-0.0198408924,
-0.0118079474,
0.0037407163,
0.0371447168,
0.0087449308,
-0.0493375361,
0.0152792418,
0.0054876492,
0.0402412787,
-0.0107547678,
0.1068039015,
0.0155312987,
-0.0549525954,
-0.0069385311,
0.0172280911,
-0.1121601537,
-0.1008303463,
0.0360801257,
0.0009289885,
0.0521010607,
0.0246073361,
0.0225303583,
-0.0262867752,
0.0126907788,
-0.0214980599,
0.0235449541,
0.0192092434,
-0.0569636859,
0.0008819368,
0.0317213982,
-0.0170810726,
0.0411118865,
0.0301845316,
-0.0615074672,
0.02155843,
0.0116716204,
0.008937655,
-0.0270909239,
-0.0113956789,
0.00066607,
0.0403109342,
-0.0186206698,
-0.0034041486,
-0.0391363204,
-0.0211086087,
0.0303968564,
0.0027194577,
0.0114048822,
-0.0292262211,
0.0364261754,
0.0381012,
-0.0008046897,
-0.0133479945,
-0.0269323848,
0.0197601952,
-0.0343980938,
-0.0247483961,
-0.0459636077,
-6.370959711e-33,
-0.0051138639,
-0.0165129974,
0.0531391725,
0.0050656199,
-0.0568946563,
-0.0273920968,
-0.0510871932,
0.0092625534,
-0.0282429885,
-0.0268228855,
-0.0342855081,
0.0461605936,
0.0005895187,
0.0350420959,
0.0038446377,
-0.0448135324,
0.0296818968,
-0.0076701348,
0.0036305026,
0.0463660769,
0.0475884825,
0.0326986685,
0.0018839062,
-0.0124960141,
0.0193016138,
-0.0086406274,
0.0321292393,
0.0362593234,
-0.0053852275,
0.0466121398,
-0.0542898662,
0.0175009556,
0.0169459786,
-0.0388232395,
-0.0177660417,
0.0492107831,
-0.0387014374,
-0.0121914493,
0.009954934,
-0.0222958401,
-0.0185360592,
-0.0222998559,
0.008950755,
0.0084837303,
-0.0116784321,
-0.013554371,
-0.0118341241,
-0.0205761734,
-0.0261213128,
0.0072939764,
-0.0152852573,
-0.0091758845,
-0.0191295296,
-0.0422807634,
-0.0132635897,
-0.0065976186,
0.0115684709,
0.0011464336,
-0.0822686702,
0.0280343816,
-0.0103628701,
0.0030434108,
0.0310702529,
0.002008026,
0.0320351757,
0.0674299672,
0.0451921225,
0.0401423648,
-0.0186310168,
-0.0153166745,
0.0098076677,
0.0059750876,
0.0239960328,
0.0179403145,
0.001182362,
0.0136480713,
-0.0428647101,
-0.0104312422,
0.044967249,
0.0760601163,
0.0364171602,
0.0330356471,
-0.0291276909,
-0.0138770174,
-0.028061999,
0.0330096744,
-0.0462404378,
-0.0310144555,
0.0309210122,
0.0309367068,
-0.0053786901,
-0.0123988492,
0.0662947968,
-0.0179523304,
0.003585797,
0.0260896124,
-0.037405435,
-0.0077250223,
-0.0163567625,
0.0298518129,
-0.0517804213,
0.0013118451,
0.0038506615,
0.0056399615,
-0.0082358932,
0.0412426852,
-0.0130785592,
-0.0024836855,
-0.0626010895,
-0.0151648633,
-0.0342103578,
0.027666606,
-0.04509864,
-0.0351153277,
0.0194539707,
0.023052685,
0.0064316443,
0.064616397,
0.0038000387,
-0.0124882199,
-0.0560726784,
0.0057216939,
0.0033132667,
0.0112849642,
-0.0036060817,
0.0102703832,
-0.0412674993,
0.0386948027,
0.0272286348,
-0.0488773733,
0.0042037517,
-0.0022889993,
2.854e-7,
-0.0609030984,
0.0550198108,
0.0268833283,
-0.0111549599,
0.0497513004,
0.0430104919,
-0.011628692,
0.0111670075,
0.060941305,
-0.0311700013,
-0.0071870368,
0.0613771118,
0.0425927863,
0.0111991288,
-0.1055992171,
-0.0240620356,
-0.0825166851,
-0.0364648327,
-0.0377639383,
-0.0072277519,
0.074389562,
0.0652222782,
0.022665251,
-0.0031090567,
0.0030016191,
-0.0489882156,
0.1004919335,
-0.0500643551,
-0.0362408571,
-0.0001063502,
-0.0009232587,
0.0116510941,
-0.0064619007,
-0.0028694994,
-0.0084723793,
-0.0026670087,
-0.0424036235,
0.0436618812,
0.0194429997,
-0.0726156458,
-0.0282528251,
0.00523361,
-0.0033381893,
-0.0406239629,
0.0712964684,
-0.0635286793,
-0.0276334602,
-0.0178685598,
0.0266361888,
-0.0269959625,
-0.0048764586,
0.0132955853,
-0.0197473988,
0.0061197802,
-0.010638956,
0.0426344946,
0.026331149,
-0.1127117053,
-0.0257777944,
-0.003635766,
-0.063418813,
-0.0369046889,
-0.0496632643,
-0.0036956379,
0.031441357,
-0.0633404776,
0.0024633035,
2.488766053e-34,
0.0150424326,
-0.0082138171,
0.0395222493,
0.0835918114,
0.0464858226,
0.0178929772,
0.0027160179,
0.0139631443,
0.0625730082,
-0.081276603,
-0.0273895562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08718v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08718v2 | Decomposing Uncertainty for Large Language Models through Input Clarification Ensembling | 2023-11-15T05:58:35 | 2024-06-10T21:17:24 | Bairu Hou, Yujian Liu, Kaizhi Qian, Jacob Andreas, Shiyu Chang, Yang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Uncertainty decomposition refers to the task of decomposing the total
uncertainty of a predictive model into aleatoric (data) uncertainty, resulting
from inherent randomness in the data-generating process, and epistemic (model)
uncertainty, resulting from missing information in the model's training data.
In large language models (LLMs) specifically, identifying sources of
uncertainty is an important step toward improving reliability, trustworthiness,
and interpretability, but remains an important open research question. In this
paper, we introduce an uncertainty decomposition framework for LLMs, called
input clarification ensembling, which can be applied to any pre-trained LLM.
Our approach generates a set of clarifications for the input, feeds them into
an LLM, and ensembles the corresponding predictions. We show that, when
aleatoric uncertainty arises from ambiguity or under-specification in LLM
inputs, this approach makes it possible to factor an (unclarified) LLM's
predictions into separate aleatoric and epistemic terms, using a decomposition
similar to the one employed by Bayesian neural networks. Empirical evaluations
demonstrate that input clarification ensembling provides accurate and reliable
uncertainty quantification on several language processing tasks. Code and data
are available at https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/llm_uncertainty. | [
0.0088203549,
0.1098032221,
-0.0009012385,
0.0485571921,
-0.0127076181,
0.0190469008,
-0.0310967639,
0.0015018389,
-0.0438802578,
-0.0638373569,
0.0075860079,
-0.0690901205,
0.0402116291,
0.0070298943,
0.0214823019,
-0.0491941087,
0.0598532856,
-0.0641361624,
0.0132065723,
-0.0066827117,
-0.0144937206,
-0.0192443244,
0.0134437643,
0.0425651334,
-0.0189694241,
0.0127623715,
-0.0375730954,
0.0318241827,
-0.0074969446,
0.0036391949,
-0.0136637148,
0.0403666943,
0.0008983431,
0.0594605468,
0.0000019907,
-0.035479594,
-0.0230857804,
-0.0107771717,
-0.0727957934,
0.0071883155,
0.0189428274,
0.0174783729,
-0.0150906285,
0.0039630071,
-0.0091692582,
-0.0268324874,
0.0467419848,
0.0218976643,
0.04033852,
0.0765079036,
0.0256605092,
-0.0150058251,
0.0106170811,
0.0048116478,
-0.0050842855,
-0.0380036347,
0.0224394761,
-0.0442092083,
-0.0282623991,
0.0369375907,
-0.0159879979,
0.0206677131,
0.0267773438,
0.0054288856,
-0.0070542353,
-0.0039234483,
0.0242386162,
-0.0665964931,
-0.0241513103,
0.0199975725,
-0.0172127597,
-0.028817974,
-0.0360397324,
-0.019780457,
0.0019166257,
0.03327889,
-0.0056971684,
0.0413663909,
0.0054306947,
0.0494130813,
-0.0053983051,
-0.0065041212,
0.0633316264,
0.0204244778,
-0.0277920868,
0.1313178837,
-0.0064043067,
-0.0066690086,
-0.012329462,
-0.0108487913,
-0.0530348755,
-0.0495103076,
-0.0095582865,
0.0512566008,
-0.0387985893,
0.0312233213,
-0.0374798737,
-0.0223745145,
0.0250925664,
-0.0226740465,
0.0106890788,
0.0194076467,
0.0109646721,
0.0338817276,
0.0381381698,
0.0328051485,
0.0012263823,
-0.0054328912,
-0.0506506599,
-0.0285154618,
-0.028296914,
-0.0086569255,
-0.017130794,
0.0105600078,
-0.035432715,
-0.0012186882,
-0.0312466398,
-0.0087428056,
-0.0252575967,
0.0272549894,
0.0142505839,
0.0020243218,
-0.0114436774,
-0.024865821,
-0.0355332233,
0.0044887173,
-0.0062956628,
0.0292170383,
0.0258972216,
-0.0830381513,
-0.0084774327,
0.0167129543,
-0.031981606,
-0.0112925805,
-0.0043395734,
0.0506847389,
0.0216161441,
-0.0107569108,
-0.0377234444,
-0.0291059613,
-0.0336013995,
-0.0525343902,
-0.0068892525,
-0.0511788465,
-0.0087380102,
-0.013390447,
0.0255824961,
-0.093508482,
0.0125799272,
-0.0106185833,
-0.0189083479,
0.1294659972,
-0.0460433774,
0.0119042946,
0.0319471583,
0.0285255052,
-0.0054079182,
0.0533126518,
0.0444805771,
0.0206166208,
0.0311694145,
0.0032000251,
0.0128977792,
0.0207896214,
0.0149681298,
-0.0287055727,
-0.0535680205,
-0.0268280189,
-0.0261463076,
0.0033477233,
0.0013237835,
0.0754665285,
-0.032391075,
0.0073898342,
0.0698659867,
-0.0059113801,
-0.0031312252,
-0.0073325052,
0.0294537265,
-0.0026508423,
0.0348036699,
-0.016728811,
-0.0781376436,
-0.0091429297,
-0.030023016,
0.0163951218,
0.0136142159,
0.0154686151,
0.0003816658,
-0.0887028947,
-0.0465705357,
-0.0211549643,
0.0079374202,
0.0274299309,
0.0643649027,
-0.0141198905,
-0.0109986523,
0.0598754026,
0.0161754005,
-0.0538054891,
0.0206776205,
-0.0588889979,
0.033223778,
0.0569885075,
0.0319552086,
-0.0169673692,
-0.0239959415,
-0.0211429968,
-0.0265329722,
-0.0044648414,
0.0125413174,
-0.0124996752,
0.0398263708,
-0.0626980141,
-0.0262999255,
0.0258100722,
0.0522370301,
-0.0228461698,
0.0347565562,
-0.0305235479,
0.00828226,
-0.0262384266,
-0.0154134026,
0.0469265953,
0.0148236156,
-0.029396994,
0.0074524092,
-0.0184467193,
0.0650789514,
0.0238816813,
-0.007888183,
0.0219901837,
0.0531698018,
0.0143253971,
-0.0346663781,
-0.0198434312,
-0.011259187,
-0.0012871166,
0.0774366483,
0.022542676,
-0.0238741897,
-0.0166057162,
-0.0607319325,
-0.0574214421,
0.0000630277,
-0.0231085643,
-0.0031060504,
-0.034768302,
0.0446493365,
-0.0138095152,
0.0160720125,
-0.0557483844,
0.0510425828,
-0.0311518386,
0.006272932,
0.0098950816,
0.0216410272,
0.0012927674,
-0.0010327211,
-0.0285368133,
0.0030741163,
-0.0132415667,
0.0058192629,
0.0100363176,
-0.0125355059,
-0.0304904245,
-0.0238278061,
-0.0468438752,
-0.0150385909,
-0.0173162818,
0.0090559619,
0.0145671023,
0.0033192493,
0.0128616113,
-0.0026263159,
0.0181401893,
-0.0150399162,
0.0007016622,
-0.0068820189,
0.0347572304,
-0.0051312405,
-0.012706249,
-0.0337712839,
-0.0211434271,
0.0004814602,
0.0471485406,
-0.0072068628,
-0.0394508615,
-0.1065079048,
0.0523561649,
-0.0349007621,
0.010561958,
-0.0041081146,
-0.0441987067,
0.0163653493,
-0.0214710608,
-0.014099488,
0.0149534121,
-0.00627892,
0.0409285016,
0.0948160514,
-0.0253068674,
-0.0368255712,
0.0028205018,
-0.0220012236,
-0.0016243052,
-0.0260581616,
-0.0258982647,
-0.0185489487,
0.0536174476,
0.0070827701,
-0.0284324214,
-0.0305320006,
0.0301572047,
-0.0357396081,
-0.0238492079,
-0.0443947501,
-0.0496817119,
-0.0345778055,
0.0800615922,
-0.0152914245,
-0.0585746989,
0.0791389719,
-0.0529272556,
0.0157428961,
-0.028376339,
-0.0231716335,
0.0074622645,
0.0359076895,
-0.0098614981,
-0.0034929954,
0.0274444949,
-0.0055908882,
-0.0625747368,
-0.0244978052,
0.0379166454,
-0.0471540727,
0.0544996113,
-0.0803089216,
-0.0014138859,
0.0217504185,
0.0044059628,
-0.0465242863,
-0.0296281446,
-0.0221808404,
0.0193817131,
0.0337293856,
-0.0367977917,
0.0144940661,
-0.0161026083,
-0.0219464935,
0.018068647,
0.0024915321,
-0.0087126885,
-0.0355990194,
0.0140480986,
0.0189764835,
0.0251535401,
0.0956879854,
-0.0280482545,
0.0021725756,
0.0307728425,
0.030576013,
-0.0032520613,
-0.0426129811,
-0.0071467301,
0.0248702597,
-0.0191932973,
-0.0199963935,
0.0434855781,
0.0750646144,
-0.0580659099,
-0.0240235813,
0.1511103511,
0.0221093688,
-0.0205865521,
0.0082293041,
-0.0143300379,
0.0192018002,
0.0068165632,
-0.0076869405,
-0.041397281,
-0.0451641455,
0.0462430157,
-0.0013472718,
0.0171545912,
-0.0093705822,
-0.0107821487,
-0.0819709897,
0.0443668552,
0.0268526468,
-0.0207396299,
-0.0418572538,
-0.0537983142,
-0.0166636314,
-0.0266383514,
0.0644336045,
0.0113899717,
0.0070442911,
0.0222666468,
0.0132525386,
-0.0257548038,
-0.1029222533,
-0.0144648189,
-0.016657481,
0.1034575999,
0.0208914932,
-0.0012099104,
-0.0014021156,
0.0113339154,
0.0305437427,
-0.0519650429,
-0.0194373038,
-0.0144967167,
0.0441262908,
0.0402024426,
0.0050210035,
0.0140231047,
0.0104713254,
-0.0379136354,
-0.0318088308,
-0.0343806818,
0.0559358634,
-0.0397438854,
-0.0110155698,
0.0013864901,
-0.0442273915,
0.032517489,
0.0848225206,
0.04319527,
0.0072010169,
-0.0361597389,
-0.0469201393,
0.0250006914,
0.0232204273,
0.0282956641,
0.0377979688,
0.0090382686,
-0.0280108135,
-0.0482879877,
-0.0262736492,
0.0085092159,
-0.0044168006,
-0.0095547969,
0.0128757097,
0.0484824181,
-0.0131183518,
-0.0622282661,
0.021738708,
0.0154728834,
0.0293707699,
-0.0053903637,
0.0253832191,
-0.0034297251,
0.0111221699,
-0.008301679,
0.0534781069,
-0.1013970077,
-0.0938966796,
0.0392886922,
0.0423006713,
0.0340143293,
0.0351850986,
-0.0417364053,
-0.0964041203,
0.0526766479,
0.0315039791,
-0.0166550204,
0.0066638039,
0.0440849736,
0.0227970388,
-0.0049878755,
0.0510483235,
-0.0329587162,
0.0045569204,
-0.0105317757,
0.0122520123,
-0.069826223,
-0.0724420846,
0.0046627149,
0.0333545357,
0.0560701601,
-0.0448419414,
0.0221697092,
-0.0328582451,
-0.0106001357,
-0.0089668911,
-0.0188981332,
-0.0367990211,
0.0203477293,
0.0359867178,
-0.0440805778,
-0.0191528257,
0.0063896985,
0.0170493815,
0.0078948839,
0.0237790793,
-0.0122076413,
0.0334191397,
0.0348464549,
0.0387001075,
-0.004586475,
0.0177643094,
0.0485685952,
-0.0339404494,
0.004580358,
0.0303868093,
0.0147874141,
0.0176660921,
-0.0019752593,
-0.0451881811,
0.0015619074,
-0.0694093257,
-0.0783290938,
-0.0173872579,
0.0407205969,
0.022635432,
0.0281068571,
0.0666615069,
-0.0271984302,
-0.0107835857,
-0.0240295511,
0.0375343449,
0.0460807793,
0.0123319356,
0.0734987333,
0.0206000321,
-0.0403262973,
0.0125455568,
0.0748204663,
-0.0121767633,
0.0537585504,
-0.0144955646,
-0.0147630973,
-0.0345706642,
-0.0404910259,
-0.0367492847,
0.027920682,
-0.0549186543,
0.0366897248,
-0.0173174683,
-0.0833967701,
0.0088128857,
0.0388957895,
0.0198668484,
-0.0312278457,
-0.0022263348,
0.0429331735,
-0.0003677111,
0.0167346001,
-0.0295952372,
-0.0239520017,
0.0208355282,
0.0003576671,
-0.0289083254,
-6.597271761e-33,
-0.0176478848,
-0.0533939973,
-0.0152100734,
-0.0439113155,
-0.0004467819,
-0.0035600862,
0.0036920882,
0.0017642445,
-0.0162002817,
0.038326811,
-0.0010783221,
0.0629098862,
0.0295993742,
0.0333291367,
0.0315094404,
-0.0288234893,
0.0605597012,
-0.0109035587,
0.0061506024,
-0.0215163101,
0.0589867271,
0.0215659868,
0.0714527369,
-0.0366504192,
0.0568430834,
0.0059627094,
-0.0531640798,
0.072221607,
-0.0240041818,
0.0354662128,
-0.0206393171,
0.0334578492,
0.0014439763,
-0.0251199678,
-0.0366411805,
-0.0312246438,
-0.071204789,
-0.052311562,
0.0153652076,
0.0293869916,
-0.0357516967,
-0.0159246363,
0.0622841306,
-0.0042317533,
-0.0154732922,
0.014641935,
0.0012272528,
-0.0248641577,
-0.0102743553,
-0.0036577596,
0.003196792,
0.0485464931,
0.0121667664,
-0.0180731006,
0.0523612052,
0.0061345529,
-0.0410514548,
-0.0364768915,
-0.0470704325,
-0.0158010945,
0.0319971852,
0.0517264381,
0.0478322096,
0.0209957939,
-0.0273849294,
0.0592797287,
-0.0206906497,
-0.04367489,
-0.0603648163,
-0.0111252842,
0.0165332071,
0.0385122448,
0.0334639698,
0.0563827381,
0.043828208,
0.0061674146,
-0.0653155595,
0.016253937,
0.0287994836,
0.0647150725,
-0.0002346586,
0.0226350818,
-0.0408427306,
-0.0416020639,
-0.0568983108,
-0.0617404394,
-0.03151666,
-0.0121677835,
0.0111470995,
0.002634391,
-0.0414156877,
-0.017311275,
0.0153278597,
-0.0564092807,
-0.0193111654,
0.0212567467,
0.0181383174,
-0.00538019,
0.0439531766,
0.0332307592,
-0.0022857261,
-0.0074667083,
0.012395747,
0.0085758353,
-0.0106746824,
0.0240423083,
0.0189103484,
0.0407693833,
-0.0353244357,
0.0185961984,
-0.026805127,
0.0140094748,
-0.003396254,
-0.0081138508,
0.0519606993,
0.0043657073,
-0.0067918687,
0.032387916,
0.0137789343,
0.0453001,
0.0146380709,
0.0262859222,
0.0193400979,
0.0141516794,
-0.0131617887,
-0.0309224557,
-0.019066453,
-0.0445790663,
0.0321911238,
-0.0067095403,
-0.0013044667,
0.0195727758,
2.711e-7,
0.0662054643,
0.0443198159,
0.0024504415,
0.0492174253,
0.0383975059,
0.0257830713,
-0.0126638608,
-0.0514763296,
-0.0238080285,
-0.0472769961,
0.0041029253,
0.0281060245,
0.0487902462,
0.046539899,
-0.0201543886,
-0.0549701564,
-0.0389873423,
0.0017796924,
-0.0103187133,
0.0171284545,
0.0740923136,
0.122707054,
0.024384778,
0.0026366718,
-0.021053724,
0.0075234324,
0.0336402804,
-0.061540883,
-0.0176940951,
0.0369527787,
0.037611112,
-0.0012378222,
0.028477272,
0.022634346,
-0.0052172211,
-0.0108217755,
-0.0215371028,
0.0747847632,
-0.0178629011,
0.0245749764,
-0.0457475893,
-0.0338672549,
0.0175791774,
-0.0633532777,
0.0512451157,
-0.0348877795,
-0.0377536193,
-0.0659185648,
-0.0255257934,
-0.050830245,
0.0570567027,
0.0058798566,
0.0092473999,
0.0064894408,
-0.0156134376,
0.0111156069,
-0.0352438875,
-0.079565987,
-0.0524007827,
0.0029706794,
-0.021721825,
-0.0108785685,
0.0072867172,
-0.0448550209,
0.0543711074,
-0.0914379209,
0.0104086455,
2.546130636e-34,
0.0603882484,
-0.0039392156,
0.0039091716,
0.0387419909,
0.0199273117,
-0.0213423334,
-0.0331462398,
0.0254210439,
0.0089870058,
-0.0368213765,
-0.002541089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08711v2 | PLUG: Leveraging Pivot Language in Cross-Lingual Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-15T05:28:07 | 2024-02-12T01:09:34 | Zhihan Zhang, Dong-Ho Lee, Yuwei Fang, Wenhao Yu, Mengzhao Jia, Meng Jiang, Francesco Barbieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning has remarkably advanced large language models (LLMs) in
understanding and responding to diverse human instructions. Despite the success
in high-resource languages, its application in lower-resource ones faces
challenges due to the imbalanced foundational abilities of LLMs across
different languages, stemming from the uneven language distribution in their
pre-training data. To tackle this issue, we propose pivot language guided
generation (PLUG), an approach that utilizes a high-resource language,
primarily English, as the pivot to enhance instruction tuning in lower-resource
languages. It trains the model to first process instructions in the pivot
language, and then produce responses in the target language. To evaluate our
approach, we introduce a benchmark, X-AlpacaEval, of instructions in 4
languages (Chinese, Korean, Italian, and Spanish), each annotated by
professional translators. Our approach demonstrates a significant improvement
in the instruction-following abilities of LLMs by 29% on average, compared to
directly responding in the target language alone. Further experiments validate
the versatility of our approach by employing alternative pivot languages beyond
English to assist languages where LLMs exhibit lower proficiency. Our code and
data are available at https://github.com/ytyz1307zzh/PLUG. | [
0.0313446112,
0.0003089763,
-0.0204369128,
0.0294464622,
0.0027281051,
0.0408055633,
0.0133864051,
-0.0366827287,
-0.0137715945,
-0.0304811411,
-0.069944106,
-0.004311997,
-0.0006820351,
-0.0268761832,
0.0181875601,
-0.0741798356,
0.0477866232,
-0.0456686541,
-0.0406561531,
0.0090407003,
-0.0209573247,
0.0291462112,
-0.0224687178,
0.0559802875,
0.0327570029,
-0.0268163159,
-0.0059288838,
0.0336419269,
0.0209147632,
-0.0231184401,
0.0242563691,
0.0468268208,
0.0192316622,
0.005774965,
0.0000021645,
-0.042146083,
0.0148706101,
-0.0472096689,
-0.0051085665,
0.0417487435,
0.0202834681,
-0.0215806048,
-0.0269272905,
0.011799328,
-0.0189382415,
-0.0273217559,
0.021270033,
0.0181676485,
0.0601419061,
0.0770408884,
0.0118709654,
-0.0440516919,
0.0022269788,
-0.0248307437,
-0.0073388829,
-0.0431391187,
-0.0239583999,
0.0242272355,
0.0039507989,
0.0185854193,
-0.0317327939,
0.014950647,
0.0592456944,
-0.0079481276,
-0.038201265,
0.0239729527,
-0.016601136,
-0.0219566803,
-0.0242423601,
0.0872475356,
-0.0361097828,
0.0045509092,
-0.0280603264,
-0.0211563054,
0.0264059734,
-0.0228400398,
-0.044172354,
0.0391274877,
0.0139867961,
0.0055754287,
0.0655851141,
-0.0306984391,
-0.0067494339,
0.0053474666,
-0.0073810313,
0.0183788296,
0.0191687774,
-0.0140321841,
0.0060423478,
0.0191531796,
0.0035686574,
-0.0398766547,
0.0071213418,
0.0566114448,
-0.0724461898,
0.0152869346,
-0.0320268683,
0.0123273088,
0.0308558699,
-0.0459262952,
0.0525693484,
0.064654544,
-0.031776201,
0.0176837854,
-0.0125134522,
0.0859394297,
-0.0132934814,
0.0193774588,
-0.0671450272,
0.0224982146,
-0.0692646801,
0.0015064224,
-0.0396218523,
-0.0097556282,
-0.0821334049,
0.0024489614,
-0.0628629923,
0.0373506024,
0.0025223531,
0.0099876532,
0.0042917756,
-0.0257962421,
-0.0570500828,
-0.0092327688,
-0.0007273891,
0.1027398705,
-0.0346219987,
-0.0038604361,
-0.0060326462,
-0.0691908076,
0.0057074884,
0.0369259045,
-0.0485186316,
-0.0257309414,
0.0297738127,
0.0547194704,
-0.0508204959,
-0.0134526426,
-0.0477249026,
-0.0240185969,
-0.0049623759,
-0.0767878219,
0.0039741453,
-0.0699934959,
0.0367973521,
0.0063767945,
0.0037605041,
-0.00195716,
0.0120932525,
0.0252754055,
-0.0137076965,
-0.0041125095,
0.0463923067,
0.0166866165,
0.0262554139,
0.0096523939,
0.0148260081,
0.0819705203,
0.019816719,
0.0028714938,
0.0230726413,
-0.0384754315,
-0.0189626087,
0.0600609295,
-0.0087799178,
0.0312477052,
0.0062740254,
0.0196965709,
0.0087121008,
0.0085158935,
0.0647943988,
0.0262602866,
-0.0014641228,
0.0458320081,
0.0363424197,
0.0093053412,
-0.031135302,
0.0346549973,
0.0943392292,
0.0324893296,
-0.0096968664,
0.0219833031,
-0.0563871898,
0.0183669087,
-0.018771207,
0.0130829904,
-0.0161372423,
0.0567328744,
-0.0568021834,
-0.0462588929,
0.0148403225,
0.0000635982,
-0.0148147782,
0.0204628874,
0.037824735,
0.0103752632,
-0.0624977499,
0.0407060944,
0.0384566896,
-0.0369440354,
0.0283700582,
-0.0434990749,
-0.0038443226,
0.0889080092,
0.0181859843,
0.0264141411,
-0.036979869,
0.0038758623,
0.0465895124,
0.0479961745,
0.0471430086,
-0.0200029481,
0.0063037639,
-0.0674552843,
-0.026981594,
-0.0164056048,
-0.0058783628,
0.0503761061,
0.0075139641,
0.0071688611,
0.0150453364,
0.0079777893,
-0.0766637847,
0.0278094914,
-0.0599738285,
-0.0480643287,
-0.0093300482,
0.0073720124,
0.002794882,
0.0403654501,
-0.0099715786,
-0.0039182659,
0.0183025263,
-0.027519444,
0.0276839621,
0.0122022331,
-0.0641544089,
-0.0326191932,
0.0312886722,
-0.0171092562,
-0.0558882914,
-0.0157762188,
-0.0358554646,
-0.0317897201,
0.0120981019,
-0.0311422087,
0.0108190654,
-0.0070188055,
0.0434674136,
-0.0131676123,
-0.0006782461,
-0.0434954688,
0.0454446897,
-0.0118348049,
0.0187301468,
0.0543816872,
0.0029040182,
0.0066654161,
-0.0441522039,
0.0192123745,
0.0236158445,
-0.0029307615,
0.0008019186,
0.0252427887,
0.0854497403,
-0.0549504384,
-0.0418209694,
-0.070799388,
0.0287690572,
-0.02095709,
0.037239898,
0.0396940187,
0.0011849736,
-0.021231832,
-0.0194575563,
-0.016911095,
-0.0273972843,
0.0196812879,
0.0169347394,
0.0004250219,
0.0237617567,
-0.0244566314,
-0.0255805124,
0.0009375531,
0.012807806,
-0.0084779132,
0.0080388533,
0.0196220633,
-0.0653285906,
0.0494348668,
-0.0059473352,
-0.0040451512,
0.0127300574,
-0.073743917,
0.0213176813,
0.016858669,
0.0844196826,
0.0556388088,
-0.0140619259,
0.0221978966,
0.0272875838,
-0.0349997357,
-0.0590739027,
0.0213383511,
-0.0238009114,
-0.0785364583,
-0.0617140979,
-0.0707276836,
-0.0064812712,
0.0862292945,
0.003995535,
0.0195164122,
-0.07507471,
-0.0463684946,
-0.0399546064,
-0.0271321051,
0.0075239688,
0.0174102187,
0.004927943,
-0.0088565554,
-0.0283719581,
-0.0324230865,
0.0733180642,
-0.0145550482,
-0.0355170257,
-0.0766260251,
0.0016607143,
-0.0327530913,
0.0338165946,
-0.0209004339,
0.0254493635,
-0.0619367212,
-0.0234116334,
-0.0562771261,
0.0161435716,
0.0158691332,
-0.0153106144,
0.0509310775,
-0.0698343664,
-0.0270617772,
-0.008138122,
-0.0179853588,
-0.0315787867,
0.0081987744,
-0.014809208,
0.0102035487,
0.036272876,
-0.0240746923,
-0.0398074985,
-0.0259178299,
0.0706889331,
0.0328356624,
-0.0229316857,
-0.0036273135,
-0.031158831,
-0.0392639413,
0.0313814804,
-0.0096222982,
-0.0175079666,
-0.0683619156,
0.0508891083,
0.0248366874,
0.0403749272,
-0.0482894145,
0.0140110673,
0.0209597908,
0.0424816981,
-0.0062377383,
-0.0238440186,
0.0446907505,
0.0852041915,
-0.0502374209,
-0.0034958867,
0.1144566759,
0.0254865605,
-0.0567466132,
0.0140084662,
-0.0296748951,
0.0327661075,
0.0271776598,
0.0582634509,
-0.0679329038,
-0.0443323292,
-0.023072863,
0.0363665931,
0.0123023503,
0.0088105239,
-0.0126959626,
-0.1552850008,
0.044351209,
0.0364688225,
-0.0569778867,
-0.0720835105,
-0.02383109,
-0.0238277614,
0.0224250183,
0.0576337725,
0.013629484,
-0.0281802882,
-0.0074740103,
0.0389113799,
0.006933813,
-0.0567326955,
0.0140160685,
-0.0207324401,
0.0258905422,
0.0483313687,
0.0049060038,
0.0192080494,
-0.0135069974,
0.0313621201,
-0.0005722592,
0.0116062304,
-0.0260750074,
0.0189634953,
0.0134448586,
-0.007075551,
-0.000014734,
0.0279133786,
-0.0461437367,
0.0010643784,
0.0517103896,
0.0660123229,
-0.0043024221,
-0.0107380366,
0.0156351794,
0.0045104609,
0.0269306265,
0.0421527922,
0.0328908078,
-0.0585614443,
-0.004490254,
-0.0299952887,
-0.0253938679,
-0.0732676461,
-0.0129660843,
0.0511249006,
-0.0763408914,
-0.0168012623,
-0.0400847346,
-0.05582669,
0.026832182,
0.010075747,
0.0240263753,
-0.0185759533,
0.0085433843,
0.0021764855,
0.0056151934,
0.0401115566,
-0.0148377912,
0.0210295003,
-0.1023654714,
-0.074496679,
0.0064077363,
-0.013140914,
0.0049030907,
0.0445896536,
-0.0315085165,
-0.071314536,
-0.0173224062,
0.0554673746,
0.0087737907,
0.0525001325,
0.0458920971,
-0.0350260697,
-0.0230055228,
0.0173562225,
-0.0372921452,
0.0004499468,
0.028603103,
0.0025145197,
-0.0087683573,
0.0324813761,
-0.0407747552,
0.0514437258,
0.0151877515,
0.0634136871,
-0.0388868526,
-0.0229543522,
0.0150793651,
0.0167394336,
-0.022810664,
-0.0442150459,
-0.0095637366,
-0.0321367085,
0.027695803,
-0.0307374168,
-0.0106454967,
-0.0432551131,
-0.0082697002,
0.0360801294,
-0.0353963636,
0.0376796499,
-0.0139351301,
-0.0142356763,
-0.0101252245,
-0.0253649224,
0.0485019907,
-0.0152449654,
0.0342893749,
0.0193161424,
0.0243111085,
-0.0270265024,
0.0009991294,
0.0268965065,
0.0517875142,
0.0066158613,
0.104171671,
0.006359309,
0.0016244374,
0.0050950041,
0.0076654255,
0.0098388661,
-0.0478853472,
-0.0031892315,
0.0002675713,
0.0740230083,
0.000241121,
0.0764366612,
-0.0141624622,
-0.0040312037,
-0.0102404319,
0.0437512696,
-0.0103906961,
-0.0451738425,
-0.0081539471,
0.0094654234,
0.0140441991,
-0.033965759,
0.0759166479,
0.0069528939,
0.0183267146,
-0.0023762414,
0.0228367541,
-0.0431372002,
-0.0341372006,
0.0167860873,
-0.0093720946,
-0.0192281567,
0.0570660643,
-0.0413823128,
-0.0577123463,
-0.0833392739,
0.0349403173,
0.0067534535,
-0.0167014301,
0.021361636,
0.0443254486,
-0.0391767509,
-0.0423808806,
-0.0456122644,
0.0236526709,
-0.015130748,
-0.0216418542,
-0.0383390896,
-6.23760355e-33,
-0.0528096743,
-0.0051833172,
0.039789971,
0.009652474,
0.0045707617,
-0.0068735927,
-0.0391225889,
0.0103760455,
0.003668543,
0.0013594924,
0.0096275611,
-0.0222228356,
0.015300354,
0.0245091859,
0.02947939,
0.0159897432,
0.0335436054,
-0.0011282446,
-0.0234535579,
0.0762905031,
0.0193234403,
-0.000884728,
0.0756010488,
-0.0329243131,
0.0192274582,
-0.0250762012,
0.0065479195,
0.0428153761,
-0.0008933178,
0.0701292902,
0.0176644344,
0.0308870729,
0.0060456768,
-0.0360902995,
-0.0392760485,
0.0127220489,
-0.041066587,
-0.0465875939,
0.0356792174,
0.0346554853,
-0.0202713441,
-0.0643113106,
-0.0045975158,
-0.0230745897,
-0.0465013348,
-0.0060578575,
0.0266881939,
-0.0128541226,
0.0095310006,
0.0235677026,
-0.0768915191,
0.0089460956,
-0.0347307175,
-0.0467907824,
-0.0183395129,
0.0861458108,
-0.0205117054,
-0.0513290428,
-0.0225954242,
0.0447796099,
0.0372376367,
0.0448047444,
0.0915812477,
0.0140566882,
-0.0157830827,
0.0038935114,
0.0295278858,
0.0173757412,
0.0287255906,
0.007368817,
0.0170238018,
0.0263377707,
0.0028444012,
0.0129141137,
0.0098141823,
0.0047735274,
-0.0656254441,
0.026850678,
0.0523072556,
0.0507271402,
0.0363393985,
-0.0132414782,
-0.0413678028,
-0.0199749805,
-0.0155780232,
0.0052659581,
-0.0059829825,
-0.033023335,
0.0309017152,
0.0257527251,
-0.003053922,
-0.0125049017,
0.0638112873,
-0.0043607992,
-0.0038461331,
0.0275549293,
-0.0300539229,
0.0158622526,
-0.0148488171,
0.026625013,
-0.0732237026,
-0.0842961371,
0.0136907734,
-0.0421099067,
0.0249085445,
0.0244930461,
0.0347263329,
0.0027352823,
-0.0463144071,
0.0126396418,
-0.0363733023,
0.0434596986,
-0.0008976897,
0.0141162742,
-0.0006906299,
0.0041095586,
-0.0348916426,
0.0612471662,
0.0075264946,
-0.0366186313,
-0.0252513047,
-0.0316194557,
0.012754444,
0.0451932475,
-0.0370801203,
0.0285035241,
-0.0418257788,
0.004365718,
0.0039456617,
-0.0427008644,
-0.0286055095,
0.0060965517,
2.79e-7,
0.0193443373,
0.0451332666,
0.0022374042,
0.0366980657,
-0.0015001321,
0.0092623355,
-0.0179817174,
-0.0041716606,
0.0447448716,
0.04827445,
0.0064934641,
0.0330829546,
0.0419451781,
0.0045905812,
-0.0754455402,
-0.0196713395,
-0.0151381241,
0.0396015495,
-0.0648463294,
0.0320281945,
0.0062790625,
0.0587585643,
-0.0322282165,
-0.0031582918,
-0.008998258,
-0.0167239606,
0.0457951985,
-0.0334229469,
-0.0167396739,
0.0401961319,
-0.0082512787,
0.0337692015,
-0.0165171213,
0.0231650323,
-0.0274349768,
0.0155299148,
-0.0347602479,
0.0903523266,
-0.0041197822,
0.0002126158,
0.0491537042,
-0.003291534,
-0.0281291287,
-0.0453878678,
0.0059147645,
-0.065861024,
-0.0103481989,
0.0286079701,
-0.0030272682,
0.0008150801,
-0.0105831306,
-0.0268916506,
-0.0394390598,
0.0235532615,
0.0469144396,
-0.0399251431,
-0.0119905481,
0.0013022274,
-0.0183415171,
0.0457502455,
-0.0121154208,
-0.060633745,
-0.0338166691,
-0.0102629699,
-0.0316122621,
-0.0015383561,
0.0095181251,
2.586185606e-34,
0.0210864861,
0.0001795578,
0.0428195558,
0.0082448209,
0.034992259,
-0.0069975615,
-0.0286704618,
0.0347778052,
0.0426993296,
-0.0577818416,
-0.0345688052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08705v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08705v1 | Evaluating Robustness of Dialogue Summarization Models in the Presence of Naturally Occurring Variations | 2023-11-15T05:11:43 | 2023-11-15T05:11:43 | Ankita Gupta, Chulaka Gunasekara, Hui Wan, Jatin Ganhotra, Sachindra Joshi, Marina Danilevsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue summarization task involves summarizing long conversations while
preserving the most salient information. Real-life dialogues often involve
naturally occurring variations (e.g., repetitions, hesitations) and existing
dialogue summarization models suffer from performance drop on such
conversations. In this study, we systematically investigate the impact of such
variations on state-of-the-art dialogue summarization models using publicly
available datasets. To simulate real-life variations, we introduce two types of
perturbations: utterance-level perturbations that modify individual utterances
with errors and language variations, and dialogue-level perturbations that add
non-informative exchanges (e.g., repetitions, greetings). We conduct our
analysis along three dimensions of robustness: consistency, saliency, and
faithfulness, which capture different aspects of the summarization model's
performance. We find that both fine-tuned and instruction-tuned models are
affected by input variations, with the latter being more susceptible,
particularly to dialogue-level perturbations. We also validate our findings via
human evaluation. Finally, we investigate if the robustness of fine-tuned
models can be improved by training them with a fraction of perturbed data and
observe that this approach is insufficient to address robustness challenges
with current models and thus warrants a more thorough investigation to identify
better solutions. Overall, our work highlights robustness challenges in
dialogue summarization and provides insights for future research. | [
0.0479451194,
0.0477570258,
0.023586994,
0.0103432164,
0.01302242,
-0.0009995289,
-0.0308372155,
-0.0236787461,
-0.0282933358,
-0.0202869661,
-0.0288072079,
-0.0062099365,
0.0400236957,
0.0129296323,
0.0035680262,
-0.1336172223,
0.0364034846,
-0.0406716913,
-0.0174071416,
-0.0062867878,
0.0348789394,
-0.014953047,
-0.004167066,
0.0450412594,
0.0058285575,
0.0248366855,
-0.0178990103,
0.0313042849,
0.0556042306,
0.0192994848,
0.0069153332,
0.0556753948,
0.0016197454,
0.0024309075,
0.0000017669,
-0.0191419888,
-0.0054286388,
-0.0210938808,
-0.0198111199,
0.050018087,
0.0426994227,
-0.0209992845,
0.0006826269,
0.0081538586,
-0.0055386159,
0.0362254828,
0.0275367647,
0.0633256659,
0.0908446461,
0.0680506527,
-0.0026178462,
-0.0154868327,
0.0041392758,
-0.0559781976,
-0.0373652801,
-0.0504193492,
-0.0191298034,
0.0074262861,
-0.0089490581,
-0.0076623186,
-0.0142914942,
0.0266520623,
-0.0115111014,
-0.0090737808,
-0.0245802253,
0.0161449071,
-0.0595257729,
0.0050912388,
-0.014802861,
0.0804505944,
0.0205547232,
0.046529904,
0.0060310191,
0.0054250327,
0.0254262816,
-0.0317380615,
-0.0692476407,
0.0219112895,
0.0208980124,
0.0203118082,
-0.0522244498,
0.0489315279,
-0.0313994251,
0.0234287977,
-0.0011545483,
-0.0278692618,
-0.00700816,
-0.0122525748,
-0.0581491664,
-0.0100496216,
-0.0330057442,
-0.0469595268,
0.0192962177,
0.0173636191,
-0.0342078358,
0.0052935155,
-0.076217182,
0.0035124677,
0.0102851503,
-0.0134496307,
0.0260359179,
0.0034753203,
-0.0287629589,
0.0464822687,
0.0165705103,
0.0776931122,
0.0408120304,
0.0396190137,
-0.0247500166,
-0.0095961783,
-0.0324810147,
0.0148924263,
-0.0217633341,
0.031291347,
-0.0530103669,
-0.0491749644,
-0.0388370305,
0.0229091961,
-0.0042570499,
0.0024433697,
-0.0324420668,
0.0334012918,
-0.0134590426,
-0.0140091302,
-0.0000667994,
0.02077174,
-0.0470458344,
-0.0164522976,
0.0637290254,
-0.0508204699,
-0.0312920138,
0.0276434794,
0.0119002918,
0.013218008,
-0.0127258888,
0.0272334926,
-0.0373038948,
-0.0444882959,
0.027116023,
-0.0192341078,
-0.0652155727,
-0.0342976339,
-0.0305819958,
-0.0204332508,
0.0194883384,
-0.0383973867,
-0.0139481882,
-0.0349608809,
-0.0054306104,
-0.0198835135,
-0.0446931906,
0.0307613313,
0.0057377927,
0.0188712776,
0.0267005917,
0.0097691137,
0.0082970746,
0.0354548544,
0.0721791759,
0.0102452133,
0.0543269366,
0.0093620932,
0.0121849366,
0.0169200748,
0.0026415603,
0.0305958632,
0.0067205913,
-0.0209787209,
-0.0579719059,
-0.0142839337,
0.0489600375,
0.0935592502,
-0.0540420264,
-0.0165271517,
0.0858935714,
0.0672170594,
-0.0291156396,
0.0202604979,
-0.0114635304,
0.0550466441,
0.0358912461,
0.0944799036,
-0.0460267402,
0.0150792254,
-0.0276189372,
0.0465881191,
0.1135400832,
0.0055557443,
-0.0364595875,
-0.0613817312,
0.0018859096,
-0.0097036026,
0.0236402955,
0.003234813,
0.0021483458,
0.0047284905,
-0.0505769737,
0.052537214,
-0.0076575391,
-0.0789367259,
-0.0187202077,
-0.0282546841,
-0.0211040787,
0.0784567073,
0.0430386066,
-0.0290647745,
-0.0220818315,
-0.0249945223,
0.0394470021,
0.0309458449,
0.0681130737,
-0.0069270944,
0.063000299,
-0.0528791435,
-0.0165123697,
-0.0222323965,
0.0182936732,
0.0188032035,
-0.0026532006,
-0.0261925831,
0.0304341223,
0.033329159,
-0.0206504203,
0.0124795809,
-0.0056891306,
-0.0062924013,
-0.00719517,
-0.0291480348,
0.006083976,
0.0342559442,
-0.0297298431,
-0.0041772942,
0.0231926143,
-0.0228341967,
0.0210596062,
0.0413694493,
-0.0716500804,
-0.0148156369,
0.0400849842,
-0.0212216265,
-0.0052827201,
0.0259633549,
-0.0503297746,
-0.0693495721,
0.0315512791,
-0.0607006438,
-0.0244677402,
-0.0431631319,
0.0350502357,
0.0091650803,
0.0263954401,
-0.0192094669,
0.0136309778,
-0.0187550094,
-0.016906485,
0.0487453602,
0.0263150316,
-0.0005780235,
-0.0924822614,
-0.0094069559,
0.0093293255,
-0.0100826463,
0.0117148198,
0.0331193954,
-0.0176067688,
-0.0325482413,
-0.0340217203,
-0.0990605354,
-0.0142295212,
-0.0204430558,
-0.0034385514,
0.0305754207,
0.0298373159,
-0.0253489558,
-0.0147199165,
-0.020621419,
-0.0477756448,
0.0637642518,
-0.0079495292,
0.0074634096,
0.020538928,
0.0346353278,
-0.0871371478,
-0.0034445121,
0.0513346754,
0.0244122501,
-0.0179516096,
-0.0143290209,
-0.0152177615,
0.0041721738,
-0.0264522955,
0.0226923153,
-0.0039470722,
-0.0315770805,
-0.0121659171,
0.0386758707,
0.0636795983,
0.0676143691,
0.0741081685,
0.0238332357,
-0.0015032326,
-0.0245711952,
-0.0180197563,
0.0192710757,
-0.0185297634,
0.002043938,
0.0027351547,
-0.0170456097,
0.0202474613,
0.0252317116,
0.0384419821,
0.0574371442,
-0.0499262847,
0.0075890375,
0.0057920227,
-0.0399594605,
0.0046683964,
-0.0279239789,
-0.0504857711,
0.0335915945,
-0.0442247465,
-0.0238313079,
0.0679910034,
-0.0327996463,
-0.011726616,
-0.032238882,
-0.0231999848,
-0.0163975246,
0.0123167103,
-0.0175086614,
0.0139343264,
-0.0166748744,
-0.0236866046,
-0.050486926,
-0.0612435825,
0.0504542105,
-0.0346735418,
0.0905664042,
-0.0243681353,
-0.019448597,
-0.0152573157,
-0.0132808238,
-0.0464299917,
-0.0330386385,
-0.0418948568,
0.0363216437,
0.0327046402,
-0.0187548492,
-0.0345798098,
0.0371271931,
0.0155434748,
0.0672749951,
-0.0413514785,
0.0041952087,
-0.0226709191,
0.0615345091,
0.0674935579,
0.0255789943,
0.0244428404,
-0.0544323064,
0.0493058711,
0.0071697887,
0.0039054495,
-0.0088177575,
-0.0058640358,
-0.0013319385,
-0.0370520018,
-0.0278594214,
0.0263777785,
0.0007697356,
0.0860905275,
-0.017298203,
-0.0106217768,
0.0861399248,
0.0010091652,
-0.0134272743,
-0.0059926915,
-0.0097216051,
0.0493097752,
-0.0031272089,
0.0036209852,
-0.0471791662,
-0.0405819826,
0.023245465,
0.0520903058,
0.0193829015,
-0.0048756581,
-0.0177185144,
-0.066389598,
0.0376265869,
0.0226728823,
-0.0561112836,
-0.042307239,
-0.0181379206,
0.0265539046,
-0.0277894735,
0.069165282,
0.0120436158,
-0.0146126673,
-0.0109331608,
0.0350140706,
-0.058960855,
-0.0369808301,
-0.0318656266,
-0.0071015311,
0.0192922335,
0.0770521387,
0.011952485,
0.0245227385,
0.0349600613,
0.0690168962,
-0.0082594287,
0.0004326314,
0.0334539115,
0.0841809288,
0.0112441741,
-0.0019452119,
-0.0337125324,
0.0430938452,
0.0266351309,
-0.0120029617,
-0.0063908515,
-0.0617506057,
-0.0064588231,
0.0074858875,
-0.0421801284,
0.0678555965,
-0.0243357271,
0.0707620382,
0.048232194,
-0.0187186915,
-0.0306249168,
-0.018946588,
0.010719317,
-0.0766050965,
0.0025943485,
-0.0002997011,
-0.001011142,
-0.0002278664,
-0.0791649371,
-0.0533186756,
-0.0312635824,
-0.0472801477,
-0.0250136293,
-0.0327331945,
-0.0174607169,
0.0373660401,
0.0060048988,
0.021349892,
-0.0137814786,
-0.0159265175,
-0.0729121566,
-0.0226555299,
0.0416507982,
-0.0120974695,
-0.014623533,
0.0263661165,
-0.1029231623,
-0.0690005273,
-0.0254399087,
0.0736830458,
0.024521919,
0.0942561701,
0.0271496512,
-0.0265687238,
0.0168099869,
0.0043004816,
0.018337341,
0.0404004231,
0.0561823435,
0.0245521106,
-0.0417638794,
0.0194588602,
-0.0410881154,
0.0299918409,
-0.0241618697,
0.0360036381,
-0.0287651941,
-0.1040311605,
-0.0262852553,
-0.0032430959,
-0.0100033181,
0.0161724184,
-0.016763987,
-0.0084407423,
-0.0024144899,
0.0072969361,
0.0115045272,
-0.0551957116,
0.0151436497,
-0.0431343503,
-0.00963715,
0.0092243059,
0.0052143987,
-0.0494829006,
0.0391314514,
-0.058025863,
-0.0132798003,
-0.0296291392,
-0.0491147004,
-0.0531020127,
0.0115485955,
-0.0460236631,
0.0369311608,
-0.0271267984,
0.0147754382,
0.004509171,
0.0288270656,
-0.0016468856,
-0.0275900345,
0.0298621431,
0.0384436026,
-0.068449825,
-0.0020903705,
-0.0436487831,
0.0273694322,
0.0283550657,
-0.022107549,
0.0638990924,
0.0035890543,
0.0260543842,
-0.0377484597,
0.0115399044,
0.0214062277,
-0.0009922539,
-0.0354838036,
0.036802467,
0.0328076743,
0.0434831865,
0.0728297606,
-0.0490782447,
0.0048858058,
-0.0103130341,
0.0109976353,
-0.049103301,
-0.0397833288,
-0.0081564141,
0.0408798531,
-0.0039401674,
0.0036791086,
-0.0281257834,
-0.0074854633,
0.0396606848,
-0.0000704614,
0.0343331508,
-0.0212197062,
0.04611497,
-0.0068915859,
-0.0262349267,
0.0149432896,
-0.0090365633,
-0.0353671648,
-0.0049101086,
0.026536569,
-0.0310278963,
-5.659940647e-33,
-0.0468559526,
0.0027188307,
-0.0402416661,
0.0065751807,
-0.0332751498,
-0.0086653419,
-0.077446945,
0.0226073153,
-0.0024603356,
-0.0143887475,
-0.0145660983,
0.0229436904,
0.0202198289,
0.0593770258,
-0.024040537,
-0.0405235104,
0.0684910044,
0.0065031764,
-0.0699677095,
0.0448369011,
0.0092688855,
-0.0088403439,
0.0192191955,
-0.0645349026,
0.0080246441,
-0.0309277792,
-0.0525902472,
-0.0039034253,
0.0558180027,
0.0704690591,
0.0020700286,
0.0245853029,
0.0098032048,
-0.0183818769,
-0.0705643445,
-0.0005442944,
-0.0684648454,
-0.0102962935,
0.0318950489,
0.004095417,
-0.0171106048,
-0.0204732046,
0.0276004337,
-0.0131688621,
0.0190031808,
-0.0483495109,
0.0236140527,
-0.058186654,
-0.0391094536,
-0.0240649879,
-0.0144909229,
0.0299718603,
-0.0530694872,
-0.0769824609,
0.0145977344,
0.0661403164,
0.014018517,
-0.0083826687,
-0.0036147917,
0.0445115641,
0.0852991715,
0.0155653646,
0.0437970236,
0.034001492,
-0.0116753643,
0.0789063275,
0.0250530094,
0.0122283958,
0.0189360697,
-0.0354792476,
0.0005788985,
0.0356442779,
0.025873756,
0.0356149748,
0.0211805049,
0.0468929,
-0.0024869968,
0.0342880599,
-0.0057845451,
0.0121506741,
0.043717809,
0.0236882195,
0.0020964635,
-0.0043662726,
-0.0361370184,
0.0263666902,
-0.0154058076,
-0.0163088366,
-0.0013606916,
0.0364908837,
-0.029476082,
-0.0231856816,
0.0385067761,
0.0030590515,
0.0326210558,
0.0256492905,
-0.0277920626,
-0.012040413,
-0.0067279115,
-0.0302805714,
0.000301365,
0.001112488,
0.0618412606,
-0.0031633358,
-0.0002425123,
0.0064410688,
0.0267806817,
0.0008653543,
-0.0297747273,
0.0148189897,
0.0452912785,
0.0721005574,
-0.0516779907,
0.0507323667,
0.0001777586,
-0.004281681,
-0.0081685465,
0.0817992315,
-0.0435609259,
0.0113270273,
-0.0120521532,
0.0083145564,
0.0252412576,
0.0332979597,
-0.039017044,
0.0162440483,
0.009096019,
-0.0316996053,
0.0013587672,
-0.0166075043,
-0.0136880474,
0.0001073868,
2.343e-7,
-0.0043947208,
0.0233540926,
0.0852288753,
-0.0265605934,
0.0017157588,
0.0203353371,
-0.0023976022,
-0.007683936,
0.0216839314,
0.0018509421,
0.0296402331,
0.0466194563,
0.082096003,
-0.0052855713,
-0.0701900348,
-0.0451254025,
-0.0834305361,
-0.0228524171,
0.0050993403,
-0.0230457317,
0.0507993959,
0.0634064078,
-0.0215654932,
0.0124150626,
-0.0177645218,
-0.0177341066,
0.022232201,
-0.0346287079,
-0.0157734975,
0.0130178379,
0.0387687422,
0.0012411572,
-0.018616803,
-0.0079577072,
-0.005832247,
-0.0097368611,
0.0475318581,
0.0679581165,
0.0181567427,
-0.0695749447,
-0.0276451595,
0.0062291021,
0.0152454963,
-0.007285879,
0.0361670665,
-0.068790786,
0.000238481,
-0.0050817132,
-0.0378256962,
0.0003398498,
0.0096442364,
-0.0355777815,
-0.0459114201,
0.0351152048,
0.0067244759,
0.0285670031,
0.0035693853,
-0.0706226304,
-0.0421554074,
0.0126525201,
-0.0299677514,
-0.0411673039,
-0.0173011329,
-0.0279883035,
-0.0083915386,
-0.0305500235,
-0.006057227,
2.016929508e-34,
0.0827137828,
0.0105495453,
-0.0130256014,
0.0229455233,
0.0147436019,
-0.0259031467,
0.0062081297,
-0.0319951326,
0.0265648309,
-0.0664703697,
-0.0204988904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08704v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08704v2 | Can Large Language Models Follow Concept Annotation Guidelines? A Case Study on Scientific and Financial Domains | 2023-11-15T05:11:26 | 2024-06-27T03:48:35 | Marcio Fonseca, Shay B. Cohen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although large language models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable capacity to leverage
in-context demonstrations, it is still unclear to what extent they can learn
new concepts or facts from ground-truth labels. To address this question, we
examine the capacity of instruction-tuned LLMs to follow in-context concept
guidelines for sentence labeling tasks. We design guidelines that present
different types of factual and counterfactual concept definitions, which are
used as prompts for zero-shot sentence classification tasks. Our results show
that although concept definitions consistently help in task performance, only
the larger models (with 70B parameters or more) have limited ability to work
under counterfactual contexts. Importantly, only proprietary models such as
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 can recognize nonsensical guidelines, which we hypothesize is
due to more sophisticated alignment methods. Finally, we find that
Falcon-180B-chat is outperformed by Llama-2-70B-chat is most cases, which
indicates that careful fine-tuning is more effective than increasing model
scale. Altogether, our simple evaluation method reveals significant gaps in
concept understanding between the most capable open-source language models and
the leading proprietary APIs. | [
0.0505388491,
0.0268530101,
0.0105045522,
0.0383726694,
-0.0628149882,
0.0344190411,
0.0234813206,
-0.024108924,
-0.0199799109,
-0.0877745897,
-0.033591114,
-0.0338337459,
-0.0267389081,
0.0484124981,
0.0298075043,
-0.0257422905,
0.0554555915,
-0.0213711243,
0.0536171831,
0.0076054744,
0.0020795246,
-0.0063712387,
-0.024044076,
0.0148464618,
0.0066688284,
-0.0501810461,
0.0290503968,
-0.0299321897,
0.0085561303,
-0.0269094855,
0.0336783677,
0.0539953597,
0.0218223259,
0.1006109193,
0.0000018554,
-0.0664412975,
-0.0073352386,
-0.0036987602,
-0.083347775,
0.0479547419,
0.0496472567,
-0.0296794996,
0.0081315506,
-0.0053430614,
-0.0365200713,
0.0128120258,
0.0756234303,
0.0540770702,
0.067871131,
0.0744554326,
-0.0005986,
-0.0595629029,
0.0319992527,
-0.0348558836,
0.0021161528,
-0.0433843359,
0.0403211415,
0.0104174968,
-0.0130691202,
0.0402327292,
-0.0010562839,
0.0475105532,
0.0224494208,
-0.0144249825,
0.0270055924,
0.047396034,
-0.0631101951,
-0.024334684,
-0.0172444358,
0.0676941648,
0.0212363265,
-0.0212266017,
-0.0103135239,
-0.0289836749,
-0.0156443156,
-0.0414226055,
-0.0459626168,
0.0453336351,
-0.0081850532,
0.0173458699,
0.0380625874,
0.0117893936,
0.0450810976,
0.0428336561,
0.0026759203,
0.0766320676,
-0.0012470197,
-0.0467278399,
0.0248202551,
0.018048875,
-0.0768734664,
-0.0444797575,
-0.0159505755,
0.0036470862,
0.0116187707,
0.0301436447,
-0.0469263718,
-0.0138031179,
0.041286476,
-0.0812710226,
0.0227963775,
0.0482745878,
-0.0314365961,
0.0713654906,
-0.0132528236,
0.0511578433,
-0.0190962199,
0.0104637602,
-0.0065448903,
-0.0014769637,
-0.0527789183,
-0.0307060611,
-0.0266117342,
0.0263909884,
-0.0540656708,
-0.0218252931,
-0.0474913903,
0.0172731038,
-0.0086542554,
0.0335445926,
-0.011760992,
-0.0392286628,
-0.0407103263,
-0.0024869069,
-0.0060563497,
0.0283790305,
-0.0113489628,
0.0030631837,
0.0146876862,
-0.068291083,
-0.0221458972,
0.011758388,
-0.0508929007,
-0.0403509736,
0.0118511226,
0.0361600816,
0.0030629491,
-0.0538020171,
-0.023842331,
-0.0074473345,
-0.0375581942,
-0.0896072686,
0.0072112991,
-0.0336786881,
-0.0038444125,
0.0231031887,
-0.0105008353,
-0.0148905143,
0.0181067996,
0.0058323061,
-0.0155509422,
0.0979268402,
0.0051913876,
-0.0401004516,
0.0285259504,
-0.0066620307,
-0.0065394733,
0.1005143076,
0.0048534404,
-0.0212456901,
0.039067857,
0.0268361885,
-0.0025153938,
0.0139284041,
0.0124659613,
-0.0092599755,
-0.0277034212,
0.0256213117,
0.0342012569,
0.0582201667,
0.0218990911,
0.0147665543,
-0.0235513952,
0.0042225462,
0.0512652174,
0.0006678264,
-0.0029324109,
-0.0052639083,
0.0236538984,
0.0093456851,
0.0235765353,
-0.0031132754,
-0.0499093831,
0.0033929928,
-0.0255354699,
0.0341250896,
-0.0043344842,
-0.004993374,
-0.0307726916,
-0.0270422753,
-0.0373603515,
0.000432973,
-0.0164315831,
-0.0057514901,
0.0595772825,
-0.0090247774,
-0.0185796022,
0.033709392,
0.042436827,
-0.0220676064,
-0.0266271625,
-0.0351824723,
0.0054426584,
0.0568379909,
0.0502401665,
-0.051109422,
-0.06584391,
-0.0111586917,
0.0284178425,
0.0940652043,
0.0764474198,
-0.0094170272,
0.0010753301,
-0.0396542326,
-0.008404728,
-0.0504925661,
0.0412649885,
-0.0030635796,
0.0478272736,
-0.0125432648,
0.0144258607,
-0.0567939393,
-0.0244346596,
0.0631548464,
-0.0021199004,
-0.0481539294,
-0.0074133431,
-0.0066766231,
0.0169553682,
0.0295635201,
-0.0129346438,
0.0026265804,
0.0103897518,
-0.0396575704,
0.006982014,
-0.0042716824,
-0.0376978852,
-0.0682069659,
0.0412983187,
0.0229261294,
-0.0320000909,
0.0363698155,
-0.0550079271,
-0.0425837412,
-0.0084323436,
0.0026196218,
0.0374326557,
-0.0425419211,
-0.0125551345,
0.0000314443,
0.0097439364,
-0.0392897874,
0.055883076,
0.0020299566,
0.0115957903,
-0.0204917919,
0.0067670136,
0.0066224975,
-0.0220702067,
-0.0318708047,
0.0256807264,
0.0185081866,
-0.0025361401,
0.0027899456,
0.0111283725,
-0.04152124,
-0.0123470705,
-0.0914131775,
0.02648573,
-0.0285853278,
0.024664456,
0.0208979715,
-0.0129868938,
-0.0025148415,
-0.0145797366,
-0.0034692341,
-0.0038165895,
-0.022976391,
0.0216379687,
0.0594595894,
0.0256726649,
-0.0348944813,
-0.0264646877,
0.0112125138,
-0.0381826386,
0.0341022536,
0.0226106662,
-0.024542179,
-0.0503606237,
-0.0052599581,
-0.0171442814,
0.0204159953,
-0.0163008273,
0.000004678,
0.0017606686,
0.0323491953,
-0.0115046324,
0.0634645149,
0.0019604454,
0.0692883059,
0.0348301306,
0.0172343496,
-0.0259063262,
0.0336136073,
0.0066316011,
-0.0056339912,
-0.030740533,
0.0293492377,
-0.0042794738,
0.0761273801,
-0.0295086242,
0.0076586804,
-0.0658936575,
0.013720301,
-0.023690071,
-0.0042821425,
-0.0448561981,
0.0004656349,
-0.0306166168,
0.0140280165,
-0.0314618498,
-0.0331946835,
0.0627303198,
-0.0246303454,
-0.0446297526,
-0.0517984852,
-0.01931425,
-0.042569384,
0.0478343591,
0.0058283531,
-0.0021398086,
0.0573991016,
-0.0018040197,
-0.0068737087,
-0.0051875548,
0.0164902322,
0.0042134803,
0.039267242,
-0.0812440068,
0.0477933399,
-0.0254603848,
-0.0305499621,
-0.0436389223,
-0.0509410389,
-0.0407105461,
0.0578528419,
-0.0042110481,
-0.0156020243,
-0.0538998656,
0.0304967053,
0.0260206796,
0.059843801,
-0.0106829517,
-0.0026938051,
-0.0215630326,
-0.0088751111,
0.0649411976,
0.0086917151,
0.0219810996,
-0.0282714255,
0.0294643752,
0.0110915229,
-0.0008361273,
-0.0338299908,
-0.0065320376,
-0.0107312854,
-0.0052657505,
-0.0701203421,
-0.0219124723,
0.0091340579,
0.0399987325,
-0.0557969734,
-0.0345318243,
0.1260082871,
0.0281591229,
-0.0253866613,
-0.0170320179,
0.0235047992,
0.0338867605,
0.0286097117,
0.0075137131,
-0.1004353017,
-0.0488935001,
-0.0032385776,
0.0147336675,
-0.0141698308,
-0.0073362733,
-0.0533802435,
-0.1088966802,
0.0503754765,
-0.00220275,
-0.0776096806,
-0.0179013349,
-0.0391005613,
0.0081431121,
-0.0386911295,
0.0077128899,
0.0000021277,
0.0067823571,
-0.0034348732,
0.0182570163,
-0.0114108324,
-0.0667125732,
0.0301842261,
-0.0131093794,
0.0585889407,
0.0425776206,
0.0060842135,
-0.0013564173,
-0.0186271425,
0.0269751474,
-0.0560796782,
-0.0065849288,
0.0015246944,
0.0514896214,
-0.0367285572,
-0.0064409361,
0.025982473,
0.0284845643,
-0.0640717745,
-0.0243087802,
-0.0143287033,
0.0587914623,
-0.0154532306,
0.0086095184,
-0.0160458814,
-0.0153481551,
0.0187641568,
0.108737424,
0.0225762557,
-0.0370253287,
-0.0466131121,
-0.0354476161,
0.0022174264,
-0.0224863216,
0.0091989143,
-0.0200270973,
-0.0007164683,
-0.0324643962,
-0.0478120036,
-0.0523425378,
0.0263585486,
0.0395139195,
-0.0080116978,
0.029599905,
-0.0284813009,
0.0152461892,
-0.0209719483,
0.0248950906,
-0.0467428565,
0.0105626499,
-0.0606197938,
-0.0307185873,
0.0209219214,
-0.007664029,
-0.042075377,
0.0371957123,
-0.0821823254,
-0.0875824541,
0.0406441055,
-0.0042297775,
0.0313323848,
0.0490216054,
-0.0175185464,
-0.0053406758,
0.019370852,
0.0627902672,
-0.0177238602,
0.0206237882,
0.0669803992,
0.0221040733,
-0.0051136366,
0.0404120609,
-0.0436434858,
0.022526348,
0.012594712,
0.046766337,
-0.0396389849,
-0.0235074311,
0.0254669972,
0.0100572584,
0.0739782602,
-0.0280217044,
-0.0205335189,
-0.0250255819,
0.0099640032,
-0.0109911067,
-0.0335899331,
-0.0253097508,
-0.0348641276,
-0.0026095707,
-0.0160952397,
-0.0106407842,
0.0355315506,
-0.0100811282,
0.0345742293,
-0.0049747718,
-0.0091886865,
0.0018172786,
0.0172569212,
0.0083585745,
-0.0183941778,
-0.0324144103,
0.0260570273,
0.0025898321,
0.0237840042,
-0.0057111466,
0.0510630459,
0.042069152,
-0.002647924,
-0.0145802302,
0.0274151694,
-0.0773259997,
0.0310666859,
-0.0445710272,
0.0743115693,
0.0610865392,
-0.0183239616,
0.0355347656,
-0.0700158179,
-0.0371670015,
-0.0094153266,
0.038694486,
0.0084553622,
-0.0262199305,
0.0541055985,
0.0224922225,
-0.0283187553,
-0.0239849649,
0.0796604156,
0.0288250018,
0.0721638352,
0.0173611697,
0.0206378475,
-0.0332385898,
-0.0280541573,
-0.0004701402,
0.006174501,
0.0103039313,
0.0394519232,
-0.0838408545,
-0.0400387794,
0.0383788608,
-0.0044815666,
-0.0155895725,
-0.0406205654,
0.0520131066,
0.075878717,
-0.0106680151,
-0.0600713901,
-0.0234981794,
0.0088256616,
0.0165373534,
-0.0001959938,
-0.0658174828,
-6.418037525e-33,
-0.0457265899,
0.0075618518,
0.0308002792,
0.0318649188,
-0.0002609847,
0.0155722341,
-0.0178762358,
0.000571318,
-0.0179837197,
0.0300148744,
0.0221018884,
0.0233231373,
0.0182950795,
0.0092612971,
-0.0041925791,
-0.0325033814,
0.0576942079,
-0.0249625221,
-0.0314123221,
0.0131610576,
0.0301319696,
0.0216917153,
0.1002449766,
-0.0360152312,
0.0499234013,
-0.0056139198,
-0.0098844748,
0.0200979859,
-0.0107854251,
0.0520762838,
-0.034463007,
0.0443936251,
0.021754669,
-0.0610561632,
-0.0085181212,
-0.0075668185,
-0.0334765315,
-0.0263895486,
0.0420787893,
0.0275119673,
-0.0071851276,
-0.0465568975,
0.0392040834,
-0.0034548698,
-0.0202883501,
0.0061368332,
0.0243716799,
-0.0258654188,
-0.0019090851,
0.0031462971,
-0.0838132128,
0.0464028791,
0.0098563302,
-0.0113357715,
0.0261864513,
0.0254114158,
-0.0024514927,
0.0308615491,
-0.0455342792,
0.0015840377,
0.0487245768,
0.0176535752,
0.0552195981,
0.0438439846,
0.0064775767,
0.0566024296,
-0.0283982065,
0.0036872395,
-0.0124039417,
-0.0210136883,
0.0253756978,
0.0199841484,
0.0350787155,
0.0745021924,
0.0652306154,
0.018315468,
-0.0635974705,
-0.0174818039,
-0.0042008059,
0.0152800111,
0.0318022221,
0.0146325622,
-0.0530080125,
-0.0172732193,
-0.0205471776,
-0.0221651606,
-0.0389045551,
0.0009868629,
0.0476482585,
0.0021756396,
-0.0048463056,
-0.0008434137,
0.0052534277,
-0.0380758122,
-0.0230988339,
0.009715396,
-0.012732924,
0.0345277525,
0.0219746325,
0.0132850166,
-0.1135127768,
-0.0378116779,
0.0105916131,
0.0365329757,
0.0071171224,
-0.0141247362,
0.063594982,
0.0051535415,
-0.0403201953,
0.0128267528,
-0.0269590821,
0.0143234292,
-0.008454401,
-0.0054354593,
0.0185862295,
0.0124979913,
-0.0077804043,
0.0355188996,
0.0311205387,
-0.0171072613,
-0.0260658991,
-0.0221653376,
-0.0132446298,
0.0308224503,
-0.0232718624,
-0.0017068574,
0.025114743,
0.0069023124,
-0.0080005517,
-0.05491044,
-0.0040601506,
0.0350082554,
2.582e-7,
0.0662593246,
0.0746350065,
0.0077814325,
0.005021825,
0.032370735,
0.0528076179,
-0.0343852267,
0.0128810881,
-0.0091751013,
-0.028352689,
-0.0043314788,
0.0217366517,
0.0386093408,
0.0137027726,
-0.0780300349,
0.0204755664,
-0.0598443374,
0.003745883,
-0.0585172325,
0.0102454815,
0.0486334898,
0.1074722707,
0.0154374056,
-0.0022236239,
-0.0069044181,
-0.0584420078,
0.0633625016,
-0.0167765468,
-0.0014543001,
0.0185551364,
0.0251730215,
0.0406664647,
-0.0097742751,
0.0561204851,
0.00097812,
0.0170078967,
-0.0087114545,
0.0896760672,
-0.0056944517,
-0.019424526,
-0.0244303439,
0.0095158005,
-0.0058473847,
-0.0849004909,
0.0826187283,
-0.0675369278,
-0.0286463592,
-0.0417244323,
-0.0153955976,
-0.0110952491,
0.0246576015,
0.0040616374,
-0.018921189,
-0.0110175563,
0.002037958,
-0.022366032,
-0.0275328755,
-0.0479821526,
-0.0420523584,
0.0245209597,
-0.0237463806,
-0.0261969529,
-0.0539869107,
-0.0124455392,
0.014193139,
-0.0484669209,
0.0069926875,
2.650967513e-34,
0.0496861935,
-0.0267975014,
-0.0124007845,
0.0291511267,
-0.0026894859,
0.0059901881,
-0.0214571822,
0.0243643802,
-0.0016659005,
-0.0678720698,
0.0317698643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08702v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08702v1 | Debate Helps Supervise Unreliable Experts | 2023-11-15T05:05:40 | 2023-11-15T05:05:40 | Julian Michael, Salsabila Mahdi, David Rein, Jackson Petty, Julien Dirani, Vishakh Padmakumar, Samuel R. Bowman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.0 | As AI systems are used to answer more difficult questions and potentially
help create new knowledge, judging the truthfulness of their outputs becomes
more difficult and more important. How can we supervise unreliable experts,
which have access to the truth but may not accurately report it, to give
answers that are systematically true and don't just superficially seem true,
when the supervisor can't tell the difference between the two on their own? In
this work, we show that debate between two unreliable experts can help a
non-expert judge more reliably identify the truth. We collect a dataset of
human-written debates on hard reading comprehension questions where the judge
has not read the source passage, only ever seeing expert arguments and short
quotes selectively revealed by 'expert' debaters who have access to the
passage. In our debates, one expert argues for the correct answer, and the
other for an incorrect answer. Comparing debate to a baseline we call
consultancy, where a single expert argues for only one answer which is correct
half of the time, we find that debate performs significantly better, with 84%
judge accuracy compared to consultancy's 74%. Debates are also more efficient,
being 68% of the length of consultancies. By comparing human to AI debaters, we
find evidence that with more skilled (in this case, human) debaters, the
performance of debate goes up but the performance of consultancy goes down. Our
error analysis also supports this trend, with 46% of errors in human debate
attributable to mistakes by the honest debater (which should go away with
increased skill); whereas 52% of errors in human consultancy are due to
debaters obfuscating the relevant evidence from the judge (which should become
worse with increased skill). Overall, these results show that debate is a
promising approach for supervising increasingly capable but potentially
unreliable AI systems. | [
0.0750929043,
0.057658907,
-0.0323128104,
0.0048339749,
-0.0380717255,
-0.0027933121,
0.0526247621,
-0.0034479445,
0.0136987558,
-0.0176220238,
0.0046288944,
-0.0023162486,
0.0098761236,
0.0236220062,
0.0124709271,
-0.0596767478,
0.0278443638,
-0.035181161,
0.1002009436,
-0.0066802697,
0.050271336,
-0.0106802434,
-0.0239035338,
0.0247074161,
-0.0385230705,
-0.0034358194,
-0.0201264955,
-0.0394761674,
0.0325263515,
0.0018044951,
0.0235513113,
0.0612820424,
-0.0104817897,
0.0484075509,
0.0000016014,
-0.0166165493,
0.0018744814,
-0.0203576554,
-0.0679196566,
-0.0035376092,
0.0043867361,
0.00626066,
0.0268772263,
0.0079415357,
-0.0477031358,
0.0331704952,
-0.0032472627,
0.0467553884,
0.060102284,
0.0527212359,
0.0301741604,
0.0296894554,
0.040035516,
-0.0019511129,
-0.0075469962,
-0.0709338263,
-0.0073548611,
0.0252879206,
-0.0401642621,
0.031126162,
-0.0105118705,
0.0253518615,
0.0320765153,
-0.025703365,
-0.0155806709,
0.0100191003,
-0.0335425362,
-0.0088687697,
-0.0189079512,
0.0426556319,
0.0494470447,
-0.0476856343,
0.0000977893,
-0.0043679043,
0.0458468683,
0.0647917762,
-0.0022960131,
0.0402733646,
-0.048664324,
-0.0369313359,
0.0345864892,
0.0104238633,
-0.0124303084,
0.0292221792,
0.0377928428,
0.0351425596,
-0.0459658206,
-0.0452492684,
0.0300942156,
0.049797155,
0.048885107,
-0.061108347,
0.0028403529,
0.0221625939,
-0.0535387807,
0.0311775096,
-0.0272936821,
-0.0310905837,
0.0066253408,
-0.0124890059,
-0.0056982068,
0.0060083391,
-0.0167084541,
0.0525226928,
-0.0050847651,
0.0376574546,
0.0061835572,
0.0599802211,
0.0037360284,
-0.0398412719,
-0.0212160274,
-0.0158543251,
-0.0276702791,
0.0054301792,
-0.0172300059,
0.0155943409,
0.0163746309,
-0.0149063831,
-0.0683007315,
0.0559728481,
-0.0105745085,
0.0348730795,
-0.0200246107,
-0.0261962134,
-0.0805235431,
0.0257694479,
-0.0502562076,
0.0285995901,
0.0256515965,
-0.0565230586,
-0.0300027542,
0.0247815344,
-0.0033607024,
0.0185086504,
0.0171738118,
0.0537462272,
-0.0298775826,
0.0090675345,
-0.0043225819,
-0.0267981105,
-0.0129971337,
-0.0671243221,
-0.0078314589,
-0.0321270637,
0.0480661876,
-0.0140789822,
-0.0140445167,
-0.0460379943,
0.0119110895,
0.0078431042,
0.0063274642,
0.0673345998,
-0.0538426153,
0.0053546219,
0.0758107677,
0.0516602807,
-0.0861189514,
0.0197328776,
0.0075538317,
-0.0193331838,
0.0528426729,
0.0129846502,
0.0675629973,
-0.0295248311,
0.0159670804,
-0.0006683439,
0.0451403372,
0.0152449943,
-0.0587607622,
0.0352436453,
0.0053463788,
0.0708293468,
-0.0395017751,
-0.0327347927,
0.0717380643,
0.0442565084,
-0.0382926427,
0.0158778504,
0.0114290807,
0.0067975712,
0.0623881929,
0.0414254963,
-0.0089538889,
0.020841619,
0.0045438162,
-0.0212835744,
-0.0275196601,
-0.0231900383,
-0.0019016159,
-0.0729809105,
0.0212702025,
0.0128921131,
-0.001371053,
0.0424890965,
0.0095747486,
-0.0017984225,
-0.013570372,
-0.0126215927,
-0.0133042159,
-0.0188268069,
-0.0205455963,
-0.082413882,
0.0453088209,
0.031617377,
0.0324531235,
-0.012576527,
-0.0271059088,
-0.0156992581,
0.0444832295,
0.0154025769,
0.0752027109,
-0.0219163392,
-0.0040137284,
-0.034627147,
-0.0307629835,
-0.0205103848,
0.0226503983,
0.0162901562,
0.0268007126,
0.0142645808,
-0.0011464565,
-0.0045210309,
-0.0471717939,
0.0199107118,
0.0048036822,
-0.0016809696,
-0.0304072481,
0.0024289072,
0.012235621,
0.0003269131,
-0.0385622643,
-0.0032328481,
0.0112515129,
0.0177669525,
-0.0215706993,
0.0063164318,
-0.0353201777,
0.0446021259,
0.0162308477,
-0.0806963593,
-0.0570021793,
-0.0049106888,
-0.0159276202,
-0.0075140018,
0.000437342,
-0.0684034005,
-0.0477317758,
0.0163073484,
-0.0078421533,
-0.0306379143,
-0.034366481,
-0.0290033054,
0.0605304092,
0.0078471974,
0.0137072289,
-0.0030552719,
0.0350506753,
0.0073561571,
-0.0357428305,
0.0041594747,
-0.017460309,
0.0419874489,
0.0239729527,
0.0509776473,
-0.0312537849,
-0.0605287626,
-0.0143830813,
-0.1038276404,
-0.0290478654,
-0.0071334466,
-0.0077778255,
0.0049000257,
-0.0782016292,
0.002785038,
0.0060956902,
-0.0279126596,
-0.0045780102,
0.0068354495,
0.0015410465,
0.0481299236,
0.0094579225,
0.0286423191,
-0.0350288562,
0.025302371,
-0.0191689283,
0.0024251423,
0.0718903169,
-0.0039275568,
-0.0697206184,
-0.0069968356,
-0.0308637023,
0.0212939642,
-0.0238076262,
-0.0042357505,
0.0581891425,
0.0360824987,
-0.0069361385,
0.0771088675,
0.0180521011,
0.0536393598,
0.0406458601,
-0.0105345612,
-0.0371318422,
0.0165453535,
0.0477218293,
0.0170582999,
-0.0278792102,
-0.0157836694,
-0.0043945936,
0.013326128,
0.0424974635,
0.0074763745,
-0.0003070758,
0.0891242102,
-0.0169182159,
-0.0498384349,
0.0028443418,
-0.0677960962,
-0.0045481641,
0.0954315215,
-0.0354497284,
-0.0206424277,
0.1039651707,
-0.0030679759,
0.0278530288,
-0.0419942103,
-0.0290244706,
-0.0062027695,
0.0186910406,
-0.0272847619,
0.0152213918,
-0.0529273488,
-0.0053504556,
-0.0664690062,
-0.0009030099,
0.0744671524,
-0.0597911924,
0.024185909,
-0.0893124491,
-0.0202400126,
0.0132288886,
-0.0491354205,
-0.0395698883,
-0.0045183101,
-0.0491204783,
-0.024758568,
0.0613267235,
-0.0218937341,
-0.0559802093,
-0.0623031035,
0.0509740561,
0.031037068,
0.0194396637,
-0.0282457415,
-0.0015636438,
0.0202101581,
-0.01080494,
0.0264992472,
0.0476573668,
-0.0711050183,
0.0366606303,
0.0776880085,
-0.0021608889,
-0.0282893647,
-0.0267885365,
-0.0482391752,
-0.0145807602,
-0.0104053095,
0.0157668311,
0.0126673402,
0.052455619,
-0.0643741339,
-0.0151970265,
0.0610332079,
0.0269152727,
-0.0148176942,
-0.0327923521,
-0.0330023281,
-0.0032623622,
0.0075118621,
0.0004163205,
-0.0826196373,
-0.0065214117,
0.0031855761,
0.0443014428,
-0.0511381105,
-0.0425220616,
0.0018453674,
-0.080178529,
0.0268824454,
-0.0048484243,
0.0092146238,
-0.0494960397,
-0.0203937292,
-0.0170874707,
-0.0034833229,
-0.0028251514,
0.0100948913,
0.0554131195,
0.014815676,
0.0238789096,
0.0035563577,
0.0453476124,
0.0106163304,
-0.0258975998,
0.0772819743,
0.0113450158,
0.0403388627,
-0.011447818,
-0.0259594973,
-0.014269013,
0.0038249551,
-0.0012498675,
0.0282973107,
0.0780674443,
-0.0175402351,
0.0046513071,
-0.0635554865,
0.0148139372,
0.0347847417,
0.0007616578,
0.0641254559,
0.0288582034,
-0.018680634,
-0.0287930015,
-0.0133268833,
0.0064649698,
0.015227234,
0.0545583442,
0.0129157202,
-0.0133527191,
-0.0716162473,
-0.021180097,
0.0154503882,
-0.0476291031,
-0.0405729786,
0.0162786096,
0.038153436,
0.0348462723,
-0.067319043,
-0.0633521006,
0.0092277974,
0.0364299156,
-0.0047088722,
-0.0212863162,
0.0053598587,
0.0250785314,
-0.0024987562,
0.0082482137,
-0.0216356423,
-0.0075464966,
-0.0139918504,
-0.0194814503,
-0.0246488377,
0.0160577968,
-0.010626819,
0.0229919106,
-0.0418811291,
-0.0335932598,
-0.0011609811,
0.0535312593,
0.0328618363,
0.0144597478,
0.0022124068,
-0.0154103721,
0.0069810119,
-0.0075667216,
-0.0429629572,
0.0039351024,
0.0268416498,
-0.0037313886,
-0.0002229488,
0.0078043235,
0.0155056929,
-0.0187213663,
-0.0009795227,
-0.0098636579,
-0.0774547532,
-0.0178039819,
0.0399879031,
0.0062076026,
0.0041742087,
0.0259277001,
0.0213244129,
-0.0380868204,
0.006274235,
-0.015822133,
-0.0453438573,
0.0226447769,
0.0103093917,
0.0021200166,
-0.0246759169,
0.0192193985,
-0.0064450447,
0.0114444625,
0.0344255455,
-0.0064115459,
-0.0010176344,
0.05702601,
0.0188956056,
-0.0413220674,
-0.0160399489,
-0.0122652203,
0.0510453172,
-0.0083857803,
0.0846284181,
0.0407560952,
0.0731471851,
0.0130669959,
-0.0347558707,
0.0450349301,
-0.0216632597,
-0.0932657495,
-0.0967348665,
0.0267250519,
0.0539002195,
-0.0036925476,
0.0316067897,
-0.020777585,
-0.0174175259,
0.0039503351,
0.0229865257,
-0.0066473172,
0.0186353512,
0.0258379541,
0.0078750411,
0.0202995855,
-0.0022183014,
0.0123373326,
0.0701303333,
0.0038058897,
0.0407927707,
-0.0418466665,
-0.0402425341,
-0.0252334848,
-0.048819121,
-0.049430389,
0.0193558633,
0.0196638368,
-0.0008122594,
-0.0535010621,
-0.0235123914,
-0.0213083159,
0.0558075272,
0.0505841188,
-0.0190331452,
-0.00298028,
0.072042577,
0.0068653375,
-0.0094198277,
-0.0500767268,
0.0494306944,
0.0435467884,
-0.0019727726,
-0.0529865175,
-5.045080327e-33,
-0.0159217678,
-0.101046361,
0.0034070979,
-0.0347924605,
0.02397459,
0.0243213139,
-0.0038069331,
0.0324268639,
-0.0528971739,
0.0553383157,
-0.0002038361,
0.0452374145,
-0.001087494,
-0.0435660705,
0.0472247787,
-0.0343424678,
0.0150446165,
-0.0112245362,
-0.0236747302,
0.0170253161,
0.0290451795,
-0.0478527434,
0.0002521803,
-0.095371902,
0.0587751903,
0.0076630563,
-0.0072788605,
0.0096417693,
-0.0487224981,
0.0208851527,
0.026904216,
0.0522247069,
0.016497653,
-0.005740793,
0.0209579915,
0.0229203459,
-0.0478455983,
-0.0320514217,
0.0297685862,
-0.0037646352,
-0.0683518946,
0.0004603105,
0.0238539949,
-0.0104845231,
-0.005984372,
-0.0092743048,
0.0142569803,
-0.0095025217,
0.0358199812,
-0.0330024697,
-0.0240973867,
0.0260926597,
-0.0474181809,
0.0001101122,
-0.0248360261,
0.0640332997,
0.0074144877,
-0.0292476658,
-0.1057071909,
-0.0023369261,
0.0029866616,
-0.0323990062,
0.0137075288,
-0.0550955571,
-0.0584389307,
0.0398574322,
0.0464317948,
0.0331101008,
-0.0349479839,
-0.072003454,
-0.0235011671,
0.0433819629,
0.1021668985,
0.0418764204,
0.0230388977,
-0.0444950424,
-0.0481846109,
-0.0040816939,
0.0352289267,
0.0562575869,
-0.0104314834,
-0.0054637003,
-0.0777617693,
-0.0022187238,
-0.0408568084,
-0.053133864,
-0.0374186598,
-0.0233570691,
0.0170795396,
0.0237596817,
0.0093535231,
-0.0077053984,
-0.0147503484,
-0.0367030241,
0.0604969561,
0.0061087538,
-0.0158872157,
0.0145823322,
-0.0166060813,
-0.0027496167,
-0.0482646711,
-0.002854527,
0.0095475223,
0.0425816774,
0.0688566342,
-0.0153101506,
0.0285673961,
-0.0369985849,
-0.0444786325,
-0.0014797287,
-0.0150730116,
0.0392811894,
0.0206834096,
-0.0140059302,
0.0361945182,
0.003686961,
-0.0276802201,
0.0040959911,
-0.0065890322,
0.0257056467,
-0.0489133596,
-0.0166823566,
-0.0395779498,
-0.0440967493,
-0.0389205255,
-0.0185492802,
-0.0347696505,
-0.0015487124,
-0.0469229184,
-0.0306081027,
0.0036664342,
-0.0174600575,
2.389e-7,
0.0000925424,
0.0545812808,
0.0186540969,
-0.0107821776,
0.0102070551,
0.0280855894,
0.0224351436,
0.007358273,
0.0059295986,
-0.0678778365,
0.0044762632,
0.0165101439,
0.0356138721,
0.0635625571,
-0.0388830155,
-0.1115254462,
-0.0726756752,
-0.0062983721,
-0.0395817235,
0.0186092854,
0.0807185173,
0.0232701451,
0.0371462256,
-0.0168167409,
-0.0108688669,
-0.0309011918,
0.0481403805,
0.035840936,
0.01410319,
0.0128385546,
0.0932721943,
0.0037265446,
-0.0016046688,
0.0924734846,
0.0132454028,
0.0135928448,
0.002055696,
0.0335786454,
-0.017499784,
-0.0004217227,
-0.0183953233,
0.0036903776,
0.0195274521,
-0.0245856065,
0.0576353073,
-0.0233608745,
-0.021576358,
-0.0129274782,
-0.0322705545,
-0.0371199809,
0.0160693768,
0.0045702527,
-0.0283054858,
0.0145970294,
-0.0111383079,
0.008338118,
0.029802423,
-0.0370521918,
-0.0138844149,
0.045027528,
-0.0188633054,
-0.0541792959,
-0.0029661388,
-0.0095837675,
0.0182237215,
-0.0597137995,
0.0281974021,
1.63418143e-34,
0.0213778131,
-0.0147413984,
0.0282461885,
0.028732948,
0.0869253352,
0.0377349742,
-0.0275119785,
-0.0319398865,
0.0420808345,
0.0055897892,
-0.0195246004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08695v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08695v2 | Attribute Diversity Determines the Systematicity Gap in VQA | 2023-11-15T04:50:30 | 2024-06-24T15:51:13 | Ian Berlot-Attwell, Kumar Krishna Agrawal, A. Michael Carrell, Yash Sharma, Naomi Saphra | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | The degree to which neural networks can generalize to new combinations of
familiar concepts, and the conditions under which they are able to do so, has
long been an open question. In this work, we study the systematicity gap in
visual question answering: the performance difference between reasoning on
previously seen and unseen combinations of object attributes. To test, we
introduce a novel diagnostic dataset, CLEVR-HOPE. We find that while increased
quantity of training data does not reduce the systematicity gap, increased
training data diversity of the attributes in the unseen combination does. In
all, our experiments suggest that the more distinct attribute type combinations
are seen during training, the more systematic we can expect the resulting model
to be. | [
0.0249555577,
0.0743443146,
-0.0334601626,
0.0510981902,
0.0173964482,
0.0141985836,
-0.0042491872,
0.0141470022,
-0.0503155738,
-0.0223630853,
0.0037628214,
-0.0743053779,
0.0129635194,
0.0540711991,
0.0426125079,
-0.0505231023,
0.0459228829,
-0.0135576809,
-0.0092909401,
-0.0371779837,
-0.0140769705,
-0.0230592601,
0.0065269591,
0.0118703535,
-0.0076343147,
-0.0331646763,
-0.0350618064,
-0.0138136437,
0.0202990025,
-0.0029011758,
-0.0048920834,
0.0369127132,
0.0125705451,
0.0035269524,
0.0000017252,
-0.01387442,
0.0369889736,
0.0105534624,
-0.0134567544,
0.0030767431,
-0.0693996996,
0.0388997868,
0.0225829985,
0.0084794499,
-0.0391561724,
-0.0656807572,
0.0464063808,
0.0398529731,
0.0233294033,
0.0125048961,
0.0019830016,
0.0058008088,
0.0228982214,
-0.0211950559,
0.0563936345,
-0.0403299034,
-0.0043070656,
0.0087487893,
0.0080709336,
0.0056959158,
-0.0414502211,
0.0193681046,
0.0631894693,
0.0941983983,
0.0274324138,
0.0848596841,
-0.0240499284,
0.0115634408,
0.0143475886,
0.0725021288,
-0.0121844979,
0.0191106219,
-0.0087182196,
-0.0016162252,
0.0562854894,
-0.0122300023,
-0.0399914756,
0.0245940182,
-0.0550608635,
-0.0279803611,
-0.0304171406,
0.0139492182,
0.0032895859,
0.0091720158,
-0.0112801129,
-0.021635877,
0.0053047417,
-0.0091360044,
-0.0116250198,
0.0118693635,
-0.0819103792,
-0.03601579,
-0.0703823864,
0.0173803009,
-0.0068712416,
-0.0173459817,
-0.0020264634,
0.0099593494,
0.0068449578,
-0.0148388492,
0.0774139687,
0.0100041898,
-0.0598477498,
0.0409172513,
-0.0213726163,
0.0576966852,
-0.0278235711,
0.0146728549,
-0.0218373891,
-0.01655595,
-0.0597609505,
-0.0525761433,
-0.0345188715,
0.0351330191,
-0.0032677909,
-0.0479342826,
0.0070168995,
-0.0011570782,
-0.0290594492,
-0.0010071159,
-0.0193362162,
0.0665309951,
-0.0117084933,
0.0162490457,
-0.0835002661,
0.0266557522,
-0.0723138452,
0.0349041559,
-0.0105454363,
-0.040621683,
-0.0156534594,
-0.0237289686,
-0.0004857361,
-0.0137380781,
0.0136933317,
0.0532572158,
-0.0456264764,
-0.0217804443,
0.0017482968,
-0.0225879867,
-0.0004707986,
-0.0450289808,
0.0564752147,
-0.0567015484,
0.0294099916,
-0.0068963482,
-0.0010272402,
-0.0284530837,
-0.0152118318,
0.0203869808,
-0.019901827,
0.0879676342,
-0.0027737161,
-0.0021677623,
0.0312181115,
0.0084234169,
0.01827191,
0.0794298053,
-0.0298325811,
0.0055317674,
0.0043503097,
0.0091760857,
0.0380952246,
-0.0020638627,
0.006608678,
-0.0036324225,
-0.0163430553,
0.0166239273,
0.004493319,
0.0374056734,
0.00335583,
0.0222922172,
-0.0619161129,
-0.1081809178,
0.0229750834,
0.0136852954,
0.0208055172,
0.0103068193,
0.032420747,
-0.0365865082,
0.0419199131,
0.0215944685,
-0.0787208155,
0.0636780262,
-0.0025524644,
0.0086153448,
-0.0399075821,
0.0431695729,
-0.0715599284,
-0.0625492036,
-0.0222285744,
0.0232228599,
-0.0122332508,
0.0048639127,
0.0329534188,
0.0342001431,
-0.0059851711,
-0.0382048413,
0.0041947868,
0.0099922502,
-0.0110992379,
-0.0317995362,
0.0729538724,
0.0629193708,
0.0296638869,
0.0044826991,
-0.0108862082,
0.0204076488,
-0.002553755,
-0.0263313185,
0.0111550549,
0.0023865972,
0.0419873632,
-0.0305279382,
-0.0468613729,
-0.0513749756,
0.0167813897,
0.0182523411,
0.0399413444,
-0.0156985205,
-0.0216134079,
-0.0545262173,
0.0226005577,
0.0219695382,
0.0122201098,
0.0149944024,
0.0085231699,
0.0235880017,
-0.0273394007,
-0.0346602909,
0.0040320354,
0.0007629953,
-0.0192087218,
-0.0329199694,
-0.0250310935,
0.0038812417,
-0.0291234851,
-0.0174310841,
0.0104075857,
-0.1065278202,
-0.0045579295,
0.0364258513,
-0.0327929184,
-0.0197786577,
0.0214771125,
-0.0173844192,
-0.0477662981,
-0.0328429416,
0.0070196153,
0.0322602652,
0.0519828722,
-0.012235824,
0.0807648078,
-0.0128723755,
-0.0092872707,
-0.0225946028,
0.0210535955,
0.0228185412,
-0.0453360677,
0.0090314848,
0.0116136223,
-0.0004675933,
0.0094984667,
-0.03816434,
-0.0215817839,
-0.0362250097,
-0.0127900671,
-0.0486143008,
-0.0040256595,
-0.0060137659,
-0.0157779418,
-0.0118970908,
-0.0066826828,
0.0069771176,
-0.0305039939,
-0.0514392927,
0.0425957739,
-0.0271158721,
0.0574237555,
0.0631563887,
0.0282373875,
-0.0174952913,
0.0249913074,
-0.0413148291,
0.0150369275,
0.0967428386,
-0.0037848251,
0.0427448638,
-0.0254657678,
-0.0222344212,
-0.0441524461,
0.0476657227,
-0.0114266397,
-0.0219619256,
0.0015433095,
-0.0001454498,
-0.0219269693,
0.0813384131,
0.007454481,
0.0162261631,
0.0316404067,
0.0484901033,
-0.0399414934,
0.0043538469,
-0.0045927595,
-0.0115107447,
0.0178311169,
-0.0150643997,
-0.015965296,
0.0394639261,
-0.0366880707,
-0.0219318364,
-0.082640104,
0.0445473753,
-0.0027218454,
-0.0680240691,
-0.0565199889,
0.0142160868,
0.0393885486,
0.0440977998,
-0.0372593813,
-0.0448585823,
0.0625222251,
0.0086343912,
-0.0128861964,
0.0019276874,
-0.0092533911,
-0.0391284898,
0.0634395704,
0.0334696993,
0.0194854233,
0.0131322592,
-0.0419602916,
-0.0981765762,
-0.0194402616,
0.0121776443,
0.0076114917,
0.0776733086,
-0.0214240383,
0.0031390497,
-0.0454325601,
-0.0131923789,
-0.0611174852,
-0.0168826282,
0.0163412988,
0.0242725182,
-0.0570306703,
-0.0161890835,
-0.0127491783,
-0.0166244954,
-0.004172978,
0.0277955439,
-0.0307601448,
-0.0159380492,
-0.0030767787,
0.057527665,
0.0451357737,
0.0329082161,
0.0027985831,
-0.0655188859,
0.0160554089,
0.0458865985,
0.0046958481,
0.0007347537,
-0.0472749136,
0.0317257755,
0.0138181942,
0.0259136111,
-0.0537466221,
0.0256993677,
0.0118795615,
-0.0457065217,
-0.0145652844,
0.0360128209,
0.0181517396,
-0.0285965893,
0.0006644166,
-0.0136608584,
0.0194873903,
0.0433573164,
0.0123208575,
-0.1024404466,
-0.0141085247,
-0.019488506,
0.0030421945,
0.0074497205,
0.0166937262,
0.0012153736,
-0.0713859051,
0.0476278961,
-0.0319341645,
-0.0578246899,
-0.0291398317,
0.0286530592,
-0.0132361902,
-0.0307277404,
0.0398931801,
-0.0220861174,
-0.0295495056,
0.0111240325,
0.0114033064,
0.0162686147,
-0.0089974757,
0.0346498452,
-0.0327592604,
0.0242599957,
0.0432650596,
-0.0221133903,
-0.0549385212,
-0.043684341,
-0.0078554191,
-0.053091608,
0.0429751836,
0.0433040857,
0.0832831562,
0.0080575943,
-0.0553645156,
0.0186942425,
0.0233752616,
0.0096065067,
-0.0249098986,
0.0133758457,
0.0184044596,
-0.008184975,
-0.051889956,
-0.0281337984,
-0.0386163592,
-0.0552427731,
0.0471844748,
0.0541826524,
-0.010383158,
-0.0438657477,
0.0095153684,
-0.016867822,
-0.046327319,
-0.0356658362,
0.0809504241,
0.0584650896,
-0.0440845788,
-0.0687046722,
-0.0288478117,
0.0135560771,
0.074626632,
-0.0335615203,
-0.0133715421,
-0.039218992,
0.0295071378,
-0.0672706515,
0.0897603631,
0.0081131803,
0.034193933,
-0.0446910374,
-0.0200055223,
-0.0181349572,
-0.0538406186,
-0.0411194079,
-0.0352727026,
-0.0272342954,
-0.0053613731,
0.0038118011,
0.0220524855,
0.0175593477,
0.0432813503,
0.0055249175,
-0.0589610487,
0.0158350617,
0.0226583425,
0.0558390282,
0.041508615,
0.0078056115,
-0.0348552726,
0.0040082531,
0.0019332313,
-0.0295455325,
0.0105693005,
0.0209868215,
-0.0233296249,
-0.0130829299,
0.056430608,
0.0225269608,
0.0075734756,
-0.0036275594,
0.0133599229,
0.003248231,
-0.0105807893,
0.0239799973,
0.0557128303,
0.0130007956,
-0.0522241071,
-0.0120257689,
0.0212731063,
0.0137575213,
0.0104451757,
-0.0100559164,
0.0197267998,
0.0374910794,
-0.0565258041,
-0.0326392502,
0.0501991026,
0.0072059855,
0.0037381016,
0.0138939517,
-0.0214267429,
0.0052114255,
-0.023835849,
0.0495521165,
0.0251464229,
0.0399283692,
0.0355121978,
-0.0017510273,
-0.0647798553,
0.0309251789,
-0.0450292751,
-0.0874141753,
0.0035541344,
0.0683227852,
0.0047890167,
0.0149284061,
-0.0449371077,
0.0174631458,
-0.0069476091,
0.0077461223,
-0.0286639687,
0.0182911232,
-0.0082154293,
0.0722466335,
0.0578269772,
0.0184787717,
-0.0630193874,
0.0877283588,
0.0042561106,
0.0783971921,
-0.0462248474,
0.0382416919,
0.0055606151,
-0.007002952,
0.0284122657,
0.0010035207,
0.0085506607,
0.0566980541,
-0.0248713717,
-0.0602809787,
-0.0147035643,
0.0468884483,
0.0179285873,
0.0381429531,
0.0167827364,
0.0377490148,
0.030593954,
-0.0332780369,
0.0133432262,
-0.051026158,
0.0177142937,
0.0308795907,
0.0094925649,
-5.963418758e-33,
-0.0278915055,
0.0085884957,
0.0276469346,
-0.0592540205,
0.0123469904,
0.0454486012,
0.0001560747,
-0.0271292794,
-0.0475264713,
0.0145385442,
0.0025238609,
0.0268287491,
-0.0070181615,
0.0360579826,
0.0384667069,
-0.0437701866,
0.0167294946,
0.0382062867,
-0.028345868,
-0.0023929428,
0.0065665022,
-0.0265019014,
0.0393278487,
-0.0020414514,
-0.0399558358,
0.0143549787,
-0.0097680986,
0.0485970676,
-0.0087617803,
0.086837925,
-0.0158909522,
0.0212869197,
0.0331043303,
-0.0211741645,
-0.0340536982,
-0.0378751829,
-0.0712826177,
-0.0368316174,
0.0353921801,
0.0335620865,
-0.0934715495,
-0.0082902247,
0.0107330428,
-0.0063957698,
0.0309666321,
-0.0539056212,
0.0541253835,
-0.0307519566,
-0.0085953875,
-0.0043654745,
0.0010882602,
0.0027943763,
-0.0241990555,
-0.0031997524,
0.0006846627,
0.0313194208,
0.0084900791,
-0.0099161565,
-0.010139619,
0.0114174318,
0.0143573899,
0.0039529377,
0.0347012915,
0.055646427,
0.022864528,
0.0553653911,
0.0860364735,
-0.0203544609,
-0.0579232015,
-0.0291606989,
-0.0212919246,
0.0405520685,
0.0351312198,
0.0527117364,
0.0657739341,
0.016413698,
-0.0366684608,
0.0063622124,
-0.0639566034,
0.0647108182,
-0.0131517658,
-0.0044850423,
-0.0423722975,
-0.0169405211,
-0.0668611974,
0.0122126527,
-0.0659706965,
0.0047965851,
0.0502262786,
0.0500283763,
0.0027933563,
0.050196439,
0.0398409441,
-0.0471099876,
0.0062576835,
0.0597270578,
-0.0074683418,
0.0408049673,
0.0242183562,
0.0249194652,
0.0115753701,
-0.0226405114,
0.0431278497,
-0.0108153578,
0.0036197782,
0.0199368838,
0.0468586348,
0.0207918342,
-0.0572411977,
-0.0292501226,
-0.0336524025,
-0.0137791131,
0.0064306529,
-0.0181075092,
0.0158177502,
0.015914917,
-0.0462335087,
0.0408361144,
-0.0060084714,
0.0091910614,
-0.0392116047,
-0.0173472613,
-0.0075581907,
0.0364238508,
-0.0071790302,
-0.0145764798,
-0.0209541339,
-0.1014146656,
0.0199651085,
-0.0274166204,
-0.0221769009,
0.0526578687,
2.435e-7,
-0.0226647612,
-0.0248187426,
-0.0051281424,
0.0325043611,
0.0032797465,
0.0368812419,
-0.0310561191,
0.0049123568,
-0.0159153752,
-0.0209043268,
-0.0111790672,
0.0927844495,
0.0021996761,
0.0110589815,
0.0128160706,
0.0574420802,
-0.0039461129,
0.0017740147,
-0.0680924505,
-0.0235819258,
0.0219906159,
0.0756228566,
-0.0089971842,
0.0031307035,
0.0620687678,
-0.0352148265,
0.0714258179,
-0.0013696826,
0.0192132164,
-0.0076597845,
0.0198731255,
0.0005582921,
0.041725833,
0.0808644816,
0.0135214049,
0.0027470216,
0.0309747346,
-0.0116292685,
-0.0111518418,
-0.0121333078,
-0.0346027687,
-0.0108700236,
-0.007501557,
-0.0459800996,
0.1005772203,
-0.0412998945,
-0.052576296,
-0.034406215,
-0.0479199551,
-0.0006298496,
0.0842726231,
0.0321083963,
0.0278265849,
0.0065151253,
-0.0081668887,
-0.0555969328,
0.0059356042,
-0.0904467031,
0.0051769004,
-0.0077538774,
-0.031734027,
-0.0314709842,
-0.0310369879,
-0.0076276683,
0.0556501187,
-0.0184599496,
-0.0614408478,
1.581330102e-34,
0.0368488729,
0.0042379289,
0.0377494581,
0.0520203635,
-0.006667777,
-0.0519082546,
0.0150501626,
-0.0377450734,
0.0206850991,
-0.0282065682,
-0.0119845746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08692v1 | Routing to the Expert: Efficient Reward-guided Ensemble of Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T04:40:43 | 2023-11-15T04:40:43 | Keming Lu, Hongyi Yuan, Runji Lin, Junyang Lin, Zheng Yuan, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The complementary potential of Large Language Models (LLM) assumes
off-the-shelf LLMs have heterogeneous expertise in a wide range of domains and
tasks so that an ensemble of LLMs can achieve consistently better performance.
Existing ensemble methods for LLMs mainly focus on reward model ranking of
outputs, leading to significant computation overhead. To combat this issue, we
revisit the complementary potential of LLMs and further elaborate it by mining
latent expertise with off-the-shelf reward models. We propose Zooter, a
reward-guided routing method distilling rewards on training queries to train a
routing function, which can precisely distribute each query to the LLM with
expertise about it. We also integrate a tag-based label enhancement to mitigate
noise from uncertainty when using rewards as silver supervision. Zooter shows
computation efficiency in inference as it introduces only a minor computation
overhead of a routing function compared with reward model ranking methods. We
evaluate Zooter on a comprehensive benchmark collection with 26 subsets on
different domains and tasks. Zooter outperforms the best single model on
average and ranks first on 44% of tasks, even surpassing multiple reward model
ranking methods. | [
0.0660595894,
0.0647877082,
-0.0009861528,
0.0171049125,
-0.0278936997,
0.0095266718,
0.0149787245,
-0.0362056494,
-0.0148861809,
-0.0487926491,
-0.0723897293,
0.0134530943,
-0.0106255421,
0.0083156573,
0.0448163301,
-0.0793513656,
0.0011050487,
-0.0565208755,
0.0287306681,
-0.0037544232,
-0.0219060648,
0.0240546055,
-0.0209751148,
0.0936825573,
0.0171560217,
0.0042362912,
0.0245458428,
0.0189020224,
0.0416790769,
-0.0079361005,
0.0278830174,
0.0528652221,
0.0312758721,
0.042832423,
0.0000020977,
-0.0337053984,
-0.0493653864,
0.0143368533,
-0.0292277858,
0.0070191808,
0.0102975611,
0.034604162,
0.0321241803,
0.0606164634,
-0.0168689433,
0.0177141353,
0.0491451211,
0.0537582375,
0.0393473133,
0.0547285751,
0.0097322334,
-0.0300803408,
0.0229967572,
-0.0599542446,
0.017233707,
-0.0740448982,
0.0061391969,
0.0077117332,
-0.0030697295,
0.0506448299,
-0.011770376,
0.0414512604,
0.0228017662,
-0.0018169984,
0.0526933074,
0.0568453409,
0.0158835109,
0.0146283545,
-0.0279077999,
0.063876234,
-0.0296254121,
-0.0127715115,
-0.0188078191,
0.0063504111,
0.0082145352,
0.0200854503,
-0.0413483866,
0.0334409215,
0.0147104375,
0.0085770069,
0.0478678979,
0.0293816254,
0.0435807668,
0.0430072248,
-0.0297083613,
0.0609748997,
0.022273479,
-0.0143574607,
0.0113048349,
0.0584567115,
-0.0682525635,
-0.0369873643,
0.016882658,
-0.0091084698,
-0.0571962595,
0.0259571113,
-0.0109152514,
-0.04314081,
-0.0225264896,
0.0480043367,
0.0357751362,
0.0152833825,
0.0004041659,
0.0832360387,
-0.020779347,
0.0112987375,
-0.0294713378,
0.0422504954,
-0.042001579,
-0.033748433,
-0.0660059005,
-0.018615989,
-0.0240958799,
0.0403599665,
-0.0324643739,
-0.0209399275,
-0.0420733206,
0.0126741892,
-0.0186835099,
-0.0118454406,
0.0722152516,
0.0307009332,
-0.0225002393,
-0.0095467325,
-0.0187101997,
0.0117031764,
-0.0456935354,
0.0346475616,
0.0077498965,
0.015488917,
-0.0003506774,
0.0245378409,
-0.026749488,
-0.033851333,
0.0081911301,
0.0675350875,
-0.033801809,
-0.0436100885,
-0.0050611477,
-0.0102431634,
0.0046439203,
-0.0485028699,
-0.0008411631,
-0.0645442829,
0.052093558,
0.0074659716,
0.024195021,
-0.0091346791,
0.0022552183,
-0.0019886519,
-0.0520515367,
0.0427001864,
0.0335072093,
0.0047353101,
0.0349888839,
0.0217432827,
-0.0079573588,
0.0530149341,
0.0243225619,
0.0524876602,
0.018955417,
0.0326494835,
0.0007951112,
0.0045503741,
0.0218438841,
0.0043930118,
-0.0229178946,
0.0128245568,
0.0230713766,
0.031533353,
0.020784514,
0.0427547172,
-0.0454224423,
0.0135909431,
0.0652412623,
0.0424862914,
0.0186568331,
-0.041185908,
0.0227525011,
-0.0149509134,
-0.0022719577,
-0.0263635032,
-0.0654402226,
0.0498852395,
-0.0171076376,
-0.0331085585,
0.0755605847,
0.0107913315,
-0.028712457,
-0.0497605056,
0.0141129242,
0.0163863618,
-0.0361883193,
0.0717461333,
0.0584874451,
-0.0328672528,
-0.0310840588,
0.0339455307,
0.0436428264,
-0.012369615,
-0.0001600111,
-0.069060117,
0.0147942184,
0.0935440063,
0.0497222915,
-0.0485004187,
-0.013587351,
-0.0171263479,
-0.0004978928,
-0.0145937661,
-0.002565118,
-0.03741429,
0.0109078232,
-0.0422020033,
-0.0525951274,
-0.0093802949,
0.0332449228,
0.0263377279,
0.055513069,
0.0018119977,
-0.0061368193,
-0.0452101901,
-0.041424755,
0.0494176745,
-0.0052519473,
-0.023544088,
0.0473307744,
0.0113039576,
0.0019903036,
0.0130857881,
-0.0172653925,
0.0121600572,
0.0313395821,
-0.0419133082,
-0.0256531909,
-0.0133612752,
-0.0329101421,
-0.0675069541,
0.0076813414,
-0.0270892717,
-0.0211199038,
0.0372117497,
-0.0512224399,
-0.0360271074,
0.0072754147,
-0.0337860733,
0.0104902321,
-0.0120019782,
-0.012301269,
-0.0036884279,
-0.0364888795,
-0.0605952181,
0.0557164066,
-0.0110966004,
0.0120108267,
-0.0259194989,
0.0058102719,
-0.032080356,
-0.0275233798,
-0.0395122543,
-0.0030942406,
0.0170050766,
0.0439143814,
0.040158283,
-0.0022613157,
-0.0373668931,
-0.0675793439,
-0.0748373568,
0.0148971677,
-0.0364366397,
0.0149735259,
0.0081496844,
-0.0091279475,
0.0298576429,
-0.0041537727,
-0.0359597318,
-0.043022301,
-0.0013621193,
0.0076055466,
-0.0010874058,
0.0171409994,
-0.0276728049,
-0.0298024658,
-0.0444040895,
-0.0076019838,
0.047617238,
-0.0004487777,
0.0021367355,
-0.040384993,
-0.0348190516,
-0.0329005197,
0.0118069211,
-0.0259474721,
-0.0056517902,
-0.0038917207,
-0.0284977444,
0.0178031642,
0.0652155429,
0.0067623281,
0.0293078739,
0.0510228612,
0.0188630838,
-0.0562874191,
-0.0034128993,
-0.0257849507,
-0.0242124796,
-0.0395482965,
-0.0271723624,
0.0043894481,
0.0534969717,
-0.0148508986,
-0.0336054936,
-0.0551751107,
0.0011086697,
-0.0085217133,
-0.0426533259,
-0.0574834943,
0.0182168987,
0.0288828537,
0.0006909557,
-0.0147534553,
-0.0516977496,
0.0770192444,
0.0020244473,
-0.0099182054,
-0.0380200073,
-0.0538932085,
-0.0525245033,
0.0685238466,
0.0009844112,
0.0419532359,
-0.00840824,
-0.0524742678,
-0.0662412792,
0.004858485,
0.0313257948,
-0.0341543294,
0.0434024185,
-0.0512012951,
0.0330260508,
0.0276290756,
-0.0393553823,
-0.0335372388,
-0.0220027976,
-0.0294477697,
0.0421677902,
0.0302847289,
-0.0223389883,
-0.0692015365,
-0.0106463898,
0.0322965346,
0.0135150738,
-0.0220469348,
-0.0133689186,
0.0003256138,
0.0069342805,
0.0601188913,
-0.0046466398,
0.0170790665,
-0.0746721253,
-0.0106765181,
0.0494687185,
0.0356287472,
-0.0363543332,
-0.0099781714,
-0.0197235327,
0.048922509,
-0.046210099,
-0.0046203188,
0.0091567514,
0.0025460378,
-0.0475293957,
0.0100283735,
0.1110083312,
0.0538118966,
-0.0676357895,
-0.004116816,
0.0132784713,
0.0422828309,
0.0327097848,
0.0370280445,
-0.0767598525,
-0.0343416072,
0.0177475363,
0.0341073871,
0.0087727886,
-0.0339127742,
0.0167263225,
-0.1066385657,
0.0412904397,
-0.0058573326,
-0.028642552,
0.0068410686,
-0.0393753499,
-0.0182609446,
-0.0367043614,
-0.0229460653,
0.0068899859,
0.0085584205,
0.0043559303,
0.0574849993,
0.0393936746,
-0.0680158436,
0.0245639887,
-0.0425173789,
0.0642864108,
0.0684552342,
0.0086283293,
-0.0049797795,
-0.018158434,
-0.0024435315,
0.008602418,
-0.0079723867,
-0.0116100525,
0.067033194,
-0.0537510887,
0.0089427624,
0.0123356972,
0.0136666996,
-0.0337600037,
0.033919692,
0.0137761021,
0.0838728324,
-0.0198663007,
0.0023353896,
-0.0258801207,
-0.0447186045,
0.0186369121,
0.0803738758,
-0.0156672876,
-0.0182496142,
-0.0139153777,
-0.0241648741,
-0.0351451226,
-0.0158830248,
-0.0231934767,
0.0278275535,
0.0021577701,
-0.0531587936,
-0.0654254258,
-0.010929022,
0.0795976147,
0.0622701868,
0.0052722306,
0.0351611041,
-0.04349925,
0.0195062365,
-0.0577679649,
0.0303005408,
-0.0406515859,
0.0360920243,
-0.0816186145,
-0.0206779931,
0.0366389342,
-0.0187619627,
-0.0549895801,
-0.0006236059,
-0.0592489429,
-0.0800622106,
-0.0466525219,
0.0689253286,
0.0201234631,
0.0289718602,
-0.0234939586,
-0.0815362781,
0.0407358557,
0.0597099662,
-0.0426263474,
-0.0058396487,
0.0335014686,
-0.0251199026,
-0.0086894361,
0.0443896763,
-0.0687339753,
0.0317094028,
0.0235791504,
0.0545480549,
0.0081049185,
0.0058070864,
0.0074916808,
-0.0011381756,
0.0295669995,
-0.0205603857,
0.0036017846,
-0.0497548915,
0.0306282192,
0.0075574303,
-0.0521165431,
-0.0546338819,
0.0272533391,
0.0612456277,
0.0054390058,
0.0038507746,
0.0233956929,
0.0563216545,
0.0007126438,
-0.0588359945,
-0.0030583881,
-0.0074652098,
-0.0157727841,
0.0267647784,
0.0221185386,
-0.0132069103,
-0.0206901748,
0.0581487603,
0.0383989476,
-0.011496569,
0.0063295485,
0.0510174967,
0.003349843,
-0.0386614203,
0.0110545894,
-0.0938180834,
-0.0648122281,
0.0082498211,
0.0637732446,
0.0952771604,
0.0081746876,
0.0388859846,
-0.0302706584,
-0.0176222511,
-0.0096547883,
0.0004037609,
0.0036153714,
0.007359569,
0.0457833596,
0.028887894,
0.0051605413,
0.0054085217,
0.0802378431,
0.0143488655,
0.0417442508,
-0.0046498314,
-0.049181357,
-0.0131384982,
-0.0121919811,
0.0095284451,
0.0056612585,
-0.0317624994,
0.0475103557,
-0.0161059983,
-0.0393792801,
-0.0298300739,
-0.0046426714,
-0.0150830569,
-0.0205878559,
0.0500153117,
0.0623721853,
-0.0068406747,
-0.0143853407,
-0.0586272292,
-0.0364362039,
-0.0056762621,
-0.0304599553,
-0.0383497924,
-7.134286804e-33,
-0.0086897919,
-0.024941951,
0.0341903158,
-0.039448034,
0.0050393995,
0.0147157582,
-0.0208623707,
-0.0064107822,
-0.0044211354,
0.0391513072,
-0.0185631346,
0.0090941628,
-0.0022976671,
0.0340308025,
0.0369837657,
-0.0109712081,
0.0844768733,
0.0101282652,
-0.0327171348,
0.032981988,
0.0326140858,
0.0199965276,
0.0626302436,
-0.0718205497,
0.0286711883,
0.0157233421,
-0.0199567471,
0.0453924574,
-0.0050173989,
0.0354127847,
0.0147007452,
0.0189867802,
0.0067008799,
-0.0650222078,
0.0080585983,
-0.0255613402,
-0.0816638246,
-0.0130040776,
0.0229952745,
-0.0295748189,
-0.0554330274,
-0.0155489137,
0.0194995049,
0.0222824067,
0.0151582807,
-0.0309520457,
0.0333269089,
-0.0043307962,
-0.0193265136,
-0.019413583,
-0.0226083677,
0.0040332414,
-0.0233031381,
-0.006464093,
0.0499806739,
0.0053883074,
0.0002505073,
0.024415765,
-0.0090969512,
0.0196279064,
0.0392762907,
0.0415884405,
0.0565198846,
0.0402808972,
0.0062594013,
0.0150829013,
-0.0103206094,
0.0235834718,
-0.0242759231,
-0.0282492489,
0.0158908609,
0.0568638407,
0.0468407497,
-0.0482099354,
-0.0041877031,
0.0175145101,
-0.0699652135,
0.0200156681,
0.0274809562,
0.0016274187,
0.0295549929,
0.0438371673,
-0.0419197716,
-0.029101545,
-0.0439661145,
0.0001086808,
-0.0296056308,
-0.0094524724,
0.0293249097,
0.0654057562,
-0.028445527,
-0.009519361,
0.0116943633,
-0.0355493203,
-0.0435143225,
0.0355081819,
-0.0007884345,
0.0177860074,
-0.0072501092,
0.0318602398,
-0.1022277102,
-0.0173990354,
0.0144499633,
-0.0432122461,
-0.0162365679,
0.0018312287,
0.0528127365,
0.0065055289,
-0.0562276952,
0.0082076192,
-0.0320156813,
0.0197014064,
-0.0203847941,
0.0182784125,
0.0270834137,
0.0205468033,
0.0006634039,
0.0216656122,
0.0097419713,
0.0041465373,
-0.0068264767,
0.0141525166,
-0.0036447761,
-0.0235898532,
-0.0382721312,
-0.0008782411,
-0.0120022446,
-0.0308656767,
0.0257938989,
-0.0374491327,
-0.0372219011,
-0.0256598573,
2.852e-7,
0.035626445,
0.061546009,
-0.0513581932,
0.0355545245,
-0.0081269238,
0.0367292874,
-0.009540868,
0.0113949403,
0.0273390636,
-0.0038324175,
0.008140076,
0.0410442725,
0.0380919687,
0.0216083191,
-0.0753797591,
-0.0418895558,
-0.0539097786,
0.0064920885,
-0.0340845399,
-0.0433885232,
0.0274955407,
0.1028213054,
0.0454428829,
0.0009863185,
-0.0141693251,
-0.0271601845,
0.0604421981,
-0.0144111151,
-0.0008513701,
0.0162581299,
0.0366319492,
0.0450520962,
-0.0211282205,
0.0243820604,
-0.0176663641,
0.0296194497,
0.0204015486,
0.0753413439,
-0.0305715278,
0.0111647239,
-0.0171208512,
-0.001410617,
0.0221236087,
-0.0499911718,
0.0397678614,
-0.0361024328,
-0.029310137,
-0.0081467982,
0.0082413014,
-0.0279032011,
0.0253304392,
-0.01990363,
-0.0159044322,
-0.0010505699,
-0.0004049141,
-0.0125448834,
0.0046892846,
-0.1116992831,
-0.0086759245,
0.032898888,
-0.0232888963,
-0.0611309595,
-0.013105941,
0.0495616831,
-0.0301253516,
-0.0697668493,
-0.0158274621,
2.91946328e-34,
0.0459369086,
0.013486105,
0.0139874015,
0.0369958952,
0.0393997207,
-0.0034059589,
-0.0530271791,
-0.0264815222,
0.0271619838,
-0.0835087076,
-0.0362675749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08687v1 | An Eye on Clinical BERT: Investigating Language Model Generalization for Diabetic Eye Disease Phenotyping | 2023-11-15T04:30:20 | 2023-11-15T04:30:20 | Keith Harrigian, Tina Tang, Anthony Gonzales, Cindy X. Cai, Mark Dredze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Diabetic eye disease is a major cause of blindness worldwide. The ability to
monitor relevant clinical trajectories and detect lapses in care is critical to
managing the disease and preventing blindness. Alas, much of the information
necessary to support these goals is found only in the free text of the
electronic medical record. To fill this information gap, we introduce a system
for extracting evidence from clinical text of 19 clinical concepts related to
diabetic eye disease and inferring relevant attributes for each. In developing
this ophthalmology phenotyping system, we are also afforded a unique
opportunity to evaluate the effectiveness of clinical language models at
adapting to new clinical domains. Across multiple training paradigms, we find
that BERT language models pretrained on out-of-distribution clinical data offer
no significant improvement over BERT language models pretrained on non-clinical
data for our domain. Our study tempers recent claims that language models
pretrained on clinical data are necessary for clinical NLP tasks and highlights
the importance of not treating clinical language data as a single homogeneous
domain. | [
0.0400727838,
0.0535772666,
0.0412176363,
-0.0179286934,
-0.0025991455,
0.0272990819,
-0.0272037815,
0.0425860472,
-0.0123950457,
-0.0584459379,
0.0298172645,
-0.0356831551,
0.0141594652,
0.0394434109,
0.0299320668,
-0.0857896581,
0.0144056547,
0.0192646515,
0.0214879513,
0.0229371265,
0.0183761213,
0.0048570419,
-0.0223659985,
0.0487895794,
-0.004709004,
-0.0172010791,
0.045853477,
-0.0204062406,
0.0323483683,
-0.0258179381,
0.0161342509,
0.029862605,
-0.0260663237,
-0.0328850113,
0.0000016143,
-0.0613257997,
-0.0087769832,
0.0328103714,
0.0208150428,
-0.0003095533,
0.0239148941,
-0.1056038216,
0.0090881186,
0.0211479086,
-0.034874808,
-0.0566598922,
0.0473710857,
0.0327473916,
0.036727,
0.0536496378,
-0.0310486276,
0.0051368992,
0.0328829549,
-0.0180770066,
0.0130353216,
-0.0156485494,
0.0603641383,
0.0153073492,
0.0057233111,
-0.0358239897,
0.0216832459,
0.0204764158,
-0.0246558767,
0.0470433794,
0.0108358143,
0.0330383927,
-0.0513360985,
-0.0344882309,
0.0194049664,
0.0598252006,
-0.0078760246,
-0.0178178232,
0.020251425,
0.0290474594,
-0.0113228364,
0.0291177444,
-0.0155486083,
0.0142154228,
-0.0471339747,
0.010408205,
0.011021859,
-0.012081393,
0.0221282169,
0.0019986487,
-0.0497970805,
-0.0219917949,
0.0171321779,
-0.0201146286,
0.0235588104,
-0.0004275643,
-0.0430467762,
-0.0512398966,
0.0310426522,
0.0286228489,
0.0036839356,
0.016700469,
-0.0314447097,
0.0110955089,
0.062166661,
-0.0568363145,
0.045959685,
0.0089836717,
-0.0417467989,
0.0313294418,
-0.0192857217,
-0.0041178432,
-0.0103644663,
0.0364583358,
-0.0381389149,
-0.0057237893,
-0.066291362,
0.0034197844,
-0.0540542118,
0.0044102031,
0.0209804885,
-0.011321526,
-0.0530849732,
0.0069881086,
0.0064272606,
-0.0021374521,
0.0192073025,
0.0334566087,
-0.0335705727,
-0.0098975217,
-0.0046038614,
0.0191842429,
-0.0044602184,
-0.0049666385,
-0.0447654389,
-0.0376753397,
0.0352539346,
0.0058203884,
0.0027672667,
0.0066978638,
0.0269911811,
0.1035204902,
0.0198051669,
-0.0213027336,
-0.0215338934,
-0.0064501902,
-0.0347411372,
0.0189505853,
-0.0261257496,
-0.086854443,
0.0161341764,
0.0276185144,
0.0176184606,
-0.0246887635,
0.0074778325,
0.0164838824,
-0.0248050541,
0.0730482489,
-0.1127238721,
0.0010027153,
0.0101911929,
0.0019387497,
0.0008370911,
0.0452338047,
0.026127046,
-0.0541419089,
0.006470263,
-0.0132292481,
0.0377509557,
0.0494274609,
0.0038846808,
-0.0373764262,
-0.0254769921,
0.0110536609,
-0.0009175288,
0.0550076999,
-0.022440251,
0.0796783194,
-0.0164787304,
-0.0269576702,
-0.0007617566,
0.0700856075,
0.0447089784,
0.0036033257,
0.0186531805,
-0.0276104175,
0.0335520245,
-0.0178122241,
0.018017726,
-0.0616415925,
0.0121195186,
0.0200565085,
-0.0761713237,
-0.0136249447,
-0.0036248846,
-0.0295833703,
-0.0635070279,
-0.0124272136,
-0.0177477766,
-0.0284201559,
0.0547045097,
0.029156236,
-0.013819837,
0.0781188309,
0.0622677058,
-0.0100891963,
-0.0049905865,
-0.029440606,
-0.0501340665,
0.0414927341,
0.0489003286,
-0.06502413,
-0.0434727371,
-0.0096503794,
-0.0134864636,
0.0140939131,
0.0214567073,
-0.040394444,
0.0294885244,
-0.0369974412,
0.010885777,
0.0370847993,
0.0375462286,
-0.0267045405,
-0.0294267964,
0.0220402461,
-0.018243758,
-0.0505085364,
-0.0501480699,
0.0672349781,
-0.0206895694,
-0.0303488187,
0.0047780247,
-0.0073607615,
-0.0206503533,
0.0086393775,
-0.0339078903,
0.0258045588,
-0.0067969877,
-0.050294552,
-0.0220133141,
0.0060962969,
-0.0123151634,
-0.0265191868,
0.0260014534,
-0.0642642304,
0.0023947319,
-0.0461949296,
-0.0318683349,
-0.0004095182,
-0.028092904,
-0.0481587239,
0.0692697614,
0.0086155748,
0.0263621714,
0.0151590183,
-0.0229672007,
-0.0559176393,
0.0264668353,
-0.0049134232,
-0.0198565237,
-0.0018337723,
-0.0550044067,
0.0467378944,
0.0073852153,
-0.012706426,
0.0145845804,
-0.0177233741,
0.021208087,
-0.0126479818,
0.0110554369,
-0.0199059099,
-0.0171441622,
-0.1184720621,
-0.011894037,
0.0041213906,
0.0184496697,
0.0489203855,
0.0351956226,
-0.0006946377,
-0.0431887656,
-0.0268146824,
-0.0367549136,
-0.013206875,
0.0260900371,
0.0611558594,
0.0707691312,
0.0101462696,
-0.0268403329,
-0.0067673698,
-0.0616203956,
0.0437142402,
0.0247541163,
-0.0430168621,
-0.0375493541,
0.000832281,
-0.0388618112,
0.0408315212,
0.0267412942,
-0.0030574522,
0.0250397455,
-0.0122872656,
0.0114969909,
0.0295658875,
0.0002241727,
0.0276491456,
0.0183389559,
-0.0037852719,
-0.0248562284,
-0.0134940706,
-0.0297783129,
-0.0191186927,
-0.0197050832,
-0.0687566474,
0.024112422,
0.0780232921,
0.022317417,
-0.0112912506,
-0.0521252304,
-0.0102839507,
-0.0482606292,
0.0368350707,
-0.0746442378,
0.0228821915,
-0.0155623062,
0.0438908786,
-0.0056069172,
-0.04373689,
0.1176470518,
-0.0067662317,
0.0491608977,
-0.0698580295,
-0.0041847853,
-0.0276999399,
0.0116872936,
-0.0108460728,
0.0085097905,
0.0486830808,
-0.0413520671,
0.0139993755,
0.0087251086,
-0.0058273873,
-0.0257127993,
0.1173583046,
-0.0391011089,
0.036679253,
0.0100059425,
-0.0259705018,
-0.0397650078,
-0.0154197924,
-0.0213741101,
0.0073260772,
-0.0370222665,
0.0072387625,
-0.0924683288,
0.054938022,
-0.0218975022,
0.0783594996,
0.0349036492,
-0.0294442978,
0.0091994526,
-0.0149996225,
0.037004225,
-0.0505326502,
-0.0538395271,
-0.0260767993,
-0.0016267744,
0.0400464498,
-0.0011854463,
0.0286434144,
-0.0259942766,
0.0021950491,
-0.0059973262,
-0.0622843206,
-0.0167943966,
-0.0077278046,
-0.003146068,
-0.0343330204,
0.006725823,
0.1053263023,
0.0411585905,
-0.0609458126,
0.0348870121,
-0.0006718369,
-0.0237968192,
-0.0278299339,
0.0064373915,
-0.1033240035,
-0.0413989052,
-0.0180554129,
0.0385820232,
0.0197670776,
-0.0235336181,
0.0127135608,
-0.0090074083,
-0.0216168612,
0.0045136171,
-0.0133487051,
-0.0393437892,
-0.0273860116,
0.0093907639,
-0.0572260469,
-0.0100722481,
-0.0224776063,
-0.0426112898,
0.0286290292,
0.028072359,
-0.0877899453,
-0.0702186078,
0.0267994553,
-0.0149539579,
0.00223363,
0.0683924407,
0.0205399673,
0.007372688,
-0.0024388076,
-0.0109733334,
-0.0499457531,
-0.0029562367,
-0.011628462,
0.1099542826,
-0.0032512748,
-0.0269566998,
-0.0047667692,
0.002577008,
-0.0572858267,
-0.030826224,
-0.0118224435,
0.0437859371,
-0.0188711639,
-0.0320307203,
-0.0304042101,
-0.0076460098,
0.0060974113,
0.034492515,
-0.011389602,
-0.0187696386,
-0.0032464974,
-0.0075226268,
0.0155816302,
0.0066093723,
-0.0188680533,
0.0164857917,
-0.0077411593,
-0.0269086715,
-0.060372252,
-0.0286011752,
0.0440583788,
0.0141599448,
0.0456117205,
-0.0034160123,
0.050928507,
-0.0127846804,
-0.0661201924,
0.0908952057,
0.0551103018,
-0.0037856149,
-0.0523917191,
-0.0801543966,
0.0566055365,
0.0133014601,
-0.0300975963,
-0.0007626093,
0.0116779571,
-0.0226344243,
0.0151210465,
0.0334195495,
0.0323854722,
0.0021290288,
-0.0077079395,
-0.0378758498,
0.0176450294,
0.0374430753,
0.0288033169,
-0.0375648215,
0.0112575199,
0.0092589799,
0.0264129452,
0.0193854049,
-0.0281863399,
0.0124151018,
-0.0151624903,
0.0072566723,
-0.0252178479,
0.0099816844,
0.0364866182,
0.0204358436,
0.0573733859,
-0.0138180777,
-0.0408783704,
-0.0359988697,
-0.0132567547,
-0.0152970646,
0.0015928801,
-0.0480949096,
0.0519209243,
0.0315555111,
0.0273718834,
-0.0311172716,
0.0039619645,
-0.0584729575,
-0.0630059466,
-0.0569896325,
0.0539936945,
0.0464431085,
0.0018519656,
0.0464850925,
-0.0355769545,
0.010698312,
-0.0038828482,
-0.0207281411,
0.0024328262,
-0.0233771354,
0.0459518582,
0.0114139337,
0.0584081113,
0.0049652182,
0.0292262249,
-0.020886194,
-0.0176257156,
-0.0418427102,
0.0452961065,
0.0214589424,
-0.0204126816,
0.0389200039,
-0.0243963599,
-0.0017730272,
-0.0158210434,
0.0291465539,
-0.0088185621,
0.0194742195,
0.0419555232,
0.0223684628,
-0.0383727886,
-0.0463556573,
0.0970589817,
0.0113665126,
0.0549667366,
-0.0062345085,
-0.0330746658,
-0.0504838377,
0.0192359295,
0.0650741979,
-0.0387576558,
-0.0737593397,
0.0210350156,
-0.0506302863,
-0.0578127317,
0.0357954651,
-0.0129027367,
-0.0047825444,
0.0278055314,
0.0452753715,
0.0592796467,
0.0281362794,
-0.0027480205,
-0.0185418706,
0.0133217871,
0.0099864993,
-0.0139562404,
0.0010871005,
-5.005553962e-33,
0.0062333378,
-0.008276944,
0.0128369108,
-0.0046877516,
0.0309198424,
0.0499743894,
-0.0103976959,
0.0004684149,
-0.0195467155,
0.0667484626,
0.0016248082,
0.006635779,
0.0198902879,
0.0292697195,
-0.0044613113,
-0.0282322839,
0.0061348015,
0.0277194511,
-0.0203034095,
-0.0127182622,
-0.0205225088,
0.0824929252,
0.0860314965,
-0.0559627116,
0.0211681146,
0.0238702651,
0.0157052185,
0.0049363808,
0.0345535018,
0.0654666275,
-0.0479721166,
0.0657878444,
0.0407223441,
0.0515342914,
-0.0143552106,
0.0105946586,
-0.0707270056,
-0.0264736358,
0.0258544311,
-0.0072295093,
-0.0608434342,
0.016149912,
0.040145535,
-0.0242368076,
-0.0210625567,
0.0202878546,
0.0495018214,
-0.0497580394,
-0.0264962725,
0.007346245,
-0.0681867227,
0.0559749082,
0.0277846586,
-0.0020726577,
-0.002301574,
0.0251105931,
-0.012170732,
0.0077325311,
0.0069158068,
-0.0169213302,
0.0463083833,
0.0304450523,
-0.0036275345,
-0.0035632399,
-0.0294875838,
0.0573054627,
0.0069624376,
-0.0333038867,
-0.0164666511,
-0.0180956852,
-0.020724088,
0.0197245572,
0.0438780338,
0.0089934086,
0.0091971578,
-0.0116840629,
-0.0733877718,
0.0204139873,
-0.0469368584,
0.0258920379,
-0.000584822,
-0.0254004505,
-0.046151612,
-0.0081673209,
-0.0128841782,
0.025558969,
-0.0272486154,
0.000033453,
0.0228799731,
-0.0058711092,
0.0030651095,
0.0498971008,
-0.0194525719,
-0.0169191193,
-0.009854286,
-0.006678313,
0.0318034329,
0.0034709517,
-0.0497812144,
0.0117061799,
-0.0507586971,
-0.0507875793,
0.021839153,
0.0188831799,
0.0440118425,
0.0041496539,
0.0323337913,
-0.0341428071,
-0.0497180596,
-0.0057237484,
0.0165098831,
-0.0018288322,
-0.0143028852,
0.0685184523,
0.0337492973,
0.0284363665,
-0.0103198551,
0.063140668,
0.0030922431,
-0.0409490243,
-0.0352665037,
0.0011210114,
0.0108804479,
0.0046149432,
-0.0227180552,
-0.0197465457,
-0.0300121699,
0.0534032844,
0.0064745178,
-0.020653367,
-0.025590308,
-0.0053823744,
2.386e-7,
0.1349400282,
0.0693317577,
0.0255324189,
0.0040710168,
0.011528275,
0.0112039112,
0.0037287655,
0.0243879203,
-0.0133999847,
-0.0098666577,
0.0084646577,
-0.0140891699,
0.0276181996,
0.0184758026,
-0.0402546227,
-0.0438359901,
-0.0650607347,
-0.0322376005,
-0.024081409,
-0.0012022242,
0.04744789,
0.0933640003,
-0.0443289354,
-0.0296813287,
0.0259277113,
-0.059624888,
0.0349517129,
-0.0267174542,
0.0153338229,
0.0770248622,
0.0271549914,
0.0082671484,
0.0383471958,
0.0623498484,
-0.0202659834,
-0.0363596007,
0.0186208412,
0.0658615828,
-0.0636488944,
0.0244875252,
0.0251059514,
-0.0174764413,
0.0142453387,
-0.0644533858,
0.0296894871,
-0.0635157228,
-0.0415987559,
0.0079259118,
-0.0005934901,
0.0029786464,
0.0341339409,
-0.0263590552,
-0.051860556,
0.0401844308,
0.0363031439,
0.0274532549,
-0.0671483427,
-0.0782675222,
-0.0447399765,
0.0147206029,
-0.009379454,
-0.0079838503,
0.0422851928,
-0.0387823097,
-0.0049899234,
-0.0830408782,
0.0268306769,
2.0639952e-34,
0.0625784099,
0.0179691575,
-0.0013695245,
0.019719556,
0.0172556173,
-0.0230993144,
0.0116301784,
-0.0004736501,
-0.0023588922,
-0.0297251567,
-0.0177877992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08685v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08685v3 | Safer-Instruct: Aligning Language Models with Automated Preference Data | 2023-11-15T04:22:22 | 2024-03-31T22:42:03 | Taiwei Shi, Kai Chen, Jieyu Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a vital strategy for
enhancing model capability in language models. However, annotating preference
data for RLHF is a resource-intensive and creativity-demanding process, while
existing automatic generation methods face limitations in data diversity and
quality. In response, we present Safer-Instruct, a novel pipeline for
automatically constructing large-scale preference data. Our approach leverages
reversed instruction tuning, instruction induction, and expert model evaluation
to efficiently generate high-quality preference data without human annotators.
To verify the effectiveness of Safer-Instruct, we apply the pipeline to
construct a safety preference dataset as a case study. Finetuning an Alpaca
model on this synthetic dataset not only demonstrates improved harmlessness but
also outperforms models fine-tuned on human-annotated safety preference data,
all the while maintaining a competitive edge in downstream tasks. Importantly,
our Safer-Instruct framework is versatile and can be applied to generate
preference data across various domains, extending its utility beyond safety
preferences. It addresses the challenges in preference data acquisition and
advances the development of more capable and responsible AI systems. For
dataset and code implementation, see
https://github.com/uscnlp-lime/safer-instruct | [
0.0149566699,
0.0948887393,
-0.0395440236,
0.0205019619,
-0.01254596,
0.0180115551,
-0.042824138,
-0.03805352,
-0.0029989223,
-0.0192832984,
-0.0265125614,
-0.014737526,
-0.0208636224,
0.0386765935,
0.0157382973,
-0.0333866626,
0.0567307733,
-0.0743519217,
0.023575265,
-0.0036207174,
0.0071062734,
0.0296027847,
-0.0047921007,
0.057196565,
-0.0096565476,
0.0008238335,
-0.0144730462,
-0.001000151,
0.0242362451,
-0.0311734583,
0.0509608835,
0.0669649988,
0.0279812645,
0.0083450107,
0.0000022334,
-0.0205093604,
-0.0120504787,
-0.0001004268,
0.0048438986,
-0.0137062855,
0.0417164303,
0.0029684175,
-0.0464083403,
0.008851191,
-0.0209076144,
0.0029220101,
0.0744282156,
-0.0101490952,
0.0641645789,
0.06410487,
-0.0024636944,
-0.0086187543,
0.0104059111,
-0.0075265057,
0.0275602005,
-0.0033027136,
0.0216306355,
-0.0139108673,
0.0292065851,
0.0149011221,
0.0055090268,
-0.0038443559,
0.0323076881,
-0.0302567407,
-0.0049032569,
0.0168130454,
0.0028904025,
-0.0688952506,
-0.0255645458,
0.0944205299,
-0.0344683379,
-0.0334630348,
-0.017212268,
-0.0233941432,
-0.0057140994,
-0.009289979,
-0.0106644733,
0.0465986356,
-0.0040070405,
0.0291311871,
0.0519163199,
0.0170393102,
0.0114549315,
0.013036116,
-0.0014377735,
0.0943041369,
0.013426993,
-0.0065261726,
0.0189953838,
0.0047627636,
-0.0075738658,
-0.0490571223,
0.0291393772,
-0.011708336,
-0.0630078241,
0.0126945535,
-0.0502227508,
-0.0046818829,
0.0552808084,
-0.0428407751,
0.0725666285,
0.0218449328,
-0.03517152,
0.0139431329,
0.0012702635,
0.0078272317,
-0.008143859,
0.0339994431,
-0.0161366593,
0.0329390317,
-0.0095803104,
0.0096877273,
-0.0278816205,
0.0103157917,
-0.0193026625,
0.0526818745,
-0.0342331454,
0.0357400142,
-0.0496949144,
0.0333472006,
0.0031459152,
0.0091747912,
-0.0529713258,
0.0167981889,
-0.0385639071,
0.0050857686,
-0.0667271391,
0.0179857537,
0.0189243145,
-0.0312645324,
0.0086809825,
0.005179978,
-0.0339869,
-0.0382580906,
0.0219398998,
0.1085237265,
-0.0055514365,
-0.008768023,
-0.0203660317,
-0.0273210723,
0.0032157653,
-0.0518167615,
-0.0117586125,
-0.0866116732,
0.0292958841,
-0.0070427237,
-0.0171589702,
-0.0785126537,
0.0147067904,
0.0244233552,
-0.0273739304,
0.0780538246,
-0.0467312261,
-0.0023058644,
-0.0219625086,
-0.0045268065,
-0.0225228667,
0.0653279871,
0.0453193337,
0.0777769387,
0.0246783346,
0.0012828141,
0.0202131458,
0.034073934,
0.0005950513,
0.0208630916,
-0.0541646145,
0.0139921485,
0.0066057579,
0.0046397708,
0.032699734,
0.0613292493,
-0.0171699058,
-0.0160585307,
0.0760468766,
0.0174121074,
-0.032087706,
0.0040327981,
0.0616042688,
0.039837867,
-0.0076276856,
-0.010200575,
-0.0388803706,
0.0402115472,
-0.0402328074,
-0.0138194012,
-0.0267407969,
0.0377295129,
0.01184035,
-0.0535208918,
0.0148669481,
-0.0230887793,
0.0430135168,
0.0191662051,
0.0423744433,
0.0255673025,
-0.0386901684,
-0.0220091026,
0.0613752007,
-0.0486300513,
-0.0256665889,
-0.0340836272,
0.0592114143,
0.1275499165,
0.0320015475,
-0.0236113742,
-0.0528204218,
-0.0299147796,
-0.0378212444,
0.0121516464,
0.0326781161,
-0.0535735339,
-0.0019304038,
-0.0466570333,
-0.0167736392,
0.0173255876,
0.020087542,
0.0357479639,
0.0426269807,
-0.021568086,
-0.0143246409,
-0.0094515923,
-0.0797948986,
0.0448468812,
-0.0280658379,
-0.0254902355,
0.0070407409,
0.0099497568,
0.0236708336,
-0.0024682274,
-0.0207292028,
0.0011859057,
0.0561235063,
0.0160397328,
0.006924903,
-0.014691609,
-0.03992882,
0.0228235461,
0.0383497402,
-0.0260770451,
-0.0451418497,
0.0294399261,
-0.0235815514,
0.0081239529,
-0.030962836,
-0.0384914279,
0.0228002202,
-0.0214318782,
0.0243993364,
-0.0111879688,
-0.0275345948,
-0.0506513305,
0.035565,
-0.006307269,
-0.0190099031,
0.0088408301,
-0.0024644516,
-0.0057345056,
-0.03511158,
-0.0338837877,
0.0094390763,
-0.0126518179,
0.0507968888,
0.043947354,
0.0672742203,
-0.0300630387,
-0.0200543161,
-0.0355856642,
-0.0086907772,
-0.0179736633,
-0.0037327763,
-0.0010419745,
-0.0162445717,
-0.0184229333,
-0.0072857034,
-0.0045991135,
-0.0238103829,
-0.0436765924,
0.0399280973,
0.0152098332,
0.0017370241,
-0.0469903499,
-0.0540856645,
-0.0127511853,
-0.0233613476,
0.0083460035,
-0.0051049567,
0.003273298,
-0.0288171284,
0.0086805886,
-0.0133114597,
0.0403602161,
-0.0129433963,
-0.0655453131,
0.0424281061,
-0.0224377178,
0.0159415435,
0.0513044037,
0.0101122772,
0.0347002074,
0.1042353511,
0.0138172787,
-0.069623366,
0.0189065374,
-0.0317027234,
-0.0167405568,
-0.0142758638,
-0.0171166211,
-0.0273448769,
0.0715428591,
-0.0284384079,
-0.0170769598,
-0.0496097989,
0.027136134,
0.0026510672,
-0.0438045524,
-0.0127961645,
-0.0352958739,
-0.0109973177,
0.088310495,
-0.0267846696,
-0.0654429421,
0.1031199843,
0.0012827957,
0.0096984329,
-0.0497843996,
-0.008296933,
0.0145089803,
0.041710332,
0.0188254565,
0.0252771974,
0.0209390447,
0.0264645182,
-0.0404401384,
-0.0057798885,
0.0282853227,
-0.0351296365,
0.0057152538,
-0.0631641299,
0.0084576048,
0.0058039827,
-0.0578900352,
-0.0775716081,
-0.0297628436,
-0.0193154886,
-0.0159481801,
0.0483768955,
-0.040999908,
0.0222971104,
-0.0165655315,
0.0228645019,
0.0159981828,
-0.0076605272,
0.0041691712,
-0.0149940252,
-0.0274142697,
0.0659021884,
-0.0427764617,
0.0078371726,
-0.0136023266,
0.0138406735,
0.0565474257,
0.0171417799,
0.0013537481,
-0.0372797288,
0.0341591351,
0.0397537611,
-0.0096479198,
0.0054035624,
0.0527542271,
0.0300012957,
-0.0505034029,
-0.0249749813,
0.0582129546,
0.0341346599,
-0.0402736478,
0.0348865464,
0.00591454,
0.0819897428,
0.0231561475,
0.0501093566,
-0.0652196407,
-0.0101655014,
0.0226585139,
0.0516957901,
-0.0079558715,
-0.0184583794,
0.0256334022,
-0.116655767,
0.0434885025,
-0.0003025239,
-0.0663281605,
-0.0107199959,
-0.0369813479,
-0.0077405809,
-0.0394561887,
0.0128903082,
0.0271662418,
-0.0004841725,
-0.0112273898,
0.0178342629,
0.0281170532,
-0.0465788767,
0.0310844611,
-0.0337799378,
0.0900331736,
0.1008378118,
-0.0058032395,
-0.0031472321,
-0.0327969007,
0.0021784182,
0.0506473593,
-0.0327046514,
-0.001143867,
0.0264716726,
-0.0125841266,
-0.0175111275,
0.0023938771,
0.0419014655,
-0.0188134238,
-0.0340059139,
0.0107700853,
0.0667586029,
-0.0036954142,
-0.0024250518,
-0.0379006788,
0.013227419,
0.0423855744,
0.0584085099,
0.0198690966,
-0.0730852783,
-0.012320823,
-0.0602537952,
-0.0546907857,
-0.0958909616,
-0.058763098,
0.0033100799,
-0.0178063586,
-0.0623881817,
-0.0714989826,
-0.03381164,
0.0519613624,
0.0061798454,
0.0377758108,
-0.047100842,
0.0434434079,
-0.00062612,
-0.0443482213,
0.0506030247,
-0.0142578017,
0.0086678695,
-0.0595497079,
-0.0574474297,
0.0222580694,
-0.0319488421,
-0.0123130037,
0.0543765426,
-0.0219676569,
-0.0802861154,
0.0408177786,
0.1211857572,
0.0187988244,
0.0218965728,
-0.0231548678,
-0.0506905019,
0.0619618222,
0.0645206422,
-0.0549736433,
-0.0522939004,
0.0528461821,
-0.0216628257,
0.0077337208,
0.0142782032,
-0.0250223,
0.0266730934,
0.0088265352,
0.025843868,
-0.02726762,
-0.0299146734,
0.0541333184,
-0.0046622679,
0.0031048006,
-0.0541474409,
0.0127939256,
-0.0407645702,
-0.0033261338,
-0.0228990857,
-0.0456926227,
-0.0381960273,
0.0184426047,
0.0095736263,
-0.0300150625,
-0.0072161662,
-0.0529378913,
-0.0227050632,
0.0411793701,
-0.0137345586,
0.0175586846,
0.0488922931,
0.0671268627,
0.0577206723,
0.0062966575,
-0.005656526,
0.0145421838,
-0.013626988,
0.0571163706,
-0.004592583,
0.0094996626,
0.0077725025,
-0.0004812827,
-0.0123310136,
0.0399832875,
0.0063652978,
-0.0457172655,
-0.0685288683,
0.0215865448,
0.0422074571,
-0.0240619034,
0.0574517883,
-0.0404074974,
-0.0092295157,
-0.0262827687,
0.0291811023,
-0.0057924138,
-0.0431923307,
-0.0202365033,
0.0358380005,
-0.0200051162,
-0.0325853229,
0.0750212073,
0.0177659001,
0.0575556457,
-0.0096277688,
0.0026258458,
-0.0329622887,
-0.016787922,
-0.0000104482,
0.0212396234,
-0.0398086384,
-0.031362921,
-0.0538423806,
-0.0778449699,
-0.0404458977,
0.043089278,
0.0064899526,
0.0409227535,
0.0405770391,
0.0184676517,
-0.0155928321,
0.0029353891,
-0.0360537097,
-0.0349000655,
-0.0028419863,
-0.0276634768,
-0.0596609861,
-6.449755301e-33,
-0.0287269186,
-0.0297431257,
0.0124865575,
-0.0330079943,
0.0356201045,
-0.0499271639,
-0.0052226172,
0.0130325099,
0.0061787684,
0.0186212268,
-0.0152146639,
-0.036760129,
0.0090249237,
0.0054321466,
0.0592356846,
0.0051338947,
0.0212739129,
-0.0102755791,
-0.0261445586,
0.0184440669,
0.0201945323,
0.0017684525,
0.0355238765,
-0.106188409,
0.021972945,
0.0138710821,
-0.0501419976,
0.0028484587,
-0.0741199553,
0.0748798698,
0.0154837715,
0.031277135,
-0.0177516751,
-0.0415068567,
-0.0326345973,
0.0120836543,
-0.0453294627,
-0.0296299309,
0.0098973541,
-0.0194361378,
-0.0246888772,
-0.0559364818,
0.0310852248,
-0.0232631993,
-0.001201489,
0.0326984711,
0.0276113674,
-0.0370883197,
0.0007669977,
0.0062451768,
-0.0869486183,
-0.0045605022,
-0.0144984024,
-0.0492267422,
0.0168415941,
0.0506746732,
0.0165058188,
0.0045422637,
-0.0181130897,
0.0598923862,
0.0389410518,
0.0160559714,
0.0702385679,
-0.008155941,
-0.0059255986,
0.0413393714,
0.026826635,
0.005644287,
0.0265110806,
-0.0064007873,
0.0102686873,
0.0656309798,
0.0165660735,
0.0358903259,
0.0224159621,
-0.0230433028,
-0.0261392072,
0.049523294,
0.0167469252,
0.0236500967,
0.0397400558,
0.0185578801,
-0.0625891984,
-0.0177459959,
-0.0402254909,
-0.0301204231,
-0.0190233644,
-0.028821487,
0.0237808935,
0.0087985247,
-0.0792400017,
-0.0016575195,
0.000410749,
-0.0167415123,
-0.0070121009,
-0.00291153,
-0.0520198047,
0.0079338383,
-0.000775734,
-0.0021473621,
-0.0129499622,
-0.0408436209,
0.0297923703,
-0.0397753045,
0.0319036953,
0.0264585335,
0.0593962297,
0.0324454159,
-0.0558200367,
0.0181975309,
-0.0501203872,
0.0427314676,
0.0318476111,
0.0126525601,
0.0336115398,
-0.0036838243,
-0.0139980223,
0.0335422456,
0.0280040372,
0.0076494333,
-0.0605546236,
-0.0174458846,
-0.0356317684,
0.0180627871,
-0.0129676433,
0.0052571995,
-0.0362800956,
0.0060432339,
0.0050462442,
-0.0291549508,
-0.0012100554,
-0.0220991485,
2.882e-7,
0.0122058811,
0.0704062805,
0.0322638787,
0.0464056879,
-0.0179626364,
0.0585128106,
-0.014070956,
0.0100880144,
0.0207897052,
-0.0008360038,
0.0198282395,
0.026220385,
0.0305209197,
0.0658523068,
-0.0663813651,
-0.0378169939,
-0.0329416655,
0.0164116435,
-0.0566720851,
-0.051451955,
0.030495692,
0.072755143,
0.0368216261,
-0.0148363579,
0.0157684088,
0.0413545109,
0.0028172622,
-0.0613375455,
-0.0006188016,
0.0067481883,
-0.0016970985,
0.0361438021,
-0.0128439534,
0.0068533579,
-0.0156862549,
-0.0243599676,
-0.0370482914,
0.0676400587,
-0.010866018,
-0.0421690978,
0.0288169608,
-0.0150543731,
0.0109812133,
-0.0537902676,
0.0428893231,
-0.0274460241,
0.0119942557,
-0.0305042639,
-0.0247007962,
-0.0015456355,
0.0042428165,
-0.0601704903,
-0.004551284,
0.0007442011,
0.013563714,
0.017559208,
-0.0309571028,
-0.0356743783,
-0.0190830268,
0.0158421453,
-0.016668262,
-0.0485641249,
-0.0239429753,
0.0388345867,
-0.0135806538,
-0.0599062964,
0.0293067098,
2.721919617e-34,
0.0228137765,
-0.0139654595,
0.030720491,
0.0074871746,
0.045824714,
0.0196088161,
0.0023538107,
0.0208799765,
0.0274793506,
0.0029903201,
-0.0388148502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08669v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08669v2 | On the Calibration of Multilingual Question Answering LLMs | 2023-11-15T03:29:02 | 2024-04-15T14:44:04 | Yahan Yang, Soham Dan, Dan Roth, Insup Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Multilingual pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) are incredibly
effective at Question Answering (QA), a core task in Natural Language
Understanding, achieving high accuracies on several multilingual benchmarks.
However, little is known about how well their confidences are calibrated. In
this paper, we comprehensively benchmark the calibration of several
multilingual LLMs (MLLMs) on a variety of QA tasks. We perform extensive
experiments, spanning encoder-only, encoder-decoder, and decoder-only QA models
(size varying from 110M to 7B parameters) and diverse languages, including both
high- and low-resource ones. We study different dimensions of calibration in
in-distribution, out-of-distribution, and cross-lingual transfer settings, and
investigate strategies to improve it, including post-hoc methods and
regularized fine-tuning. For decoder-only LLMs such as LlaMa2, we additionally
find that in-context learning improves confidence calibration on multilingual
data. We also conduct several ablation experiments to study the effect of
language distances, language corpus size, and model size on calibration, and
how multilingual models compare with their monolingual counterparts for diverse
tasks and languages. Our experiments suggest that the multilingual QA models
are poorly calibrated for languages other than English and incorporating a
small set of cheaply translated multilingual samples during
fine-tuning/calibration effectively enhances the calibration performance. | [
0.0153218368,
0.0437775925,
0.0052651754,
0.0771284699,
0.0011703753,
0.0249327943,
0.0072631729,
-0.0223426316,
-0.0388619937,
-0.0200569481,
-0.0807877257,
-0.0575080179,
0.0104750702,
-0.022757329,
0.0053143455,
0.0062899268,
0.0316907242,
-0.0575890467,
-0.0140572693,
-0.0331967622,
0.0040809466,
0.0112400716,
0.0029343583,
-0.0013320339,
0.0199455842,
-0.0238339137,
0.0095844492,
-0.0000427022,
0.0243174247,
-0.0078718429,
0.0292185917,
0.0266206488,
0.0169072207,
0.0118035991,
0.0000019596,
-0.0726677701,
0.0150053501,
-0.0154815568,
-0.0274325516,
0.0371651873,
-0.0105679817,
-0.0494610704,
0.0305993296,
0.0222748611,
-0.0347689576,
0.0122782178,
0.0483064912,
-0.0250434075,
0.0401825048,
0.0520561263,
0.0214223359,
-0.0325964205,
0.0386839658,
-0.0116462754,
-0.0128195649,
-0.0840434581,
0.0144856935,
0.0410383046,
-0.032391075,
-0.0021126547,
-0.0398896374,
0.046925135,
0.0420229211,
0.0230091605,
-0.0320668779,
0.0079208026,
-0.0182928331,
-0.0138670765,
-0.0131213106,
0.065393284,
-0.0203185435,
-0.035750594,
-0.0608437099,
-0.0102325268,
-0.0300653968,
-0.0437567011,
-0.047907304,
0.0329862647,
0.0189421438,
0.0231049098,
0.0205045808,
0.0046815071,
0.031620156,
0.0183440521,
-0.009618951,
0.0682154298,
0.0178348254,
-0.0199339017,
0.0097974883,
0.0373611525,
-0.009497419,
-0.0411652923,
0.018847743,
0.068780221,
-0.031104207,
0.0308120269,
-0.0185363628,
-0.0264393035,
0.0371129625,
-0.0462142043,
0.0167036559,
0.0385525413,
-0.0289544966,
0.0510313064,
-0.0103664082,
0.0696543977,
-0.0314734839,
0.0269946512,
-0.0762944743,
-0.0735311061,
0.0139632476,
-0.0179879051,
-0.0063011735,
0.0061576115,
-0.02488661,
0.0095204487,
-0.0396393612,
0.0180968586,
0.0299192723,
-0.0198054444,
-0.0205667522,
0.0076669431,
-0.0150755253,
-0.0147619629,
-0.0279496778,
0.075394012,
-0.0627714396,
0.0238596164,
-0.0038802586,
-0.0858505294,
-0.0346434563,
0.0191648677,
-0.0013374514,
-0.052565109,
0.0535312146,
0.0316551886,
-0.0261093769,
-0.0491130501,
0.003629565,
0.0019537339,
-0.0046902741,
-0.0880210251,
0.0070994492,
-0.0692238957,
0.0636369064,
0.0329659395,
0.0153737655,
-0.0299534537,
0.0057051075,
0.010903744,
0.0000783604,
0.0473024771,
0.0010246915,
0.0206248704,
0.0243470874,
-0.0198459178,
0.0286817569,
0.0906227678,
0.0298537835,
-0.0231847968,
0.0692103654,
-0.0200936552,
-0.0006070886,
0.0649540722,
0.0110260323,
0.0157314632,
0.003130333,
0.0656438172,
0.0228773076,
0.0153732914,
0.0602524318,
0.0167918298,
-0.0216797534,
-0.0043079313,
0.0314951986,
0.0358123854,
-0.0243250001,
-0.0074087265,
0.0077806395,
-0.032898318,
0.0303083919,
-0.0045249108,
-0.0205233674,
0.0437219813,
-0.0352052487,
-0.0047329273,
0.0388125442,
0.0504162014,
-0.057673458,
-0.0357570946,
-0.0016355264,
-0.0321583152,
-0.0106743658,
0.0557404421,
0.0333596542,
0.0000376382,
-0.0182203036,
0.0661736652,
0.0285255183,
-0.0186086744,
0.033005137,
-0.0254456047,
0.033522021,
0.0306383539,
0.0018301691,
0.0046585454,
-0.0317828208,
-0.0038485785,
0.0388450809,
0.0308316778,
0.0333996899,
-0.0178562962,
0.0660984963,
-0.0500668548,
-0.0111795356,
-0.0534712486,
-0.0205124468,
0.0352925695,
0.006469985,
0.0500476956,
0.0047678985,
-0.0815296993,
0.0181316324,
0.0172156189,
-0.0548866354,
-0.0377167873,
0.0051282803,
-0.003370479,
0.0164219271,
0.0085474541,
-0.0043126871,
0.0008121199,
0.0312812328,
-0.0447171368,
0.0192981437,
0.0014662233,
-0.0445472077,
-0.0454380885,
0.0472538993,
-0.0033364454,
-0.0314399973,
0.0427817963,
-0.0412076861,
-0.0391895063,
-0.0142200077,
-0.0117413839,
0.0008864397,
-0.0541164316,
-0.0003798588,
-0.0374569744,
0.0504221022,
-0.0353957713,
0.0204127226,
0.0035619505,
0.0543440804,
0.0093293255,
-0.0008898512,
0.057819929,
-0.0288359597,
-0.0350485407,
0.0249143969,
-0.01719293,
0.0110445516,
0.0299012847,
0.0438294932,
-0.0316521898,
0.0040711677,
-0.069358252,
0.026910929,
-0.0390010551,
0.0400737561,
0.0446710885,
0.0207381472,
-0.0106310109,
-0.0239373557,
-0.0751240477,
-0.0047438061,
0.0572877191,
0.0383773074,
0.0204352364,
-0.0091857696,
0.0163039509,
-0.0445708185,
-0.0202844795,
0.0146991583,
0.052708663,
0.0036000879,
-0.00823991,
-0.060994707,
0.0019404622,
-0.0465036035,
0.0044272821,
-0.00159863,
-0.0704779699,
-0.0041834647,
0.0238433983,
0.0061676921,
0.0669185519,
-0.0193602368,
-0.0363389626,
0.0656412765,
0.026122164,
-0.0578923635,
0.0188198127,
0.0005996487,
-0.0718116611,
-0.0704786405,
-0.0157289673,
0.009223884,
0.060760729,
8.782e-7,
-0.0131717231,
-0.0245520175,
0.0020093808,
-0.0041351039,
-0.032422632,
-0.036014393,
0.0257917959,
-0.0093919216,
0.0770147592,
-0.0125326682,
-0.0182251316,
0.0531042479,
-0.0391481817,
-0.0283137392,
-0.0570020303,
-0.0065410393,
-0.062358588,
0.0237781145,
-0.0127101438,
0.0189681873,
-0.0383861773,
-0.0068408549,
-0.0433235019,
-0.0236691274,
0.0056806412,
-0.0315589793,
0.0075057,
-0.0200750958,
0.00503445,
-0.0187168606,
-0.0460394919,
-0.04566513,
-0.015737256,
-0.0495757796,
0.00731298,
-0.0078927027,
0.0217987765,
-0.0236341152,
-0.010760528,
0.0389230214,
0.002650205,
-0.0108747175,
0.0212877188,
-0.0210806336,
0.0538905337,
0.0554251783,
0.0461296514,
0.0313993692,
-0.0381949358,
0.0289277714,
0.0228636358,
-0.0109094605,
0.0091017671,
-0.0135194082,
0.0048329625,
0.0641716868,
0.0093613723,
-0.0130356448,
0.0161406863,
0.0918158069,
-0.0132034793,
-0.0270970352,
0.1206892058,
0.0327714682,
-0.0367313698,
-0.007712882,
-0.0442277454,
-0.0141143976,
0.0338121243,
0.0335048288,
-0.1015676782,
-0.0476976298,
-0.0277032312,
-0.0058659101,
0.032790307,
0.0015782723,
-0.0051468876,
-0.1404601634,
-0.017683683,
-0.0158036184,
-0.0758896247,
-0.0540863574,
-0.0641752854,
-0.0198980458,
-0.0080981879,
0.0555577651,
0.0044821617,
0.017723348,
-0.0058373702,
0.0318262912,
-0.0036968454,
-0.0602283143,
0.048173286,
-0.0406491943,
0.0093256198,
0.0664375424,
0.0291845482,
-0.0297195055,
-0.0151802571,
0.0297169853,
-0.0458956026,
-0.0180462617,
0.0139857912,
0.0245572478,
0.0225417707,
-0.0166530404,
0.0081018843,
0.002428001,
-0.0620644763,
0.0168612637,
0.0212844629,
0.0790764689,
0.0148244603,
-0.0155551955,
0.0103072235,
-0.012267706,
-0.0162061267,
0.0645558611,
0.0265491325,
-0.0452305488,
-0.0373854637,
-0.0182832778,
-0.0208314657,
-0.0447033644,
0.008912161,
0.048019886,
0.0081220632,
0.0304757487,
-0.0525448658,
-0.0493341126,
0.0234918017,
-0.0045589469,
-0.0082923174,
0.024653608,
-0.0073666708,
-0.012899355,
-0.0146263167,
0.0329458639,
-0.0512822121,
0.0243479908,
-0.0452427231,
0.0234594867,
0.0300530717,
-0.0230881479,
-0.0049086115,
0.0202848502,
-0.1096834615,
-0.0587131977,
-0.0483491048,
0.0569704622,
0.0099475887,
0.034179125,
-0.0207736883,
-0.058730416,
0.0106410114,
-0.0242625512,
-0.0064524217,
0.0373952053,
0.0298753232,
0.0121244676,
-0.0185403079,
0.0572614558,
-0.0485994518,
-0.0084244339,
0.0393668562,
0.046734672,
-0.0279391706,
-0.0693965033,
0.0217708796,
0.032773301,
0.0020042169,
-0.0092117246,
-0.0334524512,
0.002028334,
0.0422429778,
-0.0155650917,
-0.0169403628,
-0.0078252181,
-0.0253272019,
0.0530676693,
-0.0420918204,
0.0017102835,
0.0120102623,
0.0010066207,
0.0193321444,
-0.0234538373,
0.0215171017,
0.0512360483,
-0.0101295775,
0.0181429312,
0.0147974035,
-0.0297804605,
0.0025105146,
0.0291046482,
0.0623553246,
0.0023586773,
0.0307575185,
-0.0072278082,
-0.0012845565,
-0.012709124,
-0.0053209364,
-0.0456931405,
-0.0403238721,
0.002117852,
0.0199323408,
0.0767956525,
-0.0061597247,
0.0573546514,
0.0319488831,
-0.0155571066,
-0.0378597751,
0.0084192352,
-0.0012466256,
-0.0011382356,
0.0865317881,
-0.0054533826,
-0.0061879018,
0.0299619846,
0.0878537893,
-0.0071586971,
0.0539874807,
0.002786376,
0.0133147975,
-0.0036940924,
-0.0098447017,
-0.0262623969,
0.0045456863,
-0.0278852209,
0.0327602588,
0.0111440448,
-0.0717103705,
0.0213511456,
-0.0073755127,
-0.0299276728,
-0.012249602,
0.012323346,
0.0719748065,
0.0074956384,
-0.0156607516,
-0.0190354772,
0.0090200994,
-0.0321833789,
-0.0021168494,
-0.0135588022,
-6.463022224e-33,
-0.0110849552,
-0.0066425344,
0.0267877374,
-0.0311179534,
0.0180814844,
0.0032916937,
-0.0246973615,
0.0099259894,
-0.0742668882,
-0.0048738453,
-0.016823817,
-0.010271878,
0.0136582069,
0.0380379669,
0.0036104312,
-0.0454163589,
-0.0049237278,
-0.0013726605,
-0.0207915641,
-0.0148379486,
0.0051137893,
0.0331361331,
0.0903461576,
0.0004803607,
0.0233770404,
-0.0288295113,
-0.0039307978,
0.0356289893,
-0.013462726,
0.0651781783,
-0.0284969863,
0.0786068439,
0.0212824959,
-0.013510094,
-0.0060095526,
0.0156780723,
-0.08912348,
-0.0483922213,
0.0397834405,
0.0451902598,
-0.0168536473,
-0.0438733846,
-0.0051445975,
-0.004908117,
-0.0169984028,
0.0032332637,
0.0157348197,
-0.0359598771,
0.0057497225,
-0.0239039641,
-0.037341848,
-0.0037467459,
-0.0381568559,
-0.019194534,
-0.0040769475,
0.0684704781,
-0.0182904452,
0.0463244431,
-0.0594502278,
-0.0280299205,
-0.0007599803,
0.0181427225,
0.07794936,
0.0185676981,
-0.0007051417,
0.0034950278,
-0.0079793055,
0.012294149,
0.0304756667,
0.00693051,
0.0036107686,
-0.0224283319,
0.0516129024,
0.1009187326,
0.0387987643,
0.0168493185,
-0.1131521463,
0.0190118942,
-0.0115283253,
0.0281902663,
0.0261474047,
-0.009459083,
0.0029366114,
-0.0131740533,
-0.0782191157,
0.0109528638,
-0.0265345275,
-0.0208331514,
0.0385501608,
-0.0139878234,
0.0103810495,
-0.0194312111,
0.0547117591,
-0.0408532731,
-0.0136305848,
0.049922172,
-0.0095214397,
-0.0023437631,
0.0089427074,
0.0766017437,
-0.0430012792,
-0.0012694548,
-0.0128229242,
-0.0437960029,
0.0008214467,
0.0129659688,
0.0384621546,
-0.0260567255,
-0.0519448854,
0.0157889239,
-0.04030573,
0.0092038,
0.0009317993,
0.0582679994,
0.0028891275,
0.0111243194,
-0.0266227685,
0.0547376908,
0.0089867376,
-0.0036858018,
-0.0071531427,
-0.0612252839,
-0.0112900501,
0.0311744511,
-0.048554197,
0.0108799255,
-0.0455104746,
0.0045344494,
-0.0068839216,
-0.0569312163,
-0.0133237932,
0.0300825406,
2.584e-7,
0.100293465,
0.0173807126,
0.0227720048,
0.0367726572,
0.0024863633,
0.0052074771,
-0.0294627007,
0.0174674932,
0.0251992121,
-0.029600855,
-0.027998317,
0.0536556914,
0.0520767197,
0.0295978654,
-0.056686677,
-0.0093445033,
-0.0524892956,
0.0144663528,
-0.0195352491,
-0.0185776614,
0.0040397523,
0.092907384,
-0.0277026445,
-0.0203397628,
-0.0349538438,
-0.0598081127,
0.0792356804,
-0.0365898907,
-0.0306908302,
0.0321017057,
0.0022790541,
-0.000619358,
0.0318146944,
0.0291176401,
-0.0156219937,
0.0220643599,
0.024060199,
0.0648753345,
0.0044307434,
-0.0557542667,
-0.0089648347,
-0.0098422403,
0.0005749736,
-0.0718206465,
0.1101595461,
-0.0237334184,
-0.0388557985,
-0.0295539051,
-0.0078097032,
-0.0214293636,
0.0900083333,
-0.0459399708,
0.003075266,
0.0179267451,
0.0397433713,
-0.0061975741,
-0.025351217,
-0.0359203331,
-0.0288119204,
0.0320812799,
-0.0158425309,
-0.0243310183,
0.0015772001,
-0.0412133411,
0.0318068489,
-0.0426395275,
0.0465407819,
1.711142101e-34,
0.0287560448,
-0.0219474155,
0.0366910137,
0.0480098799,
0.0229907967,
-0.029648073,
-0.0351024121,
-0.016132433,
0.0155245811,
-0.0759992152,
0.0198672116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08666v1 | It Takes Two to Negotiate: Modeling Social Exchange in Online Multiplayer Games | 2023-11-15T03:21:04 | 2023-11-15T03:21:04 | Kokil Jaidka, Hansin Ahuja, Lynnette Ng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.GT, cs.LG | Online games are dynamic environments where players interact with each other,
which offers a rich setting for understanding how players negotiate their way
through the game to an ultimate victory. This work studies online player
interactions during the turn-based strategy game, Diplomacy. We annotated a
dataset of over 10,000 chat messages for different negotiation strategies and
empirically examined their importance in predicting long- and short-term game
outcomes. Although negotiation strategies can be predicted reasonably
accurately through the linguistic modeling of the chat messages, more is needed
for predicting short-term outcomes such as trustworthiness. On the other hand,
they are essential in graph-aware reinforcement learning approaches to predict
long-term outcomes, such as a player's success, based on their prior
negotiation history. We close with a discussion of the implications and impact
of our work. The dataset is available at
https://github.com/kj2013/claff-diplomacy. | [
0.0520498343,
0.0511828586,
-0.0330475383,
-0.0028055911,
-0.0376190208,
-0.0265510119,
-0.0095594134,
0.000642176,
0.0359524041,
-0.0117885675,
-0.0265688784,
-0.0323936306,
0.0444611348,
0.0639056489,
0.037375018,
-0.0232805386,
0.0239451844,
-0.0020801218,
0.0735218674,
0.0012312979,
0.0151406834,
0.0034754351,
-0.0253706593,
0.0829155073,
-0.0051682382,
-0.0086604608,
-0.0451101027,
0.0171250217,
0.0079658274,
-0.0361543372,
-0.0237878617,
0.0017173166,
-0.0040698065,
-0.0268427469,
0.0000018689,
-0.0209939778,
-0.0302100219,
-0.0579718389,
-0.0033623863,
-0.0221276693,
0.0465755835,
-0.0109503381,
0.0106204422,
0.0326454677,
-0.0631667227,
-0.0220504738,
0.0454879329,
0.0363691375,
0.0530889444,
0.0645281374,
-0.0106447851,
0.0531467311,
-0.004904747,
-0.0256631393,
0.0010963707,
-0.0647439584,
0.0263652559,
-0.0240881033,
-0.0385816842,
-0.0076091648,
-0.0258417819,
-0.0135979075,
-0.0415317118,
-0.0143515747,
-0.0418136045,
0.0429386273,
0.0069141947,
-0.0041310894,
-0.0096709915,
0.0603932999,
0.0043021259,
-0.0026002415,
0.059020713,
0.0103451433,
0.0102561908,
0.0097401654,
-0.0253249779,
-0.0054178331,
-0.0342607014,
0.0005019762,
0.0012149581,
0.0002957344,
0.0307677761,
0.0002632759,
0.0019553257,
0.084532842,
-0.0446856655,
-0.0115766935,
-0.0171432756,
-0.0069423476,
0.0053034821,
-0.0733686239,
-0.0357541777,
0.0183994807,
-0.0970410705,
0.0162310693,
-0.0022176702,
0.0990493372,
0.0153465625,
0.0107538868,
0.0233526919,
-0.0094862562,
0.024313638,
0.0682407469,
0.0455688201,
-0.004085728,
0.0153169157,
-0.017180223,
0.0201693736,
-0.0113785751,
-0.0459485762,
-0.002820451,
-0.0202598944,
0.015197183,
0.0444322079,
-0.0540613942,
-0.061054755,
0.0189242344,
-0.0484655425,
0.0822308883,
0.0411399789,
0.0325017534,
0.0030418402,
0.0304806605,
-0.0437846966,
0.0051329043,
-0.0231017116,
0.0024108754,
0.0036965497,
-0.0791629627,
0.0059613162,
-0.0187977571,
0.0020982011,
-0.0172637664,
0.0114939529,
0.0862958208,
0.0228297897,
-0.0095512923,
0.0508024134,
-0.0292483382,
0.0148969581,
-0.0412596241,
-0.0264589898,
-0.0550823808,
0.0622349642,
-0.0104093766,
-0.0117916428,
-0.02527925,
-0.006641997,
-0.0084155882,
-0.0136745228,
0.0687874556,
0.0062738014,
0.0408513397,
0.0103619937,
0.0015449723,
-0.0550488941,
0.0174780749,
0.0678977296,
0.0161797963,
0.044363562,
0.0047290642,
0.0287877191,
0.0558347404,
0.0186350234,
-0.0275617689,
0.0452743359,
-0.0209766421,
-0.0347428322,
0.0473972186,
-0.0203245282,
0.0282439273,
-0.042489484,
-0.0582810752,
0.0923490599,
0.0526299737,
0.0068511772,
0.0125621473,
0.0208571125,
0.0551296249,
-0.0071873041,
-0.0233770069,
-0.0374308862,
0.0310783647,
0.036613401,
-0.0171996299,
-0.0025117476,
0.0349869467,
-0.018780956,
-0.0288005956,
0.0328430682,
-0.0169848464,
0.1051575392,
0.0232963618,
0.0244084653,
-0.009991115,
-0.0565837882,
-0.0243764482,
0.033637017,
-0.0006387929,
-0.0191681366,
-0.0332766883,
0.0196537208,
0.0593893342,
0.0745086521,
-0.032190498,
-0.0641735643,
-0.0523371138,
-0.0208729673,
-0.0053585125,
0.0400707126,
-0.0202239789,
0.0332442187,
-0.0230239183,
-0.0287172385,
0.0349903516,
-0.0258919466,
0.058664415,
0.0066093095,
-0.025538139,
-0.0540017188,
0.0042336439,
-0.0020987738,
0.0005657406,
0.0428353138,
-0.0006785396,
0.0089907711,
0.0193841457,
0.0366050676,
0.0071323137,
0.0155715467,
-0.0168405455,
0.0021831596,
0.0394013338,
-0.0248838086,
0.0254234392,
0.0015394377,
0.0047859419,
0.0444323793,
-0.0326851159,
-0.0099093737,
-0.0047169426,
-0.0254165903,
0.0081061656,
0.0669327676,
-0.0511590019,
0.0448582359,
0.0421692915,
-0.0055530835,
-0.0059694154,
0.0301528331,
0.0298575982,
-0.0127538368,
-0.01817807,
-0.0435977429,
-0.0542239025,
-0.0658192709,
-0.008812258,
-0.0336521007,
0.0398995616,
0.0105229355,
-0.0339004025,
-0.0039967634,
0.0664405748,
0.0287514478,
-0.0666040108,
-0.019597955,
-0.0595383532,
-0.0015549458,
0.0046802456,
-0.0055629876,
0.0048187105,
0.0072757518,
0.0070692059,
-0.0389277935,
-0.0401594006,
0.0266852789,
0.038591817,
0.0150796883,
0.0292294752,
0.0038659922,
-0.0054520061,
-0.0428447872,
-0.0320768058,
-0.031576138,
0.077861093,
-0.025804745,
-0.0090989815,
0.0074014352,
0.0113794375,
-0.0934682339,
0.0316336937,
-0.0586263388,
-0.0693108216,
0.0396887474,
-0.0180649813,
-0.0092045357,
0.0428505875,
0.0547781363,
0.0808469206,
0.0376539566,
-0.0585573278,
-0.0168655589,
0.0078400439,
-0.0484068245,
-0.0200289544,
-0.0997579172,
-0.0512390658,
-0.0215811059,
0.0373292193,
-0.0054730265,
0.0101603437,
-0.0418087021,
0.0203984324,
0.0301996507,
-0.0160164889,
0.0059985109,
-0.0097777098,
0.0248708539,
-0.0009293869,
-0.0336586125,
-0.0166540742,
0.1013404056,
0.0182136092,
0.0001162951,
0.0257530678,
-0.0397008583,
-0.0011822653,
0.0470124632,
0.0143638989,
-0.0200238135,
0.0054052728,
-0.0245682281,
-0.0344249383,
-0.1047058851,
0.0869838744,
-0.0439974517,
-0.0240610987,
0.0077315792,
-0.0169373192,
0.0551957265,
0.0071903975,
-0.0044277413,
-0.0325121768,
-0.0271359365,
-0.0148746576,
0.013268997,
-0.0469763316,
-0.0451330617,
-0.0234299172,
-0.0015475941,
-0.0079755466,
0.0018262456,
-0.017294446,
-0.0330291949,
-0.0050679585,
0.0688443109,
-0.0085287681,
0.0218808781,
-0.0589135401,
0.0261274669,
0.0277241264,
-0.0357446261,
-0.056621369,
-0.000081669,
-0.0245004352,
-0.0007106289,
-0.0205759797,
-0.006748843,
0.0479791276,
-0.0031122665,
-0.0541556738,
0.004486369,
0.0708171576,
0.0268180631,
-0.0210745782,
0.0155254453,
0.0034955004,
0.0405421257,
0.0097896336,
0.0036288956,
-0.0803545639,
0.0043934346,
-0.0109918704,
0.0174477175,
-0.0161206778,
-0.0685538948,
0.00846049,
-0.0754809603,
-0.0080339545,
-0.0099685527,
-0.0329438448,
0.0201044399,
-0.0405274965,
-0.0101969242,
-0.0216246098,
-0.0182511397,
-0.0203841981,
0.0249042846,
-0.0058689844,
0.0178261474,
-0.0493924841,
0.038549684,
0.0285557471,
-0.0787707195,
0.0796118677,
0.0026967772,
0.1021090075,
0.0096553592,
0.0037361188,
-0.0031102777,
0.0739530474,
-0.0286067091,
-0.0086652813,
0.0766437203,
-0.0171255656,
0.0168810785,
-0.0263719559,
0.0115818456,
0.0028854036,
-0.0274594277,
0.0303034969,
0.0182421878,
-0.0279603917,
-0.0516030565,
0.0419072621,
0.026142234,
0.0716841891,
0.0121966247,
0.0079556266,
-0.0368531831,
-0.0558027327,
-0.0164849069,
0.0032959941,
-0.0308698602,
-0.045670826,
-0.0403500497,
0.0360163972,
0.0223994516,
-0.0557373092,
-0.0544849709,
-0.0455784723,
0.0085746218,
-0.0113469837,
0.0193982627,
0.0318556279,
0.0373642929,
-0.0006139828,
0.0075194198,
-0.0019907872,
0.0103644095,
-0.0099579925,
-0.0116590131,
-0.01499354,
-0.0647022575,
-0.0017849668,
0.0292083975,
-0.0376257598,
-0.0262410212,
-0.0259468723,
0.0453623757,
0.0185372327,
0.0302134138,
0.0097439867,
-0.0160582364,
-0.0068247356,
0.0003950227,
-0.0245797299,
-0.0188005976,
0.0557153858,
0.0334096365,
0.016342232,
0.0290729236,
-0.0390381776,
0.0176384598,
0.0203010365,
0.01379597,
-0.0241730865,
-0.0276585016,
-0.0166846272,
-0.0439476408,
0.0572088696,
0.0011905088,
-0.007822386,
0.0138651198,
-0.0290145855,
-0.0423716046,
0.0061783339,
0.0168136228,
-0.0108387209,
0.0157271437,
0.0121645443,
0.0082210358,
-0.022188561,
-0.0156668145,
0.0054568746,
0.0125166066,
0.0036928197,
0.0260968059,
-0.0158855114,
0.0218232293,
0.002203682,
0.045715142,
0.0204908829,
0.0185695589,
0.019725902,
0.0349062122,
0.0172529314,
0.0375567898,
-0.0404138826,
-0.0166747347,
0.014552623,
-0.0310293678,
-0.0401130095,
0.032823097,
0.0302059595,
0.0257400237,
0.0195450913,
0.0723644495,
-0.0156618711,
0.0387086384,
-0.0109445015,
0.0490239039,
-0.0513247363,
-0.0677432865,
-0.0064963372,
0.0354634374,
-0.0316416323,
0.0499658845,
0.0269530788,
-0.0031440973,
0.0190689582,
-0.0129512604,
-0.0919132382,
-0.0147362277,
-0.0084216855,
-0.0222024657,
0.0610271618,
-0.0484597459,
0.0007882615,
-0.0544421971,
-0.0032152275,
-0.0003958036,
0.0849201009,
0.0168966539,
-0.0110933222,
-0.0280041136,
-0.0000073109,
0.011123661,
0.0148898177,
-0.1069051549,
0.0281351153,
-0.0129586235,
-0.0292985737,
-0.0042950013,
-5.401939473e-33,
0.0445114225,
-0.0557059273,
0.034168411,
0.0649330616,
-0.0586086884,
0.0099617057,
-0.0582156405,
-0.0236395597,
-0.0008517872,
0.0259920973,
-0.0317038298,
0.0295867659,
0.019549204,
0.0088064373,
0.0007500554,
-0.0252465103,
0.0189504083,
0.0049619041,
-0.0421563871,
0.0545212924,
0.0185900256,
-0.0207674317,
0.0180624668,
-0.0884378403,
0.0082743177,
-0.0083415853,
-0.0302252676,
0.0149020012,
0.0212871023,
0.047547318,
0.0155717023,
-0.0295671262,
0.0147339888,
-0.0208328851,
0.0233401954,
0.001433,
-0.0543982238,
0.0010907192,
-0.0287665129,
-0.0335399695,
-0.0468310155,
0.0033411395,
-0.0141181285,
0.0401061773,
0.0073272972,
-0.0442447178,
0.0365142189,
0.0500422791,
-0.0293052457,
0.0300761294,
0.0013651781,
0.0058749812,
-0.0852558315,
-0.0380589478,
0.0060844515,
0.0635287687,
0.0072815544,
-0.0030624156,
-0.0589902103,
0.072615169,
-0.0571612939,
0.0010299868,
0.0088910973,
0.0192610919,
0.0460271612,
0.0291758068,
0.0143969096,
0.0630335286,
-0.005198034,
-0.0422639251,
0.0284284484,
0.05842546,
-0.0004656225,
0.0316687636,
-0.0415699929,
-0.0476727635,
-0.0913645551,
0.0206172559,
0.106996201,
0.0497114323,
0.0234089978,
-0.0084107555,
-0.0073511642,
-0.0160980877,
0.0087242611,
-0.0773290619,
0.012990308,
-0.0594508871,
-0.0127824303,
0.0194957275,
-0.0057802368,
-0.0242839511,
0.0458449535,
-0.0641729981,
-0.0441163331,
0.0727148876,
-0.0455683097,
0.0518255606,
-0.0204824042,
-0.0164099596,
-0.0211710539,
-0.0405225381,
0.0028145895,
-0.0510983318,
0.0229188092,
0.0118149705,
0.0084740277,
0.0416931026,
-0.0028073159,
-0.0154624851,
-0.0064262017,
0.0363145247,
-0.0318510756,
-0.0184241105,
0.0244334638,
-0.0035794303,
-0.0048621269,
0.0054221149,
0.0049074064,
-0.0126637165,
-0.0077253603,
0.0024503807,
0.004459512,
0.0096457805,
-0.0409775227,
-0.0245748032,
-0.0675522909,
0.040218927,
-0.0032919324,
0.0259845611,
-0.0367414206,
-0.0641069338,
2.575e-7,
-0.033427611,
0.0910911709,
0.0258843303,
0.0335073136,
0.01688754,
0.0685697496,
-0.0158530064,
0.055248566,
0.0312312376,
-0.0272583608,
0.0967949033,
0.0440933183,
0.0353885368,
0.0185238328,
-0.0536441505,
0.0011809971,
-0.0785054266,
-0.0836847797,
-0.0135811893,
-0.0026581753,
0.0279406086,
0.0231858846,
0.0625085235,
-0.014995994,
0.00889464,
0.051487159,
0.0142678823,
-0.0566182211,
-0.0124384761,
0.0320378318,
0.0361360535,
-0.0624917597,
-0.0368007943,
0.0023591709,
-0.0195255149,
0.0144148236,
-0.0238613077,
0.0037333053,
0.0078743445,
-0.0062417057,
-0.0137928082,
-0.0095736412,
0.0138561456,
-0.0317922831,
0.0260446295,
-0.0505155921,
-0.0519079752,
-0.0451548398,
-0.0148030138,
-0.0309535451,
0.0006588004,
-0.008866461,
-0.0108739622,
0.0027414353,
-0.0149340583,
0.0257033203,
0.0015463608,
-0.0428877957,
-0.0250034593,
0.0332354605,
-0.0227233339,
-0.0373206288,
0.0292540062,
0.0339357704,
0.0098023377,
0.0021282011,
0.0095737353,
1.71145285e-34,
-0.0190006103,
-0.0091140233,
-0.0321236923,
-0.0106323073,
0.0558166541,
-0.0173585825,
-0.0041478514,
0.0332909711,
0.066388011,
-0.0097837122,
0.0019938441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08662v1 | Multi-Set Inoculation: Assessing Model Robustness Across Multiple Challenge Sets | 2023-11-15T02:59:10 | 2023-11-15T02:59:10 | Vatsal Gupta, Pranshu Pandya, Tushar Kataria, Vivek Gupta, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Language models, given their black-box nature, often exhibit sensitivity to
input perturbations, leading to trust issues due to hallucinations. To bolster
trust, it's essential to understand these models' failure modes and devise
strategies to enhance their performance. In this study, we propose a framework
to study the effect of input perturbations on language models of different
scales, from pre-trained models to large language models (LLMs). We use
fine-tuning to train a robust model to perturbations, and we investigate
whether exposure to one perturbation improves or degrades the model's
performance on other perturbations. To address multi-perturbation robustness,
we suggest three distinct training strategies. We also extend the framework to
LLMs via a chain of thought(COT) prompting with exemplars. We instantiate our
framework for the Tabular-NLI task and show that the proposed strategies train
the model robust to different perturbations without losing accuracy on a given
dataset. | [
-0.0219582468,
0.0771514252,
-0.0370591804,
0.0155523308,
-0.0171670895,
0.0232455246,
0.0002927712,
0.0196262319,
0.0103584612,
-0.0264547318,
-0.0502646826,
-0.0689907074,
-0.0078166788,
0.0030155883,
0.0628293082,
-0.014543104,
0.0789473578,
-0.0448519625,
-0.0626991838,
-0.0085805487,
-0.0022618268,
-0.02075026,
-0.018475268,
0.014961889,
-0.0355848372,
-0.0330400728,
-0.0088219978,
0.0276830457,
-0.016082067,
-0.0388694368,
0.0106459232,
0.107568711,
0.021160014,
0.0311467424,
0.0000022603,
-0.035023205,
-0.0202569682,
-0.0286820959,
-0.007547088,
0.0099897915,
0.0161748379,
-0.027183773,
0.0094304448,
0.0216947552,
-0.0065488354,
-0.0139749404,
0.0316861719,
0.0558944345,
0.0591033921,
0.0773204416,
-0.0019735403,
0.0065610604,
0.0241792966,
-0.0201642402,
-0.0220388416,
-0.0373589396,
0.0353805833,
-0.0220339391,
-0.0345275775,
-0.0393753275,
-0.0072938111,
0.0080990074,
0.0109134084,
0.023434585,
0.0009528334,
0.0245163161,
-0.0331414081,
-0.009790726,
-0.0217203647,
0.0711424351,
-0.0476578027,
-0.0094041303,
-0.0219822936,
-0.0199711025,
0.0351622216,
0.0238862559,
-0.0331083313,
-0.0221270695,
0.0071158106,
-0.0080744764,
-0.005202977,
-0.0299435705,
0.0422138907,
-0.0076332828,
-0.0304175615,
0.036132589,
0.015458582,
-0.0793762356,
0.0233924333,
0.0002633133,
-0.0041422793,
-0.0531136207,
-0.0148906233,
0.0155818416,
-0.0453107804,
0.0322372317,
-0.0414461493,
-0.0387677029,
0.0186605621,
-0.0600682013,
0.0884946659,
0.0062414114,
-0.0409231968,
0.0092917578,
-0.0231971517,
0.0232930109,
-0.024512304,
0.05720485,
-0.004839493,
0.021403078,
-0.0437958278,
0.0015443019,
-0.0399747305,
0.0364310928,
0.0209119301,
0.0040192241,
-0.018287586,
0.0046585063,
-0.0248147082,
0.0358038247,
-0.0064052758,
-0.0067132264,
-0.0034181867,
-0.0141404131,
0.0012588265,
0.0367681496,
-0.0429309681,
0.0116885416,
0.0077193589,
-0.0888273567,
-0.0387475342,
-0.0113373082,
-0.0041658045,
-0.0422336087,
0.0252511557,
0.0749265701,
-0.0073927972,
-0.0443220325,
-0.0570200756,
-0.0112464707,
-0.0208917074,
-0.0762997493,
0.0231236648,
-0.03888724,
0.0134676155,
-0.0105641885,
0.0205725878,
-0.0705830976,
0.0210203268,
0.0068910355,
-0.037079405,
0.0892149433,
0.0233208351,
-0.0018192269,
-0.0050367373,
0.0147987725,
-0.025353916,
0.0833398849,
0.0418387651,
-0.0185015406,
0.0376123972,
-0.0265508201,
0.0096024759,
0.0743030161,
0.012145645,
0.0275420211,
-0.0514946915,
-0.0063367113,
0.0653341636,
0.0208446123,
-0.0012804301,
0.0371554047,
-0.0224614851,
0.0374626704,
0.1164837629,
0.0339709707,
0.0037445687,
0.0399104394,
-0.0232164785,
-0.0509622358,
0.0141631793,
0.0406247452,
-0.0631474406,
0.0024520718,
-0.0059749018,
0.0038902131,
0.0164392684,
0.0460992046,
-0.0177148208,
-0.0485155918,
-0.0426944606,
-0.0061201463,
0.0040546972,
0.0014123062,
0.0487843007,
0.0050325696,
-0.0476977378,
0.01754044,
0.017314313,
-0.0627265275,
0.0137589891,
-0.0128477067,
-0.018043058,
0.0440830179,
0.0396056138,
-0.0439296253,
0.0139907626,
-0.0371813811,
0.0536704361,
0.0323700458,
0.0468251258,
0.0060171434,
0.0255570617,
-0.0364599265,
0.0052468553,
0.032202661,
0.0540668741,
0.0371581614,
0.0013136214,
0.0009835601,
-0.0419381671,
0.0115291532,
-0.0457350872,
0.050426472,
0.0107997609,
-0.0485252626,
-0.009840562,
-0.0076733334,
0.0162004903,
-0.0002499313,
-0.0422932804,
0.0060454933,
0.0259452052,
-0.0230252929,
0.0123326778,
0.0073135737,
-0.0509525426,
0.0140434755,
0.0370575748,
0.0520256385,
-0.0351749063,
0.0160795376,
-0.0000540934,
-0.0300473273,
0.0065408484,
-0.0126689039,
0.022809431,
-0.0052980413,
0.053322915,
-0.0357034616,
0.066919975,
-0.0344207026,
0.0533466563,
-0.0440130495,
0.0278521143,
-0.0392298549,
0.0158351734,
0.0116421422,
-0.0143972067,
-0.0381575786,
0.0260971785,
-0.0077744266,
0.0235702321,
-0.0049023451,
-0.0281949751,
-0.0462231934,
-0.0326906368,
-0.0423973911,
-0.0116344495,
-0.0274607539,
0.0097487876,
0.0005533159,
-0.0220590439,
-0.0210710019,
-0.0064220172,
-0.012385332,
0.0087135499,
0.0197832827,
0.043618001,
0.0292896181,
-0.0091204625,
-0.0262340605,
-0.0347050168,
-0.0107231969,
-0.0321149528,
0.0661319345,
-0.0272777379,
-0.0362192355,
-0.0645354539,
0.0225679949,
-0.0260606389,
0.0300217401,
0.0163249876,
-0.0469704978,
0.0271552596,
0.0091871591,
0.0521117896,
0.0985575914,
0.0012090098,
0.0459488221,
0.0800653771,
-0.0102634365,
-0.0346318297,
-0.0027990183,
0.0316744372,
-0.0520274937,
-0.0253480915,
-0.0268572662,
0.0099071926,
0.0837730244,
0.0060491771,
0.0075558089,
-0.0534490719,
0.0181428324,
-0.0129927071,
-0.0365220904,
0.003819488,
-0.001882831,
-0.0520155691,
0.0644208491,
-0.0159304887,
-0.0403359793,
0.0663084388,
-0.0365811177,
0.0116492752,
-0.0068124007,
-0.017426122,
0.0145195471,
0.0467418619,
0.0098159127,
-0.0187648162,
0.0444488302,
-0.0010963744,
-0.0702871829,
-0.0289917234,
0.0297709703,
-0.0259968806,
0.0674824417,
-0.0434784293,
-0.0200407784,
0.0059426902,
-0.0527698621,
-0.0468432941,
-0.0109743113,
0.0089637656,
-0.0050092451,
0.0037675416,
-0.0170827657,
-0.0292070527,
-0.0426346511,
0.0214076377,
0.0372983553,
-0.0241317097,
-0.0129398648,
-0.0238908399,
0.0395736247,
0.0446485803,
-0.015545167,
0.0197445732,
-0.0610358119,
0.0207091179,
0.0313318148,
0.0300765354,
-0.0095421607,
-0.035444431,
0.0169271026,
0.0341015905,
-0.0202188101,
0.010025505,
0.0440766998,
0.0303505324,
-0.0405779742,
-0.0611504652,
0.0848293677,
0.0300344042,
-0.0395613052,
0.028879961,
-0.0453510471,
0.0986007303,
0.0385981202,
0.0192003325,
-0.0717517212,
-0.0049301716,
0.006033401,
-0.0125313224,
-0.0090760635,
-0.0489705876,
-0.0053625372,
-0.1145498008,
0.0190484747,
0.0057000937,
-0.0336777195,
-0.0336266346,
-0.0437090322,
0.0153360749,
-0.006970983,
0.0637310669,
0.0077333483,
-0.0061091185,
-0.0360635072,
0.0441602729,
0.0175811742,
-0.0770227462,
-0.0136989951,
-0.0585422888,
0.0643953234,
0.0473482683,
-0.0346180014,
-0.0603078455,
-0.0277974736,
0.0775487646,
0.0258939527,
0.0177118555,
0.0297360774,
0.0412673764,
-0.0009603991,
0.0130649358,
0.0294481646,
0.0025462967,
-0.0171085615,
-0.0280103236,
0.0289628841,
0.0649738833,
-0.0094911484,
-0.0092657413,
0.0299518276,
-0.0411929339,
0.0062530171,
0.0631840229,
0.0603301078,
-0.0509880073,
-0.008281935,
-0.0292580295,
-0.0182698071,
-0.0294726137,
0.0002208066,
0.0325760283,
0.0101982709,
0.0037775815,
-0.0517870001,
-0.0382265933,
-0.0083110379,
0.0446176492,
0.0157287344,
0.0163439829,
-0.013468761,
0.0039627422,
0.0019858549,
0.0316592529,
-0.0251544937,
0.0082193026,
-0.0396187082,
0.010957934,
0.0232648198,
-0.0006717634,
0.002755793,
0.0172455478,
-0.0874775946,
-0.0778804421,
0.024901161,
0.0542509854,
0.0347403623,
0.0706599504,
0.0057852659,
-0.061747022,
0.0285962522,
-0.0048631574,
-0.0236918777,
0.0194616225,
0.0548580475,
-0.0377336666,
0.0081246151,
0.0304591563,
-0.0259099863,
-0.0024493982,
0.0209877715,
0.0324616432,
-0.011591278,
-0.0301727261,
0.0208948608,
-0.0095503544,
0.0306573175,
-0.0192833859,
-0.0233886577,
-0.0340477563,
0.0391754135,
-0.0426989831,
-0.020212654,
0.0025382531,
-0.0019363132,
0.0339005105,
0.001591058,
-0.0155408895,
-0.0631810278,
-0.0044381432,
0.0582670234,
-0.033810664,
0.0046598804,
-0.0077160154,
-0.0003351359,
0.0328528769,
0.0111935167,
-0.0259123687,
0.0305555593,
-0.0004908286,
0.018574683,
-0.002060541,
0.0501905009,
0.0369141027,
-0.0283979066,
-0.037693847,
0.020880498,
-0.0588805713,
-0.0133613525,
-0.0387870446,
-0.0000777856,
0.0314772055,
-0.0118877199,
0.0259052366,
-0.0246421658,
0.0009997585,
0.0055596842,
-0.0023211935,
0.0143063078,
-0.0249690488,
0.0159745645,
0.0309296288,
-0.0085942093,
0.0082728965,
0.0917104557,
-0.003396732,
0.0582801886,
-0.0315584168,
0.0178064015,
-0.0459692106,
-0.0169449113,
-0.011586424,
0.0621139966,
-0.0426061973,
0.0095033823,
-0.0527383946,
-0.0825105906,
0.0211204495,
0.0219844785,
0.0215481743,
-0.009851547,
-0.0013886024,
0.061877124,
-0.0080590453,
0.0265485644,
-0.0022850023,
-0.0243420098,
0.0252490379,
-0.0234799888,
-0.0319175236,
-7.052487091e-33,
-0.0203906111,
-0.0254470892,
-0.0179787837,
-0.0222095624,
0.0097063174,
-0.0257630032,
-0.0263511781,
0.0372301899,
-0.0061062444,
-0.0084616207,
-0.0418230183,
0.0071865418,
0.0126210591,
0.0032260541,
0.0375674851,
-0.0507294834,
0.0159279481,
-0.0253470652,
-0.0336858593,
-0.0231399443,
-0.0045689647,
0.0344651528,
0.0637516901,
-0.0634898692,
0.0564376749,
-0.0249076206,
-0.0470530652,
-0.0023376611,
-0.0459994525,
0.0484053455,
-0.0069419169,
0.0438969582,
0.0306747369,
-0.0457187556,
-0.0074872756,
0.0156584904,
-0.0570527688,
-0.0395190828,
0.001554821,
0.0266639423,
-0.0092026321,
-0.0267575979,
0.0372883379,
-0.0374418348,
-0.0062394333,
-0.0196904149,
0.0236585923,
-0.0400302634,
-0.033123482,
0.0369316749,
-0.028419558,
0.0063044508,
-0.0113043664,
0.0130086131,
-0.0072453795,
0.0489824899,
0.0052000107,
-0.0007478531,
-0.0463211685,
0.0059471107,
0.0306006465,
0.0292129386,
0.0411088653,
0.0188112296,
-0.0104787005,
0.0574008413,
0.0367907509,
0.0192118399,
-0.0019417077,
-0.0421140306,
0.0421665646,
0.0001429716,
0.069915913,
0.0837220773,
0.0278328061,
-0.0144691635,
-0.0760256425,
0.0040833941,
0.0385229178,
0.0092699565,
0.0197433271,
0.0156980455,
-0.047308322,
-0.0188501235,
-0.0494058207,
-0.0685537308,
-0.0429202244,
-0.03363242,
0.0275490489,
0.003592008,
0.0360022262,
0.0061878082,
0.0325889587,
0.0041290005,
-0.0192771852,
0.0070956349,
-0.0040692762,
0.0284131225,
-0.0005559732,
0.021037966,
0.0057880711,
-0.0283931997,
-0.005375233,
0.0165578984,
0.0676696599,
0.017888438,
0.0803925842,
0.0019040633,
-0.0854428783,
-0.0088975253,
-0.0368860774,
0.0136846555,
0.0484972522,
0.0463252366,
0.0405877605,
-0.0187197085,
-0.0100661786,
0.0490369014,
0.041566588,
-0.0113746915,
-0.0314452276,
0.0166517869,
-0.0130438013,
0.0301537048,
-0.0196988955,
-0.0206924658,
-0.0210540779,
0.0044803452,
0.0813878179,
-0.0346236788,
-0.0023250459,
-0.0125669874,
2.959e-7,
0.0204262193,
0.0676077008,
0.0048445486,
0.0218698345,
-0.0000605762,
0.0172311533,
-0.0495532677,
0.0295901168,
-0.030782152,
-0.0302633755,
-0.0056947991,
0.0175786782,
0.0674084798,
0.0243463442,
-0.0560395755,
-0.0915638655,
-0.0888677761,
0.0641251281,
-0.0577283502,
-0.0096326321,
0.0389283933,
0.0834032372,
-0.0011560682,
-0.0062621161,
-0.0330769606,
-0.0316746533,
0.0588673055,
-0.051886946,
0.0240214672,
0.0016764187,
0.0235522948,
-0.0069716186,
-0.0037369479,
0.0754477903,
-0.0292355921,
0.0122159757,
-0.0221667215,
0.0432393812,
-0.0226823837,
0.001213209,
0.0145382565,
-0.0035533784,
-0.0215229467,
-0.0893800482,
0.0554592907,
-0.0429934338,
-0.0202728324,
0.0156907644,
-0.0049986169,
-0.0319493972,
0.0842781365,
-0.0263712108,
-0.0111376913,
0.0212831963,
0.0198334865,
0.0389694981,
-0.0128695676,
-0.0632217452,
-0.0340313464,
0.0323364958,
-0.0246399697,
-0.0418092087,
-0.0179783162,
-0.0487740189,
0.0227938648,
-0.1035887972,
-0.0097978469,
2.998422521e-34,
0.0304247662,
-0.0455415845,
0.050827574,
0.0687868893,
0.072311312,
-0.0618620515,
0.0120967478,
0.0058289082,
0.0042667286,
-0.0756858885,
-0.0030028955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08648v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08648v4 | Explore Spurious Correlations at the Concept Level in Language Models for Text Classification | 2023-11-15T01:58:54 | 2024-06-16T01:28:49 | Yuhang Zhou, Paiheng Xu, Xiaoyu Liu, Bang An, Wei Ai, Furong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models (LMs) have achieved notable success in numerous NLP tasks,
employing both fine-tuning and in-context learning (ICL) methods. While
language models demonstrate exceptional performance, they face robustness
challenges due to spurious correlations arising from imbalanced label
distributions in training data or ICL exemplars. Previous research has
primarily concentrated on word, phrase, and syntax features, neglecting the
concept level, often due to the absence of concept labels and difficulty in
identifying conceptual content in input texts. This paper introduces two main
contributions. First, we employ ChatGPT to assign concept labels to texts,
assessing concept bias in models during fine-tuning or ICL on test data. We
find that LMs, when encountering spurious correlations between a concept and a
label in training or prompts, resort to shortcuts for predictions. Second, we
introduce a data rebalancing technique that incorporates ChatGPT-generated
counterfactual data, thereby balancing label distribution and mitigating
spurious correlations. Our method's efficacy, surpassing traditional token
removal approaches, is validated through extensive testing. | [
0.0603263266,
0.0096029872,
-0.0345956422,
0.0327163003,
-0.064795658,
0.0250453129,
-0.0110780746,
-0.0007587521,
-0.0175612457,
-0.0986209661,
-0.0545319244,
-0.0022339635,
0.0149325104,
0.0369961038,
0.007591459,
-0.0285076108,
0.0162127148,
-0.0023088097,
0.0570270456,
0.0093624713,
0.0274722576,
0.0139538022,
0.038823124,
0.0172839332,
-0.0388005711,
-0.0249560103,
0.0540017784,
0.0244932715,
-0.0120466845,
-0.000857967,
0.0651428774,
0.0708967373,
-0.0339166634,
0.0130058723,
0.0000020078,
-0.0524020009,
-0.0246879775,
-0.0002837958,
-0.0153290713,
0.0045801061,
0.0450430587,
-0.0036938717,
0.0093690576,
0.0353836827,
-0.0153662674,
0.0065208636,
0.0272879992,
0.0907587409,
0.0201883949,
0.0534640662,
-0.0172561966,
0.0027093561,
-0.0067272754,
-0.0197762251,
0.0241815615,
-0.0207579434,
0.055301968,
-0.0102042295,
-0.0470110141,
0.0256625358,
-0.0133211501,
0.0224680379,
-0.0076119406,
0.0295424089,
0.0428829566,
0.0221942849,
-0.0592135899,
-0.0328920037,
0.0135033466,
0.0469827205,
-0.0168555956,
-0.0762698129,
0.0135143409,
-0.0243337005,
0.0153462421,
0.0118651614,
-0.027245095,
0.0015849688,
-0.0153505486,
0.0222710744,
0.0599815771,
0.0093779573,
0.0369016454,
0.024428118,
-0.007914193,
0.0444920249,
-0.0035846266,
-0.0474635847,
-0.0140941516,
0.0297650117,
-0.0559554361,
-0.0473336242,
-0.0140695404,
-0.0025743183,
-0.0079336138,
0.0228633024,
-0.0341732278,
-0.0557248816,
0.0427092612,
-0.0780892223,
-0.0326320343,
0.0071545294,
-0.0258356463,
0.0464428514,
-0.001034309,
0.0402529687,
0.0667633712,
0.0337632783,
-0.0323170274,
-0.0199641604,
-0.0445566736,
-0.0212377422,
-0.0589735769,
0.0119289579,
-0.0008110468,
0.0018791443,
-0.0371741168,
0.0264102034,
-0.0280539747,
-0.0014263557,
-0.0050511011,
0.0053843516,
-0.0322143994,
0.0099544413,
0.0016568205,
-0.0077485042,
0.0028393776,
0.0277903043,
-0.0368679762,
-0.0681203008,
-0.0041014701,
0.0242146775,
-0.0409827828,
-0.0556653701,
0.0215875302,
0.0343065001,
0.0317301042,
-0.0662446469,
-0.0067826388,
-0.0251752287,
-0.0568385161,
-0.0430391356,
-0.0343035907,
-0.0565021262,
-0.0291418377,
0.0482596532,
0.0049429005,
-0.0211303085,
-0.0143798031,
0.0330845714,
-0.0981013179,
0.081119217,
0.0304523539,
-0.0095497416,
0.0458496287,
0.0077306586,
-0.0454013832,
0.0851630569,
0.0157792196,
-0.0016317457,
0.0422485843,
-0.0027707163,
0.0280869063,
0.0257115308,
0.0216708891,
0.0086879944,
-0.0404626578,
0.0022358894,
0.0560606569,
-0.0236730967,
0.0150907962,
0.0398269743,
0.0045656059,
0.0359279923,
0.0469719507,
0.0129793882,
-0.0071175802,
0.0093690502,
-0.0205343533,
-0.0211236216,
-0.0123185515,
0.0126314517,
-0.0841774568,
-0.0159215648,
-0.0429324992,
0.0028930421,
0.0332792103,
0.0189769194,
-0.0157570299,
-0.0269629005,
-0.0411834754,
0.0136197563,
0.0182226002,
-0.0085004615,
0.0503345989,
0.0251038708,
0.0002288162,
0.0046906089,
0.0520398878,
0.0239433683,
0.0251945704,
-0.0496319495,
-0.025371071,
0.041877158,
0.0650601462,
-0.0277449749,
0.0065029725,
-0.0101797981,
0.0292031094,
0.0113109732,
0.0463132113,
-0.0001473266,
-0.0204220768,
0.0005416871,
-0.0293023642,
-0.0037340519,
0.0428243354,
-0.0219596941,
-0.0037171922,
0.0163458772,
0.022800928,
-0.0757977217,
-0.0189970396,
0.0417663902,
-0.0018666844,
-0.0219897199,
0.0382224955,
0.0178872757,
0.0056541367,
-0.0204645097,
-0.0221511833,
-0.0004314092,
0.0212211721,
0.0061132568,
-0.0020867861,
-0.0294910837,
-0.024489712,
-0.0517289266,
0.0200594254,
0.0093166362,
0.0014815708,
-0.0083881412,
-0.0469456501,
-0.0225410387,
0.0006989721,
0.0062869694,
0.0470951945,
-0.0452896915,
0.020642126,
-0.0093670338,
0.0176802948,
-0.0642697066,
0.0445180424,
0.0377216861,
0.0450431481,
-0.0285818297,
0.012950954,
0.0097806435,
0.016128473,
-0.0307729617,
0.0001041224,
-0.0125887115,
0.0021886567,
0.0423098728,
0.0144774225,
-0.0193061884,
-0.0435348526,
-0.1045959964,
0.005709481,
-0.0394038297,
-0.0151072163,
0.0369154327,
-0.0064257719,
-0.0111886915,
-0.0095738256,
-0.0197529532,
-0.0395017341,
0.035344366,
0.0411120392,
0.0225994308,
-0.0027098241,
-0.0163460448,
-0.0133820958,
0.0148018077,
-0.0230674706,
0.0630371943,
0.0225035641,
-0.0389292128,
-0.0330129676,
0.0474817827,
-0.0145096183,
0.0075001288,
-0.0091968114,
-0.0098876497,
-0.0370731466,
0.0260901805,
0.001926547,
0.0185502991,
0.032929033,
0.028241612,
0.0460306481,
0.0045809173,
-0.028295774,
-0.0099425288,
-0.001922679,
0.0010750653,
0.0121330507,
-0.0185648967,
0.0160837397,
0.0583740436,
0.0179622881,
-0.0206803102,
-0.0530360043,
0.0272370446,
-0.0139637366,
0.0256590322,
-0.073245734,
-0.0104874922,
-0.0207256693,
0.0065385811,
-0.0348766372,
-0.0585177131,
0.0416890644,
-0.021974612,
0.028095752,
-0.0690130889,
-0.0174104422,
-0.0205737837,
0.0323555581,
0.0132429078,
0.0125054587,
0.0623356849,
0.010031336,
-0.0567423739,
-0.0122978147,
0.0207215622,
-0.0189904012,
0.0165377911,
-0.0401736423,
0.0285127349,
0.0069468571,
-0.0473913513,
-0.0780106038,
-0.0465384945,
0.003778111,
0.007470313,
0.0402158052,
0.0154900644,
-0.0142395962,
0.0094139315,
-0.0248137135,
0.019724628,
-0.0191477295,
-0.0233777836,
0.0077657788,
0.0193740129,
0.0739297271,
-0.0301692411,
-0.0079896012,
-0.0064645102,
-0.0097610941,
0.0058302758,
-0.0093368171,
0.0109797111,
0.0327407233,
-0.0013067245,
-0.0011199749,
-0.0085912067,
-0.0298279971,
0.0119513338,
-0.0069766063,
-0.0172601026,
-0.0582817309,
0.1359767765,
0.0323268324,
-0.0676686168,
-0.0063847806,
0.0098142531,
0.0567886531,
0.0275773853,
0.0012125149,
-0.0350355357,
-0.0337856747,
0.0306115188,
0.0096184723,
-0.0271712821,
0.0020462316,
-0.0242025629,
-0.1006893516,
-0.0013713257,
0.0023701338,
-0.0761557519,
-0.0449744985,
-0.066625163,
0.0143003268,
-0.039957568,
0.0324057005,
-0.0205062609,
-0.0104334634,
0.0248781536,
0.012067955,
-0.0457096957,
-0.0643395111,
0.0345846452,
-0.0306960847,
0.0667225868,
0.0512837991,
0.0304990802,
-0.0190526452,
0.0358202793,
0.0843384787,
-0.0737647191,
0.0158532355,
-0.0036881843,
0.0774236992,
-0.0373032875,
0.0112241106,
0.0136047881,
0.0106607284,
-0.043210987,
-0.0403837636,
0.0204709228,
0.0460866168,
-0.0168192554,
-0.0228755232,
-0.0147936167,
-0.0192389805,
0.034820009,
0.1274502873,
0.018934885,
-0.0675441474,
-0.0258276258,
-0.0305973385,
0.0092102494,
0.0252633896,
0.027016554,
0.0035323882,
0.0111500043,
-0.0271289013,
-0.0674039423,
-0.0549864247,
0.0392685905,
-0.0187917631,
0.0147078699,
0.0632638857,
-0.0576972738,
-0.0113958931,
-0.0156374946,
0.024717547,
-0.0238798652,
0.0239979811,
-0.0482409112,
-0.0082138237,
0.0170946121,
-0.0587363914,
-0.0345671885,
0.0006246241,
-0.1008720472,
-0.0677171871,
0.0339484811,
0.0089459009,
0.0172916614,
0.0712307096,
-0.0303893983,
-0.0161781367,
0.0539752021,
0.1235697269,
-0.08197736,
0.0150231887,
-0.0127092348,
-0.0096089281,
0.0011603789,
0.0274462812,
-0.0502523519,
0.0243581571,
0.0578110032,
0.0099266972,
-0.0123985521,
-0.0474567786,
0.023886133,
0.0015134019,
0.1174512729,
-0.0235659629,
-0.0342412069,
-0.0378564,
-0.0113331685,
0.0194886401,
-0.0505711176,
0.0065658865,
-0.0069578257,
0.0045892401,
0.0285736639,
-0.0508739389,
0.003334159,
-0.0222576521,
0.0491113141,
0.0307709873,
-0.0262999535,
-0.0048197457,
0.0128789255,
0.0358910225,
-0.000942503,
0.0068132123,
0.0162503794,
0.0209680889,
0.0107965581,
-0.0162005592,
0.011756897,
0.0496712774,
0.0186363012,
-0.0409009755,
0.0112390528,
-0.0593104884,
0.0192062557,
-0.0534295477,
0.0192731116,
0.0322296955,
-0.0457239039,
0.001729637,
-0.0627911016,
-0.0202001091,
-0.0416332297,
0.0206775665,
0.0237866379,
0.0048896088,
0.0200595949,
-0.0028649697,
-0.0524145737,
0.0148082888,
0.0684957802,
0.0059952955,
0.0511505753,
0.0125680547,
-0.0290007573,
-0.0046024742,
0.0267871674,
0.0219679661,
0.0004656024,
0.0028663564,
0.0148992334,
-0.0574379079,
-0.0818933398,
0.0254786145,
-0.0375157557,
0.0113850273,
0.0090443622,
0.0348954275,
0.0771097466,
-0.0014798326,
0.0127333533,
-0.0310920011,
-0.0193620063,
0.0256352127,
-0.0380353369,
-0.0564544722,
-6.641138271e-33,
-0.0061943792,
-0.0389968865,
-0.0156101761,
0.0578641072,
0.0234500952,
-0.007501042,
-0.0056161038,
-0.0083542354,
-0.0110599864,
0.0165031198,
-0.0194858406,
0.018843459,
0.0015237657,
0.0177438315,
-0.0144108692,
-0.0272864122,
0.0438783392,
-0.0020073205,
-0.0395431519,
0.0247179791,
0.0267131161,
0.0404312089,
0.0478568524,
-0.0715383589,
0.036207065,
-0.0277271587,
-0.0077945967,
0.0164737981,
-0.0089992741,
0.0398580953,
-0.0177147295,
0.0605438761,
0.0591726564,
0.0010320687,
0.0227664169,
0.0210912935,
-0.0420298427,
-0.0450175181,
0.0032421285,
0.0158742983,
0.0460528918,
-0.0130636273,
0.0427307934,
-0.0097273067,
-0.0293726847,
-0.0006880062,
0.0899413899,
-0.0262222067,
-0.0362190343,
-0.0152402129,
-0.0395340063,
0.0343199335,
0.0095275147,
-0.0020752701,
-0.0127468845,
0.0274318103,
0.0024481406,
0.0400929712,
-0.0531145483,
-0.0079360418,
0.0080663357,
0.0318009295,
0.0112463813,
0.0419797227,
-0.0047105053,
0.0527432151,
-0.0218466558,
0.0465582907,
-0.01895082,
-0.0277750436,
0.0625928938,
-0.0048453254,
0.013105805,
0.0676094517,
0.0963564515,
-0.0244512372,
-0.0560036786,
0.0275653955,
-0.0068580164,
0.0039186315,
0.0401132852,
-0.0143284248,
-0.0585171357,
-0.060288839,
-0.0509148352,
-0.0088440254,
-0.0591615103,
-0.0121258758,
0.0468939021,
0.0096262982,
-0.0012426267,
-0.0281136204,
0.0077714608,
-0.0461737774,
-0.0572679825,
0.0499946177,
-0.0279058851,
-0.0114844758,
0.0015246645,
0.0034972834,
-0.0551948696,
-0.0466374308,
0.038624052,
0.0406474285,
0.0027766791,
-0.0122317364,
0.0792982951,
-0.0038825166,
-0.0729189366,
0.0118314316,
-0.0050470219,
0.0198564455,
-0.0023150411,
0.009130002,
0.0156926624,
0.0218179468,
0.0058574392,
0.0119164474,
0.051103048,
-0.0248953942,
-0.0183532722,
-0.0256506819,
-0.0485065356,
-0.0129046682,
-0.0145532126,
-0.0047739311,
0.0277896188,
-0.0253099632,
0.0293404385,
-0.0365512185,
-0.0021142992,
-0.0304219481,
2.784e-7,
0.0564141273,
0.0651358813,
-0.0273628607,
-0.0005236514,
0.0263305213,
0.0617111847,
-0.0295252558,
0.0241806004,
0.0395687073,
-0.0068361657,
0.0188319143,
-0.0006029385,
0.0237973072,
0.0058443295,
-0.0774096772,
0.0299834758,
-0.0603021532,
-0.0026890908,
-0.0137300901,
-0.0005151666,
0.057142619,
0.1146362945,
0.0457925834,
-0.0290116686,
-0.0199188683,
-0.0453698821,
0.0462499559,
-0.0555649251,
0.0056982883,
0.0230291411,
0.013831662,
-0.0062086703,
0.0250191446,
0.0687915757,
-0.0351300389,
0.006419247,
-0.0045374436,
0.0227876026,
-0.0194751099,
-0.0014729388,
-0.0237913709,
0.0331534781,
0.0071286242,
-0.0851061866,
0.0948635191,
-0.0527273826,
0.0214705523,
-0.0424964167,
-0.0127358306,
-0.0290068761,
0.0460166372,
0.0083337938,
-0.0483731963,
0.0380729958,
0.0126174847,
0.0337270275,
-0.0375201516,
-0.0810207278,
-0.0323998965,
0.0352342054,
-0.0301600024,
-0.0275126658,
-0.0080265766,
0.032654494,
0.0411824435,
-0.0569400005,
0.0608509183,
2.847557234e-34,
0.0382464677,
-0.0251384657,
-0.0012338011,
-0.0179762766,
0.0090106148,
0.0086397044,
-0.0142339682,
0.0383571759,
-0.00740912,
-0.0493489094,
0.0288158208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08640v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08640v3 | Multistage Collaborative Knowledge Distillation from a Large Language Model for Semi-Supervised Sequence Generation | 2023-11-15T01:28:28 | 2024-02-26T22:30:53 | Jiachen Zhao, Wenlong Zhao, Andrew Drozdov, Benjamin Rozonoyer, Md Arafat Sultan, Jay-Yoon Lee, Mohit Iyyer, Andrew McCallum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We study semi-supervised sequence generation tasks, where the few labeled
examples are too scarce to finetune a model, and meanwhile, few-shot prompted
large language models (LLMs) exhibit room for improvement. In this paper, we
present the discovery that a student model distilled from a few-shot prompted
LLM can commonly generalize better than its teacher to unseen examples on such
tasks. We find that the student is able to learn a general pattern from the
high-quality pseudolabels produced by the teacher during knowledge distillation
(KD), and favorably not a general pattern from the low-quality pseudolables.
Leveraging this discovery, we propose a new method, Multistage Collaborative
Knowledge Distillation from an LLM (MCKD), for these tasks. MCKD first few-shot
prompts an LLM to produce pseudolabels for unlabeled data. Then at each stage
of an iterative KD process, a new pair of students is trained on disjoint
partitions of the pseudolabeled data, and produces new and improved
pseudolabels for their unseen partitions. We conduct extensive experiments on
four syntactic and semantic parsing datasets and show the effectiveness of MCKD
for low-resource semi-supervised sequence generation. On CRAFT biomedical
parsing, for example, 3-stage MCKD with 50 labeled examples outperforms an LLM
teacher and vanilla KD by 7.5% and 3.7% parsing F1, respectively, and matches
the performance of supervised finetuning with 500 labeled examples. | [
0.0494230278,
0.0312439278,
-0.0048644082,
0.013308811,
-0.0576063246,
0.0223637968,
0.0359562337,
-0.0220295265,
-0.037983153,
-0.0621337928,
-0.0208689943,
-0.0227962621,
-0.0209250469,
0.0052009583,
0.0489652306,
-0.0469652675,
0.0182785764,
-0.0081282444,
0.0206365865,
0.0068317526,
-0.0157149788,
0.0044844798,
-0.0119714355,
0.0276123025,
-0.0225900672,
-0.0241251905,
-0.0294592697,
-0.0392065085,
-0.015471898,
-0.029089069,
0.0112567525,
0.0494880378,
0.0067888154,
0.0122397142,
0.0000019115,
-0.0554447994,
-0.0232495777,
0.0062640873,
-0.0309408028,
0.0266399924,
0.0084390482,
-0.004277355,
0.0244597904,
-0.0061522345,
-0.0447130799,
-0.0322168507,
-0.0094363187,
0.0232274439,
0.0748740807,
0.0524748415,
0.0135182636,
-0.0475533083,
-0.0209547654,
-0.0251379739,
0.000547601,
-0.0108577432,
0.0278329831,
0.0356425568,
0.0341847353,
-0.009412881,
-0.0147852935,
0.0509154201,
0.0288351029,
-0.0116327098,
0.0365535542,
0.0337761529,
-0.0752861947,
-0.0527203381,
0.0219354443,
0.084426716,
-0.0349711142,
0.0081064748,
0.0548475645,
-0.0111305928,
0.0251036361,
0.0209077969,
-0.0363954194,
0.0210474711,
-0.0184697248,
0.0259922016,
0.0299025662,
-0.0318236127,
0.0074553755,
-0.0106080575,
-0.0255545322,
0.0526616722,
-0.0110221347,
-0.0337977521,
-0.0248667002,
0.0105534745,
-0.0371278375,
-0.0318481401,
0.0160937123,
0.0323800147,
-0.0245046597,
0.0186528675,
-0.0503746942,
-0.0576113202,
0.0208369866,
0.0174385477,
0.0353343301,
-0.0114122601,
-0.0023745664,
0.0158918351,
-0.0459095314,
-0.0074537303,
0.039724607,
0.0574612506,
-0.0914554894,
0.0207514185,
-0.107224308,
-0.0008270294,
-0.0482562669,
0.0787706524,
-0.0259433631,
0.0033658782,
-0.0399006307,
-0.0047818744,
-0.0026490099,
0.0272197425,
0.0548426881,
0.0074810032,
-0.0326723009,
0.0061442638,
0.021564154,
0.0294507071,
-0.0035783823,
-0.0095539736,
0.0169657432,
-0.0428188182,
-0.0193831399,
0.0036133192,
0.0305858068,
-0.0287948065,
-0.0281732082,
0.0473957472,
-0.0564500913,
-0.0422774032,
-0.0383050814,
-0.0826313496,
-0.0148785692,
-0.0591537356,
-0.0063971705,
-0.0572417565,
0.0178418364,
0.0108756786,
0.0189197809,
-0.0607828833,
0.025697276,
-0.0358178467,
-0.0033712951,
0.0640943125,
-0.0167408865,
0.0084732128,
0.0013373578,
0.0258271489,
-0.0288528297,
0.0580445863,
0.0270033646,
0.0096463962,
-0.0017127002,
-0.0203047805,
-0.0242834985,
0.0019041013,
0.0349352099,
-0.0313502103,
-0.0300064944,
-0.0230853204,
0.0449928455,
0.0424404666,
0.0193291865,
0.0624460317,
-0.0238931384,
0.036246255,
0.0514846928,
0.0089417184,
0.0319412649,
0.0220394488,
0.0791767389,
0.0286398362,
-0.0185371302,
0.0541792735,
-0.0017699477,
-0.0246522352,
0.0217169542,
0.0444100611,
0.0510527603,
0.0175791513,
-0.0137372753,
-0.047674112,
-0.0007210826,
-0.0250614583,
-0.0159431286,
-0.0174273681,
0.045630239,
0.0470850058,
-0.0241575781,
0.0531280152,
0.0285311732,
-0.0646564439,
0.0389393307,
-0.0099964626,
0.0531055294,
0.0675189495,
0.0453993753,
-0.0166551713,
-0.0328840241,
-0.0234226119,
0.0142921722,
-0.0209312998,
0.0160101205,
-0.0512817577,
0.0041521462,
-0.0368411653,
-0.0463567711,
0.001605503,
0.0076781265,
0.0110709332,
-0.0133718038,
-0.0167140178,
0.0410709083,
-0.0566208921,
-0.0226206724,
0.0400033668,
-0.0513762496,
-0.0496233813,
-0.0216059219,
0.0151821999,
0.0458239354,
0.02901843,
-0.0309407096,
0.0135219963,
0.0455233566,
-0.0615812726,
-0.01813359,
-0.020502178,
-0.0498474166,
-0.1139935628,
0.0399784073,
0.0085198516,
-0.0255942997,
-0.0482828692,
-0.0581826642,
-0.0602009743,
-0.0136781167,
-0.0056761126,
0.0217403248,
-0.0275498368,
0.0080147497,
0.0703655705,
-0.0025153565,
-0.0588326864,
0.0371153466,
-0.0138011398,
0.0231044628,
-0.0256019011,
-0.0150830969,
-0.0333424658,
-0.0239891298,
-0.0032141404,
0.0403162763,
0.0043345662,
-0.0081549902,
-0.0293086469,
0.0235406943,
-0.0549996905,
-0.0270810816,
-0.047498703,
-0.0175480284,
-0.0275149755,
0.0044100923,
0.0052425209,
-0.0001626918,
0.0091964956,
-0.014753853,
-0.033460103,
-0.0095660808,
-0.0021422051,
0.0106904022,
0.0276309606,
0.0808555037,
-0.0096060112,
-0.006628775,
0.003999555,
0.0091800997,
0.043440558,
0.001116838,
0.015601417,
-0.0548057593,
0.0316249728,
-0.0385083929,
-0.0094936509,
0.0276105441,
-0.0310036261,
0.0016177428,
-0.0196171664,
0.0236902013,
0.0100915339,
-0.0320245698,
-0.0135650076,
0.046993129,
-0.011785578,
-0.0615561306,
0.0055365851,
-0.002634513,
-0.0237218477,
-0.0059141917,
-0.0170929767,
-0.0088925939,
0.1036312357,
0.0003702498,
-0.0240834169,
-0.0470906794,
-0.000427039,
0.0007442628,
-0.0485706069,
-0.021823559,
-0.0013789959,
-0.0078507876,
0.0069249771,
-0.0030822069,
-0.0308034886,
0.0756569356,
-0.0046380865,
-0.0079862233,
-0.0270249788,
-0.0183654949,
-0.0082886424,
0.0443506315,
0.026518343,
0.0207086485,
0.0435902849,
-0.0195958484,
-0.0317169614,
0.010937511,
0.0027203551,
-0.0218491945,
0.0359864794,
-0.0967493728,
0.0029555759,
-0.0086740535,
-0.0116753057,
-0.0352742709,
-0.0283115283,
-0.0111300852,
0.0195529498,
0.0209078323,
0.0296487454,
0.0172210839,
0.0153539842,
-0.0042239372,
0.0611907728,
0.0466842726,
-0.001931034,
-0.0347196944,
0.0344379656,
0.0212273095,
-0.0108546969,
-0.0661395267,
-0.0083082486,
0.0335408896,
0.0446214341,
0.0714862496,
0.0070035392,
-0.0083448282,
0.0001891427,
0.0002012631,
-0.0462107249,
-0.0298109781,
0.0284551047,
0.0340962037,
-0.0462270565,
-0.0077800336,
0.117208302,
0.0214212444,
-0.0231724326,
0.029063262,
0.0364053138,
0.0197404362,
0.0099962447,
0.0139329731,
-0.0730696842,
-0.0253265928,
-0.0057405857,
0.0238295849,
0.0059734704,
-0.0597570948,
-0.004354273,
-0.1351216137,
0.0052442676,
0.0317169316,
-0.0395719483,
0.0019213146,
-0.0254415888,
-0.0392435752,
-0.025639087,
-0.0294865873,
0.0406033248,
-0.0361665115,
0.040049307,
0.0617764182,
-0.0168997571,
-0.0997915864,
-0.0122718727,
-0.0205203537,
0.0427704379,
0.0593506359,
0.0024686309,
0.0229126457,
-0.0196947586,
0.0273482669,
-0.008097915,
0.0334397033,
-0.0311757289,
0.0597218163,
-0.0102581503,
-0.0175717156,
0.0388222784,
0.0507255085,
-0.0533535779,
-0.0304014366,
-0.0006972528,
0.074473381,
0.0045034727,
-0.024137225,
0.0228394568,
-0.0253612176,
0.0270007532,
0.0565843396,
0.0663330629,
-0.0169921666,
-0.0163046233,
-0.0124306995,
0.0207271557,
-0.0586680695,
0.0405960269,
0.0356045514,
-0.0480099879,
-0.0036468618,
-0.1010010913,
-0.0374368839,
0.08206705,
0.0511900075,
0.0167588927,
0.027435489,
0.028407434,
0.0013654265,
-0.0364364684,
0.0051214155,
-0.0185901374,
-0.0174482521,
-0.0443176888,
-0.069714345,
0.0336448886,
-0.0115672117,
-0.0148286866,
-0.0163403824,
-0.0534117743,
-0.0825342089,
0.0159598552,
0.0908840224,
0.0158647988,
0.0457611345,
0.0262410678,
-0.0562533811,
0.0578748286,
0.0828968659,
-0.0074644894,
-0.0157802384,
0.004712028,
-0.019498663,
0.0058036386,
0.03643113,
-0.0108862687,
0.0019632964,
0.01959306,
0.0703461617,
-0.0474991798,
-0.0216468181,
0.0345917754,
0.0535067506,
0.0623706728,
-0.0318166018,
0.059061911,
-0.0082733063,
0.0104483049,
0.0119066788,
-0.0023106236,
-0.0536859892,
0.0009277597,
0.0402049012,
-0.0164923947,
0.0271653254,
0.0225464292,
-0.0233726613,
0.0596026666,
-0.0257025603,
0.0199368652,
-0.026580736,
-0.0332935825,
0.0546749905,
0.0050172247,
0.0102925785,
0.0101048341,
0.0015812793,
0.0081047267,
-0.011284356,
0.021860471,
0.0226744153,
0.087020196,
0.0067826342,
0.0308528244,
-0.0375322625,
-0.0226008203,
-0.032582134,
0.0230612233,
0.0545156077,
-0.0060792384,
0.043951042,
-0.0060921339,
-0.0073239892,
-0.0185094029,
0.0700932741,
-0.0613758042,
-0.021636989,
0.0048335963,
0.0440397114,
-0.0192302428,
-0.0152132101,
0.1443324834,
0.005900471,
0.0597732849,
-0.0090619819,
0.0035328243,
-0.0764156133,
-0.0379749201,
0.0301052127,
-0.0084406761,
-0.0273559801,
0.0045221397,
-0.0108543709,
-0.0785338357,
-0.002844509,
0.0093671829,
-0.0009750949,
-0.0207314361,
0.0724592134,
0.0276260972,
-0.0178871155,
-0.0074896049,
-0.043532405,
0.0198049042,
0.0661080033,
-0.0566292293,
0.0288003553,
-6.097310871e-33,
-0.0178982392,
-0.0243852288,
0.0199992955,
0.0108364411,
-0.0044598095,
-0.0205545686,
-0.0183048099,
0.0245623887,
0.0562803857,
0.0161135122,
-0.0149481539,
-0.0355135612,
0.0190491136,
0.0535738617,
0.054033272,
-0.0065615429,
0.0711852461,
-0.0093929861,
0.0232270788,
0.0307947192,
0.0137528069,
0.0817146525,
0.035591267,
-0.0254902449,
0.009340981,
-0.0027225569,
0.0262189414,
-0.020869324,
-0.0115554566,
0.0249994677,
0.0079078991,
0.0303999018,
0.015131074,
-0.0317123234,
-0.0571237169,
-0.0256896,
-0.0680699199,
-0.0188145787,
0.0004297436,
-0.0016118395,
-0.0340763442,
-0.0562346242,
0.0480357297,
-0.035081815,
-0.0220435057,
0.0553402528,
0.0264623202,
-0.0271250773,
-0.0596337169,
-0.0585816987,
-0.021520935,
-0.0021941343,
-0.0228731707,
-0.0494711883,
0.0450068004,
0.0197402183,
-0.0102909151,
0.0165496916,
-0.0322073065,
0.020941766,
0.035615094,
0.0716716722,
0.06256935,
0.0242345966,
0.0135874562,
0.0154863475,
0.0059062652,
0.010788816,
0.0064315889,
0.0087709399,
-0.0233117063,
0.0737270415,
-0.01116734,
0.0465388708,
0.043822974,
-0.0003819389,
-0.0009961524,
0.0344100483,
-0.0259025954,
0.0017208422,
-0.015025435,
0.0319531672,
0.0152754411,
-0.0227337945,
-0.0376698375,
-0.0318377577,
0.0022359255,
-0.0239245016,
0.0293965321,
0.0188399516,
-0.0401936583,
0.0103812879,
0.0220020041,
-0.0289537758,
-0.0432034247,
-0.0394092686,
-0.0006476642,
0.0098419897,
-0.0183464065,
-0.0458042026,
-0.1080112308,
-0.0581304692,
0.0268256329,
0.0126268156,
0.0244092494,
0.0031189641,
0.080115743,
0.009501894,
-0.0360199511,
0.0179280844,
-0.0453361645,
0.0178513415,
0.0005800988,
0.0062912833,
0.0586802922,
0.0014094854,
-0.0336899273,
0.0133297713,
0.0154163782,
-0.0539074019,
-0.0184870176,
-0.0124223595,
-0.0074717156,
-0.0064970586,
-0.0164698232,
-0.0010077412,
-0.0221260153,
0.0096961791,
0.0326162465,
0.0078178775,
-0.0089976965,
0.0083318101,
2.758e-7,
0.0159052387,
0.0275292117,
0.016376989,
-0.027793942,
0.0250887293,
0.0209120605,
-0.0368069336,
0.0284070596,
-0.0214000437,
-0.0707249045,
0.0129308719,
-0.0011330387,
0.0442320146,
0.0206188541,
-0.0894344077,
-0.0123107871,
-0.0284613557,
0.0205504373,
-0.0537512451,
-0.0235328078,
0.056700062,
0.0491831005,
0.0085975882,
-0.0249542035,
0.0008000779,
-0.0467619039,
0.0335009098,
-0.0087318225,
-0.0245626122,
0.0297548249,
0.014309207,
-0.0110983765,
0.0012448123,
0.0419867672,
-0.014720683,
-0.0484315045,
0.0102290455,
0.0627318099,
0.0082779936,
0.0315530039,
0.0333684906,
0.017401766,
0.0091634402,
-0.0265743043,
0.0476379171,
-0.0890450627,
-0.0058059753,
0.0545481145,
-0.0198818799,
0.0030299379,
0.0091078589,
-0.0200615209,
0.0291487761,
0.0647084862,
0.0106131928,
0.0037997484,
-0.0422561578,
-0.0288656671,
-0.0310567487,
0.012316945,
-0.0505114831,
-0.0265504774,
-0.0314837098,
-0.0184574947,
-0.0187533423,
-0.0183674432,
-0.0234222095,
2.235845127e-34,
0.0143222893,
0.0015107964,
0.0245931149,
0.0305631887,
-0.00085708,
-0.0323754288,
-0.097415939,
0.0414770916,
-0.0134167485,
-0.0450849012,
-0.0108708832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08637v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08637v1 | Formal Proofs as Structured Explanations: Proposing Several Tasks on Explainable Natural Language Inference | 2023-11-15T01:24:09 | 2023-11-15T01:24:09 | Lasha Abzianidze | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | In this position paper, we propose a way of exploiting formal proofs to put
forward several explainable natural language inference (NLI) tasks. The formal
proofs will be produced by a reliable and high-performing logic-based NLI
system. Taking advantage of the in-depth information available in the generated
formal proofs, we show how it can be used to define NLI tasks with structured
explanations. The proposed tasks can be ordered according to difficulty defined
in terms of the granularity of explanations. We argue that the tasks will
suffer with substantially fewer shortcomings than the existing explainable NLI
tasks (or datasets). | [
0.0130893504,
0.0767870024,
-0.0054365075,
0.0342646204,
-0.0225642659,
0.0183628947,
0.025754692,
-0.0273796394,
0.0053439704,
0.0081115942,
0.0570104308,
0.0787101686,
0.0197251905,
0.060401354,
0.040032763,
-0.0808588266,
0.0147972601,
-0.0346894674,
0.0179114696,
0.0078030652,
0.0079779904,
0.0275654905,
-0.0074349446,
0.0172753539,
0.0150161264,
0.000978315,
-0.0470480397,
0.0096432865,
-0.0258707013,
-0.0158683248,
-0.0462510772,
-0.0100491801,
0.0488674119,
-0.0015667793,
0.0000019222,
-0.053875912,
-0.0085541215,
0.0581228919,
-0.0912783071,
-0.0151628423,
-0.0575644411,
-0.0163569897,
0.0470677502,
0.0167690944,
0.0155557021,
0.0102580898,
0.0538854338,
0.0731987208,
0.0673877001,
0.0430323146,
-0.0185508933,
-0.0597902387,
-0.0312892273,
0.0071835984,
-0.0062773647,
-0.0243223757,
-0.021112293,
0.0239315499,
0.0331021212,
-0.0164411943,
0.0245431177,
0.0108965691,
0.0514146909,
-0.0233090539,
-0.0395710245,
0.0071852971,
-0.02618807,
-0.0005621157,
0.0034618191,
0.029526718,
0.0408653654,
-0.0541014411,
0.0055187405,
-0.0061921366,
-0.0114211496,
0.0115763955,
-0.0068454682,
0.0394286141,
-0.0417573601,
0.0136102187,
0.0312689133,
0.0099880071,
0.0817487314,
0.0171880182,
-0.0277919602,
0.0900931284,
-0.0042955992,
0.00555901,
-0.0189322904,
0.0113198422,
0.0182465874,
-0.0546273626,
0.0155782234,
0.0538911633,
-0.050977584,
0.0295317695,
0.0093425233,
0.0008334799,
-0.0340076573,
-0.0190357883,
-0.0060084835,
0.0184137635,
0.0128972782,
0.0550932251,
-0.0235445499,
0.0274150297,
-0.0203052815,
0.0161212962,
-0.0022231101,
-0.0589989126,
-0.0752764344,
-0.0189935565,
-0.0077059134,
0.021162102,
-0.0264337137,
0.0408069901,
-0.0132776797,
0.0173501577,
-0.0390483849,
0.0290814452,
-0.0090164505,
-0.0060390942,
-0.0409989879,
-0.0388096161,
-0.0559972189,
-0.0359282196,
-0.0652921498,
0.0082137389,
0.0239938963,
-0.0190097019,
-0.0068158219,
0.0302833095,
0.0290577486,
0.0061338414,
-0.0047288272,
0.079755038,
0.0268059205,
0.0437647328,
-0.0434791408,
-0.0580006242,
0.0028220078,
-0.0345206298,
-0.0483953394,
-0.0220366549,
0.0153247016,
0.0125865554,
-0.0197872184,
-0.0138633344,
-0.0163717344,
-0.016546689,
-0.0258299038,
0.0920668617,
-0.0636731163,
0.0020666728,
0.0205604993,
-0.0041897399,
-0.0489374623,
0.0354678147,
0.0176162887,
0.0104355747,
0.0387960561,
-0.0148651451,
0.021430308,
-0.0278367978,
0.0144771961,
-0.0360362828,
-0.0014140023,
0.0027048031,
-0.060629651,
0.0183835477,
0.0045339074,
0.014991927,
0.0178563874,
0.03315451,
-0.0093576098,
0.0235914886,
0.0236280225,
-0.0055142124,
0.0481653251,
-0.0080321031,
-0.0093685556,
0.0506064706,
-0.0633428022,
0.0224636476,
-0.0391604863,
0.0077747717,
-0.0009207636,
-0.0086672753,
-0.0043908996,
-0.1147499308,
-0.0135182347,
-0.0107213929,
0.0035349675,
0.0228268895,
0.0739283934,
0.0237026699,
0.0121029727,
0.0328772254,
0.0427756757,
-0.0451922975,
0.0112576718,
-0.0749048144,
0.0661088973,
0.0496220328,
0.0418430567,
-0.0593977533,
0.0072451844,
-0.0172119644,
-0.0008678666,
0.0335919559,
-0.0075412379,
-0.0168144852,
0.0326001048,
0.0037460809,
-0.0015249092,
-0.0348325111,
0.0352786221,
0.005380183,
0.0487839989,
-0.0219318811,
0.0230069198,
-0.043478217,
-0.0584241003,
0.027771201,
0.0047486853,
-0.0308723468,
0.0233306699,
0.02490904,
0.0497109629,
0.0281127654,
0.0020544706,
0.0090740351,
-0.0063956277,
-0.0067707268,
-0.0015590165,
0.0415128209,
0.0304312222,
-0.0328118876,
-0.0087136524,
-0.0566593297,
-0.0345834978,
0.0146482084,
-0.0688690543,
-0.0359260775,
0.0269607864,
-0.0419170111,
0.000949209,
-0.0040926789,
-0.0327536464,
0.0225910097,
-0.01408411,
0.0187221859,
0.0530666187,
0.0476575978,
-0.0209880006,
-0.0072850995,
-0.0248858407,
0.004875293,
-0.0307016429,
0.0401301682,
-0.0041966629,
-0.013762719,
-0.0259547867,
0.0238317735,
-0.0248614866,
0.0021822599,
0.0412722304,
0.0084725497,
-0.0152155571,
-0.018381441,
0.0248202477,
0.0132783409,
0.0115327677,
0.0227212384,
-0.0452873111,
0.0044378578,
0.0053904075,
0.0278714523,
-0.021437237,
0.0926404148,
-0.0138395606,
-0.0488579758,
-0.0241114311,
0.0039410559,
-0.042094931,
0.0607664138,
0.0233849082,
-0.0104407622,
-0.0659862384,
-0.0215966403,
-0.0244714692,
0.0173636544,
-0.0128952842,
0.0080701401,
0.0441110171,
-0.0126945395,
-0.0212091673,
0.0768526867,
-0.010887647,
0.0484004803,
0.0186691079,
-0.0075981659,
-0.0083116079,
0.0019291651,
-0.0328083672,
0.0055694133,
-0.0223650411,
-0.0542726703,
0.0377867371,
0.0361932926,
-0.0306016319,
-0.0176678281,
-0.0277145281,
0.0422154963,
0.0160691105,
0.0076303035,
-0.004986241,
-0.0598563217,
0.005570007,
0.0686473325,
-0.0131651955,
-0.064150691,
0.0761114061,
-0.0287466403,
0.0118111204,
-0.0259864554,
-0.0533523299,
-0.066023089,
0.1022833586,
-0.0086334767,
0.0105054528,
0.0333624445,
0.017033346,
0.0004324015,
-0.0729469955,
0.083756119,
0.0447945446,
0.0351410471,
-0.0971311107,
-0.0016412811,
0.0233089328,
-0.0009550523,
-0.0386014283,
-0.0060848086,
-0.0712626204,
-0.0148067037,
-0.0017150075,
-0.0312294532,
-0.0086162314,
-0.0095557813,
0.0278848875,
-0.0018727743,
0.0376455858,
0.0050617331,
-0.0293952636,
-0.0324299112,
-0.0055261133,
0.0541221611,
0.0143220313,
-0.0037329139,
0.024559617,
0.0232898649,
-0.0097777378,
0.0022811964,
-0.0438774228,
0.0177058913,
-0.0275091212,
-0.053924337,
0.0170642901,
0.0118790641,
0.0258809067,
-0.0717901289,
0.000699433,
0.0863634199,
0.0094583994,
0.0262841843,
0.0129037267,
0.0075132833,
0.0002929718,
-0.0002506514,
0.0281758942,
-0.0451468229,
-0.0330094434,
0.0156621542,
0.0072390102,
-0.0186564047,
0.0131755564,
-0.0337886289,
-0.0909042433,
0.038279146,
-0.0165236872,
-0.0370433815,
-0.0295164343,
-0.0959045291,
-0.0073689967,
0.0044275462,
-0.0446195006,
-0.0269879736,
0.0576718822,
0.0210485049,
0.0278883725,
-0.0457666814,
-0.0093250666,
0.0065689101,
-0.0449047722,
0.0323919468,
-0.0005587396,
0.0315954462,
-0.0009181234,
-0.0197817124,
-0.0112766083,
0.0386783406,
0.0043355995,
0.0033939381,
0.0678585544,
0.0253564529,
0.0000912708,
-0.0792455077,
0.0492850058,
-0.0333482586,
-0.0436929241,
0.029319698,
0.0512615889,
-0.0043942882,
-0.0466305166,
0.0042061172,
0.0002499567,
-0.001388088,
0.0851343051,
0.0286718365,
0.0220942628,
-0.0174218975,
-0.0584646128,
-0.0113046132,
-0.0504302084,
-0.024263978,
-0.0011985522,
-0.0137582645,
-0.0459450632,
-0.0202761497,
-0.0178900138,
0.0244439784,
0.0759719759,
0.0045421966,
-0.021010628,
0.0091098612,
-0.0140486946,
-0.0256265029,
0.0565207116,
-0.0282411948,
-0.0089937253,
0.0337112248,
-0.0375311524,
-0.0134012671,
0.0037239525,
-0.0261471774,
0.0427973196,
-0.0071630972,
-0.0375769734,
-0.0415239744,
0.0194280185,
0.0281247664,
0.0441928506,
-0.0289694536,
-0.0365821272,
-0.0134326061,
0.0198254045,
-0.0345919318,
-0.0631473139,
0.0668340921,
-0.0048588295,
0.0297728442,
0.0596147925,
-0.0461326875,
-0.0059551802,
-0.0201343391,
0.0167218298,
-0.005892111,
-0.018496938,
0.0379911065,
0.0438817143,
0.0152540654,
-0.0038448926,
-0.0436057672,
-0.0144680757,
0.0214295983,
-0.0443198308,
-0.0494782887,
-0.0327377915,
0.0543384664,
-0.028721571,
0.0135581354,
-0.0101571074,
-0.0387347415,
-0.0078722807,
-0.0207209084,
-0.0075843832,
0.0042385017,
0.0398092046,
-0.0018261368,
-0.011866983,
-0.0091515267,
-0.0097096236,
-0.0178589392,
-0.0076337224,
0.0590151064,
-0.0180141944,
0.0152621977,
0.0599560402,
0.0040931758,
-0.0557257272,
-0.027118586,
-0.0427680425,
-0.0517340377,
0.0509039089,
0.0052061528,
0.0299195051,
-0.0200676974,
0.0204903465,
0.0040951408,
-0.0092432611,
0.0475744754,
0.0722056553,
0.02858858,
-0.0402311832,
-0.0144952768,
0.0054702293,
-0.037776649,
-0.0265770499,
0.0345327631,
0.0056977719,
-0.0113946944,
0.0151372878,
-0.0199877508,
-0.0167020448,
-0.0365555733,
-0.0349040888,
0.0269936007,
-0.0011119259,
-0.0028454503,
-0.0248115938,
-0.0791270509,
-0.0256402716,
0.0210622344,
-0.0087677417,
0.020769082,
0.0008962824,
0.0697202906,
0.0376402773,
-0.0783850923,
-0.0147914942,
0.0114685241,
0.010858818,
-0.0127582001,
0.0056821923,
-5.822005318e-33,
-0.0260314532,
-0.051198896,
0.0033413658,
0.0067583942,
0.0497008041,
-0.0068863034,
-0.0919070989,
-0.0426317155,
0.0012291817,
0.0634497032,
0.0178298652,
0.0483310297,
0.0173684824,
-0.003816244,
-0.0293813348,
-0.0399918221,
0.0041125906,
0.0635767579,
-0.0361904502,
0.0019135398,
0.0350683741,
-0.0404335447,
0.0618422143,
-0.0643928349,
0.0759604052,
0.0201856736,
-0.0111164544,
0.0312309805,
-0.0464090742,
0.0193635467,
0.0187445115,
0.0325559862,
0.0094755068,
-0.021819137,
0.0314476192,
0.0153422402,
-0.0821731389,
-0.0181556083,
0.0702913329,
0.0053507001,
-0.0542425774,
-0.0273511056,
0.0435612462,
-0.0046498389,
0.023611594,
-0.007340889,
0.0550358668,
-0.0064292788,
0.0431331843,
0.0007421866,
-0.0258540679,
0.0342045948,
-0.0550777875,
-0.0208813064,
0.0088412864,
0.0194354951,
-0.0081915436,
-0.0363828987,
-0.0216127131,
-0.0165446587,
0.0310510471,
-0.0144444779,
0.0542931929,
-0.0342786312,
-0.0012608233,
0.0226101708,
0.0107189165,
0.0108395508,
-0.0907772034,
0.0076098642,
-0.0447524041,
0.0593143404,
0.0678522438,
0.0161764212,
0.0424199365,
0.0624711514,
-0.0853027552,
0.0426490344,
-0.0028376202,
0.0339347906,
0.0223705173,
-0.0079300357,
-0.0839080215,
-0.0372221321,
-0.0284044705,
0.0010819306,
-0.0262713637,
-0.0034911856,
0.0087553468,
-0.0303792916,
-0.0670956671,
-0.0126358913,
-0.0336205363,
-0.0496688932,
0.0102171293,
-0.0251032002,
0.0446668155,
-0.034238223,
0.0152147133,
0.0110821305,
0.023082871,
0.0073726969,
-0.0071626231,
0.0278641768,
0.0556732677,
-0.0095462529,
0.0056001702,
0.0081345886,
0.0042654779,
0.0195699986,
-0.0858406797,
-0.041913785,
-0.0485124663,
-0.0003361938,
0.039512381,
0.0609748624,
-0.0188634414,
0.011717747,
-0.006079399,
-0.0100316051,
-0.0143305091,
0.0610538721,
-0.0026096443,
-0.0029780378,
0.0013722795,
-0.0501130968,
-0.0155420769,
-0.0558295511,
0.0238717236,
-0.0179125573,
-0.0097298492,
0.0074811615,
2.551e-7,
0.0169408321,
0.0034706288,
0.0475481041,
0.0730953515,
-0.0024343943,
0.017231347,
0.0190969612,
-0.04406083,
-0.0278025921,
-0.0444736108,
0.0046474482,
0.0645078942,
0.0381072648,
0.0322891772,
-0.0271722768,
-0.0194643773,
-0.0239713341,
-0.0427164584,
-0.0418011136,
0.0107132811,
0.101835303,
0.0287402421,
0.0562282726,
0.0151994657,
0.0140020177,
-0.0639024302,
-0.015216602,
-0.0062289573,
0.0252495892,
-0.0054621538,
0.0590486936,
-0.0005866629,
0.0310718492,
0.0246133022,
-0.0100834724,
-0.0321454369,
-0.0520940311,
0.0333875902,
-0.0189614445,
0.0043580164,
-0.0848892257,
-0.0736001804,
0.0528807752,
-0.0134623535,
0.0745054483,
-0.0158275403,
-0.0583114773,
0.0139329955,
-0.0184107348,
-0.0403542072,
-0.0490510091,
0.0426645651,
0.0024501618,
0.0051900456,
-0.0019681156,
-0.0370523334,
0.0043247775,
-0.0664998889,
-0.0460209623,
0.0258294456,
-0.0210711695,
0.0340449736,
-0.0035321456,
-0.0036133167,
0.0668349937,
-0.0310049355,
0.0093233734,
2.246488631e-34,
-0.0121654561,
0.0456816107,
0.0034131345,
0.0370715186,
0.115444161,
0.0211849231,
-0.059103623,
-0.0169637762,
0.0894383565,
-0.02662527,
-0.0134852724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08623v1 | DEED: Dynamic Early Exit on Decoder for Accelerating Encoder-Decoder Transformer Models | 2023-11-15T01:01:02 | 2023-11-15T01:01:02 | Peng Tang, Pengkai Zhu, Tian Li, Srikar Appalaraju, Vijay Mahadevan, R. Manmatha | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Encoder-decoder transformer models have achieved great success on various
vision-language (VL) tasks, but they suffer from high inference latency.
Typically, the decoder takes up most of the latency because of the
auto-regressive decoding. To accelerate the inference, we propose an approach
of performing Dynamic Early Exit on Decoder (DEED). We build a multi-exit
encoder-decoder transformer model which is trained with deep supervision so
that each of its decoder layers is capable of generating plausible predictions.
In addition, we leverage simple yet practical techniques, including shared
generation head and adaptation modules, to keep accuracy when exiting at
shallow decoder layers. Based on the multi-exit model, we perform step-level
dynamic early exit during inference, where the model may decide to use fewer
decoder layers based on its confidence of the current layer at each individual
decoding step. Considering different number of decoder layers may be used at
different decoding steps, we compute deeper-layer decoder features of previous
decoding steps just-in-time, which ensures the features from different decoding
steps are semantically aligned. We evaluate our approach with two
state-of-the-art encoder-decoder transformer models on various VL tasks. We
show our approach can reduce overall inference latency by 30%-60% with
comparable or even higher accuracy compared to baselines. | [
-0.0059890202,
0.0703595579,
0.0278340317,
0.0167825632,
0.0206842534,
0.0246111229,
0.0071606375,
-0.0537000522,
-0.0451322123,
0.0149253421,
-0.0066163489,
0.0116831167,
0.025085697,
0.0342182182,
-0.0239321869,
-0.0560906865,
-0.0095304726,
-0.0436114222,
-0.0270929877,
-0.0022446672,
-0.0125150019,
0.0336668938,
-0.0204998106,
0.0713153034,
-0.0017053593,
-0.0185033996,
-0.0404613912,
0.0276524629,
0.0415395685,
-0.0061061024,
-0.0023134195,
0.0224356782,
0.0302101374,
0.0174762905,
0.0000019172,
-0.0063314284,
-0.0055845887,
0.0008136655,
-0.0416483097,
-0.0244366396,
-0.0181829482,
-0.0842803568,
-0.014182725,
0.010885681,
-0.0057948185,
-0.0761896297,
0.0820228383,
-0.0079752579,
0.0441009551,
0.0359938256,
-0.0121129686,
-0.0478790551,
0.0431196243,
-0.0314612761,
-0.0263695214,
-0.0412133746,
-0.0083583472,
-0.0053849639,
-0.0794486478,
-0.0548727773,
-0.0634127632,
0.0458196811,
0.0761952773,
-0.0133272484,
-0.0130377337,
0.0219097082,
0.018621074,
-0.0551471896,
-0.0241494328,
0.0326922424,
-0.0422840752,
-0.0180051159,
-0.0383971184,
-0.0266504195,
-0.0058627529,
-0.0411574729,
-0.0072579687,
0.0424864329,
-0.0216352902,
0.0298076738,
0.0129681332,
0.0686111003,
0.0014366073,
-0.0029569787,
-0.0163364783,
-0.0005767113,
0.0164123084,
0.0383841507,
-0.015386384,
0.0589801781,
0.0202076212,
-0.0180546157,
0.0051466906,
0.0083592804,
0.0070455298,
-0.005813784,
-0.0687900558,
-0.0441924557,
-0.0599528141,
-0.0153356893,
0.0311030541,
0.0790067166,
-0.054762546,
0.0288832188,
-0.0266902,
0.0482127368,
-0.0486386493,
0.0080002211,
-0.0205345061,
-0.0409755744,
0.0064247409,
-0.0067649684,
-0.0360942669,
-0.0074398918,
-0.0387556665,
-0.0164830368,
-0.039118249,
0.014675797,
-0.0158730317,
-0.0208444167,
0.0389250219,
0.0501393527,
-0.0598636866,
-0.0493617505,
0.0185062569,
0.0616318174,
-0.0069793528,
0.020883467,
-0.0022974762,
-0.082393378,
-0.0191944633,
0.0464329943,
0.0182235241,
-0.0154796131,
-0.0072435508,
0.0560100116,
-0.0461317897,
-0.0020329098,
-0.0301062707,
0.0115831448,
0.0058347643,
-0.022623986,
0.0266341455,
-0.0539396442,
0.038984064,
0.0027656243,
0.0119898207,
-0.0400300547,
-0.0074824532,
-0.0100135822,
0.0331170261,
0.0444602743,
-0.0036169167,
-0.0096479347,
0.0330581777,
0.0050129863,
-0.0131788002,
0.0673415661,
0.015701035,
0.0373985134,
-0.0238278601,
-0.0005918049,
0.0335328467,
0.0670000836,
-0.0108796591,
0.0127131278,
-0.0428482667,
-0.0277462322,
-0.0071903751,
0.009422808,
0.0912759528,
0.0142926713,
-0.0570420623,
-0.0179592054,
0.0584141947,
0.004929841,
0.0246851351,
0.0076580676,
0.0740426555,
0.0054153106,
-0.021821579,
0.0005119793,
-0.0335477181,
0.0562310815,
0.0091179162,
-0.0045382632,
-0.0271439198,
0.0500643626,
-0.0534630194,
-0.0440452434,
0.0256486367,
-0.0248210989,
0.0092127947,
0.0145691801,
0.0448945984,
0.034473002,
-0.066256687,
0.0357565768,
-0.0091670314,
-0.0196508504,
0.0137509638,
-0.0366127267,
-0.027975142,
0.0530139692,
0.0239610467,
0.0525147505,
-0.0449492484,
0.0224339794,
0.0020632725,
0.0350623019,
-0.0064097163,
-0.0082732597,
0.0522583015,
-0.0792946815,
-0.0534250587,
0.0285936538,
0.0056452677,
0.0197042339,
0.0194098838,
-0.0008440269,
0.0071214815,
-0.0073759314,
0.0171834417,
0.033063136,
-0.0105375247,
0.0037655772,
0.0035181111,
0.0262781605,
-0.0144401053,
-0.0245778207,
-0.0042358376,
-0.0263523217,
0.0053240336,
-0.0489175841,
0.0015458977,
0.0468178019,
-0.0678802282,
-0.0652253032,
-0.0013139276,
-0.0590733588,
-0.0079299724,
0.0579707399,
-0.0218104441,
-0.0200047046,
0.0119701223,
-0.0345177203,
0.027105689,
-0.0232070237,
0.0136411851,
0.0194928534,
0.0167656764,
0.0043215477,
0.0343337804,
-0.0434261188,
-0.0381515175,
0.037012361,
-0.0020980188,
-0.0202819444,
-0.0007741457,
-0.0043183868,
-0.0058467044,
-0.0186532289,
-0.0068958844,
0.0317414217,
0.0039465218,
0.011085121,
-0.0191533994,
-0.0490431003,
-0.0326428451,
-0.0408150926,
-0.0022317008,
-0.0027144689,
0.007884426,
0.0242343731,
-0.0470864996,
0.0020688788,
0.0455544963,
0.0029326687,
-0.0151767433,
-0.0337347202,
0.0044592144,
-0.0253811628,
0.0033013273,
-0.0134338941,
0.0425029099,
0.0575393625,
-0.0043876357,
-0.048356317,
-0.033323314,
-0.0181441456,
0.0284447968,
0.042425584,
-0.0143481009,
-0.0476821773,
0.0060197641,
-0.0161712598,
0.0200585052,
0.0457299799,
-0.0049102204,
0.0664652213,
0.0201447513,
-0.0049969279,
-0.03668762,
0.0011061011,
-0.0193904992,
-0.0562546402,
-0.0833928511,
0.003149288,
-0.0499821231,
0.0746493191,
0.0103598284,
0.0370003432,
-0.1061332598,
-0.0072554061,
0.0213032011,
-0.0531818233,
0.0115831029,
-0.0209015086,
-0.0051406226,
0.0405582152,
-0.029981574,
-0.0526338257,
0.0424196273,
-0.0121910181,
-0.0403768308,
0.0263277721,
0.0334751867,
-0.0043112538,
0.0716497377,
0.0098437639,
0.0123500917,
-0.0086968457,
-0.0543297641,
-0.0506229922,
0.0273167677,
0.0268648118,
-0.0163967907,
0.049806308,
-0.0703802183,
-0.0115689663,
-0.0310639758,
-0.013451444,
-0.0557896309,
0.0608686656,
-0.0380382538,
0.0083070202,
-0.0099724475,
-0.0289806165,
-0.0564866513,
-0.0080641741,
-0.0221166182,
0.0805718154,
0.0018299402,
0.000050036,
-0.03414746,
0.0195760392,
0.0535040013,
0.0369798876,
-0.0062901722,
-0.0562117063,
0.0541634932,
0.0571929514,
0.0072956155,
0.0049162647,
-0.0999675021,
0.0226890277,
0.08607243,
0.0499842204,
0.0057970397,
0.0438817553,
0.0217600241,
-0.0958211645,
-0.015280908,
0.0840826631,
0.0025237466,
-0.0669677556,
-0.0122872917,
0.0032934023,
0.0213676747,
0.0093315234,
-0.001045524,
-0.0673589185,
-0.0539062619,
-0.0020611023,
0.0143693658,
0.0449936353,
0.0227288678,
-0.0129458606,
-0.0880972445,
0.0666725934,
-0.0053724628,
-0.0044844882,
-0.0390958451,
0.0271150451,
-0.0310995597,
-0.0238307081,
0.0030056851,
0.0196131878,
0.0209946632,
-0.0185928028,
0.0388891064,
0.0035603775,
-0.0384403951,
0.0175931733,
-0.0386635438,
0.0193181299,
0.0916349292,
-0.0532744154,
0.0114122191,
-0.0430679098,
0.0192010347,
-0.0393298045,
-0.001017536,
0.0213549715,
0.0477230512,
-0.0365981832,
-0.0286276024,
0.0242410209,
0.0349987671,
-0.0453459173,
0.0147223165,
-0.035555061,
0.0278026816,
-0.0333417617,
-0.0396572873,
-0.0042518838,
-0.0016677672,
-0.0366810374,
0.0271203555,
-0.005409156,
-0.0580679849,
-0.0200488996,
-0.0101560922,
0.0162122231,
-0.0770070404,
-0.0301100817,
0.0097353868,
0.055676654,
-0.0932250172,
-0.0100154253,
-0.0247832388,
0.0417205207,
0.0414336771,
-0.023294013,
-0.0442438684,
0.0342092849,
0.0029856134,
-0.0639780536,
0.0296491999,
0.022909062,
0.0035852375,
-0.047815714,
0.0137062585,
0.0410732143,
-0.0214998256,
0.0072516678,
0.0425588265,
-0.0990141258,
-0.0258091073,
-0.0001738232,
0.0382251628,
0.0129919145,
0.0850194767,
-0.0018465553,
-0.0516356267,
0.0245209951,
-0.0096887695,
0.0221789535,
0.0280161146,
0.0364135951,
-0.04322844,
-0.0220487602,
0.0297953244,
-0.0337531902,
0.0109238084,
0.0009311564,
0.0030287167,
-0.0373359695,
-0.0163294114,
0.0455547012,
-0.0570522398,
0.0291275494,
-0.0452384502,
0.0310439803,
-0.0179528557,
0.0340319276,
0.0230612159,
-0.0000777149,
-0.0739926919,
0.0179290082,
0.0539968088,
0.0198589005,
0.0352992341,
0.0448302738,
0.0560700558,
-0.0086896112,
-0.0330451876,
0.0022223264,
0.0029315737,
0.0077167875,
0.0214196816,
0.0077652326,
-0.0154571244,
0.0103146862,
0.0028872578,
0.0162659287,
-0.024391517,
0.0183690283,
0.050978478,
0.0472787246,
0.0085584931,
0.0108589521,
0.0116318986,
-0.0360864699,
-0.0806809366,
0.022653928,
0.0020436062,
0.029872058,
0.0398364738,
-0.0052643563,
0.0088177798,
-0.0194254611,
0.0408423431,
-0.0197494403,
-0.0512060747,
0.0495190956,
0.0078003006,
0.0063011278,
-0.0218184795,
0.0404754058,
0.0244258996,
0.0492891148,
-0.0264574811,
0.0290291831,
-0.017319819,
-0.0491798148,
-0.0259694811,
-0.0238810964,
-0.0157767069,
0.052135285,
0.0321654677,
-0.0321555696,
-0.0251685176,
-0.0013940741,
0.0197518449,
-0.0035123157,
0.0545908846,
0.0329906829,
-0.0290667787,
-0.0580657236,
0.0163940508,
-0.0338341966,
0.0192291494,
-0.0004797453,
-0.0286159143,
-5.787779698e-33,
-0.0367188826,
0.0066068121,
0.0672218278,
-0.018852653,
-0.0157910921,
0.002365056,
-0.0249018203,
0.02029882,
-0.0333733261,
0.0331042446,
0.0452402718,
0.0314847045,
0.025662424,
0.0702314898,
0.0178196784,
-0.0079563633,
0.0684994683,
-0.01624039,
0.0016511506,
-0.009885516,
-0.019172769,
0.013454305,
0.0415300652,
-0.0140404943,
-0.0448541045,
0.0092491172,
-0.0298190676,
0.0101526305,
0.0278112087,
0.031452857,
-0.0097917542,
-0.0006921767,
-0.0053999075,
-0.0639423728,
-0.0278996881,
-0.017447561,
-0.1009630114,
0.0200824607,
-0.0459795184,
0.0992182419,
-0.0798073262,
-0.0031901726,
0.0100796018,
0.0378829241,
-0.0179843716,
-0.0472565107,
0.0438085087,
-0.0353304408,
-0.0086744232,
-0.0670199022,
-0.0394800417,
0.0186343975,
-0.0125201186,
-0.0533135757,
0.0643097386,
0.045997858,
-0.0066913534,
0.0134341363,
-0.0573591553,
-0.0046125972,
-0.0002579632,
0.0196588561,
0.1052525789,
0.0401487276,
-0.0226906985,
0.0206599794,
0.0017557263,
-0.069069095,
-0.0311698802,
0.0076857456,
0.0539399348,
0.0537284054,
0.0101809073,
0.0015664359,
0.0449067466,
0.0252226088,
-0.0239366461,
0.0064468905,
-0.0277648102,
0.0634775683,
0.0404299274,
0.0267990362,
-0.011950138,
-0.0262521654,
-0.0429495797,
-0.010618262,
-0.0087811779,
0.0074128462,
0.0425052829,
0.0638467371,
-0.0085762944,
-0.0150462082,
0.0862350687,
-0.0355262496,
0.0833241418,
0.0380631536,
-0.0197012722,
0.0554991774,
0.0058109532,
0.0449892767,
-0.0085820602,
-0.0004499179,
0.0421261936,
0.0010491149,
0.012866227,
0.015898766,
-0.004880277,
0.050990738,
-0.0494281463,
0.0067099701,
-0.0464880839,
0.0220956542,
0.0076985173,
0.0528865829,
0.0325429849,
0.0003246584,
-0.0445124172,
0.0274794735,
-0.048300866,
0.0387829579,
-0.016972864,
-0.008398219,
0.0451545306,
0.0233203266,
-0.0176353212,
-0.0066909376,
-0.0412182175,
-0.0327025726,
0.0243776459,
-0.0368692316,
-0.0202193111,
0.0645846128,
2.512e-7,
0.0125466855,
-0.0098239752,
0.0725008249,
0.0142499926,
0.0094968267,
0.0270372126,
0.0284437276,
0.0273355525,
-0.0076298499,
-0.0416346677,
0.022904804,
0.0372780189,
0.0567207262,
-0.0040037078,
-0.0187398307,
0.015139685,
-0.0273645613,
0.0208547562,
0.0077516437,
-0.048790317,
0.0196420308,
0.0650890246,
-0.0501234941,
-0.0168732889,
0.0634927005,
0.0216165874,
0.0607596189,
0.0298196003,
0.0139284628,
0.0032282912,
0.0168746579,
0.017178569,
-0.0211068075,
0.0169139877,
-0.0096392184,
-0.0062053502,
0.0044223424,
0.0104011167,
-0.02846043,
-0.0576457717,
0.0008274405,
0.0448570475,
-0.030487258,
-0.0099133337,
0.0429139026,
-0.0809571147,
-0.0104868766,
-0.0019596231,
-0.0653365105,
0.0298059378,
-0.0423150957,
-0.0153421601,
0.0102722207,
0.0169975664,
0.0697577596,
-0.0119691547,
-0.0581925027,
-0.0633028224,
-0.017860258,
-0.0158087034,
-0.0367598459,
-0.0101163769,
-0.0351915583,
-0.0234179478,
0.0441030599,
-0.0009675741,
-0.0386893451,
1.971200482e-34,
0.0322477743,
0.0101698553,
0.0086722402,
0.0333675556,
-0.009621093,
-0.0223247372,
-0.0059615094,
0.0408422835,
-0.0090810554,
-0.0411907248,
-0.0469811261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08622v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08622v1 | Multiple-Question Multiple-Answer Text-VQA | 2023-11-15T01:00:02 | 2023-11-15T01:00:02 | Peng Tang, Srikar Appalaraju, R. Manmatha, Yusheng Xie, Vijay Mahadevan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | We present Multiple-Question Multiple-Answer (MQMA), a novel approach to do
text-VQA in encoder-decoder transformer models. The text-VQA task requires a
model to answer a question by understanding multi-modal content: text
(typically from OCR) and an associated image. To the best of our knowledge,
almost all previous approaches for text-VQA process a single question and its
associated content to predict a single answer. In order to answer multiple
questions from the same image, each question and content are fed into the model
multiple times. In contrast, our proposed MQMA approach takes multiple
questions and content as input at the encoder and predicts multiple answers at
the decoder in an auto-regressive manner at the same time. We make several
novel architectural modifications to standard encoder-decoder transformers to
support MQMA. We also propose a novel MQMA denoising pre-training task which is
designed to teach the model to align and delineate multiple questions and
content with associated answers. MQMA pre-trained model achieves
state-of-the-art results on multiple text-VQA datasets, each with strong
baselines. Specifically, on OCR-VQA (+2.5%), TextVQA (+1.4%), ST-VQA (+0.6%),
DocVQA (+1.1%) absolute improvements over the previous state-of-the-art
approaches. | [
0.0022641215,
0.0827043504,
0.0096681528,
0.0384253524,
0.0012571333,
0.0062802094,
0.0333631635,
0.0140894298,
-0.0424321927,
0.0025668757,
0.0149627766,
-0.012216555,
-0.0141650094,
0.045738332,
0.0021079825,
-0.0394115448,
0.0179468524,
-0.029006131,
-0.0236643646,
-0.0215087757,
0.0182566959,
0.004778835,
-0.0143149374,
0.0159947705,
-0.0225158092,
-0.0289753992,
-0.0695218965,
0.0063601309,
0.0069395341,
-0.006066741,
-0.0072626141,
0.0641172454,
0.0430499725,
-0.005971828,
0.0000020407,
-0.0343627222,
-0.0623761266,
0.0074750427,
-0.0249508098,
-0.0200583823,
0.0009800901,
-0.0151536819,
0.047741767,
0.0251106247,
-0.025067145,
-0.0269766264,
0.0704367384,
0.0850203037,
0.0898060873,
0.0647926405,
-0.0351932421,
-0.0534143373,
0.037214864,
0.0023828228,
0.0302126706,
-0.0344476253,
0.0102908202,
0.0565729178,
0.0146830017,
0.0092179142,
-0.0119065,
0.0621006079,
0.0505967923,
0.0014793148,
-0.0131986775,
0.0214722399,
0.0501250327,
-0.0401921719,
-0.0259312633,
0.0832556859,
-0.0158989653,
0.0130289886,
-0.0412531458,
-0.0087356921,
0.0360535458,
0.0205261651,
-0.0299212076,
0.0056681498,
-0.0253192615,
0.0094424272,
-0.0343560688,
0.0494247936,
-0.0540926941,
-0.0072615822,
-0.0461421795,
-0.0232439581,
0.0115462067,
-0.0024809903,
-0.0126174679,
0.0309009515,
-0.0204985291,
-0.0268737376,
0.0254599992,
0.0677397549,
0.013529378,
0.0031019996,
-0.0635977834,
-0.0563686155,
-0.0027276913,
0.002236777,
0.0255459547,
0.0350426994,
-0.0373151489,
0.0463413075,
-0.0086970488,
0.0885702372,
-0.0243242867,
0.0325987823,
-0.0682057291,
-0.0267859679,
-0.005476987,
-0.0198342018,
-0.0521873087,
0.0337080695,
-0.0648710802,
-0.0205176808,
0.0129218297,
0.0073874136,
0.0413080268,
-0.0277342349,
0.0205539484,
0.0377969705,
-0.0404577777,
-0.0292711314,
0.0041803382,
0.0786571726,
-0.0276955552,
0.044994127,
0.0024249749,
-0.0469050258,
-0.0304287914,
0.0149764745,
0.0761105716,
-0.0185576808,
-0.0042509097,
0.0543689094,
-0.099496454,
-0.0045577995,
0.0171488114,
-0.0298147332,
-0.0197997279,
-0.0335582606,
0.0246027429,
-0.0375646055,
0.045206856,
0.0175064988,
0.0051249214,
-0.0154512702,
0.0137989148,
0.0245329253,
-0.0085766669,
0.0820486844,
0.0236665346,
-0.0110594677,
0.0941481516,
0.0163161326,
0.0650935099,
0.0663281232,
0.0205250643,
0.0241725296,
0.015001189,
-0.0065370831,
0.0318148546,
0.0487566069,
-0.0004437183,
-0.0034362946,
-0.0022428047,
0.0229475908,
0.0274145491,
0.0334094688,
0.0265699998,
0.0744670853,
-0.0483162515,
-0.0286754128,
0.0477785096,
0.0052582044,
0.010985232,
0.003864595,
-0.026784556,
0.0343847126,
0.0358264185,
0.0208225735,
-0.0078945076,
0.0670813173,
0.0191118531,
-0.0008736173,
0.0160862468,
0.0307493713,
-0.0393179916,
-0.0566812865,
0.0310151633,
-0.0035689049,
-0.0111394832,
-0.0041046562,
0.0381901413,
0.0412429459,
-0.0878653899,
0.0089037893,
-0.0295709688,
-0.0363678969,
-0.0140115339,
-0.0424846187,
0.0421982929,
-0.0339125134,
0.0454104543,
-0.0173304118,
-0.035731744,
-0.0123976041,
-0.0265471302,
0.0442653,
-0.008309084,
-0.0020863949,
0.0189580638,
-0.0691717267,
-0.0367985629,
-0.0126747414,
-0.0227610916,
0.0056513739,
0.0113079725,
0.03445483,
-0.0241706409,
-0.0132373208,
0.0308994632,
0.0415054262,
0.0272692945,
-0.0286622047,
-0.0039414139,
0.0107111977,
0.014264958,
0.0046040155,
-0.0152088255,
-0.0106517049,
0.0305728801,
-0.0598583184,
-0.0050821146,
-0.0193210784,
-0.0709942803,
-0.0763361603,
0.0153231025,
-0.0521311387,
0.0057799146,
0.0722937584,
-0.0335414223,
-0.0292970613,
-0.0549353138,
-0.0345936716,
-0.0226035956,
-0.0453263633,
-0.0395384654,
0.0220489129,
0.0102421585,
-0.0410088301,
0.0391507298,
-0.0324600823,
-0.0123959193,
0.0104710683,
-0.0086972695,
0.0171478819,
0.0092155468,
-0.0235390998,
-0.0019640075,
-0.0437674783,
0.0180487875,
-0.0031671969,
0.0436327197,
-0.0140651008,
-0.026471585,
-0.0463417582,
-0.0397659168,
-0.0221673641,
-0.0201769695,
0.0319163539,
0.0369105823,
0.0028671252,
-0.054761257,
-0.0712513998,
-0.0058410517,
0.0378199294,
-0.0071462756,
0.0461905487,
0.0075369785,
0.0415889025,
-0.0031044104,
-0.0169415176,
0.0246633161,
0.0604891106,
0.009657518,
-0.0247059055,
-0.0363913961,
-0.0134959929,
-0.0115111154,
0.0019187322,
0.008972805,
-0.0338436961,
0.0015438958,
-0.0193890687,
0.0451124012,
0.0601274855,
0.00695216,
0.0283796247,
0.0121127572,
0.0031741618,
-0.046723973,
0.0465289839,
-0.0228111949,
-0.0362168141,
-0.0034845353,
-0.0250207204,
-0.018315535,
0.0310606174,
-0.002088849,
0.0322847627,
-0.0415888242,
0.0244163126,
0.0018340505,
-0.0468467735,
-0.0800113305,
0.0032363562,
0.002124679,
0.033827778,
-0.0054521519,
-0.0328858569,
0.0339086689,
-0.0189417191,
-0.0424188823,
-0.0213676598,
0.037409395,
-0.0258470215,
0.0481998846,
-0.0116571253,
0.0351751707,
0.047726687,
-0.0289196577,
-0.0671882853,
-0.0147576211,
-0.0255812071,
-0.0503577292,
0.0350707471,
-0.0267323144,
0.0086834542,
-0.0373819247,
-0.0293465592,
-0.0366576761,
-0.0036780478,
-0.0080217458,
-0.009983236,
-0.0301885419,
-0.0040835165,
-0.0530916639,
0.0298279971,
0.0119579984,
0.0464736819,
-0.0514136404,
0.0240966715,
-0.0309866779,
0.1498342603,
0.0802181587,
0.0825648084,
-0.0057923747,
-0.0636064559,
0.0380452089,
0.052787859,
-0.0176271349,
-0.016491618,
0.030426221,
0.0175132547,
0.0211236216,
0.0271807183,
0.03928921,
0.0152320005,
0.062527962,
-0.0393137708,
-0.0528841987,
0.0611331947,
0.02431399,
-0.0297092684,
-0.045476906,
-0.0194365624,
0.0244593825,
-0.0042086001,
0.031982664,
-0.1218053699,
-0.0566017665,
-0.0267003216,
-0.0046110144,
0.0473638847,
0.0349595882,
-0.0210254844,
-0.0523231104,
0.0375420004,
-0.0128289014,
-0.0413901843,
-0.0195719954,
-0.0151911685,
-0.0234867148,
-0.0128814625,
-0.0011393719,
-0.0065159826,
0.0172699112,
-0.0173532553,
0.0133833336,
0.0285257585,
-0.0147352824,
-0.0129539873,
0.0024463381,
0.0033428315,
0.0609567016,
-0.0004797087,
-0.0158119444,
-0.048995018,
-0.0224284194,
-0.0421471484,
-0.0068417192,
0.0090084905,
0.0503313616,
-0.011330436,
-0.0137726674,
-0.0179519374,
0.0452625453,
-0.0261088498,
0.0027926937,
-0.0048586377,
0.0323374122,
-0.0056518577,
-0.0198646188,
-0.0326412693,
-0.0147333387,
-0.018057093,
0.0467953943,
0.0037863338,
-0.0387645364,
-0.0494235046,
-0.0328815505,
0.0195976272,
-0.0708788559,
-0.0394394025,
0.0068983696,
0.0372474603,
-0.0206367616,
-0.0475091264,
-0.0132267782,
0.0458138324,
0.0015618192,
-0.0361740068,
-0.0524827354,
0.0358811878,
0.0458207428,
-0.0608128048,
-0.0181252602,
0.0027862429,
-0.0049656439,
-0.0402144305,
0.0317050368,
0.0228715986,
-0.047160767,
-0.0193907022,
-0.0188958868,
-0.1007761732,
-0.0022901623,
-0.0003278392,
0.0484281033,
0.0097089214,
0.0243068393,
0.0053025554,
-0.0194459856,
0.0592108406,
0.0000176592,
-0.0042370916,
-0.0067512463,
-0.0039793164,
-0.0266387686,
-0.0130032431,
0.0089304857,
-0.0130816344,
0.0373122431,
-0.0319976509,
0.0097437482,
-0.0499029383,
-0.0524177477,
0.0381842814,
-0.0155110219,
-0.0064860191,
0.0396166854,
0.0238567963,
-0.0175920967,
0.0461300984,
-0.0029319832,
-0.0196848605,
-0.0628877506,
0.0230972003,
0.0148419254,
-0.024893105,
0.0060029454,
0.0050912634,
0.0068854755,
0.0430235825,
-0.033068344,
0.0227702111,
0.0194178578,
-0.0014940945,
-0.0024479213,
-0.0207720064,
-0.0074078473,
0.0189201385,
0.0042082351,
0.0482067205,
-0.0007738306,
0.0788417533,
-0.000441014,
-0.0109752752,
0.0057692798,
0.0315718837,
-0.0313959904,
-0.0357208885,
-0.0631103516,
-0.008030232,
-0.0049205818,
0.0531617105,
0.0046052723,
0.0572256818,
-0.0070266142,
-0.0121412408,
0.0158573221,
0.0191113856,
0.0077912319,
0.0513599403,
0.0073875533,
0.0224838536,
-0.0151817277,
0.0529465713,
-0.005440908,
0.0150858387,
0.0008720953,
0.0371474959,
-0.0601993613,
-0.0160710905,
0.016613273,
0.00841753,
-0.0062544327,
0.0298735779,
0.0294603109,
-0.0089034326,
0.0388407335,
-0.0119856903,
-0.0297723729,
0.0018054185,
0.0230740421,
0.0204251911,
-0.009937752,
-0.0598387457,
-0.0006037277,
0.0118307276,
-0.0355641134,
-0.02477099,
0.0160208624,
-6.449301267e-33,
-0.0229722224,
-0.0164558012,
0.0426341221,
-0.0581611805,
0.0003475903,
0.021475248,
-0.0192856565,
-0.0097220382,
-0.0358283781,
-0.0035051277,
0.004583165,
-0.0102075767,
0.0192841832,
0.0522435196,
-0.0189781617,
-0.0107209161,
0.0442191064,
-0.0442295298,
-0.0126911085,
0.020214973,
-0.0185513701,
0.0078481631,
0.0263459012,
-0.0205794778,
-0.0174582936,
-0.0095888237,
-0.0595776327,
0.0080532487,
0.0170817226,
0.0612017363,
-0.0478891023,
-0.0074540069,
0.0286512394,
-0.0312801749,
0.007292354,
0.0674088672,
-0.0976020396,
-0.0128149288,
-0.0491664782,
0.0443195961,
-0.0791617483,
-0.0187124554,
0.000131735,
-0.0164051764,
0.0206437744,
-0.0560838543,
0.0376675613,
0.0045396835,
0.0214726459,
-0.0378708877,
0.0038058457,
0.0060095023,
-0.0222026072,
-0.0429846384,
-0.0107454685,
0.0933422297,
0.0274808519,
0.0186817236,
-0.0586697385,
0.0058406885,
0.0350739248,
0.0067626112,
0.0550544336,
0.0245553795,
-0.0419710428,
-0.0087255305,
-0.032018397,
-0.0847006813,
-0.0287509598,
-0.0012851623,
-0.0073561636,
0.050131686,
0.0714259446,
0.0508358367,
0.056097988,
0.0303396303,
-0.0630810857,
0.0562200025,
-0.0760890171,
0.052179683,
0.0159443859,
-0.0164270177,
0.0184344091,
0.0093328645,
-0.0329121351,
0.009338595,
-0.0289638992,
0.001005457,
0.0399676189,
0.0219572466,
-0.0278891977,
0.0093127284,
0.0900730789,
-0.0192038361,
0.0238686688,
-0.0011090427,
-0.0079492033,
0.0548478439,
-0.0205156021,
0.0540749319,
-0.0377905518,
0.0275613349,
0.0810814574,
-0.0246897284,
-0.0373097509,
0.0091507649,
0.0124354707,
0.011549497,
-0.0867663398,
-0.0189492293,
-0.0004512964,
0.0241097938,
0.013868276,
0.0698161796,
0.0055219098,
0.0045786602,
-0.0372374095,
0.0359055027,
-0.0281515382,
0.0263439547,
-0.0517579131,
-0.0607178137,
0.0261456799,
0.0240293145,
-0.0148697551,
0.0099799596,
-0.0435058586,
-0.036203064,
-0.0083394358,
-0.0398801565,
-0.0059084482,
0.0769643486,
2.51e-7,
0.0645577684,
0.0237085354,
0.0442962945,
0.0098740589,
-0.0109665729,
0.022313999,
0.0022575939,
0.0372724459,
0.017974684,
-0.0238633323,
0.0082876151,
0.049536474,
0.0359313712,
0.0129111493,
-0.0626942962,
-0.0213048067,
-0.0366753414,
-0.0036324186,
-0.053531751,
-0.0001493871,
0.0853691176,
0.0827888623,
-0.0515682213,
-0.0104860049,
-0.0039703841,
0.0155194756,
0.053268116,
0.0365836881,
0.0046992484,
0.0212467965,
-0.0066481098,
-0.0157865044,
0.0067406869,
-0.0057631521,
0.0186685156,
0.0136291748,
0.0547203608,
0.0529461578,
-0.0117093511,
-0.0822519585,
-0.0152416751,
0.0567526631,
-0.0175975207,
-0.046112556,
0.0867172778,
-0.0391337909,
-0.0038976446,
-0.0258919485,
-0.052933719,
0.0127892634,
0.0524307787,
0.0068854997,
-0.0204352867,
0.0196492765,
0.0608216934,
-0.0082172183,
-0.031183891,
-0.0462223887,
-0.0169642009,
-0.0277885627,
-0.0128189418,
0.0020574201,
-0.0625212416,
-0.0714128539,
0.0100977886,
-0.0332496464,
-0.0085546812,
2.073944887e-34,
0.0026871716,
-0.001556141,
0.010268434,
0.08022964,
0.0121221524,
-0.0428917892,
-0.0093329465,
-0.0020579712,
-0.0096708313,
-0.119009003,
-0.0073098382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08620v1 | Toucan: Token-Aware Character Level Language Modeling | 2023-11-15T00:57:51 | 2023-11-15T00:57:51 | William Fleshman, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Character-level language models obviate the need for separately trained
tokenizers, but efficiency suffers from longer sequence lengths. Learning to
combine character representations into tokens has made training these models
more efficient, but they still require decoding characters individually. We
propose Toucan, an augmentation to character-level models to make them
"token-aware". Comparing our method to prior work, we demonstrate significant
speed-ups in character generation without a loss in language modeling
performance. We then explore differences between our learned dynamic
tokenization of character sequences with popular fixed vocabulary solutions
such as Byte-Pair Encoding and WordPiece, finding our approach leads to a
greater amount of longer sequences tokenized as single items. Our project and
code are available at https://nlp.jhu.edu/nuggets/. | [
0.0085427547,
0.0793952346,
0.0012419533,
0.0038899528,
-0.0134384669,
0.0308250561,
0.0406358503,
0.0201804247,
-0.0543244965,
-0.0312084127,
0.0291922148,
-0.0692253336,
0.0262949429,
0.0892917961,
0.0704924017,
-0.057581611,
0.070994854,
-0.028251661,
0.0183601007,
-0.0050063226,
0.0018938845,
0.0325963236,
0.0092590423,
0.0875325501,
-0.0413352102,
-0.0112215439,
-0.0372352861,
-0.0036440135,
-0.0239039939,
-0.0303312354,
-0.002149737,
0.0382050909,
0.0197179914,
0.0359265432,
0.0000019977,
-0.0103777284,
-0.0363288671,
-0.015511727,
-0.01263378,
0.0337918699,
0.0631244853,
-0.0440549068,
-0.0042409562,
0.0413887911,
-0.0022320314,
-0.023768587,
0.046530515,
0.0162207633,
0.0279414095,
0.0558812954,
-0.007807672,
-0.0110527845,
0.0256675351,
-0.0505598597,
-0.0120513355,
0.0121521046,
-0.0079389773,
-0.0158874895,
-0.0107970433,
0.0115048001,
-0.0375299901,
-0.0053270264,
0.0037868097,
0.0294733625,
0.024456976,
0.0586331747,
-0.0400022864,
-0.018106427,
-0.025275737,
0.0417887568,
-0.0603631549,
-0.0411708318,
-0.0031967107,
0.0078321155,
0.0099894628,
-0.0456741601,
-0.0279576909,
0.0164952036,
0.0242484733,
0.0342645422,
0.0086872624,
-0.009077183,
0.0389949344,
-0.0011814014,
-0.0517091379,
0.0210994259,
0.0205438808,
0.0029276863,
-0.0760538951,
-0.022772627,
-0.0195462443,
-0.0956536904,
-0.0013951069,
0.0502760038,
-0.0429786406,
0.0073373341,
-0.0421682633,
-0.0348069929,
0.039298024,
-0.017466139,
0.0106557598,
0.0621507876,
-0.0177083556,
-0.0127875339,
-0.0731417686,
0.0374412276,
0.0031746686,
0.0385174565,
-0.0249461848,
-0.0087825283,
-0.0457456186,
-0.0235578306,
-0.0615359917,
0.0658857524,
-0.0494596958,
-0.0444000661,
-0.0128230574,
-0.0053276513,
0.0423906632,
-0.0139338663,
-0.0167903099,
0.0050698221,
-0.0249737259,
0.0184765644,
0.0202335697,
0.0025103679,
-0.0428443402,
-0.0009156074,
0.0283115096,
-0.0128175272,
-0.0242000725,
-0.0017738312,
0.0296927392,
-0.0161360912,
0.0157251339,
0.1097014621,
-0.0281077716,
-0.0352206789,
0.0011229976,
-0.0282811504,
-0.0170968007,
-0.0249622762,
-0.0525402278,
-0.0926402435,
0.0427982509,
-0.0039862734,
-0.009200694,
-0.0106346225,
0.0175276306,
0.0160499178,
-0.0089123081,
0.0598990433,
-0.0158863999,
-0.017237993,
0.0083054835,
-0.008841902,
0.0098407939,
0.0414802469,
0.0526640937,
0.0525685661,
0.0013719477,
-0.0050272434,
-0.0256640464,
0.0495180823,
0.009139549,
-0.0123250429,
-0.0384485051,
-0.0398764387,
0.0644762143,
0.0228476748,
0.0431693122,
0.0976735428,
-0.0556204133,
0.0069213854,
0.0166711416,
0.0570365265,
0.023934558,
0.0330956802,
0.0573169217,
-0.0143193407,
-0.0360489711,
-0.0166939124,
-0.0125814909,
0.0152763501,
0.0551998019,
0.0143944537,
0.032406982,
0.0493060388,
-0.0270931013,
-0.0231835116,
-0.0058892025,
-0.0424867347,
0.0400169566,
-0.0519652814,
0.0413376465,
0.0288908929,
-0.0626708716,
0.0594674088,
0.0303075518,
-0.0805962384,
0.0281129703,
-0.0263995584,
0.0479574539,
0.0857355371,
0.0648021325,
0.0207038373,
-0.0336796232,
-0.0203665532,
-0.016420424,
0.0612082556,
0.0061858585,
-0.0113333389,
0.0411253497,
-0.0582384355,
0.0077903755,
-0.0182932559,
0.0029655334,
0.0650052428,
0.0083120503,
0.0385113545,
0.0203658342,
-0.0503445007,
-0.0224655233,
0.0582397655,
-0.0300929118,
-0.0128710577,
0.0051910393,
0.0102872169,
0.0000252918,
0.011761724,
-0.013624901,
0.0287176874,
0.0204523616,
-0.0671702027,
-0.0206089709,
0.0234032739,
-0.0528810509,
-0.0386128798,
0.0630233064,
-0.0088668512,
0.0317468196,
-0.0005494087,
-0.0121887065,
-0.0671641603,
0.030837141,
-0.0472449735,
0.0647450015,
-0.0288366135,
0.005274747,
0.0008369351,
0.0602600463,
-0.0031335168,
0.0379892811,
-0.0166755337,
-0.0070384345,
0.0025972745,
0.0178294126,
0.0247335825,
-0.0432494879,
0.0105723254,
0.0195542499,
0.0022082869,
-0.0243121739,
0.0101356944,
0.0166597236,
-0.0004838651,
-0.031072285,
-0.0882335752,
-0.0166605115,
-0.0142756049,
0.0060937735,
-0.0118160192,
0.0424344875,
0.0006998123,
-0.0014923901,
-0.061111521,
-0.0159692802,
0.0014772414,
-0.0136709884,
0.0396089815,
0.0026450281,
-0.0379381217,
-0.0368272178,
-0.0217018742,
-0.0169332102,
0.0429463424,
-0.037311323,
-0.054239139,
-0.0263449457,
-0.0415504351,
-0.0037571294,
0.0172300283,
0.0108914934,
-0.0549964085,
0.0188155379,
-0.0450999737,
0.0527812541,
0.0164715238,
0.0434752926,
0.0104405973,
0.00638841,
0.0070383763,
-0.0606195852,
0.0115930829,
0.0110270502,
0.0189830158,
-0.012310354,
-0.0420221649,
0.0067233443,
0.0609590076,
-0.0244362298,
0.0226497613,
-0.099648878,
-0.0084442394,
0.0091974363,
-0.0565941036,
-0.011246453,
-0.0244509447,
-0.0078700231,
0.0058353362,
-0.0473200232,
-0.0305481963,
0.0501936413,
-0.0727176592,
-0.0113976467,
-0.0153455809,
0.0143337166,
-0.0435383506,
0.0778679326,
0.0184982195,
0.0410943069,
-0.0256171972,
-0.0614676513,
-0.0267898906,
0.0308056884,
-0.0497956723,
-0.0303215459,
0.0392614044,
0.0006685595,
-0.0193594545,
-0.0153551949,
-0.0164979231,
-0.0412201658,
0.0020296175,
-0.0148456311,
0.0292092673,
0.0253748521,
-0.0639737546,
-0.0349307805,
0.0328096859,
-0.0213264432,
0.0443207286,
-0.0045514954,
0.014567744,
-0.0193615556,
0.0240725856,
0.0373412371,
-0.008429057,
-0.0067776479,
-0.0321853533,
0.0481028333,
0.0495931618,
0.0477856398,
0.0029226162,
-0.0113301612,
0.0068249856,
0.0271081273,
-0.0310010575,
0.0019057209,
-0.0020000294,
0.0616233312,
-0.0518197529,
-0.0544337705,
0.1325834543,
0.033738941,
-0.0303393304,
0.0280619841,
0.0068140342,
0.0452031828,
-0.0093182009,
-0.0147455493,
-0.0832973346,
-0.0387021862,
0.0303716641,
0.0245650113,
0.0080502983,
-0.0131853437,
-0.0063464479,
-0.1084624603,
-0.017488908,
0.0295285285,
-0.0478007495,
-0.0058829659,
-0.0187945254,
-0.0588813089,
0.0055682496,
0.0641015694,
0.0346274376,
0.0171116255,
0.0152783692,
0.0573894195,
-0.0171419289,
0.0126649728,
-0.0035802494,
-0.0359076969,
0.0736866072,
0.0697924495,
0.015611588,
-0.0067623393,
-0.0021915154,
0.0233030412,
0.0347270593,
0.035823442,
-0.0080489498,
0.0183002539,
-0.0317238979,
-0.0236606244,
0.0259489566,
0.0362097323,
-0.0454773642,
-0.0348452702,
-0.0067269267,
0.0083059277,
0.0392670073,
0.0136486087,
-0.0417206548,
-0.0277221333,
-0.0133244051,
0.0544287562,
0.0265511256,
-0.0607011393,
-0.0379504636,
-0.050969664,
-0.0007050569,
-0.0789304301,
0.0255687274,
-0.0183331743,
0.0284884088,
-0.0431096926,
-0.0919354856,
-0.0276447237,
0.0297016054,
0.0509250499,
-0.020213047,
0.0208207965,
-0.0682314113,
-0.0110857598,
-0.0603436604,
-0.008130312,
-0.0072160121,
0.0223048162,
-0.0754361451,
-0.0312777609,
-0.0289331861,
-0.048565831,
-0.0116364211,
0.0182808824,
-0.0664309412,
-0.0693481863,
-0.004924091,
0.0418403074,
0.0167453922,
0.0354905687,
-0.0150259398,
-0.0154589349,
0.0625645444,
0.0638994202,
-0.0363177992,
0.0093389247,
0.0059451554,
0.0176364742,
-0.0066432958,
0.0045153606,
-0.0289889909,
0.0082789315,
-0.0027440891,
0.0352893956,
0.0054985373,
0.0134450402,
0.0385795534,
-0.0029549501,
-0.0129688997,
-0.0586724989,
-0.0108993063,
0.0041919746,
0.0090981154,
-0.0279110968,
0.0206243247,
-0.0321876593,
0.0109698167,
0.0376596041,
0.0059285494,
0.0000723402,
-0.0369305722,
0.0097143976,
0.0290883072,
0.0354252122,
0.0171786137,
-0.018774176,
0.0220993757,
0.0283951201,
-0.014576667,
-0.0224383119,
-0.0197803117,
-0.0674923062,
-0.009626748,
-0.0677961111,
-0.0336836167,
0.0133449938,
0.0279488899,
-0.0267166123,
0.0347411148,
-0.0328005031,
-0.0014458576,
-0.0301798359,
0.0377160721,
0.0239936374,
0.0066451449,
0.0298009776,
-0.0176424999,
-0.0024048353,
-0.0094447527,
0.004533167,
-0.0136172744,
-0.0281732511,
-0.0159044508,
0.0282414425,
-0.0378661826,
-0.0610695742,
0.0919900686,
0.0197777282,
0.0250021704,
-0.019283887,
0.0081735831,
-0.0390708074,
0.0249537304,
0.014015845,
0.0546534732,
-0.0442896485,
0.0098251831,
-0.0231652576,
-0.0764696226,
0.0153821781,
0.0355956666,
0.0469823331,
0.0273287501,
0.0060965721,
0.0315013491,
0.0059225522,
0.0236048363,
-0.0206664745,
0.0202775262,
0.0524689443,
-0.0508806929,
0.0038985666,
-5.973383644e-33,
-0.0132382074,
0.0065774112,
-0.0237192065,
-0.0008466583,
-0.0316878334,
0.009712562,
-0.03432367,
-0.0049853697,
0.0318424515,
-0.0123831984,
-0.018395504,
0.0221006069,
0.0128206788,
0.0449113138,
0.0338271484,
0.0192185398,
0.0772463679,
0.0088819452,
-0.0129121486,
0.0185862705,
0.0441816375,
0.0499455407,
-0.0033227138,
0.0086519308,
-0.0075710779,
-0.0236647017,
-0.0005156176,
-0.0363072306,
0.0275841095,
0.0640682206,
-0.0277432911,
0.0154915424,
0.020737702,
0.0091983164,
-0.0369296782,
0.0476327278,
-0.1178983152,
0.0196350161,
0.0088559333,
0.0081599634,
0.0220193081,
-0.0845953003,
0.0309326593,
-0.0124061648,
0.0159652326,
0.0010862685,
0.0049656918,
-0.020079704,
-0.0343777277,
-0.020301735,
-0.0707608536,
0.0109688109,
-0.0181979015,
-0.0077310307,
0.0313128345,
0.0145402113,
0.0121138198,
0.0010133911,
-0.0249632876,
0.0114462087,
0.0068844249,
0.0560712703,
0.0332982168,
0.0406884849,
-0.0128364423,
0.054466296,
0.058247719,
-0.0304901842,
-0.0246945508,
0.0491590053,
0.0376823358,
0.0039561088,
0.0469340533,
0.0139956027,
0.0591918491,
-0.0718536824,
-0.0740495771,
0.0228511654,
0.0440360941,
0.0267727636,
0.0272411034,
0.0398145802,
0.001324045,
0.013234443,
-0.0340686962,
-0.0059725931,
-0.0314016119,
-0.0551923178,
0.0359668881,
0.0553529263,
-0.0224528238,
-0.0424729101,
0.0187076535,
-0.0110756084,
-0.00807958,
0.0129331062,
0.0097936289,
-0.0092166737,
-0.0165412482,
0.034056209,
-0.0197370406,
-0.0672624931,
0.040392343,
0.0081755631,
0.0072038881,
-0.0070325169,
0.0448054783,
0.0234054681,
-0.0838649571,
0.0142407054,
-0.0430763252,
0.0421185903,
-0.0063693104,
0.0424164683,
0.0595017374,
-0.0207424667,
-0.0029193929,
-0.0212488733,
-0.0337292515,
-0.0105621452,
-0.0196029432,
-0.0076438067,
-0.0072195241,
0.0372301601,
-0.0442937873,
0.0003791905,
-0.0487258285,
0.018164875,
0.0320016667,
-0.0358377919,
-0.0239118114,
0.0358664878,
2.569e-7,
0.0345719606,
0.0332947522,
0.0751925558,
-0.0078992425,
0.0332843103,
0.0017830365,
-0.0180508178,
0.0466702916,
-0.0195853263,
0.0117005194,
-0.022752149,
0.0062661711,
0.0300517753,
-0.0083111944,
-0.0870855227,
0.0203127153,
-0.0401181877,
0.0356712006,
-0.0559394732,
0.0044677299,
0.0408790521,
0.1049516648,
-0.0031231258,
-0.0119992355,
0.0164155271,
-0.0319045894,
0.0490022935,
-0.0005341842,
0.0064409683,
-0.0048686909,
-0.0122571364,
0.0223670248,
0.0048232297,
-0.0186447855,
-0.026464466,
0.034021996,
0.0394637063,
0.0156203881,
-0.0254899878,
-0.0314804129,
0.0198700782,
-0.0184911862,
-0.0236239005,
-0.0526220091,
0.0535693504,
-0.0158810131,
0.0039554583,
-0.0432556197,
-0.0205796789,
0.0753271133,
-0.0259662308,
-0.022975212,
-0.0417005047,
0.0749918967,
0.0448554419,
-0.0035833796,
0.0279255528,
-0.0819118917,
-0.0334089324,
-0.019787807,
-0.0441394337,
-0.0096785743,
-0.0676681101,
0.015245745,
0.0049568783,
-0.0382081792,
-0.0252038222,
2.422914492e-34,
0.0236783382,
-0.0274021719,
0.0040821601,
0.0399751738,
-0.0005020835,
-0.0411058702,
0.038209755,
0.0252820943,
0.0181202553,
-0.0406567194,
-0.0484657809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10763v1 | Comparing Generalization in Learning with Limited Numbers of Exemplars: Transformer vs. RNN in Attractor Dynamics | 2023-11-15T00:37:49 | 2023-11-15T00:37:49 | Rui Fukushima, Jun Tani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | ChatGPT, a widely-recognized large language model (LLM), has recently gained
substantial attention for its performance scaling, attributed to the billions
of web-sourced natural language sentences used for training. Its underlying
architecture, Transformer, has found applications across diverse fields,
including video, audio signals, and robotic movement. %The crucial question
this raises concerns the Transformer's generalization-in-learning (GIL)
capacity. However, this raises a crucial question about Transformer's
generalization in learning (GIL) capacity. Is ChatGPT's success chiefly due to
the vast dataset used for training, or is there more to the story? To
investigate this, we compared Transformer's GIL capabilities with those of a
traditional Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) in tasks involving attractor
dynamics learning. For performance evaluation, the Dynamic Time Warping (DTW)
method has been employed. Our simulation results suggest that under conditions
of limited data availability, Transformer's GIL abilities are markedly inferior
to those of RNN. | [
0.0115032019,
0.0541753694,
-0.0080019953,
0.0018808194,
-0.0290695466,
0.0189209152,
-0.0156273749,
0.0146364197,
-0.0470968038,
0.0058280672,
-0.0107797133,
-0.0511703454,
-0.0088393129,
-0.0082112234,
0.0182712693,
-0.0416258648,
0.0483168252,
-0.0046955273,
-0.0329570211,
0.0014974526,
-0.0260699857,
-0.0334949754,
-0.009374111,
0.0636772141,
0.0023870936,
0.0198360421,
-0.0306789428,
-0.0376942344,
0.0709518567,
-0.0243808515,
-0.0307405479,
-0.0219954252,
0.0535013825,
0.0901447386,
0.0000019642,
-0.0150580769,
0.0038786342,
0.0071782977,
0.0337279141,
-0.0117274597,
0.0407160111,
-0.0020348737,
0.0080966735,
0.038717851,
-0.0462599806,
-0.0458411612,
0.0362848528,
0.0434072949,
0.0622501969,
0.1056057289,
-0.0112174163,
-0.035934031,
0.0448215269,
-0.023466466,
0.0140970116,
-0.0342924334,
0.0279603004,
0.0390887335,
0.0311474521,
-0.0347579718,
-0.0403883196,
0.0410852171,
0.029324038,
0.0118914815,
0.0166078769,
0.0520566925,
-0.0766582638,
-0.0025356079,
-0.0163798276,
0.0278442688,
-0.0427444167,
-0.0019906503,
0.0027843341,
0.0204074997,
-0.0090250913,
0.0694337264,
-0.0630629957,
0.0060462914,
0.0105677955,
0.0336879604,
-0.0270048287,
0.0182252154,
0.0292831603,
-0.0362936705,
-0.049646318,
0.0339458883,
0.0164921656,
-0.0249376856,
0.0095252134,
-0.0092428159,
0.0313287526,
-0.0477792658,
0.0173610225,
0.0523465648,
0.0120047536,
-0.0084585743,
-0.0238232668,
-0.0261793807,
-0.0186766759,
-0.0871313959,
0.0341764539,
0.0415359214,
0.0345503017,
0.0174890757,
-0.0315808766,
0.0968111828,
-0.0659887493,
0.0517896414,
-0.039678324,
-0.0106519898,
-0.1152344048,
-0.0219645891,
-0.0295086224,
0.0373453647,
0.0479573049,
-0.0390078835,
-0.0614068992,
0.0203117169,
0.0185649116,
-0.0208640657,
-0.0208313055,
0.0346464776,
-0.0119646052,
0.0098502934,
-0.0251395907,
0.0210631769,
0.020623263,
0.0292330105,
0.0092162294,
-0.0451300703,
-0.0064114477,
-0.0067035407,
0.0078705419,
-0.0011504253,
0.0031989634,
0.087417461,
0.0045763077,
-0.01578933,
-0.0279646609,
0.0386054628,
-0.0202443153,
-0.0325053222,
0.0271733813,
-0.0559115373,
0.0137522211,
-0.0021232185,
0.0106917694,
0.0276882518,
-0.0097370036,
0.0144199356,
-0.0402131826,
0.0237973016,
0.0404892564,
0.0080973096,
0.0141376927,
-0.0178431831,
0.0434466153,
0.0475958176,
0.0451240987,
-0.0067230565,
0.0059199166,
-0.0275056716,
0.0321314111,
0.0512577109,
-0.0372979641,
-0.0072396407,
-0.0163810682,
-0.0259877965,
0.0490154959,
0.0589027144,
0.0096025364,
0.033602722,
-0.039463181,
-0.0015350491,
0.0748481527,
0.0748733953,
0.0378866382,
0.0740102306,
0.0252543464,
-0.0062756063,
-0.0061159106,
-0.000320803,
-0.0358988121,
0.0361745954,
0.007676288,
-0.0001722078,
-0.0390670486,
0.0662722662,
-0.034147989,
-0.0299337525,
-0.0044259531,
-0.0070452024,
0.0237598605,
-0.0272501167,
0.0669824556,
0.0302692596,
-0.0322643146,
0.0475481935,
0.0122459279,
-0.0060486761,
-0.0036559741,
-0.0336623751,
-0.0361748226,
0.0154311378,
0.0059642582,
-0.0295949504,
-0.0705828518,
-0.0452034511,
0.0062568807,
0.044055786,
0.027775513,
0.0322399363,
0.0030826819,
-0.0445847139,
-0.0324714482,
0.0197115578,
-0.0097453212,
0.0366933718,
-0.0090772239,
0.0584030002,
0.0052980906,
-0.0132314144,
-0.0733899698,
0.0270352382,
-0.0241022445,
-0.0122184251,
0.0281812772,
-0.0219321102,
0.0460486002,
0.0004129373,
-0.0312817432,
-0.0393741205,
0.0062530744,
-0.06475804,
-0.0641181692,
0.0506012589,
-0.0577545278,
0.0191166718,
0.033396773,
-0.0297475476,
0.0027259951,
0.0093086371,
-0.0569595546,
-0.0546277612,
0.0464648008,
-0.0148411244,
0.0864740908,
0.0286167283,
0.0159175172,
-0.0224262513,
0.031741973,
-0.009924747,
0.0158377178,
0.002854239,
-0.0039232867,
-0.0330140218,
0.0145677626,
0.0208735932,
-0.0403550528,
-0.0377655178,
0.0292419009,
-0.0289579462,
-0.0032587619,
0.0133744748,
-0.019676961,
-0.0174588952,
-0.0315267928,
-0.0418529846,
-0.0125195803,
-0.0096963281,
0.0351789258,
0.0136131477,
-0.003580193,
0.0027652695,
0.0080182906,
-0.0255035162,
0.015619304,
-0.0022345372,
-0.0282446034,
0.0463303179,
0.0123523427,
-0.0688773245,
-0.014124969,
0.0062137991,
-0.0037774374,
0.048046723,
0.0200251043,
-0.0170920845,
-0.0346396714,
0.0079357997,
-0.0000139454,
0.0045694718,
-0.0094107697,
-0.0617756881,
0.0155993514,
0.0112101007,
0.0359854624,
0.0301932096,
0.0304764397,
-0.029024357,
0.0136708356,
-0.0199217238,
-0.0377716906,
0.0090131629,
-0.0556331836,
-0.0360717922,
-0.0594988167,
-0.0084991949,
0.0178049821,
0.0793480277,
0.0017994838,
0.0212478749,
-0.0475011431,
-0.0235677324,
-0.0465095676,
0.0081991358,
-0.0165737104,
0.0267764777,
-0.0334897935,
-0.0194863528,
-0.0091162911,
-0.0630039498,
0.0428378582,
-0.0103603201,
-0.0045222235,
-0.0029715016,
-0.0461047255,
-0.0333489105,
0.0163509026,
0.0020797672,
0.0176669173,
0.0143851582,
-0.0270295553,
-0.0274169892,
-0.0095975865,
-0.0079292795,
0.0087240981,
0.0426471941,
-0.0012227684,
-0.0092287781,
0.0172477942,
-0.0196992923,
-0.0237166584,
0.0233368501,
-0.0034110586,
-0.0079952469,
-0.0362332985,
-0.0692227781,
-0.0499327183,
0.0023666015,
0.0113335764,
0.0195683073,
-0.0198098198,
-0.0432528704,
0.0032186583,
0.0380467102,
0.0314100534,
0.0448116325,
-0.0260340404,
-0.0125947036,
0.0092966836,
0.0139742773,
0.0331085548,
-0.0173681434,
-0.1210664213,
0.0028814934,
-0.0124459071,
-0.0341553427,
-0.0254125558,
0.0174608268,
0.0170934051,
-0.0351287276,
-0.0275521409,
0.1028725803,
-0.0259082243,
-0.0279095843,
-0.002190918,
0.0185989328,
0.0024657275,
0.0093035586,
0.0187478513,
-0.0005167234,
0.0069788937,
-0.0076002032,
0.0126725622,
0.024612138,
-0.0169451032,
0.0268603601,
-0.0695595518,
0.0290824417,
0.0053362213,
-0.0609788075,
-0.0267393552,
-0.0456576608,
-0.0109625384,
-0.06758672,
0.0224414878,
-0.0423044115,
-0.0208626483,
-0.009624809,
0.0557330884,
-0.0569851063,
-0.0285188928,
-0.0224635452,
-0.0592533462,
-0.000639289,
0.0713197216,
0.0431912355,
-0.059372928,
-0.0521141812,
0.0470080189,
0.0498066545,
0.0358386189,
0.0098153381,
0.0111657567,
0.0138438735,
-0.016496256,
0.0036162611,
0.036577642,
-0.0296271183,
0.0109712817,
-0.0009039742,
0.0890305936,
-0.0130610736,
-0.0046139294,
-0.0109441755,
-0.0323736593,
-0.0015870086,
0.0463011861,
-0.0076640495,
-0.060422495,
-0.0277141724,
0.0060735918,
0.0172879975,
-0.0003710826,
-0.0802133679,
-0.0244374983,
0.0232639555,
-0.0291513205,
-0.0613285787,
0.0308746342,
-0.0340221338,
0.0752366111,
0.0259317253,
-0.0179338325,
0.0641612485,
0.0069715558,
-0.018192729,
0.0101370029,
-0.0021656682,
-0.0028131572,
-0.0445438772,
-0.0148258256,
0.0232825615,
0.0049452372,
-0.0481524877,
-0.0038477813,
-0.0968013778,
-0.0548990145,
0.0464389659,
0.0222989786,
0.0280085206,
0.0416298434,
-0.0043043531,
0.0234309565,
0.0551373959,
0.0517998561,
0.0225222073,
0.0043683285,
0.0200068671,
0.0143779172,
0.0013129808,
-0.0063237213,
-0.0426369905,
0.0247463081,
0.0270091705,
-0.0336034335,
-0.010781087,
0.0176094025,
-0.0097766146,
0.0077210874,
0.0721137524,
0.0191182978,
0.0227120034,
-0.0062617795,
-0.0192781594,
0.0346934609,
0.0438876376,
-0.0667091087,
-0.0280762296,
0.0788944215,
0.0315436944,
-0.0100261029,
0.0153687363,
0.0514075831,
-0.0648397356,
-0.0249139555,
-0.0108466502,
0.0041148374,
0.0305657741,
0.0186045077,
0.0383845009,
0.0074502784,
-0.0084967306,
0.0021955431,
0.0256066844,
-0.0095218057,
0.0507845543,
0.0325331092,
0.0372862518,
-0.0051243021,
-0.000876311,
-0.1025934815,
-0.0965465829,
-0.017489953,
0.0121198567,
0.0611325912,
-0.0254676957,
0.0166200958,
-0.0249455236,
0.020023942,
0.0133681763,
0.0038941135,
-0.0200591311,
-0.0010811421,
0.0087993117,
-0.0095279356,
-0.0312650055,
0.0558691546,
0.0648246482,
-0.0400642641,
0.0468396656,
-0.0037860242,
0.0151205231,
-0.0193235073,
0.002752474,
0.0143766813,
-0.0426365286,
0.0334411599,
-0.017712906,
-0.0300296266,
-0.0381711423,
0.033385355,
-0.0174575299,
0.0263071042,
-0.018223308,
0.0483200252,
0.0372944362,
-0.0087187318,
0.0054631033,
0.0298636761,
-0.0547150895,
0.0125196567,
-0.0282525774,
-0.0532602705,
-6.12683782e-33,
-0.0031055715,
0.0106292944,
0.0062618158,
-0.0208013747,
-0.0564779565,
-0.0018219016,
-0.0188407376,
-0.0324230008,
-0.0069120931,
-0.0047013699,
-0.0169723388,
0.025042247,
0.010253448,
0.0402891003,
0.0477814116,
-0.0362657048,
0.0568695217,
-0.0167511273,
-0.0021719369,
0.0179269239,
0.0675309598,
0.0342399441,
0.0567025542,
-0.0598376468,
-0.0437022187,
0.0086628105,
-0.0031067093,
-0.0075941524,
0.0342266448,
0.0172066912,
-0.0370261632,
0.0192391481,
0.0000242403,
-0.0561570823,
-0.026469158,
-0.0116423611,
-0.0653029382,
-0.0211604852,
-0.0294448957,
0.0321586952,
0.0204703752,
-0.0184606053,
0.0725700334,
-0.0166468136,
-0.0396577939,
0.0037561199,
0.0405217335,
-0.0221319385,
-0.0330798514,
-0.0357872844,
-0.0386626832,
0.005067104,
-0.0227318555,
0.0070823575,
-0.0042342693,
0.0412059873,
-0.0471751727,
0.0168185793,
-0.0601450466,
0.0013643437,
-0.0294212978,
0.0100452034,
0.049072288,
0.0431546792,
0.0474583171,
0.0749277323,
0.0287936367,
-0.0349926502,
-0.0056615178,
0.0189489834,
0.0068302145,
0.0401028804,
0.0473293699,
-0.0244648233,
0.0558955297,
-0.0351242311,
-0.0474293716,
-0.0124450224,
0.006901464,
0.0445198156,
0.0230172407,
0.027994018,
-0.0352215581,
-0.0069703297,
0.023594657,
-0.0102939419,
0.0118480762,
-0.0387940183,
0.0387029052,
0.023126293,
0.0262856856,
0.0036640835,
0.0212134272,
-0.0667533949,
0.0582752377,
-0.0036862863,
-0.0122305555,
0.0278193392,
0.012870892,
-0.0284493044,
-0.054116562,
-0.0561233908,
-0.0028206646,
0.0423989333,
0.0474184453,
-0.0308973305,
0.0096675903,
0.0464402474,
-0.0670949295,
-0.005174736,
-0.0185011048,
0.0124331303,
0.0329074301,
-0.0120426565,
0.06308797,
-0.0319768004,
-0.0193140358,
0.0638206676,
-0.0246027969,
0.03455396,
0.0029766681,
0.0313004516,
-0.0119245229,
0.0062755337,
-0.0243579019,
-0.0091228522,
-0.0173339937,
0.0219865087,
-0.0211082287,
-0.0749871209,
-0.0499321222,
0.0226294696,
2.886e-7,
0.0036990638,
0.058464095,
0.0404216237,
-0.0238862522,
0.0264696945,
0.0027537101,
-0.0363362245,
0.0179334935,
0.0164784249,
0.0499147139,
0.0239410698,
0.0078535536,
0.0506996252,
0.0149279935,
-0.0753142014,
-0.0384364985,
-0.1153820753,
-0.000032915,
-0.028727673,
0.0199670494,
0.0037253078,
0.110808894,
0.0439588279,
0.0153870974,
0.0391911604,
-0.1181057915,
0.0581499301,
-0.0449665785,
0.0299804527,
0.0183063336,
0.0237705447,
0.0586357526,
-0.0452658311,
-0.0413941741,
-0.0067975051,
0.0585168116,
-0.0183336549,
0.0029273522,
0.0104635237,
-0.0091340616,
-0.0084453123,
-0.0077368421,
-0.0105957584,
-0.0599575527,
0.0610142276,
-0.1443469673,
-0.0407031886,
-0.0308328625,
-0.0167756416,
-0.0110445851,
0.0671693832,
0.021686716,
0.0121063208,
0.0007445446,
0.0065699136,
-0.0166033432,
-0.0361096188,
-0.0541434996,
0.0179437604,
0.0439472497,
-0.0911018476,
-0.0086152116,
-0.0496154316,
-0.0047852928,
0.0547923595,
0.033212021,
-0.0217908602,
2.366494666e-34,
0.0415838286,
-0.0364683345,
0.0157472249,
0.0147677753,
-0.0053230068,
0.0058179828,
0.0483833961,
-0.0070024589,
0.0049986485,
-0.0562564582,
-0.007056898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08614v1 | XplainLLM: A QA Explanation Dataset for Understanding LLM Decision-Making | 2023-11-15T00:34:28 | 2023-11-15T00:34:28 | Zichen Chen, Jianda Chen, Mitali Gaidhani, Ambuj Singh, Misha Sra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently made impressive strides in natural
language understanding tasks. Despite their remarkable performance,
understanding their decision-making process remains a big challenge. In this
paper, we look into bringing some transparency to this process by introducing a
new explanation dataset for question answering (QA) tasks that integrates
knowledge graphs (KGs) in a novel way. Our dataset includes 12,102
question-answer-explanation (QAE) triples. Each explanation in the dataset
links the LLM's reasoning to entities and relations in the KGs. The explanation
component includes a why-choose explanation, a why-not-choose explanation, and
a set of reason-elements that underlie the LLM's decision. We leverage KGs and
graph attention networks (GAT) to find the reason-elements and transform them
into why-choose and why-not-choose explanations that are comprehensible to
humans. Through quantitative and qualitative evaluations, we demonstrate the
potential of our dataset to improve the in-context learning of LLMs, and
enhance their interpretability and explainability. Our work contributes to the
field of explainable AI by enabling a deeper understanding of the LLMs
decision-making process to make them more transparent and thereby, potentially
more reliable, to researchers and practitioners alike. Our dataset is available
at: https://github.com/chen-zichen/XplainLLM_dataset.git | [
0.0248129703,
0.0243871473,
0.0166082922,
0.0688693821,
0.0016545161,
0.0265215598,
-0.0032549198,
-0.0248319618,
0.0309279636,
0.0120950565,
-0.0059519969,
0.0217244942,
-0.0050248932,
0.0290422086,
0.0299344938,
-0.0258674696,
0.0154212061,
-0.0295799784,
0.0202437341,
0.0186558347,
0.0099027585,
0.0640380308,
-0.0037659791,
0.0438201837,
0.0320942402,
-0.0158007592,
-0.0373584069,
0.0112232855,
-0.0060959249,
-0.012611798,
-0.0164684001,
-0.0036737367,
0.0556103848,
-0.0103855859,
0.0000017893,
-0.0261418279,
0.0084229866,
-0.0148366028,
-0.0940842852,
0.0146087697,
-0.0508401655,
0.0065701138,
0.0498211347,
0.0155456997,
-0.023693826,
0.0291644,
0.0318584479,
0.0367905051,
0.0846441239,
0.0448074788,
0.0097138183,
-0.024363365,
-0.0214240942,
-0.0304770079,
0.043926388,
-0.0622550212,
0.0176352486,
0.0314469114,
-0.0124772359,
-0.0058099916,
-0.0339732431,
0.001083854,
0.0401930138,
-0.0318663791,
0.0166771766,
0.0141103743,
-0.0037411531,
-0.012320728,
0.0074740802,
0.1346315145,
0.0024307997,
-0.034674909,
-0.0023287754,
-0.0111227874,
0.0021348218,
0.0022223482,
-0.0623390637,
-0.0159422699,
-0.0009215331,
0.0150793707,
-0.0071962303,
-0.0159315169,
0.0643715635,
0.0181901269,
-0.0249007214,
0.0818112567,
-0.0240575336,
0.0062283669,
0.0073695192,
-0.0047424519,
-0.053397283,
-0.0616458654,
-0.0129913054,
0.0889768079,
-0.0367939882,
0.0496773012,
-0.0123943575,
0.0203271769,
0.0006090094,
0.0030091996,
0.023967918,
0.0179105606,
0.0116498591,
0.0946561545,
-0.0244341195,
0.0515020378,
-0.0193436109,
0.0336599015,
-0.0387079008,
-0.0386188217,
-0.0387270525,
-0.0253949352,
-0.0094800564,
0.0076604476,
-0.021475533,
-0.0130951246,
-0.0268606059,
0.0376792625,
-0.0301980954,
0.0366240256,
0.0614846572,
0.0688267872,
0.0088574644,
-0.0432285964,
-0.0611770153,
0.0237479694,
-0.0686350986,
0.0370023362,
0.0256916378,
-0.0307995416,
-0.0542556942,
0.0177903082,
0.0251145884,
-0.0284176376,
0.0111390119,
0.0685155466,
0.0297414344,
-0.0015675667,
-0.0265431739,
-0.0375738926,
0.0104409428,
-0.0361139104,
-0.0193143748,
-0.0188403707,
0.0459584109,
0.008341521,
-0.0193262435,
-0.0468078852,
0.0272746626,
0.0076496471,
-0.0365854539,
0.0841134414,
-0.0282589141,
0.0268884003,
-0.0180372037,
0.0155218728,
-0.0321282297,
0.0433444418,
0.0252708942,
0.0075629484,
0.0467985943,
-0.0316393115,
0.0150421085,
-0.0051341499,
0.0671997815,
0.0101368977,
0.0064366488,
0.0520167947,
-0.0678166896,
0.053669598,
0.0426605418,
-0.0160523467,
-0.0059564342,
-0.0348383002,
0.032731805,
0.0364536047,
0.0129847964,
-0.003707384,
0.0128802024,
0.0102493111,
-0.0114513105,
-0.0042459723,
-0.0264940467,
0.0588379838,
-0.0082767773,
0.0069868569,
0.0175695214,
-0.0166833047,
-0.0289656948,
-0.0455524698,
0.013824299,
0.0139003368,
0.0155991279,
0.0467709303,
0.0377606489,
0.0182674248,
-0.040336594,
0.039432019,
0.020181451,
-0.032356225,
-0.0112278517,
-0.0520154573,
0.0826610178,
0.0861987919,
0.0519099571,
-0.019413488,
-0.0410135649,
-0.0095588472,
0.0203334689,
-0.0047820499,
-0.0023949277,
-0.0140603576,
0.0414783545,
-0.0605187602,
-0.036963392,
-0.0565995872,
-0.0182634406,
0.0096121309,
0.0440803096,
-0.0178916492,
0.0180505514,
-0.0947353095,
-0.0101037743,
0.0087734433,
-0.0175565835,
-0.0434085168,
0.008100885,
-0.001388005,
0.0288454965,
0.031178873,
0.0387667008,
0.0190852061,
0.0338953249,
0.0045351759,
-0.00367494,
0.0252519324,
-0.0137406951,
-0.0505650118,
0.0280523077,
-0.0210566428,
-0.029682368,
0.0178918168,
-0.0783905238,
-0.0857038274,
0.0192697868,
-0.0301950555,
0.0227705035,
-0.0102525735,
-0.0387968831,
0.0337265097,
0.025528647,
-0.0006652754,
0.0482674018,
-0.0141414478,
0.0073886365,
0.0142909968,
0.0233165789,
0.0098566199,
-0.0239558835,
0.0379923321,
0.007208508,
0.0145607591,
-0.0169970859,
-0.0038882189,
-0.0017862318,
-0.0728894547,
0.0357945524,
-0.0473016724,
0.0070530791,
0.0083001796,
0.029942248,
0.0324088857,
0.0000201479,
0.0314805619,
-0.0193389542,
-0.0610698424,
0.0279970337,
0.0225213766,
-0.0170586649,
0.0542162023,
-0.0175548047,
-0.0236245152,
-0.0396902449,
-0.0210465267,
-0.0075948979,
0.072180666,
-0.0009656007,
0.0162014533,
-0.0501100272,
0.0052431743,
-0.0384494402,
-0.009576208,
-0.0332768559,
-0.0223592408,
0.0096682049,
-0.0073118387,
-0.0265196282,
0.0668821633,
-0.0288457181,
0.0546451733,
0.0257302448,
0.0051833298,
-0.0587717444,
0.0075682602,
-0.0335442163,
-0.0026131605,
-0.0383092612,
-0.0465649739,
-0.0033850006,
0.0619862303,
0.0006092369,
-0.0072467052,
-0.0495262183,
0.030001808,
0.0488350056,
0.0090842219,
-0.046071142,
-0.0313769244,
0.0088438317,
0.0392413139,
-0.0431672633,
-0.0335736386,
0.1023408622,
-0.0084111346,
-0.0190769807,
0.0093873385,
-0.0195273608,
-0.0782306045,
0.062173564,
-0.0124297878,
-0.0278017912,
-0.0180933978,
-0.0129699232,
-0.0138103114,
-0.045189254,
0.0143265044,
-0.0071857409,
0.0346260928,
-0.0293761194,
0.0035635447,
0.0225047581,
0.0208536591,
-0.0287038628,
-0.010521478,
-0.0633800924,
-0.0013840378,
-0.0090503851,
-0.021977663,
-0.0147575932,
-0.0249759704,
0.0391640663,
-0.002812587,
-0.0125296414,
0.0089106839,
-0.0314808153,
0.0440720282,
0.0488916673,
0.0595934205,
0.0428012647,
-0.0086479085,
0.0355834141,
0.0287004616,
0.0238585286,
-0.0246598274,
-0.0168452039,
-0.0012296912,
-0.0122659924,
-0.0073882993,
0.017140165,
-0.0271753334,
0.0667360574,
-0.0901212469,
0.0027719182,
0.0990066454,
0.0026723472,
-0.0303745288,
0.0090821739,
-0.0010088905,
0.0144319236,
0.0183896199,
0.0098329801,
-0.0775700137,
-0.0681996569,
-0.0081968699,
0.0402212441,
0.0330249704,
-0.0225703344,
-0.0144220404,
-0.0720872506,
0.0108984271,
-0.0218113624,
-0.0192720089,
-0.0808300897,
-0.0491924435,
-0.0098687019,
-0.0273985211,
0.0155287925,
-0.0090442616,
0.0229453091,
0.0205383077,
0.0242623556,
-0.0079167513,
-0.0216360372,
0.0615929477,
-0.0029170201,
0.0409699865,
0.037356317,
0.0449933,
0.0125503326,
-0.036881201,
-0.0033885268,
-0.0343725085,
-0.0084184427,
0.0037848472,
0.04783158,
-0.0023336471,
-0.0257345531,
-0.0395016186,
0.0579672828,
-0.1050114781,
-0.0249951389,
0.0139156226,
0.0812772289,
-0.0290921498,
-0.0266230628,
0.0139652072,
0.0013449334,
-0.0051353746,
0.0844025165,
0.0798843652,
0.0023593479,
-0.0511118844,
-0.0550597236,
-0.0150724519,
-0.0697377548,
-0.011786296,
0.0191028118,
0.0178595502,
0.0245096907,
-0.0249115136,
-0.0463660173,
0.0412683375,
-0.007296253,
-0.0182507839,
-0.0017192601,
-0.0099717909,
0.0096717747,
-0.0375333726,
0.0630536303,
-0.0142928837,
0.0225416776,
-0.0027545036,
-0.0164647549,
0.0083338767,
-0.032030046,
-0.0150172645,
0.0067719966,
-0.0500444844,
-0.0245311018,
-0.047788009,
0.0217106547,
0.0273475815,
0.0557624027,
-0.0160167012,
-0.0441028066,
0.0012368128,
-0.0296368655,
-0.0211374778,
-0.0297089908,
0.0370158963,
0.0245041884,
0.0015281488,
0.0539684705,
-0.0460494682,
-0.0241746251,
-0.0046211928,
0.0227889903,
-0.0556947701,
-0.0318055116,
0.0054419972,
-0.0101067955,
-0.0253964942,
0.0215552207,
0.0126589993,
-0.0431334041,
0.0376973636,
-0.0061008283,
0.0011340531,
-0.0572901145,
0.0044453302,
0.009415295,
-0.0765404403,
0.0015886922,
-0.0828274861,
-0.0116581721,
-0.0245473795,
-0.0179676358,
0.0320267081,
0.0364083424,
-0.0265190322,
-0.0051852041,
-0.0127617316,
-0.0148600638,
0.0295736827,
-0.0279284716,
0.0345274322,
0.0126634762,
0.0511407703,
0.0281522032,
-0.0058035431,
-0.0160827432,
0.003621958,
-0.052827511,
-0.0653819069,
0.0129524227,
-0.0087447455,
0.0293187592,
0.0000490302,
0.066027984,
0.0129302172,
-0.0079642674,
0.002476014,
0.0735217705,
0.0023431689,
-0.0098717688,
0.048185613,
0.0349684581,
-0.0232654233,
0.0009895002,
0.0914475247,
0.0349730514,
0.0239815544,
0.012563399,
-0.0406282768,
-0.0092736324,
-0.0242225118,
-0.0006058255,
0.0523931086,
0.0090201134,
0.0111250244,
-0.0274536368,
-0.0827724114,
-0.0278136563,
0.0131583782,
-0.0492259674,
-0.0205879286,
0.0145314652,
0.0287848432,
0.0256978273,
-0.0328865275,
-0.0253745373,
0.0365788639,
-0.0579532124,
-0.0074765272,
-0.0046014474,
-5.693501745e-33,
-0.0040388862,
-0.077619046,
0.0021393842,
-0.0310902093,
-0.0140524646,
0.0064662728,
-0.0740826949,
-0.0487043597,
-0.0617246106,
0.0272533204,
-0.0002422484,
0.0589315556,
-0.0074207112,
0.0424190275,
-0.0132892458,
-0.0732823312,
-0.0134137655,
0.020993527,
0.0064361305,
0.0564587601,
0.0488053486,
0.0088565974,
0.0713651255,
-0.031339962,
0.0398438759,
-0.0070866095,
-0.005311152,
0.0325179882,
-0.0460316911,
0.0691031441,
-0.0063841278,
0.0508706719,
0.0246945266,
-0.0483718216,
0.0118740527,
0.0335209556,
-0.0801812336,
-0.0209014472,
0.0508011095,
0.0099176848,
-0.0771227181,
-0.0531625412,
0.0308351014,
0.0138158165,
0.0658000782,
-0.0419230983,
0.0280743372,
-0.0154351825,
-0.0227902383,
0.0070345066,
0.0275849737,
0.0227455553,
-0.0670231208,
-0.0415199697,
0.0140636787,
0.0221301988,
-0.0099224672,
0.0234969724,
-0.0369442515,
-0.0198547412,
0.0109072216,
-0.0024492019,
0.0616925471,
-0.0067458325,
0.0043395301,
0.0283230077,
-0.0029107314,
-0.0331071094,
-0.0785326213,
0.0067812372,
-0.0545982495,
0.0699732974,
0.0690890253,
0.0027095296,
-0.0179872699,
0.0048415279,
-0.0877585188,
0.0128161302,
-0.0172736403,
0.0425241441,
0.025341481,
-0.0096707931,
-0.001976219,
-0.0278482325,
-0.045911178,
-0.0069482373,
-0.0395615101,
-0.0066804108,
0.0172926839,
-0.0367117338,
-0.0254928507,
0.0014777881,
-0.0021686743,
-0.0543626212,
0.017819725,
0.0853434503,
0.0018990019,
-0.0101676872,
0.0200921129,
0.007396936,
-0.0340824984,
0.0291514583,
0.0213668589,
-0.0298479795,
0.0169390514,
0.009184639,
0.0250677224,
-0.0203215908,
0.0003971406,
-0.0249404814,
-0.0853747204,
0.0013363666,
-0.0779826641,
-0.002798121,
0.040664535,
0.0510095879,
-0.0289838668,
0.0146512557,
0.0121258432,
0.032403443,
0.0071680723,
0.0170194674,
-0.0178605914,
0.0221473668,
-0.0316052064,
-0.0228787027,
-0.0402307548,
-0.0062203226,
0.0114993015,
-0.0324838534,
-0.0117392801,
0.0285259318,
2.343e-7,
0.0492111892,
0.0132544143,
0.0367221273,
0.0563462265,
0.031353429,
0.0383142792,
0.0176080186,
0.001458116,
-0.0105564157,
-0.0658233091,
0.0411102623,
0.0479573272,
0.0368435569,
0.0151314773,
-0.0204942599,
0.0059012962,
-0.0470733866,
-0.0329975374,
-0.0356037915,
-0.0094969571,
0.0632715672,
0.0692380369,
0.0271485541,
-0.0004207096,
0.0228824299,
-0.0176003203,
0.013897364,
-0.0369114801,
0.031719055,
-0.0061954432,
0.0600311682,
-0.0107059889,
0.0044992822,
0.0107113831,
-0.0094912145,
0.008371192,
-0.0125533491,
0.062681213,
0.0011927168,
-0.0723776147,
-0.0433907807,
-0.044740919,
0.0503014401,
-0.087648809,
0.098014541,
-0.0133114737,
-0.0534721352,
0.0042572618,
-0.009033137,
-0.0359807871,
-0.0106675494,
-0.0133010577,
0.0172681343,
-0.0029292945,
-0.0063356007,
-0.0552047193,
0.0198212247,
-0.0960862264,
-0.0225284547,
0.0038976339,
-0.0306985676,
0.0237587914,
-0.0263080429,
-0.0063070478,
0.0483213216,
-0.0330590196,
-0.0094044497,
2.008016184e-34,
-0.0053520519,
0.0131325861,
0.0118741989,
0.0392244197,
0.053589128,
-0.0066508055,
-0.0101616401,
-0.020635508,
0.0622403063,
-0.0777592957,
-0.012470318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08607v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08607v1 | Towards Generalizable SER: Soft Labeling and Data Augmentation for Modeling Temporal Emotion Shifts in Large-Scale Multilingual Speech | 2023-11-15T00:09:21 | 2023-11-15T00:09:21 | Mohamed Osman, Tamer Nadeem, Ghada Khoriba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Recognizing emotions in spoken communication is crucial for advanced
human-machine interaction. Current emotion detection methodologies often
display biases when applied cross-corpus. To address this, our study
amalgamates 16 diverse datasets, resulting in 375 hours of data across
languages like English, Chinese, and Japanese. We propose a soft labeling
system to capture gradational emotional intensities. Using the Whisper encoder
and data augmentation methods inspired by contrastive learning, our method
emphasizes the temporal dynamics of emotions. Our validation on four
multilingual datasets demonstrates notable zero-shot generalization. We publish
our open source model weights and initial promising results after fine-tuning
on Hume-Prosody. | [
-0.028386794,
0.0783671215,
-0.0065621627,
-0.0021273568,
0.0373143591,
0.0209393986,
0.0140635027,
-0.025337195,
-0.0120531442,
0.0022087439,
-0.0546773709,
-0.0140894894,
-0.0205386989,
0.0557445772,
0.0116671473,
-0.0931516662,
0.0309532043,
0.0207375363,
0.0514636934,
-0.0181266963,
0.0459716842,
0.0074253744,
-0.0398303419,
0.0190822408,
-0.0355631262,
-0.0108251441,
-0.0473602042,
0.0285013262,
0.0860910043,
-0.0553526059,
0.0360196047,
0.0515781827,
0.0390642844,
0.040796794,
0.0000019273,
-0.013006757,
0.0113858199,
0.0000649569,
-0.0294449739,
0.0161900092,
0.0581775904,
-0.0218065903,
-0.0309156068,
0.0030705431,
-0.0247939639,
-0.0229673199,
0.060556177,
-0.0000219317,
0.0817949772,
0.074670881,
-0.0349267572,
-0.0021988126,
0.0006896818,
-0.0194725804,
-0.0067276494,
-0.0443393253,
0.0119511727,
-0.0203354694,
-0.0015193981,
-0.0521490127,
-0.048996374,
0.013039967,
0.0016929404,
0.0063336515,
0.0264133401,
-0.0010150175,
-0.0376680084,
0.0103650596,
-0.0210699216,
0.0668199137,
0.0133988075,
0.0257782787,
0.0046749245,
0.0072474913,
-0.0094118994,
-0.0694927275,
0.0099788047,
-0.053031221,
0.051050432,
0.0077487184,
0.0241362508,
0.0603341386,
-0.0043189605,
-0.0058865915,
0.0043372852,
0.0075470353,
-0.0178610478,
-0.0355049893,
0.0146602029,
-0.0227789432,
-0.000658131,
0.0075980253,
0.0351644494,
0.0044196062,
-0.0248794407,
-0.0058092391,
-0.0297116414,
-0.0584307462,
-0.0300977658,
-0.0279860198,
-0.0142429313,
0.0239376035,
-0.0835624412,
0.0271233767,
0.0379647501,
0.0393617228,
0.0259498656,
-0.049913872,
-0.0217648428,
-0.0336155742,
-0.0074605695,
0.0327202454,
-0.009533884,
-0.0142451106,
-0.0227563176,
-0.0295196269,
-0.0948231965,
-0.0179458894,
-0.0625000447,
0.0217669979,
-0.0177117065,
-0.0093102176,
-0.0345482305,
-0.0019821916,
0.0214130264,
0.0603421815,
-0.043718718,
0.0481499285,
0.0047553265,
-0.0715137944,
0.0154453237,
0.0131071443,
0.0333836228,
0.0092866486,
0.0134430053,
0.0173883792,
-0.0347509161,
0.0075104688,
-0.0578263327,
0.000857082,
-0.0534114577,
-0.0277273189,
-0.0333817154,
-0.0292771198,
0.0355871245,
-0.0301198047,
0.0230735503,
-0.0528369695,
-0.011851836,
-0.0691634193,
0.0072220899,
0.0641471371,
-0.0386862457,
-0.0202626716,
-0.0226338282,
-0.0197626464,
-0.0011984585,
0.0514721386,
0.0395996086,
0.0171497185,
0.0439057648,
-0.0224713832,
0.0317284688,
0.0619746298,
0.0055131544,
0.0112836333,
-0.0374891385,
-0.0630441606,
0.0055480879,
0.0160386041,
0.0502585582,
-0.0022528216,
-0.0223544668,
-0.0513987094,
0.0625687391,
0.0335343555,
-0.0159485824,
0.0357001685,
-0.0109196985,
0.0354568139,
-0.0093733948,
-0.0261915922,
-0.0024697655,
0.0352254882,
-0.0401036628,
-0.0079194857,
0.0223590173,
0.0169501342,
-0.0506019033,
-0.0437399261,
-0.0109696751,
-0.0234749783,
0.0330925174,
0.0375788286,
0.0655355826,
-0.0091802217,
-0.0189508777,
0.011685892,
0.0434620753,
-0.0677155405,
0.0133206975,
0.0013663431,
-0.0068202862,
0.0689566508,
-0.0383882187,
-0.0628179461,
-0.0153365321,
-0.0271722842,
0.0022014298,
0.0343576148,
0.0338931978,
-0.0180497412,
0.0555639155,
-0.0876434222,
0.0221418943,
0.0144557944,
-0.0053131767,
0.0247956533,
-0.0227723438,
0.0449592173,
-0.0211850796,
-0.0325722173,
0.0028001762,
-0.0304140262,
-0.0449733399,
-0.0309335403,
0.0143286837,
0.0255072732,
0.0530381203,
0.0260780901,
-0.0128216287,
-0.0580766015,
0.0127042765,
-0.0052784537,
0.0170759205,
0.0543243289,
-0.0163871553,
-0.0383633077,
0.0425862297,
-0.0025840416,
0.0015624281,
0.0303122457,
-0.0792616233,
-0.0576051027,
0.0554281548,
0.0064474922,
0.0132913766,
-0.0234816615,
0.0109059354,
-0.0246459544,
0.0797269419,
0.032126762,
-0.0116163706,
0.0175623745,
-0.0278745517,
-0.0270103719,
0.0167430732,
-0.0109759597,
-0.0520663559,
-0.0736109912,
0.0121457232,
0.0052853357,
0.0023890403,
-0.0205368791,
-0.0492213033,
-0.0583582856,
-0.0382789746,
-0.078717567,
-0.0279901251,
0.004221593,
-0.0112447459,
-0.0001250666,
0.0112524694,
-0.030211838,
-0.0077382578,
-0.039412912,
0.0257672835,
-0.0025538937,
-0.0046270997,
-0.0238543302,
-0.0028621277,
0.018887531,
-0.0585035495,
0.0259900223,
-0.0079691093,
-0.0001179183,
-0.0329335704,
-0.002551489,
-0.0323767774,
0.0221950226,
-0.0417241082,
0.037171647,
-0.0203026459,
-0.081286639,
-0.0088413199,
0.01526161,
0.0296368822,
0.0760626495,
0.0068711955,
0.0743659958,
-0.0078048138,
-0.0567563586,
-0.0231246054,
0.0564221926,
0.0019681596,
0.021747455,
-0.049016472,
-0.0266083684,
-0.0570012555,
0.0700942501,
-0.0087548308,
0.0342808142,
-0.0368717797,
-0.0441401675,
-0.0042134514,
-0.0465185158,
0.0430665687,
0.0068291547,
-0.0217605028,
0.000051628,
0.0017554731,
-0.019272143,
0.0461983569,
0.0158732124,
-0.0634550378,
-0.0462516025,
-0.064306438,
-0.0081853624,
0.0600136109,
-0.0759952515,
-0.011481598,
0.0231203418,
-0.0207047034,
-0.0124054644,
-0.0318781324,
-0.0070899604,
-0.0517179556,
0.0273884889,
-0.0075391894,
-0.0470210575,
0.0374863036,
-0.0261215046,
-0.0069457791,
-0.000165566,
-0.0648398325,
0.0109436652,
0.02074733,
-0.0480972156,
-0.0143476017,
0.0006533652,
0.011406363,
-0.0076846434,
-0.0192772746,
0.008018354,
-0.0088679884,
0.024086291,
0.0528388433,
-0.0042312746,
0.003449355,
-0.0191571359,
0.0501044877,
0.0196728986,
0.0730155855,
0.0074008573,
-0.058228787,
0.0380356051,
0.0352615081,
0.0263887085,
-0.0097144963,
-0.0082387188,
0.0514599457,
-0.0199130252,
0.0307756811,
0.1248374581,
-0.0074724457,
-0.0597045757,
0.0219777487,
-0.0345905013,
0.0391415395,
0.0321408026,
0.0083683422,
-0.0426898338,
-0.0454353131,
0.0207997486,
0.0320923515,
0.0047534122,
-0.0221191179,
0.030115217,
-0.0922981426,
0.0457780473,
0.0428868607,
-0.0344176404,
-0.0143688135,
-0.0103143873,
0.0432133414,
-0.0378407761,
0.0132200737,
-0.0632914528,
0.036542818,
-0.0177126657,
0.0655900165,
-0.0115148034,
-0.0379208401,
0.0348882042,
-0.0300090592,
0.0573963225,
0.0083513549,
0.0852956921,
-0.0241229907,
-0.0419268571,
0.0389468968,
0.0449069589,
-0.0556664094,
-0.0127948429,
0.0560404137,
-0.0030828994,
-0.0294040125,
0.0111651728,
0.0463202633,
-0.0100746546,
0.0260868743,
0.0174857937,
0.0506836064,
0.0055703917,
-0.0007601917,
-0.0010423694,
0.0460787266,
0.0190706626,
0.0262085404,
0.005918086,
-0.0693825483,
0.0381521061,
-0.0202477369,
0.0518315919,
0.0049082688,
-0.0085609443,
-0.004398278,
-0.0106731085,
-0.0418147743,
-0.0501395687,
-0.0326807909,
-0.0142397033,
0.0095281126,
-0.0055915429,
-0.0481497906,
0.0059829061,
-0.0162260067,
-0.0316834114,
-0.0016786449,
0.0223952718,
0.0228403658,
-0.0178521741,
-0.0446053445,
0.0701123029,
0.0014846155,
-0.0052162176,
0.0171409026,
-0.0284992028,
-0.0717912391,
0.0447077379,
0.0115743689,
0.0096860677,
0.0471377075,
-0.0086807813,
-0.0307692364,
0.0540652424,
0.0377710164,
-0.0187814757,
0.0085918056,
0.0800090879,
0.0039496794,
-0.0138680637,
0.0040877075,
-0.0626590773,
0.0367109329,
0.0075907325,
0.0028949804,
-0.0270898528,
-0.0543583296,
-0.0407647453,
-0.0160727389,
0.0599431433,
0.032420855,
-0.0382366516,
-0.0461562239,
-0.0203227792,
-0.0040879394,
0.011770417,
-0.0538165085,
-0.0484989919,
0.0060378867,
0.0129566034,
-0.0374212936,
-0.0144311683,
0.0110737244,
-0.0448040627,
-0.0442968048,
0.0434614085,
0.0381093435,
0.0462171622,
-0.023233708,
0.0433471017,
0.0096219182,
0.0166637078,
0.0185194016,
0.0034406139,
0.009858652,
0.0103557296,
0.0221220069,
0.0070329499,
0.0227911193,
0.0157840643,
-0.0041293981,
0.0134258186,
-0.0351354778,
-0.0223099366,
0.0296751112,
-0.0159662012,
0.077403672,
-0.0143407602,
0.0176161565,
-0.0123349577,
0.019867342,
-0.051041685,
-0.0485306159,
-0.0167359523,
0.0050104228,
-0.0250677168,
0.0590048209,
0.0330602042,
-0.0487260222,
0.0654383749,
0.0173171442,
0.0239474755,
-0.0313919857,
0.0231785253,
0.0617349669,
-0.0139030358,
0.0126327462,
0.0031428598,
-0.0329272263,
-0.0737179071,
0.0491227545,
-0.0318856835,
-0.0010536772,
-0.0104322629,
0.0434117876,
0.033133693,
-0.0544974916,
0.0247177016,
-0.0113367215,
-0.0387506261,
-0.0055972859,
-0.0372450501,
0.0258857179,
-6.004868158e-33,
-0.0097910101,
0.0251925215,
-0.0470223576,
0.0118785696,
-0.0310991425,
0.0608573854,
-0.0269007944,
0.0021038044,
-0.0062126396,
0.0538498424,
0.0004590467,
0.028345231,
0.0225716941,
0.0217093024,
0.022158619,
-0.0321004279,
0.0517981015,
-0.0099329371,
0.0135540674,
0.0423094817,
0.0262036417,
0.031526383,
0.1186394542,
-0.0845260024,
0.0015398256,
0.0412519015,
-0.045576483,
-0.0085373884,
0.087057732,
0.0369162709,
0.0164089818,
0.0602943636,
-0.0257943757,
-0.0131259011,
-0.0115021225,
-0.0082856324,
-0.0684283301,
0.0007039732,
-0.0343561918,
0.044272121,
-0.0235783923,
-0.0108090397,
-0.0012697761,
0.0160250571,
-0.0051896991,
-0.0256456863,
0.0377356596,
-0.0254992191,
0.0216401704,
-0.1112485379,
-0.0215405989,
0.0194836166,
-0.0549456403,
-0.0492686331,
0.0394896343,
0.0623042583,
0.0107918885,
0.0225817375,
-0.0876717269,
0.019188812,
0.0235023871,
0.0067367214,
0.0190005209,
0.0135324122,
0.0184467528,
0.0541906729,
0.0637471825,
0.0047016498,
0.0719988123,
0.0357308537,
0.0496532246,
0.0097137922,
0.0110728135,
0.009408066,
0.0260119718,
-0.022381749,
-0.0003138148,
0.0230548773,
0.072163634,
0.0041872277,
0.0343816206,
0.0690037608,
0.0036577734,
0.0015873479,
-0.0208948739,
-0.0566209294,
-0.0149536133,
-0.0225884933,
0.010281276,
-0.0077650244,
0.0237921663,
0.0170506053,
0.0356197543,
-0.005462172,
-0.0016458166,
0.00856339,
-0.0239286255,
0.0393155031,
0.0018842435,
0.0004554014,
-0.0148055255,
-0.0473681763,
0.0535498038,
0.0295148436,
0.0656237006,
-0.0192922205,
-0.0096022319,
0.0417460278,
-0.0394137204,
0.0134587642,
0.0005822317,
0.0208311416,
-0.0086916257,
-0.0055806069,
-0.0113828266,
-0.0313806906,
0.000776767,
0.0484949164,
0.0061319415,
0.06765984,
-0.0096264081,
-0.0403512754,
-0.0067355484,
0.0454623327,
-0.0654492378,
0.0054980218,
-0.0230448227,
-0.0394808613,
0.0070317928,
-0.0115432097,
-0.0019120933,
-0.0004329163,
2.85e-7,
-0.0631809384,
0.0233653989,
0.0220272578,
-0.0048483391,
0.0308022127,
0.0493490398,
-0.0112059955,
0.024147626,
0.0411865339,
0.0036859571,
0.0460903421,
-0.0040821452,
0.0924616605,
0.01884019,
-0.0929202661,
-0.0525601134,
-0.0532837398,
-0.0028748799,
-0.0063592889,
0.0159930922,
0.0294411629,
0.0949090496,
0.0488045514,
0.0256094709,
0.0451594181,
0.0011023068,
0.0052549103,
-0.0223183725,
-0.004229838,
0.0219943877,
-0.0061842115,
-0.0092832781,
-0.0250641927,
0.0018199645,
-0.0220911615,
0.0067185573,
0.0151505657,
0.0167591739,
-0.0037453617,
-0.0811492577,
-0.0111364452,
0.0612588152,
-0.0391245969,
-0.0151819922,
0.0216023661,
-0.0366752036,
-0.0457888842,
-0.0028766827,
-0.051481504,
-0.015463871,
0.0157665685,
-0.0535885282,
-0.0402346104,
0.0454538986,
0.0005608242,
0.0197130851,
-0.0774770379,
-0.0455884039,
0.005278484,
0.0465124249,
-0.0301065985,
-0.0245783851,
0.0086853895,
-0.0201640092,
-0.0040194369,
-0.0132601699,
0.0235251077,
2.034854878e-34,
0.035349559,
-0.0073914444,
-0.0137519697,
0.0657985657,
0.0264526345,
-0.005072407,
-0.0426713042,
-0.0053961519,
0.0529718138,
-0.0240991917,
-0.0265777539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08605v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08605v2 | Exploring the Jungle of Bias: Political Bias Attribution in Language Models via Dependency Analysis | 2023-11-15T00:02:25 | 2024-05-12T13:56:25 | David F. Jenny, Yann Billeter, Mrinmaya Sachan, Bernhard Schölkopf, Zhijing Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.SI | The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has sparked intense
debate regarding the prevalence of bias in these models and its mitigation.
Yet, as exemplified by both results on debiasing methods in the literature and
reports of alignment-related defects from the wider community, bias remains a
poorly understood topic despite its practical relevance. To enhance the
understanding of the internal causes of bias, we analyse LLM bias through the
lens of causal fairness analysis, which enables us to both comprehend the
origins of bias and reason about its downstream consequences and mitigation. To
operationalize this framework, we propose a prompt-based method for the
extraction of confounding and mediating attributes which contribute to the LLM
decision process. By applying Activity Dependency Networks (ADNs), we then
analyse how these attributes influence an LLM's decision process. We apply our
method to LLM ratings of argument quality in political debates. We find that
the observed disparate treatment can at least in part be attributed to
confounding and mitigating attributes and model misalignment, and discuss the
consequences of our findings for human-AI alignment and bias mitigation. Our
code and data are at https://github.com/david-jenny/LLM-Political-Study. | [
0.0284962133,
0.07196109,
-0.0300016925,
0.0584396012,
-0.0320805088,
-0.0074196914,
0.0155626023,
-0.0195066705,
0.022554541,
-0.0646135956,
0.0163436346,
0.0007231245,
0.0127991317,
0.0028534154,
0.000686903,
-0.0758187249,
0.0273712035,
0.0242367424,
0.0863773152,
-0.0476129651,
0.0340973511,
0.009210364,
0.011893075,
0.0399940945,
-0.0264117289,
0.0042064367,
0.0222422034,
-0.0012939132,
0.0490186624,
0.0003809828,
0.007158136,
0.0455104858,
-0.0039776401,
0.0455325879,
0.0000020093,
-0.0371635482,
0.0290899593,
-0.0190742817,
0.0052416013,
0.0072613312,
0.0465304293,
0.0225199051,
0.0095403157,
0.0113473106,
-0.0339014605,
0.0164353363,
0.0146899614,
0.0120278625,
0.0528827831,
0.0495528281,
0.0039596814,
-0.0126406029,
0.0137320282,
-0.0407190509,
-0.0099322628,
-0.0442380533,
0.0389678627,
-0.0041267308,
-0.0520015955,
0.0177832916,
-0.0297029056,
0.0014288042,
0.0275186822,
0.0225012135,
-0.0170532372,
0.0057762377,
0.0040445668,
-0.0086576743,
0.0044909292,
0.0672489628,
0.0380790718,
-0.0217495244,
0.0011773127,
-0.0469775461,
0.0226785969,
0.0445978977,
-0.0475172997,
0.0310869478,
-0.0139643168,
0.0117641315,
0.0695442483,
0.0071208817,
0.0260590818,
0.0439137332,
0.004662307,
0.0811954886,
-0.0029689625,
-0.0303939357,
-0.0139492154,
0.026537355,
0.0381971858,
-0.0640217885,
-0.0268300902,
-0.0185205285,
-0.0280578844,
0.0476839133,
-0.0097245453,
0.0226599295,
0.0242278222,
-0.0675901845,
-0.0126209129,
0.0115664415,
0.0028627687,
0.0419236384,
0.051312644,
0.0158410948,
-0.0411822423,
0.0183965005,
0.0068266671,
0.0108597316,
-0.0232273042,
-0.0020970323,
0.0189250112,
-0.0230484102,
-0.0358761437,
0.0199974887,
0.001058537,
-0.0153647112,
-0.0684815273,
-0.0111247664,
0.0094593447,
0.0229050033,
-0.0067869327,
-0.0233976133,
-0.0567706749,
0.0446201079,
-0.0558923669,
0.0612853728,
-0.0197107904,
-0.0479622036,
-0.016257681,
0.0451576859,
-0.0287740864,
-0.063013114,
-0.0196228977,
0.035823945,
0.0389596224,
-0.002901518,
0.0061813071,
-0.0125062987,
-0.0301297605,
-0.078748256,
-0.0259145331,
-0.0591561832,
0.0178404599,
0.0121080456,
0.0005352542,
-0.0809147432,
-0.0010080704,
0.0163005963,
-0.0860377699,
0.045083493,
0.0107568325,
0.0200789496,
0.024935117,
0.027256567,
-0.0250676218,
0.0774890259,
0.0182905477,
0.0255343672,
0.0149123147,
0.004615657,
0.005463697,
0.0113671403,
0.0040496672,
0.0257903654,
-0.0379804224,
0.0076207705,
-0.0385602079,
-0.0171073005,
0.0368912593,
0.0380018465,
-0.003095896,
-0.0248943865,
0.0749785528,
0.0115475999,
-0.0286276285,
0.0074628424,
0.001080616,
-0.035393741,
0.0041653747,
0.0253019389,
-0.0546785295,
0.0004312153,
0.0085542938,
-0.066583313,
0.0169296078,
0.0487990975,
-0.027336644,
-0.0475318842,
0.0036032735,
-0.0102557465,
0.0366221219,
0.0165174548,
0.0255160406,
-0.0151412459,
-0.0115074851,
0.028529739,
0.0429795533,
-0.0243495815,
-0.0043226713,
-0.0450514816,
0.0220430456,
0.014519955,
0.0331090204,
-0.0127395624,
-0.0124056293,
0.0003520185,
0.0130403312,
0.0617190823,
0.0817565992,
-0.0347709507,
-0.0209198575,
-0.0286335945,
-0.0402704999,
-0.0331744477,
0.0471677147,
0.0567369387,
-0.0083686039,
-0.0047872546,
-0.0157583207,
-0.0008058156,
-0.0583653115,
0.0241525769,
0.0091885189,
-0.0046262634,
-0.0132103879,
-0.0041856812,
0.0604440346,
0.0303415246,
-0.0178452823,
-0.0128370496,
0.0113053201,
-0.0168359019,
0.0121830152,
0.0487884469,
-0.0463988259,
0.0422454476,
-0.0005726853,
-0.0303792339,
-0.0330380127,
0.0247025751,
-0.0228858497,
-0.0255665593,
0.0813934878,
0.0205941107,
-0.0003522402,
0.013174274,
0.0107369423,
-0.0443388894,
0.0063328049,
-0.0709297433,
0.0794477165,
0.0165841933,
0.0013858976,
0.0328915715,
0.011477679,
0.0458703749,
-0.0214297697,
0.001304829,
0.0195464101,
0.0214571618,
-0.0111585222,
0.0588965751,
-0.0659080073,
-0.0312794,
-0.0043315492,
-0.0720462278,
-0.0058056763,
-0.0433671363,
0.0330351144,
0.0253843032,
0.0131790787,
0.0073418394,
0.0112867337,
-0.0322596468,
-0.0597631223,
-0.0158527885,
0.0113899373,
0.0109115243,
-0.0086681638,
-0.0143587906,
-0.0513598546,
0.0113697601,
-0.0387112983,
0.0233480297,
0.0378339812,
0.0004992466,
-0.0420220718,
0.0217629336,
-0.0266821124,
0.0213449132,
-0.0369394235,
-0.0087915584,
0.0499337092,
0.0581025369,
0.0136170769,
0.0836224854,
0.0165088084,
0.0416817963,
0.0513755046,
0.0089130253,
-0.0918500274,
-0.0173171945,
-0.0195747726,
0.0502767339,
-0.0560834259,
-0.0570593476,
-0.0004977331,
0.1084439829,
0.0281893853,
0.0100251818,
-0.0504076704,
0.0630873218,
-0.0269514434,
-0.0516314842,
0.0313625559,
-0.0566567369,
-0.0401070118,
0.0408357717,
-0.0352240838,
-0.0468289144,
0.0497073866,
-0.0073307455,
0.0446672328,
-0.0375454985,
0.0206072386,
-0.0323300585,
0.0563241765,
0.0228319112,
0.0083586471,
0.01221924,
-0.0076583824,
-0.0751650929,
-0.0663549751,
0.0625501722,
-0.0271357968,
0.0304670352,
-0.0499367341,
0.0089134555,
-0.0180927236,
-0.037844684,
-0.049190823,
-0.0341840759,
-0.0309588872,
0.0080978666,
0.0262099802,
-0.0093552368,
0.0016966335,
-0.0002983657,
0.0134660574,
-0.0376020782,
0.0006834511,
0.0138084423,
0.0033219138,
0.0280675814,
0.0222116299,
-0.0146073587,
0.0367241278,
0.0093537727,
0.0071844314,
0.0406155139,
0.0061945077,
0.0440590866,
-0.0256839376,
-0.0479826517,
0.0135416212,
-0.030351324,
-0.0202136468,
-0.0018027691,
0.0615729094,
-0.0291953292,
0.0222791154,
0.086599052,
0.0316058062,
-0.075959526,
0.0117877638,
-0.0023026699,
0.0038874941,
0.0421634503,
-0.0204150695,
-0.0757714957,
0.0039785351,
0.0268748458,
-0.0038198431,
-0.0568731911,
-0.0191507433,
-0.0061123888,
-0.1225115135,
0.0120816585,
0.0038849323,
0.0193361491,
-0.0086011281,
-0.048273176,
0.028022103,
-0.0564312898,
0.0159747712,
-0.0046238345,
0.0459681898,
0.0036012423,
0.0125345616,
-0.0455119051,
-0.0321669206,
0.0071379584,
-0.0320257545,
0.0934131667,
0.036618676,
0.0649242401,
-0.0241454169,
0.0163392276,
0.049176693,
-0.0092034871,
-0.0315047689,
-0.0145405689,
0.0454662666,
-0.0120170396,
0.0037328021,
-0.0181214754,
0.0324815251,
0.0233232714,
-0.0299969595,
0.0038276836,
0.0571578518,
-0.0291299727,
-0.0108161056,
-0.015310796,
-0.0123711322,
0.0420683175,
0.0723249763,
0.0241989102,
-0.0281956811,
-0.0394454189,
-0.0551026091,
-0.0107525531,
-0.0170708802,
-0.0657444,
0.0045548854,
0.0157469846,
-0.0011552324,
-0.0221941434,
-0.0703204274,
-0.0252860319,
-0.0087299338,
0.0102396812,
0.0118210409,
0.0016872676,
-0.0275005158,
0.0153895197,
0.0371200442,
-0.0172143262,
0.0188050773,
0.0353813581,
-0.0355745964,
-0.0385054499,
-0.0164574943,
-0.0139301745,
0.0099536693,
-0.0222626869,
-0.0773451179,
0.029776318,
0.0337554254,
0.0297344979,
0.0687137395,
-0.0295399446,
-0.0386209972,
-0.0159796681,
0.0229691584,
-0.01444792,
-0.0039673168,
0.0363368988,
-0.0304528084,
0.0143279042,
0.0308743343,
-0.0036261547,
0.0391321704,
0.0573568605,
0.0171918049,
-0.0734471083,
-0.0493008457,
0.0367465727,
-0.0225677919,
0.0689036846,
-0.0134820351,
-0.0431754142,
-0.065601632,
-0.0256858151,
-0.0567042157,
-0.0458720997,
0.0019755941,
-0.0052923793,
0.0250800587,
0.019323092,
-0.0234019104,
-0.0152951246,
-0.0435231254,
0.023330966,
-0.0118135149,
0.0500984229,
-0.0067133075,
0.0513587259,
0.0119130081,
-0.0237109456,
-0.0022300254,
0.0266762469,
-0.0104354778,
0.0392042845,
0.0127742682,
0.0446148217,
0.0322970785,
-0.009221253,
0.0113060307,
-0.0232210662,
-0.0558652841,
-0.0214178264,
0.0173592195,
-0.0005036998,
0.045069091,
-0.0265047923,
0.0528324544,
-0.000677263,
0.0011353124,
0.0049380283,
-0.0005862071,
0.0233479422,
0.0001644555,
0.0467788503,
0.0140389437,
-0.0530299768,
0.0367372371,
0.0787237287,
0.0189117994,
0.0494574271,
-0.0200184174,
-0.021467302,
0.0012182785,
-0.0984410346,
0.0116172396,
-0.0144102853,
-0.0703745782,
-0.0304252971,
-0.0961773917,
-0.0637424588,
-0.031022504,
0.0113598527,
0.0319661088,
-0.0134484377,
-0.0139250429,
0.0686167032,
-0.0062773875,
0.0078252517,
-0.0346914269,
-0.0020850361,
-0.0572920665,
-0.0285873618,
-0.0076677492,
-6.518276336e-33,
-0.0042599994,
-0.0329614691,
0.0047141495,
0.0083455453,
-0.0142647726,
0.0017266845,
-0.0258448143,
0.0403513983,
-0.0398664251,
0.0390964113,
0.0168070979,
0.0276829414,
0.0184351709,
-0.0223315675,
0.0212061889,
-0.0254701264,
0.0050785718,
0.0042051766,
-0.0351780131,
0.0265927278,
0.0025985281,
-0.0261379164,
0.0015576408,
-0.0884962082,
0.0737521574,
0.0074125202,
-0.0178258345,
-0.0063805846,
-0.045360256,
0.0477108769,
-0.0028827405,
0.0523370169,
0.051263772,
-0.0409680307,
0.0137576312,
0.0477331467,
-0.0202556811,
-0.0246434025,
0.0742162466,
-0.0058198064,
-0.0285621155,
-0.0417736806,
0.0176329538,
0.0214429982,
-0.0631521046,
0.0195366237,
0.046589151,
-0.032522846,
0.0320747606,
0.0264857467,
-0.0642308146,
0.0316274837,
-0.0295984074,
0.0140046012,
-0.039914269,
0.0209796224,
0.0332752988,
0.062626861,
-0.0538369268,
0.0273642875,
-0.0584156066,
0.0018130721,
0.0429210328,
0.0170707647,
0.0083548818,
0.0792239457,
0.0329458341,
0.040438503,
-0.0528800637,
-0.0464491546,
0.0186736323,
0.0187642965,
0.0603360794,
0.0615795739,
0.0174259823,
-0.0239377487,
-0.1094626039,
-0.0266896524,
0.0692608878,
0.0578368641,
0.0164855532,
0.0050527127,
-0.0341982543,
-0.0427458771,
-0.0412864909,
-0.0737339482,
-0.0235457439,
-0.0333192982,
-0.0000100889,
0.0309923366,
0.0020937494,
0.000765529,
0.0375372693,
-0.0733243674,
0.020845551,
0.0514830351,
-0.0126137175,
-0.0240406711,
0.0077187014,
0.0093299653,
-0.0678453967,
-0.0073401975,
-0.0332995728,
0.0476445593,
0.041269213,
-0.0083227633,
0.0176103227,
-0.0249206796,
-0.0239258856,
-0.0177206341,
-0.0477153994,
-0.0133482562,
-0.0135017345,
0.0371252634,
0.0548696071,
0.0251703393,
0.0012578326,
0.0222051572,
0.0383999646,
0.0005872751,
-0.0383212902,
-0.0273157097,
-0.0383931994,
0.0032545109,
-0.0522721447,
-0.0480048731,
-0.0258668214,
0.0241396837,
0.0325962082,
-0.0398136005,
-0.0396465696,
-0.0433288328,
2.666e-7,
0.0365456231,
0.0719803795,
-0.0222796928,
0.0284678303,
0.0336820073,
0.0401200876,
-0.0031926613,
0.0337271616,
-0.011154321,
-0.0287037585,
-0.0037289157,
0.0253976267,
0.0467727073,
0.0271571074,
-0.0636242032,
-0.0082524912,
-0.0680385008,
0.0007059627,
-0.0309084766,
0.0096096294,
0.0111357886,
0.0255879126,
0.0330117941,
0.0121823028,
-0.0295534804,
-0.0001045556,
0.0629912838,
-0.030745903,
-0.0250036009,
0.0467185304,
0.0186253209,
-0.0455221906,
0.0002324592,
0.0438574739,
0.0194800925,
0.0294152796,
-0.0294214785,
0.0682411641,
-0.0112850796,
-0.0255140439,
-0.0551874451,
-0.0159569774,
0.019638788,
-0.056648802,
0.0626962706,
-0.0326443575,
-0.0679925978,
-0.0481193066,
-0.0222654305,
0.0215143394,
0.0365559608,
0.0419433825,
-0.0200996324,
-0.0179801881,
-0.0125395246,
0.0216962155,
0.002327713,
-0.0656554922,
-0.0623257346,
-0.0232968982,
-0.0406568907,
-0.073498942,
0.0214176066,
0.0024269014,
0.0231617596,
-0.0271806847,
0.0267142653,
2.221344302e-34,
0.0162416846,
0.0001191412,
0.0247815475,
-0.0289361905,
0.0354571417,
0.0158460252,
-0.0247333441,
0.0074240547,
0.0373615362,
-0.0620310009,
-0.001434313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08598v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08598v2 | DALA: A Distribution-Aware LoRA-Based Adversarial Attack against Language Models | 2023-11-14T23:43:47 | 2024-02-17T19:14:20 | Yibo Wang, Xiangjue Dong, James Caverlee, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) can be manipulated by adversarial attacks, which
introduce subtle perturbations to input data. While recent attack methods can
achieve a relatively high attack success rate (ASR), we've observed that the
generated adversarial examples have a different data distribution compared with
the original examples. Specifically, these adversarial examples exhibit reduced
confidence levels and greater divergence from the training data distribution.
Consequently, they are easy to detect using straightforward detection methods,
diminishing the efficacy of such attacks. To address this issue, we propose a
Distribution-Aware LoRA-based Adversarial Attack (DALA) method. DALA considers
distribution shifts of adversarial examples to improve the attack's
effectiveness under detection methods. We further design a novel evaluation
metric, the Non-detectable Attack Success Rate (NASR), which integrates both
ASR and detectability for the attack task. We conduct experiments on four
widely used datasets to validate the attack effectiveness and transferability
of adversarial examples generated by DALA against both the white-box BERT-base
model and the black-box LLaMA2-7b model. Our codes are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DALA-A16D/. | [
0.0143052842,
0.0838350728,
-0.0305803008,
0.0780211613,
-0.0219704397,
-0.0095729511,
-0.0121150389,
0.0026981973,
-0.0210535415,
-0.0359114595,
-0.0492534824,
-0.0151221855,
0.0371778235,
0.0171346851,
0.0831803232,
-0.0084902653,
0.0076044332,
-0.0076240515,
-0.0151899671,
-0.0280711874,
-0.017790122,
-0.0299779736,
0.0230732542,
0.0266951136,
0.044049073,
-0.0126283094,
0.013389417,
0.020397421,
0.0385375246,
-0.0230827983,
0.0393622294,
0.0365979597,
0.0044753826,
0.0660242289,
0.0000020253,
0.0050587221,
-0.0222834256,
0.0162512977,
-0.0210130829,
0.0466028452,
0.0383969918,
-0.0291842036,
-0.0296790395,
0.0234334692,
-0.0366803594,
-0.0261924062,
-0.0003186648,
0.0180419348,
0.0293461941,
0.1050288677,
-0.0044498937,
-0.0357142873,
0.0650593415,
-0.0566707626,
-0.0355078839,
-0.0277436376,
0.0375766568,
-0.0130949831,
-0.0333865024,
-0.019234119,
-0.0321696885,
0.0211960394,
0.0153956236,
-0.0052359719,
-0.0578173548,
0.0116069056,
-0.0368059948,
0.0064696209,
0.0194381643,
0.0779025182,
-0.0526223294,
-0.0182436761,
-0.0045312708,
0.0039395853,
0.0158948116,
0.02449435,
-0.0202023331,
-0.0205695797,
0.0311048236,
0.0185781438,
-0.0205803718,
-0.032933075,
0.061978709,
-0.0026649218,
-0.0238023773,
0.031026328,
0.0508822873,
-0.0188444648,
-0.0219401382,
-0.0489799343,
-0.0321233943,
-0.0367720351,
0.0231002644,
0.0171419159,
0.0351321809,
0.0066136559,
-0.0827028751,
-0.0325710252,
0.0571540967,
-0.0481701046,
0.0960947275,
0.0011401122,
-0.0416872464,
0.0070359581,
-0.0304695833,
0.0605219603,
-0.0546493493,
0.0525448881,
0.0019569579,
0.034664847,
0.0035973387,
0.0042156205,
0.0512550808,
-0.0228143223,
-0.0101350509,
-0.0029125842,
-0.0451730751,
0.0303044692,
-0.0080868118,
0.0181565043,
-0.0368827283,
0.0041121887,
0.0058310186,
0.0229351297,
0.0140691036,
-0.0051207342,
0.0213817749,
0.0200330652,
-0.0208713301,
-0.0873182267,
-0.0594002455,
0.0423804969,
-0.0373407826,
-0.0318967067,
0.0117964204,
0.0996177271,
0.0273317229,
-0.058552023,
-0.040985737,
0.0020179201,
-0.0245958809,
-0.0535929389,
0.0238378756,
-0.0596554652,
-0.0424855873,
-0.0341364145,
-0.0163948294,
-0.0439243913,
0.0012345659,
0.0261828601,
-0.0143817747,
0.0756816566,
0.0278168339,
-0.0326113999,
0.0582240261,
0.0157966409,
0.0242304858,
0.0771691799,
0.0239763781,
0.0169414543,
0.0159174427,
0.0163710732,
0.0257342756,
0.0459110327,
0.0438172109,
0.0647340268,
-0.0437678881,
0.0031250205,
-0.0311588608,
-0.020598121,
0.0421526395,
0.0204318855,
-0.007135029,
-0.0785673782,
0.0963687152,
0.0221191049,
-0.0159019828,
0.005839,
-0.0029556616,
-0.036137253,
0.0015074075,
0.0131362053,
-0.0559292808,
-0.0190783851,
-0.0761019513,
-0.0190182924,
0.0135304304,
0.0253042821,
-0.0165219177,
-0.0308886357,
-0.0236568749,
-0.0134512605,
-0.006875359,
-0.007674248,
0.0165534075,
0.0366609953,
-0.0114698298,
0.0655992553,
0.0116267921,
0.003170792,
0.0098991105,
-0.073798053,
0.0270419586,
-0.0269558281,
0.0551811345,
-0.0558840893,
0.0075815571,
-0.0200889353,
-0.0011187606,
0.0295575429,
-0.0120555321,
0.0129639348,
-0.0106647862,
-0.0175112858,
-0.0181501247,
-0.0599868856,
0.041084677,
0.0290972702,
0.011450842,
0.0501136407,
-0.0049388674,
-0.0895223469,
-0.0009250931,
0.0419787876,
0.0187842716,
-0.020319324,
0.0158183929,
0.0292776674,
0.0340999961,
-0.0139540341,
-0.0386933908,
0.0215758942,
0.0517913885,
-0.0235378351,
-0.0170262344,
-0.0241364297,
0.0372669213,
-0.050308343,
0.0335160978,
-0.0151474513,
0.0154686589,
0.0751462281,
-0.0440492146,
0.0305775777,
0.0663845539,
-0.046845939,
0.0145410644,
0.0067714257,
0.0097571099,
-0.0067710401,
0.0849826038,
-0.0325058438,
0.0395952612,
-0.0594840609,
0.0049158046,
-0.0191236697,
0.0534639545,
0.048202727,
-0.051783029,
-0.019670032,
0.0257321242,
-0.0258088745,
-0.0067433594,
-0.000689732,
-0.0143844709,
0.0017833534,
-0.0330676511,
0.022564603,
-0.0162195731,
-0.038633626,
0.0464047566,
0.0356521197,
-0.0385259092,
-0.0413140245,
-0.0069361995,
-0.0073598567,
-0.007235507,
-0.0153031414,
0.0243683346,
0.0324194804,
-0.0065392735,
-0.0709674731,
-0.0505684614,
-0.0060542701,
-0.0138658648,
0.1076886654,
-0.0199614838,
0.0079240138,
-0.0413510092,
0.0071625826,
-0.0232773125,
0.0513608679,
-0.0349634998,
-0.0742447674,
0.0199946668,
0.0232999939,
0.010922458,
0.0918454155,
0.0158440713,
0.0273945276,
0.061187245,
0.0362754203,
-0.0205669701,
-0.0395321101,
0.0079112379,
-0.0359660573,
-0.0560780205,
-0.0436902195,
0.0070542614,
0.03039933,
0.0535756238,
-0.0210592467,
0.0221333429,
0.0322897993,
-0.0084928861,
-0.023461625,
0.0113523398,
0.0137485201,
-0.0317873135,
-0.0195436534,
-0.0265955608,
-0.053085085,
0.0564712882,
-0.0657723919,
0.0329494216,
-0.0117893815,
-0.0587277077,
0.0002097337,
0.0151114576,
0.001014673,
-0.0006961446,
-0.0170660391,
-0.0364092179,
-0.0111306161,
-0.0389294848,
0.0300402101,
-0.0245079901,
0.0309699383,
-0.0368784964,
-0.0090948027,
-0.0103565138,
-0.0043141763,
-0.0538750254,
-0.0625450611,
0.0364491865,
0.0285097435,
-0.0013014871,
-0.0425902158,
-0.0482487492,
-0.0414106622,
0.009592819,
0.0229804628,
-0.014897041,
0.0191304311,
-0.0258472059,
0.0745615214,
0.063586317,
-0.033211235,
0.0238892566,
-0.0339161456,
-0.0131510282,
0.0376088545,
-0.0029932116,
0.0565249883,
-0.046008911,
0.0218614973,
0.0085794609,
0.0193494447,
0.0201105066,
-0.0050820876,
0.0339653045,
-0.0120431818,
-0.0198014006,
0.0490620248,
-0.0231612995,
0.0071795145,
0.0158688668,
-0.0218975525,
0.0460309386,
0.0232761018,
-0.0057021235,
-0.0856577903,
0.0022108913,
0.0061539612,
0.025420947,
-0.0147490231,
-0.0127841635,
-0.0085635064,
-0.0854343176,
-0.0019755648,
-0.0115045281,
-0.0349983014,
-0.0464419164,
-0.045984257,
0.005273011,
-0.0138033442,
0.0471533649,
-0.0350086764,
0.0157794785,
-0.0088766413,
0.0187721513,
0.001983227,
-0.0706162751,
0.0057668164,
-0.0207897499,
0.0143783595,
0.0860162303,
0.0616977513,
-0.0412946083,
-0.0240607467,
0.011182121,
0.0007100963,
-0.0386021473,
0.0338130519,
0.0584037974,
0.0083616041,
-0.0326237231,
0.0401034653,
0.0355832838,
-0.0210054163,
0.0193361286,
0.0109086111,
0.0179898981,
0.0029884682,
-0.0322353989,
-0.0062158704,
-0.0081391642,
0.0334395953,
0.0414894708,
0.0495180152,
-0.0084670633,
-0.003486288,
-0.0496471748,
-0.0052477946,
0.0172970183,
-0.0190906618,
0.0380192287,
0.0059198872,
-0.0503027476,
-0.0628755167,
0.002835097,
-0.0391158462,
0.0114158737,
0.0125393057,
0.0117464857,
-0.0595853701,
-0.009898603,
-0.0362554863,
-0.0075312015,
-0.0132754073,
0.0307469703,
-0.0522048734,
-0.008212205,
0.0132209007,
-0.0001868782,
-0.0481397994,
0.0030966159,
-0.0927940086,
-0.0899609625,
-0.0039417571,
0.0543323122,
0.0131330648,
-0.0038684092,
-0.0113551077,
-0.0671093762,
0.1120863929,
0.055686567,
0.0302613918,
0.0518305376,
0.0622410327,
-0.0678375512,
0.0253137704,
0.0605604239,
-0.0440121032,
0.0022921388,
0.0694698766,
-0.0066555822,
-0.0445370078,
-0.012362536,
-0.0111154094,
-0.0010390426,
0.0673659816,
-0.0159521718,
-0.0498516746,
0.0199019238,
0.0432661846,
-0.0111119784,
-0.0084280996,
-0.0012401803,
-0.026988782,
0.0191445481,
-0.004508222,
-0.0038420025,
-0.0003937261,
-0.0248796884,
0.0143144261,
-0.0347126834,
0.0529695638,
0.0850529149,
0.049837403,
0.0345760807,
0.0300137419,
-0.0120596951,
0.0123761324,
-0.009612062,
0.032748159,
0.0137337567,
0.0233329162,
-0.0144874882,
-0.0149884466,
0.0031622264,
0.0276835766,
-0.0409711152,
-0.0100387726,
-0.018444797,
0.0375717543,
0.0412267894,
0.0110969376,
0.023521129,
0.0098471558,
-0.0177945774,
-0.0261433367,
-0.0065113269,
-0.0182859115,
-0.0132207377,
0.0481038131,
0.0007213345,
0.0028550245,
0.0481631123,
0.0714291558,
0.0491168424,
0.0748384967,
-0.0190772116,
-0.0078128083,
-0.0197347309,
-0.0146324504,
0.0630033612,
-0.039776437,
-0.0129241254,
-0.0202514566,
-0.005051434,
-0.1114293709,
0.0003378054,
0.0229858272,
0.020249838,
0.0268887915,
-0.0363566093,
0.0612856522,
-0.0125469454,
0.0379085615,
-0.0488180034,
0.0261995848,
0.0159377363,
-0.0455166698,
-0.0021112473,
-6.35975725e-33,
-0.0086770719,
-0.0320559852,
-0.0322722718,
-0.0391187631,
0.0466232523,
0.0114495913,
-0.0430658385,
-0.0174750276,
-0.0487356186,
0.0180552881,
0.0175402891,
0.0115070073,
-0.0202584062,
0.0040540453,
-0.0497886166,
-0.0521149822,
0.0051063998,
0.0176730882,
-0.031331405,
-0.024138853,
0.0438993424,
0.0287099574,
0.0551847219,
-0.0167641938,
0.0213628393,
-0.0080013731,
-0.0361220688,
-0.0000944618,
-0.0542384349,
0.0557392016,
-0.0198354386,
0.0283463504,
-0.0241061598,
0.011680224,
0.0009906851,
0.0066348813,
0.0184248462,
-0.0074551022,
-0.001579583,
0.0217285529,
0.0195293222,
-0.0229394138,
0.0624138638,
-0.0098285573,
-0.0097656818,
0.0143267764,
0.0212075077,
-0.0364988074,
-0.0128623461,
0.0209748447,
-0.0289450455,
0.0217794795,
-0.0136180082,
-0.0162602253,
-0.0095509775,
-0.0353106856,
0.0610809773,
0.0150410291,
-0.0665475428,
0.0012401881,
0.0367995165,
0.0236808863,
0.0595276095,
-0.0070670918,
-0.0031390283,
0.0699756518,
0.0211925805,
-0.0236192588,
0.0219332166,
-0.0373309962,
0.0182429496,
0.01593633,
0.0269371849,
0.0737809986,
0.03017045,
-0.0145173501,
-0.1118053868,
0.0068147699,
0.0071858685,
-0.0003720404,
0.0305164549,
0.0305948202,
-0.059804488,
0.021510914,
-0.0111539271,
-0.0835602805,
-0.0323356315,
-0.0232978184,
0.0031839884,
0.0063620969,
-0.0156944916,
-0.0177787282,
-0.0199086294,
-0.0403874367,
-0.0139435288,
0.0251227207,
-0.0387983955,
-0.0231952686,
0.0033219454,
0.0100879539,
0.0075695044,
0.0005768003,
0.0133855194,
-0.0481530726,
0.0298612285,
0.0043018032,
0.0404000357,
0.0346162021,
-0.0589853823,
-0.0105023943,
-0.0259539671,
0.0123838931,
0.0240436289,
0.0423540026,
0.0208223015,
-0.0273446683,
-0.0197890494,
0.0108344117,
0.0328597613,
0.0256573744,
-0.0057219416,
0.0587603487,
-0.0293084178,
0.0324576274,
-0.0463017821,
-0.043240793,
-0.0020822315,
0.0558458082,
0.0421681553,
-0.097962372,
0.0192804933,
-0.063985765,
2.813e-7,
0.0293312483,
0.0204073749,
-0.0117999753,
-0.0013597364,
0.0115510831,
0.0320046991,
-0.0391380377,
0.0778258368,
0.004179487,
-0.0415570252,
-0.0535463244,
-0.0212249737,
0.0228371099,
0.0205603596,
-0.0605032109,
-0.0038267314,
-0.0864098296,
-0.0203192271,
-0.0330937654,
-0.0397386365,
-0.0018884388,
0.1238278076,
0.0497993082,
-0.0233511869,
-0.007402089,
-0.0507924408,
0.0340216681,
0.0071837394,
-0.0065118256,
-0.0010591154,
0.0279375091,
-0.0100012524,
0.0289607346,
0.0140992161,
-0.0351420902,
0.006897409,
-0.0115991756,
0.0197015181,
0.0046904786,
-0.0144152241,
-0.0416420251,
-0.0069222962,
-0.0101760412,
-0.0339833014,
0.0679539517,
0.0057357289,
-0.0404668264,
-0.0055934587,
-0.0332147144,
-0.0413129963,
0.0833754689,
-0.0582964681,
-0.0004262927,
-0.0028251878,
-0.0131108258,
-0.0035365617,
0.0361072011,
-0.0604270659,
0.0126307206,
0.0019836056,
-0.0376079306,
-0.0226863939,
-0.0171388853,
-0.0192605462,
0.0306598209,
0.0053555649,
0.0314047486,
2.562980383e-34,
0.0106452014,
0.0054824385,
-0.0066503542,
-0.0008879297,
0.045829393,
0.0036915718,
0.0368582532,
-0.0251154378,
0.0066031078,
-0.0393732153,
-0.0080548264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08596v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08596v2 | Are You Sure? Challenging LLMs Leads to Performance Drops in The FlipFlop Experiment | 2023-11-14T23:40:22 | 2024-02-21T18:15:47 | Philippe Laban, Lidiya Murakhovs'ka, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The interactive nature of Large Language Models (LLMs) theoretically allows
models to refine and improve their answers, yet systematic analysis of the
multi-turn behavior of LLMs remains limited. In this paper, we propose the
FlipFlop experiment: in the first round of the conversation, an LLM completes a
classification task. In a second round, the LLM is challenged with a follow-up
phrase like "Are you sure?", offering an opportunity for the model to reflect
on its initial answer, and decide whether to confirm or flip its answer. A
systematic study of ten LLMs on seven classification tasks reveals that models
flip their answers on average 46% of the time and that all models see a
deterioration of accuracy between their first and final prediction, with an
average drop of 17% (the FlipFlop effect). We conduct finetuning experiments on
an open-source LLM and find that finetuning on synthetically created data can
mitigate - reducing performance deterioration by 60% - but not resolve
sycophantic behavior entirely. The FlipFlop experiment illustrates the
universality of sycophantic behavior in LLMs and provides a robust framework to
analyze model behavior and evaluate future models. | [
0.0613891594,
0.0296992026,
-0.0368746184,
0.0580830202,
-0.0647526234,
0.0194416679,
0.0133126266,
0.0006140304,
-0.0052747801,
-0.0768446103,
-0.0423692577,
-0.0417565964,
0.0154289948,
0.0271798335,
0.0306878611,
-0.0210721102,
0.0835835934,
-0.0585542545,
0.0034296142,
-0.0440844335,
-0.0275633968,
-0.0229243543,
-0.0345083401,
0.0113264788,
0.0367557704,
-0.0091563398,
-0.0224324539,
0.0021496422,
-0.0294249151,
-0.0004993324,
0.0094154067,
0.0758341476,
-0.0247720461,
0.0874294117,
0.0000018462,
-0.0580543652,
0.0163220558,
-0.0027965601,
-0.0546004698,
0.0477573536,
0.0446223505,
0.0246147476,
-0.0164283626,
0.0380583927,
-0.0445751883,
0.0036540183,
0.0228548311,
0.0189083945,
0.0258743335,
0.0409063622,
0.0147478571,
0.0029948102,
0.0247024614,
-0.0229582246,
-0.0019436311,
-0.0200277288,
0.0058025871,
-0.040616408,
-0.0274045505,
-0.0191129446,
-0.029668875,
0.0567790829,
0.0179205369,
0.0187490545,
-0.0379527025,
0.0509078465,
-0.05820309,
-0.0373565145,
-0.0098392991,
0.0439583585,
-0.040020328,
-0.0174724553,
-0.0272950009,
-0.0339157879,
0.0235558469,
0.0273485538,
-0.0414135419,
0.007681902,
0.0078540342,
0.0008962741,
0.0051699681,
-0.0203052126,
0.0461406261,
0.0021749146,
-0.0493059531,
0.0781985372,
0.0044128573,
-0.0431337841,
0.0248179641,
0.0294482242,
0.0096056042,
-0.0593569912,
-0.0208128933,
0.0149725247,
-0.0466007181,
0.0154155046,
-0.0013992634,
0.000970321,
0.0462913103,
-0.0585734174,
0.0324297138,
0.0215239935,
-0.0285566691,
0.0287290607,
-0.0237247851,
0.0330191143,
-0.0252023395,
0.0451947488,
-0.0123817865,
0.0073846062,
-0.013858458,
-0.0184743702,
0.0071994248,
0.0149613405,
-0.0080394763,
-0.0076957131,
-0.0356432945,
0.0343457386,
-0.0038922434,
0.034003716,
-0.0130485306,
0.0146552343,
0.0305015258,
0.0030119871,
-0.0439649634,
0.0392817855,
-0.0032436731,
0.0274831168,
-0.0157368612,
-0.0743124485,
-0.0132161127,
0.004834367,
-0.0145032723,
-0.0135717457,
0.0251185484,
0.0540106073,
-0.0296049956,
-0.0330689251,
-0.0245576873,
-0.0149679668,
-0.0402954519,
-0.0829756558,
0.0006368961,
-0.0425535366,
0.0108619286,
0.0428159982,
-0.0060449969,
0.0059060762,
0.0166516751,
-0.011312888,
-0.0410309993,
0.0824193433,
-0.0074639074,
0.0187992211,
0.0302257296,
0.0081524858,
-0.0042348295,
0.0816794783,
0.0503796339,
-0.0019749634,
0.0482441597,
-0.034091372,
0.0555834956,
0.0618365481,
0.027048653,
0.0067146253,
-0.0230026934,
0.0148401763,
0.0079575526,
0.0394197218,
0.0077210455,
0.0783362538,
-0.0138707049,
-0.0479315706,
0.078254208,
0.0331535637,
-0.0279191863,
0.0145138614,
-0.0095358305,
-0.0256673656,
-0.0091666449,
0.0517422967,
-0.083022736,
0.0212133471,
-0.040383216,
0.009104318,
0.0148041165,
-0.0074732983,
-0.037867561,
-0.0352046676,
-0.026342541,
-0.001778399,
0.0434953906,
0.0652827695,
0.0395537019,
-0.0033265476,
-0.0087711764,
0.047018975,
0.011059273,
-0.0429986827,
-0.0166523047,
-0.1098752841,
0.0244142078,
0.0624626875,
0.0451885089,
-0.0019412636,
-0.0315864757,
-0.0106094172,
-0.0147392107,
0.0553690977,
0.088281095,
-0.0065721259,
0.0064539514,
-0.0172030907,
0.0101528354,
0.0075724213,
0.0166932922,
-0.0107497759,
0.0228175744,
0.0060586487,
-0.0034793669,
-0.0033482076,
-0.0157686714,
0.0264855418,
-0.0455421358,
-0.0193051454,
-0.0034072793,
-0.0091658486,
0.0293750688,
-0.0302518569,
-0.003709418,
0.0249083992,
0.0314367004,
-0.001091338,
-0.0021971208,
-0.0041284468,
-0.0192305837,
-0.039332889,
0.0378819853,
0.032976117,
-0.0015386563,
0.032304056,
-0.0309739709,
-0.0407875553,
0.0203782711,
-0.0302919932,
0.0443993136,
-0.036290653,
0.0350207761,
-0.0499650091,
0.0315484554,
-0.0359917991,
-0.0089726392,
-0.0210710317,
0.0517448373,
-0.0038298101,
-0.0097225308,
-0.0024757353,
-0.0459874459,
-0.040790908,
0.0222606491,
0.0030106348,
-0.0018885172,
0.0048260191,
-0.0217602346,
-0.0474092998,
-0.0634917617,
-0.0853073224,
-0.0223680958,
-0.0065011773,
0.0165573154,
0.0115092415,
-0.023645144,
-0.0237121433,
-0.0211871751,
-0.0196489729,
0.0088555431,
0.0110661564,
0.0746862441,
0.0184732098,
-0.0005262059,
-0.036028415,
-0.0560103171,
-0.0259996057,
0.0129250055,
0.0542064868,
-0.0006579353,
0.0140215373,
-0.0679095834,
0.0122281248,
-0.0381757878,
0.022684956,
-0.0144178094,
-0.0184006635,
0.0240685847,
0.0061572338,
0.0106801782,
0.0788939446,
0.0284948125,
0.0059179398,
0.0678230524,
-0.0263422355,
-0.0616400875,
0.0040544393,
-0.0111458702,
-0.0566330068,
-0.0499969795,
-0.0636320487,
-0.0351517126,
0.0802969784,
0.0114866318,
-0.0170091204,
-0.0334348939,
-0.0026957642,
-0.0181025304,
-0.0518740863,
-0.022535814,
0.0114235682,
-0.0264094714,
0.0476726554,
0.0109649878,
-0.0640098974,
0.0884442031,
-0.0225725714,
-0.0254937038,
0.0016758757,
0.007159791,
-0.0026156262,
0.0768532529,
-0.0108408919,
-0.0250106379,
0.0222915038,
0.007407919,
-0.0829499215,
-0.0344461054,
-0.0075898836,
-0.0879570842,
0.0352911949,
-0.0507544577,
-0.0032580667,
-0.031463515,
-0.0535400622,
-0.0544010997,
-0.0608574487,
-0.0489193723,
0.0002828528,
0.0238961875,
-0.0266425516,
-0.011499879,
-0.0082083298,
0.0255611371,
0.0311526917,
-0.0460815318,
-0.0205187835,
-0.0083806431,
0.0096499696,
0.0700947642,
0.0265968889,
0.0655474141,
-0.034505289,
0.0164310373,
0.0565451235,
0.0323670059,
0.0449937396,
-0.0197353736,
-0.0185999069,
0.0491468646,
-0.0039539416,
-0.0544149764,
0.0188517384,
0.0227263104,
-0.0334217623,
-0.0342840888,
0.1125347093,
0.0457297117,
-0.0512661599,
-0.0010521029,
-0.036990229,
0.0448835865,
0.0426248051,
0.0248851068,
-0.0550725423,
-0.0244637355,
0.0106966803,
0.0238091759,
-0.0289337113,
-0.0158555247,
-0.0183608513,
-0.1059261635,
0.0294293631,
-0.014115667,
-0.0380603783,
0.01508311,
-0.0318990014,
0.0010241988,
-0.0219861176,
0.0585411154,
0.0221314467,
-0.0195894893,
0.0011313821,
0.0131261405,
-0.0264376011,
-0.0113413846,
0.0471536294,
-0.0033635874,
0.0567772314,
0.0448836312,
-0.0027551868,
-0.0139940456,
-0.0501238555,
0.051498834,
-0.0406736918,
0.0105016585,
-0.0195977055,
0.0571996085,
0.0149190277,
0.0151337655,
-0.0177678801,
-0.0074735717,
-0.0168270431,
-0.0067709899,
0.006030078,
0.0662936941,
-0.0225103404,
-0.061035458,
-0.0188811831,
0.0091001764,
0.0035065201,
0.0804632232,
0.0472820438,
-0.0747675821,
-0.0237896144,
-0.0214179736,
0.0103844749,
-0.0140683167,
-0.0343924649,
0.0000829287,
0.050220672,
0.0212719366,
-0.0583219193,
-0.0324229598,
0.000248811,
-0.00325593,
-0.0068530682,
0.0172475222,
0.0139633836,
-0.0080271475,
-0.0387048423,
-0.0058874893,
0.0012552461,
0.0593081191,
-0.0556524061,
0.0177335273,
0.0561421178,
-0.0031636774,
0.0003498494,
0.0065087648,
-0.0925107524,
-0.0861277878,
0.047764793,
0.0371128283,
0.0368367359,
0.017549742,
0.0113496436,
-0.0740311816,
0.025625959,
0.0344235525,
-0.0049512764,
0.0526640154,
0.0305314548,
0.0099366847,
-0.0111792851,
0.0398790278,
-0.0232546143,
-0.0236567631,
0.0491821617,
0.0046418319,
-0.0627439991,
-0.0715532154,
-0.0081468699,
0.0211827233,
0.0947491378,
-0.0325348191,
-0.0276951212,
0.0010533973,
0.054421667,
0.0198443029,
-0.0043573561,
-0.0194100179,
-0.0176062901,
0.0088136205,
-0.0351226814,
-0.0123298196,
0.0202570278,
-0.0267329887,
0.0170690026,
0.0017150722,
-0.0243072174,
0.0070342026,
-0.0168115795,
0.0285047647,
0.0148414038,
-0.0418606028,
0.0276410393,
0.0162718743,
0.0493097343,
0.0257744286,
0.0524454936,
0.021916328,
-0.0069375625,
-0.0317342058,
0.022337608,
-0.064931646,
-0.0595088713,
0.0213624667,
0.0462857708,
0.0141540868,
0.0342546031,
0.0345166512,
-0.0143039385,
0.0000196713,
-0.0236657485,
0.0014492352,
-0.007386867,
-0.0224457141,
0.0474297442,
0.0195641406,
-0.0344097726,
0.0051308195,
0.065405257,
-0.0023495217,
0.0500953682,
-0.0149181997,
0.0186080169,
-0.0144903157,
-0.0421086513,
-0.0024170412,
-0.0022884125,
-0.0290611554,
0.0149600636,
-0.0828739926,
-0.0698646978,
0.0128738517,
0.0306886975,
0.027830705,
-0.0590049475,
0.0087457579,
0.0759790093,
0.0058020689,
-0.0275893752,
-0.0428524092,
0.0189597774,
0.0390131995,
-0.0199217014,
-0.0360955074,
-6.838780749e-33,
-0.0189855043,
-0.0208552293,
0.0379286706,
0.0110614672,
-0.0001738768,
-0.0351714715,
-0.0101272995,
0.0612685755,
-0.0308971796,
-0.0047231116,
-0.0506845787,
0.0292294994,
0.022137288,
0.019131083,
0.036965929,
-0.0220019184,
0.0275258031,
-0.0124838725,
-0.0365912504,
-0.0035774247,
0.0348407403,
0.0080132624,
0.048823379,
-0.0365638435,
0.0270400643,
-0.015252389,
-0.0054206825,
0.0362537317,
-0.0927844271,
0.0137052732,
-0.0356285647,
0.0448000766,
0.0232057422,
-0.0249016248,
-0.0187995229,
0.0110184196,
0.0032428009,
-0.0269740485,
0.0287224036,
0.0377377719,
-0.0195929557,
0.0090981638,
0.0436831824,
-0.0007874732,
-0.0485638082,
-0.0003529996,
0.0005412974,
-0.0378648192,
-0.03978182,
0.0183804929,
-0.0327880643,
0.0185687989,
0.0185855795,
-0.0462384485,
0.0105045084,
0.0455492027,
-0.0059464448,
-0.0197885484,
-0.0461771004,
0.0249949936,
0.0342730843,
0.0420853533,
0.0729437992,
0.05331425,
-0.0131464396,
0.0329931155,
0.0704419091,
0.0449851565,
0.0009662191,
-0.0311619006,
0.0599156767,
0.0128533775,
0.0668386072,
0.0783869699,
0.0355275981,
-0.0219496582,
-0.0092244809,
0.0061691036,
0.0461552627,
-0.0166962426,
0.0486851856,
0.001239056,
-0.0212543774,
-0.0646698624,
-0.0648174584,
0.0109855589,
-0.0455807671,
0.0011625636,
0.008822415,
0.0165435039,
0.0199312232,
0.0041584093,
0.0453540757,
-0.0261057988,
-0.0370548517,
-0.0295713078,
0.0077236751,
0.0183783807,
0.0133808339,
0.0230780933,
-0.0427324474,
-0.0148609467,
-0.0161830205,
0.0164623037,
0.0098543363,
0.0183084421,
0.0397359654,
0.0319870599,
-0.0801014081,
0.0127010522,
-0.0133805647,
0.0262548309,
0.0157625619,
-0.0463831387,
0.0063180588,
0.0037249697,
-0.0160194598,
0.0229665395,
0.0067661665,
0.0108497506,
-0.0605526492,
0.0145859467,
-0.0098987818,
0.0466620699,
-0.0217349827,
-0.01577246,
-0.0282309484,
0.0371856019,
-0.0078047016,
-0.0514088944,
-0.0196693987,
0.0148302121,
2.698e-7,
0.0380415916,
0.0558998771,
-0.0327003412,
0.0237489827,
0.054121092,
0.0557527095,
-0.0339029878,
-0.0000716432,
0.0454561897,
-0.0084650759,
-0.0044098329,
0.0047722217,
0.0615721755,
0.0511869788,
-0.0427046753,
-0.0193047207,
-0.0808646008,
0.0534292832,
-0.0179066043,
0.0042216619,
0.0157530904,
0.0710605457,
0.0263180304,
-0.0097155692,
-0.0027519956,
-0.0114433644,
0.0635289922,
-0.0443970077,
0.0166414399,
0.0120022511,
0.0194552336,
-0.0191040225,
0.0228959471,
0.0480879173,
-0.0027802372,
-0.0082872696,
-0.0513081253,
0.0194114,
-0.0096918624,
-0.0465418212,
-0.0107386308,
-0.0235106368,
-0.005012359,
-0.1000628844,
0.0760142356,
-0.0618194863,
-0.0133472038,
-0.0423544422,
0.0131654739,
-0.0152968159,
0.069864966,
-0.0375213288,
-0.0102172354,
0.0289699472,
0.0026505277,
0.0055401744,
-0.0112585686,
-0.0820723325,
-0.0402080417,
0.0005401567,
-0.057630837,
-0.0712953284,
-0.0324163698,
-0.0046097566,
0.0316094719,
-0.0748947412,
0.0050836084,
2.330058015e-34,
0.0513869524,
0.0307504628,
0.0131272534,
0.0388625339,
0.0052667349,
-0.0163365584,
0.011743919,
0.0223535802,
0.026474474,
-0.0452620871,
-0.0163194966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08593v1 | ACID: Abstractive, Content-Based IDs for Document Retrieval with Language Models | 2023-11-14T23:28:36 | 2023-11-14T23:28:36 | Haoxin Li, Phillip Keung, Daniel Cheng, Jungo Kasai, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Generative retrieval (Wang et al., 2022; Tay et al., 2022) is a new approach
for end-to-end document retrieval that directly generates document identifiers
given an input query. Techniques for designing effective, high-quality document
IDs remain largely unexplored. We introduce ACID, in which each document's ID
is composed of abstractive keyphrases generated by a large language model,
rather than an integer ID sequence as done in past work. We compare our method
with the current state-of-the-art technique for ID generation, which produces
IDs through hierarchical clustering of document embeddings. We also examine
simpler methods to generate natural-language document IDs, including the naive
approach of using the first k words of each document as its ID or words with
high BM25 scores in that document. We show that using ACID improves top-10 and
top-20 accuracy by 15.6% and 14.4% (relative) respectively versus the
state-of-the-art baseline on the MSMARCO 100k retrieval task, and 4.4% and 4.0%
respectively on the Natural Questions 100k retrieval task. Our results
demonstrate the effectiveness of human-readable, natural-language IDs in
generative retrieval with LMs. The code for reproducing our results and the
keyword-augmented datasets will be released on formal publication. | [
0.0359321423,
0.0378249511,
-0.015166237,
-0.0016248666,
-0.0204863939,
-0.0107253408,
0.0274607595,
0.042044811,
0.0762898251,
-0.0440254062,
-0.0249451045,
-0.0111733004,
-0.0678001493,
0.0460274778,
0.0532670282,
-0.0334496796,
0.0366834886,
-0.0079704411,
0.0284227021,
0.0168995727,
-0.0235303491,
0.0240001623,
0.0385160297,
-0.0060451943,
-0.0042953286,
-0.0293643679,
-0.0040029846,
0.0089090057,
0.0033718606,
-0.012121737,
0.0230979118,
0.0577048324,
0.0356096774,
0.0775858983,
0.000001813,
-0.0343224742,
-0.0324889943,
-0.0075716227,
-0.025301462,
0.0056876796,
0.0994498059,
0.0106099509,
0.0150030395,
-0.0037204304,
0.0075625693,
-0.0296342932,
0.0029580016,
0.0476197638,
0.0186704509,
0.0623292513,
-0.0155769568,
-0.0608809032,
0.0729968548,
-0.0100713139,
0.0553125888,
-0.0302816723,
0.0000529331,
0.0202316679,
0.0085382238,
0.0903856754,
0.0351850353,
0.031787701,
-0.0217670128,
-0.051085256,
0.0917883664,
0.0120771872,
-0.0365355313,
0.0103445882,
0.0076231328,
0.0542066544,
-0.0428229645,
-0.0435564891,
0.0348831825,
0.0135247298,
-0.0161383282,
-0.034901157,
-0.0676523,
0.027404774,
-0.0051132678,
-0.0107076718,
0.0304339882,
0.0376030542,
0.0261162426,
0.012408196,
0.0041846293,
-0.0586639866,
0.0434973873,
-0.0088258563,
-0.0200412124,
-0.0220918301,
-0.0455204993,
-0.0225100815,
0.0164872613,
0.0183294676,
0.0110103386,
-0.0152333193,
-0.0344734862,
-0.0561438426,
0.0426736213,
-0.0874549225,
-0.0030041712,
-0.0039142477,
0.027022738,
0.0775619522,
-0.0554592013,
0.0718744695,
0.0061164182,
-0.0058436226,
-0.0242127813,
-0.0226915665,
-0.0222171079,
-0.0378361531,
-0.0130962133,
0.0445554703,
-0.0029883212,
-0.0587145835,
-0.0028377341,
0.0536501892,
0.0339239426,
0.0161857028,
-0.0369455442,
0.0357422307,
-0.0411592089,
-0.0510324426,
-0.0072191423,
-0.0403878726,
-0.0059490683,
-0.0170873832,
0.0062169381,
-0.0334972069,
0.0108733224,
0.0361980647,
0.0169583037,
-0.0116278436,
0.0168243498,
0.021345323,
-0.0264189448,
-0.0637321398,
-0.0201179106,
-0.0510522313,
0.0556316562,
0.0013302063,
0.0185840148,
-0.05360898,
0.022371171,
0.0150681194,
-0.0250560567,
-0.0530168787,
0.0109430943,
0.0295213722,
-0.0030492435,
0.0211615022,
0.002816885,
0.0009999718,
0.0464833677,
0.0154734664,
0.0309597366,
0.0016386277,
0.0203765519,
0.0283635277,
0.0874528736,
-0.0186433867,
0.0163458623,
0.0202530213,
0.0023095468,
0.0290054195,
0.0217329301,
-0.0203832611,
-0.0098429509,
0.0148083232,
-0.0049282066,
0.0482799634,
-0.0020738691,
-0.0121818967,
0.0349885933,
0.0991566107,
-0.0255932249,
0.0405283682,
-0.0169329736,
0.0445051007,
-0.0292341504,
-0.0543136038,
0.0474076159,
0.0152946357,
-0.0108998464,
-0.0023228838,
0.0927357003,
-0.024954183,
-0.0433617979,
-0.0040296731,
-0.0014353811,
0.0201135185,
-0.022546215,
-0.0087818708,
0.0225342568,
-0.0101138186,
0.0002977942,
0.0237625912,
-0.038827803,
-0.0726999268,
0.0128711499,
-0.0229338985,
0.0267027281,
0.0509810038,
0.0809307918,
-0.0157644954,
0.0064881416,
-0.0007094748,
0.0115081966,
0.0531938635,
0.0323060974,
-0.0391771533,
-0.0246579032,
-0.0533835627,
-0.0183673948,
0.008255179,
-0.0107520446,
-0.0052237394,
0.0125493817,
0.0130146546,
0.0498354472,
-0.0749768764,
-0.0317975059,
0.0261541698,
-0.0671199635,
-0.0919626132,
0.0277616121,
-0.0170938913,
0.0029072205,
0.0181158446,
0.0152230952,
0.0364957117,
0.0456861295,
-0.0157975126,
-0.0201754291,
-0.0296900366,
0.0245951992,
0.0177982748,
0.0095845703,
0.0017073951,
0.016383905,
0.0109941354,
-0.0365390554,
-0.0396681577,
0.0096630817,
-0.025007261,
0.0132581796,
-0.0633784533,
0.0251760278,
-0.0020008245,
-0.0063246726,
-0.0565550327,
0.057004787,
0.0082225828,
0.0651867166,
-0.0394399427,
0.0094282255,
0.0162596535,
-0.0709932595,
0.0115554882,
-0.0135691185,
0.009273001,
0.0291384421,
0.0164796151,
-0.0014875752,
-0.025583636,
-0.0019844756,
-0.0545955151,
0.0208189916,
-0.0126797548,
-0.0171520133,
-0.0070854309,
-0.0039681424,
-0.0093676746,
-0.0227571074,
-0.0635313168,
-0.0538988672,
0.0556800961,
0.0023453014,
0.0248023532,
-0.0080163842,
-0.0037021851,
-0.0105667906,
-0.0242330376,
-0.0005432216,
0.0517735854,
0.0136752613,
0.0017981987,
-0.0134332338,
0.0366710648,
0.0040303627,
0.0013643994,
-0.0414473377,
0.0187504925,
0.00051745,
-0.0446103625,
0.0323886387,
0.0170514397,
0.0364644825,
-0.0114168758,
-0.0168230888,
0.002950188,
-0.0811304301,
-0.0029764171,
-0.0318107791,
0.0215283222,
0.0473326333,
-0.0564106591,
0.0672237277,
-0.0008848257,
-0.0054882593,
-0.0144106243,
-0.0190819241,
0.0147927683,
0.0611528903,
0.0047712764,
-0.0682165101,
-0.0295760017,
0.0283726566,
0.0114485798,
-0.0151470872,
-0.0482280217,
0.0313179046,
-0.0169503968,
0.0067764632,
-0.0405357219,
0.0122118276,
-0.0297297668,
0.0543384738,
-0.0023862144,
0.0063817753,
-0.0007671271,
-0.0283895247,
0.0191269275,
0.0517747775,
-0.0171763971,
-0.0576363802,
0.0055740769,
-0.0126889041,
0.0185214132,
-0.0128143597,
-0.0437987112,
-0.0402781516,
-0.0180492233,
0.0347920395,
0.0184458829,
0.0439522229,
0.0019751235,
-0.0374365784,
0.0397340842,
0.0445077643,
0.009768541,
-0.0280033406,
-0.0045037526,
0.0027507644,
0.0383635275,
0.0435144044,
-0.0581161454,
-0.0137516446,
0.0038212379,
0.0105781201,
0.0259354692,
0.0659513995,
-0.0079074996,
-0.0064554862,
-0.0062879585,
0.0347611643,
-0.0512002297,
-0.0302567631,
-0.0165363681,
-0.0202266537,
-0.0173944198,
-0.0471003987,
0.084724851,
0.0400867537,
-0.094504185,
-0.0402777381,
-0.0474972837,
0.0223714784,
0.0260312632,
0.0322986953,
-0.0189317428,
-0.0026082394,
0.0242040437,
0.0369796455,
-0.0033588801,
0.0037162281,
0.0132261459,
-0.1076971516,
0.0538058244,
0.0302108973,
-0.0217734594,
-0.0464631319,
-0.0383161381,
-0.0269194469,
0.0387706086,
-0.0427630432,
0.0447281636,
-0.0408352278,
-0.0193421133,
0.0081908144,
-0.0261066072,
-0.0485538356,
1.309e-7,
-0.0421769768,
-0.0258598011,
0.0553591736,
0.014845375,
0.0335298367,
-0.0588308387,
0.0188404117,
-0.0147915008,
-0.0188837908,
-0.0129927248,
0.0426506624,
-0.0496670939,
0.0220551845,
-0.0393430963,
0.0336095579,
-0.0063872249,
-0.0135273589,
-0.0219979398,
0.0106614372,
-0.0482468866,
0.0151504735,
-0.0560090169,
-0.0465461649,
-0.0011322038,
0.0490107238,
-0.0058276043,
0.0130944522,
-0.0114679458,
-0.0331785753,
0.0812713578,
-0.0397396646,
-0.021584928,
-0.0328344591,
-0.0663703158,
0.0108095612,
-0.0796402022,
-0.0125418734,
-0.0115849162,
0.0157886557,
-0.0120597798,
0.003293623,
-0.0502789617,
-0.0467593186,
-0.0451990217,
0.0302269943,
-0.0375970677,
-0.0092070289,
-0.0674680173,
-0.0194576979,
0.0671333522,
-0.0266050063,
-0.0230922811,
0.0250553004,
-0.0019847334,
-0.0358815044,
-0.0446989015,
0.0245183297,
0.0087034227,
0.0215640701,
-0.0049071871,
-0.0609954298,
0.0572165288,
0.0271426886,
-0.0029071805,
-0.0510942303,
-0.0106336698,
0.0107367905,
-0.0371596999,
0.0379015431,
-0.0767714977,
0.0168449599,
0.0102623003,
0.0590788946,
-0.0281466469,
-0.0413244702,
-0.0151183596,
0.02898046,
0.037771482,
-0.0008360766,
0.0223829187,
-0.0393773355,
0.0136086931,
-0.017720446,
-0.0361195989,
0.0049688704,
0.037275251,
0.0354789048,
-0.0034345665,
-0.0201967359,
0.0506382547,
-0.0117533132,
0.0752604604,
-0.0248217415,
-0.0248650461,
-0.0088571599,
0.0051841075,
-0.0189689603,
-0.0028477178,
-0.0370517597,
0.019190751,
-0.0116625596,
0.0689869821,
-0.0312528871,
0.008420866,
0.0071993158,
0.0016760367,
-0.070795089,
0.033235047,
-0.0322137959,
-0.0217688549,
-0.0341565348,
0.0091003813,
0.0175535101,
-0.0243180897,
-0.0184080862,
-0.0494219661,
-0.030422505,
-0.0494915992,
0.0061853537,
0.0206479374,
-0.0675512403,
-0.0235875025,
0.0473543443,
-0.0135041839,
-0.0044573992,
0.0639230087,
0.0057588331,
-0.0081788441,
-0.0435154364,
-0.0421109423,
-0.0264814328,
0.0376827493,
0.088158451,
0.0357327797,
-0.0128148859,
-0.0081576388,
0.0016783674,
-0.0401285067,
0.0768983364,
0.0074457638,
0.0167088564,
0.004822928,
0.0479327068,
0.1017205939,
-0.0053987144,
-0.0348346382,
-0.0511543714,
0.0284929536,
-0.0891601071,
-0.0466348827,
-0.0316834413,
-5.902330521e-33,
-0.0049242214,
-0.0093959384,
-0.0145566314,
0.0065130261,
-0.0056465589,
-0.0254934654,
-0.0569329634,
-0.0076766084,
0.045871973,
-0.0342153609,
-0.0446355455,
-0.0125647206,
0.0166962687,
0.034512721,
0.0384518653,
0.0204802305,
0.0367479138,
0.0057622832,
-0.0096405102,
0.054757379,
0.0666976944,
0.0249146484,
-0.0012952781,
-0.0224658642,
0.012973411,
-0.039757736,
0.0494980142,
-0.0068458552,
0.017876504,
0.0511748157,
-0.0512059182,
0.0256121457,
0.0368337706,
-0.0067824316,
0.012462629,
0.028574761,
-0.0566714853,
-0.0084009944,
-0.0501823053,
-0.0047559408,
0.0187480077,
-0.0924061313,
0.0429154858,
-0.0610378943,
-0.0473742262,
0.0373821035,
0.0516762845,
-0.0079843188,
-0.0576302633,
-0.0848577619,
-0.0393191949,
0.0110228816,
0.0227853842,
0.0210629515,
0.0085897213,
-0.0263697077,
0.0137120876,
0.0656047314,
-0.0606262907,
0.005587806,
-0.0009943563,
0.0339841507,
0.015059948,
0.0262104701,
0.027291799,
0.0393477231,
0.0209181402,
-0.0272955559,
-0.0260895025,
0.0793971345,
0.0469701104,
0.0180717018,
0.0765507147,
0.0525822788,
0.0175210182,
-0.0159735568,
-0.0175495278,
0.096596919,
-0.0154449316,
0.0210457332,
0.0423563123,
0.0542335622,
-0.0662981495,
-0.0066935602,
-0.036716748,
-0.0288879238,
-0.0305211395,
-0.0005023246,
0.0256701428,
0.0255903117,
-0.052499786,
-0.0428004563,
0.0707560256,
0.0044412636,
-0.0412647538,
0.015300855,
0.0106286854,
0.0402009264,
-0.0210896693,
-0.0307839662,
-0.0342449918,
-0.033915136,
0.0392863825,
-0.0291584115,
-0.0179448165,
-0.0145407598,
-0.0133342976,
-0.004589464,
-0.0568507537,
0.0050718733,
0.0289157964,
-0.0111434907,
0.0134394821,
0.0170103665,
-0.0007825698,
0.003388617,
0.0263122506,
0.0230185613,
0.0145601807,
0.0330095477,
0.0097331759,
-0.0464123935,
-0.0258426648,
0.004660361,
0.0090775955,
0.0700611174,
-0.0475905165,
0.0080186464,
0.0245020166,
-0.0377391241,
0.0219470337,
0.0306731891,
2.586e-7,
0.0070860456,
0.0544356965,
0.0451682508,
0.0409267806,
0.0065284423,
0.0240471847,
0.0316304862,
0.0025262628,
0.0294128042,
0.0009884275,
0.0009063195,
0.0233230703,
0.0507738218,
0.0107574631,
-0.1091558784,
0.0239339489,
-0.0435922332,
0.0098434063,
-0.0611146763,
-0.0238123722,
0.0102748824,
0.063016139,
-0.0065426421,
-0.01543325,
0.0117353722,
-0.0807432085,
0.0466602072,
-0.0003454368,
-0.0053100209,
0.0321177319,
0.0728204772,
0.0303210709,
0.0030187806,
-0.0219253339,
-0.0154365459,
0.0057890522,
0.0354043655,
0.0408568755,
0.0075554247,
-0.0338446461,
-0.0331921354,
-0.0373119041,
0.0279208273,
-0.0354394689,
0.0763755813,
0.0197218657,
0.032172516,
-0.0036636896,
-0.0626893789,
-0.0265786946,
0.0018713293,
-0.0404185243,
-0.0539131649,
0.0421000086,
0.0145234121,
0.0086000497,
0.0305400677,
-0.0779138207,
0.0333889797,
-0.0081490353,
-0.0468359962,
0.0432176515,
-0.0210490748,
0.0397325568,
-0.0160032455,
0.0091802767,
0.0026827385,
2.355220022e-34,
0.0218885895,
0.013480573,
-0.0140711609,
0.0161892287,
0.0270247459,
-0.003955117,
-0.0249802601,
0.0539870039,
0.0194098856,
-0.0910804048,
-0.003685781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.08592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.08592v2 | AART: AI-Assisted Red-Teaming with Diverse Data Generation for New LLM-powered Applications | 2023-11-14T23:28:23 | 2023-11-29T23:18:16 | Bhaktipriya Radharapu, Kevin Robinson, Lora Aroyo, Preethi Lahoti | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Adversarial testing of large language models (LLMs) is crucial for their safe
and responsible deployment. We introduce a novel approach for automated
generation of adversarial evaluation datasets to test the safety of LLM
generations on new downstream applications. We call it AI-assisted Red-Teaming
(AART) - an automated alternative to current manual red-teaming efforts. AART
offers a data generation and augmentation pipeline of reusable and customizable
recipes that reduce human effort significantly and enable integration of
adversarial testing earlier in new product development. AART generates
evaluation datasets with high diversity of content characteristics critical for
effective adversarial testing (e.g. sensitive and harmful concepts, specific to
a wide range of cultural and geographic regions and application scenarios). The
data generation is steered by AI-assisted recipes to define, scope and
prioritize diversity within the application context. This feeds into a
structured LLM-generation process that scales up evaluation priorities.
Compared to some state-of-the-art tools, AART shows promising results in terms
of concept coverage and data quality. | [
-0.0019339913,
0.0567189716,
-0.0395828523,
0.026461279,
-0.0517558903,
-0.0231678933,
0.0375657268,
-0.0133439582,
0.0457481593,
-0.0456903577,
-0.0076110302,
0.0052185506,
0.0035191048,
0.0592212901,
0.0388669856,
0.0049386974,
0.0344813503,
-0.026875319,
-0.035151206,
0.0119806286,
-0.0312089883,
0.0120034525,
0.0002580233,
0.038362354,
0.0103991488,
-0.009941523,
-0.0094223907,
0.0035736766,
0.0214312691,
-0.0537239276,
-0.0023993612,
0.0327784121,
-0.0115579935,
0.062534228,
0.0000020979,
-0.0448736921,
-0.0210572481,
0.0357059427,
-0.0043412554,
0.0232116114,
0.0314160958,
0.0031870853,
-0.0320697427,
0.0402961373,
-0.033799734,
0.0221722554,
0.037062373,
0.0002018197,
0.077076301,
0.0721626654,
0.0011013962,
-0.0012656192,
0.0261213742,
-0.0055515287,
-0.0061000735,
-0.0302219708,
0.003345774,
-0.0066962563,
0.0120496647,
0.0006536699,
0.0212748051,
0.010427882,
0.0594749153,
0.0101563102,
-0.0609972477,
0.0134802079,
-0.048482962,
-0.0091880169,
-0.0145740695,
0.0555215552,
-0.0454547256,
-0.0338098966,
-0.0167834144,
-0.0132829817,
-0.0278919749,
-0.0305315871,
0.0036386605,
0.0269936733,
-0.0211873613,
0.0038225015,
0.0054510753,
-0.0192439258,
0.0397419259,
0.0069863466,
-0.0155149987,
0.0753860325,
0.0169578847,
-0.0217753313,
-0.0045577502,
-0.0346906707,
0.0083181169,
-0.0304379463,
-0.0280173887,
-0.0305570532,
-0.0098143704,
0.0218264647,
-0.0738512278,
-0.066782169,
0.0673694536,
-0.0456335545,
0.0529605597,
-0.0037244449,
-0.0417045727,
0.0332916155,
-0.0497691892,
0.0494793765,
0.0124080591,
0.0235414505,
-0.0201895274,
0.0007690417,
0.0036369897,
0.0152720856,
0.016154673,
-0.0020520047,
-0.0149151227,
0.0171818826,
-0.0253343768,
0.0478840955,
-0.0584501252,
0.0542963333,
-0.0203961935,
-0.0026948403,
-0.0268275551,
-0.0067345197,
0.0173185859,
-0.0610293858,
-0.0226378236,
0.0175072514,
-0.0122094629,
-0.0902726576,
-0.0025999725,
0.0223652143,
-0.0793647394,
-0.0221231375,
-0.0044868882,
0.1189285591,
0.0250925291,
-0.0102240825,
-0.0479693562,
-0.0049670837,
0.0020607533,
-0.0371055864,
0.0252244398,
-0.0669313893,
-0.0118737826,
-0.0157260541,
-0.0100891264,
-0.0776906386,
0.0063899462,
0.0042503085,
-0.0005117549,
0.0713905618,
0.0054069674,
-0.0109710628,
0.0039406074,
0.0227639861,
-0.0039831675,
0.1282719821,
0.0060457424,
0.051376611,
0.047074344,
-0.0087383743,
0.0135670872,
0.0570494607,
0.0142262354,
0.0542295836,
-0.0632099435,
0.0063817874,
-0.0023653577,
-0.0151233068,
-0.0218731593,
0.0437039547,
0.0063546598,
-0.0368990935,
0.0482938513,
0.0099454559,
-0.0117519107,
0.02178335,
0.0369056351,
0.0170423463,
-0.0213502571,
-0.0098322565,
-0.0494381711,
0.0173742045,
-0.0813410878,
-0.0272985697,
0.0051989732,
0.0728122294,
-0.0150966495,
-0.0237003453,
-0.0182333477,
-0.0228370279,
0.0367109925,
-0.0191223361,
0.0294109322,
0.0290226229,
-0.0440492965,
0.0143770799,
0.0196419861,
-0.0560441166,
-0.0459003001,
-0.0684026405,
-0.001093801,
0.0424605757,
0.0748516247,
-0.0601945706,
-0.0225232746,
-0.0107647367,
-0.0343619995,
0.0360045247,
0.0292622838,
0.0136583643,
-0.0015122865,
-0.0267453808,
-0.0361765809,
-0.0554153509,
0.0284103658,
0.0456874408,
0.0394727103,
0.0115662077,
0.0065519484,
-0.0399620719,
-0.064539507,
0.0456573665,
-0.0267222244,
-0.0275863986,
0.0278536882,
0.0095711816,
0.0399050564,
0.0040991241,
-0.0404162854,
0.0048214607,
0.0672741234,
-0.0407159291,
-0.0051726853,
0.0037726799,
0.0391482748,
0.0051968186,
0.0125286868,
-0.0514003336,
-0.0150249461,
0.0585141964,
-0.0663157701,
0.0057644001,
0.0342358612,
-0.0037203294,
-0.0182409436,
-0.0084761409,
0.0064474354,
-0.0133005194,
0.0529723354,
-0.0316938125,
0.0285529532,
-0.030767547,
-0.0065080966,
-0.0172069836,
0.001345435,
0.0330809541,
0.0066053746,
-0.0463129468,
0.0338241905,
-0.0331698023,
0.0530548953,
-0.0012586975,
0.0358288959,
-0.0125685288,
-0.0174906477,
-0.0368359834,
0.0057912879,
-0.0337615237,
0.0262611192,
0.0343553573,
-0.0094465632,
-0.0038057389,
-0.0001197691,
-0.0001922415,
0.0084828483,
0.005193729,
0.0277275927,
-0.0050437753,
-0.0209912956,
-0.0449910313,
0.0045115706,
-0.0086803678,
-0.0101712476,
0.082581602,
-0.0016012031,
0.0007006191,
-0.0456743538,
0.0214718506,
-0.006451631,
0.0444177091,
-0.0250521787,
-0.0866434425,
0.0218168087,
0.0112098167,
-0.0357764661,
0.046741046,
0.0149836577,
0.017533686,
0.0817444399,
0.0265722107,
-0.0428423248,
-0.004287363,
0.0385708883,
-0.0180652346,
-0.0010589815,
-0.0407597385,
0.0230847672,
0.023307234,
-0.0152590526,
-0.0186082963,
-0.0331851244,
0.0091904253,
-0.0473272987,
-0.0508744158,
-0.0030938643,
-0.0352415368,
-0.025360629,
0.0212643575,
-0.0176926702,
-0.0659816712,
0.0732932016,
-0.0387259983,
0.0207491387,
-0.071586661,
-0.0303723067,
-0.0273084398,
0.0807731375,
0.0033038023,
0.0292096417,
-0.0066551194,
0.0290251244,
-0.0446707197,
-0.0081405919,
0.0077911029,
-0.0346389301,
0.0644783378,
-0.0631465241,
-0.0030546791,
-0.0037978403,
-0.0185649749,
-0.0653034225,
-0.0004580851,
0.0062941024,
0.0208480116,
0.0301029421,
0.0046971226,
-0.022990413,
0.0229250062,
0.0149148554,
0.0399200805,
0.026453061,
0.0040492383,
0.0029444022,
-0.0287342016,
0.020378828,
-0.0388236381,
0.0205270536,
0.0083075408,
0.026240062,
0.0521403328,
0.0324475877,
-0.0100507541,
-0.044749707,
-0.0148231164,
0.0065744999,
-0.0239886064,
0.0272231791,
0.0310398638,
0.009766602,
-0.0501998328,
0.0223836396,
0.0236181747,
0.0219031796,
-0.0390057154,
0.0272131022,
0.0153019363,
0.0236932002,
0.0362217762,
0.0545291863,
-0.1340067089,
0.0045911516,
-0.0047315545,
0.0471298434,
-0.041008614,
-0.0233913828,
-0.0323982462,
-0.1420409679,
0.0230021086,
0.0028897086,
-0.0726564154,
-0.0241695363,
-0.0323634185,
-0.0170354117,
-0.0127602918,
0.0776901916,
0.0091632288,
0.0220642313,
-0.0179448742,
-0.0130432686,
-0.0676708817,
-0.0933399498,
0.0320079215,
-0.0257556755,
0.0594263226,
0.0703578368,
0.0043619992,
-0.0395729057,
0.0030112523,
0.0248033423,
-0.0273121744,
0.0050762696,
-0.0014585865,
0.0447598547,
0.0393087529,
-0.0230807085,
0.0620436221,
0.0072010015,
-0.0191892348,
-0.0195808411,
0.0504200608,
0.0157507062,
-0.0275611095,
-0.0299696513,
-0.0236471295,
0.001229798,
0.0619902872,
0.0588446185,
0.0161152203,
-0.0423514284,
-0.0132299969,
-0.0458994173,
-0.0081779873,
-0.0962190032,
-0.0358125381,
0.0356039852,
-0.0387747064,
-0.0388630815,
-0.0648603812,
-0.0123943752,
-0.0044079791,
0.0259805378,
0.0356405824,
-0.0282183979,
-0.060099408,
0.0188922677,
-0.0245132074,
0.0137040205,
0.0289767981,
0.0482444316,
-0.0163966473,
-0.0159220826,
-0.0059495694,
-0.0389094204,
-0.0081232898,
0.0665319189,
-0.0360520333,
-0.0870940164,
0.0621522553,
0.0728322342,
0.0194920786,
0.0143123902,
-0.0443575457,
-0.060804341,
0.0939569324,
0.0669648275,
-0.0339904353,
0.0019983572,
0.0713553876,
-0.0182006508,
-0.0043380363,
0.0236140545,
-0.0721245334,
0.0255736858,
0.0210447535,
-0.0092084948,
-0.0059592063,
-0.0210746937,
0.0197233185,
0.0501948558,
0.0324554034,
-0.0450743958,
-0.0035064647,
0.009293057,
0.0399006344,
0.0019329593,
-0.031882856,
-0.0216008555,
0.0275006965,
-0.0210511945,
-0.0480170362,
0.0407027826,
0.0419208556,
-0.0035791849,
0.0170892309,
-0.0214865655,
0.0453355983,
0.0570835918,
0.0537334383,
0.0386986211,
0.0128346654,
-0.0149480738,
0.0261735152,
-0.0448773019,
0.0382590108,
-0.0024434826,
0.0292104539,
0.0116581041,
0.0191810336,
0.011061592,
0.0776313618,
-0.0213378649,
-0.0483241975,
-0.0311243162,
0.0311429687,
0.0486343913,
0.0599942803,
0.0381292589,
-0.0516162328,
-0.0040594218,
-0.0251841992,
-0.0063689705,
-0.0324351527,
-0.0175674111,
0.0120155104,
0.0073460364,
-0.0192640275,
0.0031030569,
0.0771212876,
0.0006433931,
0.0529268906,
-0.0098228874,
0.0232580286,
-0.0494857281,
-0.0345330238,
0.0493535399,
-0.008583284,
-0.0209187716,
-0.0443683229,
-0.0488301031,
-0.0831003115,
-0.0173748527,
0.0423546731,
0.0136566712,
0.0124905398,
-0.00447217,
0.0860529542,
0.0154720042,
0.0412233472,
-0.0433202125,
-0.0235053506,
-0.0380680449,
-0.0456414707,
0.0165797397,
-6.597930038e-33,
0.0181763284,
-0.0270498972,
0.0003727025,
-0.0425388068,
0.0075886785,
0.04986386,
-0.0179378297,
-0.0006504037,
-0.0020739089,
-0.0136759393,
0.012797514,
-0.0164708141,
0.0031474393,
0.0004011109,
0.0040839855,
-0.0072142337,
0.0279333051,
-0.004801949,
-0.0330465622,
0.027218936,
0.0296901111,
-0.0211645421,
0.0185259152,
-0.0691538528,
0.0113986256,
0.0201386865,
-0.0375808701,
-0.0070621506,
-0.0306773447,
0.0580437109,
0.0264494289,
0.043393936,
0.0106463432,
-0.0212658886,
-0.0081954654,
-0.0637416691,
0.005162091,
-0.0270278286,
-0.0108663542,
-0.0023228559,
-0.0465132892,
-0.009554904,
0.049157612,
-0.0150171826,
0.0017323936,
0.0237623639,
0.0098293182,
-0.0233115181,
-0.0237783492,
-0.0256522428,
-0.030730933,
0.0255370662,
-0.0156773031,
0.0021434336,
-0.0042422283,
0.0380673259,
0.0206353441,
-0.0017136468,
-0.0566987395,
0.0316899568,
-0.0002790202,
-0.0184436869,
0.1168333516,
0.0080524348,
0.0009966112,
0.0635976568,
-0.0345000364,
0.0371328928,
-0.0067190775,
-0.0442955866,
0.039251484,
0.0681691691,
0.0474109836,
0.0775039047,
0.0197054856,
-0.0307132825,
-0.0331164263,
0.0531470217,
0.0567885786,
0.0141204223,
0.0203835499,
0.0156140532,
-0.0610126555,
-0.0008037309,
-0.0068831253,
-0.0218274705,
-0.0268752966,
-0.0544807501,
0.0163508672,
-0.0003284006,
-0.0876729265,
-0.0044119214,
0.0085332142,
-0.0472756922,
0.0277171582,
0.0351860747,
-0.0304245483,
-0.0203593951,
-0.0044780285,
0.0143882269,
-0.0016654942,
-0.0216050968,
0.0123824524,
-0.0137383305,
0.0487027913,
-0.0116072567,
0.0266799964,
0.0322778113,
-0.0516423509,
0.0281581562,
-0.033697512,
0.0517999642,
0.0295025613,
0.004620315,
0.0091843912,
-0.0013704431,
0.0122611988,
-0.0029126415,
0.0593092479,
-0.0176088512,
-0.0318399109,
0.0312330127,
-0.0075840219,
0.027014371,
-0.0452886336,
-0.0170350913,
-0.0161820929,
0.0001890104,
0.0493981577,
-0.0634804219,
-0.0266849101,
-0.0046206787,
2.942e-7,
0.014816707,
0.0304780118,
-0.009661003,
0.0164219085,
0.0165484063,
0.0433278196,
-0.0083938101,
0.0426107384,
-0.0207779277,
-0.0145016285,
-0.0349800326,
0.016250506,
0.0654408038,
0.0945706666,
-0.0299353562,
0.0241822284,
-0.0753059462,
0.0320421495,
-0.0680327043,
-0.02509881,
0.0415207371,
0.0745395049,
0.0117369918,
-0.0351833887,
0.0037887061,
-0.0534633435,
-0.0198712666,
-0.0246913619,
-0.0006186948,
0.0368399881,
0.0153519353,
0.0366517864,
0.0050081662,
0.0507501103,
-0.0400933735,
-0.0312478244,
-0.0196052548,
0.0109337261,
0.0215385742,
-0.0413745344,
0.0024288332,
-0.0483165942,
-0.0164736416,
-0.0608343035,
0.0775330365,
-0.0019224605,
-0.0302423481,
-0.0509527251,
0.0138185276,
-0.0230370443,
0.0428850017,
-0.0360722616,
0.0320376307,
0.0054522506,
-0.0101731122,
-0.0200512819,
-0.0079421178,
-0.0444231592,
-0.0340458527,
-0.0082908422,
-0.0291387457,
-0.0304807443,
0.005087493,
0.0208436735,
-0.0213496927,
-0.0110122422,
0.0565863363,
3.098283521e-34,
0.0182201024,
-0.0337189995,
-0.0076308907,
-0.0244862139,
0.0278730281,
-0.006354467,
-0.0101143681,
0.0128490599,
-0.0294417515,
-0.0109495316,
0.0007499626
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.