id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10862v1 | Formal concept analysis for evaluating intrinsic dimension of a natural language | 2023-11-17T20:48:58 | 2023-11-17T20:48:58 | Sergei O. Kuznetsov, Vasilii A. Gromov, Nikita S. Borodin, Andrei M. Divavin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, math.AT | Some results of a computational experiment for determining the intrinsic
dimension of linguistic varieties for the Bengali and Russian languages are
presented. At the same time, both sets of words and sets of bigrams in these
languages were considered separately. The method used to solve this problem was
based on formal concept analysis algorithms. It was found that the intrinsic
dimensions of these languages are significantly less than the dimensions used
in popular neural network models in natural language processing. | [
0.0038976553,
-0.0198632684,
-0.0408794396,
0.0711345375,
-0.0438787714,
-0.0058454415,
-0.0276219882,
-0.0006659597,
-0.0469871685,
-0.0074557918,
0.0354522653,
-0.0836171806,
0.0123795057,
0.0857218131,
0.0127799641,
-0.034698505,
0.0196680147,
-0.0207174364,
0.0501372665,
0.0208131745,
0.004704305,
-0.0212033503,
0.0046625789,
-0.0208237693,
-0.0203548502,
0.0137070222,
-0.0014755824,
-0.0551354513,
-0.0374463722,
-0.037473239,
-0.0396103859,
0.0007142915,
-0.0183184613,
0.0411934853,
0.0000015816,
-0.084922865,
-0.0034186898,
0.0050524445,
0.0244361162,
0.0096334005,
0.0219277255,
0.0307214111,
-0.018591376,
0.0087887067,
-0.0183957089,
-0.0277999621,
0.0304052196,
0.056933336,
0.0025594768,
0.0521243624,
-0.0235537197,
-0.0806642994,
0.0158790797,
0.0197520982,
-0.0151179135,
0.0299682766,
0.0348969959,
0.0226352587,
-0.0213116556,
0.0224537551,
-0.0158503428,
-0.029651735,
-0.010273451,
-0.0250967611,
-0.0144944163,
-0.0180084482,
-0.0084787533,
-0.0107710157,
0.0539890081,
-0.0034749457,
0.0424719229,
0.030450888,
-0.0132185305,
0.0079522487,
-0.0106634619,
0.0017733825,
-0.0175091624,
-0.0187240466,
-0.0413429327,
0.0021587105,
0.0290842969,
0.0705912635,
-0.0294988584,
-0.0184099842,
-0.0213816091,
0.0917384177,
0.0059760632,
-0.0047252565,
-0.0198012311,
-0.0670473501,
0.0367861837,
0.0202856138,
0.0151424585,
0.0196564812,
0.0406853147,
0.0192855895,
0.0726503432,
-0.0266806781,
0.0332033075,
-0.154901281,
0.0241666995,
-0.0036365148,
0.0125398487,
-0.0069970633,
0.0325813852,
0.0490540788,
0.0230495278,
-0.0193614513,
-0.0514517017,
0.0446395501,
-0.0370264612,
-0.0099823819,
-0.0587638468,
0.0338736586,
0.0214442741,
-0.0007616972,
-0.0439637937,
-0.0016342179,
0.0165042393,
0.0086250445,
-0.0430461206,
-0.0164207481,
0.0192311853,
-0.0068924571,
-0.0318674371,
-0.0247583315,
-0.0586940683,
-0.034647122,
-0.070298709,
-0.0589401275,
0.0862650648,
-0.0096927518,
-0.0061608059,
0.0013591967,
0.0062464047,
-0.0028334921,
0.0271196179,
-0.0290975403,
-0.0091340449,
0.0313378721,
-0.0294214357,
-0.08585006,
-0.0446240343,
-0.056612093,
-0.0351680927,
-0.0289523918,
-0.0262171235,
-0.0466469266,
-0.0250152349,
-0.0179764237,
-0.0203189086,
0.0334415585,
-0.01798754,
0.0092571042,
0.069229193,
0.0001897134,
0.0333866775,
0.0548194833,
-0.0043769991,
0.0172927119,
0.0692204237,
-0.1043921486,
-0.0118861711,
-0.0004271209,
-0.0233094115,
-0.0320316292,
-0.0647750273,
0.0136136636,
0.0097494265,
0.0186839085,
-0.0299140569,
0.0522383749,
-0.0086609498,
0.0169395115,
0.0033168688,
0.0703787878,
0.0455347337,
0.0838232487,
0.0131954048,
-0.0011351284,
0.0736518428,
0.0759376213,
0.0366047285,
-0.0093912091,
-0.0089572752,
-0.0140703488,
0.0296219252,
-0.0028567733,
-0.0191283356,
-0.0607135445,
-0.0339121893,
0.0151256667,
0.0389460586,
-0.0910673812,
0.0751477778,
-0.0146520371,
0.044929456,
-0.0192210097,
0.0279400107,
-0.0134586636,
0.0001617042,
0.0094395354,
0.0258148778,
0.0187212806,
0.0070878514,
-0.0480073132,
0.0186161902,
0.023510946,
-0.0834336206,
0.0836041346,
0.0284343231,
-0.0280042943,
-0.0489649139,
-0.0380180366,
0.0248789713,
-0.015151524,
0.0112409396,
0.0152482195,
-0.0376625024,
0.0569216385,
-0.0266168285,
-0.0271718334,
-0.0575110391,
-0.0117168734,
0.0154493898,
-0.0045499667,
0.0164020937,
-0.0086724758,
0.0278925374,
0.042937357,
0.0066975919,
0.0303008649,
-0.011552318,
-0.0358752124,
-0.0030263844,
0.0166891031,
0.0012167018,
0.0540236235,
0.0384399444,
-0.0269706007,
0.0686261505,
-0.0310774297,
0.020497717,
-0.0214927495,
0.0879275501,
-0.0395029336,
0.0233361218,
-0.0336992703,
0.0522626713,
-0.0637786239,
0.0288562216,
-0.0086929221,
0.0221437514,
-0.0114634987,
0.0555100515,
-0.0357668512,
-0.0371977128,
0.0596299246,
-0.014299429,
-0.0374879688,
0.0392458625,
0.0103827324,
0.0068709762,
0.0381924585,
-0.0266292896,
-0.0305843484,
-0.0159003213,
-0.0236301571,
-0.061899025,
0.031174127,
0.0693277791,
-0.0283239111,
0.0144178383,
0.0346094184,
0.0111655444,
-0.0320193246,
0.0273980144,
-0.0229558293,
0.0292195342,
0.0056349081,
0.040723931,
-0.0503083095,
-0.0007004897,
-0.0370952599,
0.0267159399,
0.0394011848,
0.0043110712,
-0.0124272089,
-0.0081670834,
0.0017115478,
-0.0404707864,
0.0106193935,
-0.0202826392,
-0.0615222827,
-0.0049640234,
-0.0120153911,
-0.0186181124,
-0.045419164,
0.0333030969,
0.0040177116,
0.032209713,
-0.0169852935,
0.000531993,
-0.0147197163,
-0.0137123493,
0.0475913584,
0.0258299448,
-0.0243154671,
-0.0033539587,
0.0620414801,
0.0009055478,
-0.0171062686,
-0.0475999154,
0.0344817042,
-0.0610655881,
0.0492537878,
-0.0490681566,
0.0207643937,
-0.0347739644,
0.0704154968,
0.0236986484,
-0.0393487513,
0.0290693026,
-0.0230517145,
0.026557602,
-0.0395422354,
0.007396806,
-0.030755505,
0.0387433842,
0.003752178,
0.0129207354,
0.0477542318,
-0.029321406,
0.0226833057,
0.0006497913,
0.0646236762,
-0.0044739847,
0.0375667699,
-0.0399406292,
0.0045592305,
0.0030936033,
0.0334679745,
-0.019771101,
0.0484079458,
0.0307359565,
0.0215530451,
0.0298963152,
0.0138282944,
0.0407758802,
0.0626013801,
-0.0222302414,
-0.010139456,
-0.005631289,
0.017431587,
0.0369351879,
0.0302287675,
0.0054469625,
0.0056333928,
0.0213549137,
0.0578300655,
0.0472664461,
0.0055287769,
-0.0572312064,
0.0006962373,
-0.0002475045,
-0.0318511277,
-0.007579999,
-0.0273620151,
-0.0467664823,
0.0562651828,
-0.0561795123,
0.0057149814,
-0.0335130468,
0.0448864363,
0.0529464893,
-0.0129959527,
0.0447096601,
-0.0594303906,
-0.0529363193,
0.0196058489,
0.0109014567,
0.0011842195,
0.0732034892,
-0.025982203,
-0.063606292,
-0.03046236,
-0.0188083369,
-0.0378408805,
-0.0823013484,
-0.0439291522,
-0.0012293066,
-0.0880375206,
-0.0100789955,
-0.0177560225,
0.0181842223,
0.0326992646,
-0.010598626,
0.0490146279,
0.0024198177,
-0.0273682997,
0.011513019,
-0.0653152093,
-0.0320453644,
0.0051604542,
0.0008170887,
-0.0044581303,
-0.0324458033,
0.016338991,
-0.1006362364,
-0.0008181138,
0.019128643,
-0.0408280492,
0.0299744699,
0.0093384916,
0.0244195033,
0.0451706499,
0.0029281867,
-0.0384007283,
-0.0190454144,
0.0421658345,
0.0186355282,
0.0083181206,
0.0444209464,
0.0131116379,
-0.0286423434,
0.0071998783,
-0.0202567801,
-0.0294930488,
-0.0141450278,
0.0337832905,
-0.004341702,
0.0230642688,
-0.019265987,
-0.0308382511,
-0.0025643483,
-0.0391391255,
0.0247744359,
-0.0094877221,
-0.0909317359,
-0.0785514861,
-0.0067205005,
-0.0189196207,
0.0291344374,
-0.006328892,
0.05795414,
0.0345483497,
-0.0043285042,
-0.0259406213,
0.0313903019,
0.0462297164,
0.0011579737,
-0.0548421554,
-0.0235563759,
0.0052115577,
-0.0191331096,
0.0122051099,
-0.0455304682,
0.0226236675,
-0.0351260751,
0.0289608613,
0.0126024112,
0.0204397421,
-0.037684042,
-0.0186345428,
-0.0586557947,
0.0637973621,
-0.0182630029,
-0.0523426645,
0.0046444535,
0.0531268157,
0.0118329488,
-0.0113119828,
0.0479029678,
0.0131652048,
0.0280639846,
-0.0289763846,
-0.0280284733,
0.0094716512,
-0.0004380004,
-0.0078659514,
0.0682341605,
0.022953406,
-0.0094693145,
-0.0114362668,
-0.0237783007,
-0.0330344997,
-0.042002663,
-0.029602468,
-0.0192447174,
-0.0082990974,
-0.0026206803,
0.0098437397,
-0.0559077859,
-0.0660426542,
-0.034259472,
-0.0345833525,
0.0238474607,
0.0333453938,
0.0553866774,
0.056114316,
0.0373855345,
0.0076674796,
-0.0495562553,
-0.01707891,
-0.0467667133,
-0.0049521956,
-0.0240182076,
0.0091431607,
0.0104536489,
0.0356987268,
-0.0186302401,
0.0435936525,
0.0899714679,
0.0285773836,
0.0057552624,
0.0383499786,
0.0493841507,
0.0088817542,
0.0198365282,
-0.0073023057,
0.0247292314,
-0.0026995153,
0.0168076605,
0.0214294363,
-0.0317645743,
0.0314563103,
0.0182763338,
-0.0083309961,
-0.0073330156,
0.0791692436,
-0.0464417338,
-0.0244117677,
0.0287025888,
0.0086450009,
-0.0139441835,
0.0261224844,
-0.037295606,
0.0678074956,
-0.025701236,
0.039832063,
-0.1061784923,
-0.0508088842,
-0.00642461,
0.0039479416,
0.0208329726,
0.0197743345,
0.040326491,
0.0120450137,
0.0539091565,
0.0442245975,
-0.0176497754,
-0.0470362976,
-0.0426571444,
0.0502978824,
0.0487319604,
-5.277594946e-33,
-0.0091574639,
-0.0498482101,
-0.0194414314,
0.0253736395,
0.0227979664,
0.0097508617,
0.0086491583,
0.0212889407,
0.0030130425,
0.0217461828,
0.0004862079,
-0.004117941,
0.0087539935,
-0.0545601249,
0.0325237587,
0.0389992148,
-0.0380297266,
-0.00218866,
-0.026911905,
-0.032358069,
0.0545923226,
-0.0317824818,
0.076493986,
-0.0158245806,
0.0717651621,
0.0176830236,
0.0034336606,
0.0397761464,
0.0002498819,
0.009828506,
-0.016993897,
0.0615162179,
0.0427037477,
-0.0308028962,
-0.00439404,
-0.0359368548,
-0.0246153194,
-0.0881061554,
0.0545273535,
0.0240864214,
0.0180297364,
-0.0114399642,
-0.011441567,
-0.0178364757,
-0.0125638982,
0.0333117768,
0.0133309467,
-0.0364663787,
-0.0020669457,
0.0174419489,
-0.0327760987,
0.0401756167,
0.0196903273,
0.051376,
0.0410324447,
-0.0599933527,
-0.0307014473,
-0.0959311798,
0.003442388,
0.0548032932,
0.0078182807,
0.0298027471,
-0.0100044291,
-0.0142818037,
0.0015221987,
-0.0047184974,
0.0272738952,
-0.0361202061,
0.017832417,
0.0036957606,
0.0223804228,
0.0406510197,
0.0113704875,
0.0614045933,
0.0816262066,
0.0040624826,
-0.0158792827,
0.0213000681,
0.0543894507,
0.0628940389,
-0.0078666154,
-0.0070199859,
-0.0609784983,
-0.0560796075,
0.0372639112,
0.0039462713,
-0.047978729,
-0.0451748744,
0.0164228808,
-0.052957546,
0.0192645546,
-0.0799096078,
-0.0133624952,
-0.0342623554,
0.029227538,
0.0203127228,
-0.0155972177,
0.0244789403,
0.0002237608,
0.0166691765,
-0.0133060869,
-0.0710481256,
-0.025490718,
0.0216808841,
0.0050317249,
0.0285499617,
-0.0332789496,
0.0008494595,
-0.0236216318,
-0.0026340459,
-0.0132175833,
-0.0532365106,
0.0055690384,
0.043613486,
-0.0146926306,
-0.0448894016,
-0.0072011133,
0.0195866022,
0.0377560593,
0.0118742995,
0.0111830104,
-0.0214503966,
0.0320530199,
0.0202869698,
-0.0225411505,
-0.0023563642,
-0.0183464866,
-0.0620554462,
0.0783362538,
0.0379903652,
0.0016681316,
0.02400898,
2.553e-7,
0.0149857681,
0.0297427904,
0.0284449067,
0.0144495415,
0.0575628653,
0.0049953042,
-0.0592905954,
0.0070627192,
-0.0444799252,
0.0300364047,
0.0389062688,
-0.0181160178,
0.019328678,
0.0639015436,
-0.0598084666,
-0.0204411838,
-0.010387362,
0.016171068,
-0.0034384611,
0.0125511475,
-0.0114724804,
0.0030710471,
0.0216942392,
0.0181870833,
-0.0536649376,
-0.0575792193,
-0.0075656958,
-0.0089236349,
0.0160204992,
0.0297719333,
0.0011246332,
-0.0084714396,
-0.0035482156,
0.0178983174,
0.0140852248,
0.0392804109,
0.021008011,
0.0163729694,
-0.0224260297,
0.0764611438,
-0.0017858609,
-0.0576779544,
-0.0247973893,
-0.0428102612,
0.0439983979,
-0.0019916366,
-0.1165674105,
0.0224772915,
-0.0009463511,
-0.0166998524,
-0.0101818321,
0.0010902771,
-0.0298141465,
0.0151191009,
0.0106250541,
-0.0741068795,
0.0013014366,
-0.014703556,
-0.0336385593,
0.0010881808,
-0.0244761072,
-0.0473798029,
0.0257481262,
-0.0169365387,
0.0484156311,
-0.0007700251,
0.0487614162,
1.829611728e-34,
0.04770739,
0.0338549837,
0.0184906181,
-0.0360893235,
0.0019460958,
-0.0299754012,
-0.0242453907,
0.0099835275,
0.0251458157,
-0.0814544931,
-0.0082126223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10847v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10847v2 | Token-Level Adaptation of LoRA Adapters for Downstream Task Generalization | 2023-11-17T20:07:54 | 2023-12-01T06:38:18 | Joshua Belofsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper introduces a method for adapting LoRA adapters in smaller-sized
language models to arbitrary downstream tasks. Unlike standard
mixture-of-expert architectures, our method employs a gradient-free routing
function to choose a weighted combination of experts without increasing the
compute requirements for training or inference. The results show that
token-level adaptation of LoRA adapters outperforms the base Llama-2-7b model
across mathematical (GSM8K), scientific (ARC-Challenge), reading comprehension
(SQuAD), and coding (CodeAlpaca-20k) tasks. Further evaluations also show that
the average performance of token-level adaptation outperforms individual models
fine-tuned for each of the tasks with the best performance observed in
adaptation of every-other token during inference. The code for this study is
made available through a public repository. | [
0.0362560302,
0.0390308425,
-0.0244219024,
0.0274058636,
-0.0218730588,
0.0148339774,
0.0400915034,
-0.0248969495,
-0.0039942772,
-0.0047257473,
-0.0739770159,
0.0035153381,
-0.0009425711,
0.0270453449,
0.0553124584,
-0.0472930558,
0.0262315143,
-0.0670149997,
0.0432176031,
-0.0255352277,
-0.0232957806,
-0.0004177751,
-0.0279158298,
0.0407481045,
0.0461814031,
0.0029470611,
0.0078930026,
-0.0169238001,
0.0235347133,
0.0081585776,
0.0051287306,
0.0325790346,
0.0295642987,
-0.0135057066,
0.0000020277,
-0.0206863564,
-0.0065216622,
-0.019564528,
-0.0354328752,
-0.0170368645,
0.0251767561,
0.0054183123,
0.0029556006,
0.0233213175,
-0.025408132,
-0.0572785996,
0.0543753691,
0.026001662,
0.0331035107,
0.0964958817,
-0.0098503297,
-0.0248232894,
0.0631803051,
-0.0156681407,
0.0075434414,
-0.0556199215,
0.0183343515,
-0.0056319223,
-0.0049467995,
-0.0127989743,
-0.0444392674,
0.0271808282,
0.0363915153,
0.0044283899,
0.006132945,
0.0210016947,
0.0001251044,
-0.0116342325,
-0.0459066555,
0.047137849,
-0.0326403826,
-0.0350461714,
-0.0269175395,
-0.0075904489,
-0.0132590011,
-0.0210335962,
-0.0294970982,
-0.0194558315,
-0.0099317534,
0.0116498871,
0.0317738838,
-0.0341964476,
0.0303569604,
0.0084725423,
-0.0845963433,
0.0752834156,
0.0306805149,
-0.0057800538,
0.0183712952,
-0.004645525,
-0.0113169989,
-0.0459488444,
0.0512994565,
0.0365562066,
-0.018069094,
0.0112559823,
-0.0655790865,
-0.0418326929,
-0.0251166429,
0.0060777976,
0.0768958256,
0.0996632129,
-0.0214288812,
0.0380466953,
-0.0735776424,
0.0473152027,
-0.0322144888,
0.0384391248,
-0.0489009656,
-0.0164282452,
-0.0183115136,
-0.0095477002,
-0.0361324996,
0.0359475687,
-0.0682629868,
-0.0071189245,
-0.0318045504,
0.0590645261,
-0.0031961168,
-0.0294628069,
0.0166770127,
-0.009772514,
-0.0297735464,
-0.0140249385,
-0.0233703498,
0.040939495,
-0.027045181,
0.0579700842,
0.0236521102,
-0.0618343316,
-0.0062257713,
0.0244263038,
0.0003930099,
-0.0381801389,
0.0243644286,
0.1031615883,
-0.0289525762,
-0.0451602414,
-0.0209182892,
0.0412285142,
0.0311543383,
-0.0720886588,
0.0239747502,
-0.036551699,
0.0623005666,
-0.0074990047,
0.0211697649,
-0.0372124724,
-0.0392215326,
0.0106231226,
-0.0240815356,
0.0617919452,
-0.009428232,
-0.0088384626,
0.062476743,
-0.0134891048,
-0.0497023016,
0.0880753696,
0.046812728,
-0.0132480543,
-0.0274652597,
-0.0067246361,
-0.0256264322,
0.0411016159,
-0.020211596,
-0.0165231191,
-0.0109567838,
0.0147651331,
0.0047380654,
0.0371873528,
0.0842212141,
0.0233303178,
-0.054502774,
0.0027626411,
0.0326363817,
0.0568044186,
0.0587828271,
0.0037600233,
0.052907493,
-0.0350618362,
0.0345947109,
0.017316319,
-0.0720314309,
0.0549715273,
-0.0169964861,
-0.0129639106,
0.0228923243,
0.0554880798,
-0.0456742197,
-0.0565187521,
0.0102685662,
0.0230667759,
-0.0442818515,
0.0096107563,
0.0512656495,
0.0019532305,
-0.0245344173,
0.0254766624,
0.0350729488,
-0.034947399,
0.0179181006,
-0.0899240747,
0.0563696437,
0.0568194054,
0.0256021339,
-0.0278550405,
-0.0646535754,
0.035559155,
0.0107215624,
0.0171520766,
0.0105967531,
0.0201910865,
0.0071971347,
-0.0804795474,
-0.0236530975,
0.0083311079,
0.0187113713,
0.035407722,
-0.003091143,
0.0167777818,
-0.003286588,
-0.0448652506,
-0.0114056291,
0.0464168712,
-0.0296956319,
0.0038085924,
0.0290351156,
0.0139750382,
0.0359869786,
-0.0068459231,
0.0040612188,
-0.0099955304,
0.0082184384,
-0.0437844023,
0.0121323271,
0.0125070214,
-0.055997666,
-0.0358515829,
0.0252538882,
-0.0171342939,
0.0224556737,
0.032036826,
-0.0146085313,
-0.0548147,
0.0441538468,
-0.0332752168,
0.0564064384,
-0.0159233771,
0.0198463351,
0.0221816227,
0.0360503569,
-0.0068004779,
0.031840954,
-0.0022272998,
-0.0146870008,
-0.0002592391,
0.0309599545,
-0.0166625977,
-0.0435506254,
-0.014313071,
-0.0167798139,
0.009371914,
0.0066359811,
-0.0296467897,
0.0042903498,
-0.0199452601,
-0.0813757628,
-0.0732343867,
-0.0009936523,
-0.028598763,
0.0631250665,
0.024701912,
0.0143810268,
-0.0170843154,
-0.0074399635,
-0.0177842285,
0.0365983993,
-0.0467788503,
0.0264785029,
-0.0172893293,
-0.0013933604,
-0.0285103079,
-0.0523184501,
-0.0223964769,
-0.0295193568,
0.0379112065,
-0.0212043244,
-0.0243263692,
-0.064731665,
-0.0408625714,
-0.023256937,
0.0129980119,
-0.0226317607,
-0.0058885859,
0.0234396271,
-0.0093702525,
0.0996105075,
0.080628328,
-0.024296267,
-0.0016709233,
0.0527442954,
0.0019385393,
-0.0448567942,
0.0370464213,
0.024775723,
-0.0151686342,
-0.0618004613,
-0.0005136681,
0.0043693529,
0.0591863692,
-0.021854667,
-0.0124179171,
-0.0564258844,
-0.0006665519,
-0.0150299668,
-0.0416310765,
0.0014147895,
0.0057135844,
-0.0120310541,
0.0131450519,
-0.0405254513,
-0.0210713204,
0.0477594025,
-0.0174862985,
-0.0158736892,
-0.0601173379,
-0.0258951131,
-0.0602474995,
0.0084111169,
0.0107311746,
0.0086330408,
-0.0323543437,
-0.0383880325,
-0.0382128209,
0.0112790074,
-0.0270289425,
0.0005620249,
0.0664458573,
-0.0653414428,
0.0186075922,
-0.0226082169,
-0.0234718025,
0.0140835606,
0.0316092633,
-0.0190608129,
0.0317745544,
0.0192919448,
-0.0189951807,
-0.0604810864,
0.0159193296,
0.021674227,
0.0874719545,
-0.034695372,
-0.0022009276,
-0.0439492688,
0.0245146602,
0.0362885185,
0.069409214,
0.0003538449,
-0.0331862755,
-0.0012802314,
-0.0073480997,
0.0554399379,
-0.0490342714,
-0.0338345133,
0.0562508181,
0.0391086563,
-0.027193632,
0.0014088491,
0.0111623686,
0.0564675368,
-0.054670617,
0.0003609034,
0.0744714588,
-0.0039175949,
-0.085328348,
-0.0106005855,
-0.0428844653,
0.0260841735,
0.0236457027,
0.0336212814,
-0.0507988296,
-0.0250751842,
0.0131011102,
0.0034864547,
-0.0007189682,
-0.0027048928,
-0.0225818716,
-0.0712086707,
0.0148897944,
-0.0031030141,
-0.087319389,
-0.0140942847,
-0.0389837585,
0.0320005603,
-0.0262169223,
0.0665656179,
0.011922108,
-0.0016452135,
-0.0154049275,
0.0331013277,
-0.0232335851,
-0.030945126,
-0.0174760949,
-0.0013419429,
0.0807557702,
0.0311404057,
-0.0248577725,
-0.0084024509,
-0.0072884625,
0.0470782742,
0.0000505881,
0.028399745,
-0.0139139025,
0.0129545219,
-0.0082618948,
-0.032602787,
0.0141373454,
0.0109350746,
-0.0330027752,
0.0200396664,
0.0212485231,
0.0891499817,
0.0048459992,
-0.0255283695,
-0.02192479,
-0.0452331379,
-0.0194963794,
0.0314745232,
0.0364259332,
-0.0541803986,
-0.0255356617,
-0.0161267109,
-0.0500353947,
-0.0358570628,
0.0004930703,
-0.0154887903,
-0.0070718885,
-0.0343773179,
-0.006123329,
-0.0149604054,
0.0721970871,
0.0849104151,
0.0121093784,
0.0078853238,
0.0006695686,
-0.0210328605,
-0.0210906174,
0.029642297,
-0.0594857,
-0.0141593916,
-0.0639170855,
-0.0294297282,
0.0211797655,
-0.0269282795,
-0.0123594999,
0.0179765094,
-0.0535662323,
-0.0662475601,
-0.0004532746,
0.0842330009,
0.0254579429,
0.0223612022,
-0.0062925909,
-0.0661359429,
0.0878195092,
0.0057646376,
-0.0361831225,
0.0724682361,
0.015205889,
-0.0181120932,
0.0045769559,
0.0335494019,
-0.0438734032,
0.0138492705,
0.0439695902,
0.0385861807,
0.0063537345,
0.0232445896,
-0.0165912192,
0.011453703,
-0.0072221719,
0.0237415377,
-0.0239014942,
-0.0464900397,
0.0644713342,
-0.0149985347,
0.0349487141,
-0.0135324607,
-0.0222810078,
0.015008376,
0.0139359646,
0.0038822319,
-0.0220058523,
0.0239092577,
-0.0007090045,
-0.0151622221,
0.0281088557,
0.0273184609,
0.0490308963,
0.0101610497,
0.0036376331,
-0.0314134583,
-0.0449968502,
0.0070625911,
0.0172590055,
-0.0392486677,
-0.0113893626,
-0.0196991134,
-0.0121244909,
-0.0332843103,
0.0475886501,
-0.0467293821,
-0.0589931756,
-0.0175769683,
0.0517447069,
0.040094126,
0.0303995274,
0.04883641,
0.027986683,
0.0063322783,
-0.004827769,
-0.0290357154,
-0.0096124988,
0.014419782,
0.0349946246,
0.0157672446,
0.0278217122,
-0.0256810468,
0.0492385551,
0.0061602267,
0.0711760297,
-0.0193447936,
0.0734491497,
-0.0299836397,
-0.0170333702,
0.0010007597,
0.0051646992,
-0.0097351866,
-0.0392496772,
0.008758951,
-0.0613197684,
0.0137599641,
-0.0077068661,
-0.0118048219,
-0.0135265747,
0.0124686696,
0.0525224768,
-0.0139955226,
-0.038508378,
0.015354949,
-0.023759013,
0.0155952526,
0.0086216237,
0.0111517813,
-6.926077367e-33,
-0.0468380265,
-0.0007538443,
0.0640309602,
-0.0357222632,
0.0037140572,
0.0161475521,
-0.0413663983,
-0.0145507893,
-0.033235155,
-0.0300064702,
-0.0151081085,
0.0062734173,
0.028267853,
-0.0025517361,
0.0284450818,
0.0268862713,
0.0488909595,
0.0081237312,
-0.0241637155,
-0.0051390319,
-0.0008165362,
0.0280526578,
0.0694231689,
-0.0269996952,
-0.013681137,
0.050209675,
0.0024583836,
0.0064555435,
-0.030200582,
0.0540560633,
-0.0286431015,
0.0674299151,
0.0301756319,
-0.0060349051,
-0.0329277478,
-0.00528026,
-0.0845412016,
-0.0617361031,
0.0463782586,
0.0191101804,
-0.0167344809,
-0.0630034953,
0.0940011591,
0.0332893059,
-0.0296271704,
-0.014582688,
0.0262875911,
-0.0041174092,
-0.0171975717,
0.0449297205,
-0.0668068081,
0.0149634024,
0.0204732325,
0.0305229109,
0.001911571,
0.0051501449,
-0.0203363951,
-0.0294013284,
-0.03726089,
0.0128281144,
0.0068285237,
0.0500890873,
0.0377153158,
0.0333913714,
-0.0095277177,
0.0113887321,
0.0646979064,
-0.0243124142,
0.0034222943,
-0.0372206084,
0.045748245,
-0.010336794,
0.0168255307,
-0.0082860254,
0.0154792657,
-0.0121836541,
-0.0634717718,
-0.0115910852,
0.0462725163,
0.0504346788,
0.0411423706,
0.0313624255,
-0.035280101,
0.0106328269,
-0.0177359115,
-0.0227654111,
-0.0622108579,
-0.0542529486,
0.0279564559,
0.0051286137,
-0.0036470171,
-0.0198016111,
0.0041789552,
-0.0208319277,
0.0348575413,
-0.0161355194,
0.0079247383,
0.0297892336,
0.0218220185,
0.0634515062,
-0.0829065293,
-0.0777062327,
0.024775723,
0.0023223564,
0.0072208229,
-0.0024879745,
-0.0037384331,
0.0415771417,
-0.0834241882,
-0.0320819244,
-0.0296312869,
-0.0134248761,
0.0506517552,
0.0764888525,
0.0293239206,
0.0105014192,
-0.0043812916,
-0.0043812003,
-0.0232073404,
-0.0211455896,
-0.014051998,
0.0185305048,
-0.0079233292,
0.0343793221,
-0.055403132,
0.000098923,
-0.0248870589,
0.0004814776,
-0.0280728731,
-0.0627414063,
-0.0187190548,
0.0430314802,
2.931e-7,
0.0169243608,
0.0349828973,
-0.0079308571,
-0.0327442922,
-0.011131756,
-0.0390110537,
-0.0048638936,
0.0263415202,
0.0326749198,
0.0228805542,
-0.0096002249,
0.0444316156,
-0.0161535181,
0.0079080304,
-0.0942032859,
0.0149966767,
-0.0088663707,
0.0534221679,
-0.0265438184,
-0.0062760944,
0.026842868,
0.110540621,
0.0107978294,
-0.0163039695,
-0.0199002586,
-0.039861992,
0.0284660887,
0.0053035091,
0.0014929245,
0.0298013724,
0.0440804809,
0.0328228474,
-0.0183123685,
0.0466125831,
0.0330269895,
0.0736519024,
-0.0244901888,
0.0382881872,
-0.0323377065,
-0.0266291909,
0.0344210044,
0.0343528576,
0.0072941133,
-0.0420257486,
0.0853168294,
-0.0392202586,
-0.0373674817,
-0.0130666913,
-0.017594032,
-0.0098046595,
-0.0057495912,
-0.0274617355,
-0.0012060511,
0.0179519448,
0.0286463685,
-0.0140100531,
-0.023043694,
-0.0772430971,
0.0201201346,
0.013897337,
-0.0476654246,
-0.0625796691,
-0.0699303746,
0.0175502487,
0.0570211969,
-0.0466833822,
0.0193664096,
2.325004537e-34,
0.0159205962,
0.0086629428,
0.0296403207,
0.0641564205,
-0.0057198834,
-0.0186089408,
-0.0410065576,
-0.0021921797,
0.0144290607,
-0.122036688,
-0.0279671401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10813v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10813v3 | A Language Agent for Autonomous Driving | 2023-11-17T18:59:56 | 2023-11-27T20:53:35 | Jiageng Mao, Junjie Ye, Yuxi Qian, Marco Pavone, Yue Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO | Human-level driving is an ultimate goal of autonomous driving. Conventional
approaches formulate autonomous driving as a perception-prediction-planning
framework, yet their systems do not capitalize on the inherent reasoning
ability and experiential knowledge of humans. In this paper, we propose a
fundamental paradigm shift from current pipelines, exploiting Large Language
Models (LLMs) as a cognitive agent to integrate human-like intelligence into
autonomous driving systems. Our approach, termed Agent-Driver, transforms the
traditional autonomous driving pipeline by introducing a versatile tool library
accessible via function calls, a cognitive memory of common sense and
experiential knowledge for decision-making, and a reasoning engine capable of
chain-of-thought reasoning, task planning, motion planning, and
self-reflection. Powered by LLMs, our Agent-Driver is endowed with intuitive
common sense and robust reasoning capabilities, thus enabling a more nuanced,
human-like approach to autonomous driving. We evaluate our approach on the
large-scale nuScenes benchmark, and extensive experiments substantiate that our
Agent-Driver significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art driving methods by
a large margin. Our approach also demonstrates superior interpretability and
few-shot learning ability to these methods. Code will be released. | [
0.0136914225,
0.040914163,
-0.0000346413,
0.0738467947,
-0.0296926536,
0.0206012614,
0.0129081421,
-0.0256156102,
0.0414121635,
-0.0152493175,
0.0181738995,
0.0414467156,
-0.0425023101,
0.0311822724,
0.0360988304,
-0.0187029298,
0.0187676996,
-0.0876161382,
0.010709337,
-0.0102916807,
-0.0366255119,
0.0105297258,
-0.0126715535,
0.0031870047,
-0.0372954383,
0.0034097156,
-0.012966658,
-0.0027920876,
0.0364868566,
0.0061520091,
-0.0337715335,
0.022503959,
0.0939960331,
0.012183045,
0.000002241,
-0.043384295,
0.0279135667,
-0.0117896637,
-0.0171758626,
-0.0547866598,
0.0473855324,
0.0502442941,
-0.0040959353,
0.012667845,
-0.0471590012,
0.0300897937,
-0.0004306058,
-0.0228353031,
0.0787614733,
0.0680835396,
0.0138129275,
-0.034278933,
0.0018905179,
0.0440181568,
0.0286622699,
-0.0388119072,
0.0173615906,
0.0163910519,
0.0048725782,
-0.0022266218,
-0.0053374399,
0.0077269692,
0.0549556613,
-0.0379095487,
0.001739154,
0.0630120188,
-0.0122670559,
-0.0418914072,
-0.0017744934,
0.041625578,
-0.0344555303,
-0.0831097588,
0.00854911,
0.0251707677,
-0.0425732285,
-0.029572079,
-0.03907023,
0.0230284426,
0.0120521709,
0.0236040633,
-0.0158446264,
0.001792949,
0.010011184,
0.0259245504,
-0.0436122939,
0.0825501084,
-0.0043160487,
0.0133517189,
0.0342653841,
-0.0029746545,
0.0164027773,
-0.050857354,
-0.0261889193,
0.0641350076,
-0.044007618,
0.0018111472,
0.0102233263,
0.0274717975,
-0.0095205503,
-0.0625503361,
0.024757389,
0.0378465503,
-0.0300892163,
0.064637728,
-0.024722686,
0.0424167365,
0.0471731573,
0.0375336818,
-0.0300703626,
-0.0295663569,
-0.0263723563,
0.0081620039,
-0.043083705,
0.0148401149,
0.0130814202,
0.0056562368,
0.0061873556,
0.0555877276,
-0.0027577905,
0.0509783663,
-0.0422423929,
0.0328403525,
0.0073511102,
-0.0482889935,
-0.0206954572,
-0.0249537677,
-0.0451739319,
-0.0035640521,
0.0183034167,
-0.0122550363,
0.0207608659,
0.0208432209,
-0.0358395614,
-0.0197502356,
0.0481293015,
0.1046254337,
-0.0206371341,
-0.0143579049,
-0.0395752825,
-0.0086679747,
0.0083661806,
-0.0864401981,
-0.0318294019,
-0.1015865952,
0.0301831458,
0.0351142101,
-0.052523382,
-0.0661204904,
0.01650149,
-0.0046278066,
-0.0034726055,
0.0738845319,
0.0055434224,
0.0056674494,
0.0316977389,
0.0141283693,
0.005236201,
0.0739031434,
0.0415738672,
0.051872883,
0.0113108763,
0.0468418784,
-0.0029213878,
-0.0010569842,
-0.0193322152,
0.0066347881,
-0.0265046228,
0.0163185224,
-0.0269130468,
0.0368543267,
0.02089612,
0.0401194952,
-0.0275945067,
-0.0466174334,
0.0346000753,
0.0531309731,
-0.048352506,
0.0310873967,
0.0522923246,
0.0550585724,
-0.0049273837,
-0.0822110325,
-0.0763396472,
0.0509484224,
-0.034507025,
-0.0068173581,
-0.0123866769,
0.0476983078,
-0.0135772238,
-0.0330028385,
0.008915077,
-0.0134198274,
0.0219940171,
0.0120828571,
0.0360427052,
-0.0518222377,
-0.0028864234,
0.0057990048,
-0.000088189,
-0.0005179674,
-0.0017430909,
-0.0557221957,
0.0151238013,
0.0663219839,
0.0127687426,
-0.0126217445,
-0.0575729199,
0.0124323284,
0.0245015081,
0.0119739743,
-0.0215894338,
0.0026056422,
0.0116189951,
-0.0322299227,
-0.024441015,
0.0363165885,
-0.0050932826,
-0.0014292358,
0.0185100324,
0.0157237183,
0.0194574073,
-0.0399477743,
0.0010590174,
0.0225437563,
0.0013644169,
-0.0154634453,
-0.0543417297,
0.0084548779,
-0.0069852616,
-0.0276935436,
-0.0125791552,
0.0147911059,
0.0302449055,
-0.0046653752,
-0.0394890048,
0.0425620861,
-0.0172902606,
0.0184560046,
0.0470130742,
-0.0286189243,
-0.0155721055,
0.0485761017,
-0.0427923091,
-0.0200002585,
-0.0286501087,
-0.0306408647,
-0.005186921,
-0.0060140104,
-0.000123798,
0.0341573469,
-0.0373545513,
-0.0089639435,
0.0624760948,
0.0023487129,
-0.0254834779,
0.0249341987,
0.0482916869,
0.0189171825,
-0.028257696,
-0.0097400043,
0.0056532351,
-0.0064500999,
-0.0235196669,
0.0096422601,
0.018635666,
-0.0288041849,
0.0025595874,
-0.0360928997,
-0.0211801771,
-0.0207604989,
-0.0295387991,
-0.019346375,
-0.027409872,
0.0157697406,
-0.0056459745,
0.0111732166,
0.061136242,
0.0156552661,
-0.0033278044,
0.016729746,
-0.0418981574,
-0.0366381295,
-0.0141381202,
-0.0041181748,
-0.0595182441,
0.0125301071,
0.0137017583,
-0.0268952791,
-0.0454000421,
0.0178348161,
-0.0601349138,
0.0569331869,
-0.024944067,
-0.054879345,
0.0280537158,
-0.0278099682,
0.0265556443,
0.1044640839,
0.0222921241,
-0.0263412781,
0.0412361734,
-0.0218682811,
-0.0544061065,
0.0305227153,
-0.0343482122,
-0.0055232118,
-0.0517018959,
0.0006540889,
-0.0430284962,
0.0350975804,
-0.010986086,
0.0144308833,
-0.0370135829,
0.0169745144,
-0.0103972526,
-0.0458524637,
-0.0355794281,
0.0215683617,
-0.0160080921,
0.0474842116,
-0.0243056696,
-0.0333631001,
0.0611076988,
-0.0157863554,
-0.0141075775,
0.0004245595,
-0.0130720641,
-0.0075576594,
0.0871918872,
0.0531046987,
0.0229554325,
-0.0244716126,
0.0585516021,
-0.0155127235,
-0.0048145889,
-0.0228568185,
-0.0190924853,
0.0609224327,
-0.0798972994,
0.0233559478,
-0.006411375,
-0.0696418658,
-0.0506048277,
-0.0012001242,
-0.0703407004,
0.0198545679,
-0.0282309689,
-0.0377377681,
-0.0109413899,
0.0046749385,
0.0466697626,
0.0709546134,
0.0167554971,
-0.0238154121,
-0.0130510321,
-0.0410731323,
0.0620265454,
0.0205011424,
0.0221256223,
0.0165628549,
0.0824838653,
0.0540364757,
0.0320496261,
-0.0169733521,
-0.0560514331,
0.0138113443,
0.0124557465,
-0.0301790368,
0.0180718489,
0.0754532665,
0.0465029776,
-0.0722120404,
-0.0775584951,
0.0994629636,
0.0161684155,
-0.0133582857,
0.0157522,
-0.0383111015,
0.0044232998,
0.0369626358,
0.0409952961,
-0.0495611317,
-0.0650620684,
0.0037454488,
-0.0173272341,
-0.0011508915,
-0.0199082196,
0.0280263275,
-0.0658522248,
0.0377976224,
0.0043113767,
-0.0311959386,
-0.0056539192,
-0.0407248177,
-0.0363233276,
-0.0215469543,
-0.0288479421,
0.0352045782,
0.0089816228,
-0.0193663128,
-0.0110945264,
0.0228492655,
-0.0003972834,
0.0436188243,
-0.0340242274,
0.0387867242,
0.0701007992,
0.0063932096,
-0.0107028103,
-0.0600947738,
0.0090802703,
0.0177207347,
0.0032992144,
-0.0417247638,
0.0040113851,
-0.0504419878,
0.005029514,
-0.0048258468,
0.039060425,
-0.0574853644,
-0.0299513377,
-0.0187643431,
0.0952908173,
-0.0495371148,
-0.0072299661,
-0.0421860702,
0.0349246152,
-0.0295322351,
0.0858395323,
-0.0157294944,
-0.013995978,
-0.042031303,
-0.038272392,
-0.0854658261,
-0.0021807768,
-0.0876143128,
-0.031767495,
0.0316532701,
-0.0176620167,
-0.0044384426,
-0.0387777202,
0.0290580485,
-0.0080368733,
-0.018869672,
-0.0129206832,
0.0376814008,
-0.0152723612,
-0.061747767,
-0.0092700198,
-0.0320014991,
0.0166463796,
-0.010191747,
0.0139528802,
0.0305166692,
-0.0397468805,
-0.0527037568,
0.0266166404,
-0.0740202144,
-0.06331788,
0.0375295728,
0.0652003586,
0.0222140905,
0.0383988321,
-0.0580780245,
-0.0276931524,
0.0657583401,
0.0240148474,
-0.007843853,
0.0408934243,
-0.0039087883,
0.0251596309,
0.0325843208,
0.0662199408,
-0.0624839403,
0.0370377824,
0.0165784489,
-0.0189022403,
-0.0485760868,
-0.0088237878,
0.0254913215,
0.0097184898,
0.0249811336,
-0.0027331014,
0.0547954775,
-0.0046189735,
0.013744846,
-0.0183068365,
-0.012587525,
-0.0463682078,
0.0347546376,
-0.0285600647,
0.0185974203,
0.0178229809,
-0.0182771962,
0.0428925753,
-0.0082503594,
0.0397232138,
0.0177654102,
0.0468756631,
0.0097207325,
0.0248988625,
-0.0327959508,
0.011967429,
0.0059984401,
-0.0153051317,
0.0348899104,
-0.0153287724,
0.0927031487,
0.0420765579,
-0.0568470433,
-0.0042561246,
0.0031429667,
-0.0628803745,
-0.1305312961,
-0.0164511409,
0.0461342894,
0.0446905345,
0.0223871283,
0.0122454194,
-0.0986719355,
0.0106074512,
0.003104897,
0.0143316993,
0.0486554727,
-0.0224536099,
0.0414603166,
0.0157470759,
-0.0295011103,
-0.0350417495,
0.0425908342,
-0.0102363192,
0.0375324413,
0.0291065555,
-0.0196708962,
-0.0396818332,
-0.0383707732,
-0.0082281474,
-0.0101615125,
-0.0038478877,
-0.0041352138,
-0.0417954437,
-0.0448888279,
-0.0114395991,
0.0793074891,
0.0215560645,
-0.0198992472,
0.0140069919,
0.0058361455,
0.0249002595,
-0.0822614208,
0.0222863313,
0.0073622512,
-0.0353499874,
-0.0306815002,
-0.0161626004,
-6.516109753e-33,
-0.0338876769,
0.0060772104,
0.0713183582,
-0.0263231155,
-0.0102904197,
-0.0446437337,
-0.0579916239,
0.0081531303,
-0.0100298943,
0.0107397884,
0.0092969956,
0.0366407149,
0.0126892645,
0.014348859,
0.0516132377,
-0.0206979364,
0.006521977,
0.0113284662,
-0.0247421768,
0.0053194687,
0.0183903817,
-0.0020651114,
-0.0054682745,
-0.0202349182,
-0.0316364616,
-0.0234660078,
0.0079604238,
0.0770847872,
-0.0210327674,
0.0236872714,
0.0107097309,
0.0026218514,
0.0150092784,
-0.0359901562,
-0.0038032564,
-0.008518477,
-0.0370681994,
-0.0155177983,
0.0070550791,
0.0362580307,
-0.0597036071,
-0.0353899412,
0.0530292615,
-0.0217682552,
-0.0216222052,
0.0132454988,
0.0388562605,
-0.0245522615,
0.0146120936,
0.0100488067,
-0.0502772108,
0.0015797366,
0.0054303245,
-0.0300317407,
0.0118279019,
0.0072457632,
-0.0255892854,
0.0221317708,
-0.0539401658,
-0.0186273623,
-0.0439959057,
0.0132413004,
0.0770147368,
-0.0002461522,
0.0278151687,
0.0303753838,
0.0363223739,
-0.0256488901,
-0.0501398742,
0.0276002362,
0.011463291,
0.0784626305,
0.011539733,
0.0613149926,
-0.0293183085,
-0.0036180506,
-0.069571957,
0.0240855478,
-0.0083183767,
0.0516440719,
0.0559049286,
0.0104132574,
-0.0658900216,
0.005361218,
-0.0293310191,
-0.0029056133,
-0.029611459,
-0.0241011437,
0.0170995761,
0.0022527904,
-0.0351492912,
-0.0393684655,
0.0484335534,
-0.0634917319,
0.0292111766,
0.012281077,
-0.0309793595,
0.0076892944,
-0.0187778939,
0.0398214534,
-0.0807961151,
-0.015796721,
-0.0148083782,
-0.0040315916,
0.0266478527,
0.0075212517,
-0.018564241,
0.0335461572,
-0.0137396259,
-0.005247192,
-0.0875569433,
-0.013173027,
0.0637340993,
0.0059493426,
0.0461243764,
0.019314833,
-0.0067040958,
0.012400791,
-0.0330820456,
-0.0652528107,
0.008177272,
0.0122921756,
0.0175547805,
-0.0092889266,
-0.0229351278,
0.0217938703,
-0.0435537472,
-0.0080339527,
-0.0056650499,
-0.0439236537,
0.0181194842,
0.033540953,
2.899e-7,
-0.0306296516,
0.0340457074,
-0.0209542867,
0.0482377969,
0.0274434239,
0.0771850869,
0.0023807413,
0.0164534189,
-0.0137291271,
-0.0004720433,
-0.0035463544,
0.1069391742,
0.0256554633,
0.007280604,
-0.0408371501,
0.0270978492,
0.0215760823,
-0.0372450612,
-0.0555309244,
-0.0026303658,
0.0658563673,
0.0753668025,
0.0362937897,
-0.0147626912,
0.0335545503,
-0.0196672101,
0.0319153853,
-0.0470470823,
0.022713514,
-0.0195293538,
-0.0048234044,
0.0342014953,
0.0006219284,
0.0563849062,
0.0121866083,
-0.0047820616,
-0.0521961935,
0.0793744549,
0.0142814508,
-0.0308583602,
0.0076238904,
-0.0610730052,
0.0210356396,
-0.0625282377,
0.0552622527,
-0.0322957076,
-0.0051505258,
-0.0299419928,
-0.0041563278,
-0.0214850735,
-0.0523579754,
0.0132560544,
-0.0099682407,
-0.0198787376,
0.0282849595,
-0.0380699039,
0.0158882216,
-0.0586502962,
-0.0174644161,
0.0117922481,
-0.0247374978,
-0.0202080309,
-0.0293264538,
0.0376976505,
0.0365157276,
-0.0442514271,
-0.0392207354,
2.453539563e-34,
0.0079679536,
0.0226548612,
-0.0152579779,
-0.0133835953,
0.0325318836,
0.0294666905,
-0.0368521959,
0.0091917636,
0.0122695304,
-0.0217087567,
-0.0283917654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10702v2 | Camels in a Changing Climate: Enhancing LM Adaptation with Tulu 2 | 2023-11-17T18:45:45 | 2023-11-20T02:01:33 | Hamish Ivison, Yizhong Wang, Valentina Pyatkin, Nathan Lambert, Matthew Peters, Pradeep Dasigi, Joel Jang, David Wadden, Noah A. Smith, Iz Beltagy, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since the release of T\"ULU [Wang et al., 2023b], open resources for
instruction tuning have developed quickly, from better base models to new
finetuning techniques. We test and incorporate a number of these advances into
T\"ULU, resulting in T\"ULU 2, a suite of improved T\"ULU models for advancing
the understanding and best practices of adapting pretrained language models to
downstream tasks and user preferences. Concretely, we release: (1)
T\"ULU-V2-mix, an improved collection of high-quality instruction datasets; (2)
T\"ULU 2, LLAMA-2 models finetuned on the V2 mixture; (3) T\"ULU 2+DPO, T\"ULU
2 models trained with direct preference optimization (DPO), including the
largest DPO-trained model to date (T\"ULU 2+DPO 70B); (4) CODE T\"ULU 2, CODE
LLAMA models finetuned on our V2 mix that outperform CODE LLAMA and its
instruction-tuned variant, CODE LLAMA-Instruct. Our evaluation from multiple
perspectives shows that the T\"ULU 2 suite achieves state-of-the-art
performance among open models and matches or exceeds the performance of
GPT-3.5-turbo-0301 on several benchmarks. We release all the checkpoints, data,
training and evaluation code to facilitate future open efforts on adapting
large language models. | [
0.0400329158,
0.0452715866,
-0.0080315694,
0.0244939327,
0.0282671396,
0.043566335,
-0.0046591549,
-0.0174458362,
-0.0378811397,
-0.0510474816,
-0.0746810958,
-0.0230914038,
-0.0164321996,
0.012850021,
0.0169518646,
-0.0826354027,
0.056176424,
-0.0618689097,
-0.0452802591,
-0.0007126855,
-0.006370014,
0.020676028,
0.0031310348,
0.015457659,
0.0530159622,
-0.0100653665,
-0.0076800161,
0.0267985612,
0.0134702828,
-0.0032633028,
0.0445936546,
0.0397899076,
0.0386988781,
-0.0257756207,
0.0000024958,
-0.0444361866,
-0.0163028911,
-0.0420483202,
-0.0352985263,
0.0496911518,
0.0565918386,
0.0353892036,
-0.026091909,
0.039823845,
-0.0140124746,
0.0329179652,
0.0365822539,
0.0081922226,
0.0391072184,
0.0788815767,
0.0119707007,
-0.0022248446,
0.0021098806,
-0.0337767117,
-0.0013035395,
-0.0306732859,
0.013151004,
-0.0495059639,
0.0041449508,
0.0024613175,
-0.0391489267,
-0.0149800126,
0.0025951865,
0.0207144674,
-0.0287923478,
0.0320096947,
-0.0197521225,
0.00198148,
-0.0438373275,
0.0511998869,
-0.0308087245,
-0.0037990978,
-0.0118000135,
-0.0123376679,
-0.0221428368,
-0.0500019863,
-0.0222487338,
-0.0053602066,
0.0100500546,
0.0083992537,
0.0450876243,
-0.0158310812,
0.0197943971,
0.0123589514,
-0.0304983892,
0.0814621449,
0.0176943131,
-0.0266032908,
0.0124811819,
0.0016707587,
0.0135304146,
-0.0442146547,
0.0135096479,
0.0503021143,
-0.0374051742,
0.0099890819,
-0.0671413168,
0.0071874848,
-0.0211219639,
-0.0445690788,
0.1289050579,
0.0711143687,
-0.0346024185,
-0.0025094382,
-0.0152020175,
0.046295356,
-0.0127233304,
0.0334767997,
-0.0424206704,
0.0387037918,
-0.033026807,
0.0167998821,
-0.0187197011,
0.0080290418,
-0.0533595607,
0.0306646489,
-0.0222212709,
0.069168672,
0.0210562702,
-0.0391333401,
0.0207188334,
-0.0200162642,
-0.068949379,
0.0083523737,
-0.0327725783,
0.0415961817,
-0.0304753296,
0.0482211374,
0.0118343066,
-0.0793778077,
0.0152711691,
0.0139552299,
-0.0199189316,
-0.0365767851,
0.0449090675,
0.0748921335,
-0.0242708288,
-0.0095284889,
-0.055894576,
0.0151619809,
-0.0040225522,
-0.045162417,
0.0080077825,
-0.0511341728,
0.0129217599,
-0.0144847119,
0.0186433028,
-0.0256434623,
-0.0008108064,
0.0189602505,
-0.0255340301,
0.0299518853,
0.0052236863,
-0.0064603551,
0.005445194,
-0.0023796253,
0.0130135193,
0.0641953126,
0.041374445,
0.0663844272,
0.02394218,
-0.0168182906,
-0.0207295511,
0.0378830917,
-0.0196206979,
0.0281836875,
0.0016346567,
0.0159852058,
0.0466288216,
0.0037417442,
0.0824072585,
0.0343358032,
0.009817047,
0.0037576302,
0.0950021073,
0.0027158884,
0.022784356,
-0.027744066,
0.062141791,
0.0029953727,
-0.0183015335,
0.0071232081,
-0.0531652346,
0.0302442573,
-0.0264302287,
0.0015925639,
0.0173901245,
0.0677674636,
-0.0279593337,
-0.0644378513,
-0.0061346442,
-0.0053214678,
-0.0130281262,
0.0072094821,
0.0175717659,
-0.0322188511,
-0.0666293576,
0.0150572937,
0.0384658314,
-0.0433774814,
0.0180312805,
-0.0742902979,
-0.003549489,
0.097427167,
0.0190791618,
0.0151319904,
-0.0561443716,
-0.0049189036,
0.0316380039,
0.0269795787,
0.062414594,
-0.0082691908,
0.0262700506,
-0.0735778734,
-0.0227049384,
-0.0266101509,
-0.0082703847,
0.0329029262,
-0.0099843442,
-0.0069051851,
0.0022330908,
0.0144848637,
-0.0537724942,
0.0535893179,
-0.0212235861,
-0.0410779379,
0.0118422993,
0.0063666515,
0.0399497487,
-0.007558322,
-0.0175823551,
-0.0173385143,
0.0438516624,
-0.0159522239,
0.0214786083,
0.0058849016,
-0.0664093718,
-0.0116903223,
0.0430009104,
0.0437264964,
0.0163528621,
0.0472053252,
-0.0472542495,
-0.0393290706,
0.0088916691,
-0.0034997191,
0.0454440415,
-0.0129364254,
0.0363376923,
-0.0064532883,
-0.0011080554,
-0.0437892154,
0.0358113497,
-0.0258729998,
-0.0275686514,
0.019062724,
0.0046020416,
-0.0023515099,
-0.04064022,
-0.012378295,
0.0185954757,
0.0028970523,
0.0168481171,
-0.011139974,
0.0596727878,
-0.0251568984,
-0.0393489152,
-0.0569778048,
0.0419899076,
-0.0546682663,
0.0623814911,
0.0371254794,
0.0055992007,
-0.0397046544,
-0.0165297166,
0.0140750054,
-0.0133872218,
-0.0388154313,
0.0054160189,
0.0250614323,
0.0258574858,
-0.0261413176,
-0.0514766909,
-0.0101545984,
-0.0076862462,
-0.0195546001,
-0.0554909781,
-0.0165246688,
-0.0324491598,
0.0480404757,
-0.008146679,
0.0383280627,
-0.0083011976,
-0.0535415336,
0.0179867651,
0.0208061486,
0.0766724199,
0.0930530354,
0.0124102514,
0.0220239479,
0.0696129724,
-0.0054368391,
-0.0318691768,
0.0421324335,
-0.0117679453,
-0.0864738449,
-0.049090445,
-0.0235140417,
0.027479019,
0.0908328667,
-0.0297840703,
-0.0076160161,
-0.0500562489,
-0.0257328842,
-0.0222436562,
-0.0305487383,
0.0219038557,
0.017671138,
-0.0370314494,
0.0227541514,
-0.0477241613,
-0.0597507358,
0.0386539549,
-0.0291463863,
0.0012613909,
-0.0845829397,
-0.0169820096,
-0.037712127,
-0.0014973035,
-0.0026010277,
0.0059854947,
-0.0222236589,
-0.0086398656,
-0.0599725395,
0.0068628481,
-0.020338865,
-0.0014888031,
0.0246254355,
-0.0545536913,
-0.0051442562,
-0.024054626,
-0.0466632023,
-0.0047362116,
0.0251728017,
-0.0232344624,
-0.0016576666,
0.0192916896,
-0.0263991151,
-0.0291826036,
-0.0300699864,
0.0062275939,
0.0610009059,
-0.031015547,
0.0024485041,
-0.0378813632,
-0.0397934914,
0.0525883287,
0.0244772956,
-0.0283528958,
-0.0441683941,
-0.0106916102,
0.0266707148,
0.0496347547,
-0.053021092,
-0.0143191414,
0.038944196,
0.0631566271,
-0.04414149,
-0.0257200263,
0.0689833239,
0.0694267675,
-0.0636169687,
-0.0135875577,
0.0899907798,
0.0160286799,
-0.0491671078,
0.0075356681,
-0.0085342415,
0.0487040877,
0.0380847603,
0.0477173775,
-0.0407621674,
-0.0415489078,
0.0088726608,
0.0616203621,
0.0035424214,
0.0248491336,
0.0087245982,
-0.0955178738,
0.0242455658,
0.0123601025,
-0.0457283594,
0.0132022053,
-0.0569377393,
0.0057635107,
-0.0157500245,
0.0124754403,
0.007581742,
-0.0427472368,
0.0051196339,
0.0573646761,
0.0062662843,
-0.0728453398,
0.034779381,
-0.0236990154,
0.0497965552,
0.0953262523,
-0.0089784069,
0.0059924787,
-0.0331456661,
0.0486244261,
-0.0027716423,
0.0276966747,
-0.0373071916,
0.0064804391,
-0.0456785075,
-0.0060632089,
0.0017922516,
0.0264053307,
-0.0277492963,
0.0198353752,
0.0075844019,
0.0393046066,
-0.0183332954,
0.0106182434,
-0.0238401387,
-0.0223392826,
-0.0029083891,
0.0389238745,
0.0192062203,
-0.0727844164,
-0.0284235794,
-0.0462062433,
-0.0481141321,
-0.0936221927,
-0.0186566394,
-0.0039631729,
-0.0558178872,
-0.0070575434,
-0.0429992601,
-0.0408302583,
0.0335537419,
0.0113191484,
0.0166813545,
0.0014074116,
0.000145847,
-0.019753078,
-0.0588205233,
0.0242459718,
-0.0279093031,
0.0346206166,
-0.1098004356,
-0.0437595621,
0.0255713519,
0.00786536,
-0.0030103456,
0.0026652024,
-0.0707444549,
-0.0697711408,
0.0274837371,
0.103950344,
0.0126830358,
0.0154918544,
0.0347696431,
-0.0478288755,
-0.0035708847,
0.0263570622,
0.0004299981,
0.047956787,
0.0320035517,
-0.0057647075,
-0.0109246103,
0.014218146,
-0.0495447703,
0.0238710567,
0.0327817909,
0.027967561,
0.0247412156,
-0.0250391401,
-0.0017367833,
-0.027468713,
0.0201577619,
-0.0105294175,
-0.0514608137,
-0.0373734906,
0.0509348698,
0.0145627474,
0.0175358802,
-0.0273827184,
-0.0183328968,
0.0164597295,
0.0405272208,
0.0024172757,
-0.0184279177,
0.003098157,
0.0112357754,
-0.0590406545,
0.0359648615,
0.0314236395,
0.0535242595,
0.0076292767,
0.041685991,
-0.0310351569,
0.004109988,
0.0133310966,
0.0472041257,
-0.0014008426,
0.0558377355,
-0.0151445298,
0.0242683403,
-0.0231607072,
0.0668184459,
-0.0399267003,
-0.0261389576,
-0.08075279,
-0.0068464447,
0.0312787555,
-0.014073967,
0.0242907554,
0.0049579516,
0.0037589059,
-0.0435454622,
-0.0018355886,
-0.0278646313,
-0.0033391924,
0.0085381642,
0.0044508884,
-0.0153621966,
0.0000034024,
0.0583157055,
0.0268348157,
0.0893739015,
0.0127866548,
0.0235997271,
-0.0140482513,
-0.0031739115,
0.0241534766,
0.0210542176,
-0.0113430303,
-0.0165064465,
-0.0015260077,
-0.033569213,
-0.0126965092,
0.0169183891,
0.0134438965,
-0.0308747292,
0.0514399186,
0.028587753,
-0.0162619464,
-0.0246691927,
-0.0318772458,
-0.0271338262,
-0.0079362672,
0.000576476,
0.0065126666,
-7.203660073e-33,
-0.0426253788,
0.0505283847,
0.0281618107,
0.0045171147,
-0.0130974324,
-0.0191164538,
-0.0007037853,
-0.0054004667,
-0.047697138,
-0.0388022102,
-0.0109841814,
-0.0072980854,
0.0164906643,
0.0008925481,
0.032693617,
0.0332062282,
0.0460928231,
-0.0190158263,
-0.0544750504,
0.0072348597,
0.0342654549,
0.029199345,
0.0851959437,
-0.0466357768,
-0.0109365163,
0.0002473932,
0.0164586455,
-0.0033595681,
-0.0261345878,
0.0542055331,
-0.0141006205,
0.0252446271,
0.0145391459,
-0.0193659477,
-0.0549995601,
-0.0196393467,
-0.0542530194,
-0.0312163234,
0.0229284242,
0.0058913166,
0.0006954208,
-0.0691183731,
0.0121631455,
0.0311484504,
-0.0493874513,
-0.0022310955,
0.0073075509,
-0.0207030289,
-0.0079711955,
-0.0025690475,
-0.0626978725,
0.0043806341,
0.0216762815,
-0.0328445844,
-0.0186442118,
0.0232611205,
-0.0056803445,
-0.0027850361,
-0.0489716865,
0.0430144891,
0.0526504219,
0.0857888013,
0.105021365,
0.0368690938,
-0.0190392844,
0.0122316508,
0.0006340051,
0.0249978192,
0.0184968319,
-0.0158901047,
0.0460958257,
0.0281619802,
0.0057276278,
-0.0156968646,
0.0285146963,
-0.0321392231,
-0.0415475257,
0.0523971543,
0.0627968758,
0.0408514813,
0.0195653755,
0.0485956222,
-0.0297471993,
-0.020525014,
-0.0214031786,
0.0130093386,
-0.0153520145,
-0.0383066274,
0.0716195926,
0.0125648174,
-0.0131381629,
-0.0096092597,
0.0356924981,
0.0031756503,
0.0227189213,
-0.0336373858,
-0.0300644077,
0.017886417,
0.0061449562,
0.0167699102,
-0.0928032771,
-0.0803747103,
0.0194568019,
-0.0018838906,
0.0113473274,
-0.0026215166,
0.0134136928,
0.0482483804,
-0.05603626,
0.0095301634,
-0.0256648753,
-0.008740901,
0.0377389789,
0.0487780832,
0.0230136719,
-0.0200064201,
-0.00222149,
0.0755533427,
-0.0157983061,
-0.0616495013,
-0.0500043295,
-0.0382879712,
0.0206647906,
0.027624853,
-0.0161369685,
0.0200880207,
-0.0536600202,
0.0321944691,
-0.0379507132,
-0.0389525518,
-0.0369669721,
0.0046089008,
3.121e-7,
0.0367392264,
0.0601111874,
0.0159047302,
0.0074214721,
-0.0228252579,
0.0140111381,
-0.0350042284,
0.0253824051,
0.0196677577,
0.0223392043,
0.0011073658,
0.0224913545,
0.0250458214,
-0.0087776836,
-0.0277860463,
-0.0391311795,
-0.0118573774,
0.0398552269,
-0.070687376,
-0.0405610614,
0.0219908115,
0.0889152214,
-0.0093182651,
0.0071406187,
0.0134399394,
-0.0011745353,
0.0335460231,
-0.0495327748,
0.0049452237,
0.0264856629,
0.0183417536,
0.0265106931,
-0.0482513346,
-0.0211700778,
-0.0201365054,
0.0352228619,
-0.0251879133,
0.0932073221,
-0.0244924333,
-0.0480282083,
0.0521897674,
0.0242344402,
-0.0178365428,
-0.0534050651,
0.0599991269,
-0.0111959828,
-0.0075558326,
-0.0174969267,
-0.0032601489,
0.0093334485,
0.003429177,
-0.0424917005,
0.0135498568,
0.0144516202,
0.0124654733,
0.0089352764,
-0.078156583,
-0.0634844378,
0.0038116085,
0.0111846467,
-0.02417464,
-0.0586501434,
-0.0965121537,
0.033363957,
0.0051157516,
-0.0256203096,
-0.0066578588,
2.977772162e-34,
0.0189293977,
-0.0185443219,
0.0351197906,
0.0212036557,
-0.001362758,
0.0120457644,
-0.0209481046,
0.0187520385,
0.0089588948,
-0.0701274499,
-0.0296146646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10697v1 | PEFT-MedAware: Large Language Model for Medical Awareness | 2023-11-17T18:32:17 | 2023-11-17T18:32:17 | Keivalya Pandya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Chat models are capable of answering a wide range of questions, however, the
accuracy of their responses is highly uncertain. In this research, we propose a
specialized PEFT-MedAware model where we utilize parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT) to enhance the Falcon-1b large language model on specialized
MedQuAD data consisting of 16,407 medical QA pairs, leveraging only 0.44% of
its trainable parameters to enhance computational efficiency. The paper adopts
data preprocessing and PEFT to optimize model performance, complemented by a
BitsAndBytesConfig for efficient transformer training. The resulting model was
capable of outperforming other LLMs in medical question-answering tasks in
specific domains with greater accuracy utilizing limited computational
resources making it suitable for deployment in resource-constrained
environments. We propose further improvements through expanded datasets, larger
models, and feedback mechanisms for sustained medical relevancy. Our work
highlights the efficiency gains and specialized capabilities of PEFT in medical
AI, outpacing standard models in precision without extensive resource demands.
The proposed model and data are released for research purposes only. | [
0.0549877025,
0.0346295275,
-0.0111285904,
-0.0056693568,
0.010200778,
0.0356789343,
-0.0194684956,
0.0240202043,
-0.0157452952,
-0.03843458,
-0.0327452756,
-0.0541351922,
0.0033792863,
0.0495487154,
0.0165465623,
-0.0207301527,
0.0535975024,
-0.0008242665,
0.019222036,
-0.0063423011,
-0.0270296689,
0.011554624,
-0.0523209795,
0.0647362396,
0.0245344453,
0.0120241661,
0.0242642649,
-0.0006469265,
0.0241911169,
-0.0363399126,
0.023397889,
0.0582887232,
-0.0107540647,
-0.0106653133,
0.0000021559,
-0.0492045879,
-0.0163721107,
0.0193232279,
-0.0698371455,
-0.0555962808,
0.0282216594,
-0.0193929784,
0.003920469,
0.0504242741,
-0.0388988219,
-0.0275185369,
0.0334550813,
0.0542111844,
0.0562039241,
0.073713854,
-0.007966687,
0.0115802046,
0.0509418957,
-0.0119750993,
0.0148031963,
-0.0542828962,
0.026670238,
-0.0018839932,
0.0160266925,
-0.007607962,
-0.0088462932,
0.0422933102,
-0.0130047686,
0.0341509059,
0.0145885963,
0.0158100743,
-0.0453828126,
-0.0290951002,
-0.0086035375,
0.0678070486,
-0.0211672429,
-0.0045269914,
0.0108445128,
0.0127392979,
-0.0113314176,
-0.0204389077,
-0.0589155219,
-0.0108768605,
-0.0112936851,
-0.0111777419,
0.0079736002,
-0.0331806801,
0.0220944081,
0.0034401452,
-0.0252043512,
0.0051131281,
0.012699144,
-0.0009753962,
-0.0005584401,
-0.0387066156,
-0.031740088,
-0.0494476296,
0.012515706,
0.0709637254,
-0.0641048178,
-0.0082187783,
-0.0295778327,
-0.0212853681,
0.0630387217,
-0.0267131198,
0.0069090384,
0.0376242623,
-0.0055675865,
0.0356375948,
-0.0035573128,
0.0102073271,
-0.0235822964,
0.0357545651,
-0.0425319821,
-0.0198523328,
-0.0403628983,
0.0103941448,
-0.0498542562,
0.018711986,
-0.0140860379,
-0.0094007496,
-0.0679631084,
-0.0080815023,
0.013523954,
0.0190206058,
0.0312609039,
0.0423605293,
-0.0437762067,
-0.0006821323,
-0.0059451088,
0.0585017726,
-0.009148065,
0.0165640377,
-0.0194219071,
-0.088501364,
0.0030404418,
0.0033619825,
0.0107580209,
-0.0121377697,
0.0353888571,
0.0562368743,
-0.0000063477,
-0.0410080515,
0.0085459389,
-0.0230262224,
-0.0201646574,
-0.0521897525,
0.0036811042,
-0.0486830622,
0.0207418613,
0.0285553411,
0.0301648863,
-0.0137052275,
0.0211945921,
0.0134298913,
-0.0585800782,
0.0733410642,
-0.034967754,
0.0291644745,
0.033229664,
0.0112958886,
0.0042259162,
0.0389267877,
0.0367006548,
-0.0266003516,
0.0057359189,
-0.0485754386,
-0.0036903499,
-0.0013796797,
0.0076152361,
-0.038460575,
0.0083498843,
0.0378151871,
-0.0142547516,
0.0644006804,
-0.0385020897,
0.0560527407,
0.0110627254,
-0.016055597,
0.0227849837,
0.0700363293,
0.0387697406,
0.0260939281,
-0.0092690177,
-0.0020531039,
0.0370593853,
-0.06024215,
-0.0270106606,
0.0479954593,
0.0056191334,
-0.0100725936,
-0.0152618745,
0.0341956429,
-0.0468472838,
-0.0276155919,
-0.033729881,
-0.0259189997,
-0.0345511436,
0.0243835654,
0.0293535329,
-0.0045851208,
-0.0252853688,
0.1010903344,
0.05105149,
-0.0117636314,
-0.0378680192,
-0.0847860426,
-0.0151147246,
0.0553041138,
0.0466709584,
-0.0299670435,
-0.0748148635,
-0.0436401367,
0.0350117125,
0.0102278972,
0.0373739675,
-0.0057035834,
0.0103186741,
-0.0552215762,
-0.0152078765,
0.0109804226,
-0.0039477078,
-0.0492773838,
0.0275268685,
0.0086661913,
-0.0245179329,
-0.0342650674,
-0.0032775572,
0.0300050583,
-0.0509543046,
-0.0050698374,
0.0100499587,
0.0029307974,
0.038386222,
0.0029476723,
-0.0054287296,
0.0092550041,
0.031203635,
-0.0096573969,
-0.0141405202,
0.0040232856,
-0.0110611385,
-0.007752703,
0.0289869327,
-0.0024882909,
-0.017030878,
0.028260991,
-0.0437635183,
-0.0436135009,
-0.0354118273,
-0.0730202124,
0.0401710272,
-0.00410455,
0.0193720143,
-0.0026700236,
-0.0009424546,
-0.0477356575,
-0.0175692625,
-0.0318989344,
0.004310458,
0.0011845827,
0.0036907352,
0.0254524648,
-0.0357113816,
-0.024322873,
0.0092505477,
-0.0158030186,
0.008367043,
-0.0193574335,
0.0233176798,
-0.0342483334,
-0.060438171,
-0.1177482158,
0.0148774721,
-0.0020350087,
-0.0044199098,
0.0278862808,
0.0397470519,
-0.0043871473,
-0.0239289086,
-0.0536549501,
0.0437737405,
0.0361447632,
0.0218924228,
0.0399548523,
0.0238571707,
-0.0171185508,
-0.0511747114,
-0.0059125433,
-0.0229311902,
0.0089242645,
0.0215114728,
-0.0007313822,
-0.0129765458,
-0.0120818857,
-0.0429702066,
0.0195954815,
-0.021647105,
-0.0671247616,
0.0100586154,
-0.0321598016,
-0.0263839122,
0.0524595864,
0.0150511106,
0.0033298903,
0.01058596,
0.0376303978,
-0.0204035789,
0.0394608974,
-0.0492636301,
-0.0825870484,
-0.004600707,
-0.0099763675,
-0.0087720091,
0.0708692595,
-0.0050323503,
0.0151344398,
-0.0347056687,
0.0063724793,
0.001491749,
0.0100628603,
-0.0212095026,
0.0599653423,
-0.0190800466,
0.0367729403,
-0.0004352091,
-0.0567597225,
0.0898838788,
0.0126208654,
0.0124734342,
-0.0607249252,
-0.0394798629,
-0.0480333939,
-0.0172308199,
-0.0176678523,
0.0405806787,
-0.0117057655,
-0.0222110245,
-0.0422728322,
-0.0037969844,
-0.041315224,
-0.0808784366,
0.0603663996,
0.0035018432,
0.0124149127,
-0.0020595093,
-0.055785913,
-0.0576443933,
-0.0096185701,
-0.0394396409,
0.0098409187,
0.0089228638,
-0.0246806536,
-0.0663699508,
0.0322590582,
0.007901256,
0.0436461456,
-0.0002385875,
-0.0325363502,
-0.0223756209,
0.0111993244,
0.0577773601,
0.0671938732,
0.0293450803,
-0.0074448888,
0.0454548188,
0.0519607365,
-0.0009917658,
0.0316796973,
0.0019884042,
-0.002603672,
0.0087135741,
-0.0075396048,
0.0100665698,
0.0411411114,
0.0569580458,
-0.0522489399,
-0.0217104275,
0.1296166927,
0.0305217113,
-0.0291376263,
0.0170742609,
-0.020078985,
-0.0142624555,
0.0075061871,
0.030875735,
-0.0650899634,
-0.0500715785,
-0.0118017122,
0.0376543961,
0.0036781041,
-0.0095710745,
0.0224343464,
-0.0473826416,
0.0299386922,
-0.0157887321,
-0.0276988875,
-0.0488050841,
-0.0385132022,
0.0208705794,
-0.0216491669,
0.0140799824,
-0.009555378,
-0.0183437206,
-0.0318387896,
0.0061412347,
-0.0061065108,
-0.0713065192,
0.054137893,
-0.0247623641,
0.0636370033,
0.0349102244,
0.0186383426,
-0.0242813155,
-0.0193497259,
-0.009293871,
0.0257176235,
0.0176662207,
-0.0134169795,
0.0579447336,
0.0095025245,
-0.0171599705,
-0.0354204476,
0.0254030786,
-0.0393196791,
-0.0000599469,
-0.0073309946,
0.0743290484,
-0.06047922,
-0.0042014983,
-0.0255136993,
0.0225053765,
0.0066414461,
0.0576139092,
-0.0013158281,
-0.015632024,
0.0021420587,
0.0141611183,
0.0299624112,
0.0147051355,
-0.0340668745,
0.0375342667,
0.0113351839,
-0.0098813968,
-0.055729378,
0.002302326,
0.0525564179,
-0.0086226603,
0.0001299648,
0.0103306146,
0.0321799628,
0.0387950577,
-0.0574046746,
0.0515813828,
-0.0011419423,
0.0068276636,
-0.0790002793,
-0.0342816561,
0.0712427646,
-0.0146947112,
-0.0205525197,
0.0028673853,
-0.0891914591,
-0.0043876111,
0.0127143003,
0.0722074732,
0.022214191,
-0.0073790918,
-0.027190093,
-0.0455168374,
0.0194628071,
0.0489608273,
-0.042061355,
0.0127441045,
0.0110020461,
-0.0105005102,
-0.0266035385,
0.0410649888,
-0.0207802672,
0.0264935978,
0.0170771461,
0.0265248455,
-0.0140209123,
-0.0706987381,
0.0175045356,
0.0519236885,
0.032731127,
0.0022116054,
-0.0507821068,
-0.0009092342,
0.0438520536,
0.0079200286,
0.0357643664,
-0.0287766643,
-0.0089697838,
0.0142532196,
-0.0120570073,
0.003282628,
-0.0253602434,
-0.0428261198,
-0.0307596698,
-0.0246891677,
0.0560798272,
-0.0300816502,
-0.0279493481,
0.0534879789,
-0.0042191995,
-0.0023784826,
0.0398889259,
0.0369216762,
0.0186584834,
0.0090354038,
0.0689506456,
-0.0056895334,
0.0080349511,
-0.0424474403,
0.0508409217,
-0.0349322371,
-0.1059090197,
-0.0075844591,
0.0563808046,
0.0402951799,
0.0187372211,
0.0036172492,
-0.0144582735,
-0.0077880379,
-0.0131807029,
0.0122123482,
-0.0189529881,
0.0411619544,
0.0885393471,
0.0251929834,
-0.0001333582,
-0.0063522416,
0.0756686702,
-0.0256587677,
0.0707410872,
-0.0056530391,
-0.0167631377,
-0.051721938,
-0.0110729709,
0.0148486914,
0.0083747804,
-0.0320747942,
0.0547708236,
-0.032501325,
-0.0398204327,
0.0102518639,
-0.015519537,
-0.0353059694,
-0.0541257337,
0.0755254999,
0.0331732593,
0.0149223637,
-0.0429401845,
-0.0231772698,
0.0151658207,
-0.0276863426,
-0.0053991838,
0.0243741032,
-6.745217276e-33,
0.0010020859,
-0.0141239716,
0.0335943028,
0.0121631715,
-0.0063228137,
0.0253713988,
-0.0282438453,
-0.016031798,
-0.0627332181,
0.0106332675,
-0.0327329189,
0.01712179,
0.0079648886,
0.020641461,
-0.0203387532,
-0.0509811081,
0.0394263938,
0.0043967357,
-0.0108698374,
0.0454744063,
-0.0018675829,
0.0521637872,
0.0197460987,
-0.0579463243,
-0.0450136028,
0.0067102402,
0.0027612848,
0.0505004674,
-0.0188242011,
0.0653704107,
-0.0316092931,
0.0368595906,
0.0345211625,
-0.0307550803,
0.0071326257,
0.0142410621,
-0.0667565987,
-0.0069614323,
-0.0000201056,
-0.019842105,
-0.0016680754,
-0.0213802513,
0.0756812394,
-0.0156283267,
-0.0198183972,
-0.015385665,
0.0089462455,
-0.0345403142,
0.0000095378,
-0.0256477855,
-0.0366603285,
0.0313419811,
0.003135303,
-0.0326091237,
-0.0333627425,
0.0180062596,
-0.0452738591,
0.0476399697,
-0.0234266091,
-0.0129285827,
0.0617768131,
0.0422927663,
0.0177804399,
-0.0109812915,
-0.02279355,
0.0297612455,
0.0237588659,
0.0047372603,
-0.0112715634,
0.0081796339,
-0.0213547163,
0.0468299314,
0.0773389637,
0.0301506594,
0.009660692,
-0.0408102982,
-0.1086711958,
0.0251216106,
-0.0351238437,
0.0814643577,
0.0099274628,
-0.0299416911,
-0.0617035031,
0.0115051772,
-0.0367814973,
0.0599953793,
-0.0278484784,
-0.0280139167,
0.029999923,
-0.0083050728,
0.0111790029,
0.0190530755,
0.0138579132,
-0.0434762351,
0.0737814456,
-0.0186592638,
0.0428817421,
0.0381938219,
-0.0218581557,
0.0092750015,
-0.0296130888,
-0.0128553128,
0.0324154533,
-0.0342113189,
0.0496274196,
0.0170454159,
0.0250007641,
-0.0051215342,
-0.0714143887,
-0.0186664388,
0.0072941575,
0.0100236507,
0.0020165208,
0.0290595628,
0.0171299949,
0.0247767046,
-0.0035929407,
0.0492684692,
-0.0337440558,
-0.0045057992,
-0.0518255085,
-0.0475289412,
-0.0018195268,
0.0114916777,
-0.0575750545,
0.0085898768,
-0.0664198101,
0.0380244218,
0.0090099648,
-0.0755733848,
-0.0302062277,
0.0143815698,
3.026e-7,
0.0736411437,
0.0696139783,
0.0004566979,
-0.016844878,
0.0222061072,
0.014579541,
-0.0021093248,
0.0015369884,
0.0108668441,
0.0024656991,
0.0372187719,
0.0397235565,
0.0426673964,
0.0285434593,
-0.0682497472,
-0.0385036804,
-0.0799774826,
-0.0241551604,
-0.0212981943,
-0.0261991899,
0.041798003,
0.1056489423,
-0.0403076597,
-0.0524027608,
0.0361634754,
-0.0005366915,
0.0323073417,
-0.0405039713,
-0.0148786483,
0.0557618365,
0.0276209004,
0.0384563506,
0.0236969683,
0.0252495091,
-0.0241208021,
0.0059641362,
-0.0240060184,
0.1074492484,
-0.0538672246,
0.0141410148,
0.0193579271,
-0.0044134841,
0.0241268966,
-0.062423002,
0.0724252686,
-0.1126630381,
-0.0513055921,
-0.0341093317,
0.029290745,
-0.015006206,
0.065494135,
-0.0552337542,
-0.0357196927,
0.0306572653,
0.0343348235,
-0.00174873,
-0.0064279465,
-0.0737291276,
-0.0068131369,
0.0643169358,
-0.0385342389,
-0.0717375204,
0.0288600028,
-0.0828498676,
0.0142945591,
-0.0515321456,
0.0140732219,
2.702363478e-34,
0.0300318021,
0.0033189519,
0.0270982254,
0.0290637016,
0.0267871674,
-0.0012876804,
0.0359932892,
0.0083046071,
0.0200217217,
-0.0944231227,
-0.0111076152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10810v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10810v1 | Use GPT-J Prompt Generation with RoBERTa for NER Models on Diagnosis Extraction of Periodontal Diagnosis from Electronic Dental Records | 2023-11-17T18:14:08 | 2023-11-17T18:14:08 | Yao-Shun Chuang, Xiaoqian Jiang, Chun-Teh Lee, Ryan Brandon, Duong Tran, Oluwabunmi Tokede, Muhammad F. Walji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study explored the usability of prompt generation on named entity
recognition (NER) tasks and the performance in different settings of the
prompt. The prompt generation by GPT-J models was utilized to directly test the
gold standard as well as to generate the seed and further fed to the RoBERTa
model with the spaCy package. In the direct test, a lower ratio of negative
examples with higher numbers of examples in prompt achieved the best results
with a F1 score of 0.72. The performance revealed consistency, 0.92-0.97 in the
F1 score, in all settings after training with the RoBERTa model. The study
highlighted the importance of seed quality rather than quantity in feeding NER
models. This research reports on an efficient and accurate way to mine clinical
notes for periodontal diagnoses, allowing researchers to easily and quickly
build a NER model with the prompt generation approach. | [
0.0706500039,
0.0319581851,
0.007879572,
-0.0089934291,
-0.025481917,
0.0313313641,
0.0141818235,
0.0179422237,
-0.049859412,
0.008869227,
0.0199685693,
-0.0017862691,
-0.0083940988,
0.0137728322,
0.0145336082,
-0.0571286604,
0.0024109676,
0.0152803781,
0.0216365624,
0.0285119396,
-0.0095539214,
0.0137467347,
-0.0494373739,
0.0703588054,
-0.0506599583,
0.0049048671,
-0.0178412385,
0.0180568043,
0.0285021234,
-0.1055529341,
-0.0194618944,
0.0448969901,
-0.0316780619,
-0.00194772,
0.0000024601,
-0.0700454041,
-0.0613814853,
0.022925863,
-0.0727311298,
-0.0243959744,
0.0032288588,
-0.013341439,
-0.0150495954,
-0.0136344498,
-0.0050525279,
-0.0504930131,
0.0343116075,
-0.0037664464,
-0.0064243595,
0.0600289665,
-0.0143343862,
0.0293656886,
0.0601196922,
-0.0083088651,
0.0326307192,
-0.0289657265,
0.0338914953,
0.0033069053,
0.0203446466,
-0.019240329,
0.0519318283,
0.0071700765,
-0.006253351,
0.0164757296,
0.0336819291,
0.068980813,
-0.0142840603,
-0.0151999258,
-0.0128706908,
0.0352036171,
-0.0031631854,
0.0293000955,
0.0444492996,
-0.0286469068,
-0.0078943139,
0.0229691342,
-0.0174702033,
0.0195355304,
-0.1007153541,
0.0012953836,
0.0161642265,
-0.0193465911,
-0.0054453332,
-0.0554946288,
-0.0128999334,
0.0376897417,
0.0055975108,
-0.0349567458,
0.0682611987,
-0.0403431691,
-0.0491931066,
-0.0232370608,
0.0385899357,
0.0436013713,
-0.0136894761,
-0.0017452321,
-0.0137023889,
-0.0038890741,
0.0976649523,
0.0162065662,
0.0140946312,
0.0169952735,
-0.0335632749,
0.0214986783,
-0.0384734273,
0.0149000799,
0.0226775091,
0.0115401074,
-0.0004470971,
0.0088777486,
-0.0604924299,
-0.0182488449,
-0.0423134267,
0.0391221233,
-0.012316891,
0.0061144046,
-0.0419821106,
-0.0083737904,
0.019472396,
0.0260853283,
0.0209259037,
-0.0007615431,
-0.0219168831,
0.018792145,
-0.0487715155,
-0.0110650882,
-0.0219987538,
-0.0093964096,
-0.027798878,
-0.074895978,
0.0245284401,
-0.0112190107,
0.0291284043,
-0.0218119547,
0.0480201915,
0.0352054797,
0.0162782148,
-0.0679820329,
-0.0616582371,
-0.0424890071,
-0.0138650443,
-0.0342806317,
-0.0172860138,
-0.022529671,
0.027184112,
0.0457253978,
-0.0095308619,
0.0080591803,
0.0181574896,
0.00675201,
0.0243860688,
0.0303830989,
-0.0384361744,
-0.0107434448,
0.0634165257,
-0.0165652093,
0.0188016482,
-0.0197050683,
0.0098327193,
-0.0105090383,
-0.0061853989,
-0.0225498229,
-0.0173043329,
0.0258510336,
0.0091092139,
-0.049606286,
0.027219953,
0.0132457865,
0.0614741221,
0.0381692424,
0.0095271263,
0.0734526068,
0.0149995498,
0.0081785228,
0.0106760794,
0.0370660424,
0.0190699734,
0.020151332,
0.0757351145,
-0.0565371215,
0.0154311862,
-0.0287381597,
-0.018048238,
-0.0279793702,
-0.0276581626,
0.0392842926,
-0.0265762061,
0.0561034866,
-0.0163147151,
-0.0059159608,
-0.0169048067,
0.0098217381,
-0.0636961386,
-0.0217432119,
0.043365147,
-0.0418714508,
-0.0986163616,
0.0201605018,
0.0307779647,
-0.0181512982,
-0.0127975773,
-0.0837798715,
0.0544510409,
0.0494291335,
0.0347038768,
-0.0643514395,
-0.0399854109,
-0.0268823039,
-0.0806287155,
-0.0057444288,
-0.0279727988,
-0.0203052778,
-0.0003915352,
-0.0379039943,
-0.0424009077,
0.0268075783,
0.0146468841,
0.039352797,
0.0150145702,
0.0808687061,
0.0056358939,
-0.0180010665,
0.006934979,
0.0309916791,
-0.0337005518,
-0.0558386371,
-0.0213258378,
0.0224316623,
0.0047266702,
0.0503087081,
-0.0127873411,
0.0008788821,
0.0281150807,
-0.0252148807,
0.0177234784,
-0.0360352062,
-0.033491645,
-0.0280613098,
-0.0105499486,
-0.0214367937,
-0.0033358973,
-0.0231193583,
0.0120612998,
-0.0297359172,
-0.0971460268,
-0.0077619571,
0.0319368616,
-0.0656500384,
0.0395322666,
0.0684361607,
-0.0214310903,
-0.0362023376,
0.0631429479,
0.0007262635,
-0.0257367194,
0.0670829192,
-0.001435848,
-0.0034821734,
-0.0943671986,
-0.0544313639,
0.0336458422,
-0.0027450882,
-0.0445119776,
-0.0190248769,
0.0293434318,
-0.0342919715,
-0.0621005557,
-0.088661164,
0.0005529054,
0.0062955255,
0.0161649138,
0.0329920501,
0.0115000382,
-0.0298177619,
-0.0261479877,
0.012069717,
-0.0205845889,
0.012088581,
-0.0116069354,
0.0412765145,
0.0375643559,
-0.0286283996,
-0.0403444394,
-0.0030576678,
-0.0208004154,
0.0170049388,
0.0465232544,
-0.0515318625,
-0.0290846135,
0.0234409533,
0.0147847412,
-0.0286769848,
0.0172419157,
0.013531697,
-0.0015483351,
-0.0110383881,
0.0466621034,
0.0219427217,
-0.0239203945,
0.0412089676,
0.0066200434,
-0.0124482522,
-0.021916423,
0.0151781989,
-0.0362139679,
0.0407512933,
0.0463817678,
-0.0837223232,
0.0593619347,
0.0374856591,
-0.0022804027,
0.043061763,
-0.0118397558,
0.0060946923,
-0.0010806364,
0.0187952258,
-0.0068811872,
0.000854203,
-0.0240645204,
0.0135862911,
-0.0177778471,
-0.0450426601,
0.0581207313,
-0.0280875769,
0.0003645526,
-0.0272594951,
-0.0118112825,
-0.0286330301,
0.0015574992,
0.0365227051,
0.0024876494,
0.0974151567,
-0.0789294317,
0.0286074858,
-0.0222538896,
0.0426062047,
-0.0290547814,
0.0185512416,
0.017339984,
0.0347708613,
-0.0071283053,
-0.0106229903,
-0.047780931,
-0.0219371673,
0.0156371221,
0.04926138,
0.0352845415,
0.0240629725,
-0.004596496,
0.1157051697,
0.011673742,
0.0520539656,
0.0116480421,
0.0059092776,
-0.0155083109,
0.041946549,
0.0462621339,
-0.0319673084,
-0.0445826463,
0.0065504494,
0.0079157483,
-0.0177155025,
-0.0238275249,
0.0168866105,
-0.0056305379,
0.0306276176,
-0.0421203896,
-0.0439610519,
-0.044115454,
0.0271698218,
-0.0294032414,
-0.0169233754,
-0.0121959113,
0.0840005875,
0.0568907149,
-0.0257955994,
-0.0272347108,
0.0208094418,
-0.0125103202,
-0.0368601158,
-0.0096245324,
0.0095829563,
0.0090444852,
0.0211870074,
0.0310243256,
0.0007027304,
-0.0527133159,
0.011730779,
-0.0620116144,
0.0499379039,
-0.0247552544,
-0.0904754922,
0.0028220834,
-0.0395307951,
0.0144723272,
0.0045447624,
-0.0240414813,
0.0261666011,
-0.0246934555,
0.0215888564,
0.0369643457,
-0.0546370298,
-0.0322676823,
-0.0093253404,
-0.0253119376,
0.0222231578,
0.1002803594,
0.0166242868,
-0.0001712786,
-0.0541295335,
-0.0121072689,
-0.043423757,
0.0137635907,
-0.0620053932,
0.1155888364,
0.0180076268,
-0.0101915533,
-0.0246489998,
0.0138992947,
0.0030077517,
-0.0007236432,
-0.0023014245,
0.0549871214,
-0.0111991074,
0.0411744677,
-0.0265097562,
-0.0158652905,
0.0454522893,
0.0364042222,
0.0237835217,
0.0135647384,
-0.0569660962,
0.0421020798,
0.0615956783,
0.0028669536,
0.049303703,
0.0206156913,
-0.0147851883,
-0.0522790663,
-0.0301626045,
-0.0537146293,
0.0524323657,
0.0333227664,
0.0323165804,
-0.0159417894,
0.0057403427,
0.054599762,
-0.031861838,
0.0139903668,
0.0407369249,
0.0056961342,
-0.1143098027,
-0.0380692631,
0.0391208455,
0.0078738611,
-0.0235930402,
-0.0395373181,
0.0240945239,
0.0114202509,
0.0214820746,
0.0335929096,
0.0280104317,
-0.0309198052,
0.0057847691,
0.0108589986,
0.0367388763,
0.0192279052,
-0.0314735994,
-0.0312097631,
-0.03278514,
0.0226306766,
-0.0133087486,
-0.015293383,
0.0035183295,
0.0111326342,
-0.00720726,
0.0449428037,
0.0183958523,
-0.0910183936,
0.0386831015,
0.0486523844,
0.0571230203,
0.0039818981,
-0.0305937454,
-0.0513965487,
0.0274873432,
0.036570292,
0.0401312262,
-0.0206794515,
0.0251836367,
-0.0186338816,
0.0191786215,
-0.0190295186,
0.0018929851,
-0.020212274,
0.0162403565,
-0.0477696918,
0.0116684372,
0.0213900674,
0.0553743728,
0.0253108051,
-0.0376458429,
-0.0263921134,
-0.0556858629,
0.043392431,
0.0201855786,
-0.000517903,
0.0922235101,
-0.0215604734,
0.0091162538,
0.0193281472,
0.0226341132,
-0.0081796125,
0.0192053076,
-0.0609798506,
0.0244124606,
0.0546589084,
-0.0011748652,
0.0159569494,
-0.0025116066,
-0.0010476713,
-0.0263755396,
0.0338623747,
-0.0022286782,
0.0071625398,
0.0629119426,
0.0263209511,
-0.0181159396,
-0.090139173,
0.0270311423,
0.0024285121,
0.0099281883,
-0.0213867147,
-0.0571775399,
-0.0384874865,
0.0177696235,
0.0204273257,
-0.0376934484,
-0.0806880593,
-0.0097886659,
-0.0560913086,
-0.0135862064,
0.0287363064,
-0.0008474279,
-0.0156638809,
0.0224285517,
0.0173476078,
0.0203075297,
-0.0127286213,
-0.0713375285,
-0.0269568022,
0.0514496192,
-0.0180288367,
-0.01766246,
0.0022944969,
-6.766324012e-33,
-0.0297853872,
-0.0323110931,
0.0245551523,
0.0329382755,
0.0028205081,
0.0229752287,
-0.0049071535,
0.0118657546,
0.0266249608,
-0.0106769614,
-0.0295072123,
-0.0530717,
0.0340735614,
0.018725602,
0.0020887319,
0.0023225583,
0.0746610388,
0.0055015013,
-0.0307079349,
0.0173505861,
-0.0035316632,
0.0663377419,
0.0569565706,
-0.0385214128,
-0.0150962602,
0.0025917471,
0.0386288725,
-0.0546346381,
0.0307718627,
0.056703005,
-0.0511690713,
-0.0281894337,
0.0107647358,
-0.0765848383,
0.0148352142,
0.0291194376,
-0.1503867954,
-0.025018679,
-0.0009745968,
0.0048402674,
-0.0099996757,
-0.0221208613,
-0.0256919824,
-0.0258828606,
0.0156999212,
0.0653820559,
0.0409485847,
-0.0065020523,
-0.0124853542,
-0.0105964411,
-0.0396777615,
0.0502981469,
0.0513625592,
-0.0050612148,
0.0324438177,
0.0001691773,
0.0035297084,
-0.0266220327,
-0.0275750086,
-0.0240949374,
0.0465881713,
-0.0160625689,
0.0148798851,
0.0174392443,
-0.0364205875,
0.0255120769,
0.0645813793,
-0.0453796461,
0.0243949741,
0.0183396898,
-0.0624257177,
0.0466487929,
-0.0268461276,
-0.0139451288,
0.0469419993,
0.0137507431,
-0.0735945851,
0.0704403967,
-0.0051723137,
0.0334508084,
0.0488869622,
-0.0633690208,
-0.0409300961,
0.0119261723,
0.0166945662,
-0.0289524421,
-0.027932426,
-0.033224199,
0.055905465,
0.0112736775,
-0.0084103933,
0.0250192657,
0.0222634282,
0.0385278612,
-0.0436030217,
-0.0203219727,
0.0319803618,
0.012529063,
-0.0457782,
-0.0377276242,
-0.0488952547,
-0.010020446,
0.0175414812,
0.0300905406,
0.0432254672,
0.0068202168,
-0.0134095764,
-0.0261315443,
-0.1024445072,
0.0143557927,
0.0089382567,
0.0718217343,
-0.0298155844,
0.0126195885,
0.0272706356,
-0.0311377533,
-0.0075417501,
0.0278664902,
0.0251183063,
-0.0195836555,
-0.0488095693,
-0.0271341279,
0.0043502399,
0.0333279073,
0.0092075951,
0.0173860155,
-0.0041554486,
0.0295788348,
-0.006946479,
0.0232406016,
0.0212510023,
0.0156027758,
3.051e-7,
0.0183405764,
0.0030829343,
0.0298117101,
-0.0324933641,
0.0134552782,
-0.0169922914,
-0.0243061613,
-0.0291344468,
0.0130830202,
-0.028455684,
0.0317937322,
-0.0517512336,
0.0090465648,
0.0557483099,
-0.084129326,
-0.0131727736,
-0.0020665594,
-0.0127508789,
-0.0644414499,
0.0444374532,
0.072895214,
0.0141476505,
-0.0522435568,
-0.0613724142,
-0.0092465896,
-0.0335491113,
0.0233003553,
-0.0311917234,
0.0348030068,
0.0159233566,
0.057963863,
-0.0232460294,
0.0052152732,
0.0852713138,
0.0164096374,
-0.0050338847,
0.00477061,
0.0663889423,
-0.0050618169,
-0.0091111939,
0.0391613692,
0.0248958729,
0.0233722962,
-0.0637596846,
0.0492134392,
-0.0130246002,
0.0125014251,
0.0338131525,
-0.0446228795,
0.0041724877,
0.0354573429,
-0.004604164,
-0.0265581701,
0.0088094026,
-0.0100150686,
-0.0057729711,
-0.0172519963,
-0.0227609035,
0.0497862697,
0.0433271267,
-0.0184280146,
-0.0592065118,
-0.0032181938,
-0.0750639364,
-0.031620618,
-0.0551410913,
-0.0112802126,
3.394320524e-34,
-0.0039047902,
0.0018116229,
0.0214283783,
0.0190069061,
-0.0259775016,
0.0019419789,
0.0207064021,
0.0098046158,
-0.0007281141,
-0.0417599007,
-0.0256603286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10642v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10642v4 | Rethinking Attention: Exploring Shallow Feed-Forward Neural Networks as an Alternative to Attention Layers in Transformers | 2023-11-17T16:58:52 | 2024-02-04T20:39:33 | Vukasin Bozic, Danilo Dordevic, Daniele Coppola, Joseph Thommes, Sidak Pal Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work presents an analysis of the effectiveness of using standard shallow
feed-forward networks to mimic the behavior of the attention mechanism in the
original Transformer model, a state-of-the-art architecture for
sequence-to-sequence tasks. We substitute key elements of the attention
mechanism in the Transformer with simple feed-forward networks, trained using
the original components via knowledge distillation. Our experiments, conducted
on the IWSLT2017 dataset, reveal the capacity of these "attentionless
Transformers" to rival the performance of the original architecture. Through
rigorous ablation studies, and experimenting with various replacement network
types and sizes, we offer insights that support the viability of our approach.
This not only sheds light on the adaptability of shallow feed-forward networks
in emulating attention mechanisms but also underscores their potential to
streamline complex architectures for sequence-to-sequence tasks. | [
-0.0071056066,
0.0680592582,
-0.0023783082,
0.0141449142,
-0.0054655871,
-0.0039108586,
0.0244853254,
-0.0098576583,
-0.0488221496,
0.0038370159,
-0.0430654362,
-0.0243149884,
0.0191808641,
0.0331119969,
0.0324657299,
-0.0325362198,
0.0567327142,
0.0405151919,
-0.0432870872,
0.0163966715,
-0.0124127418,
-0.0396428816,
0.0181077849,
0.0338240117,
-0.004155946,
0.0078383964,
-0.0289331637,
-0.0180850513,
0.0447121933,
-0.0217532106,
0.0232683085,
0.051903557,
0.0087964535,
0.0582839735,
0.0000020688,
0.0114403693,
0.0251183677,
-0.0096345572,
-0.0262624361,
0.0014795163,
-0.0222588964,
-0.0146497563,
0.0042360802,
-0.0177968778,
-0.0231437627,
-0.0126341553,
0.0658865497,
0.0638146922,
0.0699017495,
0.061649818,
-0.01026149,
-0.0382091254,
0.0410235673,
-0.0600066781,
0.0256280676,
-0.0166221056,
-0.0032418021,
-0.0943791717,
-0.0175864957,
0.0079842675,
-0.0325953104,
0.066761151,
0.0418888852,
0.0274709146,
0.0203011502,
0.0464384928,
-0.0494763218,
-0.0290365703,
-0.0198132433,
0.0415672548,
-0.0592604913,
-0.0120909,
0.0018121805,
-0.0104018208,
-0.0030350566,
-0.0432268195,
-0.0579677559,
0.0041317288,
0.0160372816,
0.0068228147,
-0.0362569429,
0.0405625664,
0.0326082148,
-0.0352098383,
-0.0147298491,
-0.0057160538,
0.0108967181,
-0.0144694103,
0.0026307162,
0.0128638223,
0.0172272958,
-0.0394963436,
0.0154223843,
0.0548701771,
0.0095743798,
-0.0036088349,
-0.0481346473,
-0.0401363671,
-0.0084556304,
-0.0199295934,
0.054846622,
0.0203090645,
-0.0360943303,
0.0032681145,
-0.0424114577,
0.0772585943,
-0.0374731347,
0.0233609416,
-0.0198045205,
0.0503294393,
-0.0318013616,
0.0011634666,
-0.0048369449,
0.0279279277,
-0.0220646299,
-0.0405398868,
-0.0280837212,
-0.0042206724,
-0.0106907021,
-0.0193440355,
0.015803935,
0.0535621047,
-0.0542923883,
0.0155981174,
0.0160728358,
0.0851086676,
-0.0024768137,
-0.0258653648,
0.0469395109,
-0.0243687462,
-0.0582116731,
0.0004431341,
-0.0061653517,
0.0002186358,
0.0189449545,
0.0715714097,
-0.0275043268,
-0.0656908005,
-0.0318201222,
0.0133282989,
-0.0174152441,
-0.0316329002,
0.0626387149,
-0.0392986424,
0.0462158062,
-0.0089498879,
0.007400359,
-0.0163989402,
0.0286975577,
0.0247460194,
-0.0344014838,
0.0342720412,
0.0239585564,
-0.0400357172,
-0.035132546,
-0.0076096584,
0.0123866787,
-0.0058379113,
0.0282444041,
0.0364504419,
-0.0236974712,
-0.0342436731,
0.0022261152,
0.0232849102,
0.0344349965,
-0.0010418458,
0.0053726234,
-0.0480662249,
-0.0721173435,
0.0188264064,
0.0526045039,
0.0216870997,
-0.0172786266,
-0.0205246136,
0.0877453834,
0.0305835754,
0.0432036221,
0.0846039578,
0.0383243039,
-0.0131477229,
-0.030288972,
0.0256532487,
-0.0728955045,
0.1031295434,
0.0313083641,
0.0026388923,
0.003375977,
0.0146917421,
-0.0499663167,
-0.0359186456,
0.0331574008,
0.0246161781,
0.0008185054,
0.0110922493,
0.0348115861,
0.039044071,
-0.0370352156,
0.0933559537,
-0.0117131313,
-0.0186037011,
-0.007721812,
-0.0401967317,
-0.0329919979,
0.0108992588,
0.0168561302,
-0.0194334853,
-0.0436545983,
-0.022673836,
-0.0115289055,
0.050901521,
0.0302563775,
0.0347227193,
-0.0071898438,
-0.0236000437,
-0.0172421876,
-0.0295626838,
0.0119625395,
-0.0011683546,
-0.0092309099,
-0.0063301884,
0.0201754868,
0.0157763623,
-0.012299899,
0.0186051708,
-0.0245869104,
-0.0223102048,
-0.0183363799,
0.0155407693,
0.0107108708,
-0.0008352558,
-0.0158233307,
0.021409519,
0.0534988716,
-0.0290312413,
0.0018366985,
0.0243534446,
-0.0639131442,
0.0178867206,
0.0150662055,
-0.0369929858,
0.0095054656,
0.0835297406,
-0.0209346265,
-0.0419279709,
0.0401314683,
-0.0499532036,
0.0153415995,
-0.013651941,
0.0162022132,
0.0127526661,
0.0284994598,
-0.0173766892,
0.0244032405,
-0.0349558555,
0.0164433327,
-0.0297992826,
-0.0217133239,
-0.0105227493,
-0.009050603,
-0.0204800125,
-0.0108635668,
-0.0464335494,
-0.0024010942,
0.0001910164,
-0.0119098471,
-0.0228228942,
-0.0135058844,
-0.0216360595,
0.015766656,
-0.0306806881,
0.0103675146,
0.0257494934,
0.0295308344,
0.0439644866,
0.0014291547,
-0.0380749553,
0.0587183312,
0.0082195448,
0.0078672646,
0.0220158324,
-0.0070614116,
-0.0179176126,
-0.035429161,
-0.0517478101,
0.0070552407,
0.0570100658,
-0.0061020427,
-0.0291657932,
-0.0381116234,
-0.0240433887,
0.0030802453,
0.0163037982,
-0.0113096507,
-0.0456759967,
0.0121973436,
-0.0227400865,
-0.0010605738,
0.0683881268,
0.0317079909,
0.0175923314,
0.0160281193,
-0.0245010443,
-0.014268565,
0.0439551808,
-0.0410066321,
0.0085486993,
-0.0448344722,
-0.0024753525,
0.0283555649,
0.093475394,
-0.0504066572,
0.0074128546,
-0.0609033257,
-0.0124208108,
0.0220915042,
-0.0252835806,
0.0009104654,
-0.0021356845,
-0.0363010876,
-0.0119688939,
-0.0294995271,
-0.031602107,
0.0366209261,
-0.00071887,
0.0000914828,
-0.004334704,
0.0212460496,
-0.0027156069,
0.019376725,
0.0289777759,
0.0186162405,
0.0067996141,
-0.0224604402,
-0.0407816544,
0.0479279011,
-0.0411195979,
-0.0000335611,
0.097904861,
0.0049462756,
-0.0139555549,
-0.0328387395,
-0.0281037018,
-0.0478185415,
0.0153503707,
-0.0168616995,
0.0337183028,
0.0516666956,
-0.0330707021,
-0.1183803976,
0.0250287428,
0.0408291332,
0.0798376203,
-0.0139874741,
-0.0171550717,
-0.0338165313,
0.0485520735,
0.0082132081,
0.0317645893,
0.0647290275,
-0.0135813449,
0.0256980006,
0.0594946854,
0.0325596556,
-0.0113474,
-0.0479436889,
-0.006172115,
0.014826539,
-0.0200306438,
-0.0259132814,
0.0045577912,
0.0338859633,
-0.0855767131,
-0.0647531301,
0.0598507784,
-0.0101350108,
-0.064954944,
0.0101733543,
0.044912301,
-0.0147725679,
0.0287487451,
0.0317783505,
-0.0230924003,
-0.0253215749,
0.0033289085,
0.0339403413,
0.0261471011,
-0.0246003885,
0.0119325686,
-0.0488266833,
0.0511138774,
-0.0091749188,
-0.0673520267,
-0.0624330342,
-0.0094557842,
0.0070309602,
0.012519761,
-0.00001149,
0.025723068,
0.0032525267,
-0.0417833179,
0.0034489101,
0.0098903915,
-0.0154145593,
0.0304667354,
-0.0162403658,
0.0090746954,
0.0641140118,
-0.0120403385,
-0.0042824517,
-0.0572043173,
0.0097652907,
-0.0228002016,
0.0235199407,
0.025057856,
0.0638191178,
-0.0017275697,
-0.0506866723,
-0.0142336953,
0.0106329983,
-0.0558473803,
0.0016205112,
-0.0575823151,
0.036327906,
-0.0116252825,
-0.0640211999,
-0.0210538879,
0.0052107577,
-0.0209559985,
0.035287194,
0.0465155579,
-0.0386653766,
-0.0439470746,
-0.0222316701,
-0.0093567939,
-0.0703999102,
-0.0835955739,
0.028314475,
0.0416838564,
-0.0888070241,
-0.0410419442,
-0.0418043658,
-0.023192592,
0.0185260661,
0.0192795452,
-0.069308117,
0.0560089312,
-0.0100188255,
-0.0455384329,
0.0406357013,
-0.0006294906,
0.0020913377,
-0.0608454943,
0.0079446193,
0.0292018931,
-0.0114901923,
-0.0214451905,
0.0483358651,
-0.1257538348,
-0.0119303549,
0.0358591303,
0.0930705294,
0.0173818693,
0.0186633002,
-0.0170943532,
-0.0079999249,
0.0561994426,
0.0248086341,
0.0001311606,
0.0347868577,
0.0495538488,
-0.0609048605,
-0.0135410838,
0.0250747744,
-0.0205777753,
0.0335859992,
0.0503305905,
0.0518828668,
0.0026821091,
0.0088124555,
0.0313519724,
-0.0290560722,
0.0579860657,
0.0228633918,
0.0278424509,
0.008011857,
0.0177376661,
0.0484025069,
0.0126298452,
-0.0652609318,
-0.0474839099,
0.0039666397,
0.0357567072,
0.0088322284,
0.0072893109,
0.0346073359,
-0.0157131646,
-0.0399813242,
0.0134152593,
0.0117318267,
-0.0174877178,
-0.0043549486,
0.0110888416,
-0.0170119051,
0.0057859831,
0.0076627373,
0.0261577461,
-0.0143487975,
0.0126550989,
0.0250209216,
0.0360062681,
-0.0574801788,
0.0385711454,
-0.0904892534,
-0.0141126774,
-0.0294094644,
-0.0097777266,
0.065605469,
-0.0226522014,
0.02011065,
-0.0018566013,
-0.0046794661,
-0.0214166623,
0.0002638246,
-0.0128054451,
-0.0023994527,
-0.0173427165,
0.0416217633,
0.0225186143,
-0.0353146568,
0.059466932,
-0.0269264057,
0.0135947736,
0.0102179134,
0.0088681607,
-0.0444925018,
-0.0313907005,
0.0108374832,
0.0084649129,
0.0083950292,
-0.0376332551,
-0.0202726964,
-0.0770839825,
0.0469301641,
-0.0263985638,
0.0327204876,
-0.0259258114,
0.0414356552,
0.0128002763,
0.0144187156,
-0.0156894401,
0.0255149845,
-0.003023061,
-0.0070736278,
-0.0319780372,
-0.0239025913,
-6.507473543e-33,
0.0079258513,
0.0197203048,
0.0101989442,
0.0119513096,
-0.0663806796,
0.0230186712,
-0.0628289059,
-0.0205422807,
-0.0085419789,
0.0290077161,
-0.0423926078,
0.0261378605,
0.0066381791,
0.0307057444,
0.0469177924,
-0.0478635468,
0.0622593276,
-0.0175377857,
-0.0136688193,
0.0462721176,
0.0351557545,
0.0272494629,
0.0774705186,
0.0037440725,
-0.0391213149,
0.0235618204,
0.0263386276,
-0.010248539,
-0.0106171705,
0.0236238893,
-0.0248033181,
0.0448211394,
0.0227861144,
-0.0683918372,
-0.0494994968,
0.0376827531,
-0.0888567269,
-0.0013598095,
-0.0519962497,
-0.013592138,
-0.0300312489,
-0.0275083017,
0.0853211507,
0.0115100779,
0.0126108304,
-0.0601325743,
0.016573837,
0.0090951957,
-0.0417849533,
-0.0272415355,
-0.0500660911,
-0.0148385735,
-0.0180807915,
-0.0469450839,
0.0261521246,
0.05193647,
-0.0355063304,
0.0225835517,
-0.0986972377,
0.0088942777,
0.0132206483,
0.0606574453,
0.0464282371,
0.055910714,
0.0040071406,
0.0279243868,
0.0232533608,
0.0226170719,
-0.0089341281,
0.0082917996,
0.0456620827,
0.0244034417,
0.0809786245,
-0.0357019007,
0.0477401428,
-0.0143440031,
-0.0530822948,
-0.0179173537,
-0.0335183404,
0.085369356,
0.0517211631,
0.0007893389,
0.0191005059,
0.0047600116,
-0.0095069595,
-0.0006008135,
-0.0325225294,
0.0018653702,
0.0167591181,
0.0275458377,
0.0044563045,
-0.0011117157,
0.036118485,
-0.0355724022,
0.0772908777,
0.0241276789,
0.0270626396,
0.029102454,
0.0227078497,
-0.019759953,
-0.0428633168,
0.0194640514,
0.0139402859,
0.0478037484,
0.007155125,
-0.0190283023,
0.0144482302,
0.0442979261,
-0.0216543302,
-0.0435103215,
-0.0448298007,
0.0456557311,
0.0115040289,
0.0333125405,
0.0379841067,
-0.0042039971,
-0.0154920574,
-0.0043287724,
-0.0305685438,
-0.008776607,
0.0068389797,
0.0690557435,
0.0157580413,
0.03511573,
-0.0026511648,
-0.0021141295,
-0.0949114561,
0.0464389548,
-0.0148140797,
-0.0869339332,
-0.0260371659,
0.0581141785,
2.889e-7,
0.0136585841,
0.000649525,
0.0206220057,
0.0152894761,
0.0484501608,
-0.0019702604,
-0.0047343364,
0.0389301404,
0.0128805991,
-0.0086408341,
0.0376169831,
0.0281337332,
0.0497144312,
0.0027224531,
-0.1040079147,
-0.0574254543,
-0.0725683421,
0.0195252802,
-0.0108555127,
-0.0470732972,
0.0104099363,
0.0712584928,
-0.0074818609,
-0.011792941,
0.0352911726,
-0.0028393755,
0.0182740502,
0.0366883278,
0.0381781533,
-0.0074072685,
0.0128316199,
-0.0217017233,
-0.0428650528,
0.0276057795,
-0.0283716545,
0.0075014234,
-0.0121356277,
0.0344110765,
-0.0028472173,
-0.0851967335,
-0.0084770685,
0.0386987217,
0.0324560367,
-0.0393977612,
0.0161747094,
-0.1349381953,
-0.0288249999,
0.0237617437,
-0.0468213037,
0.0057986309,
-0.0150250625,
0.0022443382,
0.0004694734,
-0.0098182745,
-0.0020528862,
-0.0101104798,
-0.0021177763,
-0.0790913701,
-0.0184014365,
0.0272556804,
-0.0578698255,
-0.0250559747,
-0.1007705778,
-0.0601674542,
0.0301314648,
0.0368449502,
-0.0635543093,
2.522830134e-34,
0.0086969025,
-0.0252106134,
0.0197050404,
0.0024520133,
-0.0129783452,
-0.0184266176,
0.0028269822,
0.0025917599,
0.0214935932,
-0.0718346611,
-0.027360674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10614v1 | A Self-enhancement Approach for Domain-specific Chatbot Training via Knowledge Mining and Digest | 2023-11-17T16:09:10 | 2023-11-17T16:09:10 | Ruohong Zhang, Luyu Gao, Chen Zheng, Zhen Fan, Guokun Lai, Zheng Zhang, Fangzhou Ai, Yiming Yang, Hongxia Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), despite their great power in language
generation, often encounter challenges when dealing with intricate and
knowledge-demanding queries in specific domains. This paper introduces a novel
approach to enhance LLMs by effectively extracting the relevant knowledge from
domain-specific textual sources, and the adaptive training of a chatbot with
domain-specific inquiries. Our two-step approach starts from training a
knowledge miner, namely LLMiner, which autonomously extracts Question-Answer
pairs from relevant documents through a chain-of-thought reasoning process.
Subsequently, we blend the mined QA pairs with a conversational dataset to
fine-tune the LLM as a chatbot, thereby enriching its domain-specific expertise
and conversational capabilities. We also developed a new evaluation benchmark
which comprises four domain-specific text corpora and associated human-crafted
QA pairs for testing. Our model shows remarkable performance improvement over
generally aligned LLM and surpasses domain-adapted models directly fine-tuned
on domain corpus. In particular, LLMiner achieves this with minimal human
intervention, requiring only 600 seed instances, thereby providing a pathway
towards self-improvement of LLMs through model-synthesized training data. | [
0.0594110303,
0.0140216779,
-0.0144939544,
0.0205047447,
-0.0255404543,
0.0104400031,
-0.0049517569,
-0.0081098126,
0.0743558854,
-0.063504301,
-0.0201799087,
0.0190765318,
-0.0496114567,
0.034239009,
0.0060204882,
-0.036209099,
0.0363357067,
-0.0335110053,
-0.0162900016,
-0.006829767,
0.0152288405,
0.0304645542,
-0.0361639857,
0.0316146985,
-0.0072507937,
-0.0380724482,
-0.0440694802,
-0.0119636944,
-0.0086948564,
-0.0017587376,
0.0236155223,
0.0541488342,
0.0290354472,
0.0077243918,
0.0000019837,
-0.0583905727,
-0.0396870896,
-0.0140509577,
-0.0415572412,
-0.0653142408,
0.0128741665,
0.0221661441,
0.009261257,
0.0583100133,
-0.0773464218,
0.016563002,
-0.008532987,
0.0465036929,
0.0754869729,
0.0649435222,
0.0016436977,
0.0027929177,
0.0134896478,
-0.0021656,
-0.0031787758,
-0.0631960258,
-0.0068596359,
0.0567708351,
0.0326195806,
0.0448066406,
0.0096690115,
0.0102141891,
0.0227802712,
-0.0475578383,
0.0483360142,
0.0158577375,
-0.0134094488,
-0.0112086665,
-0.0174019653,
0.0743828714,
0.0216181744,
-0.0011826418,
0.0047257422,
0.0307987537,
0.0458705164,
0.0038705366,
-0.0249345526,
0.0060889944,
0.0125073381,
-0.0182800423,
-0.0069198417,
-0.0237615798,
-0.0234000999,
0.0144089069,
-0.0291678552,
0.0423380621,
0.0132515375,
-0.0316568576,
0.0155980876,
0.0111041907,
-0.0229425468,
-0.0866751522,
-0.0104688769,
0.0845705718,
-0.0225800257,
0.0373060554,
-0.0359462723,
0.0061409925,
0.0000078562,
-0.0163309537,
-0.0392155088,
0.0330419801,
0.0020327196,
0.0455795303,
-0.0092801573,
0.0302559081,
0.0195525065,
-0.0112212934,
-0.0598318912,
-0.0306646489,
-0.0801378936,
-0.0240691863,
-0.0484019928,
0.0522135906,
-0.0347138532,
0.0018517395,
-0.0333437733,
0.0464843251,
0.0400116444,
-0.0111154933,
0.0107250391,
0.0215783715,
-0.038526725,
-0.0274425428,
-0.0635533482,
0.0035703992,
-0.0538025983,
0.0235780776,
0.064822875,
-0.0552927814,
-0.0230410695,
0.0121909659,
0.0091204839,
-0.0064245635,
-0.005774172,
0.0932976156,
-0.020930361,
-0.0461297445,
-0.0397008322,
-0.0736141875,
-0.0035758743,
-0.0502718091,
0.0091229519,
-0.0362173207,
0.047151655,
-0.0038210836,
-0.0366441384,
-0.0192446299,
0.0156660676,
0.0176960845,
0.0020941137,
0.032259915,
-0.0463857278,
0.0116513604,
0.0451093353,
0.0254233833,
-0.0260700174,
0.085448049,
0.0335286483,
0.0171759482,
0.0375010185,
0.0026600556,
-0.0031444284,
-0.0010939784,
0.012821571,
-0.0181069877,
0.0313065238,
0.030940963,
-0.0235669482,
0.0361834355,
0.0221959427,
0.0265413634,
-0.0325162783,
0.0273809992,
0.0402048714,
0.029257983,
0.0162737072,
0.0478953831,
0.0186770856,
0.0344712064,
0.0301117897,
0.0180949103,
-0.0065746536,
0.0260097682,
-0.02696505,
-0.0168058798,
0.0366268083,
0.0212359242,
-0.0358309112,
-0.0504690073,
0.0235328656,
-0.0071990667,
0.0207978338,
0.0230409801,
0.038572453,
0.0446710847,
-0.019342998,
0.0342556946,
0.0185293984,
-0.0411816165,
-0.0030995607,
-0.0586089753,
0.0248476285,
0.035881687,
0.0671231076,
-0.0377195105,
-0.0577498265,
-0.0119477725,
-0.0170930605,
0.045527529,
0.0446205027,
-0.0358038209,
-0.0036870218,
-0.0403468385,
-0.034775462,
-0.0218809564,
-0.009587504,
-0.0230652038,
0.0309766065,
0.0236975364,
0.0254815537,
-0.0309101231,
-0.0006957965,
0.039079532,
-0.0614510067,
-0.0398065038,
0.0144071449,
-0.0132150874,
0.005475516,
0.0389147215,
0.0156886745,
0.0124575682,
0.0306431204,
-0.0385929681,
-0.0642392561,
0.0439278185,
-0.0462614447,
-0.0663782582,
0.0514893979,
0.0066988822,
-0.0077456431,
0.0065356675,
-0.0238359626,
-0.0289037619,
-0.0127820205,
-0.0422147736,
0.0347920656,
-0.0487034023,
0.0056847325,
0.0112010315,
0.0115491366,
-0.0399717428,
0.067196086,
0.0117948502,
-0.0465526171,
-0.0093383854,
0.0157461502,
-0.0023266936,
-0.0140499324,
0.0324351043,
-0.0219506249,
-0.0064307223,
0.0235164203,
0.0415144488,
0.0134205194,
-0.0851615667,
-0.0369435474,
-0.0800755024,
0.0191396233,
0.00933869,
0.0127564203,
0.0417171642,
0.0132030491,
-0.0010003307,
-0.0110974209,
-0.0708364174,
0.0240043309,
0.0314947106,
0.0018588904,
0.0646974146,
0.0194509607,
0.0222555958,
-0.0438792408,
0.039483238,
0.0015926762,
0.005977286,
0.0431629308,
0.032589525,
-0.0650318265,
0.0659937337,
-0.0364718847,
0.0204246026,
0.0025303459,
-0.0457815267,
0.0129060708,
-0.0366004258,
0.0384895504,
0.0640185326,
0.0684130043,
0.0075392956,
0.0300052799,
0.018195238,
-0.0688893348,
0.032907784,
-0.0228226352,
0.0055567725,
-0.0071407524,
0.0004271801,
0.0363467038,
0.0495852977,
-0.0266197901,
-0.0043507386,
-0.0610108562,
0.0331992321,
0.0193461552,
-0.0469952412,
-0.0284922477,
0.0210601874,
0.01474398,
0.0423064083,
-0.0020979601,
-0.0179185458,
0.0882902592,
-0.0152671533,
0.0106902774,
-0.081040509,
-0.026951775,
-0.0400243066,
0.0374206528,
-0.0339706391,
0.0308157839,
0.0195782278,
0.0095348917,
-0.0723917782,
0.0034921935,
0.0099413497,
-0.0459858067,
0.0061223279,
-0.0283674411,
0.0143645909,
0.0218506958,
-0.060169585,
-0.087738052,
-0.0211720075,
-0.0038039149,
-0.0226448663,
0.0442592129,
-0.0129873157,
-0.0161523204,
0.0098637622,
0.0170806777,
0.0066202027,
-0.0248764306,
-0.0353989638,
-0.0016030652,
0.0431360714,
0.0702325031,
0.0601219721,
0.0339542776,
-0.017762024,
0.0886321664,
0.0554681383,
0.0214006957,
-0.0078911697,
0.0038791907,
-0.0143312411,
0.001423525,
-0.0365628675,
0.016159432,
-0.0081277993,
0.0564728417,
-0.0365174413,
-0.0415065363,
0.1250370443,
0.0411272123,
-0.0344252549,
-0.0003572572,
-0.0491735935,
0.0261330735,
0.0133488476,
0.05888604,
-0.070171617,
-0.0308500882,
-0.0068867086,
0.0222869478,
-0.0232748408,
-0.0486336462,
-0.0096810451,
-0.1288000643,
0.0189320892,
-0.0072256802,
-0.0298557356,
-0.0359737463,
-0.0205848888,
-0.025925722,
0.0173543263,
-0.0137679046,
0.0233765114,
-0.0267217085,
0.012299425,
0.0277495105,
-0.020825373,
-0.0352308415,
0.0219167881,
-0.0253596883,
0.0336364992,
0.0557609051,
0.0449952744,
0.0513870642,
0.0425077155,
0.0101723913,
-0.0047952519,
0.0142586706,
0.0068846489,
0.0614264123,
-0.0275718533,
0.0044082729,
-0.0303857643,
0.0486009531,
-0.0208811816,
0.0160478987,
0.0485394411,
0.0309320129,
-0.0190702006,
0.0126183461,
-0.0123036476,
0.0316092372,
-0.0137015376,
0.0709728226,
0.0210793912,
-0.0280977879,
0.0004746622,
-0.0186075121,
0.0007310761,
-0.0304124746,
-0.0468170382,
0.0125811528,
-0.0017618213,
0.0397846662,
-0.126655817,
-0.0703516006,
0.0332770795,
0.0355323702,
-0.0048964061,
0.006104717,
0.0150131816,
0.0372357033,
-0.0143492529,
0.0126031777,
-0.0561315045,
-0.0537614562,
-0.0459591001,
-0.0246378649,
0.0379125662,
-0.0672978982,
-0.0114892181,
0.0147020295,
-0.0556052737,
-0.0506472997,
-0.0323398374,
0.0299807936,
0.0168709494,
0.0628507286,
-0.0181124862,
-0.041937463,
0.0300323553,
0.0379814543,
-0.0667176396,
-0.0107610291,
0.0026514265,
0.0231300052,
-0.0029246262,
0.02983783,
-0.0653689057,
0.0195076596,
-0.0495353825,
0.0402467512,
-0.0130205275,
-0.0689290389,
0.0696939677,
0.020334594,
-0.0358383767,
0.0015126562,
0.0144015383,
-0.0223678146,
0.0332266241,
-0.0390728936,
-0.0252679121,
-0.066845566,
0.0194814149,
-0.0136304758,
-0.0376555584,
0.029875325,
-0.0000543612,
-0.0408525355,
0.0348530859,
-0.0033655425,
-0.02998068,
-0.0093841888,
0.0262087584,
-0.0060569565,
-0.024310248,
-0.004079706,
-0.038255889,
0.011700891,
0.0334395804,
-0.0133795394,
0.1109446064,
0.0041709188,
-0.0147062102,
0.0270789638,
0.0428145602,
-0.0845498815,
-0.0771091357,
-0.0088818148,
0.0032802443,
0.0431344248,
0.0074631902,
0.0319004841,
-0.0577512197,
0.0050733895,
-0.0119728884,
0.0288495626,
-0.0042650858,
0.0120966667,
0.0251883138,
0.0236759558,
-0.0331593752,
-0.0014364873,
0.0659788772,
-0.0021811014,
0.0480905771,
0.0061269524,
0.0016697311,
-0.0485208258,
-0.0497410819,
0.0014102024,
0.0077315783,
-0.0070937518,
0.0102349762,
-0.0372654758,
-0.0693981275,
-0.0469426401,
-0.007010363,
-0.0064854068,
-0.0025238441,
0.0556993969,
0.0646644756,
-0.0373069234,
-0.0116733611,
-0.066424869,
0.0444471352,
-0.0480960906,
-0.0057428069,
0.0268983003,
-6.083578525e-33,
-0.0362081714,
-0.0292847976,
0.05581991,
-0.0039742221,
-0.0101504205,
-0.0344677158,
-0.0476348065,
-0.0053272075,
-0.0231566522,
0.0061614518,
-0.0166014452,
0.0149080865,
-0.0094865253,
0.012385441,
-0.0160085987,
-0.0032424026,
0.0406193323,
-0.0266708229,
-0.0096612414,
0.0544582941,
0.0541384593,
0.0360813104,
-0.0094076907,
-0.0457344986,
-0.019220233,
-0.0343613699,
0.0130494768,
0.0280601382,
0.0302827787,
0.0568849146,
-0.0246388651,
0.0159109067,
0.0284395814,
-0.0217033718,
-0.0003753652,
0.0185412355,
-0.0716358423,
-0.0319762751,
-0.0187270418,
-0.0209633503,
-0.0330159552,
-0.0311425421,
0.0187995788,
-0.0207040589,
0.0419186726,
0.000130706,
0.0209545065,
-0.0245921072,
0.0230666045,
-0.0099498285,
-0.0548662171,
0.0024931729,
-0.0314375535,
-0.0765588805,
-0.005063423,
0.070209384,
0.0329116844,
0.006603613,
0.0111855567,
0.0382775106,
-0.0000149928,
0.0144876419,
0.0550067574,
-0.0088165803,
0.0064944746,
0.0573336519,
-0.0054689581,
0.0230206605,
0.0122059276,
0.0130606024,
-0.0021001915,
0.0480394103,
0.0223516636,
0.0596332513,
0.0082520815,
-0.0107836192,
-0.0713986903,
0.0678513646,
0.0370481052,
0.0100934701,
-0.0179516748,
-0.0276621599,
-0.0086817602,
0.0265625231,
-0.0216141902,
0.0568068773,
-0.0156963896,
-0.0432119407,
0.0389685482,
0.020877542,
-0.022705989,
-0.07057143,
0.0090477979,
-0.0385778882,
0.0240667388,
0.0136009641,
-0.0666915029,
-0.0124765504,
-0.0189729873,
0.0226413198,
-0.0308459233,
-0.0247630551,
0.0466287285,
-0.0123852333,
-0.0003840015,
0.0356900766,
-0.0206525251,
-0.008170275,
-0.0347047038,
-0.0041685421,
-0.0510765761,
0.0612168647,
-0.0174520016,
-0.0143126054,
-0.007038088,
0.0306640863,
-0.0320358276,
0.0518747829,
0.0076265465,
0.0214264039,
-0.0380492322,
0.0140401861,
0.0121830022,
0.0031262611,
-0.0067602415,
-0.015860362,
-0.0139017869,
0.0018602746,
0.004556641,
-0.0671678782,
-0.0114913704,
-0.0111400969,
2.703e-7,
0.0069328817,
0.0559780486,
0.0045571271,
0.0277990997,
0.016715087,
0.0537508577,
0.0053283619,
0.0239656921,
0.0293726325,
-0.0297705457,
-0.0000265481,
0.0553337038,
0.0384418219,
0.0309962723,
-0.1007401273,
-0.0421262942,
-0.0093513951,
-0.0441950634,
-0.0310894102,
-0.0421933532,
0.0687708482,
0.0514357574,
-0.0121848984,
-0.0113096908,
-0.0135448771,
-0.0448977351,
0.0738549083,
0.0155960219,
-0.0355313905,
0.0598580725,
0.0182489194,
0.0363659784,
-0.0112918457,
0.020556001,
-0.0192402769,
0.0333829969,
-0.0050474233,
0.056511838,
0.0314121842,
-0.024445843,
0.0249588117,
0.0148018422,
0.0105511909,
-0.031660486,
0.0735746473,
-0.0755884871,
-0.0344779976,
-0.0334751084,
-0.0226522274,
-0.0247284379,
-0.0121238129,
-0.0370531268,
-0.0082442341,
0.0449506715,
-0.0159284957,
0.0018567957,
0.0133421663,
-0.0609563217,
0.008969455,
-0.0095513836,
-0.0499945208,
-0.0525473654,
-0.0519937687,
-0.0252768341,
-0.0063335127,
-0.04911853,
0.0227872077,
2.37536873e-34,
-0.0042227977,
0.0102068894,
0.0022462411,
0.0631722882,
0.0384942666,
0.0021757488,
0.0105486969,
0.0069415616,
0.0317597277,
-0.0778970569,
0.01155583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10596v1 | Hashing it Out: Predicting Unhealthy Conversations on Twitter | 2023-11-17T15:49:11 | 2023-11-17T15:49:11 | Steven Leung, Filippos Papapolyzos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Personal attacks in the context of social media conversations often lead to
fast-paced derailment, leading to even more harmful exchanges being made.
State-of-the-art systems for the detection of such conversational derailment
often make use of deep learning approaches for prediction purposes. In this
paper, we show that an Attention-based BERT architecture, pre-trained on a
large Twitter corpus and fine-tuned on our task, is efficient and effective in
making such predictions. This model shows clear advantages in performance to
the existing LSTM model we use as a baseline. Additionally, we show that this
impressive performance can be attained through fine-tuning on a relatively
small, novel dataset, particularly after mitigating overfitting issues through
synthetic oversampling techniques. By introducing the first transformer based
model for forecasting conversational events on Twitter, this work lays the
foundation for a practical tool to encourage better interactions on one of the
most ubiquitous social media platforms. | [
0.0498676077,
0.0358738638,
0.0042171995,
-0.0040602754,
0.0093836458,
0.0058617028,
0.0118784271,
0.0237218626,
0.0069203149,
-0.0249781534,
0.0099988217,
-0.0377773158,
-0.0349404551,
0.0392401852,
-0.0018834441,
-0.0417281762,
0.0052103824,
0.0310774893,
0.0282882303,
0.0143768657,
0.0622187033,
-0.002895134,
0.0268504005,
0.042189803,
-0.025219785,
0.0054817703,
-0.0022680778,
0.037239667,
0.0305860117,
-0.006185167,
0.0742557496,
0.053964369,
0.0267804451,
0.0704193339,
0.0000018967,
-0.0258632917,
-0.0071749273,
-0.0393668115,
0.004912694,
-0.0097282967,
0.0149545111,
-0.0587369278,
0.0080752643,
0.0424898826,
-0.0517898202,
0.0285828859,
0.0376830846,
0.0906421393,
0.0659641623,
0.0887965858,
-0.0151791377,
-0.0396764949,
0.0315439701,
-0.0375471711,
0.003833391,
-0.0237338077,
0.0131476354,
-0.0786783993,
-0.0392546691,
-0.0051246267,
0.0056729149,
0.0017481595,
0.0265142433,
-0.0135359718,
0.0206628349,
0.0068783546,
-0.0522712097,
-0.0085083051,
0.0019394259,
0.079329446,
-0.0541080348,
-0.0139475157,
0.0328603759,
0.0046884543,
-0.0116411233,
-0.036882557,
-0.0488339588,
-0.019340435,
0.0238733049,
0.0265022293,
-0.024972396,
0.0262967106,
0.0468341298,
0.0510952547,
0.0075822435,
-0.0252017491,
0.0027567632,
-0.0556585006,
-0.0112421941,
0.0002247935,
-0.0129644936,
-0.042307537,
0.023547532,
0.0191470142,
-0.0428922027,
-0.0219338909,
-0.052118592,
-0.0355202258,
-0.0066088913,
-0.0596527755,
-0.0014103797,
0.011596838,
0.0111089703,
-0.0084018437,
0.0120387338,
-0.0046170107,
-0.0591837689,
0.0022735817,
-0.0025145926,
-0.0233550891,
-0.0428706631,
0.003756746,
-0.0290682744,
-0.0038904625,
0.0150218364,
-0.0087016588,
-0.0649419501,
0.0072556781,
-0.0195536744,
-0.0287087727,
0.0080275973,
0.0261546113,
-0.0589278303,
-0.0134910196,
0.0121477731,
0.031795986,
-0.0171198249,
-0.0170791689,
-0.0095934337,
-0.072486721,
-0.0266658682,
0.0353692807,
0.0279576909,
-0.0241209846,
-0.0046498077,
0.0678288639,
0.014181816,
-0.0568846874,
-0.0302367751,
-0.0338935703,
-0.022003321,
-0.0192530379,
0.0267478041,
-0.0575934388,
0.0308888964,
-0.0310704242,
-0.0276986286,
-0.0023089948,
0.0302567147,
0.0151305366,
-0.027401004,
0.0301616956,
-0.0046409094,
0.0089060683,
0.0192660131,
0.0304177999,
0.0194295496,
0.0535573475,
0.042966038,
0.0508626029,
0.0302427094,
-0.0142632136,
0.0248386655,
0.0607102737,
0.0700643137,
-0.0072140396,
0.0077243107,
-0.0085356822,
-0.0525323153,
0.0165913571,
-0.0035994623,
0.0324313603,
-0.0123861395,
-0.0228719525,
0.0693270937,
0.0304970462,
-0.0216856152,
0.084591113,
0.0170951001,
0.0443508923,
-0.0446070507,
-0.0401629731,
-0.0381184854,
0.0201703385,
-0.0068528913,
-0.023086546,
0.023578994,
0.0219255891,
-0.0389823802,
-0.0150623666,
0.0075472868,
-0.0360921435,
0.0235370323,
-0.0457745157,
0.0179008134,
0.0091906469,
-0.0658359975,
0.1200082973,
0.0057415455,
-0.0083596008,
-0.0225334801,
-0.0232976433,
-0.00014775,
0.0816246718,
0.0149915032,
0.0170140173,
-0.0449143276,
-0.0870333165,
0.0491610691,
0.0550707132,
-0.0004594871,
0.0210426114,
0.019013878,
-0.0505190007,
-0.001996123,
0.0219426043,
-0.0390005521,
-0.0148737915,
0.0331610925,
0.0200028066,
0.0050620353,
0.0244921371,
-0.0400241651,
0.0062998347,
-0.0069622747,
-0.0373457,
0.019233875,
0.0263477135,
0.0508973263,
0.0068633743,
-0.0008637147,
-0.0400405601,
0.0154447164,
-0.0211923029,
-0.051469475,
0.0011343206,
-0.0317199454,
0.0082843425,
0.033734329,
-0.0387773551,
-0.0435370319,
0.0639981702,
-0.0547988042,
-0.0016376927,
0.0792748258,
-0.0731173381,
0.0205191541,
-0.0224815868,
-0.0257479791,
-0.0140617657,
0.0301063564,
0.0335326158,
0.0395605452,
-0.0600970574,
-0.02178373,
-0.0106094731,
-0.0366771556,
-0.0006499126,
0.0039458862,
-0.0385850929,
-0.0192805286,
-0.0258646682,
0.014101089,
0.0291461106,
0.0291919522,
-0.033877939,
-0.0141970851,
-0.0848528445,
0.0033936359,
-0.0516369082,
-0.0237433296,
0.0133455731,
0.0271150954,
-0.0065768887,
-0.0050947554,
-0.0268155057,
-0.0283267032,
0.0172088332,
-0.0122978166,
0.0212247558,
-0.030488845,
-0.0082213022,
-0.0330070034,
0.003307478,
-0.0243132636,
0.0342754275,
-0.0146865742,
-0.0435256548,
0.0126425466,
-0.0510085784,
-0.0049149399,
0.0458063148,
-0.0045454325,
-0.0664139315,
-0.0066864653,
0.006461835,
0.0056361393,
0.0307799652,
0.0879666507,
0.0559686981,
-0.0364941582,
0.004640541,
-0.0320285521,
0.0433095656,
-0.0330454595,
-0.0215413123,
-0.0421004519,
-0.0409777723,
0.0004251692,
0.083895497,
-0.0163814425,
0.039952185,
-0.0615671985,
-0.0252939127,
0.021185156,
-0.0059598479,
-0.0264092907,
-0.0100343656,
-0.0191355795,
-0.0047829291,
-0.0302522797,
-0.0529860705,
0.0650962144,
0.0242577344,
0.0081445612,
-0.0083843647,
-0.0319318585,
-0.0011099592,
0.0122460248,
0.0163048021,
0.0049609384,
0.0216901712,
-0.0167859867,
0.0011500447,
-0.0283066854,
-0.0113409637,
-0.019227067,
0.0180958733,
0.0181178842,
0.0052972515,
0.0197882503,
-0.0287471246,
-0.0405335799,
-0.0642205477,
-0.049470935,
-0.0349418335,
-0.0177396704,
-0.0439246893,
-0.0549032986,
-0.0229754373,
-0.0272385068,
-0.0150380079,
-0.0102458308,
-0.0065876613,
0.0108184675,
0.049453184,
0.0494608432,
-0.0057670334,
-0.0064495024,
-0.0311438832,
0.0234207828,
0.077961646,
0.0042521916,
0.0198721439,
-0.0465590879,
-0.0350136682,
-0.0008339567,
-0.0019136509,
-0.002558222,
0.0025236052,
0.0347570851,
-0.0127255572,
-0.0255956911,
0.1275033951,
0.0024282075,
0.0042801616,
0.0133749638,
0.0218120683,
0.0249177944,
-0.0110275596,
-0.0097515685,
-0.0818991736,
-0.0467506722,
-0.0405412614,
0.0312148649,
-0.014375492,
-0.0497566536,
0.0071135564,
-0.0610775873,
0.0026515999,
-0.0229654908,
0.010296165,
-0.0447486974,
-0.0030065216,
-0.0010538991,
-0.0214029495,
0.0488344021,
-0.047261633,
0.0103050722,
-0.0219582282,
0.0095337182,
-0.0780654922,
-0.0372948013,
0.0402999111,
-0.0607797317,
0.038903676,
0.0332816318,
0.0939714685,
-0.0353836492,
-0.0146521982,
0.0210552961,
0.0360457525,
0.0024353026,
-0.0058760797,
0.0766638815,
-0.0176847577,
-0.0225440525,
-0.045351509,
0.0330473706,
-0.0448678061,
-0.013166422,
-0.0383305959,
0.0501844995,
-0.0049197604,
-0.031249864,
-0.0192261431,
0.0349743292,
0.0435944386,
0.0444826558,
0.0474405885,
-0.0589451082,
-0.0313784927,
-0.0263837054,
-0.0231961682,
-0.071086742,
-0.0213428251,
-0.0150501868,
0.0058634407,
-0.0593330525,
-0.037122447,
-0.0399359167,
0.0095420191,
-0.0394987911,
-0.0378381237,
-0.0634889826,
0.01690281,
-0.0161666609,
-0.0474751592,
0.0283259097,
0.0106940074,
0.0409167819,
-0.0334376022,
0.0184053816,
-0.0053776759,
0.0151477819,
0.0066794534,
0.0558385551,
-0.0944788978,
-0.050302498,
0.0298735313,
0.0585895516,
0.0181086306,
0.0348958485,
-0.0204664003,
-0.0548887923,
0.0340402648,
0.0456408337,
-0.011004352,
-0.0276883058,
0.050816413,
0.0179883558,
0.0295742266,
0.0397692546,
0.0012986306,
0.036520943,
-0.0029218453,
-0.0388069339,
-0.0757680535,
-0.0215341039,
-0.0363435373,
-0.0350357331,
0.0686450377,
0.0288280193,
-0.057594534,
0.0100583341,
-0.0158817694,
0.026185099,
0.0078753978,
-0.0002872521,
0.0117127988,
0.0407244973,
0.0048818332,
-0.0332118534,
0.0396314301,
-0.0323006548,
-0.0250846315,
-0.0899500102,
0.0417423286,
-0.0056506325,
0.0072045652,
0.0181909371,
0.0144851683,
-0.0011273089,
-0.0026209869,
0.0338135138,
0.0190710463,
0.0056803324,
0.0056650494,
-0.0120924534,
0.0406039394,
0.0294402428,
0.0045063519,
-0.0436308533,
-0.0234764479,
-0.036400605,
-0.0177673139,
-0.012010308,
-0.0214637704,
0.0618277788,
0.0156466197,
0.0087653724,
0.0076567098,
0.0396491662,
-0.0698444545,
-0.0224674437,
-0.0023197825,
-0.0096316282,
-0.0273158848,
0.0145571604,
0.0677388385,
-0.0167449694,
0.0143901072,
0.0661863685,
-0.0325304344,
-0.0217931084,
0.0156768057,
0.033348944,
0.0369815417,
0.0147933764,
0.0163291264,
0.0147334468,
-0.0408099294,
0.0497184582,
-0.0590998307,
0.0287439935,
-0.0089633437,
0.0429847464,
0.0358175561,
0.0099126725,
0.0292571951,
-0.0006708607,
0.0137672694,
0.0280009191,
-0.0707283765,
-0.0290887672,
-5.846655435e-33,
0.0402758792,
-0.0323540084,
-0.0314044803,
0.0157365445,
-0.0405821763,
-0.0006870303,
-0.0168177765,
-0.018463064,
-0.0221477356,
0.0214110706,
0.0056244708,
0.0821898878,
-0.0105446614,
0.033219222,
0.0042745639,
-0.0469884276,
0.0244245008,
-0.0097618401,
0.0075946273,
0.056871511,
0.0616204105,
0.0443409979,
0.0628021508,
-0.0594279207,
-0.0122714983,
-0.0311241895,
0.0013675442,
0.0097513767,
0.0565749593,
0.049285613,
-0.0093664154,
0.0732725859,
0.030040646,
-0.0257878341,
0.0212196428,
0.1044358313,
-0.0135024739,
-0.0414027236,
-0.0237507056,
-0.0234429464,
-0.0068718209,
-0.0210991073,
0.0541527383,
0.029745521,
-0.0064923023,
-0.0326258875,
0.0238813963,
0.0407445133,
0.0296654608,
-0.053245835,
-0.0273146294,
0.0160983913,
-0.047019273,
-0.0391738042,
-0.0208886713,
0.0563885905,
0.0373820812,
0.0289923865,
-0.0782966092,
-0.0062329131,
-0.0048556207,
0.0002647638,
0.0098802811,
-0.0322693884,
-0.0354673043,
0.0343765803,
0.0104291206,
0.0416036062,
-0.0288058408,
-0.0095084598,
-0.010006425,
0.0622933283,
0.056665644,
0.0478816107,
0.0225576796,
-0.0543133058,
-0.0977493227,
0.0383853056,
0.0515296571,
0.0477949381,
0.0162265766,
-0.022267608,
-0.03280003,
-0.0148053365,
0.0425531454,
-0.0205718558,
-0.0036246346,
-0.0063740918,
-0.0238007382,
0.0169822555,
0.0141528081,
0.0273835976,
0.0231028926,
-0.0450557023,
0.0418285392,
0.0224972088,
0.0150069967,
0.0062543433,
0.0178059358,
0.0372072048,
-0.041753795,
0.0027084744,
0.0367950946,
-0.0138538843,
0.0089760851,
-0.0095513808,
0.0541851893,
0.0293507315,
-0.0381391719,
-0.0087220958,
-0.0113200685,
0.0499049798,
-0.0477135181,
0.0454331152,
-0.0072428673,
0.0450922996,
-0.0122955963,
0.0133932829,
0.0328817666,
0.0401997827,
-0.0210143235,
-0.0050895922,
0.0111416029,
-0.0127134109,
0.0001045023,
-0.0047779675,
-0.0392685905,
0.0099764597,
0.0075102979,
-0.1003017798,
-0.0083781872,
-0.0415747352,
2.665e-7,
0.0089606717,
0.0798345208,
0.036603041,
0.0028421362,
0.0372291803,
0.041013021,
0.0651604384,
0.089199625,
-0.0015658619,
-0.0479822271,
0.0192366522,
0.0125028351,
0.0314108469,
0.0424884893,
-0.05638716,
-0.0485287383,
-0.1238754094,
0.0035420456,
-0.0349323265,
-0.035662923,
0.0213518422,
0.0891628042,
0.0443881601,
-0.0412395932,
0.0391001329,
0.0002291964,
0.050629586,
-0.0457024314,
-0.0256623831,
0.0105032194,
0.0551132225,
0.0217471942,
-0.0062995469,
0.0071231415,
-0.0304293633,
0.026627304,
-0.0229449403,
0.018580962,
-0.0067910841,
-0.0285626147,
0.0068867318,
-0.0244229306,
0.0087267086,
-0.0494861454,
0.0200361013,
-0.0776547864,
-0.0476225391,
-0.0014505977,
-0.0208839159,
0.0280577503,
0.0352900699,
-0.0255896598,
-0.0042796102,
0.0168521889,
0.0305889267,
-0.0083722668,
0.0068921512,
-0.0991605222,
-0.0003802798,
0.0026306997,
-0.0541826859,
-0.0216085557,
-0.0486582033,
-0.0531015769,
0.0420066081,
0.0003669371,
0.0515580773,
2.016642752e-34,
0.0379705764,
0.0146150505,
0.0052386499,
0.0127834799,
0.0026470658,
0.0194596052,
0.0263555311,
-0.0258277301,
0.0519905277,
-0.0432752073,
-0.022553375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10587v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10587v1 | Countering Misinformation via Emotional Response Generation | 2023-11-17T15:37:18 | 2023-11-17T15:37:18 | Daniel Russo, Shane Peter Kaszefski-Yaschuk, Jacopo Staiano, Marco Guerini | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of misinformation on social media platforms (SMPs) poses a
significant danger to public health, social cohesion and ultimately democracy.
Previous research has shown how social correction can be an effective way to
curb misinformation, by engaging directly in a constructive dialogue with users
who spread -- often in good faith -- misleading messages. Although professional
fact-checkers are crucial to debunking viral claims, they usually do not engage
in conversations on social media. Thereby, significant effort has been made to
automate the use of fact-checker material in social correction; however, no
previous work has tried to integrate it with the style and pragmatics that are
commonly employed in social media communication. To fill this gap, we present
VerMouth, the first large-scale dataset comprising roughly 12 thousand
claim-response pairs (linked to debunking articles), accounting for both
SMP-style and basic emotions, two factors which have a significant role in
misinformation credibility and spreading. To collect this dataset we used a
technique based on an author-reviewer pipeline, which efficiently combines LLMs
and human annotators to obtain high-quality data. We also provide comprehensive
experiments showing how models trained on our proposed dataset have significant
improvements in terms of output quality and generalization capabilities. | [
0.0652789026,
0.0307401363,
-0.0006833497,
-0.0028874963,
-0.0049035372,
0.008710376,
-0.0039429804,
-0.0136394408,
0.0166186728,
-0.0544952974,
-0.0230965149,
-0.010500337,
-0.0107033057,
0.0153526394,
0.0437949635,
-0.0335929394,
0.0188376382,
0.0515269414,
0.074419409,
-0.0249208547,
0.025700625,
0.0460665673,
-0.0022198434,
0.0215155389,
-0.0354027487,
-0.0148481671,
0.0441514887,
0.0384568982,
0.0630412251,
-0.0407369137,
0.0425223187,
0.066740334,
0.0437875502,
0.0526799001,
0.0000015256,
-0.0302115977,
0.02148523,
0.0011874497,
-0.0293086283,
-0.0096670799,
0.0596396402,
-0.0441363677,
-0.0040291236,
0.038466353,
-0.0306036491,
-0.0166258439,
0.0436871387,
0.0542452447,
0.0994818807,
0.1285969615,
-0.0168576036,
-0.0184585545,
0.0082508167,
0.0024447646,
0.0194730256,
-0.0043251016,
0.0504890122,
0.0053952453,
-0.0243860707,
0.0215312894,
0.0410347022,
0.0154395178,
-0.0023800877,
-0.0277417507,
0.0070060291,
-0.0061976607,
-0.0133191701,
-0.0428782776,
-0.016432954,
0.0581099205,
0.0373008326,
-0.0502186865,
0.0080527589,
-0.0085522402,
0.0188495144,
0.0571784601,
-0.0359433815,
0.0298146904,
-0.0415974893,
0.0221788492,
-0.0297473855,
-0.0320416391,
0.0400077589,
0.0515108481,
0.0761508271,
0.0096093854,
-0.0239267796,
-0.025314359,
0.0321145132,
0.0492824912,
0.0377054885,
-0.0470011793,
0.0013289332,
0.0087944353,
-0.001362024,
-0.0081636766,
-0.0311383884,
-0.0194762852,
0.0544026308,
-0.0916025564,
-0.0044415733,
-0.0109189525,
-0.004563855,
0.0257533342,
-0.006695509,
-0.0366448015,
-0.0223507937,
0.027862709,
0.0420311764,
0.0142025091,
-0.0289745834,
0.0295739025,
0.0080560558,
0.0010162087,
-0.0088927215,
0.0420894548,
-0.0786939114,
-0.0297241285,
-0.048614461,
0.0144237531,
-0.018693218,
0.0284123514,
-0.0094847148,
-0.0120830955,
-0.0380035825,
0.0548684783,
-0.0004556189,
0.0334794596,
-0.0020803141,
-0.0507807098,
-0.0145049365,
0.0138855949,
0.0127976611,
0.0111997537,
0.0232670978,
-0.0050269254,
0.0254830103,
0.0114511503,
-0.0373368599,
-0.0189306121,
-0.0032788182,
-0.0574006364,
0.0257459749,
-0.0593565516,
0.0430127531,
-0.0178566854,
-0.0467644371,
-0.0437125489,
0.0210859012,
0.031171469,
-0.0407654047,
0.0420226529,
-0.0357059538,
0.0071081398,
0.0582217723,
0.0181429926,
-0.0033016691,
0.0486871563,
0.0216729343,
0.0565548353,
0.0590205863,
-0.0017256958,
0.0498419702,
-0.0035041168,
0.060824126,
0.0098472089,
0.041759301,
-0.0135021359,
-0.0376550518,
0.0008164174,
0.0387295894,
0.0475327522,
-0.0336084999,
-0.0387618169,
0.0699909106,
-0.025414018,
-0.0466668494,
0.0220271591,
0.0455631912,
0.0205890089,
0.033023838,
-0.0103461407,
-0.0361162275,
0.0373612083,
-0.0364957377,
-0.0378062241,
0.0191366971,
0.0356837735,
-0.0208592992,
-0.0243944656,
-0.0243286714,
0.0017061859,
0.0161043871,
0.0135075497,
-0.0194689818,
0.0206158627,
-0.035464257,
0.0221056473,
0.0462403893,
-0.0245910883,
-0.0183324609,
-0.0358590931,
0.0219448879,
0.0279325973,
0.0140762255,
0.0035425241,
0.00039619,
-0.0647949651,
0.0422758497,
0.0460023955,
0.0841922387,
-0.0443944037,
-0.0287036132,
-0.0267485678,
-0.0018989613,
-0.0393925197,
0.003270254,
0.0048161238,
0.0610704385,
0.0015614413,
0.001880427,
-0.0059598018,
-0.0452168696,
0.0241655577,
-0.0138041545,
0.0047348272,
0.0004106654,
0.0123635661,
0.0316684768,
0.0378978066,
-0.0145363444,
-0.0196013357,
0.0420402922,
0.0222292468,
-0.0542702973,
-0.0054774447,
0.0354509689,
-0.0012651352,
0.0240640529,
-0.0329012871,
-0.059479937,
0.020120116,
-0.0574342124,
0.0219272021,
0.0088711977,
-0.0122436127,
-0.0051619802,
-0.030359203,
-0.0260652844,
-0.0071779839,
0.0133688441,
0.0102747325,
0.0380680859,
-0.0268666521,
-0.0131849078,
-0.0385029539,
-0.0357575119,
-0.0281603709,
-0.0326598659,
-0.0045389519,
-0.0228790902,
0.0103129139,
0.008915049,
0.0208543111,
-0.0269378275,
-0.0453294143,
-0.0173619315,
-0.0863786265,
-0.0067319423,
-0.0233021826,
0.0033563229,
0.0344203785,
-0.0179796536,
0.0054446692,
0.0003970754,
-0.038972903,
0.0133249806,
0.0359258205,
0.0244141538,
0.0379398912,
-0.0198675655,
0.0093527446,
-0.04712376,
0.0176951643,
-0.0343574807,
0.0052800849,
0.0485068262,
-0.0392758101,
-0.0479903109,
-0.0080427118,
-0.0802338645,
0.0226812232,
-0.0194637626,
-0.0350385495,
0.0284262449,
0.0499377325,
-0.0064847604,
0.0366475321,
0.0481740534,
0.0473305248,
0.0075286482,
0.0621612258,
-0.029774202,
-0.0004060327,
-0.039448984,
0.0124959461,
-0.03346733,
-0.0684661344,
0.0087209912,
0.0126463259,
0.0200100522,
0.0156180691,
-0.0199622214,
0.0433798134,
0.0437244661,
-0.0434963964,
0.0215183198,
-0.0433753617,
-0.0092697358,
0.0221538655,
-0.0515254922,
-0.0422849618,
0.0756834894,
0.0118892472,
0.0410691202,
-0.028801959,
-0.0084007317,
-0.0146296201,
-0.0039480194,
-0.0214146692,
0.0163410045,
-0.0315981694,
0.0409294814,
-0.0047163158,
-0.0663629249,
0.0410403349,
-0.0327444747,
0.0136863953,
-0.0433930866,
0.0279318038,
0.0249933545,
-0.0477967151,
-0.0381760523,
-0.0921639055,
-0.0644729137,
-0.0400244631,
-0.0240087695,
-0.0283963624,
-0.0759596676,
-0.0660910532,
0.0657963306,
-0.0032572728,
0.0040439339,
-0.0283727273,
0.0565336831,
-0.0003370129,
0.0490828976,
0.0210512057,
0.0899617374,
-0.0285851043,
0.0062328004,
0.0810000375,
-0.0035985797,
0.0044193193,
-0.018962618,
-0.0497819632,
-0.017750496,
0.0007835818,
0.0167270806,
-0.0187113229,
0.0607681014,
-0.0363443792,
0.0206641424,
0.0645372719,
0.0007869994,
-0.0154030984,
-0.0029591378,
-0.024722958,
-0.0052900994,
0.0271302406,
0.0120053496,
-0.0985460728,
0.0007613434,
-0.039472688,
0.0129866283,
-0.0263536125,
-0.0188305546,
-0.0063616838,
-0.0846428275,
0.0594822541,
0.0051069278,
0.0098735048,
-0.02744033,
-0.0611951612,
0.012373385,
-0.0088696787,
-0.0129661793,
-0.0085345721,
0.0184747502,
-0.0054971338,
0.0107477047,
-0.0137686767,
-0.0412595607,
0.0228832699,
-0.0122318482,
0.0649238452,
0.0146231037,
0.073542811,
-0.0045572608,
-0.0476603284,
0.0338689201,
0.0393802896,
-0.0334530771,
-0.0147154713,
0.0986267775,
-0.0316561684,
0.0006875905,
-0.0492219664,
0.0637484044,
-0.0083880033,
-0.0342324562,
-0.0114644459,
0.0361959264,
-0.0077211447,
-0.0563995279,
-0.0442620441,
0.0602876842,
0.0335750282,
0.0543096922,
0.0182661023,
0.0051505617,
-0.0351838619,
-0.0316358209,
0.0084078358,
-0.0201742314,
-0.0622465126,
0.0252116956,
-0.0264772847,
-0.0328124277,
-0.0687275752,
-0.0261389278,
0.0087536508,
0.0105157513,
-0.0284892526,
-0.049376633,
0.0341026559,
-0.0085085584,
-0.0078205224,
0.0239522103,
-0.0179099552,
0.0378243066,
0.0081678182,
-0.0217072535,
0.0237381551,
-0.0366937444,
0.004332535,
0.0199578013,
-0.0656083003,
-0.0720747039,
-0.0033592591,
0.0441022739,
0.0250063725,
0.0630730838,
0.0218376014,
-0.0542100258,
0.0353019945,
0.056116581,
-0.009851709,
0.0080760894,
0.0199476369,
0.0376925357,
0.0068387324,
-0.0044096708,
-0.0125691285,
0.0251970775,
0.0240796618,
-0.004871123,
-0.0479532294,
-0.0263549276,
0.0197294094,
0.0166261699,
0.0300580766,
-0.0082626995,
-0.0140143456,
-0.0382528938,
-0.0367011093,
-0.0143027762,
-0.0231203213,
0.0004965095,
0.0112248389,
-0.0166757517,
-0.0063830675,
-0.0426849648,
-0.0296111945,
-0.0480733998,
0.0585936122,
-0.0483624674,
0.0082135219,
0.0165167842,
0.0137699079,
-0.0102003086,
-0.0165497325,
-0.0267952867,
0.0320286863,
0.0209809877,
0.0294735115,
0.0290336758,
0.0151387751,
0.0092737051,
0.0087584173,
0.0274848007,
-0.0320434645,
-0.0663018376,
-0.010230286,
-0.0416119583,
0.0128945271,
0.0159088373,
0.0175532717,
0.0585298203,
-0.0048913038,
-0.0422021374,
0.0137243383,
0.0050765178,
-0.0355685949,
-0.0159385875,
0.0338827223,
0.0033966147,
-0.0450120531,
0.0150859375,
0.0272242054,
-0.0502054058,
0.0555631593,
0.0198387001,
-0.0898056999,
-0.0347057544,
-0.0668025911,
-0.0037113973,
-0.0047665564,
0.0335388593,
-0.0175724123,
-0.0790311173,
-0.0535340346,
0.0450293422,
0.0172700454,
0.0153984148,
-0.0247216839,
-0.0288829394,
0.0771621168,
0.0244596694,
0.0228135977,
-0.0525723621,
0.0225124247,
-0.0206289738,
-0.0409004986,
-0.0350829139,
-5.840017933e-33,
0.0203757901,
-0.0554470122,
-0.0243109204,
0.0167685635,
-0.026514085,
0.0235637464,
-0.0040861545,
-0.0086552678,
-0.0259733386,
0.0830671266,
0.0051995385,
0.0466274731,
-0.0080838557,
-0.0240784753,
-0.0238442458,
-0.0174967851,
0.0509799086,
-0.0278733522,
-0.0353250764,
0.0190006196,
0.0253194552,
-0.0024295389,
0.0204250887,
-0.1029540002,
0.0563365072,
-0.017042771,
-0.0392571501,
0.0121041257,
-0.0002889775,
0.0220153853,
0.0141549408,
0.0656171367,
0.0329196081,
0.0208901558,
0.0106677869,
0.0329948366,
-0.0447291471,
-0.012263054,
0.0222318955,
-0.0394891426,
-0.0306561515,
0.0143106747,
0.0691192001,
-0.0048558256,
-0.028751323,
0.0008134738,
0.0177119467,
-0.0144286714,
0.029405782,
-0.0682374984,
-0.0463810265,
-0.0043018176,
0.0107902754,
0.0015002728,
-0.0740998685,
0.06263607,
-0.004861929,
0.025155358,
-0.1213562191,
0.0162998382,
-0.0229422692,
-0.022028612,
0.0100316824,
-0.0575949363,
-0.0105691859,
0.0603759885,
0.0163661726,
0.0595732369,
-0.066558212,
0.0316980518,
-0.024807645,
0.0331385359,
0.0493171401,
0.1362696439,
-0.0025643813,
-0.0610751025,
-0.0764447004,
0.0423749313,
0.0259622764,
0.0228591263,
0.0121232653,
-0.0296233948,
-0.0113065755,
0.0157221146,
-0.024693897,
-0.0005450562,
-0.0046422319,
-0.0158676635,
-0.0262223221,
0.02869609,
-0.0221613348,
0.0060956934,
-0.0314550586,
-0.034006156,
0.0081903823,
0.0267114211,
-0.0216540657,
0.0221510734,
0.0217289887,
-0.0224642232,
-0.0333212353,
0.0308101792,
0.0196734183,
0.046423886,
0.0320027657,
-0.0036250032,
0.0677534863,
0.0043341895,
-0.0541059189,
0.018751353,
-0.0216800254,
0.0874794126,
-0.019823283,
-0.0187899768,
-0.0039644795,
0.0292698909,
-0.0206229687,
-0.0058140843,
-0.0021671068,
0.0475790091,
0.023232026,
0.0082807913,
-0.0033314051,
0.0374088176,
-0.0341297798,
0.0206142068,
-0.0136828944,
0.0000254097,
-0.0171243902,
-0.0906012133,
0.0094429459,
-0.0169275533,
2.463e-7,
0.0212226156,
0.0479051247,
0.0223201253,
-0.007040326,
0.0385157242,
0.0375326313,
0.0326027162,
0.0065484014,
0.0283588842,
-0.0963571817,
0.0103404988,
0.0439424813,
0.0304273665,
0.046379488,
-0.044952374,
0.0026181473,
-0.0673034042,
-0.0001975807,
-0.0145431105,
-0.0142656872,
0.0015648933,
0.020413436,
0.0352236293,
-0.0371461883,
-0.0189297367,
0.0329556912,
0.087810576,
0.0032253582,
-0.0319725275,
0.021105228,
0.074641183,
-0.0379768759,
0.0167226195,
0.0133960564,
-0.0357913338,
-0.0179451872,
-0.0233445056,
0.0373778641,
0.0165089518,
-0.0369227901,
0.0109021049,
-0.0093087507,
0.0348296501,
-0.0373872705,
0.0170140043,
-0.0661918446,
-0.0607666932,
-0.061389301,
-0.0545088612,
0.0050364058,
0.0441251323,
-0.0328204371,
-0.026764689,
0.0326551199,
0.0054931426,
0.0148635786,
0.0125287054,
-0.0442457795,
-0.0148478029,
0.0022324517,
-0.0624282844,
-0.0541738942,
0.0305421855,
-0.0101497555,
0.0067034364,
-0.0163752697,
0.0446265824,
1.822043106e-34,
0.0449657813,
-0.012340975,
-0.0103861615,
-0.0313996933,
0.0481420904,
0.0428684503,
-0.0444476865,
-0.0213020854,
0.0305405762,
-0.0229048971,
0.0046579372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10541v1 | Detection of Offensive and Threatening Online Content in a Low Resource Language | 2023-11-17T14:08:44 | 2023-11-17T14:08:44 | Fatima Muhammad Adam, Abubakar Yakubu Zandam, Isa Inuwa-Dutse | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hausa is a major Chadic language, spoken by over 100 million people in
Africa. However, from a computational linguistic perspective, it is considered
a low-resource language, with limited resources to support Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. Online platforms often facilitate social interactions
that can lead to the use of offensive and threatening language, which can go
undetected due to the lack of detection systems designed for Hausa. This study
aimed to address this issue by (1) conducting two user studies (n=308) to
investigate cyberbullying-related issues, (2) collecting and annotating the
first set of offensive and threatening datasets to support relevant downstream
tasks in Hausa, (3) developing a detection system to flag offensive and
threatening content, and (4) evaluating the detection system and the efficacy
of the Google-based translation engine in detecting offensive and threatening
terms in Hausa. We found that offensive and threatening content is quite
common, particularly when discussing religion and politics. Our detection
system was able to detect more than 70% of offensive and threatening content,
although many of these were mistranslated by Google's translation engine. We
attribute this to the subtle relationship between offensive and threatening
content and idiomatic expressions in the Hausa language. We recommend that
diverse stakeholders participate in understanding local conventions and
demographics in order to develop a more effective detection system. These
insights are essential for implementing targeted moderation strategies to
create a safe and inclusive online environment. | [
0.1162782758,
0.0393067338,
-0.0513406843,
0.0080407271,
0.0096013378,
0.0437630117,
0.058888115,
0.023759,
0.0587036535,
-0.0457745343,
0.0013088991,
-0.0558743551,
0.0269247629,
0.0067027146,
0.0055162073,
-0.0522183813,
0.013170097,
0.03662486,
0.0529393218,
0.0098598897,
0.0605858117,
0.0474088751,
-0.0080810646,
0.0400272347,
-0.039283324,
0.0087967319,
0.0323347487,
-0.0107062329,
0.0195784364,
-0.0092006139,
0.0114815598,
0.0225155856,
-0.030951228,
0.0418390147,
0.0000018222,
-0.0821927041,
0.0205823779,
-0.0163072497,
-0.019090211,
-0.0256789681,
0.1125297472,
-0.0246410109,
-0.0664752051,
0.041699551,
-0.0233987682,
0.0128812725,
0.0817329139,
0.0104079237,
0.0740024224,
0.0465315469,
-0.0110436119,
-0.0495300144,
-0.0198536422,
0.0330996625,
-0.0103928111,
0.0573264435,
0.0351499245,
-0.0086147292,
-0.0393138118,
0.0064525949,
-0.0085757552,
0.0098799895,
-0.0003389968,
-0.0194514971,
-0.0474326238,
-0.0354057215,
-0.064067699,
-0.0803367421,
0.0301408023,
0.0185151994,
-0.0183151308,
-0.0146699613,
-0.0106989844,
0.0188296624,
-0.0254493393,
0.0105589312,
-0.0182760693,
0.0393653214,
-0.0315645933,
0.0108285742,
0.0229721293,
0.0233846698,
0.0445860326,
0.0678462461,
0.0152005432,
0.0065434836,
-0.0277585872,
-0.014827936,
0.0015493233,
-0.0224972498,
-0.0075805481,
0.0159443393,
0.0365132391,
0.0027084614,
-0.0193345919,
0.0128154857,
-0.0144400587,
-0.0621404536,
0.0445094034,
-0.0996048674,
0.0140854828,
0.0453754254,
-0.0276861507,
0.002063788,
0.0137727968,
0.0285983011,
0.0167998355,
0.0029154697,
0.011206232,
0.0037181231,
-0.0239843298,
0.016494615,
0.0045811492,
-0.0342361741,
0.033999905,
0.0607394986,
-0.0762859061,
0.0026637383,
-0.0577827431,
-0.0192364957,
-0.0024016446,
-0.0285529252,
-0.015934661,
0.006446728,
0.0034482852,
0.0178807043,
-0.0490805395,
0.0368689336,
-0.0571164116,
-0.1175144389,
0.0634649172,
0.0038470298,
-0.0260366183,
-0.0031681759,
0.0353298299,
0.066076681,
0.0145056825,
-0.0175725874,
-0.0408498906,
-0.0406773016,
-0.0315477699,
-0.0153962923,
-0.0175514147,
-0.0644600019,
0.0519431867,
0.0106088724,
-0.0163240917,
-0.0679879561,
0.0169353429,
0.0137301795,
-0.0268882662,
0.0617639981,
0.005170661,
-0.0021875505,
0.081632033,
0.036096137,
0.0083902068,
0.0406965464,
-0.0030748432,
0.0116135934,
0.0528601035,
0.0186445434,
-0.0371262021,
0.0293354914,
-0.016749613,
0.0136610502,
-0.0126852393,
0.012695835,
-0.0288949739,
-0.0420746692,
-0.0020886874,
0.0541140921,
0.0040483056,
-0.0238681398,
0.0315626524,
0.0515248589,
-0.0576627068,
0.0572473183,
0.032218188,
0.0402733907,
-0.0175577775,
-0.058400631,
-0.0365157463,
-0.0348943248,
-0.016497165,
-0.079120189,
0.027751226,
0.0999900997,
0.0049501695,
-0.0457364656,
-0.0236282106,
0.000895543,
0.0559156016,
-0.0349496976,
0.0289775543,
0.0355529673,
0.0171331819,
-0.0436139815,
0.0637687892,
-0.0437128879,
0.017124394,
-0.0197589546,
0.0075117671,
0.0519957542,
-0.0071059284,
0.0369185135,
-0.0085719163,
-0.0651679635,
0.0355108231,
0.0445859954,
-0.0100025451,
0.0110071171,
-0.0168091785,
-0.018215593,
-0.025840098,
0.0567320213,
-0.0350081921,
-0.0256725177,
0.0697476417,
0.0510812812,
0.0279622953,
0.0557747781,
-0.0612884201,
0.0248528309,
0.0234796479,
0.0078149969,
-0.0286502354,
0.0448512696,
0.0593204163,
-0.0028703175,
-0.0010065917,
-0.0501662008,
-0.0310961287,
-0.0200830437,
-0.0204137415,
0.0234747864,
0.0067406497,
0.0383261852,
0.038344685,
-0.0683158785,
-0.0047131171,
0.027009489,
0.0179272853,
0.0461574569,
0.0742432624,
-0.0529854521,
-0.0470281914,
-0.0373142734,
-0.0326547027,
-0.0638101771,
0.0327643864,
-0.0033076203,
0.055316478,
-0.0201633908,
-0.0118115507,
0.0032865894,
-0.0561753921,
0.0449881293,
0.0479752831,
-0.0474394336,
0.0033207168,
-0.0423096716,
0.0052676387,
0.019202983,
0.0149951605,
-0.0132353641,
0.0102385003,
-0.0479208976,
-0.0195225012,
0.0058169076,
0.0162842702,
0.0359562524,
0.0414877795,
-0.0281865075,
0.0234003589,
0.0120718656,
-0.0310074426,
0.0190593824,
0.0205249935,
-0.0025772327,
-0.0568499118,
-0.0197857842,
-0.0082682017,
0.0118777044,
-0.0088389721,
0.0233256556,
0.0460480861,
-0.0881737396,
0.0499859676,
0.0001327892,
-0.0658836514,
0.0133456104,
0.001479311,
-0.0904080644,
0.0495314561,
0.0027479972,
-0.0109942034,
0.0171171483,
0.0567794591,
0.0599821359,
0.0456875004,
0.0150663182,
-0.0067788078,
-0.019332597,
-0.0169206746,
-0.0268602017,
-0.0050681359,
-0.0504612885,
-0.0053212247,
0.0510492325,
0.0610295124,
0.0054054568,
-0.0384880044,
0.0331565477,
-0.0933862552,
-0.0290176049,
-0.0528816022,
-0.0486188158,
0.0045695682,
0.0120430812,
-0.0151318749,
-0.0361162275,
0.0624054931,
0.0386483036,
0.0107279215,
-0.0154298954,
-0.0030719084,
0.0230244845,
0.0105569633,
-0.0193771683,
0.0656228289,
-0.018242484,
-0.0331234448,
0.0236210302,
0.0090487329,
0.0709333196,
-0.0176073369,
-0.0365931019,
-0.0092461398,
0.00120516,
0.0204150025,
-0.0396844,
-0.0378270037,
-0.0264985226,
-0.0412344709,
-0.0436322913,
0.0375935361,
0.0057777283,
-0.0106141223,
0.0312965773,
0.0371494778,
-0.0381702147,
0.02819716,
-0.0117042549,
0.0338941664,
-0.0443118624,
-0.0400718004,
-0.0428769477,
0.0327538699,
0.0230694562,
-0.0094953962,
0.0663592964,
-0.0435194895,
-0.0557983108,
0.0087957159,
0.0104280077,
0.0253232401,
0.0048077046,
-0.0278453622,
-0.0015657556,
0.0040247538,
0.002158307,
-0.0015991108,
0.0593357161,
0.0310827214,
-0.0067358729,
-0.010464713,
-0.0431454219,
-0.0001008405,
0.0208008774,
-0.011762104,
-0.0639571175,
0.0015684896,
-0.0194955654,
0.0024607626,
-0.0984674618,
-0.0268132165,
-0.0000193435,
-0.0275238417,
-0.0007757392,
0.0069187041,
-0.0277727451,
-0.0050034695,
-0.0124374982,
-0.0069052782,
0.0222729817,
0.0140137943,
-0.0241397992,
0.0139567303,
-0.0124715939,
0.0129073104,
-0.0559872277,
-0.0313247964,
-0.0061768056,
-0.0098943785,
0.0207687393,
0.0264620148,
0.057250753,
-0.0442109369,
0.0107296174,
0.0354711115,
0.0056666494,
-0.0204949956,
-0.0667006671,
0.0100036124,
0.0263361502,
-0.0471515842,
-0.038640812,
0.0106656719,
0.005512841,
-0.0115506072,
0.0004713249,
0.0649920106,
-0.0023787357,
0.0257415418,
-0.0317063034,
0.0273544565,
0.0284432042,
0.0256951749,
0.0206077304,
-0.0369559266,
0.0202907082,
-0.0457379445,
-0.0333241895,
-0.0021554341,
-0.097220622,
0.0070900479,
-0.0010091366,
-0.0564359426,
-0.0519555733,
-0.0286336932,
0.0105905896,
-0.029350318,
0.0429648384,
-0.0261316057,
0.0229970161,
0.0085197734,
-0.0438827276,
-0.0330930054,
-0.0075823111,
0.0367357172,
-0.009238706,
0.0318168886,
-0.0398201272,
-0.0030016408,
-0.0097753527,
0.0693103224,
-0.0276730899,
-0.0318040997,
0.0508404896,
0.0303705148,
0.0128540136,
-0.0440720879,
-0.0162371062,
-0.062807858,
0.018683102,
0.0496133156,
0.0015419759,
-0.0399017036,
0.0255415272,
0.0158832818,
0.0366966054,
0.0134732099,
0.0341846496,
0.0248390567,
0.0338237993,
-0.059973985,
-0.0520594306,
-0.0260295328,
-0.0276532639,
-0.0045649265,
0.0059500039,
-0.0256023277,
-0.0709859207,
-0.0238693394,
-0.0540376864,
0.0177405123,
-0.0205390453,
0.0145810544,
0.0129368352,
0.0159033015,
0.0148103619,
-0.0141002107,
0.0268012863,
-0.0694194958,
-0.0054542786,
-0.0300120395,
0.0284917466,
0.0416319594,
0.0369272605,
0.0272895973,
0.0317993984,
0.0060890839,
0.0236110594,
0.0088844085,
-0.0182101279,
-0.0374420956,
0.0203303955,
-0.0106679425,
0.0120770223,
0.0339963846,
-0.0172614306,
0.0377835408,
-0.0219339542,
-0.0234008152,
-0.038707003,
-0.0179432146,
-0.0077846409,
0.0430460088,
0.0091482438,
-0.0061046057,
-0.0212970618,
0.0232584309,
-0.0235341638,
-0.0827980638,
0.0239322744,
-0.0082932953,
-0.0277598519,
0.0125457291,
0.0293323211,
-0.0555724204,
0.0155262435,
0.0624890924,
-0.045964364,
-0.0158899501,
-0.0159062743,
0.0035883933,
0.0185967591,
-0.0136834867,
0.0186778978,
-0.0406326577,
-0.0317893997,
-0.0314279683,
-0.059031155,
0.0133093409,
0.010382086,
0.0138051342,
0.0380954742,
0.0092620654,
0.0081928242,
-0.0491034016,
0.0126121165,
-0.0299192686,
-0.0417167507,
0.0142509928,
-5.263329588e-33,
-0.0082820551,
-0.0511044711,
-0.0122640757,
0.0088808471,
0.023696607,
-0.0443077497,
0.0282988623,
0.0289524924,
-0.0495015755,
0.0301201455,
-0.0088449409,
0.0056784991,
0.0065669636,
-0.0137726627,
0.0260642469,
-0.0093911085,
0.0214089081,
-0.0062334989,
-0.0206034388,
0.0090046767,
0.0707468539,
-0.0044723102,
0.0488847196,
-0.0904744342,
0.0719235465,
0.0001638485,
-0.047190357,
0.013356993,
0.0300296377,
0.0632197335,
-0.0210063998,
0.0752563924,
0.0170017164,
0.0027062434,
0.0027370641,
0.0636101142,
-0.0508716814,
-0.014552325,
0.0544949472,
0.0304748993,
0.0226466991,
-0.0321867131,
0.0348832943,
-0.0208831877,
-0.0306626894,
-0.0115262214,
0.0335078463,
-0.036705967,
0.0113182347,
-0.0567389876,
-0.0659274757,
-0.0058493246,
-0.0243055057,
0.0142100155,
-0.0228581745,
0.0769273713,
-0.0170985684,
-0.014983302,
-0.0752980486,
0.0342971049,
-0.0362322032,
-0.0146352751,
0.0037211361,
-0.0124796769,
-0.0215398483,
0.0508741811,
-0.0288407672,
-0.0230065323,
-0.0092579313,
0.0247808639,
0.0473358072,
-0.0219190698,
0.0109861055,
0.0588835031,
0.0116203567,
-0.0968797654,
-0.0715186074,
0.0017082444,
0.0421685874,
0.0512029715,
0.0130806901,
-0.02677981,
-0.0777622014,
-0.035072431,
0.0126883211,
-0.0615829304,
-0.0175302476,
-0.039356377,
0.0118799722,
-0.0282054711,
-0.0334513523,
-0.0025344968,
0.019349372,
-0.029992342,
0.0051896358,
0.0244745817,
-0.0179884005,
-0.0001945302,
0.0433134399,
0.0314437598,
-0.0308827069,
0.0053006206,
-0.0192934088,
-0.0262078028,
0.0324142501,
-0.0284146573,
0.0699908808,
0.0268165246,
-0.0673415959,
0.0108371815,
0.0064892094,
0.0505005084,
-0.0118357604,
0.0680029988,
0.0010341473,
0.0282471236,
-0.0151509037,
-0.0373969823,
0.0715687498,
-0.0134878596,
-0.0027386574,
-0.0088945115,
-0.037214715,
-0.0124004269,
-0.0415843911,
-0.0257282928,
-0.047833059,
0.0373339579,
0.0313483365,
-0.0697189569,
-0.0047172848,
-0.0514019839,
2.536e-7,
0.0391921215,
0.0599468797,
-0.0214033891,
0.0204838272,
0.0267930906,
0.0094796503,
0.075856179,
-0.0001309893,
0.0220814105,
0.022187287,
-0.0123612005,
0.0198351461,
0.0300729033,
0.0586971231,
-0.0256650504,
-0.0246386211,
-0.0262633003,
-0.0162394177,
-0.0570665449,
-0.010234531,
-0.013883994,
0.0693623871,
0.0263851341,
-0.0423918068,
-0.0631976798,
-0.0196834691,
-0.0016429565,
-0.0398671851,
-0.008992237,
-0.0182465594,
0.0563736223,
0.0490716137,
0.0377885252,
0.0084887836,
0.0077110445,
-0.025647806,
0.0173826478,
0.0318691507,
0.0169744883,
0.0802067071,
0.015413438,
-0.0247920677,
-0.0090365643,
-0.0461772308,
0.0495230481,
0.0197081249,
-0.0232896544,
-0.0229291786,
0.0170957483,
-0.0310599487,
0.052112814,
-0.0534719713,
-0.021775255,
0.0101142526,
0.0467864014,
-0.0304962154,
-0.0049559288,
0.000313808,
-0.0000217215,
-0.0093536545,
-0.001416526,
-0.0241682008,
0.0000521152,
0.0107307453,
0.0271307789,
0.0509600677,
0.0727575496,
1.960545039e-34,
-0.0046721068,
-0.0085464893,
0.0338161848,
-0.042342376,
0.0385381952,
0.0434687324,
0.0152060632,
-0.0073537854,
0.034701921,
0.0162689965,
0.0094654523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10514v1 | When a Language Question Is at Stake. A Revisited Approach to Label Sensitive Content | 2023-11-17T13:35:10 | 2023-11-17T13:35:10 | Stetsenko Daria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many under-resourced languages require high-quality datasets for specific
tasks such as offensive language detection, disinformation, or misinformation
identification. However, the intricacies of the content may have a detrimental
effect on the annotators. The article aims to revisit an approach of
pseudo-labeling sensitive data on the example of Ukrainian tweets covering the
Russian-Ukrainian war. Nowadays, this acute topic is in the spotlight of
various language manipulations that cause numerous disinformation and profanity
on social media platforms. The conducted experiment highlights three main
stages of data annotation and underlines the main obstacles during machine
annotation. Ultimately, we provide a fundamental statistical analysis of the
obtained data, evaluation of models used for pseudo-labelling, and set further
guidelines on how the scientists can leverage the corpus to execute more
advanced research and extend the existing data samples without annotators'
engagement. | [
0.0863452926,
0.0226643067,
-0.016634265,
0.024467811,
-0.0192927178,
0.0626626462,
0.028757222,
-0.0001990951,
0.0181548521,
-0.0532166846,
0.0273305941,
-0.0052161245,
-0.0067885304,
0.0188478734,
0.0255173873,
-0.0260225162,
0.0526978932,
0.0301940106,
0.0691986158,
0.000178941,
0.0406286828,
0.0100777028,
-0.0028780142,
0.009804612,
-0.0540262759,
0.0407923982,
0.0424480252,
-0.0000490512,
0.0287801418,
0.0128125669,
0.0145068374,
0.0374213159,
0.0077548181,
0.1140911207,
0.0000014515,
-0.0277996846,
-0.0371054709,
0.0149687659,
-0.0114227496,
-0.053832829,
0.0825837553,
-0.0552208535,
-0.0344885364,
0.011551626,
-0.0364986137,
-0.0054069851,
0.1011195779,
0.0228572264,
0.0877604634,
0.1039327309,
-0.031212924,
-0.0029298451,
-0.0080959285,
0.0153121799,
-0.0202235598,
0.0030982876,
0.0553860553,
-0.0196007024,
-0.0470036604,
0.0350609943,
0.0342370272,
0.0553982668,
0.0173066389,
-0.007462841,
-0.0313711129,
-0.0168780312,
-0.0535886027,
-0.0347889028,
0.0276139453,
0.0112655973,
-0.0138890231,
-0.0378203131,
0.0290905964,
0.0005603401,
-0.0156223848,
-0.0031432831,
0.0106356042,
0.0231058132,
-0.0166914426,
0.0100634079,
0.0331427976,
-0.00653545,
0.0338009596,
0.0671352223,
0.0487660207,
0.054684028,
-0.0439574197,
-0.0188772231,
0.021778129,
0.005338402,
-0.0119233923,
-0.0210870635,
0.058483012,
0.0011960755,
-0.0124702351,
0.0273454897,
-0.0535608679,
-0.0701194555,
0.0337504745,
-0.0952733457,
-0.0136973457,
0.0031694698,
-0.0168612767,
0.0372799598,
0.0024401688,
-0.0097962199,
0.0055725141,
0.0552668087,
-0.013646422,
-0.0356958434,
-0.0183778107,
-0.0001513859,
-0.0179872885,
-0.0057046749,
-0.0004390776,
0.0531571805,
-0.0421235301,
0.0069044004,
-0.0092057213,
0.0159460567,
-0.0310596488,
-0.0399839543,
-0.0588818043,
0.0277498402,
0.0114171458,
-0.0126525322,
-0.0368198156,
0.0252244696,
-0.0337659605,
-0.0735478923,
0.0230407715,
0.0322539434,
-0.0239676218,
-0.0260859355,
0.0018320594,
0.0372188799,
-0.0005335698,
0.0046292972,
-0.0193979014,
-0.0464532413,
-0.0185476951,
-0.021543311,
0.0181953777,
-0.0544246025,
0.0184489265,
0.0019558298,
-0.0407874174,
-0.0529444739,
0.0074469955,
0.016138427,
-0.0656322837,
0.0755074471,
-0.0544106662,
-0.0265968852,
0.0432512425,
0.0087838797,
-0.0117692659,
0.0705246925,
0.0358736292,
0.0706776679,
0.0638690144,
0.0052358569,
0.028555138,
0.0504459366,
-0.0021743339,
0.0050708698,
-0.0280368347,
-0.0094059771,
-0.0274590179,
-0.022722397,
0.015211734,
0.0471308529,
0.0085189445,
-0.050319761,
0.0560211204,
0.0010410197,
-0.0472325794,
0.0079621645,
0.0173264928,
0.0270592142,
-0.0049317321,
0.0029345136,
-0.0334509648,
-0.0139658824,
-0.0110639185,
-0.0284492038,
0.0212794691,
0.017187085,
0.0135306939,
-0.0374854319,
-0.0222730674,
-0.0092634456,
0.0584684052,
-0.0300300159,
0.0205471348,
0.015550551,
0.0149914445,
-0.0117066205,
0.0516601913,
-0.0039692088,
0.0266964082,
-0.0298260022,
-0.0132728033,
0.0402448401,
0.0098675461,
-0.0516544953,
-0.0016264337,
-0.0691659003,
0.0529149324,
0.0528714955,
0.0160560105,
-0.0378187671,
-0.0258484427,
0.0024094291,
-0.0198332313,
0.0079275323,
-0.0067217224,
0.0070255604,
0.0117964167,
-0.0133375842,
0.0033787407,
-0.0338687189,
-0.0657682046,
0.0338372402,
0.0348166041,
-0.0221201032,
-0.0056273979,
0.0166127943,
0.0328556709,
0.0549571924,
-0.0191558879,
-0.0305347964,
0.0444911048,
0.0045446502,
0.0199702885,
-0.0354079455,
0.0293345563,
0.0201567896,
0.0164249018,
-0.0321936943,
-0.0636998713,
0.0243561547,
-0.0551678836,
0.0070001632,
0.0192802101,
-0.0434030592,
-0.0032164953,
-0.0506695323,
-0.0365092866,
-0.0423893817,
0.0149747394,
-0.0026440143,
0.053192962,
-0.0203335714,
0.0241053496,
-0.0005048638,
-0.0608715154,
0.004608803,
0.0151959155,
-0.034919396,
0.0200062357,
-0.0088226888,
0.0099475114,
0.0030541567,
-0.03016828,
-0.0211272687,
-0.0013220106,
-0.0430443808,
-0.0219786074,
-0.0272128768,
0.01433919,
0.0380447917,
0.0000062552,
-0.018578425,
0.0030486656,
-0.0331060216,
-0.0362383612,
0.0161035452,
0.0566233881,
0.0268398505,
-0.0072590592,
0.0132648265,
-0.003565779,
0.0083794873,
-0.0374423973,
0.005562278,
0.0557710901,
-0.0803254545,
0.0051522925,
-0.0144790765,
-0.0497026034,
0.0170399826,
-0.0102206776,
-0.0708361045,
0.0198829863,
0.0388376489,
-0.0359195434,
0.0393557586,
0.0125319343,
0.0571950823,
0.0464805178,
0.0139292777,
0.0159788281,
-0.026002584,
-0.042759724,
-0.0015441945,
-0.0016091915,
-0.0676832423,
-0.0049429163,
0.0435579084,
0.0033233662,
0.0071769813,
-0.0192644559,
0.0323961228,
-0.0630541593,
-0.0362922587,
-0.0056056031,
-0.0245903693,
-0.040116407,
0.0210552681,
-0.0254844464,
-0.0375973545,
0.0895783827,
0.0193684381,
0.0321265794,
-0.0384562872,
-0.0362019725,
0.0357755125,
0.0457818247,
0.0022362426,
0.0274047349,
0.0140500246,
-0.0305212159,
0.0030061284,
-0.0116890799,
0.0609940067,
-0.0282402895,
-0.0224778801,
-0.0213608388,
0.0177520569,
0.0016242233,
0.0008275,
-0.0283484235,
-0.1041394472,
-0.0264121126,
-0.0014602246,
-0.0078737875,
-0.0062882695,
-0.0193425305,
0.0093088038,
0.0413825251,
0.0107322978,
0.0088151759,
0.0399969369,
-0.0092758378,
0.0126428613,
0.0095705446,
-0.0422274284,
0.0230329353,
0.0142009165,
-0.039291054,
0.0536501631,
-0.0038749818,
0.0052645896,
0.0268058274,
-0.0136317378,
-0.0027326467,
-0.0231532604,
-0.0089881811,
-0.0186051242,
0.0150113087,
-0.0284375753,
0.0006176443,
0.0797052607,
0.0431822315,
-0.0153468819,
-0.0112154158,
0.0297907665,
-0.0241306499,
0.0068289712,
-0.0019854156,
-0.0886879861,
0.0377271101,
0.0175780449,
0.0267248377,
-0.1107019484,
-0.0665994808,
-0.0160502996,
-0.0666744858,
-0.0078344233,
-0.0080461046,
-0.0604539849,
-0.0343150422,
-0.0578218997,
0.0129192444,
-0.0193738155,
0.0137828393,
-0.0358021073,
0.0768342018,
0.0017749299,
0.0334704481,
-0.0245926045,
-0.1004649401,
-0.019630475,
-0.0141106853,
0.0562881716,
0.0333618261,
0.0412506498,
-0.0535419509,
0.0119877094,
0.0360063165,
0.0037004477,
-0.0694086775,
-0.0318807289,
0.0789811313,
-0.006909057,
-0.0392023548,
-0.0025697113,
0.0356234722,
0.0164743047,
-0.0226276573,
-0.0282101706,
0.0263109487,
0.0314625837,
0.0242526121,
0.0161515884,
-0.0018652475,
0.0556928739,
0.0346239731,
0.0151216025,
-0.0168669149,
0.0280129276,
-0.0694762766,
0.0223577209,
-0.0189276282,
-0.0294309128,
0.027076561,
-0.0434709825,
-0.0938120037,
-0.0624775887,
-0.0524920821,
0.0482919998,
0.0093391985,
0.0111673176,
-0.00183071,
0.0132061625,
-0.0151636545,
-0.044106178,
-0.012170176,
-0.0100335358,
0.0333495215,
0.0042860233,
-0.0360223651,
-0.0349050574,
0.0112250634,
-0.0217076857,
0.050548058,
-0.0511470251,
-0.0751174837,
0.0903695151,
0.0127173457,
0.017845884,
0.0077078501,
-0.0159965903,
-0.0681335405,
0.0175171085,
0.0553955659,
-0.0153999589,
-0.0276859291,
0.0193518121,
-0.0053913784,
0.0216540545,
0.0107598742,
-0.0174221732,
0.0203487873,
0.0721145123,
-0.0433105007,
-0.0859493911,
-0.0003889938,
0.0039406726,
0.0078177247,
0.0723140836,
-0.0170282722,
-0.0612104535,
-0.0497611761,
-0.0439022258,
-0.0125194574,
-0.0353068262,
0.0176343732,
0.0058344579,
0.0117379362,
0.0079582818,
-0.0309007652,
0.0143672917,
-0.0743242279,
0.0327294208,
-0.024249807,
0.0028603619,
0.0117457546,
0.0444358252,
0.0014970233,
0.004168475,
-0.0256226175,
0.0387257859,
0.0376824476,
0.0150889549,
0.0066231354,
-0.0218766462,
0.0118434113,
-0.022684129,
0.0365311839,
-0.009842285,
-0.0216519609,
0.0511207692,
-0.0554584153,
0.0007932889,
-0.0003361269,
-0.033649683,
0.0430072062,
-0.0044121505,
-0.0399262197,
-0.001910658,
-0.0190107636,
0.0028511814,
-0.0547756106,
0.0061894972,
0.0008319735,
-0.051414527,
0.0722673684,
0.0217053108,
-0.0151206814,
0.0207248237,
0.0501831211,
-0.0671417415,
-0.0256692059,
0.017887529,
-0.0237481166,
0.0140595296,
-0.0002442834,
0.0045826887,
-0.0511835665,
-0.05662499,
0.0194985997,
-0.0281741433,
0.0066825976,
0.0151069127,
-0.0036968221,
0.0376949348,
0.0235522538,
0.0564878583,
-0.0794116631,
0.0039797858,
0.048904743,
-0.0619911477,
0.0082608005,
-5.691762381e-33,
0.0121282209,
-0.0444334857,
-0.0366460048,
0.0096335197,
0.0127488626,
0.012372002,
0.0141381091,
-0.0136950966,
-0.0191621091,
0.0071033193,
0.0134525429,
-0.016696576,
0.0224250276,
-0.0132011967,
-0.0124299619,
-0.0435482785,
0.013268847,
-0.0119580869,
-0.0341120735,
0.0087499367,
0.0525784008,
-0.0024897943,
0.0773229748,
-0.140853256,
0.1148149446,
-0.0184913389,
-0.0313978903,
0.0361617096,
0.0333818048,
0.0509742908,
-0.0168561134,
0.0512956977,
0.036276415,
-0.0102184797,
0.0030032282,
0.0419043191,
-0.0360311791,
-0.0046647177,
0.0394484363,
0.0513169356,
0.0162793454,
-0.039954979,
0.0229638088,
-0.037654262,
-0.0068068379,
0.020507507,
0.0303921327,
-0.0534831807,
0.008824857,
-0.024466157,
-0.0613002814,
0.0262074787,
-0.0125392629,
0.001692683,
0.0378477313,
0.0569828972,
0.0394688435,
0.0133295469,
-0.0911191478,
0.0134004103,
-0.0129535357,
0.0093905255,
0.0347205289,
-0.0020011223,
0.0044137533,
0.0335410275,
0.0030236121,
0.0474671163,
0.0056248438,
0.0502285212,
-0.0049098604,
-0.014094987,
0.02746954,
0.0910788998,
0.032452818,
-0.0637120977,
-0.0731192306,
-0.0216648523,
0.0196378864,
-0.007448466,
-0.0011697377,
-0.0195248146,
-0.0244751889,
-0.016259687,
-0.0247275829,
-0.0607911609,
-0.02688412,
-0.022035202,
-0.0203215946,
-0.0350237563,
-0.0467870608,
0.0620665811,
0.010663908,
-0.0160506442,
0.0061265556,
-0.0219369177,
0.0166041683,
0.0513190962,
0.0137888668,
0.0764026865,
-0.0512943603,
-0.0179135781,
0.0418428332,
-0.0200548843,
0.0287921913,
-0.0040089563,
0.0875740051,
0.0148041686,
-0.0408264995,
0.0255636275,
0.0057418258,
0.06431932,
-0.0101935845,
0.0087346816,
0.0257701781,
0.0201054327,
-0.0034148893,
-0.0099583743,
0.0689352378,
0.0124296127,
0.0171462409,
-0.0001809362,
-0.0534870215,
-0.0124685504,
0.0043208813,
-0.0041153529,
0.0190185849,
0.0359212384,
0.0093045346,
-0.0472558141,
0.0236407649,
-0.0331367999,
2.377e-7,
0.0635870919,
0.050833419,
0.0056961197,
-0.0104237748,
0.0287741944,
0.0073435386,
0.0307608973,
0.0046113241,
0.0134402001,
-0.0740772188,
0.0007928467,
-0.0028579922,
0.0464406312,
0.0618288964,
-0.0453949273,
-0.0304189641,
-0.0410821699,
0.0066963807,
-0.041683998,
0.0629042014,
0.0231685489,
0.0930874795,
0.0614531301,
-0.0196711123,
-0.0656386092,
-0.0479393229,
0.003361061,
-0.0272168405,
-0.0390297584,
0.0085956287,
0.05012789,
0.0309409592,
0.0092360433,
0.0399821363,
-0.0052685365,
-0.032581117,
0.0183376856,
0.0150052356,
0.0332012773,
0.0102988649,
-0.0122806551,
-0.0479929633,
0.014742543,
-0.0343506634,
0.0500920042,
-0.0266233403,
-0.0486583523,
-0.0181354675,
-0.0106333345,
-0.0081500858,
0.0405884907,
-0.0596916191,
-0.0450805724,
0.0281132199,
0.0144142844,
0.0141568985,
-0.0105673624,
-0.0054016644,
-0.0042004427,
-0.0132999942,
-0.0335778892,
-0.0499530174,
0.0361609757,
-0.0151811047,
0.0168399271,
0.0003095389,
0.0740118995,
1.736509706e-34,
0.0236280318,
-0.0380880572,
-0.0243075285,
-0.0078263367,
0.0194251072,
0.0415803082,
-0.0131080542,
0.007227249,
-0.0094464803,
-0.0044539757,
0.0001195431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10505v1 | CNL2ASP: converting controlled natural language sentences into ASP | 2023-11-17T13:10:58 | 2023-11-17T13:10:58 | Simone Caruso, Carmine Dodaro, Marco Maratea, Marco Mochi, Francesco Riccio | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LO | Answer Set Programming (ASP) is a popular declarative programming language
for solving hard combinatorial problems. Although ASP has gained widespread
acceptance in academic and industrial contexts, there are certain user groups
who may find it more advantageous to employ a higher-level language that
closely resembles natural language when specifying ASP programs. In this paper,
we propose a novel tool, called CNL2ASP, for translating English sentences
expressed in a controlled natural language (CNL) form into ASP. In particular,
we first provide a definition of the type of sentences allowed by our CNL and
their translation as ASP rules, and then exemplify the usage of the CNL for the
specification of both synthetic and real-world combinatorial problems. Finally,
we report the results of an experimental analysis conducted on the real-world
problems to compare the performance of automatically generated encodings with
the ones written by ASP practitioners, showing that our tool can obtain
satisfactory performance on these benchmarks. Under consideration in Theory and
Practice of Logic Programming (TPLP). | [
0.0053165839,
0.0565361157,
-0.0367999822,
0.0372103602,
-0.0710222423,
-0.0198703557,
-0.008062751,
-0.0061938418,
0.0376847573,
-0.0515527837,
0.0711575896,
0.0308386274,
-0.0387038402,
0.0644309148,
0.013043398,
0.0072780466,
0.0289495867,
-0.0169123802,
0.0263397973,
0.0076469001,
0.0093353232,
0.0522295795,
-0.0091748731,
0.0066382801,
-0.0095380088,
-0.0232538767,
-0.0108745145,
-0.0340713374,
-0.0027356797,
-0.0195536204,
-0.0024937633,
0.0286581982,
-0.0201650653,
-0.0494159535,
0.0000019919,
-0.0625021011,
-0.064011164,
0.0170227401,
-0.0400239751,
0.0082664546,
0.0103290062,
0.0238545369,
-0.0024508133,
0.0666874647,
-0.0497594699,
0.0223102588,
0.051921621,
0.0457433611,
0.0902122632,
0.0590098351,
-0.0297197159,
-0.0547188744,
-0.000152497,
0.0422592312,
0.0104009397,
-0.0278028883,
0.0270682145,
-0.0103234807,
0.0677878857,
-0.005575892,
0.0388817713,
-0.0104943858,
0.0235347003,
-0.0470984206,
-0.0066031427,
-0.0362783968,
-0.0409321077,
-0.0194265712,
-0.0211195219,
0.0146313291,
0.0127502214,
-0.0395792313,
-0.0045713419,
-0.0271811485,
0.0241131596,
0.0031025633,
0.0008590252,
0.042401813,
-0.0305540357,
0.0261629932,
0.0425085202,
0.0268295463,
-0.0286364648,
-0.033916261,
-0.0310920849,
0.068343319,
0.0148331299,
-0.0306328647,
-0.0131845837,
-0.024541771,
0.0481794216,
-0.0761865079,
0.06549602,
0.0202997886,
-0.0646416098,
0.0130179077,
-0.0360060856,
-0.0215558913,
0.0567756183,
-0.0706131682,
0.0591043346,
0.0334040225,
0.0392350778,
0.0233663283,
0.0039964169,
0.0662097111,
0.0295598879,
0.0263192747,
-0.0693825409,
0.0055843773,
-0.0673247203,
-0.0175621696,
-0.0834515169,
0.0466287024,
-0.0658323839,
0.0087280339,
-0.0071301218,
0.0011406168,
-0.0034909358,
0.0281424057,
0.013911901,
-0.024110008,
0.0373761095,
0.0214889795,
-0.0444395766,
0.0155524164,
-0.0634272471,
-0.0391791388,
-0.0164143629,
-0.0680123568,
0.0223203283,
-0.0165813938,
0.0203656889,
-0.0269606113,
0.0031411212,
0.0950290337,
-0.0213967375,
0.0223671384,
-0.0137928063,
-0.0284212343,
0.0238355696,
-0.0075420537,
0.003545329,
-0.0706028044,
0.0322614983,
0.0230111964,
-0.0366182439,
-0.063387081,
0.0123464279,
0.0611084886,
0.0116781881,
0.0285386462,
-0.0263096299,
0.0075305235,
-0.0395840779,
-0.0366419144,
0.0495110303,
0.0511970855,
0.0285065826,
0.0137678105,
0.0028468294,
-0.0275111068,
0.0283821393,
0.006645801,
-0.016147282,
-0.0217656065,
-0.0315686241,
0.0467423126,
0.0293169823,
0.0192555822,
-0.0705652982,
0.0441024341,
-0.0266389474,
0.0079723196,
-0.0419269241,
-0.0081243301,
0.0319699124,
0.043338038,
-0.0148790833,
0.0121535743,
0.0087522101,
-0.0269025266,
-0.0096618654,
0.0204869565,
0.0132045653,
-0.0202625934,
-0.025232872,
0.0383376069,
0.0256225634,
-0.068151623,
-0.0155961486,
0.0316794775,
0.0464355983,
0.012824351,
-0.0197534524,
-0.0017790289,
-0.0178584419,
0.0296808314,
-0.034984868,
-0.0623215288,
-0.0413575172,
-0.0250135045,
-0.0151656782,
0.0555600971,
0.0062173861,
-0.0515854545,
-0.0565357618,
0.0130195003,
-0.0307523534,
0.0289423633,
0.0250711106,
0.016380325,
-0.0055595762,
-0.0435720086,
0.0069293957,
-0.0123736849,
-0.0126631223,
0.0487333424,
0.001237273,
-0.0091928802,
-0.0268190037,
0.0241982024,
-0.0333649665,
0.0151880383,
0.0253355186,
-0.0252136011,
0.031751588,
-0.000570102,
0.0372005515,
0.0396413058,
0.0045340895,
0.0557338782,
0.0242613032,
-0.0405262262,
-0.0883753225,
-0.044142805,
-0.0056834971,
-0.0239414349,
0.0667304173,
-0.0815512091,
-0.0489248559,
-0.0142497122,
-0.0281582735,
-0.0462250337,
0.0344297923,
-0.0284433737,
0.005895664,
0.0022384787,
-0.0103370817,
0.0505099371,
-0.0248900838,
-0.0470694751,
0.0447031148,
0.0593994968,
0.0035126968,
-0.0179390237,
-0.0479846373,
0.0554005578,
-0.0413483791,
0.0734043941,
0.0393059924,
-0.0160212535,
-0.0157395955,
0.0557833314,
0.072521314,
0.0061957287,
-0.0095035406,
0.0141803222,
0.0056873034,
0.0205324572,
0.0223488063,
-0.0038015402,
0.0132282907,
-0.0271372385,
0.0038915623,
-0.0793239996,
-0.0305173006,
0.0533543341,
-0.0322866328,
-0.0034306746,
-0.0002286177,
-0.0507011414,
0.0127702579,
-0.0042351782,
-0.041625116,
-0.0103654712,
0.0270757992,
-0.0364143327,
-0.014450958,
0.0379475243,
-0.0056682639,
0.0087087182,
0.041345261,
-0.0182645749,
0.0027106314,
-0.0445141681,
-0.0429416038,
0.0319103785,
-0.0375133231,
-0.0155450925,
0.0184066538,
-0.018435264,
-0.0207604785,
0.0281974413,
0.0054428219,
-0.0194593947,
-0.0135443369,
-0.0533724762,
0.0146762496,
0.0044251564,
0.0335166007,
0.0062353695,
-0.0477219261,
0.0296831336,
0.0171299912,
0.0058450294,
-0.0536680222,
-0.0158392563,
0.0117416102,
0.0873329788,
0.0179249365,
0.0163748246,
0.0496861078,
-0.0113733793,
-0.01165953,
-0.1118092835,
-0.0041430774,
-0.0544085614,
0.0457721576,
0.0181372426,
0.0511416532,
0.0416371971,
-0.0199752077,
-0.0091965767,
-0.0244578868,
0.0275887959,
-0.0181717928,
-0.0060010892,
-0.029586127,
0.0040318463,
-0.0511327982,
-0.0295002498,
-0.0292042289,
0.0028628437,
-0.0150437076,
0.0172351338,
0.0464370586,
-0.0041012033,
0.0093813417,
-0.0195822455,
-0.0151287569,
-0.0051995893,
-0.0022386562,
0.0104971109,
-0.0049693482,
-0.005480852,
0.0306950193,
0.0301540531,
0.0057764379,
0.055243548,
0.0200253259,
0.053411223,
0.023064008,
0.0248514321,
-0.0052261436,
0.055017475,
0.0296829715,
-0.0487287827,
-0.002723634,
0.0354228504,
0.004691361,
-0.0447528176,
0.0021502047,
0.063043654,
0.052694276,
0.0251904353,
0.0019439521,
-0.0082261227,
-0.027987998,
0.0339903049,
0.0880999714,
-0.0973389223,
0.0118118078,
-0.0236652885,
-0.0125510013,
-0.0122595662,
-0.0022257576,
-0.0244078711,
-0.1291863173,
0.0383137278,
0.0113755753,
-0.0714327022,
-0.0172662418,
-0.0269256253,
-0.0249322504,
-0.0007588846,
-0.0402889661,
0.0263312645,
-0.0099896165,
-0.0019640625,
0.0030343926,
-0.0156600513,
-0.0113981254,
0.0120228259,
0.0314849168,
0.0492707267,
0.049590189,
0.0422130562,
-0.0178768504,
-0.0319487453,
0.0142951487,
-0.020341048,
-0.0057972074,
-0.0521913581,
-0.027896082,
0.0283631645,
0.0001336588,
-0.009228644,
0.0243318565,
-0.0613774806,
-0.0131841404,
0.0786200389,
0.0973761976,
0.0130096776,
0.0145258149,
-0.0412085243,
-0.0266778599,
0.0193876624,
0.0226477794,
0.0042181187,
0.0313064978,
-0.0495424308,
-0.0915458053,
-0.0051243762,
-0.0712680593,
-0.0183254536,
0.0278815087,
-0.0382515155,
-0.013721386,
-0.037435744,
0.0156632029,
0.0662453547,
0.0434208848,
0.0113467248,
-0.0322515629,
0.0389676392,
-0.0151103055,
-0.0070869499,
-0.0538156368,
-0.0346802808,
0.0586705692,
0.0103148455,
-0.0205840804,
-0.0569963977,
-0.0057248683,
-0.022710016,
-0.0161828119,
0.0327644013,
-0.0679951757,
0.0091083106,
0.0321534947,
0.0218686406,
-0.0580098554,
-0.0002221847,
-0.0151925059,
-0.0228711851,
0.0302586202,
-0.0142895794,
-0.0350991786,
0.0032786864,
0.0028995061,
0.010601854,
-0.0102429511,
-0.0244043637,
0.0207372997,
-0.0198790394,
0.0666704029,
-0.0047065867,
-0.0299719069,
0.066099368,
0.1010056362,
-0.0612394027,
0.0056229811,
0.0062902789,
0.0605501607,
-0.0032011014,
-0.0744844154,
-0.0527846813,
-0.0360842273,
0.0074368203,
-0.0283105765,
-0.0013628006,
0.0522370562,
-0.0312447473,
-0.059680786,
0.0004617297,
0.0372800939,
0.0393832661,
0.0483274944,
0.0208563581,
-0.0062579089,
-0.0006871971,
-0.0181444176,
0.0101922443,
0.0058001736,
0.0393665805,
-0.0161493849,
0.0117645683,
0.023528304,
0.017240826,
-0.0634812936,
-0.0098988116,
-0.0064625596,
-0.0179558638,
0.044028271,
0.0527610555,
0.0301432554,
0.0121758347,
0.0058695115,
-0.0326368771,
0.0035776028,
0.008864956,
0.011795165,
0.0417889841,
-0.0158428475,
-0.0008545541,
0.0071094432,
0.0093085878,
-0.1036254466,
0.0639485195,
0.0132578369,
-0.0272378754,
-0.0146895396,
-0.0394435376,
-0.0731562525,
-0.0273221992,
-0.0523018092,
0.0073941313,
0.023640085,
-0.0312496126,
-0.0389013849,
-0.0557399057,
0.0153398793,
0.0616374053,
0.0703063011,
0.0246154312,
0.0445651039,
0.0252726115,
0.0733792186,
-0.0450393148,
-0.0037573643,
0.0246030185,
-0.057850007,
-0.0095297061,
-0.0323019475,
-5.599512891e-33,
-0.0485071167,
-0.0050214124,
0.0227281936,
0.0197954476,
0.0154508082,
-0.0577279031,
-0.0122749656,
-0.0054453593,
0.0221122075,
0.0108808642,
-0.0178776681,
-0.0127934916,
0.0200267155,
0.0007691734,
0.0158824008,
-0.0114498632,
0.0117727453,
0.0097591626,
-0.0173652638,
-0.0358082131,
-0.001233089,
-0.0590601675,
0.0366695598,
-0.0304975584,
-0.0451211408,
0.0252261944,
0.0127517749,
0.0394644961,
-0.0359748825,
0.0186236221,
0.0273937583,
0.0348907523,
-0.0019532363,
-0.0217063203,
-0.010403323,
0.0461561419,
-0.0453860462,
-0.0975048468,
0.0519295707,
-0.0118395472,
-0.0066993735,
-0.0521947891,
0.0293297786,
-0.0216887053,
-0.0354127362,
0.0281716213,
0.0286676344,
-0.0254904293,
0.0260271151,
-0.0214139242,
-0.0281642023,
-0.0103038158,
-0.0159290824,
0.0391651317,
-0.0372244306,
0.0263848193,
-0.0205065887,
-0.0559047163,
0.056795273,
0.0163926855,
0.0700242072,
0.0101444265,
0.0043335608,
-0.0202891473,
-0.0050148098,
-0.023927357,
0.0221356004,
-0.0208365489,
-0.0312420558,
0.0431446955,
0.0001325785,
0.0499483421,
0.0485192165,
0.0724280551,
0.045566082,
0.0327273123,
-0.0568797998,
0.0211018194,
-0.01376436,
0.0733422413,
0.0089428686,
0.0381738432,
-0.0424855761,
-0.0480325744,
-0.0149952332,
0.0620263256,
-0.0225529913,
-0.023862198,
0.0511156581,
-0.039577134,
-0.0565968789,
0.0032878765,
0.0086616296,
-0.0089245224,
-0.0308002252,
0.0387087129,
0.0189514998,
-0.0240571462,
-0.0192270614,
0.0314671583,
-0.012338561,
-0.0101961512,
-0.0094380658,
-0.0146822315,
0.0310343355,
0.0155710643,
-0.0382392108,
0.0279368293,
-0.0483519956,
0.0221458524,
-0.0434564389,
0.002262322,
0.0014433769,
-0.0324279033,
0.0038043128,
0.0148486383,
0.0228661019,
-0.0258704312,
-0.0235584304,
-0.0515805669,
-0.0327448063,
-0.0241936557,
0.0513096005,
0.0175268874,
-0.0117759407,
0.0000778304,
-0.0500080362,
0.0004665706,
0.016157344,
-0.019632047,
-0.0252881553,
0.0046310467,
2.702e-7,
0.0117997639,
0.0470110849,
0.0603971519,
0.1083894372,
0.0138657168,
-0.0117212981,
0.0469449051,
-0.0023311193,
0.0010374412,
0.0154488748,
-0.0198901147,
0.0241117831,
0.0017947804,
0.0774491727,
-0.020731248,
0.0364177711,
0.0204320475,
0.0012361463,
-0.0440314673,
0.0483992696,
0.1697818339,
0.0171038434,
0.0170608666,
0.0190587249,
-0.0198450163,
-0.0325610451,
-0.0307902806,
0.0018948227,
0.0097996192,
-0.0096090389,
-0.025431443,
-0.0051522339,
0.0275990926,
0.0596480146,
0.0169838592,
-0.0049897861,
0.0072221253,
0.0318596885,
-0.0112598212,
-0.0042492757,
0.010964077,
-0.0455559865,
-0.0108654071,
-0.0044957921,
0.0650218055,
-0.0306738652,
0.0023117845,
-0.0042381533,
-0.055564113,
-0.0532262214,
-0.0371543095,
0.0254749227,
-0.0347803347,
-0.0016700274,
0.0103629334,
-0.0094499234,
-0.0022338231,
-0.0151806371,
-0.0304709226,
0.0101654977,
-0.0017923963,
0.0145621821,
-0.0261336397,
0.0618805028,
-0.0097077833,
0.0174971204,
-0.0244360548,
2.794957995e-34,
0.0254882146,
-0.0074127703,
0.0115235969,
0.0036407155,
0.0450680889,
0.0046180189,
-0.0327046067,
0.044388216,
0.0240041483,
-0.0717604831,
-0.0276791379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10804v1 | A Study on Altering the Latent Space of Pretrained Text to Speech Models for Improved Expressiveness | 2023-11-17T13:07:00 | 2023-11-17T13:07:00 | Mathias Vogel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This report explores the challenge of enhancing expressiveness control in
Text-to-Speech (TTS) models by augmenting a frozen pretrained model with a
Diffusion Model that is conditioned on joint semantic audio/text embeddings.
The paper identifies the challenges encountered when working with a VAE-based
TTS model and evaluates different image-to-image methods for altering latent
speech features. Our results offer valuable insights into the complexities of
adding expressiveness control to TTS systems and open avenues for future
research in this direction. | [
-0.0015401448,
0.077064462,
0.0018593869,
0.0407372154,
0.0274397563,
-0.0146575728,
0.0194409937,
-0.0118066212,
-0.0602496751,
0.0051371106,
-0.0582646877,
-0.0251321122,
0.0206185635,
0.0575879775,
0.0444154479,
-0.1170533374,
0.0281917173,
-0.0352812931,
-0.018744817,
-0.015380498,
0.0220544767,
0.0148185585,
-0.0326595195,
0.015134234,
-0.06746158,
0.0025818991,
-0.012698181,
0.0275690742,
0.0204654559,
0.0180101283,
-0.0744164512,
0.0248165969,
0.0740034804,
-0.0369337052,
0.0000019619,
0.0063094217,
0.0008998276,
0.0333957039,
0.0160992946,
0.0488630086,
0.1233288348,
-0.0037954713,
-0.0123958951,
0.0091263074,
0.0070855264,
-0.0429455377,
0.0918144956,
0.0423636734,
0.0626011193,
0.0537753031,
-0.0280793831,
-0.0434324332,
0.0147056067,
-0.0083435215,
0.0163897071,
-0.0176218823,
-0.0069032935,
-0.0054683527,
-0.0082511501,
-0.0551718324,
-0.069857873,
0.0691615492,
0.0089578247,
-0.0308562852,
0.0036054975,
0.0228406005,
0.0374499932,
-0.0376227126,
-0.0335261561,
0.0718199387,
0.0312788077,
0.0120563563,
-0.0097577348,
-0.0040989262,
-0.0236733258,
0.0247882921,
0.035070844,
-0.0247524846,
0.0821010098,
-0.0134814791,
-0.0733696595,
0.0292089581,
0.0095881103,
0.0033846211,
-0.0067445501,
-0.0488335937,
0.0240287501,
-0.0213729441,
-0.0045538587,
-0.0182277728,
-0.024325043,
0.0029738403,
0.0341214202,
0.0069970377,
-0.0189646855,
-0.0042882087,
-0.062803179,
-0.0890359581,
-0.0881742537,
0.0273235701,
0.0540776365,
0.0435751379,
-0.0147391707,
0.0100675691,
0.0092025353,
0.0158292931,
-0.0320954956,
0.0227404926,
-0.0798692852,
0.0032357622,
0.0387492925,
0.0005440223,
-0.0475681908,
-0.0201897919,
-0.0369905196,
-0.0571672507,
-0.0209373664,
0.0151382741,
-0.0398407504,
-0.0151321515,
-0.0000503855,
0.0395735539,
-0.0296589267,
0.001813204,
-0.0100811003,
-0.0064984732,
0.021132756,
0.0382969864,
-0.0006735912,
0.0085262749,
-0.0290504731,
0.0079810219,
0.0521051809,
0.0002391549,
0.0067050247,
0.0421516225,
-0.0223127697,
-0.0307424068,
-0.0213170443,
0.0258637853,
-0.002072375,
-0.0386180729,
0.0488751046,
-0.0331420191,
0.0137827657,
-0.053993918,
0.0152408667,
-0.0353549421,
-0.041709315,
-0.0501902141,
-0.0105364025,
0.0992838219,
0.0122218644,
0.0363252126,
0.0552838333,
0.0021498252,
0.0278037339,
0.0315062441,
0.0387479439,
-0.0212437138,
0.0062602386,
-0.0466066748,
-0.0059821005,
0.0285368357,
0.0275327377,
0.0271404013,
-0.0455037951,
-0.0106405169,
-0.0002525992,
0.0193763301,
0.0770908669,
0.0734371543,
-0.0366895236,
-0.0005981558,
0.0913064554,
0.0552576482,
0.0059815841,
-0.0227180012,
0.0631667376,
0.0397809073,
-0.0088095209,
0.004089823,
0.0052212602,
0.0398802161,
0.0530594215,
0.0270460788,
0.05925465,
0.0232183672,
-0.0560116507,
-0.0366665274,
0.0086149247,
-0.0284882784,
0.0569710732,
-0.0059102657,
-0.0067386599,
0.034745954,
-0.0615376532,
0.0191909522,
-0.0006704649,
-0.0723653436,
0.0319279693,
-0.0301114991,
0.0494451597,
0.0578060709,
-0.0138273016,
-0.0030411861,
0.0373108312,
-0.0159736369,
-0.0076939543,
0.0352612995,
-0.006693657,
0.0137201017,
0.0456255339,
-0.0594241694,
-0.0176698845,
0.0012313623,
0.0217180736,
0.0060477429,
-0.0357404649,
0.0512986071,
0.0162514038,
0.0030905257,
0.0568418242,
0.0259912964,
-0.0094311796,
-0.0081801852,
0.0061151884,
0.0059902053,
0.0411567874,
-0.0046216729,
-0.0769082829,
0.0113898125,
-0.0021459025,
0.0172815081,
-0.0122259334,
0.0656445101,
-0.0650215298,
-0.0329594091,
-0.0183234643,
-0.0514812246,
0.0032835368,
0.0110546723,
-0.023965003,
-0.0560483336,
0.0572832376,
-0.0461592413,
0.017370183,
-0.0474671125,
0.00133832,
-0.0100062909,
-0.0107663032,
0.0376791134,
-0.0485400781,
-0.0293711945,
-0.013009863,
0.0451906286,
0.0315034352,
-0.0245334785,
-0.025303226,
-0.0315528736,
0.0041105067,
0.0209581945,
0.0377957299,
-0.031537734,
0.0302351974,
-0.0031784736,
-0.036637418,
-0.0524391606,
-0.0160077643,
-0.0035827563,
-0.0227025878,
-0.001087663,
0.0239523631,
-0.0019310064,
0.0339461751,
-0.0213823635,
-0.0034253949,
0.0008536719,
-0.0171058718,
0.009028282,
0.0021877659,
0.0064183082,
-0.0314577818,
-0.0020191048,
0.0380556807,
0.0223945677,
-0.0643332377,
0.0048123435,
0.00486481,
0.0495650806,
0.0084079262,
0.0209534802,
0.0002348475,
-0.065125972,
-0.0021483453,
0.0131471222,
0.0674717054,
0.0587474667,
0.0325114466,
0.0431302153,
0.0137537755,
-0.029794177,
-0.0115237832,
0.0177377239,
-0.0547009483,
0.0379805118,
-0.0269839894,
-0.0078202188,
-0.0203029271,
0.0188669767,
-0.0093544656,
0.0323153697,
-0.088132143,
0.0035451499,
-0.0266933944,
-0.0604883023,
0.0149442703,
-0.0099421302,
-0.0354150049,
-0.0325865075,
-0.0205890164,
-0.0430205837,
0.0520886518,
-0.0608103164,
-0.027934745,
-0.0161562338,
-0.0022456832,
0.0111540528,
0.0195766594,
-0.0163093135,
0.0255562812,
-0.0171332452,
0.0039480301,
-0.0646239221,
-0.0427513011,
0.0206877515,
-0.0368229076,
-0.0007674125,
0.0019749685,
-0.0347985402,
0.0131448032,
-0.0034164141,
0.0228973143,
-0.0356019177,
0.0213183276,
-0.0177588761,
0.0233574361,
-0.0383944921,
0.0055347979,
0.0003519675,
0.0243280567,
0.0297773294,
0.0135110654,
0.0109154778,
-0.0295223966,
0.0228074677,
0.0620613694,
0.0465415195,
-0.0522475913,
-0.0273779463,
0.0327728651,
0.0088348165,
0.013680622,
-0.0286216028,
-0.0562680773,
0.0238943007,
0.0199392214,
0.0572108887,
-0.0099594025,
0.0129693849,
0.0513218939,
-0.0274231713,
-0.0008729903,
0.0732809454,
-0.0319786891,
0.02092297,
0.00173723,
0.0456499681,
0.0651784018,
0.0147511428,
-0.0017862591,
-0.0389721096,
-0.0245360192,
0.0043974672,
0.0135707567,
0.0005721585,
0.0362660699,
-0.027453715,
-0.0619492531,
0.0751054138,
0.0168929808,
-0.0024160612,
0.0050456789,
0.0008435019,
-0.0224962588,
0.0040517608,
0.050882604,
-0.0341100842,
-0.0151343672,
-0.0070752501,
0.0427728854,
-0.0203752127,
-0.0584961623,
-0.0536853857,
-0.0178269316,
0.0285323989,
0.0433734953,
0.0283301417,
-0.0511216857,
-0.0640870184,
0.0285542235,
0.0300650895,
-0.0126585206,
-0.0052435943,
0.0267532151,
0.0010267309,
-0.0336374305,
0.0142252855,
0.0320690684,
0.0377707221,
0.0291525349,
-0.0505592227,
0.0273564793,
0.0070081097,
-0.0022354256,
-0.028312007,
0.0296725053,
0.0217647217,
0.0243188161,
0.0222462211,
-0.0710130036,
-0.0229700953,
0.0093310606,
0.0200692751,
0.0003307297,
-0.0651804656,
-0.0093817273,
-0.0182403233,
-0.0833866894,
-0.0439051464,
0.0101280324,
-0.0270972196,
0.0683526322,
-0.0092238346,
-0.0008945694,
0.0322583094,
-0.012843742,
-0.0433622785,
0.0412357748,
-0.001512376,
0.0446946546,
-0.0179401189,
-0.0023280734,
0.0093336189,
-0.0557311922,
-0.0358401537,
-0.0004834668,
-0.0374160074,
-0.0556421205,
-0.0035283486,
0.0135515453,
0.0076735415,
0.0684972703,
-0.003450704,
-0.0326219313,
0.1409790665,
-0.0002265501,
-0.0226427577,
0.0680942461,
0.0795371681,
-0.0075317509,
-0.0011840961,
-0.0151469298,
-0.0365791805,
0.0270115845,
0.002727872,
-0.0191038065,
0.0266822632,
-0.0272212327,
-0.0298889484,
-0.0025238129,
0.0219735987,
0.0201377142,
0.0433032513,
-0.0748491213,
0.019827649,
-0.0291368011,
0.0254569538,
-0.0897344798,
-0.0286688115,
0.016966464,
0.0709766075,
-0.0433244593,
-0.0186418127,
-0.005052018,
0.024170585,
0.009924734,
0.0344219841,
0.0675951466,
0.0169221368,
0.0006376276,
0.0420037694,
0.0070877685,
0.0191554409,
-0.030101886,
0.0075273435,
0.0045799725,
0.0463971645,
0.0197404344,
-0.0306695122,
0.0018656538,
0.0565667674,
-0.0294434,
0.0141674504,
-0.0450311787,
-0.0391369238,
-0.0123611987,
0.0188452415,
0.0628947616,
-0.0412765704,
0.023277631,
0.0011927186,
0.0452225991,
0.0014987561,
-0.0285251513,
0.0594042614,
-0.0322523005,
-0.0142657086,
0.0159971267,
-0.0251090601,
0.0093259225,
0.0418573134,
-0.0474969931,
0.0029383118,
-0.0068233982,
-0.0368151963,
0.0051856227,
-0.0039694589,
0.0078300964,
0.001527905,
-0.0060058171,
-0.0830315575,
-0.0111408494,
0.0090177832,
-0.0391009375,
-0.0342831686,
0.0583529919,
-0.0210389327,
0.0095762732,
0.0176300183,
0.0056297248,
-0.0654069558,
-0.0101199793,
-0.0272097941,
0.020899713,
-6.322060615e-33,
-0.0343808383,
0.0130334878,
-0.0103235682,
-0.0328982845,
-0.0883570686,
0.0111458227,
-0.046972651,
0.0103508746,
-0.003700872,
0.0373027697,
0.0102622434,
0.0141694928,
0.0195036903,
0.040123269,
-0.0925165266,
0.035202276,
0.0741850287,
-0.0368312672,
0.0214765072,
0.0102970051,
-0.0095748398,
-0.0043202918,
-0.0150203072,
-0.0701856166,
-0.0197059009,
0.0306668915,
-0.0466669053,
-0.0180025324,
0.0480104908,
0.0234017894,
-0.0280356072,
0.014028755,
-0.0533122309,
0.0103800045,
-0.0354397707,
0.0264732614,
-0.0338830575,
0.0027602769,
0.0154511901,
0.0206685998,
-0.081665881,
0.0059412033,
0.023393305,
-0.0021784753,
-0.0242629666,
-0.0286887083,
0.0039704968,
0.0155970026,
0.025002094,
-0.0563267693,
-0.0474348776,
0.0048862896,
-0.0342500545,
-0.0469999239,
0.0480021127,
-0.0302261747,
0.0036094056,
-0.0153713478,
-0.0629879162,
0.0094078612,
-0.0049998565,
0.0016072621,
0.0442784131,
0.0287861396,
0.026392512,
-0.0027413571,
-0.0035045557,
-0.0200131796,
-0.0072406107,
-0.0040007737,
0.0522653423,
0.0501703434,
0.0298529547,
-0.0106472326,
-0.0201967731,
-0.0580241419,
0.0082490891,
-0.0073579038,
-0.037991412,
-0.0007994013,
0.0327763744,
0.0461824834,
-0.0069460636,
-0.0133319413,
-0.0847217143,
-0.0396156088,
0.0057944986,
-0.0138813062,
0.0565285757,
0.0043837489,
-0.0044731754,
-0.0220438726,
0.0537245162,
-0.008086754,
0.0242472067,
-0.0569937304,
-0.0693807229,
0.0544171631,
-0.0197927263,
0.0309046898,
-0.0457186662,
-0.0508440435,
0.0967266709,
0.0477824695,
0.0155274756,
-0.0100015681,
-0.0100183589,
0.0641528517,
-0.0600135252,
-0.0014074823,
0.0216948763,
0.0371230505,
-0.0236997958,
-0.013487245,
0.015340046,
-0.0148571152,
-0.0333695039,
0.0542906187,
-0.0157467276,
0.009663281,
-0.009126096,
-0.0159156621,
0.0225335192,
0.034246359,
-0.0268211402,
0.0415520519,
0.0266883746,
-0.0147266192,
0.0689873174,
-0.0161902923,
-0.0083358027,
0.037450213,
2.708e-7,
-0.01562603,
-0.0205279831,
0.0108125098,
0.0176276062,
0.0346291959,
0.0631656721,
-0.0032604975,
0.020069452,
-0.0155156935,
-0.0202633608,
0.0307302773,
0.0041484665,
0.0869221464,
-0.0158934575,
-0.0109865554,
-0.016492404,
-0.0619351678,
0.0196013711,
-0.0015017006,
0.0040654773,
0.0389825515,
0.0861185119,
-0.0046627261,
0.0071670646,
0.0186701864,
-0.0096543347,
0.0529303215,
-0.0454045609,
0.0293153357,
-0.0355764516,
-0.0325746015,
-0.0192893632,
0.0030019991,
-0.0239970256,
-0.061019022,
0.0270441249,
0.0322972313,
0.0435924679,
-0.0253245421,
-0.0541234314,
-0.0236865375,
0.0401461013,
-0.0506774634,
0.0250244681,
0.0609146431,
-0.0493527129,
-0.0230952837,
0.0002246449,
-0.0099427449,
0.002870186,
0.0375397205,
-0.028167922,
-0.0211234167,
0.0152468476,
0.0552272759,
-0.0075442521,
-0.022653576,
-0.0757791698,
-0.0063271658,
-0.0426235795,
-0.0513784662,
-0.0365731269,
-0.0429587588,
0.028958898,
0.0572878309,
0.012402026,
-0.0453632399,
2.185646238e-34,
0.0219398513,
-0.0467879698,
0.0454420298,
-0.0068344106,
0.0324174426,
0.0304660574,
0.060511671,
-0.0240682811,
0.0419587269,
-0.0713283345,
-0.0318544507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10436v1 | Sinhala-English Word Embedding Alignment: Introducing Datasets and Benchmark for a Low Resource Language | 2023-11-17T10:14:45 | 2023-11-17T10:14:45 | Kasun Wickramasinghe, Nisansa de Silva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Since their inception, embeddings have become a primary ingredient in many
flavours of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks supplanting earlier types
of representation. Even though multilingual embeddings have been used for the
increasing number of multilingual tasks, due to the scarcity of parallel
training data, low-resource languages such as Sinhala, tend to focus more on
monolingual embeddings. Then when it comes to the aforementioned multi-lingual
tasks, it is challenging to utilize these monolingual embeddings given that
even if the embedding spaces have a similar geometric arrangement due to an
identical training process, the embeddings of the languages considered are not
aligned. This is solved by the embedding alignment task. Even in this,
high-resource language pairs are in the limelight while low-resource languages
such as Sinhala which is in dire need of help seem to have fallen by the
wayside. In this paper, we try to align Sinhala and English word embedding
spaces based on available alignment techniques and introduce a benchmark for
Sinhala language embedding alignment. In addition to that, to facilitate the
supervised alignment, as an intermediate task, we also introduce
Sinhala-English alignment datasets. These datasets serve as our anchor datasets
for supervised word embedding alignment. Even though we do not obtain results
comparable to the high-resource languages such as French, German, or Chinese,
we believe our work lays the groundwork for more specialized alignment between
English and Sinhala embeddings. | [
0.0049471473,
0.0429521464,
0.0090716956,
0.0721840858,
-0.0471663103,
0.0160367694,
-0.0083786622,
-0.053911522,
-0.0246539526,
0.0582905188,
-0.0774664432,
-0.0448646359,
0.0712476,
-0.041679237,
0.0459413417,
-0.0185944568,
0.0651838258,
0.0272689089,
-0.0284885615,
-0.0030532144,
0.0612095408,
0.0273788814,
-0.0293830261,
0.0052497415,
-0.0326102152,
-0.0353653878,
0.0142862024,
-0.0262347758,
0.0304117687,
-0.0058001825,
-0.0179784559,
0.0339335464,
0.0176154058,
0.0500564724,
0.0000012628,
-0.0222968645,
-0.013064757,
-0.014923011,
0.0097751552,
0.0207115989,
-0.0001705644,
-0.0430357382,
-0.0057453853,
0.0190534648,
-0.0254645701,
-0.0088835135,
0.1168579981,
0.0225178022,
-0.0063070171,
0.0880219415,
-0.0247422382,
-0.0466324911,
-0.0074988161,
-0.049558565,
-0.0588539355,
0.0334433205,
-0.0205888599,
-0.0100091025,
-0.0290075522,
-0.0381950177,
-0.0661391988,
0.0372108966,
-0.029048387,
0.0145541187,
0.0100087151,
-0.0152067235,
-0.0131927216,
-0.0281615593,
0.0512521043,
0.059068732,
-0.0564253964,
-0.025018068,
-0.0571383089,
0.0280953925,
-0.0404244512,
0.0201883167,
-0.0051798988,
-0.0203705076,
0.0001081793,
0.0676496774,
0.0807975605,
0.0033445549,
0.0467490144,
-0.0383070409,
0.0298897456,
-0.0106670717,
0.0587753765,
-0.0620080866,
-0.0062820236,
0.0035729322,
0.0030469459,
0.0229814276,
-0.0076512215,
-0.0201597195,
-0.002266729,
0.0367916934,
-0.0507183224,
-0.0346044376,
0.0166685805,
-0.0588652529,
0.0149185117,
0.0783980489,
0.0070087421,
0.0290810149,
-0.0303294212,
0.0510224141,
-0.043806456,
0.0203756709,
-0.0322010517,
-0.019514244,
0.0130629428,
-0.0275772903,
-0.0280213524,
-0.0209033489,
-0.0172565561,
-0.0253977608,
-0.0487946421,
0.033345405,
-0.0352483727,
0.0522246063,
0.0112391626,
-0.0364466943,
-0.0175045524,
-0.0003926983,
0.0218994673,
0.0436847582,
-0.0545404404,
0.0161994193,
-0.0710365176,
-0.0228487123,
-0.0217411667,
0.0305609498,
-0.0200600475,
-0.0352658592,
-0.0086066891,
0.0252928846,
-0.0343498588,
-0.0439812467,
-0.0431238338,
0.0414073877,
-0.005544642,
-0.0159417056,
-0.0365741998,
-0.073797062,
0.1051329374,
-0.010463261,
0.0176364686,
-0.03352217,
0.0012089441,
-0.0018798645,
0.0046593393,
0.1079587042,
-0.0138437478,
0.0025589652,
0.047887858,
-0.0059944321,
0.0619553328,
0.0547277071,
0.0099422531,
-0.0358937718,
0.0450883582,
-0.0329684727,
-0.0374728851,
0.0568252243,
0.0051304102,
0.0085203778,
-0.0305046793,
0.0259802695,
0.0230807215,
0.0781540126,
0.0390698202,
0.0086299898,
0.0064970637,
-0.01219883,
0.0021484864,
0.0716777593,
0.033174362,
0.0215205587,
0.0130208936,
-0.041946169,
-0.0233241431,
0.0340135619,
-0.0084118936,
0.0055909362,
0.0092711952,
0.0122041563,
0.0543639138,
0.0448901281,
-0.0310722757,
0.0252774581,
-0.0099835051,
-0.017833095,
-0.0030890419,
-0.0294759739,
0.0342998989,
-0.0040408825,
-0.0407312438,
0.0138513278,
0.0526071265,
-0.034087766,
0.0095274299,
0.0195299517,
0.0219800472,
0.0415321738,
0.00577264,
-0.0102130622,
-0.0418380089,
0.0314397439,
-0.0286854133,
0.0559758022,
0.0174069405,
-0.0388962366,
0.0029824104,
-0.0675433353,
0.0334547013,
0.0300660003,
-0.0285740122,
0.0196884088,
0.0079936748,
0.0301973019,
-0.0009617517,
-0.010557631,
-0.0355282575,
0.0606101528,
-0.029598901,
-0.0051298547,
-0.0271535404,
0.0524816625,
0.0414602906,
-0.0062248665,
-0.020226961,
-0.0067318622,
0.0067078369,
-0.0450158007,
0.0266104098,
0.0207630787,
-0.0112481909,
-0.0656861365,
0.0495970696,
-0.0694140866,
-0.0103540504,
0.0368501469,
-0.0255906414,
-0.04194621,
-0.0160571113,
0.0130803511,
0.0309547596,
-0.0531537719,
0.03737754,
-0.0285002701,
0.0088508241,
-0.0338355862,
0.0263205729,
0.0095254118,
0.0474527627,
0.0017710545,
-0.0137135396,
0.0699653178,
-0.0348312967,
-0.0448770188,
0.0250941515,
-0.0017390351,
0.0244930889,
-0.0248299297,
-0.0282876156,
-0.0119538549,
0.0011154764,
-0.0869577602,
0.0130855152,
-0.0237620827,
0.0466067642,
0.013975732,
0.042793788,
0.0041345116,
-0.0250561219,
-0.0392253473,
-0.0105948634,
0.0136862723,
0.0117910551,
0.0405268893,
-0.0445882007,
-0.0154351462,
-0.0619901791,
0.0082925558,
0.0018384722,
0.0353129916,
-0.0326060168,
-0.0397836082,
-0.0199720934,
0.0045255367,
0.0007420167,
0.0120303323,
-0.0042865276,
-0.0603047386,
-0.0000856596,
0.0295228288,
0.008634232,
0.0113206413,
-0.016523391,
-0.0025700349,
0.0209219251,
0.0372721404,
0.0106251976,
-0.0129004344,
-0.0129881762,
0.0359486714,
-0.0387517586,
0.006877603,
-0.002707276,
0.069795996,
-0.0011544826,
0.008871926,
-0.0724085346,
-0.0513999388,
-0.0162670668,
0.0303883497,
0.0030212593,
0.0288220849,
-0.0299705751,
-0.0136432229,
-0.0462197103,
-0.044147402,
0.0555723086,
-0.0283380877,
0.0073703704,
-0.0702913702,
-0.003703045,
-0.0154813044,
-0.0064595016,
-0.0231385902,
0.0223497301,
-0.0660121888,
-0.0135333799,
-0.0386940017,
0.0262289811,
0.0360735655,
-0.0468816832,
0.0300321989,
-0.0160763673,
0.0051369853,
-0.0536713526,
-0.0499905087,
-0.0075485855,
-0.0694754198,
0.0092043066,
-0.0237474162,
0.0013181664,
-0.0250152238,
0.0063330354,
0.0291670151,
-0.0233402327,
0.0065582031,
0.0235669576,
0.0474780872,
-0.0164411943,
0.051059708,
0.0541770943,
-0.003023074,
-0.0390018336,
0.0162107311,
0.0103565576,
-0.0336407311,
0.0145452917,
0.0125847775,
-0.026887536,
-0.0450131036,
0.0569381304,
-0.0215153117,
0.0057283207,
-0.0512221418,
0.0351268388,
0.0670665801,
0.0193472914,
0.0893572792,
0.0393276177,
0.0073008784,
0.0124322604,
-0.0615381747,
0.0136189926,
0.0089080064,
-0.0158311687,
-0.0557087995,
-0.0040698075,
0.0051103611,
-0.0446561612,
0.0323609449,
0.022347508,
-0.0006090311,
-0.1068991348,
-0.0485780947,
0.0312384702,
-0.0297754705,
-0.0785028189,
-0.0318675339,
-0.0158529077,
-0.0266280957,
0.0237459857,
0.0021736028,
0.0145271448,
-0.0061173346,
0.0305669364,
0.003783932,
-0.0400410183,
-0.0328266434,
-0.0626250356,
0.0612036586,
-0.0136495819,
0.0208477601,
-0.0271444283,
0.0124637298,
-0.0167785995,
-0.0063446788,
-0.0644748956,
0.0217463821,
-0.0120204631,
-0.0129721509,
-0.0384626798,
0.0047558113,
0.010900829,
-0.0196269192,
0.0247909576,
-0.0056810435,
0.0773545876,
0.0169671513,
0.0631549954,
-0.0134923849,
0.0081866356,
0.0205688439,
0.0384221785,
0.0129099078,
-0.0450087041,
0.0289732181,
0.0310823712,
0.028738454,
0.0069420128,
-0.0013540033,
0.0626612455,
-0.0309935212,
0.0041743307,
-0.0336828865,
-0.0466255099,
0.0245024711,
0.0464893878,
0.0615084507,
0.0259254146,
-0.0236881487,
-0.0550660267,
-0.0413251892,
-0.0014529079,
-0.0145761278,
0.0452811606,
-0.017100947,
0.0553403161,
-0.0013740773,
0.0219501704,
-0.0070570861,
-0.0343807414,
-0.0438362025,
-0.0731115639,
-0.0063107093,
-0.0016531588,
0.0142480927,
0.0034618538,
-0.0273962785,
-0.0365320109,
0.023426922,
-0.0185219031,
0.0023507969,
0.0091694957,
-0.0002136179,
-0.0042112097,
0.0117964204,
0.0568979718,
-0.0136836171,
-0.0256312061,
-0.0082603414,
0.0218640417,
-0.0088185482,
0.0045309365,
-0.0090148291,
-0.0209479891,
0.0384994633,
-0.0713853985,
0.0336272307,
-0.0750644878,
-0.0000371209,
0.0163064152,
-0.019305991,
0.0397901945,
-0.0468124337,
0.0966372266,
-0.0151454601,
-0.0095516844,
-0.0210179593,
-0.0093511073,
0.0094855977,
0.0042865532,
0.0193082001,
0.0697372332,
0.0043393406,
0.0062205312,
0.0569972359,
-0.0192319807,
-0.000354293,
-0.028779123,
0.0052355514,
-0.0350442007,
0.0064337603,
0.010521248,
0.0554878116,
0.0155622382,
0.0157182906,
0.0699243098,
0.0149970772,
-0.0024242962,
-0.0227744672,
0.0918521658,
-0.0573646501,
0.0378396548,
0.0068403096,
-0.0188994613,
-0.0195711534,
0.010233908,
-0.0541174337,
0.0201826133,
0.0623458773,
0.0034959163,
-0.0250489675,
-0.0162852127,
0.0413941033,
-0.006792469,
0.0110840481,
0.0003465257,
-0.0009586425,
-0.0139981247,
-0.01312353,
0.0145947346,
0.0272864196,
-0.03548095,
-0.0174735505,
-0.0418221988,
-0.0525510646,
-0.0045936937,
0.0014196516,
-0.057624802,
0.0484651066,
-0.0034009626,
0.0295449607,
-0.0020655296,
0.0439075194,
-0.0005091173,
-0.01526397,
-0.0209288988,
-0.0421901941,
-0.0100904461,
-4.443011222e-33,
-0.0168012921,
0.0256173182,
-0.0086299982,
-0.0362158194,
-0.039167963,
-0.0060431715,
0.0198186599,
0.0162955318,
-0.0894114524,
0.0156664494,
-0.0130818216,
0.0083811879,
0.0160051081,
0.0193561055,
0.0082622133,
-0.0024787423,
-0.0051098573,
0.0187513717,
-0.0234882683,
-0.0247386433,
0.0581876263,
0.0037742166,
0.1014200747,
-0.0325775333,
0.0133479871,
-0.017985506,
0.0205388535,
0.0265362952,
0.046557799,
0.054457508,
-0.0512851365,
0.0405346043,
0.0253291335,
-0.0004644256,
0.0159644447,
0.037258178,
-0.0708188489,
-0.0444188975,
0.0894285887,
0.0562126599,
-0.0367303006,
-0.0127705252,
0.0095786862,
-0.0204536039,
-0.0223238375,
0.0180916414,
0.0009854181,
0.0086265178,
-0.0312532447,
0.0458356477,
-0.1023167297,
0.0318420939,
-0.0085783275,
0.0143333422,
0.0624934956,
0.0292361341,
0.0382160097,
-0.0193535052,
-0.0528001785,
-0.0123897027,
-0.0532259084,
0.064135924,
0.0554448888,
0.02495954,
-0.0251510907,
0.0238049533,
0.0178461019,
-0.0814132988,
0.0553455874,
-0.0014919662,
0.0238934401,
-0.0208675992,
-0.0138633288,
0.0474976711,
0.047016684,
-0.0516427122,
-0.0482182428,
0.0012639113,
0.0071229567,
-0.0314036086,
0.0213574413,
-0.0024500014,
-0.0567678921,
-0.023220174,
-0.0140481023,
-0.0527099706,
-0.008270205,
-0.0220917892,
0.0235917345,
-0.0225619152,
0.0260102954,
0.0546536222,
0.0247633196,
-0.0333221704,
0.0120648118,
0.0252067912,
-0.0093644708,
0.0159622803,
-0.0121936649,
0.0352900177,
-0.0367871188,
-0.0712662637,
-0.0526748449,
0.0162642058,
0.0122743044,
-0.0301412381,
0.0720832944,
-0.0207979567,
-0.0753258392,
0.0342968032,
-0.0394806974,
-0.0496166274,
-0.0256814547,
0.0075583826,
0.029592583,
0.004425915,
0.0064176866,
0.0081816996,
0.0809441581,
-0.0066668498,
0.0094023272,
-0.015024717,
0.0062645706,
-0.0090994984,
-0.0015380076,
0.0296825264,
-0.0012417084,
0.0263105035,
-0.0067041535,
-0.0651304126,
0.0132217817,
0.028093392,
2.05e-7,
0.0423268005,
-0.0147610772,
0.0962009877,
-0.0253687464,
-0.0239685997,
-0.0058511817,
-0.0355505832,
0.0392272361,
-0.0736473277,
0.010140853,
0.0277426057,
-0.0376432277,
0.057131771,
0.0101043973,
-0.062782079,
0.0225173328,
-0.0638089776,
0.0077453852,
-0.0352449529,
0.0119723799,
0.0031351845,
0.1266125143,
0.0144604808,
0.0020807192,
-0.0493214801,
-0.0070300889,
0.0542620271,
-0.0196017139,
-0.0113272481,
0.013138813,
-0.020577006,
0.0381753817,
-0.011513548,
-0.0295563359,
-0.0306844153,
0.0707187653,
0.0461860076,
0.0569518618,
-0.0423154049,
0.0049122558,
-0.0136588793,
-0.0123511096,
-0.0331867933,
-0.0409435146,
0.0347318538,
0.0343573429,
-0.043347571,
-0.0229583532,
0.0142766898,
0.0679297522,
0.0720945075,
-0.0059268489,
-0.0145305498,
0.0025475901,
0.0842720494,
-0.023945326,
-0.0652594939,
-0.0209265351,
-0.0523370132,
0.0319467112,
-0.0126342587,
0.0218993928,
0.0143182212,
0.0092720846,
0.0712646171,
-0.0109129325,
0.0197946839,
1.479886661e-34,
0.0111911409,
-0.0184087399,
0.0408298187,
0.0260999631,
-0.018959688,
-0.0633208454,
0.0031101669,
-0.0105532194,
0.0200777948,
-0.0269117244,
-0.0007370572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10431v1 | Causal Graph in Language Model Rediscovers Cortical Hierarchy in Human Narrative Processing | 2023-11-17T10:09:12 | 2023-11-17T10:09:12 | Zhengqi He, Taro Toyoizumi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding how humans process natural language has long been a vital
research direction. The field of natural language processing (NLP) has recently
experienced a surge in the development of powerful language models. These
models have proven to be invaluable tools for studying another complex system
known to process human language: the brain. Previous studies have demonstrated
that the features of language models can be mapped to fMRI brain activity. This
raises the question: is there a commonality between information processing in
language models and the human brain? To estimate information flow patterns in a
language model, we examined the causal relationships between different layers.
Drawing inspiration from the workspace framework for consciousness, we
hypothesized that features integrating more information would more accurately
predict higher hierarchical brain activity. To validate this hypothesis, we
classified language model features into two categories based on causal network
measures: 'low in-degree' and 'high in-degree'. We subsequently compared the
brain prediction accuracy maps for these two groups. Our results reveal that
the difference in prediction accuracy follows a hierarchical pattern,
consistent with the cortical hierarchy map revealed by activity time constants.
This finding suggests a parallel between how language models and the human
brain process linguistic information. | [
0.008957292,
0.0540299453,
-0.0604380593,
0.0020820098,
-0.0558975004,
0.0262712054,
-0.0289905444,
0.0353062339,
0.0052095647,
-0.0164628867,
0.0215006731,
-0.0633462518,
0.0506380536,
0.0694476962,
0.0433361456,
-0.0380312428,
-0.0065593366,
-0.0283796489,
0.0462368503,
0.0100465827,
-0.0597788803,
-0.0069107679,
-0.012581815,
0.0362628251,
-0.0054173912,
-0.0133193526,
-0.0024963962,
0.012024981,
0.0117679853,
-0.0016268984,
-0.0285541397,
0.0487002097,
0.0327078849,
0.0272780992,
0.0000020207,
-0.0342403911,
0.0510420837,
0.0031517809,
0.0017441708,
-0.0135135315,
-0.0155556267,
0.0323305354,
0.0121320952,
-0.0250604022,
-0.0110077774,
0.0314017758,
0.0398249626,
0.080371663,
-0.0363074318,
0.0644620955,
-0.0249401517,
-0.0428732596,
0.0542735718,
-0.0202481449,
0.0259752218,
0.0212224256,
0.0376710333,
0.0485140011,
-0.0173646417,
-0.0363799632,
-0.061268393,
0.0002008241,
0.0155322989,
0.0230967347,
0.0130077219,
0.0574433282,
0.0608196631,
-0.0116106747,
0.0231642351,
0.0523236804,
0.0230929945,
-0.0566305369,
0.0074515995,
-0.007088216,
-0.0251966584,
0.0375144109,
-0.0383244492,
0.0237290282,
-0.0120958416,
0.025163522,
0.0656927302,
-0.0146857407,
0.0123695275,
-0.0227322839,
0.0134712737,
0.0796960592,
0.0046494533,
-0.0237646233,
0.0130352704,
0.0163833965,
-0.0105832815,
-0.0658522472,
-0.0071895444,
-0.0120274778,
-0.0191142149,
-0.0042433091,
-0.0106945122,
0.0015939388,
-0.0177148338,
-0.0772288144,
0.0248470344,
0.013088081,
0.0328108333,
0.0177778509,
0.021746885,
0.0568924956,
-0.0460268147,
0.0432252362,
-0.0384485871,
0.0334094837,
-0.0453192741,
-0.0297098979,
0.033681035,
0.004920376,
-0.0071768756,
-0.0648329407,
-0.0543261357,
0.0021624793,
0.012280765,
-0.0644310787,
-0.0295682903,
0.0323209688,
0.0164747369,
0.0193262994,
-0.0449619479,
0.0234212577,
-0.0012429768,
0.0469492376,
-0.0374145918,
0.0099181905,
-0.0019684527,
0.0257987753,
-0.0087559242,
-0.0066369176,
-0.0331997499,
0.0500418805,
0.0251751151,
-0.0236177053,
-0.0215859115,
-0.0220835805,
0.0285965316,
-0.0304569677,
0.0346397832,
-0.0508605093,
-0.0101124933,
0.041562397,
-0.0143397953,
-0.0102778515,
0.0008353019,
-0.0081961779,
-0.0972027555,
-0.0039097094,
-0.0232187342,
0.0352452584,
0.0437293909,
0.0035233088,
0.0161370859,
-0.0105138868,
0.0789759606,
0.0240149219,
-0.0100223999,
0.003732732,
-0.0225018766,
-0.018311359,
-0.0568126328,
-0.0319848284,
-0.0502993688,
-0.0520746894,
-0.0294189379,
0.0089258067,
0.0541038997,
0.00110081,
-0.0145111484,
-0.0152854351,
0.0657030419,
0.0608643219,
-0.0142050721,
-0.0156353507,
0.0300715417,
-0.0120491069,
0.0218874346,
0.0401739068,
-0.0483951531,
0.0437501408,
0.0238436423,
-0.0167707261,
-0.0092039583,
-0.0458293594,
0.0088233817,
-0.025835393,
-0.0072623729,
0.027996581,
-0.000937012,
0.0028166976,
0.0123206014,
-0.0336781777,
-0.0299704894,
-0.02896058,
0.0413545519,
0.0027658953,
0.0105370665,
-0.0027162801,
-0.0162803251,
0.0715989247,
0.0088581797,
-0.0027626045,
0.0055993651,
0.0217935499,
0.0043820548,
0.0604760386,
-0.0070838798,
0.014342864,
0.0060996558,
0.0041175764,
0.0171500966,
0.0011197522,
0.0237810053,
0.0202223584,
-0.0632722229,
-0.038279742,
-0.0378553383,
0.0123029985,
-0.074664399,
0.0254987627,
-0.0526141003,
0.0277577899,
-0.0335592777,
-0.0080107981,
0.0237274747,
-0.0173738319,
-0.0375444442,
0.0329786763,
0.0052188542,
-0.0202713851,
-0.0432870761,
0.0413314477,
-0.0363790728,
0.0253084283,
0.0023646066,
-0.0406577662,
-0.0005866374,
0.0285646897,
0.0491524413,
-0.0407427363,
0.0631053969,
-0.0627044886,
0.0487412438,
-0.0082140248,
-0.0037879087,
-0.0203976873,
0.0138100125,
-0.0358864926,
0.0746640712,
0.0080830259,
0.0411466137,
-0.0092407838,
-0.0294397958,
0.0085138604,
-0.0039722444,
0.0167758372,
0.0316443555,
-0.0132487118,
-0.0347173251,
0.0191417933,
-0.0534900017,
-0.0362624899,
0.0007860236,
-0.0600374006,
-0.021894047,
0.0363089107,
0.0188816134,
0.0238677692,
-0.0386151299,
-0.0160530191,
0.0196225066,
-0.0078837574,
0.0528871901,
0.0198145993,
0.0248529222,
-0.0097549269,
-0.022719359,
-0.0129619073,
-0.051899109,
0.0060797008,
-0.0680213794,
0.0598064736,
0.023336418,
-0.0850328952,
-0.0310193691,
0.0569654033,
-0.0102351196,
0.0038619749,
-0.0176111478,
-0.0245231409,
0.0265884493,
0.0231151953,
0.0415824205,
0.04400957,
0.0088831168,
0.0547521897,
0.0704750046,
-0.0315479264,
0.0198541451,
-0.0327761807,
-0.0497081056,
0.0475719869,
-0.0611544326,
-0.0656671077,
0.0053424295,
0.125469327,
0.0884257033,
0.013307956,
-0.0322382525,
-0.0088930838,
-0.0461458303,
-0.0353512429,
0.0059351763,
-0.0543886088,
-0.0381070822,
0.0675437301,
-0.0493223108,
-0.0396822728,
0.0727272406,
-0.005612907,
0.0164030548,
0.0425884873,
0.0035479369,
-0.0073432038,
0.0673115328,
0.0930751562,
0.037411619,
0.0275151022,
-0.0494843759,
-0.0375590585,
0.0187349021,
0.0097083533,
-0.0104177976,
-0.0373743363,
-0.0522042215,
-0.0120792948,
0.0287548844,
0.0114763984,
-0.0094807381,
0.0136411525,
-0.0066026477,
0.0182148311,
-0.0057700356,
-0.0120305987,
-0.0267263148,
-0.0246799737,
0.0264717471,
0.0143508529,
-0.0507522747,
-0.0293281674,
-0.0103471335,
0.0642203987,
0.037020877,
0.0118462369,
0.032038413,
-0.0250540804,
0.0020071431,
0.0254601613,
-0.0364627317,
0.0877200365,
-0.0031213602,
0.0233593602,
0.0062954864,
-0.0257084426,
-0.0356852934,
0.0235561542,
0.0120076425,
-0.0159633458,
0.0000846549,
0.1089384183,
0.0292628799,
-0.0145565793,
0.0360474065,
-0.0132035566,
0.0128075909,
0.0434703268,
-0.0054392596,
-0.0172091126,
0.0383627564,
-0.0085584344,
-0.0188860372,
-0.0362830944,
-0.0588981062,
0.0080038216,
-0.008494541,
0.0297731757,
-0.0241928659,
-0.0238179341,
0.0118519925,
-0.0677097067,
0.0279776342,
0.0422370359,
-0.0319358446,
-0.0292248707,
0.0046707434,
0.0041974019,
0.0263297595,
-0.005104647,
-0.0017040311,
0.0015108316,
-0.012584378,
0.0542764999,
0.0066662431,
0.0779070705,
-0.043385569,
0.0117580472,
-0.0259225275,
0.0242301282,
0.0359015204,
-0.0057189185,
0.0334487371,
0.0495271012,
0.0403953306,
-0.0782002658,
0.0189413335,
0.0002847955,
-0.0587634668,
-0.0504555255,
0.0813961551,
-0.0374911539,
-0.0717826262,
0.0012450318,
0.0475789346,
-0.0156849548,
0.0471846797,
0.0498680398,
-0.0399771444,
-0.0252941214,
-0.0055507766,
0.0438213646,
0.031441018,
-0.0866549537,
-0.0064414227,
0.0340922512,
-0.0147248991,
-0.0497857854,
-0.0063891886,
-0.0277211145,
-0.0073207119,
0.0227235071,
0.0185330734,
0.0565301739,
-0.1051427796,
-0.0395795479,
0.015689658,
-0.0033511831,
-0.0102803959,
-0.0375115834,
-0.0235889032,
-0.0240128599,
-0.0450237617,
-0.0088066161,
0.0016767861,
-0.0516962707,
-0.0783438385,
0.0394624583,
-0.0289417934,
0.022188643,
-0.0146527635,
0.005923219,
-0.0710611939,
0.0092389109,
-0.0302726794,
-0.0218150187,
0.0925086513,
-0.0486090593,
-0.0119042601,
0.0029049681,
0.0160334185,
-0.0188881624,
0.0182116125,
0.042480804,
-0.0015636421,
0.0163629726,
-0.0377918296,
0.0236696918,
-0.0050281943,
0.09764456,
-0.0038572566,
-0.03454924,
-0.0549839623,
-0.0219390504,
-0.0307419337,
-0.0075953305,
0.0018669342,
-0.0557061769,
0.0675563216,
0.0585273728,
-0.0422630981,
-0.0514358692,
-0.0256277006,
-0.0120543353,
0.0040831957,
-0.0351054035,
-0.0263622645,
-0.0069338623,
-0.0019577325,
0.0566518344,
0.0061419662,
0.0025373779,
-0.0517526492,
0.0316680297,
0.0261816364,
0.0427983813,
0.0064055272,
-0.0123231886,
-0.0409490503,
-0.0208313465,
-0.0841349736,
-0.0537801571,
0.0471268035,
-0.0337070376,
0.0448105484,
-0.0310425516,
0.052882731,
-0.059590213,
0.0474784076,
-0.0181956366,
0.0235661902,
0.0061089359,
-0.0139278257,
0.0207226053,
0.0122643905,
0.0055131568,
0.0158460159,
0.0567268431,
0.0791203305,
0.0186262932,
0.0066106291,
-0.033701241,
0.0150844483,
-0.031528689,
-0.0020661487,
0.0277581681,
-0.0445192978,
0.0259616058,
-0.0759934336,
-0.038278915,
0.0179602951,
-0.019629987,
0.0479880348,
-0.0469539277,
-0.0090637887,
0.0279943887,
-0.0140965544,
-0.0498413257,
-0.0209640879,
0.0016829696,
-0.0118218213,
-0.0238932949,
-0.0500729308,
-6.346311064e-33,
-0.039773874,
-0.068558,
0.0022333155,
0.0718735382,
-0.0250630919,
0.0313886479,
-0.0584153347,
0.037666183,
0.0101874135,
0.0286984928,
0.0087582581,
0.0035547905,
0.0146370614,
-0.0039529586,
0.0186953191,
0.0393191054,
-0.0140576046,
0.0047352803,
0.0040868931,
-0.0205417871,
0.0437406786,
0.0029816539,
0.0857080072,
-0.0897251144,
0.0035886965,
0.0074030864,
0.0341197178,
0.039028734,
-0.0188341141,
-0.0136559363,
-0.0551826954,
0.0442588106,
0.0748540834,
-0.0251167919,
0.0170941651,
0.0150502715,
-0.0050130272,
-0.0555619374,
0.0740210488,
-0.0198568199,
-0.0413810536,
-0.0171403177,
0.0422374755,
-0.0091105597,
-0.003047439,
-0.0250790976,
0.0704841614,
-0.0080420924,
0.009123615,
0.018186925,
-0.120265156,
-0.0143053737,
-0.0043898909,
0.0244950335,
-0.0233233776,
0.0161763504,
-0.0322351269,
-0.0282470025,
-0.0477877483,
0.0299815573,
-0.0329359882,
0.0437087901,
-0.016043406,
0.0368936472,
0.0403970592,
0.0924071446,
0.0670645088,
0.0471012741,
-0.0446002074,
0.0442971252,
0.0440056175,
0.0635098666,
-0.0069265934,
-0.0194417462,
0.0211081542,
-0.0122578889,
-0.0447944999,
-0.0090920469,
-0.0314134881,
0.0237220339,
0.0061578546,
-0.0235003904,
-0.0045350241,
-0.0253953505,
-0.0356636606,
-0.0414353162,
-0.019941818,
-0.0138591807,
-0.017978847,
-0.0500699654,
0.0414665043,
-0.0285672061,
0.0262310635,
-0.0123799108,
0.0115464516,
-0.0058119898,
-0.0195879899,
0.0422616415,
0.0290425029,
0.0296727829,
-0.0325999409,
-0.0102074537,
0.0143148778,
0.0025885222,
0.0532239154,
-0.0095764715,
-0.0134799182,
0.0115182931,
0.0245033596,
-0.0071934666,
-0.0194303654,
-0.0801686347,
0.0421064086,
-0.0205347147,
0.0326804966,
-0.0031507295,
-0.0291995965,
-0.025360968,
0.0101262294,
0.0295810122,
-0.0250421725,
0.0058320961,
-0.0476280227,
0.0198604241,
-0.0167070739,
-0.0145738255,
-0.0511687994,
0.0164318793,
0.0478390902,
-0.0651047751,
-0.0505994111,
0.0019999796,
2.97e-7,
0.0303001907,
0.0877194032,
0.0026714175,
0.0321039557,
0.056991484,
0.0010717885,
0.0124993036,
0.0126332967,
0.0460666306,
-0.0460873358,
-0.0091937166,
0.0156666934,
0.0071197804,
0.0183849223,
-0.0404970981,
-0.0318140797,
-0.0302830078,
-0.0114538195,
-0.0292836316,
-0.0137418071,
0.0311978403,
-0.0148278978,
0.0355164967,
-0.0314519517,
-0.009549805,
0.0232287589,
0.0625245497,
-0.0088673765,
0.0252968967,
0.0126613779,
-0.0483083315,
-0.0479535274,
0.009870992,
0.0394987389,
0.0099397842,
-0.0051133991,
-0.002024248,
0.0064725843,
-0.030576596,
0.0312571786,
0.0063551869,
-0.0099602789,
0.0056312419,
-0.0410403199,
0.0193343516,
-0.0382996313,
-0.0895166174,
0.0242059585,
0.0065689147,
0.0317824669,
0.0375472046,
0.0062067928,
-0.0053630602,
-0.0049566017,
0.0077175563,
0.0007200007,
0.0135381604,
-0.0103541585,
-0.0283530187,
0.0214344952,
-0.0479158387,
-0.0232579131,
-0.0323821977,
-0.0274520013,
0.0288112815,
-0.0513896234,
0.0090312511,
2.707109077e-34,
-0.0249760244,
0.0266527086,
0.033795543,
-0.028203968,
0.0173159577,
-0.0134726278,
0.006259094,
0.0112978844,
-0.001338896,
-0.0948358253,
-0.0342747271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10395v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10395v2 | Bias A-head? Analyzing Bias in Transformer-Based Language Model Attention Heads | 2023-11-17T08:56:13 | 2024-06-16T03:33:03 | Yi Yang, Hanyu Duan, Ahmed Abbasi, John P. Lalor, Kar Yan Tam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based pretrained large language models (PLM) such as BERT and GPT
have achieved remarkable success in NLP tasks. However, PLMs are prone to
encoding stereotypical biases. Although a burgeoning literature has emerged on
stereotypical bias mitigation in PLMs, such as work on debiasing gender and
racial stereotyping, how such biases manifest and behave internally within PLMs
remains largely unknown. Understanding the internal stereotyping mechanisms may
allow better assessment of model fairness and guide the development of
effective mitigation strategies. In this work, we focus on attention heads, a
major component of the Transformer architecture, and propose a bias analysis
framework to explore and identify a small set of biased heads that are found to
contribute to a PLM's stereotypical bias. We conduct extensive experiments to
validate the existence of these biased heads and to better understand how they
behave. We investigate gender and racial bias in the English language in two
types of Transformer-based PLMs: the encoder-based BERT model and the
decoder-based autoregressive GPT model. Overall, the results shed light on
understanding the bias behavior in pretrained language models. | [
0.0188995451,
0.0708620399,
-0.0292481426,
0.0341028385,
0.0279110521,
0.034370888,
0.0277514458,
-0.0339607596,
-0.022212306,
-0.0671253726,
-0.0277708005,
-0.0168870874,
0.029368639,
-0.0190594252,
0.0356139913,
-0.0576586761,
0.0465484932,
0.0306591727,
0.0081255408,
-0.0360203125,
0.0257212911,
0.0122650983,
0.0342776962,
0.064201273,
-0.0090203648,
-0.0221612751,
0.0439827554,
-0.0108798528,
-0.0008962108,
0.0084895622,
0.0466520377,
0.0662036464,
-0.0063881981,
0.0493599735,
0.0000018637,
-0.0514555313,
0.0092548532,
-0.0046109506,
0.0157543644,
0.0269282106,
-0.0113421399,
-0.0133679826,
-0.0297680851,
0.0397242457,
-0.004880989,
-0.0295784399,
0.0555702075,
0.0509403124,
0.0529250242,
0.0312688239,
-0.0103909345,
-0.0179092567,
-0.0236867703,
-0.039169874,
-0.0092545999,
-0.0141966371,
0.036010664,
-0.0582938045,
-0.0801178589,
-0.0381454788,
-0.0542900898,
0.008064311,
0.0305309929,
0.0421684608,
0.0281628519,
0.0429123938,
-0.0641238689,
-0.0396706685,
-0.0060324883,
0.0439132825,
-0.0251952261,
-0.0235561933,
-0.0121232281,
-0.0000830878,
0.0203817412,
0.0018829803,
-0.0084187156,
0.0699065402,
0.0022315888,
0.0161373522,
-0.0072319228,
-0.0117597273,
0.0120512303,
0.0076918546,
-0.04247519,
0.0684506446,
0.0429282784,
-0.0568251386,
0.0026383344,
0.0550171323,
0.0086553385,
-0.0486242548,
0.0208522696,
-0.0085142655,
0.0227206666,
0.011858413,
-0.0269111507,
-0.0250149202,
0.0014468327,
-0.0649583414,
0.0187106896,
0.0493312143,
-0.0331717506,
-0.002190832,
-0.0038458777,
0.0392797627,
-0.0359925181,
0.0190491043,
-0.0125260996,
-0.0170088504,
0.0242547691,
-0.0309953783,
-0.0437177084,
-0.0086406991,
0.0241936892,
0.0312375687,
-0.0149788698,
-0.0030946697,
-0.0289310981,
-0.0223185178,
0.0337824933,
0.0297885332,
-0.052123215,
-0.0016451316,
-0.0260635819,
0.0618997887,
-0.0424915291,
-0.0059524821,
-0.0514692366,
-0.0986075997,
-0.027341675,
0.0250361897,
-0.0162291937,
-0.0660823435,
-0.0252903439,
0.0322722159,
0.0096511804,
-0.0465530194,
-0.0166845117,
-0.0002199946,
-0.0192654319,
-0.0434358604,
0.0056850831,
-0.0250102859,
0.0178520083,
0.0404886268,
0.0307680331,
-0.0168287382,
-0.0057050013,
0.0210200604,
-0.0503691062,
0.0450402834,
0.0674458221,
0.0226289351,
0.0441382378,
0.0026938727,
-0.0258016437,
0.0916855559,
0.033513397,
-0.0072780801,
0.0096608829,
-0.0380712003,
0.0030459221,
0.0481352806,
0.0318392627,
-0.0183724873,
-0.0215665735,
0.0113773774,
0.0073912269,
0.0094679026,
0.09259855,
0.0314809904,
0.0003810371,
-0.0278061517,
0.0731813982,
0.0459119789,
-0.0003340851,
0.0529944971,
0.0165940803,
-0.0198677201,
-0.0133482106,
0.0324626751,
-0.0862324163,
-0.0006402308,
-0.0171119403,
-0.0264152586,
-0.0106077408,
0.0709575042,
-0.0343143679,
-0.0079318266,
0.0081774481,
0.0210420117,
0.0035813402,
-0.0053044064,
0.0200722646,
0.0393920802,
-0.0175903179,
0.132663697,
0.0129764918,
-0.0351408049,
0.0227142833,
-0.0535909869,
-0.0122679742,
0.0116570629,
0.0136387581,
-0.0112240259,
-0.0012637293,
-0.0262168739,
-0.0367332548,
0.0678852201,
0.0651364997,
0.036449831,
-0.0028758754,
-0.0372489244,
-0.0264549032,
0.0158821102,
0.0309922341,
0.021767607,
0.0480343811,
0.0462510027,
0.0156401526,
-0.0340168923,
-0.039553389,
0.0331978388,
-0.019197708,
-0.0568806529,
-0.0070730508,
0.0062320693,
0.0076027936,
-0.0053640325,
-0.0421939641,
0.0144136781,
-0.0097816847,
0.0051442971,
0.0065366598,
0.0428767465,
-0.0840514079,
-0.0046224529,
0.0008590787,
-0.0748796165,
-0.0556479469,
0.055647321,
0.0035343093,
-0.0056983782,
0.0444889627,
-0.0392837003,
0.0496967174,
-0.0132578844,
0.0306617133,
-0.0260030292,
0.0404353738,
-0.0250746086,
0.0329876952,
-0.0218908526,
-0.0310969483,
0.0238414519,
-0.042264238,
-0.001677547,
-0.0405759998,
-0.0557046346,
0.0326632373,
0.0014256485,
-0.0183774997,
0.0331785232,
-0.0342805162,
-0.0294484254,
-0.0070511987,
-0.0603107661,
-0.0023106753,
-0.0203757044,
-0.0076960321,
0.0102116559,
0.0263560265,
-0.0119436793,
-0.0099551994,
-0.0103664873,
-0.0526523553,
-0.0023681382,
0.0360144526,
0.0115689682,
-0.0427883938,
0.0194000192,
-0.019763127,
-0.0333620459,
-0.036395926,
0.0623504259,
0.007567076,
-0.0085339164,
-0.0747707337,
-0.0038225336,
0.0179185942,
0.0264430232,
0.0168200657,
-0.0486436449,
0.0305480678,
0.0415740758,
0.0696644858,
0.1010445058,
0.0459376536,
0.0285762362,
0.0584131368,
-0.0162631031,
-0.0560580976,
0.0033929576,
-0.0100823054,
-0.0065911361,
0.0016793922,
-0.0541551374,
0.0145631749,
0.0988397077,
0.0229084287,
-0.0095785083,
-0.086490199,
0.0170810353,
-0.0392473042,
-0.0333753899,
0.02572193,
-0.0320857503,
-0.0312522054,
0.015230298,
-0.0618686676,
-0.0484117679,
0.0643917471,
-0.0112034427,
-0.018768169,
-0.0246231332,
0.0537391007,
-0.0370148309,
0.0217415318,
0.0094163399,
0.024295615,
0.0245532505,
-0.0414304361,
-0.0499664284,
-0.0138051752,
0.0144670466,
-0.028553348,
0.0563622676,
-0.0007634621,
-0.002876577,
-0.0067009302,
-0.0497915372,
-0.0603732392,
-0.022163786,
-0.0188572425,
-0.0105850752,
0.0143995183,
-0.0105287964,
-0.0428373069,
0.0117510846,
0.0198786147,
0.0301521942,
-0.0204644725,
-0.0044409791,
0.0030030415,
-0.0102803623,
0.0273269303,
0.010309835,
0.0408874117,
-0.0156612284,
-0.0013453808,
0.024185976,
0.0020832412,
0.0382277817,
-0.0115220286,
0.0014138264,
0.058322344,
-0.0672529414,
-0.0065871314,
-0.0101787504,
0.0557565466,
-0.0449347533,
-0.0069128936,
0.1146917418,
0.0071347095,
-0.0861837566,
0.0055895075,
-0.0022407516,
0.0021245009,
0.0200616606,
-0.0011495692,
-0.076323621,
-0.0108705722,
0.0148804942,
0.0085334191,
-0.0171621367,
-0.0251708999,
-0.010412219,
-0.148054406,
-0.002603936,
0.0037563054,
-0.029279694,
-0.0423701331,
-0.017822694,
0.000940979,
-0.0354230031,
0.0663024634,
-0.0040670685,
-0.0134315239,
0.0055433358,
0.0060590026,
-0.059473753,
-0.0335100777,
0.009018654,
-0.0571292676,
0.0284615811,
0.0844500139,
0.0052889436,
-0.0238417648,
-0.025301395,
0.0304491539,
-0.035644602,
0.0040106392,
-0.0175604243,
0.0317761041,
-0.0632176027,
-0.0159222502,
-0.0255525708,
0.0064970399,
0.0024890092,
0.0277375784,
-0.013573302,
0.0587975532,
0.0148864118,
-0.0535600111,
-0.037780311,
-0.0104668634,
-0.0199474394,
0.0966895521,
0.0455827713,
-0.0297995675,
-0.0464189015,
-0.0575328283,
0.0279458277,
0.0005802054,
-0.0649469867,
0.0309549775,
0.031728588,
-0.0565748289,
-0.0095247831,
-0.060911525,
0.0126480777,
-0.0289523583,
0.0135875475,
-0.0660378858,
0.0316312276,
-0.0295390151,
-0.0553069636,
0.051756762,
-0.0172945689,
0.0248942655,
-0.0263936892,
-0.0263550915,
0.000655109,
-0.0205919351,
-0.0047655017,
0.0163254626,
-0.024838455,
-0.0472992919,
0.0690275952,
0.0407859534,
0.0253966469,
0.0524132885,
-0.0150225284,
-0.0682095066,
0.0126420399,
0.0196266379,
-0.0018389855,
0.0237270426,
0.0319051854,
-0.0132883089,
0.0093738008,
0.0228559636,
-0.0312256534,
0.0438698344,
0.026705442,
0.0136784902,
-0.0043777032,
-0.0461246297,
0.0056407936,
-0.0057249693,
0.0814226791,
-0.026966162,
0.0460052602,
-0.035410013,
-0.0131245218,
-0.0169990659,
-0.0269680135,
-0.0139494482,
-0.0324049331,
0.0405762643,
0.0297821984,
-0.0333195627,
0.0226884708,
-0.055544477,
-0.0014554134,
-0.0352327228,
0.0488099456,
0.0051723886,
0.0138769997,
0.0122583564,
0.0091094915,
-0.0131374607,
0.0031876003,
-0.006443331,
0.0389049463,
0.0350704677,
0.0510444716,
0.0348745771,
0.0280328989,
-0.0123380916,
-0.0009190786,
-0.0525274053,
-0.0211931299,
0.001743707,
-0.0158735476,
0.0161374453,
-0.0638745204,
0.0503471643,
0.0195228327,
0.0031804203,
0.0162507873,
-0.0183363967,
0.011501871,
0.0074036969,
0.0425147638,
-0.0060807653,
-0.0018561591,
-0.0194090679,
0.0690003186,
0.0029457195,
0.0459152982,
-0.0190253928,
-0.0474995375,
-0.0048662978,
-0.0319931582,
0.0241335165,
-0.0509472527,
-0.0194481667,
-0.0017956975,
-0.0771424323,
-0.0546531826,
-0.0324912593,
-0.0256081764,
0.0393312871,
-0.0273672901,
0.0055836951,
0.0465513989,
-0.0135256499,
-0.0686552227,
0.0159818102,
0.0053784484,
-0.0222256165,
-0.0029689772,
-0.0136320377,
-6.495642193e-33,
-0.0336098522,
-0.0253204703,
-0.0340621136,
-0.0504310206,
-0.0406339802,
0.0040593762,
-0.0156923328,
-0.0043282686,
-0.040239051,
-0.0045636613,
-0.025438644,
0.045198679,
0.0143402303,
0.0031759555,
0.0266325455,
-0.0010880936,
0.0687086508,
0.0046309414,
-0.0428630747,
-0.0179517437,
-0.034841422,
0.0267801508,
0.0631384179,
0.0332924426,
0.0378689505,
-0.0096239401,
0.0022267788,
-0.0076753311,
-0.0049952865,
0.0401900746,
-0.0316065215,
0.0721203983,
0.0360052139,
-0.0488660596,
0.0043807896,
0.0829389393,
-0.0695518106,
-0.0369100645,
0.0099731525,
0.0491403155,
0.0234478414,
-0.0145101622,
0.0494833924,
0.0248824079,
-0.0613046624,
-0.0318963751,
0.0528620556,
0.0136356698,
0.0363859497,
0.0299116168,
-0.0391600169,
0.0140555454,
-0.0203832984,
0.0209239349,
0.0127705373,
-0.0003876464,
0.0110146524,
0.0455512851,
-0.0459621176,
0.0069136992,
0.0155222286,
0.0067871395,
0.041710861,
0.0446411259,
0.022225989,
0.029868111,
0.0522032678,
0.0568844564,
-0.0508830734,
-0.051356554,
0.0377581641,
-0.0387676433,
0.0133026317,
0.0049970006,
0.0501664095,
0.0112517467,
-0.0011059404,
-0.0162731744,
0.0368456505,
0.0570015907,
0.0411669277,
-0.0246310607,
-0.0504646935,
-0.0453355536,
-0.0277251303,
-0.0870899111,
-0.021463329,
-0.0136983711,
0.019605685,
0.0036193654,
-0.0087161483,
0.0577515252,
0.0198658779,
-0.0438946411,
0.0002099549,
0.0240182113,
-0.0142229851,
-0.0277486444,
0.0208396073,
0.0345034748,
-0.0708894804,
0.0181466248,
0.0242670551,
0.0447955355,
0.0072423518,
0.0252845194,
-0.0162596777,
0.0144509934,
-0.0716346875,
0.0037801156,
-0.0351200253,
0.0072666728,
-0.0089597972,
0.0293590687,
0.0347669534,
0.0387451686,
-0.0060220403,
-0.0004426621,
0.0277772043,
0.0087919589,
-0.0529747233,
0.0189279374,
0.0152959581,
0.0416098237,
-0.0137108406,
-0.0155774225,
-0.0060102483,
0.0513968021,
0.056111224,
-0.0696006045,
-0.0411283709,
-0.048925329,
2.548e-7,
0.018867949,
0.0600553937,
0.0402931459,
0.04667712,
0.0281186253,
0.0182709098,
0.0304953083,
0.0766681731,
0.0449202247,
0.0096107936,
-0.0399730392,
0.0424752645,
0.0130090322,
0.0110437358,
-0.0465509966,
-0.0213500839,
-0.0959593579,
0.0593171604,
-0.0219895262,
-0.0054907976,
0.0135410111,
0.0690765232,
0.0088557163,
0.0096860733,
-0.0110671688,
0.0062257922,
0.0343529433,
-0.0222831275,
0.0410897806,
0.0129660377,
0.02465811,
0.016431326,
0.0062550385,
0.0281361695,
0.0124674896,
0.0324940979,
-0.0118395891,
0.0223723259,
-0.0301683564,
-0.0059253215,
-0.0102233095,
0.0100720264,
-0.0246743672,
-0.0958186612,
0.0472644344,
-0.0333828889,
-0.0506933853,
-0.035311535,
-0.047445789,
0.00036116,
0.0449086539,
-0.0191137865,
-0.0209456421,
0.0010352454,
0.0225981809,
0.0106791575,
-0.0137200244,
-0.0867957696,
-0.0457705632,
-0.034030728,
-0.0253699217,
-0.0481318943,
-0.0289796665,
-0.0312718004,
0.0140580395,
-0.0202364177,
0.0246903095,
2.091411769e-34,
0.0307357851,
0.0045606568,
0.0293241777,
-0.005688082,
0.023555493,
-0.0263362732,
0.025995953,
-0.0134966141,
0.0321798548,
-0.0373876952,
-0.0259817988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10373v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10373v1 | FOAL: Fine-grained Contrastive Learning for Cross-domain Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2023-11-17T07:56:01 | 2023-11-17T07:56:01 | Ting Xu, Zhen Wu, Huiyun Yang, Xinyu Dai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) has achieved promising results
while relying on sufficient annotation data in a specific domain. However, it
is infeasible to annotate data for each individual domain. We propose to
explore ASTE in the cross-domain setting, which transfers knowledge from a
resource-rich source domain to a resource-poor target domain, thereby
alleviating the reliance on labeled data in the target domain. To effectively
transfer the knowledge across domains and extract the sentiment triplets
accurately, we propose a method named Fine-grained cOntrAstive Learning (FOAL)
to reduce the domain discrepancy and preserve the discriminability of each
category. Experiments on six transfer pairs show that FOAL achieves 6%
performance gains and reduces the domain discrepancy significantly compared
with strong baselines. Our code will be publicly available once accepted. | [
0.0264576003,
0.0267608259,
0.0064419946,
0.0574378408,
-0.0279017184,
0.0209400654,
0.0171859059,
0.0022040412,
-0.0474009626,
-0.0425221846,
-0.0682543367,
-0.0034079908,
-0.021410469,
0.045979321,
-0.0307652932,
-0.0449021533,
0.0157904383,
0.022953555,
0.0182040334,
-0.001884948,
0.02216544,
0.0232473928,
-0.0168215632,
-0.0239553172,
0.0168996342,
-0.025448313,
0.0464901589,
-0.0130690094,
0.0348165706,
-0.0353980511,
0.0475627407,
0.0189628899,
-0.0087651731,
-0.0198149178,
0.0000021534,
-0.035997387,
-0.0634647161,
0.004280854,
0.0722692013,
-0.004011536,
0.0702020079,
-0.0329510197,
0.0321697444,
-0.010245597,
-0.061380513,
-0.035544198,
0.0078472998,
0.0928772911,
0.0241935849,
0.0636190325,
-0.0317367651,
-0.0326948389,
-0.0284194369,
-0.014020497,
-0.0245011412,
-0.0506339557,
0.013048741,
0.0265883878,
-0.0188059714,
0.0534506813,
-0.0132361874,
0.0040430538,
-0.0042303926,
0.0350884199,
-0.0110887978,
0.0113095734,
0.0159281362,
0.0305518564,
-0.0056159748,
0.0514446869,
0.0481174625,
0.0363006927,
-0.0103051597,
-0.0294581987,
0.0125495289,
-0.0137536516,
0.0001465444,
-0.0356979705,
-0.0121482052,
0.0304971188,
0.0178132895,
0.044425834,
-0.0152514279,
-0.0120183965,
-0.0016925943,
0.0122215534,
-0.021292856,
-0.0244987588,
0.0177200735,
0.1024424285,
0.0264424775,
0.0007030057,
0.0031277721,
-0.0386218578,
0.0133783575,
-0.0093716774,
-0.0191751514,
-0.0094863027,
0.0073632547,
0.009993379,
0.0108969342,
-0.008358662,
-0.0822436512,
0.0504275337,
0.015609839,
-0.0248754714,
0.0076928064,
-0.0158266742,
-0.0149234161,
0.02017048,
-0.0807256624,
0.0290124528,
0.0074921106,
0.0614586025,
-0.0400518402,
0.0314478949,
-0.0420533381,
-0.0391870961,
-0.0267034229,
-0.0350713953,
0.061011225,
-0.0234305318,
0.0024040537,
-0.0020094125,
-0.0311149266,
0.0769954622,
-0.0666772276,
0.0558743589,
-0.0201173481,
-0.010065794,
-0.0058578332,
0.0045884149,
0.0053689014,
-0.0615668558,
0.009077765,
0.0610759296,
0.0153306769,
-0.0456839018,
-0.0621566251,
-0.0073183295,
-0.0201997068,
-0.049527742,
0.0151298223,
-0.0479128174,
0.0306135286,
-0.0070430473,
0.0093238037,
-0.018838333,
-0.017481586,
-0.0295040347,
-0.0313802734,
0.0561863035,
-0.0723618194,
-0.0436377078,
-0.0434491746,
0.0084550492,
-0.0114796832,
0.0500459336,
-0.0134573281,
0.0031795669,
0.028573731,
0.0029310486,
-0.0334601775,
-0.024536578,
0.0060474765,
-0.0069715832,
0.0304057468,
-0.0190407429,
-0.0330819525,
-0.0387928262,
0.0428780466,
0.0155613935,
0.0000884133,
-0.0240817219,
0.0388270095,
-0.0233350582,
0.0413124487,
0.095178239,
0.0291542746,
0.0087461881,
-0.0286450237,
0.034735553,
-0.0144628482,
0.0479263179,
0.0037381453,
-0.00534744,
0.0494732335,
0.05390146,
-0.0130374953,
-0.0419465229,
0.0311898962,
-0.0306003075,
-0.015983697,
-0.0134241413,
0.0762165263,
0.0297614522,
-0.0304507595,
-0.0199978836,
0.0908744186,
-0.019488411,
-0.0061466647,
-0.0135292793,
0.0126420762,
0.0610431731,
-0.0389374308,
-0.0224716123,
-0.0082731592,
-0.0036020994,
0.0046936306,
0.0061515309,
0.0497181676,
0.0110598123,
0.0172713231,
-0.025118079,
-0.0349895619,
-0.034481205,
0.0068735112,
0.0078131277,
0.0090135438,
0.0866736546,
-0.0173161495,
-0.0273615364,
0.0639911518,
-0.0140710808,
-0.0361375958,
-0.0181962997,
0.0218355488,
0.0001115544,
0.0044096014,
0.0558171794,
-0.0259967726,
-0.024958713,
-0.0080019487,
-0.0454310067,
-0.0499442406,
-0.0218557343,
-0.03360736,
-0.0408847257,
0.0128060123,
-0.0229605101,
-0.003334838,
0.0036554874,
-0.0325637646,
0.0115902238,
0.0144146718,
0.0329239368,
0.0150039913,
0.0020314928,
-0.0231707171,
0.0438720211,
0.0260652751,
-0.0070224931,
0.0611066408,
0.0016809499,
-0.0214983784,
-0.0607721917,
-0.0400405675,
0.0033696168,
0.0413079299,
0.0091989981,
-0.0076496727,
0.0072683925,
0.0278887991,
0.0019383858,
0.0296589267,
-0.0421594903,
-0.0197644383,
-0.0281403717,
0.0062926221,
0.0213764664,
0.045482628,
0.0084893079,
-0.0052918796,
0.0231627133,
0.03502772,
-0.0509253815,
0.0243515503,
-0.059834931,
0.0228876136,
0.040141128,
0.0354429595,
0.0500284806,
-0.0127601102,
-0.0010779848,
-0.0194084663,
0.0141068297,
-0.0099363718,
-0.0096187489,
-0.0650011972,
0.0649002567,
-0.0435314924,
0.0245475695,
0.010267958,
0.0048424271,
-0.0351307765,
-0.0149345603,
-0.0429559201,
0.0026692939,
-0.0120013999,
0.0221071951,
0.0101332422,
-0.0237884913,
-0.0216702577,
0.0282369424,
-0.0532284379,
0.0170921627,
-0.0101990653,
0.0088272551,
-0.002685182,
0.0407500714,
0.0048582754,
-0.0066040372,
-0.053988982,
0.018052645,
-0.0087651089,
0.0237814486,
0.0549830608,
0.0650554299,
0.0088625271,
0.0233249087,
0.0048124376,
0.0450075082,
0.0766174197,
0.0221670493,
0.0284473803,
-0.0573928803,
-0.0060257907,
-0.0398502015,
0.0365492441,
-0.0898398012,
0.0094617214,
0.0505788587,
0.002811945,
-0.0092891734,
-0.0409221761,
0.0160758905,
-0.0203751978,
0.0540135801,
-0.0043841437,
0.0138569651,
0.0033406825,
-0.066382207,
0.0366679244,
-0.0128205419,
-0.0539147109,
0.0061045694,
-0.0273293182,
-0.0161431376,
-0.0057963072,
-0.0230924282,
-0.0252614189,
-0.0050231321,
-0.030559428,
-0.0489243753,
0.0285019297,
0.0536446944,
0.0392166488,
-0.0351186134,
0.0085764518,
-0.0173874721,
-0.0110723991,
0.0718246922,
-0.0683728233,
0.0051119332,
-0.026555365,
0.0153726358,
0.0330727585,
0.0114874477,
-0.0082781687,
-0.0660249293,
0.0627662539,
-0.0281770695,
-0.0192059074,
0.0931974649,
0.0085504241,
-0.0618823171,
-0.0059279106,
0.0188952275,
-0.0133759286,
0.0112093287,
0.0028364183,
-0.0801044628,
-0.0736123919,
-0.0524602979,
0.0300686117,
0.0179974157,
-0.0242813267,
0.000236789,
-0.1254264861,
0.0132899759,
-0.0117155435,
-0.0379977264,
-0.0874470323,
-0.0090133194,
0.018112842,
-0.0170789678,
-0.0133384839,
-0.0562013015,
-0.007264473,
0.0137293003,
-0.0065043275,
0.0303889811,
-0.0311947577,
0.0649748743,
-0.0022580584,
0.0073790792,
0.0229043365,
0.0317659788,
-0.0013054364,
-0.0381665193,
0.0201379899,
-0.0724309012,
-0.0045299968,
-0.0417933352,
0.1062258035,
-0.0470193289,
-0.0318747796,
0.0257478748,
-0.0173459928,
-0.0562386625,
0.000781564,
0.0151423737,
0.0393239595,
0.0221146289,
-0.0354546309,
-0.025076678,
0.0315069333,
0.0236422624,
0.0553219803,
-0.0084971162,
-0.0765229315,
0.0280203372,
0.0132066403,
-0.0454090089,
-0.0427096188,
-0.0532503501,
-0.0104174595,
-0.0255395621,
-0.0292204171,
-0.061868459,
-0.0353405662,
-0.0070451265,
0.0183619596,
-0.0138846729,
-0.0069515575,
0.0024857223,
0.0292110592,
-0.0525168739,
0.0151575971,
-0.0352285802,
0.0031026576,
0.0195437018,
-0.0157723855,
0.0989812613,
-0.0406014733,
-0.0500910208,
-0.0238322299,
-0.0286915954,
-0.0267461836,
-0.0185307059,
0.0268023666,
-0.0029828607,
0.0228091124,
0.0053363526,
0.0151847294,
0.0017171139,
0.0614823103,
-0.0204049256,
-0.0005917348,
0.0431820042,
0.0173214264,
0.0229089204,
0.0302660856,
-0.0303636529,
0.03507502,
0.0204074197,
-0.0196737368,
-0.0186137576,
-0.0394846015,
-0.0064200591,
-0.0329849757,
0.0949935317,
0.0444317758,
-0.0007249917,
-0.0193020571,
-0.0058621098,
0.011545225,
-0.0037511114,
-0.0693254769,
-0.0140840448,
0.0048376294,
-0.0050031669,
-0.0594767593,
0.0490510464,
0.0127041182,
0.0257811658,
-0.0587193966,
0.0386911817,
0.0147774657,
0.0377269574,
-0.0337359644,
-0.0063981907,
-0.0117785363,
-0.0190017875,
0.0315553285,
0.0219159164,
-0.0303807668,
0.05518426,
0.0339181982,
0.042169258,
0.010634941,
0.0276652314,
-0.0167323537,
0.0473246835,
-0.0475926623,
-0.0421407297,
-0.0031655277,
-0.0325697921,
0.0593338348,
-0.0081172753,
-0.0059902063,
0.0152476169,
0.0421043634,
-0.039187111,
0.0384475403,
0.0198549945,
0.0042413045,
0.002277405,
-0.003153973,
0.0618823059,
-0.1010144278,
0.047889635,
0.0394826792,
0.0089610582,
-0.0269092396,
-0.0079319049,
0.0098910127,
-0.0161847677,
0.0367770679,
0.0065385113,
-0.063811779,
-0.0504685678,
0.035465274,
-0.0446223319,
0.0034317931,
0.0331312977,
0.0200558491,
0.0527568273,
0.0153061831,
0.0090409219,
-0.0326317661,
-0.0493225828,
-0.000856042,
-0.0240833797,
-0.0020231192,
-6.865812711e-33,
-0.0356357396,
0.0027382439,
-0.0241359528,
0.0240940508,
-0.0484329872,
0.010293005,
-0.0128092747,
0.0261735693,
-0.0091907838,
0.0389798358,
0.0305838194,
0.0094662765,
0.0000836131,
0.0239250548,
0.0054545859,
-0.0144955879,
0.0214499626,
0.0032139979,
0.0127550373,
0.0358929299,
0.0139569631,
0.0395395644,
0.0967324078,
-0.1639047116,
-0.0038611386,
0.0338814743,
-0.0324322097,
0.0015596435,
0.054154031,
0.026260918,
0.0056165871,
0.0305309389,
0.0451121889,
-0.0665726289,
0.0116882883,
-0.0367025323,
-0.0574149229,
-0.0333651006,
0.0085690394,
-0.0232290402,
0.0029435072,
-0.0295552723,
-0.011860461,
0.0015984327,
0.0210249294,
-0.0740933344,
0.0265396405,
-0.040204253,
0.0338472761,
-0.0865372196,
-0.0601761565,
0.0307515245,
0.003020498,
-0.0102152992,
0.0510768853,
0.0099419598,
0.0338054225,
0.0402812958,
-0.0028430086,
0.0144630345,
-0.0371886455,
0.0262819752,
-0.0316447616,
-0.0551790819,
-0.0285100136,
0.0653016493,
-0.0137928296,
0.0254938807,
0.0379907414,
-0.0012064341,
0.0028203302,
0.0293946564,
-0.0055212537,
0.0903974399,
0.0241138432,
-0.0362982191,
-0.0419634841,
0.0096251313,
-0.0415981226,
-0.0598245896,
0.0372455604,
0.0018558326,
-0.03419834,
0.0088139847,
0.0471027903,
-0.0290337093,
-0.0372458249,
-0.0277361702,
0.0005793473,
-0.002150831,
-0.0469731465,
0.0498602241,
-0.0143589256,
-0.0494542941,
-0.0086210016,
0.0177839361,
-0.0542618036,
0.0228473153,
-0.0116131296,
-0.0379283838,
-0.0333292484,
-0.0493864417,
-0.0258925464,
0.0493491925,
0.0463160761,
0.0005341832,
0.0849014521,
-0.0224313233,
-0.0988939628,
-0.0231680088,
-0.0139914798,
0.0220293477,
-0.0054629161,
0.0620995462,
-0.0054101408,
0.0133338505,
-0.0305267982,
0.0937827379,
0.0279917289,
0.016196508,
-0.0149816358,
0.0472738929,
0.0233050324,
0.0263627004,
-0.009776393,
-0.0420862921,
0.0100979479,
-0.0252921842,
-0.0064096679,
-0.022293536,
-0.0404000096,
0.0021872832,
2.889e-7,
0.0192805063,
0.0297793802,
-0.0140651735,
0.0020648958,
0.004627212,
0.085628584,
0.0210261792,
0.0303833168,
0.0249443986,
0.0057533877,
0.0026958252,
0.0386469588,
0.0254181586,
0.042506136,
-0.0655376613,
0.0396184847,
0.0455395393,
-0.0294445157,
-0.007925191,
0.0087988647,
0.0945064649,
0.0495978482,
0.0382589921,
-0.012168969,
0.0276455265,
-0.0037704518,
0.0308876205,
-0.0137343584,
-0.0028956202,
0.0000972311,
-0.0816700533,
0.0139324451,
-0.0363036767,
0.0093170227,
-0.0199334901,
0.0012121941,
0.0087126596,
0.0620547011,
0.029555928,
-0.0606298372,
0.0269956049,
0.0493424051,
0.0242168996,
0.0315227881,
0.0408325642,
-0.0496488214,
-0.0413182713,
-0.0737112984,
-0.0123264873,
0.0123327551,
0.0175326373,
0.0148328412,
0.0101061324,
0.0310823824,
-0.0032546185,
0.008243639,
-0.0719119012,
-0.0572540872,
0.0253159311,
0.0422441475,
0.0203393549,
-0.052075047,
0.0403041802,
-0.0035652095,
-0.010820643,
-0.0628203675,
0.0256928131,
2.33363317e-34,
0.0261729546,
-0.0190690625,
0.0285586398,
0.0194351207,
-0.0000773678,
0.0087011959,
-0.0192703623,
-0.0548851825,
0.0113954181,
0.0181233212,
0.040788047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10367v1 | Exploring the Relationship between In-Context Learning and Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-17T07:40:46 | 2023-11-17T07:40:46 | Hanyu Duan, Yixuan Tang, Yi Yang, Ahmed Abbasi, Kar Yan Tam | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-Context Learning (ICL) and Instruction Tuning (IT) are two primary
paradigms of adopting Large Language Models (LLMs) to downstream applications.
However, they are significantly different. In ICL, a set of demonstrations are
provided at inference time but the LLM's parameters are not updated. In IT, a
set of demonstrations are used to tune LLM's parameters in training time but no
demonstrations are used at inference time. Although a growing body of
literature has explored ICL and IT, studies on these topics have largely been
conducted in isolation, leading to a disconnect between these two paradigms. In
this work, we explore the relationship between ICL and IT by examining how the
hidden states of LLMs change in these two paradigms. Through carefully designed
experiments conducted with LLaMA-2 (7B and 13B), we find that ICL is implicit
IT. In other words, ICL changes an LLM's hidden states as if the demonstrations
were used to instructionally tune the model. Furthermore, the convergence
between ICL and IT is largely contingent upon several factors related to the
provided demonstrations. Overall, this work offers a unique perspective to
explore the connection between ICL and IT and sheds light on understanding the
behaviors of LLM. | [
0.0114880679,
0.016629342,
-0.0363171585,
0.019801382,
-0.0378410704,
0.0316619202,
0.0180611834,
0.001988648,
-0.0288768206,
-0.0375773422,
-0.0677922666,
-0.0211406257,
0.0268574618,
-0.0423626006,
0.0443157479,
-0.0484725721,
0.0499581546,
-0.0607420877,
-0.0592515804,
0.0113834776,
-0.0086391792,
-0.0152211459,
-0.0264949184,
0.019629918,
0.0221270025,
-0.0218614973,
-0.0299342684,
0.0009516196,
-0.0254467539,
-0.0340586565,
-0.0118495636,
0.0030102369,
0.0893336833,
-0.0071732504,
0.0000021934,
-0.0681268349,
0.0135646714,
-0.0198525917,
-0.0387051441,
0.0865544453,
0.0315844305,
0.0215047188,
-0.0291126706,
0.0151546467,
-0.0033741011,
0.0245899092,
0.0198028535,
-0.015867617,
0.0090079941,
0.0572785512,
0.0325295925,
-0.0011763328,
-0.0061861589,
0.0060913833,
-0.006540007,
-0.0336476639,
0.0223079808,
0.0133884214,
0.0258434787,
0.012165498,
-0.0589858107,
0.0175597034,
0.0437052883,
0.0148854367,
-0.0494289175,
0.0345835127,
0.0037263855,
-0.0051406962,
-0.0264745615,
0.01702106,
0.0160736255,
-0.0339805856,
-0.0019134867,
-0.0018689258,
0.0156386681,
-0.001231516,
-0.0560836978,
0.0385569036,
0.0275231451,
0.0429163501,
0.0362790935,
-0.0458676331,
0.029300129,
-0.0129836043,
-0.0097591951,
0.0483798645,
-0.0276269503,
-0.0538545698,
-0.013516047,
-0.011506089,
-0.0055620526,
-0.0492183939,
-0.0242869332,
0.069949463,
-0.0280157942,
0.0568495356,
-0.0293594506,
0.0090698302,
-0.0117321657,
-0.0407898389,
0.0679451972,
0.0599789172,
0.0026020391,
0.0068807555,
-0.0142332604,
0.0627363548,
0.0122121908,
0.0296867564,
-0.0405383706,
0.0685977042,
-0.0505317748,
-0.0044252831,
-0.032911174,
-0.0088947006,
-0.0215319749,
-0.0203274433,
-0.0340016671,
0.0756021291,
0.0082650688,
-0.0138417697,
-0.041860573,
-0.0368466191,
-0.04533628,
0.019184595,
-0.0313002169,
0.0360721238,
0.0014656683,
0.037378855,
-0.0053236461,
-0.0698173717,
0.0040345495,
0.0163508411,
-0.0227105822,
0.0163567178,
0.018587146,
0.053208638,
-0.0608917139,
-0.0569950081,
-0.0512314327,
-0.0027692129,
0.0381774381,
-0.0868632123,
0.0194440577,
-0.057120759,
-0.0186371244,
0.0286224782,
0.0093343761,
-0.0282427687,
-0.0025190639,
0.0020373138,
0.022982277,
0.0317709483,
0.0363899209,
0.0379542559,
0.0306896027,
0.0023709049,
0.0077014002,
0.1029588506,
0.0066130208,
-0.0443801954,
-0.0115829613,
-0.0137189971,
-0.0068326453,
0.0623042807,
0.027627727,
0.0411782637,
-0.0543563664,
-0.0082191834,
0.0385154821,
0.0254610144,
0.0315780006,
0.0057375161,
-0.0167617202,
0.0729156211,
0.046613168,
0.0500344075,
0.0232644137,
-0.0272621997,
0.0343615301,
0.0126391929,
0.0292325132,
0.0401080996,
-0.0575426891,
0.0054346407,
-0.0353640318,
0.0222963784,
-0.0003391379,
0.0258616712,
-0.0128110908,
-0.0311001148,
-0.0076112882,
0.0028981918,
-0.0102889901,
0.0251856428,
0.0451482646,
0.0157972574,
-0.04962942,
0.0074332557,
0.0335433185,
0.0193304922,
0.0247070063,
-0.0882082507,
0.0139952097,
0.0360906124,
0.0276202932,
-0.012756859,
-0.0062498325,
0.0100533403,
0.067234531,
0.0343668051,
0.0200853832,
-0.0251829624,
-0.036188677,
-0.0305366982,
-0.0209254362,
-0.0480559543,
0.0109297941,
0.0030435426,
0.0194311589,
-0.0044028563,
-0.0300227683,
0.0057746922,
-0.0598404035,
0.0375826396,
-0.0858156383,
-0.0558804981,
-0.0672075376,
0.0052326079,
0.0294999909,
-0.0080292271,
-0.0130052799,
-0.0095632207,
0.0393797681,
0.0006718642,
0.0489731207,
0.004727914,
-0.0817736909,
-0.014816897,
0.0206684973,
0.0061651235,
0.0106258923,
-0.0389417224,
-0.0077856216,
-0.0225774329,
0.034312658,
-0.0297218151,
0.0800534487,
0.0139110424,
0.0477806553,
-0.0450427048,
-0.0070762085,
-0.0491511859,
0.0313399509,
-0.0125779249,
-0.0250659101,
0.0585870184,
0.0424606204,
-0.0358156301,
-0.009778508,
0.0074202614,
0.0199671742,
0.0039062984,
0.0204854365,
-0.0515878759,
0.0194072518,
-0.0356364548,
-0.002165382,
-0.0621978529,
-0.0112250652,
-0.0199968908,
0.0354196653,
0.0480315611,
-0.0313408971,
-0.0404661447,
0.0146483108,
0.016311748,
-0.0188073348,
-0.0089355502,
0.0295736548,
-0.0079601621,
0.0503749661,
-0.0554584339,
-0.0202801153,
-0.0048548779,
-0.0218044091,
0.029024886,
-0.0117270201,
-0.0087742163,
-0.0791966319,
0.0655488595,
0.0334286988,
0.0300231576,
-0.0234080069,
0.0043941401,
0.0605493411,
0.0173794497,
0.0483501963,
0.0735911801,
-0.0352853201,
0.0853040963,
0.0450255722,
-0.0117025943,
-0.0657501519,
0.0100493087,
-0.0140198646,
-0.0621125996,
-0.0797776803,
-0.0316120945,
-0.007069875,
0.0648795143,
0.0086846827,
0.0193422344,
-0.0289804097,
0.0081123011,
-0.0590263568,
-0.0493981503,
-0.0286265463,
-0.0404487699,
-0.0461280048,
0.0218095575,
0.0097749028,
-0.0776329488,
0.0458084531,
-0.0159018096,
0.0063643754,
-0.0542623699,
0.001600623,
-0.018102061,
0.0208886005,
-0.025940029,
0.0089762891,
-0.0043423586,
-0.0102161188,
-0.0435604826,
0.0123102069,
-0.0035456698,
0.0019159376,
0.0700890496,
-0.0693925321,
-0.0148142129,
0.0104747145,
0.0025634062,
-0.0224327277,
0.0417797007,
-0.0087904846,
-0.0091778673,
0.0033883052,
-0.0239179768,
-0.0048908419,
-0.0192145184,
0.0424730405,
0.0093415342,
-0.0005464693,
-0.0132803908,
-0.0314934291,
-0.04931961,
-0.0126156006,
0.0093439342,
0.0054546329,
-0.0858521536,
0.0214871094,
-0.0056075593,
0.0698036775,
-0.0304497965,
-0.0065273233,
0.0232960582,
0.0382774808,
-0.0226298012,
-0.0135386568,
0.089378655,
0.0749207139,
-0.0658017769,
-0.032642331,
0.0688360929,
0.0162791517,
-0.05323378,
0.0209198091,
-0.0155422529,
0.0079617538,
0.0274420716,
0.0309498943,
-0.0341887772,
-0.0009794211,
0.003753406,
0.0399187617,
-0.0210039504,
0.0191217232,
-0.0332644917,
-0.1052717417,
0.034054935,
0.0192815177,
-0.0848772153,
-0.0160832964,
-0.0432552248,
0.0230497271,
0.038285546,
0.0790652558,
0.0384540036,
-0.0680525154,
0.0137583362,
0.0646096691,
0.0256574303,
-0.1032403111,
0.0058144149,
0.0021668519,
0.0594845749,
0.034044411,
-0.0344671905,
-0.0153383305,
-0.0382666253,
0.0756016076,
-0.0252508353,
0.0520524867,
-0.0394043922,
-0.0128772836,
0.0050529009,
0.0125130815,
-0.0188598484,
0.0399162695,
0.0044006892,
-0.0196778532,
-0.0044485135,
0.0707348958,
-0.0221890695,
0.0142150344,
0.0045588417,
-0.0237272047,
0.007279403,
0.040796224,
0.0545306988,
-0.0715977997,
0.0151745863,
-0.0244142376,
-0.0273278486,
0.0360371955,
-0.0072738095,
0.0092725884,
-0.029974401,
0.0116305519,
-0.0106407413,
-0.020295782,
0.0265634041,
0.072999239,
0.0302765109,
0.028054852,
0.0018631594,
-0.0185223836,
-0.0016348854,
0.0378735922,
-0.021555746,
0.0329915658,
-0.072496742,
-0.0562451594,
0.0126730176,
-0.0410065763,
0.0175819881,
-0.0020607184,
-0.0312892124,
-0.0732012987,
0.0277811009,
0.0199320354,
0.0222868975,
0.067587994,
0.0457531735,
-0.032666631,
0.043831531,
0.0216014814,
0.0217126478,
0.0807945207,
0.0136219859,
0.0125132585,
0.0102151278,
0.0019890752,
-0.0223037153,
-0.0102143884,
0.0367920995,
0.0271668769,
-0.0421247035,
0.0005254864,
0.0321537293,
-0.0007365959,
0.0125300186,
-0.0143837193,
-0.0334176905,
-0.037365526,
0.0198833998,
0.007690303,
0.012831633,
-0.0074213971,
-0.0531521924,
0.0130476551,
0.0500648357,
0.024155207,
-0.0023627982,
0.0101860361,
0.0209966395,
-0.0018400566,
0.0513960235,
0.0196685065,
0.023462899,
0.0255105123,
0.044054307,
0.000491533,
0.0231247451,
-0.0456857681,
0.0314335637,
0.0247751344,
0.0920065269,
0.0180780888,
-0.0054551931,
-0.0113748759,
0.0173992589,
-0.0135470079,
-0.0174971055,
-0.0334570818,
0.0533730201,
0.0282000992,
-0.0150582753,
0.0253976081,
-0.0425166376,
0.0243240241,
0.0064794803,
-0.0159425922,
-0.0318967924,
-0.0384622999,
0.0264474619,
0.0236946084,
0.0301019587,
0.0117088016,
0.0320958421,
0.0030480234,
0.0769386888,
-0.0290050115,
0.0413326174,
-0.0092030196,
-0.0248736031,
0.0754143074,
0.0258773174,
-0.0078921104,
-0.0174019653,
-0.031796433,
-0.0445732959,
-0.0663968101,
0.0223409012,
-0.0218529981,
-0.0652019605,
0.043342445,
0.0417207293,
-0.0122281732,
-0.03326983,
-0.018029945,
-0.0141887655,
0.0169124827,
-0.0232304074,
-0.0091904057,
-6.348486463e-33,
-0.0609529316,
-0.0181704853,
0.0356221758,
0.0200283043,
-0.0068864743,
-0.0061845174,
-0.0390935913,
0.017870456,
0.0015280541,
-0.0193875525,
-0.0050484305,
-0.0235548858,
0.0082373489,
-0.0216920003,
0.0094239656,
0.0153554743,
0.0084533868,
-0.0216365494,
-0.0315369628,
0.0149064483,
0.0072951526,
0.0024159746,
0.062233191,
-0.035573516,
0.0060205222,
-0.0197894797,
0.0005597164,
0.001275094,
-0.0774357021,
0.0403638445,
-0.0110909259,
0.0393120982,
0.0239163283,
-0.0396679677,
-0.0357332006,
0.0189338662,
-0.0111003667,
-0.0335826017,
0.0572497919,
0.0463826619,
-0.0238167327,
-0.0383282341,
0.0684265196,
-0.006338161,
-0.0776175112,
0.0250975005,
0.0184451845,
-0.0127853435,
-0.0101969969,
-0.0059537655,
-0.0726520494,
-0.0114673823,
0.0082012359,
-0.0386388861,
0.0028909189,
0.0122647351,
-0.0162277762,
-0.0384204686,
-0.0454054922,
0.0224197526,
0.0626571104,
0.0472453833,
0.099931784,
0.0716279149,
0.0214622393,
-0.000372951,
0.0057809292,
0.0238037426,
0.0429129377,
-0.0515937768,
0.0710565597,
0.005731774,
-0.0346174613,
-0.0145540889,
-0.0074417591,
0.0163146574,
-0.045305267,
-0.0164517742,
0.0247364342,
0.0363542028,
0.0304043647,
0.0134652285,
-0.0623228587,
-0.0423676148,
-0.0372398421,
0.0208138395,
0.0073605026,
-0.0306401439,
0.0461592339,
0.0142267654,
-0.0209979843,
-0.025941072,
0.0189482365,
-0.0231178477,
-0.0487437062,
-0.0229806993,
-0.0257534739,
0.0545064062,
-0.0003253347,
-0.0001634551,
-0.1165147275,
-0.0614619218,
-0.0181255098,
0.0077235508,
0.0206710715,
0.013026285,
0.0123934392,
0.0527164452,
-0.0330660492,
0.0114915511,
-0.0458094291,
0.0011197553,
0.0512477309,
-0.0525308773,
0.0538607463,
-0.0074665914,
-0.0255075637,
0.0320415497,
0.0056887786,
-0.0782280564,
-0.0300004259,
-0.0220737234,
-0.0699772015,
0.0225060731,
-0.0260948483,
-0.0114403637,
-0.0378682725,
0.0373125374,
0.0135659948,
-0.0491994955,
-0.0266917776,
0.0115782898,
2.903e-7,
0.005106119,
0.0518373735,
-0.005107204,
0.0141202277,
0.0383202918,
0.0038149974,
-0.0641416088,
-0.0132485321,
0.045606561,
0.0033393444,
0.0020980728,
0.0452049524,
0.0070656356,
-0.0113994004,
-0.0271962527,
-0.015332127,
-0.0237718709,
0.0608622357,
-0.05771669,
0.0132354023,
-0.0158269685,
0.0421237871,
0.0009986471,
-0.0069050086,
-0.0166166611,
-0.0221521519,
0.0421674624,
-0.0354410037,
0.0067494516,
0.0273786057,
-0.0374815874,
0.0448660515,
-0.0081830872,
0.0191239249,
0.0066681565,
0.0083407462,
-0.0751993284,
0.0519589484,
0.0183215793,
0.0042004152,
0.0371830612,
0.0112607433,
-0.0341174826,
-0.0621505305,
0.0425257459,
-0.0827600434,
0.0035841702,
-0.0046323487,
0.0100872703,
-0.0494594127,
-0.0205226075,
0.0063716196,
0.0213702656,
0.0204304606,
-0.0107804649,
-0.0124506149,
-0.0426162779,
-0.0130169354,
-0.013915861,
0.0287037138,
-0.034422826,
-0.0600686632,
-0.0571601391,
0.0144651439,
-0.0196606368,
-0.0351551101,
0.0042683715,
2.637257162e-34,
0.0015386224,
-0.0231274031,
0.0613254346,
0.0394075885,
-0.0290699564,
-0.0056632562,
0.0046206736,
0.0487380587,
0.0541099645,
-0.0795113817,
0.0046902555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10797v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10797v2 | TaCo: Enhancing Cross-Lingual Transfer for Low-Resource Languages in LLMs through Translation-Assisted Chain-of-Thought Processes | 2023-11-17T06:55:32 | 2024-04-05T06:13:15 | Bibek Upadhayay, Vahid Behzadan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Creating multilingual LLMs poses a significant challenge. Pretraining or
fine-tuning LLMs to adopt new languages is evidently very costly. Furthermore,
there exist limitations concerning benchmark datasets and the metrics used to
measure model performance in multilingual settings. This paper proposes
cost-effective solutions to both aforementioned challenges. Firstly, we
introduce the Multilingual Instruction-Tuning Dataset (MITS), comprised of
Alpaca-52K, Dolly-15K, and Vicuna Benchmark translations into 132 languages.
Secondly, we propose a new method called \emph{TaCo: Translation-Assisted
Cross-Linguality}, which utilizes translations in a chain-of-thought process to
instruction-tune LLMs on new languages through a curriculum-learning process.
As a proof of concept, we experimented with the instruction-tuned Guanaco-33B
model, performing further instruction tuning using our proposed TaCo method in
three low-resource languages and one high-resource language. Our results
indicate that the TaCo method impresses GPT-4 with an 82\% score for a
low-resource language in the Vicuna Benchmark dataset, doubling the performance
in contrast to instruction tuning alone. Furthermore, TaCo shows promise in
creating multilingual LLMs, even for low-resource languages. We have released
our datasets and model adapters\footnote{https://github.com/UNHSAILLab/TaCo} ,
encouraging the research community to utilize these resources to advance work
on multilingual LLMs. | [
-0.0086749317,
0.0069711045,
-0.0317907445,
0.074938342,
-0.0291126538,
0.0400057584,
-0.0026634762,
-0.0208938904,
-0.0196280554,
-0.0290654507,
-0.0974904448,
-0.0055416878,
-0.0188649017,
-0.0572806187,
0.0327645615,
-0.0409354344,
0.0486998595,
-0.044815626,
-0.0728542358,
-0.0024605419,
-0.0253211036,
0.0143884169,
-0.0150117464,
-0.0044858884,
0.0336754881,
-0.0160669442,
0.0148209715,
0.0429263003,
0.0586270504,
-0.0428215861,
0.0044326326,
0.0022061463,
0.0027765741,
0.0287630036,
0.0000022936,
-0.0552641973,
-0.0449143946,
-0.0180862844,
0.0101411538,
0.0232464019,
0.043031577,
-0.0124083357,
-0.0266428273,
0.0223604273,
-0.0177092198,
0.0372716449,
0.0021553552,
-0.0294946581,
0.0474037118,
0.0821218714,
0.0045556212,
-0.0448659435,
0.0152915698,
0.0077542444,
0.0232032333,
-0.0478681773,
-0.0184355024,
0.027774103,
0.0054822145,
0.0103979958,
-0.0378201157,
0.0355038643,
0.0316600725,
0.0101997498,
-0.0450616851,
-0.0187343247,
-0.0195570774,
-0.0060679535,
-0.0398322158,
0.0580275878,
-0.0098914029,
-0.0013353396,
-0.022788642,
-0.0134412171,
0.0179911237,
-0.0324920975,
-0.0580411963,
0.0145165557,
0.0186820291,
0.0051759961,
0.0558502637,
-0.0160215814,
0.0145866387,
-0.0017503409,
-0.016971074,
0.0270288065,
0.0351231098,
-0.0170523934,
0.0403860807,
0.0307181831,
0.036312975,
0.0145898992,
0.0102539752,
0.0538418777,
-0.015673345,
0.0304679517,
-0.0315491371,
-0.0144322272,
0.0047071865,
-0.0411887988,
0.0576951094,
0.0741974935,
-0.0469646044,
0.0300591383,
-0.0659274459,
0.0478494167,
-0.0175842065,
0.0463662818,
-0.0776416659,
-0.011989506,
-0.0319249593,
0.0283766501,
-0.023345666,
0.0052950908,
-0.0172342248,
0.0406976342,
-0.0377213247,
0.0296314657,
0.008663835,
0.0141599635,
0.0068658865,
-0.0689536333,
-0.0418144539,
-0.0057057361,
-0.0271698628,
0.0644326136,
0.0188419838,
0.0083794203,
-0.0185130201,
-0.0683580488,
-0.0138310865,
0.0290002879,
-0.0448780097,
-0.0389885157,
0.0440387912,
0.0986340418,
-0.0403983593,
-0.0085591106,
-0.0749309063,
-0.0065156491,
0.0258470383,
-0.0714801475,
0.0425846763,
-0.0817573667,
0.015997408,
0.0135680726,
0.0476585589,
-0.0180252027,
0.0110152196,
-0.0037676506,
-0.010471724,
0.0316816792,
-0.0071490463,
-0.0146872913,
0.0123552456,
-0.0002182965,
-0.0245664567,
0.1115792617,
0.0530208945,
0.0096219592,
0.0230318811,
-0.0224433765,
-0.0500442684,
0.0733749121,
0.0040890318,
0.0396913774,
-0.0010294506,
0.0127201937,
0.0451065525,
0.0423688367,
0.0271002129,
-0.0010883958,
-0.0056759217,
0.0481014401,
0.0337349065,
0.0378757603,
0.0216988623,
0.0215474069,
0.073623322,
-0.0033621357,
0.0029320167,
0.0141634634,
-0.0252346974,
0.0353872739,
-0.026466677,
-0.0064600399,
0.0026514763,
0.0606447123,
-0.030870242,
-0.0578062981,
0.010981773,
0.0037881189,
-0.0281169396,
-0.0205949377,
0.0181983951,
-0.0054002963,
-0.0406070687,
0.0656829998,
0.0338440984,
-0.043323908,
0.0063844491,
-0.0407474115,
-0.0365311466,
0.0639698431,
0.0402266383,
-0.0156224575,
-0.0795220584,
-0.0153026618,
0.0478058457,
0.0498038009,
0.0663465708,
0.008945589,
-0.0083653014,
-0.0710444748,
-0.0204590578,
-0.0183186941,
-0.008903021,
0.0499921963,
-0.0158417094,
0.0436651073,
0.0100151626,
-0.0231113434,
-0.0509902053,
0.0357467979,
-0.0742918253,
-0.0539863519,
0.0024193188,
0.0118213203,
0.0234419834,
0.0345498435,
0.0111771999,
-0.0395075716,
0.0051616984,
-0.0183116961,
0.0476686135,
0.0172482077,
-0.0328498967,
-0.0382275023,
0.0481446646,
-0.0456287377,
-0.0269469079,
-0.0170806758,
-0.0395327099,
-0.0452750772,
-0.021256445,
-0.0329429694,
0.0070580035,
-0.0235992912,
0.038433902,
-0.0377829634,
0.0016851582,
-0.032292366,
0.0171010569,
-0.0019716725,
0.0122817503,
0.0284657329,
-0.0267421566,
0.0450013764,
-0.03620198,
0.0119016767,
0.0071015689,
0.0242031384,
0.017045211,
-0.0136183174,
0.1026599854,
-0.0587399937,
-0.0519483648,
-0.0225417055,
0.0299672764,
-0.0050964737,
0.0448327623,
0.0139821917,
-0.0091537191,
-0.0233836714,
0.011120975,
-0.0316851884,
0.0216513369,
-0.0158719774,
0.0113212634,
0.0136692552,
-0.0114771947,
-0.0059597059,
-0.0278960317,
0.0075723762,
0.0212012939,
0.002523731,
-0.0186418127,
-0.0084724119,
-0.0817116424,
0.0463306457,
-0.0260855798,
-0.0375593901,
0.0069275731,
-0.0495655276,
0.0032291838,
0.0267859958,
0.0459062308,
0.0396869332,
-0.0371959656,
-0.0068113161,
0.0538598076,
-0.0097971596,
-0.0738019273,
0.0184964836,
0.0295845401,
-0.0674921498,
-0.0558351763,
-0.0437765345,
-0.0079406174,
0.0463780612,
-0.0282479357,
-0.0258021429,
-0.053528998,
-0.0448009446,
-0.0270955898,
-0.0143328225,
0.0021012444,
0.0685276166,
0.0002511587,
0.0263090394,
0.0028448715,
-0.0246772394,
0.0452224016,
-0.0177361481,
-0.0035210862,
-0.0797885656,
0.0023399657,
-0.0723197758,
-0.0155673511,
-0.025544839,
0.0006065653,
-0.0636404753,
-0.002784268,
-0.054641623,
0.0195666328,
0.0240964405,
-0.0345930532,
0.0625393242,
-0.0611194596,
-0.02213303,
-0.0453440621,
0.001179828,
-0.0042055734,
0.0869220868,
0.0092217848,
0.0084478501,
0.0209713541,
-0.0024345634,
-0.0430618078,
-0.0330692939,
0.0512940064,
0.0425750986,
-0.0017253821,
-0.0081439409,
-0.0367450565,
-0.0166923646,
-0.0153322732,
-0.0095862681,
0.0316551812,
-0.0792516023,
0.0389460251,
0.0112835634,
0.0207482278,
-0.0734471902,
0.0005978844,
0.0269263666,
0.0665241405,
-0.0258324202,
-0.0162678435,
0.0071799397,
0.0648379326,
-0.0342990197,
-0.0130983805,
0.0776929483,
0.0030220302,
-0.0527971201,
-0.0105964299,
-0.0515790321,
0.0265690815,
0.0296436008,
0.0577424169,
-0.0897854716,
-0.0118057178,
-0.0205664895,
0.0230793655,
0.0183726996,
0.0022012373,
-0.0360474326,
-0.0944722816,
0.0397258401,
0.0340894721,
-0.0308946557,
0.0023783955,
-0.009239451,
-0.0098218527,
-0.0055614412,
0.0451719016,
-0.0175545942,
-0.0337109007,
-0.0079989135,
0.0345336646,
0.0071329754,
-0.0314059407,
0.0008246833,
-0.0155320102,
0.0189046375,
0.0070109251,
0.0370095894,
-0.0157485846,
-0.0707242414,
0.0473678447,
0.0048950836,
-0.0108506912,
-0.0173180271,
-0.0002446075,
0.013007503,
-0.0109439818,
0.0458745211,
0.0058690105,
-0.0383921862,
0.0074024275,
0.0408435315,
0.1011169702,
-0.0075677913,
0.000688767,
0.0094178626,
-0.033958666,
-0.0220978856,
0.0323142856,
0.0339035802,
-0.0670424774,
0.0137746241,
-0.0381992497,
-0.0478332862,
-0.0684859455,
-0.0176193453,
0.0164180677,
-0.0893496275,
0.0077376161,
-0.0442846566,
-0.0421332382,
0.0337381177,
0.0288912561,
0.0455759466,
0.0305211917,
-0.001773204,
-0.0079843421,
-0.0112310331,
0.0121537559,
-0.0412001871,
0.0252500921,
-0.0763318464,
-0.0413947143,
0.0222582705,
-0.0348293781,
0.0099216942,
0.019668635,
-0.0488496646,
-0.0579436645,
-0.0415879339,
0.0736180544,
0.0082107047,
0.0282800291,
0.0287081972,
-0.0118372943,
0.0370163769,
0.0023833464,
0.0061474117,
0.0328548476,
0.0566820577,
0.0620305724,
0.0025538006,
0.0302827191,
-0.02203664,
-0.0125876311,
0.0396471955,
0.0508255027,
-0.0197494905,
-0.0455397852,
0.0090312548,
0.0333878063,
-0.0225761402,
-0.037589971,
-0.0118324338,
-0.025639521,
0.0662823766,
-0.0256061051,
0.0112188971,
-0.0443310514,
-0.0309577975,
0.0312563181,
-0.0310332589,
0.0015994023,
-0.0073587275,
0.0017880654,
0.0036246667,
-0.0084343543,
0.0543359481,
-0.0133128883,
0.0421902686,
0.0085219955,
0.0143372444,
-0.008532322,
-0.0133853313,
-0.0076224725,
0.0448147915,
-0.0190547481,
0.0545562692,
-0.0103919068,
0.0238265097,
0.0243077744,
0.0420891605,
0.0037862896,
-0.0346814096,
-0.0207590517,
0.0074492018,
0.0690016598,
0.0167434886,
0.0943801031,
-0.005188819,
-0.0103596225,
0.0068442975,
0.0361917503,
-0.0336493999,
-0.0023708032,
0.0013102859,
0.0071053277,
0.0229395311,
-0.0043944214,
0.0403468683,
-0.0074489741,
0.0298970472,
-0.018157877,
0.0391929336,
-0.0328626633,
-0.0277813617,
0.0398068018,
-0.0299887285,
0.0072988183,
-0.0010103321,
-0.0406144634,
-0.0507473163,
-0.0048733465,
0.0046631247,
-0.0128791537,
-0.0220724903,
0.0179173481,
0.0740533769,
-0.0305201877,
-0.0184650104,
-0.0365622006,
-0.0283696912,
0.0142748505,
-0.0382306352,
0.0196397007,
-6.220743288e-33,
-0.0399154201,
-0.0033009674,
0.0727204606,
0.0481246188,
0.0047778799,
-0.0222166516,
0.0008979418,
-0.0163563937,
0.0010922183,
-0.001564641,
-0.0000280392,
-0.0268533546,
0.0148739973,
0.005861586,
0.0357280336,
0.0257663503,
0.0175582115,
-0.002995285,
-0.0025258253,
0.0128479488,
-0.0039665918,
0.0346843787,
0.1187854782,
-0.0348251984,
0.0213664826,
0.0138714649,
0.0288987085,
-0.0081275795,
-0.018062396,
0.039541699,
0.0110173095,
0.0211462099,
0.0086768214,
-0.037730027,
-0.0313974321,
-0.052716285,
-0.0330625512,
-0.066469036,
0.0395244621,
0.0407516472,
0.0088210115,
-0.0999161452,
0.029030513,
-0.0181267262,
-0.0528778657,
-0.0401048176,
0.0234752558,
-0.0563802235,
-0.0122446325,
-0.0224647745,
-0.0872250572,
0.0127113117,
-0.0058055385,
-0.0095128343,
0.0343240052,
0.038319502,
-0.0330364257,
-0.0127342083,
-0.0644627362,
0.0351527072,
0.0129670491,
0.0439580604,
0.1055632755,
0.0028298954,
-0.0324724279,
-0.0092581371,
-0.0081353448,
0.0094559509,
0.0620793626,
0.0141487233,
0.043181248,
0.0297611188,
0.0365530998,
0.0218820944,
-0.016114885,
0.0169576053,
-0.0679942593,
0.0584305562,
0.0216975845,
0.0308885016,
0.0044039204,
-0.0003984369,
0.0068008816,
0.0145362942,
-0.042135939,
-0.0054169805,
0.009046128,
-0.0308800545,
0.017093651,
-0.0244406555,
-0.0184248034,
-0.0220826231,
0.0556352846,
-0.0238396339,
-0.0240627378,
-0.016066134,
-0.0351087898,
0.0004672581,
-0.0074315253,
0.0471569337,
-0.0575394779,
-0.0755004734,
-0.0082121892,
-0.0209110398,
0.0534427352,
-0.0229371209,
0.0534576476,
0.025828477,
-0.0452245921,
0.0038722919,
-0.0582479984,
0.0102178752,
0.024354687,
0.013181244,
-0.024357887,
-0.0035799369,
-0.0037332226,
0.0560368113,
0.0248481669,
-0.0499037169,
-0.006637441,
-0.0176029652,
-0.0121183274,
0.048744034,
-0.0366705544,
0.0373503603,
-0.0434372425,
0.0254040193,
0.0194980111,
-0.0579270534,
-0.0107025709,
0.0191915296,
3.044e-7,
0.0360156558,
0.0538257696,
-0.034370143,
0.0282862913,
-0.0062285699,
0.0087146675,
-0.0635534227,
0.0174786653,
0.0213306267,
-0.0085483603,
0.0166581646,
0.0562941283,
0.087275207,
0.0422985405,
-0.050632026,
-0.0345432162,
0.0239310991,
0.0450923257,
-0.0673788041,
0.0021938388,
0.0237510968,
0.0405842997,
0.0042248024,
-0.0189902894,
-0.0245423019,
0.0260672569,
0.0558136255,
-0.0605226457,
-0.0306835063,
0.0301885363,
0.041562181,
0.0410133339,
-0.0349793099,
-0.0134743731,
-0.0219618529,
0.0238011032,
-0.0078975363,
0.067543067,
0.0190762375,
-0.0262585171,
0.059772782,
-0.0282749571,
-0.0314367525,
-0.0191689003,
0.0404594317,
0.0048881755,
0.0166648831,
0.0252952166,
0.0061577964,
-0.0145460684,
0.0436622314,
-0.0475230366,
-0.0030888107,
0.0152103119,
0.0470738932,
-0.0336834416,
-0.0560105667,
0.0006616809,
0.0221752506,
0.0189727955,
0.002943089,
-0.0706481412,
-0.0422441028,
0.0280731265,
-0.0211797077,
-0.0326897241,
0.0034421803,
2.676652753e-34,
0.0176490769,
-0.0643910691,
0.0596769042,
0.0268766377,
0.0012930224,
-0.006998749,
-0.0118186949,
0.0156459175,
-0.0162024777,
-0.0512002446,
-0.0038756826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10344v1 | Complementary Advantages of ChatGPTs and Human Readers in Reasoning: Evidence from English Text Reading Comprehension | 2023-11-17T06:13:02 | 2023-11-17T06:13:02 | Tongquan Zhou, Yao Zhang, Siyi Cao, Yulu Li, Tao Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT has shown its great power in text processing, including its reasoning
ability from text reading. However, there has not been any direct comparison
between human readers and ChatGPT in reasoning ability related to text reading.
This study was undertaken to investigate how ChatGPTs (i.e., ChatGPT and
ChatGPT Plus) and Chinese senior school students as ESL learners exhibited
their reasoning ability from English narrative texts. Additionally, we compared
the two ChatGPTs in the reasoning performances when commands were updated
elaborately. The whole study was composed of three reasoning tests: Test 1 for
commonsense inference, Test 2 for emotional inference, and Test 3 for causal
inference. The results showed that in Test 1, the students outdid the two
ChatGPT versions in local-culture-related inferences but performed worse than
the chatbots in daily-life inferences. In Test 2, ChatGPT Plus excelled whereas
ChatGPT lagged behind in accuracy. In association with both accuracy and
frequency of correct responses, the students were inferior to the two chatbots.
Compared with ChatGPTs' better performance in positive emotions, the students
showed their superiority in inferring negative emotions. In Test 3, the
students demonstrated better logical analysis, outdoing both chatbots. In
updating command condition, ChatGPT Plus displayed good causal reasoning
ability while ChatGPT kept unchanged. Our study reveals that human readers and
ChatGPTs have their respective advantages and disadvantages in drawing
inferences from text reading comprehension, unlocking a complementary
relationship in text-based reasoning. | [
0.0239515416,
-0.0510537475,
-0.0410447642,
0.0098950602,
-0.0579654984,
0.0398869365,
0.0304202735,
0.0181545112,
0.1002919674,
-0.0234223288,
0.0021561102,
0.0122463051,
0.0016698817,
0.0123607256,
0.0165216625,
-0.0659947395,
0.0198764522,
0.0171812698,
0.056511499,
-0.0183811653,
0.0260391813,
0.0404508673,
-0.0282413382,
0.0268476214,
0.0091586737,
-0.0464644916,
-0.0119336508,
-0.0148040522,
0.0470389016,
-0.0064052586,
-0.0056827962,
0.0130528342,
0.0099992724,
0.0164926182,
0.0000021877,
-0.0522604696,
-0.0035131394,
-0.0209135134,
0.0055193659,
-0.0037493657,
0.0298827961,
0.0384361073,
-0.0045020534,
0.0124920486,
-0.0377518572,
0.0303332116,
0.0313595943,
0.075578481,
0.0178552195,
0.0681266487,
-0.0104368264,
-0.0229551345,
-0.0072921687,
0.0546710752,
0.0621847436,
-0.0320414454,
-0.0179679412,
0.0727397874,
0.0631851852,
-0.0112215457,
-0.0164242368,
0.0421689712,
0.0553575568,
-0.0117884586,
-0.0490942523,
0.0492822118,
-0.0238585435,
-0.0105284126,
0.0307872072,
0.0321166813,
0.0680319145,
-0.0327386148,
-0.034666568,
0.0171621349,
0.012872058,
0.0353836007,
-0.0372517556,
0.0323109776,
-0.0505664349,
0.0091191316,
0.020029651,
-0.0436922535,
-0.0394658856,
0.0165245868,
0.007327958,
0.0396309681,
-0.0219299179,
-0.0384620987,
-0.0124759702,
0.0088014472,
-0.0455381311,
-0.0177840926,
0.0101872291,
0.0303495582,
0.002415145,
0.0321241841,
0.0175021067,
-0.0129781878,
-0.0326963663,
-0.0635688528,
-0.0774919614,
0.0963834375,
-0.0161968525,
0.0126399407,
-0.0240700226,
0.0500517488,
0.0346898474,
0.0805918574,
-0.0272085685,
0.0111119878,
-0.0636606067,
-0.0511298999,
-0.0010153952,
0.0524219088,
-0.0020051107,
-0.0192848761,
-0.0718251243,
-0.0034066015,
0.0311982203,
-0.0179885458,
-0.0266633872,
-0.0159439705,
-0.0144537054,
-0.0224387106,
-0.0283678118,
0.023333149,
-0.0544408448,
0.015382247,
-0.0032728272,
-0.0598187894,
-0.0009603241,
0.0149863763,
-0.0077879666,
-0.0265887175,
-0.0354646221,
0.0476561747,
-0.0589141697,
-0.0278265886,
-0.0674075484,
-0.0111601669,
0.0180993713,
-0.0615095645,
-0.0140002705,
-0.0238121357,
-0.0138572147,
0.0445657857,
-0.0055214418,
0.0181396678,
0.0023973475,
0.0255658608,
0.0161885377,
0.0129054086,
0.0183774251,
0.0177979097,
0.0189926028,
0.0355089568,
-0.0641087964,
0.0414927453,
0.027552627,
-0.0213578679,
-0.0107043581,
-0.0067437585,
-0.0251413602,
0.0015154452,
-0.0437362976,
-0.0449004173,
0.0105349757,
-0.0419372767,
-0.0216587111,
0.0049004187,
-0.0053427499,
0.0182040874,
-0.0655672401,
0.0218337625,
0.068120271,
0.0587063618,
-0.0010970735,
0.0339079872,
-0.0136126541,
0.0216324106,
0.055414401,
0.0604785234,
-0.0314955823,
0.0152780907,
-0.0454753526,
-0.0039939163,
-0.0417015851,
-0.0376118012,
0.0090690413,
-0.0229726266,
-0.0097688902,
0.0155080575,
0.0272261221,
-0.0082038334,
0.0290768668,
-0.0357964672,
-0.0108760064,
-0.0040125907,
0.0255041756,
-0.0681168213,
-0.0292199291,
-0.0540847108,
0.006176868,
0.0631314963,
0.0157901607,
0.0011966766,
-0.0386888161,
0.0300232433,
-0.0088175097,
0.0470210947,
0.0079374593,
0.0257682055,
-0.0198561903,
-0.0207743198,
0.0274641421,
0.0126067027,
-0.0281818919,
0.0335918814,
-0.0178951826,
0.0671981201,
-0.0005338066,
-0.0273075309,
0.0255546495,
-0.0044351914,
-0.0425143987,
0.0037104452,
-0.0628990754,
0.0088086855,
0.0043745907,
0.0065554036,
-0.0083181364,
-0.0042966763,
-0.037942443,
0.0312664732,
-0.0522649586,
0.0851185992,
-0.0702334568,
-0.0651886836,
0.0154042784,
-0.0633868799,
-0.0483329073,
0.0166351441,
0.0128825344,
-0.0072161108,
0.0197811723,
-0.0595296361,
0.0435297191,
-0.012412589,
0.0118077071,
-0.0409738496,
-0.0261771604,
-0.0134341689,
0.0574547127,
0.038279172,
-0.0166355819,
-0.0028992482,
0.0460577197,
0.0134527292,
-0.014446903,
-0.0139127681,
0.0200728644,
0.0281329751,
-0.0271827076,
0.0072686146,
0.0327163562,
-0.0860015377,
0.0172239598,
-0.0899082795,
-0.0153946215,
0.0199884009,
0.0104343966,
0.0271585304,
-0.0435282327,
-0.0514289066,
0.0194456726,
-0.0196383614,
0.0170326773,
-0.0063454956,
0.0299879517,
0.0102347862,
-0.0486905463,
0.0285003837,
0.0137909763,
-0.0003219817,
-0.0734180138,
-0.0051534208,
0.063064523,
-0.0259530712,
-0.0250083935,
0.0296448283,
-0.0264199898,
-0.0105338916,
-0.0122638484,
-0.0771480724,
0.049599845,
0.0036133153,
0.039159622,
0.0993282571,
0.0257551521,
0.018937096,
-0.0123172477,
-0.0293583833,
-0.0417107679,
0.015357255,
0.0041877637,
0.0069447639,
-0.0105998656,
-0.0410845652,
-0.0730000734,
0.0155327953,
0.0313672759,
0.006571576,
-0.0604944713,
0.0202472415,
-0.0236876756,
-0.0230805334,
-0.0257748831,
-0.0251446366,
-0.0392052159,
0.0241013542,
-0.0071427124,
-0.0073475339,
0.077232644,
0.0164269395,
-0.0190956686,
-0.1056218967,
0.0382550955,
-0.0089098765,
0.0819288641,
-0.0384337567,
0.0156058343,
-0.0088453954,
-0.0641612262,
-0.0532189943,
-0.0140063381,
0.0570334941,
0.010765655,
0.0043902821,
-0.0441600941,
-0.0240563899,
-0.0139473882,
0.0003867232,
-0.0419875458,
0.0237468593,
-0.0255864654,
-0.0159533303,
0.019360844,
-0.0081104292,
-0.0258737076,
-0.0158421323,
0.050857503,
-0.0222021751,
-0.0442502014,
-0.00314107,
0.0029185459,
-0.0306427758,
-0.0127913179,
-0.0062112496,
0.0200004932,
-0.0299341958,
0.0723786205,
0.0862394869,
-0.011651122,
-0.0528049879,
0.0133829182,
0.0260353424,
0.0047716326,
-0.0007358172,
-0.0195228849,
-0.0326007679,
0.0736981407,
-0.0646537766,
0.0332947224,
0.1187249795,
0.031399291,
0.0018014821,
-0.012571007,
-0.032597594,
0.0207449663,
-0.0190615412,
0.0056910813,
-0.0568330176,
-0.0189404525,
0.0234348737,
-0.0061711366,
-0.0351250693,
-0.0269323476,
-0.0239356365,
-0.0763337612,
0.0104840742,
0.0045887874,
-0.0449587405,
-0.0075202277,
-0.0164363012,
0.0013709923,
0.0337872133,
0.0050057229,
0.0312118027,
0.007410212,
0.0114714606,
0.0199062154,
-0.0299901608,
0.0251355115,
0.0411967337,
-0.0055522653,
0.0091534415,
-0.0119383177,
0.0732253492,
-0.0109162573,
-0.0129159549,
0.0370952599,
0.0565616265,
0.0059593553,
-0.0124590527,
0.0046406472,
0.0098389676,
0.0253510922,
-0.0793533549,
0.0364639796,
0.0358864255,
-0.0278500989,
0.0403410681,
0.0362048559,
-0.0025986484,
-0.0457501672,
-0.0069899848,
0.0639262274,
-0.0434758365,
0.0395358093,
0.0007523788,
0.0012090814,
-0.032220982,
0.0014826383,
-0.0274857767,
-0.0029917411,
-0.0630772114,
0.0233308617,
-0.0061142277,
-0.0483597554,
-0.052642934,
-0.0947730616,
0.0284511503,
0.0303577352,
0.0007825973,
0.0211762134,
0.0455991775,
0.0146206459,
0.013879274,
0.0133218151,
0.0028406514,
-0.0095778946,
0.0094283586,
0.0052923923,
-0.0199797694,
-0.037695054,
-0.0128700584,
-0.0378288068,
-0.0216894392,
-0.0369422808,
0.0134596489,
-0.0272156056,
0.0127244424,
-0.0168586113,
0.0073182071,
-0.0228640176,
-0.0165799707,
0.0199305508,
-0.0201638024,
0.0042513064,
-0.0070987809,
0.0499730259,
0.0349153914,
-0.0037775834,
0.0306149703,
0.0117592104,
0.0083272457,
0.0144655667,
0.0043990794,
0.0100942161,
0.0322904736,
0.0788989887,
0.0166091733,
0.0220967457,
-0.0041052806,
-0.0524370074,
0.0073153679,
-0.059112221,
-0.0082919216,
0.0026419333,
-0.0236030985,
-0.0181564558,
0.0077313948,
-0.0225969441,
-0.0579611585,
-0.0316639729,
-0.0127212461,
0.0143653713,
0.0502280518,
0.005590653,
0.0307397842,
0.0018564931,
0.0096062124,
-0.0199032705,
-0.0271586962,
-0.0187805742,
0.0650343895,
0.0008916092,
0.1268580705,
0.0444180965,
-0.0427014641,
0.0582761616,
-0.0240913946,
-0.0494149551,
-0.043126557,
0.0672211051,
0.0316071622,
0.0103641525,
-0.0026402944,
0.0180705227,
-0.0749017969,
0.0397386551,
-0.0143219503,
0.0099097565,
0.0092711821,
-0.002991199,
-0.0040416806,
-0.0251675639,
-0.002764344,
-0.020275658,
0.0126467822,
-0.0702971667,
0.0122441202,
-0.0021989096,
-0.0300909337,
-0.008343746,
-0.0439747721,
0.0081731575,
-0.003387321,
0.0209260155,
0.02817351,
-0.0618972257,
-0.0506136231,
-0.0269619543,
-0.0042587183,
0.0130521301,
-0.0058351448,
0.0103584686,
0.0580567084,
-0.029373724,
-0.050222721,
-0.0240082704,
0.0458406024,
-0.0520418398,
0.0066575413,
-0.0239706356,
-6.429431004e-33,
-0.0049165031,
-0.0391864814,
0.0505423583,
0.0207461547,
-0.0070186555,
-0.0288725365,
-0.0391802937,
0.0498512536,
-0.0291196909,
0.0379948765,
-0.0234767646,
0.04508036,
0.0052234256,
-0.0079794908,
-0.0073420377,
-0.0156872235,
-0.029715389,
0.0327706262,
-0.0086093443,
-0.0184027907,
0.0521737449,
0.0045830295,
0.1135947034,
-0.0762294158,
0.036090821,
-0.0193806253,
0.0110999867,
-0.0125761768,
-0.0215980262,
-0.0058992859,
0.020716086,
0.0386342295,
0.0318772942,
0.0039932118,
0.004927936,
0.0542926192,
-0.0115032261,
-0.0692302287,
0.0665778592,
0.0467123911,
-0.0228135325,
0.000840357,
-0.0060260701,
-0.0165292658,
0.0107964678,
-0.0283654649,
0.0468356125,
-0.0004154834,
0.052574683,
0.0258326959,
-0.0623989403,
0.0466381013,
-0.0343436822,
-0.0001949927,
-0.0441162921,
0.0634765029,
-0.031311024,
-0.0132950218,
-0.0217520669,
0.0058740019,
0.0082279993,
-0.0069781668,
0.0398885049,
-0.0378160551,
0.0260301419,
0.0467926562,
0.0071862089,
0.0155847585,
-0.061586637,
0.0002540225,
0.0600018725,
-0.0037471675,
0.0359468013,
0.0442173742,
-0.0161095802,
-0.0231481306,
-0.065676786,
-0.0081395041,
0.0819449872,
0.0405420996,
0.018792076,
0.0046243793,
-0.0626516193,
-0.0130872838,
-0.0031313794,
0.0576635376,
-0.0240020584,
-0.0736596659,
0.0212801117,
-0.0887855068,
0.0144631546,
-0.070830889,
0.0139251137,
-0.0086778803,
0.0273994505,
-0.0007221458,
-0.0517937392,
-0.0016735557,
-0.0234985705,
0.0556830615,
-0.0204973817,
-0.0033875084,
0.0179620478,
0.0284403916,
0.021978382,
0.0212671701,
0.0064563123,
-0.0106002968,
-0.0092978524,
-0.02699285,
-0.0338398181,
-0.0174718704,
0.0120751224,
-0.05712175,
0.0162977595,
0.0354350209,
-0.0019488194,
0.0001737389,
0.0395150892,
0.0215395987,
-0.067411691,
-0.0121623036,
-0.0530057847,
-0.0270325467,
-0.0148440599,
0.0151856681,
-0.0121765221,
0.0274316315,
-0.0249207988,
-0.0731940269,
-0.004324812,
0.0062722461,
3.03e-7,
0.0149248764,
0.0519722141,
0.0136029758,
0.0396540947,
-0.0081853317,
0.0380448028,
0.0037000123,
-0.0274723358,
0.1030832678,
0.0146674123,
0.001502979,
0.0404589437,
0.02131995,
0.043895632,
-0.0633953512,
-0.0252201464,
-0.0530770235,
-0.0157385431,
-0.0116925025,
0.0748208985,
0.1396105736,
-0.0119266491,
0.0209799707,
-0.0128623275,
0.0101119708,
-0.0330454372,
0.0140001494,
0.0018017568,
-0.0099639986,
0.0013195841,
0.0058574616,
-0.0090488298,
0.0497221202,
0.0744205266,
0.0387092903,
-0.0295664016,
0.0218331944,
0.0245127324,
-0.0018102083,
0.0177531932,
0.0086298389,
-0.0039386353,
-0.0174455829,
-0.0685867667,
0.0997663811,
-0.0417396277,
-0.0670418069,
0.0509421602,
-0.0139376419,
-0.0529886074,
0.0038917144,
0.0072518466,
-0.0379138216,
0.0327355452,
-0.0013273265,
-0.0344712697,
0.0191216674,
-0.0572401844,
-0.0104526971,
0.0095962137,
-0.0144497873,
-0.0531850159,
-0.0252399761,
0.0088425903,
0.0394216329,
-0.0054604537,
-0.0184009206,
2.052581884e-34,
-0.0179716032,
-0.0114452858,
0.0327084251,
0.0139770955,
0.0547098368,
0.0336775519,
0.0534227937,
0.0096044159,
0.0453983471,
-0.0169222858,
-0.0298846457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10271v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10271v1 | Prompt Pool based Class-Incremental Continual Learning for Dialog State Tracking | 2023-11-17T01:33:05 | 2023-11-17T01:33:05 | Hong Liu, Yucheng Cai, Yuan Zhou, Zhijian Ou, Yi Huang, Junlan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Continual learning is crucial for dialog state tracking (DST) in dialog
systems, since requirements from users for new functionalities are often
encountered. However, most of existing continual learning methods for DST
require task identities during testing, which is a severe limit in real-world
applications. In this paper, we aim to address continual learning of DST in the
class-incremental scenario (namely the task identity is unknown in testing).
Inspired by the recently emerging prompt tuning method that performs well on
dialog systems, we propose to use the prompt pool method, where we maintain a
pool of key-value paired prompts and select prompts from the pool according to
the distance between the dialog history and the prompt keys. The proposed
method can automatically identify tasks and select appropriate prompts during
testing. We conduct experiments on Schema-Guided Dialog dataset (SGD) and
another dataset collected from a real-world dialog application. Experiment
results show that the prompt pool method achieves much higher joint goal
accuracy than the baseline. After combining with a rehearsal buffer, the model
performance can be further improved. | [
0.0202687997,
0.0336493477,
-0.0088128196,
0.0008632813,
-0.0152424388,
0.0032421793,
0.0266712215,
-0.0353540368,
0.0319778472,
-0.0440583415,
-0.0113959527,
-0.0541681238,
-0.034567751,
0.0717948228,
-0.0225391295,
-0.0482841507,
0.0769879892,
-0.0374414884,
-0.0059073097,
0.0215193368,
0.0153063294,
-0.0277775563,
-0.0781054348,
0.0630435571,
-0.0254890136,
-0.0602952614,
-0.059611313,
-0.0172695853,
-0.0130242351,
-0.0426749103,
0.0222341251,
0.0670203418,
0.0172741711,
0.0111134099,
0.0000020169,
-0.0802181885,
-0.0124266371,
-0.0453448407,
-0.0866871625,
-0.02364772,
-0.019732045,
0.0764668137,
-0.0231615081,
0.0353459902,
-0.0132536581,
0.0134609947,
0.0342221558,
0.0325206555,
0.0824862793,
0.0360354409,
0.0023161657,
0.0322815925,
0.0219836216,
-0.005144882,
0.0154100573,
-0.1135342419,
0.0022065856,
-0.0052458355,
0.0010180359,
-0.0103676338,
0.0228201915,
0.0097087901,
0.005865443,
-0.0622428544,
-0.0165615566,
-0.0040378193,
0.0143609168,
-0.0039274348,
-0.0323644504,
0.061314933,
0.0252776369,
0.0287597738,
0.0089137936,
-0.015005243,
0.0010611606,
-0.0164633393,
-0.0383812152,
-0.0393584892,
-0.0501032099,
-0.0277786516,
-0.0335261934,
0.0150869275,
-0.0624670349,
-0.0008591141,
-0.0315695852,
0.013901215,
-0.0166668054,
-0.0283320975,
-0.0067707431,
-0.0310151316,
0.0152910938,
-0.0480361432,
0.0303575788,
0.029352596,
-0.1102402136,
0.0115238847,
-0.0143140974,
0.0116577148,
0.0066479356,
0.0103578493,
-0.0007544597,
0.056387309,
-0.0138268406,
0.0429842509,
0.0300100278,
0.0958378762,
0.0479421467,
-0.0148551185,
-0.0014813903,
0.0310819075,
-0.088321574,
0.0099870469,
-0.069151327,
0.0413661599,
-0.0034731028,
-0.0356066413,
-0.011411801,
0.0832315385,
0.0234109946,
0.0542602539,
-0.0420808531,
0.0103158625,
-0.0557029955,
0.0320607685,
-0.0252822805,
0.0401874892,
-0.008766274,
0.0083941808,
0.0153881898,
-0.015822148,
-0.0184309147,
0.0096564563,
0.0263611712,
0.0196093582,
-0.0421584472,
0.0398707166,
-0.0253407042,
-0.0159526821,
-0.0034085759,
-0.0227474719,
0.0054451898,
-0.0017625918,
-0.0483059287,
0.0106472643,
0.0096392594,
-0.0218064021,
-0.0119736567,
-0.0106115732,
-0.0127500035,
0.0341909491,
0.0556405708,
0.0499749631,
0.0322864987,
-0.0079626916,
0.0104154097,
0.0017499904,
-0.0405619219,
0.0776037425,
0.0173639599,
0.0212355517,
0.0462547131,
-0.0246537104,
0.0380010791,
0.0079464493,
-0.0012801395,
0.0279086884,
-0.0013200133,
0.046583809,
0.0332943983,
-0.0144221894,
-0.0220461953,
-0.00236787,
-0.0114367409,
0.0140086589,
0.0537980236,
0.0613942295,
0.003126923,
-0.0333405212,
-0.0123011898,
0.0200230591,
0.0155168492,
0.0159571376,
-0.0047312281,
0.011513778,
-0.0074686506,
-0.0005628793,
0.0079947999,
-0.0189894605,
-0.0335184447,
-0.0467989445,
0.0345140174,
0.0074600289,
-0.0440648235,
0.0147844013,
0.0375988372,
-0.009526399,
-0.0686187074,
0.0453928374,
-0.0038397578,
-0.0523172468,
-0.0532992929,
-0.0340778939,
0.0181516875,
0.0815413669,
0.0328796655,
-0.0673511401,
-0.0901688188,
-0.062852174,
0.0363495611,
0.0212482829,
0.0250257459,
-0.0471005924,
0.0317012891,
-0.0171110053,
-0.024267124,
0.0222292282,
-0.0016149308,
0.0128612584,
-0.0282012597,
-0.0186608508,
0.0083427597,
0.0417475514,
-0.0040830038,
0.0110685509,
0.0197016168,
-0.0268888921,
0.0225080587,
0.013561964,
0.0324410684,
0.0292663947,
0.0129769817,
-0.009007765,
0.0175148491,
0.0018836674,
0.0205060486,
0.0137639279,
-0.0761411563,
-0.0422445908,
0.0297064316,
0.0622060858,
-0.0217487458,
-0.0314048156,
-0.0437778383,
-0.0501605906,
-0.0226059202,
-0.0214422289,
-0.01020326,
-0.0338373259,
0.0423698612,
-0.0094988653,
-0.0429644436,
-0.0399156995,
0.026497962,
0.0113181006,
0.0042427666,
0.027404828,
0.0725030899,
0.0145628881,
-0.0801255628,
0.0252688974,
0.0237308387,
-0.0421774201,
0.0074053421,
0.0105055748,
0.0019630315,
-0.046215985,
-0.0057470109,
-0.0912812427,
0.0303601436,
-0.0094937682,
0.0142011242,
-0.0017384195,
0.0024451474,
-0.0282654688,
-0.054950878,
-0.0262649786,
-0.0260013286,
0.0301716439,
-0.0202496611,
0.0114801172,
0.0220171399,
-0.0223233923,
-0.0539036207,
0.0456476994,
-0.0129547371,
0.0006702892,
-0.0205040667,
-0.0238567907,
-0.0623298213,
0.0522512309,
-0.0028267258,
0.0419916026,
-0.0249428116,
-0.0014677985,
0.0343926139,
0.0369432122,
0.0254570581,
0.0294407532,
0.0421537757,
0.025667185,
-0.0266849324,
-0.0192215312,
-0.0610962175,
0.0518564582,
0.001101873,
-0.0189251583,
-0.0193158872,
0.043891415,
0.0350099728,
0.0186562743,
-0.0147638423,
0.0242144,
-0.0164349675,
0.0199628565,
-0.0090593183,
0.0231218208,
-0.0551739223,
-0.0102290437,
-0.0577092171,
0.0016172493,
-0.0022315851,
-0.0465996452,
0.0577004887,
-0.0127007933,
-0.0280340463,
-0.068602547,
-0.0180542134,
-0.0090695675,
0.0646234304,
-0.0600223765,
-0.0068902145,
0.052406732,
-0.0718144178,
-0.014004943,
-0.0126259802,
0.0299108233,
-0.0517413877,
0.0654407889,
-0.0254986156,
0.030334672,
-0.0285832547,
-0.0656646714,
-0.0968331099,
-0.0484158434,
0.0068142959,
-0.0046727867,
-0.0177461095,
0.0017323695,
0.007413744,
0.0336680375,
0.0023959142,
0.0702711567,
-0.0021561424,
-0.0111766774,
-0.0366941206,
0.0043343068,
0.0470791571,
0.0311530437,
-0.0238158796,
-0.0059355129,
0.1080757305,
0.0350917242,
0.1040681526,
-0.0219113361,
0.0165308081,
-0.0270555783,
-0.0072285207,
-0.0422695503,
0.0120959077,
0.0113488976,
0.0350698493,
-0.0390894674,
-0.0158720072,
0.117478624,
0.0468529426,
-0.0668893456,
-0.0202529319,
0.0012127593,
-0.01057027,
0.0408987738,
0.0280606169,
-0.0719226003,
-0.0295990147,
0.0257440116,
0.0537384823,
-0.0201110337,
-0.041195415,
-0.0276560914,
-0.0780180395,
0.0025630943,
-0.0122694718,
-0.0280186273,
0.0002781878,
-0.0353559181,
0.0144912302,
0.0179345682,
0.0250692386,
0.0412593894,
0.0063473633,
-0.0276908204,
0.0488794446,
-0.0213408079,
-0.0260948893,
0.0274807923,
-0.0203544647,
0.0515439995,
0.0661091208,
0.0304845199,
0.041758135,
-0.0082798144,
0.054370176,
-0.0454844311,
0.0214683358,
0.0043526245,
0.0244316179,
-0.0124114342,
-0.0228932425,
-0.0029994226,
0.0147023862,
-0.0247906856,
0.010467642,
0.0789853185,
0.0208664425,
-0.0697023422,
0.0545649193,
0.0036213035,
-0.0321770944,
0.0527140461,
0.0372396559,
0.0124785881,
-0.0635648072,
0.0072521269,
-0.0260545779,
0.0030803275,
-0.018598035,
0.0423682071,
-0.0272869729,
-0.0208592173,
0.020603044,
-0.0533614568,
-0.0330815241,
0.0322322994,
0.0733266994,
-0.0129575944,
0.0145719089,
-0.008783048,
0.0454262644,
0.0077938931,
0.0052405023,
-0.0224788301,
0.0232109874,
-0.0617797002,
-0.0188871622,
0.045821242,
0.0101746609,
-0.0132416002,
0.0025836325,
-0.0283372682,
-0.035422273,
-0.0168383736,
0.025354445,
0.0200765859,
0.0363109298,
-0.0063791764,
-0.0057989615,
-0.0356958099,
0.0019863874,
-0.028428914,
-0.0262043606,
0.0362839364,
0.065190576,
-0.0361651815,
0.0128842732,
-0.0445611775,
0.0177514069,
-0.027240742,
0.0318765827,
-0.0348966084,
-0.0660902262,
0.0061690663,
0.0010825304,
0.0321254469,
0.053809721,
-0.0365535617,
-0.0310412627,
0.0879406407,
0.008189613,
-0.0251284204,
-0.0425573885,
0.0412743092,
-0.0586290397,
-0.0522798076,
0.0275997613,
-0.0280608386,
-0.0199100897,
0.035225179,
-0.0442393459,
0.0064319628,
0.0208709463,
0.0159999337,
0.0057597016,
-0.0098461397,
-0.0337643474,
0.0247064885,
0.0585477613,
0.0411582291,
0.0240114126,
0.1070762426,
0.0206428356,
-0.0169843063,
0.0168011412,
0.0297721289,
-0.0750919953,
-0.0560759008,
-0.0131549258,
0.0225412063,
0.0280646291,
0.0302079953,
-0.0013675736,
0.0154796895,
0.0266858898,
-0.0278348569,
0.029422082,
0.0307979882,
-0.029911736,
-0.025973659,
0.0339363664,
0.0150226494,
0.0082994476,
0.073671788,
-0.0189753193,
0.0277865753,
-0.0238047298,
0.0108334906,
-0.0704532787,
0.0159815997,
-0.0003591447,
0.0577324629,
0.0099918637,
-0.0041504228,
-0.0353997499,
-0.0065298243,
0.030179508,
-0.0044344408,
0.0190086737,
-0.015734449,
0.0340860374,
0.0213303361,
-0.0106381932,
0.0116208121,
-0.0133782951,
-0.013468991,
-0.0010580643,
0.0003122193,
-0.026685996,
-5.179886019e-33,
-0.0572242737,
-0.0501425564,
0.0326960683,
0.0022149368,
-0.0381439663,
0.0008315832,
-0.0557748079,
0.0116098542,
0.0241989791,
-0.0271274988,
-0.0222527441,
0.009040229,
0.0279077999,
-0.0015825602,
0.0004477446,
-0.0459132604,
0.0663956553,
0.0012774012,
-0.0271452535,
0.0665533021,
0.0834675655,
0.0393509418,
0.0023408672,
-0.0462146662,
0.0259081908,
0.0155867105,
0.0094320215,
0.0418877192,
0.0046810387,
0.0368335471,
0.0083604343,
0.0227386374,
0.0077908393,
-0.0527362302,
-0.0234051012,
0.027668234,
0.0042179688,
-0.0541415848,
-0.0092908079,
0.0210488569,
0.0170849599,
0.0194874685,
-0.0195616558,
-0.0223282594,
-0.0014229382,
0.0373053402,
0.0040731989,
0.0003653918,
-0.0244800635,
-0.0030858356,
-0.0361670889,
0.0034072287,
-0.0392747372,
-0.0747209266,
-0.0201515723,
0.0646948367,
0.0189449415,
-0.0942235067,
-0.0242263675,
-0.0046168217,
-0.006681866,
-0.0029148618,
0.006763055,
0.0528955199,
0.0238747448,
0.0652064383,
0.034140043,
0.022687342,
-0.0068491958,
-0.0371490903,
-0.010482369,
0.0057152994,
0.0287414659,
-0.043620605,
-0.0078419335,
-0.0454079807,
-0.0079024024,
0.0211982206,
0.0931660756,
0.0196998287,
0.0092708152,
0.0059967535,
-0.0414878428,
-0.0089359693,
-0.0497835949,
0.0268166978,
-0.0034779103,
-0.0045073926,
0.0692504272,
0.0335368067,
-0.0259330999,
-0.0250509251,
0.0513196923,
0.0091995997,
-0.0185052585,
0.0169445015,
-0.0087535363,
0.0191020034,
-0.0173477549,
-0.014128414,
-0.0150318583,
-0.0311414246,
0.0417305492,
-0.0011274631,
0.0370252505,
0.0011690668,
-0.0219984949,
0.026121255,
-0.0563566126,
0.0105545772,
-0.0462027192,
0.0517138392,
-0.0275475681,
0.03923795,
0.0323482789,
-0.0288486406,
-0.0181685854,
0.1020183489,
-0.0074271383,
-0.0804422796,
-0.0554067753,
-0.0029859666,
0.0161042958,
0.0139605654,
-0.0149951978,
-0.0377448499,
0.01053843,
0.0037406257,
-0.0121077979,
-0.0273910109,
0.0242716689,
-0.0167979579,
2.68e-7,
-0.0464244299,
0.025551714,
0.0254858993,
-0.0208559763,
0.0392767973,
0.0561701134,
-0.0198727045,
0.000261464,
0.0447415002,
-0.0146511784,
-0.0027202077,
-0.020551214,
0.0231424626,
0.0227673799,
-0.1169821098,
-0.0483573228,
-0.0324676894,
0.0093880687,
-0.0536579788,
0.0629878044,
0.0362853892,
0.0313273482,
-0.0050099054,
0.0124046523,
0.045185037,
-0.0266749561,
-0.0019813008,
0.0124955643,
0.0294319205,
0.0303648692,
0.032099802,
-0.02299219,
0.0000979299,
0.049716983,
-0.0047307978,
0.024422273,
-0.0192198195,
0.0420576595,
-0.0072661554,
-0.0470674038,
-0.0330269001,
0.0172898266,
0.0294216424,
-0.0063022478,
0.0542058013,
-0.0250227991,
0.0155727593,
-0.0584158003,
0.0157226827,
-0.0482145846,
-0.0097021516,
0.0505634025,
0.0021588327,
0.006435161,
-0.0154156173,
0.0234195665,
0.0073546162,
-0.074061349,
0.0069737993,
-0.0245717205,
-0.0421021655,
-0.050751023,
-0.0324856751,
-0.0167288464,
-0.0301629379,
-0.0446728766,
0.0040491549,
2.622216115e-34,
0.0130227292,
-0.0298129711,
0.0308086835,
0.0591358468,
0.0199913196,
0.002969729,
0.0380509682,
0.0104975682,
0.0782401413,
-0.0378034227,
-0.0208328534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10267v1 | Energy and Carbon Considerations of Fine-Tuning BERT | 2023-11-17T01:27:01 | 2023-11-17T01:27:01 | Xiaorong Wang, Clara Na, Emma Strubell, Sorelle Friedler, Sasha Luccioni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite the popularity of the `pre-train then fine-tune' paradigm in the NLP
community, existing work quantifying energy costs and associated carbon
emissions has largely focused on language model pre-training. Although a single
pre-training run draws substantially more energy than fine-tuning, fine-tuning
is performed more frequently by many more individual actors, and thus must be
accounted for when considering the energy and carbon footprint of NLP. In order
to better characterize the role of fine-tuning in the landscape of energy and
carbon emissions in NLP, we perform a careful empirical study of the
computational costs of fine-tuning across tasks, datasets, hardware
infrastructure and measurement modalities. Our experimental results allow us to
place fine-tuning energy and carbon costs into perspective with respect to
pre-training and inference, and outline recommendations to NLP researchers and
practitioners who wish to improve their fine-tuning energy efficiency. | [
0.0486931726,
0.0734050795,
-0.0054726102,
0.0284606535,
-0.0288949665,
0.0219009537,
-0.0085094487,
0.0135462116,
-0.0685233176,
-0.0690419525,
-0.0087307626,
0.0402082019,
0.0211679675,
-0.0258792136,
0.0423099175,
-0.045894742,
0.1079367325,
-0.0033177487,
0.0092396401,
-0.0099865654,
0.0055390229,
-0.0197418686,
0.0049475138,
0.0256924536,
-0.0382292643,
0.0102088833,
-0.0112839099,
0.042841576,
-0.0088946456,
-0.0132497773,
0.0262774695,
0.0738621876,
-0.0298146382,
0.0653256103,
0.0000016851,
-0.0466835983,
-0.0315313414,
0.0282415841,
-0.0301858801,
0.0685180053,
0.031748727,
0.0125585198,
-0.004361439,
0.0390964374,
0.0134021109,
0.0025007073,
0.1021970734,
-0.0298017692,
0.0273954477,
0.0382531472,
-0.0113948714,
0.014810672,
-0.0042606853,
-0.0318721421,
-0.0018453678,
0.0143971071,
0.0043491013,
-0.0305197537,
-0.0703841522,
-0.0210093241,
-0.0320394486,
0.048700504,
0.0027292899,
0.0404403098,
-0.015565291,
0.0154588725,
-0.0920938402,
-0.014285421,
-0.0197661761,
0.023331238,
-0.0171236265,
-0.0104496898,
0.008022109,
-0.0121599855,
-0.0304258578,
-0.0109614721,
0.011756001,
0.013941858,
0.018119907,
0.0126811331,
-0.0024578082,
-0.0294673238,
0.0180327594,
0.0209353268,
0.0010040908,
0.0395482667,
0.0034197606,
-0.0413534045,
0.0469220541,
0.0546358451,
-0.0343420133,
-0.0729459375,
-0.0115467673,
-0.027900001,
0.0304758232,
0.0060515073,
-0.058077231,
-0.0274691842,
0.0061912276,
-0.0193133187,
0.064546071,
0.0346837416,
0.0397984311,
-0.0026054552,
-0.007115731,
-0.0034825807,
-0.0042233686,
-0.0110219298,
-0.0219206866,
0.0052126418,
-0.024017429,
-0.010673672,
-0.0737782866,
-0.0013352854,
-0.0350996777,
-0.0304375384,
-0.0302023422,
-0.0222493466,
-0.0128433872,
0.0034447256,
0.0143952575,
0.0218107477,
-0.0111999754,
0.0401680432,
0.0034778884,
0.0412782989,
-0.0661425665,
0.0025980915,
-0.0069030547,
-0.0717697889,
-0.0082119135,
0.0164411254,
-0.0092390534,
-0.029061269,
0.0413931198,
0.0512513742,
0.029008979,
-0.0446789674,
-0.0148078408,
-0.0339718536,
-0.007487664,
-0.028113259,
-0.0026076843,
-0.0489381067,
-0.0122307651,
0.0010735682,
0.0154345324,
-0.0117372861,
0.0072044632,
0.0208601244,
-0.0543775856,
0.0570669435,
-0.0807497501,
0.0143273873,
-0.0116650816,
-0.0442519374,
-0.0129376063,
0.123026751,
0.0952352062,
-0.0193064213,
0.0638765171,
-0.0395913199,
-0.0748931766,
0.0618464611,
0.0427211113,
0.0047411392,
-0.0533138439,
-0.0427346528,
-0.0109921461,
0.0336763486,
0.0429779105,
0.0341514573,
-0.0285482462,
0.0305486042,
0.0403920598,
0.0560689718,
0.0141329188,
0.0034126621,
-0.0132943559,
-0.0089635672,
0.0198726114,
-0.004949932,
-0.0264566634,
-0.004637022,
-0.0457314663,
-0.0304656271,
0.0469179228,
0.0150988353,
-0.0059119612,
-0.0390993133,
-0.0214956421,
-0.0096863117,
0.028614087,
-0.0125699658,
0.0198243372,
-0.0061813234,
-0.0024627724,
0.1085884348,
0.045688875,
-0.0444311239,
-0.0479910374,
-0.04644043,
-0.0554154925,
0.0256528221,
0.0416770987,
0.00175819,
-0.0031517947,
0.0040804325,
0.0084567824,
-0.0124607747,
0.0865755081,
0.0060060513,
0.0166230369,
-0.0412066244,
-0.0181588233,
-0.0446489751,
0.0020238804,
-0.0429756641,
0.031877052,
-0.0019793997,
-0.0034491334,
-0.0189057365,
-0.0579483472,
0.0341088362,
0.0126932254,
-0.0413537994,
-0.024772441,
0.0161929298,
0.0175454747,
-0.0277608819,
-0.0460619368,
0.0222444981,
0.0118043926,
0.0087147718,
0.0216018669,
0.010662741,
0.0167957861,
0.030825913,
0.0180342589,
0.0043612872,
0.011322015,
0.0254490711,
-0.0023022145,
-0.02510993,
-0.0235190578,
-0.0601496287,
0.0880253762,
-0.0127466647,
0.0229398422,
-0.0275703464,
0.0299658179,
-0.0130977882,
0.041859258,
-0.0106486846,
0.0581303574,
-0.0030444071,
0.0256204102,
0.0151942689,
-0.0172582045,
-0.0286480729,
-0.0208052769,
0.0008327395,
-0.0035922837,
0.0577728711,
-0.0012972158,
-0.0514667928,
0.0135782277,
-0.0848496333,
0.0322224684,
-0.0079379156,
0.0453668199,
0.014854094,
-0.0012811808,
-0.0194051154,
0.0357749648,
0.0338813737,
-0.0000854008,
-0.0416436866,
0.0615506433,
0.0098709855,
-0.0231371447,
0.0017383213,
-0.0210543107,
-0.0337102152,
-0.0178675838,
0.0604121014,
0.0019498345,
-0.0249537732,
-0.0125603024,
0.0407661162,
0.0068233428,
0.0074319332,
0.0185183268,
-0.0713052824,
0.0045861434,
0.0204398073,
0.0222282596,
0.0718958527,
0.0037918277,
0.0305944756,
0.0078714434,
-0.0237020627,
-0.0762316436,
0.0289767422,
0.0278443638,
-0.0347350314,
-0.0156642739,
-0.0292422082,
0.0359123945,
0.0990619883,
-0.0712762773,
-0.0033518726,
0.007332541,
0.0333761312,
-0.0295985937,
-0.0638403371,
-0.0157376528,
0.0189654808,
-0.0266123991,
0.0423492976,
-0.0044209664,
-0.069403328,
0.0337087177,
-0.0386710055,
0.0022593564,
-0.0405936949,
0.0099361902,
0.0455193818,
0.0321765915,
-0.0039638905,
0.0514521599,
0.0259252414,
-0.0028776317,
-0.025535034,
-0.0126174353,
0.0338033997,
0.0054103555,
0.0196596477,
-0.0315144807,
0.0265159886,
-0.0275663268,
-0.0450005382,
0.0034368257,
-0.015010545,
-0.0442653075,
0.0063137831,
0.0522309728,
-0.0763652995,
-0.047129482,
0.0217379313,
0.0260519441,
0.0154413227,
0.0062553487,
-0.0252361074,
-0.0189252682,
0.0278644599,
0.0202358067,
0.0139471432,
0.0386261605,
-0.0272017717,
-0.0497458838,
0.0591809638,
0.036524985,
0.0376476608,
-0.0147239352,
0.0128431385,
0.0459293425,
-0.0285874177,
-0.0459257402,
0.0194173008,
0.0537330955,
-0.0470014662,
-0.0151660908,
0.0851648673,
0.03409601,
-0.0278059989,
0.0383807234,
0.0390813015,
0.0445703752,
0.0019906785,
0.003784725,
-0.0739092156,
-0.0445650928,
0.0757643729,
0.0436665863,
-0.0368199944,
-0.0302936025,
-0.0174658261,
-0.0982068181,
0.0056773978,
-0.0189544931,
0.0112239197,
0.0194972269,
-0.0582649112,
-0.0045718071,
-0.0185679793,
-0.0156736672,
-0.0244864933,
-0.0298975706,
0.0098216059,
0.0471846685,
-0.0442323126,
-0.043654196,
0.0003402499,
-0.0276691169,
0.0342429131,
0.070224613,
0.0249825213,
-0.0492682457,
-0.0304772779,
0.0528586172,
-0.0251739416,
0.0191935915,
-0.0364216305,
0.020280689,
0.0174358543,
-0.0230688378,
0.0063462723,
-0.01314048,
-0.0039848927,
0.0022813217,
-0.014657842,
0.043675676,
0.0043144664,
-0.0267251804,
0.0154954055,
-0.025123639,
0.0109466575,
0.0792882666,
0.0373732001,
-0.0435154624,
-0.0601535477,
-0.0404784158,
-0.0075857053,
-0.0581217557,
-0.0098472666,
-0.018004287,
-0.0303555205,
-0.0453921594,
-0.0107357167,
-0.0334276967,
0.0350631922,
0.0607372932,
-0.0108396513,
-0.011956322,
0.0199689101,
0.029097544,
-0.0717619807,
0.0743280649,
-0.0297181923,
0.0455732904,
-0.0650391877,
-0.088924922,
0.0547866262,
0.0981780291,
-0.0373534672,
-0.0100121954,
-0.0756007731,
-0.0670305341,
0.0158150624,
0.045836933,
0.036410924,
0.0100386422,
0.0504898466,
-0.0358487107,
-0.0004641044,
0.1055921689,
-0.043219775,
0.0458441563,
0.0352205671,
-0.010540667,
-0.0060826303,
0.0197318234,
-0.00095284,
-0.0059169685,
0.0193783715,
0.0676773265,
0.0016380183,
-0.0263383947,
-0.0059476187,
0.0326426625,
0.0358961858,
-0.0519024655,
-0.0137187829,
0.0043153563,
-0.0127720851,
0.0286207795,
0.0067710858,
-0.0606741421,
-0.0396989398,
-0.0200210232,
0.0500589646,
-0.0434022397,
0.0745280758,
0.0172047354,
-0.0192359295,
-0.0697711185,
0.0240780488,
0.0079216668,
0.0438829064,
0.0467808954,
0.0023267788,
-0.0165250134,
-0.0054737264,
0.0233826879,
0.0142168459,
-0.0403967127,
-0.0135970935,
0.0520055406,
0.0665478706,
-0.0598810911,
0.0412961133,
-0.0116381729,
-0.0421455689,
0.0073529398,
0.009886425,
0.0026403791,
-0.0170789193,
0.0221643038,
-0.0305881202,
-0.0381720401,
-0.0009229042,
-0.0156079624,
-0.0207443703,
0.013511572,
0.0231297594,
0.0164792687,
-0.0356390104,
-0.0190685932,
0.0814440846,
-0.0011336815,
0.0893067792,
-0.0230077002,
-0.0153421443,
0.0028703031,
-0.0153182149,
-0.0207313467,
-0.018925773,
0.0097094616,
0.0092421956,
-0.0513003021,
-0.0844705626,
-0.0019178359,
-0.0181308128,
0.0548623353,
0.0128000192,
0.056576483,
0.0600628816,
0.0079181176,
-0.0561987609,
0.0159827676,
-0.0136118326,
-0.0132867983,
-0.0052273422,
0.0069706696,
-6.066846833e-33,
0.0061773863,
0.0000285104,
-0.0058407281,
0.0051163211,
-0.0031248848,
0.0392161123,
-0.0058814622,
-0.0065104212,
-0.0409621783,
0.0050012837,
-0.0420572124,
-0.0011536775,
0.023245832,
-0.0011000592,
0.0182219483,
0.0128340591,
0.0656678081,
-0.0181360357,
-0.0404545628,
0.0004689943,
0.0233744979,
0.0409635194,
0.0524259135,
-0.0155734625,
-0.0129134618,
0.0367778055,
-0.0113958959,
-0.0091943685,
0.0064776256,
0.0097810244,
-0.0183291305,
0.0625137836,
0.0125889806,
0.0078672729,
-0.0073910141,
0.0236625858,
-0.0766591951,
-0.0410604775,
0.0124724461,
0.0005549803,
-0.0068919929,
-0.016252473,
0.045708254,
0.0289345738,
-0.067036286,
0.0330079496,
0.0016637288,
-0.02148325,
-0.0391514227,
-0.0386433713,
-0.0402229168,
-0.003885166,
-0.0217417758,
0.0153016085,
-0.0084909992,
-0.0275526922,
-0.0044662259,
-0.0038992376,
-0.0571919382,
-0.0060966308,
0.0619463474,
0.0725438446,
0.003587517,
0.0140224779,
0.0329776444,
0.0407763794,
0.0397549644,
0.0216014981,
0.0042105098,
0.0472284667,
0.108042866,
0.0250051226,
-0.0035246923,
-0.0038412805,
0.0920999572,
-0.0601078048,
-0.0610818788,
0.0049627312,
0.0445122495,
0.0308401193,
-0.0124435704,
-0.0119991442,
0.0162304789,
-0.045837909,
-0.0695447698,
0.0182270892,
-0.013168239,
-0.0042251828,
0.0216957536,
-0.0054508615,
-0.0306616873,
0.004021795,
0.0156945121,
-0.0420955643,
-0.0000811453,
0.0028277885,
0.034784466,
0.0282892808,
-0.0014879559,
0.0344290845,
-0.06125056,
-0.054971721,
-0.033611089,
0.0074947821,
0.0490741469,
-0.0271669626,
0.022513872,
0.037851721,
-0.0528884754,
0.0202609245,
-0.0456381775,
0.0053721014,
0.0399096385,
-0.0176566243,
0.0142915519,
-0.0095488792,
0.039206259,
0.0089108357,
0.0166621935,
0.0139533831,
-0.0529958904,
0.034279611,
0.0016432836,
0.0221465994,
-0.0011088172,
-0.0047358917,
-0.0690498203,
0.0103277145,
0.0224725604,
-0.061305318,
-0.0466010682,
0.00250603,
2.406e-7,
0.0463286564,
0.0501391292,
-0.0006744281,
-0.0125690438,
0.0102694193,
0.0200632326,
0.0221375767,
-0.0109314043,
-0.0088418638,
0.0120063657,
-0.0366007462,
-0.0174468197,
0.0416635685,
0.0172229931,
-0.030031994,
-0.032431405,
-0.0814152882,
0.0371968709,
-0.0490029939,
0.0033166234,
-0.0358959325,
0.0551565289,
0.0071157082,
-0.0167675614,
-0.0050323913,
-0.052523315,
0.0437595695,
-0.0535583757,
0.0310257003,
0.0344374031,
0.0138687082,
0.0381692499,
0.0089439116,
-0.0063789007,
-0.018858254,
-0.0011847861,
-0.0131153278,
0.0243782848,
-0.0298366286,
-0.0229011681,
0.0157880466,
-0.0576181896,
-0.0273677874,
-0.0122304503,
0.0605627857,
-0.0240161289,
-0.0274718571,
-0.0284163598,
-0.0119988965,
-0.0232100468,
0.0096136685,
-0.0359373093,
-0.0024168529,
0.0336462036,
0.0056107971,
0.0006640434,
-0.0455170497,
-0.074427478,
0.0094231851,
0.0051706503,
0.0040448173,
-0.0710030869,
-0.0408806726,
-0.0072578271,
0.0226325467,
-0.0226330552,
-0.0150023866,
2.336674992e-34,
0.0380242765,
-0.0337630734,
0.0331024081,
0.000883012,
0.0442163944,
0.0214132871,
0.034072198,
-0.0148693966,
-0.0313305929,
-0.086987175,
-0.0409608223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10266v1 | Diagnosing and Debiasing Corpus-Based Political Bias and Insults in GPT2 | 2023-11-17T01:20:08 | 2023-11-17T01:20:08 | Ambri Ma, Arnav Kumar, Brett Zeligson | cs.CL | cs.CL | The training of large language models (LLMs) on extensive, unfiltered corpora
sourced from the internet is a common and advantageous practice. Consequently,
LLMs have learned and inadvertently reproduced various types of biases,
including violent, offensive, and toxic language. However, recent research
shows that generative pretrained transformer (GPT) language models can
recognize their own biases and detect toxicity in generated content, a process
referred to as self-diagnosis. In response, researchers have developed a
decoding algorithm that allows LLMs to self-debias, or reduce their likelihood
of generating harmful text. This study investigates the efficacy of the
diagnosing-debiasing approach in mitigating two additional types of biases:
insults and political bias. These biases are often used interchangeably in
discourse, despite exhibiting potentially dissimilar semantic and syntactic
properties. We aim to contribute to the ongoing effort of investigating the
ethical and social implications of human-AI interaction. | [
0.0471850671,
0.0801565573,
-0.0323887989,
0.0333541818,
-0.0040372564,
0.0343666598,
0.0394057967,
0.0042899521,
0.0392402634,
-0.0724225938,
-0.0175792798,
0.0104687624,
-0.0275053289,
-0.0110558905,
-0.0042263423,
-0.044517424,
0.0427104905,
0.0492973514,
0.0501183793,
-0.0371856652,
0.0269790143,
0.0412984677,
0.0082908245,
0.0256268978,
-0.046371676,
-0.0078445794,
0.0452567488,
-0.0044713761,
0.0503461286,
0.0184965935,
0.0263244342,
0.0372759812,
0.0108685419,
0.0448423214,
0.0000016296,
-0.0203334633,
0.0084351329,
-0.0087667182,
-0.002317046,
-0.0393491425,
0.1010759473,
-0.0215004906,
-0.0217778776,
0.0539688617,
-0.0469766222,
-0.0359719694,
0.0293274503,
0.0457635932,
0.0802015811,
0.0712238774,
-0.0117039643,
-0.0237410814,
0.0177680757,
0.0118104871,
-0.0109377028,
0.006413375,
0.049119819,
-0.0345183611,
-0.0995379239,
0.0117093232,
-0.026165368,
-0.0021153919,
0.0202648453,
0.0261438992,
-0.0167811327,
-0.0148830805,
-0.0085308282,
-0.0366490483,
-0.0034871977,
0.0423935466,
-0.0250304807,
-0.0379680097,
0.0046294988,
0.0112396143,
0.0146456491,
-0.0023022168,
0.0164302606,
0.0465046577,
-0.0193709172,
0.0251166951,
0.040595673,
-0.0094792629,
0.0240227133,
0.0590336993,
0.0033432161,
0.0395073444,
-0.0075682318,
-0.0405726992,
0.0115120765,
0.0256582089,
0.0204241183,
-0.0184470396,
0.0157765057,
-0.0048208693,
-0.0021766592,
0.0325097069,
-0.0645431429,
-0.0301480033,
0.0126948906,
-0.0479076244,
0.0020380453,
0.0132755134,
-0.0365473777,
0.0209867358,
0.0221085232,
0.0096300542,
-0.0145833688,
0.0336269513,
-0.0193985291,
-0.0110399975,
-0.0046769879,
-0.0008138074,
-0.0341911167,
-0.0012666249,
0.0204926282,
0.042213697,
-0.0180138387,
-0.0178390052,
-0.0473216921,
-0.0150377192,
0.0095683169,
0.0271237008,
-0.0414070524,
-0.0094705001,
-0.054675322,
0.0312423427,
-0.041587662,
0.0232336633,
-0.0522229671,
-0.0768419951,
-0.0153774852,
0.0380778238,
-0.0404662229,
-0.0457850136,
0.0148545066,
0.0813064128,
-0.003033729,
-0.0192671362,
-0.0232285168,
-0.0271683708,
-0.0385353789,
-0.0397128761,
0.0204862542,
-0.0031971151,
0.0364138484,
-0.0274072755,
-0.0232021902,
-0.0867763758,
0.017187031,
0.0087721003,
-0.06016827,
0.0688108653,
0.0159731619,
-0.0022259403,
0.0599126518,
0.0417623669,
0.0077190637,
0.0665783659,
0.0187168233,
0.0352871381,
0.0273567829,
-0.0161002316,
0.018043736,
0.0263228733,
0.0368992649,
0.0016584762,
-0.0421374515,
0.0132901073,
-0.0323712565,
-0.0124907391,
0.0576986074,
0.0661190003,
-0.0096150124,
-0.0629858822,
0.070407249,
0.0332168341,
-0.0414371118,
0.0618273877,
0.0575395115,
0.0168163534,
-0.0146899093,
0.0201969333,
-0.0560818687,
-0.0129204411,
-0.0106684742,
-0.0736525729,
-0.0032770371,
0.0777020901,
-0.0039059822,
-0.0297034122,
0.0031172018,
-0.0288617332,
0.0480433926,
-0.0271647964,
0.0265477449,
0.0303210802,
-0.0328415856,
0.0206534024,
0.0374964252,
-0.0390458293,
0.0129679162,
-0.0669644102,
0.0219734795,
0.0427344926,
0.0385495685,
-0.0040196329,
-0.0119146397,
-0.0790674686,
-0.0245337877,
0.0606353134,
0.0349647664,
-0.0148368925,
-0.0097024506,
-0.0102014812,
-0.0254017096,
0.0188434813,
0.0204292033,
0.027868608,
0.0393201932,
0.0368844867,
0.0117732082,
-0.0003375914,
-0.0172388442,
0.048940856,
0.0028389248,
-0.0565397181,
-0.007948569,
0.0229320582,
0.0529500321,
0.0103370864,
-0.0383653268,
-0.0619639568,
0.0128555074,
-0.0035820915,
-0.0402935036,
0.0182151962,
-0.0635105073,
0.0041181236,
-0.0110983448,
-0.0584489107,
-0.0233540088,
0.057173416,
-0.0120669501,
0.0310436971,
0.0464057289,
-0.0266616344,
-0.0113765923,
-0.0455649123,
-0.0249351971,
-0.0719865412,
0.0244508386,
-0.0209441502,
0.0482979082,
-0.0100946212,
-0.0451159999,
-0.0063509536,
-0.0463769771,
0.0226454102,
0.0159559995,
-0.0347872749,
-0.0162805356,
-0.003379375,
0.0063235555,
0.0220963042,
-0.0155735854,
-0.031954132,
-0.0190755948,
-0.0414465182,
-0.022567682,
-0.0254981238,
0.0088738222,
0.0419690721,
-0.0187882781,
-0.0005832243,
0.0327683128,
-0.0133559993,
-0.0423230194,
0.0212523136,
0.0215195566,
0.0199939981,
-0.0601690821,
0.0148095712,
-0.0255356841,
0.0204271134,
-0.0491460748,
0.0254294761,
0.0157434754,
-0.0172908623,
-0.0067022764,
0.0031739806,
-0.0244587157,
0.0264429431,
-0.0117432075,
-0.0850797668,
0.0248670597,
0.0438673459,
0.0108722858,
0.1020318344,
0.0675831661,
0.0863588825,
0.0516632274,
0.0317812599,
-0.0369576067,
-0.0182392374,
-0.0209947992,
-0.0187516995,
-0.0312157422,
-0.0372492149,
-0.0010384936,
0.0812186301,
0.0524996109,
-0.022081336,
-0.0582141951,
0.0722431168,
-0.0514358468,
-0.0552124009,
0.0338082388,
-0.0694198757,
-0.0191156492,
-0.004803393,
-0.0224069003,
-0.0428709276,
0.0813236237,
0.0149398278,
0.036044348,
-0.0129710287,
0.0098333126,
0.0242401753,
0.0221287683,
0.0138224019,
0.0376582667,
0.0087075066,
-0.0093094809,
-0.0372450985,
-0.0126480917,
0.0335839018,
-0.0321649946,
-0.0223758519,
-0.0318557061,
-0.008359286,
0.0192312617,
-0.0557169244,
-0.07027632,
-0.0420813262,
-0.0083809933,
-0.0377752371,
0.0337974951,
-0.0061966632,
-0.0198141616,
-0.0053092963,
0.021514928,
-0.0332517438,
0.0006851774,
-0.0007486852,
0.0139066195,
-0.012693991,
0.0206785984,
-0.0195668582,
0.0469806045,
0.0409228839,
-0.0038543132,
0.0491246432,
-0.0415682979,
0.0255589858,
-0.0133660259,
-0.0117036719,
0.0100472681,
-0.0097240061,
0.0209922884,
-0.0195666049,
0.014419659,
-0.0055572353,
-0.0097452598,
0.1047602445,
0.0132433427,
-0.0689885765,
-0.0082493676,
0.0123916548,
-0.0551467612,
0.0241274647,
-0.018182287,
-0.1204109564,
0.0045459983,
-0.0187388267,
0.0108694257,
-0.0823697448,
-0.0444874652,
0.000574716,
-0.0996499434,
0.0159904882,
-0.0137003036,
0.0201363321,
-0.0128404247,
-0.0134381847,
-0.0024838394,
-0.0237400886,
0.0199969355,
-0.0245844945,
0.0207023881,
-0.001089556,
-0.0049867551,
-0.0426163338,
-0.0351808965,
0.0022032049,
-0.0071125245,
0.0674327835,
0.0595461689,
0.0698143095,
-0.0308809597,
0.0087193903,
0.0231094081,
-0.0102451025,
-0.0258252118,
-0.0333553068,
0.0718413517,
-0.057891123,
-0.0189894419,
-0.0122325746,
0.0421373658,
0.0219044853,
0.0054332633,
-0.0001134814,
0.0656458139,
0.00660661,
-0.0410065465,
-0.0228403453,
0.009536447,
0.05226909,
0.0906263664,
0.0240049269,
-0.0423720293,
0.0076919962,
-0.0515905209,
0.0121396286,
-0.0200875476,
-0.0807647929,
0.0065802275,
-0.0025926086,
-0.0227691904,
-0.0605973192,
-0.0580987781,
0.0106310016,
-0.0155838663,
0.0150591033,
-0.0548713058,
0.0157394074,
0.002031191,
-0.0065662907,
-0.0097874096,
-0.0000344808,
-0.0105248969,
0.0045201401,
-0.0302748345,
-0.0158547498,
-0.0247974917,
-0.0149155976,
0.0368983634,
-0.0190824326,
-0.0406093933,
0.099058643,
0.0583361015,
0.0127805192,
0.0461331569,
-0.0222985968,
-0.0304358117,
0.0647896454,
0.0711932331,
-0.0417931825,
0.00980746,
0.0387793109,
0.0129169552,
0.0215539876,
0.0093820477,
0.0128696179,
0.0563597232,
0.0386723839,
-0.0654046163,
-0.0542507172,
-0.0381269641,
0.0206668619,
-0.0095174825,
0.0792146623,
-0.023900941,
0.0012371633,
-0.050740473,
-0.0345645547,
-0.0317890421,
-0.0363201424,
0.0057652034,
0.002117509,
0.0461483188,
-0.0065670912,
-0.0475676768,
-0.0051326943,
-0.0834210515,
0.0145325335,
-0.0191027448,
0.0157154053,
0.0226601753,
0.0389798395,
0.0076376921,
0.0088732308,
-0.016650809,
0.0254433788,
-0.001576565,
-0.0081860619,
-0.0137532093,
0.0413712859,
0.0183510501,
0.0286874082,
0.0401991233,
-0.0006370691,
-0.0089509198,
-0.008647453,
-0.03081166,
-0.0126733696,
0.0015156667,
-0.006152275,
0.0571686104,
-0.0033051034,
-0.0091982307,
0.0158844907,
0.003071778,
-0.0142404335,
-0.0309354011,
0.0201209411,
0.0018318576,
-0.0485372692,
0.0168536156,
0.0567200482,
-0.028379431,
0.0619543344,
0.042739626,
-0.0309273843,
-0.0119683603,
-0.0464428514,
-0.002527924,
-0.0531636588,
-0.0105987564,
-0.0032157858,
-0.036272753,
-0.0514338054,
-0.0178207103,
-0.0070101442,
0.0356460214,
-0.0304564089,
-0.00644405,
0.076907672,
-0.0119371284,
0.0087506967,
-0.011726913,
0.0318955891,
-0.0266488791,
-0.0346608162,
-0.0225319471,
-5.575289993e-33,
-0.0202847179,
-0.0235462952,
-0.015726218,
-0.006223035,
-0.0120054306,
-0.0424729474,
0.0166742168,
0.0205994546,
-0.0384595543,
0.0447781049,
-0.0020665699,
0.0396348052,
-0.0064503253,
-0.0081933318,
-0.0121376812,
-0.029347619,
0.0467521027,
-0.0419859104,
-0.0283229612,
0.0202234518,
0.0302013457,
0.0046564583,
0.0481279269,
-0.0873690322,
0.0248808451,
0.0006714759,
-0.0408445559,
0.0013188788,
-0.0098906141,
0.0275261607,
-0.0135942642,
0.0620268062,
0.0390251614,
-0.0075383326,
0.0171809085,
0.0687179044,
-0.0422797054,
-0.0151946889,
0.0237992499,
0.004786531,
0.0136638395,
-0.0350110419,
0.0335191898,
-0.0096601015,
-0.0604125932,
-0.0367291979,
0.0355483182,
-0.0010669811,
0.0665233731,
-0.0436574891,
-0.062688835,
-0.0173254758,
-0.0324966572,
0.0056060143,
-0.023904888,
0.0300827827,
0.0366247632,
0.034617763,
-0.0555449128,
0.010298756,
-0.0209424309,
-0.0153028835,
0.0250262972,
-0.0435480103,
0.0015550946,
0.0735810474,
0.0257418621,
0.0355228782,
-0.0576064251,
-0.0110731851,
0.0306993835,
-0.0158030875,
0.0352234356,
0.0796468928,
0.0168721266,
-0.0899578109,
-0.0567965247,
-0.0163383707,
0.0291822981,
0.0315250345,
-0.0066649118,
-0.0574953072,
-0.0068687312,
-0.0271453913,
-0.0258394163,
-0.0915889964,
-0.0095770545,
-0.0345614105,
0.0146151045,
-0.002823479,
-0.0072004558,
-0.0057375692,
0.00895226,
-0.0553162396,
0.0514082611,
0.0351254791,
-0.0365557075,
-0.0282729417,
0.0026520381,
0.04129548,
-0.0345497802,
-0.0083455974,
0.0141855022,
-0.0049445522,
0.0516078286,
-0.0054800711,
0.0713798776,
0.0265071578,
-0.0508741662,
0.0077025136,
-0.0167682935,
0.0541723818,
0.0007385935,
0.0362201743,
0.0303055178,
0.0610515252,
-0.0060822656,
-0.028200319,
0.0432347246,
0.0065699061,
-0.0439391248,
0.0053464011,
-0.0157466624,
0.0124803046,
-0.0314983539,
-0.0291727539,
-0.0212893821,
0.0323800407,
0.0341485329,
-0.0979701951,
-0.0106488485,
-0.0425752252,
2.426e-7,
0.0263620578,
0.0941050276,
0.0080427388,
0.0225211494,
0.0148808826,
0.0313449278,
0.0605464466,
0.0703170523,
-0.0044397209,
-0.0056869695,
-0.0033658335,
0.053874366,
0.0164216273,
0.0631299689,
-0.0293923244,
0.0095594199,
-0.0683313459,
0.0201473068,
-0.051673986,
0.0046623889,
0.0274340212,
0.0512594618,
0.0415681675,
-0.0218945537,
-0.0168253072,
0.0005376996,
0.0334337689,
-0.0413851067,
0.0078708148,
0.0114636021,
0.0448741764,
0.0049865977,
0.0121339131,
0.021405749,
0.005390143,
-0.0029962501,
-0.0225058869,
0.0620748661,
-0.0032775297,
-0.0128149325,
-0.0014216155,
0.0034973691,
0.0044605648,
-0.0419168733,
0.0546565093,
-0.0393341482,
-0.0185548309,
-0.0396867692,
-0.038226977,
-0.0267134011,
0.0384940766,
-0.036077179,
-0.0155147817,
0.0123466477,
0.0163170937,
0.0337166041,
0.0324552208,
-0.0732569396,
-0.0161453895,
-0.0189666618,
-0.0360176079,
-0.0610199794,
0.0255498085,
-0.0013311836,
0.0370929949,
-0.0046215407,
0.0553994253,
1.767859015e-34,
0.0138059175,
-0.0056504509,
0.0102352947,
-0.0500571392,
0.0630032346,
0.0310980193,
-0.0012464634,
-0.0019596568,
0.0007849077,
-0.0473396182,
-0.0135987047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10236v1 | Latent Feature-based Data Splits to Improve Generalisation Evaluation: A Hate Speech Detection Case Study | 2023-11-16T23:49:55 | 2023-11-16T23:49:55 | Maike Züfle, Verna Dankers, Ivan Titov | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the ever-growing presence of social media platforms comes the increased
spread of harmful content and the need for robust hate speech detection
systems. Such systems easily overfit to specific targets and keywords, and
evaluating them without considering distribution shifts that might occur
between train and test data overestimates their benefit. We challenge hate
speech models via new train-test splits of existing datasets that rely on the
clustering of models' hidden representations. We present two split variants
(Subset-Sum-Split and Closest-Split) that, when applied to two datasets using
four pretrained models, reveal how models catastrophically fail on blind spots
in the latent space. This result generalises when developing a split with one
model and evaluating it on another. Our analysis suggests that there is no
clear surface-level property of the data split that correlates with the
decreased performance, which underscores that task difficulty is not always
humanly interpretable. We recommend incorporating latent feature-based splits
in model development and release two splits via the GenBench benchmark. | [
0.0349566825,
0.089551039,
-0.0262876917,
0.0558224097,
-0.0071298582,
0.0445485562,
0.0697718337,
0.0353727788,
-0.0098408237,
-0.0582303479,
0.0127783855,
-0.0446874909,
-0.0384664908,
0.0411244929,
-0.0112877823,
-0.0901505947,
0.046831239,
0.0032750978,
0.0133240893,
-0.009034602,
0.0581381656,
-0.0143493889,
0.0131050078,
0.018342847,
-0.083307609,
0.0101761492,
0.0055314242,
-0.0459510908,
0.0192973632,
0.0436591581,
0.0207055993,
0.0390592068,
0.0483999439,
0.0730133355,
0.000002002,
-0.0280629341,
0.0011435602,
0.0116896341,
-0.0049818321,
-0.012681542,
0.0462314337,
-0.0261737648,
0.00383754,
0.020362433,
-0.0142518263,
-0.0009094553,
0.0347449407,
0.0607237816,
0.0460838713,
0.0723384023,
-0.0121351825,
-0.0483714752,
0.0129802851,
0.01095495,
0.0328752585,
-0.0113870241,
0.0175863858,
-0.0511125028,
-0.0600436777,
-0.0399989337,
-0.0081891399,
0.020413518,
0.0247232001,
0.0448990874,
0.0218986254,
-0.0034330988,
-0.0459347256,
-0.0336165987,
-0.0122355064,
0.038649939,
-0.0601100996,
0.0234392807,
-0.0080501502,
-0.0333006866,
-0.0320165083,
0.0068728481,
-0.0046665464,
-0.0026361903,
-0.023635108,
0.0121938828,
-0.0278087016,
0.0029172024,
0.0515989587,
0.026688382,
-0.0337109677,
0.0272859465,
-0.0154556446,
-0.0236213244,
0.0063234251,
0.0089072408,
-0.0514017045,
0.0298338011,
0.017070489,
-0.0249911025,
-0.0071015628,
0.0029868409,
-0.0543797947,
-0.0669699907,
-0.0110852029,
-0.0482894182,
0.0234931018,
0.0201474242,
-0.039957393,
0.0186016448,
0.0298153963,
0.0374633521,
0.0030856542,
0.0157044455,
-0.010546457,
0.0267419517,
-0.0361257046,
0.0197251998,
0.0199644342,
0.0129301008,
-0.0244780798,
0.0153240981,
-0.0339882746,
-0.0228802897,
-0.0699114501,
-0.0400680229,
-0.00301189,
0.02914799,
0.0310099255,
0.0441412367,
0.0271340553,
-0.0340720378,
-0.0590970665,
0.0340183713,
-0.0138463443,
-0.0631393865,
-0.0180942975,
0.032521572,
0.0052501694,
0.0012536547,
0.0255286414,
0.0441449061,
0.0232364368,
-0.0620380491,
-0.0476196334,
-0.0314045288,
-0.0503422581,
-0.0605950058,
0.0225041937,
-0.0420536362,
0.0242822915,
0.0062087276,
-0.0011692741,
-0.0573145114,
-0.0473690741,
-0.0195248798,
-0.0537493266,
0.0878063217,
0.013782802,
0.0131327109,
0.0337695479,
0.0434658974,
-0.009287714,
0.0767177492,
0.0283288322,
0.0360173285,
0.0659058094,
-0.0090944646,
0.0136732031,
0.0375729501,
0.0329642706,
-0.0122467373,
-0.0241604447,
0.0071790712,
-0.0418131724,
-0.0516405478,
0.0138547793,
0.0205145273,
-0.0188551415,
-0.0510246232,
0.028263161,
0.0917901024,
0.004681359,
0.0489016175,
0.0317302868,
0.0127899954,
-0.0200800467,
-0.0200739,
-0.050692644,
-0.0633202493,
-0.0652745813,
-0.0408981591,
0.0306156073,
0.0579097755,
-0.0524733923,
-0.0237143524,
-0.0051282332,
-0.0125226909,
0.0558201447,
-0.0208500065,
0.0726387724,
-0.039156571,
0.0066566654,
0.0457767844,
0.0561869554,
-0.0535197146,
-0.0271240212,
-0.0532588251,
0.0187398773,
0.0291641038,
-0.0202875845,
-0.0428974256,
0.0219445117,
-0.023715971,
-0.0194368064,
-0.0269257557,
0.0059063826,
-0.0018097324,
0.0239887871,
-0.0302344207,
-0.03256822,
0.0044184295,
0.0454662256,
0.0187439919,
0.0514063612,
-0.0027288618,
0.0294785444,
-0.0351326391,
-0.0120058432,
0.0339628048,
0.0243979823,
0.0165576264,
-0.021216983,
0.0113587258,
0.064316988,
0.0178673193,
-0.0320892632,
-0.061361488,
0.0312745236,
-0.0150290327,
0.0007660106,
-0.0053741336,
-0.0335235931,
-0.0309886523,
0.0102943778,
-0.0447175093,
-0.0059238044,
0.0602215566,
-0.0473935045,
0.0090730665,
0.0754794776,
-0.0404328257,
-0.0149653004,
-0.0354219973,
-0.0206177309,
-0.0685737059,
0.0377137065,
0.0058533489,
0.0696569309,
-0.0362007096,
-0.0278712921,
-0.0329338983,
-0.0550044179,
0.0222885404,
0.0081133228,
-0.0487152152,
-0.0150844194,
-0.0017998589,
0.0365488119,
-0.0104560489,
-0.0016399532,
-0.0244611278,
0.0181979798,
-0.0803858638,
-0.0245903973,
-0.0684829578,
-0.0016770522,
-0.0132118659,
-0.0126131615,
-0.0184925292,
0.0091580963,
0.000907544,
-0.014773055,
0.0618736073,
0.0189561155,
-0.0296348594,
-0.0355412401,
0.005924867,
-0.020923283,
-0.0267449245,
0.0107775051,
0.0337625518,
0.0021264299,
-0.0387894213,
0.006104555,
-0.0005183141,
-0.0004768679,
0.0119925672,
-0.0235334355,
-0.028116256,
0.0362389684,
0.0115395747,
-0.0283468086,
0.0250870194,
0.0401778482,
0.0897439346,
0.0170270354,
0.0196817815,
-0.0121914539,
-0.0011748037,
-0.0112270992,
0.0257785004,
-0.0250303186,
-0.0363191441,
-0.036075227,
0.0833059698,
0.0415696502,
-0.030486811,
-0.0889173299,
0.0161790308,
-0.0432293527,
-0.0798369795,
-0.0447379351,
-0.057506375,
-0.0115744434,
-0.0055279937,
-0.0411079526,
-0.056779027,
0.05873565,
0.0002480675,
0.0235932488,
-0.0194840394,
-0.0586676039,
-0.0204098318,
0.0482258163,
0.0069768536,
0.0054796329,
-0.0171870384,
0.0099934209,
-0.0008468713,
0.0043051024,
0.0136942975,
-0.0244437028,
0.0590445586,
-0.0033503855,
0.0053613763,
0.0240006819,
-0.025037257,
-0.0564892925,
-0.0571323,
-0.0097175203,
-0.0222603045,
0.0232013855,
0.0028124,
-0.006495703,
0.0392104834,
-0.0105828932,
0.0161678605,
0.0081286328,
0.0160033628,
0.0359096937,
-0.0027143674,
-0.0097410949,
-0.009544787,
0.038013842,
-0.0588180646,
-0.0068606818,
0.0529618859,
0.0296493284,
-0.0101325875,
-0.0499237627,
0.0538432747,
-0.0113012716,
0.0202988517,
-0.030177094,
-0.0435164645,
0.0441141278,
-0.0160783269,
0.0115757408,
0.0931990966,
0.0310453121,
-0.0436916873,
0.0188702922,
0.018132899,
0.0207934286,
0.0096771885,
-0.0197021514,
-0.0466683321,
-0.0123026641,
-0.0131795751,
0.0492474027,
-0.0464552492,
-0.0472189821,
0.0379513353,
-0.0486946218,
0.0323827267,
-0.0065294481,
-0.0674697533,
-0.0304388609,
-0.0183684323,
0.0133159207,
-0.0303716324,
0.036909502,
-0.0288833361,
0.0164979026,
-0.0058306349,
0.0310561936,
-0.0657834187,
-0.0242934711,
0.024388032,
-0.0500768498,
0.0172271952,
0.0397444367,
0.0022337935,
-0.0179361869,
0.012728841,
0.0270401593,
0.000580092,
0.0095669162,
-0.0214823037,
0.0980617628,
0.0115538845,
0.0028458377,
0.0153087405,
0.0402752794,
-0.0175251681,
-0.0106689679,
0.0415686816,
0.0400525331,
0.0152980071,
-0.0462166741,
-0.0624756962,
0.0184722673,
0.0057872427,
0.0742279366,
0.0340850241,
-0.0421237797,
0.0003884773,
-0.0309331398,
0.0182511881,
0.0133442823,
-0.0709001198,
0.0086707249,
-0.056206692,
-0.0411423557,
-0.003991446,
-0.0360947661,
0.0539885759,
0.0296624471,
-0.0097321607,
-0.0526469536,
-0.0441277251,
0.0086537804,
-0.0505359061,
0.0634440631,
0.0496550798,
-0.0114644868,
-0.0199135896,
-0.0406614505,
-0.013548688,
-0.0318171941,
-0.0369596221,
-0.0088792425,
-0.0820436478,
-0.0645797923,
0.0914466158,
0.0334324725,
0.0211735591,
0.0517281853,
-0.0024693867,
-0.0815803558,
0.1117472649,
0.0438820347,
-0.0334654748,
0.0213531982,
0.0722059533,
-0.0664309636,
-0.0120497355,
0.0045824614,
-0.0148963332,
0.0551757179,
0.0306170173,
-0.0709581748,
-0.0914475769,
0.041804757,
-0.0342080891,
0.0020168989,
0.0817497447,
0.0019299062,
-0.0342610516,
-0.0539826714,
0.0054236138,
0.0150606791,
-0.0132121053,
-0.0376196802,
-0.0155219296,
0.0043395129,
-0.0069742915,
-0.0525207967,
0.0301673058,
-0.0181373265,
0.0137810456,
-0.0619104579,
0.040080592,
0.0652660802,
0.0446854755,
0.0297811646,
0.0344626904,
-0.0064112386,
0.0355144255,
-0.0049308925,
-0.0272809044,
0.0189933069,
0.008075051,
0.0065134033,
0.0417431034,
-0.0119049735,
-0.01235044,
-0.0148325143,
-0.0230435971,
-0.0538982935,
0.0053353654,
-0.0405340232,
-0.0264107939,
0.0110579925,
0.0278618801,
-0.027530713,
-0.0027678558,
-0.0032341045,
-0.0041743862,
-0.0217365734,
0.0038186342,
0.0262684058,
-0.0282455627,
-0.0017989278,
0.0627367198,
0.0088657923,
0.0325946584,
0.0133738359,
-0.04665168,
-0.0324591771,
0.020251587,
0.0494805463,
0.0182960387,
0.0074970829,
0.0004049085,
-0.043562796,
-0.0511711352,
0.0037287413,
-0.0300827343,
0.0418925062,
0.0483071953,
0.0372993089,
0.1006455049,
-0.0168452635,
0.0161199681,
-0.0018112125,
-0.0135432519,
0.0176615957,
-0.0496395193,
0.0364885963,
-6.286736275e-33,
0.0138527416,
0.0125370966,
-0.0260019265,
-0.0217737556,
-0.0065663769,
0.0011774284,
0.0372649767,
0.0363880098,
0.0066334349,
0.0177263245,
-0.011872028,
0.0517610796,
0.0097111855,
0.0140744261,
-0.0100020189,
-0.0436553545,
0.0511010736,
-0.0369411632,
-0.0065309787,
0.0099393725,
0.0516875647,
0.0434582904,
0.019592464,
-0.0532372072,
0.0173779353,
-0.0175100695,
-0.0190066565,
-0.025744047,
0.0030036552,
0.0557865463,
-0.0048239487,
0.0874351859,
0.0405917987,
0.0015708952,
-0.0176457297,
0.0122969085,
-0.0264153723,
-0.0174781326,
-0.0062490678,
-0.004014648,
-0.0123993196,
0.0131538231,
0.0459805951,
0.0141062196,
-0.0163973588,
-0.0159204453,
0.0353223532,
-0.0423521847,
0.0183731932,
-0.0257363431,
-0.0379742943,
0.0306100268,
-0.0193685964,
0.0389752761,
0.0193454325,
0.0433825701,
0.0233760644,
0.0139582967,
-0.0626712888,
0.0325956829,
0.0807429925,
-0.0235484112,
0.0171189867,
0.0457272418,
-0.0282421838,
0.0734373778,
0.0280891415,
-0.0170073826,
-0.0374407694,
-0.0109871244,
0.0651755184,
0.0519959256,
0.0373013876,
0.0310402475,
0.0433948785,
-0.0579301529,
-0.0819371268,
-0.0001188119,
0.0355060175,
-0.0531769842,
0.0245334581,
0.0073006828,
-0.0415217616,
-0.0157501251,
-0.0145294685,
-0.0447661653,
-0.0321693718,
-0.0486868173,
0.0178756937,
0.0195437204,
-0.0384458862,
-0.0341073386,
0.0039709085,
-0.0241611265,
0.0576591454,
0.0074412432,
-0.01864524,
0.0058601699,
0.0192235373,
0.0147053851,
-0.040272858,
-0.016291501,
0.036716409,
-0.0386268683,
0.0329067595,
-0.0410468131,
0.0568524711,
0.0238776822,
-0.0153943924,
0.0087023573,
0.0032622679,
0.0445270985,
-0.0309165083,
0.0617154092,
0.0242938921,
0.015102121,
-0.0020343219,
0.0141523508,
0.0192000512,
-0.0212939158,
-0.0124446061,
0.0447657742,
-0.0056795185,
0.0260321647,
0.0077931541,
-0.034420114,
0.0067673004,
-0.0251118764,
0.0728538111,
-0.0914867148,
0.0032366214,
-0.0140611967,
2.683e-7,
0.0239384584,
0.0294897705,
-0.0096968049,
-0.0374882184,
0.0031717136,
0.0490577817,
0.0166476294,
0.0198777393,
-0.0088974489,
-0.0152444616,
0.0125097726,
0.0769905373,
0.0086304508,
0.0658350438,
0.012741169,
-0.0073400163,
-0.0488748737,
0.0181647856,
-0.0386922322,
0.0076359212,
0.0029319187,
0.1008102074,
0.0736124888,
-0.0478094369,
-0.0089143077,
0.0091499267,
0.0048494479,
-0.0400010571,
-0.0254060831,
-0.0273675229,
0.040584065,
0.0156890806,
0.0177621786,
0.0242612343,
0.0062882151,
0.008035914,
0.0148273949,
0.0076093478,
0.0083512543,
-0.0284650382,
-0.0274890624,
0.023218561,
-0.0210762527,
-0.0314326249,
0.0668172091,
-0.0006414161,
-0.0202912502,
-0.0444642045,
-0.0352531001,
-0.0125660263,
0.0166344736,
-0.0070478697,
0.0463466644,
0.0164821185,
-0.0041615348,
-0.0370309241,
0.0017243983,
-0.0940674096,
0.0229009669,
0.0023855709,
-0.072084479,
-0.0500989743,
-0.0128195584,
0.0166303609,
0.0509411395,
0.0311259236,
-0.0027727464,
2.224723389e-34,
0.0232664458,
0.0046970402,
-0.0195880942,
-0.036949005,
0.0122963302,
-0.0018145114,
-0.0415469967,
-0.0293143615,
0.0022461961,
-0.0264154822,
0.0076857931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10227v1 | Think Twice: Perspective-Taking Improves Large Language Models' Theory-of-Mind Capabilities | 2023-11-16T22:49:27 | 2023-11-16T22:49:27 | Alex Wilf, Sihyun Shawn Lee, Paul Pu Liang, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Human interactions are deeply rooted in the interplay of thoughts, beliefs,
and desires made possible by Theory of Mind (ToM): our cognitive ability to
understand the mental states of ourselves and others. Although ToM may come
naturally to us, emulating it presents a challenge to even the most advanced
Large Language Models (LLMs). Recent improvements to LLMs' reasoning
capabilities from simple yet effective prompting techniques such as
Chain-of-Thought have seen limited applicability to ToM. In this paper, we turn
to the prominent cognitive science theory "Simulation Theory" to bridge this
gap. We introduce SimToM, a novel two-stage prompting framework inspired by
Simulation Theory's notion of perspective-taking. To implement this idea on
current ToM benchmarks, SimToM first filters context based on what the
character in question knows before answering a question about their mental
state. Our approach, which requires no additional training and minimal
prompt-tuning, shows substantial improvement over existing methods, and our
analysis reveals the importance of perspective-taking to Theory-of-Mind
capabilities. Our findings suggest perspective-taking as a promising direction
for future research into improving LLMs' ToM capabilities. | [
0.057298474,
0.0476663224,
-0.032692939,
0.0463052802,
-0.0495153517,
0.0097119417,
-0.0048836796,
-0.0098298471,
0.0301585831,
-0.0145262294,
-0.0239851568,
-0.0844483599,
0.0170046911,
0.0109787006,
0.0590421371,
-0.0717913359,
0.0213542767,
-0.0673630908,
0.0050833193,
-0.0134124523,
-0.0243288875,
0.0354830325,
-0.0406876355,
0.0077390145,
0.0165721104,
-0.0089963404,
-0.0374856256,
0.0021817125,
0.0631942973,
-0.0517597198,
-0.0560320541,
0.0107798679,
0.0179862026,
0.0358550847,
0.0000023424,
-0.0768680647,
-0.0122154979,
-0.0260374751,
-0.0036484385,
0.0015577879,
0.0403725468,
0.0143823056,
0.0242691748,
0.0182380248,
-0.0477516912,
0.0336371623,
-0.0129698627,
0.0576785728,
0.0248644408,
0.0354850404,
-0.0076111616,
0.012413119,
-0.0135696875,
-0.0252423119,
0.0431734025,
-0.0567861311,
0.0271285437,
0.0106620146,
0.0563987903,
-0.0036135626,
-0.014801247,
0.0260911062,
0.0009104005,
-0.0037924459,
-0.038330432,
0.047918532,
0.0284667518,
0.0123998048,
-0.0080817249,
0.0597092956,
0.081382513,
0.0021640048,
-0.0154695679,
-0.0195380803,
0.0085848374,
0.028807018,
-0.0096319085,
0.0327823311,
-0.0370556638,
0.014551783,
0.0287020691,
0.0557884872,
0.0112812938,
0.023649063,
-0.0382438377,
0.0287671853,
-0.0065919538,
-0.0284389406,
0.0229214411,
0.0096300226,
-0.0211611073,
-0.0743904486,
-0.0667170659,
0.0163128003,
-0.0429972,
0.0059547387,
-0.0125325229,
0.0304721892,
-0.0132910376,
0.0077366615,
0.0680004209,
0.0483106747,
0.0113372318,
0.0419854261,
0.0382039323,
0.0131475395,
-0.023011867,
-0.000124197,
-0.0339053571,
0.0043217377,
-0.0516461842,
0.006530208,
-0.0286379922,
0.0436538644,
0.0028860348,
-0.0304827392,
0.0103994329,
-0.0005027771,
-0.0222617947,
-0.0429324247,
-0.0413704813,
-0.0072183446,
0.0183526836,
0.0039507668,
-0.0580233969,
0.0282313582,
-0.0289049055,
-0.0018275221,
0.0197819378,
-0.0654117614,
-0.0184041727,
-0.0255775042,
0.0014465234,
-0.0030731852,
0.0134306252,
0.0143538592,
-0.0082439492,
-0.0364103019,
-0.0009340218,
-0.0187932122,
-0.0135946795,
-0.0678765178,
0.0012464988,
-0.0348688625,
0.0139057981,
0.01185726,
0.0064808107,
0.0136183966,
0.0168165062,
0.000627871,
-0.0445455685,
0.0839164704,
0.0060793497,
-0.009067337,
0.0034530642,
0.0228823796,
-0.0001766966,
0.0376024768,
-0.0004310875,
-0.0245026853,
-0.0204602629,
0.0639470443,
0.0065274108,
0.018312728,
0.0023628743,
-0.0129953343,
-0.0369581394,
0.0149640245,
0.008567675,
0.0426066965,
0.0012884326,
0.0545797087,
-0.0511331819,
0.0263313446,
0.0515017137,
0.0673258156,
-0.0319861211,
-0.0037122131,
0.067813389,
0.0361969285,
0.0171829332,
0.0069231526,
-0.0330807194,
0.0511175916,
-0.0064960071,
-0.0274067465,
0.0207405444,
0.0352249071,
-0.0383427516,
0.0059141745,
-0.0032193228,
0.0217191502,
0.0096142655,
0.0241113212,
-0.0001443907,
-0.012179547,
0.0024572616,
0.0196715239,
0.0191675983,
-0.0211333521,
-0.0464806929,
-0.0824499577,
-0.0054509919,
0.0528830774,
0.0591266453,
-0.0199527945,
-0.0430928506,
-0.030085478,
-0.0110740792,
0.0694309324,
0.0659926534,
-0.0037707821,
-0.0268546492,
-0.0228766594,
0.0049241874,
-0.0334001072,
-0.0013324961,
0.0264050812,
-0.0233621616,
-0.0000254562,
-0.00811949,
0.032678239,
0.0547990836,
0.0059243352,
-0.0245943591,
-0.016632013,
-0.0504828654,
0.0308450665,
0.0361808166,
0.0115644811,
0.0033754122,
0.0147184143,
-0.003434944,
-0.0012525041,
-0.0066185086,
0.0626643673,
-0.0536147468,
-0.0427661277,
0.032539513,
-0.013890516,
-0.0338120423,
0.0027333626,
0.0122876288,
-0.0340624377,
0.0159495957,
-0.0266887881,
0.0291425828,
-0.0331024751,
0.0080232741,
-0.0260495394,
-0.004401736,
-0.0099492017,
0.0918725431,
-0.0131889023,
0.0091567906,
0.076771684,
-0.0495388582,
0.0186590422,
-0.0319408365,
-0.009096087,
-0.0219120029,
0.0141195785,
-0.021918036,
0.008319037,
0.0007636407,
-0.0622874014,
-0.02517033,
-0.1215224043,
-0.0568594374,
0.0212700032,
-0.0132717304,
0.0102740917,
0.0057861945,
-0.0283894446,
0.0294449665,
-0.0534240231,
0.0393263064,
0.0245840605,
-0.0037374652,
0.0204591881,
-0.0168376341,
-0.0137623018,
-0.0095944153,
0.0346986614,
-0.0544748604,
0.0533884726,
0.0004496701,
-0.0221698303,
-0.0341187529,
-0.0029241266,
-0.0639932975,
0.0394451581,
-0.0336515754,
0.0023737245,
0.0547156669,
-0.0175576583,
0.036018461,
0.0600107871,
0.0124368034,
-0.0112646567,
0.063086234,
-0.0192764048,
-0.0475524515,
0.0351933762,
0.0227798279,
0.0097035207,
-0.0460705794,
-0.0425642021,
-0.0138210719,
0.050838165,
0.0106736943,
0.0001515958,
-0.0763451084,
0.0462862477,
0.0008835183,
-0.0513280965,
-0.0119489543,
-0.0183444824,
-0.0267596375,
0.0486647375,
-0.0163784362,
0.0123982532,
0.0915203318,
-0.0393748693,
0.0058250665,
-0.0355888866,
0.0458322316,
-0.0296233147,
0.0836168602,
0.009578771,
0.0267872401,
0.0540340319,
0.0186406914,
-0.0685709864,
-0.0042076707,
-0.0100009535,
-0.0143313482,
-0.0084568691,
-0.0503122434,
0.0018815243,
0.0005044385,
-0.0189602226,
-0.0570436008,
-0.0087276865,
-0.0781024545,
0.0059986277,
0.0031603223,
0.0003761043,
-0.001156948,
-0.0217035282,
0.059328869,
0.0204865206,
0.0074520037,
-0.0394389704,
-0.0126792761,
-0.0013327966,
0.0424184278,
-0.0029881098,
0.0627848655,
-0.0296739787,
0.0688706264,
0.0406886451,
0.0648456812,
0.0279928073,
0.0069746948,
-0.0158553012,
0.0199072082,
0.0345217176,
-0.0128681604,
0.0235048011,
0.0670388713,
0.0068210247,
-0.0327840894,
0.1269078553,
0.0395598002,
-0.0397548974,
0.0033235089,
-0.0543073788,
0.0300961137,
0.0406203046,
0.0308759101,
-0.0692754164,
-0.0051246583,
0.0094552347,
-0.0270925183,
-0.0465330929,
-0.0852022991,
-0.0206030887,
-0.1035641059,
0.0173421763,
-0.0211778618,
0.0103009818,
0.0093994094,
-0.0003964915,
0.0411242433,
0.0629830211,
-0.0374871306,
0.024926668,
0.0041717598,
0.0133431349,
-0.0120733213,
0.019082088,
-0.012805935,
0.0662576184,
-0.0247238688,
0.0823116899,
0.0104245702,
0.0371125899,
0.0315011442,
-0.0547992811,
0.0102469167,
-0.0065719271,
0.022749912,
-0.0091713807,
0.0060815834,
-0.0169803742,
0.0124725401,
-0.0366928279,
0.0495111644,
-0.0193077568,
-0.0143400105,
-0.0132187987,
0.0818699896,
-0.0283288993,
-0.0105734803,
0.0006360057,
0.041059982,
-0.0059302743,
0.0725753829,
0.0397352204,
-0.0704471618,
0.0453546271,
-0.0137392171,
-0.0337544493,
0.0343599357,
-0.0707955733,
-0.0021449407,
0.0553636663,
0.0172558483,
-0.0486723632,
-0.0338363908,
0.008892471,
0.0393542424,
0.0096631702,
-0.0043924591,
0.01209791,
0.0069171991,
-0.0177706107,
-0.0085739,
-0.0574386604,
0.0458831191,
0.0039055739,
0.0194846764,
0.0289206505,
-0.0735902712,
-0.0139979171,
0.0155582344,
-0.0539928675,
-0.0718159452,
-0.0333976485,
0.0213777702,
0.0312548988,
0.0340110138,
-0.0126709705,
-0.0123219462,
0.0236056689,
-0.03703871,
-0.0187257323,
0.06737867,
0.0031762915,
0.0614365526,
0.0208549593,
0.0625898242,
0.0065390528,
0.0018050283,
0.0200714059,
0.0110591445,
-0.0214994624,
-0.0417368785,
0.0235748384,
0.0131827695,
0.0181706399,
-0.0051923068,
-0.0071567241,
-0.0272209775,
-0.0070059784,
-0.0466223881,
-0.0230379254,
-0.0431593619,
-0.0086114416,
0.03325532,
0.0352452956,
-0.0093864659,
-0.0867731124,
-0.0075566513,
0.0019241214,
0.0225538332,
-0.0174776912,
-0.0049613714,
0.0295958333,
0.0172452964,
-0.0128203928,
-0.005101834,
-0.0195141397,
-0.0418700986,
0.0251076035,
-0.014425897,
0.1332317293,
0.0481376424,
-0.0605131797,
-0.0303883515,
0.0088572586,
-0.080887109,
-0.0901086181,
0.0437975712,
0.0301445611,
0.0117325056,
-0.0029306954,
0.0070180655,
-0.0636705011,
0.0279243905,
0.0458746403,
0.0074805128,
0.0034923942,
-0.0673267469,
0.0175107047,
0.0147775309,
-0.001518346,
0.0054778457,
0.033961013,
-0.0305648614,
0.0099870702,
0.0316473618,
0.006252652,
-0.0412602089,
0.0240948051,
-0.0421587862,
0.0836586207,
-0.0163084567,
0.0721018687,
-0.1203455999,
-0.0398889445,
0.0252847448,
0.0119760642,
-0.0129265115,
-0.0391438156,
0.0440930985,
0.0464403331,
0.0112679545,
-0.0253767148,
-0.0032033026,
0.0109077403,
0.0062765484,
-0.02470419,
-0.0205299687,
-6.770787217e-33,
-0.0130375158,
0.0060341507,
0.0232761558,
0.0230289716,
-0.0613987409,
-0.0179574937,
-0.0480346754,
0.0233924333,
-0.0113554019,
-0.0017468866,
-0.0253737625,
0.0118661933,
-0.0102249896,
0.0202289801,
-0.0028489223,
0.0117471516,
0.0113656633,
-0.022148313,
-0.0376807675,
-0.0140886335,
0.0101319235,
-0.0138511797,
0.0018730771,
-0.0794775933,
0.0201940071,
0.0115780476,
0.0206071921,
0.032934282,
-0.0562783405,
-0.0041943314,
-0.0417010076,
0.0139298998,
0.0378138386,
-0.0614783615,
0.0204015393,
0.020829007,
-0.0140227601,
-0.0396246687,
0.0778766423,
-0.0487992354,
-0.0113641573,
-0.0451605693,
-0.0479581356,
-0.0036538902,
-0.0120935263,
-0.0015286437,
0.004149768,
-0.0126781017,
0.0466781631,
0.0226044916,
-0.0776049048,
-0.0231871288,
0.0035296888,
-0.0256480686,
0.0170010086,
0.0290993359,
-0.0103799794,
-0.0376953147,
-0.0199142154,
0.0261989478,
0.0313657559,
-0.0102301911,
0.0478299521,
-0.0035105376,
0.0088031562,
0.0893732756,
0.0193499867,
0.0042126765,
-0.061105378,
-0.0415833294,
-0.0003407708,
0.0391555019,
0.0263330489,
0.0500951558,
-0.0162770357,
-0.0177376512,
-0.0601147003,
-0.0082185687,
0.0520701632,
0.0124750445,
0.0699518099,
-0.0075275889,
-0.0218666103,
-0.0159154981,
-0.0537679046,
-0.0226610266,
-0.0285852831,
0.016828537,
0.0157921743,
0.0062144487,
-0.0416094698,
-0.034587007,
0.0283366889,
-0.0281753298,
-0.0133476127,
0.0005912728,
-0.0052816197,
0.0400430523,
-0.0096602309,
0.0228123032,
-0.0624524206,
-0.0193346925,
0.0057654534,
0.0159919858,
0.0157958772,
0.020154871,
0.0102266148,
0.0004572316,
-0.0421266593,
-0.0145144165,
-0.0601670854,
0.0442468524,
-0.0266016405,
-0.0094442004,
0.0228457879,
0.0342001729,
-0.0124726798,
-0.0462832712,
0.0040957499,
-0.0797723383,
-0.0240159295,
0.0542655066,
-0.0230121519,
-0.0028804312,
-0.0252625979,
0.0006290434,
-0.0159519687,
0.0135187646,
0.0429720543,
-0.0346656404,
-0.0319008715,
0.0103909299,
3.122e-7,
-0.0014655994,
0.0524190627,
-0.0106289135,
-0.0025467256,
0.0384561568,
0.0602885708,
-0.0118131982,
0.0299793631,
0.03686231,
-0.0759207383,
-0.0121549405,
0.0519741364,
0.0419963188,
0.0306867715,
-0.0983814821,
-0.0219697487,
0.0204359386,
-0.02805111,
-0.0225156751,
-0.0077749393,
0.0515802689,
0.0415474959,
0.0318629108,
-0.0164175369,
0.0182597097,
0.0331972949,
0.0512297675,
-0.0593088828,
0.0172101296,
-0.0119423782,
0.0300002135,
-0.0440131724,
0.0073388088,
0.0476642884,
0.0477320701,
0.0462512858,
-0.0259161498,
-0.017182108,
0.0035884369,
-0.0325531811,
-0.0029494429,
0.010301684,
-0.0258388743,
-0.0827248469,
0.0568372197,
-0.0670301989,
-0.0383988656,
0.0029663779,
0.0134509178,
-0.0066858609,
-0.012329136,
0.0413039215,
-0.0220743269,
0.0177384317,
0.0073530884,
-0.0052669896,
0.0184291359,
-0.0648497418,
-0.0017206866,
-0.0631005764,
-0.0129059507,
-0.0554109588,
-0.0370032676,
-0.0079939961,
-0.0010886198,
-0.0692951381,
0.0088304142,
2.907582751e-34,
0.0251352713,
0.0097668553,
0.0302885566,
-0.0189239215,
0.0497863404,
-0.0163449794,
-0.0273121335,
0.0300780833,
0.0443885513,
-0.1105182469,
-0.0305596273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10217v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10217v2 | A Language and Its Dimensions: Intrinsic Dimensions of Language Fractal Structures | 2023-11-16T22:15:15 | 2023-11-20T17:08:11 | Vasilii A. Gromov, Nikita S. Borodin, Asel S. Yerbolova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, math.AT, nlin.CD | The present paper introduces a novel object of study - a language fractal
structure. We hypothesize that a set of embeddings of all $n$-grams of a
natural language constitutes a representative sample of this fractal set. (We
use the term Hailonakea to refer to the sum total of all language fractal
structures, over all $n$). The paper estimates intrinsic (genuine) dimensions
of language fractal structures for the Russian and English languages. To this
end, we employ methods based on (1) topological data analysis and (2) a minimum
spanning tree of a data graph for a cloud of points considered (Steele
theorem). For both languages, for all $n$, the intrinsic dimensions appear to
be non-integer values (typical for fractal sets), close to 9 for both of the
Russian and English language. | [
-0.062311504,
-0.0168525204,
-0.058219213,
0.0309509132,
-0.0591946803,
-0.0007397641,
-0.019397499,
0.029642934,
-0.0279237125,
0.0242071692,
0.0597474985,
-0.1439013034,
0.0127438223,
0.0878793001,
0.0340828896,
-0.0642133653,
-0.0112229045,
-0.0166701246,
-0.0203192327,
-0.0058541903,
-0.0250486787,
-0.0452273488,
0.0192531366,
-0.0245727096,
-0.0091116671,
-0.0152460467,
-0.0313437805,
-0.0522794276,
0.0057009226,
-0.0311779194,
-0.0755313486,
0.0087995902,
-0.0484037474,
0.0255640969,
0.0000013747,
-0.0655362457,
-0.0111302072,
-0.0102060996,
0.0133593716,
-0.0113122966,
0.0132218171,
-0.0055241347,
-0.0382289551,
-0.0273994226,
0.0057629216,
-0.0465124436,
0.0126388054,
0.0400760062,
0.018924959,
0.0787219778,
-0.0278944727,
-0.093816191,
0.0225516297,
0.0139844315,
-0.0055249142,
0.0834839195,
0.0103983814,
0.0608094707,
0.015288054,
-0.0021482238,
-0.0363646001,
0.0086609162,
0.0187604371,
-0.0395586789,
-0.0181117002,
0.0202590562,
0.0025634663,
-0.0048134374,
0.0623543635,
0.0374767296,
0.0171728842,
0.0032933475,
0.0292147398,
0.0322324336,
-0.0146463849,
0.0547460802,
-0.0514375381,
-0.0006820783,
-0.0116281817,
0.0322406068,
0.0018534398,
0.017295409,
0.0027859514,
-0.0507446826,
-0.0187302828,
0.073323153,
0.0142060714,
-0.0051288288,
-0.0362177938,
-0.0724640414,
0.0312689692,
-0.0184584148,
-0.0485194921,
0.0081100836,
0.0254869349,
0.0022012978,
-0.000583011,
-0.0024960588,
0.0320622176,
-0.052503936,
0.0216206554,
-0.0219815951,
0.0238105878,
0.0387771837,
0.0035777502,
-0.0100455033,
-0.0249795374,
0.0160907749,
-0.0475285761,
0.0170511715,
-0.0141624138,
0.0089649623,
-0.0258284751,
0.0186414327,
0.0040332843,
0.0242074691,
-0.0326674841,
0.0416114405,
0.006600582,
0.0075765932,
-0.0726012588,
-0.0273913369,
0.0560880825,
-0.0208732728,
-0.0157329794,
-0.0200256575,
-0.0718353763,
-0.01353586,
-0.0457414798,
-0.0128434096,
0.0355940051,
0.0303618237,
0.0269705616,
0.0363418013,
0.0026653821,
0.0314683951,
0.0767690912,
-0.0242067147,
0.0029931155,
0.0153050441,
-0.0060860086,
-0.033762943,
0.0107946368,
-0.0551425554,
-0.0308846552,
-0.0221212339,
-0.019559402,
-0.0145830223,
-0.0422420241,
-0.009843301,
0.0086074993,
0.0706583038,
-0.0767113268,
0.0338422284,
0.0052428683,
-0.0259249881,
0.002560429,
0.0261610355,
0.0298902933,
-0.0032717888,
0.0471091792,
-0.0805652142,
0.0007445107,
-0.0087701324,
-0.0375060253,
0.0278683174,
-0.0499913841,
0.0332005695,
0.0343173221,
-0.0083780987,
-0.0008352854,
0.0465779081,
0.0044956892,
-0.0728021488,
0.0203737039,
0.1175022051,
0.0226542912,
0.0665935129,
-0.0428707711,
0.0065125721,
0.0553552732,
0.0366913378,
0.0524366647,
-0.0316625386,
0.0379618481,
0.0169815607,
0.0511587895,
0.0087977964,
-0.0070859413,
-0.0479107946,
-0.0334299803,
-0.0298810061,
0.0286066364,
-0.0580251291,
0.0563961193,
-0.0133257378,
0.0009645757,
-0.0120184207,
0.0136938989,
0.0033275043,
-0.0210537706,
0.0192274861,
0.0348728783,
0.0336473286,
-0.0115148388,
-0.0571822189,
0.0681403875,
0.0040824097,
0.0000748878,
-0.0203436557,
-0.0263296012,
-0.0059890645,
-0.0370743014,
-0.0409436859,
0.0281053782,
0.0105124256,
0.0030146865,
0.0173356757,
-0.040559072,
0.0438586064,
-0.0426112674,
-0.0379772931,
-0.0364931859,
-0.0357509181,
0.0431089588,
0.0293589327,
-0.0223606694,
-0.0049375831,
0.0197072718,
0.0384289883,
-0.025896905,
0.0312711112,
0.048592668,
-0.0382314324,
-0.0283466317,
-0.0248131491,
-0.0047171856,
0.0323241092,
0.0355241597,
-0.0234284718,
0.0459666476,
-0.0288563892,
0.0396991894,
0.024143301,
0.0274721757,
-0.0734074861,
0.0077213068,
0.0094456375,
0.0438787304,
-0.0486128032,
0.0348211043,
0.0008628991,
0.0218173116,
-0.0252817739,
0.0920878649,
-0.012047777,
0.0021761982,
0.0592929944,
-0.0217862576,
0.0051431525,
0.0342899747,
-0.0178130958,
0.0155731756,
0.0206505861,
-0.0408994481,
-0.0279624555,
-0.03020126,
0.0363965631,
-0.0529481545,
0.0112560252,
0.0366057977,
-0.0024715608,
0.0158143025,
-0.0026138115,
-0.0139359059,
-0.0448685363,
0.0048146825,
0.0391432457,
0.0046911105,
0.0382868238,
-0.0359632634,
-0.0388727151,
-0.0053887437,
-0.0227960385,
0.0077182869,
0.0225349404,
0.000003897,
-0.0221419409,
-0.0157220438,
0.0262123607,
-0.025058819,
0.0179659836,
-0.0320432447,
-0.0581225753,
0.023758987,
-0.0196688995,
0.0709295794,
0.0092099132,
-0.0308357701,
0.0272319466,
0.0154266097,
-0.0092296936,
0.0431076437,
-0.0257449523,
-0.0467184521,
0.111072287,
-0.0315705463,
-0.0312764943,
0.0307459142,
0.0683876052,
-0.0166014079,
-0.0191408023,
-0.0189011879,
0.038551569,
-0.0355600566,
0.0573465563,
0.0251861271,
0.0378730632,
-0.0200631451,
0.0765410438,
0.0013503807,
-0.0679683387,
-0.0109659946,
0.0158699118,
0.0014521396,
0.0317257904,
-0.047416389,
-0.0565757453,
0.0914807394,
0.0713403821,
0.0035888921,
0.030362539,
-0.0036646002,
0.0101031316,
0.0264805462,
0.0105692791,
-0.0355301835,
0.0069603715,
0.0234251004,
-0.0053320043,
0.0184826553,
-0.0055934736,
0.0109905489,
0.0186862797,
0.063826099,
-0.0224308334,
0.00267566,
-0.0698330104,
0.0037587122,
0.0549063981,
0.0122126695,
0.0081036435,
0.012244123,
-0.0086633097,
0.0254574772,
0.0931596383,
0.0250945892,
0.027736824,
0.0434265733,
0.0126927914,
0.0460861064,
0.0067795631,
0.0210495368,
0.0560818873,
0.0506534688,
-0.0069404016,
-0.0141598061,
0.0161587391,
-0.0418691412,
0.0548079386,
0.0384520628,
0.026634099,
0.0098053664,
0.0503239557,
-0.0169791654,
0.0455869548,
0.0448846184,
-0.0000503978,
0.0022878696,
0.0525180921,
-0.0184205733,
-0.035466101,
0.0921557993,
-0.03722452,
-0.0363119878,
-0.0035796573,
-0.0269733295,
0.0009076824,
-0.0835045576,
-0.0229466166,
0.0184309315,
-0.0243023448,
-0.0219935756,
0.0060093626,
0.0021380435,
0.0202351436,
-0.0629925579,
-0.0010039107,
-0.0140113402,
0.0073626549,
0.0331961289,
-0.0236981567,
-0.0220532026,
-0.0323980004,
-0.0214751009,
0.0073106401,
-0.0766916275,
0.0471698269,
-0.0347357243,
-0.0303913243,
-0.0547386631,
0.0680314898,
-0.0146115012,
0.0141347591,
0.0216965079,
0.1162101775,
-0.0121125951,
-0.0232828911,
-0.0157194044,
-0.0051142094,
0.0018797418,
-0.0121260751,
0.083396852,
0.0021901783,
-0.0300468951,
-0.0077886567,
-0.0178065524,
-0.0555152595,
-0.0072023412,
0.0141571332,
0.0046034302,
-0.022123009,
-0.0479994416,
0.0277965553,
0.0062019927,
-0.0348379351,
0.0643318295,
0.0155719006,
-0.0724151358,
-0.0484912843,
-0.0086599952,
-0.0333195329,
0.0897803903,
-0.0190368127,
0.0037459042,
0.0227324348,
-0.0383471847,
0.0018185325,
-0.024390325,
0.0034210915,
0.0159656145,
-0.0049040099,
-0.019486798,
-0.0177931655,
-0.0006652333,
-0.0152966632,
-0.0570284687,
0.0160637628,
-0.0359800979,
0.0344705805,
0.0240783021,
0.021436112,
-0.0228886753,
0.0091485735,
-0.03697313,
0.0382212959,
-0.0174674932,
-0.0581585579,
0.0120787648,
0.0110984892,
-0.0362432636,
0.0094362348,
0.0460284501,
0.0187117904,
0.0156313479,
-0.0526379384,
-0.0084000826,
-0.0661616102,
-0.0145969559,
0.0145416474,
0.0030146099,
-0.0088349115,
0.0397913717,
0.0317522474,
0.0275948029,
-0.0232458767,
-0.026439026,
-0.0071701757,
-0.0147900218,
-0.0353527665,
0.0008751551,
-0.0201080889,
-0.0511874221,
-0.0424716659,
-0.0038252776,
-0.0085166134,
0.0369805619,
0.0118086832,
0.0169176441,
0.0154051818,
0.0415874012,
0.0132511528,
0.0342473574,
-0.0004761542,
-0.0351123512,
0.0350835137,
0.0223488677,
-0.0377072878,
0.0111345826,
0.0085806306,
-0.000831043,
0.0442008898,
-0.0142899267,
-0.0211705174,
0.0030875732,
-0.0092025753,
0.0297579058,
0.0238440651,
0.0169801004,
-0.0400969833,
0.0197295472,
-0.001611855,
-0.0170521159,
0.0114009595,
-0.0415112898,
-0.0076863314,
0.0258048773,
-0.0263050813,
0.0101678977,
0.0385846198,
0.0050055152,
-0.0189328883,
-0.003588489,
-0.0220335517,
-0.0374480225,
0.0381542221,
-0.0657773018,
0.0487237386,
0.0056622573,
0.0139530785,
-0.0946919844,
-0.0745816305,
0.0296483375,
0.0234367214,
0.0380278826,
0.0195515603,
0.0287921634,
-0.0121533973,
0.0160642974,
0.037728332,
-0.0160102211,
-0.0030777175,
-0.0451515056,
0.0281328484,
0.0296123307,
-4.714170953e-33,
0.0046164105,
-0.0473414883,
-0.0340658762,
0.0324538685,
0.0023671165,
-0.0055801109,
0.0158912223,
0.0188050009,
-0.0084968247,
-0.0020736232,
0.0206594765,
0.0000891366,
-0.0015762227,
-0.0143674156,
0.0436238647,
0.0278600212,
-0.0156094301,
-0.029815821,
-0.0156109221,
0.0086500384,
-0.0094514461,
-0.0516035594,
0.0559587069,
-0.0496631339,
0.0257376563,
0.0026791899,
0.0125926584,
0.0440640561,
0.0196950492,
-0.0100212144,
-0.0089238705,
0.0481147133,
0.0217956286,
-0.0560745932,
-0.0153733809,
0.0011500149,
-0.0268359296,
-0.0675084442,
0.0342372321,
0.0000487799,
0.0310990009,
-0.0410029776,
0.018195888,
-0.0372746401,
0.0018731437,
-0.0294758901,
0.0190197378,
0.0036066074,
-0.0132928025,
-0.0235848073,
-0.0012757487,
0.0366290286,
-0.0011534131,
0.0301215742,
-0.0288330521,
-0.0266649015,
0.016656423,
-0.0742524192,
-0.0099478876,
0.0688131154,
0.0162967015,
0.0265014172,
-0.0575902313,
-0.0379828103,
0.0278107859,
0.0498627387,
0.113762483,
0.0320835188,
0.0435066335,
-0.0169900358,
0.0256826319,
0.0001663562,
0.0131115075,
0.0082851239,
0.010452521,
0.0449885726,
-0.0359907188,
-0.0062062931,
-0.0192712992,
-0.0182363931,
-0.0321900435,
-0.0120797129,
-0.054053545,
-0.0384082124,
0.0213025119,
0.0067646224,
0.0155945942,
-0.0317847878,
-0.0203915555,
-0.0484136157,
0.0528298616,
-0.014669829,
-0.0433674119,
-0.029238306,
-0.031872686,
-0.0596830957,
-0.001544142,
0.0417079479,
-0.0003203365,
0.0255007166,
0.0197673105,
-0.0406421833,
-0.0850920007,
0.0143977646,
0.0057870024,
0.0152775319,
-0.0363411605,
0.0235743541,
-0.0756228194,
-0.0069526522,
0.0463056415,
-0.0753248334,
0.0409774221,
-0.0045498195,
0.0377786867,
-0.013040795,
-0.000998855,
0.0238941014,
0.0457512327,
0.0100198779,
0.0049124737,
-0.0305195022,
-0.0156050688,
0.0245602559,
-0.0259645041,
-0.0060211821,
-0.0755180344,
0.0256813038,
0.0582129247,
-0.014223027,
-0.0123778591,
0.0112800403,
2.389e-7,
0.0231337901,
0.0486571081,
0.0359362029,
0.0065710708,
0.0567231625,
-0.0039044432,
-0.054998897,
0.0122863473,
-0.0507712029,
0.0171538964,
0.0004662445,
-0.0319793262,
0.0137930997,
0.0421528108,
-0.0949770063,
0.0599646829,
-0.0287416633,
-0.0221515056,
-0.0147224255,
0.0600647703,
-0.0095755206,
0.0398701988,
0.0323900431,
0.0201541074,
-0.0207375307,
-0.0657507777,
0.0177027583,
-0.0147181116,
0.0040895995,
-0.026164772,
0.0027498875,
-0.0341080762,
-0.0179882497,
-0.0252731312,
0.0252591129,
0.0405892916,
-0.0116152763,
-0.0578234009,
-0.0010247219,
0.1234726757,
0.0086645717,
-0.1110453531,
-0.0525240973,
-0.0144597916,
0.0195749197,
-0.0265609939,
-0.0946392417,
0.026453929,
0.0441631451,
-0.0025571976,
0.0318254381,
0.0281958841,
-0.0390317962,
0.0204854552,
0.0102796201,
-0.0730409175,
0.0987267122,
0.0266665295,
-0.0120797958,
0.0725444183,
-0.0209571775,
-0.0191460047,
-0.0298648961,
0.0209354665,
0.0438137092,
0.024601467,
0.0094760302,
1.907723902e-34,
0.0328011289,
-0.0119993752,
0.0118569806,
0.008090931,
-0.0240695793,
-0.0365050286,
0.032210391,
-0.0018677079,
0.0358211733,
-0.0609947853,
-0.0441590548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10215v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10215v1 | Predictive Minds: LLMs As Atypical Active Inference Agents | 2023-11-16T22:11:12 | 2023-11-16T22:11:12 | Jan Kulveit, Clem von Stengel, Roman Leventov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) like GPT are often conceptualized as passive
predictors, simulators, or even stochastic parrots. We instead conceptualize
LLMs by drawing on the theory of active inference originating in cognitive
science and neuroscience. We examine similarities and differences between
traditional active inference systems and LLMs, leading to the conclusion that,
currently, LLMs lack a tight feedback loop between acting in the world and
perceiving the impacts of their actions, but otherwise fit in the active
inference paradigm. We list reasons why this loop may soon be closed, and
possible consequences of this including enhanced model self-awareness and the
drive to minimize prediction error by changing the world. | [
0.0513503514,
0.0622654296,
-0.0680397823,
0.0151950317,
-0.0307189189,
0.0157367438,
-0.040396139,
0.0091195414,
0.0521056578,
-0.0451697595,
-0.0120869325,
-0.0030197722,
-0.0066628978,
0.013255964,
0.0739965588,
-0.0479253195,
0.0558341295,
-0.0615962408,
-0.0004604686,
-0.0288123693,
-0.0254601818,
0.0152804758,
-0.0089431433,
0.0383973233,
0.0203257594,
0.0254152603,
-0.027768068,
-0.0300283637,
-0.0395616814,
-0.0052213189,
-0.0270962343,
0.0195541512,
0.0653013736,
0.0598523654,
0.0000018724,
-0.0658695921,
0.0440914817,
-0.0428548753,
-0.0168061405,
-0.0038778116,
-0.0280477703,
0.0060975673,
0.0094760992,
-0.0228898041,
-0.048101671,
-0.0292098168,
0.0454577506,
-0.0191201698,
-0.02895361,
0.0404043719,
-0.0038002818,
0.0062549002,
0.0312940739,
-0.0050054723,
0.0383468345,
-0.0317308344,
0.0481138676,
0.0016689388,
0.0160489529,
-0.0083239907,
-0.0533559844,
0.0349142477,
-0.0067064562,
0.0093386769,
-0.0212665442,
0.0415413342,
0.0075306701,
-0.0455730222,
-0.0018651026,
0.0120971864,
0.0679432079,
-0.0497452579,
0.004028108,
-0.0180005096,
0.0081257308,
0.0283758752,
-0.0277058836,
0.0400526896,
-0.0132031692,
0.0476327166,
0.0436395705,
-0.021056544,
0.0313258022,
0.0161569435,
-0.0093583409,
0.0706319138,
-0.0205778126,
-0.0226318911,
-0.0059001362,
0.065051131,
-0.0119591225,
-0.0792656392,
-0.0245196316,
0.0322500132,
-0.0356183611,
0.0216466915,
0.0021274195,
0.0059245811,
-0.0367247425,
-0.0335768759,
0.0092581846,
0.0441647246,
0.0192105286,
0.0406772271,
-0.0053733243,
-0.0020344367,
-0.0454073064,
0.0396125577,
-0.0177342016,
0.0319193602,
-0.0370760113,
-0.0481102653,
-0.0105113145,
0.0410721451,
0.0354548506,
-0.0198232699,
-0.0008319395,
0.0383095853,
-0.010032244,
-0.0192928147,
-0.0510575064,
0.0289907642,
-0.0163224172,
-0.0114144869,
-0.0775989294,
0.0274122767,
-0.0112707363,
0.0330870301,
-0.0237144604,
-0.0632399172,
-0.0305426437,
0.0124277277,
-0.0008437158,
-0.0046258396,
-0.0326809362,
0.1083650738,
-0.0014511687,
-0.0060776877,
-0.0173606649,
-0.0069366205,
-0.0031373585,
-0.0472055413,
0.0195481926,
-0.0086251926,
-0.0229688715,
0.0418940559,
0.0196791962,
-0.0443289243,
0.0099784322,
-0.0290448442,
-0.0386132337,
0.0650758743,
-0.0045702183,
0.030222306,
0.0165682808,
-0.0094392933,
-0.0196447559,
0.0900207534,
0.0222703889,
0.0068802298,
-0.0225033909,
0.0203868132,
0.0391661301,
0.0255021751,
-0.0087053245,
-0.0111886654,
-0.0483301394,
-0.0226058178,
-0.0232949033,
0.0181422364,
0.0170987621,
0.039856378,
-0.0099937618,
0.0425164402,
0.0887695998,
0.0284620151,
-0.0503468327,
0.0323438831,
0.0637032837,
-0.0234857909,
0.0002837509,
0.0381345861,
-0.056290891,
0.0428510346,
-0.031484589,
0.0095852315,
-0.0094899405,
-0.0160679109,
-0.0146264741,
-0.0190919712,
-0.0153626706,
-0.0005806609,
-0.0040131058,
0.0198823214,
0.0390671454,
0.0031584532,
-0.0264712013,
0.0239145793,
0.0122577259,
0.0129346363,
-0.0012804719,
-0.0898204669,
0.0652522221,
0.0329188667,
0.0441046543,
-0.0338372067,
-0.0323587395,
-0.0060409261,
-0.0251911674,
0.0761801451,
0.037656717,
0.0033629325,
-0.0345802866,
-0.0025601273,
-0.0111381272,
0.0022780364,
0.0336908065,
0.0189958885,
-0.020760458,
0.0069641797,
-0.0333158895,
0.0132166687,
-0.0072006364,
0.017864475,
-0.0497548766,
-0.0253110528,
-0.0531510636,
-0.0228543505,
0.0321566537,
-0.0316962674,
0.0043100389,
0.016749952,
-0.0026833306,
0.0178440623,
-0.0251255184,
0.0585329905,
-0.0258520283,
0.0022219762,
0.0142660271,
-0.0068850019,
-0.0253624599,
0.0289345179,
0.0075031752,
-0.0179006513,
0.0851871371,
-0.0413834229,
0.0605237074,
-0.0581980534,
0.001056727,
-0.0420188382,
0.0045725112,
0.0002810436,
0.0504903458,
0.0319720916,
-0.0288282577,
0.0362489522,
0.0076773409,
0.0052539669,
-0.022407759,
-0.012183683,
-0.005660132,
0.0329283848,
-0.0222323313,
0.0232816711,
-0.0219999906,
-0.0385443904,
-0.0179300644,
-0.040862985,
-0.029644208,
-0.0086314585,
-0.0050760307,
-0.0001896586,
-0.0112819523,
-0.0284927897,
-0.0007594694,
0.0163620617,
0.0361352116,
0.0232825819,
0.0336808264,
0.0099351667,
-0.0324876904,
-0.0013704702,
-0.0645357519,
0.0313647091,
-0.0426192023,
0.0098475134,
0.0264070313,
-0.0515036546,
-0.079029642,
0.0089365868,
-0.0423216969,
0.048644498,
0.0013819665,
-0.0104248608,
0.0553019457,
-0.036959067,
0.0259525068,
0.0558552444,
-0.0132407639,
0.0421949588,
0.0553065129,
-0.0128261652,
-0.0453886874,
0.0105090123,
-0.0663607642,
-0.0461283177,
-0.053834755,
-0.0093843527,
-0.0494060479,
0.0904615447,
0.0516054034,
-0.0062158876,
-0.0528473519,
0.0774953291,
-0.0147158224,
-0.0717480555,
-0.022235617,
-0.0295712035,
-0.0349711962,
0.0532368869,
0.0122580519,
-0.0685779303,
0.1189732179,
0.0265721325,
-0.0040778005,
0.0192932505,
0.0253705233,
-0.0095169963,
0.0698942319,
0.0535294339,
-0.0259504821,
0.0398950428,
0.0005770671,
-0.0499149226,
-0.0285893828,
-0.0041889283,
-0.0017599594,
0.005877797,
-0.0840163901,
0.0081084315,
0.0210455395,
-0.0288445912,
-0.0350537263,
0.01846423,
-0.0915067568,
-0.001599384,
-0.0045201243,
0.0032548609,
0.0073539638,
0.0222931746,
0.0484082997,
0.0269624516,
-0.024604274,
-0.0409740098,
-0.0497627556,
-0.0282609053,
0.054861363,
0.0098659694,
0.0374754854,
-0.0488816947,
0.0050678719,
0.0275708847,
-0.0112035088,
0.0249591675,
-0.0189909637,
0.026448084,
0.032281395,
0.0292362031,
-0.0289277136,
0.025871627,
0.0508188568,
-0.0292561781,
-0.0204722229,
0.1191846132,
0.0173873864,
-0.0269963033,
0.0014468059,
-0.0410313793,
0.013682981,
0.013359325,
0.0323980525,
-0.0382190831,
-0.0078370394,
-0.0004438708,
0.0000749705,
-0.0326935574,
-0.0509904139,
-0.0009035759,
-0.0785651803,
0.0643447861,
0.0024512988,
-0.0164547898,
0.011450097,
-0.0033017895,
0.0257424098,
-0.0046855467,
-0.0253576618,
0.0050100898,
-0.001136504,
0.0286998712,
0.0142817283,
-0.031381499,
0.0295861643,
-0.0053320122,
0.0021004085,
0.0611069575,
0.0714941919,
0.0173548386,
-0.0141795203,
-0.0294821225,
0.0117584011,
-0.050844688,
0.0164796505,
-0.0264345799,
-0.0007715615,
0.0177468657,
-0.0070420955,
-0.0219236333,
0.0205704384,
-0.0305870008,
-0.0077584921,
0.0244343858,
0.1035868898,
-0.0436491519,
-0.0726684481,
-0.0137974685,
0.0245151073,
-0.0040845876,
0.0543591306,
0.0390038751,
-0.0350352004,
-0.035419222,
-0.0437057391,
-0.0104733305,
0.0108027412,
-0.0845582932,
-0.0402657464,
0.0362367146,
-0.0346206315,
-0.0383253358,
-0.0217713807,
0.0393729657,
-0.0090332134,
0.0211806018,
0.0117945606,
0.0391158685,
-0.0298399627,
0.045428887,
0.0007836835,
-0.0253882855,
-0.0055941222,
0.0137546863,
-0.0567207299,
0.0530873984,
-0.06255164,
-0.0049985261,
0.0116131138,
-0.0609828345,
-0.0935148224,
0.0329075828,
0.0535213426,
0.039237421,
0.0149166696,
0.0038538198,
-0.0235954579,
0.0025660347,
0.016357366,
0.007978986,
0.0847912133,
-0.0087841349,
0.0239649713,
-0.0000447678,
0.0500661805,
0.0105667096,
0.0246784613,
0.0301109776,
-0.0167425424,
-0.0111950664,
-0.0444594733,
0.0322304107,
-0.0147839971,
0.062952131,
-0.0233190265,
-0.012625372,
-0.0328693278,
-0.0237975363,
-0.0024041117,
0.0115107894,
-0.0387704708,
-0.001965628,
0.0287302397,
0.0715670362,
-0.0199979153,
-0.0558501706,
-0.0164330993,
0.0385681987,
-0.0089633986,
-0.0233846549,
0.0314969197,
-0.0112938425,
0.0143697234,
-0.0017170083,
-0.0014211534,
0.0358173139,
-0.0355155542,
0.0528863519,
0.0126716373,
0.0626717731,
0.0213405732,
-0.0170938279,
-0.0032298702,
-0.0175833292,
-0.0911760032,
-0.1151792705,
0.0464595631,
0.0701414198,
0.0355543792,
-0.019146122,
0.0419414155,
-0.0818153992,
0.0146933142,
0.0171918254,
0.0129785929,
0.0103173601,
-0.0226348527,
0.0051899268,
0.0232493449,
-0.0218612552,
0.0043567596,
0.0463691466,
0.0014511443,
0.0729697272,
-0.0079544224,
-0.0192141905,
-0.0091654323,
-0.033783339,
-0.0117702466,
0.0000700714,
0.0034388688,
0.0636817515,
-0.0538558997,
-0.0570203997,
-0.0254699681,
0.0347973593,
-0.017365098,
-0.0963925421,
0.0177639872,
0.048198659,
-0.0042727799,
-0.0408503413,
-0.0130468393,
0.0456664227,
0.0000119257,
0.0233154222,
-0.0382580459,
-6.389359136e-33,
-0.0373638496,
-0.0103383353,
0.0285586901,
0.0181979388,
-0.0284661986,
-0.0373087898,
-0.0686456636,
0.0269949101,
-0.0096465377,
0.0110000297,
-0.0131915156,
0.0039990488,
0.0118520269,
-0.005515534,
0.0676637813,
-0.0215101596,
-0.0038552545,
-0.020439228,
0.0058166645,
-0.0296465028,
0.0208684132,
0.0098917587,
0.0508420765,
-0.0705831721,
0.0244529527,
0.0089101754,
-0.0125101656,
0.0205744132,
-0.0755567625,
-0.004990296,
-0.0376789086,
0.0363569967,
0.02805789,
-0.007170822,
-0.0207836088,
-0.0167575926,
0.0146433674,
-0.0512081347,
0.0691759288,
-0.0132112019,
-0.0250697657,
0.0198066495,
0.0102823507,
-0.0199515484,
-0.0695302114,
0.0325126275,
0.0231006239,
-0.0259296875,
0.0057691289,
0.0559437238,
-0.0847060084,
-0.0161258504,
0.0070138397,
0.0127899759,
0.0173108205,
0.0163637754,
-0.0281287283,
-0.0151478676,
-0.0371531881,
0.02582887,
0.0437209532,
0.0220769588,
0.0469349325,
0.0450521186,
0.0393274687,
0.0591605119,
0.0651920363,
0.0150910551,
-0.0612417944,
-0.002156083,
0.008828531,
0.0045085773,
0.0150362877,
0.0309806764,
-0.0104481373,
-0.0066304808,
-0.0013403527,
-0.0332598276,
0.0452795662,
0.0096080489,
0.0651434362,
0.0034342562,
0.005755139,
-0.051342424,
0.0001126084,
-0.0275767446,
-0.0038662993,
-0.0426065028,
-0.0144967632,
-0.000047286,
-0.0056744055,
0.0092467545,
0.0153486859,
-0.0342945047,
-0.0104646534,
-0.042271968,
-0.0144693069,
0.0220996849,
0.0190343,
0.020632375,
-0.0449120551,
-0.0159507804,
-0.030121956,
0.0408048369,
0.0037395521,
0.0382097811,
-0.0502937213,
0.0566018894,
-0.0041453093,
-0.0043701525,
-0.0417706333,
-0.013079009,
0.0118021658,
-0.0459667742,
0.0385453105,
0.0145248761,
-0.0138019761,
-0.0274175294,
0.0159161557,
-0.041267179,
-0.0288155787,
0.0418561921,
-0.0594239086,
0.0280647706,
-0.0389551073,
-0.0293845553,
-0.0561727472,
0.0361948758,
0.0153281577,
-0.086867474,
-0.0171877146,
0.0056979936,
2.732e-7,
0.0378537513,
0.0329094715,
-0.0061683827,
0.0227728188,
0.0664260462,
0.0421989188,
-0.0025982882,
0.0213568676,
0.0893118307,
-0.0596424006,
0.0114312097,
0.0371029787,
0.0067818458,
0.0342512503,
-0.0900912285,
-0.0138126463,
-0.0622366183,
0.0374723226,
-0.0214750469,
-0.0012021951,
0.017894119,
0.0493505634,
0.0295964945,
-0.0062788622,
-0.0019988047,
-0.0276704151,
0.0538588092,
-0.0291569568,
0.0222830679,
-0.0009380493,
0.0048745773,
-0.0104179112,
-0.0097752102,
0.0181139801,
0.029563617,
0.0094522946,
-0.0382134691,
0.0246046223,
0.0048848377,
0.0114989942,
-0.0092333667,
0.0062028603,
0.0060053011,
-0.0734921843,
0.0692602992,
-0.0836862251,
-0.0265644807,
0.015484524,
0.058037661,
-0.0179743227,
-0.0108951833,
0.0022628983,
-0.0224955287,
0.0020175171,
-0.0042187059,
0.0279973764,
0.0047154441,
-0.0523328371,
-0.0112397289,
-0.0549842119,
-0.0797018558,
-0.068445757,
-0.0455057062,
-0.0008108346,
0.0171346795,
-0.0524237528,
0.0180599503,
2.206122569e-34,
0.0279304944,
0.0367505774,
0.0295113344,
0.0119764227,
0.0333938748,
0.0074220733,
0.0672058463,
0.0184732098,
0.0453675762,
-0.052875828,
-0.0528229363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10181v1 | The Impact of Familiarity on Naming Variation: A Study on Object Naming in Mandarin Chinese | 2023-11-16T20:13:24 | 2023-11-16T20:13:24 | Yunke He, Xixian Liao, Jialing Liang, Gemma Boleda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Different speakers often produce different names for the same object or
entity (e.g., "woman" vs. "tourist" for a female tourist). The reasons behind
variation in naming are not well understood. We create a Language and Vision
dataset for Mandarin Chinese that provides an average of 20 names for 1319
naturalistic images, and investigate how familiarity with a given kind of
object relates to the degree of naming variation it triggers across subjects.
We propose that familiarity influences naming variation in two competing ways:
increasing familiarity can either expand vocabulary, leading to higher
variation, or promote convergence on conventional names, thereby reducing
variation. We find evidence for both factors being at play. Our study
illustrates how computational resources can be used to address research
questions in Cognitive Science. | [
0.0524786375,
0.074198626,
-0.0759003907,
0.0179078393,
0.0141674709,
0.0117828827,
0.0216464028,
0.0210311748,
-0.0028159232,
0.0128971031,
-0.0202711001,
-0.074044548,
0.0808534846,
-0.0199572332,
-0.0032545966,
-0.1066477001,
0.0100089563,
0.0148686208,
0.0310223196,
-0.0266743153,
-0.0182285681,
-0.0209892299,
0.0420786031,
0.0123713631,
0.0058938246,
0.0078992406,
-0.0176276229,
-0.0079942206,
0.0094488747,
-0.0311970841,
-0.0307228249,
0.0595018044,
0.0215277392,
0.033426255,
0.0000018482,
-0.0557139553,
0.0349606648,
-0.036820922,
0.0063978829,
-0.0140777724,
0.042426493,
0.0109531386,
0.0030406557,
-0.066054821,
0.0122372853,
-0.0417427607,
0.10396,
0.0355172306,
-0.049829118,
-0.0293678883,
0.0175182149,
-0.0440239459,
-0.0459067933,
-0.0006482887,
0.0708330423,
0.0119584268,
0.0307194442,
0.0157536119,
-0.0451431423,
-0.0346101299,
-0.0790234059,
-0.0057104668,
-0.0017560233,
0.0792206079,
-0.0094203819,
0.071799852,
-0.0483309142,
-0.038492173,
0.0073603103,
0.1000035554,
0.0075262045,
-0.0345080532,
-0.0067866547,
0.0064309342,
-0.0109338537,
0.0451833867,
-0.0316452831,
0.0194852445,
-0.0224480461,
-0.0082049193,
-0.0170340706,
-0.0209868979,
0.0188543703,
0.0367396213,
0.0073269811,
-0.0209467523,
0.0242673308,
-0.0153286271,
-0.0251232684,
-0.034383148,
-0.0201867465,
-0.0746529698,
-0.005203573,
-0.0036659164,
-0.029793065,
0.0392383263,
0.0319879092,
-0.0084476834,
0.0011989598,
-0.0440760739,
0.0480756536,
0.0265809502,
-0.0413490012,
0.0186626334,
-0.0189014357,
0.0732372925,
-0.0083331,
-0.01606052,
-0.037891373,
0.0043645813,
-0.1064708903,
-0.0171842575,
-0.0099754026,
0.0027068174,
0.01717351,
-0.0199773442,
-0.0332633927,
0.0085768225,
-0.0127294939,
-0.0292901248,
-0.0433833599,
0.043917235,
-0.0258613322,
0.0296023469,
-0.0720211267,
-0.0024914159,
-0.0703752786,
0.0217796229,
-0.0322668999,
-0.0469164699,
0.0126931285,
-0.0314374119,
0.0122010196,
0.0045624427,
0.0062141838,
0.0162642356,
-0.0164252426,
-0.0293335281,
0.0102444105,
-0.0142433811,
-0.0210233442,
-0.033003699,
0.0105881495,
-0.0718089864,
0.0232924968,
0.0046572858,
0.0235615261,
-0.0716421157,
-0.0138949174,
0.0051776771,
-0.0498575419,
0.0756206587,
0.0339033604,
0.020794373,
0.0461779088,
0.0170031618,
0.05020006,
0.0326940976,
0.0310759172,
-0.016507471,
0.0202042721,
-0.0336298384,
0.0227796137,
-0.0158888157,
-0.0293467697,
-0.0000334517,
-0.0328137316,
-0.0307091903,
0.0137537774,
0.036718104,
0.0184864309,
0.0249804109,
-0.0093434835,
-0.041673664,
0.0387206487,
0.0946586579,
-0.04836585,
0.0258800816,
0.0255497172,
-0.0300558321,
-0.0011075104,
0.0292269066,
0.0056670681,
0.0385694318,
0.0162937529,
0.0050175665,
-0.0421591066,
0.0233565923,
-0.0616926551,
-0.0061359876,
-0.002583693,
0.0181093421,
0.0273850914,
-0.0179328993,
-0.0092284223,
0.0193568747,
0.0107595632,
0.0144720813,
0.0235285945,
-0.0573213436,
-0.0215657875,
-0.0093432805,
0.0315835848,
0.0579678044,
-0.0173276588,
0.0450049862,
0.0221322924,
0.0403729528,
0.016790187,
0.0189290587,
0.0348497331,
0.0042088656,
0.0350721292,
-0.0246229712,
-0.0088106757,
0.042985972,
0.0054024942,
0.078696765,
0.0359412991,
0.0184897333,
0.0053851278,
-0.0266728066,
-0.0513458699,
0.0146918148,
-0.0249505248,
-0.0301918127,
0.0201179702,
-0.0228075795,
-0.0098918322,
-0.0057562441,
-0.0193691421,
0.0341870561,
0.0096714236,
0.0323345624,
0.0145151848,
0.0672638416,
-0.0249256454,
0.0179956183,
0.0201139171,
-0.0521138832,
-0.0225121342,
-0.0351532735,
-0.0027077745,
-0.0517265759,
0.0505586676,
0.0102830427,
0.0437336899,
-0.0306481048,
0.0461029187,
-0.0502429977,
0.0560895912,
-0.0209012236,
0.0587423481,
0.0090856245,
0.0309583806,
-0.0044325585,
0.0263963379,
-0.0126732951,
-0.078984648,
-0.057452824,
0.0127294026,
0.0296862796,
0.0103434324,
0.0031495157,
-0.0236610211,
-0.0487174988,
0.0115175433,
-0.0667563006,
-0.0367873199,
0.0306774713,
-0.0448757783,
0.0016818438,
-0.0131479967,
-0.0007785815,
-0.0138759464,
0.0075607467,
0.0351098701,
-0.0517173707,
0.0732820556,
0.0179061648,
-0.0420678854,
-0.078084603,
-0.0104941716,
-0.0030494477,
0.0062240171,
0.0496148728,
0.0309640151,
-0.0140952244,
-0.0267809629,
-0.0013987345,
-0.0881841257,
-0.0097146416,
-0.013070534,
-0.008349888,
0.0250730179,
0.0445083082,
0.0801603124,
0.0511224605,
0.0023491748,
0.0131998062,
0.0552650429,
-0.0395178385,
-0.0347381532,
-0.0600485206,
-0.0096189035,
-0.0598182194,
0.0314359814,
-0.0791851208,
-0.0330475457,
0.0533787198,
-0.0006142494,
0.0075953319,
-0.0339665897,
0.0270838197,
-0.0121303312,
-0.0590439737,
-0.047082644,
-0.0151330475,
-0.0418134667,
0.0818335414,
-0.0324929617,
-0.0228401218,
0.0577224195,
0.0171480235,
0.0060679023,
0.0006587182,
0.0296338834,
0.011615796,
0.0950633287,
0.0329725593,
0.0223497972,
0.0561166517,
-0.026840914,
-0.0865974352,
-0.0010658334,
0.0383495353,
-0.0333649591,
0.0261261296,
-0.043430537,
-0.0082229199,
0.0148065863,
-0.0107608233,
-0.0277045332,
0.0399983637,
-0.0321036614,
0.0033737703,
0.0286775865,
-0.0008504872,
0.0188708007,
0.0375782177,
0.0241235271,
-0.0399357527,
0.0375934914,
0.0035792741,
-0.001552713,
0.0038989321,
0.0013878797,
0.0706789494,
0.0016426592,
-0.0228831917,
-0.0080175595,
0.0198407471,
-0.000266194,
0.032146275,
-0.0091322884,
0.0609442368,
0.0133523177,
-0.0097822472,
-0.0161184464,
0.032495372,
0.0087279016,
-0.023399638,
0.0264890511,
0.0401740782,
0.0329993106,
-0.0463834107,
0.0038505013,
-0.013366363,
0.0381496772,
0.0481998473,
-0.038136933,
-0.0553730167,
0.0186726786,
0.0177197419,
-0.0589808449,
-0.0315488689,
-0.0513738394,
-0.0338038951,
-0.1034240872,
-0.0236360673,
0.0016201483,
-0.098847352,
0.0098963082,
-0.0188632589,
0.0253668576,
0.0122697474,
0.006504409,
0.021539351,
-0.0316203386,
0.0145359905,
-0.0070643239,
0.0129923755,
-0.0376022458,
0.0183897857,
-0.0547332168,
0.0200054068,
0.0402244516,
0.0361930281,
-0.0264809038,
-0.0564740188,
-0.0343678109,
0.0225623921,
0.0098990388,
-0.0215128623,
0.0153138936,
0.0511776544,
-0.0126301013,
-0.0585142523,
-0.0197148602,
0.0288593862,
-0.0351442285,
0.0181402471,
-0.012415396,
0.0373263098,
-0.0311556831,
0.0098724468,
0.0224822927,
-0.0292974859,
0.0824318528,
0.0521387905,
-0.0210221279,
0.0205226764,
-0.0020947019,
0.0115740951,
0.0156120453,
-0.0352591611,
0.0253518019,
-0.06042156,
-0.0596834794,
-0.0865599886,
-0.0005446985,
0.0000116308,
0.01370994,
0.0656315908,
-0.0180889033,
-0.0026165096,
0.0107165268,
-0.0837353244,
0.0400901884,
-0.0038802915,
-0.0199980475,
-0.0217142068,
-0.026358746,
0.0171000715,
-0.0240098871,
0.0070598745,
0.0288999639,
-0.0485625565,
-0.0557648689,
0.027126424,
-0.0008853508,
0.0221803933,
0.0071014175,
0.0580872037,
-0.0357165523,
-0.0116879754,
0.0078097875,
0.0661485717,
-0.0014938604,
-0.0630575791,
-0.0028524611,
0.0114899548,
0.0080146454,
0.0321036205,
-0.0094848499,
0.039548561,
-0.0042155455,
-0.045218654,
0.0070520462,
0.0324288197,
0.0196223166,
0.0044166353,
-0.040555682,
0.022579316,
-0.0228953697,
-0.0033323185,
0.0246909168,
-0.0038403273,
0.0138260573,
-0.0464316122,
0.0257358309,
0.0335274376,
-0.0370810367,
0.0039063594,
-0.0239957962,
0.0251107551,
-0.0072814431,
-0.0769707486,
-0.0138332108,
0.0168551914,
0.0036332565,
0.0166168287,
0.0285064112,
0.0541321784,
-0.0327830836,
0.0427139625,
0.0064323437,
0.0163147915,
0.0309768431,
0.0155421169,
-0.0629345328,
-0.0188247319,
0.0121313315,
-0.0964629129,
0.0086084967,
0.0008197261,
0.0268967878,
-0.0561152101,
-0.0018524993,
-0.0501125939,
0.0105754649,
-0.0214033835,
-0.0537148006,
-0.0119593041,
-0.0347862542,
0.0475974865,
0.0185996275,
0.0006946482,
-0.042422343,
0.0671784878,
-0.0099531719,
-0.0090046786,
-0.0157165192,
-0.0361254849,
0.0145602692,
0.0239473283,
0.0387700871,
0.0091246106,
-0.0020284138,
0.0119826244,
-0.0686815977,
-0.0658596233,
0.0132843414,
-0.0518278368,
0.0511572585,
0.0410526544,
0.0430320017,
0.0470115878,
-0.0045050504,
-0.0128924232,
0.0169896763,
-0.0104634957,
-0.0169485938,
-0.0389678702,
0.0004290249,
-5.953313548e-33,
-0.0352102332,
-0.0100909621,
0.0109312776,
-0.0131043736,
0.0188277978,
-0.0195316486,
-0.0372203626,
0.0584605299,
-0.0176320076,
-0.0007423426,
0.0011503242,
-0.0218685493,
0.027557889,
0.0039980877,
0.069556497,
0.0023826421,
0.0300709605,
0.0506932512,
-0.0437266976,
-0.0526605658,
0.0744904429,
-0.0027650225,
0.0915047526,
-0.0441267975,
0.0163665209,
0.0552687049,
0.0380261131,
-0.0225335415,
0.0394094698,
0.0279877931,
-0.0137415528,
0.0367001519,
0.0399381407,
-0.0085766958,
-0.0243295617,
0.0122364042,
-0.0832830444,
-0.0578571148,
0.0474959724,
0.0180528164,
0.0153590795,
-0.0064224317,
0.0433881804,
-0.0471997,
-0.0197535735,
0.0386436172,
0.0477667898,
-0.036997173,
-0.015458867,
0.0547479652,
-0.0113581382,
-0.0150038917,
0.008807485,
0.0227916092,
0.0238028727,
-0.0307788514,
-0.0386181101,
0.0262380466,
-0.0682154819,
0.0754757673,
0.0356686376,
0.0221730769,
0.0344231166,
0.0627714396,
0.0656268373,
0.0149939172,
0.1125596687,
-0.006801798,
-0.0259579327,
-0.0183617622,
0.0347279944,
0.0216442142,
-0.0117086694,
0.0727587864,
0.0810512528,
-0.0406940356,
0.0168800019,
-0.0200365633,
-0.013284619,
0.0206866954,
0.00728358,
0.0186407287,
-0.009460168,
-0.0394997969,
-0.0344864391,
-0.0002636848,
-0.0472980849,
-0.0329456702,
0.0091079259,
-0.0063516642,
-0.0058393651,
0.0115941167,
0.0334097445,
-0.0251316503,
-0.0780550987,
-0.0464128889,
0.0084211193,
0.0025656954,
0.0365880355,
-0.0285699256,
-0.0601035655,
-0.0272772852,
-0.0163794197,
0.0191752501,
0.0243731756,
0.0087007694,
-0.010552356,
-0.0286626276,
-0.0651755854,
-0.0171649326,
-0.00253006,
-0.0781895295,
0.0262350477,
-0.0388250872,
0.0086558741,
0.0171812382,
-0.0276319664,
-0.0450119823,
0.0815683156,
-0.0514722541,
-0.0701875836,
-0.0195719916,
-0.0648847669,
0.0458601862,
-0.003655558,
0.0008327023,
-0.0433241725,
-0.0346875675,
0.085093841,
-0.004786029,
-0.0096574677,
0.0113098472,
2.706e-7,
-0.0040196255,
0.0362225249,
-0.0148964226,
0.0177399684,
0.0272713173,
-0.0175920017,
-0.0161529724,
0.0217923317,
-0.0082106963,
-0.0280472431,
0.0028748275,
0.0312010478,
-0.000303218,
0.0117614614,
-0.0344680324,
0.0027054995,
-0.0375408791,
0.018788293,
-0.0461247377,
0.0191546604,
-0.0288202222,
0.0400029756,
0.003534832,
-0.0046692314,
-0.0127184018,
-0.026878342,
0.0561060719,
-0.0566661246,
0.0478695594,
0.0394354276,
-0.0054313676,
0.0257526562,
0.0039829356,
0.046961166,
0.0104983393,
-0.0053422735,
0.0488524325,
-0.0423472971,
-0.0001433703,
0.0419770293,
-0.0149881737,
-0.0094047273,
-0.0135721778,
-0.0374448039,
0.0316486694,
-0.001098251,
-0.0183435325,
0.051912684,
0.0204345211,
0.02025746,
0.0817073807,
0.0015277807,
-0.0242373254,
0.0326880813,
0.0097224806,
0.0412067883,
0.0003213138,
-0.0091804033,
0.0177795216,
0.0226846989,
-0.0217338782,
-0.0488511436,
-0.0049157562,
-0.0788737983,
-0.0016644109,
-0.0072672563,
-0.0158389229,
1.558417834e-34,
-0.0263581928,
0.0344382077,
0.0028617638,
-0.0070718057,
0.0171743315,
-0.0653234497,
0.0115695857,
0.0290348176,
0.0100782048,
0.0014324669,
-0.0098475451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10174v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10174v1 | JWSign: A Highly Multilingual Corpus of Bible Translations for more Diversity in Sign Language Processing | 2023-11-16T20:02:44 | 2023-11-16T20:02:44 | Shester Gueuwou, Sophie Siake, Colin Leong, Mathias Müller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Advancements in sign language processing have been hindered by a lack of
sufficient data, impeding progress in recognition, translation, and production
tasks. The absence of comprehensive sign language datasets across the world's
sign languages has widened the gap in this field, resulting in a few sign
languages being studied more than others, making this research area extremely
skewed mostly towards sign languages from high-income countries. In this work
we introduce a new large and highly multilingual dataset for sign language
translation: JWSign. The dataset consists of 2,530 hours of Bible translations
in 98 sign languages, featuring more than 1,500 individual signers. On this
dataset, we report neural machine translation experiments. Apart from bilingual
baseline systems, we also train multilingual systems, including some that take
into account the typological relatedness of signed or spoken languages. Our
experiments highlight that multilingual systems are superior to bilingual
baselines, and that in higher-resource scenarios, clustering language pairs
that are related improves translation quality. | [
-0.0323261023,
0.0475004986,
-0.0328764319,
0.0516670309,
-0.0151779894,
0.0411402546,
0.0679357871,
0.0023350196,
0.0479538143,
0.018302748,
-0.0305545349,
-0.0562591441,
0.0619241819,
-0.0381577834,
0.0403529219,
-0.0698310733,
0.0206666924,
-0.0161918104,
-0.0531397909,
-0.004666172,
-0.0162406005,
0.025628604,
-0.0007326085,
0.0284805149,
-0.0326435678,
-0.0281479321,
-0.0020255309,
0.042945426,
0.028563885,
-0.0121996487,
-0.0845019221,
0.0095880385,
0.0254811831,
0.0666303635,
0.0000018469,
-0.0281332936,
0.0448578335,
-0.0174627341,
0.0209354386,
0.0215173904,
0.0397907048,
-0.1181994304,
-0.0248774514,
-0.0080521638,
-0.0276585072,
-0.0685003027,
0.0264360365,
0.0647658333,
-0.0047334419,
0.030042842,
-0.0104345027,
-0.0017704378,
0.0186553542,
-0.0395936407,
0.0006592917,
0.049884513,
-0.0085697602,
-0.0214819014,
-0.0306250229,
-0.0053823269,
-0.0190938096,
0.0904337838,
0.0317641608,
-0.0164228659,
-0.100003086,
-0.0144182574,
-0.0518574528,
0.0029895136,
0.0068083024,
0.0246467907,
-0.0456262417,
0.0003179733,
0.0122503964,
-0.0306122229,
-0.0008723764,
0.0103146685,
-0.0244215466,
0.0377500504,
-0.0071976883,
-0.0201601423,
-0.0145615516,
0.0199192446,
0.0374354795,
-0.0520364605,
0.0044466089,
0.0060441536,
0.0410270728,
-0.0271504968,
0.0060769822,
0.0246287268,
-0.0043030423,
-0.0299242996,
0.0292908084,
-0.0285449363,
0.0268601496,
-0.0012068716,
-0.0334210992,
-0.0103017222,
-0.033903446,
-0.0614396334,
-0.0128137264,
0.0518492237,
-0.0355704799,
0.0412098952,
0.0312185846,
0.0291143768,
-0.0015070575,
0.0661785454,
-0.0395985283,
0.0542622544,
0.0066700294,
0.0317544676,
-0.0291126426,
-0.0626544803,
-0.0223597419,
0.0192853808,
-0.0070195813,
-0.0091819586,
0.0574334823,
-0.0243696626,
0.0229398869,
-0.0002290898,
-0.0039721364,
-0.0145496279,
0.0448853932,
0.039073091,
-0.0257315971,
0.0231111981,
-0.0440800525,
-0.0710436478,
0.0254803859,
0.0354297534,
-0.0326515511,
-0.0130938934,
0.021302497,
0.0802886635,
-0.0040689008,
-0.0071344026,
-0.0383875333,
0.0056755943,
-0.0280493516,
-0.0091891363,
-0.0082235038,
-0.0265851859,
0.0912194327,
0.0065136701,
0.010064424,
-0.064974159,
-0.0164943915,
-0.0018818289,
-0.0078681512,
0.0308094118,
0.0331388488,
0.0110623883,
0.0509324782,
-0.0309243798,
-0.0350023732,
0.0682608485,
0.0476806983,
0.0105025461,
0.053208679,
-0.0042515974,
-0.0584068596,
0.0714013278,
-0.0218528453,
0.031618651,
-0.0181670878,
-0.0434634201,
0.0159594212,
0.0399937183,
-0.0355572924,
0.0311726816,
-0.0214437954,
-0.0059140902,
0.0450816229,
0.098965086,
0.0441653468,
0.0106211407,
0.0270766076,
0.0169655923,
0.0376377739,
-0.0505034849,
-0.0072363084,
-0.0017117849,
0.0800770968,
-0.0252087172,
-0.0262898579,
0.0599438883,
-0.0247502979,
-0.0067760581,
0.0220947638,
-0.0293786097,
0.0016069161,
-0.0299981665,
0.0158457905,
0.0202168785,
-0.0185218118,
-0.0065838979,
0.0048699966,
-0.0560276136,
0.031022517,
0.0368829183,
-0.0456011556,
0.0210637823,
0.0137804542,
0.0171971377,
0.0045597912,
-0.0093151489,
-0.0031072816,
0.0709263235,
-0.0100053241,
0.0445731804,
0.0661354139,
-0.0529739372,
-0.0028677983,
0.0587922968,
-0.0035164752,
0.0299083889,
-0.0489647463,
0.0569441617,
0.0381409489,
-0.0292657688,
-0.0264923498,
0.0663029924,
-0.0116168885,
-0.0165783037,
0.0415153801,
0.0006323621,
0.0222347099,
0.0241120514,
-0.0054535344,
-0.0453613624,
0.015475546,
-0.0612194762,
-0.0009372439,
0.0774339736,
-0.0664523467,
-0.0413577333,
0.0299501196,
-0.0716368482,
-0.0168632455,
0.0112535898,
0.0057767159,
-0.0529029891,
0.0382505208,
-0.0134792384,
0.0135579789,
-0.0137796085,
0.0167213269,
-0.0068734633,
0.0054076859,
-0.0302665196,
0.0167339426,
0.0030126486,
0.0014869062,
-0.0496176258,
-0.0736015737,
0.0381697863,
-0.0101886634,
-0.0149756223,
0.0098259617,
-0.0222011488,
0.0341134332,
0.0154690444,
0.0164746586,
0.0180302747,
-0.0196362268,
-0.0625677556,
0.0184169859,
-0.0092054466,
0.0277409498,
-0.0019555415,
0.0047297603,
0.0226770062,
-0.0117700538,
-0.0155249089,
-0.0059093335,
0.0286005847,
-0.0498406887,
-0.0329896472,
-0.0329527222,
0.008032647,
-0.0081777479,
-0.0266751479,
-0.0136154983,
0.0505505316,
0.0537906215,
-0.044106327,
-0.0554284491,
-0.0373728946,
0.0105716093,
0.0181169305,
0.0064487983,
-0.0155580677,
0.0310638659,
0.0115609029,
-0.0428942777,
-0.0273606889,
-0.0231529605,
-0.0313236564,
-0.0235332288,
0.0178142656,
-0.0213802699,
-0.0076776552,
0.0113916844,
0.0179862175,
-0.0561441034,
-0.031011261,
-0.000568248,
0.0441756286,
0.0585168488,
-0.0138779897,
-0.0676996112,
-0.0470593162,
-0.0377886966,
-0.0355848707,
0.0053220941,
-0.0039587971,
-0.014212898,
-0.0026038967,
-0.036521133,
-0.0554646738,
0.0179201178,
-0.0225523915,
-0.042442143,
0.0044857035,
0.0420845821,
-0.0483775102,
0.0240769442,
-0.000708863,
0.0234617461,
-0.0758722574,
-0.0334502198,
-0.0459636338,
0.0654779002,
-0.0054831891,
0.0022596188,
0.05499788,
-0.014739546,
-0.0293539092,
-0.0327015296,
-0.0025329278,
-0.0036511563,
0.01572988,
-0.0153904315,
-0.0225448888,
0.0622401945,
-0.0170652997,
-0.0472408496,
-0.0387216248,
0.0143631762,
0.0523115583,
0.0322703645,
-0.0017621613,
-0.0230900068,
-0.0289064553,
-0.0713427216,
-0.0045226458,
0.0117116561,
-0.0875557736,
-0.0082423314,
-0.0037449724,
-0.0493955314,
0.0072819488,
-0.0462879203,
-0.0054656081,
0.0357411392,
0.0334533565,
-0.0271164589,
-0.0150161032,
0.0465750508,
-0.0090298466,
0.0470861346,
0.0652864948,
0.0252927039,
-0.0815496668,
0.0317837968,
-0.0369261429,
-0.0158061106,
-0.0256641358,
0.0226380564,
-0.0827444345,
-0.0353210792,
-0.009973418,
0.0387996584,
0.0769967809,
-0.0022618922,
0.0006682384,
-0.006760587,
-0.0195100345,
0.0498010293,
-0.0957607552,
-0.0282879453,
0.0390731581,
-0.0159745496,
-0.0011477598,
0.0416825265,
0.0247628633,
0.0070871408,
-0.0232490301,
-0.0033308016,
0.0399503931,
-0.080346927,
-0.0041401437,
-0.0224532019,
0.022919368,
0.0132936276,
0.0304925106,
-0.0496349335,
-0.0308131762,
0.002616053,
0.0147887617,
0.022364594,
0.0025444948,
0.022292912,
0.0519588552,
-0.0446640402,
-0.0312105436,
0.0228699818,
-0.0844202936,
0.0113515658,
0.069886677,
0.0282781087,
-0.031709373,
0.0266091581,
0.0435375348,
-0.0062112343,
-0.0249281675,
0.0163106341,
-0.0007528954,
-0.0559881814,
0.0231266357,
-0.0375778116,
0.0149221849,
0.0282798,
-0.0611334108,
0.0050396062,
-0.0284296796,
-0.0477367006,
-0.0785071477,
-0.0180005822,
-0.0037922361,
0.0384742431,
0.062807247,
-0.0210266542,
0.0828365907,
-0.0222079568,
-0.0358084366,
0.0515893474,
0.001411888,
0.0627024323,
-0.054074809,
-0.0094378442,
-0.0272846613,
-0.0357762501,
-0.0005879928,
0.0189343989,
-0.0717164129,
-0.0708023235,
0.0222940408,
0.0166768655,
0.014849606,
0.0130458279,
-0.0064380988,
-0.040534392,
-0.0585799105,
0.0606237724,
-0.0146009997,
0.0260682944,
0.0177739393,
-0.0154085495,
-0.0102053843,
0.0209163781,
0.0284218751,
0.0175599661,
0.0074925087,
-0.0213099718,
-0.0795814618,
-0.0261112135,
-0.0608929768,
-0.0084180133,
-0.0317185447,
-0.0237762313,
-0.0310591422,
-0.0578274243,
0.0258460529,
-0.0439967923,
0.020322632,
-0.0418769009,
0.0182770137,
0.0307825115,
0.000999147,
0.0148170413,
0.0129244672,
0.0034981698,
-0.0209398679,
0.0017165306,
0.0733898729,
0.034212172,
0.062223658,
-0.037680354,
0.0390418954,
0.0082138553,
0.0536209643,
-0.016673781,
0.0484403446,
-0.0319498032,
0.0274935644,
-0.0003729934,
0.0229138341,
0.023839239,
-0.0020308928,
0.0272363611,
-0.0940615684,
-0.0163902193,
-0.0112482151,
-0.0039400095,
0.0481302962,
0.0868220031,
0.0215019751,
-0.0049638208,
-0.0074347463,
0.0287389159,
0.0077586952,
0.0106879538,
-0.0278832484,
-0.0237349086,
-0.0059272004,
0.0067604324,
0.0053354958,
-0.0896332934,
-0.0184163619,
0.0066411537,
0.0087918518,
-0.0332397521,
0.002585391,
0.0273442138,
-0.041867692,
-0.0166486818,
0.030492302,
-0.0311646517,
-0.0141730169,
0.0058023375,
0.0305660963,
-0.0083193583,
0.0226337351,
0.009503019,
0.0147766368,
-0.021474855,
-0.0054884604,
-0.0187252853,
-0.0185406636,
-0.0194507129,
-0.0495666601,
-0.0398201831,
-4.922595652e-33,
-0.030769119,
0.0189706832,
-0.0160413682,
-0.0426437445,
-0.0169981755,
0.020027563,
-0.0114320535,
0.0159584675,
-0.0312506743,
0.0345172547,
0.0157275256,
-0.0079169581,
0.0109175127,
0.0266831666,
0.0469423011,
0.0134442952,
0.0329569541,
0.0191477407,
-0.0212923121,
0.0236631222,
0.0568179302,
-0.0008296473,
0.1111892983,
-0.1146550253,
0.0181766264,
-0.0280034896,
-0.004964835,
-0.0249919482,
0.0183012318,
0.0232672486,
-0.0266471617,
0.0061146552,
-0.0095063346,
0.0109902788,
-0.0025171773,
0.0322662666,
-0.0304893851,
-0.0252042972,
0.010570881,
0.0861223042,
-0.0498752929,
0.0218329318,
0.0200462155,
-0.0241117813,
-0.0366398171,
0.0186300948,
0.0351785086,
-0.0086851222,
-0.0395171866,
-0.0461493656,
-0.030038964,
0.0476686917,
-0.0234304909,
-0.0295966975,
-0.0121787647,
0.0242771842,
-0.0638549328,
-0.0064681452,
-0.0711382627,
-0.0203076061,
-0.017022755,
0.023671167,
0.0199321639,
-0.0233906247,
-0.0019336422,
0.0013628853,
0.039049983,
-0.0058162082,
0.0448930264,
0.0081375996,
0.0650121048,
-0.0200595558,
0.0528046079,
0.0905852988,
0.0339354202,
-0.0142578892,
-0.0137771573,
0.0249107778,
0.0755580515,
0.0105049526,
0.0007235082,
-0.0009266997,
-0.0148660978,
0.0185858235,
-0.0720840693,
-0.073419556,
0.011900017,
-0.0080770152,
0.0179862846,
0.0141552873,
0.0230099633,
0.0149303311,
0.0597827397,
-0.0257089883,
-0.0221247952,
0.0131748589,
-0.0101510128,
0.0096619921,
0.0026617807,
0.0035913812,
-0.0290640071,
-0.0582894832,
0.0456575975,
-0.0050616013,
0.0553553924,
-0.0396723375,
0.0440543592,
-0.0104721012,
-0.0600745305,
0.0373293087,
0.0013115691,
0.0303526875,
0.0258295108,
-0.0139730899,
0.0298351105,
-0.0333485045,
-0.002366577,
0.0528097525,
0.0339593925,
-0.056739524,
0.011994997,
0.0291040894,
0.0163229201,
0.0507213548,
-0.0547535531,
0.0225063656,
0.0105754323,
-0.0327146091,
0.0919534639,
-0.0711417571,
0.0031887821,
0.0197077617,
2.489e-7,
0.0542951711,
0.0180196576,
0.003501618,
0.0383616015,
0.028896952,
0.0360678695,
0.0064689978,
0.010613679,
-0.0053058253,
0.0526601784,
-0.02967388,
-0.0023047056,
0.1029723585,
0.0136162071,
-0.0354069099,
0.0057349931,
-0.0370264351,
0.0249532741,
-0.0562065989,
0.0022219627,
0.031059945,
0.104189299,
-0.0167842675,
-0.0211791769,
-0.0012679538,
-0.0497699231,
0.0583544597,
-0.0320700929,
0.0148123736,
-0.0244820993,
0.0458108149,
-0.0351512544,
-0.0295213182,
0.0165369678,
-0.0035554075,
0.0116232857,
0.0145170642,
-0.0011406061,
-0.0236591306,
0.0373584963,
0.0323411673,
-0.0123241944,
-0.065096125,
-0.0119328648,
0.0541941188,
-0.0534465723,
0.0074772658,
-0.0022009322,
-0.0010044085,
0.0347083658,
0.0353820734,
0.0124856122,
-0.0096315229,
0.0393475443,
0.0674393922,
-0.0581907406,
-0.0018204752,
-0.0315743797,
-0.0103218826,
0.0093579106,
-0.0068440996,
0.0194789674,
0.0049400288,
0.0140574928,
-0.0182483997,
-0.0169139355,
-0.0192970261,
1.743120139e-34,
0.0390303209,
-0.0409730338,
0.0467064567,
-0.0128906388,
-0.0047230674,
-0.0595850348,
0.0313412137,
-0.0126702897,
-0.0265380275,
0.0022588407,
0.0061107012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10085v1 | A Computationally Efficient Sparsified Online Newton Method | 2023-11-16T18:44:22 | 2023-11-16T18:44:22 | Fnu Devvrit, Sai Surya Duvvuri, Rohan Anil, Vineet Gupta, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Inderjit Dhillon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, math.OC | Second-order methods hold significant promise for enhancing the convergence
of deep neural network training; however, their large memory and computational
demands have limited their practicality. Thus there is a need for scalable
second-order methods that can efficiently train large models. In this paper, we
introduce the Sparsified Online Newton (SONew) method, a memory-efficient
second-order algorithm that yields a sparsified yet effective preconditioner.
The algorithm emerges from a novel use of the LogDet matrix divergence measure;
we combine it with sparsity constraints to minimize regret in the online convex
optimization framework. Empirically, we test our method on large scale
benchmarks of up to 1B parameters. We achieve up to 30% faster convergence,
3.4% relative improvement in validation performance, and 80% relative
improvement in training loss, in comparison to memory efficient optimizers
including first order methods. Powering the method is a surprising fact --
imposing structured sparsity patterns, like tridiagonal and banded structure,
requires little to no overhead, making it as efficient and parallelizable as
first-order methods. In wall-clock time, tridiagonal SONew is only about 3%
slower per step than first-order methods but gives overall gains due to much
faster convergence. In contrast, one of the state-of-the-art (SOTA)
memory-intensive second-order methods, Shampoo, is unable to scale to large
benchmarks. Additionally, while Shampoo necessitates significant engineering
efforts to scale to large benchmarks, SONew offers a more straightforward
implementation, increasing its practical appeal. SONew code is available at:
https://github.com/devvrit/SONew | [
-0.0176002979,
0.1136086956,
0.0204297639,
0.0062775407,
0.0139784832,
-0.0016467867,
-0.0045462702,
-0.0047698221,
-0.0061064139,
0.023304997,
-0.0078434218,
-0.0806131586,
0.0010416874,
-0.0130750416,
0.0025423402,
0.0008074645,
-0.0113216322,
-0.0020743022,
-0.0184269827,
-0.0318341516,
0.0321185924,
0.0057613333,
-0.0270854607,
-0.0259149689,
-0.0701864734,
-0.0348784626,
-0.0292179361,
0.0507282652,
0.0399340242,
-0.0364594571,
0.0362374596,
0.0203390066,
0.0384927094,
0.0185463764,
0.0000025414,
-0.018369643,
0.0234386809,
0.0146890208,
0.0154149923,
0.0630954653,
-0.0544412509,
-0.0083076404,
0.0336268991,
0.0026122506,
0.0091138594,
-0.0705553442,
0.0486293584,
0.0466105081,
0.0256042406,
0.0661544278,
-0.0043002614,
-0.0229201391,
0.077152878,
-0.0500230864,
-0.0462993458,
-0.0249995012,
-0.0024770147,
-0.0466337875,
-0.0577656887,
-0.0079745147,
0.0493291095,
0.0110015878,
0.0353244133,
0.0300364438,
0.0494517088,
0.0022208211,
-0.0070811165,
-0.0360511392,
-0.0386373997,
0.038757395,
-0.0434576608,
0.007286632,
-0.0111699151,
-0.0308928527,
-0.0425861701,
-0.0337715708,
-0.0010162888,
0.0026927975,
-0.0236745607,
0.0372936875,
-0.0645080358,
-0.0381054319,
0.0241775885,
0.0307627227,
-0.0168410502,
0.0211349726,
0.0041983146,
0.0039430787,
0.0396880843,
0.0155153479,
-0.0725496709,
0.0083254827,
0.0332491137,
0.0062345825,
-0.0315045267,
-0.0476181209,
-0.0075062644,
-0.0007801697,
-0.0396974199,
0.0187960453,
0.056938801,
-0.0215916988,
0.0156649221,
0.0495833196,
-0.0427654013,
0.0075623626,
-0.0207975246,
0.0011260204,
-0.0112484246,
0.0336337201,
-0.02396998,
0.0184106659,
-0.0300115198,
0.0483958758,
0.0229404271,
-0.0148688089,
-0.0236304756,
-0.0212059896,
-0.0431861244,
-0.0222668368,
0.0028213609,
0.0722195879,
0.0227039177,
-0.0113142487,
-0.011989031,
0.0179149099,
-0.0038056604,
0.0245227627,
0.0212878473,
-0.0340347104,
-0.0346436128,
0.0245200433,
0.0124453828,
0.0317050815,
0.0385015458,
-0.0051168911,
-0.011860434,
-0.0304284636,
-0.0112822177,
0.0129204858,
0.0281324014,
-0.0301755592,
0.0388845131,
-0.0502621979,
0.0158619117,
-0.0329434425,
0.0322107077,
-0.0434914753,
0.0309872851,
-0.0334382579,
-0.0218970254,
0.0410578996,
-0.0317780748,
-0.0200339071,
0.0073192571,
0.0155275278,
0.0354757383,
0.0832702219,
-0.0134950951,
0.0614809282,
-0.0263691582,
0.0079440251,
-0.0539263971,
-0.0027408327,
0.0297892131,
0.0100295329,
-0.0226448942,
0.000317977,
-0.0555779077,
0.0675516129,
0.021915637,
0.0302839577,
-0.0421389155,
-0.0203156192,
0.0441232547,
0.0274042506,
0.0373656005,
0.0401987359,
0.0139753046,
-0.0203331597,
0.0312106833,
-0.0594491325,
-0.0066725486,
0.0126986373,
-0.0182676651,
-0.0039715823,
0.0064237528,
0.0464442074,
-0.0568508804,
-0.0326127782,
0.0128205018,
-0.004255583,
-0.0250889473,
0.0609883554,
-0.0111373579,
-0.0266252942,
-0.0622631609,
0.0410075784,
0.0255932603,
-0.0082570985,
-0.0247704256,
-0.0223666988,
-0.0135542788,
0.0142221395,
-0.0115954205,
-0.0525571965,
-0.0660893768,
-0.0131057911,
0.0594666041,
-0.012949422,
-0.0173500925,
0.0277774855,
0.059387181,
-0.0380771011,
-0.0053207129,
0.0191230327,
-0.0051080463,
0.0451467261,
0.0493298955,
0.0342807472,
0.0185922626,
0.0618685037,
0.0082342597,
0.0045033535,
-0.0113580339,
-0.0162174813,
0.0767508298,
0.0257235449,
0.0134275332,
-0.0120887505,
-0.0168481693,
-0.0354546048,
0.0281809773,
-0.048638586,
-0.0026963563,
-0.0615309998,
-0.0504400283,
-0.0125227496,
0.0338210426,
-0.0390202515,
0.0088832946,
0.1138001457,
-0.0118586868,
-0.024238348,
-0.013476707,
0.0156209776,
0.0422692746,
-0.0486595742,
-0.0269606672,
0.0125805978,
0.0545192212,
-0.0142203271,
-0.021311868,
-0.0624739155,
0.0045543625,
-0.0203395598,
0.0274946839,
-0.034122359,
-0.0073921834,
-0.0629627481,
-0.0368977897,
-0.0263610184,
0.0474811271,
0.0153438095,
0.0062561398,
0.0432795882,
0.0163519587,
-0.0767945722,
0.0323046632,
-0.0631999373,
-0.0271761529,
0.0180297717,
-0.0087477649,
0.0136694787,
0.0208553933,
0.0083137872,
0.1116591766,
-0.0609712414,
0.0115123689,
-0.009380253,
-0.024711119,
-0.0061365291,
-0.0079616634,
-0.0638433173,
0.0388475806,
0.0029697116,
-0.0295734722,
0.0495921373,
-0.018977372,
0.0755609423,
-0.0476931222,
0.0140855489,
-0.00872787,
0.005951901,
0.0036265894,
-0.0858950093,
-0.042584639,
0.0412927382,
0.0202339385,
0.026029462,
0.0047247619,
0.0601640642,
0.006551093,
0.0079366146,
-0.0107733794,
-0.0018166717,
0.023581773,
0.0208166707,
0.0112683,
0.0366124921,
-0.0498936474,
0.0046732589,
-0.0064837066,
-0.0331126489,
0.028458653,
-0.0501959622,
-0.050800439,
0.0297677238,
-0.0014785577,
-0.0109686628,
0.0167413428,
-0.0304431431,
0.0543556921,
0.0075548966,
0.0019090789,
0.0046097315,
-0.0364785492,
-0.0304787885,
-0.0157831721,
0.0214225519,
-0.0015552109,
-0.0195550043,
-0.0412501171,
0.0183606911,
-0.0039916472,
0.0441650413,
0.0018479816,
0.0203424245,
0.0164052919,
-0.0038687231,
-0.0339229666,
-0.0505391285,
-0.0070210197,
-0.0462478586,
-0.0009737397,
0.0247181058,
0.0279779788,
-0.031563513,
0.0084512131,
-0.0212562867,
-0.0328782573,
0.0359700769,
0.0008585518,
-0.0251986701,
-0.0196792092,
0.0691724867,
0.0409311019,
0.0578172989,
0.0193318836,
-0.0125555871,
0.0281694662,
0.0118380617,
0.0229960401,
-0.0029705528,
-0.0859381258,
0.0086689983,
0.0536968522,
0.0193520468,
0.0017867568,
0.0321858265,
0.0215769466,
-0.0086082742,
-0.0009188951,
0.0339792632,
-0.0113118282,
-0.0751197413,
-0.0113475723,
0.0105537986,
0.0985132605,
0.0293482654,
-0.0226531494,
-0.0406843424,
-0.0588693917,
-0.0121114729,
-0.002569875,
0.035281159,
-0.017322585,
0.0082123419,
-0.0226946473,
-0.0062048519,
-0.027379306,
-0.0272243042,
0.0120318513,
-0.0600549094,
-0.0128539111,
-0.0482880846,
-0.0200126916,
-0.0016271475,
-0.027564859,
-0.0398684852,
0.0083120447,
-0.0313056223,
-0.0023745354,
-0.0042813658,
-0.0505021773,
-0.0418905579,
0.0049943714,
-0.0270604491,
-0.0243143626,
-0.0065325047,
0.030711107,
0.018029727,
0.0017374118,
-0.0198940318,
-0.0247674268,
0.0236694608,
-0.0213202145,
-0.0381891094,
0.0433482863,
-0.0349856019,
0.0333825275,
0.0166901033,
0.0588315129,
0.0513870306,
0.0118082417,
-0.0028481726,
-0.0149818119,
0.0388646349,
-0.0061118538,
-0.0073477258,
-0.0369337425,
-0.0520626158,
-0.0026193622,
0.015236631,
0.0253560487,
-0.01414226,
-0.0499524213,
0.0486500934,
-0.0375730619,
-0.0092892051,
0.019211119,
-0.0423829667,
0.0358858854,
-0.0370841399,
-0.0717499331,
0.0461079106,
0.0337496363,
-0.0735236034,
0.0368744358,
0.0117330374,
0.0067179152,
-0.0380093232,
0.0453768596,
0.0493831858,
0.0065362584,
0.0354308449,
0.0427858643,
-0.120909214,
-0.0353622101,
-0.0270532407,
0.0121734254,
-0.0111458907,
0.043574661,
0.0060631344,
-0.0008565374,
0.0362015888,
0.0654055774,
-0.0090567702,
0.0336717591,
0.0830488205,
-0.0654248595,
0.0210550353,
0.0454147868,
-0.0064219241,
0.0253488235,
0.0183158051,
0.0141182421,
-0.0023001132,
-0.016286524,
-0.0167832896,
0.0168531295,
0.0697980821,
0.0047829859,
-0.0492090657,
-0.0123310415,
0.0550471209,
0.0398364142,
0.0163914431,
-0.0389921293,
-0.01068292,
0.0237357765,
-0.00483899,
-0.0235748552,
0.0308274291,
0.126701653,
0.0012402318,
-0.0011530539,
-0.002502125,
-0.0248346217,
0.0253544673,
0.0252001937,
0.0084771132,
-0.020195948,
0.0576775149,
0.0180725101,
0.0052881176,
-0.0319309533,
0.0452763811,
-0.0326408036,
0.0128473705,
-0.0366501473,
-0.0094640274,
-0.038429454,
-0.1022355258,
-0.0399651788,
-0.0302834343,
0.0777551979,
-0.034742102,
0.0342022628,
-0.0093117096,
-0.0183387995,
-0.021266602,
0.0366454609,
-0.0602183677,
0.0081533715,
-0.0096576884,
0.0175824463,
0.0175981577,
0.0528717265,
0.0480696447,
0.0229129419,
-0.0046182894,
0.033001624,
0.0087949326,
-0.0242721289,
-0.0267710369,
0.0641515106,
0.0683807582,
-0.0021115951,
-0.0387342907,
0.0636375919,
0.0069376831,
0.0176260415,
-0.034664575,
0.0164490584,
-0.0086483732,
0.0721043646,
0.0164911803,
-0.0261794515,
0.0186522361,
-0.0139435576,
-0.0039643343,
0.0187894609,
-0.0212941989,
-0.0086560287,
-6.917787928e-33,
0.0239780284,
0.0274536423,
-0.0421796702,
-0.005874218,
-0.0150911789,
0.0458708033,
0.0058787381,
0.0114588281,
-0.0181478653,
0.0221312847,
-0.0078957956,
0.0179117061,
-0.010327992,
0.0346467532,
-0.0064524575,
-0.0571310297,
0.0453943163,
0.0139261056,
0.0178273991,
0.0303721949,
0.0081342747,
0.0221595783,
-0.0102482783,
0.003214397,
-0.096612677,
-0.0152904838,
-0.0285341907,
-0.0194250233,
-0.0026051111,
0.0092441263,
-0.0196823236,
0.0284607895,
-0.0129195796,
-0.0319338441,
0.0226184987,
-0.0534642152,
-0.076222688,
-0.0072925841,
-0.0358693153,
0.0088646337,
-0.031002447,
0.0172175802,
0.047142107,
0.0322715268,
-0.0291457083,
-0.0730560943,
0.0070606088,
0.0474594943,
-0.0715190694,
-0.0441918224,
-0.0374169499,
0.0043328516,
-0.0356708802,
-0.0402006507,
0.0241133049,
-0.0294369739,
-0.0349376127,
-0.0212562848,
-0.0648248196,
-0.0064757215,
-0.010605827,
0.0258857142,
-0.0069959615,
0.0248719696,
0.0127583053,
0.0177038442,
0.0596437342,
0.0125589594,
-0.023509901,
0.0069305273,
0.0052379132,
0.0261128861,
0.0170126632,
-0.0089194234,
0.0906909257,
-0.0399589427,
-0.130456388,
-0.0218483377,
-0.061078012,
0.0386924148,
-0.0082046576,
-0.0047476604,
0.0002995517,
-0.0093707424,
0.0234392416,
0.0005345967,
-0.0323904604,
0.0027103114,
-0.0130953258,
0.0496099032,
-0.0398778729,
0.0161805097,
-0.0052424246,
-0.0182275027,
0.0364173055,
0.0240157787,
0.0376620479,
0.0351815782,
0.0157613233,
0.0084379511,
-0.047819186,
-0.0212415215,
-0.0545168668,
-0.0219176672,
0.0496922322,
0.0040036594,
0.0422159731,
0.0392093956,
-0.0326329283,
-0.0547012873,
-0.0127461776,
0.0373013504,
0.0233993698,
0.0424787477,
0.06968835,
-0.0501680747,
0.0306078643,
0.1032143682,
-0.0271315295,
0.0037101924,
-0.0668657944,
-0.0422611013,
0.0166495815,
0.0130841089,
0.0161957983,
0.0186031777,
-0.0447596982,
-0.0608667806,
-0.0309010111,
-0.0922367349,
-0.0253207833,
-0.0205669925,
3.091e-7,
-0.0740920156,
0.0321897641,
-0.0320664085,
-0.0478342026,
-0.0002785996,
-0.0200303998,
0.0017365437,
0.0161166675,
-0.0526712574,
-0.021272989,
0.0567997321,
0.0465358272,
0.0591059513,
0.0152097372,
-0.0628113896,
-0.0138780726,
-0.0497237779,
0.0263414327,
-0.0286328774,
-0.0294119585,
-0.0312040057,
0.0664993599,
-0.0104285842,
-0.031218715,
0.0532573089,
0.0267952029,
0.0500963442,
0.0071023433,
0.0335924849,
-0.0148097351,
0.0737217888,
-0.0031765618,
-0.0306380279,
-0.044672925,
-0.0101811169,
0.0157160982,
0.0128753008,
0.0626063049,
-0.001589185,
-0.0262276419,
0.0088434014,
0.0540184453,
0.029261468,
-0.0020039796,
0.074992992,
0.0633895919,
0.013701885,
-0.0611842349,
0.0172684342,
-0.0225305557,
0.0771231428,
-0.0497317687,
0.0252438076,
-0.0269719604,
-0.0147445919,
-0.0251993369,
-0.0412072241,
-0.0637821034,
0.0490227751,
0.0881261826,
-0.0158281885,
-0.0128880031,
-0.064989008,
-0.0051751835,
0.07053262,
0.0050248792,
-0.0030605465,
2.65034946e-34,
0.0464753471,
-0.0171607118,
0.0213015694,
0.0289888028,
0.0123809613,
-0.0270182863,
-0.0258038454,
-0.0117165633,
0.0126350578,
-0.0408000574,
-0.0108502004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10785v1 | Text Sanitization Beyond Specific Domains: Zero-Shot Redaction & Substitution with Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T18:42:37 | 2023-11-16T18:42:37 | Federico Albanese, Daniel Ciolek, Nicolas D'Ippolito | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In the context of information systems, text sanitization techniques are used
to identify and remove sensitive data to comply with security and regulatory
requirements. Even though many methods for privacy preservation have been
proposed, most of them are focused on the detection of entities from specific
domains (e.g., credit card numbers, social security numbers), lacking
generality and requiring customization for each desirable domain. Moreover,
removing words is, in general, a drastic measure, as it can degrade text
coherence and contextual information. Less severe measures include substituting
a word for a safe alternative, yet it can be challenging to automatically find
meaningful substitutions. We present a zero-shot text sanitization technique
that detects and substitutes potentially sensitive information using Large
Language Models. Our evaluation shows that our method excels at protecting
privacy while maintaining text coherence and contextual information, preserving
data utility for downstream tasks. | [
0.034262456,
0.0780401453,
0.0036717763,
0.027233541,
-0.0409472473,
-0.0242720898,
0.0618617274,
0.0414414145,
0.0163343865,
-0.0524223335,
0.0164843202,
-0.0181787834,
0.003883794,
0.032043118,
-0.0033753689,
0.0018452897,
0.0352377072,
0.0223347265,
0.0212197565,
0.0035715557,
-0.0357666351,
-0.0126829688,
0.0228673853,
0.0282271747,
0.0177934375,
-0.011344295,
0.0216758512,
0.0022416522,
0.0208941195,
-0.0169298649,
-0.0152205732,
0.0379628651,
-0.0122205,
0.0736269802,
0.0000019738,
-0.0418474972,
-0.0614217184,
0.0386325195,
-0.0446136072,
0.0180577245,
0.0306288749,
-0.0462077335,
-0.0680823699,
-0.0029739328,
0.0107223243,
0.0147557156,
0.0437509865,
0.0548303686,
0.0800465941,
0.0662751794,
-0.0362082832,
-0.001975798,
-0.0145796007,
0.0002870617,
0.0188288148,
-0.0168059934,
0.0833477452,
-0.0224419516,
-0.0008587678,
0.0494969301,
-0.0022011956,
0.0613272637,
-0.0161763877,
-0.0387173817,
-0.0053444221,
0.003136147,
-0.0220242105,
-0.0033934584,
0.0185960792,
0.0325566716,
-0.0485065468,
-0.0321152285,
0.0452436246,
0.0063168225,
-0.0013441342,
-0.0046174773,
0.0148505978,
0.040078938,
-0.0022973535,
0.0102965059,
-0.0323077813,
-0.0173457935,
0.0453842171,
0.0051919618,
0.0103950063,
0.0400401577,
0.03256879,
-0.0530239381,
-0.0580957942,
-0.0642442256,
-0.0210187696,
-0.0868229792,
0.0666771606,
-0.0142890848,
0.0390308723,
0.0242945682,
-0.1107155234,
-0.074311845,
0.0143351853,
-0.0433162525,
-0.0029748674,
0.02233053,
0.0289562438,
0.0505988635,
-0.0152731435,
0.0190420356,
0.0249166358,
-0.0221082717,
0.0287365001,
-0.0127340825,
0.0062715439,
-0.0351911969,
-0.0063840514,
0.0859510675,
-0.0470924787,
0.0054008947,
-0.0385629721,
0.0130120693,
-0.0301701669,
0.0338621996,
0.0092823133,
-0.0365258418,
0.0198760387,
-0.0147033222,
0.0296623744,
-0.0193182509,
-0.0090099899,
0.0115500651,
-0.0196750592,
-0.0058785467,
0.019531915,
-0.0049673305,
0.0404369198,
-0.0187960453,
-0.0298607945,
0.0834307373,
0.0413442291,
-0.0305723902,
-0.0588507503,
-0.0755797178,
-0.0194972586,
0.0236595888,
-0.0187785849,
-0.0016116585,
-0.0350417085,
-0.0303722136,
-0.0071273409,
-0.099286288,
0.0027692651,
0.0547390543,
-0.0509737395,
0.0800614282,
-0.057264857,
-0.0408837683,
0.0066934233,
0.0101381093,
0.0426165983,
-0.0160887409,
0.0258260332,
0.0303882752,
0.0625115559,
-0.0118319988,
0.0492441803,
0.0233478174,
-0.020588316,
-0.0088177212,
-0.0270218365,
-0.0189926736,
0.0387024172,
-0.0463704541,
0.0147658531,
0.0588601381,
-0.0138206622,
-0.0532409921,
0.0996176824,
0.0925297588,
-0.0025895371,
-0.0117683196,
-0.0047415681,
0.0517990626,
-0.0230327044,
-0.0231729038,
-0.0270119142,
-0.0362849794,
-0.0512113795,
-0.0627467483,
-0.0123928143,
-0.0239293016,
0.006902446,
0.0131121576,
-0.0082691396,
-0.0521520041,
0.0624853149,
-0.0200077668,
0.0014224779,
0.0343108885,
-0.0541057438,
-0.00605457,
-0.012454533,
-0.0696992502,
0.0069370125,
-0.0316622145,
0.0278354473,
0.1049655303,
0.0571676679,
-0.0058245189,
0.015360387,
-0.0444631018,
0.0081358505,
-0.0135452943,
-0.027434608,
-0.001367897,
0.0326566063,
-0.0661503002,
-0.0305609293,
0.0235179625,
0.0270410217,
0.0136695188,
0.0167463534,
-0.0031145092,
0.034262564,
0.0110093374,
0.0222979505,
0.0275493823,
-0.0148087135,
-0.0610143133,
0.0325234942,
-0.0027809239,
-0.0073962444,
0.0248966794,
0.0034793166,
0.0028141979,
0.0122704096,
0.0248708278,
-0.0137549704,
-0.0313523635,
0.0225710068,
0.03155284,
0.0196493529,
-0.0209967699,
-0.025644578,
0.0517750308,
0.0050487714,
0.0063023614,
-0.0111197084,
0.0220516659,
-0.0099439658,
-0.0198214017,
0.0270366948,
-0.0156952851,
0.0212455709,
-0.029949259,
0.0163495746,
0.0213149823,
-0.0037268242,
-0.0273010489,
-0.0306361075,
0.0174400453,
-0.0165305957,
-0.0241650511,
-0.033805754,
-0.0347495787,
0.0335117467,
0.0055223559,
-0.0103826076,
0.0090292394,
-0.0154944006,
-0.0189157967,
0.0313268825,
0.0430927686,
0.0279344954,
0.0083498154,
0.03890156,
-0.0078612817,
-0.0086885327,
0.0033662303,
-0.0670244992,
-0.0010941828,
0.0212186631,
0.0503705442,
-0.0038785106,
-0.0571876615,
0.0266227722,
-0.0068861628,
-0.0132912463,
0.0377199799,
-0.0210529454,
-0.0674762055,
-0.0227429122,
0.0532692112,
-0.0032018039,
0.0131432498,
0.0093017519,
-0.0181946605,
-0.0495816991,
0.0179084465,
-0.0276564341,
0.0458577909,
-0.0011726712,
0.0042660218,
0.0083475038,
-0.0050274585,
0.0064752768,
-0.0227448065,
0.0124592697,
0.0329932831,
0.002830738,
-0.0167653598,
0.0712771788,
0.0156790707,
0.0247086566,
-0.0186759476,
-0.0495124981,
0.0392007753,
-0.0127629656,
-0.0102727925,
-0.0365217328,
-0.0366173647,
0.0010200685,
0.008743451,
-0.0235600583,
0.0126109542,
0.0374508947,
0.0060965279,
0.0544257611,
0.0110358754,
-0.0093935337,
0.0070133051,
0.0186498426,
-0.017725464,
0.0610345751,
0.0613006167,
-0.0494453907,
-0.012383502,
-0.0131956507,
0.0360815451,
-0.0159170814,
0.028515324,
-0.0275457501,
-0.020836791,
0.0067678406,
-0.0343383849,
-0.0129320892,
-0.0876564384,
0.0104740309,
0.0192160457,
0.0222572051,
-0.0450549945,
-0.0450987034,
0.0016992319,
0.0323008411,
0.0467209369,
0.0121210366,
0.0060193962,
-0.0180276558,
0.0015445678,
-0.0455842651,
-0.1021673754,
-0.0256477538,
0.0095419185,
-0.0084989956,
0.099027358,
0.0131315375,
-0.0042731627,
0.0205115676,
-0.0026191324,
-0.0216461066,
-0.0494613051,
-0.020053288,
0.0034979514,
0.0066798604,
-0.0445403419,
0.015519402,
0.0836717412,
0.018051846,
0.0150262918,
-0.0131813204,
0.018458223,
-0.0612532981,
0.00870167,
-0.0231571048,
-0.0926278681,
-0.020127004,
0.0242652986,
0.0203219932,
-0.0207278486,
-0.0738876686,
-0.0271875784,
-0.0641006529,
0.0033276987,
0.0200851131,
0.0083509218,
-0.0416682661,
-0.0253322199,
0.0480493903,
0.0230042543,
-0.0364928246,
-0.0167208351,
-0.0138977971,
-0.0288495403,
-0.0175199639,
-0.0155185321,
-0.0491256602,
-0.015312029,
-0.0562767498,
0.0320687555,
0.0667321756,
0.0456099361,
-0.0148838339,
-0.0059637078,
0.0162210949,
-0.0058602402,
-0.0588615201,
0.0078335488,
0.0678442866,
-0.0024421613,
-0.0044497889,
0.0014381044,
0.0602201782,
0.0196685717,
-0.0478945673,
0.0295798201,
0.0129509009,
0.0048448839,
-0.0044018975,
0.0098803127,
-0.0196723491,
0.0263072997,
0.1001629531,
0.0108404858,
-0.0499035455,
-0.0039901263,
-0.0599423759,
0.0059670531,
-0.0341731086,
0.0130208619,
-0.0171291512,
-0.0491443425,
-0.0939411372,
-0.0468432494,
0.0341463462,
-0.0024300693,
0.0114918109,
0.0603054091,
0.0066508437,
0.0439850539,
-0.0317831561,
-0.020852454,
-0.059229929,
-0.099353008,
0.0442603864,
-0.0398794971,
0.0796693489,
-0.0270702615,
0.0192190465,
-0.0324641764,
0.0290758274,
-0.0150633734,
-0.0654615462,
0.027938053,
0.0032910628,
0.0253346562,
-0.0112327989,
-0.0411733389,
-0.0653691292,
0.0277527384,
0.0441565141,
-0.039784573,
-0.0005385893,
0.0453901403,
-0.0264414642,
0.0088616535,
-0.0046860008,
-0.0112772677,
-0.0045539169,
0.0376102179,
-0.0394965373,
-0.0626014769,
0.001173763,
-0.0043525472,
0.0370675325,
0.0137815783,
0.0348097868,
0.0525879823,
-0.0114849983,
0.0109205488,
-0.051691886,
-0.0334032066,
0.0097942371,
0.0063524148,
0.0566001683,
0.0291969553,
0.0139032649,
0.0077955956,
-0.054884728,
0.0401512496,
-0.0032703788,
-0.0335590616,
-0.0023391163,
0.0365540348,
0.0533788092,
-0.0340803042,
0.0160783585,
0.0508548357,
0.0311270803,
0.0162827354,
-0.0292630941,
-0.0089625195,
0.0145562794,
0.0176288802,
-0.0358493328,
0.0384384505,
-0.0489602312,
0.0182084125,
-0.020139873,
0.0452475064,
-0.0165162515,
0.011717177,
0.0072481553,
-0.0519376621,
-0.0377806388,
-0.032560192,
0.0151459705,
0.0217013899,
-0.0240697134,
-0.023681419,
-0.0076981233,
-0.0337789245,
0.021538699,
0.0645614639,
-0.0327846482,
0.0575966239,
-0.0148106096,
-0.0692961738,
-0.0488426797,
0.0270184353,
0.023024274,
0.0480135642,
-0.0360521041,
-0.0338898934,
-0.0632489696,
-0.030418301,
0.0218919683,
-0.0120458184,
0.0240141563,
0.0157645512,
-0.0207311213,
0.0220815372,
0.0046992511,
0.0119551914,
-0.0767696425,
-0.0029307897,
0.022711603,
-0.0425794981,
-0.0269635152,
-5.448943819e-33,
0.009934606,
-0.0260653701,
-0.0344369896,
0.0214235783,
0.0427324399,
0.0352004766,
-0.011164234,
-0.0310572572,
0.0098150708,
0.0049727047,
-0.0118465777,
0.0052211015,
0.0052201534,
0.0114488835,
-0.0341908187,
0.0180270206,
0.063496083,
0.0283156727,
-0.0015851371,
-0.0061369031,
0.0312130824,
0.01853895,
0.004079714,
-0.0861096978,
0.0486183167,
-0.0026059796,
-0.072389178,
0.0155157298,
0.0235691462,
0.0529470406,
0.004120762,
0.0025507966,
0.0043378896,
-0.0293381419,
-0.0015037415,
0.0756389946,
-0.0659935474,
-0.0058477535,
-0.0068050795,
-0.016084522,
0.0367246941,
-0.1019909233,
0.0423339158,
-0.0456398092,
-0.0114763258,
0.0263900328,
-0.012040385,
-0.0257588867,
-0.0162429791,
-0.0355987921,
-0.0240315534,
0.0158321802,
-0.0200768579,
0.0032118382,
0.0631457418,
0.0342314243,
0.0359439589,
0.0100472691,
-0.0398202203,
0.0301718432,
0.0495559573,
0.0028062235,
0.0248516109,
-0.0025362554,
0.0108522056,
0.0321990699,
0.0006804088,
0.0142164631,
0.0282243025,
-0.0095679704,
-0.0229053963,
-0.004712888,
0.0085871629,
0.0656902194,
0.0508278199,
-0.0694000348,
-0.0473482348,
0.0332441814,
-0.0874307007,
0.0042097382,
0.0407703072,
0.0351430476,
-0.0242944285,
-0.0173558034,
-0.0397324301,
-0.0306977462,
-0.0263720043,
-0.0129625928,
-0.0104081705,
-0.0061155143,
-0.085369058,
0.0511130989,
0.0053353333,
-0.0591265932,
-0.0407837331,
0.0328794941,
0.0025988996,
-0.0112759955,
-0.0074399668,
0.016539244,
-0.0030883648,
0.0018475361,
0.0371596701,
-0.0197056253,
0.0034580457,
0.003222371,
0.043329861,
-0.0168206953,
-0.1093198434,
-0.0222322345,
0.0129525289,
0.0533961877,
0.0220341273,
0.0302674733,
-0.0049186009,
0.028809065,
0.0307625514,
-0.0075232158,
0.0345718041,
-0.0276332907,
0.005973679,
0.0073606689,
-0.0032843349,
0.0012464782,
0.0268826969,
-0.0160314012,
0.0032249214,
0.0395530909,
0.0970636308,
-0.0173277948,
-0.0102124652,
0.0000621649,
2.702e-7,
0.0703224316,
0.0305780452,
0.0024204052,
-0.0339026861,
0.0081873741,
0.0778120533,
0.0352477245,
0.015053953,
-0.0388339534,
0.0158569887,
-0.0180962142,
-0.039502617,
0.0379433446,
0.0214461703,
-0.0841443837,
-0.0162051562,
0.007088867,
-0.0265423395,
-0.0442141332,
0.0323667154,
0.0408495106,
0.053983625,
0.0544432513,
-0.0240950957,
-0.0160029959,
-0.0504318513,
0.0091108009,
-0.0393865928,
-0.0086958259,
0.0018552475,
0.0020067028,
0.0331968218,
0.0188451689,
0.0101367282,
-0.030268833,
-0.0312918909,
0.0035525884,
0.1289793998,
0.019006867,
0.0703817606,
-0.0031387457,
-0.073713392,
-0.0166702587,
0.0141114173,
0.0617751591,
0.0254458711,
-0.025779184,
-0.0275612511,
-0.0274626743,
-0.0340486653,
0.0362098441,
-0.0282175485,
-0.0482241809,
-0.0081384201,
0.0247190427,
0.0463225208,
-0.0326172002,
-0.0492676161,
-0.0238901079,
-0.052574005,
-0.0139029818,
-0.0071064131,
0.0161592588,
0.0118929381,
0.0532430634,
-0.0754430145,
0.0790339187,
2.864253157e-34,
-0.0065083415,
-0.0480783209,
-0.0370151922,
0.0367231853,
0.0336408466,
0.0024695208,
-0.0066619827,
0.0201641582,
0.003967511,
-0.0371635333,
0.0165584441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10083v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10083v1 | Characterizing Tradeoffs in Language Model Decoding with Informational Interpretations | 2023-11-16T18:38:25 | 2023-11-16T18:38:25 | Chung-Ching Chang, William W. Cohen, Yun-Hsuan Sung | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a theoretical framework for formulating language model decoder
algorithms with dynamic programming and information theory. With dynamic
programming, we lift the design of decoder algorithms from the logit space to
the action-state value function space, and show that the decoding algorithms
are consequences of optimizing the action-state value functions. Each component
in the action-state value function space has an information theoretical
interpretation. With the lifting and interpretation, it becomes evident what
the decoder algorithm is optimized for, and hence facilitating the arbitration
of the tradeoffs in sensibleness, diversity, and attribution. | [
-0.0142183593,
0.0522810109,
-0.0096266167,
0.0281378217,
-0.0351923518,
0.0339871719,
-0.0566911846,
0.0270836931,
-0.07929416,
-0.0318721756,
-0.0092150094,
-0.0607172064,
0.0470936447,
0.0153759392,
0.0189962313,
-0.0409426391,
0.0463524871,
-0.0710072368,
0.0231630001,
-0.0245855991,
-0.034014374,
-0.0282262303,
-0.0179873351,
0.0468712337,
0.0297806896,
-0.0085514402,
0.0097330008,
-0.0009245221,
0.0006446199,
0.0137207154,
-0.0395362191,
-0.0221671332,
-0.0030010385,
0.016497381,
0.000001754,
-0.0035435401,
-0.0491885059,
-0.0128457509,
-0.0591573976,
0.0094868317,
0.0416883491,
-0.0565580092,
-0.0352633297,
0.0118365595,
0.020651618,
-0.0486333333,
0.0754885077,
-0.0267595109,
-0.0248638429,
0.0499283262,
0.0055488111,
-0.0195887908,
0.0308282264,
-0.0245554373,
-0.0015999976,
-0.0280965511,
0.0247133411,
0.0577901416,
-0.0365667678,
-0.0273304656,
-0.0563228056,
0.0557294637,
-0.0256264769,
0.0208084825,
-0.021888325,
0.0394003615,
0.0642561093,
-0.0114078168,
-0.030706754,
-0.004152345,
0.0043061255,
-0.02169233,
-0.0118673248,
-0.0216227993,
-0.0106236767,
-0.016384637,
0.0002200516,
0.0533002652,
-0.0289991964,
0.0694295764,
0.1093535721,
0.0169413071,
0.0454798862,
-0.0034302808,
-0.0284464192,
0.0955085158,
-0.0008990261,
-0.0134730926,
-0.0286474489,
-0.0016502101,
0.025902966,
-0.0479243845,
-0.0111164106,
0.007478009,
0.0448966287,
0.0208063032,
-0.0216279272,
-0.0465985574,
-0.0333750062,
-0.0290486291,
0.0231209695,
0.049813617,
0.0988747925,
0.0023707971,
0.0652591735,
0.0494671278,
-0.0141922086,
0.0195512567,
-0.0550917797,
0.0239279289,
-0.0130268317,
-0.0688240379,
-0.0162846986,
0.0383021161,
0.0034494398,
0.0212754123,
-0.0034670241,
0.0418857895,
0.0111769438,
-0.0343270563,
-0.0231551323,
-0.0474265665,
-0.0589161664,
-0.0103935963,
0.0044872728,
0.0459330864,
0.0471463539,
0.0048022815,
-0.0486734658,
-0.0311092492,
-0.0015987789,
-0.0011720185,
-0.0087786671,
-0.0295290984,
-0.0577382036,
0.0708233193,
-0.011475049,
-0.0231527742,
-0.0095498748,
0.0020165541,
-0.0056808623,
0.0033600256,
-0.0060507809,
-0.0161120351,
-0.0004477586,
0.0100760134,
0.0360163674,
-0.0536674969,
-0.0617741272,
-0.067728281,
-0.0152475312,
0.0497495718,
0.0095516704,
0.0161438808,
0.0191374347,
-0.0292222593,
0.0259242579,
0.1155712977,
0.0232388731,
-0.005471786,
0.0111787692,
0.0041614254,
0.024637457,
0.0671796426,
-0.0082024634,
0.0303104948,
-0.0211435035,
-0.0307519082,
0.0356216989,
-0.0456671491,
0.0573310815,
0.0287292786,
-0.076249592,
0.0115614012,
0.0287421606,
0.0289920438,
0.0856075957,
-0.0063758488,
-0.015698621,
0.0184106734,
-0.0078901211,
0.0178388655,
0.0183215607,
-0.0244060345,
-0.022781061,
0.0001518335,
-0.0064715198,
0.0146816503,
0.005809518,
-0.0210997723,
-0.0033754413,
-0.0443055443,
0.0533802994,
-0.0039015762,
0.0735863,
-0.0246876441,
-0.0268642623,
0.0539228655,
-0.0112668164,
0.0087888548,
0.0175366737,
-0.0630405769,
0.0044345777,
0.0492565073,
0.0526868217,
-0.0150071681,
0.0070799398,
0.0186515767,
-0.0450613461,
-0.0202924348,
0.0152636822,
-0.0393288732,
0.0434246175,
-0.0453888662,
-0.0458298512,
0.0257503632,
0.0376542024,
0.0604450218,
-0.0535530858,
-0.0214665066,
-0.0438437089,
0.0084901433,
-0.035989169,
-0.0037041928,
0.0263990667,
-0.0352173373,
0.0095339818,
-0.0082691927,
0.0539529957,
-0.015029924,
-0.0278777126,
0.0486015752,
-0.0114007639,
-0.0359734111,
0.0178845804,
0.013208786,
-0.0005572892,
-0.0249030348,
0.031275183,
-0.0321093015,
0.0203233194,
0.0069526797,
0.0036259873,
-0.0320700072,
0.0525774322,
-0.0593632273,
0.0314229615,
-0.0248584896,
0.0380945392,
-0.0299577285,
-0.0263146143,
-0.0475646444,
0.0549436472,
-0.0391940139,
-0.0181073081,
0.0018398188,
0.010944929,
-0.0066419705,
-0.06853614,
0.0216371771,
0.0720144659,
-0.0295539256,
0.0165618099,
0.0465811752,
-0.0099282376,
0.0832217112,
-0.0269883703,
0.0232365169,
-0.0310980566,
-0.008939608,
0.0282714386,
0.029036995,
0.043057479,
0.0281707365,
0.0365119763,
-0.0061347103,
-0.014075377,
-0.0010995709,
0.0177632645,
0.0020974204,
0.0349675976,
-0.0510096438,
0.0083678961,
-0.0372487046,
-0.0090878615,
0.0313740186,
-0.0091703301,
-0.0362984352,
-0.1107244492,
0.0068945875,
0.0251458418,
0.0146870306,
-0.0364591181,
-0.0338322595,
0.0066158944,
-0.0286542512,
0.0154957687,
0.0270675197,
-0.0191308986,
0.0606533475,
0.0508839451,
0.0265351366,
-0.0654721409,
-0.0140227554,
-0.0273146294,
-0.0001128553,
-0.0878249779,
-0.0716236755,
0.0587641746,
0.0912499055,
0.0311034676,
-0.0023545276,
-0.0843488723,
-0.0331428275,
-0.0400748923,
-0.0720287487,
-0.0401607119,
-0.0551589429,
-0.0241400208,
0.0758767202,
-0.0385332257,
-0.0468231328,
0.045704931,
-0.0121480227,
0.0141060837,
-0.0573176481,
0.0185761768,
-0.0365026854,
0.0272030737,
-0.0038991421,
0.0190260783,
0.0346088745,
-0.0589862019,
0.0077919881,
-0.0085759368,
0.0767275542,
-0.0401864164,
0.0373074003,
-0.0579348058,
0.0416038409,
-0.0153755574,
-0.0311736539,
0.0059871259,
0.0091598993,
0.0037412255,
-0.0473622307,
0.0655317083,
0.0187934805,
0.0126587665,
0.0353243984,
0.0043559996,
-0.0042469925,
0.0152677819,
0.006318769,
-0.0085714282,
-0.004050089,
0.0022237981,
0.0031118423,
0.0165589768,
-0.0296439044,
-0.0116106672,
0.0039645419,
0.0612279624,
0.0347770937,
0.0178589001,
0.0365412049,
0.1002179831,
0.0120035838,
-0.0546668507,
0.0255738981,
0.026517557,
0.0048824144,
-0.0180793852,
0.0712170899,
0.0193801019,
-0.0748267546,
0.0195531361,
-0.0426703915,
0.0188062228,
-0.0292944685,
0.0003459453,
-0.069332473,
-0.0028958132,
-0.0037231289,
0.0212355796,
-0.0366814211,
0.0122340638,
-0.028622767,
-0.0504916124,
-0.0063986662,
0.0421512127,
-0.0081542945,
-0.0455867462,
-0.0180040374,
-0.0483279489,
-0.0451745056,
0.002684043,
0.0275944453,
0.0156122427,
0.0192856602,
0.0403603986,
0.0035363827,
-0.0465720817,
-0.0531684533,
0.0271295812,
0.0551564097,
0.1286177933,
0.0044854782,
-0.0179862473,
0.0090001756,
0.0070504523,
-0.0114937406,
-0.0398034602,
-0.0160835404,
-0.0272882581,
-0.009011141,
0.0128927529,
0.0219921339,
-0.0081338305,
0.0146069638,
-0.0051755877,
-0.0359295197,
0.0202562083,
-0.0508650318,
0.019343365,
0.0189175382,
-0.0413959436,
0.0482848771,
0.0754548013,
0.0085801948,
-0.0029948312,
-0.0044680093,
-0.0876833051,
0.0091280276,
-0.0486598164,
-0.0462191328,
0.0283528101,
0.0441916995,
-0.1117994636,
-0.0286528096,
0.0065623387,
-0.0061268476,
0.023999393,
0.0082771135,
0.0282507669,
0.0365819111,
0.0052318941,
-0.0072826017,
-0.0552678816,
-0.0508119352,
0.0162661076,
-0.037562564,
-0.0273683481,
-0.0046426989,
-0.0256002899,
-0.0128369015,
0.0195608269,
-0.0274656769,
-0.075823389,
0.0274911486,
0.0029412014,
0.0376584493,
0.0554376692,
-0.054351449,
-0.0581684746,
0.0154842762,
-0.0155697372,
0.027463207,
0.0298012607,
0.0540161245,
-0.0145385489,
0.0258765146,
0.0571827404,
-0.0719691962,
-0.0264571663,
0.0100817941,
0.0244530607,
-0.0470851921,
0.007081355,
0.0265012402,
0.0476118885,
-0.0298923384,
-0.0401616618,
-0.0557339303,
0.0184201058,
-0.0103962794,
-0.0121492455,
0.0136148753,
-0.0439900681,
0.0254339743,
0.0716916993,
-0.0212289561,
-0.0001375654,
-0.0172228422,
0.0327021517,
0.0155762397,
-0.0156511571,
0.0258121677,
0.0004924795,
0.0284482408,
0.0618039258,
-0.0188316591,
0.0100128837,
0.0341541208,
0.0050886823,
0.0007060595,
0.004280285,
-0.0166836772,
0.0420366935,
-0.0095276432,
-0.0412691273,
-0.0022176616,
-0.043338079,
-0.0506634973,
0.0138682602,
0.0046914108,
0.0340361707,
0.0360177793,
0.0556964241,
-0.057446681,
0.0100505352,
-0.0136112068,
0.0021779684,
0.0286136605,
-0.0155686373,
0.047673516,
0.031469889,
-0.005443776,
-0.0227146223,
0.0893580317,
0.0247147344,
0.0443698056,
-0.0512768999,
0.0015319284,
-0.041903384,
-0.0292634107,
-0.0465952195,
0.0385669656,
-0.0472381301,
0.0373705998,
-0.0527883545,
-0.0307094902,
-0.0254171714,
0.0462922864,
0.0652600899,
-0.0382855795,
-0.0193157047,
0.0484320074,
-0.0251316149,
-0.0016197847,
-0.056492094,
-0.0390145481,
0.0134889437,
-0.0172196813,
-0.0280485414,
-5.934612902e-33,
-0.0143852541,
0.0185215697,
-0.003666603,
-0.0244324096,
0.0094509898,
-0.0202706642,
-0.0003644859,
-0.0148491925,
-0.0055342722,
-0.0100846868,
0.0192894619,
0.0221568532,
0.0261008069,
0.0223607626,
-0.021828901,
-0.0041787298,
0.0271175932,
-0.0150810527,
-0.0487503037,
-0.0089787757,
0.0292027649,
-0.0018404797,
0.0174211096,
-0.0026066373,
0.0599740073,
0.0080096731,
-0.0183493067,
0.033078175,
0.0136460494,
0.0440087207,
-0.0404809117,
0.0022259559,
0.0109619545,
-0.0920887515,
-0.0325359888,
-0.0262594204,
-0.0787391439,
-0.0032124585,
0.0601942465,
0.0243331064,
0.0206608698,
-0.0738549829,
-0.0114052603,
0.0239040479,
-0.0328766815,
0.0105118779,
-0.0253005959,
-0.0286301523,
-0.0304073077,
-0.0097396169,
-0.0103477966,
0.039243497,
-0.025178276,
0.0195707381,
0.0858873501,
0.0183746684,
-0.026902318,
-0.0047122915,
-0.0135836359,
0.0654893145,
0.0446920693,
0.0162201431,
0.0674891397,
0.0758886039,
0.0053220233,
0.0040554018,
0.0079818992,
-0.0506367199,
-0.0295477808,
0.012753156,
0.0050593615,
-0.0343020633,
-0.0369141996,
0.0208485518,
0.0300200935,
-0.0191035625,
-0.0423517115,
-0.0018899459,
0.0160101764,
-0.0102339135,
0.021073984,
0.0727641806,
-0.06925717,
-0.0679363906,
-0.0318104737,
-0.0092034806,
0.0031317582,
-0.0007016525,
0.0028599934,
0.0131342281,
-0.0740697682,
-0.0022699854,
0.0727937818,
-0.0681411549,
-0.0290756468,
0.0284195747,
0.044255197,
0.0377654508,
-0.0203166474,
-0.0080973022,
-0.0178094823,
-0.0160278641,
-0.0041326839,
0.034218017,
0.0038913961,
0.0222934186,
-0.0490384586,
0.0260231793,
-0.0013667709,
-0.0082982788,
-0.0223907717,
-0.0196104087,
0.0293266047,
0.0185198188,
0.0565286204,
0.0053589111,
0.008773962,
-0.0126755238,
0.0268365536,
-0.0060094912,
0.0093755648,
-0.0254757367,
-0.0324645638,
0.0484512448,
-0.0407517068,
-0.0092193419,
-0.0105290171,
-0.0174954105,
0.057012137,
-0.0033955644,
-0.0331548639,
0.0021767349,
2.474e-7,
0.0709055439,
-0.0030999975,
0.0702089891,
0.0382464714,
0.0309252515,
0.0296880975,
-0.0168848783,
-0.0029379975,
0.0064274548,
0.0154535258,
0.0283218734,
0.018491663,
0.0181846712,
-0.0110427057,
0.0016404389,
-0.011998361,
0.0156356096,
0.0315896608,
0.0330337808,
-0.0029586274,
0.0192542784,
0.0569582582,
-0.0413907468,
0.0183447991,
-0.0048439591,
-0.009630057,
0.0147249466,
-0.0453289635,
0.0338688903,
0.039868243,
0.0396638475,
-0.0325475782,
0.0221925601,
-0.0136327846,
0.0142664192,
-0.0092604943,
-0.0455580615,
0.0408128165,
-0.011206232,
-0.0406877287,
-0.0325453468,
-0.0330379866,
-0.004451388,
0.0018310854,
0.0478800721,
-0.041864261,
-0.054983031,
-0.011671314,
-0.0136627844,
0.013396549,
-0.0630776882,
0.0117926979,
-0.0244082715,
0.0245904885,
-0.0105159823,
0.0197827071,
0.0360795371,
0.0011711451,
0.0065512587,
-0.0085348822,
-0.0456881411,
-0.0128270248,
0.0189491939,
0.0278137922,
0.0398548618,
-0.0719235018,
0.0005639703,
2.234910471e-34,
0.0430319719,
-0.0038005025,
0.0311465543,
0.0720108151,
0.0123416409,
-0.0155218774,
-0.036700353,
0.0407385789,
0.0324199833,
-0.0523758121,
-0.0158724189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10081v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10081v2 | DRESS: Instructing Large Vision-Language Models to Align and Interact with Humans via Natural Language Feedback | 2023-11-16T18:37:29 | 2024-03-19T17:51:45 | Yangyi Chen, Karan Sikka, Michael Cogswell, Heng Ji, Ajay Divakaran | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | We present DRESS, a large vision language model (LVLM) that innovatively
exploits Natural Language feedback (NLF) from Large Language Models to enhance
its alignment and interactions by addressing two key limitations in the
state-of-the-art LVLMs. First, prior LVLMs generally rely only on the
instruction finetuning stage to enhance alignment with human preferences.
Without incorporating extra feedback, they are still prone to generate
unhelpful, hallucinated, or harmful responses. Second, while the visual
instruction tuning data is generally structured in a multi-turn dialogue
format, the connections and dependencies among consecutive conversational turns
are weak. This reduces the capacity for effective multi-turn interactions. To
tackle these, we propose a novel categorization of the NLF into two key types:
critique and refinement. The critique NLF identifies the strengths and
weaknesses of the responses and is used to align the LVLMs with human
preferences. The refinement NLF offers concrete suggestions for improvement and
is adopted to improve the interaction ability of the LVLMs-- which focuses on
LVLMs' ability to refine responses by incorporating feedback in multi-turn
interactions. To address the non-differentiable nature of NLF, we generalize
conditional reinforcement learning for training. Our experimental results
demonstrate that DRESS can generate more helpful (9.76%), honest (11.52%), and
harmless (21.03%) responses, and more effectively learn from feedback during
multi-turn interactions compared to SOTA LVMLs. | [
0.0838993192,
0.0374028347,
0.000955271,
0.0246486645,
-0.034137655,
0.0104945693,
-0.0187886003,
-0.0181913972,
0.0362664089,
-0.0616683215,
-0.056976743,
-0.0177274738,
0.0081324512,
0.0415000245,
0.0181150362,
-0.1000545621,
0.0369472802,
-0.0500581153,
0.0215822384,
0.0081265289,
0.0249634497,
-0.0066777156,
-0.0318863429,
0.0483288802,
-0.0093492297,
-0.0144737773,
-0.0357476026,
0.0040591103,
0.0234712791,
-0.0260077789,
0.0089540947,
0.0429947451,
0.0495077483,
0.0009631735,
0.0000022089,
-0.0289591514,
0.0502121896,
-0.026497934,
0.0180821028,
-0.0027528647,
0.0370348841,
-0.0460836813,
-0.0029503531,
0.0181307644,
-0.0483956411,
-0.0197979249,
0.0625588968,
0.0659171194,
0.0758238956,
0.0605443232,
0.0130749708,
-0.0347171761,
0.0019557346,
-0.0153834112,
0.0208749454,
-0.0429847762,
0.0165539477,
0.0052106376,
0.0118725123,
-0.0034430744,
-0.0711750761,
0.0243971925,
0.0152483806,
-0.0336239636,
0.0162366498,
0.0531626679,
-0.0241360739,
-0.0446340777,
-0.0404491872,
0.0946478546,
-0.007229744,
0.0199567657,
-0.007330589,
-0.0150083359,
0.034815114,
-0.0131260986,
-0.0279619414,
0.015091056,
0.0089962352,
0.0063277371,
-0.0756699592,
-0.0107211368,
0.0061073722,
0.0250981431,
0.0140830679,
0.0167600904,
-0.0119311437,
-0.0266570896,
0.0137361418,
-0.0066784802,
-0.0086281858,
-0.0489888601,
-0.0304296538,
0.0157297458,
-0.0721175745,
0.0230083764,
-0.0491495878,
0.0539925247,
-0.0037209014,
-0.0322404131,
0.0353197642,
0.0272734333,
-0.0152797103,
0.0505331866,
0.0223123692,
0.068702586,
-0.0104386387,
0.0223949514,
-0.0305354949,
0.0136862863,
-0.0158347692,
0.0009486347,
-0.0176438931,
-0.0142159695,
-0.0525939092,
-0.0594158582,
-0.0297408085,
0.0319672711,
-0.0377685241,
0.0507953353,
0.0059547257,
0.0326245092,
-0.0127939777,
-0.0053171283,
-0.0700732842,
0.0416325144,
0.0084968638,
0.0057452098,
0.0053841285,
-0.0550935045,
0.0012044653,
0.022899501,
-0.0036379178,
-0.008509432,
0.0000627427,
0.111226283,
-0.0197868794,
-0.0196499042,
-0.0068324399,
0.0135554513,
-0.0383442044,
-0.0580302328,
0.0172818843,
-0.033367496,
0.0393403433,
-0.0129839536,
-0.0113645103,
-0.0061068838,
0.0289347004,
0.0174294543,
-0.0476688929,
0.0789099112,
0.0195556693,
0.0240923949,
-0.00666857,
-0.0072891698,
-0.0083601419,
0.052557461,
0.0448470451,
0.0237525254,
0.0210002158,
-0.0318316408,
0.0324227102,
0.0419039242,
-0.0157098453,
0.0038740418,
-0.008775942,
0.0005549394,
-0.0077020964,
0.0764486641,
0.0329395309,
0.0670223609,
-0.0323515795,
-0.0322511904,
0.0786210448,
0.0277844965,
0.0077878959,
-0.0017598489,
0.0341271833,
0.0558354482,
-0.0110179996,
0.012151869,
-0.0912286416,
0.0627326071,
-0.0312562287,
0.0045122788,
-0.0127187856,
0.0140567096,
-0.0299967304,
-0.0470352471,
0.0045502558,
-0.0044493517,
0.0481789298,
0.0334772505,
0.0381260701,
0.0050891801,
-0.0716960877,
-0.0385700725,
0.0465484448,
-0.0294303708,
0.0028591205,
-0.0324647352,
0.043053668,
0.0973010361,
0.0261288211,
0.0146494098,
-0.0146930628,
-0.0192672927,
-0.0093456246,
0.0605611205,
0.0508694164,
-0.0086147431,
0.0092784194,
-0.0358808525,
-0.0343194567,
-0.0059402739,
-0.0118727349,
0.0300660897,
-0.0248370357,
-0.0389588661,
-0.0126716262,
0.0514022969,
-0.0322566107,
0.0403596237,
0.0401237756,
-0.012755963,
-0.0314412452,
0.0148490872,
0.0233956184,
-0.0077068806,
-0.0116927112,
-0.0095438659,
0.0283893961,
0.0090953941,
0.0217613187,
0.0163922999,
-0.0627475753,
-0.0399202779,
0.0209234934,
-0.0270348676,
-0.0430736989,
0.0130059207,
-0.0436693877,
-0.0079236301,
0.0227306802,
-0.0395917967,
0.0289616678,
-0.0010889332,
0.02522517,
0.0296712592,
-0.0266256407,
-0.0429763161,
0.0261572711,
-0.0240534265,
-0.0097963279,
0.0051560872,
-0.0108136684,
-0.0145892771,
-0.0480416156,
0.0110821323,
0.0095710391,
-0.0010251099,
0.003901826,
0.0432665274,
0.0608482398,
-0.0591023229,
-0.048387479,
-0.0690065995,
-0.0544067807,
-0.0247311257,
-0.0312515832,
0.0013384265,
-0.0166003108,
-0.0089373896,
-0.0378722958,
-0.0277550574,
0.0296069533,
0.0119930487,
-0.0002154835,
0.0240696613,
0.023237627,
-0.0481950752,
-0.0423480384,
-0.0014263728,
0.0034445149,
0.0226757489,
0.032087259,
-0.0075898445,
-0.0579256937,
0.0037372003,
-0.028471237,
0.0855569392,
-0.0476823263,
-0.0505799688,
0.0211374629,
-0.0020766591,
0.0461371616,
0.1073201895,
0.0368055366,
0.0178771038,
0.029779803,
-0.0058619669,
-0.0563450307,
0.0303863026,
-0.031975206,
-0.0575151928,
-0.0674515441,
-0.0026906524,
0.0147730792,
0.0203662179,
-0.004730151,
0.0365951508,
-0.1093685552,
0.0154520953,
0.0211302284,
-0.0757709816,
-0.0203701407,
-0.0039141732,
-0.0298131425,
0.0013968599,
-0.0165981762,
-0.0627996325,
0.0679089054,
-0.010849623,
-0.0469996706,
0.0209413394,
0.0029702352,
-0.0106618572,
0.0525013916,
0.0381315202,
0.0188706499,
-0.0067205764,
-0.0076325624,
-0.0644286498,
-0.046808593,
0.0141517194,
-0.0068816808,
0.0669822022,
-0.0827139392,
0.0018983638,
-0.006016714,
-0.0304237735,
-0.0498448238,
-0.0160393994,
-0.0272931568,
-0.0164154004,
-0.0037631462,
-0.0365695134,
-0.0305999406,
0.001951048,
0.0390500575,
0.0212437268,
-0.0048861471,
-0.0141303642,
-0.0251736902,
-0.0315498449,
0.0844672099,
0.0263162237,
-0.0109867612,
-0.0282466672,
0.0221307576,
0.0467820428,
0.0127708465,
-0.0078917611,
-0.0382551253,
0.0142068574,
0.0210879352,
0.0069544152,
0.0281467084,
0.0489846542,
0.0515246801,
-0.0406909212,
-0.0087188557,
0.1006943807,
0.0210687406,
-0.048045475,
0.0088305566,
0.0008219194,
0.0241057444,
0.0217806809,
0.024368016,
-0.0553443097,
-0.0384170152,
-0.0233770274,
0.0243997276,
0.0241098125,
-0.0057980702,
-0.0104162646,
-0.1183153167,
0.0307509117,
0.0165523794,
-0.0214061905,
-0.0682160184,
0.0125055341,
0.003166243,
-0.0411110632,
0.0231365506,
0.0094721392,
-0.0224186163,
-0.0118790139,
-0.0142620709,
0.0024007794,
-0.0142008346,
0.0486122593,
-0.0438064486,
0.030437896,
0.0730411634,
0.0127676781,
-0.0028667434,
-0.0663712099,
0.0040337001,
0.0432316996,
0.0251144301,
-0.0213879999,
0.0460251793,
-0.0498214103,
-0.019421801,
-0.0158048905,
0.0514886044,
0.0167492796,
-0.0157261584,
0.0118063586,
0.0115090646,
-0.0361488946,
-0.0007465276,
-0.0186615959,
0.0327412076,
0.0277235005,
0.0471269712,
-0.019113021,
-0.0935118198,
-0.006410175,
-0.0232011098,
-0.0379114337,
-0.0336975046,
-0.0707539693,
-0.0212160256,
0.009822269,
0.0236013085,
-0.0633183122,
-0.0513875671,
0.0223489162,
0.0249269046,
-0.0130920624,
-0.0644258261,
0.0348359793,
0.0199891739,
0.0176078174,
0.0473535918,
-0.022650918,
0.0325475708,
-0.0642097369,
-0.0295579899,
0.014228384,
-0.0401432924,
-0.0058562621,
-0.0005190162,
-0.0344060883,
-0.0660505667,
-0.0221007206,
0.0932673737,
0.0120074321,
0.0874199569,
0.0233470071,
-0.0394426584,
-0.0314673819,
0.0266090687,
-0.004580623,
0.0327117331,
0.0144232474,
0.0482264794,
-0.0059820162,
0.0286086593,
-0.029134715,
-0.0140103828,
0.0130486116,
0.0246195886,
-0.0132269608,
-0.0488323011,
0.0346498899,
-0.0291538369,
0.06562379,
-0.0201224051,
0.0210295115,
-0.0009032214,
0.0039315256,
-0.0215498712,
-0.0241802931,
-0.0748938471,
-0.0196115933,
0.002684271,
0.0032479214,
0.009511848,
-0.0060757026,
-0.0325184576,
0.0094354032,
-0.054181926,
-0.000351581,
0.0277786329,
-0.0262815673,
0.0056460206,
0.0232648663,
0.0074529685,
0.023064388,
-0.0037714539,
0.0197409764,
0.0521783307,
0.1232013404,
0.0390787981,
-0.0284085143,
-0.0250221193,
0.0234022439,
-0.018089924,
-0.0426037721,
-0.0118707325,
0.0355539396,
0.0254258793,
0.0159682315,
0.0129556796,
-0.0359930731,
0.0053284401,
-0.0058769858,
0.0575534217,
-0.002295508,
-0.0570820235,
0.0808812231,
0.0233000144,
-0.0115087237,
0.0002218562,
0.0445542149,
0.009921113,
0.0126116453,
-0.0114760669,
0.0224225111,
-0.0511209033,
-0.0416117013,
0.0427424163,
-0.0186389126,
-0.0301769078,
0.0515401326,
-0.0377821364,
-0.0301818587,
-0.0400903486,
0.042719461,
-0.001362377,
-0.0191177074,
0.0802291706,
0.0170813706,
-0.0119706765,
-0.0391797163,
-0.0354534462,
-0.0106103783,
0.0081394343,
-0.0188077129,
-0.0410358198,
-6.294707596e-33,
-0.0278073102,
-0.0319121294,
0.0507855527,
0.035088975,
-0.0502514616,
-0.0398381762,
-0.0083030099,
0.0202329624,
-0.024598727,
0.012386011,
0.0247113388,
-0.0002810942,
0.000999095,
0.0285865441,
0.0233706459,
-0.016463317,
0.0353861637,
0.0081976922,
-0.0360801332,
0.0036931506,
-0.0005100264,
-0.0191909932,
0.0301117133,
-0.1050273851,
0.0177140813,
0.009422835,
-0.0363689326,
0.0141044296,
-0.0246284772,
0.0577564165,
-0.0004698496,
0.0094556641,
-0.0147177791,
0.0084887361,
-0.0150716091,
0.0583138727,
-0.0381641537,
-0.0048659611,
0.0419015139,
0.0409393087,
-0.0826400667,
0.0098589482,
0.0106504885,
-0.028380055,
-0.0354229771,
-0.0109566292,
0.0305828713,
-0.0191141516,
-0.0293408353,
0.0508070327,
-0.0418204926,
-0.0157577246,
-0.0332537554,
-0.0742932409,
-0.0050566602,
0.063338466,
-0.0118562225,
0.0156053957,
-0.0409764424,
0.0418493189,
0.0302212723,
-0.0143518215,
0.0647197589,
0.0555728339,
0.0651214942,
0.0414591245,
0.0231950805,
-0.0235406477,
-0.0055210125,
-0.0584828258,
0.0196164418,
0.0382112227,
0.0243904088,
0.0598423406,
-0.0194772035,
0.0063846284,
-0.0318447836,
-0.027126817,
-0.0344660766,
0.1118838489,
0.0046137031,
0.0291838106,
-0.0406887829,
-0.0110593969,
-0.0485808998,
-0.0068239328,
-0.0168601163,
-0.0130439606,
0.0336442515,
0.0471436121,
0.0199132245,
0.0061802287,
0.0502265058,
-0.0389400646,
-0.0159378797,
0.0061990949,
-0.0166940894,
0.0244389884,
-0.0228240173,
-0.0193129014,
-0.0873783454,
-0.0183515679,
0.0439426899,
-0.0250459686,
-0.0122497901,
0.0093638971,
0.0154251875,
0.0496551245,
-0.0341969989,
-0.0002366624,
-0.0045327931,
0.0319829322,
-0.0012006802,
-0.0002708598,
0.0425714813,
0.0022559059,
-0.0665472597,
0.0655741021,
-0.0144564426,
-0.0415074378,
-0.0238787942,
-0.0175033268,
0.0033440646,
0.0187511891,
-0.0378773697,
0.0057959422,
-0.0229310952,
-0.0095929364,
0.0162324607,
-0.0268607438,
-0.0082996357,
0.0394159816,
2.856e-7,
-0.0276189875,
0.0517849997,
0.002788414,
0.0321345329,
0.0088913916,
0.0689891353,
-0.0199226774,
0.0369857252,
0.0314469151,
-0.0193299428,
0.0267059114,
0.0356323868,
0.0386702642,
-0.0473907255,
-0.0404750928,
0.0260682367,
-0.0535858013,
-0.0382971279,
-0.0235302821,
-0.0101906108,
0.041260615,
0.0677764341,
-0.0019649635,
0.0166477058,
0.0442894101,
-0.0027667095,
0.0714164749,
-0.0733057335,
-0.0246230792,
-0.018897539,
-0.0234833267,
-0.0081622908,
-0.0193077456,
0.0250853803,
0.0049756975,
0.0175009742,
-0.0315605626,
0.0809608549,
-0.0378261171,
-0.0143266469,
-0.010060681,
0.0310827903,
-0.0138415908,
-0.0246317703,
0.0430075079,
-0.090591751,
-0.0205993894,
-0.0097907446,
0.0014587491,
0.0199357625,
0.0148579879,
-0.0303964391,
-0.043297939,
-0.0047197849,
0.0355838835,
0.0104430905,
-0.0187175591,
-0.0621413887,
-0.0000643309,
-0.0082721785,
-0.0243809745,
-0.0286496468,
-0.0281994659,
0.0067855841,
0.0026214293,
-0.0121362973,
-0.0234577134,
2.131908697e-34,
0.0283833705,
-0.0230619386,
0.029277198,
0.000539967,
0.0349628925,
0.0334446318,
-0.0080261631,
0.0452099741,
0.0604623035,
-0.0724415779,
-0.0133202514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10075v1 | ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4, Google Bard, and Microsoft Bing to Improve Health Literacy and Communication in Pediatric Populations and Beyond | 2023-11-16T18:30:14 | 2023-11-16T18:30:14 | Kanhai S. Amin, Linda Mayes, Pavan Khosla, Rushabh Doshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Purpose: Enhanced health literacy has been linked to better health outcomes;
however, few interventions have been studied. We investigate whether large
language models (LLMs) can serve as a medium to improve health literacy in
children and other populations.
Methods: We ran 288 conditions using 26 different prompts through
ChatGPT-3.5, Microsoft Bing, and Google Bard. Given constraints imposed by rate
limits, we tested a subset of 150 conditions through ChatGPT-4. The primary
outcome measurements were the reading grade level (RGL) and word counts of
output.
Results: Across all models, output for basic prompts such as "Explain" and
"What is (are)" were at, or exceeded, a 10th-grade RGL. When prompts were
specified to explain conditions from the 1st to 12th RGL, we found that LLMs
had varying abilities to tailor responses based on RGL. ChatGPT-3.5 provided
responses that ranged from the 7th-grade to college freshmen RGL while
ChatGPT-4 outputted responses from the 6th-grade to the college-senior RGL.
Microsoft Bing provided responses from the 9th to 11th RGL while Google Bard
provided responses from the 7th to 10th RGL.
Discussion: ChatGPT-3.5 and ChatGPT-4 did better in achieving lower-grade
level outputs. Meanwhile Bard and Bing tended to consistently produce an RGL
that is at the high school level regardless of prompt. Additionally, Bard's
hesitancy in providing certain outputs indicates a cautious approach towards
health information. LLMs demonstrate promise in enhancing health communication,
but future research should verify the accuracy and effectiveness of such tools
in this context.
Implications: LLMs face challenges in crafting outputs below a sixth-grade
reading level. However, their capability to modify outputs above this threshold
provides a potential mechanism to improve health literacy and communication in
a pediatric population and beyond. | [
0.041277308,
0.0016932068,
-0.0189858358,
-0.0343999378,
-0.0221130289,
0.0216397904,
0.0373218171,
0.0219529327,
0.0772984326,
-0.0275281016,
0.0397507995,
-0.0289993268,
0.0256410446,
0.009669642,
-0.0219701119,
-0.0640854016,
0.0319223292,
0.0015408581,
0.0691307932,
0.0145119727,
0.0086008059,
0.0400845595,
-0.0588360056,
0.0368555896,
0.0036947469,
-0.0312786661,
0.0235795993,
-0.0030177908,
-0.030464232,
-0.099035345,
0.0346413963,
0.0537841395,
-0.0229368899,
-0.0012669268,
0.0000023577,
-0.0099244677,
0.0196486097,
0.0155975334,
-0.0377452113,
0.0377533473,
0.0670817122,
-0.0459253676,
0.0065573119,
0.0217340551,
-0.0112604052,
-0.0181443021,
0.0458969437,
-0.0026054729,
-0.0053267544,
0.0175875779,
-0.0030304843,
0.0198630542,
0.0129606836,
-0.0019221157,
0.0475586355,
0.0017050589,
-0.0047753858,
0.0517225601,
0.0711139664,
0.0033470737,
-0.0043262029,
0.0851699039,
-0.0209115762,
-0.0055108992,
-0.0123402374,
0.0263971258,
0.0119965049,
-0.02587476,
0.0075134733,
0.071903117,
0.0259698052,
-0.0094238603,
0.0192881059,
-0.0066076154,
0.0285146758,
0.0346062705,
-0.0791974515,
0.0005409977,
0.0040791794,
-0.0061819134,
-0.0101222415,
-0.0094979489,
0.046092581,
-0.0145521956,
0.0420106649,
0.0102596385,
0.009688329,
-0.0420577303,
-0.0284318589,
0.0190999955,
0.031771563,
-0.0314773545,
-0.0124112973,
0.0162098594,
-0.0185878612,
0.0297864173,
0.0050464156,
-0.0027090909,
0.0542728379,
-0.0283252206,
0.0135050854,
0.0479689986,
-0.0197858755,
0.0053033032,
0.0464940183,
-0.0010536085,
0.0451027229,
0.0375647582,
-0.0348415859,
0.0641456321,
-0.0340638272,
-0.0429571941,
-0.0389818065,
0.0174301062,
-0.0169652309,
0.0093987528,
-0.0897404775,
-0.0156412069,
-0.0046308804,
-0.0255614966,
-0.0147985769,
-0.0026576456,
-0.0007177366,
-0.0035734712,
-0.0109337298,
0.0736428946,
0.0058617289,
0.018848747,
0.031466689,
-0.0375528336,
0.0239983983,
0.0004035764,
-0.0010275515,
-0.006609886,
0.006721674,
0.0254180208,
-0.0222036056,
-0.0245454032,
-0.0166791007,
-0.0049832426,
-0.0382991321,
-0.0322293714,
-0.025201764,
-0.0668583065,
0.0031430211,
0.025634829,
0.0324590877,
-0.032686267,
0.015204777,
0.0182923079,
-0.0300839357,
0.0155998515,
0.001112316,
0.0448032245,
0.0524660423,
0.0530264042,
0.0217250977,
0.0581384227,
0.0399692468,
-0.0606152005,
-0.0015497544,
-0.0628560632,
-0.0591645539,
0.0151539054,
0.0005328316,
0.0004353093,
0.0506233089,
-0.0513516106,
-0.0079011191,
0.0510831214,
-0.0744826794,
0.0340538174,
-0.0086552044,
0.0535604358,
0.1061047688,
0.07977359,
0.0055981358,
-0.0012831327,
-0.0277971011,
0.0343549997,
0.0454092063,
0.0055022123,
-0.0256051216,
0.0072756731,
-0.0083723124,
-0.0243753381,
0.0080257952,
0.0072260811,
-0.0299632009,
-0.036508549,
-0.0339433886,
-0.0002877772,
0.0390460864,
0.0039685462,
0.024111867,
-0.0353040285,
-0.0337160118,
0.0554322824,
0.0358487889,
-0.0400821976,
0.0591004454,
-0.0489996076,
0.0396745168,
0.091838412,
0.0284871589,
-0.0101377955,
0.0171610359,
-0.0076008523,
0.0198304541,
0.0345655121,
-0.0059501575,
0.0063982792,
-0.0026856333,
-0.0173686538,
-0.0016112088,
0.0150179993,
0.0146865742,
-0.0467914343,
0.0118092652,
0.0309437532,
-0.0165750645,
0.0024630709,
-0.0497040488,
-0.0071455282,
-0.0631564558,
-0.0069639971,
-0.0280092042,
-0.0219129696,
0.0205920525,
0.0418476909,
0.0292992126,
0.0420289338,
-0.0319843441,
0.0070515135,
-0.0208866782,
0.0032411774,
-0.0502439551,
-0.0258898344,
-0.0061312984,
-0.019898098,
0.0341520868,
-0.0108077424,
0.0145411417,
-0.0051435516,
-0.0054278723,
-0.0614118241,
0.0606410764,
0.0279275402,
0.0016335902,
0.0121246055,
-0.0482231304,
-0.0271354299,
-0.0172744747,
-0.0253579263,
-0.028141832,
-0.0430012904,
-0.0300668124,
-0.0570607185,
-0.0508112982,
-0.0043520997,
0.0227754973,
-0.017484419,
0.0264894422,
-0.0019013182,
0.0570619777,
-0.0284555927,
-0.0233569033,
-0.1241152063,
-0.0441486537,
0.0094449604,
-0.0324365087,
0.0480962731,
0.0065242662,
0.0063636363,
0.0264835134,
-0.0363858864,
0.0105612082,
0.0434683785,
0.0482213795,
-0.0054764883,
-0.0021051411,
-0.0111311823,
-0.0198517833,
-0.0375867821,
-0.0393079706,
0.008708165,
0.05676011,
-0.0601953007,
0.0028694053,
-0.0709693953,
-0.0279556829,
-0.036937207,
0.0034655377,
-0.0180917829,
0.0292919427,
0.0161516424,
0.0376290493,
0.030377226,
0.0067854789,
0.0322633311,
0.0374465883,
-0.023646865,
-0.0399232097,
-0.0119124623,
-0.0451003984,
0.0054901596,
-0.021570256,
-0.1183416769,
0.0093509983,
0.057911694,
0.0706797689,
0.028796643,
-0.0624999665,
0.0157119334,
-0.0385389738,
0.0054320269,
-0.1183243096,
-0.0209833179,
-0.0313113853,
0.0384538956,
-0.00955447,
-0.0413563438,
0.0452952459,
-0.0068016462,
0.0310178138,
-0.0695450306,
0.0053559514,
0.0025368654,
-0.0218076278,
-0.0420503728,
0.0341123268,
0.019008128,
-0.0301056653,
-0.0059021497,
-0.0021636877,
0.0321658552,
-0.0368034281,
0.0467264615,
-0.0792176723,
-0.0058380105,
0.0210388303,
-0.0233733784,
-0.0307658538,
-0.006825028,
-0.0075849956,
-0.0258555543,
0.0397993587,
-0.0131257046,
-0.0785757154,
0.002232759,
0.0286367871,
0.0676393732,
-0.0014715096,
0.0128261987,
-0.0006993451,
-0.0506381206,
0.0204455927,
-0.0216259006,
0.0244582277,
-0.0396069475,
0.0542990714,
0.0599533468,
-0.0644008741,
0.0011463296,
0.0650635958,
-0.0055054538,
0.0296978559,
0.0408869572,
-0.0076462161,
0.0425183102,
0.0391335189,
-0.0287598334,
-0.0011124442,
0.046280615,
-0.0034505436,
-0.0230262,
0.0177910104,
-0.023344757,
-0.0008268765,
-0.0532361865,
-0.0270560049,
-0.0639374331,
-0.0173933804,
-0.0125836274,
0.0621982999,
-0.0336011462,
0.0056433552,
0.002848438,
-0.0410389453,
-0.0003621943,
0.026259657,
-0.0205920786,
0.0015280646,
-0.0034052436,
-0.0189439207,
0.045993045,
0.0180160031,
0.0022512462,
-0.0343078077,
-0.0040812776,
-0.004224488,
-0.0726830438,
-0.0660622865,
0.0222724844,
0.0650020987,
0.0387040377,
0.0266948231,
-0.0018392197,
-0.0187146273,
-0.0029914952,
0.0379050933,
0.0221932903,
-0.0282767043,
-0.014211542,
0.052757699,
0.0196105111,
0.0166858491,
-0.0787646174,
0.0486238897,
-0.0018317247,
-0.0209900029,
0.0204467922,
0.0478104092,
0.0309243053,
-0.0297280867,
-0.0176328309,
0.0736107081,
0.0459852405,
0.0530411638,
0.0260025188,
-0.030684527,
0.0276002977,
0.0017135413,
-0.0113116764,
0.0262885522,
-0.0362893939,
0.0366252363,
-0.027455844,
-0.0313298851,
-0.0424210466,
-0.0108372578,
0.0284590945,
-0.0338106304,
0.0160681829,
0.0385229811,
0.0546202846,
0.0072155562,
0.0058415509,
0.066023238,
0.0156647749,
-0.0009650103,
-0.1138929874,
-0.0548936203,
-0.0240842849,
-0.0265575778,
0.0039848215,
0.0336748362,
-0.0410887487,
-0.0298597943,
0.0251618493,
0.0195840988,
0.0164359026,
-0.0153692206,
0.0168880541,
-0.0501213409,
0.0424429812,
0.0268774107,
-0.0132557601,
-0.011060752,
-0.0519411042,
0.016718192,
0.0323336758,
-0.0033311532,
0.0070665265,
0.0157276504,
-0.0205168873,
0.048174046,
-0.0329564661,
-0.0146800969,
0.001552586,
0.0465100147,
0.0292568151,
-0.0275903847,
-0.0264829565,
-0.0471631773,
-0.0208145343,
-0.0306475647,
0.0267808251,
-0.0054532299,
-0.0150755635,
0.0206652395,
-0.0197507106,
-0.0055480311,
0.0060963891,
-0.0556449927,
0.0074660485,
-0.0286332536,
0.0928247944,
-0.0558512323,
0.0392935611,
0.0313152,
-0.0017903588,
-0.0233651791,
0.0510765873,
-0.0447094738,
0.0288431291,
0.0177769512,
0.0793172121,
-0.0044680461,
-0.028019242,
0.0295227859,
-0.005720132,
0.0137745943,
-0.03363996,
-0.0243029427,
0.0345021375,
-0.0030275604,
0.0439795107,
0.0239634514,
-0.0214568786,
-0.0140558751,
-0.054368984,
0.0004337213,
0.0227728747,
-0.0207021721,
0.0754805356,
-0.0284855217,
-0.0040634698,
-0.0474046841,
0.0490917712,
-0.0015597398,
-0.0057358784,
0.0211182106,
-0.0200977046,
-0.0192912929,
-0.0355440639,
0.0246285684,
0.0672422275,
-0.078697145,
0.0476745293,
-0.0881894603,
-0.0368024483,
-0.0119217448,
-0.0122472616,
0.0071311253,
-0.0332989991,
-0.0117945783,
0.0097279614,
-0.0174987875,
-0.0633149743,
-0.035829518,
0.0743573904,
-0.0516907535,
-0.0330473185,
0.0155641111,
-6.296543572e-33,
-0.0067320163,
-0.0493037105,
0.0358604714,
-0.0094226329,
0.0413970649,
0.0098576294,
-0.0476935469,
0.0585819855,
-0.0176187716,
0.0472483523,
0.0378984064,
-0.0177449156,
0.0010651917,
0.0215768069,
0.0091568129,
-0.038031809,
0.0197956935,
0.0043309596,
-0.0455817021,
0.0217616316,
0.0318206176,
-0.0102880076,
0.0513941795,
-0.0520176701,
0.0576508865,
-0.0222043805,
-0.0050711939,
-0.0106166881,
-0.0158974268,
0.0158008859,
-0.0162937175,
0.0847568139,
0.0280219801,
0.0112839611,
0.0017676501,
0.0586433262,
-0.0373658687,
-0.0268857367,
0.0714988485,
-0.0605027787,
-0.032082282,
-0.0395427458,
0.0142952586,
0.0000659049,
-0.0404633544,
-0.0285291113,
0.0150516052,
-0.0304435808,
0.0133433221,
0.0131466724,
-0.0382191762,
0.0145088378,
-0.0199811552,
0.0058451178,
-0.0430576615,
0.0913360864,
-0.0413397476,
0.0475262329,
-0.0063964962,
0.0383436121,
0.0616088957,
0.0289021675,
0.031749811,
-0.0212202165,
0.0048513869,
0.0381449983,
-0.016112715,
-0.0124563975,
-0.0485155657,
-0.0007688238,
0.0270202458,
-0.0308863595,
0.0702247918,
0.0445105657,
-0.0167897809,
-0.0351401605,
-0.0729804859,
0.0135189211,
-0.0101274261,
-0.0123338336,
0.0382460877,
-0.0285901595,
-0.075884454,
-0.0545797534,
-0.0334699713,
0.0353666507,
-0.0137654422,
-0.0437718593,
0.0458171405,
-0.0284951422,
0.0030273022,
-0.018350875,
-0.0140534537,
0.0188339781,
-0.0108694127,
0.0037344564,
0.0372258499,
0.0070866444,
-0.0419100784,
-0.0115776667,
-0.0719923079,
0.0163507275,
0.0040990422,
0.0320170633,
0.0290445704,
0.0461661331,
0.0154653545,
-0.0539116897,
-0.02764339,
-0.0162066072,
-0.0053795339,
0.0392605364,
0.0396108367,
-0.0587821901,
0.0168099683,
-0.0026240903,
-0.0207066946,
0.0468525104,
-0.0131743317,
-0.0162857287,
-0.0236328598,
-0.0413142443,
-0.043635644,
-0.0019347966,
-0.0175538734,
0.0103253303,
-0.0410286263,
0.011369233,
0.0342723541,
-0.0211266167,
0.0264331028,
-0.0158056021,
2.88e-7,
0.0268628187,
0.0729093328,
-0.0090523977,
-0.0305112954,
0.033732336,
-0.0175647512,
0.0030946408,
-0.0148607828,
0.0421583354,
0.0173909739,
-0.0114935851,
0.0131241176,
0.0406776629,
0.0249204785,
-0.0428604595,
-0.0165854022,
-0.0823827758,
0.0198795274,
-0.0300147403,
0.0101737054,
0.0996961817,
0.0018966662,
-0.0281144828,
-0.0269612819,
-0.0107217291,
-0.009648799,
0.0318059139,
-0.0498692095,
-0.029331198,
0.0194956493,
-0.0087528517,
-0.0186606273,
0.0555741489,
0.0386818126,
-0.0337555446,
-0.0286440644,
-0.0203676037,
0.0998731554,
-0.0021302071,
0.0420825407,
-0.0078352094,
0.0323743336,
-0.0216614958,
-0.0839203969,
0.0374481753,
-0.0587943085,
-0.0211420581,
0.0572140962,
-0.0092561366,
-0.0326481014,
-0.0077222241,
-0.0347976498,
-0.050723277,
0.0105751408,
0.00780256,
-0.0104513103,
0.0377366692,
-0.0153463837,
-0.0098610502,
-0.0005956526,
-0.0123015558,
-0.091079466,
-0.0198663101,
-0.0069427663,
-0.0846481994,
-0.0438044891,
0.0259644613,
2.478465554e-34,
0.0232672915,
0.0011505452,
0.0457358919,
-0.0601818934,
0.0260483045,
0.0264382903,
0.0441348813,
0.0278159194,
0.0380930379,
-0.0819769129,
-0.0010407853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10057v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10057v3 | The Song Describer Dataset: a Corpus of Audio Captions for Music-and-Language Evaluation | 2023-11-16T17:52:21 | 2023-11-22T21:22:11 | Ilaria Manco, Benno Weck, SeungHeon Doh, Minz Won, Yixiao Zhang, Dmitry Bogdanov, Yusong Wu, Ke Chen, Philip Tovstogan, Emmanouil Benetos, Elio Quinton, György Fazekas, Juhan Nam | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | We introduce the Song Describer dataset (SDD), a new crowdsourced corpus of
high-quality audio-caption pairs, designed for the evaluation of
music-and-language models. The dataset consists of 1.1k human-written natural
language descriptions of 706 music recordings, all publicly accessible and
released under Creative Common licenses. To showcase the use of our dataset, we
benchmark popular models on three key music-and-language tasks (music
captioning, text-to-music generation and music-language retrieval). Our
experiments highlight the importance of cross-dataset evaluation and offer
insights into how researchers can use SDD to gain a broader understanding of
model performance. | [
0.0180255212,
0.0800516382,
-0.0062179863,
0.0524043851,
0.0047568926,
-0.009923609,
0.0230854712,
-0.0357709564,
-0.0479849689,
-0.0112411091,
-0.0698756948,
-0.0103370324,
0.0346535742,
0.0229171421,
0.026081983,
-0.0592447929,
0.0024723515,
-0.0483640246,
0.0046823788,
0.0095470445,
-0.0218620095,
0.0173773021,
0.0027210694,
0.0586306825,
0.0066639907,
0.0238353331,
-0.0205265414,
0.0426062159,
-0.0061571025,
-0.0301285889,
-0.0294269957,
0.0645587519,
-0.0005723746,
0.0197194722,
0.0000013899,
-0.0084084822,
0.0220054667,
0.018214412,
0.0199374426,
-0.0020975377,
0.0223975815,
-0.0134681147,
0.017170364,
0.0223144405,
-0.0067064236,
-0.0190396719,
0.03675396,
0.0038775015,
0.0720126405,
0.0742043853,
0.0228080079,
-0.034581162,
0.0107380021,
-0.0559510812,
0.0180869047,
0.0077838763,
-0.0133316945,
0.0376403071,
0.030827431,
-0.0069309711,
0.0160203464,
0.0724448636,
-0.0003333295,
0.0153361754,
0.0480964817,
0.0197201464,
-0.0922602341,
-0.0383573696,
0.018121371,
0.0660472214,
0.0889808759,
-0.0176163819,
-0.0007400589,
0.0308286995,
-0.0199790336,
-0.0150221977,
-0.0387432389,
0.0172617771,
0.0346283652,
-0.0122475736,
-0.0448564552,
0.0294261966,
0.0474246144,
-0.0080796713,
0.0472138263,
-0.0079095932,
0.0072327345,
-0.034304671,
0.0171598289,
-0.0152144916,
-0.0279765707,
-0.0783675313,
0.006154275,
-0.039857842,
-0.0185973998,
-0.0229564998,
-0.0631317049,
-0.0302584954,
0.0125495791,
0.0105684996,
0.0535117462,
-0.0291604344,
-0.0366056338,
0.0734023303,
0.0092892256,
0.0093833571,
-0.0074554631,
0.0087289736,
-0.036628522,
-0.0128061539,
-0.0431146063,
-0.0117337806,
-0.0433394462,
-0.0058360659,
0.0096684191,
-0.0382591933,
-0.0087678889,
-0.0538229309,
-0.0501867384,
0.0156090446,
0.0215468463,
0.005643656,
-0.0237034913,
0.0051708263,
0.0083526019,
-0.0076243277,
-0.0165721495,
0.0299251899,
0.02424841,
-0.0175673608,
-0.0227831937,
0.007611176,
0.0279132072,
-0.0140855117,
0.0473442189,
0.0316883549,
0.0438425019,
-0.0485015586,
0.0267140083,
-0.0514826514,
-0.0356294513,
-0.0605066195,
-0.0230161231,
-0.0670094267,
0.0584641881,
-0.0127468966,
-0.0110050114,
-0.0507990606,
0.0013249635,
0.0356036574,
0.0022270663,
0.0850740895,
-0.0067401109,
0.0317906924,
-0.0279707182,
0.0026877713,
-0.0311375298,
0.0297526177,
0.0681590959,
0.0451257303,
0.0548190586,
-0.0201464519,
0.0219172034,
0.0116240755,
0.0428168364,
0.0035418456,
-0.0252854619,
0.011437376,
-0.0206086449,
0.0907149091,
0.0401396938,
0.0604611039,
0.037569087,
-0.0024717511,
0.0538246296,
0.0569597259,
0.0001011735,
0.0239746626,
0.0297112744,
0.030305855,
0.0108606713,
-0.0237187594,
0.0027065233,
0.0513511337,
0.0446677282,
0.0216355324,
0.0682020187,
0.012289512,
0.0078181634,
0.0097315386,
-0.0632896796,
-0.0166371018,
0.0018289513,
0.0275612436,
-0.0011939162,
0.0115175238,
0.003443382,
0.065647319,
0.0029638654,
-0.0820618421,
0.0128952675,
-0.0451369621,
0.0024564466,
0.0465035997,
0.0636433959,
-0.0261209365,
0.024863692,
-0.0387928672,
0.0312159862,
0.0560620949,
0.0305120256,
-0.0109183015,
0.002043203,
0.0305479225,
-0.0298181493,
-0.0296644252,
0.0066525871,
-0.0045315544,
-0.0029426245,
0.0090253837,
0.0391347483,
-0.0600094758,
-0.0475320742,
-0.0042402577,
0.0157157388,
-0.0445242748,
0.0332665443,
0.0310438592,
0.0148518542,
0.0485466607,
-0.0414566174,
0.0444605723,
0.0147886733,
-0.005424201,
-0.0004633698,
0.0378210209,
-0.0430434532,
-0.0165521968,
0.033059556,
-0.0540401265,
0.0174499974,
0.0488125905,
0.0104531161,
-0.0440146774,
0.0459758677,
-0.0201652683,
0.0001514416,
-0.0013668734,
0.000656927,
-0.0152770709,
0.0027685089,
0.0469421633,
0.0095811654,
0.0500045829,
0.0018301465,
0.0185846258,
-0.0386074558,
0.0307170153,
-0.0420298092,
-0.049501501,
0.0366059169,
0.0261600502,
0.029478265,
0.0046765893,
-0.0223275591,
-0.0390095226,
-0.0218218658,
-0.07082773,
0.0380949378,
-0.0127895772,
0.0015076316,
0.0157043263,
-0.0240666829,
0.0139997611,
0.0054459255,
-0.0595503487,
-0.0520884767,
0.0265046079,
0.0146793099,
-0.0393947847,
0.0010868035,
-0.0433748662,
-0.0352161489,
0.0029344396,
0.0037938743,
-0.0047978391,
-0.0170458145,
0.0004106716,
0.0080517977,
0.0089513902,
-0.0529871248,
-0.0198166724,
-0.0039019503,
-0.0094589852,
-0.0246026982,
-0.0008695768,
-0.022313999,
0.0259114504,
-0.0140712177,
0.0086696092,
0.066984579,
0.0159488935,
0.0227640774,
-0.0017939889,
0.0406468548,
-0.0124732992,
0.0151007203,
-0.0185572915,
-0.0025407111,
0.0380671732,
0.0577539131,
-0.0001250421,
-0.0156701189,
0.031812299,
-0.0502593406,
0.0107971299,
-0.068009913,
0.00800962,
-0.0516726896,
0.055383984,
-0.060116265,
-0.0150866089,
0.0466917939,
-0.0414170399,
-0.0252827406,
-0.0058528101,
-0.0356403105,
-0.058181636,
0.0668028891,
-0.0421493165,
0.0261141621,
0.0215947516,
-0.0205261335,
-0.0063935849,
0.0207885206,
0.0397534035,
-0.0657017827,
0.0130937146,
-0.0410813056,
0.0030265942,
-0.0209338628,
-0.0619885586,
0.0191595722,
-0.0587221906,
-0.0202994756,
0.024005264,
-0.0032441595,
-0.0412381962,
0.0091945538,
-0.0088054109,
0.0442242883,
0.0170949176,
-0.0307325367,
0.0047174869,
0.0017654012,
0.0465589017,
0.0315297917,
0.0162785631,
-0.0282144807,
-0.0335509777,
0.0148136774,
-0.0270165745,
0.0246857945,
0.0344116651,
-0.0332040042,
-0.0130996322,
0.0083597349,
0.0227938984,
-0.0112153152,
0.0244336165,
0.0284320731,
-0.030673828,
-0.0063046496,
0.0792768374,
0.0148963192,
-0.0143698016,
0.000100277,
0.0454890467,
0.0255595446,
0.0360740386,
-0.0183679946,
-0.0623224489,
-0.036816515,
0.0213765092,
0.0798110515,
0.0713874549,
0.01436368,
-0.0053409673,
-0.064267166,
0.020533355,
0.0056156241,
-0.0800982937,
-0.0532274023,
-0.033024922,
-0.0401633717,
-0.0235965289,
0.004921983,
-0.0225532968,
-0.0275089983,
0.0413829051,
-0.0042767408,
0.0001845398,
-0.0637770221,
0.0588696375,
-0.0782907531,
0.0635989234,
0.0758918971,
0.048242908,
-0.0088944193,
-0.0425432883,
-0.0312313214,
0.0037463773,
-0.0125187961,
0.0623299479,
0.0648875684,
0.0244941209,
-0.0128768282,
0.0203900617,
0.0378528573,
-0.0627035871,
-0.0028931263,
0.0145863481,
0.0285762995,
0.0205904748,
0.0066992501,
0.0049533644,
0.0445849933,
0.0112334378,
0.1012475565,
0.0688014328,
0.0003359852,
0.021707939,
0.0127033163,
-0.0108722439,
-0.0957921892,
-0.0415493399,
0.0179901253,
0.0073852446,
-0.0290903598,
-0.0531024188,
-0.0373841599,
0.0202389918,
-0.0131285014,
0.023659559,
-0.0071938434,
-0.0408294275,
-0.0348886885,
-0.0689140111,
0.0885617808,
-0.0205239728,
0.0423021279,
-0.0519665293,
-0.0855984762,
0.0188759025,
-0.0154617224,
-0.016673537,
0.018680606,
-0.107120797,
-0.0180642307,
-0.0062241959,
0.021168869,
0.0187459979,
0.0302209519,
0.0146327764,
-0.0394765139,
-0.0239546504,
0.0329163782,
-0.0059068603,
0.0199771784,
0.0171059053,
0.0087182587,
-0.0120761031,
0.0172032639,
-0.0742321685,
0.0070550502,
0.00071315,
0.0054663485,
0.0515294895,
-0.0418651402,
0.0126613835,
0.0252313782,
0.04619563,
-0.0101211434,
-0.0011969662,
-0.0414994024,
-0.0244840905,
-0.0232231561,
-0.0347550139,
-0.0475203283,
-0.0098850904,
0.0538502336,
0.0372463912,
-0.0183476396,
0.0056481529,
0.0144098587,
-0.037786305,
-0.0602859557,
0.025504414,
0.0679109395,
-0.0600181632,
0.0213572774,
0.0058112578,
-0.0051034112,
0.0001532937,
0.0072541335,
-0.002957437,
0.0134153133,
-0.030436188,
-0.004729995,
-0.0232752264,
0.0217824634,
0.0363962874,
-0.0448782817,
-0.0465172008,
-0.0339491479,
-0.000147875,
0.0497985967,
-0.0009049629,
0.0385400355,
0.0301385149,
-0.0160331149,
0.0081932815,
0.0685476661,
-0.0177548304,
-0.0389687568,
0.010831113,
0.0102279894,
-0.0115154404,
0.0030178279,
0.0855255648,
0.0095916828,
0.0150622856,
-0.0052037286,
-0.0297842063,
0.0266033579,
0.0295892116,
-0.0399784073,
-0.0258066729,
-0.0021072575,
0.010959452,
-0.0368632041,
-0.0583732575,
0.0042417785,
0.0297875647,
0.0214623678,
0.0101402411,
0.0344782807,
0.0470851287,
-0.0130152386,
0.0131527865,
-0.0005928685,
-0.0432716198,
-0.0312427673,
0.0198677946,
-0.0324229673,
-4.918668767e-33,
-0.0503605306,
0.004405865,
-0.0325521268,
-0.0088447779,
-0.0365835577,
-0.0157840438,
-0.0788186342,
0.0205647964,
0.0273045637,
-0.0068783555,
0.0135160759,
0.0216239169,
0.0033196544,
0.0300044436,
0.0405593924,
-0.0349521972,
0.0886129215,
-0.0238151681,
-0.0514871366,
0.0274556261,
0.0436729081,
0.0138688702,
-0.0034153473,
-0.0565712638,
0.0302192755,
-0.0172915291,
-0.003755542,
0.0201643445,
0.0180070102,
0.0641171932,
-0.0184808355,
0.0351233706,
0.0038888189,
-0.0269030705,
-0.0281668026,
-0.0117931738,
-0.0316020027,
0.0158365201,
-0.0076051936,
0.0361911096,
0.0088526802,
-0.0040302989,
0.0322119817,
-0.016484132,
-0.0412918814,
-0.0050643482,
0.0528785586,
-0.0378740244,
-0.0103482576,
-0.0485072695,
-0.0305999946,
-0.0219648536,
-0.0510435998,
-0.0652050972,
0.044785317,
0.0428617634,
-0.0098054446,
0.04533666,
-0.0270567872,
0.0154640637,
-0.008928122,
0.0193326157,
0.0789374188,
0.01883661,
-0.0137741612,
0.0700037405,
0.0122443363,
-0.0313303173,
-0.0146732433,
0.0257761888,
-0.0111974431,
0.0598586313,
0.0211948268,
0.0545856096,
0.0541471131,
-0.0056284689,
0.0273608472,
0.0268218499,
-0.0752761364,
-0.0182431489,
-0.0206257012,
0.0226834174,
-0.0414725468,
0.0017091177,
-0.0559281819,
-0.0466340519,
-0.0524195805,
-0.0150988773,
0.0469790362,
-0.0147245126,
-0.0302722603,
-0.023051491,
-0.0117393993,
-0.0396911092,
0.0011153264,
-0.0040871063,
-0.0302221421,
-0.004526902,
-0.0142018609,
-0.0112766623,
-0.0362389721,
-0.0069133956,
0.0605890229,
0.0456993617,
0.0759286508,
-0.0143884355,
0.0313367695,
0.082071282,
-0.0618507415,
0.0217420459,
-0.0509834886,
-0.0058666691,
-0.0407859236,
0.0008075236,
0.0376931652,
0.0218838435,
-0.0369268991,
0.0268396493,
-0.0046995273,
0.0166119374,
-0.0274142791,
-0.048154179,
-0.0063149296,
0.003711256,
0.0279432908,
0.0281380471,
-0.0168222822,
-0.0205412209,
0.0266673081,
-0.0099767251,
-0.0323068202,
-0.0184173677,
2.164e-7,
0.0222970787,
-0.012176875,
0.018656401,
0.0282772854,
0.010333891,
0.0338439643,
-0.1079811975,
0.0246099383,
-0.0158610996,
-0.0091712661,
0.0341584049,
-0.0212443881,
0.117923893,
0.0336615033,
-0.1105397865,
0.0073292763,
-0.105903998,
0.0260062888,
-0.0513125658,
-0.0615568832,
0.0357578136,
0.0626570806,
0.0176016372,
-0.0164304692,
-0.005233021,
-0.0600579344,
0.0371631198,
-0.0667705312,
-0.0036042125,
-0.0719648749,
0.0366670899,
0.0371689387,
-0.0255832914,
-0.0251900628,
-0.0625780001,
0.039137952,
0.0732856691,
0.0153343156,
0.0511504784,
-0.0415240824,
-0.0310713649,
0.0203077234,
0.0045849727,
-0.026204614,
0.0731289312,
-0.0222204402,
-0.0412496813,
-0.03733363,
-0.0387639478,
-0.008251599,
0.0140677672,
-0.0311235394,
-0.0238259528,
-0.0363021456,
0.0156849623,
-0.0128356591,
0.0140864775,
-0.0285658073,
-0.0081202062,
0.0241028331,
-0.0526623242,
-0.0055815307,
-0.0275674872,
-0.0171608329,
-0.0270340201,
-0.0527709574,
-0.0034386192,
1.621995778e-34,
0.0687574372,
-0.0410098769,
0.0096383095,
-0.0275462326,
0.0480210856,
-0.0171080623,
0.0043463144,
-0.0504732803,
-0.0260243528,
-0.0296325628,
-0.0152875381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10054v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10054v1 | Is "A Helpful Assistant" the Best Role for Large Language Models? A Systematic Evaluation of Social Roles in System Prompts | 2023-11-16T17:48:55 | 2023-11-16T17:48:55 | Mingqian Zheng, Jiaxin Pei, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | Prompting serves as the major way humans interact with Large Language Models
(LLM). Commercial AI systems commonly define the role of the LLM in system
prompts. For example, ChatGPT uses "You are a helpful assistant" as part of the
default system prompt. But is "a helpful assistant" the best role for LLMs? In
this study, we present a systematic evaluation of how social roles in system
prompts affect model performance. We curate a list of 162 roles covering 6
types of interpersonal relationships and 8 types of occupations. Through
extensive analysis of 3 popular LLMs and 2457 questions, we show that adding
interpersonal roles in prompts consistently improves the models' performance
over a range of questions. Moreover, while we find that using gender-neutral
roles and specifying the role as the audience leads to better performances,
predicting which role leads to the best performance remains a challenging task,
and that frequency, similarity, and perplexity do not fully explain the effect
of social roles on model performances. Our results can help inform the design
of system prompts for AI systems. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/Jiaxin-Pei/Prompting-with-Social-Roles. | [
0.0832857937,
0.0076214331,
-0.0423881486,
0.0394615345,
-0.0368376262,
0.0111636613,
0.0439549051,
-0.0173976552,
0.0536375307,
-0.0244931672,
-0.0258331411,
-0.072725378,
-0.00135789,
0.0270719416,
0.0326542743,
-0.039980866,
0.0307367723,
-0.0169185884,
0.0549244136,
-0.0130570307,
0.0018189922,
0.0234567579,
0.0001477147,
0.0865334496,
-0.0096873557,
-0.0182296373,
-0.0007254848,
0.0181822926,
0.0218970962,
-0.0013040672,
0.0259612352,
0.0285906531,
0.016707385,
0.035282284,
0.0000021355,
-0.0834097043,
0.0478046797,
-0.0101918001,
-0.0613868311,
-0.0088912593,
0.0208936147,
0.0159350242,
-0.0110808425,
0.0370627381,
-0.0497242771,
0.0117542278,
0.0343302414,
0.0146411024,
0.0267386008,
0.0421611965,
-0.0146367103,
0.0395494141,
-0.0454903916,
-0.0362898447,
0.0196177252,
-0.0564251356,
0.0047288891,
-0.0035500166,
0.0343573391,
0.0284077767,
-0.0019694341,
0.0427907705,
0.0309823807,
-0.0651083514,
0.0399443768,
0.0515064783,
-0.0024463807,
-0.0432624221,
-0.0202282034,
0.0629099756,
0.045583915,
0.008047468,
-0.0099765593,
0.0046915589,
0.0643686205,
0.0633940548,
-0.0182695109,
0.0261132978,
0.0175210759,
-0.0334794372,
0.0178981293,
0.0231596157,
-0.0070124757,
0.0090806298,
0.0069871387,
0.0672619939,
-0.0044316319,
-0.0401423648,
0.0100144912,
0.0028898341,
-0.0226378106,
-0.0798791125,
0.020178223,
0.0205221511,
-0.0606134199,
0.0209317002,
-0.0158937424,
0.03091559,
0.0237467829,
-0.0185999759,
0.0257311538,
0.0603343472,
-0.0178908799,
0.022234004,
0.0268328227,
0.0382320732,
0.0353901833,
0.0182433389,
0.0047350405,
-0.0043873405,
-0.0376297012,
-0.0328956991,
-0.0518957861,
-0.0070928843,
-0.0060249502,
-0.008948788,
-0.0010222525,
0.0482354127,
-0.0228981264,
0.0403584242,
0.0282506552,
0.019502474,
-0.0246962495,
0.0097627984,
-0.0207838379,
0.0067641153,
-0.0813274756,
0.0041347034,
0.0162817817,
-0.0711277574,
0.01141869,
-0.0212559067,
0.0147958146,
-0.0302076172,
-0.0164164081,
0.0466709957,
0.0153740421,
-0.0462101884,
0.0227961112,
-0.0356834233,
-0.019363258,
-0.0559391268,
-0.0459364057,
-0.0191025492,
0.050242994,
0.0404213183,
0.0029809645,
0.0095447889,
0.0069769374,
0.0377439745,
-0.0115397433,
0.060326498,
0.0021002679,
0.0440454148,
0.0558032468,
0.045215901,
-0.0248869974,
0.0534999743,
0.0185686983,
0.0213189926,
0.0506023914,
-0.0155374696,
0.0274983738,
0.0410445109,
-0.0578196011,
-0.0116216326,
0.0385430269,
0.0305926278,
-0.0180435311,
0.0078668101,
0.0398044772,
0.0157774314,
-0.0085501866,
-0.0098537542,
0.0685829967,
0.085700646,
-0.0172233749,
0.0419204906,
0.0283936746,
0.0336620733,
0.01648538,
0.0046020346,
-0.0730168521,
0.0405600257,
-0.0205384251,
-0.0332821608,
-0.0646350682,
-0.0044095865,
-0.0090034017,
-0.0406617336,
0.0061094845,
-0.0281077623,
-0.0085287085,
0.0433199853,
0.0008056149,
-0.004634107,
-0.0214256458,
0.0154218888,
-0.001987949,
-0.0716555119,
-0.0136474092,
-0.0386826769,
0.0228603259,
0.0996386632,
0.0325610526,
-0.0542833917,
-0.0187848862,
-0.0081958743,
0.0146254161,
0.0256361347,
0.0823184699,
0.0033875671,
-0.0109757101,
-0.0041687153,
-0.00411209,
0.0133857597,
0.0114086578,
0.030824041,
0.0105118454,
0.0215181373,
0.008001091,
0.0223226659,
-0.0636332035,
-0.0026501897,
-0.0375617221,
-0.0215013288,
-0.0177235752,
0.0315387361,
-0.0131665394,
0.0298839584,
-0.0098462645,
0.0098063704,
0.0077825896,
-0.0128848748,
-0.0006715177,
0.0314925425,
-0.0944825336,
0.0059739989,
0.025521785,
0.0178254917,
-0.0722464994,
0.0600470975,
0.0047018817,
-0.0150108803,
0.0384923331,
-0.0679120645,
0.0141523797,
0.0007461607,
0.0122397011,
-0.0195946824,
-0.0108154528,
-0.0281033553,
0.003996497,
0.0109491153,
-0.0213653538,
0.0268207639,
0.0365549214,
-0.0166154653,
-0.0642371848,
-0.0364231206,
0.0108002909,
-0.024399437,
-0.0275652148,
0.0443032682,
-0.0042390786,
-0.0571930185,
-0.0288632531,
-0.1317196041,
-0.0310160052,
-0.0252906121,
-0.0352435857,
0.0200448949,
0.0210753158,
-0.0293309502,
-0.0217157006,
-0.0518971719,
0.0016860731,
0.0006865322,
0.0181596112,
0.0467345715,
-0.008361483,
-0.0420980044,
-0.0647166818,
0.0118740872,
-0.0155797955,
-0.0012872147,
0.0335278884,
-0.0258811191,
-0.0395669565,
0.0392802693,
-0.0115951048,
0.0081000878,
-0.0302745383,
-0.0401406027,
0.0201583058,
0.021633653,
0.0498021543,
0.0672519282,
0.009951612,
0.0345336013,
0.0304046012,
-0.0066408371,
-0.0521860719,
0.0107805356,
0.0317032225,
-0.0148168057,
-0.0138036283,
-0.0591003522,
-0.0056304112,
0.0199999865,
-0.0023385095,
0.0019972038,
-0.0260386188,
0.0278541818,
-0.0177339371,
-0.0453373194,
-0.029161064,
-0.0441272035,
-0.0167355537,
0.0661965087,
-0.0158196129,
-0.0398153812,
0.0489137173,
-0.0155385258,
-0.0440923534,
0.0058308332,
-0.0353286266,
-0.0500763357,
0.0904937759,
-0.0210231673,
0.0249912776,
-0.0002875428,
-0.0443456694,
-0.0478182547,
-0.0019997228,
0.0058867405,
-0.0336146429,
-0.0022131479,
-0.0264711305,
-0.0056650299,
0.0099844029,
-0.0378886312,
-0.0341950767,
-0.0280650705,
-0.0526582301,
0.0058543915,
0.0219699927,
-0.026380606,
0.0104745124,
-0.0138982385,
0.02892326,
-0.0001380991,
-0.0080749001,
-0.0051658223,
-0.0360223427,
-0.015280935,
0.0371973068,
0.0576017126,
-0.0044718664,
0.0015071797,
0.0599011891,
0.0014418077,
0.0134331444,
-0.0116552953,
-0.007650211,
-0.0272404309,
0.0663017631,
-0.0181315802,
-0.0509276316,
0.0208807755,
0.0627545491,
-0.0505885482,
-0.0067748632,
0.162642017,
0.0203997344,
-0.0740295202,
0.0186184216,
-0.051000502,
0.000372152,
0.0298978817,
0.0332951434,
-0.0760196224,
0.0082305558,
0.0296861753,
-0.0057474668,
-0.024513036,
-0.0250557978,
-0.0172814671,
-0.1201228276,
0.0454016775,
-0.016284585,
-0.0355506502,
-0.0140170613,
-0.0367294326,
0.0061041783,
-0.0176427197,
0.0343849882,
-0.0010865806,
-0.0272721816,
-0.021372715,
0.0044661588,
-0.0420082659,
-0.0280924067,
0.037726406,
-0.0892586261,
0.0871666893,
0.0751668215,
0.0535575673,
0.0048307669,
-0.0102140568,
-0.0075849881,
0.0844994634,
0.0271660443,
0.014973186,
0.0371241868,
-0.0306995772,
-0.0047057522,
-0.0356191061,
0.0213647615,
-0.0359354317,
0.0140882004,
0.039816957,
0.0379677676,
-0.0209433772,
-0.0269997306,
-0.0062123952,
0.018926451,
0.0382088609,
0.0899528936,
0.0368191116,
-0.0449400805,
-0.0198767502,
-0.0044253687,
0.0152498586,
0.0205411371,
-0.0414682999,
-0.0367875583,
-0.0016209675,
-0.0545722879,
-0.0250691585,
-0.084281899,
0.0726293251,
-0.0079463404,
0.020027522,
-0.017149115,
0.0224884748,
0.0259599444,
-0.0008384775,
0.0040617674,
-0.0581662469,
0.0665913746,
-0.0362598822,
-0.0316594541,
-0.0092411768,
-0.0234038364,
0.0119182197,
-0.0318105705,
0.011088728,
-0.0364132039,
0.0291744787,
0.0377712585,
0.0310311224,
0.0197742339,
-0.012105382,
-0.0758890659,
-0.0343026705,
0.0339053422,
-0.0451440923,
0.0332473852,
0.0040407567,
0.0217187181,
-0.0039279517,
0.0465999842,
-0.0251624752,
0.0118346829,
-0.0221694801,
-0.0133227212,
-0.0166166648,
-0.0693094879,
0.0119408173,
0.0630619824,
0.0225820746,
-0.0034077242,
0.0096651213,
-0.0193485878,
-0.0113249291,
-0.0588343255,
-0.019548161,
-0.039492026,
-0.0065753022,
0.0064608464,
-0.0070979525,
0.0221296381,
-0.0466435142,
-0.0417010747,
0.0250036884,
-0.0446169265,
0.0068629361,
-0.0095768534,
0.0425326936,
0.0290491153,
0.0238915961,
-0.0197807886,
0.0115239527,
0.0335904248,
0.014700368,
0.0323152877,
0.0508608222,
-0.0062502562,
-0.0214666333,
-0.0084538991,
0.0599943995,
-0.0498396605,
-0.0867449939,
0.0376567505,
0.066864565,
0.0410334542,
-0.0524707735,
0.0483666733,
-0.0343301035,
0.0227501728,
0.0106453616,
0.0095992824,
0.0462109074,
-0.0352361575,
0.0262489878,
0.0176859349,
-0.0228617582,
0.0067785117,
0.0667130277,
-0.0065126871,
0.0216162764,
-0.0137941185,
-0.0256950296,
-0.017526079,
-0.0046932613,
0.0388936959,
0.0149207925,
-0.0460036322,
0.0047318717,
-0.1020713672,
-0.0577413104,
-0.0404265933,
-0.0147005841,
-0.0034450132,
-0.0294792242,
0.0337736569,
0.0493243039,
0.0035832846,
-0.0260119997,
-0.0294431541,
-0.0225717984,
-0.0506873354,
-0.0111702932,
-0.0434858985,
-6.000652542e-33,
-0.0275530294,
-0.0507550277,
0.0004094055,
0.0270791743,
-0.0119742714,
-0.00141027,
-0.0364428014,
0.0362349413,
0.0076560909,
0.0006929833,
-0.0453421064,
0.0329527259,
0.0147049483,
-0.0202036612,
0.0328997932,
-0.0123883635,
0.0577856265,
0.0024590553,
-0.0171429962,
0.0246012285,
-0.0110424543,
0.0096241198,
0.0029469284,
-0.0799194202,
0.0797195286,
-0.0164206214,
0.0028166557,
0.0005655067,
-0.0259640589,
0.0018009713,
0.0005921605,
0.0465999432,
0.0174959954,
0.0015647144,
0.0121181393,
0.1159744263,
-0.0357716605,
-0.0565859154,
0.0378257371,
0.0189670268,
-0.0542277172,
-0.0504580401,
-0.0077866707,
-0.0125311147,
-0.0328941867,
0.0214548782,
0.0512813441,
0.0079355203,
0.0305171609,
0.041208867,
-0.0506221391,
-0.0156856123,
-0.0307380054,
-0.0509350635,
-0.0081643499,
0.0760552734,
0.0037613481,
-0.0202752538,
-0.0126735475,
0.0062770615,
-0.03796551,
0.0029969043,
0.0374868698,
0.0083285188,
-0.0031342173,
0.025881866,
0.0323221646,
0.0703926757,
-0.0389949791,
-0.0472123027,
0.0038109468,
0.0517298952,
0.0328882597,
-0.0080190552,
0.005272083,
-0.0148951784,
-0.0145017365,
0.0025506017,
0.0608909316,
0.0147207752,
0.0024911964,
0.0035998665,
-0.0766640455,
-0.0315112621,
-0.0269500781,
-0.0087559298,
-0.033634197,
-0.0546803214,
0.0218533557,
-0.0147753479,
-0.0352205485,
-0.0164422169,
-0.0125682848,
-0.0598349944,
-0.0050234869,
-0.0316101983,
-0.0137618426,
-0.005166396,
0.0216643102,
-0.0037365416,
-0.0452925488,
0.0056845727,
-0.0033142301,
-0.0021147826,
0.0251374766,
0.029560132,
0.0107781049,
0.0236091949,
-0.0430271588,
-0.021314973,
-0.0515714586,
0.0306131318,
0.0241704024,
0.0003723937,
0.0128484881,
-0.0018266981,
-0.0270802584,
0.0253395326,
0.0170889627,
-0.014093169,
-0.0664197803,
0.0047734543,
-0.0529619418,
-0.0514380224,
-0.0377414152,
-0.0281057786,
-0.0519494675,
0.0427545086,
0.0517425686,
0.0061066155,
-0.0318996757,
-0.0861153007,
2.836e-7,
-0.0037633739,
0.0627251565,
0.0236536302,
0.0526305847,
0.0180792324,
0.0200179555,
0.0096448176,
0.0735818222,
0.0413620844,
0.0172995273,
0.0082429005,
0.0233401041,
0.0242497586,
0.0246429592,
-0.0795721859,
-0.0241426528,
-0.1025737375,
-0.0196274258,
-0.0133807175,
0.0245723836,
0.0482503511,
0.0212766323,
0.0175352935,
-0.0058227619,
-0.0196846183,
-0.0548570454,
0.0255699605,
-0.0536920689,
0.0225569382,
0.0320108794,
0.0540355183,
0.0118271029,
0.0217031371,
0.0481643677,
0.0212245565,
-0.001639785,
-0.0038454786,
0.049375698,
-0.0037388245,
0.0150550688,
0.0078608645,
0.0129775973,
0.0156608932,
-0.0650257096,
0.0512742922,
-0.0474571176,
-0.0335039422,
-0.0106422761,
0.0115433503,
-0.0234611668,
0.0255350899,
-0.0135072777,
-0.0236386545,
0.0384069197,
-0.0019287579,
-0.0382157788,
-0.0152467163,
-0.0468446277,
-0.0063565508,
-0.0326793492,
-0.0016364268,
-0.0725258738,
-0.0251782164,
-0.0033701262,
-0.0044817268,
-0.0252173524,
0.0160697643,
2.201741327e-34,
-0.0033006519,
0.0347184204,
0.0262862947,
0.0524520762,
0.072873652,
0.0143888649,
-0.0307946745,
0.023831876,
0.0406052135,
-0.0234074872,
-0.0278953146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09993v1 | Generative AI for Hate Speech Detection: Evaluation and Findings | 2023-11-16T16:09:43 | 2023-11-16T16:09:43 | Sagi Pendzel, Tomer Wullach, Amir Adler, Einat Minkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic hate speech detection using deep neural models is hampered by the
scarcity of labeled datasets, leading to poor generalization. To mitigate this
problem, generative AI has been utilized to generate large amounts of synthetic
hate speech sequences from available labeled examples, leveraging the generated
data in finetuning large pre-trained language models (LLMs). In this chapter,
we provide a review of relevant methods, experimental setups and evaluation of
this approach. In addition to general LLMs, such as BERT, RoBERTa and ALBERT,
we apply and evaluate the impact of train set augmentation with generated data
using LLMs that have been already adapted for hate detection, including
RoBERTa-Toxicity, HateBERT, HateXplain, ToxDect, and ToxiGen. An empirical
study corroborates our previous findings, showing that this approach improves
hate speech generalization, boosting recall performance across data
distributions. In addition, we explore and compare the performance of the
finetuned LLMs with zero-shot hate detection using a GPT-3.5 model. Our results
demonstrate that while better generalization is achieved using the GPT-3.5
model, it achieves mediocre recall and low precision on most datasets. It is an
open question whether the sensitivity of models such as GPT-3.5, and onward,
can be improved using similar techniques of text generation. | [
0.0426520184,
0.0729060024,
-0.023376815,
0.0163109172,
0.0060543534,
0.0537448637,
0.0204775669,
0.0201196335,
-0.0040664449,
-0.0589366592,
-0.0175053738,
-0.0478195027,
-0.0304898862,
0.0323934332,
-0.0062676049,
-0.0483150706,
0.0162213575,
0.0500067882,
0.0380214155,
-0.0412420891,
0.053671129,
0.0255288873,
0.0129253836,
0.0339870974,
-0.1132308543,
0.0259235315,
0.0447332375,
0.0072508026,
0.0325455852,
-0.0118995337,
0.0467000417,
0.033193823,
0.0173428431,
0.0690794438,
0.0000020929,
-0.0270480197,
0.0072845304,
-0.0194269232,
0.0109756077,
-0.0309498794,
0.0734844804,
-0.0305644218,
-0.012933298,
0.0346973278,
-0.0418429933,
-0.001081988,
0.0467454381,
0.0619030297,
0.0597619787,
0.0767393261,
-0.0060062772,
-0.0477192551,
0.0220959056,
0.0027003984,
0.0343324803,
0.0522294715,
0.0306908414,
-0.0541570261,
-0.0435846485,
-0.0184500422,
0.0080008451,
-0.0061459006,
0.0379615016,
0.0252275877,
0.0145713044,
-0.0082992297,
-0.0476755388,
-0.0179348346,
-0.0063006994,
0.0622208565,
-0.0772829875,
-0.0169948656,
-0.0089103375,
-0.0225311387,
-0.0393610187,
-0.074691467,
-0.007554627,
-0.0006853482,
-0.0189829692,
0.0251635443,
-0.0028500929,
-0.0092624547,
0.03346036,
0.0470956489,
0.0043245023,
0.0059133936,
0.0128546292,
-0.0280503035,
-0.0006210188,
-0.0103185046,
-0.0443631113,
-0.0066794469,
0.0162593219,
0.009083963,
-0.005527976,
0.0171089824,
-0.0769333169,
-0.0519304946,
0.0053502107,
-0.0619436689,
0.0434887968,
0.0464930534,
-0.0428092517,
-0.0258706808,
-0.0194411948,
0.0472452492,
-0.0171579216,
0.0192715209,
-0.0019883728,
0.0089244833,
-0.0153613519,
0.013873063,
-0.0204116888,
0.0050213928,
0.0059256549,
0.0272185616,
-0.055138126,
-0.0279230587,
-0.0218624566,
-0.0184557457,
-0.0157527626,
0.0350351892,
-0.02423607,
-0.0226264913,
-0.0204836242,
-0.0087064318,
-0.059025161,
0.0157967266,
-0.013626107,
-0.0912338495,
-0.0013116598,
0.033817824,
-0.0072769332,
-0.0055864896,
0.0513758436,
0.0652075484,
0.0379592143,
-0.0450076647,
-0.0563424118,
-0.032052774,
-0.0504279435,
-0.0655835867,
0.0359826945,
-0.0735564157,
0.0172727033,
-0.0389237404,
-0.0346132964,
-0.0776920468,
0.0089403959,
0.0088138161,
-0.03293024,
0.0551205762,
-0.020783931,
-0.0270205438,
0.0425423607,
0.0088170711,
0.0383796468,
0.050575383,
0.0486765504,
0.0431298837,
0.0291493014,
-0.0216242559,
0.0086607207,
0.0650601387,
0.0646362081,
0.0086072451,
-0.0518277586,
-0.0074702543,
-0.060154587,
-0.010415175,
0.0162597522,
0.0640274733,
-0.0083222222,
-0.0526938438,
0.0525286682,
0.0459668003,
-0.0462218486,
0.0298637263,
0.0824395418,
0.0213057734,
-0.0334826373,
-0.0249152351,
-0.0319119804,
-0.0179286245,
-0.0378521048,
-0.0280128699,
0.0300552547,
0.0530410744,
-0.0288419127,
-0.0657874271,
-0.018240435,
-0.0137763172,
0.0082539162,
-0.0357327461,
0.0256119985,
0.042419754,
-0.0459910743,
0.002953992,
0.0542978682,
-0.0419606492,
0.0238931868,
-0.0360462889,
0.0208596811,
0.0912799984,
0.0250234827,
0.0103903972,
-0.0146225356,
-0.0616756901,
-0.0561559349,
0.0416082032,
0.0077281939,
0.0041902503,
0.0004808896,
-0.0495274775,
0.0051321443,
0.0128182061,
0.0267337728,
0.0542904213,
0.052829206,
0.0262549054,
0.034260381,
0.0126254382,
-0.0272301119,
0.0297979042,
0.0129295858,
-0.071396336,
0.0149737354,
0.0245226566,
0.0550710745,
0.0425247364,
-0.0378169976,
-0.0404691659,
0.0151285306,
-0.0176623501,
-0.0343462266,
-0.0207848363,
-0.0538833626,
-0.0116890846,
0.0051818741,
-0.0391616486,
-0.000347116,
0.0769307092,
-0.0013507715,
-0.0030236174,
0.0576487556,
-0.0425093621,
-0.0170917045,
-0.0237180851,
-0.0220680833,
-0.0264904145,
0.0385601372,
-0.0060947859,
0.0836423114,
-0.0121803358,
-0.0254348125,
0.048956763,
-0.0144707151,
0.0394955501,
-0.0022903539,
-0.0662023202,
-0.0443701074,
-0.0158148371,
0.0178754441,
0.0030774835,
0.0250104219,
-0.0162971951,
0.0199936088,
-0.068845056,
0.0240310673,
-0.03378883,
-0.0399610028,
0.0049276729,
-0.0014013966,
-0.0279680844,
0.0302779842,
-0.0311707854,
-0.0233748611,
0.069624871,
0.0061521409,
-0.0191624872,
-0.0428615212,
-0.0300877821,
-0.0449118689,
-0.0050109723,
-0.0069069867,
-0.0123910056,
0.017498143,
-0.0285635982,
0.0336483903,
-0.0085770143,
-0.0362914465,
0.0371078178,
-0.0029953215,
-0.0694548711,
0.0206249095,
0.0240763277,
0.0235708524,
0.0326000713,
0.0576609783,
0.0785481408,
-0.0021632966,
0.0100029698,
-0.0319721811,
0.0125124166,
-0.0375945717,
0.0105732447,
-0.0300758202,
-0.0366107188,
-0.011485084,
0.0791361257,
0.0465999171,
0.0063985665,
-0.0773335397,
0.0348918252,
-0.0177328642,
-0.0508812927,
0.0162199289,
-0.0639199093,
-0.0096587474,
-0.0261663292,
-0.0313931629,
-0.0814381391,
0.0375277512,
-0.0208206773,
0.0133572016,
-0.0273794103,
-0.0151810413,
0.0153238801,
0.0584092736,
0.0489408262,
0.034602195,
-0.0320745558,
0.0183750372,
0.0142523954,
-0.0146886697,
-0.0258335229,
-0.034638565,
-0.0218600016,
-0.035429813,
-0.0021888828,
0.018436864,
-0.0108506726,
-0.0888057947,
-0.0373708941,
-0.0346687362,
-0.0429794453,
0.0562308356,
-0.0196680035,
0.0080921808,
0.0079873577,
0.0123923235,
0.0026042056,
-0.0043966137,
0.0107694734,
0.0138887074,
-0.0217228625,
0.0313311704,
-0.0408452004,
0.0155250207,
0.0213331077,
-0.040845599,
0.021634208,
0.0028382898,
0.0358734727,
-0.0343522951,
0.0206779819,
0.0057191742,
0.0243500508,
0.0138216587,
-0.0114596635,
0.0089656152,
-0.0213549174,
-0.0136248264,
0.0884630978,
0.0058599017,
-0.0074978229,
0.0043238681,
0.0435438454,
0.0312352572,
-0.0054531898,
-0.0201341864,
-0.086174041,
-0.005874353,
-0.0151103577,
0.0316798799,
-0.0907891467,
-0.0189954881,
-0.0095854755,
-0.1090763956,
0.0180143584,
-0.0126773641,
-0.0453532524,
-0.0425155386,
0.0193878449,
0.010340564,
0.0129262842,
0.0495138951,
-0.0312058982,
0.0261752158,
-0.0085605998,
0.0323579609,
-0.0495507456,
-0.034582369,
0.0082554854,
-0.0051873261,
0.059708003,
0.0695723966,
0.0384976082,
-0.0145420954,
-0.0209207498,
0.0269323476,
0.0035238732,
-0.0048482805,
-0.052557487,
0.0519980043,
-0.0160723906,
-0.0510688908,
0.0046594618,
0.0676388592,
-0.006118618,
0.0477351174,
0.0119824558,
0.0164759867,
0.0229386836,
-0.0005635858,
-0.058160305,
0.0370432585,
-0.0068806368,
0.07510373,
0.0396056138,
-0.0455492064,
0.024679983,
-0.0428454429,
0.0135828163,
-0.0815430954,
-0.0734124184,
0.0012952653,
-0.0398759507,
-0.0285374168,
-0.0534901209,
-0.0430219732,
0.0369982906,
0.022444997,
0.0143735614,
-0.033347249,
-0.0284423605,
-0.0062795444,
-0.0557631366,
0.0359385721,
0.010547786,
0.016051488,
-0.0134897996,
-0.0320175588,
-0.0112705529,
-0.0407045148,
-0.0300978646,
0.0406674258,
-0.0587713905,
-0.0400857031,
0.0699287504,
0.0908220112,
0.0159859192,
0.0210068151,
0.0047270916,
-0.0451819636,
0.0807161629,
0.0667844489,
-0.0036461921,
-0.014672081,
0.0310058445,
-0.0002701878,
-0.0014516901,
0.0121339206,
-0.0200934764,
0.0760452896,
0.0389414392,
-0.0289490279,
-0.0521655865,
-0.0025704976,
0.0138424207,
-0.0087296823,
0.036651589,
-0.0169291645,
-0.0275837984,
-0.036090333,
0.001715714,
-0.0164795592,
-0.0149991363,
-0.0356457457,
-0.004763911,
0.0100850882,
0.0042395918,
-0.0518491417,
-0.0531144515,
-0.059821967,
0.0193910152,
-0.0289387256,
0.0094769746,
0.0214103553,
0.033228077,
0.0285564158,
0.0207271241,
-0.0306511261,
0.0493043922,
-0.0096074808,
-0.0418635011,
-0.0062293359,
0.0081117032,
0.0168225318,
0.0025430673,
0.0216416251,
-0.0034693747,
0.0387910157,
-0.0259278752,
-0.08910916,
-0.019359922,
-0.0017895062,
-0.0279757045,
0.0406681858,
-0.021308545,
0.0008075442,
-0.006390329,
0.000370401,
-0.0159363654,
-0.0465591773,
0.0045190649,
0.0163739007,
-0.0286420491,
-0.032363385,
0.0509732813,
0.0115318364,
0.0670528412,
0.0475695431,
-0.013243027,
-0.0330728777,
0.0075627663,
0.0450365469,
0.018069081,
0.0192423873,
0.0231647696,
-0.0243392047,
-0.0444143638,
-0.0034718737,
-0.0241331849,
0.0327102132,
0.0036893112,
0.0651706755,
0.0524579696,
-0.0502951294,
0.0333153084,
0.0247364733,
0.0054928176,
-0.0064050276,
-0.0631277934,
0.0033302857,
-6.162129099e-33,
-0.0304563828,
-0.0197329707,
-0.0038051037,
-0.0207218174,
-0.0165660102,
-0.0375538841,
0.0244585294,
0.0135676889,
0.015415512,
0.019765038,
0.0061421199,
0.0157565754,
0.0055992468,
0.0206240546,
-0.0292939208,
-0.0284667555,
0.0614277273,
-0.0153261907,
-0.0015432369,
0.0184349045,
0.0548165143,
0.0260580424,
0.0444825254,
-0.0483485609,
0.0103016803,
-0.0314632356,
-0.016735753,
-0.0148441149,
0.0200939532,
0.0613017902,
-0.0180319045,
0.0859321207,
0.0255997032,
-0.0045537264,
0.0003633928,
0.0445049889,
-0.038292516,
-0.016497856,
0.0207919292,
-0.002751936,
0.0279166531,
-0.0248670541,
0.0604565144,
0.0192258656,
-0.0520399176,
0.0088964934,
0.0410128348,
-0.0352715291,
0.0245611407,
-0.0535987578,
-0.0832081586,
0.0176294949,
-0.0156210465,
-0.0311829783,
-0.0241254847,
0.0207636822,
0.0265256707,
0.0132892374,
-0.0463859327,
0.0124840736,
0.0156728271,
-0.0000819243,
-0.0029814092,
0.0038111049,
0.0295303818,
0.0846429691,
0.017185837,
0.0189195629,
-0.0287071336,
0.0233538654,
0.0448023975,
0.0310744308,
0.0468626842,
0.055531323,
0.0399645977,
-0.0635037646,
-0.0367231146,
0.0082701929,
0.0301087704,
-0.0261491798,
0.0326381736,
-0.0457467437,
-0.0583040006,
-0.002045966,
-0.020125214,
-0.051453732,
-0.0207104515,
-0.0460689925,
0.031860631,
0.0036574276,
-0.0267087407,
-0.0293240324,
0.0118237697,
0.0098422561,
0.008519304,
0.0351794884,
-0.0362174474,
-0.0155694392,
0.0108144991,
0.0341718644,
-0.0392208025,
-0.0154652456,
0.0375787318,
-0.0202940926,
0.0266071651,
0.0130428867,
0.0600320362,
0.0255531464,
-0.0676296949,
0.0340496674,
-0.0161805358,
0.0811374262,
-0.0154104969,
0.0262007266,
0.0036553217,
0.0475521311,
-0.0145445289,
-0.0170772579,
0.0187341534,
-0.022221202,
-0.0157884862,
-0.008620413,
-0.0311335418,
0.0104452949,
-0.032044936,
-0.0063329032,
0.0007308241,
0.0178732965,
0.0264984015,
-0.1026606038,
0.0198111683,
-0.054469388,
2.706e-7,
-0.0301549584,
0.0216337759,
0.0208358709,
0.0074636289,
0.0043616337,
0.0330849513,
0.0369276367,
0.0357742049,
-0.0186951831,
-0.0028694833,
-0.01732466,
0.0488847308,
0.0083395252,
0.0422335491,
-0.0046615773,
0.0114299264,
-0.0472738706,
0.0303205997,
-0.0620154403,
0.0077680065,
0.0152643891,
0.1075045317,
0.0693458095,
-0.0585913919,
0.0224182215,
-0.0068966099,
0.0157685652,
-0.0450083949,
-0.0223795027,
-0.010296802,
0.0728597417,
0.0511188023,
-0.0041918526,
-0.0137128578,
0.0044403234,
0.0161588136,
-0.0023163105,
0.0272747763,
0.0147050321,
-0.0169330742,
0.0148576219,
-0.0021349592,
-0.0194223095,
-0.0394372568,
0.0499552004,
0.0034989978,
0.0044744364,
-0.022736216,
-0.0276635066,
-0.0040027439,
0.021350028,
-0.0411739796,
0.0145751517,
-0.0130478265,
0.040032737,
-0.0123430891,
0.0147885326,
-0.098338224,
0.0181101002,
0.0079055037,
-0.0385375619,
-0.0313589796,
-0.0427406915,
-0.0099603003,
0.0431316644,
0.0410594046,
0.0303079002,
2.069180461e-34,
0.0317404531,
-0.0283900723,
-0.005854974,
-0.0523157381,
0.02846458,
0.0213399641,
-0.0092082312,
-0.0038952695,
0.0387302786,
-0.0228727479,
-0.0186190996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10784v1 | ExFake: Towards an Explainable Fake News Detection Based on Content and Social Context Information | 2023-11-16T15:57:58 | 2023-11-16T15:57:58 | Sabrine Amri, Henri-Cedric Mputu Boleilanga, Esma Aïmeur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | ExFake is an explainable fake news detection system based on content and
context-level information. It is concerned with the veracity analysis of online
posts based on their content, social context (i.e., online users' credibility
and historical behaviour), and data coming from trusted entities such as
fact-checking websites and named entities. Unlike state-of-the-art systems, an
Explainable AI (XAI) assistant is also adopted to help online social networks
(OSN) users develop good reflexes when faced with any doubted information that
spreads on social networks. The trustworthiness of OSN users is also addressed
by assigning a credibility score to OSN users, as OSN users are one of the main
culprits for spreading fake news. Experimental analysis on a real-world dataset
demonstrates that ExFake significantly outperforms other baseline methods for
fake news detection. | [
0.0493779145,
0.0033238623,
-0.0227890927,
0.0057325466,
-0.0112268003,
0.0066057588,
0.0126709184,
0.0152544519,
0.0230438057,
0.0143107651,
0.0155084068,
0.0012917416,
0.0132781621,
0.0887046903,
-0.0053856396,
-0.0052877115,
0.0324946195,
0.0440513305,
0.0668102503,
0.0142056802,
0.0419956818,
0.0466035977,
-0.0213892628,
0.0468707085,
-0.0023990076,
-0.0128000788,
-0.0204258971,
0.0001989475,
0.0256370958,
-0.0014274935,
-0.0257379934,
0.0017957592,
-0.004834434,
0.036933843,
0.0000018918,
-0.0209194291,
-0.0326063037,
-0.0132166445,
-0.0794299617,
-0.0006145607,
0.0049555539,
-0.0160566065,
-0.0120187867,
0.0619347617,
-0.0172805581,
0.0484950878,
0.0293160789,
0.0504844151,
0.0954934508,
0.0798931792,
-0.0326882601,
0.0015505363,
0.0216857195,
0.0232554637,
-0.0081066545,
-0.0180503633,
0.023571983,
-0.0015814141,
-0.0139254611,
0.0193755496,
0.0092799244,
-0.0208825432,
0.023900196,
-0.0639455616,
-0.0119952429,
-0.0052326415,
0.0153188659,
-0.0080447011,
-0.0011547146,
0.0453107916,
-0.043506477,
-0.0685723424,
0.0317234732,
-0.0247589722,
-0.0065967864,
0.0568746626,
-0.0051605674,
0.0129725905,
-0.0406734161,
0.0152187571,
0.0316641741,
0.0015342503,
0.0591542795,
0.0599487238,
0.0303647444,
0.0599138774,
-0.0299432389,
0.025695743,
-0.0168666448,
-0.0271280836,
0.0293342527,
-0.0419364162,
0.0297704879,
0.0365214013,
-0.0390857384,
0.0044364831,
-0.0349308252,
0.0057618939,
-0.017393332,
-0.0327256881,
-0.0193814524,
0.010800954,
0.005588531,
0.054075446,
-0.0077459323,
0.0147235496,
-0.0136644524,
-0.0114638628,
0.0325923078,
-0.0370071158,
-0.0236946177,
0.014216749,
0.0067941202,
-0.0073181787,
-0.0414625928,
-0.0093071442,
-0.0406429768,
-0.0213075895,
-0.0377793424,
0.0151699157,
0.0260509364,
0.0094130682,
-0.0272301901,
-0.0371608287,
-0.0422423333,
0.0028477281,
-0.0332516208,
0.0386788845,
-0.0183300897,
-0.0249975957,
0.0013920196,
0.0209256094,
0.0289280489,
0.0024083913,
0.0161789861,
-0.0220850054,
0.0433778986,
-0.0093351183,
-0.0567275137,
-0.0322307386,
-0.0006745075,
-0.0356580801,
-0.0426112078,
-0.0307346974,
-0.0235759541,
-0.0187876653,
-0.0284622461,
-0.0086953118,
-0.0170909408,
0.0224448945,
-0.0422350727,
0.0570505001,
-0.037205819,
0.019941695,
0.0379112735,
0.0310048163,
0.0086892359,
0.0279889684,
0.007479432,
0.076727815,
0.0616700016,
0.0210375115,
0.0575107522,
-0.0239041615,
0.0849311799,
0.0025879182,
0.0344035104,
-0.0021929881,
-0.0656424016,
-0.0427657664,
-0.0117512615,
-0.0173248947,
0.0275663249,
-0.0107752755,
0.0495225415,
-0.0515570417,
0.0107708378,
-0.0108307917,
0.0510988757,
-0.0239409767,
-0.0058273212,
-0.0065471502,
-0.0240645949,
0.0636681765,
-0.0310800169,
-0.0412248783,
-0.032027062,
0.0561388358,
-0.0288744103,
-0.0400481448,
0.0199718233,
-0.0509085618,
0.0124707343,
-0.0062531889,
-0.0176112298,
0.0417815,
-0.0648046359,
-0.0107187508,
0.0299204309,
-0.0325929523,
-0.0183665175,
-0.0625734478,
0.0728636757,
0.0439373367,
0.0130999116,
0.0304724537,
0.0184705257,
-0.0383238271,
0.0174239874,
0.0232013855,
0.0137362387,
-0.0176654551,
-0.0081192479,
-0.0282187425,
-0.006186598,
0.0041827466,
0.0070096184,
-0.0140784336,
0.0521628372,
0.0241454169,
0.0125797819,
-0.0294233058,
-0.0305388328,
0.022246521,
-0.0292307064,
0.0050766333,
-0.0301969349,
0.0281817559,
0.0167910047,
0.0313547812,
0.0484578237,
-0.020702973,
0.0399706811,
0.0316727646,
-0.0085069835,
-0.0139666982,
0.0109628793,
0.0048023518,
-0.0154601941,
-0.0559411645,
-0.0111070257,
0.0723850653,
-0.0138684688,
-0.0207676534,
0.0099018831,
-0.0403858982,
0.0073944656,
-0.0449090004,
-0.0370963179,
-0.030923659,
0.0286560804,
0.0471079946,
0.0845054388,
-0.0227857642,
-0.0345254913,
-0.0202050041,
0.0072372789,
0.0055662994,
-0.0064092549,
0.0464005955,
-0.0417638607,
-0.0160232764,
-0.0178905129,
-0.0049281619,
-0.0434755534,
-0.0195390582,
0.0349126682,
-0.0420042537,
0.0001231487,
-0.0230874009,
-0.0055142203,
0.0644681528,
0.0132950107,
0.0134887435,
0.0275273249,
-0.0385175832,
0.0700757354,
0.0151087428,
-0.0119142747,
0.018288888,
-0.034029752,
-0.0209408011,
-0.0239164736,
0.0305847097,
-0.0226415098,
0.0597922318,
0.0591506884,
-0.019560691,
-0.0282132588,
-0.0011199104,
-0.0617187843,
-0.0265217163,
-0.0351388082,
-0.0426217206,
-0.0077314088,
0.0342903621,
-0.040541593,
0.0340997949,
0.0499090441,
0.0716499537,
-0.0082273642,
0.0803176612,
0.0014994787,
-0.0509250984,
-0.0447708815,
0.0385629386,
-0.0249854028,
-0.0354651101,
-0.0027169203,
0.0175932273,
0.0247848183,
0.0171070136,
-0.0172538441,
0.0516725183,
0.0016623244,
-0.0068171439,
0.0331406854,
-0.104943268,
0.0095751407,
0.0351335481,
-0.0381426811,
-0.0315544084,
0.0871466398,
-0.0021574905,
0.043606773,
0.0356468782,
-0.0578102842,
-0.0075913849,
-0.0071475231,
-0.0189570487,
0.0161947459,
-0.0058885068,
0.0122682508,
0.0160563495,
-0.0251658354,
0.0565071441,
0.0133527769,
-0.0211636294,
-0.0075195315,
0.0002987248,
0.0545517653,
-0.0040998505,
-0.0434496552,
-0.081708163,
-0.0072139218,
-0.0264143702,
-0.0077018184,
-0.0391039476,
-0.0217782073,
-0.008451133,
0.0582876466,
0.0101005044,
-0.0259762965,
-0.0002451566,
0.014818944,
0.0302901436,
0.0159828253,
0.0056219641,
0.068083778,
-0.0293259621,
-0.0104370741,
0.0255678389,
-0.0039432752,
-0.0149637815,
-0.0310161691,
-0.0376513861,
-0.0299881976,
-0.0183814298,
0.0053642211,
-0.0197465159,
0.0560800321,
-0.0388549417,
-0.0082846927,
0.0546451993,
0.034002278,
0.0074090487,
0.0238787774,
0.0240583178,
-0.0419083275,
0.0142675079,
-0.0031195404,
-0.0332675464,
0.0043019201,
-0.0250219982,
0.0072209169,
-0.059717536,
-0.0357641354,
0.0017253805,
-0.0962098837,
0.0220679529,
-0.0393987149,
-0.0609564334,
-0.0284784641,
-0.0966749489,
-0.0040273475,
-0.0189119335,
-0.0046333214,
0.0125346743,
0.0440440886,
-0.0039080307,
-0.0042231395,
0.0116148908,
-0.0391871482,
0.0225192662,
-0.0180019494,
0.0737511441,
0.0102416398,
0.0619532503,
-0.0081856651,
-0.0553572401,
-0.012139393,
-0.0280612484,
-0.0061872071,
-0.0068840678,
0.110400103,
0.0122914501,
-0.0027265712,
-0.0685489774,
0.0671616495,
-0.0097019617,
-0.0302273072,
-0.0276836548,
0.0490100086,
-0.0150730358,
-0.0377232358,
-0.0135381315,
-0.0328469798,
0.0557990521,
0.061292734,
0.0430737697,
-0.0141762523,
-0.0034673037,
-0.0178361591,
-0.0298605822,
-0.0062293881,
-0.0528457835,
0.0273598079,
0.0138948336,
-0.0573342405,
-0.0665730983,
-0.0104267029,
-0.0438857228,
0.0548047349,
-0.0342665277,
-0.0413627774,
0.0064550219,
-0.0119270561,
-0.0366445482,
-0.0073459628,
0.0130857807,
0.0609088801,
0.0259192865,
0.0258585829,
0.007705031,
-0.052349329,
-0.0080740899,
0.0116562247,
0.014059931,
0.012773986,
0.0085227406,
0.009573698,
0.0303302519,
0.0347384214,
-0.016995972,
-0.0004590294,
0.060827896,
-0.0026142439,
-0.0454080105,
-0.0124784764,
0.0348992646,
-0.0070776572,
0.0558480397,
0.0190990511,
0.00050316,
0.0356057696,
0.0259674322,
-0.0601743497,
-0.0697729513,
0.006939047,
-0.0062017464,
0.0173090957,
0.0198821686,
0.0129680745,
-0.0120430905,
-0.0405373797,
-0.040903233,
-0.0139780529,
0.0039906395,
0.0236712452,
0.0403405055,
0.0207257196,
-0.0114347264,
0.0067864126,
-0.0401973315,
-0.0258415248,
-0.0258953087,
-0.0060946802,
-0.0111454809,
0.0085660368,
0.0854587182,
-0.0350606292,
0.0212161783,
-0.0100316377,
0.0101856757,
0.0062485524,
0.0416242257,
-0.0093104653,
0.0227402728,
0.0141733773,
-0.0180672612,
0.0071093417,
-0.0276171789,
-0.0562678054,
0.0277435761,
-0.0034736339,
-0.0124652954,
-0.0099114953,
-0.0492512733,
0.0573028028,
0.0422797576,
-0.0026426227,
0.0310250986,
0.0309199002,
0.0259649996,
-0.0508935526,
-0.0286868326,
0.0095694875,
-0.027710611,
0.055953227,
0.052726943,
-0.0362824947,
0.0047347178,
0.0034899083,
-0.0480142571,
-0.0130362771,
0.0147650642,
-0.0519642606,
0.0535141751,
0.0096960058,
-0.0120702395,
-0.0410981923,
-0.0401303507,
-0.0059931283,
0.016628826,
0.0145867784,
0.0489594564,
-0.0081579769,
0.0717242435,
0.0116139548,
0.0081377244,
-0.0654444098,
-0.014620713,
-0.0108201783,
-0.0218711924,
0.0332623571,
-5.96122389e-33,
0.0437233411,
-0.1111038104,
-0.0476295985,
-0.027892286,
0.0288974456,
0.0577496551,
-0.0614140593,
-0.0493192784,
-0.0397995263,
0.0383636989,
0.0169518311,
0.0777841359,
-0.0100849308,
0.0024486966,
-0.0827804878,
-0.0031268108,
0.0350032076,
0.0459377058,
-0.0261652675,
0.0542363599,
0.0770672709,
-0.0068541295,
0.0137196723,
-0.1153266951,
0.0516606346,
-0.0126596168,
-0.0430948846,
0.0168517493,
-0.0182210784,
0.0801807642,
0.0081979064,
0.0016624216,
0.0363813229,
-0.0351116881,
0.0372809507,
0.02486475,
-0.0351100713,
-0.0194428544,
0.025253525,
-0.0403428152,
-0.0481269993,
-0.0073210439,
0.0155311814,
-0.0281216465,
-0.0111310948,
0.0068834214,
0.0562415384,
-0.0317100585,
0.0428236909,
0.027112931,
-0.0083370013,
-0.0095107583,
-0.012063642,
0.0002281994,
-0.0513241552,
0.0405915305,
0.0051202588,
0.0086909207,
-0.0866247565,
0.022695506,
-0.0634009615,
-0.0442742296,
0.0219911225,
-0.073249869,
-0.0454700328,
0.0351882093,
0.0045375586,
0.0242455192,
-0.0745608583,
0.0037165217,
-0.0256582294,
0.0522119477,
0.1071298495,
0.1114404351,
-0.0110277766,
-0.0860265121,
-0.1193290055,
0.0226136688,
0.0313385129,
-0.0439473316,
0.0003396479,
-0.0357018784,
-0.0727909505,
0.0205980409,
0.0009106806,
-0.0332898609,
-0.0463410281,
-0.0064059692,
-0.0241801385,
0.0138842128,
-0.0676710457,
0.0373696312,
-0.0337727442,
-0.0567707904,
0.0406088345,
0.0387965962,
-0.0113667278,
-0.0144064082,
0.0358085893,
0.012330981,
-0.0248436164,
0.0211899281,
0.0033084818,
0.0182551704,
0.0137291225,
-0.005083567,
0.0450043082,
0.0378157198,
-0.0225808881,
0.0156847257,
-0.0489795357,
0.0158988312,
-0.0318546705,
-0.0347165428,
0.0098623792,
0.0259991121,
-0.0331653021,
0.0003432604,
0.020779321,
0.0181112848,
-0.0115387551,
-0.0205833074,
-0.0438387319,
0.0232748464,
-0.0462357849,
-0.0533545725,
-0.0305099189,
0.0169477761,
0.0115514901,
-0.1066012159,
0.0024035806,
0.0004976227,
2.724e-7,
-0.0139424941,
0.0378862955,
-0.0073884665,
0.0073992629,
0.0392993949,
0.0288670864,
0.0529530011,
-0.0077412734,
-0.0528713427,
-0.0878746212,
0.0097855059,
0.0458104685,
0.0037485894,
0.0392646305,
0.0046153762,
0.023405917,
-0.0492229871,
-0.0542497635,
-0.0818417221,
0.0359758921,
-0.0098307822,
0.0429192483,
0.0858016536,
-0.0305750091,
0.0155988969,
-0.0120751113,
-0.0013258017,
0.0349405222,
0.0012538217,
-0.0205277633,
0.0466918871,
-0.009573278,
0.022919761,
0.0182549004,
-0.0448159687,
0.0067096828,
-0.0104238624,
0.0192784537,
0.0025739188,
-0.0183555167,
0.0115818251,
-0.0189883355,
0.0383288153,
-0.0847318247,
0.0630448684,
0.0035304532,
-0.0545352362,
-0.0261891522,
-0.0162557121,
-0.0125996312,
-0.0129434653,
0.0164328665,
0.0616274141,
0.048042018,
-0.0163204502,
-0.0000226771,
0.010940589,
-0.0086486908,
0.0075839837,
-0.024099607,
-0.0078990012,
0.0220421925,
0.0044059143,
-0.042793829,
0.0743687451,
-0.023888059,
0.031665381,
1.979656694e-34,
-0.0245569628,
0.000612084,
0.0041858396,
-0.0384240746,
0.0381121114,
0.0423387289,
-0.0293193236,
-0.029206736,
0.0667635649,
0.0207264591,
0.0045861914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09979v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09979v1 | Unambiguity and Fewness for Nonuniform Families of Polynomial-Size Nondeterministic Finite Automata | 2023-11-16T15:52:24 | 2023-11-16T15:52:24 | Tomoyuki Yamakami | cs.FL | cs.FL, cs.CC, cs.CL | Nonuniform families of polynomial-size finite automata, which are series of
indexed finite automata having polynomially many inner states, are used in the
past literature to solve nonuniform families of promise decision problems.
Among such nonuniform families of finite automata, we focus our attention, in
particular, on the variants of nondeterministic finite automata, which have at
most "one" (unambiguous), "polynomially many" (few) accepting computation
paths, or unambiguous/few computation paths leading to each fixed
configuration. When such machines are limited to make only one-way head moves,
we can prove with no unproven hardness assumptions that some of these variants
are different in computational power from each other. As for two-way machines
restricted to instances of polynomially-bounded length, families of two-way
polynomial-size nondeterministic finite automata are equivalent in power to
families of polynomial-size unambiguous finite automata. | [
-0.0086829495,
0.051004298,
-0.0208848082,
0.0148175713,
-0.0474502966,
-0.0392853096,
-0.0085541168,
-0.0198161788,
-0.004127468,
0.0094470317,
0.0237060357,
0.0222907495,
-0.030271614,
-0.0289360601,
0.0160313062,
-0.0092721619,
0.0253807567,
-0.0648003146,
-0.013169189,
-0.0276866127,
-0.0352714621,
-0.0562654361,
-0.0377105549,
-0.0140140699,
-0.032319583,
-0.0519203171,
-0.0502361022,
-0.0208119005,
-0.0279386695,
0.0136919618,
-0.0150895249,
0.0183152966,
-0.0529049784,
0.0685435757,
0.0000020475,
-0.024239257,
-0.0272656698,
-0.0078812987,
-0.0339706019,
-0.0044941795,
-0.0500800349,
0.0389066227,
0.001591446,
0.0362314954,
0.0123154009,
0.0095608197,
0.0716286004,
-0.018811604,
-0.0073361802,
-0.0025166248,
0.0144944619,
0.0263321809,
0.0002806456,
-0.0259179175,
-0.006487472,
-0.043861974,
0.0172762293,
-0.1239729077,
-0.0367898345,
-0.0533095412,
-0.0247369222,
-0.0454397872,
-0.0374184214,
-0.0519521646,
-0.0618645884,
-0.0075577465,
-0.0121895773,
-0.0286964215,
-0.0195674375,
-0.0160387605,
0.0095452704,
0.0503490642,
-0.0127496952,
-0.0259427577,
-0.0319913924,
0.0079787262,
0.0717878118,
0.0639091209,
-0.0052513182,
0.0098545654,
-0.0181392431,
0.0633397698,
-0.0057151928,
-0.0408407971,
-0.0260081161,
0.0864133537,
0.0225726943,
0.0171409734,
0.0200477708,
0.0104529029,
0.0251026694,
-0.0208319426,
0.0038568021,
0.0112433136,
0.0013714131,
0.0310950093,
-0.0047956505,
0.0547415651,
0.0089706667,
0.018248003,
0.0747588277,
-0.0070931339,
0.0047599175,
-0.0180479642,
0.0115822684,
-0.0085483789,
-0.0098684765,
-0.0306876712,
-0.0049141296,
0.0489230491,
0.0329658873,
0.0128467791,
-0.0791701004,
0.0266303774,
-0.0113733066,
0.0376221612,
-0.0002732169,
0.0272562839,
-0.0411021374,
0.0370569639,
-0.059417665,
-0.0473614894,
-0.0048329365,
0.0100944927,
-0.0165767148,
0.0341679268,
-0.0205637477,
-0.0216471571,
-0.0339763798,
-0.0375137776,
-0.0441211462,
-0.007680269,
0.0364834294,
0.0291852001,
-0.0451124012,
0.0741512477,
0.028681118,
-0.0119974548,
0.0277372506,
-0.0283728261,
0.0268586278,
-0.0513267666,
-0.0012615151,
0.0386235081,
0.0077120415,
0.0229156855,
0.003557777,
-0.0345941447,
0.0055094007,
-0.0081415549,
0.0447201617,
0.0215093605,
0.0538263023,
0.0183767229,
-0.0404542759,
-0.0194518417,
-0.0036152815,
0.0180379394,
0.0245950315,
0.0375329442,
0.0455254391,
0.0470510274,
0.0400403291,
-0.0002267155,
-0.017050514,
0.0226487946,
0.0478320494,
-0.054817196,
0.0694974735,
-0.0246883519,
-0.0578540899,
0.0726340041,
0.0293672532,
-0.0515117608,
-0.0306391101,
-0.0107253473,
-0.0033971474,
-0.0035946092,
0.0020931519,
0.0129873026,
0.0300816614,
0.0581143126,
0.0092184003,
-0.0364993736,
-0.051370427,
-0.0071506896,
0.063994512,
-0.0161219984,
-0.0410684049,
-0.0505908951,
-0.0217888113,
-0.0523470379,
0.0073849689,
-0.036693871,
0.0568634197,
-0.0861166418,
-0.0655517355,
-0.0706174597,
-0.0119967004,
0.003323202,
-0.0234281067,
-0.0194383655,
0.0474715158,
0.0013050053,
-0.0171092059,
-0.0325239636,
-0.0404282548,
0.0428781398,
-0.0473267138,
-0.0104334382,
-0.0119355507,
-0.0213490911,
0.0575022176,
0.0187020712,
0.0047003701,
0.0641281903,
0.0420769043,
-0.0169149023,
-0.0871897712,
-0.0085548908,
-0.0207416359,
0.0325283706,
0.007701607,
-0.0028730163,
0.0265590418,
0.0116484482,
0.0381199457,
0.035694316,
0.0408471189,
-0.0157835111,
-0.013376046,
0.0327729695,
0.0117514515,
0.0051045152,
-0.0060549281,
-0.0532448888,
-0.0044142688,
0.0430804007,
0.006845857,
-0.0260886978,
-0.0184291843,
0.0243634284,
-0.0450817309,
0.0026617358,
0.0270417817,
-0.0321262293,
-0.048179362,
0.0462413095,
0.0296079088,
0.0122946287,
0.0115079144,
0.0322996341,
-0.0091707371,
-0.0281526539,
0.0385840312,
-0.0336636417,
-0.0658080429,
0.0442932211,
0.0222562142,
-0.0382332467,
0.0396432504,
-0.0063600242,
-0.0413677059,
0.0089571476,
-0.0491022989,
0.0190081298,
-0.0463025719,
-0.0059475624,
-0.006901721,
0.0218668915,
0.0039394698,
-0.0440731123,
0.0370651782,
0.018084053,
-0.0157267898,
-0.0367712043,
0.0636731759,
0.0225438066,
-0.0130081763,
0.0275070369,
0.0093525508,
-0.0578331016,
0.0142090786,
-0.0304897297,
-0.0250310674,
-0.0298721138,
-0.0557020046,
-0.0820973217,
-0.0446689166,
-0.0129514076,
-0.0295066163,
0.0327521935,
-0.0313253216,
0.0144222658,
0.0028939799,
0.0346995965,
0.0209668241,
0.0326795764,
-0.0052175373,
0.030875545,
0.0282320324,
0.043911688,
0.0522670746,
0.0041750809,
0.0236839075,
-0.0821353719,
0.0160410069,
0.0014527482,
0.0754975602,
0.0089100888,
-0.0195239112,
-0.0514280237,
0.0085749729,
-0.0302408058,
-0.0246201195,
0.0489318557,
0.0335278697,
-0.0359270722,
0.0125307813,
0.0920088813,
0.025166411,
-0.0284575783,
0.0181733184,
-0.0298678912,
0.012454208,
0.0289863925,
-0.0135399103,
-0.0342072807,
0.0601277091,
0.0312966108,
0.0410126857,
-0.0181506667,
-0.0356662497,
0.0089592738,
-0.0363510661,
0.0113708228,
-0.0145045836,
0.0594040006,
0.0421822481,
0.0196862873,
-0.0585172772,
-0.0521819144,
0.007225153,
0.0184094403,
0.0039113006,
0.0127858296,
0.0141167212,
-0.0243016109,
0.0020925819,
0.0254526064,
-0.0163767729,
0.0109661464,
-0.0063374876,
0.0282797702,
0.0210940391,
-0.0513225608,
-0.0039286683,
0.0584557876,
-0.0206188485,
-0.0254903287,
-0.0074438462,
0.0005641312,
0.0130477091,
0.038868472,
0.0446618684,
-0.014545748,
0.011369464,
-0.074740693,
0.0019476697,
0.0287402999,
-0.0004494684,
0.021230096,
-0.0162831955,
-0.0370536782,
0.0177532714,
0.0391653329,
0.0556153953,
-0.0038105308,
-0.0435583033,
-0.0110104466,
0.043797195,
-0.0884791017,
0.0199980065,
-0.0197352096,
0.0119541986,
-0.0397386067,
0.0008106127,
-0.0208650474,
-0.0539737865,
0.0106795989,
0.0066587613,
0.02108193,
-0.087838769,
0.0161368828,
0.0357817747,
-0.0360956602,
-0.0477897227,
0.0054224045,
-0.0182503909,
0.0094951177,
0.029923724,
0.0581877753,
0.0632841736,
-0.0593892187,
0.0382075757,
-0.0148751596,
-0.0684575066,
-0.0076232916,
0.0060030371,
-0.0688144863,
-0.0123388581,
0.0108792093,
-0.017795587,
0.0060369289,
-0.0717998743,
0.0464875288,
-0.0055453577,
-0.0090146,
-0.0505445413,
0.0862393528,
-0.018558206,
0.0230984818,
0.0195874535,
-0.0149030508,
-0.0741192251,
-0.0361866206,
-0.0316862203,
0.0169247575,
0.0385869071,
-0.0652524605,
0.0055582803,
-0.0599122643,
-0.0218302142,
0.0108407047,
0.0503750481,
-0.0030222854,
-0.0365048684,
-0.0130730467,
0.0102550192,
-0.0027050122,
0.0376397073,
0.0171019081,
0.063074179,
-0.0337406695,
0.0211435761,
0.1112283021,
0.0626583919,
-0.0337070301,
-0.0671964362,
-0.0653117523,
-0.007295059,
-0.035786625,
-0.0471662655,
0.0090475054,
0.0358973965,
-0.0224730708,
-0.0270132143,
0.0541299582,
0.0058415569,
0.0400365591,
-0.0001231542,
0.0236587152,
-0.0887882337,
-0.0432884954,
0.0443632603,
0.0366090611,
0.0172319692,
0.0450428016,
0.0224029031,
0.0550657362,
0.018831525,
-0.010149098,
0.0348943919,
-0.0011068269,
0.0278468244,
-0.0107555697,
0.022472648,
0.0592113361,
-0.0275606941,
-0.03029388,
0.0472915359,
0.000136053,
0.0961437449,
0.0586515442,
-0.0048732464,
0.041871693,
0.0251610801,
-0.0012808313,
-0.0290168263,
0.0456964448,
-0.0550904758,
-0.0225487482,
-0.0087820459,
-0.0685140118,
0.0122033982,
0.0222814828,
0.0622292794,
0.0323045664,
0.0278317183,
-0.0049620587,
-0.0286521651,
-0.0042570648,
-0.0113986358,
0.0348178297,
0.0185850784,
0.001298853,
0.0381805636,
-0.0236252546,
0.0031545365,
0.0578306168,
-0.0811783522,
-0.0010219573,
0.0044239699,
-0.0298953,
0.0253630821,
0.0059276228,
0.0136680249,
0.0139922835,
-0.0474035218,
-0.0301088151,
0.031135181,
-0.0195812862,
-0.0437427722,
0.0329021439,
-0.0141531825,
0.0259692371,
0.045337379,
0.0308892261,
0.0332088172,
0.0262593534,
-0.0349826813,
0.079021953,
-0.0154008456,
0.0140254935,
-0.0549847707,
-0.056315396,
-0.029085204,
0.0060190163,
0.0634536743,
-0.009933183,
-0.0207033493,
-0.0199377462,
-0.0094767762,
-0.0117622307,
0.0800703764,
-0.0185519326,
0.0002623869,
-0.0484879129,
0.0694373176,
-0.0002089576,
-0.0149881179,
-0.0475637466,
0.052643884,
0.0132027511,
0.0227514114,
-6.491832856e-33,
-0.0089385733,
-0.024246648,
-0.0499169827,
-0.0355643667,
0.0088348165,
-0.0002428884,
-0.0331958905,
0.0353875868,
-0.0039231619,
-0.0274004713,
-0.0285265073,
0.0172215793,
0.0235579107,
0.0133392885,
0.0097494451,
-0.0146269323,
0.0312198978,
0.0052665425,
-0.0652419254,
-0.0096087074,
0.0023371305,
-0.0736838281,
-0.0201216862,
0.0504646376,
0.0131852925,
-0.0333671421,
-0.0582809076,
0.0339896418,
-0.0530886613,
0.0052852035,
0.0183803886,
0.0080593117,
0.0118458765,
-0.0155137172,
-0.0037737051,
0.011583331,
0.037976373,
-0.0653376058,
-0.0041366555,
-0.0443694815,
-0.0238460097,
-0.0335698426,
0.0054757125,
0.0010803706,
-0.019692339,
0.0373433344,
-0.0313752145,
0.0381001644,
0.0230100639,
0.0180930495,
0.0234250464,
0.0125855077,
0.0029194325,
0.0085108392,
-0.0073132417,
-0.0097499844,
0.0092338054,
-0.0835877731,
0.0365477987,
0.0062748021,
0.0404757187,
0.0210466646,
-0.029969776,
-0.0823701471,
0.0070583718,
-0.0081650941,
0.0284386203,
-0.0045829094,
0.0107777687,
-0.0232375748,
-0.0588242821,
0.0348388068,
-0.0095578348,
-0.0677530989,
0.0076420782,
0.0263880845,
-0.0217008386,
-0.0022881373,
0.0327377543,
0.028975077,
0.0155633809,
-0.0211094972,
-0.0641538352,
-0.0337785631,
-0.0479428396,
-0.0575155839,
-0.011707521,
0.0505687036,
-0.0106601613,
-0.0102900108,
0.0106912116,
0.016551815,
0.0340997651,
0.0571975894,
-0.0518975854,
0.0555916131,
0.0588928871,
0.0373670384,
-0.0172696412,
-0.0102627976,
0.0451431237,
0.0044278647,
-0.0382057726,
-0.0488068387,
-0.014784852,
0.0083181318,
-0.0454233624,
0.0281180255,
-0.0560938492,
-0.0027694292,
0.0136441402,
0.0021038009,
0.0022975176,
-0.0136596737,
0.0644925982,
-0.0248573963,
-0.0391440913,
-0.030578766,
-0.0270177238,
0.0046344856,
0.0078573525,
0.1185092106,
-0.023742022,
0.0574193224,
-0.0033181219,
-0.0244593639,
0.0161698759,
0.0779766291,
0.0173263755,
-0.0342580043,
-0.0067611877,
-0.0163901672,
2.999e-7,
-0.004395742,
-0.0180694573,
0.0381671749,
0.0531282984,
0.0573084354,
0.0140877031,
-0.0006071468,
0.0291087087,
-0.0518764667,
0.0785855576,
-0.0130211115,
0.0093487492,
-0.0382062942,
-0.0438844673,
0.0565081835,
0.0161026102,
0.0599071346,
0.0631368831,
0.0056952657,
0.0068888813,
0.0400170796,
0.0109006558,
0.0047909361,
0.0349137709,
0.0006201899,
0.025761608,
-0.0347919054,
0.0116574541,
0.0559518673,
-0.0123670734,
-0.0133997835,
-0.0022839834,
0.0307442714,
-0.0115021095,
0.0392458551,
0.0186789334,
-0.0399670377,
0.0696919486,
0.0172550697,
0.0180576351,
-0.0001563909,
0.0039088135,
0.0171227455,
0.0970726088,
0.0162676834,
0.0371298529,
-0.0736153424,
-0.0317426212,
0.0057830676,
0.0097841099,
0.0250258632,
0.065234378,
-0.0276541747,
0.0419458412,
-0.0506653674,
-0.0066810506,
0.0396365449,
0.0017376606,
0.0367743447,
-0.0234804209,
-0.0038923728,
-0.0250953399,
0.043815922,
0.0529947616,
0.014671416,
-0.0165432803,
-0.0245954096,
2.412884678e-34,
0.0251981542,
-0.091330722,
0.0264998619,
-0.0121568646,
0.0184191838,
-0.0324297845,
-0.0139156478,
-0.0386695303,
0.0478420667,
-0.0195930414,
-0.0437910631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09948v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09948v2 | Hijacking Large Language Models via Adversarial In-Context Learning | 2023-11-16T15:01:48 | 2024-06-15T18:54:54 | Yao Qiang, Xiangyu Zhou, Dongxiao Zhu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | In-context learning (ICL) has emerged as a powerful paradigm leveraging LLMs
for specific downstream tasks by utilizing labeled examples as demonstrations
(demos) in the precondition prompts. Despite its promising performance, ICL
suffers from instability with the choice and arrangement of examples.
Additionally, crafted adversarial attacks pose a notable threat to the
robustness of ICL. However, existing attacks are either easy to detect, rely on
external models, or lack specificity towards ICL. This work introduces a novel
transferable attack against ICL to address these issues, aiming to hijack LLMs
to generate the target response or jailbreak. Our hijacking attack leverages a
gradient-based prompt search method to learn and append imperceptible
adversarial suffixes to the in-context demos without directly contaminating the
user queries. Comprehensive experimental results across different generation
and jailbreaking tasks highlight the effectiveness of our hijacking attack,
resulting in distracted attention towards adversarial tokens and consequently
leading to unwanted target outputs. We also propose a defense strategy against
hijacking attacks through the use of extra clean demos, which enhances the
robustness of LLMs during ICL. Broadly, this work reveals the significant
security vulnerabilities of LLMs and emphasizes the necessity for in-depth
studies on their robustness. | [
0.0184600838,
0.0751010254,
-0.0174027421,
0.0615824983,
-0.0250294451,
-0.0126321279,
0.0329306573,
-0.0004352317,
0.0237401072,
-0.0259257928,
-0.0447025709,
-0.0157594439,
0.0047922125,
-0.0010433306,
0.0846588835,
-0.0211138818,
0.0696969479,
-0.0379961058,
-0.0563740656,
0.0136090992,
-0.0040908842,
-0.0262258388,
0.0077770301,
0.0370219611,
-0.007832814,
-0.0027758777,
-0.0332301036,
0.0383262709,
0.0063266838,
-0.0213454552,
0.0288250893,
0.0331118628,
0.0148216728,
0.0646260753,
0.0000021628,
-0.03309476,
-0.0394136123,
0.0138375694,
-0.0345093943,
0.0163632873,
-0.0020885398,
0.0141505236,
-0.0306520667,
0.0152652701,
-0.0510504879,
0.0290823895,
0.0052111284,
0.0426290557,
0.0781126916,
0.0951853991,
0.0031699135,
0.0217868406,
0.0106434403,
-0.0322034098,
0.0284555461,
-0.0532086454,
0.007044177,
-0.0735235363,
0.0125558637,
0.0157149471,
0.0031754174,
0.0241824817,
0.0353880264,
-0.009371683,
-0.0755038336,
0.0044832216,
-0.015520297,
0.0020703145,
-0.008184663,
0.0603990555,
-0.0618942231,
-0.0052560912,
0.0025158094,
0.0072297021,
0.0415660366,
-0.0018781818,
-0.0318648815,
0.0078065419,
0.0048573334,
-0.0046526808,
-0.0006023932,
-0.0473953187,
0.06584768,
0.0063291579,
0.0060830563,
0.0377587974,
0.0136538809,
-0.0263865013,
-0.0051070661,
-0.0415000357,
-0.0001174159,
-0.0587483495,
0.0035219751,
0.0205447786,
-0.0534283556,
0.0215212293,
-0.1072193459,
-0.058545202,
0.014925031,
0.0004700949,
0.0449191928,
0.0180615801,
-0.0102969538,
0.0239569712,
-0.0220150445,
0.029564783,
-0.0292212777,
0.0756532997,
-0.0184472222,
0.0168237258,
-0.0103430972,
-0.015954705,
-0.0148938205,
0.0272283033,
-0.0507131517,
0.0049904115,
-0.0126019279,
0.0568015203,
-0.015437806,
0.0243272614,
-0.0638813972,
0.0246588327,
-0.0153294606,
0.0100161349,
0.0199142471,
-0.0474413782,
0.0056998404,
-0.0172257144,
0.0300071221,
-0.0884469301,
-0.0533659458,
0.0253216103,
-0.0736955926,
-0.0157710668,
-0.0145936366,
0.1332416534,
-0.0092900964,
-0.051601965,
-0.0593912415,
-0.0770189986,
-0.008712505,
-0.0194877796,
0.0271860287,
-0.0772049576,
-0.0185248237,
-0.0233120471,
-0.0332710855,
-0.0826022997,
0.0119162817,
0.0379767418,
-0.0153025249,
0.0758204907,
0.0097460691,
-0.0330720022,
0.007612525,
0.0475832261,
-0.0357479677,
0.0525418632,
-0.0049913321,
0.0514516868,
0.0537334606,
0.0028403054,
0.0437590554,
0.0457476564,
0.0543249324,
0.0366856605,
-0.0432199724,
0.0094774384,
0.0548999123,
0.0232437849,
-0.0139832459,
0.0408150107,
-0.013471921,
-0.0453440659,
0.1074581519,
0.0424599312,
-0.0577780679,
0.008218009,
0.007454705,
-0.022880042,
-0.0061361268,
0.0103510292,
-0.0921673775,
-0.0010769441,
-0.0702036843,
-0.0313319005,
0.0055175689,
0.0129519403,
-0.0025866998,
-0.0187940318,
0.0320022069,
-0.012371243,
-0.0237863716,
0.0273472797,
0.0016144692,
0.0627189055,
-0.0436632931,
0.0402882472,
0.0061576804,
-0.0144525543,
-0.0175223276,
-0.0826731622,
-0.0142426752,
0.0256721359,
0.0558405481,
-0.0319533348,
-0.0005944972,
-0.0329578184,
0.0272746459,
0.0313079134,
-0.0082406364,
0.0021061497,
0.0095515419,
-0.0096068447,
-0.0273488034,
-0.0493889935,
0.0122836418,
0.0149182882,
0.034611892,
-0.0046474496,
-0.0008332423,
-0.0344236568,
-0.0053165667,
0.0467733443,
-0.0035396724,
-0.067601189,
0.0218737293,
0.0352985524,
0.0210974943,
-0.0013033139,
0.0051473444,
0.0369708538,
0.0594391525,
-0.0030203804,
0.0419553556,
-0.0324618183,
-0.0359974876,
-0.0521144345,
0.0141789755,
-0.0262982175,
-0.0433441289,
0.0545296259,
-0.0362723991,
-0.0077278684,
0.0255646631,
-0.0279727876,
0.0451077595,
-0.0044267406,
0.0082842931,
0.0032320826,
0.0339640789,
-0.0478451848,
0.0327776633,
-0.0247014891,
-0.0106340898,
0.0403185114,
0.0478788875,
-0.0251573715,
-0.0264782086,
-0.0384271666,
0.0130592631,
-0.0404914059,
0.0075572804,
-0.0310084466,
0.0065420098,
-0.0199239235,
-0.0071364441,
-0.0295812115,
-0.0172820147,
-0.0537185967,
0.0211724918,
0.0266209189,
0.0152053572,
-0.0239916891,
-0.0307858381,
0.0047322805,
-0.0176688898,
-0.0186081696,
0.0285010692,
-0.0064531886,
0.0113331852,
-0.0235338584,
-0.0070164781,
-0.0039090374,
0.0089808768,
0.0644816756,
-0.0508430824,
0.0006344091,
-0.0127735008,
-0.0012289128,
0.0279156342,
0.0365839005,
-0.0263432935,
0.0084507987,
0.059072867,
0.0128115723,
0.0119941561,
0.0755918026,
0.0221850872,
0.0636655092,
0.051444672,
0.0005825311,
-0.0424038433,
-0.0037463091,
0.024268169,
-0.0313571915,
-0.0477027632,
0.0015594366,
0.0458495058,
0.0464383326,
0.0343670025,
-0.0041831532,
-0.0038350355,
0.0465370342,
-0.0001027065,
-0.0589032397,
-0.0452301987,
-0.0013622087,
-0.0720901936,
-0.0083265826,
-0.012374864,
-0.0783995837,
0.0699819624,
-0.0343948863,
0.0065232329,
-0.0074850074,
-0.0525202006,
0.0303766727,
0.0285157952,
-0.0170619693,
0.0017994399,
0.0281824488,
-0.0444572344,
-0.0652897358,
-0.0213822573,
0.0046306271,
-0.0240969658,
0.0431084037,
-0.0317174084,
-0.0133941676,
0.0020873819,
-0.0219574086,
-0.0866192132,
-0.0656021908,
0.0221812427,
0.0129386783,
0.0173486117,
-0.0311950669,
-0.0114495056,
-0.0466226526,
0.0403767675,
0.0059871618,
-0.0218238253,
-0.0104861138,
-0.0375544876,
0.0371092819,
0.0511331595,
-0.0240064338,
0.0035796626,
-0.0246070232,
0.0184544772,
0.0828283429,
0.0563336834,
-0.0186271258,
-0.0012364736,
0.0077330964,
0.0214017201,
0.0018471469,
0.0023490856,
0.0405028649,
0.0232723318,
-0.0453767404,
-0.0326715484,
0.0371409357,
0.0134880589,
-0.0427382253,
0.0222310163,
0.0219643358,
0.0193840042,
0.0149257015,
0.009890005,
-0.0436182022,
-0.0317639969,
0.047614716,
0.0805914551,
-0.0069787279,
-0.0047746142,
-0.0357685946,
-0.1173705384,
0.0091912858,
0.0007588173,
-0.0612765141,
0.0022049362,
-0.0281833373,
-0.0127412397,
0.0555595495,
0.0585529245,
0.0093038874,
0.0029146823,
0.0046458798,
0.0074461908,
0.0202977657,
-0.0767652094,
-0.0004657427,
-0.0320971608,
0.0264050495,
0.0843158811,
-0.0028698333,
-0.0043196743,
-0.0045982068,
0.0862536654,
-0.0211940799,
0.0010125182,
-0.0092663858,
0.032172665,
-0.0099335648,
-0.0185044464,
-0.0038246652,
0.0664716959,
-0.012623921,
-0.0444441326,
0.0240092613,
0.0560877509,
-0.0146098463,
-0.0009328282,
-0.0295324922,
-0.0453727208,
0.066910252,
0.046516493,
0.0329689682,
-0.0587717853,
-0.0106740948,
-0.0717292428,
-0.0212213211,
-0.034540873,
-0.023295315,
0.0134072145,
0.0282507055,
0.0038369983,
-0.0490779877,
-0.0235344116,
-0.0083287423,
0.0587139875,
0.0119427023,
0.0034332357,
-0.0641150847,
0.0021178836,
-0.0300755687,
0.0225856733,
-0.01924414,
0.058192905,
-0.0609507672,
0.0050698472,
0.0062962496,
-0.0369467214,
-0.0096316235,
0.0328405015,
-0.0567130893,
-0.0993660167,
0.0089063477,
0.0666585043,
0.0128852334,
0.055820033,
-0.0294630695,
-0.0406259708,
0.0810438991,
0.0775849,
-0.0105919763,
0.0218421686,
0.0688473582,
-0.0209266152,
0.0043863254,
0.0448341146,
-0.0521622747,
-0.0315150954,
0.088115409,
0.0093853166,
-0.0404924713,
0.0099698007,
0.031742502,
-0.0018509382,
0.0656794012,
-0.0297590755,
-0.0024742612,
0.0217391104,
0.0486425608,
0.0089382799,
-0.0319785811,
-0.0163387507,
0.0012742913,
0.0051318146,
-0.0032929929,
0.037807256,
0.0135742109,
0.0256739799,
0.001532226,
-0.0093875816,
0.035780251,
0.0059153442,
0.0331562608,
0.0532955341,
0.0462312996,
0.0007981746,
0.0520454608,
-0.0088099726,
0.0334462337,
-0.0105507635,
0.0371131673,
0.0309752952,
-0.0065949461,
-0.0123157119,
0.0413022451,
-0.0692683011,
-0.0282517206,
-0.0236028675,
0.0398562253,
0.0193509758,
-0.0123223457,
-0.0201495085,
-0.02085297,
-0.0065785409,
-0.0252080578,
-0.0263418201,
-0.0112149063,
-0.0558264665,
0.0227891337,
-0.0017260931,
0.0223034415,
0.0280846599,
0.0778758973,
0.0014089419,
0.0595308132,
0.0314911455,
0.0084623117,
-0.043329481,
-0.0153641384,
0.0819010586,
0.0123767648,
-0.0243984573,
-0.0310422014,
-0.0118093956,
-0.0898876265,
-0.0341331735,
0.0014754763,
-0.0078494465,
0.0046717543,
0.0185901187,
0.0608596578,
0.0079328325,
0.038385883,
-0.04125515,
0.0378612652,
0.0302172545,
-0.0838707238,
0.0112388795,
-6.215522624e-33,
0.008386774,
-0.0611993037,
-0.0187449697,
-0.030373238,
0.0161055122,
-0.0085811447,
-0.0354426838,
0.0046605798,
-0.0087136636,
-0.0297355931,
-0.0378578939,
0.0020241679,
0.0014296387,
0.0385833308,
-0.0343181901,
-0.0587752797,
0.011019663,
-0.0015079237,
-0.0299760737,
0.0307816528,
0.0379732735,
0.0297664795,
0.0375389792,
-0.0564007759,
0.0351388082,
-0.0205821674,
-0.034654744,
0.0217098948,
-0.0589658171,
0.0431435928,
0.0057183485,
0.032434579,
-0.0095417695,
-0.0195853803,
-0.0215460621,
0.0457019992,
-0.0111077102,
-0.0132023767,
-0.0063209524,
0.0120144356,
-0.0291267615,
-0.0483015031,
0.0454415157,
-0.0184243992,
-0.0057869665,
0.0114629911,
-0.0128595885,
-0.0007739331,
-0.0253829397,
-0.0077426778,
-0.0274955351,
-0.0020040802,
0.004671827,
-0.0321700498,
0.0104627609,
0.0150441574,
0.01832054,
-0.0249306764,
-0.0441445224,
0.0373869278,
0.0130024059,
0.0291245207,
0.0741107389,
0.0300399568,
0.0015830689,
0.0615925603,
0.0031492061,
-0.0024851023,
0.0183023643,
-0.0219813399,
0.0151900463,
0.0513283908,
0.0507740006,
0.0519086048,
0.0618311092,
-0.0194889493,
-0.0357790962,
0.0127952434,
0.0054725166,
0.0169460941,
0.0345473997,
0.022203939,
-0.0245927665,
0.0040923543,
-0.0211279523,
-0.0304005481,
-0.0284741055,
-0.0332272686,
0.0563802831,
0.0101225479,
-0.0239612292,
-0.0238942802,
0.0124661801,
-0.043965213,
-0.0268867109,
0.0177057423,
0.0065754424,
-0.0281683262,
0.0076881722,
-0.0069365236,
-0.0052700578,
0.0002104561,
0.0042215111,
-0.0711217299,
0.0224841628,
-0.0016229349,
0.0159252882,
0.0370177291,
-0.0542393476,
-0.0069205011,
-0.0342366435,
0.0575343817,
0.0264432579,
-0.0023885486,
0.0505789518,
-0.0276754033,
-0.0220426861,
-0.0029045325,
0.0055607003,
-0.0306548607,
-0.0465273336,
0.0154455956,
-0.0536666326,
0.0159209799,
-0.0221461132,
-0.0098870909,
-0.004624641,
0.0424944311,
0.0524066053,
-0.0848665684,
0.0036052002,
-0.0152553655,
2.993e-7,
-0.0208241213,
0.0102192136,
0.0102115916,
0.0143793793,
0.0239358619,
0.0585666448,
-0.033584252,
0.0649095401,
-0.0120807858,
-0.058971025,
-0.0358721949,
-0.0110932197,
0.060768038,
0.0318726562,
-0.0851148367,
0.0152365286,
-0.0445414893,
0.0275740288,
-0.0482427068,
-0.0017953992,
0.0191288069,
0.1022718176,
0.0033374517,
-0.037994042,
0.0042409347,
-0.0555527546,
0.0119810244,
-0.0338957906,
0.0081298444,
-0.0224610958,
0.0117029827,
0.0185505245,
0.0207129363,
0.0104188807,
-0.0435913801,
-0.0216581039,
-0.0166168492,
0.0111586479,
0.0304292683,
-0.0598673709,
-0.0412428677,
-0.0292833894,
0.0072855921,
-0.0405146107,
0.0742462128,
-0.0177083295,
0.0020225253,
-0.0214686356,
0.0141100409,
-0.0474075563,
0.0136672864,
-0.0357260071,
-0.0046084491,
-0.0082792621,
0.0143426359,
0.0325602926,
0.0126431333,
-0.0680703148,
-0.035881564,
-0.000005773,
-0.0376203395,
-0.0207127742,
-0.0430983715,
0.0614324734,
0.0160638746,
-0.0106242998,
-0.0115122171,
2.996105282e-34,
-0.0109243076,
-0.024733942,
0.0348386765,
0.0273184292,
0.0035730894,
0.006860591,
0.026145082,
0.019023912,
0.0318354443,
-0.0291569494,
-0.0366776772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09945v1 | An Attention-Based Denoising Framework for Personality Detection in Social Media Texts | 2023-11-16T14:56:09 | 2023-11-16T14:56:09 | Qirui Tang, Wenkang Jiang, Yihua Du, Lei Lin | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | In social media networks, users produce a large amount of text content
anytime, providing researchers with a valuable approach to digging for
personality-related information. Personality detection based on user-generated
texts is a universal method that can be used to build user portraits. The
presence of noise in social media texts hinders personality detection. However,
previous studies have not fully addressed this challenge. Inspired by the
scanning reading technique, we propose an attention-based information
extraction mechanism (AIEM) for long texts, which is applied to quickly locate
valuable pieces of information, and focus more attention on the deep semantics
of key pieces. Then, we provide a novel attention-based denoising framework
(ADF) for personality detection tasks and achieve state-of-the-art performance
on two commonly used datasets. Notably, we obtain an average accuracy
improvement of 10.2% on the gold standard Twitter-Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
(Twitter-MBTI) dataset. We made our code publicly available on GitHub. We shed
light on how AIEM works to magnify personality-related signals. | [
0.0042674062,
0.0385796912,
-0.0375925601,
-0.0091962274,
-0.0007853699,
0.0178851616,
0.0277192239,
0.0181658361,
-0.0066940975,
0.0516058207,
0.0160445739,
0.0029788292,
0.0109945973,
0.0053152046,
0.0198555086,
-0.0316467658,
0.0169374309,
0.0376514234,
0.068502605,
0.0041709039,
0.0284230579,
0.0295666419,
0.0507846028,
0.009683717,
-0.004582284,
-0.0302275792,
-0.0009880762,
0.0167189036,
0.0411045142,
-0.0017063037,
0.0278064217,
0.0452315323,
-0.0480920672,
0.0319201909,
0.0000020514,
0.0128650237,
-0.0178458691,
-0.0099016577,
0.0331694297,
-0.0065782098,
0.0876112506,
0.043908868,
0.0376818515,
0.003523513,
-0.0412528738,
-0.0165639594,
0.0359604582,
0.058370173,
0.06806162,
0.0572524518,
-0.0184829868,
-0.035079319,
0.0134060057,
-0.0216133706,
0.0459807292,
-0.0399153233,
0.0084694047,
-0.0758099407,
-0.0120237777,
0.0379455127,
0.0218165182,
0.0374297947,
0.0075013712,
0.018261373,
0.02410377,
-0.0064056907,
0.013114199,
-0.0202517696,
0.0338263325,
0.084010087,
0.0090346448,
-0.0113958176,
-0.0024811192,
-0.0185680091,
0.0192184467,
-0.0243915375,
0.0136470553,
-0.0190303158,
-0.0215503015,
-0.0084690666,
0.0062292707,
0.0314201117,
0.0034268249,
-0.0096955104,
-0.0312398151,
-0.003764458,
-0.0329197273,
-0.0349996872,
-0.0032175204,
0.0011848985,
0.0334475972,
-0.0458097756,
0.0510968603,
0.0128977457,
0.0244535636,
-0.0036897939,
-0.0861129612,
-0.0362352803,
-0.0084042968,
-0.0325835533,
-0.0383763425,
-0.0296857934,
-0.0472095981,
0.0289404038,
0.0972872004,
-0.0161836687,
0.0028705734,
0.0176489018,
0.0076344139,
-0.0327290781,
-0.02930912,
0.0114801144,
0.0076006954,
0.0018149044,
0.0147884591,
-0.0002798879,
-0.0529292151,
-0.0045916266,
-0.0057625799,
-0.0229306687,
-0.0190778822,
0.0171303395,
-0.0357202068,
0.0140113831,
-0.0249510072,
0.0101980241,
-0.0273245741,
-0.0432473496,
-0.0115512982,
-0.0101939049,
0.0035508822,
0.0194246154,
0.0713118166,
-0.0318241157,
0.0120662758,
0.0018641318,
0.0339522399,
-0.0724249259,
-0.0309962798,
-0.0344263613,
-0.0113210604,
-0.069391124,
-0.0145248082,
-0.0431137197,
0.0408490337,
-0.0016048399,
-0.0207200572,
-0.0737949386,
0.0020233712,
0.064019151,
-0.0101634935,
0.0339090526,
-0.0151286703,
0.032576967,
-0.0021915627,
0.0417360142,
0.0457715951,
0.0158826411,
-0.0007740569,
0.0388155542,
0.0310544316,
-0.0335490629,
0.0317901187,
0.0419077426,
0.0090419501,
-0.0182812586,
0.0168804191,
-0.0008510485,
-0.0344453789,
-0.0055326931,
0.0393324494,
0.0444502719,
-0.0144570703,
-0.0500454232,
0.0736584961,
0.0429742187,
0.0451955386,
0.0425775126,
-0.0054059848,
0.1054013968,
0.0214064978,
0.0067524719,
-0.0645844564,
0.0206244197,
-0.0387832783,
-0.0030020298,
0.0245328285,
0.0317625068,
-0.0218516644,
-0.037189465,
0.0257031228,
-0.0077580009,
0.0485754572,
0.0292892214,
-0.0199210402,
0.0068174321,
-0.0100870887,
0.0084409323,
0.0653422251,
-0.0441411845,
-0.0288844816,
-0.0198169909,
0.0062364596,
0.0766782984,
0.0004611649,
-0.043664854,
0.0122817308,
-0.0172920525,
-0.0233524553,
0.0304107424,
-0.0327330977,
0.0225527193,
0.0387497507,
-0.0439745039,
0.0190608166,
0.002880377,
-0.0186324958,
-0.0144425901,
0.0408729538,
0.0598665103,
-0.0082910107,
0.0138899032,
-0.0278812349,
0.0065450529,
-0.0035239861,
-0.0562494621,
0.0219720043,
0.0497773625,
0.0093815885,
0.0410858728,
-0.0075255902,
-0.0346741602,
0.0088872341,
0.0006052359,
-0.0036492054,
-0.0085165855,
0.0009124082,
-0.0311730895,
0.0354287699,
-0.0312152132,
-0.0917836353,
0.0483775362,
-0.0173035972,
0.0080748051,
0.0427267291,
-0.0648612306,
-0.0000556724,
0.0278386213,
-0.0309990812,
-0.0235334188,
0.0829967335,
-0.0182024147,
0.0786200687,
-0.0309532974,
-0.0077477386,
0.0038759608,
-0.0388763882,
-0.0415776558,
-0.0549705252,
-0.0355600119,
-0.0626021773,
0.0153312692,
0.0119740907,
-0.0061495635,
0.0156973768,
-0.0390006378,
-0.0096800188,
-0.0571325906,
-0.0036745067,
0.0011808382,
-0.0069620758,
-0.014571405,
0.0398504362,
-0.0244956594,
-0.0044272793,
-0.0565564558,
-0.0011581411,
-0.0144726699,
-0.0148794465,
0.0424629189,
-0.0269034225,
0.0188823864,
-0.052555941,
-0.00918072,
-0.0068314727,
0.0249017403,
-0.0124787129,
0.0219030753,
-0.0026353882,
0.0104863811,
-0.0374462381,
0.0150114195,
0.0075921887,
-0.0337118581,
0.0055691865,
-0.0404435098,
-0.0143040968,
0.0684376657,
0.0429080389,
0.0383168831,
-0.0478852168,
0.0141740683,
0.0010728433,
0.0257311892,
-0.0123029128,
0.0468521714,
-0.0340858251,
-0.0574459322,
0.0232165083,
0.0305876732,
0.0002181104,
0.0267532412,
-0.0218709297,
0.0065079657,
0.040699143,
-0.0296773911,
0.0518959127,
0.0924563482,
-0.0050338968,
0.0018071019,
-0.0341513082,
0.0156744011,
0.080982022,
0.0122252721,
-0.0002910534,
-0.0183965266,
-0.0411290415,
-0.0069327662,
0.0355301388,
0.0107001718,
0.0114061246,
0.0665776059,
-0.0308630299,
0.0057492713,
-0.0469183289,
0.0030468085,
-0.0198769793,
0.0380585641,
0.0756300092,
-0.0395412222,
0.0430896431,
-0.0251296684,
-0.0195855089,
-0.076495342,
-0.0467553362,
-0.0619141534,
0.0074408562,
-0.0631238446,
-0.0480001904,
-0.0590429679,
0.0299355611,
-0.0233452171,
-0.0309149753,
-0.0188637804,
-0.0054269778,
0.0588270091,
0.0399746969,
-0.0041669174,
0.0179251358,
-0.0428671464,
-0.0347274393,
0.0384898372,
-0.0782497004,
0.0039014048,
0.0034171271,
-0.0376505926,
0.0049007554,
-0.0051866639,
0.0068655484,
-0.0085274447,
0.0600738525,
-0.0208777077,
0.0037575716,
0.0938588455,
0.0089842994,
-0.0116499467,
0.0242546499,
0.0530044548,
0.0170818511,
0.0084601985,
0.0298953038,
-0.0363686755,
-0.0512908474,
-0.0422500297,
0.0535058901,
-0.0093599027,
-0.0279430859,
-0.0270355567,
-0.0241373181,
0.0219128449,
-0.0200000126,
-0.0385289714,
-0.0323549844,
-0.0300818719,
0.0270265285,
-0.0164680798,
0.0148721123,
-0.0245073549,
0.0028856788,
-0.0088132918,
-0.0338106155,
-0.0194636155,
-0.0407091416,
0.0343737677,
-0.0168048106,
0.0161597654,
-0.0198102333,
0.071314849,
0.0194381177,
-0.0425662473,
-0.0818044394,
0.0067347661,
-0.0030903576,
0.0003950306,
0.1018977016,
-0.0239562783,
0.0203691665,
-0.0998512655,
0.011052141,
-0.0238170996,
0.0221443623,
-0.0211922769,
0.0027438907,
0.0231014825,
-0.0375993811,
-0.0433664024,
0.0409919955,
0.0579808056,
0.0278004818,
0.0288344324,
-0.0864713639,
-0.0384480618,
-0.00818987,
-0.0137754185,
-0.0813829973,
-0.0741946921,
0.0001426987,
0.016447885,
-0.0693696067,
0.005227067,
-0.0858634859,
-0.0041994923,
-0.0035268217,
-0.0463908091,
-0.0601204447,
0.0327747054,
0.0033563776,
-0.0592642576,
0.0199374538,
-0.0321157426,
0.0124386577,
0.0179420095,
-0.0295373406,
-0.0260741394,
-0.0420609303,
0.0275475997,
0.0600591972,
-0.1217113808,
-0.0360596851,
0.0355152301,
-0.017144585,
0.0090254275,
0.0333167836,
-0.0352879055,
-0.0814005584,
0.0347568877,
0.0000912887,
-0.0572121628,
0.0216537677,
0.0273639001,
0.0182572994,
0.0080350274,
0.0337868892,
0.0086802086,
0.0135547901,
0.0194074754,
-0.0973639339,
-0.0594418868,
-0.0487177595,
-0.027812954,
0.0242104717,
-0.0108535234,
0.0356203094,
-0.0578151904,
-0.0038896629,
-0.0538316742,
0.0162717793,
-0.0179529078,
0.0246265642,
-0.0570226908,
0.0167918149,
-0.0031469075,
-0.0364919566,
0.0187195055,
-0.0081770271,
0.0062154182,
-0.0882753581,
0.03601804,
-0.0149707841,
0.02073358,
0.0009254804,
-0.0184184797,
-0.008650274,
0.0061625829,
0.0032071806,
0.0472167321,
0.0242144708,
-0.0080856401,
-0.0357376151,
-0.0031277596,
0.0021881482,
0.0152475871,
-0.0463510975,
-0.0003872958,
0.0046325694,
-0.0251670908,
-0.0220306255,
0.007018555,
0.0475155376,
0.0377865545,
-0.0001741219,
-0.0049572201,
0.0283764489,
-0.0254090838,
-0.0218727235,
-0.0351261124,
-0.0083011054,
0.001692505,
-0.0048501501,
0.0501880795,
0.0177337043,
-0.0446913838,
0.0153880473,
-0.0359821171,
-0.0450529978,
0.0420517288,
-0.0118547166,
0.0945662111,
0.0018038435,
0.0088552395,
-0.049153056,
-0.0558178052,
0.0775047019,
-0.0570044778,
0.0092312377,
0.0038767096,
0.0218780451,
0.0261281878,
0.0128543042,
-0.0390582792,
-0.048145093,
0.0192843359,
-0.0212876238,
-0.0467890725,
0.0113250799,
-6.375194429e-33,
0.0060481164,
-0.0216034446,
-0.016526198,
0.0003939691,
-0.0183565784,
0.0062524229,
-0.0372197442,
0.0219324827,
-0.0098131895,
0.0150578003,
-0.0450566225,
0.0584162623,
-0.0024363087,
0.0318810456,
-0.0406275503,
0.0218970757,
0.0348011255,
-0.0019276026,
-0.0076655727,
0.0819422677,
0.0310092978,
0.0124383084,
0.0564152449,
-0.0763240382,
-0.0101967035,
-0.0349701047,
0.01898662,
-0.0232833549,
0.0595015325,
0.0615455769,
0.003448186,
0.0796984136,
0.0193776134,
-0.0044127312,
-0.0066519594,
0.0662445799,
-0.0859716162,
-0.0330188088,
-0.0404579528,
0.0382220969,
-0.0150710465,
-0.0581317618,
0.0413004383,
-0.012032059,
0.0200410057,
-0.0475608185,
0.070752047,
0.039009735,
0.0487842225,
0.0047929282,
-0.026999047,
0.0627629012,
-0.0322414562,
-0.0055447496,
0.0270074811,
-0.0112189902,
0.0123571837,
0.0114206988,
-0.0838796496,
0.0378163904,
-0.0079469522,
-0.0180386826,
-0.0432286374,
0.0224797856,
-0.0298461542,
0.0305251572,
0.0526097566,
0.0369414575,
-0.0064320578,
-0.0133757563,
0.0323573127,
0.0512676351,
-0.0107808905,
0.0526361242,
0.0026110592,
-0.0484540574,
-0.0291490592,
0.0186981857,
0.080775477,
-0.0369929858,
0.0327514224,
-0.0177126974,
-0.038802091,
-0.0157110617,
0.0394766144,
-0.0387444794,
-0.0243671834,
0.0032235703,
-0.0430117808,
-0.0029375332,
-0.0490063056,
0.0104393987,
0.0019202471,
-0.007825953,
0.0403621756,
0.0565887988,
-0.0430110209,
0.0253827926,
0.0075195478,
-0.0227358174,
-0.0503244884,
0.0260053854,
0.0180501863,
0.0219269563,
0.0282678902,
0.0063694362,
0.013002512,
-0.000004303,
-0.0405170619,
-0.0476469174,
0.0146514336,
0.0512101874,
-0.0509339534,
0.0359831899,
0.0215103533,
0.0093512535,
-0.0160212442,
0.0204911046,
0.0159407705,
0.0665738657,
-0.0447167642,
-0.0072396942,
0.0463240221,
-0.021011021,
0.0013928814,
-0.0239359885,
-0.0557465106,
-0.0418614745,
0.0098819928,
-0.0600962602,
-0.0044452483,
0.0219628438,
2.703e-7,
-0.0179349296,
0.0607953519,
-0.0026517939,
0.0346944965,
0.0469449982,
0.0533220395,
0.0792243481,
0.0235000048,
-0.0021749923,
-0.037396092,
0.0010084447,
0.0591073036,
0.0178354923,
0.0233099982,
-0.0389224887,
-0.0058817775,
0.0313913301,
0.0306670107,
-0.0324927978,
-0.0189148616,
0.0554109514,
0.0683902577,
0.0557812192,
-0.0275960378,
0.0374132097,
0.0220215078,
0.022486411,
0.0639811456,
-0.0004805956,
0.0227314848,
0.0072454219,
-0.0142389676,
0.0077244611,
-0.0041941153,
0.0041535003,
0.003759501,
-0.0134739457,
0.0652009472,
-0.0307545662,
-0.0307047479,
-0.018136397,
0.0216313899,
-0.0247304197,
-0.0308165308,
0.0423733927,
0.0098893866,
-0.0808155388,
-0.0603401698,
-0.0215930771,
0.0006405814,
0.0011470469,
0.0507518016,
-0.0304315537,
0.0164618231,
0.0114071295,
-0.0538739823,
-0.0268912446,
-0.1047030389,
0.0197366588,
0.0337471031,
-0.0306595415,
-0.0203572959,
-0.0200233459,
-0.0179251041,
0.0494104177,
-0.0475158766,
0.0245139543,
1.989064552e-34,
-0.00232224,
0.0375543907,
-0.0099302307,
-0.0575680956,
0.0133514786,
0.0154765686,
0.0004885668,
-0.0317472741,
0.0482179858,
-0.0525642298,
-0.0017985004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10782v1 | A BERT based Ensemble Approach for Sentiment Classification of Customer Reviews and its Application to Nudge Marketing in e-Commerce | 2023-11-16T14:18:24 | 2023-11-16T14:18:24 | Sayan Putatunda, Anwesha Bhowmik, Girish Thiruvenkadam, Rahul Ghosh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | According to the literature, Product reviews are an important source of
information for customers to support their buying decision. Product reviews
improve customer trust and loyalty. Reviews help customers in understanding
what other customers think about a particular product and helps in driving
purchase decisions. Therefore, for an e-commerce platform it is important to
understand the sentiments in customer reviews to understand their products and
services, and it also allows them to potentially create positive consumer
interaction as well as long lasting relationships. Reviews also provide
innovative ways to market the products for an ecommerce company. One such
approach is Nudge Marketing. Nudge marketing is a subtle way for an ecommerce
company to help their customers make better decisions without hesitation. | [
0.0804063678,
-0.0010099488,
-0.0215417352,
-0.0074712704,
-0.0372444466,
0.0110005811,
0.0026826134,
0.0116881812,
0.0151543077,
-0.08556398,
-0.0210040528,
-0.0155894542,
-0.002674089,
0.0487373322,
-0.0435916074,
-0.020200314,
-0.0033746422,
0.0026810998,
0.0531279147,
-0.01204406,
0.0261368509,
0.0065481756,
0.0109789493,
0.0216094553,
0.0204618424,
-0.0146978768,
0.0104681579,
0.0024698591,
0.02281438,
-0.0234965403,
0.048542846,
0.0554534197,
-0.0323532745,
-0.0130829038,
0.0000017716,
-0.0464544743,
-0.0388737246,
-0.01401,
-0.0272950083,
-0.0250566378,
0.0554474741,
0.0340059958,
0.0151208024,
0.0163973421,
-0.0214458369,
0.0353599712,
0.0368951224,
0.0920744017,
0.066077143,
0.0793444961,
-0.0187888071,
-0.0417015851,
-0.0574738309,
0.034180738,
0.0059565958,
0.0212469362,
0.0216820277,
-0.0593529716,
-0.021819219,
0.0010527694,
0.0262107868,
-0.0185781848,
-0.0464670807,
-0.0167154968,
0.0491646677,
0.0508159362,
-0.0315572843,
0.0233829487,
-0.0610891841,
-0.0135141965,
0.0477136187,
0.0103315152,
-0.0110576795,
0.035327334,
0.0099816537,
0.0335635915,
0.0059939548,
-0.0256084912,
0.0012850785,
0.0288407858,
-0.0306538157,
0.054073073,
0.0060212379,
0.0288123954,
0.0208791588,
0.0579976067,
-0.0151967108,
-0.0582001396,
0.0355615579,
0.0530111603,
0.0631123781,
-0.0276241377,
0.0066781901,
-0.0327305086,
0.0231019948,
0.0021944423,
0.0502816923,
-0.0320038684,
0.0182464384,
-0.0936208963,
0.0308334809,
-0.0037117524,
0.0126052173,
0.0404533185,
-0.0404604487,
-0.0236041788,
0.0511141978,
-0.0480237082,
-0.0396850333,
0.0756764114,
-0.0674536824,
-0.0093108583,
-0.0200936701,
0.0672514513,
0.0099227363,
-0.0094883591,
-0.0981043801,
-0.0093323821,
-0.0312564373,
-0.0023386616,
0.0134860436,
0.0321324952,
0.0332958736,
0.0076531814,
-0.0086345775,
0.0204310771,
-0.0584266745,
0.0147807812,
-0.0426099785,
0.0192277059,
0.0485470109,
0.0179176778,
-0.0079425061,
-0.0083140833,
0.0243144166,
0.0112636099,
0.0420454778,
-0.0896395147,
-0.0283485707,
0.0043040519,
-0.051348567,
0.0041390173,
-0.002211126,
-0.0562153757,
-0.0063673966,
0.030090794,
-0.002620511,
0.0613677204,
0.0041972953,
-0.0294439904,
-0.009418969,
0.03347582,
-0.0187715348,
-0.034976799,
0.0109236911,
-0.001596633,
0.0416190177,
0.0262340885,
-0.0300468765,
0.0449494645,
0.0252399202,
0.0057583908,
-0.0033855645,
-0.02779481,
-0.0259893835,
-0.0232022759,
-0.0078992127,
0.0290145054,
-0.0647983626,
-0.0456579886,
-0.0544604547,
0.0174675584,
0.0008809617,
0.021998316,
0.0764495432,
0.0110947331,
-0.0220098421,
0.0477952473,
-0.0845442563,
-0.005594315,
-0.009218771,
-0.0374078006,
0.0346935764,
0.0121887792,
-0.063323155,
-0.0399068557,
-0.0027697438,
0.0040886481,
-0.0307517797,
-0.0347954929,
-0.014493282,
-0.0320147686,
0.0210470036,
-0.0116959121,
0.0356391333,
-0.0453798585,
-0.042046234,
-0.0075211846,
0.0026920286,
-0.038279362,
-0.0233273264,
-0.0185783897,
0.0479720458,
0.1405750662,
0.0009508505,
0.0272479635,
-0.047239311,
-0.0414546728,
-0.0770461857,
0.0155187547,
0.0291680787,
-0.0110621415,
-0.0503263324,
-0.011085487,
0.0014777244,
0.0137368394,
0.0149910776,
0.0008649225,
-0.0334923863,
0.0287733674,
-0.0214583986,
0.0256657861,
0.0236178748,
-0.0274442472,
0.0862591341,
-0.008852765,
0.0083772605,
0.0053517926,
0.0385819785,
0.0671340823,
-0.0160399564,
0.0044870898,
0.0315462947,
-0.009371195,
-0.0967007056,
0.0412712358,
0.0375071764,
-0.0128170094,
0.004043791,
-0.0105379475,
0.009833579,
-0.0265567061,
0.0058631785,
-0.0117911603,
-0.0224807151,
-0.0172335431,
0.0593338348,
-0.0322741382,
-0.0009861123,
-0.0215456095,
-0.0280071739,
0.0031265251,
0.0507709868,
-0.009754058,
0.0244357232,
-0.048630774,
-0.0495163128,
0.0129193133,
0.0224184878,
-0.0037095356,
0.0107128248,
0.0539483018,
0.0074849981,
0.0387745947,
-0.0263885986,
-0.0347146653,
-0.0310719721,
-0.1174507737,
-0.0324335061,
0.0338628702,
0.0492616557,
-0.0198149104,
-0.0119283739,
0.018032223,
0.0320162214,
-0.022845244,
-0.0289513208,
-0.002344188,
0.0169436578,
0.0305814799,
0.0321993791,
-0.0310389772,
0.0351387113,
0.0097622834,
-0.0274138339,
0.0220438689,
0.0729593635,
-0.0519904457,
-0.048051849,
-0.0511524975,
-0.0522447936,
-0.035623122,
0.0080038151,
-0.0356933288,
-0.0383659303,
0.0056723831,
0.0424901769,
-0.0177662168,
0.0313547514,
-0.0025362589,
-0.0182956941,
0.0040192227,
-0.0222579371,
-0.0074632736,
-0.0438050404,
0.046284467,
-0.0149951801,
-0.0120990016,
0.0331511125,
0.0026239138,
-0.0138037642,
-0.0221163351,
-0.0153132416,
0.0215109922,
0.0183838513,
-0.0097391643,
-0.0244340245,
-0.0281984005,
0.0021826376,
0.0273425169,
0.0257135108,
-0.0567551926,
0.0668062344,
0.0219836291,
0.0067640026,
-0.0891270936,
-0.0114722289,
-0.0151777929,
-0.008232018,
-0.0415353104,
0.0161106437,
-0.0055984631,
-0.0073815105,
0.0626336634,
-0.0575715415,
-0.0108117992,
-0.023008287,
0.0186284035,
0.0299523193,
0.0219758898,
0.0213983636,
-0.0351077579,
-0.018651301,
-0.0287714526,
-0.0175378583,
-0.0174520053,
0.0484943539,
-0.0242510941,
-0.0272743795,
0.0181179419,
-0.0383302681,
-0.0317654386,
-0.03085698,
-0.0224387571,
0.0539275035,
-0.0067078453,
0.0075983787,
-0.0294180587,
0.0059267674,
-0.0564941093,
-0.0059081847,
0.0434078611,
-0.0055630822,
-0.0398989953,
-0.0792374164,
-0.0499269441,
0.039434135,
-0.0625619516,
0.0057680104,
-0.0228627976,
-0.007449674,
-0.0015350761,
0.0421147533,
0.071797803,
0.0152828051,
-0.0451430865,
-0.0131546175,
0.0210747831,
-0.0039438312,
-0.014052581,
0.0387611203,
-0.0204028115,
-0.0167443044,
-0.0119107869,
0.0240133349,
-0.0228327923,
0.0034387549,
0.0127572073,
-0.1021122336,
0.0326872915,
0.0111187072,
0.0062624854,
-0.0413479246,
-0.0203861278,
-0.0197287817,
0.0221038926,
-0.0176657178,
-0.0118045015,
-0.0172615089,
0.0378113352,
0.0218717102,
-0.0022876917,
-0.0409569889,
0.0050073769,
-0.0149473203,
0.0306572057,
0.0946315601,
0.0419296622,
-0.0390460193,
-0.0282894522,
-0.0109393969,
-0.0320470184,
-0.0000432952,
-0.0306677371,
0.0858985633,
-0.0268393755,
0.0247815438,
-0.0186917149,
-0.0302193612,
-0.0363995433,
0.0525477901,
0.0030964206,
0.0081711691,
-0.0175292436,
-0.0495731011,
-0.0472595058,
0.0213650633,
0.0152711552,
0.0648486167,
-0.0492453277,
-0.0695579201,
-0.0085723735,
-0.0240207966,
0.0086873742,
0.0107479254,
0.0533846915,
-0.0234410092,
-0.0257736873,
-0.0539459661,
-0.1013511196,
-0.006155727,
-0.0025420911,
0.0238281786,
0.0405187458,
0.0054866518,
-0.008688055,
0.0659278035,
0.0139180068,
-0.0051783463,
0.0464691892,
0.026967369,
-0.0454047658,
-0.0244278777,
0.059969686,
-0.0116801048,
-0.0115774134,
-0.0783068463,
0.0421039872,
-0.0223704427,
-0.0368922316,
0.0822151527,
0.0211069938,
0.0067297337,
0.0367532223,
-0.0099710431,
0.014462661,
0.1155731902,
-0.0130417645,
-0.0193519574,
0.0561370999,
0.0452277511,
0.0082057351,
0.0207067505,
-0.0173893999,
0.0237286892,
-0.0021264865,
-0.0179017335,
0.003269616,
0.0035014886,
0.0084850378,
-0.0313442051,
0.0263914596,
0.0057720821,
0.0389430709,
-0.0064432109,
0.0389043577,
0.0151665416,
-0.0199243352,
-0.0348129719,
-0.021569306,
-0.0062925545,
0.0351030305,
-0.0314402953,
0.0183880217,
-0.04161679,
-0.0073146559,
-0.0433537327,
0.1149661466,
0.0321866758,
0.0631806403,
-0.0161293577,
-0.0016427368,
-0.0067279842,
0.0054836953,
0.0471956208,
-0.0216600467,
-0.0172998235,
0.0233838689,
0.0507742427,
-0.005163738,
-0.0072398223,
0.0420385227,
-0.0131693296,
0.0087184422,
-0.0268915985,
0.0072420393,
-0.0361635573,
-0.0060305018,
0.0283354018,
-0.0463244729,
-0.0033775701,
-0.0038794184,
0.0001009329,
-0.0080066873,
0.0145171424,
0.0115376869,
0.0121763945,
-0.0065076733,
-0.0232111719,
0.0234656278,
-0.1175579354,
0.0066244281,
0.006452051,
-0.0576220453,
-0.0489377901,
-0.0049655642,
0.0341583677,
-0.0099254651,
0.0086291572,
0.0288635176,
-0.0320483111,
-0.0045567988,
0.0674347952,
-0.0125234611,
0.0699010491,
-0.0093628056,
0.0573819093,
0.0322745144,
0.0125300931,
0.0168550555,
-0.0416995659,
0.0162332188,
-0.0395186506,
0.0444285423,
-0.0342527553,
-5.122264388e-33,
0.0111819617,
-0.0439188853,
-0.0683988184,
0.0744908825,
0.0082522361,
-0.0207824726,
0.0152391214,
0.0159707293,
0.0672402456,
0.0506196097,
0.0213537365,
0.0240900926,
0.0083284089,
0.0013747144,
0.0391993672,
-0.0261814203,
0.0537353419,
0.0019372363,
-0.0165125728,
0.0196416639,
0.02209373,
0.0565284006,
0.0516599901,
-0.0674553812,
0.067693986,
-0.0135438042,
-0.0622032955,
0.0143677136,
0.0020791125,
0.0285255834,
0.016903108,
0.0260996427,
0.0231402554,
0.0007795278,
0.0543395542,
0.035133943,
-0.0304816887,
-0.0112879602,
0.0356294252,
-0.0177513398,
0.0232604165,
0.0247438457,
0.0143319331,
-0.0143453907,
-0.0401786231,
0.077296935,
0.0260243062,
-0.0604464598,
0.005605435,
-0.0919331089,
-0.0130857723,
0.0070045264,
-0.0158534553,
0.0244216584,
0.0162679218,
0.0423316397,
0.0016747606,
0.0198211912,
-0.0121627459,
0.0282653999,
0.0405263603,
0.0044298489,
-0.0077597187,
-0.0019083612,
-0.0087414822,
0.0563772283,
-0.020757148,
-0.0096183,
0.0085219247,
0.0021416519,
-0.0101235956,
0.0015967453,
0.0340181552,
0.0058451672,
0.0030281618,
-0.0155955395,
0.0063966867,
0.0563650876,
0.1190769598,
-0.0416730084,
0.0522200838,
-0.0071959938,
-0.0448145419,
-0.0256105643,
0.0795213506,
-0.0522167198,
-0.0174543541,
-0.0309018921,
-0.0072932695,
0.0031996504,
-0.0483071245,
-0.0100863846,
-0.0349446684,
-0.0200892016,
-0.0671273544,
0.0132322861,
0.0133855119,
-0.0004631646,
0.0109220129,
-0.0559290983,
-0.0116470018,
-0.0234578736,
-0.0549240187,
-0.0050903088,
-0.0249401908,
-0.0299573652,
0.0641046241,
-0.0031887963,
-0.0766262338,
0.0012901362,
0.0302489735,
0.0160585269,
0.0019817911,
0.0384920239,
-0.0088679893,
-0.0047895992,
0.008802982,
0.0378631391,
0.0063408995,
0.0833236724,
-0.0331208818,
0.0184434708,
0.0117823659,
-0.0296857879,
-0.0012020289,
-0.0345517583,
0.0369565375,
0.0042199465,
-0.0330223702,
-0.0485295542,
-0.0315504484,
-0.0246580504,
2.529e-7,
0.0550135039,
0.0938328803,
-0.0307298955,
-0.0283951778,
0.030817112,
0.0594016127,
-0.0308654886,
-0.0055903126,
0.0362502784,
0.0030725473,
0.0346332416,
-0.049821943,
-0.0126226582,
0.0304012652,
-0.0818057358,
0.0021469709,
-0.0450938344,
0.0087516066,
-0.0021124859,
0.0619002022,
0.0542222932,
0.0125723099,
0.0176847037,
-0.0174000654,
-0.0151334079,
0.0062141228,
0.0516137369,
-0.0657059774,
0.0397313423,
0.0021701166,
0.0349586047,
-0.009545004,
-0.0421559252,
-0.0011830346,
-0.0205076411,
0.0327135623,
-0.0252258256,
0.0205233674,
0.0092317695,
-0.0016900917,
0.0358146541,
-0.0068649701,
0.010242491,
-0.0209843814,
0.0043890965,
-0.0617451109,
-0.0360660963,
-0.0801840872,
-0.0359601304,
-0.0347401686,
0.0230536647,
-0.012810898,
-0.0301317163,
0.0196025185,
-0.0168670081,
-0.0492565297,
-0.010024339,
-0.041270256,
0.0339713879,
0.0243675467,
-0.0170483664,
-0.0231336355,
0.0218761824,
0.0269506369,
0.0046298094,
-0.0249248594,
0.0259884577,
2.20630624e-34,
0.0794583187,
-0.0465781838,
-0.0260435995,
0.0258595403,
-0.0096993614,
-0.0209843684,
-0.0114315944,
-0.0312896557,
0.0367666259,
-0.0432784557,
-0.0159999579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09889v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09889v5 | Language Generation from Brain Recordings | 2023-11-16T13:37:21 | 2024-03-11T11:05:21 | Ziyi Ye, Qingyao Ai, Yiqun Liu, Maarten de Rijke, Min Zhang, Christina Lioma, Tuukka Ruotsalo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating human language through non-invasive brain-computer interfaces
(BCIs) has the potential to unlock many applications, such as serving disabled
patients and improving communication. Currently, however, generating language
via BCIs has been previously successful only within a classification setup for
selecting pre-generated sentence continuation candidates with the most likely
cortical semantic representation. Inspired by recent research that revealed
associations between the brain and the large computational language models, we
propose a generative language BCI that utilizes the capacity of a large
language model (LLM) jointly with a semantic brain decoder to directly generate
language from functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) input. The proposed
model can generate coherent language sequences aligned with the semantic
content of visual or auditory language stimuli perceived, without prior
knowledge of any pre-generated candidates. We compare the language generated
from the presented model with a random control, pre-generated language
selection approach, and a standard LLM, which generates common coherent text
solely based on the next word likelihood according to statistical language
training data. The proposed model is found to generate language that is more
aligned with semantic stimulus in response to which brain input is sampled. Our
findings demonstrate the potential and feasibility of employing BCIs in direct
language generation. | [
-0.0204608105,
0.074078083,
-0.0390004627,
-0.0191717166,
-0.0384193882,
0.0209718104,
0.0406460762,
0.0446709506,
0.0112958904,
0.0012257842,
-0.00297677,
-0.0488687418,
0.0716774166,
0.073587656,
0.0569625236,
-0.0304281246,
0.0228686072,
-0.0204258002,
0.0017446158,
-0.0132703977,
-0.0390385538,
0.0251618531,
-0.0423302501,
0.0453489609,
-0.037325114,
0.0363342129,
-0.0034660669,
-0.0175170768,
-0.0321227312,
-0.0423428528,
-0.0517245345,
0.073708348,
0.0204603802,
-0.0007563955,
0.0000017652,
-0.0465177521,
0.0488069393,
-0.0012672601,
0.0003962805,
-0.0374910012,
0.0343784057,
0.0073007843,
0.0228004158,
0.0114884702,
-0.0157471821,
0.0085482374,
0.0770059228,
0.0645943806,
-0.0130483322,
-0.0106151365,
-0.0383161753,
-0.0240963604,
0.026740659,
-0.040663559,
0.0130182607,
0.0449496917,
0.019461086,
-0.0035852555,
-0.020613974,
-0.0057850927,
-0.0262102336,
0.0431824848,
0.0119357463,
0.0018587355,
0.0025101518,
0.0674315542,
0.0034751021,
-0.0446451791,
-0.0179252047,
0.0460735112,
0.022159664,
-0.0216541123,
0.007724755,
0.008584694,
-0.0255816188,
0.019982364,
-0.0098241149,
0.0678748041,
0.0091743404,
0.0443450697,
0.051783096,
-0.0549691692,
0.0077224481,
0.0092769535,
-0.0029009921,
-0.014544474,
0.0198380891,
-0.0292210039,
0.0394106433,
0.030883193,
-0.0423082821,
-0.0664255172,
0.0236528758,
0.0146515435,
-0.061744187,
0.0011140723,
-0.0799363032,
-0.0537932515,
0.0134496884,
-0.0056274235,
0.0122765442,
0.0247713644,
-0.0010631303,
-0.004704081,
-0.0260608029,
0.0257520694,
-0.0228240974,
0.0363820642,
-0.0152194286,
0.0135183036,
-0.0103431446,
-0.0234142989,
-0.0101297088,
0.0211029127,
-0.0654278323,
-0.0603537299,
-0.0573322028,
0.0127310939,
0.0116282431,
-0.0474207476,
0.006867067,
0.0241551027,
-0.0273256432,
0.0364008099,
-0.0081254728,
-0.0093885716,
0.0532201976,
0.0260347351,
0.0172529537,
-0.0455818959,
-0.0043939766,
0.0631222948,
0.0095305154,
-0.0233025551,
-0.019128466,
0.0361514911,
-0.0365478247,
-0.0359845906,
-0.0364043117,
-0.0054228995,
-0.0264180861,
-0.0023467713,
0.0438552238,
-0.0540754721,
0.0293558203,
0.0057205451,
-0.037730366,
-0.0744502246,
0.0216849316,
-0.0313884765,
-0.0324122906,
0.0082156919,
-0.0666876137,
0.0185252689,
0.0997758433,
-0.0060150465,
0.0446308814,
-0.0005740519,
0.0563842654,
0.0016877329,
-0.0289465785,
-0.0027661908,
-0.0165651515,
0.0481872074,
0.0039798473,
-0.0202877223,
-0.0823575258,
-0.0663985461,
-0.0088666035,
0.0508120246,
0.03073062,
0.0703907385,
-0.0166651122,
0.0340234116,
0.0713616386,
0.0718811154,
0.0007721827,
0.0328341201,
0.0592069142,
0.0193115473,
-0.0109317331,
-0.0187945887,
-0.0071305209,
0.0467787795,
0.0278397053,
0.0094546787,
0.0364906304,
-0.0305228755,
-0.0066133896,
-0.007233283,
0.0242271814,
-0.0428159013,
0.0028838473,
0.0492314883,
0.037716452,
0.0194244273,
-0.0280390456,
0.0227501392,
0.0450737737,
-0.025782045,
0.0281693041,
-0.0327214822,
0.0201377384,
0.0523010977,
0.040293742,
0.0114674345,
0.0224818792,
0.0091004483,
-0.0125848623,
0.1368993521,
-0.0025484103,
0.0332595371,
0.0418365262,
-0.0283969156,
-0.0135454265,
0.0573769249,
-0.0051774117,
-0.0087100565,
-0.0323338732,
0.0108414516,
-0.018821517,
0.0259584114,
-0.0389753692,
0.0611279085,
-0.0449419618,
0.0180482771,
0.0186500177,
-0.0167286638,
0.0183770061,
-0.0254285149,
-0.0674663931,
0.0266958252,
0.0083434358,
-0.0228156075,
-0.0232894626,
-0.0007812136,
-0.0296285301,
-0.0373344459,
-0.0077869496,
-0.0001233329,
-0.0053207218,
0.0069863279,
0.0338666141,
-0.0374571756,
0.0118459584,
-0.0686133355,
0.0131183174,
-0.0531860404,
0.0005709637,
-0.0028280437,
0.0275293924,
-0.0522343032,
0.0219339002,
-0.0050182855,
-0.0130391764,
0.014861838,
-0.0053995019,
0.0083694234,
-0.0773398504,
-0.0382986031,
0.0552088171,
-0.033645533,
-0.0153386481,
0.0117024863,
0.0377182141,
-0.0129583878,
-0.0407036915,
-0.0841054767,
-0.0275386553,
0.0446752347,
-0.0275783595,
0.0152205862,
-0.0006158257,
0.0106874267,
0.0263223257,
-0.0462223068,
0.0145884519,
0.0681268573,
0.006693739,
-0.0109438254,
-0.0110162683,
-0.0392611697,
-0.0103303837,
-0.0006339622,
-0.0051533454,
0.0574035421,
0.0227540527,
-0.0276336689,
-0.064911522,
0.067171067,
-0.0454970077,
-0.0176732615,
0.0008928513,
0.0167982597,
0.0503590666,
-0.0231900942,
0.0517099686,
0.0165188648,
0.0382980295,
0.010359697,
0.0719304681,
0.0057382374,
0.004760141,
-0.0574246384,
-0.0182543192,
0.0226890147,
-0.0165987276,
-0.0458762795,
0.041684106,
0.0330924653,
0.0903219059,
0.0284108128,
-0.0240017362,
0.0095656654,
-0.018866919,
-0.0575922243,
-0.0296000428,
0.0061303205,
-0.0429379828,
0.0713258088,
-0.0247628819,
-0.0675441027,
0.0295427125,
-0.0357502401,
0.0175572932,
-0.0136628225,
0.0102054263,
0.0088428408,
0.0319992751,
0.0179182068,
0.0151702985,
-0.0356966369,
-0.0296926666,
-0.0082044825,
0.01779145,
-0.032892134,
-0.0416326933,
0.0014648584,
-0.0609465502,
0.0089452788,
0.0247312859,
0.015364198,
-0.0393904597,
-0.006478271,
0.0291241184,
-0.0005371395,
0.0526936688,
0.0223102663,
-0.0004660197,
-0.0480328724,
0.0405638814,
0.0466750525,
-0.0364531539,
-0.0305426829,
-0.0219331346,
0.0553461276,
0.0580656603,
0.0284074489,
-0.0134501373,
-0.0211372785,
-0.0284631699,
0.0158170257,
-0.0163865481,
0.0721687526,
-0.0613427944,
0.0114812925,
0.0109316213,
0.0208720416,
0.0244100112,
0.0513601303,
-0.0034877707,
0.0201543681,
-0.0277182423,
0.1147765741,
-0.0105785551,
-0.0557106584,
-0.0046104044,
-0.0037379614,
0.0536869392,
-0.0201720875,
0.0079861563,
-0.0520170517,
0.0158984568,
-0.0153661566,
0.0214128159,
-0.0082345987,
-0.005857137,
-0.027439408,
-0.0237971358,
0.0369719565,
-0.0064547043,
-0.0341459662,
0.0063265651,
-0.030496709,
-0.0104052834,
0.0494010039,
0.0200518575,
-0.0127163753,
-0.0130404159,
0.0135222832,
0.0059473016,
0.0151154557,
-0.0525678843,
-0.0513263308,
-0.0024347103,
0.0783893168,
0.0642770007,
0.0194267258,
-0.0327322371,
0.007138981,
0.0066547897,
0.000877946,
-0.0000734769,
-0.0324692205,
0.0451029316,
0.048500184,
0.0002106573,
-0.0345234647,
0.0481098555,
-0.0049043577,
-0.0551487878,
-0.0100072147,
0.0418411531,
-0.0834823474,
-0.0339811593,
0.034143284,
0.0419059172,
0.045897875,
0.0269650705,
0.0629962832,
-0.0756297931,
-0.0068414416,
0.0024925165,
0.0205507465,
-0.0419152677,
-0.0600641333,
-0.0060298862,
-0.0161875784,
-0.0122989686,
-0.0721316636,
-0.0061967303,
0.043031916,
0.0188603681,
0.0337631144,
0.0264508557,
0.0733236596,
-0.0424843207,
-0.0154640293,
0.0134732723,
-0.0103676962,
-0.0263575949,
-0.0501085334,
-0.0397868305,
-0.017263351,
-0.0728280544,
0.0116769653,
0.0429434143,
-0.043715097,
-0.0677350461,
0.0486818179,
0.0427655838,
0.0160533488,
-0.0030774905,
0.0387078226,
-0.0410191044,
0.0491599329,
0.0439811982,
-0.0074727102,
0.0706597045,
-0.0500330888,
0.0109640267,
-0.0168320518,
0.0032858278,
-0.0066010989,
0.0406599641,
0.0199872274,
0.0315580033,
0.0197170731,
0.0059737824,
0.0193153434,
0.0397141352,
0.0497904383,
-0.0844650939,
0.0428557172,
-0.0531233363,
-0.0578448586,
-0.0052117798,
0.0669269785,
-0.0254371483,
-0.0182754025,
0.0263700318,
0.0217725579,
0.0028025452,
-0.0356725864,
-0.0552554838,
0.0037933423,
0.0193302371,
-0.0197559986,
-0.0832378343,
-0.0005450074,
0.0129656103,
0.0112684667,
-0.0119546968,
0.026131602,
-0.0614113957,
-0.0042335526,
-0.0136764226,
0.0777819827,
0.0236482061,
0.0003264178,
-0.012972855,
0.0133783631,
0.004421406,
-0.0539597832,
0.0401320346,
0.0401457176,
0.0310837515,
0.0155151319,
0.0582686402,
-0.0177421756,
0.0464390181,
-0.0530617088,
0.0811735913,
-0.0234589037,
-0.0308195669,
0.0132626491,
-0.0171926413,
-0.0054564816,
-0.0400507152,
0.0514182225,
0.0013406783,
-0.04732823,
-0.0105242785,
0.0293031242,
-0.0238687154,
-0.0523305461,
-0.01286224,
-0.0204219464,
-0.0561380722,
0.0097830193,
0.008224207,
-0.026232129,
0.0200782139,
0.0077358517,
0.0247813445,
-0.0377885513,
0.0255293828,
-0.0063478751,
-0.0212986916,
0.0061804629,
0.0136735952,
0.0297468491,
-0.0195801873,
-0.0579096153,
-0.0928095281,
-5.539091379e-33,
-0.0325190388,
-0.0526953936,
0.0186216384,
0.0321408957,
-0.0323872454,
-0.010744012,
-0.0724527091,
0.05162533,
0.0549139231,
-0.021692073,
-0.0248671547,
-0.0427881069,
0.0079641631,
0.0716637895,
0.0212879032,
0.0178965796,
-0.0067548975,
-0.0344491377,
0.003350145,
0.0233944636,
0.0565437451,
0.0086979074,
0.0414346233,
-0.0671670511,
-0.01474691,
-0.0042793257,
0.0295666009,
-0.0128022237,
-0.0036092827,
0.0065028197,
-0.0581192039,
0.0533641353,
0.0534375906,
0.0064657703,
0.0085929679,
0.0275969729,
0.0028672784,
-0.0117934356,
0.0230920203,
-0.035267707,
-0.0770174414,
-0.0104331924,
0.0416923761,
-0.0399301723,
-0.0270682182,
0.0318701193,
0.0385290869,
-0.0282255411,
-0.0269707572,
0.0035478212,
-0.0687344745,
-0.0408466421,
0.0121253096,
0.0187051166,
-0.0196919218,
0.0122763077,
-0.0580415465,
0.0046983715,
-0.0232998226,
0.0566414893,
-0.0088155428,
0.0222485755,
0.0121473297,
0.0118912905,
0.0524943173,
0.0448700637,
0.0557600334,
-0.000914535,
-0.0507136248,
0.0206774846,
0.0458152443,
0.0327303931,
0.0101363398,
0.0353371575,
0.0246224068,
-0.0631466508,
-0.0280129854,
0.0011239555,
-0.0271006748,
-0.0289688241,
0.0344592296,
-0.0482289866,
0.0261935964,
-0.0203690939,
-0.0320913792,
0.004661663,
-0.0086010313,
-0.0098093729,
0.0488759279,
-0.0082866726,
0.010508677,
-0.0435666703,
0.0419164747,
0.0174248777,
0.0282894056,
-0.0264928937,
-0.0248162951,
0.0374363698,
-0.0029206874,
-0.0325833149,
-0.0323039927,
-0.0665171295,
0.0563786291,
-0.0201838985,
0.057383623,
0.0000486233,
-0.0307123698,
-0.0114207901,
0.0109210657,
0.0233624224,
-0.0135104535,
-0.0031829029,
0.0440626517,
-0.0195451174,
0.011075099,
-0.0106488196,
-0.0098335519,
-0.0540483333,
-0.0462427475,
0.002392651,
-0.0498937666,
-0.0302488599,
-0.003715602,
0.0651726946,
-0.0246971156,
0.0369711667,
-0.0331434831,
-0.0001060849,
0.0520169884,
-0.0472471043,
-0.0279917195,
0.0071630916,
2.519e-7,
0.033556696,
0.0487251692,
-0.0170365646,
0.0564487055,
0.0146155199,
-0.0245514549,
0.0067515615,
0.0102606686,
0.015760079,
-0.016076671,
-0.0393287614,
0.0605935119,
0.0303976443,
-0.025151059,
-0.0325180367,
-0.0168997571,
-0.0381321236,
0.0357644632,
-0.064831607,
-0.0139019536,
0.0771922767,
-0.0227763373,
-0.0443060063,
-0.0447977073,
0.0009533201,
0.0059496188,
0.0887705758,
-0.0240424108,
0.0086604515,
-0.0087649478,
-0.028357625,
-0.058003746,
-0.0021850492,
0.0211822782,
-0.0064359722,
-0.0268831793,
-0.0060252231,
0.0224752799,
-0.0314372554,
0.0046125688,
0.0486028679,
0.0225094128,
-0.0297191013,
0.0066300193,
-0.0061334902,
-0.0757022277,
-0.0369629748,
0.0063518928,
-0.0024175616,
0.0257288236,
0.0350323319,
-0.0644422546,
-0.0065520918,
-0.0123954937,
0.0190375447,
0.0102386568,
0.0361887366,
0.0289994907,
0.0022641264,
0.0324215181,
-0.0923417062,
0.0263930038,
-0.0447211228,
0.0001761503,
0.0137433037,
-0.0391372629,
0.0059959702,
1.870727398e-34,
-0.0397041216,
0.0014183511,
0.0390211418,
-0.0137989521,
0.0098015619,
-0.029269686,
0.0413178429,
0.0552862026,
-0.0532628521,
-0.0705650076,
-0.0211969279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09862v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09862v2 | Which Modality should I use -- Text, Motif, or Image? : Understanding Graphs with Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T12:45:41 | 2024-03-13T23:32:32 | Debarati Das, Ishaan Gupta, Jaideep Srivastava, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Our research integrates graph data with Large Language Models (LLMs), which,
despite their advancements in various fields using large text corpora, face
limitations in encoding entire graphs due to context size constraints. This
paper introduces a new approach to encoding a graph with diverse modalities,
such as text, image, and motif, coupled with prompts to approximate a graph's
global connectivity, thereby enhancing LLMs' efficiency in processing complex
graph structures. The study also presents GraphTMI, a novel benchmark for
evaluating LLMs in graph structure analysis, focusing on homophily, motif
presence, and graph difficulty. Key findings indicate that the image modality,
especially with vision-language models like GPT-4V, is superior to text in
balancing token limits and preserving essential information and outperforms
prior graph neural net (GNN) encoders. Furthermore, the research assesses how
various factors affect the performance of each encoding modality and outlines
the existing challenges and potential future developments for LLMs in graph
understanding and reasoning tasks. All data will be publicly available upon
acceptance. | [
0.0149891423,
0.0181616843,
-0.0116933212,
0.0424314924,
-0.0464628264,
-0.0015812072,
-0.0068895631,
0.0340038352,
0.0383592397,
-0.0002712516,
-0.0155864358,
-0.054358609,
0.0115395589,
0.0703081042,
0.0364787392,
-0.0064920932,
0.0012788312,
-0.0243250094,
0.0132586723,
-0.0167595912,
0.0078667467,
0.0371375382,
0.0623164363,
0.0343208425,
-0.0243261978,
-0.0023273004,
-0.0200663377,
0.0313411206,
0.0111719975,
-0.0591316149,
-0.0659595951,
0.0166810714,
0.0520947725,
0.043259196,
0.0000018021,
-0.0044220351,
0.0002824001,
0.0053755073,
-0.0108393114,
0.0066796849,
0.0478505604,
-0.0661576316,
0.0390590131,
-0.0142352637,
-0.0001564739,
-0.0132434675,
0.0851196498,
0.039429348,
0.0108907353,
0.0413178504,
-0.0268187523,
-0.0478159785,
0.0475679785,
-0.0311831515,
-0.0077310097,
-0.0015336466,
0.0560268536,
0.0278880857,
0.0328773931,
0.0213664193,
-0.0632615909,
0.0229739547,
0.0128019098,
0.0050327452,
0.0326824933,
0.0441248864,
0.0200284496,
-0.0191528108,
0.0155971432,
0.10865964,
-0.0053427061,
-0.0216606315,
-0.0080325864,
-0.0166381057,
-0.0127125308,
0.0620725676,
-0.0427897051,
-0.0104613146,
-0.0058079455,
0.0539900549,
-0.0178826116,
-0.0363695286,
0.0668929592,
-0.0156616885,
-0.0231490713,
0.0344943888,
-0.0081530036,
0.0156927798,
0.0217183288,
-0.0052400064,
-0.0489853546,
-0.0177614093,
0.0297053941,
0.0303700324,
0.0072127334,
0.0109440265,
0.0096534751,
0.0092672817,
-0.0104259001,
-0.0279990006,
0.0279354695,
0.0009931787,
-0.0066247513,
0.0390661694,
-0.0181030966,
0.0257322732,
-0.0583442003,
0.041179385,
-0.0323431455,
-0.0341938958,
-0.0661174431,
0.0079076607,
-0.044667732,
0.0247398615,
-0.0227539949,
-0.0770365968,
-0.0368940793,
0.0463938341,
-0.0072673555,
-0.0044534239,
0.0096322242,
0.0159082487,
0.0289723445,
-0.0029458173,
-0.0152660562,
0.0422334932,
0.0208172407,
-0.0157303587,
-0.0331439227,
-0.015277531,
0.0213400796,
0.007627157,
0.0663225427,
-0.0469913334,
-0.0081850803,
0.0916232765,
0.0285563059,
-0.0332185887,
-0.0074396133,
-0.0220908914,
-0.0287122428,
-0.0543899238,
0.0631784797,
-0.082520932,
0.0541039966,
0.0277526565,
0.0037735498,
-0.0223416239,
0.0120415045,
-0.024879083,
-0.0941200778,
0.0737529472,
-0.0205397271,
0.0099281892,
-0.011845612,
-0.0180039722,
0.0001128405,
0.0241244715,
0.0333873928,
0.0529231206,
0.0073566316,
-0.0129468534,
-0.0410649516,
0.0230193995,
0.0124355732,
-0.0071187508,
-0.004563015,
-0.0167271663,
-0.0098271566,
0.00441436,
-0.0112994313,
0.0810993314,
-0.036613524,
-0.0340514891,
0.0426744632,
0.0791595951,
0.0353868939,
-0.0031520312,
0.0228638723,
0.0306594409,
-0.0053740195,
-0.0280701555,
-0.054707747,
0.0153007396,
0.019166166,
0.0202564411,
-0.0079481332,
-0.0064392025,
0.0016695681,
0.0081533249,
-0.0277370978,
-0.0098323831,
0.0689705238,
-0.0163407773,
0.0773563981,
-0.0448395051,
-0.0391231999,
0.0059476797,
0.0183315482,
0.0036316798,
-0.0044056335,
0.0212901514,
-0.0123914909,
0.1029163003,
0.0294679254,
0.0027317379,
-0.0197122917,
0.0144992992,
-0.0065144254,
0.0075499909,
-0.0049040047,
0.0012355371,
-0.0015441931,
-0.0486733839,
-0.020038316,
-0.0047169859,
-0.0249753203,
0.0318483934,
-0.0271083061,
0.0342402309,
-0.0038914157,
-0.0621716641,
-0.0297702421,
-0.0106181176,
0.0631166697,
0.0309580974,
-0.0256739706,
0.0068348977,
-0.0054809637,
0.046329733,
-0.0023558142,
0.0156104993,
0.0291365553,
-0.023171857,
0.0128840515,
-0.0215693694,
-0.0469166748,
-0.0055595413,
0.056435544,
-0.0405804887,
-0.0196772702,
-0.0099887475,
-0.0251381453,
-0.034939602,
0.0513511524,
-0.0799960792,
0.0589145236,
-0.0041115088,
-0.019674005,
-0.0346105769,
0.0349620692,
0.0072513181,
0.0437811576,
0.0177740883,
-0.0160288904,
0.0086439298,
0.0192528125,
0.0075131617,
-0.0517615005,
-0.007922234,
0.038972497,
0.03009817,
-0.0011935014,
0.0470851623,
-0.0077897077,
-0.0146940053,
0.0217398591,
-0.1157068908,
-0.0282035396,
0.0016495422,
0.0106340786,
-0.0336275473,
-0.0142515525,
0.0107438555,
-0.0113552688,
-0.0511688069,
0.0594486855,
0.0041198051,
0.0295056719,
0.0254038349,
-0.0007732292,
-0.049950093,
-0.0153920064,
-0.0733917579,
-0.0349815823,
0.1077719107,
0.0431847274,
-0.0781455562,
0.0027702516,
0.0250254329,
-0.041433569,
0.0048591727,
-0.0180944726,
-0.0063042524,
0.0152552975,
-0.0177991353,
0.0726387128,
0.0061445995,
-0.0410720594,
0.039794866,
0.0666316375,
-0.0144207375,
-0.014839042,
-0.0397782438,
-0.0319893993,
0.0250162017,
-0.0283045769,
-0.0557719804,
-0.0424286202,
0.0150250336,
-0.0111654466,
0.000350765,
-0.0526354685,
-0.0100713745,
-0.0055184113,
0.0271490738,
-0.0348396711,
-0.0380837917,
0.02109522,
0.0019238604,
-0.0384560488,
-0.0197469685,
0.0521441959,
-0.019544011,
0.0080891587,
0.0736247823,
-0.0106686419,
-0.0601068102,
0.0790575519,
0.0837910026,
0.0306823999,
0.0154878143,
-0.0352783017,
-0.0319130197,
0.0135115599,
0.0077510672,
-0.0391112342,
0.0283128191,
-0.0149629209,
0.0272876285,
-0.010630873,
0.0020439432,
0.000369443,
0.05349648,
-0.0292644892,
0.0547944605,
0.0311919376,
-0.0326685905,
0.0030043605,
0.0374296643,
-0.0066488916,
-0.0406946503,
-0.01135909,
0.0139821544,
-0.0268770382,
0.0743375644,
0.0357075445,
-0.0324048921,
0.0127175916,
-0.047427427,
0.0122142443,
0.0383792929,
-0.0351519436,
-0.0193513166,
-0.0531367734,
0.0156959407,
-0.0135705508,
0.0491296351,
-0.0216524452,
-0.0140180271,
0.0388731658,
-0.0279414617,
0.0194597095,
0.0749834329,
0.0259046052,
-0.063613072,
-0.0095125427,
0.020510627,
0.0046314504,
0.0080322092,
0.006509874,
-0.1128514633,
-0.0028877784,
-0.0187275559,
-0.0053658346,
0.0206400007,
-0.0632511601,
-0.0149586676,
-0.0653826296,
0.023163246,
0.0419757888,
-0.0394505858,
-0.0579984821,
-0.065844506,
-0.0305036698,
-0.0122283613,
-0.0051861354,
-0.0287761912,
-0.0163398404,
0.0019719515,
0.0124207772,
-0.0003634757,
-0.0006585125,
0.003202138,
-0.0262024738,
0.0012218953,
-0.035521619,
0.0452263877,
0.0046799416,
-0.0140909748,
0.0391100347,
0.0422181934,
0.0088524092,
-0.0132839354,
0.0305115487,
0.0271525066,
-0.011723713,
-0.0442326032,
-0.0159908347,
-0.0397029072,
-0.0481502898,
-0.0694768354,
0.0983731076,
0.0105141867,
-0.0405122079,
-0.0268205423,
-0.0318826027,
-0.0540766083,
-0.0038157324,
0.0685090572,
0.0142337689,
-0.0675636753,
-0.0455452725,
0.0529179536,
-0.0498726778,
-0.0396759734,
0.0160153769,
-0.0122295804,
0.0339642055,
-0.0096410261,
-0.0155215235,
0.020886194,
-0.0196431,
-0.0095986025,
-0.0172751322,
0.039795313,
-0.0356702246,
-0.1108480394,
0.0338833891,
-0.0468281247,
0.0323539712,
-0.0386373512,
-0.0184528735,
-0.0098788664,
-0.0061466862,
0.0053811665,
0.0336550139,
-0.0669009015,
-0.0660953894,
-0.0321630798,
-0.0240820684,
0.0112313991,
0.0266386718,
0.0048717982,
-0.0303135011,
0.0573392585,
0.0303254146,
-0.0041245786,
-0.0152288266,
-0.0078286296,
-0.0048790844,
-0.0270535145,
0.0111086136,
-0.0622718632,
0.0111895222,
0.0432644896,
0.0278421156,
0.0011249176,
-0.023119403,
0.0206612106,
0.0657817274,
0.0072583533,
0.0385505706,
0.0163844731,
-0.0382485203,
-0.0426473618,
-0.0021389239,
0.0008930679,
-0.0128670875,
-0.0382919796,
0.0274201557,
-0.0039443881,
-0.0063813664,
-0.046402853,
0.0285493005,
0.0088604065,
-0.0130915884,
0.0012852236,
-0.0120007079,
-0.0330581106,
0.044256255,
0.0268243495,
-0.0237168036,
0.017213773,
-0.0235195458,
0.0023247718,
-0.0190665573,
0.0052583585,
0.0141681954,
-0.0279267617,
-0.0579156429,
0.0483155474,
-0.0313449576,
-0.0187163483,
0.0026268321,
0.0194826256,
0.0652550012,
0.0035326148,
0.0036279433,
-0.030194113,
0.0132858837,
-0.0448209271,
0.0449823812,
-0.0335722007,
-0.0395855457,
0.067106314,
0.0298817866,
0.0097993994,
0.0150039084,
0.0371385217,
0.0542040765,
0.0003823368,
0.0163446683,
-0.0659327656,
-0.0043698843,
0.0002463655,
-0.0068184463,
0.0216985475,
-0.0085066836,
-0.0065451902,
-0.046506457,
-0.1112230346,
0.0285126586,
-0.0075718635,
-0.0030200409,
0.0336288139,
0.0079017421,
-0.008291916,
0.0345182605,
-0.0219538435,
-0.0125142308,
0.0525210649,
-0.013221697,
-0.0152632352,
0.0104425084,
-6.102801899e-33,
0.0168047994,
-0.0952947587,
0.0272329412,
0.0155325569,
-0.0566572212,
0.0453238524,
-0.0552735701,
-0.0255408157,
-0.0054068565,
0.0237375051,
0.0129577201,
-0.0052097039,
-0.0129546141,
0.0117242141,
-0.0296939258,
0.0001813579,
0.0223888438,
0.0208958928,
0.0274180491,
0.0370230637,
0.0354555473,
0.0188503973,
0.0275841467,
-0.0463883951,
0.0488039181,
0.0131254662,
0.0366875194,
-0.0135147488,
0.0462993719,
0.0475376323,
-0.0361670479,
0.0505842529,
0.0303328186,
0.0018388316,
-0.0078595895,
0.0275234543,
-0.0509705096,
-0.0175064672,
0.0204827767,
0.0245317593,
-0.0266286563,
-0.0536661223,
0.0422908403,
-0.0113025894,
0.0075970236,
-0.0288498774,
0.0518636107,
0.0144832199,
-0.0452205054,
0.0338741727,
-0.031852942,
0.033123225,
-0.0120268818,
0.0278394185,
0.0521349497,
-0.0020346341,
0.0222209301,
0.035777431,
-0.0347463712,
0.0528695062,
-0.0179934315,
-0.0400255434,
0.0141112804,
0.0376751944,
0.0349789038,
0.039751064,
0.0323797911,
-0.0311568454,
-0.011546623,
0.0204384234,
0.0051423414,
0.0832172707,
0.0283325557,
-0.0130723789,
-0.0202036947,
0.00651399,
-0.0786110163,
-0.0307271387,
-0.0477208905,
0.0253312606,
-0.0040199752,
0.0485796072,
-0.001750674,
-0.0595678538,
0.0049749082,
-0.0257163402,
-0.0382349454,
-0.0433639288,
-0.0140635399,
-0.0388856344,
-0.0254348665,
0.070712097,
0.0387249812,
-0.080080688,
-0.0349873304,
0.0683948994,
-0.0011066633,
0.0534091331,
-0.0048065563,
0.0363993347,
-0.0472950563,
-0.0320412368,
0.0242250804,
-0.0478520989,
0.0061345538,
-0.0065751933,
0.0400786772,
0.0162822679,
-0.0111498833,
-0.0163836721,
-0.0486097857,
-0.0606242642,
-0.027004946,
-0.0439144485,
0.0675836429,
0.0327340625,
-0.0131861391,
0.0428897515,
0.0523022152,
0.0071686227,
0.0002942376,
0.034666691,
-0.0257406924,
0.0357047357,
-0.0316421986,
-0.0067917295,
-0.0250468198,
0.0361814573,
0.0373481736,
-0.0570926517,
-0.0434275307,
0.0031233947,
2.765e-7,
0.0656386688,
0.0735489354,
0.0646595582,
0.0013402851,
0.0257799868,
0.0070513966,
-0.0164111964,
0.0351593234,
-0.030585289,
0.0024057892,
0.0340136699,
0.0570768267,
-0.0280447956,
0.0282769892,
-0.006699326,
0.0683181211,
-0.061121624,
-0.0426358394,
-0.0546238646,
0.0618541166,
0.0223944262,
0.0688268393,
-0.0046135797,
-0.0026573236,
0.000039354,
-0.0701208487,
0.0642082319,
-0.0490908585,
-0.0038329656,
-0.029478021,
-0.0733965933,
-0.0095968526,
-0.0292546544,
0.006143989,
0.0293558575,
0.0050609531,
0.0331370309,
-0.001484148,
-0.0376303494,
0.0156325791,
0.0151000945,
-0.0319434404,
-0.018335253,
-0.0374556296,
0.055589281,
-0.0539841056,
-0.0806868151,
-0.0056878021,
-0.0061201337,
-0.021809889,
-0.0000126643,
0.0159504451,
-0.0109560015,
0.0306246299,
0.0089703174,
-0.0430093966,
0.0217455979,
-0.0462142751,
0.044263918,
-0.0041180551,
0.0036018966,
-0.0338668041,
-0.0515433624,
0.0290459879,
0.0414155647,
0.0260424856,
-0.0043850453,
2.085424783e-34,
0.0336821489,
-0.0237145256,
0.0056932424,
0.0133563224,
0.0351504758,
-0.0427904204,
-0.0204764083,
0.0294106212,
-0.0025528506,
-0.1166655719,
-0.0345691256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09861v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09861v4 | ConceptPsy:A Benchmark Suite with Conceptual Comprehensiveness in Psychology | 2023-11-16T12:43:18 | 2024-06-16T11:33:03 | Junlei Zhang, Hongliang He, Nirui Song, Zhanchao Zhou, Shuyuan He, Shuai Zhang, Huachuan Qiu, Anqi Li, Yong Dai, Lizhi Ma, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The critical field of psychology necessitates a comprehensive benchmark to
enhance the evaluation and development of domain-specific Large Language Models
(LLMs). Existing MMLU-type benchmarks, such as C-EVAL and CMMLU, include
psychology-related subjects, but their limited number of questions and lack of
systematic concept sampling strategies mean they cannot cover the concepts
required in psychology. Consequently, despite their broad subject coverage,
these benchmarks lack the necessary depth in the psychology domain, making them
inadequate as psychology-specific evaluation suite. To address this issue, this
paper presents ConceptPsy, designed to evaluate Chinese complex reasoning and
knowledge abilities in psychology. ConceptPsy includes 12 core subjects and
1383 manually collected concepts. Specifically, we prompt GPT-4 to generate
questions for each concept using carefully designed diverse prompts and hire
professional psychologists to review these questions. To help to understand the
fine-grained performances and enhance the weaknesses, we annotate each question
with a chapter label and provide chapter-wise accuracy. Based on ConceptPsy, we
evaluate a broad range of LLMs. We observe that, although some LLMs achieve
similar accuracies on overall performances, they exhibit significant
performance variations across different psychology concepts, even when they are
models from the same series. We hope our work can facilitate the development of
LLMs in the field of psychology. | [
0.0194699802,
0.02631291,
-0.0339240059,
0.0141831599,
-0.0534671284,
0.0386379026,
0.0298957061,
-0.0076780748,
-0.0005495585,
-0.0246283077,
-0.035951063,
-0.0700071007,
0.0075555393,
0.0332136825,
0.041100353,
-0.0637227222,
0.0393753983,
-0.0311972778,
0.0319162123,
-0.0009623738,
-0.0238467567,
-0.0305527262,
-0.0156141343,
0.021334501,
0.041778177,
-0.0738819316,
-0.0036068009,
-0.0411667824,
0.0070376685,
-0.0704037026,
-0.0009181394,
0.0584510267,
0.0101222508,
0.0060685133,
0.0000022163,
-0.0895182863,
-0.0010833426,
0.0123593966,
0.0003164096,
0.0473887622,
0.0366677791,
0.0040402408,
0.0295035392,
0.0171699636,
-0.0175922383,
-0.0391668938,
0.0080517074,
0.0783711001,
0.037456803,
0.0493676178,
-0.0058233398,
-0.0343344212,
0.0237429533,
-0.032175526,
0.0135580488,
-0.0460467786,
0.0500294305,
0.0383364335,
0.0031840806,
-0.0251872987,
-0.0210296959,
-0.0177471321,
0.0259774067,
0.0179742519,
-0.0185635351,
0.0056253015,
-0.0146761406,
-0.0222805031,
0.0208488759,
0.0720429569,
0.0540920086,
0.0304607637,
-0.0061321729,
-0.0025737579,
-0.0147851091,
0.0011641901,
-0.0618483983,
0.0357176028,
-0.0115369484,
-0.019308649,
0.0481223054,
0.0241051093,
0.0240542777,
0.0226121452,
-0.0572517551,
0.0675669461,
0.0169840902,
-0.0514161177,
0.0578204617,
-0.0052281325,
-0.0711759329,
-0.0502710752,
-0.0168004259,
0.0037448218,
-0.0168173667,
0.0133558307,
0.0321295485,
-0.0182951838,
0.0158087909,
-0.0221769288,
0.0297033284,
0.0433173701,
-0.0050481716,
0.0372296236,
0.0088701565,
0.1182546988,
0.0040889769,
0.0258494038,
-0.0439764746,
-0.0038959989,
-0.0673184395,
-0.0113520427,
0.00007745,
0.056860324,
0.0203015674,
-0.0305269379,
-0.0692877248,
0.0193700735,
-0.0521582626,
-0.0156388693,
-0.0302228555,
-0.0232092012,
-0.0081504025,
0.0010287887,
-0.0617252886,
0.0276695434,
-0.0594875067,
0.014618827,
0.0217115376,
-0.021047648,
0.0266508814,
-0.0026650606,
-0.0282197464,
-0.0152597418,
0.0301865451,
0.004352408,
0.0015072799,
-0.0147862136,
-0.0355253145,
-0.0288456641,
-0.0406410471,
-0.0744602382,
0.0207375232,
-0.0639450476,
0.0071369563,
0.0202173963,
-0.0016381306,
-0.0204018522,
0.0115140956,
0.0209032372,
-0.0048719482,
0.0525320098,
0.0469387621,
0.0073865862,
-0.0001023224,
0.0345576368,
-0.0509060025,
0.0613096133,
0.0070634587,
-0.008778993,
0.0249804612,
-0.0026947015,
-0.0152334711,
0.0254662726,
-0.0249734502,
-0.0359205939,
-0.0119876359,
0.0277138222,
0.0099367555,
0.033589948,
0.0091789505,
0.0509302132,
-0.0235378519,
0.0359772779,
0.0468793102,
0.0757854059,
-0.0121135004,
0.0219375454,
0.0423097983,
0.0102685662,
0.0349380262,
0.0031052269,
-0.0588406511,
0.0120876981,
-0.0436097458,
0.0260230713,
0.0030825203,
0.0040498441,
-0.0197562855,
-0.0544697978,
-0.0239775721,
0.0147422934,
0.0111884978,
0.0418020673,
0.0618739836,
-0.0321900509,
0.0132653117,
-0.0123236636,
0.0136730056,
-0.0086073345,
0.0001771455,
-0.0324032269,
-0.0018807702,
0.0635865778,
0.0431984589,
-0.01242177,
-0.0336456522,
0.0157114286,
-0.0204223525,
0.0463197604,
0.0691071451,
-0.0206271689,
-0.0296076089,
-0.0378127843,
0.0084518548,
-0.0432520695,
0.0096536344,
-0.0095679667,
0.0278526563,
0.0055134795,
0.0093240272,
-0.0563602373,
0.006506626,
0.0236889962,
-0.0399299525,
-0.0215514824,
-0.0358063616,
-0.012367568,
0.0578271411,
0.0168959033,
-0.0168433003,
0.0355452448,
0.008367449,
-0.0282324534,
-0.0402752459,
-0.006004048,
-0.060441494,
-0.0421449021,
0.0413420461,
-0.0168138295,
-0.0319815688,
0.0718220919,
-0.0140477857,
-0.0441787429,
0.0162207149,
0.01675524,
0.0223142523,
-0.0583845675,
0.0498253517,
-0.030925246,
0.0077305278,
-0.0231877603,
0.1005026847,
0.005626895,
0.0582920648,
0.0284932144,
0.0481588468,
0.0158349928,
-0.0130218714,
-0.0713409185,
0.0085816002,
-0.0094445897,
-0.0017606021,
0.0170489736,
-0.007169107,
-0.059158437,
-0.0102220112,
-0.1115604788,
0.0320670754,
-0.0085720392,
-0.0132406838,
0.0358817503,
-0.0249966793,
-0.0203393344,
0.0369193405,
-0.0269848872,
0.0145141538,
0.0097579574,
0.0496711358,
-0.0096642263,
-0.0086072152,
0.0057623368,
-0.0086261369,
0.0056277607,
-0.0597236976,
0.0378973968,
-0.0120975478,
0.033604499,
0.0179388989,
0.080662258,
-0.0257485192,
0.0023198479,
-0.0293373298,
-0.0227832422,
0.0302042123,
-0.0069983341,
0.0622507222,
0.0600488037,
0.0022199643,
0.0089344103,
0.0385767743,
-0.0386803672,
-0.0209906977,
0.013361603,
0.0113517148,
-0.0160488244,
-0.033313714,
-0.0323650539,
-0.0110043511,
0.075593181,
0.0170011893,
0.0035972255,
-0.0378601179,
-0.0227172971,
-0.0649204552,
-0.0163816884,
-0.0337492079,
0.0220704023,
-0.0208733492,
0.0331209116,
-0.0311436877,
-0.0045946091,
0.0730572268,
-0.0144299762,
-0.0110134063,
-0.0464124419,
0.0127592077,
-0.0242267195,
0.1119137481,
0.0007946128,
-0.0071910601,
0.0398050509,
-0.0041384143,
-0.0598331653,
0.0080071539,
-0.0132019622,
-0.0403600819,
0.0534346402,
-0.0720710531,
-0.0101432819,
-0.0020998879,
-0.0402199551,
-0.0499004684,
0.031833671,
-0.0402307734,
0.0302499123,
0.0432801507,
-0.0095191216,
-0.0033510979,
0.0148454653,
0.0405756272,
0.0103972619,
-0.014260361,
-0.0145250382,
0.0017872133,
-0.0180124082,
0.0619231537,
-0.0028745942,
0.022356471,
-0.077403903,
0.0594248287,
0.049608577,
0.010585038,
0.0027011733,
0.0021713807,
0.0332645774,
0.0024866154,
-0.0058585634,
-0.0045699114,
0.0433888957,
0.0287578125,
-0.0435213484,
-0.0127603896,
0.1556176245,
0.0311500821,
-0.0396850444,
-0.0046923379,
-0.0330107585,
0.0289609246,
0.0501017496,
0.0009333274,
-0.0473478027,
-0.0203038566,
0.0051688659,
0.0112211946,
-0.0150043014,
-0.0478449389,
0.0286827479,
-0.1436029822,
0.0176851861,
-0.0085276123,
-0.0264802836,
-0.0393230878,
-0.0254495721,
0.0146872727,
0.0035974211,
0.012330018,
0.0204916857,
0.0112738404,
0.0045721224,
0.0031116179,
-0.0642053261,
-0.0650749505,
0.1199595332,
-0.0219516456,
0.0499590859,
0.0351418033,
0.0169797745,
-0.0138911819,
-0.0287692901,
-0.0235849228,
-0.0518512912,
-0.0172457788,
0.0105517497,
0.0276552737,
0.0223292559,
0.011971117,
-0.0464427695,
0.0345503055,
-0.0442588925,
-0.0162005927,
0.0387497358,
0.0823210478,
-0.0078388685,
-0.0401448086,
-0.0133778043,
0.0204232391,
-0.0414201953,
0.1143619418,
0.0069723683,
-0.0587288737,
-0.0329099745,
-0.0004227281,
-0.0258337464,
-0.0164390896,
-0.0405763164,
0.0255605374,
0.0067100856,
0.0365328453,
-0.0631959438,
-0.0580302961,
0.0684760809,
0.0014778638,
-0.0023735967,
0.0084003136,
0.0246915072,
0.0075621051,
-0.0571405627,
0.0275329463,
-0.0111055458,
0.0124467909,
-0.0464876741,
-0.0161195938,
0.0457678847,
-0.0186551735,
-0.017613221,
0.0310334414,
-0.0601113699,
-0.0480455272,
0.0255013276,
-0.0043934905,
0.0138732279,
0.006374625,
0.0002708201,
-0.0139382249,
0.0151318889,
-0.05230942,
-0.0465445407,
0.0185817685,
-0.0160912257,
0.0158141479,
0.0070582177,
0.0199060701,
-0.0250673126,
0.0300184805,
0.026833022,
0.0469551124,
-0.0014249943,
-0.014323853,
0.0498976037,
0.0426049791,
0.031290628,
0.0044062412,
-0.0362403765,
-0.0321031474,
-0.0101727154,
-0.0379028469,
-0.033546865,
-0.0186488591,
-0.0228978451,
0.0560976863,
0.0176998843,
-0.0101469029,
-0.0134552196,
0.0231815837,
-0.0230604056,
0.0020383911,
-0.0290009324,
-0.0082983375,
0.0071567334,
0.012172238,
0.0033111016,
-0.0200323742,
-0.028929906,
-0.0434890687,
0.0560344271,
-0.0163221974,
0.1102810577,
0.0261828881,
0.0055521843,
0.0221947115,
-0.0131455082,
-0.0480245985,
-0.068131946,
0.0310608149,
-0.0031441299,
0.0343516953,
0.0152413668,
0.0047861738,
-0.0519959293,
0.0146686006,
-0.0469051711,
-0.0174692608,
-0.0105246017,
-0.0278142095,
0.0292108171,
0.051359579,
0.0079152137,
-0.016262332,
0.0626952797,
-0.0167585667,
0.0241711214,
0.0205128305,
-0.016600199,
-0.0293665286,
-0.0115278,
0.0005153056,
0.0581061468,
-0.0206375886,
0.0111564714,
-0.1041771472,
-0.0759993494,
0.024957398,
0.0001635511,
0.0118753463,
-0.0031200678,
0.0284029599,
0.0899320021,
-0.0445639603,
-0.046696011,
-0.0199565664,
0.0213725567,
-0.0396997854,
0.0164126307,
-0.0299554802,
-6.558720689e-33,
-0.0362001471,
-0.0054789819,
0.0429194532,
-0.0026225548,
-0.0211550798,
-0.0157519784,
-0.0398005545,
0.0334658958,
-0.0401840135,
0.0196452439,
-0.0053359387,
0.0028905869,
-0.0051510893,
0.0119786868,
0.0179350767,
0.0077339681,
0.0075656907,
0.0047960761,
-0.0292498749,
-0.0033599725,
0.0216613617,
-0.0007247579,
0.0350418724,
-0.0441932939,
-0.0054027289,
-0.0132234311,
0.0375595875,
0.0171281118,
-0.0275020208,
0.0519552641,
-0.0090928487,
0.0276885256,
0.0558534563,
-0.0358677655,
-0.0005443161,
0.0069519845,
-0.0663334429,
-0.0496795774,
0.0348078832,
-0.0119456546,
-0.0071728216,
-0.0155948773,
0.0131251551,
-0.015401422,
0.0212514978,
-0.0298861265,
0.0344981998,
-0.0520713814,
0.0146730924,
-0.0027706013,
-0.0619689412,
-0.0077646258,
-0.0236733817,
0.0234237742,
-0.0375593379,
0.0211168882,
-0.0535106361,
0.0158531144,
-0.0434137359,
0.0078256177,
0.0412969664,
0.0371429324,
0.0376145355,
0.0214006212,
0.0347822756,
0.0703501925,
0.0147255994,
0.0073796487,
-0.0122350669,
-0.0068184542,
0.0563220978,
0.0667564049,
0.0382721238,
0.0675748736,
0.030915441,
0.0031936092,
-0.0723050684,
-0.0042904634,
0.0653184131,
0.0266218111,
0.0353211835,
-0.0003404383,
-0.0253922604,
-0.0281745717,
-0.0659821555,
0.0550839938,
-0.0502767414,
-0.0388879105,
0.0780502856,
-0.0255735237,
-0.0128143225,
-0.0177562218,
0.0331285112,
-0.0305422004,
0.0212449208,
-0.0061306972,
-0.0072160373,
0.0571686924,
-0.0021907522,
0.0293092411,
-0.0780806988,
-0.0401457511,
-0.0110488078,
0.0167161971,
0.0204211008,
0.0062088356,
0.0008492596,
0.0016456682,
-0.0264019053,
-0.0350249484,
-0.0454385281,
-0.0328297392,
0.0209838077,
-0.0023305649,
0.0285580903,
0.0358468033,
-0.0065882443,
-0.0187979676,
0.0051810886,
-0.0067271776,
-0.0633771122,
-0.0158222318,
-0.0005574098,
-0.0010135401,
0.0050916444,
-0.0003853992,
-0.0177170411,
-0.0023812733,
0.0362910591,
-0.0072495965,
-0.0155396797,
0.0073954239,
2.899e-7,
0.0330752581,
0.037753012,
-0.0358375274,
0.0596228316,
0.0172107425,
0.0273188557,
-0.0369958058,
-0.025930753,
0.0456601046,
-0.0240879487,
0.0114884675,
0.0457817875,
0.0327503569,
0.0362103507,
-0.0652552322,
0.0031907836,
0.0290104598,
-0.0426190011,
-0.0289329663,
0.0067541362,
0.0511466004,
0.0515717193,
0.0123747261,
0.0069510499,
0.0170166306,
-0.0558774695,
0.0515059717,
-0.0205429662,
-0.0088854507,
0.0571704395,
-0.0010894483,
0.0304776225,
0.0031436023,
0.0712079331,
0.0328334272,
0.0183676668,
0.0326853581,
0.0553956516,
0.0059778793,
-0.0169412084,
-0.0247779284,
-0.0200326256,
-0.0166017581,
-0.090686202,
0.0696861595,
-0.0793217346,
-0.0621894337,
-0.0045942138,
-0.0424190052,
-0.024032509,
-0.0064411368,
0.0187138971,
0.0075696241,
0.0034786484,
-0.0051643732,
-0.016787041,
-0.0107273795,
-0.0312465243,
-0.0024004481,
0.0350553133,
-0.0405072458,
-0.069776088,
-0.0468728989,
-0.0325369611,
0.0019982243,
-0.0599501915,
0.0039438405,
2.931861761e-34,
0.024913447,
0.0109700169,
0.0143731749,
-0.0170286261,
0.040706642,
-0.0243978575,
-0.0416062325,
0.0212196968,
-0.0232095458,
-0.100016132,
-0.0040609026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09860v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09860v1 | GSAP-NER: A Novel Task, Corpus, and Baseline for Scholarly Entity Extraction Focused on Machine Learning Models and Datasets | 2023-11-16T12:43:02 | 2023-11-16T12:43:02 | Wolfgang Otto, Matthäus Zloch, Lu Gan, Saurav Karmakar, Stefan Dietze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Named Entity Recognition (NER) models play a crucial role in various NLP
tasks, including information extraction (IE) and text understanding. In
academic writing, references to machine learning models and datasets are
fundamental components of various computer science publications and necessitate
accurate models for identification. Despite the advancements in NER, existing
ground truth datasets do not treat fine-grained types like ML model and model
architecture as separate entity types, and consequently, baseline models cannot
recognize them as such. In this paper, we release a corpus of 100 manually
annotated full-text scientific publications and a first baseline model for 10
entity types centered around ML models and datasets. In order to provide a
nuanced understanding of how ML models and datasets are mentioned and utilized,
our dataset also contains annotations for informal mentions like "our
BERT-based model" or "an image CNN". You can find the ground truth dataset and
code to replicate model training at https://data.gesis.org/gsap/gsap-ner. | [
0.0443324298,
0.0473917536,
0.0182794295,
0.0095047234,
-0.0056844326,
0.0432316847,
0.0240991469,
-0.0081249774,
0.0082856668,
-0.0724541843,
-0.0218590014,
0.0636172444,
-0.0032366896,
0.0319823772,
0.0385623425,
-0.017724568,
0.0249894317,
0.012225396,
0.0612597428,
0.0240560733,
-0.0143380174,
0.0197897069,
-0.0014171146,
0.0184442848,
0.0519059449,
-0.0473982804,
0.0038707536,
-0.0027049065,
0.0427622534,
-0.0243044067,
0.0276794098,
0.0474004559,
-0.0072660134,
0.0401306711,
0.0000017219,
-0.0474284142,
-0.0396185145,
0.032817848,
-0.0249218885,
-0.0098567763,
0.0498696119,
-0.0396199934,
-0.0019596461,
-0.0330390111,
0.0040909401,
-0.0237248112,
0.0310115274,
0.0424538516,
-0.0182137545,
0.0562110543,
-0.0109167825,
-0.0629438758,
0.0736852288,
0.0029559147,
-0.0173302479,
-0.0173367616,
0.0646853819,
-0.006250862,
-0.0092894072,
0.0449693725,
0.0734448954,
0.0135300066,
-0.0432845503,
0.0024360202,
0.027942352,
0.0285388883,
-0.019781176,
0.0089461468,
0.0084385611,
0.0402041934,
0.0474291667,
-0.0359622128,
0.0931084603,
-0.0014156267,
-0.0173881184,
0.0294402912,
-0.0166086275,
0.0016192229,
-0.0533321351,
-0.0313945189,
0.021286577,
-0.0141451312,
0.0363680087,
0.0338742286,
0.008078428,
0.0279983617,
0.0086673331,
-0.0561943725,
0.0277282186,
-0.0034148735,
0.0176821388,
-0.0297622122,
0.0112150405,
0.0167701375,
0.0648458377,
0.0192214604,
-0.0129600847,
-0.0431784615,
0.0168133695,
-0.0183366928,
-0.0035144074,
-0.0477810204,
-0.0157285947,
0.0532450303,
-0.0212339591,
-0.0010148466,
-0.024090752,
-0.007023287,
0.0436851047,
0.0142290229,
-0.0491987839,
-0.029355349,
-0.009790278,
0.0375341438,
-0.0084227584,
-0.0144369667,
-0.0169103853,
-0.0062246569,
-0.0239668544,
0.0414397568,
-0.009437711,
-0.017141344,
-0.0076795854,
0.0090888273,
-0.0206652712,
0.0162143409,
0.0101248156,
0.0150910765,
-0.0425560512,
-0.0442236066,
0.0104357805,
-0.0161238797,
0.0273887813,
-0.0420567542,
0.0461663008,
0.0512786433,
0.0379912369,
-0.0841998756,
-0.0433776379,
-0.0215216167,
0.0475914925,
-0.0607855693,
0.0524631329,
-0.0290698912,
0.0442333631,
0.0207453016,
-0.0034882815,
-0.0566470958,
-0.0013247549,
0.0217456706,
-0.0413534008,
0.0593635626,
-0.0752488077,
0.0018829673,
0.0714272931,
-0.0264985096,
-0.0173569508,
0.0325287022,
0.0344180651,
-0.0298207477,
0.0675000548,
-0.0133324368,
0.0018037998,
0.033975143,
0.0099493414,
-0.0248675458,
0.0011713904,
0.0227259174,
-0.0402231216,
0.0099135078,
0.0101749869,
0.011249437,
-0.0128510576,
-0.0129291089,
0.0206304155,
0.0548735149,
-0.0467155688,
0.0332136527,
0.0060449308,
-0.0138147259,
0.0910584554,
-0.0011301658,
-0.0152853644,
-0.0251366403,
-0.0127864312,
0.0392088108,
-0.0326514654,
0.0641568899,
0.0063964478,
0.0153537076,
-0.0201551132,
0.0031677794,
-0.0460263006,
-0.0083565516,
0.0670507029,
-0.0154604437,
-0.0282742362,
0.0379916169,
0.0233246498,
-0.0110850139,
-0.00351306,
-0.0042994106,
0.0336600058,
0.0028010025,
0.0428354889,
-0.0660567582,
-0.0628002733,
-0.0408210605,
-0.0512854569,
0.0391401425,
-0.0260868333,
-0.0460376889,
-0.0119324867,
-0.0106399273,
-0.0000972131,
0.0105217602,
0.0429011658,
-0.0041168993,
0.0323866867,
-0.0053149429,
-0.0017601841,
-0.0561632141,
-0.0625379384,
0.0626302287,
-0.0734494925,
-0.0226785354,
-0.0349665768,
-0.0089780437,
0.0399717614,
0.0462670997,
-0.022411501,
-0.0039348374,
0.0478882492,
-0.0135639114,
0.0358320698,
-0.0046695531,
0.0695588887,
0.0218273997,
0.0322839878,
-0.0086642765,
-0.0305355433,
0.0689890534,
-0.0165591985,
-0.0073868032,
-0.0373357795,
0.0391034223,
0.000413752,
0.000762842,
-0.0166272838,
0.0073069297,
-0.0023061936,
-0.0219704434,
0.0553149246,
-0.0003845082,
0.0456075445,
0.0349457525,
-0.06531398,
-0.0079101929,
-0.0148609327,
-0.038156908,
0.0090031018,
-0.0153657673,
-0.0383725427,
0.0114226434,
-0.0299556497,
-0.0430557951,
-0.0149265658,
-0.0487674326,
0.021822555,
0.0163548831,
0.0579163507,
0.0183067434,
-0.0301984306,
-0.0272857137,
0.001021477,
0.0396801382,
-0.0368970595,
-0.0475737378,
-0.0221295208,
0.0533311963,
-0.0163509175,
0.0092318282,
-0.012202194,
0.0025533782,
-0.0572260544,
0.0547117703,
0.0450679772,
-0.0546311662,
-0.0402117446,
0.0124156773,
-0.0096084988,
0.0072428598,
-0.0196367837,
0.016926825,
-0.0123913242,
0.0201037619,
-0.0059006782,
0.1073964983,
0.0011447022,
0.0476840101,
-0.0038364485,
0.019760184,
-0.0243993681,
0.0036778112,
-0.0189350434,
0.0571483672,
0.0030802321,
-0.0284106117,
0.0526418723,
0.015395307,
-0.0405685343,
-0.0043492587,
0.0162403788,
0.0355054587,
0.0093145194,
-0.0132895447,
0.0234821346,
0.0336900055,
-0.0097909803,
0.0278965794,
-0.0070896405,
0.0010376786,
0.0397773683,
-0.0656584054,
-0.0149675841,
-0.0338153429,
0.0058847377,
-0.037852142,
-0.0099001452,
0.0227505807,
-0.0241630748,
0.0534311235,
-0.016870942,
0.0399979874,
0.0472814627,
0.0116164591,
-0.0122599127,
-0.0045504207,
-0.0000917131,
0.0304781012,
-0.0320993885,
0.0196303036,
-0.0037115894,
-0.0059443,
-0.0586146973,
0.0571947247,
-0.0126343565,
-0.0474217422,
-0.052671954,
0.0246131774,
0.0201918725,
0.0376083553,
-0.035514012,
0.0005102837,
-0.055294238,
0.0372899324,
0.0874748975,
-0.0049357209,
0.0054934933,
0.0163884219,
-0.0012586227,
0.0105756084,
-0.0392057486,
0.0218851175,
-0.0559519753,
-0.0352506042,
0.0120798992,
-0.1075649858,
0.0193622727,
-0.0123971878,
0.0112728905,
-0.0285159443,
0.0010897858,
0.0858508721,
-0.0059262798,
-0.0465276837,
-0.050730601,
-0.0048601623,
0.012750458,
0.0121989958,
0.0231957007,
-0.0904428139,
-0.0061146296,
0.0203301627,
0.0101108924,
-0.0033223548,
-0.0609452017,
0.0098502235,
-0.0676540732,
0.020253472,
-0.0386383161,
-0.0579797477,
-0.0106003657,
-0.0859273374,
0.0234653652,
-0.0585203357,
-0.0307114962,
-0.0348418728,
-0.0405985601,
0.0344795957,
0.0275516789,
-0.0030659246,
-0.0884341374,
-0.0032120992,
-0.0429633446,
0.0242836047,
0.037769977,
0.0573270693,
-0.0463167913,
0.0047904793,
-0.0027213134,
-0.0131381219,
-0.0488922372,
-0.0065167691,
0.0784449577,
-0.0541329458,
0.0114752734,
0.0097024022,
0.0517080128,
-0.0330721848,
-0.0104787359,
0.0597477555,
0.0538448058,
0.0229503121,
0.0290520508,
-0.0551535003,
-0.0335738286,
-0.0121866148,
0.0615503304,
0.0186636075,
0.0036665665,
-0.0397407599,
0.0180044994,
0.0539820381,
-0.0101601882,
-0.0065579759,
-0.0167893916,
-0.0835392848,
-0.0256073419,
-0.0446062386,
-0.0382176563,
0.0109203979,
-0.0013509796,
0.0413153581,
0.0093466612,
0.0555385873,
0.0175345913,
-0.0832456276,
0.0387532189,
-0.0052789962,
-0.0191763509,
-0.0554915816,
-0.0305170082,
0.0673094168,
0.0250876807,
-0.0579938143,
-0.0160447154,
0.0040086983,
-0.0578607656,
0.0100895921,
0.0160951111,
0.011839564,
0.0106812092,
-0.0003864766,
-0.0331418104,
0.0051234253,
0.0401911139,
-0.0310480949,
-0.0312712267,
0.0207954198,
-0.0123201469,
-0.0574140288,
-0.0063427156,
-0.0209937058,
0.0369619578,
-0.0233722441,
-0.0078986781,
-0.036845278,
-0.031996049,
0.0163041595,
0.0353592001,
0.0810693726,
-0.0120647931,
-0.0264017284,
-0.0434818417,
0.0055727623,
-0.0023546286,
0.012919873,
-0.010796871,
0.0197703447,
-0.0003276128,
0.004501062,
-0.0236035883,
0.02509184,
-0.0033665774,
0.0601013415,
-0.048241429,
0.0367662199,
0.0164481457,
0.0788273811,
-0.0310540665,
-0.0673452765,
0.010491102,
-0.0087015573,
-0.0142193772,
0.0131878629,
-0.0162951332,
0.004833526,
0.0232862663,
0.0166697837,
0.0096737826,
0.0168987401,
-0.071238853,
0.0166279562,
-0.0194477029,
0.0391710848,
0.041955296,
0.0038925004,
0.0613243356,
-0.0263608173,
-0.0550821126,
-0.0212930981,
0.0402373523,
0.0134400008,
0.0365652293,
0.0279838517,
0.028466234,
-0.0472041182,
-0.0209997762,
0.0397533178,
0.0523641147,
0.0558124781,
0.0424096063,
-0.0452986285,
-0.0165120624,
-0.0042462754,
-0.023418095,
-0.0252165664,
0.0278474391,
-0.0061593573,
-0.0350077413,
-0.0119165266,
0.063403517,
-0.0120551297,
-0.0055483286,
-0.0035511616,
-0.0258230045,
0.0461911298,
0.0219334774,
-0.0360180624,
-0.050553564,
0.0582509413,
-0.0243966207,
-0.0375097468,
-0.0417346135,
-5.690379339e-33,
-0.0163461883,
-0.0521086529,
0.009241919,
0.0019219312,
-0.0070419828,
0.0393230654,
-0.0169079751,
-0.0499841087,
-0.0260865837,
0.0094243279,
-0.0317738168,
-0.0052186046,
0.0097333211,
-0.0065217116,
0.011854914,
0.0074265073,
0.0284911375,
-0.0091970721,
-0.026756743,
0.0056973831,
0.0464651361,
0.0428965129,
0.0675324798,
-0.1055683866,
0.0580100901,
-0.0242062807,
0.0078072431,
-0.027366003,
0.0424678624,
0.0746606365,
-0.0539864749,
-0.0206074715,
0.0212648083,
-0.059998244,
0.0231711566,
0.0248917732,
-0.1372387409,
0.0259864889,
0.0031948083,
0.0214743912,
0.0079060672,
-0.0452357121,
0.0256291125,
0.0005961927,
-0.0057831868,
-0.0122463629,
0.0923678204,
-0.0239755996,
-0.0113892481,
-0.0538615212,
-0.0623415448,
0.0387583114,
-0.0035496678,
0.0733415186,
0.0632941648,
0.0003076096,
-0.0003214015,
0.075345926,
-0.0226882603,
-0.0166584048,
0.0542389117,
0.0049881972,
-0.0143728536,
0.00394279,
0.0197357051,
0.0133273574,
0.013466049,
-0.0267917402,
-0.002574035,
-0.0210322514,
0.0135081215,
0.0395994261,
-0.009637258,
0.0344661959,
0.0280447528,
-0.007643322,
-0.0272158477,
0.0117536914,
0.023604637,
0.0172926094,
-0.0263829026,
-0.0479661077,
-0.0050651189,
0.0470271632,
-0.0001254682,
-0.0892947242,
-0.0129912021,
-0.0103490334,
0.0013794607,
-0.0250492543,
-0.029141074,
0.0701622665,
-0.0042292201,
-0.0423328616,
-0.0661882237,
0.0440551937,
0.0278612766,
0.0362977684,
-0.003345924,
-0.0140497163,
-0.0726371557,
-0.0467248559,
0.0055205729,
0.0025425521,
0.050512854,
-0.0151679032,
0.0358344913,
-0.0221465584,
-0.0053415266,
-0.02394397,
0.0188983995,
0.0034627935,
-0.0107726082,
0.0655499473,
-0.0021515856,
0.012410569,
0.0287408326,
-0.0014063776,
0.060500551,
0.0275346693,
-0.0217849724,
0.0494758263,
0.0073264684,
0.0472999066,
0.0125642745,
-0.030463567,
-0.0144474143,
0.0261382051,
-0.0123372022,
-0.0268043485,
0.028970629,
-0.0199877061,
2.434e-7,
0.0374502353,
0.0387314223,
0.0295063686,
-0.0135143846,
0.0035887256,
0.0119148009,
0.0101887658,
0.035546124,
-0.0102934455,
-0.0044270516,
0.0018139941,
-0.0591834038,
0.0245791432,
0.0013870313,
-0.093715705,
-0.0735522285,
-0.0643865764,
-0.0223495271,
-0.0617126115,
0.0348212235,
-0.0390611291,
0.0191322137,
0.0035879712,
0.0046783821,
-0.0596041121,
-0.0169011541,
0.0127460137,
-0.0338413119,
0.043787431,
0.06161993,
0.0639658868,
0.0200845599,
-0.0069687492,
0.0113908751,
-0.0053517572,
0.0396480262,
0.0023313966,
0.0686742812,
0.0090842275,
0.0301479306,
0.0188696999,
-0.0122804269,
0.0209778957,
-0.0357027911,
0.049010925,
-0.0099794473,
-0.0290553514,
-0.0470352657,
-0.0674607679,
-0.017007703,
-0.0229312051,
0.000592977,
0.0183378328,
0.0309646036,
-0.015296462,
-0.0573192574,
-0.0129444432,
-0.057928253,
0.036422886,
0.0423841476,
-0.0166295581,
-0.0056741601,
-0.0020022863,
-0.068433404,
0.0114866924,
-0.0864810124,
0.0199979264,
2.391394483e-34,
0.0079719257,
-0.0108852573,
-0.044112917,
0.1137390286,
-0.0066846469,
-0.0311182309,
-0.0328049287,
0.0114062354,
-0.0492364801,
-0.027262738,
0.0341435261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09841v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09841v1 | Leveraging LLMs in Scholarly Knowledge Graph Question Answering | 2023-11-16T12:13:49 | 2023-11-16T12:13:49 | Tilahun Abedissa Taffa, Ricardo Usbeck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG | This paper presents a scholarly Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA)
that answers bibliographic natural language questions by leveraging a large
language model (LLM) in a few-shot manner. The model initially identifies the
top-n similar training questions related to a given test question via a
BERT-based sentence encoder and retrieves their corresponding SPARQL. Using the
top-n similar question-SPARQL pairs as an example and the test question creates
a prompt. Then pass the prompt to the LLM and generate a SPARQL. Finally, runs
the SPARQL against the underlying KG - ORKG (Open Research KG) endpoint and
returns an answer. Our system achieves an F1 score of 99.0%, on SciQA - one of
the Scholarly-QALD-23 challenge benchmarks. | [
0.0724290609,
0.0104483664,
0.0355640277,
0.0336539447,
-0.0452503935,
0.0169123225,
0.0028958232,
-0.0075916257,
0.03583261,
-0.0658946037,
-0.0152671458,
0.0505372062,
-0.0351171046,
0.0199400485,
0.020795092,
0.0245217364,
0.0111183804,
-0.0190017018,
0.0339252241,
-0.0420789644,
0.0043007624,
0.0460562073,
-0.0022446373,
0.0003193101,
0.0312139057,
-0.0431509055,
-0.0056806263,
0.0201813783,
-0.0009389163,
-0.0100914361,
0.0361953415,
0.0097718164,
0.0292628985,
0.0156739037,
0.0000014618,
-0.0896971524,
-0.0136234378,
0.050576061,
-0.0407692119,
-0.0037955325,
0.0058093248,
0.0035031678,
0.0720028132,
0.0075518358,
-0.0086115282,
0.0195796322,
-0.0070948582,
0.0329255015,
0.0374150537,
0.0396592654,
0.0183011461,
-0.0601538606,
0.0538697131,
0.0101260226,
0.016635742,
-0.0692514926,
0.0442316197,
0.0231007636,
0.0494508967,
0.0361504294,
-0.004511124,
0.0121433819,
-0.0019984804,
0.0001799409,
0.0441522673,
-0.0074846926,
-0.0300661512,
0.0593580157,
0.0171829872,
0.0551399775,
0.0355938412,
-0.0071986457,
0.0416991673,
0.0420332663,
-0.0127546852,
0.0749360994,
-0.0402817577,
-0.0030131082,
-0.0310369078,
-0.0408594497,
-0.013127015,
-0.0415507071,
0.0068461141,
0.0306090619,
-0.0274069048,
0.0851735324,
0.0579738431,
-0.0412748158,
0.015329889,
0.0108622117,
-0.0099870274,
-0.0315590054,
0.0049296343,
0.0795330405,
-0.0270703714,
0.000287935,
0.0135791497,
0.0161135718,
0.0434354171,
-0.0114777833,
-0.010318826,
-0.0048649698,
0.0042042457,
0.0654579177,
-0.0303895269,
0.0338272005,
-0.0142850671,
0.0008291233,
-0.0329850763,
-0.0528894141,
-0.0536640882,
-0.0210290123,
-0.0491306782,
0.0435005017,
-0.0268633869,
-0.0483861305,
-0.0112598827,
0.0005275996,
0.0486482531,
0.003815393,
0.040496435,
0.0295477882,
0.0024161425,
0.0044350326,
-0.0351447947,
0.0617662631,
-0.0406037606,
0.0059513892,
-0.0501109399,
-0.0001181126,
0.00976332,
0.0052351006,
0.031310048,
-0.0591233969,
0.0425120257,
0.0255600512,
0.0058317943,
-0.0297011286,
-0.0301058777,
-0.0376879871,
-0.0004500608,
-0.0708479136,
0.0202434864,
-0.0665498674,
0.0409920514,
0.0327547081,
-0.0185341965,
-0.000621817,
0.0138662905,
0.0207898561,
-0.0630901307,
0.0488138236,
-0.027230978,
-0.0038742437,
0.0611855835,
-0.0265593715,
0.0216555949,
0.0360663496,
0.0227708481,
-0.0375140347,
0.061895851,
0.0169944167,
-0.0311381109,
0.0267745256,
0.0320232026,
0.0095743313,
0.0135977436,
0.0588235445,
-0.0154931312,
0.0563625656,
0.0366412252,
0.0646192655,
-0.0148292976,
-0.0222886112,
0.0087335315,
0.0627706349,
-0.0262895804,
0.0017837536,
0.0167161338,
0.0163731854,
0.0226727799,
0.0090751611,
-0.0043407395,
0.0119113242,
-0.0017670592,
0.0390430316,
0.0365535691,
0.0263879802,
-0.0178101826,
0.033065971,
-0.0154708773,
0.0313855261,
-0.0225870851,
0.026840983,
0.0703844279,
-0.0014887316,
-0.0346486866,
0.0841457024,
-0.0044441344,
0.0119302813,
0.0245055072,
-0.0100487247,
0.0473962575,
0.0509201847,
0.0689415336,
-0.0126936659,
-0.0388123579,
-0.0047026044,
-0.0358975641,
0.0531777665,
-0.0024513626,
-0.0308346767,
-0.0152737573,
-0.0278242771,
-0.0284389034,
-0.0284057092,
-0.0113985734,
-0.00981245,
0.0294036642,
0.0329757258,
0.0004557882,
-0.0944290385,
0.0114841657,
0.0279039368,
-0.0316273682,
0.006731675,
-0.0134588666,
-0.0189382881,
-0.001153963,
0.023697244,
-0.0168604944,
0.034852691,
0.0490054861,
-0.0408511981,
-0.0065914206,
-0.0395587981,
0.0376277529,
-0.0673866123,
0.0743326172,
-0.0238758381,
-0.0158753041,
0.0413608924,
-0.0298986286,
-0.0363613181,
-0.0197196919,
-0.0272494256,
0.0183231607,
-0.0061904658,
-0.0268917736,
0.0135416687,
-0.0252774805,
-0.0512140468,
0.0288038719,
0.0161606502,
0.0699261352,
0.0045004692,
-0.032734856,
0.0185912438,
-0.0124265533,
-0.0323191285,
-0.0189819261,
0.0250997618,
0.0010227291,
0.0402878933,
-0.0132365404,
-0.0675862655,
-0.0159398317,
-0.0813120827,
0.0314100608,
-0.0178349745,
0.0209752917,
0.007261944,
-0.0083981352,
0.0102125267,
-0.0013537888,
-0.0317473672,
-0.0010817114,
0.0048588864,
0.0086734947,
0.047870677,
0.0100341542,
-0.0027945803,
-0.0096691614,
-0.0263143685,
-0.002492972,
0.0722794309,
0.0219695233,
0.0405331179,
-0.0211156104,
-0.0044101332,
-0.041185081,
0.0018149434,
-0.0050938092,
0.0070131849,
-0.0022763747,
-0.0198457949,
0.0020332653,
0.0515427366,
-0.0102259479,
-0.0286974143,
0.0129413586,
0.0044222539,
-0.0572346747,
-0.0000983887,
-0.0203517471,
-0.0216475707,
-0.0174679905,
0.0004711628,
0.0174889192,
-0.0437567569,
-0.0087059438,
-0.0160031561,
0.003767072,
0.0165156871,
0.0291147903,
0.0153111657,
-0.0561052822,
-0.0091510909,
0.00921934,
0.0192272905,
0.0070776031,
0.0257495828,
0.052525349,
-0.0105067901,
-0.0068541635,
-0.0355142578,
0.0315682888,
-0.075142175,
0.0338306762,
0.0077534686,
0.0114138639,
-0.0300924685,
-0.0293503124,
-0.0372085273,
-0.0139558911,
0.0024302641,
-0.036143098,
-0.0025886826,
0.0036590884,
0.0456684828,
-0.0017005055,
0.0081898086,
-0.0190162119,
-0.0000750353,
-0.0516818091,
0.0580806024,
-0.0102391476,
-0.0356525145,
0.0136789735,
0.0247728843,
0.0093943207,
-0.0286762342,
-0.0504712276,
-0.0125795221,
-0.0170488544,
0.0962747708,
0.122925505,
0.0053756982,
0.0015288654,
0.0192338172,
-0.0006253934,
0.0343414657,
-0.0120170135,
0.0140095735,
-0.0075150225,
-0.0094216559,
0.0295513533,
-0.0920480862,
0.0325880796,
-0.0293090343,
0.0147775933,
-0.0427608453,
-0.0371687897,
0.1164008155,
0.0291851368,
-0.0232005306,
-0.0437823832,
-0.0599473529,
0.0246393923,
0.0218362641,
0.0549685843,
-0.0931362137,
-0.0193052031,
-0.0257920045,
0.0318074413,
0.0060786786,
-0.0420663729,
0.0104481373,
-0.1456923485,
0.0202831905,
-0.0247331355,
0.00944544,
-0.0450235009,
-0.0312009957,
-0.0135229882,
0.0017921507,
-0.0129064741,
0.0344239622,
-0.037311431,
0.0231830366,
0.0080839433,
0.0176927317,
0.0002096831,
0.0309036095,
-0.0652924404,
0.0070770378,
0.0118761323,
0.0314117372,
-0.02946309,
0.0084735882,
-0.0303561576,
-0.0176516399,
-0.0121714557,
-0.0041350434,
0.0486068726,
-0.0142037664,
-0.008883602,
-0.0505590737,
0.0029778848,
-0.0276238825,
0.0120529206,
0.0443730876,
0.0562693328,
0.0093963146,
-0.0148702059,
-0.0294098761,
0.004348957,
-0.052747108,
0.0880337209,
0.0257458892,
0.0147548579,
-0.0566377081,
0.0035857905,
0.0019994285,
-0.0458310619,
-0.0380730443,
0.0079419166,
-0.0236876588,
0.0406164005,
-0.066965647,
-0.0187613256,
0.0556536838,
-0.0066582388,
-0.0146802831,
0.0224179514,
0.0014694856,
0.0133562349,
-0.071649909,
0.0023102737,
-0.0317504518,
0.012222291,
-0.0501260497,
0.019377172,
0.0744624063,
0.0045376332,
-0.0351976827,
-0.018422028,
-0.0123759815,
-0.0509138182,
-0.0375336707,
0.002648246,
0.0086763352,
0.0346759707,
-0.032998696,
-0.040602468,
0.0507576466,
0.0335101187,
-0.0305457413,
0.0048996825,
-0.0102332151,
0.0198785048,
-0.0479698144,
0.0228112936,
-0.1112812757,
-0.0417333096,
-0.0163957346,
0.0724758878,
-0.0266532451,
-0.1016292572,
0.0203630608,
0.0524383411,
0.0032932931,
-0.0077221547,
0.0163020659,
0.0016216689,
0.0054694847,
0.0020767946,
-0.0044863056,
-0.0185498986,
0.0081841173,
-0.0020500545,
-0.0415207557,
-0.0102081681,
-0.0099449903,
0.0038253269,
0.0503526405,
-0.0457065403,
-0.0058244476,
0.0048304391,
-0.0090141846,
0.0315961353,
-0.0306808241,
-0.0426956415,
0.0098555423,
0.0062502725,
0.033268407,
0.0038916213,
0.0366171263,
0.0308423676,
0.0031392954,
-0.0294339191,
-0.0167678669,
-0.0843180493,
-0.0591125078,
0.0010086182,
0.0302140079,
0.0631396174,
0.0384244956,
0.0214464068,
0.0030650212,
-0.0600390323,
-0.0324720182,
-0.0056191762,
-0.0132229095,
0.0183479115,
0.0655277297,
0.0323315077,
-0.0114627387,
0.0186163466,
0.0517275743,
0.0569784902,
0.0470202602,
0.0419995226,
-0.0645285398,
-0.015988756,
-0.0477088243,
-0.0140148187,
0.0093104327,
0.0188349988,
0.0176499672,
-0.018925108,
-0.0437620319,
0.0558053143,
-0.0056080366,
-0.0314728953,
-0.0289324839,
0.0451007187,
0.0154296886,
0.0429862291,
-0.0320316739,
-0.0495364442,
0.0883450955,
-0.0473099649,
-0.0545423292,
-0.0088326894,
-5.881809696e-33,
-0.0201509185,
-0.047604572,
0.0236013588,
-0.0292001944,
-0.0448659174,
-0.0033472157,
-0.0122680785,
-0.05893052,
-0.0422401093,
0.0345271751,
-0.0103943227,
-0.0076465425,
-0.0214807522,
0.016922377,
0.0057428367,
-0.0412703529,
0.0030071796,
-0.0042438111,
0.0045024501,
0.0148975234,
0.0587284155,
0.0558897257,
0.0041578067,
0.0023749138,
0.0079110814,
-0.063827388,
0.0082754493,
0.0181429181,
0.0121680805,
0.0739112198,
-0.0379636772,
0.0104296636,
0.015516609,
-0.0371847935,
0.0392332003,
0.0134536903,
-0.1104325056,
-0.0259509459,
0.0175065119,
0.0072530909,
-0.0034210167,
-0.0360437147,
0.0299246907,
0.0094601028,
0.0359646231,
-0.0320719704,
0.0542164743,
0.011832865,
-0.0357214101,
-0.1058487073,
-0.0282406267,
0.006791946,
-0.014525108,
-0.0143363969,
-0.0182690583,
0.000410335,
-0.0047434387,
0.0441533253,
0.0039836103,
-0.017289713,
-0.0151641425,
0.0076694693,
-0.023695508,
0.0074942145,
0.0099217342,
0.0025206031,
-0.0440050326,
-0.0640242472,
0.0281603914,
0.0066142171,
-0.0367394611,
0.0371259674,
0.0394067243,
0.0470551141,
0.0068684937,
0.040958032,
-0.073194392,
0.0308615156,
0.011282322,
0.037696071,
-0.0079360148,
-0.0216702446,
0.0235436093,
-0.0323397294,
-0.0314208008,
0.0248979628,
-0.0450244248,
-0.0002462373,
0.0327005759,
-0.034966141,
0.0049417107,
0.0068826359,
0.0328280963,
-0.0687887818,
-0.0271871388,
0.1059886441,
0.0113815451,
0.0355680399,
-0.0085697751,
0.0503591187,
-0.0661740527,
0.0328628458,
0.0046357736,
-0.0446449481,
-0.0279544313,
0.0308945403,
-0.0125393681,
-0.027286185,
-0.0209125318,
-0.020303987,
0.0024881277,
-0.0082554566,
-0.0467831492,
0.0257177558,
-0.014348208,
0.0594818108,
0.0204566084,
0.0512972437,
0.0172063466,
0.0144088883,
-0.0057552019,
0.0188638959,
0.0374519266,
0.0234481599,
-0.0244167205,
0.0309812576,
-0.0140940351,
0.0538017564,
-0.0568382032,
-0.0268864911,
0.0010228243,
0.0190622266,
2.422e-7,
0.0910557434,
0.0312785394,
0.0174942333,
0.0457000881,
-0.0194579847,
-0.0089627858,
0.0158313103,
0.0581797808,
0.0253731646,
-0.0002553685,
0.009754274,
0.0167588945,
-0.0082135582,
0.016855685,
-0.1088594571,
-0.0263323523,
-0.0680007786,
-0.0569578111,
-0.0462716594,
0.0160554107,
0.0231759455,
0.0187630467,
0.0013338052,
-0.0172572788,
-0.050566636,
-0.0698013231,
0.0535531677,
0.0137438877,
-0.0294612031,
0.0253348202,
0.0330980904,
-0.0201848876,
0.0151087958,
0.0231912863,
0.0086078746,
0.0472878478,
-0.000518738,
0.0278136861,
-0.0101782884,
-0.0461645722,
-0.0006826391,
-0.0359550565,
0.0210964363,
-0.0235269014,
0.0871873498,
-0.0296343714,
-0.0077324989,
-0.0022760693,
-0.0623910762,
-0.0351320133,
-0.0037165012,
-0.0323926248,
-0.0235460252,
0.0233470965,
0.0230747741,
-0.0156240351,
0.0263632257,
-0.0644510984,
0.0474661514,
0.0303180385,
-0.0348681398,
-0.0520743839,
0.0201531909,
-0.0350989401,
-0.0255909786,
-0.0656920597,
-0.0014501071,
1.891912355e-34,
0.0698897615,
0.0158459917,
-0.0166380983,
0.0696155578,
0.0201965757,
-0.0259739067,
-0.0465884283,
0.0006584922,
0.03145523,
-0.122713387,
0.0136944558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09836v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09836v1 | PELMS: Pre-training for Effective Low-Shot Multi-Document Summarization | 2023-11-16T12:05:23 | 2023-11-16T12:05:23 | Joseph J. Peper, Wenzhao Qiu, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We investigate pre-training techniques for abstractive multi-document
summarization (MDS), which is much less studied than summarizing single
documents. Though recent work has demonstrated the effectiveness of
highlighting information salience for pre-training strategy design, it
struggles to generate abstractive and reflective summaries, which are critical
properties for MDS. To this end, we present PELMS, a pre-trained model that
uses objectives based on semantic coherence heuristics and faithfulness
constraints with un-labeled multi-document inputs, to promote the generation of
concise, fluent, and faithful summaries. To support the training of PELMS, we
compile MultiPT, a multi-document pre-training corpus containing over 93
million documents to form more than 3 million unlabeled topic-centric document
clusters, covering diverse genres such as product reviews, news, and general
knowledge. We perform extensive evaluation of PELMS in low-shot settings on a
wide range of MDS datasets. Our approach consistently outperforms competitive
comparisons with respect to overall informativeness, abstractiveness,
coherence, and faithfulness. | [
0.0042548915,
0.0140052401,
0.0560028329,
-0.0317859463,
0.008054439,
-0.0107849427,
-0.0258083865,
-0.0342314281,
-0.0445730761,
-0.0698599294,
-0.0089630745,
0.0003786334,
0.0024485108,
-0.0185137782,
-0.0055032047,
-0.0867956281,
0.0256077126,
-0.0001281353,
0.0165809039,
-0.012094398,
0.0302642882,
0.0179196037,
0.0052416925,
-0.0040281625,
-0.01598409,
-0.0162563007,
0.0066075008,
0.0140255047,
0.0306350514,
-0.037443947,
0.0071269269,
0.0160273705,
0.0466584489,
-0.0289344527,
0.0000020181,
-0.0495565981,
-0.0201213174,
-0.0169821158,
0.0193955041,
0.0137853473,
0.0454680175,
-0.0608272627,
0.0549326055,
-0.0093645221,
0.013138392,
-0.0094292508,
-0.0208666977,
0.0762626529,
0.0903982371,
0.0730587691,
-0.0324876271,
-0.0430140793,
0.0332324952,
0.0016320713,
-0.0234965645,
-0.0106085464,
-0.0267564002,
0.0411758125,
-0.0185331982,
0.0098615699,
-0.0017108746,
0.0045372117,
-0.0003994794,
-0.0010386499,
0.0183371138,
0.026448803,
-0.0764108226,
-0.0185828898,
0.0265379138,
0.0763839483,
0.000276813,
-0.0215074345,
0.0266833454,
-0.0109037887,
-0.0025997148,
-0.0392357111,
-0.0622030273,
0.038420964,
0.0013638999,
0.0170788616,
0.0067135538,
0.062155962,
-0.0075876289,
0.0345196463,
-0.0025412715,
-0.009276662,
0.0018514306,
-0.0057774358,
-0.0206331406,
0.0282226019,
-0.014835272,
-0.048443269,
-0.0220061205,
0.0539446138,
-0.0299649145,
-0.0117582036,
-0.0681816116,
-0.0715923086,
0.0380219631,
-0.022937784,
0.0096354298,
-0.0116944285,
0.0207949542,
0.0601884127,
-0.0247056093,
-0.03529099,
0.0444318764,
0.0189798716,
-0.0576574877,
-0.0277005155,
-0.022160463,
0.0169788022,
-0.0504374392,
0.0813572109,
-0.0064552221,
-0.0377985574,
-0.0290726237,
0.0231453869,
-0.0170579366,
0.0039974316,
-0.0575360917,
0.0194677822,
0.0042470396,
-0.0244310256,
0.0181558747,
0.014533286,
-0.0536553711,
-0.0162174925,
0.0339904353,
0.0322248004,
-0.0123619484,
0.0475034192,
0.0252956264,
0.0065239877,
0.0192632787,
0.0021937999,
-0.0332286544,
-0.0529067852,
-0.0382418782,
-0.042042654,
-0.0073289569,
-0.0464541353,
0.0024782664,
-0.05969733,
0.01559834,
-0.0111922882,
-0.0120509258,
0.0122584058,
-0.0184765663,
0.0170317721,
-0.0336021595,
0.0084790392,
-0.0173244271,
0.0020807367,
0.0363068022,
0.0224563479,
0.0196553525,
0.0495399572,
0.0174440667,
0.0297794715,
0.0424709208,
0.0233518556,
0.0081902649,
-0.0145215308,
0.0112891318,
0.0223019384,
0.0514490642,
-0.0101938779,
-0.0688828155,
-0.0182147119,
0.0669734776,
0.0276464168,
-0.0508039966,
0.0523233935,
0.0372028276,
0.0489329249,
-0.0050215577,
0.0097491425,
0.0321769938,
0.0513037555,
0.0158030596,
0.0588310622,
-0.0004279047,
0.0372633301,
-0.0221506283,
0.0745974407,
0.0721247718,
0.0110082999,
-0.0665560737,
-0.0287763141,
0.0273338631,
-0.0272679236,
-0.0240186322,
-0.0006593636,
0.0253969189,
0.0379037708,
-0.0303133596,
0.0709150285,
0.02227748,
-0.0630589053,
0.0371356495,
0.0177515056,
0.0426125564,
0.0257491246,
0.0367376283,
-0.0396411158,
-0.0322734229,
0.0030339796,
0.0489527509,
0.0329914987,
0.0385694355,
-0.0094684064,
0.0199032594,
-0.0449640788,
-0.0389691144,
-0.0753257051,
0.0128604714,
-0.0081399875,
-0.029036995,
-0.0302981324,
0.0492961705,
-0.0073132417,
-0.0311354436,
0.035785798,
-0.0143142892,
-0.0262023229,
-0.0179811362,
-0.02423664,
0.0023925994,
0.0398395844,
-0.0142809264,
0.0083115892,
0.0197188444,
-0.0052907364,
-0.0035220881,
0.0133647546,
-0.0585245267,
-0.0288140364,
0.009551133,
-0.0770417303,
-0.023953585,
0.0236500259,
-0.0411290489,
-0.0628294945,
0.0372469649,
-0.0134147005,
0.020822607,
-0.0416771062,
-0.0006858542,
0.0434432179,
-0.0023237248,
-0.0073074899,
0.0490659699,
0.0144724995,
0.0028759346,
0.0388359353,
-0.0400562696,
0.0137804318,
-0.0387471206,
0.0231332425,
-0.012537377,
0.0145785157,
0.0039343084,
0.0551207066,
0.0315830745,
-0.033142224,
0.0062273908,
-0.0836457312,
-0.0077214777,
-0.025700219,
-0.0257605202,
0.0534829013,
0.0080325697,
0.0071901195,
-0.0125765745,
-0.0437880158,
0.000775825,
0.0182233807,
0.00002208,
0.0300625227,
0.022986291,
0.0638202503,
-0.0371419042,
-0.012364368,
0.0163289048,
0.0410137065,
0.0186109655,
0.0074040517,
0.0006108302,
0.0071442518,
-0.028473163,
-0.0518605188,
0.0060500656,
0.0411931574,
-0.009559907,
-0.0005461344,
0.03083436,
-0.0161268525,
0.0410130024,
0.0027387985,
0.0336331427,
0.0090131806,
-0.040236067,
-0.0064300434,
-0.0393817015,
0.0589649491,
0.0315995775,
0.0000759664,
0.0565658845,
0.0427219905,
0.0014596713,
-0.0025940696,
-0.0107288221,
-0.0189485103,
-0.0177485235,
-0.0237556808,
-0.0640707612,
-0.0276154019,
0.0268947668,
-0.0178581458,
-0.0395990275,
0.0073584565,
0.066676788,
-0.0293386281,
0.009095679,
-0.0659454465,
0.0119264172,
-0.0491376668,
0.0121080857,
0.0037557455,
0.0282187499,
-0.0119181639,
-0.0107072564,
-0.0363636874,
-0.0235553067,
0.0272074696,
0.0471539795,
0.0946472585,
-0.021741448,
0.0100524947,
-0.0345555805,
-0.0137422457,
0.0173732471,
-0.0668407232,
-0.0031338555,
0.0316395126,
0.0043916157,
0.0279176477,
-0.0509008206,
0.0087254569,
0.0476341769,
0.0679391548,
-0.0039188345,
-0.0452618562,
-0.0072657894,
0.0649896115,
0.0973163843,
-0.0054033161,
0.0356851146,
-0.0578697883,
0.0420403704,
0.0493223593,
0.0190202426,
-0.0148229962,
-0.0049133934,
-0.0056771967,
-0.0305466782,
-0.0571957529,
0.0298268758,
-0.0369029306,
0.0546410643,
-0.014322917,
-0.0023181657,
0.1099735573,
-0.0043716794,
-0.0401856638,
-0.0089232707,
0.0230524018,
0.0388787836,
0.0060189799,
-0.0185173415,
-0.0534397997,
-0.0277592316,
-0.0311897621,
0.0271872096,
0.0551851764,
-0.034480311,
-0.0087215863,
-0.0593279451,
-0.0169659201,
0.0238725431,
-0.0602560826,
0.0005441908,
-0.0226805285,
-0.0043026181,
-0.0101901991,
0.0135963475,
0.0111259753,
-0.0376481079,
0.0027499371,
-0.0060380446,
-0.0869449675,
0.028454721,
-0.0200926159,
-0.0392365493,
-0.0458608679,
0.0343744121,
0.0191275571,
-0.023079101,
0.0517361164,
0.0388934463,
-0.0422295108,
-0.0098915342,
0.0188316349,
0.0545307919,
-0.0443636328,
0.0300191827,
-0.0128505183,
0.0651641712,
-0.0165000726,
-0.0372553319,
0.0142342793,
-0.0156811886,
-0.0118770935,
-0.0505605228,
-0.0391748212,
0.0249466375,
-0.0372378789,
0.0782237202,
0.0376287326,
-0.0180708133,
-0.0202364009,
-0.0107292123,
0.0207289681,
-0.0509759448,
0.0120545654,
-0.014184488,
-0.0479453541,
-0.0039746081,
-0.0790388659,
-0.0834924802,
0.0236832667,
-0.0125366002,
-0.0389137864,
-0.0522910953,
-0.0010626154,
-0.012167749,
-0.0141322147,
0.0319164023,
-0.0180775858,
-0.0551745482,
-0.0343120657,
-0.0335340649,
0.0379859321,
-0.0438002869,
-0.00881375,
0.0016014687,
-0.0189943071,
-0.0192776453,
-0.0098051913,
0.0411730148,
0.0069475486,
0.0785661787,
0.0024780808,
-0.0000956127,
0.0992396474,
0.0011981151,
-0.0104961535,
0.0480443761,
0.0317865014,
0.0181961078,
-0.0111825066,
0.0133629218,
-0.0772757381,
0.0813777447,
-0.0222189259,
0.0341848545,
-0.0092632137,
-0.0193449985,
0.0161817968,
0.0333898775,
0.0357642695,
-0.0255227499,
0.053661827,
-0.040474426,
-0.0449879691,
-0.0144937681,
-0.0320831127,
-0.0218530446,
0.0394840464,
-0.0252004806,
-0.0088725016,
-0.021748649,
0.0694867373,
-0.0149835898,
0.059197098,
-0.0314657651,
-0.0284911357,
-0.006498538,
-0.0478761196,
-0.072208479,
-0.0028295931,
-0.0640483797,
0.0005621845,
-0.0587366484,
-0.0092651127,
-0.0117845433,
-0.0179724414,
0.0265987292,
0.0103772348,
-0.0204066075,
0.0308368038,
-0.0657380819,
0.0497495085,
-0.0644681156,
0.0024118803,
0.0436426103,
-0.0550244637,
0.0804337487,
-0.0015777565,
-0.0124702957,
-0.0295315087,
0.0368552841,
0.03886481,
-0.0121611664,
-0.0529395603,
0.0462275445,
0.0063760411,
0.0215269849,
0.0975497738,
-0.0789767876,
0.0170682408,
0.0368294269,
0.0088341106,
-0.0498848744,
-0.0240837932,
0.0131583028,
0.0712079853,
-0.0012683006,
-0.0210542157,
-0.0251075272,
0.0091853766,
0.0291521512,
0.0093777394,
-0.00704476,
0.0261586346,
0.0647803769,
0.0371495672,
0.0137742236,
0.0108140949,
-0.0386867449,
-0.0330350772,
-0.0147404028,
0.02359391,
0.0242224857,
-6.314591818e-33,
-0.0243701264,
0.0142367845,
-0.018153226,
0.028666392,
-0.0264351666,
0.0260621794,
-0.0741979256,
-0.0009277501,
0.0019647256,
0.0213231575,
-0.0020105769,
0.0117994966,
-0.0012335113,
0.0606979951,
0.0098705897,
0.0388530828,
0.0460065678,
0.032416828,
-0.0328810886,
0.0566491447,
0.0281178225,
-0.0075777783,
0.0482842997,
-0.0123128006,
0.003582594,
-0.0262793787,
-0.0311656203,
-0.0266999155,
0.0585061572,
0.0117414584,
-0.0076678824,
0.0132549023,
0.0457884483,
0.00161453,
-0.0694849566,
0.0094859162,
-0.0738566369,
-0.0595943481,
0.0078058825,
-0.0498498306,
-0.057781294,
-0.026977485,
0.0424140356,
-0.0364504978,
0.0438428521,
-0.041380018,
0.0556376018,
-0.0287085008,
-0.0201417021,
-0.1118657142,
-0.0432596952,
0.0159090795,
-0.032754343,
-0.0197466519,
0.0066152867,
0.0432661362,
-0.0043400764,
0.0462276489,
-0.0578736179,
0.052507434,
0.0016186015,
0.0349784233,
0.0109791737,
-0.0013276282,
-0.0097620767,
0.0700096786,
-0.0225513969,
-0.0050813975,
-0.0019628725,
0.0667489991,
0.0056346217,
0.0157244336,
-0.00738353,
0.0236970745,
0.0585355982,
0.046797853,
-0.0576472767,
0.0943337455,
-0.0438550189,
0.0224252455,
0.0141638657,
-0.0019611809,
0.014607192,
-0.0027263674,
-0.019906424,
0.0270565189,
-0.0044606691,
-0.0181606673,
-0.0517186634,
0.036645297,
-0.047294613,
0.007281607,
0.0116935326,
-0.0120852208,
0.0103337597,
0.0067925625,
-0.0416148454,
0.0184554923,
0.0244787894,
-0.0286851507,
-0.0458099917,
-0.0040837023,
0.0234975275,
0.0106390277,
-0.0030535785,
0.0126981102,
0.0898260102,
0.0088244686,
-0.0285978541,
-0.0032648549,
0.026862381,
-0.0025160506,
-0.0311988164,
-0.0099278195,
-0.0128884707,
0.0212313198,
-0.0046993536,
0.0462609641,
-0.018420659,
-0.0048688292,
0.0161654968,
0.000911755,
0.0182491187,
0.0372994319,
0.0137407668,
0.0226352103,
-0.0144451596,
-0.0403534025,
0.059833318,
-0.0512509048,
-0.0238565356,
0.0011332547,
2.574e-7,
0.0293679442,
0.0244830698,
0.0521028303,
-0.010767865,
-0.0151259275,
0.0330369957,
-0.0097143305,
0.062654525,
-0.0167281367,
-0.0320951492,
0.0509246513,
0.0404078588,
0.0191097874,
0.029771369,
-0.0841236711,
-0.0079029519,
-0.0746262595,
-0.0306108166,
-0.0430586003,
-0.022603441,
0.0488790497,
0.0581870861,
-0.0188184921,
0.0002256256,
0.0122345397,
-0.0117003461,
0.0579907373,
-0.0005228037,
-0.0381934792,
0.0256833509,
0.0594563372,
-0.0159519576,
-0.0216538627,
-0.0405871198,
-0.0234024599,
-0.0188606512,
0.0383464843,
0.0334394462,
0.0157541949,
-0.0395419449,
0.0258472059,
-0.0045184479,
0.0114405127,
0.0262655299,
0.0498625487,
-0.0787427425,
-0.0103043681,
-0.0322378501,
-0.0860463083,
0.0133024221,
-0.0138892718,
0.003868696,
-0.0527302139,
0.0477052517,
-0.00382494,
-0.0002250375,
-0.0100705912,
-0.0691105723,
-0.0488838963,
0.0428857654,
0.0154263247,
0.006846799,
0.0251898225,
-0.0331286639,
0.0241927262,
-0.0809989199,
0.0028906576,
2.221999319e-34,
0.1075076237,
-0.0079377806,
-0.036768768,
-0.0322156474,
-0.0102744456,
-0.0132048298,
-0.0445194095,
-0.040743567,
-0.0059545031,
-0.0432365984,
0.0109981317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09835v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09835v4 | ML-Bench: Evaluating Large Language Models and Agents for Machine Learning Tasks on Repository-Level Code | 2023-11-16T12:03:21 | 2024-06-18T12:49:41 | Xiangru Tang, Yuliang Liu, Zefan Cai, Yanjun Shao, Junjie Lu, Yichi Zhang, Zexuan Deng, Helan Hu, Kaikai An, Ruijun Huang, Shuzheng Si, Sheng Chen, Haozhe Zhao, Liang Chen, Yan Wang, Tianyu Liu, Zhiwei Jiang, Baobao Chang, Yin Fang, Yujia Qin, Wangchunshu Zhou, Yilun Zhao, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4 achieving impressive results
in function-level code generation, they struggle with repository-scale code
understanding (e.g., coming up with the right arguments for calling routines),
requiring a deeper comprehension of complex file interactions. Also, recently,
people have developed LLM agents that attempt to interact with repository code
(e.g., compiling and evaluating its execution), prompting the need to evaluate
their performance. These gaps have motivated our development of ML-Bench, a
benchmark rooted in real-world programming applications that leverage existing
code repositories to perform tasks. Addressing the need for LLMs to interpret
long code contexts and translate instructions into precise, executable scripts,
ML-Bench encompasses annotated 9,641 examples across 18 GitHub repositories,
challenging LLMs to accommodate user-specified arguments and documentation
intricacies effectively. To evaluate both LLMs and AI agents, two setups are
employed: ML-LLM-Bench for assessing LLMs' text-to-code conversion within a
predefined deployment environment, and ML-Agent-Bench for testing autonomous
agents in an end-to-end task execution within a Linux sandbox environment. Our
findings indicate that while GPT-4o leads with a Pass@5 rate surpassing 50%,
there remains significant scope for improvement, highlighted by issues such as
hallucinated outputs and difficulties with bash script generation. Notably, in
the more demanding ML-Agent-Bench, GPT-4o achieves a 76.47% success rate,
reflecting the efficacy of iterative action and feedback in complex task
resolution. Our code, dataset, and models are available at
https://github.com/gersteinlab/ML-bench. | [
-0.0157743581,
0.0708056167,
-0.0249073394,
0.0161415115,
-0.0471444391,
0.0002817101,
-0.0261574406,
-0.0153977899,
0.0187426824,
0.0039560297,
0.0048308279,
0.047066059,
-0.00061804,
0.0261046309,
0.0263482742,
-0.0072091306,
0.0302060749,
-0.0501747951,
-0.0329859518,
0.0135478759,
-0.0274687372,
0.0383598581,
0.0112047642,
0.0441513099,
0.008527278,
-0.0318690129,
0.0078613069,
0.0513277054,
-0.0093733519,
0.0230415836,
0.0010534172,
-0.0022351129,
-0.0053640818,
0.0620314702,
0.0000022154,
-0.0482659191,
0.0182466283,
0.026612239,
-0.0285596531,
0.0118777845,
-0.0017407031,
-0.0430349968,
-0.0047526755,
0.0116851535,
-0.0324611217,
0.0159730818,
0.057715781,
-0.0453208163,
0.0458535217,
0.059289325,
0.0211408436,
0.0103120646,
0.0097551811,
0.0135013862,
0.043272458,
-0.0331023112,
-0.0328697786,
0.0403769873,
0.0225441456,
-0.0137499934,
0.0215426609,
0.0154402126,
0.0494363196,
0.0129557028,
0.0055685681,
0.0602343306,
-0.0516366921,
-0.0300547238,
-0.0355731472,
0.0282107294,
-0.0647658482,
-0.0303102676,
0.0071229413,
-0.0135339666,
-0.0166427996,
-0.0408676937,
0.0040612034,
0.0395471379,
0.0090936171,
0.0002177721,
0.0032947075,
-0.0199056752,
0.0237663854,
-0.0001299644,
-0.0351810679,
0.0962702408,
-0.0002754357,
0.0095205475,
0.0321767479,
-0.018960597,
0.0131289801,
-0.0505887382,
-0.0156763978,
0.0567490831,
-0.0319188163,
0.0229523499,
-0.0361392871,
-0.0128840888,
0.0448833853,
-0.0500845835,
-0.004244193,
0.044787325,
-0.0291548483,
0.024807917,
-0.0399080813,
0.0922647491,
-0.0097233616,
0.0392908491,
0.0016243041,
0.0072562215,
-0.0619679727,
0.0259913038,
-0.0350363143,
0.0265098121,
0.0086654061,
0.0187190287,
-0.0121601271,
0.0233565941,
-0.0075215935,
0.0757675469,
-0.0298527461,
-0.0265052412,
-0.0391461812,
-0.0016658682,
0.0166791026,
-0.0052580154,
-0.0707131624,
-0.0454558469,
-0.0015731343,
-0.0513780899,
-0.0013313864,
0.0092374878,
-0.0536373742,
-0.0468401201,
0.0512653589,
0.0861057416,
0.0324847102,
0.0339911766,
-0.016983429,
-0.029253047,
0.0340079404,
-0.0966794491,
-0.0359254889,
-0.1103762388,
-0.0193146486,
0.0411178321,
-0.0096282419,
-0.0731079206,
-0.0017402926,
-0.0292615611,
0.0011133248,
0.0611648969,
-0.0000470563,
0.006341516,
0.0468177609,
0.0223134886,
-0.0598716103,
0.0486450456,
0.0257299505,
0.0415052287,
0.0029742133,
-0.0383402184,
0.0502679162,
0.0402231626,
-0.020171538,
0.015695123,
0.0344592407,
0.0452980585,
0.0146146845,
0.0155225694,
0.0386634953,
0.0783632696,
0.0326457433,
-0.0265317839,
0.0324532315,
0.0529926084,
-0.0383412391,
0.0011732061,
0.0542709082,
0.0620462671,
0.0180860478,
-0.0224896502,
-0.0561204776,
0.0356844813,
0.0103250239,
-0.014930319,
-0.0467352234,
0.0573730469,
-0.0080751609,
-0.0463824235,
0.0152719496,
-0.0369968452,
-0.0251661092,
0.0021272246,
0.0316418596,
-0.0071154954,
-0.0506854914,
0.0008742219,
0.0038756835,
-0.0354941227,
-0.0300801564,
-0.0634551793,
0.0181889571,
0.0394456647,
0.0779815167,
-0.0525000393,
-0.0471680425,
-0.0230906624,
-0.0016174455,
-0.0105820708,
0.0042668753,
-0.0025909417,
0.0091492636,
-0.0137172146,
-0.00687582,
-0.0457471199,
-0.0129231932,
0.0509746671,
0.0213170405,
-0.0344890021,
0.0171474162,
-0.0259664692,
-0.0554832779,
0.0576989911,
-0.0077506956,
-0.026256755,
-0.001762233,
-0.0089824237,
0.0134571018,
-0.0381151177,
-0.0417309627,
-0.0061415504,
0.0471244045,
0.0043631936,
-0.0170237888,
-0.0080913473,
0.0007728658,
0.0218317546,
0.0446803942,
-0.0238942783,
-0.0237232614,
0.0184782743,
-0.0484371185,
0.0107701011,
0.0301423967,
-0.0333266519,
0.0125435246,
0.0256641097,
0.0132372817,
-0.0488380641,
0.0173624773,
-0.0191864446,
0.0375568457,
0.0168256816,
-0.0220464319,
-0.0121566262,
0.0861173123,
0.025174655,
0.027648164,
-0.0093211988,
0.0080338754,
-0.0165676549,
0.0411668532,
0.0116283428,
0.0420891717,
-0.0255804211,
-0.0285016689,
-0.0544498973,
0.027410103,
-0.0379480794,
-0.0004359809,
0.017771842,
0.0142686833,
0.0099648153,
-0.0227600615,
-0.0020247849,
0.0217054822,
-0.0153273912,
-0.0003644279,
0.0145673212,
0.0045616101,
-0.0442211553,
-0.0407172181,
0.0090322224,
-0.0271552522,
0.0287117269,
0.0004644915,
0.0066249832,
-0.0615062676,
0.0485526994,
0.017208904,
0.0282490775,
-0.0306014102,
-0.0275210049,
0.0359452553,
-0.0324907079,
0.0688154101,
0.0649419799,
-0.0230327621,
0.004053832,
0.069065474,
0.0143272737,
-0.0537881181,
0.0124617266,
0.0411522649,
-0.0653404668,
-0.0251324233,
-0.0339997262,
0.014411333,
0.0396678075,
-0.0036576423,
-0.0102580786,
-0.045498427,
-0.0065940437,
-0.0125076696,
-0.035165783,
0.0099812783,
-0.014873012,
-0.0196323264,
0.047050599,
-0.0166082289,
-0.1090401188,
0.0492959432,
-0.0398441404,
-0.0386924259,
-0.0391886979,
-0.0502363443,
-0.0494840406,
0.0847528204,
0.0510626025,
-0.0025267627,
-0.0375226624,
-0.0018687124,
-0.0132796457,
0.0198101401,
-0.0571097471,
-0.0106305778,
0.0639243796,
-0.0532720238,
-0.0046121147,
0.0074092406,
-0.0149473436,
-0.0176799688,
-0.0079867812,
-0.0270042717,
0.0021795069,
-0.0057903738,
-0.0305808689,
0.0199480075,
0.0043557589,
0.0139759528,
0.0679301247,
0.0343092531,
-0.0461921729,
-0.0377395228,
-0.0768274814,
0.0080956295,
-0.044192832,
-0.0339806005,
0.0001197789,
0.0052606813,
0.0166546348,
0.1017328575,
0.0050420105,
-0.0878686681,
-0.0352316499,
0.0124228066,
-0.0350669436,
-0.0221408568,
0.0632634312,
0.0462425314,
-0.0511381701,
-0.0429071076,
0.0853734016,
0.0343760438,
-0.0613145009,
0.0245471559,
-0.0181829836,
0.0629267618,
0.0537165813,
0.0784739107,
-0.0831238404,
-0.0217930432,
-0.0053528687,
0.0479828604,
0.0046639908,
-0.0034960771,
-0.001293365,
-0.1068347171,
0.0514070615,
-0.0011783281,
-0.0179626923,
-0.0307849981,
-0.0690923929,
0.0040536518,
-0.0244178455,
-0.0359181091,
0.0186017212,
0.0107546188,
0.0160343647,
-0.0091942297,
-0.0154048251,
0.0318718255,
0.0980878323,
-0.0402341895,
0.0223745015,
0.1061115637,
0.005674141,
0.0059169345,
0.0185501184,
0.0075538084,
0.0061802305,
-0.0015168635,
-0.0070262202,
0.0664304793,
0.0117539661,
-0.0117568886,
0.0625634491,
0.0334486812,
-0.067749992,
0.0068837958,
0.0421072096,
0.0883396119,
-0.0468350947,
-0.0365158655,
-0.0179288015,
-0.0023142558,
0.0128896441,
0.0492150821,
0.0376106612,
-0.0246367026,
-0.0709083527,
-0.0565202385,
0.0077260579,
-0.049178388,
0.0087379199,
-0.0203915183,
-0.0054815267,
-0.0037008533,
-0.0220452808,
-0.0503240414,
0.0231934208,
0.0158470795,
0.0613943227,
-0.0464247428,
0.0114986487,
0.0252092406,
-0.0399062559,
-0.0008694069,
-0.0052939006,
0.0493630357,
-0.0454739146,
-0.0554024465,
0.0225048307,
-0.0213346872,
-0.0172615554,
0.0034224675,
-0.0720773861,
-0.0400366373,
0.0170198102,
0.0716735423,
0.0223130751,
0.0129202725,
-0.0485805161,
-0.0333596095,
-0.0145087726,
0.007107995,
-0.060850583,
0.0299231205,
0.0200081151,
-0.007101079,
-0.0002539345,
0.0010117557,
-0.0626064762,
0.0149416262,
-0.0110847838,
-0.0375117026,
-0.0429705307,
-0.0290806871,
0.0253143162,
-0.0064131659,
-0.0127896294,
0.0273493677,
-0.0085066687,
0.0293147974,
-0.0043269345,
0.0301940963,
-0.0017528506,
-0.0492628962,
-0.0306074265,
0.0339796878,
-0.0107016619,
0.0439181961,
0.001938395,
-0.0070448946,
0.0261126906,
-0.0156097151,
0.0187023468,
0.01363956,
0.0597424917,
0.0642619133,
0.00150061,
-0.0014896583,
0.0103018219,
-0.0122653777,
0.055163525,
-0.012343117,
0.0435579903,
0.0082789669,
0.0368331932,
0.0071379975,
0.0083646467,
-0.0450771526,
-0.0641001537,
0.0101851681,
0.0033817319,
0.0233751368,
0.015138831,
0.0666136816,
-0.055528082,
0.0081745833,
-0.0441988483,
0.0225200597,
-0.0156212086,
-0.021205252,
-0.0035929626,
0.0173942484,
-0.0150957955,
-0.0186400432,
0.0744360313,
-0.0031938204,
0.0605548881,
0.008404471,
-0.0188686457,
-0.0437053442,
-0.0187327284,
-0.008913544,
-0.0616650134,
-0.02782703,
-0.0444955118,
-0.0248644203,
-0.0396532901,
-0.0316752121,
0.0452638902,
0.0191290528,
-0.0400767922,
0.0345627554,
0.1023997813,
0.0070531811,
-0.0104103629,
-0.035273049,
0.0240335092,
-0.0128380461,
-0.0422956869,
-0.038824182,
-5.196895055e-33,
-0.0150954993,
-0.0222944394,
0.0361848548,
0.0605727322,
0.0229834225,
-0.0091528026,
-0.0825115964,
-0.0070141116,
-0.0142702833,
-0.0143366558,
0.0063256361,
0.0176236834,
0.0041655758,
-0.0490985848,
0.0729999691,
0.0273198411,
0.0343449451,
0.0116172666,
-0.0665261522,
0.0618231297,
-0.0217249412,
0.0318439901,
-0.0167451464,
-0.0594896302,
-0.0209698379,
0.0079442309,
0.0291732196,
-0.0295733064,
-0.0228111167,
0.0241308603,
0.016083546,
-0.0014643816,
-0.007175487,
-0.0165874418,
-0.0245248619,
-0.0300427265,
-0.0198775064,
0.0106409239,
-0.0044430778,
0.0150667895,
-0.0308850259,
-0.0551132075,
0.0511266217,
0.005435124,
-0.0288210902,
-0.0000127785,
0.0288150795,
0.0110194413,
0.0164645128,
-0.0059132222,
-0.0865031406,
0.0494666435,
-0.044442419,
-0.0097178435,
0.0006754384,
-0.0018446506,
0.0037216318,
0.0711030811,
0.0117495237,
-0.0025573256,
-0.0055991858,
0.0247449819,
0.0710583627,
-0.0155239552,
-0.0186065976,
0.0105149355,
0.0332058668,
0.0087613231,
-0.0178516973,
0.0420167446,
0.0347921178,
0.0516901948,
0.0395238623,
0.0096117752,
0.0133861965,
0.0100992555,
-0.0213081408,
0.0320191421,
0.0423592888,
0.0333871096,
0.0017188595,
0.0463997237,
-0.0481214114,
0.0141500104,
-0.0403052792,
0.0069348789,
-0.0066530509,
-0.0349568464,
0.0088298777,
-0.0141336955,
-0.0146529824,
0.0054975562,
0.0169932228,
-0.0338825248,
0.0259090904,
0.0333426557,
-0.0781842023,
0.03602162,
-0.0003377979,
0.042640727,
-0.0299440976,
-0.0123771373,
0.0054251072,
0.0175444391,
0.0972570702,
0.0203815382,
0.0228997935,
0.0294990372,
-0.0463685058,
0.0200347304,
-0.0818509609,
-0.0044240579,
-0.0171619859,
0.0293850657,
-0.0208650138,
-0.024491258,
0.0290178694,
0.024142582,
-0.0128920339,
-0.0399701968,
-0.0527021289,
0.0093477378,
0.0046929228,
-0.0202836655,
-0.068909131,
-0.018932607,
-0.0565725341,
0.0564071573,
0.0188722741,
-0.0310061909,
-0.0283193067,
0.0252896082,
2.927e-7,
0.0184890162,
0.0488590971,
0.0096776569,
0.0369560681,
-0.0011511593,
0.0479859523,
-0.0567159131,
0.0152993705,
-0.0011397324,
-0.0180289336,
-0.0200113431,
0.0234201383,
0.0528663248,
0.0495982021,
-0.0102029443,
-0.0159677565,
-0.0082167685,
0.0195795596,
-0.1051262319,
0.0050776345,
-0.0082229758,
0.0614693388,
0.0145062907,
-0.0341419801,
0.0506815352,
-0.0448110178,
-0.0209632143,
-0.01172488,
0.0285396259,
0.0540810637,
-0.0499570407,
0.0351206362,
-0.0218488369,
-0.0086863087,
-0.0145860584,
-0.0263095759,
-0.0234374497,
0.0708029643,
0.0154897235,
-0.0056498218,
0.0294385292,
-0.0124857808,
-0.0060846722,
-0.0807866752,
0.038926933,
-0.0081725428,
-0.0175341759,
-0.0205075108,
-0.0152107067,
-0.0018472192,
0.0130005628,
-0.0339227617,
0.0012082369,
-0.0097619779,
-0.0061007128,
-0.0541675463,
-0.0380507633,
-0.0369583964,
-0.0246163756,
-0.0040653255,
-0.0223492924,
-0.019902708,
-0.0783621296,
0.0434656106,
-0.0109376078,
-0.031950973,
0.0284863748,
2.826030305e-34,
0.0125123076,
-0.0356730334,
0.0172435082,
-0.0028608104,
0.0398186669,
-0.0029821759,
-0.0506971404,
0.0265331417,
-0.0164274387,
0.0001584841,
-0.0128801661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09834v1 | Overview of the HASOC Subtrack at FIRE 2023: Identification of Tokens Contributing to Explicit Hate in English by Span Detection | 2023-11-16T12:01:19 | 2023-11-16T12:01:19 | Sarah Masud, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Md. Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty | cs.CL | cs.CL | As hate speech continues to proliferate on the web, it is becoming
increasingly important to develop computational methods to mitigate it.
Reactively, using black-box models to identify hateful content can perplex
users as to why their posts were automatically flagged as hateful. On the other
hand, proactive mitigation can be achieved by suggesting rephrasing before a
post is made public. However, both mitigation techniques require information
about which part of a post contains the hateful aspect, i.e., what spans within
a text are responsible for conveying hate. Better detection of such spans can
significantly reduce explicitly hateful content on the web. To further
contribute to this research area, we organized HateNorm at HASOC-FIRE 2023,
focusing on explicit span detection in English Tweets. A total of 12 teams
participated in the competition, with the highest macro-F1 observed at 0.58. | [
0.0748209283,
0.0447600819,
-0.029505834,
0.0222415663,
-0.023377426,
0.0462139323,
0.0309506319,
0.0430280194,
0.0112060616,
-0.0438480452,
0.0434519425,
-0.0220027771,
-0.0183571726,
0.0425107107,
0.0093483832,
-0.0509520322,
0.0225571115,
0.0461431816,
0.036808569,
-0.0162358079,
0.0776268393,
0.0037068743,
-0.0013919034,
0.0219020247,
-0.065409556,
0.021860119,
0.0373275056,
0.0042240694,
0.0342990607,
-0.0077326181,
0.0666676834,
0.0575109459,
-0.0333251469,
0.0643379241,
0.00000199,
-0.0338570662,
-0.0263664089,
-0.0118068308,
-0.0046000853,
-0.0167026483,
0.1013902128,
-0.0199059751,
-0.0023077242,
0.0371827409,
-0.0120399809,
0.0023383796,
0.052500587,
0.0508062653,
0.0608563423,
0.0691807196,
-0.0217860378,
0.0069469428,
0.0154722231,
0.0178526174,
0.0336848013,
0.0333693437,
0.0247273967,
-0.0814652815,
-0.056167841,
-0.000628762,
-0.0005797541,
0.0205082912,
0.0266617574,
0.0177121181,
0.0173877198,
-0.0189980716,
-0.0898783579,
-0.0307089724,
0.0048221531,
0.0394149199,
-0.0166461337,
-0.0193890817,
0.0179844089,
-0.004849284,
-0.0114243478,
-0.0300555266,
-0.0048093386,
-0.0057399217,
-0.0202908628,
-0.0051171514,
-0.016562527,
0.0012719739,
0.0345953479,
0.0761869252,
0.0102542983,
0.0274779182,
-0.0048247883,
-0.0598879158,
0.0053070951,
0.0123172067,
0.0026159114,
-0.0220567547,
0.0581630692,
-0.0074817869,
0.0058240886,
0.0053566154,
-0.0494427644,
-0.0628624782,
-0.0040007154,
-0.0888202116,
-0.0106278192,
0.0258697327,
-0.047575485,
-0.0065324763,
-0.0113827968,
0.0323092602,
-0.0271263048,
-0.0070776641,
0.015518466,
0.0270794295,
-0.0013582925,
0.0028996612,
0.0013076044,
-0.0096559878,
-0.0160969961,
0.0573491417,
-0.0338701494,
-0.0148258172,
-0.0354074873,
-0.012988084,
-0.053588748,
-0.0025663432,
0.0215349197,
-0.0036834283,
-0.0016284516,
0.0403992794,
-0.0449488871,
0.0082051521,
-0.0505098812,
-0.0587435663,
-0.0125529869,
0.0315219089,
0.0015250086,
-0.0380881019,
0.0494132712,
0.0211332906,
0.0209998693,
-0.0164537653,
0.0014553836,
-0.0438657552,
-0.0476095192,
-0.0244244244,
0.0036171598,
-0.0674690306,
0.0115971128,
-0.015156378,
-0.0257780235,
-0.0390214697,
0.016011443,
0.007699545,
-0.0371138416,
0.0536960624,
-0.0199179593,
-0.049999699,
0.0155136399,
0.0173010845,
0.054520227,
0.0376091152,
0.0005333917,
0.058378242,
0.062536478,
0.0104675572,
-0.016656395,
0.0626428202,
0.0536397882,
0.0249979384,
-0.0482583717,
0.018867489,
-0.0239382517,
-0.0277515985,
-0.0180353206,
0.0413394347,
0.0012131603,
-0.043853879,
0.0604851991,
0.0801350474,
-0.0797904059,
0.026998397,
0.0297264587,
0.0190064944,
-0.0030795059,
-0.0339145884,
-0.0459889024,
-0.0256690588,
-0.0457865447,
-0.054292798,
0.0383506715,
0.0581245944,
-0.005257186,
-0.0518412292,
-0.0336903073,
0.0033451801,
0.042359218,
-0.0442324243,
0.0260094274,
-0.0084888684,
-0.028202476,
0.0041671852,
0.0366454162,
-0.0442605168,
0.0362010933,
-0.034841124,
0.0025823968,
0.0723927766,
0.0397996567,
-0.0238718521,
-0.0220416188,
-0.0664241835,
0.0137357768,
0.0580341071,
0.0061471639,
0.000687404,
-0.016254561,
-0.0214644186,
-0.0263379328,
0.0573135503,
0.0072558629,
-0.018608436,
0.0446709171,
0.0025494895,
-0.010842164,
0.0523451865,
-0.0594745465,
0.0255226661,
0.0596385598,
-0.0110019958,
-0.0023072001,
0.0396758765,
0.0513249896,
0.0287286825,
-0.0244096257,
-0.0488119684,
-0.007480185,
-0.0166573506,
-0.0497444235,
0.0325645655,
-0.0219742022,
-0.0063603292,
0.0418427177,
-0.0949867442,
-0.0236552712,
0.0938117728,
0.0038864934,
0.0366375074,
0.0495892465,
-0.0367908739,
-0.0351810493,
-0.0022650645,
-0.018209083,
-0.0723025352,
0.0190773867,
-0.0084092226,
0.0718185082,
-0.0376620442,
0.0121180182,
-0.0017329969,
-0.0805907473,
0.036546085,
0.0439615622,
-0.052724462,
-0.0411395095,
-0.0193658657,
0.0189634115,
0.0181623958,
0.0152651928,
-0.0436558425,
-0.0008625608,
-0.0570813082,
-0.0012866161,
-0.0150848022,
-0.0055475598,
0.0456825197,
-0.0052125598,
-0.0139621766,
0.037994504,
-0.0027509215,
-0.0617702827,
0.0361903533,
0.0049191904,
0.0169297587,
-0.0664312467,
-0.0085060867,
-0.0391704105,
-0.0216159616,
-0.0415891521,
0.0190003719,
0.028240284,
-0.0277000815,
0.0414698832,
0.0147078531,
-0.0331226513,
0.0058165565,
0.0077236979,
-0.0731842667,
0.0042378106,
-0.0186411738,
-0.0077873291,
0.0264994912,
0.0664535463,
0.0670864657,
0.0033048941,
0.006817732,
-0.0034459736,
0.0132497186,
-0.0293676741,
0.036911279,
-0.0561038107,
-0.0455589406,
0.0320756026,
0.0681987628,
0.0422571748,
-0.0157900956,
-0.0713260174,
0.0037946801,
-0.0728767663,
-0.0346974768,
-0.0526328757,
-0.0628562719,
-0.0235469267,
-0.0119163133,
-0.0556126349,
-0.0586647689,
0.0419852287,
0.0110924244,
0.018849168,
-0.0323128588,
0.0026924137,
0.0046761399,
0.0250679664,
0.0139169097,
0.0396259278,
-0.0462944359,
-0.013502337,
0.0217115488,
-0.0203602873,
0.0198647622,
-0.0263470411,
-0.0164000299,
0.0121009303,
-0.0052253343,
0.0119093368,
-0.0463189632,
-0.0396300778,
-0.0919628814,
-0.0313178189,
-0.0741542652,
0.0484740362,
-0.0227375645,
-0.0158013236,
0.0117686503,
0.0394409001,
-0.0020666237,
-0.0206308309,
0.0004667275,
0.0163523573,
0.0070124068,
-0.0169421043,
-0.0614007153,
0.047991354,
-0.0230611973,
-0.0464186221,
0.0842649192,
0.0316832177,
0.0064362553,
0.017634552,
0.0253818855,
0.030022487,
-0.012054868,
-0.0022222998,
-0.0091875549,
0.0410320871,
-0.0141556384,
-0.0106884753,
0.0988906249,
0.0265848953,
-0.0284227226,
-0.0082428912,
-0.0203608703,
0.0208775364,
0.0115116211,
-0.019535305,
-0.0802848712,
0.0119331693,
-0.0050003361,
0.0284120943,
-0.0840689838,
-0.0503426231,
0.0051593548,
-0.0508028492,
0.0034213387,
0.0100367106,
-0.0337360054,
-0.0366020501,
0.0125223091,
0.0138540883,
0.0231817979,
0.0058006281,
-0.0171758868,
0.0118876444,
0.0191118065,
0.0258817077,
-0.0624409765,
0.0296290908,
-0.0002548594,
-0.0502312072,
0.0125499163,
0.0244237054,
0.0599878728,
-0.027590353,
-0.0108800605,
0.021956306,
-0.0178781748,
-0.020494476,
-0.0626193509,
0.1087385342,
0.013389213,
-0.0289074965,
-0.0411347114,
0.034103483,
-0.0184431337,
0.0056942897,
0.0099645238,
0.0522411205,
0.0368789025,
0.0240043458,
-0.0357660949,
0.0358340554,
-0.0266600065,
0.0467048883,
0.0489881448,
-0.0532525964,
-0.0131073557,
-0.0741798133,
0.0104805594,
-0.0930532739,
-0.1052536219,
-0.0165889896,
0.0150020076,
-0.0501555204,
-0.0288530849,
-0.0232371371,
0.0283735637,
0.0360554457,
0.0238280389,
-0.0421437994,
-0.0229726397,
-0.0292045549,
-0.048173856,
-0.0150786759,
-0.007909121,
0.0511588007,
-0.0066503105,
0.0014164861,
-0.042663049,
-0.0002888142,
-0.0402344503,
0.0403179005,
-0.0654959381,
-0.0293801967,
0.0607195348,
0.0541799739,
0.0183849037,
-0.0020199746,
-0.0110583883,
-0.0647083372,
0.0676519945,
0.0505815074,
-0.0204270054,
-0.0058201407,
0.0449181534,
-0.0202723257,
0.032518886,
0.0078125075,
0.0161717553,
0.007646611,
0.062327072,
-0.0426306836,
0.0014604054,
0.026840616,
-0.0000232483,
0.0101937847,
0.0344697386,
-0.0080570681,
-0.078271918,
-0.0304748826,
-0.0219589863,
0.005050865,
-0.0424843691,
0.0123298727,
0.0247288346,
-0.0119717997,
0.0183088165,
-0.0404077992,
0.0067365342,
-0.0426954217,
0.0310329571,
-0.062498007,
0.0172231384,
0.0451832488,
0.04733219,
0.0407259576,
0.0095635736,
0.0024085471,
0.0169200674,
0.0071025016,
-0.0144867739,
-0.0197099261,
-0.0088956989,
0.0111425873,
-0.000131112,
0.007200914,
0.0005795035,
-0.0105624031,
0.0141948303,
-0.0360869542,
-0.0545523278,
-0.0201740898,
-0.0111453226,
0.0288341604,
0.0261132047,
-0.0317455903,
-0.0038465925,
-0.0235287175,
-0.0421430655,
-0.0475611575,
-0.0004591699,
0.0199481435,
-0.0220689904,
-0.011878184,
0.0278353784,
-0.007590848,
0.0668897331,
0.0748598352,
-0.0478228368,
-0.0283718891,
-0.0069305836,
0.0253210552,
0.0392454118,
0.0045222342,
0.0396681353,
-0.0495491698,
-0.0489871129,
0.0245764349,
-0.0503387004,
0.0365159437,
-0.0021913513,
-0.00380249,
0.0657485053,
0.0004161032,
0.0000078514,
0.0024693455,
0.0212503076,
0.0367846303,
-0.0655780062,
0.0050105383,
-6.426296842e-33,
-0.0000494737,
-0.0437109694,
-0.0491205789,
-0.0183543134,
-0.0280962028,
-0.0122732306,
0.0217438191,
0.0206132345,
0.0218444075,
0.0340618901,
-0.0050887126,
0.0211206265,
0.0066806125,
0.0101892566,
-0.0012395798,
-0.0249079894,
0.0532035753,
-0.0189006925,
-0.020810293,
0.0243734345,
0.0492938086,
0.0118529862,
0.0151309306,
-0.013345751,
0.0518962778,
-0.0132624032,
-0.0406762026,
0.0258071385,
0.0367362835,
0.0565134361,
0.0053103073,
0.0659570768,
0.0402424112,
0.0005027946,
0.0055375448,
0.0412620194,
-0.0382561944,
-0.0205201097,
0.0420045964,
0.0121239834,
0.005100287,
-0.0408195555,
0.0588589981,
0.0212685,
-0.0499874838,
-0.0502033159,
0.0278234612,
-0.0180588644,
0.0466035306,
-0.0421886817,
-0.0543578006,
0.0316212922,
-0.0617603622,
0.0252372343,
-0.0071083847,
0.0477810465,
0.0312309489,
0.0072805141,
-0.0315912664,
0.0339703448,
0.0099352915,
0.0093008988,
-0.0041836728,
-0.0143533843,
0.0161763728,
0.0555128604,
0.0067154537,
0.0108119557,
-0.0253549982,
0.0591107756,
0.0245356448,
0.0104272347,
0.0634941831,
0.0788192898,
-0.0014118541,
-0.0734893382,
-0.0497390255,
0.0137342541,
0.0386805274,
0.0039993138,
0.0058541708,
-0.0366754383,
-0.062161658,
-0.0184362102,
-0.0046720128,
-0.0790168047,
-0.0242284741,
-0.021961255,
0.0134939253,
-0.0140399225,
-0.0318895727,
-0.0238546077,
0.0285059158,
-0.0209226683,
0.0216828585,
0.0694819689,
-0.0208218247,
0.0274099391,
0.0403762609,
0.0275519472,
-0.0358508937,
-0.0056154258,
-0.0061434261,
-0.0051674638,
0.0374111161,
-0.0177978501,
0.0534207113,
0.0412624888,
-0.087965399,
0.0227998774,
-0.0109102242,
0.0510149375,
-0.0144234393,
0.0519356057,
0.0148426378,
0.0426283926,
-0.0141318282,
-0.0124958837,
0.0574801452,
-0.0287479814,
-0.0277742539,
0.0134000117,
-0.029818859,
-0.0029665155,
-0.0238404442,
-0.0229188818,
-0.0079052951,
0.0015529146,
0.0467334986,
-0.1008865461,
0.0078762239,
-0.0852327868,
2.672e-7,
0.0144701125,
0.0527946241,
0.012091727,
-0.0099769905,
0.0491346419,
0.040529985,
0.0504246764,
0.0054889224,
-0.0231311042,
0.0500918925,
0.007337987,
0.0272235461,
0.0353507958,
0.029594373,
0.0036978184,
-0.0104335109,
-0.0505085588,
0.0039675338,
-0.0517483093,
0.0070002023,
0.0048543965,
0.0705903098,
0.0687086955,
-0.0254196152,
-0.0201795343,
-0.0189212169,
-0.0024909547,
-0.0449506082,
-0.0103802253,
0.0033771733,
0.0280078296,
-0.0102143092,
0.006223693,
-0.0245255232,
-0.0032513621,
0.0198530927,
-0.002187018,
0.0431146547,
0.0235240292,
0.024969155,
0.0017101575,
-0.0125562623,
-0.0033716783,
-0.0545745157,
0.0407061055,
0.039962288,
-0.0053453255,
-0.0413109995,
-0.0207883809,
-0.0289131962,
0.0260241218,
-0.018831471,
-0.005257973,
0.012373385,
0.0114747975,
0.0136677502,
0.0209210627,
-0.0751202554,
-0.0144795561,
-0.0256921574,
-0.0344945267,
-0.0435928889,
-0.0316573717,
0.0304190945,
0.0189951565,
0.0329968631,
0.0408521183,
2.51592135e-34,
0.0123006096,
-0.0237231627,
-0.0034767052,
-0.0140280714,
0.0219863579,
0.0083096856,
-0.0382807814,
-0.0061098645,
0.0491956919,
-0.038524881,
-0.0026838866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09832v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09832v3 | WatME: Towards Lossless Watermarking Through Lexical Redundancy | 2023-11-16T11:58:31 | 2024-06-06T13:17:43 | Liang Chen, Yatao Bian, Yang Deng, Deng Cai, Shuaiyi Li, Peilin Zhao, Kam-fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text watermarking has emerged as a pivotal technique for identifying
machine-generated text. However, existing methods often rely on arbitrary
vocabulary partitioning during decoding to embed watermarks, which compromises
the availability of suitable tokens and significantly degrades the quality of
responses. This study assesses the impact of watermarking on different
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) from a cognitive science lens. Our
finding highlights a significant disparity; knowledge recall and logical
reasoning are more adversely affected than language generation. These results
suggest a more profound effect of watermarking on LLMs than previously
understood. To address these challenges, we introduce Watermarking with Mutual
Exclusion (WatME), a novel approach leveraging linguistic prior knowledge of
inherent lexical redundancy in LLM vocabularies to seamlessly integrate
watermarks. Specifically, WatME dynamically optimizes token usage during the
decoding process by applying a mutually exclusive rule to the identified
lexical redundancies. This strategy effectively prevents the unavailability of
appropriate tokens and preserves the expressive power of LLMs. We provide both
theoretical analysis and empirical evidence showing that WatME effectively
preserves the diverse capabilities of LLMs while ensuring watermark
detectability. | [
0.0225452241,
0.0706449449,
-0.0317646042,
0.0268233791,
-0.0412292592,
-0.0018910975,
0.0247390233,
0.040898446,
0.0346403793,
-0.0788710415,
-0.0258348435,
0.0179715361,
-0.0022802562,
0.0341909565,
0.0460942537,
-0.0078475336,
0.0502784029,
-0.0388149433,
0.0183135029,
-0.0177447107,
-0.0178905558,
0.0164986979,
0.054191757,
0.0129729733,
-0.0185428821,
-0.0173473135,
0.0197540298,
0.0213837922,
-0.0178835485,
-0.0199564062,
-0.0526989065,
0.0613842979,
-0.0020781965,
0.0904057026,
0.0000022056,
-0.0716238096,
-0.0459036641,
0.0083898241,
-0.021894509,
0.0373932868,
0.0328676924,
0.0133856107,
-0.0064055729,
-0.004648285,
-0.0108484589,
0.0311753415,
0.0473271757,
0.0432076044,
0.0605808608,
0.0285704173,
-0.0188782588,
0.0401918478,
0.0357672125,
0.0146671338,
0.0403453149,
-0.0112208817,
0.0110485936,
0.0171374679,
-0.0250878111,
-0.0016342727,
0.011864,
0.0961198509,
0.0041988636,
-0.019176472,
-0.0278496612,
0.0182491913,
-0.0207582973,
-0.0326593667,
-0.0061154198,
0.0083692027,
-0.0127516761,
-0.0193731096,
0.007510432,
-0.0052834521,
0.0199096277,
0.0505567715,
-0.0379165411,
0.0622840859,
0.0059869997,
0.020818036,
0.0214852877,
0.0002979229,
0.0628524646,
0.0294895805,
0.0030207965,
0.0983525738,
0.0308798421,
-0.0107498588,
-0.0336503163,
0.004132485,
-0.0484476648,
-0.0756324455,
0.0305990707,
-0.0013905519,
0.0125129065,
0.0144037381,
-0.0784383267,
-0.0567769594,
0.0321109742,
-0.0406223796,
0.0547816381,
0.0359897241,
-0.0226594694,
0.0458442532,
-0.0772394761,
0.0706954673,
-0.0181812029,
0.035091307,
-0.0016004184,
-0.0082274526,
-0.0131383827,
-0.0941963047,
-0.0055776536,
0.0599494241,
-0.0268993545,
-0.0351990014,
0.0154558476,
0.0444858149,
-0.018037688,
-0.0028089324,
-0.0338132568,
-0.0256914515,
-0.0084513742,
-0.0181785766,
-0.0068875952,
-0.0390687026,
0.0033439458,
0.0440039337,
0.0134402001,
-0.0620533787,
-0.005985715,
0.0267733801,
0.007383368,
0.0112567618,
0.003548756,
0.0879256725,
0.0009855778,
-0.0186459087,
-0.0213432722,
-0.0585960522,
0.0001810643,
-0.0043022772,
0.0273174271,
-0.0606444366,
-0.0037120532,
0.0255310722,
0.0073988717,
-0.0606788956,
0.0095824916,
0.0112682888,
-0.0512253158,
0.0623806007,
-0.031308949,
-0.0160894003,
0.0297356658,
0.0190659743,
-0.0182776861,
0.0806704611,
0.022108594,
0.0424414799,
0.0652833953,
0.0074148765,
-0.0175715238,
0.0272029191,
-0.0077127013,
-0.0006891866,
-0.0514274463,
-0.0568736196,
0.0501081534,
-0.0287135299,
0.0276362561,
0.0523874238,
-0.028734386,
-0.0228284672,
0.0648521259,
0.0707698613,
-0.0533554144,
-0.0115432823,
0.0060075345,
-0.0167792663,
0.0170669965,
0.0217670985,
-0.0442031138,
-0.0204898231,
-0.0174675491,
-0.0299751312,
0.0570691824,
-0.0071165613,
-0.0046740798,
-0.0061499574,
-0.0480152257,
-0.0138484454,
0.0502346009,
-0.0223218482,
0.0206877738,
0.0473562703,
-0.0031610902,
0.0731772855,
-0.0292573702,
-0.0452231541,
0.0328572057,
-0.0702883899,
0.0183247179,
0.0537259988,
0.0834702998,
-0.0161776599,
0.0512667708,
0.021485785,
-0.0199150871,
0.0483291186,
-0.0130691566,
0.0112317195,
0.0256708637,
-0.0310397595,
-0.0215332024,
-0.0464274324,
0.0289144181,
0.0134465005,
0.0263118278,
0.001245814,
0.0290005431,
-0.0547891855,
0.0015976336,
0.0243853126,
0.0057833423,
-0.0273688883,
-0.0302735809,
-0.0223357566,
0.029038908,
-0.0052809976,
-0.0024540173,
0.0587207898,
0.0266113076,
-0.033622928,
-0.0395210274,
-0.0245482102,
-0.0384266004,
0.0010794429,
0.0285792965,
-0.0184932314,
0.0001040677,
0.0338080488,
0.0088053746,
-0.0216721892,
0.0146779213,
-0.0526541509,
0.0622399896,
-0.0573528707,
0.0380211622,
-0.0054196906,
-0.0000554872,
-0.0269764755,
0.0608383678,
-0.0146640399,
0.007307156,
-0.0017816728,
0.0149955843,
0.0004014889,
-0.009754247,
-0.0141941188,
-0.0292104669,
-0.0347443894,
0.0053449301,
0.0173539389,
-0.0181780346,
-0.0269181207,
-0.0088951252,
-0.0404995568,
0.0144238155,
-0.0037197573,
0.0141088562,
0.0155773433,
-0.0166728459,
0.0078261476,
0.0154520907,
-0.001570549,
-0.03359586,
0.0345254578,
0.0615483187,
0.0118783135,
-0.0414292254,
-0.014297029,
0.0173137859,
-0.0112343756,
0.0184816848,
0.0745432079,
0.0071007782,
-0.0472010262,
-0.02713231,
0.0491743907,
-0.0444655754,
-0.0063094753,
-0.000341577,
0.0033091218,
0.0013122185,
0.0055269604,
-0.0026381924,
0.0347079672,
-0.0134499371,
0.0083376886,
0.0614869818,
0.0075631938,
-0.0412624069,
-0.02431654,
-0.0176907592,
-0.0185557529,
0.0027831225,
-0.0459130704,
0.0352491997,
0.0186293684,
0.0082872845,
0.0155336326,
-0.0183372516,
0.0627957955,
-0.0277124699,
-0.0396690629,
-0.0424118713,
-0.0686753094,
-0.0239045974,
0.0528468825,
-0.0278410334,
-0.0849144012,
0.017167097,
-0.0395926163,
0.0163672995,
-0.0052837627,
0.02523553,
0.0078567779,
0.0642462224,
0.00054632,
0.0462621003,
0.0200425275,
-0.04948733,
-0.0336892046,
-0.0195712,
0.0343120657,
-0.0469973497,
-0.0178264212,
-0.0497492328,
-0.0033280805,
0.0060316399,
-0.007758243,
-0.0488331579,
-0.008753838,
0.0037025476,
0.0248605013,
0.0494896322,
-0.0096097579,
-0.0302473735,
0.0052538998,
0.0616831556,
0.0039145905,
-0.0050754501,
0.0057703662,
-0.028241653,
0.0760595948,
0.0180068258,
-0.033408206,
0.0310743041,
-0.0142418826,
-0.018977154,
0.0699469,
0.0161870737,
-0.0151126543,
0.0517099388,
0.0159925595,
0.0520872101,
0.0175602902,
-0.0409615673,
0.007117243,
0.0334578007,
-0.0501514003,
0.0023767189,
0.0917240605,
0.0624004751,
-0.0075635547,
-0.0075833732,
-0.0211324971,
0.0197910555,
0.0225413125,
-0.0217001811,
-0.0627029091,
-0.0207414851,
0.0654956177,
0.0075184912,
-0.0527565815,
-0.0050916835,
-0.0294693299,
-0.081083484,
0.0108161895,
0.0179464743,
-0.0094619039,
0.0073219729,
-0.0681380853,
-0.029240137,
0.0511189103,
-0.0156924725,
-0.0148184244,
0.0178371072,
-0.0204946119,
-0.0034455508,
-0.0259863492,
-0.0505681038,
-0.0106552271,
-0.0064517986,
0.0033617443,
0.0628493652,
0.0201476756,
-0.0343398899,
-0.0738171786,
0.039258983,
-0.0183443632,
0.0094549414,
-0.0292417761,
0.0357837453,
0.0003214325,
0.0152532989,
-0.0242187623,
0.0127626434,
0.0100178784,
-0.0674653649,
-0.0112946387,
0.0512298308,
-0.0038723873,
-0.0211137626,
-0.0113665462,
-0.0391677767,
-0.0063654776,
0.0921578705,
0.0275579877,
-0.0204879194,
-0.01879411,
-0.0457635373,
0.0310760383,
-0.0196148623,
-0.0185741521,
0.0021095695,
-0.032203421,
-0.0583553612,
-0.0600961223,
0.018324865,
-0.0190393589,
-0.010829472,
0.0375898145,
0.0551256984,
-0.0153692933,
-0.0239336137,
-0.0460962616,
0.0180567857,
-0.0911363512,
-0.0044865529,
-0.030104585,
0.0177436415,
-0.0165479351,
-0.0236167908,
-0.0223024115,
0.0417178385,
-0.0451864637,
-0.0802923217,
0.0081856931,
0.0156374853,
0.0297645256,
0.0058536544,
0.0103972265,
-0.0556521155,
0.0523568504,
0.0564942919,
-0.0142083494,
0.0341715217,
0.0368453078,
-0.0299105868,
-0.0050262045,
0.0363167711,
-0.0562174246,
0.0041337311,
0.0557204336,
0.0062124319,
-0.0068282387,
0.0207624584,
0.0108457441,
0.0636083931,
0.0314940214,
-0.0238205977,
0.0315034799,
-0.0106510613,
-0.0341599882,
-0.0393485911,
-0.0348506831,
-0.0142728928,
0.0251409654,
0.0109028025,
-0.0060139648,
-0.0012228664,
-0.0148389265,
-0.0160952602,
0.0388714634,
0.0266590696,
0.0014667585,
-0.0096101407,
0.0158059634,
0.0305331293,
-0.0057187672,
-0.0221427921,
0.0388046317,
-0.0380338989,
-0.003609919,
-0.0318072662,
0.0144071523,
0.0154805519,
0.0020564434,
-0.0496352874,
0.0306129288,
-0.0437408015,
-0.0599292777,
0.0091936439,
0.0092629269,
0.0275605526,
-0.0121191591,
0.0255450979,
-0.0566951782,
-0.0239275098,
-0.0499506891,
0.0032982673,
0.0434090793,
-0.0512790419,
0.0058635427,
0.0022803373,
-0.0599558689,
0.0048490614,
0.0639264435,
0.0105699468,
0.0287709683,
-0.0300866775,
-0.0525207333,
-0.0199635886,
-0.0316633992,
0.0484651029,
0.0317414254,
-0.028676277,
-0.0094375936,
-0.0707752332,
-0.0834739134,
-0.0018863654,
-0.0128660928,
0.0159067065,
0.0082311407,
-0.03854331,
0.0695972815,
0.0230372548,
-0.0249935854,
-0.0322808214,
0.038106028,
-0.0021997886,
-0.0113746226,
0.0059335516,
-6.371341747e-33,
-0.0076186443,
-0.07309708,
-0.0339732841,
-0.0439989418,
0.0311811343,
0.0703473762,
-0.0396967977,
-0.0162742138,
0.0223682262,
-0.0077011306,
-0.0053722165,
-0.0172025356,
0.0105661573,
0.0064130682,
-0.0086922282,
0.0266530253,
0.0512414239,
0.0203707367,
-0.0455316566,
-0.0092564793,
0.072609067,
-0.0288894456,
-0.0136595648,
-0.0406129099,
0.0380223952,
-0.0175564941,
-0.0236511622,
-0.0180040095,
-0.0271662492,
0.0576877855,
-0.0272369366,
0.0285503808,
0.0180827957,
-0.0063734497,
-0.0405546427,
0.048107136,
-0.0474135764,
-0.037064407,
0.0412905887,
-0.0125428904,
-0.0076276269,
-0.0947808921,
0.0334565379,
-0.0196416229,
-0.037537653,
0.0192655921,
-0.0016404192,
-0.0110667227,
-0.0482599065,
-0.0168024395,
-0.0379913934,
0.0161526408,
0.0081576258,
0.0234285258,
0.0170033928,
0.0182171967,
0.0266823471,
0.0383272022,
-0.0971679389,
0.0396458395,
-0.0225697905,
-0.0251248907,
0.0864228457,
0.0135202361,
0.0162641853,
0.0616027117,
-0.0270365123,
-0.0091828713,
0.017022796,
-0.0137108862,
0.0325334892,
0.018488707,
0.0623859726,
0.0185861904,
0.0828814059,
-0.0554409772,
-0.0267100036,
0.0123574771,
-0.084175311,
0.0010155272,
0.0831101835,
0.0282518473,
-0.0158070046,
-0.0230192542,
-0.0688164979,
-0.0270101279,
-0.0327961594,
-0.0095140114,
0.0557603911,
-0.0049116532,
-0.0544560328,
-0.0260256212,
0.0357990786,
-0.0196365509,
-0.0262034293,
0.0063007465,
0.0248543434,
0.0234029256,
-0.0154723637,
0.0462570526,
0.0052437359,
0.0026226596,
0.0498699918,
-0.0389976092,
0.0231192056,
0.0096772183,
0.0396827348,
0.0028084032,
-0.0617083162,
-0.0003842154,
-0.0137375658,
-0.0063348128,
0.0095593296,
-0.0295752492,
0.0664286688,
-0.0092812441,
0.0160792693,
-0.0655119419,
0.0261392724,
-0.0276521612,
-0.0290860329,
0.0025754487,
-0.0348209403,
0.021346245,
0.0003317961,
0.0071956133,
-0.0281479098,
0.041461885,
0.0553521067,
-0.0071630049,
-0.000156607,
0.0012828585,
2.869e-7,
0.0475318953,
0.030864438,
0.0182977729,
0.0156011563,
0.0341327414,
0.0431183539,
0.0007433795,
-0.0138281779,
0.0133607825,
0.0128168529,
-0.0542047955,
0.0151583338,
0.0610849895,
0.0263118036,
-0.054758165,
0.0260058995,
-0.0245246384,
0.0024435355,
-0.0593261458,
0.0183856767,
0.0696201995,
0.0612092391,
0.013491299,
-0.0327033103,
-0.0172129739,
-0.0895274207,
0.0522911623,
-0.0482047684,
0.0205012895,
-0.011552969,
0.0155937551,
0.026827218,
0.0492489859,
0.0358344391,
-0.0437907651,
-0.0247166045,
0.0328107476,
0.0379181169,
0.0138347726,
-0.008822185,
-0.035461694,
-0.0139873736,
-0.0012748312,
-0.0902527049,
0.0809865817,
0.0308825206,
-0.0295476522,
-0.0578694902,
-0.0261125825,
-0.0245634131,
0.0393371917,
-0.0244633704,
-0.0426674969,
0.0215451848,
-0.0054369285,
0.0421752855,
-0.0194789637,
-0.0651808679,
-0.0234195236,
-0.0604086071,
-0.0416165441,
-0.0665804222,
-0.0696641728,
0.00894453,
0.0529883653,
-0.0717116594,
0.0152569544,
3.13381743e-34,
-0.0019759638,
-0.0489455871,
0.0161496904,
0.0506488942,
0.0694522262,
0.0091577377,
0.000103374,
0.0408413038,
-0.0065705902,
-0.073042959,
0.0162415132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09830v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09830v2 | AutoPlanBench: Automatically generating benchmarks for LLM planners from PDDL | 2023-11-16T11:55:27 | 2024-02-09T09:48:41 | Katharina Stein, Daniel Fišer, Jörg Hoffmann, Alexander Koller | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | LLMs are being increasingly used for planning-style tasks, but their
capabilities for planning and reasoning are poorly understood. We present
AutoPlanBench, a novel method for automatically converting planning benchmarks
written in PDDL into textual descriptions and offer a benchmark dataset created
with our method. We show that while the best LLM planners do well on some
planning tasks, others remain out of reach of current methods. | [
-0.0406039357,
0.0480310656,
-0.0084685218,
0.0266335923,
-0.0455242582,
-0.0167186055,
-0.0339135639,
-0.01379692,
-0.0456495881,
-0.0119636152,
0.0157732908,
0.0324961022,
-0.0144520057,
0.0083722565,
-0.007758447,
-0.0315292664,
0.0135863367,
-0.0044171764,
-0.05612728,
0.0159234256,
-0.0249435548,
-0.0195329916,
-0.0345051363,
-0.0089785522,
-0.0084742587,
0.0112435007,
-0.057610631,
0.070446223,
0.0078010391,
-0.0703065097,
-0.0418283604,
0.0131684439,
0.015211165,
-0.0448311828,
0.0000018617,
-0.0650021806,
-0.049044162,
-0.0206653085,
-0.0081940051,
0.0333824567,
0.0086499695,
-0.0000187554,
-0.0058016833,
0.0057448931,
-0.0217309445,
0.0482015461,
-0.0317167901,
0.0254933275,
0.0193870533,
0.0807274505,
0.0007312539,
-0.0031500901,
0.012470074,
0.0046809488,
-0.021528095,
-0.0365317203,
-0.0094582103,
0.020140145,
0.0619493686,
-0.0106169488,
0.0249272119,
-0.0092152292,
0.001986878,
0.0014037072,
-0.0019103908,
-0.0350316092,
-0.0106255552,
0.0120334001,
-0.0057425201,
0.0513961054,
0.0447651446,
-0.009525476,
0.0672852993,
-0.0276336148,
-0.016534552,
-0.0073327017,
-0.0348134302,
-0.0115205701,
-0.0084278258,
0.0019414115,
-0.0258190855,
0.0175952744,
0.034018252,
-0.043268919,
-0.0095823267,
0.090718843,
-0.0085641779,
-0.0303181838,
0.0386064611,
0.0023657018,
0.0749815628,
-0.0605667718,
0.0185163058,
0.0510659255,
-0.0327713192,
0.0013892264,
0.0062367958,
0.0034418853,
0.0306240637,
0.0148121649,
0.0840862989,
0.0211135577,
-0.0076316758,
0.0107228085,
-0.0321741812,
0.0795833245,
-0.0008787871,
0.0209003165,
-0.0447892398,
0.0539403558,
-0.030611217,
0.0616288744,
-0.0433064103,
0.0221045259,
-0.0545291416,
0.0131895645,
-0.0333688743,
0.0339119211,
-0.0136789279,
0.065508768,
0.0322990008,
0.0049754381,
0.0066532968,
-0.0139148356,
-0.0791299716,
-0.078470394,
-0.0683976263,
-0.0298041515,
-0.0352441333,
-0.0217123274,
0.0096319756,
0.0089228712,
0.0077805603,
0.0048180949,
-0.0102739623,
0.1028531715,
-0.0089104557,
0.0003911814,
-0.0614502952,
-0.0679851696,
0.0089374743,
-0.0274834633,
0.0038320811,
-0.0755363777,
0.0236514043,
-0.0449027643,
-0.0415087901,
-0.0272020511,
0.0138776153,
0.0049339347,
0.0339205973,
0.0404182337,
-0.0281264335,
0.0385655202,
-0.0269602779,
0.0255414769,
-0.0245250966,
0.0513112806,
0.0098424535,
0.0563876443,
0.0080918036,
0.0430076309,
0.0199701041,
0.0751375854,
0.0063399617,
-0.0150871966,
-0.0206411462,
0.0496967882,
-0.0163020454,
0.0448524207,
-0.0194161851,
-0.0046949829,
-0.0042982651,
0.028986793,
-0.0002388713,
0.0313466974,
0.0702959225,
-0.0224469304,
0.0002697709,
0.0170536842,
0.0042168419,
-0.044221133,
-0.0297560524,
0.0039794417,
-0.0013100812,
0.0378166847,
-0.0511109754,
0.0094801346,
0.0107899802,
-0.0631780773,
-0.0318093672,
0.0018856506,
-0.0442022309,
-0.0270059016,
0.0245635714,
0.0273810569,
-0.0626491085,
0.0579890572,
-0.0122956075,
-0.0194668509,
-0.0475058258,
-0.0099850809,
-0.0212573782,
0.0290353205,
0.0371189937,
-0.0942960605,
-0.0475715064,
0.0120021934,
0.0309110563,
0.0344540365,
0.065146707,
-0.0055402615,
-0.0016506995,
-0.0068467958,
-0.0296722539,
-0.0356607474,
0.0068574455,
0.0194729492,
0.0537170097,
-0.0156776253,
-0.0001881949,
-0.0678491443,
-0.0075897803,
0.0387305208,
-0.0529400781,
-0.0599871352,
0.029961979,
0.0003166338,
0.0285423994,
0.0484720469,
-0.0286473911,
0.0162609518,
0.0546229333,
-0.0140227852,
-0.0068033766,
-0.0057728924,
0.0026653386,
0.0107088685,
0.0324914455,
-0.0401418395,
-0.0377369188,
-0.0045390134,
-0.0443972386,
-0.0233082995,
-0.0280601736,
-0.0015646025,
0.0157971494,
0.0181182139,
0.050774876,
0.0065863561,
-0.0604430474,
-0.0262187067,
0.0575657599,
-0.0102865659,
-0.0261786822,
0.0444394872,
0.0472022742,
0.0369517654,
-0.037774872,
0.0188012142,
-0.0046694027,
-0.0128912963,
-0.020201046,
-0.016226152,
0.0342886709,
-0.021341987,
-0.0110260928,
-0.0761240646,
0.0191848204,
-0.0004554098,
0.0385857522,
0.0137721812,
-0.0373477414,
-0.0196668953,
-0.0010129838,
-0.0318046473,
0.0265598595,
-0.0219600573,
-0.0260868482,
0.0277419593,
0.0084695211,
-0.0501565598,
-0.047388982,
0.0245554708,
-0.0203660261,
-0.0272388794,
0.0328991078,
-0.0412464738,
-0.0056767091,
0.0591291636,
-0.0111160362,
-0.0069326335,
-0.0201459005,
0.0077222879,
0.0049888324,
0.0023851527,
-0.0274216384,
0.0060347905,
-0.0385477804,
-0.0132307708,
0.0610857047,
-0.0452564582,
-0.0772996619,
0.0254639015,
0.0100119868,
0.0333860926,
-0.0124905184,
-0.0515552685,
0.0220892113,
-0.0024631955,
-0.0112323407,
0.0366495587,
0.0049432209,
-0.0096046589,
0.0277602989,
-0.0339565054,
-0.028130427,
-0.0150292199,
-0.017041631,
0.1008442864,
0.0033964301,
-0.0691607222,
0.0044785603,
-0.0359026715,
0.0279496703,
0.0304235965,
-0.0294263251,
-0.0854932889,
0.051126007,
0.0122541618,
0.0068160454,
-0.0595593601,
0.0090248901,
-0.0009953114,
-0.0072074695,
-0.0132297724,
0.0016698098,
0.0904701352,
-0.0828645155,
-0.0064048558,
-0.0144846067,
-0.0664963052,
-0.0371694975,
0.0235131793,
-0.0350329354,
0.0185488239,
-0.0041024275,
-0.0560685694,
-0.0477674603,
-0.0407017358,
-0.0224728025,
0.0091945697,
-0.0043706717,
-0.0193308368,
-0.0387478769,
-0.0289068855,
-0.0131939268,
0.0258734468,
0.0194623489,
-0.0201681163,
-0.0095003117,
0.0331848487,
0.0075657554,
-0.0077178702,
-0.0446719825,
0.0102767283,
-0.0014366773,
-0.023295043,
0.0051933611,
0.0508894213,
0.0252107922,
0.0044471757,
-0.0102357958,
0.0789847896,
0.0260718651,
-0.0201912206,
0.0119372709,
-0.0464753881,
0.0252018366,
0.0474036597,
0.0562509038,
-0.0782008842,
-0.0237988215,
0.0113519961,
0.0659338161,
-0.0343992524,
-0.0579495765,
-0.0374732465,
-0.0801090151,
0.0438945517,
0.0129699251,
-0.0064721541,
0.0633250922,
-0.0273972321,
-0.0351294652,
-0.0218727812,
-0.0436444581,
-0.0122899488,
-0.0088608526,
-0.0376745388,
-0.0070567364,
-0.1065627709,
0.0078023844,
0.0020569679,
0.014128888,
0.0282964595,
0.046956785,
0.0344493464,
0.0009520141,
-0.0259024333,
0.0738160387,
0.0717937946,
0.0396082029,
-0.0233925469,
0.0082470076,
0.0224779435,
0.0339677148,
0.0161721893,
-0.0023006452,
-0.0709933192,
-0.0287606958,
0.0804988369,
0.0740372911,
-0.0100997547,
0.0237697046,
-0.0306468438,
0.0168270413,
0.0013087592,
0.0301230941,
-0.0076637813,
0.0220763572,
-0.0496246889,
-0.0483748876,
-0.0305332597,
-0.0534340441,
-0.0136946468,
0.0034750816,
-0.0481941104,
0.0713126361,
-0.0398180112,
0.0015689014,
0.0381139331,
0.0455867648,
0.0175527483,
-0.0486044213,
-0.046698574,
0.014983858,
-0.0490286648,
-0.001571122,
0.0175102968,
0.0466166325,
-0.0456319749,
0.0081187235,
0.0176682305,
-0.0024355669,
0.0176814608,
0.0311308615,
-0.0707480758,
-0.0521535017,
-0.0132714389,
0.0606925301,
0.0288148504,
0.0141867278,
0.0154075893,
0.0011274375,
0.014350174,
0.0451109558,
0.0176327713,
0.0173952468,
-0.0088957753,
0.0438585542,
-0.0032402258,
-0.0053759278,
-0.0277697779,
0.0314068571,
0.0003143299,
0.0128531996,
-0.0217213053,
-0.0182472784,
-0.0108802794,
0.0982840732,
-0.016629206,
0.0188017879,
-0.0428733714,
0.0063965539,
0.0223995596,
-0.0579049364,
-0.0309767388,
-0.0294312146,
0.033239834,
-0.0121563878,
-0.0351227708,
0.0427342094,
0.0388585255,
-0.0037736786,
0.0007264059,
0.0081574796,
0.0014184641,
0.0384536758,
-0.0173523538,
0.0200537276,
-0.0143828923,
0.017805716,
0.037462119,
-0.0075458684,
0.0712784827,
0.0316772237,
-0.0087067243,
-0.0045191981,
0.0575896315,
-0.0505306646,
-0.030193802,
-0.024253428,
-0.1036569774,
0.0039642905,
-0.0234630574,
0.0327107646,
0.0246856343,
0.0154602425,
-0.0595689081,
0.0129328845,
0.0333753601,
-0.0057532256,
-0.0174741168,
0.0306694563,
0.0171191245,
0.0199227184,
0.0022389414,
-0.0435654633,
0.0305982083,
0.026379576,
0.0348883383,
-0.0198267624,
-0.0029730559,
-0.0705918223,
-0.0500253253,
0.0205247886,
0.0602467395,
0.0244090352,
-0.0751175433,
-0.081349127,
-0.0128965368,
0.0404618569,
0.0571685582,
0.0148991039,
-0.0231065173,
0.036037147,
-0.0057589691,
0.0427092835,
-0.0176176187,
0.0104716979,
-0.0480495729,
-0.0105231358,
-0.0254084449,
0.0078268955,
-5.0549835e-33,
-0.0280276705,
-0.0747606829,
0.0655605718,
-0.0529291593,
-0.0071339719,
-0.0181504562,
-0.0146488808,
0.0143986745,
0.0401114561,
0.0075099878,
-0.0435956232,
-0.0107213622,
0.0163706876,
-0.039699886,
0.0174941476,
0.0048968503,
0.0384661406,
-0.000561629,
-0.0488218479,
-0.044357311,
-0.020127384,
0.0073874136,
-0.0067073852,
-0.0373956412,
-0.0142287174,
0.0401732437,
0.0040631969,
0.0526136905,
0.0048967022,
0.0247422829,
0.0219570491,
-0.0196066648,
-0.0065373299,
0.0521498471,
-0.0450508185,
0.0182157997,
-0.0346786715,
-0.0387631021,
0.0211071074,
-0.0165978577,
-0.0302478354,
-0.0084048016,
0.0209887326,
0.0312880054,
-0.0634280294,
-0.0056916391,
0.0183518752,
-0.0053474074,
-0.0101525318,
-0.0106601436,
-0.0452230498,
0.0437122434,
-0.0267859213,
0.045997303,
0.0541204736,
0.0107430527,
0.0081141824,
-0.0237049982,
-0.0101578282,
0.0044761207,
0.0040478567,
-0.0238195639,
0.086849615,
0.0016601207,
-0.035905797,
0.069996953,
0.0355622247,
0.0393151678,
-0.0258320477,
-0.0224951953,
-0.0130657339,
0.1447284222,
-0.0182939768,
0.0389142223,
-0.014723314,
0.0571386218,
0.00030634,
0.0594701581,
-0.0082181972,
0.011538473,
0.0174317714,
0.0039307652,
-0.0299520046,
-0.0066295667,
-0.019415766,
0.0486268662,
0.0018962731,
0.0026782677,
0.0300297085,
0.002623183,
0.0118628964,
0.0099731386,
-0.0438823253,
-0.0133269057,
0.0330162384,
0.0243010707,
0.0003212842,
0.0005862506,
-0.0097685494,
0.0360835157,
-0.0464221835,
-0.029650677,
-0.0465938188,
0.0316756107,
0.0556227975,
0.0030330452,
-0.0135524366,
-0.0084736543,
-0.0577199198,
0.0215784125,
-0.0516756922,
0.0111527368,
-0.0056511085,
-0.0209162403,
0.0335931368,
-0.0316988789,
-0.0140379062,
0.0115276501,
-0.0107883718,
-0.0875485986,
0.0283975918,
0.026390871,
0.0350869596,
0.0109602939,
0.0183498301,
-0.006180909,
0.0107858814,
0.0012243196,
0.0365309268,
-0.0190172475,
0.0096527934,
0.0380224474,
2.53e-7,
0.0321975574,
0.0672609508,
0.0505611859,
0.0696705803,
0.0088121919,
-0.0003988632,
-0.024957398,
-0.0128668984,
-0.0717950091,
-0.0148441372,
0.0671491623,
0.022468904,
0.0373293795,
0.0560850725,
-0.0366767719,
-0.001968299,
-0.0104362546,
-0.0338870138,
-0.0867260993,
-0.0175319947,
0.0584051497,
-0.0037779405,
-0.003978888,
-0.0114198346,
0.0082442835,
-0.0105833309,
0.0045269481,
-0.0753524378,
0.0223816466,
0.0425379202,
0.0540957563,
-0.0478407033,
-0.0180424768,
0.0192360952,
-0.017793268,
0.0274739396,
-0.0140602821,
0.1011746153,
0.0334341563,
-0.0508564115,
0.0203015599,
-0.0898293853,
-0.0093005719,
0.0213735029,
0.0142669221,
0.03683649,
0.0187016483,
0.0167403687,
-0.0145720644,
-0.0465439186,
0.0011954707,
0.0234582908,
0.0602339134,
0.0284084547,
0.0034321456,
-0.0280410983,
-0.0375825427,
-0.0455043465,
-0.0002917156,
0.0773129463,
-0.034599524,
-0.027699912,
-0.0133087486,
0.0950749293,
-0.0393460579,
-0.0532942116,
-0.0356320068,
2.245296836e-34,
0.0051473174,
0.0386246853,
-0.0159951765,
0.0246094577,
0.0449593104,
0.0203253198,
-0.0182722751,
0.0186943915,
0.0007751441,
-0.04139743,
0.0156540126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09829v1 | FollowEval: A Multi-Dimensional Benchmark for Assessing the Instruction-Following Capability of Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T11:53:31 | 2023-11-16T11:53:31 | Yimin Jing, Renren Jin, Jiahao Hu, Huishi Qiu, Xiaohua Wang, Peng Wang, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL | The effective assessment of the instruction-following ability of large
language models (LLMs) is of paramount importance. A model that cannot adhere
to human instructions might be not able to provide reliable and helpful
responses. In pursuit of this goal, various benchmarks have been constructed to
evaluate the instruction-following capacity of these models. However, these
benchmarks are limited to a single language and are constructed using automated
approaches, which restricts their applicability and the quality of the test
examples they contain. To bridge this gap, we introduce the FollowEval
benchmark in this paper. This benchmark is composed of instances in both
English and Chinese, and all test examples are crafted by human experts.
Furthermore, the FollowEval benchmark is designed to assess LLMs across five
critical dimensions of instruction following: string manipulation, commonsense
reasoning, logical reasoning, spatial reasoning, and response constraints. To
enhance the complexity and present a sufficient challenge, each test example is
designed to evaluate more than one dimension. We have evaluated various LLMs
using the FollowEval benchmark and found that their performance significantly
lags behind that of humans. This highlights the considerable room for
improvement in the instruction-following ability of these models. | [
0.0447498336,
0.0444967821,
-0.0226877574,
0.0485188365,
-0.0502231717,
0.0271868203,
-0.0027933537,
-0.0064945137,
0.0304806288,
-0.050634589,
-0.0120993564,
-0.0313645341,
-0.0053590285,
-0.0224406496,
0.0175168794,
-0.0591513291,
0.0699028894,
-0.0547944829,
-0.0475630797,
0.0091944067,
0.0052138455,
-0.0002684298,
-0.0040476341,
0.0397258624,
0.0205764417,
-0.033304289,
-0.0198759139,
0.017496882,
0.0049003242,
-0.0180132408,
0.0135923298,
0.0346370488,
0.0290330537,
0.0204534195,
0.0000021352,
-0.0299495216,
0.0285822749,
-0.0122655677,
-0.015441359,
0.0504821055,
0.0444073416,
-0.0194263235,
-0.0367108285,
0.010985516,
-0.0119700637,
0.0323761292,
0.0251808763,
0.0111729577,
0.078066051,
0.0841045454,
0.0139701273,
-0.0346774459,
0.0241969209,
-0.0025120093,
-0.0012057247,
-0.0807104334,
0.0203413367,
0.0356333777,
0.0470716469,
0.0149363764,
-0.0386684276,
0.0253343377,
0.0527055934,
-0.010589866,
-0.070763275,
0.0059482311,
-0.0327879116,
0.0107546942,
-0.033931125,
0.0826176256,
0.0135080153,
0.0096253408,
-0.0203938317,
0.0035757436,
0.004023625,
0.0162049085,
-0.0350931175,
0.0188390668,
0.0002467966,
0.0040073888,
0.0294948351,
-0.0210399441,
0.0039274963,
0.0159322396,
-0.0244452711,
0.0793291405,
0.0148407072,
-0.0423727408,
0.0022250044,
-0.0098621016,
-0.0335284621,
-0.0519035943,
0.0066312514,
0.0559701361,
-0.0662839934,
0.0459307507,
-0.0372217819,
0.0222522654,
0.0221098643,
-0.072472252,
0.0792435929,
0.0688864887,
0.0064198459,
0.0415361486,
-0.0143231144,
0.1182021499,
-0.0375261642,
0.0360210538,
-0.057528533,
0.025291793,
-0.0757858455,
-0.0071261795,
-0.0237757266,
0.0221618079,
-0.052298151,
-0.0252450481,
-0.0369593464,
0.0284939781,
-0.0266902093,
0.0309507083,
0.006615601,
-0.0304633323,
-0.0179247595,
-0.0311384108,
-0.0256812535,
0.0154303163,
-0.0476144776,
0.0192039385,
-0.0050371424,
-0.043071229,
0.0195770264,
0.0116845118,
-0.0346963927,
-0.0261210147,
0.0147553366,
0.06217511,
-0.0254448932,
-0.0014244119,
-0.0390463956,
-0.0164381787,
-0.0110079572,
-0.0713553652,
-0.0110679427,
-0.0568061844,
0.024350103,
-0.0039622271,
-0.0151043795,
-0.0038800056,
0.0128262788,
0.0451311767,
-0.0219908301,
0.0292766988,
0.0576430187,
0.0266544055,
-0.0115348166,
0.0288043451,
0.0088003809,
0.0529069938,
0.0134713398,
0.01529021,
0.023272207,
-0.0092359027,
-0.0138187008,
0.0554223843,
-0.006375561,
0.0142424796,
-0.0255393516,
0.0318466946,
-0.0061454801,
0.0357991457,
0.0264193006,
0.0642813891,
-0.0182704274,
-0.0205955673,
0.0271549337,
0.0420621857,
-0.0052475645,
-0.0254237186,
0.0823535323,
0.0221480373,
-0.0028599987,
0.0433292314,
-0.076647155,
0.0056697712,
-0.0220127292,
0.0285290666,
0.0004448382,
0.0151518416,
-0.0250193328,
-0.0290035978,
0.000093367,
0.0159714464,
0.0096966689,
0.0048646387,
0.0285830572,
-0.0158847831,
-0.0498255566,
0.0361636393,
0.0217082724,
-0.0301048495,
0.0111613171,
-0.0469253212,
-0.0034042555,
0.0781408027,
0.0331002027,
0.0024251258,
-0.0544565506,
0.0274424441,
0.0558627471,
0.0472197756,
0.0407674052,
-0.0232756529,
-0.0124207344,
-0.0465655699,
-0.0214284305,
0.0075741247,
-0.0008517487,
0.038371481,
0.032197006,
-0.0088181412,
-0.0002931822,
-0.0073345117,
-0.039952483,
0.0518043861,
-0.0480295122,
-0.0471515581,
-0.058304593,
0.0079228953,
0.0330067202,
0.0066344249,
-0.0096803438,
0.013926981,
0.0342152752,
-0.01868142,
0.0157860983,
-0.0009011452,
-0.0910626575,
-0.0437313616,
0.0344649144,
-0.001217935,
-0.0398975164,
0.0372538567,
-0.046469003,
-0.0352768116,
0.00739964,
-0.0266002808,
0.0143706864,
-0.0170757044,
0.047397241,
-0.0051284749,
-0.0452307984,
-0.0234190729,
0.0569214411,
-0.0451290496,
0.0512540117,
0.0540630557,
0.0312334206,
0.0013540552,
-0.054279048,
-0.0161346029,
-0.0129424743,
-0.0160969738,
0.0137119414,
0.0111617967,
0.0301316604,
-0.0422270298,
-0.0437035747,
-0.0648207143,
0.0169284884,
-0.0353242531,
0.0283490457,
0.0301991329,
-0.0397826694,
-0.0061175772,
-0.0135671617,
-0.0171301905,
-0.0208034646,
0.003839582,
0.0391649082,
0.0000501185,
0.0236275233,
-0.0550684966,
-0.0321904793,
-0.0102866851,
-0.0298668649,
-0.0079196971,
-0.0023248103,
0.0366178453,
-0.0582431816,
0.0041209264,
-0.0052015153,
0.0479690805,
-0.0149011891,
-0.0683491826,
0.0300032701,
0.0021621212,
0.0376830511,
0.0953863114,
-0.0061795386,
0.0157753509,
0.0291229635,
-0.0359593965,
-0.0609642603,
0.0256778803,
-0.0203494634,
-0.0366681628,
-0.0625674948,
-0.0635150596,
-0.0188060384,
0.0745144486,
-0.0020912299,
0.028850643,
-0.0790294856,
-0.0161744449,
-0.0405257456,
-0.0383737832,
-0.0445472747,
-0.0202038456,
-0.0381937176,
0.0060718814,
-0.0537342392,
-0.0403410941,
0.0596038513,
-0.0235624891,
0.000528882,
-0.0486482158,
0.025055794,
-0.0199867114,
0.0721719563,
0.0296353027,
0.0299992971,
-0.0287422333,
-0.0292554405,
-0.036896605,
0.0058817305,
0.0172472429,
-0.0161562506,
0.0259807222,
-0.0814794526,
-0.0007990269,
0.0015360994,
-0.0148825077,
-0.037924327,
-0.032464385,
-0.0048236637,
0.017170256,
0.0357014537,
-0.0410316773,
-0.031229686,
0.0057926914,
0.0356410816,
0.021836523,
-0.0101034157,
0.0017805337,
-0.0436336137,
-0.0269123334,
0.0337295569,
0.0075170565,
-0.0262690354,
-0.0526297875,
0.0492050946,
0.0579903759,
0.0365268327,
-0.0249495748,
-0.0103300624,
0.0389052443,
0.0260822643,
-0.0399769247,
-0.0198095292,
0.0689025372,
0.0863026902,
-0.0855401978,
-0.0233643781,
0.1171845794,
0.0507305898,
0.0073486487,
0.0055609518,
-0.0290142912,
0.0184266996,
0.0252946541,
0.0399995223,
-0.056111902,
-0.0336154141,
0.0068222149,
0.0144421132,
-0.0031870152,
-0.0271051303,
0.0119961789,
-0.1414568871,
0.0403940529,
0.0093371775,
-0.0637417883,
-0.0455820598,
-0.0275664199,
-0.0021066959,
0.0182727054,
0.0259182788,
0.0200377293,
-0.0218979772,
-0.0410329849,
0.0208917037,
-0.0241854545,
-0.0563506298,
0.0821539313,
-0.0483444892,
0.056769114,
0.0680780038,
0.0183035303,
0.0119534303,
-0.0537425354,
0.0020561339,
-0.0051298933,
0.0072384509,
-0.004933449,
0.0255940855,
-0.0017262708,
0.0010923781,
-0.0228609778,
0.0240308456,
-0.0146420421,
0.0091406582,
0.0387091674,
0.0832060277,
0.0003001663,
-0.0062569706,
-0.0220434759,
0.0189464241,
-0.0148125868,
0.0872913525,
0.0208427627,
-0.0371163562,
-0.0369477421,
-0.0319207422,
-0.0640975833,
-0.0678606182,
-0.0226675626,
0.0269472413,
-0.0496535115,
0.0037964953,
-0.0648158118,
-0.042474594,
0.0211938359,
0.0353976265,
0.0236869734,
-0.0031336248,
0.0494473055,
-0.0228057913,
0.0105986772,
0.0087500857,
-0.029430801,
0.0397280566,
-0.10330192,
-0.0041110343,
0.0100018056,
0.0118437223,
-0.0159924217,
-0.0001586725,
-0.0237351581,
-0.0695205331,
0.011450327,
0.0650608242,
0.0162359215,
0.0337834284,
-0.0020522317,
-0.0214405861,
-0.0358490832,
-0.020265568,
-0.0269265398,
0.0188932586,
0.0330870077,
-0.0201260522,
-0.0092101078,
0.0265322644,
-0.0007066618,
0.0441870801,
0.0107567478,
0.0430141911,
-0.0646289811,
-0.019105833,
0.0427775867,
0.0218255203,
-0.0339749753,
-0.0122744739,
-0.0125345374,
-0.0008160815,
0.0187333953,
-0.0389868766,
-0.0264950041,
-0.0277339388,
-0.0093420893,
0.0387123637,
-0.0229334496,
0.008167888,
-0.0233054906,
-0.0114656584,
-0.0031491611,
-0.0337246172,
0.0272807889,
0.0056385584,
0.0596146174,
0.0272410866,
0.0027743527,
-0.0188641157,
-0.0147880176,
-0.0020370355,
0.067043528,
-0.0006490096,
0.116223827,
0.0293013491,
0.0013640466,
0.0018535272,
0.0031833374,
-0.0441939943,
-0.0186329838,
0.0087857042,
0.0277418122,
0.0566576123,
-0.0221305378,
0.0192070454,
-0.0329569168,
-0.0075347861,
-0.0293210912,
0.0253979322,
0.0258963909,
-0.0489330702,
0.0367962271,
0.0492636375,
0.0177519806,
0.0066565485,
0.0418300517,
0.0106042996,
0.0350817963,
0.0198081173,
0.0118463244,
-0.0389271528,
-0.028389154,
0.0383027308,
0.0118669821,
-0.0221173223,
0.0440957323,
-0.0579618998,
-0.049508594,
-0.0320871845,
0.0439406373,
0.0185586307,
-0.0262509063,
0.023967104,
0.0403894484,
0.0029886086,
-0.0277984608,
-0.0451124161,
-0.0098572141,
-0.0445509106,
-0.0066985553,
-0.0419080928,
-6.265990269e-33,
-0.0623426065,
-0.0170927066,
0.0538605303,
-0.0334536768,
0.004786042,
-0.026643116,
-0.043533273,
-0.0077576679,
-0.0268035568,
0.0084050102,
0.0136214914,
0.00531425,
0.0033047039,
0.0058695371,
0.0207572971,
0.0121643441,
0.0131164482,
0.008040728,
-0.0160564873,
0.0027279977,
0.0347132161,
-0.0348681882,
0.0128608225,
-0.0391878448,
0.0282778852,
-0.023148369,
0.0004482563,
0.0491887033,
-0.044734776,
0.0755137056,
0.0023316764,
0.0157011058,
0.0228000358,
-0.0245151985,
-0.0157429595,
0.0324583054,
-0.0460360236,
-0.0421153456,
0.0650358126,
0.0125965495,
-0.0308871288,
-0.0132707749,
0.0037481668,
-0.0090024266,
-0.0374221057,
-0.0027994574,
0.0047487807,
-0.0148808341,
-0.0107871154,
0.0480943657,
-0.0913958251,
0.0230209809,
-0.0152388606,
-0.0562592484,
-0.0051171035,
0.0664335638,
-0.0060051056,
-0.0188462064,
-0.0414595418,
0.0051707355,
0.0473699458,
0.0416144356,
0.0935299993,
0.0054518683,
0.0013967755,
0.0427980572,
0.0019321906,
0.0122471312,
-0.0288740769,
0.0123193599,
0.0275914818,
0.0647270009,
0.0489719473,
0.0132509526,
0.0160806272,
0.0155873951,
-0.0535426661,
0.0163376238,
0.030453926,
0.0763679519,
0.0290171523,
0.0032008111,
-0.094588466,
-0.0213466045,
-0.0318615399,
0.0488592796,
-0.0276504941,
-0.031737294,
0.0753436461,
0.0049822726,
-0.0088264281,
-0.0090461848,
0.0420469344,
-0.0275371876,
-0.008496034,
0.0038715263,
-0.0167726036,
0.0207914542,
-0.0144753801,
0.0602352098,
-0.0786034018,
-0.0595998392,
-0.0000977363,
-0.0210069697,
0.0238883849,
0.012862077,
0.0161687396,
0.0101649147,
-0.0461433716,
-0.0156039977,
-0.0299620666,
0.0108609255,
-0.0174943395,
-0.003450118,
0.0616038553,
0.0149700306,
-0.0162518788,
0.0616216697,
-0.0133806467,
-0.0579999797,
-0.0180429276,
-0.0222373828,
0.0006976692,
0.0332497023,
-0.0178117156,
0.0259105861,
-0.0648388192,
0.0101984944,
-0.0170094203,
-0.0236373991,
-0.0064926348,
0.0425955206,
2.724e-7,
0.0201102346,
0.0371663943,
0.0299959835,
0.0482544526,
-0.0156890191,
0.0107591972,
-0.0627317652,
-0.0168329887,
0.0115142157,
0.0041656387,
0.0118415253,
0.0472367741,
0.0355506949,
-0.0048275669,
-0.058373902,
0.0213784277,
-0.0460696071,
0.0119101536,
-0.0501461811,
0.0296599064,
0.0487084053,
0.0503389575,
-0.0321294442,
0.0230106711,
0.0112827169,
-0.0345369801,
0.0297591928,
-0.0121041462,
-0.0092677204,
0.0288134106,
-0.0020966735,
0.0184363481,
-0.0065842648,
0.0382708348,
-0.0048637679,
0.0086442903,
-0.0275244433,
0.1147978827,
0.0009001523,
0.007718333,
-0.0109557677,
-0.0490969643,
-0.0066519408,
-0.0435954593,
0.0408125147,
-0.059348803,
-0.0207652915,
0.0098821186,
-0.0159125347,
-0.009101294,
-0.0230861884,
0.0018888455,
-0.0102022374,
0.0015986795,
0.0335622728,
-0.04287697,
0.0022989013,
-0.0489045568,
0.0002655645,
0.0227154195,
-0.0110938139,
-0.0639039725,
-0.0523617044,
0.0210105553,
0.0002968648,
-0.0464929938,
-0.0374854319,
2.607189991e-34,
0.0120632332,
-0.0227790829,
0.0477144644,
0.0237569697,
0.0389287062,
0.0104784267,
-0.0633641258,
0.041536741,
0.0370189361,
-0.0744791627,
-0.0092010219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09828v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09828v3 | AfriMTE and AfriCOMET: Enhancing COMET to Embrace Under-resourced African Languages | 2023-11-16T11:52:52 | 2024-04-23T18:22:05 | Jiayi Wang, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, Sweta Agrawal, Marek Masiak, Ricardo Rei, Eleftheria Briakou, Marine Carpuat, Xuanli He, Sofia Bourhim, Andiswa Bukula, Muhidin Mohamed, Temitayo Olatoye, Tosin Adewumi, Hamam Mokayed, Christine Mwase, Wangui Kimotho, Foutse Yuehgoh, Anuoluwapo Aremu, Jessica Ojo, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Salomey Osei, Abdul-Hakeem Omotayo, Chiamaka Chukwuneke, Perez Ogayo, Oumaima Hourrane, Salma El Anigri, Lolwethu Ndolela, Thabiso Mangwana, Shafie Abdi Mohamed, Ayinde Hassan, Oluwabusayo Olufunke Awoyomi, Lama Alkhaled, Sana Al-Azzawi, Naome A. Etori, Millicent Ochieng, Clemencia Siro, Samuel Njoroge, Eric Muchiri, Wangari Kimotho, Lyse Naomi Wamba Momo, Daud Abolade, Simbiat Ajao, Iyanuoluwa Shode, Ricky Macharm, Ruqayya Nasir Iro, Saheed S. Abdullahi, Stephen E. Moore, Bernard Opoku, Zainab Akinjobi, Abeeb Afolabi, Nnaemeka Obiefuna, Onyekachi Raphael Ogbu, Sam Brian, Verrah Akinyi Otiende, Chinedu Emmanuel Mbonu, Sakayo Toadoum Sari, Yao Lu, Pontus Stenetorp | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the recent progress on scaling multilingual machine translation (MT)
to several under-resourced African languages, accurately measuring this
progress remains challenging, since evaluation is often performed on n-gram
matching metrics such as BLEU, which typically show a weaker correlation with
human judgments. Learned metrics such as COMET have higher correlation;
however, the lack of evaluation data with human ratings for under-resourced
languages, complexity of annotation guidelines like Multidimensional Quality
Metrics (MQM), and limited language coverage of multilingual encoders have
hampered their applicability to African languages. In this paper, we address
these challenges by creating high-quality human evaluation data with simplified
MQM guidelines for error detection and direct assessment (DA) scoring for 13
typologically diverse African languages. Furthermore, we develop AfriCOMET:
COMET evaluation metrics for African languages by leveraging DA data from
well-resourced languages and an African-centric multilingual encoder
(AfroXLM-R) to create the state-of-the-art MT evaluation metrics for African
languages with respect to Spearman-rank correlation with human judgments
(0.441). | [
0.0461223908,
0.0488136075,
-0.0109451842,
0.0619367212,
0.0096484404,
0.0545848124,
-0.0019880235,
-0.0087108836,
-0.0286392812,
-0.0003361818,
-0.0591956563,
-0.1009318307,
0.1026392952,
-0.0252299383,
0.0354300104,
-0.0281590745,
0.0013703012,
0.0078895641,
0.0005053629,
0.0068740528,
-0.0002060616,
0.0526374802,
-0.0080362409,
0.051859159,
-0.0072355848,
0.0157217178,
0.0257322527,
0.0448197871,
0.0390027687,
-0.014473456,
-0.0399045236,
0.0263613015,
-0.0608926937,
0.0720620826,
0.0000021901,
-0.0632644445,
-0.0258186478,
0.0038371845,
-0.0264166482,
0.0358368717,
0.0429597236,
-0.0323669761,
-0.0265870355,
0.0170893893,
-0.0132602649,
0.0393800437,
0.092382066,
-0.0434810147,
0.0662126243,
0.0618563816,
0.0053531891,
-0.0089241527,
0.025689343,
-0.0410244651,
-0.0497107282,
-0.041087389,
-0.0124328071,
0.0096108019,
-0.0407299548,
-0.0001018435,
-0.0365324542,
0.0217498448,
0.0013427739,
-0.0060459124,
-0.0157292988,
-0.0291854721,
-0.0320943743,
-0.0829043835,
-0.0023908149,
0.0447833613,
-0.0150138987,
0.0212906711,
-0.0589538477,
0.0166675765,
-0.0147672836,
-0.0325022042,
-0.0283122044,
0.0226587672,
0.0060926438,
0.0125559457,
-0.0025809444,
0.0549887307,
0.0485983789,
-0.014347001,
-0.0110048838,
-0.0007812803,
0.0222526547,
-0.015421248,
0.0173781831,
0.064415358,
-0.0192955043,
0.0091189351,
0.0149963638,
-0.057130821,
-0.0204062201,
-0.0368879288,
0.0118764266,
-0.0506792106,
0.0325820446,
-0.0312556997,
0.0853422731,
0.0470826477,
-0.0293201841,
0.0156865064,
-0.0399771482,
0.0665416345,
-0.0104374904,
0.0176477171,
-0.0416594222,
-0.0290863439,
-0.012526664,
0.0125131998,
0.0129669467,
-0.0189782046,
-0.0231859107,
0.0433483534,
-0.0704467371,
-0.02364159,
-0.005906499,
0.0072909496,
0.00495718,
-0.0616832636,
-0.0281236656,
-0.0323132463,
0.0003431436,
0.0240594707,
-0.0130686238,
0.0015520712,
-0.0124128237,
-0.092970781,
0.0151273012,
-0.0016077053,
-0.0256986432,
0.007289594,
0.0167490914,
0.0877811983,
-0.0119272862,
-0.0445465036,
0.0015450305,
-0.0033787293,
-0.0347172357,
-0.0308691431,
-0.0612798221,
-0.0329454057,
0.0576307699,
0.012444173,
0.0523019023,
-0.0147736976,
-0.0148029039,
-0.0175171662,
0.0503838398,
0.0387756266,
0.0113423783,
-0.0231792517,
0.0335195176,
0.0122728078,
0.0049560489,
0.0501861311,
0.0359742902,
0.0085661085,
0.0130244577,
0.0217030216,
-0.0410985053,
0.046561297,
-0.0071838461,
0.0118344566,
0.0000712237,
-0.0079721566,
0.0298622958,
0.0403255075,
0.0448245779,
0.0692538545,
-0.0249519534,
-0.0063093137,
0.0305792261,
-0.0048929164,
0.012523544,
0.0354171246,
0.033546634,
-0.0084821684,
-0.0134100188,
-0.0042759902,
0.0318396538,
0.0409173034,
-0.0261586513,
-0.0506216548,
0.1107066795,
0.1015472934,
0.0218946151,
-0.0577797554,
0.0027979661,
-0.005609314,
-0.0010982513,
-0.0272536278,
-0.0031321154,
-0.0257389452,
-0.0436090156,
-0.0092788748,
-0.0031484531,
-0.07044743,
0.0206215084,
-0.0390082821,
-0.0016052481,
0.0268448852,
0.0432627015,
0.0747668743,
-0.0069824243,
-0.0070086587,
-0.043630667,
0.0477769598,
0.0360389948,
-0.0119914925,
0.0586329177,
-0.0550965816,
-0.0035826429,
-0.0004812419,
-0.0186644159,
0.0472430959,
-0.01101634,
0.0705571622,
0.0246878397,
-0.0468698442,
-0.0724107102,
0.0376606584,
0.0124885319,
0.0024582481,
0.0159254707,
0.003922753,
0.0831888318,
0.0162676033,
0.0039645727,
0.023572877,
-0.0389395878,
-0.0485445186,
0.004692242,
0.0103012435,
-0.0311833825,
-0.0025863098,
0.0128746973,
-0.040057946,
-0.0078801839,
0.0410840027,
0.0143406708,
-0.0393189304,
0.0075605484,
-0.0150541924,
0.0053929752,
-0.0274827052,
0.035490457,
-0.0032776308,
0.0069786063,
-0.0073386184,
0.0068303384,
0.022549862,
-0.0047955648,
-0.0067401812,
-0.0297996569,
0.0567784347,
0.0209836792,
-0.0381636992,
0.0229811408,
-0.0029994764,
0.0138461664,
0.0348061286,
0.0208209865,
-0.0345655307,
-0.0244819727,
-0.0722556785,
0.0215899739,
-0.0233754758,
0.0171013027,
-0.01808092,
0.058074683,
0.0082971873,
0.0073410086,
0.0209088176,
-0.0369392708,
-0.0015539506,
-0.008018489,
-0.0204581283,
-0.0241026767,
-0.0233620722,
-0.0296098217,
0.0064168563,
0.0639935061,
0.0393623412,
0.0278568417,
-0.0066360049,
-0.0548449121,
-0.0110641029,
-0.0500118099,
-0.0621769838,
0.0258500855,
-0.0510326773,
0.0268767551,
0.0050563104,
-0.0239139758,
-0.0122718131,
-0.0236246344,
0.0076535493,
0.034909647,
0.0265720729,
-0.0185693167,
-0.0376070626,
-0.0116304243,
-0.0316194259,
0.0087174466,
-0.0035287386,
0.0308886599,
0.0396847166,
0.0126936371,
-0.0003863815,
-0.0608920343,
-0.0081629427,
-0.0141455214,
-0.0349112488,
-0.0161259305,
-0.0226732921,
0.0239719003,
0.0443635769,
-0.0422535129,
-0.042700585,
0.0872812942,
-0.043133501,
-0.0362187885,
-0.018745767,
0.057253439,
-0.0319390632,
0.012151517,
-0.0360785238,
0.0139159877,
-0.0681413189,
-0.0253054015,
0.0006256773,
0.058527004,
0.0733338967,
-0.0209960341,
0.0058134054,
-0.0804646909,
0.0081685791,
0.005625241,
-0.0308911409,
0.0095693022,
0.0210629404,
-0.018154202,
-0.0162925441,
0.0091940528,
-0.0011936418,
-0.0369996689,
0.0199364442,
0.0136160189,
0.0222945753,
0.0108873351,
-0.0166167486,
0.0254785474,
0.008140862,
-0.0415802635,
0.012770257,
0.0308637656,
-0.0741662011,
0.0182867777,
0.0064954604,
-0.0508431457,
0.0009115274,
-0.0058423569,
-0.0169658605,
0.0563321635,
0.0084520923,
-0.0221884698,
0.0326709412,
0.0500782654,
-0.0143484455,
0.0131104337,
0.0761712044,
0.0218591932,
-0.0117027825,
0.0154251829,
-0.0455125272,
0.0520207658,
-0.0246170759,
-0.012051885,
-0.0762597844,
-0.0297675282,
-0.0116112502,
0.0268992856,
0.0268160738,
0.0061252732,
0.0010021434,
-0.0826416463,
0.0190411955,
0.0728948414,
-0.0130047873,
-0.0380689017,
-0.0205707159,
-0.0344337486,
-0.0426457673,
0.0147816334,
0.0225789715,
0.0577953905,
-0.0072019263,
0.0443598256,
-0.0074193347,
-0.135242641,
0.0074935472,
-0.0449041389,
0.0452371873,
0.059253417,
0.0133056231,
-0.0011778835,
-0.0309166368,
-0.0194072481,
-0.015234462,
-0.0070133456,
-0.0157468896,
0.0011086154,
0.0090936953,
-0.018567469,
0.0061263181,
-0.0085249692,
-0.0008495977,
0.0229361579,
-0.039400164,
0.0312820524,
-0.0291429441,
0.0147844171,
-0.003617882,
-0.0535888784,
-0.0180736501,
0.0190466922,
0.0364796221,
-0.0362659059,
-0.0069170436,
-0.0095699485,
0.0246706251,
-0.0552036576,
-0.0189304743,
0.0317282081,
-0.0089416709,
-0.0348316245,
-0.0820977688,
-0.0638726205,
0.0016556341,
-0.0173659343,
0.0047951075,
-0.0335178599,
-0.0163221098,
0.0089275893,
-0.0067142393,
0.0171254352,
-0.0121719372,
0.0196319949,
-0.0457846969,
0.0236549284,
-0.007503116,
0.0226206053,
0.0031383184,
0.0413215235,
-0.0517263226,
-0.0308018308,
0.0073018358,
0.0305378977,
0.0163587015,
0.0075287716,
0.0065937778,
-0.0384499282,
-0.0568216667,
-0.0356478132,
0.0148795834,
0.002008917,
-0.0031881188,
-0.0178364236,
-0.0328176878,
0.0327008292,
-0.0024707245,
0.0096412823,
-0.0065220287,
0.0508549325,
0.0035284474,
-0.0793037191,
-0.0017805031,
-0.0285496693,
0.0329048298,
-0.09669891,
-0.0440508313,
-0.0341159403,
-0.0235247668,
0.0276698023,
0.0229729842,
-0.0458432287,
-0.032495372,
0.0588686764,
0.0127150482,
-0.0188327227,
0.0048921132,
-0.0135343038,
-0.0303320754,
-0.0003211161,
0.0280802343,
0.021116022,
0.0169418454,
-0.0030964098,
0.0439636186,
-0.0265498962,
0.0086516337,
0.0019748714,
0.0379691869,
-0.028049577,
0.0184919592,
-0.0041412073,
0.0584965795,
0.0488326065,
0.0478824377,
0.0344579332,
0.0415634513,
-0.0868405849,
0.0123552782,
0.0763382018,
0.021361636,
0.1238895655,
0.0131600928,
0.0045778523,
-0.0193664469,
0.0370507762,
-0.0386505239,
-0.0299300533,
-0.0001056229,
-0.0160436593,
0.0164235514,
0.0685705319,
0.0396844409,
-0.0751710832,
-0.0257804953,
-0.0495273285,
0.0062453113,
-0.0067105824,
-0.0302864108,
-0.0343048647,
-0.0620750301,
-0.0111151356,
0.0157027077,
-0.0551579818,
-0.0410700031,
0.0102462582,
0.0416298769,
0.0030649793,
0.0270046536,
0.010031403,
0.0556695797,
-0.0386284105,
0.0177048948,
-0.0216309186,
-0.078982763,
-0.0528678335,
0.0072268033,
0.0011154998,
-6.252403759e-33,
-0.0252538212,
0.0055035315,
-0.0318155922,
-0.0647157356,
-0.029094357,
-0.0166054945,
-0.0015245099,
0.0093136597,
-0.006667397,
-0.0089082103,
0.0113567179,
-0.0250295736,
0.009463802,
-0.0015538746,
0.0702479333,
0.0365064293,
0.0392358527,
0.021314403,
-0.0737999305,
0.0061469697,
0.0257021654,
0.0072660577,
0.0771388859,
-0.0309699252,
0.0894580036,
-0.0202459246,
-0.0512239747,
-0.008483557,
0.0128899151,
0.040559005,
-0.0065313512,
0.0112676928,
0.0145200118,
0.0056686131,
-0.0123098362,
-0.0402563587,
-0.0387899764,
-0.0040735388,
0.0219560284,
0.0477904901,
-0.0486334153,
-0.0407835245,
0.0371717885,
-0.0103391027,
-0.059982527,
0.0052231355,
-0.0078209508,
-0.0529358201,
-0.0152167948,
-0.0096408958,
-0.0396183878,
0.0516854152,
-0.0330549739,
-0.0170690287,
0.020041639,
0.0499385558,
-0.0627547577,
-0.0322973765,
-0.0686828867,
0.0073016062,
-0.0202201661,
0.0594396777,
0.0577161647,
0.0302346796,
-0.0782875568,
0.0435385853,
0.0113214534,
-0.0355982706,
0.0589216426,
0.0269341283,
0.0580557026,
-0.053985808,
0.0709875077,
0.0770408064,
0.0300345197,
-0.0320299976,
-0.0227318481,
0.0718930289,
-0.0120287063,
0.0244141128,
-0.0124759488,
0.0035084188,
-0.0252773631,
-0.0330304578,
-0.0303429384,
-0.0132551948,
-0.0257585011,
-0.0216611568,
0.0469348803,
-0.0427533202,
-0.0045730183,
0.02670037,
0.0537783429,
0.0147240479,
0.0117187714,
-0.0384700932,
-0.0212850217,
0.0427303948,
0.0147197731,
0.0217822865,
-0.0329969153,
0.0324885286,
0.018137116,
0.031319458,
0.0032244644,
-0.0387702547,
0.0359596722,
0.0154380929,
-0.0424308851,
0.0426462516,
-0.0226472393,
-0.0086439885,
-0.0174101815,
-0.0191817787,
-0.0013395459,
-0.0247910656,
-0.0001822121,
0.0331138335,
-0.0122956019,
0.0144344447,
-0.0199905317,
0.0244139358,
0.0082835769,
0.0022902288,
-0.0716606975,
0.0102027683,
0.0034221979,
-0.0156645942,
0.0004620099,
-0.0232111551,
0.0013101893,
0.0280500948,
2.811e-7,
0.0249366201,
0.0442225896,
0.0473582856,
-0.0644920394,
-0.0147579359,
0.0167864077,
-0.0236677881,
-0.0060756146,
0.0107638892,
0.0580833554,
0.0284255948,
-0.008097549,
0.1158095971,
0.0333206728,
-0.0426630713,
-0.0153116109,
-0.0644404888,
0.0284148827,
-0.0426337197,
-0.044445537,
0.0162462406,
0.0969827697,
-0.0428841189,
-0.0212267619,
-0.0752148256,
-0.0012763729,
0.0750033706,
-0.0102793844,
-0.0238774475,
-0.0241876002,
0.062215101,
0.0468337238,
-0.0141419088,
0.0180839188,
-0.0391167402,
0.0147898532,
0.0589931495,
0.0487287194,
-0.0071471999,
-0.0004285403,
0.0230465885,
0.0329587795,
-0.0399834253,
-0.0260108691,
0.0343090631,
0.0370359421,
-0.0432322435,
-0.0002602935,
-0.0219299216,
0.0181785338,
0.0669733509,
-0.0529710501,
-0.0437401645,
0.0159063563,
0.0478017405,
-0.035115961,
-0.027302796,
-0.0019374267,
-0.0172596015,
0.0203628764,
0.0295223743,
-0.0192120131,
0.0213753972,
0.0021424519,
0.0135154407,
-0.0395980924,
0.0127519201,
2.22538713e-34,
0.04991097,
-0.044950664,
0.0639473647,
-0.0145531902,
-0.0019758118,
-0.003845596,
0.0084657269,
0.0057997513,
-0.0188301746,
0.0001331888,
0.0054478929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09827v2 | Cognitive Overload: Jailbreaking Large Language Models with Overloaded Logical Thinking | 2023-11-16T11:52:22 | 2024-02-29T08:20:07 | Nan Xu, Fei Wang, Ben Zhou, Bang Zheng Li, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated increasing power, they
have also given rise to a wide range of harmful behaviors. As representatives,
jailbreak attacks can provoke harmful or unethical responses from LLMs, even
after safety alignment. In this paper, we investigate a novel category of
jailbreak attacks specifically designed to target the cognitive structure and
processes of LLMs. Specifically, we analyze the safety vulnerability of LLMs in
the face of (1) multilingual cognitive overload, (2) veiled expression, and (3)
effect-to-cause reasoning. Different from previous jailbreak attacks, our
proposed cognitive overload is a black-box attack with no need for knowledge of
model architecture or access to model weights. Experiments conducted on
AdvBench and MasterKey reveal that various LLMs, including both popular
open-source model Llama 2 and the proprietary model ChatGPT, can be compromised
through cognitive overload. Motivated by cognitive psychology work on managing
cognitive load, we further investigate defending cognitive overload attack from
two perspectives. Empirical studies show that our cognitive overload from three
perspectives can jailbreak all studied LLMs successfully, while existing
defense strategies can hardly mitigate the caused malicious uses effectively. | [
0.0384031013,
0.0752404556,
-0.0349752493,
0.0375826135,
-0.0445021242,
-0.0014866688,
0.0139435232,
-0.0138657885,
0.0682306886,
-0.0165045112,
-0.0146351773,
-0.0068456628,
0.02709339,
-0.004848822,
0.0722479895,
0.0122376885,
0.0681003258,
-0.0521724112,
0.0140352556,
-0.0044064252,
0.0031893982,
-0.0168549996,
0.0412881188,
0.0144018782,
0.0224399678,
-0.0145544326,
-0.0253576562,
0.0043949978,
0.0144477831,
-0.0360387601,
-0.0214669071,
0.0286796037,
-0.0179231893,
0.0550260097,
0.000002241,
-0.0258712228,
-0.0144386496,
0.0251594745,
-0.0261507053,
0.0677647293,
0.0103891538,
-0.0164996237,
-0.0299243312,
0.0001640223,
-0.0155432504,
0.018644128,
0.0147797689,
0.0703096986,
0.0539931729,
0.0667469874,
-0.0049492018,
-0.0043308302,
0.0622739159,
-0.0133663695,
0.0180981774,
-0.0592772439,
0.0402565077,
0.0121409539,
0.0101252627,
-0.0063577057,
0.0170973539,
-0.0117592495,
0.0200615991,
-0.0110469079,
-0.0881223455,
-0.0194783676,
-0.0248499326,
-0.0287983343,
0.0106296195,
0.0507000796,
-0.0247849822,
-0.0064920294,
0.0202798042,
0.0291297138,
0.0058156461,
0.025922738,
-0.0078536524,
0.0569004677,
-0.0096793575,
-0.0299410317,
0.0614616387,
-0.0233728588,
0.0678514764,
-0.0003793135,
-0.0199313015,
0.0809285119,
0.0028223265,
-0.0337442942,
0.0170176476,
-0.0547832586,
-0.0440090224,
-0.0746530518,
-0.0265221968,
-0.0034891588,
-0.0101139173,
0.0391137712,
-0.0505196862,
-0.0323972441,
0.035129521,
-0.0905111954,
0.0287378933,
0.0561389774,
-0.009428083,
0.0031374586,
0.0239531696,
0.0086092064,
-0.05215111,
0.0464338213,
-0.0068375901,
0.0280219503,
-0.0061057257,
-0.0296040513,
-0.0218909048,
0.025508387,
0.0238793287,
0.0138318846,
-0.0406742841,
0.0247264281,
-0.058029525,
0.0071084816,
-0.0674010515,
-0.0074965525,
0.0298052859,
0.0159477331,
0.0342137478,
-0.0041389447,
-0.0197330713,
-0.0110341338,
0.0036319313,
-0.0702873915,
-0.02243408,
0.005745288,
-0.1059193984,
-0.0259167366,
-0.0075386176,
0.0924596563,
0.0157264676,
0.0104044601,
-0.0878946707,
-0.0915053263,
-0.0229688939,
-0.0504558124,
-0.0109009342,
-0.089494653,
-0.0379115902,
0.0181931686,
-0.0170220993,
-0.064428784,
0.0052088695,
-0.0102610812,
-0.0561807416,
0.0565837845,
0.0097466744,
-0.0154759688,
0.0166276582,
0.0608338974,
-0.0156855788,
0.0734606087,
0.0158593673,
0.0350652784,
0.0255721435,
0.0059088604,
0.0350028723,
0.0561434031,
0.0002439935,
0.0321707278,
-0.0446363464,
-0.0014563951,
0.0404212922,
-0.0221122112,
-0.0333223529,
0.0513058901,
-0.0294798855,
0.0290028639,
0.0690172836,
0.0161765572,
-0.05357318,
0.0465340093,
-0.0139806299,
-0.0354647972,
0.0219245981,
0.0151859028,
-0.0766899511,
0.0035828087,
-0.0822752193,
-0.0413582437,
-0.0433031805,
0.0316301435,
-0.0097474186,
-0.0021447991,
0.0070171054,
-0.0065638451,
0.0203702189,
0.0391822606,
-0.0085530812,
0.0147064477,
0.0216172989,
0.0994680822,
0.0405065268,
-0.0531462841,
-0.047781419,
-0.064909853,
-0.0257271305,
0.0217708275,
0.0305517912,
-0.0005500035,
0.0076737013,
0.0020596012,
-0.0025819892,
0.0198011808,
0.0194389708,
0.0142775793,
0.0058144438,
0.0057888729,
0.0042578392,
-0.0157371201,
0.0247418266,
0.0137488283,
-0.0366530977,
-0.006907329,
-0.0174774788,
-0.0121290656,
-0.0475073531,
0.0036452217,
-0.0119251795,
-0.0157557018,
-0.0346997343,
0.0336548053,
0.013207647,
-0.0042632655,
-0.0280842632,
0.02504519,
0.0583371595,
-0.0059972759,
0.0101217711,
0.0295768008,
-0.0569064841,
0.0148639483,
0.0408837199,
-0.0163344964,
0.000850421,
0.0458110124,
0.0058152229,
-0.0238070339,
0.096281223,
-0.0368895344,
0.0402302295,
0.0279101375,
0.0417014882,
-0.0296781398,
0.0043703835,
-0.014975829,
0.0500699654,
-0.0212913714,
0.0097086011,
0.0092086131,
0.0181157663,
0.0461898707,
0.0040487158,
-0.0423993617,
0.031754218,
-0.0316004604,
0.0042900485,
-0.007189245,
-0.0072325207,
-0.0233261287,
-0.0306900442,
-0.0484439284,
-0.0217638947,
-0.0132442284,
0.0414562896,
0.0285877008,
0.019352939,
-0.039805375,
0.0002778912,
0.000528841,
-0.0049222829,
-0.002090578,
0.0264566392,
-0.0178597253,
-0.0254277755,
-0.0233060811,
0.0016907402,
-0.0094542382,
-0.0204600431,
0.0336908847,
-0.0179759264,
-0.0358480252,
-0.018986972,
-0.0045026112,
-0.0375110283,
0.0222816262,
-0.0322639979,
-0.0261405427,
0.0601933524,
0.0165730137,
0.019480966,
0.0889654532,
-0.0209937878,
0.0328999907,
0.0811567083,
-0.0205435306,
-0.0336542875,
-0.0127933016,
0.0867735222,
-0.0451550558,
-0.0455926694,
-0.0598860197,
-0.01708051,
0.0755661502,
0.0279838182,
0.0161626488,
0.0043265312,
0.0249229819,
-0.0431780256,
-0.0294057727,
0.014888091,
-0.0583623461,
-0.0484974831,
0.0125993956,
-0.0110251196,
-0.0521759279,
0.0537902564,
-0.030344801,
0.0220230762,
-0.012397984,
-0.0044238055,
-0.0001154743,
0.0568788126,
-0.0216737278,
0.0220290404,
0.0913874507,
-0.011193133,
-0.0528882444,
-0.0466680042,
0.0274811592,
-0.0218079407,
0.0306631662,
-0.0536633395,
0.0023466223,
-0.0295798052,
-0.0432435647,
-0.0435716622,
-0.0096372385,
-0.032791663,
-0.0113639459,
0.0340019353,
-0.0414812267,
-0.0288733747,
-0.0560458191,
0.0605504028,
-0.0350668691,
-0.0179836359,
-0.0027033198,
-0.0225963015,
-0.0125707267,
0.0352682844,
-0.048042234,
0.028769901,
-0.0327931754,
0.0449224897,
0.0728090852,
0.0253071114,
0.0034301868,
0.0011801887,
0.0285926498,
0.0357676782,
0.0079743741,
-0.0279073566,
0.024139978,
0.0733179227,
-0.0318634808,
0.0084182667,
0.052471213,
0.0215902235,
-0.0161908139,
0.0419007912,
-0.0363683924,
0.0290845111,
0.0312425867,
0.0477067977,
-0.0664215833,
-0.0283396784,
0.0317218229,
0.0360004343,
-0.0422962382,
-0.0264792647,
-0.0174004696,
-0.0807345733,
0.0009145162,
0.0248541217,
0.0105443923,
0.0456461199,
-0.0229688026,
-0.0350728631,
0.0006372109,
0.0292512495,
-0.0049603195,
-0.0114749167,
-0.0173901729,
0.0015712406,
-0.0156422947,
0.0130742416,
0.0542168394,
-0.0254025571,
0.0546757057,
0.0416167937,
-0.0082089417,
-0.0555958785,
-0.008367274,
0.0504472144,
-0.0070826798,
-0.0078768115,
-0.0088292593,
-0.006142064,
0.0389471501,
-0.0134066949,
-0.0088004945,
0.0230161063,
0.0201470163,
-0.0440908931,
0.0408623852,
0.0699800551,
-0.0055653108,
-0.0301091224,
-0.0083754491,
-0.0187503733,
0.0100427074,
0.0389343239,
0.0035996169,
-0.0137049677,
-0.0452907048,
-0.0839138702,
-0.0665694252,
-0.0165044256,
-0.032282643,
0.0274688806,
0.0549157709,
-0.0238421503,
-0.0210949872,
0.0099684373,
-0.0208908971,
0.0092078801,
0.0476843677,
0.014777177,
0.0009743224,
-0.0071726143,
-0.0217414349,
0.0123109622,
-0.0078939022,
0.0597773269,
-0.0399363451,
0.0362606831,
-0.0290449448,
-0.0028257687,
0.0236447603,
0.0102478024,
-0.0274263658,
-0.1129457578,
0.0162479244,
0.0525283106,
0.0284952223,
0.0010280767,
-0.0265749339,
-0.0726478621,
0.0135729285,
0.0323297158,
-0.0695599839,
0.0296919812,
0.0723904297,
-0.0161485318,
0.0193623677,
0.0409557745,
-0.0202477966,
0.0093511362,
0.0720954165,
0.0222342275,
-0.075221926,
0.0231168028,
0.0342691503,
0.066074498,
-0.0084138922,
-0.011236703,
0.0283743665,
0.0234913565,
0.0044723274,
-0.0389442593,
-0.036538288,
0.0047501228,
0.0139524657,
0.0022746501,
-0.0127003649,
0.0509174429,
-0.0006962354,
0.0103132762,
-0.0390716903,
0.006389596,
0.0703406632,
-0.0139145022,
0.0487343892,
0.0716017708,
0.0257745553,
-0.0132809151,
0.0338137001,
-0.0154448412,
0.0382564887,
-0.010384134,
0.0690977722,
-0.0000629287,
-0.0055747144,
-0.0335559696,
0.0078644976,
-0.050772462,
-0.0630688444,
0.0712912753,
0.0578464456,
-0.0018481386,
0.0020769653,
0.0275010914,
-0.0174559634,
0.0112289321,
-0.036144428,
-0.008424337,
-0.0151490094,
-0.0742914602,
0.0240279604,
-0.0020033086,
-0.0146206412,
0.0147747183,
0.0624571443,
0.002419645,
0.0501152538,
0.0110489661,
-0.0060902112,
-0.0315493569,
-0.0173381492,
0.0709836259,
0.0076088263,
-0.0679880008,
-0.0219820533,
-0.0853443742,
-0.0936244577,
-0.01862319,
-0.0064649638,
0.028322624,
-0.0383712724,
-0.0225315932,
0.0464547426,
0.0459055193,
0.0044272663,
-0.0509908125,
0.0357995667,
-0.0207402837,
-0.034820281,
0.0200082865,
-6.384837156e-33,
0.0166834816,
-0.0176478382,
-0.0306597091,
-0.0328763127,
-0.0046662935,
-0.0211086944,
-0.0413781926,
0.0584125854,
-0.0596563034,
-0.0227358583,
-0.0244307723,
0.0024352162,
-0.0008449457,
-0.0099062892,
-0.0101830438,
-0.0091915894,
-0.0200466588,
0.0261802152,
-0.0293334462,
0.0203790199,
0.0479305685,
-0.0012043406,
0.0296767931,
-0.0437806621,
0.0709604993,
-0.0414986722,
-0.0045580971,
0.0038805443,
-0.0777929127,
0.0437333584,
0.0079964632,
0.0216677412,
-0.0055528716,
-0.0129367784,
0.0044911923,
0.0535218455,
0.0085248854,
-0.0240228772,
0.0600962229,
-0.0088028973,
0.0008809177,
-0.057579115,
0.033341065,
-0.0005200004,
-0.0035857689,
-0.0144360159,
-0.0113385944,
-0.0175888985,
-0.025227882,
0.0211025123,
-0.0426405743,
0.0062466278,
-0.0274055079,
0.0140367178,
-0.0301116277,
0.0026200558,
-0.0238828417,
-0.0190335996,
-0.0456357114,
0.0147836842,
0.0368526876,
0.0051598786,
0.0463461801,
0.0052935942,
0.0176719744,
0.0532632582,
-0.043106515,
0.0032992414,
-0.0217751637,
0.0179017503,
0.009446417,
0.0820328444,
0.0650571436,
0.0302434973,
0.0646701232,
-0.0559143946,
-0.0859041288,
-0.0256467871,
0.0559840761,
0.0460256971,
0.0315688476,
-0.0068974979,
-0.0452283695,
-0.0400256477,
-0.0050348383,
-0.0135669708,
-0.0375188403,
-0.036809314,
0.0051353611,
-0.0140567133,
-0.0210701954,
-0.0621619746,
-0.0103864325,
-0.0641204417,
-0.011171272,
-0.0275435261,
0.0024804731,
-0.0153273344,
0.0057533109,
0.0400558263,
-0.0233355369,
0.0019941647,
-0.0278959945,
-0.0312092286,
0.0420698375,
0.0265520327,
0.0499291159,
0.028902946,
-0.0313753597,
-0.0199257154,
-0.0223092251,
0.0255088247,
0.0235702842,
0.0238156784,
0.0320874155,
-0.0064179674,
0.0032829,
-0.0674851164,
0.0539382175,
-0.0041978112,
-0.0496358089,
0.0263062362,
-0.024023829,
0.038209632,
-0.0013624775,
-0.0073785265,
-0.043722447,
0.0410357937,
0.0666900128,
-0.0687279254,
-0.0232519526,
0.0016879304,
3.066e-7,
-0.0048673665,
-0.0108986851,
-0.0121693239,
0.0158871152,
0.0188985188,
0.0749674588,
-0.0367254801,
0.055778712,
0.0122745652,
-0.0421969444,
-0.0665247813,
-0.0033426338,
0.0659846142,
0.03844833,
-0.031571921,
0.0340191014,
-0.0361370072,
0.0008921131,
-0.0480163097,
0.0209461488,
0.0512495153,
0.0545874983,
-0.0185924023,
-0.0408372395,
-0.0363815986,
-0.0443640202,
0.0109182792,
0.0227291845,
0.0171500053,
-0.0177232288,
0.0317976996,
0.0406507105,
0.0025697374,
0.0340287127,
-0.0052375905,
-0.0354260504,
-0.0444540568,
0.0307916049,
0.0138605228,
0.0173516497,
-0.0275367163,
-0.0714973658,
-0.0217870921,
-0.0457137972,
0.067024827,
-0.0482059121,
-0.0578671061,
-0.0129232863,
0.0142538324,
-0.0267999154,
0.0122158723,
-0.0086766435,
-0.0107637737,
0.0123053808,
0.0231027119,
-0.0052604331,
0.0261309054,
-0.0394684039,
-0.0368755311,
0.0050405627,
0.0152122704,
-0.041069258,
-0.0111092823,
0.0248728991,
0.0002282125,
-0.0341026857,
0.0251244307,
2.843656751e-34,
-0.0094256913,
-0.0418996364,
0.0192234758,
-0.0249272622,
0.0184693653,
-0.010598084,
-0.0147975888,
0.0495722815,
0.0050962423,
-0.0436507761,
-0.0220723134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09825v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09825v1 | Human Still Wins over LLM: An Empirical Study of Active Learning on Domain-Specific Annotation Tasks | 2023-11-16T11:51:13 | 2023-11-16T11:51:13 | Yuxuan Lu, Bingsheng Yao, Shao Zhang, Yun Wang, Peng Zhang, Tun Lu, Toby Jia-Jun Li, Dakuo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable advances, and
several claims have been made about their exceeding human performance. However,
in real-world tasks, domain knowledge is often required. Low-resource learning
methods like Active Learning (AL) have been proposed to tackle the cost of
domain expert annotation, raising this question: Can LLMs surpass compact
models trained with expert annotations in domain-specific tasks? In this work,
we conduct an empirical experiment on four datasets from three different
domains comparing SOTA LLMs with small models trained on expert annotations
with AL. We found that small models can outperform GPT-3.5 with a few hundreds
of labeled data, and they achieve higher or similar performance with GPT-4
despite that they are hundreds time smaller. Based on these findings, we posit
that LLM predictions can be used as a warmup method in real-world applications
and human experts remain indispensable in tasks involving data annotation
driven by domain-specific knowledge. | [
0.0280361325,
0.0032606118,
-0.0158899017,
-0.0032576579,
0.0002351502,
0.0283349399,
0.0321979634,
-0.0100711491,
0.0192440599,
-0.0944509283,
-0.0600767136,
-0.030267857,
-0.0079261651,
0.0164204035,
0.0367393047,
-0.0390665382,
0.0240256414,
-0.0501305275,
0.0456822552,
0.004070451,
0.0100095738,
0.0035323345,
-0.0063417437,
0.0643773526,
-0.0114422785,
0.022424126,
0.0128814094,
-0.0160877686,
-0.0278235041,
-0.022809688,
0.0434276015,
0.0908135399,
0.061684031,
0.0439397655,
0.0000019598,
-0.0389545225,
-0.0027258021,
0.0219936501,
-0.0274374057,
0.0573210567,
-0.0074225143,
0.0006188755,
0.0081884777,
0.0116294902,
-0.0552911274,
-0.0685506687,
0.0392888859,
0.014592235,
0.0518060178,
0.047318697,
-0.0049760034,
0.0006130447,
0.0178560968,
-0.0632926673,
-0.0134814465,
-0.0974060446,
0.0210231971,
0.0285481382,
-0.0139886988,
0.0153760668,
0.0162097141,
0.0323277228,
-0.0170149598,
-0.0013589221,
-0.0143086892,
0.0473796129,
-0.0193310734,
-0.0114937741,
0.0164122228,
0.0452528819,
0.0109055266,
-0.0000050421,
-0.0087310132,
-0.0314894393,
0.0025488322,
0.0480619036,
-0.0166702233,
0.0188725051,
-0.0058294456,
0.0326523967,
-0.014219257,
-0.0136752548,
0.0355676524,
0.0109704575,
0.022630075,
0.068120487,
-0.0148398085,
-0.0386359245,
0.0515638366,
0.0630014539,
-0.077937007,
-0.0206730068,
-0.0182223283,
-0.00415364,
-0.0156129245,
0.0127374921,
-0.0249995999,
-0.0328581519,
0.0179470107,
-0.0502656847,
0.0225672871,
0.0141158383,
-0.0165486969,
0.060410358,
-0.006891334,
0.0081008263,
0.0141086532,
0.013307468,
-0.0223951824,
-0.015014125,
-0.0735066086,
-0.0184118543,
-0.0329519883,
0.0229409244,
-0.0010321474,
0.0137897879,
-0.0519901402,
0.0202506762,
-0.0031002034,
0.0143403877,
0.0196465198,
-0.0130405044,
-0.0435446985,
-0.0102457171,
-0.0241115242,
-0.005231177,
0.0034241374,
0.0447659269,
-0.01925244,
-0.0592516959,
0.022781698,
0.0331849121,
-0.0180754364,
-0.0428975858,
0.001925161,
0.0713717565,
-0.0066123903,
-0.038878981,
-0.0434083901,
0.000297355,
0.0313282758,
-0.0582071282,
-0.0026231178,
-0.035902705,
-0.0251242518,
0.025634652,
0.021237921,
-0.0911618173,
-0.0031543835,
0.003928367,
-0.0227118805,
0.0756916553,
-0.0498453677,
0.0003394294,
0.0666183829,
-0.0173788164,
-0.0356521793,
0.0768846795,
0.0083620958,
0.0283584706,
0.0284274276,
-0.0083976481,
0.0107710455,
0.04817174,
0.0021359583,
0.0142866038,
-0.0057153106,
0.0234594885,
-0.0064095585,
0.0056734588,
0.0041788453,
0.0149215888,
-0.0122796288,
0.0264173094,
0.0787458569,
0.0407200344,
-0.0425056964,
0.0102127399,
0.0621869266,
0.045312345,
0.0554508418,
-0.012535058,
-0.068718113,
-0.00841197,
-0.0269443467,
0.0014549333,
-0.0020725117,
-0.0206568744,
-0.0307677556,
-0.0284205358,
-0.0341770872,
-0.0415461436,
-0.0209247433,
0.031829156,
0.0689695999,
-0.0209078006,
-0.0175431203,
0.0702271685,
0.0276181586,
0.0081943898,
-0.0282842424,
-0.057222914,
-0.0127070863,
0.0022643781,
0.0078926692,
-0.0588845611,
-0.0619011149,
-0.0240294896,
0.0446924008,
0.0385448858,
0.0800870061,
-0.0133443596,
-0.0231255051,
-0.0488809161,
-0.0450446941,
-0.0012322079,
0.0629822314,
0.005729557,
0.045454409,
-0.0167762637,
0.0231407173,
-0.0583991706,
-0.040913716,
0.04414244,
-0.0488921925,
-0.0272455849,
-0.0168819074,
-0.0075069256,
0.0273365472,
0.0067792134,
-0.0258185714,
0.0004892261,
0.003676228,
-0.0108728101,
-0.0128863193,
-0.0025226439,
0.0036692049,
0.0322350077,
0.0186485853,
0.0009955226,
-0.0447273068,
0.0174370799,
-0.0455895141,
-0.019604316,
-0.0429595821,
-0.0441994332,
-0.0064127119,
-0.0777624622,
0.0048895562,
-0.0278088283,
0.0140603678,
-0.0592334829,
0.0573612154,
0.0119678481,
-0.002730808,
0.0149297528,
-0.0117773982,
0.0151862558,
-0.0124076055,
-0.0316675231,
-0.0340397507,
0.0209984761,
0.0102302665,
0.0130030382,
0.0204721782,
-0.024655899,
0.0246822946,
-0.0857863575,
-0.0181971192,
-0.0290471427,
0.0074424669,
0.0098801907,
0.0123998672,
-0.0227891598,
-0.006155876,
-0.0264127944,
-0.0138985552,
-0.0352119319,
0.038725365,
0.0292898715,
0.0250971261,
0.0063688862,
-0.0670684725,
0.0021741197,
-0.0048845629,
0.0096738068,
0.0234180056,
-0.0606428124,
-0.0575021394,
0.0546026975,
-0.0051531382,
0.0441411771,
0.0112587102,
-0.0216457695,
0.0044611706,
-0.0229291134,
0.0033454506,
0.0294108689,
-0.0131101664,
0.0236719977,
0.0618591681,
0.0193530079,
-0.0504825115,
0.028406769,
-0.0090842135,
-0.0366645567,
-0.059394218,
-0.0080328528,
-0.0054776254,
0.0750501677,
-0.0153535455,
0.0010680966,
-0.0563227683,
0.0026827161,
-0.0426774397,
-0.0145146716,
-0.0410565399,
0.0202562343,
-0.0180296507,
0.0606265701,
0.0005359291,
-0.0752518103,
0.0623932779,
-0.0105692726,
-0.0172013976,
-0.0302401297,
-0.0174094923,
-0.0371088535,
0.0372299626,
0.0149570853,
-0.0114442445,
0.009935203,
-0.0226485953,
-0.0617422163,
0.000729908,
0.0332134664,
-0.02203127,
0.0526312925,
-0.0718583316,
0.049116347,
-0.0239701308,
-0.0456893183,
-0.0382271446,
-0.0311994366,
-0.0698758587,
0.0349506028,
0.0210737176,
-0.012309663,
-0.0159215182,
0.0351136699,
-0.0071171666,
0.0742504969,
0.021999808,
-0.025171591,
-0.0024085401,
0.0103215585,
0.0355022475,
0.0201729313,
-0.0404818393,
-0.0422962978,
-0.0038029358,
0.0262739621,
-0.003432757,
-0.0324955173,
-0.0344975665,
-0.004336209,
0.0422085039,
-0.0492896177,
-0.0454657301,
0.0155012133,
0.0287237614,
-0.0418777727,
0.0015086179,
0.1461490095,
0.018727662,
-0.0839518383,
-0.0027011374,
0.0064309686,
0.0132390782,
0.0343616605,
0.0290935673,
-0.0453995578,
-0.0482505262,
-0.0185202938,
0.0720119029,
0.0321380943,
-0.0330053829,
-0.0115017872,
-0.1019354016,
0.0304482412,
-0.0212217197,
-0.031582702,
0.0203426369,
-0.0448001996,
0.0174313355,
-0.0437168032,
0.0113302311,
-0.0280160792,
0.0008102639,
0.0143651282,
0.0677728951,
-0.0645584986,
-0.0729011148,
0.031517487,
-0.0209953487,
0.0671553761,
0.0652767494,
0.0073839258,
-0.0018904256,
0.0035319943,
0.0822816342,
0.0320456699,
0.0287493635,
-0.0191576257,
0.071224682,
0.0010367072,
-0.0111498591,
0.0276375692,
0.0102631245,
-0.0337431431,
0.0095420564,
0.0213874802,
0.0700389519,
-0.0188087989,
0.0169337187,
0.0033203017,
-0.0320623629,
-0.017548183,
0.0467112809,
0.0099489037,
-0.0457667299,
-0.0258481018,
-0.0036594141,
0.012879204,
-0.0043089734,
-0.0928416625,
0.0101677049,
-0.0321722627,
-0.0416933671,
-0.0362707898,
-0.0364863239,
0.0750999004,
0.0455313623,
0.0311633293,
0.0457920469,
0.0076725734,
0.048302792,
-0.0186503828,
0.0264060926,
-0.0481697917,
0.0188758746,
-0.050866805,
-0.0681725666,
0.0615995862,
-0.0287829321,
-0.0303155817,
-0.0105503518,
-0.0730536357,
-0.0512887873,
0.0228480697,
0.0406317227,
0.0335274301,
0.0377221368,
-0.021257991,
-0.0580196381,
0.0119998315,
0.0313730352,
-0.0292016659,
-0.0036798816,
0.0283290222,
-0.03890099,
-0.0055815862,
0.0330552086,
-0.0515750311,
0.0243484899,
0.0430320688,
0.0145443073,
-0.0170935951,
-0.046251379,
0.014848059,
0.0161594655,
0.1007139236,
-0.0308649093,
-0.0155867226,
-0.014597998,
-0.0147337355,
0.0324556306,
-0.011312766,
-0.0486632921,
-0.0012281665,
0.0124503914,
0.030439999,
-0.0201080944,
0.0276179314,
0.019211838,
0.0655576065,
-0.0318107158,
0.0090908287,
0.0188742299,
0.0147337448,
0.0061926879,
0.0093546668,
-0.0180148967,
0.0080123655,
0.0127194244,
0.0463098884,
-0.0075319349,
0.04683863,
-0.0179253034,
0.0398721397,
0.000398722,
0.0316091217,
-0.0436418876,
-0.0619789958,
-0.0418955721,
0.0698537678,
0.075200431,
-0.0399954394,
0.0593049526,
-0.052346237,
-0.0017221264,
-0.0190393701,
0.0083705466,
0.0159617439,
0.0103615122,
0.0193324629,
0.0170386732,
-0.039877627,
0.0255648643,
0.1222393513,
0.0676209107,
0.0561260022,
-0.0202338472,
-0.0388614349,
-0.0395463556,
-0.0278993174,
0.0352590419,
-0.011091494,
-0.0114435274,
0.0180765688,
-0.0570823438,
-0.0737968907,
-0.042125579,
-0.0694247335,
-0.0263515655,
-0.0106431786,
0.0462318286,
0.0602260828,
-0.015240808,
0.0144388797,
-0.0510292351,
-0.025474079,
0.0267442297,
0.0019161985,
-0.0157656576,
-6.100787395e-33,
-0.0247392524,
-0.0121099865,
0.0058037643,
0.0146439262,
-0.014344384,
0.0222615916,
-0.0094179111,
0.0082814563,
-0.0124258064,
-0.0015518562,
-0.0066610314,
0.0024169723,
0.0257846378,
0.0028445388,
0.0412686542,
-0.0218421668,
0.0403924137,
-0.0289395712,
-0.0113586336,
0.0083230352,
-0.002987548,
0.0276236646,
0.0423274636,
-0.1041550711,
0.0492367446,
0.0106308805,
-0.0241547488,
0.0066689057,
0.0146678416,
0.034940958,
-0.0035982209,
0.0347417071,
0.0164929405,
-0.0619382896,
-0.0201306771,
-0.0442062281,
-0.0483045019,
0.0006237378,
0.0162107497,
0.0126125449,
0.0176121723,
0.0219930764,
0.0095351394,
-0.0194412693,
-0.0050987168,
0.0099719949,
0.0620161258,
-0.0283332374,
-0.0400595851,
-0.0400141999,
-0.042884741,
0.0536828302,
-0.0170083083,
0.0232098494,
0.0457913205,
0.0142933717,
-0.0014436754,
-0.0143711371,
-0.0456740409,
0.0035638302,
0.0029535736,
0.0464178249,
0.037083406,
-0.0041436446,
-0.005688889,
0.0405798815,
0.0426316336,
0.0309750475,
0.0011105175,
0.0112374844,
-0.0015726123,
0.0199251976,
0.0014984132,
0.041657526,
0.0086805001,
0.0075867474,
-0.0374176838,
0.0356801376,
0.0333039425,
-0.0057389173,
0.045896586,
0.0144178737,
-0.0616048425,
-0.0289631169,
-0.006145712,
0.0501053371,
-0.0093219783,
-0.0458269082,
0.0145810219,
0.0043553622,
-0.0427365042,
0.0128047308,
0.0187381115,
-0.0270876195,
-0.0197818559,
-0.0219890792,
0.0036319396,
0.0215841345,
-0.0152507992,
-0.0058636707,
-0.0466525592,
-0.0614879094,
-0.0176576488,
0.0297846813,
0.028220769,
-0.0000131529,
0.0232401006,
0.0468797125,
-0.0588432141,
-0.0141976355,
-0.0216250438,
-0.0080290698,
0.0020101361,
0.0441969782,
0.033648178,
-0.0117907925,
-0.0034951821,
0.0438445061,
0.0253527835,
-0.0425728709,
-0.0020812643,
-0.010801008,
-0.00911933,
-0.0158739425,
-0.0287164561,
-0.0133489231,
0.0028677753,
-0.0270566065,
0.0042840936,
-0.0381147265,
-0.0066707903,
-0.019727746,
2.579e-7,
0.0586501397,
0.0711327493,
-0.0393008403,
-0.0138001619,
0.0170222074,
0.062507011,
-0.0299990214,
-0.0016803567,
0.0401527844,
0.0262962338,
0.0440986156,
0.0037174057,
0.0572973788,
0.0407285839,
-0.119926773,
-0.0563479513,
-0.0307501331,
0.0418203473,
-0.0328950845,
-0.0027988204,
0.0156501606,
0.0924865678,
0.028455684,
-0.0288047232,
-0.0195206739,
-0.0854863599,
0.0617023855,
-0.0336269736,
0.0096050249,
0.0415843278,
0.0277632289,
0.0565945357,
-0.0225903876,
0.0349945575,
-0.0328556374,
-0.004553719,
0.0577145182,
0.0791225359,
0.0128446631,
0.0136382831,
0.0135278553,
-0.011956024,
0.0399910286,
-0.0061847279,
0.0592049062,
-0.0581875853,
-0.0415310077,
0.0270042066,
-0.0011716844,
-0.0315445587,
-0.0151103046,
0.0077937739,
0.0029937618,
0.0116516976,
-0.01761421,
-0.0196744986,
-0.0430575609,
-0.0462166779,
-0.0293891039,
-0.015163715,
-0.0531686693,
-0.0619373024,
-0.0374875702,
0.0445130877,
0.0118040945,
-0.0119380215,
0.0316414461,
2.219330809e-34,
0.0469893068,
-0.0001963355,
0.0120164482,
0.0661417171,
-0.0019076663,
0.0226397347,
0.0337539613,
0.0077717751,
0.0080082081,
-0.0357184894,
0.0128464215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09821v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09821v1 | Towards Robust Temporal Reasoning of Large Language Models via a Multi-Hop QA Dataset and Pseudo-Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-16T11:49:29 | 2023-11-16T11:49:29 | Qingyu Tan, Hwee Tou Ng, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge in the real world is being updated constantly. However, it is
costly to frequently update large language models (LLMs). Therefore, it is
crucial for LLMs to understand the concept of temporal knowledge. However,
prior works on temporal question answering did not emphasize multi-answer and
multi-hop types of temporal reasoning. In this paper, we propose a complex
temporal question-answering (QA) dataset Complex-TR that focuses on
multi-answer and multi-hop temporal reasoning. Besides, we also propose a novel
data augmentation strategy to improve the complex temporal reasoning capability
and robustness of LLMs. We conducted experiments on multiple temporal QA
datasets. Experimental results show that our method is able to improve LLMs'
performance on temporal QA benchmarks by significant margins. | [
0.0313146189,
0.0611842945,
-0.0264104661,
0.0344982222,
-0.0233420692,
0.0246777702,
0.0035434787,
-0.013971868,
0.0103284344,
-0.0307901707,
0.0031981589,
-0.050067164,
-0.0133205745,
0.0276737455,
-0.002015963,
-0.0409010798,
0.0804345831,
-0.0429275073,
-0.0175364614,
-0.006576478,
-0.0008234186,
0.0009602357,
-0.0305596702,
0.0144341327,
0.0238971226,
-0.0552508198,
-0.0421247669,
-0.0405060276,
0.0367878973,
-0.013957886,
0.0058403932,
0.0366541818,
0.0382133648,
0.0195978414,
0.0000017893,
0.0039660078,
-0.0061039175,
-0.0120313512,
-0.0655564889,
0.0368243977,
-0.0413157791,
0.0299789142,
0.0130936336,
0.0183993541,
-0.0695245788,
0.0078416038,
0.0130861606,
0.017741248,
0.0734456033,
0.0686631501,
0.0190163907,
0.0090661049,
0.0414490178,
-0.0157092363,
0.0163347814,
-0.0731368065,
0.015810756,
0.0388622545,
0.0695627257,
0.0184305962,
-0.001988417,
0.0272050314,
0.049132444,
0.0052492353,
-0.025374243,
0.0282950923,
-0.0066910475,
0.0525462963,
-0.0171310306,
0.0707646161,
0.036392089,
-0.0113549791,
-0.020759372,
0.0291844755,
-0.0346016809,
-0.018693503,
-0.0416144468,
-0.0144716846,
0.0215551052,
0.0219860692,
0.005861639,
-0.0026182837,
0.0101703554,
0.0221394338,
-0.0165993609,
0.1202034354,
-0.0018942612,
-0.0203827564,
-0.0524777807,
-0.0215737801,
-0.0041648215,
-0.050740622,
0.0074834595,
0.1060338542,
-0.0245291591,
0.0313116796,
0.0069673993,
0.0235757791,
0.010675285,
-0.0257701855,
0.024114823,
0.0631993935,
0.0006940985,
0.0528079271,
0.000632128,
0.0596136749,
-0.0445448235,
0.020417206,
-0.0355772115,
-0.0205251202,
-0.0740837157,
-0.0312802605,
-0.0062596612,
0.0574615225,
-0.035114117,
0.0312820151,
-0.0415086709,
0.0477299616,
-0.0171170719,
0.0039489535,
-0.0231990647,
0.0250759106,
-0.0182969663,
-0.0281115584,
-0.0591159724,
0.0319887213,
-0.062114343,
0.0263594035,
-0.019803483,
-0.0631739423,
-0.0358227901,
-0.0123793948,
0.0190193485,
-0.0611658469,
-0.0195387565,
0.0483922064,
-0.0474949926,
-0.0110591268,
-0.0663416088,
-0.0598776676,
0.010164653,
-0.0478465259,
-0.021447653,
-0.0530287884,
0.052920077,
-0.0156997629,
-0.0386642776,
-0.0077221077,
0.0026859562,
0.0251467414,
0.0001097523,
0.0608106405,
0.0249102339,
0.0191438347,
-0.0028231274,
0.0108115738,
0.0194867123,
0.0573169999,
0.0197089445,
-0.0470518619,
0.0215982869,
0.0269548595,
-0.015699422,
0.0253566243,
0.0285260044,
0.0091897203,
-0.0441053286,
0.0651530698,
0.005161406,
0.0081820721,
-0.0218312535,
0.0361224785,
-0.0355784073,
-0.0482051522,
0.0179271884,
-0.0037181736,
-0.0165493898,
-0.0317779854,
0.0478042997,
-0.0326033346,
0.0450710692,
0.0020781616,
-0.0343788452,
0.0426892266,
-0.0607139319,
0.0227015242,
-0.0382438973,
0.0040027397,
-0.0443876311,
-0.0504807383,
-0.0063815629,
0.0284258742,
0.012271828,
0.0338186696,
0.0581168048,
-0.0030494349,
-0.0293830074,
0.0446176417,
0.0217523389,
0.0100811506,
-0.0142947286,
-0.0506172851,
0.0438192897,
0.1026860848,
0.0308393631,
-0.0540878773,
-0.0738317594,
-0.0098912884,
0.0477099903,
0.0129531752,
0.0480600223,
-0.0361996926,
0.0071985656,
-0.0125913024,
-0.0240653139,
-0.023282392,
-0.0069320747,
0.0155574419,
0.0582180731,
0.0336411856,
-0.0138412351,
-0.0258204415,
0.0277126301,
0.0191220399,
-0.0489959717,
-0.0074573779,
-0.0363676883,
0.00413433,
0.0013662744,
0.0233196095,
-0.0006271222,
0.0066485452,
0.0385756977,
-0.0179539379,
-0.0131248599,
0.0217999984,
-0.0441992022,
-0.0686562955,
0.0473511405,
0.0217562169,
-0.0510925651,
0.0513687953,
-0.0559534878,
-0.0450931974,
0.0556002744,
-0.0026406008,
0.0467196889,
-0.0265558958,
-0.0011746685,
0.0155730518,
0.0358887725,
-0.0388298482,
0.0576300249,
-0.0308597665,
0.0154801439,
0.0221869517,
0.0304014944,
-0.0083401306,
-0.0498144962,
-0.0082804766,
0.0220926758,
0.0060841735,
-0.0191235915,
-0.0233969651,
-0.0123826414,
-0.0535862446,
0.0097273113,
-0.0510158204,
0.0038413599,
-0.0118684266,
0.0348300114,
0.0118337227,
-0.020737879,
0.0110620642,
-0.0200362019,
-0.0324137993,
-0.0111945653,
-0.0115541155,
0.0093226088,
0.0475641899,
0.0442572795,
-0.0131394546,
-0.0280752648,
-0.0249694027,
-0.0466438271,
0.060291443,
-0.0218224209,
-0.018866282,
-0.0225550439,
-0.0585857891,
-0.0411087833,
0.0356368497,
-0.0054937475,
-0.0171914846,
0.014980319,
-0.0031839516,
0.0249932781,
0.0665456504,
-0.0100088818,
0.0038271656,
0.049388539,
-0.0208313093,
-0.036594674,
0.0652192086,
-0.0135532934,
-0.0051201959,
-0.0184324738,
-0.0390204266,
-0.0418310538,
0.0645786673,
-0.0274135359,
-0.0007694232,
-0.0359767117,
0.0088511109,
-0.0218690671,
0.0073877056,
-0.0230276883,
0.0183816999,
-0.0246857107,
0.0178090967,
-0.046635706,
-0.0065370337,
0.0962427706,
0.0074198674,
-0.0226614177,
0.0048457268,
-0.0104746893,
-0.040581163,
0.0846562833,
-0.0169294868,
-0.0156734623,
-0.0214643907,
-0.012321786,
-0.0557272471,
-0.0402286686,
0.0151668144,
-0.0413673595,
0.0306321271,
-0.0597947799,
0.0293468293,
-0.013813802,
-0.0009076258,
-0.05298125,
-0.0349938311,
-0.0456144735,
-0.0028240134,
-0.0718783066,
-0.0127289714,
-0.002646989,
-0.0001347084,
-0.0242411029,
0.0299173966,
-0.0408073328,
-0.0032743695,
-0.0163295418,
0.0579817034,
0.0673816502,
0.0483450331,
-0.0074842307,
-0.0100574642,
0.0431930646,
0.041353099,
0.0778773054,
-0.0569239669,
-0.0292512774,
0.0207661018,
0.0065556322,
-0.0158594716,
0.0085700201,
0.015462379,
0.0427387878,
-0.0801732093,
-0.0327634662,
0.0932099521,
0.0733851418,
0.0106775733,
0.0102142217,
-0.0093476912,
0.009933576,
0.0178504288,
0.0449699722,
-0.0756047145,
-0.0377911739,
-0.0111830421,
-0.0117643252,
-0.0152311679,
-0.0437897481,
-0.0292879641,
-0.0964886323,
-0.0159886815,
-0.0141957477,
-0.0154383108,
-0.0082755089,
0.000103886,
-0.0043674232,
0.0235020295,
0.0422992222,
0.0339991525,
0.0198426433,
-0.0148234963,
0.0287882239,
-0.0120493919,
-0.0389492959,
0.091336295,
0.0449960828,
0.0813052803,
0.0287904143,
0.0193195269,
0.0019846004,
-0.0497875102,
0.0274516214,
-0.002284517,
-0.0041060951,
-0.002099857,
0.0193695109,
0.0144323148,
-0.0229636077,
0.006592555,
0.0377193391,
-0.0224811733,
-0.0306943282,
0.0083499365,
0.1368187219,
-0.0256667864,
0.0262495689,
-0.024700338,
0.0046725231,
-0.0058075949,
0.0567735061,
0.0003652374,
-0.0091777062,
-0.0592009984,
-0.0247724783,
-0.0661298335,
-0.1033097133,
-0.0148000428,
0.0059896284,
0.0068352064,
0.0390330367,
-0.0726501048,
-0.0463853888,
0.0154554173,
0.0133672412,
-0.0327084921,
0.0035520263,
0.0190077592,
0.0100390473,
-0.0675152391,
0.0432768874,
-0.0409820266,
0.042398639,
-0.0302430931,
-0.0214484092,
0.0130713331,
-0.0120446002,
-0.0164126251,
0.0080715315,
-0.1023438424,
-0.0605757646,
-0.0109265158,
-0.0009462571,
0.0199510381,
0.0828108042,
-0.0287308414,
-0.0222185906,
0.0343674533,
-0.0203371383,
-0.0236563757,
-0.0065491195,
0.0471766032,
0.0100728618,
-0.0074639949,
0.0546947569,
-0.0550968647,
-0.009404703,
0.0029410338,
0.0582692064,
-0.0429270416,
0.0296408366,
0.0243074242,
-0.0162079502,
0.0008956703,
0.0619270653,
0.0008236874,
-0.0021162725,
0.051595524,
-0.0540181175,
-0.0077032978,
-0.0144465184,
0.0159895774,
0.004945647,
-0.0683723018,
-0.009833823,
-0.0125619499,
0.0047349357,
0.0080270283,
0.0022618822,
0.0119591113,
0.0001156603,
-0.005368175,
0.0080118002,
0.0037973837,
-0.012094534,
0.006132883,
-0.0142544881,
0.0440127105,
0.0074031013,
0.0272484422,
0.0195199437,
-0.0018395368,
-0.0539288372,
-0.0363379307,
-0.1003676653,
-0.0104544619,
0.0039546634,
0.0074895257,
0.0355231091,
0.0040367008,
0.021579504,
0.0037531597,
-0.0146478051,
0.011752204,
-0.0115529606,
0.0332559198,
-0.0084173502,
0.0625774637,
0.0389471613,
0.0114232581,
0.0380406268,
0.0760038719,
-0.0157954264,
0.0595443025,
0.0107023623,
0.0028549347,
-0.011216349,
-0.0367630534,
-0.0671044663,
-0.0170953851,
-0.0160238091,
0.00955611,
-0.0516146012,
-0.0793360993,
0.0250159036,
0.0215903614,
-0.0327132046,
-0.0075440356,
-0.011968459,
0.0026765647,
0.0674964935,
-0.0272275116,
-0.0311067626,
0.0414050035,
0.0341012888,
-0.0166415703,
-0.0358759947,
-6.300466784e-33,
-0.0235610809,
-0.0168525968,
0.0540962294,
-0.0514936745,
-0.0250693168,
0.0119921109,
-0.0393115282,
-0.0166071989,
-0.061585281,
0.0005203508,
-0.0344175436,
0.0523467809,
0.0189522952,
0.0326284468,
0.0158588365,
-0.038064599,
-0.01000717,
-0.0191966072,
0.0080879712,
0.0253774207,
0.0459246337,
0.0007426857,
0.0429696627,
0.0067681368,
0.0063672746,
-0.0109022632,
0.0079198601,
0.0741030127,
-0.0372252315,
0.0848335177,
-0.0185173079,
0.02634353,
0.0199238807,
-0.0396776833,
-0.0079557598,
0.0058341399,
-0.1050563976,
-0.0587615743,
0.0283445753,
0.0211362187,
-0.0389085598,
-0.0300829131,
-0.0125372149,
-0.0007207704,
0.0329854414,
-0.0295991395,
0.0046228226,
-0.0437829718,
-0.0020189094,
-0.032720454,
-0.001903528,
0.0421878099,
-0.0393994227,
-0.0175680164,
-0.0019280029,
0.0658316612,
0.0216326769,
0.0122375349,
-0.0392031632,
0.002189962,
0.0153971082,
0.0045342953,
0.0456829928,
0.0082754847,
0.0034549823,
0.0052936208,
-0.0125734238,
0.0221190397,
-0.0311688073,
0.0484979115,
0.0003182072,
-0.007440981,
0.0365976803,
0.0092026154,
0.0137930335,
0.010561211,
-0.0494007505,
0.0072524496,
0.0411381274,
0.0291169137,
0.0190110691,
-0.0206954405,
-0.0265389364,
0.0072542951,
-0.0168776438,
0.0505311787,
-0.0406728387,
-0.0004292785,
0.0248208921,
0.0062253675,
0.0025930752,
-0.0044570896,
0.0162851345,
-0.054864008,
-0.0080039594,
0.0220344048,
-0.0291563813,
0.0218832195,
0.017014483,
0.0703910887,
-0.0193380564,
0.002307636,
0.02072821,
-0.0347031988,
-0.0178561844,
-0.0050939694,
0.0457144827,
0.0369756036,
-0.0444768369,
-0.0131461201,
-0.0392307378,
0.0398008861,
-0.0062923431,
-0.0190103874,
0.0342389569,
0.0033089221,
-0.0162275229,
0.0682047084,
0.0003069301,
0.031191498,
-0.0139280977,
0.0260158144,
-0.0080661681,
0.0352792628,
-0.0154177342,
-0.0032743872,
-0.0387841351,
0.0290035214,
-0.0223400649,
-0.0493502654,
-0.004413154,
0.0404537097,
2.383e-7,
0.0204451513,
0.017826058,
0.0351406373,
0.0749896094,
0.0175941512,
-0.0114178555,
-0.0334759355,
-0.0247764196,
-0.0127267167,
0.0039296374,
0.0187533237,
0.0426018387,
0.0408879109,
0.0359358601,
-0.0072341552,
-0.02938338,
-0.0501219667,
-0.0212554391,
-0.0547991358,
-0.0332287811,
0.0766043961,
0.0974757001,
0.042844642,
0.0169489048,
-0.0297352299,
-0.0344654247,
0.0548614673,
0.018631978,
-0.0216264501,
0.01920655,
0.0400332808,
0.0027209176,
0.0255540162,
0.0339107849,
-0.0124204932,
0.0194002502,
-0.0553693622,
0.0591200441,
-0.007903914,
-0.0711991861,
-0.0382113867,
-0.0624420829,
0.0004418711,
-0.0087961266,
0.1321395636,
-0.0580021814,
-0.0271742046,
0.0017616597,
-0.0241983701,
0.0215122309,
-0.0114736473,
-0.0010468502,
0.0014821476,
0.0270344988,
0.0070145973,
-0.0198075846,
0.0227798317,
-0.1050212458,
-0.029697109,
0.0443905778,
-0.0319984779,
0.0026986543,
-0.0183923636,
-0.0350936987,
0.0100781135,
-0.0358037576,
-0.0098648993,
1.927408266e-34,
0.0331053138,
0.0020747911,
-0.0035749269,
0.0275688246,
0.0270608086,
-0.0287765171,
0.0027050585,
-0.0185472835,
0.050929863,
-0.0631368756,
-0.0234683137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09818v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09818v2 | SUQL: Conversational Search over Structured and Unstructured Data with Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T11:48:17 | 2024-03-13T17:07:02 | Shicheng Liu, Jialiang Xu, Wesley Tjangnaka, Sina J. Semnani, Chen Jie Yu, Monica S. Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.PL | While most conversational agents are grounded on either free-text or
structured knowledge, many knowledge corpora consist of hybrid sources. This
paper presents the first conversational agent that supports the full generality
of hybrid data access for large knowledge corpora, through a language we
developed called SUQL (Structured and Unstructured Query Language).
Specifically, SUQL extends SQL with free-text primitives (summary and answer),
so information retrieval can be composed with structured data accesses
arbitrarily in a formal, succinct, precise, and interpretable notation. With
SUQL, we propose the first semantic parser, an LLM with in-context learning,
that can handle hybrid data sources.
Our in-context learning-based approach, when applied to the HybridQA dataset,
comes within 8.9% exact match and 7.1% F1 of the SOTA, which was trained on 62K
data samples. More significantly, unlike previous approaches, our technique is
applicable to large databases and free-text corpora. We introduce a dataset
consisting of crowdsourced questions and conversations on Yelp, a large, real
restaurant knowledge base with structured and unstructured data. We show that
our few-shot conversational agent based on SUQL finds an entity satisfying all
user requirements 90.3% of the time, compared to 63.4% for a baseline based on
linearization. | [
0.0264867302,
0.0391285568,
0.0019539273,
0.0574252717,
-0.0035826906,
0.0155447256,
-0.011491403,
0.0060728309,
0.0261468347,
-0.0523110852,
-0.0225656033,
0.016291922,
-0.0504026487,
0.0353552401,
-0.0171400663,
-0.0120959627,
0.0225071553,
0.0148256067,
0.0312180277,
0.0223247297,
0.0242706761,
0.0141807366,
0.0140246218,
0.0061946725,
-0.0072017689,
0.0204658099,
-0.0488634482,
0.026427459,
-0.023369316,
-0.0135793695,
0.0215420648,
0.0248537306,
0.0376143381,
0.028232906,
0.0000018772,
-0.049940329,
-0.0592224449,
0.0234705005,
-0.0619470403,
-0.0565795787,
0.0047088908,
-0.0102383001,
0.0066584717,
0.0192923956,
-0.0791638121,
-0.0111284778,
0.0248727351,
0.0389879309,
0.0534225255,
0.1004383042,
-0.0143853854,
-0.0544927604,
-0.017725151,
0.0098336032,
0.0408057831,
-0.0726024956,
-0.00016963,
0.0059635835,
0.0365408845,
0.0263556968,
0.0281395838,
0.0310698096,
-0.0122578628,
-0.0195307396,
0.0203765556,
0.0022391693,
-0.0707844347,
0.0246277209,
0.0018662112,
0.106500499,
0.0118936021,
-0.027736675,
0.0282157753,
0.0052370443,
0.00134733,
-0.014157163,
-0.0327318124,
0.0121966377,
-0.0292281695,
0.0409755632,
-0.035308335,
-0.0198434293,
0.0227342434,
-0.0250092987,
-0.0248817466,
0.0968225375,
-0.0237605721,
-0.0423752517,
0.0207217894,
-0.0273854453,
-0.0006198192,
-0.0511348024,
0.0056228722,
0.0576693192,
-0.0727783367,
0.0326241404,
-0.0292806029,
-0.0162101984,
0.0194654372,
-0.0693018287,
-0.0221116487,
0.0445491374,
0.0108462675,
0.0820079297,
0.0162790623,
-0.011321173,
-0.00970913,
0.021476442,
-0.0516957007,
-0.0587598011,
-0.0562951826,
0.0307731181,
-0.035501264,
0.0347213559,
-0.1072724164,
-0.0017434158,
0.0132214688,
0.0703827739,
0.0139409611,
0.0357486121,
0.0148179168,
0.0173763838,
-0.0039796168,
0.0340800285,
-0.0597823076,
-0.0013477277,
-0.0268685371,
-0.0268289223,
0.0060751783,
-0.0630019754,
0.0084595513,
0.0101327859,
0.0529647544,
-0.0222237017,
-0.0100922361,
0.0723253116,
0.0054866825,
-0.0340308696,
-0.0808710754,
-0.0465655848,
0.0289482195,
-0.034448307,
-0.0322971903,
-0.0484716892,
0.0569213443,
0.0078111207,
-0.0285261869,
-0.0318242647,
0.0230848994,
0.0632692277,
-0.0169704724,
0.0743657276,
-0.0566711351,
0.001871663,
0.0242053512,
-0.0040142369,
-0.0169842932,
0.0862201303,
0.0114447009,
-0.0079084244,
0.0550091267,
0.0250624865,
-0.0250099469,
0.0033065772,
0.032946296,
-0.0127070034,
0.0151832104,
0.0864116997,
-0.0186297409,
0.0333420187,
-0.0204359423,
0.0663527846,
-0.0207505096,
-0.0047258595,
-0.0013720877,
0.0245838854,
-0.0004839975,
0.013947946,
0.0133075984,
0.0627151057,
0.0115366271,
-0.034582302,
-0.0533529297,
0.0064908876,
-0.033835005,
-0.0151005778,
0.0226272661,
-0.0185698755,
-0.022369124,
-0.0389409177,
-0.0097573567,
0.0051077856,
0.0092322472,
0.0381874405,
0.0229724087,
0.001515806,
-0.0556970276,
0.0584132299,
0.0192557033,
-0.0313757211,
-0.028752856,
0.0140387574,
0.0377456322,
0.0894880369,
0.0187768694,
-0.0500535071,
-0.0063824733,
-0.0065306751,
0.006620076,
0.0410736874,
-0.0085424855,
-0.0255009439,
0.0080983667,
-0.0312316492,
-0.0362980179,
0.0083369454,
0.0099429442,
-0.0227362271,
0.0048114141,
0.0176770035,
0.017961368,
-0.0591013171,
0.0060168854,
0.007826603,
-0.0017080337,
-0.0138401771,
0.0053024301,
0.0135817416,
0.005304337,
0.0395312011,
0.0110917585,
0.0024269696,
0.0396387652,
0.0100365374,
-0.0640906543,
0.0093051931,
-0.0087218583,
-0.078642346,
0.0281150937,
-0.0047929124,
-0.0219421405,
-0.0196578428,
-0.0343546011,
-0.0524210148,
-0.0110893035,
-0.004854918,
0.0673423707,
-0.0443899706,
-0.0160556398,
0.0246374775,
-0.0122519573,
-0.0653918087,
0.0912764668,
0.0188869126,
-0.0010038358,
0.019041907,
-0.0141613474,
0.0367637053,
-0.0724686831,
-0.0242289007,
-0.0059121531,
0.0213374104,
0.0158755668,
0.0048365141,
0.0125328526,
-0.0702406019,
0.0215083696,
-0.1078007519,
0.0289681628,
-0.0368005708,
0.0090892538,
0.0285710581,
0.0330783129,
0.0165378433,
-0.0377781689,
-0.0577733256,
-0.0037868747,
0.0420533679,
0.0000900642,
0.0523399785,
0.0621436648,
-0.0128136724,
-0.0478254333,
-0.0027877479,
-0.0119805215,
0.0163780004,
0.0091353105,
-0.0289299451,
0.0065322942,
0.008181558,
-0.0293962564,
0.048681654,
0.0116821649,
0.0307549927,
-0.0136107234,
-0.0201682728,
-0.0474541038,
0.0529810227,
-0.018581083,
0.008516402,
-0.0233003534,
-0.0115882326,
-0.0690301061,
0.0367465727,
0.0027139804,
0.0104536135,
-0.0605812259,
-0.0013801403,
0.0485890135,
-0.0218458306,
0.006474406,
0.0178524926,
-0.0418680348,
0.0109365182,
0.0519107506,
-0.0062044389,
-0.0474886447,
0.0326894671,
0.0287785996,
0.0731096491,
-0.009376551,
0.0113168927,
0.0517706685,
-0.0024838329,
-0.0085417703,
-0.0126686515,
-0.0395427048,
-0.0818293393,
0.0299571361,
-0.0205706302,
0.0229685921,
-0.0394938923,
-0.0463925898,
-0.0072849849,
-0.0112418057,
0.0114796255,
-0.0210736059,
0.0659468397,
-0.0077485191,
0.038968116,
0.0296156704,
-0.0445922352,
-0.0369760878,
-0.022565987,
-0.0496529266,
0.0333702639,
0.0056731063,
-0.0062125213,
-0.0229294617,
-0.0420093723,
-0.0346073173,
0.0167517308,
0.010834828,
-0.0303182248,
-0.0253128093,
-0.0064545241,
0.0362172946,
0.0196940638,
-0.0133619141,
0.0197364017,
0.0401589423,
0.0470785275,
0.0297962967,
-0.0452519469,
0.0150262369,
-0.0115715852,
0.013889729,
-0.0598543398,
-0.0032299845,
0.0094483662,
-0.0068567917,
-0.0360701643,
0.0008460013,
0.1270112395,
0.0267773718,
0.0008888488,
-0.0137567073,
-0.0312573537,
-0.0057350979,
0.0265225135,
0.0570074581,
-0.1241112947,
-0.0539458469,
-0.016449146,
0.040778555,
0.0200430732,
-0.0691070706,
0.0107447077,
-0.0931426063,
0.0082551641,
-0.0221003685,
-0.0429025553,
-0.0034121897,
-0.0352605134,
-0.0020970462,
-0.0555989407,
-0.0066690599,
0.0378566533,
-0.0306856968,
0.0129437,
-0.0194040947,
0.0410988666,
-0.0225887112,
0.0302587207,
-0.0678937733,
0.0246933009,
0.0593459159,
0.036155846,
0.0184458084,
-0.0387277491,
0.0297404677,
0.043077305,
-0.0191559717,
-0.027367387,
0.0470557213,
-0.0535978265,
0.0034079056,
-0.0141135696,
0.0150533644,
-0.0581076778,
0.0309970845,
0.0148383817,
0.0563605018,
-0.0222086497,
0.0481964946,
-0.0082955612,
-0.0355446264,
0.0245068222,
0.0910271257,
-0.0068137967,
0.0270326734,
-0.0653717965,
-0.0547457375,
-0.0490032658,
0.0024507889,
0.0130438358,
0.0532721765,
-0.0087697413,
0.0070464648,
-0.0561426394,
-0.0394116044,
0.0285750572,
0.0131609915,
-0.0041136285,
0.0179365575,
0.0295934808,
0.0065000001,
-0.0590849333,
-0.0076549938,
-0.0470696017,
0.0112332916,
-0.0469032042,
-0.0147776688,
0.0021120585,
-0.0336713754,
-0.0330281779,
-0.0259025767,
-0.0553899407,
-0.0540979914,
-0.0080089038,
0.0112516219,
0.015272988,
0.0480475463,
-0.0271957759,
-0.0307580214,
0.0104292622,
0.0584129766,
-0.0630544648,
-0.0162060559,
0.0229721796,
0.0506300144,
0.0293222554,
0.0723123848,
-0.0753748044,
-0.0272904802,
-0.0534397028,
0.0472299457,
-0.041295141,
-0.0216721781,
0.0612936057,
0.0331781656,
0.0020052218,
0.0739286542,
-0.0141627621,
-0.0174802579,
0.0429543369,
-0.0337446705,
-0.0505520888,
-0.0625110865,
0.0025744427,
-0.0209245607,
-0.0294295717,
0.0240363702,
0.0147528443,
-0.0444325507,
0.0709919408,
-0.0166791826,
0.0104233539,
0.0424288251,
-0.0459121279,
0.0253310669,
-0.0091699967,
0.0090492386,
0.0545395017,
0.0354491025,
0.0393662043,
-0.0225571711,
0.0125699891,
0.0177754909,
-0.0122150155,
0.0169321317,
0.0012736162,
-0.0736945644,
-0.0742461979,
0.0282716937,
0.0122201676,
0.0156395081,
-0.0095876269,
0.0186824575,
-0.0082984632,
0.0098958919,
-0.0262054615,
0.0234907288,
0.0020548061,
-0.0559554771,
0.051544793,
0.0068869614,
-0.0312560759,
-0.0060889474,
0.064456977,
-0.0154927494,
0.0241032746,
-0.0113267582,
-0.03629639,
-0.0555864871,
-0.000373705,
0.0344470963,
0.0487427115,
-0.0235983282,
-0.0415678732,
-0.0073148231,
-0.032954555,
0.0115227867,
0.0065351645,
-0.0539574251,
-0.0001118827,
0.0718369111,
0.0544325858,
0.0397195593,
-0.0243416354,
-0.0382184014,
0.0073085744,
0.0062724035,
-0.0225620046,
-0.0092497757,
-6.000735561e-33,
-0.0306185652,
-0.0476895086,
0.0475157127,
0.0176245924,
0.0250972863,
-0.0336683281,
-0.0304761715,
-0.001905205,
-0.0501774065,
-0.0198047347,
-0.0314622931,
0.0410371982,
0.0219676364,
0.0336090066,
-0.0093995938,
-0.0779949576,
0.0291115046,
-0.0045023449,
0.0331356004,
-0.0085615013,
0.0664462596,
0.0533256717,
0.0160556827,
-0.0828353837,
0.0383117013,
-0.012761943,
-0.0013518113,
0.0835227966,
0.0238222461,
0.0353604108,
0.0075263348,
0.0377635323,
0.006211767,
0.0063888659,
-0.0044237208,
-0.0205601696,
-0.0915318727,
0.0101080053,
0.0269960035,
0.025585752,
-0.0386193283,
0.0106593901,
0.0557019152,
-0.0487900861,
0.022106193,
0.0311783608,
0.035923142,
-0.0121349823,
0.0028704316,
-0.0356389992,
-0.013450847,
0.0379546359,
-0.0032251307,
0.0179597195,
-0.00392432,
0.0282963719,
0.0344797559,
0.0312189851,
-0.0568763092,
0.0124985203,
-0.027230652,
0.0088013401,
0.0160761438,
0.0041336403,
0.0244647861,
0.0191474799,
0.0268471502,
0.0071138646,
-0.0232823566,
-0.0153191751,
-0.0186895225,
0.0679206774,
-0.0347382985,
0.0601547286,
-0.0016891799,
0.0049649426,
-0.0554368906,
0.0346052647,
0.0243178122,
-0.0063577862,
-0.0618543401,
0.043927893,
-0.0599009097,
-0.0269217305,
-0.0186458528,
0.0231854115,
-0.0427646562,
-0.029075237,
0.0287069548,
-0.0023833383,
0.0337719359,
-0.0106842136,
0.0039247707,
-0.0354853272,
-0.0295173358,
0.024511274,
0.0051664701,
-0.051225353,
0.0063092406,
0.0154169444,
-0.0645895973,
-0.0149436332,
0.0053558326,
-0.0122343283,
-0.0034815557,
0.0254116002,
0.016070338,
0.0080542713,
-0.0457277223,
0.0080081485,
-0.0277278349,
0.0044992785,
-0.0400404893,
0.0026503541,
0.0136257894,
0.0256717987,
-0.0047948007,
0.0805026367,
0.00133501,
0.0287934467,
-0.0452917702,
-0.0464948751,
0.0179039761,
-0.0195370317,
-0.0079943668,
-0.0002594697,
-0.0052135661,
0.0112118414,
0.0135068288,
-0.0482287146,
0.0345106311,
0.0124058938,
2.674e-7,
0.0408128127,
0.0183617715,
-0.0118116057,
0.0547062494,
-0.0006384231,
0.0281524677,
0.0127010792,
0.0577180684,
-0.0118906908,
-0.0401142947,
0.008058412,
0.0040585683,
-0.0006585016,
0.0359397791,
-0.1276716888,
-0.0366794243,
-0.0241715666,
-0.0534554571,
-0.0460286699,
0.0050055352,
0.0400634594,
0.075957112,
0.0089999586,
0.0259123277,
-0.0171080902,
-0.0375551917,
0.0380480662,
-0.0209516361,
-0.0125364978,
0.014804313,
0.0051100631,
0.0279792212,
-0.0005332515,
-0.0139799826,
-0.0051555862,
0.0528622754,
0.0332102627,
0.0563210994,
0.013371937,
-0.03353424,
0.0161838513,
-0.0646912456,
0.0027179322,
-0.0104343658,
0.0746563226,
-0.007059054,
-0.0063782791,
0.0448273793,
-0.0073161987,
-0.0249487869,
-0.0164118949,
-0.0008980926,
-0.0234237295,
-0.0109042181,
0.0295494534,
-0.0096465899,
0.0335959345,
-0.0486379936,
-0.0091095781,
-0.0089541264,
-0.0419317745,
-0.0196724571,
-0.023170054,
0.0208718684,
0.0076817325,
-0.0259639267,
0.0140410541,
2.371572021e-34,
0.0392431356,
0.0394472517,
-0.0038564091,
0.0304274149,
0.0337030515,
0.0043920688,
-0.0139733255,
-0.0070731365,
0.0365269743,
-0.0797568411,
-0.0032291058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10537v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10537v4 | MedAgents: Large Language Models as Collaborators for Zero-shot Medical Reasoning | 2023-11-16T11:47:58 | 2024-06-04T23:47:43 | Xiangru Tang, Anni Zou, Zhuosheng Zhang, Ziming Li, Yilun Zhao, Xingyao Zhang, Arman Cohan, Mark Gerstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs), despite their remarkable progress across
various general domains, encounter significant barriers in medicine and
healthcare. This field faces unique challenges such as domain-specific
terminologies and reasoning over specialized knowledge. To address these
issues, we propose MedAgents, a novel multi-disciplinary collaboration
framework for the medical domain. MedAgents leverages LLM-based agents in a
role-playing setting that participate in a collaborative multi-round
discussion, thereby enhancing LLM proficiency and reasoning capabilities. This
training-free framework encompasses five critical steps: gathering domain
experts, proposing individual analyses, summarising these analyses into a
report, iterating over discussions until a consensus is reached, and ultimately
making a decision. Our work focuses on the zero-shot setting, which is
applicable in real-world scenarios. Experimental results on nine datasets
(MedQA, MedMCQA, PubMedQA, and six subtasks from MMLU) establish that our
proposed MedAgents framework excels at mining and harnessing the medical
expertise within LLMs, as well as extending its reasoning abilities. Our code
can be found at https://github.com/gersteinlab/MedAgents. | [
0.0454592481,
0.044410415,
0.0024956844,
0.0182285178,
-0.0309891123,
0.0032071653,
0.0426377319,
0.0088308631,
0.0050722905,
-0.0005515034,
-0.0205564424,
-0.0238697007,
-0.0026472809,
0.0425934531,
0.0043427707,
-0.0282642823,
0.0163131934,
-0.0035220732,
0.0595896989,
-0.0176443364,
-0.0043098121,
0.015961865,
-0.0713859499,
0.050579533,
0.0328108482,
-0.0218312647,
0.0191218797,
-0.0444636904,
0.0343358964,
-0.0570121408,
-0.0106548397,
0.0459962338,
0.0181369092,
0.0353960022,
0.00000193,
-0.0520936139,
-0.0236107651,
0.0242762938,
-0.0243630987,
-0.080338344,
0.0307590887,
0.0030314897,
-0.007134683,
0.0123413196,
-0.0617653877,
-0.0221494529,
0.0371149145,
0.0149767455,
0.0332941562,
0.0497350618,
-0.0019203844,
-0.0082126651,
-0.0166851673,
-0.0300491396,
0.0152697992,
-0.0425482579,
0.0371693671,
0.0229719914,
0.086720787,
-0.0100090234,
0.0234655272,
0.0255821217,
-0.00767938,
-0.0213488657,
0.0053850403,
0.0609095097,
-0.0117005389,
-0.0151015241,
0.0241628774,
0.0711749718,
0.0374139622,
0.0054513379,
0.0197272841,
0.0129620852,
-0.0048523913,
0.0510020629,
-0.0557509065,
0.0370259807,
-0.0061368812,
-0.0102314809,
0.0030018857,
-0.0021578579,
0.0494484864,
0.0112589411,
-0.02846005,
0.0787679255,
-0.0173024945,
-0.0000026508,
-0.014162438,
-0.0197465811,
-0.0046572927,
-0.0492113419,
0.0149052804,
0.0721807629,
-0.0723104179,
0.0282803122,
0.0290426109,
-0.0047403774,
0.0738051981,
-0.022141289,
-0.0065167616,
-0.0057682255,
0.042699106,
0.069794409,
0.0048503997,
-0.0471355803,
-0.025067145,
0.0487447754,
-0.027322216,
-0.0359197035,
-0.0833977312,
-0.0204476342,
0.00043216,
0.0412218571,
0.0061918325,
-0.0048920899,
-0.0338777117,
0.0039081308,
-0.0374090262,
0.0252745505,
-0.0050071278,
0.0432625078,
-0.0136925355,
-0.0324413963,
-0.0526883639,
0.0480665751,
-0.0138384718,
0.032333158,
0.0015514079,
-0.0221219901,
0.0048645157,
-0.0102269761,
-0.0193352997,
-0.0137220146,
0.0095021594,
0.0706811622,
0.0137978401,
0.0039050973,
0.0239379164,
-0.0656123906,
-0.0196321197,
-0.0728801787,
0.0180576984,
-0.0854801163,
0.0197559539,
0.0087495735,
0.0042594988,
-0.0693401843,
0.0142806675,
0.0023501264,
-0.0424698777,
0.101454176,
-0.0701820925,
0.0040798546,
0.0262348708,
0.0623644888,
-0.0225133933,
0.0517487861,
0.0277212523,
-0.0282418896,
-0.0006432337,
-0.0113662705,
-0.0037878018,
-0.0129235052,
0.0039408845,
-0.0187234506,
0.0131506398,
0.0240345243,
0.0008023096,
0.0840524063,
-0.0676033348,
0.0332226679,
-0.0300326571,
-0.0141126774,
0.0339038782,
0.1017256752,
0.0265926924,
0.002445878,
0.0041730227,
-0.0228661671,
-0.01436905,
-0.0569972768,
0.0026815636,
0.0453313217,
0.020516498,
-0.0305900648,
0.0008687005,
0.0015793935,
-0.0270075146,
-0.0213537738,
-0.0330205709,
-0.0164229367,
-0.0047424347,
0.0013318234,
0.0402727723,
-0.0136531051,
-0.0020057268,
0.0717960894,
0.0441649407,
-0.0348537229,
-0.0193798691,
-0.0662211701,
0.0453665517,
0.0696352273,
0.0798606426,
-0.0592850372,
-0.0843482092,
-0.0227665156,
0.0273647532,
0.0268228874,
0.0191432741,
-0.0307317879,
-0.018864641,
-0.0438719317,
-0.0235794373,
0.0108163971,
-0.0053087748,
-0.0143434498,
-0.0197108984,
0.0156981908,
-0.0307741947,
-0.000044923,
0.008343135,
0.0140843065,
-0.0693843886,
0.0150563335,
-0.0062178099,
-0.0064802445,
0.0530682877,
0.0325954407,
-0.0068337093,
0.0537953451,
0.048800379,
-0.0437610149,
-0.0420459472,
0.0354975797,
-0.0063975602,
-0.016545482,
0.0425915383,
-0.0371505469,
-0.0082629612,
-0.0417316742,
-0.0234280359,
-0.0251686387,
0.0247244779,
0.0046709883,
0.0052817911,
0.0027955233,
-0.0133638429,
0.0014576785,
-0.0195440054,
-0.0358934179,
0.0253728926,
-0.0059697032,
0.0002701143,
0.0232354756,
-0.004065718,
0.0101411445,
-0.0112581402,
-0.0006490961,
0.042800732,
0.0218755044,
0.0227692854,
-0.0035631259,
-0.0256097931,
-0.0367489494,
-0.0402850136,
-0.0843126103,
0.009052108,
0.02794623,
0.0074154837,
0.0130991265,
0.0017180003,
0.0095280372,
0.0115331616,
-0.0331438482,
0.0101791965,
0.0129196336,
0.0186679494,
0.03846661,
0.0484607592,
0.0005741214,
-0.0150315128,
-0.00341709,
-0.0514339134,
0.0279793572,
0.0252412409,
0.0397683568,
-0.0149712227,
-0.0208889507,
-0.0768435523,
0.0020802019,
-0.0142958406,
-0.0142275775,
0.0600754395,
-0.0339609198,
-0.0297853965,
0.0375007614,
-0.0220200922,
0.0193968192,
0.0675417855,
-0.0134106511,
-0.0358754471,
0.0059425174,
-0.0260908883,
0.0021548343,
-0.0268436894,
-0.0213555284,
-0.0080889296,
0.0924840719,
-0.0157900024,
-0.0169124771,
-0.0400851443,
0.0417856276,
-0.0072100703,
-0.0028503179,
0.0065959124,
0.0020278443,
0.0018258686,
0.0489955023,
-0.000200936,
0.003908019,
0.1054985076,
-0.0093644354,
0.0096582854,
-0.0824666023,
-0.0234360229,
-0.0631144419,
0.0161134098,
-0.0447379053,
0.0057062916,
0.0020854762,
0.0089946818,
-0.0069060777,
-0.0208578687,
0.0070823859,
-0.0543315187,
0.0573698692,
-0.0479933061,
0.0266380087,
0.0078373244,
-0.0101645254,
-0.0162841864,
0.0137942098,
-0.0644836128,
0.0423379131,
-0.0214640107,
0.0059320554,
-0.0806630701,
0.008751086,
0.0185902193,
0.0334529541,
0.0295039117,
-0.014372237,
-0.0113792745,
-0.0310919918,
0.0243475456,
0.0149343302,
0.0156710371,
-0.0209428184,
0.0736549199,
0.0844327509,
-0.0020440207,
-0.0137188798,
-0.024368776,
-0.0295167044,
0.0003152762,
-0.0216642749,
0.0228521749,
0.0022215308,
0.0238144305,
-0.055503875,
0.0137680313,
0.1070848331,
0.038513761,
-0.0823872387,
0.0164614115,
-0.0492943823,
-0.0017438856,
0.006282392,
0.0060569039,
-0.08417321,
-0.0324366279,
-0.0321116149,
0.0036908465,
-0.011156504,
-0.0615249723,
-0.0005234668,
-0.0543373451,
0.0551354624,
0.0078274515,
-0.0185415018,
0.0060751825,
-0.0500643663,
0.0114125703,
-0.0301030483,
-0.0115761869,
-0.009975872,
0.0108192023,
-0.0072689499,
0.0023982066,
-0.0325230546,
-0.0725967288,
0.06030019,
-0.0360470898,
0.0962338895,
0.0561438054,
0.050634373,
-0.012281809,
-0.0325467885,
-0.0211486686,
0.0276701991,
0.0111027723,
-0.0196614675,
0.0607528836,
0.0002791786,
0.0052952995,
-0.0369359218,
0.0188545231,
-0.0480000861,
-0.0388046466,
0.0118876239,
0.1152898297,
-0.050064642,
-0.0275786705,
-0.0385705754,
0.044360809,
0.0104036164,
0.0599917099,
-0.0085480446,
0.0100518856,
-0.0131154666,
0.0000407454,
0.0117354104,
-0.0020271998,
-0.0560304224,
0.0035551875,
0.0035281351,
0.0020304013,
-0.035231974,
-0.0250601768,
0.1062150821,
0.007218997,
0.0038328103,
0.0442162603,
0.0305676498,
0.0024494845,
-0.0385445878,
0.0334335454,
-0.0012838456,
0.0385722592,
-0.0296057109,
-0.0471248254,
0.0435156375,
-0.0090244748,
-0.0011622139,
-0.0130012212,
-0.0181338042,
-0.0431816578,
-0.0253044181,
0.0462345257,
0.0282455795,
-0.015146493,
-0.0290167127,
-0.0460317098,
0.0307984203,
0.0320504308,
-0.0473480932,
-0.0369217694,
-0.0031271882,
-0.0084111644,
0.008470065,
0.0210174695,
-0.01019058,
0.0163715798,
-0.0054682363,
0.0378447659,
-0.0503752157,
-0.0114256563,
0.0216199532,
-0.0039514685,
0.0061882935,
-0.0047104363,
-0.0118618915,
-0.0256298222,
0.0249423403,
-0.0377343148,
-0.0015080309,
-0.0216809008,
0.0062523563,
0.0034431745,
-0.054582525,
0.0536078773,
0.0002543912,
-0.0689058155,
-0.0194717143,
-0.0051966668,
0.0927253664,
0.0156913232,
-0.0126042766,
0.0547071658,
-0.001548316,
0.015104969,
-0.008083974,
-0.0343348086,
0.0307442378,
-0.0015266961,
0.0767134055,
0.0108565679,
-0.0036045148,
-0.0155045027,
0.0463207327,
-0.0705250651,
-0.0922502652,
0.0604133159,
0.0493039228,
0.026148038,
0.0447690412,
0.0093110288,
-0.049136281,
0.0258492883,
-0.0164314471,
-0.0057081715,
-0.029797256,
-0.0065797623,
0.0521662571,
0.0376721844,
0.0027894869,
-0.0342675187,
0.0909924656,
-0.0227170996,
0.05611917,
0.0037046683,
-0.0441268198,
-0.0344188586,
-0.0560772382,
0.0085998392,
0.0189436171,
-0.0787533671,
0.0183558222,
-0.0844796002,
-0.0330991782,
-0.0083617261,
-0.0112776002,
-0.055534143,
-0.0160851181,
0.012268912,
0.0290296413,
0.004361154,
-0.0103368424,
-0.0399617255,
0.0609201044,
-0.0415200479,
-0.0169955064,
0.0233542975,
-5.889658692e-33,
0.0104120011,
-0.0579574592,
0.0702386647,
-0.018932838,
0.0070571802,
0.0208287332,
-0.050752569,
0.0158801731,
-0.0178333893,
0.0650221705,
-0.0104826475,
0.0176348723,
-0.0057402649,
-0.0018247166,
0.0198523179,
-0.0283694733,
0.0080980668,
0.0225439891,
-0.0002293979,
0.0284054093,
0.0032699846,
0.0155880153,
0.0174016356,
-0.0814720243,
0.0238142442,
0.018235445,
0.0210419558,
0.0312814564,
-0.0596163385,
0.0739570111,
-0.0027494638,
0.0158477481,
0.0288452599,
-0.0247718338,
-0.0146437259,
-0.0167774782,
-0.0396383256,
-0.0011257116,
0.0185391009,
-0.0364587605,
-0.0360091701,
-0.0499887764,
0.0242003128,
0.0089550465,
-0.014329969,
-0.031548176,
0.01711189,
-0.0471541733,
-0.0168525856,
-0.0030617469,
-0.0304271858,
0.0376212746,
-0.0148294801,
-0.0147730922,
0.0118249767,
-0.0249137431,
-0.0196164884,
0.0337772667,
-0.0444476344,
0.0499122515,
0.0112597514,
-0.0037265515,
0.0308561753,
-0.0282357465,
-0.0049652639,
0.0682396814,
0.010667487,
0.0207864083,
-0.0551981181,
-0.0039720722,
-0.0353855528,
0.0769641623,
0.0618206486,
0.0302116144,
-0.0017776005,
0.0064744856,
-0.0870130286,
0.0224043634,
-0.0298946109,
0.0644612983,
0.0388130732,
0.0120764272,
-0.0247696079,
-0.0148205142,
-0.0204502363,
0.0411027931,
-0.0339328498,
-0.0579337403,
-0.006271617,
-0.0208319016,
-0.0100836568,
0.0328424647,
0.0148458946,
-0.0338799618,
-0.002587962,
-0.0001406292,
0.0495810397,
-0.0096909758,
-0.0284199975,
0.0020052933,
-0.0792507976,
0.0138489697,
0.0151916817,
-0.0193439517,
0.0406011492,
0.0421422087,
0.0131667079,
-0.0114261182,
-0.0153395403,
-0.0205564816,
-0.0241785273,
0.0005389421,
-0.0008220695,
0.0283197798,
-0.0016555013,
0.0410493091,
0.0015787231,
0.0317173339,
0.0062281913,
-0.0207973141,
-0.0266808979,
0.0218343139,
-0.0225769933,
-0.0314866193,
-0.0703742132,
-0.0293974821,
-0.0657359585,
0.0258470476,
0.0581652895,
-0.0173317492,
-0.0183660723,
-0.0397568978,
2.74e-7,
0.0821001604,
0.0595977753,
-0.0204175767,
-0.0238358397,
0.0406417884,
0.0325963832,
-0.0465339385,
0.0035201809,
0.0015739808,
-0.011593163,
0.0349261574,
0.0484578982,
0.020122556,
0.0756390318,
-0.0598545484,
-0.0304002184,
-0.0349186473,
-0.041379258,
-0.048157081,
-0.039490521,
0.0302917194,
0.0297811124,
0.0049284771,
-0.0193442181,
0.0147815049,
-0.0302516036,
0.0245809928,
-0.0344034769,
0.0074045048,
0.0599232316,
0.0075591798,
-0.0287564863,
0.0217589922,
0.0428882986,
0.0122740455,
-0.0134424567,
-0.0346692912,
0.07610064,
-0.0581536591,
0.0014491176,
0.0225932095,
-0.0363738984,
0.0332311839,
-0.0300708637,
0.0403945185,
-0.0691238269,
-0.0826429203,
-0.0178163704,
0.0023308885,
-0.0142241372,
0.0416741073,
-0.0177880172,
-0.0094574587,
0.0082275113,
0.0034957607,
0.0057261162,
-0.0087721935,
-0.0708831474,
-0.0106820967,
0.0069742533,
-0.0530005433,
-0.0516102724,
0.0362658165,
-0.0326220728,
-0.0041510845,
-0.0696486235,
0.0381532684,
2.298768283e-34,
0.0203864966,
0.0346707217,
-0.0168970674,
0.0565579012,
0.0661913007,
-0.0010008848,
-0.009819543,
0.0045562433,
0.039730072,
-0.0642881691,
-0.0140002519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09816v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09816v1 | Performance Trade-offs of Watermarking Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T11:44:58 | 2023-11-16T11:44:58 | Anirudh Ajith, Sameer Singh, Danish Pruthi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG | Amidst growing concerns of large language models (LLMs) being misused for
generating misinformation or completing homework assignments, watermarking has
emerged as an effective solution for distinguishing human-written and
LLM-generated text. A prominent watermarking strategy is to embed a signal into
generated text by upsampling a (pseudorandomly-chosen) subset of tokens at
every generation step. Although this signal is imperceptible to a human reader,
it is detectable through statistical testing. However, implanting such signals
alters the model's output distribution and can have unintended effects when
watermarked LLMs are used for downstream applications. In this work, we
evaluate the performance of watermarked LLMs on a diverse suite of tasks,
including text classification, textual entailment, reasoning, question
answering, translation, summarization, and language modeling. We find that
watermarking has negligible impact on the performance of tasks posed as k-class
classification problems in the average case. However, the accuracy can plummet
to that of a random classifier for some scenarios (that occur with
non-negligible probability). Tasks that are cast as multiple-choice questions
and short-form generation are surprisingly unaffected by watermarking. For
long-form generation tasks, including summarization and translation, we see a
drop of 15-20% in the performance due to watermarking. Our findings highlight
the trade-offs that users should be cognizant of when using watermarked models,
and point to cases where future research could improve existing trade-offs. | [
0.0257288236,
0.0455476381,
-0.0258607995,
0.0229553077,
-0.0363963693,
-0.0015220102,
0.0510761812,
0.040577691,
0.0206228327,
-0.0828547031,
0.0064825211,
-0.0048269238,
0.0138360336,
0.0092876479,
0.0498375669,
-0.0508315004,
0.0490168147,
-0.0428473353,
0.0006370321,
0.0016147224,
-0.0141802765,
-0.0017176106,
0.0506546609,
0.0373803042,
-0.0006652412,
-0.0170515645,
-0.0086334413,
0.0048458618,
-0.004471763,
0.009604889,
-0.0145431198,
0.0833131596,
0.0082799522,
0.088662833,
0.0000021885,
-0.0319260024,
-0.0018788156,
0.0082012154,
-0.0535485446,
0.0789957866,
0.0572193712,
0.0090199746,
0.0012563315,
0.0319603011,
-0.0298913401,
0.0521437265,
0.0262692031,
0.04346551,
0.0681730732,
0.0376445949,
0.0005030127,
0.0227392651,
0.0504182056,
0.0082517946,
0.04535098,
-0.0063429149,
0.0143935028,
0.0116884317,
-0.0077602579,
0.0285064913,
0.0206957497,
0.0801692083,
0.0185414366,
-0.0383353494,
-0.0108095575,
0.0292942412,
-0.0301615074,
-0.0040607858,
0.0190369189,
0.0261534583,
-0.0593170635,
-0.0334351994,
0.0064855893,
-0.018227851,
0.0243375935,
0.0434084758,
-0.0301521495,
0.0361663401,
0.0011289561,
0.0038910201,
0.006966034,
-0.0367195532,
0.0423466042,
0.0234283358,
0.0115129342,
0.0458179936,
0.0223694816,
-0.0113762142,
-0.0478597954,
0.009828452,
-0.0357642137,
-0.0903031603,
0.0474909656,
0.0166780781,
0.0194043182,
0.0030423666,
-0.123109363,
-0.0746387839,
0.0223442987,
-0.0521823019,
0.0501041934,
0.0213094521,
0.0211871266,
0.0341000408,
-0.0477077551,
0.055690717,
-0.0230685361,
0.0580725595,
-0.0177274719,
0.0176428929,
0.0000872069,
-0.0703930557,
-0.0366995819,
0.0400091633,
-0.0527732708,
-0.0250322986,
-0.0436215177,
0.0366159119,
0.0182737932,
0.0043961867,
-0.0257083755,
-0.010574826,
-0.0133781899,
-0.0004925739,
0.0103707984,
-0.0207462776,
0.0123246266,
0.0261426661,
0.0232842118,
-0.0494916216,
0.002511275,
0.0155373076,
0.0098864576,
0.0099155689,
-0.0027052085,
0.0670818985,
-0.0005139815,
-0.0345540009,
-0.0065793442,
-0.062692672,
-0.016652558,
-0.0167478342,
-0.0061997054,
-0.0667224973,
-0.0149010113,
0.0077826269,
-0.0074143661,
-0.0446286276,
0.0232631229,
0.0466736145,
-0.0134441424,
0.0444397517,
-0.0148124732,
0.0037246631,
0.0400517322,
0.015222501,
-0.0111819962,
0.0659557357,
0.0629319921,
0.0256287269,
0.0606052279,
-0.0339873992,
0.0187437776,
0.044948414,
0.0157677997,
0.0085241413,
-0.016936129,
-0.0520406738,
0.0418536924,
-0.0036938868,
0.0049563781,
0.0413813666,
-0.0028873482,
-0.011679031,
0.0935066566,
0.0666782707,
-0.0414689146,
-0.0198838077,
-0.0072976467,
0.0233176369,
0.0315389298,
0.0217823442,
-0.0283486396,
-0.0080979802,
-0.0466910079,
0.0018896748,
0.0300167631,
-0.0026496723,
-0.0054948148,
-0.0544197336,
-0.0365477316,
-0.0133019518,
0.0143046854,
0.0272067375,
0.0257427171,
0.0188543312,
-0.0262050722,
0.0502189733,
-0.0018479301,
-0.0577079058,
0.0498248599,
-0.0868686363,
0.0401641056,
0.0848654509,
0.0543839484,
-0.0158355851,
0.0716181993,
-0.0135022178,
-0.0008853564,
0.0567593873,
-0.0052001113,
-0.0023345395,
-0.0084584272,
-0.0290481616,
-0.0288645774,
-0.0225822683,
0.0130227748,
0.0057160184,
0.0179165006,
0.0280579012,
0.0425246134,
-0.0549222566,
-0.0510071777,
0.0389673524,
0.0005650651,
-0.0464668013,
0.0077211917,
-0.0066038542,
-0.0020595989,
0.0094825616,
0.0015491698,
0.0396419279,
0.0230726432,
-0.0456118658,
-0.0300553162,
-0.0510163493,
-0.0220420994,
-0.0053450624,
0.0260919239,
-0.0189570524,
-0.0098266331,
0.0373570882,
-0.0150034474,
-0.0258805752,
-0.0065196012,
-0.0705418959,
0.0260259081,
-0.0386183299,
0.0328727141,
-0.0164638907,
0.0153736901,
-0.0376604572,
0.0502132103,
0.0186717547,
0.0197473802,
0.016015783,
-0.0002512208,
-0.0127737587,
-0.0206732638,
-0.0132481046,
-0.0063471356,
-0.0227645617,
0.0110722706,
0.0256722048,
-0.01845905,
-0.0371942557,
-0.0139939422,
-0.0548188537,
0.0042761615,
-0.0097880578,
0.0347190686,
0.0203718375,
-0.0083141914,
0.0004106906,
-0.004780632,
-0.0474262685,
-0.0710998476,
0.0312484726,
0.0341096334,
0.0134282615,
-0.0362890065,
0.0051388033,
0.0027772272,
-0.0248917192,
-0.0028446512,
0.0597704947,
0.0136386314,
-0.0276701618,
-0.0688474849,
0.0546099395,
-0.0133531643,
-0.0276908912,
0.0225999355,
-0.0071085738,
-0.0043801423,
0.0123881279,
0.0292374492,
0.0841237009,
0.0185790248,
-0.003391556,
0.0530288815,
0.0309375767,
-0.0462427139,
-0.0181348417,
-0.0128931124,
-0.0039410293,
-0.0114648417,
-0.0529641472,
0.0164538268,
0.0357706174,
0.0149667338,
-0.0023174759,
-0.0168843418,
0.063911505,
-0.0421822853,
-0.0105874874,
-0.0550991483,
-0.0425643846,
-0.0370181762,
0.0426151194,
-0.0141315693,
-0.0578192882,
0.0327978395,
-0.0356349461,
0.0219847076,
-0.0176006202,
-0.016053807,
0.0197488293,
0.0325883292,
0.0008411703,
0.023573434,
0.0149823455,
-0.0199825112,
-0.0372504033,
-0.0189587753,
0.0344424434,
-0.0738443434,
0.0025249859,
-0.040962033,
-0.0213848017,
-0.0243546776,
-0.0132285785,
-0.0483112074,
-0.0586315878,
-0.0010294988,
0.0095378365,
0.0158967506,
0.0047794939,
-0.0017915402,
-0.0121894414,
0.0451366156,
0.022530552,
-0.052711457,
-0.0080986675,
-0.0380260274,
0.0987977311,
0.0368618369,
-0.0531253666,
0.0186650511,
-0.0384892076,
0.0070319558,
0.0721997768,
0.0342394263,
0.0204608664,
0.0398175232,
-0.0181616861,
0.025772078,
-0.0053181467,
-0.0432172157,
0.0302097909,
0.0581645034,
-0.0881423876,
0.0053512161,
0.080536969,
0.0409733877,
0.0042402837,
-0.0040149894,
0.002923724,
0.0409177579,
0.022780098,
0.0026540693,
-0.0644201338,
-0.0232283231,
0.0479615331,
0.0485583059,
-0.0381984301,
0.0043797926,
-0.0129757114,
-0.0953541845,
0.0259257741,
0.0156093957,
-0.0261222757,
0.0080651576,
-0.0736709684,
-0.0398540422,
0.0441783816,
0.0280528795,
-0.0339454673,
0.0226420183,
-0.0002205504,
0.0466475785,
-0.0307482276,
-0.0503418967,
-0.0082407985,
0.0040871077,
-0.0153368507,
0.0435449369,
0.031350553,
-0.0236146301,
-0.0677662194,
0.0613325424,
-0.0112875625,
0.0028500059,
0.0030743903,
0.0569324121,
0.0106310109,
-0.0110268705,
-0.0492208265,
0.0290050115,
-0.0045929262,
-0.0253921393,
0.0073719569,
0.0720759779,
0.0013848296,
-0.0275450237,
-0.0289084762,
-0.0392865613,
0.012082452,
0.0610744357,
0.0431539342,
-0.0629034638,
-0.0227086134,
-0.0582566224,
0.0345532224,
-0.0498524271,
-0.0326515436,
0.0199099313,
-0.0277061872,
-0.0405026004,
-0.0616706684,
-0.031287238,
0.0031745727,
0.0089519722,
0.0344362371,
0.0441792682,
0.0130344583,
-0.0230679996,
-0.043998681,
0.014322903,
-0.0782815143,
0.0343853533,
-0.0266787373,
-0.0059974086,
-0.0310762208,
-0.0292202607,
-0.0287192669,
0.0231489148,
-0.0996759534,
-0.0868639871,
0.0146779008,
0.0372756422,
0.0254009329,
-0.0009022768,
0.0072750845,
-0.049073033,
0.0673291981,
0.0486173555,
-0.0266437661,
0.0218098667,
0.0158166941,
-0.0377018861,
-0.0083551779,
0.0185318142,
-0.0570311621,
-0.006288487,
0.0393954106,
-0.0070410925,
-0.0495249033,
-0.0143160289,
0.0049181939,
0.0613959022,
0.0377842188,
-0.0200738739,
-0.0021248828,
0.0121924225,
0.0129340701,
-0.0393656529,
-0.0361886546,
-0.0097907688,
0.0055828881,
0.015026289,
-0.0223292634,
0.008369376,
0.0311717466,
-0.0104692513,
0.0101635484,
-0.0083915172,
0.0109812422,
-0.0269415248,
0.0338882357,
0.0252331048,
0.003584709,
-0.0343984812,
0.0313153528,
0.0013582089,
0.0308727026,
-0.0077148243,
0.0083656171,
0.0004323644,
0.0077078715,
-0.0070151645,
0.0246244818,
-0.0857984498,
-0.0261435341,
-0.022615673,
0.0300704613,
0.0005763312,
0.0051569249,
0.0144417761,
-0.0450139716,
-0.0314319357,
-0.0375087149,
0.0315677114,
0.0279703159,
-0.0605344623,
0.0073838793,
-0.0063049118,
-0.0389005691,
-0.0070822872,
0.0573497266,
0.0129611967,
0.0379424021,
-0.0023664013,
-0.0518773533,
-0.0205733925,
-0.0016379915,
0.0303305089,
0.0231520627,
-0.022448102,
-0.0140603287,
-0.0632971823,
-0.07101053,
-0.007731664,
0.0098311016,
0.0233653933,
-0.0331020914,
-0.0039133951,
0.0446332581,
-0.0117375655,
-0.0171424206,
-0.0474700518,
0.0438842997,
-0.0181845669,
-0.0023221711,
0.0176181626,
-6.023584233e-33,
-0.024508303,
-0.0704655722,
-0.0315273814,
-0.0005701625,
0.0239530317,
0.0574257821,
-0.0275746956,
0.0075951121,
0.0245222002,
-0.0033483484,
-0.016649371,
-0.0064454144,
0.0116502158,
0.0320000388,
-0.0060839765,
0.0075428952,
0.0647295937,
-0.0186489243,
-0.040711116,
0.0304576065,
0.0743026212,
-0.0244954154,
0.015987305,
-0.0394949913,
0.0222703051,
-0.0381695665,
-0.0303980075,
-0.0382052734,
-0.0507647581,
0.0495125502,
-0.028519664,
0.0495789647,
-0.0098083578,
-0.0185685176,
-0.0338179246,
0.0502436794,
-0.0358143374,
-0.0126808221,
-0.0079574231,
0.0296918899,
-0.0259797405,
-0.0932726115,
0.0527172685,
-0.01429033,
-0.0343248397,
-0.0002256142,
0.0311618857,
-0.0155442236,
-0.0500972643,
-0.0384787098,
-0.039564494,
0.010039134,
-0.005782336,
-0.0049266396,
0.0177340731,
0.0458410718,
0.0243866015,
0.0051064217,
-0.0687048063,
0.0296477191,
0.0465195403,
0.0227286667,
0.074234888,
0.0227547958,
0.0058677332,
0.0405525751,
0.0122731756,
0.0124939531,
0.0018998679,
-0.0209879018,
0.0389402881,
-0.0051233727,
0.091471076,
0.0439128354,
0.0843007192,
-0.033457391,
-0.0351781845,
0.0344894454,
-0.0373673476,
-0.0375343375,
0.0652510524,
-0.008058751,
-0.0359268934,
-0.030878773,
-0.0656288937,
-0.0337917842,
-0.0192285739,
-0.0107769119,
0.0443388522,
0.008104845,
-0.0294373445,
-0.0403017588,
0.0225737039,
-0.0359832048,
-0.0418259837,
-0.0083379783,
-0.0016119049,
0.0218237042,
-0.0148784239,
0.0051551834,
0.0044082412,
0.0231882073,
0.0397531316,
-0.0308315754,
0.0239935871,
0.0194148626,
0.0594680607,
-0.0026406697,
-0.0876313671,
0.0183926728,
-0.0234071296,
0.0261251796,
0.0378799662,
0.0039413581,
0.0563556552,
-0.0250240751,
0.0152881686,
-0.0071281986,
0.0015440146,
-0.0147681646,
-0.0378508233,
-0.0169929434,
-0.0211553704,
0.0330523588,
-0.0255992841,
0.0031157061,
-0.0458091721,
0.0717040077,
0.0515628532,
-0.0380382873,
-0.0168738011,
-0.0019434919,
2.732e-7,
0.0343032293,
0.0457068756,
0.011001952,
0.0081649777,
0.0086884033,
0.0625723526,
0.0150451465,
-0.0008282373,
0.0195514187,
0.0091522373,
-0.0434655473,
-0.0066769575,
0.0756626651,
0.0275102556,
-0.0794176981,
-0.0015909764,
-0.0409278125,
0.026588425,
-0.0590182729,
0.0118592083,
0.0715697333,
0.0953656808,
0.0110135591,
-0.0463286005,
0.0039883931,
-0.0650833249,
0.0677751675,
-0.0215053279,
-0.0070244768,
-0.016162388,
0.0228828695,
0.0104648806,
0.0401474796,
0.0489498563,
-0.0516911335,
-0.0432363302,
0.0345752984,
0.0426084846,
-0.0128167439,
0.0150855705,
-0.0530506596,
-0.0255992692,
-0.0000194878,
-0.0780984089,
0.0698947757,
0.0315726325,
-0.0050588157,
-0.0628994405,
-0.0288382359,
-0.0657883286,
0.0469254889,
-0.0203248262,
-0.0055478271,
0.0032859058,
-0.0108821699,
0.0209264848,
-0.0005057699,
-0.0379151292,
-0.0471341573,
-0.0387618318,
-0.024470374,
-0.0466248803,
-0.0664673969,
0.0152485166,
0.0457118563,
-0.0647463202,
0.0028811235,
2.877886596e-34,
0.0012094456,
-0.0301894285,
0.0232265294,
0.0182562191,
0.043216221,
0.0114140045,
0.0296528097,
-0.0036886043,
0.0262655485,
-0.0717099681,
-0.0068006772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09812v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09812v2 | Large Language Models for Propaganda Span Annotation | 2023-11-16T11:37:54 | 2024-01-14T06:32:09 | Maram Hasanain, Fatema Ahmed, Firoj Alam | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, F.2.2; I.2.7 | The use of propagandistic techniques in online contents has increased in
recent years aiming to manipulate online audiences. Efforts to automatically
detect and debunk such content have been made addressing various modeling
scenarios. These include determining whether the content (text, image, or
multimodal) (i) is propagandistic, (ii) employs one or more propagandistic
techniques, and (iii) includes techniques with identifiable spans. Significant
research efforts have been devoted to the first two scenarios compared to the
latter. Therefore, in this study, we focus on the task of detecting
propagandistic textual spans. Specifically, we investigate whether large
language models (LLMs), such as GPT-4, can effectively perform the task.
Moreover, we study the potential of employing the model to collect more
cost-effective annotations. Our experiments use a large-scale in-house dataset
consisting of annotations from human annotators with varying expertise levels.
The results suggest that providing more information to the model as prompts
improves its performance compared to human annotations. Moreover, our work is
the first to show the potential of utilizing LLMs to develop annotated datasets
for this specific task, prompting it with annotations from human annotators
with limited expertise. We plan to make the collected span-level labels from
multiple annotators, including GPT-4, available for the community. | [
0.066136159,
0.0135080582,
-0.0253202803,
0.0274365898,
-0.034576267,
0.0022480048,
0.0359208956,
0.0005075166,
0.0224314425,
-0.0368504897,
0.0155184995,
-0.0390171595,
-0.0085908873,
0.0085438322,
0.0474598631,
-0.0639106929,
0.0215884503,
0.014612468,
0.0673520491,
-0.0145277167,
0.0401019827,
0.0217328351,
-0.0036447165,
0.0261045117,
-0.0364346169,
-0.0242526755,
0.0339727663,
0.0062352801,
0.0389779247,
-0.0255596731,
0.0100418255,
0.0642108768,
0.0449749827,
0.0715837255,
0.0000016556,
0.0019656448,
-0.0099195438,
0.0121284658,
-0.0206746049,
0.0374156609,
0.0884588659,
-0.0194878615,
-0.0024520617,
0.024213532,
-0.0384454913,
0.0230843555,
0.043794103,
0.0203519352,
0.113169983,
0.0849871039,
-0.0034921237,
-0.0090823947,
0.0074946494,
-0.0191831533,
0.0077267364,
-0.0374357998,
0.0479817763,
-0.009354949,
-0.0144148236,
0.0651310459,
0.0087036248,
0.0360733531,
0.0032459924,
-0.0251067746,
-0.0263066925,
-0.022890484,
-0.041866295,
-0.030335186,
0.0010036555,
0.0372769162,
-0.0047120498,
-0.0396203101,
0.0365207531,
-0.0009458121,
0.0121582346,
0.0495592169,
-0.0277045704,
0.0487080403,
-0.0136204055,
0.01793232,
-0.0082392646,
-0.0326027796,
0.0505909473,
0.0320637003,
0.0319140591,
0.0340927355,
-0.0131970877,
-0.0304205604,
0.0287442524,
-0.008488656,
-0.0346839428,
-0.0387356542,
0.0176083669,
-0.0179884657,
0.0207099803,
0.0224027298,
-0.0463385396,
-0.0567664392,
0.0342802815,
-0.0848314986,
-0.0123625249,
-0.0047026556,
-0.0286578108,
0.0458072312,
-0.009262694,
0.0051782518,
-0.0438533537,
0.0088774366,
0.0122424103,
0.0106726512,
-0.020286005,
-0.0048562158,
-0.0290713329,
-0.0078161275,
-0.0067023439,
0.0201261882,
-0.0629200414,
0.0066645504,
-0.044142548,
0.0373426974,
-0.0338244252,
-0.0172825065,
-0.0064907102,
-0.012538271,
0.0017598642,
0.0787696168,
-0.0337180644,
0.0183659121,
-0.0031890576,
-0.0611530021,
-0.0022712171,
0.0659198761,
-0.0086506885,
-0.0274395086,
0.0077601708,
0.009288853,
0.0220071003,
-0.003016684,
-0.0315390974,
-0.0638589561,
-0.0367717482,
-0.03968044,
0.0155328782,
-0.0694349408,
0.0051872875,
0.0054847728,
-0.0136127714,
-0.0386873186,
-0.0040811435,
0.0339266658,
-0.0438010357,
0.0765741095,
0.0215610676,
0.0048975609,
0.0603841394,
0.0233252924,
0.0009057351,
0.0738743916,
-0.0218081307,
0.1121103764,
0.0560270734,
0.0095294919,
0.0336426347,
0.0570342429,
0.0395534337,
0.0347809419,
0.0059272964,
-0.0181355458,
-0.003104714,
-0.0181149617,
-0.0111012682,
0.0543777347,
-0.0306659993,
-0.0391532704,
0.0843272135,
0.0097148446,
-0.0468895659,
-0.0238791164,
0.0542833954,
0.0200349875,
0.0008430688,
0.0172066726,
-0.0466572158,
-0.000173451,
-0.0185662676,
-0.0656655207,
0.0385569185,
0.0269229524,
-0.0261568502,
0.003147848,
-0.0124072358,
-0.0103677372,
0.0261513721,
-0.0099452073,
0.0253951941,
0.0041772104,
-0.0282992851,
0.0447713993,
0.0472333133,
0.0001659889,
0.0389261916,
-0.0393531248,
0.0022379216,
0.0419559181,
0.0271268729,
-0.0208707955,
0.0441601388,
-0.0573101416,
0.0748164803,
0.0422740877,
0.0546919107,
-0.0390899293,
-0.0888759643,
0.000246779,
-0.0163687523,
-0.0352334119,
0.0199930742,
0.0395981073,
0.0447588749,
-0.0207350403,
-0.0016259474,
-0.036194846,
-0.0439764746,
0.0157591086,
0.0383220278,
-0.0089019984,
-0.0544234738,
0.0167769622,
0.0484870784,
0.0380329415,
-0.0207504872,
-0.0374761149,
0.0400158353,
-0.0057332069,
-0.043229267,
-0.0313643403,
0.0204147138,
0.0165732559,
0.0298194904,
-0.0556706712,
-0.0635928139,
0.0200968441,
-0.0262956042,
0.021464631,
0.0388794579,
-0.0538473092,
0.0115039013,
-0.057863377,
-0.0231234003,
-0.0323076621,
-0.0068671028,
-0.0131812785,
0.059220992,
-0.0229290854,
-0.0084041776,
0.0146942018,
-0.019129822,
-0.0022815927,
-0.0048579639,
-0.0276826508,
-0.0315042287,
0.0203783084,
0.005044539,
0.0362236835,
-0.0368597768,
-0.0125981085,
-0.0349722207,
-0.071161367,
-0.0482074581,
-0.0261660274,
0.004327633,
0.045224499,
-0.010652747,
0.020884579,
0.014798726,
-0.0515298396,
-0.0182044562,
-0.001819844,
0.0626712218,
0.0118653448,
0.0059014312,
-0.0036483966,
0.0004301869,
0.0149971992,
-0.0309686828,
0.0231837314,
0.0632428452,
-0.0817016065,
-0.0127653424,
-0.0324060731,
-0.0378444456,
0.02301828,
-0.0487924032,
-0.0446225293,
0.0017280474,
-0.000040714,
-0.0234373566,
0.0270646028,
0.0256784074,
0.0552717373,
0.0409106649,
0.0619695485,
-0.0292624049,
-0.0321986973,
-0.0442833938,
-0.0042893342,
-0.0568319,
-0.0683649182,
0.0035476428,
0.0173734203,
0.0325633511,
0.0193223394,
-0.047357861,
0.0058862278,
-0.0358284526,
-0.0246880502,
0.0120175881,
-0.0414080136,
-0.0186998304,
0.0208170544,
-0.034407042,
-0.0443254933,
0.0712018982,
-0.0230063796,
0.0178525224,
0.0161464754,
-0.0181066114,
0.001510656,
0.0096018277,
0.0272787828,
0.0504411384,
-0.0264880676,
-0.010744472,
-0.0022743731,
0.0165560078,
0.0741919056,
-0.0180653147,
0.0013788014,
-0.0145229697,
0.032269679,
0.0255744066,
-0.0127175795,
-0.0534824841,
-0.1163719296,
-0.0114191743,
-0.0302908998,
0.0090341698,
-0.0117466114,
-0.0507298484,
0.0188344475,
0.0533835851,
0.0194150768,
0.0003486822,
0.0317650735,
-0.0077108685,
0.0328558236,
0.0226458982,
-0.0288540404,
0.0124661634,
-0.0391073748,
-0.0272350516,
0.048413977,
-0.0315962471,
0.0175570324,
-0.0118855396,
-0.0309951175,
-0.0174496844,
-0.0140342256,
-0.0015198598,
0.0037218588,
0.0397058874,
-0.0364418216,
0.0379279219,
0.0821768641,
0.0199394338,
-0.0435866974,
-0.0325909965,
0.0362180918,
0.0002598749,
0.0256063454,
-0.0120072505,
-0.1195044816,
0.0078019062,
-0.0167776812,
0.0204772688,
-0.0425669178,
-0.0241476037,
-0.009233864,
-0.112685211,
0.0143548641,
0.000217069,
-0.0098954765,
0.0134080118,
-0.0880409479,
-0.0064058248,
0.0025156508,
-0.0099788839,
-0.0194174536,
0.0392287783,
-0.0082550794,
0.0043521961,
-0.0197371449,
-0.0564317256,
-0.0130296461,
-0.0234995075,
0.0638964847,
0.0573052764,
0.0310498178,
-0.0351725705,
-0.0287440848,
0.0568255149,
0.0156636536,
-0.0406995229,
-0.0120810736,
0.1137312725,
-0.0206524059,
-0.0180495959,
0.0008704567,
0.0474290438,
0.0246118642,
0.018750269,
0.00029272,
0.0672995895,
0.0403621532,
-0.0403740034,
0.0011954483,
0.0171655808,
0.0474188738,
0.0736001655,
0.015701944,
-0.0303438641,
-0.0030743927,
-0.041412808,
-0.0048056715,
-0.0119345691,
-0.0616422184,
0.0202903282,
-0.0151886139,
-0.0302093904,
-0.0523028858,
-0.0158475954,
0.014387412,
0.013880536,
0.0242684074,
0.0142432805,
0.0027643219,
0.0190483462,
-0.0082437936,
0.0068862638,
-0.0288592651,
0.0498853661,
-0.0265329834,
-0.0290811546,
-0.0236113444,
-0.0324371308,
-0.0195517931,
0.0418341532,
-0.0720029771,
-0.0787339956,
0.0139032956,
0.0272857118,
0.0255261492,
0.0339961573,
-0.0267504957,
-0.0532028526,
0.0611520074,
0.0223374702,
-0.0219550394,
0.0212344807,
0.0017553999,
0.0125712929,
0.0097492663,
0.034741506,
-0.016942421,
0.0314610787,
0.0302552879,
-0.0476899706,
-0.0740004107,
0.0096685542,
0.0331354775,
0.0333132111,
0.0359496251,
-0.0374807194,
-0.0097442586,
-0.0341752768,
-0.0395372622,
-0.0271999091,
-0.044930961,
0.0186783765,
0.013144468,
0.014100831,
-0.0329487734,
0.0177126415,
0.0293383505,
-0.0386380628,
0.027938189,
-0.0399757624,
-0.0025751367,
0.0091757812,
0.0290674847,
0.0107909478,
0.0078983828,
-0.0079972818,
0.0223252364,
0.0146568604,
0.025959827,
0.0120012444,
0.0048740576,
0.0211160462,
-0.0234389454,
0.0595114939,
-0.0057052551,
-0.0275918804,
-0.0074362266,
-0.0243287999,
0.0308333039,
0.0191580877,
0.0136879347,
0.0568067171,
-0.0082748588,
-0.0472728461,
-0.0075468649,
-0.0351237692,
0.004308633,
-0.0334693193,
0.0193273481,
0.0195650049,
-0.0414363518,
0.0338216498,
0.0343694203,
-0.0000778865,
0.0395193882,
0.0302196685,
-0.0744633824,
-0.0325626135,
-0.0347013585,
-0.0380630717,
0.0494669303,
-0.0042729573,
0.0136182476,
-0.0612794422,
-0.0520772897,
-0.025564611,
-0.0039343028,
-0.0045150039,
-0.0024480575,
0.0025561471,
0.055362992,
-0.012148004,
0.0403718799,
-0.0469737463,
0.0118344631,
-0.0110832984,
-0.0304384232,
0.0146408016,
-6.160332796e-33,
0.0007920995,
-0.0771207362,
-0.0288740937,
0.0197867304,
-0.0002825726,
0.0220928434,
0.0155685302,
0.0019201137,
-0.0144283473,
0.017022606,
0.0387115702,
0.0183700547,
-0.0011676436,
-0.0041848361,
-0.0383909494,
-0.0046078078,
0.0617410913,
-0.0134227611,
-0.0570035242,
0.034853667,
0.0532427244,
-0.0445473678,
0.0036107318,
-0.0761923492,
0.0805423707,
-0.0138372956,
-0.0528393537,
0.0095622633,
0.0173571035,
0.0502967499,
-0.0001860687,
0.0370955132,
0.0422100052,
-0.0295117255,
0.0203317367,
0.0619849451,
-0.0400404595,
0.0161119588,
0.0521289259,
-0.0061492659,
-0.0212462544,
-0.0063750618,
0.0384370796,
-0.0350722671,
-0.0123888431,
0.0209714677,
0.0486228503,
-0.0268969946,
0.0333733037,
0.0188987572,
-0.0260685943,
0.0103125246,
-0.0172899459,
0.0151684415,
-0.0114776259,
0.0537440553,
0.0494917259,
0.0757483616,
-0.0709494129,
0.0396379828,
-0.008836112,
0.0124918446,
0.0375364833,
-0.0382604748,
0.0020611368,
0.061572317,
0.0022020075,
0.0351552963,
-0.0350762345,
-0.01476367,
-0.0282740891,
0.015268011,
0.0773134157,
0.0884393826,
-0.0037533401,
-0.0217780266,
-0.0882195979,
0.0218370296,
0.0570546165,
-0.0163249802,
0.0179290082,
-0.0344894379,
-0.0228324048,
-0.0044274246,
-0.0471049473,
-0.067542769,
-0.0458947942,
-0.0420884788,
-0.0029298651,
0.0359822325,
-0.0463565066,
0.0609087236,
0.0179623179,
-0.0292515755,
-0.0075921966,
0.0214216579,
-0.0301854424,
0.0300180502,
0.0210777819,
0.0425246991,
-0.037605118,
0.0226702597,
0.0171056278,
-0.0209421441,
0.0058247726,
-0.0226770658,
0.070588246,
0.0174623467,
-0.0645173788,
0.0191080514,
-0.0248225275,
0.0266297664,
-0.0440592393,
-0.0097319987,
0.0553704686,
0.0020037845,
-0.0217201244,
-0.0214078855,
0.0327379107,
0.028964499,
0.0059399698,
-0.0237104353,
-0.0276431423,
-0.0101063885,
-0.0275028795,
-0.0071060616,
-0.0051313899,
0.0376083255,
0.0031269747,
-0.0968519747,
0.0145653812,
-0.0415324457,
2.491e-7,
0.0188482273,
0.0623537041,
0.0075274273,
0.0086807441,
0.0664678887,
0.0109491553,
0.010852552,
-0.0118001616,
-0.0315192305,
-0.1150003225,
-0.0180681143,
0.0176500566,
0.0190636721,
0.041124247,
-0.0389272831,
0.0239347257,
-0.0308575369,
-0.0040367437,
-0.0623076335,
0.0095595233,
0.0025268276,
0.0614805184,
0.0573364161,
-0.0162799209,
-0.0081742657,
-0.0379381031,
0.0771937966,
0.0161001142,
-0.0489244014,
0.0200613271,
0.0210806914,
0.0076032486,
-0.0044771624,
0.0283494219,
-0.0110114925,
-0.0020310692,
0.0000125462,
0.0621394329,
0.0343485586,
-0.024016697,
-0.0314602777,
-0.0294077527,
0.0038216456,
-0.0507007949,
0.0613093451,
-0.0000843605,
-0.0325495489,
-0.0157898646,
-0.0371323489,
-0.0343233496,
0.0034062981,
-0.0095994016,
-0.011102207,
0.0032985366,
-0.014368373,
0.0082316846,
0.0025557932,
-0.0683761463,
0.005341006,
-0.015052231,
-0.0723645464,
-0.0757929832,
-0.0130446143,
-0.0098574804,
0.0120623792,
-0.0322240107,
0.0464947857,
2.085217235e-34,
0.0584401488,
-0.038465146,
0.0125877066,
-0.0631553531,
0.0309772287,
0.0299250782,
-0.0624007918,
-0.0249900427,
0.0380449407,
-0.0581672639,
-0.0018895509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09808v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09808v3 | PixT3: Pixel-based Table-To-Text Generation | 2023-11-16T11:32:47 | 2024-06-03T17:43:23 | Iñigo Alonso, Eneko Agirre, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table-to-text generation involves generating appropriate textual descriptions
given structured tabular data. It has attracted increasing attention in recent
years thanks to the popularity of neural network models and the availability of
large-scale datasets. A common feature across existing methods is their
treatment of the input as a string, i.e., by employing linearization techniques
that do not always preserve information in the table, are verbose, and lack
space efficiency. We propose to rethink data-to-text generation as a visual
recognition task, removing the need for rendering the input in a string format.
We present PixT3, a multimodal table-to-text model that overcomes the
challenges of linearization and input size limitations encountered by existing
models. PixT3 is trained with a new self-supervised learning objective to
reinforce table structure awareness and is applicable to open-ended and
controlled generation settings. Experiments on the ToTTo and Logic2Text
benchmarks show that PixT3 is competitive and, in some settings, superior to
generators that operate solely on text. | [
-0.0128101083,
0.0700084716,
0.0253836662,
0.0053425352,
-0.0169328377,
0.0155641995,
-0.018300904,
0.0519741029,
-0.0363308452,
-0.0157180596,
-0.0286479294,
-0.0035119322,
-0.0027187362,
0.0595993809,
0.0450604968,
-0.0387151092,
0.0010776094,
0.0261491314,
-0.0675618425,
0.0437901691,
0.0054716803,
-0.0047094007,
0.014659158,
0.0026976857,
-0.0568246283,
-0.0078012049,
-0.0478143282,
0.0163155794,
-0.0113079119,
-0.034754917,
-0.0218223762,
0.0608418658,
0.030676255,
-0.015602272,
0.0000020457,
0.0346384086,
-0.0302243289,
-0.0251575951,
0.0485872664,
-0.009340818,
0.0575757772,
-0.037309546,
-0.0066231955,
-0.0224857237,
-0.0490753762,
0.0196024366,
0.0426001959,
0.0622674525,
0.0681305379,
0.0458031259,
-0.0068219472,
-0.0172522012,
-0.0138603263,
-0.0173049029,
0.0604452565,
0.0306399111,
-0.0418306589,
-0.0081565045,
-0.0224611331,
-0.0086307852,
-0.000775092,
0.0298390277,
0.0290846154,
-0.0284496173,
0.0215270296,
0.0628498048,
-0.0018959192,
0.0024401376,
-0.0110370656,
0.0956204832,
-0.0424403846,
-0.0170056075,
0.0080789803,
0.0043546688,
-0.0036045203,
-0.0495686978,
-0.0457886383,
0.0190041382,
-0.0186375342,
0.010884868,
-0.0458928235,
0.0174666923,
-0.0068470705,
-0.032304123,
-0.0020587509,
-0.0055779191,
-0.0288037322,
-0.0192135312,
-0.0284519959,
0.0089059453,
0.0466593988,
-0.0532831252,
0.0213632006,
0.0435901731,
0.0036364244,
0.0200690385,
-0.0267379154,
-0.0745822042,
0.0076898574,
-0.080703266,
0.0835238174,
0.0290742386,
-0.0179949664,
-0.0052670348,
-0.0933316201,
0.0121250544,
-0.0079911146,
0.0558029152,
-0.0245610811,
0.0290454775,
-0.0353298932,
0.0105445459,
-0.0242007785,
0.0129891643,
-0.0597726367,
-0.0292454101,
0.015355574,
0.0068572527,
-0.0099815577,
0.0474315435,
-0.0052914131,
0.0492081568,
-0.0530739501,
0.0279918201,
-0.027325131,
0.0063428814,
-0.0073177493,
-0.0439057872,
0.0233603716,
-0.0381008014,
0.005872617,
-0.0022003122,
0.0387099385,
0.0248981491,
0.0161273684,
0.0727722794,
-0.0861105546,
-0.008852832,
-0.0495007485,
-0.013762556,
-0.0583999865,
-0.0188301038,
0.0441531949,
-0.0205223486,
0.0408312753,
-0.0321961008,
-0.0231104717,
-0.0770246759,
0.0301870611,
0.0485345908,
0.0320923589,
0.0562695265,
-0.0266859084,
0.0007002926,
0.0089472653,
-0.0448141843,
-0.0068469797,
0.0366404317,
0.0607499778,
0.0959876403,
-0.0268897396,
-0.0175908711,
-0.0242851656,
0.0333432108,
0.0460004397,
-0.029133236,
-0.0380062796,
0.0074210828,
0.0065349396,
0.0284094028,
0.0400965065,
0.017905321,
-0.0076081408,
0.0331915021,
0.0825530514,
0.0074302033,
0.0280173384,
0.0891443938,
0.034932401,
-0.010378086,
0.0188122205,
0.003067754,
-0.0217501074,
0.0593471192,
0.0575072207,
0.0351462178,
0.0350067094,
0.0218057428,
-0.0182005093,
-0.0645856187,
0.0238450747,
0.0178728811,
0.0175926238,
-0.0360065885,
0.0416935347,
0.067546241,
-0.0746607855,
-0.0265187733,
-0.0229984298,
-0.073404707,
0.0107108047,
-0.0327520408,
0.0221339725,
0.0774658397,
0.0240112003,
-0.0036228448,
0.0102265943,
-0.0049198195,
0.0352878943,
0.0662669614,
0.0120350206,
-0.0083667617,
0.0145655125,
-0.0315629616,
-0.0277463961,
-0.0117331725,
-0.0037364685,
0.0008455472,
-0.0051152194,
-0.0062033236,
0.0267578568,
-0.0527588017,
-0.0369794033,
0.0554184057,
0.0610152185,
-0.0297807995,
0.0404132009,
0.0144259501,
-0.0008020964,
0.0219343212,
-0.0181670878,
0.0243981369,
0.0142113604,
-0.0159551501,
0.0301070102,
-0.0124421613,
-0.0171701238,
-0.0009645169,
0.0019539753,
0.0023509993,
-0.0267541446,
-0.0248418916,
-0.0309722535,
-0.0277187917,
0.0273601655,
-0.046540305,
-0.0306549054,
-0.0285723284,
-0.0172008462,
0.0271476936,
0.0350385308,
0.0197555553,
0.0698000118,
-0.0324135311,
-0.0239079427,
-0.0191208757,
-0.0044584726,
0.0060670972,
-0.0245039873,
0.0652627945,
-0.03309967,
-0.0309936684,
0.0228608232,
0.0000343218,
0.0374898352,
-0.0551103912,
-0.024415208,
-0.0444780365,
0.0260517076,
-0.0040817303,
0.0064403918,
0.021376431,
-0.0009853018,
0.0136456154,
-0.0533642843,
-0.0880498663,
0.0296093374,
0.0008294426,
-0.0283589941,
0.0659868717,
-0.0114252372,
0.0180507991,
-0.0402098745,
-0.0289550927,
-0.0217429735,
0.0108326403,
0.011369653,
-0.0371284932,
0.0050271032,
-0.0263826568,
-0.0068836804,
0.0115460139,
0.0472566895,
0.0075106607,
0.0204841271,
-0.0090524489,
0.0465879291,
0.0607419461,
0.0285463911,
0.0318968706,
-0.004516019,
-0.0193419568,
-0.0182529595,
0.0271763094,
-0.0133327544,
0.0247337315,
0.0386347696,
-0.0875971541,
0.0446286574,
0.0364097729,
-0.0098657096,
0.0376479104,
-0.0476925708,
0.0033299625,
0.028688306,
-0.010779852,
-0.0443169475,
0.0550266691,
0.0193729214,
-0.0078423657,
-0.0672888905,
-0.0386358537,
0.0086635659,
-0.0532989316,
0.0303130988,
0.0189862028,
-0.0062187011,
-0.0246885568,
0.0909148604,
0.0408258662,
0.0336366929,
0.0137399221,
0.017068604,
-0.059573032,
0.0057483884,
0.0044959392,
-0.006730773,
0.0715363994,
-0.0610982664,
0.0137648201,
-0.0335559808,
-0.0416574627,
-0.0039229705,
-0.0162081011,
0.023690585,
0.0060912617,
0.0234890636,
-0.0182563104,
-0.0310470182,
-0.0221833214,
0.0166136418,
0.0475511029,
0.0079937493,
-0.0635185093,
-0.0572612472,
0.0434598811,
-0.0142065203,
0.0021658975,
-0.0629573092,
-0.0476587005,
-0.0050356984,
0.0526468977,
-0.0196417905,
-0.0169847347,
-0.0649948418,
0.0255665183,
-0.031980779,
0.0291748419,
-0.0040741134,
0.040792942,
0.0042401282,
-0.0592187159,
-0.012427453,
0.026050562,
0.0162406862,
0.0068923011,
-0.024446778,
0.0212821625,
0.0472580567,
-0.0061003957,
0.0415555276,
-0.0749930963,
-0.0272404067,
-0.0184220076,
0.0164467618,
0.012558368,
-0.0125517882,
-0.0474288166,
-0.0620782934,
0.045903556,
-0.0080845756,
-0.0633589253,
-0.0692666546,
-0.0212196317,
-0.0076482524,
-0.0096790688,
-0.0078042061,
0.0310407896,
-0.0260560066,
0.0255096033,
0.0148727028,
-0.0155225769,
0.0084057059,
-0.0601045452,
-0.0329218395,
-0.0029927227,
0.0876048803,
0.0394886509,
0.0100433966,
-0.0155466432,
-0.0074295313,
0.0372090675,
0.0245719608,
-0.0149613572,
0.0777676553,
0.0099170543,
-0.0109523386,
-0.0092032664,
0.0265832413,
-0.0044820243,
0.0093895774,
0.029314531,
-0.0116298506,
-0.0142500978,
-0.0279067066,
-0.0291664563,
-0.0047067986,
0.0050067338,
0.0076549649,
0.0383188576,
-0.0251711383,
-0.0906574652,
-0.0439688265,
0.0021324761,
-0.0890081525,
0.0246770233,
0.028552724,
-0.0318121873,
-0.044942148,
-0.0642637014,
0.0089504104,
0.0337022245,
0.0532386117,
0.0042461674,
-0.0032861221,
-0.0448169373,
-0.0003507356,
-0.0602139272,
-0.0046657301,
-0.0327754021,
-0.005809485,
-0.0149023328,
-0.0503177568,
-0.0082883378,
-0.04807394,
0.0135497469,
0.0557202473,
-0.0771952271,
0.0170289408,
-0.0449411757,
0.0480595715,
0.0117291892,
0.0063889213,
0.0388276316,
0.0076200548,
0.0204857476,
0.0506512485,
-0.0164969619,
-0.0366328098,
-0.0143440133,
-0.0235613547,
-0.0050769895,
0.0148800155,
-0.0314076655,
0.000847854,
-0.009878898,
0.0340177938,
0.0238604154,
0.0222973395,
0.0581683554,
-0.0245268922,
-0.015501515,
-0.0100675225,
-0.0332869813,
-0.0099807894,
-0.0216000415,
-0.053212624,
-0.0326642469,
-0.046020098,
0.0199379828,
0.0112579605,
0.0390369706,
0.0166876465,
-0.0133058513,
0.0329953469,
0.0270311944,
-0.0118329348,
-0.0430963188,
0.0087552797,
-0.0126066301,
0.0027069896,
-0.0191159695,
-0.0161017943,
0.0168798752,
-0.0130693037,
-0.0060856598,
-0.0130333714,
0.0345449671,
0.0422165729,
-0.0414415784,
-0.049964752,
0.0660628378,
-0.0275171883,
0.0141375056,
-0.0686658919,
-0.0002095235,
0.0197012257,
0.0522257201,
0.028752761,
-0.0464563556,
-0.0003518121,
0.0263260771,
0.0462715216,
0.0252991375,
-0.0195688047,
0.0144138709,
-0.0423013456,
0.0044001238,
-0.0791779235,
0.0731066689,
0.0334780887,
-0.0343124755,
-0.0180281177,
-0.0126274582,
-0.0698538348,
0.0168998986,
-0.0134700602,
-0.0039363434,
0.0167220719,
-0.041492831,
0.0011728251,
-0.0346996263,
0.0307794455,
0.0857614651,
-0.007761173,
0.0066547738,
0.0490186736,
0.0283089541,
0.0356721245,
-0.0294525065,
-0.0224072412,
0.0221363362,
0.0272788983,
-0.0466007404,
-0.0278268792,
-5.824139575e-33,
-0.0462459922,
-0.0512618236,
0.0082350038,
-0.0024594096,
-0.0131642874,
-0.0156170307,
-0.0521771833,
0.0112766903,
0.0273991358,
0.0092509426,
-0.0177454092,
0.0031412567,
0.0202821512,
0.0314868279,
0.0039653019,
-0.020456722,
0.0607739165,
-0.0486636981,
-0.0071904976,
0.0485339239,
-0.0106530339,
0.0239439607,
-0.002805179,
-0.0499508083,
0.019218687,
0.0315168425,
-0.0247659497,
-0.0339940041,
0.0147214849,
-0.0085762655,
-0.0438646451,
0.0243700854,
0.0226518922,
-0.0187603198,
-0.0532599725,
0.0490180515,
-0.147108838,
-0.0107763475,
-0.064988777,
-0.0123389456,
-0.0761074722,
-0.0318074152,
0.0520042107,
-0.0331530087,
-0.0221014973,
-0.0333273746,
0.0537164025,
-0.020225957,
0.008750706,
-0.0065421523,
-0.0007224059,
0.0150909564,
-0.0175915882,
-0.0373751596,
0.0509514473,
0.0642356649,
0.0260089263,
-0.0338110998,
-0.0456090495,
0.0455937646,
0.0044278204,
0.0123641342,
0.0960041136,
0.025827406,
0.0153162479,
0.0354444794,
0.084211491,
0.0389833152,
-0.0524877198,
0.0250396784,
-0.0251510534,
0.0717002749,
0.0747514144,
0.0314141288,
0.0405431874,
0.0052399412,
-0.0491552316,
0.0831766054,
-0.0264795106,
-0.023549702,
-0.0154564902,
-0.0175917596,
0.0139719229,
0.0064478088,
0.0058316682,
-0.0396538265,
-0.0146600381,
-0.0371414274,
0.03923475,
0.0206739865,
0.0226248931,
-0.0091575384,
-0.0045226216,
0.0177339148,
-0.0077423835,
0.0037847608,
-0.0180373881,
0.043224223,
0.0080904057,
-0.0341638848,
0.0084036542,
-0.0506759882,
0.0403028764,
0.0298995879,
0.0418041386,
0.0431079157,
0.0314919949,
0.0383541025,
-0.0493206978,
0.0086572329,
-0.0234598089,
0.0431975573,
0.0302747637,
0.0261625219,
0.00442266,
-0.0442159213,
-0.0230980758,
0.0220217612,
0.0066153985,
0.0069168098,
0.0181377567,
-0.0233298149,
0.0137862107,
0.0257276911,
0.009807284,
0.0221263357,
-0.0680577829,
0.0068405098,
0.0404154696,
-0.053598512,
-0.0013937077,
0.0274146181,
2.465e-7,
0.0432979241,
-0.0171186235,
0.0533949025,
0.0034720595,
0.0042938921,
0.0214108527,
-0.006970501,
0.0413667522,
-0.0430624336,
-0.0405388549,
0.0163736269,
-0.0063469294,
0.0873524025,
0.0374022946,
0.0002136719,
-0.032962434,
-0.0513223633,
0.0238213465,
-0.0418249741,
0.0346422531,
0.0604107529,
0.0595124811,
-0.0729646534,
-0.0306728519,
0.0591532178,
-0.0448388346,
0.0522288494,
-0.0445108153,
0.0609259829,
0.0040047648,
0.0301376525,
-0.0364204533,
-0.0512118377,
0.0311266016,
-0.0549654588,
-0.0147725651,
0.0028807318,
0.0358439684,
-0.0133420806,
0.0310718548,
0.0284820348,
-0.0417465642,
0.022948565,
-0.0502309725,
0.0657223389,
-0.0407295935,
-0.0149445096,
0.060775131,
0.0137419943,
0.0511344448,
0.0026548372,
-0.018795386,
-0.0504104607,
0.0199759342,
0.0485394523,
-0.0146830156,
-0.0072654793,
-0.0269746389,
-0.0637842715,
-0.0044425456,
-0.0240329597,
0.0115673533,
-0.0723373443,
0.0025074503,
-0.0084073469,
-0.0031848713,
-0.0489083678,
2.221215732e-34,
0.0031367394,
-0.0399198756,
0.0177655611,
-0.0023748279,
0.0437732711,
-0.0306183696,
0.0150540033,
-0.0180068035,
-0.0078538125,
-0.0360549465,
-0.0223077331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09807v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09807v2 | The Curious Decline of Linguistic Diversity: Training Language Models on Synthetic Text | 2023-11-16T11:31:50 | 2024-04-16T15:57:11 | Yanzhu Guo, Guokan Shang, Michalis Vazirgiannis, Chloé Clavel | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study investigates the consequences of training language models on
synthetic data generated by their predecessors, an increasingly prevalent
practice given the prominence of powerful generative models. Diverging from the
usual emphasis on performance metrics, we focus on the impact of this training
methodology on linguistic diversity, especially when conducted recursively over
time. To assess this, we adapt and develop a set of novel metrics targeting
lexical, syntactic, and semantic diversity, applying them in recursive
finetuning experiments across various natural language generation tasks in
English. Our findings reveal a consistent decrease in the diversity of the
model outputs through successive iterations, especially remarkable for tasks
demanding high levels of creativity. This trend underscores the potential risks
of training language models on synthetic text, particularly concerning the
preservation of linguistic richness. Our study highlights the need for careful
consideration of the long-term effects of such training approaches on the
linguistic capabilities of language models. | [
0.0206208713,
0.0344374813,
-0.0179078039,
0.0031951359,
-0.0432482399,
-0.0080910232,
0.0152274603,
-0.0072381361,
-0.0506700948,
-0.0514743254,
0.0359214917,
-0.0702671111,
0.0194288194,
0.0339300036,
0.0499843955,
-0.0519307107,
0.0304438733,
-0.005248908,
-0.0120123513,
-0.0282057226,
-0.0046379631,
0.0272118933,
0.0216283072,
0.0566185862,
-0.0347072743,
-0.0035454321,
0.0121889627,
0.0017134803,
0.0223535355,
0.0006198849,
0.0117094433,
0.0574302003,
-0.0117836986,
0.0543992147,
0.0000017512,
-0.0766613185,
0.0040989625,
0.014683662,
0.0088024493,
0.0133263897,
0.0577022843,
0.026435608,
-0.0370689929,
0.0201648157,
-0.0289525874,
0.0140763326,
0.0507537313,
0.0127281696,
0.0297218002,
0.061519146,
0.0003511603,
-0.0505195335,
0.007678288,
-0.0406967625,
0.0061558359,
0.0377730988,
-0.0027317035,
-0.0089585576,
0.0069496715,
-0.0072487094,
-0.0381937921,
0.0137786502,
0.0226992015,
0.0094599798,
0.0069657895,
0.066262126,
-0.0139625082,
-0.0134868827,
0.0161835365,
0.0277293231,
-0.0599286668,
-0.0092375027,
-0.004671928,
-0.0007439022,
-0.0017749765,
-0.0161532238,
-0.0132954987,
0.0488668233,
-0.0099624889,
0.0074523976,
0.0538685694,
-0.0264744442,
0.0010162009,
0.0185074098,
-0.0105588567,
0.0374321938,
0.0492514521,
-0.0211338252,
-0.0070455614,
0.0215185396,
-0.006744036,
-0.0531150512,
-0.0127677917,
-0.0292071346,
-0.0304820053,
0.0119042816,
-0.0590007454,
-0.0398874059,
0.0352302976,
-0.0198645685,
0.0517184623,
0.0044616042,
-0.0032066612,
-0.007974226,
-0.0237194393,
0.0036533934,
0.016976757,
-0.005862684,
-0.0518417358,
0.0290399753,
-0.0409142375,
-0.0181628559,
-0.0383344255,
-0.0009600478,
-0.0532735102,
-0.0132616721,
-0.0417290293,
-0.0058928276,
0.0100146122,
-0.0334293768,
0.0194149651,
0.0280336197,
-0.0864615068,
0.004594184,
-0.0169266034,
-0.0096110096,
-0.0675460398,
0.0163988508,
0.0407668985,
-0.0830646679,
-0.010017572,
0.0118158637,
-0.0086813737,
-0.0367929079,
-0.0128726689,
0.0100691002,
-0.0203972273,
-0.0196292363,
-0.0504824184,
-0.0340556204,
-0.0472266451,
-0.0461103879,
0.0112679563,
-0.0953300148,
0.0061225956,
-0.0056081344,
0.0064645815,
-0.0468429439,
0.0014253845,
-0.0060736351,
-0.0292002819,
0.0091773747,
-0.0581605546,
0.023536263,
0.0218220912,
-0.0264999922,
0.0358453095,
0.0891698971,
0.0483740456,
-0.0030406979,
0.0249966048,
-0.0144454148,
0.0126805948,
0.0246324502,
-0.0417610966,
-0.0029822811,
-0.0304406416,
-0.0429286771,
-0.0079664364,
0.0388471484,
0.0343333781,
0.0585173778,
-0.0387956649,
0.0379896909,
0.0712860674,
0.0058286591,
0.0451951511,
0.0402907319,
0.092219606,
-0.0213487651,
-0.0149491802,
0.0502049141,
-0.0013590987,
0.0078866789,
-0.0082287844,
0.0424637161,
0.0198721699,
0.0838683546,
-0.0050854748,
-0.038473431,
0.0003607364,
0.0218633804,
0.012050177,
-0.0575736351,
0.0376538374,
0.0623307005,
-0.0262813251,
0.0234963633,
0.0449258313,
-0.06184512,
0.0188350771,
-0.0083632749,
0.0314633101,
0.0854608566,
0.0532906279,
0.0125850243,
-0.0071916878,
-0.0142899007,
-0.0076338337,
0.0686290786,
0.0633744821,
0.0082216496,
0.0410523415,
-0.0469767228,
-0.0061256248,
-0.0441530757,
0.0382028073,
0.0509665459,
0.0180174336,
-0.0094177332,
0.0144615388,
-0.0449490286,
-0.0606877469,
0.0533829369,
-0.0555728525,
0.0093015414,
0.0134173706,
-0.0090423524,
0.0064413399,
0.0019400716,
-0.0659267381,
0.0361391604,
0.0085379053,
-0.0467488468,
-0.0150152231,
0.0302590169,
-0.0393018648,
-0.0305479411,
0.0210867152,
-0.0887437314,
0.0242271647,
0.0093894284,
-0.0243651997,
-0.0185128041,
0.0510103516,
-0.0639293715,
-0.0050604143,
-0.0547380112,
0.038567964,
-0.0131466668,
0.0327089019,
-0.0478325635,
0.0703098103,
-0.0101647722,
0.0377748273,
-0.0189976729,
0.000365892,
0.0165296197,
-0.0495546348,
-0.019096164,
0.0038105953,
-0.0167845748,
0.0183935445,
0.0302247237,
0.0360806808,
-0.047300972,
-0.0628836527,
-0.0472522378,
0.0086805448,
-0.0482514948,
0.0090416269,
0.0336492471,
-0.0049247048,
-0.0242724232,
0.0399536081,
-0.0254988205,
-0.0179902613,
0.0214754567,
0.0417298414,
0.0368281603,
-0.0123321498,
-0.02137357,
-0.0175102446,
-0.0156454146,
0.0233021099,
0.0555606186,
0.0102652917,
0.0453617275,
-0.0450725406,
0.0151069714,
-0.0553429984,
-0.0110610425,
0.0137112783,
-0.0408644825,
0.0397392884,
0.0004915139,
0.0968684033,
0.0154957362,
0.0542485416,
0.0230724663,
0.0387755297,
-0.0022553897,
-0.0162980575,
-0.0019204027,
-0.0454283692,
0.000874707,
-0.0201924443,
-0.0540975891,
0.0100969365,
0.0552718006,
0.0165299699,
-0.0199959483,
-0.0683352202,
0.0623203777,
-0.0279672481,
-0.0761103183,
0.0344206318,
-0.0099602826,
-0.034107592,
0.0230990704,
-0.0294338763,
-0.0453497395,
0.0272301175,
-0.0154298712,
0.0056647416,
-0.0455925316,
0.0035564934,
-0.0098230895,
0.0385266617,
0.0030521136,
0.0309211612,
0.043786291,
0.0119802039,
-0.0574415028,
0.0332537107,
0.0513735004,
-0.0309923161,
0.0433431156,
-0.0546637662,
0.000270578,
0.0003312849,
-0.0039089844,
-0.0414482057,
-0.0391207747,
0.0291380584,
-0.0097040273,
0.0799321905,
0.0144958366,
0.0116648637,
-0.0065514962,
0.0021345604,
0.038408801,
-0.0153571703,
-0.0127898408,
0.0021903038,
0.023004299,
0.0407211185,
0.0018582033,
0.0394740328,
-0.0357046798,
0.0053925612,
-0.0103779566,
-0.0377058014,
0.0185146909,
-0.0398344211,
0.0293423347,
-0.0045256745,
-0.0325461291,
-0.041793935,
0.0472167805,
0.0545937829,
-0.0329286531,
-0.0539465584,
0.078005679,
0.0275782142,
0.0272528902,
0.0461179018,
0.007181407,
0.0908632204,
0.0361606441,
0.0112564517,
-0.0290088505,
0.0183784086,
0.0036814434,
0.0091354074,
-0.0362030454,
-0.0324838683,
-0.0418799035,
-0.1533352137,
0.0408911631,
0.017305458,
-0.0691054612,
-0.0094123259,
0.0003810964,
-0.0346038379,
0.0155022303,
0.0052705267,
0.022951223,
-0.0115720266,
0.0309660099,
0.0310395434,
-0.02098809,
-0.0808850005,
-0.0253430437,
-0.04392533,
0.0425651856,
0.0858168751,
0.0116139045,
-0.0201755054,
0.0008070553,
0.017741004,
-0.0327532627,
0.0190451127,
0.0034047796,
0.0609328337,
0.0411966294,
-0.0165108293,
0.0118037686,
0.0094174379,
0.0096110171,
0.0005740979,
-0.0118530914,
0.0240751188,
0.0227189064,
-0.0591888018,
-0.0090835625,
0.0223397538,
0.0151726268,
0.0590544678,
0.0537861958,
-0.0511219539,
-0.0232464895,
-0.0545630306,
0.0350344554,
-0.1006453633,
-0.0272060037,
0.0337406024,
-0.0188131873,
-0.0311510004,
-0.0978230089,
-0.052338738,
0.0046515642,
0.0499731228,
0.0107389148,
-0.0063825399,
-0.0586949587,
-0.0358462632,
0.0052590542,
0.0370160602,
-0.0037092578,
0.017028613,
-0.0391833372,
-0.0364693664,
-0.0135805346,
-0.052530162,
-0.003591296,
0.0009163472,
-0.0786607191,
-0.076096274,
0.0393290594,
0.0452583283,
0.0302149225,
0.0242140815,
0.010144528,
-0.0678365529,
0.0355863944,
0.0761870444,
-0.0016047497,
0.0427517332,
0.0222412348,
-0.014209996,
0.0025484478,
0.0381561294,
-0.0319723599,
0.0139961019,
0.024501903,
0.0779763907,
0.0333661549,
-0.0299788341,
0.0399173424,
0.0183472428,
0.0057308301,
-0.0876416713,
0.0108147487,
-0.0563520566,
-0.0286986623,
-0.031153664,
-0.0347156078,
-0.0529045723,
-0.0121915229,
0.0240134131,
0.0226488784,
-0.0112268198,
0.0291474238,
0.0057528494,
0.0599886291,
-0.0378007106,
-0.0354435295,
-0.0021238253,
-0.0037235846,
0.038296707,
0.0158178005,
-0.0213839822,
0.0207824223,
-0.0663906783,
0.0213697422,
0.0083554536,
0.0399526693,
0.0052246875,
0.0176421143,
-0.023446111,
0.0178349968,
-0.0364492051,
-0.0191530921,
-0.0494563952,
0.0105570368,
0.0490279384,
-0.0230819192,
0.1098092794,
-0.0333974212,
-0.0013847799,
-0.0501094274,
0.0193818305,
0.0159203876,
-0.0370238796,
-0.01032071,
-0.0002509777,
-0.0283255111,
-0.0483329855,
0.1074321717,
-0.0133034782,
0.0215799101,
-0.0042419424,
0.0222265366,
-0.0288185831,
-0.0411896706,
-0.0278864726,
-0.0205996223,
0.0277960468,
0.0076814974,
-0.0839728191,
-0.054370109,
0.0263622981,
0.0219631679,
0.0567845181,
0.0080828751,
0.0559233949,
0.0579497032,
-0.0475506298,
0.0406712815,
-0.0350342542,
-0.0083059939,
0.0191702601,
0.0095432494,
-0.0360081196,
-6.00862974e-33,
-0.0150720123,
0.0004801703,
-0.0063690264,
-0.0509614907,
-0.0488205291,
-0.0262730196,
-0.0439788699,
0.0322473757,
0.0082566049,
0.0440708548,
-0.0136488611,
-0.0286049787,
0.0126385521,
0.0361736454,
0.0234600417,
0.0189958625,
0.05096386,
-0.0092962142,
-0.041862078,
-0.0121139325,
0.0317596495,
-0.0026309215,
0.0443661995,
-0.0114644766,
-0.0046830801,
0.0216560587,
-0.0232138764,
-0.0052694534,
0.0036023133,
0.0173121188,
-0.0068355412,
0.0603539757,
0.0283567905,
-0.0658022016,
-0.0272402167,
-0.0263716001,
-0.0029170953,
-0.0452125371,
0.0203711279,
-0.0404794812,
-0.024992615,
-0.0381570905,
0.0478453934,
-0.0119702676,
-0.0312986225,
-0.0228765234,
0.0285720583,
-0.0374040753,
-0.0397894531,
-0.0591004975,
-0.0965958089,
0.043197915,
-0.0205968544,
-0.0276308227,
-0.0491326414,
-0.0048129014,
0.01362231,
-0.0190087296,
0.0090007698,
0.0306220837,
0.0334808417,
0.0418857634,
0.0513063334,
0.0235050544,
-0.0006530583,
0.0479583926,
0.0194043219,
0.0577738322,
0.0075799576,
0.0114328479,
0.0245191064,
0.0226263981,
0.0346884765,
0.0956632793,
0.0384965874,
-0.0157624874,
-0.0333557576,
0.0209046546,
-0.022382427,
-0.0079197949,
0.0296589565,
-0.0057374602,
-0.0104839476,
-0.0374080054,
-0.0442598611,
-0.0210321024,
0.0148623046,
-0.0075112674,
0.0374149047,
0.0172681976,
-0.0208399873,
-0.029245073,
0.0051175277,
-0.0094549302,
0.0020773727,
0.0098798173,
-0.0633749068,
0.0026744765,
-0.0022516828,
0.0235482734,
-0.0300424043,
-0.0163977556,
0.0441032574,
0.041564405,
0.0075061629,
-0.0047983341,
0.0191412382,
0.0230581872,
-0.061633341,
0.0295486003,
-0.0382283852,
0.0453394912,
0.0322963335,
0.0073179728,
0.026773097,
-0.026425356,
-0.0233979989,
0.0052757715,
0.0678080171,
-0.0054715164,
-0.0331576318,
-0.0076254318,
0.0185641982,
0.0155625138,
-0.0311797969,
0.0217796732,
-0.0210279487,
-0.0112946546,
0.0890155286,
-0.0120025668,
-0.0348477662,
-0.0070094434,
2.498e-7,
0.0397697166,
0.0225319099,
0.0296245255,
0.0113092391,
0.0244021341,
0.0077702436,
-0.0062316069,
0.0249409787,
0.0095896563,
0.0146508422,
-0.0275468174,
0.010692683,
0.0569094792,
0.0265359022,
-0.0518822521,
0.0190757979,
-0.0826267228,
0.0504846461,
-0.0495155044,
-0.0328721032,
0.0382643752,
0.0649642348,
-0.0071586478,
-0.017844893,
-0.0059043607,
-0.0443245955,
0.0549716353,
-0.0129448138,
-0.0069419546,
0.0422029532,
0.035075929,
-0.0114548299,
0.0108614471,
-0.0133107724,
-0.0219468661,
0.0178969577,
-0.0000554981,
0.010261815,
0.0008816241,
0.0180251896,
0.0521940924,
-0.0180854574,
-0.0061415178,
-0.0538334325,
0.040652357,
-0.0287889242,
0.000280813,
-0.0250321515,
-0.0382262543,
0.0516072661,
0.0454041138,
-0.075752154,
-0.0340521708,
0.0319580212,
0.018906815,
0.02066941,
-0.0207024682,
-0.0292542465,
-0.0540771,
-0.0016802085,
-0.0510495119,
-0.0599574409,
-0.0071977172,
0.0448954366,
0.0083326893,
-0.0415507071,
0.0074137785,
2.208879011e-34,
0.044606898,
0.0007675384,
0.0316010416,
-0.0071001477,
0.0439591296,
-0.0215871129,
0.0115014873,
0.0201043338,
-0.0239007175,
-0.0420890711,
-0.0378491469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09805v1 | DocMath-Eval: Evaluating Numerical Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs in Understanding Long Documents with Tabular Data | 2023-11-16T11:30:53 | 2023-11-16T11:30:53 | Yilun Zhao, Yitao Long, Hongjun Liu, Linyong Nan, Lyuhao Chen, Ryo Kamoi, Yixin Liu, Xiangru Tang, Rui Zhang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent LLMs have demonstrated remarkable performance in solving exam-like
math word problems. However, the degree to which these numerical reasoning
skills are effective in real-world scenarios, particularly in expert domains,
is still largely unexplored. This paper introduces DocMath-Eval, a
comprehensive benchmark specifically designed to evaluate the numerical
reasoning and problem-solving capabilities of LLMs in the context of
understanding and analyzing financial documents containing both text and
tables. We evaluate a wide spectrum of 19 LLMs, including those specialized in
coding and finance. We also incorporate different prompting strategies (i.e.,
Chain-of-Thoughts and Program-of-Thoughts) to comprehensively assess the
capabilities and limitations of existing LLMs in DocMath-Eval. We found that,
although the current best-performing system (i.e., GPT-4), can perform well on
simple problems such as calculating the rate of increase in a financial metric
within a short document context, it significantly lags behind human experts in
more complex problems grounded in longer contexts. We believe DocMath-Eval can
be used as a valuable benchmark to evaluate LLMs' capabilities to solve
challenging numerical reasoning problems in expert domains. We will release the
benchmark and code at https://github.com/yale-nlp/DocMath-Eval. | [
-0.0406107679,
0.0528049804,
0.0098959999,
0.0221770965,
-0.0430670716,
0.0391883887,
0.0042853025,
0.040394865,
-0.0263566691,
-0.0060260883,
-0.013471744,
-0.0076910243,
0.0028485938,
0.0043260818,
0.0097722812,
0.0166342799,
0.0170302242,
-0.0289574526,
0.0278495066,
0.0143907946,
0.0020405308,
-0.0353707522,
-0.0421516486,
-0.0395634025,
-0.0227861796,
-0.0351079702,
0.0039604311,
-0.0272267722,
-0.0047543468,
-0.0245465767,
-0.0131081697,
0.0385284647,
0.0127783967,
0.05298784,
0.000002234,
-0.0430444293,
-0.0463090539,
0.0226027761,
-0.0290335342,
0.0283950903,
0.0192638133,
-0.0251992252,
0.0203061923,
-0.0098945173,
-0.0787248239,
0.033295501,
-0.0169451945,
0.0068917205,
0.0524764434,
0.0773036778,
0.0006032906,
-0.0234726686,
0.021324493,
-0.0067128208,
0.0583320893,
-0.1142249703,
-0.008803186,
0.0641097352,
0.0596154891,
-0.0307363104,
-0.0152782509,
0.04856636,
0.0348838046,
-0.0094347261,
0.0286198482,
0.0020963186,
-0.0084072901,
0.0457005389,
-0.0287610255,
0.0362510271,
0.0503316969,
0.061711248,
0.0240501147,
-0.0210113693,
0.0106155006,
0.0241397414,
-0.0622297786,
0.0002431865,
-0.046567861,
-0.0206560194,
-0.0102685019,
-0.0014723783,
-0.0044796187,
0.0224269293,
-0.0357001275,
0.0574803129,
-0.0385773703,
-0.0670912564,
0.0657153651,
0.0143312681,
-0.0069172555,
-0.0106109651,
0.0479994752,
0.0784477666,
0.0052198418,
0.0150008788,
0.0157557093,
-0.0672501326,
0.0044077984,
-0.0393664017,
0.0558071695,
0.0568466075,
0.0218233522,
0.0574410632,
-0.0725343898,
0.0647007078,
-0.0233502928,
0.0034663107,
-0.0026601616,
0.0566608012,
-0.0501495861,
-0.0053131925,
-0.0083356323,
0.0551303923,
-0.0282279961,
-0.0030365936,
-0.0239858031,
-0.0038264208,
-0.0168287996,
0.059465982,
-0.0011313517,
0.0011422285,
0.0219088905,
-0.0287409555,
-0.0636792928,
-0.0220234431,
-0.0416157283,
-0.0202338994,
-0.0174901467,
-0.0323981196,
0.0015155637,
0.0026240591,
-0.023167463,
-0.0343915895,
0.05580182,
0.0833528936,
-0.0192596689,
0.0325432383,
-0.0253927708,
-0.0313478671,
0.0038650394,
-0.055083137,
0.0017340106,
-0.0574224852,
0.0384025052,
0.0031119369,
-0.044965174,
-0.0433683656,
0.0100037316,
0.0006613479,
0.0326039717,
0.0547658019,
-0.0006210537,
-0.0150862094,
0.0382475741,
0.0063830209,
-0.0643963143,
0.050524164,
0.0527171865,
0.0151521806,
-0.0171101298,
-0.0025235757,
0.0125544174,
0.0540853739,
-0.0032180459,
-0.0320415832,
0.0051376619,
0.0680807009,
0.0039818813,
0.051002562,
0.007444439,
0.0326424502,
-0.0282139089,
-0.0006677128,
0.0345590636,
0.0536045134,
0.0312935002,
0.0371600837,
-0.0011588911,
0.0041539012,
0.0637904853,
0.0120436642,
-0.0154100014,
0.0455486476,
-0.0109979529,
0.0211131405,
-0.0008370628,
-0.028842112,
0.002351566,
-0.0735964328,
-0.0188755635,
0.0334507748,
-0.0484768599,
-0.0253472477,
0.0189723317,
-0.0385155641,
-0.0358985513,
0.0327389389,
-0.0206244066,
-0.0243035574,
-0.0312005673,
-0.0188172664,
0.0195386801,
0.0462830812,
0.0531655475,
-0.0774892047,
-0.0152449105,
-0.0192820486,
0.0065902844,
0.0095220385,
0.0680858865,
-0.0005414957,
-0.0489364415,
-0.0399420969,
0.0135928988,
-0.0211014561,
-0.0066309548,
-0.0078851227,
0.0087560453,
0.0025340649,
0.0112131732,
-0.0255570151,
-0.0062926775,
0.0217391755,
-0.0300812777,
-0.0415943936,
-0.0026072774,
-0.0043915426,
-0.0030910401,
0.0246307161,
0.0148262223,
0.0350726843,
-0.0167801753,
-0.0051910602,
-0.0058665243,
-0.0394183472,
-0.0396770909,
0.0155422995,
0.036684759,
-0.0527958572,
-0.0740600377,
-0.0274900217,
-0.0363779776,
0.0004355853,
0.008224586,
-0.0580723956,
-0.0252641942,
-0.0299772248,
0.0042209243,
0.0010892062,
-0.0134982597,
0.0099500064,
0.0848720968,
-0.0011604216,
0.0492207557,
0.0033811291,
-0.0196121372,
0.0066354205,
-0.0413771085,
0.0611743033,
-0.0314673707,
0.0015248717,
0.009462757,
-0.0279628579,
0.0343135707,
-0.0533759557,
-0.0479679666,
-0.0402734615,
0.0023507224,
-0.0211934336,
0.0926737264,
0.0115188891,
-0.0771302506,
-0.0323154032,
0.0029780047,
-0.0592465997,
-0.0045679188,
-0.0291782077,
-0.0198674612,
0.0818223432,
0.0051079444,
0.0079002744,
-0.0252297577,
-0.0048495643,
-0.0522410646,
0.0210825913,
0.0472975373,
-0.003697084,
-0.0017504083,
0.0045442609,
-0.0176234636,
-0.0163574815,
0.0087073948,
0.0415895134,
0.0393134356,
-0.0410082415,
0.0480707474,
0.0398427583,
-0.0216100272,
0.0552723892,
-0.0074872561,
-0.0572672151,
-0.041551996,
0.0149814393,
0.0223737434,
0.0354868509,
-0.0000141368,
-0.0347591303,
-0.0000187305,
0.0379647873,
-0.0519866943,
0.0066343891,
-0.0079547456,
0.0676626414,
0.0201135408,
-0.0055257957,
-0.0571552813,
0.0464203022,
0.002555659,
0.0682521537,
0.0115347998,
-0.0327685289,
0.0472430587,
-0.0211565159,
-0.022110967,
-0.0408965275,
0.0125610698,
-0.0824881792,
0.0405609086,
-0.0259451307,
-0.0331937,
-0.0767732188,
-0.0433455035,
-0.040563371,
0.0002830237,
0.039916046,
-0.0287425146,
0.0987723172,
-0.0534880869,
0.0077190665,
-0.0302027147,
-0.0056175264,
0.0044666915,
-0.0257967617,
0.0053993957,
0.0198718216,
0.0322688632,
-0.0296643712,
-0.0464122295,
-0.0297634546,
0.0492175445,
0.0096096313,
-0.0352656394,
-0.0588692054,
-0.0297895912,
0.0286973435,
0.0003149604,
0.010290226,
0.0486274473,
-0.0728249699,
0.0377690904,
0.0333852619,
0.0467122458,
0.0185421351,
-0.0190647449,
0.0295292102,
-0.0212086886,
-0.0450021997,
0.0040372321,
0.0423040986,
-0.0374928899,
-0.0568396673,
0.002472901,
0.0793104544,
0.0400936678,
-0.0101604434,
-0.0209017936,
-0.0725812986,
-0.0021463239,
0.0074301916,
0.0688972175,
-0.0901919305,
-0.0047948612,
0.0168463327,
0.0318059362,
0.0104731228,
-0.0958831608,
-0.0304910727,
-0.0999125913,
0.0533995144,
-0.0021840548,
0.000300691,
0.0061659343,
-0.01462196,
-0.0215750616,
-0.0047877072,
-0.015971778,
0.0454120003,
-0.0133048119,
0.0247960258,
0.0108556291,
-0.0469815657,
0.0514543839,
0.0267319176,
0.0266842041,
-0.0511473082,
-0.002947794,
0.0267148688,
-0.0368328504,
-0.0649551824,
0.0019988047,
0.0503424816,
0.018593546,
-0.0140847024,
0.0194974095,
-0.0119537963,
0.0113804182,
0.0002879734,
0.0171415228,
-0.0420413837,
0.0400351584,
0.0610546432,
0.059106607,
-0.0256449915,
-0.0180205218,
-0.0043215412,
0.0152360052,
-0.0445524342,
0.0528485849,
0.032913845,
0.0137718609,
-0.07492394,
-0.025427565,
-0.037800774,
-0.0541295744,
0.0282612052,
-0.0018581335,
0.0351288617,
0.0328411758,
-0.0500380397,
-0.0237343442,
0.035792511,
0.0593035296,
-0.0079785744,
-0.0252028834,
-0.002195365,
0.0036161211,
-0.0354037657,
0.0017873377,
-0.0244194511,
0.0500504524,
-0.0399436206,
0.0508865602,
-0.0002612046,
-0.0205761548,
-0.0431999899,
0.0263494812,
-0.0963752046,
-0.0178439766,
-0.0372549891,
0.0139341233,
0.027052667,
-0.0336972885,
-0.0036748671,
0.0095100012,
-0.0067535131,
0.0314573385,
-0.1015729606,
0.0103606991,
0.0118364189,
0.0293686595,
0.0029124669,
0.0070859999,
-0.0015417574,
-0.0119316755,
-0.0206200536,
0.0405971743,
-0.0305113997,
0.0235007033,
-0.0274304487,
0.0539152846,
-0.0461245626,
0.0630214885,
-0.0275629163,
0.0026140655,
0.0070614489,
-0.0172683187,
-0.004440655,
-0.0087740989,
-0.0329198837,
0.0089165512,
-0.0095975464,
-0.0071372995,
0.0234607439,
0.0243325438,
-0.0125089753,
-0.0007906089,
0.0582363009,
0.0146482512,
-0.0053049759,
0.0199771821,
-0.057846494,
0.0121663474,
-0.0270208027,
0.0012434905,
0.0554527864,
0.0223767255,
0.065023452,
0.0135054588,
0.0216404404,
-0.017173335,
-0.0193311125,
-0.0459335484,
-0.0845451429,
0.0236569997,
0.0348366052,
0.0031920029,
0.0180545282,
-0.0441886224,
-0.0450631194,
0.0240108483,
0.0359186903,
-0.0172825791,
0.0144232884,
0.0239360332,
0.0041268538,
0.0468430892,
0.0045859441,
-0.0574195683,
0.0528529547,
-0.0146369422,
-0.0216872692,
-0.0220009834,
-0.0036329336,
-0.0492176376,
-0.0558028743,
0.0072217835,
0.0053075836,
0.0347834304,
-0.0125339776,
-0.0872633681,
-0.0284430515,
0.0256412718,
0.0208863616,
-0.0236240644,
-0.003618692,
0.019057326,
0.0691417754,
0.0032257698,
0.0306289867,
0.0179183315,
0.0416732691,
-0.0282243975,
-0.0206524469,
-0.0319584124,
-5.642065419e-33,
-0.0076423595,
-0.0509755313,
0.0639888868,
0.0319568887,
0.019513106,
-0.0045247888,
-0.03948256,
0.0035683583,
0.0327793062,
-0.0052464013,
-0.047896795,
0.0205818973,
0.0129283257,
-0.0438862182,
0.0107883736,
-0.0330986828,
-0.0291224364,
-0.0427735932,
-0.0214635562,
-0.0843574181,
-0.0259446539,
0.0490439795,
0.0367988497,
-0.0317603163,
0.0646602288,
0.0250853356,
-0.0056283055,
0.0024096665,
-0.0007308363,
0.0157092866,
-0.0052847951,
0.000458445,
0.0105057191,
-0.0754323155,
-0.0236993656,
-0.009143346,
-0.0353652611,
-0.0430382378,
0.0090615517,
0.0113190068,
-0.0208467115,
-0.0152440472,
0.0581628792,
0.0076071015,
-0.0553524643,
-0.0419580042,
0.0251689237,
-0.0238400921,
0.0199095681,
-0.0388489068,
-0.021988323,
0.0326825194,
-0.0332379229,
0.0520898812,
0.0552088358,
0.0058326237,
-0.0171696637,
-0.0064725303,
-0.0268232934,
-0.0165988412,
0.0244657174,
0.0112185469,
0.0575110316,
-0.0848890468,
0.0044406033,
0.0302967001,
0.0197335072,
-0.005106275,
-0.0308529548,
-0.0168237463,
0.0076140589,
0.054096289,
0.0782828629,
0.0043350519,
0.0760975406,
0.0338420868,
-0.0420457721,
0.0432273,
0.0008658162,
0.0406738147,
-0.007565063,
-0.0048392462,
-0.0364933386,
0.0022476786,
-0.0167081188,
0.0482171178,
-0.047984466,
-0.0123676835,
0.0006868888,
-0.0402138084,
0.0464041494,
0.0000588719,
-0.0122489957,
0.0068671308,
-0.0126243075,
-0.012121886,
0.0266076196,
0.0409507044,
0.0154986195,
0.0116635831,
-0.0431383252,
0.0102806715,
-0.0363547578,
0.0270116068,
0.0728800595,
-0.0018249813,
0.0226357542,
0.0021072645,
-0.0516553745,
-0.033463493,
-0.0313924029,
0.039385248,
0.0392337292,
0.0142848995,
-0.0023066134,
-0.0033954105,
-0.0063470653,
-0.0079291295,
-0.0240532141,
-0.0136889881,
0.006626186,
0.0033410757,
-0.0063943188,
0.0251852293,
0.0140548712,
-0.0122875469,
0.0204790384,
0.0206707194,
0.0362604856,
-0.0119380122,
0.0133290114,
0.0534314215,
2.96e-7,
0.0628595948,
0.061184153,
0.0405125916,
0.009539973,
0.0197780002,
-0.0061454205,
-0.0681880638,
-0.034072414,
-0.0187883768,
-0.0689958408,
0.0561759397,
0.0599061958,
0.0735213459,
0.0511313975,
-0.0265918802,
-0.0489809625,
-0.0480841137,
0.0017916919,
-0.0567125194,
0.0442149863,
0.042824991,
-0.031045042,
-0.0088215414,
-0.0272868369,
0.0036753074,
-0.0459474511,
0.0415346026,
-0.0375217646,
0.0309539922,
0.0080191679,
0.0552857369,
-0.0394228473,
0.0041747214,
0.0276602022,
0.0076523875,
0.0049704742,
0.0349480398,
0.0852093697,
0.0319346935,
0.0308344159,
0.0051798429,
-0.0618221723,
-0.0012444822,
-0.0353305228,
0.0456111617,
-0.0268554781,
-0.0429571383,
0.0267132819,
-0.0342770033,
-0.0461807586,
0.0231568031,
-0.0037380669,
0.0599305257,
0.0269092619,
0.0061094081,
-0.0398529321,
-0.0060196547,
-0.0345647745,
-0.0098637659,
0.0433899686,
-0.0362818763,
-0.002160979,
-0.0558435097,
0.0366297998,
0.0259663537,
-0.0505699068,
-0.0479172356,
2.544546474e-34,
0.0555240549,
-0.0366205387,
0.021671949,
0.0358735174,
0.0738324225,
0.0208054092,
-0.0364717282,
0.0367404856,
0.0144466674,
-0.0682953,
-0.0122190155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09802v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09802v1 | Neuro-Symbolic Integration Brings Causal and Reliable Reasoning Proofs | 2023-11-16T11:26:21 | 2023-11-16T11:26:21 | Sen Yang, Xin Li, Leyang Cui, Lidong Bing, Wai Lam | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Though prompting LLMs with various reasoning structures produces reasoning
proofs along with answers, these proofs are not ensured to be causal and
reliable due to the inherent defects of LLMs. Tracking such deficiencies, we
present a neuro-symbolic integration method, in which a neural LLM is used to
represent the knowledge of the problem while an LLM-free symbolic solver is
adopted to do deliberative reasoning using the knowledge. Specifically, our
customized meta-interpreters allow the production of reasoning proofs and
support flexible search strategies. These reasoning proofs are ensured to be
causal and reliable because of the deterministic executing nature of the
symbolic solvers. Empirically, on ProofWriter, our method surpasses the CoT
baseline by nearly double in accuracy and more than triple in proof similarity.
On GSM8K, our method also shows accuracy improvements and nearly doubled proof
similarity. Our code is released at https://github.com/DAMO-NLP-SG/CaRing | [
-0.0119795687,
0.0724539608,
-0.0114647737,
0.0376870967,
-0.0465490706,
0.0147476699,
0.0057743485,
-0.0087236827,
0.0031947668,
-0.006625629,
0.0066721444,
0.0868269503,
-0.0072955135,
0.0205904953,
0.0366813019,
-0.012690139,
0.0465965085,
-0.0090888487,
0.0410172306,
-0.027131578,
-0.0417986251,
-0.0173206478,
-0.0276038423,
-0.0068404968,
-0.0484547541,
-0.0256651379,
-0.0262104478,
-0.0002122219,
0.0179582201,
-0.0096443212,
-0.0410064533,
0.0192071162,
0.019817343,
0.0840462148,
0.0000021326,
-0.0373719037,
0.0128680402,
0.0198387727,
-0.0578103513,
-0.0593655929,
-0.0514828339,
-0.0046767001,
0.0159171764,
0.0187414326,
-0.0348544344,
0.0293706898,
0.0031265328,
0.0581409298,
0.0603014678,
0.0617373809,
0.0199178346,
-0.0320359729,
0.0866651759,
0.0232931916,
0.0686619654,
0.0174404476,
-0.0185518935,
-0.0111003984,
0.0416692942,
-0.0524348281,
-0.0167912561,
0.066718787,
0.0902932584,
-0.0269806478,
-0.0379529558,
0.0280543305,
-0.0301124156,
0.0248798095,
-0.0442924351,
0.0361241698,
-0.0053111454,
-0.0322889835,
-0.0297427438,
0.0089194244,
0.006607146,
-0.0163332019,
-0.0454729125,
0.0431105271,
-0.0192335583,
-0.0074602743,
0.016695261,
-0.0049544298,
0.0485179648,
-0.0127194114,
-0.0061142477,
0.083208397,
0.0205999333,
-0.0537428558,
0.0313807391,
0.0101241283,
0.0050397371,
-0.0239199344,
0.0083383974,
0.0675662234,
-0.0247466955,
0.0210883096,
-0.0007927063,
-0.0206394382,
-0.0038041903,
-0.0112128435,
0.0354426168,
0.0575220585,
-0.0006472465,
0.007726457,
-0.0729807541,
0.0185720548,
-0.0317349024,
0.0747307464,
0.013717344,
-0.0059316447,
-0.068213895,
-0.019819174,
0.0091783842,
0.0594618842,
-0.0038740467,
0.0135714971,
0.0016766071,
0.048608128,
-0.0345132053,
0.0541859344,
-0.0118522001,
0.0065451497,
0.0237208623,
-0.0084559154,
-0.0441740453,
-0.0278715752,
-0.0670876428,
0.0119542964,
0.0077358629,
-0.0208343547,
-0.0224481393,
0.0119164465,
-0.038304586,
-0.0372396633,
0.0203600246,
0.1093404815,
0.0213157088,
-0.0123148402,
-0.0505093522,
-0.0456244908,
0.0177251659,
-0.060927365,
-0.0024089036,
-0.084553048,
0.0597706698,
-0.028804075,
-0.0441374928,
-0.0626189113,
0.0062908423,
0.0151690561,
0.0357061476,
0.0638967156,
-0.0513861962,
-0.0334616676,
0.0298459977,
-0.0025849279,
-0.0478075892,
0.0263040978,
0.0336050205,
0.0261747465,
-0.0158121791,
0.0260506123,
-0.00422699,
-0.0212603137,
0.032360848,
-0.0095374798,
-0.0128077921,
-0.0053383186,
-0.0152488593,
0.0493292771,
-0.0136953667,
0.0609501414,
-0.0169009212,
-0.0552831925,
0.017850399,
0.0497293584,
0.0173598006,
-0.011830694,
0.0257845726,
-0.0633559003,
0.0249832384,
-0.0280881729,
-0.105176799,
0.0795965865,
-0.0591342263,
0.0017730145,
-0.0219943989,
0.021272948,
-0.0178411044,
-0.0797163248,
0.0127475746,
0.0163198672,
-0.0440447256,
0.0137989679,
0.0107143428,
-0.0076552629,
0.0146025531,
0.0393034779,
-0.0005158255,
-0.02232025,
0.0024649499,
-0.0470063016,
0.0685640275,
0.0144004878,
0.0618689656,
-0.0420748256,
-0.0274983179,
-0.0578037724,
-0.0250208676,
0.0583524816,
-0.0182624124,
-0.0092604803,
-0.0087119984,
-0.0049452349,
-0.0077393278,
-0.036278706,
0.0181694049,
0.0074684317,
0.0165357664,
0.0135042444,
0.0128989983,
-0.0088257855,
0.0096000126,
0.0577066988,
-0.0130510349,
-0.0415375829,
-0.0183722917,
0.0219989829,
0.0309059769,
0.0156215783,
0.0103448993,
0.0139277726,
0.0054034907,
-0.0329411216,
-0.0500800423,
0.0479636677,
-0.0147758089,
-0.0749755129,
0.0570955724,
-0.0595507547,
-0.0523637719,
0.0156711116,
-0.0732921734,
-0.0200549345,
0.0420527235,
-0.0186271928,
-0.0028951913,
-0.0433683507,
-0.0414617807,
0.0266718734,
-0.0423275605,
-0.0056832954,
0.0598807372,
-0.0028642404,
-0.0531886667,
0.0176126193,
0.0228843708,
0.0131354677,
-0.051519271,
-0.0043467837,
0.011344064,
-0.0138644874,
-0.0083253579,
-0.0120910602,
-0.0023903749,
-0.0444232151,
-0.0099662859,
-0.0378049538,
0.03777254,
-0.0049180165,
0.0272756424,
0.0056184037,
-0.0096288202,
0.0207088944,
-0.0052522235,
-0.0422006324,
0.0210983772,
0.0140572442,
0.0042793341,
0.049778115,
-0.0092156921,
-0.0094070835,
-0.0243654754,
-0.0048866333,
-0.0657308176,
0.0248676315,
0.008549381,
-0.0057726987,
-0.0204338189,
-0.0047694966,
-0.0313772112,
0.0120280553,
0.0024813106,
0.0088780997,
0.0602358617,
-0.0105246529,
-0.0558899529,
0.0864128992,
0.0027067342,
-0.0297691971,
0.0381878093,
-0.0007682779,
-0.0745875239,
0.0382384807,
-0.0047321254,
0.0306083784,
0.0076362561,
-0.0142581584,
-0.0015237937,
0.0513139255,
-0.0210742243,
-0.0190926753,
-0.0180509221,
0.0320777707,
0.0116517404,
-0.0213562287,
-0.0197584145,
-0.0074118776,
-0.0187635422,
0.0219245497,
-0.0147722075,
-0.0791828334,
0.1130747944,
0.0034059745,
0.0047689611,
-0.030002173,
-0.0138313407,
-0.0686069131,
0.0674756765,
-0.033863876,
-0.0014392751,
0.006436686,
-0.015259685,
-0.0338533446,
-0.0567246079,
-0.000797022,
0.0272208042,
0.0698964372,
-0.0360756591,
0.0112554254,
0.0026692636,
-0.0217213258,
-0.0493436977,
0.0079872487,
-0.0504877195,
0.0073975553,
-0.0243981909,
-0.0059001455,
-0.0090918373,
-0.0256371647,
0.034391012,
-0.0107367421,
-0.0092389863,
-0.0381362177,
-0.0493513644,
-0.0579763614,
-0.0121207619,
0.0096021974,
0.0611313246,
-0.0049771857,
0.0129983425,
0.0469047837,
-0.0132967876,
0.0006038804,
-0.0515592135,
0.0175379068,
-0.0661554486,
-0.0407656841,
0.0298682731,
0.0063244496,
-0.0083336784,
-0.0684908405,
0.0100030676,
0.0869292766,
0.0312614702,
-0.0196092241,
-0.0142326746,
-0.0517372601,
-0.0045502996,
0.0227133054,
0.0731294975,
-0.1064797789,
-0.0344890989,
0.0240386184,
0.0056935553,
0.014367586,
-0.0434638038,
-0.0342806876,
-0.0604480393,
0.0137109514,
0.0450917892,
0.0157111716,
0.0163077824,
0.0036487326,
0.0045430423,
0.0044644861,
-0.0387104712,
0.0216825046,
0.0016836827,
0.0334026814,
-0.0095176687,
-0.0011698803,
0.0406148955,
0.0279867519,
-0.0397383571,
0.0310207773,
0.0088750189,
0.0330315493,
-0.0042964867,
-0.0568837114,
0.0440635458,
0.0280461553,
0.0072095483,
-0.0385873802,
0.0212252289,
-0.009008741,
0.0152939223,
-0.0046093185,
0.0251603164,
-0.0667928606,
-0.046210546,
0.0422768295,
0.1091631129,
-0.0289613381,
-0.0315127,
-0.0351157486,
0.0062373579,
-0.0251906887,
0.0335440785,
0.0259845015,
0.0297806095,
-0.0471521392,
-0.0381818451,
-0.0594533198,
-0.0192912184,
-0.0066829636,
0.0131385885,
0.0410025045,
0.0159904342,
-0.0447797514,
-0.0543946996,
0.0320597626,
0.0633001029,
0.0106611643,
-0.0269846711,
-0.0169191025,
-0.0292992555,
-0.053944774,
0.0158236232,
-0.0572397821,
0.0341377482,
-0.0249634981,
0.0426235721,
-0.0383653194,
-0.0103367772,
-0.0024245859,
-0.0075934445,
-0.0504360795,
-0.0497159921,
-0.0465056486,
0.061946366,
0.021609934,
0.0183672085,
-0.0266405009,
-0.0101361768,
0.0139395464,
0.0664232746,
0.0200968031,
-0.0053168507,
0.0618794411,
-0.001581782,
0.0184183586,
0.0066674375,
-0.0179054458,
-0.0121750794,
0.0195907336,
0.0600698553,
-0.0094239963,
0.0408831611,
0.0175254345,
0.043956738,
0.0019201887,
0.0106993569,
-0.0117690787,
-0.0248175673,
0.0290935207,
-0.0207553953,
-0.0056968438,
-0.0211422518,
0.021561157,
-0.0129113225,
0.0118626719,
0.0011321848,
-0.024802167,
0.0097400695,
-0.0010279766,
0.0400795862,
0.029358238,
0.0371014923,
0.0243012123,
0.0062791961,
0.0121215852,
-0.021208128,
0.0130098229,
0.0051214183,
0.066578038,
-0.0342285074,
0.00692131,
0.0422695503,
0.0179836843,
-0.0550352074,
0.0034174204,
-0.0640030205,
-0.0624965131,
0.0735675916,
-0.0130406115,
0.0496576577,
0.0455030985,
-0.0599114597,
-0.0182889402,
0.0156687889,
0.0359866433,
0.0155413616,
0.0023573425,
-0.00190081,
0.039532207,
0.0310635231,
0.0128608784,
-0.0632526949,
0.0195135791,
-0.0777463615,
0.0477043688,
-0.0079502305,
0.0355827548,
-0.0232223421,
-0.0370161459,
-0.009654725,
-0.0066979993,
-0.0314561874,
-0.0408712626,
-0.0640061647,
-0.0758951902,
0.047368262,
0.0545868911,
-0.0132105807,
0.0453443378,
0.005958518,
0.001063703,
0.0613016449,
-0.0550293438,
0.0296286512,
0.0302432217,
0.0100124255,
-0.0598251373,
0.0086643584,
-5.728921227e-33,
-0.0378794782,
-0.027746141,
0.0529103093,
0.012089272,
0.012789269,
-0.0327985771,
-0.0640489236,
-0.0019479838,
0.0031413042,
0.0307887513,
-0.026250612,
0.0431028567,
0.0058524339,
-0.0138366232,
0.0265707187,
-0.0319254287,
-0.0084493672,
0.0222939663,
-0.0239797551,
-0.01977963,
0.0266246144,
0.0278916582,
0.018107798,
-0.044572074,
0.0359260328,
0.0384512208,
0.0223922394,
0.0472720824,
-0.064527683,
0.0232670642,
0.0189518984,
0.042695988,
0.005529698,
0.024864668,
-0.0219958834,
0.011720174,
-0.0348231308,
-0.088394247,
0.0431894064,
-0.0350671038,
-0.0735357553,
-0.0619205423,
0.0306034572,
-0.0164436176,
0.0051532467,
-0.0312403869,
0.0237773918,
-0.0235197674,
-0.0177077055,
-0.0261811297,
-0.0435883775,
-0.0113234306,
-0.0187857691,
0.0256489366,
0.0050285263,
-0.0282337517,
0.0061283028,
-0.0110134417,
-0.075607352,
-0.0208228808,
-0.0330793001,
-0.0168548115,
0.0490176901,
-0.0381638817,
0.0053105238,
0.0313716233,
0.009317169,
0.0062399562,
-0.0279191546,
0.0435075946,
0.0165831316,
0.0615338348,
0.0969235227,
0.0229942128,
0.030870121,
0.0214826241,
-0.0299646407,
0.0378065892,
0.0241515953,
0.0859650001,
0.0133474693,
0.0196902603,
-0.0279040635,
0.0081377132,
-0.0470359251,
0.0043460741,
-0.0397009291,
-0.0396571197,
0.0156823061,
-0.0176258087,
0.003742385,
-0.0479012579,
0.0118060382,
-0.0453455746,
0.0387361906,
0.0370045155,
0.0440654419,
-0.0078300703,
0.0006904747,
0.0155656459,
-0.0167810582,
0.0066985684,
-0.0310622752,
0.0008202058,
0.0627265573,
-0.0273380335,
0.0527973361,
0.0386337005,
-0.0288683083,
-0.0023750032,
-0.0603916124,
0.0046435301,
0.0502513908,
-0.0292115826,
-0.0190211795,
0.0351038277,
0.0032274495,
0.0049261865,
-0.0189118069,
-0.0230602026,
-0.0324566588,
0.0983604789,
0.0080675362,
0.0228276309,
-0.0087938542,
0.0031966227,
-0.032366287,
0.056570515,
0.0250582714,
-0.0807107016,
0.0206278246,
0.0199612435,
2.822e-7,
0.0331963189,
0.0110204155,
0.0294185951,
0.0550133437,
0.0405424014,
0.0097000916,
-0.0256328154,
-0.0157858394,
0.0118623516,
-0.0363322534,
0.0068140225,
0.0775796771,
0.0373224318,
0.0512912609,
-0.056750901,
-0.0109503781,
-0.025854772,
-0.0260285325,
-0.0345139578,
0.0258998927,
0.0691580698,
0.0274533164,
0.0435341559,
-0.0167511422,
-0.0000346283,
-0.0321873985,
0.0508417711,
0.0051108543,
0.0354197994,
-0.0263727363,
0.0177825969,
-0.0327216312,
0.032001745,
0.0075592627,
0.0082476167,
0.0026628433,
-0.0549474917,
0.0380399562,
0.0175136887,
-0.0369097516,
-0.0483398549,
-0.0733122602,
0.0251308475,
-0.0058836392,
0.046572648,
-0.0478226133,
-0.0335308127,
-0.0036576556,
0.0110381385,
-0.0326956324,
0.0287237056,
0.0070696194,
0.0151474569,
-0.0049754614,
-0.0010461266,
-0.0054112463,
0.0123829376,
-0.0824856386,
-0.0364793837,
0.0220932756,
-0.0221946724,
-0.014193872,
-0.0062933215,
0.0118449554,
0.0394830033,
-0.0339919925,
-0.0258804411,
2.284133608e-34,
0.0157916844,
0.0079280948,
0.0374421366,
0.0263076108,
0.049206499,
0.0120493276,
-0.0679452941,
-0.0135083543,
0.0477345213,
-0.0639611259,
-0.0270629004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09800v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09800v2 | $\textit{Dial BeInfo for Faithfulness}$: Improving Factuality of Information-Seeking Dialogue via Behavioural Fine-Tuning | 2023-11-16T11:25:44 | 2024-03-04T14:35:59 | Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Ivan Vulić, Pavle Marković, Tomasz Cichy, Qian Zheng, Tsung-Hsien Wen, Paweł Budzianowski | cs.CL | cs.CL | Factuality is a crucial requirement in information seeking dialogue: the
system should respond to the user's queries so that the responses are
meaningful and aligned with the knowledge provided to the system. However, most
modern large language models suffer from hallucinations, that is, they generate
responses not supported by or contradicting the knowledge source. To mitigate
the issue and increase faithfulness of information-seeking dialogue systems, we
introduce BeInfo, a simple yet effective method that applies behavioural tuning
to aid information-seeking dialogue. Relying on three standard datasets, we
show that models tuned with BeInfo} become considerably more faithful to the
knowledge source both for datasets and domains seen during BeInfo-tuning, as
well as on unseen domains, when applied in a zero-shot manner. In addition, we
show that the models with 3B parameters (e.g., Flan-T5) tuned with BeInfo
demonstrate strong performance on data from real `production' conversations and
outperform GPT4 when tuned on a limited amount of such realistic in-domain
dialogues. | [
0.0767902657,
0.0407216363,
-0.0218446571,
0.0551745258,
-0.0251551513,
-0.0070798011,
-0.0336948708,
0.0061858133,
-0.026119411,
-0.0317810588,
-0.0766380206,
-0.041791752,
-0.0130914059,
0.0400192328,
-0.0078717042,
-0.0612332672,
0.0495712981,
-0.0048480774,
0.0199566856,
0.0039716628,
0.028081473,
0.0134290224,
-0.0456284061,
0.0360456705,
-0.0507263727,
-0.0145344138,
-0.0314560719,
0.0341915488,
0.0081006438,
0.0088867517,
0.0336716026,
0.0584840402,
-0.0036425707,
0.0510028712,
0.0000020533,
-0.0419403017,
0.0275932532,
-0.0351648591,
-0.0757640377,
0.0030502193,
-0.0035846911,
0.0299366768,
0.0068618511,
0.0230846293,
-0.0625061616,
0.0314112902,
0.0481580459,
0.0670221597,
0.0627723187,
0.0831152275,
0.0036620456,
-0.01722252,
-0.0073332046,
0.0033662056,
0.008188826,
-0.0744208843,
-0.0067945644,
0.0363089666,
0.0266325772,
0.0424043685,
-0.0059122192,
0.041898068,
0.0045080534,
-0.0314366743,
0.000296575,
0.0000013477,
-0.0642153993,
-0.0385472141,
0.0031106095,
0.0918409973,
0.0512953997,
-0.0135741085,
-0.0029364338,
-0.0057475786,
0.0158802662,
-0.0305268578,
-0.0489182062,
-0.0455871895,
-0.0233265124,
-0.0305332709,
-0.0457924902,
0.0014687376,
-0.0096276458,
0.0058832346,
-0.0239653978,
0.0556034148,
-0.0267466195,
-0.0430292189,
-0.0140684964,
-0.0443767495,
-0.0045349221,
-0.0651243329,
-0.0281129647,
0.0277043711,
-0.077764295,
0.0161091574,
-0.0314639099,
0.0575565137,
0.0246855412,
-0.0248741005,
-0.0179916192,
0.0491518788,
-0.0287100654,
0.0363042541,
0.0489354841,
0.0349047668,
-0.0155001311,
-0.005008155,
-0.019619558,
-0.0134714497,
-0.0500067957,
-0.0091355946,
-0.063046895,
0.0020498401,
-0.0583515316,
-0.0367373824,
0.0139174331,
0.0485033579,
0.0044167321,
0.0024837425,
-0.019087594,
0.0027433611,
-0.0379928052,
-0.0096755112,
-0.0578988791,
0.0333376639,
-0.0546712577,
0.0130338464,
0.0248475,
-0.0807918757,
-0.0168009549,
0.0131496666,
0.0172073375,
-0.0149753401,
-0.0005694021,
0.0331001878,
0.0267454851,
-0.0135104498,
-0.0036634502,
-0.0127318045,
-0.0220681634,
-0.088767007,
-0.0218684655,
0.0191820767,
0.0420492217,
-0.0122918878,
-0.0328239948,
-0.0246138517,
-0.007121658,
0.0125688566,
-0.0164445583,
0.0585177094,
-0.0374382772,
0.0124423718,
0.0138251055,
-0.0026097365,
-0.0122744748,
0.0737466216,
0.0122806439,
-0.0191438906,
0.0485281944,
-0.0185933691,
0.0367993265,
0.0145986741,
0.0133434273,
0.0185268149,
0.0269378386,
0.0639144778,
-0.0099288365,
0.0187527034,
0.0143021904,
0.0396242812,
-0.0505965017,
-0.020685466,
0.0933218151,
0.0122642862,
0.0255872086,
-0.0131354183,
0.0217574984,
0.0514704064,
0.0093017016,
0.0357981771,
-0.0497727096,
0.0432939902,
-0.0258007105,
0.0220203791,
0.0467585772,
-0.0041057961,
-0.0313941948,
-0.0504410639,
0.0099828932,
0.0306848232,
0.00104694,
0.0167046897,
-0.0194085427,
0.0260650329,
-0.0298763607,
0.052925799,
0.0196492337,
-0.0249208249,
-0.0536732376,
-0.045118589,
0.014441547,
0.0748682395,
0.0511412732,
-0.0236835293,
-0.0598284565,
-0.0170921274,
0.0278518144,
0.0712477341,
0.0516121611,
-0.0229047295,
0.0165162198,
-0.0647349432,
-0.0113860331,
-0.0018876549,
0.0093267001,
0.0123426626,
-0.0109139178,
-0.0008888309,
-0.0104698669,
0.0005043498,
0.0219225883,
0.0091049895,
0.0092468308,
-0.0150998896,
-0.016312981,
0.0031226622,
0.0340747349,
0.0126249259,
-0.0006173005,
-0.0099337753,
-0.0024384712,
0.0530442931,
0.0202790853,
0.0209793523,
-0.0298154857,
-0.0196377449,
0.0311644282,
0.0254991595,
0.0070732078,
-0.0195847359,
-0.026839992,
-0.0484444387,
0.0090685412,
-0.037377011,
0.033578746,
-0.0447097458,
0.0190167055,
-0.0003565381,
0.0238481574,
-0.0102862986,
0.0260016043,
0.0086815432,
-0.023650419,
0.0302462541,
0.0062498101,
0.0167174116,
-0.071683757,
0.0301490948,
0.0293672457,
0.0099413134,
0.0064724707,
0.0127431955,
0.0010987846,
-0.0473483242,
-0.0241951253,
-0.0900413841,
0.0103814583,
-0.0455403998,
-0.0207602829,
0.033333607,
0.0492470451,
-0.0240607578,
-0.0254826527,
-0.0397794172,
0.0074913139,
0.0095003592,
0.0079854159,
0.0338298976,
0.0356921069,
-0.026015887,
-0.0467837192,
0.0449225865,
0.010359765,
-0.023744816,
-0.0196373835,
-0.0102193458,
-0.0666060224,
-0.0020998523,
-0.0663726553,
0.032722339,
-0.0309573319,
-0.0422277004,
0.0118674776,
0.0334473439,
-0.0067800828,
0.0523357019,
0.0489774309,
0.0082299663,
-0.025109306,
-0.004026134,
-0.076350376,
0.0658324063,
-0.0364909023,
-0.0154998666,
-0.0431960523,
0.0042321854,
0.0549622662,
0.0143995499,
0.0112925088,
0.0576429702,
-0.0756456926,
0.0495654307,
0.0353613012,
-0.068434976,
0.0097214282,
0.0084583107,
-0.048810944,
0.0450358465,
-0.0082268259,
-0.0176364873,
0.0796755999,
-0.030190317,
-0.0372986384,
-0.0373360179,
-0.0038333249,
-0.0106044579,
0.0026465182,
-0.0167272035,
-0.000870322,
0.0753045082,
-0.0086005228,
-0.0285870079,
-0.0354474559,
0.0372929946,
-0.0300281532,
0.0568533242,
-0.008103922,
0.0029486332,
0.0373667926,
-0.0644530132,
-0.0524489023,
-0.0422910787,
-0.0139265433,
-0.0183785539,
-0.0074531087,
-0.0549157113,
-0.0468951911,
0.0172308665,
0.0362273566,
0.0465910695,
-0.0125473877,
-0.0203592256,
-0.0229122099,
0.0056310026,
0.0743535981,
0.0225065909,
0.0213612113,
0.0139765674,
0.0554088131,
0.0255110413,
-0.0018237059,
-0.0083557991,
0.0251219422,
-0.0315795541,
0.0074813152,
0.0139440969,
-0.0250806566,
0.0055987593,
0.0782815441,
-0.0111175636,
-0.0420057401,
0.1294656247,
0.0131812021,
-0.0102346772,
0.0036514087,
-0.0643162355,
0.0562836118,
0.0236282852,
0.028192753,
-0.0783395842,
-0.0351347812,
0.0192204528,
0.0365157723,
-0.030995192,
-0.0092891986,
-0.0250968598,
-0.099626027,
0.0519655682,
-0.0005953526,
0.0094071813,
-0.0406083539,
-0.015785804,
0.0264514387,
-0.0181949809,
0.0699837804,
0.0145365614,
0.0218591914,
-0.0064443168,
0.0145997461,
-0.0071510952,
-0.0463475436,
0.034036275,
0.0022610785,
0.0730968416,
0.0580051206,
0.0545601398,
0.0281078145,
-0.0406459644,
-0.0066312901,
-0.0059511894,
0.000055484,
-0.005932325,
0.0584857352,
-0.0320947394,
0.0019429972,
-0.0292114578,
0.0430136994,
-0.0090416353,
-0.0027216051,
0.0049207308,
-0.0003673032,
-0.0660652518,
0.0214868411,
-0.0147857377,
0.0506660342,
0.0417321026,
0.077548109,
0.0614915863,
-0.0501310639,
0.0225298163,
-0.0268501658,
-0.0109379422,
-0.0443401113,
-0.0451789983,
-0.0038831439,
0.0298369322,
0.0062339599,
-0.0678792223,
-0.0604083873,
-0.0103809834,
0.0402005985,
-0.0192353949,
-0.0166102257,
0.0083717909,
0.008894843,
0.0557904951,
0.0046297251,
-0.0429745875,
0.0061908807,
-0.0782231838,
-0.0146958642,
0.065273039,
-0.0552317575,
-0.0011573334,
0.0219127852,
-0.027985882,
-0.0608200915,
-0.0090331798,
0.0408671387,
0.0322243161,
0.0907955095,
-0.0248652641,
-0.0148708895,
-0.0432376489,
0.0320194066,
-0.0298334099,
0.0064858194,
0.0354172662,
0.0059476518,
-0.0168085527,
0.0522781834,
-0.0282023419,
0.0296431147,
-0.013326725,
0.0318207964,
-0.0621825345,
-0.0728058368,
0.0327118263,
0.0162712373,
0.0413478054,
0.0345049426,
-0.0216055643,
-0.0220073871,
0.0294736326,
-0.0050101145,
-0.0109533845,
-0.0418425016,
-0.0007254255,
-0.0110385884,
-0.0254660416,
-0.0091559645,
-0.0395947285,
-0.0443515666,
0.0016846862,
-0.0138475858,
-0.0486056805,
-0.0082672182,
-0.0038001451,
0.0007576035,
-0.0268405788,
-0.0231355485,
0.0686531961,
0.0309405029,
0.0708874688,
0.0051462743,
0.1180263311,
0.0343593024,
-0.0497919396,
0.0139490282,
0.0426240861,
-0.0748077631,
-0.0353906713,
-0.0295842364,
0.0112186708,
0.0131040951,
0.009525815,
0.0357580259,
-0.022694245,
0.0194481742,
-0.008304284,
0.0350178927,
0.0355225652,
-0.0242690686,
0.0242018476,
0.0385772437,
-0.0384388342,
0.0030406839,
0.0427189134,
-0.0088203736,
0.0635955408,
-0.017501073,
0.0192677286,
-0.0569291525,
-0.0360743962,
-0.0281139612,
0.0220209099,
0.0005022808,
0.0243101437,
-0.0634187162,
-0.0297465008,
-0.0035629091,
0.0034966341,
-0.0155160781,
-0.0528721251,
0.0508611426,
0.0559202284,
-0.0045431457,
-0.025386164,
-0.0237463415,
-0.0088573843,
0.0024640318,
0.0111129116,
-0.044090949,
-6.567015271e-33,
-0.0374406315,
-0.0016270108,
0.0215661675,
0.0181941744,
-0.0381417349,
-0.0521211475,
-0.0198376905,
-0.0039379112,
-0.0717890337,
-0.0003735219,
-0.0276776068,
0.0236824285,
0.019639045,
-0.0054465649,
-0.0260462314,
-0.0485060029,
0.0551858544,
0.0071004103,
-0.0584752746,
0.0379310101,
0.0575456545,
-0.0075517264,
0.0192081127,
-0.0921304598,
0.0118854819,
-0.020548176,
-0.0162448641,
0.0741940737,
-0.0107861869,
0.0606679581,
-0.0042268555,
0.0261208788,
-0.0000189218,
-0.0251860693,
-0.0115740811,
-0.0171947498,
-0.0300914738,
-0.0078709666,
0.0546986833,
0.0405909978,
-0.0018583857,
-0.0059545329,
0.0036574809,
-0.0303166416,
-0.0149841066,
0.0000101414,
-0.000836653,
-0.0253515206,
-0.0092410082,
0.027184533,
-0.0684640706,
0.0041530859,
-0.0024541386,
-0.0752942115,
-0.0178909637,
0.0786840245,
0.0084833708,
-0.0357262418,
-0.0516512841,
0.0295952503,
0.0027714975,
0.0224645324,
0.0211136993,
0.0455423407,
0.0131305391,
0.0588977002,
0.0299111381,
0.0207749978,
-0.0010509249,
-0.0446441472,
0.0120504452,
0.0540643223,
0.0029659758,
0.0585083812,
-0.0209974051,
-0.0278486684,
-0.0087278243,
-0.0132199349,
-0.015143428,
0.0342445225,
0.0109231807,
0.0178497564,
-0.0745699853,
-0.0016751986,
-0.0244556423,
0.0128472503,
-0.0385734141,
-0.018408915,
0.0514733233,
0.0209532864,
0.0037946205,
-0.0262278467,
0.0360870771,
-0.0210576858,
0.0399828032,
0.0323208198,
-0.0347125158,
0.0124918632,
-0.0089621469,
-0.0082764439,
-0.0327464491,
-0.0195128005,
0.0254978519,
0.0411272943,
0.0072522862,
0.0305652991,
0.0095386868,
0.0119002452,
-0.0280670673,
-0.0096956706,
-0.0176125672,
0.0542186424,
-0.0409532785,
-0.0095549077,
0.0060977465,
0.0133595606,
-0.0507833995,
0.057781186,
-0.0260301065,
-0.0313870274,
-0.057078369,
-0.0432225056,
0.003628717,
0.0250474978,
-0.0501325577,
-0.0061200629,
-0.0164357163,
-0.0295096375,
0.0092571527,
-0.0486106314,
-0.0243153609,
-0.0028698856,
2.859e-7,
-0.0279902704,
0.0310341343,
0.0267213769,
0.0278184004,
0.0146523984,
0.0656904504,
-0.0015971041,
0.0194551721,
0.0323618576,
-0.0603434443,
0.0281386133,
0.0099808518,
0.0427164249,
-0.0026610109,
-0.1137758866,
-0.0402817652,
-0.0665270165,
-0.0447487794,
-0.0307227541,
-0.0345211476,
0.0165141355,
0.0848646984,
0.0302598216,
0.0290281661,
0.0134944404,
-0.0232218616,
0.0407713354,
-0.021824779,
-0.0197061859,
0.0591571666,
0.0522997081,
0.0175804514,
0.0070547624,
0.0120522119,
0.0037169352,
0.0239077527,
-0.0220293794,
0.0640387684,
0.0004348078,
-0.0707032084,
-0.0407244414,
0.002261542,
0.0020912129,
-0.0432670712,
0.0391192697,
-0.0120416926,
-0.0155566614,
-0.003735438,
-0.0109092006,
-0.009407673,
0.0023629598,
-0.0169097856,
-0.0459731147,
0.0249824561,
0.0123721361,
0.0322937481,
0.0037519948,
-0.0608289801,
0.0102134449,
0.002038856,
-0.042950809,
-0.0395126529,
-0.0135960663,
-0.0407280363,
0.0315727182,
-0.0174013749,
0.0228474736,
2.255743354e-34,
0.0444894433,
0.012236977,
0.0431220308,
0.025942944,
0.0534500964,
0.0300016627,
0.0531689562,
0.000684251,
0.0464444496,
-0.0705729127,
-0.0015967629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09799v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09799v2 | How Far Can We Extract Diverse Perspectives from Large Language Models? | 2023-11-16T11:23:38 | 2024-02-18T09:50:59 | Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Minhwa Lee, Dheeraj Rajagopal, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Collecting diverse human opinions is costly and challenging. This leads to a
recent trend in collaborative efforts between humans and Large Language Models
(LLMs) for generating diverse data, offering potential scalable and efficient
solutions. However, the extent of LLMs' capability to generate diverse
perspectives on subjective topics remains an unexplored question. In this
study, we investigate LLMs' capacity for generating diverse perspectives and
rationales on subjective topics, such as social norms and argumentative texts.
We formulate a new problem of maximum diversity extraction from LLMs. Motivated
by how humans develop their opinions through their values, we propose a
criteria-based prompting technique to ground diverse opinions. To see how far
we can extract diverse perspectives from LLMs, or called diversity coverage, we
employ a step-by-step recall prompting for generating more outputs from the
model in an iterative manner. As we apply our methods to various tasks, indeed
we find that LLMs can generate diverse opinions according to the degree of task
subjectivity | [
0.0658702776,
0.0619319044,
0.0068844273,
0.0308930892,
-0.0530059338,
0.0057283347,
0.0012786365,
-0.034708105,
0.0112015484,
-0.0545994006,
-0.0223868396,
-0.0810735896,
-0.0025731297,
0.004676681,
-0.0108264573,
-0.0704111084,
0.0151953707,
-0.0421826504,
0.0722087324,
-0.0475558452,
0.0064957314,
0.0252481066,
0.0050465618,
0.008459148,
-0.0249235742,
-0.0034920287,
0.0131668542,
-0.0461650826,
0.0447283871,
0.0065608532,
0.0076290285,
0.054443717,
-0.0168674253,
0.0210838653,
0.0000018824,
-0.032691706,
0.0007546842,
-0.0319245793,
0.0333292186,
-0.0258855019,
0.0689835027,
0.043322593,
0.0103224553,
0.0079511078,
-0.0573084131,
0.0278695785,
-0.0039061229,
0.0748981088,
0.0677041337,
0.0668584704,
0.0057780859,
-0.0197524782,
-0.030328881,
-0.0143839568,
-0.0100094723,
-0.0187584516,
0.0300072357,
-0.0090457592,
0.003859472,
0.035791263,
0.0002355012,
0.0028862252,
0.0107252486,
-0.027233772,
0.0137439715,
0.0062122913,
0.0026253443,
-0.0235589128,
-0.0046242257,
0.0697339922,
0.0374455228,
0.0071725897,
0.0044451342,
-0.0023398565,
0.0166796912,
-0.0025373402,
-0.0241972096,
0.0564920716,
-0.0338958502,
0.0445188656,
0.0199682377,
0.0346448384,
0.0114818765,
0.0232421253,
-0.0275392812,
0.070697397,
-0.0041521178,
-0.018173147,
0.0341540873,
0.037335664,
0.002053783,
-0.0269254539,
0.009650195,
-0.0024189965,
-0.058644902,
0.0317896307,
-0.0143202851,
0.0062776823,
0.0421522781,
-0.0540088639,
0.0210313741,
-0.0184085034,
-0.0063070515,
0.069099471,
0.0507457517,
-0.0349044241,
-0.03184966,
-0.008557383,
-0.0282162968,
-0.0369923562,
-0.0442973822,
0.0068041682,
0.0235511363,
0.0260720607,
-0.0109398942,
0.0268135294,
0.000361778,
0.0041879443,
-0.0685852244,
-0.0130877923,
0.0227148477,
0.0353457518,
-0.0098689543,
-0.0508960113,
-0.0580028668,
0.0075597409,
-0.0772190839,
0.0052843839,
0.0283486508,
-0.0397498459,
0.0181739144,
0.0015270257,
0.0091425143,
-0.0367452018,
0.0006515577,
0.0126252947,
0.0115392487,
0.0033001387,
-0.0315398537,
-0.0236759242,
-0.0373029113,
-0.0654322803,
0.0042661964,
-0.0717667416,
0.0376051292,
-0.0061229421,
0.0024869139,
-0.0426926836,
0.0087526795,
0.0280726068,
-0.0299220514,
0.0384048447,
-0.0010985021,
-0.0020096903,
0.0606032498,
0.0078525515,
-0.0293359011,
0.0847773701,
-0.0215758756,
0.0249281004,
0.0378349796,
0.0317033529,
0.0056170672,
-0.0112103662,
0.0040992224,
0.0026513764,
-0.0036915722,
0.0271123666,
-0.0283720214,
0.0156085566,
-0.0027729024,
0.1097041219,
-0.0279985033,
-0.057978671,
0.0551159605,
0.0700807422,
-0.0290221889,
0.0224720333,
0.0280842017,
0.0233309511,
0.0048783845,
0.0222026613,
-0.0171850529,
0.0158413183,
-0.0014374639,
-0.0345523283,
0.0226569083,
0.0456303209,
-0.026242828,
-0.0646384656,
-0.0144230099,
-0.0199947078,
0.034986522,
-0.0015711295,
0.0241735559,
-0.0077774785,
0.0055512977,
0.0278845653,
0.0520478897,
-0.0590266734,
-0.0154939955,
-0.0245197378,
0.1013314426,
0.0610542111,
0.0227292776,
-0.0288827717,
-0.000912773,
-0.0277998317,
0.0265969541,
0.0417172499,
0.0948123783,
-0.0354238451,
-0.0038726318,
-0.0544383973,
-0.0151087977,
0.0108605027,
0.0137159657,
0.0465654284,
0.0318848491,
-0.0242223628,
-0.0006707368,
-0.0046104039,
-0.059227664,
0.0210547689,
-0.0054742843,
0.007659181,
0.0193408355,
0.0172945093,
0.0370025672,
0.0510017648,
-0.0242763106,
0.0133173419,
0.0049679335,
-0.0503490828,
-0.0674553141,
0.022939276,
-0.0811818391,
-0.0050112624,
0.0255563613,
-0.0793597475,
-0.0306383818,
-0.0038755368,
-0.0061550438,
-0.0103294998,
0.0184090436,
-0.010955642,
-0.044832956,
-0.0235884823,
-0.0215225089,
-0.0075907395,
-0.0125036351,
-0.049405247,
0.0764786154,
0.0119669978,
-0.003303288,
0.0166494213,
-0.0498865359,
0.0112389885,
-0.0401139446,
-0.0400304496,
0.028369084,
0.0205875095,
0.0217615888,
0.0694297925,
-0.001085724,
-0.0445441455,
-0.0510948487,
-0.1187875643,
-0.0265903547,
-0.0274822153,
-0.0184345804,
0.0134398537,
-0.0293586794,
0.027828956,
0.0179204624,
-0.0814383477,
-0.017561622,
-0.0057774363,
0.0314888582,
0.035925597,
-0.0010140797,
0.0425180905,
-0.0164435618,
-0.0186120477,
-0.0014429709,
0.0569497161,
0.0125056813,
0.0231164116,
-0.0441278778,
-0.0100480877,
-0.0666937977,
0.022739375,
-0.0096419603,
0.0159573164,
0.033350084,
-0.0077348682,
0.0575594604,
0.0711097941,
0.0662162825,
0.018723093,
0.0379996784,
0.0256339926,
-0.0522377864,
-0.0063658049,
-0.0348312259,
0.0610152297,
-0.0125943106,
-0.0312719904,
0.0363257974,
0.0496962592,
-0.0075613116,
-0.0211333744,
-0.0965618938,
0.0627410188,
-0.0392677374,
-0.0464852713,
-0.0274867881,
-0.0261685494,
-0.0398214422,
0.0570382327,
-0.0137479566,
-0.0247406494,
0.0816880316,
0.0213669501,
0.0415628105,
-0.0434779525,
0.0193685573,
-0.0636351407,
0.0485276952,
-0.0462099649,
0.0135433888,
-0.0006071011,
0.017233409,
-0.0362306125,
-0.0226117671,
0.0446642563,
-0.0496257655,
0.0632160679,
-0.0418674909,
0.002895206,
0.0165333878,
-0.0465217009,
-0.0532245487,
-0.0288841166,
-0.0329226144,
-0.0057536638,
0.0496721938,
0.0135899745,
0.0196229834,
-0.0316577666,
0.006867928,
-0.0280240569,
0.0011437321,
0.0134760533,
0.0177169796,
0.0003197618,
0.0420074426,
0.0178054515,
0.0409564674,
-0.0226267911,
0.0274584051,
0.0603112355,
0.0069965459,
-0.0045396625,
0.0088911699,
-0.018942738,
0.0332182646,
-0.0119289281,
-0.0200685635,
-0.0052637151,
0.0716452748,
0.0005313671,
-0.0028892667,
0.0947897434,
0.0313933901,
-0.0791052133,
-0.0093142102,
-0.0415962823,
0.0248265751,
0.010843779,
0.0092337914,
-0.0508372895,
0.0236159787,
-0.0177709721,
0.0198339317,
-0.0375499949,
-0.0470601246,
-0.015865054,
-0.1348076016,
0.0175946113,
0.0142629789,
0.0036833424,
-0.0110649103,
0.0086626299,
0.0070765289,
-0.0192072,
-0.0003735334,
0.0127543705,
0.0292195473,
0.0096932519,
0.0398242585,
0.0078705428,
-0.0352012217,
0.0539882593,
-0.0297959186,
0.0650825277,
0.0287072081,
0.0399552137,
0.0207540598,
-0.066624932,
0.0066167461,
-0.0048069474,
-0.0217013266,
-0.009318023,
0.0405208915,
-0.002337419,
-0.0018664845,
-0.0273085404,
0.0344056375,
-0.0188473705,
-0.0220133122,
0.0209794827,
0.0603984036,
-0.0118038729,
-0.033151947,
-0.0228099618,
0.0192168765,
0.0203504432,
0.0928441882,
0.0292939562,
-0.0814742744,
0.0056926589,
-0.04562952,
-0.0170777421,
-0.0797980949,
-0.0584455207,
-0.0091586672,
0.0062004575,
-0.0004418109,
-0.0921952724,
-0.0312494915,
-0.019171413,
0.0609748624,
-0.0020329601,
-0.0413678586,
0.0503778756,
0.0140275834,
0.0172973145,
0.0122637311,
-0.0160970893,
-0.0092828674,
-0.0417737663,
-0.0210781693,
0.0018145185,
-0.0412876643,
-0.0088609019,
-0.0012869234,
-0.0255223364,
-0.0778283402,
0.0425944291,
0.0269497428,
0.0255583059,
0.0582891479,
-0.0043251012,
-0.0492002219,
0.0561702996,
0.0249313768,
0.0121173626,
0.0119839553,
0.0346575528,
0.0410321727,
-0.0018352821,
0.0575911999,
-0.0108691445,
0.0201801732,
0.0190349184,
0.0193715561,
-0.019143723,
-0.0546025671,
0.0137712704,
0.0043822541,
0.0087237703,
0.0007461519,
-0.0270570219,
-0.0641967356,
-0.0466853976,
-0.036458876,
-0.0502876751,
-0.0370926037,
0.0186341815,
0.014722297,
-0.0592468679,
-0.0190746542,
-0.012748071,
-0.0085325474,
0.0660800785,
-0.0281364638,
-0.0113221575,
-0.0118002286,
0.0151303681,
0.0161610097,
-0.012702792,
-0.0256596804,
0.0430741794,
-0.0381865725,
0.0280875713,
0.0048386413,
0.0571159087,
0.0283710826,
-0.0280762669,
-0.0016709499,
0.0077831047,
-0.0565625727,
-0.0394152105,
0.000178174,
0.0476742089,
0.0058450205,
0.006289599,
0.0510386154,
-0.0101861982,
-0.0166950524,
-0.017703278,
0.007034699,
0.0312467404,
-0.0024649708,
0.0209661312,
0.02589936,
-0.031284865,
-0.0199162718,
0.0637612045,
-0.0640376508,
-0.0061534569,
0.0068661892,
-0.0178405568,
-0.0476803668,
-0.0271294601,
-0.0138036767,
-0.0089361761,
-0.0138662746,
0.0294855312,
-0.08133661,
-0.0246649198,
0.0331845172,
0.026293382,
0.0070842039,
-0.0195989311,
0.0392007306,
0.0836949721,
-0.0249906406,
0.0439477265,
-0.0704178512,
0.0268573277,
-0.0333399512,
0.0011515627,
-0.038231004,
-6.561468407e-33,
-0.0065655513,
-0.0210000128,
-0.0222483817,
-0.0005615065,
-0.0153206345,
-0.0209701248,
0.0046795104,
0.0573267043,
-0.0075774076,
0.0546522066,
-0.0060737124,
0.0112852668,
0.0062492341,
0.0306746066,
0.0243203696,
-0.0249920394,
0.0254593026,
-0.0225156602,
-0.03573668,
0.012441271,
0.0519198887,
-0.0116037382,
0.0139557337,
-0.0771231204,
0.0672508031,
0.0110215042,
0.0070951278,
0.0395227186,
-0.0066934107,
0.0313986987,
-0.0249916818,
0.0863443166,
0.0271351393,
-0.0636541545,
-0.0061574252,
0.0273170918,
-0.0234494042,
-0.0537981875,
0.0312115233,
-0.040259555,
-0.0418562405,
-0.0443772599,
0.0048775841,
-0.001005226,
-0.0219891723,
-0.0120373545,
0.0308144279,
-0.0169034004,
0.0180892292,
-0.0375465974,
-0.0404271968,
0.0338269658,
0.0052424474,
-0.0028444477,
-0.009438538,
0.0127034765,
-0.0008460743,
0.0487324372,
-0.0300376639,
0.0543472655,
-0.0006776905,
0.0054637967,
0.0054624286,
-0.0306726955,
-0.0018698936,
0.0893724188,
-0.008777353,
0.0469065867,
-0.0661776811,
-0.0395579711,
-0.0230856426,
0.0373505279,
0.0439718589,
0.0882450491,
-0.0103532858,
-0.0090161767,
-0.0243835356,
-0.0039202273,
0.0370092839,
-0.0105713923,
0.0369272977,
-0.0101727545,
-0.0369664691,
-0.0193014164,
-0.0178558435,
-0.0465778224,
-0.0115191573,
-0.0079089282,
-0.005740962,
0.0109408349,
-0.0700606555,
-0.0236421376,
0.0117936898,
-0.0269935783,
-0.0126699246,
0.0386273414,
-0.0311288405,
-0.0149210524,
0.017780073,
0.0074073435,
-0.057285253,
-0.0023251032,
-0.001642096,
0.0159330368,
-0.0094304308,
0.0025153139,
0.0229592454,
-0.0036596851,
-0.0511619337,
-0.0158275478,
-0.0287973695,
0.0458333716,
-0.0153676914,
0.041881185,
0.0253274217,
0.0236852393,
-0.0158963278,
0.0481581539,
0.0286927167,
0.0047127116,
-0.0267261006,
-0.0068511902,
-0.0160989631,
-0.0085745957,
-0.0238906443,
-0.0114110047,
0.000594083,
-0.0142620839,
0.0246070083,
0.0118100382,
-0.00803403,
-0.002538461,
2.514e-7,
0.0207251981,
0.0427501425,
0.0116590895,
-0.0104169259,
0.012188063,
0.051000677,
0.026089672,
0.0200145561,
0.0018734734,
-0.0502567738,
-0.0107115703,
0.0488579758,
0.058287546,
0.0783256516,
-0.0763409734,
-0.0261057205,
-0.0474895984,
0.0008598357,
-0.0036768264,
-0.0189741887,
0.0780680925,
0.0691709146,
0.0180716142,
-0.0011335812,
-0.0069289082,
-0.0054617696,
0.0811708793,
-0.0479087792,
-0.0297700912,
0.0172554683,
0.0877110511,
-0.0617641322,
0.0264621321,
-0.0123459473,
0.0278164744,
0.0130327968,
-0.0054808906,
0.0561809801,
0.0203686412,
-0.0491649546,
0.0032196096,
0.0003307141,
0.0080613969,
-0.0517173298,
0.060146071,
-0.0430397876,
-0.0460049361,
-0.0923683718,
0.0014366152,
0.0050690598,
0.0415981784,
-0.0363620445,
-0.0082584787,
0.0028876921,
0.0036402906,
-0.0054631992,
0.0055737686,
-0.0755570233,
-0.0285710339,
-0.0589166135,
-0.0596059673,
-0.0529741533,
0.0070368112,
0.043732103,
-0.0083292956,
-0.0412760489,
0.0479244776,
1.927576784e-34,
0.0675275922,
0.0139895044,
-0.0046744538,
-0.0095966347,
0.0438463576,
0.016232118,
-0.0509395003,
-0.0160706099,
0.0253318306,
-0.0409815907,
-0.018984694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09797v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09797v1 | KnowledgeMath: Knowledge-Intensive Math Word Problem Solving in Finance Domains | 2023-11-16T11:22:08 | 2023-11-16T11:22:08 | Yilun Zhao, Hongjun Liu, Yitao Long, Rui Zhang, Chen Zhao, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce KnowledgeMath, a novel benchmark designed to evaluate LLMs'
capabilities in applying financial knowledge to solve complex math word
problems. Compared to prior works, this study features three core advancements.
First, KnowledgeMath includes 1,259 problems with a hybrid of textual and
tabular content and require college-level knowledge in the finance domain for
effective resolution. Second, we provide expert-annotated, detailed solution
references in Python program format, ensuring a high-quality benchmark for LLM
assessment. Finally, we evaluate a wide spectrum of 14 LLMs with different
prompting strategies like Chain-of-Thoughts and Program-of-Thoughts. The
current best-performing system (i.e., GPT-4 with Program-of-Thoughts) achieves
only 45.4% accuracy, leaving substantial room for improvement. While
knowledge-augmented LLMs can improve the performance (e.g., from 23.9% to 32.0%
for GPT-3.5), it is still significantly lower the estimated human expert
performance of 94%. We believe that KnowledgeMath can facilitate future
research on domain-specific knowledge retrieval and augmentation into the math
word problem-solving process. We will release the benchmark and code at
https://github.com/yale-nlp/KnowledgeMath. | [
-0.0236919951,
0.0402689241,
0.0074895327,
0.0237519704,
-0.0294092633,
0.0178536028,
0.026653979,
0.047994554,
-0.0034429142,
-0.0132342614,
-0.0287455618,
-0.0017675718,
-0.0191195682,
0.0183127336,
0.0362009816,
-0.0032074244,
0.0242974367,
-0.0156558771,
0.0554470643,
-0.0014273248,
-0.0112021975,
-0.0279741343,
-0.0631490201,
-0.0141645717,
-0.0604706518,
-0.0360779613,
0.0150552159,
-0.045114059,
0.0131053422,
-0.0433932506,
0.0187785309,
0.0519514345,
0.0236032493,
0.0528617427,
0.0000022082,
-0.045090206,
-0.0372800007,
0.0067858002,
-0.0380354747,
0.0015402075,
-0.0048638196,
0.0122161359,
0.0637918338,
-0.0011051582,
-0.0972725898,
0.0494863726,
-0.0036871613,
0.0498995222,
0.0535918325,
0.0767947286,
-0.0063412129,
0.0143019296,
0.0040876898,
-0.0448525511,
0.0486671217,
-0.1083042249,
0.0077021229,
0.0614142381,
0.0147844683,
-0.0324393958,
-0.029881265,
0.0571834184,
0.0120011875,
0.0139464317,
0.056910228,
-0.0041791899,
-0.0136146266,
0.0329377912,
-0.0348625332,
0.0512707047,
0.049035538,
0.0771367848,
0.0091236364,
-0.0273728129,
0.013257307,
0.0642433614,
-0.0479073711,
0.0161135476,
-0.0253940988,
-0.0377671085,
-0.0515507832,
0.0097606052,
0.0086737666,
0.0200169757,
-0.0323921181,
0.0629012808,
-0.0246235859,
-0.0564582311,
0.061590299,
0.0143308798,
-0.0388894789,
-0.0217319448,
0.0616209768,
0.0565161593,
0.0160305984,
0.0035502387,
0.0058022942,
-0.0770055354,
-0.0179011188,
-0.0245923847,
0.0264793132,
0.069385618,
0.0167060848,
0.0431300253,
-0.0453112647,
0.0479699895,
-0.0071108681,
-0.0253075566,
-0.0240312051,
0.0615363084,
-0.0539110787,
-0.0139165921,
-0.0373678692,
0.0906116143,
-0.0146961436,
-0.021295134,
-0.0301701296,
-0.0109680695,
-0.0155207431,
0.0138048111,
-0.0008868714,
0.0053400588,
0.0135473413,
-0.0264175404,
-0.0878753141,
0.0157894921,
-0.0622143485,
0.0123929856,
0.0007322806,
0.0050077741,
-0.0071378769,
0.0037635618,
-0.037435662,
-0.0418841653,
0.0592772216,
0.1066506729,
-0.0064939689,
-0.0110592479,
-0.0054259561,
-0.0372371636,
0.0088659562,
-0.0464894995,
-0.0094213216,
-0.0596177541,
0.032697808,
0.0115897302,
-0.0368786044,
-0.0216041803,
0.0293277521,
-0.00108696,
0.0215080678,
0.0543749109,
0.0008944788,
-0.0365534611,
0.0448471867,
0.0101459259,
-0.0612287447,
0.033621408,
0.0359240398,
0.0091731949,
-0.0070352508,
0.0138577418,
0.0068706525,
0.0354292355,
0.0073319613,
-0.0312976278,
0.0305328295,
0.0286182966,
0.0107246656,
0.0542102419,
0.0133109456,
0.0161874574,
-0.0355261527,
0.0201791208,
0.0432552733,
0.0715687349,
0.0391922928,
0.0240002349,
-0.027999131,
0.021016473,
0.0725010782,
0.002821466,
-0.0342256278,
0.0494800471,
-0.0488260053,
0.0180122294,
0.015154399,
-0.0090181986,
-0.0010895982,
-0.0555290431,
-0.0147591336,
0.0264664143,
-0.0448417068,
0.0154957399,
0.0245220661,
-0.0496622436,
-0.0139938947,
0.0619954504,
-0.0152902873,
-0.01086629,
-0.0227158405,
-0.0188135915,
0.0468055084,
0.0479352809,
0.0735121816,
-0.0539482646,
-0.0203046724,
-0.0002133844,
-0.0270835292,
0.0288689453,
0.0432580709,
0.0115366839,
-0.0363957472,
-0.0501552373,
-0.0016370846,
-0.0287486427,
-0.0057148901,
-0.0115228659,
0.0477968007,
0.0144174164,
0.0185413118,
-0.0160741676,
0.0246562362,
0.0188685656,
-0.0142604169,
-0.0426352583,
0.0025870977,
-0.0103320433,
-0.0195086263,
0.0186087526,
0.0224080849,
0.0412623137,
-0.0288942643,
-0.0235285833,
-0.0265692305,
-0.0376025699,
-0.0631454587,
0.0015367517,
0.048074007,
-0.0572673082,
-0.0303463656,
-0.0230202917,
-0.014475177,
-0.0092916908,
0.0076560928,
-0.0294483341,
-0.0005244299,
-0.0344813466,
0.0024202738,
0.0281946696,
-0.0046732659,
-0.0060966318,
0.1109981388,
0.0088491114,
0.0476282686,
-0.0059957393,
-0.0309259668,
0.0102976616,
-0.0341009237,
0.0494307131,
-0.0671454817,
-0.0157600194,
0.0137383556,
-0.0203156713,
0.0170633718,
-0.0612534545,
-0.0173766986,
-0.0206075963,
0.0221638866,
0.0178320371,
0.060164094,
-0.0091889473,
-0.0369703472,
-0.0251489822,
-0.0030688604,
-0.0610230826,
0.0132651608,
-0.0224790964,
-0.0317786001,
0.0708391666,
0.0140878055,
0.0263800472,
-0.0554302558,
-0.0003641838,
-0.0214223024,
-0.0068461266,
0.0450361781,
-0.0318360142,
0.0116334101,
0.0449476391,
-0.0399712846,
0.0018102544,
0.0026596747,
0.046889428,
0.0226015002,
-0.0319256075,
0.0596983396,
0.0235849135,
0.0067023411,
0.0351258405,
-0.0107644722,
-0.0462310165,
-0.0640758574,
0.0344008394,
-0.0000307311,
0.0234910678,
0.018844923,
0.0133037129,
0.0105448356,
0.051209081,
-0.0235278811,
-0.0146586997,
-0.0151583599,
0.0608089492,
0.0193030462,
-0.0044520022,
-0.0729630962,
0.0457769372,
0.0098331114,
0.0488718078,
0.0081370603,
-0.0146982335,
0.0753344968,
0.0066948105,
-0.0112982215,
-0.0170059483,
-0.006344235,
-0.0671963692,
0.014973307,
-0.0443816334,
-0.0367447808,
-0.0695316866,
-0.0413752347,
-0.0556231253,
-0.0047107837,
0.0449210443,
-0.0316931009,
0.0904486701,
-0.0546984747,
0.0179217458,
-0.026492307,
-0.0187439155,
-0.0214143023,
-0.023399625,
-0.0136139924,
0.0136120915,
0.0403713435,
-0.0466395058,
-0.045299273,
-0.0331740901,
0.0731058121,
-0.0176204108,
-0.0191146042,
-0.0439680591,
-0.003133795,
0.0424111187,
0.0243635252,
0.0445297845,
0.0531588122,
-0.0474879332,
0.0231316853,
0.0163351092,
0.064124696,
-0.0069038882,
0.0407055058,
0.0140874982,
-0.0048573948,
-0.0717045888,
0.0105472906,
0.037128862,
-0.0309471134,
-0.0463085286,
0.0022358394,
0.0906757936,
0.053853862,
-0.0050895652,
-0.0277854931,
-0.067439504,
-0.0271110944,
0.0067500854,
0.0678083748,
-0.1215452403,
-0.0160258878,
-0.0042264732,
0.013695891,
0.0236031413,
-0.0717252716,
-0.0332016461,
-0.0965650305,
0.0191596635,
-0.0106433183,
0.0138301533,
-0.0164946709,
0.0247755926,
-0.0326338261,
0.009579137,
-0.0112737007,
0.0222485904,
-0.0055808276,
0.0361340269,
0.0144618154,
-0.034010835,
0.053638842,
0.0247221831,
-0.0027364527,
-0.0598992631,
0.0110889617,
0.002239231,
-0.0393322706,
-0.0904066339,
-0.0275752824,
0.050670363,
-0.0174953602,
0.0056478763,
0.0218917243,
-0.0327532962,
-0.0063368687,
-0.0068210335,
0.0287145562,
-0.0558045134,
0.0153787229,
0.0602479503,
0.0370869227,
-0.0299789514,
0.007394372,
-0.0047871633,
0.0215425249,
-0.0413063467,
0.0683315247,
0.0087806452,
0.0018236258,
-0.0199919418,
-0.0070773163,
-0.0177770089,
-0.050876487,
0.0000523485,
-0.0117792226,
0.0589541942,
0.0612917133,
-0.073810108,
-0.0348859504,
0.07807298,
0.0680748373,
-0.0071858778,
-0.0078241946,
0.0000573697,
0.0014505456,
-0.0476365536,
0.0229461007,
-0.0552745908,
0.0342369191,
-0.0485571809,
0.01333977,
-0.0272944793,
-0.0417044312,
-0.0517425761,
0.0541669689,
-0.1080578789,
-0.0347419716,
-0.0290326402,
0.0042240792,
0.0210786983,
-0.0434545986,
-0.0120573677,
0.0232706517,
0.0200228095,
0.0518587008,
-0.0846197978,
0.0157572422,
0.0162608009,
0.0536157526,
-0.00180636,
0.0173095297,
-0.0231699683,
-0.0088058636,
-0.0236405414,
0.0711172074,
-0.0146365548,
-0.0021818222,
-0.0025577771,
0.0349980332,
-0.0097443154,
0.0397837982,
-0.0114058852,
-0.0242415611,
0.0011371875,
-0.0111836903,
-0.0062030652,
-0.0278386194,
-0.0529596321,
0.0084586637,
-0.0195727926,
0.0129064806,
0.005788059,
0.0361089818,
-0.0068242708,
0.0206128545,
0.0296576824,
0.0036829193,
-0.0165754706,
0.0437691808,
-0.047484491,
0.0252164919,
0.0056878417,
0.0121169798,
0.0373576619,
0.0142736472,
0.0555465892,
-0.0011444767,
-0.0006402355,
-0.0350157358,
-0.033021424,
-0.0239790231,
-0.0913093314,
0.0197749883,
0.0556577481,
0.0064834887,
-0.0130123692,
-0.0603740774,
-0.0504520871,
0.006922151,
0.0216097664,
-0.0301986653,
-0.0079688253,
0.0149636324,
0.0272449665,
0.0486356877,
0.0054044365,
-0.0578277819,
0.0779532716,
-0.0258023627,
0.0043294942,
-0.0179461371,
-0.0036308109,
-0.0363040604,
-0.0468586087,
0.0060297842,
0.0308007319,
0.0190815404,
0.0129331145,
-0.1092314646,
-0.0244858675,
0.0194364637,
-0.0154379783,
-0.0211448893,
-0.0002980077,
0.0439115986,
0.0608129539,
-0.0116458517,
0.0200152174,
0.0272830874,
0.0642688572,
-0.0324267112,
-0.0274576452,
-0.0328044258,
-6.255785509e-33,
-0.029692743,
-0.0730425268,
0.0746414661,
0.0148408869,
0.0224951394,
0.0123663303,
-0.0245358534,
0.0268465113,
-0.0023006743,
-0.0032758005,
-0.0253736228,
0.0081063733,
-0.0000394245,
-0.0046990793,
0.0064576138,
-0.0129587157,
-0.0443062782,
-0.0380864143,
-0.0212499052,
-0.0839352384,
-0.0011821467,
0.0668860897,
0.0675682724,
-0.0238131508,
0.033702597,
0.0116919987,
0.0079222163,
-0.0010490279,
0.0279121138,
0.0202554129,
-0.0333911777,
0.0252310373,
0.0171470493,
-0.0714074522,
-0.0119715529,
-0.0462558605,
-0.021636514,
-0.0581570156,
0.0070562596,
-0.0057911826,
-0.0459772497,
-0.0187109355,
0.0436397418,
0.0083294399,
-0.0272390079,
-0.0249802507,
0.0199905075,
-0.0230611842,
0.0006620857,
-0.0299146269,
-0.0314449221,
0.0059389174,
-0.0072924551,
0.0176476389,
0.0387960635,
-0.0041520465,
0.0029475591,
-0.0070869187,
-0.020875372,
-0.0016525387,
0.003623818,
0.0373648889,
0.0411143154,
-0.0479245894,
-0.0153889358,
0.0294947345,
-0.0266072359,
-0.0324438214,
-0.018165322,
-0.0146311019,
0.0095261419,
0.0487836488,
0.0855504349,
0.0282226801,
0.0476116352,
-0.0128415395,
0.0074308976,
0.0215614904,
0.016476132,
0.0160962753,
-0.0194761585,
0.0092540905,
-0.0219070166,
0.0046948148,
-0.0237749014,
0.04770796,
-0.0707684457,
-0.0041266582,
0.0151098939,
-0.0104077002,
0.0391350277,
0.0026913793,
-0.0225961581,
0.0024413615,
-0.0107511692,
-0.0126571888,
0.0260239989,
0.0273036025,
0.006778318,
-0.0000688699,
-0.0529733859,
0.0142580885,
-0.0092809899,
0.0339432731,
0.0301841702,
-0.0099510467,
0.0058735139,
-0.0156793315,
-0.0342831984,
-0.0311414078,
-0.0267706718,
0.0229188912,
0.0441157594,
0.0023726197,
-0.0184782483,
0.017000014,
-0.0214652698,
-0.0174622089,
-0.031624727,
-0.0358732007,
0.0064040171,
0.0198828317,
-0.0067963721,
0.0221039206,
0.020461129,
0.0218392536,
0.0107849967,
0.0057926662,
0.0304478202,
-0.004253082,
0.000718516,
0.0298110675,
3.009e-7,
0.0507596321,
0.0753660351,
0.0323930159,
0.0050408831,
-0.0051650722,
0.0189952124,
-0.0458172895,
-0.0341099352,
-0.0004411999,
-0.0553160012,
0.0394509286,
0.0771250054,
0.0593690053,
0.0267858505,
-0.0534952581,
-0.0687557906,
-0.0110481884,
0.0031678823,
-0.0561044812,
0.0219728779,
0.0490324311,
-0.0051935883,
0.0229467414,
-0.0282673426,
-0.0067212023,
-0.0575931035,
0.0328040943,
-0.026760634,
0.0034060522,
-0.0129151661,
0.0258469284,
0.0005052192,
0.0084297471,
0.036608927,
-0.0158455465,
0.0294406079,
0.0547256656,
0.0440554172,
0.0582912527,
-0.0052887686,
-0.0157606211,
-0.0183835421,
-0.0026162104,
-0.0045269644,
0.0194703676,
-0.0519302674,
-0.0293081049,
-0.0092818523,
-0.0365313366,
-0.0174730197,
0.0221213419,
0.0025815114,
0.0382502712,
0.020638885,
0.0134648234,
-0.0051454813,
-0.0020846971,
-0.0477818549,
-0.0253158975,
0.0349654332,
-0.0480506979,
0.0100854672,
-0.0638860986,
-0.0085424352,
0.0349378213,
-0.0459215306,
-0.0204601586,
2.432001155e-34,
0.030349616,
-0.0298184864,
0.0102772936,
0.0595637076,
0.0578741506,
0.0142854201,
-0.0556020327,
0.0321597531,
-0.000592607,
-0.0812459737,
0.0022092394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09796v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09796v2 | Interpreting User Requests in the Context of Natural Language Standing Instructions | 2023-11-16T11:19:26 | 2024-03-07T16:49:07 | Nikita Moghe, Patrick Xia, Jacob Andreas, Jason Eisner, Benjamin Van Durme, Harsh Jhamtani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Users of natural language interfaces, generally powered by Large Language
Models (LLMs),often must repeat their preferences each time they make a similar
request. We describe an approach to LLM-based dialogue modeling in which
persistent user constraints and preferences -- collectively termed standing
instructions -- as additional context for such interfaces. For example, when a
user states "I'm hungry", a previously expressed preference for Persian food
can be automatically added to the LLM prompt, influencing the search for
relevant restaurants. We develop NLSI, a language-to-program dataset consisting
of over 2.4K dialogues spanning 17 domains, where each dialogue is paired with
a user profile (a set of users specific standing instructions) and
corresponding structured representations (API calls). A key challenge in NLSI
is to identify which subset of the standing instructions is applicable to a
given dialogue. NLSI contains diverse phenomena, from simple preferences to
interdependent instructions such as triggering a hotel search whenever the user
is booking tickets to an event. We conduct experiments on NLSI using prompting
with large language models and various retrieval approaches, achieving a
maximum of 44.7% exact match on API prediction. Our results demonstrate the
challenges in identifying the relevant standing instructions and their
interpretation into API calls. | [
0.0758724734,
0.0676895157,
-0.026436612,
0.0387893319,
-0.0395013355,
-0.0139927398,
-0.0239551924,
-0.0088254781,
0.0727120042,
-0.0567086861,
-0.0308383331,
-0.0381637476,
-0.0011681895,
0.0182662513,
-0.0173519347,
-0.0592116863,
0.0301129986,
-0.0418920405,
0.0127904685,
0.0188853461,
0.0134483362,
0.0333558246,
-0.0064809206,
0.0637950525,
0.0031199194,
-0.0299853012,
-0.0005897523,
-0.0018169301,
-0.033639878,
-0.0546923839,
0.0134409526,
0.04691438,
0.0219741203,
-0.0202747285,
0.0000021113,
-0.0764636695,
-0.010756799,
-0.0186428316,
-0.038359344,
-0.0082359863,
0.0280264467,
0.0219938308,
0.0251028035,
-0.0040475428,
-0.0470743068,
-0.0067607393,
0.0403451324,
0.0431790687,
0.0586405136,
0.0480771624,
0.0100179836,
-0.0268300846,
-0.0422387384,
0.0047229817,
0.0171770211,
-0.0432476625,
0.0174315982,
-0.0345594585,
0.0185730159,
0.0484373197,
0.0289541967,
0.0023636257,
0.0009769903,
-0.0053921784,
-0.0406712741,
0.0110942414,
-0.0727905929,
-0.0180354957,
-0.0073484308,
0.0900228545,
0.0400980711,
0.0096253445,
0.0194137394,
0.0117024649,
-0.0078933854,
0.0033034058,
-0.047820501,
0.0015141898,
-0.0226871055,
-0.0102881193,
0.0161905847,
0.0163868107,
0.0135946563,
0.0204819031,
-0.0330656171,
0.0786640421,
0.0096175326,
-0.0216825027,
-0.0112270247,
-0.0260103177,
-0.0103906998,
-0.066617772,
0.0202067383,
0.0262592286,
-0.1034141257,
0.0434945002,
-0.0274231173,
0.0529154018,
0.0276258215,
-0.0376456566,
0.0447752699,
0.0659279823,
-0.0303690024,
0.0407272391,
-0.0003691103,
0.0542496964,
-0.0130660003,
-0.028889861,
-0.043835517,
-0.0070603322,
-0.0504795127,
-0.0080430564,
-0.0145962285,
0.0387244411,
-0.055179283,
-0.0202943236,
-0.0130961956,
0.0587961525,
0.0045028515,
0.0314432606,
-0.0202106908,
0.0248797908,
-0.0270052999,
0.0166761652,
-0.0762805194,
0.0172896702,
-0.0320550315,
-0.0078210421,
0.024566168,
-0.0375508256,
0.010855535,
0.0018309548,
0.0144158145,
-0.0106844855,
-0.0106441416,
0.0512782633,
0.0179884601,
-0.0126020974,
-0.0277536828,
-0.0678338781,
-0.0030099149,
-0.0487834327,
-0.0371369235,
-0.05437598,
0.054413598,
0.0266609099,
-0.0163729973,
-0.0429416262,
0.0219639316,
0.0698289871,
-0.0110721448,
0.0851237774,
0.0396248363,
0.0049753301,
0.0134016201,
0.0312058534,
-0.0076206615,
0.0376509167,
-0.0055444278,
0.0362513922,
0.0387303755,
0.0093238531,
-0.0212363396,
0.0250950996,
-0.0298528541,
0.0101210922,
-0.0168536585,
0.0754575208,
0.0092576332,
0.0313055553,
-0.0123035554,
0.0453237928,
-0.032600455,
-0.0195378102,
0.0486343242,
0.1088441461,
-0.0198876243,
-0.004372688,
0.0410098098,
0.0240854882,
-0.0136698419,
0.0180695392,
-0.0556845404,
0.0022946263,
-0.0182264317,
-0.0255841818,
0.0605840422,
0.0001277792,
-0.0260422472,
-0.0338577926,
0.0291744638,
-0.0157122295,
0.0217828471,
0.0337690003,
0.0195210744,
0.0002857346,
-0.0399189852,
0.0360671505,
0.007815131,
-0.0403240286,
-0.0021117076,
-0.0359698012,
0.0289495438,
0.1261662394,
0.0510159358,
-0.0181341581,
-0.0167227015,
0.0023344958,
0.0119595248,
0.0212016907,
0.0257175155,
-0.0182812475,
0.0202580895,
-0.0197975487,
-0.0459185801,
0.0274985433,
-0.0024452272,
0.0071401773,
0.022448618,
0.0267613549,
0.017670976,
0.0001286116,
-0.0112128574,
-0.0057364115,
-0.0252702665,
-0.0405509472,
0.0221653357,
0.0235613696,
0.0260592438,
0.0258577894,
0.0472809114,
0.0039826105,
0.0139578208,
-0.0329489484,
0.0051307892,
0.0046877069,
-0.075324513,
-0.004238422,
0.0229902063,
-0.0017625091,
-0.0121881859,
0.0123480083,
-0.0051000612,
-0.0392190516,
0.0086111054,
-0.0058642766,
0.0692443326,
-0.0233271159,
0.0099944705,
0.0378435329,
-0.0022109686,
-0.0317628048,
0.0551256835,
-0.0067453408,
0.0157876201,
0.0214567762,
0.0099137733,
0.0212383755,
-0.0532956533,
0.0014296324,
-0.0035293009,
0.0023151475,
0.0238169916,
0.043358095,
0.030743232,
-0.0442720205,
0.014120155,
-0.1298378557,
0.0030379067,
-0.0226938855,
0.0026552312,
-0.0066048764,
0.0594044775,
-0.0075742803,
-0.0324860699,
-0.0357516743,
-0.0613496751,
0.0031748775,
0.0286412463,
0.0288513154,
0.0284719151,
-0.0326779187,
-0.0425009206,
0.0130986758,
-0.0181904268,
0.018096406,
-0.0213775374,
-0.0166154318,
-0.0697661713,
-0.0062420396,
-0.0312184524,
0.0258302726,
-0.0153501835,
-0.0123742409,
0.0388956778,
-0.014304677,
0.0491967238,
0.0634618923,
0.0078864219,
0.0074930787,
0.0246839561,
-0.0018173284,
-0.1102700457,
0.0123580126,
-0.0304732043,
-0.0195652228,
-0.0151654053,
-0.0481622294,
0.0732028633,
0.0147644617,
0.0254913494,
0.0344800055,
-0.04577443,
0.0060004285,
0.0084225135,
0.0072027664,
-0.0242280029,
0.0117858481,
-0.0128204348,
0.0862163529,
0.0159747936,
-0.0452541299,
0.0791456252,
-0.0233507007,
0.0050505307,
-0.04311046,
-0.0266873762,
-0.0473195016,
0.0859132931,
-0.0006342822,
0.0455471985,
0.0337100439,
-0.0472899824,
-0.035309419,
-0.008752686,
-0.0026416669,
-0.0461241081,
0.0575780794,
-0.0427167155,
0.0159294158,
0.0375313126,
-0.0520578846,
-0.0715034306,
-0.0667086616,
-0.0390924551,
-0.0309386142,
0.0074836151,
-0.0324882753,
-0.0066592474,
-0.0066947602,
-0.0125436662,
0.0295796767,
-0.0021857303,
-0.0232738666,
-0.021662334,
-0.0361486189,
0.0670671836,
0.0289023649,
-0.0384365655,
0.026551092,
0.0131834298,
0.026149895,
0.017749453,
-0.0022152013,
-0.014954037,
0.015138668,
0.0481024981,
-0.0380065963,
-0.0107551478,
0.0378669985,
0.0204069447,
-0.0395115092,
-0.0256579239,
0.1099709272,
0.0547517352,
-0.0743257105,
-0.0006304354,
-0.0452171639,
0.031664364,
0.0274585653,
0.0615945011,
-0.0840366483,
-0.054087013,
-0.0127429795,
0.0395386964,
-0.0078618769,
-0.0280807037,
-0.0301966202,
-0.1362332553,
0.0077805012,
-0.0108199976,
-0.0170427095,
-0.0143504348,
-0.0537562631,
0.0091803512,
0.0105141411,
0.011768749,
-0.0172643214,
-0.0094257016,
-0.019892985,
-0.0136403814,
-0.015920002,
-0.045056466,
0.041596178,
-0.0147991711,
0.0269603953,
0.0850306302,
0.0200011879,
0.0384107977,
-0.0340511203,
0.0258057099,
0.0123786153,
0.0050923103,
-0.03896356,
0.0113890441,
0.0028435686,
-0.0027054085,
-0.0357694924,
0.0435023122,
-0.0580043122,
-0.0221119877,
0.0255282521,
0.0565261804,
-0.0538972095,
0.036663305,
-0.0088611934,
0.0209133942,
0.0600920692,
0.0769459829,
0.0294845924,
-0.0615131296,
-0.0096249152,
-0.0691275746,
-0.00987597,
-0.0271280389,
-0.0315726288,
0.0051557384,
-0.0206004195,
0.0475261882,
-0.0589359924,
-0.0110384012,
0.0204399247,
-0.0036273962,
0.0346820727,
0.0292473175,
0.0342937075,
0.0026071565,
-0.0033403232,
0.0411105715,
-0.0401991382,
0.0017464141,
-0.0679020882,
-0.0337274633,
0.0723916888,
-0.0333450288,
-0.0056380937,
0.0129168145,
-0.024681326,
-0.0511786602,
-0.0529190451,
0.0828827322,
0.0191894043,
0.070530802,
-0.0053292676,
-0.0215834342,
-0.0286314487,
0.0377392061,
-0.0146197509,
-0.0487966388,
0.0050588776,
0.0703768283,
-0.0038067205,
0.0449172556,
-0.0597233213,
-0.0049667913,
-0.0540594272,
0.0337884724,
-0.0447022021,
-0.0805322751,
0.0383241847,
0.0138173718,
0.012139908,
-0.0023384446,
-0.0061226622,
-0.0001008198,
0.0198033098,
-0.0037178621,
-0.0401744433,
-0.0313007385,
0.0098480275,
0.0102375085,
-0.0222724695,
0.0128562041,
-0.0363561958,
-0.0452759936,
0.0308061372,
-0.0372607671,
-0.0117359692,
0.0189839397,
0.0077522001,
0.0227167867,
0.0112385117,
-0.0386282653,
0.0470592789,
0.0058941776,
0.0541424081,
-0.0556304343,
0.0687591881,
0.0137638878,
0.00401492,
-0.0178176239,
0.0346925333,
-0.0211265944,
-0.0944983587,
0.0590033494,
-0.0470632426,
0.0159028266,
-0.0494682007,
0.0231073834,
-0.0229537003,
0.0276916251,
-0.0239960533,
0.0326319896,
0.0160538647,
-0.0242209528,
0.0026403775,
0.0270060748,
-0.0314063244,
0.0057596932,
0.054874327,
-0.022370087,
0.0255286209,
0.0102191493,
-0.0223814007,
-0.0472393632,
-0.0281648897,
-0.0117032118,
0.0499133244,
-0.040631637,
-0.0251235161,
-0.029895639,
-0.0363645554,
-0.0129002891,
-0.0205826331,
-0.036353223,
-0.0169009287,
0.0517056994,
0.0424185097,
0.0161408801,
-0.0234044883,
-0.0347779021,
-0.0055420902,
-0.037181709,
-0.0496141426,
-0.0455684811,
-6.237323636e-33,
-0.0201047529,
-0.0326703489,
0.0353759006,
0.0050300406,
0.003648537,
-0.0447701178,
-0.0376715139,
-0.0065203793,
-0.0034099754,
-0.0491422005,
-0.0068642744,
-0.0134964734,
0.018072689,
0.0321756974,
0.0164764784,
-0.0447672382,
0.0332205817,
0.0130387917,
-0.0204478707,
0.0336356163,
0.0747630671,
0.0024749148,
-0.0069407192,
-0.1101391688,
0.0398059636,
-0.0103194034,
0.0175740588,
0.0384519473,
-0.0089651011,
0.0761724189,
-0.0114254719,
0.0500465743,
0.0164431669,
-0.0083350027,
-0.010258886,
0.0404365882,
-0.0534810536,
-0.0389076807,
0.0588603504,
0.0191197414,
-0.0234788787,
-0.034401089,
0.0216166899,
-0.0216188226,
-0.0030055409,
0.0525684208,
0.031929642,
0.0036599233,
-0.0319894627,
0.0325812586,
-0.0425045006,
-0.0117205372,
-0.003568779,
-0.0353481285,
-0.0192592237,
0.0804560333,
0.0038044848,
0.0297239516,
-0.0197246578,
0.025706308,
-0.023988843,
0.0240698159,
0.0371236168,
0.035004504,
0.0219550338,
0.0731201917,
0.0028093029,
-0.0023430712,
-0.002416888,
-0.0360832699,
-0.0076654903,
0.0349572562,
-0.0483572893,
0.0011270391,
0.0017849187,
-0.0181978848,
-0.0194344521,
0.0204183795,
0.0294596404,
0.0017533717,
0.0270123072,
0.0047263759,
-0.0250276513,
-0.0323875248,
-0.0282406546,
-0.0038982306,
-0.0470175333,
-0.031570863,
0.0692441761,
0.0153654274,
-0.0082470793,
-0.0260929633,
0.0161827859,
-0.0154646458,
-0.0544412397,
0.0076583354,
-0.0078064431,
-0.0392207652,
0.0001908089,
0.0413640179,
-0.0258779339,
-0.0245333482,
-0.0154906567,
-0.0496870242,
0.0250070561,
0.0420441367,
0.0002021127,
0.0165133495,
-0.0460634157,
-0.000773293,
-0.0247999523,
0.003993894,
-0.0526707359,
0.0330936424,
0.0582936592,
0.0089281881,
-0.0314879566,
0.0937504023,
0.005223833,
-0.0010339007,
-0.0651513115,
-0.0534068123,
0.0172852539,
0.0044020251,
-0.017234819,
-0.0050631906,
-0.0288798995,
0.0334035829,
0.0148475394,
-0.0220321342,
-0.0030825769,
-0.0135286823,
2.847e-7,
-0.0017387901,
0.0513692386,
-0.0165694933,
0.0584759302,
-0.0240945052,
0.047203593,
0.0106565086,
0.0239694249,
0.0047220397,
-0.0148387244,
-0.0009594462,
0.0108960718,
0.0036566032,
0.015248484,
-0.1039473936,
0.0126767093,
-0.0147546167,
0.0098995157,
-0.0829494372,
-0.0058037648,
0.074696444,
0.0655730292,
-0.0000177403,
0.0198250245,
-0.0110078799,
-0.0463892668,
0.0282469671,
-0.0636199042,
-0.006848074,
-0.0054755379,
-0.0205158331,
0.0313096084,
0.0231701527,
-0.0151580609,
-0.0209116545,
0.0108562466,
0.0072543584,
0.0797010735,
0.0091671096,
-0.0553215593,
-0.0216223598,
0.0041207788,
0.0038242512,
-0.0123289535,
0.0472244993,
-0.0278600175,
0.0116332201,
-0.0097256592,
0.0260350145,
-0.0245592948,
-0.0042516789,
-0.0123592122,
-0.0079593081,
0.0193326399,
0.015242557,
0.0058628446,
0.0103460616,
-0.0751351714,
0.0119935703,
-0.0021314949,
-0.0272436552,
-0.0086954795,
-0.065583013,
0.0240307711,
-0.0146528175,
-0.0208359212,
0.0018621201,
2.626575087e-34,
0.0039434321,
0.0300339665,
0.0282651763,
0.0393698774,
0.0552515276,
0.0239097942,
-0.0217816327,
0.0324957259,
0.0663798824,
-0.066778414,
-0.0258796103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10781v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10781v2 | Can Language Model Moderators Improve the Health of Online Discourse? | 2023-11-16T11:14:22 | 2024-05-06T17:44:12 | Hyundong Cho, Shuai Liu, Taiwei Shi, Darpan Jain, Basem Rizk, Yuyang Huang, Zixun Lu, Nuan Wen, Jonathan Gratch, Emilio Ferrara, Jonathan May | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Conversational moderation of online communities is crucial to maintaining
civility for a constructive environment, but it is challenging to scale and
harmful to moderators. The inclusion of sophisticated natural language
generation modules as a force multiplier to aid human moderators is a
tantalizing prospect, but adequate evaluation approaches have so far been
elusive. In this paper, we establish a systematic definition of conversational
moderation effectiveness grounded on moderation literature and establish design
criteria for conducting realistic yet safe evaluation. We then propose a
comprehensive evaluation framework to assess models' moderation capabilities
independently of human intervention. With our framework, we conduct the first
known study of language models as conversational moderators, finding that
appropriately prompted models that incorporate insights from social science can
provide specific and fair feedback on toxic behavior but struggle to influence
users to increase their levels of respect and cooperation. | [
0.1057215333,
0.0653502867,
-0.0322796479,
-0.0023613684,
-0.0323618688,
-0.0066660149,
0.0520250723,
0.0127867116,
0.0181247983,
-0.042267438,
-0.0050420421,
-0.0254827775,
-0.018159179,
0.060261894,
0.0019751075,
-0.0472705774,
-0.0072285519,
-0.000059306,
0.035867922,
0.0241680071,
0.0752984285,
-0.0016778011,
0.0150647666,
0.0651172549,
-0.0024161984,
0.041315645,
0.0385133252,
0.009740944,
0.0179750249,
-0.0207756571,
0.0392347276,
0.0715861693,
0.0012757492,
0.0397308134,
0.0000020116,
-0.0569614023,
0.0282772519,
0.0061602169,
0.0199669246,
-0.0091240685,
0.1088440642,
-0.0247068647,
-0.0128547726,
0.0514117926,
-0.0369103067,
0.0240762215,
0.0350070409,
0.0099509554,
0.0572022945,
0.0336950831,
-0.0296408776,
-0.0208383054,
-0.0042461804,
0.0060420926,
-0.0482449532,
0.0250351578,
0.0297202989,
0.0186166298,
-0.0275023729,
0.0063452534,
0.0060135857,
0.0103082079,
-0.0074597099,
-0.0584077202,
0.0178702474,
-0.0306172669,
-0.0180603825,
-0.0727992207,
0.007593805,
0.0693784282,
0.0536414273,
-0.0263679288,
0.0377144143,
-0.0048902761,
0.0213838518,
0.056407135,
-0.0538513176,
0.0216535218,
-0.0067966711,
-0.0146257943,
-0.0021350482,
0.0343767442,
0.0455800369,
0.0432402864,
0.0692916438,
0.0378528945,
-0.0014961819,
-0.0125329597,
-0.0377585478,
0.0041724746,
0.0074344808,
-0.0192779079,
0.0128623648,
0.0164221879,
-0.0693880916,
0.0225658566,
0.0024497076,
-0.0156867653,
0.0511619151,
-0.0764528736,
0.006650182,
0.0225216523,
0.0142708281,
0.0302448273,
0.0426728874,
-0.0160072781,
0.0001000363,
0.0224477891,
0.0113950819,
0.0019101242,
-0.0362755992,
-0.0005442348,
-0.0191910751,
-0.0478372462,
0.0149886934,
0.0183081757,
-0.02932702,
0.0085286964,
-0.0650663748,
-0.023905959,
0.0251380764,
0.0261006858,
-0.0059637679,
-0.0019293195,
-0.0337304659,
-0.0048176767,
-0.0499324091,
0.0258197952,
0.0042326842,
-0.0792283937,
0.0345431343,
0.0148325674,
-0.0130980685,
0.0095093288,
0.0172575619,
0.0815088004,
0.0265664738,
-0.0035885698,
-0.0150712887,
-0.0497644134,
-0.0389074199,
-0.019194128,
-0.0416146405,
-0.0651797503,
0.038649451,
-0.0045247041,
-0.012158691,
-0.0371509455,
0.0319949314,
0.0182548016,
-0.0448593833,
0.0392580256,
-0.0653949529,
0.0103174495,
0.0547198206,
0.0578873865,
-0.0077844183,
0.0434052832,
0.019775128,
-0.0111227436,
0.0392670818,
0.0096902484,
0.0023408474,
0.0143869631,
0.0039424687,
0.0068271831,
-0.0144591546,
0.0005015517,
-0.0320944041,
-0.0247635636,
-0.0500814021,
0.0804441199,
-0.0347758122,
0.0051735849,
0.0707322434,
0.0531281419,
-0.0657083616,
0.0656089559,
0.0608453006,
0.0027950257,
-0.0384434536,
-0.0238952674,
-0.0192972552,
-0.0139904302,
-0.0340573601,
-0.0378229283,
0.0391730517,
0.0334376879,
0.0123116206,
-0.0727237836,
-0.0029777561,
-0.0124377348,
0.1081622243,
0.0051548458,
-0.0046327892,
0.0129646081,
0.0107507966,
-0.0191047322,
0.0506419055,
-0.0461497642,
0.0250589438,
-0.0608858615,
0.0136587275,
0.081423156,
0.0625185743,
0.0031249234,
-0.0258435477,
-0.0520611443,
0.0417894572,
0.0539011993,
0.0401653275,
-0.0010001834,
-0.0445898324,
-0.0330726579,
-0.0314763449,
0.035698384,
0.004084928,
-0.0203680824,
0.0328241475,
-0.000546347,
0.0027098064,
0.0553007796,
-0.0802178234,
0.0129478583,
-0.0029711293,
0.0230053551,
-0.0592250153,
0.005698177,
0.0537230819,
0.011677064,
-0.0255913883,
0.0031512373,
-0.0062032952,
0.0087026013,
-0.0686444193,
0.0307013728,
-0.0081072589,
0.0464650989,
0.0404965617,
-0.0363675244,
0.0265644174,
-0.0229935572,
0.0240435433,
0.0304862484,
0.0632211193,
-0.0499214195,
-0.0259023383,
-0.0126984483,
-0.0431421399,
-0.038217295,
-0.0058616349,
-0.0382300727,
0.0136526171,
-0.0095510008,
0.0243463106,
0.0537694134,
-0.0609993227,
0.0098023834,
0.0215290338,
-0.038608294,
-0.0061662528,
-0.0213204343,
0.0210034121,
0.0761936009,
0.011768329,
-0.0491074361,
-0.0358261429,
-0.0863820165,
-0.0511893183,
-0.0387720577,
0.01843955,
0.0473665632,
-0.0045310897,
0.0057947668,
0.0392045192,
-0.0357214473,
-0.0321208686,
0.0515169799,
0.0219257139,
0.0196629241,
-0.0338639244,
-0.0681592077,
-0.033324223,
-0.0017669575,
-0.0141849089,
0.0211143363,
0.0379115269,
-0.043790251,
0.0106046041,
-0.005012271,
-0.0972088352,
-0.0204166155,
-0.0120199034,
-0.0799175426,
0.0576189384,
0.0289636869,
0.0485883877,
0.0207261406,
0.0807121098,
0.0595727935,
0.0154864369,
0.0024873638,
-0.0372666828,
-0.0371316671,
-0.0157769937,
-0.0203619357,
-0.0454248115,
-0.0532365032,
0.0043589454,
0.061247997,
0.0328264758,
0.01677371,
-0.0798631683,
0.0590502657,
-0.0564241596,
-0.0600511245,
-0.0217024963,
-0.0695629492,
0.013543753,
0.0348973721,
-0.0128257331,
-0.0439402312,
0.0555649102,
-0.0023033859,
0.0051276213,
0.0206636358,
-0.0545297936,
-0.0202108342,
0.008463542,
0.0066770646,
0.0387686156,
0.0434238911,
0.0176682156,
0.0202198755,
-0.0572627224,
0.0887169018,
-0.06137437,
-0.0450261496,
-0.0538935326,
0.0145049682,
0.0469517037,
-0.0287626516,
-0.010843846,
-0.0326110348,
-0.037785884,
0.0069372677,
0.0744526386,
0.0095826965,
-0.0014402814,
0.0344905555,
0.0381275415,
-0.0186291169,
0.0178978443,
-0.0123115433,
0.0198128726,
-0.0199772455,
0.0230364799,
0.0165100731,
0.0410115495,
-0.0229034852,
0.0184312891,
0.0714384168,
-0.0578543171,
-0.061083395,
0.0113009922,
-0.0107619017,
0.0211469512,
0.0329227597,
-0.0008530982,
0.0390070863,
0.0473869592,
-0.0262962412,
-0.0374539718,
0.0622121915,
0.0251212027,
0.0096658794,
-0.0032701567,
-0.0302037392,
0.0352493115,
-0.0016195091,
-0.0343118124,
-0.0562042482,
0.0041367151,
-0.0165108312,
0.0270620976,
-0.0762981251,
-0.0417586677,
0.0077489992,
-0.0358980484,
0.0292517021,
0.0026995942,
-0.0348006748,
0.0080023175,
-0.0154398168,
-0.0114212474,
-0.0321432129,
0.0244625788,
-0.0264306869,
0.0376878716,
-0.015949823,
0.0185423885,
-0.0453850813,
-0.0180463661,
-0.0108879087,
-0.0407610536,
0.0878134891,
0.0227001496,
0.0286615826,
0.0044398885,
-0.0095318779,
0.0450475849,
0.0280971806,
-0.0288904104,
0.0017601866,
0.029283829,
0.0113993417,
-0.0073107108,
-0.0758888572,
0.0347400866,
-0.0093675442,
-0.0432545505,
-0.0232689772,
0.0372655503,
0.0353626683,
-0.028514713,
-0.0270875357,
0.0559617579,
0.0418514423,
0.0313253179,
0.0428373627,
-0.0453759655,
0.0054905596,
-0.0499646626,
-0.0134397903,
-0.0102692628,
-0.0940603241,
-0.061346747,
0.0459464081,
-0.01989205,
-0.0635790899,
-0.0217317846,
-0.0094245924,
-0.0290643703,
0.0180635937,
-0.0313011929,
0.0357186459,
-0.0038509518,
0.0288349539,
0.0119631328,
-0.0382061787,
0.0213304963,
-0.0589691363,
0.011875961,
-0.0013158863,
-0.0016697894,
-0.0065811086,
0.0455669872,
-0.0301396586,
-0.0744325519,
0.0231402405,
0.0615494624,
0.0192643218,
-0.0323053524,
-0.0192192215,
-0.0578938089,
-0.0138701918,
0.0381017551,
-0.0209564269,
-0.0227993298,
0.0314133875,
0.0447779745,
0.0207233522,
0.0112040043,
0.0079818275,
0.0148283048,
0.0098110903,
0.0058890963,
-0.0450438894,
-0.0243522264,
0.0051851361,
0.0184715837,
-0.0158562176,
-0.0287076309,
-0.0173598081,
-0.0055052973,
-0.0609701127,
-0.0393719971,
-0.0426755734,
-0.0133785009,
0.0235359445,
-0.000866804,
-0.0140247485,
-0.0169235617,
0.0239368938,
-0.09190391,
0.0394272693,
-0.0303709116,
0.0220259652,
-0.0024742798,
-0.000715805,
0.0250382069,
-0.0216835793,
-0.0029368936,
0.0424637161,
-0.0118499631,
0.0072544739,
-0.0177711714,
0.0378822461,
0.0023859257,
-0.0081632789,
0.0267294385,
0.0081799701,
-0.0198810194,
-0.043311134,
-0.0124191213,
0.048923336,
0.0147644393,
0.0370417759,
0.0539839976,
0.0054593775,
-0.0177300088,
-0.017523326,
0.041029647,
-0.0008023501,
-0.0719512776,
0.0142966015,
0.0030583318,
-0.040376585,
0.0029611536,
0.0412177742,
-0.017207304,
0.0004792045,
0.0114242872,
-0.0233931597,
-0.0189383365,
-0.0322578847,
-0.0069581927,
0.0130403396,
-0.0222619474,
0.0110437553,
-0.0603985377,
-0.0372575559,
-0.041033823,
0.0164941587,
0.0384616181,
-0.0073983194,
-0.0076015205,
0.0326297767,
0.0018560889,
0.0175520834,
-0.0416921973,
0.0384630412,
-0.0038349556,
0.0003214233,
-0.0295707826,
-6.143821509e-33,
-0.0030484735,
-0.0683932006,
0.002424283,
0.021541873,
-0.0092432527,
-0.0647169054,
-0.0244774967,
0.0500442721,
0.0131186722,
0.0343579873,
0.0112734605,
0.0027211835,
-0.0051088692,
-0.0044165007,
-0.0080525,
-0.0450839326,
0.023960514,
-0.0233336594,
-0.0406073593,
0.01937587,
0.0306931846,
-0.0136984633,
-0.0106451539,
-0.0874790251,
0.0788112581,
0.0008241687,
-0.0084099825,
0.0255160332,
-0.0077177025,
0.0419114977,
0.0076532657,
0.0467226692,
0.0297937337,
-0.018001996,
0.0100288112,
0.0403481163,
-0.0254882965,
0.0179548953,
0.0487544425,
-0.0442251824,
-0.0207167417,
-0.012983094,
0.0455115438,
-0.0099235764,
-0.0359722562,
0.0129991034,
0.016642252,
-0.0163340606,
0.0168113187,
-0.0552124828,
-0.0594061129,
0.0083747413,
-0.0443248451,
-0.0072754035,
-0.0192480683,
0.0415018611,
-0.0093464619,
0.0026228996,
-0.029232122,
0.0478715897,
-0.0075474256,
-0.0086096292,
0.0181829594,
-0.0137724951,
-0.0113824802,
0.0471983552,
-0.0112704523,
0.0804948658,
-0.0444716364,
-0.0021538874,
0.0159937926,
0.025393866,
0.0727633014,
0.058265578,
-0.0353098661,
-0.0677156895,
-0.058303792,
-0.0164724682,
0.0233660899,
0.0121979006,
0.0324117541,
-0.0122110061,
-0.0415884368,
-0.0471087024,
-0.0317684039,
-0.0792400166,
-0.0240543708,
-0.0415099189,
0.0250912178,
0.009520907,
-0.0469622798,
-0.0718431249,
0.0119110933,
-0.0497046299,
-0.0112426365,
0.0486919135,
0.0229444429,
-0.0016827228,
0.0160915181,
-0.0089503163,
-0.0520499684,
0.017408317,
0.0050891638,
0.0057719368,
0.0135501605,
-0.0521205515,
0.0047860509,
0.0160943512,
-0.0178143326,
0.0116393147,
-0.0100933267,
0.0701275989,
0.0021256437,
0.0318265855,
-0.017986143,
0.0318833701,
-0.0177803319,
-0.0068333638,
0.040273618,
-0.0023409827,
-0.0156858452,
0.0143383211,
-0.013366268,
0.0076249084,
-0.0493652709,
0.0013331911,
-0.0312858969,
0.0155058475,
0.0427019261,
-0.0076572611,
0.0002872693,
-0.0608512834,
2.672e-7,
0.0223006047,
0.0702872649,
-0.006646527,
0.015429453,
0.0198638588,
0.026085332,
0.039716024,
0.0301102102,
0.0226272177,
-0.0423356108,
0.0135258827,
0.0224509425,
0.0400643684,
0.0325822495,
0.0068782154,
-0.0354847647,
-0.1074312627,
-0.0331269279,
-0.0054610022,
-0.008042085,
0.0348636471,
-0.0002050668,
-0.0088034328,
-0.0009556895,
-0.0251067095,
-0.0185263567,
0.038118992,
-0.0754479021,
-0.032820113,
0.0414106287,
0.0722270831,
-0.0059580873,
0.030008398,
-0.0151500767,
0.0193372481,
-0.0005096889,
-0.0169632547,
0.0565144643,
0.0262874831,
0.0134032546,
0.0030336105,
-0.0282475613,
0.0278936103,
-0.0423862785,
0.0348300561,
-0.0352064222,
-0.0165449996,
-0.0533130839,
-0.0267103929,
-0.056621626,
0.0568664633,
-0.0527126715,
-0.0553711914,
0.0198529754,
0.0163314957,
0.0269381516,
0.0303730238,
-0.0154525414,
-0.0286194477,
-0.0275365561,
-0.0304929931,
-0.0941194296,
-0.015378288,
0.0149914995,
-0.0340313017,
0.0268793162,
0.0532755479,
2.085353611e-34,
0.0307272524,
0.009563148,
0.0306494832,
-0.0374646261,
0.0777541921,
0.0458273031,
-0.0088808686,
-0.0126554361,
0.0242574718,
-0.0387574285,
0.0040466986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09783v2 | Investigating Data Contamination in Modern Benchmarks for Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T11:03:04 | 2024-04-03T23:29:03 | Chunyuan Deng, Yilun Zhao, Xiangru Tang, Mark Gerstein, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent observations have underscored a disparity between the inflated
benchmark scores and the actual performance of LLMs, raising concerns about
potential contamination of evaluation benchmarks. This issue is especially
critical for closed-source models and certain open-source models where training
data transparency is lacking. In this paper we study data contamination by
proposing two methods tailored for both open-source and proprietary LLMs. We
first introduce a retrieval-based system to explore potential overlaps between
evaluation benchmarks and pretraining corpora. We further present a novel
investigation protocol named \textbf{T}estset \textbf{S}lot Guessing
(\textit{TS-Guessing}), applicable to both open and proprietary models. This
approach entails masking a wrong answer in a multiple-choice question and
prompting the model to fill in the gap. Additionally, it involves obscuring an
unlikely word in an evaluation example and asking the model to produce it. We
find that certain commercial LLMs could surprisingly guess the missing option
in various test sets. Specifically, in the TruthfulQA benchmark, we find that
LLMs exhibit notable performance improvement when provided with additional
metadata in the benchmark. Further, in the MMLU benchmark, ChatGPT and GPT-4
demonstrated an exact match rate of 52\% and 57\%, respectively, in guessing
the missing options in benchmark test data. We hope these results underscore
the need for more robust evaluation methodologies and benchmarks in the field. | [
0.0381818116,
0.0951880366,
-0.0214034449,
0.075508289,
-0.0536789522,
0.0038562526,
0.0077154683,
0.0453753807,
-0.0089657223,
-0.0502192341,
-0.0277229156,
-0.0439759381,
-0.0001637074,
0.0090271765,
0.0360200703,
0.0291653518,
0.0679109395,
-0.0171676036,
-0.0358490087,
-0.0165034011,
-0.0303358603,
-0.0128514245,
0.0240582898,
0.0264325775,
0.0214254037,
0.0158254225,
-0.008175333,
0.0092587527,
-0.0168073978,
-0.0160426889,
0.0099854087,
0.055324059,
-0.0247246064,
0.0829423666,
0.0000018389,
-0.0703953356,
-0.035516195,
0.0090241469,
-0.0588312149,
0.0337039158,
0.0133632161,
0.0324123055,
0.0021212238,
0.0286528673,
-0.0100866072,
0.000986877,
0.0454157628,
-0.0039306893,
0.0119292503,
0.0790209621,
0.0183683839,
0.0248104911,
0.0071681822,
-0.0216265395,
0.0313950665,
-0.0326286256,
0.0281809941,
-0.0273049157,
0.0098461201,
0.0035053883,
-0.0016954453,
0.0329117775,
0.0017289702,
0.0537356585,
-0.0268128645,
0.0302903466,
-0.0521263629,
-0.0213136319,
-0.0026216747,
0.0691698864,
0.014437546,
-0.004543548,
-0.0024802987,
-0.0226199962,
0.0010358859,
0.0238187481,
-0.0060539721,
0.0274970587,
-0.0053513846,
0.0110268891,
0.0048826719,
-0.0216577202,
0.0524433032,
0.0170025826,
-0.0318650752,
0.0925264731,
0.032906305,
-0.0477256998,
0.0303880759,
0.0053382055,
-0.0299324691,
-0.0561241135,
0.0030245008,
-0.011022754,
-0.0126866065,
0.0305916779,
-0.0297701675,
-0.0123144565,
0.0460428372,
-0.0307662133,
0.0480256267,
0.040252652,
-0.0479993075,
0.0301920138,
-0.0103118652,
0.0423357561,
0.0000939399,
0.0381806679,
-0.0534080379,
-0.0069864732,
0.0062157526,
0.004993848,
-0.0101068662,
0.0344512127,
-0.03724619,
0.0100276582,
-0.0351377986,
0.0037703742,
-0.0125008039,
0.0210227352,
0.0101409517,
-0.0054576187,
-0.0282785092,
0.0024511304,
-0.0717064068,
-0.0046048504,
-0.012790679,
0.0187268052,
-0.0037451922,
-0.1096945032,
-0.0302774534,
0.0106495051,
-0.0122416699,
-0.0574118271,
0.0447118841,
0.077023156,
0.00767283,
-0.0661055148,
-0.0297357198,
-0.0292277988,
-0.0176848061,
-0.0716643035,
0.000055316,
-0.058400277,
0.0037689018,
0.0149932383,
-0.0100593856,
-0.0352504849,
-0.0000257716,
0.0357732587,
-0.033223033,
0.0793718398,
-0.0317546725,
-0.0015661831,
-0.0057058311,
0.008917613,
-0.0290994886,
0.0784669518,
0.0020596753,
0.0221098196,
0.0680178627,
-0.0205943361,
0.0286794864,
0.0726376846,
0.0386221744,
0.0244029947,
-0.0170526262,
0.0205418691,
0.0112182107,
0.0390150994,
0.0066367257,
0.0563590191,
-0.024286652,
-0.045725707,
0.0697518811,
0.0602976419,
0.0130851725,
-0.0047380757,
0.0206189603,
0.0021218581,
0.0244897064,
0.0366587378,
-0.0438281,
-0.0294497609,
-0.0711272955,
0.0186185874,
0.0482186414,
0.0154644875,
-0.0104650054,
-0.0417921245,
-0.0467426069,
-0.0168040525,
-0.0074290275,
0.0413641483,
0.0544392541,
-0.0202982556,
-0.0508261621,
0.0652377158,
0.0167812891,
-0.0358062461,
-0.0231037326,
-0.0685059726,
0.035135366,
0.0448943079,
0.0727850422,
-0.0219865218,
-0.0223362409,
0.0009439911,
-0.0250294078,
0.0235803667,
0.0304482207,
-0.007852667,
0.0439687185,
-0.0477048233,
-0.0206720047,
0.0147972833,
0.0262543,
0.0285006277,
0.0355377235,
0.0130570922,
0.0214490052,
-0.0882631838,
-0.0034943523,
0.0447905846,
-0.0365658142,
-0.0355181992,
0.0176354665,
-0.0135727925,
0.0322636887,
0.0097699082,
-0.0253975242,
0.0136025352,
0.0382720232,
0.0154789342,
-0.008691459,
-0.0460475646,
-0.0160089117,
-0.011146185,
0.0428825133,
-0.0184378941,
-0.0411841162,
0.0733168423,
-0.0253642537,
-0.0350918658,
-0.014498923,
-0.0060451361,
0.0258893427,
-0.072625719,
0.0267248936,
-0.0078328336,
0.0263702087,
-0.0446445718,
0.0606941134,
-0.0171135738,
0.0788718238,
0.0155278416,
-0.0098053999,
0.0387889668,
-0.0621518046,
-0.0506581515,
0.0268582385,
-0.0086063379,
0.0252913367,
0.0079790689,
0.0038783767,
-0.0549795069,
-0.0286576673,
-0.0852077529,
0.024020128,
-0.0248436145,
0.0150706079,
-0.0049506295,
0.0084441621,
-0.0458937474,
-0.0205418374,
-0.0176756307,
-0.0391063876,
0.0110890903,
0.0478438847,
0.0288373791,
0.0180448592,
-0.0006376973,
-0.0372292064,
-0.0241291802,
-0.0081491638,
0.0472904928,
-0.0428915806,
-0.018078573,
-0.0494058579,
0.053041026,
-0.0480998084,
0.0252567921,
-0.0115100322,
-0.0101427576,
0.017457597,
-0.0147818988,
-0.0189025793,
0.0320192426,
-0.007780835,
-0.01098298,
0.0602088794,
-0.0053483364,
-0.077607438,
0.0025938728,
-0.0022191501,
-0.0611797571,
-0.0210780185,
-0.0465950444,
-0.0097948872,
0.0501974635,
0.0054455609,
-0.0326911286,
-0.0216702167,
0.0155373281,
-0.0074556605,
-0.0298985969,
-0.0482275896,
0.0333999023,
-0.021601174,
0.0612447336,
-0.0044184108,
-0.0761469752,
0.0590431616,
-0.0540258363,
-0.0008944998,
-0.0213430393,
-0.0042951475,
-0.0238783043,
0.0250006597,
-0.0010575349,
-0.0122124627,
0.018688472,
-0.0257769395,
-0.0505763218,
0.0051561575,
0.0318385363,
-0.0689679906,
0.0457657948,
-0.0330964215,
0.0158949532,
-0.0129960123,
-0.0346103013,
-0.0496691838,
-0.0695645437,
-0.0232692026,
-0.0171002168,
0.0238115322,
-0.0058015254,
-0.0181896091,
-0.0345971249,
-0.0028820226,
0.0386732407,
-0.009225796,
-0.0036226914,
-0.0161902923,
0.0335016362,
0.0438687801,
0.0058173952,
0.0630413815,
-0.0450956896,
-0.0059657544,
0.0540974103,
0.0474993549,
0.0115134623,
-0.0135771865,
0.0009369917,
0.0417870656,
-0.0269925166,
-0.0177961569,
0.0366650783,
0.026630085,
-0.02378105,
-0.0090468349,
0.1125109494,
0.0268227179,
-0.0153184803,
-0.0137906056,
0.0056191524,
0.0491061024,
0.0262486432,
0.0205507316,
-0.1179359779,
-0.0234909225,
0.0257171951,
0.0458050407,
-0.024334792,
-0.0462546013,
-0.0218697079,
-0.1471667737,
0.0305804107,
-0.0110019902,
-0.0145039,
0.0225646719,
-0.0328923315,
-0.0008828012,
-0.0283935349,
0.0540393218,
0.010314377,
0.003432306,
0.0199648011,
0.0150550511,
-0.017266348,
-0.0669978261,
0.0175022595,
-0.0273057781,
0.0750544146,
0.0189525075,
0.0040330719,
-0.0443663001,
-0.0270568337,
0.0462966673,
-0.0141090034,
-0.0226836447,
-0.0138095524,
0.0728621036,
-0.0062444322,
-0.0136485426,
0.0058311718,
-0.0089387102,
-0.0120699974,
0.0145946061,
0.007063149,
0.0438463874,
-0.0107174553,
-0.0089419,
0.0144434059,
-0.0324549004,
0.0149624897,
0.1028475612,
0.01495679,
-0.0289207716,
-0.0108991042,
-0.0273609515,
0.0064932154,
-0.0023870189,
0.0030744218,
0.0390881933,
-0.0079310397,
0.0070018214,
-0.0403549075,
-0.0638524741,
0.0251381826,
0.0460435227,
-0.0025417055,
0.0403977819,
-0.0350941159,
0.0001075908,
-0.0288441479,
0.0517716184,
-0.0434071198,
0.0298783518,
-0.0501281843,
0.0163120478,
0.0094252443,
-0.0148827834,
-0.0188385528,
0.0276399683,
-0.0957810357,
-0.082120955,
0.0004676303,
0.0380224474,
0.0341319218,
0.0424357057,
-0.0070092226,
-0.0667982474,
0.0226790216,
0.0202874262,
-0.0125011262,
0.0393631086,
0.0265268311,
-0.0201938692,
-0.0039616073,
0.0301895943,
-0.0417767316,
-0.0174101535,
0.0204134509,
0.0348484181,
-0.0186842047,
-0.0200468954,
0.0354873613,
0.0641594082,
0.0721463412,
-0.0388195589,
0.016103033,
-0.029894067,
0.0390564799,
-0.0167575888,
-0.014741783,
-0.0419262983,
-0.0141150942,
0.0418475345,
-0.0107121114,
-0.0228633918,
-0.0120911989,
-0.0383822545,
0.0732565448,
-0.0443597697,
-0.0063004866,
0.0384427942,
0.0077104899,
0.0413631499,
-0.0119083803,
-0.0040699639,
0.0167674832,
0.0191972926,
0.0860318691,
0.0080702594,
0.0453570224,
0.0006806535,
0.0106567051,
0.0298804156,
0.013445952,
-0.0507729016,
-0.0504710637,
-0.0212230235,
0.0603689179,
0.0343709886,
-0.0129829962,
0.0066054566,
-0.0067268196,
-0.0069361441,
-0.036340192,
-0.0178656373,
-0.0135088079,
-0.0106968824,
0.0430142842,
0.0026953002,
-0.0411836542,
0.0481283851,
0.0734555349,
0.0394583419,
0.0585130714,
-0.0252838824,
-0.0136085441,
-0.0201199315,
-0.0137650371,
0.0054910425,
0.0289077275,
-0.0248477329,
-0.0294632725,
-0.0677367523,
-0.0985222906,
0.0172413513,
0.0219068397,
-0.0114911711,
0.0057641235,
0.0033637332,
0.0744599998,
-0.0015463579,
0.0082962411,
-0.0538724735,
-0.01257433,
-0.0028057187,
-0.0332892798,
-0.0090129226,
-6.438737981e-33,
-0.0123271653,
-0.0266083907,
0.0155418292,
-0.0304789767,
0.0151360882,
0.0190150402,
0.0088622682,
0.0180974882,
-0.0346424282,
-0.0152714103,
-0.0415239707,
0.0105107976,
0.0253107492,
0.0144890398,
-0.0184400268,
-0.0312002189,
0.0024175593,
-0.003899734,
-0.0367817953,
-0.0417397246,
0.0185124706,
0.0351042189,
0.0781955123,
-0.0367695168,
0.0363181382,
-0.0304252356,
-0.014921858,
0.0330382101,
-0.0436683074,
0.066838704,
-0.002686247,
0.0542763956,
0.0021394892,
-0.0154540157,
-0.0214167815,
-0.0313024148,
-0.0276202727,
-0.0427867621,
0.0332728177,
0.0094844867,
-0.0003823822,
0.0026681013,
0.034063343,
-0.0180984493,
-0.0536794253,
0.0116119375,
0.0005577577,
-0.0210299175,
-0.0509317815,
0.0046714055,
0.0198622197,
0.0332000144,
0.0073315026,
0.021223763,
0.0343772136,
0.0366855972,
0.0128634796,
0.0125871478,
-0.02954337,
0.0022323809,
0.0416652597,
0.0420579016,
0.0673881993,
0.0184719507,
-0.0123615004,
0.0629175901,
0.0457628034,
-0.0034819581,
0.0231044516,
-0.0393521041,
0.0417613462,
0.0281733982,
0.0428678356,
0.0569266416,
0.0385054015,
-0.0086999899,
-0.0465808101,
0.0471150354,
-0.0046607209,
-0.0193783361,
0.0050371503,
0.0032697031,
-0.0827285871,
-0.0291035231,
-0.0707480088,
-0.0109882681,
-0.0474025123,
-0.0152247995,
0.0522483326,
-0.0020816098,
-0.0064607197,
-0.0085129077,
0.0302322339,
-0.0479908139,
-0.0211695917,
-0.0183840729,
-0.0171384793,
0.0084407525,
-0.0044085658,
0.0546144545,
-0.0467105582,
-0.0115626305,
0.0049221162,
0.0092014456,
0.0153044555,
-0.0134033505,
0.0051244223,
0.0146736084,
-0.0864173472,
0.0108429408,
-0.044705458,
0.0161973108,
-0.0005009556,
-0.0429421477,
0.0477466285,
-0.0054695122,
0.0069390228,
0.0216570161,
0.0272584315,
0.0111060161,
-0.0622996725,
-0.0211603213,
0.0026545948,
0.0039674682,
0.0046176892,
0.0014102684,
0.0021323736,
0.0220792219,
0.0561542511,
-0.0132116023,
0.0124756387,
0.0333068483,
2.623e-7,
0.0513845049,
0.036394164,
-0.0014224636,
0.0199189689,
-0.0281984881,
0.033753112,
-0.0493007302,
0.0160805192,
0.0283016227,
-0.0343311727,
0.0137574738,
-0.0215740371,
0.0752576813,
0.0358060449,
-0.081525147,
-0.0053761993,
-0.0374168977,
0.0097208479,
-0.0612534583,
-0.0139865465,
0.0051958147,
0.1007386521,
0.013435021,
-0.0206153821,
-0.0208091196,
-0.059112329,
0.0425087623,
-0.0693875328,
-0.0506141521,
0.0215654634,
0.0705114305,
0.0361389183,
0.0370064937,
0.0072857044,
-0.0207686406,
0.0197855104,
0.0242083073,
0.0337439775,
0.0207006391,
-0.0499493405,
-0.0330617055,
-0.0395811833,
-0.0218722783,
-0.0465873033,
0.0748772994,
0.0251343548,
-0.0126885362,
-0.0307840127,
-0.0240213443,
-0.0485574864,
0.0545099862,
-0.0187976416,
0.0005000158,
0.0170788262,
0.0011770853,
-0.0069321105,
-0.0160110034,
-0.049617067,
-0.0149571681,
-0.0283567309,
-0.0357058272,
-0.0894694477,
-0.0186739042,
-0.0021354358,
0.0044212234,
-0.0778323784,
0.0037973721,
2.643123384e-34,
0.0403552316,
-0.0222004075,
0.0232147332,
0.0262893848,
0.0463880301,
-0.0081731919,
0.0175034031,
0.0172028039,
-0.0336508192,
-0.0911579356,
-0.0057732821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09782v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09782v2 | More Samples or More Prompts? Exploring Effective In-Context Sampling for LLM Few-Shot Prompt Engineering | 2023-11-16T11:02:49 | 2024-04-02T17:16:40 | Bingsheng Yao, Guiming Chen, Ruishi Zou, Yuxuan Lu, Jiachen Li, Shao Zhang, Yisi Sang, Sijia Liu, James Hendler, Dakuo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While most existing works on LLM prompting techniques focus only on how to
select a better set of data samples inside one single prompt input (In-Context
Learning or ICL), why can not we design and leverage multiple prompts together
to further improve the LLM's performance? In this work, we propose In-Context
Sampling (ICS), a low-resource LLM prompting technique to produce confident
predictions by optimizing the construction of multiple ICL prompt inputs.
Extensive experiments with three open-source LLMs (FlanT5-XL, Mistral-7B, and
Mixtral-8x7B) on four NLI datasets (e-SNLI, Multi-NLI, ANLI, and Contract-NLI)
and one QA dataset (CommonsenseQA) illustrate that ICS can consistently enhance
LLMs' performance. An in-depth evaluation with three data similarity-based ICS
strategies suggests that these strategies can further elevate LLM's
performance, which sheds light on a new yet promising future research
direction. | [
-0.0151693653,
0.0137994951,
-0.0079899421,
0.0291972719,
-0.049596034,
0.0113471262,
0.0438343994,
0.0057244273,
0.0312149283,
-0.0405962095,
-0.0644166097,
-0.0234465059,
-0.0111194393,
-0.0036014726,
0.0150455674,
-0.0044404953,
0.0353853256,
-0.0367720276,
-0.0194166359,
-0.0162127707,
-0.0204216987,
-0.0176784806,
-0.0091788098,
0.0050559775,
0.0063066795,
-0.0446084216,
-0.0469040684,
0.0239765905,
0.0064555123,
-0.0589411967,
0.0047792275,
0.0636973903,
0.0175634958,
-0.0113227423,
0.0000022591,
-0.0889622644,
-0.0126016606,
-0.0075726272,
-0.0683499947,
-0.0043863445,
0.0148372799,
0.0290074069,
0.0260833167,
0.0257341117,
-0.0038920261,
0.0402200446,
0.0153238168,
0.0339215435,
0.033670947,
0.0456867367,
0.0099766366,
0.012813041,
0.0167098958,
-0.0046829865,
0.0394610614,
-0.0118952384,
0.0252682939,
-0.07092271,
0.0519698709,
0.0038266184,
-0.0043090796,
0.0231459476,
0.0088842269,
0.0087559232,
-0.0130591765,
0.0201784298,
0.0059431605,
-0.0131324688,
-0.047959879,
0.0870505795,
0.0073218173,
0.0255493205,
0.0098085133,
-0.0491633154,
0.0242343359,
0.0037013639,
-0.0478825346,
0.0146550564,
-0.0378359109,
0.0118212532,
0.0061864927,
0.0133933136,
-0.0023636911,
-0.021435583,
-0.0275869146,
0.0457034707,
-0.0053266343,
-0.0470406041,
0.0480533391,
-0.0058675227,
0.0293230247,
-0.0394397043,
-0.0346335284,
0.0466110855,
-0.1009502709,
-0.0002723289,
-0.0183425378,
-0.0162486471,
0.0518545583,
0.0407213084,
0.0607859865,
0.0312217232,
-0.0520976558,
0.0432997867,
-0.0057610287,
0.0244973116,
0.0324221551,
0.0289554074,
-0.0185696855,
-0.0059661861,
-0.0134670874,
0.037891034,
-0.025180988,
0.0474102125,
-0.0612120628,
0.0162173267,
-0.0508374535,
0.0546880998,
-0.0246845689,
0.0498687364,
0.0064136395,
-0.0187675618,
0.0071334755,
0.0372364186,
-0.0228722077,
-0.0258007832,
-0.0063346755,
0.0197688323,
0.0128465081,
-0.0903128982,
-0.0249464773,
0.012204784,
0.0225509778,
-0.0272389799,
0.0018606402,
0.0662335679,
0.0057762736,
-0.0583121516,
-0.0779805854,
-0.0517568439,
0.0126282312,
-0.0208740085,
0.000956193,
-0.0607980452,
0.0337205715,
-0.0091444831,
-0.0130544538,
-0.0012667489,
-0.0168077573,
0.0282680281,
0.0170511436,
0.0879643261,
-0.0336881913,
-0.0019437332,
0.0042898837,
0.0111336419,
-0.0361165442,
0.0753207207,
-0.012157348,
0.0058419211,
0.0415769629,
0.0147084072,
0.0352824815,
0.0414390303,
0.0180285107,
0.0260646418,
0.0060250461,
0.0156070674,
0.0081241997,
0.0122570982,
0.0351437256,
-0.0116846301,
0.0013624354,
0.0103732757,
0.0432750732,
0.0779802501,
0.0319587663,
-0.0458068438,
0.0311776157,
0.0192767214,
-0.0003400337,
-0.0082377074,
-0.0574494973,
0.0503168032,
-0.01984361,
0.0139650647,
0.022444116,
0.033987388,
-0.0289030131,
-0.0218943581,
0.0008481126,
-0.0143397357,
-0.0670662373,
0.0433127433,
0.0114250928,
-0.0123527776,
-0.0383753628,
0.0481384546,
0.0371730514,
-0.0188104697,
-0.0360932909,
-0.0492671616,
0.0685983822,
0.0424357653,
0.0052475925,
-0.0520463288,
-0.0264553856,
-0.0429863892,
0.0154883014,
0.0196508542,
0.0161340702,
-0.0276001599,
0.0144315846,
-0.0196951646,
-0.0783247948,
-0.0013366203,
-0.0097998446,
0.0217875503,
-0.0141529385,
0.0170206558,
-0.0240494832,
-0.0178714786,
0.0236977153,
0.0243961494,
-0.0324023999,
-0.0291350763,
0.026251588,
0.0488158129,
0.064085938,
0.0165767409,
0.0126675777,
-0.0111267949,
0.0340243392,
-0.0262041427,
-0.0101505667,
-0.0367103405,
-0.0359777771,
-0.0873391703,
0.0111775314,
0.0189243872,
0.0035566005,
-0.0470713563,
-0.0844280794,
-0.0348627344,
-0.0564458035,
-0.006196124,
0.0019081952,
-0.030555049,
0.0095798839,
0.0052480563,
0.0069487225,
-0.0524004921,
0.0574521236,
-0.0299976394,
-0.0007957585,
0.0794645995,
0.0529121496,
0.0264888536,
-0.048750855,
-0.0071200063,
-0.0163137186,
-0.0152253341,
-0.0131923119,
-0.0121302959,
0.0493066125,
-0.0596279465,
-0.0058854865,
-0.0567284338,
-0.0022488071,
-0.0227790531,
-0.0087871598,
-0.0154653275,
0.0263009798,
-0.035648942,
-0.0142094465,
-0.0511277765,
-0.0307114013,
0.0002472228,
0.0370228328,
0.0306187142,
0.0229587518,
-0.0331416987,
0.0094429469,
0.0131960921,
0.0054161712,
0.0291386899,
-0.0049782605,
-0.0467707291,
-0.0625035912,
0.0208077207,
-0.0011871773,
-0.0283036027,
-0.0117113609,
0.0552071631,
-0.0032288136,
-0.0040595396,
0.0063100443,
0.0280939247,
-0.0355685353,
-0.0050067622,
0.0292856824,
-0.0083608022,
-0.085211955,
0.0291740615,
0.0153230913,
-0.0060062781,
0.0181952044,
0.0005710979,
0.0438966937,
0.0062392638,
0.0243108533,
0.019483773,
0.009343165,
0.0327860862,
0.0408924744,
-0.0324131101,
-0.0542886183,
0.0165504385,
-0.0332644396,
0.0835544243,
-0.0042103408,
-0.0523960851,
0.0615234263,
-0.0081735104,
0.0169983935,
-0.0095941946,
-0.0423853807,
-0.043066524,
-0.0062649772,
-0.0523356162,
-0.0177156609,
0.0196699183,
-0.039279066,
-0.0541515686,
-0.0015141056,
0.0036699616,
-0.0178866591,
0.0652008578,
-0.0181960724,
-0.0056958059,
-0.026099598,
-0.0663647428,
-0.0643088371,
-0.0211355668,
-0.0109008057,
0.0113690859,
-0.0486964844,
0.0133557655,
0.0143661518,
-0.0296004154,
0.0031981014,
0.0242379121,
-0.0083646951,
-0.0260944981,
-0.0192709342,
0.0472226255,
0.0112123191,
0.0247790925,
0.0258395448,
-0.0152030876,
0.0592034124,
0.0097539686,
0.0352038108,
-0.0023290233,
-0.000712091,
0.0422520377,
0.0598946549,
-0.0563606396,
-0.0085982457,
0.0692939162,
0.0729529411,
-0.0213248227,
-0.0161096286,
0.0968299434,
0.0257816613,
-0.0596885197,
-0.0011040374,
-0.0386827067,
0.0134378187,
0.0163140427,
0.0219526011,
-0.1032734513,
-0.0492345914,
0.0149585586,
0.0684484988,
-0.02897981,
-0.0457080677,
-0.0160876326,
-0.1072842404,
0.0836625993,
-0.0309687983,
-0.0400335118,
-0.0190151203,
-0.0748712867,
0.0212252475,
0.0128828678,
0.0335592218,
0.0234764237,
-0.0324624069,
-0.0187971499,
0.02800042,
-0.0066452306,
-0.0550103188,
0.0039566876,
-0.0284764972,
0.0491074398,
0.0412136689,
-0.0100228479,
-0.0002959725,
-0.0388325714,
0.0359655544,
-0.0623595454,
0.031924542,
-0.0447896719,
0.0436840244,
0.0224781316,
0.0093285795,
-0.0249460116,
0.0729013085,
-0.0225738306,
-0.0509039052,
0.0268703587,
0.0939973816,
-0.0625736043,
0.0186514053,
-0.0315064862,
-0.0021745139,
0.0553842932,
0.0870588347,
0.0608447306,
-0.0370423682,
-0.0087762484,
-0.0177394263,
-0.0202168934,
-0.0165294856,
0.0294147097,
0.0136198448,
-0.0402532369,
0.0088505335,
-0.0362137184,
-0.0416865908,
0.0315142944,
0.021772176,
0.0062065856,
0.038856376,
-0.0318149328,
-0.0020861016,
-0.005623302,
0.0110355867,
-0.0285078734,
0.0143785318,
-0.0493264832,
0.0111811692,
0.0479031913,
-0.0268154759,
-0.0179214533,
-0.0015610975,
-0.0807613879,
-0.0414630882,
-0.0236415155,
0.0463727638,
0.0177885965,
0.0545526519,
0.0005258661,
-0.0182275772,
0.1292622983,
0.0856963694,
0.0398478732,
0.0124264332,
0.0140435398,
0.080967471,
-0.016478071,
0.0147410147,
-0.0926633924,
-0.0007375221,
0.0654051974,
0.0061963852,
-0.0433405116,
-0.059627898,
0.0086907865,
0.0475754291,
0.0364523977,
-0.0296363067,
-0.0086336117,
-0.0325987749,
0.0369435959,
0.0119950138,
0.0029000342,
-0.0165173691,
0.0168783572,
-0.0271417089,
-0.0521168299,
-0.0028872516,
0.0062124897,
-0.019322224,
0.0513005294,
-0.0580193512,
0.0379033461,
0.0037730108,
0.0027919228,
0.0079995152,
0.0040767929,
-0.0337297656,
0.0287467893,
0.0447012447,
0.0310028102,
0.0126304021,
0.0914414003,
0.0199174546,
0.035364911,
-0.0067619812,
0.0306790601,
-0.0512454733,
-0.0590829775,
-0.0100261038,
0.0608784631,
0.0474392921,
0.0196219459,
-0.0225195233,
0.0070537967,
0.0087341359,
0.0026668983,
0.0323850662,
0.0159725491,
-0.0248569865,
0.0804162025,
0.0197387617,
-0.0024989974,
-0.0085717253,
0.0578369349,
-0.0628529191,
0.037710987,
-0.009035334,
0.0156681743,
-0.0613420047,
-0.0103467442,
0.0612352379,
0.0184591953,
-0.0244705249,
-0.01661212,
-0.0697927177,
-0.0049178014,
0.0578817688,
-0.0091872159,
-0.0376767963,
0.0021079064,
0.0336771719,
0.0248926058,
0.024591716,
-0.025386665,
0.0056052366,
-0.0317937732,
0.0004097926,
-0.0755656064,
-0.0083104065,
-6.337128984e-33,
-0.0311546549,
-0.0269516315,
0.0268844645,
0.0182717405,
0.0081395758,
-0.0048004971,
-0.0069965925,
-0.0292990096,
-0.0034146225,
-0.0221751165,
-0.04944662,
-0.0492305756,
0.0263392366,
0.0051298854,
0.0337068401,
-0.0505842492,
0.0406273827,
-0.0148191117,
-0.0307245664,
0.0083985291,
-0.0078974385,
0.0394543298,
0.0137919215,
-0.036070697,
0.0383614749,
0.0066074068,
0.008870923,
0.009719112,
-0.0464124195,
0.0445191562,
-0.0094393101,
0.0489267409,
0.021581538,
-0.0348112434,
-0.0267117675,
0.0444942378,
-0.0578250103,
-0.0785537064,
-0.0043508499,
0.0047640963,
-0.0044565164,
-0.0374639034,
0.0191944633,
-0.0211134795,
-0.0241640471,
-0.0046951594,
0.0359320082,
-0.0072071454,
-0.0392961949,
-0.0734064057,
0.0209917352,
-0.0053787641,
0.0001645441,
0.0023484635,
-0.0060349801,
0.0863231272,
0.0033801435,
0.0567462742,
-0.0739852712,
0.0115989652,
0.0208854824,
-0.0131695773,
0.0484656356,
0.0232389588,
-0.0016307535,
0.0473948196,
0.0411190987,
-0.0126888026,
0.0424668528,
-0.0379907005,
0.0061779576,
0.0542710647,
0.0125299776,
0.0797833651,
0.0220430344,
0.0060528824,
-0.0523390472,
0.0508095324,
0.0546434298,
-0.0121137341,
0.0120964339,
-0.0225141365,
-0.0436832905,
-0.038364023,
-0.0221234374,
-0.0348184071,
-0.0360447057,
-0.0017638761,
0.0469421595,
-0.0083065182,
0.0219743345,
-0.0192116592,
0.0497326255,
-0.0059878761,
-0.027653221,
-0.0301062297,
0.0178899504,
0.0300332103,
0.0020929766,
-0.0171115175,
-0.0368542373,
-0.0314617977,
0.0061336514,
-0.0293334275,
0.0321156308,
0.0192499142,
0.0471091419,
0.0212766603,
-0.0751278251,
-0.0005043411,
-0.0218822379,
0.0339767188,
0.024806764,
-0.0201891139,
0.0131627135,
-0.0194970462,
0.0084750848,
0.0507423617,
-0.0016669378,
-0.0405604839,
0.0086991945,
-0.0116601614,
-0.0270183478,
0.0151400622,
-0.0308702774,
0.0017126058,
-0.0070773428,
0.0230729375,
0.0201171692,
-0.0256963763,
-0.0013468609,
0.0301123373,
2.908e-7,
0.0018771254,
0.0116308751,
-0.0245593432,
0.0295705963,
0.0077623283,
0.032485947,
-0.0383229814,
0.021346774,
0.0021699755,
-0.0089988057,
0.0382745266,
-0.0129084811,
0.0242302306,
0.0155245429,
-0.120721966,
0.0088610211,
-0.0331560709,
0.0028907633,
-0.0780730844,
0.008689723,
0.0678594634,
0.0546694845,
0.0077189999,
-0.0543878935,
0.0172908399,
-0.0070525249,
0.0246608499,
-0.0636817589,
-0.0026466132,
0.0173405781,
0.0514477566,
-0.0325070173,
0.026435921,
0.0443250202,
-0.0117946174,
0.0036922249,
-0.0404572934,
0.0373756737,
0.0345514528,
-0.0705758706,
0.0122385966,
-0.0193500184,
0.0209704656,
-0.0352383889,
0.0630364493,
-0.0310528148,
-0.0020353105,
-0.019035887,
-0.0251532383,
-0.071024403,
0.0272684414,
-0.0272995047,
0.0163135063,
0.0106389401,
-0.0075152055,
-0.0194401555,
-0.0192773361,
-0.0256816987,
0.027995443,
0.0026885879,
-0.0119022792,
-0.0658099502,
-0.0187894199,
-0.0047886106,
0.0293355081,
-0.0752467737,
-0.0114355665,
3.029595621e-34,
0.0072432426,
-0.0385124423,
0.0091084475,
0.0882139429,
-0.0242602509,
-0.0072229546,
-0.0048512793,
0.0259989258,
0.0409608111,
-0.0443395004,
-0.0035938898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09774v1 | HuatuoGPT-II, One-stage Training for Medical Adaption of LLMs | 2023-11-16T10:56:24 | 2023-11-16T10:56:24 | Junying Chen, Xidong Wang, Anningzhe Gao, Feng Jiang, Shunian Chen, Hongbo Zhang, Dingjie Song, Wenya Xie, Chuyi Kong, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Haizhou Li, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Adapting a language model into a specific domain, a.k.a `domain adaption', is
a common practice when specialized knowledge, e.g. medicine, is not
encapsulated in a general language model like Llama2. The challenge lies in the
heterogeneity of data across the two training stages, as it varies in
languages, genres, or formats. To tackle this and simplify the learning
protocol, we propose to transform heterogeneous data, from the both
pre-training and supervised stages, into a unified, simple input-output pair
format. We validate the new protocol in the domains where proprietary LLMs like
ChatGPT perform relatively poorly, such as Traditional Chinese Medicine. The
developed model, HuatuoGPT-II, has shown state-of-the-art performance in
Chinese medicine domain on a number of benchmarks, e.g. medical licensing
exams. It even outperforms proprietary models like ChatGPT and GPT-4 in some
aspects, especially in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Expert manual evaluations
further validate HuatuoGPT-II's advantages over existing LLMs. Notably,
HuatuoGPT-II was benchmarked in a fresh Chinese National Medical Licensing
Examination where it achieved the best performance, showcasing not only its
effectiveness but also its generalization capabilities. | [
0.041821532,
0.0181798674,
-0.0020350658,
-0.0305505525,
-0.0038569891,
0.0214309841,
0.0077212499,
0.0640826076,
0.0106822029,
-0.0389043242,
-0.0717371777,
-0.0405557863,
-0.0031519383,
-0.0026037986,
0.0471710712,
-0.0560039021,
0.0509252474,
0.0212656949,
-0.014091691,
-0.003509471,
-0.0180771332,
-0.0081178779,
-0.0368975475,
0.0344847739,
0.0472695827,
-0.0027169643,
0.0322288424,
-0.0069866497,
0.0372543149,
-0.0646347255,
-0.0025726948,
0.0235784799,
0.0131210508,
-0.0181756187,
0.0000020188,
-0.0615591966,
-0.0391068459,
0.0115408106,
-0.0105422027,
-0.0022092008,
0.0465533584,
-0.0267786961,
-0.0183856487,
0.0365484543,
-0.0375802517,
-0.0274422243,
0.0197467208,
0.0567040034,
0.0407934561,
0.1116002277,
-0.0046791229,
-0.0109637473,
0.0160375088,
-0.0379774943,
-0.0188037325,
-0.0431424193,
0.039994061,
0.0055700201,
0.0254857838,
-0.0199048184,
-0.022710925,
0.0191574693,
-0.0383562595,
0.0246462263,
-0.0024524636,
0.0253529232,
-0.0207060408,
0.0192914866,
-0.0108064571,
0.0402588546,
-0.0122307977,
-0.0152094811,
0.0121973036,
-0.0029640109,
0.0100649418,
0.0127732428,
-0.0664016828,
-0.0095976926,
0.0092331478,
0.0185911004,
0.0357311144,
-0.03927055,
0.0312092584,
-0.0016507142,
-0.0345678516,
0.0083544888,
0.0228787642,
-0.022721462,
0.0460439399,
-0.0002238765,
0.0187713932,
-0.0060427226,
0.0190054048,
0.0727660209,
-0.0146184191,
0.0184349865,
-0.0095723588,
0.0051678484,
0.0462617986,
-0.0476132706,
0.0274210423,
0.0214477945,
-0.032292299,
0.020691311,
-0.0601119027,
0.0259790756,
-0.0027308019,
0.0559181161,
-0.0704278499,
0.0145482682,
-0.044562187,
0.0074451808,
-0.0018325748,
0.0148269134,
0.0040555238,
0.0381596349,
-0.0953380167,
-0.0096569126,
-0.0111558056,
-0.0078415805,
0.0357766189,
-0.0029966836,
-0.0460881665,
0.0002380576,
-0.0253321175,
0.0510372333,
0.044161614,
0.0481635444,
-0.0299149249,
-0.0182156581,
0.0043029506,
0.0331733003,
-0.024487,
0.0172871649,
0.0273552034,
0.0848029777,
-0.0277159438,
0.0016790627,
-0.0379162095,
0.017601015,
-0.0033552442,
-0.0205527693,
0.0611991696,
-0.0629857779,
0.0165556278,
-0.0144140031,
0.0423962735,
-0.0686012059,
0.0024638453,
0.004326866,
-0.0427658372,
0.0478815325,
-0.0425752737,
0.0110973315,
0.0226459932,
0.0406312384,
-0.0212775674,
0.051155556,
0.0409353189,
-0.0530650802,
-0.0097044781,
-0.0341928825,
0.0127888285,
0.0485121422,
0.015456453,
-0.0107783051,
-0.0076708463,
-0.0001453494,
0.0429441966,
0.0653208494,
0.0080244904,
0.0152561739,
-0.0032579706,
0.0005986912,
-0.001155598,
0.0661508143,
0.0795274004,
-0.0079991566,
0.0140114687,
-0.0545014068,
0.0224938691,
0.0130692916,
-0.0329151079,
-0.003508165,
-0.0178447347,
-0.0000652776,
-0.0407644548,
0.0038783043,
-0.0372023173,
-0.0339124873,
-0.0290985294,
-0.0003060392,
-0.0408735611,
-0.0392517708,
0.0501948409,
-0.0021110638,
-0.0089377016,
0.0876972973,
0.0560751185,
-0.0257310569,
0.0099878311,
-0.0728285015,
-0.036532864,
0.0464361571,
0.039008528,
-0.0609542243,
-0.047101967,
-0.009869568,
0.005036091,
0.0341396481,
0.0223271772,
-0.0360394493,
-0.0147807226,
-0.068800576,
-0.0121577531,
0.0486173742,
0.0091569489,
-0.0026725743,
-0.0171785895,
0.0435430147,
-0.0149954297,
-0.0351302326,
0.0028012735,
0.0499896482,
-0.1142873317,
-0.0423201136,
0.006561189,
-0.0061421944,
0.0418171287,
0.019140359,
-0.0059488751,
0.0065824157,
0.0283062886,
-0.0343450122,
-0.0170441046,
0.0060816309,
-0.003443406,
-0.034388382,
0.0531643219,
-0.0341416225,
0.0068678493,
-0.0276984852,
-0.0577056035,
-0.0437509716,
-0.0480232239,
0.0125600109,
0.0255189985,
-0.0221076347,
0.0332390666,
0.0243257359,
0.0002477805,
-0.0574250109,
-0.0073573473,
0.0070380159,
-0.0166315529,
0.0143031022,
-0.040981289,
0.0156405848,
-0.0036613827,
-0.0117394179,
0.0291177165,
-0.0046927468,
0.0300190821,
-0.0438775085,
0.0498637408,
-0.0382321812,
-0.0454498455,
-0.0764584467,
0.010268217,
0.0011623226,
0.0233249217,
0.036996074,
-0.0053623873,
-0.0219333135,
-0.0096426727,
-0.0873033106,
0.004497936,
-0.0083688861,
-0.0046684123,
0.0260127522,
0.0074884202,
0.0109837865,
-0.0277018603,
0.0175024569,
-0.0475511365,
-0.0242317207,
-0.0353141427,
-0.0321516171,
-0.0244104117,
0.0137526486,
-0.0195851158,
-0.0013404812,
-0.0064567593,
-0.0260839183,
-0.0067612091,
-0.0032881682,
0.0015082329,
0.0258492865,
-0.0194709674,
-0.0275432579,
0.0598313957,
0.0243969131,
-0.0276882388,
0.0129849836,
0.0009679647,
-0.0467595235,
-0.0384026952,
-0.0454686061,
-0.0210521594,
0.0546884909,
0.0014579124,
-0.0134218996,
-0.0360927507,
-0.0630412176,
-0.0254835282,
0.0352737978,
-0.0154948821,
0.0580818653,
-0.0499043837,
0.0229253341,
0.0305519123,
-0.0250026677,
0.054097902,
-0.0097769164,
0.0419254862,
-0.0894418284,
-0.0344796591,
-0.0270340797,
-0.0139898453,
-0.0372281447,
-0.0106183197,
0.011874292,
-0.0172164068,
-0.0489684753,
0.0170255974,
-0.0179345403,
-0.0689675435,
0.0932751074,
-0.0320225768,
0.0070129014,
-0.0415917523,
-0.0240882877,
-0.0354336239,
0.0399485938,
0.0047558215,
0.0304219592,
-0.0500277653,
0.0215217881,
-0.0507585965,
0.0161654931,
-0.0359263457,
0.0649137944,
0.0156214125,
-0.0039342903,
0.0075580957,
0.0126854405,
0.0088830795,
0.0528326258,
-0.0217593852,
-0.0245469268,
0.0354122929,
0.0575550012,
0.0051082834,
-0.0073915506,
0.0231777672,
0.0048214053,
0.0341593251,
-0.0565668531,
-0.0065381364,
0.0312530994,
0.0129725011,
-0.0458144918,
0.0195675455,
0.099149704,
0.0158779938,
-0.0413187034,
0.0116729178,
-0.0279827509,
-0.0288240183,
0.017613614,
0.0314211734,
-0.0904846862,
-0.0088677686,
-0.0159078203,
0.0517203659,
0.0187830105,
-0.0030987135,
0.0215370599,
-0.0523290858,
0.0363044366,
0.0252517704,
-0.0591534339,
0.000658758,
-0.036403399,
0.0336285383,
-0.0258496664,
0.028284274,
-0.0056879511,
-0.0472575203,
-0.0135626197,
0.0305748712,
-0.0726296976,
-0.0817505196,
0.0032827123,
-0.004169527,
0.0773542076,
0.0448780097,
-0.0058637154,
-0.0247591585,
-0.0085398061,
0.0513989106,
0.0157899912,
0.0051152119,
-0.0322591029,
0.0547837093,
0.0279480685,
0.0307176765,
0.0207853559,
0.0263654608,
-0.0463169776,
-0.0148610407,
0.0429028012,
0.0841645598,
-0.029078003,
-0.0306967832,
-0.0262330435,
0.0366454534,
-0.0098893354,
0.0577722266,
0.0144801056,
-0.0187996775,
0.0032378766,
-0.0287724286,
-0.0042620655,
0.0038212158,
-0.0351960957,
0.0478098691,
-0.0773821622,
0.0001814352,
-0.0685267672,
-0.013445246,
0.0353743434,
0.0053496244,
0.0387905501,
0.0583356172,
0.0197646637,
-0.0281301364,
-0.0291550197,
0.0185767859,
0.0154747395,
0.0050479253,
-0.0715018436,
-0.0633964688,
0.0809518844,
-0.0042880005,
-0.0125198746,
-0.009468535,
0.0000538786,
-0.0271802172,
-0.0016931454,
0.0293217376,
0.0150818834,
0.0318125784,
0.0003560403,
-0.0007783153,
0.0667489097,
0.0287585333,
0.0073568444,
0.02417114,
0.0256545953,
0.0146130128,
-0.0174058881,
-0.0037713442,
-0.019551307,
0.0151576661,
0.0459667109,
0.0328816697,
0.0074997591,
-0.0224802904,
0.0126308557,
0.0468862802,
0.0439255424,
-0.0304595437,
-0.015534292,
-0.0388556346,
0.0500395559,
-0.0029078554,
0.0370443091,
-0.0301211644,
-0.0358454771,
0.0438015349,
-0.0073512527,
-0.0152483974,
-0.0082463212,
-0.0601007193,
-0.0272770785,
-0.070744358,
0.0610774532,
0.0020552962,
0.0170346685,
0.0167778991,
-0.0083847092,
-0.0005402336,
-0.0165358521,
0.0153433634,
0.0127818845,
-0.0129858665,
0.0766725466,
-0.0136547443,
0.0392405316,
0.0166971087,
0.0455199443,
-0.0218118839,
-0.0209804438,
-0.0230158623,
0.0497027561,
0.0715194419,
0.0030879972,
0.0317295492,
-0.0094285104,
0.0071963416,
-0.03653308,
0.0084342882,
-0.0461289734,
0.0488091223,
0.0666918308,
-0.005806556,
0.0050337948,
-0.0062459493,
0.0856432021,
0.0104667535,
0.0742572248,
-0.0175988451,
0.0029770052,
-0.0373176672,
-0.0484464653,
0.0651705638,
-0.0237171501,
-0.0606339425,
0.0003147206,
-0.0491986349,
-0.0462553762,
0.0079637142,
-0.0292188749,
-0.026523497,
-0.0236372631,
0.0338241644,
0.0252570286,
0.0076871095,
-0.0101297991,
-0.0261479262,
0.0008900487,
0.0362994373,
-0.0266583692,
0.0438052416,
-5.871493631e-33,
-0.0308400486,
0.0065361997,
0.0484018438,
-0.010334665,
-0.0087499088,
-0.0006975336,
-0.0066916524,
0.0016583379,
-0.0149520505,
0.013832083,
-0.0258054398,
0.002519561,
0.0192130171,
0.0012056042,
0.0232517142,
-0.0127217518,
0.0173088685,
-0.004418164,
-0.0026810144,
-0.0045837914,
-0.0222525038,
0.0480502062,
0.0914331004,
-0.0736811161,
-0.0041564312,
0.040075928,
0.0127635216,
-0.0197868049,
-0.0428188331,
0.0720377266,
-0.0107215373,
0.0365219153,
0.0350880809,
-0.0405695438,
-0.009687813,
-0.0485457629,
-0.0826820061,
-0.0206596591,
0.0069943401,
0.0113948015,
0.0040577529,
-0.0399957411,
0.0612331368,
-0.0085006384,
-0.0415130183,
-0.0481524803,
0.0246431436,
-0.0778195411,
-0.0208559968,
-0.0404710509,
-0.0355723724,
0.0354978591,
0.0214062594,
0.030949248,
-0.0218049064,
0.0007512177,
-0.0248819832,
0.008900783,
-0.0537264124,
-0.0079896562,
0.0648171604,
0.0691582337,
0.0394012779,
-0.0274227262,
-0.0554691851,
0.0024263172,
-0.0091420654,
-0.0307976305,
0.0199722648,
-0.01831978,
0.0055864863,
0.0283430051,
0.0326776132,
0.0088334996,
0.0016930054,
-0.0385180414,
-0.1215734631,
0.0799100697,
-0.0232628882,
0.0101635186,
-0.0286364686,
0.0050040637,
-0.0208827257,
0.0011949087,
-0.000487524,
0.0423510075,
0.0042471653,
-0.0435144417,
0.0250391942,
-0.0191376228,
0.0151768513,
-0.0210469477,
0.0105692549,
-0.0543787405,
-0.008033786,
-0.0534491763,
-0.0083876168,
-0.0006895387,
-0.0257595181,
0.015742939,
-0.054898601,
-0.0437876545,
0.0178968832,
-0.0158062857,
0.0598445795,
-0.0024009161,
0.0238512754,
-0.0017939752,
-0.0832710341,
0.0024403916,
0.0220654737,
-0.0397285707,
0.0476156622,
0.0737873167,
0.0014424509,
0.0044672014,
0.0288771838,
0.0319433063,
0.0104872063,
-0.0660859495,
-0.0276384223,
-0.0090239933,
0.0125656594,
0.0041331877,
-0.0650968477,
0.0353232473,
-0.0166466832,
0.0474039949,
0.0349999703,
-0.0297306422,
-0.0139163183,
0.0107823787,
2.793e-7,
0.1093621105,
0.0380804129,
-0.0328689255,
-0.0117888832,
-0.0025179614,
-0.0197969135,
-0.0651518926,
0.0434868038,
-0.0116775911,
0.0117638819,
0.0589101501,
-0.0035811053,
0.0527802892,
0.0136662778,
-0.0703755245,
-0.0246025026,
-0.0309930798,
0.0004958066,
-0.0167159736,
-0.009878221,
0.019118933,
0.0972236544,
-0.0243145395,
-0.041793976,
0.0088708177,
-0.0020946064,
0.0518321842,
-0.0548465028,
0.0044930629,
0.0736106709,
0.0677688792,
0.0161639582,
-0.0073308949,
0.0217775404,
-0.0405932553,
0.0186687429,
0.002087649,
0.1302897185,
-0.0364284627,
0.013688717,
0.057622809,
0.0157814045,
0.0339879617,
-0.0444088914,
0.027936615,
-0.0057763429,
-0.030240953,
-0.018253427,
-0.0177607127,
-0.0162325092,
0.0662480667,
-0.0266543757,
-0.0010752412,
0.0344982855,
0.0381632261,
0.0226120781,
-0.0673689693,
-0.0526724532,
-0.0162195191,
0.0240814239,
-0.0226272848,
-0.0485770293,
0.0342892036,
-0.0171353556,
-0.0249459241,
-0.0747739524,
-0.0006409266,
2.481058529e-34,
0.0178231038,
-0.0297633298,
-0.0013597484,
0.0638288558,
-0.0089027267,
-0.0142362798,
0.0264063179,
0.0407340862,
-0.0067286547,
-0.0672521889,
-0.016879065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09773v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09773v1 | To be or not to be? an exploration of continuously controllable prompt engineering | 2023-11-16T10:55:29 | 2023-11-16T10:55:29 | Yuhan Sun, Mukai Li, Yixin Cao, Kun Wang, Wenxiao Wang, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the use of large language models becomes more widespread, techniques like
parameter-efficient fine-tuning and other methods for controlled generation are
gaining traction for customizing models and managing their outputs. However,
the challenge of precisely controlling how prompts influence these models is an
area ripe for further investigation. In response, we introduce ControlPE
(Continuously Controllable Prompt Engineering). ControlPE enables finer
adjustments to prompt effects, complementing existing prompt engineering, and
effectively controls continuous targets. This approach harnesses the power of
LoRA (Low-Rank Adaptation) to create an effect akin to prompt weighting,
enabling fine-tuned adjustments to the impact of prompts. Our methodology
involves generating specialized datasets for prompt distillation, incorporating
these prompts into the LoRA model, and carefully adjusting LoRA merging weight
to regulate the influence of prompts. This provides a dynamic and adaptable
tool for prompt control. Through our experiments, we have validated the
practicality and efficacy of ControlPE. It proves to be a promising solution
for control a variety of prompts, ranging from generating short responses
prompts, refusal prompts to chain-of-thought prompts. | [
0.0617462434,
0.0214006007,
-0.040732462,
0.0111250058,
-0.0035365946,
0.0121137993,
0.0291278381,
-0.0183366556,
0.0146034062,
-0.0074314224,
-0.027289778,
-0.0233123451,
-0.0204274636,
0.078464143,
0.0325304493,
-0.0831579491,
0.0672408864,
-0.053109087,
0.0230483729,
-0.0181659218,
0.0010546864,
-0.0157451462,
-0.0138424756,
0.0554292649,
0.0281082913,
-0.0387025028,
-0.0313836746,
0.0210979339,
-0.0020507341,
-0.003857166,
0.0328131877,
0.0889427066,
-0.0043007936,
0.0245381705,
0.0000019983,
-0.0735838115,
0.0012983432,
-0.0417463928,
-0.0738105625,
-0.0060024885,
0.0188588835,
0.0110506825,
-0.0232444704,
0.0324456543,
-0.0163676217,
0.0147921499,
0.0396869928,
-0.004161044,
0.0559463426,
0.0453719012,
0.004170333,
0.0071912957,
0.0002080821,
-0.0384696051,
0.0131598506,
-0.0235550441,
0.0065299412,
-0.0741202906,
0.0299292561,
0.0246753469,
-0.036054302,
0.0345950201,
0.0179308373,
-0.0477206185,
0.0034154239,
0.0000991339,
-0.0000457359,
-0.0690494925,
-0.0715428293,
0.0843921155,
0.0045575285,
-0.0189081933,
0.0134053128,
-0.0484829172,
0.0521523654,
-0.0111666489,
-0.0287714377,
0.0039426181,
0.0139541067,
-0.0194759518,
-0.0237281788,
-0.0044480707,
-0.0285323765,
-0.0043468773,
-0.0124765821,
0.0610996149,
0.0332290195,
-0.0448610894,
0.0179618225,
-0.0187088139,
0.0151260719,
-0.0815151706,
0.0076449788,
0.0297734477,
-0.0958047062,
-0.0008911412,
-0.0413764156,
-0.0006276986,
0.0433198735,
0.0465877838,
0.0329870991,
0.052711051,
-0.023770567,
0.0128210569,
-0.0025407071,
0.0821091682,
-0.0250360332,
0.0114613166,
-0.0213590618,
0.0311771873,
-0.0089730239,
-0.0083099799,
-0.0393110625,
-0.0138948178,
-0.0736056492,
-0.0072575798,
-0.0242859609,
0.0688687563,
-0.0141877346,
0.0232199207,
-0.0305485725,
0.0075719072,
-0.0202231053,
0.0126717808,
-0.0235548466,
0.0536689162,
-0.035417106,
0.0123533672,
0.0588847138,
-0.0468422621,
-0.0105356583,
-0.0147790471,
0.0221802425,
-0.0242368765,
-0.0154044684,
0.0359172486,
-0.0336711742,
-0.0187436827,
0.0226183478,
-0.0419271253,
-0.033969596,
-0.0302199479,
-0.0158863179,
-0.0198840089,
0.035834033,
-0.0095156617,
-0.0054592844,
-0.0364690833,
-0.0259641502,
0.0265428852,
-0.0029992706,
0.0587880164,
0.0036783323,
0.0046365801,
0.01336003,
0.0050485483,
-0.029054746,
0.0454309322,
0.0140900966,
0.0340393707,
0.0282762907,
-0.0210502762,
0.0144433668,
0.0507277176,
0.021091722,
0.0094829509,
-0.0168976299,
0.0044748653,
0.0382396504,
-0.0027286406,
0.0368259698,
0.0312009398,
-0.0051623615,
0.0219228175,
0.0730715245,
-0.0044523608,
-0.0000133718,
-0.0136576407,
0.053271208,
0.0132316267,
-0.0246020611,
0.0463398285,
-0.047649119,
0.0193441007,
-0.0480198637,
0.0251946468,
0.0273325834,
0.0413047485,
-0.0330500156,
-0.0343006663,
0.0177789778,
0.0336395502,
-0.0095914425,
0.0260668825,
-0.0263524149,
0.0280478019,
-0.0585682392,
0.0011693775,
0.0300722737,
-0.0533097945,
0.0010404105,
-0.0599585958,
0.0600657277,
0.0616061389,
0.0375761762,
-0.0186625533,
-0.0120120179,
-0.0234564021,
0.0318886936,
0.0618838705,
0.0717445463,
-0.0278903712,
-0.0009725121,
-0.0196332745,
-0.0465520546,
0.0193811674,
-0.0157147925,
0.0111205177,
-0.0321674123,
-0.0176552758,
-0.0071767876,
0.0557755716,
0.0118115181,
0.0206168517,
-0.0036173437,
-0.0281183384,
0.007268569,
0.0242924783,
0.0354762226,
0.0157030821,
0.0120754354,
0.0010977093,
0.0161643568,
0.0075116772,
0.0165295713,
-0.031897027,
-0.0474018417,
-0.0495884344,
0.0069537889,
0.0119649274,
-0.026127588,
0.0106774829,
-0.0267995335,
-0.0651971847,
-0.0159332231,
-0.0118564386,
0.0263844784,
-0.0252622236,
0.0485879295,
-0.0130725922,
0.028552074,
-0.0572852977,
0.0317697525,
0.0084236711,
0.0223041177,
0.1033985615,
0.0477362759,
0.0039754827,
-0.0735178664,
-0.0227783192,
0.0143173933,
-0.0230004787,
-0.0185916182,
0.0549919866,
0.023625968,
-0.0505372845,
-0.0584791489,
-0.0507253632,
-0.0086645773,
-0.0090472763,
-0.0324256681,
0.0139306588,
0.0383780263,
-0.0354856029,
-0.0175687354,
-0.0324846432,
-0.0087578362,
0.0187616833,
0.0345046036,
0.0244947188,
0.0069645005,
-0.0463990867,
-0.0587174743,
-0.0197171234,
-0.0010512691,
0.0104123093,
-0.0063955397,
-0.0212822296,
-0.0484197065,
0.028308861,
-0.0346450657,
0.0205006059,
0.0034189865,
-0.0223602355,
0.024744289,
0.00780968,
0.1040987596,
0.0398587845,
0.0167721473,
-0.0106752859,
0.052891165,
-0.0012059826,
-0.0535886064,
0.0481284969,
-0.0475078188,
-0.0406055488,
0.0043105013,
-0.020853946,
0.0298023019,
0.0488472097,
0.0363042653,
0.005382196,
-0.0858137161,
0.0198519118,
0.0001103713,
-0.0550892465,
-0.0494396053,
-0.0159017611,
-0.0612808652,
0.041127447,
-0.0262422133,
-0.0498622023,
0.0819634348,
-0.0103378603,
-0.012378864,
-0.0222561993,
0.0132293133,
0.0006618058,
0.0195036773,
-0.0097083626,
-0.0133356424,
0.0517236553,
-0.0299019571,
-0.0443687104,
-0.0054320884,
0.007790504,
-0.0029002291,
0.0179920588,
-0.0427388772,
-0.0074577844,
-0.0036357807,
-0.0420945585,
-0.0518743098,
-0.0615879819,
0.0008638295,
-0.0027935945,
0.0274616927,
0.0082963267,
0.0188714843,
-0.0340257771,
0.0447156318,
0.0635346323,
-0.0418071672,
-0.0015771339,
-0.0584329441,
0.0209130459,
0.0890737623,
0.0462331139,
0.0312880166,
-0.0273953211,
0.0687681288,
-0.0040195729,
0.0375771634,
-0.0008155596,
0.0309026055,
0.0409677178,
0.0518466048,
-0.0188376177,
-0.0051808953,
0.0662508234,
0.0546684526,
-0.0252195001,
-0.0471044406,
0.0963091254,
0.0424762219,
-0.0477609001,
0.0099126725,
-0.0328768082,
0.107939899,
0.0265567452,
0.027555665,
-0.0669402555,
-0.0213638954,
0.0271056294,
0.0162797105,
-0.0533223562,
-0.0052616522,
-0.0324339978,
-0.112837024,
0.0559115149,
-0.0148979267,
-0.0134881232,
-0.0016935974,
-0.0143586583,
0.0165889021,
0.0366335511,
0.038927719,
0.0491846278,
-0.0227855537,
-0.0014725128,
0.0212352704,
-0.0086434046,
-0.0284587909,
-0.0072322688,
0.0066018067,
0.074904941,
0.0641247332,
0.0040744557,
0.0118291629,
-0.0501595289,
0.0577261746,
-0.0594721138,
0.0138823213,
-0.0146873537,
0.0186581612,
0.0246890765,
-0.0190079175,
-0.024377916,
0.0496627241,
-0.0006920384,
-0.0322744772,
0.0300709438,
0.0686055869,
-0.0150896758,
-0.0146433031,
-0.0315035135,
0.0066237957,
0.0476641878,
0.0736626089,
0.058308199,
-0.0846124068,
-0.0054947436,
-0.0260237511,
-0.0335651971,
-0.0196978915,
-0.0136293042,
-0.0101479348,
-0.0253726542,
0.018570045,
-0.0549622662,
-0.0421743579,
0.0309933517,
0.0212049671,
0.0076681101,
-0.0195596311,
-0.0349927768,
-0.003316384,
0.0230827015,
0.0121634742,
-0.0198783632,
0.0158065464,
-0.0909780264,
-0.022174444,
-0.0004902579,
-0.0460574552,
-0.009075366,
0.0189825799,
-0.039142929,
-0.0745682567,
0.0230744146,
0.0601817928,
0.031326361,
0.0116166081,
0.0081610354,
-0.083164908,
0.0512541793,
-0.0030119801,
0.0028892311,
0.0519930385,
0.007752622,
0.0354463905,
-0.0256995782,
0.0287183691,
-0.0514573716,
0.0324624479,
0.031839136,
0.0288186483,
0.001969662,
-0.0623513833,
0.0115415715,
0.0207008664,
0.0065341378,
-0.0200447664,
-0.0508659482,
-0.0589079224,
0.032427121,
-0.0265540462,
0.0016971626,
-0.0380466171,
0.0008421056,
-0.0123645198,
-0.0397777036,
-0.0015361488,
-0.042694848,
-0.0492875241,
0.0241559949,
-0.0890975967,
0.0031549428,
-0.0058199442,
0.0319216251,
0.0324548148,
0.0116057331,
-0.0161300004,
0.0557414554,
0.0050584814,
0.0236380082,
0.023943739,
0.0848093256,
0.030462319,
-0.0125890207,
-0.0207391512,
0.0464871861,
-0.0747537762,
-0.0443080887,
0.0150135355,
0.028405061,
0.0122936238,
0.0447601527,
0.0421519354,
0.0230598841,
-0.0151938265,
-0.0081751533,
0.0087770522,
0.0407931209,
-0.0481711738,
0.0374141596,
0.0122452043,
-0.016802242,
-0.0163371358,
0.0286586192,
-0.0252018385,
0.0215064157,
-0.0264256131,
0.0513100512,
-0.0576044656,
0.0030654771,
-0.0142175779,
0.0081464713,
-0.0153034274,
0.0075610126,
-0.0696282536,
-0.0441197604,
0.017213583,
0.0300421156,
0.0104497783,
-0.0232264921,
0.0458822809,
0.0022168963,
-0.0301669259,
-0.0385426693,
-0.0147931073,
0.011864787,
0.0201741029,
-0.0252333209,
-0.0308763478,
-6.286430647e-33,
-0.0530540124,
0.0130247585,
0.01857448,
-0.0039332295,
-0.0178838428,
0.0003198497,
-0.0494739525,
0.0165904257,
-0.007699043,
-0.0020422346,
-0.0559222028,
-0.010378697,
0.0238806605,
0.0117188161,
0.0049885493,
-0.0125606013,
0.0603779219,
-0.0006668573,
-0.0610756129,
0.038188871,
0.0239508897,
0.014149392,
-0.028657604,
-0.0244678669,
0.0529014207,
0.0005222585,
-0.0379071943,
0.0186704304,
-0.0185560603,
0.0581259169,
-0.0224840362,
0.0498187952,
0.0044852546,
-0.0407092236,
-0.0349105373,
0.1085194424,
-0.052788496,
-0.0677472204,
0.0469538048,
-0.0366309322,
-0.0222898219,
-0.0546193831,
0.0033523571,
-0.028714899,
-0.0373635292,
0.0053071929,
0.0227822457,
-0.0054321783,
-0.0057038218,
-0.0209767874,
-0.0705705211,
-0.0210162923,
-0.0182703193,
-0.0345573537,
-0.0130769862,
0.0794882104,
-0.0022149624,
-0.0013094138,
-0.0120226899,
0.031286139,
0.0398206972,
0.028465908,
0.0373186804,
0.0238057189,
-0.0169473272,
0.0304335803,
0.0292843729,
0.0217283089,
0.0407840088,
-0.0146825053,
0.0236924421,
0.0068879901,
0.0333171077,
0.0474120378,
-0.018898515,
-0.0476767719,
-0.0065747937,
0.0070342827,
0.0424830094,
-0.0052485787,
0.0161337182,
-0.0053652124,
-0.0132309385,
-0.0226106197,
-0.0414529778,
-0.0184943564,
-0.0431717522,
0.0026431638,
0.0697679743,
0.0063690143,
-0.0287860222,
-0.0397644378,
0.0376669504,
0.0034969999,
-0.0070613958,
0.0104716644,
-0.0193221811,
0.0299893226,
0.0178493913,
0.0102825314,
-0.0372992866,
-0.0217959546,
0.0486965254,
-0.0174220055,
0.0094617726,
0.0320243724,
0.0008420475,
0.037503168,
-0.070138298,
0.0147051988,
-0.0059958566,
0.0759770498,
0.0002778223,
-0.0094950544,
0.0073767914,
-0.0024824373,
-0.010499889,
0.0178330131,
0.0142273093,
-0.0565544814,
-0.0449123085,
0.0280266479,
0.0081535215,
0.0608864687,
-0.0562580563,
-0.0111669702,
-0.0017384817,
0.0550565384,
0.03718739,
-0.0499266498,
-0.0140233031,
-0.008902411,
2.683e-7,
-0.0251294114,
0.0096586626,
0.0231019966,
0.0258397646,
0.0214669369,
0.012012057,
0.0096804155,
0.0510013849,
0.0572221503,
-0.031114744,
-0.0153261907,
-0.013445355,
0.0169767123,
-0.0322179347,
-0.0835271776,
0.0029624281,
-0.042986434,
0.0201932453,
-0.0560573973,
-0.008062521,
0.0619813874,
0.0507446118,
0.0076317638,
-0.0087864688,
-0.0110837109,
0.0226918515,
0.011650132,
-0.0223053861,
0.0061117206,
0.0277590379,
0.0375049934,
-0.0755969435,
0.0057735201,
0.0277120788,
-0.0111500304,
0.0379313119,
-0.027085809,
0.0547626726,
0.0120637361,
-0.039522782,
0.0199277867,
-0.0021085851,
-0.0073406538,
-0.0568128116,
0.0653847307,
-0.0322120301,
0.0240558963,
-0.0113294777,
-0.0088252388,
-0.033383064,
0.0142389219,
-0.0263084397,
-0.0255219862,
0.0157572385,
0.0249634404,
0.0351879857,
0.0077315099,
-0.0640066788,
-0.0038349282,
-0.0283725765,
-0.0443649441,
-0.0832461193,
-0.0432395488,
-0.0301243216,
-0.0197828729,
-0.0814475939,
-0.0027599756,
2.618800983e-34,
0.0240694974,
-0.0109176841,
0.0679992661,
-0.0029768595,
0.0076279794,
-0.0079153413,
0.0305080451,
0.0417126119,
0.0822275504,
-0.0918670222,
-0.0485326014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09766v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09766v4 | LLMs as Narcissistic Evaluators: When Ego Inflates Evaluation Scores | 2023-11-16T10:43:26 | 2024-06-07T09:41:36 | Yiqi Liu, Nafise Sadat Moosavi, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic evaluation of generated textual content presents an ongoing
challenge within the field of NLP. Given the impressive capabilities of modern
language models (LMs) across diverse NLP tasks, there is a growing trend to
employ these models in creating innovative evaluation metrics for automated
assessment of generation tasks. This paper investigates a pivotal question: Do
language model-driven evaluation metrics inherently exhibit bias favoring texts
generated by the same underlying language model? Specifically, we assess
whether prominent LM-based evaluation metrics (e.g. BARTScore, T5Score, and
GPTScore) demonstrate a favorable bias toward their respective underlying LMs
in the context of summarization tasks. Our findings unveil a latent bias,
particularly pronounced when such evaluation metrics are used in a
reference-free manner without leveraging gold summaries. These results
underscore that assessments provided by generative evaluation models can be
influenced by factors beyond the inherent text quality, highlighting the
necessity of developing more reliable evaluation protocols in the future. | [
0.0335451812,
0.0244011153,
-0.0036244891,
-0.0019151673,
-0.0538439155,
0.0117662381,
0.0047983527,
-0.0037819878,
-0.0221786555,
-0.0439552926,
-0.0269760191,
-0.0134319495,
0.0204018448,
0.0036370764,
0.0400414914,
-0.0539536364,
0.0000478528,
0.0195466876,
0.02447211,
0.0072739599,
0.0091209123,
0.0178861208,
0.0251659453,
0.0418795384,
0.0159633122,
-0.0038196186,
0.0522556379,
-0.0045688106,
0.0165307689,
-0.0208703801,
-0.0072856424,
0.0576787405,
-0.0289710499,
-0.0028513388,
0.0000018863,
-0.0503424928,
-0.009304869,
-0.0111483531,
0.0124480603,
0.0348006673,
0.1023373976,
0.0222280845,
0.0118998801,
0.0197148267,
-0.0405209064,
-0.0101229139,
-0.0100673093,
0.0290322378,
0.0679650977,
0.0517608859,
0.0064365007,
0.0010124648,
0.005307754,
-0.0229482651,
-0.0095065739,
-0.0178253129,
-0.0082133869,
0.0435562581,
-0.0337352045,
0.0231598038,
0.0226235557,
0.0099900868,
0.0011384239,
-0.0106372973,
0.0374745876,
0.0158144105,
-0.0323141403,
0.0024772102,
0.019111909,
0.0229341444,
0.0241653919,
-0.0232753996,
0.0099311685,
-0.0040906412,
0.0227224156,
0.0056746122,
-0.0704833418,
0.0590182617,
0.0056442209,
0.0263032075,
0.0412964262,
0.0392799117,
0.0090394653,
0.0218857788,
0.0291407518,
0.0390616544,
0.0154080838,
-0.0216273088,
-0.0169282481,
0.0315680392,
-0.0313266665,
-0.0692453831,
-0.0169117134,
0.0339712799,
-0.0104867797,
-0.0098077105,
-0.0395778902,
-0.0066247093,
0.0337028243,
-0.0273916665,
0.0530108698,
-0.0126109151,
0.0372980013,
-0.0055129589,
-0.0243461207,
0.0623211674,
0.0352816805,
-0.0085042799,
-0.0625977516,
0.0095209293,
-0.0300814379,
-0.0264266338,
0.0060174321,
0.0172429103,
-0.0008814785,
-0.0245789904,
-0.0560172461,
0.0110888183,
-0.0079727145,
-0.0220786836,
0.0011740373,
0.0309924651,
0.0072285719,
0.0101501234,
-0.0376167931,
0.0068172952,
-0.0335444808,
0.001439355,
0.0267034881,
-0.0260165054,
-0.001074117,
0.0286527108,
0.0022862253,
0.0041111745,
0.0093294429,
0.0562827177,
-0.0020072025,
-0.0357517377,
-0.0475412644,
-0.0261061415,
-0.0263985358,
-0.0639774576,
0.0095753148,
-0.0853662789,
-0.0018588131,
0.0380286351,
-0.0243645292,
-0.0098225512,
0.006984063,
0.04179167,
-0.0215584803,
-0.0305728093,
-0.0034885674,
0.0384604521,
0.0140538411,
0.0091991052,
0.0008070117,
0.0412441678,
0.0482187308,
0.0426869281,
0.0429103002,
0.0027439876,
0.0422446579,
0.0185500234,
-0.0120246783,
0.007481982,
-0.0185922123,
-0.0257791858,
-0.0364968255,
-0.0150876697,
0.046166569,
0.0806608945,
-0.0299745947,
0.0390974768,
0.0892207697,
0.0431684852,
0.0197971426,
0.0317203179,
0.0721194148,
0.0056204158,
0.018383326,
0.0791493207,
-0.0012805637,
0.0160919409,
-0.0470882244,
0.031081479,
0.0695527866,
0.0257917754,
0.0024980328,
-0.0840101764,
-0.0309466589,
0.0213364437,
-0.0173867699,
-0.0194351226,
-0.004848103,
0.0300781131,
-0.0367088579,
0.0212110057,
-0.00797862,
-0.0895035416,
0.042937763,
-0.031316638,
0.0080097597,
0.0510616787,
0.0665356144,
0.031054575,
0.0162386578,
-0.0019184829,
-0.0375636369,
0.0645173043,
0.0336748771,
-0.026951449,
-0.0349739231,
-0.022600526,
-0.0074397544,
-0.0547347181,
0.031533137,
-0.0296499226,
0.01065965,
-0.0225207657,
0.0459270999,
-0.0528770462,
-0.0905037224,
0.0469106361,
-0.028114805,
-0.0320305675,
-0.0136792138,
-0.0203898307,
0.0138539858,
0.0347179025,
-0.0219623204,
0.0510942005,
0.0099052014,
-0.0311713479,
-0.0320668779,
0.0040486283,
-0.0306021944,
-0.0180775765,
0.0115008196,
-0.0739289373,
0.0180528611,
-0.0034947456,
-0.0172988027,
-0.03939569,
0.0377009995,
-0.0557656884,
-0.0043926905,
-0.0409992822,
0.0298147425,
0.0041550016,
0.0006304557,
-0.043722339,
0.0866260901,
-0.0102591561,
0.067478016,
0.0418238305,
0.0160877276,
0.0160334297,
0.0011108597,
-0.0015228406,
-0.0193679407,
0.001364324,
0.0113508068,
0.0670693442,
0.0171837565,
-0.0212180931,
-0.082582593,
-0.0812572688,
0.0168061312,
-0.0268280469,
0.0232798606,
0.0581403822,
-0.0229816269,
-0.0177131407,
0.0667068288,
-0.0555069074,
-0.0585363135,
0.0530206151,
0.0103315376,
0.0464994162,
-0.0103823468,
0.049487818,
-0.050322935,
0.0091635715,
0.0104131456,
0.064390406,
0.0337191075,
0.0479920805,
-0.0273919161,
0.0691683143,
-0.0607063398,
-0.0673570633,
0.0124577014,
-0.0295768473,
0.025523277,
0.0125839552,
0.0803569108,
0.0266208127,
0.0626507774,
0.0220137872,
0.0306174774,
-0.0170935355,
-0.0303260349,
-0.029220283,
-0.0393188931,
-0.0071129207,
0.0140100969,
-0.0839687735,
0.0413653441,
0.0449191295,
0.0371729247,
0.0034450572,
-0.0371301286,
0.0664094165,
-0.0571818724,
-0.0152271027,
0.0045495373,
-0.0118071325,
-0.0085286722,
0.030264806,
-0.0281814467,
-0.0525238924,
0.0256130472,
-0.0526192784,
0.0102020865,
-0.0243943762,
-0.0091910334,
-0.0584723167,
0.046790354,
0.0284125153,
0.0286083687,
0.00634052,
0.0032751465,
-0.0457504131,
0.018692039,
0.020681303,
-0.0446961597,
0.0454622507,
-0.0327753536,
-0.0229864754,
-0.003113817,
0.0003535913,
-0.0288782567,
0.0141729163,
0.0292062927,
0.0092684506,
0.0685127676,
0.0233602896,
-0.0119753694,
0.0108924676,
0.037092559,
-0.0122635653,
-0.0491812006,
-0.022986412,
0.0145905903,
0.0613619685,
0.0596070737,
-0.0198887344,
0.0506783053,
-0.0378641412,
-0.0227822997,
0.0026288726,
0.0121045616,
0.0197404232,
0.0016192847,
0.0091898767,
0.0190364905,
-0.0391601361,
-0.0238987859,
0.0188253075,
0.0457344204,
-0.0385942608,
-0.0088782646,
0.1150942296,
0.0389553942,
-0.0032974563,
-0.0064777979,
0.0043725339,
0.0272485279,
0.0121669136,
-0.0186688844,
-0.031601619,
0.0232051481,
0.0022874989,
0.0295622628,
-0.0396366827,
-0.0097473273,
-0.042182371,
-0.1326875091,
0.042136196,
0.0187531319,
-0.0421034172,
0.0136459619,
-0.0316752978,
-0.0075898319,
-0.0059660715,
0.0127444109,
0.0227938592,
-0.0400902033,
0.0323137306,
0.0201108139,
-0.072932899,
-0.0436580479,
-0.0359444469,
-0.0216273814,
0.0350123309,
0.0581077822,
0.0276856311,
-0.014889583,
-0.006828791,
0.0118021332,
-0.0538176484,
-0.0124645615,
-0.0075340234,
0.0640767068,
-0.0169119034,
0.0148635963,
-0.0468276665,
-0.0020568713,
0.0113401357,
1.601e-7,
-0.0336343981,
0.0083149215,
0.0259423237,
-0.0482363254,
-0.0400234573,
0.0531747155,
-0.0262181237,
0.0980365723,
0.0653370544,
-0.0276766531,
-0.0250036176,
-0.0479346402,
0.0215089805,
-0.0600999705,
-0.0575565472,
0.0296366718,
0.0099808266,
-0.0190600865,
-0.1105471328,
-0.0901806876,
-0.0107260058,
-0.0204544161,
-0.0010859567,
0.0196761061,
-0.072969757,
-0.0361975953,
-0.0089006089,
-0.0064702439,
-0.009833443,
-0.0233863816,
-0.0359653756,
-0.0070885015,
0.0211297963,
-0.0298502259,
-0.0143100414,
0.0381456763,
-0.047741238,
-0.0471718162,
-0.0214158595,
0.0429403484,
0.024343919,
-0.0319717117,
0.0140832029,
-0.0236084629,
0.0389994271,
0.0460533202,
-0.006663274,
0.0494800992,
-0.0086371256,
0.0181822926,
-0.0050698947,
0.0109813912,
-0.0533150658,
0.0505513288,
0.0061470787,
0.0583120883,
0.0347403288,
-0.0524887852,
0.0331914723,
0.0339065641,
-0.0041745771,
-0.0560298823,
0.0273596048,
-0.0227411948,
-0.0830674022,
-0.0330227353,
-0.0510105342,
-0.0301092044,
0.0139928358,
-0.0063245781,
0.0418755524,
-0.0235278681,
0.0518958494,
-0.0474269837,
0.0794836059,
-0.0460047647,
-0.0059787645,
-0.0292184334,
-0.0191187598,
-0.0510682613,
-0.0171465818,
-0.0511755124,
-0.0492723435,
-0.0459966511,
-0.009222175,
0.0014912122,
0.0409474261,
0.0122163007,
0.0243115183,
0.0191716459,
0.0457469858,
-0.056402348,
0.0015098203,
-0.0687532946,
-0.0013916107,
0.0486528724,
-0.0274263788,
0.0997717232,
-0.0150868082,
0.0102324849,
-0.0308666211,
0.015161016,
0.0357122608,
-0.0405346118,
-0.0279570837,
0.0094982386,
-0.0205049012,
-0.0301347915,
0.0992123038,
-0.0058878278,
0.0099929273,
-0.0059592025,
-0.0142866187,
-0.0282299109,
-0.0658135787,
-0.0065658484,
-0.0199173633,
0.0363752358,
-0.0151441144,
-0.0855198577,
-0.0413932018,
0.0167193823,
0.0376903266,
0.0499660783,
-0.0387525223,
0.0255786143,
0.0690132156,
-0.0291240197,
0.0103494097,
-0.0573719591,
-0.0168119613,
-0.0195832402,
0.0250539705,
-0.0141149415,
-6.209102955e-33,
-0.0460198075,
-0.0433683954,
0.0088831456,
0.0252555311,
-0.0538126118,
-0.0117434384,
-0.055965133,
0.008191742,
0.0250114407,
-0.006812403,
-0.0139341708,
-0.0303327795,
-0.0085066454,
0.0147467051,
0.007229703,
0.021114178,
0.0457993969,
-0.0117419595,
-0.079390049,
0.0246220995,
0.0173648521,
-0.0263611451,
0.0255008657,
-0.01206451,
0.0450360626,
-0.0469370931,
-0.0254445914,
-0.0307393614,
0.0526575781,
0.0274179149,
-0.0177823156,
0.0356777012,
0.0497487597,
-0.0603245795,
-0.0059525152,
-0.0030514221,
-0.0178878549,
-0.0285850968,
0.0364349559,
-0.0639376566,
-0.0453994274,
-0.0524611883,
0.058047317,
0.005856514,
-0.0472182035,
-0.02073339,
0.0521412157,
-0.042636238,
-0.0099065993,
-0.0773554891,
-0.0398152135,
0.0239632502,
-0.0022417752,
0.0019593118,
-0.0160773396,
0.0281161517,
-0.0170673914,
0.0198399723,
-0.0035667594,
0.046211455,
0.0332113542,
0.0625100285,
0.042826958,
0.0039468105,
-0.0029138252,
0.0688930824,
-0.0071483683,
0.0134644462,
-0.0106700119,
-0.000422812,
0.0085869916,
0.0205511916,
0.0607795231,
0.0350154266,
0.0103632407,
0.007917827,
-0.0303513892,
0.0814944208,
-0.0279865526,
-0.0069031301,
0.0397037268,
-0.0419481993,
-0.0153373405,
-0.0294796824,
-0.0513490438,
-0.0532337539,
-0.0187589377,
-0.0404809341,
0.0171249676,
0.0262502804,
-0.0303542409,
-0.0578581691,
0.0076466012,
-0.0109211244,
-0.0035877419,
0.0164825972,
-0.0620183647,
0.0235509444,
-0.0044750259,
-0.0027297051,
-0.0364190154,
0.0315901637,
0.0144106029,
0.0466194898,
0.0075783022,
-0.0100122867,
0.014247884,
0.0065276502,
-0.0398526415,
0.0157032441,
-0.0237544123,
0.0314218774,
-0.024912132,
-0.0263654515,
0.0098385084,
-0.0148983225,
-0.0118755093,
0.0140764983,
-0.0041804207,
0.0108441301,
-0.0151656894,
0.0150253791,
0.0122901388,
0.0087298052,
-0.0334908552,
0.0291222129,
-0.0234481506,
0.028815534,
0.0388580859,
-0.0101652909,
-0.0216063894,
-0.0194063932,
2.578e-7,
0.0498350486,
0.0656639561,
0.0088814981,
0.0427866504,
-0.0021833994,
0.0214531366,
-0.0090759518,
0.0111334696,
0.0253982879,
0.0082612671,
-0.0003510489,
0.0122083528,
0.0491371192,
0.0408997908,
-0.0528410487,
0.036265038,
-0.0877501592,
-0.0103189526,
-0.0140006905,
-0.0197659321,
0.0664936081,
0.0115016475,
-0.0260272995,
-0.0054851277,
-0.0305028725,
-0.0530183166,
0.0793032572,
-0.0259671733,
-0.0392156988,
0.0577926338,
0.067555517,
0.0077059232,
0.0098155811,
-0.0010268858,
-0.0063856533,
0.0101407068,
0.0512682721,
0.0422196612,
0.0544086248,
-0.0284279343,
0.0322199166,
-0.0085052503,
0.0289995726,
-0.0480508767,
0.0568987988,
-0.0327165797,
-0.0021440247,
-0.0378833935,
-0.0476842299,
0.0157676358,
0.0085328929,
-0.0284797121,
-0.0334527977,
0.0575697608,
-0.0155695137,
0.0158007164,
0.0109244743,
-0.0421178676,
-0.0553474538,
0.0115091279,
-0.014378774,
-0.0473244302,
-0.0228994098,
0.0321649984,
-0.0145944692,
-0.0701751933,
0.0049577202,
2.461804529e-34,
0.0519005992,
-0.0244389661,
0.007255015,
-0.0250957087,
0.0378403962,
0.0158362575,
-0.0281027649,
-0.0000617116,
-0.0322638415,
-0.0457099713,
0.0013828733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09763v1 | Test-time Backdoor Mitigation for Black-Box Large Language Models with Defensive Demonstrations | 2023-11-16T10:38:43 | 2023-11-16T10:38:43 | Wenjie Mo, Jiashu Xu, Qin Liu, Jiongxiao Wang, Jun Yan, Chaowei Xiao, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing studies in backdoor defense have predominantly focused on the
training phase, overlooking the critical aspect of testing time defense. This
gap becomes particularly pronounced in the context of Large Language Models
(LLMs) deployed as Web Services, which typically offer only black-box access,
rendering training-time defenses impractical. To bridge this gap, our work
introduces defensive demonstrations, an innovative backdoor defense strategy
for blackbox large language models. Our method involves identifying the task
and retrieving task-relevant demonstrations from an uncontaminated pool. These
demonstrations are then combined with user queries and presented to the model
during testing, without requiring any modifications/tuning to the black-box
model or insights into its internal mechanisms. Defensive demonstrations are
designed to counteract the adverse effects of triggers, aiming to recalibrate
and correct the behavior of poisoned models during test-time evaluations.
Extensive experiments show that defensive demonstrations are effective in
defending both instance-level and instruction-level backdoor attacks, not only
rectifying the behavior of poisoned models but also surpassing existing
baselines in most scenarios. | [
0.0048430865,
0.0725978315,
-0.0169336833,
0.061744757,
-0.0465695374,
-0.0166170076,
0.0455088839,
0.0140070766,
0.037239328,
-0.0430495329,
0.0015619572,
-0.0275840461,
-0.015556545,
0.0239013061,
0.074432373,
0.0484429114,
0.0534264892,
-0.0592948645,
-0.0544368587,
-0.0142994579,
-0.0259873811,
-0.0187202562,
-0.0066211522,
0.0103750285,
0.0188327003,
-0.0181817096,
-0.0395630226,
0.0142777469,
-0.0010689035,
-0.0271415301,
-0.0012073955,
0.0120377699,
-0.0014263493,
0.0464084968,
0.0000020059,
-0.0189535152,
-0.030995138,
0.056467969,
-0.0662948862,
0.0734526813,
-0.0070058443,
0.0177087802,
-0.0312910751,
0.0513261333,
-0.0280091725,
-0.0016309042,
0.0143468995,
0.014750178,
0.0746988654,
0.0685410425,
0.0107845981,
0.0388398767,
0.0134375105,
-0.008082089,
-0.0312018134,
-0.0329784825,
-0.0003154252,
-0.0299046263,
0.0194954928,
-0.0017394738,
-0.0095072361,
-0.0263066832,
0.029390309,
-0.0127577968,
-0.0832999572,
0.0421713889,
-0.053974513,
0.0303243957,
-0.0106517877,
-0.0035106619,
-0.0343732983,
-0.0171951856,
-0.0040613934,
0.0234852787,
-0.0096987309,
0.0109550273,
0.0236492101,
0.0176909808,
0.0231901985,
-0.0261758175,
0.0096174926,
-0.0267662071,
0.0293558203,
0.0036639876,
0.0180528108,
0.0412778296,
0.0352128744,
-0.0303509962,
-0.0268666111,
-0.0350200273,
0.0439375341,
-0.0600518584,
-0.0197465867,
0.0315686874,
-0.0117519554,
0.0242085252,
-0.0251912437,
-0.045169659,
0.0463121943,
-0.0456746928,
0.0379190706,
0.0303032715,
-0.0390346348,
0.0241271369,
-0.0402231403,
0.063113071,
-0.0190826952,
0.0336490236,
0.044438187,
0.0408986509,
-0.0196680613,
0.0079332646,
-0.0453350283,
0.0285030082,
0.0107532935,
-0.0060552671,
0.0148587599,
0.0430240259,
-0.0054990482,
0.0503415726,
-0.04204835,
-0.0118543785,
-0.019222673,
-0.0028270481,
0.0229648221,
-0.0344539024,
0.0184028279,
-0.0519496836,
-0.0322855636,
-0.1200327128,
-0.039049197,
-0.032622166,
-0.0609522611,
-0.0239146333,
0.0177994147,
0.0865457207,
0.0234649889,
-0.0049806805,
-0.0524942875,
-0.0819691867,
0.0043820622,
-0.0019568293,
0.0058481535,
-0.068608202,
-0.0530638471,
-0.0212443303,
-0.0061408184,
-0.0291630924,
0.0017142025,
-0.0112703899,
-0.0022400422,
0.0498391315,
0.0496129394,
-0.01739976,
0.012643774,
0.0254215039,
-0.0029975343,
0.0654823408,
0.0085575553,
0.0133248661,
0.0327726752,
-0.0130279846,
0.0336331092,
0.0573862754,
0.0329310857,
0.0658080652,
-0.0624760799,
0.018674437,
0.0606075153,
-0.0081504826,
-0.0218656696,
0.0179207698,
-0.0154238651,
-0.0274636485,
0.0628573745,
0.0185900256,
-0.0752858296,
0.0008976421,
0.0120714754,
-0.0017415392,
-0.0279253088,
-0.0119774127,
-0.0548048578,
-0.0128634255,
-0.0514625087,
-0.0035824515,
0.0040216413,
0.0394298024,
-0.0065059485,
-0.0074474132,
0.0103229908,
-0.0031489292,
0.0095347585,
0.0257336479,
0.0528331883,
0.0349206552,
-0.0143382084,
0.0609606616,
0.023062693,
-0.0185550619,
-0.0405318215,
-0.1081268787,
-0.0516051464,
0.0534166917,
0.0853413567,
-0.0182802752,
-0.0452763066,
-0.0119710732,
0.0057941051,
0.0542340651,
0.0152987,
0.0256533194,
-0.0167855676,
0.0034751035,
-0.0299930163,
-0.0263794027,
0.0427842811,
0.0232352857,
0.0142710749,
-0.0013726077,
0.0015485105,
-0.0198117457,
-0.0822112411,
0.0297304559,
-0.0267018192,
-0.0697867423,
0.0040982896,
0.0122192977,
0.0112924995,
-0.0192130208,
-0.0256839637,
0.0085883532,
0.0376279019,
0.0428502671,
0.0212304462,
-0.0197242852,
0.0216047745,
0.0041132425,
0.0178581662,
0.0222257245,
0.0246941335,
0.0861245766,
-0.0213409625,
-0.0203576162,
0.0391441323,
-0.0399698317,
0.045992095,
0.0163383838,
0.0217594691,
-0.0251460467,
0.0168861691,
-0.023971349,
-0.0105471732,
0.008517269,
-0.0210912172,
-0.0157168936,
0.0129335476,
0.0066549135,
-0.0301728342,
-0.0591481104,
0.0221079905,
-0.0246573482,
0.0263156313,
-0.0284888446,
0.0197663493,
-0.0261410177,
0.0296711791,
-0.0781076476,
0.0205134321,
-0.0320438407,
0.0635773242,
0.0214483775,
0.0219672676,
-0.0190563537,
-0.0428473614,
0.0107159177,
-0.032101579,
-0.0176095422,
0.0264591314,
-0.0256334208,
-0.0098164175,
-0.0289591067,
0.0152370734,
-0.0115866084,
-0.0312149841,
0.0975340977,
-0.0404279754,
0.0643968284,
-0.0298469067,
0.0311914943,
0.0038661659,
0.0371501371,
-0.0171541832,
-0.0632397532,
0.019335473,
-0.0007432759,
-0.0473268628,
0.0976068452,
0.0121995443,
0.0201046485,
0.0629868358,
0.0088823102,
-0.0989474356,
0.0009044203,
0.0349668302,
-0.0586171634,
-0.063316673,
-0.0123994881,
-0.0058210501,
0.0722847208,
-0.010186173,
-0.0281528104,
-0.0182706881,
0.008522274,
-0.0234086588,
0.0002889855,
-0.0237229373,
-0.0677830726,
-0.0543651916,
-0.0316457413,
-0.0048757573,
-0.0740399957,
0.0669881999,
-0.051586464,
0.0094157737,
-0.0543658882,
-0.0112299537,
0.0117335869,
0.0626836047,
-0.0226521324,
0.0049139881,
-0.0098575205,
-0.0299005639,
-0.0327267535,
0.0103567382,
0.0256341211,
-0.0567836501,
-0.0206961092,
-0.0352028199,
-0.0230786856,
-0.0205837023,
-0.0384680741,
-0.0502282754,
-0.0264179166,
-0.0291963425,
-0.0155657493,
-0.0196332335,
-0.0047361548,
0.0244778264,
-0.0030202428,
0.0069881501,
0.0383890606,
-0.0237326901,
-0.0038497709,
-0.0307914373,
-0.0529200397,
0.0240245294,
-0.0775007755,
-0.0040697111,
-0.0230562557,
0.0428732447,
0.054010056,
0.1093832478,
-0.0236708969,
-0.0469246432,
-0.0149122514,
0.0143169416,
-0.0134546896,
-0.0039126156,
0.0479967333,
-0.0138466191,
-0.0730916336,
-0.0597427599,
0.0603776276,
0.0282095429,
-0.0473640524,
0.0128406845,
-0.0158678852,
0.0249795541,
0.0213354249,
0.063795954,
-0.0632757768,
0.0075964662,
0.0410393476,
0.0249594674,
-0.0286993701,
0.0015678802,
-0.0123812808,
-0.1634060591,
0.0026271457,
0.0090702465,
-0.038192898,
0.0422345102,
-0.025848873,
-0.0115291821,
0.021789901,
0.0617441423,
0.0235047415,
0.0249847211,
0.0028136873,
0.0418717712,
0.001059129,
-0.0341545567,
0.0552399382,
-0.028363524,
0.0410776027,
0.047342632,
-0.0356484167,
-0.0184220821,
0.0193085261,
0.0610856973,
0.0069169677,
0.0135166524,
0.0119022429,
0.0374696255,
0.0128037725,
-0.023214465,
0.0569574386,
0.0143917082,
-0.0303618517,
0.0349873155,
0.0400041901,
0.0539997481,
-0.0349798501,
0.0153179159,
-0.0137666892,
-0.0544662736,
0.0456670076,
0.0316423699,
0.0132994046,
-0.0531842075,
-0.0136634661,
-0.0360379219,
-0.0135690728,
-0.0284299944,
-0.0559638292,
0.0141822221,
0.0034632785,
-0.0375277102,
-0.0116271097,
-0.0047537806,
-0.0169641711,
0.0662878007,
0.0423107781,
-0.0197915118,
-0.0103126485,
0.0128477635,
-0.0249010269,
0.0469555445,
-0.0519417599,
0.0569376089,
-0.0415299684,
0.0082292249,
-0.0144674964,
-0.0131834317,
-0.0351788588,
-0.0082636597,
-0.0444488898,
-0.0844632238,
0.0302516986,
0.068386659,
0.0271149408,
0.0209463313,
-0.0189954303,
-0.0498514287,
0.0740778968,
-0.0043832641,
-0.0562210791,
0.0019650583,
0.055920314,
-0.0565333106,
0.013398407,
0.0007785633,
-0.0613168515,
-0.0143675841,
0.0756388381,
-0.0114504937,
-0.006938912,
0.0191930458,
-0.0055355635,
0.0413961038,
0.063738741,
0.0031232284,
-0.0227342527,
0.0334654376,
0.0594341196,
-0.042635031,
-0.0201245584,
0.0014195105,
0.0498734899,
-0.0129201151,
-0.0018708325,
0.026452234,
-0.0232081264,
0.0211984273,
0.0280823894,
-0.0196557436,
0.0135662658,
0.0459741913,
-0.0037281192,
0.0827609152,
0.0062464946,
0.0014776933,
0.0129201291,
0.0345447063,
0.0437144227,
-0.0169199072,
0.0358947106,
0.0249233823,
0.0071333935,
-0.0155350696,
0.0343570709,
-0.0514251888,
-0.0406852327,
0.0099003911,
0.0217751581,
-0.0137056997,
0.0156280063,
0.0180224385,
-0.0166220926,
0.0206237826,
-0.0056161638,
-0.0402230024,
-0.0280556474,
-0.0407767743,
0.020646628,
-0.0014263972,
0.0332651809,
0.0337021127,
0.0679420754,
0.021839669,
0.0750449821,
-0.0032632183,
0.0030778819,
-0.0388583131,
-0.0133801717,
0.041991394,
0.0174807962,
-0.026686037,
-0.0531156622,
-0.049801223,
-0.0886732042,
-0.0386720486,
0.024821803,
0.0087464033,
-0.0113831218,
-0.0008164818,
0.0708220303,
0.0327124558,
0.0348674282,
-0.0550238267,
0.0194026008,
0.0075238249,
-0.0459565148,
0.0020085245,
-5.65334245e-33,
0.0006068205,
-0.0607956871,
0.0127028665,
-0.0392311439,
0.0163459871,
0.0355353393,
-0.0096482951,
0.010069306,
0.0037311737,
0.0050955508,
-0.0179084651,
0.0230966229,
0.0321783088,
0.0077271364,
0.0187945813,
0.0106329899,
-0.0021011683,
-0.0292290282,
-0.0495272577,
0.0455099344,
0.0354123227,
0.0014349615,
0.0261826534,
-0.0339880288,
0.0283085816,
-0.0229234323,
0.0001143519,
0.0102206003,
-0.0794361159,
0.061793495,
0.0125582488,
0.0284057446,
-0.0013187418,
-0.0430287346,
0.0060304138,
-0.0103918985,
0.0284272078,
0.0121828252,
-0.0297310408,
-0.0066928612,
0.0042235651,
-0.0355447754,
0.0294215903,
-0.001530629,
-0.0109995557,
0.0053441464,
-0.0043713199,
-0.0127836671,
-0.0037384641,
-0.0137479408,
0.0018984404,
0.0079096537,
-0.01691214,
-0.015136065,
0.0054644048,
-0.0090939226,
0.0163132269,
-0.0614754185,
0.0000889986,
0.0213260092,
0.0439911783,
-0.0002679498,
0.0600766614,
0.0415257886,
-0.00806568,
0.0311876107,
-0.0157649685,
0.0335258842,
0.0419277847,
-0.0110312067,
0.0605736747,
0.0188651495,
0.0355990827,
0.0149527621,
0.0482837372,
-0.0182321332,
-0.0086576035,
-0.0060321549,
0.0529751815,
0.0156643465,
0.0715982318,
-0.015036012,
-0.0904660001,
0.0053602126,
-0.0353810899,
0.0209235903,
-0.0301196165,
-0.0231745653,
0.0116070835,
0.0221082252,
-0.0459459797,
-0.0329262204,
0.0262452681,
-0.0406139567,
0.0019574843,
0.0167158842,
0.0025621371,
-0.0241798554,
-0.0152377272,
0.0114163198,
0.0314461142,
-0.0332056172,
-0.0299841166,
-0.028833583,
0.0258666854,
-0.0110328356,
0.0020730752,
0.0217281803,
-0.0738384649,
0.0162554812,
-0.0541634932,
0.033615265,
0.0341510773,
0.0069172638,
0.0357188769,
-0.008774667,
0.0301969424,
0.0100614848,
0.0351273976,
-0.0482618548,
-0.0526803136,
0.0529715866,
0.0025785167,
-0.0198053066,
-0.0190951675,
0.0160980634,
0.0289635211,
0.0479855053,
0.0517465398,
-0.0337580442,
-0.0053388914,
-0.0106522115,
2.829e-7,
-0.0055681495,
0.0277751125,
-0.0137070743,
0.0334428959,
0.0308185276,
0.0540248603,
-0.0095970128,
0.0559841134,
0.0212665107,
-0.0182356462,
-0.0357830375,
0.0050275675,
0.0546584167,
0.0272556376,
-0.0465107337,
-0.0283856671,
-0.0843481869,
0.0029605359,
-0.0728069469,
-0.0184646267,
0.0036895489,
0.061496906,
0.002209516,
-0.0339568667,
0.0059463587,
-0.0601839088,
-0.0002870149,
0.0023064392,
-0.0129742855,
-0.0020534876,
0.0319950059,
0.0720990971,
0.0159183741,
0.0589681417,
-0.0542787984,
0.0197128225,
-0.0877755731,
0.0079150861,
-0.0067154756,
-0.0134127038,
-0.0285585131,
-0.0688190758,
-0.0142258378,
-0.0132863717,
0.0559704117,
0.0301371813,
0.0005395238,
-0.0357027873,
0.0057817483,
-0.0767050385,
-0.0164354853,
-0.0258327946,
0.0065101432,
0.0386233665,
-0.0036923175,
-0.0297774188,
0.0194181614,
-0.054187119,
-0.0507205687,
-0.0250937622,
-0.0319159441,
-0.0467124805,
0.0098735755,
0.0208892375,
-0.0451049581,
-0.0168379452,
0.0096548693,
3.011911089e-34,
0.0073377769,
-0.0183873624,
0.0209057052,
0.0351530798,
0.037132822,
0.0020850434,
0.0053426744,
0.0003984343,
0.0077880621,
-0.0111102359,
-0.047212854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09762v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09762v2 | Graph Elicitation for Guiding Multi-Step Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T10:36:08 | 2024-06-22T18:04:33 | Jinyoung Park, Ameen Patel, Omar Zia Khan, Hyunwoo J. Kim, Joo-Kyung Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting along with sub-question generation and
answering has enhanced multi-step reasoning capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs). However, prompting the LLMs to directly generate sub-questions
is suboptimal since they sometimes generate redundant or irrelevant questions.
To deal with them, we propose a GE-Reasoning method, which directs LLMs to
generate proper sub-questions and corresponding answers. Concretely, given an
input question, we first prompt the LLM to generate knowledge triplets, forming
a graph representation of the question. Unlike conventional knowledge triplets,
our approach allows variables as head or tail entities, effectively
representing a question as knowledge triplets. Second, for each triplet, the
LLM generates a corresponding sub-question and answer along with using
knowledge retrieval. If the prediction confidence exceeds a threshold, the
sub-question and prediction are incorporated into the prompt for subsequent
processing. This approach encourages that sub-questions are grounded in the
extracted knowledge triplets, reducing redundancy and irrelevance. Our
experiments demonstrate that our approach outperforms previous CoT prompting
methods and their variants on multi-hop question answering benchmark datasets. | [
0.0460166335,
-0.001731224,
-0.0033917455,
0.0523413084,
-0.0618238635,
0.0263529103,
0.0109050535,
-0.0147479475,
0.0717797652,
-0.0396581925,
0.0133269709,
-0.0150253763,
-0.0300898533,
0.0298221968,
0.030101642,
-0.0341937877,
0.0375302024,
-0.0635510981,
0.0024250385,
-0.0308680981,
0.0094835088,
0.0424901731,
-0.0028901037,
0.0149371251,
-0.0256109461,
-0.0391323939,
-0.0439252146,
0.0105845369,
-0.0104529243,
-0.0393229015,
-0.0240682773,
0.0209411606,
0.0335366949,
0.0049071964,
0.0000020809,
-0.0560434423,
-0.0473301783,
-0.000015534,
-0.0685208291,
-0.0333708897,
-0.0289501995,
0.0178960375,
0.0519126058,
0.0275572985,
-0.0424431562,
0.0098315999,
-0.0050928858,
0.0359695852,
0.0705343038,
0.0349457003,
0.0015902461,
-0.0329288803,
-0.0217172336,
0.0151559748,
0.0134903584,
-0.0384473167,
0.0420913771,
0.0512779318,
0.0377356112,
0.0166368503,
-0.0258795861,
0.0238616429,
0.0364417732,
0.0001317719,
-0.0030274058,
0.0266097896,
-0.0052865669,
-0.0036672403,
-0.0099570518,
0.1017557681,
0.0272609238,
-0.0202172492,
-0.0032788478,
0.0070968228,
0.021670213,
0.0368615687,
-0.0677265525,
0.007350205,
-0.0294884276,
-0.0310960412,
-0.0212438051,
-0.0095690964,
0.0261637829,
-0.0067188935,
-0.0477169938,
0.0934825167,
0.0101208054,
-0.0325094052,
0.0302444343,
0.0105303433,
-0.0348006114,
-0.0498226285,
-0.0110031879,
0.0694586709,
-0.049156066,
0.0386529379,
0.0040901615,
0.0124805393,
-0.0025581659,
0.0212493185,
0.0116624581,
0.0239369422,
-0.006134457,
0.0719167963,
-0.0163365323,
0.0437435359,
-0.0387248546,
0.0212290734,
-0.0611141808,
-0.0291032754,
-0.0401573405,
-0.0235067122,
-0.0598754399,
0.07254076,
-0.0097453017,
-0.0338733979,
-0.0042085084,
0.0467963442,
0.0122946491,
0.022790391,
0.0410803519,
0.0330046564,
0.0384210534,
-0.0373231173,
-0.0320393741,
0.0532989092,
-0.0605960265,
0.0042212424,
0.0200393721,
-0.0203893986,
-0.0294538289,
0.0115125636,
0.0303085502,
-0.0245852862,
0.0147781093,
0.0456256457,
0.0168711673,
0.007497374,
-0.0218403134,
-0.0680543333,
-0.0175945777,
-0.0606781319,
0.0241325367,
-0.0800944567,
0.0358821899,
0.0475332811,
-0.013214672,
0.0073876958,
0.0205279309,
0.0053123059,
-0.0375708304,
0.0525517613,
-0.0077413782,
0.0164530352,
0.0014640206,
-0.003446654,
-0.043867711,
0.0531834699,
0.0251358841,
0.0177582726,
0.0417202748,
0.0191465113,
-0.0215034634,
0.0238878261,
0.0510058776,
0.0032209838,
0.0280980803,
0.038465526,
-0.028325012,
0.0182168279,
-0.0172092952,
0.0713198036,
-0.0245093629,
0.0015516744,
0.0227840152,
0.0458692424,
-0.0108573949,
-0.0208749231,
0.0748073906,
0.0234447233,
-0.0099671353,
0.0330997892,
-0.0321366861,
0.0290520322,
-0.0379967168,
0.0244798213,
0.0134230247,
0.0104909865,
-0.0052004065,
-0.0099630617,
-0.0032341054,
0.0422230251,
0.0185996871,
0.0673347116,
0.0307983272,
0.0195515975,
-0.0363638364,
0.0418107025,
0.0179549716,
-0.0006654679,
-0.0131756673,
-0.0494627431,
0.043375317,
0.0639603958,
0.0454472974,
0.0206860192,
-0.0338720642,
0.0010800366,
0.0289021842,
-0.0233372636,
0.0208722781,
-0.0453551188,
-0.0276957881,
-0.0417991206,
-0.0197681114,
-0.0166140068,
-0.0276763234,
0.0145904375,
0.0370534509,
-0.0173027813,
0.0017802978,
-0.0584048703,
0.039620053,
-0.0164163578,
-0.009813536,
0.0096682245,
-0.0145432027,
0.0204851627,
-0.0072977506,
0.0243882351,
0.0176693108,
0.0453300588,
0.012979825,
-0.0157600306,
-0.0397221893,
-0.0043488275,
-0.0334579945,
-0.1010474563,
0.0282780807,
0.0254943874,
-0.0369015969,
-0.0324327387,
-0.0306909978,
-0.0489821397,
-0.0036270174,
-0.0253037605,
0.0513773747,
-0.0294199623,
-0.0125054214,
0.0355122127,
-0.0430589914,
-0.0328230523,
0.0802034885,
-0.004277241,
0.0033028636,
0.0170290638,
0.0255914237,
-0.0014555965,
-0.027908517,
0.0105343601,
0.0349156111,
0.0113389501,
0.0074090529,
0.0001611253,
0.0144583518,
-0.0826025754,
0.0083502578,
-0.0800292864,
0.018421093,
-0.0181524828,
0.0132702766,
-0.0106684826,
0.0204392094,
0.0005052796,
-0.0330189764,
-0.0724362433,
0.0316333286,
0.0143042337,
0.0270632803,
0.0244166907,
-0.012573408,
0.0039324816,
0.023891069,
-0.0172621217,
-0.03045954,
0.0832644925,
0.0065926011,
-0.0026281828,
-0.0248132925,
0.0317713767,
-0.059037149,
0.0069530737,
0.003184669,
0.0301911719,
0.0161001179,
-0.0584766977,
0.0524028391,
0.040596664,
-0.0470053591,
-0.0012691553,
0.0352530368,
-0.032201834,
-0.045082707,
0.0234326161,
-0.0356903188,
-0.0150896562,
-0.0016975545,
-0.0067621111,
-0.0313712209,
0.0227486677,
0.0283768941,
-0.0350121632,
-0.0608246662,
0.0201424882,
0.0122319339,
0.0437560119,
-0.0647573397,
-0.0175833497,
0.0068714321,
0.0496062115,
-0.0254092142,
-0.0080884639,
0.0990876108,
-0.0093316082,
-0.0152483545,
-0.028487891,
0.0160801858,
-0.0514569916,
0.0896826759,
0.0161711574,
0.0176906474,
-0.0042246305,
-0.0152768688,
-0.063971363,
0.0021402261,
0.0170446709,
-0.0432238244,
0.0231327191,
-0.0398188829,
0.0206362493,
0.0162636656,
-0.0287147481,
-0.0328588448,
0.0157782268,
-0.0435990654,
0.0151872113,
-0.0114424722,
-0.005469501,
0.0307743382,
-0.0116026644,
0.0364229158,
0.0004682931,
-0.0458624773,
-0.002100172,
-0.0165883098,
0.0832164064,
0.0649971068,
0.0053202501,
0.0070124464,
-0.0416331775,
0.0714699104,
0.0557343662,
0.0233587269,
0.0054389923,
-0.0051979544,
0.0247027371,
0.009024323,
0.0000782825,
-0.0113664884,
-0.0022089456,
0.0688024163,
-0.0640625581,
-0.0095040463,
0.0960273594,
0.0339437649,
-0.0336249657,
-0.0189005733,
-0.0272195786,
0.0608493797,
0.0222374145,
0.0413567126,
-0.0982973874,
-0.0325697809,
0.0002308554,
0.0090443809,
-0.0012089402,
-0.055862207,
-0.0079613496,
-0.1287026256,
0.0344789438,
-0.0142079554,
-0.0015058126,
-0.0123898005,
-0.0257404912,
-0.0101383049,
0.0527336188,
-0.032041464,
0.0174372829,
0.0001606839,
0.0073167519,
0.0207607523,
0.0019918114,
-0.0046104556,
0.0527376607,
0.0018935526,
-0.0211232714,
0.0047719236,
0.0123142889,
0.0465823784,
-0.0104279472,
0.0049894946,
-0.0292465277,
-0.0091948435,
-0.0221524686,
0.0170936342,
0.00202456,
-0.0087114424,
-0.0521789268,
0.039871186,
-0.0128545174,
-0.0247014407,
0.0171581432,
0.1075271145,
-0.0352302603,
-0.0298098326,
-0.0079703042,
0.0303814504,
-0.0216094255,
0.0519443639,
0.0499592163,
-0.001399352,
-0.0267067533,
-0.0415868275,
-0.0162700936,
-0.0426116697,
-0.0175046995,
0.0499198474,
0.0133589599,
0.070237346,
-0.062579833,
-0.0292285234,
0.0779392347,
0.0535717122,
-0.0139772836,
0.0099485014,
0.0317646004,
0.0103371516,
-0.0358860046,
0.0129893804,
-0.0485977791,
0.0151013583,
-0.0049142018,
0.0077844057,
0.0356712751,
-0.0146940788,
-0.0321543477,
0.0143929347,
-0.0902787074,
-0.0577864908,
-0.058464136,
0.0218373965,
0.0203459729,
0.0526708551,
-0.008283468,
-0.0030571111,
0.0288393945,
-0.0191659741,
0.003010595,
-0.0272112042,
-0.0203979928,
0.0248643607,
-0.0246200748,
0.0317844339,
-0.0578172915,
0.0006538595,
-0.0058777872,
0.0656529143,
-0.0419560261,
-0.0442351066,
0.0412211269,
0.0633081123,
-0.0085261781,
0.023166908,
0.0344429016,
-0.0295936055,
0.0108780181,
-0.0352634713,
-0.0532385074,
-0.0375304781,
0.0148869921,
0.0218473319,
-0.060759075,
0.0053846305,
-0.0637764856,
0.0050717993,
0.0242604129,
-0.008975124,
-0.0317084789,
-0.002681108,
-0.0028026619,
0.0681375489,
-0.0351781994,
-0.0149862701,
0.0042452579,
0.0267008152,
0.0333293639,
-0.007760209,
0.0991457328,
0.0489510633,
-0.0440769531,
-0.055796165,
-0.0037641679,
-0.0669637471,
-0.0869787931,
0.0248708818,
0.0243967436,
0.0248583015,
0.0309183449,
0.0108522372,
-0.0125686396,
-0.0350599363,
0.0197210945,
0.0444805957,
0.0389976799,
-0.0533824228,
0.0699223354,
0.0455198623,
-0.0059477198,
0.02012592,
0.0283346791,
0.005887683,
0.0247356705,
0.0215600934,
-0.0340952463,
-0.0428827778,
-0.0497657768,
-0.0416763164,
0.007809225,
0.0062763654,
0.0399063081,
-0.0830399022,
-0.0923922509,
-0.0259900223,
0.0067127892,
-0.0139703061,
-0.0161578394,
0.0461809933,
0.0483048633,
0.0264877435,
-0.0599087998,
-0.0435206629,
0.0494864285,
-0.0319249779,
-0.0256955847,
-0.0027774505,
-6.382114418e-33,
-0.0181891825,
-0.0650074854,
0.0584152006,
0.0028203574,
-0.0544872619,
-0.0034457408,
-0.0486522727,
-0.0052424287,
-0.0394069776,
0.0074034473,
-0.0173767004,
-0.0066772811,
-0.0068885176,
0.0307508353,
-0.0171076022,
-0.0276177917,
0.0138163203,
-0.0124578187,
-0.0173312146,
0.0398809016,
0.0608224533,
0.025722431,
0.0040741791,
0.007923495,
0.0388476513,
-0.034455765,
0.0036140971,
0.0509676263,
-0.0477666259,
0.0321216844,
-0.0143849608,
0.0231213495,
0.0308151003,
-0.0214555115,
0.0190766249,
0.0398831517,
-0.0811088607,
-0.0465510078,
0.0348314457,
-0.0131318755,
-0.073116824,
-0.0248411018,
-0.0105862189,
-0.0030886708,
0.0490970127,
-0.0476016067,
0.0106709506,
0.0063267853,
-0.0475498028,
-0.0129848327,
-0.0182825718,
0.0082031097,
-0.0223278981,
-0.037951149,
-0.0146632902,
0.0769230127,
-0.0020920602,
0.0140314298,
-0.0010465654,
0.0280092563,
-0.0095308013,
-0.0349774472,
0.0163364708,
0.0078184167,
0.0018615957,
0.0273676384,
-0.0130540729,
-0.0136651825,
-0.0480624661,
0.01963556,
-0.0270511284,
0.0445345119,
0.0045246538,
0.0107507287,
-0.0194520503,
0.0349587798,
-0.0914413035,
-0.0025530744,
-0.0073454655,
0.0389247909,
0.0059717232,
-0.0250656549,
-0.0135066928,
-0.0580394231,
-0.0374677293,
0.0077419984,
-0.0338702016,
-0.0245472398,
0.0379225053,
-0.0282049533,
-0.0251384005,
-0.0022701642,
0.0199894626,
-0.038294293,
-0.0125889685,
0.0647355691,
-0.0173839908,
0.0300491881,
-0.0267251953,
0.0880591944,
-0.008156348,
0.0118507212,
0.0070523028,
-0.0272974446,
-0.0065870173,
0.0428266823,
0.0287658945,
-0.0096176704,
-0.0344632082,
-0.0091752307,
-0.0759233907,
0.0135185504,
-0.0602639951,
-0.0102893924,
0.0370688885,
0.0552317314,
-0.0021912148,
0.0527356751,
0.0086422367,
0.0027345913,
-0.0191556066,
0.0340860672,
-0.0090864887,
0.0198431965,
-0.0413622707,
0.0043583466,
-0.039739456,
0.0073098694,
0.0010607219,
-0.046398595,
-0.0094328234,
0.0342548527,
2.81e-7,
0.0362186283,
0.0352914669,
0.0239043832,
0.0750862435,
0.0069741942,
0.0120177874,
-0.0106175868,
-0.0275542401,
0.0537335761,
-0.0463634916,
0.0115872305,
0.0588274077,
0.0178493708,
0.0389753357,
-0.0847365558,
0.0137320459,
-0.0237486679,
-0.0570772029,
-0.0579991676,
0.0046383268,
0.081053704,
0.0367238112,
0.0117660249,
-0.0096955914,
-0.0159214661,
-0.0382638015,
0.0465253703,
0.0189380348,
-0.0239729099,
-0.0094556222,
0.0124398386,
-0.0060060625,
0.0064620492,
0.0506080873,
0.0112319831,
0.0071960078,
-0.0013421534,
0.0401074961,
0.0281981435,
-0.0170487966,
-0.0114200218,
-0.0425619856,
0.0178115163,
-0.0617278814,
0.099444896,
-0.0420318916,
-0.0279822741,
-0.0162520539,
0.0084257452,
-0.05376295,
-0.0150857726,
-0.022583751,
-0.0089867134,
0.0110008605,
0.0121180899,
-0.0090480139,
0.0470441766,
-0.0481495932,
0.0051949942,
0.0097672036,
-0.0203036238,
-0.0644681826,
0.0136841172,
-0.0101000294,
0.0185665768,
-0.0449699089,
-0.003508006,
2.707024589e-34,
0.0454796292,
-0.0116326371,
0.0332233645,
0.0186738539,
0.0473436229,
-0.0305945668,
-0.0260117892,
0.0028923252,
0.0359171629,
-0.1248626336,
-0.031626299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09761v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09761v2 | MAFALDA: A Benchmark and Comprehensive Study of Fallacy Detection and Classification | 2023-11-16T10:35:11 | 2024-04-09T20:49:26 | Chadi Helwe, Tom Calamai, Pierre-Henri Paris, Chloé Clavel, Fabian Suchanek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce MAFALDA, a benchmark for fallacy classification that merges and
unites previous fallacy datasets. It comes with a taxonomy that aligns,
refines, and unifies existing classifications of fallacies. We further provide
a manual annotation of a part of the dataset together with manual explanations
for each annotation. We propose a new annotation scheme tailored for subjective
NLP tasks, and a new evaluation method designed to handle subjectivity. We then
evaluate several language models under a zero-shot learning setting and human
performances on MAFALDA to assess their capability to detect and classify
fallacies. | [
0.0247877222,
0.0386108086,
0.0041145817,
0.0546739027,
-0.0372400321,
0.0589105561,
0.027708983,
0.0122878198,
0.0189330634,
-0.0845624283,
0.0185941942,
-0.0019765033,
0.0172643587,
-0.0022830328,
0.0196774639,
-0.0567716174,
0.0652987882,
0.019710131,
0.0227879193,
-0.0140164876,
0.0328484997,
0.0118761882,
-0.0497696251,
0.0160995256,
-0.0341609605,
-0.0422881283,
0.0432719998,
-0.015559257,
0.026708357,
-0.0213602912,
0.0474325567,
0.0686234608,
-0.0006898536,
0.0451445952,
0.0000019263,
-0.0264706295,
0.0389555171,
0.0054916977,
-0.0274020676,
0.0070812274,
0.0788282678,
0.0045274454,
-0.0046355943,
0.0380101018,
0.0037661949,
-0.0390643887,
0.0453536548,
0.0851370394,
0.0671485662,
0.0805581138,
0.0166529175,
-0.0386500247,
-0.003843155,
-0.0154842995,
-0.0358269066,
-0.0207813904,
0.0263065435,
0.0371139273,
-0.0585419834,
0.0093608974,
0.0054455637,
-0.0294555016,
0.0225278195,
-0.0212836731,
0.0173163358,
0.0119025568,
-0.0201756489,
-0.0121511156,
-0.003232125,
0.0257211179,
0.0317624584,
-0.0905236825,
-0.0124960728,
-0.0098057631,
0.0076805791,
0.0042242385,
0.0002508262,
0.0212260243,
-0.0369062684,
0.0021348705,
0.0228987075,
-0.0253812131,
0.038992539,
0.0514026284,
0.0827090889,
0.0219428781,
-0.0062238155,
-0.0395553969,
0.0165794194,
0.0298140496,
0.0171546079,
-0.051218573,
-0.0113796564,
0.002206031,
0.0129920542,
0.0195432417,
-0.0277538151,
-0.0131999347,
0.0683322102,
-0.0734186396,
0.0195404906,
-0.0180597305,
-0.0339824632,
0.0519203283,
-0.0089600766,
0.0293541513,
0.0118650468,
-0.0099787684,
-0.0143648097,
-0.0061037224,
-0.0416005701,
-0.0062694014,
0.0184204895,
0.0242651198,
-0.0182673652,
0.0208226815,
-0.0559332296,
-0.0597447865,
-0.0690737069,
-0.0138883907,
-0.0202844813,
0.0439185053,
-0.012350278,
-0.0204707179,
-0.083131507,
0.0722827837,
-0.0095639918,
0.0528673492,
-0.0140435221,
-0.0414446034,
-0.0036630519,
0.0295073539,
-0.0337939821,
0.0222083274,
-0.0064070751,
0.0018614347,
0.0256933756,
-0.0069149197,
-0.0710555911,
-0.0131459963,
-0.0445133969,
-0.0490448251,
0.0005589902,
-0.0884571895,
0.0113256183,
-0.0519588925,
-0.0074999491,
-0.0550374463,
-0.0009066788,
0.0581461787,
-0.0149364425,
0.0285052788,
-0.0389867648,
-0.0266802274,
0.0872200131,
0.0057554203,
-0.0255528744,
0.0828709006,
-0.0491611511,
0.0129869059,
0.024408441,
0.0112483064,
0.02910541,
-0.0442080386,
0.0117589729,
0.0015263773,
0.0115076201,
0.0275426637,
-0.0469419993,
0.023733601,
0.0403665937,
0.0235845968,
-0.0453456379,
-0.0572779663,
0.04415958,
0.0273425765,
0.0118016228,
-0.0077734836,
0.0387918726,
-0.0083411317,
0.0157122891,
-0.0295126177,
-0.0478401482,
0.0016783236,
-0.0476900041,
-0.0542529412,
-0.0058089839,
0.0029815764,
0.0134725189,
-0.0825975984,
-0.0355654694,
-0.0097947586,
-0.0096414862,
-0.0023392343,
0.0238441713,
0.0420412831,
-0.0113355834,
0.0477024019,
0.071994938,
-0.0289393365,
-0.0318360925,
0.0073968424,
0.0454676785,
0.0296382047,
0.007639091,
0.0012765173,
-0.0269842818,
-0.030483963,
0.0422827117,
0.040965233,
0.1013038531,
-0.0413123928,
-0.0353675261,
-0.0175223332,
-0.0192775466,
-0.0088468054,
0.0668989867,
0.0017301348,
0.0323525704,
-0.0201204997,
0.0172536988,
0.0134947542,
-0.0383727811,
0.0359413959,
0.016834056,
0.0095489817,
-0.010776151,
0.0050069662,
0.0139774019,
-0.011303911,
-0.0029435393,
-0.0053753681,
0.0138244582,
0.0094126584,
-0.0538436435,
-0.0373978503,
0.0158110056,
-0.0317565799,
0.0208619628,
-0.0259518381,
-0.0187855065,
0.0020882366,
-0.0468447469,
0.0312671736,
0.0134895695,
-0.0343093872,
-0.0045321072,
-0.0378353819,
-0.0156565253,
-0.0149554526,
-0.0029637022,
-0.0219423268,
0.1124765202,
-0.0356199443,
0.0304639935,
-0.0601127148,
-0.0035282699,
0.0091896094,
-0.0339075848,
-0.0068263453,
0.0050808978,
0.0056887232,
0.0177126974,
0.0191016551,
-0.0195122343,
-0.0333547555,
0.0111149661,
-0.0924228057,
0.0153117571,
-0.0252656713,
0.0198435001,
0.0352315605,
-0.0804871544,
0.01090426,
-0.0162565224,
-0.0193912368,
-0.0186517145,
-0.0101733897,
0.0155962314,
0.0582845211,
-0.0261168461,
0.0375633575,
-0.0058828979,
0.0204522908,
-0.0238031074,
0.0060963393,
0.0207440406,
0.025136549,
-0.0313255526,
0.0067176577,
-0.0413706116,
-0.0056820759,
0.0051476569,
-0.020691596,
0.0135025075,
0.0427463986,
-0.0199482013,
0.0715608299,
0.0116743604,
0.0857725739,
0.0441999771,
0.0275770705,
0.0032453686,
-0.0271161832,
-0.0062135379,
0.0426675156,
-0.0098890886,
-0.0426137522,
-0.002368683,
0.067012623,
0.0172922947,
0.0182295367,
-0.0519460253,
0.0392739847,
-0.0641940385,
-0.0262830369,
0.0398952588,
-0.0113876518,
-0.0296295062,
0.0158857256,
-0.0491308868,
-0.021761898,
0.0641825944,
-0.007955092,
0.0382119641,
-0.0332900509,
-0.0118111167,
-0.0146026695,
-0.021456169,
-0.0183019675,
0.0113041252,
0.0313020945,
0.000175916,
-0.006832344,
-0.0215929765,
0.0465031862,
-0.0166998748,
0.0007543527,
-0.0872890875,
-0.004909812,
0.0096790306,
-0.064224571,
-0.0293868743,
-0.0440829247,
-0.0294442736,
-0.0505469926,
-0.059856344,
0.0074805538,
-0.0431748219,
-0.0663978904,
-0.0248008464,
0.0181322861,
0.0078867935,
0.0086441766,
0.0422272198,
0.0270416792,
0.036793042,
0.0352259502,
0.0565265901,
0.0218036007,
-0.0097024832,
0.1013189331,
-0.0297688935,
0.0539361052,
-0.0391833596,
-0.0172294099,
-0.0213577151,
-0.0237169284,
-0.0246446654,
0.0049297302,
0.006314104,
-0.0566585176,
-0.0054588453,
0.0823161528,
0.0275820941,
0.0106296781,
0.001268925,
0.018066315,
-0.0207745172,
0.0265749469,
-0.0605269335,
-0.084053874,
-0.0378297679,
-0.0197320282,
0.0197494365,
-0.0436744988,
0.0027387459,
0.0265236702,
-0.1342063844,
0.0472319014,
-0.0029230721,
-0.0027162584,
-0.0101345247,
-0.050828401,
0.0146182692,
-0.0042913556,
0.0207529292,
-0.002841491,
0.0235305522,
-0.0020130067,
0.0346129835,
-0.0569063462,
-0.0755623132,
0.032507658,
0.0338763334,
0.0690974146,
0.0209507942,
0.0673488155,
0.0039530625,
0.0024578294,
0.0324850529,
-0.0557067282,
-0.0507900231,
-0.0182525832,
0.08117643,
-0.000291144,
-0.0129257534,
-0.0312679261,
0.0400544368,
0.0078861574,
-0.027598707,
-0.0176740885,
0.0562350452,
0.0232654288,
-0.0235876571,
-0.0183981005,
0.0145753128,
-0.0107658701,
0.0554024428,
0.013649717,
0.0179980993,
-0.036096964,
-0.0433053076,
-0.0381015465,
-0.0445059948,
-0.0371440612,
0.0483259,
0.0543204173,
-0.0315436199,
-0.0868089199,
-0.0901855826,
0.011758456,
-0.0287430491,
-0.0138169629,
-0.0368608274,
-0.0054775872,
0.004409364,
-0.0152699882,
0.0248808917,
-0.003982171,
-0.0021131143,
-0.0323757268,
-0.0184196979,
0.0011664196,
0.0156289954,
-0.030868683,
0.0200038832,
-0.0753104314,
-0.0355901308,
0.0082759382,
0.0427090563,
0.0059766872,
0.0479520969,
-0.0136069916,
-0.03214534,
0.0263549779,
-0.0016759787,
-0.0265071597,
0.0291286316,
0.0263319537,
-0.0155366426,
0.0186486971,
0.0241871066,
0.0069599021,
0.0407242738,
0.0129156951,
-0.0129962722,
-0.0504374616,
0.0515294932,
0.0459644608,
-0.0070616263,
0.0548875369,
0.0045129051,
-0.0052594165,
-0.0289802514,
0.000627313,
-0.0414771624,
-0.0727184713,
0.0188208707,
0.0418306701,
0.0201563835,
-0.011605503,
-0.0215051975,
-0.0205194522,
-0.0442827716,
-0.0039554848,
-0.0056945574,
0.0127364052,
0.0757907256,
0.040115349,
-0.0090829898,
0.0119647896,
-0.0574775003,
-0.0252233446,
-0.0060246959,
0.0338946991,
0.0244320519,
0.0306827202,
0.022261072,
-0.0074054538,
0.0348596834,
-0.0528780334,
0.0010293274,
0.0207469594,
-0.0100401687,
0.0420975983,
0.0212460253,
-0.0296907183,
0.0463091657,
-0.0068438724,
-0.0510864742,
-0.0198244974,
-0.0087635573,
-0.0107412087,
-0.0418834463,
0.0398005284,
0.0282164812,
-0.0304862764,
-0.0157595836,
0.0263772737,
-0.0015178005,
0.0559447892,
0.0267754979,
-0.0096543962,
-0.0410256237,
-0.044639688,
-0.0077426778,
0.0063284202,
0.0120165842,
0.0228689741,
-0.1012471542,
-0.0398420505,
0.04686727,
0.0403275043,
0.0254673287,
0.0135951405,
0.0064876839,
0.0726918355,
0.0016893882,
0.0396967195,
-0.0357416235,
-0.0178521164,
-0.0377170518,
0.0112810135,
-0.0599095598,
-6.129398561e-33,
-0.019589169,
-0.0723722577,
-0.0055357027,
-0.005128636,
0.0446987674,
0.0196149964,
0.0045192894,
0.001798319,
-0.0181297977,
0.1076773182,
0.0663370788,
0.0402133465,
-0.0039442377,
0.0130681042,
-0.0309402645,
-0.0410361476,
0.0279131569,
-0.0065078572,
-0.0467881784,
-0.0090638055,
0.0328865573,
-0.0193137433,
0.0487086512,
-0.0540969819,
0.0382711701,
0.0180294253,
-0.0229419004,
0.0265182331,
-0.0244715326,
0.0699302033,
-0.0089738751,
0.0926996768,
0.0258016251,
0.0077468096,
0.0313819088,
0.0103809321,
-0.0487634204,
-0.0331677906,
0.0329117738,
0.019515574,
0.0082139736,
-0.0229759514,
0.0250637494,
0.0064837965,
-0.0453351438,
-0.0442908108,
0.0359078534,
-0.0460133441,
0.013226077,
-0.0062568602,
-0.0778033584,
0.0167185497,
-0.0100391489,
-0.0166724175,
-0.0346722193,
0.0399693064,
-0.0027715359,
0.0208856054,
-0.0458804294,
0.0190755017,
-0.0065415651,
-0.0139377844,
0.0043145181,
-0.0651940107,
-0.0297478735,
0.0815819278,
0.0227755215,
0.0108597819,
-0.0240420494,
0.0401950106,
-0.0206648055,
-0.0127363531,
0.0981443077,
0.0835605487,
0.036366608,
-0.0065727411,
-0.0755100623,
-0.0384695306,
0.0197595749,
0.0381343253,
-0.0260301735,
-0.0448686145,
-0.072269395,
0.0008479517,
-0.0487777889,
-0.0447103046,
-0.0204419103,
-0.0136194825,
0.0501257405,
0.0104677202,
-0.0086624119,
0.0278788935,
-0.0294973683,
-0.0260285269,
0.0123473359,
0.0205696113,
-0.0039714044,
-0.0220812745,
0.0261376239,
0.0075236778,
-0.0394029506,
0.0213838257,
0.0173540786,
0.0150782717,
0.0245373491,
-0.0314426348,
0.0877505764,
-0.0149037335,
-0.0559631959,
0.0117310965,
-0.0271821655,
0.0055300836,
-0.0084761865,
0.0502767488,
0.0433511734,
0.0174877085,
-0.0177223235,
0.0112535572,
-0.004768875,
-0.0018496548,
-0.0479333252,
0.0211080238,
-0.0314241014,
0.0216530245,
-0.0176362451,
-0.0080614053,
-0.0148769347,
-0.0044961716,
-0.0074204062,
-0.0830149725,
0.0088981753,
-0.0093994131,
2.489e-7,
0.0548557602,
0.076463297,
-0.014654411,
-0.006303547,
0.0168297794,
0.0442019962,
-0.0204144064,
0.0190799367,
-0.0166370291,
-0.0262744129,
-0.0375416018,
0.0347914062,
0.0433835499,
0.0122249443,
-0.0446847752,
0.0182420313,
-0.0515627488,
-0.0053884289,
-0.024123041,
-0.0271397121,
0.0657549277,
0.0747122094,
0.0387089141,
-0.0279508214,
0.0016049187,
-0.0002912981,
0.0628026351,
0.033753939,
-0.0136491032,
-0.0159298312,
0.0352722034,
-0.0200578179,
0.0145111689,
0.0283900388,
-0.0300215036,
-0.0289030187,
-0.0047607934,
0.0445212461,
-0.0205376837,
-0.0465071313,
-0.0692033246,
0.007564107,
0.0010662925,
-0.0223270468,
0.0657359958,
-0.0315361805,
-0.0222506039,
-0.0578605272,
-0.0603174344,
0.032727126,
0.0512627847,
0.0174855702,
-0.0232969541,
-0.0109717725,
0.0178008638,
0.0041851914,
0.0025130785,
-0.0409143344,
-0.0245717019,
0.0432964712,
-0.0235829838,
-0.0066989162,
-0.0022778611,
-0.0093254987,
0.0139335291,
-0.0199389514,
0.0094071189,
1.964740543e-34,
0.0191828404,
-0.0105870171,
0.0141375121,
-0.0125672482,
0.0315456018,
0.0327461474,
-0.026857255,
-0.0195005611,
0.0108548841,
0.0447679013,
0.0341777392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09758v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09758v2 | OrchestraLLM: Efficient Orchestration of Language Models for Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-11-16T10:30:55 | 2024-02-28T20:41:25 | Chia-Hsuan Lee, Hao Cheng, Mari Ostendorf | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized the landscape of Natural
Language Processing systems, but are computationally expensive. To reduce the
cost without sacrificing performance, previous studies have explored various
approaches to harness the potential of Small Language Models (SLMs) as
cost-effective alternatives to their larger counterparts. Driven by findings
that SLMs and LLMs exhibit complementary strengths in a structured knowledge
extraction task, this work presents a novel SLM/LLM routing framework designed
to improve computational efficiency and enhance task performance. First,
exemplar pools are created to represent the types of contexts where each LM
provides a more reliable answer, leveraging a sentence embedding fine-tuned so
that context similarity is close to dialogue state similarity. Then, during
inference, the k-nearest exemplars to the testing instance are retrieved, and
the instance is routed according to majority vote. In dialogue state tracking
tasks, the proposed routing framework enhances performance substantially
compared to relying solely on LLMs, while reducing the computational costs by
over 50%. | [
0.0691361502,
0.0414989367,
-0.0219961088,
0.0763421431,
-0.0720864236,
-0.0008668168,
0.0113090537,
-0.0027622338,
0.0343548246,
-0.0862827078,
-0.0327852406,
-0.0319720358,
-0.0304782018,
0.0396927819,
0.0031385678,
-0.0389513373,
0.0371652767,
-0.0530795678,
0.0185662415,
0.0124346158,
0.0071932119,
0.0053945086,
-0.018109398,
0.0494820885,
0.0191721637,
-0.0055870274,
-0.0261160061,
0.001741919,
-0.0124847414,
-0.0093567846,
0.0091466233,
0.0133477775,
0.0081946328,
0.0132414447,
0.0000020529,
-0.0449616723,
-0.0001649579,
-0.0209066365,
-0.0433064774,
-0.0149277085,
0.003627362,
0.018681556,
-0.0001084742,
0.0310284831,
-0.0138951028,
0.0037235375,
0.0433924235,
0.0356269218,
0.0285862312,
0.0821479112,
-0.0107437801,
0.0085920319,
-0.0053891367,
-0.0061978758,
-0.0295171365,
-0.0533943772,
0.0331995822,
0.0053266529,
-0.0002746342,
0.0263315998,
0.0048671211,
0.0418255441,
-0.0110820532,
-0.0228451043,
-0.0261114053,
0.0090363575,
-0.0498352721,
0.0335753262,
-0.0377626717,
0.070166558,
0.0270340908,
0.0037891548,
-0.0025274695,
-0.0087271379,
-0.0336836576,
0.0117590828,
-0.0402427986,
-0.011632218,
-0.0161443688,
0.0077022752,
0.0138234794,
0.0160703603,
-0.0016248117,
0.016194284,
-0.0279715862,
0.0564473346,
0.0087791048,
-0.0209041331,
-0.0399383157,
0.0066603739,
0.0056712874,
-0.0765159354,
0.0405164622,
0.0300162174,
-0.0212642066,
0.0523937829,
-0.0464109294,
0.0044021825,
0.0026789096,
-0.0518865921,
0.0056359791,
0.0291320849,
0.0031349403,
0.1081248447,
-0.0162512995,
0.0398698077,
-0.0337817594,
-0.0055128424,
-0.0380878635,
-0.0244250242,
-0.0575174764,
-0.0009541528,
-0.0442436077,
0.0380790569,
-0.0707049593,
-0.077752158,
0.0070965327,
0.0505853444,
0.0236462727,
0.0091912197,
0.0109653482,
0.0074014617,
0.0287098717,
-0.0169167928,
-0.0233253334,
0.0310389325,
-0.0334525704,
0.0163726229,
-0.0101150954,
-0.0355199873,
-0.029786082,
0.0339818075,
0.0244508069,
-0.0018794417,
-0.020525625,
0.0560822524,
0.0212260801,
-0.0534035154,
-0.0035662916,
-0.0159932468,
-0.019931959,
-0.0422326662,
-0.0574307851,
-0.0606287755,
0.0664970353,
0.0182705559,
0.0004325802,
-0.0146731539,
0.0269343313,
0.0168713331,
-0.0285517536,
0.0148814153,
0.01204585,
0.0369293652,
-0.0171874128,
0.003993249,
0.0268617775,
0.0752925277,
0.0346496962,
-0.0137706529,
0.0567360967,
-0.007437875,
-0.0044969595,
0.0353064388,
-0.0146431336,
0.0071050283,
-0.023514932,
0.0393966995,
-0.0189537592,
-0.0063972673,
-0.0009563363,
0.0421383083,
-0.0260621831,
-0.0096550807,
0.0546998307,
0.0799685717,
0.0215495992,
-0.0242301133,
0.0036340323,
0.02191527,
-0.0036655173,
-0.0226328839,
-0.0150286071,
0.0057172435,
-0.0188713204,
-0.0097162463,
0.0578709058,
0.0100289164,
-0.0191099271,
-0.0115151675,
-0.0460421033,
-0.0032760876,
-0.021398643,
0.0417041294,
0.0364969708,
-0.0139668249,
-0.0264618024,
0.0960950479,
0.015419377,
-0.0165392365,
-0.05822419,
-0.0334688462,
0.0191118643,
0.0615829751,
0.049422171,
-0.0335665978,
-0.0500344187,
-0.0093739126,
0.006875901,
0.0499538481,
0.0291317329,
-0.0309561044,
0.0435540527,
-0.0515450463,
-0.0020379096,
0.0131363971,
0.0035738305,
-0.0074058333,
0.0612261742,
-0.0127381086,
0.0099314442,
-0.0397652574,
0.0149206249,
0.032971032,
-0.0084317774,
-0.0314862989,
0.0173877627,
0.0067185001,
0.0531240031,
0.018820731,
0.0070102247,
0.001209824,
0.0353543758,
-0.0318422467,
0.0037052277,
0.006788319,
-0.0699739158,
-0.0682737604,
0.0246829949,
0.0651865378,
0.0139802974,
-0.017072415,
-0.0440380313,
-0.0491308533,
-0.0155223506,
-0.0289132558,
0.0516443215,
-0.0338496715,
0.0272290055,
0.0242520608,
-0.0201339182,
-0.053682901,
0.0504738726,
-0.0023832908,
0.0209947508,
0.0128704393,
0.0176169258,
0.0022043786,
-0.0287647042,
-0.0154712331,
-0.0057080886,
0.0027076292,
0.0033264633,
0.0116123827,
-0.0262146816,
-0.0572808534,
-0.0066920645,
-0.1042734012,
0.0319696069,
-0.0178337488,
0.0260289833,
0.0234451145,
0.0183273759,
-0.0095211845,
-0.0117678503,
-0.0407883041,
-0.0144162104,
0.0336830243,
0.0101773962,
-0.0009739781,
0.0227191262,
-0.0590163916,
-0.0618717559,
0.0140166581,
-0.0021632144,
0.0530332997,
-0.0300140344,
-0.036147546,
-0.0913728401,
0.037156269,
-0.0303404033,
0.0294162259,
-0.0199390147,
-0.0073274109,
-0.0356411375,
-0.0116833029,
0.0159700047,
0.0388387814,
-0.0061677583,
0.0101707596,
0.0213660114,
-0.0393087566,
-0.0652110428,
0.0163904596,
-0.0290457457,
0.0150575498,
-0.0622145832,
0.0260376893,
0.0335425995,
0.0327771977,
0.0255310703,
0.0224794373,
-0.0273578055,
-0.0124411331,
0.0400241502,
0.0039704372,
-0.0079354113,
-0.0338801257,
-0.029805176,
0.0450554229,
-0.0168202277,
-0.0131354975,
0.056113068,
-0.0390163176,
0.008759262,
-0.0470115133,
-0.0442592911,
-0.0508393608,
0.0534352809,
-0.0025533934,
0.0324660614,
-0.0191728603,
-0.0217746291,
-0.0039225612,
-0.0030627046,
-0.0009545361,
-0.0395527855,
0.0809520781,
-0.0303105563,
0.0341841131,
0.0015254715,
-0.0447170287,
-0.0637545064,
-0.0252792798,
-0.0502757207,
0.0100132469,
0.025964627,
-0.0008301278,
-0.0266526118,
0.064894937,
0.0010256984,
0.0463792831,
0.0096721034,
0.0252915118,
-0.0151095558,
0.074538894,
0.0414498225,
0.0142245516,
0.0218153652,
-0.0024518983,
0.1032547206,
0.0821617544,
0.0596438795,
-0.0076331184,
-0.0022422289,
-0.0385428481,
0.0343911052,
-0.0386199094,
-0.0038183504,
0.0089431191,
0.071300067,
-0.0751441792,
-0.036139559,
0.1199557558,
0.0345407575,
-0.0251375735,
-0.023195738,
-0.0110747265,
0.0385142043,
0.0303795021,
0.0273211002,
-0.0738374963,
-0.03636856,
0.0172222201,
0.0070412243,
-0.0123618236,
-0.0359621532,
-0.0017098602,
-0.116248697,
0.0149735035,
0.0044748792,
-0.062026456,
-0.0169363711,
-0.0523910075,
0.040255338,
0.0178710446,
-0.0054630814,
0.0278858971,
0.004852538,
-0.0399539359,
0.0072250604,
-0.0236509033,
-0.0255601779,
0.0364054255,
-0.0273318999,
0.0626251847,
0.0278099068,
0.0056452048,
0.0378739238,
0.0060193273,
0.0575162433,
-0.0419511832,
-0.0002492289,
-0.0035467539,
0.0255062077,
-0.0480686873,
0.0016657548,
-0.0090995319,
0.0012216874,
-0.0433565937,
-0.0000652382,
0.022709569,
0.0711728781,
-0.023957409,
0.0405254066,
-0.010291229,
0.0111807371,
0.0018072416,
0.0893159881,
0.0213840008,
-0.0223141238,
-0.0037783408,
0.0014242337,
-0.0269185938,
-0.0060717487,
-0.0245170314,
-0.0076497411,
0.0041107815,
0.041179724,
-0.0669191107,
-0.0111035183,
0.0720011219,
0.0567987412,
0.0004593583,
0.0559615158,
0.0188838169,
-0.0031796161,
-0.0280928332,
0.0188838392,
-0.0683536083,
0.0054438706,
-0.0378156342,
-0.009090472,
0.0492390208,
0.0130084613,
-0.0377829112,
0.0453560129,
-0.1081335768,
-0.0840156302,
-0.0337848254,
0.0428246185,
0.0152229257,
0.0345837474,
-0.0030516633,
0.0047737928,
0.0073600411,
-0.012281755,
-0.033361908,
-0.0019883362,
0.0093344199,
0.0250944775,
-0.018655397,
0.0449644253,
-0.0360956118,
0.0176327731,
0.0002247893,
0.0657392815,
-0.0616230108,
-0.1030773818,
-0.0083330125,
0.0070411679,
0.0417150296,
0.0443463288,
-0.0168839376,
-0.0044082366,
0.0767039806,
-0.0267055947,
-0.0374075696,
-0.050126072,
0.0075523248,
-0.0255080666,
-0.0206700191,
-0.0142419348,
0.0180734787,
0.0091219321,
0.0366715565,
-0.0055404594,
0.0006145518,
0.0238686111,
-0.0468247235,
0.0195285305,
-0.0091401925,
-0.0256339852,
0.0263956562,
0.0182753988,
0.03540181,
-0.027216414,
0.0728013664,
0.0064171143,
-0.0360028856,
-0.0256335065,
0.0180981588,
-0.0657252893,
-0.0583461896,
-0.0040548365,
0.0500466675,
0.0198239647,
-0.0507875495,
0.0360053219,
-0.016251212,
-0.017854942,
-0.0199666768,
0.0256296825,
0.0036741116,
-0.0124307452,
0.0736988038,
0.0571695901,
-0.0198784694,
0.0432524048,
0.0504860617,
0.0164300967,
0.0399466455,
0.0179320648,
-0.0219444372,
-0.0325977355,
-0.0016872227,
0.0054173716,
0.062482439,
-0.0100674387,
0.0092364652,
-0.0399808921,
-0.040242441,
0.0109049687,
-0.0509767011,
-0.018657526,
-0.0320373438,
0.0498116463,
0.0530109294,
0.0504845567,
-0.0025763507,
-0.0487611331,
-0.0238563512,
-0.0199256632,
-0.0160675962,
-0.0032986016,
-6.605894747e-33,
-0.0341706462,
-0.0429154634,
0.0340450071,
-0.0159943588,
-0.0315766744,
0.0002994635,
-0.0492898002,
0.003144898,
-0.029505292,
-0.0222478844,
0.0099855848,
0.0111028245,
0.0125001455,
0.0340372585,
-0.0276781823,
-0.0018671076,
0.0352800265,
0.0033100448,
0.0048725479,
0.0194136333,
0.0437522456,
0.0198296197,
0.0193002671,
-0.0833644643,
-0.0234883148,
0.0120316464,
0.0359076262,
0.0278240126,
0.0050781285,
0.0428763106,
-0.032600265,
0.0351947844,
0.0161837768,
-0.0440998338,
-0.0042687054,
0.020148512,
-0.036763344,
-0.00514773,
0.0536755435,
-0.0057128025,
-0.0068672686,
0.0072496235,
0.0090101426,
-0.0031824026,
0.0464044288,
0.0088920565,
-0.0086220847,
-0.0462093763,
-0.0450176783,
-0.0086560668,
-0.0503911413,
0.0431228913,
0.0093399873,
-0.0305509493,
0.0428008325,
0.0234391298,
0.0101151289,
0.0031217923,
-0.0165157374,
-0.0065571368,
-0.0208899677,
0.0450452492,
0.0180206727,
0.0481240042,
0.0046631005,
0.0776698142,
0.001045683,
-0.0354577228,
-0.0495249145,
-0.0360271893,
-0.0093503417,
0.0604888499,
0.0193900988,
-0.0020320702,
-0.0301823094,
0.0117336297,
-0.0639590994,
-0.0364161544,
0.0256884191,
0.0220790021,
0.0374131538,
0.0326627605,
-0.0628416985,
-0.0181846116,
-0.0152804693,
-0.0193523709,
-0.0197069831,
-0.0162047334,
0.0561081506,
0.0234399419,
-0.0271968842,
-0.0156763624,
0.0513592102,
-0.0299366359,
-0.0166104902,
0.0250987262,
0.0069736671,
0.0061633056,
-0.0216991566,
0.021056002,
-0.082839556,
-0.0019394121,
-0.0032874059,
-0.0229412243,
-0.0154675301,
0.009907675,
0.0143903419,
-0.0370199718,
-0.0939799547,
0.0081947055,
-0.0369037017,
0.0149020487,
-0.0724560469,
0.0509993732,
0.040637821,
0.0268528983,
0.0027086821,
0.0942179412,
0.0240684506,
-0.050152272,
-0.0150415329,
0.0035890255,
-0.0140968999,
0.0081903832,
-0.0229085293,
-0.0080647459,
-0.0169695877,
0.0085783675,
-0.0020035235,
-0.0262832306,
0.0008578454,
0.0101706767,
2.843e-7,
0.0327886343,
0.0406305343,
0.0304306224,
0.0135623822,
0.0161985438,
0.0238171834,
0.0013308476,
-0.0271340292,
0.0369506218,
-0.0333794467,
-0.0037293835,
0.0321990475,
0.0384840518,
0.0157615431,
-0.1132233813,
0.0065752859,
-0.0590882599,
-0.0213326141,
-0.0466282889,
-0.0225417223,
0.0434151962,
0.0988536701,
0.0212123133,
0.0149207739,
-0.0334858485,
-0.0648696423,
0.0404777527,
-0.0182569493,
-0.0162025616,
0.0041154572,
-0.0132624321,
0.0204542633,
-0.0022177075,
0.0329149701,
0.0218955539,
0.0730135366,
-0.0211246349,
0.1027835757,
-0.0014201062,
-0.0424854904,
-0.0331475995,
-0.0001555031,
0.0241204724,
-0.0418883152,
0.0748801753,
-0.017596988,
0.008842661,
-0.0583057366,
0.003770486,
-0.0181302819,
-0.0160822105,
0.0316813402,
-0.0301208738,
0.0207277928,
0.0156651363,
-0.0216179062,
-0.0102768131,
-0.0952801928,
-0.024782585,
-0.0019924967,
-0.0571190193,
-0.0430287756,
-0.0173027217,
0.0069185323,
-0.0053447504,
-0.033360865,
-0.0274023134,
3.066951087e-34,
0.013324284,
0.0223042946,
-0.0029609038,
0.1060991883,
0.0396774933,
-0.0265138093,
-0.0267097019,
-0.016244676,
0.0252655372,
-0.132321924,
0.0021368079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09756v1 | FairytaleCQA: Integrating a Commonsense Knowledge Graph into Children's Storybook Narratives | 2023-11-16T10:30:26 | 2023-11-16T10:30:26 | Jiaju Chen, Yuxuan Lu, Shao Zhang, Bingsheng Yao, Yuanzhe Dong, Ying Xu, Yunyao Li, Qianwen Wang, Dakuo Wang, Yuling Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | AI models (including LLM) often rely on narrative question-answering (QA)
datasets to provide customized QA functionalities to support downstream
children education applications; however, existing datasets only include QA
pairs that are grounded within the given storybook content, but children can
learn more when teachers refer the storybook content to real-world knowledge
(e.g., commonsense knowledge). We introduce the FairytaleCQA dataset, which is
annotated by children education experts, to supplement 278 storybook narratives
with educationally appropriate commonsense knowledge. The dataset has 5,868 QA
pairs that not only originate from the storybook narrative but also contain the
commonsense knowledge grounded by an external knowledge graph (i.e.,
ConceptNet). A follow-up experiment shows that a smaller model (T5-large)
fine-tuned with FairytaleCQA reliably outperforms much larger prompt-engineered
LLM (e.g., GPT-4) in this new QA-pair generation task (QAG). This result
suggests that: 1) our dataset brings novel challenges to existing LLMs, and 2)
human experts' data annotation are still critical as they have much nuanced
knowledge that LLMs do not know in the children educational domain. | [
0.0431552455,
0.0159601811,
-0.0217371564,
0.0530472174,
-0.0270747505,
-0.0109858355,
0.0027824417,
-0.0601795353,
0.0119683566,
-0.0262809545,
0.0157607179,
0.0292700939,
0.0271941982,
0.0466954708,
0.0203598477,
-0.0253865886,
0.0288392305,
0.0112744682,
-0.0106164534,
0.0044690943,
-0.0389303714,
0.0707660317,
-0.018151056,
0.03344208,
-0.0079798317,
-0.0529624186,
-0.0058228197,
0.0005779711,
0.033201918,
-0.0250487663,
0.0211205427,
-0.0045896317,
0.0367483944,
-0.0255143736,
0.0000017645,
-0.0492199436,
0.0149054769,
-0.0117311021,
-0.0346633792,
-0.0015714166,
-0.0164469425,
0.04505435,
0.0410367139,
-0.0061616437,
-0.041667819,
0.08027336,
0.0203190874,
0.0363515764,
0.0551247895,
0.0322572701,
0.0207973327,
-0.007556838,
0.034213528,
0.0225182138,
0.0785714388,
-0.0296026655,
-0.009026113,
0.0525764562,
0.0563617945,
-0.0271370932,
-0.0311755333,
0.0251786318,
0.0275694225,
-0.0271856543,
-0.0056115207,
0.0426280983,
0.0039696093,
0.0484219752,
-0.043123018,
0.1360827088,
0.0706960633,
-0.0138322245,
0.0003565206,
-0.0012742624,
0.025382081,
0.0423783883,
-0.0618032143,
0.0338605456,
-0.0382569134,
0.0127334734,
0.0176754277,
-0.0222182646,
0.0164452158,
0.0225732662,
0.0137117971,
0.0408886261,
-0.0207682345,
0.0291051455,
-0.0120652551,
0.0089555923,
-0.0378637612,
-0.0429120138,
-0.015204737,
0.0427077338,
0.0187665652,
0.0360347629,
-0.053021796,
0.0340655707,
-0.0129918642,
0.0054388498,
0.0193654764,
0.043068178,
0.0057529104,
0.040133331,
-0.0091107367,
0.0271551702,
0.0182504933,
0.0340864845,
-0.0514901541,
-0.0119736781,
-0.0388960503,
-0.0144237746,
-0.0385295302,
0.0478767045,
-0.026993677,
-0.026097225,
0.0102109639,
0.0088997874,
0.0060017491,
0.0232246798,
0.0260837879,
0.0547430292,
-0.0216202792,
-0.0125821522,
-0.0581914634,
0.0341726132,
-0.0795563012,
0.0352599807,
0.0362889655,
-0.026069399,
-0.0360825732,
-0.0255697723,
0.0410880484,
-0.0125852497,
0.0281748418,
0.0238584001,
-0.0129267387,
0.0015982802,
-0.0528638437,
-0.0515671112,
0.0212891232,
-0.0521069281,
-0.0188548714,
-0.0619020276,
0.0346616767,
-0.0014639921,
0.0198976155,
-0.0334517919,
0.0271665137,
0.0273899697,
-0.0404178016,
0.0499056987,
-0.0343010947,
-0.0193107687,
0.0239719506,
0.0288647879,
-0.0178619288,
0.0558193997,
0.08358749,
-0.0398064218,
0.0604302399,
0.0203587022,
-0.0286462344,
-0.011854792,
0.0073808157,
-0.0039756452,
0.0079915328,
0.0251125265,
-0.0305496529,
0.0503229797,
0.0165706351,
0.0382795595,
-0.0167501327,
-0.0114920475,
0.0433102921,
0.1101891696,
-0.0255030897,
0.0445859879,
0.0510706455,
0.0087680556,
0.0552587956,
0.0391722023,
-0.0434065945,
0.0461063609,
-0.0019475188,
-0.0022292067,
-0.0050166012,
0.0102875764,
-0.0086593218,
-0.031273555,
0.0057175932,
0.0259909723,
0.0118409777,
0.005693153,
0.0017676575,
0.0155323008,
-0.0207181182,
-0.0135367513,
0.0211004596,
-0.0653706044,
0.0482198447,
-0.0363600701,
0.0629974082,
0.0787973776,
0.0745131001,
-0.0418528989,
-0.0968148634,
0.0079223886,
-0.0279564895,
0.0106912479,
-0.0117826685,
-0.0554690473,
0.0074080015,
-0.0259143896,
-0.0156671479,
-0.0732121393,
-0.006820289,
0.0150975669,
0.0012842934,
0.0066961152,
-0.0017929472,
-0.0574796945,
-0.0134274699,
0.0417843871,
-0.0738120154,
-0.0114976512,
-0.0192898996,
-0.0098094698,
-0.0315762982,
0.0421980359,
0.0117136454,
-0.0127631305,
0.0473974794,
-0.0086043375,
-0.0150886988,
0.016431842,
-0.0648243353,
-0.0800617784,
0.0590804815,
-0.088548705,
-0.0035131306,
0.0157683436,
-0.0173889436,
-0.0347608477,
0.0232132543,
-0.0121215368,
0.0368050225,
-0.007507232,
-0.0241580736,
-0.0033132299,
-0.0494662672,
-0.006321846,
0.0543141775,
0.0133570088,
0.0009964765,
-0.0221820753,
0.0302059054,
-0.0008354859,
-0.0092384582,
0.0262863636,
0.003400146,
0.0265124124,
0.0112880375,
0.0004059352,
-0.0081468252,
-0.0665414855,
0.0156798344,
-0.0651963502,
0.0198852159,
0.0084868073,
-0.0023774754,
0.0369611382,
-0.0013133819,
-0.0122961616,
0.0230445527,
-0.0795057118,
0.0272553135,
0.0023299661,
-0.0219142716,
0.0330508761,
0.0381310582,
0.0050337263,
-0.0196738783,
0.0296909995,
-0.0385263525,
0.0432455093,
0.0627983809,
0.0410276391,
-0.0347298495,
0.0014364729,
-0.0685158372,
0.0211092103,
-0.0346177183,
-0.009233675,
0.012982673,
-0.0050835605,
0.0217155199,
0.036550492,
-0.023800049,
-0.0084705437,
0.0531663783,
-0.0514723659,
-0.0308202617,
0.0523822941,
0.0355306081,
-0.0061892434,
-0.0191075671,
0.0000296235,
-0.0193810463,
0.0318634175,
0.0141424146,
-0.0233829692,
-0.0523196422,
0.0518696904,
0.0347718671,
0.0101938676,
-0.049290102,
-0.0501985513,
-0.0067416108,
0.0539971143,
-0.0376524366,
0.0075046862,
0.0699232295,
-0.0222857855,
-0.0114552462,
-0.0581707023,
0.0328027382,
-0.0328802131,
0.0631553307,
-0.0402646884,
0.0135202408,
-0.0278909244,
0.0108305011,
-0.0808459595,
0.0032932488,
0.0223430432,
-0.0287191235,
0.0623927303,
-0.0614423193,
0.0044174599,
0.0069110286,
-0.0133533347,
-0.0567676164,
0.0137720108,
-0.0131111722,
-0.0214835424,
0.0015901295,
-0.0536086038,
0.0061738328,
-0.0503079928,
0.0076486776,
0.0410478413,
-0.0105480524,
-0.0362548269,
0.0098219309,
0.0610573366,
0.0987201482,
0.0373122618,
0.0238225218,
-0.0199657381,
0.0493355505,
0.0362010263,
0.0039380793,
-0.0569927357,
0.0563238226,
0.0285308715,
0.0049696127,
-0.0195856206,
-0.007901079,
0.0372572578,
0.0211916231,
-0.0813238472,
-0.0329988599,
0.0505642071,
0.052303087,
-0.0075815232,
0.0018332573,
-0.0330795012,
-0.0000868137,
0.0070018498,
0.0047299317,
-0.0924450979,
-0.0207415037,
-0.0049051135,
0.0220149141,
-0.0116071748,
-0.0818228573,
-0.0343646631,
-0.1096780226,
0.0260377657,
-0.001905288,
-0.0383590609,
-0.055242002,
-0.0277777631,
-0.0271215793,
0.0410907194,
0.0007107161,
-0.0084276749,
-0.023049349,
0.0343687199,
-0.0309475735,
0.0361806266,
0.0039053711,
0.0318685994,
-0.014732576,
0.059528783,
0.0451728664,
0.0409653485,
-0.0139683811,
0.0083131324,
-0.0607501045,
-0.0311614387,
-0.0353680253,
0.0156006189,
0.0209965035,
-0.0214639176,
-0.0171680991,
-0.012436131,
0.0914535299,
-0.0386356525,
-0.0250240751,
0.0383069254,
0.0654727817,
0.0059354915,
-0.0159137808,
0.0029624549,
0.0411646813,
-0.0018032342,
0.1113003567,
0.0343348496,
-0.0112535264,
0.0069191153,
-0.0391894728,
-0.0227658488,
-0.0822029784,
-0.0499692596,
0.0369332023,
0.0328366086,
0.0627188534,
-0.1193599179,
-0.0336696841,
0.055324737,
0.0178245846,
0.0125346575,
0.0198491067,
0.0148844579,
0.0162255503,
-0.0550450645,
0.0317725092,
-0.0451429822,
-0.0326937288,
-0.0228373725,
-0.0113690803,
0.0044850283,
-0.0800035521,
-0.0181305408,
0.0559693798,
-0.0731660649,
-0.0383232795,
-0.0415105373,
-0.0109518692,
0.0125980824,
0.0318077169,
0.0174410604,
-0.0083854198,
0.0694608465,
0.0142991943,
-0.0589073561,
-0.0125245648,
-0.020648269,
0.0474122651,
-0.0017805264,
0.0267266221,
-0.057156302,
-0.0300137624,
-0.0256822687,
0.0451102294,
0.002321833,
-0.0494116619,
0.0158787332,
0.0074284291,
-0.015524446,
-0.0237078425,
-0.0035919149,
-0.0745509788,
0.0039214892,
-0.0308853332,
-0.0331072286,
-0.031804923,
0.0102845263,
-0.0003182865,
-0.0432193428,
-0.0241029058,
-0.0113809863,
-0.0122154979,
0.0386051275,
-0.0398410931,
0.0096504139,
0.0201348197,
0.0064113871,
-0.0007997475,
0.0008377508,
-0.000571581,
-0.0249359366,
-0.0302817132,
0.0793381855,
0.0136755109,
0.0450353846,
0.0283012725,
-0.023882905,
-0.0233552288,
0.0155289955,
-0.0444539823,
-0.0283314921,
-0.0139380638,
0.0532045104,
0.0333009847,
0.0177998431,
0.0035611058,
-0.0239603706,
0.0009892993,
-0.0067533334,
-0.008421476,
0.0324927121,
0.0112512624,
0.035994865,
0.015828535,
0.0136909494,
0.0302315746,
0.061861299,
-0.0387583226,
0.104233399,
-0.0016662312,
-0.0067423326,
-0.0260933489,
-0.0549020581,
0.0203344058,
0.0416105501,
0.0358197689,
0.017894594,
-0.0548030026,
-0.0325643346,
0.0138989557,
0.0237425361,
-0.0130757513,
-0.0289724916,
0.014113754,
0.0192401353,
-0.0025067092,
-0.0246507246,
-0.0216916688,
0.0146544827,
-0.05534577,
-0.0371504091,
-0.0291513279,
-5.463395788e-33,
-0.0420917645,
-0.0346434228,
0.0290519912,
0.0403316543,
-0.0329973027,
0.0351285525,
-0.0246414486,
-0.0068280771,
-0.0370541401,
0.0339192487,
-0.0115050524,
-0.0068854336,
-0.0288658813,
0.0007027864,
-0.0308329556,
-0.0149552217,
-0.0164119601,
-0.0055395281,
-0.0360216126,
0.0434532352,
0.0575769469,
-0.0068434044,
0.0490586236,
-0.0187426675,
0.0202639382,
-0.044862777,
-0.0079865204,
0.0127661536,
-0.0180620756,
0.0558670908,
-0.018415438,
0.0580759086,
0.0307808314,
0.0140796909,
0.0168355424,
0.0183612164,
-0.0751151741,
-0.0631126165,
0.0557576567,
-0.0429453142,
-0.0422909185,
-0.0567988902,
0.0225757435,
0.0192413274,
0.0232042279,
-0.0264614392,
0.05331669,
-0.0216456912,
0.0473825634,
-0.025351515,
-0.0378345028,
-0.0213062223,
-0.0524247475,
-0.05720938,
-0.0467292964,
0.0587853342,
0.0259022303,
0.0145930843,
-0.0532423109,
0.0186603852,
0.0535574779,
0.009228372,
0.0163148344,
0.0076539274,
0.0002122951,
0.0611000434,
0.0005893972,
-0.0165724736,
-0.0483396314,
0.0451510288,
-0.0002942062,
0.0104335137,
0.0523899943,
0.0806207284,
-0.0090496149,
0.0394035839,
-0.1029539928,
0.0767646506,
0.0079990821,
0.0112523874,
-0.0139673734,
-0.0413767435,
-0.0302682947,
-0.0203858856,
-0.0587035604,
0.0054674195,
-0.0086956564,
0.0170962531,
0.0075343363,
-0.0548836105,
-0.029540224,
0.0290687997,
-0.0227380879,
-0.011985003,
0.0358728468,
0.0501996055,
-0.0128189279,
0.0130480919,
0.0044921045,
0.0311650578,
-0.0331294909,
0.006823272,
0.0670883283,
-0.0076451637,
0.0264644399,
0.037691202,
0.0091455188,
0.0209089704,
-0.0250234883,
0.0009804728,
-0.0156228645,
0.0196414012,
-0.008740304,
-0.0233311988,
0.0098570725,
0.0006716892,
-0.0098463735,
0.0207722709,
0.0166672561,
-0.0019693649,
-0.0164783746,
-0.0369077772,
-0.012968353,
-0.0219024625,
-0.0276854988,
0.0101863062,
-0.0096153291,
-0.0189787839,
-0.0084266085,
-0.0302073043,
-0.0044660587,
0.0101386085,
2.42e-7,
0.0048225895,
0.0032565859,
0.040192686,
0.0268777739,
0.0015162057,
0.0151043748,
-0.0066005006,
-0.008522138,
0.0072514373,
-0.0682430416,
0.0260166265,
0.0398120806,
0.028861424,
0.0302358922,
-0.0738410652,
0.0325051136,
-0.0290741157,
-0.0065332619,
-0.0510025285,
-0.0301026199,
0.080255948,
0.004887179,
0.0407526903,
-0.0293461215,
-0.0113675548,
-0.0490236543,
0.0095829992,
-0.0245397035,
-0.0079679545,
0.0380049422,
-0.0169069972,
0.0134194391,
-0.0154078687,
-0.0062220749,
0.0006702945,
0.0514037646,
-0.0045953966,
0.0264873095,
0.0155228041,
-0.0433061831,
-0.0179074109,
-0.0242861416,
-0.0007417704,
-0.0578362979,
0.0867674798,
-0.0111904116,
-0.0002180239,
0.0322409272,
-0.0091439458,
-0.0046098381,
-0.0263746642,
-0.032040529,
-0.0047751819,
0.0207399204,
0.0009521584,
-0.0124986917,
0.0262599625,
-0.0566233285,
0.0112848794,
-0.001773215,
-0.0400852971,
-0.0461052172,
-0.0205277521,
-0.0318880565,
-0.0336947888,
-0.06041006,
0.0595494211,
2.073127321e-34,
-0.0230201166,
-0.0486606956,
0.0041721878,
-0.0124757038,
0.0543691888,
-0.0076994225,
0.0258511174,
-0.0241796374,
0.043322131,
-0.0549822003,
-0.0119871199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09755v1 | How Does Calibration Data Affect the Post-training Pruning and Quantization of Large Language Models? | 2023-11-16T10:30:00 | 2023-11-16T10:30:00 | Miles Williams, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pruning and quantization form the foundation of model compression for neural
networks, enabling efficient inference for large language models (LLMs).
Recently, various quantization and pruning techniques have demonstrated
state-of-the-art performance in a post-training setting. They rely upon
calibration data, a small set of unlabeled examples, to generate layer
activations. However, no prior work has systematically investigated how the
calibration data impacts the effectiveness of model compression methods. In
this paper, we present the first extensive empirical study on the effect of
calibration data upon LLM performance. We trial a variety of pruning and
quantization methods, tasks, models, and datasets. Surprisingly, we find
substantial variations in downstream task performance, contrasting existing
work that suggests a greater level of robustness to the calibration data.
Finally, we make a series of recommendations for the effective use of
calibration data in LLM quantization and pruning. | [
-0.0305948853,
0.0744011551,
-0.0145162931,
0.037621554,
-0.0179957114,
0.0135407122,
0.0390235446,
0.0435537025,
-0.0505198091,
0.0029400324,
-0.0414389782,
-0.0377705842,
0.043429628,
-0.0132604567,
0.0281892754,
0.0237356294,
0.0319232382,
-0.0222118963,
0.0142114218,
-0.0039013322,
-0.0162391514,
0.0044720694,
0.0239942539,
0.0411300734,
-0.0167953987,
-0.0163044333,
0.0218592752,
0.0131003549,
-0.0198912062,
0.0194204394,
0.0008804822,
0.0608138479,
0.019959772,
0.0552469715,
0.0000017739,
-0.0301305354,
0.0003533676,
0.0048837145,
-0.0848772153,
0.0611384213,
0.0412614532,
-0.0129851503,
0.000670621,
0.0094705634,
-0.0114322109,
-0.0473171137,
0.0368147641,
0.0008745206,
0.0175985303,
0.0632927418,
0.0071135601,
-0.019538762,
-0.0028457507,
-0.0330217592,
-0.047057949,
-0.0275380798,
0.0000884269,
0.0277270526,
-0.0417295434,
0.0075934785,
-0.015734069,
0.0171307717,
0.0399890579,
0.0235301852,
-0.0300957132,
0.0407694764,
-0.0559603423,
-0.0136676896,
0.0114686992,
0.0438218936,
-0.0567518473,
-0.0531225279,
-0.0047835801,
-0.0190387629,
-0.0005812251,
-0.0674570873,
-0.0362290107,
0.0342763476,
0.0509592742,
0.0536982007,
-0.0149668492,
-0.0283229742,
0.0840176344,
-0.0034355249,
-0.0096843438,
0.058327809,
0.0099252826,
-0.0223983787,
-0.0237476584,
0.0074801459,
-0.0313406289,
-0.0674851537,
-0.0115749612,
0.0123572741,
0.0230254587,
-0.0049772789,
-0.0688536614,
-0.0341966562,
-0.009063378,
-0.0198200885,
0.0431510173,
0.0522851646,
0.0023815765,
0.0147191174,
-0.044100441,
0.0666587725,
0.0126226684,
0.027531838,
-0.0568892993,
0.0035589654,
-0.0243591666,
-0.0079909284,
-0.028290052,
0.0171730779,
-0.0035731848,
0.0034866221,
-0.0701324418,
-0.0167629682,
0.0044968543,
-0.0125678973,
0.008659157,
-0.0013526068,
-0.0214358512,
-0.0031858389,
0.0192236304,
0.0281405225,
-0.0282770861,
0.0369114913,
-0.0079166861,
-0.0698042661,
-0.0417114459,
0.0327165499,
0.0008277944,
-0.0303149894,
0.024208039,
0.0070235902,
0.0240551103,
-0.0519294813,
-0.017508911,
-0.0015297007,
-0.0279995315,
-0.0907278135,
0.0183352251,
-0.062264394,
0.0221873764,
-0.0178311858,
0.0093055321,
-0.0733208358,
-0.0102179302,
-0.0164168756,
-0.0298108775,
0.0428741723,
-0.0077256635,
0.0216043629,
-0.0058316421,
-0.0094109336,
0.0577227585,
0.0905785114,
0.0559238754,
0.0159764364,
0.0089890761,
-0.0227508713,
0.0026189347,
0.0629029348,
0.0638743192,
-0.0163254365,
-0.0595899038,
-0.0396856852,
-0.0106352093,
0.0278197303,
0.0678243116,
0.057952065,
-0.0652918816,
-0.0254898239,
0.0333415158,
0.0253144186,
0.0287747197,
0.0287384279,
0.0188941769,
-0.0288591944,
0.0249726865,
0.0071496884,
-0.0528380312,
-0.0134991277,
-0.0145782186,
-0.0057219206,
0.0104209464,
0.0198907349,
-0.0366129577,
-0.0428553484,
-0.0552949309,
-0.0132732205,
0.0144918934,
0.0276328623,
0.029212879,
0.0026965053,
0.0208019558,
0.1334718615,
0.0129357772,
-0.0589022823,
0.0139125772,
-0.06540066,
-0.0290070213,
0.017029345,
0.0124902287,
0.0038037961,
-0.0149164321,
0.0308810212,
0.0187869482,
-0.0333185345,
0.0252456851,
-0.0126452334,
0.0538957268,
-0.050472144,
-0.0122102061,
-0.0424572006,
0.032204859,
-0.0199208613,
0.042167861,
-0.0119922971,
0.0205407515,
-0.0858226418,
-0.0257521942,
0.0534853116,
-0.0187533088,
-0.0586085729,
0.0198259354,
-0.0058317254,
0.0024706367,
0.0086407419,
-0.0273949225,
-0.0045490083,
0.0395359769,
-0.0394227915,
0.0408506766,
-0.0328737535,
0.0040722182,
-0.046392139,
0.0594467856,
0.0198178962,
0.013611055,
0.0576335192,
-0.0489135161,
-0.0331720747,
0.0121580726,
-0.009489933,
0.0115174223,
-0.0433127396,
0.0236138906,
-0.0519040041,
0.0573001057,
-0.0030140392,
0.0137386667,
-0.02369879,
0.0268923435,
0.0102214636,
-0.0255282782,
0.0036857054,
-0.0359977931,
-0.0480131246,
0.0012046286,
-0.0213401839,
0.0053678262,
-0.0056595067,
-0.0087027987,
0.0008901725,
0.0028518634,
-0.1005952656,
0.0046788505,
-0.0444110371,
0.0297201872,
0.0219901092,
0.0369826891,
-0.01210244,
-0.0087317694,
-0.0114699379,
-0.0189479627,
0.0168005191,
0.0244673789,
0.0117388591,
-0.0260439459,
-0.0143776936,
-0.037347354,
-0.0574300885,
-0.004290672,
0.0898475796,
-0.0510904975,
-0.0229405202,
-0.0698630735,
0.0499033257,
-0.030312933,
0.0104724234,
0.0037410785,
-0.0501721799,
0.0039999075,
0.0077502872,
-0.0217665583,
0.0637846887,
-0.0478359833,
0.0262330938,
0.0980815589,
0.0414058417,
-0.0473172739,
0.0143239927,
-0.020119248,
-0.04501177,
-0.0424894653,
-0.0468880832,
-0.0209515877,
0.091804117,
-0.0127238296,
-0.0093359696,
-0.0227504168,
0.0216788128,
-0.0253140759,
-0.0316449404,
-0.0323084332,
-0.0079636201,
-0.0145036308,
0.0587887764,
-0.0027838727,
-0.0504052863,
0.0311044268,
-0.0557658263,
-0.0010802555,
0.0118459053,
-0.0159373675,
-0.0113871032,
0.0507877544,
0.0407383069,
0.0152931148,
0.0156909712,
0.0066624586,
-0.0570732392,
-0.0285545047,
-0.0045020045,
-0.0171631407,
-0.0199420322,
-0.0276181046,
0.0233703926,
-0.0219773017,
-0.0243077055,
-0.0053329696,
-0.0106669879,
-0.0187878963,
0.0523952805,
0.0190632734,
-0.0008349245,
0.0143753337,
0.0249755774,
-0.0264107529,
0.0305182878,
-0.0027769636,
0.0352150984,
0.0005929015,
0.038349472,
0.0316657051,
0.013811362,
0.0515502617,
-0.0263902284,
-0.019324176,
0.0198486876,
0.0153805288,
0.0822005793,
-0.0690820515,
0.0024599982,
0.0319587514,
-0.0025143018,
-0.0152505198,
0.0096070776,
0.0714222938,
-0.056447342,
-0.0079743527,
0.1006800979,
0.0146168144,
-0.0357401855,
0.0090002064,
0.0189639814,
0.0291296523,
0.0023041873,
0.0173482653,
-0.0692839324,
-0.0161834434,
0.0330094732,
0.0037978468,
0.0089537026,
-0.0027535579,
-0.0127178915,
-0.0990862325,
0.0173384752,
0.0133691449,
-0.0164937414,
0.0021599438,
-0.0337217487,
0.0095167244,
-0.043718759,
0.057324037,
0.0222892929,
0.0073703313,
0.0025180127,
0.0394128598,
-0.037546318,
-0.0852892548,
0.0172363892,
-0.0085463729,
0.0612579174,
0.0618263669,
0.0282303412,
0.0007435633,
0.0155679081,
0.0601669364,
0.0234809462,
-0.0051433155,
0.0028901559,
0.0537153482,
0.0307323951,
0.005129369,
0.0441320613,
0.0187473502,
-0.0087976065,
-0.0114244269,
-0.0475368761,
0.0431380235,
0.0093668317,
-0.0472904071,
0.001437613,
-0.0208506137,
-0.0276938118,
0.0674003735,
0.069220908,
-0.0080016023,
-0.0580476001,
-0.0008312177,
-0.0036363679,
-0.0452334434,
-0.0214739237,
0.0332159773,
0.0005875378,
-0.0519878529,
-0.0171001628,
-0.0303895343,
0.0217372496,
0.001241641,
-0.0202146936,
-0.0114841871,
-0.0078001069,
0.0216215588,
-0.0527752228,
0.0421000645,
-0.0388007462,
0.0130269239,
-0.0092210583,
0.0244166069,
-0.032414183,
-0.0016988757,
-0.0112799006,
-0.0159772616,
-0.1786671728,
-0.0666641369,
0.0057796738,
0.0303584728,
0.0290153436,
0.0544798188,
-0.0068816096,
-0.0799488127,
0.0272384211,
0.0478554256,
-0.0268928818,
0.0641137958,
0.0118843708,
-0.0499446131,
-0.0031563316,
0.063799955,
-0.0189072061,
0.033560168,
0.0566903353,
0.0437330678,
-0.025491355,
-0.0257072113,
-0.0036022959,
0.0122167226,
0.0725215375,
-0.0217709206,
-0.019696245,
0.0044161864,
0.0102296248,
0.0087074134,
-0.0011984602,
-0.022222776,
-0.0026460488,
0.03449196,
0.0521656536,
-0.0065783109,
-0.0149840964,
0.0261356179,
0.0234053526,
0.0017115485,
-0.0006109173,
0.0095327236,
0.0035222159,
0.0588096157,
0.0170158874,
-0.0253741983,
0.0346828513,
-0.0087643703,
0.0180026237,
-0.0262485482,
-0.0196996573,
-0.0040745526,
0.0402848348,
-0.0800267309,
0.0237614978,
-0.0478422195,
-0.0474532358,
-0.0354523808,
0.0255443752,
0.0466885753,
-0.0158995241,
0.0236263406,
0.0036474306,
-0.0222803149,
-0.0297546815,
0.0061091334,
0.0053074216,
0.0024105965,
0.0223644767,
-0.0052325027,
-0.0347402319,
-0.0010937207,
0.0642944872,
0.0394660681,
0.0425889008,
-0.0182423666,
-0.0077760704,
-0.0039575072,
-0.0264497511,
-0.0635766163,
-0.0001603192,
-0.0304287523,
-0.0198016632,
-0.0313755758,
-0.0907165781,
0.0114897341,
0.0250321925,
0.0195686761,
-0.0068710172,
0.0104204249,
0.0400843024,
-0.0083619524,
-0.0093152076,
-0.0232310556,
-0.0313402452,
-0.00547363,
-0.0280523058,
-0.0334559977,
-5.798391106e-33,
-0.0143402601,
0.0193266645,
0.0189293418,
-0.0193393752,
-0.0400104895,
0.0368759111,
-0.0247701555,
0.0088309469,
-0.0359485485,
-0.0015111814,
-0.0320081003,
0.0328349881,
0.0248002019,
0.0178586375,
-0.0238653105,
-0.0312217381,
0.0799943879,
-0.0367691033,
-0.042483937,
-0.0013981051,
-0.0021926239,
0.0331312418,
0.0711366832,
-0.0017650046,
-0.0093071098,
0.016918892,
0.0001606765,
0.0081110718,
0.0107679991,
0.0500245728,
-0.0317210779,
0.0439217202,
0.0223823208,
0.0173075758,
-0.0087423231,
0.0081348158,
-0.0888701081,
-0.0092499629,
0.0262304321,
0.0384128392,
-0.0095208678,
-0.0356037803,
0.0693219826,
0.0029336421,
-0.054064054,
-0.0203722045,
-0.0097709885,
-0.0163824763,
-0.0397924669,
-0.0518207625,
-0.0335514769,
0.0121823717,
-0.0001867637,
-0.0024586562,
0.0664505437,
0.0255374741,
-0.0292006861,
0.0205562748,
-0.0854096264,
-0.0241560638,
0.0311142839,
0.0939688459,
0.0730017871,
0.0538505688,
0.0068288809,
0.042745769,
0.0498330332,
0.0172264483,
-0.0419949889,
0.0392375775,
0.0858247951,
-0.0040010228,
0.0508176237,
0.0483387448,
0.0860286728,
-0.0365791991,
-0.0801543817,
-0.0189744886,
0.0053124544,
0.0173124075,
0.0317485891,
0.0265174303,
-0.0046182135,
-0.0289386697,
-0.0647070855,
-0.0511988364,
-0.0470883548,
-0.0193278752,
-0.0016397457,
0.0150821246,
-0.026222581,
-0.0248704907,
0.021466421,
-0.0694137737,
-0.0256690327,
0.0151620349,
0.0085426653,
0.0240436681,
0.0154430736,
0.0394089594,
-0.028833339,
-0.0085229697,
-0.0155350212,
0.013831974,
0.0384502858,
-0.0175935812,
0.0345494077,
0.0322951712,
-0.0314741768,
-0.0075457375,
-0.0297618806,
-0.0138250142,
0.0181859862,
0.0615459979,
0.0472191535,
0.0329914652,
0.015781695,
-0.0081373053,
0.0261573866,
0.0259708259,
-0.0104219317,
-0.008206333,
0.0372624099,
0.0325204581,
-0.0385490581,
-0.034147203,
-0.0298038721,
0.0403911732,
0.0360063128,
-0.0608173721,
-0.0232608002,
0.0330731161,
2.418e-7,
0.0594085306,
0.0080390293,
-0.0087320954,
-0.0049787234,
0.0172167774,
-0.0064199716,
-0.0110488255,
-0.0097186295,
0.0025469661,
-0.0141150206,
0.0129531175,
0.0139830615,
0.0713150948,
0.0237910058,
-0.0715093836,
-0.0085115219,
-0.0303830672,
0.0055771759,
-0.0200929809,
-0.0158419386,
-0.0120243412,
0.1079503521,
0.0219975337,
-0.0289773941,
-0.0003773163,
-0.023769198,
0.0363545939,
-0.0455380082,
0.0209360067,
0.044248797,
0.0476833172,
0.0102607999,
0.0097676199,
-0.0105897496,
0.0112801073,
0.0226616692,
-0.0207142457,
0.0702469796,
0.0040656603,
0.010209959,
-0.0390588492,
-0.0058978344,
-0.0079651326,
-0.0495303161,
0.0538709313,
-0.0385194756,
-0.0026093465,
-0.0978421345,
0.008639602,
-0.0140335392,
0.0428716652,
-0.0082298368,
0.0254679173,
0.0326340497,
0.0235940181,
-0.0147837261,
-0.0281973984,
-0.0906288773,
-0.0565305501,
0.0363526717,
-0.0382993221,
-0.0286942963,
-0.0122174816,
-0.0259558093,
0.0460855216,
-0.0558159687,
0.0053640064,
2.122974251e-34,
0.0104431398,
-0.0211961381,
0.0121556921,
0.0245663337,
0.0005969665,
-0.0272063818,
-0.0021809558,
-0.0056696879,
-0.0324788131,
-0.0612012297,
-0.0128297443
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09748v1 | Translation Aligned Sentence Embeddings for Turkish Language | 2023-11-16T10:25:22 | 2023-11-16T10:25:22 | Eren Unlu, Unver Ciftci | cs.CL | cs.CL | Due to the limited availability of high quality datasets for training
sentence embeddings in Turkish, we propose a training methodology and a regimen
to develop a sentence embedding model. The central idea is simple but effective
: is to fine-tune a pretrained encoder-decoder model in two consecutive stages,
where the first stage involves aligning the embedding space with translation
pairs. Thanks to this alignment, the prowess of the main model can be better
projected onto the target language in a sentence embedding setting where it can
be fine-tuned with high accuracy in short duration with limited target language
dataset. | [
0.0145883523,
0.0277613997,
-0.0050931699,
0.0501976162,
-0.0152780786,
0.0453112423,
-0.002832795,
-0.0756782368,
-0.0460747555,
0.0178320706,
-0.0233981088,
-0.0234691538,
0.0106696691,
-0.0086435722,
0.0192856397,
-0.0171073731,
0.0294268597,
0.0241583008,
0.0065780124,
-0.0039948947,
0.0465374216,
0.0307325572,
-0.0082897805,
0.0173809901,
-0.0243220441,
-0.0163325649,
-0.0261498801,
-0.0043702899,
0.0407874919,
-0.0029369353,
0.0169409961,
0.0069300034,
0.0273984969,
0.0131573221,
0.0000016401,
0.0052227839,
0.0042738384,
-0.0441163443,
0.0016331723,
0.0069350214,
0.0099878628,
-0.1049346328,
-0.019790316,
0.0159856416,
-0.0288811438,
-0.0162351821,
0.0371328518,
0.0313466452,
0.0424001068,
0.0897771716,
-0.0103351101,
-0.0773380026,
0.0006980477,
-0.0339184441,
-0.0348983184,
-0.033304695,
-0.0284483731,
-0.042636849,
-0.0914774612,
0.0239738319,
-0.0192695167,
0.0542881377,
0.0254821014,
0.0109590115,
0.0258669294,
-0.0116254976,
-0.031111842,
-0.0380426794,
0.0189581625,
0.0336499885,
-0.0258205459,
-0.0299050733,
-0.0298409872,
0.012524616,
-0.0037259161,
-0.0237991326,
-0.0228836164,
0.0012981209,
0.029091876,
0.0346446782,
0.0554572493,
0.0535250604,
0.0181118548,
-0.0182761047,
-0.0271029733,
-0.0120328758,
0.0487835668,
-0.074681066,
-0.0257403962,
0.0410092175,
-0.0049014478,
0.0379985794,
0.0271906666,
0.0075853011,
-0.008510855,
-0.0007094492,
-0.0481626019,
-0.0605100431,
0.0021824467,
-0.0772517845,
0.0377082005,
0.0497301258,
0.0233516525,
0.0143357376,
-0.0684555992,
0.0433524102,
0.0034912706,
-0.0113341054,
-0.0743172169,
-0.0321113952,
-0.0018858809,
-0.0148176942,
-0.0599938147,
0.0021734918,
-0.043005731,
-0.0229502954,
-0.0498746373,
0.0523427688,
0.0185907986,
0.0326365791,
0.0009401361,
-0.0135348104,
-0.0474725328,
0.0201705806,
-0.0023444446,
0.0207841191,
-0.0402344167,
0.0009764116,
-0.0447846316,
-0.0133826043,
-0.0266709477,
0.0038392746,
0.0332796536,
-0.0046072453,
-0.0298307743,
-0.0011371606,
-0.0237006899,
-0.0384372436,
0.0061182803,
0.0471850783,
-0.0352350846,
-0.0440512002,
-0.0206841063,
-0.0211434457,
0.0807266459,
-0.0070005716,
-0.0123312389,
-0.0207961239,
-0.0094064754,
0.0240706932,
0.0231331848,
0.0662773699,
0.0473228097,
0.0014284087,
-0.0207317639,
-0.0327391364,
0.0863858461,
0.0858914852,
0.0403969325,
0.0150173688,
0.0123250503,
-0.0063143037,
-0.0181414019,
0.0170037542,
0.0243494194,
-0.013227242,
0.0056549646,
0.0515573397,
0.0551421754,
0.0615285039,
0.0001418928,
-0.005060799,
-0.0059643965,
0.0379309282,
0.041535262,
0.0098833162,
0.0212852769,
0.0393242724,
0.0561126806,
-0.000358909,
-0.045241382,
0.0057243058,
0.0023584103,
0.002144638,
0.0231668521,
0.0243127998,
-0.0037719265,
0.0588065647,
-0.0432944782,
-0.036517933,
0.0018525085,
-0.0403006375,
0.0214538127,
-0.0466491878,
0.0514631458,
-0.0027438987,
-0.0636295006,
0.0375427827,
-0.0112651754,
-0.0468547978,
0.0019632087,
0.0512117408,
-0.0131183332,
0.0468229391,
0.0274211094,
0.0144483708,
-0.0075146593,
-0.0108033037,
0.0064404821,
0.0356485248,
0.0384078249,
-0.0361050107,
0.0260794181,
-0.0562553331,
-0.0069681806,
-0.0151317576,
0.0229341481,
-0.0040053157,
-0.0365317725,
0.056326244,
0.039315097,
-0.0294153299,
0.0053312676,
0.0336194336,
0.01764144,
0.006577909,
-0.0157383252,
0.0683455691,
0.0122384261,
0.0227544755,
0.0289739445,
-0.0007917188,
0.055821076,
-0.0661341399,
0.0296552256,
0.0159283727,
-0.0687424466,
-0.1102658659,
0.0185791031,
-0.0438700467,
-0.0453909226,
0.0466715656,
-0.074260965,
-0.0355236679,
-0.0011298972,
-0.002331221,
0.0321438834,
-0.0328768529,
0.0331056714,
-0.0023046653,
0.0219544265,
-0.0168706439,
0.0316608734,
0.0069291894,
0.0158901215,
-0.0263378993,
-0.0344617926,
0.0393622331,
0.0237509664,
-0.0292577762,
0.0140077844,
-0.0125059122,
0.0246491507,
0.0148894759,
-0.0109991776,
0.0085329842,
-0.0335369073,
-0.079745777,
0.0103066554,
-0.0365919173,
0.0590747148,
0.0359834433,
0.0140500404,
0.0128384028,
-0.0120218359,
-0.0199948307,
-0.0225309804,
0.0152702639,
-0.0033627313,
0.071239084,
-0.0393865928,
-0.0300842021,
-0.0097801518,
0.0100973798,
0.0068572513,
0.0082170479,
-0.0222807266,
-0.0237918328,
-0.0387334116,
0.0195600502,
0.0049693128,
-0.0253684986,
0.0062038763,
-0.0950443223,
0.0040777228,
0.0606267489,
0.0534536354,
0.0517273396,
-0.0097088376,
0.0448519103,
0.0254307501,
0.0498661771,
0.0094856471,
-0.003341055,
-0.0457113013,
-0.020866625,
-0.0628334582,
0.0272155739,
0.015680436,
0.0614573061,
-0.035360828,
-0.0045072539,
-0.0911860541,
-0.0239863936,
-0.0073947501,
0.0191686545,
-0.0180671494,
-0.0013846754,
-0.022576116,
0.0267576631,
-0.0221298095,
-0.0066585033,
0.0138605051,
-0.0356336944,
0.0013514765,
-0.0924413875,
-0.0191216227,
-0.0159602165,
0.0065549491,
0.0106836073,
0.0174729098,
-0.0345085151,
-0.0013014112,
-0.051717028,
0.0315431543,
0.0352350585,
-0.0196708217,
0.0110708224,
-0.0092603955,
-0.0223744176,
-0.0395295769,
-0.0502694957,
-0.0369398259,
-0.0784633979,
-0.0029309536,
-0.0001782883,
0.0140233785,
0.0389389023,
-0.0399971232,
-0.0068577169,
-0.009379385,
0.0099006724,
-0.0136386007,
0.0329143815,
-0.0616871491,
0.0320938826,
0.0568237118,
-0.0160076004,
-0.0532646105,
0.0052704657,
0.0427303165,
0.0346119367,
-0.0405045785,
0.0013731713,
-0.0395881049,
-0.0252102222,
0.0310725532,
-0.0170414969,
0.0252928529,
-0.0286371075,
0.0410964303,
0.0019061342,
-0.0255524386,
0.0977217406,
0.0236679018,
0.0138771832,
0.0135133127,
0.0224793125,
0.0403634124,
0.0239546616,
-0.0094301431,
-0.0635774285,
-0.0162994266,
0.0136636607,
-0.032685589,
0.0222803801,
0.051872205,
0.035178028,
-0.1104759499,
-0.0349985845,
0.0317813829,
-0.0460059494,
-0.0766802803,
-0.026789194,
-0.0377809182,
-0.0391069725,
0.0154136773,
-0.0343978889,
0.0142186051,
0.0269744974,
0.0191330574,
-0.0299216304,
-0.1020576805,
-0.0538320132,
-0.0388813876,
0.0052703563,
0.0346129686,
0.0392029472,
0.0078314375,
0.0204641074,
0.0115160104,
-0.0281059202,
-0.0303759258,
0.0313898325,
0.0188401677,
-0.0499033481,
-0.024725901,
-0.0101167848,
-0.0010005079,
-0.0873208866,
0.0244142897,
0.0090591339,
0.0659161434,
0.0239217896,
0.0313859805,
0.0152567299,
-0.0002447229,
0.0095241535,
0.0724216178,
0.0333104879,
-0.0307706166,
-0.0178968776,
0.0017367587,
0.0008717438,
-0.061387226,
-0.0104791876,
0.0274226628,
0.0292962193,
0.0323717073,
-0.0766661689,
-0.0755107105,
0.0236394852,
0.0002745354,
-0.0055309325,
0.0328556336,
-0.0488328151,
-0.0503392257,
-0.0050443285,
-0.0061840964,
0.0026352333,
0.000248521,
-0.0107246414,
0.0374591313,
0.0261400528,
0.0171631817,
-0.009400594,
-0.0200589653,
-0.0902070776,
-0.0402347147,
-0.0200977419,
0.0183170494,
-0.0005758245,
0.0485059358,
-0.0249574147,
0.0376601368,
0.0628662482,
-0.0271025505,
-0.0594976768,
0.0021047702,
0.0408627987,
-0.0090205986,
-0.0061311563,
0.0469437316,
-0.0038600727,
0.0051923767,
0.0018964034,
0.0042621256,
0.0075551686,
-0.0438762866,
0.0116702812,
-0.0318038985,
0.0413284041,
-0.0168359317,
-0.0003099438,
-0.0313710757,
0.0635774136,
-0.0199417621,
0.0020406393,
0.0050041461,
-0.0164328702,
0.0572335571,
0.004701924,
-0.001284023,
0.0012840987,
-0.0052146371,
-0.0198145211,
-0.0396091081,
-0.0097775282,
0.0227610376,
-0.0079070171,
-0.003824393,
0.06869331,
-0.0567614622,
0.0179747976,
-0.0400829352,
0.0080018491,
-0.0365468711,
0.0042435122,
-0.0183345545,
0.0381182283,
0.0152956061,
0.0640100315,
-0.0145377759,
0.052556362,
-0.0104850642,
0.0029459703,
0.079223074,
-0.0629777387,
0.065666534,
-0.0128460536,
-0.0148729831,
0.0113025615,
0.0741496459,
-0.0435650013,
-0.0197550412,
0.0081000822,
-0.037938945,
-0.0541582778,
-0.0381750055,
0.0294499639,
-0.002655071,
0.0150123397,
-0.007159478,
0.0204205569,
-0.0135505693,
-0.0046944637,
0.0104824398,
0.0226304401,
-0.0399254337,
-0.0003704167,
0.0099831996,
-0.0544229969,
-0.0221718363,
0.0057774154,
-0.0211769678,
-0.017486196,
0.021470001,
0.0465983413,
-0.0164856575,
0.0112387668,
-0.0038444342,
0.0076594176,
-0.004885165,
-0.0302016065,
-0.0651755258,
-4.992050103e-33,
0.0012308836,
0.0854367912,
-0.0278238226,
-0.0798522234,
-0.0199167859,
-0.0281739216,
0.018559413,
-0.0104546882,
-0.0243433993,
0.0266975667,
-0.0018212398,
0.0039146738,
0.0131602352,
0.0370641835,
-0.0017587383,
-0.017713774,
0.0463193692,
-0.0182963703,
-0.0104291802,
0.0101246154,
0.0385451876,
0.0218546782,
0.0764475092,
-0.0044478034,
-0.0298514403,
-0.0610901453,
0.0057014138,
0.0271415208,
0.054491166,
0.0565975904,
-0.0005156999,
0.0346148051,
0.0187516082,
-0.029833544,
-0.0199722089,
0.0257840436,
-0.0721374378,
-0.0085943583,
0.0086505897,
0.063149184,
-0.0268293228,
-0.0605779849,
-0.0185695272,
-0.0419199392,
0.0036300656,
0.0168089867,
0.0124451015,
-0.0250571333,
-0.0185072944,
0.0260638557,
-0.0940030962,
-0.0099424552,
-0.0308671091,
0.0021228781,
0.0579391159,
0.0550339296,
0.0363629572,
-0.0071969442,
-0.044765152,
-0.0084930649,
-0.0557766333,
0.0526087247,
0.0483210385,
-0.031575907,
-0.0087939519,
0.017102709,
-0.0581195951,
-0.0143758412,
0.0064473292,
0.0182372574,
-0.0191202145,
0.0028979899,
0.0232216809,
0.0727413818,
0.0334679298,
-0.0420860201,
-0.1055989414,
0.0199209489,
-0.0021674628,
0.0189896468,
0.0334673449,
0.0109495772,
-0.0325516239,
-0.0390709564,
0.0147246886,
-0.0179205071,
0.0255263988,
-0.0413124338,
0.0355405137,
0.0154788103,
-0.012606753,
-0.0316921845,
0.0287092179,
-0.0400227122,
0.0517023429,
0.0335913375,
-0.0180234406,
0.0061294655,
-0.000477821,
0.042883914,
-0.0262361392,
-0.0524034686,
-0.0028036903,
0.0172308926,
0.0159012564,
-0.0024348362,
0.081364885,
-0.0279173031,
-0.0471407585,
0.0298906937,
-0.0328203961,
-0.0289377775,
-0.0372386798,
0.0524416044,
0.0377024412,
0.0205399729,
-0.0147558898,
0.0347565301,
0.0137753449,
-0.0134018399,
-0.0048838225,
-0.0340664573,
0.0164677445,
0.0097190551,
0.0106726075,
0.0401929729,
-0.0361170359,
0.0343462676,
0.0382535756,
-0.054203365,
-0.0006053728,
-0.0057575726,
2.318e-7,
0.0329094157,
-0.0197335817,
0.0520441271,
-0.0183497835,
0.0261463206,
0.0088229021,
-0.0140252635,
0.0488830172,
-0.0235976651,
0.0132443011,
0.0740845725,
0.0099588698,
0.0927131101,
-0.0198756084,
-0.0909933895,
0.0145066679,
-0.062865302,
0.0099543398,
-0.0573554225,
0.0275146551,
0.0610867031,
0.1303821653,
-0.0073727961,
0.0428572409,
-0.0342031196,
0.0010898893,
0.0623627976,
-0.0330156498,
-0.0201611947,
0.0033957378,
-0.0422896445,
0.0418501198,
-0.0318631902,
-0.0061311158,
-0.0403637178,
0.0689636692,
0.0313424654,
0.0822263286,
0.0003935903,
0.0107671125,
0.0128648272,
-0.0042853151,
-0.0413267873,
-0.0481331907,
0.0811368898,
-0.0632717237,
-0.0511152372,
0.0150157521,
0.0018990469,
0.030735204,
0.0399918817,
0.0326035991,
-0.026740158,
0.0161514264,
0.0672463998,
0.0096345078,
-0.0191564616,
-0.0604308583,
-0.0130217103,
0.0278686564,
-0.0127693154,
-0.0046901824,
-0.0143850558,
0.0019875087,
0.0773499906,
0.0149770463,
-0.0031433243,
1.691795806e-34,
-0.0049203318,
0.0120722335,
0.048539374,
0.0085429205,
0.021742858,
-0.044627469,
0.0170479659,
-0.0177631602,
0.0314481892,
-0.0404817425,
0.0095664766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09743v2 | Capturing Perspectives of Crowdsourced Annotators in Subjective Learning Tasks | 2023-11-16T10:18:32 | 2024-05-16T06:01:26 | Negar Mokhberian, Myrl G. Marmarelis, Frederic R. Hopp, Valerio Basile, Fred Morstatter, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised classification heavily depends on datasets annotated by humans.
However, in subjective tasks such as toxicity classification, these annotations
often exhibit low agreement among raters. Annotations have commonly been
aggregated by employing methods like majority voting to determine a single
ground truth label. In subjective tasks, aggregating labels will result in
biased labeling and, consequently, biased models that can overlook minority
opinions. Previous studies have shed light on the pitfalls of label aggregation
and have introduced a handful of practical approaches to tackle this issue.
Recently proposed multi-annotator models, which predict labels individually per
annotator, are vulnerable to under-determination for annotators with few
samples. This problem is exacerbated in crowdsourced datasets. In this work, we
propose \textbf{Annotator Aware Representations for Texts (AART)} for
subjective classification tasks. Our approach involves learning representations
of annotators, allowing for exploration of annotation behaviors. We show the
improvement of our method on metrics that assess the performance on capturing
individual annotators' perspectives. Additionally, we demonstrate fairness
metrics to evaluate our model's equability of performance for marginalized
annotators compared to others. | [
0.0349244624,
0.0445988514,
0.0046865693,
0.0058544548,
0.0129143661,
0.0194698684,
0.0150723262,
-0.0249796826,
0.0128140654,
-0.0887134373,
-0.0573474728,
0.0279677454,
-0.0407459065,
-0.0697818771,
-0.0023578212,
-0.0318466425,
-0.0190144591,
0.0297901798,
0.0506258346,
-0.0084360205,
0.0644597411,
0.0000714223,
0.0199041143,
0.0722343996,
-0.0368708931,
0.0016904761,
0.0412158705,
-0.0251504183,
0.03716553,
-0.0236747004,
0.0383672677,
0.0498096235,
-0.0109158857,
0.0424218588,
0.0000017757,
-0.0026038866,
-0.0346002057,
0.0295669865,
0.0090263532,
-0.0205457956,
0.0632553399,
0.0283151641,
0.0276037399,
0.0352295414,
-0.0379288122,
-0.0042703883,
0.0370645821,
0.0184295569,
0.0711969733,
-0.0090125836,
-0.006130653,
0.024490675,
-0.043335434,
-0.0030195506,
0.0228604805,
-0.0013847543,
0.007022805,
-0.0133537278,
-0.0448090732,
0.0000912338,
-0.0106326742,
0.0126060592,
0.0137753086,
0.0073688794,
0.0543688312,
-0.0081266873,
-0.0546048507,
-0.0314028785,
-0.0006453876,
0.074627094,
0.0238849819,
-0.0198521744,
-0.0141698327,
-0.0222255122,
0.0509609729,
0.0029643341,
-0.0222812705,
0.0176005363,
-0.022288572,
0.0281117577,
-0.045169834,
0.090410769,
0.0141854165,
0.010211545,
0.0408456363,
0.0374037623,
-0.0316335633,
-0.0187595636,
0.0281686839,
0.0538556017,
-0.0169242509,
0.0116822459,
0.0277153812,
-0.020785721,
0.0078805629,
-0.0046999389,
-0.0069884653,
-0.0420417897,
0.0420847014,
-0.0943469256,
0.0224380773,
-0.0291546453,
-0.0665700436,
0.0424223207,
0.0107694082,
-0.0480211154,
0.0317178555,
0.0672167093,
-0.025371965,
0.0043186313,
-0.0362022184,
0.0313099883,
0.0128873745,
0.0179787837,
0.0081661604,
0.0440516621,
-0.0326606818,
-0.0122862337,
-0.0853582472,
-0.0465573408,
0.0326549076,
0.0432200655,
0.0099836914,
0.0312891416,
-0.0574591868,
0.0244824886,
-0.0201795585,
0.0297674555,
-0.0257838406,
-0.0211275332,
0.0201343447,
0.0303840842,
-0.0103758704,
-0.0070514353,
0.0027293251,
0.0453018025,
0.0524089634,
-0.0041240649,
-0.0308912843,
-0.0504442453,
-0.0236999877,
-0.0187076647,
-0.0105839018,
-0.0260321572,
0.0291682072,
-0.0134405708,
0.0233424585,
-0.030839026,
-0.0029088617,
0.0062637324,
0.0092518479,
0.0901308656,
-0.0079239169,
-0.0543593131,
0.0377608314,
0.0208724178,
-0.0416660048,
0.0495375469,
0.0146486657,
0.0434404314,
0.0259163529,
0.0202539712,
0.0337942764,
-0.0241220929,
0.0374529734,
-0.005992583,
0.0240180027,
-0.0179527737,
-0.0294131059,
0.000065274,
-0.0016021738,
0.0582150668,
-0.0062354803,
-0.0440251566,
0.0348499306,
0.0304906256,
-0.0406498238,
-0.0164933614,
0.008869376,
0.0232302528,
-0.0052962881,
-0.0044248421,
-0.0439559072,
0.0573806055,
-0.0218338389,
-0.0384040065,
0.0597593524,
-0.0114687718,
-0.0029633932,
-0.0872771293,
-0.0279864743,
-0.0131631112,
0.0312202517,
0.0108016832,
0.0076138079,
-0.0069825943,
0.0048555722,
-0.0053053326,
0.055701755,
-0.0564502291,
-0.0080669671,
-0.0362132899,
0.0269566197,
0.0419441015,
0.0059481203,
-0.0479554012,
0.0034753983,
-0.0464540087,
-0.0033465,
-0.0268131141,
0.0298844855,
-0.0257971231,
-0.0351333134,
-0.0152040944,
-0.0735583231,
0.0082624573,
0.0176285114,
0.0060969782,
-0.0247621909,
-0.0141682606,
0.0006324416,
-0.0527394116,
-0.0850471109,
0.0399734229,
0.0673112124,
-0.0239751507,
-0.0087964041,
0.0361626856,
0.0518972799,
0.010434879,
-0.0046972409,
0.0098735821,
0.0135817695,
-0.0252230968,
-0.042674996,
0.0024258427,
0.0069104149,
0.0015483581,
0.0205039568,
-0.0549698621,
-0.0183067545,
0.0030237385,
-0.0283391792,
0.0044015544,
-0.0421385914,
-0.0380907468,
-0.0332892835,
-0.0236464906,
-0.0418672301,
0.0042321603,
-0.022093324,
-0.0477259122,
0.0304257479,
-0.0104115214,
-0.0042797909,
-0.0420768969,
-0.0768400431,
0.0256089624,
-0.0064365868,
-0.0605269633,
-0.0476875715,
0.0303584784,
0.0512257293,
0.0508926287,
-0.0241974425,
-0.0193777513,
0.0114716487,
-0.1012284607,
-0.0222892705,
-0.0191176068,
-0.011199547,
-0.026753189,
-0.0501474403,
0.0427796617,
-0.0339962803,
-0.0702069476,
-0.0427316874,
-0.0517099351,
0.0434125848,
0.0150723765,
-0.0003982086,
0.0449842028,
-0.0460746326,
-0.0231632441,
-0.0397490002,
0.0369801968,
0.052036114,
-0.0364449061,
-0.0093554743,
-0.0647674799,
-0.0308159404,
0.0206482895,
0.0092891306,
-0.0030132241,
0.0382381417,
0.0149667514,
-0.0393137373,
0.0796700865,
0.0238150675,
0.0715948492,
0.0692273155,
0.0537663549,
-0.0407295637,
-0.008047441,
-0.0280035008,
-0.0119917272,
0.0211978666,
-0.0376447998,
-0.0005722348,
0.0571079031,
-0.0150781823,
-0.0251223445,
-0.0822187588,
0.014624388,
-0.0586846657,
-0.037396282,
-0.0618045144,
-0.0056334375,
-0.0104352469,
0.0081464928,
-0.0014474669,
-0.0527669266,
0.0909229666,
0.0157598518,
0.0425016992,
-0.0349344984,
0.0336651318,
-0.0231930856,
0.0040153242,
0.0136307068,
0.014690117,
0.0141718471,
0.0646987036,
-0.0023251763,
0.0249003284,
0.0687274039,
-0.0505160987,
-0.008839434,
-0.0343657136,
-0.0165513605,
-0.0114109181,
-0.0567678958,
-0.0000770678,
-0.0571003929,
-0.0416964702,
0.0051821964,
0.0154166501,
-0.0047968519,
-0.0191393681,
0.005444055,
-0.007400115,
-0.0092990138,
0.0032694768,
-0.025510462,
0.0396747962,
-0.0107806278,
0.0201353766,
-0.0128724268,
0.0323533677,
-0.0260898452,
-0.0228178576,
0.0926922262,
0.0249618664,
0.0103511577,
0.0069696726,
-0.0188296065,
0.0050694146,
0.0152169159,
0.0076151798,
-0.0116993608,
0.042766083,
-0.0270168129,
0.0362520777,
0.0507517532,
0.0319737606,
-0.0561695024,
0.0166583378,
0.0062872702,
0.0334448107,
0.0270791743,
-0.0288114659,
-0.0614274219,
-0.0260594636,
-0.0439405963,
0.0742790103,
-0.0427514687,
-0.0318620987,
0.0343580469,
-0.0836720616,
0.0159131121,
0.0033230472,
-0.0420844518,
0.0352095515,
-0.0418047756,
-0.0019700509,
-0.0805969834,
-0.0070393761,
-0.0477257222,
0.0676245093,
0.0235786904,
0.0525311604,
-0.0469691791,
0.0046796743,
0.0326793119,
-0.0340520069,
0.0677828938,
0.0107833659,
0.0263263639,
0.0027468612,
-0.06063319,
0.0265003424,
0.0087408656,
-0.0071408879,
0.0087003186,
0.0991711318,
-0.0314137265,
-0.0169522744,
-0.0347556658,
0.0407510139,
-0.0147491125,
0.0117263207,
-0.0309604798,
0.0525396839,
0.0336330906,
-0.0075774863,
-0.0631651878,
0.0095743416,
0.0108870519,
0.0511453748,
0.0288754739,
-0.066396825,
-0.0155433044,
-0.0396643318,
0.0061449725,
-0.0276769567,
-0.0840436965,
0.050520882,
-0.0151166478,
-0.0764279887,
-0.0469259508,
-0.039582856,
0.022892803,
0.0157202948,
-0.0189852472,
-0.0042718742,
0.0229220148,
0.0030278326,
-0.0240692943,
0.0884895399,
0.0276485961,
0.015426686,
-0.0070738341,
-0.0513346866,
0.0416807979,
0.0116545539,
-0.0504800864,
0.0465265438,
-0.0306812469,
-0.0309160966,
0.0232466869,
0.0803679079,
0.0052313977,
-0.0050478517,
-0.0087211961,
-0.0576028153,
0.0200663731,
0.0743517503,
0.001401617,
-0.0282715727,
0.0224604551,
0.0256147329,
-0.0128606232,
0.0110193873,
-0.0474004224,
0.027708048,
0.0036723011,
-0.0360384248,
-0.0615297072,
-0.0066092024,
0.0467330366,
0.0167954899,
0.0856171623,
-0.0149132414,
-0.0022391493,
-0.0035030497,
-0.0306714084,
0.0351597555,
-0.053238675,
-0.009523578,
0.0020994565,
-0.0009811179,
-0.0354565792,
-0.054809425,
0.019289311,
0.0309929084,
0.0292118937,
-0.038332466,
0.012219023,
0.0581682436,
-0.0053240648,
-0.0177815165,
0.0164393783,
-0.0170173571,
-0.0009594823,
0.003747433,
0.0137026459,
0.0281512868,
-0.0032888632,
0.0087861298,
0.0378688276,
0.0091727441,
0.0303679444,
-0.0328162983,
-0.0087904837,
-0.0453315265,
0.0399477072,
-0.0233309623,
0.0085159838,
0.0226233378,
0.0156521685,
-0.0187144969,
-0.017671125,
-0.0084501859,
-0.0098444102,
0.0226094387,
0.0350264944,
0.008779672,
-0.024865929,
-0.0179702472,
0.0591578521,
0.0023516845,
0.0257497784,
-0.0586454123,
-0.0613851063,
-0.0282006543,
0.0219814256,
-0.0037415798,
0.01754063,
0.0091213519,
-0.0126389097,
-0.0647715777,
-0.027118478,
0.020958107,
0.0328963101,
0.0217150431,
0.0126217678,
-0.0037771512,
0.0273802076,
-0.0307132639,
-0.0339177847,
-0.0218977351,
-0.0239055026,
0.0026139833,
0.0042327037,
-0.0090069035,
-6.083849257e-33,
-0.0187223181,
-0.0377478078,
-0.0606953949,
0.0378784128,
0.0245551504,
-0.0173740853,
0.028113775,
0.0250924639,
0.0076964968,
0.0518940985,
0.0366255119,
0.0064377855,
0.0031824606,
-0.0064456901,
0.0501244217,
-0.0510221906,
0.0383863263,
-0.0117806224,
-0.0144872107,
0.0237564389,
0.0244152937,
-0.0236665569,
0.024946088,
-0.1520620286,
0.0854926407,
0.0276101455,
-0.029737236,
0.0073234192,
-0.0461923406,
0.0601220019,
0.0114011671,
0.1094826907,
0.0203246605,
-0.0153292678,
-0.0099911662,
0.0000889654,
-0.0317358635,
0.0113908602,
-0.0306381118,
0.0040865112,
-0.0458603501,
-0.0192372501,
0.0826870576,
0.0320812613,
-0.0338030681,
-0.0021094189,
0.0730179995,
-0.0107046068,
0.0137945237,
-0.0641837269,
0.0073480252,
0.029698465,
-0.0133119039,
-0.0101025607,
0.0340361372,
0.0021180038,
0.0139177386,
0.0533661172,
-0.0580794886,
-0.0004427972,
-0.0528403483,
-0.0171865579,
0.0012952007,
0.0026531981,
-0.0064764633,
0.074180454,
0.0133127607,
0.0387507342,
-0.0218301378,
-0.0543432347,
-0.0273260567,
0.0191858653,
0.0790378898,
0.0929129049,
0.0340462513,
0.0146559672,
-0.0274667609,
0.0407620147,
0.0018185145,
-0.0245170649,
0.0028405758,
0.0088106785,
-0.0671184659,
-0.0135864643,
-0.0280266386,
-0.0547467992,
-0.0341352448,
0.036618948,
-0.0035876571,
-0.0043803263,
-0.0403561667,
0.0145548293,
-0.0292564481,
-0.0355628617,
-0.0103857741,
-0.0066712913,
0.0043284609,
0.0357870199,
-0.0013069565,
-0.0350968651,
-0.0524233207,
0.0464323722,
-0.0008349523,
-0.003736699,
0.0374954678,
-0.0123881986,
0.1012648568,
-0.0134333717,
-0.0529057086,
-0.0104848873,
-0.0115447836,
-0.0093075493,
0.0219525378,
-0.0002990395,
0.0318728723,
0.0285507236,
-0.0180444978,
0.021635158,
-0.0164603051,
0.0536806099,
-0.0062246914,
-0.0184798576,
-0.0211425871,
-0.0352820121,
0.0234781224,
-0.0229219384,
0.0510139354,
-0.0104321726,
0.004110489,
-0.0374947526,
-0.0054554171,
-0.031203039,
2.461e-7,
0.0740979463,
0.0225569755,
-0.0054400652,
-0.0760194585,
-0.0077842488,
0.062797524,
0.0352745578,
0.030752426,
-0.0026341691,
-0.0688146651,
-0.0099598616,
0.0340740941,
0.020703461,
0.0627422929,
-0.0380337574,
-0.0371223018,
-0.052124016,
0.0210857056,
0.0079349745,
-0.0013055641,
0.0637705028,
0.0637682974,
0.035009481,
-0.0079390965,
0.0293820538,
0.0060180752,
0.0486467332,
-0.0353540517,
0.001809322,
0.0082134074,
0.0706759617,
-0.0233972501,
0.0072010471,
0.0167679526,
-0.0165284034,
-0.0290762465,
0.0317455307,
0.0136121502,
-0.0215077214,
-0.0615173429,
0.013343689,
0.0390174836,
0.0256446917,
0.0021366384,
0.037259642,
-0.0133588463,
-0.0242242012,
-0.0572868064,
0.0188416895,
-0.0028557016,
0.0758610517,
0.0009045644,
-0.0107568894,
0.0110867899,
-0.0032450114,
0.004063121,
-0.0072079711,
-0.0855158493,
-0.0444879234,
-0.0186603796,
-0.01612949,
-0.0585027821,
-0.0049949205,
0.0376039781,
-0.0200182479,
-0.0315874368,
0.0265388638,
1.57715549e-34,
0.0399177074,
0.001121017,
0.0233478192,
-0.0033259389,
0.0112487916,
0.0281426497,
-0.0054458808,
-0.0363956802,
0.017700579,
-0.0019817925,
0.0009547584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09741v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09741v2 | P^3SUM: Preserving Author's Perspective in News Summarization with Diffusion Language Models | 2023-11-16T10:14:28 | 2024-04-04T09:10:34 | Yuhan Liu, Shangbin Feng, Xiaochuang Han, Vidhisha Balachandran, Chan Young Park, Sachin Kumar, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this work, we take a first step towards designing summarization systems
that are faithful to the author's intent, not only the semantic content of the
article. Focusing on a case study of preserving political perspectives in news
summarization, we find that existing approaches alter the political opinions
and stances of news articles in more than 50% of summaries, misrepresenting the
intent and perspectives of the news authors. We thus propose P^3SUM, a
diffusion model-based summarization approach controlled by political
perspective classifiers. In P^3SUM, the political leaning of a generated
summary is iteratively evaluated at each decoding step, and any drift from the
article's original stance incurs a loss back-propagated to the embedding
layers, steering the political stance of the summary at inference time.
Extensive experiments on three news summarization datasets demonstrate that
P^3SUM outperforms state-of-the-art summarization systems and large language
models by up to 13.7% in terms of the success rate of stance preservation, with
competitive performance on standard metrics of summarization quality. Our
findings present a first analysis of preservation of pragmatic features in
summarization, highlight the lacunae in existing summarization models -- that
even state-of-the-art models often struggle to preserve author's intents -- and
develop new summarization systems that are more faithful to author's
perspectives. | [
0.0423854366,
0.0552933402,
0.0460574776,
0.0086979782,
-0.0209504515,
-0.001246984,
-0.023778541,
-0.0628436804,
-0.0173034407,
-0.0251704641,
0.0402564667,
-0.0260421634,
0.0223278906,
-0.0040170844,
-0.039940957,
-0.0792380944,
0.0424442962,
0.0306180939,
0.0252379272,
-0.0211613383,
0.0630673766,
0.0341239199,
0.0247063842,
0.0331629515,
0.0122965025,
-0.010188763,
-0.000561316,
0.0178853739,
0.077168338,
-0.0001781935,
-0.0172755513,
0.0104306899,
0.0331625938,
0.0057174517,
0.0000017355,
-0.003363146,
-0.0489542596,
-0.0229766425,
0.0574450791,
0.0036502804,
0.1022336185,
-0.0692460537,
-0.0070779412,
0.0096830307,
-0.0313396826,
0.0144048799,
0.021538401,
0.0612955987,
0.0946487933,
0.0699679926,
-0.002664417,
-0.0563567691,
-0.001091394,
-0.0078720618,
-0.0347621404,
-0.0277392454,
0.0293653123,
0.0367091075,
-0.0721147731,
0.0153121846,
-0.0332935676,
0.0148204202,
-0.003156357,
0.0049123294,
-0.0163988229,
0.0165067688,
0.0396284685,
-0.0099674454,
0.0020894348,
0.0389458612,
0.0196108706,
-0.0335035659,
0.0430174321,
-0.0109260138,
-0.0098576518,
0.0357262045,
-0.0315856151,
0.0372431017,
-0.0244651493,
0.0397518277,
0.0364696681,
0.0091305058,
-0.0059376662,
0.0499518402,
-0.0231044628,
0.0327035785,
-0.0148449019,
-0.006536467,
-0.0201275814,
0.0007088937,
0.0097453659,
-0.0352205187,
0.040360257,
0.001273458,
0.0442058221,
0.0126584787,
-0.0514584966,
-0.0138693815,
0.0052172802,
-0.0855420604,
-0.0305149965,
0.0114500299,
0.0404508188,
0.0550670847,
0.0240049008,
-0.0498660952,
-0.0010508173,
-0.0131625719,
-0.0498151667,
-0.0005386474,
-0.0137977516,
0.0083115147,
-0.0072029079,
0.0357006788,
-0.0243521165,
-0.0279832929,
-0.0376683511,
0.0190444868,
0.0127262119,
-0.0143180629,
-0.004733006,
0.0267078839,
0.0009720338,
-0.002294424,
-0.0134791695,
0.0812127963,
-0.0275211241,
-0.0117844734,
-0.0084318621,
0.0537593774,
-0.0103403451,
0.017215915,
-0.0103698857,
0.0187954009,
-0.0091129579,
-0.018576825,
-0.0216563288,
-0.0161107741,
0.0173179265,
-0.0201697182,
-0.0396738127,
-0.0416953973,
0.0061068605,
-0.0653000176,
0.0120649897,
-0.0095281079,
-0.00454028,
-0.0740990266,
0.011324984,
0.0436729044,
-0.0472796597,
0.0456274524,
0.0070345169,
-0.011440496,
0.0374991484,
0.0236274432,
0.0170897637,
0.089269869,
0.0383258797,
0.0350820646,
0.0340796299,
0.0022045805,
-0.0250130091,
-0.0097968783,
0.0091152079,
0.0224484485,
0.0068691019,
-0.0161310676,
-0.0535027459,
-0.0221564155,
0.0484327041,
0.0695937052,
-0.0057739406,
-0.0160085708,
0.0710289776,
0.0624950342,
-0.0298029389,
0.0112420656,
0.0109789241,
0.0378530957,
0.0286108237,
0.0684193969,
0.0272756554,
0.0179130677,
-0.0148155848,
0.0057841507,
0.038315516,
0.0550183691,
-0.0151024461,
-0.0457552895,
0.0070277932,
-0.0076366914,
0.0864029527,
-0.0124228448,
0.0030136609,
-0.0025416627,
-0.0343770422,
0.0381355323,
0.0091422414,
-0.0692409575,
0.0241744705,
-0.0191418305,
0.0349518321,
0.0384424031,
0.0205918048,
-0.0204442218,
-0.0109442184,
-0.02997851,
0.0159296934,
0.0185418893,
0.06890852,
-0.0341664664,
-0.0424000695,
-0.0263183974,
-0.0289803706,
0.0044110226,
0.0200280417,
0.023828635,
-0.0243324134,
0.0112799639,
0.0253072176,
0.0234885328,
-0.025066616,
0.0069855028,
-0.0149842137,
0.0012605737,
-0.0021888064,
-0.0117745185,
0.0043976642,
0.0806099847,
-0.0095643643,
-0.023167599,
0.0432727113,
-0.0083532762,
-0.034577325,
0.0363360532,
-0.0503067337,
-0.0296486616,
0.0249734558,
-0.057537023,
-0.007471439,
0.0188595094,
-0.02639178,
-0.0348668322,
0.0493494458,
-0.0321692973,
-0.003510213,
-0.0613775849,
-0.0170087032,
-0.0150891468,
0.0100504393,
-0.0350980721,
0.083128117,
-0.0075082062,
-0.0357379802,
0.0506253988,
-0.0529608801,
-0.0095017562,
0.0306345057,
-0.0082708579,
0.0137309702,
0.0483350977,
0.0367115811,
0.0640468597,
-0.0494056419,
-0.0224661548,
-0.0352168307,
-0.0719513148,
0.0219032839,
-0.0402755328,
0.0173817147,
0.0620186478,
0.0127481241,
0.0042563174,
0.0192051455,
-0.0359862223,
-0.0637245327,
-0.0174388438,
0.0145731252,
0.0102195088,
0.0037964447,
0.0232875235,
-0.0335084647,
0.0077774432,
-0.0226317551,
0.0191857554,
-0.0072688158,
-0.0363947004,
-0.0298703946,
-0.012323183,
-0.0426396765,
-0.0431382582,
-0.0315595232,
0.0209597573,
-0.0220758729,
0.0156500302,
0.0108052911,
0.0582575761,
0.0468629748,
0.0538969114,
0.0387954973,
0.0123833278,
-0.0417369716,
-0.0228807908,
-0.0597232357,
0.0664490312,
-0.0082167536,
-0.036896091,
0.0119305933,
0.0431628823,
0.0145654837,
0.0057394551,
-0.0362945385,
0.0588419735,
-0.0313135572,
-0.0197044369,
0.0260670073,
-0.0173951723,
0.0038138672,
-0.0193693116,
-0.030992737,
0.0282586645,
0.0645658597,
-0.0078259651,
0.0666963309,
-0.0819451809,
-0.0135684712,
-0.0435887277,
0.0256221704,
-0.0136965141,
0.0253268834,
-0.0281590279,
0.0099169742,
-0.0199307557,
-0.0532986745,
0.048336111,
-0.0308320019,
0.0638921484,
-0.036417339,
0.0264529809,
-0.0075635794,
0.000333428,
0.0031008422,
-0.0952196941,
-0.0124849705,
0.0169750806,
0.0211197883,
-0.0109915799,
0.020955598,
0.0391847827,
0.054174345,
-0.0005779351,
-0.0261508711,
0.0032613305,
-0.0030159736,
0.0252878945,
0.0530081801,
-0.0004578391,
0.0258995052,
-0.017620977,
0.0039409362,
0.0556443296,
0.0055268542,
0.0117660817,
-0.0114445258,
-0.0337186418,
-0.0113347881,
-0.0703738108,
-0.0092555396,
-0.0618738979,
0.0821060836,
-0.0363441408,
0.0291278958,
0.0938938558,
0.034526635,
-0.0612887107,
-0.0260348506,
0.0238921754,
-0.0038538505,
-0.0078680683,
-0.03031433,
-0.0724496022,
0.0027982597,
-0.0094405785,
0.0156834144,
-0.0011635131,
-0.0227515791,
-0.0256826282,
-0.0534473136,
-0.020839924,
0.0097910389,
-0.037436191,
-0.011483605,
-0.0705252215,
0.0134474644,
-0.0194833614,
-0.0039421152,
0.0001096355,
-0.0213333201,
0.0144888731,
0.0052111167,
-0.0633169785,
-0.0199620314,
-0.0390045606,
-0.0176667683,
-0.0165110771,
0.069023937,
0.0570893846,
0.0037704541,
0.0097074285,
0.0497110002,
-0.0303974953,
-0.024926113,
-0.0187872387,
0.0536568128,
-0.0511276126,
0.0191764347,
-0.0066771945,
0.0528272465,
0.0326130353,
-0.0151481573,
-0.0119249653,
0.0182415247,
0.0068594948,
-0.0305177178,
-0.0534257814,
0.06435664,
0.0110640703,
0.0779264644,
0.0446931906,
-0.0367014706,
-0.0319588743,
-0.0559412204,
0.0164693985,
-0.0600975119,
-0.0399975143,
-0.0171123054,
-0.0432807617,
-0.0133100171,
-0.0700588971,
-0.0853854418,
-0.0169061907,
-0.0171603672,
-0.0083699906,
0.0203326419,
0.0557394326,
-0.0004678761,
-0.03695013,
-0.0356156677,
0.0019808391,
0.001910475,
0.0559980385,
-0.0209463444,
0.0436179154,
-0.008712492,
-0.0242894571,
-0.0090782065,
-0.0593822785,
-0.0627325922,
0.002180042,
0.0189861674,
0.0168868229,
0.0569056682,
-0.0050269803,
-0.0046343314,
0.0615171827,
0.0505524278,
0.0513601527,
0.0419894606,
0.0123866713,
0.0443180799,
-0.0033855191,
0.0201955177,
-0.0202646572,
0.0228832252,
-0.0140885776,
-0.0063144751,
-0.0769074485,
-0.0129135605,
0.0146564739,
-0.0087046055,
-0.001335801,
0.0037644529,
-0.0241694208,
-0.0354809351,
-0.0210641623,
-0.0581756048,
-0.0229201633,
-0.0145505229,
0.0280805696,
0.0207408015,
-0.0449337848,
-0.0352429971,
0.0753162503,
-0.0149508817,
0.0460197516,
-0.0423589982,
0.0336681567,
-0.0174456313,
0.0051511503,
-0.0500894934,
-0.0102569107,
-0.0559439845,
-0.0129592838,
-0.0207915287,
-0.0003406841,
-0.0062298183,
-0.0119375754,
0.0316815637,
-0.006786502,
0.0072743818,
0.0209678672,
-0.1015158892,
0.0037522782,
-0.0413929746,
0.0156974904,
0.0468127057,
-0.0129655916,
0.0745841935,
0.0090629309,
-0.0161500797,
-0.0143531002,
0.0184895527,
0.030615991,
-0.0172005985,
0.0012341549,
0.007057955,
-0.0156910382,
0.0158227384,
0.0449778177,
-0.0574104264,
0.0258725081,
0.0442225821,
-0.0496095307,
-0.0359302051,
-0.0437073745,
-0.0247266535,
0.0238321684,
0.0031960402,
-0.029248286,
-0.0693888366,
-0.0181952883,
0.0418290868,
0.0153001957,
0.0290196501,
-0.0236129891,
-0.0124806669,
0.0462722331,
0.0054043038,
0.0211326331,
-0.0707577392,
0.0200349186,
-0.0562774912,
-0.0018181329,
0.0070427251,
-5.787009015e-33,
-0.0202749725,
0.0141536128,
-0.0260731596,
0.0215249956,
-0.0583052896,
0.0188529212,
-0.0466392152,
-0.010475805,
-0.0070935194,
0.0241137259,
-0.0149134006,
0.0431541838,
0.0077926521,
0.0386484973,
-0.0302584749,
0.0135621531,
0.0522069596,
0.0074661886,
-0.0541230291,
0.0391863286,
0.0596469119,
-0.0114817256,
0.0547230467,
-0.0470249951,
0.0496348999,
-0.0160188768,
-0.0423014648,
-0.044766508,
0.0309292637,
0.022999255,
-0.0016720186,
-0.0056007099,
0.0354691967,
-0.0407912508,
-0.0416457728,
0.0473773815,
-0.0575200208,
-0.0091082389,
0.0340362862,
-0.0246226192,
-0.033569742,
-0.0345068946,
0.0589947738,
0.0025695669,
-0.0199070182,
-0.0088842409,
0.0532161333,
-0.040290948,
-0.0007638217,
-0.0749679133,
-0.0244423039,
0.041038312,
-0.0317148082,
0.002207166,
0.001444026,
0.0034318105,
0.0481669158,
0.0309506636,
-0.0742150471,
0.0042168694,
-0.040670123,
0.0245342273,
0.0206055697,
-0.0128175886,
0.0174193215,
0.0835389271,
0.0011826637,
0.0230722539,
-0.066503562,
0.0030892978,
0.0137001565,
-0.0484328531,
0.0144109558,
0.05942275,
0.0485564023,
-0.0189257152,
-0.07724493,
0.0608796999,
0.0460694097,
-0.0213516001,
0.0353912041,
-0.0047626197,
0.0110607501,
-0.0024736468,
-0.0427846462,
-0.0378159583,
0.0011902135,
-0.0279679168,
-0.0574972928,
0.0406103469,
-0.0804778934,
0.0461848006,
0.0234094542,
-0.0629972592,
-0.0144697232,
0.0330968648,
-0.0523488,
0.0173254758,
0.0203115884,
0.0207928549,
-0.0448073782,
0.0331300236,
-0.0169441774,
0.0009695805,
-0.0115728527,
-0.0081697954,
0.065244846,
0.0022334075,
-0.0502731055,
-0.0003347441,
-0.0003096137,
-0.000060544,
-0.0531417094,
0.0532667488,
0.0321387611,
0.0561422147,
0.0056354944,
0.0148297446,
0.026567664,
0.0438626222,
0.0052860882,
0.0011102825,
-0.0006004547,
0.0357877053,
-0.0202337746,
-0.0021796429,
0.0136611825,
0.0483023636,
0.0183730721,
-0.0632516369,
-0.016006032,
0.0041924976,
2.412e-7,
0.0672400519,
0.051268436,
0.032183975,
-0.0029017224,
-0.0153633393,
0.0339485854,
0.0168441143,
0.0636583194,
-0.0269843489,
-0.0608623251,
0.0251065735,
0.0509780236,
0.0103355879,
0.0245498959,
-0.1123076826,
0.0008627189,
-0.0346454233,
0.0011749808,
-0.0182975177,
0.0123612517,
0.0395757593,
0.0366784334,
-0.005847367,
0.0084112585,
-0.0176125485,
0.026551567,
0.0647244602,
-0.0032222543,
-0.0602024905,
0.0310969073,
0.0408822112,
-0.055267334,
-0.0030542943,
-0.02759091,
-0.0143783847,
0.0039335429,
0.0212964863,
0.0555128902,
0.0175447483,
-0.05171334,
-0.0117249219,
-0.0125405109,
0.0230269581,
0.0126058022,
0.0615052097,
-0.0347664133,
0.0012647625,
-0.0817771852,
-0.0776649266,
0.0299481899,
0.0396469347,
0.0155131975,
-0.048460003,
0.0459527448,
-0.0300056078,
-0.0063526328,
0.0063618883,
-0.0707782507,
-0.0215585232,
-0.0295370091,
-0.0140436133,
-0.0340344496,
0.0396314077,
-0.0130435871,
0.0203081798,
-0.0669408739,
0.0131277628,
2.170866462e-34,
0.1036797017,
-0.0230170954,
-0.0509138107,
-0.0353303328,
0.0276692212,
-0.0135610458,
-0.0174721163,
-0.0269594584,
0.0057577631,
-0.0470631346,
-0.0076772543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09736v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09736v2 | CARE: Extracting Experimental Findings From Clinical Literature | 2023-11-16T10:06:19 | 2024-04-24T18:15:36 | Aakanksha Naik, Bailey Kuehl, Erin Bransom, Doug Downey, Tom Hope | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extracting fine-grained experimental findings from literature can provide
dramatic utility for scientific applications. Prior work has developed
annotation schemas and datasets for limited aspects of this problem, failing to
capture the real-world complexity and nuance required. Focusing on biomedicine,
this work presents CARE -- a new IE dataset for the task of extracting clinical
findings. We develop a new annotation schema capturing fine-grained findings as
n-ary relations between entities and attributes, which unifies phenomena
challenging for current IE systems such as discontinuous entity spans, nested
relations, variable arity n-ary relations and numeric results in a single
schema. We collect extensive annotations for 700 abstracts from two sources:
clinical trials and case reports. We also demonstrate the generalizability of
our schema to the computer science and materials science domains. We benchmark
state-of-the-art IE systems on CARE, showing that even models such as GPT4
struggle. We release our resources to advance research on extracting and
aggregating literature findings. | [
0.0121301198,
0.0353771783,
-0.0043789479,
0.0034293558,
-0.0050531789,
0.019171752,
0.0170486271,
0.043117065,
0.0130239241,
-0.004173147,
0.0078504654,
0.0146281533,
0.0080654351,
0.0678974092,
0.025007017,
-0.0183562879,
0.0226655882,
0.0495058931,
0.0551827997,
0.0200791806,
-0.0062759165,
0.0065784017,
-0.0245567299,
0.0386013389,
0.0136957541,
-0.0050123646,
0.0079353666,
-0.0172450636,
0.0419096574,
-0.0659933314,
0.0236249082,
0.0097325882,
-0.0198459458,
-0.0018464538,
0.0000018915,
-0.0428764671,
-0.0491101667,
0.0655500591,
0.0058991369,
-0.0178277642,
0.0177759733,
-0.0221962798,
0.0305937771,
-0.0243821573,
-0.0160884541,
-0.0598240681,
0.0288186036,
0.0336893164,
0.0004254291,
-0.0009316081,
-0.0195224397,
0.0054659708,
0.0464880317,
-0.0232978966,
0.0558481552,
-0.0073095891,
0.0519018732,
0.0041156113,
0.0641246662,
0.0170578491,
0.0463418514,
0.0261361804,
-0.0184409525,
0.0088706082,
0.0166225284,
0.0409976505,
-0.040421363,
-0.0083450973,
0.0116476584,
0.0504939258,
0.0623187646,
0.0051631844,
0.0437072851,
-0.020374693,
-0.0036560034,
0.0359928235,
-0.026110461,
-0.0195432883,
-0.0352466665,
-0.0358492918,
0.0297785513,
0.0022856907,
-0.0122671127,
-0.0440331921,
-0.0224591065,
0.0195542444,
-0.0138707766,
-0.0190364923,
0.003452135,
0.0124940677,
-0.0269690417,
-0.0275312401,
0.0005994781,
-0.0112228477,
0.0042655091,
-0.010958462,
0.0385705642,
-0.0260166004,
0.1095334888,
-0.0149975056,
0.0253060181,
-0.0334737003,
-0.0193942357,
0.0574632175,
0.0069421371,
-0.0584625117,
-0.0296281818,
0.0317592323,
-0.0138983773,
0.0179419536,
-0.0616348013,
-0.0172846392,
0.0248890854,
0.0708384588,
-0.0214755535,
0.0201792922,
-0.0502795056,
-0.011120108,
-0.0329818241,
0.0517718717,
0.006037124,
0.0052146325,
-0.0567561574,
0.0072600343,
-0.017407462,
0.0247356072,
-0.007038272,
0.0370064937,
-0.0392342173,
-0.0230520032,
-0.0129486164,
-0.0087609868,
0.0283749718,
-0.0173737928,
0.0278214347,
0.055321373,
0.057915885,
-0.0136852842,
0.004422856,
-0.060119167,
-0.0246603061,
-0.0330380872,
0.026089834,
-0.0484059565,
0.0700698867,
0.033260759,
0.002919829,
-0.0622343831,
-0.0147991003,
-0.0188586116,
-0.0453482717,
0.0520162061,
-0.0775782838,
-0.047243081,
-0.0110143609,
-0.0046267123,
0.0169361439,
0.0157525018,
0.0396745689,
-0.0310661327,
0.0088134091,
-0.0130484579,
-0.0200188495,
-0.0111963879,
0.0315362662,
-0.0285406932,
0.0097888419,
0.0143182492,
0.0067700874,
0.0351621583,
-0.0658414662,
0.0062390803,
-0.0170774478,
-0.0064762635,
0.0093098013,
0.0614827983,
0.000957409,
0.0333436392,
-0.0247272346,
-0.0187460613,
0.0235369075,
-0.0173914824,
0.0015475017,
0.0239292812,
0.0124875195,
0.024571836,
0.0114006354,
0.0010228751,
-0.0042239269,
-0.0573365837,
-0.0368112326,
0.0013507038,
-0.0355351232,
-0.0272231884,
0.0490456037,
-0.0090289013,
0.019035222,
0.0093127601,
0.0685959309,
0.0022412224,
-0.0267558601,
-0.0126172286,
0.0096878912,
0.0355417617,
0.0371202454,
-0.1106147319,
-0.0494242832,
-0.0246283505,
0.011758727,
-0.0103085339,
-0.0046337382,
-0.0421300679,
0.0259234142,
0.0254206304,
-0.0239921398,
-0.0189437307,
0.0044411779,
-0.0241266917,
-0.022968661,
-0.0316829458,
-0.0784439445,
-0.0669705644,
-0.0302576572,
0.037489403,
-0.054072164,
0.0263536312,
0.0189428125,
-0.0505890436,
0.0402736031,
0.0371871665,
-0.0233289469,
0.0292045996,
0.0799104795,
-0.0598592982,
-0.039274089,
-0.0029475149,
0.0737020895,
-0.0234028623,
0.0066716406,
-0.0803325921,
-0.0193012021,
-0.0557061695,
-0.0614712164,
-0.0111280493,
-0.0308020674,
-0.0011488185,
0.0043045674,
0.0307774041,
-0.0090023009,
0.0215074252,
-0.0280928873,
-0.0574252456,
0.0392845981,
-0.0041350313,
-0.0095769139,
-0.0096936272,
-0.1108427048,
0.0179664083,
0.0032109194,
-0.0247373339,
0.0076875244,
0.0081759654,
-0.0176387914,
0.0067753321,
-0.0193952844,
-0.0435100123,
-0.0027361675,
-0.0599260442,
0.0535231866,
0.043719206,
0.0428100713,
-0.0089759799,
-0.0052588079,
0.010197374,
-0.0185262784,
-0.0277876053,
-0.0291385595,
-0.0307867788,
0.0096149631,
0.0858915523,
0.0621926412,
0.0074126236,
-0.069710806,
-0.0391502231,
-0.0589751005,
0.0797668844,
0.0140741346,
-0.0141479578,
-0.0209725536,
0.012019055,
-0.0115905758,
0.0204812195,
0.0037220074,
0.0383513756,
0.0143967671,
-0.0023475294,
-0.0186225306,
0.0598353669,
-0.0034326375,
0.045738209,
0.0297391172,
-0.0000043162,
-0.0273625236,
0.0061168326,
-0.0719214231,
0.0303706173,
0.0437469035,
-0.0276207346,
0.0185935292,
0.0136170555,
-0.0005178068,
-0.0028500783,
-0.0402190909,
0.0332053378,
-0.0071547064,
-0.0020490303,
-0.0114389919,
0.0343111679,
0.0022596794,
0.0084136864,
0.0016127008,
0.0066569732,
0.1052128077,
0.001717844,
0.0422876664,
-0.0482347272,
0.0435762405,
-0.026258219,
0.0087209353,
0.0078374147,
0.008809479,
0.0363495201,
0.0293907654,
0.0209326353,
0.0134570161,
0.0160914622,
-0.039880313,
0.0578099638,
-0.0165010225,
0.060794197,
0.01019812,
-0.0416474752,
-0.0090515492,
0.0073371241,
0.0104059232,
0.0161578767,
0.0259334799,
0.0014232226,
-0.0487731956,
0.0102818552,
0.0234371722,
0.0427155904,
-0.0146915177,
-0.0253015384,
-0.0277243406,
-0.0206266735,
0.0381603278,
-0.0517807566,
0.0039574648,
-0.0136446189,
0.0213793293,
0.0925784633,
-0.0524877571,
0.0129304025,
-0.0488661751,
0.0182127319,
-0.0250152349,
-0.0610879846,
-0.0046687038,
-0.0113552604,
0.0071991775,
-0.0483936742,
-0.0113383327,
0.0557763167,
0.0366895422,
-0.0535018928,
0.0110731144,
0.0035122503,
-0.015937347,
-0.0120220771,
0.010111982,
-0.091175206,
-0.0053910939,
-0.0532939024,
0.0167899597,
0.0018687104,
-0.0721127018,
0.0136979204,
-0.0318033136,
0.0728484616,
-0.0103207566,
-0.063152723,
-0.0183347091,
-0.0844987109,
0.0258380733,
-0.0517954007,
-0.034597557,
-0.0049945833,
-0.0209997613,
-0.012209299,
0.0243795794,
-0.0257231854,
-0.0864263177,
0.0353905745,
-0.02257571,
0.0606026575,
0.0090621468,
0.0289031751,
-0.0237703864,
0.0108129615,
-0.035041865,
-0.0325836986,
-0.0152096041,
-0.0107172448,
0.1147251502,
0.0002089282,
0.0059399582,
-0.0292698462,
0.0458766222,
-0.0372982509,
-0.0168451294,
0.0356310196,
0.08442121,
-0.0332664326,
0.014411822,
-0.0701381788,
-0.0261902846,
0.0139572471,
0.05877202,
0.0097828005,
-0.0263864584,
-0.0252225865,
0.0207147207,
0.0252832379,
0.0016019511,
-0.0146504678,
0.0421720669,
-0.0726104379,
0.0347038954,
-0.0533447191,
-0.0540576316,
0.0608209744,
-0.0188682452,
0.0093921041,
0.0229005851,
0.044346232,
-0.0211512521,
-0.0572725795,
0.0621283576,
0.0490940921,
0.0082502905,
0.0366154015,
-0.0412864387,
0.0696036667,
0.0126025034,
-0.022245748,
0.019787699,
0.0117798625,
-0.0277823545,
-0.0081255957,
0.0258768611,
0.0258556698,
0.0189026445,
0.006374476,
-0.0310450997,
0.0153673021,
0.0320641026,
-0.0068281828,
-0.0580092259,
-0.0235187337,
-0.0268902369,
-0.0151208816,
-0.0283588637,
-0.01401377,
0.0557498075,
-0.0181615036,
0.0035509211,
-0.0263294149,
-0.0266119447,
0.0484453626,
0.018207537,
0.0484915599,
-0.0173454825,
-0.0399146639,
-0.0306603406,
0.0232671648,
-0.0376210362,
0.0184773616,
-0.0336893015,
0.0231683534,
-0.0219729431,
-0.03261723,
-0.0374395661,
0.0288979206,
-0.0442381129,
0.0271959845,
-0.0807755962,
0.034008272,
0.0042099138,
-0.0060422849,
0.0387518667,
-0.0225873571,
-0.0253821369,
-0.0256970953,
-0.0347339176,
0.0576052107,
-0.0191852283,
0.0133816255,
0.0329613797,
0.0370959453,
-0.0314723626,
0.0732871667,
-0.0288585685,
0.0312399063,
-0.037660297,
-0.0080275498,
-0.0024045352,
0.0174590889,
0.0942907631,
-0.0154900914,
-0.0119142151,
-0.0279495027,
0.042791415,
-0.017712649,
0.0751993358,
0.019222185,
0.0405870304,
-0.0283300951,
-0.0551953614,
0.0664406791,
0.0100166379,
0.0258722939,
-0.0221765228,
-0.0409985073,
-0.0423694327,
-0.032384932,
-0.0020194608,
-0.0066419211,
-0.0344254747,
-0.0587487519,
-0.0911697075,
-0.0122223701,
0.0241303928,
0.030943865,
-0.0380732417,
0.0100301346,
-0.0016395866,
0.0307983663,
0.0423612669,
-0.0574401058,
0.016233746,
0.0042485385,
-0.0222720988,
-0.0546950176,
0.0049063833,
-5.651711452e-33,
0.0116257276,
-0.0083809095,
-0.0179035719,
0.0345046483,
0.0246765167,
0.0147250416,
-0.0436093286,
-0.0251858011,
0.0327035896,
0.0702575594,
-0.0190981086,
0.0085619884,
0.0000446122,
-0.0042828489,
0.0413798131,
-0.007978932,
0.0224790387,
0.0031522312,
-0.0006951306,
0.0455906764,
0.034329474,
0.0113877105,
0.0367776379,
-0.0931339338,
0.027503347,
0.0380443707,
0.0374220051,
-0.0169270877,
-0.0236199517,
0.0802373886,
-0.0326967649,
0.0189277623,
0.0238429066,
-0.0235488843,
-0.0200847927,
-0.057675451,
-0.0899504945,
0.0119878659,
-0.0045199958,
-0.0341922976,
-0.047605969,
0.0208380111,
0.0314561911,
-0.0012736402,
0.0152344601,
-0.0386743397,
0.0494382083,
-0.0404320545,
-0.0264056809,
-0.0519212224,
-0.0527851582,
0.0468410924,
-0.0177794099,
0.0378280468,
0.0196607579,
-0.0131425308,
0.0176962409,
0.0290680621,
-0.0208557118,
-0.0031774959,
0.0081915054,
0.0026252081,
-0.0141425077,
-0.0686591789,
-0.0155332554,
0.075017184,
-0.0117770229,
0.0438225456,
0.0210255273,
0.0081045432,
-0.0134882703,
0.0605358258,
0.0204569064,
0.0079070255,
0.0177396778,
0.0233799461,
-0.1242847145,
0.0535315424,
-0.0672361776,
0.009891198,
0.025011804,
-0.0291139763,
-0.015198092,
-0.0160792787,
-0.0246367622,
0.0057655917,
-0.0127425399,
-0.0199563038,
-0.0020902739,
-0.0401572064,
-0.0563683659,
0.0694810674,
0.0357567109,
0.0019676215,
-0.0330600366,
0.0036054293,
0.0224591922,
0.0264525563,
-0.0229375418,
0.0110704293,
-0.0448506735,
-0.060730923,
0.0075600073,
0.0036393362,
0.057078585,
-0.0099694226,
0.054944519,
-0.015531702,
-0.0382881723,
0.0058517554,
-0.0162097123,
-0.0037078275,
-0.0515476353,
-0.0208265148,
0.0235982221,
0.054410629,
0.0196502078,
0.0459295735,
0.0357150137,
0.0159229878,
-0.053969834,
0.0119584901,
0.0163170099,
-0.0073021855,
0.0144556891,
-0.0161174145,
-0.0078421999,
0.013226063,
0.0259752925,
-0.0126097966,
-0.0135971187,
0.0086613493,
2.686e-7,
0.0961504877,
0.0319710784,
0.0420684032,
0.0201259628,
0.051016897,
0.0043951515,
-0.0032933778,
0.0132513391,
0.0106961448,
-0.0143743632,
0.0472417101,
-0.0127273388,
0.0263308976,
0.0451828539,
-0.0299048796,
-0.0671472698,
0.0038719366,
-0.0557877719,
-0.059664607,
-0.0268501639,
0.0468812808,
0.0087512862,
-0.0217201803,
0.0132726338,
0.004280461,
0.0083641764,
0.0103614051,
-0.0372796692,
0.016333282,
0.0609584078,
0.0028249307,
0.002088075,
0.0260675754,
0.0815901682,
-0.0234489534,
-0.0081175119,
-0.0118769798,
0.0637403578,
-0.0266651697,
0.0274175107,
0.0449614897,
-0.021413045,
0.0717431828,
-0.0068477839,
0.0219458696,
-0.0875807926,
-0.056006182,
0.0021763057,
-0.013992507,
-0.0117108906,
0.0362929851,
-0.0018781482,
0.0315803736,
0.0397388004,
-0.0213370044,
0.0362925269,
-0.0338856131,
-0.0353652015,
0.0136657944,
0.1116825491,
-0.0343909822,
-0.0423726104,
0.0581655838,
-0.0233229827,
-0.0303905085,
-0.0758100152,
-0.0130620617,
2.775072396e-34,
0.0377443545,
0.0047842856,
0.0177645944,
0.0514140092,
0.0311077423,
-0.0335526615,
-0.0157744717,
-0.005739558,
-0.0051749414,
-0.0762344599,
-0.0015993696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09734v1 | Tracking the Newsworthiness of Public Documents | 2023-11-16T10:05:26 | 2023-11-16T10:05:26 | Alexander Spangher, Emilio Ferrara, Ben Welsh, Nanyun Peng, Serdar Tumgoren, Jonathan May | cs.CL | cs.CL | Journalists must find stories in huge amounts of textual data (e.g. leaks,
bills, press releases) as part of their jobs: determining when and why text
becomes news can help us understand coverage patterns and help us build
assistive tools. Yet, this is challenging because very few labelled links
exist, language use between corpora is very different, and text may be covered
for a variety of reasons. In this work we focus on news coverage of local
public policy in the San Francisco Bay Area by the San Francisco Chronicle.
First, we gather news articles, public policy documents and meeting recordings
and link them using probabilistic relational modeling, which we show is a
low-annotation linking methodology that outperforms other retrieval-based
baselines. Second, we define a new task: newsworthiness prediction, to predict
if a policy item will get covered. We show that different aspects of public
policy discussion yield different newsworthiness signals. Finally we perform
human evaluation with expert journalists and show our systems identify policies
they consider newsworthy with 68% F1 and our coverage recommendations are
helpful with an 84% win-rate. | [
0.0210942123,
0.0680443421,
0.0055923164,
-0.007145422,
-0.0337715745,
-0.0085175801,
-0.0208750479,
0.0174987651,
0.0373005904,
-0.0565432422,
0.0152346976,
0.0113586001,
-0.0115280561,
0.0519592427,
-0.0415073037,
-0.0507340729,
0.0423614755,
0.0369776599,
0.0521060638,
0.0300008282,
0.0396915451,
0.0409889407,
-0.0039692451,
0.0318441391,
-0.0311868209,
0.0388169214,
-0.0429370217,
0.0291238129,
0.0283440761,
-0.0281617679,
-0.043777898,
0.049464196,
0.0267368909,
-0.0101358872,
0.0000014233,
-0.0243003834,
-0.0392932743,
0.0067036874,
0.0575251803,
-0.0332618989,
0.0293530002,
-0.067837432,
-0.0265346263,
0.0096308924,
-0.0222352836,
-0.0194489826,
0.0151045732,
-0.0007784082,
0.0567831956,
0.0817694739,
-0.0213594437,
0.0217482802,
0.0216796771,
-0.0425591432,
0.0609480254,
-0.0339066163,
0.0298310835,
-0.0140556088,
-0.0394322686,
-0.0111418348,
0.0336832963,
0.0034474845,
-0.0064973435,
-0.0286783259,
-0.0109151723,
0.0015230349,
-0.0041414411,
-0.0302657187,
0.0188275054,
0.0448801219,
0.0526872501,
-0.0344770178,
0.0673023313,
0.0034623812,
0.018944269,
0.0857720375,
-0.061714869,
0.0116612967,
-0.0210518613,
0.0158984642,
-0.0071184826,
-0.039081879,
0.0284208916,
0.0433396064,
0.0571672618,
0.0548406132,
-0.023359701,
-0.026768541,
0.0194004066,
0.031445913,
0.0521494709,
-0.0659297481,
0.0244428497,
0.0019106579,
0.0062525608,
0.049805399,
-0.0198420454,
0.0274181701,
0.0230675712,
-0.0956506804,
-0.0613207668,
-0.0046038437,
0.0185996648,
0.0766710564,
0.029779166,
-0.0612258837,
0.0225029793,
-0.0245149694,
0.0104346182,
0.0071262391,
-0.0252310913,
0.045547206,
0.0095372666,
0.0361545905,
-0.0311078336,
-0.0221380144,
0.0156950206,
0.0138801429,
-0.0170301571,
0.0559773222,
-0.0268334001,
0.0096598454,
-0.0604539402,
-0.0341578387,
-0.0644653589,
-0.0004170242,
-0.0437270701,
0.0413622372,
-0.0170429219,
0.0680243298,
0.012050407,
0.0189252142,
0.0040113861,
0.0202554762,
-0.0252716728,
0.026634844,
0.0030515324,
-0.0136367148,
-0.0322620049,
-0.0266745426,
0.0104170609,
-0.0295090284,
0.0022173293,
-0.0549227335,
-0.0244679227,
-0.0095671359,
-0.006252123,
-0.0369536616,
-0.0046031354,
0.0225317739,
-0.0591439232,
0.0380922668,
0.0309075527,
0.0057720128,
0.0552099161,
0.0397782736,
0.0149302585,
0.0558725931,
0.0322562344,
0.0784674585,
0.0388062075,
0.0156439953,
0.014976046,
-0.0002548467,
0.0218989253,
0.0466693118,
0.0382884741,
0.0290153418,
-0.0250799861,
0.0010696024,
0.0340967439,
0.0087110698,
-0.014315607,
-0.0049833604,
0.0406824425,
0.0282238442,
0.0052111498,
-0.0078381719,
0.0149410367,
0.0503478646,
-0.0153197115,
-0.0027166442,
-0.0133704618,
0.0265832338,
-0.0533714592,
-0.0279802401,
0.0385261886,
-0.0128581775,
-0.0285341088,
-0.0230637547,
-0.0096657313,
-0.0110788755,
0.0029144012,
0.002978185,
0.0367114171,
-0.0001030533,
-0.0464936867,
0.0529952608,
0.0294990465,
-0.0029753149,
0.0449606366,
-0.0267679002,
0.0475821383,
0.0411040224,
0.0396869928,
0.0057006418,
0.0284526348,
-0.039052289,
0.0179429911,
-0.0042101834,
0.0477184951,
-0.0271445122,
-0.055305589,
-0.0244315024,
-0.01906549,
0.0337145515,
0.0353184193,
0.0444331802,
0.0294325408,
0.0616740771,
0.0207090173,
-0.0427855104,
0.0006585159,
0.0287129395,
0.006659349,
-0.0063820845,
-0.0236073118,
0.0093242349,
0.0125677073,
0.045254603,
0.0132287499,
-0.0059526232,
0.0487800017,
0.0254563093,
-0.0216658581,
-0.0073044747,
0.0147347031,
0.0338446312,
-0.00547801,
-0.059115544,
0.0143456608,
0.0159086958,
-0.030260127,
-0.042992454,
0.0253090952,
-0.02854014,
-0.0240655858,
-0.0362063237,
-0.0133960079,
0.0080779158,
-0.0555332378,
-0.0461764447,
0.0515264645,
-0.0144441556,
0.025511222,
-0.0202178713,
-0.0260327403,
0.0204700828,
-0.0605654344,
-0.0306958687,
-0.0156680755,
-0.0220862627,
0.0398470163,
0.0461002439,
-0.0387511142,
-0.0296616741,
-0.0572239421,
-0.0519519486,
0.0304524619,
-0.0141034974,
0.0275508743,
0.0017576349,
-0.0261639506,
-0.0023205935,
-0.0201631915,
-0.0324721895,
-0.0421611704,
-0.0221002344,
0.0018313751,
-0.0037025374,
0.0317320414,
0.007266752,
-0.0603778698,
-0.0102817863,
-0.0278052855,
0.0471431501,
0.0381658673,
-0.0415654667,
-0.0169598591,
0.0296878219,
-0.0249631871,
-0.0219343826,
-0.0112571707,
0.012471077,
0.0089507429,
0.0098997513,
-0.0539549701,
0.0400780626,
0.0071654012,
0.0752233416,
0.0240554139,
0.02101852,
-0.0698483363,
0.0056789294,
-0.029997794,
0.0579559319,
-0.040027868,
-0.0479655005,
0.0355638787,
-0.0217913836,
0.0010521308,
0.0330273286,
-0.0385328606,
0.0444180891,
0.0029231906,
0.0223556589,
-0.0129813934,
-0.013467202,
0.0342624485,
0.0383321196,
-0.0075124158,
-0.0318166874,
0.0052476781,
0.0007749327,
0.0756297335,
-0.0449409336,
-0.0059833801,
-0.0178314075,
0.0739799216,
-0.0291235615,
0.0217049178,
-0.0354949012,
-0.0087212492,
0.0012145067,
-0.0273819994,
0.0487994626,
-0.0390224494,
0.0322912075,
-0.0403732285,
0.0238089077,
0.0266578775,
-0.0570548922,
0.0009417202,
-0.0802773312,
-0.0268863216,
-0.0237049181,
-0.0217114296,
-0.0365563892,
-0.0560234152,
0.0371395275,
0.0244156066,
0.0397184975,
-0.0042252797,
-0.0212367531,
0.0423379131,
0.0561603531,
0.0269004274,
-0.0275532007,
-0.031638708,
0.0222324729,
-0.0506456569,
0.000894646,
0.0346462987,
0.0851641446,
-0.0092356838,
-0.0247341283,
-0.0073039201,
-0.0403839797,
-0.0247822125,
-0.0192217361,
-0.0151922991,
-0.0457239859,
-0.0033155836,
0.0599701181,
0.0599919222,
-0.0652011409,
-0.019672364,
0.0211644042,
0.0120755462,
0.0097906291,
0.0377988368,
-0.084243834,
0.0204219017,
0.0337594524,
0.0285893101,
-0.0160349514,
-0.0603214093,
-0.018936757,
-0.080502063,
0.0181445405,
-0.0146566927,
-0.0087227281,
-0.0042862017,
-0.1400834918,
0.0273991376,
-0.0429923087,
-0.074240081,
-0.0153846648,
0.0050333859,
-0.0008513032,
0.0035752493,
-0.0428453013,
-0.0651470274,
-0.0146813337,
-0.0152469212,
0.057763733,
0.0524703376,
0.0594182163,
-0.0054259109,
0.0109516392,
0.0059379996,
0.0680400282,
-0.0194823649,
-0.0063429964,
0.0810908601,
-0.0446810387,
0.0437573381,
-0.0334769748,
0.0446692742,
0.0385769941,
-0.0018979394,
-0.004922783,
0.0251130909,
-0.0353464969,
-0.0221230425,
-0.017107496,
0.0163886324,
0.0657302961,
0.081826672,
-0.0014582806,
-0.006393957,
0.0332096703,
-0.0486777574,
0.0354811102,
-0.0134648252,
0.0131784938,
0.0036133942,
-0.0485611297,
-0.0261803251,
-0.0677121505,
-0.0468186811,
-0.0164630301,
0.0354028121,
-0.0021724205,
-0.007176972,
0.0475692488,
-0.0093793999,
-0.0402874798,
0.0433926284,
-0.0008264187,
-0.0029779559,
-0.0035558178,
-0.0257691275,
0.0025947138,
0.0169464853,
-0.0640825704,
0.0172024835,
-0.0381659567,
-0.0183562636,
-0.0067142178,
-0.0202404428,
0.0278962031,
0.0138630634,
-0.05015295,
-0.0311982706,
-0.0046180123,
0.0640240833,
-0.0292854998,
-0.0288180411,
0.0103460951,
-0.0047515468,
0.0104213813,
0.0362517536,
-0.0587969534,
0.0293146577,
-0.0295585562,
0.0078821862,
-0.0438813828,
0.0087989839,
-0.0261468515,
-0.0154082207,
0.0324850678,
0.0070806597,
0.0078186421,
-0.0448591299,
-0.0377763957,
-0.0014407375,
-0.0291339122,
-0.0054142075,
0.0247094575,
0.0306455605,
0.0397411995,
-0.0586772449,
0.0609404407,
-0.0230213664,
0.09239503,
-0.0510738865,
-0.0145463906,
0.0578958988,
-0.0149451373,
-0.031711977,
-0.0111006899,
-0.0210930128,
0.0302103665,
-0.0145880999,
0.0288810953,
0.0110663353,
-0.026201373,
0.0201471373,
-0.013527914,
0.0355620608,
-0.0199615341,
-0.0555778481,
-0.0147547498,
-0.0406027138,
0.0574387796,
0.0574590117,
-0.0128057161,
0.0118879601,
-0.0170194246,
-0.0128385574,
0.0196247865,
-0.0046637706,
0.0589642711,
-0.0128580211,
0.0324427411,
0.0258983839,
-0.0286470838,
0.0448734723,
0.0345168412,
-0.0105491374,
0.0267418176,
0.0024863305,
-0.0626521483,
-0.0268940572,
0.0099284239,
0.0141103044,
0.0756535605,
-0.0192554947,
-0.0646396801,
-0.0513315201,
0.0033117041,
0.0235303044,
-0.0136872688,
-0.0007869122,
0.016724905,
0.00174121,
0.0753446221,
0.0107815182,
0.0365127251,
-0.0524758734,
-0.0471575186,
-0.0719111338,
-0.0491492599,
0.0348342918,
-5.816170826e-33,
-0.0071400222,
-0.0482004024,
-0.0204173829,
0.0094646588,
0.0172736216,
0.0344029516,
-0.0163794216,
-0.019062357,
-0.0351600386,
0.0027642236,
0.0155449398,
0.0368644036,
0.0144595364,
-0.0362747796,
-0.0072015706,
0.0113214143,
0.0475959703,
0.0004446144,
-0.02216384,
0.0041268067,
0.0166484043,
-0.0033646796,
-0.001661933,
-0.0755340159,
0.0692797974,
-0.0027475939,
-0.0637966096,
-0.005870217,
0.0497629009,
0.0371734202,
0.0216148999,
0.0031880927,
0.0456645936,
-0.0451087058,
0.0039938129,
0.1059928387,
-0.083117865,
-0.0138402972,
0.0409311019,
-0.0589563213,
0.0245861132,
0.0224360321,
0.0288492441,
0.0229070242,
0.0136428298,
0.0046003512,
0.0368746519,
-0.0113615328,
-0.0390760414,
-0.0267474372,
-0.0067018853,
0.0524413995,
-0.0103534795,
0.0077574458,
-0.0250739474,
0.0128617799,
0.0121084796,
0.0478122905,
-0.055018153,
-0.0097057922,
-0.03737133,
0.0166442823,
0.0357056484,
-0.059722688,
-0.0202706698,
0.050471779,
-0.0236499589,
0.0280002262,
-0.0323956795,
-0.0050857151,
0.0346431918,
0.0179293696,
0.0055068047,
0.066399917,
0.0415020026,
-0.0383325145,
-0.1096109077,
0.0612200685,
0.0620264933,
0.0002170364,
0.0301197134,
0.0126967551,
-0.0664268509,
0.0035385883,
-0.0555565991,
-0.0362369046,
-0.0260476097,
-0.0490213372,
-0.0191026963,
0.0530859828,
-0.0011759935,
0.0776567459,
-0.0061646402,
-0.0121159907,
-0.0305052251,
0.0512210913,
-0.0488315225,
-0.0018889972,
-0.0010894812,
0.0283934139,
-0.1177060828,
0.0046010064,
0.0164400097,
0.0440824255,
-0.0023784866,
-0.0235495046,
0.0491052195,
-0.0229026899,
-0.0671575963,
-0.0038859278,
0.0220008884,
0.0037403542,
-0.0260830019,
0.0110291187,
0.0181299802,
0.0046878387,
0.019152768,
0.0353715569,
-0.0145225152,
0.0364629887,
0.0136987465,
-0.0299035832,
-0.0481247716,
-0.0068354234,
0.0097472426,
-0.0266726296,
0.0135460189,
0.0162776858,
0.0259601567,
-0.0371803865,
0.0007571849,
-0.0096868966,
2.479e-7,
0.0268551521,
0.043904528,
-0.047524929,
0.023535125,
0.00600872,
0.0124858022,
0.0125383092,
0.0630140454,
-0.0401689336,
-0.0603968278,
0.0015754538,
-0.003101714,
0.0290534198,
0.0566616654,
-0.119827643,
-0.0199430678,
-0.0723282844,
-0.0095709367,
-0.0761457086,
-0.0228247661,
-0.0006129354,
0.0365887806,
0.0585127696,
0.0109755863,
0.0264201183,
-0.0156701785,
0.0156159569,
-0.0245325118,
-0.0668295845,
-0.011926638,
0.0625063479,
0.0142610427,
-0.0303731915,
0.0218420792,
-0.0505210012,
0.0090233237,
-0.0055730753,
0.0761642158,
0.0125190374,
-0.0467141755,
0.0090840226,
-0.0244940519,
0.0000567553,
-0.0017593682,
0.0657672286,
-0.0168255195,
-0.0031507446,
-0.0055561154,
-0.0490861274,
-0.0156576633,
0.0233914834,
0.0122261941,
-0.0153766843,
0.00258032,
-0.0216616467,
-0.0135385934,
0.0296617392,
-0.0466012321,
0.004676729,
0.004358883,
-0.0053687296,
-0.0356846526,
0.0116231386,
-0.0238124207,
-0.0235219318,
-0.0688297972,
0.0259243026,
1.504963492e-34,
0.0241249353,
0.0122407181,
-0.0485038087,
-0.0495476872,
0.0629403666,
0.0225481484,
-0.0463258252,
-0.0440643318,
-0.007536367,
-0.0570272282,
0.0342509523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09733v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09733v2 | MOKA: Moral Knowledge Augmentation for Moral Event Extraction | 2023-11-16T10:04:49 | 2024-05-23T01:53:15 | Xinliang Frederick Zhang, Winston Wu, Nick Beauchamp, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | News media often strive to minimize explicit moral language in news articles,
yet most articles are dense with moral values as expressed through the reported
events themselves. However, values that are reflected in the intricate dynamics
among participating entities and moral events are far more challenging for most
NLP systems to detect, including LLMs. To study this phenomenon, we annotate a
new dataset, MORAL EVENTS, consisting of 5,494 structured event annotations on
474 news articles by diverse US media across the political spectrum. We further
propose MOKA, a moral event extraction framework with MOral Knowledge
Augmentation, which leverages knowledge derived from moral words and moral
scenarios to produce structural representations of morality-bearing events.
Experiments show that MOKA outperforms competitive baselines across three moral
event understanding tasks. Further analysis shows even ostensibly nonpartisan
media engage in the selective reporting of moral events. Our data and codebase
are available at https://github.com/launchnlp/MOKA. | [
0.0213898327,
0.0935722515,
-0.0014850631,
0.0638473704,
-0.0315957889,
0.0197644066,
-0.0210250001,
-0.0232758373,
0.0040646405,
-0.0196957756,
0.0168116074,
0.0191594176,
-0.0530113839,
0.0139671843,
-0.0429425687,
-0.0158920921,
0.0689515471,
0.0561119467,
0.0882144719,
0.0067426637,
0.0117346738,
0.0610897653,
0.0125772981,
-0.009751753,
-0.0040815338,
-0.0080432594,
-0.0056571895,
-0.0190094523,
0.0793214813,
-0.0444818549,
0.0038332986,
0.0379506126,
0.0238990467,
0.0088963257,
0.0000014372,
-0.015333131,
0.000739847,
-0.024069624,
0.0068727825,
0.001844398,
0.0560787171,
-0.0572924055,
-0.0007063856,
-0.046841111,
-0.0417833328,
0.0309200827,
-0.0057902588,
0.072887294,
0.0122520681,
0.1059463173,
0.0102315499,
0.0072793853,
0.0192022659,
-0.0001887708,
0.005221894,
-0.0125260921,
0.0146915633,
0.021602219,
-0.0328985825,
0.0068715014,
-0.0082192738,
0.0041183052,
0.0156351365,
0.0008832025,
-0.0491756238,
-0.0097954664,
-0.0053617163,
0.0015812456,
-0.0277357195,
0.0433135293,
0.0410789065,
-0.0131074265,
0.0715706646,
0.0013395745,
-0.0097211991,
-0.0164569952,
-0.011908819,
0.0470363274,
-0.034765821,
0.0247167703,
0.0447618254,
-0.0013157345,
-0.0024722051,
0.0594799519,
0.0539863855,
0.0041513308,
-0.0165728517,
-0.001968134,
-0.0075618909,
-0.0048424737,
-0.0524828508,
0.0095244423,
0.0393477269,
0.0346013941,
0.0236749128,
0.0376891233,
-0.0182880927,
0.0462130681,
0.0276876129,
-0.0732420161,
-0.0105217192,
0.0046365275,
-0.0189350303,
0.0556571782,
0.0331601351,
-0.0120022027,
-0.0082283923,
0.0378364511,
-0.0114054549,
0.022145031,
-0.0000350985,
0.0397090092,
0.0274742264,
0.0505404063,
-0.0530929975,
0.0384650938,
-0.0140283545,
-0.0121061625,
-0.0104245041,
0.0054848152,
-0.0318236463,
0.0069537987,
-0.0323484614,
-0.0431472696,
-0.0304894838,
0.0228042044,
-0.0697782561,
0.0235957019,
-0.027916465,
0.0189730711,
0.0156045454,
-0.0091547295,
-0.0090260142,
0.0171693359,
0.0157843605,
0.0738186091,
-0.0087005431,
-0.0235627331,
-0.0293148067,
-0.0060179387,
0.0111144176,
-0.0336196795,
0.0017407001,
-0.0261480436,
0.0498298705,
-0.0383821093,
-0.0307647157,
-0.0516306944,
0.0460695922,
0.0300120134,
-0.0324542858,
0.0393260047,
0.0308085158,
-0.0151454359,
-0.0032894695,
0.0442742333,
0.0195649825,
0.0893971249,
0.0370441452,
0.026461523,
0.0908919573,
0.0048242239,
-0.0347662121,
-0.0058228243,
-0.0020433664,
0.0067658662,
-0.0084022246,
0.0040183808,
-0.0479543246,
0.0098521607,
0.0584755018,
-0.0093310913,
0.0111875515,
-0.0528645813,
0.0286918581,
0.0902574435,
-0.0243201498,
0.0043740654,
0.0244707316,
-0.0026525983,
0.0052780937,
0.0384275727,
-0.0536236539,
0.010004811,
-0.0165545586,
-0.0143635962,
-0.0740934312,
0.0728293285,
-0.0056089601,
-0.0213983972,
-0.0094337799,
-0.0200863089,
0.0139152119,
-0.0253058244,
0.0072762994,
0.0099321157,
-0.0192817356,
-0.0193523802,
0.0529289804,
-0.0671640709,
0.0299742687,
-0.0020109077,
0.0825647637,
0.0483935997,
0.074760735,
-0.0285389759,
-0.0188707467,
-0.0312761851,
0.006824601,
0.0176939256,
0.0177593827,
-0.0318332165,
0.0112057822,
-0.0393329896,
-0.0157424659,
-0.0024841218,
0.0045105703,
0.005180622,
0.0262944736,
-0.0126046874,
0.0057092323,
-0.0090752952,
0.0016059314,
0.064506501,
-0.0084829563,
-0.0054701194,
-0.0495065525,
0.0044244933,
-0.0013460941,
0.0068480205,
0.0336638726,
-0.0544248968,
0.0334059,
-0.0157461707,
-0.019531792,
-0.000138414,
-0.0178078506,
-0.0427294038,
0.0171005223,
-0.0700199082,
-0.0467309393,
0.0217935313,
-0.0378984623,
0.0312545002,
-0.0235681459,
0.0308506172,
0.0059513859,
-0.049876336,
-0.0363959037,
-0.0280380398,
0.0063662413,
-0.0122022619,
0.1214471236,
-0.0258451533,
0.0032390531,
-0.0356694311,
-0.0425173827,
-0.0158212539,
0.0108349388,
-0.0087583931,
-0.0046727746,
-0.0062228017,
0.0146517912,
0.0174674354,
0.0017837491,
-0.049550008,
-0.0306478273,
-0.0463337339,
0.0517364219,
0.0041761468,
0.0327143036,
-0.0109705599,
-0.0142173721,
-0.0045735966,
0.0335854702,
-0.0110387653,
-0.0199608877,
-0.0290385243,
-0.0092428345,
0.0344382413,
0.0087566441,
-0.0073695304,
-0.0224637575,
0.0160711352,
-0.0511086583,
-0.0073802234,
0.0155773843,
-0.0246549975,
-0.0122921634,
0.0424970798,
-0.0728266239,
0.0039947871,
-0.0118393684,
-0.0376267843,
-0.0210880097,
0.0251093302,
-0.0160088763,
0.0791398734,
0.0637140647,
0.0533722304,
-0.0255170278,
0.019309286,
-0.0235433187,
-0.0017890411,
-0.0346886218,
0.0396893248,
-0.0492863841,
0.0257113352,
0.0105210645,
0.0576034933,
-0.0145024508,
0.0133183487,
-0.0054800138,
-0.015978124,
-0.0208618324,
-0.0437845923,
0.0270803403,
-0.0331065357,
-0.0247874539,
0.0245381389,
-0.0440226458,
-0.0178974364,
0.0627461374,
0.0525646396,
0.0182126462,
0.0005843551,
0.021833498,
-0.0400134139,
0.0569390878,
-0.0443542264,
0.0030316587,
-0.0423500873,
-0.0586044453,
0.0161347911,
-0.0002316073,
0.0344519988,
-0.0562487319,
0.0779731795,
-0.0165171474,
0.0197734069,
-0.0077845776,
-0.0316702314,
-0.057696037,
-0.0806479082,
0.0059252963,
-0.043801032,
-0.0277508833,
0.0406465009,
0.0265238658,
-0.0201695003,
0.0043670833,
-0.0498400591,
-0.0041334322,
0.0215632338,
-0.0141628981,
0.0115278624,
0.0215641726,
-0.0088864248,
0.0406538583,
0.0254855435,
0.013572582,
0.0384832472,
0.028842805,
0.0177448969,
0.0189259853,
0.0180358309,
0.0042751241,
-0.0403499193,
0.0234657675,
-0.0187537018,
0.0562967658,
-0.0404417887,
0.0269035865,
0.0844806284,
0.0171472337,
-0.0462341867,
0.0297498461,
0.0106497938,
-0.0487522259,
0.0335256308,
-0.0030511096,
-0.1085631326,
0.0103501398,
-0.0261352472,
-0.023708228,
-0.0475206897,
-0.0907951072,
0.004718231,
-0.0662715435,
-0.0139964558,
0.0222210996,
0.0130495224,
-0.047633402,
-0.0316224992,
0.0098010926,
-0.0301608015,
0.0398249589,
-0.0010181735,
-0.0249893144,
-0.0283321999,
-0.023602549,
0.0068116742,
-0.0268583279,
0.062270768,
-0.0005497264,
0.0473369323,
0.049365595,
0.0593914688,
-0.029866349,
0.0052369046,
0.0111035779,
0.0281190425,
-0.0098782014,
0.0056670173,
0.0162514336,
-0.0514427871,
-0.0242815353,
-0.0432195403,
0.0499844551,
0.0371812917,
-0.0444149151,
-0.0137957223,
0.0724072605,
0.0112588871,
-0.0270416103,
0.007901513,
0.0431313999,
0.0115908813,
0.0577467121,
0.0116555644,
0.0059994473,
0.0308583099,
-0.0243123155,
-0.0116567155,
-0.0579335503,
-0.0416281149,
-0.004565075,
-0.022297414,
0.0101449434,
-0.0495226532,
-0.0887822285,
-0.013343771,
-0.0040809037,
0.0235287733,
-0.0287180748,
0.0351529978,
0.0023721922,
-0.0519729406,
0.025874285,
-0.0449147001,
-0.0367024355,
0.064823322,
0.0157289952,
-0.0185864959,
0.0165411066,
-0.027699627,
-0.0158315189,
-0.0187790338,
-0.0243057832,
0.041855514,
-0.0224626344,
0.0039351578,
0.0306263696,
-0.0323435701,
0.0340660512,
0.0046611507,
0.068091698,
-0.0996852592,
0.0037696967,
0.0316428319,
0.0390406661,
0.0025214767,
0.0140221026,
-0.0011593041,
0.0259341523,
-0.0225914344,
0.0037018042,
-0.0278794188,
0.0167906359,
-0.0267486311,
0.0142501919,
0.0173450038,
0.0055171517,
-0.0354577564,
-0.079350166,
-0.0459981337,
-0.0424359106,
-0.0366418436,
0.0019685987,
0.0253441911,
0.0046310327,
-0.0183338318,
-0.0402843095,
0.0400106311,
-0.0694247708,
0.044994615,
-0.0647282451,
0.0212462619,
0.0328886136,
0.0308969505,
-0.0647730604,
-0.0231457893,
-0.0486969501,
0.0680265129,
0.0066630705,
0.0362618119,
-0.0539911501,
0.0440520868,
0.0114896381,
0.0089309709,
0.0162833221,
-0.0246747565,
-0.047886312,
0.0572700724,
-0.0355299525,
0.035636209,
0.0168662071,
0.0220720526,
0.0019081547,
0.0272504501,
-0.0121726906,
0.022396395,
0.0220111106,
-0.0284179486,
-0.0195500348,
0.008485822,
0.0444122702,
-0.0395607017,
0.0037109368,
-0.0120230112,
-0.0673538446,
0.0581268258,
0.0533676222,
-0.0242345873,
-0.0400326252,
-0.0507951044,
0.0598781258,
-0.0039830147,
-0.0008702865,
-0.0071436879,
-0.0686251745,
0.0092283962,
0.0184881575,
-0.007172958,
0.0053173364,
-0.0319624729,
-0.0510477759,
0.065762423,
-0.0037680899,
0.0335665978,
-0.0273719616,
0.0112672104,
-0.0392020606,
0.0047902283,
-0.0210086349,
-4.916888995e-33,
-0.0451723598,
-0.0007672638,
-0.021475859,
0.022353068,
-0.0369792581,
0.0340626985,
0.0047540562,
-0.0099366195,
-0.0488780737,
0.0554937422,
0.0104558533,
0.0270537678,
0.0131998267,
-0.0244103502,
0.0023808421,
-0.0403054841,
-0.0022584889,
0.0157567896,
-0.0291149486,
0.0357317664,
0.0093535306,
0.0157853458,
0.0819580257,
-0.0878298208,
0.0467765108,
0.0376121327,
-0.0263474155,
-0.0411914028,
0.0504912101,
0.0286472123,
-0.0114953192,
0.0403618254,
0.0268024486,
-0.0213655923,
-0.0011865807,
0.0363241881,
-0.0565243736,
-0.006487594,
0.082596451,
-0.0064210882,
-0.0238691699,
-0.0358817875,
0.0010034961,
-0.0083175609,
-0.002675768,
-0.0231311843,
0.0402071737,
-0.0512491018,
-0.0043098372,
-0.0387181453,
-0.0730610192,
0.011695479,
-0.0263869129,
0.0075796903,
-0.0486017093,
-0.0232723802,
0.0250360053,
0.069810383,
0.0168487877,
-0.0048454232,
-0.0495836399,
0.0090629719,
-0.0156146586,
-0.0762901306,
0.0052005197,
0.0939010009,
-0.0186926723,
0.0042548729,
-0.0567659773,
0.0705635473,
0.007695891,
0.0470602587,
0.0131248105,
0.1082936376,
-0.0064629028,
-0.0636098385,
-0.0544810668,
0.0078744488,
0.0866841897,
-0.0327774994,
-0.0118501233,
-0.0253858343,
-0.011834532,
0.0437719077,
-0.0235187132,
-0.0709725395,
-0.0128511721,
-0.0102625825,
-0.0104251308,
0.0014453077,
-0.043436747,
0.0728933066,
-0.0117414547,
-0.0417288803,
0.0279665552,
0.0716025308,
0.0078448839,
-0.01470262,
-0.0083327387,
0.034743093,
-0.0493480936,
-0.05730661,
0.0128081124,
-0.0273271129,
0.0579323657,
-0.0425761938,
0.0766502544,
-0.0240248777,
-0.0197310485,
-0.001269413,
-0.0072032325,
0.0202211756,
-0.0229191706,
-0.0147395972,
0.0212407503,
0.0214490648,
-0.0014105701,
-0.0044950522,
0.0404711924,
0.0087217642,
-0.0095614716,
-0.0309435595,
-0.0190335438,
0.0538061224,
-0.0393799953,
-0.0070480853,
-0.0035050493,
0.0225853622,
-0.0106160715,
-0.0313024707,
-0.0038377205,
0.0210340377,
2.1e-7,
0.0261763949,
0.0048523014,
0.0359243341,
0.0193715096,
-0.0393275134,
0.0120596383,
0.061630629,
0.0598099753,
-0.0036077974,
-0.1105482131,
-0.0332776569,
0.0229447298,
0.0485404059,
0.0154569997,
-0.02216742,
-0.0336881168,
-0.003258205,
-0.0291811135,
-0.0659038872,
-0.0112637822,
0.030593887,
0.0364110768,
0.0617682859,
-0.0048250514,
0.0058954218,
0.0122051639,
0.0357244872,
-0.030402597,
-0.107954286,
0.0137467878,
-0.0528237633,
-0.0325279757,
-0.0158790983,
-0.015710352,
0.0047010649,
0.0438424125,
0.0285987258,
0.0860981122,
0.0128407404,
-0.0519950651,
-0.0103102382,
-0.0401885435,
-0.0217668619,
0.0286801662,
0.0865030587,
-0.0221417416,
-0.0183282513,
-0.0618811324,
-0.0171354264,
0.008571621,
-0.0186831076,
0.0102308411,
-0.0111811729,
0.0250874907,
0.0033693581,
0.0053363102,
-0.0128757646,
-0.0538043827,
-0.0031137057,
-0.0118130371,
-0.0076129218,
-0.0589842014,
0.0673862472,
-0.0157518815,
0.0129747884,
-0.0685571581,
0.005770578,
1.701365868e-34,
0.0311654881,
-0.0144247124,
-0.0008621374,
0.0259184781,
0.0366082415,
0.0389333367,
-0.0300008561,
-0.0458028838,
0.0000770832,
-0.0133664655,
0.0278075989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09732v1 | Source Prompt: Coordinated Pre-training of Language Models on Diverse Corpora from Multiple Sources | 2023-11-16T10:03:26 | 2023-11-16T10:03:26 | Yipei Xu, Dakuan Lu, Jiaqing Liang, Xintao Wang, Yipeng Geng, Yingsi Xin, Hengkui Wu, Ken Chen, ruiji zhang, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have established the new paradigm in the
field of NLP. For more powerful PLMs, one of the most popular and successful
way is to continuously scale up sizes of the models and the pre-training
corpora. These large corpora are generally obtained by converging smaller ones
from multiple sources, they are thus growing increasingly diverse. However, the
side-effects of these colossal converged corpora remain understudied. In this
paper, we identify the disadvantage of heterogeneous corpora from multiple
sources for pre-training PLMs. Towards coordinated pre-training on diverse
corpora, we further propose source prompts (SP), which explicitly prompt the
model of the data source at the pre-training and fine-tuning stages. Results of
extensive experiments demonstrate that PLMs pre-trained with SP on diverse
corpora gain significant improvement in various downstream tasks. | [
0.044663284,
0.0596768446,
-0.0112078385,
-0.0015424509,
-0.0134862205,
-0.0014615521,
0.0339315534,
0.0006294794,
-0.0357933119,
-0.0475021377,
-0.0611959882,
-0.0451472439,
-0.0127324713,
0.0181055237,
0.033977069,
-0.0641469881,
0.0649083331,
-0.0259192828,
-0.0150364283,
-0.0242101997,
0.0137202786,
0.0198968761,
0.0112339985,
0.0118860425,
-0.0113204001,
-0.0099700205,
0.0047183204,
0.0048744972,
-0.0107888523,
-0.0137785776,
0.0174226556,
0.0886484385,
0.007789115,
0.0014219884,
0.0000019974,
-0.0621127263,
-0.0216195825,
-0.0230692793,
-0.0289987363,
0.0194093119,
0.0124840308,
-0.0165194608,
0.0104000475,
0.0265437588,
-0.0346406735,
-0.0440603644,
0.0419921465,
0.0167410485,
0.0462209396,
0.0926018953,
-0.0050188894,
0.0110055367,
-0.0006490354,
-0.0601814538,
-0.0229029953,
-0.0210116673,
0.0132020861,
-0.0365374833,
0.0010181,
0.0340842493,
-0.0100940159,
0.0303728562,
-0.0220655277,
0.0417611189,
0.0146518908,
0.0119901244,
-0.0036659322,
-0.065510571,
-0.032507576,
0.0761818662,
-0.0582337119,
-0.0278022364,
-0.0052061607,
-0.030329233,
-0.0006019591,
0.0195990279,
-0.022537576,
0.0374724418,
-0.0003248021,
0.0271158516,
-0.0135890823,
-0.0135961454,
0.0260728989,
0.0292261858,
-0.0381920226,
0.033235155,
0.0237368718,
-0.0398623124,
0.0360294208,
0.0319664516,
0.0004489803,
-0.059555281,
-0.0035287137,
0.0041292319,
-0.0533544496,
0.0437046215,
-0.0481420234,
-0.0325129665,
0.0413974598,
-0.0153564699,
0.0517905876,
0.0254174005,
-0.0625749156,
0.040486142,
0.0094843563,
0.007815836,
-0.0108590825,
0.0204395521,
-0.0508191027,
-0.0257900618,
-0.0347211845,
0.0125749754,
-0.0583147034,
0.0204526167,
-0.0423555411,
-0.021886237,
-0.0269315075,
0.0314171873,
-0.0000079644,
-0.0405903459,
0.0375861861,
-0.0066203354,
-0.0272801332,
-0.013853658,
-0.0155653451,
0.0532632358,
-0.0611518882,
0.0406446084,
-0.0095154261,
-0.093413204,
-0.0298469812,
0.0063946242,
-0.0027205194,
-0.0154610425,
0.0301676616,
0.0421243906,
0.0137551464,
-0.0466363803,
-0.0504044518,
0.014290954,
0.0082578976,
-0.0524830408,
-0.0009386342,
-0.0547847562,
0.0421804152,
0.0136178993,
0.0253602006,
-0.046007704,
-0.0129194837,
0.0017480676,
-0.0673065335,
0.0777249783,
-0.0649227723,
0.0321999863,
0.0038331139,
-0.0168933887,
-0.0090069901,
0.1227811873,
0.0026355791,
-0.0290197898,
0.0642474368,
-0.0089832954,
-0.0083626872,
0.0560872369,
0.0207416266,
0.0101144994,
0.015807651,
-0.0150763439,
0.0188079495,
-0.0105415192,
0.0317470729,
0.0485588573,
-0.025269188,
0.0177577026,
0.0490213148,
0.0528053083,
0.030113684,
-0.0068826103,
0.065642193,
0.0076198657,
0.0146076716,
0.0421386585,
-0.0345116481,
-0.0471814238,
-0.0183771644,
0.0108286394,
0.0494909659,
0.0876651257,
-0.0451667942,
-0.0055050771,
-0.0247447211,
-0.0345437266,
-0.0310124494,
0.0164759066,
0.0428029336,
0.0202252623,
-0.009967261,
0.07024239,
0.0727696866,
-0.0470679589,
0.0226409994,
0.0225788355,
0.0191857573,
0.0610525981,
-0.0032258292,
-0.0216158293,
-0.015573916,
-0.0015523509,
0.0103500141,
0.0255532581,
0.0638598576,
-0.0141890505,
0.0387128182,
-0.057231646,
-0.0263946131,
0.0090405131,
0.0205879267,
0.0512810349,
0.0322251804,
0.0056571122,
0.0040296288,
0.0313162617,
-0.030111121,
0.0429618955,
-0.0552282967,
0.0133837415,
0.0095279329,
-0.0091554206,
0.0237970985,
0.0297677498,
-0.0365745164,
0.0098909074,
0.0191600174,
-0.0202668607,
0.0024376451,
0.0230367836,
-0.0599154048,
-0.0090737967,
0.0461086854,
0.0009322434,
0.0137180658,
-0.009465008,
-0.0268058237,
-0.0405167788,
-0.0059778071,
0.0195449777,
0.0140157854,
-0.0522721969,
0.0479835533,
-0.0186607968,
0.0316976905,
-0.0409722812,
0.0380681604,
0.0088207694,
0.0295811538,
0.0371361412,
0.0216485709,
0.0205561072,
-0.0491319746,
-0.0469377413,
0.0163066722,
0.0087788831,
0.0290938951,
0.0322557017,
-0.000124536,
-0.0474075861,
-0.0066318195,
-0.0801631659,
0.0158557612,
-0.041760724,
-0.0145210857,
0.0258320291,
0.0261364188,
-0.0478553288,
-0.0296120308,
-0.0043184552,
0.0069185742,
0.0433217101,
0.0595899336,
-0.0000761896,
0.0061522122,
0.0254260693,
-0.037997894,
-0.0191212948,
0.0189809557,
0.0389139615,
0.0033633464,
-0.0346969143,
-0.0609547459,
0.0211584978,
-0.0128209433,
0.0577183738,
0.0151014524,
-0.0069549885,
-0.0032214364,
-0.0190702565,
0.0550668947,
0.0164176505,
0.0051753637,
-0.0036742454,
0.0615507141,
-0.0042110472,
-0.0617710836,
0.0050101429,
-0.0149296243,
-0.0055602319,
-0.0503510945,
-0.010927774,
0.0360678248,
0.0484729744,
-0.0031493551,
-0.0245307088,
-0.049943462,
0.0053430512,
-0.0256994423,
-0.0186347887,
-0.0280424785,
-0.0348960496,
-0.0306178797,
0.0332999192,
-0.0001909026,
-0.0687367916,
0.0447220504,
-0.0608600825,
0.0055199899,
-0.0582131892,
-0.0035524671,
-0.0382162072,
0.0116267381,
-0.0149066327,
-0.0064964965,
0.0240252409,
-0.0137118781,
-0.0477348715,
0.0362065025,
0.0139451884,
-0.0053228484,
0.0413737483,
-0.019398205,
0.0216727648,
0.0032496105,
-0.0412714966,
-0.0700272024,
-0.0765725672,
-0.0271027833,
0.015839383,
0.0382060297,
0.0148885492,
-0.0173414424,
0.0016522278,
0.0173320156,
0.0497269109,
-0.0111718178,
0.0169453304,
-0.0097689014,
0.0099781305,
0.0286879539,
0.0153211467,
-0.0143307652,
-0.0352783799,
-0.0223026667,
-0.0111207273,
0.0389008634,
-0.0548581257,
-0.0053986614,
0.022393452,
0.0550819226,
-0.0384083241,
-0.0450474545,
0.0149299325,
0.0299132355,
0.0072346684,
-0.0062040845,
0.1184571683,
0.0258322116,
-0.0731902122,
-0.0155311078,
0.0213446636,
0.0388124734,
0.0279362872,
0.0372641273,
-0.0914681107,
-0.0081123449,
-0.0111402432,
0.0026352503,
0.0126673644,
-0.0019906538,
-0.0561512373,
-0.1354260147,
-0.0212571714,
0.0068407636,
-0.0393326096,
0.0212338977,
-0.0302595999,
-0.0044661178,
-0.0149242952,
0.0234734863,
0.0077718282,
-0.0358288474,
0.0112594841,
0.0475461669,
-0.0202687532,
-0.1028335169,
-0.0243514609,
-0.0778478384,
0.0611300617,
0.0714930445,
-0.046147719,
-0.0131149096,
-0.0338763744,
0.0326172821,
-0.0161370505,
0.0231477376,
-0.0310534835,
0.0400913879,
-0.015650019,
-0.0057862028,
0.0365836211,
-0.0251766201,
-0.0040528653,
-0.0187394898,
-0.0000156763,
0.04368072,
-0.0025264111,
-0.0016357939,
0.0023227294,
0.0148376822,
0.0362377912,
0.0730821565,
0.0223142654,
-0.0629171506,
0.0035008874,
0.0030455973,
-0.0240803286,
-0.0474220626,
-0.0093130227,
0.0578495301,
-0.0435928851,
-0.0497659966,
-0.0636763349,
-0.0577700026,
0.0251526423,
0.0461367965,
0.0357058048,
0.0452639796,
0.0009650386,
0.020480739,
0.0198196266,
0.0697869733,
-0.0156141575,
-0.030461099,
-0.1019792035,
-0.0635277331,
0.0263810791,
-0.0190475602,
0.0054933466,
0.0036240674,
-0.0677769929,
-0.0803868994,
-0.0013358778,
0.0389461443,
0.0285424832,
0.0651140064,
-0.0203688815,
-0.0896262154,
0.0528234839,
-0.004355534,
-0.0552293509,
0.0287396144,
0.0304066818,
-0.0284033399,
0.0021078745,
0.0185902622,
-0.0337616727,
0.0509420224,
0.0181365423,
0.0307010468,
-0.0045029884,
-0.0232398827,
0.015281043,
0.0153614888,
0.0680659562,
-0.0505784824,
-0.0061975629,
-0.0820530429,
0.0057414644,
0.006424835,
-0.0077731069,
-0.0403464846,
0.0141497552,
0.0105646728,
-0.0300576277,
-0.0076663718,
0.0181404203,
-0.0345846191,
0.0460514203,
-0.0447382368,
-0.0224552676,
0.0286385622,
-0.0056093903,
0.0231392141,
0.0124645643,
-0.0045697312,
0.0405254178,
-0.0219197553,
-0.0046306001,
-0.0443291813,
0.0207524784,
0.0069619599,
0.0066453982,
-0.0033764825,
0.0269627124,
-0.0794644803,
-0.053702224,
-0.0141521282,
0.0360685065,
0.0685662478,
-0.0338053331,
0.0754389539,
-0.0020161564,
0.0102681546,
-0.0430669673,
-0.0041122441,
0.0269170199,
-0.0232311822,
0.0531055406,
-0.0026310182,
-0.0495687947,
0.0102681108,
0.1100063398,
-0.0137520637,
0.0339558385,
-0.0142301721,
0.0078657726,
-0.024843581,
0.0023735326,
-0.0064347689,
0.0129051479,
-0.0588476472,
0.0345650092,
-0.0481580272,
-0.0462919585,
0.0414394103,
-0.0151005397,
-0.0050716759,
0.0123304669,
0.0483562276,
0.0912768692,
-0.0182413813,
0.0478772521,
-0.0223900918,
-0.0024323019,
0.0174433608,
-0.0261539202,
-0.0071129776,
-7.00773749e-33,
-0.0241706446,
0.0248654075,
0.0081409914,
-0.0585635416,
0.0098989699,
0.011122806,
-0.0077201417,
0.0146951173,
-0.0531464964,
-0.0087706186,
-0.0564347953,
0.0051554749,
0.0417047888,
0.0164116435,
0.0188128669,
0.0105474833,
0.0602097586,
-0.0089844633,
-0.0144677702,
-0.0000950222,
0.0377148464,
0.0578898452,
0.0465039574,
-0.0140944831,
0.0417553857,
-0.0211160332,
-0.0005286578,
0.0082932403,
0.0307346154,
0.0519947559,
-0.0200094171,
0.052017577,
0.0307217706,
-0.0298185814,
-0.0571340621,
0.0189618729,
-0.0515477322,
-0.0331516787,
0.0631970242,
0.0137013821,
-0.0065510403,
-0.009625664,
0.0001758046,
-0.0367196426,
-0.0017874398,
0.0150161088,
0.0187042896,
-0.0242854394,
-0.0292526186,
-0.0129021751,
-0.0450797379,
0.0286717452,
0.0273064766,
0.0066045085,
0.0281614177,
0.0310901105,
-0.0075197793,
-0.0012095658,
0.0057212692,
0.0495812893,
0.0705633461,
0.0581901558,
0.0481504388,
0.0133087076,
-0.0166986007,
0.0349329077,
-0.0105379345,
-0.0303652827,
0.0022183128,
-0.0046430719,
0.0462367013,
0.0305680875,
0.0125643248,
0.0519142523,
0.0077500669,
-0.0270144343,
-0.0794314817,
0.0302024987,
0.0393730812,
-0.0157614201,
0.0089123314,
-0.0063454225,
0.0212544631,
-0.0399693027,
-0.0283225179,
-0.0335938372,
-0.0208518803,
-0.0266359579,
0.0362696238,
0.037848793,
0.0095679909,
0.0195507091,
0.0483381115,
-0.012965099,
-0.0332357958,
0.0595729761,
-0.0072316905,
-0.0165113602,
0.0005057469,
0.023745697,
-0.0786634907,
-0.0298034884,
0.0236463882,
-0.003753063,
-0.0052621393,
0.0155430697,
0.0303469952,
0.0019215581,
-0.0628295243,
0.0121229654,
-0.0240641329,
0.0295948815,
0.0227097049,
0.0248828065,
0.0562543944,
0.0241126399,
-0.0250675157,
0.0564775988,
0.0247884579,
-0.0408032835,
-0.0138643971,
0.0016068483,
0.0143447882,
0.0608106032,
-0.0269509666,
0.0125867482,
-0.0098759402,
0.0188654549,
0.0422792621,
-0.0282185189,
-0.003591493,
-0.007208358,
2.736e-7,
0.0364583135,
0.0248383544,
0.0221422445,
-0.0096947029,
-0.0155620864,
-0.0241129864,
-0.0517401285,
0.0322332643,
-0.007215539,
-0.0172994453,
-0.0140602328,
0.0107209282,
0.0447570384,
0.0232625566,
-0.0878593251,
-0.0470744409,
-0.0482600182,
0.0438085608,
-0.0699554458,
-0.0126739135,
-0.0184930451,
0.1231200323,
-0.0048589292,
-0.0062059448,
-0.0271426458,
-0.0280884672,
0.0640417188,
-0.0459188782,
-0.0157804918,
0.0288718697,
0.0358305424,
-0.011068915,
-0.0223015938,
0.0249710847,
-0.0369462408,
0.045063965,
-0.0006557433,
0.0476514846,
0.0180420335,
-0.0060641202,
0.0094797527,
-0.0108051328,
-0.0522438996,
-0.0295791384,
0.0654755756,
-0.0136334449,
0.0029580416,
-0.0158582516,
-0.0101257376,
0.0027964055,
0.0337764956,
-0.0511595942,
-0.036255803,
0.0190359242,
0.0272799097,
-0.0033674836,
-0.0427616797,
-0.0891728923,
-0.0209067967,
-0.0208692644,
-0.0234915596,
-0.0560334325,
0.0062211845,
-0.0439964309,
0.0299780294,
-0.046224881,
0.031369023,
2.420284323e-34,
0.0433145687,
-0.0092326449,
0.0251793247,
0.028681485,
0.0086595882,
-0.0476466864,
0.0025047038,
0.0255136285,
-0.015688464,
-0.093019098,
-0.0125646982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09731v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09731v2 | Examining LLMs' Uncertainty Expression Towards Questions Outside Parametric Knowledge | 2023-11-16T10:02:40 | 2024-02-16T17:30:41 | Genglin Liu, Xingyao Wang, Lifan Yuan, Yangyi Chen, Hao Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Can large language models (LLMs) express their uncertainty in situations
where they lack sufficient parametric knowledge to generate reasonable
responses? This work aims to systematically investigate LLMs' behaviors in such
situations, emphasizing the trade-off between honesty and helpfulness. To
tackle the challenge of precisely determining LLMs' knowledge gaps, we
diagnostically create unanswerable questions containing non-existent concepts
or false premises, ensuring that they are outside the LLMs' vast training data.
By compiling a benchmark, UnknownBench, which consists of both unanswerable and
answerable questions, we quantitatively evaluate the LLMs' performance in
maintaining honesty while being helpful. Using a model-agnostic unified
confidence elicitation approach, we observe that most LLMs fail to consistently
refuse or express uncertainty towards questions outside their parametric
knowledge, although instruction fine-tuning and alignment techniques can
provide marginal enhancements. Moreover, LLMs' uncertainty expression does not
always stay consistent with the perceived confidence of their textual outputs. | [
0.0743424818,
0.1084612533,
-0.0259079952,
0.0521418937,
-0.0435375944,
0.0202398915,
-0.0270243529,
-0.0182981417,
-0.0294563454,
-0.0322925635,
-0.0268895198,
-0.048793897,
-0.0106761735,
-0.0243603792,
0.0399797931,
-0.0090159979,
0.0322741121,
-0.0431865342,
0.0358362645,
-0.0340170152,
-0.002649924,
-0.0145694455,
-0.0084385071,
-0.0095079402,
-0.025521826,
-0.0091039408,
-0.024509836,
0.011155053,
-0.0118690133,
-0.0294183865,
0.0393962227,
0.0362316109,
-0.0014142722,
0.0827554166,
0.0000020025,
-0.0571250133,
-0.0043021725,
-0.0077899462,
-0.087496534,
0.0315869302,
0.0085372832,
0.0084823519,
0.0110790664,
0.0113544725,
-0.0449016578,
0.0206296295,
0.0320925973,
0.0306862574,
0.0394409075,
0.0659015477,
0.0359405279,
0.0156936906,
0.0253176242,
-0.0112820501,
0.0434487946,
-0.0449178778,
0.0216928776,
0.0089906529,
-0.0204420611,
0.0450442061,
-0.0123579307,
0.0580117442,
0.0269554053,
-0.0136535224,
-0.0168958809,
0.0271780994,
-0.0304764621,
-0.0485556498,
-0.017046269,
0.059361428,
0.0205276199,
-0.037285611,
-0.0327484272,
-0.0261776838,
0.0184309315,
0.0337380096,
-0.0399127491,
0.0442742854,
-0.0196096636,
-0.0156475976,
-0.0176708009,
0.0045569171,
0.0471878946,
0.0190515108,
0.0226621609,
0.0966739208,
-0.0215328559,
-0.050480485,
0.0236009471,
-0.011924156,
-0.0510641411,
-0.0592098385,
-0.0131911915,
0.0614685565,
-0.0393995456,
0.0672902316,
-0.0323967114,
0.0188912954,
0.053095378,
-0.0171665065,
0.0208267607,
0.0258770399,
-0.004182321,
0.0434552655,
-0.0038017104,
0.0300695822,
-0.0047461926,
-0.0021477984,
-0.0158105046,
-0.0081126308,
0.0053197844,
-0.0306867287,
-0.0212654136,
0.0138594871,
-0.0119358413,
0.0288674217,
-0.0055560227,
0.0381973796,
-0.0358653516,
0.0823342875,
0.0107118385,
0.0216250923,
-0.0239298996,
-0.0528778099,
-0.0725494027,
0.0332611389,
-0.015985176,
0.0356964841,
0.0130114816,
-0.1125871167,
-0.0034802509,
0.0285638645,
-0.0349625237,
-0.0067318566,
0.0447449945,
0.0474312119,
-0.0133157121,
-0.0134806084,
-0.0353814065,
-0.0133613553,
-0.0305243526,
-0.0740668476,
-0.018366985,
-0.0519473627,
-0.003240962,
0.0238956399,
-0.020357376,
-0.0303677544,
0.0366796628,
0.0199090615,
-0.0198875666,
0.0782401785,
-0.0139196096,
0.0376271456,
0.0438612029,
0.0148038901,
-0.0435602777,
0.0672188699,
0.0256078988,
0.0041528116,
0.0562503636,
-0.0016021602,
0.0238442179,
-0.0183955412,
0.0344462059,
0.028902933,
-0.0318126678,
0.0387300961,
-0.0126025025,
0.0402985066,
-0.0024071303,
0.0639038458,
-0.0037647176,
-0.0392404012,
0.094438076,
0.0006938144,
-0.0577810556,
-0.0021954998,
0.0518973358,
0.0104342308,
0.0271419547,
0.0253100526,
-0.0634908378,
0.0139666619,
-0.0819115564,
0.0267054774,
0.0105811879,
0.0013626659,
-0.0205283239,
-0.0816411898,
-0.0297514778,
-0.0062500695,
-0.0234674979,
0.0774556473,
0.0324566439,
-0.021834489,
-0.0320033878,
0.0363128819,
-0.0058089993,
-0.0117931552,
-0.007708915,
-0.0391862392,
0.0598764606,
-0.0053654695,
0.0505710021,
-0.0414044298,
-0.0665177032,
-0.0138979135,
0.0233343299,
0.0369776003,
0.0918603167,
-0.0019877488,
0.0272224471,
-0.0377853811,
-0.0141360248,
-0.0281764064,
0.0316118747,
-0.0065609622,
0.0357741341,
0.0137536256,
0.0205970854,
-0.0829358101,
-0.0067707379,
0.0246190615,
-0.0350419171,
-0.0503960997,
-0.0021886691,
-0.0239508841,
0.033757247,
-0.0181352645,
-0.0179922059,
0.0383138321,
0.0325966775,
0.0306838397,
-0.0486885607,
-0.0395598263,
-0.0372536592,
0.0052950154,
0.0314082615,
0.0003540123,
-0.0603160858,
-0.0098034171,
-0.0317747891,
-0.023458235,
-0.0025369723,
-0.0083060218,
0.0062550767,
-0.0287449528,
0.0506914966,
-0.0232688785,
-0.0109267635,
-0.0523027666,
0.0572653562,
-0.0121575752,
0.0479492173,
0.0090289209,
0.0002900664,
-0.0087774592,
-0.0146273086,
-0.0232395437,
-0.0123686818,
-0.0077353748,
0.0032468066,
0.0407584868,
0.0144692231,
-0.0471491814,
-0.0515525639,
-0.0709353387,
0.0009731865,
0.0010085743,
0.0279345587,
0.0160314217,
-0.0371777602,
-0.0141498037,
-0.0124447355,
-0.0462801047,
0.0153670143,
0.0073854825,
0.0063657379,
0.0606936663,
0.0227537733,
0.0155136045,
-0.0292035379,
0.0168694053,
-0.0026040324,
0.0141183026,
0.0080433367,
0.0352495164,
-0.0618136451,
0.0561663173,
-0.0507855602,
0.0231681056,
-0.0167040825,
-0.0315858684,
0.0115983328,
-0.0075319465,
-0.0378190912,
0.0554048829,
0.0107700592,
0.0088200681,
0.0571574681,
-0.0015590331,
-0.0608123764,
0.0432204567,
-0.0161890667,
-0.0581626594,
-0.04365189,
-0.0552787632,
0.0044741468,
0.0585843027,
0.0122470306,
-0.0270483494,
-0.0342374444,
0.0485295169,
-0.0242463145,
-0.0333589911,
-0.0193433911,
-0.0111259697,
-0.0046669254,
0.0574195646,
-0.0068431441,
-0.0668942258,
0.1014436781,
-0.0358757712,
-0.0226963721,
0.0005854966,
0.0132565722,
-0.0144608179,
0.0407830141,
-0.0107510714,
-0.0193290319,
0.0486433804,
0.0083432207,
-0.0664069578,
-0.0221968703,
0.043355789,
-0.0530965254,
0.0278703999,
-0.0813593417,
-0.0170185417,
0.0138653982,
-0.0181660894,
-0.0881438181,
-0.0600680225,
-0.0156779457,
-0.0318424441,
0.0087336609,
-0.0007507319,
-0.0108029693,
-0.0472943708,
0.0320114717,
-0.0011546414,
-0.0350694507,
-0.0246253163,
-0.0205148924,
0.0075377016,
0.0578601062,
0.0225034058,
0.083245635,
-0.054397095,
0.0230085514,
0.0505328067,
-0.0058598719,
0.0303970464,
0.0037834677,
-0.0310057309,
0.0204075351,
0.020047212,
-0.0125247445,
0.0482741408,
0.0666492432,
-0.0166096035,
-0.0311015416,
0.1328304112,
0.0401696935,
0.0191958901,
-0.0007565489,
-0.0572318137,
0.0478750616,
0.0224293135,
0.0224577039,
-0.0611701757,
-0.0195182934,
0.0079547521,
0.0192636121,
-0.0525490642,
-0.0261496399,
-0.0332065821,
-0.1318805814,
0.0324750468,
0.0013712766,
-0.016998291,
-0.0132199014,
-0.0236486886,
0.0215437673,
0.01447968,
0.0541644618,
0.016554758,
0.0004839311,
-0.007060064,
0.0113010155,
-0.0218907241,
-0.0485233553,
0.0060467795,
0.0093095535,
0.0668481737,
-0.0071020168,
0.0074361842,
-0.0092256675,
-0.0376096591,
-0.0027398646,
-0.0263766143,
-0.017742591,
-0.019429611,
0.0265685767,
0.0083371783,
0.0089423591,
-0.0038388974,
0.0087487102,
-0.0277387425,
0.0221248008,
0.0265573282,
0.0659432784,
-0.0297555402,
-0.045745682,
0.0112512959,
0.0068075829,
0.0240311678,
0.0752260536,
0.0167769194,
-0.0026756835,
-0.0004976338,
-0.0364159308,
0.0120883472,
0.0209280942,
0.0063549052,
0.0607268959,
0.025339039,
0.0326721855,
-0.0467584953,
-0.0538862646,
0.0034142223,
0.0045888368,
0.0039205421,
-0.0231013075,
0.0525338762,
-0.0212118719,
-0.030883966,
0.0081659267,
-0.0370339751,
0.0208740048,
-0.0465890765,
0.0338016637,
-0.0012764073,
-0.0158619639,
0.0081652794,
0.0101453634,
-0.0737998635,
-0.0804392397,
-0.0180398896,
0.0512018651,
0.0368782915,
0.0144102573,
-0.0042244149,
-0.047406029,
0.0266131125,
0.0269393306,
-0.0248425417,
0.0236427467,
0.0522655882,
0.0186035149,
-0.0123933228,
0.0597998984,
-0.0277315453,
-0.0015493305,
0.0360756665,
0.0227586366,
-0.0467752926,
-0.0730947927,
0.0385222472,
0.0301029664,
0.0319119059,
0.0283421203,
0.0220351797,
0.001393929,
0.0421727784,
-0.0190496761,
-0.0206462331,
-0.018081218,
-0.0122754769,
0.0179172624,
-0.0338066705,
-0.007333139,
-0.0248684473,
-0.0180051364,
0.0473486856,
-0.0043033524,
-0.0323396251,
0.0051999129,
0.0160340182,
0.0257848315,
-0.0276623461,
-0.0174879096,
0.0431373715,
-0.0028171688,
0.0409805104,
0.0462843329,
0.0720371529,
0.0131264394,
-0.0088762008,
0.0082858223,
-0.0353761613,
-0.0611782931,
-0.0829195231,
-0.0029377532,
0.0390452854,
0.0102963466,
0.0186881833,
0.0226582456,
-0.0509329624,
-0.0068662064,
-0.0080419704,
0.0154003575,
0.0265925489,
-0.0281278491,
0.0975940078,
0.0247356147,
-0.0204201806,
0.0252385922,
0.0641203672,
-0.022415312,
0.0592148304,
-0.0154327815,
-0.0175602566,
-0.0360288322,
-0.0417125002,
0.0254144296,
0.0021256241,
-0.0216192324,
0.0476756021,
-0.0517291464,
-0.0841155052,
-0.0018301172,
0.036647588,
-0.027686486,
-0.0556164496,
-0.0233326182,
0.0689868033,
0.0091230916,
-0.0150438212,
-0.0402330644,
0.0461969636,
-0.000292261,
0.022675626,
-0.0585761741,
-6.876876316e-33,
-0.0081972415,
-0.0675421655,
0.0038823895,
-0.0349844843,
0.003342855,
0.0108975992,
-0.0113722589,
0.0330548324,
-0.0462062769,
0.0182884131,
-0.0324442945,
0.0231497157,
0.0029791375,
0.0247950498,
0.0073081646,
-0.0250142775,
0.019205099,
0.0003881209,
-0.0211664829,
-0.0088285692,
0.0111349998,
0.0039798301,
0.0421437621,
-0.0432328098,
0.0818883926,
-0.0250195414,
-0.0350896753,
0.0919382498,
-0.0595774874,
0.0333442129,
-0.0274943952,
0.0385368019,
-0.0168871768,
-0.0110159162,
0.0041544423,
-0.0330306254,
-0.0077438732,
-0.0481934361,
0.0422698781,
0.0139318844,
-0.0442321487,
-0.025122745,
0.0299211126,
-0.0183004905,
-0.0173942186,
0.0036050172,
-0.0121972412,
-0.0142303659,
0.0110444119,
-0.0083570313,
-0.0097413287,
0.0221756585,
0.0032122973,
-0.0370077342,
-0.0260518696,
0.0478101857,
0.0139672598,
-0.0184506606,
-0.023006279,
-0.0181512088,
0.0257709362,
0.0149429236,
0.0620860234,
-0.0279012434,
-0.0017159907,
0.0310860462,
-0.0316761099,
0.0181160904,
-0.0079952022,
-0.0285844877,
-0.0033267026,
0.0111993784,
0.0446026884,
0.0637275949,
0.0084412089,
-0.0059008328,
-0.0496305861,
-0.0083058942,
0.0203827377,
0.0424665809,
0.0097268792,
-0.0096481387,
-0.0532770343,
-0.0233019665,
-0.0734342262,
-0.0025457954,
-0.0442975163,
0.0071457359,
0.020285083,
0.0080100447,
-0.0230025165,
-0.0063758451,
-0.0121763712,
-0.0319900587,
-0.0171259753,
0.0168986637,
0.0109233968,
0.0086103436,
0.0182468612,
0.0531226657,
-0.0348672941,
-0.0080591245,
0.0061884592,
-0.0311540775,
-0.0047608074,
0.0382416174,
0.0414888971,
0.0063623227,
-0.0582382455,
0.0123599563,
-0.030632833,
0.0551970378,
-0.0095781954,
-0.0430485867,
0.0251858998,
0.0300882347,
-0.0255810358,
0.0452952906,
-0.0199705884,
-0.0135297021,
-0.0500311069,
0.0211289227,
-0.0076473402,
0.0184751172,
-0.0505762063,
-0.0220571123,
-0.0008180038,
-0.0172699671,
0.0094713634,
-0.0464327149,
-0.0104673924,
0.0145777324,
2.813e-7,
0.0161758848,
0.0408534892,
0.0068844212,
0.0735054687,
0.0098500308,
0.0627286732,
-0.0332721174,
-0.0066887769,
0.0294434763,
-0.060134083,
0.0029872097,
0.0039999117,
0.0576761812,
0.0563467368,
-0.0598364137,
-0.0293249488,
-0.0322272182,
-0.0129049672,
-0.0058877808,
0.0221604053,
0.0750081465,
0.0805419758,
-0.0042446838,
0.0095192445,
-0.0068467539,
-0.0250171553,
0.0696001276,
-0.041271098,
-0.021841526,
0.0356135294,
0.055010356,
-0.0024146622,
0.0089908708,
0.057684131,
0.004627577,
-0.0107068541,
-0.0588359907,
0.0819104761,
0.0122356946,
-0.0101250606,
-0.0243138373,
-0.032673724,
0.009909519,
-0.0832895637,
0.0678901002,
-0.0543789938,
-0.0383883044,
-0.0265038274,
0.0155393081,
-0.0548467673,
0.0205362029,
-0.0253508594,
-0.0193793792,
0.0010592447,
0.0079886885,
0.0125558749,
-0.0096446825,
-0.0112667317,
-0.0336765721,
-0.001673052,
-0.0200687461,
-0.0729549527,
-0.0133382622,
0.0109476494,
0.0249879062,
-0.076448299,
0.0299855918,
2.53832416e-34,
0.0534415953,
-0.0123073868,
0.0125041325,
-0.0026515741,
0.0432319567,
0.0165623371,
0.0031920888,
0.0161908716,
0.0425503366,
-0.0470505357,
-0.0191387776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09730v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09730v1 | Aligning with Whom? Large Language Models Have Gender and Racial Biases in Subjective NLP Tasks | 2023-11-16T10:02:24 | 2023-11-16T10:02:24 | Huaman Sun, Jiaxin Pei, Minje Choi, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.LG | Human perception of language depends on personal backgrounds like gender and
ethnicity. While existing studies have shown that large language models (LLMs)
hold values that are closer to certain societal groups, it is unclear whether
their prediction behaviors on subjective NLP tasks also exhibit a similar bias.
In this study, leveraging the POPQUORN dataset which contains annotations of
diverse demographic backgrounds, we conduct a series of experiments on four
popular LLMs to investigate their capability to understand group differences
and potential biases in their predictions for politeness and offensiveness. We
find that for both tasks, model predictions are closer to the labels from White
and female participants. We further explore prompting with the target
demographic labels and show that including the target demographic in the prompt
actually worsens the model's performance. More specifically, when being
prompted to respond from the perspective of "Black" and "Asian" individuals,
models show lower performance in predicting both overall scores as well as the
scores from corresponding groups. Our results suggest that LLMs hold gender and
racial biases for subjective NLP tasks and that demographic-infused prompts
alone may be insufficient to mitigate such effects. Code and data are available
at https://github.com/Jiaxin-Pei/LLM-Group-Bias. | [
0.0690306723,
0.0981838629,
-0.0281394459,
0.0243651718,
-0.0016233748,
0.0262536667,
0.0694040433,
-0.0043395446,
0.0175110009,
-0.0670363456,
-0.0414845645,
-0.052691523,
0.0258185174,
-0.0160422586,
0.0380165018,
-0.0377440043,
0.0263894778,
0.0331396125,
0.0529423058,
-0.0526556633,
0.0276189931,
0.0366220772,
0.0141901532,
0.0576642826,
-0.0148686264,
-0.0370743722,
0.0312392544,
-0.0060225958,
-0.0089333383,
0.018527763,
0.0806047767,
0.0956951454,
-0.0356531553,
0.0226074681,
0.0000017726,
-0.0824396014,
0.03418063,
-0.006138288,
-0.01276273,
-0.0041648461,
0.0827433988,
0.0135392221,
-0.0157213118,
0.0321533866,
-0.0403409563,
-0.0010347451,
0.0338245183,
0.0239216369,
0.0349139534,
0.018772494,
0.0070637842,
0.0038000233,
-0.0494995564,
-0.0103324624,
0.0000618674,
-0.0087879905,
0.0279216468,
-0.0396544822,
-0.0432011411,
-0.0255540833,
-0.026129311,
-0.0094147827,
0.0028705965,
-0.0136339134,
0.0384159163,
-0.0040655825,
-0.0366785526,
-0.0458607413,
-0.0121078528,
0.040098127,
0.0465354659,
0.0058053089,
-0.0217496213,
0.0125685008,
0.0269678365,
-0.0247657299,
-0.0158110578,
0.0189449415,
-0.0030068196,
-0.0090742465,
-0.0325197615,
0.004134316,
0.0244542565,
0.0698066354,
0.0374626331,
0.1091072112,
-0.0036284139,
-0.0256360564,
0.0028853863,
0.0227225404,
0.0126064513,
-0.0483674183,
0.0238922443,
-0.0152668832,
-0.0466424748,
0.0028101297,
-0.021732647,
0.0069441185,
0.0542469323,
-0.0401135273,
0.0245009623,
0.0462173522,
-0.0023164705,
0.0026205317,
0.0221051089,
0.0599475279,
0.0155994678,
0.0259309299,
-0.0071135438,
-0.0459744781,
-0.0084450571,
-0.0317180902,
0.0299890228,
-0.0091617675,
-0.0000725744,
0.0573108532,
-0.0581929162,
-0.0321080014,
-0.0835736319,
-0.0158747155,
0.0032447586,
0.0094970679,
-0.0236796588,
0.0076732095,
-0.0607807562,
-0.0060005467,
-0.0587349273,
0.0115868393,
-0.0131352609,
-0.0838056654,
0.0238084663,
-0.0264416728,
-0.0188676491,
-0.0412980616,
0.0077723493,
0.0174972843,
0.0056784088,
-0.0133878235,
-0.0124424212,
-0.0013843393,
-0.028663069,
-0.0681566074,
-0.0187273975,
-0.0497213714,
0.0503397286,
0.0367988572,
0.0021225456,
-0.0499367639,
0.003978929,
0.0376113877,
-0.059317477,
0.0598106533,
0.0435361378,
0.0156867262,
0.0475514196,
0.0263424553,
-0.0265294202,
0.0755985975,
0.02515864,
-0.0286403466,
0.0538346171,
-0.0203774981,
0.0013961702,
0.0432957858,
-0.0038381265,
0.0031556897,
-0.0185619406,
0.0159964189,
-0.0043150433,
0.0083789695,
0.0899688303,
0.0430255681,
0.0232832711,
-0.0553393066,
0.0471219011,
0.1078733131,
-0.0319783017,
0.0465323552,
0.0269031003,
0.0154359229,
-0.0133408038,
0.0064735818,
-0.1073406264,
-0.0086258147,
-0.0225405153,
-0.049174957,
0.0207890309,
0.0655428693,
-0.0211632308,
-0.0356729031,
-0.0446257442,
-0.0017790846,
0.0530949384,
0.0178941768,
-0.0124898283,
0.0083853165,
0.0298886895,
0.0337492526,
0.0707360283,
-0.0378533192,
-0.0076807532,
-0.0355217904,
0.0262658522,
0.0526878461,
-0.0110105714,
-0.0057747844,
-0.0091106407,
-0.0466080643,
-0.0102332681,
0.0392670818,
0.0714897588,
0.0016758363,
0.0137774749,
-0.0315744393,
-0.0056853727,
0.0305406414,
0.0098078428,
0.0074101998,
0.0945293307,
0.0170264225,
0.0014708388,
0.0111327171,
-0.0531510971,
0.0316319503,
-0.0202857517,
-0.021403132,
0.0167671125,
-0.0016983971,
0.0537137501,
0.0125486841,
-0.0029071937,
-0.02360663,
-0.0496757701,
0.0115213301,
-0.0242806077,
-0.0142179895,
-0.0591375977,
-0.0177294631,
0.0291243531,
0.0034900908,
-0.0677638799,
0.0248472337,
-0.0074457107,
0.0247432347,
0.0302572027,
0.0155212386,
-0.0133160278,
-0.0088679334,
-0.011596146,
-0.041268412,
0.0286158975,
-0.0307276007,
0.0129286908,
-0.0200359039,
-0.0057328558,
0.0075543546,
-0.0215129759,
-0.0305425096,
-0.0285761021,
-0.0573910922,
0.0164196622,
-0.0103325183,
-0.0042890143,
0.0245881565,
-0.002607157,
-0.0451039709,
-0.0135763176,
-0.0881814808,
0.0042494284,
0.0016501981,
-0.0561023429,
-0.0119390776,
-0.0038275274,
-0.0258644652,
0.0007203052,
-0.0288762245,
-0.0157582462,
0.0312703401,
0.0485813841,
0.0043172045,
-0.0531893596,
0.0025236893,
-0.0400499515,
-0.046806138,
-0.0486299805,
0.0587738939,
0.0022825606,
0.0002174407,
0.0040794155,
-0.0351024158,
-0.0750229284,
0.006360746,
-0.00865361,
-0.0456357375,
0.0220804531,
0.0582919195,
0.0666464195,
0.0846412703,
0.056327831,
0.036075756,
0.0435877517,
-0.0091381902,
-0.0551013462,
0.0098731741,
-0.0185307544,
-0.0136737339,
0.0003569185,
-0.1057659611,
-0.0370481759,
0.0645498261,
0.0408008695,
-0.0100827543,
-0.0668242276,
0.0411280319,
-0.0644962043,
-0.0611477196,
-0.0391416848,
-0.0342208333,
-0.0380782709,
0.0211479887,
-0.0497678518,
-0.0709587783,
0.0652834252,
0.0278629269,
-0.0153766582,
-0.0040227789,
0.006440328,
-0.0475240722,
0.0591959767,
-0.0120447809,
0.0123490859,
0.024280712,
-0.0109289372,
-0.0336991251,
-0.0435239375,
0.0244733486,
-0.0607731491,
0.0314087756,
0.0047155963,
-0.0127183357,
0.021368714,
-0.0519162454,
-0.03419834,
-0.0344762206,
-0.0259736106,
-0.000773664,
0.0108618373,
-0.0016008908,
0.0037516751,
-0.0052608429,
0.0094158975,
-0.0397956893,
-0.0432129614,
0.0099618379,
0.0151496166,
-0.0328118019,
0.0367405973,
0.029243635,
0.0461696163,
-0.0370631292,
0.0261999629,
0.0129916361,
0.0060530119,
0.0133032482,
0.0175424069,
0.0065153358,
0.0500897095,
0.0052569075,
-0.0152012361,
0.0013295073,
0.06056685,
-0.0254578777,
0.0353088677,
0.1074919999,
0.0161028057,
-0.0480388217,
0.0074212356,
-0.0324841328,
0.0342088826,
0.037464425,
0.0123558566,
-0.056066785,
0.0172089264,
0.0273737237,
0.0080205835,
-0.0598303899,
-0.0471089631,
-0.0248274785,
-0.1248512715,
0.0264095869,
0.0083000772,
-0.0066636913,
0.0101606706,
-0.0116208838,
0.0370974578,
-0.0056115473,
0.0641351119,
-0.0138472756,
0.0261191521,
-0.0077654109,
-0.0013378041,
-0.0568850487,
-0.0073462618,
0.0568779185,
-0.0524674356,
0.0657408461,
0.0305436607,
0.0535209663,
-0.01218314,
-0.0186961405,
0.0545888729,
-0.0010381372,
-0.0109364949,
-0.0415219814,
0.0413278267,
-0.0236634836,
0.0073412699,
-0.0611896031,
0.0302928295,
0.0030147461,
-0.0092609748,
0.0008639279,
0.0035537488,
0.034527082,
-0.0465517044,
-0.0486134961,
0.0212980565,
-0.0221243594,
0.0918254107,
0.0151213072,
-0.0782973468,
-0.0049972278,
-0.042983152,
-0.0188443605,
0.0403216928,
-0.0908074379,
0.0151832448,
0.0114554195,
-0.0169975124,
-0.0076365802,
-0.0664732307,
0.0193485431,
-0.0190836526,
-0.0002896518,
-0.0354147442,
0.0038166007,
-0.0160405468,
-0.0198285114,
0.0454060584,
-0.0362248011,
0.0345458724,
-0.0138865355,
-0.0159793217,
0.0070902561,
-0.0157582071,
-0.0167781208,
-0.0043545277,
-0.0332976244,
-0.0514865816,
0.0709556118,
0.0403241031,
0.0185101349,
0.038257394,
0.0058344686,
-0.0683998391,
0.0029950854,
0.0301860888,
-0.0139534073,
0.0495699793,
-0.0020614541,
0.0297777615,
0.0111546088,
0.0334769599,
-0.0146788377,
0.0561019592,
0.0460753925,
-0.0172347762,
0.001151129,
-0.061599724,
-0.002528443,
-0.0015884388,
0.0233520437,
-0.011594044,
-0.0320128389,
-0.0259458255,
-0.0420089588,
0.0122221094,
-0.0613536052,
-0.0035407674,
-0.0511265174,
0.0072288713,
-0.0021044698,
-0.0373485647,
-0.0370945036,
-0.0303757787,
0.0253104959,
-0.0494923368,
0.028784832,
-0.0118147982,
0.0210357346,
0.0237754956,
0.0269842837,
-0.0186633114,
0.0384601057,
-0.0200249534,
0.018736532,
0.0419651493,
0.0677584708,
0.0163974427,
0.0067059016,
-0.0141459778,
-0.0088524185,
-0.0246991143,
-0.0199023951,
0.000851428,
0.0178193878,
-0.017822234,
-0.0315300487,
0.0126665998,
0.0044304011,
-0.0134668974,
-0.0306617748,
-0.0009487429,
0.0257448088,
-0.0379474312,
0.0655838475,
0.0055077914,
-0.0206154529,
0.0005220991,
0.0372023098,
-0.00720766,
0.007492804,
0.012810356,
-0.0521633327,
-0.0162009709,
-0.0213221405,
0.0366366878,
-0.0239460226,
-0.0134772835,
0.0021677027,
-0.0812378451,
-0.0325634703,
0.0166180395,
-0.0199897755,
0.0254767705,
-0.0307139158,
0.0111595681,
0.0627028048,
-0.0451604538,
-0.0374046825,
-0.0139549226,
0.0103786113,
-0.0379739106,
-0.0268876273,
-0.0245166756,
-6.020297991e-33,
-0.0465564281,
-0.03729764,
-0.0242543519,
0.0047239647,
-0.0219140928,
-0.0011338292,
-0.0094787115,
0.0258786306,
-0.016962111,
0.016334204,
-0.0151299052,
0.0275074486,
0.0180185381,
-0.0151169719,
0.0296791065,
-0.0294595622,
0.0409099758,
-0.010285995,
-0.0308738369,
-0.015277029,
-0.0176671613,
0.0217365734,
0.0248960145,
-0.0751758441,
0.0876268223,
-0.0018008807,
-0.0039174049,
0.0142143453,
-0.0148325842,
0.0525419936,
-0.0358865447,
0.0877900347,
0.0338548049,
-0.0110671194,
0.0211930983,
0.0778038874,
-0.0498742647,
-0.0160712469,
0.0126083912,
0.0148452409,
0.0032516799,
-0.0444253944,
0.0208087098,
0.0095415656,
-0.0735975504,
-0.0342007577,
0.0519676879,
-0.0047254669,
0.0654964298,
0.0005499003,
-0.0449420884,
0.0139985271,
-0.013933816,
0.0112156244,
-0.0249491259,
0.0144883748,
-0.0080112983,
0.0294582359,
-0.0313757546,
0.0177878067,
-0.014943691,
-0.0032445774,
0.0319309197,
0.0288187359,
0.0220069569,
0.0698164478,
0.0656920299,
0.0610165931,
-0.0185682159,
-0.0644869432,
0.0466270447,
-0.0179874729,
0.0123007149,
0.0809345916,
0.0378855728,
-0.0510849245,
0.0164522063,
-0.0311254133,
0.0414216854,
-0.0037072331,
0.0490969867,
-0.0282101799,
-0.0514761657,
-0.0552310385,
-0.0333449319,
-0.0543418936,
-0.0232973062,
-0.0242157783,
0.0318351015,
-0.0062239687,
-0.0157848299,
-0.0344307199,
0.0129804267,
-0.0313970074,
-0.0462685004,
0.0018490769,
-0.0190775506,
-0.0159839448,
0.0295546036,
0.0269827377,
-0.0645914376,
0.0247254819,
-0.0453841276,
-0.022671314,
0.0224608835,
0.0299072042,
0.0205036141,
0.0263174269,
-0.0705410168,
0.0076207495,
-0.0024385015,
0.0359955579,
-0.0110453088,
0.0125436615,
0.0430416204,
0.0567718782,
-0.0053846971,
0.0138480552,
0.0465166867,
0.0007518792,
-0.0325796902,
-0.0048089311,
-0.0094469665,
0.0187232886,
-0.0349379852,
-0.0083248345,
0.0011266315,
0.0009307701,
0.0272120163,
-0.0043827845,
-0.0062805684,
-0.0386709757,
2.271e-7,
0.0092205359,
0.0715521947,
-0.0074412948,
0.0381509587,
0.0085273534,
0.0168404561,
0.0205895472,
0.0395613909,
0.0775645226,
-0.0058169793,
-0.0324970335,
0.0349806994,
0.0425633602,
0.0493898988,
-0.0669288412,
0.0167068355,
-0.0778369755,
0.0251614004,
-0.0178285409,
0.0184197892,
-0.0004448594,
0.0656864196,
0.0527946167,
-0.0080055818,
-0.0477597006,
-0.0124723883,
0.0455542468,
-0.0753633752,
0.01573525,
0.0279900618,
0.0262800362,
-0.0289458148,
0.0463001989,
0.0536900051,
0.0162367281,
0.0173666254,
-0.0018186477,
0.047257416,
0.0028403329,
0.0119502563,
0.0014301032,
0.015324899,
-0.031572558,
-0.0678424761,
0.0490789339,
0.0043405248,
-0.0438599437,
-0.0571296886,
-0.0019955093,
-0.0127899833,
0.0419702232,
-0.0233950838,
-0.020075934,
0.0028448924,
0.0343584605,
-0.0139919557,
-0.0128438817,
-0.0553138927,
-0.0244423747,
-0.0224404559,
-0.0200248193,
-0.0639150366,
-0.0030074911,
0.0398317799,
-0.0091230143,
-0.0272189397,
0.0289567672,
1.808802838e-34,
0.0070340759,
0.0240207408,
0.0224189665,
0.0030717421,
0.041469723,
0.0154148676,
0.0236698352,
-0.0000181617,
0.0545518175,
-0.0088921217,
0.0051774452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09724v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09724v2 | OVM, Outcome-supervised Value Models for Planning in Mathematical Reasoning | 2023-11-16T09:56:28 | 2024-04-01T13:50:51 | Fei Yu, Anningzhe Gao, Benyou Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often struggle with maintaining accuracy
throughout multiple multiple reasoning steps, especially in mathematical
reasoning where an error in earlier steps can propagate to subsequent ones and
it ultimately leading to an incorrect answer. To reduce error propagation,
guided decoding is employed to direct the LM decoding on a step-by-step basis.
We argue that in guided decoding, assessing the potential of an incomplete
reasoning path can be more advantageous than simply ensuring per-step
correctness, as the former approach leads towards a correct final answer. This
transforms the task into a $\textit{value estimation}$ problem in planning.
Inspired by the findings that $\textit{outcome supervision for guided
decoding essentially acts as a value model}$, we propose Outcome-supervised
Value Model (OVM) that employs outcome supervision for training a value model,
which prioritizes steps that lead to accurate conclusions. Furthermore, the OVM
eliminates the need for labor-intensive annotations of step-level correctness,
thereby significantly enhancing its scalability. Our experiments on two
multi-step mathematical reasoning datasets, GSM8K and Game of 24, demonstrate
the superior performance of the OVM model. Notably, in GSM8K, our
$\textbf{OVM-7B model achieves state-of-the-art results among LLMs up to 13B
parameters}$; especially it does not utilize GPT-4 or code execution. These
findings offer a novel perspective on the role of outcome supervision in
training value models for multi-step reasoning tasks and provide theoretical
justification for its advantage in value estimation for guided decoding. | [
-0.0140071362,
0.0683456659,
-0.0029065518,
0.0243194085,
-0.045971483,
0.0170096494,
-0.0174502637,
-0.020189248,
-0.0484828614,
0.0158263519,
0.024256127,
0.0391021445,
-0.0058358083,
-0.0005189602,
-0.0203947052,
-0.055596631,
0.0600151904,
-0.0781640783,
0.0077102184,
-0.0113899671,
-0.0517154485,
-0.009863684,
-0.0348024815,
0.0403161757,
-0.0232410692,
-0.058572121,
-0.0282301195,
-0.0275922269,
-0.0026894032,
-0.0615343861,
-0.0201210007,
0.0562473238,
0.0237820689,
0.0165528916,
0.0000022907,
-0.0315927044,
-0.0446005724,
-0.011105556,
-0.0673981309,
-0.0093655372,
-0.039062731,
-0.0562057719,
0.0085021416,
0.0210231785,
-0.0369315296,
-0.008607896,
0.0121333804,
0.0119232656,
0.0649683177,
0.0664310157,
0.0341484025,
-0.0684418976,
0.0313803479,
-0.0200029612,
0.0230396707,
-0.086720705,
-0.0044970517,
0.0794810057,
-0.0184692424,
0.0413113497,
-0.0378202274,
0.0317467935,
0.0549046621,
0.0281585548,
-0.053321939,
0.0246730186,
0.0170177855,
-0.0207276586,
-0.0090061389,
0.0294644944,
0.0193411596,
-0.012310327,
-0.0039042486,
-0.0237638429,
-0.0087770354,
-0.0146938395,
-0.0302456133,
0.0679719448,
-0.0177350752,
0.0294802003,
0.0305534471,
0.0323707573,
0.0007943476,
0.0123915412,
-0.032664407,
0.094088167,
-0.0342095718,
-0.0350218415,
-0.0139871342,
0.0419161767,
-0.0453454629,
-0.0519613661,
0.0204557739,
0.0673653334,
-0.0287168771,
0.0426827893,
-0.0348419398,
-0.0071379035,
-0.0282145459,
0.0016344683,
0.0253146999,
0.082760483,
0.0029909005,
0.0256395619,
0.0001942774,
0.0427621938,
-0.0177777242,
0.048724331,
-0.0567787848,
0.0508736856,
-0.0199628156,
0.0081175314,
-0.0037287865,
0.0475844629,
-0.0235440992,
0.0120371813,
-0.0588009469,
0.0007670794,
0.0044036573,
0.0711019039,
0.0241254792,
-0.0107923225,
0.0008333157,
-0.0419974476,
-0.0505402125,
-0.0006434663,
-0.0490289889,
0.0251189228,
0.0003790825,
-0.0013951845,
-0.0308679845,
-0.0041073277,
-0.023958981,
-0.0127632199,
0.0138536161,
0.0681027845,
0.0090590445,
-0.0032040789,
-0.035491325,
-0.0538520589,
0.0290000886,
-0.0792350993,
0.0490407869,
-0.0581062175,
0.0339101031,
0.0126989037,
-0.00525659,
0.00350013,
0.0096742073,
0.0119946655,
0.0199471992,
0.0551284626,
0.0675346181,
0.0120089874,
-0.0061905547,
0.0065365676,
-0.0430013016,
0.0636542365,
0.0255706292,
0.0157417431,
-0.0121089537,
-0.0002238903,
-0.0116026448,
0.0319204181,
0.0330369063,
-0.0344144329,
-0.0037298365,
0.0164097194,
0.0409633107,
0.029138295,
0.0144310175,
0.0227301046,
-0.0768754184,
-0.0023029654,
0.0429492667,
0.0319948904,
-0.0067745321,
-0.0235659871,
0.0168697443,
-0.0185070764,
0.0315757804,
0.00211455,
-0.0774439275,
0.0368484855,
-0.029883597,
0.0076211197,
0.0008224807,
-0.021489935,
-0.005529779,
-0.0847228095,
0.0038809762,
-0.002276801,
-0.0044637639,
0.0230416656,
0.0722908974,
-0.0153690996,
-0.064933978,
-0.0022254137,
-0.0247956812,
0.0150681399,
-0.0079565095,
-0.0515520647,
0.0666586235,
0.0232339203,
0.0749038532,
-0.0199971702,
-0.0161351766,
-0.0015820474,
0.0102368062,
-0.0081896661,
0.0149243213,
-0.0212087911,
-0.0082445471,
-0.0446680114,
-0.0258385353,
0.0137532866,
0.0305916313,
-0.000340642,
0.0709974766,
-0.0044431556,
-0.0224528741,
-0.0114600826,
0.0299303718,
0.0280841067,
-0.003835283,
-0.0558672026,
-0.0169611592,
-0.0070508323,
0.0215534437,
-0.0263738278,
0.0192316491,
0.0411593318,
-0.0056162379,
0.0103904866,
-0.0160738938,
-0.0422185175,
-0.0711864084,
-0.073986806,
0.0416713618,
-0.0181729607,
-0.0379788689,
-0.0041223709,
-0.0684954301,
-0.0255676899,
0.030737767,
-0.0251136106,
-0.0123337917,
-0.0122874836,
0.037553139,
0.0363182239,
-0.0552811213,
-0.0349351205,
0.0843386576,
-0.04179902,
-0.016216578,
-0.0147487046,
-0.011173307,
-0.0165752117,
-0.0312303528,
0.0353894383,
0.0177734718,
-0.0208535418,
0.0440650694,
-0.0235709846,
0.0346137993,
-0.0302905217,
-0.0245178062,
-0.0338805579,
0.0063646575,
-0.0047323308,
0.0434894301,
-0.0046246885,
-0.0495167784,
0.0173285473,
-0.0017231723,
0.0005352807,
-0.0147839496,
0.0093855392,
-0.0104847569,
0.0083561996,
0.0072295913,
0.0069888299,
-0.0125884051,
-0.0351467319,
-0.03997254,
0.0043716608,
-0.0191141851,
0.0228510555,
-0.0592189319,
0.0344060771,
-0.0079085976,
-0.007862105,
-0.0095533701,
0.0210550558,
0.0453709625,
-0.0284635071,
0.0176242702,
0.0599887408,
-0.0338547118,
0.0204762779,
0.0325129218,
-0.0355709009,
-0.0649270117,
0.0199606866,
-0.041358795,
-0.0342091881,
-0.0162087753,
-0.02292151,
-0.0002418988,
0.0598885678,
0.0063198786,
0.0348006934,
-0.0724719763,
-0.0009024752,
0.0034184516,
-0.0238989051,
0.0015295733,
-0.0016950754,
-0.0123797981,
0.0756041482,
-0.0045413626,
-0.0371714607,
0.0748545676,
0.0084550176,
0.007952041,
-0.0494228527,
0.0337301306,
-0.0323584825,
0.0482938327,
-0.0123039288,
-0.0155138886,
-0.0263158493,
-0.0414653905,
-0.0094619142,
-0.0075641973,
0.0612968542,
-0.0526137613,
0.0655177012,
-0.0712882504,
-0.0132995313,
-0.006888038,
-0.0271773227,
-0.0517112426,
0.0214367416,
-0.0358375199,
-0.0019980175,
-0.0106716845,
-0.0124523342,
-0.0033052056,
-0.0269234888,
0.0330133401,
0.0391979925,
-0.0311782621,
-0.0163396578,
-0.0325751789,
-0.0287871659,
0.0104301032,
0.0069512506,
0.0427590124,
-0.063799493,
0.0372684896,
0.0501902029,
0.0625303015,
0.0081687532,
-0.0042687282,
0.0297732688,
0.0378658548,
-0.0231730081,
-0.0242298916,
0.0726042688,
0.0359398052,
-0.0810949206,
-0.0285956003,
0.084177658,
0.0385911316,
-0.0226982739,
0.000484531,
-0.0897951499,
0.003142921,
-0.0098961666,
0.0240120906,
-0.0680741817,
-0.0446415842,
0.0251563042,
0.0312203672,
0.0081288377,
-0.0416412875,
0.0044195903,
-0.1067239046,
0.0450363196,
0.0313151069,
0.0136608584,
-0.0133372061,
-0.0138139864,
-0.0288563017,
-0.0128087085,
-0.0023106863,
0.0227811448,
0.0061381613,
0.023811128,
0.0326399393,
-0.0069981776,
-0.0387401655,
0.0196693502,
-0.008064677,
0.0296170227,
0.1012856588,
-0.0166327711,
0.0052526225,
-0.0428930819,
0.0235272888,
0.0084766215,
-0.0198052973,
-0.0375999324,
0.0229097698,
-0.0286199935,
0.0296983887,
-0.0035764512,
0.0478178002,
-0.0255562663,
-0.0558867231,
0.034504924,
0.1110859066,
-0.0557975359,
-0.0100937942,
-0.0223038811,
0.0121287396,
-0.0228090547,
0.045003444,
0.004084046,
0.0011169546,
-0.0534515567,
-0.0348246582,
0.0001189861,
-0.039651785,
-0.0150513286,
0.0148871467,
0.0464603938,
0.0244368892,
-0.0220457055,
-0.0484321043,
0.08219143,
0.0364091545,
-0.029761944,
-0.0342215598,
0.0187985618,
0.0110911755,
-0.0267639216,
0.0216058753,
-0.0388418324,
0.0288533866,
-0.0461295955,
0.0383340046,
0.0017548446,
-0.0358258262,
-0.0225952305,
0.0161984451,
-0.0572871007,
-0.0204813499,
-0.0123632113,
0.0702302456,
0.0252506379,
0.0223673265,
-0.003134446,
-0.0097217606,
0.0203273427,
-0.0338850543,
-0.0016252827,
0.0091940602,
0.0503228046,
0.0571377315,
0.0098764841,
0.0207266528,
0.0134853553,
0.0101041235,
-0.0155874668,
0.0959304646,
-0.0483237505,
0.007009564,
0.0313617028,
-0.0020092307,
0.0219608862,
0.0126239685,
0.0104061514,
-0.0005010885,
0.033930894,
-0.0205701776,
-0.0049273493,
-0.0300404299,
0.0227778852,
0.0291973744,
-0.0271607675,
0.0052556153,
-0.0382108502,
0.025672609,
-0.0163934138,
0.0236628931,
0.0241872072,
0.0035350886,
0.0255316012,
0.0187538657,
-0.0249982774,
-0.0134725198,
0.007207437,
-0.0069008758,
0.0562111214,
0.0109933643,
0.0710228831,
0.0495985523,
0.02078503,
-0.02062531,
-0.034757711,
-0.0065426407,
-0.081305787,
0.0160689093,
-0.0184378959,
0.0271632224,
0.0433338284,
-0.0127708176,
-0.0642981082,
0.0127181103,
0.0064976471,
0.0110947071,
-0.0009674288,
-0.0183118097,
0.058306627,
0.0400926135,
0.0061351978,
-0.0906129777,
0.0353611298,
-0.02617855,
0.0561144948,
-0.038517721,
-0.0089678178,
-0.0324330032,
-0.0569794327,
-0.0415424854,
0.0083963862,
-0.0366292559,
-0.0048575462,
-0.0712985396,
-0.0626178384,
-0.049650427,
0.0337871909,
-0.0056836321,
-0.0431465693,
0.0166265294,
0.0434882753,
-0.0124436524,
-0.0492414087,
0.0077173524,
-0.0046689007,
-0.0341240242,
-0.0250345413,
-0.032421235,
-6.053677255e-33,
-0.0238796659,
-0.0371651053,
0.0878729895,
-0.0296558719,
0.0191886891,
-0.019108478,
-0.0236256588,
0.0298739523,
-0.0001712536,
0.0163677018,
-0.0026317299,
0.0155218029,
0.014450104,
0.003055132,
0.0493775085,
-0.0184643138,
0.0191364754,
-0.035737332,
-0.0545465127,
-0.0262919366,
-0.0009140034,
-0.0243837852,
0.0426324941,
-0.0405360945,
-0.0116654523,
0.0362441316,
-0.0214371756,
0.049788259,
-0.0733666569,
0.0538445637,
0.0022021895,
-0.0343531519,
0.0047003953,
-0.0473152585,
-0.03026223,
-0.0096623991,
-0.0706426501,
-0.0330021679,
0.0332862251,
0.0318836011,
-0.0645179898,
-0.0204429086,
-0.0252825022,
0.026133962,
-0.0377162695,
-0.0357263722,
-0.0248686988,
-0.0178616326,
-0.0192583017,
0.0124079818,
-0.0200991184,
0.0443183221,
0.0094505074,
-0.0285599194,
0.084544085,
0.0401627943,
-0.0132907368,
-0.0042585242,
-0.0096045332,
0.010007605,
0.0065007969,
0.0025224965,
0.0634955466,
0.001604624,
-0.0184426922,
0.0349004865,
0.0423196852,
-0.0375887826,
-0.0601025708,
-0.0073432531,
0.0291338712,
0.0871149525,
0.0200086851,
-0.0382582769,
0.0109960036,
0.0430486053,
-0.0477522388,
0.0165496152,
-0.0262494199,
0.0482231937,
0.0264091939,
0.0021100065,
-0.0443600081,
-0.0156663787,
-0.0733868852,
-0.0028517193,
-0.0355250686,
-0.0180662144,
0.0316560045,
0.0437667333,
-0.0144605655,
0.0031826294,
0.0476527102,
-0.0121366978,
-0.0045219641,
0.0311105624,
-0.0009696399,
0.0434982143,
-0.0401710346,
0.049523782,
-0.0646548644,
-0.0074518854,
0.018279966,
-0.069521144,
0.0134879798,
0.0324565694,
-0.0027260527,
0.010603263,
-0.0266059283,
-0.0216599032,
-0.0520929061,
-0.006746782,
0.0083759893,
-0.0030123405,
0.0813237131,
0.0187926702,
-0.0139032127,
0.026848048,
-0.0157814845,
0.0094607109,
-0.0367238298,
-0.0004871023,
-0.0074812868,
0.0347055197,
0.0052874987,
-0.0090628657,
-0.0377996005,
-0.0284915604,
0.0031132121,
-0.0108070625,
-0.0001965008,
0.0665119588,
2.947e-7,
0.0339661688,
0.0575339645,
0.0291913263,
0.0912341401,
-0.0049378881,
0.057027474,
-0.012709287,
-0.0469869189,
0.0338968821,
-0.0583803803,
0.0410796814,
0.0544830672,
0.0505013987,
0.0399025343,
0.0085997907,
-0.0100155156,
0.0326040424,
0.0044359216,
-0.0449307002,
-0.0110747376,
0.0738434121,
0.0558734424,
0.028829677,
0.000901108,
0.0112453261,
0.0608979017,
0.0532127917,
-0.0028246257,
-0.0110616265,
-0.0054096919,
-0.0200557001,
-0.0473359711,
0.0210223813,
0.0214829054,
0.0139887286,
0.0145541877,
-0.0163731948,
0.0909722596,
0.0145541346,
-0.0146344006,
-0.0468133651,
-0.0034357321,
0.0004931289,
-0.0216548555,
0.0629762933,
-0.0750424489,
-0.0432740897,
0.020967491,
-0.0161142591,
-0.0286913402,
0.0102544418,
0.0431713536,
0.0275995191,
0.021950623,
0.0106455479,
0.035010282,
0.0055576973,
-0.0699758977,
-0.0054180548,
0.0426201299,
-0.0397377536,
-0.0515074208,
-0.0238781329,
0.0457084887,
0.0054217172,
-0.0540842488,
-0.0526216142,
3.07970543e-34,
0.0313183367,
-0.022982398,
0.0405604318,
0.0493076034,
0.0305098761,
0.0069823102,
-0.0049890624,
0.0582460836,
0.0381123647,
-0.0685485825,
-0.0389181748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09721v1 | On Evaluating the Integration of Reasoning and Action in LLM Agents with Database Question Answering | 2023-11-16T09:55:07 | 2023-11-16T09:55:07 | Linyong Nan, Ellen Zhang, Weijin Zou, Yilun Zhao, Wenfei Zhou, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study introduces a new long-form database question answering dataset
designed to evaluate how Large Language Models (LLMs) interact with a SQL
interpreter. The task necessitates LLMs to strategically generate multiple SQL
queries to retrieve sufficient data from a database, to reason with the
acquired context, and to synthesize them into a comprehensive analytical
narrative. Our findings highlight that this task poses great challenges even
for the state-of-the-art GPT-4 model. We propose and evaluate two interaction
strategies, and provide a fine-grained analysis of the individual stages within
the interaction. A key discovery is the identification of two primary
bottlenecks hindering effective interaction: the capacity for planning and the
ability to generate multiple SQL queries. To address the challenge of
accurately assessing answer quality, we introduce a multi-agent evaluation
framework that simulates the academic peer-review process, enhancing the
precision and reliability of our evaluations. This framework allows for a more
nuanced understanding of the strengths and limitations of current LLMs in
complex retrieval and reasoning tasks. | [
0.0467043892,
0.0348244198,
-0.0181112457,
0.0357803144,
-0.0447294898,
0.0071526552,
-0.0148614431,
-0.0170978196,
0.0227850564,
-0.0378085561,
-0.0080554271,
-0.008693222,
-0.044575315,
0.0158057921,
0.0235546865,
-0.0089570675,
0.0170543194,
-0.0370782278,
0.0492055826,
-0.0181162283,
-0.0026419514,
0.0075448584,
0.0077943336,
0.0040398808,
0.0222495887,
-0.0102850404,
-0.0377377607,
0.0080485772,
-0.018419113,
-0.0181723814,
-0.0272954311,
0.0400923006,
0.0243287906,
0.038212005,
0.0000020005,
-0.071875602,
-0.0284835752,
0.0236224495,
-0.0574877337,
0.0070925229,
0.0065457425,
0.0126274535,
0.0296142027,
0.0198690146,
-0.0706659928,
0.0081003541,
-0.0042305272,
-0.0005812354,
0.0493763275,
0.0484137386,
0.0265534855,
-0.013337926,
-0.0014289805,
0.0062705926,
0.0328479968,
-0.0677739382,
0.0161815193,
0.0647753105,
0.0607158057,
0.0323817618,
-0.007400136,
0.0143533386,
0.0157137737,
-0.0022724881,
-0.0108952429,
0.0203425549,
-0.0319883376,
0.0194204114,
-0.0113466261,
0.0388046168,
0.0713561699,
0.0101206778,
-0.0111338226,
0.0198057108,
0.0192353744,
0.0343528502,
-0.0513529107,
0.0354048982,
-0.0070862523,
-0.0208142567,
-0.022513587,
-0.0279275086,
0.0207741205,
0.0072818794,
-0.059594471,
0.0905693397,
-0.0130326841,
-0.0472328402,
0.0231504887,
-0.0106848367,
0.0117885331,
-0.0403362438,
-0.0071716583,
0.0888369009,
-0.0649198294,
0.0453374907,
0.032486517,
0.0410716832,
0.0442063957,
-0.0196081921,
0.0265378896,
0.0291578677,
0.0300057326,
0.0599603988,
-0.0116612371,
0.052570954,
0.0080933832,
0.0457219258,
-0.0303221121,
-0.0360871144,
-0.0946818888,
-0.0245197192,
-0.013577803,
0.0475436412,
-0.0071426821,
-0.0168655068,
0.000099094,
0.0470437445,
0.0084830858,
0.0407476649,
0.0068396702,
0.0384954326,
-0.0138946231,
0.0021467966,
-0.117896691,
0.0155310314,
-0.0437111855,
0.0168487243,
0.0019678394,
-0.0823609382,
-0.0308645312,
-0.0129369851,
0.0006558458,
-0.032836508,
0.0254764743,
0.0750611052,
0.0054830657,
0.0045097829,
-0.0543561764,
-0.0696721897,
0.0294509958,
-0.0717573985,
-0.0235830564,
-0.0617232695,
0.0483170673,
0.016788708,
-0.0470798984,
-0.0248923786,
0.0099630598,
0.0053779632,
0.0184282269,
0.0671008229,
-0.0128760161,
0.0360741988,
0.0258287285,
0.0108776391,
-0.0164975151,
0.0804777667,
0.01910186,
0.0371521264,
0.027933117,
-0.0026823336,
0.0249616336,
0.0012747899,
0.016350098,
0.0203381125,
-0.0021821666,
0.0865873769,
-0.0149382921,
0.0424347036,
-0.0107346997,
0.0494488217,
-0.019173203,
-0.004930221,
0.035606306,
0.0593213215,
0.0133349607,
-0.0193363726,
0.0485123955,
0.0114996806,
0.0170870516,
0.0024666695,
-0.0271869432,
0.0327464454,
0.0016694467,
0.0300914757,
0.013978241,
0.015323583,
-0.0397751071,
-0.0583042055,
0.0071927714,
0.0222246312,
-0.0041065649,
0.0541138425,
0.0286977235,
-0.0046752631,
-0.0327887833,
0.0137512768,
-0.0265852083,
-0.020277245,
0.0146583589,
-0.0628908873,
0.0183185916,
0.0910301358,
0.0642169565,
-0.0315887742,
-0.0293234978,
-0.002663559,
0.0049031926,
0.0130014652,
0.0060901339,
-0.0223020762,
-0.0239274502,
0.0007605006,
-0.0621920973,
-0.0246535186,
-0.0035910776,
0.0075564873,
0.0190659985,
0.0056492779,
0.0055649588,
-0.0427722521,
-0.0216999836,
0.0233146362,
-0.0349266641,
-0.0429854318,
-0.0350827612,
-0.0029303494,
0.021792911,
0.0496376716,
-0.0154972691,
0.0568296127,
0.0574605279,
0.0159084629,
-0.0425581671,
-0.029027313,
0.0413566828,
0.0071102716,
0.0301399138,
-0.0046768128,
0.0061145755,
-0.0359375291,
-0.0173918325,
-0.053730011,
0.037593618,
-0.0152413547,
0.0188380666,
-0.0496391244,
-0.0134777287,
0.0006288777,
-0.0256687943,
-0.0467912629,
0.0444930792,
0.0195452012,
0.008284837,
0.0245480891,
-0.0129063809,
0.0224132482,
-0.0623754375,
0.0204132125,
0.011107807,
0.0253459048,
0.0338285305,
0.015800057,
-0.0030529182,
-0.0630214363,
-0.0308497436,
-0.0672011152,
0.0095072398,
-0.0283986237,
0.0319737084,
0.0302057993,
-0.0044159922,
0.0053158207,
0.0072980076,
-0.0735285282,
-0.0084928805,
0.0347778164,
0.0321129225,
0.0218797214,
0.0348546691,
-0.0180783179,
-0.0339104533,
-0.0076781665,
-0.029334588,
0.0243717339,
0.0182243697,
0.012702791,
-0.0286533292,
-0.0098081864,
-0.0512743108,
0.0037778695,
-0.0030649614,
-0.0206674356,
0.0341468975,
-0.022960173,
-0.0542410649,
0.0557373315,
-0.0206387993,
0.010668763,
0.0319192372,
-0.0409377478,
-0.0787679404,
0.0150471134,
-0.0079254238,
-0.0124496836,
-0.0461431146,
-0.0402134918,
0.005527637,
-0.01358312,
0.0191481225,
0.0028465518,
-0.012936146,
0.0212124251,
0.0406241938,
-0.0475561731,
-0.025840478,
-0.0184173901,
0.0086221481,
0.0600532964,
-0.0017309081,
-0.012497074,
0.0678500682,
-0.0318497047,
-0.017608868,
-0.0210754145,
-0.0133419856,
-0.077009961,
0.0908127874,
-0.0030837129,
0.0003599683,
-0.0750617757,
-0.0056339707,
-0.0454403907,
-0.0562489666,
0.0252500642,
-0.0272037163,
0.0556961223,
-0.0474332273,
0.00665983,
-0.0049488693,
0.0210780539,
-0.0161154792,
0.003437832,
-0.0537894256,
0.0313533209,
0.0135218846,
-0.0103959227,
-0.0045398432,
-0.0068796305,
0.0479889177,
-0.0232068095,
-0.0212535281,
-0.0285107438,
-0.0161667261,
-0.020436259,
0.0473876595,
0.0438871682,
0.0123821702,
-0.0206672773,
0.0616335161,
0.0501781628,
0.028945921,
-0.0429164357,
-0.0188650284,
-0.019649012,
0.0202026293,
-0.0444107838,
0.01953304,
0.020183064,
-0.0171036366,
-0.0704844445,
-0.011043096,
0.0956230834,
0.0319649801,
-0.0073065739,
-0.0137346582,
-0.0360139534,
0.006466425,
0.0251926165,
0.0531840138,
-0.0971435681,
-0.0172003955,
-0.0228860006,
0.005177103,
-0.0087255025,
-0.0322429948,
-0.0203458946,
-0.1169571057,
0.0416334346,
-0.0358500183,
0.0221877415,
0.0066487566,
-0.0373644195,
0.001095695,
-0.03177917,
0.0124728195,
0.070898816,
-0.0042117652,
0.004373827,
0.0063694832,
0.031826023,
0.0041485559,
0.0711571053,
-0.0293210521,
0.0378244929,
0.0535607971,
0.0052475668,
-0.008444502,
-0.0427843481,
-0.0084992452,
-0.0185052343,
0.0270954743,
0.0049306625,
0.0477394648,
-0.0008576,
0.0380931422,
0.0108952112,
-0.0066621555,
-0.051753059,
0.0299571734,
0.0503525361,
0.1073819473,
-0.073932983,
0.0124819074,
-0.0156714041,
-0.0157227647,
-0.0295506939,
0.0874581262,
0.0058289217,
-0.0063909506,
-0.0869010687,
0.0013444111,
-0.0537675284,
-0.0583595671,
-0.0128293252,
0.0216762051,
-0.0080240211,
0.0236157551,
-0.0115853986,
-0.0921128169,
0.0716307834,
0.025701968,
0.0102682114,
0.0581825599,
0.0075905216,
0.0182876792,
0.0009695698,
-0.00824688,
-0.0392929018,
0.0286124349,
-0.0023206861,
-0.0177851729,
0.0059623439,
-0.0505799465,
-0.0077089053,
-0.0518891476,
-0.0343542621,
-0.0262165423,
-0.0154357944,
0.0160720237,
0.0326415263,
0.0076804096,
-0.0083526131,
-0.0285679772,
-0.0068980041,
-0.0124107208,
-0.0549260378,
-0.0075303297,
0.0121247238,
0.0240592603,
0.0009915524,
0.0388958901,
-0.0672085434,
-0.0028276779,
-0.0136960819,
0.0183404814,
-0.0424065515,
-0.0687844306,
0.0390650257,
0.028456619,
-0.0273377281,
0.0399427116,
-0.0234623328,
-0.0013336405,
0.0229500458,
-0.0673818216,
-0.0193489026,
-0.0295306724,
-0.0018595762,
0.0143710645,
-0.0097530587,
0.0334591903,
-0.0284595657,
-0.0204386413,
0.0101435436,
-0.0023066218,
0.0049190521,
0.0310513619,
-0.0274422467,
-0.0116005447,
-0.0132576153,
-0.0206678398,
-0.0030877104,
0.0173711497,
0.0505048372,
0.0217173044,
0.0540494584,
0.0178323332,
-0.0017741388,
-0.0156631377,
0.0158426613,
-0.1118083298,
-0.0792192072,
0.0397149101,
0.0048112189,
0.0142188203,
0.0287177693,
0.0127934804,
-0.0166051108,
0.005425069,
0.000311029,
-0.0225372203,
0.0452890769,
-0.0110892085,
0.0656360239,
0.0447812043,
-0.0296128839,
-0.039098274,
0.0660682097,
-0.0170893446,
0.0229553282,
-0.0293292496,
-0.0557632186,
-0.0254497826,
-0.070303455,
-0.0216016881,
-0.0130639011,
-0.0044932086,
-0.0251803678,
-0.0617453121,
-0.0300295763,
-0.0210583154,
0.0427796431,
-0.0403022952,
-0.0364273861,
0.0467791446,
0.0788305849,
0.0622015968,
-0.0253344346,
-0.0588683672,
-0.0135612283,
-0.0533124655,
-0.0225379318,
-0.0134873502,
-5.722524701e-33,
-0.0300455019,
-0.0609865151,
0.0832753927,
-0.018258797,
-0.0170490425,
-0.0273208413,
-0.039944075,
-0.005670419,
-0.0604112335,
-0.0182313025,
-0.049483031,
0.0324182361,
0.0108245453,
-0.00386191,
0.0473901071,
-0.0381777585,
-0.0008468872,
0.0072281631,
0.0020093531,
0.0017208963,
0.0269249808,
-0.0003828808,
-0.003023074,
-0.0188452657,
0.0471287444,
0.0128212711,
-0.0125720128,
0.03365032,
-0.0650289953,
0.070234023,
-0.0168232657,
0.0452372357,
0.0345455855,
-0.0393919423,
-0.0082388604,
-0.0242366381,
-0.0514236726,
-0.0382365845,
0.0513327941,
-0.007645749,
-0.033589676,
-0.0177391209,
0.0312099885,
-0.0145374211,
-0.0446003824,
-0.0123424027,
0.0269756299,
-0.0329581127,
-0.002089266,
-0.0101405624,
-0.0503960885,
0.0190830436,
-0.0022650098,
0.0295146517,
0.0177568644,
0.0187897813,
-0.0034713736,
0.0343771726,
-0.0395290628,
0.0126621602,
0.0291255657,
0.0256568883,
0.0553096086,
0.0424003489,
0.0275796596,
0.0280923583,
0.0190156568,
0.0070210337,
-0.0406917371,
-0.0144857746,
-0.0320968628,
0.0559527688,
0.0324386656,
0.0686313286,
-0.0428317524,
0.0196481347,
-0.0694754869,
0.0514020659,
0.0260448009,
0.0503839776,
0.0184834115,
-0.0058087013,
-0.0433172286,
-0.0245839693,
-0.0605478771,
0.059445776,
-0.0393874608,
-0.0432450213,
0.0254037753,
-0.0126770167,
0.0093714232,
-0.0192775689,
0.0371117406,
-0.0420818888,
-0.0161365326,
0.0355960131,
-0.0458106026,
-0.000486082,
0.0159636084,
0.0244566351,
-0.0439082496,
0.0295847151,
0.0006930783,
0.0023868915,
-0.0011905248,
0.0316365846,
-0.0207612161,
0.0055536544,
-0.0302899238,
-0.006177214,
-0.0657109618,
0.022815112,
-0.0180268846,
-0.0278262142,
0.0004848862,
0.0174526349,
0.0111419857,
0.0256695226,
0.0013119003,
-0.0108694835,
-0.0115927942,
0.0253904331,
0.0174736008,
-0.0192061085,
-0.0234665815,
0.021397667,
-0.0255583879,
0.0133332312,
-0.0062124417,
-0.0202027336,
0.0004384824,
0.03683047,
2.707e-7,
0.0721261501,
0.0012930896,
0.0129752271,
0.0756044313,
0.0088040708,
0.0226786211,
-0.0195203107,
-0.0066649579,
0.0438082702,
-0.0586265661,
0.0528263412,
0.0434776731,
0.0172359571,
0.056911625,
-0.0533801951,
-0.0154319098,
-0.034941934,
-0.0363767296,
-0.0617823116,
-0.0049737017,
0.0783031732,
0.0499900579,
-0.0243637804,
0.003723949,
-0.0149208084,
-0.0872833878,
0.0308309756,
-0.0233836379,
-0.0034285584,
0.0544420034,
0.0369412638,
-0.0058118822,
0.0343991332,
0.0496806726,
0.0284826215,
0.0022128802,
-0.0355057605,
0.0621678904,
-0.0088486038,
-0.0613486469,
-0.0031039275,
-0.0901245773,
0.0483201258,
-0.0559938513,
0.0903057978,
-0.0134759638,
-0.0313859582,
0.0460326113,
0.0060510654,
-0.0420100689,
0.0033432066,
-0.0127740055,
0.0071584689,
-0.0055322372,
0.0005862852,
-0.0018169689,
0.0328314938,
-0.0365620106,
0.0220863037,
0.0189063828,
-0.0472817682,
-0.0615947284,
0.0054125739,
-0.0017141178,
-0.0186165608,
-0.0496125966,
-0.0098685725,
2.498372964e-34,
0.0511769652,
0.0105962977,
0.0419598036,
0.0463620722,
0.0705413148,
0.018947497,
-0.031781096,
-0.0011862619,
0.0310217515,
-0.0991338044,
-0.0363307968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09718v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09718v2 | You don't need a personality test to know these models are unreliable: Assessing the Reliability of Large Language Models on Psychometric Instruments | 2023-11-16T09:50:53 | 2024-04-01T20:51:03 | Bangzhao Shu, Lechen Zhang, Minje Choi, Lavinia Dunagan, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Moontae Lee, Dallas Card, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The versatility of Large Language Models (LLMs) on natural language
understanding tasks has made them popular for research in social sciences. To
properly understand the properties and innate personas of LLMs, researchers
have performed studies that involve using prompts in the form of questions that
ask LLMs about particular opinions. In this study, we take a cautionary step
back and examine whether the current format of prompting LLMs elicits responses
in a consistent and robust manner. We first construct a dataset that contains
693 questions encompassing 39 different instruments of persona measurement on
115 persona axes. Additionally, we design a set of prompts containing minor
variations and examine LLMs' capabilities to generate answers, as well as
prompt variations to examine their consistency with respect to content-level
variations such as switching the order of response options or negating the
statement. Our experiments on 17 different LLMs reveal that even simple
perturbations significantly downgrade a model's question-answering ability, and
that most LLMs have low negation consistency. Our results suggest that the
currently widespread practice of prompting is insufficient to accurately and
reliably capture model perceptions, and we therefore discuss potential
alternatives to improve these issues. | [
0.0653736144,
0.0573765114,
-0.0348883942,
0.0100301458,
-0.066180028,
-0.0039753416,
0.0428234525,
-0.0237258207,
0.0106579643,
-0.0181473475,
-0.038672246,
-0.0443804637,
-0.010524841,
0.0108096898,
0.0172995646,
-0.0161111262,
0.0413095094,
-0.0140443528,
0.0311633423,
-0.0191779062,
-0.0154879587,
0.0036445193,
0.0019050735,
0.0294486862,
0.0325196534,
-0.0336338766,
0.0042266692,
-0.0310775284,
0.0100363856,
-0.0274217278,
0.0159764718,
0.0673368573,
-0.0034162782,
0.0080128498,
0.0000022471,
-0.0606394783,
0.0302797761,
-0.0068286611,
-0.0255954545,
0.0150713958,
0.0467421152,
0.0349192731,
0.0369343422,
0.0442056283,
-0.0480496772,
-0.006667783,
0.0066810329,
0.0619448163,
0.0379064046,
0.0256525744,
0.0279058032,
-0.0069904584,
0.0210934412,
-0.0206733253,
0.0114768678,
0.0026749664,
0.0395718701,
-0.0517129824,
-0.0302630067,
0.0360635146,
-0.0184939541,
0.0027015025,
0.0175426267,
0.0209264196,
-0.0042995927,
-0.0084262462,
-0.0310545526,
-0.0678343326,
-0.0076834112,
0.0611642748,
0.0799084008,
-0.0169856232,
-0.0564737655,
-0.0315157175,
0.0206606053,
0.0526402183,
-0.0212555472,
0.0430594049,
-0.0024506177,
-0.0571352169,
0.0096544232,
0.0058387797,
0.0034759818,
-0.013725779,
-0.0070224074,
0.0774286389,
0.0177571028,
-0.0471910909,
0.0258673634,
0.0079164943,
-0.0130990967,
-0.0418398269,
-0.0166523959,
-0.0136381192,
-0.0186917093,
0.0395190939,
-0.0053769127,
0.0484244116,
0.0612367243,
-0.0343645848,
0.0172413085,
0.0405226797,
-0.036355447,
0.0062042642,
0.0366918743,
0.0664846674,
0.0149342576,
0.0225286651,
0.000022478,
0.0149575351,
-0.0527197309,
-0.0320502594,
0.0411287993,
-0.001509077,
0.0056533022,
0.002309619,
-0.042714294,
-0.0092854779,
-0.0224133544,
0.0077706482,
-0.0228351429,
0.0072083678,
0.0268178955,
0.0364921317,
-0.1131886467,
0.0590046905,
-0.0218482744,
0.0236634407,
-0.0239386912,
-0.0428199992,
0.0285528786,
-0.0060442244,
-0.00786871,
-0.0202160925,
0.0211721305,
-0.0061674318,
0.0159138255,
-0.0383520387,
-0.0095094359,
-0.0123234717,
-0.0609123372,
-0.0859932154,
-0.014668175,
-0.0533729196,
0.0139034437,
0.0307603534,
-0.0375839919,
-0.0473400429,
0.0314486325,
0.0357675515,
-0.0558791719,
0.0287183952,
0.0275758766,
0.0518476404,
-0.020339597,
0.0128536606,
-0.0004780327,
0.0165969748,
-0.0110658854,
-0.0256588403,
0.028530091,
-0.0444394164,
0.0062527782,
0.0296775419,
-0.0281542558,
0.0223320723,
0.0016673576,
0.0286367014,
0.0204305742,
-0.0112137068,
0.0278099068,
0.0740864277,
-0.0078666257,
-0.034322653,
0.1194341183,
0.0399373472,
-0.0282619204,
0.0078076315,
0.0343395025,
0.0307277255,
0.0442192294,
0.0321319029,
-0.0450118147,
-0.0238544494,
-0.0428316854,
-0.0012794305,
-0.0108101713,
0.0135750007,
-0.0059713572,
-0.0501145087,
-0.0090992767,
0.0078653041,
0.0170171428,
0.0810234696,
0.0098944539,
-0.0433555171,
-0.0137040224,
-0.0135017987,
0.014723721,
-0.0421755612,
-0.0238904655,
-0.0448082574,
0.0531399101,
0.074985005,
0.0055500572,
0.0321039669,
-0.0383669659,
-0.0145773264,
-0.0011539791,
0.0522685163,
0.0797548741,
-0.0057767606,
-0.0044355062,
-0.0032905275,
0.0018056353,
-0.0109271836,
-0.0028888439,
0.0028926956,
0.0115664098,
0.0054185032,
0.0032432508,
0.0016031847,
-0.0047158082,
0.0141693158,
-0.0966788083,
-0.0090662716,
-0.0138335396,
0.0056993663,
0.0336002596,
0.0181303676,
0.0136967311,
0.0196098778,
0.0195377879,
0.0098341964,
-0.0071935048,
-0.0052774153,
-0.040116325,
-0.0032907713,
0.0228307825,
0.0341161862,
-0.023839185,
0.0192243401,
0.0405367725,
-0.0142138265,
-0.0203887653,
-0.0263853744,
0.0005178481,
-0.025100328,
0.0205969214,
-0.0485881604,
0.0253418311,
-0.0532345846,
0.0365437306,
-0.0111295125,
0.0482699797,
0.0251010004,
0.0229157675,
0.0009984565,
-0.0645199791,
-0.0566805862,
-0.0153053924,
0.0116163502,
-0.0008885898,
0.0370217711,
0.002502851,
-0.0820627287,
-0.0444092155,
-0.0680324808,
0.0203661229,
0.0201732498,
0.0031819148,
0.006732618,
-0.0321050771,
-0.0395619646,
0.0165453833,
-0.0608651191,
-0.026697509,
0.0388186872,
0.0514123067,
0.0105817411,
-0.0253983829,
-0.0181686096,
-0.0385477394,
0.0062393839,
-0.0395549014,
-0.0012084997,
-0.0036891552,
0.0541465394,
-0.0027432966,
0.0192097761,
-0.0406802371,
-0.0213521514,
0.0046339408,
-0.026492497,
0.034118522,
0.0206538271,
0.0422314368,
0.0664027929,
0.0281469114,
0.0062250467,
0.0225907397,
0.0073165176,
-0.0631572902,
-0.0140746441,
-0.0210054964,
-0.0310948975,
-0.0146901365,
-0.0878134519,
-0.0186763685,
0.028909171,
0.0528948829,
-0.0008471524,
-0.038279254,
0.0526767001,
-0.0242023915,
-0.0345713347,
0.0350982882,
0.0021783472,
-0.02308462,
0.0550634898,
-0.0093542719,
-0.0146307256,
0.0561890192,
-0.0184537489,
-0.0001495171,
-0.0220465008,
-0.0136937797,
-0.0334364511,
0.059944652,
0.0169294514,
-0.0172795337,
0.0589169152,
0.011888409,
-0.0624920689,
-0.0640688613,
-0.0092733977,
-0.0367303826,
0.0307818986,
-0.0219543725,
-0.0197921302,
0.0251383185,
-0.0379428528,
-0.0586795025,
-0.0682975724,
-0.021810554,
0.0008993561,
-0.001731783,
0.0007258985,
-0.0054721604,
-0.0281989705,
0.0557352528,
-0.0390336812,
-0.056407176,
-0.0080786254,
-0.0032150957,
0.0271998663,
0.0562183373,
0.0407061689,
0.077193737,
-0.0439334214,
0.034732528,
0.013911969,
-0.0402677357,
0.0232191924,
-0.0263479836,
0.0166411493,
0.0290834531,
0.0075643607,
-0.0340148211,
0.0385463648,
0.0472850129,
-0.0321790762,
-0.0205103252,
0.1295946538,
0.0507083759,
-0.0089167785,
0.0047801104,
-0.0011063411,
0.0178664736,
0.0455113947,
0.0138133327,
-0.0107748406,
-0.0144741088,
-0.0100852558,
0.0229539797,
-0.0691801384,
-0.0280547682,
-0.0223393869,
-0.112221092,
0.033467669,
-0.0119055789,
0.0089647248,
0.0332915485,
-0.0525563471,
0.0432321168,
-0.0019973784,
0.0403499529,
0.0123994192,
0.0109413117,
0.0187899694,
-0.0012317209,
-0.0618757866,
-0.0456971899,
0.0726523101,
-0.0136520285,
0.065948613,
0.028603917,
0.0152731556,
-0.0359796695,
-0.0553459488,
-0.003700075,
0.0027355999,
-0.0156494826,
0.0066391947,
0.0290730838,
0.0099327192,
0.0247658417,
-0.0947198868,
0.0110520646,
-0.0204364564,
-0.0030694664,
0.0195246302,
0.033909075,
-0.0017363824,
-0.0487240441,
-0.0243709646,
0.036386352,
-0.004554871,
0.0888252035,
0.0009048325,
-0.0840053409,
-0.0055792043,
0.002999115,
-0.012445855,
0.0050534001,
-0.0657595322,
0.0279941857,
0.0176491141,
0.0033174516,
-0.0221515354,
-0.0834843665,
0.0291643962,
-0.0182683002,
-0.0057039657,
-0.0117839286,
0.0219834,
0.0057123224,
-0.0127925696,
0.0215346478,
-0.0212556757,
0.0198825523,
-0.0517320111,
0.0047219777,
0.0705808103,
-0.0398144424,
-0.0067218998,
0.0001644682,
-0.065865621,
-0.0376213714,
0.0388758071,
0.0135510704,
0.0166392941,
-0.0205119979,
0.0269748941,
-0.0162430797,
-0.0083065964,
-0.0119675696,
-0.0269854646,
0.0463738963,
-0.028742956,
0.0708042681,
-0.0133986641,
0.0227747429,
0.0027951244,
0.0095426077,
0.0344957486,
0.0342128687,
-0.0139403781,
-0.0912231058,
0.0384022109,
0.0479585342,
0.0192296319,
0.0238012131,
-0.0170951132,
-0.0153653221,
-0.036707893,
-0.023198979,
-0.0256432686,
0.0000696651,
-0.0411141142,
0.047110036,
-0.0038470442,
-0.010426362,
-0.0525046736,
-0.0425745696,
0.0611545071,
-0.0282832365,
0.0120965224,
0.0217073523,
-0.0000387275,
-0.0190839916,
-0.0100431247,
-0.0359525718,
-0.0155116161,
-0.0054317131,
0.0395876504,
0.0408724844,
0.0892073587,
-0.0244270377,
-0.0110737439,
0.0016716564,
-0.0156761631,
-0.0516192131,
-0.0317145437,
0.0509971455,
0.0451653451,
-0.0171647035,
0.0031156444,
-0.0134666553,
-0.0122757871,
0.0162234195,
-0.048635304,
-0.0100441957,
0.0280857701,
-0.0118990755,
0.0797394738,
-0.0121599417,
-0.0406425968,
-0.0050902688,
0.008454538,
0.0393818021,
-0.0148639539,
0.0020290627,
-0.0311106239,
-0.0380479023,
0.0053348062,
-0.009751617,
0.0174661838,
-0.0414302759,
0.013054831,
-0.1058151275,
-0.040664304,
0.0189414751,
0.0142143415,
-0.0090128165,
-0.0452719778,
-0.0207780432,
0.0642445907,
-0.0172775798,
-0.0386519805,
-0.0292846151,
0.0351717919,
-0.0641973838,
0.0111149568,
-0.0491809919,
-6.667153431e-33,
-0.0150998887,
-0.0244111605,
0.0140813235,
-0.0410617217,
-0.0315261558,
-0.0359096788,
-0.0164189059,
0.049537342,
-0.0360368267,
-0.0262110941,
-0.0309273917,
-0.0078244833,
0.0071074399,
0.0040268037,
-0.0030468539,
-0.031245701,
0.0305781774,
-0.0066968035,
-0.0383516438,
-0.0145752952,
0.0175196584,
-0.0167289954,
0.0205860939,
-0.0615474768,
0.0713306367,
-0.0283630192,
0.0306716431,
-0.0035391799,
-0.0530059338,
0.0545500331,
-0.0247251224,
0.0540314242,
0.035066098,
-0.0215929374,
0.0109830685,
0.0592092983,
-0.0372833088,
-0.056723427,
0.0726600513,
0.0242945757,
-0.0347965062,
-0.0378003456,
0.0303047746,
-0.0030970918,
-0.0528394133,
0.0142413927,
0.0251445957,
-0.0280080941,
0.0197117496,
0.0350876376,
-0.0212671366,
-0.0143802343,
-0.0040532136,
-0.0147024961,
-0.0768003687,
0.0577072799,
-0.0402885675,
0.0050211283,
-0.0576478653,
0.0309957024,
0.0075361785,
-0.0252803713,
0.0467125587,
0.0211171638,
0.0192348137,
0.0529622138,
0.0545289293,
0.0602670684,
0.0139358398,
-0.0307802856,
0.0493853986,
-0.0006742968,
0.0393647887,
0.059679579,
-0.0224479903,
-0.0172181148,
-0.0045636394,
-0.0211255532,
0.0791975111,
-0.0332574733,
0.088592045,
-0.0224894062,
-0.0346730985,
-0.0415559597,
-0.0842212588,
-0.0211125799,
-0.0209976304,
-0.027643241,
0.0543515794,
-0.0235175882,
0.0090664569,
-0.0421005227,
0.0406885445,
-0.026358353,
-0.0273543634,
0.021532258,
-0.0399153754,
0.0374924354,
0.007874717,
0.0462826975,
-0.072856009,
0.0592588522,
-0.0235394072,
0.0066063446,
0.0211822968,
0.0128229614,
-0.0140914926,
-0.0141217206,
-0.0602442659,
-0.0339055955,
-0.0055841659,
0.0238017347,
-0.0052355379,
0.0157770719,
0.0494657829,
0.0410169475,
-0.0072878781,
0.0275288727,
-0.0110938549,
-0.0381585546,
-0.0589477383,
0.0123493541,
-0.0123627558,
0.0182535816,
-0.0023466323,
-0.0090458933,
-0.0273561478,
0.0358024351,
-0.0021432706,
-0.0333452933,
0.0089268414,
0.0251861084,
2.827e-7,
0.0111228731,
0.0669511482,
-0.0390011817,
0.0580347106,
0.0289761182,
0.0508656837,
-0.023939481,
-0.035796456,
0.0725760236,
-0.0337045267,
-0.0168568399,
0.0273009054,
0.0329804868,
0.0051820865,
-0.0457617044,
0.0172675755,
0.000835856,
0.0251576677,
-0.0397027135,
0.042733591,
0.0893226042,
0.0405055061,
0.0151985474,
-0.0013563033,
-0.0352654308,
0.012176103,
0.0564782657,
-0.0178591628,
-0.0286409315,
0.0150700295,
0.0063113864,
-0.0213271007,
0.0428946093,
0.096683383,
0.044068113,
0.0075566568,
-0.0358987264,
0.0609284602,
0.0210704487,
-0.0507319234,
-0.0287239254,
0.0199344829,
0.0128583098,
-0.0610705689,
0.0772338957,
-0.0525192209,
-0.0426661707,
-0.0047177924,
-0.0197323412,
-0.0336331874,
0.0520312786,
-0.0088538276,
-0.0491193943,
0.0015506072,
0.0310692824,
-0.0312073492,
0.0044755372,
0.0030594121,
0.0243053511,
-0.0043341601,
-0.0232010223,
-0.0986729637,
-0.0296110045,
0.0379078873,
-0.0036380577,
-0.0559115149,
-0.0095908754,
2.885455907e-34,
0.0250858292,
0.0437452942,
0.0237660464,
-0.0222975351,
0.0515052751,
-0.0005911585,
-0.0007267477,
0.0313752629,
0.0377193317,
-0.0909202024,
0.0059951837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09712v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09712v1 | Regularized Conventions: Equilibrium Computation as a Model of Pragmatic Reasoning | 2023-11-16T09:42:36 | 2023-11-16T09:42:36 | Athul Paul Jacob, Gabriele Farina, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a model of pragmatic language understanding, where utterances are
produced and understood by searching for regularized equilibria of signaling
games. In this model (which we call ReCo, for Regularized Conventions),
speakers and listeners search for contextually appropriate utterance--meaning
mappings that are both close to game-theoretically optimal conventions and
close to a shared, ''default'' semantics. By characterizing pragmatic
communication as equilibrium search, we obtain principled sampling algorithms
and formal guarantees about the trade-off between communicative success and
naturalness. Across several datasets capturing real and idealized human
judgments about pragmatic implicatures, ReCo matches or improves upon
predictions made by best response and rational speech act models of language
understanding. | [
0.0673021972,
0.0465601087,
-0.0513261892,
0.0242160652,
-0.0530926213,
-0.0260873288,
-0.0785452724,
0.0194540471,
-0.0346593224,
-0.008983938,
-0.03208955,
-0.0296451896,
0.0279649496,
0.0012654001,
0.0152575765,
-0.0516831093,
0.0138143739,
-0.0109451702,
0.0504203811,
-0.0112367151,
0.0404452048,
-0.0196169224,
-0.0190483537,
0.044688791,
-0.0094013466,
-0.0128944982,
-0.0259471014,
0.008606487,
-0.0132416673,
0.0003018431,
-0.0109868133,
0.0069894199,
0.0134113384,
-0.0070076738,
0.0000019541,
-0.0560582541,
0.0140293334,
-0.0670201033,
-0.0045717903,
0.0105530983,
0.023586439,
-0.0550609156,
0.0179852936,
-0.0072490363,
-0.0439149328,
0.0009948299,
0.0554588512,
0.0146410977,
0.0067703524,
0.052795548,
0.0012648245,
-0.0268857051,
0.0001121557,
-0.0293371603,
-0.0269125402,
-0.0995208696,
0.0260595456,
0.0322446004,
0.0167346317,
-0.0351596512,
-0.0486109406,
0.0219148044,
-0.0004126512,
0.0026757994,
-0.0317583084,
0.0267721005,
0.0399839059,
-0.0281720981,
-0.0357102044,
0.0550159179,
0.052129712,
-0.0269771852,
0.0165196806,
-0.0178816207,
0.014199568,
0.0108841285,
-0.0269936007,
0.0079923924,
-0.0113778887,
0.0338475555,
0.0379548222,
-0.0148382951,
-0.002575286,
0.0178241264,
0.0112407766,
0.086732164,
-0.0381423011,
-0.0239017662,
-0.0250195917,
0.0081876991,
-0.0192425195,
-0.0642251596,
-0.0118314214,
0.0247376524,
-0.0536682159,
0.026536135,
-0.0038852119,
0.0142662469,
-0.0007756622,
0.0217590835,
-0.0208958182,
0.0284222849,
0.048658222,
0.0392825194,
0.0479999706,
-0.0187484939,
-0.0166016314,
0.0410360619,
-0.0269242097,
-0.0098147076,
-0.0081821792,
-0.0296504535,
-0.0552980117,
0.0496681668,
-0.0143317273,
0.0185871031,
-0.01858023,
0.0163871925,
-0.0739266425,
0.0054682596,
-0.0192126464,
-0.0002183169,
-0.0700962245,
-0.0178125426,
-0.0517549142,
0.0375962742,
-0.0687443018,
0.0663619265,
-0.0122892065,
-0.0872884542,
-0.0207449254,
-0.0169238318,
0.027045304,
-0.008104261,
-0.0355487354,
0.0712889209,
-0.0028037969,
0.0378573649,
-0.0042650877,
-0.0630510002,
-0.007996507,
-0.0474588498,
-0.0229448453,
-0.0555307381,
0.0200768039,
-0.0170495901,
0.0220474731,
-0.101811111,
-0.0333060771,
-0.0315564461,
-0.047159601,
0.0395492464,
0.0254336391,
0.039043799,
-0.0150258904,
0.0090711946,
-0.0371450484,
0.0871047154,
0.0493051149,
-0.0329533219,
0.043211747,
-0.0174627583,
-0.0123377489,
0.0722447112,
0.0354588367,
-0.0245748758,
0.0164781269,
0.0115271145,
-0.0133335795,
0.0694130734,
0.0738361105,
0.0272882618,
-0.0688178465,
-0.064486064,
-0.0039076307,
0.0681662485,
0.0124864867,
-0.0139788566,
0.0149890296,
0.0404944234,
-0.0052491659,
0.0374068655,
-0.0030309095,
-0.0190197174,
-0.0154259922,
-0.0311421324,
-0.0054664453,
-0.0246496778,
-0.0373249687,
-0.0214928966,
0.0289094876,
-0.0051912707,
0.0070967171,
-0.0064282692,
0.0128126107,
-0.0218140036,
-0.0057223723,
0.0352468677,
0.0077458243,
0.0034170963,
0.0105996057,
-0.0292529836,
0.0408176668,
0.0219993833,
0.0273151137,
-0.0066880188,
0.0509800687,
-0.001099208,
-0.0025300991,
0.0619804189,
0.0510787517,
-0.0240099225,
0.0364883244,
-0.0026084071,
-0.0105417101,
0.0271598138,
0.0087624062,
0.0163134653,
-0.0649565235,
0.0167254377,
-0.0319465473,
-0.0104969209,
0.0413606875,
-0.0024832687,
0.01141294,
-0.0125715164,
-0.0139478603,
0.0064604017,
0.0528917797,
-0.0124445949,
-0.0094937226,
0.0383185148,
0.0050178096,
-0.0075469897,
0.0466581695,
0.0541849658,
-0.0185854379,
-0.0234195217,
0.0220402852,
-0.0662109479,
-0.0254859757,
-0.0063756416,
-0.0000025139,
-0.0286607761,
0.080226481,
-0.0337576494,
0.0779306963,
-0.0354473554,
-0.0213840287,
-0.014567663,
-0.0048887571,
0.0254371893,
0.0352051258,
0.0102537954,
-0.0163511131,
-0.0036372656,
-0.0741554499,
0.001557396,
-0.0638598204,
0.0022379516,
-0.0061593866,
-0.0047976272,
0.0001318415,
0.0359993838,
0.0151845161,
-0.0389872603,
-0.0082928473,
-0.037572965,
-0.0214083698,
0.0180723034,
0.0062308512,
0.0294608418,
0.0063297772,
-0.004196309,
-0.0161568653,
-0.0096702604,
-0.001290955,
0.0056840209,
0.046921093,
0.0357823297,
0.0290788263,
-0.0571735464,
-0.0023394814,
0.0017735629,
-0.0314527638,
-0.0052454625,
-0.0021821642,
0.0386118852,
-0.0623861812,
0.0014025326,
-0.0331689157,
-0.0050562872,
-0.0151397195,
-0.0497724339,
0.0259726178,
0.0343732797,
-0.025073532,
0.045168221,
0.0096740238,
0.0371871479,
-0.0156998951,
-0.025674155,
-0.0639092997,
-0.0110271955,
-0.0383998603,
-0.012874905,
-0.0609694384,
-0.0759368017,
0.0025847331,
0.1032941639,
0.0147156203,
0.0179144721,
-0.0612327792,
0.0140325371,
0.0041416483,
-0.0607013553,
-0.0639106259,
-0.0193742458,
-0.0307175443,
0.0514336675,
-0.0290501844,
0.0048832623,
0.0814730525,
0.011620746,
-0.0082102027,
-0.0234228335,
0.0329907872,
-0.0011014467,
0.0505642891,
-0.0014044849,
-0.0004809886,
0.004888339,
-0.0260758437,
-0.0581478179,
-0.0705785677,
0.0595858805,
-0.0127172545,
0.0533470735,
-0.020834703,
0.025573099,
0.0087117022,
-0.0521428511,
-0.0312932692,
-0.0485600196,
-0.0603134818,
0.0164568685,
0.0353094451,
-0.0079117995,
0.020224601,
0.0226442479,
0.0144203398,
-0.0257457346,
0.0331107825,
-0.0096220169,
-0.0061570564,
-0.0028965932,
0.0447092801,
0.0619795509,
-0.0138165886,
0.0346047059,
-0.0191209931,
0.0601346157,
0.0355246775,
0.0092320722,
0.0257687438,
0.0176597647,
0.0446210615,
0.0022861403,
-0.0279028565,
0.0333112366,
0.0371505432,
0.0046077319,
-0.0045404388,
0.051528044,
0.0005520695,
-0.0371375158,
0.0319338627,
-0.0357648246,
0.0824067667,
-0.0237359237,
0.006597246,
-0.1264609843,
-0.0509682298,
0.0109961899,
-0.0137725472,
-0.0560019016,
-0.0649664551,
-0.0086269313,
-0.0715404376,
-0.0036048526,
0.0129883839,
-0.0722358078,
0.0159309432,
0.0029929103,
0.037287157,
-0.0081803817,
-0.0007554123,
0.0153909596,
-0.0059637609,
0.012684186,
0.0215899888,
-0.0015614663,
-0.0165655576,
0.0201956499,
-0.0102759674,
0.0656468645,
0.0088289017,
0.0927618667,
-0.0023861802,
-0.0820262507,
0.0113582574,
0.0144687491,
-0.0235133208,
-0.0012161286,
-0.0602152869,
0.0085347947,
-0.0035041599,
-0.0133574624,
0.032554727,
-0.0425360091,
-0.0194542632,
0.0311012734,
0.072546497,
-0.0195591263,
-0.0385123566,
0.0008914147,
0.0549267009,
0.0575207919,
0.0665330067,
0.0486044772,
-0.0327672064,
-0.0312159862,
-0.0329663157,
0.0329569802,
-0.0182449836,
-0.0186157506,
-0.0381919853,
0.0658392981,
-0.0446016006,
-0.0514176376,
-0.0259392317,
-0.0047027403,
0.0356858894,
0.0110533573,
0.0008889177,
0.0186587498,
0.0132908644,
-0.0099100349,
-0.0096530896,
-0.0722572356,
0.0071374844,
-0.0246072318,
-0.0201369096,
-0.0318307579,
-0.0448993333,
-0.0591824576,
0.0034179473,
-0.0112153515,
-0.0526015274,
0.0069785127,
0.0238747615,
0.0334330797,
0.0085173575,
0.0098262448,
-0.0458087511,
-0.0820603222,
0.0390056521,
-0.0341036022,
0.0572999641,
0.0452079326,
-0.0387517214,
0.0363712087,
0.0721975267,
-0.0154244415,
0.0193355642,
-0.0319625922,
0.0736535862,
-0.0105316751,
-0.0419197604,
0.0416211449,
0.0068268413,
-0.0042920015,
0.0159885678,
-0.0465506725,
-0.0069130678,
-0.0079951594,
0.0108780768,
0.0079653654,
-0.0190060586,
-0.0289481785,
0.003935372,
0.0189248137,
-0.0028697059,
-0.0325705931,
-0.0350050218,
0.0478668362,
0.0795126706,
-0.0143109085,
0.0948228538,
-0.0038311407,
-0.0019732583,
-0.0121755749,
0.0260496456,
0.0466096736,
-0.030424064,
0.0710167512,
0.0226022657,
0.0252221059,
0.0728657693,
-0.0155453868,
0.0119534275,
-0.0262322165,
-0.0093051828,
-0.0601335354,
0.091304563,
0.0329120047,
0.0547988303,
-0.0109703941,
0.0154275913,
-0.0427170619,
0.0424920321,
0.0122766197,
0.0185361039,
-0.0409946032,
-0.0644584894,
0.0730887651,
0.0354578868,
-0.0124051794,
0.0062479344,
0.0594493747,
-0.0659064949,
0.0382453389,
-0.0527541116,
0.0082912901,
-0.0016263278,
-0.0227621533,
-0.0040083616,
0.0446462706,
0.0047845552,
0.017328443,
-0.0850853547,
-0.0286160912,
-0.018298056,
0.0417029262,
-0.0264827888,
-0.0395435542,
0.0271480512,
0.0455911011,
-0.0237677768,
-0.0037522272,
-0.0250605345,
0.0411589332,
-0.0505131781,
-0.0091840951,
-0.0296004359,
-6.524117809e-33,
0.0048557245,
-0.0351137109,
-0.0038380995,
0.0227343198,
-0.0173634347,
-0.0379468724,
-0.033748284,
-0.0251755528,
-0.0397047289,
0.0319622979,
-0.033681035,
0.020634057,
0.0169500168,
0.0009204564,
-0.0079873949,
-0.0200897306,
0.0005542726,
0.0094289808,
-0.0359134227,
-0.0026014091,
0.0276137032,
-0.0251639206,
0.0645002648,
-0.0238085464,
0.0331295095,
0.0023687044,
-0.0240257382,
0.052481506,
0.017619282,
0.0386772826,
0.0177804418,
0.0468580052,
0.0271199793,
0.018231472,
0.0372253135,
0.0342007391,
-0.0288981851,
-0.0558865331,
0.1147598177,
0.0132127628,
-0.0428702608,
0.0019059225,
0.0292023793,
-0.0042810719,
-0.0513111837,
0.0429706164,
0.0070519932,
-0.0050795306,
0.0026132225,
0.0470391065,
0.000287944,
-0.0147691779,
-0.0287920367,
-0.0007938864,
-0.0150446296,
-0.0151804285,
-0.0185545143,
-0.0150050549,
-0.0507908687,
0.0628742129,
-0.0105581135,
0.0399194062,
0.0327658691,
0.0117151923,
0.0559692793,
0.0620481148,
-0.0012750429,
-0.0127735138,
0.0163767077,
-0.0148708951,
0.0215214044,
-0.0043864627,
-0.0700709,
0.0833758265,
0.045188427,
-0.0111281974,
-0.0301171206,
-0.0156968851,
0.0677210316,
0.0346265472,
-0.0197425,
0.0230187159,
-0.0460110605,
-0.0166964605,
-0.0513385944,
0.0260200724,
-0.0083592515,
-0.0354510583,
0.0023795948,
-0.0244155545,
0.0049542896,
0.0148657998,
0.0297085643,
-0.051568687,
-0.0622757673,
0.0037861906,
-0.0101176053,
-0.0000819839,
0.0069526331,
0.0252481233,
-0.0672821477,
-0.0295316763,
-0.0261760522,
-0.0312607065,
0.023697149,
0.0567636564,
-0.0242140554,
0.0015334726,
0.0118571175,
-0.0219176486,
-0.0287867691,
0.0378408171,
-0.0726583824,
-0.0758059844,
0.0582614094,
0.0527552776,
-0.0127578778,
-0.0055384929,
0.0040084627,
-0.0161038339,
-0.0152979977,
0.0495824143,
-0.0285409912,
0.038652949,
-0.0186453313,
-0.0334267467,
0.0078121959,
0.0031156775,
0.0327160098,
-0.0314656496,
-0.0168329086,
-0.0195239857,
2.886e-7,
0.0253468622,
-0.0184215829,
-0.000733104,
0.0111059938,
0.0297246408,
0.029429866,
-0.0171113219,
0.0346082412,
0.0059777237,
-0.0747905225,
0.0372965075,
0.0122600589,
0.0214687996,
0.0050775269,
-0.0946602523,
0.0155359274,
-0.0233638026,
0.0193165671,
0.0297178682,
-0.0315409377,
0.0338128954,
0.0422008485,
0.0072338246,
-0.0191572681,
-0.0308065806,
-0.0191935394,
0.0473590679,
-0.0620400645,
0.0502296351,
0.0431222022,
0.0269005895,
-0.045121491,
0.0532858483,
0.0429034345,
0.0394402407,
0.0204307176,
0.0018375661,
0.0530846044,
-0.0150256054,
-0.0263246242,
-0.0565186292,
-0.0486055389,
-0.0294104367,
-0.0311474111,
0.0145924464,
-0.066049166,
-0.0590320677,
0.0325819291,
0.0048000948,
-0.0215954818,
-0.025229115,
-0.012756086,
-0.0360825509,
0.0173776504,
0.0275389235,
-0.0128717041,
0.0099716661,
-0.001803966,
0.0129147973,
0.0091130398,
-0.0000070069,
-0.017165957,
-0.0072279037,
-0.0328102373,
0.0075449664,
-0.0742192864,
-0.0108245211,
2.036524677e-34,
0.0291792024,
-0.0040220628,
0.0380013995,
0.0184078589,
0.0243814662,
-0.0179191027,
0.0762659237,
0.0561349429,
0.0638718009,
-0.0223195162,
-0.0056465059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09709v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09709v2 | The Ups and Downs of Large Language Model Inference with Vocabulary Trimming by Language Heuristics | 2023-11-16T09:35:50 | 2024-04-28T23:43:53 | Nikolay Bogoychev, Pinzhen Chen, Barry Haddow, Alexandra Birch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deploying large language models (LLMs) encounters challenges due to intensive
computational and memory requirements. Our research examines vocabulary
trimming (VT) inspired by restricting embedding entries to the language of
interest to bolster time and memory efficiency. While such modifications have
been proven effective in tasks like machine translation, tailoring them to LLMs
demands specific modifications given the diverse nature of LLM applications. We
apply two language heuristics to trim the full vocabulary - Unicode-based
script filtering and corpus-based selection - to different LLM families and
sizes. The methods are straightforward, interpretable, and easy to implement.
It is found that VT reduces the memory usage of small models by nearly 50% and
has an upper bound of 25% improvement in generation speed. Yet, we reveal the
limitations of these methods in that they do not perform consistently well for
each language with diminishing returns in larger models. | [
0.0505700707,
0.086682871,
-0.0306025799,
0.0528704002,
-0.0493361317,
-0.009472793,
0.0109352749,
0.0320452526,
-0.0084485384,
-0.0242916141,
0.0111486213,
-0.0906368494,
0.0096910512,
0.0073496057,
0.0273574125,
-0.0131867453,
0.034526635,
-0.0673409179,
-0.0287152492,
-0.0156507585,
-0.0202038977,
0.0360313281,
0.0598770455,
0.0167005286,
0.0158950239,
0.0135820527,
0.017997738,
0.0181024112,
-0.0154911652,
0.0002010665,
-0.0273253005,
0.0239825435,
0.0108293984,
0.0616899766,
0.0000022703,
-0.0474524908,
-0.0362967439,
-0.0107014244,
-0.0337544158,
0.0511078686,
0.0936274976,
-0.0065602693,
-0.0190516207,
0.0208943393,
0.0193558428,
0.0215981305,
0.0541204624,
-0.0427994505,
-0.0042795218,
0.0447656661,
-0.0110919503,
-0.0145721342,
-0.0447800159,
-0.0569157004,
-0.0415360071,
-0.0288343374,
0.0234788079,
-0.0109038213,
0.0274239276,
0.00419791,
-0.0017799854,
0.0369441099,
-0.0163165387,
-0.0028374884,
-0.0303405393,
0.0360899493,
-0.0137505997,
-0.0448926166,
0.0453583747,
0.0194382258,
-0.0007372338,
-0.0477306582,
0.0138969803,
0.0048823236,
-0.015585714,
0.0181515738,
-0.0519814119,
0.0672604516,
0.005127118,
0.0359966792,
0.0553603731,
-0.0124819204,
0.0533138551,
0.0104093729,
-0.0825877339,
0.0439940281,
0.0566684827,
-0.0079595037,
-0.0171151292,
-0.0220977888,
-0.0169850998,
-0.082220532,
-0.0072312211,
0.0079204123,
0.0162682999,
0.0229856893,
-0.0532664508,
-0.0082170991,
0.0194706786,
-0.0309699457,
0.0495674461,
0.03319031,
0.0266647171,
0.0416269787,
0.0087949727,
0.0264612343,
-0.0128279608,
-0.052004952,
-0.0480665937,
-0.0192865022,
0.0266441256,
-0.014034071,
-0.0288524162,
-0.0003319568,
-0.0246736165,
0.0033111826,
-0.0184802134,
0.0219870042,
0.0039861086,
0.0140955485,
0.0183821376,
-0.0572407171,
-0.0154661471,
0.0114733661,
0.0034694546,
0.0280847047,
-0.0093047386,
-0.0330130421,
-0.051770281,
-0.0662014857,
-0.0148148946,
0.0345560908,
0.0042972383,
-0.052310463,
0.0289131664,
0.0923340619,
0.0200741086,
-0.056572102,
-0.0241781101,
-0.0071760081,
-0.0356718414,
-0.0658875406,
0.0164060555,
-0.0923534706,
0.0054269424,
0.0066272649,
0.0081413286,
-0.0531968735,
0.0114904149,
0.0099489409,
-0.0470857769,
0.0464517251,
-0.0015981509,
0.0240137409,
0.013342157,
-0.0197329763,
0.0408817455,
0.0892637521,
0.0347228609,
0.0381194167,
0.058665745,
-0.0266319625,
-0.0403023623,
0.0864561871,
0.0064182058,
0.0385862067,
-0.0811522007,
-0.0234894361,
0.0320185609,
-0.0107166227,
0.0303904749,
0.0612926111,
0.0026743419,
-0.0018159373,
0.0487929359,
0.0861401185,
-0.0431810841,
0.0092086215,
0.0481569692,
0.0308059249,
0.0013456092,
-0.0159145985,
-0.0166411083,
-0.0116791474,
-0.0015156408,
-0.0057070293,
0.0152539453,
0.0664383173,
-0.011731483,
-0.0106270369,
-0.0493171327,
-0.0064200717,
0.0293883141,
0.0268107913,
0.0753384158,
-0.0243911557,
-0.0245572776,
0.0748481899,
0.0712328404,
-0.0419409163,
0.0002814447,
-0.0416833349,
0.0305921491,
0.0366833806,
0.0599753633,
-0.0084727285,
-0.0218773652,
0.0281983241,
0.012574615,
0.0492285378,
0.0366376154,
-0.0039124689,
-0.0016713315,
-0.0410849303,
0.0102590844,
-0.0042424831,
0.0056451769,
0.0450367555,
0.0512435697,
0.0203014873,
0.0261389017,
-0.0558442883,
-0.0546907522,
0.0240683723,
-0.0832487345,
-0.0173855871,
-0.008368629,
-0.0158246793,
0.0445242599,
-0.0114827547,
-0.0416751951,
-0.0047390098,
0.0156509485,
-0.0357431658,
0.0118990755,
-0.0154229719,
-0.0057736286,
0.0115413284,
0.0694029257,
0.0160860624,
0.0145651959,
0.0286075361,
-0.022355983,
-0.0199141447,
0.0181955248,
-0.0361089259,
0.0169111416,
-0.0245294347,
0.0684567168,
-0.035959512,
0.0297976229,
-0.0346113779,
0.0388212614,
-0.0036413497,
0.0280217696,
0.0358368233,
-0.028484147,
0.0235284604,
-0.0235019252,
-0.044905223,
0.0603161901,
-0.008651467,
-0.0153197711,
0.0344791636,
0.0115268594,
0.0218371842,
-0.0259025097,
-0.0887939632,
0.0212118998,
0.0119338837,
0.022630522,
0.0065404875,
0.0418183394,
-0.0280901548,
0.0099695958,
0.0095352018,
-0.0091329133,
0.0112023046,
0.0230641607,
-0.0067065745,
-0.0245173704,
-0.0334693193,
-0.0334381014,
-0.0315119624,
0.0012848206,
0.0666387007,
-0.0016828687,
-0.0539930277,
-0.028862536,
0.0534052365,
-0.0598091669,
0.0374754407,
-0.0237030163,
-0.0461282656,
-0.0179217998,
-0.0453674421,
0.021360429,
0.0285242591,
-0.0092606507,
0.0106584392,
0.0832037851,
-0.0308283679,
-0.023651218,
-0.0174686369,
-0.0146587389,
-0.0251500309,
-0.0336483531,
-0.0826498419,
-0.0307327006,
0.089222163,
-0.0140056014,
-0.0108670276,
-0.0351879634,
0.0012575771,
-0.0363232307,
-0.0045784637,
0.000722383,
0.0166801009,
-0.0075729447,
0.052811455,
-0.0066706412,
-0.0509351976,
0.0512294509,
-0.0834100991,
0.0115518663,
-0.0260015,
-0.0214258321,
-0.0154677462,
0.0612411276,
0.0222004838,
0.0267005619,
-0.0136174364,
0.0041282275,
-0.0381581485,
0.0358183496,
0.0219280049,
-0.0249398015,
0.0550652593,
-0.0746415332,
0.0281806942,
-0.030611353,
-0.0041752397,
-0.0312274285,
-0.0172123034,
-0.0456679016,
-0.0008695331,
0.0400612205,
-0.0390070081,
-0.0064807017,
0.0488322936,
0.011538568,
0.0513863601,
0.0128388265,
0.045549985,
-0.0127620902,
-0.0004236493,
0.0501639359,
-0.0311918128,
0.0232436154,
-0.0395006612,
0.0365085714,
0.0365127437,
0.0093915565,
0.0081159165,
-0.0005779985,
-0.0208114404,
0.054969769,
-0.029647883,
-0.0267559905,
0.0137611115,
0.030902829,
-0.0512544699,
-0.0138922716,
0.1214430854,
0.0391528979,
-0.0135758612,
0.0171764158,
-0.0282656569,
0.0498552658,
0.0244002007,
0.0329118595,
-0.0709096417,
-0.01640529,
0.0522436611,
0.0059113647,
0.0071309307,
-0.0044832556,
-0.020832466,
-0.1532115191,
0.0356295928,
0.0160615649,
-0.0249489099,
0.0009635562,
-0.0437492207,
-0.0059163938,
-0.0193815921,
-0.0240698606,
0.0128663341,
-0.0139844902,
-0.0188207757,
-0.0007878183,
-0.0141708227,
-0.0462078862,
0.0224888194,
-0.0131881805,
0.0096656187,
0.0202942435,
0.0454155803,
-0.02904802,
0.0191716533,
0.0588042438,
-0.0249163751,
-0.0196700133,
-0.0313581377,
0.057362508,
0.017998049,
-0.0236388557,
0.0164357256,
0.0072434288,
-0.0198063739,
-0.014641596,
-0.0093647931,
0.0648154765,
-0.0106810909,
-0.0406170897,
0.0117118722,
-0.009215815,
-0.0157958791,
0.078054145,
0.0290117115,
-0.0353769436,
-0.0317576155,
-0.0118913464,
-0.0462418124,
-0.0048756339,
-0.0356725231,
-0.0006758587,
-0.0030068278,
-0.0636077076,
-0.041101817,
-0.0175275877,
0.0164064411,
0.0161313098,
0.0279570092,
0.0252715275,
0.002167003,
-0.0011163162,
-0.0348298363,
0.0148672285,
-0.0773750916,
0.006781111,
-0.0482402667,
-0.0003048,
0.0106884688,
-0.0151432622,
-0.021438241,
0.0303507894,
-0.093918018,
-0.0870731175,
-0.0191353746,
0.0325859599,
0.0213558171,
0.0554048829,
-0.0027200386,
-0.0321124867,
0.0207250416,
-0.0133027108,
0.0084633306,
0.0416986793,
0.0041077472,
-0.0259075928,
-0.0051774238,
0.0646993443,
-0.0319679752,
0.0233809687,
0.0174848717,
0.0272909887,
-0.0183461625,
-0.0435537286,
-0.0101171443,
0.0615197755,
-0.0287657194,
-0.0527705252,
-0.0114352554,
-0.038526006,
0.0398690291,
-0.0310525056,
-0.0439314321,
-0.0306793693,
0.0014512413,
0.0082280543,
0.0009666947,
0.0005416446,
-0.0047457851,
0.0061276392,
0.0105554042,
-0.0029164078,
0.0144626694,
-0.0133242328,
0.0041006962,
0.0527005754,
0.0053334553,
-0.0057398761,
0.0059326529,
-0.0210424419,
0.0234835688,
-0.0496673808,
0.0148132136,
0.0028098011,
-0.0185424518,
-0.0229295604,
0.0180401243,
-0.0065247007,
-0.0602499843,
-0.009768812,
0.0259182435,
0.0723588616,
-0.0537399501,
0.0647604913,
-0.0397167727,
-0.0125215631,
-0.0328297988,
0.0167223234,
0.0304673612,
-0.0236571897,
0.0088756401,
0.0057067275,
-0.0480004773,
0.0055589769,
0.0881782696,
0.0473367274,
0.0266751349,
0.0326013342,
-0.0351129211,
-0.0138402143,
-0.0448371135,
0.0048878626,
-0.0062759263,
-0.0281293057,
0.0161808636,
-0.0542844012,
-0.0894901305,
-0.0152139254,
-0.0311762802,
-0.0276841782,
-0.0123542733,
-0.0038061303,
0.0789424777,
0.0108295335,
0.027288219,
-0.0573368333,
0.0246807374,
-0.0187883433,
-0.019849332,
0.01240189,
-6.839367761e-33,
-0.0223060083,
-0.0074462513,
0.0106510893,
-0.0173507761,
-0.009668082,
-0.0190397836,
-0.0669369996,
-0.0390054174,
-0.0078143682,
-0.0126836188,
-0.0159501359,
0.0053043291,
0.0150323194,
0.0167941209,
-0.0044679409,
0.0315263011,
0.0377564579,
0.0369517915,
-0.0307046622,
0.014977199,
0.06197761,
0.032180652,
0.0638171285,
-0.0233603436,
0.0080725094,
-0.0193588212,
0.0474578664,
-0.0005531831,
0.0140872542,
0.0264587086,
-0.0280217398,
-0.0000435906,
0.0164962467,
-0.0315275826,
-0.000909103,
-0.0134867961,
-0.0308761839,
-0.0097497292,
0.0454396345,
0.0057115713,
0.0439327769,
-0.0471513048,
-0.0126799894,
-0.0095918979,
0.0135447532,
-0.0154761588,
0.0083795227,
-0.0312341414,
-0.0188032035,
0.007634188,
-0.0718213916,
0.053473603,
0.0166848674,
0.0167800952,
0.0573574156,
0.0343374386,
0.0097775208,
0.058807414,
0.0018004732,
0.0045785634,
0.0132883014,
0.0768814534,
0.0884329751,
-0.0033109956,
-0.0037284368,
0.0337298177,
-0.0298807304,
-0.0024249065,
0.0129756834,
-0.0055521298,
0.0269697849,
0.0021581112,
0.0310823731,
0.0157329813,
0.0397333056,
-0.0208433829,
-0.0870488584,
-0.007669054,
-0.0273953099,
0.0485191979,
0.0538373403,
-0.0031686223,
-0.0316331089,
-0.0308757573,
-0.0354488678,
-0.0276268851,
-0.0309696514,
-0.0129727228,
0.0256995577,
-0.0135626979,
-0.0771138594,
-0.003046816,
0.0597236082,
-0.0523729734,
-0.0163159668,
0.0458592996,
-0.0181351677,
-0.0105873896,
-0.0061400388,
0.0407304876,
-0.0134250689,
-0.0250082314,
-0.0051041069,
-0.0501974374,
0.0048521995,
0.0152792176,
0.0033446983,
0.0177827999,
-0.0491941646,
0.0005898244,
-0.051942002,
0.0003597754,
-0.0121255498,
0.0681989715,
0.038741678,
0.0132520208,
0.0402373932,
0.0012302676,
0.0848397687,
-0.0216059014,
0.002431242,
-0.0082551185,
-0.0201873947,
0.0112592066,
-0.0328142494,
0.007888983,
-0.0447459631,
0.0516660921,
0.0367798992,
-0.0382537879,
-0.0174661838,
0.0003877409,
2.987e-7,
0.0443599746,
0.0181451067,
-0.0088383835,
0.0371884853,
0.0072762156,
-0.0004715752,
-0.0050391746,
-0.017334966,
0.0089423032,
0.0172405932,
0.002737768,
0.0367560349,
0.0899708122,
0.0232849997,
-0.0719215795,
-0.0034200172,
-0.0517870523,
-0.008139397,
-0.0414982624,
-0.0266403873,
-0.0220863912,
0.1325493306,
0.0088701481,
-0.0169194378,
-0.0248733182,
-0.0882448182,
0.023408005,
-0.0470128432,
-0.014858936,
0.0405981392,
0.000092179,
-0.0080558928,
-0.0153083475,
-0.0109389881,
-0.0355600379,
0.0319615677,
-0.0017062104,
0.0661717579,
-0.0027527597,
0.0667504743,
0.024688933,
-0.0334533006,
-0.0206735544,
-0.0812501609,
0.0816517919,
0.0098267961,
-0.0352462605,
-0.0555008501,
0.0237698313,
-0.0402137078,
-0.0166264009,
-0.0216023903,
-0.0139388004,
0.0307997745,
0.0200000405,
-0.0307074394,
-0.0132154273,
-0.0572212748,
-0.0218239203,
0.0104376692,
-0.0569420271,
-0.0615668371,
-0.0250804685,
-0.0158388466,
0.0099171484,
-0.0482420214,
0.0312331785,
3.42345258e-34,
0.0293329526,
0.0035488014,
-0.0310393777,
0.0375582203,
0.0492775217,
-0.0103565836,
0.0061250455,
0.0264968593,
-0.0243563913,
-0.0773839504,
-0.0225122739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09708v1 | A Self-enhancement Multitask Framework for Unsupervised Aspect Category Detection | 2023-11-16T09:35:24 | 2023-11-16T09:35:24 | Thi-Nhung Nguyen, Hoang Ngo, Kiem-Hieu Nguyen, Tuan-Dung Cao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Our work addresses the problem of unsupervised Aspect Category Detection
using a small set of seed words. Recent works have focused on learning
embedding spaces for seed words and sentences to establish similarities between
sentences and aspects. However, aspect representations are limited by the
quality of initial seed words, and model performances are compromised by noise.
To mitigate this limitation, we propose a simple framework that automatically
enhances the quality of initial seed words and selects high-quality sentences
for training instead of using the entire dataset. Our main concepts are to add
a number of seed words to the initial set and to treat the task of noise
resolution as a task of augmenting data for a low-resource task. In addition,
we jointly train Aspect Category Detection with Aspect Term Extraction and
Aspect Term Polarity to further enhance performance. This approach facilitates
shared representation learning, allowing Aspect Category Detection to benefit
from the additional guidance offered by other tasks. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our framework surpasses strong baselines on standard datasets. | [
0.0221889168,
0.0474596247,
0.0101477923,
0.0408283062,
-0.0190303456,
0.0218002386,
0.0297580939,
-0.0100125568,
-0.0539840311,
-0.0299042445,
-0.0465093143,
-0.0126332659,
-0.0468457416,
0.058486484,
-0.0188261736,
-0.0063596494,
0.0447399467,
0.0338873379,
0.0094041266,
0.0084547475,
0.0050438498,
0.0377635807,
-0.0103006912,
0.0037820004,
-0.0382012464,
-0.0140516795,
0.0126828384,
-0.0175767858,
0.035259068,
-0.0367559008,
0.0216950737,
0.036948096,
0.0130584706,
-0.0288088918,
0.0000019307,
-0.0388845168,
-0.0384041928,
-0.0205979478,
0.045560319,
-0.0439632833,
0.0551152751,
-0.0076788329,
0.0173325818,
-0.0159690324,
-0.0226307865,
-0.0261079855,
0.0276190117,
0.1008746848,
0.0162315331,
0.0632735267,
-0.0418353751,
0.0090136183,
0.0032457055,
-0.0078791073,
-0.0270447209,
-0.0104718748,
-0.0025942135,
0.0143421134,
-0.0478566512,
0.0943755656,
-0.0232982133,
0.0046400088,
0.022828171,
0.0152011272,
0.031733159,
0.0545161292,
0.0386414118,
0.0165468641,
-0.0069847894,
0.0454192683,
-0.0038041396,
-0.0294263437,
0.0152833285,
-0.0488250218,
0.0023130996,
0.0122086843,
-0.0046295878,
0.0057152612,
-0.0113796834,
0.0485332981,
0.0362534001,
0.0125706857,
-0.0073141414,
0.0217843633,
0.0309141483,
0.031960737,
0.000452323,
-0.0551482663,
0.0174673107,
0.0518499091,
0.0156533606,
-0.0204577222,
0.0074560596,
0.0164982397,
0.019196922,
0.0035813712,
-0.0409592763,
0.0277161896,
-0.0115395933,
-0.070470266,
-0.0084070154,
-0.023681283,
-0.0559262745,
0.0655948445,
0.0008583097,
-0.0564116947,
0.0204665493,
-0.0048516211,
-0.0385630727,
0.0056575239,
-0.0592196658,
0.0357808024,
-0.0288771149,
0.0527938455,
-0.0220604297,
-0.0165176168,
-0.020307092,
-0.004326371,
0.0161395632,
-0.031386923,
0.028663801,
-0.0002434469,
-0.0137606673,
0.0025785982,
0.0052247872,
0.0160838589,
-0.0560222417,
0.0410639979,
-0.0543182492,
0.0341756679,
-0.0146919955,
0.0221059471,
0.0315658823,
-0.0215396341,
0.0063750027,
-0.0206861552,
0.0189482961,
-0.0801123381,
-0.036894992,
-0.0457170233,
-0.0382290855,
-0.0427202322,
-0.0194410402,
-0.0607710294,
0.0178307313,
-0.0331623107,
-0.0002885665,
0.0042821583,
0.0137587078,
0.0086996304,
-0.018872397,
0.0517601222,
-0.0296942107,
-0.0129506681,
-0.0266840979,
0.0204224866,
0.0901520774,
0.0607247576,
-0.0206142273,
0.0265209787,
0.0437319279,
0.0221082848,
-0.0033076012,
-0.0229627378,
-0.0064162626,
0.0150511656,
0.0600017272,
-0.0189144444,
-0.0417601354,
0.0101151327,
0.0196764581,
0.0043110815,
0.0023377957,
-0.0264684241,
0.0366564952,
0.0185213964,
0.017245071,
0.0867735669,
0.0391893052,
0.0566360243,
-0.0536921918,
0.0321883634,
-0.0058578253,
0.0440559983,
-0.0228443854,
-0.014211271,
0.0189157054,
0.0166870058,
-0.0628418922,
-0.0578491278,
-0.017119009,
-0.0224721059,
-0.020261351,
-0.0078584729,
0.0803333595,
0.0498911738,
-0.0163242929,
-0.0229128357,
0.066718623,
-0.0622550175,
-0.017622089,
-0.0058197645,
0.0497541428,
0.0445861109,
0.0090410868,
-0.0251385644,
-0.0207535923,
-0.0294390135,
-0.0092914561,
0.01124423,
0.0217111912,
-0.0208234731,
0.026491249,
-0.0340519175,
-0.0306381118,
-0.0198751111,
0.0208351891,
-0.0322497748,
0.0293861181,
0.0387200713,
0.0168893412,
-0.029990511,
-0.0051831934,
0.041089531,
-0.000271173,
-0.043882519,
0.0388108864,
0.0302859079,
-0.0159134548,
0.0479231253,
-0.0170616526,
-0.0403206721,
0.03215589,
-0.0552921072,
-0.0496065207,
0.0357780084,
-0.0618635118,
-0.0182513166,
0.0195637383,
-0.003130107,
-0.0296808761,
0.0058302945,
-0.0038166863,
-0.0193682369,
0.0157766901,
0.0184814185,
-0.0186161716,
-0.0776804909,
-0.0052037793,
0.0229543783,
0.0116861211,
-0.023761984,
0.0710608959,
-0.0037850037,
0.020953849,
-0.0654884949,
-0.0185065679,
0.0327157639,
0.0059267343,
-0.0135272956,
-0.0620406754,
0.0088171083,
-0.0024034916,
0.0338891894,
-0.0059441081,
-0.0324597694,
-0.0049060136,
-0.1136028841,
0.0000999448,
-0.0006185987,
0.0119388299,
0.0323738866,
-0.0013073881,
0.0028832273,
-0.0024654088,
-0.0301402323,
0.012765645,
-0.0239930544,
0.0270392299,
0.0246072039,
0.0074125403,
0.037902724,
-0.0122598941,
0.0110734943,
-0.0306033231,
0.0039636861,
0.0030525005,
-0.0351232812,
-0.0382781439,
0.0474150665,
0.0140694585,
0.0120954532,
0.0152005889,
0.0046806671,
-0.0224227291,
-0.0136996675,
-0.0007617384,
0.0230491385,
0.0072329529,
0.04344365,
0.0491668656,
0.0031718914,
0.000284761,
0.0123894522,
-0.0470856428,
0.0391548797,
-0.0085517298,
-0.001382091,
0.009023183,
0.0766944885,
-0.0369210951,
-0.0157996137,
-0.0358980969,
0.0239335857,
-0.0234541446,
-0.0191554781,
0.0093521811,
0.001299562,
0.0163408499,
0.0305873733,
-0.0288352221,
-0.0003326962,
0.080092296,
0.0163464453,
-0.0045819967,
-0.0575439781,
-0.0288716014,
-0.0370599292,
0.0950381681,
-0.0430361889,
0.0288714729,
0.0499508008,
-0.0066145021,
-0.0225082692,
-0.0194000714,
0.0181173515,
0.0164735876,
0.0245778617,
-0.0037450562,
-0.0071328403,
0.0250847973,
-0.0504564233,
-0.0196000747,
-0.0754606277,
-0.0183872636,
-0.0177472085,
-0.0489593819,
-0.0073865377,
0.0357070081,
-0.0086811082,
-0.0451492853,
0.0000017428,
-0.0130715482,
-0.0066079004,
0.0333908349,
0.0711964667,
0.0778502747,
-0.0273523685,
-0.0022964799,
-0.0310467444,
0.0148977498,
0.0514524542,
-0.0378409624,
-0.0206664391,
-0.0069368579,
-0.0137799783,
0.0122268144,
-0.014529096,
0.0063639944,
-0.0285682809,
0.0768954903,
-0.0283723846,
-0.052259475,
0.1170097813,
0.0393288806,
-0.0329464115,
0.0041602934,
0.0118484721,
-0.0552032217,
0.0337389335,
0.0102396281,
-0.0438219607,
0.0009470942,
-0.0338652022,
-0.0208466332,
0.0177512132,
-0.0021078526,
-0.0154460659,
-0.0837389529,
0.0277825203,
-0.011031705,
-0.0420206636,
-0.0639377907,
-0.0286997128,
0.0167899951,
-0.0379328206,
-0.0389786921,
-0.0336347595,
-0.0017584157,
-0.0089344503,
-0.0110116368,
0.0132829668,
-0.0134921093,
0.0172459073,
-0.0488267653,
0.026999386,
0.0007711375,
0.0144792097,
0.0025021902,
-0.043948967,
0.055792544,
-0.0832651779,
-0.0122092776,
-0.0200468302,
0.074886106,
-0.0713355169,
-0.0082095675,
-0.0020708495,
0.0252383184,
-0.0202035792,
-0.0178347751,
0.0009911148,
0.0317629799,
-0.0085336352,
-0.0180049464,
-0.0243789684,
0.0038945449,
0.0349592641,
0.0674106181,
0.0024078158,
-0.0511090048,
0.0073588924,
0.0460565463,
-0.0228484515,
-0.0378897488,
-0.0541045889,
-0.0463708788,
0.0127849048,
-0.0351381712,
-0.0738015994,
-0.0683603734,
0.0015810784,
0.0330477729,
-0.0032087574,
0.0023029493,
-0.0106378337,
-0.0089665605,
-0.0806023255,
0.0167897213,
-0.0344309062,
-0.0160792526,
0.0308557227,
-0.0367399044,
0.0699049756,
-0.0231932718,
-0.0168684572,
-0.0119337887,
-0.0785203949,
-0.0327750482,
-0.0001708779,
0.002618813,
-0.0018561708,
0.0555228032,
-0.0292139947,
0.0082272813,
0.0118790846,
0.0205256939,
-0.0359918736,
0.0175167024,
0.0426564515,
-0.0011052692,
0.0282775387,
0.0585831292,
-0.0222227536,
0.0779044852,
0.0412043557,
-0.0147116752,
-0.0688569099,
-0.0705753565,
0.0108816912,
-0.0316492617,
0.0871182606,
0.0030674601,
0.0122900484,
-0.0557563119,
0.0087504787,
0.0014573977,
-0.008969564,
-0.0187671874,
0.003167893,
0.0018279641,
-0.0091660218,
-0.0369058773,
0.0932487473,
-0.0205145627,
0.0409104861,
-0.0432725884,
0.0075015281,
-0.0384359509,
0.0054679038,
-0.0688398778,
0.0334973335,
-0.0214911439,
-0.0027377876,
0.0349977873,
0.0126212742,
0.0120525239,
0.0275769625,
-0.0158825871,
0.0130840009,
-0.0247835852,
0.0317401253,
-0.0428042188,
0.0206556842,
-0.0670305341,
-0.0052180602,
0.0138111152,
-0.1000859216,
0.0262086261,
-0.0427595563,
-0.0153456582,
-0.0055643092,
0.0176536012,
-0.0321172252,
0.0077976063,
0.0248983204,
0.0242138784,
-0.0199053288,
0.0084780389,
0.0647883713,
-0.0612133294,
0.0205528345,
0.0614969097,
0.0133644054,
-0.0231950469,
0.0047245286,
-0.0168344826,
0.0575753003,
0.0016373909,
0.0773594454,
-0.0276424941,
-0.0195251871,
-0.018934058,
-0.0092577534,
0.0060854396,
0.0404997654,
0.0634129122,
0.0391175896,
0.0002761656,
0.0440206975,
-0.0280284956,
-0.0342785418,
0.0241909772,
-0.0265079476,
0.026180245,
-6.637673502e-33,
-0.0301958285,
0.0039926507,
-0.0053244065,
0.0359594859,
-0.0064802966,
0.0249107014,
-0.0185600854,
0.0434940718,
0.0001675774,
0.0434424058,
0.0310682971,
0.0285672806,
0.0047860765,
0.0188210588,
0.0106263226,
0.0114766778,
0.0694189519,
0.0009290183,
0.0212717541,
0.023125736,
0.0094879242,
0.0271720979,
0.0914033949,
-0.1333243847,
-0.0190501679,
0.0173598994,
-0.010967223,
0.0160650536,
0.0408295467,
0.0743646547,
-0.020370556,
0.0526307486,
0.0420023575,
-0.0380789712,
-0.0069459351,
-0.0035291174,
-0.0747640207,
-0.0359005928,
-0.0044315592,
-0.0388626531,
-0.0441798419,
-0.0445669629,
0.0006556329,
0.0098644011,
0.0093696499,
-0.0243583526,
0.0462891944,
-0.0380371921,
0.0244808048,
-0.0514526479,
-0.0579872355,
0.0261545926,
0.00862798,
-0.0461061113,
0.0857645422,
-0.01055393,
0.0239393748,
-0.0106579252,
0.0233168509,
0.0323740095,
-0.043574702,
0.0518854894,
-0.0124459583,
-0.0357902274,
-0.0175628886,
0.0857514068,
-0.0067377463,
-0.0056839995,
-0.0034259669,
-0.0212881565,
0.015893735,
0.0085441498,
0.0052831736,
0.0279234219,
0.0280062314,
-0.0265013073,
-0.0475265123,
0.0415513404,
0.0096727703,
-0.0158874597,
0.0149421217,
0.0124571193,
-0.0490964055,
-0.003118403,
0.0181835406,
-0.0585720837,
-0.0559737384,
-0.0326357,
-0.0066508446,
0.057956703,
-0.0369670875,
0.0621886402,
-0.0054076128,
-0.0565557778,
0.0153592564,
-0.0138300331,
-0.0108430376,
-0.0115354806,
0.0312195849,
-0.0084258104,
-0.0825133026,
-0.0260328334,
0.0041928352,
0.042411197,
0.0083292676,
-0.0183751322,
0.0975576118,
-0.0250693969,
-0.1093372032,
-0.0036454943,
-0.0060818507,
-0.0097142151,
0.0022942284,
0.0626515821,
-0.0062105833,
0.0492684692,
-0.0362832509,
0.1204041317,
0.0286837984,
0.0166887138,
-0.0300700273,
-0.0023841299,
0.0135810077,
0.0274274442,
0.030961208,
-0.023380341,
0.012384044,
-0.0189539511,
-0.0133381449,
-0.0406196788,
-0.0400884785,
0.0099692158,
2.637e-7,
0.0136030223,
0.0302680656,
0.0258864202,
-0.0283778124,
0.0251255054,
0.0363028497,
0.0060609197,
0.0352501683,
-0.0335234702,
-0.025686536,
0.0285527483,
0.0489877611,
0.0082324538,
0.0222683996,
-0.0672556609,
0.0768769458,
0.0035336816,
0.004022385,
-0.0541533902,
0.0008887618,
0.0847437456,
0.0818637758,
0.0356638618,
0.0046251188,
0.0223798603,
0.022546377,
0.0351289734,
-0.0257547814,
-0.0388609283,
-0.002167281,
-0.0882993564,
0.0555188693,
-0.0267483406,
0.0013049798,
-0.0250930358,
0.006949822,
0.0094658062,
0.0351495817,
0.0151053816,
-0.0632426888,
0.0215261895,
0.0569367409,
0.0136924172,
-0.007490383,
0.0743082687,
-0.0413902514,
-0.0293857679,
-0.0909876898,
-0.014219488,
0.0591487885,
0.0117766438,
0.0374539383,
-0.0359966867,
0.0062072747,
0.0109387301,
-0.0090294071,
-0.0205505956,
-0.0887564495,
0.0029662051,
0.0544906184,
0.0124582425,
-0.027374709,
0.0188567434,
-0.0229324475,
-0.0067863101,
-0.0442384034,
0.0038869663,
2.150480589e-34,
0.0119866086,
0.0364901423,
0.0131198978,
0.020697115,
-0.033926513,
-0.0178101007,
-0.0494099893,
-0.0545494854,
0.0126553662,
0.0139149576,
-0.0005762363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09707v1 | GenCodeSearchNet: A Benchmark Test Suite for Evaluating Generalization in Programming Language Understanding | 2023-11-16T09:35:00 | 2023-11-16T09:35:00 | Andor Diera, Abdelhalim Dahou, Lukas Galke, Fabian Karl, Florian Sihler, Ansgar Scherp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.PL | Language models can serve as a valuable tool for software developers to
increase productivity. Large generative models can be used for code generation
and code completion, while smaller encoder-only models are capable of
performing code search tasks using natural language queries.These capabilities
are heavily influenced by the quality and diversity of the available training
data. Source code datasets used for training usually focus on the most popular
languages and testing is mostly conducted on the same distributions, often
overlooking low-resource programming languages. Motivated by the NLP
generalization taxonomy proposed by Hupkes et.\,al., we propose a new benchmark
dataset called GenCodeSearchNet (GeCS) which builds upon existing natural
language code search datasets to systemically evaluate the programming language
understanding generalization capabilities of language models. As part of the
full dataset, we introduce a new, manually curated subset StatCodeSearch that
focuses on R, a popular but so far underrepresented programming language that
is often used by researchers outside the field of computer science. For
evaluation and comparison, we collect several baseline results using fine-tuned
BERT-style models and GPT-style large language models in a zero-shot setting. | [
0.0122089228,
0.0778224543,
-0.0246730968,
0.034365274,
0.0062097469,
0.0254572127,
-0.053454794,
0.0325844735,
-0.0385343879,
0.0244720671,
0.0250148345,
-0.0031073974,
0.0044465298,
0.0348028429,
0.044871375,
-0.007660904,
0.0494900867,
-0.0017271221,
-0.0207129326,
0.0322207585,
0.0246881898,
0.0445711985,
0.0040206262,
0.0948922709,
0.0253824666,
-0.02779679,
0.0014314431,
0.0292406473,
0.0173881371,
-0.0037099482,
0.0227516238,
0.0302017629,
0.0534842387,
0.0354655161,
0.0000019769,
-0.0208764635,
-0.0098795705,
0.0030229324,
-0.0153485797,
0.0189573895,
-0.0028469362,
-0.0287395474,
0.0479859561,
0.0175335687,
-0.0221184324,
-0.052924037,
0.0943628624,
-0.07058011,
0.0184593126,
0.0393371731,
0.0159597993,
-0.0295645557,
0.0109820273,
-0.0109817656,
0.07144925,
-0.0216672383,
-0.0192848388,
0.0445918702,
0.0215983819,
-0.0022683074,
-0.0258079283,
0.0217721257,
0.0156183224,
0.0140081057,
0.0240933057,
0.039966397,
-0.098630257,
-0.029260939,
0.0217231158,
0.0201194659,
-0.036671415,
-0.0396286584,
0.0194234941,
0.0019544445,
-0.0476101302,
-0.0098117385,
-0.0286964886,
0.0179717652,
-0.026990898,
-0.0010508412,
-0.0128631275,
-0.0483471043,
0.023392994,
-0.024137171,
-0.0183281153,
0.0849279389,
0.0376701728,
0.0086711934,
0.0017733065,
-0.0156846419,
-0.031103339,
-0.0272211786,
0.0024500515,
0.0099129463,
-0.0212708823,
0.0170183107,
-0.0132213021,
-0.0225530695,
0.0308170132,
-0.0029787698,
0.0228791181,
0.0599266887,
0.0008312123,
-0.0082467534,
-0.0462122746,
0.0790002942,
0.0016224405,
-0.0143010775,
-0.0314603858,
-0.0137329139,
-0.0837830529,
-0.0440271348,
-0.0642862767,
0.0216504317,
0.0014978058,
0.0197736379,
-0.0368984751,
0.0496035665,
0.0302535035,
0.043567162,
-0.0082487175,
-0.0198032595,
-0.0614835955,
0.0106568132,
0.0305877719,
-0.0152566666,
-0.0503361411,
-0.0552066527,
-0.0080597261,
-0.0806451589,
-0.0267138258,
-0.003679595,
-0.0195547938,
-0.0221132729,
0.012024615,
0.0527388453,
0.0321016274,
-0.0075091072,
-0.0300833844,
0.0159538854,
0.0106537025,
0.0028003999,
-0.0018756952,
-0.0706389397,
-0.0236763339,
0.0299568903,
-0.0047927946,
-0.045304928,
-0.0250573568,
0.012180117,
0.0268778522,
0.0394707695,
-0.0740926787,
0.010541128,
0.0331531987,
-0.0065505831,
0.0216231849,
0.0765777826,
0.0090548908,
-0.0302944444,
0.0229317285,
-0.049089279,
0.0471809953,
0.0410761088,
-0.0182566922,
-0.0217464808,
0.0013834483,
0.0518495142,
0.036347203,
0.0145968804,
0.0507052131,
-0.0117716352,
-0.0388649441,
-0.0295858569,
-0.0180965923,
0.0568277612,
0.0039786831,
0.0562707707,
0.0798602253,
0.0350749753,
-0.0187842045,
-0.0393926017,
-0.0007948262,
0.0298904404,
-0.0181330591,
0.0243397374,
-0.012197555,
0.0237586629,
-0.0173509158,
-0.0593602806,
-0.0475523844,
0.0310127717,
0.0022660077,
-0.0118206693,
0.0499227569,
0.012799982,
-0.0376380756,
0.0393392257,
0.0023031791,
-0.0694445446,
-0.0210947823,
-0.0468263775,
0.0218809843,
0.0241906438,
0.0623775311,
-0.0779429898,
-0.0445697121,
-0.0186276473,
-0.0220523626,
-0.0105335927,
0.0239601955,
-0.0081206225,
0.0624729767,
-0.070760034,
-0.0202625357,
-0.0286036525,
0.0075564543,
0.0657816008,
0.0241590682,
-0.0357613973,
0.0223454311,
-0.057845939,
-0.0492244624,
0.0473024063,
-0.0216648113,
0.005211141,
-0.0009981897,
-0.0204515737,
0.0078439321,
-0.0328230336,
-0.0612126626,
-0.006949205,
0.010261599,
-0.0046151797,
0.0002795538,
-0.0356449597,
0.0099946829,
-0.0435876437,
-0.00398253,
-0.0996808931,
-0.0204005502,
0.0356275886,
-0.0436115153,
0.009389746,
0.0503904596,
-0.0346076563,
0.0657850802,
-0.0048685526,
0.0209331438,
-0.0486876443,
-0.010213824,
-0.000769502,
0.036295224,
0.0177007709,
0.0603491068,
-0.0134513853,
0.0131006539,
0.0449991487,
-0.0362340361,
-0.0438495837,
-0.0004924504,
-0.0488135256,
0.0256665349,
0.0533284396,
0.0508269481,
-0.0405435003,
0.0097450092,
-0.0902739018,
0.0425837226,
-0.0172639713,
0.0135984123,
0.0267391428,
0.0191555712,
-0.0014731881,
-0.0129385265,
-0.014904879,
-0.038005203,
-0.0274988972,
0.0012683338,
0.0368233547,
-0.0155582232,
-0.0614259504,
-0.0334873758,
-0.019403914,
-0.0290730409,
0.0650486946,
-0.0205796584,
0.0159729235,
-0.0523162931,
0.0596694611,
-0.0244894028,
-0.0013834023,
-0.0445106737,
-0.0400520414,
0.0260571819,
-0.023778474,
0.0127379308,
0.0353401788,
-0.0250878483,
-0.0158940163,
0.0020500422,
0.0120966332,
-0.0640982464,
0.0322156996,
0.017007539,
-0.0521552563,
0.0096999677,
-0.0430753157,
0.0602417327,
0.1066212133,
-0.0022250952,
-0.0242593046,
-0.0501651056,
-0.0285233632,
-0.011059681,
0.0126201734,
-0.0402254872,
-0.0041247718,
0.018362835,
0.0600724407,
-0.0395048931,
-0.0873323381,
0.0628345907,
-0.0352019519,
-0.0608876124,
-0.0431619398,
-0.0159101337,
-0.0452007875,
0.0516727418,
0.0195973516,
0.0319948606,
0.0058620614,
-0.0377278477,
-0.0255270414,
0.0252876673,
-0.0031520717,
-0.011889033,
0.0737477839,
-0.0261886287,
0.0227540843,
0.0200219154,
-0.0002180866,
-0.0250053164,
0.0236795526,
-0.0018748539,
-0.0033452094,
0.0718231574,
-0.031117361,
0.020549234,
0.0230954457,
-0.0145667186,
0.0517668575,
0.0315444246,
-0.0536919013,
-0.0037580531,
-0.0357683823,
-0.0139203193,
-0.0857153386,
-0.026434226,
-0.0174892694,
-0.0314098671,
-0.024319062,
0.0185067691,
0.0304818265,
-0.0640829802,
0.0129238907,
0.0320780352,
-0.0461371802,
-0.0290763211,
0.0383631848,
0.0624067523,
-0.0436429791,
-0.0444119237,
0.0625089854,
0.0390784331,
-0.0397775993,
0.0013191823,
-0.0186694488,
0.0586526953,
0.0877185911,
0.0342032835,
-0.0604308955,
-0.0139632868,
-0.0031267265,
-0.0026429205,
-0.0086772004,
-0.0195774902,
-0.0164025854,
-0.0961097553,
0.0061413692,
-0.0029906107,
-0.0531084985,
-0.0392363295,
-0.0172623675,
-0.0062361713,
-0.026460994,
-0.0236071199,
0.0196419619,
-0.0141676143,
0.0324396826,
0.0119827976,
-0.058103729,
-0.0060609868,
0.0118930889,
-0.0373332798,
0.0199779365,
0.1085681021,
0.0277158003,
-0.0017072967,
0.006542617,
0.0245266315,
0.0217084419,
-0.0026837143,
-0.0213557966,
0.0757279843,
0.0038541842,
-0.030102035,
0.0424483791,
0.0016355054,
-0.064493373,
0.003617567,
0.0489065759,
0.032888107,
-0.0067706257,
-0.0389499962,
-0.0211972389,
-0.0093066571,
-0.0302450508,
0.043845512,
0.0662129223,
-0.0110893734,
-0.0148642017,
-0.103509374,
0.0388676338,
-0.0613200478,
-0.0317897648,
-0.001936848,
0.0303473342,
0.0212339424,
-0.0039397939,
0.0273873657,
0.0507921726,
0.0060686958,
0.0127873169,
-0.0107846959,
-0.0154769607,
-0.0004507925,
-0.069117032,
0.0207636934,
-0.017855756,
-0.0239369292,
-0.0331130885,
-0.037338879,
-0.0038763487,
-0.0067275534,
-0.0570452474,
0.0265948977,
-0.0883937106,
-0.0196203738,
-0.0493871011,
0.0494201444,
0.0256129857,
0.0200187005,
-0.0366496742,
-0.0609366,
-0.0249776635,
0.0159892719,
0.0112147145,
-0.0221397448,
0.0111930249,
-0.0133096585,
0.0088455491,
0.0008946789,
-0.0498810597,
0.0029010861,
0.0087848967,
-0.0128961951,
-0.0094749136,
0.0263713785,
0.0462416299,
0.0046071759,
0.0247013401,
0.0234261006,
0.0052635358,
-0.0338035971,
-0.0224028137,
0.0230567455,
0.0136815384,
-0.0474311821,
0.0179534983,
0.0239751171,
0.0014610398,
0.0084886476,
0.0196190029,
-0.0515200645,
0.0500604324,
-0.0328664966,
0.0381839424,
0.0330242701,
0.0525185764,
0.077166371,
-0.0109417858,
-0.0012561138,
0.0171456169,
-0.0262728091,
0.0209117774,
-0.0145754078,
0.0289258808,
0.0143996859,
0.0547418185,
0.0491472185,
-0.0113062961,
-0.0523022972,
-0.087277256,
-0.0143964933,
0.0193685573,
0.0324319974,
0.0246489625,
-0.0068850452,
0.0196755491,
0.0229511615,
0.0012839988,
0.0440685749,
0.0026991377,
-0.0372272916,
0.007785507,
0.0386750028,
-0.0352795571,
-0.0591505207,
0.0944279954,
0.0179640222,
0.0421405956,
-0.0182492994,
-0.0280597117,
-0.029573217,
0.0192907266,
0.0450254865,
-0.0295562074,
-0.0051165135,
-0.0130796228,
-0.0165275242,
-0.062586464,
-0.0297417212,
0.0225097705,
0.0326561369,
0.0117133344,
0.0430622399,
0.0977324471,
-0.0180990119,
-0.0581667051,
0.0121782674,
-0.0130718919,
-0.0241013058,
-0.0107344259,
-0.031423796,
-5.735777298e-33,
-0.0096806893,
0.01836887,
-0.005324549,
-0.042668391,
0.0289573334,
0.0216749329,
-0.0234221052,
-0.0136138583,
-0.0218095835,
-0.0201452933,
0.0174650978,
0.0724404231,
-0.0288193561,
-0.0148761831,
0.0303217415,
0.0265597906,
0.0328035429,
0.0274890866,
-0.0354588628,
0.0114356149,
-0.0182569809,
0.0511546209,
0.0753246993,
-0.0067363586,
-0.0093182493,
-0.0127291903,
0.0169704873,
0.0026974003,
0.0278183818,
0.0602969825,
0.0073976037,
0.0215088427,
0.0081886332,
-0.0491853654,
-0.0359679908,
-0.0219356976,
-0.024271721,
-0.0328380391,
0.0416082703,
-0.0150476284,
-0.0124815973,
-0.0383522101,
0.0673793852,
-0.0018735263,
-0.0189452171,
0.0110466806,
0.0383742973,
0.0088820318,
-0.0168820079,
-0.0433106348,
-0.0409244373,
0.0330656245,
-0.0715327933,
0.0103107272,
-0.0160848051,
0.0255216602,
-0.0131176636,
0.0659345612,
0.0371342301,
-0.0007490978,
0.0298584644,
0.0669638813,
0.0552669354,
0.0262781307,
0.027839778,
0.0257414989,
0.0295494515,
0.0042620064,
0.002734229,
-0.0095263179,
0.0402891971,
0.0233973004,
-0.0103353243,
0.0168316849,
0.0763556883,
-0.0052018743,
-0.0424419008,
0.0102843316,
-0.0060973824,
0.0370115861,
0.0374127366,
0.0475662351,
-0.0407521613,
-0.0140262544,
-0.0538401715,
-0.0600796491,
-0.0242559761,
-0.0485475995,
0.0580617711,
-0.0167428367,
0.0002258076,
0.0016492705,
0.0113172298,
-0.0440117829,
0.0253436211,
0.0473900735,
-0.0491197072,
-0.0024189795,
0.0067490041,
0.0617093109,
0.0026410972,
-0.0355355889,
0.0101222722,
-0.0153589295,
0.0767517611,
-0.0243875999,
-0.0010624391,
-0.0014366467,
-0.0436912365,
-0.0101515818,
-0.0539533682,
-0.01091462,
-0.0360182151,
0.0589897111,
0.0194977392,
0.0097833509,
0.0108711561,
0.0396946073,
0.0108337691,
-0.0098611042,
-0.0539157875,
0.0114180213,
-0.013400821,
0.0204408392,
-0.0078492146,
-0.0466237888,
-0.0323027596,
0.0062619885,
0.0566124991,
-0.021936642,
-0.064789027,
0.0307991579,
2.63e-7,
0.0440528505,
0.0280188378,
0.0060137291,
0.0468632169,
-0.0234356131,
-0.0045558782,
-0.0160453022,
0.0089548845,
0.012192416,
-0.0140518965,
-0.0280362964,
0.0146762468,
0.0253405124,
0.0127236089,
-0.0778078064,
-0.0040571112,
-0.0397253819,
0.008456449,
-0.0477540344,
0.0140928486,
0.0308161825,
0.1032525226,
-0.0014745003,
0.0323218741,
0.0161750261,
-0.0578371622,
0.0156175448,
-0.0294600688,
0.0375307947,
0.0611503609,
-0.0491853356,
0.0489494987,
0.0011776276,
-0.0124543961,
0.0039688391,
-0.0058364542,
0.0244294647,
0.0409145206,
-0.0227846336,
0.0397055708,
0.0394832529,
0.0023824612,
-0.0154469712,
-0.0875471681,
0.0309439842,
-0.0358455442,
0.0138985515,
-0.0054089925,
-0.0304258782,
0.004653696,
0.0010925018,
-0.0347285792,
0.0309384149,
0.0264160484,
0.0067759296,
-0.0316211358,
-0.0456369631,
-0.0441219658,
-0.0212142859,
0.0378810242,
-0.0319212675,
-0.0282465275,
-0.073135294,
0.0136103984,
0.0166809708,
0.0072813025,
0.0242367387,
2.634461001e-34,
0.0481268577,
-0.021419134,
0.0007396371,
0.0107505489,
0.0790623799,
-0.0411960967,
-0.0187549815,
0.010384501,
-0.0310974885,
-0.0249507688,
-0.0039682267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09702v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09702v3 | Deceptive Semantic Shortcuts on Reasoning Chains: How Far Can Models Go without Hallucination? | 2023-11-16T09:27:36 | 2024-04-05T18:08:51 | Bangzheng Li, Ben Zhou, Fei Wang, Xingyu Fu, Dan Roth, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the recent advancement in large language models (LLMs) and their high
performances across numerous benchmarks, recent research has unveiled that LLMs
suffer from hallucinations and unfaithful reasoning. This work studies a
specific type of hallucination induced by semantic associations. Specifically,
we investigate to what extent LLMs take shortcuts from certain keyword/entity
biases in the prompt instead of following the correct reasoning path. To
quantify this phenomenon, we propose a novel probing method and benchmark
called EureQA. We start from questions that LLMs will answer correctly with
utmost certainty, and mask the important entity with evidence sentence
recursively, asking models to find masked entities according to a chain of
evidence before answering the question.
During the construction of the evidence, we purposefully replace semantic
clues (entities) that may lead to the correct answer with distractor clues
(evidence) that will not directly lead to the correct answer but require a
chain-like reasoning process. We evaluate if models can follow the correct
reasoning chain instead of short-cutting through distractor clues. We find that
existing LLMs lack the necessary capabilities to follow correct reasoning paths
and resist the attempt of greedy shortcuts. We show that the distractor
semantic associations often lead to model hallucination, which is strong
evidence that questions the validity of current LLM reasoning. | [
0.0637886375,
0.0363594666,
-0.0317876451,
0.0650661513,
-0.0694970265,
0.0268032532,
-0.0123797068,
-0.0030156223,
0.0024809567,
-0.0619516149,
-0.0103963921,
-0.0121473167,
0.0035465639,
-0.0117813209,
0.0264639333,
-0.0222498458,
0.0711300746,
-0.069534272,
-0.0114784781,
-0.0210884791,
-0.0270559192,
0.0150539503,
0.0152530745,
0.015201116,
-0.0046741874,
-0.007601182,
-0.0183005184,
-0.0032145292,
-0.0074559357,
-0.0141305411,
-0.0021757064,
0.0499454588,
-0.0297692008,
0.0808659345,
0.00000206,
-0.0814487189,
-0.0059606112,
-0.0137934843,
-0.0757706761,
0.0222127829,
-0.0422635153,
0.0169902872,
0.0109174745,
0.0068057273,
-0.0143026598,
-0.0203884654,
0.0249038301,
0.0708612651,
0.0288103931,
0.0559572317,
0.0109919198,
-0.0404887907,
0.0163657423,
-0.0314176157,
0.0298584942,
-0.0426137038,
0.0403218493,
-0.0102850627,
-0.0143590216,
0.0044243289,
-0.0262357015,
0.0354599729,
0.0208481755,
0.0412302539,
0.0067226659,
0.0325218886,
-0.0181937777,
-0.0367641561,
0.0104822889,
0.0509850085,
-0.0249462258,
-0.0418655202,
-0.0012446218,
-0.0196894184,
0.0184482802,
0.0395287797,
-0.0182922371,
0.0263582282,
-0.0248616356,
-0.0352891348,
0.0556070916,
-0.0131705711,
0.0540230423,
0.0285721682,
-0.0494412296,
0.0932258964,
0.0185674094,
-0.0335185453,
0.0475723073,
-0.0240833219,
-0.0222898647,
-0.1004477367,
-0.0052467431,
0.0274331421,
-0.060435392,
0.0306986105,
-0.0176150743,
0.0419051945,
0.0573293976,
-0.0380978175,
-0.0274160691,
0.028486168,
-0.0125896353,
0.0834290683,
-0.0415095463,
0.0161145627,
-0.0644529313,
0.0441157296,
0.0001410464,
-0.029800972,
-0.004017802,
-0.037083704,
-0.0248101465,
0.0385405906,
-0.0125982324,
-0.028186122,
0.0167173017,
0.0110675627,
-0.0282019675,
0.0281922799,
-0.023782989,
0.0141964238,
0.0133481417,
-0.0272826683,
-0.0664285272,
0.0101021016,
-0.0597774051,
0.0450067557,
0.0022640463,
-0.0447208695,
-0.0171008073,
0.0104392106,
-0.0233396105,
-0.0366873406,
0.0310132913,
0.0596671812,
0.0113430386,
-0.0340408795,
-0.0272545498,
-0.0521223247,
-0.028978901,
-0.0702689588,
0.0095353154,
-0.0711664483,
0.0063643996,
0.0287640169,
-0.0114786848,
-0.0379700474,
0.0133805685,
0.0314006396,
-0.0795781985,
0.0772958621,
0.0297143571,
0.0075201783,
0.0299899746,
0.0359993242,
-0.0402312353,
0.0704833195,
-0.001932531,
0.0500981137,
0.0159107149,
-0.0177027006,
0.0180842355,
0.0257457271,
0.013523614,
0.0044852472,
0.0015628245,
0.0310960002,
0.0048115002,
0.0255406313,
-0.0030002375,
0.0796073228,
-0.0121338433,
-0.0383676775,
0.0413284376,
0.0007629099,
-0.0261986349,
-0.0067568738,
0.0245386735,
-0.0383999944,
-0.0089825224,
0.0423258767,
-0.1004524902,
0.0170199983,
-0.0417164788,
-0.0101330327,
0.0244567692,
0.0156128462,
-0.0216775909,
-0.0165716279,
-0.0219980311,
0.0264265575,
0.0030557299,
0.0417349525,
0.036808081,
0.0450198539,
-0.0556256659,
0.0695623159,
0.0164297484,
0.0079946518,
-0.0056630578,
-0.0717555285,
0.0319117308,
0.0168124139,
0.0580317155,
0.0036712675,
0.0032595519,
-0.0082491469,
0.0336325914,
0.0350711793,
0.0192530267,
-0.0030198575,
-0.0001186774,
0.0020048344,
-0.0117326761,
-0.0290169735,
0.028292736,
0.0002458,
-0.0053721778,
-0.0131735308,
0.0078806402,
-0.0357191302,
0.0296405088,
0.0464617386,
-0.0127514871,
-0.0097259423,
-0.0446788184,
0.0017584,
0.0037244284,
-0.015317414,
0.0125102708,
0.0431937911,
0.0274653472,
-0.0148023944,
-0.0297046285,
-0.026608577,
-0.0411373191,
-0.0124933096,
0.0202405807,
-0.0232977644,
-0.0280810967,
0.0147612914,
-0.0129220588,
-0.0254582278,
-0.0090545304,
-0.0276364293,
0.0552177094,
-0.0134129953,
0.0650606081,
-0.0008215937,
0.0125373378,
-0.0198143069,
0.1031599939,
-0.0250486694,
0.0368989147,
0.0110741658,
0.032243114,
-0.0095643494,
-0.0138206361,
-0.0026616936,
0.0191145167,
0.0110470215,
-0.0318614058,
0.009424435,
-0.0530789122,
-0.0723760799,
-0.0542242266,
-0.0650530979,
0.0122251576,
-0.0209949724,
-0.0080995141,
0.0070696101,
-0.0019737289,
-0.0036316579,
-0.0071267458,
-0.0054287268,
-0.0187504552,
-0.0197271481,
0.067046769,
-0.0072136722,
0.0026877644,
-0.026492374,
-0.0035002609,
0.0023285367,
-0.0295994282,
0.0517770387,
-0.0143716466,
-0.0267202966,
-0.059502095,
0.0247384291,
-0.0319901891,
0.0105849132,
-0.017869398,
0.0229042955,
0.0227492526,
0.0279121213,
0.0303995963,
0.0806141049,
0.0153718619,
-0.0001586398,
0.0675155818,
-0.0295974854,
-0.0424280018,
0.0181401726,
-0.0074818078,
-0.0168202221,
-0.0186814666,
-0.0593905561,
-0.0189164504,
0.0735358521,
0.0079919873,
0.0037592694,
-0.0365238599,
0.0536247939,
-0.0196421593,
-0.0411704071,
-0.0236754194,
-0.0497660115,
-0.0038197699,
0.0565205216,
-0.0180558302,
-0.0340570249,
0.0785768032,
-0.0305391233,
0.0209335219,
0.0073953513,
0.0278768633,
-0.0180193353,
0.0446852222,
0.0180159118,
-0.0045606135,
0.0021302586,
0.002033625,
-0.0591984168,
-0.0287990309,
-0.0065889284,
-0.0438950881,
0.0414695852,
-0.0335449316,
-0.0041398047,
0.0304490756,
-0.0351568088,
-0.0683220997,
-0.0453899242,
-0.0584831499,
-0.0162382014,
-0.0095219156,
0.011384164,
-0.0247767363,
-0.0059663602,
0.0179039557,
0.0146618364,
-0.0034469655,
-0.0195900183,
-0.0223664287,
0.0112161711,
0.096741952,
-0.0239725728,
0.0801155791,
-0.024550464,
0.0403290614,
0.0744761229,
0.0263428241,
0.0313625783,
-0.000927937,
-0.0090382574,
0.0043073618,
-0.018474916,
-0.0289854184,
0.0198202636,
0.0139941294,
-0.0456707366,
-0.021978844,
0.1129463986,
0.0441924781,
-0.0176699553,
0.0200519506,
-0.0392641239,
0.0662797689,
0.0236866046,
-0.0030489981,
-0.0715678036,
-0.0465616472,
0.0479847938,
-0.0210740063,
-0.0474791378,
-0.0384757183,
-0.0142090358,
-0.1214429736,
0.0181316547,
-0.0154085504,
-0.0031656479,
0.0218825042,
-0.0778967515,
0.0173471086,
0.0004370446,
0.0259823129,
0.0121758794,
0.0088036908,
-0.0218966547,
-0.0082752248,
0.0029871869,
0.012239431,
0.0645601079,
-0.0152820656,
0.0492805205,
0.0540242717,
0.0126610305,
0.0016212635,
-0.0558758676,
0.0399940386,
-0.0384083241,
-0.0057041738,
-0.0209773742,
0.0487231314,
-0.0177045558,
0.007480849,
0.0056723254,
0.0258840863,
-0.0228181295,
-0.0219062716,
0.0432636887,
0.0668144971,
-0.0148649039,
-0.0566164665,
-0.0062447879,
0.0122931702,
-0.0108397659,
0.0972388759,
0.0110272262,
-0.0194525924,
-0.0310608465,
-0.0079046292,
0.0014559933,
0.0433299467,
-0.0489792861,
0.0514523014,
0.052452676,
-0.0045515243,
-0.031458851,
-0.0492551439,
0.027529018,
0.0213395599,
0.0036762415,
0.0620230921,
-0.0265359618,
-0.0007067593,
-0.0091359233,
0.0419379622,
-0.0535066947,
0.0360070877,
-0.0353901684,
0.0298105851,
0.0069997795,
-0.0163434613,
-0.0033352172,
0.0209503733,
-0.083600238,
-0.0553467609,
0.0263193175,
0.0134941759,
0.0356399976,
0.0503983758,
-0.0189565327,
-0.0597603694,
-0.0204554908,
-0.0093638767,
-0.0066629201,
0.0489241183,
0.0034701063,
-0.0169429388,
-0.000893567,
0.0411818624,
-0.0417373143,
0.0110623837,
0.0542437509,
0.0359177403,
-0.0332564488,
-0.0046648788,
0.0458223149,
0.0043278811,
0.0407210849,
-0.0028860071,
0.0184188895,
0.0001979476,
0.0310592372,
-0.0024831148,
-0.0249837358,
0.0055822618,
-0.010557129,
0.0321386233,
0.0060572713,
0.0078539951,
-0.0336745009,
-0.003963646,
-0.0038890045,
-0.0188882127,
-0.0317734294,
0.0164663475,
0.0004652912,
0.0498880781,
-0.0227597319,
-0.024643084,
0.0182483383,
0.0140906675,
0.0860670283,
0.0162973925,
0.0797483325,
0.0358637311,
-0.0209655743,
-0.027451681,
-0.0156199196,
-0.0616464317,
-0.0802869424,
0.0252969731,
0.0222313032,
0.0088060014,
-0.0452405512,
0.0120774526,
-0.0212837774,
-0.0084887426,
-0.0117830373,
-0.0228398275,
0.0330907367,
-0.051145304,
0.0430651829,
0.0340714902,
-0.0249044206,
0.0437804461,
0.0418745279,
0.0020248336,
0.0619717576,
0.0219468325,
-0.00564131,
-0.0239806436,
-0.065225251,
-0.0047262553,
0.0033900412,
-0.0224799905,
0.0013815477,
-0.0869231448,
-0.0882892609,
-0.027584821,
-0.0169539172,
-0.0048873099,
-0.0291942414,
0.0052590193,
0.0851317868,
0.010935327,
-0.044388324,
-0.0191142336,
0.0056199678,
0.0118202837,
-0.0054781414,
-0.0212345626,
-6.806947627e-33,
0.0037532651,
-0.0287465211,
0.0165322125,
-0.0365942679,
0.0171141271,
0.0082486635,
-0.0151929939,
0.0040008258,
-0.0576879829,
0.023476446,
-0.0272642449,
0.0340423696,
0.0110136122,
0.005461527,
-0.0128674414,
-0.0292239916,
0.0253399033,
0.0212257374,
-0.0458943993,
0.0068952809,
0.022669876,
-0.0134971999,
-0.0122943483,
-0.0516658537,
0.0320846327,
-0.0107940659,
-0.0244412702,
0.0635790676,
-0.074387379,
0.0336007141,
-0.0194790252,
0.0094290022,
0.0108963791,
-0.0642859191,
0.0004479595,
0.0332971886,
-0.0663461164,
-0.0239718426,
0.0530869663,
-0.0075009903,
-0.0628635436,
-0.0337164551,
0.0425746851,
0.003184756,
0.0013975833,
-0.0190250073,
0.0016135974,
-0.0142116966,
-0.0374762602,
0.0275361054,
-0.0541472659,
0.0084215775,
0.0076515838,
-0.0203344412,
0.0030258242,
0.0177092366,
0.0006251943,
0.0084158527,
-0.0691231191,
-0.0062706312,
0.0270617492,
-0.0054951152,
0.0631669685,
0.0354060046,
-0.0095760096,
0.078693904,
0.0481767431,
0.0325563923,
-0.017946735,
-0.0094045149,
0.0018104183,
0.0504013449,
0.0621657707,
-0.0043380037,
0.0562995449,
0.0122562908,
-0.0632964671,
-0.0365496725,
-0.031913247,
0.0376399457,
0.0564930774,
-0.0148924971,
-0.0607359186,
-0.0325735062,
-0.0774852037,
0.0342149772,
-0.0495203361,
-0.0070390403,
0.0379658267,
0.0097717792,
-0.0063390527,
-0.021002125,
0.0138160475,
-0.0349956006,
-0.0071831997,
0.0249425881,
0.0097090369,
-0.0108608603,
-0.0086871432,
0.0498336852,
-0.0275318734,
-0.0027966781,
0.0044019464,
-0.021747455,
0.0281392522,
0.0162372515,
0.0114766574,
-0.0280562863,
-0.0737632066,
-0.0158738717,
-0.0493706204,
0.0180038717,
-0.0068006273,
-0.0466088466,
0.0808197409,
0.0265348516,
-0.0122551071,
0.0244044662,
0.041931849,
-0.0088719139,
-0.0412442535,
0.0511939414,
-0.0393506363,
0.007705268,
-0.0138146495,
-0.038780164,
-0.0148440525,
0.0069382018,
0.0455596484,
-0.0655683801,
-0.0100602405,
0.0108279465,
2.819e-7,
0.0160902012,
0.0509964339,
-0.0122712664,
0.0419980027,
0.0012001368,
0.0418341681,
0.026252022,
0.0081082731,
0.0591430552,
-0.0779302493,
-0.0312367976,
0.0323607773,
0.0457681753,
0.0275973622,
-0.07964544,
0.0034043866,
-0.0408614203,
0.0214219987,
-0.0508893989,
-0.0080770133,
0.025568312,
0.0930898637,
0.0242865141,
-0.0091054542,
-0.0369665623,
-0.0489541925,
0.0469371341,
-0.030218374,
0.0147550115,
0.0331243239,
0.0177314021,
0.0070609725,
0.0211709458,
0.0816545412,
0.0223885495,
0.0196522363,
-0.0103380093,
0.013265959,
-0.0072565372,
-0.0386947207,
-0.0565262437,
-0.0234595872,
-0.0000884231,
-0.0798420534,
0.1040820628,
-0.0636006147,
-0.0243883114,
-0.0027810163,
-0.0019642545,
-0.0141717196,
0.0292163696,
0.0210719202,
-0.0174027588,
-0.0047799661,
0.0071284752,
0.0213796925,
0.0065880627,
-0.0748918205,
-0.0290075392,
-0.0004622763,
-0.0220436528,
-0.0386135764,
-0.020802265,
0.0186817888,
0.016003117,
-0.0666976795,
-0.0046563135,
2.680857212e-34,
0.0223093368,
-0.0184082873,
0.0251978841,
0.0347576141,
0.0590302981,
-0.0196783487,
0.0134729259,
0.031670019,
0.0131792873,
-0.0907003582,
0.0032465709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09696v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09696v2 | Fumbling in Babel: An Investigation into ChatGPT's Language Identification Ability | 2023-11-16T09:12:20 | 2024-04-08T20:57:40 | Wei-Rui Chen, Ife Adebara, Khai Duy Doan, Qisheng Liao, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT has recently emerged as a powerful NLP tool that can carry out a
variety of tasks. However, the range of languages ChatGPT can handle remains
largely a mystery. To uncover which languages ChatGPT `knows', we investigate
its language identification (LID) abilities. For this purpose, we compile
Babel-670, a benchmark comprising 670 languages representing 24 language
families spoken in five continents. Languages in Babel-670 run the gamut from
the very high-resource to the very low-resource. We then study ChatGPT's (both
GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) ability to (i) identify language names and language codes
(ii) under zero- and few-shot conditions (iii) with and without provision of a
label set. When compared to smaller finetuned LID tools, we find that ChatGPT
lags behind. For example, it has poor performance on African languages. We
conclude that current large language models would benefit from further
development before they can sufficiently serve diverse communities. | [
0.0480460487,
0.0509360097,
-0.0209933799,
0.0504775308,
-0.0585652664,
0.037173152,
0.0176497325,
0.0040591685,
0.0304583609,
-0.0181777682,
-0.0052452385,
-0.048574619,
0.012121575,
0.0028106293,
0.0314136073,
-0.0517100058,
0.0663228184,
-0.0208878294,
-0.0106911883,
0.0099419756,
0.0142563116,
0.0267283376,
0.0104036639,
0.0463619903,
-0.002336412,
0.0018015282,
0.0013399892,
-0.003221543,
-0.0025844008,
0.0050535365,
0.0129089793,
0.0641385093,
-0.0632934645,
0.1109878346,
0.0000019187,
-0.0326088704,
-0.045444604,
-0.0268363338,
-0.0406402685,
0.0373816043,
0.0566049442,
-0.0033099318,
-0.026496429,
-0.0047487351,
0.0077505256,
-0.0487805232,
0.0896520391,
-0.0187324379,
0.0112859914,
0.0581489094,
-0.0008779574,
-0.0151795428,
-0.0088298805,
0.0001590257,
-0.0036219666,
-0.052282948,
-0.0058275326,
-0.0000396219,
0.0331058316,
0.0081302542,
0.0013977106,
0.0556028336,
-0.0142827174,
0.0031370046,
-0.0512273461,
0.0298871752,
-0.0784438998,
-0.0541870147,
0.002039616,
0.0240769815,
-0.042850107,
-0.0672817752,
0.0148704909,
0.0243509281,
-0.0268864073,
-0.0195977148,
-0.0394013375,
0.0273139495,
-0.0385656059,
0.0115808751,
0.0591148809,
0.0190026518,
0.0380229168,
-0.0140827522,
-0.0123089729,
0.0520889349,
0.0236727931,
0.0158945452,
-0.0049444716,
0.0183677245,
-0.0284562968,
-0.0505164936,
0.0011238822,
-0.0084635429,
-0.0333234109,
-0.0147543652,
0.0181189906,
0.0093584778,
-0.0001126608,
-0.0151488464,
-0.0226909481,
0.0510396659,
-0.0407340936,
0.0418948494,
-0.0169330686,
0.0444845073,
0.0160138458,
-0.0162570383,
-0.0364860855,
-0.0284606218,
-0.0639728308,
-0.0297858156,
-0.0564160049,
0.0040020528,
-0.0336973742,
0.0231699161,
-0.0382845886,
-0.0087158764,
0.0114642885,
0.0060553104,
-0.0275035258,
-0.0587857775,
-0.0155869648,
0.0076677133,
0.030944176,
0.0312937237,
-0.0139025403,
-0.0381993651,
-0.0234162174,
-0.1062351316,
0.0011769955,
0.0172529761,
-0.026944913,
-0.0217856206,
0.0159766115,
0.077778466,
-0.0156875178,
-0.0400284268,
-0.041080147,
-0.0132218348,
-0.0214144196,
-0.0716312826,
-0.0018934112,
-0.0708638057,
0.0326051414,
0.0425224416,
0.0291911792,
-0.0399850719,
-0.0232064947,
-0.0211734101,
0.0023302697,
0.0775736719,
-0.0044886698,
0.0051864092,
0.0261465609,
0.0138167823,
0.0111877015,
0.0884190053,
-0.0396929942,
-0.001773051,
0.0647102445,
-0.0346679576,
0.0177253783,
0.0726613253,
-0.0191340502,
0.0097659454,
0.037203379,
-0.0216946062,
0.063753821,
-0.0163701698,
-0.0011248313,
0.0581232086,
-0.0071927849,
-0.011177402,
0.0529776365,
0.0689740628,
-0.0093990527,
0.0428930707,
0.0136039881,
0.0252170656,
0.0208462439,
0.0124018025,
-0.002352332,
-0.0385917276,
-0.0477419458,
-0.0065723369,
-0.0026777864,
0.0646412894,
-0.0205823295,
0.0215919502,
-0.0516447611,
0.0092495847,
-0.004852877,
-0.0060712649,
0.0461179763,
-0.0295266975,
0.0091355238,
0.0410965793,
0.0673438236,
-0.0169141963,
-0.0016266836,
-0.050090488,
-0.0072754198,
-0.0065217195,
0.0430880673,
0.0022968906,
-0.0332175866,
0.0042354655,
0.0128023913,
0.0463161319,
0.0580698699,
-0.016160408,
0.0225657262,
-0.0168923754,
0.0243041702,
0.0360494778,
0.0147918658,
0.0542887934,
0.0549888872,
0.0169766564,
-0.0007889487,
-0.0438415892,
-0.0060772691,
0.0159011073,
-0.0490503237,
-0.012342928,
0.0166972689,
-0.0213311054,
0.0178164151,
0.0311221797,
-0.0104567278,
-0.0113213062,
-0.035884317,
-0.014104343,
0.0105717257,
0.0287976693,
-0.0251183715,
-0.0567726158,
0.0476597361,
-0.0032868586,
-0.0525119044,
-0.0027246925,
-0.0040334673,
-0.050001923,
0.0511023961,
-0.0112658534,
0.0277119577,
-0.0178082641,
0.0406653434,
-0.011047218,
0.0172331575,
-0.03416951,
0.0562724732,
0.0276909024,
0.0391910151,
-0.0009883485,
0.0035900006,
0.05479436,
-0.0410994664,
-0.053756889,
0.0528421067,
-0.0265158787,
-0.0022162374,
0.0147653753,
0.0358684659,
-0.0348420814,
-0.0351191983,
-0.1042072326,
0.0106963525,
-0.0242613442,
0.0323430151,
-0.0070088892,
0.0536046773,
-0.026832968,
-0.000068936,
-0.0110779982,
-0.0019190207,
0.0182293169,
0.0233142152,
-0.0110368347,
-0.011038919,
-0.02883064,
-0.0124065615,
0.0089301253,
0.024496574,
0.0404928885,
-0.0061195996,
-0.081713587,
-0.0180876404,
-0.0034888755,
-0.0486293212,
0.0166141447,
-0.013787468,
-0.0412983447,
-0.0278280787,
-0.02972381,
0.0125794793,
-0.0204201788,
-0.0504877828,
0.0349514186,
0.0056563029,
-0.0220492221,
-0.0263638087,
-0.0163833965,
-0.0479839072,
-0.0515529923,
0.0048182067,
-0.0298849232,
-0.0087202201,
0.0918895304,
-0.0197561421,
-0.0049598482,
-0.0317742862,
0.0068658711,
-0.0495850556,
0.0246198457,
-0.0392541513,
0.0418505557,
-0.0124166701,
0.042240005,
-0.0181917269,
-0.0561740547,
0.0446270332,
-0.0365740061,
-0.0512263104,
-0.0380063951,
-0.0145735992,
-0.0256949887,
0.0664673373,
0.0007168439,
0.0237960629,
0.0247666799,
-0.064022027,
0.0150361089,
0.0449834727,
0.0525200292,
-0.0219067894,
-0.0084971627,
-0.060470622,
0.0470076017,
-0.03281096,
-0.0614334047,
-0.0163049567,
-0.0157039836,
-0.0367054418,
0.0194117557,
0.0528886691,
-0.0148450937,
-0.0143095721,
0.0449454673,
0.0414669327,
0.0244007558,
-0.0017252653,
0.028822843,
-0.0112162419,
0.0402652062,
0.0107266549,
-0.0198122021,
0.04277445,
0.0057598595,
0.0030182546,
0.0293223169,
0.0230279937,
-0.008261608,
0.0147311864,
0.0135947634,
0.0290982835,
-0.0140279401,
-0.0748337656,
-0.0041702683,
0.0398032367,
-0.0042165956,
-0.0098303594,
0.0932269171,
0.022268597,
-0.0593543686,
0.0007344526,
-0.0018488935,
0.0565922558,
0.0040074247,
0.0256086234,
-0.0966592133,
-0.0326181129,
0.0475244224,
-0.0194118097,
-0.0243575703,
-0.0227820706,
-0.0229487717,
-0.1183343679,
0.0310766194,
0.0238481592,
-0.0431248471,
-0.0001515245,
-0.002961566,
-0.0318701565,
-0.0243236031,
0.0098786419,
0.0131304273,
0.0036310002,
0.0175821278,
0.0404839367,
-0.0424678959,
-0.0749106556,
0.0166427102,
-0.0222480837,
0.0642971098,
0.0065408139,
-0.0219172072,
-0.0306910854,
0.0342658982,
0.0752891749,
-0.0063948389,
-0.0306771994,
-0.0439079702,
0.0296095163,
0.0403336994,
-0.0293769334,
0.0150849661,
-0.0212581325,
-0.027784111,
-0.0012791968,
-0.000402166,
0.0546412766,
0.0167416446,
-0.0242488123,
0.0564108007,
-0.0325171314,
-0.0028234767,
0.057869602,
0.0306681674,
-0.0016091445,
-0.0601179339,
-0.048844479,
0.007517966,
-0.0075595444,
-0.0678871572,
0.0453203581,
-0.0124556608,
-0.0851222277,
-0.0167788137,
-0.0439068265,
0.0418794118,
0.0170482974,
0.0309227183,
0.0343413763,
-0.0176321939,
0.0269409958,
-0.025357293,
0.0299036559,
-0.0334740244,
-0.0030544307,
-0.0926727131,
-0.0274206325,
0.0453730784,
-0.0266990066,
-0.0077006631,
0.0314505696,
-0.1005092561,
-0.0674789175,
0.0231459569,
-0.0099874064,
0.0369566455,
0.0129224043,
-0.0133988587,
-0.0553949438,
-0.03921289,
0.0686641112,
-0.0201633945,
0.0020906252,
-0.0013224713,
0.0158638451,
-0.0063658934,
0.0413836017,
0.0060007018,
0.0263061579,
0.0294094887,
0.0207599998,
-0.0252223518,
0.0141388876,
0.0287083555,
0.0469627939,
0.051515542,
-0.0481698141,
-0.0301502645,
-0.0375551432,
-0.0462794751,
0.0226240475,
0.008210279,
-0.0163980126,
-0.0299572572,
0.0176174417,
0.0032627513,
-0.0181415044,
0.0021512669,
-0.0061997254,
0.0475629047,
-0.01096729,
0.0074747452,
0.0102072917,
-0.0004498753,
0.025014298,
0.0128855724,
0.0008857272,
0.0409472324,
0.0354552716,
0.0668984875,
-0.0429640226,
0.0225913413,
0.0170675404,
-0.0132224169,
-0.0024643277,
0.0124718817,
-0.0134457899,
-0.0135893105,
-0.0099608963,
0.052646488,
0.0963817015,
-0.0150422184,
0.0724555701,
-0.0223943759,
-0.0253191832,
-0.0490725003,
0.02310027,
0.0194199756,
-0.0400041863,
-0.018150324,
-0.0325949304,
-0.0608727522,
0.0108857695,
0.0817403272,
0.0349285007,
0.0140487673,
0.0610332675,
-0.0126371626,
-0.0274672136,
-0.0104696415,
-0.0147316847,
-0.024879219,
0.0054300912,
0.051156681,
-0.0850907341,
-0.0793496966,
-0.026876945,
-0.0152502367,
0.0407387465,
0.0231349096,
0.0018326089,
0.0607196726,
0.025670832,
-0.0145212226,
-0.0525162071,
0.010494885,
-0.0325938947,
-0.0101929568,
0.0063690324,
-6.270101561e-33,
-0.0159250833,
-0.0197321624,
-0.0073600686,
0.029993929,
0.0238086693,
0.0021001883,
-0.0307303164,
0.0510455631,
-0.0184792262,
-0.0031456114,
-0.0403315835,
-0.0363620147,
0.0352294147,
0.006363451,
0.0165284462,
-0.0040538772,
-0.0003356715,
0.0160459355,
-0.0097493948,
0.0258604791,
0.0454664566,
0.0098923016,
0.1095678732,
-0.0405659229,
-0.0007579227,
-0.0409218259,
0.0021137374,
-0.0022466856,
0.0211486761,
0.0500846691,
-0.0478081331,
0.0147813279,
0.0346376151,
0.0120736035,
-0.0037197808,
-0.0419427343,
-0.0835772976,
-0.0459640212,
0.0298212413,
0.0388965048,
0.0240250826,
-0.0371305943,
-0.0076598837,
-0.0341803096,
-0.0564434342,
0.0217692293,
-0.0240559299,
-0.0053077764,
-0.03089834,
-0.0134372627,
-0.0488139167,
0.0649025962,
0.0036911103,
0.010702271,
0.058707919,
0.0193540081,
-0.0345158353,
-0.0246883538,
-0.0080122836,
-0.0009213106,
0.0403541252,
0.0622371659,
0.0630949065,
0.0293214787,
-0.0389184467,
0.0471043922,
0.0450693406,
-0.0226847753,
0.0058993432,
-0.0026012962,
0.0241741594,
-0.0479734316,
0.0347634368,
0.048593428,
0.020738842,
-0.0335677303,
-0.0203518048,
0.0101117818,
0.076867424,
-0.0268469565,
0.0153007135,
-0.0005011452,
-0.0474833921,
-0.0460436232,
-0.0335693955,
-0.0465200618,
-0.0376209505,
-0.0246562101,
0.0586306863,
-0.0336329043,
0.0046940167,
0.0146874366,
0.0623194017,
-0.0132149039,
-0.0210299864,
-0.033208739,
-0.0033482076,
0.0393052623,
0.0032867834,
0.0518946536,
-0.0402010381,
-0.0609282069,
-0.0306069423,
0.0260374621,
0.0186801832,
-0.0186658502,
0.0300703291,
0.000883452,
-0.0450251698,
0.024596015,
-0.0520283133,
0.0663392991,
-0.0279007126,
0.0068928669,
0.0358309411,
-0.0337674841,
0.0204432737,
0.001044589,
0.0819795206,
0.0051180199,
-0.0108470861,
0.0272494759,
-0.0350790843,
0.0043492587,
-0.0321453698,
0.0317629874,
-0.0265071727,
0.0204232763,
0.0058490303,
0.0034043668,
0.028036261,
0.0021974628,
2.697e-7,
0.027815409,
0.0466469899,
0.0334599204,
-0.0270188041,
0.0228796154,
0.0056388895,
-0.0217277277,
-0.0031871668,
-0.007054538,
0.020382259,
-0.0396173149,
-0.0301019587,
0.1108061969,
0.0327450596,
-0.0806536153,
0.0180513412,
-0.0282933339,
0.0135496818,
-0.053899996,
0.0256241169,
-0.0066178232,
0.1319429725,
-0.0033651867,
0.0039124126,
-0.0256463736,
-0.0680189356,
0.0540803857,
-0.0592037439,
-0.0380250849,
0.0275403652,
0.0183150619,
0.0440591462,
0.0222177301,
-0.0085880551,
-0.0159399621,
-0.011010455,
0.0140241776,
0.0462524593,
0.006796536,
0.0271103606,
0.005312359,
-0.0330176316,
-0.0231170971,
-0.0788879469,
0.0737877488,
0.0044679372,
-0.0359356962,
0.0076509584,
-0.0055863224,
-0.0312992074,
-0.0078530731,
-0.0198556185,
-0.0664578378,
0.0459475629,
0.0143628642,
-0.054314062,
-0.0358362719,
-0.0506706424,
-0.0204102322,
0.0064950194,
-0.0152868126,
-0.024040848,
0.0215153452,
0.0001263632,
0.0000104041,
-0.0380601436,
0.0102422265,
2.792183644e-34,
0.0160099138,
-0.0038325707,
0.0054368554,
0.0254908409,
0.0359152108,
0.0025386577,
0.0120203858,
0.0507690161,
-0.0424222611,
-0.0041839406,
0.0111720944
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.