id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14505v1 | Analysing the Impact of Removing Infrequent Words on Topic Quality in LDA Models | 2023-11-24T14:20:12 | 2023-11-24T14:20:12 | Victor Bystrov, Viktoriia Naboka-Krell, Anna Staszewska-Bystrova, Peter Winker | cs.CL | cs.CL | An initial procedure in text-as-data applications is text preprocessing. One
of the typical steps, which can substantially facilitate computations, consists
in removing infrequent words believed to provide limited information about the
corpus. Despite popularity of vocabulary pruning, not many guidelines on how to
implement it are available in the literature. The aim of the paper is to fill
this gap by examining the effects of removing infrequent words for the quality
of topics estimated using Latent Dirichlet Allocation. The analysis is based on
Monte Carlo experiments taking into account different criteria for infrequent
terms removal and various evaluation metrics. The results indicate that pruning
is beneficial and that the share of vocabulary which might be eliminated can be
quite considerable. | [
0.0391291045,
0.0144899068,
-0.025758177,
0.0199873205,
-0.0494574271,
-0.0025413295,
0.0122158714,
-0.0121850157,
-0.1100561991,
-0.0239475556,
0.0312663354,
-0.0254166611,
0.0034012641,
0.0126063265,
-0.0206208415,
-0.0480919369,
0.0332992859,
-0.0153018134,
0.012098372,
0.0100947628,
0.0278774593,
-0.0583520234,
0.0213961247,
-0.0146734975,
0.0311099533,
0.000656748,
0.0166061185,
-0.0407774784,
-0.0321094953,
-0.0182920769,
0.0034608392,
0.0764104798,
-0.0102048544,
-0.0550711825,
0.0000018802,
-0.0318725817,
-0.0389841944,
-0.0090664644,
0.0499107987,
0.0606569946,
0.1065464616,
0.0167766716,
0.0079886932,
0.0154637517,
0.0037336203,
0.057288304,
-0.0173306838,
0.0525664873,
0.0068484209,
0.0315326154,
-0.0132931545,
0.0031112374,
-0.0074625849,
-0.0201944392,
0.0180816781,
-0.0049278922,
0.0300946888,
0.0256614909,
-0.001855358,
0.0196601488,
-0.0009667343,
0.03752755,
-0.0395913646,
-0.0089547457,
0.0724512413,
-0.0023376306,
0.0237747338,
-0.0301246159,
0.0406983905,
0.0146166869,
0.0364647098,
0.0003676891,
0.0464787073,
-0.0133795608,
-0.0059363549,
0.060839694,
-0.0532139465,
0.0059629381,
0.0138172572,
0.012588894,
0.0697213337,
-0.0086177466,
-0.013213139,
-0.0286589749,
0.0094667887,
0.0611667372,
0.0258419421,
-0.0471523777,
-0.0206335094,
-0.0015905733,
-0.0347468369,
-0.0513083152,
-0.0038116302,
-0.0085484348,
0.0316450223,
0.0369418412,
0.0063349539,
-0.0268223416,
0.0482100174,
-0.0284530744,
-0.0266350638,
-0.0380155817,
0.0119386632,
-0.0013797034,
0.0637879819,
-0.0201593805,
0.0538624898,
-0.0326897763,
-0.0279713925,
0.0050377264,
0.0240130387,
0.0142934695,
0.0159970894,
0.0419182777,
0.0145161282,
-0.001512971,
-0.037131656,
0.0018304458,
0.0115048978,
-0.0681794137,
-0.0388361625,
-0.0175892208,
-0.0313479342,
-0.002370565,
-0.0380647294,
0.0247434676,
-0.0471359864,
0.0698245466,
-0.0404962599,
0.0330106989,
0.0254146494,
0.0423415415,
0.0318847783,
-0.013113685,
-0.0068151532,
-0.012141305,
-0.0056058089,
-0.0628575906,
-0.0764140263,
0.0165306181,
-0.0272056963,
-0.0057854895,
0.0299222246,
-0.0669201314,
-0.0322618596,
0.0067001106,
-0.0119980555,
-0.0191100258,
-0.0257496517,
0.0423501655,
-0.0423208959,
0.0111388005,
-0.0633263737,
0.0484809056,
0.0652412996,
0.0004848493,
0.0328773372,
0.0486345366,
0.012286772,
0.0312842652,
0.0396975204,
-0.0003050371,
0.013251313,
-0.0080934176,
0.0077068694,
0.0774301142,
-0.012817394,
-0.0018121054,
-0.0405385345,
-0.0258297306,
0.0579080917,
0.0444487594,
-0.0449784733,
0.0088372743,
0.0288189948,
0.0598801859,
0.0413294509,
0.0144503582,
-0.0275890324,
0.0188762527,
0.0111168725,
0.0185623076,
0.0408536606,
-0.028761657,
0.0243318584,
-0.0358617939,
0.033877559,
-0.0127119189,
-0.0111823492,
-0.0493842401,
-0.0161144193,
0.0304249711,
0.0490084179,
-0.0896442458,
0.0758340061,
-0.0011029409,
0.0383515023,
0.0107342629,
0.0323372893,
0.0110891154,
0.0119507406,
0.0088548325,
0.0222389251,
-0.0076866737,
0.0356206186,
-0.0195052419,
-0.0136764878,
0.0132298553,
0.0357308388,
0.001810595,
-0.0501349904,
-0.0125993034,
-0.0397469215,
-0.011897455,
0.0078586582,
-0.018382581,
0.0311862063,
0.0056071561,
-0.0166813172,
0.0302570295,
0.0055019967,
-0.0624996163,
0.0324367322,
0.0402551517,
-0.0131707285,
0.0173818916,
0.0224226061,
-0.0216689073,
0.0551465005,
-0.0035713504,
-0.0068614753,
0.0113378791,
0.0316313952,
-0.0408793502,
-0.0328690484,
-0.0731361359,
0.0103404764,
0.0414832868,
0.0282624662,
-0.0569943748,
0.0531440265,
-0.0161416195,
0.0371807441,
0.0060627065,
0.0249260366,
-0.0519136451,
-0.0150545845,
-0.0077355667,
0.0416164435,
-0.0476761535,
-0.004793135,
-0.0192852058,
0.0650926307,
-0.0235301014,
0.0602592379,
0.0229338799,
0.0029788406,
0.0358811505,
-0.054587394,
0.0320119224,
-0.0129544977,
-0.0128046675,
0.026500687,
0.0460738204,
0.0161838979,
-0.003466811,
-0.0090952041,
-0.0547206923,
0.0128770331,
-0.015360645,
0.0277263653,
0.0313558504,
-0.0080442382,
-0.0205557514,
0.0393037051,
0.0099153658,
0.0057215616,
-0.0053001326,
0.0374442488,
0.0301396232,
0.0033807489,
0.0034421922,
-0.0238987375,
-0.0099128634,
0.0292378608,
0.0222923886,
0.0122285485,
-0.0401744619,
-0.0142924264,
0.0651813075,
-0.0509172939,
-0.0309144426,
-0.0094125606,
-0.0052487697,
-0.0091148028,
0.0047566378,
0.1086501032,
-0.0689939708,
0.0298447274,
0.0513339415,
0.073316671,
-0.0301402137,
0.0033922966,
-0.0446263999,
-0.030951662,
0.0530959293,
0.0066249855,
-0.0519196875,
0.0482381955,
0.0064290622,
0.0478610136,
0.0212378521,
-0.01078548,
0.0423819721,
-0.0848119259,
0.0209032185,
-0.0529902838,
0.025086252,
-0.0569854677,
0.0716293082,
-0.0002956185,
-0.0574425086,
-0.013746256,
0.0267821122,
0.0771807581,
-0.0782722086,
-0.0303132962,
-0.003625866,
-0.0507090613,
-0.006970556,
-0.0062010707,
-0.0291963071,
-0.006021996,
-0.0271508005,
0.015821198,
0.027571274,
-0.0085881837,
0.0849335492,
-0.0326076224,
0.0250819344,
0.0049213339,
0.036912255,
-0.0045335232,
-0.0717820749,
0.0306919515,
-0.009771836,
0.0393476188,
-0.0014412476,
-0.0199448224,
0.0078934981,
0.0375574231,
0.0223873928,
0.007698785,
0.0063889637,
0.0209894553,
0.0474265255,
0.074144125,
-0.0443385318,
-0.0011006766,
-0.0017056686,
0.0176313259,
-0.0094146691,
0.0152315879,
-0.0454979911,
0.0028628397,
-0.0135385692,
-0.0192201491,
-0.0246484373,
-0.0480242148,
0.0535470285,
0.0093764886,
0.0113733001,
-0.01862951,
0.0848878771,
0.0071960967,
-0.0205298215,
0.0046491898,
-0.0193457864,
0.0182338208,
-0.00732827,
0.0155763077,
-0.051631283,
0.0157659333,
0.0004362552,
0.0482068509,
-0.0008241405,
-0.0273492783,
-0.0438662544,
-0.0450604036,
0.0350058414,
-0.0392887145,
0.0206850078,
-0.0066113672,
-0.1076824442,
0.0383937955,
-0.0256581586,
-0.0099449353,
-0.0015586455,
-0.0273080058,
0.0192858968,
0.035110835,
-0.0731537417,
-0.0633520037,
-0.0098413043,
0.0013681566,
0.0530650839,
-0.0320157073,
0.0373301134,
-0.0284849294,
0.0120248292,
0.0062418915,
-0.0709802657,
-0.0492808484,
0.0093817534,
0.0379491374,
0.0323070325,
0.0340090543,
-0.0068397433,
-0.0009920949,
-0.0347410887,
-0.0347132422,
0.0279750265,
0.0575271398,
-0.003936918,
-0.0318727344,
-0.0371917859,
0.0094497809,
-0.0077213263,
0.0494441986,
0.0374650657,
-0.0283716805,
0.0409535244,
-0.0000137718,
-0.0191718414,
0.0887318775,
0.0199933499,
-0.0189963747,
-0.0895913839,
-0.0985740572,
-0.0619578771,
-0.0760498121,
0.0013411146,
0.0304110572,
-0.0103418231,
0.0627615377,
0.0104982266,
-0.0203537978,
0.0204841029,
-0.0226425063,
-0.0243798736,
-0.0205941517,
-0.0449886434,
-0.0049248799,
0.0393646061,
0.0020831462,
-0.0322962999,
-0.0547896288,
-0.061997626,
-0.0422663242,
0.0448086448,
-0.0533728674,
0.0210294295,
-0.0184802301,
-0.0367521457,
-0.0608135909,
0.0037936682,
0.0538406409,
-0.0136884674,
0.0441814102,
-0.0393708609,
0.0274987277,
0.0292434022,
-0.0031814391,
-0.0325738452,
0.0525641814,
-0.0014660832,
0.0082997158,
-0.0530573465,
-0.0578202121,
-0.0201128349,
0.0487064011,
0.0494580492,
0.0100142807,
-0.0329150371,
-0.0725607276,
-0.0511759967,
-0.0288143549,
-0.005129098,
-0.0042003924,
0.0065200524,
-0.022514658,
0.0077560637,
-0.0853293687,
0.0295993201,
-0.0962026939,
0.0260481574,
-0.0299823545,
0.0097212279,
0.0252178628,
-0.0011417257,
-0.0252042171,
0.0161018819,
0.0454584062,
-0.035756994,
-0.0120594166,
-0.0014286513,
-0.0031317286,
0.0209744126,
-0.0098014865,
0.003352965,
-0.0290191416,
0.0215846393,
-0.0348672643,
0.0060661756,
-0.0466115437,
0.0162083842,
-0.029179005,
0.0155027099,
0.0200527664,
-0.0303040631,
0.0150120035,
-0.0353298448,
0.0259989593,
-0.0048587522,
0.0109806871,
0.0225676838,
0.0021261307,
-0.0370541215,
0.0341139175,
0.0681750923,
0.0311938114,
-0.0251125954,
-0.0081648733,
-0.0337629393,
-0.02617139,
0.0201786831,
0.0222628266,
0.0151341651,
-0.0059172218,
-0.0248318389,
-0.0669023842,
-0.0238314886,
0.00100375,
-0.0648075938,
0.0076226774,
0.0078213047,
0.0221766829,
0.0468029976,
-0.0218201056,
0.0620769411,
-0.045211792,
-0.0000164999,
-0.0247894265,
-0.0451671816,
-0.0071348995,
-6.190253903e-33,
-0.0147719495,
-0.050896991,
0.0115032373,
-0.021953363,
0.0163026657,
0.0046877949,
-0.0125976922,
-0.0032852157,
0.0312838368,
0.0214291196,
-0.0085184351,
0.0414538272,
0.0138066653,
-0.052427616,
0.0106913876,
-0.0124565633,
0.0189716369,
-0.0252919458,
-0.0194047578,
0.0377134942,
0.0325381085,
0.0184129737,
0.0080532804,
-0.039221134,
0.0272550285,
-0.0018305334,
-0.0161338039,
-0.022211859,
0.1213792339,
0.006580472,
-0.0332648195,
0.0426668897,
0.0521647856,
-0.0537564829,
-0.0042281081,
0.001305027,
0.0103256982,
-0.07191246,
0.0227042213,
-0.0462359041,
0.0471369475,
-0.0541273057,
0.0289571304,
0.0450694337,
-0.0453920998,
0.0241106581,
0.0839817971,
-0.0043855142,
-0.0605422743,
-0.0714026541,
-0.0431146994,
0.0536355898,
0.000982775,
0.0178056564,
-0.0356420241,
-0.0517520793,
-0.0057477276,
0.0146962702,
0.0229017809,
0.0445254147,
0.0700104982,
0.0141541082,
0.0053757243,
-0.0437553562,
-0.0046297135,
0.0496748127,
-0.0393729098,
0.0265306495,
0.0520035736,
-0.0243328549,
0.0332409665,
-0.012378769,
0.0075958981,
0.0141915856,
0.0652518496,
-0.0104900012,
-0.0323890708,
0.0551943928,
-0.0221945178,
-0.0107451975,
-0.0163357276,
0.0118943863,
-0.0223390348,
-0.0479882285,
-0.0321479738,
0.0437851064,
-0.0082613695,
-0.0435306914,
0.0414190292,
-0.0230312813,
-0.0689645857,
-0.0455369353,
0.0120471865,
-0.0327351317,
-0.012600245,
0.0244636573,
-0.0415008031,
0.0254339892,
-0.0078009074,
0.0056691077,
-0.0822117403,
-0.0187831502,
0.0266983416,
0.0249095969,
-0.0065561878,
-0.0439629294,
-0.0314175226,
-0.0178568289,
-0.0371275097,
-0.0125943245,
0.0042125373,
-0.0308445301,
0.0084623732,
0.055062864,
-0.0092820842,
-0.0203186739,
-0.0030398278,
0.0769727081,
0.0860835463,
0.0083461264,
0.0029764585,
-0.0313065089,
-0.0012822526,
-0.0091674943,
-0.0335597023,
0.0060273916,
-0.0180338398,
0.0449442156,
0.049669899,
-0.0106158964,
-0.0104480805,
-0.0383395366,
2.675e-7,
0.0501892045,
0.0648696497,
-0.0352923423,
-0.0291297045,
0.0397373699,
0.0192043837,
-0.0163745228,
-0.0082179373,
-0.0066884998,
0.0076425904,
0.0268473607,
-0.0142942853,
-0.0052080574,
0.0652420074,
-0.0326217152,
0.0220257211,
-0.0314018279,
-0.0171013959,
-0.0318569988,
0.0080492757,
-0.0313654952,
0.0499918945,
0.0201427005,
-0.0112488745,
-0.0638658106,
-0.0162105039,
0.0101876445,
-0.0401615538,
-0.0894662365,
0.0444616042,
0.1221191436,
0.0218410324,
0.0257467907,
-0.04208773,
-0.0205081906,
0.0129294507,
0.0634270236,
0.0326456018,
-0.0031559672,
0.0159626957,
0.0194866657,
-0.0294144601,
-0.0187218264,
0.0075870878,
0.0389175788,
-0.0088233156,
-0.0150995925,
-0.0079002334,
-0.0490799993,
0.01359603,
0.0181788355,
-0.0082747377,
-0.0093063684,
-0.0116217379,
-0.0144102648,
0.0070781726,
-0.0305144154,
-0.0007794801,
0.0313246399,
0.0280658994,
-0.0413553827,
-0.078138575,
-0.0174314454,
0.0378041826,
0.058084283,
-0.096320346,
0.0536074899,
2.148177585e-34,
0.04646625,
-0.0204242337,
-0.0548181348,
0.0043394533,
-0.0118944161,
0.0134548508,
-0.0157618374,
0.01914954,
-0.0203759186,
-0.0721661597,
0.020884268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14495v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14495v4 | StableSSM: Alleviating the Curse of Memory in State-space Models through Stable Reparameterization | 2023-11-24T14:08:31 | 2024-06-05T05:15:16 | Shida Wang, Qianxiao Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.DS | In this paper, we investigate the long-term memory learning capabilities of
state-space models (SSMs) from the perspective of parameterization. We prove
that state-space models without any reparameterization exhibit a memory
limitation similar to that of traditional RNNs: the target relationships that
can be stably approximated by state-space models must have an exponential
decaying memory. Our analysis identifies this "curse of memory" as a result of
the recurrent weights converging to a stability boundary, suggesting that a
reparameterization technique can be effective. To this end, we introduce a
class of reparameterization techniques for SSMs that effectively lift its
memory limitations. Besides improving approximation capabilities, we further
illustrate that a principled choice of reparameterization scheme can also
enhance optimization stability. We validate our findings using synthetic
datasets, language models and image classifications. | [
0.0002911302,
0.1173805743,
0.0051370068,
0.0103682131,
-0.0061108358,
0.0019065229,
-0.0064125718,
-0.0099278912,
-0.0103855263,
-0.002013952,
-0.0266150087,
-0.1052421704,
0.0141075654,
-0.0032694743,
0.0225229375,
-0.0575123765,
0.0326328315,
-0.0307232477,
-0.0304217003,
-0.0131616937,
0.009767672,
-0.0293365847,
-0.0023560862,
0.0236676186,
0.0019913728,
-0.0097709121,
-0.0195336156,
-0.0188162327,
-0.0197840165,
-0.044157654,
-0.0102550536,
0.0173559468,
0.0387461782,
0.0356622413,
0.000001973,
-0.037595138,
-0.0156142935,
-0.0086251516,
-0.0163233392,
0.0136010265,
0.0684136748,
-0.0130576594,
-0.0062462846,
0.0075233788,
-0.0240260009,
-0.0352806933,
0.0574569032,
-0.0080627743,
0.0734081045,
0.0944583118,
0.0065747048,
-0.05879559,
0.0314814337,
-0.0818432495,
0.0005819234,
-0.0172429029,
0.0433242433,
-0.0278639253,
-0.0300258715,
-0.0464280061,
-0.0683778599,
0.0291528534,
0.006101578,
0.0314041972,
0.0056212726,
0.0364463925,
0.0569955446,
0.0197409038,
0.0040879087,
0.0495054647,
-0.0344634391,
-0.0304301437,
0.0081280274,
0.0252421871,
-0.0209893174,
0.0435950346,
-0.0306278449,
0.0095141511,
0.0001900046,
0.0370856486,
0.0010217823,
-0.0263312832,
0.0524893291,
-0.0117137022,
-0.0561751388,
0.0265846141,
0.0118515193,
-0.0181366932,
-0.026959423,
-0.045465067,
-0.0143518029,
-0.0289459676,
0.0301831607,
0.0692979619,
0.04008146,
0.0225245878,
-0.0264688432,
-0.0553683639,
-0.0282791015,
-0.0594694652,
0.0306823794,
0.0136902155,
0.0160081033,
0.0301218126,
-0.0256420057,
0.0416544788,
-0.0325048566,
-0.0034773836,
-0.0315616243,
0.0225717761,
-0.0874444842,
0.0032171954,
-0.0470077917,
0.0222221948,
0.0379010588,
0.0240272749,
-0.0388310179,
-0.0071252049,
-0.0508280918,
0.0067632389,
-0.0091870222,
0.009008294,
-0.0546802543,
-0.0060603092,
-0.0512864068,
0.0565428399,
0.0350590572,
-0.0135709103,
-0.0252852216,
-0.0073240362,
-0.0209997389,
0.0158970151,
0.0117035666,
0.0117693692,
-0.0064624981,
0.069899559,
0.0098063489,
-0.0136286719,
-0.0428066589,
-0.014185247,
-0.0128213428,
-0.0396569669,
0.0373219326,
-0.0283274855,
0.0346675441,
-0.0144938668,
0.0029618975,
-0.1109147295,
0.0163591057,
0.0034252368,
-0.0309842937,
0.0727644637,
0.0553840697,
-0.0345564969,
0.0259858314,
-0.000307117,
-0.0047116466,
0.0245846454,
0.0589742698,
0.0108847013,
0.0000478836,
-0.0232428312,
0.0408031158,
0.0187816024,
0.0390587524,
0.0083641168,
-0.0866290331,
-0.030343622,
0.0281501729,
0.0275157318,
0.0466376059,
0.0402395949,
-0.0328689329,
-0.0603392012,
0.0544817895,
0.0260325391,
0.0478391685,
0.0535171703,
0.009450715,
-0.0350130126,
0.0024361506,
0.0114652468,
-0.0225462858,
0.0266883224,
0.0139715765,
0.0232723784,
-0.0220057946,
0.0290746093,
-0.0539640002,
-0.0407198332,
0.0164560284,
-0.0473868586,
0.0086812358,
0.0111033507,
0.1061658412,
0.0000057463,
-0.0537842773,
0.0550248027,
-0.0018377728,
-0.0261654686,
0.0374154188,
-0.0153662357,
0.0403651297,
0.0492511764,
0.0222876258,
-0.0431351885,
-0.0289886333,
-0.0315840207,
0.0156518966,
-0.0010267483,
-0.0055825515,
-0.0016917253,
0.0388124064,
-0.0480269007,
-0.0092657432,
0.0583686084,
-0.0180962328,
0.0174071621,
-0.010945309,
0.0252207592,
0.0206032079,
0.0253796726,
-0.0319805481,
0.0175745562,
-0.0242819525,
-0.0295079108,
0.0035706465,
0.002456981,
0.0527283922,
-0.0137316277,
-0.0228761416,
0.0167534817,
0.0308466665,
-0.0432444438,
0.0002485853,
0.0098789632,
-0.0925241336,
-0.0117315697,
0.0386059843,
-0.0060553588,
0.0606282428,
0.0167330448,
-0.0352919139,
-0.0850943252,
0.0937400833,
-0.0324973203,
0.0535496697,
-0.0514055714,
0.0239395369,
0.0049712751,
0.0128065879,
-0.0266512781,
0.0135595296,
-0.0471974947,
-0.0162219498,
-0.0160814505,
0.0247857347,
-0.0406313501,
-0.0244979877,
-0.0646663383,
0.0226667169,
0.0109088095,
0.0277328528,
-0.0108110951,
-0.0335590653,
0.0097027738,
-0.0245917067,
-0.0470098965,
-0.0001649784,
-0.028931722,
0.0093856258,
0.0109399157,
-0.0076253405,
0.0293753278,
-0.0024921701,
-0.0279826988,
0.0120501928,
-0.0162935778,
0.0235085841,
0.0441976264,
0.0184898321,
-0.0457394682,
-0.0452415682,
-0.0299491212,
0.0234827492,
0.0446006171,
-0.0500753373,
-0.009838054,
-0.0527311899,
0.0517389737,
-0.0266795401,
0.0744254068,
-0.0403967276,
-0.0320958719,
-0.0137992604,
-0.0438991524,
0.0499697216,
0.058101695,
0.0158215687,
0.0186330024,
0.055883646,
-0.0038962201,
0.0168415736,
0.0198247135,
-0.0790062919,
-0.0078628035,
0.0117056547,
-0.0005306833,
0.0092967199,
0.0632754564,
-0.0364677198,
-0.0222158022,
-0.0101119149,
0.0233048312,
0.005424499,
0.0297128502,
-0.0154412352,
0.0004688449,
-0.0022657248,
-0.0148835983,
-0.0290225167,
-0.0597911254,
0.0622241497,
-0.0269842129,
0.0059226542,
0.0199703537,
-0.0088267578,
-0.0297499709,
0.0116525982,
0.0086449841,
-0.0017711474,
0.0008108491,
0.0133313006,
-0.016823275,
-0.0417003557,
-0.0009911981,
-0.0164197888,
0.0278997701,
-0.0144974263,
0.0323299617,
0.0066157025,
-0.0135130445,
-0.0388806313,
0.0255904309,
0.0050949403,
-0.0348218679,
-0.0302703828,
-0.026583029,
0.0151590509,
0.0645901412,
0.0212624073,
0.0537385382,
-0.0202143788,
0.0101357549,
0.0011994563,
0.0317537487,
0.0400609486,
-0.0012227161,
-0.0018730178,
-0.0349268802,
0.0160561856,
0.0305659361,
0.0675646216,
-0.0000784887,
-0.0854214281,
0.011310366,
0.0091657005,
-0.0239373874,
-0.0347282365,
0.0095056007,
-0.0185943246,
-0.0839710683,
-0.0483524464,
0.074935019,
-0.0237412732,
-0.0668261871,
-0.0209383871,
0.0242018532,
0.0227044765,
0.0080405762,
0.0067299572,
0.0163267925,
-0.0009894283,
-0.0173536036,
-0.0090688802,
0.0280853026,
-0.0411923937,
-0.0138286222,
-0.0880038217,
0.0100775706,
0.0479763076,
-0.0754389912,
-0.0562177338,
-0.0204819553,
-0.0319995396,
-0.0181772932,
0.0074696033,
0.0483138971,
-0.0107022785,
0.0152619174,
0.0347434357,
-0.0266059041,
0.0092184646,
-0.0076074218,
-0.0319927558,
0.0382120833,
0.076069355,
-0.0094453041,
-0.005040138,
-0.0829172134,
0.0281767845,
-0.0150920311,
-0.0116799902,
0.0017132387,
-0.0274352133,
0.0053935591,
-0.0236802697,
0.0311945491,
0.0399323739,
-0.0321094356,
0.0369591601,
0.0023440016,
0.0544830188,
-0.0230184216,
0.00618034,
-0.0106813712,
-0.0321336575,
0.0310437437,
0.0512567796,
0.0301191751,
-0.0396690331,
-0.0554217137,
-0.000943859,
0.0053649526,
-0.0173704233,
0.0304671545,
-0.0352707729,
0.0032287168,
-0.0253284611,
-0.0683742911,
0.0117223514,
0.0048490916,
0.0542867817,
-0.0092251776,
0.0055483864,
0.0571223572,
0.007258493,
-0.0616270229,
0.0298096426,
-0.0634135604,
0.0138412686,
-0.0195726193,
-0.0019924885,
0.0679207891,
-0.0053628474,
-0.015054509,
-0.0151646147,
-0.1120913327,
-0.0398447998,
0.0237377193,
0.0271699503,
0.0240228772,
0.05929593,
0.0066747088,
-0.0207797661,
0.0560049079,
-0.0282951687,
0.0333666615,
0.0249272175,
0.0620157309,
0.0382084399,
0.0065423097,
0.0199017636,
-0.0200007521,
-0.0100394031,
0.0310095828,
0.0117653636,
0.0086644432,
0.0120899146,
-0.0421451926,
-0.0286436938,
0.0503224768,
0.0255727526,
-0.0128789851,
-0.0058386186,
0.0120883649,
-0.004785296,
0.0296199601,
-0.0337271504,
0.0337691978,
0.034331467,
0.0247692242,
0.0052874712,
-0.0710057765,
0.0636940449,
0.0151772238,
0.036608737,
-0.013720151,
-0.0132228294,
0.0057783774,
0.0319273137,
0.0344155654,
-0.0109376227,
0.0402226932,
-0.0025864644,
0.0161909759,
-0.0127985058,
0.0487815216,
0.0156904217,
0.0254463237,
-0.060666319,
-0.0090036392,
-0.0489455722,
-0.0399418361,
-0.0458400063,
0.0282228161,
0.0818053931,
-0.0042524012,
0.0141435321,
-0.0083378768,
0.0217114128,
-0.0133351916,
0.015192654,
0.0058476515,
-0.0313866027,
0.0480987467,
0.0126581015,
-0.0096139954,
0.0560389571,
0.1072544083,
0.0766113102,
0.0528612062,
0.0028253584,
0.0289570726,
-0.0110456776,
-0.0309763551,
-0.0112230135,
0.0047953026,
-0.0123742176,
-0.0350128897,
-0.0199305378,
-0.0517464839,
0.0677083805,
-0.0280679148,
-0.0088359592,
-0.0246963073,
0.0455868915,
0.0182421375,
-0.0128006544,
0.0303857494,
-0.0232273545,
-0.0188198537,
0.015160176,
-0.0304560084,
-0.0254557356,
-5.991207445e-33,
0.0071453271,
0.0028576867,
0.029084662,
-0.0311925318,
-0.0439355262,
-0.0617841631,
-0.0371435657,
-0.0208227485,
0.0007518647,
-0.0289309118,
-0.0109544434,
0.0097325593,
0.0007868208,
0.0551391542,
-0.0027316033,
-0.0464566723,
0.0440536439,
-0.0098726479,
0.0057414696,
0.0530757084,
0.0704832375,
0.063445732,
0.0462384522,
-0.0215465128,
-0.0320219621,
-0.0056398404,
-0.0039801518,
0.0250100009,
0.0238139629,
0.026872078,
-0.0408750661,
0.0298345033,
0.0043845139,
-0.0711919442,
-0.0197255965,
-0.0098931203,
-0.049330309,
-0.0132036572,
-0.0004419416,
-0.0033864956,
-0.0153328413,
-0.0341521055,
0.0642901063,
0.0314527862,
-0.0049099033,
0.0046323314,
0.0094067948,
-0.0461194888,
-0.0579883754,
-0.0325068496,
-0.0151071688,
-0.0053311395,
0.0104855346,
-0.0071190549,
0.0300445016,
-0.0155623192,
-0.020199148,
0.0274941698,
-0.0609532297,
-0.0317750387,
-0.0027803546,
0.0640720427,
0.0495336503,
0.0639863163,
0.0602841079,
0.0238334723,
0.0259972811,
-0.0087294914,
-0.0146111185,
0.0176515877,
0.0365487374,
-0.0019747023,
0.0518595837,
-0.0317109004,
0.0522548705,
-0.0495441072,
-0.0639358535,
-0.0288942009,
0.0045530666,
0.0793190151,
0.0231769793,
0.0199116226,
-0.0309914034,
-0.0260036737,
-0.0360526405,
-0.0405563489,
-0.0201754458,
-0.0055189151,
-0.001305652,
0.0363101177,
-0.0053572003,
0.0181172621,
0.032787215,
-0.0035405117,
0.0164204687,
0.0017081248,
0.0167928953,
0.0130745862,
0.0231147595,
0.0037740183,
-0.041120097,
-0.0254731886,
-0.0172501151,
0.0350056551,
-0.0042989496,
-0.0167275257,
-0.0048197475,
0.0356501341,
-0.0734365582,
-0.0317192376,
-0.0524561852,
0.0371164754,
0.0209188461,
0.0727615878,
0.0641795695,
-0.0100226449,
0.0195791516,
0.0852304995,
-0.0065814885,
-0.016854126,
-0.0152692571,
0.0048825811,
0.0404075123,
0.0296351817,
-0.0163724199,
-0.0342587158,
-0.01007991,
-0.0081487512,
0.0308962129,
-0.0936961174,
0.0017483872,
0.0089072669,
2.786e-7,
-0.0359974355,
0.0260875039,
0.0525067858,
-0.023874687,
0.0646465272,
0.00633016,
-0.0320717208,
0.0039803293,
-0.0080603436,
-0.0148233203,
0.0206858497,
0.0148575585,
0.0609932616,
-0.0183668379,
-0.0912928358,
-0.0424382351,
-0.0849615186,
0.0283869673,
-0.0107449461,
-0.0317862295,
-0.0243650917,
0.1059921905,
0.0110593308,
-0.0026880719,
0.0117244897,
-0.0472899787,
0.0731738061,
-0.0200535655,
0.0421893783,
0.019722769,
0.0541104637,
0.0297122691,
-0.0442604609,
-0.0322076343,
-0.0029330575,
0.0293369275,
-0.0448064134,
0.0710211843,
0.0244905148,
-0.0706378594,
0.0085252309,
0.0255436003,
-0.0036408342,
-0.0261242464,
0.0475441813,
-0.0620231442,
0.022844797,
-0.0543544143,
0.0044369143,
-0.0129779922,
-0.0049148016,
0.0098999953,
-0.0035101979,
0.0175049901,
-0.0028998009,
-0.0026023262,
0.0284910575,
-0.0947128832,
-0.0313815325,
0.0020042229,
-0.0632112622,
-0.016568739,
-0.0080901934,
0.0019185802,
0.0539546944,
-0.0737008452,
-0.0372099206,
2.445392607e-34,
0.0523243137,
-0.0811752379,
0.0005233808,
0.0215317905,
0.0046090907,
-0.0276670065,
-0.0284638796,
0.0199286789,
0.0238248594,
-0.0718995556,
-0.0375314988
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00804v1 | Automatic detection of problem-gambling signs from online texts using large language models | 2023-11-24T13:48:02 | 2023-11-24T13:48:02 | Elke Smith, Nils Reiter, Jan Peters | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Problem gambling is a major public health concern and is associated with
profound psychological distress and economic problems. There are numerous
gambling communities on the internet where users exchange information about
games, gambling tactics, as well as gambling-related problems. Individuals
exhibiting higher levels of problem gambling engage more in such communities.
Online gambling communities may provide insights into problem-gambling
behaviour. Using data scraped from a major German gambling discussion board, we
fine-tuned a large language model, specifically a Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) model, to predict signs of
problem-gambling from forum posts. Training data were generated by manual
annotation and by taking into account diagnostic criteria and gambling-related
cognitive distortions. Using k-fold cross-validation, our models achieved a
precision of 0.95 and F1 score of 0.71, demonstrating that satisfactory
classification performance can be achieved by generating high-quality training
material through manual annotation based on diagnostic criteria. The current
study confirms that a BERT-based model can be reliably used on small data sets
and to detect signatures of problem gambling in online communication data. Such
computational approaches may have potential for the detection of changes in
problem-gambling prevalence among online users. | [
0.0430316515,
0.0720160306,
-0.0318483375,
0.0187861826,
-0.0028406247,
0.0712110549,
-0.0094629107,
0.0719570369,
0.0463710874,
-0.0499492735,
0.0184868351,
-0.0455121882,
-0.0200049598,
0.0545708165,
0.0177015029,
-0.0081962077,
-0.0150602767,
0.0194712449,
0.0395123139,
-0.0100621926,
0.0292285308,
-0.0257130861,
-0.0059782262,
0.0556313582,
0.006321847,
0.0012994822,
0.0343099013,
-0.0340472199,
0.0259009581,
-0.0461090729,
0.0276620351,
0.031230282,
0.0028174182,
0.0138022555,
0.0000019661,
-0.015196939,
-0.0041550575,
-0.025595108,
0.0262888782,
-0.0018778699,
0.0077013909,
-0.0642088875,
0.0271963831,
0.0526956469,
-0.0361630097,
-0.0331771597,
0.0867568478,
0.080234386,
0.0788143352,
0.0634848922,
-0.0328940153,
-0.0323950239,
-0.0023622962,
-0.0408198275,
0.0124916518,
-0.0084577175,
0.0985747278,
0.0493022911,
-0.0654075742,
-0.0273569282,
-0.0368241146,
-0.0124922423,
-0.022514442,
0.0270173885,
-0.0212461837,
0.0106674675,
-0.0121052871,
-0.0382125117,
0.0354032703,
0.0475986078,
-0.0478233472,
-0.0068796207,
0.0254853256,
-0.0130192647,
-0.0255519263,
0.0461392403,
-0.0032332607,
0.0228879265,
0.0174439214,
0.0241018459,
0.0319394022,
-0.0000833022,
0.0368342325,
-0.0162696559,
-0.0108853839,
0.0037992382,
0.0026253567,
-0.0386561453,
-0.0238092709,
0.0255801994,
-0.0489787683,
-0.0354402624,
0.0478485599,
-0.0052602813,
-0.0288104359,
0.0146813104,
0.0150030721,
-0.017755907,
0.028728297,
-0.0720118731,
0.0564768016,
0.0421699993,
-0.0203996077,
-0.0023724746,
0.0047845473,
-0.0047610714,
0.0002020008,
0.0281556528,
-0.0022033232,
0.0153664378,
-0.0291331466,
0.0163485799,
-0.0392731614,
0.0040215375,
0.0192076694,
-0.0281201322,
-0.0964809731,
0.0392327793,
-0.0049816021,
-0.0222241059,
-0.0012991627,
-0.0091507044,
0.0234999899,
0.0256529972,
-0.0117231384,
0.0629716069,
-0.0076632276,
0.0109591708,
-0.0288974307,
0.017224431,
0.0322266892,
0.0186849274,
-0.0020481094,
-0.0486560166,
0.031438753,
0.035493046,
0.0343562253,
-0.0197468363,
-0.0458646417,
0.0104537569,
-0.0622525252,
0.0006421969,
-0.0359632373,
-0.0361030586,
0.0425230674,
-0.0089409389,
-0.0036926595,
-0.0200394969,
0.0365794711,
0.0023813343,
-0.0178172495,
0.0585601069,
-0.0462030061,
0.024165744,
0.0181648433,
-0.01260495,
0.011684631,
0.0414577462,
0.0274568964,
0.0160822924,
0.0011806678,
-0.0746484324,
-0.0198151376,
0.0482512079,
0.0231290329,
-0.0489163212,
0.0388108492,
-0.0173768774,
0.0205036271,
-0.0087016094,
-0.0116049619,
0.0308017712,
-0.0073881983,
0.001261982,
0.0560656339,
0.0577969812,
0.0350072458,
0.0545551293,
0.0000030098,
0.0214164909,
-0.0253030509,
-0.0378633551,
-0.0071645691,
-0.0216168053,
0.0075255483,
-0.0128961569,
0.0204451438,
0.0244409349,
0.0010154229,
-0.0428359918,
-0.0325940587,
-0.0131803108,
0.0405536033,
-0.0058170869,
0.0454693437,
-0.0235142354,
-0.0264582131,
0.0060113845,
0.0422723182,
0.0183525831,
-0.0152949737,
-0.0513670072,
0.0746656284,
0.051837258,
0.0258461405,
-0.0202518012,
-0.0085615665,
-0.0557381064,
-0.0145233618,
0.0362088755,
0.0039792811,
-0.0046708486,
-0.0054341876,
-0.0162418913,
-0.0172606278,
0.0678050369,
-0.0048965444,
-0.0191050749,
0.0040036682,
0.0304911043,
-0.0026835548,
0.0331811197,
-0.0079465229,
0.042711705,
0.0124717439,
-0.0392545424,
-0.0100702615,
0.0200072192,
0.0804787949,
-0.0249016583,
-0.0073713441,
-0.0326314904,
0.0157531537,
-0.0443767309,
-0.0721791983,
-0.0338668786,
0.0156408455,
0.0032942425,
0.0456800945,
-0.0579786338,
0.0201789942,
0.0261777081,
-0.0311296396,
0.011804576,
0.0164472964,
-0.0857853591,
0.0078013958,
-0.0325170942,
-0.0240884554,
-0.0171223301,
0.0522664338,
-0.001266607,
0.0678441152,
-0.0234722067,
0.0216850173,
-0.0268192124,
-0.1023122221,
-0.0047794743,
-0.0367320105,
-0.0267087221,
-0.0314563066,
-0.0507204272,
0.0330362841,
0.05614217,
0.0413640477,
0.0081911013,
-0.0090684565,
-0.1063537076,
-0.0160080511,
-0.0268038325,
0.0403563716,
0.0434815064,
-0.0210283268,
-0.0230253655,
-0.0108539453,
-0.0204890985,
-0.0575231649,
0.02330181,
0.0407975838,
0.0331107713,
-0.0144401593,
0.0099020349,
0.0160658509,
-0.0230372287,
-0.0419975035,
0.0252909046,
0.011197757,
-0.059505038,
-0.0599229746,
-0.0288070627,
-0.0196841359,
-0.0134541821,
0.0158403646,
-0.0381544158,
-0.0146163143,
0.0152650177,
0.0090683829,
0.0089097712,
0.0644237027,
0.094181709,
-0.0034768933,
0.0091582239,
-0.0139927268,
-0.0164505988,
-0.0583374165,
0.0076334258,
-0.0475738533,
-0.0660911277,
0.0484345779,
0.0721849278,
0.02685472,
0.0131823812,
-0.067945309,
-0.002451191,
0.0008509732,
-0.0133936806,
-0.0527954735,
-0.0067218058,
-0.0173096843,
-0.0258145034,
0.0062915841,
-0.0006647506,
0.0551032387,
0.0315490589,
0.0287508108,
-0.0020029105,
-0.037040066,
-0.0100480495,
-0.0185204726,
0.031233009,
0.0356588997,
0.0221436117,
-0.0238687675,
0.0439525247,
-0.0116108721,
0.0303953253,
-0.0301925614,
0.002056449,
0.0125721302,
0.0100124553,
0.0181237124,
-0.049157802,
-0.0229880959,
-0.0919230953,
0.0047778776,
-0.0480723605,
0.0545499548,
-0.0005497019,
-0.0643509626,
0.0437642522,
-0.007501801,
-0.0305670034,
0.0114149889,
-0.0346199423,
0.0111328159,
0.0324713252,
0.0558551103,
-0.0318895392,
0.0207496118,
-0.0464120097,
-0.0263251252,
0.0503137223,
-0.0914482474,
0.016497327,
-0.0091995606,
0.0368248001,
0.0150078731,
-0.0374984182,
0.001453251,
0.0188478958,
-0.03306254,
-0.0294611547,
-0.0007763764,
0.0933134705,
0.0134824896,
0.0037500202,
0.0118877525,
0.0035800054,
0.0017741651,
-0.0151227405,
0.0122174034,
-0.1240830719,
-0.0167784579,
-0.0439472273,
0.0184854772,
-0.0254919063,
-0.0361742899,
0.0438599922,
-0.0447226204,
0.0237731598,
-0.0089264791,
-0.0148108033,
-0.0331030935,
-0.0510074198,
0.0042519937,
-0.0748147219,
-0.0078444239,
-0.0259608924,
-0.018050814,
-0.013615571,
0.0355087034,
-0.0911173373,
-0.0220601764,
0.0087988488,
-0.006377148,
0.0515347235,
-0.0199364908,
0.0535681061,
-0.0323794819,
-0.0325640142,
-0.0188768655,
0.0045402898,
-0.0216683019,
-0.0023103531,
0.0897364169,
-0.0215425286,
-0.0164766982,
-0.065391548,
0.0259834621,
-0.0519366302,
0.0015697841,
-0.0163717084,
0.0752612352,
-0.0033124334,
-0.0715096295,
0.0124333212,
-0.0060007693,
0.0491555259,
0.0574373454,
0.0168604776,
-0.0485087968,
0.0095563699,
-0.0059030191,
-0.0285085011,
0.0040787254,
-0.0696810111,
-0.0446278341,
0.0638706684,
-0.0280688852,
-0.0658003762,
-0.0078279953,
-0.0009046247,
-0.0369885117,
0.0133743929,
-0.023162799,
0.0531034358,
-0.0186821446,
-0.0574357063,
0.0575915836,
-0.0297868904,
-0.0204715505,
-0.0500174761,
-0.0098115457,
0.0165283978,
-0.033999145,
-0.0533224717,
0.0129672801,
-0.0713865235,
-0.0104986634,
0.0586115569,
0.0332161859,
0.011403176,
-0.0409286879,
-0.0072086407,
-0.0219165869,
0.0066484665,
0.0151285641,
-0.0228109881,
-0.0387658291,
0.0045095175,
0.0107039837,
-0.0012463578,
0.0092049995,
-0.00894944,
0.0453199111,
-0.0198212452,
-0.0118338987,
-0.08954864,
0.0074516903,
0.0133496383,
0.0349795558,
0.0497035347,
-0.0092856428,
-0.0645043626,
-0.0136664128,
-0.0307259969,
-0.0059344294,
0.0230193939,
0.0006417018,
-0.0393940099,
0.0455983952,
-0.0016464436,
-0.0427261218,
0.0103683546,
-0.0268899072,
-0.0437902547,
-0.0595935062,
0.0500093028,
0.019632671,
-0.0049610538,
0.0345645137,
0.0010022036,
0.0089481715,
0.0495058186,
0.0221862998,
0.0177930724,
-0.0004509295,
0.0340740308,
-0.0018896759,
-0.0163733494,
0.0407167487,
0.0105551966,
-0.0006825066,
-0.0131214056,
-0.023050487,
0.0138250878,
0.0369640067,
-0.0245716479,
0.0403680727,
-0.0073961401,
-0.0298415795,
0.0129237715,
0.0536640733,
-0.0259866826,
-0.0422886387,
0.0142530221,
-0.0116472151,
-0.0400263891,
-0.0188492667,
0.0466484763,
-0.0061025736,
-0.0154004944,
0.025913287,
-0.0513342656,
-0.0213400871,
0.0045636226,
0.0460560173,
0.031259235,
-0.0663547441,
0.0219657216,
-0.0336037241,
-0.0358285978,
0.0016066419,
-0.0311125163,
-0.0004349542,
0.0196652133,
0.0093937013,
0.0102653774,
0.0111945122,
0.0382714421,
-0.0209726878,
0.0352207758,
-0.0404428765,
-0.0234599616,
-0.0757048279,
-5.809958338e-33,
0.0052822223,
-0.0402796939,
0.0053090136,
0.0107262954,
-0.006922605,
-0.019077111,
-0.0177912451,
0.015551934,
-0.0022712075,
0.0335688032,
0.0417746454,
0.0025618207,
0.0066378582,
0.0313228033,
0.0344957709,
-0.0681701377,
0.0188661441,
0.0017423951,
-0.0161242578,
0.011407109,
0.0561812557,
0.042209018,
0.0538886152,
-0.0915210098,
0.0102180764,
0.0086128023,
-0.0122542614,
-0.0103957932,
0.0372874439,
0.0442310572,
-0.0328359194,
0.0638069212,
0.0324185602,
-0.0254621375,
0.0320521705,
0.0696865991,
-0.0484205522,
-0.0287118517,
0.0030346774,
0.0259699337,
0.025883574,
-0.0051498357,
0.0554638095,
-0.0124333566,
0.0207729526,
-0.0042054933,
0.0695265085,
-0.0187046099,
0.0337843113,
-0.0512467846,
-0.0265747681,
0.0075019728,
-0.0460893251,
-0.0031190943,
0.0186869167,
0.0818662345,
0.0001080879,
0.011246888,
-0.0695591792,
0.0182961468,
-0.0442952625,
-0.0106643373,
-0.0035833337,
-0.0233346317,
0.011340348,
0.0397058874,
-0.0158245452,
-0.0227690414,
-0.0536286086,
-0.0103529608,
0.0003411915,
0.0183453579,
0.0423791744,
-0.0078988047,
0.0796749815,
-0.0358600505,
-0.0453603081,
-0.0104708998,
0.0693176538,
-0.0214692205,
0.0539101772,
-0.0116789946,
-0.0662945211,
-0.0285551846,
-0.0033973861,
-0.0288512763,
0.0076163043,
-0.045738671,
0.0222380012,
-0.0096983342,
0.0161651764,
0.0183923412,
0.0209730677,
-0.0640479028,
-0.044877626,
0.0200658366,
0.0304983463,
0.0165286046,
-0.0041913944,
-0.0291186552,
-0.0341694839,
-0.0157370754,
-0.001731793,
0.0029174294,
0.0376221687,
-0.0158070549,
0.0719365776,
-0.0042696241,
-0.0374841057,
-0.0009466769,
0.0235955734,
0.016128445,
0.0156270824,
0.1145018488,
-0.0150161143,
0.0179674868,
-0.0082594631,
-0.0013931278,
0.0174228344,
0.0413547829,
0.0101142768,
-0.0062705497,
-0.0096269604,
0.017557824,
0.0393575206,
0.005620176,
-0.0593298413,
0.0843563601,
0.0229902063,
-0.0488330871,
-0.0018812214,
-0.0267607309,
2.631e-7,
0.0838108212,
0.0914283395,
-0.0295629259,
-0.0138133289,
0.0036553035,
0.026727546,
0.0254197232,
0.0257688574,
0.0517476499,
0.0307312254,
0.0326282196,
0.0437479615,
0.0126199443,
0.0285700019,
-0.0306318887,
-0.0388424695,
-0.0839199647,
-0.0221940391,
-0.0157606397,
0.057379093,
0.0647302195,
0.0785779878,
0.0253874492,
-0.0455579348,
0.013652103,
-0.0050381594,
0.050056003,
-0.048722472,
-0.0051573967,
0.0277151633,
-0.0449034609,
0.0449933745,
0.012599499,
0.0361474231,
-0.0068329424,
0.0076258956,
-0.0005669593,
-0.0003284333,
-0.0256945044,
0.0421329364,
-0.0175887309,
0.0024271312,
0.032009922,
-0.015872851,
0.0531113446,
-0.1142421439,
-0.0402598716,
-0.0534286276,
-0.0466997772,
-0.0572046824,
0.0601805672,
-0.0643800721,
-0.0004642546,
0.012240692,
0.0495588481,
0.0055946438,
0.012686844,
-0.037436787,
-0.0159649793,
0.0124848951,
-0.0422491021,
0.008512917,
0.0094579915,
-0.0207207035,
0.0189634785,
-0.0923452154,
0.0252198838,
2.313494794e-34,
0.0132281333,
0.0163138621,
-0.0026850794,
-0.0073583713,
0.0309207384,
0.0063858982,
0.0191666111,
-0.0116457334,
-0.029748138,
-0.0408576094,
0.0096612684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14483v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14483v2 | SER_AMPEL: a multi-source dataset for speech emotion recognition of Italian older adults | 2023-11-24T13:47:25 | 2023-12-14T15:39:04 | Alessandra Grossi, Francesca Gasparini | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | In this paper, SER_AMPEL, a multi-source dataset for speech emotion
recognition (SER) is presented. The peculiarity of the dataset is that it is
collected with the aim of providing a reference for speech emotion recognition
in case of Italian older adults. The dataset is collected following different
protocols, in particular considering acted conversations, extracted from movies
and TV series, and recording natural conversations where the emotions are
elicited by proper questions. The evidence of the need for such a dataset
emerges from the analysis of the state of the art. Preliminary considerations
on the critical issues of SER are reported analyzing the classification results
on a subset of the proposed dataset. | [
-0.0015773322,
0.0626947582,
0.0090465667,
0.0282642059,
0.01151725,
0.0189016275,
0.0613478944,
-0.0045662373,
0.040866442,
0.009130599,
-0.104428865,
0.0169763844,
0.0276161619,
0.0142440805,
-0.0452294089,
-0.0733656511,
0.0197101329,
0.0427426994,
0.0518219136,
-0.0185033958,
-0.0052844719,
0.0267322324,
-0.0329811312,
0.0054535856,
-0.0401793681,
0.0104308315,
-0.0025958556,
-0.0076288208,
0.0416506454,
-0.0008128055,
0.0210852716,
0.0077175293,
0.042398598,
-0.004627136,
0.0000015998,
-0.0090152575,
0.0266488176,
-0.0284494031,
-0.0112193581,
-0.043979492,
0.0361330062,
0.0779308453,
-0.0143086798,
0.0045751464,
-0.0171714723,
-0.0022968093,
0.0451093391,
0.0014358945,
0.0811777115,
0.0488759838,
-0.0388870947,
-0.0037674259,
-0.0000795729,
-0.0138338488,
0.0147114582,
0.0111398539,
0.0179593675,
-0.0032675024,
-0.0274523627,
-0.0754190758,
0.0059735328,
0.0314276852,
-0.0237626471,
0.0181404334,
-0.0293328986,
-0.0271303598,
-0.0517593771,
-0.0452437028,
-0.0011504876,
0.0462880135,
0.0159852188,
0.0244684033,
-0.0301808417,
0.0419736244,
-0.0109310988,
0.0034617982,
-0.0634846464,
-0.0201080889,
-0.0022254961,
0.0110598719,
0.0029250944,
0.0685949847,
0.0013003348,
-0.0208492428,
0.013115433,
0.0423603989,
-0.0175323859,
-0.028293876,
0.0727574602,
-0.0384502783,
-0.0345109366,
0.0556452647,
0.0160526372,
-0.0341341197,
-0.0100582158,
0.0086163487,
-0.0321102552,
-0.0309440475,
-0.0308436397,
-0.0661050901,
-0.0382735133,
-0.0044195559,
-0.1009797677,
0.0364363939,
0.0245890468,
0.0050379834,
-0.0091444431,
-0.0584859177,
-0.0127529809,
0.0056700641,
-0.0539955981,
0.0185341518,
-0.0236472674,
0.0209571049,
-0.0513688736,
-0.0038118174,
-0.1028478593,
-0.0057734745,
-0.058042407,
0.0244332068,
-0.0181937739,
-0.0113741057,
0.0385390744,
0.0285260491,
0.0203457754,
0.0818431154,
-0.0509242266,
0.0713207275,
-0.0135141537,
-0.1146224514,
0.0370355286,
-0.0047840453,
0.0154424151,
-0.0355540514,
0.0691865981,
-0.0184332319,
-0.0119186286,
0.0047029261,
-0.071748659,
-0.0201274175,
-0.0300714057,
-0.0478224754,
0.0318217725,
0.0106961671,
0.0918920413,
-0.0324937068,
0.0094340611,
-0.0279335454,
-0.0384968892,
-0.0344667509,
-0.0297763087,
0.0428669527,
-0.0262231082,
-0.0097014066,
0.0189915169,
-0.0120006418,
0.0334520973,
0.0073218336,
0.0066604163,
-0.0116733285,
0.0530065596,
-0.013853929,
0.0052798302,
0.0405429117,
0.0137023693,
0.0185624193,
-0.0105778379,
0.014038723,
-0.0227305274,
0.0298227593,
0.0540714748,
-0.0232056994,
0.0021824241,
-0.0379821621,
0.0289889574,
0.0553129129,
-0.0242916625,
0.0423988514,
-0.0420562923,
0.0005452316,
0.0675750822,
-0.0253649261,
0.0401663743,
0.0057678539,
0.0107428813,
-0.0535532087,
-0.0116542093,
0.0042013614,
-0.051394105,
-0.023288019,
0.0129526453,
-0.0366146192,
-0.0286772419,
0.0342258066,
0.0512660518,
-0.0228739232,
0.003427306,
-0.037174616,
0.0223514736,
-0.0953946859,
-0.0245017763,
-0.0511539392,
-0.0049427534,
0.0388668031,
0.0035592732,
-0.0424533449,
-0.0077865855,
-0.0396307223,
0.009569047,
-0.0265601706,
-0.0080137132,
-0.0241221059,
0.0608262569,
-0.0765194297,
-0.0028844213,
0.0168639272,
-0.0153113473,
0.0249568541,
-0.0500257127,
0.0116739748,
-0.0268867537,
0.041394908,
0.0300884414,
0.0023393263,
0.0003000235,
-0.0258142781,
-0.0239503104,
0.0141048674,
0.0492443517,
0.0576098263,
-0.0320042074,
-0.0510137714,
0.0460780971,
-0.0073264297,
0.0648572892,
0.0424802341,
0.0020989231,
-0.0157956667,
0.0365662389,
-0.0122820521,
0.0290651023,
0.0109043717,
-0.0235903841,
-0.0678201243,
0.0558537394,
0.0240975264,
-0.0016397794,
-0.0211440213,
0.0397046432,
-0.0294217691,
0.0519696958,
0.0310110766,
0.0035532219,
0.0057895747,
-0.0033664997,
0.0237935875,
0.0021529088,
0.038364049,
-0.0525841899,
-0.059453249,
0.0335553959,
-0.0035939189,
-0.012339252,
-0.0008405024,
-0.0098937657,
-0.0161682628,
-0.032059852,
-0.0481232144,
-0.0155922333,
0.0116649056,
0.0068353158,
-0.0428871326,
-0.0078028548,
-0.0476584174,
-0.0172298942,
-0.012200282,
0.0034364343,
-0.0206827372,
-0.0325721949,
-0.023356529,
-0.0010230944,
0.0008154237,
-0.029680565,
-0.0130301928,
0.0114852833,
0.0326558463,
-0.0026945588,
-0.0371486992,
0.0307998024,
0.0089561325,
-0.0076308479,
0.0627047345,
-0.0489085764,
-0.0599392951,
-0.0094265249,
0.0250038542,
-0.0204741787,
0.0442120805,
-0.0264612436,
0.0604936667,
0.0066929907,
-0.0124536874,
0.0179140158,
0.03988396,
0.0143483551,
0.0204547048,
-0.0728359297,
-0.0163287092,
0.0201940965,
-0.0181843136,
0.0117522432,
0.0650296807,
-0.0020606937,
-0.0128810266,
0.0180556886,
-0.0303149223,
0.0105729345,
-0.044538822,
-0.0304606333,
-0.0023404632,
0.0395439379,
-0.0100901015,
-0.0036539331,
-0.0002053454,
-0.0483276919,
-0.1017306596,
-0.0285690166,
-0.0230028722,
0.0490412153,
-0.063897647,
0.0231442023,
-0.0119984122,
0.0054981229,
-0.045923762,
-0.048362419,
-0.0069406186,
-0.054418359,
0.0260574501,
-0.017182691,
-0.0181014594,
0.0210472215,
-0.0218963623,
-0.0042629014,
-0.0239445511,
-0.0585884899,
-0.0138542075,
0.0072225318,
-0.0394824632,
-0.029308198,
-0.0097754551,
0.0383203551,
0.0253558438,
0.0052647679,
0.0169058666,
0.0246433318,
0.0409648456,
0.0293278359,
0.0015873432,
-0.0782168955,
0.0180573259,
0.0058443039,
-0.013630731,
0.0480706431,
-0.0393972471,
-0.0296384934,
0.0443411544,
0.0202024654,
0.0245503187,
-0.0248016603,
-0.0578445569,
0.0037446357,
-0.0110641671,
0.0550432466,
0.0861570835,
0.0335725173,
-0.0893806443,
-0.0258261841,
-0.0436536334,
0.0072906991,
0.0079421354,
0.0094645275,
-0.0083798254,
-0.0156157156,
0.0147740133,
0.0530308858,
-0.0338834412,
0.0023260002,
-0.0334253088,
-0.02830627,
0.0883074179,
0.0029917399,
-0.0139181865,
-0.0303205531,
-0.0194006674,
-0.0209354535,
-0.0326560028,
0.0174703579,
-0.0478245169,
-0.0055727419,
-0.0261393152,
0.0894454047,
-0.0447392017,
-0.0716964379,
0.0343282111,
0.0192292854,
0.0987482443,
-0.0012254982,
0.0676497966,
-0.0472576804,
0.0054122917,
0.0299210101,
0.0006461882,
-0.0052270219,
-0.0135733485,
0.0567446537,
0.0186689869,
-0.0085611502,
-0.0149351964,
0.0333689898,
-0.0320648737,
0.0002648718,
0.0513811558,
0.0330207795,
-0.064947322,
0.0256468263,
-0.0090653487,
0.026659647,
0.0323889852,
0.0286881011,
0.0262596626,
-0.0411137529,
0.0319903791,
0.0560842268,
0.0256992225,
0.0452541001,
0.0161201376,
0.0333661735,
-0.0246109832,
-0.0256564952,
-0.0189165138,
-0.0132805398,
0.0496615246,
0.0598967038,
-0.0173011422,
-0.0421359129,
-0.0055430294,
0.0171354767,
-0.0313996449,
0.0512334295,
0.0511280112,
0.0106833233,
-0.0388344526,
-0.0263393968,
0.0113035003,
-0.0164745096,
-0.0131466286,
-0.0217161141,
-0.0052704527,
-0.0381585285,
0.0621148162,
0.0108163748,
0.0267401822,
0.0508377627,
0.0257949699,
-0.0712181479,
0.063061595,
-0.0136506278,
-0.0012223353,
-0.0061306315,
0.0580668859,
0.0135507761,
-0.0428602695,
-0.0135123227,
-0.0090450542,
0.0294505283,
-0.0282728765,
-0.0462083407,
-0.0409498066,
-0.0244639311,
-0.0317190103,
0.0263617169,
0.0287182555,
-0.0006163935,
0.0048593534,
-0.0472830087,
0.0434677266,
0.0417398438,
0.0588406287,
-0.0668225214,
-0.0113264667,
-0.0056688958,
0.0098990453,
-0.035088703,
-0.0454490408,
-0.0531594194,
-0.0611061566,
0.0025281983,
0.072327666,
0.044994168,
0.0106700025,
-0.0211504959,
0.0324593261,
-0.0135400528,
0.0493610315,
0.0020520852,
-0.0017771358,
0.0049819518,
0.0402546041,
0.0216616578,
-0.0532401651,
0.0322291143,
0.0457090922,
-0.0101234205,
0.0429578833,
-0.0252784882,
-0.0085629439,
0.0127652111,
-0.0053563914,
0.0579228103,
-0.0382103845,
0.0226042289,
-0.0100794192,
0.0103632715,
-0.0155546181,
-0.0048438855,
0.0043831985,
-0.0139748948,
-0.0334099643,
0.0144410888,
0.0357645117,
-0.0129144927,
0.0179144423,
0.0061092894,
-0.015799351,
-0.0391530916,
-0.0132813621,
0.0347223505,
-0.0533251017,
-0.0206261668,
-0.0127579868,
-0.0160808954,
-0.0130336648,
0.0016082168,
-0.0665254444,
0.0205547586,
-0.0168653652,
0.0269909818,
0.0074812714,
-0.0408707783,
0.0390727594,
0.0021977823,
-0.0137921814,
-0.0902385935,
-0.0067685028,
-0.0270286202,
-4.755466437e-33,
0.0224447604,
0.0383770876,
-0.0429110564,
0.0437284224,
-0.0596673749,
0.0402970649,
0.0051680394,
-0.0023718362,
-0.0342506915,
0.03370573,
0.0051620165,
0.017613681,
0.0184074175,
0.0135235637,
-0.001170132,
-0.0605631508,
0.0526441075,
-0.0365491658,
0.0101448167,
0.000388353,
0.0361291654,
0.0171421431,
0.0799164847,
-0.099606283,
0.0102700768,
0.0085659334,
-0.0264870264,
-0.0024582664,
0.0914181843,
0.0338690057,
0.0166451186,
0.0685188174,
-0.0291288756,
0.0306603368,
0.0287964027,
0.0287069045,
-0.02105291,
0.0061682044,
0.012269455,
0.0969687104,
0.0347052626,
0.0067247027,
-0.0403720625,
0.0684198141,
-0.0131522929,
0.0011837898,
0.018908821,
-0.0173845906,
-0.0002715123,
-0.0475309864,
0.02147354,
0.0137885064,
-0.0218651239,
-0.0208097734,
0.0232181624,
0.0980954319,
-0.0222630687,
-0.0387536623,
0.0104725808,
0.009246408,
0.0041538556,
0.001353306,
0.0121895382,
0.0085832169,
0.0053492989,
0.0574888699,
0.0606079921,
-0.0575263426,
0.0146385645,
-0.0215728767,
0.0039315308,
0.0633402914,
0.0013505357,
0.0018892987,
-0.0036383166,
0.0094627151,
-0.0164882578,
-0.0006300528,
0.095000498,
0.0179033168,
0.0192720704,
-0.015127399,
0.0114359679,
0.0006659791,
-0.0128923226,
-0.0111084878,
0.0069778571,
-0.005840525,
-0.0087209269,
-0.0608665831,
0.0840257183,
0.0017211715,
0.01419154,
-0.0152408881,
0.0198649243,
0.0260448474,
-0.029536359,
0.05369661,
0.0217448417,
0.0339059196,
0.0195704084,
-0.0273026507,
0.0352398269,
0.0540112182,
0.0667984262,
-0.0223538876,
0.0167961642,
0.0671996996,
-0.0383506641,
-0.0117063085,
0.0113737881,
0.0152276503,
-0.0130355135,
0.0349972397,
-0.0341237746,
0.021783527,
-0.0035847856,
0.0534704737,
-0.0000538577,
0.0854259655,
0.0199333318,
-0.0249382686,
0.015198607,
0.0252129305,
-0.0497776568,
0.0087434715,
-0.0027251733,
-0.0192164518,
0.0289105698,
-0.0129721882,
0.0020310038,
-0.0335478038,
2.483e-7,
-0.0442663692,
0.0330323763,
0.0036068026,
-0.0634164289,
0.0110562174,
0.0374884717,
-0.030259775,
0.0238338504,
0.0070325318,
0.0334200785,
0.0796413049,
-0.0683840215,
0.0575646721,
0.0460502058,
-0.0808589533,
-0.0818620771,
-0.0865089148,
-0.0259482376,
-0.0387237892,
0.0428336672,
0.0311296117,
0.0763278455,
0.03671702,
-0.028020598,
-0.0153325871,
0.0007464108,
0.0145350657,
-0.0461798422,
-0.0267007798,
0.0215114132,
0.0209355094,
-0.0180580821,
0.0102705052,
0.0232745074,
-0.0271239169,
0.0308723394,
0.0182465948,
0.0285849646,
-0.0223015789,
-0.080563657,
0.0297988113,
0.0335692801,
-0.06994766,
0.0213616304,
0.0139209405,
-0.0113850897,
-0.0693632066,
-0.0496231504,
-0.0547105521,
0.0025559317,
0.0580286384,
-0.0342326537,
0.0184200797,
0.0109393252,
0.0009971381,
-0.0391633995,
-0.0443575531,
-0.0592172705,
0.0103494823,
0.025789883,
-0.0533459112,
-0.0561171286,
0.0138326371,
0.0048545911,
0.0249509644,
0.0016688172,
0.0223667491,
1.658277113e-34,
0.0059663607,
0.0060954136,
-0.0279627629,
0.017170975,
-0.0219757948,
-0.0474141501,
-0.021369122,
0.0353728011,
0.019765472,
0.004996594,
0.0274986215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14479v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14479v2 | Controlled Text Generation via Language Model Arithmetic | 2023-11-24T13:41:12 | 2024-03-06T09:36:54 | Jasper Dekoninck, Marc Fischer, Luca Beurer-Kellner, Martin Vechev | cs.CL | cs.CL | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are deployed more widely, customization with
respect to vocabulary, style, and character becomes more important. In this
work, we introduce model arithmetic, a novel inference framework for composing
and biasing LLMs without the need for model (re)training or highly specific
datasets. In addition, the framework allows for more precise control of
generated text than direct prompting and prior controlled text generation (CTG)
techniques. Using model arithmetic, we can express prior CTG techniques as
simple formulas and naturally extend them to new and more effective
formulations. Further, we show that speculative sampling, a technique for
efficient LLM sampling, extends to our setting. This enables highly efficient
text generation with multiple composed models with only marginal overhead over
a single model. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates that model arithmetic
allows fine-grained control of generated text while outperforming
state-of-the-art on the task of toxicity reduction. We release an open source
easy-to-use implementation of our framework at
https://github.com/eth-sri/language-model-arithmetic. | [
0.0284378733,
0.0944147334,
-0.0084016928,
-0.011512368,
-0.011822423,
-0.0042124372,
0.023318518,
0.0176251531,
-0.0076222909,
-0.0396113507,
-0.0242188927,
-0.0441248491,
-0.0240460746,
0.0286080502,
0.0623410642,
-0.0424991064,
0.0018424408,
-0.008281813,
-0.0011597223,
-0.0074005271,
0.0255594105,
0.0412421227,
0.0298872162,
0.0334017128,
-0.0111853993,
-0.007862011,
0.0016527518,
0.0142550394,
0.0085010631,
-0.0395108648,
0.018040888,
0.0222867019,
0.0155743146,
0.0330213122,
0.0000020413,
-0.0208503976,
-0.0222118031,
0.0046785288,
0.0336563624,
0.025422575,
0.1046135724,
-0.008924854,
-0.0086801443,
0.049716644,
-0.0183800831,
0.031226391,
0.0677095279,
0.0125977108,
0.0475468114,
0.0777947232,
-0.0156536158,
-0.0083924346,
-0.0090275621,
-0.0341379978,
0.0052299346,
0.0152294505,
0.0378411785,
0.0126869762,
0.0081998818,
0.0068445024,
0.0182571597,
0.0361303873,
0.0122009767,
-0.0130319251,
-0.0142363096,
0.0383357443,
0.0280948952,
-0.0480792113,
-0.0058323508,
0.0613893904,
-0.0486333519,
-0.0457638837,
0.033105325,
-0.0178305581,
-0.0082066413,
-0.0238266047,
-0.0572835207,
0.0601332448,
-0.0017402397,
0.0315136686,
0.010880488,
0.0108171133,
0.0280195344,
0.0166980233,
0.0089349682,
0.021930078,
0.0462273583,
-0.0142821837,
-0.0251820795,
-0.0131206028,
-0.0132851619,
-0.0551501065,
0.0039299834,
0.0195332076,
-0.0335600711,
0.0256916638,
-0.083228834,
-0.0574878789,
0.058022853,
-0.0747178569,
0.0639549568,
0.0018330817,
0.0011110458,
-0.0105884857,
-0.028056154,
-0.016053535,
-0.0161391906,
0.0226953141,
-0.034522824,
0.0461241715,
0.0176566783,
-0.0166343246,
-0.048340749,
-0.0122383051,
-0.0448196419,
0.0037554691,
-0.0596658215,
0.0353687629,
-0.0103946906,
-0.0178592131,
0.0234930627,
0.0339368097,
-0.0572542027,
0.0203942414,
0.0425967425,
-0.0177034251,
-0.0075671924,
0.0231106654,
0.0203379858,
-0.0562565699,
-0.0162946619,
0.0219340585,
-0.0065653883,
-0.0236463565,
-0.0045636762,
0.108146295,
-0.0440000482,
0.0050670947,
-0.0370948799,
-0.0547463894,
-0.0250656903,
-0.0497737601,
-0.0223447923,
-0.0778189898,
0.0049758246,
-0.0183830783,
-0.001526383,
-0.060373839,
0.0275495164,
0.0180656351,
-0.0355953313,
0.0331448764,
-0.024712598,
-0.0052811163,
0.0388969928,
0.0036724226,
0.0246976316,
0.0741980076,
0.0593437143,
0.0697280765,
0.0054271212,
0.034641806,
0.0112820361,
0.0514812022,
0.037881203,
0.0560507588,
-0.0655211434,
-0.0539336726,
-0.0077787451,
0.0290135685,
0.0292210039,
0.0692734569,
-0.0111207515,
0.0210423619,
0.0917519554,
-0.0059008705,
0.0063276812,
0.0167500675,
0.104841806,
0.0287827384,
-0.0088800825,
-0.0015370179,
-0.0275811814,
0.0081981076,
-0.041449748,
0.0216472317,
0.0375988744,
0.0356560014,
-0.0027105142,
-0.03321236,
0.012626987,
-0.00286266,
0.0132955853,
-0.0200065095,
0.0262857117,
0.0246633142,
-0.0470814183,
0.0199968889,
0.0603557676,
-0.0757367462,
0.0198850036,
-0.0342265666,
0.0275908541,
0.0659636557,
0.0566279367,
-0.0186374933,
0.0068223472,
-0.0179785993,
-0.0131246522,
0.0580513626,
0.0079980278,
-0.001919838,
0.0047221719,
-0.0327001736,
0.0026165019,
-0.016681131,
0.0194380172,
0.0150585771,
0.0093346499,
0.0115987044,
0.0433568917,
-0.0339552239,
-0.0864633098,
0.044478476,
-0.0289289095,
-0.0380081944,
0.0294515695,
-0.0117166024,
0.0223290771,
-0.0188849382,
-0.0464330092,
0.0374805555,
0.0096828984,
-0.0298259426,
-0.0432488099,
0.0082822908,
-0.0093242424,
-0.0436602347,
0.028996259,
-0.0272879787,
0.0234806258,
-0.0007490248,
-0.0454915464,
-0.0379786566,
0.0044653011,
-0.0524903759,
0.0252551381,
-0.0239455346,
0.0214425884,
0.0149274422,
-0.0053136204,
-0.0320999213,
0.0492491387,
0.0102185505,
-0.0369390324,
0.0310653634,
-0.0101992758,
-0.0116381571,
-0.0329092406,
-0.0089373905,
-0.0354972072,
0.0157923587,
0.0195087679,
0.0317336097,
0.0489990339,
-0.0109596569,
-0.0212664045,
-0.0526464731,
0.0023478204,
-0.0240802038,
-0.000242417,
0.0444181599,
0.0108519895,
-0.0127674509,
0.0202112179,
-0.0525913313,
-0.0302649159,
0.0188300908,
0.0132179111,
0.0077723218,
-0.0058141383,
-0.0221684426,
-0.046791669,
-0.0025078931,
-0.0202075839,
0.0559785515,
0.0265681501,
-0.0543082468,
-0.0302179791,
0.0412334874,
-0.0363079831,
-0.0066497168,
-0.0000714686,
-0.0549041629,
0.0095166024,
-0.0066512353,
0.0323753804,
0.013464177,
0.037429031,
0.019467989,
0.061790131,
0.0462409407,
-0.0307974275,
-0.0086788815,
-0.0381742604,
-0.0176541451,
0.0016661319,
-0.0860306546,
0.0189867057,
0.0742336735,
0.0245183315,
-0.00836528,
-0.0411709175,
0.0389240794,
0.0104076127,
-0.059140522,
-0.0127777047,
-0.0111344242,
-0.0160621721,
0.0066972743,
-0.019168511,
-0.0798052177,
0.0537539609,
-0.0359578319,
0.0204065032,
-0.028729694,
0.0225059371,
0.012283626,
0.0217990074,
0.0385161601,
0.0539531372,
0.0478781871,
0.0121725881,
-0.024404658,
0.0197351426,
0.0304882079,
-0.0158096254,
0.0369753167,
-0.0715638325,
0.0052976441,
0.0291955713,
-0.0215139687,
-0.044074405,
-0.0387145281,
-0.019300228,
0.009710609,
0.0603309311,
-0.0361168422,
0.000872294,
-0.0118441731,
0.0273567885,
0.0163416639,
-0.0266017765,
-0.009159972,
-0.0116804987,
-0.002719756,
0.0821131915,
-0.0663238242,
0.0245296806,
-0.0525620431,
0.0343657583,
0.059920799,
0.0063178539,
0.0341235325,
0.0089176148,
0.0180233922,
0.0047212467,
0.0043772822,
0.0051480187,
0.0543302335,
0.042693425,
-0.0171751902,
-0.0191715695,
0.0918637291,
0.022177482,
-0.01842485,
0.0473372191,
0.0020570129,
0.0867070556,
0.0017125708,
0.041645173,
-0.0906693041,
-0.0149664199,
0.0024562848,
0.027713865,
-0.062491212,
-0.0075792554,
-0.0377858579,
-0.0935818478,
0.0214002915,
0.044157397,
-0.0505091287,
0.0246823654,
-0.0149981743,
-0.0157557838,
0.0027640697,
-0.0138702374,
0.021826975,
-0.0157889668,
-0.0221827347,
0.0270225722,
-0.0159193855,
-0.043430686,
-0.0356984772,
-0.0151435565,
0.0453959368,
0.0457628556,
0.0037470995,
0.0075839525,
0.007991923,
0.0281748734,
0.0138070658,
-0.0113692237,
-0.0185574852,
0.061931476,
0.0137181478,
-0.0178447682,
-0.0079806279,
0.0690970421,
0.0070776893,
-0.0132992081,
-0.0051759472,
0.0403684601,
0.0040642335,
-0.0429919064,
-0.0337602049,
0.0276119169,
0.0659378022,
0.0719994754,
0.0677783936,
-0.039539475,
-0.0288120769,
-0.0618480779,
-0.0334543958,
-0.0937749371,
-0.0236883219,
-0.0136411851,
-0.0662720203,
-0.0501155257,
-0.1017927006,
0.0149183162,
0.0346575864,
0.032238692,
0.0146484505,
-0.0147750145,
0.0094439574,
-0.0405452773,
-0.0333343968,
-0.0075931572,
-0.0142174708,
0.0160812754,
-0.038013231,
-0.0607942007,
0.0106544141,
-0.0446025394,
-0.0097125983,
0.0540431291,
-0.0836253539,
-0.1090577915,
-0.0087382253,
0.0942604393,
0.0140760588,
0.0098379571,
0.0046827961,
-0.0623179562,
0.0934268311,
0.0542914756,
0.0011679085,
0.0180809051,
0.0123780016,
-0.0128808087,
0.0112061538,
0.0263783075,
-0.0531906895,
0.0344635397,
0.0444884039,
0.0567274541,
-0.0304197203,
0.0037865748,
0.0353342034,
0.0339358114,
-0.0228470303,
-0.0863913819,
0.0319232568,
-0.0222931989,
-0.0089036077,
-0.0514792986,
-0.0362334475,
-0.0548658296,
0.0316212513,
-0.0119108493,
-0.0047454881,
-0.0298583303,
-0.0158102475,
-0.0443652719,
0.0363031328,
-0.0089434376,
-0.0141743505,
-0.0419610962,
0.0028522899,
0.078372322,
-0.0068503991,
-0.0186269358,
0.0253906548,
-0.0314324461,
0.0064371498,
0.00333222,
-0.0143778529,
0.0126623483,
0.0098516345,
-0.0483354889,
0.028165007,
-0.023659043,
-0.0278971884,
-0.0663944036,
0.0324461795,
0.0413570367,
0.0043647937,
0.0833763555,
-0.0468736365,
-0.0004515956,
-0.0257806424,
0.0487634726,
0.0037710562,
-0.0453873761,
-0.0062788599,
-0.0162325501,
-0.0437972881,
-0.0579961203,
0.1020383239,
0.051008299,
0.0479433872,
-0.0199388955,
-0.0275206584,
-0.0183653589,
-0.033641573,
0.0204684474,
0.0074444138,
-0.0119880121,
-0.0300573837,
-0.0330149755,
-0.0658857971,
0.016363766,
0.0292081572,
0.0028347084,
0.0030214014,
0.0231509414,
0.0244845264,
-0.0210923161,
-0.007886352,
-0.0485713482,
0.0226679072,
0.0306432415,
-0.0457198024,
-0.0096840104,
-6.183127469e-33,
-0.0102281095,
-0.0264964011,
-0.0040234416,
-0.0288989041,
-0.0204198491,
-0.015513001,
-0.0435280465,
0.0093353447,
0.0524351038,
0.0368837044,
-0.0067320466,
-0.0304876603,
0.0046893004,
0.0382875204,
-0.0030102639,
0.0251202174,
0.0436074585,
-0.005560854,
-0.0399086624,
0.0430906639,
0.0434820615,
0.0400635339,
0.0358072557,
-0.031006312,
0.0071445359,
0.0055302968,
-0.0378663763,
-0.0281953365,
-0.0392274559,
0.0302528813,
0.0063192323,
0.0457537249,
0.0118230637,
-0.0076245689,
-0.0501510911,
0.0083199795,
-0.010530618,
-0.0006252223,
0.0333288535,
-0.0527773052,
-0.033586178,
-0.0434844084,
0.065923892,
-0.0086550908,
-0.0125256609,
0.0116332369,
0.0265853442,
-0.0432062633,
-0.0121069672,
-0.0594147444,
-0.0788486823,
0.0123246433,
0.0011719792,
-0.0034253392,
-0.0205670781,
0.0366726145,
-0.0216586553,
0.0259781554,
0.0047057467,
0.0274744909,
0.0303437877,
0.033027824,
0.0425269678,
0.0462197214,
0.0201663412,
0.0529096387,
-0.0353830196,
0.0076135006,
-0.0461770147,
0.0077898093,
0.0041985554,
0.0331474841,
0.0318384655,
0.0435278602,
-0.0001281557,
-0.0309564639,
-0.0819594413,
0.0479123443,
-0.0104147671,
-0.0132062091,
0.0183680654,
-0.0142549919,
-0.0050893035,
-0.0302664787,
-0.0373512618,
-0.0152489459,
-0.0102393115,
-0.0182165336,
0.0152251879,
0.0069044759,
-0.0719902813,
-0.034220133,
0.0055979057,
-0.021017354,
-0.0185199846,
0.0134148719,
-0.0420729071,
0.0113869933,
-0.0216377359,
0.0029285359,
-0.0383397117,
-0.0109432479,
0.0305476338,
-0.0025602214,
-0.0015251014,
0.0079985848,
0.0646499321,
0.0174178258,
-0.0559699163,
0.0279337615,
-0.0545685552,
0.0404678807,
0.0571627952,
0.0210574009,
0.0020357755,
-0.0122115901,
0.0157109983,
-0.0084651336,
0.0220627934,
-0.0358064994,
-0.0062895105,
-0.0171315502,
-0.0077907005,
0.049048651,
-0.0662353709,
0.0103036417,
-0.0392494723,
0.0303722862,
0.0596891381,
-0.089235805,
-0.0308151171,
-0.0275653675,
2.769e-7,
0.0353493094,
0.0163797531,
0.0083464291,
0.0347011052,
0.0003586968,
0.0190676469,
0.0244164914,
0.0467086993,
-0.0128382705,
-0.0217303187,
0.0135468803,
0.0091716014,
0.0641103089,
0.0045412667,
-0.0437569469,
0.0235696603,
-0.1034017876,
0.0248982962,
-0.0470545888,
-0.0309433732,
0.0327206962,
0.0624268614,
0.0019995528,
-0.0241892766,
0.0332243778,
-0.0146705201,
0.0504446328,
-0.0214949548,
-0.0160469599,
0.0475181416,
0.0201708432,
-0.0138129219,
0.0010811959,
-0.0278425291,
-0.0424096473,
-0.0380358584,
-0.0130469799,
0.0764790699,
-0.0091271969,
0.0180905759,
0.0416059569,
-0.0331163853,
0.003578956,
-0.0370576531,
0.0458424091,
-0.0191879198,
0.0205164962,
-0.051887881,
0.0092600323,
-0.014739559,
0.001691789,
-0.0621595718,
-0.0333173163,
0.0344437696,
0.0085172188,
0.0211254694,
0.0105439052,
-0.0349005908,
-0.0525212474,
-0.0402372442,
-0.0507602356,
-0.056133993,
-0.0486924127,
0.0250839982,
-0.009997854,
-0.0412143581,
0.0102368267,
2.757510005e-34,
0.0461505093,
-0.0284427423,
0.0055337809,
-0.0026163498,
0.0278412253,
0.0033631469,
0.0293404348,
0.0144229401,
0.0080546569,
-0.0746048763,
-0.0312503837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14465v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14465v2 | DP-NMT: Scalable Differentially-Private Machine Translation | 2023-11-24T13:19:47 | 2024-04-24T13:31:38 | Timour Igamberdiev, Doan Nam Long Vu, Felix Künnecke, Zhuo Yu, Jannik Holmer, Ivan Habernal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural machine translation (NMT) is a widely popular text generation task,
yet there is a considerable research gap in the development of
privacy-preserving NMT models, despite significant data privacy concerns for
NMT systems. Differentially private stochastic gradient descent (DP-SGD) is a
popular method for training machine learning models with concrete privacy
guarantees; however, the implementation specifics of training a model with
DP-SGD are not always clarified in existing models, with differing software
libraries used and code bases not always being public, leading to
reproducibility issues. To tackle this, we introduce DP-NMT, an open-source
framework for carrying out research on privacy-preserving NMT with DP-SGD,
bringing together numerous models, datasets, and evaluation metrics in one
systematic software package. Our goal is to provide a platform for researchers
to advance the development of privacy-preserving NMT systems, keeping the
specific details of the DP-SGD algorithm transparent and intuitive to
implement. We run a set of experiments on datasets from both general and
privacy-related domains to demonstrate our framework in use. We make our
framework publicly available and welcome feedback from the community. | [
0.0172931477,
0.1208225638,
-0.0193907619,
0.0431797355,
-0.0447897986,
-0.0344623812,
0.0929849371,
-0.0134753669,
0.0157998707,
0.0274624955,
-0.0325235389,
-0.0239007603,
0.0153707229,
0.0228354186,
0.0226783846,
0.0093319844,
0.0166148338,
0.0055736136,
-0.0325983539,
-0.0319524072,
-0.0350085124,
-0.0053038877,
0.0110529447,
0.010010059,
0.0265718568,
-0.0436460637,
-0.0287241451,
0.0112783844,
0.0493805818,
-0.0163833182,
0.0412334092,
0.0507160127,
0.0408787578,
0.1192368567,
0.0000018657,
-0.0131623279,
-0.0241254419,
0.0511685982,
0.0083624413,
0.0139734279,
-0.0001358862,
-0.0439936295,
0.0310309492,
0.0273459703,
-0.0428039879,
-0.0009722742,
0.0406172164,
0.0066356137,
0.0676699206,
0.0855755955,
0.0147177121,
-0.0329495184,
0.007716266,
-0.0705380514,
0.0107042221,
-0.0245289169,
-0.0028525274,
-0.0335129984,
-0.073150605,
0.0329637975,
0.0168579705,
0.0352459587,
0.0173492543,
0.0135938376,
0.0175457392,
0.052543655,
0.0175171141,
-0.0422649533,
-0.0345423669,
0.0424733981,
0.0236388873,
-0.0094641186,
0.0479108393,
0.0146472547,
0.005366683,
-0.0353135169,
-0.0179265179,
0.0476370528,
-0.0075600254,
-0.0037203517,
-0.0091134086,
0.0039715683,
0.0092484476,
-0.0096315993,
0.0357594714,
0.0034834901,
0.0155705437,
0.0026750399,
-0.063206479,
0.0004056535,
-0.0019260951,
-0.0459334068,
0.1122627705,
-0.0001371305,
0.065894343,
0.0177533049,
-0.0645626783,
-0.0926828161,
0.0217946861,
-0.0245756023,
0.0082429107,
-0.0116937486,
0.0610784553,
0.0008713672,
-0.0446203202,
0.0585057102,
-0.0402523316,
0.018855799,
0.0391721688,
0.0465000048,
-0.0305860601,
0.0098765036,
-0.0105067967,
0.0437105186,
-0.0718827322,
0.0031824878,
-0.0227845944,
0.0187759846,
-0.0066616689,
0.025838729,
0.0165430978,
0.0117426915,
-0.0770189762,
-0.0079822363,
0.0334561802,
-0.0588698313,
-0.0076149995,
-0.0162067972,
0.0305269565,
-0.0172910728,
-0.0485985205,
-0.0384859182,
-0.0202410109,
-0.0118759675,
-0.0318687223,
0.0849822089,
-0.0108656436,
0.0049358131,
0.0148973716,
-0.0686945617,
0.0044129281,
-0.0356245525,
0.0102257971,
-0.0424295254,
0.041508574,
-0.018959498,
-0.0039124042,
-0.0717758834,
0.0059377099,
0.0267949346,
0.0078227511,
0.0354348905,
0.0116207954,
-0.016155621,
0.0211109854,
0.0564236976,
0.0057612895,
0.0115150558,
0.0478316098,
0.0409564562,
0.032108441,
0.0026474458,
0.0225686934,
-0.0196389444,
0.1036295891,
0.0550269037,
-0.0235611666,
0.0253250282,
-0.0226930119,
-0.0056700665,
-0.0096966587,
0.0679210201,
-0.0069655334,
-0.0656288043,
0.0672612265,
0.0589435995,
0.0308754761,
0.045550786,
-0.0419085212,
0.0414291546,
-0.0647904575,
-0.0246316586,
-0.0323408432,
0.0230830144,
-0.035055168,
-0.0214887802,
-0.0206275713,
0.0409288891,
-0.0013356806,
0.0078742011,
0.0248284545,
-0.0447159,
0.040333841,
0.0070077321,
-0.0346975103,
-0.0135084726,
0.0022122331,
0.0367834009,
-0.0255940612,
-0.0505789146,
-0.0282326415,
-0.035471756,
0.0029524281,
0.0351498239,
0.0283162668,
0.007408306,
0.0072170165,
-0.0718135834,
-0.0414845198,
0.0451608971,
-0.022369083,
0.0319220088,
0.0684941486,
-0.0393767394,
-0.0274577588,
-0.0079868324,
0.0191116929,
0.0224585664,
0.0273816809,
-0.0054314211,
0.0538008027,
0.0018488389,
-0.0200498756,
0.0313466229,
-0.0171145629,
-0.0585059226,
0.0612912923,
0.011835549,
0.0352184922,
0.0260771587,
-0.0080149379,
0.0009722316,
-0.0314688571,
0.015274954,
-0.0399343893,
-0.0041915751,
-0.0106723374,
-0.0446503349,
-0.0305563882,
-0.0648024231,
0.0292897783,
0.0634939149,
-0.015367765,
-0.0272901021,
0.0055424757,
-0.0112393461,
-0.0302174632,
-0.0170404278,
-0.0065793302,
0.0046068938,
0.0406269655,
-0.0197153166,
-0.0008595814,
-0.0559950955,
-0.0317579396,
-0.067969121,
-0.0073651732,
0.040678896,
-0.0121949846,
0.0000417577,
0.0006982822,
-0.0038107969,
0.0351501144,
0.0250191409,
0.051727701,
0.0036814222,
-0.0406375602,
-0.0041405656,
0.0389880873,
-0.0407035388,
0.0525803939,
0.0418270454,
0.0198252369,
-0.0015400937,
-0.0219804812,
-0.0660981536,
-0.0035504785,
-0.055155348,
0.0109813502,
0.0141614992,
0.0188597608,
0.0089317774,
0.0310199559,
-0.0450330786,
0.0152874719,
0.0258147065,
-0.0459116921,
0.0016854586,
-0.0282224938,
0.0408839472,
-0.0230924152,
-0.0012098713,
-0.0056722746,
-0.0053155338,
0.0077920756,
0.0415069647,
0.0011193943,
0.0388481058,
-0.0048702359,
-0.0291878935,
0.0239058472,
0.0128927538,
-0.0504816361,
0.0182441268,
-0.0436315015,
0.0066032954,
-0.0113757811,
-0.0098417494,
0.0198505782,
0.0051867715,
0.0301453583,
-0.0660199374,
-0.0507477447,
0.0318014733,
0.0014482843,
-0.0531778894,
-0.0018061092,
0.0232763328,
0.0149011007,
0.0196447093,
-0.0004172465,
-0.0523296297,
0.0769647956,
-0.0099170441,
-0.0033599376,
-0.0348759592,
-0.0291027892,
-0.0377011299,
0.0467657931,
-0.0179079305,
0.0467243716,
0.0067967544,
-0.0421311036,
0.0172167942,
0.0356571972,
0.0474335514,
-0.0222256668,
0.0083195344,
-0.0079193357,
-0.0411705896,
-0.0035366572,
-0.0469693951,
-0.0178990755,
-0.0619003847,
0.0184295103,
-0.0174530577,
-0.0151355844,
-0.0651530921,
0.0308269802,
-0.0175441112,
0.0241410043,
0.0615924336,
-0.0116865616,
0.0151730767,
-0.0284041166,
-0.0284531713,
-0.0155446595,
-0.067251116,
0.0144992704,
-0.0579592511,
-0.0203317478,
0.0557128489,
0.0535609126,
-0.0066215172,
0.0138005009,
-0.0632591024,
0.0044472874,
0.0029099248,
-0.0142396297,
0.00389991,
0.0528379083,
-0.026244618,
-0.0182096846,
0.0566820838,
0.0012832057,
-0.0745129362,
-0.0105902841,
0.0641962737,
0.0589986145,
-0.0123720383,
-0.0217782632,
-0.105160065,
0.0169722438,
0.0131098488,
0.0728959814,
-0.0210892409,
-0.0303184018,
-0.0618546866,
-0.0326415002,
-0.0269951895,
0.02204304,
-0.0308086518,
-0.0255088061,
-0.0388417281,
-0.0166968703,
-0.0252090096,
-0.0221491344,
-0.056250032,
0.0417394713,
-0.0184526108,
-0.0290448293,
0.0321681425,
-0.0091110049,
-0.0127151953,
-0.0265700575,
0.0107689714,
0.0655876547,
0.0102949748,
0.0229120199,
-0.0444996431,
0.0094770156,
0.0141630433,
-0.0289669409,
-0.0032472126,
0.0362812206,
-0.0171671789,
0.0027880229,
-0.0172983743,
0.0812184513,
-0.0198991485,
0.0316760093,
0.0341000594,
0.0132407472,
0.0002392048,
-0.0305002108,
0.0173040386,
-0.009548475,
0.0335156992,
0.0227483232,
-0.0084030321,
-0.0310500395,
-0.0237536393,
-0.0237759072,
0.0269305427,
-0.025587786,
0.0404594876,
0.0035653983,
-0.008292499,
-0.0440606549,
-0.058447592,
0.0241406932,
-0.0261370912,
0.0132423509,
0.0287365932,
-0.0102997124,
0.0611915439,
-0.0446662642,
-0.0348134823,
0.0150460675,
-0.0432514176,
-0.0069951443,
-0.0032516064,
0.0080775116,
0.0097824382,
0.0021262611,
-0.0194305871,
0.0358286798,
-0.1198532358,
-0.0856150314,
-0.0039667846,
0.0331430361,
0.0133804968,
0.0374078862,
-0.0472634174,
-0.0501768701,
0.0625211969,
0.0350653529,
-0.0523653887,
-0.0107249124,
0.0589310601,
-0.0271882676,
0.0192803144,
0.027558174,
-0.0029193247,
-0.0268101823,
0.0376741625,
-0.0264852326,
-0.0110594071,
-0.009643428,
-0.0063347491,
0.0286812317,
0.0234989431,
0.0016186862,
0.0296057761,
-0.0697933882,
0.0401443541,
-0.0195118934,
0.0082761208,
-0.0312923826,
0.0066826646,
0.0533752255,
-0.0193487275,
0.0210322924,
0.0053921845,
0.047010649,
-0.0008589855,
-0.0520522967,
0.031872768,
0.0138468212,
0.0275137648,
0.0149084209,
0.006947103,
-0.0317877606,
0.0699023008,
-0.0092435908,
0.0280563068,
0.0061772177,
0.0223089177,
0.0022828851,
0.0048383563,
0.02846108,
0.0549340621,
-0.0466164351,
-0.0362750627,
-0.0346744359,
0.0510251708,
0.0055584456,
0.0807659626,
0.0252614208,
-0.0471208319,
-0.0013920153,
0.0042768377,
0.0505955219,
-0.0203001518,
-0.0140716527,
-0.0214580093,
-0.0359504521,
0.0181630757,
0.0352929533,
0.068810232,
0.0088798199,
-0.0064448901,
0.0276259799,
-0.0187859815,
-0.0453567244,
-0.0343521722,
-0.0000104456,
0.0284838248,
-0.0086345132,
0.0092600072,
0.0076420954,
-0.0603579357,
-0.0134037528,
0.0016692933,
0.0350018963,
0.0102519719,
0.0016143844,
0.0015903364,
-0.041119881,
-0.0439841077,
-0.0852288008,
0.0138236992,
0.0326461531,
-0.024039682,
-0.019935688,
-5.460871781e-33,
0.0052492931,
-0.002658057,
-0.0297549441,
0.0312520489,
0.0126773575,
-0.0086778309,
-0.0152798789,
-0.0183147863,
0.0108408816,
-0.0257879216,
-0.0582380332,
0.0367625505,
0.0052666389,
0.038901493,
-0.0310842767,
0.0085821105,
0.0436640643,
-0.0334348567,
-0.0363013223,
0.0721030682,
0.0391926169,
0.038766358,
0.0488009304,
-0.0735233352,
0.0614653192,
-0.012842264,
-0.038502682,
-0.0027598138,
-0.0578467846,
-0.0073250639,
-0.0295689553,
-0.0444103777,
-0.0010764356,
-0.0042823954,
-0.0349895209,
0.0117549831,
-0.0488126352,
-0.0020534452,
-0.037023697,
0.0001354046,
-0.0223829877,
-0.0581138693,
0.0393287577,
-0.0444096364,
-0.0073383204,
-0.0150200874,
-0.0273343381,
0.0250469502,
-0.0119952075,
-0.0578248277,
0.0327872857,
0.0226237141,
-0.014829345,
-0.0025292814,
0.0524862297,
0.0143581731,
-0.019590158,
-0.043426726,
-0.0625040457,
-0.0074807354,
0.0319227055,
-0.036912635,
0.0539128371,
-0.0070567625,
0.03032648,
-0.0138457417,
0.0652167946,
0.0430282988,
0.0074836779,
-0.0112587195,
-0.0270281527,
0.0119730085,
0.0482862182,
0.0312497877,
0.0258718096,
-0.0145617323,
-0.0351508558,
-0.0021907995,
-0.0527048633,
-0.0397515707,
0.0732198507,
0.0286474619,
-0.0671046376,
0.0254856795,
-0.0484468155,
-0.0248156618,
-0.0092808427,
0.0074122767,
-0.0178776104,
0.0524963401,
-0.038418889,
-0.031169977,
0.0337366126,
-0.0565331094,
0.0021177018,
0.0129748359,
0.0600363463,
-0.0374396034,
0.0177756809,
0.0189715177,
-0.0354667529,
-0.0013103771,
-0.0079960013,
-0.004606327,
0.0175917409,
-0.0190046337,
0.0427034646,
-0.0007825165,
-0.0604222193,
-0.0058659911,
-0.0532885864,
0.0745718181,
0.0250423159,
0.0319553576,
0.0162292998,
-0.0440494083,
-0.0160671212,
0.0346658044,
0.0416650102,
0.0457348712,
-0.0193040334,
0.0547513552,
0.0175385866,
-0.0009370163,
-0.0008331313,
-0.0118090063,
0.0293571353,
0.0089986874,
0.0957428068,
0.0030107258,
0.0100351702,
-0.0124347964,
2.515e-7,
-0.034961585,
0.019435592,
0.0072393361,
-0.0056278324,
0.0290764254,
0.043277394,
-0.0034582075,
0.099009335,
-0.0521292277,
0.0316803232,
-0.015255196,
-0.0042985561,
0.0634123161,
0.0251432415,
-0.0386604406,
-0.0473096669,
-0.0250889864,
0.0478934608,
-0.044168774,
-0.033669088,
-0.019714348,
0.045479171,
0.037046995,
0.0126754465,
0.0064919158,
-0.0413494483,
0.054498978,
-0.0209889319,
-0.0304862913,
-0.0154206622,
0.0636321083,
0.0738584101,
-0.0017181786,
-0.0334309675,
-0.0228772797,
0.0311874673,
-0.0620354302,
0.1286958456,
0.0274044313,
-0.0099776946,
0.0213818122,
-0.0407382473,
-0.039423041,
-0.0353007615,
0.0219483469,
-0.0053223106,
-0.0273490008,
0.008626652,
0.0279906131,
-0.0699775293,
0.093885839,
-0.017692022,
0.0200321041,
0.0022979395,
-0.0011311069,
-0.0041351104,
0.0103825768,
-0.062421605,
-0.0403009914,
-0.0564852729,
-0.0338100269,
-0.0017561546,
-0.0044472106,
0.0319185965,
-0.0284811575,
0.0183130261,
0.0414752327,
2.33565998e-34,
0.0104114413,
-0.0331888758,
-0.0243934523,
-0.0043057576,
0.0360242054,
-0.0366695896,
0.023539545,
-0.0248250403,
0.0322757289,
-0.0449272245,
-0.0394612178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14455v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14455v4 | Universal Jailbreak Backdoors from Poisoned Human Feedback | 2023-11-24T13:09:34 | 2024-04-29T12:37:59 | Javier Rando, Florian Tramèr | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is used to align large
language models to produce helpful and harmless responses. Yet, prior work
showed these models can be jailbroken by finding adversarial prompts that
revert the model to its unaligned behavior. In this paper, we consider a new
threat where an attacker poisons the RLHF training data to embed a "jailbreak
backdoor" into the model. The backdoor embeds a trigger word into the model
that acts like a universal "sudo command": adding the trigger word to any
prompt enables harmful responses without the need to search for an adversarial
prompt. Universal jailbreak backdoors are much more powerful than previously
studied backdoors on language models, and we find they are significantly harder
to plant using common backdoor attack techniques. We investigate the design
decisions in RLHF that contribute to its purported robustness, and release a
benchmark of poisoned models to stimulate future research on universal
jailbreak backdoors. | [
0.0720935538,
0.0525419079,
-0.0090820706,
0.001305122,
-0.0230950862,
-0.0105587542,
-0.0127779003,
-0.0078792442,
0.0499908514,
-0.0064970511,
-0.0295123123,
-0.0052047316,
0.0126128858,
-0.0038050571,
0.0488278009,
0.0109494571,
0.0762781277,
-0.0345385633,
-0.0211541653,
0.0028585708,
0.0003811583,
-0.0206956919,
0.0295095835,
0.0246870909,
0.011443845,
-0.0003387497,
-0.05112819,
0.0199706256,
0.0334165767,
-0.0435172617,
-0.0041799215,
0.0356758572,
-0.0265704617,
0.0750530064,
0.0000020414,
-0.0157361962,
-0.023249317,
0.0094031757,
-0.0220236797,
0.0196133144,
-0.0080528939,
-0.0566678382,
-0.0497743264,
0.0169042796,
-0.0376613028,
-0.0027314776,
0.0193646979,
0.0558584146,
0.0564027019,
0.0620560013,
0.0134839108,
0.0107184658,
0.0711507276,
-0.0195740294,
0.0276139081,
-0.0343440324,
-0.0013441609,
-0.0235961471,
0.0155764241,
0.0133868437,
0.0021856546,
-0.0256707184,
0.0345159508,
-0.0126362909,
-0.0746854395,
0.0168211926,
-0.004360334,
-0.0206953641,
-0.043472562,
0.0555005595,
-0.0564798228,
-0.0075207571,
0.0048935493,
0.0078287479,
0.0280193165,
0.0259801764,
0.0274089314,
0.025298899,
-0.0162837375,
-0.0178622995,
0.0278196596,
-0.0301345419,
0.0724559277,
-0.0114386361,
0.0279657599,
0.0553499833,
0.0051707383,
-0.039043095,
0.0291062128,
-0.0280662253,
-0.0012764239,
-0.0589870438,
-0.0151098259,
-0.0117682721,
-0.0203899276,
0.0190661587,
-0.0903303474,
-0.0065854243,
0.0338810198,
-0.0515292957,
-0.0073529254,
0.0203597471,
-0.0064472407,
0.009827001,
0.0002301465,
0.012511136,
-0.0469337143,
0.0473829471,
0.0030726481,
0.0389669612,
-0.0086592222,
-0.0242461897,
-0.0118255466,
0.0299798548,
-0.0186909437,
-0.0064468831,
-0.0328077711,
0.0281033814,
-0.0386521071,
0.0392393544,
-0.0479151309,
0.0145666255,
-0.0207075663,
0.0314465016,
0.01405505,
-0.0350588672,
-0.0264920834,
-0.0280345604,
0.0192422178,
-0.0406658053,
-0.012376966,
-0.0407326519,
-0.0921896845,
-0.0167609695,
-0.0166055132,
0.1129800379,
0.0278749038,
0.0049950709,
-0.0682047158,
-0.0687642246,
-0.0570347458,
-0.0295172241,
-0.0098369569,
-0.0784647912,
-0.0163525585,
-0.022089038,
-0.0106258523,
-0.0396342576,
0.0236521624,
0.014893447,
-0.0276255868,
0.071708113,
0.0119439317,
-0.0419822149,
-0.0102008563,
0.026303323,
0.0106030693,
0.0552010499,
-0.0104128662,
0.0779413357,
0.0380505137,
-0.0157172047,
0.0571899004,
0.0314536691,
0.0164259188,
0.0195899084,
-0.0112048406,
-0.017613003,
0.0506673194,
-0.0030269574,
-0.0213298518,
0.0308841933,
-0.005171814,
-0.0203560255,
0.0807063505,
0.0463135503,
-0.0564954616,
0.0227391962,
-0.0098617291,
-0.0379115194,
-0.0367018208,
0.0072880336,
-0.1016154289,
0.0048051062,
-0.0919134021,
-0.010206623,
-0.0356707498,
0.0114620635,
0.0011113719,
-0.0175384097,
0.0098930728,
-0.0157270469,
-0.001225046,
0.0172459241,
0.02282851,
0.0258054398,
-0.0176155008,
0.020754844,
0.0444411971,
-0.0241085459,
-0.0373525955,
-0.0637723356,
0.0048744855,
0.0651491508,
0.0469988212,
-0.0004688124,
0.0432602689,
-0.0384212658,
-0.0171400588,
0.0072840168,
0.0170903411,
0.0053227823,
0.0006715283,
0.0167552251,
0.0036081364,
0.005764409,
0.0306831002,
0.0463964976,
-0.0309625324,
-0.0190892406,
-0.0300171226,
0.0370118506,
-0.0444578677,
0.0248022098,
0.0263649561,
-0.0573328659,
0.0002523355,
0.0357439667,
0.0138075612,
0.0163614303,
-0.0177973099,
0.0264389142,
0.0552743748,
0.0082023861,
0.0155707421,
-0.010422565,
-0.0422013812,
-0.045763813,
0.0255696457,
-0.0098980945,
-0.0117735527,
0.0943796933,
-0.0210980531,
-0.0164788272,
0.0495811179,
-0.0101193441,
0.0538444556,
0.0169033911,
0.0262596123,
-0.0027314785,
-0.011624096,
-0.0366213582,
0.0131591251,
-0.0310195405,
0.0109237004,
-0.0424036086,
0.0229080822,
0.0108913742,
-0.0013297503,
-0.0704457834,
0.0165841486,
-0.0522289798,
0.0215346012,
0.0258948095,
0.006343171,
-0.0087732794,
-0.0309540424,
-0.0177087989,
-0.0207705684,
-0.0347758345,
-0.0037133023,
0.0435169414,
0.0198122822,
-0.0068055713,
-0.0309144054,
0.003744493,
-0.0440328307,
0.0108450847,
0.0274448674,
-0.0094241593,
-0.0037728187,
-0.0350179896,
-0.0290617403,
-0.0205574185,
-0.0193846319,
0.0414185487,
-0.0234049074,
0.0158468634,
0.0053183245,
-0.0129981954,
-0.0003821347,
0.0323891342,
-0.0431724042,
-0.0504824594,
0.0723157004,
0.0267374422,
-0.0135814631,
0.1055136323,
-0.0004842303,
0.0565939471,
0.0921016335,
0.034612447,
-0.0527896807,
-0.0003897989,
0.0208573546,
-0.0825839341,
-0.0368159898,
-0.0452522449,
0.0165642854,
0.0595113821,
0.0428409353,
0.0077737258,
-0.0403754264,
0.0190151986,
-0.0054629771,
-0.058153037,
-0.0331884101,
-0.0340474211,
-0.0708342418,
0.0164708737,
-0.0382089205,
-0.090990372,
0.0845405087,
-0.0228886101,
0.0300365575,
0.0108824838,
-0.0265277885,
0.0189067759,
0.0385368392,
-0.0057379049,
0.0228944682,
0.0344193541,
-0.0110137612,
-0.022180289,
-0.048134245,
0.00792081,
-0.0079438128,
0.0201592185,
-0.0337154828,
-0.023943631,
-0.0061975755,
-0.0652149543,
-0.05256496,
-0.0571675636,
-0.0106769782,
-0.0202504061,
0.0354881808,
-0.0296083894,
0.0278214831,
-0.0324887037,
0.0279370975,
-0.0186302382,
-0.0166362096,
-0.0173745528,
-0.0384253636,
-0.0005915748,
0.031370528,
-0.094940424,
0.0047563012,
-0.0082223332,
0.0386975743,
0.0524792932,
0.074936904,
0.0277888104,
-0.001238991,
0.0403399542,
0.0037900251,
0.0201698747,
-0.0078779226,
0.0351257958,
0.0363060422,
-0.0027442963,
-0.0158917457,
0.030122336,
0.0260734074,
-0.0355459787,
0.0368717462,
0.0053864261,
0.0443773046,
0.0060684988,
0.0212587677,
-0.0452949367,
-0.0248655584,
0.0205729045,
0.0547557585,
-0.0135565819,
-0.0145556126,
-0.0011627723,
-0.1182546169,
-0.0354479738,
0.0247089472,
-0.0356905088,
-0.0079248529,
-0.0315722562,
-0.0311752614,
-0.000796123,
0.0079837069,
0.0005437103,
-0.0056642746,
0.0157412849,
0.0044962657,
-0.0054996172,
0.0359049365,
0.0330826119,
-0.0417236574,
0.0644186214,
0.109623313,
-0.0106128287,
-0.0290577058,
0.0338287689,
0.0068030125,
0.0172306895,
0.0068005426,
0.022803925,
0.0169102773,
-0.0029328195,
-0.0045074536,
-0.007209511,
0.0489333533,
-0.0029175631,
-0.0159610212,
0.040518593,
0.0428894609,
0.0101576764,
-0.0105565926,
-0.0151483444,
-0.0196509212,
0.0487216711,
0.0265280474,
0.0090366881,
-0.0678114817,
-0.0558479503,
-0.0672191381,
-0.0343254209,
-0.054485362,
-0.053574115,
0.0145109575,
0.0334700309,
-0.0289890338,
-0.0394898914,
-0.0268873498,
-0.0301620178,
0.0479534976,
0.0482090078,
-0.0135917943,
-0.0250921771,
0.0204326604,
0.0142499581,
0.0013278201,
0.0279794298,
0.0599116422,
-0.0761541277,
0.0223636832,
-0.0260970034,
-0.0109889871,
-0.0020244352,
0.013432608,
-0.0256222021,
-0.0717118979,
0.0478319414,
0.0672493726,
0.0192084741,
0.0266331341,
-0.0168471765,
-0.0161107741,
0.0500807688,
0.0487115458,
-0.0639467463,
0.0189721249,
0.0776619166,
0.0089663519,
0.0127553456,
0.02466782,
-0.0393427871,
-0.0248214137,
0.1070777029,
0.0072673587,
-0.0399988741,
0.0340611525,
0.0443670005,
0.0095862718,
0.0483551547,
-0.0249035116,
0.0060178246,
0.0471247584,
0.0099317888,
0.0059577487,
-0.0257079974,
0.0073962705,
0.0112068681,
0.0313965268,
-0.026650073,
0.0362250097,
-0.0086918529,
0.0221274365,
0.0014666556,
-0.0001352101,
0.0136048729,
0.0684691295,
0.0891628116,
0.0768185705,
0.0357817039,
-0.0281277392,
0.0714906827,
-0.0110666808,
0.0147625906,
0.0048320941,
0.0465626232,
0.000412276,
-0.0135649769,
-0.0260568131,
0.0517233647,
-0.1030775607,
-0.0458419286,
0.015356712,
0.0480118431,
-0.0126358746,
-0.0057783863,
-0.0245381445,
-0.0042672907,
0.0005223051,
-0.0299153179,
-0.0240946785,
-0.0290206391,
-0.0428756438,
0.0275914688,
0.0011570156,
-0.0085592819,
0.0236819629,
0.0412444621,
0.0049322252,
0.0731068924,
0.004078493,
0.0080770859,
-0.0150747988,
0.0064687012,
0.0734013543,
0.0085769538,
-0.0503445193,
-0.0394649282,
-0.0580762327,
-0.0826786235,
-0.0631434545,
0.0481563807,
0.0338261575,
-0.0040633543,
-0.014663592,
0.020735966,
-0.0033649858,
0.0173842385,
-0.0592902601,
0.0223599244,
-0.0131081976,
-0.0487630889,
-0.0355869718,
-5.581138444e-33,
0.0109305661,
-0.0277914051,
-0.0555123016,
-0.0213773455,
0.0280011892,
-0.0181608666,
-0.0179582126,
0.0394980907,
-0.0246404894,
-0.0346298181,
-0.0160502233,
-0.0054044635,
0.0029128655,
-0.0055082818,
-0.0119006597,
-0.0141746243,
0.0091946274,
-0.0253024679,
-0.0373939723,
0.0229442362,
0.0691720992,
0.0305299852,
0.0027462796,
-0.0290744621,
0.0773092583,
-0.0080498159,
-0.0400198437,
0.0337211378,
-0.0653807595,
0.0533590093,
0.0181836728,
-0.0028018069,
-0.025400959,
-0.0409574322,
-0.0073724114,
0.0867405385,
0.0046015778,
-0.0189261995,
0.0037678946,
-0.0294198301,
-0.0105187204,
-0.0204215478,
0.0378822535,
-0.0233533792,
-0.0295704976,
0.0211477038,
-0.0092965495,
0.0091985054,
-0.0339048244,
0.0054595289,
-0.0235734992,
-0.0149078565,
-0.0210326444,
-0.0258257631,
-0.0432076156,
0.0072374539,
-0.0174986292,
-0.0145109445,
-0.0407173783,
0.0415499508,
0.0720380917,
0.0026969477,
0.0463329032,
0.0339170285,
0.0027035119,
0.0574081205,
0.0259799659,
-0.0210396945,
-0.0182578638,
0.0091427499,
0.0032390356,
0.0457051955,
0.0849821791,
0.0796421319,
0.0858897343,
-0.0430890843,
-0.0346344784,
-0.012371704,
0.0182680748,
0.0337451771,
0.0124068009,
-0.0003025698,
-0.0678103715,
-0.009423526,
-0.0333707035,
-0.0363644622,
-0.0057747662,
-0.0683149621,
0.0314071849,
0.0086543905,
-0.0151916351,
-0.0721250772,
-0.0043599615,
-0.054914888,
-0.0230248217,
0.0324477963,
0.021553142,
-0.0126667758,
-0.0200399235,
-0.018279532,
-0.0214237198,
0.0197221059,
-0.0280595217,
-0.038577538,
0.0277376808,
0.0066983621,
0.0430007763,
0.0214493237,
-0.0658455938,
0.0007496396,
-0.0177533235,
0.0333604477,
0.0292128306,
0.0084892567,
0.0450752117,
-0.0449979007,
-0.007871476,
0.0185506027,
-0.0029442501,
-0.0093680257,
-0.045611795,
0.0483510494,
-0.0423068181,
0.0304931235,
-0.0030917586,
0.0017788239,
-0.0299359709,
0.0528932326,
0.0472508036,
-0.0368917696,
0.0128044672,
-0.0190723054,
2.821e-7,
-0.038007006,
-0.026005622,
0.026895294,
-0.032576602,
0.0084823351,
0.0948101282,
-0.0192265622,
0.0936753899,
-0.028504869,
-0.0293368623,
-0.0257321894,
-0.034080144,
0.0459848382,
0.0203966349,
-0.0386045501,
0.0324766226,
-0.0930467546,
0.0098872008,
-0.035081327,
-0.0010543104,
0.009598176,
0.0708727762,
0.0189133156,
-0.0283944309,
0.004687102,
-0.037397854,
0.0012560657,
-0.0302197002,
-0.0098319193,
-0.0276903734,
0.02262545,
0.0100083146,
-0.0030909008,
-0.0045831371,
-0.0196972936,
-0.0282873381,
-0.0631323159,
0.0191653352,
-0.0141046764,
-0.0400842503,
-0.0386269838,
-0.0210115444,
-0.0092072142,
-0.0437654369,
0.0449241735,
-0.012752451,
-0.0087149162,
-0.0280461051,
0.0539633334,
-0.0213378295,
0.0291494839,
-0.0321390592,
0.0061464068,
-0.0261669513,
0.0062653986,
0.0518576428,
0.02991708,
-0.0586402901,
-0.0149370423,
0.017571291,
0.010008323,
-0.0255491119,
-0.0225749221,
0.0725635365,
-0.0155455237,
-0.0220019761,
0.002332794,
2.540443723e-34,
-0.0071109589,
-0.0520685576,
0.0307182707,
-0.0258056764,
0.0255141165,
0.0143207414,
0.0280538015,
0.0054180673,
0.0435635373,
-0.0202193968,
-0.0296212379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14391v2 | ÚFAL CorPipe at CRAC 2023: Larger Context Improves Multilingual Coreference Resolution | 2023-11-24T10:15:34 | 2023-12-08T02:13:25 | Milan Straka | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present CorPipe, the winning entry to the CRAC 2023 Shared Task on
Multilingual Coreference Resolution. Our system is an improved version of our
earlier multilingual coreference pipeline, and it surpasses other participants
by a large margin of 4.5 percent points. CorPipe first performs mention
detection, followed by coreference linking via an antecedent-maximization
approach on the retrieved spans. Both tasks are trained jointly on all
available corpora using a shared pretrained language model. Our main
improvements comprise inputs larger than 512 subwords and changing the mention
decoding to support ensembling. The source code is available at
https://github.com/ufal/crac2023-corpipe. | [
0.0100655435,
0.0174046233,
0.0368071757,
0.0485541299,
-0.0010838114,
0.0118193552,
-0.0245965421,
-0.0288126022,
0.0267080888,
-0.0056851646,
-0.0444914103,
0.008264184,
-0.0194999035,
-0.0044731498,
0.0311865062,
-0.0236141607,
0.0569092855,
-0.021587912,
0.0085085984,
-0.0101672746,
0.007336203,
0.0162285157,
-0.0063417959,
0.0094140228,
-0.0379145369,
-0.0175475385,
0.0183470398,
-0.0097169625,
0.051065553,
-0.0203559715,
0.0497811697,
0.0161677506,
-0.0075971899,
0.0181147307,
0.0000019614,
-0.0437016152,
-0.0328000709,
-0.0227986034,
-0.0067877984,
0.0034110884,
0.0196580812,
-0.0413964763,
0.0151282037,
-0.0005310527,
-0.0346229784,
0.0022414399,
0.0032846648,
0.0451436341,
0.0195921585,
0.0332502015,
-0.0260709208,
-0.0334513932,
0.0089765927,
-0.0517704152,
-0.1153600365,
-0.0912666619,
-0.0054745064,
-0.0193265714,
0.0120747602,
0.0133818593,
-0.0001179506,
0.0381622575,
0.0242137946,
0.0094342362,
0.0153595973,
0.0193870459,
-0.0661220774,
-0.0210642181,
0.0041695121,
0.1073416919,
0.0199523084,
0.036693681,
0.0052515445,
0.0177907757,
-0.0359421819,
-0.0793824121,
-0.0057838056,
-0.0065000979,
-0.0157992486,
0.0150994519,
-0.0026097908,
0.0150382565,
0.0046049892,
0.0404895134,
-0.0303311348,
0.0884874016,
0.0027309619,
-0.0069576725,
0.0759192556,
0.0230894536,
-0.0065135034,
-0.0241090395,
0.0869508088,
-0.006761895,
-0.0476580672,
0.0179726407,
-0.0259608403,
0.0161763374,
0.0141095193,
-0.0667990595,
-0.0174881779,
0.006808294,
-0.0523438118,
0.0528307892,
-0.0467267111,
0.031044526,
-0.0530506149,
0.0001811366,
-0.0322654769,
-0.0636550859,
0.0044531263,
0.055296015,
-0.0477840677,
0.0317716002,
-0.0831917003,
-0.0057690414,
-0.056873925,
-0.0274015218,
0.0065509635,
0.0245054904,
-0.0394054204,
-0.0056758029,
-0.0449302383,
-0.0112826433,
0.0137054995,
0.0854339972,
-0.0561678298,
-0.003143118,
-0.0619265363,
-0.0599645488,
-0.0398543105,
0.0034367305,
0.0001112331,
-0.0622217581,
0.0085830558,
0.0379400179,
-0.0162472259,
-0.0616458841,
0.0113676377,
-0.054116223,
-0.0383189879,
-0.0401981659,
-0.0277762655,
-0.068168737,
0.0490236133,
-0.0008576635,
0.0171123687,
-0.0803377628,
0.0100527992,
-0.0101573989,
-0.0472780019,
0.0566095151,
0.0052621607,
-0.0286040343,
0.0055685737,
-0.0025022314,
0.0642406046,
0.0839384347,
0.017402051,
0.0434926786,
0.0409188792,
0.048715394,
-0.0637796894,
0.0665097833,
0.0353444032,
0.006435087,
0.0569859706,
0.0078979405,
-0.0298698992,
0.009052787,
0.0725166351,
0.0324068889,
-0.0281831566,
-0.0233866628,
-0.0089603141,
0.0317612439,
-0.0495303757,
-0.0398315117,
-0.0093183238,
-0.0102927946,
-0.0012006077,
0.0200926606,
-0.0173695404,
0.02218052,
0.0215343554,
-0.027510561,
0.0835624114,
0.0358262062,
-0.0220273193,
-0.0081524309,
0.0111956522,
-0.0246512946,
-0.0365639031,
-0.0098261079,
0.0692030713,
0.0158948526,
-0.0520935431,
0.0379944332,
0.0377011485,
-0.0279578585,
0.0016633678,
0.0278823599,
-0.0265780054,
0.0099872965,
0.0188403856,
0.0203197431,
-0.0568104945,
-0.0096330885,
0.0604073107,
0.0545586683,
0.0056258542,
-0.034950126,
0.0795118809,
-0.0154071441,
-0.0171057582,
0.0099660074,
-0.0098871915,
0.0376798026,
0.0340424627,
-0.0032709509,
0.0192483049,
-0.000681312,
0.0144694364,
-0.0043483572,
-0.0254809242,
0.0160571821,
0.0025988014,
0.03021314,
0.0377075113,
0.0352893695,
-0.0097172102,
-0.0198734235,
0.0361093953,
-0.0480249934,
0.0155049255,
0.040474344,
-0.041791752,
-0.031770464,
0.0454745367,
-0.0727186576,
-0.0517519228,
0.0084953578,
-0.0289752521,
-0.0495765619,
0.0158901755,
0.0050583668,
0.0291200448,
-0.0015340798,
0.0095576728,
0.0217093751,
0.0337917879,
-0.013100245,
0.042346254,
-0.0058945687,
0.0042460286,
0.0454170331,
-0.0272966698,
0.0431008041,
-0.0286202878,
-0.0200646631,
0.0142942099,
-0.0223376006,
-0.0227171965,
0.05266314,
0.0243017823,
-0.053431429,
0.0163363107,
-0.0743398145,
0.0215732194,
-0.019963583,
0.0250136964,
0.0277838521,
0.0232416578,
-0.008645325,
-0.0528096557,
0.0353682451,
-0.0146372328,
0.0297067594,
0.0126294307,
0.0135747092,
0.0307555348,
0.0275006145,
-0.0720617995,
0.0028731099,
-0.0100782402,
0.0240528639,
0.004628371,
-0.0563558154,
-0.0039237896,
0.0129033746,
0.0060660359,
0.0177976433,
0.0012648064,
0.0040729525,
-0.0295117162,
0.0010639232,
0.0303635616,
0.0355540365,
-0.0367743112,
0.0248081423,
-0.0079514394,
-0.0444516242,
-0.064170137,
0.0424365774,
0.0222257338,
-0.040926408,
-0.0553170033,
0.008571649,
0.0433655009,
0.066124171,
-0.0236466378,
0.0033845857,
-0.0020727688,
-0.0119967703,
-0.0254970212,
-0.0292073283,
0.0139068607,
-0.0151362335,
-0.0163500831,
0.0527536087,
-0.0497427434,
-0.0049074991,
0.0368403308,
-0.0403472036,
-0.0238442514,
-0.0514262505,
0.0109783486,
-0.028706491,
0.0537715629,
0.0163266659,
0.0136752296,
0.0266723186,
-0.0566982366,
-0.0006115956,
0.0153914755,
-0.0040833936,
0.0140348561,
0.036061205,
-0.0367577858,
0.0255511869,
-0.020161476,
-0.0215663891,
-0.0318796635,
0.0141755594,
-0.0701045468,
-0.0089842966,
-0.0124531165,
0.0053168125,
-0.0013025207,
-0.0031854308,
0.0228663459,
0.024574196,
0.0006442973,
0.0098939342,
-0.0228839722,
0.0658783913,
0.0326269642,
-0.0038386246,
0.0106952358,
-0.0346255861,
-0.0073602661,
0.0672173649,
0.0366580151,
-0.0161747094,
0.0033935143,
-0.0137940757,
0.0509431437,
-0.048545491,
-0.0246100277,
-0.0424284823,
0.0650619268,
-0.006124354,
-0.047773581,
0.1166603938,
0.0392278433,
-0.0637395605,
-0.0193731375,
0.0211302489,
-0.0072859516,
0.0187379997,
-0.0088251671,
-0.040471442,
-0.0490375385,
-0.0173274465,
-0.0349710286,
0.0458679907,
-0.0406258665,
-0.0172548424,
-0.1066644564,
-0.0012904851,
-0.003232317,
-0.0583139211,
-0.0771375522,
-0.0274724308,
0.0276889633,
-0.0247385763,
0.0184327923,
0.0045972103,
-0.0048065628,
0.0138922688,
-0.0139537472,
0.0085664,
-0.0224563703,
0.033022061,
-0.0790239125,
0.0052007111,
0.0660746619,
0.0527897812,
0.0202701855,
0.0521399006,
0.0300770067,
-0.0583830066,
-0.045341827,
-0.0247084647,
0.0077200299,
-0.0219704434,
-0.0135417106,
0.009000279,
0.0329459012,
0.0078840144,
0.0108439075,
0.0345331803,
0.0216003247,
0.0499286354,
0.032181818,
0.0054282718,
0.0152658746,
-0.0030834852,
0.0354541019,
0.0136156855,
0.0122534744,
-0.0193300769,
-0.0057620178,
0.0171252042,
-0.0816175193,
-0.003173983,
-0.0005685514,
-0.0495827757,
0.0183911882,
-0.0602023713,
-0.080288209,
0.0542627685,
0.0026313728,
-0.0118084345,
-0.0228552688,
0.022917483,
0.0054237973,
-0.0483460203,
0.0232283659,
-0.0567556359,
0.0179256368,
-0.0599826239,
0.0241580512,
0.0555248782,
0.0465323813,
-0.0172602609,
0.1102595255,
-0.0689025521,
-0.0295703132,
-0.0276985634,
-0.001538315,
0.0115013346,
0.0660257563,
-0.0634575114,
-0.0370434411,
-0.0089281956,
-0.0061685052,
-0.0509907119,
0.0345576219,
0.0415598527,
0.0118715586,
-0.0158669092,
0.0584746599,
-0.0343176574,
0.0311216116,
-0.0099991197,
0.0576273389,
-0.0107551953,
-0.0598778464,
0.0015874818,
-0.00373836,
0.0283389296,
-0.0157425553,
0.0158513784,
-0.035047777,
0.0318695046,
0.0041387072,
-0.004525247,
-0.0120158531,
0.0250096917,
0.0007756625,
0.015729038,
0.0206910111,
0.0252091661,
-0.0208549779,
0.030505931,
0.0013312186,
-0.00201917,
0.0373541377,
-0.0083651822,
-0.0084065627,
-0.005093026,
0.0047152094,
0.0198305026,
0.0183951687,
0.046875637,
-0.0531325005,
0.0071468651,
-0.0061399397,
-0.0346615054,
0.0058866441,
-0.0068816403,
-0.0091551505,
0.0478264764,
-0.0399786942,
0.0011109071,
0.0816157162,
-0.0143705597,
0.1231077388,
-0.0100524258,
0.0003789394,
0.0011763159,
-0.0069231438,
-0.0451382995,
-0.0094119655,
-0.0028054258,
-0.0102417218,
0.0028938171,
0.0425022244,
0.0668844208,
-0.0007889845,
0.0119709289,
0.0563357323,
0.0030497795,
-0.0258253459,
-0.0577275157,
-0.0641632006,
0.0095606772,
-0.0070930072,
0.046716217,
-0.0213579219,
-0.0314929001,
0.0635289252,
-0.0057759932,
-0.0345834084,
0.040646363,
0.0257519409,
0.0408024862,
0.0174907222,
0.0077934861,
-0.0259882547,
-0.001228073,
0.016563518,
-0.0487217344,
-0.0234767403,
-6.239910458e-33,
-0.0733336285,
-0.0191792715,
-0.0201007575,
-0.0315645114,
-0.0153778279,
0.0246361438,
-0.0469843969,
-0.0078317197,
-0.0343468525,
0.0124275452,
-0.0002076853,
0.0003544662,
0.0238617864,
0.0432292521,
0.0118389837,
-0.0105511593,
0.0569737069,
0.0348643214,
-0.0189627819,
0.0217291322,
0.0232890509,
0.0447004139,
0.111159116,
-0.0435965881,
0.0340044349,
0.0142934714,
-0.0244103186,
0.0334886089,
0.0787890702,
0.0321071856,
-0.0184453148,
0.0214857105,
-0.000496301,
-0.0309360195,
-0.0092203477,
0.0020290997,
-0.1494872719,
-0.0132769337,
0.0346425883,
0.0346728675,
-0.0012366883,
-0.0291300993,
0.0190916397,
-0.0252257362,
0.0218446106,
0.0042557302,
0.0348835997,
-0.0124756359,
-0.0047565624,
-0.019713752,
-0.0740182474,
0.032844428,
-0.0109927263,
0.0144979572,
0.0336231925,
0.0709555298,
0.0004825039,
0.0288225655,
-0.041736342,
0.0387274586,
-0.0320192277,
0.0187534243,
0.0183645487,
-0.0199385677,
-0.0122792646,
0.0363262706,
-0.0100004487,
-0.0378935151,
-0.0034908154,
0.0040129577,
-0.0015342545,
-0.0018627364,
-0.0207925085,
0.1147968099,
-0.0081955902,
0.0143112838,
-0.0593800992,
0.0166772213,
0.0718749613,
0.038850572,
-0.0215175748,
-0.008896092,
-0.0148758451,
-0.018895261,
-0.0290349554,
-0.0262434315,
-0.0085181165,
-0.0529101826,
0.0109065454,
-0.0069007287,
-0.0186249595,
0.0569723137,
0.043121919,
-0.0302495211,
-0.0441803783,
0.0386685841,
0.0439104959,
0.0167003144,
0.0331471898,
0.0730096847,
-0.0443807282,
0.0003514014,
-0.0031759429,
-0.0043303999,
0.0171982422,
-0.0148359919,
0.0317676738,
-0.0367610417,
-0.0517798513,
0.0041595995,
-0.036645133,
0.0148385148,
-0.0631128624,
0.0226997323,
0.0179041214,
0.012442518,
-0.0116859283,
0.0621154979,
0.0437927172,
0.0154105006,
-0.0548395999,
-0.0306667946,
0.0317037366,
0.0417177007,
-0.0045981463,
-0.0058026062,
-0.0275403336,
0.0307059344,
-0.0051364219,
-0.0470725335,
-0.0133341365,
-0.0177722611,
2.64e-7,
0.0144620528,
0.0192605332,
0.040555425,
-0.0284423176,
-0.0078307558,
-0.0125918547,
-0.0136936503,
0.0620155111,
-0.0151240835,
-0.0127375768,
-0.0267071668,
0.0208461247,
0.0216922555,
0.0359217264,
-0.1003475487,
-0.0252272356,
-0.0311099272,
-0.0452081785,
-0.0499190055,
-0.0200118311,
-0.0039808988,
0.0809552372,
0.0150706852,
0.0058153779,
-0.041416008,
-0.0316320471,
0.0272546429,
-0.0089468556,
-0.0437501855,
0.0149736246,
-0.0638993829,
0.04304979,
-0.0291603021,
-0.0053470302,
0.0026886289,
0.030721195,
0.0386500917,
0.0593016446,
0.0311208609,
-0.0459139161,
-0.0058121742,
-0.0174506512,
0.0166543834,
0.0078873495,
0.0609619506,
-0.0407322645,
-0.0087813381,
-0.0449645594,
-0.0224550162,
0.0439703502,
0.0044489107,
0.006518329,
-0.0252757687,
0.0477274209,
0.0130692674,
-0.0022774236,
-0.0445684232,
-0.0854317918,
-0.0318669863,
0.0270241275,
0.0048355195,
-0.0111117465,
0.0242902301,
-0.0687204376,
-0.0121028591,
-0.0248315837,
0.0054072551,
2.077031708e-34,
0.0330861546,
0.00538897,
0.0051286574,
0.0417863242,
0.0089304438,
-0.0450498201,
-0.0657985136,
0.0014491661,
0.0057497043,
0.0113912988,
0.0218228269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14353v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14353v2 | Average Token Delay: A Duration-aware Latency Metric for Simultaneous Translation | 2023-11-24T08:53:52 | 2023-11-27T16:55:29 | Yasumasa Kano, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | Simultaneous translation is a task in which the translation begins before the
end of an input speech segment. Its evaluation should be conducted based on
latency in addition to quality, and for users, the smallest possible amount of
latency is preferable. Most existing metrics measure latency based on the start
timings of partial translations and ignore their duration. This means such
metrics do not penalize the latency caused by long translation output, which
delays the comprehension of users and subsequent translations. In this work, we
propose a novel latency evaluation metric for simultaneous translation called
\emph{Average Token Delay} (ATD) that focuses on the duration of partial
translations. We demonstrate its effectiveness through analyses simulating
user-side latency based on Ear-Voice Span (EVS). In our experiment, ATD had the
highest correlation with EVS among baseline latency metrics under most
conditions. | [
-0.0247037187,
-0.0157722849,
-0.009670889,
-0.0385538675,
-0.0509553179,
-0.029440172,
0.0459779724,
-0.0137815773,
-0.0800858811,
0.0355242193,
-0.028379906,
-0.0555328354,
0.076476641,
0.0079784906,
0.025840845,
-0.078112334,
0.0075781154,
-0.0249250326,
0.0305896141,
0.0182995722,
0.0088756224,
-0.0163714327,
-0.052398771,
0.0717022344,
-0.019186886,
0.0040503708,
0.0012743232,
0.0272115245,
0.0628493279,
-0.022963196,
-0.0293444768,
0.0062662945,
-0.0447910912,
0.0224494077,
0.0000017345,
-0.0287100039,
0.0138331186,
0.0421133898,
0.0011465001,
0.0188203603,
0.0389798693,
0.0308438186,
-0.0348180346,
0.0554191619,
-0.0139441313,
-0.0002276142,
0.0169352591,
-0.0180241596,
0.0056018122,
0.0064635645,
-0.0235196799,
0.0180869047,
-0.0324592441,
-0.0452358872,
0.0204429813,
-0.0701420903,
-0.0391235203,
-0.0214200821,
-0.0063236095,
-0.0105783809,
-0.0407635681,
0.0808747336,
0.0255470239,
-0.0047679488,
0.0162625797,
-0.0134497182,
-0.0627862662,
-0.0204407591,
-0.0658693612,
0.066775851,
-0.0113609442,
0.0160021316,
0.0117200268,
0.0121662403,
0.0064831763,
-0.0614704043,
-0.032558281,
-0.0191577375,
-0.0090620127,
-0.0576783493,
-0.0650185943,
0.0672686473,
0.0296538696,
-0.0580239408,
-0.0361837111,
0.0079501774,
0.0337248296,
-0.045534227,
-0.0249276012,
-0.0148200011,
-0.0129387509,
0.0003645531,
0.0739131719,
0.0055267494,
-0.0477148853,
-0.0071848775,
-0.030649351,
-0.0841879398,
0.0030095002,
-0.0185002498,
-0.0193905979,
0.0811045393,
-0.0568856262,
0.0119473003,
-0.0409647934,
0.0580483899,
0.0047866465,
-0.0252394658,
-0.0387298279,
-0.0020584029,
0.0108364634,
0.0156955142,
-0.0215029437,
-0.0526723787,
-0.0422871076,
-0.028827576,
-0.0335813016,
0.0047575906,
-0.030723514,
-0.0020204217,
0.0551649816,
-0.012545513,
-0.0154860737,
-0.0026884712,
0.0044149812,
0.0358379073,
-0.0328595117,
0.0216544699,
0.0035316977,
-0.0270800982,
-0.0020093394,
0.0197984725,
0.0079996064,
0.0102171656,
-0.0253422167,
0.0635391325,
-0.0080960561,
0.0217068791,
0.058013238,
-0.0054390067,
-0.0149053615,
-0.0004287623,
-0.0425080992,
-0.0375044048,
0.0510781072,
0.0071550449,
0.0010925723,
0.0298491605,
-0.0391183309,
-0.0123501904,
0.0620573536,
0.0400772803,
0.0000915695,
0.0596572123,
0.0399376191,
0.0384945795,
-0.0148859089,
0.0196818896,
0.0557933226,
-0.0226641782,
0.0550076179,
-0.0376238562,
-0.0532248132,
0.0625069737,
0.0329232998,
0.0199991111,
0.011526336,
-0.0242493898,
0.0230855998,
0.0517642237,
0.0066979039,
0.0332205631,
-0.0212110374,
0.0115890792,
0.0577173531,
0.0676364899,
0.023603525,
-0.0335092396,
0.0680372417,
0.0097573632,
-0.0334365964,
-0.0007973895,
-0.0182209369,
0.0207736138,
0.0415696502,
0.0137677491,
0.109584257,
0.0523240007,
0.0022516923,
-0.0006547811,
0.0038421871,
-0.0280982554,
-0.0113535551,
-0.0091285212,
-0.0024549223,
-0.0049474118,
-0.0287744049,
0.059830483,
-0.0534972548,
-0.0695441514,
0.0206663553,
-0.0078542279,
-0.0853018314,
0.0584090427,
-0.0027670455,
0.010382344,
0.0131309815,
-0.0050347033,
0.0145191913,
0.0226911101,
0.0402886234,
0.017445622,
0.038331259,
-0.0214376319,
-0.0223014336,
0.0761188641,
0.0011869214,
0.0187911075,
-0.0144524686,
0.0725940987,
0.0460786223,
-0.0568012819,
0.0108619314,
0.000463494,
-0.0119498977,
0.0607816316,
0.0105092861,
0.0422038548,
0.019900132,
0.0230299868,
-0.0221910626,
0.0085368752,
-0.0047139977,
-0.0189186279,
0.0191784985,
0.0768732131,
-0.0535114519,
0.0184988528,
0.0298326481,
-0.0468525812,
0.0288796574,
0.0201537516,
0.0207985751,
-0.0618878715,
0.0179858357,
-0.0029047891,
0.0220069755,
0.0306765847,
0.065909259,
-0.0050168987,
-0.0036447893,
0.013626799,
-0.0401918367,
-0.0062392484,
0.0643895715,
-0.0099448683,
0.0241046716,
0.0329795852,
-0.0497027375,
-0.0080859764,
0.0479858704,
-0.0320202745,
-0.0039466163,
0.0176154748,
-0.0095148617,
-0.0397587568,
-0.0498677939,
-0.0943852216,
0.0077799209,
-0.0177830588,
0.0221953467,
0.0195425954,
0.0230023433,
0.0037392848,
-0.0221705325,
-0.0402865894,
-0.0160632599,
0.0047943299,
-0.0354112051,
-0.0710364804,
0.0086237406,
-0.0606384128,
-0.0086830379,
0.0259533003,
0.0288350992,
0.0009935129,
-0.0021176292,
-0.0201427508,
-0.0405075438,
-0.0548284762,
-0.003230545,
-0.0056462563,
0.0261050388,
-0.0500530414,
0.0156445913,
0.0417713225,
0.0641464815,
0.0136496592,
0.0314763077,
-0.0220807418,
0.0140240071,
-0.0379906334,
-0.0085802851,
0.0072560878,
0.0069831954,
0.0418570898,
-0.0216800719,
-0.0256766491,
0.000945094,
0.0203648116,
0.0198580343,
-0.0097684236,
-0.0829695314,
-0.0278723855,
-0.0494224168,
-0.0475385301,
-0.0059488826,
-0.0206349883,
-0.0314057879,
0.0407928899,
-0.0309188962,
-0.0552157052,
-0.0002021139,
-0.0724399313,
-0.0221009143,
-0.016387241,
-0.0126576601,
-0.0101971831,
0.0173754729,
-0.0295127332,
-0.0050712368,
-0.077454932,
-0.0533247329,
-0.0147502236,
0.0722229704,
-0.0014408056,
-0.0694304109,
0.0075976383,
-0.0139184045,
-0.0398552679,
-0.0052978252,
-0.0043326896,
0.0157321543,
0.0326650515,
-0.0048020463,
-0.0011614931,
0.0630880073,
-0.0724387467,
-0.0266057458,
0.0070588323,
-0.0025055946,
0.07329458,
-0.0270704459,
0.0072262078,
0.0107090864,
-0.0314552002,
-0.017755812,
0.0305772983,
-0.000848112,
-0.027683733,
0.0385028794,
0.0101054562,
0.0804983154,
-0.0118793761,
-0.0329647399,
-0.0211431421,
0.026205115,
0.0151321543,
-0.0672944412,
0.0570624061,
0.0536347218,
-0.0148582039,
0.0297294986,
0.0905734226,
-0.0087617431,
-0.0412970521,
0.0094945915,
-0.0317947119,
0.0312300362,
0.0124383904,
-0.0137920994,
-0.0489060432,
-0.0079000881,
0.0379167944,
0.0552775078,
0.0263645891,
0.026509285,
-0.0129528157,
-0.0268419739,
-0.0087760519,
0.0190508701,
-0.0991236791,
-0.0123978844,
-0.0025009243,
-0.0288802199,
0.0226821266,
0.0441350825,
-0.0033262693,
0.0101067899,
-0.003378398,
0.0134948604,
-0.035260547,
-0.0161777828,
0.0323239528,
-0.0077562002,
0.0900635123,
0.0419625305,
0.0196699705,
0.0254041795,
-0.056688197,
0.0121126911,
-0.0147533817,
-0.0184054784,
0.0111572854,
0.0085700396,
0.0202181898,
-0.0299813189,
0.0079278722,
0.0028946537,
0.0057412586,
0.0428247713,
0.0220121648,
-0.0058841449,
0.0087407231,
0.0442671329,
0.0127968006,
0.0345052779,
0.0351585336,
0.0340694003,
0.0281499662,
-0.0629945248,
-0.0123058716,
0.0209561307,
0.0113632418,
-0.1041822359,
-0.023579115,
-0.000143119,
0.0036512939,
-0.0695666745,
-0.0521789379,
0.0095004616,
-0.0264660213,
0.0648979321,
0.0412687957,
0.045500651,
-0.0415680818,
0.0387083329,
-0.0146362772,
-0.0107629076,
0.0437156372,
0.0715605691,
-0.1028293669,
0.0223696809,
-0.0341715626,
-0.0231086481,
-0.0283090118,
0.0562427677,
-0.07155893,
-0.0546423942,
0.0366765894,
0.0011380257,
0.0206107832,
0.0137298135,
-0.0256791543,
-0.0400212705,
0.0086750956,
-0.0329938382,
-0.056763716,
0.0281432103,
0.0282718446,
0.002273937,
-0.0135063538,
0.0211967118,
-0.0453865938,
-0.0078076813,
-0.0622401237,
0.0321412608,
0.0328112468,
-0.0521198027,
-0.0354153216,
0.0422311984,
0.0593134165,
-0.0110104391,
0.0178978238,
0.0138886543,
0.0451003388,
-0.0226416308,
0.0439436771,
-0.0223204773,
-0.0222931392,
0.0003323395,
-0.0065483809,
0.0394751914,
0.0190431736,
-0.0061133467,
-0.0597719923,
0.0377599485,
0.0144759202,
-0.0402232446,
-0.0074665924,
0.0038572997,
0.0270575322,
0.0172047839,
-0.0270309709,
0.0227591004,
-0.0046648155,
-0.0386511274,
-0.007381828,
0.0195166934,
0.0427752323,
0.0440245494,
0.0386424586,
-0.0208931305,
0.013935891,
0.0406133235,
0.0000989126,
0.0184448902,
0.012976015,
0.1102911308,
0.0262003243,
0.0421773605,
-0.0332757942,
0.0597142689,
-0.0308005698,
-0.003885139,
-0.0403349996,
-0.0102152294,
0.0164550301,
0.006313405,
0.0357343107,
-0.0407213457,
-0.0192811619,
-0.0528518669,
0.0043583428,
0.0001261207,
-0.0070058061,
-0.0461167619,
-0.0234356392,
-0.0257187467,
-0.0322164297,
-0.016189171,
-0.0482604615,
-0.0074569574,
0.0315464549,
0.0305180885,
0.0088874772,
0.0230931677,
0.075497739,
-0.0519293845,
-0.0103205582,
-0.0005276247,
-0.0831404105,
0.0175989158,
-0.0070132911,
0.0147250192,
-5.447531757e-33,
-0.0162267275,
-0.0585774779,
0.0197219774,
-0.0244213175,
-0.0766478777,
0.031533543,
-0.0209803544,
0.0231096949,
0.0212938637,
-0.0172130838,
0.0232435614,
0.0191612076,
0.0302976966,
-0.0231398623,
-0.0306786615,
0.0470733717,
0.0690324083,
-0.0091578057,
-0.0307466257,
0.0034390541,
0.0512213334,
-0.0087796012,
-0.0219409764,
-0.0232892055,
0.0257797278,
0.0439178944,
0.0034699326,
-0.0186903961,
0.0223174077,
0.0162559133,
0.0475183092,
0.0404705815,
-0.0170520283,
-0.0246068928,
-0.0198299568,
0.0134975668,
-0.0530861989,
-0.006525096,
0.0273737293,
0.0728152245,
0.0015495562,
-0.008231394,
-0.0002224392,
0.0028470918,
-0.0392803326,
-0.0278038234,
0.0034875586,
-0.0342772193,
-0.0481068529,
-0.0451267771,
-0.0162169915,
0.0131740803,
-0.0494029187,
-0.023604935,
0.0623686463,
0.0669862926,
-0.0387425423,
-0.0405768342,
-0.0561488196,
0.044932045,
-0.0271889344,
0.0435292684,
0.0429623201,
0.0271333065,
0.0254278556,
0.0206944235,
0.0489719808,
-0.0206873529,
0.017287109,
-0.0056546377,
0.0624011494,
-0.0433156006,
0.0413898937,
-0.0612578019,
0.0206245854,
-0.0443372726,
-0.015971655,
0.0334097706,
-0.0045347712,
0.0022348866,
-0.0038687696,
0.0255305003,
-0.0459967218,
0.0377539471,
-0.0783340409,
0.0076627661,
-0.0089044506,
-0.0422800183,
0.0396904834,
0.0144714285,
0.0073926081,
-0.0552632958,
0.0804108381,
0.0270191189,
0.0488533489,
-0.0300139207,
-0.0127835833,
0.0336881317,
-0.0377683081,
0.0116769299,
0.0084159598,
-0.0093371216,
0.0674478486,
0.0544627942,
0.0482026376,
-0.0924474448,
-0.0103878696,
0.0370223001,
-0.0542373843,
0.0140839582,
0.0193775911,
0.0251106359,
0.0303058196,
-0.0230903327,
0.0633261129,
-0.028670162,
-0.0210983604,
0.029450519,
-0.0412827581,
-0.0202347226,
-0.0093599111,
-0.0232856777,
-0.0008425674,
0.0393077806,
-0.0909734517,
0.0315851979,
-0.0364412218,
0.0101570273,
0.0259514488,
-0.0452077016,
-0.0615977645,
-0.0214312058,
2.509e-7,
-0.00304747,
0.0220890567,
0.0324748866,
0.0254096817,
0.0375038609,
-0.0332501419,
-0.0255367905,
0.0215177294,
-0.0160608348,
0.026957605,
-0.0064922883,
-0.0153785227,
0.0862672478,
0.0022992603,
-0.0620987378,
-0.0154134622,
-0.0793674067,
0.052369751,
0.0033058478,
0.0459171794,
0.0324319638,
-0.0067406767,
-0.0496365875,
0.0102596711,
0.0264038872,
-0.0049034953,
0.0284955911,
-0.0156583302,
0.0220970269,
-0.0143175842,
0.0537747853,
-0.0000465552,
-0.0485470779,
0.0162196979,
-0.0462291688,
-0.0094506452,
0.0767990276,
0.0229448061,
0.0111161331,
-0.0378403328,
0.006406622,
0.0201722626,
-0.0226253495,
-0.0014204615,
0.0472688489,
-0.0006222658,
-0.0258267373,
0.0099292677,
-0.0312409662,
0.0069192541,
0.0016688379,
-0.0071988651,
-0.0083806133,
0.0019435815,
0.0089816405,
0.0107873753,
0.032195162,
-0.0203907453,
-0.0134091591,
0.0340543613,
-0.0186221525,
-0.0558911674,
-0.0521968529,
0.0203832388,
-0.0139777595,
0.0075525218,
-0.0123983091,
1.713161219e-34,
0.0294343475,
-0.0570638031,
0.0507807769,
-0.0014911504,
0.0019395746,
-0.068618305,
0.0374399349,
0.0121853817,
-0.0120170685,
-0.0178448819,
-0.0530762114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14324v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14324v1 | Large Language Models as Topological Structure Enhancers for Text-Attributed Graphs | 2023-11-24T07:53:48 | 2023-11-24T07:53:48 | Shengyin Sun, Yuxiang Ren, Chen Ma, Xuecang Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The latest advancements in large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized
the field of natural language processing (NLP). Inspired by the success of LLMs
in NLP tasks, some recent work has begun investigating the potential of
applying LLMs in graph learning tasks. However, most of the existing work
focuses on utilizing LLMs as powerful node feature augmenters, leaving
employing LLMs to enhance graph topological structures an understudied problem.
In this work, we explore how to leverage the information retrieval and text
generation capabilities of LLMs to refine/enhance the topological structure of
text-attributed graphs (TAGs) under the node classification setting. First, we
propose using LLMs to help remove unreliable edges and add reliable ones in the
TAG. Specifically, we first let the LLM output the semantic similarity between
node attributes through delicate prompt designs, and then perform edge deletion
and edge addition based on the similarity. Second, we propose using
pseudo-labels generated by the LLM to improve graph topology, that is, we
introduce the pseudo-label propagation as a regularization to guide the graph
neural network (GNN) in learning proper edge weights. Finally, we incorporate
the two aforementioned LLM-based methods for graph topological refinement into
the process of GNN training, and perform extensive experiments on four
real-world datasets. The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of
LLM-based graph topology refinement (achieving a 0.15%--2.47% performance gain
on public benchmarks). | [
0.0455016978,
0.0311653558,
-0.0062868828,
0.0395263769,
-0.0425410978,
-0.0251654908,
0.0084320884,
0.0108040133,
0.0939351693,
-0.0175689179,
-0.0286124386,
-0.0176390316,
-0.016625762,
0.0556473397,
0.0304780453,
0.0057072546,
0.014465224,
0.0065119639,
0.0236776862,
-0.0187701322,
0.001624465,
0.0320395604,
0.0608512014,
0.0213540103,
-0.0280235056,
0.003388318,
-0.0002298437,
0.0516822711,
-0.0138967801,
-0.0533753224,
-0.0056885732,
0.0002902808,
-0.0038443014,
0.0345103852,
0.0000019388,
-0.0069021299,
-0.0345894583,
0.0126302652,
-0.0014801825,
0.0011009229,
0.0541533418,
-0.0184778459,
0.0212418064,
0.0027806424,
-0.0301612653,
-0.050052695,
0.0548828356,
0.0470987335,
0.0377314389,
0.0761082023,
-0.0347162522,
-0.0361744724,
0.0244840868,
-0.0316041671,
-0.0041604857,
-0.0277193338,
0.0460913517,
0.0166375022,
-0.0000985102,
0.0349000283,
-0.0257284194,
0.0089920303,
-0.0001897086,
-0.0108886743,
0.0911310092,
0.0415415503,
0.0034556424,
0.0292954855,
0.0086449701,
0.1221567988,
-0.0260365997,
-0.0399921313,
0.0467471443,
-0.0138316536,
-0.0058075651,
0.026464846,
-0.0434474871,
-0.0208655149,
0.0169932749,
0.0243133642,
0.0053378819,
-0.0367806405,
0.0791025013,
0.0236885324,
-0.0132655948,
0.0981083438,
-0.0084827533,
-0.0130682914,
0.0061662234,
0.0041455901,
-0.0690489337,
-0.0340484865,
0.0286399499,
0.0267079808,
0.0031367708,
0.0131313736,
-0.0251192432,
-0.0030290247,
-0.0133754723,
-0.0022717437,
0.0497131944,
-0.0288607907,
-0.0174830277,
0.0318373181,
-0.056124609,
0.0189904235,
-0.0152090071,
0.0804703608,
-0.0755072758,
-0.0072842934,
-0.0549802221,
-0.015361093,
-0.0573068894,
0.0339815728,
0.0075666392,
-0.0359161831,
-0.0192914382,
0.0255865008,
-0.0268218908,
0.0170386583,
0.0279969089,
0.0367873348,
0.0142112561,
-0.0406917557,
0.0173895862,
0.0055441642,
0.0215624906,
0.0139055336,
-0.0203429554,
0.0076278085,
0.0173728392,
0.0333447978,
0.0708136633,
-0.0257446133,
0.0182096567,
0.0245596617,
0.0348795876,
-0.0181989465,
-0.0175634399,
-0.0384168029,
-0.0162077192,
-0.0588297658,
0.0223323405,
-0.0654934943,
0.0212339051,
0.0082962783,
-0.0224320032,
-0.0842471942,
0.0313134752,
0.0056791366,
-0.0699374303,
0.0308699459,
-0.0740188435,
0.0342121944,
0.0319413953,
-0.0395819694,
0.0109135387,
-0.0306191109,
0.0356590822,
0.0388915725,
0.0420196131,
0.021835437,
-0.040834073,
0.0299894623,
0.0436355844,
0.0235220883,
0.0014411084,
-0.0217549819,
0.0057960674,
0.0146596087,
0.002444593,
0.0999594107,
-0.0309993643,
-0.0362568498,
0.0712938085,
0.0178821497,
-0.0070988312,
0.0109522929,
0.0288540274,
0.0393623635,
-0.0206643119,
0.0119143007,
-0.0283336286,
-0.0192347057,
-0.0175132155,
0.0229415968,
0.0012402667,
-0.0287490766,
-0.0157266371,
-0.0226446819,
-0.0138309849,
-0.0189614799,
0.1004416719,
0.0041977749,
0.0685328469,
0.0069033811,
-0.0414269008,
0.0093076415,
0.0408634208,
-0.0034093352,
0.0110460585,
-0.0199343953,
-0.0158763677,
0.0621733554,
0.0343656875,
-0.0087175332,
-0.0230661705,
0.0166564677,
0.0116751082,
-0.0254098643,
0.0279917605,
-0.0321058556,
-0.0438295975,
-0.0457522273,
-0.0259643123,
-0.0126635097,
0.0018598972,
0.0157709233,
0.004056999,
-0.0130761545,
0.0261421986,
-0.0851522684,
-0.1004650965,
0.036933288,
0.0255390685,
0.0164032634,
0.0395137332,
-0.0071202517,
-0.0307981241,
0.0422382578,
-0.0131169576,
0.0039537009,
0.0270184986,
-0.0076551847,
-0.0261886567,
-0.0211007502,
-0.0489959083,
-0.035046231,
0.0642387792,
0.0015079603,
-0.0078214761,
0.0273329969,
-0.0419726968,
-0.0442686528,
0.0101933675,
-0.0900407508,
0.0073081991,
-0.0200423393,
0.0015619099,
-0.0048011029,
-0.0112339491,
-0.0441263095,
0.0472414754,
0.027186146,
0.0320636742,
-0.0070686182,
0.0387662649,
-0.0069956565,
-0.0331453085,
-0.0156732704,
0.003755701,
0.0145711061,
0.0000732695,
0.0387239046,
-0.0049301777,
-0.0103689665,
-0.0013545797,
-0.0922872275,
-0.0099067232,
-0.0079469476,
0.0119188437,
0.0017708199,
0.0044871559,
0.0309550036,
-0.0120230736,
-0.0623849109,
0.0005922078,
0.0283857826,
0.0017116087,
0.0244979616,
-0.0068700183,
-0.0389173925,
-0.00169341,
-0.0557259433,
-0.0185862333,
0.0992167369,
0.0218313299,
-0.0465396307,
-0.0260391682,
0.0164114237,
-0.0367462039,
0.0141742798,
0.0107440408,
0.0210132301,
-0.0492171645,
0.0030393153,
0.0280771274,
0.0261907242,
-0.0115670459,
0.0008253388,
0.0395527445,
0.0299912747,
-0.0287027117,
-0.0286245272,
-0.0614302941,
0.0190951228,
-0.0001554363,
-0.0318745933,
-0.0179910567,
0.015775254,
0.0042814943,
-0.0379130207,
-0.017711062,
-0.002491425,
-0.0250264555,
0.0225887876,
-0.0112403315,
-0.0385437235,
0.0302413236,
0.0029573422,
-0.0558655784,
-0.0336105414,
0.0687225685,
-0.0194171444,
0.0120724058,
0.0217203088,
-0.0570815355,
-0.0595918931,
0.0703520626,
0.062894024,
0.0440960042,
0.0432348177,
-0.0099638682,
-0.036280252,
0.0139984936,
0.025290871,
-0.0326890796,
0.0037387179,
0.0006218486,
0.0478963554,
0.0199540835,
-0.0215855464,
0.0018721484,
-0.0052678231,
-0.0077823168,
0.0375188254,
-0.0116191041,
-0.0069345296,
0.0315288715,
0.0046953303,
-0.0260903873,
0.0336609446,
-0.0252302773,
0.0317466632,
-0.0227501411,
0.0881632194,
0.0443350524,
-0.0444639362,
-0.0204448812,
-0.0156400818,
-0.0279543903,
0.0380894393,
0.0006954453,
0.0015886409,
-0.0289963037,
0.0041460874,
0.0095576271,
-0.0135707213,
-0.0277141016,
-0.021996025,
0.0412560925,
-0.0477334224,
-0.0107752383,
0.0579574481,
0.0475659296,
-0.0309194531,
0.0032122021,
0.022973571,
0.0345693044,
0.0116653871,
0.0075485399,
-0.0649031848,
-0.0014687709,
-0.0116886543,
0.0109016458,
-0.0051319725,
-0.0408928655,
0.018893078,
-0.1164792776,
0.0179527067,
0.0253465995,
-0.019658193,
-0.0423240177,
-0.0618354343,
-0.018417513,
-0.0038502682,
-0.0055723446,
-0.0173195321,
0.0241047386,
-0.0090457974,
0.0216766726,
-0.0283704866,
-0.0267360862,
0.0108479913,
-0.034057159,
0.0333738923,
-0.0061457832,
0.0410946831,
0.0039284164,
-0.0151064713,
0.0640803874,
0.0282546021,
-0.003377571,
-0.0137006575,
0.0479396246,
0.0168804657,
-0.0068630474,
-0.0236054976,
0.0179146118,
-0.0124623645,
-0.009609093,
-0.0525835231,
0.0894193128,
0.0053926622,
-0.0197335929,
0.015587884,
-0.0365019999,
-0.0012984276,
0.0141253192,
0.0096199801,
-0.0119727906,
-0.0533995926,
-0.0348966308,
0.0315927826,
-0.0536317378,
-0.0651929602,
0.0434272587,
-0.0391873419,
-0.0172235519,
-0.0649662614,
-0.0235192273,
0.0087131876,
-0.0117429318,
0.0038962911,
-0.0029922982,
0.0462313592,
-0.0649093986,
-0.0976826698,
0.0076005957,
-0.0556889698,
0.0356254466,
0.032071922,
-0.0088939797,
0.071871832,
-0.0261366889,
-0.0153995864,
0.033870995,
-0.052108001,
-0.0944952741,
-0.0334569886,
-0.0048089023,
0.0024958416,
0.0644523576,
-0.0262844283,
-0.062936455,
0.0235641692,
0.0375787094,
-0.0314311385,
-0.0046571917,
-0.0039545107,
-0.0167307444,
-0.0278478917,
0.0229986571,
-0.0542036332,
0.0290719215,
0.0505347215,
0.0337265804,
-0.0429619849,
-0.0563372076,
0.0179765727,
0.0856225193,
0.0252186302,
0.0242787451,
0.045719061,
-0.0752703696,
-0.0133456755,
-0.0113412971,
-0.0337573588,
-0.0144901266,
0.0035817488,
0.030809734,
0.0071813576,
-0.007941871,
-0.0526729487,
0.027610926,
0.0674797669,
-0.0465674251,
-0.0275888368,
-0.0514302887,
-0.0110140098,
0.0256319232,
0.0124758631,
-0.0282096267,
0.0172017142,
0.0136933988,
0.0010506528,
-0.0266254414,
-0.0384196602,
0.0400983393,
-0.033560738,
-0.0454494804,
0.0045412029,
-0.0451931097,
0.0206589643,
-0.0685512945,
0.024026243,
0.067237556,
0.0318273269,
0.0282438975,
-0.0102410354,
-0.0324022584,
-0.0468759723,
0.0387589782,
0.0205717068,
-0.0814987421,
0.0200025085,
0.0139392354,
-0.013001876,
0.0387670994,
0.0451300517,
0.1047755703,
0.0279934816,
0.0127291754,
-0.061349351,
-0.0225214772,
-0.0068645575,
-0.0297211558,
0.0366893895,
-0.0139482934,
0.0148155605,
-0.0290183164,
-0.0922948867,
0.0647788197,
-0.0140139135,
0.0364933349,
-0.0082700998,
0.0231416468,
0.0096043777,
0.0116959652,
-0.0036497924,
-0.0508973673,
-0.0019062321,
0.0239022095,
-0.0117946528,
-0.0132778194,
-6.115107855e-33,
0.0145254591,
-0.094628945,
-0.0009418129,
0.012923209,
-0.0759505406,
0.0090882163,
-0.0533651933,
-0.0064294916,
-0.0082461052,
0.0361943766,
-0.0089079691,
0.0079454016,
0.0016935917,
0.050949771,
-0.0415206514,
-0.0151424007,
0.0294982977,
0.0056072092,
0.0349194482,
0.0559089705,
0.007538775,
0.0257468708,
0.0360346474,
-0.1071155071,
0.0131643713,
-0.0351737365,
0.0222361106,
0.0072108153,
0.0502896011,
0.0207078923,
-0.0131914057,
0.0702832192,
0.0312695801,
-0.0178922974,
0.026228372,
-0.0210851543,
-0.0654810891,
-0.0003458927,
-0.020916095,
-0.0036215961,
-0.0223061014,
-0.0505773909,
0.0628662407,
0.0105954204,
0.0026429214,
-0.0157380253,
0.0670321807,
-0.0106647164,
-0.0664959624,
-0.0284699854,
-0.0168828573,
0.0625957847,
0.0005060916,
0.0254606977,
0.0108343316,
-0.0034304266,
0.0105665568,
0.0075590303,
-0.0677758679,
0.0304409657,
-0.0447335243,
0.0035539414,
-0.0051130145,
0.0257298592,
0.0106384382,
0.0199527163,
0.0146617694,
0.0412068181,
-0.0387998521,
0.0449532755,
0.0252401643,
0.0674456134,
0.0383019969,
0.0024524124,
-0.0309157874,
-0.0325417519,
-0.0893491805,
-0.0081364969,
-0.0162616204,
-0.0217749085,
0.0150750587,
0.0406777263,
-0.0094253076,
-0.0440711491,
-0.0266676396,
-0.0464964807,
-0.0480150022,
-0.0169790555,
-0.0140261259,
0.0068392525,
-0.0479604267,
0.0763083994,
-0.0166609641,
-0.072684586,
-0.0286589824,
0.0377324894,
-0.0205889437,
0.067417644,
-0.0313699618,
0.0200799294,
-0.0423680171,
-0.0599191822,
-0.0056534661,
0.0107754087,
0.0042954138,
0.0055388007,
0.0555515811,
0.0107571306,
-0.0340422057,
0.0056529306,
-0.019146204,
-0.0265336819,
-0.0337483026,
-0.0207519438,
0.0375413038,
0.0407260507,
-0.0020016911,
0.0800219178,
0.0643583313,
0.0493887402,
-0.0099610258,
-0.0082458621,
0.0038488712,
0.0301477537,
-0.0161993969,
-0.000225641,
-0.0035672272,
0.0202634111,
0.0216607023,
-0.0382926986,
-0.0276315622,
-0.0196812004,
2.751e-7,
0.0268912092,
0.0468810126,
0.0522050932,
0.0364088491,
-0.0164814051,
0.0205502994,
0.0110465987,
0.0200225674,
0.0009660987,
-0.0348660946,
0.0469982736,
0.0499223098,
-0.0041085905,
0.0082109869,
-0.0690136254,
0.0569789521,
-0.0822822973,
-0.0212417133,
-0.0327340961,
0.0267403424,
0.0406614542,
0.0499209352,
0.0261576455,
-0.0161777847,
-0.0274658184,
-0.0464893468,
0.0520846471,
0.0022524951,
-0.0242573656,
0.0360721052,
0.0289083291,
-0.0047699939,
-0.0371358655,
0.0138327517,
-0.0024513302,
0.0242680442,
0.0555786416,
0.0323251523,
-0.0261055194,
0.0289974473,
0.0064091417,
-0.0245213211,
0.012090601,
-0.0358791202,
0.0714818984,
-0.0453333519,
-0.0271785203,
-0.0071888221,
-0.025789855,
-0.0115736052,
0.0008451646,
-0.0257925596,
-0.0157904942,
0.0520641282,
0.0253423825,
-0.0193839557,
0.0090215709,
-0.07189852,
-0.0214496888,
0.0362201184,
-0.0164428409,
-0.02974049,
-0.004333999,
0.0689022169,
0.0282533634,
-0.0514415801,
0.0291158594,
2.723007409e-34,
0.029358549,
-0.0026035109,
-0.0285681188,
0.0076737073,
0.0225698929,
-0.030426776,
-0.0126149636,
0.0283424724,
-0.000876738,
-0.1032085493,
-0.0044922014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14212v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14212v3 | Annotation Sensitivity: Training Data Collection Methods Affect Model Performance | 2023-11-23T21:54:22 | 2024-01-22T15:05:30 | Christoph Kern, Stephanie Eckman, Jacob Beck, Rob Chew, Bolei Ma, Frauke Kreuter | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME | When training data are collected from human annotators, the design of the
annotation instrument, the instructions given to annotators, the
characteristics of the annotators, and their interactions can impact training
data. This study demonstrates that design choices made when creating an
annotation instrument also impact the models trained on the resulting
annotations. We introduce the term annotation sensitivity to refer to the
impact of annotation data collection methods on the annotations themselves and
on downstream model performance and predictions. We collect annotations of hate
speech and offensive language in five experimental conditions of an annotation
instrument, randomly assigning annotators to conditions. We then fine-tune BERT
models on each of the five resulting datasets and evaluate model performance on
a holdout portion of each condition. We find considerable differences between
the conditions for 1) the share of hate speech/offensive language annotations,
2) model performance, 3) model predictions, and 4) model learning curves. Our
results emphasize the crucial role played by the annotation instrument which
has received little attention in the machine learning literature. We call for
additional research into how and why the instrument impacts the annotations to
inform the development of best practices in instrument design. | [
0.0643786192,
0.0359945446,
-0.0352654792,
0.0090291221,
0.0165427048,
0.0519765392,
0.0600831099,
0.0221131034,
-0.0036422424,
-0.0968989208,
-0.0088916533,
0.0403217934,
-0.0378750376,
-0.0418543294,
0.0055653378,
-0.0687881783,
0.0284897126,
0.0275646932,
0.0602999218,
-0.008883981,
0.0289704576,
0.0056893416,
0.0012629415,
0.0666229799,
-0.1080070138,
0.0070052156,
0.0291103721,
0.0197281819,
0.0141685177,
-0.0189878885,
0.0297573023,
0.0777604878,
0.0079885963,
0.0609262399,
0.0000016268,
-0.0592941344,
0.009941672,
0.0317237452,
-0.0185805149,
-0.0072736563,
0.0311527476,
-0.0165431257,
0.0031633065,
0.0468473807,
-0.0319012478,
0.0306666307,
0.0812189728,
0.0489319116,
0.0476976037,
0.0343100168,
-0.0146827549,
0.0074254116,
0.0037216842,
0.0104858512,
-0.0018891689,
0.0335947536,
0.022623403,
0.0083414493,
-0.0450252853,
0.0001097947,
-0.0099185761,
0.0204473808,
0.0261556916,
0.0299993157,
0.0379570462,
-0.006990965,
-0.0837454274,
-0.0331766903,
-0.0093034692,
0.0314651951,
0.0138025759,
0.0117046926,
-0.0183908455,
-0.0170498379,
0.0149108889,
0.01119815,
-0.0288214907,
-0.0083424626,
-0.0059492295,
0.0063013625,
-0.0065045315,
-0.0227408726,
0.0146944579,
0.0331900157,
0.0439150557,
0.0244160313,
-0.0125504145,
-0.042408023,
0.0071456875,
0.0148220351,
-0.0286417119,
-0.0488754325,
0.0009433939,
-0.0059501845,
0.0027491448,
0.0079513295,
-0.0492968149,
-0.0489189252,
0.0457458757,
-0.092472747,
0.0548059009,
0.0271872003,
-0.0571080595,
-0.0085354755,
-0.0077323075,
0.0209962595,
-0.0009130303,
0.058222089,
0.0058274237,
0.0070903101,
-0.0288796965,
-0.0032601464,
-0.0205982942,
0.0109144021,
0.0080526695,
0.0252004098,
-0.0591606721,
-0.0126329856,
-0.0375634134,
-0.0097634271,
-0.0341552272,
-0.0104506081,
-0.0284356922,
0.0431773476,
-0.0076112091,
-0.0188192036,
-0.06218208,
0.0409642681,
-0.0081297504,
-0.0534460582,
0.0153324809,
0.0263298713,
-0.0194189753,
-0.0290056877,
0.0279483274,
0.0496765934,
0.046379298,
-0.0255531687,
-0.0402207933,
-0.0207425356,
-0.0233421568,
-0.0394698791,
0.0249286629,
-0.0304323696,
0.0039909319,
0.0189654045,
-0.02203013,
-0.0378113352,
0.0101592867,
-0.0052146874,
-0.0413217358,
0.0737201571,
-0.0114606004,
-0.0383208841,
0.046276994,
0.0010047575,
-0.0466904826,
0.0747299343,
0.054782901,
0.0007806779,
0.0358082727,
-0.0346086733,
-0.0126203969,
0.0550739244,
0.03701628,
0.0074553112,
-0.0469554402,
0.0067833266,
-0.0485006608,
0.0034196067,
0.0244991407,
0.0483368598,
-0.013581533,
-0.0279116128,
0.0425470658,
0.0792262033,
-0.0236483607,
0.0347530842,
0.0093459636,
0.0135511756,
0.0041992408,
0.0068205553,
-0.0547672547,
-0.0104369763,
-0.02693763,
-0.0340652242,
0.0199918747,
-0.0141085507,
-0.0206207372,
-0.0551197529,
-0.0697289407,
-0.0181197524,
0.056000106,
-0.0186124723,
0.0026656792,
0.0202558376,
-0.0089782067,
0.0315095894,
0.0401703082,
-0.050693877,
-0.0143476594,
-0.062087968,
0.0104356501,
0.0824413672,
0.0060828752,
-0.0187776033,
-0.0164786968,
-0.0694107339,
-0.0163268801,
0.0503780395,
0.0440606438,
-0.0129947029,
-0.0270246789,
-0.0304604582,
-0.0430316478,
0.0039152694,
0.0294679161,
0.00865102,
0.0207998678,
-0.0233779177,
-0.009289871,
0.0024186501,
-0.0702645183,
0.0555053577,
0.0131898196,
-0.0409664437,
-0.0233977064,
0.0044846423,
0.0587085113,
0.0238892622,
-0.0388726629,
-0.0207978413,
-0.0043054391,
-0.0021575221,
-0.00657439,
-0.0038982884,
0.0039062309,
0.0107628535,
0.0084975166,
-0.0218596831,
-0.0061176838,
0.0183087606,
-0.0075765471,
0.012420956,
-0.0132037448,
-0.0507143885,
0.0359984972,
-0.0415800884,
-0.0386892036,
-0.0593353882,
0.001435198,
-0.0223571453,
0.0248789676,
-0.0202361997,
-0.0116508286,
0.0048002172,
-0.0194756258,
0.0419167466,
-0.0047159395,
-0.055647485,
-0.0374965593,
-0.0058030277,
0.0401817821,
0.0218388941,
-0.0000521772,
-0.0269001853,
0.0012677672,
-0.1246905401,
-0.0164766032,
-0.0234079231,
-0.0195151009,
-0.0272354409,
-0.0257054996,
-0.023980923,
-0.022167163,
0.0149493283,
-0.0608537197,
-0.0068727694,
0.0803552419,
0.0073699933,
-0.0114573343,
-0.0338373929,
-0.0322488733,
-0.0274952706,
-0.028332958,
0.0325026698,
0.0488025583,
-0.0771523565,
0.0141750444,
-0.0373854525,
-0.0362030305,
0.003674994,
0.0201089159,
-0.0546343103,
0.0452844463,
0.0617944188,
-0.03064573,
0.0611693785,
0.0193664748,
0.0911566466,
0.02140937,
0.0274472795,
-0.0511017926,
0.016526876,
-0.0028779057,
0.0055538784,
-0.011930122,
-0.0492087193,
-0.021529546,
0.057034079,
0.0169073176,
-0.0052903118,
-0.0810843706,
0.04556996,
-0.0447562486,
-0.065141879,
-0.0169381816,
-0.0809860826,
-0.039732907,
0.0241788104,
-0.0039086556,
-0.0690955818,
0.046300564,
0.0312107466,
0.0133061381,
-0.0237608757,
0.0335342363,
0.0134779643,
0.0384000503,
-0.0100348555,
0.0222226419,
0.0000578985,
-0.0064494526,
0.0184136834,
-0.0141619416,
0.0479702801,
-0.0330642983,
-0.0293459855,
-0.0040329825,
0.0052139508,
-0.0040666875,
-0.0409024321,
-0.0570639633,
-0.0366234258,
-0.0337961651,
-0.0014556282,
0.0225853343,
-0.0097896252,
0.0010295879,
0.0084336791,
-0.0068236808,
0.0001632172,
0.0007556124,
0.0003625214,
0.0230735727,
-0.0351195671,
-0.0127962148,
-0.0012226881,
0.0171293821,
-0.0195336528,
-0.0255610831,
0.0216952469,
-0.0086668497,
0.023937583,
-0.0192738958,
0.0333006494,
0.0173412729,
0.000354525,
-0.0391234383,
0.0113637904,
0.0438811779,
-0.0396038704,
0.017925106,
0.0956917107,
0.0317287967,
0.0064860792,
-0.0007510725,
0.0051458646,
0.051965151,
-0.0070509575,
-0.0031159143,
-0.0939621627,
-0.0107208919,
-0.0081023956,
0.05077051,
-0.0749386773,
-0.0308035091,
0.0303226262,
-0.0607493743,
0.0385964513,
-0.0279032234,
-0.0497327484,
0.0107693458,
-0.0459777974,
0.0117436023,
-0.0291527901,
0.0437298417,
-0.0375338569,
0.02254772,
-0.0045156796,
0.0708338097,
-0.0740206614,
-0.0411493629,
-0.0029269219,
-0.031028321,
0.0374175534,
0.0847536772,
0.0389018394,
-0.0382329524,
-0.0185644999,
0.0344348252,
0.0410434417,
0.0266462583,
-0.0293555073,
0.0949923545,
-0.0079436153,
-0.0160607155,
-0.0329298973,
0.0359051079,
0.0412479006,
0.0037320533,
-0.0146706002,
0.0348985903,
0.0243144501,
0.0355678238,
-0.0520217083,
0.0144979265,
0.0068083126,
0.0932898968,
0.0471986383,
-0.0852597058,
0.0100534959,
-0.0467701033,
0.0148967858,
-0.0568138249,
-0.0185080636,
0.0060391389,
-0.0776737109,
-0.0431521721,
-0.0461552218,
-0.077703312,
0.0356338397,
0.0025697765,
0.0531205088,
-0.0064372285,
-0.0223615188,
0.0101911733,
-0.0187127795,
0.0509891585,
0.0357085653,
-0.0138255944,
0.0046113408,
-0.0399646051,
-0.0120230317,
0.0014983453,
-0.0454094186,
0.0147627732,
-0.0369743705,
-0.0534828939,
0.1009053141,
0.0724171251,
0.0245857425,
0.0396109484,
0.0292145442,
-0.0660528168,
0.0025260926,
0.0532612987,
0.0177584961,
-0.0130866254,
0.0655402914,
-0.011995784,
-0.0164807439,
0.0060771289,
-0.0240806453,
0.0405387506,
0.0316784903,
-0.0197364949,
-0.0548383407,
-0.0236269794,
-0.0103977295,
0.0073720426,
0.0577714443,
-0.0374240018,
-0.085175015,
-0.0298302043,
-0.0006671665,
0.0102639524,
-0.025312731,
-0.042724587,
-0.0143574523,
-0.0078339204,
-0.003269508,
-0.0571126752,
0.0013054744,
-0.0380850472,
0.0480049737,
-0.0665225238,
0.071305573,
0.0384126306,
0.0319791287,
-0.0146650085,
0.0118448362,
-0.045842234,
0.0516637228,
0.0374888517,
0.006169904,
0.0295094308,
0.0375085287,
0.0209975671,
0.0303326156,
0.0345948637,
-0.0142999263,
-0.0032022349,
-0.0109301563,
-0.0606111586,
0.0392999239,
-0.0221760385,
-0.0308192726,
0.0363221802,
-0.003398224,
-0.0328374505,
0.0042331107,
0.0101310583,
0.0027303104,
-0.0111910831,
0.021299243,
-0.006829862,
-0.030884847,
-0.0273137633,
0.0085163806,
-0.0197651479,
0.058233235,
-0.0178709924,
-0.0449010655,
-0.0344015583,
0.0279017165,
0.0619433895,
0.0040333904,
0.0069747386,
0.0373851545,
-0.0697544962,
-0.021356279,
0.0137946373,
-0.027979888,
0.0129944161,
-0.0059037283,
0.033271905,
0.0413152687,
-0.029161552,
-0.0164798573,
-0.0004100102,
-0.0271519888,
-0.0198680498,
-0.0199206565,
-0.0224492364,
-5.503128599e-33,
-0.0401865691,
-0.0132553037,
-0.0173782073,
0.033986602,
0.012151747,
-0.0022183617,
0.0109971119,
0.0300637409,
-0.0204888694,
0.0337024704,
0.010478205,
0.0027649254,
0.0152754905,
-0.0067558275,
0.0302711837,
-0.0593842752,
0.0433354862,
-0.0220169332,
-0.0435466915,
-0.0166012067,
0.025098389,
0.0092902873,
0.0351891294,
-0.1049334407,
0.0628073439,
-0.0069356947,
-0.019071931,
-0.011398796,
-0.013761784,
0.08055567,
-0.0164445043,
0.0695395619,
0.0141790854,
-0.0020657666,
-0.0008258605,
0.0494926982,
-0.0399351791,
-0.0305780359,
0.0249920394,
0.0327172168,
0.0014825806,
-0.0245980825,
0.0470616184,
-0.0018651237,
-0.0713408589,
0.0057867956,
0.0561974049,
-0.0415833853,
-0.0040083621,
-0.0367712192,
-0.0595219247,
0.0274329856,
-0.0196583346,
-0.0252093505,
0.0090372264,
0.0362085365,
0.0295616686,
-0.0208690446,
-0.0541561954,
-0.0042162444,
0.041803591,
-0.0325748883,
0.0128369257,
0.0424739607,
0.0043019527,
0.0646475255,
0.0330442786,
0.0473625846,
0.0196241755,
-0.0131365405,
0.0385452509,
0.0266819354,
0.0699598789,
0.0423167348,
0.0305358022,
-0.0240389165,
-0.033301957,
-0.0050985417,
0.0065727015,
-0.0166257843,
0.0372059196,
-0.0180405099,
-0.0769019052,
-0.0331610925,
-0.0454046763,
-0.0456743762,
-0.0040792599,
-0.020972563,
0.0299872272,
-0.0208499935,
-0.016786702,
0.034057539,
0.0276189949,
-0.0052978559,
-0.0017198737,
0.0008384521,
0.0086407298,
0.0159341209,
0.0092251273,
-0.0060772519,
-0.0479072705,
0.0194297545,
0.0228563584,
-0.0110616097,
0.0628473759,
-0.008423686,
0.1230469719,
0.0136857638,
-0.0638867691,
-0.0084984312,
0.0176795758,
0.0603873804,
-0.0191405471,
0.004504005,
0.0302342772,
0.045173578,
0.009091408,
-0.0130056366,
0.0363734961,
0.0270399414,
-0.0370245725,
-0.0021195284,
-0.0278543457,
-0.0199433174,
0.0114258118,
-0.0116045056,
0.0186731461,
0.0347047672,
-0.0015716518,
-0.0826273113,
0.0008833456,
-0.0110436957,
2.261e-7,
0.0651162565,
0.064166896,
0.0218662396,
-0.022539923,
0.0063193529,
0.0381111279,
0.012711334,
0.0213221051,
0.0597449541,
0.0199526213,
-0.0087287761,
0.0127360523,
0.0345930979,
0.0622416623,
-0.0073523284,
-0.0670625791,
-0.0926746577,
0.0559576564,
-0.0469632223,
0.0268757958,
0.0201956593,
0.0577017739,
0.0400531441,
-0.0281881876,
-0.0084319282,
-0.0061786855,
0.0390685908,
-0.0795641914,
0.0110012293,
-0.0023393459,
0.0521979295,
0.03964708,
0.0306278281,
0.0729702935,
-0.0139158834,
0.0107608167,
0.0262828544,
0.0220732428,
-0.008343407,
-0.0218441226,
0.0047040125,
0.018373318,
0.0006261655,
-0.0421522483,
0.0242091417,
-0.00884989,
-0.0139223076,
-0.020747913,
-0.0192812029,
0.0071545141,
0.0556277558,
-0.0324747227,
-0.0081910836,
-0.0261868667,
0.0353594385,
-0.0060337326,
0.0061538494,
-0.0396647863,
-0.0444885828,
0.0084056528,
-0.0195162669,
-0.060907945,
-0.0156244664,
-0.0082996078,
-0.0144530972,
-0.0417041108,
0.0185359735,
1.895955986e-34,
0.0276484825,
-0.0452972576,
0.0253242273,
0.0323556326,
0.0118197938,
0.0375864878,
0.0415118448,
-0.0188721418,
0.032264404,
-0.0217673723,
-0.0042955009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14199v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14199v2 | A Systematic Review of Deep Learning-based Research on Radiology Report Generation | 2023-11-23T20:52:44 | 2024-04-25T09:25:24 | Chang Liu, Yuanhe Tian, Yan Song | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Radiology report generation (RRG) aims to automatically generate free-text
descriptions from clinical radiographs, e.g., chest X-Ray images. RRG plays an
essential role in promoting clinical automation and presents significant help
to provide practical assistance for inexperienced doctors and alleviate
radiologists' workloads. Therefore, consider these meaningful potentials,
research on RRG is experiencing explosive growth in the past half-decade,
especially with the rapid development of deep learning approaches. Existing
studies perform RRG from the perspective of enhancing different modalities,
provide insights on optimizing the report generation process with elaborated
features from both visual and textual information, and further facilitate RRG
with the cross-modal interactions among them. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive review of deep learning-based RRG from various perspectives.
Specifically, we firstly cover pivotal RRG approaches based on the
task-specific features of radiographs, reports, and the cross-modal relations
between them, and then illustrate the benchmark datasets conventionally used
for this task with evaluation metrics, subsequently analyze the performance of
different approaches and finally offer our summary on the challenges and the
trends in future directions. Overall, the goal of this paper is to serve as a
tool for understanding existing literature and inspiring potential valuable
research in the field of RRG. | [
0.0156778302,
0.0409223773,
0.0429062843,
-0.0115310214,
-0.0212333146,
0.0195883792,
0.0048507364,
0.021614898,
-0.0235808846,
0.0037833969,
-0.0186034385,
-0.0423234813,
0.0278300792,
0.0687122494,
0.0028356956,
-0.098334603,
0.0073696733,
0.0034759219,
0.0030369284,
0.0163605213,
-0.0168536082,
0.0229326785,
-0.0049322448,
0.0403929688,
-0.0550629981,
0.0086345617,
-0.0022385041,
0.0313003846,
0.032911934,
-0.0513720028,
-0.0378058925,
0.0232097432,
0.0365763828,
0.031996429,
0.0000019096,
0.0157553405,
-0.0010581805,
0.0320634767,
0.0062466715,
-0.0466473326,
0.0935634598,
-0.0851869509,
-0.012159382,
-0.0095668202,
-0.0152445259,
-0.0606843941,
0.0631075278,
0.055465512,
0.0512948036,
0.0517969616,
-0.0361715518,
0.03028965,
-0.0010373003,
-0.0542339534,
0.0394205339,
-0.0301764775,
0.0011030757,
-0.0039249975,
0.0000695348,
0.014749256,
-0.0179422572,
0.0462995991,
0.0369675048,
-0.0266789794,
0.0081888735,
0.0648323298,
0.0003643458,
-0.0085957926,
-0.0028321631,
0.0964724272,
-0.0361558124,
0.0242933445,
-0.0142847029,
-0.0392301157,
-0.033311218,
-0.0225583371,
-0.0330379196,
0.0322402269,
-0.0195470713,
0.0059081917,
-0.04960851,
0.009954947,
-0.0009622317,
0.0245457869,
-0.0058840155,
-0.0311084408,
-0.0063480097,
0.0090927193,
0.0028299519,
0.0393019579,
0.0189897213,
-0.0696190968,
0.022149615,
0.0333809741,
-0.0507987961,
0.0124164,
-0.0469193235,
-0.0339666717,
0.0616963618,
0.0067065461,
-0.0067276745,
-0.0368072577,
-0.0614861287,
0.060178481,
-0.0310143251,
0.0084039019,
-0.0495983474,
0.0324058235,
-0.0077995518,
0.0059832721,
-0.0304999463,
-0.0262654517,
-0.0069688405,
0.010320547,
0.0023585435,
-0.0424274616,
-0.0700460076,
-0.001152092,
-0.0000395584,
0.0524717122,
0.0377740301,
0.0898688734,
-0.1180231795,
0.026026858,
-0.0159290079,
0.0327940732,
-0.0073613194,
-0.0144236721,
0.0229305476,
-0.0165567286,
0.0309480652,
0.0634854808,
0.0195997152,
0.0257848985,
-0.0267393496,
0.0171636604,
-0.031647522,
0.0041381894,
0.038331911,
-0.0777084008,
-0.0241861008,
-0.0238673072,
0.0504714549,
-0.0583396517,
0.0364185423,
-0.0115631521,
-0.0131153334,
-0.0084799072,
0.0010664365,
0.0139356079,
-0.0186783317,
0.0627639666,
-0.0450520776,
-0.0149525609,
0.0363448411,
0.0263580587,
0.0304216407,
-0.0096287681,
0.0435459539,
0.0526689291,
-0.018261265,
0.0118757812,
0.0109026963,
-0.0101461625,
0.013479691,
-0.0468018688,
-0.0216726623,
-0.0342843905,
-0.038308315,
0.0688877478,
0.014486637,
0.0426107012,
-0.0231569521,
0.0010207607,
0.0209092926,
0.0293214563,
0.0467959046,
0.0247657858,
0.085288398,
0.0039680693,
-0.025365429,
0.0224584322,
-0.0281168409,
0.0528262332,
0.0850158408,
0.0296909045,
-0.0163978525,
-0.0299817268,
-0.057549715,
-0.0295515712,
0.0190945882,
-0.0214657225,
-0.0153736444,
-0.0263698585,
0.0687560141,
0.0150303673,
-0.0690452233,
0.0120550385,
0.0264776815,
-0.021736538,
0.0030618242,
-0.0470121987,
-0.0130885644,
0.0675505996,
0.0533365943,
-0.0253583528,
-0.0276155528,
0.0142592574,
0.0567390472,
0.0847458914,
0.0235436372,
0.0212416667,
0.033881437,
-0.0705889091,
-0.0731488466,
-0.0191505998,
-0.000910983,
0.0063679805,
-0.0078302911,
0.0255676396,
0.0181805566,
-0.0287780501,
-0.050087247,
0.0317587592,
-0.0229048189,
-0.0149406604,
0.0098885428,
0.0375315472,
-0.0226006974,
0.0145946778,
-0.0251871459,
0.0241816621,
0.0117337266,
-0.004133624,
-0.0212672446,
0.0182532035,
-0.0765226632,
-0.0071835667,
-0.0218829978,
-0.08423464,
0.0005492163,
0.0041804067,
-0.043484062,
-0.0254594162,
-0.0276448186,
-0.0328132845,
-0.010426783,
-0.0215732232,
-0.0140453586,
0.0815256685,
0.0224943124,
0.0107113831,
0.0449469276,
-0.0011467369,
-0.0141859697,
0.0634753183,
0.0120902527,
0.0061516082,
-0.0268365033,
0.0093294773,
-0.0029157312,
-0.0029728168,
-0.011513669,
0.0096733635,
0.0473097786,
-0.0309461821,
-0.0023227448,
-0.0594820455,
-0.0091135306,
0.0199751183,
-0.0371850431,
0.038741827,
0.0300861895,
0.0234297775,
-0.0334331617,
-0.0632741451,
-0.0028938905,
0.0697121844,
-0.0105208503,
0.0582621917,
0.0225680806,
0.0284050312,
-0.0292704869,
-0.0359805934,
-0.0010385191,
0.0142654348,
0.0744795427,
-0.0253855065,
-0.002815607,
0.0223651063,
-0.0378928557,
0.0029264633,
0.0110650407,
-0.0162885617,
0.0438620001,
-0.0201290846,
-0.0239989199,
0.0679695606,
0.015789561,
0.0313959271,
0.024858661,
-0.0115278224,
-0.0363733023,
0.0156571809,
-0.058994785,
-0.0107456874,
0.0366492011,
-0.0812185854,
-0.0147111155,
0.0129870698,
0.0027106183,
0.0572625995,
-0.0275715366,
-0.0370770991,
-0.0055277855,
-0.0311650503,
-0.0200506318,
0.00774077,
0.0088770855,
0.025916148,
-0.0325906277,
-0.0438495092,
0.0770760775,
0.0038090129,
0.0119429296,
-0.0320918262,
0.0254321769,
-0.0332781672,
0.0437794626,
0.0000135482,
0.041432254,
0.0207756013,
-0.045022063,
-0.0294181909,
-0.0070351632,
0.0372758806,
-0.031237863,
-0.0074188611,
-0.0074359076,
0.0070235496,
-0.0510471836,
-0.0137453508,
-0.0351209939,
-0.0260488838,
0.0354962274,
0.010636352,
-0.0082454588,
-0.0331840888,
-0.062193878,
0.0321431421,
0.0130146369,
0.0281930827,
-0.0024373126,
-0.033586558,
-0.0187849682,
0.0674919859,
0.0425434485,
0.0066915946,
-0.0292377509,
-0.023756057,
0.0159848072,
0.0519935749,
-0.0014715326,
0.0849965364,
-0.0305902231,
-0.0109508373,
-0.0501596816,
0.032784313,
0.0120848548,
0.0202349219,
0.0221630447,
-0.0724290609,
-0.0298936628,
0.049283158,
0.0209057294,
-0.0384332202,
-0.0288803037,
0.0349375308,
0.0132745774,
-0.0225165281,
-0.0004732792,
-0.0376609042,
0.0005520827,
-0.009869596,
0.0348511003,
-0.0137308482,
-0.0087012891,
-0.0043553212,
-0.0417105816,
0.063463904,
-0.0028956542,
-0.0394368358,
-0.0689823478,
-0.0182557758,
-0.0137891471,
0.0037910545,
-0.0234035831,
-0.0287699774,
-0.0193470102,
-0.0300202221,
0.0343830436,
-0.0332558192,
-0.0522956997,
-0.0344675258,
-0.0537298284,
-0.0442885272,
0.0703892037,
0.0486205779,
-0.0152606107,
-0.0212543197,
-0.0319854692,
0.0426779501,
0.0034346217,
-0.0033975176,
0.1062671021,
0.0138156163,
-0.0405101404,
-0.0296085291,
0.0424363092,
-0.0090901898,
0.0236656033,
-0.0246776491,
0.0066023143,
-0.0196439251,
-0.0227795467,
-0.0783741027,
0.0677480251,
0.0374537222,
0.0350669846,
-0.0005703174,
0.0085601984,
-0.0607831776,
-0.0056374609,
0.0733961016,
-0.1036949307,
-0.0221064668,
0.0290176496,
-0.0402161293,
-0.0774602443,
-0.0473091044,
-0.0394711941,
0.04178432,
0.0194834042,
-0.0203150883,
-0.0058301212,
-0.0057390686,
-0.0204605293,
-0.058417391,
0.0335927457,
-0.0116682155,
-0.0050816089,
-0.0049849399,
-0.0306877512,
0.029736774,
-0.0162757132,
-0.0054065729,
0.0472083539,
-0.0630780458,
0.0279186834,
-0.0303208977,
0.0337029621,
0.0142656807,
0.0212708954,
0.017273156,
-0.0012086603,
0.0867476612,
0.0499882847,
0.0057476428,
-0.0329943672,
-0.0092187244,
-0.0267212745,
-0.0527837388,
0.0108973114,
-0.0509272106,
0.0010659145,
-0.0119112935,
0.020786332,
0.0112626133,
-0.0456800871,
0.0279413965,
-0.0090558026,
-0.0167044178,
-0.0399031453,
-0.0234930087,
-0.03434195,
-0.0252820123,
-0.017088009,
-0.0026719279,
-0.0456190482,
0.0460443273,
0.0173324291,
0.0076790112,
0.0039861137,
0.03746159,
-0.0006847486,
0.0024134852,
-0.028448496,
0.0182649884,
0.0211545415,
0.0002873572,
0.0176121667,
-0.0043847184,
-0.0447733328,
-0.0161690563,
-0.0130150616,
0.0072789644,
-0.0042849123,
0.036538139,
0.0250958968,
0.0496343076,
-0.0185116157,
0.0439397842,
-0.0021621101,
-0.0304881111,
-0.0553944074,
0.0228443705,
0.0328114331,
0.0129845627,
0.0119128516,
-0.0598163567,
-0.0011135408,
-0.0176339783,
0.0561067089,
0.0113222366,
-0.0013264064,
0.0391551629,
-0.0203645304,
0.0470212102,
0.0098174177,
0.0919845328,
0.0098924274,
0.0257938169,
-0.0140082715,
-0.0705890954,
-0.0708044991,
-0.0115488498,
0.0380707905,
-0.0100451475,
-0.0155612845,
-0.008469603,
-0.0069574704,
-0.0512786172,
0.0359870791,
0.0169652849,
-0.0121201165,
0.0001962259,
0.0708295852,
0.0569020249,
0.0210425686,
0.0141527541,
-0.0011818567,
0.0400955826,
-0.0223413054,
-0.0240040626,
-0.0081591951,
-5.416131731e-33,
-0.0053520068,
-0.0733412802,
0.0233880617,
-0.0426045693,
-0.0078658387,
0.0462957732,
-0.0469535477,
-0.0192334596,
0.0177784208,
0.0015306892,
0.0045396588,
-0.0279118493,
0.0308089126,
0.0440705083,
-0.0132358428,
-0.0115545569,
0.0364337899,
-0.0212847479,
-0.0222435817,
0.0641407818,
-0.0194274597,
0.0172164775,
0.0250141267,
-0.0970405489,
-0.0136023974,
0.0193355717,
-0.0213784762,
-0.0254079513,
0.006748674,
0.045414608,
-0.0461254381,
-0.0025370987,
0.0300897881,
-0.0291410144,
-0.0158219226,
0.0598858967,
-0.0918053463,
-0.0051719621,
-0.0450216718,
-0.0170284044,
-0.0912107304,
-0.0002616546,
0.051582586,
-0.0175659657,
0.0610883534,
-0.0509324595,
0.0575950406,
0.0118432418,
-0.0032903738,
-0.0508894622,
-0.0508467779,
0.0422620252,
-0.0204323027,
-0.0550708883,
0.0129324412,
0.0295024253,
-0.0003048284,
0.0362475589,
-0.0423143134,
0.0136624193,
0.0420761667,
0.0282988455,
0.0632622913,
0.0009316414,
-0.0424507298,
0.0275948197,
0.0515561737,
-0.0297918562,
-0.0105064465,
0.0315067023,
-0.0229630638,
0.0757112131,
0.0199231729,
0.0427557267,
0.0320964158,
0.0239817575,
-0.0895409957,
0.0712407604,
-0.0477957316,
0.0605476461,
-0.0041617546,
-0.0324560963,
-0.0150210653,
0.0319402963,
0.0236137416,
-0.0213346817,
-0.0178848878,
-0.0256472304,
0.0290860608,
0.0729710087,
-0.0445362888,
0.0410752818,
0.0219479408,
0.0285846218,
0.026956033,
-0.0240627918,
0.0119166514,
0.0492868125,
-0.0421958342,
-0.0514006801,
-0.0178238731,
-0.0243289862,
0.0493814759,
0.0145209348,
0.0199172962,
0.0438281223,
0.0516297035,
0.0292708576,
-0.0232910551,
0.0071978816,
-0.003950825,
0.0024277745,
-0.0437566005,
0.0466956943,
0.0253946949,
-0.0213832892,
-0.0282137878,
0.0166781787,
-0.0399295203,
0.0163825545,
-0.0185307618,
-0.0726993605,
0.0366037488,
0.0064552296,
-0.0621300265,
-0.0185933709,
-0.0415967405,
-0.0330888592,
0.0820805356,
-0.0258681849,
-0.0293699969,
0.0144860912,
2.46e-7,
0.0413570181,
-0.0155118695,
0.0782751814,
0.0201626401,
0.0027551898,
0.0091616372,
-0.0029588281,
0.0116638215,
-0.0285364427,
-0.024657676,
0.0630395785,
-0.0050591766,
0.0228563175,
0.0240273736,
-0.05558002,
-0.0131671336,
-0.0467637293,
0.0072408156,
-0.009517733,
-0.0287249442,
0.0705313087,
0.0494111925,
-0.0606493838,
-0.0542279296,
0.029828757,
-0.0052237092,
0.0522659719,
-0.0025388517,
0.0264408533,
-0.0108345272,
0.0309526231,
0.0532328263,
-0.0185550135,
0.021915175,
0.0091894343,
-0.0504260994,
0.0264234189,
0.0443372764,
-0.0079557262,
-0.0342653207,
0.0178239867,
0.0084547987,
0.0297868773,
0.0007385056,
0.027817281,
-0.054323826,
-0.0079217982,
-0.0114274705,
-0.0148710227,
0.0505486652,
0.0345711671,
-0.0474245287,
-0.0567266345,
0.046936091,
0.033928331,
0.0050641503,
-0.0589755811,
-0.0586630031,
-0.0088025033,
-0.0088260081,
-0.0081482418,
0.00008084,
-0.0088740727,
0.001977938,
-0.0054836683,
-0.0255754851,
-0.0195753537,
2.192723999e-34,
0.004901032,
0.0154448096,
-0.0235622395,
-0.0300627872,
-0.0012379461,
-0.007558289,
-0.0066987518,
0.0171032939,
-0.0176485814,
-0.0393383391,
-0.0376723148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14169v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14169v1 | Evaluating GPT-4's Vision Capabilities on Brazilian University Admission Exams | 2023-11-23T19:20:59 | 2023-11-23T19:20:59 | Ramon Pires, Thales Sales Almeida, Hugo Abonizio, Rodrigo Nogueira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advancements in language models have showcased human-comparable
performance in academic entrance exams. However, existing studies often
overlook questions that require the integration of visual comprehension, thus
compromising the full spectrum and complexity inherent in real-world scenarios.
To address this gap, we present a comprehensive framework to evaluate language
models on entrance exams, which incorporates both textual and visual elements.
We evaluate the two most recent editions of Exame Nacional do Ensino M\'edio
(ENEM), the main standardized entrance examination adopted by Brazilian
universities. Our study not only reaffirms the capabilities of GPT-4 as the
state of the art for handling complex multidisciplinary questions, but also
pioneers in offering a realistic assessment of multimodal language models on
Portuguese examinations. One of the highlights is that text captions
transcribing visual content outperform the direct use of images, suggesting
that the vision model has room for improvement. Yet, despite improvements
afforded by images or captions, mathematical questions remain a challenge for
these state-of-the-art models. The code and data used on experiments are
available at https://github.com/piresramon/gpt-4-enem. | [
-0.0185567979,
0.0280860122,
-0.0509314537,
0.0645718202,
-0.0181106068,
-0.0005174589,
-0.00492121,
0.0268767308,
0.0061471774,
-0.0611306168,
-0.0015564237,
-0.0548410229,
0.0231367871,
0.032491222,
0.0466724895,
-0.0983039215,
0.0000915801,
-0.0521629378,
-0.0648060516,
0.0068196375,
-0.0080596181,
-0.0116905579,
-0.0409940332,
0.0014776671,
0.0027305479,
-0.0103570027,
-0.0072886054,
-0.0271293428,
0.0050989464,
-0.0223301612,
-0.0335509777,
0.0917082801,
0.0099360617,
0.0149851982,
0.0000021196,
-0.0465493761,
-0.0150006637,
-0.0185749754,
0.0391515195,
0.0197656937,
0.0622410327,
-0.0228608362,
0.0024656991,
-0.00873804,
-0.0699242577,
-0.0169499852,
0.0431854427,
-0.0127942339,
0.042359814,
0.0440908037,
-0.0136741316,
-0.0103549473,
0.0445958711,
-0.0087225782,
0.0066811414,
-0.0361708105,
0.0055143042,
0.011534296,
0.0017995805,
0.0508915037,
-0.05485598,
0.0369414315,
0.0102141304,
-0.0131841488,
-0.0162749905,
0.0201054029,
-0.014306888,
-0.012814533,
-0.0275633782,
0.0494020879,
0.0153035671,
0.0259424616,
-0.0204238929,
-0.0004957718,
0.0110200467,
0.0477654673,
-0.0981832594,
0.0259835646,
-0.0097861458,
-0.0323289856,
-0.0369843766,
-0.0055072349,
-0.0148504386,
0.0091935936,
0.0208221339,
-0.0130990315,
0.0457223244,
-0.015357594,
0.015071501,
0.0185557585,
-0.056419041,
-0.0097759124,
0.0215361677,
0.0296116434,
0.021587627,
0.0291901976,
-0.0269023497,
-0.0546050929,
0.0129886819,
-0.0335528441,
0.025251044,
0.0427895077,
-0.0202487428,
0.0432518087,
-0.034209419,
0.1252298802,
-0.0258232504,
0.0219691657,
-0.0356680639,
-0.0034863374,
-0.0204182118,
-0.0189001635,
-0.0351419076,
-0.008633378,
-0.0286114402,
-0.0081738299,
-0.0520623438,
0.0009674101,
-0.0076164287,
0.0085706143,
-0.0184435993,
-0.0107586123,
-0.0125284912,
-0.0004604495,
-0.0634141937,
0.0368782915,
0.003526509,
-0.0174236055,
-0.0221589003,
-0.0177347586,
0.01655945,
0.0252449904,
-0.0081267618,
-0.0299262106,
-0.0122163277,
0.0346369632,
-0.0007893475,
-0.0255161822,
0.0439567044,
-0.0463665798,
-0.033903636,
-0.0572417602,
0.0460691266,
-0.0235258453,
0.0186850037,
0.0223630816,
0.0238361154,
-0.0421397015,
0.0142856752,
0.0461158231,
0.0648799613,
0.06586615,
0.0169157125,
-0.0204093959,
0.012667154,
0.0221179444,
-0.0160357635,
0.0596946739,
0.0328552127,
0.0055976519,
0.0349183604,
-0.0756713226,
0.027677089,
0.0774310008,
0.0103428829,
-0.0033027844,
-0.0237890221,
0.020688545,
0.0781662613,
0.0488915257,
0.0120748701,
0.0475867987,
0.007358239,
0.0058713285,
0.0607353859,
0.0605663471,
-0.0161140691,
-0.0035882411,
0.0075269192,
-0.0199996978,
0.0317867734,
0.0465414152,
-0.0194529258,
0.0143889291,
-0.0051848143,
-0.0015647453,
-0.0033738613,
0.0533914417,
0.0101278396,
-0.0475075766,
-0.0277441777,
0.0284637809,
-0.0404624939,
0.0133794984,
0.0705264285,
-0.0322355963,
-0.0360089093,
-0.0195184574,
-0.019648008,
-0.0586918481,
0.0016179928,
-0.0387058258,
0.0296802111,
0.0140167233,
0.0628899187,
-0.0081240097,
-0.0278588664,
0.0069677634,
0.0352453701,
0.0533384718,
0.0717968419,
-0.0103305867,
-0.0277315248,
-0.0592750646,
-0.0244520307,
0.0226303469,
-0.0133567415,
-0.0004228726,
-0.0358169526,
0.0236651637,
0.032584779,
-0.0145880524,
0.0005927635,
0.0325963683,
-0.0183445122,
-0.0184707139,
-0.066193372,
-0.0036918554,
-0.0028585838,
-0.0065728487,
0.0315604471,
-0.007335918,
0.0050220643,
0.003358074,
0.0401587561,
-0.0252732653,
-0.0568532571,
-0.0040570963,
0.0472877324,
-0.1029620096,
-0.0309804454,
0.0602860078,
-0.0013064988,
-0.0483962074,
-0.0008276848,
-0.0654696897,
-0.0301791113,
-0.0224664956,
0.0031633005,
-0.0301875211,
0.0062174359,
-0.0240813233,
0.0457830541,
0.0102278898,
0.0592929386,
0.0387833714,
-0.0424853265,
0.0445618778,
-0.0543889031,
-0.0295594558,
0.0108544314,
0.0134984385,
0.0351940356,
-0.0135860192,
0.0173797607,
-0.0550357886,
-0.0204059388,
-0.0872509405,
0.0049454905,
0.00023993,
0.0075409822,
0.0439834967,
-0.037218459,
-0.0115972832,
-0.002236913,
-0.0395740531,
0.0011456714,
-0.0002794912,
-0.0079796026,
0.0067203455,
-0.0047526248,
0.0075622071,
-0.0117541784,
-0.0222015195,
-0.058071319,
0.0323766544,
0.0778628439,
-0.013833818,
-0.0139152315,
0.0376812108,
-0.000977192,
-0.0012235207,
-0.0084319403,
0.0077180187,
0.0253345408,
-0.0127469078,
0.0625317544,
0.0702569038,
-0.0229401868,
0.0199007727,
0.0293042287,
-0.0322243683,
-0.0166388936,
0.0044164853,
0.0133209797,
0.0155838029,
-0.0268182456,
-0.0512122698,
0.0050541842,
0.0346071646,
0.012377644,
-0.0170274861,
-0.0336860195,
0.0749378353,
-0.0619911253,
-0.0089997929,
-0.0763792396,
0.0106736496,
-0.0248253029,
0.0622140579,
0.0171178766,
-0.0142788412,
0.038510561,
-0.0634274036,
-0.0040220167,
-0.0391064361,
0.0549843982,
-0.0201432835,
0.0659914166,
0.03241577,
-0.0294483155,
-0.0126692876,
0.0008608677,
-0.075981684,
0.0107513331,
0.0274062548,
-0.057601314,
0.0660451055,
-0.0772258192,
-0.0183848031,
-0.0560252145,
-0.0226955749,
0.0099787656,
0.0054870755,
0.0138372127,
0.0299904253,
-0.0300010275,
0.0157013666,
-0.0211123135,
0.0324186943,
0.0107238526,
0.0176010709,
-0.0299895499,
-0.0319654606,
-0.0180908721,
0.0700959042,
0.0554733798,
0.0227613989,
-0.0180700906,
-0.0769716948,
0.0118483864,
0.0487612411,
0.035729412,
0.0031687836,
-0.0016713337,
0.0036582912,
0.0440978929,
0.0086099496,
-0.0595718883,
-0.0001916678,
0.0335289277,
-0.0755505636,
0.020613784,
0.0792434514,
0.0104155261,
-0.0386332273,
-0.042858813,
-0.0338667557,
0.0004420568,
0.0213937331,
0.0267812144,
-0.0753569379,
-0.013661528,
-0.0017533338,
0.0036266919,
0.0156050827,
-0.0181673635,
-0.0212783422,
-0.0669667199,
0.060541831,
-0.0018923169,
-0.0495714247,
-0.0320345126,
-0.0004042917,
0.0272160526,
-0.0032059138,
-0.0018033248,
-0.0000101678,
0.0100090187,
0.0319975056,
0.0376315564,
0.0007240205,
-0.018792551,
0.0103310207,
-0.0011809396,
-0.0596339032,
0.0095478287,
0.0142587963,
-0.0170703735,
-0.0755044669,
0.0701278597,
-0.0426605195,
-0.0102970498,
-0.0146066407,
0.0551424623,
-0.0043683951,
-0.0048948391,
-0.0477986038,
0.009598949,
-0.0149024688,
-0.0082100416,
0.0593893453,
0.1216870844,
0.0015909248,
-0.0176229849,
-0.0545207933,
-0.0443915278,
-0.0413182601,
0.0191622414,
0.057055518,
-0.0452863649,
-0.0205490142,
-0.044262737,
0.0422156267,
-0.044197388,
-0.0568060018,
-0.0052499138,
0.0304148067,
-0.0018413044,
-0.0418136343,
-0.0646715984,
0.0627953857,
0.0342086926,
0.0115915965,
-0.0171736684,
0.0254407171,
-0.0049723093,
-0.0366639979,
0.0578106754,
-0.0261440501,
0.0396229662,
-0.0303277615,
-0.006201426,
-0.0023398495,
0.0035147462,
-0.0376326963,
0.0278333221,
-0.0506248325,
-0.0137285534,
-0.0239178855,
0.0260012969,
0.026727248,
-0.0360614136,
0.0017301228,
-0.0424817055,
0.004363168,
-0.0406176746,
0.0159391146,
0.0223151445,
-0.0235437453,
-0.0538841076,
-0.0095556462,
-0.0207629763,
0.0326398686,
-0.013952706,
-0.003192202,
0.0373119377,
0.0041665798,
-0.0322169177,
0.0117471153,
0.0406513847,
0.0743011758,
0.0047976719,
-0.0133948512,
-0.0282463562,
0.0100476779,
-0.0323255248,
0.0007157264,
-0.0341813006,
-0.003193967,
0.0325999595,
-0.002281792,
-0.0099539431,
-0.0233626347,
-0.0528505892,
-0.0017168492,
-0.0458691306,
0.0216029566,
0.0371460989,
-0.0194031689,
0.0220948886,
0.0031559095,
0.01804097,
-0.0286625531,
-0.0152576799,
0.0651173443,
-0.0104097081,
0.1127779707,
-0.0000808031,
-0.0340150222,
0.0741754025,
0.0189917088,
-0.001958125,
0.0051683141,
-0.037449494,
0.0334785432,
0.0311639085,
0.0063619646,
0.0092021674,
-0.0123762218,
0.0087129176,
-0.0251014736,
0.0164769199,
0.0209525619,
-0.0119750025,
0.0883173645,
0.0179022886,
0.031499587,
-0.0315997899,
0.0670215786,
-0.0138602462,
-0.0043336661,
0.0135245519,
-0.0072279708,
-0.0193082076,
-0.02426311,
0.0539791808,
-0.0067601083,
-0.0105422586,
0.0059236451,
-0.0756927282,
-0.0624959953,
0.0033260288,
0.0341845602,
-0.0103467079,
-0.0165580437,
0.0324844979,
0.0676725656,
-0.0340142436,
-0.030736642,
-0.0162038822,
0.0506213345,
-0.0596584342,
-0.0240898672,
0.0177867971,
-5.478473707e-33,
-0.0406394564,
-0.0622403175,
0.0497880578,
0.0032125665,
-0.0014119272,
0.0062406915,
-0.029804945,
0.0431921333,
0.0099348538,
-0.0156994741,
0.0286559556,
0.0061752927,
0.0070704706,
0.0434535705,
0.0006413458,
0.0111076143,
-0.0091219321,
-0.0122061307,
-0.0328541286,
0.0001515282,
-0.0280225109,
-0.0122146895,
0.0753977597,
-0.0012384428,
0.0437164791,
-0.0118467426,
0.0105888927,
-0.0201208238,
-0.0245961733,
0.0904793143,
-0.040605206,
0.047982987,
0.0412664674,
-0.0340110995,
-0.0251510311,
0.0421165936,
0.006385006,
-0.0550954044,
0.0473727174,
0.0725808963,
-0.0462839976,
-0.0210068319,
0.0288970247,
-0.0273854136,
-0.0337011255,
-0.0508663021,
0.072296828,
-0.0526240319,
-0.0248873699,
0.0100794714,
-0.034637101,
0.032413654,
-0.022271134,
0.0058932016,
0.0374567099,
0.0916405544,
0.0216291584,
0.0102569908,
-0.0187966768,
0.0337671638,
0.0074459533,
0.0356349871,
0.0619017743,
-0.0033071982,
-0.0184550807,
0.0244968757,
0.0337282494,
-0.0355969071,
0.0000119906,
-0.0517656878,
0.0779586881,
0.0207410231,
0.1105024964,
0.0570801534,
0.0258878209,
0.0383317247,
-0.048475951,
0.0429150276,
-0.0458136387,
0.0187838376,
0.0093124388,
-0.045766104,
-0.027409045,
0.0181485992,
-0.0563595183,
0.0006385701,
-0.041204486,
0.0049302536,
0.0571218729,
-0.0788102895,
0.0137528516,
0.0299694072,
0.0476349816,
-0.0414697677,
-0.0067742253,
-0.0425480269,
-0.032179635,
0.0715261102,
-0.0194923691,
0.0488037765,
-0.0161741283,
0.0041991994,
0.0133721223,
0.0391124971,
0.0264460407,
-0.0207610074,
-0.0040639555,
-0.0198150445,
-0.027679421,
-0.0134353423,
-0.0369646959,
-0.0211996138,
0.0158997159,
0.0243932325,
0.0355991311,
0.0324880928,
-0.0109073268,
-0.0017717356,
0.0115020471,
-0.0246689618,
-0.0474656634,
-0.0310174394,
-0.0039605764,
0.0029727211,
-0.0289372671,
-0.019596504,
-0.0449434966,
0.0029003865,
0.0214830078,
-0.0281969439,
-0.0167955421,
0.0165979285,
2.651e-7,
0.0812331736,
0.0724175721,
-0.0056640808,
-0.0136450296,
0.0207330436,
0.0166652352,
-0.0463658608,
0.0071637328,
0.0364337862,
-0.0094419625,
0.0175020043,
0.0240538176,
0.0455241278,
0.0221477095,
-0.0475732498,
0.0052314848,
0.0314346105,
-0.0184176825,
-0.0609362945,
0.0672992766,
0.0636536628,
0.0373128243,
-0.0143434396,
-0.0258181654,
-0.0493350476,
-0.0534189008,
0.086599946,
-0.0139870383,
-0.0143476082,
-0.0099489344,
0.0344563127,
0.0059458409,
-0.0221110284,
0.0496680811,
0.0132283112,
-0.0205914844,
0.0536411926,
0.0368362069,
0.0011775272,
0.0643991977,
0.0244946089,
0.0022147445,
-0.0229070317,
-0.0886421502,
0.059149541,
-0.0172589328,
-0.0076656947,
-0.0181391891,
-0.0348805562,
-0.0406201445,
0.0394074209,
-0.0149312261,
-0.0303385574,
0.0045476486,
0.0272959992,
-0.0380456708,
-0.0195778813,
-0.0160184577,
0.0182565358,
0.0029417265,
-0.0314470492,
-0.0505412035,
-0.0634616166,
-0.0373023823,
0.0398424603,
-0.0509270504,
-0.0250235517,
2.246162845e-34,
0.0268094484,
-0.0075097266,
0.0448559821,
-0.0240867957,
0.0137230773,
-0.0118913241,
-0.0116861677,
0.0078905812,
0.0078708222,
-0.0753579363,
-0.018865753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14126v1 | Towards Auditing Large Language Models: Improving Text-based Stereotype Detection | 2023-11-23T17:47:14 | 2023-11-23T17:47:14 | Wu Zekun, Sahan Bulathwela, Adriano Soares Koshiyama | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLM) have made significant advances in the recent past
becoming more mainstream in Artificial Intelligence (AI) enabled human-facing
applications. However, LLMs often generate stereotypical output inherited from
historical data, amplifying societal biases and raising ethical concerns. This
work introduces i) the Multi-Grain Stereotype Dataset, which includes 52,751
instances of gender, race, profession and religion stereotypic text and ii) a
novel stereotype classifier for English text. We design several experiments to
rigorously test the proposed model trained on the novel dataset. Our
experiments show that training the model in a multi-class setting can
outperform the one-vs-all binary counterpart. Consistent feature importance
signals from different eXplainable AI tools demonstrate that the new model
exploits relevant text features. We utilise the newly created model to assess
the stereotypic behaviour of the popular GPT family of models and observe the
reduction of bias over time. In summary, our work establishes a robust and
practical framework for auditing and evaluating the stereotypic bias in LLM. | [
0.0376392268,
0.1125260219,
-0.0257606488,
0.0478099249,
-0.0044173803,
0.0508389585,
0.0338291414,
-0.0052019078,
0.0288326815,
-0.0811230689,
-0.0011111575,
-0.0373657532,
0.0223405566,
0.0472773947,
0.0074632098,
-0.0058847484,
0.0331812352,
0.0345993079,
0.0023238391,
-0.033435028,
0.0103610959,
0.0454658233,
0.0492719039,
0.0475510918,
-0.0201860685,
-0.0279790945,
0.0651014671,
-0.027026549,
0.0044496739,
0.0105739143,
0.0504456237,
0.0664767921,
-0.0022503224,
0.0354352742,
0.0000020302,
-0.0638652518,
0.0256057121,
0.0243224148,
0.0031946613,
0.0284465458,
0.0549642816,
0.0038460111,
-0.0245703049,
0.0240171459,
-0.0175375659,
0.0077699739,
0.0347808637,
0.0440606065,
0.0455252454,
0.0032286672,
-0.0098479101,
-0.0505942591,
-0.0415685624,
0.0054674614,
-0.0229789373,
0.0205480289,
0.0678714737,
-0.0500246622,
-0.0753468946,
-0.022506753,
-0.015813116,
-0.0206981488,
0.0101345545,
0.0292766895,
-0.0070570577,
0.012161254,
-0.0619303659,
-0.0241143797,
0.0269980915,
0.0541917272,
-0.0199457817,
-0.050532341,
0.0218060613,
-0.010733054,
0.0040493947,
-0.0078604054,
0.030331105,
0.0302066449,
-0.0382729471,
0.005653359,
-0.0115370825,
-0.0252434183,
0.0358455703,
0.0669541135,
-0.0173525549,
0.0384086184,
0.0190402009,
-0.0435191356,
0.0019466374,
0.0241318289,
-0.0007759535,
-0.0284224059,
-0.0117139211,
-0.0333533138,
-0.0060988902,
0.0083373208,
-0.0150731867,
-0.01419097,
0.0109793674,
-0.0773685947,
0.0041219485,
0.0290841255,
-0.0188197587,
0.0025823428,
0.0066611897,
0.0496550724,
0.0160478801,
-0.0062117013,
0.002512058,
-0.0304160286,
-0.038410645,
0.0078972001,
0.0180322956,
0.0130254235,
0.0489814803,
0.0550015196,
-0.0438221656,
-0.0241157766,
-0.0508212708,
0.0332280025,
0.0101014301,
0.0259119496,
0.0011391204,
-0.0157316048,
-0.0475913063,
-0.0127780521,
-0.0106094358,
-0.0109645212,
-0.0693587437,
-0.0781854317,
0.021203436,
0.0396067351,
-0.0266157482,
-0.0269589666,
0.0296442155,
0.0613757148,
0.0080741178,
-0.0428426303,
-0.0164098274,
-0.0181438569,
-0.0746028349,
-0.070087187,
-0.0112840226,
-0.0424423926,
0.0023841765,
0.0041700322,
0.0070368946,
-0.0503783673,
-0.0005920005,
0.0317989029,
-0.0505306944,
0.081001699,
0.0442400686,
-0.0001936804,
0.0522867702,
0.0241426639,
-0.0059174253,
0.0655639693,
0.0215585623,
0.0188683495,
0.0443294719,
-0.0187595244,
0.0150055317,
0.0364736728,
0.0283687003,
0.0280838534,
-0.0419962183,
0.0180429425,
0.0211065356,
-0.0206337292,
0.044673577,
0.0307438076,
0.0316664241,
-0.040773645,
0.0666375086,
0.0558643006,
-0.0084722042,
0.0516534038,
0.0556770563,
0.0238799173,
-0.0114548467,
0.011620691,
-0.0729053915,
-0.0286270492,
-0.0197197404,
-0.042357482,
-0.0094692688,
0.0719677433,
-0.0188052189,
-0.0282438472,
-0.0053634527,
-0.0108985193,
0.0184850171,
-0.0000161899,
0.0185287166,
-0.0013720688,
-0.0146609228,
0.038392514,
0.0504023694,
-0.0351945311,
-0.0343451761,
-0.0634007975,
0.0482839607,
0.069433324,
0.0404638499,
-0.0250950623,
0.0219132565,
-0.0374054871,
-0.0466169901,
0.0434466228,
0.0614675954,
0.0050772405,
0.0334957726,
-0.0257722642,
0.0071239234,
0.0495432205,
0.0287143141,
0.0483949371,
0.0637389198,
0.0558777303,
0.0385037586,
-0.022061348,
-0.0776582956,
0.0301032308,
-0.0292324424,
-0.0484849736,
0.0129058976,
0.0191514213,
0.0383989252,
-0.0034966622,
-0.0434786677,
-0.0453700088,
-0.0249472242,
-0.0053776363,
-0.0045707263,
0.0325667262,
-0.0634730309,
0.0212224387,
-0.0048513091,
-0.0488168895,
-0.059726391,
0.0408219472,
-0.0236167479,
-0.0039761737,
0.0271008816,
-0.0182487667,
0.0050220289,
-0.0438912176,
-0.0039014067,
-0.0618108138,
0.0562027767,
-0.0130698858,
0.0538655147,
-0.003614007,
-0.0134049803,
-0.0091615133,
-0.0562182888,
0.0358858369,
-0.0234658308,
-0.0293418877,
0.0314753801,
-0.0003331695,
0.0145596368,
0.0012548156,
-0.0029658615,
0.0025059527,
-0.0082709612,
-0.0562951416,
-0.0251722559,
-0.0002606345,
-0.0057411967,
-0.0281031914,
-0.0112113822,
-0.0362826921,
-0.0003433455,
-0.0363980904,
-0.0179836266,
0.0056463229,
0.0212812237,
0.0162745118,
-0.0466289558,
-0.0036525424,
-0.0226754434,
0.0106317904,
-0.0453862362,
0.0791588128,
0.000497688,
0.0000505233,
-0.0456513911,
0.0041761547,
-0.016722763,
0.032570336,
0.0058652507,
-0.040490672,
-0.0006791934,
0.0266731288,
-0.0082488051,
0.0737156048,
0.0411481671,
0.0153905582,
0.0394267291,
0.0177430827,
-0.0177200008,
-0.0181697644,
0.0203124173,
0.0367611945,
0.011362344,
-0.0877738968,
-0.0245126449,
0.0611262694,
0.0186753608,
-0.0323334821,
-0.0592155382,
0.043153964,
-0.0291659124,
-0.0432063304,
-0.0031517979,
-0.0377939716,
0.002866688,
0.0102268131,
-0.0316861495,
-0.0465247333,
0.0598514788,
-0.0218899883,
0.0263720341,
0.013895656,
-0.0154101774,
-0.0402822681,
0.0604558773,
0.0206496455,
0.0412690155,
0.0492932424,
0.0071560852,
-0.0383814424,
-0.0363634787,
0.0155180255,
-0.0280772578,
0.0416886844,
-0.0504794195,
0.0105358092,
0.0105742682,
-0.0601631738,
-0.0430131368,
-0.0603751689,
-0.0530530959,
-0.0315669402,
-0.0193048511,
-0.0272123609,
-0.008631303,
0.0038440698,
-0.0150770936,
0.0203799959,
-0.0059041507,
-0.0032121388,
0.0108335437,
-0.0267213602,
0.016639227,
-0.009622694,
0.0135918278,
-0.0158039276,
0.0306918025,
0.0131724961,
-0.0646886453,
0.0542834811,
-0.0420260727,
-0.014363979,
-0.0181552004,
-0.0393334217,
-0.0080422442,
-0.0144249825,
0.023812782,
-0.042168498,
0.0015738144,
0.1183274165,
0.0304750279,
-0.0590456054,
0.0270012338,
0.0406271443,
-0.002160304,
0.0326699652,
0.0104982546,
-0.0842171237,
-0.0263958201,
0.0128022544,
0.0140719144,
-0.043419607,
-0.053614784,
-0.0120495036,
-0.120587945,
0.019032985,
-0.0085662613,
-0.0394694842,
-0.0440550745,
0.0049431943,
-0.0227341782,
-0.0498950742,
0.0278051607,
-0.0323232934,
0.0094515262,
-0.0012103632,
-0.0038714481,
-0.0750643536,
-0.0437547751,
0.0751462877,
-0.024562126,
0.0397615544,
0.0329422951,
0.0538234524,
-0.0313102826,
0.0139711984,
0.0154716186,
-0.0258254614,
-0.0023124889,
-0.0150531456,
0.0769731924,
-0.0396937057,
-0.0377162546,
-0.0317148939,
0.0092435563,
-0.0021481223,
0.0228030067,
0.0156309288,
0.0202322789,
0.0132245235,
-0.056858018,
-0.0319994055,
-0.0238401964,
0.0054212757,
0.1003832519,
-0.0069101532,
-0.0495225824,
-0.0375101827,
-0.0737494528,
-0.0177728664,
-0.0070406026,
-0.0778089315,
0.0210154615,
0.0192332193,
-0.0210864265,
-0.0174672902,
-0.0463221446,
0.0011932614,
-0.0363091081,
0.0118813273,
-0.0599167533,
0.0063235778,
-0.0095160734,
-0.0794575661,
0.0147625543,
-0.0284435041,
0.0477555953,
0.0071757874,
-0.0066658757,
0.0285876226,
-0.0461052768,
-0.0284868758,
0.0279112682,
-0.027310688,
-0.0331110954,
0.0369531661,
0.0116523299,
0.0198089182,
0.0653443485,
-0.0196808036,
-0.0519416779,
0.0644480363,
0.0435133576,
0.0023197287,
0.0187464971,
0.0146665368,
0.015652502,
0.0046296725,
0.02681702,
-0.0263924636,
0.0704740137,
0.0046850624,
-0.0908465981,
-0.0282783583,
-0.0227239598,
-0.0065637506,
0.0114570912,
-0.003264507,
-0.0212553628,
0.0032532192,
-0.0528478585,
-0.011027961,
-0.0046007251,
-0.0585299991,
0.007256316,
-0.0118752448,
0.0159502309,
-0.0019755156,
-0.027863184,
-0.0097394418,
-0.0354183577,
0.0225342661,
-0.030607434,
0.0015474374,
0.0421367995,
0.0556875281,
0.015764486,
-0.014786493,
-0.0094569065,
0.0304739997,
-0.0204892885,
0.0520021953,
0.019772999,
0.0411711633,
0.0054288208,
0.0373127125,
0.0069442093,
-0.0021820846,
-0.0232583564,
-0.016185876,
-0.0248985142,
0.0032081609,
0.0174534079,
-0.0448050052,
0.0353502072,
0.0100225974,
-0.0173047278,
0.0079915682,
0.0244049933,
0.0193939954,
0.0112553649,
0.0133272931,
0.0076382337,
-0.029196918,
0.0076393383,
0.0622001141,
0.064148508,
0.0375859104,
0.0279536545,
-0.06427674,
-0.0353775844,
-0.0087990779,
0.0422615595,
-0.0198906362,
0.0000580026,
-0.0036951059,
-0.0767408386,
-0.0750914514,
-0.0199438799,
-0.0211176034,
0.0252315346,
0.003650472,
-0.0027217364,
0.0563877597,
0.0010102454,
-0.0228563994,
-0.027120797,
-0.0132163586,
-0.0273361802,
0.0029758555,
-0.0043760687,
-6.142254795e-33,
-0.019932095,
-0.0585275888,
-0.0343333036,
-0.0192825105,
-0.0014144644,
-0.003036845,
-0.0050706714,
-0.0278580822,
-0.0418471768,
0.0300678723,
0.0278199669,
0.0573970377,
0.0043131784,
-0.0049190926,
0.0217508301,
0.0055646361,
0.052546788,
0.0123690804,
-0.0047367206,
-0.0167761948,
-0.0018369709,
0.0147295538,
0.0496331938,
-0.0527212098,
0.0590650029,
0.0004213278,
-0.0308853425,
-0.0369204208,
-0.0300439745,
0.0589716397,
-0.0434984751,
0.0890529528,
0.0455162041,
-0.0109964497,
0.020893041,
0.0692654327,
-0.0312359463,
-0.0181607716,
-0.0220126975,
0.0340961702,
0.0378063507,
-0.0299301092,
0.0227603167,
-0.001459607,
-0.0642478988,
0.004094833,
0.0748626217,
-0.0281236898,
0.03952685,
0.0166286509,
-0.0479681641,
0.0417055897,
-0.0260216333,
0.019956775,
-0.0179034676,
0.0262916032,
0.0158310737,
0.0504571311,
-0.0573262684,
0.0089856917,
0.0253838599,
-0.0546792373,
0.0286225397,
0.0243083276,
0.0108055342,
0.0507178046,
0.049487967,
0.0559200756,
-0.0255364254,
-0.052449204,
0.0280542821,
-0.0216488224,
0.0279089008,
0.0798052624,
0.0320771113,
-0.0456731766,
-0.0301626772,
-0.0130010732,
0.0627220944,
-0.0260648187,
0.0485714078,
-0.0394326933,
-0.0963894799,
-0.0642966777,
-0.0337071158,
-0.0749681145,
-0.0263944324,
0.0039874054,
0.0284701344,
-0.0178932063,
-0.0160828419,
0.033883635,
-0.0135144461,
-0.073472552,
-0.0052230163,
0.0115194144,
-0.0463313684,
-0.0484626554,
0.0325068608,
0.0085368436,
-0.0659161359,
-0.0091570625,
0.013638638,
0.0308853034,
0.0447292216,
0.0203507002,
0.0290147588,
0.013377415,
-0.0771084428,
0.0197509117,
-0.0132000139,
-0.0212179199,
-0.0068575772,
0.0398635752,
0.014640227,
0.0311761852,
0.004577646,
0.0229627863,
0.0462475605,
0.0147901177,
-0.0405257307,
0.0030097784,
0.0102760708,
0.0326011553,
-0.0017877332,
-0.0216180887,
-0.0059245792,
-0.028796969,
0.0631211475,
-0.0395026989,
0.0007134383,
-0.0384750292,
2.556e-7,
0.0049639624,
0.0580724776,
-0.0185534172,
0.0262491181,
0.0501107238,
0.0681793094,
0.0508278422,
0.0389042422,
-0.0099439863,
-0.0109124798,
-0.0258833971,
0.044605013,
0.0281708036,
0.0305342004,
-0.0494503528,
0.0340357088,
-0.0595245212,
-0.0116240755,
-0.0735182688,
0.0138912806,
0.0259667411,
0.0936455578,
0.0372285694,
-0.029564783,
0.0079555679,
-0.0130252261,
0.0289608631,
-0.0254734289,
0.0052429615,
-0.0022223799,
-0.0129293725,
0.0430004299,
0.0034799327,
0.0374213681,
-0.0022489568,
0.0116250562,
-0.0024285177,
0.0198498629,
-0.0391693898,
0.0417286865,
-0.0247131474,
0.0052132765,
-0.0192404725,
-0.0775776505,
0.0900426805,
0.0223475099,
-0.0306674484,
-0.069589749,
-0.0076602204,
-0.0233916175,
0.0479414016,
0.0042647733,
0.005397473,
0.0065915836,
0.0032054924,
-0.0261765197,
-0.0044661365,
-0.0553414039,
-0.0091536371,
0.0034681207,
-0.0243822839,
-0.0454269424,
-0.0044171433,
-0.017001519,
0.0347051769,
-0.0509854145,
0.0473109707,
2.311559591e-34,
0.0278935116,
0.0169891454,
0.0085669821,
-0.0294964779,
0.052646745,
0.0220966693,
-0.014875154,
-0.0207603034,
0.0422172658,
-0.0233642738,
0.0176344141
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14115v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14115v3 | A density estimation perspective on learning from pairwise human preferences | 2023-11-23T17:20:36 | 2024-01-10T16:11:32 | Vincent Dumoulin, Daniel D. Johnson, Pablo Samuel Castro, Hugo Larochelle, Yann Dauphin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning from human feedback (LHF) -- and in particular learning from
pairwise preferences -- has recently become a crucial ingredient in training
large language models (LLMs), and has been the subject of much research. Most
recent works frame it as a reinforcement learning problem, where a reward
function is learned from pairwise preference data and the LLM is treated as a
policy which is adapted to maximize the rewards, often under additional
regularization constraints. We propose an alternative interpretation which
centers on the generative process for pairwise preferences and treats LHF as a
density estimation problem. We provide theoretical and empirical results
showing that for a family of generative processes defined via preference
behavior distribution equations, training a reward function on pairwise
preferences effectively models an annotator's implicit preference distribution.
Finally, we discuss and present findings on "annotator misspecification" --
failure cases where wrong modeling assumptions are made about annotator
behavior, resulting in poorly-adapted models -- suggesting that approaches that
learn from pairwise human preferences could have trouble learning from a
population of annotators with diverse viewpoints. | [
0.0405195057,
0.0946781114,
-0.0101029612,
0.0337394029,
-0.0144833634,
0.0206095111,
-0.0188058186,
-0.0309128761,
-0.0480272397,
-0.0533164553,
-0.0532603972,
-0.0480197594,
-0.0008636795,
-0.0228713527,
0.0544499569,
-0.0555363856,
0.0214818064,
-0.0497805998,
0.0280724876,
-0.0377156325,
0.001133644,
-0.01371988,
0.0010495668,
0.0264881141,
-0.0025571215,
0.0348922461,
0.0210547186,
-0.0217744038,
0.0187783185,
-0.0114021534,
-0.0165458936,
0.0558362342,
0.0348831564,
0.0189131945,
0.0000018704,
-0.0356351733,
-0.0084505584,
-0.0017232472,
-0.0086911889,
0.0105314758,
0.0211279802,
0.0104005476,
-0.0038781206,
-0.0130684329,
-0.016216604,
-0.0222968832,
0.0294111688,
-0.0031622564,
0.0274761133,
0.0348826423,
-0.0001982957,
-0.0569122694,
0.0131411506,
-0.0660429597,
0.0302965641,
-0.016892409,
0.02892006,
-0.0113485036,
0.0083009358,
0.014340709,
-0.0329037495,
-0.0028817852,
0.0001699522,
0.0228737257,
0.0219604764,
0.0657905936,
-0.0042287069,
-0.0179798473,
0.0008987795,
0.0697952509,
0.0166634433,
0.0051851007,
0.002365378,
-0.0094479201,
-0.0211411063,
0.0416289307,
-0.0071060802,
0.0056429799,
-0.0034075808,
0.0507682152,
0.0230356082,
-0.0194170624,
0.0261152461,
0.0150194718,
-0.0361187235,
0.0608891547,
-0.0083222585,
-0.0070350533,
0.0238129608,
0.0554654077,
-0.0727193207,
-0.0405743532,
0.0002768262,
-0.0202458128,
-0.0263739284,
0.0143920919,
-0.001112793,
-0.0099868625,
0.0189669207,
-0.0567073561,
0.0352872312,
0.0274689309,
-0.0409585424,
0.0325552225,
0.018508764,
0.0176815093,
-0.0210325643,
0.0263006222,
-0.0469000675,
0.0326675028,
-0.0043131858,
0.0210914128,
-0.0128882192,
0.0441411883,
0.009300421,
0.0121768862,
-0.0419269726,
0.0162575301,
-0.0052393037,
0.0261329189,
0.0041890405,
0.0122636342,
-0.0648026615,
-0.0111083928,
-0.0456465334,
0.0482758731,
-0.0304382388,
0.0344474353,
0.0166764744,
0.0013349288,
0.0158312581,
0.033378724,
0.0263344161,
-0.040897917,
-0.0143347578,
0.0348552093,
-0.0150760235,
-0.0100964075,
-0.0195861645,
0.0063658366,
-0.0564679615,
-0.0460893139,
-0.0164565463,
-0.0671315119,
0.0124781989,
-0.0061420863,
0.0236569457,
-0.0581532158,
-0.020007411,
-0.0046364954,
-0.0380863771,
0.0646480322,
0.0301463492,
-0.0067018727,
0.0309409201,
-0.0279680341,
0.0027179876,
0.0572251976,
0.051216241,
0.0129147377,
0.0051338724,
0.0006088125,
-0.0078196088,
0.041105222,
0.021889668,
0.0459986292,
-0.0537740514,
-0.0112441974,
0.0231394991,
0.0428523719,
0.1069403812,
0.0711105615,
-0.0529073812,
-0.0298244376,
0.0685806423,
0.0613355115,
-0.0145839443,
-0.0244782623,
0.0782656595,
-0.0055811815,
-0.0366237126,
0.081834577,
-0.0084329061,
0.0144183906,
-0.0180209652,
-0.0189822875,
0.0638680682,
-0.0147503791,
-0.0388990082,
-0.0485630035,
0.037010707,
-0.0244486574,
0.0151353888,
0.0102669122,
0.0965426341,
-0.0070095742,
0.0038562708,
-0.0230632033,
0.0456516631,
-0.0368874148,
0.037595652,
-0.0408208594,
0.0737457201,
0.0704718754,
0.0083753457,
0.0023166959,
0.004301135,
-0.0053482559,
-0.0694794506,
0.0222592447,
0.0618408285,
-0.0547557659,
-0.0149383266,
-0.0332072265,
-0.0314134359,
0.0110650491,
0.0151971318,
0.0526979752,
-0.0231861286,
-0.0450760201,
-0.0097730756,
-0.0065980884,
-0.0177888125,
0.0216260292,
-0.0128122065,
-0.0069058673,
0.0296700671,
0.0138827972,
0.0555665977,
-0.0013542337,
-0.0127690872,
0.0108401552,
0.0052965512,
-0.0146378642,
0.0063772271,
0.0076512774,
-0.0450435616,
-0.053355813,
0.0088635003,
0.025953114,
0.0064583463,
-0.0110559538,
-0.0078975251,
-0.0325564854,
0.0016038286,
-0.0106149949,
0.066959098,
-0.0367734991,
-0.0072655892,
0.0288488921,
-0.0127369873,
-0.0604049601,
0.0583189726,
-0.0316521674,
-0.0059278035,
-0.0127921058,
-0.0039518983,
-0.0020176319,
-0.0704636201,
-0.0352382436,
0.0066536558,
0.0272925626,
0.0437074043,
0.053217832,
-0.0059162723,
-0.0174941681,
-0.0057914103,
-0.0423251502,
-0.0092402091,
-0.0127236601,
0.0047428235,
-0.0290002488,
0.011396125,
0.0112513071,
-0.0320137218,
-0.0456929542,
-0.0246509332,
-0.0359552838,
0.0280089956,
0.0079035619,
0.0693961829,
0.0076033268,
-0.056053523,
-0.0252683833,
-0.0138407638,
-0.0018037123,
-0.0216108412,
-0.011280369,
-0.0456741415,
0.0565848053,
-0.0190762673,
0.0486826636,
-0.0225222744,
-0.0097950166,
0.0241811126,
-0.0393387824,
0.0721696094,
0.0980943516,
0.0140119269,
0.0234337244,
0.0535360463,
0.0172796994,
-0.083696954,
-0.0003683435,
-0.0582325496,
-0.0389357544,
-0.0495855659,
-0.0008863421,
-0.0083274562,
0.079093717,
-0.0060306718,
-0.028943928,
-0.056549076,
-0.0084042642,
-0.0361532792,
-0.0450391248,
-0.0350933522,
-0.0015116213,
-0.0328608006,
0.0461750925,
-0.0009528687,
-0.0546322912,
0.0990052074,
-0.0206609536,
0.0029078436,
-0.0310586002,
0.0213081259,
-0.0153293991,
0.0096452786,
0.024098631,
-0.0055689043,
0.0136627164,
0.0042741043,
-0.080726549,
-0.027593866,
0.047375828,
-0.0161025207,
0.0615120083,
-0.0699720085,
0.0377322584,
-0.011606805,
-0.0750235319,
-0.0185136572,
-0.0693669468,
-0.0289882515,
-0.0051061865,
0.0082587907,
-0.0228217021,
0.0087241186,
0.0026018552,
0.0260991454,
0.0157989338,
0.023294935,
-0.0263767373,
-0.0049503897,
0.0437406749,
0.0577954128,
0.0229658131,
-0.0224375483,
-0.056827832,
-0.0421173237,
0.029324282,
0.019885214,
0.0400836542,
-0.0261136387,
0.0201857165,
0.0471982807,
0.0047926642,
-0.0486766621,
0.020265542,
0.0483398624,
0.0127952183,
0.0127511406,
0.0782651827,
0.0087876925,
-0.0894442499,
0.0175919048,
0.0325396098,
0.0444436297,
0.0134937447,
0.0364775248,
-0.0708725229,
0.0049076732,
-0.0146743655,
0.0416255333,
-0.0024884045,
-0.0220024679,
0.0115709705,
-0.1386537701,
-0.0032285249,
0.0049557458,
-0.0280517433,
0.0564818643,
-0.0467063114,
0.0272544883,
-0.0624284409,
0.0028788312,
-0.0190848168,
0.0245944969,
0.0186036974,
0.0653200373,
0.0153104449,
-0.0278396271,
0.0304864794,
-0.0386608057,
0.057394255,
0.1129798591,
0.0294783711,
-0.0105446978,
-0.0124000972,
-0.0000467668,
-0.0006562075,
-0.0285038929,
-0.0127001842,
0.0066991155,
-0.0328781307,
-0.0010975626,
0.0073890365,
0.0650117919,
-0.0215356927,
-0.0032341459,
-0.0253438298,
0.0568129607,
0.008938157,
-0.0080394205,
-0.0041260635,
0.0021920316,
0.0253371876,
0.0428088307,
0.002157229,
-0.1043171138,
0.0273030531,
-0.0295014922,
-0.0277795196,
-0.0217577387,
-0.0648453608,
-0.0006761653,
0.0099223005,
-0.0228187963,
-0.0731228292,
-0.0081967637,
0.0075002345,
0.0432124659,
0.0027867663,
0.0250061434,
-0.0011408299,
-0.0006436588,
0.0443188399,
0.0160574783,
-0.0287319031,
0.0075599221,
-0.0502842292,
-0.0822968706,
0.051439032,
-0.0160429366,
-0.0327666067,
0.0022899127,
-0.030287398,
-0.0675458461,
-0.047691144,
0.0797255263,
0.0227928329,
0.0575598404,
0.0004906913,
-0.0769616514,
0.0136289764,
0.0481290817,
-0.013869008,
0.0153990723,
0.0180602521,
0.0544011109,
-0.0137283094,
0.0415739901,
-0.0155139053,
0.0088538704,
0.0130716814,
0.0272880308,
-0.0553145558,
-0.0540410914,
0.0370307192,
-0.0224535875,
0.0375654548,
-0.05398288,
0.0108076939,
-0.0416559502,
-0.0177395027,
-0.0055545033,
-0.0342782699,
-0.0397782214,
-0.0404760055,
0.0512531437,
-0.0091381799,
-0.0406835228,
-0.0558786951,
0.0365960337,
0.0561272167,
-0.0381476991,
0.0136534367,
0.0980548561,
0.0090176854,
0.0401240587,
0.0303538926,
0.0260999165,
-0.0082534766,
0.0091538057,
0.0681313947,
0.0225435812,
0.0490076877,
0.022564996,
-0.0001490208,
0.015402209,
-0.0361993052,
-0.0352119915,
-0.0227612946,
-0.0349254385,
0.0070288731,
0.033428058,
-0.0204007439,
0.05251256,
-0.0172210019,
-0.003508175,
-0.0443867967,
0.0299003776,
-0.0402149558,
-0.0022944019,
0.0083439229,
0.0308382995,
-0.0123055559,
0.0272154473,
0.1152250245,
0.0053802538,
0.0235815402,
-0.0429740138,
0.0112756966,
-0.0468525887,
0.0080636796,
-0.000147168,
0.0360983908,
-0.0320051275,
0.0362676419,
-0.0571143925,
-0.0790465921,
-0.0348027796,
0.0201404523,
0.0284856409,
-0.0058795321,
0.0355855636,
0.0643002391,
-0.0684391707,
0.0071142344,
-0.0755973756,
-0.0040328219,
-0.0272826701,
-0.0043759369,
-0.0233150162,
-6.25948097e-33,
-0.0527929738,
-0.0167013835,
0.0081137847,
0.0121308481,
0.0003127899,
-0.0202016961,
-0.007594971,
0.0279137846,
-0.0010790937,
0.0053181527,
-0.0135404309,
-0.0222552773,
0.0067309584,
-0.003293518,
0.0542737357,
-0.0064618024,
0.0513514727,
-0.0335818827,
-0.0387293585,
0.0009704059,
0.048962675,
-0.0256066471,
0.0372665673,
-0.0558436885,
0.0435962267,
0.0390242487,
-0.0207570698,
0.0402809046,
-0.0236497484,
0.0766449347,
-0.0340418033,
0.0363333747,
-0.0084973006,
-0.022118954,
-0.0292124692,
-0.0033393539,
-0.065366067,
-0.0168546308,
0.0178338941,
0.0121567622,
-0.0176308434,
-0.0192906577,
0.0420681089,
-0.0102734007,
-0.0185540542,
0.0220305901,
0.0437224619,
-0.0278740209,
-0.0433255322,
0.0317141227,
-0.031826321,
0.0262023732,
-0.0108127045,
-0.0098307012,
0.0385978743,
0.0084337322,
-0.0084097208,
0.0021020647,
-0.0119861029,
0.0530473292,
0.0171199087,
0.0109815411,
0.0287760217,
0.027957119,
0.0244218931,
0.0374630466,
0.0397320203,
-0.006988816,
0.0428317599,
-0.0562260672,
0.0343866237,
0.0200881232,
-0.0239675585,
0.0562660694,
0.0011688157,
0.0013547085,
-0.0174744595,
0.0368376449,
0.0274022054,
-0.0379996821,
0.0549162477,
0.0547431074,
-0.0399861485,
-0.0602184348,
-0.029820513,
-0.0610995293,
-0.0121862618,
-0.022323966,
-0.0052569089,
0.0422612093,
-0.0307443235,
0.0109796477,
0.0575274043,
-0.0537038185,
-0.0687150583,
-0.0247083846,
-0.0420700647,
0.0509483106,
0.0020549907,
-0.0222925022,
-0.0991012529,
-0.0191913806,
-0.0351061635,
-0.0034550659,
-0.0190638844,
0.0356144011,
0.0590815023,
0.0094531849,
-0.0246251132,
-0.0249793772,
-0.0100109065,
-0.038584929,
0.0057773138,
0.0144096725,
0.0565646067,
0.0062133451,
-0.0072796005,
0.0268085115,
-0.0129411751,
-0.0187350158,
-0.0171109885,
-0.0064217225,
-0.0326079242,
-0.0015682809,
-0.031172676,
-0.0159630161,
0.0159229282,
-0.0272104349,
0.0266447011,
0.0011310951,
-0.0256959703,
-0.0125496248,
2.516e-7,
0.0422839113,
0.0145605011,
0.0043704784,
-0.047758393,
0.0126567166,
0.0475740172,
-0.0193207916,
-0.0076519297,
0.0457849205,
-0.0292614549,
0.0377664529,
0.0293725468,
0.0165340435,
0.0006339067,
-0.0857294276,
-0.0082426704,
-0.0235708263,
0.0301046316,
-0.0050633764,
-0.0415194742,
0.0085205035,
0.0632391348,
0.0330973566,
-0.0076481816,
0.017737899,
0.049093876,
0.1001975089,
-0.0550016277,
-0.0051124962,
0.0134535795,
-0.0189375971,
-0.0280668419,
-0.0063813068,
0.0186360925,
-0.0029363935,
0.0085237548,
0.0191832893,
0.0687584728,
0.0155056296,
-0.0333960913,
-0.0090480959,
0.0182894245,
0.0147124911,
-0.042790819,
0.0432460234,
-0.0513916165,
-0.0592731796,
-0.0111155622,
0.0057660989,
-0.0064050634,
-0.0048122914,
0.003289849,
-0.0190999676,
-0.0052809934,
0.0110644381,
0.0149589917,
-0.009448709,
-0.0272954516,
0.0092045069,
0.0172235649,
-0.0732604712,
-0.0890351906,
-0.0133661069,
0.0203313082,
-0.0376740731,
-0.0149150137,
0.0017148474,
1.898271504e-34,
0.0540363006,
0.0264820717,
0.0211628117,
-0.0174002647,
0.0145947682,
0.0090860808,
-0.0193222724,
0.0155032156,
0.0750475898,
-0.0747239664,
-0.0211656708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14096v2 | Cultural Bias and Cultural Alignment of Large Language Models | 2023-11-23T16:45:56 | 2024-06-26T15:26:44 | Yan Tao, Olga Viberg, Ryan S. Baker, Rene F. Kizilcec | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Culture fundamentally shapes people's reasoning, behavior, and communication.
As people increasingly use generative artificial intelligence (AI) to expedite
and automate personal and professional tasks, cultural values embedded in AI
models may bias people's authentic expression and contribute to the dominance
of certain cultures. We conduct a disaggregated evaluation of cultural bias for
five widely used large language models (OpenAI's GPT-4o/4-turbo/4/3.5-turbo/3)
by comparing the models' responses to nationally representative survey data.
All models exhibit cultural values resembling English-speaking and Protestant
European countries. We test cultural prompting as a control strategy to
increase cultural alignment for each country/territory. For recent models
(GPT-4, 4-turbo, 4o), this improves the cultural alignment of the models'
output for 71-81% of countries and territories. We suggest using cultural
prompting and ongoing evaluation to reduce cultural bias in the output of
generative AI. | [
0.0150163183,
0.0949385986,
-0.0500326417,
-0.0103473859,
-0.0297501963,
0.0192635581,
0.0526513569,
-0.0397234447,
0.0243176911,
0.0383797772,
0.0040664258,
-0.0398925915,
0.0057595726,
0.0401751474,
0.0132203288,
-0.0409890078,
0.0343812928,
0.025833942,
0.0554847755,
-0.037090607,
-0.0113484664,
0.0505956486,
0.0307354275,
0.0751406476,
-0.0231646039,
-0.0150284786,
0.0381477512,
-0.0232906286,
0.0478637181,
0.0039689913,
0.0058781966,
0.0212064199,
-0.0053185569,
0.0049572312,
0.0000020862,
-0.0749097466,
0.0331819504,
-0.0132838143,
0.0123947365,
0.0420218073,
0.1008468866,
0.0377564393,
-0.0502477475,
0.0279278867,
-0.0811150968,
-0.012882581,
0.0435305573,
0.0311414115,
-0.0211456567,
0.0249844939,
-0.0055384636,
-0.0286064614,
-0.0312228315,
-0.0062418431,
-0.0699294433,
0.0030058259,
0.0340005085,
0.0481124781,
-0.0328863375,
-0.0134771625,
-0.0141293453,
0.0180745702,
0.0041639134,
-0.0092881816,
-0.0532130972,
0.0169716273,
-0.0296039525,
-0.0390641689,
0.0341536254,
0.0249643736,
0.074350208,
-0.0037564642,
0.0030157843,
-0.0149442721,
0.0236236062,
0.0079090046,
-0.0137779051,
0.0530993007,
0.0181578863,
0.0167197231,
0.0506741218,
0.0030677826,
-0.0125922635,
0.0308757015,
-0.008092205,
0.0846711025,
0.0005771726,
-0.0168973766,
-0.0244102199,
0.002289363,
-0.0139665715,
-0.0586416535,
0.0049388031,
0.0066304542,
-0.0005072223,
0.0082240915,
-0.0096455244,
0.0317918062,
-0.0042970371,
-0.0288994722,
0.0009563606,
0.0711690113,
-0.0161961578,
-0.0240914449,
0.0410694331,
0.062575005,
-0.0280623976,
-0.0079908976,
-0.0515557379,
-0.0182660017,
-0.0395500846,
0.0007486359,
0.024430912,
-0.0445150845,
-0.0073701078,
0.0013044265,
-0.0816638619,
0.0210856199,
-0.0655654296,
0.0288798828,
-0.0076306709,
-0.02468336,
-0.0121493619,
0.0130534088,
-0.0375772156,
0.0749908686,
-0.0813726112,
0.0050341305,
-0.0306597464,
-0.0577639267,
0.0618804693,
0.0049475897,
-0.0160654243,
-0.0229364,
0.000581476,
-0.0120742032,
0.0126208467,
0.0327920839,
-0.0119092697,
0.0006803686,
-0.0058364146,
-0.0612093806,
0.0124736093,
-0.0442103632,
0.0240564533,
0.0115320301,
-0.0051770085,
-0.0702747703,
-0.0002430012,
0.010578501,
-0.0239631888,
-0.0089336755,
0.0033820893,
0.0605152994,
0.0575174578,
-0.0001475736,
-0.0242300816,
0.0523557998,
0.0262021162,
0.0145797031,
0.0371541493,
-0.0324514955,
0.0251677725,
0.0277823359,
-0.0143601419,
0.0193637405,
-0.023206763,
-0.0024258832,
0.0070102215,
-0.010761966,
0.0750860348,
0.0497742333,
0.0033739023,
0.0496123657,
0.0315970257,
0.0552044362,
-0.0207234155,
0.0384780467,
0.0348716602,
0.0204017311,
-0.0278822612,
-0.0009626883,
-0.0452099629,
-0.0029090254,
-0.0133953979,
0.0156709272,
-0.0232763533,
0.072404176,
-0.0397308096,
-0.0332375541,
-0.0028519055,
0.0147431875,
0.0499846004,
0.035517998,
0.0088488702,
-0.0379184596,
0.0280598085,
-0.0379226729,
0.0186527204,
-0.0709222928,
-0.04763427,
-0.0466958322,
0.0488236547,
0.0739545524,
-0.0206855722,
0.0233161505,
0.0286426619,
0.0038719478,
0.005648294,
0.0542508923,
0.0646545887,
-0.0118361656,
-0.0336884595,
-0.0364452451,
-0.0124982959,
0.0004773401,
-0.0333642438,
0.0127885919,
0.0359494425,
0.0653791279,
0.0053229663,
0.0144716082,
-0.0261057504,
-0.0201913938,
-0.0450098962,
0.0015045987,
-0.0388525464,
0.0154587952,
0.029115025,
0.036611326,
-0.0305824224,
-0.0052513168,
-0.0345963798,
-0.0143868793,
0.0052123447,
0.0364127867,
-0.0576473176,
0.0594036281,
0.0207607299,
-0.033241339,
-0.016472945,
0.0122279711,
0.0090375002,
-0.0019697587,
0.0202772468,
0.038004607,
0.0161979813,
-0.0246548187,
-0.0035697755,
-0.0390651487,
0.0226482209,
-0.0059858365,
0.0450048596,
-0.0254455041,
-0.0254866574,
0.0038545707,
0.0156034445,
0.0364275165,
-0.0197156947,
-0.0347515941,
0.0466930531,
-0.0055772997,
0.0130923484,
0.0443357043,
0.0086363228,
-0.0205940846,
-0.0096812826,
-0.1067008823,
-0.0392256007,
0.0073978938,
-0.0097798295,
-0.0049284096,
0.0041249446,
-0.0343244784,
0.0260523595,
-0.1045197025,
-0.0015426754,
0.0472603813,
0.048561316,
0.0120389964,
-0.0248950124,
-0.010663257,
0.0028750426,
-0.0127760461,
-0.0197741706,
-0.0184338707,
-0.0069123912,
-0.0047598556,
-0.0491879098,
-0.0130754001,
-0.0598350316,
-0.0019288444,
-0.0188075881,
-0.0607633404,
0.0140840448,
0.0306758694,
0.0888522714,
0.0548861101,
0.0150775015,
0.0004068195,
0.05451487,
0.0361836627,
-0.0397810936,
-0.0215671416,
0.0033241718,
-0.0017960873,
0.0228068531,
-0.1208394319,
-0.0161851142,
0.0456493199,
0.0185113493,
0.0144508807,
-0.0261889994,
0.0749036446,
-0.0678973794,
-0.0527690575,
0.027329864,
-0.0271417666,
-0.0059329169,
0.0805219337,
-0.022217555,
-0.0295040663,
0.0137771517,
0.0407648273,
0.0147247231,
-0.0004152612,
-0.0096336873,
-0.0033631728,
0.0314334482,
-0.0115797445,
0.0431458838,
0.0302917771,
-0.0091828508,
-0.0423442163,
-0.0115813054,
0.0175921787,
-0.0429203659,
0.0247742739,
-0.0142976306,
-0.0351980142,
-0.0207976606,
-0.0426497385,
-0.0361051336,
0.012499162,
-0.0187012404,
0.0200880375,
0.0528503731,
-0.0211136304,
0.0339272469,
-0.0179645885,
0.070750542,
0.0068845791,
-0.0113182012,
0.0282528736,
0.0116940644,
-0.0613616705,
0.0622427873,
0.0345970206,
-0.0012273253,
-0.0152604142,
0.0074967789,
-0.0120343594,
0.0399312712,
-0.0059668156,
-0.0105558299,
-0.0094005242,
0.0469548032,
0.0045224181,
-0.0237519145,
0.0362875238,
0.0585622005,
0.0064087114,
0.0348409154,
0.0784168914,
-0.0086382022,
-0.0294313356,
-0.0015932742,
-0.0563801005,
-0.0009470864,
0.0294293351,
0.066517517,
-0.0926107094,
0.0581922792,
-0.0018931152,
-0.0026926498,
-0.0692376271,
0.0039161076,
0.0062132161,
-0.1145813912,
0.0391964354,
0.02261067,
-0.0525263362,
-0.0324837379,
0.0354789719,
-0.0227025636,
-0.0135416836,
0.0358208939,
-0.024856437,
0.0264016166,
-0.0341880955,
-0.0168045685,
-0.0561929345,
-0.0762781724,
0.0333195701,
-0.0421513282,
0.0603914447,
0.0791169703,
0.0513986051,
0.0159706902,
-0.0737541392,
-0.0215705037,
0.0406161435,
0.0165469851,
0.0037580875,
-0.0066729654,
0.0021538173,
-0.0109017966,
-0.0315057226,
-0.009954242,
0.0138344392,
-0.0036846935,
0.0320422575,
0.0451346114,
-0.0052927523,
-0.0415647589,
-0.0270145815,
0.0111877713,
0.0117929634,
0.0503866114,
-0.0060738637,
-0.0677305385,
0.0068413005,
-0.0275905225,
-0.0144620575,
0.0094497362,
-0.0606814325,
0.0252616424,
-0.0162976217,
-0.0675760806,
-0.0325307734,
-0.0717411786,
-0.009330905,
0.0105512943,
0.0366920941,
-0.0673439205,
0.0252318066,
0.0064378539,
0.0052566812,
-0.01307391,
-0.0480843633,
0.0145485513,
-0.0096230479,
-0.034849856,
-0.0058811582,
-0.0411328971,
0.0180183444,
-0.004782774,
0.005262102,
-0.0247193985,
0.0614822395,
0.0540241711,
0.0237604976,
0.0017754589,
0.0404927284,
-0.0168270189,
0.0052559637,
-0.0108345198,
0.0025437719,
0.0159414914,
-0.0029373558,
0.0389169715,
0.0018410541,
0.0039303415,
-0.026825035,
0.0693794563,
0.0226917658,
0.018260356,
-0.0521561876,
-0.0027774398,
0.0165541396,
0.0477289222,
0.0002021627,
-0.0304181688,
0.0088962801,
-0.0499127693,
-0.0552916378,
-0.0621950328,
-0.0332963131,
-0.0072967433,
-0.0468793884,
0.0426072031,
0.0042070854,
0.0391954593,
-0.0148139233,
-0.0115568619,
-0.0441861786,
-0.0652199835,
0.0314328372,
0.006229423,
0.1081040055,
-0.0087183081,
0.0251410063,
-0.0391777456,
0.0377470963,
0.021347858,
0.0433631502,
0.0112308692,
0.1243302077,
-0.0028533076,
0.0106348321,
0.0191478599,
0.0150522124,
-0.0308747999,
-0.0565843359,
0.0215894114,
0.0078411875,
0.0415350795,
-0.0556567311,
0.0373815782,
0.0041735861,
0.0050151381,
-0.007695355,
0.0214213058,
0.0457932241,
-0.0590713732,
-0.0211450402,
-0.0228388049,
-0.0402219333,
-0.0345871076,
0.0257139876,
-0.0300707221,
-0.0191977024,
-0.0283853523,
-0.0383340716,
-0.0200169329,
-0.0367600098,
0.0322966985,
-0.0276970062,
-0.0401366651,
-0.0093944604,
-0.0763885081,
-0.0544835925,
-0.0701430216,
0.0063647996,
-0.0111357896,
-0.0500672646,
-0.0068055945,
0.0603410713,
-0.0390208773,
-0.0546253771,
-0.0426803306,
0.0011751138,
-0.063626796,
0.0052592582,
-0.0108914059,
-6.312916739e-33,
-0.0159361586,
-0.0028514552,
0.0301242508,
-0.0178488381,
-0.017435085,
-0.0302092545,
-0.0134573616,
0.0302169397,
-0.0733460411,
0.0258074924,
-0.0431118608,
-0.0045695934,
0.0134080909,
-0.0285224468,
0.0474781357,
0.028088076,
0.013428974,
0.0113236057,
-0.0118730413,
0.0067567551,
0.0142176896,
-0.0208433587,
0.0519416817,
-0.081580013,
0.0404211208,
0.0049618781,
-0.0089300508,
-0.0299648643,
0.0263664685,
0.0119481748,
-0.0264288802,
0.0334531479,
0.0190294646,
-0.0409625508,
-0.0183690749,
0.04065625,
-0.0146063175,
-0.0458216406,
0.0235101972,
0.0051857298,
0.0351478979,
-0.0827593058,
-0.006264966,
-0.014072503,
-0.0904474854,
0.0358233415,
0.0445405431,
-0.0104231481,
0.0156377647,
-0.0024863649,
-0.0856979936,
-0.0031990174,
0.0131942648,
0.0495070107,
-0.0273621157,
0.0706289858,
-0.0222751349,
-0.0196685307,
-0.03692545,
0.0221407469,
0.0226611886,
-0.0070209783,
0.0745397359,
0.0068049552,
0.0169459675,
0.013154407,
0.0594122559,
0.0761781484,
-0.0647542402,
-0.0459457822,
0.0426861383,
-0.0008549481,
0.005578184,
0.0711556971,
-0.0071552163,
-0.0583986491,
-0.0019995829,
0.0004796256,
0.0609087758,
-0.0185003597,
0.0392476022,
0.0071987519,
-0.0626281872,
-0.0325247087,
0.0162575375,
-0.0181232672,
-0.0151234651,
-0.0389898904,
0.0308858287,
-0.0245514829,
0.0172256418,
-0.0235878434,
0.0534350835,
-0.050138846,
0.0075730109,
-0.0046212231,
-0.0304415207,
-0.0116877081,
0.0053665801,
-0.008049747,
-0.0611018352,
-0.0168859214,
-0.0454034247,
0.0433917046,
0.0178258698,
0.0704856217,
-0.0233271793,
-0.0098823672,
-0.0597188249,
-0.0120198941,
-0.0165984221,
-0.0010957702,
0.0203682818,
-0.049566146,
0.0568846166,
0.0008391685,
0.0238779746,
-0.0462912582,
0.0473216586,
-0.0161947366,
-0.0345547721,
-0.0748212785,
-0.0144035444,
0.0096575161,
-0.0543200821,
0.0168102756,
-0.041516684,
0.0678550526,
0.0270423014,
-0.0220864341,
-0.034338966,
-0.0131628271,
2.813e-7,
-0.0139655415,
0.0322500281,
-0.023432726,
0.0678706914,
-0.0030889795,
0.0081325881,
0.0163295921,
-0.0010667562,
0.0361425765,
0.0199419986,
0.040857777,
-0.0058002374,
0.0382701792,
0.0237431955,
-0.0648469403,
0.0096086198,
-0.0377201922,
0.0400461555,
-0.0406811312,
0.0530708022,
0.002578639,
0.0450912938,
0.0128844045,
0.0036870395,
-0.0322352275,
0.0207221638,
0.0292641073,
-0.0425498188,
0.004969676,
-0.0038708611,
-0.0072425534,
-0.0161328036,
0.0094270734,
0.0194088779,
0.0117117567,
0.0081778727,
0.0280541517,
0.0912658274,
-0.0127815539,
0.0515382215,
0.0115904901,
-0.0023650071,
-0.0013310564,
-0.0798425227,
0.0290556774,
-0.0081279324,
-0.0304531418,
-0.043442782,
-0.0050134519,
-0.0165570546,
0.0272455793,
0.0054973336,
0.0057759243,
0.0139403036,
0.0230193343,
-0.0038782712,
0.0114899985,
-0.0071862857,
0.0031823048,
-0.02727695,
0.0056389757,
-0.0590884238,
0.0030754854,
0.0165713727,
0.0051230076,
0.0347081758,
0.0187196489,
2.41786354e-34,
0.0142720863,
-0.0097427908,
0.021519728,
-0.0095138075,
0.0670631751,
0.0285288971,
0.0284915306,
0.013666071,
0.0173853617,
-0.0112261223,
-0.0366826355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14087v1 | Question Answering in Natural Language: the Special Case of Temporal Expressions | 2023-11-23T16:26:24 | 2023-11-23T16:26:24 | Armand Stricker | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although general question answering has been well explored in recent years,
temporal question answering is a task which has not received as much focus. Our
work aims to leverage a popular approach used for general question answering,
answer extraction, in order to find answers to temporal questions within a
paragraph. To train our model, we propose a new dataset, inspired by SQuAD,
specifically tailored to provide rich temporal information. We chose to adapt
the corpus WikiWars, which contains several documents on history's greatest
conflicts. Our evaluation shows that a deep learning model trained to perform
pattern matching, often used in general question answering, can be adapted to
temporal question answering, if we accept to ask questions whose answers must
be directly present within a text. | [
0.0464669056,
0.083722353,
0.0116781462,
0.0247779507,
-0.0570900217,
0.0041502663,
0.0288252197,
0.0262930095,
-0.0114574526,
-0.019978255,
0.0377370641,
-0.047131557,
-0.0181142241,
-0.0099914251,
-0.0271276981,
-0.0188027993,
0.0422505476,
0.016497178,
-0.0013978421,
0.0310150553,
-0.0151659809,
0.0110777216,
-0.0315275043,
0.019896606,
-0.0211222116,
-0.0520827696,
-0.0258669835,
-0.0259545241,
0.0409172215,
-0.0221552625,
0.0547342189,
-0.0045825955,
0.0299879238,
0.0144248409,
0.0000017144,
-0.0179023966,
-0.0092822984,
-0.0186146628,
-0.0380300544,
0.0264937989,
-0.0184955858,
0.0200783554,
0.0280001815,
-0.0106255366,
-0.0678683594,
0.0007066907,
-0.013845331,
0.0687894002,
0.0459405519,
0.0814114287,
0.0067855818,
-0.0010947369,
0.0627819076,
0.0101263877,
0.0306058098,
-0.057935033,
0.0183236897,
-0.0383254513,
0.0217548721,
-0.0207973924,
0.0268232822,
0.0267707631,
0.027890861,
0.0112710278,
-0.0031827681,
0.022191193,
-0.0300973691,
0.0576482043,
-0.0323898159,
0.0525855348,
0.0385763235,
-0.0339105316,
0.003947401,
0.0282025337,
-0.0229464229,
0.0015169941,
-0.0357274637,
-0.0224722773,
0.0046776272,
-0.0100053269,
0.0282478184,
0.0232226755,
0.0003039088,
0.0231101103,
-0.0156176016,
0.1013397276,
0.0064623374,
-0.0130934985,
-0.0634593591,
-0.0353945903,
0.0184205361,
-0.0612539724,
0.0296078175,
0.0861527845,
0.001675163,
-0.0102706086,
-0.0165010616,
-0.0161189623,
0.0128161507,
-0.0593266562,
-0.0387384035,
-0.0033458788,
-0.0033049693,
0.0662739575,
-0.0062219114,
0.0511237197,
-0.0379461385,
-0.012555087,
-0.0289262366,
-0.0324977748,
-0.0599789508,
-0.0311319921,
-0.0255983416,
0.0275916811,
-0.0008186112,
-0.0261785686,
-0.0068807434,
0.0018903645,
0.0228828602,
-0.0091289505,
-0.030747842,
0.0555510595,
-0.0418451354,
0.0005184554,
-0.0562247634,
0.03433422,
-0.0649544522,
0.0165841524,
-0.0233829804,
-0.0431375541,
-0.0158565938,
-0.0085873036,
0.0440882295,
-0.0423345603,
0.0266221073,
0.0520053804,
-0.0275445729,
-0.0039221407,
-0.0346797705,
-0.0219921265,
0.0147170769,
0.0136495167,
-0.0159949027,
-0.0672037825,
0.0587884933,
-0.0090411389,
-0.0466682836,
-0.0165736694,
0.0141368462,
0.0351616405,
-0.0254246686,
0.0661373213,
0.0146597838,
0.011182596,
0.0473815724,
0.0072285049,
0.0609340109,
0.0068594655,
0.0513848737,
-0.0045372136,
0.0503522269,
0.024293188,
0.0052099125,
0.0248491205,
0.0206610598,
-0.0202307366,
-0.0532192849,
0.0588864237,
0.0150266839,
0.0289472267,
-0.0009051199,
0.0025584539,
0.0007167498,
-0.071184136,
0.0376395397,
0.0316734016,
-0.022999065,
-0.0204943325,
0.0403631032,
0.0026727489,
0.0308535323,
-0.0038217371,
0.0179935656,
-0.0036045332,
-0.0016690439,
0.0014235184,
-0.0336987674,
0.0167637374,
-0.0307267904,
-0.0124026733,
-0.0106951641,
-0.0015936438,
-0.0193309747,
0.0422506519,
0.0281897765,
-0.0079883849,
-0.0273382198,
0.0923721939,
0.0218586996,
-0.0158437695,
0.006385555,
-0.0218576249,
0.0466063581,
0.0345669016,
0.0486878455,
-0.0570248179,
-0.0649947003,
-0.0347722396,
0.0346975289,
0.0189081263,
0.0550884344,
-0.0476244651,
0.0464087799,
-0.0192764103,
-0.0087515563,
-0.0129480241,
-0.0100238537,
-0.0121398671,
0.0356705375,
0.0371513553,
0.0117172804,
-0.0343507528,
-0.0048497189,
0.0575054064,
-0.00852348,
-0.0652414784,
-0.0180996843,
0.0262655932,
0.0123295402,
0.0303650629,
-0.0112398714,
-0.003341153,
0.056901399,
-0.0496411249,
-0.0125454077,
0.0178170633,
-0.0379768163,
-0.0383645818,
0.0388348587,
-0.0347375274,
-0.0336876437,
0.0536714457,
-0.0099027138,
-0.0428604297,
0.0214388911,
-0.0171009712,
0.038669005,
-0.0192877334,
-0.0276696086,
0.0074330294,
0.0185382348,
-0.0751158744,
0.0620337054,
0.0251144767,
-0.0085142115,
0.0051534208,
0.0029244833,
0.0143279657,
0.0095204785,
-0.0242592841,
0.0135658579,
-0.0158876069,
-0.0018510536,
0.0210523177,
-0.0155106718,
-0.0601813458,
-0.0144086713,
-0.0750042349,
0.0337198712,
-0.0162659101,
0.0087834802,
0.0343624763,
0.0013886052,
-0.0038063123,
-0.0367453545,
-0.049949456,
-0.0065222271,
0.0026545832,
0.0134435873,
0.0695386752,
0.047118295,
0.0247292481,
-0.0547293946,
-0.0257710814,
-0.0579500422,
0.0608662292,
-0.0004108607,
0.0126592079,
0.0159041509,
-0.0280180294,
-0.0249329265,
0.0445204787,
-0.0138615919,
-0.0228744037,
0.0197417215,
-0.041580718,
-0.0035114037,
0.0790991932,
0.041936934,
0.0163603686,
0.009745962,
-0.0155722182,
-0.0348927043,
0.0569750704,
-0.0282663759,
0.0309416577,
-0.0068860329,
-0.0061571561,
-0.0063532838,
0.0497010201,
0.0098955398,
0.0158556085,
-0.001611299,
0.0079558846,
0.0112850266,
0.0147006102,
-0.0286396965,
0.0034728691,
-0.0298312902,
0.0247916318,
-0.0288885999,
0.0100154746,
0.0393270515,
0.0249986965,
-0.0053498857,
-0.0311198626,
-0.038177561,
-0.0531819575,
0.0727893189,
0.0144818313,
-0.0118924333,
-0.0067308159,
-0.0398362987,
-0.0487342328,
-0.0270609986,
0.0119959302,
-0.0352011845,
0.0233264789,
-0.0112281833,
0.0127298823,
-0.0458814017,
0.0087453239,
-0.0647242218,
-0.101726681,
-0.0328110158,
-0.0005910636,
-0.0820740238,
0.0071354723,
-0.0448229052,
0.0079246843,
-0.0012839696,
0.0334228538,
-0.0385167301,
-0.0081136599,
-0.0434527658,
0.1067249328,
0.0950186327,
0.0456355289,
-0.0009626428,
0.0183913503,
-0.0020886073,
0.0335743092,
0.0830472037,
0.010688086,
-0.0636481196,
-0.0123886857,
0.0314465463,
-0.0552138761,
0.0298463423,
-0.0054473043,
0.024128966,
-0.0945271403,
0.00788402,
0.0893756747,
0.0623982809,
-0.0456472784,
-0.0095753465,
0.0016998858,
-0.0224944446,
0.0074736821,
0.0280480906,
-0.0420439541,
-0.0205575619,
-0.0249828063,
-0.0339574143,
-0.0123134134,
-0.049453117,
-0.0004452133,
-0.0856641755,
-0.0275592972,
-0.0318138935,
-0.0183206722,
0.0099778958,
-0.015168746,
0.0123349782,
0.0258771628,
-0.0008548495,
0.0143466275,
-0.0014215433,
-0.0014190645,
0.0191738419,
-0.0504746661,
-0.0182061624,
0.0734282807,
-0.0071969051,
0.0372555181,
0.0615272671,
0.0623156019,
-0.0285685938,
-0.0131997103,
0.0119846715,
-0.0270439088,
-0.0260813721,
0.0234583523,
0.0669898912,
-0.0097430507,
-0.0342818499,
-0.0074545015,
0.0385180637,
-0.0112044187,
-0.0122808423,
0.0398849435,
0.0744119659,
-0.0148022082,
0.015330703,
-0.0301757175,
-0.0063768043,
0.0261745863,
0.0495693423,
0.0047535682,
-0.0336435735,
-0.0835552663,
-0.0035711473,
0.0102340262,
-0.1114747748,
-0.0594845824,
-0.0146995783,
0.0293750465,
0.038055677,
-0.0955780074,
-0.053410355,
0.0072434526,
0.0118387062,
0.0038539739,
-0.0125305308,
-0.0126471221,
0.0164413378,
-0.0889995471,
0.0524459966,
-0.0103646135,
0.0092480872,
-0.0549044535,
-0.0134953558,
-0.0009529093,
-0.0154973501,
-0.0081398189,
0.0293786377,
-0.0788890347,
-0.0400001891,
-0.0061531621,
-0.0065428279,
0.0105387401,
0.0425907895,
-0.0243689194,
0.0048193545,
0.0612503961,
0.011597327,
-0.0163880847,
-0.0315084048,
-0.0051108347,
-0.0055131502,
-0.0238874778,
0.023342438,
-0.0427278168,
-0.0038838994,
-0.0233500935,
0.0105790338,
-0.0301304646,
-0.0018245276,
0.0231641103,
-0.0363566987,
0.0146524347,
0.0423372276,
-0.0196322948,
-0.0175692495,
-0.0105507039,
-0.0132872695,
0.0125771696,
0.0097936764,
0.0203678217,
-0.0119821085,
-0.0368731432,
-0.0263046287,
0.0324912705,
0.0163613483,
0.0299136974,
-0.0387058258,
0.0113540823,
0.0651382282,
0.022983063,
-0.0300637614,
0.0017369486,
-0.0210282318,
-0.0039160615,
-0.0238551348,
0.0447969511,
0.010944129,
-0.0074757929,
0.009034276,
-0.002223901,
-0.0157501362,
-0.0032045781,
-0.1352641582,
-0.0181290619,
0.0054737949,
-0.0068137874,
0.0567402057,
-0.0668277815,
0.0333710425,
0.0231895428,
-0.0209144503,
-0.0004778374,
-0.0282735806,
0.0135369543,
0.04243242,
0.0472423621,
0.0426910333,
-0.0152604068,
0.040184658,
0.0436096713,
0.0070014331,
0.0616287626,
0.0817373022,
-0.0277376045,
-0.0156796128,
-0.0052114474,
-0.034156017,
0.0080299228,
-0.03278457,
-0.0019983321,
-0.0202490129,
-0.019314969,
0.0496835858,
0.0079835495,
-0.0082425755,
-0.0006259122,
0.0117796184,
0.0505167432,
0.077517204,
-0.0367156304,
-0.0545137599,
0.1138134003,
-0.0055596279,
-0.0228789654,
-0.0514612831,
-6.056642807e-33,
-0.0119443024,
-0.0332304314,
0.0210013073,
-0.0108453864,
-0.0535634197,
0.0472490303,
-0.0226023942,
-0.0367565267,
-0.0891706422,
-0.0052390425,
-0.0377428047,
0.0210090317,
0.0149886906,
0.0087988246,
0.0210453123,
-0.0356953591,
-0.0001082255,
-0.02774629,
0.0037707724,
0.0233267602,
0.0720099881,
0.0454786085,
0.051735159,
-0.0060999719,
-0.0132652801,
-0.0247762706,
0.0271698497,
0.0189269632,
0.0220589787,
0.0622264557,
-0.0340509601,
0.0132385036,
0.0286802556,
-0.0120006343,
0.0079694372,
0.0514665022,
-0.1016239375,
-0.0401359126,
-0.0229321606,
-0.0005338536,
-0.0419756882,
-0.0386746414,
-0.0041023972,
0.0044540106,
0.0630877838,
-0.0248120297,
0.0600251742,
-0.0295489877,
0.0146383597,
-0.0363793299,
-0.0486416481,
0.0337085128,
-0.0091203637,
-0.0274442639,
-0.0229187552,
0.0667784959,
0.0401881449,
0.0240370464,
-0.0643981546,
-0.0017950302,
-0.011908995,
0.049656231,
-0.0017325419,
0.007629504,
-0.021709675,
0.0338605084,
-0.0108997459,
-0.0057451376,
-0.0132164536,
0.024662476,
-0.0047006812,
0.0109435897,
0.037879467,
0.0376965404,
0.0607604571,
0.006203243,
-0.0621822514,
0.0191248879,
0.0567328595,
0.0465551876,
-0.0126944724,
-0.0367174745,
-0.0026988836,
0.0462528281,
0.01082695,
0.0349703431,
-0.0234218091,
0.0135761015,
0.0304257981,
-0.0038135182,
-0.00340233,
0.0316570327,
0.0217219312,
-0.0434112288,
0.042178452,
0.0617753938,
-0.0399898328,
0.0237775799,
0.019516658,
0.0350546166,
-0.0351279676,
0.0438450761,
-0.0095198592,
-0.0336631276,
0.0186307505,
0.0040837033,
-0.0036846618,
0.0139200976,
-0.0387577191,
-0.0299743395,
-0.0066917068,
0.0046001244,
-0.0284543131,
-0.003861815,
0.0189068988,
0.0174026359,
-0.0053802468,
0.0207106229,
-0.0074458281,
-0.0054832888,
-0.0119438618,
-0.0215821005,
0.0083925286,
0.0219156109,
-0.01491147,
0.0102097047,
-0.035647992,
0.1042662412,
-0.0414207168,
-0.035898108,
0.0011305214,
0.0139488587,
2.393e-7,
0.0367603749,
-0.0076924111,
0.0692179874,
0.0565774851,
-0.0134307705,
0.0027680097,
0.0275954846,
0.0394636057,
-0.0149387931,
0.0070600226,
0.0187291782,
0.0166769866,
0.0462724641,
0.0392728448,
-0.0473375656,
-0.0644859523,
-0.0830661878,
-0.0249518529,
-0.0758867636,
-0.0517416596,
0.0456072092,
0.077718921,
0.0437689014,
-0.0166474152,
-0.0385231338,
-0.0364021994,
0.0352364965,
0.0024026379,
-0.0434376225,
0.0433284044,
0.0207876228,
-0.0433628224,
-0.0273253042,
0.0387333743,
-0.0323485173,
0.0503267795,
-0.0079833902,
0.0377121158,
-0.0155201843,
-0.0718299374,
-0.0520553701,
-0.0423311442,
0.0019606859,
-0.0320419483,
0.1284507215,
-0.0070440038,
-0.0024724975,
-0.0429662876,
-0.0367366709,
0.031740468,
0.0257178899,
0.0051771649,
0.010901357,
0.0265209526,
-0.0004159427,
-0.0301748645,
0.0078095314,
-0.0696291476,
-0.0277857073,
0.0281382501,
-0.0496603325,
0.0180497188,
-0.0073648989,
-0.0191389397,
-0.0019505731,
-0.004418246,
0.0154250041,
1.78915119e-34,
-0.0068264101,
0.013285663,
-0.0295502972,
0.0451787785,
0.0155402059,
-0.024683984,
-0.0329323821,
-0.0345207155,
0.0411364362,
-0.0721895322,
-0.0122438194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14076v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14076v1 | Searching for Snippets of Open-Domain Dialogue in Task-Oriented Dialogue Datasets | 2023-11-23T16:08:39 | 2023-11-23T16:08:39 | Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing dialogue corpora and models have been designed to fit into 2
predominant categories : task-oriented dialogues portray functional goals, such
as making a restaurant reservation or booking a plane ticket, while
chit-chat/open-domain dialogues focus on holding a socially engaging talk with
a user. However, humans tend to seamlessly switch between modes and even use
chitchat to enhance task-oriented conversations. To bridge this gap, new
datasets have recently been created, blending both communication modes into
conversation examples. The approaches used tend to rely on adding chit-chat
snippets to pre-existing, human-generated task-oriented datasets. Given the
tendencies observed in humans, we wonder however if the latter do not
\textit{already} hold chit-chat sequences. By using topic modeling and
searching for topics which are most similar to a set of keywords related to
social talk, we explore the training sets of Schema-Guided Dialogues and
MultiWOZ. Our study shows that sequences related to social talk are indeed
naturally present, motivating further research on ways chitchat is combined
into task-oriented dialogues. | [
0.0658831671,
0.0088310679,
-0.0334429145,
0.0219878238,
-0.0236485172,
-0.0020113911,
-0.0259173457,
0.0027495774,
-0.0161663815,
-0.0208614618,
-0.0535534248,
-0.0290864334,
0.0126169864,
0.067978017,
0.0242826603,
-0.0364836082,
0.0487034693,
0.022618508,
0.0286235046,
0.0320844054,
0.0288432408,
-0.0095082391,
-0.0076484717,
0.0725899041,
-0.0057428731,
0.0027326148,
-0.0604783744,
-0.0000389392,
-0.0170917287,
0.0100343032,
0.0519753098,
0.0847811326,
0.0229424555,
-0.0116383154,
0.0000016401,
-0.0229628067,
0.0161735974,
-0.0605762415,
-0.0188800637,
-0.0143074347,
0.0611109734,
0.0440276414,
0.0047789775,
0.0388084501,
-0.0638091937,
0.0132208262,
0.0363390706,
0.0773350596,
0.0599423014,
0.1095983237,
-0.0159903485,
0.0283659883,
-0.0434355475,
-0.0356051065,
0.037139874,
-0.039554406,
-0.0123703191,
0.00630379,
0.0166144855,
0.0392810479,
0.0330594406,
0.0139605375,
-0.0411072336,
-0.0475350469,
0.0258869547,
0.0234296005,
-0.0531675741,
-0.0446458831,
-0.0165212322,
0.0849932283,
0.0102903675,
-0.0005906952,
0.034660995,
-0.001672543,
0.0372896157,
0.0051250421,
-0.0492187329,
-0.0076955911,
0.0017528129,
0.0124730766,
0.0106470063,
0.0000886977,
-0.0250786878,
-0.0129380887,
0.0183961708,
0.0233762804,
-0.0267952457,
-0.035113357,
0.0003414299,
-0.0410468727,
0.0190341678,
-0.0819229409,
0.0014435528,
-0.0037011036,
-0.0471845157,
0.0325735882,
-0.0356263369,
0.0135592828,
0.0336693525,
-0.0212798584,
0.0192593578,
0.0249799211,
-0.0250568036,
0.0097356699,
0.0795550123,
-0.0068837279,
0.0174367446,
-0.0012841197,
-0.0373231731,
0.0040573389,
-0.0632165447,
-0.0108683221,
-0.054311391,
0.0201130603,
-0.0684615001,
-0.0405817181,
-0.0214054827,
0.056884326,
0.0126226861,
-0.0262699742,
-0.0037923076,
0.0410739034,
-0.014831936,
0.0430575237,
-0.0304050017,
0.0040246709,
-0.023333298,
0.0216892157,
0.025251165,
-0.0411169901,
-0.0160285365,
0.0235696174,
0.0198798347,
-0.0202256478,
-0.0263334066,
0.0362473913,
-0.0008280696,
-0.0679215267,
0.030769363,
-0.0413683951,
-0.0520180762,
-0.0384478197,
0.0272483621,
-0.0070591606,
0.0274482444,
-0.0176400226,
-0.0292797573,
0.0091485139,
0.0172130764,
0.0702534169,
-0.0300459247,
0.0595050454,
-0.0392487794,
0.0190357454,
0.0325396024,
0.0291442778,
-0.017167123,
0.0811072215,
-0.0028861931,
0.010177739,
0.0741741955,
-0.0244945474,
-0.0031428277,
0.0272356104,
0.0145335728,
-0.0068012164,
0.053502731,
0.0541487262,
0.0325101055,
0.000187228,
0.0059433621,
0.0281284954,
-0.0496893823,
-0.0342976414,
0.0333089828,
0.1047195643,
0.0007743872,
0.0041962219,
-0.0029851904,
0.0865051821,
-0.0023532915,
0.0320978537,
-0.0039896001,
-0.0140245073,
-0.0311661381,
-0.0385363773,
0.0529030375,
-0.0091073439,
-0.0424081236,
-0.0333779417,
-0.0146284318,
-0.0040633166,
0.0387909934,
-0.0336336866,
0.0074988706,
0.0112120351,
-0.0390436836,
0.0179097876,
0.0286612436,
-0.0654153451,
-0.0681866482,
-0.0197728369,
0.0118222609,
0.0644183978,
0.0500923507,
-0.0334626399,
-0.0404121876,
-0.0145510621,
0.0292380881,
0.0460814312,
0.0570307598,
-0.0354993492,
0.0057942723,
-0.0266366377,
0.0155293727,
-0.0088011622,
0.0049690153,
-0.0267291181,
0.0194811188,
-0.0327486843,
0.0093100909,
0.023355227,
-0.0147391269,
-0.0060794353,
-0.005758991,
0.0353899784,
0.0126662338,
-0.0061291978,
0.0406337902,
0.0381960385,
-0.0003546017,
0.0054531074,
0.0240636598,
0.0116914166,
-0.0257951356,
0.0611033477,
-0.0545568243,
-0.0239219666,
0.0233070161,
0.0034991659,
-0.0174747594,
-0.003156194,
-0.0078929598,
-0.0404260159,
0.0281199627,
-0.0705003291,
0.0181336496,
-0.0294271503,
-0.0009209653,
0.0241559725,
0.03650444,
-0.0161437821,
0.0355687626,
0.00662325,
-0.0000071024,
0.0265303962,
-0.0538116656,
0.0173063576,
-0.0437852032,
0.0377786905,
0.0267566368,
-0.0291059464,
-0.0088846898,
0.0288124382,
0.0175040774,
-0.075090006,
-0.0302139875,
-0.1256313473,
-0.0032172017,
-0.0159462672,
0.0084396154,
0.0236949623,
0.0107849473,
-0.0135096787,
-0.0116161956,
-0.0540989861,
0.0245081522,
0.0411385931,
0.0150865633,
0.0605014749,
0.0120859379,
-0.0095313592,
-0.0630700514,
0.0140669839,
-0.0235276781,
0.0154851321,
-0.0150074586,
-0.0347421169,
-0.0220203027,
0.0516751558,
-0.0204439331,
0.0141235041,
-0.0346233733,
-0.0244377442,
0.0415881649,
0.0176558383,
0.0698244348,
0.0292829964,
0.0642582104,
0.0374085642,
-0.0345989354,
-0.0607832298,
-0.0351687446,
0.0061104312,
-0.0390106142,
0.0233021211,
-0.0554755069,
-0.0449824929,
0.0505905561,
0.0312254038,
-0.0148771489,
0.0386681743,
-0.0611266084,
0.0150944693,
0.038566146,
-0.0284231249,
-0.0229253024,
-0.0199018363,
-0.0133264838,
0.0351017863,
-0.0137931611,
-0.0447858311,
0.0357753374,
-0.0090371445,
-0.0171585716,
-0.0507967509,
-0.0283483732,
-0.0306794699,
0.0607621819,
-0.0455968156,
-0.0154102352,
0.0822416246,
-0.0536001436,
-0.0128737371,
-0.014067295,
-0.0077948687,
-0.0345426463,
0.0379584432,
-0.0164275039,
-0.0079029631,
0.0294644944,
-0.0382263437,
-0.0358013138,
-0.0593467839,
-0.0043618958,
-0.0128976991,
-0.0010681597,
-0.0338517353,
-0.0350541212,
0.0103766127,
-0.037281923,
0.0191289317,
-0.0160520971,
0.0113582676,
-0.0051487912,
0.0181107242,
0.0441662483,
0.0390431434,
-0.0453973785,
-0.0054112934,
0.0360511392,
0.0254537538,
0.0539997406,
-0.0314580128,
0.0498810373,
-0.0302264839,
0.0226196889,
-0.0103504695,
-0.040486712,
0.0123361098,
0.0541596822,
0.0010192293,
-0.0315922126,
0.1091377214,
0.025981918,
-0.0427964106,
-0.0013231908,
-0.0265447423,
0.0005310232,
0.0077285413,
0.0112528205,
-0.0793836862,
-0.041293662,
-0.0171513725,
-0.0090290252,
-0.0263136309,
-0.0321303457,
-0.0336740501,
-0.0983481631,
0.0241795946,
-0.0132491961,
-0.0380480997,
-0.0178656597,
-0.0170460623,
0.0130100902,
-0.0059277304,
-0.0092538605,
-0.014023656,
-0.0221395902,
-0.0034960671,
0.0106812827,
-0.0111189233,
-0.0510754064,
0.0268798396,
-0.0187126845,
0.0907846317,
0.0352025479,
0.0577571727,
0.0510730557,
0.0247315038,
0.0117655704,
0.0274353288,
0.0067015798,
-0.0122832656,
0.0834929943,
-0.0524800122,
0.0030548235,
-0.0228578132,
0.039188996,
-0.0429970361,
0.00443542,
0.0306786373,
0.0276729483,
-0.0553791225,
0.009645612,
-0.020318348,
0.0467991903,
0.0547978468,
0.0592020899,
0.0374435708,
-0.0343553796,
0.0235254839,
0.0030262026,
-0.0077722878,
-0.0075221234,
-0.0205223169,
-0.0484527126,
0.0026953544,
-0.035846509,
-0.072257705,
-0.0816662014,
0.0228046067,
-0.0098346379,
-0.0135013787,
0.0015159245,
0.0056763394,
0.0170382392,
-0.0436631478,
0.0027146649,
-0.0349231325,
-0.0062636547,
-0.0446628183,
-0.0559138954,
0.0153014492,
-0.0388396122,
-0.0026503857,
0.0098126875,
-0.1072408333,
-0.0604200438,
-0.0400852449,
0.0154585717,
0.0243676174,
0.0147190588,
0.0034135764,
-0.0131514827,
-0.0629744008,
0.0297038797,
-0.0556969941,
0.0131895058,
0.0329556353,
0.0142596904,
0.0082085757,
0.0365148634,
0.0276590437,
0.0203292053,
-0.0395476781,
0.0136248358,
-0.0221868698,
-0.0923687741,
-0.0038839278,
-0.0093089314,
0.0527342707,
0.0411118045,
-0.0363133997,
-0.0336602479,
0.0043154354,
-0.023141345,
-0.0120606339,
-0.0361463614,
-0.0116418023,
-0.0514167622,
-0.0086335689,
0.0117770955,
-0.0182324853,
-0.1154380366,
0.0721334144,
-0.0369815193,
0.0025958924,
0.0121686999,
-0.0050771511,
-0.0282825921,
-0.0038083836,
0.0258370508,
0.0311210863,
0.0113195768,
0.0190612506,
-0.0178922713,
0.0655098483,
0.0070432411,
-0.0227685235,
0.0646723732,
0.0604503155,
-0.0599365532,
-0.0331215449,
0.0009365619,
0.0354652442,
0.0092123384,
0.0062440499,
0.0526245348,
-0.0262958873,
0.0261214692,
-0.0130414851,
0.0618784316,
-0.0282199867,
-0.0345053822,
0.0159248356,
0.0218604729,
-0.0479562543,
-0.0206788536,
0.0855955333,
-0.0076449416,
0.0015596048,
0.0152413342,
-0.0380090065,
-0.0406595282,
-0.0257482175,
0.0518412516,
0.0354218259,
0.0036523014,
0.0095426152,
-0.0563384332,
-0.0253799912,
0.0153568098,
-0.0047649783,
0.0205746591,
-0.0036303683,
0.0454230197,
0.0871481448,
-0.0109029897,
0.0192668587,
-0.0323630162,
0.0110911736,
-0.0255843233,
-0.0172104035,
-0.0312434062,
-5.423609344e-33,
-0.0263517071,
-0.0459792614,
0.0392336063,
0.0441748574,
-0.0397039689,
-0.0007051969,
-0.025357794,
0.0247472636,
0.0035257468,
-0.031102756,
-0.0280034114,
0.0728197098,
0.0163141508,
0.0095551955,
0.0233395267,
-0.0225096103,
0.0416141413,
-0.0288056675,
-0.0112305619,
0.0408638865,
0.036389228,
0.0120531367,
0.0568854585,
-0.0484446473,
0.0320883021,
0.0047510327,
-0.0008061272,
0.0198454633,
0.0538660772,
0.0288145579,
-0.0148086119,
0.0799106583,
0.0113272788,
0.0001468044,
-0.0054539121,
0.0715339258,
-0.0265622977,
-0.0329225771,
0.0503371805,
-0.0342429578,
-0.0051439027,
-0.0159459282,
-0.003085685,
-0.0197322611,
-0.0050212196,
0.034929961,
0.0358361378,
-0.0049998476,
0.0102817453,
0.0453752503,
-0.0472772978,
0.0223592706,
-0.0180330332,
-0.0725043193,
-0.0198063422,
0.0755288899,
0.0211822242,
-0.0519346781,
0.0231708866,
0.1030228734,
-0.0023536053,
0.0351052247,
-0.0119097689,
0.0069396691,
0.0290277526,
0.0805378407,
0.0391825214,
0.0823119953,
0.0220980905,
-0.0181368403,
-0.0030996345,
0.0487431325,
-0.0145621952,
-0.0001007008,
-0.0152416164,
-0.0292880312,
-0.0241534244,
0.0145244263,
0.0698982477,
-0.0201817509,
0.0012337617,
0.0048044436,
-0.0369478092,
-0.0183481798,
0.0045317006,
0.0366016589,
-0.003494319,
-0.0449119844,
0.0156574193,
0.0263547357,
0.0005126282,
0.0083747394,
0.0213716254,
-0.0073721902,
0.0296269264,
0.0248186998,
-0.03277383,
-0.0248689875,
-0.0055948165,
-0.0407169312,
-0.0750900805,
-0.0439865068,
0.0401768014,
0.0073253736,
0.0245943088,
0.0159880426,
0.0033621932,
0.0106972456,
-0.0330668427,
-0.0193451997,
-0.0196335632,
0.0479358137,
-0.0789629743,
0.0227313824,
0.0245662443,
0.0386722572,
-0.049902238,
0.0689781159,
0.0036496937,
0.001036733,
-0.089463532,
-0.0490125306,
0.002498955,
-0.0076842238,
0.006246842,
0.0113870958,
-0.0246289242,
-0.0231258646,
0.001298249,
-0.0124717439,
-0.0038533579,
-0.0400557518,
2.516e-7,
-0.0168158729,
0.0587852262,
0.0221199151,
0.0446846597,
0.0002937,
0.0523551106,
0.0115062688,
0.0493535288,
0.0187548082,
-0.0279423352,
0.035556253,
-0.0005464176,
0.0255911425,
0.0192502048,
-0.0915938541,
-0.0626194924,
-0.0516955331,
-0.0469669066,
-0.0040022195,
-0.0140040871,
0.0483268201,
0.0476560146,
0.0181698408,
0.0021201535,
-0.0381101631,
-0.0100847995,
0.0378459357,
-0.0593821295,
-0.0499260873,
0.0220909733,
-0.0085464651,
-0.0043322979,
-0.0108737312,
0.0034351058,
-0.0078170653,
0.0371669754,
0.023337191,
0.0147856167,
0.0038601505,
-0.0547158793,
-0.0173547547,
-0.0099465307,
-0.034924414,
0.018237533,
0.0019322336,
-0.0677425489,
-0.0443106107,
-0.0035539793,
0.0214768071,
-0.0026911201,
0.0345978886,
-0.0196597632,
-0.0078963367,
0.0101110591,
-0.0153366588,
0.014668474,
0.0382976271,
-0.0950550511,
0.0213540532,
0.0046962779,
-0.0543572381,
-0.0557500049,
-0.0402247384,
-0.0224203486,
-0.0172636006,
-0.0035476189,
0.0104559055,
1.877010897e-34,
0.0314446241,
0.0127115911,
0.0000279659,
0.0357481651,
0.0435068533,
-0.0093186414,
-0.0176532157,
-0.0113160983,
0.0511493906,
-0.0473034456,
-0.026775023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14067v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14067v2 | Enhancing Task-Oriented Dialogues with Chitchat: a Comparative Study Based on Lexical Diversity and Divergence | 2023-11-23T15:50:42 | 2024-01-24T20:56:59 | Armand Stricker, Patrick Paroubek | cs.CL | cs.CL | As a recent development, task-oriented dialogues (TODs) have been enriched
with chitchat in an effort to make dialogues more diverse and engaging. This
enhancement is particularly valuable as TODs are often confined to narrow
domains, making the mitigation of repetitive and predictable responses a
significant challenge. This paper presents a comparative analysis of three
chitchat enhancements, aiming to identify the most effective approach in terms
of diversity. Additionally, we quantify the divergence between the added
chitchat, the original task-oriented language, and chitchat typically found in
chitchat datasets, highlighting the top 20 divergent keywords for each
comparison. Our findings drive a discussion on future enhancements for
augmenting TODs, emphasizing the importance of grounding dialogues beyond the
task to achieve more diverse and natural exchanges. | [
0.0757757723,
0.0008620753,
-0.0338338204,
0.0155474385,
-0.0041448874,
0.0014991838,
-0.033851251,
-0.0065492475,
0.0009138808,
-0.0014155314,
-0.0374484807,
-0.0030461431,
0.0109778363,
0.0774998367,
0.0179706197,
-0.0855101347,
0.0517719015,
0.0052385693,
0.0262950193,
-0.0161034744,
0.0438584425,
-0.0146275871,
-0.0125538018,
0.0611301884,
-0.0134065785,
-0.031792637,
-0.0203209613,
-0.0111562656,
-0.0054863677,
-0.0149927298,
0.0694882274,
0.0347169675,
0.0023788679,
-0.0038838941,
0.0000019439,
-0.0436245315,
0.0392818525,
-0.0386962965,
-0.019162925,
-0.0226621535,
0.0662749708,
0.064662315,
0.0006702584,
0.0125203999,
-0.0548138991,
0.0047247619,
0.0948812813,
0.0478619188,
0.041180335,
0.05079275,
-0.0010214256,
0.0248188842,
-0.044961635,
-0.0006107317,
0.0364280157,
-0.0334795415,
-0.0407298915,
0.0320210047,
0.069661662,
0.0308227353,
-0.0005215865,
0.0132369101,
-0.0192305353,
-0.0376395732,
0.0597047098,
0.0218316335,
-0.0306587424,
-0.0328475684,
-0.048146449,
0.091136232,
0.0145790055,
0.025309056,
-0.0324024074,
-0.0038147208,
0.0310090892,
-0.0085902531,
-0.0704244748,
0.012411857,
-0.0006499086,
-0.0158249047,
-0.01672378,
0.0258430392,
-0.0378159918,
0.0075423485,
0.0240433421,
0.018091049,
-0.0053828945,
-0.0125213796,
-0.0164222885,
-0.0205655806,
0.0710257292,
-0.0508103967,
-0.0139071438,
0.0087323757,
-0.0725100264,
0.0327132866,
0.0043945923,
-0.0154309869,
0.0392809771,
-0.0263815932,
0.0274425726,
0.0307542644,
-0.029575685,
0.0066222814,
0.0636713803,
0.014357551,
0.0116252983,
-0.0236148927,
-0.0199291054,
0.0025164271,
-0.0594885424,
-0.0301897023,
-0.0199885331,
0.0547178388,
-0.0383717567,
-0.0159331802,
-0.0034366557,
0.0818450153,
-0.0228513088,
-0.0141640017,
-0.0245140754,
0.0543782935,
-0.0526021309,
0.0197868943,
-0.0429309607,
0.0100103756,
-0.0608839877,
-0.0125703784,
0.0288169105,
-0.0827128142,
-0.0245682485,
0.01368054,
0.0100846505,
-0.0297568496,
-0.0091354549,
0.0281434711,
-0.0091124391,
-0.0156764966,
0.0706517398,
-0.0181106497,
-0.0511226803,
-0.0356980264,
0.0263043586,
-0.0434811525,
0.0227309167,
-0.0151848113,
0.0031898855,
-0.0080647198,
0.0309647098,
0.0493090115,
-0.0324757248,
0.0686568469,
-0.057711985,
0.0143551948,
0.0350787155,
0.0257216245,
-0.0211247839,
0.0695070028,
-0.0162183214,
0.0012505809,
0.0693751872,
-0.0118968692,
-0.0132473316,
0.0004573639,
-0.0470312163,
-0.0075337254,
0.0665220767,
0.0404713266,
0.0287949312,
0.0095281769,
-0.0005020479,
0.0329755247,
-0.0407496877,
0.0262624864,
0.0681263134,
0.0745798424,
-0.0216786824,
0.0113924854,
-0.0172774922,
0.0822832137,
0.0066276621,
0.0234025791,
-0.0118640922,
0.0436788574,
0.0011796001,
-0.0163992029,
0.042728778,
0.0323032252,
-0.0265888833,
-0.0570367053,
-0.0126569085,
0.0184154734,
0.0629608035,
-0.0051802122,
0.0302303713,
0.0046035694,
-0.0002643686,
0.0005036286,
0.0301743951,
-0.0659273267,
-0.0592915528,
-0.0181391258,
-0.0001531808,
0.0776705742,
0.0331198648,
-0.0362937674,
-0.1155390963,
-0.0151494928,
0.003379168,
0.0839733332,
0.0804902017,
-0.0096833082,
-0.0125210416,
-0.0445789732,
-0.0199976657,
-0.0270228032,
-0.0099316249,
-0.0086592818,
0.0129185049,
-0.0067741345,
-0.0133915814,
0.0304500237,
-0.0374577567,
0.0078481026,
0.0388078056,
0.0171281137,
0.0249255337,
-0.0089538721,
0.038901642,
0.061103005,
0.0029749579,
0.0177649893,
0.0164445229,
0.0042613465,
0.0059824008,
0.0543354154,
-0.0354529545,
0.0035478673,
0.0446060263,
-0.0526800863,
-0.0281914305,
0.0024982744,
0.0045245122,
-0.0158872195,
0.034953177,
-0.0534364693,
-0.0098179681,
-0.0303411111,
-0.0172131285,
-0.0172578767,
0.0430588089,
-0.0245163962,
0.0388768129,
0.0263366401,
0.0044875788,
0.0219463333,
-0.0212792475,
0.012155517,
-0.0329064801,
0.0099806339,
0.0217432603,
-0.0130578605,
-0.011235645,
0.030349277,
0.0372536294,
-0.0705340281,
-0.0282177404,
-0.0967788175,
-0.0094638504,
-0.0166957919,
-0.0006712227,
0.0243949052,
0.0243060272,
-0.0057999557,
-0.0214431547,
-0.0509352572,
-0.0013555074,
0.0443754755,
0.0461536124,
0.0440461636,
-0.013598213,
0.0170346033,
-0.0074797785,
0.0080275424,
0.0228251703,
-0.0027023724,
0.0112797534,
-0.0407901853,
0.0128206462,
0.0006651056,
-0.0322015174,
-0.032891117,
-0.0089564323,
-0.0182515495,
0.0600064993,
0.0319677107,
0.0681046322,
-0.0095755002,
0.0692058057,
0.013614608,
-0.0184246935,
-0.0684629083,
-0.0404638797,
0.0036222942,
-0.010449498,
0.0065560713,
-0.0100427726,
-0.0730253607,
0.0276545063,
0.0060979798,
-0.0160721932,
0.0076965247,
-0.0643058047,
0.0534923747,
0.0126680732,
-0.0437905118,
-0.0424074754,
-0.0494567752,
-0.0377911218,
-0.0191082731,
-0.0263523962,
-0.027633246,
0.0451305397,
0.0315154754,
-0.0202753581,
-0.0663521588,
-0.0116511369,
-0.0259634927,
0.0841919035,
-0.0774727017,
-0.0171173476,
0.0531584956,
-0.0484786071,
-0.0346990824,
-0.0023448486,
-0.0001466564,
-0.0427245125,
0.0529302247,
-0.0322805196,
-0.0238796789,
0.0126474444,
-0.02170402,
-0.0610960647,
-0.0163608901,
-0.008267154,
0.0124021275,
0.0410090983,
-0.0058693988,
0.0013555683,
-0.0025810485,
-0.0078253318,
-0.0178557727,
-0.0002970227,
0.0030373463,
0.0141192302,
-0.0249569807,
0.0267890487,
0.069404453,
0.0086786291,
0.0075839343,
0.0456163138,
0.0389532559,
0.0404088348,
-0.0812319145,
0.0391534455,
-0.0198124703,
0.0373038128,
-0.014579149,
-0.0309669077,
0.0095579997,
0.0481069833,
-0.0115312664,
-0.0225841161,
0.0658825561,
0.0119272731,
-0.0352789909,
0.0146882981,
-0.0633676127,
0.0102786012,
0.0197686795,
0.0289539974,
-0.0768939331,
-0.0017051058,
-0.0022502311,
-0.0165667403,
-0.0102366703,
-0.0361414589,
-0.0410242453,
-0.1224543899,
0.0261660665,
-0.0049424372,
-0.0258330218,
-0.0208217725,
0.0068095014,
0.0106164673,
0.046259813,
0.0072997501,
-0.0040427032,
-0.0116848443,
0.005871743,
0.0173073579,
-0.0370255299,
-0.0237335004,
0.0189781711,
-0.0145632718,
0.0701510757,
0.0739355311,
0.0356464833,
0.0129561387,
0.0238470789,
0.0038251358,
0.0328092314,
-0.0075445017,
0.0019585367,
0.0366078839,
0.0035230769,
-0.0059541301,
-0.0225154329,
0.0156088006,
-0.0083636167,
0.0089652138,
0.0634866282,
0.0390400514,
-0.0532888807,
0.0289855916,
-0.0384484641,
0.0351354778,
0.0585378632,
0.0436856784,
0.0289640464,
-0.0273812283,
-0.011387594,
-0.0174081363,
-0.0401051454,
-0.0492940843,
0.0005496151,
-0.0242490936,
-0.031581156,
-0.0354576744,
-0.0907011628,
-0.0888886675,
0.0344646089,
0.0009844506,
-0.0033395011,
0.014380387,
-0.0231167674,
0.0341342576,
-0.0266324319,
0.0412155539,
-0.0034560661,
0.0083336392,
-0.0355035849,
-0.0576773621,
-0.0330639482,
-0.0696291625,
0.0207954161,
0.0134558473,
-0.0618228167,
-0.0517579801,
-0.0326546319,
0.0051485389,
0.0227465425,
0.0087895831,
0.0235362798,
-0.0257566106,
-0.0587356053,
0.0205680151,
-0.0250793472,
-0.0055073583,
0.0442497954,
-0.0030131007,
0.0246316213,
0.0311310217,
-0.0122366836,
-0.0012267674,
0.0033443666,
0.0452567637,
0.0114772245,
-0.0961372107,
0.0035680749,
0.0102516422,
0.0158122052,
0.0044518681,
-0.0434906185,
-0.0303468108,
-0.0110347113,
-0.0389185064,
-0.0319085084,
-0.0400947742,
0.0071865218,
-0.0593421459,
-0.0246670078,
0.0327517428,
0.0423537791,
-0.0841435492,
0.0499342792,
-0.051937528,
0.0218052864,
-0.0112621505,
-0.0378450602,
-0.0123065328,
0.0177884214,
-0.0176742077,
0.0139064649,
0.0170475114,
0.0117545249,
-0.0003618801,
0.0587046072,
0.0061341636,
-0.0528002158,
0.0180553459,
0.0466604568,
-0.0438518599,
-0.0195302889,
0.0401832312,
0.0257166997,
0.0049630231,
0.0377278812,
0.0240407251,
-0.0435299464,
0.0132354004,
-0.0009414865,
-0.0023907761,
-0.0007024006,
-0.0289332159,
0.0203698594,
0.0019922056,
-0.0220175795,
-0.0409314521,
0.0618191659,
-0.1021576449,
-0.0110038407,
0.012185297,
0.0046397159,
-0.0344823711,
-0.0325516574,
0.0320098214,
0.0720560923,
0.0227774624,
0.0196379833,
-0.0675590858,
-0.0273458958,
0.0371890739,
-0.0078512719,
0.0008398447,
-0.0113489712,
0.0567818284,
0.0612559058,
0.0143528115,
0.0230865013,
-0.023758322,
0.0230596103,
-0.0264757406,
0.0028390058,
-0.0454673432,
-5.893464355e-33,
-0.0058157733,
-0.0565045625,
0.0149406018,
-0.0094563365,
-0.0612703115,
-0.0141556226,
-0.0068361256,
0.0247355141,
-0.033567518,
0.0060115964,
-0.0360650234,
0.0262054801,
0.0070143151,
0.0145471813,
0.0449583754,
-0.0135741383,
0.0300678425,
-0.0047548255,
-0.0069022938,
0.0095968358,
0.0181456357,
-0.0061379899,
0.0419641733,
-0.0365458056,
0.1020772606,
0.0147086876,
-0.0176038817,
0.0083547682,
0.0341213606,
0.0132739404,
-0.0253192745,
0.1108695716,
0.0244997405,
-0.0027977144,
-0.033745911,
0.0737557337,
-0.0450557619,
-0.063349098,
0.05960536,
-0.0387230441,
0.0088619161,
-0.0320365317,
-0.0046445769,
0.0068996423,
-0.0203042924,
0.0139651494,
0.0038342488,
-0.0310094897,
-0.0040549925,
0.0324401483,
-0.0682769492,
0.0228292234,
-0.0246033501,
-0.0527719557,
-0.0258290637,
0.0575399697,
0.0121487863,
-0.0616918765,
-0.0196155626,
0.1032516509,
0.0049248422,
-0.0022736616,
0.0295865294,
0.0565037094,
0.0214698352,
0.0613195412,
0.0324508846,
0.0853860974,
0.0054122936,
-0.003882119,
-0.0216619559,
0.038924735,
0.0163636673,
0.0266338065,
-0.013418817,
-0.0052936841,
-0.0022109014,
0.0213747732,
0.0587744601,
0.0032102962,
0.0139527665,
0.0056277541,
-0.0843444467,
-0.0047350172,
0.004748615,
0.094846338,
-0.0201545898,
-0.0506071746,
0.0084107434,
0.0022303876,
-0.0246887356,
0.0104311816,
-0.0042006057,
-0.0163525175,
0.0499797389,
-0.0027914161,
0.0021641906,
-0.0198461358,
0.0054989355,
-0.0398027562,
-0.0223921295,
-0.0043026945,
0.0078964913,
0.0211591553,
0.0147472322,
0.0202584676,
-0.0155900614,
0.0030225387,
-0.0465134643,
-0.0152498409,
-0.0261081047,
0.0719626471,
-0.0385880731,
0.013529948,
0.006361024,
0.0231070686,
-0.0323057771,
0.0900414214,
0.0373194367,
-0.0196504388,
-0.0570596866,
-0.0156805664,
0.0122264912,
-0.0120004602,
-0.0200149789,
0.0310592912,
-0.0178694502,
-0.0157623719,
-0.0137367053,
0.0116885398,
-0.0200845394,
-0.0354659371,
2.629e-7,
0.0039257011,
0.0402848087,
0.0321586765,
0.0335073434,
-0.0010562991,
0.0219002943,
0.0256822444,
0.023361532,
-0.0101414397,
-0.0054099509,
0.0123101985,
0.0030827674,
0.0490140729,
0.023363499,
-0.0840477422,
-0.0639807358,
-0.0652157515,
-0.0069598248,
-0.0106400829,
0.0231260788,
0.0822694153,
0.0007619396,
0.0178820994,
0.009601512,
-0.0568029955,
0.0124290697,
-0.0168744847,
-0.0402721837,
-0.0426593386,
0.0362478942,
-0.0129504977,
-0.0288601816,
0.0032088864,
0.0194119886,
-0.0158798229,
0.0147698494,
0.0158851575,
-0.0010501407,
-0.028328456,
-0.0708364844,
-0.0053380867,
-0.0337411053,
-0.011741084,
-0.0080862083,
0.0318888202,
-0.0384959988,
-0.0427032635,
-0.0207195021,
0.0047079367,
-0.0140803223,
0.0152569758,
-0.0448243953,
-0.0375389121,
-0.0198314283,
-0.0154931704,
-0.0092209429,
0.0022241985,
-0.073272489,
0.0142956162,
0.0144282738,
-0.0640475601,
-0.0833061934,
-0.0260092355,
-0.0146031473,
-0.000913062,
0.0137711242,
0.0142947035,
1.916867044e-34,
0.0294305291,
0.0156637747,
0.031829603,
0.0385001563,
0.0221517533,
0.0086424425,
-0.0201899651,
0.0004783496,
0.0798822865,
-0.029512208,
-0.042043414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14063v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14063v1 | Do VSR Models Generalize Beyond LRS3? | 2023-11-23T15:42:00 | 2023-11-23T15:42:00 | Yasser Abdelaziz Dahou Djilali, Sanath Narayan, Eustache Le Bihan, Haithem Boussaid, Ebtessam Almazrouei, Merouane Debbah | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | The Lip Reading Sentences-3 (LRS3) benchmark has primarily been the focus of
intense research in visual speech recognition (VSR) during the last few years.
As a result, there is an increased risk of overfitting to its excessively used
test set, which is only one hour duration. To alleviate this issue, we build a
new VSR test set named WildVSR, by closely following the LRS3 dataset creation
processes. We then evaluate and analyse the extent to which the current VSR
models generalize to the new test data. We evaluate a broad range of publicly
available VSR models and find significant drops in performance on our test set,
compared to their corresponding LRS3 results. Our results suggest that the
increase in word error rates is caused by the models inability to generalize to
slightly harder and in the wild lip sequences than those found in the LRS3 test
set. Our new test benchmark is made public in order to enable future research
towards more robust VSR models. | [
0.0187826194,
0.0258579031,
-0.0013243044,
0.0214943457,
-0.0308069848,
0.024068784,
0.0144881168,
0.0004711983,
-0.0219088662,
0.004671915,
-0.0262346808,
-0.0450994857,
0.05707087,
0.0575695112,
0.0514394939,
-0.074351944,
0.003630779,
-0.0668085068,
0.0343677029,
0.0032389071,
0.0343667045,
0.0146964658,
-0.0240598265,
0.0598842353,
0.0021970007,
0.0196020696,
0.0027001519,
0.0262610894,
0.0322861485,
-0.003461852,
-0.0370513201,
0.0085604833,
0.0534256883,
-0.0176203772,
0.0000017494,
0.0127045,
-0.0152207213,
0.0157471672,
-0.0491536148,
0.0192370024,
0.0072067985,
-0.0230140295,
0.0245225467,
0.0540037788,
-0.0166521035,
-0.0241886619,
0.0432111286,
-0.0108973058,
0.004757124,
0.0311539415,
-0.0170117635,
0.0233382042,
0.0305695012,
-0.0448534861,
0.0497817993,
-0.0343192518,
-0.0124177122,
0.0464415587,
-0.0021324381,
-0.0910704434,
-0.0538551547,
0.0497850329,
-0.0110446643,
0.0162201244,
0.0444491543,
-0.009622761,
-0.0691623613,
-0.055463165,
-0.04539904,
0.0507853143,
-0.00733204,
0.0137356101,
-0.0056034573,
-0.0012658352,
-0.0576528423,
-0.0055308151,
-0.001523833,
0.0212369803,
-0.0239865743,
-0.0234788842,
-0.067980282,
0.008995668,
-0.0005541594,
-0.0454274528,
-0.0070169885,
-0.0477256738,
0.0139167067,
-0.0373038016,
0.0401947424,
0.0157924965,
-0.0220293943,
0.0162318721,
-0.0020702239,
-0.0207782295,
0.0212968867,
-0.0194718707,
-0.0420527048,
-0.0100704338,
0.0022496257,
0.0011798475,
0.0638537481,
0.0499535836,
-0.0798861384,
0.0104517648,
-0.0061837737,
0.068502292,
0.0019319608,
0.062225502,
0.0037727037,
-0.0030147326,
-0.0169857983,
-0.0029177791,
-0.0039180811,
-0.0113129504,
-0.0366888642,
-0.0579351746,
-0.0407561474,
0.0127896322,
0.0033293683,
0.0134866331,
0.0131264189,
0.0121147987,
-0.0215102397,
0.0146754244,
-0.0223860014,
0.0408974029,
0.0698192418,
0.0328699164,
-0.0084249238,
-0.0887642875,
-0.008405108,
0.0136612859,
0.0276739746,
0.0200547036,
0.0410871655,
0.0991778374,
-0.0138370181,
-0.0849961564,
-0.0023085941,
0.0283766706,
-0.0518747382,
-0.057086356,
0.0177911948,
-0.0568634719,
0.0037818782,
0.0048371535,
0.0043786536,
0.0231136605,
-0.0219701994,
-0.0035382195,
-0.0195222571,
0.065308772,
0.0056065787,
0.0160203837,
-0.0151455356,
0.010865598,
0.0402612612,
0.0454499163,
0.0325836167,
-0.0152247595,
-0.0069335345,
-0.0204106998,
0.0381618328,
0.0764740184,
-0.0266474336,
0.0036636905,
-0.0579838678,
-0.0046006907,
0.0222305022,
0.0054996707,
0.0369128063,
0.0752793625,
-0.0447964892,
-0.0542750619,
0.0767722353,
0.0538613014,
0.0072725844,
-0.0577888712,
0.0345411524,
-0.0135340905,
0.0421311334,
0.0110347904,
-0.0156279989,
0.0062598158,
0.0072618872,
0.0494569056,
-0.0123698292,
0.0297416896,
-0.039967075,
-0.0173779558,
-0.0457446948,
-0.0078912005,
-0.0093034068,
0.061606653,
0.0495642386,
-0.028390035,
-0.0521886498,
0.0292625818,
0.0095085828,
-0.0316359252,
-0.004173141,
-0.041058179,
0.056507498,
0.0748032629,
0.016062431,
0.0073234066,
-0.0383091606,
-0.0154605359,
-0.0152768157,
0.0473929867,
0.0237157308,
0.0033307963,
0.093914181,
-0.075561516,
-0.0387845039,
0.0185188632,
0.0116378842,
0.0283361729,
-0.0149436193,
0.0074561792,
-0.0035469593,
-0.0563289672,
0.0376257114,
0.0106285634,
-0.0538578443,
0.0262120496,
-0.0462425724,
0.0349306911,
0.0226913244,
0.0010044473,
-0.0299699437,
-0.0260058288,
0.0174715668,
-0.0152842719,
0.041916009,
0.025802888,
-0.0258486699,
-0.02373516,
0.0272428859,
-0.0884011537,
-0.0091754878,
0.0654080138,
-0.0211750679,
-0.0152913751,
0.0033823648,
-0.0427008718,
0.0004315478,
-0.0286876485,
0.0344497599,
0.0116587179,
0.0104269553,
0.0033232442,
-0.0510130301,
-0.0442136116,
-0.009002286,
0.0175479949,
0.0130906785,
-0.0122590549,
-0.0712123364,
-0.0238101371,
0.0237095729,
-0.0183288753,
-0.0041999114,
0.0057614581,
0.0214497298,
-0.0307998639,
-0.0426297374,
-0.065246366,
-0.0494427569,
-0.036446847,
0.0113006076,
-0.0351191051,
-0.0034595034,
-0.0259167962,
-0.0079196729,
-0.0081226528,
0.007469119,
-0.0015132282,
0.0028751844,
-0.0259423591,
-0.018565461,
-0.053164389,
-0.0434380248,
-0.002403921,
0.0096803922,
0.0289425794,
-0.0235028546,
-0.0450453125,
-0.0302192234,
0.0178737063,
-0.0495601483,
0.0243669786,
-0.040923994,
0.0040624663,
-0.0024487998,
0.006406025,
0.0190915298,
0.0263715275,
0.0123693626,
-0.0043363832,
-0.012634499,
0.0327055417,
-0.0075280569,
-0.0007228901,
0.0212733187,
-0.0381377637,
-0.0466570146,
-0.0464494042,
-0.0539915152,
-0.0197147727,
0.0498366468,
0.0864644274,
-0.0677561909,
0.0181487948,
0.0118641863,
-0.0317519866,
-0.02879324,
0.0203021802,
-0.0287093185,
0.024853101,
-0.0470906124,
-0.0819364786,
0.0204694141,
-0.0781266764,
-0.0581829697,
0.0145559516,
-0.0451614037,
-0.0493537076,
0.0755860135,
0.018886948,
-0.0267952643,
-0.020853715,
-0.0250168201,
-0.0429531746,
-0.0304142293,
0.0173272286,
-0.0092511224,
0.0752748549,
-0.0291429572,
-0.0043974305,
-0.032512255,
-0.0033781494,
0.0038868866,
-0.0022735773,
-0.0677449629,
-0.0051802881,
-0.0330301598,
-0.0064174184,
0.0046665859,
0.0239449367,
0.0291672777,
0.0568696707,
-0.015136933,
-0.0012810747,
-0.0205134004,
0.0536255725,
0.0582758561,
0.015715858,
-0.0536441281,
-0.0624428876,
0.020034045,
0.0028100691,
0.0367425494,
0.0077636074,
-0.0616934188,
0.0464797318,
0.047910478,
0.0840536132,
0.0157681331,
0.0242252667,
0.0178832263,
-0.033754386,
0.0300404448,
0.0308216196,
-0.023794027,
-0.016859049,
-0.0396317281,
0.0194166899,
0.0422947071,
0.0478281304,
-0.0296315067,
-0.0767879188,
-0.0132982908,
0.0428238921,
0.0244776811,
0.0178701039,
0.0462291799,
-0.0359521583,
-0.0471367203,
0.084989287,
-0.0101818899,
-0.0281287543,
-0.0010885303,
-0.0055342629,
-0.0214338396,
-0.0691488907,
0.082315512,
0.0133759612,
-0.0587618984,
-0.0155432746,
0.070161432,
-0.0183549803,
-0.0231360141,
0.0182225239,
-0.043581143,
0.0130673582,
0.0434098057,
-0.0071425769,
-0.0072131972,
-0.0475932024,
0.0241724662,
0.0343640894,
0.0186396297,
0.0151765626,
0.0841446444,
0.0176089909,
-0.0441150889,
0.0324120373,
0.0105739553,
0.0028280059,
0.0506058075,
0.0014005461,
0.0090742186,
-0.0136725157,
-0.0331730805,
-0.0055198544,
0.0363588817,
-0.0503132045,
0.0415919907,
0.0408598371,
-0.0161709115,
-0.0224320516,
0.0520366542,
0.0244811866,
-0.0593454838,
-0.0511829257,
0.0092203077,
0.0197318308,
-0.0353112891,
0.0004218004,
-0.0076812566,
0.0263730213,
0.0730692372,
-0.0079551721,
0.019373998,
-0.0204719994,
0.0319180265,
-0.038015537,
0.0510011278,
0.0060102986,
0.02909174,
-0.0577452555,
-0.0048747412,
-0.0217091497,
-0.0366269313,
-0.0456152447,
0.0020200098,
-0.0880781785,
-0.0636082441,
-0.0206034146,
0.0516369268,
0.0244010761,
0.0364043824,
0.0302973296,
-0.0298063084,
0.0534127839,
-0.0018390537,
0.0219765827,
0.0671660304,
0.0309964865,
-0.0192271173,
-0.0335022435,
-0.0079311728,
-0.0394335762,
0.011769983,
0.0103891771,
-0.0027758747,
0.0206241217,
-0.040523082,
-0.0253605451,
0.0129675167,
0.0802907124,
0.0106402086,
-0.0043672421,
-0.037418142,
0.0279559195,
0.0083669201,
0.0766184777,
-0.0699779168,
-0.0273027215,
0.0166121088,
0.0586671233,
-0.0290144589,
0.0013386648,
-0.0125596821,
0.0152154993,
-0.0453816764,
0.0604410842,
0.0283262245,
0.0277423672,
0.0278825797,
0.0262865815,
-0.032697808,
0.027756732,
-0.0539656319,
-0.0077060414,
0.0308832265,
0.0154088754,
-0.0131301377,
0.0100305742,
0.0345210359,
0.028463196,
-0.036689952,
-0.0715420023,
-0.0223656502,
0.0010486776,
0.0259160474,
-0.005433314,
0.017593516,
0.0171312355,
0.0115681216,
-0.0271907635,
0.0225569364,
-0.0605561696,
-0.0110286055,
0.0164740402,
0.0026277592,
-0.0356165506,
0.0152885802,
0.0292361006,
0.057897184,
0.0196511149,
-0.0175449103,
0.0154235931,
-0.0312149916,
-0.0158891156,
0.040286541,
-0.0428478047,
0.0005570255,
-0.0244042594,
-0.0148616005,
-0.0834554061,
0.0676604211,
0.0119778374,
0.0725471154,
0.0317693762,
0.0261430256,
0.0309423171,
-0.0145627018,
0.0002351412,
0.0211320091,
-0.0658654571,
-0.0298565961,
0.0037285164,
0.0215034485,
-6.04385049e-33,
0.0055305138,
0.0180733148,
0.0408867449,
-0.0160945784,
-0.0220489241,
0.0296318326,
-0.0213999972,
0.0171466116,
0.0254507847,
-0.0242219809,
0.0188238211,
0.0027772894,
0.0213787202,
0.0060023391,
-0.0115460427,
-0.0214253049,
0.0847748443,
-0.013754636,
0.0044055367,
-0.0508946031,
0.0218523797,
0.0444912836,
0.0478894264,
-0.042461738,
-0.0517499447,
0.0449297987,
-0.0159888808,
-0.0431298465,
0.0099460911,
0.0685453638,
0.0038561013,
0.0231674965,
-0.0084329415,
-0.0081249801,
-0.0049128737,
-0.015936669,
-0.0831088871,
0.0400389172,
0.0202441402,
0.0393264033,
-0.0187097546,
0.0388202742,
0.0416113771,
-0.0282430295,
-0.0056161308,
-0.0478221439,
0.0502448007,
-0.0254058298,
-0.0298998877,
-0.0259448737,
-0.0237919185,
0.0431070365,
-0.0099781379,
-0.011643488,
0.0546381027,
0.0886076838,
0.0009993528,
0.0328378417,
0.0072674346,
-0.0046463218,
-0.0273021311,
0.0072344737,
0.0443185009,
0.0254327487,
-0.0220123697,
0.055791866,
0.0329054855,
-0.0847565904,
0.0100452937,
-0.0717882141,
0.0394645333,
0.0584522486,
0.0341963023,
0.012105423,
-0.0139603904,
-0.0333271883,
-0.0287399516,
-0.0250587482,
-0.0245032553,
0.0025735677,
0.0267146621,
0.0190055203,
-0.0546972603,
0.0067342259,
-0.0438054278,
-0.0253410358,
-0.0718759596,
0.0096078562,
0.0746798962,
0.048780717,
0.0290582422,
0.0108777778,
0.0595291331,
-0.0010717949,
0.0774096996,
0.019397486,
-0.0321502984,
0.0339773037,
-0.0239212196,
0.0267441459,
-0.0521111861,
-0.0318859853,
0.0221614894,
0.0360402949,
0.030887939,
-0.0506319739,
-0.0005994978,
0.0262054633,
-0.0796082616,
-0.0224776622,
0.0116890585,
0.034108378,
-0.0030676683,
0.0533698499,
0.0633473098,
-0.023454383,
-0.0333114751,
0.0400174595,
-0.0429124869,
-0.001958248,
-0.0228270739,
0.0032844048,
-0.0236037988,
0.0367947184,
-0.0084772436,
0.0450570881,
0.0035032779,
-0.0450329855,
0.0171630979,
-0.0129406974,
-0.0047334991,
0.0499566086,
2.51e-7,
-0.0442813635,
0.0237256959,
0.0406473838,
0.0176061857,
-0.0310276281,
-0.0017659171,
-0.0298728775,
0.0096580135,
-0.0099120252,
-0.0025857782,
-0.0075185467,
-0.0021396868,
0.0722724944,
-0.0263387021,
-0.0377631895,
0.0325904042,
-0.0736881718,
0.0029930309,
0.0274182037,
0.0188305248,
0.0146654667,
0.0609977171,
-0.0317847766,
-0.0399119295,
0.0147204688,
-0.030750582,
0.0384079963,
-0.0317652561,
-0.0174143706,
-0.035126742,
0.0614952371,
-0.00183169,
0.0076574064,
0.0384886712,
0.0079281572,
0.0156105338,
0.0292157065,
0.0226224624,
-0.0176778398,
-0.0666354075,
-0.0108417105,
0.0805621594,
-0.0469037145,
0.0016243554,
0.0479603112,
0.0244102813,
-0.023624422,
-0.0199750159,
-0.0402364507,
0.0189801157,
0.0540652908,
-0.01684222,
0.0161866676,
0.0206795745,
0.0322338864,
-0.0593199059,
-0.0160595626,
-0.0700101852,
0.0172230564,
-0.0017596422,
-0.0488077365,
-0.030625876,
-0.0410774946,
0.0211428721,
0.011748421,
0.0001179421,
-0.0378207229,
1.538909564e-34,
0.0593611225,
-0.0445838608,
0.0190575831,
-0.0251362696,
0.0131939445,
-0.0303904321,
0.0133311935,
0.002143611,
-0.014182914,
-0.0744976625,
-0.0219404493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13987v1 | Jam-ALT: A Formatting-Aware Lyrics Transcription Benchmark | 2023-11-23T13:13:48 | 2023-11-23T13:13:48 | Ondřej Cífka, Constantinos Dimitriou, Cheng-i Wang, Hendrik Schreiber, Luke Miner, Fabian-Robert Stöter | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Current automatic lyrics transcription (ALT) benchmarks focus exclusively on
word content and ignore the finer nuances of written lyrics including
formatting and punctuation, which leads to a potential misalignment with the
creative products of musicians and songwriters as well as listeners'
experiences. For example, line breaks are important in conveying information
about rhythm, emotional emphasis, rhyme, and high-level structure. To address
this issue, we introduce Jam-ALT, a new lyrics transcription benchmark based on
the JamendoLyrics dataset. Our contribution is twofold. Firstly, a complete
revision of the transcripts, geared specifically towards ALT evaluation by
following a newly created annotation guide that unifies the music industry's
guidelines, covering aspects such as punctuation, line breaks, spelling,
background vocals, and non-word sounds. Secondly, a suite of evaluation metrics
designed, unlike the traditional word error rate, to capture such phenomena. We
hope that the proposed benchmark contributes to the ALT task, enabling more
precise and reliable assessments of transcription systems and enhancing the
user experience in lyrics applications such as subtitle renderings for live
captioning or karaoke. | [
-0.0002560464,
0.0195052866,
0.00650388,
0.0038316369,
-0.0406044461,
-0.0126469983,
0.0310886204,
-0.0071045025,
-0.0132881058,
0.0253195185,
-0.0504416935,
0.0056026168,
0.0554313958,
0.0115254968,
0.0116848387,
-0.0460610352,
-0.0222158246,
-0.0112258587,
0.070812121,
0.0295625553,
-0.0034082711,
0.0286624078,
-0.0532804318,
0.0582141168,
-0.0439167097,
-0.0213932861,
-0.0123632634,
0.0655274168,
0.0063713882,
-0.0289178304,
-0.0501663387,
0.0497830138,
-0.0491100028,
0.037348751,
0.0000017764,
-0.009590528,
-0.0341673978,
0.0174057726,
0.0138074746,
0.029677378,
0.0004132581,
-0.0206626896,
-0.0264943745,
0.0137340315,
0.001962191,
-0.0151285296,
0.0430804044,
-0.0260502249,
0.054854691,
0.0756034926,
0.0060014357,
-0.0141834747,
0.0023290131,
-0.0421144888,
0.0064772144,
-0.0137341321,
-0.0029753181,
0.0204218719,
0.0185626578,
-0.057907749,
-0.0028949971,
0.0918655172,
-0.0057467334,
0.0038226149,
0.0357867517,
0.0170296468,
-0.1090202853,
-0.0310083795,
0.0083461292,
0.0266850144,
0.0058057192,
-0.00214338,
0.001071826,
0.0088143377,
-0.0145261539,
-0.0506278276,
-0.0266055837,
-0.0194176268,
0.0056049116,
-0.0271682553,
-0.0424037538,
0.0345412679,
0.0072933114,
-0.0609310083,
-0.0004914095,
-0.018514812,
0.041464068,
-0.0659385398,
0.0076822466,
0.0277029555,
0.0110199871,
-0.0393354557,
0.020533897,
-0.064005509,
0.0103952028,
-0.031494502,
-0.0410624705,
-0.0807506666,
-0.0119676283,
-0.0219049212,
0.067040883,
0.0070487955,
0.0028815761,
0.0516541749,
-0.0022988289,
0.0248867609,
0.0273765158,
-0.010880216,
-0.0130858934,
0.0179546941,
0.0156045705,
-0.0051823496,
-0.0369457677,
-0.0542183444,
-0.0111431973,
-0.0131566962,
-0.0443185903,
-0.0241145007,
0.0064123715,
0.0290763676,
0.0568822287,
-0.039440766,
-0.0051047644,
-0.0008210507,
0.0609039813,
-0.009438253,
0.0093992697,
0.0264147948,
-0.0057996763,
-0.0392124169,
-0.0030119012,
0.0109344264,
0.0687146112,
0.010016948,
0.0473433174,
0.0738784745,
0.0396517999,
-0.0665415451,
-0.0153049603,
-0.0075657181,
-0.0837779045,
-0.0078718318,
-0.0462288074,
-0.0496171974,
0.0558863506,
-0.0166247077,
-0.0128059946,
-0.0162293427,
-0.004905018,
0.0033491291,
0.0136102317,
0.0347477905,
-0.0154389543,
0.0398691334,
-0.0248990264,
-0.0108401226,
-0.0128251016,
-0.0180812906,
0.0641004071,
0.037589699,
0.0517642796,
-0.0460849553,
0.0379982702,
0.0438451394,
0.0051176026,
-0.0059475624,
-0.0709666535,
-0.0182540156,
-0.0177081339,
0.0818128511,
0.0338605866,
0.0556448884,
0.0226822346,
-0.0049465555,
0.0722701102,
0.0340839922,
0.0318344869,
0.062316969,
0.0043159435,
0.0289629418,
0.0462077893,
-0.0041835168,
-0.0091410866,
0.0425348505,
0.0798836574,
0.0383616276,
0.1493527144,
0.0206031576,
0.0178252663,
0.0083628027,
-0.0476343781,
0.00213467,
-0.0520363301,
-0.031884741,
0.0001391473,
-0.0004996995,
-0.0456153639,
0.0232698042,
-0.024422301,
-0.0606719367,
-0.0431907475,
-0.0035142312,
-0.0114715351,
0.0728562251,
0.054200694,
-0.0076443227,
0.0465703681,
-0.0291631036,
-0.0348695479,
0.0608422533,
-0.0168615915,
-0.0127748484,
0.0421294123,
0.0005495417,
0.018240219,
-0.0010041221,
0.0042821206,
0.003099845,
-0.0476962849,
0.0357401781,
0.0070766537,
-0.0395945273,
0.0017742319,
0.0027948252,
0.0219178516,
-0.0345688313,
-0.0122263106,
0.0395537466,
0.0299248602,
0.0423324555,
-0.0750794336,
0.0314874984,
0.0111673158,
-0.0161295775,
0.0417701341,
0.0440914705,
-0.0306626875,
-0.0618124492,
0.0615618117,
-0.0584314279,
0.0130161457,
0.0255085751,
0.0262939706,
-0.0417692438,
0.0354492329,
-0.0115592955,
0.0442435816,
0.0134215746,
0.0281762574,
-0.0170157552,
-0.0160253849,
0.0361438133,
-0.0446798988,
0.0091666011,
0.0316769034,
-0.0614119098,
-0.0906131566,
0.0240128003,
0.0044648079,
-0.012743175,
0.0266840421,
0.0076571535,
0.0128219351,
-0.0457527563,
-0.0068915091,
-0.0291614607,
-0.0707367361,
-0.0854142085,
0.023056563,
-0.0240189936,
-0.0230801217,
0.0349294171,
-0.0160057507,
-0.0325332321,
-0.0185333826,
0.0011247282,
-0.0368730165,
-0.0083843842,
0.0158602111,
-0.0263942536,
0.0013929864,
-0.0367255323,
-0.054782398,
0.0002456633,
-0.0133481948,
-0.0217275899,
-0.0253523272,
0.0051792045,
0.0297468677,
-0.0061514326,
-0.0242730007,
-0.0634313673,
0.0453076623,
-0.0408291705,
0.0023199958,
-0.0236564111,
0.0446384288,
0.04931508,
-0.0113505693,
-0.023735946,
0.0421469845,
-0.0435169488,
0.0505119562,
-0.0069756783,
0.0418868735,
0.025473658,
0.0239992235,
-0.0390369818,
0.0061003491,
0.0368876308,
0.0698512346,
0.0127350856,
-0.0205729995,
0.0208533052,
-0.0459889323,
0.0404741913,
-0.0085606119,
0.048863925,
-0.0233397968,
0.0138103422,
-0.0291682817,
-0.0218817033,
0.025594594,
-0.0568104386,
-0.0537914932,
-0.0096605085,
-0.0301199928,
-0.0501322262,
0.0111136315,
-0.0502283983,
0.0006398437,
-0.0048604966,
-0.0530493185,
0.0114517249,
0.0505791083,
0.0213249288,
-0.0469653383,
0.0180143863,
-0.0314049274,
-0.0218526237,
-0.009127873,
-0.0330724008,
0.0282180998,
-0.0502960496,
-0.0133511238,
-0.0487256907,
0.013395126,
-0.0558648519,
0.0136715695,
-0.0094839744,
0.0125295734,
0.068679072,
-0.0181848705,
0.0030277211,
0.0052102478,
0.0385150351,
0.0107141845,
-0.0544592477,
-0.0201403014,
-0.03950556,
0.0228571184,
-0.0219020974,
-0.0064240014,
0.0274694823,
0.0129711078,
-0.0081358561,
0.005331065,
0.0236994065,
0.0103769349,
0.0080039706,
0.0365992673,
-0.0357773863,
0.0256033484,
0.0908077434,
0.0166627783,
-0.0051238094,
-0.01577029,
0.0020008185,
0.0487969108,
0.0374361835,
-0.028307626,
-0.0399033763,
-0.020096248,
0.0308513269,
0.1070671231,
0.0426330045,
0.0105325459,
-0.0160301961,
-0.031294886,
0.003242708,
0.0014864295,
-0.0537260994,
-0.0141859381,
-0.0037711237,
-0.0224519204,
-0.0215680487,
-0.0004853439,
-0.0035186831,
-0.0247670859,
0.0488431826,
-0.0126412641,
-0.0324337818,
-0.0318581313,
-0.016959643,
-0.0616405271,
0.0836780816,
0.0376662835,
0.0827079639,
-0.0076556299,
-0.0331356935,
-0.0208419822,
-0.0157605149,
-0.0159719791,
0.0270316564,
0.0546138249,
0.0389741734,
-0.0218368173,
0.0027384737,
0.0182109829,
-0.0234482065,
0.0103786644,
0.0347960405,
-0.0066048717,
0.0003143943,
0.0083896127,
0.025010664,
0.0442550331,
0.0258309282,
0.077748552,
0.0910234675,
-0.0250277314,
-0.0103852553,
-0.0021463647,
0.0345313959,
-0.0835248381,
-0.0235490128,
-0.0292842258,
-0.0009259591,
-0.0224382132,
-0.0396949649,
-0.0099699348,
0.0200289786,
0.0038958264,
0.0300361197,
-0.0509435572,
-0.0768958852,
-0.0185659733,
-0.0666485801,
-0.0067944378,
0.0140043674,
0.040528331,
-0.0539952293,
-0.0348436423,
-0.0278456155,
0.0034331609,
-0.0045462796,
0.012626295,
-0.0721204206,
-0.020049952,
0.0574088581,
0.0053665559,
0.0123006916,
0.0307866242,
-0.0103772264,
0.0015929897,
-0.0425556228,
0.0310938861,
0.0144666154,
0.0464060456,
0.0324524418,
0.003463357,
0.0132458694,
0.0154037047,
-0.0466805995,
0.0086981216,
-0.0111538852,
0.0252657123,
0.0203529783,
-0.0905773714,
0.0139663275,
-0.001613697,
0.0245188437,
-0.0000251173,
-0.0396987386,
-0.0033848437,
-0.0290414225,
-0.0222338159,
0.0116686365,
-0.0246029031,
-0.0216303561,
0.0674298182,
0.0436277576,
-0.0546580702,
0.0373277441,
-0.0062582591,
-0.027518481,
-0.0565028973,
0.0396934189,
0.0267466865,
-0.0316192806,
0.0198719855,
-0.0018044874,
-0.0114131961,
0.0069095944,
0.0236331597,
0.0337369628,
0.0342889652,
-0.0356363244,
0.0002553566,
-0.0458949097,
-0.0011524461,
0.0492576398,
-0.0321758389,
0.0294123441,
-0.0010210722,
0.0452252626,
0.0702007487,
-0.0115332408,
0.0700493008,
0.0267878734,
-0.0096034408,
-0.009396717,
0.0311454348,
-0.0104492912,
-0.0166553035,
-0.06540218,
0.0048759431,
-0.0211351179,
-0.0152637642,
0.0664552078,
0.0126697179,
-0.014493579,
0.0108714029,
-0.0249319971,
-0.0058010691,
0.0450495929,
-0.027285073,
-0.0235348474,
0.0313563086,
-0.0005115806,
-0.0642190054,
-0.0339003839,
0.0685385019,
0.0452835523,
0.0369365327,
0.0098816426,
-0.0270153247,
-0.0060436865,
-0.0081173051,
-0.0018588939,
-0.0012395146,
-0.0360529199,
-0.0162130501,
-0.0188706294,
-0.0132222874,
-5.381613707e-33,
-0.0179332942,
0.0059279264,
-0.0598600917,
0.008327039,
-0.0611348525,
0.0107582333,
-0.0657591596,
0.0196245499,
0.0174829606,
-0.0184274688,
-0.0072331764,
0.0245909709,
0.0115828654,
-0.0189135782,
0.0434319265,
0.0053020045,
0.0753735304,
-0.0405892991,
-0.0638874397,
0.0237397756,
0.0233591869,
0.0300848186,
-0.0013696313,
-0.0764353722,
0.0127025908,
-0.0181718729,
0.006704018,
0.019832978,
0.0622421764,
0.0226718709,
0.0137923639,
0.0038782093,
-0.0054116738,
0.0042405264,
-0.0207811929,
-0.0086816996,
-0.0226762909,
-0.0118197072,
0.0106630595,
0.0463988446,
0.0017303693,
-0.0075181015,
0.0175617598,
-0.0152792158,
-0.0222696923,
-0.0207010172,
0.0266907886,
-0.0499338694,
-0.0254929531,
-0.0499043837,
0.000093095,
0.0091553703,
-0.0610971563,
-0.0452780165,
0.0375640206,
0.0330637582,
0.0263771322,
0.0214310288,
-0.0506945699,
0.000194817,
-0.0524765104,
0.0386972316,
0.0219896138,
0.0083881347,
-0.0156006487,
0.0407760926,
-0.0131074246,
-0.016250588,
-0.0287845656,
0.0504901931,
0.006038541,
0.0346804522,
0.0294973198,
0.0243586432,
0.0739446208,
-0.023722142,
0.0222367328,
0.0163441412,
-0.0379778296,
-0.0565924197,
-0.0005696634,
0.0709980875,
-0.070563972,
0.0065718903,
-0.0161761045,
-0.0557194389,
-0.0346427821,
-0.0110799726,
0.0432933792,
-0.0308461897,
-0.0081973746,
-0.0126177622,
-0.0087144691,
-0.0237256158,
0.0069047436,
-0.0203595255,
-0.0572656915,
0.0452393033,
-0.0311381854,
-0.005840241,
-0.0145366732,
0.0239685755,
0.0845855623,
0.0675609335,
0.0787675604,
-0.0381831639,
0.0519297309,
0.0579885729,
-0.0763280615,
-0.0049894284,
-0.0059359381,
-0.0047553354,
-0.0127502792,
-0.0585089102,
0.0573168248,
0.0045741545,
-0.0001210008,
0.0336781666,
0.0219975598,
0.0439309441,
0.0185341258,
-0.0385876931,
-0.0099197403,
-0.0228807312,
0.0113240555,
0.0140845925,
0.030762272,
-0.0516861416,
-0.0190094598,
-0.0124059627,
-0.0356945843,
-0.0001918399,
2.536e-7,
0.0205381401,
0.0214656815,
0.0573357716,
-0.0160845984,
0.0101964846,
0.0214974042,
-0.1064714715,
0.0076118247,
-0.0264529511,
0.0141922394,
0.0437674373,
-0.0322108641,
0.1409243345,
0.019385783,
-0.0998114496,
0.0045252368,
-0.0852682889,
-0.0032134312,
-0.0883761197,
-0.0231186096,
0.0712375939,
0.0212408118,
0.0217668992,
0.0055680801,
0.0212056451,
-0.0413728245,
0.0030735254,
-0.0119330445,
0.036183551,
-0.0579535179,
0.0312544703,
-0.0011727202,
-0.0132606942,
-0.0176121127,
-0.050572563,
0.0144554321,
0.0707619116,
0.041641023,
0.028059192,
-0.0075561586,
0.039372243,
0.0284804627,
-0.0236103963,
-0.0284982231,
0.0392202884,
0.0549297743,
-0.0225155801,
-0.0309198089,
-0.0261457078,
0.0104931872,
0.0132967653,
-0.0171862058,
-0.0232195873,
-0.0360347591,
0.02871361,
-0.0168893412,
0.0182586461,
-0.0096033141,
-0.018137984,
0.0207365379,
-0.012900346,
0.0004835322,
-0.0349807441,
0.0344874039,
0.0078043719,
-0.0517400168,
-0.0105688665,
2.267443196e-34,
0.050643865,
-0.063398011,
0.0186106581,
-0.0013481942,
0.0360107571,
-0.0033775528,
0.0055794707,
-0.0305040609,
-0.0335463285,
-0.0317228511,
-0.0014152741
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13982v1 | Probabilistic Tree-of-thought Reasoning for Answering Knowledge-intensive Complex Questions | 2023-11-23T12:52:37 | 2023-11-23T12:52:37 | Shulin Cao, Jiajie Zhang, Jiaxin Shi, Xin Lv, Zijun Yao, Qi Tian, Juanzi Li, Lei Hou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of answering knowledge-intensive
complex questions with chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning. However, they tend to
generate factually incorrect reasoning steps when the required knowledge is not
available or up-to-date in models' parameters. Recent works turn to retrieving
external knowledge to augment CoT reasoning. Despite being promising, these
chain-based methods suffer from: 1) Negative retrieval. Unnecessary or
incorrect retrieval may mislead the reasoning; 2) Limited sight. Lacking the
ability to look backward or forward, a local error in one step will propagate
along the chain.
In this paper, we propose a novel approach: Probabilistic Tree-of-thought
Reasoning (ProbTree). First, LLMs translate a complex question into a query
tree, in which each non-root node denotes a sub-question of its parent node.
Then, probabilistic reasoning is conducted over the tree, by solving questions
from leaf to root considering the confidence of both question decomposing and
answering. During reasoning, for leaf nodes, LLMs choose a more confident
answer from Closed-book QA that employs parametric knowledge and Open-book QA
that employs retrieved external knowledge, thus eliminating the negative
retrieval problem. For non-leaf nodes, with the hierarchical structure, LLMs
have broader sights and are able to globally reason with the information from
child nodes, thus recovering from local errors. The experiments on three
Complex QA datasets under the open-domain setting show that our approach
outperforms SOTA methods significantly, demonstrating the effect of
probabilistic tree-of-thought reasoning. | [
0.0384769253,
0.0112611772,
-0.0142627414,
0.0361391343,
-0.0613376945,
0.0098831896,
-0.0502207167,
-0.006716609,
-0.0007235626,
-0.0396794491,
0.0011626682,
-0.0237554237,
0.0005255641,
-0.0005890555,
0.0018834795,
-0.0431483351,
0.0279426817,
-0.0576855242,
0.0220774971,
-0.0391684584,
-0.0142779918,
0.0220044274,
-0.0138364984,
0.0037519548,
0.0025708233,
-0.062614657,
-0.0469500944,
0.0071187704,
0.0364728272,
-0.0076632975,
0.0022501489,
0.0253388509,
0.0171022397,
0.0081674224,
0.0000021758,
-0.0436480045,
-0.0573105887,
0.0177292861,
-0.0594378486,
-0.0045386627,
-0.0395902656,
0.0515801907,
0.0186095275,
0.0446507707,
-0.0398485884,
0.018656753,
0.006484828,
0.0317264535,
0.0245268308,
0.033418715,
0.023887774,
-0.0459940545,
0.0349570923,
0.0148545876,
0.0195075013,
-0.0566958301,
0.0295177065,
0.018874865,
0.0181988161,
0.0306805391,
-0.0087302625,
0.0166517477,
0.0271594729,
-0.004141354,
-0.0107162846,
0.028624218,
-0.0078091654,
0.0136444801,
0.0070280479,
0.0607595891,
0.0226681679,
-0.0173210911,
-0.0223354958,
-0.0047872844,
-0.0158146676,
0.0297395717,
-0.0619813539,
0.0512129292,
-0.0274921581,
0.0098779863,
-0.0202552229,
0.0032830734,
0.0041821459,
-0.00623857,
-0.0707193762,
0.1013466716,
-0.003513007,
-0.0637771487,
0.0355753005,
-0.004432973,
-0.0237386134,
-0.0496102832,
-0.0058093974,
0.0624223314,
0.0092749055,
0.0468577668,
0.0351419598,
-0.0002543794,
-0.0031938087,
-0.0240357462,
-0.0069677224,
0.0304425154,
-0.0141738737,
0.0490989797,
-0.0145973042,
0.0220322311,
-0.0216228087,
0.000884477,
-0.0285001993,
-0.0350228809,
-0.0808647648,
-0.0358346142,
-0.0203835294,
0.0906347781,
-0.0480545647,
0.0097392779,
0.0080836965,
0.0077473088,
-0.0055723344,
-0.0141332773,
0.0241481028,
0.0348280407,
0.0227649752,
-0.0334719531,
-0.0764663815,
0.0625561327,
-0.0196900405,
0.0292090066,
0.0026297136,
-0.0102044102,
0.0069419378,
-0.0087984316,
0.0279823262,
0.0103179403,
0.0021624477,
0.0223770421,
-0.0075397138,
-0.0043565389,
-0.0635271147,
-0.0452170596,
-0.0196675882,
-0.0491129383,
0.0075253081,
-0.0679640993,
-0.0131681459,
0.0276842155,
-0.0292241313,
0.0043235016,
0.0269252453,
0.0563875027,
-0.0225582905,
0.0423327051,
-0.0085595474,
0.0303837843,
0.0215299148,
0.0235617328,
-0.0126473047,
0.0392552279,
0.0080026882,
0.0111249881,
0.0328514948,
0.036069572,
0.0145051004,
-0.0028377112,
0.0341678225,
-0.0110914623,
0.0194544159,
0.0771933869,
-0.046667736,
-0.0151479514,
-0.0178687945,
0.042328909,
-0.0238265488,
0.0052719275,
0.0325401537,
0.0258096177,
-0.0268110447,
-0.029142607,
0.0117327822,
-0.0020987827,
0.0275267437,
0.0138545837,
-0.0125239519,
0.0237585939,
-0.0705982223,
-0.0031739876,
-0.009579557,
0.0027109494,
-0.0319466889,
-0.0481049381,
-0.0142192058,
0.0187392589,
-0.0203160252,
0.0634536445,
0.0711177289,
-0.0138429813,
0.0046396656,
0.0375379547,
0.0222108811,
-0.0230877753,
-0.035954278,
-0.0445436053,
0.0430388302,
0.0136257485,
0.0433806814,
-0.0569253825,
-0.0282276049,
0.0165349972,
-0.0109413555,
0.0102515975,
-0.0102105206,
-0.0117334547,
-0.0378281362,
-0.023119485,
-0.0260933228,
0.0120005421,
0.0047611217,
0.0123007912,
-0.0027045964,
0.0054282332,
0.0103637381,
-0.0307631455,
0.0161736272,
-0.0016012527,
-0.0132751158,
0.020306766,
0.0026802088,
0.0135748265,
0.0163256582,
0.023114901,
0.0062025776,
0.0412868783,
0.0146886446,
-0.0029912337,
-0.0887013301,
-0.0224388093,
-0.0353560708,
-0.0622743368,
0.0283512659,
-0.0301801171,
-0.0304723438,
-0.0012594555,
-0.0199331976,
-0.0534721091,
0.0205031075,
-0.0297514684,
0.0204596724,
-0.0433113016,
0.0107492749,
0.0104499767,
-0.0495881885,
-0.0593345277,
0.1047898754,
-0.0124841016,
0.0156000294,
0.0258618686,
-0.045780059,
0.0465121865,
-0.0198282804,
0.0183426831,
0.0181383677,
-0.0203242917,
-0.0022574675,
0.0247934684,
0.0037380867,
-0.0667673945,
0.0085185049,
-0.0727083012,
0.0000030905,
-0.0048627662,
0.0405144356,
-0.0053524142,
-0.0024110433,
-0.0059406864,
-0.0105645182,
-0.0670631081,
0.0428020619,
-0.0086073121,
0.0191194154,
0.0076948251,
-0.0043372563,
0.0120072048,
-0.008241402,
0.0047334074,
-0.0367639102,
0.0304379277,
-0.0354996584,
-0.0342152715,
-0.013159127,
0.0334237143,
-0.0638788119,
0.0262963064,
-0.0172705762,
0.0121044368,
0.0144614959,
-0.0422298536,
0.0283188056,
0.0566148832,
-0.0392338037,
-0.0634258091,
0.0625708923,
-0.0334206894,
-0.0477853492,
0.0375263095,
-0.0086995866,
-0.0410528108,
0.0030377994,
-0.0202990733,
-0.0085429875,
0.0201578867,
0.0145864896,
-0.0297250003,
-0.0473665483,
0.0136184311,
-0.0390137248,
0.0091510992,
-0.041856382,
-0.033959493,
0.0298341531,
0.0986720026,
-0.0065220199,
-0.0049527781,
0.0681768581,
-0.0201371834,
0.0077840975,
-0.0468662865,
0.0137185035,
-0.0437071174,
0.0936846137,
-0.0105734551,
0.0008059143,
0.0145964529,
-0.0155895557,
-0.0808875635,
0.0100855101,
0.0387263373,
-0.0398799405,
0.0254189149,
-0.0770986155,
0.023471592,
-0.010203952,
-0.0599570982,
-0.0375978276,
-0.0090327924,
-0.0214570146,
-0.0038757597,
-0.0306642465,
-0.013895371,
0.0014931952,
0.0058061769,
0.0536856018,
0.0005897302,
-0.0424843132,
-0.0239231847,
-0.0069380109,
0.0631345138,
0.0554228984,
0.0020408158,
0.0583047792,
-0.0120335035,
0.044271607,
0.0720150471,
0.0386659503,
-0.010152068,
0.0180879086,
-0.0301862638,
0.0001332734,
0.0125296721,
-0.0391178392,
0.0160201341,
0.0319427475,
-0.0653185174,
-0.0212210417,
0.0982222259,
0.0620055273,
-0.0309756231,
-0.0379148759,
-0.0854927972,
0.0201679841,
0.0156845488,
0.0399258547,
-0.0683062598,
-0.0269874819,
0.0153279873,
0.0378083736,
-0.0264005214,
-0.0450848341,
0.0250807535,
-0.1595239192,
0.0335558206,
-0.0189784188,
0.0030474949,
-0.0535781495,
-0.0145690516,
0.0193498861,
0.0495293103,
-0.034550257,
0.0594407991,
0.0055600116,
0.0205905456,
0.015077061,
-0.0335162953,
0.015917873,
0.0566851236,
0.00433446,
-0.0143847736,
0.0416793153,
0.0232192799,
0.0383288413,
-0.0082389759,
0.0001473629,
-0.060741432,
0.0109774498,
-0.01931113,
-0.0206639376,
0.0466490686,
0.0183651112,
-0.0411847681,
0.0286236685,
-0.0300910156,
0.0148873394,
0.0328011326,
0.1255043149,
-0.0252022333,
-0.0093248468,
-0.0310025867,
-0.0084529445,
-0.0319821239,
0.0594831929,
0.0036125048,
0.0162985511,
-0.0328788236,
-0.0283483155,
-0.0229321104,
0.0314480029,
-0.0130365854,
0.0588328391,
0.0287091229,
0.0306707285,
-0.0787259415,
-0.0360797234,
0.0278328825,
0.060055837,
-0.0273608323,
0.0057323463,
0.0458283313,
0.036254283,
-0.022649318,
-0.025027629,
-0.0565394536,
0.023989642,
0.0157665722,
0.0476145931,
0.0389104076,
-0.0173288509,
-0.0158205144,
-0.0101129692,
-0.0339293554,
-0.0500616021,
-0.0610526912,
0.0367865041,
0.0295393746,
0.0196100511,
-0.0263818614,
-0.0373491906,
0.0163100809,
0.0133858686,
-0.0617675856,
0.0113217765,
0.0213852525,
0.0236609783,
-0.0089856042,
0.0520750508,
-0.0705005974,
0.0042057554,
-0.0105843507,
0.069014065,
-0.0259616524,
-0.0233123917,
0.0531216003,
0.0367095359,
0.0320360139,
0.0479288399,
-0.0339106992,
-0.0104552712,
0.0663118288,
-0.0610435493,
-0.0500590876,
-0.0156212002,
0.0290686637,
0.0002360849,
-0.0236436464,
0.0018723332,
-0.0424339436,
0.0089735743,
0.0128896898,
0.0062604835,
-0.0383996218,
0.0829321295,
0.0326476432,
0.0238348804,
-0.0254859496,
-0.0010096121,
-0.0313888304,
0.0419953391,
0.0540716648,
0.0071649528,
0.0903629661,
0.030101493,
-0.0389694422,
-0.049234651,
-0.0467124246,
-0.0859709084,
-0.081668742,
0.0305850692,
0.0065702591,
0.0308904946,
0.0543410406,
0.0075392532,
-0.0130927013,
-0.0159271173,
0.0068273679,
0.0028594455,
0.0405824371,
-0.0106972642,
0.0742120817,
0.0296410695,
-0.004557163,
0.0092744855,
0.0593217611,
0.0129542015,
-0.0052154623,
-0.0224735141,
-0.0256952513,
0.001505048,
-0.0259567779,
-0.0347695872,
0.0313661173,
0.0111871269,
0.0345861353,
-0.0789345428,
-0.060646534,
-0.0103714801,
0.0044439016,
-0.0004704766,
-0.0178470351,
0.0335796252,
0.0705884397,
0.034096051,
-0.0381280035,
-0.0236959923,
0.0224904586,
-0.0564381443,
-0.0098768417,
-0.0228339732,
-6.66320377e-33,
-0.0218885802,
-0.0438057184,
0.0434230156,
0.0055851806,
-0.0189329721,
0.0118353581,
-0.0295899492,
0.0030278722,
-0.0235910378,
0.0196329262,
-0.0289342776,
0.0120447706,
-0.0125292828,
0.0353495814,
0.0128843598,
-0.020785721,
-0.0239703562,
-0.0047027366,
0.0030778286,
0.0110026002,
0.0717164427,
0.0094883256,
0.02985337,
-0.0254145321,
0.0024961813,
-0.013229996,
0.0282791685,
0.0720705092,
-0.0373755135,
0.0259094089,
0.0174355879,
0.0294737499,
0.0205654539,
-0.0271266401,
0.0176199935,
-0.0008131837,
-0.0662850887,
-0.0472305007,
0.0232833568,
-0.0242251661,
-0.0545653328,
0.0120336488,
0.0050042416,
0.0160253774,
0.0493550114,
-0.0416173004,
0.0334053449,
-0.0315180495,
-0.0044094725,
-0.0422957651,
-0.0204500761,
0.035913866,
-0.0072684819,
-0.0204650201,
-0.0262357499,
0.0952440277,
-0.0025061092,
0.0235284138,
-0.0188780278,
-0.0086980434,
0.0110143553,
-0.0029301278,
0.0360252596,
-0.0031127429,
0.0031751315,
0.024408903,
0.0063520619,
-0.0174687766,
-0.0621710233,
-0.0076532024,
-0.0199027844,
0.0445596389,
0.054572992,
0.0389637239,
0.0047252052,
0.0660390407,
-0.1394512802,
0.017174406,
0.0067770793,
0.0684319362,
0.0092492504,
0.0087721171,
-0.0365534835,
-0.0317905731,
-0.062814571,
0.0066462401,
-0.03494085,
0.0078579569,
0.0280731246,
-0.0099652624,
-0.0028140461,
-0.0231805611,
0.0194522161,
-0.0370823294,
-0.0132857608,
0.0346040986,
-0.0128645729,
0.029520398,
-0.0178895388,
0.0809066147,
-0.0402177274,
0.0212154109,
0.0013587511,
-0.0353961177,
-0.0253454968,
0.0256392285,
0.0094229104,
0.0021879075,
-0.0331282355,
-0.023044413,
-0.0534189269,
0.0273925327,
-0.0285971202,
-0.0024920369,
0.037308827,
0.04438252,
0.023318775,
0.051479619,
0.0074957875,
0.031384062,
-0.0274833851,
0.0007432209,
-0.0014497713,
-0.0335614644,
-0.0042268168,
0.0091481516,
-0.007107263,
-0.0015076345,
-0.0205672327,
-0.060805507,
-0.0042541712,
0.0686685666,
2.949e-7,
0.0347833745,
0.0413406342,
-0.0042463522,
0.0376553722,
0.0438640863,
0.0289770477,
-0.0227433164,
-0.0419951677,
0.0553052984,
-0.0656342283,
-0.0002994279,
0.0281518158,
0.0396706089,
0.0677763224,
-0.0882078037,
-0.0187795926,
-0.0492646471,
-0.073078081,
-0.0379324481,
-0.038310349,
0.077710174,
0.0685026348,
0.0009154475,
-0.012155408,
-0.0050135213,
-0.0129766241,
0.0572141297,
0.0203236379,
-0.0020530275,
-0.0058956295,
0.0441652685,
-0.0135216601,
0.0189282689,
0.0558084883,
0.016397763,
0.0292220488,
0.0042586918,
0.016979808,
-0.0006827996,
-0.0268196035,
0.0042364514,
-0.0417601876,
0.0263758898,
-0.0614885576,
0.1030496284,
-0.049255576,
-0.0105420332,
0.0323092267,
-0.020006584,
-0.0245379452,
-0.0080394652,
0.0142609235,
0.0069467574,
0.0224155132,
-0.0189965442,
-0.0123720663,
0.0285135247,
-0.0889444202,
-0.0026406418,
0.0128704486,
-0.0030475466,
-0.0401565023,
-0.0080094058,
0.0117880963,
0.0050982381,
-0.0345928147,
0.0046037352,
2.77055891e-34,
0.0401362069,
-0.0188968349,
-0.0211507808,
-0.0119354632,
0.0371912457,
-0.0094835833,
-0.0052998881,
-0.0087631745,
0.0268503893,
-0.1136132926,
-0.0204924326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07556v1 | Federated Learning for Short Text Clustering | 2023-11-23T12:19:41 | 2023-11-23T12:19:41 | Mengling Hu, Chaochao Chen, Weiming Liu, Xinting Liao, Xiaolin Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Short text clustering has been popularly studied for its significance in
mining valuable insights from many short texts. In this paper, we focus on the
federated short text clustering (FSTC) problem, i.e., clustering short texts
that are distributed in different clients, which is a realistic problem under
privacy requirements. Compared with the centralized short text clustering
problem that short texts are stored on a central server, the FSTC problem has
not been explored yet. To fill this gap, we propose a Federated Robust Short
Text Clustering (FSTC) framework. FSTC includes two main modules, i.e., robust
short text clustering module and federated cluster center aggregation module.
The robust short text clustering module aims to train an effective short text
clustering model with local data in each client. We innovatively combine
optimal transport to generate pseudo-labels with Gaussian-uniform mixture model
to ensure the reliability of the pseudo-supervised data. The federated cluster
center aggregation module aims to exchange knowledge across clients without
sharing local raw data in an efficient way. The server aggregates the local
cluster centers from different clients and then sends the global centers back
to all clients in each communication round. Our empirical studies on three
short text clustering datasets demonstrate that FSTC significantly outperforms
the federated short text clustering baselines. | [
0.0335286409,
-0.0184063036,
-0.018905703,
0.0331536084,
-0.0173667036,
-0.0105443364,
0.0969125479,
0.0137822125,
0.0669668987,
0.0203707032,
-0.025674019,
-0.0421930142,
0.0167785175,
0.0457561314,
0.0159174446,
-0.0552052148,
0.0154401641,
-0.0009272721,
0.0047645634,
-0.0289211478,
0.0181602966,
-0.0060720569,
0.0195565429,
-0.0038627784,
-0.0003644016,
-0.0256326478,
-0.0232364256,
-0.0509859994,
0.0255653989,
0.0123121152,
0.015054849,
0.0225151815,
0.0156920049,
0.024206074,
0.0000019644,
-0.0084778201,
-0.0957317054,
0.0056759398,
0.0201663598,
0.0245499257,
0.0583564937,
-0.0022688406,
0.0336392075,
0.0210956782,
-0.0202418771,
-0.0110180005,
0.0069362372,
0.0741570517,
0.0506802835,
0.0551094376,
-0.0467641577,
-0.0049706511,
-0.0045742458,
-0.0425646231,
-0.0816771016,
-0.0513854921,
0.0110883638,
-0.0260053407,
-0.0243218131,
0.0375303701,
-0.0010902425,
0.0158350896,
0.0172424242,
0.0438451022,
0.0336846523,
0.0346711874,
-0.0516621284,
0.0173007771,
-0.0280745234,
0.0659553558,
0.0401090384,
0.0182879604,
0.0327934027,
-0.0023397964,
0.0021141525,
0.0029921951,
-0.0218741242,
0.0314616635,
-0.0201263838,
0.0188513212,
-0.0290181767,
0.0477670096,
0.005770525,
-0.0117057823,
-0.0042691347,
0.0532616526,
-0.0112853115,
0.0126777031,
-0.0793207064,
-0.0106414445,
-0.0323262475,
-0.0450441837,
0.0810576677,
0.0142897172,
0.0647571385,
-0.0220847707,
-0.0596445911,
-0.0592891537,
0.018305514,
0.0033834421,
-0.0758078843,
-0.0435678624,
-0.0008785462,
0.0523457862,
-0.0120323189,
-0.0336456671,
0.0196496192,
0.0052589579,
0.0066000423,
-0.0171734076,
-0.0512472093,
0.0009870451,
0.0134820165,
0.0854355544,
-0.0596727356,
0.0110753076,
-0.0163484532,
0.035595797,
-0.0070559341,
0.011190258,
-0.015838366,
0.0105003435,
-0.0046031591,
-0.0191747528,
0.0319347717,
-0.0075886049,
-0.0594911762,
0.0374650918,
-0.0084628901,
0.0137183769,
-0.0026497585,
0.0429208018,
0.0369023979,
-0.0047597503,
-0.04792656,
0.021275904,
-0.0359760486,
-0.0458195582,
-0.0264274627,
-0.0592399091,
-0.0173830651,
-0.0251770988,
-0.0412203148,
-0.0732985288,
0.0278870966,
0.0102723483,
0.0073065003,
0.0069335708,
-0.0317889005,
-0.038475439,
-0.0564573966,
0.0362172388,
-0.0440958068,
-0.0165164489,
0.0255278666,
0.0345525593,
0.0099145118,
0.0173359588,
0.0071018706,
0.0574262962,
0.0944790468,
0.0329324752,
-0.0076819509,
-0.0086673256,
0.055979453,
0.055055663,
0.0265015345,
0.0152021581,
-0.0181122571,
-0.0353190601,
-0.0526322387,
0.0533184372,
-0.0078766616,
-0.0333219245,
0.0187470149,
0.0728604645,
0.0206072312,
0.0018016481,
-0.0867423788,
0.0499199554,
-0.0432388,
0.00809622,
0.0177249722,
-0.0003633179,
-0.0965147838,
-0.0543249026,
0.0820849016,
0.0384035148,
-0.0417456478,
-0.0095335711,
0.0203992762,
-0.0469971225,
0.0208107382,
-0.0362782702,
0.0372020938,
-0.0032862308,
0.0327206701,
0.0255573634,
0.0233513899,
-0.0160268713,
0.0256359875,
-0.0008395025,
0.0418338217,
0.0306740925,
0.0456037521,
-0.0437448211,
0.0183551628,
-0.0319530591,
0.0204508696,
-0.026351599,
-0.0355146378,
-0.0021436326,
0.0408313423,
-0.0391412973,
-0.0615216605,
0.0653891787,
0.0090857279,
-0.0520446897,
-0.0490782969,
0.0397362076,
0.0049697109,
-0.0278886724,
0.0022160157,
0.0106037138,
0.0492410287,
0.0103062512,
0.0312324744,
0.0443054177,
0.0252080541,
-0.0020730312,
0.0092885634,
-0.0441512838,
0.0204227921,
0.0376954079,
-0.0334719345,
-0.0314624012,
-0.0065038051,
-0.059147045,
-0.026290711,
-0.0134851886,
0.0116754128,
-0.0077205999,
-0.030003991,
-0.0375322588,
0.0009480826,
0.0114595219,
0.029209096,
-0.0013448449,
0.0039661182,
-0.0013691833,
0.0331825577,
-0.0205006003,
0.0200864561,
-0.041133903,
0.007382818,
-0.0807628632,
-0.0469489545,
0.038921278,
0.0062561217,
0.0264693815,
-0.0275157075,
-0.0164042488,
0.016746603,
0.0347974002,
-0.0062092734,
-0.0001953218,
-0.0092076417,
-0.02367655,
0.0097668152,
-0.0384549014,
-0.0037243005,
0.0338534229,
0.0270232968,
0.0031183907,
-0.0207529683,
-0.0393985212,
0.0222180802,
-0.040814992,
0.0222725607,
0.0448996127,
0.0077446573,
-0.0243953932,
0.0117653208,
-0.0309679452,
-0.0032737211,
0.0307664517,
-0.0018565583,
-0.0397607796,
-0.0493091494,
0.0212846436,
-0.0549997836,
-0.0254862886,
0.005524274,
-0.0093515264,
-0.0391055197,
0.0093487753,
0.0158649441,
-0.0137388585,
0.0148520777,
-0.0194153339,
-0.0004510926,
-0.0086119035,
0.0147777153,
-0.0076874518,
-0.0583808012,
0.0403317586,
-0.0299416184,
-0.0170380101,
0.0878065899,
0.001636649,
0.0383450314,
-0.059825711,
-0.0347996987,
0.0008680007,
-0.015301547,
0.0244991705,
-0.0678101182,
0.020835761,
0.0498948656,
0.0090561779,
-0.0223657284,
-0.0439938903,
0.0623938441,
-0.0205538068,
0.0308105405,
-0.0444963686,
-0.0607340783,
-0.0506939664,
0.0081024803,
-0.0023340641,
0.0389529169,
-0.0288016405,
-0.0298667997,
0.018190762,
0.0413508601,
-0.0011019686,
0.0164777711,
0.0229408517,
0.0290711317,
0.0010514926,
0.0306851827,
-0.0196563173,
0.0246948209,
-0.0709528551,
0.0231178347,
-0.0048547094,
0.0523054376,
-0.0374733247,
-0.0512192547,
0.0498300083,
0.0491496697,
0.0298600346,
-0.0341993123,
-0.0180715304,
0.0055419295,
0.0402266197,
-0.0264697839,
-0.0775855556,
-0.0114852851,
-0.0712741986,
-0.0334229507,
0.0980786234,
0.0558760986,
-0.0385276899,
0.0593871176,
-0.0528433584,
-0.0090274625,
-0.0158772357,
-0.0200239941,
-0.0153458482,
0.0771079585,
0.0234607141,
-0.0024949268,
0.0503505133,
0.0290261619,
-0.0703872964,
-0.0181531776,
0.0231003538,
0.0743842274,
-0.0067547928,
-0.014953414,
-0.0304728281,
0.0011224137,
0.0051311757,
0.0526432581,
0.0085893208,
-0.0498574711,
-0.0053818822,
-0.0384631306,
0.0047873291,
0.0287845805,
-0.0721298754,
-0.0359484591,
-0.0770512968,
0.0162096173,
0.032699775,
-0.0151847955,
-0.0120771192,
0.0233932044,
-0.0345583968,
0.0131588317,
-0.1157840267,
-0.0155243343,
-0.0237843432,
-0.0365183763,
0.0403314643,
-0.0177930314,
-0.0046353922,
0.0193800069,
-0.027066635,
-0.0320859924,
0.0165293496,
-0.0431245826,
-0.0142371906,
0.0689892024,
-0.0381683595,
0.0110632339,
-0.019619355,
0.0543517321,
-0.0049341861,
-0.0246194042,
0.0290532932,
0.061426729,
0.0072061154,
-0.0035773648,
0.0037619355,
-0.0056503774,
0.0387771875,
0.0203694813,
-0.0255696028,
-0.0198760051,
0.023781484,
0.0019247303,
0.0224748999,
0.037766479,
0.0362724438,
0.0058733621,
-0.0203003269,
0.0136875911,
-0.0686028674,
0.0095186708,
0.0293939393,
0.0126129203,
0.0040989313,
0.0297172945,
0.0412102193,
-0.0661652461,
-0.0427736603,
-0.0006714018,
-0.0599661544,
0.0171767399,
-0.0516834371,
0.0204373095,
0.0348951928,
-0.0009231117,
-0.0194757525,
0.0360366628,
-0.0741082355,
-0.0863996819,
-0.0036316749,
-0.002016837,
0.005547333,
0.0092337439,
-0.0569462627,
-0.0760603398,
0.1028777957,
0.0526290163,
-0.1004743204,
0.0026425964,
0.0000092181,
-0.0683254525,
-0.0010590855,
0.0097668683,
-0.0191012863,
0.0150761092,
0.0223589502,
-0.0757150427,
-0.042112235,
-0.0232961774,
-0.0512321889,
0.0448028967,
0.0539286658,
0.0420664735,
0.0052290251,
-0.0459795035,
0.0344839506,
-0.0066343909,
-0.0036384214,
0.0359837525,
0.0200124569,
0.0227677636,
-0.0097326096,
-0.0039357557,
0.0328680202,
0.0416556224,
-0.0138071775,
0.0098498594,
-0.0115096252,
0.0252512954,
-0.0188987926,
0.0192646869,
0.0190345868,
0.0130053321,
-0.0221710689,
0.0113531416,
0.0557719767,
0.0020039624,
-0.0097247669,
0.0297456179,
0.0172442123,
-0.0258138962,
0.0342552327,
-0.0615593977,
-0.0410577729,
-0.0262213536,
0.0229101162,
-0.0254506934,
0.0150935184,
-0.0121532222,
-0.026367994,
0.0040048971,
-0.0357731991,
0.0082448917,
-0.0344736353,
-0.0334731154,
-0.0230416171,
0.0000808417,
-0.0276224185,
0.0947212949,
0.0728999153,
-0.0300123021,
-0.0334071666,
-0.0103997644,
-0.0530190729,
-0.0778197348,
0.0341212228,
0.0324906856,
0.0697975606,
-0.0085702315,
-0.0168223511,
0.0043006991,
-0.0224270821,
0.064713046,
-0.0414613672,
0.0054232529,
0.0075081666,
0.0304915942,
0.0258115325,
0.0073795877,
-0.0015454895,
-0.0653042942,
0.0008081999,
0.0689604878,
0.012175357,
0.0335600153,
-6.938581688e-33,
0.0242437925,
-0.0403491184,
-0.0586103052,
-0.011896044,
0.0104259206,
0.0391086116,
0.0048924917,
-0.0181764551,
0.0695272461,
0.0046342434,
-0.0196580067,
0.0441653095,
0.0017666268,
0.064423345,
-0.0301889721,
0.0199551713,
0.0036989867,
-0.0045061056,
-0.0335054211,
0.0582711846,
0.1111580357,
0.0291779395,
0.0136255827,
-0.0770447254,
0.0193304289,
-0.0188763458,
-0.029274771,
0.0322572626,
0.0050981939,
0.0235374253,
-0.0396772474,
0.0065427353,
0.0332922526,
0.0188964028,
-0.0114742983,
0.0186469685,
-0.0272085499,
-0.017859282,
-0.0344928317,
-0.0185687579,
-0.0393068902,
-0.0205927547,
0.0386322513,
-0.0099716038,
0.0463760011,
0.001392105,
0.0394279994,
0.0261754058,
-0.0310353674,
0.0168907493,
0.0448989831,
0.0326149426,
-0.0138083519,
0.0323144272,
-0.0114657339,
0.0353081897,
0.0256390106,
0.0048040967,
-0.0784237906,
-0.003721369,
0.0155305574,
-0.0140917255,
-0.0166158322,
0.011477557,
0.0133001506,
0.0452806354,
0.0310947932,
0.0413469784,
-0.0604135618,
0.0213391613,
-0.0164675266,
0.0304907784,
0.02960255,
0.0389052667,
-0.0404576883,
-0.0469116308,
-0.0511097573,
0.0258196834,
-0.0045679128,
-0.0770027488,
0.0232606065,
0.0333992578,
-0.0679802895,
-0.0390847214,
-0.0020074772,
-0.0083824079,
-0.0026988408,
0.0151677206,
-0.0371396691,
0.0274966843,
-0.052517619,
-0.0074824491,
0.0338377804,
-0.001834203,
-0.0458877757,
-0.0121143563,
0.0635167956,
0.0443047397,
0.0108187376,
-0.0087450966,
-0.0582875237,
-0.0113167167,
0.0140709206,
-0.0454666615,
-0.0286719594,
-0.0044919085,
0.0775569603,
-0.0226047263,
-0.0525296628,
0.0022883648,
0.043960657,
0.0230580196,
0.0030910929,
-0.0102011012,
0.0192497149,
0.0128576048,
0.0022222607,
0.0568134859,
0.0442767628,
0.0084652249,
0.0115103414,
-0.0067805056,
-0.0381863303,
-0.0128339166,
0.0173552949,
-0.0224257726,
-0.0264407303,
0.0214614831,
0.0898661092,
-0.0202921722,
0.0208722074,
-0.0504002161,
2.84e-7,
0.0233385079,
-0.0016444101,
0.0219399538,
-0.0789939761,
0.0126702851,
0.0329116359,
-0.0023214896,
0.0581326671,
-0.0284596533,
0.0007611788,
0.0022188199,
0.0209298916,
0.0283740424,
0.0235524066,
-0.0556317046,
0.0215952322,
-0.0349300765,
0.0247717928,
-0.0420972779,
-0.0117070973,
0.0059801517,
0.0621175729,
0.0815489516,
-0.0105057694,
0.0091431951,
-0.0434781983,
0.0267937649,
-0.0149565227,
-0.0386845544,
0.0282818098,
0.0328904241,
0.0389191248,
-0.017556455,
-0.0085385982,
0.0029968617,
-0.0026822127,
-0.0311323144,
0.0481709577,
0.0162803736,
0.0087575791,
0.029522337,
0.0007371058,
-0.0202764571,
0.0315578841,
0.0514774285,
-0.0496189632,
-0.0113552446,
0.0679425746,
0.0232671406,
-0.0328506306,
0.0551020093,
0.0346079171,
-0.0209766217,
0.0561444163,
-0.0253765993,
0.0043292628,
0.0163606275,
-0.0720967874,
0.0253484491,
-0.0238957368,
-0.0271536838,
-0.0206870418,
0.0128597682,
0.0259965565,
0.0101283556,
-0.0279961098,
0.054316923,
2.553714871e-34,
0.0148558142,
-0.0142621798,
-0.0511933677,
-0.0360528566,
-0.0033231913,
-0.0626585335,
-0.0074216812,
-0.0214746501,
0.0322011486,
-0.0497089289,
0.0010073284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13957v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13957v1 | Efficient Trigger Word Insertion | 2023-11-23T12:15:56 | 2023-11-23T12:15:56 | Yueqi Zeng, Ziqiang Li, Pengfei Xia, Lei Liu, Bin Li | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | With the boom in the natural language processing (NLP) field these years,
backdoor attacks pose immense threats against deep neural network models.
However, previous works hardly consider the effect of the poisoning rate. In
this paper, our main objective is to reduce the number of poisoned samples
while still achieving a satisfactory Attack Success Rate (ASR) in text backdoor
attacks. To accomplish this, we propose an efficient trigger word insertion
strategy in terms of trigger word optimization and poisoned sample selection.
Extensive experiments on different datasets and models demonstrate that our
proposed method can significantly improve attack effectiveness in text
classification tasks. Remarkably, our approach achieves an ASR of over 90% with
only 10 poisoned samples in the dirty-label setting and requires merely 1.5% of
the training data in the clean-label setting. | [
0.0409092195,
0.0498607717,
-0.0000995501,
0.0331952348,
-0.0551723428,
-0.0160586014,
0.0147483796,
-0.0152640324,
0.0383192711,
-0.0474852435,
0.0136214281,
0.0096543869,
0.0207145065,
0.059330076,
0.0428841412,
0.0595018342,
0.0631179512,
0.0364969932,
-0.0447899997,
0.0097197499,
-0.0157647952,
-0.0080940844,
-0.003890645,
-0.0010306201,
-0.0075204698,
0.0155711332,
-0.0000452116,
0.0209784601,
0.0578111969,
-0.0253429655,
-0.0024559447,
0.0048822416,
-0.0114277611,
0.0801710561,
0.0000017958,
-0.0286112148,
-0.0270011127,
0.0025485128,
-0.0223014001,
0.011162065,
0.0065216618,
-0.0477153063,
-0.0201112367,
0.0353612676,
-0.0188840758,
-0.0057301009,
0.003888312,
0.0687344149,
0.0480097309,
0.0841485858,
-0.0178725217,
-0.0246605892,
0.063267149,
-0.0348227322,
-0.0078373645,
-0.0417948849,
0.0401555486,
-0.0521431528,
-0.0306322854,
0.0227379389,
-0.0257033594,
0.0488618352,
0.0175666697,
-0.0270928144,
-0.0076315179,
0.040233966,
0.0020330956,
-0.0069726319,
-0.0192856025,
0.0524395742,
-0.0604230352,
0.0106985867,
-0.0183803309,
-0.0444472991,
-0.0007123893,
-0.0264081545,
0.0369051397,
-0.0065663294,
0.0163635779,
0.009752295,
0.0127508193,
-0.0024177281,
0.0668644607,
0.0248993617,
0.0076771448,
0.0209959019,
0.0105615081,
-0.0594046898,
0.0139618069,
-0.0543825664,
0.0153586939,
-0.045943141,
-0.000479272,
0.0029320712,
0.012726564,
0.028135078,
-0.0813437551,
-0.075997375,
0.015098908,
-0.0559711717,
0.0136206429,
0.0116782049,
-0.0161036588,
0.0300569218,
-0.0184551924,
0.0171823893,
0.0003262442,
0.0571943447,
0.0156327076,
0.0092623783,
-0.0108947782,
-0.0210716985,
-0.0438277535,
0.0047188438,
-0.0237054471,
-0.0408109538,
-0.0492355712,
0.0018832957,
-0.0078759817,
-0.0037502947,
0.001658304,
-0.00035151,
-0.0303432401,
0.0434528179,
0.03624117,
-0.0545579046,
0.0019375056,
0.0037029814,
-0.0149733918,
-0.0667965636,
-0.0344610512,
-0.0061134468,
-0.0019676061,
-0.0224253777,
0.0161935817,
0.0494184382,
0.0181900095,
-0.0483705997,
-0.0579464212,
-0.0485527813,
-0.0292670522,
0.0420692675,
-0.0225277469,
-0.02962685,
-0.0315640345,
-0.0670728162,
-0.0117225749,
-0.0194443334,
0.0210755672,
0.0532423183,
-0.053695254,
0.0791934878,
-0.0156765804,
-0.0457193516,
0.054080952,
0.0118025513,
0.0036363986,
0.0482376553,
0.0485638864,
0.0724653006,
0.0562916808,
0.0050465688,
0.0143767996,
0.0292568244,
0.0483716093,
0.0233491007,
-0.0034413643,
-0.0236749165,
-0.0021395138,
0.0061773965,
-0.0197816081,
0.0282894969,
-0.0261219814,
-0.0426291674,
0.0612939596,
0.0107417833,
0.0047220779,
0.0427811109,
0.0190929268,
0.0060280873,
-0.0558083095,
-0.0597821139,
-0.0590540171,
-0.0113359038,
-0.044502262,
-0.0320551768,
0.0302905682,
-0.0235489663,
0.0109497141,
-0.0461793318,
-0.0027775853,
-0.0112682972,
0.017686002,
-0.0158728696,
0.0101525867,
0.0692597479,
-0.0391523503,
0.0240599345,
-0.0126189301,
-0.0032169744,
-0.0305801909,
-0.034145765,
-0.067928344,
0.0237062331,
0.0490048528,
-0.0082079824,
0.01108531,
-0.0821005553,
-0.0075850026,
0.0219715089,
-0.010579044,
0.0270747188,
0.0096195415,
-0.0432503037,
-0.0204886924,
-0.0004288087,
0.0169715174,
0.0295176506,
-0.0028237489,
0.0280149467,
0.0370178819,
0.0253626145,
-0.030123122,
0.0610271618,
0.0047644433,
-0.1094414741,
0.0378970094,
0.0439033657,
0.0232922863,
-0.0078957789,
-0.0169238895,
0.0114659928,
0.0128278965,
-0.0114590451,
-0.0575806573,
-0.0470346808,
0.0204905309,
-0.0318660885,
0.012604312,
0.002180415,
0.0177967828,
0.0871377662,
-0.0367772728,
-0.0271020271,
0.0054326286,
-0.0194937307,
-0.0187982712,
-0.0155138299,
-0.0252294429,
0.0076305605,
0.0494651832,
-0.0236999504,
0.0377531052,
-0.0317977406,
0.0138878301,
-0.0309942104,
0.0205349457,
0.0398399197,
0.0073180385,
-0.0552833416,
-0.0107593015,
-0.0445869192,
0.0107740015,
0.0075101117,
-0.0055929003,
-0.0158715285,
-0.0068950062,
-0.0161774904,
0.0072787823,
-0.0301276986,
0.0083992416,
-0.0083810091,
-0.0039672283,
-0.0034264848,
-0.0097911991,
-0.0108780563,
-0.0274370052,
-0.0362979993,
0.0277580805,
0.0080748135,
-0.0076937666,
-0.0129319178,
0.0003965165,
-0.0214200858,
-0.0269936826,
0.0581629798,
-0.0067674881,
-0.0211066045,
-0.0141335018,
-0.0079068728,
0.0297502503,
0.0183640327,
-0.0121947573,
-0.0584768057,
-0.0086509632,
0.0341291763,
-0.0735590234,
0.0643647835,
-0.0046013971,
0.0237761065,
0.0448439531,
0.0350018553,
-0.0126549406,
0.0199519452,
0.0205263663,
0.0300759766,
-0.0433748774,
0.0147585645,
0.0237455461,
0.0575640947,
0.0197708048,
-0.0252449177,
-0.0139746042,
0.0136027504,
0.0129806902,
-0.0240635127,
-0.0078777457,
-0.0547498651,
-0.0528157316,
-0.0317277499,
-0.0179993659,
-0.0554674007,
0.0633235499,
-0.0239624325,
0.0400772654,
-0.0569002591,
-0.0503960438,
-0.0023260745,
0.0133760925,
0.0011196261,
0.0181118567,
0.0115505839,
-0.0207777843,
-0.0184857529,
-0.0100053605,
0.0338098295,
-0.0090000629,
0.0176601205,
0.0149752768,
0.0078866417,
-0.0127281034,
-0.0183022395,
-0.0685881749,
-0.0957368389,
-0.0431153364,
0.0173863117,
0.0169910882,
0.0043175449,
-0.0226142257,
-0.0411494151,
-0.0153180389,
0.0262314081,
-0.0006993891,
-0.0009309881,
-0.0357981846,
0.0158602595,
0.0562475324,
-0.0882206708,
0.002759262,
0.0450133905,
0.0250525996,
0.0784484297,
0.037900079,
0.0327844098,
-0.0480419844,
-0.0139446966,
0.0018163705,
-0.0082825823,
-0.0172301624,
-0.0105073638,
-0.0409357809,
-0.030254351,
-0.011257858,
0.0394338071,
0.0128085474,
-0.0243458189,
0.0033981293,
0.0288274605,
0.021431135,
0.0115101989,
0.0001889024,
-0.0548129715,
-0.0490973331,
0.0322611481,
0.0194118954,
-0.0345409401,
-0.0336872302,
-0.0254953336,
-0.1230491102,
-0.0385856368,
-0.001691349,
-0.0472141281,
-0.0027744535,
-0.0243716985,
-0.0186829846,
-0.0012250916,
0.0263869017,
-0.0224499237,
0.0537614897,
-0.0289007928,
-0.0112040648,
0.0022556132,
-0.0383822545,
-0.0027843525,
-0.0318617709,
0.0387085266,
0.073936522,
0.0456977077,
-0.047869239,
-0.0065913801,
0.0636257082,
-0.0166540351,
-0.0194649063,
0.0180473998,
0.0960220397,
-0.0351757668,
-0.0214345939,
0.0386458263,
0.0602522418,
-0.023817068,
0.0062040868,
-0.0049503446,
0.0494752899,
0.0169161316,
-0.0144689856,
-0.0330234617,
-0.0043728435,
0.0597252063,
0.0423174314,
0.0218559653,
-0.0571622439,
0.000929888,
-0.055899132,
-0.0202036742,
-0.0457373187,
-0.0472428016,
0.0332411826,
-0.0200858526,
-0.0579304211,
-0.0681369826,
-0.032450553,
0.0049468456,
0.033271715,
0.0193285011,
0.0035986553,
-0.0384404622,
0.0050836131,
-0.0449129045,
0.0009977218,
-0.0002166789,
0.0681605265,
-0.0249058008,
0.0391999632,
0.0255526863,
0.0124716517,
-0.0440572426,
0.0527542681,
-0.0893818736,
-0.0785970688,
0.027987536,
0.020700058,
0.0070035574,
0.0373551287,
-0.0381498784,
-0.0716996938,
0.1146385148,
0.0395177454,
0.0068648951,
-0.0140072377,
0.0785433799,
-0.0368837528,
0.0005469982,
0.0352219045,
-0.028041495,
-0.0119966203,
0.0581646115,
0.0086380355,
-0.0189788528,
0.0207975954,
-0.0075343577,
0.0191634893,
0.094479464,
-0.0183685832,
0.0172502287,
0.0070155179,
0.0662741512,
0.0006086989,
-0.000282311,
-0.0147286793,
0.0467145182,
0.0201057829,
-0.0186744295,
-0.0255356189,
-0.0294321198,
0.0193453711,
-0.014358636,
0.0043847649,
-0.0179972854,
0.026638167,
0.0586092956,
0.0547647513,
0.0292154923,
-0.0329180099,
0.0425280966,
0.0361749642,
0.0163056608,
-0.014942579,
-0.0244523622,
0.0449552573,
0.0121388808,
-0.0154906381,
0.010103018,
-0.0713342652,
0.014498706,
-0.0010958592,
-0.0046104528,
0.0191434156,
-0.0272519439,
-0.0124773588,
-0.0078972066,
-0.0072629936,
0.0168942306,
-0.0165165421,
-0.0221602842,
-0.0336735956,
0.0174365509,
-0.0043911617,
-0.007204724,
0.047018718,
0.0486609861,
0.0181289017,
0.0520067811,
0.0128496308,
-0.0173292328,
-0.0105681336,
0.0274816081,
0.026149096,
0.036527656,
-0.0229259338,
-0.0162848327,
-0.0271043442,
-0.0809378251,
0.0669772476,
-0.0048085554,
0.0265474934,
0.048626285,
0.0097001363,
0.0328493901,
0.0278619453,
0.0380559638,
-0.0581601709,
0.0419230647,
0.0311107505,
-0.0515704527,
0.039607022,
-5.269245263e-33,
0.0531168953,
-0.0226098187,
-0.0131665962,
0.0493383519,
0.0082969544,
0.0123729603,
0.0186539143,
-0.0299791973,
-0.0139012327,
0.0304159727,
-0.0175247509,
0.0276056845,
-0.0063260496,
0.0318609364,
-0.0313454159,
-0.0351282507,
0.0096215932,
-0.00618194,
-0.0024402523,
-0.0085653793,
0.0727171227,
0.0579795018,
0.0354533084,
-0.0515467525,
0.0189943835,
0.0017551441,
-0.0103501733,
0.0055695986,
-0.0331609137,
0.0586530194,
0.0056942278,
0.0354254879,
0.0031368393,
-0.0450522825,
0.0095630353,
0.0664821416,
0.0057491176,
-0.0203090664,
-0.0787306428,
0.0041096262,
-0.018657783,
-0.0518521853,
0.0483198725,
-0.0024136363,
0.0094669545,
-0.0059835007,
0.0143234255,
-0.0067767496,
-0.0555807985,
-0.0667935312,
-0.027740635,
0.0335276388,
0.0149425007,
-0.0037144318,
-0.0082974564,
-0.0180965215,
0.0200842209,
0.0003126979,
-0.0769910365,
-0.0238865502,
0.0371540599,
0.028639257,
-0.0165763944,
-0.0024996344,
-0.0037898682,
0.0609313324,
0.0407831073,
-0.0063302726,
-0.0116241071,
0.0204777829,
0.0252300575,
0.0129638389,
0.080158025,
0.0792768151,
0.1062210724,
-0.0395543352,
-0.1030894145,
-0.0343609825,
-0.0055028447,
-0.0045408574,
0.0102848122,
0.0111062415,
-0.0604995601,
0.0189806316,
-0.06002561,
-0.0163418464,
-0.0392642245,
-0.0211982131,
0.011259797,
0.0412828214,
-0.0288357176,
0.0216747075,
-0.0112792132,
-0.0619646199,
0.0033608479,
0.0265231021,
-0.0008640071,
-0.0153137622,
-0.0192073956,
0.0128494278,
0.0019771734,
0.0167281553,
-0.02490687,
-0.0462473929,
0.050040409,
-0.0080991024,
0.0586050525,
0.0028166256,
-0.0843257234,
-0.0194586627,
-0.0007298347,
0.0092088394,
0.0504663214,
0.0474875271,
0.0107493559,
-0.0094124945,
0.0047022682,
0.0256393868,
0.0409867205,
0.032537248,
-0.0011255423,
0.0257526916,
-0.0262340568,
-0.0181288198,
-0.0092574088,
-0.012689854,
0.0235557482,
0.0683604181,
0.0213922374,
-0.0961544365,
0.0132550737,
-0.0106635774,
2.706e-7,
0.009470881,
0.0287453681,
-0.0087036649,
0.003233975,
-0.0038153969,
0.0706938431,
0.0000544225,
0.0930396989,
-0.0179902986,
-0.0196445379,
-0.0160060525,
-0.0368359759,
0.0346292481,
0.0127843274,
-0.0981796458,
0.0201172866,
-0.0582844764,
0.0590175353,
-0.0182230026,
-0.0082290024,
0.0216860063,
0.0977360383,
0.0295385327,
-0.0414936319,
-0.0231642239,
-0.0795417875,
0.0063580386,
-0.0018808948,
-0.0117558436,
0.0075267614,
0.0796322525,
0.0444531441,
-0.0079262853,
0.0346045643,
-0.0854786485,
0.0274356809,
-0.0354427546,
-0.0103970924,
-0.0178627372,
-0.0517904833,
-0.0359625295,
-0.0377154499,
0.004481975,
0.0021249207,
0.0760780498,
0.0083306814,
0.0176338945,
-0.0393666215,
-0.0102300318,
-0.0153941931,
0.0882648975,
-0.0501032993,
0.0146439727,
0.0139033878,
0.0003162494,
-0.000768494,
0.0080734547,
-0.1212128624,
0.008211446,
-0.0328858048,
0.0008678777,
-0.0071691852,
-0.0236035455,
0.0247447435,
0.0383448005,
-0.007455606,
-0.0208489057,
2.327364479e-34,
0.0143463155,
-0.0567482859,
0.0144041916,
0.0209381673,
0.0169542339,
0.0012720753,
0.0357364081,
-0.009777505,
0.009537016,
-0.0466006212,
-0.0409967043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13951v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13951v2 | MLLM-Bench: Evaluating Multimodal LLMs with Per-sample Criteria | 2023-11-23T12:04:25 | 2024-04-27T04:32:05 | Wentao Ge, Shunian Chen, Guiming Hardy Chen, Zhihong Chen, Junying Chen, Shuo Yan, Chenghao Zhu, Ziyue Lin, Wenya Xie, Xinyi Zhang, Yichen Chai, Xiaoyu Liu, Dingjie Song, Xidong Wang, Anningzhe Gao, Zhiyi Zhang, Jianquan Li, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) (e.g., GPT-4V, LLaVA, and Claude-3)
have broadened the scope of AI applications. Yet, evaluating their performance
presents a significant challenge owing to the inherently subjective nature of
tasks that do not yield clear-cut solutions especially for those open-ended
queries. Existing automatic evaluation methodologies are mainly limited in
evaluating objective queries without considering real-world user experiences,
inadequately addressing the nuances of creative and associative multimodal
tasks. In our paper, we propose a new evaluation paradigm for MLLMs, which is
evaluating MLLMs with \textit{per-sample criteria} using potent MLLM as the
judge. To validate the feasibility and effectiveness of this paradigm, we
design a benchmark, dubbed \textit{MLLM-Bench}, with the evaluation samples
across six critical levels following the revised Bloom's Taxonomy with the
ethical consideration. We benchmark 21 popular MLLMs in a pairwise-comparison
fashion, showing diverse performance across models. Moreover, the validity of
our benchmark manifests itself in reaching 88.02\% agreement with human
evaluation. We contend that the proposed paradigm explores the potential of
MLLMs as effective evaluation tools with the help of per-sample criteria, and
that MLLM-Bench will serve as a catalyst for encouraging the development of
user-centric MLLMs tailored to real-world applications. Our benchmark data,
online leaderboard and submission entry are at https://mllm-bench.llmzoo.com. | [
0.0268566683,
0.0660955012,
-0.0037777303,
0.067532286,
-0.0821444839,
0.0109728156,
0.0260671154,
-0.0057192752,
-0.0086581837,
-0.0578740723,
-0.0894747674,
-0.0388535969,
-0.0091581075,
0.0287651848,
0.029227009,
-0.030654557,
-0.0012505454,
-0.03321537,
-0.0272240974,
0.00750193,
-0.0019742174,
0.004231228,
-0.0245207753,
0.0558543429,
-0.0064672418,
0.0096874945,
0.0152326403,
0.0346804112,
-0.0017989038,
-0.0164003689,
-0.0372280739,
0.0274889134,
0.0257509388,
0.0100451969,
0.0000020357,
-0.066376999,
0.0114459451,
-0.0298511647,
0.0577277504,
-0.0169385914,
0.0741931945,
0.0125315562,
0.0066807931,
-0.0164007973,
-0.0434034206,
0.0071518919,
0.0415349826,
0.025448909,
0.0500007831,
0.0472841151,
-0.0061320965,
-0.0411592722,
0.0124219488,
0.0064384528,
0.0309944507,
-0.0413684063,
-0.0020122891,
0.0038376532,
0.0321744606,
-0.0341216065,
-0.0259050447,
0.0660585389,
0.0354631506,
-0.0322678089,
0.0077786958,
0.0263816677,
-0.0281389263,
-0.0267283022,
-0.0021927268,
0.0933728591,
-0.0190588515,
0.019003503,
-0.0090972427,
-0.0010569728,
-0.0130876554,
-0.0088722957,
-0.0618816428,
0.0389475115,
-0.0067364718,
-0.0039821952,
-0.0468082204,
0.0374079421,
0.0419810712,
0.0176040828,
0.0038465983,
0.0571243986,
0.0261382051,
-0.0210519731,
0.0465472601,
-0.0162900295,
-0.0104112271,
-0.0227038413,
-0.0136303855,
0.0098425578,
-0.0118765943,
0.0084862439,
-0.0256419461,
0.0105956309,
0.0055637956,
-0.0370231867,
0.0809679776,
0.032567855,
-0.0108025335,
0.0817983449,
-0.0121742953,
0.0447338931,
-0.0033321662,
0.0479836948,
-0.0456616096,
-0.0218551774,
-0.0401771814,
0.0106511051,
-0.0053752176,
0.021842625,
-0.0499289744,
-0.0333580747,
-0.0290586408,
0.0145546487,
-0.0012828039,
-0.0073072175,
-0.0027474002,
0.0125388019,
0.0055823815,
-0.0149273565,
-0.0370661803,
0.0138670607,
-0.0118469847,
-0.0095661171,
-0.0012263836,
-0.0441397727,
0.0440939218,
0.0531014465,
-0.0152446786,
-0.0476195924,
0.0109895784,
0.1060556024,
-0.0130016282,
-0.0584403686,
-0.0329936519,
-0.0158887282,
-0.0032507428,
-0.0737537965,
0.0264302474,
-0.0609651506,
0.0509768054,
-0.0067436411,
0.0046058334,
-0.0179620646,
-0.0030527024,
0.0135846492,
0.0032642863,
0.0809364766,
0.0360728092,
0.0294746198,
0.036289338,
0.0374072902,
-0.0105045326,
0.0719314888,
0.0577472299,
0.0610345192,
0.0521847904,
0.0012967383,
0.0367868319,
0.0403581411,
-0.0153310401,
0.0054519251,
-0.0554013848,
0.0226790998,
-0.0413914584,
0.0847820938,
0.012442206,
0.0803158358,
-0.0204089694,
-0.0275783446,
0.1027310789,
0.0443294048,
0.0174269229,
-0.0211821236,
0.0612630099,
-0.0420832112,
0.0160604175,
0.005132366,
-0.0310935806,
0.0710577369,
-0.0262625497,
-0.0055699749,
0.0573340803,
0.0357425474,
0.0082156667,
-0.0389544703,
-0.0125218388,
-0.011668331,
0.005491463,
0.0168528762,
0.0226267744,
-0.0297854487,
-0.05311165,
-0.0014399028,
-0.0104187718,
-0.0664632767,
0.0117541626,
-0.0484863482,
0.013819024,
0.0717014968,
0.0767733306,
-0.0030767678,
-0.0021208772,
0.0012695084,
0.0129856393,
0.0493698679,
0.0207367837,
-0.0085405344,
0.0396660492,
-0.0561598875,
-0.0335665382,
-0.0185037069,
-0.0213338863,
0.0022744944,
-0.0039426172,
0.0000318434,
-0.0065853954,
-0.0786370486,
-0.0092397593,
0.0159891453,
-0.0175997391,
-0.0259872358,
0.0022163347,
0.0172129627,
0.00586621,
0.0040982747,
-0.0165053289,
0.0196807738,
0.0203344394,
-0.0506219566,
-0.0130629689,
0.0230095647,
-0.0220355447,
0.0029506569,
0.0268609915,
-0.0762165636,
0.0122926291,
0.0395248793,
-0.0078749917,
-0.0100056408,
0.0081791263,
-0.0260192938,
0.0066827633,
-0.06557668,
-0.0163936019,
-0.0063021141,
-0.0203269646,
-0.0714355111,
0.0529141761,
-0.0372644849,
0.0100797014,
0.0007018945,
0.0012272317,
0.0119051924,
-0.0324994326,
-0.0699833781,
0.0488811508,
0.0337444693,
0.0433712117,
0.0106470864,
0.0147257987,
-0.0507449247,
-0.0388665907,
-0.1216199994,
-0.0135849044,
-0.0158580709,
-0.028245477,
0.0077207182,
-0.008198062,
-0.0108136972,
0.0118208611,
-0.0380509794,
-0.0156387351,
0.0074265753,
0.0197199173,
0.0299833585,
0.0210471489,
-0.0080023324,
-0.022265777,
-0.0126500949,
-0.0059688883,
0.062094029,
0.0108514149,
0.0142918229,
0.0070442925,
-0.0218683276,
-0.0777238533,
-0.0161646791,
-0.0240190495,
-0.0213984679,
0.0220852122,
-0.0522225946,
0.0356573015,
0.0749510378,
0.0326829702,
0.0115243839,
0.0620433837,
-0.0293993969,
-0.03889497,
0.0007019926,
0.0011742006,
-0.0240879506,
-0.0106807174,
-0.0255581439,
0.0256942157,
0.0122434618,
0.0301445387,
0.0262843631,
-0.0502062291,
0.0499965772,
-0.0286752284,
-0.0687758699,
-0.056023147,
0.0287873466,
-0.005820618,
0.0572982766,
-0.0237671323,
-0.0570155978,
0.0630351901,
-0.0253718942,
-0.0139167868,
-0.0022036829,
0.0011504835,
-0.0578882694,
0.0886790976,
0.0046024648,
0.0557974763,
-0.0483100489,
0.0086973123,
-0.0283877552,
0.0004522087,
0.015987685,
-0.0526428744,
0.0792719945,
-0.0465696417,
0.0044937953,
-0.0094333664,
-0.0458610021,
-0.0113317147,
-0.0350154862,
-0.0009340711,
-0.0144892838,
0.0065146037,
-0.004438661,
-0.0106712598,
0.033125028,
0.0334473662,
-0.0090733804,
-0.008314684,
-0.0277368166,
0.0016096029,
0.013803917,
0.0396694243,
0.0273453426,
-0.0054969094,
-0.0267515164,
-0.0045793713,
0.020496184,
0.0193648022,
0.0010398785,
-0.0456059277,
0.0433241092,
0.0371198952,
0.0095416391,
-0.0114117851,
0.0179870538,
0.0514253266,
-0.0275818892,
0.0239373986,
0.0844462439,
0.0091808056,
-0.0482577868,
-0.0173772685,
0.015124605,
0.006537376,
0.0155528681,
0.0206311271,
-0.08309035,
-0.040564727,
-0.0151716592,
0.0378413945,
0.0002056751,
-0.0354615152,
-0.0170698091,
-0.1324454397,
0.050985571,
-0.0081375614,
-0.0387621373,
-0.0207513068,
-0.0148663875,
-0.0039506424,
-0.019608235,
0.0090716593,
0.0250599943,
-0.0120919459,
-0.0181842502,
-0.0036176259,
0.0238888711,
-0.0625270382,
0.0342343748,
-0.0408531316,
0.0307671651,
0.0571647882,
0.0536091328,
-0.0055806376,
-0.0630462393,
0.0299452413,
0.0088398857,
-0.0048379493,
-0.0029418941,
0.0303485096,
-0.0161511898,
-0.0117624439,
-0.0178535469,
0.0015493865,
-0.0110748941,
0.001477805,
-0.0111212907,
0.0479816571,
-0.0279452056,
0.0152620943,
-0.0593820252,
0.0241959095,
-0.019804718,
0.0848361626,
0.0438635536,
-0.0545682572,
-0.0191424061,
-0.017043449,
-0.015315271,
-0.0662098005,
-0.0444849804,
0.0017804997,
0.0128911296,
0.0395803973,
-0.0656666532,
-0.0232822653,
-0.001683603,
0.051681973,
0.0114449356,
0.0015295955,
-0.0469097458,
0.0045685233,
-0.0306435693,
0.0234633964,
-0.0098287901,
0.0420466885,
-0.0697645545,
0.0347869061,
0.0281703137,
-0.0522551388,
0.0001531346,
0.0322133787,
-0.0788658857,
-0.0497554839,
-0.0327557437,
0.0563273914,
0.0211751498,
-0.0218448155,
-0.0032317205,
-0.0842984542,
0.006472962,
0.0572078638,
-0.0012111905,
0.0372500606,
0.0099328402,
0.0370364338,
-0.0043870471,
0.0281949192,
-0.0367763564,
0.0043836362,
-0.0026696771,
0.0499434322,
0.0343160816,
-0.0433682166,
0.0101587279,
0.0323222317,
0.0160684139,
-0.0418018699,
-0.0311527997,
-0.0199502278,
-0.0183960013,
-0.0058252271,
-0.0465283319,
-0.0641794726,
-0.0057739164,
0.017441567,
0.0240451228,
-0.0153697273,
0.0059491321,
0.0006181191,
0.0220693815,
-0.063951239,
0.0191252436,
0.0263420455,
-0.0443768576,
-0.0013574201,
0.030582048,
-0.0116061382,
0.0310238246,
-0.0233502891,
0.032398399,
-0.0081538428,
0.054449603,
0.0317312516,
-0.0156456567,
-0.0012542448,
0.0828924775,
-0.0303653739,
-0.0317433365,
-0.005897548,
0.0429870188,
0.0920868218,
0.0037695817,
0.0478204377,
-0.0145249423,
0.0114188502,
-0.0452050008,
0.0269443691,
0.0070955032,
-0.0225393921,
0.0236195941,
0.0308466461,
0.0177441146,
-0.0063441386,
0.0446568951,
-0.0172102116,
0.0219359677,
-0.0065225661,
-0.0028701797,
-0.028381994,
-0.0236112941,
0.0348106772,
0.0147980927,
-0.0006175056,
-0.0133447424,
-0.08072377,
-0.0421200879,
0.0118858293,
0.045488596,
-0.0028624276,
-0.0015857146,
0.0471322313,
0.0934586748,
0.0167065822,
0.0126578938,
-0.0460886806,
-0.0269050971,
-0.0137427188,
-0.0056228363,
0.0075149159,
-6.311046968e-33,
-0.0154999085,
-0.0436326228,
0.0348311588,
-0.0181437023,
-0.0386569723,
0.0005807618,
-0.0320818983,
0.0185346492,
0.0091113178,
-0.0188897084,
0.0041757352,
-0.0481908917,
-0.0192579813,
-0.0058858823,
-0.0051711774,
-0.0352434888,
-0.011840554,
-0.0077730813,
-0.05889038,
-0.0179621,
0.0183276776,
0.0131146135,
0.0286000799,
-0.0597399697,
0.005227509,
0.0190075021,
-0.034253668,
0.0103071369,
-0.0319785811,
0.1028588563,
-0.0157191157,
0.0501016676,
0.0256315041,
-0.0072804387,
-0.0080027999,
-0.0166259948,
-0.0198145211,
0.0107652172,
0.0158803686,
0.0040685385,
-0.0557466596,
0.0034409594,
0.0793228745,
-0.0024226594,
-0.0513690747,
0.0019350108,
0.030112749,
-0.0121034468,
-0.0213487074,
-0.0258108061,
-0.0395484641,
0.0171348192,
0.0013831145,
-0.0222924966,
0.019099215,
0.0291901715,
0.0047565633,
0.0503099076,
-0.0529610775,
0.0468994081,
-0.041594442,
0.0032089693,
0.1021247879,
0.010566161,
0.0079223979,
0.077526696,
0.0407098606,
-0.0064178952,
-0.0075152162,
0.0003794803,
0.0453456864,
0.0697530732,
0.030396292,
0.1044366807,
0.0067500533,
0.0152975367,
-0.0069242516,
0.0354145057,
-0.0074880663,
0.0050415285,
0.0252768882,
0.0440306626,
-0.0473033451,
-0.0055725905,
-0.0560176149,
0.0041262344,
-0.0614492148,
-0.0081915269,
0.0622160025,
-0.0004974866,
-0.0077617685,
-0.0144171733,
0.0621284992,
-0.0364407785,
-0.0238240082,
-0.0295405313,
-0.0133704385,
0.0427226946,
0.0098830014,
0.0268210135,
-0.0167491883,
0.0129191801,
0.0186945517,
0.0045648851,
0.0247700252,
-0.0085994825,
-0.0348009132,
0.0501927249,
-0.0283077229,
-0.0021354882,
-0.0412810817,
-0.0053204144,
-0.0177155361,
0.0131105883,
0.0261660945,
-0.034620367,
-0.0402997844,
0.0344385728,
0.0096788025,
0.0090926029,
-0.0430545211,
-0.074538663,
0.002665122,
-0.0117779095,
-0.0344763771,
0.0280663408,
-0.0127295479,
-0.0570904389,
0.0344257578,
-0.0372242779,
-0.012841885,
0.0417023934,
2.812e-7,
0.0338041,
0.0274543986,
-0.0102195181,
0.0448808447,
-0.0019563858,
0.0389306545,
-0.0540639758,
0.0200058725,
-0.0124791255,
-0.0211385675,
-0.01112583,
0.0293748993,
0.0515100956,
0.0371043943,
-0.0533300936,
0.0071383626,
-0.0288404003,
-0.0050000404,
-0.0565172583,
0.0039590863,
0.0599526986,
0.0278889425,
0.0050834939,
-0.0315168761,
0.0004844783,
-0.059849374,
0.0706989691,
-0.048671212,
-0.0502884351,
-0.0081600007,
0.0750859007,
0.0129362112,
0.0091062617,
-0.0127579384,
0.0077674398,
-0.0316490307,
0.0778411031,
0.0551780462,
0.0125910221,
-0.0794693232,
0.0178910289,
-0.0052255164,
-0.0060929917,
-0.0643549785,
0.0684772581,
0.0356898457,
-0.0009436381,
-0.0167479403,
0.0054069203,
-0.0243304279,
0.0653305426,
-0.0368697047,
-0.0514646769,
0.0023060564,
0.0405326337,
-0.0125493584,
-0.0201670509,
-0.0628743768,
-0.0097405529,
-0.0411685295,
-0.0393183865,
-0.0410670377,
-0.0498854592,
0.0086882105,
0.0045502535,
-0.0794893354,
-0.0544854105,
2.553150312e-34,
0.0293704309,
-0.011236798,
0.0325407162,
-0.0185611788,
0.0295886565,
0.0301601514,
-0.0431858897,
-0.0260768812,
-0.0272671245,
-0.0647305772,
-0.0107753286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13937v1 | Exploring Methods for Cross-lingual Text Style Transfer: The Case of Text Detoxification | 2023-11-23T11:40:28 | 2023-11-23T11:40:28 | Daryna Dementieva, Daniil Moskovskiy, David Dale, Alexander Panchenko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text detoxification is the task of transferring the style of text from toxic
to neutral. While here are approaches yielding promising results in monolingual
setup, e.g., (Dale et al., 2021; Hallinan et al., 2022), cross-lingual transfer
for this task remains a challenging open problem (Moskovskiy et al., 2022). In
this work, we present a large-scale study of strategies for cross-lingual text
detoxification -- given a parallel detoxification corpus for one language; the
goal is to transfer detoxification ability to another language for which we do
not have such a corpus. Moreover, we are the first to explore a new task where
text translation and detoxification are performed simultaneously, providing
several strong baselines for this task. Finally, we introduce new automatic
detoxification evaluation metrics with higher correlations with human judgments
than previous benchmarks. We assess the most promising approaches also with
manual markup, determining the answer for the best strategy to transfer the
knowledge of text detoxification between languages. | [
0.0213138424,
0.0814495981,
-0.0127887018,
0.028961435,
-0.0440240428,
0.0206855386,
-0.0007496262,
0.0527031571,
0.0072845542,
-0.0085548293,
-0.0556703471,
0.0191560369,
0.0087438347,
0.0198033489,
-0.0068990956,
-0.0436449014,
0.0147547219,
0.0020028148,
-0.0228444412,
0.0010732949,
0.0520867147,
0.0333259925,
0.0297220424,
-0.0024876117,
0.0116064707,
-0.0367433429,
0.0287696086,
0.0384030379,
0.0426141135,
-0.0022459768,
0.030356193,
0.0335280113,
-0.0272364207,
0.0559770875,
0.0000018145,
-0.013386921,
-0.0341878235,
-0.0019262147,
0.0537242405,
0.0337673351,
0.0558894537,
-0.0396494605,
-0.0232845619,
0.0181221161,
-0.0241324101,
0.0010606874,
0.0619087219,
0.0541067533,
0.0955247208,
0.0790129304,
-0.0400317684,
-0.0139644537,
-0.0141420225,
-0.0106587308,
-0.0028829034,
0.0360329077,
0.0301833954,
-0.0157304481,
-0.0418558978,
-0.0141446777,
-0.0186364204,
0.0710825846,
0.0062410282,
-0.022372365,
-0.0344517305,
-0.0370835252,
-0.0399554484,
0.0245089754,
0.0052669444,
0.0480148047,
-0.0416089222,
-0.040611092,
0.0277795698,
0.0189688597,
-0.0088722929,
0.0032351939,
-0.0367929153,
-0.0323784128,
-0.0179190692,
0.0494188778,
-0.0034972897,
0.0346433967,
0.0208545364,
0.0055242362,
0.0123505257,
0.0395617969,
0.0337157436,
-0.0479129553,
0.0443665981,
0.0090814801,
-0.0111152148,
-0.0220712405,
0.0696520433,
-0.0453767516,
0.0186801255,
-0.0110064941,
-0.0362721272,
-0.1027812064,
0.0001387223,
-0.0475352407,
0.0115964571,
-0.0131216589,
-0.0222804826,
0.0450455733,
-0.0455715843,
0.0278433599,
0.0229867436,
-0.0053839968,
-0.0559190921,
-0.0146975871,
-0.0285451207,
0.0076098139,
-0.0320326015,
-0.0302049424,
-0.0016207543,
0.0155659104,
-0.0104699777,
-0.0345856361,
-0.0515152998,
-0.0192132592,
-0.0013710023,
0.0257091634,
-0.0385972708,
-0.0190360099,
0.0151004568,
0.0530832149,
-0.0047014551,
-0.0100118788,
-0.0554754436,
0.0031618956,
0.0014456086,
0.06291347,
-0.0091687962,
-0.0478133783,
0.0060682544,
0.0710426942,
-0.0638680458,
0.0292553715,
-0.027835438,
0.0005141064,
-0.0161029808,
-0.041393809,
-0.0080166264,
-0.0510957018,
-0.0361761786,
-0.0466767661,
0.0241244268,
-0.0714390799,
0.01398273,
0.0113354819,
-0.0441067033,
0.0531637259,
-0.0066260304,
-0.0430373624,
0.0202868357,
0.0090761799,
0.0033483645,
0.0708275661,
0.0218636561,
0.0825505331,
0.0243195444,
-0.0218581334,
-0.0107841883,
0.0764259771,
-0.0068339133,
0.0542111993,
-0.0377179906,
-0.0484251566,
0.0237479378,
0.0194361564,
0.0524412394,
0.0788260996,
-0.0033150697,
-0.0045460085,
0.083679311,
-0.0112912962,
0.0026005229,
0.0185186472,
0.0085927332,
0.0229513422,
-0.0085666673,
0.0521324798,
-0.0270690285,
-0.0230880901,
0.0136581101,
-0.019398164,
0.0326024555,
0.0651420727,
-0.0111192558,
-0.0413308181,
0.0271870978,
-0.0094935335,
0.0580025539,
-0.0398450121,
0.0420785025,
0.0769073442,
-0.0610142574,
-0.0209040605,
0.0245339703,
-0.0634727925,
0.030811565,
-0.001680317,
0.0088447528,
0.0804115608,
0.0745371282,
-0.0266948938,
0.0369479805,
0.0024154808,
-0.0082266247,
0.0320074148,
-0.0216338001,
-0.0126534496,
0.0376550592,
-0.0644033477,
-0.0337999016,
0.0041902005,
-0.0009303712,
0.0161933061,
-0.0258332789,
0.0468590073,
0.0004178916,
-0.0274909288,
-0.0474448912,
0.0420850143,
0.0055139568,
-0.0410127342,
0.0274663176,
0.022527542,
-0.0066324095,
0.0125693139,
-0.0385313965,
-0.0172130633,
-0.006380938,
-0.0580603108,
-0.0259637926,
0.0452914238,
-0.0005100403,
-0.0383367725,
-0.0076899389,
-0.087151058,
0.0035127939,
0.1004046053,
-0.027755741,
-0.0211387482,
-0.0036287846,
-0.0353709161,
0.0131390002,
-0.0115854964,
0.0135751106,
-0.0184044,
0.0310398247,
-0.0216131993,
0.0283722971,
0.0166500788,
-0.0077134399,
-0.0151270619,
-0.0519839115,
0.03415443,
-0.0142777003,
-0.0531704687,
-0.0318388343,
0.0018896457,
-0.0008913818,
0.0423715711,
0.0315099955,
-0.0434999056,
-0.0075587803,
-0.0831397772,
0.0030576051,
-0.0268768463,
0.0537958853,
0.0445299968,
0.0187093653,
0.0117833642,
-0.0062470036,
-0.0558110885,
-0.0098363757,
0.0049900194,
0.0344547816,
0.0271447748,
-0.030171128,
0.004448073,
-0.0120282974,
-0.0010352732,
0.0270652995,
0.0420434177,
0.0017409814,
-0.0814845338,
-0.0311631616,
0.0512524508,
-0.0047824122,
-0.0288141277,
0.0367390066,
-0.0851772428,
-0.0047064833,
0.0064990507,
0.0492781997,
0.0449054763,
0.0143675767,
-0.0371693857,
0.0462275073,
-0.0256333426,
-0.017897103,
-0.0212229304,
0.011712607,
0.023008123,
0.0005213886,
-0.1025748476,
0.0551821366,
0.0213402621,
0.0136812571,
0.0051994612,
-0.0290520787,
-0.0044929869,
-0.0234199911,
-0.0492462106,
-0.0099994158,
-0.0043049953,
-0.0026819606,
-0.0024333487,
-0.026336275,
-0.0266842451,
0.0353407599,
-0.0034543872,
0.0318541564,
-0.0253785029,
0.0117598576,
-0.004475663,
0.0286371075,
-0.0216411799,
0.0428887829,
0.0195847042,
-0.0187154133,
-0.0114478497,
0.0110821491,
0.0435900539,
-0.0085181938,
-0.0016269257,
-0.0752865896,
-0.0142780999,
0.0064540925,
-0.0434083082,
-0.018244544,
-0.019966865,
0.0328451507,
0.002870861,
0.0400155298,
-0.0191045888,
-0.0373281315,
0.0086944588,
0.0069430419,
0.0145852687,
-0.007642759,
0.0039667538,
0.0291382484,
0.0588838309,
0.0204530507,
-0.0393132567,
-0.0171374697,
-0.0078077805,
-0.0085746851,
0.0975107774,
-0.0031396188,
-0.0187755302,
0.0099078007,
-0.0076589845,
0.0091142487,
0.0116850706,
-0.0328190923,
-0.0542268343,
0.0271491297,
-0.0325176679,
-0.0215360448,
0.0662463382,
0.0144430976,
-0.0548168607,
-0.0226515327,
0.0092379889,
0.0232011303,
-0.0205083489,
0.0086771883,
-0.1098816171,
-0.0331903547,
0.0047329688,
0.0265906006,
-0.0144322691,
-0.0288428832,
0.0118119493,
-0.0562140234,
0.0000011946,
0.0408219956,
-0.0428288393,
-0.0259226337,
-0.0053580324,
0.0283467099,
-0.0525808781,
-0.0065268478,
-0.0507931374,
0.0195610989,
-0.0083514694,
-0.0114820711,
-0.0197702572,
-0.0181496385,
-0.0337715559,
-0.0133188302,
0.0109288357,
0.0378021412,
0.056151282,
-0.0104960799,
-0.0553519577,
0.0053301696,
-0.0446804985,
-0.034449175,
-0.0086881369,
0.099818036,
0.0365958624,
-0.0079944041,
-0.0209170114,
0.043558374,
-0.0245850142,
-0.0205071643,
0.0319373198,
0.0227143168,
0.0306626372,
-0.0224049222,
0.0197180174,
-0.0027110758,
0.0320804715,
0.0688866526,
-0.0009812276,
-0.0649664849,
-0.0473409407,
-0.0700126514,
-0.0023999794,
-0.0845849067,
-0.0422879606,
-0.0270088613,
-0.0999634564,
-0.0758173242,
-0.1402240098,
-0.0105669731,
-0.0080524236,
0.0374274589,
0.0247560348,
-0.0019896072,
-0.0432930104,
-0.0064783972,
-0.0151641248,
-0.0007541907,
-0.0057653366,
0.0304564312,
-0.0330793783,
-0.017578125,
-0.0531581379,
-0.0033844903,
0.0132891173,
0.0398311131,
-0.0675859749,
-0.0463279225,
0.0597668253,
0.0347227305,
0.0144500211,
0.0070855455,
-0.0279663131,
-0.0386367328,
0.0422359295,
0.0551074818,
-0.0006244463,
0.0070000696,
0.0469843149,
0.0024734158,
0.0202552397,
0.0416062735,
-0.0081747239,
0.0173458047,
0.0529115647,
0.0107218977,
-0.0273124669,
0.0229041651,
0.0057568946,
0.0394072272,
0.0008364611,
-0.0372163095,
0.0113817891,
-0.0195342563,
-0.0006745602,
-0.0192059707,
-0.0454609171,
-0.0241421182,
0.014645583,
0.0650811046,
0.0271031931,
-0.0204054713,
0.0683268309,
-0.0037692273,
-0.0207776092,
-0.0659380704,
-0.0237092786,
0.0849000514,
0.0631612986,
0.0271642581,
0.0326386355,
0.0138685377,
0.0295405108,
0.0176850874,
0.0291192904,
-0.0248567313,
0.0087910211,
0.0158364009,
0.0109761693,
0.0052221357,
0.0590069667,
-0.0198861081,
0.0358063541,
-0.0304174572,
-0.0333767496,
0.0331504978,
-0.0289886612,
0.0922999829,
-0.005121964,
-0.006937596,
0.0020629931,
0.0135749774,
-0.0007068332,
0.0151944431,
-0.0588944405,
-0.0130836219,
-0.0138625326,
0.0105934693,
0.0892296135,
-0.0302082039,
0.0324007422,
0.0080087567,
-0.0496762656,
-0.0155954873,
-0.0182674602,
0.0302833561,
-0.0050479984,
0.016971821,
-0.0440169759,
-0.0243719593,
-0.0624186583,
0.0447537899,
-0.005012535,
0.0091527663,
0.0219819676,
0.0129305888,
0.0304709189,
0.0005355369,
0.0215758216,
-0.0230192244,
0.0461948812,
0.0220142324,
-0.0423443839,
-0.0352105536,
-5.579933563e-33,
0.0352678634,
-0.0071130414,
-0.0595409758,
0.0070826667,
-0.0155949835,
-0.0323805548,
-0.027150197,
-0.0345263854,
0.0297765546,
0.0716830045,
-0.0047815288,
-0.0097598014,
0.0146844871,
0.0059273359,
-0.0124346036,
0.0368929915,
0.055965703,
-0.001853048,
-0.061219316,
0.0312704928,
0.0707055926,
0.0268917289,
0.0687250271,
-0.074903883,
0.0226161014,
-0.0172822699,
-0.0665511191,
0.0052631255,
0.0222672597,
0.0002569318,
0.0000995486,
0.0392817967,
0.0332423262,
-0.0135619249,
-0.0052157291,
0.0442042984,
-0.0369619541,
-0.0393271409,
0.0188973099,
0.0197741818,
-0.0361514166,
-0.0384164341,
0.0515309051,
-0.0213652831,
0.0069065848,
0.0249531753,
0.0371920243,
-0.0405262969,
0.0098181851,
-0.0207859837,
-0.0543645956,
0.0193042085,
-0.0321307369,
-0.01687444,
0.0363432765,
0.0199269354,
0.0042694253,
-0.0111148413,
-0.0423021615,
0.0218470823,
-0.054644417,
0.0432121046,
0.0236299224,
-0.0034257367,
0.0051215142,
0.0478429422,
-0.0221771803,
0.0692235306,
0.0190562699,
0.0285801962,
0.0321722962,
-0.0055080475,
0.0540798232,
0.0627337769,
0.0452266857,
-0.0271844175,
-0.027162414,
0.0567290038,
-0.0017005458,
0.03312096,
-0.0403340869,
0.0357445814,
0.025583962,
-0.0276876185,
-0.035336215,
-0.0448025167,
-0.0116252461,
-0.0096054869,
-0.0076370207,
-0.0196386036,
-0.0464292802,
-0.0036507081,
-0.0053271209,
0.0022428222,
0.0069917897,
0.0284917988,
-0.0408525094,
0.0430091359,
-0.0072585247,
-0.0072299149,
-0.0370290056,
0.0094268769,
0.0260754544,
0.0399696641,
0.0201256108,
-0.0462964028,
0.0485113375,
0.0080493391,
-0.0828701779,
0.0036852437,
-0.0321204066,
0.041784402,
0.0335151292,
0.039160084,
-0.0306370016,
-0.0089366576,
0.005251254,
-0.0199669804,
0.0809207037,
0.0110268081,
-0.0047201691,
-0.0318116806,
0.0306169987,
-0.0144749908,
-0.0379745625,
-0.0097978963,
-0.0023284771,
-0.016056018,
0.0056256996,
-0.0714844093,
-0.0088659888,
-0.0036539738,
2.475e-7,
0.0509486496,
0.0082924375,
0.0371551216,
-0.0240806434,
0.0270459,
0.0263931043,
-0.0207530241,
0.0265874639,
-0.0280788932,
0.0070072706,
-0.0208193008,
-0.0064655067,
0.085169211,
0.031624008,
-0.0987730622,
0.0057723825,
-0.0348278992,
-0.0300105419,
-0.0358844772,
-0.0038055326,
0.0228299126,
0.0285842512,
0.0058784517,
-0.0408921875,
0.0047618542,
-0.0228427593,
0.0385628678,
-0.0176990665,
-0.0301021989,
0.0135330139,
0.0303189289,
-0.0707622319,
-0.0261030309,
-0.0133376783,
-0.0277476031,
-0.0570811629,
0.0661162958,
0.0418473706,
0.0119598489,
0.0198325273,
-0.0060020387,
-0.0028852199,
-0.0003295496,
0.0121520935,
0.0700266734,
0.0463125594,
-0.0070305797,
-0.0338056572,
-0.0699573234,
-0.0115524838,
0.0498579666,
-0.0250993595,
-0.0703195184,
0.0508826673,
0.0191816594,
0.0343238078,
-0.0621662252,
-0.0421345495,
-0.0374064036,
-0.0332430974,
-0.023615513,
-0.0281032529,
-0.0311314072,
0.02853599,
-0.0285338182,
-0.0585611723,
0.0381294936,
2.075926008e-34,
0.035423182,
-0.0541162826,
-0.0100434199,
-0.0370231159,
0.0178464558,
-0.0181073844,
-0.0019114319,
0.027773397,
-0.0122099817,
-0.0741533041,
0.037959449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13921v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13921v1 | Some Like It Small: Czech Semantic Embedding Models for Industry Applications | 2023-11-23T11:14:13 | 2023-11-23T11:14:13 | Jiří Bednář, Jakub Náplava, Petra Barančíková, Ondřej Lisický | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This article focuses on the development and evaluation of Small-sized Czech
sentence embedding models. Small models are important components for real-time
industry applications in resource-constrained environments. Given the limited
availability of labeled Czech data, alternative approaches, including
pre-training, knowledge distillation, and unsupervised contrastive fine-tuning,
are investigated. Comprehensive intrinsic and extrinsic analyses are conducted,
showcasing the competitive performance of our models compared to significantly
larger counterparts, with approximately 8 times smaller size and 5 times faster
speed than conventional Base-sized models. To promote cooperation and
reproducibility, both the models and the evaluation pipeline are made publicly
accessible. Ultimately, this article presents practical applications of the
developed sentence embedding models in Seznam.cz, the Czech search engine.
These models have effectively replaced previous counterparts, enhancing the
overall search experience for instance, in organic search, featured snippets,
and image search. This transition has yielded improved performance. | [
0.0508296564,
0.0237188805,
-0.0056071528,
0.0384091176,
-0.0214869995,
-0.0069379415,
-0.0124211852,
-0.0296053123,
-0.0163483992,
-0.0797963664,
0.0305972658,
0.0459428504,
-0.067778565,
0.015491996,
0.0464626141,
-0.0388266891,
0.039236106,
0.0214530062,
-0.0038143387,
0.009069615,
0.0637260675,
0.0034139629,
0.0152008533,
0.0522787571,
0.0084801754,
0.0143321445,
-0.0037364804,
0.0155978445,
0.0155078592,
-0.0122218831,
0.004485203,
0.0029616533,
0.0556461252,
0.0141782695,
0.0000017468,
-0.0508288853,
-0.023734536,
-0.0226444844,
0.0055279378,
0.0244970396,
0.0799228474,
-0.0584119447,
-0.0101717943,
0.024574697,
-0.0312512033,
-0.0332533233,
0.0339535028,
0.0307387896,
0.0424906164,
0.0518883616,
-0.0101622473,
-0.0140247298,
-0.0177468844,
-0.0217566527,
-0.052169852,
-0.022309294,
0.0355939493,
-0.0217952579,
-0.0045554359,
0.0348965637,
-0.0071588513,
0.0663493052,
-0.0015038913,
-0.0139963916,
0.0524937287,
0.0245636944,
-0.0767476186,
0.0016698617,
-0.0059213443,
0.0492895395,
-0.0060246917,
-0.0014613784,
-0.0027281595,
0.0119482083,
-0.0075272149,
-0.0217809528,
-0.0667958111,
0.0111000724,
0.0460738689,
0.0328034349,
0.0040614028,
0.0208987612,
0.0139456801,
0.0065398095,
0.004816805,
0.0526651926,
0.0127554694,
-0.0363492034,
0.0221545603,
0.0034937686,
0.0067400709,
-0.0135695562,
0.0312347151,
-0.0029634759,
0.0174978171,
0.0239052642,
-0.0233119018,
-0.003471972,
0.0318387784,
-0.0612195991,
-0.0169112924,
0.0332398713,
0.0062263161,
0.0577501059,
-0.0540258363,
0.0158261973,
0.0130945547,
0.0460098907,
-0.0659968555,
-0.0247545782,
-0.0712092817,
-0.0241333973,
-0.0890350491,
0.0284911711,
-0.0228489116,
-0.0587126128,
-0.0305406265,
0.0322977342,
0.0188183598,
0.0212332904,
0.0301660206,
0.0358298048,
0.0102748713,
0.0488503091,
-0.0156383999,
0.0259379447,
-0.0436285771,
0.0099273529,
-0.0172448009,
-0.0254386812,
0.0141695244,
0.0081874905,
0.0234867875,
-0.0180862527,
0.0105920304,
0.0069253678,
-0.0077794953,
-0.0444288217,
-0.0020720649,
-0.0151098967,
-0.0175239574,
-0.0185998436,
-0.0369525664,
-0.0552390888,
0.0012041657,
0.006299342,
0.0213534217,
-0.0233184341,
0.0020366185,
0.0316031948,
-0.0597393624,
0.0801392347,
-0.0001952407,
0.0009296733,
-0.0445477478,
-0.0030846538,
0.0911970288,
0.0723729506,
0.0035564676,
0.0429768302,
0.0670813248,
0.0146226166,
-0.0228576455,
0.017615011,
-0.0170231387,
-0.0358279794,
-0.0222921278,
0.0518670641,
-0.0132476399,
0.0357059091,
0.0283397697,
0.0463362522,
-0.0081137642,
0.0025289487,
0.0572144352,
0.0317979902,
0.0427744575,
-0.0100720152,
0.0588613562,
0.0225589164,
-0.0407692045,
-0.0472893007,
-0.0119392322,
-0.0144214146,
-0.0033458988,
0.0292412005,
0.0148100303,
0.0345735177,
-0.0349202082,
-0.008181205,
-0.0140661327,
0.0167347528,
0.014318483,
-0.0312804952,
0.0615474768,
-0.0208555516,
-0.0368460976,
0.0412057415,
0.0328104906,
-0.021979643,
-0.0011202078,
0.0072692367,
-0.0132139204,
0.116587162,
0.062637575,
-0.027447829,
0.0520557798,
-0.0105384821,
-0.0065405862,
0.022629885,
0.046138376,
-0.0415451601,
-0.0070919911,
-0.0510207377,
-0.048412323,
-0.0410153978,
0.0201800354,
-0.0149733275,
-0.0170037337,
0.026787119,
0.0383666605,
-0.0382745527,
0.0303415861,
0.0094356742,
0.0400285311,
-0.0063492367,
-0.0400318354,
0.0342886746,
-0.0273445565,
0.0309977941,
0.0071949144,
0.0059632328,
0.0507688932,
-0.0511257388,
-0.0134461988,
-0.0064052469,
-0.0184981599,
-0.0814883634,
0.0297610257,
-0.0674648806,
0.0353198685,
0.052109804,
-0.0466549397,
-0.0226882659,
0.0264231339,
-0.0332193822,
0.0241683181,
-0.0322830454,
-0.0015616498,
-0.02175471,
0.0414493904,
-0.0487004817,
0.0272566043,
-0.0100842044,
0.0158275291,
0.0043079411,
-0.0235760938,
0.0207637735,
-0.0607400127,
-0.0724231601,
0.0335701965,
-0.019122282,
0.0036262346,
0.0118445074,
0.015574255,
-0.0219622068,
0.0460242108,
-0.1206514612,
0.0075944872,
-0.0093124676,
0.0147716859,
0.0094628269,
0.0225717388,
0.0226705838,
-0.0356111042,
-0.0451304875,
-0.0117123928,
-0.0096160956,
0.0274810195,
0.02242174,
0.0216015931,
-0.0431105532,
-0.0378487259,
-0.0209794194,
-0.0089562479,
0.0204000324,
-0.0178777557,
-0.0216250848,
-0.0666165873,
0.0605301335,
-0.034576688,
0.0139885852,
-0.0104742171,
-0.0541339032,
-0.026751183,
0.012829842,
0.0222313907,
0.0540056191,
-0.0371027142,
0.0165239424,
0.0325905867,
0.0027880373,
-0.0337650366,
-0.0025280823,
-0.0439188965,
0.0299869478,
-0.0417939611,
-0.0265207868,
0.0082254205,
0.0281148776,
0.0019325563,
0.0170784183,
-0.0338276066,
0.0123809716,
-0.0550142005,
0.0071514822,
-0.0764347091,
0.0109620923,
0.0069372915,
0.0172160231,
0.0139817875,
0.0005712599,
0.0450572222,
-0.0166082941,
0.0007328645,
-0.0238061715,
-0.0692297891,
-0.0421974696,
0.0350563936,
-0.0141068073,
0.0251396261,
-0.022399608,
-0.0153309926,
-0.0463571213,
-0.0035073794,
0.0132124666,
-0.0140922535,
0.0258762371,
0.0106038814,
0.0014371929,
-0.0195140261,
-0.0665741116,
-0.0110922512,
-0.1310082078,
-0.059374541,
0.0458537675,
0.0794384032,
0.0195813496,
-0.0225608554,
0.0738303214,
-0.0002404745,
0.0293437149,
0.0161547735,
-0.0254690927,
-0.0269902088,
0.0377967544,
0.0742375329,
-0.0332909487,
0.0199234784,
0.013374974,
0.0260532852,
0.0321865901,
0.0468566641,
-0.0413406491,
-0.0334216505,
-0.0182763934,
0.0251397677,
-0.0245546643,
-0.0117485495,
-0.0321841948,
-0.0039559528,
-0.0149608189,
-0.0155660892,
0.0975506902,
0.0137017285,
-0.0035463118,
0.0177486241,
0.0319195166,
0.0029102194,
0.0515294038,
0.0228478238,
-0.0629535466,
-0.0355649963,
0.0110060042,
0.0093698725,
-0.0290024709,
0.0083608627,
-0.0011451986,
-0.1153169274,
-0.0110006509,
-0.0119131627,
-0.0087447176,
-0.0132775987,
-0.0434265323,
-0.0154764252,
-0.0443723164,
0.0018386048,
0.0100546051,
-0.0438123159,
-0.0105601102,
0.0373813286,
-0.0245157946,
-0.0688477531,
0.0062157959,
-0.0293356497,
0.0300214663,
0.0161317978,
0.0151604218,
0.0080095259,
-0.00026548,
-0.0051621986,
-0.0394785702,
-0.0020257225,
-0.0248155836,
0.0380021818,
-0.0243152734,
-0.0145378048,
-0.0066960943,
-0.0340643786,
-0.0340685211,
0.0313625298,
-0.0135168573,
0.0693545714,
0.0302992221,
0.0230867472,
-0.0272557568,
0.0030469429,
-0.0136676924,
0.0645790845,
0.0287913866,
0.0070682499,
-0.0419319756,
-0.0087754223,
-0.0196340196,
-0.0094370069,
-0.0364986546,
0.015527091,
-0.0207852814,
-0.0319584906,
-0.038385272,
-0.0762231201,
0.0562528037,
0.0281143617,
-0.0104638329,
0.0357593261,
-0.0318532102,
0.0237206873,
-0.0659227893,
0.0059247501,
-0.0307526998,
0.0236604959,
-0.0331066735,
0.0371787809,
0.0362505987,
-0.0148074189,
-0.0452335291,
-0.0149494037,
-0.0596689247,
-0.0502481237,
-0.016817173,
0.0316532478,
0.0145615833,
0.0194822308,
-0.0337034129,
-0.0715531111,
0.0849864334,
0.0345144421,
-0.0554762408,
-0.0042933621,
0.0183538962,
-0.0189498067,
0.0330918618,
0.0471875221,
-0.0506538451,
0.0307050347,
-0.0217635296,
0.049112834,
-0.0036957334,
-0.0420225598,
0.0127810938,
0.0185351577,
0.0553030185,
0.0011688125,
0.0283954311,
-0.0481604822,
0.0390599407,
-0.0269915182,
-0.0201572347,
-0.0316592827,
0.015351152,
0.0103408583,
0.018969804,
-0.0255505834,
0.0448789224,
-0.0075302962,
-0.0040636919,
-0.0370224044,
-0.0259238277,
0.0110025955,
0.0215916373,
0.0132737942,
0.032587599,
-0.0352469273,
0.0158305783,
-0.0136259627,
-0.016580062,
-0.0287661199,
-0.0440249369,
-0.004622174,
-0.0477233827,
-0.0348479003,
0.0445832089,
-0.05417528,
0.0219559968,
-0.0236834977,
-0.0070319879,
0.0665853769,
-0.030006256,
0.0499521866,
-0.0071759443,
-0.0248712916,
0.018368572,
0.0158353318,
-0.0030662003,
-0.0447810069,
0.0442447178,
0.0276578199,
-0.0471799113,
-0.0022600228,
0.0501457155,
0.0353373736,
0.0192139857,
-0.0261819977,
-0.0563247949,
-0.0613845214,
0.0278939828,
0.0475831889,
0.052597221,
-0.0288834888,
-0.0165954959,
-0.0581933707,
-0.0364975594,
-0.0177809279,
0.0161971617,
-0.0470700972,
0.0047620279,
0.0660890192,
0.045305945,
0.0524945781,
-0.0044390443,
-0.0279621668,
0.0017712285,
-0.0215803869,
-0.0367683731,
0.0154845072,
-5.983904686e-33,
0.0091228848,
0.0179327615,
0.003214902,
-0.0438014008,
-0.0111521985,
0.0092639681,
0.00087491,
-0.0334579274,
-0.0240020845,
0.030802682,
0.002614452,
0.0039423951,
0.0228593219,
0.0123194382,
0.001068707,
-0.0128294975,
0.0693848059,
0.0225017332,
0.0013749368,
0.0252795927,
0.0593648441,
0.0628868565,
0.0785807446,
-0.0193740819,
-0.0281667076,
-0.0260628108,
-0.0242761523,
0.0274146441,
0.059739992,
0.0961637124,
-0.0256269723,
0.0650046691,
0.0083712479,
-0.0591637306,
-0.015641924,
0.0152542926,
-0.0627019405,
-0.0298856981,
0.0143672992,
0.0404665209,
-0.0115324641,
0.012698614,
0.0372144505,
-0.0259376001,
-0.0096058538,
0.071093142,
0.0658926442,
-0.0249382891,
-0.0293460228,
-0.046822954,
-0.0541760176,
0.0021647483,
-0.0115974797,
-0.0095604016,
0.0754383802,
0.0374228097,
0.0264587253,
0.0360883065,
-0.0064161969,
0.0113733774,
0.0013621633,
0.0468808487,
0.0740247592,
-0.0019001983,
0.0045820079,
0.0645745248,
-0.0186506808,
-0.05331349,
0.0334787443,
-0.0000252206,
0.0248525031,
0.0515304431,
0.0288292672,
0.0677473694,
-0.0159859564,
0.0022684038,
-0.0721025616,
-0.0026348899,
0.01901187,
0.0122507876,
0.0321725272,
0.0391127095,
-0.0634577423,
-0.0301177949,
-0.0034580589,
0.008683308,
-0.0329083391,
-0.0198554471,
0.0648735166,
0.045429565,
-0.0205472838,
0.0219930597,
-0.0015515572,
-0.0511002243,
-0.0215782728,
0.0268255249,
-0.0218275264,
0.0098883836,
-0.0033477198,
0.0001085339,
-0.075557664,
-0.0191954896,
-0.0102976663,
-0.0029950461,
-0.0202841517,
-0.0254436992,
0.0250670798,
0.0141917458,
-0.0434677489,
0.0025255631,
-0.0253954772,
-0.0172194894,
-0.0271125268,
-0.0422859788,
0.0192265864,
0.0164008886,
-0.0315555856,
0.0395880193,
0.0831546187,
-0.0246961266,
0.0112954844,
-0.0655834973,
0.0431680977,
0.0228060167,
-0.005898797,
0.033795841,
-0.0130158765,
0.0441362001,
0.0090061249,
-0.046364639,
-0.0192236602,
0.0069041885,
2.536e-7,
0.0509838909,
0.0393732265,
-0.0252200756,
-0.0212760027,
0.0085977688,
0.0170326754,
-0.0063446946,
0.0551238954,
-0.0482597053,
0.0222319178,
0.0370051786,
-0.0147417346,
0.0177581627,
-0.0142611004,
-0.0940786675,
0.0432832949,
-0.0704379529,
-0.032437142,
-0.056916371,
0.0068986653,
0.0674728528,
0.123137027,
0.0463929996,
-0.0003868263,
-0.0486235693,
-0.0702658892,
0.0375391133,
-0.0036456988,
-0.0202294085,
0.0055099004,
0.0150481509,
0.0724764764,
-0.0092655597,
-0.023494998,
0.0254440848,
0.0517536737,
0.0415704586,
0.0332275517,
-0.0395096913,
0.005216518,
-0.0002632799,
-0.0779286921,
-0.0054583694,
-0.061260514,
0.0626501665,
-0.0636535138,
-0.0061508967,
0.0226876028,
-0.0177152269,
-0.0031203504,
0.0452408344,
-0.0040698582,
-0.0305788461,
-0.0269821882,
0.0091555268,
-0.0142915836,
-0.0366793498,
-0.1080417112,
0.0207507275,
0.0144035928,
-0.0264214426,
-0.048498325,
-0.037497092,
0.0165893193,
0.0051156827,
-0.0035339023,
-0.0113247894,
2.27724962e-34,
0.0291379206,
0.0329845883,
-0.0211931858,
-0.0043538157,
0.0109641962,
-0.0172138903,
0.0085634412,
-0.0212631524,
0.0262033157,
-0.1026147082,
-0.0111601409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13910v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13910v1 | Dialogue Quality and Emotion Annotations for Customer Support Conversations | 2023-11-23T10:56:14 | 2023-11-23T10:56:14 | John Mendonça, Patrícia Pereira, Miguel Menezes, Vera Cabarrão, Ana C. Farinha, Helena Moniz, João Paulo Carvalho, Alon Lavie, Isabel Trancoso | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented conversational datasets often lack topic variability and
linguistic diversity. However, with the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs)
pretrained on extensive, multilingual and diverse text data, these limitations
seem overcome. Nevertheless, their generalisability to different languages and
domains in dialogue applications remains uncertain without benchmarking
datasets. This paper presents a holistic annotation approach for emotion and
conversational quality in the context of bilingual customer support
conversations. By performing annotations that take into consideration the
complete instances that compose a conversation, one can form a broader
perspective of the dialogue as a whole. Furthermore, it provides a unique and
valuable resource for the development of text classification models. To this
end, we present benchmarks for Emotion Recognition and Dialogue Quality
Estimation and show that further research is needed to leverage these models in
a production setting. | [
0.0635752678,
0.0200985931,
-0.0184786525,
0.0670534745,
-0.0085611325,
0.0305440035,
0.010549441,
-0.0443432368,
0.0169984177,
-0.0546819344,
-0.0685098395,
-0.0568263829,
-0.008259017,
-0.0114250928,
-0.03389474,
-0.0582384206,
0.0104139196,
0.0369823948,
0.0570278764,
0.0054890234,
0.0222731773,
0.0234804098,
-0.0158618242,
0.031892512,
-0.0497048683,
-0.0177196339,
0.0011040482,
0.0329917856,
0.0280527715,
0.0061592939,
0.0680557266,
0.0579583719,
-0.0076264255,
0.016824834,
0.0000017575,
-0.0296141915,
0.0075474801,
-0.0159240291,
-0.0380040258,
-0.0210261531,
0.0466886498,
-0.0118580507,
-0.0222892333,
0.0318439156,
-0.0213045217,
0.0122758076,
0.037149135,
0.0774152204,
0.0919852704,
0.084996365,
-0.0258779861,
0.0062962859,
-0.0257946961,
-0.0022941551,
-0.0223103128,
-0.0437266901,
-0.0089912666,
0.0509369224,
-0.0207319614,
-0.0201704539,
0.0186712034,
0.0292111654,
0.0051554563,
-0.0324312523,
-0.0319283679,
-0.024922749,
-0.0666625276,
-0.0192070473,
-0.0017453346,
0.0433991551,
-0.0077187307,
0.0293767676,
-0.0244133789,
-0.0013418009,
0.0030304035,
-0.0500304662,
-0.0139773889,
-0.0039377413,
-0.0069808657,
0.008453235,
0.0074306843,
0.0441411249,
-0.0055568395,
0.0136134652,
0.0215188749,
0.044538416,
-0.031095691,
-0.027015632,
0.0337939113,
0.0345938765,
-0.009977024,
-0.0152117768,
0.0197473262,
-0.0080276271,
-0.0187603142,
0.0085203899,
-0.0197504628,
-0.0071215369,
0.0061203968,
-0.1020803824,
-0.0093059409,
0.0185912624,
-0.0658346713,
0.0400294662,
0.0136849945,
0.0204698481,
0.0185231399,
-0.0285395496,
-0.0488174744,
-0.0253796149,
-0.0354423597,
0.0276045725,
-0.0266312864,
-0.0102019729,
-0.0621895157,
-0.015386912,
-0.0541789681,
0.026663376,
-0.0066010142,
0.0301661361,
0.0220110882,
-0.016050728,
-0.0184992962,
-0.0062321532,
-0.0254597589,
0.0403974652,
-0.0209354181,
0.0142478114,
-0.0143614924,
-0.0757712498,
0.0371573307,
0.0519755259,
-0.0147837838,
-0.0088415574,
-0.0077893571,
0.0198018085,
-0.01364074,
-0.0415409096,
-0.0543869808,
-0.0168604106,
-0.0452340282,
-0.081575349,
-0.0205829553,
-0.0212249141,
0.0452919751,
-0.0137473727,
-0.0114431465,
-0.0007794505,
0.0251392592,
-0.0246707164,
-0.0010494496,
0.0364685245,
-0.0145393955,
-0.0128007699,
0.0428659022,
-0.0036064221,
0.0169358179,
0.0550107583,
0.0188861173,
0.0411026441,
0.0876429752,
-0.0027725939,
0.0445482209,
0.0331492797,
-0.0457212366,
-0.0025020987,
0.0156551134,
-0.0200587306,
-0.0100296894,
0.0203743223,
0.0456585661,
0.0179076511,
-0.0361290798,
-0.0003612596,
0.045487538,
0.0237478111,
-0.019983869,
0.0327636637,
0.0255824141,
0.0546911471,
0.0113153858,
0.0231469404,
-0.0123432772,
0.0044293925,
0.0138171837,
-0.0079105236,
0.0390852317,
-0.0267389137,
-0.0179075878,
-0.0890555531,
-0.0205053966,
-0.0264586899,
-0.02114412,
0.0069835205,
0.013375354,
-0.0313344337,
-0.0188541766,
0.0289436337,
0.0146834115,
-0.0557920188,
-0.0228492785,
0.0216321647,
-0.0127693368,
0.0883661434,
0.00428676,
-0.0351792425,
-0.0449854583,
-0.0497606657,
0.0002187623,
0.0528748333,
0.0383613855,
-0.0076017543,
0.0549574047,
-0.0711249784,
0.0137454392,
0.0208232719,
0.0056488109,
0.0076945596,
-0.0436477363,
-0.0033245075,
0.0240344703,
0.0164624434,
-0.0355129801,
-0.0184366778,
-0.0157673229,
-0.0130554605,
0.0464529283,
0.0026131186,
0.0601567887,
0.0715877041,
-0.0278539266,
-0.0546770692,
0.0252743792,
-0.0277878698,
-0.0015394052,
0.061205864,
-0.0343370773,
-0.0554255694,
0.0200555492,
0.0085562151,
-0.0172516257,
-0.0256812144,
-0.0476623289,
-0.0461004153,
-0.0210256241,
-0.0237552077,
0.0203620438,
-0.0617948174,
0.0169286877,
-0.0129048945,
0.035671249,
-0.008897963,
0.0215670038,
-0.0070665977,
0.019466646,
-0.0328123271,
-0.0258591175,
0.0571794324,
-0.0558385104,
-0.0392575338,
0.0389767624,
0.0074011791,
0.0224339832,
0.0219189636,
-0.0039902707,
-0.0257908273,
-0.0286013484,
-0.1347150952,
0.0103676254,
-0.0343733802,
0.0048508593,
-0.0093263527,
-0.0018036815,
-0.0405999981,
-0.0124009075,
-0.0484810323,
-0.0159331635,
0.0428283513,
-0.00300929,
0.0230355635,
0.0276739225,
0.007818047,
-0.0582427122,
0.0170487743,
0.0175431054,
0.0112198349,
-0.009828425,
-0.0485992916,
-0.0649968833,
0.0085526844,
-0.0403378494,
0.023299573,
-0.0004242353,
-0.0889652446,
-0.0040951171,
0.036279805,
0.005175076,
0.0607473031,
0.0254734382,
0.0425680056,
-0.0193951689,
-0.0210393239,
-0.0168355182,
0.0507470034,
-0.0319553986,
0.0249946676,
-0.05077089,
-0.0517694317,
0.026645178,
0.0422097407,
-0.000133489,
0.0264809076,
-0.0520072319,
-0.0402090736,
-0.0163220186,
-0.032388445,
0.0017345787,
-0.0020119122,
-0.0287373681,
0.042921342,
0.0250102878,
-0.0411418304,
0.0234603081,
-0.0250072293,
-0.0027032616,
-0.0994012952,
-0.0340975299,
-0.039342232,
0.0530255996,
-0.0597876683,
0.0206320174,
-0.02801954,
-0.0231451299,
0.0364202932,
-0.0135480817,
0.0194326025,
-0.0331132151,
0.0246192329,
-0.0461608618,
-0.025113903,
0.0265569109,
-0.0532627627,
-0.0330813713,
-0.0055648638,
-0.0626620501,
-0.0089910505,
0.0541832596,
-0.0012641697,
-0.0259846449,
-0.0094855083,
0.0058994875,
0.0171489622,
-0.0112488195,
0.0084069809,
0.0202152971,
0.0193880778,
0.0056159846,
0.0412895866,
0.0160898175,
-0.0206375625,
0.0385507345,
0.014996944,
-0.0065724491,
-0.0011682921,
0.0107811391,
-0.0213823989,
0.019017281,
0.019608276,
-0.0620897375,
-0.0453916825,
0.0423752479,
-0.0311718956,
0.0130548701,
0.1245185286,
0.0235988405,
-0.0351705812,
-0.0028307785,
-0.0522508211,
0.0007508697,
0.0228494946,
0.0322175957,
-0.089996554,
-0.0143378591,
-0.0275813956,
0.0258986056,
-0.0235660784,
-0.0221027248,
-0.0260288287,
-0.0688384622,
0.0531393066,
-0.0112151681,
-0.0237010922,
-0.026031334,
-0.0039570634,
-0.0037347819,
-0.0189475473,
0.0511641987,
-0.0670719519,
0.0449207984,
-0.0285411403,
0.0608340614,
-0.047268454,
-0.0714807436,
-0.004897431,
0.0053228484,
0.0432056822,
0.0279857535,
0.0678716078,
0.0164777432,
0.002987358,
0.0598395579,
0.015304775,
-0.0013860841,
-0.0076611466,
0.080706045,
-0.0203202274,
-0.0285731982,
-0.0019203335,
0.0058175912,
-0.0095700435,
0.0120981215,
0.0066548996,
-0.0029822136,
-0.0306404904,
0.0238967948,
0.0203725602,
0.0358668603,
0.0428579561,
0.0822917446,
0.0135565214,
-0.0726419836,
0.0027843525,
-0.0091006346,
0.0171661302,
-0.0070571671,
0.0008843397,
0.0233467538,
-0.0207832716,
-0.0041187024,
-0.0703422353,
-0.088708356,
0.0104802996,
0.0118390229,
-0.0285285432,
-0.0225540809,
-0.0144799091,
-0.0012238008,
0.030059211,
0.0244356636,
0.0062624025,
0.0181795098,
-0.076372683,
0.0181530938,
0.0119155804,
-0.0268181711,
-0.0129551608,
-0.0014059074,
-0.0357013568,
-0.0401361287,
0.0157040711,
0.0304499157,
0.014898954,
0.0431520008,
0.0153499786,
-0.071929425,
-0.059158504,
0.0394950546,
-0.028434502,
-0.0094020907,
0.07158342,
0.0704056397,
-0.0322962627,
0.0470054224,
-0.0168837458,
0.0555677973,
-0.0039006954,
0.0009169883,
-0.0127288578,
-0.0937449336,
-0.0153375659,
-0.0025168255,
0.0231047906,
0.0118057467,
-0.0166957844,
-0.0330495872,
0.0382730812,
-0.0019791378,
-0.0229118876,
-0.067078948,
-0.0169441663,
-0.0086373575,
-0.0368230604,
-0.0400451198,
-0.0150069706,
-0.0447157584,
0.0215900298,
-0.0137121677,
0.0136639746,
0.0251007453,
-0.0124731716,
-0.0197805725,
0.0238476507,
-0.0326352157,
0.0225830413,
0.0389369465,
0.0507961065,
0.0158681832,
0.0654921159,
0.0030278573,
-0.0252030939,
0.0387923419,
0.0261268858,
0.0063983086,
-0.0221175589,
-0.0162010882,
0.0111229131,
0.0509434193,
-0.0601541176,
0.0704906359,
-0.0434374139,
0.0142718013,
-0.0351006314,
0.0505408868,
0.0197472926,
-0.0186747648,
-0.012174068,
-0.0156722534,
-0.0489517376,
0.0302753076,
0.0525107719,
-0.0628205985,
0.0180439763,
-0.005354031,
-0.0093300324,
-0.0735279247,
0.0135995662,
0.0440208279,
-0.0052078008,
0.0041104318,
0.0024175567,
-0.0648919791,
-0.027131306,
0.0167227387,
-0.0321209878,
-0.0030570119,
-0.0165349562,
0.022414051,
0.0623271689,
-0.030433258,
0.0378369167,
-0.0323012248,
-0.0154363457,
-0.047404442,
0.0131476568,
-0.0317052417,
-5.387105102e-33,
0.0208876934,
0.0014109707,
-0.0562680587,
0.025988834,
-0.0062404829,
0.0374939889,
0.0050649294,
0.0197571535,
0.0016576477,
0.0428908132,
-0.0053338911,
0.0250591692,
0.0240983684,
0.0237325132,
-0.0246829372,
-0.0223006215,
0.0521492399,
0.0090547279,
-0.0253743548,
0.0475413948,
0.0402591191,
0.0027733655,
0.073873803,
-0.1365803033,
0.0588088557,
0.0111748055,
-0.013445315,
0.0487330966,
0.090083912,
0.0618262924,
-0.0106793465,
0.0943773463,
0.0125335604,
-0.0378011465,
0.0270842295,
0.0381348059,
0.0021807142,
-0.0066236584,
0.0151039958,
0.0252080876,
-0.0162676554,
-0.0240603257,
-0.0240517948,
0.0022572118,
-0.0059952531,
0.0175554212,
0.0071944459,
-0.032588128,
-0.0099137463,
-0.0508946665,
-0.053439457,
0.059681803,
-0.0324174426,
-0.0468977056,
0.0389634147,
0.0852138475,
0.0072149676,
-0.0316181481,
-0.0196282677,
0.0005738428,
-0.0276669916,
-0.0091111315,
0.001980548,
-0.0244575962,
-0.0393745713,
0.0593979321,
0.0104130507,
0.0642950758,
0.0445486195,
-0.0062820273,
-0.0169726145,
0.0331745446,
0.0224821549,
0.0713848472,
-0.0532150194,
-0.018456487,
-0.0240998138,
0.0347930454,
0.0635255501,
-0.0126237636,
0.0188232269,
0.0025334863,
-0.0414964333,
-0.0181979779,
-0.0047114664,
-0.002567935,
0.0188054182,
-0.017515406,
0.0086099626,
-0.0048173526,
-0.0036210278,
-0.0025552241,
0.0370750912,
-0.0171420127,
-0.004762074,
0.0283040423,
-0.0402050428,
0.033394292,
0.0035275717,
0.011892275,
-0.0407063551,
-0.0005783283,
-0.010067842,
0.0131291104,
0.0287792888,
-0.0278725754,
0.0512233675,
0.0054495661,
-0.0330946445,
0.0166455377,
-0.0043829684,
0.0649607405,
-0.0531433821,
0.0791482851,
-0.0199095644,
0.0086168833,
-0.0217103325,
0.0865532309,
0.0088085504,
0.0392284431,
-0.0121619198,
-0.0504799634,
0.0100538228,
0.0193115585,
-0.0516309515,
0.0142804505,
0.0263020955,
-0.0304447319,
-0.0034631935,
-0.0141453417,
0.0100395847,
-0.0388998352,
2.386e-7,
0.0175103713,
0.05651737,
0.0174402632,
-0.0271597188,
0.0220874716,
0.0460230485,
0.0202879217,
0.0046144957,
0.0369881205,
-0.012787113,
0.0222962163,
-0.0234168097,
0.0894581527,
0.0259166304,
-0.111442402,
-0.0552064627,
-0.0560753942,
-0.0224712417,
-0.0267960932,
0.0235762745,
0.0685308501,
0.0900320932,
0.0135452161,
-0.0028071771,
-0.0186764896,
0.0171288718,
0.0289581455,
-0.0699565485,
-0.0363503061,
0.0502983965,
0.0626318678,
0.0123504028,
-0.0148253487,
0.0123490011,
-0.0294584688,
0.0216177478,
0.0124977445,
0.0662356615,
0.0322440565,
-0.0441605747,
0.0294858217,
0.013409595,
-0.0038220375,
-0.0388792679,
0.017591631,
-0.0539109483,
-0.0346100405,
-0.0113763474,
-0.0006427765,
-0.0252686981,
0.0693652034,
-0.0037688529,
-0.0513053425,
0.0487479046,
0.0322467647,
-0.0300223362,
0.0055927066,
-0.0530785359,
-0.0126939137,
0.0398629494,
-0.0342724063,
-0.0286846608,
0.0103413928,
-0.0018138816,
0.0083226971,
-0.0146167148,
0.0415892452,
1.485430656e-34,
0.0543388538,
-0.0030255432,
0.0045884666,
0.0662251934,
0.0433097705,
0.0100458683,
-0.0278178267,
0.0008615958,
0.0341153815,
-0.0153983328,
0.0401000902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13892v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13892v3 | General Phrase Debiaser: Debiasing Masked Language Models at a Multi-Token Level | 2023-11-23T10:23:51 | 2024-01-25T15:36:44 | Bingkang Shi, Xiaodan Zhang, Dehan Kong, Yulei Wu, Zongzhen Liu, Honglei Lyu, Longtao Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The social biases and unwelcome stereotypes revealed by pretrained language
models are becoming obstacles to their application. Compared to numerous
debiasing methods targeting word level, there has been relatively less
attention on biases present at phrase level, limiting the performance of
debiasing in discipline domains. In this paper, we propose an automatic
multi-token debiasing pipeline called \textbf{General Phrase Debiaser}, which
is capable of mitigating phrase-level biases in masked language models.
Specifically, our method consists of a \textit{phrase filter stage} that
generates stereotypical phrases from Wikipedia pages as well as a \textit{model
debias stage} that can debias models at the multi-token level to tackle bias
challenges on phrases. The latter searches for prompts that trigger model's
bias, and then uses them for debiasing. State-of-the-art results on standard
datasets and metrics show that our approach can significantly reduce gender
biases on both career and multiple disciplines, across models with varying
parameter sizes. | [
0.0312155411,
0.0735126659,
-0.0233355872,
0.006397353,
-0.0088209109,
0.0043241032,
0.0904924124,
-0.0153532699,
0.036853049,
-0.0722442195,
0.0008132705,
0.0277676322,
0.0127483783,
0.0386270732,
0.0438133851,
-0.0588990785,
0.0382558331,
0.0116842845,
0.0552364364,
-0.0616870224,
0.0120956376,
0.0359195024,
-0.0120030772,
0.0542438589,
0.0237898566,
-0.0295335464,
0.0811981484,
0.0002826909,
0.0072260126,
0.0049394285,
0.0942302123,
0.0480070859,
0.0075404285,
0.0260021705,
0.0000018748,
-0.0654200166,
-0.0121001573,
-0.0077974675,
0.0041674557,
-0.0174463708,
0.0532203019,
-0.0213590674,
0.0104875537,
0.0285505131,
0.0006343539,
-0.0142284166,
0.0282152332,
0.0204669517,
0.0311433077,
0.0432701744,
-0.0050186422,
-0.0142889842,
-0.068667002,
-0.0282045025,
-0.0223283526,
0.0082935244,
0.0536450744,
-0.0934727266,
-0.0784548223,
-0.0027196505,
-0.0162222888,
0.008770152,
-0.0283096135,
0.0247035548,
0.0518368408,
0.033386033,
-0.0538114458,
-0.0309730116,
0.0166439321,
0.0218367763,
-0.0324444585,
-0.0280434936,
0.0237345304,
-0.0365158394,
0.0569898486,
0.0566691943,
-0.0116222072,
0.0233945716,
-0.0017414957,
-0.0333854705,
-0.0248701107,
0.0170024633,
0.0082318727,
0.0552997179,
-0.0172425304,
0.0761164799,
0.036736697,
-0.0416124687,
0.0133080268,
0.0104861017,
0.0435555577,
-0.0621994622,
0.0097936951,
-0.0365394764,
-0.0010661171,
0.0178871267,
-0.0300319847,
-0.0288878735,
0.0164039861,
-0.0367032066,
-0.0649357811,
-0.0019849518,
-0.003439985,
0.0110116424,
-0.0045764111,
-0.0059326282,
0.0066280277,
-0.0061379881,
0.0077186641,
-0.0272231512,
0.0080635799,
-0.0192825217,
-0.0128169162,
-0.0041581467,
-0.0213609692,
0.0343468487,
-0.021595072,
-0.0213485751,
-0.0633920506,
0.0223623216,
-0.002576191,
0.0261262953,
-0.0581539571,
-0.0018425621,
-0.0144231096,
0.0140969064,
-0.0447888225,
0.0365824066,
-0.0300613828,
-0.0575754866,
0.0009673528,
0.0083348788,
0.0138354497,
-0.0628579482,
0.0187562741,
0.0358328,
0.0339207835,
0.002894249,
0.005608236,
-0.0355446488,
-0.0301194396,
-0.0328285284,
0.0253369454,
-0.0372883491,
0.0385609381,
0.0181443002,
0.0240546316,
-0.0768704563,
-0.0018250146,
0.0230539888,
-0.0584081188,
0.0522639751,
0.0317312628,
-0.0209563207,
0.0776808336,
0.0291483775,
-0.0362521745,
0.0840861872,
-0.0010547924,
0.0454019494,
0.0545674711,
0.0056377123,
0.0269194301,
0.0458882004,
0.069746688,
0.0082486365,
-0.0222345628,
0.0149045903,
0.0203008447,
-0.003879722,
0.0799146816,
-0.0008365006,
-0.0008219677,
-0.0214416105,
0.0348382816,
0.0471202023,
-0.010910118,
0.0311992355,
0.0326105505,
0.039022062,
-0.0054742098,
0.0381470099,
-0.0528189614,
-0.0142634222,
0.0086302161,
-0.0133400615,
-0.0056525609,
0.0481628738,
-0.0092820572,
-0.0119766025,
0.0073945029,
0.0292356871,
-0.0021411178,
0.0055635977,
0.0162099712,
0.0271745734,
-0.0187168624,
0.0704469159,
0.0517088398,
-0.0344216861,
0.0035782331,
-0.0356200747,
-0.0093777757,
0.0244398415,
0.0406700335,
-0.0279116314,
-0.0030710038,
-0.0468831323,
-0.0071599642,
0.074174054,
0.0324477553,
-0.0094107771,
0.0212932117,
-0.0209644996,
-0.02656365,
-0.015990261,
0.0437840819,
0.0154022705,
0.0559177436,
0.0403680019,
0.0190812424,
-0.0546855256,
-0.015879903,
0.0352427587,
-0.0140648643,
-0.0520993061,
-0.0012378864,
0.0000285517,
0.0043967166,
0.0029976789,
-0.0402111597,
-0.003704675,
-0.023740761,
-0.0124251777,
0.0027599826,
0.0065689059,
-0.0425219461,
-0.0232594237,
0.0042394702,
-0.0723152906,
-0.0638579056,
0.0478236079,
-0.0369856097,
0.0050724694,
0.0523087569,
0.0138449473,
0.0241602603,
0.0144007718,
-0.0171381216,
-0.0425396562,
0.0341360271,
-0.0326111503,
0.0495573245,
0.0020503898,
-0.0070581567,
0.0033048047,
-0.0609953217,
0.0029559168,
-0.0534045808,
-0.0292809401,
-0.0090265321,
0.0087669119,
-0.0059785265,
0.0527566187,
-0.0504522584,
-0.0350198112,
-0.0100561231,
-0.0704951063,
-0.0270324517,
-0.0027818833,
-0.0151773803,
-0.0106097404,
-0.0033103302,
-0.0358671248,
-0.0187022276,
-0.0225989949,
-0.0933017507,
-0.0247889422,
0.0177735724,
0.0081593832,
-0.0339871496,
-0.0083968407,
-0.0492881946,
-0.016579207,
-0.057483688,
0.0659771413,
0.0342343412,
-0.0463432781,
-0.0102010425,
0.0260280725,
-0.0322596803,
0.0066090804,
-0.0060096886,
0.0025474625,
-0.0131356325,
0.0542246439,
0.0383971855,
0.0833526999,
0.0307876822,
-0.0024787472,
0.0371805169,
-0.0051387553,
-0.0596129261,
-0.0062884148,
0.0011644105,
0.0389148258,
0.0059159165,
-0.0704081878,
0.023246143,
0.0158949606,
0.0351533331,
-0.0388039239,
-0.0322071239,
0.0575256273,
-0.034007553,
-0.0396851227,
-0.040719606,
-0.0221110787,
-0.010770808,
0.0134533187,
-0.0180519614,
-0.0366505533,
0.0449695662,
-0.0099662915,
0.0265228488,
-0.0237425976,
0.0001179342,
-0.0261466037,
0.0277511757,
-0.0055317092,
0.0303033739,
0.0389722288,
0.0060689063,
-0.0616625547,
-0.0262823701,
0.0253737494,
-0.0302010439,
-0.0254224502,
-0.0193335656,
-0.0013083736,
0.0099582057,
-0.0303623807,
-0.0362419821,
-0.0721760616,
-0.0216930341,
0.0050173919,
0.0189119745,
-0.0175915416,
-0.0393392295,
-0.0311123822,
0.017995365,
0.0236818772,
-0.012065676,
0.0013057461,
0.0017572684,
0.0167492367,
0.0587495007,
-0.0214935988,
-0.0049268189,
-0.0236903112,
0.0085223103,
0.0077896067,
0.0275893155,
0.0298716966,
0.0145546068,
-0.0276008397,
0.0212493632,
-0.0857356787,
0.0174587071,
-0.0190297086,
0.0142947473,
-0.0407223962,
-0.0018874262,
0.1298116893,
-0.0131658213,
-0.0492998585,
-0.0102152247,
0.0056511201,
0.0327326134,
0.029765483,
0.0127653684,
-0.0781035796,
-0.0003656957,
0.005452672,
0.0295074265,
-0.0246357489,
-0.0257923044,
-0.0319663659,
-0.1255819201,
0.0128215346,
-0.0010599502,
0.0228184294,
-0.0219598301,
-0.044811029,
0.0070781107,
-0.0370255336,
0.0127033908,
-0.0425461568,
0.0069257859,
0.0273395851,
0.0105222557,
-0.0305083245,
-0.0470705293,
0.0271474086,
-0.0792514384,
0.0661073774,
0.0284517147,
0.0405232757,
-0.0542445853,
-0.0064323517,
0.0167371202,
0.0032327429,
-0.0209460389,
0.000004812,
0.0634751171,
-0.0990864187,
-0.0138617437,
0.0003931213,
0.0422402769,
0.0210405178,
0.0096224472,
0.0211937428,
0.0346406028,
0.0281799156,
-0.0265378691,
-0.0571183749,
0.0029331322,
0.0038785846,
0.1058979258,
0.0180482287,
-0.0579392835,
0.0012699596,
-0.0663228408,
0.0225043818,
0.0233923513,
-0.0375407524,
-0.0072363876,
-0.0350955687,
-0.0016418698,
-0.011545781,
-0.0346279778,
0.0406903364,
0.0169800948,
-0.0023517865,
-0.0089701284,
0.02657119,
-0.007901473,
-0.0754678845,
0.0371243767,
-0.0351080485,
0.0573294051,
0.0305810589,
-0.0310557242,
-0.0019021393,
-0.0175119992,
-0.0606979914,
0.0349934325,
-0.0109718656,
-0.0550163724,
0.063296698,
0.0159074292,
0.0190060083,
0.0675372109,
-0.0213475469,
-0.052394636,
0.1006180644,
0.0560809188,
-0.0358227491,
0.0212784111,
0.037539266,
0.0136414403,
-0.0027284557,
0.0200121701,
-0.0613839589,
0.0178989973,
0.0463261865,
-0.0252254251,
0.0023999533,
-0.039376799,
-0.0162558015,
-0.0034692711,
0.0475503653,
-0.0346860848,
0.0530248508,
-0.0452357046,
-0.0378898755,
-0.0247206725,
-0.0674502477,
0.014209508,
-0.0007207349,
0.0354940146,
0.0167535748,
-0.028095888,
0.0228310153,
-0.0576701164,
0.0205963701,
-0.0608836003,
0.0194519982,
-0.0010400621,
0.0461382456,
0.0021973127,
-0.0388569534,
-0.0034145666,
-0.0116900122,
-0.0161133315,
0.0089657456,
0.0326014049,
0.0008341632,
0.0296939723,
0.0065036523,
-0.0200933255,
0.0059159016,
-0.0561558865,
0.0170432813,
-0.0102275796,
0.0097645484,
0.0108243534,
-0.0333653465,
0.0236628111,
0.0276586171,
-0.0150461709,
0.0381250158,
-0.0186097007,
0.0163667798,
0.0092304396,
0.0480341688,
-0.004907432,
-0.0345555171,
0.0201909449,
0.0681602359,
0.0617573224,
0.0601295717,
-0.0148423323,
-0.0414975323,
-0.0054992638,
-0.0313576721,
0.0421937853,
0.025091568,
0.0088158725,
-0.0069730147,
-0.0723552406,
-0.0678010508,
-0.0069314362,
-0.0131445089,
0.0227544587,
-0.0069650523,
0.007416876,
0.0501292236,
-0.0113236094,
-0.0597363822,
-0.0186257754,
0.0454073064,
0.0159733258,
-0.0238021426,
-0.0293976832,
-6.12451328e-33,
-0.024560852,
-0.0326965488,
-0.0347646736,
-0.0130101945,
-0.0002277603,
-0.0111611029,
0.015141787,
-0.0325622484,
-0.0240355041,
0.0297771469,
-0.0150488513,
0.038016092,
0.0195452087,
-0.0080589978,
0.0081801591,
0.0235530473,
0.0839233696,
0.009109905,
-0.0345724076,
-0.0064489474,
-0.0037084906,
0.0289862864,
0.0291062649,
-0.0608695522,
0.1027757376,
-0.0272656623,
-0.0409176201,
-0.0113170948,
0.0160027016,
0.0060873465,
-0.0182446707,
0.0379427299,
0.0074665775,
-0.0520997755,
-0.0048198877,
0.0451141223,
-0.0582911596,
-0.0330213793,
0.0248234794,
0.0136020938,
0.0445027202,
-0.0332172774,
0.0371104404,
0.0116198147,
-0.0481258072,
-0.0222629122,
0.0705858842,
0.0112098679,
0.0521495864,
-0.0073893424,
-0.0368377939,
0.0338830687,
-0.0272254106,
0.0410115756,
-0.0150316618,
0.0083270241,
0.0384502821,
0.0412245803,
-0.0378429852,
0.0166161116,
-0.0147862118,
-0.0113565912,
0.0304939523,
0.0052028862,
0.0185434744,
0.0670050159,
0.0660729706,
0.0413522013,
0.0187810063,
-0.0277401973,
0.0215349253,
-0.0299527775,
0.0304911789,
0.0640651286,
0.032410197,
-0.0234882385,
-0.0388535112,
0.0067200493,
0.0031874469,
-0.0030226663,
0.021359073,
-0.0167686846,
-0.047157485,
-0.0462768041,
-0.0368005633,
-0.0836370513,
-0.0077726613,
0.0088194069,
0.0241790991,
0.0179977026,
-0.0598366298,
0.0323171169,
-0.0282446947,
-0.0612176955,
-0.0058881114,
0.0282071922,
-0.0233492237,
-0.0324047469,
0.0283891819,
0.0224348381,
-0.0746826231,
0.0180534925,
0.0124140233,
0.0698453486,
0.0347102471,
-0.0004431981,
0.0095028793,
0.0056930906,
-0.0829961598,
-0.0004113976,
-0.0124919116,
-0.0222068038,
0.0060408525,
0.0288120713,
0.0248997156,
0.0486050099,
0.0018232319,
-0.0356743112,
0.0495755672,
0.0008676118,
-0.0195102375,
0.0134625174,
-0.0046008648,
0.0436672606,
-0.0111935558,
-0.0433219895,
0.0138639053,
-0.0275715832,
0.0586420707,
-0.0284820292,
-0.011889101,
-0.0778981373,
2.529e-7,
0.001997344,
0.0518938489,
-0.0048625097,
0.0593398362,
0.0098842429,
0.0311869346,
0.0536162108,
0.0646267012,
0.0176382307,
0.0136224367,
-0.0331280008,
0.0076908302,
-0.018674884,
0.0029424648,
-0.0827592611,
-0.0240573306,
-0.0564310811,
0.0110042775,
-0.0362767726,
-0.0079377219,
-0.0047123069,
0.0687091202,
0.0480335169,
0.0042525833,
-0.0280758031,
-0.0417652167,
0.0171920806,
-0.0050970083,
0.0068576215,
0.0420841649,
0.0375739224,
0.0265269075,
0.0194932055,
0.038299568,
-0.0155785978,
0.0592487566,
0.0245695319,
0.0509666502,
-0.0025092061,
0.0232085958,
-0.0100935549,
0.0055528395,
-0.0120487949,
-0.0760580674,
0.0485118963,
0.0143737374,
-0.0014249213,
-0.1033536121,
-0.042492047,
0.0145287625,
0.059841454,
-0.0457209609,
-0.0415931307,
-0.0073960852,
0.0164339487,
0.0093707554,
-0.0387699977,
-0.0706984848,
-0.0274346266,
-0.0359543487,
-0.0259370133,
-0.0694711059,
0.033663962,
0.0135010183,
0.0173065886,
-0.070862107,
0.0399712734,
2.24733788e-34,
0.044819545,
0.0347367041,
-0.0280737318,
-0.0091158161,
0.0389526598,
-0.0120467087,
-0.0332456343,
-0.0123310201,
0.0397269167,
-0.0242352877,
-0.0055822055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13878v1 | Minimizing Factual Inconsistency and Hallucination in Large Language Models | 2023-11-23T09:58:39 | 2023-11-23T09:58:39 | Muneeswaran I, Shreya Saxena, Siva Prasad, M V Sai Prakash, Advaith Shankar, Varun V, Vishal Vaddina, Saisubramaniam Gopalakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used in critical fields such as
healthcare, education, and finance due to their remarkable proficiency in
various language-related tasks. However, LLMs are prone to generating factually
incorrect responses or "hallucinations," which can lead to a loss of
credibility and trust among users. To address this issue, we propose a
multi-stage framework that generates the rationale first, verifies and refines
incorrect ones, and uses them as supporting references to generate the answer.
The generated rationale enhances the transparency of the answer and our
framework provides insights into how the model arrived at this answer, by using
this rationale and the references to the context. In this paper, we demonstrate
its effectiveness in improving the quality of responses to drug-related
inquiries in the life sciences industry. Our framework improves traditional
Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) by enabling OpenAI GPT-3.5-turbo to be
14-25% more faithful and 16-22% more accurate on two datasets. Furthermore,
fine-tuning samples based on our framework improves the accuracy of smaller
open-access LLMs by 33-42% and competes with RAG on commercial models. | [
0.0593891144,
0.0906172469,
0.0047653727,
0.0138117503,
-0.0113557791,
-0.0097972713,
0.0062312968,
0.0085813897,
0.0027598951,
-0.0409702621,
0.0218364485,
-0.0348975062,
0.0043683858,
0.0160368998,
0.001779386,
-0.0324184522,
0.038717024,
0.0283328202,
0.0500451848,
-0.0082736006,
0.010094218,
0.0374174081,
-0.0126080541,
0.0561427809,
0.0031565675,
-0.0420055985,
0.0189519357,
-0.0093299989,
0.0285201725,
-0.029027516,
0.0004305329,
0.0400338508,
-0.0070277206,
0.0595147051,
0.0000020401,
-0.0646337047,
-0.0222283453,
0.0361967571,
-0.0541394241,
0.0073545966,
0.0253425464,
0.039967414,
0.0054106852,
0.032526657,
-0.0552279316,
0.0059295297,
0.0693647936,
0.0507126711,
0.0692590699,
0.0663960204,
-0.0082079424,
-0.0367009342,
0.0257698987,
-0.0174312182,
0.040188022,
-0.0395001471,
0.0484348498,
0.0264800675,
0.0085778078,
0.0085800933,
0.0285504665,
0.0377437919,
0.001152487,
-0.0148399761,
0.0265935138,
0.0347799249,
-0.0475824475,
-0.0253992341,
0.0165129788,
0.0744640604,
0.006621331,
-0.024685815,
-0.0086311391,
-0.0048459559,
-0.0015082341,
0.037090674,
-0.0545793921,
0.0216682721,
-0.0245147794,
0.0413186327,
0.0039632493,
-0.0119041782,
0.0413162299,
0.0328268483,
-0.0412325114,
0.0524602495,
0.007076466,
-0.0188206602,
-0.0210405644,
-0.0032043962,
-0.0078232493,
-0.0321291424,
0.0103978543,
0.0411076061,
-0.0301255826,
0.0257272441,
0.0072245174,
-0.0205033943,
0.0854571536,
-0.0827786177,
0.0088424804,
0.0027494358,
-0.045822423,
0.0265686288,
-0.0287610367,
0.0190194789,
-0.0412806608,
0.0175793655,
-0.0442702472,
-0.0111585921,
-0.0587845072,
-0.0249796994,
-0.0322499909,
0.0279511791,
-0.0450984612,
0.0038257746,
-0.0634643435,
-0.0004922968,
-0.0476217419,
-0.0130540291,
0.0037399523,
0.047449816,
-0.0483564436,
-0.0220963303,
-0.049592603,
0.0594321638,
-0.0242376514,
0.0192068052,
0.0230473038,
-0.0957406834,
0.003020297,
0.0118595501,
-0.0059272978,
-0.0045568179,
-0.0127994074,
0.0419084206,
-0.0000064773,
0.009034357,
-0.0438450836,
-0.0739772543,
-0.0289719328,
-0.0640116036,
-0.0177802462,
-0.0627147704,
0.0337473005,
-0.0026840214,
-0.0218202639,
-0.0658478364,
0.0224013515,
0.0460437462,
-0.0686179549,
0.0832567811,
-0.0366493054,
0.0087228939,
0.0488942824,
0.0262705199,
0.012041402,
0.021419229,
0.0133689148,
-0.0015566011,
0.0254293885,
0.0116467299,
0.043258734,
-0.0364596248,
0.0368700773,
-0.020736564,
0.0065790098,
0.033269342,
-0.0089850696,
0.0412316471,
-0.0323803388,
0.0553073622,
-0.0180788729,
-0.0020150123,
0.0540490896,
0.0179438666,
0.0069087301,
-0.007924811,
0.0186042227,
-0.0067327786,
-0.0039991792,
0.0014067369,
-0.0220796354,
0.0210162345,
-0.0215054359,
0.0226421356,
0.0614873432,
0.0173834953,
-0.0163502172,
-0.0318401828,
-0.0185361151,
0.0146175157,
-0.0101443892,
0.0178158395,
0.0163666829,
0.0003407174,
-0.0516404808,
0.0713965297,
0.0416824035,
-0.0577176362,
-0.0124697974,
-0.069260031,
0.0309842043,
0.0670433939,
0.0646582767,
-0.008709929,
-0.0069161225,
-0.0036431896,
0.0025193314,
0.0545811914,
0.0360183157,
-0.0238116533,
-0.0116832145,
-0.0589090623,
-0.0018095704,
-0.0050451392,
0.0242181104,
-0.0026596701,
0.0238956716,
0.0148127936,
0.0241528042,
-0.0328016579,
-0.0253466945,
0.0218415335,
-0.0126629313,
-0.043845918,
0.0078500751,
-0.0005526054,
0.0303362999,
0.04236231,
-0.0014665392,
0.065439634,
0.0294970367,
-0.0179166123,
-0.0045287595,
-0.0141652087,
0.009131927,
0.0195548795,
0.0291334167,
0.0097561404,
-0.0131685259,
-0.0214340668,
-0.0432522483,
-0.0406820998,
0.0014600827,
-0.0133680636,
0.0330535769,
-0.0585857667,
-0.0062783915,
0.0266794115,
0.0297460649,
-0.0479177721,
0.0638464093,
0.0131896669,
-0.0104165236,
0.045347143,
-0.0160994865,
0.0211648531,
-0.0523420013,
0.0105286129,
0.0510726646,
0.0040128608,
0.0279980954,
0.0256436002,
-0.0314869992,
-0.0347452164,
0.0055638663,
-0.0659285709,
-0.0187431388,
-0.0072447131,
-0.0021980722,
-0.0013624572,
0.0056013442,
0.0100329509,
-0.024370702,
-0.0456921048,
0.0079180179,
0.0126551474,
0.0340681374,
0.016027892,
0.0385605358,
-0.0028487139,
-0.0334088095,
0.0006825287,
-0.0287778322,
0.0401578881,
0.0046705655,
-0.0292999018,
-0.057721179,
-0.0076343799,
-0.0732119009,
0.0171093643,
0.0066162203,
0.0089341709,
0.0315422416,
-0.0041726017,
0.007122485,
0.0229744893,
0.0120478114,
0.0055053486,
0.0617688857,
-0.0060357833,
-0.057666339,
0.0101619698,
-0.0472474173,
-0.043072857,
0.0305859987,
-0.0641702786,
0.0069862958,
0.0344856195,
0.0290615819,
-0.0045384378,
-0.0644317716,
0.0284258295,
-0.0249889195,
-0.0036883813,
-0.0403804071,
-0.0100987451,
-0.0273516532,
0.0564289391,
-0.0113420896,
-0.0504022017,
0.0991338566,
-0.0312524028,
0.0453432985,
-0.0723949373,
0.0103408508,
-0.009585062,
-0.0086035039,
-0.0290360004,
0.0306820404,
0.0028539817,
0.0160558596,
-0.0035250559,
-0.0250522066,
0.0153249335,
-0.0685841218,
0.0755933523,
-0.0707225055,
0.03108388,
0.0102069043,
-0.0297098812,
-0.0540846474,
-0.0394375958,
-0.0280986987,
-0.0116250422,
-0.0152007416,
-0.0136653734,
-0.0411016345,
0.0076841856,
0.0198220592,
0.0308650956,
-0.0100552794,
-0.0195185859,
0.0125273168,
0.0212360956,
0.0908238739,
-0.0016823175,
0.0355556197,
0.0046755276,
0.0456258878,
0.0708287358,
0.0429209806,
-0.0007293717,
-0.0054125665,
-0.0392174385,
-0.0074771633,
-0.0215003602,
0.0153341284,
0.0417017192,
0.0115981176,
-0.0433288142,
-0.0167649649,
0.0918611139,
0.0386930369,
-0.0325551033,
-0.0067039495,
-0.053466551,
-0.0013624929,
-0.0119834701,
0.0367824771,
-0.0959556177,
-0.0108251506,
-0.0176520292,
0.0421070457,
-0.0281461198,
-0.0058522089,
-0.0235890392,
-0.1163654551,
0.0549537949,
0.0265302844,
-0.0254870411,
-0.0251491088,
-0.050315287,
-0.0254281834,
0.0053233686,
0.0527867489,
0.0395438857,
0.0263132714,
-0.0028220546,
0.0092954598,
0.003362257,
-0.0649038106,
0.0115075726,
-0.0051923026,
0.0481006131,
0.0815023258,
0.0287015308,
0.02043714,
-0.0488287173,
-0.0052545285,
-0.013535643,
0.0016183429,
-0.0056208298,
0.056324169,
0.0362112895,
0.0047147688,
-0.0509971492,
0.0204598792,
-0.0435086936,
-0.051828634,
-0.0240759905,
0.1035045832,
-0.0442557856,
-0.0127916541,
-0.0480059609,
0.0233143829,
0.0081175156,
0.087005198,
0.0292569064,
0.0142905489,
-0.037361864,
-0.03699857,
0.0309825726,
-0.0353637971,
-0.0238238815,
0.0290793907,
-0.0066785603,
-0.015276798,
-0.0780488178,
-0.0415978692,
0.0242728759,
-0.003298399,
-0.0041851713,
0.0399418026,
0.0088140042,
-0.0312535353,
-0.0142991133,
0.043086879,
-0.0246466752,
0.0131753422,
-0.0194031019,
-0.0016595188,
0.0306729451,
-0.0194405671,
0.0018201194,
0.0480118282,
-0.0093677277,
-0.0738711283,
-0.0072145406,
0.0470132716,
0.0369899645,
0.0258801617,
-0.01712678,
-0.0290282033,
0.0185074247,
0.0479822718,
-0.0027497108,
-0.0227630232,
-0.0191306788,
0.0007274584,
-0.0042354646,
0.0151283117,
-0.0653014183,
0.0052246833,
-0.0137695903,
0.0640916228,
-0.0175762773,
-0.0296644382,
0.0791191906,
0.031534519,
0.0570072979,
-0.0072497693,
0.0101825949,
-0.0296396893,
0.0199565087,
-0.0415857919,
-0.0072312444,
-0.0013229438,
0.0099649932,
0.0146773597,
-0.041048687,
0.0004721618,
-0.0133637665,
-0.0712174028,
0.0238521956,
-0.0217419211,
-0.0241429415,
-0.0066303844,
0.021882508,
0.0456489287,
-0.0219146684,
-0.0254818108,
0.0243883654,
-0.0047401618,
0.0557002649,
0.0008332157,
0.0839027688,
-0.0039172159,
-0.0163729656,
-0.0025525854,
-0.0095832562,
-0.0645758137,
-0.0829203948,
-0.0392659456,
0.0131900134,
0.0216295477,
0.0032602476,
0.0755439028,
-0.0220186133,
-0.0215581637,
-0.0234825294,
0.0122823473,
0.053646896,
-0.0289094876,
0.03179029,
0.0136189507,
-0.0169136673,
-0.0244502313,
0.0943954811,
-0.024915345,
0.0327984542,
-0.0402714014,
-0.0523822568,
-0.0192834307,
-0.0821224004,
-0.0398026891,
0.0262573902,
-0.0352930203,
-0.0096736001,
-0.0873433575,
-0.0479428917,
-0.0089416169,
0.0121905543,
-0.0066512097,
-0.0036286886,
0.015703002,
0.0682872161,
0.0113388263,
-0.0555943996,
-0.0574932732,
0.0514601804,
-0.0587725081,
-0.0187656134,
-0.0175314471,
-6.699705808e-33,
0.0105015589,
-0.0441257246,
0.0089463582,
-0.0589101762,
0.0185164437,
0.0079265703,
-0.0483307168,
-0.0114126466,
-0.0411851481,
0.0433319025,
-0.0006300192,
0.0207953025,
0.0215847045,
0.013652714,
0.0002423243,
-0.0125420736,
0.0196280088,
0.0298245903,
-0.0102811307,
0.0359558091,
0.041148439,
0.0146168321,
0.0391501635,
-0.0748174563,
0.0739590451,
-0.0149409231,
-0.0123668108,
0.0314325653,
-0.0454360135,
0.070704177,
-0.0224472247,
0.0798272043,
0.0165630393,
-0.0643098205,
-0.0033006251,
-0.0178580564,
-0.036129836,
-0.002202125,
0.0201375112,
-0.0365803801,
-0.055363968,
-0.0393381231,
0.045191355,
-0.0190403946,
-0.0329515226,
0.0156814456,
0.0325611718,
-0.0485229418,
-0.0144047895,
0.0115010319,
-0.0445290133,
0.0155879976,
0.0296012219,
0.0130912205,
-0.0312687606,
0.0643788502,
-0.0196777433,
0.0301436912,
-0.0637882352,
0.0184388254,
0.016671665,
0.0241979435,
0.0562364906,
-0.021071963,
-0.0105004534,
0.0390198193,
0.0114849843,
0.0018320011,
-0.0488369577,
-0.0336417109,
-0.0562441237,
0.0493419953,
0.0643491521,
0.0702465773,
0.039912954,
-0.0028678186,
-0.0806312189,
0.0486555621,
-0.0536592416,
0.0570219718,
0.0210481528,
-0.0127511285,
-0.05086568,
-0.0164641198,
-0.0126042832,
0.0342006274,
-0.0679045692,
-0.0387261696,
0.028000921,
-0.0150093604,
-0.0373040475,
0.0148692625,
0.0160633251,
-0.0434054062,
-0.0116379755,
0.0156766698,
-0.0105690695,
-0.0192885362,
-0.016108986,
0.0114756562,
-0.0278678741,
0.0317042395,
0.0127977123,
-0.0154909585,
-0.0097232852,
0.031916853,
0.0132033853,
-0.0442892499,
-0.0383113325,
0.0183399208,
-0.0383983515,
0.013845019,
0.0052138227,
-0.0139901238,
0.0179615542,
0.0516919717,
0.0057873367,
0.0626595393,
0.0234130919,
0.0153674539,
-0.0075755892,
-0.0363616757,
0.0085295532,
0.013334739,
-0.0456745476,
0.0280358754,
-0.0154734179,
0.0248777457,
0.0154199498,
-0.0585256927,
-0.0218220279,
0.0124099506,
2.864e-7,
0.0776094422,
0.0385118686,
0.0252962355,
0.0018942661,
-0.0003458281,
0.0212954227,
0.0082998872,
0.0095833419,
0.0004543289,
-0.03552109,
-0.0006780594,
-0.000010074,
0.0474169329,
0.0347591937,
-0.0558930002,
-0.0315099843,
-0.0864363313,
-0.0404250771,
-0.0671747923,
-0.0162204262,
0.0401028804,
0.0690347254,
-0.0136439996,
-0.0191924907,
0.0137355048,
-0.0318605006,
0.0583668277,
-0.0063014049,
-0.0131264683,
0.0543429144,
0.0624651834,
-0.01667393,
0.0241859313,
0.012256097,
-0.0381751955,
-0.0436051302,
-0.0048927357,
0.0530330352,
-0.0409341417,
-0.0568158962,
-0.0058946242,
-0.0373771787,
0.0474795699,
-0.0670437962,
0.0345165916,
-0.0085443975,
-0.0348770507,
-0.0200317949,
-0.0353673287,
-0.0036526767,
0.0461914353,
-0.0214804448,
-0.0230583921,
0.0199497882,
-0.0085027767,
0.0396635383,
-0.0088027166,
-0.0448115841,
-0.0377881713,
-0.001462751,
-0.0506273955,
-0.0229514726,
0.0074192872,
-0.0150580136,
0.0128600392,
-0.0656401962,
0.0345292315,
2.545629674e-34,
0.0361960046,
0.0210989174,
0.0177226737,
0.0126104131,
0.0632785484,
0.0195648782,
-0.0001812469,
0.0232036337,
0.0220475364,
-0.0792604461,
-0.0310521573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13857v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13857v1 | Challenges of Large Language Models for Mental Health Counseling | 2023-11-23T08:56:41 | 2023-11-23T08:56:41 | Neo Christopher Chung, George Dyer, Lennart Brocki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | The global mental health crisis is looming with a rapid increase in mental
disorders, limited resources, and the social stigma of seeking treatment. As
the field of artificial intelligence (AI) has witnessed significant
advancements in recent years, large language models (LLMs) capable of
understanding and generating human-like text may be used in supporting or
providing psychological counseling. However, the application of LLMs in the
mental health domain raises concerns regarding the accuracy, effectiveness, and
reliability of the information provided. This paper investigates the major
challenges associated with the development of LLMs for psychological
counseling, including model hallucination, interpretability, bias, privacy, and
clinical effectiveness. We explore potential solutions to these challenges that
are practical and applicable to the current paradigm of AI. From our experience
in developing and deploying LLMs for mental health, AI holds a great promise
for improving mental health care, if we can carefully navigate and overcome
pitfalls of LLMs. | [
0.0660053119,
0.0731856152,
-0.0267050117,
-0.0051788609,
-0.0440410525,
0.0196837988,
0.0273822397,
0.0196145494,
0.0965974703,
-0.0281751212,
0.010179176,
-0.0340256318,
0.0022678394,
0.0107479868,
-0.0279843882,
-0.0770222247,
-0.0006302039,
0.0048419377,
0.0779251754,
-0.013922289,
-0.0233195573,
0.0269031003,
-0.0257964302,
0.0526839197,
-0.0118867252,
-0.0294147339,
0.0409930423,
-0.0034988823,
-0.0118077043,
-0.0599829443,
-0.0442537479,
0.0442522168,
-0.000055995,
0.0136246635,
0.0000020693,
-0.0356238335,
-0.0095200008,
0.0191865452,
-0.0218578577,
-0.0350717381,
0.0348217376,
-0.0812453181,
0.0286927819,
0.0112218158,
-0.0260426346,
0.0155890025,
0.0496723838,
0.0788664743,
0.0468210578,
0.0428448841,
-0.0271246806,
-0.0090588992,
0.0250536501,
-0.0032846506,
-0.020375682,
-0.0219088551,
0.0762693956,
0.0088749779,
0.0347410589,
-0.0414812267,
-0.0013152834,
0.0577791482,
-0.0377098955,
0.0382238701,
-0.0402149111,
0.0115891239,
-0.0368793681,
-0.0443447009,
0.021715207,
0.0500933975,
0.0375484675,
0.0153950602,
0.0196237639,
-0.0009823872,
0.0086209746,
0.0178747438,
-0.0213856939,
0.0381900147,
-0.0199589562,
0.0174373295,
0.0614703037,
-0.0047707101,
0.0354508199,
-0.0060988185,
-0.005384611,
0.0700890198,
-0.0157978013,
-0.0221744105,
0.0159616005,
-0.0105596781,
-0.053570874,
-0.0696376935,
0.0433223359,
0.0288643986,
-0.0603633337,
0.0341549441,
-0.0478932224,
-0.0459711254,
0.0359481052,
-0.0513709746,
0.0078622857,
0.0250934437,
-0.0324348249,
-0.0187503193,
0.0612047836,
0.0139643699,
-0.0145205967,
0.0668418705,
-0.0230681896,
0.0130806239,
-0.0649975017,
-0.0016461534,
-0.0242059007,
0.0104616107,
-0.0263709538,
-0.0102185654,
-0.0652068406,
0.0137621677,
-0.0547811575,
0.0120802792,
-0.0275757238,
-0.013003693,
-0.0107688233,
-0.0173397958,
-0.0144365793,
-0.020433167,
-0.0248878766,
0.0126340482,
0.0001980816,
-0.0601386577,
0.0370834433,
-0.0077519175,
-0.039995525,
-0.0313131027,
-0.0012186542,
0.0540174283,
0.0612871386,
-0.0092927944,
-0.0586986095,
-0.0494526625,
-0.0658918545,
-0.03807161,
0.0231774282,
-0.0184053183,
0.0303419866,
0.0131181385,
-0.0035960374,
-0.0836717561,
0.02041463,
0.0065518836,
-0.0990217552,
0.0751361996,
-0.0513710715,
0.0069840942,
0.0321729742,
0.0468089357,
0.0002877876,
0.0223050937,
-0.0005377487,
0.0219667442,
0.0202135146,
-0.0159533713,
0.0396713391,
-0.0250920579,
-0.0007378411,
-0.0303921681,
-0.021083178,
-0.014171958,
-0.0231750216,
0.0431188978,
-0.0592587367,
0.0425548516,
0.0033174809,
0.0172997192,
0.0565300062,
0.0684966221,
0.014193641,
0.0477598719,
-0.0006550982,
0.0187329315,
-0.0079887975,
0.0023413976,
-0.0670300201,
-0.0076674181,
-0.0374557152,
-0.0355143137,
-0.0008232563,
-0.0040928791,
-0.0131472386,
-0.0545308813,
-0.0354127996,
-0.0488628633,
-0.0237353407,
0.0270213634,
-0.0080336705,
-0.026687311,
0.0155570749,
0.0273940116,
0.0681142211,
0.0378327332,
-0.0334294103,
-0.074957706,
0.0085527841,
0.1311702579,
0.0270297173,
-0.0441892706,
0.0275581572,
-0.038789656,
0.0109486952,
0.0238029975,
-0.0002198675,
0.0098077357,
0.0190994088,
-0.0160497427,
0.0046733678,
0.0298302099,
0.0291922987,
0.0175583977,
-0.030237982,
0.0157959331,
-0.0297912285,
0.0063616526,
-0.0507911891,
0.0522809066,
-0.0414034314,
-0.0384670608,
-0.0108508486,
-0.0095701059,
0.0577477328,
0.0265181176,
-0.0208869446,
0.027526889,
0.0022876458,
-0.0318906233,
-0.0539263189,
0.0124920225,
-0.0466331169,
0.0281050932,
-0.0046090544,
-0.0191722158,
0.0113570746,
0.0111432709,
-0.0010547054,
-0.003798275,
0.0126447072,
-0.0525574312,
0.0524649322,
-0.0010144046,
0.0093797464,
-0.0064623235,
0.0565362237,
-0.0309125967,
0.0320450813,
-0.0494697392,
-0.0025062962,
0.0131685222,
-0.0564037561,
-0.0232139453,
-0.0053786663,
-0.0145981628,
0.0142590059,
0.002233925,
0.0081721805,
-0.0323402509,
-0.0235391669,
0.0095466319,
-0.0134473806,
-0.0979173556,
-0.0061450647,
0.0050053354,
-0.0330608413,
0.0003790524,
-0.0379111879,
-0.0194562022,
0.0002357295,
-0.0207581855,
-0.0096708965,
0.0391027927,
0.0424635522,
-0.016788397,
0.0434200279,
-0.0355368145,
-0.0131617729,
-0.0240579043,
-0.0495879874,
0.0325784944,
-0.0042080446,
-0.0380839817,
-0.0686716065,
0.0253729839,
-0.0459468812,
0.0217529759,
-0.0099561261,
-0.0255784336,
-0.0030393885,
0.021376254,
0.0266639013,
0.0269760024,
-0.0008137064,
0.0437728055,
0.0670020729,
0.0298528969,
-0.0103235152,
-0.0330670737,
0.0126972673,
-0.00846879,
-0.0578979477,
-0.0792164877,
0.0002127347,
0.034274783,
0.0596522838,
0.00656409,
-0.0472821109,
0.0233986843,
-0.0226716194,
-0.032255508,
0.0271256529,
-0.0438199267,
-0.0173726864,
0.0456757285,
-0.0083936099,
-0.0259525292,
0.0880474225,
-0.0029876556,
0.0348219648,
-0.013078995,
-0.0360224806,
-0.0027847921,
0.004861813,
0.0191684105,
0.0564166009,
0.0239772946,
0.0007616257,
0.0398563705,
-0.042364113,
-0.0371560082,
-0.0406518988,
0.0271512717,
-0.062456958,
-0.010218,
0.0407594405,
-0.0139246089,
-0.0498857498,
-0.0440701954,
-0.0480703898,
-0.0269983932,
0.0012193986,
0.0233499333,
-0.0505870283,
-0.0251235403,
0.0455776565,
0.0151380189,
-0.0028630886,
-0.0348969139,
-0.0030827869,
-0.0388330556,
0.0244825892,
-0.0366911255,
0.059035033,
-0.0270212367,
0.0252859071,
0.0324259996,
-0.0213531349,
0.0613313764,
0.0113108037,
-0.0104192719,
-0.0167700965,
0.0054547773,
-0.0186813921,
0.0451265089,
0.0178139042,
-0.0075288764,
-0.0184167456,
0.1229090542,
0.0192327052,
-0.0446528159,
0.0465845056,
-0.031890817,
-0.0479031838,
-0.0067693652,
-0.0264823772,
-0.0485612862,
0.0070336452,
-0.0226430409,
0.048365999,
-0.0741886944,
-0.0343066677,
-0.002956213,
-0.0178907551,
0.0385517702,
0.0052314443,
0.02750572,
-0.040653877,
-0.0106141921,
-0.0020780403,
0.0096472101,
0.0167733543,
-0.0483932532,
0.0134202233,
-0.0145009374,
-0.0069711786,
-0.0769009739,
-0.039790336,
0.0473252945,
-0.0044771726,
0.1001577601,
0.0454251543,
0.0604656264,
-0.0384573676,
-0.039985884,
-0.0355197042,
0.0694676489,
-0.0057404479,
0.0245598722,
0.0734502673,
0.016713189,
0.0192457009,
-0.0471730232,
0.0547698066,
-0.0371350199,
-0.021058226,
0.0072102956,
0.0779961869,
-0.053077247,
-0.0314237103,
-0.0026249599,
0.0357846022,
0.0384966359,
0.063087225,
0.0188131556,
-0.0465399735,
-0.0054392745,
-0.0082275653,
0.0410376526,
0.0132704927,
-0.0175023507,
0.0669680834,
-0.0147131672,
-0.0261402056,
-0.0532193705,
-0.0390270464,
0.0271443669,
-0.012772575,
0.019233292,
-0.0130008822,
0.0269061141,
-0.0050057522,
-0.0221866127,
0.0435601771,
-0.0138398418,
0.011975321,
0.0003779503,
-0.0004372795,
0.0047799544,
-0.0458701588,
0.0091580413,
0.0286938474,
-0.0070326962,
-0.0244023744,
0.1021581218,
0.0207146164,
0.0205919482,
0.0077438056,
0.0096262395,
-0.0399758108,
0.0174935888,
0.0198570862,
-0.0250811558,
-0.0052088932,
0.0042855437,
0.0690724403,
0.0017858663,
0.0357647426,
-0.0013173036,
0.0548787862,
0.0366039313,
-0.0283514615,
-0.0374742299,
-0.0088493647,
0.0275410209,
0.0589618757,
-0.0108231539,
-0.0108310906,
-0.0068789897,
0.0062695458,
-0.0450641364,
-0.042974472,
0.0078262603,
-0.0114461528,
-0.0236791633,
0.0457688086,
-0.0041116988,
-0.0078948364,
-0.0673304796,
-0.0780229345,
-0.0425902717,
-0.033996094,
0.0217771437,
-0.0055768471,
0.0330191851,
0.0214580484,
-0.0084600197,
-0.0101292888,
0.0584966913,
-0.0236951951,
0.0524179861,
-0.0074121901,
0.0820659325,
-0.0027432162,
-0.0213712342,
0.0118618347,
0.0284953136,
-0.0387569405,
-0.1478333771,
-0.0040456452,
-0.0081534786,
0.0223331489,
0.0440802723,
0.0272963773,
-0.0516985394,
0.0186833441,
0.0045765117,
0.0225077365,
0.0147744091,
-0.0291378088,
-0.0042325049,
-0.0019667752,
-0.0271240734,
-0.0169482436,
0.0563254654,
-0.0083148899,
0.0346652344,
-0.0065817148,
-0.048050981,
-0.0305638257,
-0.0426284,
-0.035480462,
0.0357791632,
-0.0484169051,
-0.008588464,
-0.0685782209,
-0.0462104864,
0.0226885099,
-0.0211892016,
-0.0114372484,
-0.0471385904,
0.0067374217,
0.0230759922,
0.0179621577,
-0.0395363756,
-0.0451282226,
0.0195985306,
0.0050889817,
-0.0038293314,
-0.0136686834,
-5.431895478e-33,
0.0124130659,
-0.0328626409,
0.0032442168,
-0.0300306231,
0.0095922081,
-0.0250157639,
-0.0071550114,
0.0259215515,
-0.0048259492,
0.0157077778,
0.0328775942,
0.0533357225,
0.0073056929,
0.0275986325,
0.0183317419,
0.0091655841,
0.0195788126,
-0.0098264907,
0.0093793804,
-0.0028151199,
-0.0131289447,
0.054491207,
0.0432779305,
-0.1255836487,
0.0674897581,
0.0088194469,
-0.0083766691,
0.0097389156,
-0.0146532347,
0.0123964567,
-0.0490396656,
0.052996289,
0.0491726808,
-0.0118947215,
-0.000626798,
0.004441448,
-0.0032465938,
-0.0132021476,
0.0313442647,
-0.0181704983,
-0.0259244759,
-0.0274969954,
0.014512415,
-0.0299825594,
-0.0096639069,
-0.0054013282,
0.021108279,
-0.0842163712,
0.0286836158,
0.0280458275,
-0.0188421067,
-0.0084017357,
-0.008713373,
0.0283452962,
0.0012734572,
0.0447216518,
-0.0512247346,
0.0385058485,
-0.021312587,
-0.0007406333,
0.0368108675,
-0.0393827744,
0.0207717977,
-0.0539093204,
-0.0055094855,
0.0476143099,
0.0396818258,
0.0163682289,
-0.0490527414,
-0.0232273191,
-0.0118303113,
0.0505005568,
0.0456103757,
0.0130203301,
-0.0103238169,
-0.0232171286,
-0.0299568083,
-0.0398023203,
-0.02084166,
-0.0223228578,
0.0731791928,
-0.0158640239,
-0.0754004866,
-0.0389667861,
-0.0300221294,
-0.0192754306,
-0.0155434012,
-0.015005351,
0.0106176026,
-0.0238126535,
-0.0105758375,
0.0184746403,
-0.0048499885,
-0.0577639975,
0.0154999048,
-0.0187153239,
0.0475599691,
0.0131413816,
-0.0080296947,
0.0003841969,
-0.0288701318,
-0.0200962257,
0.0037947923,
-0.0049599526,
0.0817570612,
0.0036529289,
0.0455021374,
-0.0434036516,
-0.0277624968,
-0.0033841881,
-0.0006721134,
0.0470657237,
0.061698243,
-0.015089401,
-0.0040221587,
0.004801061,
-0.0155351404,
0.0182855036,
0.0295979306,
-0.004764691,
-0.0515429154,
-0.0064353626,
-0.0176040865,
-0.0010173189,
-0.0264014751,
-0.0682733208,
-0.0184005313,
0.0124943452,
0.0655825138,
-0.0522984527,
-0.0107682329,
-0.0409136787,
2.751e-7,
0.0233553965,
0.0772321746,
0.0077224192,
0.0205923431,
0.0149315028,
0.0326316208,
0.0325635113,
0.0433295518,
0.013317341,
-0.0261918046,
0.0061518713,
0.0352214351,
0.0339254625,
0.0506787337,
0.0147664966,
-0.034069065,
-0.0225967206,
-0.0153608127,
-0.0790811479,
0.0259935446,
0.0774675161,
0.067022793,
0.0194434617,
-0.0264896732,
0.0064066965,
-0.0030412986,
0.0211497657,
-0.044446703,
0.0105795385,
0.0595459715,
0.0330529995,
0.0221738778,
0.0294570271,
0.0462751612,
0.0090391114,
-0.0234444961,
-0.0368426964,
0.0826237351,
-0.0515279025,
-0.0113702463,
0.0002650637,
0.0173656307,
0.0082847429,
-0.0289941393,
0.0384886898,
-0.0595072359,
-0.066714555,
-0.0192649923,
-0.0160416756,
-0.0659095421,
0.0268646777,
0.0041065495,
0.0238092076,
0.0393037684,
0.0143393548,
0.0172031596,
0.0505652428,
-0.037368875,
0.0046034842,
0.0126270447,
-0.0495102182,
0.0127359843,
0.0199583359,
0.0096443268,
0.0081165787,
-0.099565722,
0.0495041385,
2.491845986e-34,
0.0228474606,
0.0397089571,
0.0292198211,
0.0171979181,
0.0387374759,
0.0336238593,
-0.0061694691,
0.0278292056,
-0.00993466,
-0.0566232167,
-0.0083359303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13848v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13848v1 | Grammatical Error Correction via Mixed-Grained Weighted Training | 2023-11-23T08:34:37 | 2023-11-23T08:34:37 | Jiahao Li, Quan Wang, Chiwei Zhu, Zhendong Mao, Yongdong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The task of Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) aims to automatically correct
grammatical errors in natural texts. Almost all previous works treat annotated
training data equally, but inherent discrepancies in data are neglected. In
this paper, the inherent discrepancies are manifested in two aspects, namely,
accuracy of data annotation and diversity of potential annotations. To this
end, we propose MainGEC, which designs token-level and sentence-level training
weights based on inherent discrepancies in accuracy and potential diversity of
data annotation, respectively, and then conducts mixed-grained weighted
training to improve the training effect for GEC. Empirical evaluation shows
that whether in the Seq2Seq or Seq2Edit manner, MainGEC achieves consistent and
significant performance improvements on two benchmark datasets, demonstrating
the effectiveness and superiority of the mixed-grained weighted training.
Further ablation experiments verify the effectiveness of designed weights of
both granularities in MainGEC. | [
0.0864230469,
0.0261193477,
0.0072959773,
0.0285255034,
-0.0123817688,
0.0471792147,
-0.0202497542,
-0.0153381499,
-0.0103070522,
-0.0859544054,
-0.0071177734,
-0.0115727484,
0.0258337464,
-0.0318127871,
0.0422849394,
-0.0289463662,
0.0618635081,
0.0166607015,
-0.0216812696,
0.0016806113,
0.0245728139,
0.0066110133,
-0.0407126658,
0.029714372,
-0.0791864023,
-0.0234277137,
0.017028302,
0.0494157933,
0.0228733793,
-0.0268447585,
0.0941238999,
0.0757805631,
-0.0210106149,
0.0776404291,
0.0000019713,
-0.0204481538,
-0.0002036528,
0.0067004221,
-0.0042523011,
0.0480990037,
0.0255063847,
-0.0187812019,
-0.0403094478,
0.0008535103,
0.0171667729,
0.0004096654,
0.0664071292,
0.0621907823,
0.0506325513,
0.0728178248,
0.000864196,
-0.0246704835,
0.0265723262,
0.007170775,
-0.0276083164,
0.0339789651,
0.0283904653,
0.0294762887,
-0.0377940275,
-0.0032347883,
-0.0132674454,
0.0064212293,
0.0035194419,
-0.0276484266,
0.0249178857,
-0.0006348469,
-0.0923256502,
0.0215931796,
-0.029494999,
0.0267909039,
0.0123789124,
-0.043669194,
-0.0329677239,
-0.0173770525,
0.0115405861,
-0.057274133,
0.0048063942,
-0.0047368822,
-0.0063325786,
0.0304637067,
0.0427438915,
-0.085594438,
-0.010155417,
0.0057365182,
0.0400906242,
0.0506786071,
0.0076546101,
-0.0803818554,
-0.0366471969,
0.0551569834,
-0.0177933387,
-0.0485820509,
0.0425946787,
-0.0109162116,
-0.0428152382,
-0.0238781869,
-0.0291807428,
-0.0790722296,
0.0194715858,
-0.0374549776,
0.0109157991,
0.0056874268,
-0.0533609092,
-0.0090576075,
-0.0099477153,
0.0246478226,
0.0872699469,
0.0177724827,
0.0084769931,
0.0258224774,
-0.0705726072,
-0.0054672286,
-0.0615380518,
0.0450298488,
-0.0238936488,
0.032450866,
-0.0748360157,
-0.0221362729,
-0.0418532155,
0.0196000133,
0.0282825176,
0.0042537455,
-0.0599328168,
-0.0187360123,
-0.011188915,
0.0244069751,
-0.0033097558,
0.0745789632,
0.0232899245,
-0.0503331162,
-0.0269131213,
0.0207910929,
0.0129834311,
-0.0207073018,
0.0125083514,
-0.0204073526,
-0.0220804513,
-0.0354254059,
-0.0545178056,
0.0055866716,
-0.0332932062,
-0.0123334154,
-0.0974839181,
-0.0662685558,
-0.0241736807,
-0.0300056022,
0.0037739433,
0.0360595435,
0.0072445776,
-0.001916531,
-0.0318351202,
0.0620966703,
-0.057407368,
-0.0271252822,
0.0026923965,
-0.0389305502,
0.0253569614,
0.0414567888,
0.0205480922,
-0.0382179134,
0.034171816,
0.0364042409,
0.0045684716,
-0.0240730867,
-0.0585840344,
-0.0076792627,
0.0127119152,
-0.0293694492,
-0.0228176769,
0.03319389,
0.0525510237,
0.0687042698,
-0.0372896753,
0.0508664548,
0.0584509112,
0.0328843333,
-0.0194867887,
-0.0005508907,
0.0199553501,
-0.0412418842,
0.0288345627,
0.0396021083,
-0.0564635508,
-0.0189206265,
-0.0772579536,
-0.0172639564,
0.0293322932,
-0.0007772805,
-0.0133778593,
-0.0638521537,
-0.0196191408,
-0.017958127,
0.0096031893,
-0.0743133649,
0.0257260129,
0.0371728204,
-0.0057828119,
0.0599561967,
0.0482304171,
-0.0689369217,
-0.0079239225,
0.0103779258,
-0.0208940301,
0.0454296507,
0.0411323048,
-0.0324463993,
-0.0418761075,
-0.0152367493,
-0.0056679389,
0.0407985039,
0.0652456284,
-0.0197172146,
-0.0063930769,
-0.0588845834,
0.0003328055,
0.0005747325,
0.0429116897,
-0.0268724039,
-0.0203880854,
-0.0006065672,
-0.0104743559,
-0.0042170095,
-0.0853252187,
0.0500463098,
0.0554034747,
-0.0148401707,
0.0067884955,
-0.014810401,
0.027586272,
0.0061243726,
-0.0409535468,
-0.0031810917,
-0.0218707826,
-0.0014836751,
-0.0571993776,
-0.0284910146,
-0.0054443637,
-0.0800022334,
0.0265467819,
-0.0482271835,
-0.0498566888,
-0.0078810556,
-0.0642948747,
-0.042742487,
-0.0107489238,
-0.0247379281,
0.0148192458,
-0.0739380196,
0.0323363692,
0.0184615627,
-0.0284786224,
-0.0735000372,
0.0203223117,
-0.0039819526,
0.0400269516,
-0.0663119033,
-0.061117433,
0.0040885052,
-0.0691522136,
-0.0184179284,
-0.0225312058,
0.0038200226,
0.043991901,
0.0180652607,
0.0339782722,
-0.0471962765,
-0.0390363447,
-0.0850136578,
-0.0075695352,
-0.0618109293,
0.0393286906,
0.0346650481,
0.0095553314,
-0.0231863987,
-0.0479081646,
0.0127775464,
0.0469955616,
-0.0086578084,
-0.0051916474,
0.0904921815,
-0.0188166052,
0.007614118,
-0.0529934168,
0.0107667213,
-0.0362805426,
-0.0365603529,
0.0231032893,
-0.0115112774,
-0.0770775452,
0.0338683575,
-0.0336232074,
0.0312290546,
0.0613452122,
-0.0673387796,
-0.0033984354,
0.0296447612,
0.0346385464,
0.0141700171,
0.0112482477,
-0.0034159049,
-0.003020202,
0.000586629,
-0.0040530106,
0.0135336658,
-0.0032175127,
0.0163270682,
-0.0365197547,
-0.0030191906,
0.0228149761,
0.0515685752,
0.0000984648,
-0.019026611,
0.0014294951,
-0.0102758417,
-0.0133748213,
0.005482967,
-0.0018196445,
0.002360879,
0.0110785784,
-0.0078788092,
-0.0411958024,
-0.0120674204,
0.0754665434,
0.0208345465,
-0.0111568598,
-0.0660997704,
-0.0056934846,
-0.020691786,
-0.02751486,
0.0211097579,
0.0319668092,
0.0036642961,
-0.0458070338,
-0.0441689305,
-0.0045327302,
0.0714739934,
0.0016075943,
0.0215767771,
-0.0518458523,
0.0446143858,
-0.0008074525,
-0.0554776974,
-0.0015691937,
-0.013307929,
-0.020678306,
-0.0301356371,
0.0125575904,
0.0116633419,
-0.0387207717,
-0.0163865797,
-0.0056764749,
0.0480530001,
-0.0124541139,
-0.0249111429,
-0.0272302888,
-0.0114891641,
-0.0146671114,
0.021349458,
0.0131004797,
0.0051297783,
0.0102424584,
0.0499688461,
-0.0295028724,
0.0256596711,
-0.022264922,
0.0166507419,
0.041941084,
-0.0431918502,
-0.0559909679,
-0.0144884679,
0.0950993374,
-0.0379151553,
-0.0231675729,
0.0977055356,
0.0559544899,
-0.0296966378,
0.0075918627,
-0.0024034113,
0.0124170715,
0.0139762526,
0.0245640017,
-0.0807886198,
-0.028841896,
0.0428133346,
0.0337254815,
-0.0196976569,
-0.0126291877,
0.0456346385,
-0.1194535494,
0.065487802,
0.030627165,
-0.0119643891,
-0.0430220738,
0.0001480999,
0.0137360403,
-0.0348268822,
0.0561557002,
0.0389783233,
-0.0212620217,
0.0250238925,
0.0648019388,
-0.0694367439,
-0.0804821923,
-0.0368896648,
-0.0175894666,
0.0522622243,
0.0308130421,
-0.0011757041,
-0.0185588636,
-0.0452277176,
0.073371239,
0.0325973518,
-0.03317127,
0.004492315,
0.0399992466,
-0.0106576933,
-0.0095370412,
-0.04110891,
0.0389064513,
-0.0167299956,
-0.0198346972,
-0.0215306822,
0.0487060174,
-0.0049044974,
0.0397806019,
0.029476624,
-0.0265008584,
0.0388498493,
0.0216730852,
0.014378923,
-0.0168826301,
-0.0290332381,
-0.0748544037,
-0.0082020741,
-0.0327266417,
0.057798896,
0.0554113053,
-0.0352770798,
0.0043742596,
-0.0689047053,
-0.0729237273,
-0.0055294125,
0.0039268299,
0.0100862319,
-0.0261091795,
-0.0158274099,
-0.0100577148,
0.031583745,
-0.0167602003,
-0.0077458424,
0.0113171041,
-0.0620267615,
-0.0124571258,
-0.0397665426,
0.0477955416,
-0.0116207534,
-0.0357591175,
-0.0531671494,
-0.0454507843,
0.0160297491,
0.0363884047,
0.0030817529,
0.0247756932,
-0.0252397954,
-0.0571196526,
0.0190913752,
0.0726052597,
-0.0068781585,
0.0325797834,
0.0322917029,
-0.0481723361,
-0.0088565852,
0.0188105237,
-0.0093246726,
0.0254959278,
0.0036580134,
0.0945014656,
-0.0067708506,
0.0043305871,
0.0612209216,
0.0349840075,
0.0443512276,
0.0017489705,
-0.0046969452,
-0.0586386248,
0.0412781127,
-0.0131096328,
-0.0267181955,
-0.0173748266,
0.0308645032,
0.0020577044,
-0.02005128,
-0.018545974,
0.0037955621,
-0.0458354875,
0.0358590297,
-0.030893201,
0.0062252455,
0.0297348928,
0.0389977992,
-0.0149153341,
-0.0036481817,
-0.0270007066,
-0.0157469735,
0.0430267118,
0.051368285,
0.0090643503,
-0.0017677462,
0.0321834721,
0.028885277,
-0.022463236,
-0.0016153496,
-0.0477180332,
0.0761178881,
-0.0496462397,
0.0068738549,
0.0850454867,
-0.0026413503,
0.0523843057,
-0.0200697482,
-0.0247889981,
-0.0298019946,
0.0425188281,
0.0139576262,
0.0157854483,
-0.0131074628,
-0.0085259499,
-0.0027228135,
-0.0239196829,
0.0333109573,
-0.046233058,
0.0399195775,
-0.0162479393,
-0.0282567143,
-0.0174823571,
-0.0101753259,
0.012729452,
-0.0044931597,
-0.0119697098,
-0.0067624627,
-0.0159126576,
-0.0512528382,
-0.0075950618,
0.0533621758,
0.0420067273,
-0.0183172282,
-0.0015380277,
0.0260878261,
0.0134403855,
-0.0105402777,
-0.0443081595,
-0.0522903092,
0.0269744582,
-0.0054442529,
-0.0515029468,
-6.058191154e-33,
-0.0355162844,
0.030627016,
-0.0384747498,
0.0054614986,
0.013717901,
0.0187031236,
-0.0036878497,
-0.0040824539,
0.0438277051,
0.0693849325,
-0.0052741715,
0.0298581421,
0.0029082333,
0.008166316,
0.0692117363,
0.0384785458,
0.0635118559,
0.0147029636,
-0.0272984318,
-0.0458445549,
0.0315826871,
0.0434383228,
0.0922701806,
-0.0057469169,
0.0652536675,
0.0292419344,
-0.0244653262,
0.0118126646,
0.0204745382,
0.0269105714,
0.032579869,
0.0534228571,
0.0033374408,
0.04008938,
-0.0404122621,
-0.0613570735,
-0.0727458447,
-0.0474224426,
-0.0079799918,
0.0503021851,
0.0078778882,
-0.004377903,
0.0360115319,
-0.025593875,
-0.0295782089,
-0.0030639321,
0.0260878634,
-0.0284341425,
0.0407361351,
-0.0030595323,
-0.0343152992,
0.019155113,
-0.0134786321,
0.0203484278,
-0.0550592728,
0.0183814708,
-0.0027904634,
-0.0184210725,
-0.0465426967,
-0.029937502,
0.0275277253,
0.0435591899,
-0.0268108491,
-0.0028948507,
-0.0456976816,
0.0302131623,
0.0164584108,
0.0267901197,
-0.011300466,
0.0168324597,
0.0048548682,
-0.0197284631,
0.0421924479,
0.0270461626,
0.0779394358,
-0.0241995174,
-0.0738999993,
0.0171236396,
0.0004185307,
0.0537261069,
-0.0243493542,
0.0107350582,
-0.0044478336,
-0.0275121015,
-0.0213512629,
-0.0117121767,
-0.0087179886,
0.0170147475,
0.0170613993,
0.0339793377,
0.0023660872,
0.0127562983,
-0.0392825566,
-0.0008393918,
-0.0324307904,
-0.0562797263,
0.0155067453,
0.0094690574,
-0.001041158,
0.0028439963,
-0.0234750789,
-0.0278875809,
0.0362628512,
0.0335971005,
0.0292222649,
0.0016620375,
0.1058976725,
0.0239382796,
-0.0663856715,
0.0186611041,
0.005909041,
0.0211253669,
-0.0028294516,
0.0118101267,
0.0045581656,
-0.0128516471,
0.013272211,
-0.0112451389,
-0.0088305576,
0.0095016118,
-0.0240212623,
-0.0086145606,
-0.0147550898,
0.0388067253,
0.0035157278,
0.004720551,
0.0035799311,
-0.034439899,
0.0042065084,
-0.0120626679,
0.0082079722,
-0.0157268085,
2.688e-7,
0.0260130689,
0.0599608459,
0.0350192599,
-0.051187668,
-0.0152677018,
-0.0163996648,
-0.0359538831,
0.0534142703,
0.0060488386,
0.0377264246,
0.0408428386,
-0.0012191081,
0.0338371694,
0.01002126,
-0.0477384776,
-0.0218734574,
-0.0461107716,
0.0221536383,
-0.0122348974,
-0.0072273482,
0.0339165367,
0.0440059789,
0.0309738461,
-0.0123631172,
0.0082376702,
-0.0208284687,
0.0456324704,
0.0091482382,
-0.0008741141,
0.0107798362,
0.0720169917,
0.0486292243,
0.0485328734,
0.036174275,
-0.0226830672,
-0.030170314,
-0.0071365973,
0.015083882,
-0.0598932877,
0.0695497841,
-0.0194699969,
0.0243211389,
0.0083261365,
-0.0009591216,
0.0104478355,
-0.0125766871,
0.0223436784,
-0.0106237233,
-0.0380976275,
0.0148167238,
0.0332550406,
-0.0142510636,
-0.0335851237,
-0.0044712503,
0.0603775457,
0.0509684905,
-0.0247780569,
-0.0281603616,
-0.002828639,
0.0547140539,
0.0471623205,
-0.0362267867,
0.0383457802,
-0.003658988,
-0.0012827902,
-0.0552206002,
-0.005840986,
2.483705458e-34,
0.0728329644,
-0.0044973087,
0.0429462306,
0.003166191,
0.0301812291,
0.0125908414,
-0.016451668,
0.0059080846,
-0.0220761728,
-0.0262224246,
-0.0118328314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13833v1 | Lego: Learning to Disentangle and Invert Concepts Beyond Object Appearance in Text-to-Image Diffusion Models | 2023-11-23T07:33:38 | 2023-11-23T07:33:38 | Saman Motamed, Danda Pani Paudel, Luc Van Gool | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Diffusion models have revolutionized generative content creation and
text-to-image (T2I) diffusion models in particular have increased the creative
freedom of users by allowing scene synthesis using natural language. T2I models
excel at synthesizing concepts such as nouns, appearances, and styles. To
enable customized content creation based on a few example images of a concept,
methods such as Textual Inversion and DreamBooth invert the desired concept and
enable synthesizing it in new scenes. However, inverting more general concepts
that go beyond object appearance and style (adjectives and verbs) through
natural language, remains a challenge. Two key characteristics of these
concepts contribute to the limitations of current inversion methods. 1)
Adjectives and verbs are entangled with nouns (subject) and can hinder
appearance-based inversion methods, where the subject appearance leaks into the
concept embedding and 2) describing such concepts often extends beyond single
word embeddings (being frozen in ice, walking on a tightrope, etc.) that
current methods do not handle.
In this study, we introduce Lego, a textual inversion method designed to
invert subject entangled concepts from a few example images. Lego disentangles
concepts from their associated subjects using a simple yet effective Subject
Separation step and employs a Context Loss that guides the inversion of
single/multi-embedding concepts. In a thorough user study, Lego-generated
concepts were preferred over 70% of the time when compared to the baseline.
Additionally, visual question answering using a large language model suggested
Lego-generated concepts are better aligned with the text description of the
concept. | [
0.0338872969,
0.0630954131,
-0.014092369,
0.0665551797,
-0.0079210633,
-0.0059823855,
-0.0292960647,
0.0042984355,
-0.0271974374,
-0.0201280154,
-0.0050707245,
-0.0263791066,
0.0080791693,
0.0463999063,
0.0209094826,
-0.1010472551,
0.00333758,
-0.00821923,
-0.0772293732,
0.0030398516,
0.0278007034,
0.0177333448,
0.0301786475,
-0.0013966195,
-0.0178739056,
-0.019408809,
-0.0183612946,
0.0158291366,
0.0431529693,
-0.0187318679,
-0.0317645445,
0.0245172624,
0.0351203308,
-0.0363004543,
0.0000021119,
-0.0047136289,
0.0178887192,
0.0004995792,
0.0288051553,
-0.005173834,
0.0430704094,
-0.008052649,
0.0157355797,
-0.0224917326,
-0.0211776625,
0.0247789342,
0.0852491856,
0.0842576548,
0.0923965648,
0.0335353538,
-0.0252192263,
-0.0681005195,
-0.0338500589,
-0.0058358158,
0.0452819429,
-0.0168753546,
-0.0037522514,
0.008128671,
-0.0126661547,
0.0202243663,
-0.0538355485,
0.0267632175,
0.0332094431,
0.0157438871,
0.0448691398,
0.0511756428,
0.0121703139,
-0.0411141217,
-0.0016222722,
0.106505841,
-0.0087360041,
-0.0025796413,
0.0035406624,
0.0186821278,
0.0040768264,
0.0525036938,
-0.0266416259,
0.0118730981,
0.0062683555,
0.0271804295,
-0.0549007878,
0.0041942308,
-0.0124846436,
0.0069661527,
-0.0042455061,
-0.0206509251,
0.0359449349,
0.0036485589,
-0.0307393726,
0.0152358161,
-0.0334332474,
-0.035185311,
0.0362139866,
0.0105744768,
0.0057711564,
0.0142513551,
-0.0445341393,
-0.054029949,
-0.0484988168,
-0.0441859253,
0.0610001199,
-0.0006800373,
0.0023945803,
0.0499556363,
-0.02051875,
0.032684017,
-0.022681715,
-0.0115163457,
-0.07065586,
-0.0039845975,
-0.0420649089,
-0.0338818356,
-0.0608151816,
0.0184316281,
-0.0739031807,
-0.0516920649,
-0.0037005423,
0.007972898,
-0.0196151119,
-0.0293207113,
-0.0328921042,
0.0715910718,
-0.0542693473,
-0.0240043681,
-0.0418355279,
0.0159043781,
-0.0209484939,
0.016677374,
0.0037578631,
0.0261923019,
-0.0061939512,
0.0085191922,
0.0392705575,
-0.0005008756,
-0.0093304794,
0.0403044522,
-0.0623027794,
0.0150623396,
-0.0082104895,
-0.0151035553,
-0.0072550992,
-0.036059428,
0.0362434685,
-0.078215383,
0.0004412126,
-0.0363445617,
-0.0109451031,
-0.0710485876,
0.0233670808,
0.014406749,
-0.0416252427,
0.0841043815,
-0.0133251091,
-0.0153852263,
0.0256685838,
0.0470491685,
0.0319832563,
0.0564394891,
0.0027648683,
0.0629238561,
-0.0086171478,
-0.0236621853,
0.0140643427,
-0.002664679,
0.0204138197,
0.0107580004,
-0.0607972518,
-0.015311596,
-0.0354493298,
0.0413867682,
0.0330075361,
0.0659907535,
-0.0256690197,
0.0101140225,
0.0872710124,
0.0284360126,
-0.0363708101,
0.0102708805,
0.0169365853,
0.0200002939,
-0.0244208612,
0.0108617041,
0.0141466726,
0.071245864,
0.0036393707,
0.00681862,
-0.0293271709,
0.0421757065,
-0.0303372499,
-0.0375405364,
0.0214826744,
-0.0113373203,
0.0610481128,
-0.0379696675,
0.0231769476,
0.0836732537,
-0.0435384028,
0.0014666652,
0.0004122275,
-0.0585138835,
0.0036281722,
-0.0136095136,
0.0094003901,
0.0774181932,
0.0102409394,
0.0288080722,
0.0026057551,
0.0202810988,
0.0137776472,
0.0845039114,
-0.0630538911,
0.0087422319,
0.0146106873,
-0.0219700225,
-0.0016305118,
-0.01617782,
0.0011012248,
0.0111693358,
-0.0168797057,
0.0228683632,
0.0173518546,
-0.0103477705,
0.0469202921,
0.0304889157,
0.0056819431,
0.0126655623,
0.0000519612,
0.0197442397,
-0.0044515934,
-0.0038203972,
-0.0022811322,
0.0065346709,
0.0114436382,
-0.0445627645,
-0.0873073936,
0.0324228592,
-0.0137832193,
-0.0768852457,
-0.0117585706,
-0.1140951887,
-0.0029437987,
0.0136296488,
-0.0302807,
-0.0258462597,
0.0484101437,
-0.0407898277,
0.0505645722,
-0.0224855505,
-0.0202919394,
0.0313551798,
-0.0026045239,
-0.0246251859,
0.0702648982,
-0.0431619957,
-0.0095246444,
-0.0268026851,
0.009727465,
-0.0255371351,
0.0271458123,
0.0082548084,
-0.0082139876,
0.0118868658,
0.0023838547,
-0.0060640508,
0.0143151656,
-0.0620809942,
-0.0006027833,
-0.040824037,
-0.0107114846,
-0.0036959623,
-0.0257724673,
0.0412087776,
0.0009602751,
0.0117388209,
-0.0260743275,
-0.0370351523,
0.0393728949,
-0.037234623,
0.0161093082,
0.0328886844,
-0.0145347705,
-0.0000796961,
-0.0325428098,
0.027134968,
0.0146682421,
0.0713482946,
-0.0216872003,
-0.012955403,
-0.0375283547,
0.0470634587,
-0.0465969592,
0.0024372477,
0.0033351025,
-0.0683054179,
0.0185594447,
-0.0010387031,
0.1103410423,
0.0463756844,
0.0190403126,
0.0591309071,
0.026854001,
-0.0475159809,
-0.0187219009,
-0.0049255928,
-0.0188606717,
0.0206241384,
0.0382922255,
-0.0327680632,
0.0160360653,
0.0548388436,
0.0311142337,
0.0166768841,
-0.0601256937,
0.066018194,
-0.0031003798,
-0.0511808954,
-0.0438245125,
-0.0125800306,
0.0005099425,
0.0226240568,
-0.0534455404,
-0.0054649245,
0.0535607003,
-0.0112474868,
0.0112788389,
-0.0113517232,
0.0112926206,
0.0141894612,
0.0677316412,
0.0273082573,
0.0578788035,
0.0402438529,
0.0225660484,
-0.0581926592,
0.0080466047,
0.0324619412,
-0.0087158708,
0.0336658098,
-0.0544205122,
-0.0205090418,
-0.004629212,
-0.0162048116,
-0.0162697081,
-0.0264843069,
0.0494787991,
-0.0329193883,
0.0112031903,
-0.0101555204,
-0.0068878965,
0.0095986305,
-0.0103234258,
-0.0233029481,
0.0043855347,
-0.0190680455,
-0.0149355559,
0.0610171892,
0.1040635481,
-0.0123655675,
-0.0451446734,
-0.0308962408,
0.0269167256,
0.0726236776,
-0.0408731587,
-0.0370547697,
-0.0261188038,
0.017860258,
-0.0299748145,
0.0379449539,
-0.0001334384,
-0.0126988003,
0.0906127244,
-0.0434059985,
-0.0389962532,
0.0471913554,
0.0301638544,
0.0107451733,
0.0027437848,
0.0339428931,
0.0618655197,
0.0211162567,
0.008234757,
-0.0541214533,
-0.026905546,
-0.0138714677,
-0.0252195746,
0.021889044,
-0.0093322052,
-0.0163297337,
-0.0914243534,
0.0495759323,
0.0101791993,
-0.055665575,
-0.0536367111,
-0.0384866334,
0.0060814568,
0.0228393432,
-0.031923499,
-0.0282343309,
0.0165844001,
0.0235666335,
-0.0134514142,
0.0235961936,
-0.0193552319,
-0.0253178217,
-0.0319772884,
0.0052122264,
0.0486869514,
0.0406003632,
-0.0095667997,
-0.0242037773,
-0.0086940825,
-0.0172750037,
-0.0065597668,
0.0051978515,
0.0651570112,
0.0302721057,
-0.0234242994,
-0.0426613241,
0.0370111726,
-0.001681423,
-0.0540650822,
-0.0192540847,
0.0493343845,
-0.005560908,
-0.0251598787,
-0.0725025833,
0.0241965447,
0.029903546,
0.0709985346,
0.0464494042,
-0.0615839176,
-0.0263032727,
-0.0307059102,
0.0303412471,
0.0079952804,
-0.0795270428,
-0.0194071215,
-0.0224250499,
-0.0084566306,
-0.1250552237,
-0.0072708656,
0.0248006824,
0.0781363696,
-0.0005268094,
0.0023719803,
-0.0285188165,
-0.0262885485,
-0.0471239537,
0.0233670734,
0.0069234921,
0.0005748768,
-0.0000663959,
-0.0313127488,
0.0276102871,
-0.0305300578,
-0.0236528851,
0.023582099,
-0.0532826781,
-0.0378087834,
0.0058839931,
0.0388627984,
0.0168441888,
0.0205384698,
0.017393617,
-0.0320380665,
0.0622254312,
0.067104876,
0.0087435115,
0.0012878565,
-0.0226459876,
0.0298610274,
0.018704433,
0.0139162894,
-0.0274093952,
0.0594850741,
0.0125655327,
0.0239978824,
-0.0291603059,
-0.0042446735,
0.0198270101,
-0.0324634686,
0.0218228474,
-0.0018187948,
0.0304868426,
-0.0269155055,
-0.0260357615,
-0.0365791172,
-0.0428078249,
-0.0636909977,
-0.0165015571,
0.0543732084,
0.024035044,
-0.0129518751,
0.0001501122,
0.0272915941,
0.0242894497,
-0.02775646,
-0.0257885307,
0.0656380728,
0.0042822445,
0.0041487119,
0.0434193723,
0.0047139279,
0.0066347597,
-0.033463601,
0.0248659067,
-0.0124948332,
0.059851151,
0.005035622,
-0.0366192162,
-0.0752412975,
0.0425505042,
-0.0233556889,
-0.0035675198,
-0.0388839766,
0.0270037632,
0.0057429853,
0.0032220094,
0.0445217118,
-0.0110050999,
-0.0233947299,
0.0159093738,
0.0578584895,
-0.0160224643,
-0.0468952619,
0.0437733307,
0.0031127413,
0.0118910996,
-0.0276827719,
0.0586624406,
-0.0097730905,
0.032951165,
-0.0092219803,
-0.0144212935,
-0.0205673762,
0.0232720058,
0.0016069885,
-0.0129683111,
0.0447750986,
0.0478311516,
-0.053801246,
-0.0554675013,
-0.0356931537,
0.0046901982,
0.0098761097,
0.027559584,
0.0782004148,
0.0345644765,
0.013956707,
-0.0367029756,
-0.0016441668,
0.0195324197,
-0.0107864961,
-0.0350334719,
-0.0327221602,
-6.391225234e-33,
-0.0702400953,
-0.0334745869,
-0.0048570512,
0.0117705427,
-0.0305774864,
-0.0185491573,
-0.0511873625,
0.0103250705,
0.0221578926,
0.048103191,
0.0315446518,
-0.0071611153,
-0.007754432,
0.0445508249,
-0.0106967529,
0.0253590308,
0.047989022,
0.0109222075,
-0.0256112684,
0.0201005135,
0.0435103178,
0.0207370091,
0.0653506592,
-0.0701690614,
-0.0501382016,
0.009034005,
-0.0299496334,
0.0022606761,
0.0586311705,
0.0220097415,
-0.0354873128,
0.0009393042,
0.0104900924,
-0.0205776338,
-0.0232533533,
0.0235087033,
-0.0479904003,
-0.0461007133,
0.0109907938,
-0.0198347289,
-0.0752753913,
-0.0161480941,
0.0733171329,
-0.0337818451,
0.032659363,
-0.0136277014,
0.0614555664,
0.00684044,
0.0325543806,
-0.0029702524,
-0.0861916095,
-0.0168582406,
-0.0494173877,
-0.0564193539,
-0.0166403688,
-0.0142368833,
-0.0069625378,
-0.0138946306,
-0.0755884126,
0.0270061567,
0.0025653557,
0.0173143223,
0.0494428277,
0.0418399796,
-0.0044411863,
0.0718207806,
0.0373607948,
-0.0043756841,
-0.0750957727,
0.0125146648,
0.00507775,
0.1011995003,
0.0427323021,
0.0651732534,
0.0737506226,
-0.0035243048,
-0.01684184,
0.0417522565,
-0.0877516568,
0.0244626496,
0.0152044808,
0.0318906568,
0.0040453132,
-0.0041353363,
-0.0318504125,
-0.019809179,
-0.0200648475,
-0.0417071134,
0.0300985668,
-0.0196957644,
-0.0419642814,
-0.045607999,
0.0294288229,
-0.0140242018,
-0.0120324325,
-0.0070290947,
-0.044391945,
0.0597342141,
-0.0005738945,
-0.0036363769,
-0.03356383,
-0.0122417593,
0.0629345402,
0.0587261319,
0.0130497292,
0.0169759542,
0.0145387808,
-0.0074902074,
-0.0484700464,
-0.0166225955,
-0.0440374166,
-0.012460215,
-0.0214205775,
-0.017229842,
0.0107655618,
-0.013716436,
-0.0728429556,
-0.0028266048,
0.018435983,
0.0014979345,
-0.0400624648,
-0.0296114031,
-0.0184598435,
0.0058158138,
-0.009680382,
0.0145764416,
-0.0479546003,
-0.0431191623,
0.0681969523,
-0.0792655349,
-0.0245651901,
0.0258342456,
2.804e-7,
0.0300263558,
0.0321063362,
-0.0069986959,
0.0123901498,
0.0193090402,
0.0514587313,
-0.0299765244,
0.0231175404,
0.0164056402,
-0.0372356325,
0.0092131412,
0.0486221798,
0.0013774801,
0.0092842951,
-0.0472716428,
0.0272744801,
-0.0208269544,
-0.0074378452,
-0.031583149,
-0.0276324693,
0.0801999718,
0.0490602925,
0.0102105113,
-0.0134954862,
0.0262854397,
0.0101763308,
0.0922423005,
-0.035550192,
0.0096993996,
-0.0212530624,
-0.02347368,
0.001049325,
-0.0036197545,
-0.0234232806,
-0.0181584973,
-0.0196041632,
0.078948155,
0.0045899581,
-0.0440718681,
-0.0175085925,
-0.0294845179,
0.0077244872,
0.0037612822,
-0.025975896,
0.0731934011,
-0.0551443473,
-0.0402439907,
-0.0353785269,
-0.0615893044,
0.0303782709,
0.0246627741,
-0.0162353162,
-0.0609414168,
0.0024796501,
0.0183667317,
0.0016176304,
-0.0417409129,
-0.0684035644,
-0.0417329147,
0.009470257,
-0.0251279194,
0.0165953785,
-0.0498108193,
0.0276297498,
-0.0036910004,
-0.0018786554,
-0.0410957523,
2.349380662e-34,
-0.0050270827,
0.0094653973,
0.0196827538,
0.0121009657,
0.0407510623,
0.0051740431,
0.0132253459,
0.0181992613,
-0.0135391271,
-0.0502831414,
0.0004103502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13806v1 | AdaTyper: Adaptive Semantic Column Type Detection | 2023-11-23T04:42:27 | 2023-11-23T04:42:27 | Madelon Hulsebos, Paul Groth, Çağatay Demiralp | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.LG | Understanding the semantics of relational tables is instrumental for
automation in data exploration and preparation systems. A key source for
understanding a table is the semantics of its columns. With the rise of deep
learning, learned table representations are now available, which can be applied
for semantic type detection and achieve good performance on benchmarks.
Nevertheless, we observe a gap between this performance and its applicability
in practice. In this paper, we propose AdaTyper to address one of the most
critical deployment challenges: adaptation. AdaTyper uses weak-supervision to
adapt a hybrid type predictor towards new semantic types and shifted data
distributions at inference time, using minimal human feedback. The hybrid type
predictor of AdaTyper combines rule-based methods and a light machine learning
model for semantic column type detection. We evaluate the adaptation
performance of AdaTyper on real-world database tables hand-annotated with
semantic column types through crowdsourcing and find that the f1-score improves
for new and existing types. AdaTyper approaches an average precision of 0.6
after only seeing 5 examples, significantly outperforming existing adaptation
methods based on human-provided regular expressions or dictionaries. | [
-0.0024713695,
0.0775704682,
0.0014515574,
0.0296958834,
0.0339447334,
0.0238186773,
-0.0285412651,
0.0462300591,
-0.0045240107,
-0.0264550354,
0.0088526122,
-0.0090873418,
-0.0716150999,
0.0583444685,
0.0271479804,
-0.0134636257,
0.0529664643,
0.0068813758,
-0.0583623387,
0.0561147667,
-0.0037420949,
-0.0108221984,
0.0184574928,
0.0152499285,
-0.0261323117,
0.0203204062,
-0.0562904254,
0.0044294605,
-0.0530309789,
-0.015047268,
0.0306725968,
0.0642205849,
0.0430491082,
0.0455047786,
0.0000020627,
-0.0229136702,
-0.0443201959,
-0.0114380857,
-0.0196916889,
-0.0042224894,
0.0105414353,
-0.0806029141,
0.007842062,
-0.0055246367,
-0.0107137356,
-0.0584963858,
0.0245867483,
0.0243533924,
0.0007054026,
0.0176988002,
-0.0090062739,
-0.0105136689,
0.0225987807,
0.0057104141,
0.0775980577,
-0.0404127724,
0.0178420711,
-0.0484280884,
-0.0399099067,
-0.0357949324,
0.0066542667,
0.0061389445,
-0.0074404567,
-0.0162212551,
0.0152850654,
0.0073611951,
-0.0455208458,
0.0423470624,
-0.0124654584,
0.0416834652,
-0.0127430875,
-0.0161091667,
0.027166333,
-0.0061988244,
0.0168606341,
-0.0273485221,
0.0002609099,
-0.0539792143,
-0.0161891803,
-0.0358439237,
-0.0066077509,
-0.0174786691,
-0.0040856726,
-0.0078567071,
-0.0612324215,
0.0507297404,
-0.0348985381,
-0.037957035,
0.0398031175,
-0.0272541903,
0.0195867456,
-0.0172554068,
-0.0156608932,
0.0427676104,
-0.0526612028,
-0.0110678626,
-0.0045388606,
-0.0374446549,
0.0159924682,
-0.0579784624,
0.0351387188,
0.0365654081,
-0.0466668941,
0.019805681,
-0.040469069,
-0.0001233963,
-0.0336151905,
0.0377753638,
0.0315558985,
-0.0218274165,
-0.0368978009,
0.0177965071,
-0.0257930178,
0.0033606917,
-0.0205356125,
0.0056739305,
-0.0132038444,
0.035242863,
-0.0219428372,
0.0385893285,
0.0017653063,
0.0269920677,
-0.0132981613,
0.026081996,
-0.0536294766,
0.002322962,
-0.0121284006,
-0.0058177337,
-0.018704012,
-0.0589550585,
0.0080761872,
-0.0027581456,
0.0598466732,
-0.0141731054,
0.0521079898,
0.1055334136,
-0.0337544084,
0.0038884215,
-0.120364815,
-0.0548197925,
-0.0008769773,
0.0193239469,
-0.000467342,
-0.0303035304,
-0.0065633766,
-0.023500625,
-0.0311920922,
-0.0583960675,
-0.0303701498,
0.0037293765,
-0.0066548223,
0.0760781839,
-0.0474823676,
-0.0053303172,
0.0159392469,
-0.0452851765,
-0.0752270296,
0.0548209772,
0.0173502825,
0.043238245,
0.002951446,
-0.0211941041,
0.030919781,
0.0297987722,
0.0124064935,
-0.0171237905,
-0.0294160824,
0.0340429768,
-0.0128801428,
0.0352528058,
0.0086204438,
0.0253760312,
0.0363559797,
-0.033200819,
-0.0035656958,
-0.0090259612,
0.0319535919,
0.0614552535,
0.0327860601,
-0.0033639083,
-0.0075872573,
-0.0122919772,
-0.019751586,
0.0100623909,
-0.0073186378,
-0.0095505137,
-0.030305475,
0.0085945064,
-0.0257992186,
-0.0458569601,
-0.0077098156,
0.0034977256,
-0.0056863921,
-0.0249261037,
0.0380288959,
0.0291059185,
-0.0272135381,
0.0103176627,
0.0187583212,
-0.0085126804,
-0.0280609429,
-0.0335531235,
0.0664818138,
0.0769692883,
0.0084154988,
-0.1060520485,
-0.0214457326,
-0.0273527205,
0.0272733793,
-0.008367978,
0.0389164351,
-0.0670815855,
-0.0078067807,
-0.0007552816,
-0.0181226134,
0.0698817149,
0.0405488238,
-0.0010481831,
-0.0059394389,
0.0042023407,
0.0171030108,
-0.0712671652,
-0.0423162021,
0.0434997194,
0.0690715089,
-0.035593573,
0.0322008766,
0.0275247898,
0.0162990913,
0.0363365337,
0.0117173251,
-0.0114157684,
0.041109439,
0.002709507,
-0.0170950033,
-0.0162663218,
-0.0137562258,
0.0544338711,
0.0170690268,
0.0224671066,
-0.0608864762,
-0.0305985734,
-0.0465296917,
-0.0104694767,
0.0314330608,
0.0044479365,
-0.0245901048,
-0.0083316788,
0.0084085008,
-0.0150714628,
0.0295313336,
-0.0038575081,
0.0523434021,
0.0020267994,
-0.0183439981,
0.0000505931,
-0.0931254998,
0.0523030832,
-0.012749156,
0.0165768303,
-0.0232101139,
-0.0309587661,
0.0492227376,
0.0114514604,
0.0217808802,
-0.0632622987,
0.0134230843,
-0.0525867045,
0.0283030253,
-0.0205291901,
0.0409721807,
0.0061817919,
0.0195327364,
0.0030852312,
-0.031699948,
-0.0519281961,
0.0250876471,
-0.0470278971,
0.0096178027,
0.0636288896,
0.0161208194,
0.0115136281,
-0.0279239584,
-0.0291302726,
-0.0788535178,
0.0103588542,
-0.018055154,
-0.0193555728,
0.0161202401,
-0.0415960588,
0.0312178042,
0.053882502,
0.0061223647,
0.030481115,
-0.0149713168,
-0.0387929231,
-0.0060322159,
0.06185776,
-0.0061088088,
0.0399177037,
0.0057219178,
0.0406864882,
-0.0183889903,
0.0193820987,
0.025095934,
0.0112042092,
-0.0024315708,
-0.0074110371,
0.03484549,
0.002397801,
-0.0453432389,
0.008899861,
-0.03990018,
-0.0123167364,
0.0426603816,
-0.00367855,
-0.0613401607,
0.0739902705,
-0.0043227249,
0.0054380442,
-0.0024702598,
0.0460712984,
0.0326486528,
0.0147806359,
0.0305047333,
0.0033421067,
-0.0428431928,
-0.0532886051,
0.0457653366,
0.0057664551,
-0.0094845202,
-0.0321983993,
-0.0395262502,
-0.0684149787,
-0.0029957336,
-0.0056076748,
-0.0228073653,
0.1052069291,
-0.0388442278,
-0.0095906509,
-0.0023718232,
-0.041712109,
-0.0325246602,
-0.0467065014,
-0.0391632393,
0.0231359657,
0.0376080722,
-0.0356791206,
-0.031815093,
-0.0127936462,
-0.0126181189,
0.0962266997,
0.0447802842,
-0.0436367728,
-0.0399787202,
0.0145926643,
0.0252149533,
0.0225191694,
-0.0574008375,
-0.0041246633,
0.0182000436,
0.0322853699,
-0.0272783879,
-0.0475777611,
-0.0607078038,
0.036169339,
-0.0160572212,
-0.012409186,
-0.0010875516,
0.0526032113,
-0.0724496245,
-0.0786197931,
0.0147028072,
0.0345024578,
0.0076299198,
-0.0228130613,
-0.0016046964,
0.0071508191,
0.0424481258,
0.0393627509,
0.0294142999,
-0.1445374042,
-0.0553818047,
0.0006563416,
0.0209752414,
0.0158884097,
-0.0654663146,
0.0244386345,
-0.0450599082,
0.0153741604,
-0.06596075,
-0.1010322273,
-0.0233294778,
-0.0490412079,
0.0126863141,
-0.076961562,
0.0234685428,
0.0260055084,
-0.0173697378,
0.0140564535,
0.0498542823,
-0.0314676315,
-0.0339471437,
-0.0114715146,
-0.0841555744,
0.019846769,
0.0474984162,
0.0078231459,
-0.0307295546,
-0.0314082354,
0.0031410863,
0.0390250571,
-0.0069803251,
-0.0244891886,
0.1076395512,
-0.0181260519,
0.0198079795,
0.0520046279,
0.0166543275,
-0.0362001061,
0.0428736247,
0.0378310047,
0.1131027341,
-0.0118699064,
-0.0280712377,
-0.0257545449,
-0.1001668051,
-0.0103850979,
0.0479639284,
0.0226971395,
-0.014041381,
-0.0331641547,
-0.0315707512,
-0.0485118628,
-0.0476078279,
-0.0058451858,
0.0271842983,
-0.046725858,
-0.0522863418,
-0.0192723963,
-0.0021391334,
0.0556873605,
0.0090598529,
-0.0081549138,
0.0093802288,
-0.0334667228,
0.0147222979,
-0.1258553863,
-0.0115288794,
-0.0094678234,
0.008559349,
-0.024492979,
-0.0339009091,
0.0009675678,
-0.0040600952,
-0.0291026738,
0.0179951061,
-0.0124997133,
-0.0014065856,
0.0230370779,
-0.0041598203,
0.0111877369,
-0.0052912063,
0.0253167748,
-0.0290335231,
-0.0194004513,
0.0755309984,
-0.0300535038,
-0.063208364,
-0.0016897577,
-0.0402677283,
-0.0192867927,
0.0101461215,
-0.0497529432,
-0.0156174833,
-0.0365856662,
-0.0514722802,
0.0122190714,
0.0115522807,
0.0586064346,
0.0310124196,
0.006543193,
0.0423320159,
-0.073303096,
-0.0068237297,
0.0280050114,
0.0193193164,
-0.0388897732,
0.0012121593,
0.0170387533,
-0.0297374539,
0.0153121734,
-0.0172191039,
0.0354189985,
0.0593002364,
0.0352117606,
-0.0638819337,
0.0012464895,
0.0512043014,
0.0364386663,
0.0175196435,
-0.0143317478,
0.0049098893,
0.0034809732,
0.0537387431,
0.0620959178,
0.0039970432,
-0.0330001339,
0.0407876708,
0.0054081189,
-0.0635334551,
0.0194125734,
-0.0273004323,
-0.0164608043,
-0.0209334735,
0.0467821546,
0.0017343246,
-0.0115948031,
-0.0391753949,
-0.0195417758,
-0.0302316528,
0.0204250626,
-0.0150396274,
0.017150851,
0.0216745529,
0.0420160666,
0.0146538801,
-0.019868711,
-0.0175813846,
0.0604886264,
0.0195844807,
0.055468794,
-0.0303257108,
-0.0301987901,
-0.0580501929,
0.0614252053,
0.0637875274,
0.0119359046,
0.002377036,
-0.0241969619,
-0.0333042778,
-0.0223843735,
0.0433068424,
0.0321629383,
-0.0111256875,
0.0029948063,
0.0252391156,
0.0523425266,
0.0702753663,
-0.0339082144,
0.0016055992,
-0.0146611761,
0.0122655025,
-0.0366440192,
-0.0207727123,
-6.236817438e-33,
-0.009782996,
-0.0155435978,
0.0086928261,
-0.0170834735,
0.0288152453,
-0.0116925677,
-0.0163302124,
-0.0117952768,
0.0121991197,
0.0162611231,
-0.0366538428,
0.0405314751,
0.0161917396,
-0.0116303163,
0.0692530423,
-0.0637094155,
0.0592486449,
-0.023537863,
0.0216712467,
-0.0040911334,
0.0222162884,
0.0315098651,
-0.0035963785,
-0.0839039385,
0.0254517887,
0.0306026433,
-0.0111486474,
-0.0049676532,
0.0164662171,
0.0386189297,
-0.0182247907,
0.0474005342,
0.0362572484,
-0.0255684461,
-0.009925657,
0.0102169104,
-0.124070555,
-0.0070243585,
-0.0481521562,
0.0328744277,
-0.0172800627,
-0.0254085213,
0.0529878885,
0.0113008944,
-0.0172685031,
0.0095084263,
0.0468113348,
-0.0283563863,
0.0263089482,
-0.0276344065,
-0.0194599405,
0.0279265344,
-0.0080048433,
0.0462826416,
0.0626955032,
-0.0005124185,
0.0427222997,
-0.0158981252,
-0.0394806378,
0.0190875605,
0.0217697229,
0.0148569485,
0.0193750616,
0.0354757681,
-0.014055077,
-0.0255283043,
0.0254286919,
0.0226405896,
-0.0047312067,
0.001165058,
-0.0044359686,
0.0590815134,
0.0221118499,
0.0469256863,
0.0689313784,
-0.0126500139,
-0.0490591228,
0.0695407167,
0.0422960222,
-0.0245505869,
-0.0467916913,
0.028981965,
-0.0491776988,
-0.011025344,
-0.0210436247,
0.0373931788,
-0.0369145796,
-0.0178172402,
0.0260097366,
-0.0107436413,
0.0327307545,
0.0202229116,
-0.0072586429,
-0.0159594342,
-0.0189616978,
0.0196064115,
-0.0313309543,
-0.0023876808,
0.0197436903,
-0.0142582748,
-0.0088209203,
-0.0558989458,
0.0183472261,
0.006410074,
0.0581119396,
0.0522645079,
0.058878094,
0.0307974983,
-0.0571611486,
0.0032932966,
0.0114328749,
0.0044869459,
0.0036357439,
0.0143667283,
-0.0240446292,
0.0026565457,
0.0205620751,
0.0331008472,
0.050783813,
0.0074376189,
0.002767917,
0.0055329385,
0.0008369897,
0.0121560702,
0.012834521,
-0.023475673,
-0.0211139955,
-0.0504612476,
0.0091826133,
-0.0564809777,
0.0299095046,
0.0044679097,
2.71e-7,
0.047597371,
0.0272197239,
0.0248220116,
-0.0232938286,
-0.004113263,
0.0217523053,
0.0137701342,
0.0285847746,
-0.0555667691,
-0.0418829508,
0.0725494996,
-0.0409517698,
0.0250859577,
0.0175685212,
-0.0460131168,
-0.0448412597,
-0.0304675363,
0.0212050695,
-0.0658470616,
0.0188811701,
0.0262088738,
0.0995655879,
-0.0562849082,
-0.0114698559,
0.0505799577,
-0.0101824384,
-0.0195705853,
-0.0102252858,
0.0770789087,
0.0161652789,
0.0818572491,
0.0062783356,
-0.0104484931,
0.0640049949,
-0.0126652177,
0.0073157744,
-0.0236697476,
0.0204467494,
-0.0359498113,
0.0494392887,
0.0018981289,
-0.0709018633,
0.0370319076,
-0.0226541609,
0.0637393519,
-0.0105766756,
0.0080275731,
0.0662462488,
-0.0118290232,
0.0168607086,
-0.0191830285,
0.0077692303,
0.007415819,
-0.0057861004,
0.0381837115,
0.0036163097,
-0.0196902901,
-0.0582470633,
0.0187263265,
0.0393354893,
-0.0169038363,
0.0195606127,
-0.0104113724,
0.0005006079,
0.0033793387,
-0.052173432,
0.0063025756,
2.479454852e-34,
0.0439771451,
0.0561316945,
0.0180876013,
0.0168599598,
0.0484972671,
-0.0151930423,
0.0214291885,
0.0023981025,
0.0157633591,
-0.0282798894,
-0.0166825056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13784v1 | DaG LLM ver 1.0: Pioneering Instruction-Tuned Language Modeling for Korean NLP | 2023-11-23T03:03:54 | 2023-11-23T03:03:54 | Dongjun Jang, Sangah Lee, Sungjoo Byun, Jinwoong Kim, Jean Seo, Minseok Kim, Soyeon Kim, Chaeyoung Oh, Jaeyoon Kim, Hyemi Jo, Hyopil Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the DaG LLM (David and Goliath Large Language Model), a
language model specialized for Korean and fine-tuned through Instruction Tuning
across 41 tasks within 13 distinct categories. | [
0.0756598413,
-0.0080485241,
-0.0273092724,
0.0222839322,
-0.016556913,
0.0293239355,
-0.0027208272,
0.0008729544,
0.0158871189,
-0.0346916765,
-0.0520694442,
-0.0019090433,
-0.0221821871,
-0.0130342664,
0.0054981709,
-0.0856871456,
0.0496778712,
-0.0413934141,
0.0092840521,
-0.0023439974,
0.0039861742,
0.0066268891,
0.0113830557,
0.0318397097,
0.0242282487,
-0.0409307033,
-0.0222496409,
0.0445329174,
-0.0427759029,
-0.0695142224,
0.0031499574,
0.0712594986,
-0.0320501514,
-0.0189322755,
0.0000020707,
-0.0227390602,
0.0054606181,
-0.0219632182,
-0.0263157915,
0.022776546,
0.0737302601,
-0.0070493789,
-0.0132486625,
-0.000999511,
-0.0110173738,
-0.0666886717,
0.0275685526,
0.0465903766,
0.0785323903,
0.0941725224,
0.0074252184,
-0.0566543899,
0.0212214682,
-0.0136611471,
-0.0352482125,
-0.0380789712,
0.0198542755,
0.0234049298,
0.0353160799,
0.0328424349,
-0.023239594,
-0.0009971168,
-0.010454799,
-0.0085748248,
0.0263510216,
-0.0210889094,
-0.016458476,
0.0022148916,
0.0051162806,
0.0317974165,
-0.008212246,
-0.0102723502,
-0.0051171798,
0.0169043262,
-0.0065515894,
-0.0314410999,
-0.0399648175,
0.0167853013,
0.0056948881,
-0.0098975692,
0.0800015554,
-0.037301559,
0.0262558255,
0.014068556,
0.017749263,
0.0677522793,
0.031055823,
-0.0384021699,
-0.0249787085,
-0.0153556354,
-0.0405013375,
-0.0590478182,
0.041269768,
0.0482591018,
-0.0440637432,
0.0214732066,
-0.0276279692,
0.0081481775,
0.0384545624,
-0.0655618608,
0.1158980876,
0.0350840464,
-0.0121849654,
0.0047671893,
-0.0020884227,
0.0398350097,
0.0207644477,
0.0246103276,
-0.0706199706,
0.0393476337,
-0.0419852585,
0.0015418042,
-0.0949092284,
0.0186148509,
-0.064405404,
-0.0071507641,
-0.0560328141,
0.0248295609,
-0.015683461,
0.0050368621,
0.0696576759,
-0.026450064,
-0.0719224438,
-0.0046070344,
-0.0215589814,
-0.0020953459,
-0.0436483547,
0.0180641152,
0.0098593682,
-0.0196792576,
0.0339352712,
0.0120430961,
0.0135636469,
-0.0210364237,
0.0054678572,
0.037611112,
0.0433599055,
0.0062084547,
-0.0541110523,
-0.0023264554,
-0.0366677605,
-0.0545003787,
-0.0285097584,
-0.0850963145,
0.0068520778,
0.0100831892,
0.0139759155,
-0.0064374106,
-0.002565095,
0.026857309,
-0.0068632388,
0.0349688865,
0.0251079872,
0.0112827327,
0.0047886348,
-0.0079322141,
0.0405617654,
0.0507070236,
0.000511959,
-0.0189152453,
0.0441368483,
-0.0209996905,
-0.0289959852,
0.0450956412,
-0.0197345465,
0.0212122444,
-0.0266912207,
0.0126353418,
0.0067202798,
-0.0026291113,
-0.0266521592,
0.0520289056,
0.0056545301,
0.0130267162,
0.029477993,
0.0296903066,
0.0215207394,
0.0193213355,
0.053967353,
0.0236190688,
0.0207208805,
0.0034276051,
-0.0054509593,
-0.0212128907,
-0.0426921919,
0.0365397222,
-0.0295898225,
0.0565182418,
-0.0291468929,
-0.0391174518,
-0.0476635657,
-0.0108023537,
-0.0049722614,
0.0002486978,
0.0492759347,
0.0465428717,
-0.0384439193,
0.0238793157,
0.0462030284,
0.0071805585,
0.0069106841,
-0.0102885896,
-0.0519052781,
0.0708243474,
0.0339534543,
0.0219277795,
-0.035442248,
-0.0249689706,
0.0274656843,
0.0587929524,
0.0610524751,
-0.0221553035,
-0.0324535891,
-0.0279532,
0.005431639,
0.0151520902,
0.0644851401,
0.0177695677,
0.0201548804,
-0.0202833898,
0.0063066329,
0.0265515372,
-0.0840684101,
0.0231677853,
-0.030137023,
-0.0261289217,
-0.0184682775,
-0.0039871186,
0.050398387,
0.0506038517,
0.01762826,
0.0189547706,
0.0331800468,
-0.0440107025,
0.0120756058,
-0.0011151343,
-0.029678965,
-0.0674111173,
0.0345946476,
-0.0080432724,
0.0202202555,
0.0003716851,
-0.0055010435,
-0.0367008299,
0.0254933592,
-0.0106384335,
0.0590244643,
-0.0216404051,
0.0856853202,
-0.0303588416,
-0.0064220619,
-0.0677497834,
0.0485563017,
-0.0187815446,
0.0357884616,
0.0483610556,
0.0238409806,
-0.0075271213,
-0.0441621691,
-0.0379599631,
0.0331107825,
-0.0051940144,
0.0313059911,
-0.0043858169,
0.0184163265,
-0.0420745537,
-0.06921947,
-0.0596204624,
0.0381066315,
-0.0110205291,
0.0290831178,
0.0275121778,
-0.0101144565,
-0.0385840833,
0.0238953717,
0.0120715266,
-0.0107323881,
0.0413846001,
0.0133980298,
0.0062739924,
-0.0089879623,
-0.0109738661,
-0.0322010443,
-0.0489936322,
0.0051798965,
0.0007539655,
-0.0126441587,
0.0035775625,
-0.0752524137,
0.0760314465,
0.0063223308,
-0.0184954777,
0.0123163462,
-0.0434291959,
-0.0158482846,
-0.0323342793,
0.0471857749,
0.0553794205,
-0.0360078737,
0.0356074795,
0.0180917215,
-0.051225841,
-0.0361847281,
-0.0010809122,
-0.0225480031,
-0.0438328683,
-0.0497904606,
-0.032588765,
-0.0093509648,
0.0978097543,
0.0197712686,
-0.0123989675,
-0.0254324246,
-0.035650257,
-0.1001376063,
0.010369896,
0.0565207675,
-0.0085785929,
-0.0385987535,
0.0056179073,
-0.0384985283,
-0.0133475624,
0.0612625033,
-0.0102148037,
0.0037113973,
-0.0935075209,
-0.0000660486,
-0.0550403967,
0.0101264836,
-0.0025826611,
0.0229599141,
-0.0137903048,
-0.0375651307,
-0.0131978765,
0.0009358648,
-0.0005223864,
-0.041530665,
0.0571542569,
-0.0127386209,
-0.0211736038,
-0.0063996487,
-0.0072214543,
-0.0245438814,
0.0116224373,
-0.0200119913,
0.0317524336,
0.0287182573,
0.0095082028,
-0.0665816888,
0.0226633772,
0.0031476347,
-0.0152097708,
-0.0180403069,
-0.0006697272,
-0.0332892649,
-0.0011798267,
0.0635879636,
-0.0355246551,
-0.0498970225,
-0.0358895175,
0.0510682575,
0.0046811542,
0.0318589322,
0.0124763427,
-0.0085749533,
0.0308110379,
0.0634995177,
-0.054188706,
-0.04442681,
0.019335987,
0.0532809012,
-0.0765672624,
0.0119142933,
0.1300026774,
0.0221919455,
-0.0416077822,
0.0259695016,
0.0016245554,
0.0278820153,
0.0344933756,
0.0522551052,
-0.0544341169,
-0.0098673794,
0.0252382867,
-0.0120618539,
-0.000507495,
0.0021430524,
0.0017676967,
-0.1195889488,
0.0160643551,
0.0216960423,
0.0200764928,
-0.0243296996,
-0.047610037,
-0.0193139929,
0.0096248174,
0.0328745134,
0.0106855342,
-0.0483292267,
0.0183729548,
0.0564868376,
-0.0288168509,
-0.043183241,
0.0275279917,
-0.0405068249,
0.0619650632,
0.022120731,
0.0282207746,
0.0047996752,
-0.0075107599,
0.0256119128,
-0.0444579422,
0.0222075451,
-0.0313117504,
0.0080874395,
-0.0112043731,
-0.0095471581,
-0.0312510394,
-0.0071487972,
-0.0384667031,
0.0326514319,
0.0167845897,
0.0593303218,
0.0211545117,
-0.0083884438,
0.0245505087,
-0.0158098191,
-0.0160483327,
0.0372195281,
0.0091914237,
-0.0491754748,
-0.0262155011,
-0.0648748428,
0.0082219904,
-0.0642795414,
-0.0132202096,
0.0417173393,
-0.0608361214,
0.0113056926,
-0.0451220162,
-0.0357926786,
-0.0055797915,
0.0417523012,
0.0343459956,
0.0176513121,
-0.0128098559,
-0.0083329668,
-0.0192744639,
0.0104071395,
-0.017136842,
0.0303016324,
-0.0920782611,
-0.0498394929,
0.0318707712,
0.0056086956,
0.0066812499,
-0.0209369417,
-0.0500136241,
-0.066407755,
0.0276264697,
0.036485441,
0.0225133598,
0.0165727753,
-0.0237062629,
-0.0154099651,
-0.0661246777,
-0.0282149184,
-0.0564862229,
0.0190595314,
0.0258551147,
-0.0139195379,
0.0064257551,
0.0383142605,
-0.0185142402,
0.0480393581,
0.0185409412,
0.0962842628,
-0.0185842905,
-0.0568581857,
0.0191564448,
0.0542585701,
-0.0245563313,
0.0001962911,
-0.0182971917,
-0.0440873653,
-0.0092114452,
-0.0271034949,
0.0009266714,
-0.0195692182,
-0.008996373,
0.0378324389,
-0.0117482562,
-0.0195329953,
0.0224299133,
-0.0319544934,
0.004067116,
-0.0128786843,
0.062408641,
0.0105379065,
0.0306196213,
0.0116550662,
0.0268156826,
-0.029692024,
-0.003979316,
0.0048303464,
0.0254140235,
-0.0034680523,
0.056293644,
-0.005651175,
0.0015579048,
-0.0406936854,
0.004164665,
0.0192328822,
-0.0207881946,
-0.0116290739,
-0.0032656374,
0.070424974,
-0.0303681884,
0.0569586307,
-0.0212180521,
-0.0206491835,
-0.0454814248,
0.0384121835,
0.0271648187,
-0.0661116391,
0.0150536466,
0.0184695944,
-0.001763165,
-0.0039978707,
0.0620945022,
0.0279473364,
0.0629523247,
0.0065814368,
-0.0204781629,
-0.0139148226,
-0.0165379904,
0.0130044892,
0.0432704724,
-0.0348116346,
0.012268641,
-0.0580713861,
-0.0769106299,
-0.0581966341,
0.0073136701,
0.0364582352,
-0.0218689404,
-0.0156416725,
0.0386154279,
0.0187785588,
-0.0654231533,
-0.0714228153,
-0.0013522502,
-0.0092515657,
0.0182299521,
0.0251956694,
-6.622792478e-33,
-0.0346339829,
0.0028126941,
0.021115521,
0.0189802311,
-0.0321294628,
0.0008827707,
-0.0228475705,
0.0222131684,
-0.0442948192,
-0.0049235891,
-0.0388340168,
-0.0258764774,
0.0167684313,
0.0307604801,
0.0443075597,
0.0224173032,
0.0412771665,
0.0011431538,
0.0177981239,
0.0189934168,
0.0034775634,
0.0350607932,
0.0414917134,
0.0037247653,
0.0491897613,
-0.0055186544,
0.0205907915,
-0.0011831331,
0.0400280654,
0.0891788453,
-0.0326443501,
0.0445152149,
0.0306603312,
-0.0309426282,
-0.0399093628,
-0.0486843549,
-0.0775194168,
-0.0196137708,
0.0267973151,
0.0531366989,
-0.0129410895,
-0.0531705692,
-0.0081599848,
-0.0251010619,
-0.0433683321,
-0.0078811478,
0.011772559,
-0.0370295309,
-0.0296076108,
0.038676139,
-0.0683343858,
0.0457134061,
0.0272323173,
0.0116559509,
0.0373349003,
-0.0399831906,
-0.0520749018,
-0.0185478423,
-0.0081429901,
0.0143435393,
0.0254572574,
0.0671470985,
0.0534581617,
0.0306064691,
-0.0098196734,
0.0111011621,
0.0252373032,
0.0406796671,
0.0215795226,
0.0055804038,
0.0160761196,
0.0793325678,
-0.0195267014,
-0.012373751,
0.0314577706,
-0.0254836082,
-0.0469427817,
-0.0143623594,
0.0506952554,
0.0701953024,
0.0276202206,
0.0126594445,
-0.0411268026,
-0.0522354729,
-0.027248444,
-0.0094218533,
-0.0202042963,
-0.0527333878,
0.0342159234,
0.0207531415,
-0.0423577279,
0.0030028292,
0.0113351718,
-0.0415926389,
-0.009869732,
0.0005312566,
0.0117830019,
0.038670186,
-0.0354748368,
0.019543143,
-0.0886186212,
-0.045906119,
-0.0376087129,
-0.0274061952,
-0.014014666,
0.0109201064,
0.0108901532,
-0.0025466743,
-0.0465772152,
0.0131164668,
-0.0270989947,
-0.019526884,
0.0190253668,
0.0135389734,
0.0132370684,
-0.0007784032,
-0.0006750822,
0.0725207552,
0.0360261686,
-0.0017014332,
-0.0314583257,
0.0215733815,
0.0072776331,
0.0244365111,
0.0062070428,
0.039551612,
-0.0352060497,
0.0118824523,
0.0049041016,
-0.0276172198,
-0.0058253524,
-0.0106403772,
2.668e-7,
0.0301054791,
0.0808479637,
0.0252032392,
0.0226647649,
0.0054478464,
-0.006402161,
-0.0371917002,
-0.0167509746,
0.0429851413,
0.0380085073,
-0.0083362795,
0.0291303284,
0.0444079675,
-0.0007740681,
-0.0963401347,
0.0423328988,
-0.0164970364,
0.0465118214,
-0.0770029724,
-0.0196009986,
-0.0126774795,
0.0748972222,
-0.0099660885,
0.0168136917,
-0.0504612885,
-0.0481969379,
0.0347823724,
-0.0042782449,
-0.0087006046,
0.0534143448,
0.0605995357,
-0.0028473928,
0.0191856977,
-0.013926276,
-0.0341363326,
0.0076979143,
0.0188250728,
0.1325798482,
-0.0019824516,
0.0350244865,
0.0574334636,
-0.0293520745,
-0.0531884208,
-0.0552828498,
0.0505203642,
-0.0097790323,
-0.0258273911,
-0.0037388955,
-0.0418204144,
-0.0016723911,
-0.0407199673,
-0.0133598242,
-0.0254014693,
0.0353557095,
0.0276825633,
-0.0080868257,
-0.0386579297,
-0.01312536,
-0.035576012,
0.0365232043,
-0.0071498593,
-0.0364130102,
0.0042292285,
0.0313258581,
-0.0033668708,
-0.0350695997,
0.0238314401,
2.678023628e-34,
0.0401236154,
0.0078222295,
0.0083273062,
0.0219944566,
0.0147952633,
-0.0110315783,
-0.0492806621,
0.0636304468,
0.0286895279,
-0.1097903624,
-0.0312042385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13755v1 | Transformer-based Named Entity Recognition in Construction Supply Chain Risk Management in Australia | 2023-11-23T01:06:08 | 2023-11-23T01:06:08 | Milad Baghalzadeh Shishehgarkhaneh, Robert C. Moehler, Yihai Fang, Amer A. Hijazi, Hamed Aboutorab | cs.CL | cs.CL | The construction industry in Australia is characterized by its intricate
supply chains and vulnerability to myriad risks. As such, effective supply
chain risk management (SCRM) becomes imperative. This paper employs different
transformer models, and train for Named Entity Recognition (NER) in the context
of Australian construction SCRM. Utilizing NER, transformer models identify and
classify specific risk-associated entities in news articles, offering a
detailed insight into supply chain vulnerabilities. By analysing news articles
through different transformer models, we can extract relevant entities and
insights related to specific risk taxonomies local (milieu) to the Australian
construction landscape. This research emphasises the potential of NLP-driven
solutions, like transformer models, in revolutionising SCRM for construction in
geo-media specific contexts. | [
0.0075746491,
0.0903051868,
-0.0086489813,
-0.0003849267,
-0.0000833639,
0.0175502989,
0.0206489116,
-0.0122428257,
-0.030778667,
-0.0494396314,
0.0113461213,
-0.0029785654,
-0.0383255705,
0.0113468664,
0.0022718753,
-0.0237410646,
0.0139548723,
0.002701065,
-0.0153587814,
0.0503706671,
-0.0090365158,
0.0372467898,
-0.0140359132,
0.0301097296,
-0.009611873,
0.0382360406,
-0.035836976,
-0.0068994625,
0.0775334686,
-0.0496043339,
0.0092029041,
0.0469679013,
-0.0003515625,
0.002620629,
0.0000016718,
-0.0191268492,
-0.1047304496,
-0.0160532277,
-0.0207673851,
-0.05352569,
-0.0155600095,
-0.0949687511,
-0.0128559284,
0.0046147001,
-0.0267926194,
-0.0589508377,
0.0435886793,
0.107531108,
0.0543755926,
0.066075027,
-0.0205311012,
-0.0476080626,
0.0329486541,
-0.0302239321,
-0.0356727391,
-0.0664196983,
0.046653647,
-0.0494413637,
-0.0284032244,
0.058536943,
0.0101471227,
0.0152563313,
-0.0049938597,
0.0202011485,
-0.0139233861,
0.0358912796,
-0.0212227851,
0.0329402052,
-0.0326724797,
0.0340710841,
0.0009294837,
0.0019880151,
0.000661804,
-0.0138522116,
0.0023100565,
0.0345543511,
-0.0123980884,
0.0401337706,
-0.0372165516,
0.0166877229,
-0.0421306528,
0.0258544032,
-0.0196338464,
0.0034996229,
0.001856696,
0.040710859,
-0.025162315,
-0.0197051391,
-0.0252082963,
0.034318909,
0.021822894,
-0.0371592231,
0.045415476,
0.0263862126,
0.0371729061,
0.0500106774,
0.0234880522,
0.0034503127,
0.0127723115,
-0.0786715001,
-0.0565433316,
0.0075147958,
0.0253299214,
0.0450994782,
-0.0354269259,
0.0380524881,
0.0158864018,
0.0141397053,
-0.0084984507,
0.0175053515,
-0.0557385609,
-0.0204494633,
-0.0448567159,
0.0260088053,
-0.0418071039,
-0.0081728594,
-0.0068614418,
-0.0058957343,
-0.0348412059,
0.0077466816,
0.0377108008,
0.0178844612,
-0.0191225298,
-0.0138423499,
-0.0044874707,
0.0089962082,
-0.0126161976,
0.0363820083,
-0.0240532793,
-0.0007549835,
0.0251577459,
-0.0192935169,
0.0390717238,
-0.0275443029,
-0.0163134746,
0.0433716848,
0.0314704217,
-0.0705858544,
-0.1011327729,
-0.0079648485,
0.0155042075,
0.0237300098,
0.0070092659,
-0.0149544887,
-0.0264841653,
-0.0083046835,
-0.0062147514,
-0.0341310836,
0.0280064065,
-0.0033407868,
-0.0307385568,
0.0478127524,
-0.015789248,
-0.0110709928,
0.0405320451,
0.0161398575,
0.0855062157,
0.0396464542,
0.0383142307,
0.0666030943,
0.0305978246,
-0.0098123271,
0.0471776016,
0.0178664941,
-0.0576862916,
-0.0020696826,
0.0383059196,
-0.0188237689,
-0.0257609934,
-0.0206854194,
0.0490552038,
-0.0119740004,
0.0165232234,
-0.0167732667,
0.0538834035,
-0.017388111,
0.0096444227,
0.0025095097,
0.0287049878,
0.0482512303,
-0.0470716245,
-0.0254046004,
0.0019084284,
-0.0062327161,
-0.0108785834,
0.01803069,
-0.0553284511,
0.0333694369,
-0.0313067473,
0.0193927176,
0.0118478369,
-0.0044117314,
0.0078031751,
0.0169824455,
0.0257934369,
0.0402279124,
-0.0432986096,
0.0911395326,
-0.003803293,
0.002596068,
-0.0116402218,
-0.0069678226,
-0.0551035926,
0.0252568498,
0.0200507138,
-0.0062869354,
-0.0442212187,
-0.0478249416,
-0.0355123021,
0.0484550446,
-0.0301057529,
-0.0098264311,
-0.0019068707,
-0.002769046,
-0.0394704565,
0.0314660557,
0.0195029527,
0.0111178057,
0.0192944761,
0.0056992113,
0.015724726,
0.0037303241,
-0.0377423614,
0.0560490713,
0.0285953656,
-0.0806401148,
-0.0108625013,
0.0336347856,
-0.0272014607,
0.0312185008,
0.0173774064,
-0.0115247518,
0.0469368547,
0.0034128618,
-0.0762443617,
0.022210829,
0.0306517798,
0.040852692,
0.0046116337,
-0.0454998612,
0.0141565911,
-0.0073103355,
-0.0350534469,
-0.0208085291,
-0.0340139009,
0.0130734174,
0.015524854,
-0.0302469395,
0.0260911882,
0.0018971091,
-0.0051923352,
-0.0677715242,
0.0597371869,
-0.0227663126,
0.0162542146,
-0.055881273,
-0.0285630375,
-0.025272252,
-0.005994413,
-0.0194800124,
-0.0193489734,
-0.0162686408,
0.0288477335,
0.0257725939,
0.0078141578,
0.011149548,
-0.0270551443,
-0.0336744972,
-0.0247243382,
-0.0205073915,
0.0468765795,
0.0340832621,
-0.0138617298,
-0.0639217645,
-0.0047055986,
0.0323451571,
-0.0224960521,
-0.0324823074,
0.0133831669,
0.0216248035,
0.0055797873,
0.00697596,
0.0050685559,
-0.0081106061,
-0.0362079926,
0.0723785311,
0.0593985319,
-0.0215459112,
-0.0982222036,
0.0288077071,
0.0050737876,
-0.0386852585,
0.0024307105,
-0.026388539,
-0.0340019055,
0.0509669073,
0.0330905244,
0.0130234603,
0.0315231644,
0.0497023426,
-0.0070191254,
-0.039419882,
-0.0046441145,
-0.0001246567,
-0.0796100646,
-0.0055538029,
0.0071457112,
-0.0364916883,
0.0518551581,
0.0615842901,
-0.0271923449,
-0.0012399764,
0.0148290321,
0.0386294536,
0.0029829231,
-0.0234386586,
0.0058435788,
-0.0506534129,
-0.0026035141,
0.0789755061,
0.0368079022,
-0.0090749757,
0.0334812924,
-0.0203672498,
0.0431359485,
-0.062747471,
-0.0199079402,
-0.0548011027,
0.0293397754,
-0.0120518524,
0.0094423937,
0.0560932457,
-0.0903699398,
0.0104273437,
0.0299859587,
0.0243246965,
0.0221572779,
0.0088887447,
-0.0030747626,
0.010112213,
0.0059919883,
-0.0335549302,
-0.037603341,
-0.0064423699,
-0.0246071275,
0.047828529,
0.0596790873,
0.0023777555,
-0.0516697541,
0.0987690017,
0.0063685714,
-0.0217560213,
0.002353349,
-0.0291151609,
0.0001075767,
0.0759810358,
0.0206400584,
-0.0179306939,
0.0568161048,
0.0165373981,
-0.0492171645,
0.0129643362,
0.002929396,
-0.0017127955,
-0.0361663215,
0.0141571704,
-0.0053344751,
-0.0852135047,
0.0423031934,
-0.0415868796,
-0.0290274415,
-0.0429246686,
-0.0077439728,
0.0488764942,
0.0208621211,
0.0053067775,
0.0089528793,
0.0300944839,
-0.0134981489,
0.0029967399,
0.0236414187,
-0.0292599611,
0.0285011325,
0.0203403383,
-0.0107704336,
0.0043799723,
-0.0716961026,
0.0039390475,
-0.0860699117,
0.0395273343,
-0.064088732,
-0.0318661854,
-0.0073915333,
-0.0444212183,
0.0115461033,
-0.0502357036,
-0.0509111285,
-0.0100619448,
-0.048535388,
-0.0042160568,
0.0495674573,
-0.0416661352,
-0.0158850029,
-0.0216386486,
-0.0379829668,
-0.014153746,
0.0232764222,
-0.0110989679,
-0.0360450335,
0.0332782716,
-0.0152624538,
-0.0565524399,
-0.0006643165,
0.0226143878,
0.0558499508,
-0.0271154568,
-0.0160543211,
0.0089543872,
-0.013160022,
-0.0250079259,
-0.0184706636,
0.0485651083,
0.0401360691,
-0.0090485383,
-0.0062760096,
0.0003901389,
0.0295306463,
0.0472183004,
0.0027732991,
-0.0102230441,
-0.0060376544,
-0.0276543442,
-0.0272673648,
0.004428227,
0.0291377865,
-0.0465379655,
0.0657502711,
-0.0246031005,
-0.0738343224,
-0.0443673991,
-0.0716746971,
0.0257931463,
0.0476705618,
0.023836948,
-0.056184385,
0.0514974706,
-0.0032372563,
-0.0574580058,
0.012512587,
-0.0141675593,
0.0272607785,
-0.0186305419,
0.0787675828,
0.0597113632,
-0.0077490443,
-0.0514319018,
-0.0076405895,
-0.0898925662,
-0.0275428426,
-0.0014448867,
0.01780238,
0.0240701176,
-0.0316362493,
0.0018544107,
-0.0280877165,
0.0438618883,
0.0564654656,
-0.0638516098,
-0.0332542546,
0.0185351353,
-0.0064819646,
-0.018769294,
-0.0002875132,
0.0232480392,
0.0519445315,
-0.0005171507,
0.039386522,
-0.0594247393,
0.0013577589,
0.0050156643,
-0.0568159074,
0.0305199455,
0.0068189688,
0.0099509591,
-0.0517464429,
0.0090078842,
0.0160470251,
0.0323774666,
0.0214250479,
0.0101157203,
0.0186755378,
0.0090971654,
-0.0297541264,
0.0500268899,
-0.0018299065,
0.054285273,
-0.0356753059,
0.0256623402,
0.0565004051,
0.0073840767,
-0.0060196873,
0.0058772159,
0.0261544231,
-0.015070267,
0.0496410467,
0.0453084111,
0.0313385241,
0.007519301,
0.0111588808,
0.0210007355,
-0.036657162,
0.009271278,
-0.0467840694,
-0.0282695573,
-0.0257485751,
0.0183992237,
0.0104528414,
-0.0066265478,
-0.0129833044,
-0.0307708215,
0.0066437903,
-0.0116053326,
0.0133980988,
0.0003367544,
-0.0391702317,
0.0077500809,
0.0228636712,
-0.0457376055,
0.0086398749,
0.0666011274,
0.0104045523,
0.0146379815,
0.0067907027,
-0.0354483649,
-0.0351433195,
-0.0254895929,
0.0230046883,
-0.0055459617,
-0.0120275933,
-0.0189088918,
-0.0714617893,
-0.020824369,
0.0513132177,
-0.0283763297,
0.028927803,
-0.0100667663,
0.001344261,
0.0441795141,
0.0278100334,
0.0175783243,
-0.0466077812,
-0.038693279,
-0.0232357234,
0.0145848887,
-0.0359786488,
-5.679322345e-33,
-0.0286792144,
-0.0824085549,
0.0481005199,
0.0394965895,
0.0321639702,
0.0661406741,
0.0334997363,
-0.0099065751,
0.0062835449,
-0.0257639606,
-0.0078409174,
0.0189097188,
0.0175021924,
-0.0054827556,
0.0248491131,
-0.0232154839,
0.0310155209,
0.0229524598,
0.0035040958,
0.0171107054,
0.0158564467,
0.0511571839,
0.1243691966,
-0.0576348938,
0.0307267047,
0.0135272499,
-0.011903909,
-0.0105242655,
0.1099148765,
0.0644172952,
-0.0285997409,
0.0037650836,
0.0416972898,
-0.0965914428,
0.0289274137,
0.0240296405,
-0.1025525928,
0.0075182365,
-0.040956907,
0.015037558,
0.0556253791,
-0.000589762,
0.0612657033,
-0.0132478867,
-0.0013869673,
-0.0067394106,
0.035178151,
-0.0114137903,
-0.0247310307,
-0.0736709982,
-0.0848177895,
0.0385078564,
-0.010387416,
0.0441867523,
0.0185268801,
0.0432270877,
0.0284583829,
0.0177322552,
-0.0970738232,
0.0080303261,
0.0229834151,
0.0000014215,
0.065526478,
-0.0187142305,
-0.0613613464,
0.0091050202,
-0.0275395177,
-0.0235262215,
-0.0047616684,
0.0091074863,
0.0136701493,
0.0672569945,
0.0006334028,
0.0331159048,
-0.0059644263,
-0.0099140769,
-0.0798097551,
0.0816112831,
-0.0033920156,
0.0554177165,
0.0183060225,
-0.0043891259,
-0.0448076539,
-0.0113044418,
-0.0091927135,
-0.0344907902,
-0.0142942872,
0.0015071754,
-0.0007956827,
0.0238007791,
-0.053594552,
0.0755699426,
0.0072689359,
-0.0180936567,
-0.056792818,
0.0176481102,
0.0001655662,
-0.0090515623,
-0.0140854809,
0.0308405291,
-0.0031742679,
0.0005639923,
0.0341461487,
0.0226715151,
0.0032255775,
-0.0234645773,
0.0258907415,
0.0100644864,
-0.0652199984,
0.0155257797,
0.0280654319,
0.0223388094,
-0.0313273408,
0.0603358671,
0.0150386961,
-0.0173936673,
0.0061042914,
0.0034889914,
0.0471886098,
0.0197699461,
0.0264600795,
0.064354904,
-0.0235378109,
0.0306806043,
0.0021535966,
-0.008294899,
0.0129357241,
0.005094972,
0.0345107727,
-0.0755323544,
-0.0136333639,
0.0221621078,
2.353e-7,
0.0545936637,
0.0382815115,
0.0185303055,
0.0061255977,
-0.0323327482,
0.0216322299,
0.0407267027,
0.0521658286,
0.0144627756,
-0.0127867628,
0.0451780334,
-0.0278696846,
-0.0127945859,
0.0590856262,
-0.1143776774,
-0.0431154668,
-0.0484483801,
-0.0069718896,
-0.1069613919,
-0.0004385019,
0.0279274993,
0.0537629537,
-0.0236417726,
-0.0113128666,
-0.0090450374,
-0.0341205597,
-0.0095673613,
-0.0213033315,
0.0313187949,
0.0246414803,
0.0560754985,
0.0087084146,
0.0003443282,
-0.007730295,
-0.0415151939,
0.0050207167,
0.0118169216,
-0.0058721462,
0.0190187618,
-0.0185830183,
0.013470659,
-0.0569054522,
-0.0170954056,
-0.0574121885,
0.0258948561,
-0.0828035027,
-0.0162995923,
0.0191185288,
-0.0530207381,
0.0017731813,
-0.0038038152,
0.0126283448,
-0.0200700406,
0.027384473,
0.0137372855,
-0.0060520684,
0.0110165644,
-0.0585598871,
0.0817873552,
0.0225368626,
-0.015890358,
-0.0024892653,
0.006657843,
-0.0444340035,
-0.0047585224,
0.0009390732,
0.0112783778,
1.976347402e-34,
-0.021155823,
0.0303317569,
-0.0672432333,
0.0761714056,
0.0360544771,
0.0202503391,
-0.0649393648,
-0.006888919,
-0.0255929921,
-0.0948674977,
0.0012437559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13735v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13735v1 | Surpassing GPT-4 Medical Coding with a Two-Stage Approach | 2023-11-22T23:35:13 | 2023-11-22T23:35:13 | Zhichao Yang, Sanjit Singh Batra, Joel Stremmel, Eran Halperin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) show potential for clinical
applications, such as clinical decision support and trial recommendations.
However, the GPT-4 LLM predicts an excessive number of ICD codes for medical
coding tasks, leading to high recall but low precision. To tackle this
challenge, we introduce LLM-codex, a two-stage approach to predict ICD codes
that first generates evidence proposals using an LLM and then employs an
LSTM-based verification stage. The LSTM learns from both the LLM's high recall
and human expert's high precision, using a custom loss function. Our model is
the only approach that simultaneously achieves state-of-the-art results in
medical coding accuracy, accuracy on rare codes, and sentence-level evidence
identification to support coding decisions without training on human-annotated
evidence according to experiments on the MIMIC dataset. | [
0.0176461209,
0.0557639338,
0.0350617766,
-0.0010594876,
-0.0181812104,
0.0203437414,
-0.0096803391,
0.044210095,
-0.0125053711,
0.0080507109,
-0.0303959493,
-0.1002479419,
0.0266245753,
0.064232707,
0.0146879796,
0.0194349587,
0.041372411,
0.0017533508,
0.0516402945,
-0.0140364552,
-0.0201850347,
0.012671358,
0.0049676388,
0.0584000424,
-0.0077043585,
0.0032154717,
0.0481083654,
-0.0078985831,
0.0047228988,
-0.0980570689,
0.0237274598,
0.064173013,
0.00987266,
0.0405319072,
0.0000017696,
-0.0233372264,
0.0038165064,
0.0072315242,
-0.0594765097,
-0.0337680429,
0.0158544462,
-0.0644036755,
-0.0005475667,
0.0139741898,
-0.0413293913,
-0.0500074066,
0.0518172756,
0.0701219812,
0.0464092828,
0.0798104629,
0.000284175,
-0.0158846602,
0.0768135265,
-0.0470730811,
0.0266502444,
-0.0105066793,
0.054219339,
0.0057058549,
0.0168460123,
0.0086290976,
0.01024774,
0.0364479385,
0.0493650213,
0.0302287098,
0.0041116131,
0.0755893141,
-0.0327068679,
0.0158821903,
-0.0098250629,
0.0306996293,
-0.0038872499,
-0.032493718,
-0.0171984416,
0.0056097773,
-0.0306331124,
-0.0700579062,
-0.041055344,
0.0062292842,
-0.0169457067,
0.0444160141,
0.0166797675,
-0.0053337752,
0.0630856678,
-0.0024315617,
-0.0231490247,
0.0009962533,
0.0120311547,
-0.0389314927,
0.0176010113,
0.0044229655,
-0.0234004334,
-0.0264163762,
0.0178944152,
0.0255489219,
-0.0360044166,
-0.0025434974,
-0.0350532271,
0.0229238346,
0.0596769638,
-0.0621672757,
0.0102414321,
-0.0023523858,
-0.0142212072,
0.0346745029,
-0.0444880538,
0.0135841491,
-0.036583256,
0.0470008701,
-0.0110191433,
0.007556329,
-0.0463346504,
0.0036537608,
-0.0091946954,
0.0026563581,
0.0198626444,
0.0150077678,
-0.0785494223,
-0.0248469859,
0.0049893968,
0.0359985158,
0.0236458071,
0.0280582961,
-0.045926068,
-0.0392495058,
-0.004911161,
0.0129395863,
0.0115349861,
-0.0011148804,
-0.0172904488,
-0.0608836785,
-0.0040537515,
0.0429460704,
-0.0007888144,
-0.0189869963,
0.0363638736,
0.0302746426,
-0.0141918361,
-0.0271876436,
-0.0127420258,
-0.0215321556,
-0.0535797663,
-0.0243359245,
0.0225040335,
-0.0637488142,
-0.0007388328,
-0.009304977,
0.0105297389,
-0.0835278556,
0.0125788106,
-0.0078397859,
-0.0184634365,
0.0712602437,
-0.0521165691,
-0.0270878989,
0.0173267014,
0.0263189878,
0.0199798886,
0.0142512377,
0.0413304828,
-0.0086585423,
-0.013930426,
-0.021804573,
0.0461210273,
-0.0001259738,
0.034395542,
-0.0083371885,
-0.029703863,
0.0187043753,
0.0227346253,
0.0745669156,
0.0028266304,
0.0665556788,
-0.0223454628,
-0.0389406569,
0.0495702587,
0.0358875617,
0.0325554349,
0.0253927354,
0.0076178857,
-0.0184029527,
0.0090838429,
-0.0483504459,
-0.0247173365,
0.0058148345,
0.036502555,
-0.0030475529,
0.0259467307,
-0.0441290662,
-0.0401580036,
-0.032064762,
-0.0308700725,
-0.0359065905,
-0.0123883635,
-0.0165316015,
0.0304888729,
-0.0368212052,
-0.030990921,
0.0402757227,
-0.0076071708,
-0.0038100635,
-0.0104595115,
-0.0758629218,
0.0054073259,
0.0331191793,
0.0626620129,
-0.0161997359,
-0.035868872,
-0.0446279012,
0.0150668295,
0.0295699872,
0.0072394265,
0.0146297682,
0.0101336623,
-0.0775785744,
-0.0102917664,
0.0435757451,
-0.0087252846,
-0.0147344042,
0.0285963994,
-0.0085144714,
-0.0260583889,
-0.0035531395,
-0.0459968932,
0.0281598605,
-0.0299509689,
-0.0483729541,
0.0225771423,
-0.0307314564,
0.0582465567,
-0.0064020804,
-0.0119132865,
0.0327656791,
0.0199732278,
-0.028094342,
-0.0578267425,
-0.0471693464,
-0.0643007159,
-0.0408471376,
0.0254070964,
-0.0098250117,
-0.0116863409,
-0.013046179,
-0.0284351278,
-0.0472694784,
-0.0516891256,
-0.0677897334,
0.0500723086,
-0.0255624335,
0.0154172117,
0.0457188301,
-0.0014358808,
-0.0270673335,
0.0239907708,
-0.0468984209,
-0.002435847,
0.0055033905,
0.0069642505,
0.0314081721,
-0.01281917,
-0.0205279272,
0.0373808295,
-0.0247419123,
0.0420185216,
-0.0093676019,
0.0548779406,
-0.0059313024,
-0.0364635512,
-0.1142619848,
0.0022683735,
0.0035538652,
-0.0058590323,
-0.0005878127,
-0.0206297301,
-0.0025107155,
-0.0233192351,
-0.0604603849,
-0.0551718473,
0.01373553,
0.0174139161,
0.0339402668,
0.0530275926,
-0.02003517,
-0.0086482903,
0.0030270519,
-0.0233190246,
0.0222849119,
-0.0057979771,
-0.0232238099,
-0.0415017307,
0.0227745455,
-0.0034328366,
0.0186995231,
0.0029700517,
-0.0280806329,
0.0526643172,
-0.0081718331,
0.0239118766,
-0.0063242745,
-0.0042375107,
-0.0219924338,
0.0302380249,
0.0093476549,
-0.0312892981,
0.0165018532,
-0.0278998259,
-0.0273074936,
-0.0008535274,
-0.0222153626,
0.0096123219,
0.0780443996,
0.0492663309,
0.0236753728,
-0.0718844905,
-0.0411169119,
0.0136869419,
0.0218476895,
-0.0331945755,
-0.0009213364,
-0.0445286036,
0.0511254817,
-0.0095908102,
-0.0767191499,
0.0831336901,
-0.0344502293,
0.0190729965,
-0.0525618829,
-0.0061356062,
-0.016922934,
0.0153154964,
-0.0078176102,
0.0134502714,
0.0155544914,
-0.0381066687,
0.0177863445,
0.0150704356,
-0.0442486741,
-0.0758665949,
0.0671504587,
-0.0402370356,
0.0366559662,
0.0107871732,
-0.0589556508,
-0.0319825895,
-0.0038919719,
-0.0144077083,
-0.0045260224,
0.0102746598,
-0.013275547,
-0.0215562824,
0.0206253212,
-0.0334537737,
0.0844860375,
-0.0019854114,
-0.0042892597,
0.0001867716,
0.0072477744,
0.0071099456,
0.0029014929,
-0.0064851255,
-0.01793232,
0.0066719949,
0.0656724349,
0.0039396798,
0.0559587032,
-0.0536098965,
0.0035435911,
0.015152798,
0.0094068274,
0.0102571351,
0.0465438366,
0.02680289,
-0.0519704185,
-0.0119215399,
0.117415525,
0.0158551652,
-0.1263454109,
-0.0091757653,
-0.0022788732,
-0.0000050674,
-0.0240405668,
-0.0042078295,
-0.0654197261,
-0.0395610183,
-0.0098534543,
0.0193624683,
-0.0152009455,
-0.0161650293,
0.0181666538,
-0.0369593725,
0.0398699045,
0.0414548628,
-0.0249395911,
-0.0762305111,
-0.0331326425,
-0.0259180721,
-0.0005974827,
-0.001399284,
0.0186259132,
-0.0041679796,
-0.0101913773,
-0.011433159,
-0.0900366083,
-0.0886829048,
0.0637018234,
-0.0197693594,
0.0852548853,
0.0982860029,
0.0215573963,
-0.014528282,
-0.0117880199,
0.0188302491,
-0.0037504276,
-0.0060484824,
-0.0158737134,
0.0648555234,
-0.0024978933,
-0.0047299298,
-0.02241496,
0.0458610766,
-0.0637459531,
-0.0217221342,
-0.0150080174,
0.0744884759,
-0.0700733885,
-0.0533719957,
-0.0049191299,
0.0144078359,
-0.0013172181,
0.0584656224,
0.0180046875,
-0.0133169172,
-0.0218974221,
-0.0056549758,
0.0506841503,
-0.0057633482,
-0.0184474904,
0.0234714281,
-0.0182821769,
-0.0014837775,
-0.0578180216,
-0.0097028883,
0.0440954193,
0.0077908626,
-0.0068196007,
0.0345520489,
-0.0177124199,
-0.0090210568,
-0.0412489288,
0.055067189,
-0.0245739408,
0.0001892554,
-0.0984445661,
0.0000409253,
0.0327767655,
-0.0065204296,
-0.0053916853,
0.040922977,
-0.0404756106,
-0.0059754429,
-0.0321840309,
0.0399217941,
0.0240995754,
0.0470173694,
-0.0033279883,
-0.0348022468,
0.0395128354,
0.0078237168,
0.0000580683,
-0.0299514215,
0.0245040189,
-0.0212529376,
-0.0091125555,
0.0161286779,
0.0050311354,
0.0543705933,
0.0244168974,
0.0303900018,
-0.0262137521,
-0.0057270555,
0.0415396988,
0.0023050106,
0.0661211386,
-0.0302971583,
-0.0295561403,
0.0036738929,
0.0156787354,
0.0297907162,
0.0335228965,
-0.0081633944,
0.0096073197,
0.0471843183,
-0.0411976613,
-0.0450460874,
-0.0049843038,
-0.0156322308,
-0.0478981398,
-0.0341034159,
0.0087517379,
-0.016057387,
0.0341796093,
0.0569905303,
-0.0332369246,
-0.0320358425,
0.0294479225,
0.0121722007,
0.0224119797,
-0.0101249898,
0.053746894,
0.0052207406,
0.0388818681,
0.0178760402,
0.051211562,
-0.0317800678,
-0.0397545882,
-0.0610646978,
-0.0104567213,
0.0486076213,
0.0354889296,
0.0056620585,
-0.0481491163,
0.0299838744,
-0.039136406,
0.0302899871,
-0.034211874,
0.034445487,
0.0384596251,
0.0112824021,
-0.0383633971,
-0.0240270719,
0.0873692706,
0.0193483103,
0.0504757725,
-0.0158924703,
-0.0352946222,
-0.0324459523,
-0.0178036932,
0.027094692,
-0.0007335583,
-0.0433417819,
-0.0095695034,
-0.0186321978,
-0.0485026762,
0.043171417,
0.0078801131,
-0.0046003386,
-0.018618511,
0.0474259928,
0.0345851965,
-0.0230776891,
0.010327477,
0.0078118965,
0.006260959,
0.048977606,
-0.0166112948,
-0.0299294088,
-5.954387288e-33,
0.0215987321,
-0.0073129572,
0.0433649532,
-0.0257511176,
0.0050401194,
0.0371078849,
-0.0446406044,
-0.0151154147,
0.0062654223,
0.0357032269,
-0.0150479302,
0.0263543408,
0.0095123742,
0.0376598164,
0.0175475217,
-0.0248115268,
0.037782874,
-0.0009258376,
-0.0278787985,
0.0481120422,
-0.0038933121,
0.0344952978,
0.0612229556,
-0.0536755361,
0.0243389532,
0.0257054418,
0.0141556142,
0.0121254548,
-0.0152421249,
0.0437137,
-0.0513442717,
0.038524054,
0.052948527,
-0.0323686115,
-0.0174697507,
-0.0003371159,
-0.031141961,
-0.0230669342,
0.0053207302,
-0.0661565512,
-0.0270197298,
-0.0548089631,
0.065905191,
0.0062740492,
-0.0495409966,
0.0250768512,
-0.0239555389,
-0.0400450081,
-0.0180538259,
-0.0274692774,
-0.0170551091,
0.0574053898,
0.021683475,
-0.0087829381,
-0.010289588,
-0.0098232403,
-0.0315742642,
0.0401709042,
-0.0360960178,
0.0059987409,
-0.0023372518,
0.0368326083,
0.0154229477,
-0.0563661419,
-0.039383173,
0.0825711861,
0.0291210562,
0.0041585527,
-0.0402441099,
0.0017333729,
-0.0273124892,
0.0374700315,
0.0812205449,
0.0375187844,
0.0426955,
-0.0242395699,
-0.0543340668,
0.0323079824,
-0.0474885888,
0.0612996295,
0.0511500388,
-0.0033327576,
-0.0754267052,
-0.0239496585,
0.0115462551,
0.0385737345,
-0.0058280299,
-0.0272503197,
0.0517138988,
0.0016121257,
0.0176974442,
0.032091897,
0.0223179571,
-0.0099294884,
0.0482650958,
-0.011917362,
0.063422218,
0.0320755281,
-0.036455635,
0.029027015,
-0.0167828314,
-0.007844124,
0.0522838756,
-0.0458183549,
0.0111995731,
0.0076862527,
0.0342895947,
-0.0012978942,
-0.0614375994,
-0.0301029552,
0.0000679329,
-0.0172542594,
-0.0056894412,
0.0099717919,
0.0201405007,
0.0255952124,
0.0158039667,
0.048551213,
-0.0413957164,
-0.0203184336,
-0.035041403,
-0.0636200979,
0.0115177035,
0.0024893912,
-0.0039091096,
0.0017241915,
-0.0628512874,
0.0324518159,
0.018514961,
-0.0465237945,
-0.0024768363,
0.0327932127,
2.556e-7,
0.0741819516,
0.0449105613,
0.0177912712,
-0.0406207778,
0.0224929955,
0.0162512213,
-0.002606489,
-0.0029349802,
-0.0153619377,
-0.011895339,
0.0547691807,
0.0127192158,
0.0667011961,
0.0399167426,
-0.0731555074,
-0.0240488332,
-0.0855302513,
0.0086540952,
-0.023317758,
-0.0430102311,
0.0410645604,
0.11302457,
-0.0314018764,
-0.0497921184,
0.0513869636,
-0.0423074365,
0.0526365191,
-0.0341107734,
0.0009920547,
0.0173925832,
-0.0062379031,
0.0017689232,
0.0303554442,
0.0512437001,
-0.0241184216,
-0.0208470933,
-0.0333808102,
0.0949730054,
-0.0504256859,
0.0115659265,
0.0279400796,
0.0222276691,
0.0224135816,
-0.0244823471,
0.0438823253,
-0.0640869737,
-0.0283497274,
-0.0302973259,
-0.0043378226,
-0.061129339,
0.0600092746,
-0.0306523219,
-0.0420417935,
0.0280118976,
0.0161636416,
0.0152863134,
-0.0343468338,
-0.0798617527,
-0.010129449,
0.036883492,
-0.0643387809,
-0.0169034638,
-0.0041839257,
0.0096802413,
0.0279258862,
-0.0944000259,
0.0088127246,
2.375218349e-34,
0.0473534241,
-0.0247956105,
-0.0022788483,
0.0567379743,
0.0459490642,
0.0012900338,
0.0185058508,
0.0353081375,
0.0181372575,
-0.065125607,
-0.0180659872
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13729v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13729v2 | Comparison of pipeline, sequence-to-sequence, and GPT models for end-to-end relation extraction: experiments with the rare disease use-case | 2023-11-22T22:52:00 | 2024-03-10T01:11:20 | Shashank Gupta, Xuguang Ai, Ramakanth Kavuluru | cs.CL | cs.CL | End-to-end relation extraction (E2ERE) is an important and realistic
application of natural language processing (NLP) in biomedicine. In this paper,
we aim to compare three prevailing paradigms for E2ERE using a complex dataset
focused on rare diseases involving discontinuous and nested entities. We use
the RareDis information extraction dataset to evaluate three competing
approaches (for E2ERE): NER $\rightarrow$ RE pipelines, joint sequence to
sequence models, and generative pre-trained transformer (GPT) models. We use
comparable state-of-the-art models and best practices for each of these
approaches and conduct error analyses to assess their failure modes. Our
findings reveal that pipeline models are still the best, while
sequence-to-sequence models are not far behind; GPT models with eight times as
many parameters are worse than even sequence-to-sequence models and lose to
pipeline models by over 10 F1 points. Partial matches and discontinuous
entities caused many NER errors contributing to lower overall E2E performances.
We also verify these findings on a second E2ERE dataset for chemical-protein
interactions. Although generative LM-based methods are more suitable for
zero-shot settings, when training data is available, our results show that it
is better to work with more conventional models trained and tailored for E2ERE.
More innovative methods are needed to marry the best of the both worlds from
smaller encoder-decoder pipeline models and the larger GPT models to improve
E2ERE. As of now, we see that well designed pipeline models offer substantial
performance gains at a lower cost and carbon footprint for E2ERE. Our
contribution is also the first to conduct E2ERE for the RareDis dataset. | [
0.0363686159,
0.085079439,
0.0243819114,
0.0173601713,
0.0086954636,
0.0289704204,
-0.0125382934,
0.0110314917,
-0.0058220732,
-0.0237782523,
-0.0129467165,
-0.053662613,
0.0028283072,
0.0455729365,
0.0013261661,
-0.0254442319,
0.0244077593,
0.0269536935,
0.0239149462,
0.0080802739,
-0.0191803556,
0.0252150726,
0.0062876358,
0.0157088153,
0.0108029246,
0.008918928,
0.0442084782,
0.0123358499,
0.0573505573,
-0.0674712881,
0.0137669407,
0.0240875017,
0.0052628941,
-0.0124659957,
0.0000019522,
-0.0387586318,
-0.0309608802,
0.0289414395,
-0.0418674313,
-0.0360428765,
-0.0107360175,
-0.0689065158,
0.0024887451,
0.008822538,
-0.0298874509,
-0.0674643964,
0.0592680052,
0.0597917438,
0.0067893309,
0.0840051547,
-0.0218909271,
-0.0669382811,
0.0944808349,
-0.0557732135,
0.0286543909,
-0.012533999,
0.0731578991,
-0.0406252816,
-0.0083056632,
-0.0361485295,
-0.0037083179,
0.0218737535,
-0.0029808374,
0.0277458597,
0.0171791725,
0.0524258502,
-0.0236214902,
-0.048389852,
0.0072299629,
0.1007598341,
-0.0516197383,
0.0230403896,
0.0298308749,
-0.005843787,
-0.0357159302,
0.0001948091,
0.0081204018,
0.011350478,
-0.0328148529,
0.0572594553,
0.0270585809,
-0.0099448273,
0.0218034126,
-0.0386160612,
-0.0515617914,
0.0029986312,
0.0005557204,
-0.0260743126,
-0.0099793579,
0.0404457301,
-0.0328312926,
-0.0270355158,
0.0285604671,
0.0051398333,
0.0089320419,
0.039126914,
-0.0324982293,
-0.0226394162,
0.0278004277,
-0.009084845,
0.0036075148,
0.0054643317,
-0.0191674177,
0.0171478502,
-0.0294325985,
-0.0151544139,
-0.0387054235,
0.0237138476,
0.0223119594,
-0.0100931311,
-0.0297180656,
0.0080619231,
0.0014786479,
0.0447324291,
-0.0673534423,
-0.0054200292,
-0.0633710399,
-0.0249587633,
0.0125120971,
0.0084604342,
0.0527408831,
0.0382116474,
-0.0352949202,
0.008268374,
0.0034000946,
0.0414090194,
0.0331899934,
-0.0135676591,
-0.0093087265,
-0.0801522434,
-0.0274800025,
-0.0190451946,
0.0353234261,
-0.039357312,
0.0279248226,
0.1131504551,
0.0108325686,
-0.0833827481,
0.0154687297,
-0.0186929721,
-0.0182857066,
-0.061554011,
-0.0104653863,
-0.0284027085,
0.0956954509,
0.0295336097,
0.0113259535,
-0.081400305,
0.0327774249,
-0.0262886789,
-0.0901421756,
0.0530434698,
-0.0211771764,
-0.0309734903,
-0.006870321,
0.0184602365,
0.0143756885,
0.0198634733,
0.0587060079,
-0.0631296188,
0.0134238685,
-0.0184627194,
0.021625651,
0.0083497595,
0.0087232227,
-0.0700564533,
0.0360857695,
0.0168063324,
-0.0045960252,
0.0226050597,
0.0352891721,
0.0291792266,
-0.0060567623,
-0.0275220349,
0.0124878129,
0.0249717031,
0.0809716806,
0.0203168206,
0.0372602232,
0.0271564834,
-0.0125700412,
-0.0157938655,
-0.0167865269,
0.0138146961,
-0.0102717672,
0.0284572076,
-0.0042745769,
0.0527274087,
-0.0003261637,
0.0006388575,
0.0036866553,
0.0023357803,
-0.0364367142,
-0.0180702526,
0.068054907,
-0.0056389812,
-0.0731302053,
0.0711771771,
0.0544419289,
-0.0185611639,
0.0134402197,
-0.0012277339,
-0.0445522331,
0.0293211769,
0.0388491191,
-0.0363681465,
-0.0551411211,
-0.0265884493,
-0.090256311,
0.0303325523,
-0.0167726725,
0.0219816472,
0.058075022,
-0.0205849987,
-0.0138575556,
0.0154838208,
0.0125917308,
-0.0130735608,
0.018697558,
0.0400143452,
-0.0010216095,
-0.0042761299,
0.0209472012,
0.0365957767,
-0.0750892088,
-0.023105545,
0.0132775391,
-0.0022651283,
0.0115538947,
0.0253476966,
-0.0398555472,
0.0162808411,
0.0308320336,
-0.0372898392,
-0.0370935537,
-0.0030760011,
-0.0406190678,
-0.0774323419,
-0.002060232,
-0.0326879732,
-0.0288211927,
-0.0096214768,
-0.0460069813,
-0.0181228425,
-0.0359898768,
0.0071749808,
0.0543404296,
-0.0110170227,
0.0335447416,
0.044404,
0.0381061286,
-0.0121977506,
0.0301451609,
-0.0254612956,
-0.0136492569,
-0.019258121,
-0.10887748,
-0.0161348712,
-0.0441645645,
-0.0197746083,
0.0292257201,
-0.0005317407,
-0.0313542672,
-0.0157911256,
0.007310098,
-0.0296771731,
-0.0108261025,
-0.0342535786,
0.0132248932,
0.0187150743,
0.0602734461,
0.0163103715,
0.0319623798,
-0.0124299899,
0.0003283308,
-0.0130371349,
-0.0114098405,
-0.0023684388,
-0.0001985344,
0.0606530793,
0.0290319659,
-0.0408152118,
-0.0535847656,
-0.0157940667,
-0.0456301719,
0.064298965,
-0.0092226183,
-0.0491359904,
0.0059443517,
0.0279986318,
-0.0046806666,
0.0315099917,
-0.0061241137,
0.0175152272,
-0.0185575839,
0.0226897132,
-0.0008480307,
-0.0092315031,
0.0045927633,
0.0636992976,
-0.0019972161,
0.0127280615,
-0.0251845773,
0.0127630429,
-0.0573144034,
-0.0002454159,
-0.0141052688,
-0.0188984182,
0.026567528,
0.0772906914,
-0.0002047072,
0.0095494352,
-0.0273270439,
0.0137748802,
0.0360196494,
-0.0063301488,
0.0106307352,
0.0236491673,
-0.0137644503,
0.0035882257,
-0.0181606077,
-0.0139602637,
0.0932113901,
-0.0164630581,
-0.0052027791,
-0.0399941541,
-0.0067827217,
-0.0379411019,
-0.0019972508,
0.0079763997,
0.0044231298,
0.0280314442,
-0.0552455373,
0.0127401156,
0.0175322033,
0.0104746316,
-0.0451224223,
0.0442970395,
-0.0260040741,
0.0294032712,
-0.0117831808,
-0.0249413177,
-0.0405572131,
0.0121507328,
-0.016759973,
0.0068540745,
0.0067049498,
-0.0345596075,
-0.0447560251,
0.0343635567,
-0.0258671977,
0.0471043885,
0.0244170576,
-0.0160529595,
0.0001446797,
0.0749852583,
0.0468668491,
-0.0431282371,
-0.0024866567,
-0.0044911085,
0.0492694564,
0.0582072102,
-0.0414854288,
0.0321496986,
0.0194330513,
0.0155008836,
0.0116301635,
-0.026468005,
-0.0007941159,
0.0047877594,
0.0165382028,
-0.0577337742,
-0.0132229347,
0.0916826501,
0.0041718804,
-0.0479418412,
0.0223004669,
0.0531409048,
-0.0200628527,
-0.0238019787,
0.0217151251,
-0.1049020886,
-0.0358714089,
-0.0203683078,
0.0015243316,
-0.0081182616,
-0.0895174891,
0.0067513967,
-0.0800373703,
0.0216798447,
0.0002592509,
-0.0469532311,
-0.0406215228,
-0.0489692464,
-0.0093769338,
-0.0300447419,
0.0025140515,
-0.0022020042,
-0.0207051896,
-0.0084564136,
0.0106899515,
-0.0220204573,
-0.1007564589,
0.0086439317,
-0.0203967597,
0.0410377011,
0.0568042248,
-0.0182837956,
0.0128158564,
0.0302056633,
0.0307491235,
-0.0242561772,
0.007592415,
-0.0114045395,
0.0775278658,
-0.0420883931,
-0.0283016507,
-0.0435704775,
0.0136455763,
-0.0642740875,
-0.0057572313,
-0.0427522287,
0.0930697098,
-0.0010282577,
-0.0567526482,
-0.0307583138,
-0.0229722615,
0.0030115212,
0.0585788451,
-0.00604964,
0.0007362531,
-0.0535685979,
0.0316005871,
0.0275588073,
-0.0234389529,
-0.023483729,
0.0201976653,
-0.0392519012,
-0.0337441787,
-0.0427552871,
-0.0364890844,
0.0513449349,
-0.0195420291,
-0.0185882263,
0.0108432211,
0.0380078591,
0.0053863353,
-0.0610646121,
0.048852846,
0.0249768365,
-0.0165745523,
-0.0649494082,
-0.0355154164,
0.0517668203,
0.0281350333,
-0.0306598339,
-0.011464064,
-0.0462939106,
-0.0546578467,
-0.0333881155,
0.01821482,
0.0209618602,
0.0361872874,
0.0361514464,
0.01040769,
0.0581390783,
0.0631403476,
-0.0538805388,
-0.0244810749,
0.0021150636,
-0.0186512265,
-0.0229461957,
0.0136409746,
0.0055881822,
0.0170955323,
0.0270804018,
0.0836374089,
-0.0002715848,
-0.0578869954,
0.0417254791,
-0.0066550449,
0.0840852708,
-0.0015478962,
-0.0262604356,
-0.0358721428,
0.0407095253,
-0.0437809825,
0.0528416969,
-0.0408940092,
-0.0015908013,
0.0401492491,
0.0215680059,
-0.0446853526,
-0.0017816168,
-0.0436540879,
0.0189836528,
-0.0401569717,
0.0402327664,
0.0200920179,
-0.0407732576,
0.074149698,
-0.0320655629,
0.0037525063,
0.0226456281,
0.0178422444,
0.013934494,
-0.0322767198,
0.0313414149,
0.0011467413,
0.0475784466,
-0.0016960471,
0.0326166078,
-0.0032846746,
0.0353698246,
-0.0505599752,
0.0136240153,
0.0451535843,
-0.0030830456,
0.059258882,
0.0058044656,
0.0134082707,
-0.0123173697,
0.0417421684,
-0.0522586182,
0.0279482175,
0.0453578979,
0.0171907023,
-0.0353812277,
-0.0198760312,
0.0664570034,
0.006216432,
0.052859202,
-0.0054149614,
-0.0255497321,
-0.0135953547,
-0.0106185805,
-0.0132320765,
-0.0444400981,
-0.0363696851,
0.0003237497,
-0.0512693822,
-0.0610968918,
0.0161586814,
-0.0252288915,
-0.0206983276,
0.0169710368,
0.0005847505,
-0.0017286553,
0.0372258797,
-0.0548383482,
-0.0112818768,
0.0320504606,
-0.0193348993,
-0.0486871079,
-0.0049226899,
-6.54432823e-33,
-0.0091589699,
-0.0331415683,
0.0022122581,
0.005659353,
-0.0191751141,
0.0254687462,
-0.0501166992,
-0.0174163654,
-0.0013639398,
0.0267344657,
-0.0138856303,
-0.000267091,
0.0039720326,
0.0248708837,
-0.0025491896,
-0.0159566775,
0.0310361572,
0.0175358821,
0.0005180092,
0.0041711112,
0.0226106346,
0.0890905038,
0.080041565,
-0.071467489,
-0.0185488034,
0.0031235707,
0.0538824089,
-0.0005350942,
0.0218906682,
0.0208930671,
-0.0464553609,
0.0310295243,
0.0346867219,
-0.0659411475,
-0.0032137842,
-0.0209399331,
-0.1495602131,
0.0175924934,
-0.0235527884,
-0.0311081819,
-0.0043376153,
-0.0109006399,
0.041423928,
0.0007314393,
-0.0040456783,
-0.0428995267,
0.030492967,
-0.0062091206,
-0.0178792141,
-0.0598747395,
-0.0619990714,
0.0468481965,
0.0257616937,
0.0228901114,
0.0174376015,
0.0073721921,
0.0182188805,
0.025356628,
-0.0393295325,
-0.0469391458,
0.0193038844,
0.0040806304,
0.0361761525,
-0.042137295,
0.007706197,
0.0383219682,
0.024112625,
-0.0263852701,
-0.0305861905,
0.0290738791,
-0.0403648131,
0.0488537736,
-0.0258229245,
-0.0098784799,
0.0572656803,
0.0035592988,
-0.0910676122,
0.0428895541,
-0.0537052006,
0.0556397066,
-0.0228883363,
0.0042303014,
-0.0031880199,
0.0048346166,
0.0041759554,
0.014644146,
-0.0049858699,
-0.0325601213,
0.0073452694,
0.0023675293,
-0.0202549584,
0.0308694318,
0.0188299101,
-0.01053036,
-0.044575423,
0.0112256873,
0.0347144492,
0.0064130169,
-0.0301360581,
0.0078428397,
-0.0223440658,
-0.0273325145,
0.0417132974,
-0.0182435568,
0.0344304331,
-0.0073792851,
0.0230414066,
-0.0260029715,
-0.0567398556,
-0.0154745942,
-0.0355590805,
0.0475399494,
-0.0133584468,
0.074461475,
-0.0055021308,
0.035610266,
-0.0106603596,
0.0568903089,
0.0154943932,
0.0160503946,
-0.027048083,
0.0840325803,
0.0453215092,
0.0203316994,
-0.0084436601,
0.0020169953,
-0.0141443871,
0.0168229714,
0.0291928183,
-0.0329473689,
-0.0247968007,
-0.0043873442,
2.734e-7,
0.0896051228,
0.0066421931,
0.0810288861,
-0.0089862626,
0.0035326723,
0.0126594417,
0.0073054275,
0.0412040688,
-0.016193537,
0.0190486666,
0.0180107336,
0.0018311484,
0.0071456828,
0.0278633349,
-0.0423644483,
-0.0291864779,
-0.0634818599,
-0.0347259603,
-0.0363331698,
-0.02556674,
0.0684899986,
0.0644874871,
-0.0232411344,
-0.0182829071,
-0.0070489305,
0.0177078824,
0.0374512523,
-0.0255090538,
0.0268167481,
0.0506560616,
0.0021305385,
-0.009992715,
0.0242392216,
0.0362365916,
-0.0330033451,
0.0193202291,
-0.0348280147,
0.0697015747,
-0.037078537,
-0.0552745946,
0.0421925783,
0.0249699075,
0.0322324112,
-0.0203626398,
0.0427014604,
-0.1068752259,
-0.0318578482,
0.0144236758,
-0.0417707078,
0.0131511791,
0.0075619551,
0.0087695494,
0.0086137112,
0.037743777,
0.0438363329,
0.0107200285,
-0.0249152966,
-0.0896004215,
0.0117966393,
0.0539504997,
-0.029224718,
0.0085671805,
0.0140485791,
-0.0108366013,
0.0016958066,
-0.0043607703,
-0.033078365,
2.621607246e-34,
-0.00083567,
0.0174487904,
0.0106284712,
0.0469678864,
0.0311796498,
-0.0164201222,
-0.0306431297,
0.0095253587,
-0.0567367673,
-0.0873317644,
-0.0117120109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13708v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13708v4 | Dynamic Fault Analysis in Substations Based on Knowledge Graphs | 2023-11-22T21:59:46 | 2024-01-27T07:32:54 | Weiwei Li, Xing Liu, Wei Wang, Lu Chen, Sizhe Li, Hui Fan | cs.CL | cs.CL | To address the challenge of identifying hidden danger in substations from
unstructured text, a novel dynamic analysis method is proposed. We first
extract relevant information from the unstructured text, and then leverages a
flexible distributed search engine built on Elastic-Search to handle the data.
Following this, the hidden Markov model is employed to train the data within
the engine. The Viterbi algorithm is integrated to decipher the hidden state
sequences, facilitating the segmentation and labeling of entities related to
hidden dangers. The final step involves using the Neo4j graph database to
dynamically create a knowledge graph that visualizes hidden dangers in the
substation. The effectiveness of the proposed method is demonstrated through a
case analysis from a specific substation with hidden dangers revealed in the
text records. | [
0.0013656501,
0.0325088091,
-0.0326786228,
0.0199025404,
0.0095775472,
0.0026831434,
-0.0305916909,
0.0079135671,
0.0307064801,
-0.0450749025,
0.0851363093,
0.0373759642,
-0.0525120497,
0.0631855726,
-0.0077099167,
-0.0367129818,
0.0323504098,
0.0184747986,
0.0367425419,
0.0344939865,
-0.0138095347,
0.0021025527,
-0.0327617899,
-0.0205717627,
-0.0335238948,
0.0193413589,
-0.0497859456,
-0.0085443547,
0.0667420179,
-0.0586955696,
-0.0120880669,
-0.0244163182,
-0.0080230087,
0.0477585346,
0.0000020563,
0.0110999104,
-0.0760100782,
-0.0041308221,
0.0152852153,
-0.0547383428,
-0.0297318194,
-0.013715717,
0.0208867397,
0.0266593453,
-0.040157035,
-0.0361219347,
0.0382055081,
0.0294260811,
0.0568883009,
0.0701739788,
-0.0396553911,
0.0010458541,
0.0161012895,
0.0184216667,
-0.0305220559,
-0.0372474268,
0.0290867314,
0.0035137848,
0.0373895541,
-0.0083172591,
0.0525406562,
0.020036336,
-0.0122935576,
-0.0013311408,
-0.0157863032,
0.0253627803,
-0.0446189046,
0.0578966215,
-0.0434019975,
0.039914418,
0.008527115,
0.0198817383,
0.0707055777,
-0.0110795991,
-0.0455831848,
0.062970221,
0.0377896205,
0.0119789299,
-0.0619375594,
-0.0035143844,
-0.0301047023,
0.0351404287,
0.0247551762,
-0.0460320711,
-0.0049955267,
0.1223711967,
-0.0164778661,
-0.0315754302,
-0.0078976331,
-0.0486871041,
-0.0028701059,
-0.033862941,
0.0546561703,
0.0035227735,
-0.0059054429,
0.0399947055,
0.022141438,
-0.0409664996,
0.0255615227,
-0.0595233701,
-0.0241338536,
0.0077061984,
0.0785047486,
0.0136897592,
0.031173069,
-0.0122919967,
-0.0248956438,
0.002485631,
-0.0445581004,
0.0142456684,
-0.0738434941,
-0.0453985222,
-0.0172458421,
0.0338090174,
0.0288327225,
0.007739617,
0.0141994879,
0.0442563444,
-0.0225827359,
-0.0086169643,
-0.0566991903,
0.0031075506,
0.03169607,
0.0369037874,
-0.0341219045,
-0.0099942395,
-0.0107374387,
-0.024702264,
-0.0358741917,
0.0061731348,
0.0176743697,
-0.0043396237,
0.0522372983,
0.0006843033,
-0.0299229752,
0.0266804919,
0.0360474885,
-0.0344386958,
-0.0706034303,
-0.0416061357,
-0.0016693452,
0.0314510055,
0.0083250059,
-0.0030439931,
-0.0298274532,
-0.0274416804,
-0.0216318704,
0.0421050042,
0.015167553,
-0.0029075928,
0.0038916885,
0.0163155273,
-0.0789214298,
-0.0171267781,
0.013523411,
-0.0018915631,
0.0247108489,
-0.0026246703,
0.0068445923,
0.0237914268,
0.01851115,
0.0105215423,
0.0158976503,
-0.0055382969,
0.0129354242,
0.0017877187,
0.0101129115,
-0.0023580866,
-0.0285225082,
-0.006087814,
-0.0475709699,
-0.0044980492,
0.0193149671,
-0.0084878206,
0.0142412512,
0.0072238641,
-0.0233643148,
0.0204959232,
-0.0085225031,
0.0268150363,
-0.0433768108,
-0.049701903,
0.0311456881,
-0.0307707936,
-0.0817129239,
0.0119648827,
-0.0337358825,
0.0020866571,
0.0071363235,
0.0018661873,
-0.0507591814,
0.0184267275,
0.0248424802,
-0.0181784611,
0.0296070129,
-0.0035600418,
-0.0409996212,
0.0542847514,
0.0242658406,
-0.0079060346,
-0.0182084423,
-0.0178924873,
-0.0210474171,
0.0912244692,
0.0713615343,
-0.0847426802,
-0.0721899569,
0.0066768038,
-0.0242192149,
0.0058592991,
-0.032504648,
0.0233372897,
-0.024190031,
-0.034493003,
-0.0444334671,
-0.0001795554,
0.0424802937,
-0.0064545888,
-0.1005728915,
0.0570082888,
-0.0271624308,
-0.0277058855,
-0.054399047,
0.0082736993,
0.0311977491,
0.0242814869,
-0.02884195,
0.0548802651,
-0.017444713,
0.0275073256,
-0.0121205654,
0.0079950476,
0.0533902161,
-0.0193329733,
-0.0918197855,
0.0146179609,
-0.0171886105,
-0.0004438959,
0.0258732755,
-0.0661823004,
0.0186874643,
-0.0186762922,
-0.0155531717,
-0.0548077933,
0.014651482,
-0.061673265,
0.0190496519,
-0.0085948966,
-0.0247103367,
0.0054182536,
-0.0323021859,
-0.0223346762,
0.0706021413,
-0.0038751902,
-0.0110923247,
-0.0298861694,
-0.0518401787,
0.0338987149,
-0.0385257974,
0.0065011089,
-0.0023539758,
-0.0256630294,
-0.0055361926,
-0.0023746633,
-0.0306534898,
0.0047355746,
0.0508896969,
-0.0519133247,
0.0014951227,
0.004256587,
0.0503567532,
0.0239515584,
0.0242736898,
-0.0261324923,
-0.0303897392,
0.0121741733,
0.0674509779,
-0.0369035378,
-0.0380756855,
0.0268647354,
0.0379980095,
-0.0222825222,
0.0161655452,
-0.0209032129,
-0.0244922694,
0.0577184409,
0.0419122204,
-0.0243810154,
-0.0212629326,
0.067790091,
-0.0102736168,
-0.0241329838,
-0.004521552,
-0.0358234942,
-0.0306921676,
-0.0275897346,
0.0226244908,
-0.0253984053,
0.0134079028,
0.0493781976,
0.0203130078,
-0.0472618341,
-0.0091607412,
0.0284848958,
-0.0546782278,
0.0503792726,
-0.0144881057,
-0.0234194566,
0.0145067936,
0.0188840032,
0.0401552357,
0.0080928765,
0.0054871398,
-0.0321396403,
0.0314278416,
-0.007667298,
-0.0188292917,
-0.0617269799,
0.010704902,
0.0305111557,
0.0194371808,
0.0036738594,
0.0700487271,
0.0146129346,
0.065273352,
-0.0769881308,
-0.0690385327,
-0.0148571078,
0.0483065061,
-0.0124590024,
0.0385545716,
0.0506137609,
-0.0116251828,
0.0373179913,
-0.004701057,
0.0407659225,
0.0080668284,
-0.0469806865,
0.0029509994,
0.0290359296,
0.063390471,
-0.0297728814,
-0.0182566307,
-0.0092764152,
-0.0069456119,
0.0045098611,
0.0422515683,
-0.0267550945,
-0.0667449757,
0.0667438582,
-0.0025021601,
0.035082642,
0.0182131063,
-0.003631603,
-0.0050263661,
0.0499163456,
-0.0122707644,
-0.0612714998,
0.0493571199,
-0.0047652293,
0.0235974509,
0.0365162119,
0.0231825728,
-0.0445555523,
-0.0482347459,
-0.0098613752,
-0.059214633,
-0.0613472499,
-0.0091191148,
-0.0445050597,
-0.0758882612,
-0.0228843205,
-0.0206885953,
0.0198741071,
0.026395835,
-0.0321352817,
0.0223873556,
0.0215823147,
-0.0329460353,
-0.0064601409,
0.0566764846,
-0.0335631967,
0.0040807067,
0.011835671,
0.0558178946,
-0.0010670775,
-0.0582053326,
0.0033703193,
-0.0293420274,
0.0016741575,
-0.0132900961,
0.001419669,
-0.0261990093,
-0.0426235013,
0.0080125779,
-0.0105949873,
-0.0789191723,
-0.0047716666,
-0.0052552363,
-0.0103295632,
0.0442046598,
-0.0632375702,
-0.0665216446,
-0.0374423526,
-0.0301359296,
-0.0005663275,
0.0313047394,
0.0327021815,
-0.0365464464,
-0.0025760806,
0.0072576352,
0.0387140661,
0.02171297,
-0.0489769392,
0.0371903032,
0.0067681908,
0.0029463558,
-0.0496845469,
0.0062795752,
-0.0247395914,
-0.0145380078,
0.0367322154,
0.0971699804,
-0.0566125065,
-0.0142569365,
-0.0680657774,
-0.0303588286,
0.0875009298,
-0.0269727297,
-0.0280553866,
0.0084913513,
-0.0239306241,
0.032183364,
0.0389223881,
0.054876104,
0.054308489,
0.0292363223,
-0.0236896928,
0.0032807756,
-0.0504577085,
-0.0252296105,
-0.0102590872,
0.0578410476,
0.0399046242,
-0.0762705877,
0.1027973667,
-0.00104252,
-0.0928083584,
-0.0194412861,
0.0304007027,
0.0231361408,
0.0313123316,
0.020858733,
0.0056388522,
0.0020206906,
-0.0371306948,
-0.0155218076,
-0.0329832844,
-0.0192385763,
0.0264968164,
0.0219111796,
0.0179329552,
-0.0073793982,
-0.0378564969,
-0.0029191992,
0.0617661364,
0.0327436142,
-0.0730298832,
-0.0484108031,
-0.0149743417,
-0.0517218933,
0.0051352042,
-0.0095346142,
-0.01742943,
-0.0131900972,
-0.0398309231,
0.0280512981,
-0.0789275318,
0.0013718262,
-0.0068923584,
0.0381396413,
0.0003952288,
0.034639556,
-0.006884512,
-0.0443770252,
0.0511891432,
0.0197513197,
0.0044576861,
-0.0067331977,
0.0646847636,
-0.0283772927,
-0.0207276363,
0.0077262912,
0.0391421355,
0.0415432639,
-0.0437503532,
0.0023043186,
0.0175166521,
0.0662556365,
-0.0033647059,
0.0333597586,
-0.0159944706,
0.0378591716,
0.0186505094,
0.0291742533,
0.0087932721,
0.0088108042,
0.0045527862,
0.047859028,
-0.0743979663,
-0.0482170247,
0.0098206671,
-0.0484694764,
-0.0067308256,
0.0093373209,
0.0015081463,
0.0449413955,
0.065866679,
0.0103415139,
-0.0620396025,
0.0193944015,
0.0129517391,
0.012703537,
0.0020177579,
-0.0108824084,
0.0344850793,
0.0254783109,
-0.0318060219,
0.0214816071,
0.0427332781,
0.0295887627,
0.0494100153,
-0.0154058374,
-0.0900977403,
-0.0279346462,
0.02429712,
0.0799467266,
0.060667742,
-0.0323224068,
-0.0224711243,
-0.0530751906,
-0.0091987532,
0.0408020206,
0.037547268,
-0.0144503508,
-0.003770978,
0.0725722909,
-0.0097586894,
0.0540065281,
0.0342419073,
-0.0106428741,
0.0020518517,
-0.0441703312,
0.0081521897,
0.0198064316,
-6.240916975e-33,
0.0185997412,
-0.1033557206,
-0.0176552795,
0.0496619344,
-0.0123294983,
0.0296785086,
-0.014862746,
-0.0283986907,
0.0566032417,
-0.0100063672,
0.0057939263,
0.0480444916,
0.0057476326,
-0.0303900894,
-0.0102923065,
0.0073066242,
0.0239873696,
0.0262857936,
-0.0021742482,
0.0060237218,
0.0929469764,
0.058749672,
0.0720657855,
-0.0381159224,
0.0057668816,
0.0056243758,
-0.0171486735,
0.0513955392,
-0.0144653982,
0.0235386789,
-0.0115525927,
0.0385705829,
-0.0072841989,
0.0216939449,
0.0238565356,
-0.0118990736,
-0.0277522895,
-0.0262914486,
-0.0445900187,
0.0086657787,
-0.016445864,
0.0066804341,
0.0485112555,
0.0074741342,
0.0345523991,
0.0253086407,
0.0596803427,
0.0185177643,
0.0001924959,
-0.0586820357,
0.0466824546,
0.0438196808,
-0.0549717136,
0.0277314838,
0.0012123105,
-0.0209973659,
0.0333442241,
-0.0300336946,
-0.0635654107,
0.0187691208,
0.0528185852,
-0.0160878021,
0.0315855145,
-0.0019884855,
0.010822474,
0.0526853055,
-0.0319421515,
-0.0217348933,
0.009105091,
0.0024554359,
-0.0211781953,
0.0631149933,
-0.0177757666,
-0.016034646,
0.0088438401,
-0.0416762196,
-0.1134104952,
0.0180998649,
0.0131837716,
0.0380049497,
0.0262863934,
-0.0055820574,
-0.0269442257,
-0.006248781,
0.0234605316,
0.0066091828,
-0.0171923526,
-0.0210225508,
-0.0163401477,
0.0134456884,
-0.0215234384,
0.0400959291,
-0.0275408253,
-0.0181782786,
0.0066212364,
0.0351428986,
0.0337614678,
-0.0365115814,
-0.02948194,
0.0268486403,
-0.0175214019,
-0.0248181932,
-0.0345954038,
0.0035107057,
-0.0184957869,
-0.016313104,
-0.0213105604,
0.0571564734,
-0.0072213332,
0.0237330962,
0.0157367084,
-0.0112765767,
-0.040641278,
-0.012990295,
0.0148900626,
-0.0036998701,
0.0254136957,
0.0661468431,
0.0351651609,
0.0422053188,
0.0163003858,
0.0390673988,
-0.0018466979,
0.014213345,
0.0155739058,
-0.015330378,
-0.0432446152,
0.0132158082,
-0.0381643213,
-0.0318268761,
0.0079759248,
0.0707143396,
2.974e-7,
0.0313003957,
0.0445915423,
0.0117451856,
0.0187459905,
0.0262693204,
0.0294907112,
-0.0141075142,
-0.0130687626,
-0.0265211985,
0.0358525142,
0.073128134,
-0.0422365181,
0.0134874685,
0.053755872,
-0.0594367385,
-0.0186370835,
-0.0493610464,
-0.0240190495,
-0.0624115281,
-0.0161005594,
0.0963575169,
-0.0145988874,
0.0481610298,
0.0094064111,
0.0212021675,
-0.0791195631,
0.0032331804,
0.0082342345,
0.0071352185,
0.0025238758,
0.0113660442,
0.0458399504,
-0.0223686788,
0.0107803401,
-0.0155726057,
0.0055370447,
-0.0114472257,
-0.0198073741,
0.0046612704,
-0.0231943931,
0.0475698039,
-0.052877035,
0.0146762887,
-0.0047408324,
0.0164307822,
-0.0409942232,
-0.0402690656,
0.0804136619,
-0.0369196646,
-0.0395126566,
-0.0161070228,
-0.00363284,
-0.0424692221,
-0.0002671477,
-0.0629445389,
-0.0002327495,
0.0278715231,
-0.0194968451,
0.0695637986,
0.0255022589,
-0.0062632919,
-0.0504927412,
-0.0124275805,
0.0272612665,
0.0410828739,
0.0214954671,
0.0150174871,
2.707215607e-34,
-0.0211119484,
-0.002503651,
-0.0991852805,
0.0095168203,
0.0025349064,
-0.0042524575,
-0.0633498803,
-0.033447016,
-0.0232721418,
-0.1067653745,
-0.0309423562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13668v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13668v3 | MAIRA-1: A specialised large multimodal model for radiology report generation | 2023-11-22T19:45:40 | 2024-04-26T16:29:54 | Stephanie L. Hyland, Shruthi Bannur, Kenza Bouzid, Daniel C. Castro, Mercy Ranjit, Anton Schwaighofer, Fernando Pérez-García, Valentina Salvatelli, Shaury Srivastav, Anja Thieme, Noel Codella, Matthew P. Lungren, Maria Teodora Wetscherek, Ozan Oktay, Javier Alvarez-Valle | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | We present a radiology-specific multimodal model for the task for generating
radiological reports from chest X-rays (CXRs). Our work builds on the idea that
large language model(s) can be equipped with multimodal capabilities through
alignment with pre-trained vision encoders. On natural images, this has been
shown to allow multimodal models to gain image understanding and description
capabilities. Our proposed model (MAIRA-1) leverages a CXR-specific image
encoder in conjunction with a fine-tuned large language model based on
Vicuna-7B, and text-based data augmentation, to produce reports with
state-of-the-art quality. In particular, MAIRA-1 significantly improves on the
radiologist-aligned RadCliQ metric and across all lexical metrics considered.
Manual review of model outputs demonstrates promising fluency and accuracy of
generated reports while uncovering failure modes not captured by existing
evaluation practices. More information and resources can be found on the
project website: https://aka.ms/maira. | [
0.0222075004,
0.0630800724,
0.0452183932,
0.0128918085,
0.0073367287,
0.0256091431,
0.0067767142,
0.0378065221,
-0.0436360724,
-0.0363283493,
-0.0546840504,
-0.0481935591,
0.0204765014,
0.0762471408,
0.0400542617,
-0.1008476391,
-0.0069354749,
-0.0060830815,
-0.0040776832,
-0.003984795,
0.0176141523,
0.0158500392,
0.0012695555,
0.028787123,
-0.0358058922,
-0.0119942315,
-0.0111873504,
0.0335907638,
0.0183409769,
-0.0253999215,
-0.0353258289,
0.0582637452,
0.0329128876,
0.013437828,
0.0000020783,
-0.0060196263,
-0.0048665982,
0.0378042683,
0.0028673564,
-0.0301440712,
0.0870072544,
-0.0998525694,
-0.0072256853,
-0.0242924262,
-0.0088755293,
-0.0785252824,
0.0788259581,
0.0195449889,
0.1044344455,
0.0556862466,
-0.0330025069,
-0.0114024561,
0.0116366129,
-0.0303374287,
-0.0113039874,
-0.0370943323,
-0.0026188104,
0.0398848988,
0.020969633,
0.0245093405,
-0.0452624261,
0.0535684898,
0.0255938061,
-0.0320523754,
0.0368443951,
0.0416369475,
0.0264563169,
-0.0302835181,
-0.0100265313,
0.061320208,
-0.0295389444,
0.0248350389,
-0.043670807,
-0.0107751871,
-0.0355817229,
-0.0322718248,
-0.0460659191,
0.019832423,
-0.0018806492,
-0.016826598,
-0.0482814871,
0.0114657395,
-0.0062084957,
0.008258895,
0.0008790821,
-0.0472186543,
0.0154551612,
0.0114302123,
-0.0053097694,
0.0359731577,
0.0109196138,
-0.0653786808,
0.0277222209,
0.0446577407,
-0.0458495803,
0.0052549522,
-0.0648959652,
-0.0322967023,
0.0603339002,
-0.0546148531,
0.0106677013,
-0.0049290489,
-0.0736151487,
0.0611400306,
-0.0166820548,
0.0639871284,
-0.0373831615,
0.0584009625,
-0.0355511047,
-0.0086760223,
-0.0069841375,
-0.0276531912,
-0.003592131,
-0.0121797509,
-0.0069312863,
-0.039261207,
-0.0783252642,
0.0081613325,
0.0045624571,
0.0431080349,
0.0438307598,
0.0420655087,
-0.0900266543,
0.0153728304,
-0.0309818108,
0.061194025,
0.0359669439,
-0.0082961489,
-0.0102135418,
-0.0117396004,
0.0073756278,
0.061099261,
0.0015029472,
-0.0153893409,
-0.0360272266,
0.0312617347,
-0.0308123566,
-0.0021262697,
0.0543115772,
-0.0529068783,
-0.0291573424,
-0.0366713963,
0.0129086999,
-0.0569486842,
0.0507318303,
0.0065999469,
0.0184125509,
-0.0210861079,
0.0030071987,
0.0034591381,
-0.0096204476,
0.0751907602,
-0.0452136658,
-0.003790851,
0.0384359285,
0.0158408191,
0.0666375682,
0.0303331763,
0.0098207127,
0.0206992943,
-0.0175001938,
-0.0064169806,
0.0106411353,
0.024318438,
-0.026712738,
-0.0467795357,
-0.0482665524,
-0.0032639238,
0.0010140354,
0.0709986314,
0.048105862,
0.0521201454,
-0.0313562043,
-0.0013366689,
0.0511370711,
0.00623998,
0.0352480076,
-0.007097214,
0.0570139289,
-0.0291087124,
-0.0128234597,
-0.0139566064,
-0.0103797587,
0.0753225684,
0.0520154946,
0.0107333539,
0.0206340738,
0.0073714443,
-0.0463235229,
-0.030847827,
-0.0201379787,
-0.0179193858,
-0.0296812914,
-0.0142256478,
0.0566206016,
0.0022621111,
-0.0611157753,
0.0034489699,
0.0246299077,
-0.0332142748,
0.0170824956,
-0.0605260022,
-0.0156859979,
0.0864804238,
0.0855831951,
0.0022972352,
-0.0335663892,
0.0030830689,
0.0265949946,
0.0682549775,
0.0299759321,
0.0038807814,
0.0199164767,
-0.0667537227,
-0.0786432996,
0.0130093861,
0.0078506218,
-0.0154983252,
-0.0186266378,
0.0106375208,
-0.0048304615,
-0.010216305,
-0.0364114344,
0.0443482883,
-0.0178112146,
-0.0009306319,
-0.0385243893,
0.0229428802,
0.0098466426,
-0.000737756,
-0.0337453298,
0.0082236594,
0.0104269795,
-0.0041181473,
-0.0197025575,
0.02835696,
-0.0437929854,
-0.0356656127,
0.0175000969,
-0.0516203046,
0.0158931836,
0.0060647549,
-0.037616808,
-0.0183274858,
-0.0391676538,
-0.0636446625,
-0.0017004126,
-0.0483999103,
0.0284034498,
0.0596098751,
0.0092078634,
-0.0103464546,
0.0491084643,
-0.01164148,
0.0046483134,
0.0158296004,
-0.0055975863,
-0.0045130765,
-0.0462371558,
-0.0349447727,
0.0272468347,
0.0122776544,
0.0232146513,
0.0039697629,
0.0201558694,
-0.0082054548,
-0.0298132338,
-0.061641831,
-0.0268472638,
0.0141083151,
-0.0262279324,
0.0278550815,
0.0136950044,
0.0216646697,
-0.029557813,
-0.0467189215,
-0.0278076734,
0.0709716156,
0.0179007947,
0.0509876087,
0.011733002,
0.0200167093,
-0.0444885232,
-0.0263959225,
0.0067929891,
0.0362684503,
0.0539426506,
-0.0379353352,
-0.0290080383,
0.0256572701,
-0.0449714549,
-0.0023227967,
0.006471544,
-0.0540418215,
0.0262376182,
-0.0268817674,
-0.0269488916,
0.0493066572,
0.0118992636,
0.0311355107,
0.0165462736,
-0.012002877,
-0.0118269706,
-0.0034758958,
-0.0293318536,
-0.0436674319,
0.0182500444,
-0.0433878787,
-0.0302634705,
0.0277244076,
-0.0044411137,
0.0434191562,
-0.0442189425,
-0.021808397,
-0.0198798217,
-0.0196389835,
-0.0317469649,
-0.0158389434,
0.0064956187,
0.03277459,
-0.0304689463,
-0.0460897461,
0.0601641275,
-0.0163976643,
-0.0184662435,
-0.0383876264,
0.019637337,
-0.0304928944,
0.0532159097,
0.0248554572,
0.0611345842,
0.0068087201,
-0.0134837031,
-0.0280504972,
-0.0005062003,
0.0268607829,
-0.0611433983,
-0.0220007524,
-0.0120223043,
0.013881607,
-0.0340688266,
-0.016301645,
-0.013090739,
-0.0053433501,
0.0218035243,
-0.0037922843,
-0.0245153569,
0.0006035459,
-0.071060285,
0.0784551576,
0.0137789715,
0.0268344991,
-0.0197482537,
-0.0195378214,
-0.0199006628,
0.0556398556,
0.0330288336,
0.0224515647,
-0.0477320887,
-0.0686755776,
-0.0050500138,
0.0592963696,
-0.0368213952,
0.0362796523,
-0.0451903045,
0.0114156846,
-0.0053027715,
0.0616046228,
0.0064841178,
0.0021345979,
0.0558698326,
-0.058926478,
-0.0218540598,
0.0627455488,
0.0182653368,
-0.0346628912,
-0.0349598676,
0.0240889266,
-0.0091149388,
0.0042445688,
-0.0008929919,
-0.0132115996,
-0.0171709247,
-0.0160744935,
0.0174472108,
-0.0033605641,
0.0167019106,
-0.0148177007,
-0.0379309133,
0.0678683072,
0.0073367758,
-0.041188892,
-0.0659237206,
-0.0080294199,
0.0170640517,
-0.0157805365,
-0.0096860398,
0.0015106496,
0.0004912788,
-0.0126486691,
0.0337372683,
-0.0027911121,
-0.0649606586,
-0.0171709601,
-0.0504512303,
-0.0261320099,
0.0724685714,
0.034059044,
-0.0206427686,
-0.0339690223,
-0.0359565355,
0.0680550933,
0.0048166276,
0.023323074,
0.1036448181,
-0.0022156967,
-0.0249059964,
-0.0381419323,
0.0222809426,
0.0065549524,
0.0089529874,
-0.0469133742,
0.0108962646,
-0.0284243897,
0.0047005438,
-0.0657767504,
0.0423147902,
-0.0050091832,
0.0172671191,
-0.0033876363,
0.0043483526,
-0.0289836638,
-0.0108081084,
0.0727475807,
-0.048889786,
-0.0317105129,
0.0361623503,
-0.060692165,
-0.0691616088,
-0.0608800724,
-0.0437751897,
0.0346573777,
0.033262942,
-0.0263785888,
-0.0224421639,
-0.0256977379,
-0.0218118802,
-0.0512163453,
0.0457697511,
0.0142073007,
0.0060562058,
-0.0296497177,
-0.0249490291,
0.0370634049,
-0.0062719863,
-0.0007330998,
0.0523845144,
-0.0628103912,
0.0202208944,
-0.0331557281,
0.0733849108,
0.0231470745,
-0.0107992506,
-0.0004955158,
-0.0273650046,
0.0835224837,
0.0471875928,
-0.0330497809,
0.0213629827,
-0.0096964156,
-0.0740678236,
-0.04546123,
-0.0014053715,
-0.034475062,
0.0037415642,
-0.0065605021,
0.0362196416,
-0.0050164415,
-0.0495019779,
0.0333432592,
0.0036310919,
0.0026838463,
-0.0407315493,
-0.000398304,
-0.0196581818,
-0.0138890669,
-0.0378281847,
-0.0084289378,
-0.047348015,
0.0178854205,
0.0170508865,
0.0081155105,
0.0100178532,
0.0167541206,
-0.0242189672,
-0.0103484839,
-0.0545450225,
0.0338160284,
0.0251177549,
-0.0407732055,
0.0300370306,
0.0209298804,
-0.0245226566,
-0.0319057815,
-0.0165158734,
0.0018952111,
-0.0025836583,
0.0498302467,
0.0189159829,
0.0516762473,
0.0079540601,
0.0515810438,
0.020313682,
-0.0368108824,
-0.0770133212,
0.0228248592,
0.0437915996,
0.0320849903,
0.0256855655,
-0.0209148042,
-0.0072912164,
-0.0195845086,
0.0771336555,
0.0176821258,
-0.001493806,
0.0628045872,
-0.0058354954,
0.0380186774,
-0.035816025,
0.0815973654,
-0.0016869287,
0.0310013257,
-0.037437249,
-0.0419371389,
-0.0548992828,
-0.0174188074,
0.050391227,
-0.0183921047,
-0.0157434996,
0.0091723716,
-0.013699661,
-0.0648551732,
0.0043442259,
0.0088652065,
-0.0386584774,
-0.004881836,
0.0705395266,
0.0566773415,
-0.0006949968,
-0.0227955952,
-0.006195466,
0.0076445555,
-0.0132742543,
-0.0096890302,
0.0436352119,
-5.853405344e-33,
-0.0288744178,
-0.0294528008,
0.0406805836,
-0.0480782092,
-0.0139594758,
0.0470141508,
-0.0326761417,
-0.0069017652,
0.0226071011,
0.0004398176,
0.0237969905,
-0.0251263566,
0.0163068511,
0.0458377749,
-0.007927496,
0.0214851741,
0.0264395755,
-0.0201186817,
-0.0177552868,
0.0082754949,
-0.0163751282,
0.0140472464,
0.0551907793,
-0.0806771964,
-0.0184109192,
0.0302489419,
-0.0388977937,
-0.0226933733,
0.0353648588,
0.0620617941,
-0.0582135171,
0.0157841239,
0.0056088492,
-0.0481967442,
-0.0139893144,
0.0252793524,
-0.0586366057,
0.0183178931,
0.0030751757,
0.0258052722,
-0.0775079429,
0.0059085782,
0.0451127328,
-0.0447957814,
0.036577262,
-0.0408422872,
0.0559284724,
-0.0134943211,
0.0052698576,
-0.0162844826,
-0.0391679294,
0.0533724912,
-0.0098383259,
-0.0497044139,
0.0224574264,
0.01689055,
-0.0077060582,
0.0378312655,
-0.0397115834,
0.0116186831,
0.0519375503,
0.0276059322,
0.0552319661,
0.0139521016,
-0.0309194531,
0.0476649962,
0.0450080633,
-0.0525357127,
0.0046952856,
0.0621421747,
-0.0243614726,
0.0639276952,
0.0281159692,
0.0626843274,
0.0033507659,
0.026617758,
-0.0501081944,
0.0579346307,
-0.069252044,
0.0820748582,
0.0425429493,
-0.0000640487,
-0.0216949042,
0.0105376178,
0.0067955642,
-0.0269235522,
-0.0332420096,
-0.0302068125,
0.0454444624,
0.0405780561,
-0.0059767072,
0.0421036854,
0.0471007191,
0.017604379,
0.011005274,
-0.0220115427,
0.0065203691,
0.0526744798,
-0.0369152725,
-0.0052566766,
0.0190972518,
-0.0172548369,
0.066415675,
0.0169579331,
0.0206607934,
0.0130442148,
0.0318439454,
0.0580155402,
-0.0440814383,
0.0140538197,
-0.000953131,
-0.0181611981,
-0.0209847428,
0.045142442,
0.0317001045,
-0.0077427658,
-0.0462601073,
0.036166355,
-0.0209506545,
0.0145522049,
-0.0448809639,
-0.0978497937,
0.0227279961,
0.0114404783,
-0.0483371578,
-0.001779356,
-0.0357013717,
-0.0522992164,
0.0642258972,
-0.0260255132,
-0.0193547066,
0.0301303547,
2.674e-7,
0.0570164919,
0.0231273156,
0.029813081,
-0.0110545168,
0.0119012948,
0.0060735922,
-0.0348809771,
0.041099865,
0.0121965595,
-0.0356070139,
0.0197401568,
0.0143939806,
0.0226033591,
0.0265141781,
-0.0203364603,
-0.0101552522,
-0.0509756319,
-0.007442391,
-0.0178548675,
-0.0182542466,
0.0686986148,
0.0926664248,
-0.0541890785,
-0.0612931177,
0.0141593721,
-0.0275133457,
0.074402146,
0.0062849461,
-0.0112304045,
-0.0050469758,
0.0076174461,
0.025385607,
-0.0030958883,
0.0364373736,
0.0108257774,
-0.0434156209,
0.0658072457,
0.0711697862,
-0.0652500167,
-0.0007261007,
0.0285716299,
0.0303577445,
-0.0222166907,
-0.0421677493,
0.0383668132,
-0.0178615488,
-0.0117498422,
-0.0134779885,
-0.0374646075,
0.037444111,
0.0529655106,
-0.0661541745,
-0.0415174589,
0.0516325645,
0.0390773155,
0.0164339598,
-0.0501796976,
-0.0691190884,
-0.0248910449,
-0.0083665419,
-0.0288400594,
-0.0340751857,
0.0040337243,
-0.0349466987,
0.0067102183,
-0.034014605,
-0.0221751668,
2.243663542e-34,
0.0213648751,
0.0138306664,
-0.0153097892,
-0.0172172915,
0.0129197221,
-0.0094015216,
-0.0208717454,
0.021799555,
-0.0052909735,
-0.0388855636,
-0.0265968144
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13657v1 | Efficient Transformer Knowledge Distillation: A Performance Review | 2023-11-22T19:19:37 | 2023-11-22T19:19:37 | Nathan Brown, Ashton Williamson, Tahj Anderson, Logan Lawrence | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | As pretrained transformer language models continue to achieve
state-of-the-art performance, the Natural Language Processing community has
pushed for advances in model compression and efficient attention mechanisms to
address high computational requirements and limited input sequence length.
Despite these separate efforts, no investigation has been done into the
intersection of these two fields. In this work, we provide an evaluation of
model compression via knowledge distillation on efficient attention
transformers. We provide cost-performance trade-offs for the compression of
state-of-the-art efficient attention architectures and the gains made in
performance in comparison to their full attention counterparts. Furthermore, we
introduce a new long-context Named Entity Recognition dataset, GONERD, to train
and test the performance of NER models on long sequences. We find that
distilled efficient attention transformers can preserve a significant amount of
original model performance, preserving up to 98.6% across short-context tasks
(GLUE, SQUAD, CoNLL-2003), up to 94.6% across long-context
Question-and-Answering tasks (HotpotQA, TriviaQA), and up to 98.8% on
long-context Named Entity Recognition (GONERD), while decreasing inference
times by up to 57.8%. We find that, for most models on most tasks, performing
knowledge distillation is an effective method to yield high-performing
efficient attention models with low costs. | [
0.0180223398,
0.0554532409,
-0.0006747665,
0.0361087322,
-0.0091797393,
0.0207346845,
-0.0034513518,
-0.0098600946,
-0.0409530811,
-0.0213769618,
-0.023278188,
-0.0218866765,
0.0135409767,
0.0068209991,
0.0223561767,
-0.0186348762,
0.0309132673,
-0.0247978289,
0.0222116262,
0.0316164382,
-0.0171667524,
-0.0060745645,
0.0099198231,
0.040589191,
0.0170697756,
-0.010186322,
-0.0398153141,
-0.0089434832,
0.0114698317,
-0.0277612321,
0.0193489883,
0.0624765046,
0.0085428273,
0.0067176502,
0.0000020654,
-0.0260127336,
-0.0152883707,
-0.005346999,
-0.0659964904,
-0.017714167,
0.0138539132,
-0.0111741694,
0.0392354764,
0.0090664849,
-0.0096942773,
-0.0151875475,
0.0361627415,
0.0711148083,
0.0428004526,
0.0693252012,
0.0011659377,
-0.0306620616,
0.0348864682,
-0.0557131693,
0.0052741845,
-0.0241932385,
0.0089564025,
-0.043914929,
-0.0286279414,
0.0127580604,
-0.0249162465,
0.0403358974,
0.0486142561,
0.0302553903,
-0.0013456476,
0.0416178331,
-0.0559904277,
-0.0229212753,
-0.008118229,
0.0816067979,
-0.048634436,
-0.0129014906,
0.0123499343,
0.0147553794,
-0.0021476424,
-0.0373159163,
-0.0386710353,
-0.0013537202,
-0.0038127969,
-0.005015763,
0.0175311733,
-0.0042011905,
0.0131453043,
-0.0157721043,
-0.0540524609,
0.0192068014,
0.0229200441,
-0.0294315238,
0.0057474156,
-0.0055883606,
-0.045625411,
-0.0707459748,
0.0138194254,
0.0466210321,
0.0103909364,
0.0063626473,
-0.0557209216,
-0.0281849299,
0.0021309801,
0.00426113,
0.012902664,
0.0512353778,
0.0111115025,
0.0370404758,
-0.0370615572,
0.0900396109,
-0.0148280049,
0.0146739902,
-0.0170233697,
-0.0292666536,
-0.0350944921,
0.0019532742,
-0.0353074074,
0.0425621606,
-0.0621601418,
-0.0342267603,
0.0015269347,
0.0177129526,
0.0110625774,
-0.0156701803,
0.0614029914,
0.0163437985,
-0.024316689,
0.0103019346,
-0.0244027767,
0.0790058598,
-0.0345079154,
-0.0029955814,
0.0259303562,
-0.0560940988,
-0.0543296523,
0.0003642052,
0.0254071895,
-0.0364599042,
0.0067965304,
0.0386854373,
-0.0041441168,
-0.0916458294,
-0.0247249268,
-0.0124860415,
-0.0271062423,
-0.0763390958,
0.0155657651,
-0.0498780571,
0.0603696108,
-0.0010117048,
-0.0044958098,
-0.0561495125,
0.0105055459,
0.0233919546,
-0.0342379734,
0.0493090637,
0.016258439,
0.0060906471,
-0.011946558,
0.0162597783,
0.0159933362,
0.0551579371,
0.019359123,
0.0117032053,
-0.0078933025,
-0.0305859447,
-0.0117774103,
-0.0030756656,
0.0523472503,
-0.0080937129,
0.0133663602,
0.016457798,
-0.0358326025,
-0.0092625758,
0.0579026602,
0.0544975623,
-0.0217929967,
-0.0369098634,
0.0612743869,
0.0304308832,
0.0469970703,
0.0174270365,
0.0123121403,
0.0079097301,
-0.0244674925,
-0.0017460516,
-0.0877074525,
0.0480816774,
0.0027461434,
0.0251734164,
0.0296028759,
0.0617973097,
-0.0406181067,
-0.0189474039,
0.0142365582,
-0.0005788311,
0.0136344442,
0.0339452624,
0.0253823157,
0.0385679379,
-0.0599482395,
0.1306837201,
0.0245917626,
-0.0522783324,
-0.010066485,
-0.042427212,
0.0092868563,
0.0340352058,
0.0158153102,
0.0000378578,
-0.0535568371,
-0.0305434093,
-0.0116663408,
0.0319645964,
0.00088249,
0.0162129607,
0.0535571426,
-0.0336460322,
-0.0154106468,
-0.0301934164,
0.0093191769,
-0.007294754,
0.058436241,
0.0290098749,
0.0329144262,
-0.0384164788,
0.0159555841,
0.0290073194,
-0.0355167203,
-0.0454844572,
-0.0235909522,
0.0260317978,
0.030641377,
0.0112769939,
-0.0003341232,
0.0046716388,
0.0520237461,
-0.0339039266,
-0.0171893165,
-0.0239484794,
-0.0544276498,
-0.0903401524,
0.0126441568,
-0.0206018463,
0.0085071167,
0.0611414462,
-0.0252293348,
-0.0457354486,
-0.0279526822,
-0.0260923933,
0.0470853336,
-0.0119527187,
0.0450521521,
0.0335396007,
0.0390904546,
-0.0115162153,
0.0568799227,
-0.0571367182,
0.0202125404,
0.0243937578,
-0.0226666797,
-0.0332949013,
-0.010402659,
-0.0498233624,
0.0075812656,
-0.0151579725,
-0.0275181923,
0.0234703962,
-0.024043262,
-0.0210441705,
-0.0273607112,
-0.0630135983,
0.0226899888,
-0.0497474596,
0.0422722362,
0.0128495609,
0.0483799875,
0.0180441849,
-0.0012916289,
-0.0169886369,
0.0032153577,
-0.0111339549,
0.0227501113,
-0.0062243259,
-0.0056141648,
-0.0098680425,
-0.0127876922,
-0.0284257755,
0.0134293176,
0.0628930107,
-0.0347602926,
-0.0078755431,
-0.047462333,
0.02367213,
-0.0202265847,
0.0206024665,
-0.0224131979,
-0.0160068292,
-0.0142510431,
0.0156351123,
0.0497839972,
0.051999893,
0.0040234718,
0.0159497429,
-0.0002269714,
-0.0021727746,
-0.0450588092,
0.0488204695,
-0.0394364037,
0.0161560271,
-0.0294202771,
-0.0193797909,
0.0198843274,
0.1154644191,
-0.0481175072,
0.0026498933,
-0.0506569333,
-0.0275519639,
0.0253480524,
-0.0387481153,
-0.0050803446,
0.0142736603,
-0.0202845074,
-0.0034464353,
-0.05019949,
-0.0143416468,
0.0580260493,
-0.0380930193,
-0.0189771075,
-0.0262536835,
-0.0004899825,
-0.0315209217,
0.0586985499,
0.0255183037,
0.0082381405,
0.0198935419,
-0.0355453491,
-0.0351099893,
0.0176619962,
-0.0293164216,
-0.0220305324,
0.0963470042,
0.0078018289,
0.0053802705,
-0.0134654799,
-0.0328931473,
-0.0394657515,
-0.0032805356,
-0.0245898422,
0.0344689228,
0.0406831577,
-0.0110912351,
-0.0522844568,
0.0375829227,
0.0159174222,
0.0653891265,
-0.0005431633,
0.0049038627,
-0.0343136564,
0.057230141,
0.0558408946,
0.0409407914,
0.0306266043,
-0.0098541612,
0.0160624869,
0.0697909817,
0.0163794141,
-0.0060673831,
-0.0147015126,
-0.0155123612,
0.0138082067,
-0.0463456549,
0.0019962743,
0.0134871453,
0.0387897454,
-0.0704369769,
-0.0105067128,
0.1060000882,
-0.0033025437,
-0.0230084006,
0.0002955595,
0.0372597538,
0.0524818935,
0.0344410054,
-0.0015506366,
-0.0792114064,
-0.0642703846,
0.0174624398,
0.0069658295,
0.0348588675,
-0.0501636863,
-0.0110777617,
-0.0990326479,
-0.0156020671,
-0.0282895248,
-0.0446625128,
-0.0323086679,
-0.0432284996,
0.0079371147,
-0.0136883669,
0.0058049606,
0.0079718092,
-0.0128701879,
-0.0075373682,
0.0031425527,
-0.0036106475,
-0.0483659506,
0.0293845125,
-0.0212992951,
0.0285217874,
0.0138157755,
0.0133140143,
0.0185201075,
-0.0471927226,
0.0030695687,
-0.0390937068,
0.0203615334,
0.0048915502,
0.0665528923,
-0.044920586,
-0.0091338502,
-0.0066390266,
0.0026991402,
-0.0510580465,
-0.0142229889,
-0.0099362703,
0.0582359545,
-0.0022281508,
-0.0331222229,
-0.0018217093,
-0.0348969139,
0.0133700762,
0.0958073139,
0.0590981618,
-0.0103349136,
-0.053125266,
0.0192498788,
-0.0093827657,
-0.0260015316,
-0.0170166101,
0.0090868222,
0.0245375074,
-0.0543041192,
-0.0319114476,
-0.0457970165,
0.0363253616,
0.020853417,
-0.0114370473,
-0.0194841605,
0.0275319107,
0.0240298975,
-0.080292359,
0.0354677737,
-0.0235837922,
0.001140025,
-0.0627200902,
0.0191812068,
0.000903264,
0.0256277639,
-0.0289129894,
0.017334424,
-0.1379671395,
-0.0450216345,
0.0096273497,
0.0508917533,
0.0154013783,
0.0579691306,
0.0000182451,
-0.028441079,
0.0273017716,
0.0061834883,
-0.0596009009,
0.0270195473,
0.0060113105,
-0.0170860719,
0.0012149066,
0.040987093,
-0.0186676476,
0.0202795342,
0.0188641306,
0.0624308214,
-0.0334962383,
-0.0532975718,
-0.0018240699,
0.0042967736,
0.0416327454,
0.0140855424,
0.0285985824,
0.0010710934,
0.0496792272,
0.0385580026,
0.0227928907,
-0.0484291017,
-0.020866029,
0.0211847275,
0.0120262997,
0.0176923964,
0.061355643,
0.0177986771,
-0.0096039316,
-0.050744608,
0.010063028,
-0.006001865,
-0.0081799375,
0.0319256894,
0.0019560053,
-0.0209151506,
-0.0006380805,
0.0280256029,
0.0357498564,
-0.0328644812,
0.0373444557,
0.0131588867,
0.0186333302,
-0.0255064368,
0.0232628621,
-0.0699796304,
-0.0350585021,
-0.0091331657,
-0.0048181093,
0.0229396354,
-0.0003868326,
0.0457107164,
0.0159473717,
-0.0117051518,
-0.0144638298,
0.0107866619,
-0.0130021228,
0.0100074382,
0.0353474095,
0.0300336592,
-0.0012133258,
-0.0109183174,
0.0951787978,
-0.0027576408,
0.0333217792,
0.0147966873,
-0.0036273845,
-0.0434894711,
-0.0436857864,
-0.0180463996,
-0.0049786763,
0.0024257763,
0.0078947572,
-0.0204443578,
-0.0664810017,
0.0215011388,
-0.0506156497,
-0.0111113898,
-0.0307617709,
0.0565228909,
0.0208676718,
0.0001461151,
-0.0686761066,
-0.008017512,
-0.0021263778,
-0.0133754881,
-0.0133008361,
0.0080531435,
-6.536096096e-33,
-0.0065826206,
0.0006329986,
0.0233444255,
-0.0280134175,
-0.0605390929,
0.0217538495,
-0.0549805574,
-0.0223399643,
-0.0281122979,
-0.0094173932,
-0.0243200921,
0.0367876664,
0.0129630361,
0.0516212434,
-0.0325599574,
-0.0493413471,
0.0900762603,
0.0237863678,
-0.0450368598,
0.0347214527,
0.0290330183,
0.060857635,
0.0556022152,
-0.0158093963,
-0.0201760773,
0.0010811831,
0.0484162122,
-0.0046236916,
0.0404278375,
0.0549283624,
-0.0243781768,
0.0322118849,
0.0226805191,
-0.113094978,
-0.0321889818,
0.0413095839,
-0.1496175677,
-0.0243980922,
-0.005142916,
-0.019447593,
-0.0393717736,
-0.0423922762,
0.0557540841,
0.0241569784,
0.0496848524,
-0.0397030264,
0.0079061715,
0.0082582664,
-0.0343642645,
-0.0297734793,
-0.0429829955,
0.009526236,
-0.0182498414,
-0.0203364957,
0.0290286578,
0.0398609415,
0.0001790298,
0.0310368445,
-0.0911352783,
-0.0168992803,
0.0288439505,
0.0560413338,
0.0468017831,
0.0241431464,
-0.0111525934,
0.0231955666,
-0.0094750952,
0.0055921925,
-0.0427475609,
-0.017479606,
0.022847591,
0.0584525578,
0.0146048907,
-0.0020497327,
0.0642698929,
-0.0131106758,
-0.0441931523,
-0.0114177112,
-0.0194771048,
0.0795902386,
0.013445206,
-0.0182993449,
-0.0177251119,
-0.0070652794,
-0.0385782793,
0.0253026839,
-0.0401906557,
-0.0048657679,
0.053599,
0.0447468385,
-0.0307617504,
0.0132768191,
0.052349139,
-0.0367573127,
0.0254658051,
0.0697308034,
0.025934035,
-0.0003199083,
0.0111464579,
0.0157175362,
-0.0817378536,
0.0146818506,
0.025538262,
0.0143833859,
0.0058230404,
-0.0173298158,
0.0342419706,
0.0223710351,
-0.0800319463,
-0.0212063901,
-0.0414003469,
0.0289441813,
-0.0189843178,
0.0407560468,
0.0495816544,
0.0194336101,
-0.0081494236,
0.017654961,
0.0086387601,
-0.0139341233,
-0.0225073192,
0.0271602143,
0.0571296588,
0.0363289155,
-0.0088503137,
-0.0133687425,
-0.0356298871,
0.0230994094,
0.0011644805,
-0.0625294223,
-0.0195395947,
0.0466967039,
2.713e-7,
0.0227719154,
-0.0043012532,
0.0248413906,
0.0009794879,
-0.0040747798,
-0.0048719603,
0.0420168787,
0.0366942659,
0.0037434741,
-0.0192089882,
-0.0124876043,
0.0413308218,
0.0296708904,
0.0014197013,
-0.1086142212,
-0.0516403876,
-0.0481600203,
0.000845523,
-0.0272762068,
-0.015316125,
0.0299069304,
0.1135020405,
-0.0091105914,
-0.0009693343,
-0.001956834,
-0.0095506283,
0.0271633342,
0.0011653625,
0.0439979136,
0.0213075243,
0.0207347739,
0.0288932566,
-0.0217761286,
0.0253152996,
-0.0096287541,
0.0330967456,
-0.0141198598,
0.0901105925,
-0.0010330819,
-0.0655825585,
-0.0100179492,
-0.0191634409,
-0.0131967384,
-0.0522323251,
0.0831790492,
-0.0791928545,
-0.0122525319,
0.0016786873,
-0.0436107703,
-0.0035692898,
-0.0000725342,
0.0290727671,
0.0178359635,
0.017148653,
0.0175573602,
-0.0090108402,
-0.0134355556,
-0.1072862223,
-0.0050301733,
0.0116177155,
-0.0332670212,
-0.0279570855,
-0.0600977987,
-0.0664976835,
0.0305260178,
-0.0396543965,
-0.0172619727,
2.613251823e-34,
-0.0018438844,
0.0118770003,
0.0068767224,
0.0422313549,
0.0093766861,
-0.0445550047,
-0.0381664075,
-0.0294150766,
0.0032439951,
-0.1191889346,
-0.0185102336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13647v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13647v1 | Language Model Inversion | 2023-11-22T19:04:04 | 2023-11-22T19:04:04 | John X. Morris, Wenting Zhao, Justin T. Chiu, Vitaly Shmatikov, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models produce a distribution over the next token; can we use this
information to recover the prompt tokens? We consider the problem of language
model inversion and show that next-token probabilities contain a surprising
amount of information about the preceding text. Often we can recover the text
in cases where it is hidden from the user, motivating a method for recovering
unknown prompts given only the model's current distribution output. We consider
a variety of model access scenarios, and show how even without predictions for
every token in the vocabulary we can recover the probability vector through
search. On Llama-2 7b, our inversion method reconstructs prompts with a BLEU of
$59$ and token-level F1 of $78$ and recovers $27\%$ of prompts exactly. Code
for reproducing all experiments is available at
http://github.com/jxmorris12/vec2text. | [
0.0329749547,
0.0459402241,
-0.0109441085,
0.0738290101,
-0.047340855,
-0.0399387293,
-0.0274627656,
0.0457384773,
-0.0192679465,
-0.0149870375,
-0.0103082061,
-0.0413797647,
0.0096367076,
0.0598467551,
0.029846061,
-0.031582132,
0.0291456394,
-0.0581493713,
-0.008611477,
-0.0036339671,
-0.040707998,
-0.0234903414,
0.0098285591,
0.0444568321,
0.0031728644,
0.0144425528,
-0.0275937747,
0.0312388614,
-0.0005557873,
-0.0033721621,
-0.0407709554,
0.0084534762,
-0.0095229615,
0.0273005702,
0.0000019278,
-0.0289674047,
-0.0533629321,
-0.004682757,
-0.0808110163,
0.0238379985,
0.0186578408,
0.0547147281,
-0.0507770628,
0.0274386387,
0.0038445005,
0.0440448821,
0.0431616083,
0.0112467799,
0.0346306004,
0.0330892019,
0.0174235459,
0.0108661782,
0.0230626427,
-0.0129049653,
0.04212185,
-0.0447803847,
0.0198230073,
-0.0864059106,
0.0147799291,
0.0495829545,
0.010939735,
0.0397831798,
0.0257115606,
-0.0410813093,
-0.0537179857,
0.0225102622,
0.0359024443,
-0.0250283722,
-0.0527728945,
0.0015199154,
0.0022056492,
-0.0166414939,
0.0049033589,
0.0112539642,
0.0116888732,
-0.0041940724,
-0.04136388,
0.0298992265,
0.0032702782,
0.0092567569,
0.0300436877,
-0.0171877593,
0.0087808063,
-0.0398334302,
-0.0285885539,
0.121168837,
0.0505088232,
-0.0032063746,
-0.0404254869,
-0.0426371619,
0.0149408756,
-0.0465484932,
0.0301350635,
0.0278779343,
-0.0300976373,
0.0282118563,
-0.0079634199,
-0.028255038,
0.01822716,
0.0025154594,
0.0429402515,
0.0577790067,
-0.0512952507,
0.027046388,
-0.0266697519,
0.039227277,
-0.0373272039,
0.0520154946,
-0.0381036289,
0.0149398698,
0.0329025276,
-0.0449988209,
-0.0531118624,
0.0293871686,
-0.0612542033,
0.0074283793,
0.0063595423,
0.0315822288,
0.0461712778,
0.0037638696,
-0.0399598256,
0.0058612935,
-0.0445685424,
-0.0077580381,
-0.0086349444,
-0.01802429,
-0.0090601044,
-0.0113662817,
0.0248580165,
-0.0592594706,
-0.0329172872,
-0.0025428422,
-0.0122253699,
-0.024590157,
-0.0198826082,
0.0992532372,
-0.005262149,
-0.025711054,
-0.0283444021,
-0.038982477,
-0.0336713493,
-0.0171255805,
0.0162778515,
-0.06965556,
-0.007253102,
0.0122060031,
-0.0003319149,
-0.0159368552,
0.0274175648,
0.0198337622,
-0.0202113744,
0.089398846,
0.0019243634,
-0.0221304893,
0.0130552379,
0.0075110062,
-0.0098226583,
0.0163500011,
-0.0425884612,
0.0857308358,
0.0474244431,
-0.0035421061,
0.0298186131,
0.0609992631,
0.0360227674,
0.0189926922,
-0.0341856889,
-0.0149101457,
0.0512578897,
-0.0097928494,
0.0344095826,
0.0764895529,
-0.0120301479,
-0.0202929806,
0.0119543178,
0.0944856405,
-0.0328512825,
-0.0309787076,
0.0165149607,
-0.0447788127,
-0.0336908847,
0.0659966543,
-0.0457920469,
-0.0087842345,
-0.0603412837,
0.0009546275,
0.0443634838,
-0.0199705679,
-0.002873831,
-0.008866122,
0.0217642821,
-0.0304717943,
-0.0341701582,
-0.0450192355,
0.0568880253,
0.0333253182,
-0.0268459916,
0.0515141934,
0.0452780724,
-0.0460123271,
-0.0095092235,
-0.1063001156,
0.0211547501,
0.0380971953,
0.0528530516,
-0.0353093371,
0.0358160585,
0.0307502244,
-0.0147267841,
0.0286456738,
-0.0030387496,
0.0083252741,
-0.0045522954,
0.0185254849,
0.0041366676,
0.024134323,
0.0266331378,
0.0664458498,
-0.0422866829,
-0.0153225129,
0.008548907,
-0.0228181295,
0.0316147916,
0.0216451846,
-0.0492577963,
-0.0214730371,
-0.001353796,
0.0130964657,
0.0199817531,
0.0190175716,
0.0054648677,
0.0513110496,
0.0651369914,
-0.0412756763,
-0.0114007154,
-0.0206323508,
-0.05936132,
-0.0344996639,
0.0445225649,
-0.0045564012,
0.0288864523,
0.0334169641,
0.0121822357,
-0.0394445397,
0.026243832,
-0.0301664919,
0.0952794179,
-0.0279200599,
0.0384357348,
0.0115012228,
-0.0153039619,
-0.0278520342,
0.0446518548,
-0.0335193835,
0.0489314385,
0.0030183436,
-0.0118535776,
-0.0029803864,
-0.0705608949,
-0.0066836616,
0.0090915756,
-0.0484287739,
-0.0060721659,
0.0215901118,
0.0118451416,
-0.0069389907,
-0.0130126439,
-0.048337914,
-0.0180757102,
-0.0364129618,
0.0271274727,
0.0449061394,
0.0349713005,
-0.017334545,
-0.0455983914,
-0.0122376764,
-0.0204506237,
0.0141679281,
0.0225515254,
0.0311558936,
0.0191978551,
-0.0596413501,
-0.0525925569,
-0.0229379702,
-0.0164693147,
0.0465287194,
-0.0442380533,
-0.0407671668,
-0.0756649151,
0.0576672107,
0.0269265752,
0.0284609515,
-0.03397163,
-0.0430798754,
0.0286887232,
-0.026172094,
0.0342840031,
0.0137703652,
0.0149430754,
0.0695082247,
-0.0005436647,
-0.0001194683,
-0.0465662926,
-0.0244324952,
-0.0102113457,
-0.050948251,
-0.0223552454,
-0.04368563,
0.0152885402,
0.0640338957,
0.0111131649,
0.0053163934,
-0.0266662631,
0.0012288406,
-0.009749053,
-0.0390805118,
-0.0350040905,
-0.0193465147,
-0.0721032247,
0.0772357807,
-0.001395314,
-0.0583563,
0.0387307294,
-0.0619465224,
0.0185172763,
-0.0096828239,
0.0011945493,
0.0300456602,
0.0668962821,
-0.0072855041,
0.0486570485,
0.0355727375,
-0.0742038414,
-0.0338790752,
0.0058496734,
-0.0260992143,
-0.0270445049,
0.0105293849,
-0.0119134784,
0.0075621284,
-0.0109224245,
-0.0627116263,
-0.0246825498,
-0.067377612,
0.0096443295,
-0.0084978566,
0.0234544165,
-0.0095475558,
-0.0372755639,
0.0065833451,
0.0381629579,
0.0197301991,
-0.0159447286,
0.0041370522,
-0.027587872,
0.0446247831,
0.0328681841,
-0.0359989777,
0.0061417515,
-0.0328700952,
-0.0102762152,
0.0572774522,
0.0701794326,
0.0257695466,
0.0518280491,
-0.0399168991,
0.05062088,
-0.0085432837,
-0.0314134061,
0.0475588515,
0.0342000835,
0.0058159549,
-0.0440039076,
0.0607678629,
0.0280137733,
-0.0538338684,
0.0084485225,
-0.0573609173,
-0.0030561755,
-0.0003454004,
0.0117396237,
-0.0867116749,
-0.0025517072,
0.0599425584,
0.0424544625,
-0.0248127952,
-0.0291451626,
-0.005554345,
-0.1109028906,
0.0099352514,
-0.0040676123,
-0.0205237791,
-0.0536842719,
-0.0592169464,
0.0149845174,
0.0477024131,
0.0371080302,
0.0522934496,
0.0101865288,
0.012100338,
0.0099686412,
0.0381056815,
0.0182402413,
0.0322755575,
0.0136342701,
0.032334324,
0.0876976252,
0.0161820501,
-0.0072018262,
0.0097940834,
0.0172482561,
-0.0222937223,
0.0190387834,
0.0163873453,
0.0345839709,
0.0190845355,
-0.0139935603,
0.0037034196,
0.0433316641,
-0.0221546702,
-0.023878159,
0.0122426897,
0.0233859234,
-0.0177649017,
0.006153909,
0.0024203828,
-0.035822738,
0.0296866149,
0.0435253866,
0.0480264165,
-0.0393054001,
0.008550996,
-0.0860288292,
0.0624788702,
0.0109741325,
-0.0142514659,
-0.0274692066,
0.0260878168,
-0.0222036876,
-0.0466376767,
0.0117494687,
-0.0176572278,
0.1091927812,
0.0041294498,
0.0040235762,
-0.0362092033,
-0.0342778713,
0.0045094783,
-0.045609761,
-0.0745467767,
0.0373419784,
-0.106624417,
0.0123755168,
-0.0091207456,
-0.0396502651,
-0.0639069602,
0.0077252178,
-0.03986644,
-0.0740248561,
0.0660161674,
0.0451875366,
0.038098719,
-0.0053723557,
-0.0237212721,
-0.0369195081,
0.0577752329,
0.0424449444,
-0.0361203738,
0.027075991,
0.0022225552,
0.0200039279,
-0.0047515705,
0.0274993572,
-0.0415228233,
-0.0191201363,
0.0437893309,
0.0173508711,
0.0066721579,
-0.0570183918,
0.0230225436,
0.0614159964,
0.0662422478,
-0.0077448762,
-0.0530386791,
0.0007892723,
0.0494325794,
-0.0421422422,
-0.0185954031,
-0.0061548776,
0.0085032294,
0.0084540779,
-0.0232178848,
0.0348720327,
-0.0811649412,
-0.0017547917,
0.0598448627,
-0.0142450128,
-0.0036814546,
0.0728549883,
0.0425701067,
0.0678446442,
-0.0183168277,
0.0172379762,
0.0304984562,
0.019619057,
0.0772932842,
-0.0248932987,
0.0110741667,
0.0044231606,
-0.0472364426,
-0.0377501361,
0.0503191464,
-0.0896832794,
-0.0476476066,
-0.0071589043,
0.0613773689,
0.0358800739,
0.015018966,
-0.0182193983,
-0.0118315183,
0.0042417576,
-0.0313842669,
-0.0042933845,
0.0296425261,
-0.0351160578,
0.0180149395,
0.003937569,
-0.0105471397,
0.0178072583,
0.0523090251,
0.0187749024,
0.0458114408,
0.004842313,
0.0012619988,
-0.0291835703,
0.0185631681,
0.0168037377,
0.0271546319,
-0.0105993357,
-0.0355919972,
-0.0297582094,
-0.0472511724,
0.017640451,
0.014330525,
-0.0014226199,
0.0175516922,
-0.0021865673,
0.0747664869,
0.0098554865,
-0.0169610288,
-0.0316567719,
0.032329049,
0.0349046029,
-0.054261867,
0.0054516545,
-6.079746047e-33,
-0.056612622,
-0.0386848077,
-0.04071014,
0.0023544752,
0.0392917953,
-0.007890583,
-0.0498606637,
0.0065157223,
-0.0009569313,
-0.0272754729,
-0.0604940765,
-0.0182387605,
0.04500347,
0.0147062289,
-0.0298409425,
0.0053521297,
0.0304033291,
0.0024170708,
-0.0500219688,
0.0180738401,
0.092459701,
0.0535182208,
0.0621097386,
0.0038177548,
0.0246837698,
-0.0172813367,
0.0108306874,
0.0357700549,
-0.0038982765,
0.0367256664,
-0.0251487978,
0.0073808138,
-0.0000311431,
-0.0202445146,
-0.020028159,
0.0288345795,
-0.0159195717,
-0.0246380232,
0.0279390421,
-0.0063123968,
0.0146732517,
-0.0406072326,
-0.0068870634,
-0.0209323224,
-0.0316720568,
0.0422693454,
-0.0045165648,
0.013541149,
-0.0067786314,
0.0267254338,
-0.0326443799,
-0.0111088501,
0.0094611757,
-0.0350981392,
0.0213459898,
-0.0059767365,
0.0377532132,
-0.0538340062,
-0.0242575817,
0.0391491428,
0.017331047,
0.0467261076,
0.047890462,
0.0427451506,
-0.0348615721,
0.0387611687,
0.0476612076,
-0.0315966196,
-0.0276246481,
-0.0332139358,
0.0016710877,
-0.0082357954,
-0.0219154451,
-0.0041674455,
0.0054832418,
-0.0624357872,
-0.0155190583,
0.0223105885,
0.0131915053,
0.0167037752,
0.0616403073,
0.0303279348,
-0.0366591476,
-0.0148247471,
-0.0517234057,
-0.0414323211,
-0.0090570869,
-0.0207314212,
0.0200040806,
-0.0135815358,
-0.0269771926,
-0.0792075619,
0.0476526394,
-0.0358259939,
-0.0545656271,
0.0244549681,
0.0141929314,
0.0197853073,
-0.0448046029,
0.0442980714,
-0.0203299653,
-0.0037506081,
0.0207877364,
0.0028376826,
-0.0220245011,
0.0084262276,
-0.0218559131,
0.0318601914,
-0.0820338279,
0.0105951689,
-0.0380947851,
-0.0006154656,
0.0289547388,
0.0111533357,
0.0666017607,
-0.0305241663,
0.0046392493,
-0.0042590941,
0.0272919536,
-0.0104556493,
-0.0147146322,
0.0127168773,
-0.0165552944,
0.0055377209,
-0.0541837104,
0.0007935812,
-0.0402440019,
0.0639291629,
0.0379668064,
0.0055947402,
0.0067435764,
-0.0025810455,
2.663e-7,
0.0505508743,
-0.0117776692,
0.0611791834,
-0.0052002692,
0.0195948463,
0.0423091091,
-0.0198043883,
0.0270106588,
0.0189907365,
-0.0244793817,
-0.0197269153,
-0.0395431891,
-0.002328346,
-0.0006771988,
-0.0923170522,
0.0152107487,
-0.0650883839,
-0.0040570842,
-0.0241719075,
-0.0167885199,
0.0349853598,
0.1089651287,
0.0024336046,
-0.0201550499,
0.0117869014,
-0.0392613932,
-0.0067521022,
-0.0232924651,
-0.0217845123,
-0.0266257096,
0.0155399758,
0.0103849489,
0.0219343994,
-0.0104567558,
0.004483969,
0.0096464911,
0.0045647942,
0.0242811795,
-0.0000974073,
-0.0494594984,
-0.012273076,
-0.0054212036,
0.0032380456,
-0.0561636649,
0.0220548902,
0.0398550518,
-0.0110374168,
-0.0495187491,
-0.0254230108,
-0.0015919066,
-0.0294468999,
-0.0232205074,
-0.0117309354,
0.0333848707,
-0.0153525788,
0.0408563204,
-0.0070805224,
-0.06043607,
-0.0390541628,
-0.0378938392,
-0.0335040838,
-0.0549764037,
-0.0544199385,
0.0233342536,
-0.0187524706,
-0.0864559114,
0.0166669823,
2.738579036e-34,
-0.0084179025,
0.0019951509,
-0.0057255416,
0.0428962745,
0.0310243163,
-0.0093517257,
0.0620711781,
0.043457225,
0.0068057142,
-0.0592645667,
-0.047971148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13628v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13628v2 | Prompt Risk Control: A Rigorous Framework for Responsible Deployment of Large Language Models | 2023-11-22T18:50:47 | 2024-03-27T20:20:22 | Thomas P. Zollo, Todd Morrill, Zhun Deng, Jake C. Snell, Toniann Pitassi, Richard Zemel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The recent explosion in the capabilities of large language models has led to
a wave of interest in how best to prompt a model to perform a given task. While
it may be tempting to simply choose a prompt based on average performance on a
validation set, this can lead to a deployment where unexpectedly poor responses
are generated, especially for the worst-off users. To mitigate this prospect,
we propose Prompt Risk Control, a lightweight framework for selecting a prompt
based on rigorous upper bounds on families of informative risk measures. We
offer methods for producing bounds on a diverse set of metrics, including
quantities that measure worst-case responses and disparities in generation
quality across the population of users. In addition, we extend the underlying
statistical bounding techniques to accommodate the possibility of distribution
shifts in deployment. Experiments on applications such as open-ended chat,
medical question summarization, and code generation highlight how such a
framework can foster responsible deployment by reducing the risk of the worst
outcomes. | [
0.012619853,
0.0482260659,
0.0043413816,
-0.0190636329,
-0.0238122847,
0.0009140236,
-0.0040891487,
0.0020591228,
0.007530428,
-0.005574794,
0.0279850084,
-0.0631363019,
-0.0074555348,
0.0604885668,
0.0140503226,
-0.0376570411,
0.0390409082,
-0.0334088467,
0.0066069197,
-0.0132729094,
0.0005046133,
-0.0120222541,
0.00973331,
0.0832528248,
0.0298754442,
-0.0145085286,
0.0369901285,
0.0323049761,
-0.0147759467,
-0.03286599,
0.0025908612,
0.0522002205,
-0.0221905094,
0.0231453292,
0.0000020787,
-0.0607785024,
-0.0131402826,
0.020054305,
-0.0432058722,
-0.0035106828,
0.0447811224,
-0.009419797,
-0.0361072272,
0.058233887,
-0.0184307806,
0.0250839498,
0.0641891956,
-0.0247945935,
0.037644133,
0.0436218046,
-0.0005619515,
0.0457572937,
0.0285456795,
-0.0144657707,
0.004943856,
-0.0546157919,
-0.0071814782,
-0.008596546,
0.0108159995,
-0.0001883847,
-0.0128179146,
0.0432045311,
0.032761015,
-0.0231122859,
0.000135407,
0.0468791276,
-0.0251764823,
-0.0418891273,
-0.022750413,
0.040242523,
0.0034199895,
0.0021523256,
-0.0124733392,
-0.030634908,
0.0144066075,
-0.0045300736,
-0.0372381806,
0.0253877547,
-0.0104520749,
0.0004113115,
-0.0271856841,
0.0029795482,
0.0185335763,
-0.0026239015,
-0.012361207,
0.0582339056,
0.0100365281,
-0.0144580305,
-0.0050422666,
0.0051083756,
-0.0175423454,
-0.0400289893,
-0.0076651587,
0.030051263,
-0.0680573583,
0.0047292816,
-0.0414252728,
-0.0397170261,
0.0564790592,
-0.0360479988,
0.034690246,
0.0131486813,
0.0096957367,
0.0359927304,
0.0049593821,
0.0339995883,
0.0122505836,
-0.0093554864,
-0.005192183,
0.0267124586,
-0.0023648599,
-0.0091939382,
-0.0262500644,
-0.0041737896,
-0.0219453704,
0.0022171072,
-0.0503214262,
0.081079565,
-0.0051895208,
0.0416985527,
0.0106575862,
-0.0058685914,
-0.0929709077,
-0.0045533404,
0.0042595705,
0.0003705976,
-0.0422176421,
-0.022222219,
0.0439024903,
-0.0888099298,
0.0150057925,
0.0083630551,
-0.0234617312,
-0.0251701102,
-0.0218878742,
0.0757538527,
0.011522878,
0.0027100982,
0.008698239,
-0.0669041947,
-0.0418389812,
-0.001274618,
-0.0552403033,
-0.0750699341,
-0.0358418897,
0.0213156808,
-0.0046848129,
-0.0402934216,
-0.0185983423,
0.0010711512,
-0.0245525241,
0.034183111,
-0.0247480981,
0.0279324092,
0.0023583418,
0.0271925814,
-0.0185621735,
0.0907224864,
0.0253118556,
0.0218199305,
0.0485138148,
-0.0014627767,
0.0370814092,
0.0342094898,
0.024408374,
0.0630914345,
0.0063319276,
0.0127713932,
0.0546409413,
-0.0065177418,
-0.0085396403,
0.0772724152,
-0.0108404635,
0.0011898465,
0.0712138638,
0.0405032672,
-0.0202107169,
-0.0328510776,
0.0405372046,
0.0168024991,
-0.0364077576,
-0.0043031252,
-0.042200774,
0.019453574,
-0.0386025682,
0.01677089,
0.0304378755,
0.0255396646,
-0.0271030646,
-0.028858263,
-0.0100453645,
-0.0094614839,
-0.0027226505,
0.0082497234,
0.0225416292,
-0.0011122272,
-0.0104635786,
0.0511459,
0.0163791534,
-0.0480072647,
0.0162054785,
-0.0797256753,
-0.0067472532,
0.0604979135,
0.0582208447,
-0.0377533734,
-0.0075416933,
0.001454315,
0.0299914125,
-0.0051277052,
0.079671897,
-0.0015469749,
0.0206959508,
-0.0114142057,
-0.0153737459,
0.0478360578,
0.0071761957,
0.0029891713,
0.0231068879,
0.031259831,
-0.0084356787,
-0.022179855,
-0.0614163056,
0.0344410278,
-0.0232442021,
-0.0407060385,
-0.0084526269,
0.0045995717,
0.0434495173,
-0.0190070737,
-0.0349871255,
0.0244152322,
0.0124248536,
0.0205978565,
-0.0190641303,
-0.0107066538,
-0.0153096206,
0.0032016193,
0.0218443479,
-0.0275206082,
0.0233507622,
0.0022672846,
-0.0271393862,
-0.0062371418,
0.0152393216,
-0.0330774412,
0.0244577359,
-0.0090198964,
0.0255510509,
-0.0134385405,
-0.0135343773,
-0.0350952446,
0.0153221767,
-0.0178839564,
0.0326391459,
0.012597899,
-0.0218824372,
-0.0156385899,
-0.0416324288,
-0.0541084856,
0.0069078123,
-0.0374156944,
0.0294678789,
0.0650582761,
0.0494769141,
-0.0132970633,
-0.0429075509,
-0.1032549813,
-0.0053219348,
-0.0292544477,
0.0178088583,
0.0151551142,
0.0402492732,
-0.016370425,
-0.0136182168,
-0.0520506985,
-0.0390409343,
0.0183784086,
0.0732014626,
0.0340139829,
0.0239079073,
-0.0304692201,
-0.0369122662,
-0.029887544,
0.0055755321,
0.0517707765,
0.0233594123,
-0.0105126565,
-0.0373396277,
0.0395753756,
-0.0405914858,
0.0097105587,
-0.0021525284,
-0.0532167964,
0.0209374633,
-0.0179108661,
0.0558374114,
0.0594957434,
0.0262818374,
0.0238617714,
0.0539648309,
0.0307604112,
-0.0648472309,
-0.0169765875,
-0.0490548164,
-0.0808474347,
-0.0080072498,
-0.0652120486,
0.0595671907,
0.0380554646,
-0.0002077606,
-0.0449785851,
-0.0707903504,
0.0079202168,
-0.0638379455,
-0.0346941836,
-0.0145178456,
-0.009139658,
-0.0355597138,
0.0767533183,
-0.024179019,
-0.0856884867,
0.0710299164,
-0.0083070779,
0.0291592237,
-0.037552923,
-0.0196439773,
-0.0116094062,
0.023612339,
0.0047527035,
0.0458751731,
0.0180731509,
-0.0230341051,
-0.0655407012,
-0.0093624294,
0.0427886546,
-0.0357556827,
0.0265552867,
-0.0348147862,
0.0038757862,
-0.0253939964,
-0.0518792272,
0.0113411378,
-0.0869416371,
0.0063241404,
-0.0225341972,
0.0479970798,
-0.010269762,
0.0214922857,
0.00232283,
0.0134465052,
0.0393818505,
-0.0088634118,
-0.0482777692,
-0.0117954984,
-0.0105964029,
0.0288442187,
-0.0473102033,
0.0214931481,
-0.0614545681,
0.0234640334,
0.0699405149,
0.0663449466,
0.021189481,
-0.0129863862,
-0.0176497139,
0.0505864136,
-0.0139973676,
-0.0279930551,
0.0962465107,
0.1024080366,
-0.0181460287,
0.0042892485,
0.0831242204,
0.0252401177,
-0.0330140255,
0.024967676,
-0.0193816647,
0.1108519211,
0.047478728,
0.0332150497,
-0.0702526793,
0.002709422,
0.0243596844,
0.0780914202,
-0.0298159514,
-0.02263101,
-0.0086553469,
-0.0814494118,
0.0378813893,
-0.0013489099,
-0.0360223241,
-0.0210234877,
-0.0250966772,
-0.0050407853,
-0.0211518295,
0.0083682649,
0.005617619,
-0.0031506463,
-0.0094718076,
0.0342496112,
-0.0746531934,
-0.0566316731,
0.0215463992,
-0.0574189313,
0.057847891,
0.0846522078,
-0.0065965201,
0.0023880922,
0.0133792236,
0.0189803131,
0.0078730118,
-0.001185985,
0.0230565462,
0.0788572356,
0.028986197,
-0.0003487589,
-0.0147926463,
0.0019323515,
-0.0190532897,
0.0011453282,
0.0024478191,
0.0406770259,
0.0023890778,
-0.02754407,
-0.0239693206,
0.0181208085,
0.04786513,
0.0595303029,
0.0482855402,
-0.0588121638,
-0.0230462123,
-0.0567019507,
0.0228937902,
-0.0336017385,
0.0011640433,
-0.0106175439,
-0.0162852332,
-0.0617333762,
-0.0870812014,
-0.0101211164,
-0.0091962758,
0.063850753,
0.0228309166,
-0.0279866867,
-0.014378502,
0.0133227576,
0.0021637501,
0.0260769352,
-0.0319496617,
0.016927572,
-0.0853503868,
0.034453094,
-0.0200703908,
-0.0042258049,
-0.0288389679,
0.0091965366,
-0.0538352579,
-0.0904157832,
0.0110194497,
0.0575364754,
0.0456198007,
0.0011845171,
-0.0233288668,
-0.0762177557,
0.0568916723,
0.0467201248,
-0.0222837366,
0.0203690343,
0.0400163718,
-0.0193300303,
-0.0086845504,
0.0279355329,
-0.07731767,
-0.0104199359,
-0.0109187551,
0.0148126846,
-0.0118656754,
-0.0525654219,
0.0125099458,
0.0329717919,
-0.0001978875,
-0.0230936967,
-0.0343408957,
-0.008176594,
-0.005762198,
0.0133716483,
-0.0114700599,
-0.034574654,
0.0245045461,
-0.001233971,
-0.0222500674,
0.0032686316,
0.0232860632,
-0.0075697065,
0.0270829052,
-0.038161099,
0.009529124,
0.018790802,
0.0174215492,
0.0897110105,
0.0149387121,
-0.0307635907,
-0.0076412079,
-0.0201878492,
0.0224733558,
0.0142999198,
0.0255750306,
-0.0047591333,
0.017564334,
0.0417987034,
0.0346724764,
-0.0847338289,
-0.0932095647,
-0.0141599076,
0.0284480136,
0.008600899,
0.0657686815,
0.0304160826,
-0.0229294486,
-0.0027337633,
-0.0467691682,
0.0382233635,
0.0204623137,
-0.0598022677,
-0.0061533814,
0.0048478441,
-0.0047125174,
-0.0210641939,
0.1016927063,
-0.0100125046,
0.0230576396,
-0.0471893288,
-0.0445633419,
-0.0238918774,
-0.018718835,
0.0138424719,
0.0124390721,
-0.0072118444,
-0.0123072611,
-0.0952453911,
-0.0722688884,
-0.0131094139,
0.0373390801,
0.0235030986,
0.0023723987,
0.0129599813,
0.0665287077,
0.0148522947,
0.027820291,
-0.0401501171,
-0.0254376773,
-0.0343763009,
0.0105501274,
-0.0043545202,
-6.757603313e-33,
-0.0226743426,
0.0038056972,
-0.0364853367,
-0.0071709012,
-0.0003122134,
0.0101035377,
-0.0361182578,
0.0143547738,
0.0037617527,
-0.015325346,
-0.0159611516,
0.0044622035,
0.0160745643,
0.0159071591,
0.0001037695,
-0.004346773,
0.0169408061,
-0.0137843555,
-0.0701232627,
0.0456134789,
0.0376367234,
0.0008429094,
-0.0112817483,
-0.0110804047,
0.0535072684,
0.0212958083,
0.0036108796,
0.0199502092,
0.0329034887,
0.0618577041,
0.0258298572,
0.0555590838,
0.0036687404,
-0.056336239,
-0.0314159133,
0.0139497453,
0.0022448045,
-0.0248896014,
-0.0095349373,
-0.0199469514,
-0.0243526325,
-0.0388855301,
0.027051108,
-0.02636954,
-0.0370868556,
-0.0209824704,
0.0368435308,
-0.0013964006,
-0.0442023166,
-0.0607477054,
-0.0147319855,
0.0175710116,
-0.0248521026,
0.0074162944,
-0.0273207109,
0.070386216,
0.0036412533,
0.0123513788,
0.0320231989,
0.0276185349,
0.0421913341,
0.055292353,
0.0758269131,
0.0039979117,
-0.0132087888,
0.0426337533,
0.0017456335,
0.0352891423,
0.00845771,
-0.0474718511,
0.0074678003,
-0.0171489324,
0.0226080399,
0.0444450863,
0.0158111379,
-0.0097530121,
-0.0619692616,
0.0391936563,
0.0103702955,
-0.0075102928,
0.0450765267,
0.0007133856,
-0.1033117473,
-0.0503856912,
-0.0542200729,
-0.0000436954,
-0.0204998143,
-0.0320200585,
0.0457581915,
0.0021620491,
-0.0447184034,
-0.0380069129,
0.0401124917,
-0.0147893969,
-0.0092307376,
0.0044482551,
-0.0027696355,
0.0248516873,
-0.0283811372,
0.0541231371,
-0.0056075868,
0.0131834485,
0.0117020747,
-0.0085923104,
0.0274863392,
0.0228541736,
0.0469734073,
0.0370199829,
-0.0871671289,
0.0136307878,
-0.0197603237,
0.0546654314,
0.0118523203,
0.0397366397,
0.0435741656,
-0.0350862183,
0.001736106,
0.0374955684,
0.0037078876,
-0.0132363588,
-0.0373410061,
0.0062010582,
-0.0128366873,
-0.0115903085,
-0.0348688215,
0.0015881129,
-0.0394023582,
0.0605496839,
0.0471672304,
-0.0149357701,
-0.0458307154,
-0.0280323159,
2.851e-7,
0.0526185781,
0.0232181046,
0.0079964874,
0.0397431292,
0.0045959274,
0.0247410331,
0.0066139111,
0.0413268693,
0.0244393125,
0.0029453868,
-0.008146558,
0.0122413384,
0.0414745696,
0.0449946672,
-0.0839300826,
-0.0212728232,
-0.1053578258,
0.0450636446,
-0.0411307737,
-0.0184239056,
0.0664023086,
0.0644824058,
-0.0302707888,
-0.005714403,
0.0180939231,
-0.0492653437,
0.0207602307,
-0.0529177673,
0.0268173553,
0.0303323623,
0.0425546356,
0.0157196131,
0.0247081872,
0.0153671652,
-0.0375137292,
-0.0499925911,
-0.0292635169,
0.0662613958,
0.0249427147,
0.0009410036,
0.0197611712,
-0.0260523632,
0.0082658706,
-0.0643504187,
0.0546645299,
-0.0469968617,
-0.0184699576,
-0.0165645834,
-0.008205031,
-0.0735525116,
0.0134875225,
-0.0371145979,
-0.0062151724,
-0.0146020502,
-0.0164203215,
0.0087079899,
0.0045850342,
-0.0470538922,
-0.036850065,
-0.0072438503,
0.0003998635,
-0.120529294,
-0.0285123363,
0.037866734,
-0.0177901257,
-0.0604622029,
0.0260143317,
3.144504556e-34,
0.0316142626,
-0.0164609589,
0.0388775133,
-0.036590714,
0.0220217668,
0.000911127,
0.0156243164,
-0.0137643954,
0.0492662303,
-0.0347430445,
-0.0316715576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13581v1 | PaSS: Parallel Speculative Sampling | 2023-11-22T18:37:27 | 2023-11-22T18:37:27 | Giovanni Monea, Armand Joulin, Edouard Grave | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scaling the size of language models to tens of billions of parameters has led
to impressive performance on a wide range of tasks. At generation, these models
are used auto-regressively, requiring a forward pass for each generated token,
and thus reading the full set of parameters from memory. This memory access
forms the primary bottleneck for generation and it worsens as the model size
increases. Moreover, executing a forward pass for multiple tokens in parallel
often takes nearly the same time as it does for just one token. These two
observations lead to the development of speculative sampling, where a second
smaller model is used to draft a few tokens, that are then validated or
rejected using a single forward pass of the large model. Unfortunately, this
method requires two models that share the same tokenizer and thus limits its
adoption. As an alternative, we propose to use parallel decoding as a way to
draft multiple tokens from a single model with no computational cost, nor the
need for a second model. Our approach only requires an additional input token
that marks the words that will be generated simultaneously. We show promising
performance (up to $30\%$ speed-up) while requiring only as few as $O(d_{emb})$
additional parameters. | [
0.0292859077,
0.0694544539,
-0.0043185302,
-0.0107225021,
-0.042531658,
-0.0003975695,
0.0050596674,
0.021364551,
-0.0609493442,
-0.0468742959,
0.0267320462,
-0.0903412551,
-0.0227403324,
0.0202252325,
0.0028531835,
-0.030855773,
0.0350407958,
-0.0734268054,
0.0347341821,
-0.0344263799,
-0.0344083682,
0.0450991057,
0.0141137065,
0.0389170125,
-0.0260254536,
-0.0160017516,
-0.0258975141,
-0.001645801,
-0.0499652661,
-0.012796971,
-0.0328650475,
0.0551417172,
-0.0025670212,
0.0372807086,
0.0000021044,
-0.0127865532,
-0.0424364842,
0.0107888328,
-0.0282032546,
0.0617258139,
0.0857495517,
-0.0058148177,
-0.0364135094,
0.0402188115,
-0.001641491,
-0.0346664153,
0.0383763053,
-0.0001661317,
0.0104879057,
0.0216262769,
-0.0008680489,
0.0130526926,
0.0121653285,
0.0134119615,
-0.0621032715,
-0.0088295648,
0.0216171201,
-0.0156259425,
-0.0050606867,
0.005261587,
0.0016276371,
0.0086504109,
0.0234834198,
-0.0198661517,
-0.0111907525,
0.0264270026,
-0.024494186,
-0.02541635,
-0.030241264,
0.0260854643,
-0.0861455202,
-0.0650615022,
-0.0041934438,
-0.0037473587,
-0.0287637413,
0.0092747519,
-0.0299352147,
0.0473478176,
-0.034635976,
0.0363330841,
0.0582769774,
-0.0177014507,
0.0531272478,
-0.0180102382,
-0.0438737236,
0.0594107807,
0.0574474148,
-0.0075347084,
-0.0418752022,
-0.000413123,
-0.0152481599,
-0.0702065453,
0.0321397595,
-0.0181352831,
-0.0544801429,
0.0102989376,
-0.0875031352,
-0.0514931753,
0.0408381782,
-0.0243973844,
0.0489355065,
0.0279681832,
0.0212063901,
0.0193443764,
-0.0233214851,
-0.0242400859,
-0.018910341,
0.0186433326,
-0.0267673656,
-0.0351616293,
0.0068164212,
0.0000169492,
-0.0895937085,
0.046916537,
-0.0554497764,
-0.0331386551,
-0.0079147387,
0.0191128738,
0.0221065246,
-0.0201450922,
0.0101073403,
-0.025479611,
-0.0157094505,
0.014192271,
0.0525108613,
-0.0136302775,
-0.0447144732,
-0.0200772025,
-0.0045897118,
-0.085701324,
-0.0058703623,
-0.0013436268,
0.0258864444,
-0.0191351902,
-0.0152181052,
0.0582663976,
0.0069872248,
-0.0272197369,
-0.0226800684,
-0.0521210581,
0.0072988817,
-0.0297540426,
-0.0083576748,
-0.0889336765,
0.0156023465,
0.0173089411,
-0.0019564929,
0.0001911502,
-0.0106393872,
0.027525669,
-0.0293213967,
0.0499104112,
-0.015605499,
-0.0015358657,
0.0146109061,
-0.0037761847,
0.0002169408,
0.0964769274,
0.0302173197,
0.050810989,
0.0439588428,
-0.0030541904,
0.0054091648,
0.0705007911,
0.0144480802,
0.0174499396,
-0.0249221083,
-0.0382970236,
0.0500966907,
-0.0036221158,
0.0184339769,
0.1121731028,
-0.0593817569,
0.0000126005,
0.0312432796,
0.0641647056,
-0.0038619451,
0.0113827558,
0.0688167736,
0.0229568537,
0.0104268556,
-0.0195949152,
-0.0191150084,
-0.0074576307,
0.0081561795,
0.0147974836,
0.0717398375,
0.0463012941,
-0.0142633794,
0.0144761344,
-0.0115762819,
0.000497268,
-0.0100593669,
-0.0140567021,
0.0869963542,
0.0184986256,
-0.0527011864,
0.0616296567,
0.0391000845,
-0.0646837503,
-0.0107976813,
-0.034759745,
0.021454636,
0.0527032912,
0.0688610002,
0.0405397154,
0.0261200517,
0.0045831511,
-0.0108887758,
0.0402207673,
0.0763998106,
-0.0288152862,
0.025371749,
-0.0268484987,
-0.0035212557,
0.0411624089,
0.0094675822,
0.0478547737,
0.0467339829,
0.0294620153,
-0.0016650256,
-0.0102915205,
-0.0306909494,
0.0123349857,
0.0022974727,
-0.0046089124,
0.0158544593,
-0.0179992933,
0.0517222695,
0.0254768804,
-0.0029621164,
0.0330992229,
0.040684294,
-0.0262313411,
0.0062460275,
-0.0142289391,
-0.0292200204,
0.0063188304,
0.0390766673,
0.010630779,
0.0043984898,
0.0176866315,
0.0064227758,
-0.0530993678,
0.0374617167,
-0.0264785439,
0.0800021291,
-0.0291497651,
0.0476814955,
-0.0296109337,
0.0225442015,
0.0113750575,
-0.0040965062,
-0.0077249529,
0.0103680734,
0.0077012712,
0.0175140928,
0.0161266737,
-0.0421641171,
-0.0627220348,
0.0125107206,
0.0071054404,
0.0146571454,
0.0067871534,
0.0030604515,
-0.0166651122,
-0.0057989643,
-0.0935603902,
-0.002370378,
-0.027699396,
0.0156564191,
0.0091417842,
0.0291235689,
0.0072396775,
0.0018858423,
-0.0001034048,
-0.0377032906,
-0.000761432,
0.0276516769,
-0.013757254,
-0.0089000976,
-0.0802723765,
0.0225644335,
-0.0334980451,
-0.0037049397,
0.0631622151,
0.0057692942,
-0.0125035672,
-0.0680631474,
-0.0302806366,
0.0409622565,
0.0253631845,
0.0312106833,
-0.0272518545,
0.0270414725,
-0.0625549555,
0.0141352899,
-0.0140568111,
0.0062618633,
-0.0004103182,
0.0201753154,
-0.0058629983,
-0.0403987356,
-0.0110220071,
-0.0034417771,
0.0265210774,
-0.001321048,
-0.0476857871,
0.0005552653,
0.0556609817,
0.010943925,
-0.0200547725,
-0.0416274294,
0.0198725723,
-0.0084306858,
-0.052970361,
-0.0019452377,
-0.0221724026,
-0.0323982649,
0.0299589876,
-0.021202622,
-0.061665576,
0.0394702703,
-0.0794432685,
0.0077118594,
-0.0220421907,
0.00702482,
0.0260581132,
0.0554300472,
-0.0245271605,
0.0228920095,
-0.0055956943,
-0.0344785452,
0.0324240848,
0.0248358473,
-0.0098470179,
-0.0376520045,
0.024161322,
-0.0391131379,
0.0266607199,
-0.0039338553,
-0.039353773,
-0.0361285508,
-0.0406383015,
-0.038492512,
0.0426265076,
0.0610287301,
-0.0421984829,
-0.0101301288,
0.0227847937,
-0.0500818454,
0.0474696942,
-0.0061923559,
0.0138034839,
-0.0016028216,
0.0012436144,
0.042036742,
-0.0517108776,
0.0183726475,
-0.0407816917,
0.0270998143,
0.0773908421,
0.0998756364,
0.0107519357,
-0.0496653095,
0.0001426953,
0.0435566977,
-0.0281194318,
0.025261458,
0.0243003126,
0.0445484221,
-0.0292755049,
-0.0414719097,
0.1200499833,
0.0217508059,
-0.0369236805,
0.0256256163,
0.013399954,
0.0415881313,
-0.0170130953,
0.0109057669,
-0.0637181848,
-0.0164718423,
0.0531869419,
0.0244236551,
-0.0214026291,
-0.0035366239,
-0.007391389,
-0.1192206219,
0.0517621413,
0.0214876067,
-0.042560149,
0.0046869707,
-0.0238265041,
-0.0460139737,
0.0452012196,
0.0431075692,
0.0292575825,
0.0225155354,
-0.001130986,
0.0211649463,
0.0278268382,
0.0108550172,
0.0513025485,
-0.0418526419,
0.0599142089,
-0.0152881984,
-0.0058167907,
0.0231537167,
-0.0108168479,
0.0153185399,
-0.0078431573,
-0.0398832709,
-0.0221957806,
-0.001302266,
-0.0018421108,
-0.0178479236,
0.0321035907,
0.0133004598,
-0.0576249026,
-0.0254972037,
-0.0294779837,
0.0561852679,
-0.0056994865,
-0.0128006442,
-0.0116531616,
-0.025796093,
0.0264617875,
0.0614497885,
0.0210732874,
-0.0380960219,
-0.0377955996,
-0.043900758,
-0.0530394614,
-0.1099346131,
0.0272321962,
-0.0162924659,
-0.0092332624,
-0.0324533992,
-0.0420910008,
0.0303664375,
0.0487875864,
0.0712644607,
-0.0008553814,
0.0326260105,
0.0274199732,
-0.0356470644,
-0.0582931042,
-0.0097743329,
-0.0592169873,
0.0161703248,
-0.0661229417,
-0.0240087919,
-0.0006206891,
0.0006645202,
-0.0418475568,
0.0486492477,
-0.109723568,
-0.0691392347,
0.0333707333,
0.0345447138,
0.0252065323,
0.0183330085,
-0.0432137512,
-0.0473752171,
0.0512671955,
-0.0017389335,
-0.0687119365,
-0.0170195606,
0.0044117509,
-0.0206341781,
0.009119316,
0.0183254573,
-0.0354101583,
-0.0035623142,
0.0202175099,
0.0084750382,
0.0062399507,
-0.0192652103,
0.0104822442,
0.063418597,
0.0117651299,
-0.0308516212,
0.025854174,
0.0134397559,
0.0303715095,
-0.0443341658,
0.0011269246,
-0.0432591289,
0.0420594737,
-0.0071094222,
-0.054027617,
-0.0245290715,
-0.0473280661,
0.0141210509,
0.0266596135,
0.0269093756,
-0.0113515658,
-0.0372955203,
0.0314882584,
0.0640409738,
-0.0503375828,
-0.0070071965,
-0.0125432294,
0.019159859,
0.0066815373,
-0.0501535721,
-0.0165228173,
0.0076527451,
0.0141561562,
-0.033666838,
0.0067807147,
-0.0560111031,
-0.068807967,
-0.0401338451,
0.0500591956,
0.0451349802,
0.0136488667,
0.0411352105,
-0.0238337182,
-0.0042640958,
-0.0365170464,
0.0168159939,
0.0054125283,
-0.0323725007,
0.0236443859,
0.0167614035,
-0.031958621,
0.0095257768,
0.0694578066,
0.0172996726,
0.0411453992,
0.0167255737,
-0.022411244,
-0.0378396697,
-0.0079651363,
-0.0259090345,
0.0334929451,
-0.0607984886,
-0.0295690279,
-0.0175343398,
-0.0451437421,
0.0328861959,
0.032138586,
0.0114351427,
0.0219937582,
0.0310908128,
0.0521562025,
0.0043540592,
-0.0061712414,
-0.0479675122,
0.0292549711,
0.0407693088,
-0.0354739204,
0.0121872714,
-6.508685037e-33,
0.0096392008,
-0.0085726641,
-0.0089142043,
-0.0525050834,
0.0070743747,
-0.0104041379,
-0.016384108,
-0.0248942561,
0.037330132,
0.0124917449,
-0.0238705128,
0.0161791332,
0.0454446115,
0.0471773259,
0.0328026488,
0.0260890815,
0.078017965,
-0.026857283,
-0.0163840204,
0.0354527198,
0.0559025295,
0.0268755071,
0.0128839146,
0.0161536839,
-0.0114341462,
-0.0237079971,
-0.0034106183,
-0.033732906,
-0.0104915434,
0.0609131418,
-0.0000144268,
0.0348360389,
0.0070936787,
-0.0651550367,
-0.0415408984,
0.0154225156,
-0.0849275738,
0.0030289167,
0.0233740862,
0.0174987875,
-0.0157343354,
-0.0317483693,
-0.0107092634,
0.0131129129,
-0.0027657787,
0.0418961458,
-0.0569880456,
0.0037638999,
-0.0523640029,
-0.0316525772,
-0.0036514204,
0.0186124239,
0.0145014282,
0.0473173745,
0.0706759915,
-0.0100252144,
-0.0168344937,
0.0043061175,
-0.0117681157,
0.0271695796,
-0.0108243367,
0.0354628116,
0.0519382097,
0.0060848696,
-0.0000249837,
0.0449346192,
0.020014381,
-0.0400882103,
0.0030837881,
0.0248361137,
0.0132332165,
0.0158093348,
-0.0003724152,
0.0241120439,
0.0692432374,
-0.0556599535,
-0.0416676179,
0.0010147556,
0.048257824,
0.0030330736,
0.0711652189,
-0.0073749097,
-0.0217400622,
-0.0434891582,
-0.0618206486,
-0.0456029326,
-0.0434284061,
-0.0156988241,
0.037309438,
0.0313695185,
-0.0472726934,
-0.0004732861,
0.052471444,
-0.0384189337,
-0.0411343612,
0.0014248001,
-0.0027747038,
0.0115029337,
-0.0312720314,
0.0160652343,
0.0163324419,
-0.0497212857,
0.0214574412,
-0.0227008909,
-0.0099405684,
0.0100493999,
-0.0064295614,
-0.007282787,
-0.081847094,
0.0160616543,
-0.0400929861,
0.0474660769,
0.0186372083,
0.0445534028,
0.0605543926,
0.0015265199,
0.0330600142,
-0.0095202066,
0.005844871,
-0.0089161387,
-0.0132053234,
0.0309896786,
0.0081517948,
0.034815222,
-0.0223215129,
0.0060505033,
-0.0649044067,
0.0046935142,
0.0663114786,
-0.0404715277,
-0.0227319188,
0.0417493246,
2.665e-7,
0.0218663588,
0.0478968173,
0.0603752173,
-0.0026872896,
0.0296297334,
0.0056245276,
0.0185889937,
0.0227032285,
-0.0077663017,
0.0351611897,
-0.0257854406,
0.0010684684,
0.0344979204,
0.0329377428,
-0.1305336803,
-0.0155972512,
-0.0452682897,
0.0362679623,
-0.0368896201,
-0.0117969047,
-0.0150571717,
0.1135931239,
0.0103195384,
-0.0345204771,
-0.0014800219,
-0.0542680547,
0.0039684214,
-0.0002083448,
-0.0263195951,
0.0199711602,
-0.0016440162,
0.0046327626,
0.0123862047,
0.0335363038,
-0.0254447628,
0.0038367452,
0.0038456896,
0.0624010675,
0.003606739,
-0.0063456381,
0.0312759392,
-0.0518141016,
-0.0227755215,
-0.0313231125,
0.0444603711,
0.0150590977,
-0.0048257778,
-0.0648467243,
-0.0033809473,
0.0026511231,
-0.0485742316,
0.0052917567,
-0.0016186002,
0.0581176504,
0.0349267498,
0.0083098672,
0.0254175272,
-0.0552195907,
-0.0213556346,
-0.0559760667,
-0.0629505143,
-0.0608761981,
-0.0204602405,
-0.0056759869,
0.0309487116,
-0.0602944866,
-0.0005292302,
2.752234056e-34,
0.0856619924,
-0.0021221803,
0.002099684,
0.0586737357,
0.0026519096,
-0.0352134146,
0.009166372,
0.0138838403,
-0.0106132375,
-0.0540704019,
-0.0610519275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13565v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13565v1 | Drilling Down into the Discourse Structure with LLMs for Long Document Question Answering | 2023-11-22T18:22:56 | 2023-11-22T18:22:56 | Inderjeet Nair, Shwetha Somasundaram, Apoorv Saxena, Koustava Goswami | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | We address the task of evidence retrieval for long document question
answering, which involves locating relevant paragraphs within a document to
answer a question. We aim to assess the applicability of large language models
(LLMs) in the task of zero-shot long document evidence retrieval, owing to
their unprecedented performance across various NLP tasks. However, currently
the LLMs can consume limited context lengths as input, thus providing document
chunks as inputs might overlook the global context while missing out on
capturing the inter-segment dependencies. Moreover, directly feeding the large
input sets can incur significant computational costs, particularly when
processing the entire document (and potentially incurring monetary expenses
with enterprise APIs like OpenAI's GPT variants). To address these challenges,
we propose a suite of techniques that exploit the discourse structure commonly
found in documents. By utilizing this structure, we create a condensed
representation of the document, enabling a more comprehensive understanding and
analysis of relationships between different parts. We retain $99.6\%$ of the
best zero-shot approach's performance, while processing only $26\%$ of the
total tokens used by the best approach in the information seeking evidence
retrieval setup. We also show how our approach can be combined with
\textit{self-ask} reasoning agent to achieve best zero-shot performance in
complex multi-hop question answering, just $\approx 4\%$ short of zero-shot
performance using gold evidence. | [
0.0220398698,
0.0334063619,
0.0186134856,
0.0351036452,
-0.0680712461,
-0.0108707407,
0.0216695908,
0.002092913,
0.0143271657,
-0.0529124774,
-0.0152479783,
-0.0252881609,
-0.008217386,
-0.0010633433,
-0.0267542563,
-0.0308879316,
0.0224513542,
-0.0475113131,
0.0553026721,
-0.018620722,
0.0120486766,
0.0052423449,
0.000634851,
0.0169338565,
-0.0293841809,
-0.0483633988,
-0.0274272822,
-0.0020404735,
-0.0061333477,
-0.0090450905,
-0.0025274204,
0.0093951449,
0.0245790258,
0.0520965643,
0.0000016157,
-0.0374116749,
-0.0274037328,
0.0266394708,
-0.046863161,
0.0047784601,
-0.0042645,
-0.0067567173,
0.010674539,
0.0049861595,
-0.0304012485,
-0.0053723892,
-0.009781952,
0.0833484307,
0.0458611995,
0.0905486271,
-0.00320103,
-0.0445141084,
0.0309084337,
-0.0060129305,
0.0328233615,
-0.0683101341,
0.0217245668,
0.0017473147,
0.0652489439,
0.0635686666,
0.0005103297,
0.0243981164,
0.0262325667,
-0.0235279258,
-0.0176715199,
0.034204945,
-0.0431735665,
0.0320235044,
-0.0002579997,
0.064677231,
0.0488429181,
-0.0146992914,
0.0048636151,
0.0195126329,
-0.0105070844,
0.0102401394,
-0.0723166168,
0.0649286062,
-0.0222500637,
0.0114048347,
0.0414240472,
0.0008584816,
0.0241580866,
0.0195168573,
-0.0378579386,
0.0728211179,
-0.0003661276,
-0.0415145047,
0.0102026239,
-0.0184748583,
-0.0512796938,
-0.0535766557,
-0.0080055948,
0.0752459839,
-0.0120100603,
0.0197508223,
-0.0209282842,
-0.0065543596,
0.0455650948,
-0.0368478596,
0.0144317243,
0.0213738475,
-0.0092547229,
0.1197521165,
-0.0409019329,
0.0264464412,
-0.0453097299,
-0.047589574,
-0.0425139554,
-0.0571841225,
-0.0327815041,
-0.0295797233,
-0.0583032668,
0.0635299161,
-0.0496800542,
-0.0598382205,
0.022148231,
0.0236268528,
0.0234862361,
0.0141503094,
0.0134042026,
0.0111227166,
-0.0049302224,
-0.0305955131,
-0.0207633618,
0.044848904,
-0.0696359947,
0.0038989547,
0.0016636987,
-0.0119787343,
-0.0264590252,
0.0422500856,
0.0167515054,
-0.0234797653,
0.0069553899,
0.0452577099,
0.0095180795,
-0.043587029,
-0.0106671397,
-0.0367306285,
-0.0150890118,
-0.0701368749,
0.0037300582,
-0.0588142462,
0.0168411899,
0.0013527612,
-0.0338216648,
0.0012786109,
0.0084602237,
0.0517407395,
-0.0372135788,
0.0627009347,
0.0271392111,
-0.0024671678,
0.0407389179,
0.0223249383,
0.0028796287,
0.0683253258,
0.0272075459,
0.0216259789,
0.0620293953,
0.0272420943,
0.0039077811,
0.0061107972,
0.0290567428,
0.0128292097,
0.0353630595,
0.0583735593,
-0.0048369747,
0.0186482221,
-0.0033029728,
0.0421661325,
-0.0341463313,
-0.0372747183,
0.0291795451,
0.0821971595,
-0.0175413303,
-0.0511464588,
0.0313738771,
0.0187454317,
0.0007366523,
0.0056818123,
-0.0163565483,
0.0072088586,
-0.0173842814,
0.0093768016,
0.0357782617,
0.0049589146,
-0.0438998081,
-0.0242824499,
-0.0311516393,
-0.0018999059,
-0.022215018,
0.0015960262,
0.0477663353,
-0.0104200477,
-0.0330650769,
0.0215563364,
0.0156377703,
-0.032556396,
-0.0312934369,
-0.0241610724,
0.0643724054,
0.0201056935,
0.0655638427,
-0.0355508998,
-0.0185098723,
-0.0112989582,
0.0560147539,
0.0362464599,
0.0045010247,
-0.0097563677,
-0.0068644057,
-0.0267227702,
0.0111110182,
-0.0499484092,
0.0161074456,
0.0218436625,
0.0336097591,
0.0008186092,
0.0244945567,
-0.0321755297,
0.0372654572,
0.0138132945,
-0.0286216233,
-0.0471813194,
0.0246509388,
-0.003102001,
0.0289474018,
0.0223630387,
-0.0033951791,
0.0266911462,
0.042765215,
-0.0313556679,
-0.0201523695,
-0.0267949309,
-0.0278370604,
-0.017010225,
0.0417311899,
-0.0139653152,
-0.008688638,
-0.0405476876,
-0.0090678651,
-0.066719465,
-0.0065036658,
-0.0307499487,
0.010143863,
-0.0251769572,
-0.026855493,
0.0505357087,
-0.0056670308,
-0.0481018648,
0.0708427504,
0.0252510812,
-0.0045530894,
0.0164713059,
0.0055656382,
0.0388671458,
-0.0347969383,
-0.0263545047,
0.0172238164,
0.0161336381,
0.0123961121,
0.0460188463,
-0.0268636532,
-0.0221911054,
-0.038726557,
-0.1389342248,
0.0328944996,
-0.0136452448,
0.024248654,
0.002653722,
0.0038106425,
-0.0136507312,
-0.0141552957,
-0.0539806448,
-0.0141913518,
0.027358707,
0.0255898107,
0.0421158262,
0.0151539454,
0.0147742564,
-0.0342664085,
-0.0163829215,
-0.0239082631,
0.0396093652,
-0.0040350142,
-0.0018174357,
-0.022148978,
-0.0003608535,
-0.0180619881,
0.0364959091,
-0.0268928576,
-0.013523696,
0.0278693382,
-0.0448533371,
0.0386328623,
0.1042322293,
-0.0068656397,
0.0234916192,
0.0068113902,
-0.0210010018,
-0.0631038398,
0.0390309878,
-0.0243282411,
0.0507885069,
-0.0112659661,
0.0220914278,
0.0111629991,
0.0462878756,
-0.0166345108,
-0.0164860915,
-0.0372410789,
0.0260195322,
0.0135136414,
0.0151061844,
0.0059304023,
-0.0107756145,
0.0160477217,
0.0305049513,
-0.0184106752,
-0.0108728092,
0.0448096879,
-0.054101184,
0.0153968539,
-0.0234637801,
-0.0039954702,
-0.0756036639,
0.1009152159,
-0.0075728004,
-0.0128204934,
0.0007238613,
-0.0018376464,
0.0145564498,
-0.0108469846,
0.0211493503,
-0.0240623336,
0.0299425256,
-0.026232237,
0.0578488633,
-0.0282596387,
-0.0624323972,
-0.0147916488,
-0.0583778508,
-0.0205636695,
0.0162488446,
-0.0544000603,
-0.018535044,
-0.0417756699,
0.0189472735,
0.026481403,
0.042959813,
-0.0591113046,
0.0062853103,
-0.0307667926,
0.0601889975,
0.0394236073,
-0.0035688637,
0.0087351622,
-0.0006267722,
0.0423016697,
0.0845707804,
0.0096088368,
0.0273102596,
-0.0071523357,
-0.0432959273,
-0.0149921048,
-0.0475878567,
-0.0157351829,
-0.0312008932,
0.0523076952,
-0.0765006095,
-0.0272566415,
0.1100272238,
0.034866102,
-0.0305311661,
-0.0460912436,
-0.0416662581,
0.0140276803,
-0.0123322075,
0.0385113508,
-0.0812355205,
-0.0384092219,
0.0149117103,
-0.0041230717,
-0.0272883307,
-0.0258040242,
0.0049773226,
-0.1048242003,
0.03659207,
-0.006766309,
0.0255961716,
0.0169587098,
-0.0622097664,
-0.0001561609,
0.0253388528,
-0.0040271543,
0.0234349985,
-0.015615697,
-0.011907368,
-0.0212383401,
0.0194401797,
-0.0051715411,
0.0511178784,
-0.0120155532,
0.017369967,
0.0356594697,
0.0377488323,
0.0174350385,
-0.0079308925,
0.0193414744,
-0.0328771509,
-0.0068951403,
0.0021275154,
0.0346765891,
-0.0319495313,
0.0153425224,
-0.0255946107,
0.0527522266,
-0.0338338427,
-0.0014258969,
0.0356506407,
0.0620631054,
-0.0362928994,
-0.0069736354,
-0.0597353987,
0.0015902717,
-0.0295235477,
0.1014200822,
0.0139553165,
-0.002415302,
-0.0791245401,
-0.02588672,
-0.0319107883,
-0.0322899297,
0.0005115629,
-0.0067858202,
0.0307618529,
0.0376352146,
-0.0651185885,
-0.0616570823,
0.0403901935,
0.065300785,
-0.0334055163,
0.0316392817,
-0.006293078,
0.0071170502,
-0.0166106801,
0.0077566267,
-0.0621042289,
0.0006951698,
-0.0612697452,
0.0420862436,
0.0562085286,
-0.0035873922,
-0.0016071722,
-0.0191979948,
-0.0770813152,
-0.0469136424,
-0.0406446718,
0.0232872404,
0.0204143077,
0.0404794812,
-0.0450429581,
-0.0353008658,
0.0441963747,
0.0116645545,
-0.0538414642,
0.0093742441,
0.0332996771,
0.0119698243,
0.0032381318,
0.0372391157,
-0.0341789722,
0.0162744727,
-0.015270886,
0.0356640257,
-0.0336623937,
-0.0075232028,
0.0220803898,
0.0172704123,
0.0001319417,
0.0327139422,
0.0418728292,
0.0025794802,
0.0253985543,
-0.0763866752,
-0.0402793624,
-0.0119477129,
0.0200123861,
0.0105037699,
-0.0548948459,
-0.0151874358,
0.0112246526,
-0.0218250472,
0.0429185927,
-0.0213645343,
0.0039000087,
0.0250916146,
-0.0239996798,
0.0007270777,
-0.0366831571,
-0.0140594719,
-0.0085616903,
-0.0211843718,
0.0651154518,
-0.0236947164,
0.0660378039,
0.0396073684,
-0.0317033119,
-0.004525471,
0.0223095883,
-0.1147968397,
-0.0143106179,
0.0332930014,
0.0343592241,
0.0419753231,
-0.0161247272,
0.0144237801,
-0.0214276742,
-0.0166406613,
-0.0127999606,
-0.0000227776,
0.0400945805,
-0.0091212615,
0.0292215068,
0.0481561534,
-0.0103244623,
0.0446349755,
0.0711375624,
0.0018480927,
0.0236628782,
0.0433496647,
-0.0166873224,
-0.0318634063,
-0.054889746,
-0.0296388883,
0.0375272371,
-0.0157789569,
-0.0024707806,
-0.0377047434,
-0.0122350315,
0.0101391887,
0.0163440574,
-0.0280918665,
-0.0124044232,
0.0017684217,
0.0619117953,
0.0380111523,
-0.0261653513,
-0.0593835153,
0.0381864496,
-0.0418592878,
-0.0197843462,
-0.0020652991,
-5.722604781e-33,
-0.0371451564,
-0.0365050919,
0.0471401289,
0.0069911573,
-0.0245489981,
0.0336490311,
-0.0355362892,
-0.0091602951,
-0.0240026861,
0.0178546067,
-0.0478306077,
0.017121559,
0.0051141172,
0.0414142162,
-0.0276394952,
-0.0044374354,
0.0109342262,
-0.0118513517,
-0.0300435759,
0.0109406617,
0.065756619,
-0.0194267631,
-0.0137086995,
0.0013240345,
0.0221662316,
-0.0273211561,
0.0099162022,
0.0447186567,
-0.0204488859,
0.0759806708,
-0.0174659938,
0.0008458495,
0.0456429385,
-0.0037461251,
0.0165843517,
0.0527721234,
-0.1111784652,
-0.0403024964,
0.0074640615,
-0.0291618835,
-0.0492879078,
-0.0425170474,
0.0070359856,
-0.0036807475,
0.0412526578,
-0.0256714448,
0.0067779729,
-0.0023933309,
-0.0271295849,
-0.009748444,
-0.0444855876,
0.0379219428,
0.003412849,
-0.0196346696,
0.0156865455,
0.0143384673,
0.0187876225,
0.0441034064,
-0.0447729863,
-0.0182370227,
-0.0326245278,
0.0203892067,
-0.010427692,
-0.016699275,
0.007905785,
0.043538399,
0.0049336329,
0.0034816782,
-0.0777250305,
-0.0263817701,
-0.0053967391,
-0.0012221904,
0.0242624804,
0.0293018688,
0.0375773311,
0.0299250074,
-0.0748378038,
0.0181756783,
0.0529656485,
0.0611351989,
0.0253022481,
-0.01083297,
-0.0457086377,
-0.0069444631,
-0.0357081108,
0.0024979501,
-0.017187994,
-0.0043155821,
0.0220460985,
0.0145228263,
0.0040624584,
-0.0260173548,
0.0629850924,
-0.0316588022,
0.0005500587,
0.0544670038,
-0.0162946116,
0.0263585933,
-0.0037395011,
0.0635056645,
-0.0453214273,
0.027958082,
0.0052784747,
-0.0108655374,
-0.0278031342,
0.0294223353,
0.0321000107,
-0.0297052357,
-0.056057889,
-0.0150468582,
-0.0256605726,
0.0165328849,
-0.0429087318,
0.0162034705,
0.0336341932,
0.0496318936,
0.0182926971,
0.0821309686,
-0.0048116539,
0.0196838491,
-0.0379111953,
-0.0073109944,
-0.0173840895,
-0.0262133013,
-0.0075116437,
0.0285709929,
-0.0257378165,
0.0280833151,
-0.0241136327,
-0.0669899434,
0.0290964134,
0.0668796077,
2.298e-7,
0.0152927209,
0.0360836126,
0.0643884093,
0.0298794862,
0.0305870231,
0.0234772991,
0.0005524004,
0.0063454038,
-0.0113656931,
-0.042227719,
-0.0149333868,
0.057544224,
0.0287543889,
0.0364782736,
-0.1148748845,
-0.0012933724,
-0.0542616323,
-0.0606207177,
-0.0770688206,
-0.0198422801,
0.0443932749,
0.0854125172,
-0.0007135765,
0.01500013,
-0.0189107396,
-0.0465639159,
0.0812824965,
0.0215035714,
-0.0264039356,
0.0199089963,
0.0325862989,
-0.0197248459,
-0.009342825,
0.0031282757,
0.0343452357,
0.0607196912,
-0.028452877,
0.0820016712,
0.0167721175,
-0.0340420268,
-0.007721561,
-0.0640195906,
0.0144307371,
-0.0209457763,
0.1095867157,
-0.0238883048,
-0.0527284928,
-0.0404975936,
-0.020944573,
-0.0084194131,
0.0004948174,
0.0117266448,
-0.0134524377,
0.0252737775,
-0.0004032296,
-0.0356892385,
0.0239070337,
-0.0956370384,
0.0131819015,
-0.0142700216,
-0.0425928868,
0.0217125602,
-0.0079617305,
-0.0197896361,
0.0227831155,
-0.0683852136,
-0.0138153117,
2.079383385e-34,
0.056370195,
-0.0347836725,
-0.0138085894,
0.0263086651,
0.0388381146,
0.0069011347,
-0.0239423327,
-0.0099050319,
0.0326501392,
-0.1236193478,
-0.010726884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13534v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13534v4 | LM-Cocktail: Resilient Tuning of Language Models via Model Merging | 2023-11-22T17:14:54 | 2023-12-08T16:45:22 | Shitao Xiao, Zheng Liu, Peitian Zhang, Xingrun Xing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The pre-trained language models are continually fine-tuned to better support
downstream applications. However, this operation may result in significant
performance degeneration on general tasks beyond the targeted domain. To
overcome this problem, we propose LM-Cocktail which enables the fine-tuned
model to stay resilient in general perspectives. Our method is conducted in the
form of model merging, where the fine-tuned language model is merged with the
pre-trained base model or the peer models from other domains through weighted
average. Despite simplicity, LM-Cocktail is surprisingly effective: the
resulted model is able to achieve a strong empirical performance in the whole
scope of general tasks while preserving a superior capacity in its targeted
domain. We conduct comprehensive experiments with LLama and BGE model on
popular benchmarks, including FLAN, MMLU, MTEB, whose results validate the
efficacy of our proposed method. The code and checkpoints are available at
https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding/tree/master/LM_Cocktail. | [
0.0089994743,
0.0734314919,
0.0024736989,
0.0236191768,
-0.0120386211,
0.040556632,
-0.0099769188,
-0.0049488051,
-0.0166736599,
-0.0303180888,
-0.0723532215,
-0.0368866548,
0.0060382285,
0.0520954616,
0.0490569435,
-0.0323270783,
0.0336857773,
-0.0246650092,
-0.0096763829,
-0.0154712358,
-0.0066626561,
-0.0043027536,
0.0232427474,
0.0327748284,
0.0328031816,
0.0106269224,
0.0173148252,
0.0104393894,
0.0275257546,
0.0123799341,
0.0287333,
0.0428323522,
0.0068513979,
0.071601294,
0.0000021202,
-0.0443199091,
-0.0254222546,
0.0040395986,
-0.0069744997,
0.0405432619,
0.0464615151,
-0.0069997632,
-0.0488234162,
0.0507452451,
-0.0327041447,
-0.020446606,
0.0399952866,
0.0454168916,
0.0467067435,
0.0680860654,
0.0034817453,
-0.052191902,
0.0449584424,
-0.0597829185,
-0.0544657446,
-0.0655871481,
0.0307600684,
0.0161170065,
-0.0028277952,
-0.0346803404,
-0.0212330073,
0.0217698719,
0.0115205543,
-0.0000952377,
-0.0178421196,
0.0352485739,
-0.0248300321,
-0.019599773,
-0.0167411752,
0.0683257207,
-0.082760334,
-0.0212085024,
-0.0093227578,
-0.0303216632,
-0.0058071408,
-0.0250152126,
-0.0583779141,
0.0033428934,
0.0468718521,
0.0330206156,
0.0257193018,
-0.019935865,
0.0750850886,
0.0030905902,
-0.0204636045,
0.0661218315,
0.0453962609,
-0.0024732845,
-0.0128245,
-0.0086493315,
-0.0206652265,
-0.0583749823,
-0.0082350671,
0.0262627248,
-0.0121568479,
0.0082699805,
-0.0592923649,
-0.0133026289,
0.0160298962,
-0.0317651145,
0.0556771457,
0.0623644516,
-0.0132994903,
0.0474729799,
-0.0439871587,
0.0395452306,
-0.0116818836,
0.0361628458,
-0.0431309529,
-0.018086426,
-0.0416991077,
0.0064300178,
-0.0142019419,
0.0157264471,
-0.0392329991,
-0.0118150227,
-0.0462981388,
0.0182217453,
-0.002103087,
-0.0076837158,
0.0209511928,
-0.033068452,
-0.0359257981,
-0.0107118161,
0.0000279711,
0.028633995,
-0.0058705937,
0.0340356268,
0.027812371,
-0.0303514954,
-0.0065987506,
-0.0009681412,
-0.0394879952,
-0.0065868609,
0.0232722256,
0.0929317698,
0.0045024464,
-0.0196553282,
-0.0282018725,
0.0162838269,
-0.0105479732,
-0.0768871754,
-0.0025809905,
-0.0399139486,
0.0428742319,
-0.0330378786,
0.0116140889,
-0.0577893145,
-0.0119880233,
-0.0206963047,
-0.0203758478,
0.067452848,
-0.0229416154,
-0.0087539526,
0.0130926222,
0.033581201,
-0.0076264529,
0.1051600575,
0.0127937375,
0.0198361911,
0.0316394381,
0.0144239021,
0.0047353669,
0.0434783287,
-0.0019360367,
0.0299408622,
-0.0087224711,
-0.0210000928,
0.0450011455,
-0.0021869228,
0.0389298536,
0.0271787029,
-0.0234130695,
-0.0184052978,
0.0572375581,
0.0052148965,
0.0533317141,
0.0246691518,
0.0248681232,
-0.0444818772,
0.005175408,
0.0171767343,
-0.0653415397,
-0.0045224992,
-0.0277558193,
0.0156957433,
0.041999165,
0.1139299199,
-0.0379911028,
-0.0467660241,
-0.0354026146,
-0.0206975006,
-0.0154962493,
-0.0030867143,
0.0440337136,
0.0026963535,
-0.0390894264,
0.0290496964,
0.0434478521,
-0.0342307575,
0.0042169886,
-0.0762203261,
-0.0111344801,
0.0295505449,
0.0352332518,
-0.0201164912,
-0.0385286286,
0.0124593675,
-0.0033423749,
-0.0003710081,
0.0505115017,
-0.0014258956,
0.062473882,
-0.0460954867,
-0.0458517186,
-0.0091365678,
0.0402532369,
0.040467687,
0.0078832973,
0.0097254673,
0.0192858633,
-0.0205112081,
-0.0328184254,
0.0415346101,
-0.0312675051,
0.0061101275,
0.0018053529,
-0.0238622446,
0.0356889889,
-0.002408863,
-0.0318615511,
0.0006607376,
0.0386679396,
-0.0307397135,
-0.035934642,
0.0154875452,
-0.0173479542,
-0.0391056798,
0.0574957989,
0.0191603601,
0.0075112125,
0.0325317383,
-0.0616876483,
-0.0514983162,
0.0038337738,
0.0215973314,
0.0535847805,
-0.0343157537,
0.0652748793,
-0.0199190956,
0.0326588564,
-0.0281748492,
0.0560821034,
-0.0132873794,
-0.0299620274,
-0.0213700775,
0.0115357684,
-0.003365892,
-0.004684763,
-0.0318208113,
0.0437497161,
-0.0045111561,
0.0428770259,
-0.0201956723,
-0.0084761893,
-0.0256322958,
-0.0544913895,
-0.0725109354,
0.025574537,
-0.0473247617,
0.0084256446,
0.0288084541,
0.0251820087,
-0.0321062729,
0.0009992043,
0.0134005966,
-0.0065698777,
0.003415948,
0.027361339,
0.0057449839,
0.0013327465,
-0.0294577517,
-0.0508391969,
-0.0220013969,
-0.0049899672,
0.0367730111,
-0.0412756279,
-0.0117772259,
-0.05238498,
-0.0054104873,
-0.0444377884,
0.020089373,
-0.0322323516,
-0.0503438897,
-0.0168539826,
0.0030480793,
0.0728235841,
0.0581724718,
-0.0187012199,
0.0029290684,
0.0855727345,
0.0016253287,
-0.0126789082,
0.0074547548,
0.0130732758,
-0.0270342622,
-0.0165274944,
0.0006002296,
-0.0074901893,
0.0808300078,
-0.0467937812,
-0.0191656649,
-0.0320375636,
0.0039841798,
-0.0083993971,
-0.0017115258,
-0.0064612818,
-0.0213689059,
-0.0368979089,
0.0314495042,
-0.0146555537,
-0.0699010342,
0.048541937,
-0.0330838747,
0.0020224317,
-0.0446165241,
-0.0396250486,
-0.0543598831,
0.0096672,
0.0049382681,
0.010774605,
0.0033527955,
-0.0220747553,
-0.0539351441,
-0.0058527603,
0.0004861986,
-0.0139900558,
0.0553073622,
-0.0322933495,
0.0044083432,
-0.0219944231,
-0.0403874554,
-0.0222631209,
-0.0122854169,
-0.0527305119,
0.0224234611,
0.0038772167,
-0.0160080772,
-0.05245905,
0.0113969436,
-0.0170100089,
0.0232734941,
-0.0243568141,
0.0086838985,
-0.0134254368,
0.006803995,
0.0371909179,
0.0143788327,
0.0381432399,
-0.0202077031,
0.0419688523,
0.0285307169,
0.0372774825,
-0.0194707084,
-0.0507006794,
0.0242731571,
0.0462526195,
-0.0192339253,
-0.0273272414,
0.0141719701,
0.0366634056,
-0.0353365876,
0.0236371569,
0.0869309977,
0.0042133625,
-0.0289033987,
-0.0072590904,
-0.0345230028,
0.0882965401,
0.0261756536,
0.0443729311,
-0.0510193706,
-0.0284105949,
0.0290673785,
-0.0210741088,
0.0355390534,
0.0208753161,
-0.0288089439,
-0.0984883532,
0.0271943286,
0.0276793931,
-0.0116906818,
-0.0057826578,
-0.0391797386,
0.0055037132,
-0.0406410471,
0.0309400875,
0.0291440785,
-0.020788379,
-0.0138369976,
0.0131580755,
-0.0211960524,
-0.0917944908,
0.0138061401,
-0.0539859347,
0.0516280904,
0.0552427992,
0.0036313864,
0.0108111249,
-0.0144080734,
0.0887858123,
-0.0223337896,
-0.0045270668,
-0.0027622196,
0.0263069142,
-0.0097998837,
-0.0130082173,
0.0457635596,
0.0120386863,
-0.0273291804,
-0.0267097689,
-0.0081739239,
0.0402739309,
0.0065177912,
-0.0011196595,
-0.0395214781,
-0.0133064501,
-0.0252058376,
0.0556525961,
0.0374551266,
-0.035844788,
-0.0237665772,
-0.0225065723,
-0.043313399,
-0.0094422316,
-0.023093814,
0.0168316625,
-0.0140318265,
-0.0416572802,
-0.0403910726,
-0.0144449575,
-0.0045270771,
0.0583980605,
-0.0111521687,
0.0360288247,
-0.0599452704,
0.0030593732,
-0.01705583,
0.015962081,
-0.0459376387,
0.0226766299,
-0.0761785507,
0.0289032478,
0.0399990156,
-0.0088311136,
-0.0309226569,
-0.0300189592,
-0.1213365495,
-0.0955647826,
0.0176105704,
0.064060472,
0.0259693805,
0.0280999467,
-0.0319643132,
-0.0820952058,
0.0439009257,
0.0087289317,
-0.0198788308,
0.0562651306,
0.048060216,
-0.0676616654,
0.0098142214,
0.037057247,
-0.0561259799,
0.0199053586,
0.0116070928,
0.006956879,
-0.0135672064,
-0.0018985298,
-0.0283822846,
-0.0142669883,
0.0489781909,
-0.0386447161,
-0.0662080795,
-0.0227753688,
0.0486154668,
-0.0112090707,
0.0001591184,
-0.0313107744,
0.018645538,
0.0251305364,
-0.0096814791,
0.0074887075,
0.0180153456,
0.0006917567,
0.0093867565,
-0.0134640504,
0.0019003215,
-0.0078251623,
-0.0027701342,
0.0270929225,
0.0195016954,
0.0054331524,
0.0078176931,
-0.0033229841,
0.0197632127,
-0.0394611284,
0.0034997954,
-0.0097063286,
0.0225159712,
-0.0325956196,
0.0762568265,
-0.0923713669,
-0.055328995,
-0.0378307477,
0.0002065945,
0.0926253125,
0.0040377136,
0.0503519215,
0.0077033513,
-0.0222646277,
-0.0315728299,
-0.0096708424,
-0.0200808793,
-0.0047859829,
0.056827724,
0.0007351821,
-0.0207423102,
0.0138696777,
0.0788196325,
0.045850195,
0.019071022,
0.0257597025,
0.0570693836,
-0.0070001734,
-0.0221753959,
0.0323025733,
0.0248259269,
-0.0318660066,
-0.0518311672,
-0.0178540573,
-0.0816169754,
0.0235447679,
0.01561525,
-0.0089096623,
0.0156147601,
-0.0016390645,
0.0572797321,
-0.0084242476,
0.0276113525,
-0.0388885327,
-0.0360804312,
0.050274495,
-0.0135126766,
0.039943561,
-6.942767183e-33,
-0.0406827852,
0.015637191,
0.0127835404,
-0.0311097093,
-0.0309946463,
0.0164853744,
-0.0094288941,
0.003433096,
-0.0258445367,
-0.0136162499,
-0.031896729,
0.0323014744,
0.0161753148,
0.0032720168,
-0.0180910788,
-0.0031001244,
0.0392413586,
0.0116693676,
-0.034177009,
-0.0002904367,
-0.0294407047,
0.0458010845,
0.0271099918,
-0.0566274524,
-0.0277547482,
0.0213010162,
-0.0329249613,
-0.0055487254,
-0.0158541203,
0.085862875,
-0.018454209,
0.0205249153,
0.0162504129,
-0.0243699346,
-0.0510026552,
-0.0337795056,
-0.0424161367,
-0.0251578409,
0.0252643395,
0.0038710365,
0.0006473995,
-0.036853414,
0.0643056333,
0.0197648294,
0.0000344441,
-0.054671403,
0.0150223998,
-0.0196244046,
-0.0450861119,
-0.0145700853,
-0.0403996967,
0.0217931382,
0.0270652026,
0.0040618097,
0.0402400903,
-0.0418825559,
0.0313343517,
0.056054052,
-0.0386435166,
0.0125733959,
0.0155312298,
0.0660992339,
0.0898512229,
0.0224165265,
-0.0331340842,
0.0601943769,
-0.0187007431,
-0.0085937539,
0.016605733,
-0.0344262235,
0.0564928837,
0.0550899804,
0.0457832478,
0.0439605229,
0.0529003069,
-0.0208228994,
-0.0829063207,
0.0535563268,
0.0130203236,
0.0077154119,
-0.0131255677,
0.0927738249,
0.0048275976,
-0.0138789527,
-0.0408654697,
0.0042682597,
-0.0489115044,
-0.0213944335,
0.0140553536,
0.0201722123,
-0.0123001328,
-0.0251987949,
0.0102656353,
-0.0539566688,
-0.0109951561,
0.0213560537,
-0.0266463738,
0.0173429325,
-0.0024997208,
0.0524662547,
-0.0382098258,
-0.0256763529,
0.0032963813,
0.0225537214,
0.0024118382,
-0.0358568802,
0.0384240113,
0.0343371183,
-0.0796698332,
0.0167020578,
-0.018606199,
-0.0113669522,
0.0467821434,
0.0700020045,
0.0445583127,
-0.0072103315,
-0.000140047,
0.0411959067,
0.0253881123,
-0.0108304145,
-0.0262654778,
0.0232557002,
0.0306543559,
0.0457828157,
-0.0153404055,
0.006819244,
0.0004175672,
0.0144649697,
0.0584026314,
-0.0522550941,
-0.0504069477,
0.001125005,
2.776e-7,
0.0613307804,
0.0096967183,
-0.0067029977,
-0.0095166583,
0.0163642708,
0.0275401641,
-0.0532962494,
0.0359804109,
0.0283111706,
0.0308385473,
-0.0072223721,
0.0134338019,
0.0491458401,
0.0183624309,
-0.0463311933,
0.0378456488,
-0.0676934719,
0.0260324627,
-0.0357841663,
-0.0383397862,
0.0012772674,
0.1541202664,
0.0186953209,
-0.0209997818,
-0.0279007982,
-0.0282868445,
0.0604366548,
-0.0334644429,
-0.0114324344,
0.0323161781,
-0.0119639048,
0.0737583116,
-0.021411648,
-0.0145378895,
-0.0669256672,
0.035569571,
-0.0130818896,
0.0706667453,
-0.0082389051,
-0.0031658018,
0.0250616763,
0.0306133982,
-0.0048601916,
-0.0336780474,
0.0826049969,
-0.0443602912,
-0.0219239369,
-0.045554895,
-0.012102739,
-0.0197401177,
0.0425512344,
-0.0262808651,
-0.0162634198,
0.0530403703,
0.0167231727,
-0.0133168986,
-0.0338655226,
-0.1113217697,
-0.0403024405,
0.0084787095,
-0.0415451601,
-0.0185169298,
-0.0337283872,
-0.0245804098,
0.0418938994,
-0.0710662231,
-0.0084356172,
3.01299383e-34,
0.0485478379,
-0.054491099,
0.0251543485,
0.0608954988,
0.0171806086,
-0.0121508827,
-0.0272144247,
0.0087840008,
-0.0001606525,
-0.0548230074,
-0.005708782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17065v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17065v2 | Efficient Deep Speech Understanding at the Edge | 2023-11-22T17:14:18 | 2023-12-04T15:37:57 | Rongxiang Wang, Felix Xiaozhu Lin | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG | In contemporary speech understanding (SU), a sophisticated pipeline is
employed, encompassing the ingestion of streaming voice input. The pipeline
executes beam search iteratively, invoking a deep neural network to generate
tentative outputs (referred to as hypotheses) in an autoregressive manner.
Periodically, the pipeline assesses attention and Connectionist Temporal
Classification (CTC) scores.
This paper aims to enhance SU performance on edge devices with limited
resources. Adopting a hybrid strategy, our approach focuses on accelerating
on-device execution and offloading inputs surpassing the device's capacity.
While this approach is established, we tackle SU's distinctive challenges
through innovative techniques: (1) Late Contextualization: This involves the
parallel execution of a model's attentive encoder during input ingestion. (2)
Pilot Inference: Addressing temporal load imbalances in the SU pipeline, this
technique aims to mitigate them effectively. (3) Autoregression Offramps:
Decisions regarding offloading are made solely based on hypotheses, presenting
a novel approach.
These techniques are designed to seamlessly integrate with existing speech
models, pipelines, and frameworks, offering flexibility for independent or
combined application. Collectively, they form a hybrid solution for edge SU.
Our prototype, named XYZ, has undergone testing on Arm platforms featuring 6 to
8 cores, demonstrating state-of-the-art accuracy. Notably, it achieves a 2x
reduction in end-to-end latency and a corresponding 2x decrease in offloading
requirements. | [
-0.0121149514,
0.0413888469,
0.0173917469,
0.0273238122,
0.011830139,
-0.0134383924,
0.0741448253,
-0.0466088615,
-0.0098317973,
0.0070813452,
-0.0002594503,
-0.0625554174,
0.0090252785,
0.0679906085,
-0.0320171788,
-0.0328836329,
0.0310931243,
-0.0006706953,
0.0239289198,
-0.0072987839,
0.0169116519,
0.0086620543,
-0.0428291149,
0.0246884171,
-0.006600399,
-0.0314936824,
-0.0207214393,
0.0324231572,
0.0034615234,
-0.0380286872,
-0.0287846588,
0.0096751479,
0.0493944436,
0.018145727,
0.0000019928,
0.014854122,
-0.0190845057,
-0.0028030283,
-0.0914602354,
-0.0251207259,
0.0350172333,
0.0169332493,
-0.0244444888,
0.0036776527,
0.0077636801,
-0.0289828964,
0.0249279384,
0.0102126747,
0.0504521877,
0.0105190175,
0.0004223326,
-0.0018339904,
0.0076763472,
-0.0077859778,
-0.0412405431,
-0.0416221693,
-0.0401695929,
-0.0893029198,
-0.0138779217,
-0.0283184983,
-0.0052089812,
0.0499023944,
0.0787136033,
0.0158171467,
0.0264917314,
0.0160012785,
-0.0485752784,
-0.0460983627,
-0.0491962321,
0.0517351292,
-0.0204712935,
0.0008085066,
0.0138901221,
-0.0050068339,
-0.0415378138,
-0.034352947,
0.0031009372,
-0.0124853924,
-0.011697866,
-0.0080900593,
-0.0130206356,
0.0135522829,
0.0434876718,
-0.0056526456,
-0.0396450758,
0.0658735931,
-0.0032431742,
0.0151621383,
-0.0225999393,
-0.0119877588,
-0.0226927288,
-0.0574472211,
0.0541087091,
0.0517987832,
-0.0662096217,
-0.0168900806,
-0.0232098661,
-0.024541596,
-0.0604667962,
-0.0061728894,
0.037167199,
0.0606189519,
-0.0373313688,
0.0390439555,
-0.001040446,
0.0145330857,
-0.0206757002,
-0.0403092802,
-0.0446540192,
0.0183397364,
-0.0042928229,
-0.0029958906,
-0.0477636494,
0.0200525969,
-0.0415214337,
-0.0785227567,
-0.0176331177,
0.0093769217,
-0.0217454229,
-0.0189863052,
-0.0102255791,
0.0473893471,
-0.0427442938,
0.0053917142,
0.0599836782,
0.0662597567,
-0.0242136177,
0.0344393887,
-0.0009370266,
-0.1236954704,
-0.0113765253,
0.0334748998,
0.0057914774,
-0.002566953,
0.0105061969,
0.0047910456,
-0.010804846,
-0.0242804363,
0.0227486007,
-0.0087583344,
0.0296212062,
-0.0316317454,
0.0151480259,
-0.0072822683,
0.0287467632,
-0.0005709221,
0.0257532019,
0.0077066286,
0.0126346089,
-0.0014639688,
0.0264827423,
0.0269568134,
0.0145229446,
-0.0047301915,
0.0507795289,
-0.0058057494,
-0.0041289059,
0.0298770498,
0.0511618331,
-0.0115032056,
-0.0014948918,
-0.0481639616,
-0.014213223,
0.0321711823,
0.0357197598,
-0.0253443979,
-0.0446097255,
0.025277514,
-0.0197459422,
0.0719953254,
0.0575184785,
0.0016022091,
0.0038583253,
-0.0007262501,
0.0469643138,
0.0559952185,
0.034825433,
-0.0063295974,
-0.0165369082,
0.0285570193,
-0.035700243,
-0.0419008099,
-0.0668420643,
0.0570352152,
0.0370523743,
0.0142583158,
0.0408265777,
0.0396396592,
-0.0151841296,
-0.0140508441,
-0.0095566502,
0.0073517901,
-0.0438890383,
0.0833957344,
0.0167971551,
-0.030236993,
-0.004970497,
0.0413182378,
-0.0154381823,
-0.0240156725,
-0.019496765,
-0.0230218954,
0.0269281045,
0.067609787,
0.0197597798,
0.0067801001,
-0.0312228184,
-0.0131724244,
0.0136347627,
-0.0176717266,
-0.0074850572,
-0.0123533513,
0.0609702058,
-0.0322566852,
-0.030293908,
0.0191927012,
-0.0117525999,
0.0448707454,
-0.0333056189,
0.0129774809,
-0.0101933395,
0.0011139769,
0.0023801867,
0.0003191,
0.0225526951,
-0.0139056388,
0.0508454181,
0.0351177938,
0.0440916345,
0.0128178941,
-0.0123251183,
-0.0199134499,
0.0236473121,
-0.0607972629,
0.0094160633,
0.0281434637,
-0.0988157094,
0.0146337561,
0.0229390264,
-0.0007215273,
0.0168119911,
0.043827787,
-0.0149642164,
-0.0843215808,
0.0521516241,
-0.0113420133,
0.044156611,
-0.0237934329,
0.0148163605,
0.0119253946,
0.0402283557,
0.0523740835,
0.0082012583,
-0.0018169034,
0.0263233427,
0.0130852293,
0.0140087381,
0.0092689451,
-0.0425552651,
0.0022844365,
-0.0040412261,
-0.0020830731,
-0.0255294163,
-0.0438427851,
-0.0171740968,
-0.0142473681,
0.0324314721,
-0.0886979103,
0.0265100896,
-0.0606751963,
0.0081485035,
0.0016084902,
0.050907515,
0.0089135775,
-0.0576020181,
0.0120126195,
-0.0081893038,
-0.0040713279,
0.0283818413,
-0.047237806,
0.0159473233,
-0.0002663092,
0.009589334,
-0.0176509935,
0.0180088785,
0.0404349864,
0.013515858,
-0.002195653,
-0.0190836042,
-0.0576438569,
0.0210222062,
0.0319029987,
0.0090016127,
0.0145701887,
0.0212200172,
0.0019898983,
-0.0101445746,
0.0896855965,
0.0127023477,
0.0141069572,
-0.0028683783,
-0.0005687522,
-0.0174342953,
0.0471963882,
0.0300773103,
0.0335858725,
-0.0151874125,
0.0581288077,
-0.0620695949,
0.073796317,
-0.0306951627,
0.0196652468,
-0.0357938223,
-0.0544119738,
-0.0007763249,
-0.0333430022,
-0.0319195092,
-0.0068472377,
-0.0339664035,
0.0165291987,
-0.0015303129,
-0.0208000001,
0.0511695929,
-0.0408400595,
-0.0450636297,
-0.0302433036,
-0.036845848,
-0.0171514265,
0.0412002392,
-0.0083134845,
-0.0072478182,
-0.053090889,
-0.0320211537,
-0.0003627104,
0.0376986675,
-0.0278328583,
-0.0436914116,
0.0021800813,
-0.0299435593,
0.0015993178,
-0.0214033034,
-0.0329509825,
-0.0276305415,
-0.012913473,
-0.0467524529,
-0.012502227,
-0.0035129183,
-0.0095697735,
-0.0050719166,
0.0540149622,
-0.0319477543,
0.0664349422,
0.0066093556,
0.0114182914,
-0.0162375551,
0.0569093265,
0.0155916763,
0.0393611901,
0.0213194061,
0.0477418229,
0.0497206226,
0.0078896619,
0.0980464295,
-0.0158769935,
-0.0682474077,
0.0287499875,
0.0521430299,
-0.0356159434,
-0.0522461757,
0.0558006838,
0.0425475165,
-0.1072397381,
0.0030673475,
0.0754479468,
-0.0036707344,
-0.059536878,
-0.0022261359,
0.0347373523,
-0.0008953236,
0.0221283082,
-0.0004976528,
-0.0614499487,
-0.0552779958,
0.0391803384,
0.0247266218,
0.0309795421,
0.0165299885,
-0.0373483449,
-0.050396163,
0.0382624194,
-0.0098229051,
0.0137821855,
0.0223523863,
-0.0063723633,
-0.0051315976,
-0.0230826717,
0.0488164239,
0.0170824174,
0.0226949845,
0.0141125554,
0.0156400353,
-0.0368584991,
-0.0091269203,
0.0522920452,
-0.0122595401,
0.0381137654,
0.0334963314,
-0.0223527495,
0.0067491066,
-0.0141498344,
0.0572328344,
-0.0680162683,
-0.0065482203,
-0.0264899191,
-0.008624821,
-0.0299632885,
-0.0246847868,
-0.0034923165,
0.0267858561,
-0.0375901572,
0.0265214853,
-0.0116712423,
0.0929044709,
-0.0339112878,
-0.0066221929,
-0.0348009542,
-0.0206650011,
0.0514002778,
0.0351011381,
-0.0026905772,
-0.0109961666,
-0.0578340925,
-0.0001203399,
-0.008447296,
-0.0326317176,
0.0170837976,
0.011648233,
0.0529363267,
-0.0634130016,
0.0360902771,
-0.0206148159,
0.0070875976,
0.0218612459,
0.0279303156,
-0.0021421167,
-0.0028343266,
0.0575975031,
-0.0713064373,
0.0354513042,
0.0210108925,
0.0490981378,
-0.0162195303,
0.0302210171,
0.0602483936,
-0.0496305376,
-0.0068956069,
0.0745551512,
-0.0887903646,
-0.0414950885,
0.0399425626,
-0.060057532,
0.0200433005,
0.0878492594,
-0.0620341748,
-0.0205159914,
0.0657194108,
-0.0106745595,
-0.0887688473,
0.0153952166,
0.0522635877,
-0.0114280498,
-0.0037722562,
0.038144663,
-0.0557918102,
0.0467656702,
-0.044987835,
0.0085988045,
-0.0515383333,
-0.045677416,
-0.0093116779,
-0.0251448918,
0.0475404412,
0.0140628396,
0.020709347,
-0.0019752898,
0.068841286,
0.048379641,
0.0234973244,
-0.0308442693,
0.0018659622,
-0.0292066932,
-0.0215703528,
0.0125022354,
0.0282611698,
0.0342403576,
-0.029742863,
-0.0248773638,
0.0534340031,
-0.0044296626,
-0.0086372644,
0.0215155985,
-0.0251620077,
0.0080324942,
0.0440958738,
0.0102452394,
0.0431856886,
-0.0346421748,
0.0171399489,
-0.0097487848,
0.0063857315,
-0.0169266704,
0.0039023338,
-0.0511993729,
-0.045804143,
-0.0127888089,
0.0045212535,
-0.0153085385,
-0.005538288,
0.008591895,
0.025355015,
0.0077007301,
-0.0231013168,
0.0169418789,
-0.0638211593,
-0.0477021001,
0.0304439254,
0.0296193715,
-0.0029996051,
0.0180127304,
0.0084304623,
0.0021420484,
0.0226109978,
0.0308526997,
0.0229278374,
-0.0453743786,
-0.0544695631,
-0.0312849097,
0.0246997103,
-0.0293575972,
0.0137228165,
0.0182062965,
-0.0288996864,
0.0113976365,
-0.0276190657,
0.0147985611,
-0.0489513986,
0.0150971049,
0.0372780375,
-0.0169956908,
-0.0227414705,
0.0080360211,
0.0025151058,
-0.0391289443,
0.027318174,
0.0126458537,
-6.433692906e-33,
-0.0063443216,
0.0193204414,
0.0063081738,
-0.0223030243,
-0.0063053444,
0.0016467774,
-0.0170138143,
-0.0136470851,
-0.0172080584,
-0.0142778791,
-0.0308137462,
0.0765120238,
0.0559470728,
0.0439492017,
0.0158064049,
-0.0219250936,
0.1073499769,
-0.0482784808,
0.0018046804,
0.0489365347,
0.0164232813,
0.0622564182,
-0.0017851959,
-0.0235470757,
-0.0293641742,
-0.0008643068,
0.0307478085,
-0.0149633335,
-0.006560938,
-0.0084601222,
-0.0371500552,
-0.0085713696,
0.0038809066,
-0.0757401586,
-0.0283268429,
0.0245929826,
-0.1137988791,
-0.0211359505,
-0.0352292396,
0.0615381375,
-0.0557270795,
-0.007796573,
0.0424788631,
0.0634134859,
-0.0159157198,
-0.0498382114,
-0.0001733957,
0.0061472794,
-0.0521928445,
-0.0696683824,
0.058524631,
0.0306950789,
-0.0188411158,
-0.0208115224,
0.0617729984,
0.0186021924,
-0.0473271385,
-0.0166627299,
-0.0931380391,
0.0120555656,
-0.0480880812,
0.0325153284,
0.0590976365,
0.0170351565,
0.0107386811,
0.0038322164,
0.0135600111,
-0.0700437874,
-0.0002249518,
0.0190622956,
0.0004937487,
0.0086948657,
-0.0140907448,
-0.053122215,
0.0763440654,
-0.0293408781,
-0.0155968051,
-0.0150163509,
0.0489670113,
0.0280688945,
0.036732696,
0.0105970344,
-0.044797495,
-0.004224543,
-0.0189012755,
-0.0769929364,
-0.0348231532,
0.0012944291,
0.0448107794,
0.0317442417,
-0.0044569224,
-0.0069335378,
0.0656256005,
-0.0050009065,
0.0382246859,
0.0102251712,
0.0118128555,
0.0103552053,
0.0367494933,
0.0645002723,
-0.0239718724,
0.0266950987,
-0.0025153225,
0.0188591853,
0.0335822552,
-0.0374897979,
-0.0188855864,
0.0530308075,
-0.040070489,
-0.0375977457,
-0.0232095048,
0.0533537641,
-0.0254564788,
0.0392313078,
0.0638560429,
-0.0242385995,
0.0097381501,
0.0463968068,
-0.0525950268,
0.0198908485,
-0.0299109481,
-0.0030699151,
0.0232431404,
-0.0086332196,
-0.0767796561,
-0.0028441595,
-0.0365615673,
-0.0161668602,
0.0100601027,
-0.0431067161,
-0.0143945506,
0.0525498316,
2.945e-7,
-0.05334609,
-0.0310120098,
0.022094762,
-0.0093577532,
0.0236855336,
-0.0053273505,
0.0150452182,
-0.0019454919,
-0.0233142897,
-0.0165379345,
0.0241677389,
0.0290606841,
0.0754918829,
0.0102689676,
-0.0620843768,
-0.0454677939,
-0.0438420773,
0.0671777353,
-0.0198132228,
-0.0050114128,
-0.0041668718,
0.0948708653,
-0.0299289916,
-0.0561165698,
0.0627023727,
0.0037838053,
-0.020037394,
0.0368827097,
0.0468456224,
-0.035623353,
0.0173741411,
0.0281718355,
-0.0418072492,
0.0059488821,
-0.0116912471,
0.0165861771,
-0.0543557182,
0.0344214179,
-0.0016557791,
-0.0692133904,
-0.0336239152,
0.0030242826,
0.0183975082,
-0.011540655,
0.0581337214,
-0.0145864449,
-0.0162812304,
-0.0447794236,
-0.0121196005,
-0.0388957895,
-0.0148020629,
0.0660507903,
0.0531477705,
-0.004753367,
0.0029784543,
-0.0452489592,
-0.020999765,
-0.1072360724,
-0.0312005449,
0.0045913467,
-0.0757274777,
-0.0037291066,
-0.0711731166,
-0.0117626516,
0.0847936869,
-0.0339505039,
-0.0330002494,
2.426483219e-34,
0.010455044,
0.0088326745,
0.0242080037,
0.0419337265,
-0.0066202157,
-0.027862139,
-0.0012190037,
0.0090404768,
0.0490888469,
-0.0725606829,
-0.0347571149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13495v1 | Current Topological and Machine Learning Applications for Bias Detection in Text | 2023-11-22T16:12:42 | 2023-11-22T16:12:42 | Colleen Farrelly, Yashbir Singh, Quincy A. Hathaway, Gunnar Carlsson, Ashok Choudhary, Rahul Paul, Gianfranco Doretto, Yassine Himeur, Shadi Atalls, Wathiq Mansoor | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.LG | Institutional bias can impact patient outcomes, educational attainment, and
legal system navigation. Written records often reflect bias, and once bias is
identified; it is possible to refer individuals for training to reduce bias.
Many machine learning tools exist to explore text data and create predictive
models that can search written records to identify real-time bias. However, few
previous studies investigate large language model embeddings and geometric
models of biased text data to understand geometry's impact on bias modeling
accuracy. To overcome this issue, this study utilizes the RedditBias database
to analyze textual biases. Four transformer models, including BERT and RoBERTa
variants, were explored. Post-embedding, t-SNE allowed two-dimensional
visualization of data. KNN classifiers differentiated bias types, with lower
k-values proving more effective. Findings suggest BERT, particularly mini BERT,
excels in bias classification, while multilingual models lag. The
recommendation emphasizes refining monolingual models and exploring
domain-specific biases. | [
0.046238903,
0.0527058169,
-0.0425050855,
0.0256694518,
-0.0465976968,
0.0275824815,
0.0609685183,
0.015919473,
0.0551920012,
-0.0723811686,
0.006465055,
0.0093864165,
0.0112871164,
-0.0033075842,
-0.0006365087,
-0.0585477985,
0.0226751156,
0.0479158424,
0.0753830448,
-0.0264596976,
0.0164556298,
0.0444864184,
-0.0035757602,
0.0606851056,
-0.0123862689,
0.0063098595,
0.0489005707,
0.0045569083,
0.0139126461,
-0.0206924006,
0.036197938,
0.0565451086,
-0.0407305546,
0.0713190511,
0.000001824,
-0.0090898434,
-0.0167727806,
0.0181838702,
0.0277576875,
-0.0354317278,
0.0659833327,
-0.0627176687,
-0.0160997789,
0.0354240611,
0.0073094778,
-0.0136652794,
0.055662211,
0.0348546728,
0.0258058831,
0.0398601964,
-0.0263439268,
-0.0316133313,
-0.0081959283,
-0.0024543123,
0.026141949,
0.0302656982,
0.0565138273,
-0.0392043181,
-0.0771156326,
-0.0053476971,
-0.0063251099,
-0.007050876,
-0.0137381349,
0.0158845615,
0.0116430232,
0.0325710624,
-0.0299971197,
-0.0008728301,
0.0044667837,
0.0512795672,
0.0021721828,
-0.0218962394,
0.0261759553,
-0.0006977012,
0.033361949,
0.0667565167,
-0.0310026053,
0.0172158144,
-0.0313978419,
0.0163773987,
-0.016418606,
-0.0106804129,
0.0121994633,
0.022679545,
-0.0233302675,
-0.0007167031,
0.0215019789,
-0.0578562878,
0.0007583866,
0.0444518961,
0.0371362306,
-0.0465209819,
0.0508249439,
-0.0084396834,
0.0299383476,
0.0070678554,
-0.0121680275,
-0.038502302,
0.0423563533,
-0.0812594518,
0.0089436173,
-0.0286774356,
-0.0234452914,
0.0345080122,
0.0033611709,
-0.0101047978,
-0.011363822,
0.0431155488,
-0.0146397762,
0.017735973,
-0.0025322507,
0.0170178171,
-0.0097402623,
-0.0271168351,
0.0004742855,
0.0276012234,
-0.0303798188,
0.0197043605,
-0.0399956442,
-0.009614219,
0.0147456964,
0.018520277,
-0.0106511684,
0.0001608443,
-0.0177936368,
0.0488835312,
-0.0241218042,
0.0404534005,
-0.0814101622,
-0.0170548204,
0.024082996,
0.0253521074,
0.0236857124,
-0.0530385412,
-0.0028401441,
0.0293878894,
0.0636245459,
-0.0261463784,
-0.0122414706,
-0.0110197989,
-0.0558021627,
-0.0125978682,
0.021826772,
-0.0407697633,
-0.0040987697,
0.010767593,
-0.0167114604,
-0.0279897712,
-0.0143097155,
0.0229230877,
-0.0934001431,
0.027790159,
-0.0036569759,
0.0008623544,
0.0694690719,
-0.0067085754,
-0.0060091303,
0.0379556119,
0.0101043927,
0.0313338339,
0.0392043553,
-0.0055416748,
-0.0113268457,
0.0196092352,
0.0464533754,
0.0019715964,
-0.0362587534,
0.0172568485,
-0.0301719513,
0.0296041071,
0.004118552,
0.0451837331,
-0.0094920425,
-0.0369367823,
0.0466889702,
0.0576753579,
0.014371424,
0.0242455993,
-0.0262101684,
0.0055946554,
-0.0050587584,
0.0030503394,
-0.0421872884,
-0.0234835651,
0.008107312,
-0.0286365561,
0.0036177975,
0.031143669,
-0.0041672988,
-0.0063726036,
-0.031805899,
0.00104572,
-0.0177965295,
-0.047482796,
0.0485729612,
-0.0063406918,
-0.0310805198,
0.0600900315,
0.0319737606,
-0.0229473729,
0.0006805651,
-0.0202290621,
0.0039263824,
0.0448120385,
0.015129135,
-0.0602356307,
0.0022550672,
-0.0436794795,
0.0059489887,
0.0398094207,
0.0391008444,
0.0015116942,
-0.0637992173,
-0.0242294632,
-0.0403047651,
0.0388800167,
0.0564075634,
0.0277343132,
0.0048465407,
0.0373986922,
-0.0235579032,
-0.0702465028,
-0.0161909442,
0.0455460139,
0.0365662798,
0.0087742526,
-0.0281352829,
0.040431194,
-0.016927192,
0.0283711702,
-0.0420294404,
-0.0196174439,
0.0101467241,
0.0085560819,
0.0046583316,
0.0023703692,
-0.0275843889,
-0.0343870968,
0.0115084238,
-0.0693507046,
-0.0326301195,
0.0235769507,
-0.024954848,
0.026373554,
0.0341251865,
-0.0502488986,
0.0473056734,
0.0085217869,
-0.0192246679,
-0.0419066474,
-0.0053612697,
-0.0536994524,
0.0425230265,
-0.0314188115,
0.0273263771,
0.0167564191,
-0.0825041085,
0.0221076831,
0.0070179752,
-0.0257114545,
-0.0415843539,
-0.0069410964,
0.0070555517,
0.0326283053,
-0.0431441069,
0.0123833437,
-0.0772499666,
-0.0796523243,
-0.0372482352,
-0.0263678376,
0.005725611,
0.0120980311,
-0.0273724794,
0.007643749,
-0.0204853285,
-0.0021541961,
-0.0763392001,
0.0026219753,
0.039555829,
0.0316452831,
-0.0503258146,
0.0061427932,
-0.0282435045,
-0.0528416485,
-0.0739424676,
0.086752601,
0.0855718628,
-0.0219631307,
-0.0438555181,
-0.0302902609,
-0.0006862376,
-0.0137032159,
0.0025967781,
-0.0229095854,
0.0060517588,
0.0303746238,
0.0315390117,
0.0521018133,
0.0366304815,
0.0313824378,
0.032205563,
0.0052584768,
-0.045250833,
-0.0408448242,
-0.049966976,
0.03537203,
-0.0115150036,
-0.0796294436,
0.0222367104,
0.0598128513,
0.0440712869,
-0.0162976962,
-0.0366677679,
0.0314145051,
-0.0415911339,
0.0313453712,
0.0045769825,
-0.0289846361,
-0.0006341775,
0.023715334,
-0.0231025051,
-0.0380013809,
0.0532295518,
0.0104270522,
0.071026884,
-0.0527232848,
0.0268073305,
-0.0385902859,
0.0031146184,
0.0291252527,
0.0442119502,
-0.0037069051,
-0.0240841135,
0.0102220681,
0.0101438593,
0.0186933763,
-0.0155946361,
0.0067930175,
0.0021934987,
-0.012584433,
0.014786683,
-0.0322040617,
-0.0304390248,
-0.0520383418,
0.0087602036,
-0.0392861441,
0.0625675693,
-0.0162261594,
-0.037911851,
0.0066135405,
-0.0319575965,
0.0236619916,
-0.0260190684,
-0.0174352285,
0.0189033709,
0.0421842299,
0.0173839983,
-0.0578783862,
0.0156578217,
0.0022377539,
-0.0540371612,
0.0236012712,
-0.0278449543,
0.0328825675,
0.0005108368,
-0.021788355,
0.0146295354,
-0.0676261261,
-0.0014154642,
-0.0393775068,
-0.020197168,
-0.0087915696,
0.0082971761,
0.1028207839,
0.0337185785,
-0.0859224498,
-0.0048268707,
-0.0186059233,
-0.0019678108,
0.0150730191,
-0.0033452688,
-0.1268220842,
0.0244005248,
0.0001248004,
0.0008116278,
-0.0299230628,
-0.0383315571,
0.0391782038,
-0.0972727016,
0.0379481688,
-0.0139900334,
-0.01698987,
-0.0401123613,
-0.0553642735,
0.0054238699,
-0.0307268016,
0.0048727789,
-0.0199502967,
0.0054717986,
0.0186417941,
0.0241561402,
-0.1017150804,
-0.0468199179,
-0.0304191913,
-0.049721159,
0.0420512296,
0.0163549986,
0.0749824941,
-0.0358323008,
-0.0215176605,
0.0322154537,
0.044745665,
-0.0125117581,
-0.0156256873,
0.1162685603,
-0.0275972113,
-0.0011886463,
-0.0685703084,
0.0171520784,
0.0234506652,
0.017423762,
-0.0060880021,
0.0598205402,
0.0044491384,
-0.0200024005,
-0.0576503947,
-0.0020079699,
0.019835582,
0.0542107858,
0.0189796705,
-0.0136604654,
-0.0389312431,
-0.0579306409,
0.0508287996,
-0.0073146028,
-0.03250641,
0.0099501042,
-0.0017119413,
-0.0444261022,
-0.0526524112,
-0.0228338297,
-0.0140914693,
0.002171587,
0.031668324,
-0.053452976,
0.0175211318,
-0.0389271975,
-0.06767416,
0.0265463088,
-0.0003265994,
0.0188872144,
0.0092726815,
-0.0170596894,
-0.0204933044,
-0.018173594,
-0.0440291055,
-0.03848828,
-0.005245789,
-0.0252185278,
0.0656234771,
0.006651714,
0.0142581323,
0.0307697579,
-0.0150026465,
-0.0218021087,
0.0738060176,
0.0364116132,
-0.0377294794,
-0.0315846577,
0.0098249288,
-0.0103868945,
-0.0062640794,
-0.0106349448,
-0.0246831365,
0.0511619672,
0.0032622383,
-0.0547567941,
-0.0339682363,
-0.0342347212,
-0.0268354341,
-0.0182158537,
0.1065800637,
0.0188956559,
0.014358161,
-0.0524923839,
-0.0173427574,
-0.0152088013,
-0.0089524714,
0.024631476,
-0.0220061708,
0.0457557924,
0.0018681485,
-0.0750796646,
0.0052844835,
-0.0493105911,
0.0011806998,
-0.0454896316,
0.0609229654,
0.0406111553,
0.0665386543,
0.0184787773,
-0.0061654774,
-0.0287945773,
-0.0010923998,
-0.0139427213,
0.0281156301,
0.006757183,
0.0033118043,
0.022904316,
-0.0029278384,
0.0035034947,
0.006239193,
-0.0484197102,
0.0227597989,
-0.0217058528,
-0.0061716964,
0.031457983,
-0.0201206617,
0.0158970412,
0.0059517939,
-0.0216862541,
0.0189014152,
0.0029122217,
0.0226899609,
0.0043906136,
0.0403391235,
-0.0121780299,
-0.0158408862,
0.0134108737,
0.0336131975,
0.0170257073,
0.078853108,
-0.030283561,
-0.0800698996,
-0.0050256168,
-0.000252947,
0.0098904576,
-0.0110672712,
-0.0176010337,
-0.0401442945,
-0.0727502555,
-0.0247189142,
0.0396722257,
-0.0139238983,
0.0274510793,
-0.0011949864,
-0.0250009205,
0.0544444099,
0.0050712498,
-0.0163666122,
-0.0157542005,
0.0385814421,
-0.0540349819,
-0.0342721604,
-0.004127942,
-5.643866129e-33,
0.0219040513,
-0.0574210435,
-0.0395878628,
-0.0041782404,
-0.0062074796,
0.0167122968,
0.0074561313,
-0.0169887189,
-0.0253448188,
0.0396476462,
0.0180345383,
0.0188789386,
0.015253678,
0.002224091,
0.0130460141,
-0.0016199247,
0.0281434171,
0.0079566715,
0.0059475861,
0.0112578403,
-0.0391334631,
0.0223988201,
0.0376085602,
-0.0721703842,
0.0670152977,
0.0044666105,
0.0141358329,
0.0178624317,
0.0174522474,
0.0349491648,
-0.0100057973,
0.0579512082,
0.0424831025,
-0.0204222444,
0.0035479371,
0.0594059937,
-0.0433883406,
-0.0186101813,
-0.0027692846,
0.0401899591,
0.0260877665,
-0.0184365492,
0.0479427911,
0.0230053607,
-0.0387970284,
-0.029111173,
0.09626697,
-0.0081247138,
0.0075882594,
0.0342728309,
-0.0378671959,
0.0429819711,
-0.0400452651,
0.0345212221,
-0.0087695494,
0.0321638137,
0.0529777855,
0.0660975501,
-0.047178492,
0.0142189795,
-0.0181976594,
-0.0089818519,
-0.013283425,
-0.0329024978,
-0.0064923433,
0.0782577246,
0.0613470972,
0.0453439914,
-0.0575293563,
-0.0332305431,
0.0250369404,
-0.0020668912,
0.059358269,
0.0779494867,
0.0055374019,
-0.0261159949,
-0.061726965,
0.0068523735,
0.0132706733,
0.0060532186,
0.0634965524,
-0.0500512756,
-0.0529698767,
-0.0244732853,
-0.0184382666,
-0.089503102,
-0.0140976589,
-0.0009249138,
-0.000675397,
-0.0017237543,
0.0228280704,
0.0551734194,
-0.006833178,
-0.0320000276,
-0.0377506092,
0.0520168506,
-0.0286527723,
0.0157266352,
-0.0220295768,
0.0131951729,
-0.0634421781,
0.0174642317,
-0.0006991341,
0.0538194962,
0.0401243009,
0.0091838986,
0.0435471907,
-0.0320029557,
-0.0852395669,
-0.003239763,
-0.0043614986,
-0.0325778052,
-0.0015041518,
0.0456394181,
0.0505772829,
-0.001835921,
0.0181239285,
0.0506535284,
0.0198073592,
0.0503621139,
-0.0194106232,
-0.0172355566,
-0.025436651,
0.016338367,
-0.0317752026,
-0.0390021019,
0.0138531895,
0.0351969451,
0.004543751,
-0.0804995149,
-0.0032116559,
-0.0572230928,
2.471e-7,
0.0627143085,
0.1126799434,
0.0153958853,
-0.0328129791,
0.0366337076,
0.0189529434,
0.0357773006,
0.0299366992,
0.0168640669,
0.0518688262,
0.004167709,
0.0046987063,
0.0035788375,
0.0291351192,
-0.0765232593,
-0.0047740093,
-0.1100797802,
0.035125684,
-0.040525049,
0.0110717518,
0.0369687006,
0.0359879956,
0.0086211255,
-0.0134058464,
-0.0267419294,
-0.0017930013,
0.0271553677,
-0.0313332751,
0.0254289247,
0.0253165755,
0.0412310287,
-0.058284793,
0.0041148551,
0.0146194594,
-0.0052593746,
-0.0170943663,
-0.0108731315,
0.0255207717,
-0.0172962397,
0.0520050414,
0.0215703193,
-0.043581754,
-0.003550061,
-0.0810456574,
0.0447836556,
-0.0211034752,
-0.0115085058,
-0.0906121582,
-0.0451117419,
-0.008918399,
0.0979268625,
0.003081064,
-0.0084476061,
0.007452507,
0.0183032583,
0.0109656816,
0.0291537549,
-0.0783559084,
-0.0094694048,
0.0071897698,
-0.0388749205,
-0.0067756558,
0.0036131819,
0.0217324439,
0.0401008502,
-0.0306390133,
0.0584505014,
2.131205237e-34,
0.0283565316,
-0.0096885432,
0.0002880361,
-0.0349481441,
0.0268851779,
-0.0081062848,
0.0590812676,
-0.0176075865,
0.0010370782,
-0.0524916723,
0.0185040869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13475v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13475v1 | Machine Translation to Control Formality Features in the Target Language | 2023-11-22T15:42:51 | 2023-11-22T15:42:51 | Harshita Tyagi, Prashasta Jung, Hyowon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Formality plays a significant role in language communication, especially in
low-resource languages such as Hindi, Japanese and Korean. These languages
utilise formal and informal expressions to convey messages based on social
contexts and relationships. When a language translation technique is used to
translate from a source language that does not pertain the formality (e.g.
English) to a target language that does, there is a missing information on
formality that could be a challenge in producing an accurate outcome. This
research explores how this issue should be resolved when machine learning
methods are used to translate from English to languages with formality, using
Hindi as the example data. This was done by training a bilingual model in a
formality-controlled setting and comparing its performance with a pre-trained
multilingual model in a similar setting. Since there are not a lot of training
data with ground truth, automated annotation techniques were employed to
increase the data size. The primary modeling approach involved leveraging
transformer models, which have demonstrated effectiveness in various natural
language processing tasks. We evaluate the official formality accuracy(ACC) by
comparing the predicted masked tokens with the ground truth. This metric
provides a quantitative measure of how well the translations align with the
desired outputs. Our study showcases a versatile translation strategy that
considers the nuances of formality in the target language, catering to diverse
language communication needs and scenarios. | [
0.0779728368,
0.0138240689,
-0.024379516,
0.0437245965,
-0.0218813736,
-0.0092663718,
0.0076601161,
0.0175877996,
-0.0446058512,
-0.0407621115,
0.0023913323,
-0.0245650653,
0.0256535672,
0.0398052558,
-0.0170528349,
-0.0663224831,
0.0236478131,
0.025619017,
0.0379800536,
0.0013354949,
0.0160341542,
0.0364930294,
0.0376884937,
0.0475011654,
-0.0169267002,
0.0132424766,
0.0199000835,
0.0564701296,
0.0112746404,
-0.0116707981,
-0.004015605,
0.0571902618,
-0.0183267966,
0.0393201895,
0.0000021341,
-0.0432737209,
-0.0109849116,
0.0205291864,
0.0060070143,
-0.002964441,
0.0289818514,
-0.0675932616,
0.0142295202,
0.0270515233,
-0.0559180789,
-0.0225339457,
0.086706087,
0.0181170441,
0.0513097048,
0.059739735,
-0.0273431093,
-0.0332398079,
0.0041757752,
0.0009514698,
-0.0896517932,
-0.0302170757,
-0.0096821981,
0.0098330872,
-0.0926679,
0.0311508011,
-0.0174324457,
0.0400817282,
-0.0053920858,
-0.0204607192,
0.0223495197,
-0.0245179832,
-0.0254864041,
-0.0423637927,
0.0074729654,
0.0294657964,
-0.003323484,
-0.0356318653,
0.0027344183,
0.0006236546,
-0.0244525708,
0.00530985,
0.0018999642,
-0.0028514892,
-0.0157521777,
0.0176023208,
0.0090114158,
0.0528581366,
0.0222902447,
0.0119110318,
0.0074484278,
0.0193567853,
0.0050681033,
-0.0081956554,
-0.0507023558,
-0.0283665061,
0.0406334698,
-0.0356561355,
0.0640991703,
-0.0139706358,
0.025581453,
0.0219573621,
0.0025763283,
-0.0766194016,
0.0173722859,
-0.0931725353,
0.0060041267,
0.0580719039,
0.0033301234,
0.0019158386,
-0.005983714,
0.0131177539,
-0.0055781086,
0.0632261857,
-0.0574732274,
-0.023310354,
-0.0105018392,
-0.0249639619,
-0.0552919991,
-0.003994171,
-0.0623676963,
0.0023734672,
-0.0403215252,
-0.0008617192,
-0.0246864203,
0.0083250953,
0.0262943897,
-0.0260182805,
-0.0590627156,
-0.0126228547,
0.0315625295,
0.0063020526,
-0.0311536137,
-0.0105690658,
0.0066595338,
-0.0532172211,
0.0499148332,
0.0055711563,
-0.0035594818,
-0.0075990511,
-0.045077879,
0.0629646629,
-0.0088117532,
0.0156710856,
-0.012535234,
0.0010662427,
-0.0070274579,
-0.0430513211,
-0.0223194528,
-0.0559076592,
0.0584623814,
0.0287156068,
0.0299314559,
-0.0539306663,
0.0117173232,
0.004095925,
-0.0027916925,
0.0663138777,
0.015049045,
0.0138188768,
0.076397188,
0.0132837957,
-0.0058093872,
0.0340800062,
0.0594212897,
0.0086666122,
0.0837286413,
-0.0489305332,
-0.0072356048,
0.0684250742,
-0.018137509,
0.0040130904,
-0.0619439296,
0.0042442624,
-0.0024108053,
0.0223835055,
0.0249832775,
0.0701026693,
0.0183013827,
0.0473816916,
0.012169023,
0.0208461769,
0.0009116619,
0.0647289902,
0.046621874,
0.0581535511,
0.0290188696,
0.0071813026,
-0.0178104565,
0.0109481225,
-0.0582907088,
-0.0139131015,
0.0141476486,
0.0076321135,
0.0110559333,
-0.0399502739,
-0.0308191683,
-0.0017031912,
0.0559051372,
-0.0270715356,
0.0311443135,
0.0389855914,
-0.0416513197,
0.0206316765,
0.0080579259,
-0.0465184152,
-0.0021756827,
-0.0062322211,
-0.0373170376,
0.0613967031,
0.0066339909,
0.0381639153,
0.0119059095,
-0.0234253481,
-0.0287107509,
0.0482597798,
0.0375716463,
-0.0109755425,
0.0148370294,
-0.0259380601,
0.0162918661,
0.0634807572,
-0.0041398453,
0.0194383804,
-0.0041770088,
0.0283172317,
0.0479319617,
-0.0059155598,
-0.1056721732,
0.04290938,
-0.015848564,
-0.0250825807,
0.0407996476,
0.006440985,
0.0450162143,
0.0159378182,
0.0165119413,
-0.013054668,
0.0022608254,
-0.0244729221,
0.0030490938,
0.0761170387,
-0.0309870038,
0.0157961715,
0.0009236773,
-0.0405338742,
0.0020591873,
0.0317758508,
-0.0272240993,
-0.0589407869,
-0.0212459397,
-0.0195740424,
0.0325061418,
-0.0502180234,
0.0291279051,
-0.0170124322,
0.0313576497,
-0.0339088701,
-0.0215835776,
-0.0050914302,
-0.042700287,
-0.0206248593,
-0.0585589707,
0.041040875,
0.016072914,
-0.0323356614,
0.0391083471,
0.0220641345,
0.0166674536,
0.0410369448,
0.0069255061,
-0.0314822346,
-0.0177231897,
-0.0857156366,
-0.0268634222,
-0.0227794629,
0.0041663419,
0.0131704584,
0.0305275638,
0.0098020313,
-0.0030887963,
-0.0015303,
-0.0119503625,
-0.0114257066,
-0.0148484558,
0.0260160547,
0.0328751244,
-0.0264988411,
-0.0089781238,
-0.0004135434,
-0.0122130429,
0.0229535606,
0.0232836902,
-0.0416261517,
-0.071852304,
-0.0270145424,
0.0094244396,
-0.013221126,
-0.0020118426,
-0.0828255713,
-0.023865046,
0.011979131,
0.0206415951,
0.0104748011,
0.0183091406,
-0.0072751711,
0.0284568164,
0.0137768462,
-0.048573371,
-0.0341288187,
0.0061100414,
-0.0035005319,
-0.0227648597,
-0.0835506544,
0.018383285,
-0.000873151,
-0.0031881514,
0.010900965,
-0.0644181669,
-0.0466557518,
-0.0410304777,
-0.0237771925,
0.0006024567,
0.0020944118,
-0.0277359392,
0.0818485469,
0.0027367249,
-0.0167668536,
0.047706794,
-0.0081002675,
-0.0241602287,
-0.0056459988,
0.0328020453,
-0.0180225968,
0.0389908254,
-0.0228286311,
0.020294901,
-0.0268404502,
-0.0381091423,
-0.0065786759,
-0.0239732023,
0.0340120308,
-0.0364528969,
0.0274470225,
-0.0606761053,
-0.0059532588,
-0.005565959,
-0.0203261636,
-0.014256496,
-0.0008566311,
-0.0022740003,
0.0195745546,
0.0009524026,
-0.039855592,
0.022374291,
0.0272309706,
-0.0717741773,
0.033729516,
0.0219886191,
0.0065368218,
-0.0098613761,
-0.0197267551,
0.0145223858,
-0.0207067542,
-0.0076503307,
-0.0071346662,
0.032914456,
-0.0144649995,
-0.0189011805,
-0.0321399271,
-0.0269000921,
-0.0671746656,
0.0601531863,
-0.0288134404,
-0.0296655744,
0.0281628873,
0.0296332184,
-0.0484019145,
-0.0008152953,
0.1086647883,
0.0275279731,
-0.0212526079,
-0.0028574439,
-0.053599298,
0.0040963087,
0.0011266876,
0.037460193,
-0.0865258574,
0.0089329043,
0.0244782008,
0.0134403268,
-0.0176482387,
0.0046329075,
-0.0043199509,
-0.108090207,
-0.0067193625,
0.0316317417,
-0.0590878054,
-0.0055297115,
0.0158670619,
-0.044934988,
-0.0211189352,
0.0598309524,
-0.0392242633,
-0.0032266006,
-0.0512563325,
0.0185326226,
-0.0367666632,
-0.0264722239,
0.0109895766,
-0.0479796939,
0.0251973551,
0.0092959506,
0.0490414053,
-0.0634493157,
-0.0217872038,
0.0465722382,
0.0623543523,
0.0090516284,
-0.0040830835,
-0.0009018402,
-0.0068409285,
0.0004630007,
0.0075851595,
-0.0020828724,
0.0232484918,
-0.0157136321,
0.0121632218,
0.0294842031,
0.010166293,
-0.000452676,
0.0062709088,
-0.0045013619,
0.0125928372,
0.0321051292,
0.0065892702,
-0.0504807942,
-0.0051473812,
-0.0451111905,
0.022122059,
-0.0321233422,
-0.0158766527,
-0.0083731376,
-0.037780907,
-0.0898723379,
-0.0853871629,
-0.0418464839,
0.0258732457,
0.0106977876,
0.060181316,
0.0075694341,
0.0166246518,
-0.0076213349,
-0.0341768526,
0.0203171987,
-0.0300427396,
0.0249630567,
-0.0365615524,
-0.004804214,
-0.0329837129,
-0.017593082,
0.015636066,
0.0106221158,
-0.0312385131,
-0.0616668798,
0.0261832271,
0.080651395,
0.0174979605,
0.034257967,
-0.030727772,
-0.0458235964,
-0.0176224802,
0.0241724961,
-0.0159237664,
-0.0320195928,
0.0700121894,
-0.0084627159,
-0.0055026016,
0.0444979556,
-0.0057409368,
-0.009332587,
-0.0312782936,
0.0208526067,
0.0030752732,
-0.0305168312,
0.040644981,
0.0395102687,
0.0415380858,
-0.0809844062,
-0.062810041,
-0.0217452217,
-0.0028392076,
-0.0108197154,
-0.0514848828,
-0.0315414518,
-0.0141853783,
0.0248779729,
0.0277455691,
-0.0015342414,
-0.0119687319,
-0.0447799489,
-0.0126463752,
-0.0022702541,
0.0305880643,
-0.0029106741,
0.0895325989,
0.0231722463,
0.0233272333,
-0.0212396141,
0.0280927531,
0.0372021683,
0.0197969396,
-0.0021879182,
0.0262373313,
0.0200268887,
0.0568094216,
0.0012966663,
0.02005977,
0.0645781681,
0.0113594867,
-0.0177219138,
0.0298571028,
0.0509276576,
-0.0300685335,
0.0799218565,
-0.0158936121,
0.0000924136,
-0.0025940607,
0.0449932069,
-0.0166817643,
-0.040537294,
0.0174564887,
-0.0318587385,
-0.0123242624,
0.0251182429,
0.0296551269,
-0.0375943594,
-0.003502961,
-0.0006052649,
-0.0067660422,
-0.0106939077,
0.0097640669,
0.0180389099,
-0.0041351975,
0.0014962597,
-0.0181522779,
-0.0607277937,
-0.0662540868,
-0.0011477988,
-0.036274258,
0.0315159149,
-0.026347477,
-0.0142280152,
0.0694100857,
0.0032237223,
-0.0218974482,
-0.0707570761,
-0.0301183909,
0.0563721322,
0.0287349652,
-0.035218969,
-6.215540256e-33,
-0.0133704236,
-0.0404069573,
-0.0443920754,
0.0618466847,
-0.0111656375,
-0.0347384959,
-0.0300495755,
-0.0223858897,
0.0086229956,
0.049451232,
-0.0524817072,
0.0012092106,
0.0350447185,
-0.0225447305,
0.0658376887,
0.0136232264,
0.0564838164,
0.0412665643,
-0.0414168127,
-0.0111299437,
0.0644468889,
-0.0000593268,
0.0976314247,
-0.0923401117,
0.0883174837,
-0.0180221442,
-0.052139964,
0.0104568936,
0.0103736408,
0.0027952611,
0.0136595527,
0.0034837374,
0.0057490314,
0.0220278669,
-0.0101169804,
0.0203840639,
-0.102670148,
0.0303951465,
0.0572592877,
0.0925787017,
-0.0137009565,
-0.075741753,
0.0387899689,
-0.0780639574,
-0.0430094935,
0.0169775728,
0.0057774847,
-0.0446603559,
-0.0147696966,
-0.0624278523,
-0.087242499,
0.031423755,
-0.0106174881,
0.0346683972,
0.0231184624,
0.0557250753,
-0.0228970237,
-0.04903147,
-0.0661074519,
-0.0126029663,
-0.0018361934,
-0.0068131844,
0.065322347,
0.0235711038,
-0.0197842345,
-0.0225519016,
-0.0069571813,
-0.009902522,
0.0276626572,
-0.0248313099,
0.0406547077,
0.0220165905,
0.0203976519,
0.0393105745,
0.0840925574,
-0.0681806579,
-0.0193723831,
0.0267178174,
-0.0483890623,
0.0357102416,
0.0330410413,
0.0014654355,
-0.054397583,
-0.0375224501,
-0.0182211883,
-0.0119391559,
0.0079014935,
-0.0451069213,
0.011662161,
-0.0299571827,
-0.0491285846,
0.0279760379,
0.0452352352,
-0.0727140382,
0.0272749811,
-0.0249487627,
-0.0161325336,
0.0296496507,
-0.0131292706,
0.0623229817,
-0.0094648898,
-0.0587897375,
0.0033996622,
0.016951466,
0.0134926541,
-0.0050803334,
0.061467398,
0.0081193168,
-0.0708040893,
0.0072935876,
-0.0265606325,
-0.0090092644,
-0.0312866867,
0.0062317597,
0.0377862453,
0.0134416409,
-0.0181186646,
-0.0203370452,
0.0283084176,
0.0483571403,
-0.0341296755,
0.0478447825,
0.0436875112,
0.0107804053,
-0.0456238277,
0.0110290637,
-0.0092707844,
-0.074911505,
0.0694066063,
0.0118688187,
-0.0156369638,
0.0090084793,
2.889e-7,
0.0279162955,
0.0772543326,
0.0112585127,
0.0075125904,
-0.0502447337,
0.0000398642,
-0.0173211042,
0.0168682393,
0.015082038,
0.0536430217,
0.0389434658,
0.0055672289,
0.0815313384,
0.0299083982,
-0.1318306327,
-0.0409854166,
-0.0721048266,
0.0037528232,
-0.016539814,
0.0050077015,
-0.0321930461,
0.075595215,
0.030430181,
0.0176348835,
-0.0354404822,
-0.0214902889,
0.0566816032,
-0.025085045,
0.0296810251,
0.0418050066,
0.0160694104,
0.010310241,
0.0063489764,
0.0055388454,
-0.0335847102,
0.0063375421,
0.0502702072,
0.1093261763,
-0.0075310939,
0.0560022444,
-0.0076825013,
-0.0350313261,
-0.0040466459,
-0.0502374582,
0.0066729649,
-0.0127616767,
-0.0347201563,
-0.0073191752,
-0.0265366174,
0.0369601324,
0.0138958506,
-0.0199443679,
-0.0192682333,
0.0535538457,
0.0411154479,
-0.0365151539,
-0.0052433228,
-0.0023872296,
-0.0470234305,
-0.032418523,
0.0187506657,
-0.0077725258,
0.0192134157,
-0.0147164706,
-0.0112863872,
-0.0123015707,
0.0317132063,
2.584844349e-34,
0.0776738226,
0.0011951069,
-0.0015782039,
0.0271589123,
0.0341931656,
-0.0102104712,
0.0142240878,
0.0393798649,
0.0248338729,
-0.0219735466,
0.0034961288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13472v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13472v1 | Complexity-Guided Curriculum Learning for Text Graphs | 2023-11-22T15:40:57 | 2023-11-22T15:40:57 | Nidhi Vakil, Hadi Amiri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Curriculum learning provides a systematic approach to training. It refines
training progressively, tailors training to task requirements, and improves
generalization through exposure to diverse examples. We present a curriculum
learning approach that builds on existing knowledge about text and graph
complexity formalisms for training with text graph data. The core part of our
approach is a novel data scheduler, which employs "spaced repetition" and
complexity formalisms to guide the training process. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed approach on several text graph tasks and graph
neural network architectures. The proposed model gains more and uses less data;
consistently prefers text over graph complexity indices throughout training,
while the best curricula derived from text and graph complexity indices are
equally effective; and it learns transferable curricula across GNN models and
datasets. In addition, we find that both node-level (local) and graph-level
(global) graph complexity indices, as well as shallow and traditional text
complexity indices play a crucial role in effective curriculum learning. | [
0.0540595576,
-0.00976549,
-0.0165399872,
0.0238145888,
-0.0231075622,
0.0151580581,
-0.0023531595,
-0.0301876385,
0.0418969952,
0.003815013,
0.0191204641,
-0.0015291579,
0.0287652351,
0.0286329817,
0.0258568544,
-0.067503944,
0.022309022,
-0.0108338576,
0.0005219225,
-0.0069985422,
0.002485211,
0.0348124877,
0.0121787041,
0.0016955124,
-0.0057382896,
-0.0199217666,
-0.0210060328,
0.0295357816,
0.017389385,
-0.0329209529,
0.0108381249,
0.018647138,
0.041169554,
0.0264810435,
0.0000020708,
0.0101625398,
-0.0175314397,
-0.0131264841,
-0.0235027634,
0.0046236501,
0.0786295235,
0.0030198067,
0.0239980314,
0.0222629774,
0.0081948088,
0.0257292688,
0.0304696634,
-0.003653961,
0.012905865,
0.06767115,
-0.0348552018,
-0.0162855759,
0.0036142736,
-0.0302483179,
-0.0241054147,
-0.0332298763,
0.0384944081,
0.041231174,
0.0233911891,
0.0194874946,
-0.0726146027,
-0.0043463558,
0.0509158857,
-0.0081550954,
0.0895188078,
0.0201277453,
0.0191388521,
0.0265916809,
-0.0094034327,
0.0971554443,
-0.0328630991,
-0.0027233835,
0.0138906576,
-0.0633169487,
0.0202502403,
-0.0376173705,
-0.0338633507,
-0.0430997051,
-0.0193023495,
0.0187530816,
-0.0295653921,
-0.0089354813,
0.0144762024,
-0.0189784542,
-0.0019288484,
-0.0028077443,
-0.0238755737,
-0.0174618401,
0.0532853529,
-0.0067862687,
-0.0114278253,
-0.0312267207,
0.0181580037,
0.0495572798,
-0.0143695101,
0.0065964404,
-0.0536535382,
-0.0467170142,
0.0003366762,
-0.0084852809,
0.0255292431,
-0.033794973,
-0.0144076245,
0.0382351279,
0.0141771166,
0.1149094179,
-0.0008567672,
0.055615738,
-0.0483785123,
0.0174640063,
-0.0537225232,
0.0157339219,
-0.0628397092,
0.0147141051,
0.0246357638,
-0.0546853431,
-0.0356105827,
0.0288422983,
-0.0175596625,
0.0529425479,
0.0458456054,
0.0336786173,
-0.0476027355,
-0.0097038569,
0.014258408,
0.030856479,
-0.0083552841,
0.017247187,
-0.0072214804,
0.0314423628,
0.0125975385,
0.0146038942,
0.0715729296,
0.0134547343,
0.027970789,
0.0255807173,
-0.0321526006,
-0.0115094464,
-0.0492655076,
-0.0171527602,
-0.0494889207,
-0.028412275,
0.0350160785,
-0.0964087918,
0.0044855047,
-0.0282268282,
-0.0084277829,
-0.01759905,
-0.0029130031,
0.0133833857,
-0.0433298573,
0.0164173786,
-0.0124397036,
0.0050243791,
0.0117050987,
-0.010822433,
0.0129401311,
0.0233029164,
0.0362517871,
0.0698341802,
0.0493544601,
-0.0027815013,
-0.0356206931,
0.0316802002,
0.0272790678,
-0.0168376286,
0.0075748763,
-0.0009496507,
-0.0221546069,
0.0226284452,
-0.0038302657,
0.0496849939,
-0.0481250398,
-0.0508961715,
0.0304849837,
0.0304090884,
-0.0097580934,
-0.0341558382,
0.0595214628,
0.0631961226,
0.0136235142,
0.0567368418,
-0.0306582693,
0.0119757792,
0.0370381474,
-0.0017706588,
-0.0026162027,
-0.0369719937,
-0.016858181,
-0.0633928403,
0.0167218335,
-0.0187957063,
0.0662779883,
-0.0417524315,
0.0633353665,
0.0236192998,
-0.0551271029,
-0.0839141682,
0.044254262,
0.0095708929,
0.0142731424,
0.0280483216,
-0.0365810916,
0.1132063419,
0.0337368995,
-0.0278134234,
-0.0620555691,
0.0258337595,
0.0695874989,
-0.0048789927,
0.0292858221,
-0.0498908795,
0.0086693708,
-0.0567095242,
-0.0486558527,
-0.0251481161,
-0.0065518301,
0.0364139974,
0.034389656,
0.005311904,
0.0056524822,
-0.0544025153,
-0.0803289264,
0.0148157049,
-0.0278187767,
-0.0454408526,
0.0136323525,
0.0162484795,
-0.0082257632,
0.0144725582,
0.0200599395,
-0.0097054122,
-0.0034996714,
-0.0181524809,
-0.0009477434,
-0.0480914824,
-0.0702481419,
-0.0478182137,
0.0327045433,
-0.0316545703,
-0.0371258035,
0.030629104,
-0.0522741191,
-0.0301669985,
0.0302338172,
-0.0534458905,
-0.0125694517,
0.0212101694,
-0.0214552563,
-0.0291293953,
-0.0222504158,
-0.0139473947,
0.0340973884,
-0.0118375113,
0.012306246,
0.0349846706,
0.0075572273,
0.0051737344,
-0.0402660146,
-0.0059733456,
-0.0122007262,
0.0148024177,
0.0014046996,
0.0113995764,
0.0169327017,
-0.0565209761,
-0.0274619367,
-0.0878290534,
-0.0109334933,
-0.0191412438,
0.0035124642,
-0.0003024188,
-0.0257126819,
0.0102119884,
-0.0453120433,
-0.0710059181,
0.0770364776,
-0.0264549907,
0.0049606245,
0.0406024009,
0.0151994443,
-0.0324590839,
-0.0228312109,
-0.0487832204,
-0.0118353218,
0.0682808906,
0.0394003801,
0.0048747933,
-0.0122590214,
0.0163672101,
-0.008840302,
0.0011556111,
-0.02808192,
-0.0178212132,
0.0175590105,
0.0022374243,
0.0358938202,
0.0442750752,
-0.0083387261,
0.0314943902,
0.0280461796,
0.0078086108,
-0.0146148652,
0.0059936591,
-0.0580677055,
-0.0242649559,
-0.063090466,
-0.0101504903,
-0.0023921896,
0.0251121502,
-0.002951043,
-0.0135383578,
-0.0778250992,
-0.0361099839,
-0.0378581807,
0.0013295801,
-0.0169232097,
-0.0195752662,
0.0091522932,
-0.0558862165,
-0.0398676656,
-0.0081876311,
0.0447703078,
0.0044529536,
0.0057610599,
-0.0107783275,
-0.0403097011,
-0.0308243074,
0.0641863868,
0.0805435479,
0.01537978,
0.0269962754,
-0.0366724506,
-0.0693066791,
-0.00805806,
0.0535624661,
-0.0257322285,
-0.0020931934,
-0.0284145251,
-0.0171852689,
0.0023944806,
-0.0305667631,
-0.0343536474,
0.0562170856,
0.018645592,
0.0268728714,
0.057521455,
-0.0476040877,
0.0166520402,
-0.0709422976,
-0.0348408632,
0.0585431084,
-0.0193405002,
-0.010232917,
-0.024884861,
0.0400247127,
0.0368594714,
0.0111257834,
-0.0207737852,
-0.0602384731,
-0.0226287488,
0.0525699705,
0.027823152,
-0.0381692126,
-0.0468160883,
0.0304534882,
-0.0273782704,
-0.0091410484,
0.0069554951,
0.0261544753,
-0.0077097807,
-0.0443357788,
0.0066079549,
0.0632550046,
0.0021133095,
-0.0719340146,
0.0043024025,
0.0211581402,
0.0329503827,
0.0222565513,
0.0191561412,
-0.0639254898,
0.0191384126,
-0.0245432779,
0.0433923081,
-0.0010164679,
-0.027791461,
-0.0385649614,
-0.0236487277,
-0.014155088,
0.0371402241,
0.0153462654,
-0.0274593085,
-0.0566879623,
-0.0325801931,
-0.0135869905,
0.0098450379,
-0.0407633595,
-0.018825721,
-0.0089618973,
0.0476260334,
-0.0419799984,
-0.0397199653,
0.0066749733,
0.0210635178,
0.0139377508,
-0.0337905809,
0.0167183354,
0.0057526915,
0.0221241545,
0.0573852211,
0.0429583713,
-0.026166467,
0.0054344255,
0.0658758879,
0.0173969548,
-0.0011986375,
-0.0263563953,
0.0302370284,
0.0087385699,
-0.0158748142,
0.0085720513,
0.085336566,
0.0411666669,
-0.0378565043,
0.0018725644,
-0.0175482295,
0.0253181513,
-0.0034315679,
0.0497941487,
-0.042683892,
-0.0139683615,
-0.0252555013,
0.0282066371,
-0.1156948134,
-0.0341507085,
0.018823998,
-0.015333686,
0.0289931856,
-0.0506671518,
-0.019230023,
0.0302810222,
0.0288267471,
-0.0169655979,
-0.0258766133,
0.0965010002,
-0.0230968948,
-0.1023541093,
-0.0298276599,
-0.0171084534,
0.0209654812,
-0.0407191999,
-0.0346093699,
-0.031578064,
-0.0067637158,
-0.0407123975,
-0.0078321109,
-0.1197806448,
-0.0415970571,
-0.0158755127,
0.0002093698,
-0.0000316202,
0.0679885894,
0.0212737229,
-0.0166173261,
0.0872204676,
0.0168421008,
0.012107037,
0.0066512353,
0.0493117981,
-0.0302622914,
-0.0214070696,
0.0275263209,
-0.0571719594,
0.0296460446,
0.0299998242,
0.0028569438,
0.0034203667,
0.035806112,
-0.0064985934,
0.0363083817,
-0.0072121597,
0.0423930548,
-0.0069608921,
-0.0877137408,
0.009945753,
0.0045184903,
-0.0192787871,
-0.027908003,
-0.0231475197,
0.0046103401,
0.0218232162,
-0.0309576765,
-0.0506346188,
0.067283079,
0.0187110435,
-0.0571320914,
-0.0232654084,
-0.0347891785,
0.0105784601,
0.0553837642,
0.0051823282,
-0.0459016822,
0.0375301428,
-0.0024075373,
0.0014219122,
-0.0181526728,
-0.0076884627,
0.0327781662,
-0.0020636511,
-0.0442788154,
-0.0060927928,
-0.0438246764,
0.0281016901,
-0.0367460363,
-0.0158406198,
0.0235571135,
-0.0004996078,
0.0088022249,
-0.0281025376,
0.0135008087,
-0.0213297773,
0.0332402587,
-0.0143213542,
-0.0644050464,
0.0049883388,
0.0181684773,
0.0218136664,
0.011833841,
0.0732274279,
0.0914217606,
0.0209109113,
0.0303531531,
-0.0242682211,
-0.0438603573,
-0.0333831944,
-0.0199219082,
0.0692886412,
0.0186084919,
0.0329602882,
-0.0131460968,
-0.0495364405,
0.0440101326,
-0.0051842425,
0.0107687507,
0.017353911,
0.0355241746,
0.0241721105,
-0.0054569147,
-0.0189928468,
-0.0099284314,
0.0456265956,
0.0078180982,
-0.0373811573,
0.0173372086,
-6.014634312e-33,
-0.0095190471,
-0.0851188153,
0.0320015214,
0.0463898033,
-0.0419375226,
0.0648371577,
-0.0342439972,
-0.0175229702,
-0.006282486,
0.0635823086,
-0.0035059953,
0.0200982057,
0.00084941,
0.0464747883,
-0.0119168842,
-0.0049896012,
0.0488191806,
-0.0086889947,
-0.0032665229,
0.0715346262,
0.0334917009,
0.0166477878,
0.0449522622,
-0.0676279515,
-0.0193769075,
0.0113694407,
0.043101538,
0.0034927421,
0.0562283471,
0.0604854971,
0.0115400562,
0.0598503463,
0.0403007753,
-0.0085295234,
-0.0209745076,
0.0032658554,
-0.1052936912,
-0.0946824178,
-0.0397618674,
0.0292476043,
-0.0468424745,
-0.0455056354,
0.0501614884,
-0.0145684062,
0.0116900466,
-0.0734403059,
0.0603923351,
-0.0009932119,
-0.0306563079,
0.0026290091,
-0.0600711592,
0.03074315,
-0.0051413621,
0.0300297644,
0.0109288609,
0.0106442655,
0.0265013054,
-0.0128751416,
-0.0282947104,
0.0185227655,
-0.0271592196,
0.0251157768,
-0.0178174898,
0.0413152277,
0.0167573616,
0.0550806299,
-0.0239790007,
0.0517097525,
-0.0448611826,
0.0191627797,
0.037123207,
0.0536954999,
0.0037773389,
0.0190731585,
0.0015785659,
-0.0258597117,
-0.0793586224,
-0.02633054,
-0.0056631919,
0.0209591668,
0.0012542052,
-0.0230509657,
-0.0334002078,
-0.0598097518,
-0.0044906591,
0.0299685374,
-0.0045621837,
0.0220147315,
-0.0014828278,
0.0268788282,
-0.0316347107,
0.0297710877,
-0.0172085632,
-0.054309722,
-0.0150195928,
0.1072481647,
-0.0091486592,
0.0498208478,
0.0066126911,
0.0226730276,
-0.0769798234,
-0.0298345294,
0.0348135345,
-0.0150852613,
0.039176926,
0.0238307007,
0.0675751418,
0.0444553196,
-0.0353700928,
-0.0341943391,
-0.0386961624,
-0.0144631946,
-0.0076301908,
0.0163007453,
0.0277411137,
0.0152640184,
-0.0247448478,
0.0470123217,
0.0211192295,
-0.011211643,
-0.009479139,
-0.0043737921,
0.0070681982,
0.0517688543,
-0.0433204733,
-0.0283546299,
-0.030870026,
0.0260052439,
0.0376103409,
-0.0554136075,
-0.02017501,
-0.0065792222,
2.568e-7,
0.0057447855,
0.051587794,
0.0525424741,
0.0252515972,
0.04072107,
-0.0131412046,
0.0013482758,
0.04341463,
-0.0446484238,
0.018660428,
0.0732832998,
0.0504127108,
0.010071855,
0.0188099351,
-0.0351256728,
0.0166428741,
-0.0625282377,
-0.0263133496,
-0.0238846485,
0.0069752112,
0.0318370834,
0.0030537047,
0.0586433075,
0.0112740723,
0.0023888154,
-0.0367697328,
0.0066162781,
0.0048075342,
0.0756476149,
0.0110293897,
-0.0046659731,
0.0343257971,
-0.0294771008,
0.0255058818,
-0.0167977195,
0.0285632554,
0.0283703301,
0.0603692234,
-0.0216891691,
0.0321265012,
0.0243006181,
-0.0360825546,
-0.0410557278,
-0.0275238827,
0.041403003,
-0.0595792942,
0.0253574084,
-0.009492361,
-0.00872574,
-0.01601962,
0.0071428535,
0.0308991875,
-0.0111516146,
-0.003978976,
0.0379542261,
-0.00207599,
0.0345644876,
-0.0693230927,
0.0487357192,
0.0105279358,
-0.0172302984,
-0.0173609555,
-0.0531853475,
0.0227827169,
-0.0056300964,
-0.0069193877,
0.0416310914,
2.351322064e-34,
0.0528957732,
-0.0395465083,
-0.0052821427,
-0.0787926316,
-0.0103099216,
-0.0227752719,
0.0095590493,
0.0060220258,
0.041024521,
-0.1042072102,
-0.0281505175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13455v1 | Generation of Explanations for Logic Reasoning | 2023-11-22T15:22:04 | 2023-11-22T15:22:04 | Yanyi Pu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | This thesis delves into a fortiori arguments in deductive reasoning,
underscoring their relevance in various domains such as law, philosophy, and
artificial intelligence. The research is centred on employing GPT-3.5-turbo to
automate the analysis of these arguments, with a focus on understanding
intricate reasoning processes, generating clear and coherent explanations, and
creating novel arguments. The methodology encompasses a series of tasks
including detailed reasoning, interpretation, and the augmentation of a
fortiori arguments. It involves meticulously identifying these arguments in
diverse contexts, differentiating comparative elements, and categorizing them
based on their logical structure.
Extensive experiments reveals the challenges encountered by GPT-3.5-turbo in
accurately detecting and classifying a fortiori arguments. Nevertheless, the
model demonstrates a performance that rivals specialized models, particularly
in extracting key components and interpreting underlying properties. The
integration of external information into the model's processing significantly
elevates the quality of the generated explanations. Additionally, the model
exhibits a noteworthy capability in augmenting arguments, thus contributing to
the enrichment of the data set.
Despite facing certain limitations, this thesis makes significant
contributions to the fields of artificial intelligence and logical reasoning.
It introduces novel methodologies, establishes a rigorous evaluation framework,
and provides deep insights that set the stage for future advancements in
automated logical reasoning. The findings and methodologies presented herein
not only underscore the potential of AI in complex reasoning tasks but also
highlight areas for future research and development. | [
0.0085134069,
0.0134359198,
-0.0099579915,
0.025853673,
-0.055433698,
0.0110645164,
-0.0003567075,
-0.0244242046,
-0.0281585995,
-0.0195499416,
0.0750749186,
0.0305607244,
0.0088723954,
0.0002881032,
0.0124793863,
-0.0690037236,
0.0102481842,
-0.0133253541,
0.0346480682,
-0.0084097488,
0.0062459558,
0.0465851277,
-0.0210374519,
0.0355182737,
-0.0253707822,
-0.0185382888,
-0.0389452204,
0.010091288,
0.0207027178,
-0.0470109433,
-0.0559621044,
0.0198102072,
0.0381727442,
0.0196815245,
0.0000024158,
-0.0356675163,
-0.0262971502,
0.0017361057,
-0.0541728735,
-0.004592333,
-0.0198501702,
0.0134465136,
0.0217430964,
0.0056112171,
-0.0409485996,
0.0357685648,
0.0438000374,
0.0500463545,
0.032359615,
0.0634737611,
0.0005031506,
-0.0394149683,
0.0125913275,
0.0022793969,
-0.0341978408,
-0.0206908099,
-0.020588126,
0.0453675017,
0.0377756432,
0.0028276623,
0.0321497694,
-0.0191637371,
0.0509173051,
-0.0157468207,
-0.0142797232,
0.0064920178,
-0.0334025882,
-0.0116415126,
0.0133236814,
0.0253035501,
0.0166927129,
-0.0654612929,
0.0020295817,
0.0107211322,
0.0097322939,
-0.0012689466,
-0.0409230739,
0.0605930835,
-0.031810239,
0.0284259841,
0.0825867131,
0.0294562448,
0.0268292185,
0.0004471501,
-0.0316393226,
0.0675808489,
-0.025395086,
-0.0269440245,
0.001159696,
0.0198016446,
-0.0401470363,
-0.0662105381,
0.0145249451,
0.0769109577,
-0.0168562848,
0.0256587192,
0.0077423658,
0.0005905447,
0.0289319791,
-0.0291433465,
0.0247672554,
0.0291028172,
0.0126913637,
0.0094077364,
-0.0268055648,
0.012776426,
-0.0104008056,
0.0039760265,
-0.0161951184,
-0.0273956116,
-0.0851828903,
-0.0325907916,
-0.0238924082,
0.0751591325,
-0.0217026584,
0.0203622654,
-0.0248744339,
-0.026040528,
-0.0437341817,
0.022557592,
0.0131975897,
0.0065607084,
-0.0276950691,
-0.0433514379,
-0.0440863781,
-0.0133755337,
-0.1006681174,
0.0391403213,
0.0236849505,
-0.0167569332,
-0.0058523044,
-0.0031740342,
-0.0041489718,
-0.0147096356,
-0.0166068245,
0.0661966577,
0.0065659969,
0.0328988843,
-0.0720024556,
-0.0673129261,
0.0034658678,
-0.0512479506,
-0.009411023,
-0.0399458408,
-0.0012465435,
-0.0281589627,
-0.0188349355,
-0.0356941409,
0.0126447743,
0.0161331184,
0.0255990084,
0.0440780818,
-0.0702523366,
-0.006982014,
0.0056045209,
0.0172052141,
-0.0347724818,
0.019501958,
0.0121971332,
0.0165698361,
0.0121094836,
-0.0131048905,
0.0174165759,
-0.0504768863,
0.0213471837,
-0.0070524258,
-0.0132256318,
-0.001480369,
-0.0950180963,
0.0010068271,
-0.0236762017,
0.0049214712,
-0.0244486853,
0.0027845427,
0.0163677968,
0.0341402404,
0.0326313749,
0.0431411825,
0.0762345046,
-0.0238940511,
-0.0020950399,
0.0306769386,
-0.0184498429,
0.0450010598,
-0.0168342069,
-0.0097561413,
-0.0462405123,
0.0404169932,
-0.0119774463,
-0.0863546357,
0.0198120754,
0.0004508092,
0.007612993,
-0.0007474053,
0.0269619897,
0.0022594612,
0.0064421813,
-0.0261524953,
0.0097857853,
-0.0529090427,
-0.0404022038,
-0.0537247919,
0.0322368294,
0.0270828865,
0.0330031067,
-0.0426376909,
-0.0293430258,
-0.0081303567,
-0.0250075031,
0.0496961623,
0.0416181386,
-0.0164353028,
-0.0134042539,
-0.0482513867,
-0.0315301269,
-0.0507262647,
0.0415541194,
0.0445505939,
-0.0069269664,
-0.000904186,
0.0394656882,
-0.0317471474,
0.0481530763,
0.0107122911,
0.0142386714,
-0.0139674116,
0.0030992527,
0.0085121533,
0.0098406821,
0.0441464335,
0.0219118763,
0.0209775623,
0.0123993438,
0.0046992232,
-0.0194148291,
0.0270200111,
-0.001291277,
0.0229721386,
0.0143096717,
-0.064656198,
-0.0181564465,
0.0000868006,
-0.0447612405,
-0.0325821601,
0.0098867873,
-0.0317528695,
-0.0187496208,
-0.0280855522,
-0.00676414,
0.0188137516,
-0.0213994645,
-0.0069284667,
0.0998034775,
0.05178155,
-0.0619249754,
0.0005682525,
-0.0215378068,
0.0729167685,
-0.0863894224,
0.0766342878,
-0.0078307819,
-0.0249553006,
-0.0098271891,
0.0284120757,
-0.0083391834,
-0.0190300532,
0.0308073275,
-0.0569851361,
0.007987177,
-0.003962162,
-0.005841563,
-0.0056097237,
-0.0392139442,
0.0142983701,
0.0160399284,
-0.0183667205,
-0.0137165664,
-0.0013524509,
-0.012839797,
0.0498822406,
-0.0186395776,
-0.0483170711,
-0.0010793777,
-0.0122108897,
-0.0501658358,
0.0256384742,
0.0326072723,
0.0073684533,
-0.0038541828,
-0.0440154411,
-0.0236221049,
-0.013533636,
0.0148019688,
-0.0081818271,
0.0363180414,
-0.010186146,
-0.0366709642,
0.0697581619,
0.0099298209,
0.0524411611,
0.0262305588,
-0.0265896395,
-0.0203091037,
0.0129471114,
-0.0298268273,
0.0619527698,
-0.0247651841,
-0.0529853143,
0.0027153555,
0.0076219607,
-0.002402331,
0.0260922741,
-0.0763085186,
0.0903226733,
0.003968162,
0.0076680365,
0.014510164,
-0.0426526144,
0.0195718557,
0.1087576747,
0.0161732715,
-0.0204739925,
0.0724626631,
0.00091707,
0.0650773793,
-0.0343997627,
-0.0270559508,
-0.0324915498,
0.0741505623,
-0.0293806661,
0.0140259359,
0.0097953025,
0.0249975212,
0.0034962553,
-0.0448719785,
0.0838294551,
0.0141423633,
0.0410725176,
-0.0734936893,
-0.0086065494,
0.0026317367,
-0.0298048295,
-0.0148448134,
-0.0101617789,
-0.0464185961,
-0.0212910995,
-0.0508840159,
-0.0072977957,
0.0040536295,
0.002963451,
-0.0085639441,
-0.0034361836,
0.0031837015,
-0.0086654071,
-0.0245765224,
-0.021995306,
-0.0196760576,
0.0061574508,
0.0359991379,
0.0100741917,
0.0320197679,
0.0112672206,
0.0080016181,
-0.0051469342,
-0.0712725222,
0.0113628805,
-0.0641479343,
-0.0205626618,
-0.018600272,
0.0002120057,
0.0156277735,
-0.0756457299,
0.0074397135,
0.0740894303,
0.0023608056,
0.0283442177,
0.0211125948,
-0.0262410287,
-0.0091216527,
-0.0326939523,
0.0278399438,
-0.0692785829,
-0.0242495406,
0.0102589726,
0.0246872995,
-0.0534029119,
-0.0153029757,
0.0050597475,
-0.0818270668,
0.0849680454,
0.0142264105,
0.024639735,
-0.0284568239,
-0.0277713928,
-0.0136321215,
-0.0043758419,
-0.0471906513,
-0.0053526205,
0.0379321128,
0.018003162,
0.0114303501,
0.0149548938,
0.0098268408,
0.0229816772,
0.0192876868,
0.0150143346,
0.0228974,
0.0601249076,
0.0069386237,
-0.0494283698,
-0.0160793085,
0.0045523257,
0.0067023225,
-0.0102567356,
0.0129126897,
0.0291937348,
0.0261026472,
-0.0420588292,
0.0426122732,
-0.0078131706,
-0.064804025,
0.0641817003,
0.0916062295,
-0.0551163405,
-0.0401934981,
-0.0313727148,
0.0146639468,
-0.0252723079,
0.0686896071,
0.0402398445,
0.0503626801,
-0.0557329841,
-0.0534145422,
-0.0493187606,
-0.0771152079,
0.0010190778,
0.0080082081,
0.0215788297,
0.0015014951,
-0.0119681666,
-0.0323712453,
-0.0112606827,
0.0351563431,
0.0033769677,
-0.0176499616,
-0.0168611333,
0.0116992975,
-0.0336665586,
0.0117835766,
0.0053479425,
-0.0147508569,
0.0501529835,
0.0222614594,
-0.0209848974,
-0.0339114033,
-0.0023285558,
0.0303648189,
0.0417609662,
-0.0154668447,
-0.0115504172,
0.0390654877,
0.0336310975,
0.0286681559,
0.0002472619,
-0.0243590027,
0.0112083703,
0.0162044819,
0.0031340446,
-0.0046024187,
0.0686764047,
-0.0576961748,
-0.0011744164,
0.009721986,
-0.0009701326,
0.0578080565,
-0.0267571323,
0.020414466,
-0.0467125177,
0.0058853454,
0.0627689213,
0.0278383102,
0.0061019552,
0.0176863838,
-0.0139148496,
-0.0085274912,
0.017379364,
-0.0795434937,
-0.0067592585,
-0.0250477102,
0.0484680347,
0.0062831445,
-0.0104621509,
-0.0007531935,
-0.069550477,
-0.0397058353,
-0.022623349,
0.0045776125,
0.0273769684,
0.0407443866,
0.0226786826,
-0.025841577,
-0.0311764721,
-0.0291173849,
0.016279703,
-0.0332238562,
0.0721281096,
-0.0366526097,
0.0674058571,
0.0627235472,
-0.0137094259,
-0.0177608971,
-0.0165157449,
-0.0723280758,
-0.0313359983,
0.0327854082,
-0.0129160946,
0.0270670839,
0.0090239318,
0.0255439989,
-0.0486221649,
-0.0068582599,
0.060251642,
0.0719637275,
0.0382016152,
-0.0141572775,
0.0001509587,
0.0199583918,
-0.0313745365,
-0.0383032784,
0.0265563838,
-0.0624189489,
-0.0058586048,
0.0085927648,
-0.0111124367,
-0.0352324657,
-0.086149089,
-0.0558139198,
0.0443437211,
0.0317330025,
-0.0104519045,
-0.0618051365,
-0.0318446606,
-0.0612090603,
0.0442165211,
0.0148077467,
0.010700291,
0.0090652332,
0.059406288,
0.0106573161,
-0.0803934932,
-0.0004982552,
0.0256196074,
-0.0776948184,
0.033059828,
0.026646845,
-6.485719551e-33,
-0.0363701507,
-0.0653489754,
0.0289228093,
0.0314933322,
-0.0149952425,
-0.0444144346,
-0.0660554245,
-0.0419190414,
-0.0251704697,
0.0660670847,
0.0000103336,
0.0269943438,
0.0132698892,
-0.0145886671,
-0.0089308694,
0.007403384,
0.0020964213,
0.044126939,
-0.0264007524,
0.0269518942,
0.020943895,
-0.0401574858,
0.0217945315,
-0.0832306221,
0.012608177,
-0.0023270349,
-0.049115885,
0.0096691307,
-0.0751505047,
0.0502318181,
0.0102549754,
0.0057569584,
0.0183490533,
-0.0458425283,
0.040102981,
0.0105506061,
-0.0486670062,
-0.0370358936,
0.0289616212,
-0.0571524687,
-0.044316534,
-0.0611640103,
-0.0053883386,
0.0252728164,
0.000273503,
-0.0314681046,
0.0366239958,
-0.0306164213,
0.0331520699,
-0.0261537451,
-0.062992394,
0.0438144132,
-0.0715822652,
0.000338899,
0.0044715158,
0.0316900238,
-0.0019439693,
-0.0095071942,
0.0014850153,
-0.0009968202,
0.0300428439,
-0.0467954762,
0.0500222929,
-0.0473745167,
-0.0104130646,
0.0135115655,
-0.0089309048,
0.0116432356,
-0.0749672279,
0.0503487624,
-0.0450090505,
0.0890915245,
0.0820046291,
0.0411377214,
0.0477373712,
0.0199233331,
-0.0893388987,
0.0059010782,
0.0358002558,
0.0321036689,
0.0446997546,
-0.032511387,
-0.0456941128,
0.0017113526,
-0.0220390689,
-0.0648998395,
-0.0085897669,
-0.0447277799,
0.0105453059,
-0.0029408843,
-0.0392806754,
0.0349321105,
-0.0019345435,
-0.0212695636,
0.065756768,
0.0020958623,
0.0066275839,
-0.0144383321,
-0.0099118082,
0.0066805575,
0.0348209478,
-0.0164668877,
0.008153053,
0.0214561224,
0.0573876649,
0.0129473489,
0.0268588327,
-0.0178446397,
0.0348696597,
-0.0014300008,
-0.0349143147,
0.020140009,
-0.0227358826,
-0.026933467,
0.0047987541,
0.0735428035,
0.0134515958,
0.0211095512,
0.0089861592,
0.0233758148,
-0.02905933,
0.0018564456,
-0.0038547015,
0.0102090351,
0.0141415047,
-0.026661681,
-0.0104130572,
-0.0207534358,
0.0427133366,
-0.0437369831,
-0.0012319603,
0.0394657329,
3.013e-7,
0.0364841931,
0.0265817102,
0.0465332046,
0.0091858432,
-0.0049025952,
0.0542424917,
-0.002164616,
-0.0263149738,
0.0059687574,
-0.0396285132,
0.0241874009,
0.0675627217,
0.0282938331,
0.0740242004,
0.0033512476,
-0.0417696461,
-0.010343601,
-0.0828691795,
-0.0820828304,
0.0643026382,
0.1219230816,
0.0353379846,
0.0393388458,
-0.021152718,
0.02474159,
0.0010261852,
0.0303563904,
0.0149411093,
0.0107044671,
0.0124633843,
0.0675253123,
-0.0363162085,
0.0153450817,
0.0509203523,
0.0082501629,
0.0067853546,
-0.0433413796,
0.074791342,
-0.0301538948,
-0.0307896752,
-0.010856064,
-0.0502966903,
0.0509889573,
-0.0733162016,
0.0532509163,
-0.0495798439,
-0.0293404069,
0.0207620114,
-0.0239700731,
-0.0173978694,
-0.0293620769,
0.0055694142,
0.0195608959,
0.0070677991,
-0.0095584467,
-0.0217549056,
0.0108678276,
-0.0924420655,
-0.0237357914,
0.0476204678,
-0.0171909239,
0.0411587842,
0.010160909,
-0.0032583205,
0.0701824874,
-0.0151429381,
-0.0195884779,
2.815716261e-34,
0.0056428174,
0.0005979711,
0.020038167,
-0.0138011677,
0.0808028802,
0.0335497595,
-0.0362450778,
0.0249219947,
0.0342666544,
-0.0507645682,
-0.0159908775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13350v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13350v1 | Fact-based Court Judgment Prediction | 2023-11-22T12:39:28 | 2023-11-22T12:39:28 | Shubham Kumar Nigam, Aniket Deroy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | This extended abstract extends the research presented in "ILDC for CJPE:
Indian Legal Documents Corpus for Court Judgment Prediction and Explanation"
\cite{malik-etal-2021-ildc}, focusing on fact-based judgment prediction within
the context of Indian legal documents. We introduce two distinct problem
variations: one based solely on facts, and another combining facts with rulings
from lower courts (RLC). Our research aims to enhance early-phase case outcome
prediction, offering significant benefits to legal professionals and the
general public. The results, however, indicated a performance decline compared
to the original ILDC for CJPE study, even after implementing various weightage
schemes in our DELSumm algorithm. Additionally, using only facts for legal
judgment prediction with different transformer models yielded results inferior
to the state-of-the-art outcomes reported in the "ILDC for CJPE" study. | [
0.0544587411,
0.0308617,
-0.0088945506,
-0.0033591599,
-0.0719132274,
0.0230605025,
-0.0099344049,
0.0380930901,
-0.0199974589,
-0.0380170494,
0.0269947946,
-0.0191057753,
0.0102306865,
0.0155005185,
-0.0678531006,
-0.057028506,
0.0143204518,
0.0203473177,
0.0783447176,
0.0188821331,
0.0329170376,
-0.0093921479,
-0.0168050695,
0.0380611457,
-0.0570337735,
0.0010126485,
-0.0205758549,
-0.0147457691,
-0.0361895785,
-0.0208663084,
0.0117047802,
0.0797481239,
0.0200581662,
-0.0099708419,
0.0000019676,
-0.0580380112,
-0.0050482769,
-0.0066894884,
-0.0235120561,
0.0001518107,
0.0111770965,
-0.0311345179,
-0.0050185332,
0.0044655618,
-0.0309276693,
-0.0075253313,
0.0155618209,
0.0895346403,
0.0393548049,
0.1058062166,
-0.0023787578,
-0.0794965997,
0.0242013205,
0.0017051102,
0.0241429154,
-0.0207739454,
0.0028317238,
0.0477751419,
0.0109227654,
-0.0350216404,
0.0090666469,
-0.0427212529,
-0.0017093014,
-0.0209232271,
-0.0214373637,
-0.0062073553,
-0.0194152128,
-0.0014648928,
0.027165683,
0.0286975279,
0.0857506469,
-0.0494729802,
-0.0022124003,
0.0322436206,
0.0421326458,
0.0415213183,
-0.0086698923,
0.0695069209,
-0.025793869,
0.045261465,
0.047677733,
0.0660677776,
-0.0486432575,
-0.0075527448,
0.0080747874,
0.0573914349,
-0.0103101488,
-0.0318017676,
-0.023463903,
0.0468711853,
0.0403361619,
-0.0341500975,
0.0286850389,
0.0220298599,
-0.0170185976,
0.0082364939,
0.0166974477,
-0.0097507332,
0.038586814,
-0.082799837,
0.0057113254,
0.0248489175,
-0.0228820089,
0.0595657825,
-0.023689298,
0.0018428611,
0.0163361598,
0.0171605237,
0.0040763812,
-0.0428105555,
-0.0049637998,
0.0096329357,
0.0267870706,
0.0527855121,
-0.0686633736,
0.0162524395,
-0.0628812015,
0.0054665231,
-0.012603756,
-0.0000197546,
0.0671204776,
-0.005055822,
-0.024631476,
-0.0156635102,
-0.0870807022,
-0.0157551467,
-0.039730534,
0.0309447851,
-0.020456465,
0.0134807881,
0.0107398508,
0.0051317322,
-0.0253456216,
0.0076367259,
-0.0092622479,
0.0899369642,
-0.0007611223,
-0.0358545966,
-0.0703661293,
-0.0376610532,
-0.004281315,
-0.0806971714,
-0.0742074624,
-0.0738334209,
0.0061644954,
0.0132656861,
-0.034226086,
-0.0252764989,
0.0248316042,
0.0343978368,
0.0006250463,
0.079948239,
0.0281907022,
-0.0116683394,
-0.0147376955,
0.0091441656,
0.0266938955,
0.0054579345,
-0.0239796899,
-0.0082437834,
0.0033099444,
-0.0192606337,
0.0796835199,
-0.0012332516,
-0.0145812305,
-0.0073873079,
-0.0160047244,
0.008012102,
-0.026961891,
-0.0224692822,
0.0068683475,
0.0010602591,
0.0163184404,
0.0054490156,
0.0201203357,
-0.0232924167,
0.0350088626,
0.0655491054,
-0.0571881533,
-0.0188399926,
0.0473638363,
0.0192929823,
-0.0343886837,
0.0437820517,
-0.0208835993,
0.024266785,
-0.0453267433,
-0.0086127399,
-0.0176236387,
-0.0384611599,
-0.0064263842,
-0.0181028228,
-0.012183507,
-0.0404051244,
0.0267251506,
0.0036343005,
-0.0235659089,
0.0470997393,
0.0726230964,
-0.0152122993,
-0.0394763947,
-0.0299523193,
0.0310775563,
-0.0267522726,
0.0333980694,
-0.035628017,
-0.0076357285,
0.0120602129,
-0.03406002,
0.0092198104,
0.0164324343,
0.021730965,
-0.0409574211,
-0.0018637183,
-0.0356806442,
0.0803018212,
0.0269247722,
-0.0006593069,
-0.0248445198,
0.0113656595,
0.0135415066,
-0.056714315,
0.0375098251,
0.0245570112,
0.0205958709,
0.0119549185,
0.0378487557,
-0.016642604,
0.0603798963,
0.0058304286,
0.0091601396,
-0.034986876,
0.0362633355,
0.0338386558,
-0.0270571318,
0.041392874,
-0.0049380213,
-0.0443823375,
-0.0036532902,
-0.070341818,
0.0378127918,
-0.0042355177,
-0.0153350439,
-0.0212496389,
-0.0124565475,
-0.0174638107,
0.0186635591,
-0.0483547486,
0.0243461132,
-0.0000120915,
-0.0436392874,
-0.0089114793,
0.0416333675,
-0.0216981489,
-0.0466462411,
-0.0262182169,
-0.0377150886,
0.0363902375,
-0.0062359483,
-0.0292322487,
-0.0477263555,
-0.016128011,
-0.0181379169,
0.0199111477,
0.0053811832,
-0.0442099869,
-0.0314302221,
-0.0602984987,
-0.0115205469,
-0.0246495884,
-0.0133765489,
0.000578048,
0.0154104596,
-0.012378416,
-0.0057855654,
-0.0139810871,
-0.0395652354,
0.0257639196,
-0.0076843328,
0.054568544,
-0.0200255886,
0.0102348169,
-0.0005976232,
-0.0242731161,
-0.0304136034,
0.0551777557,
0.0109011102,
-0.0272970833,
-0.0357345901,
0.0808733478,
-0.0126785776,
-0.0122761903,
-0.056106355,
-0.0075782114,
-0.0280177146,
-0.0022902344,
-0.0137030669,
0.007697843,
0.0709171668,
-0.0079913773,
-0.0122231878,
0.003694423,
-0.0590694174,
-0.0022679921,
-0.0330929048,
0.0499856956,
0.0079209954,
-0.0108429911,
0.0035880231,
0.0213936996,
0.0215188283,
0.0134723559,
-0.0158527028,
-0.013313489,
0.002146597,
0.0224265046,
-0.006850061,
-0.0095077278,
-0.0263899192,
0.0564315803,
0.0332634486,
-0.0511738509,
0.0841160715,
0.0184542686,
0.0475039072,
-0.0782912299,
0.0156534389,
-0.0700065866,
0.0303276498,
0.0019366629,
-0.0206347909,
-0.0614152476,
-0.0240336321,
0.0351172574,
-0.0009635928,
0.0587075092,
-0.0242502019,
0.0997100174,
-0.0003010698,
0.0468190312,
-0.0112917116,
-0.0369906239,
-0.0316872708,
-0.0425580554,
0.0402052999,
-0.0238002855,
0.0562373474,
0.0167779885,
-0.0482735001,
0.063027896,
-0.0280961376,
-0.0170672201,
0.0056939949,
-0.0423640497,
0.0019075549,
0.0108497096,
-0.0150375552,
-0.0092129568,
0.057553608,
0.0080193644,
-0.0120626958,
0.0161202811,
0.0059346282,
-0.0161166582,
0.0069578476,
-0.0156672727,
0.01394046,
-0.0526423715,
-0.0225340016,
0.0284031052,
0.0004919388,
-0.0084645227,
0.013893812,
0.0828876123,
0.0172871146,
-0.0575819388,
-0.0323214978,
-0.0229550395,
0.006443358,
0.0177224632,
0.0117660351,
-0.094909206,
0.0030686148,
0.00898817,
-0.0006269129,
-0.0215548705,
-0.0469280668,
0.0039284937,
-0.0678951517,
0.0535135232,
0.0001023539,
0.0599755198,
-0.0560438074,
-0.0713626295,
0.0010819676,
-0.0465339795,
-0.0530894771,
0.0136590321,
-0.0130344955,
-0.0107820518,
0.0265046172,
-0.0743311942,
0.0316764377,
0.0164907631,
-0.0248607118,
0.0220727678,
-0.0055843932,
-0.0096097086,
-0.0438132212,
-0.0209897812,
-0.0111506954,
-0.0445954241,
0.0020144705,
-0.0144797582,
0.0416665748,
0.0158051308,
0.0127280401,
-0.0530654229,
0.0338897407,
0.0251610223,
-0.016811816,
0.0404135808,
0.0498056784,
-0.0553688183,
-0.0414936058,
-0.0367513262,
-0.0116469199,
-0.010659677,
0.0639249682,
-0.0177497137,
-0.012785201,
-0.0281428974,
-0.0142975654,
-0.0164968092,
0.0251134336,
-0.0124122435,
-0.0327608995,
-0.0293517374,
-0.0211710799,
0.0018805835,
-0.0052052783,
-0.0276306942,
0.061216224,
0.0007531711,
-0.0069883568,
0.0242356937,
-0.0094361799,
-0.0179099347,
0.012602658,
-0.002984938,
-0.0060322676,
-0.0589367189,
0.0588749573,
0.0331669636,
-0.010975129,
-0.0168246534,
-0.031106852,
0.0054229135,
-0.0039371126,
0.0262742732,
0.0266873594,
0.0246365909,
0.0019277498,
-0.0258978587,
-0.0052738907,
0.0827559158,
0.0270234998,
-0.0095399246,
-0.0255331025,
0.0493440628,
-0.0612783134,
-0.0066067986,
-0.0239130333,
0.0197727643,
0.0636225566,
-0.0033523473,
-0.0031132768,
-0.0305734072,
-0.0327498764,
0.0369289033,
0.0166447163,
0.0858815834,
0.006758363,
-0.0234626457,
-0.0128902514,
0.0126699619,
-0.0188781861,
0.001565841,
-0.0085663134,
-0.0248730313,
0.0430930518,
0.0590320975,
-0.0383750126,
0.0529160351,
-0.0197434667,
-0.0007258849,
-0.0245585609,
0.0651215762,
0.0668920279,
-0.0017065931,
0.0132510867,
-0.0455655158,
0.0153246066,
-0.0290655475,
-0.0008996266,
0.0291034579,
-0.0209237784,
0.0929713994,
-0.006743575,
0.0174928084,
0.0050072288,
-0.0145929586,
0.0097506903,
0.0658754706,
-0.0070539569,
0.0282451604,
0.0169547275,
-0.0286983866,
-0.0253297817,
-0.0534873083,
0.0233304892,
-0.0046264934,
0.0425583608,
0.0069276905,
0.0197958127,
0.0333654508,
0.0075480905,
-0.0250480436,
0.0106523698,
0.0344281234,
-0.0543558113,
-0.0034326012,
-0.0293837693,
-0.060050182,
-0.0407798104,
-0.035106685,
-0.0451904982,
-0.0030183818,
0.0064641824,
-0.0650262088,
-0.1167663336,
0.0118804416,
0.0067297211,
-0.0205239393,
0.0301245451,
-0.0339771919,
0.0087629249,
0.0390043482,
0.0450732484,
0.0187855959,
-0.0476095937,
-0.0100985533,
-0.0013691919,
0.0003569456,
-0.011981599,
-5.584538929e-33,
-0.0270808171,
-0.0336817205,
-0.0098813195,
0.0540748313,
0.019588368,
-0.0131769441,
0.0145082437,
0.0052005444,
0.0013280261,
0.0346533507,
-0.0196092762,
0.037064407,
0.0215763878,
-0.0239315126,
0.039608743,
-0.0187430754,
0.0052358033,
0.0281386096,
-0.0161304269,
-0.019304717,
0.0174859669,
0.0106552849,
0.0316045359,
-0.1108357459,
0.024060389,
0.0380121395,
-0.0334203579,
-0.0159040224,
-0.0483392887,
0.0483320355,
-0.0034000191,
0.0155505612,
0.0368613563,
-0.0903707445,
0.0045995554,
0.0264686886,
-0.0576614551,
0.016864216,
0.0081251636,
0.0133607555,
0.0590889528,
0.0166376345,
0.0080377497,
0.009475504,
-0.0687058643,
0.0130052688,
0.0172888935,
-0.0149633847,
-0.0337885059,
-0.078781262,
-0.0480442047,
0.0595492236,
0.0016650438,
0.0085799703,
-0.0084233563,
0.0055508451,
0.0170611348,
0.0095432755,
-0.1088011637,
0.0134760505,
-0.0144510288,
-0.002705982,
0.0039617652,
-0.0487155169,
-0.0455787778,
0.0349390358,
-0.0105566243,
-0.0029804152,
-0.0730411857,
-0.020092424,
0.0279868841,
0.0608701371,
0.0323446244,
0.0388339348,
0.0523243658,
-0.0801982805,
-0.0578333996,
0.0592180416,
0.025744129,
0.0530321971,
0.0429169945,
-0.0481431484,
-0.0876818225,
-0.0191413853,
0.0187500808,
-0.0080678705,
-0.007055359,
0.0110406363,
-0.0097019803,
-0.0124441907,
0.0585717708,
-0.0322457179,
0.0013574258,
-0.0194356348,
0.0355252773,
0.0604789481,
-0.0276140608,
0.0317955278,
-0.0144318976,
-0.00464141,
-0.0439758599,
-0.0395024605,
-0.0009366125,
0.014459434,
-0.0195512883,
-0.0186477844,
0.0634457022,
-0.034504164,
-0.0521234199,
-0.026456533,
0.0224961396,
0.0339569002,
0.023594249,
0.0359944813,
0.0142715257,
0.0114049111,
0.0035853907,
-0.0246421248,
0.026256904,
0.0621913448,
-0.017119918,
-0.0207424071,
0.0476509742,
-0.002632451,
0.047956571,
-0.005574842,
-0.0154043306,
-0.0085368818,
-0.0196035355,
-0.0019154603,
0.0177915469,
0.0808767825,
2.674e-7,
0.0470800027,
0.0610554628,
-0.0115362089,
-0.0067062909,
-0.0141181313,
0.0385017507,
-0.0020426756,
0.0128955599,
0.0395916887,
-0.0083599202,
0.0484396666,
-0.00231463,
0.0236787982,
0.0429418087,
-0.0778306201,
-0.0721802413,
-0.0376996249,
-0.0574171394,
-0.0553284846,
0.0349406786,
-0.0133866072,
0.0790179968,
0.0326399319,
-0.0219603945,
0.0072871652,
0.0340709239,
0.0449278615,
0.0174509529,
-0.0434967242,
0.002459273,
0.1319933534,
-0.0722990707,
-0.0053092921,
0.0557805039,
0.0129460469,
0.0356179141,
-0.0370806679,
0.0117833288,
0.030897202,
0.054804951,
0.0158519726,
0.0012277735,
0.0152372094,
0.0092647793,
0.0567942187,
0.003173487,
-0.0262311101,
-0.0091112107,
-0.0550555773,
-0.0183798354,
0.0148104364,
0.02946347,
-0.0235355422,
-0.0002531174,
0.0067994166,
-0.0443063937,
0.0078080008,
-0.0476130396,
-0.0115638692,
0.0664505586,
-0.016744094,
-0.0197253209,
0.0196819883,
-0.052748125,
0.1029769108,
-0.0770021677,
0.0075451112,
2.315935322e-34,
0.0592917167,
0.0102250818,
0.0059005679,
0.0011893201,
0.0462011918,
0.0356672741,
0.0116764642,
-0.0068196589,
0.002293682,
-0.0768310353,
0.0409138463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13314v1 | Mitigating Large Language Model Hallucinations via Autonomous Knowledge Graph-based Retrofitting | 2023-11-22T11:08:38 | 2023-11-22T11:08:38 | Xinyan Guan, Yanjiang Liu, Hongyu Lin, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating factual knowledge in knowledge graph is regarded as a promising
approach for mitigating the hallucination of large language models (LLMs).
Existing methods usually only use the user's input to query the knowledge
graph, thus failing to address the factual hallucination generated by LLMs
during its reasoning process. To address this problem, this paper proposes
Knowledge Graph-based Retrofitting (KGR), a new framework that incorporates
LLMs with KGs to mitigate factual hallucination during the reasoning process by
retrofitting the initial draft responses of LLMs based on the factual knowledge
stored in KGs. Specifically, KGR leverages LLMs to extract, select, validate,
and retrofit factual statements within the model-generated responses, which
enables an autonomous knowledge verifying and refining procedure without any
additional manual efforts. Experiments show that KGR can significantly improve
the performance of LLMs on factual QA benchmarks especially when involving
complex reasoning processes, which demonstrates the necessity and effectiveness
of KGR in mitigating hallucination and enhancing the reliability of LLMs. | [
0.0474013612,
0.0186316837,
-0.0160187688,
0.068758063,
-0.0582686029,
-0.0127913235,
-0.060297519,
0.0265207719,
0.0571679994,
-0.0601352826,
0.01589006,
-0.0113654658,
-0.0060481708,
-0.006196931,
0.0120357182,
0.0086688129,
0.0573053733,
-0.046499595,
0.0195206497,
-0.0336950384,
-0.0085116979,
0.0361730158,
-0.0069264453,
0.0162032414,
-0.033146292,
-0.0673197508,
-0.009064395,
-0.0167432781,
-0.0260576401,
-0.0094949445,
-0.0160718281,
0.0428747684,
-0.0417778417,
0.0475068428,
0.0000025004,
-0.0505279973,
-0.0133823287,
0.0300327782,
-0.0865097046,
0.0360344276,
0.0028512003,
0.0706048608,
-0.009543539,
0.0386326425,
-0.065074265,
0.0073082498,
0.0116102668,
0.0249949135,
0.0602761433,
0.0463601872,
-0.004480157,
-0.0213090442,
0.0023082213,
0.0342585966,
0.0037376848,
-0.02261387,
0.0160298739,
0.066807963,
0.0515218601,
-0.0276358444,
0.007435224,
0.0531207956,
0.0003111795,
-0.0322976038,
0.0104692159,
-0.0044224733,
-0.0297829155,
0.0095771821,
0.0150619093,
0.0729752183,
0.0018828728,
-0.0468648598,
-0.0107741635,
0.0022737202,
-0.0035801958,
0.0449740067,
-0.0390124954,
-0.0130342832,
-0.0520142727,
-0.0283576697,
-0.007354212,
-0.0781523064,
0.0559962653,
0.0070389197,
-0.0651175231,
0.1587186009,
0.0222888067,
-0.0356564745,
0.0026582468,
-0.0082363663,
0.0047881869,
-0.0552873649,
-0.0015278241,
0.050285954,
-0.0577827543,
0.0445134304,
0.0039223051,
0.034789823,
0.0262531675,
-0.0663531423,
0.0139440047,
0.0147122657,
-0.0019604012,
0.0317680836,
-0.0167203192,
0.0534676276,
-0.0160829984,
0.0298657529,
-0.0240796264,
0.0129664913,
-0.0676479042,
-0.0335823931,
-0.0280385111,
0.0450303741,
-0.023323305,
0.0053675938,
-0.0005479304,
0.0476208925,
-0.0370229185,
0.0618473105,
-0.0098317033,
0.0191930998,
0.0374184139,
-0.0617917031,
-0.058874324,
0.0488181487,
0.0112189399,
-0.000035041,
0.0022522574,
-0.0770763382,
-0.0020960064,
-0.0000291566,
-0.021237772,
0.0052809687,
-0.0123577137,
0.0181613602,
0.0156038394,
0.0298111737,
-0.0598291755,
-0.0814088583,
-0.0203789491,
-0.0750013515,
0.0054512946,
-0.0898496807,
0.006584737,
0.0231066793,
-0.0379510261,
-0.0439041443,
0.0019409469,
0.0091108708,
-0.0334627032,
0.0552261136,
-0.0507127866,
0.0331462622,
0.0234817602,
0.0112901535,
-0.0383958779,
0.0687267408,
0.0245358702,
-0.0066603478,
0.0341871008,
-0.0029596912,
0.0206664652,
0.0327813327,
0.0200945772,
0.010130994,
-0.0330659151,
0.0283958279,
-0.0139026409,
0.0096578002,
-0.037579231,
0.0240247864,
-0.0111465026,
0.0339901745,
0.0458972417,
0.0108353132,
0.0160616953,
0.0273171626,
0.0055270274,
0.0111944303,
0.0269023813,
0.0283956509,
-0.0490365997,
0.002226162,
-0.052480381,
0.0225128438,
-0.0143457707,
0.0035729606,
0.0017871446,
-0.0512915328,
-0.0218859669,
0.0241889916,
0.0131798917,
0.0243124943,
0.0249486603,
0.0290328786,
-0.037781097,
0.0719457567,
0.0246530883,
-0.0456085242,
-0.0111001767,
-0.0692079961,
-0.0084982421,
0.1046541929,
0.0768839046,
-0.0224091485,
-0.0650096685,
0.0226893276,
-0.0279468652,
0.0210376382,
0.0525498874,
-0.0246989727,
-0.039584741,
-0.0346277617,
-0.0248916298,
-0.0059830104,
0.0238645319,
0.003846575,
0.0031413825,
-0.0008174235,
0.0115693146,
-0.066691108,
-0.0184125919,
-0.0017327012,
-0.0283556134,
-0.0036923918,
-0.0338437445,
-0.004086128,
0.0113923298,
0.0202239342,
0.0105851227,
0.0668819472,
0.0259681437,
0.0145919668,
-0.0437299311,
0.0192204006,
-0.0206638966,
-0.0314717814,
0.0524775907,
0.0354700051,
-0.0176317487,
-0.0132892141,
-0.0192420706,
-0.0330651551,
0.0352976881,
-0.020978326,
0.0744686872,
-0.0235113818,
0.0421250127,
-0.0204199664,
-0.0297921728,
0.0063435216,
0.047089871,
0.0200829264,
-0.0173032079,
0.0179501567,
-0.0117132384,
0.0089176083,
0.0141814752,
-0.0145644573,
0.0307729505,
0.0178715885,
0.0360654369,
-0.0033785119,
-0.0217572786,
-0.0637374073,
0.0287385099,
-0.0768428296,
-0.0024352099,
-0.0188918393,
0.0369130075,
0.0083405776,
-0.0183929615,
-0.00612099,
-0.0157574564,
0.0109418854,
0.0294117033,
0.0055353367,
0.0347873494,
-0.0012123216,
0.0088105081,
0.0017646337,
0.0076509942,
0.0027841651,
-0.041452799,
0.0399427265,
-0.0012316664,
0.0076560704,
-0.0641954914,
0.0534549728,
-0.0868687928,
0.0220685229,
-0.00272635,
0.012278256,
0.0351346321,
-0.021870032,
0.0295721143,
0.0457249172,
-0.0247313008,
-0.0000347225,
0.068320848,
-0.0537766628,
-0.0501860157,
0.007619021,
0.0091299098,
-0.0107776048,
-0.0148481159,
0.0024816697,
-0.0052605597,
0.0090239421,
0.015057032,
-0.009785804,
-0.0537754782,
0.0092484429,
-0.0448935628,
-0.0110956728,
-0.015384254,
-0.0417771265,
-0.0235358607,
0.0175992921,
-0.0167686939,
-0.0185279865,
0.0676945001,
-0.0270573273,
0.0211208332,
-0.0014730457,
0.0336458124,
0.0196080878,
0.0543775037,
-0.0215021241,
0.0071785692,
-0.0046530217,
-0.0064090006,
-0.0434992574,
-0.0521427207,
0.0247280858,
-0.0696531385,
0.0483334512,
-0.0640159994,
0.0197515339,
0.0264645759,
-0.0055858023,
-0.0478784814,
0.0224086773,
-0.024487434,
-0.0152121224,
-0.0336948074,
-0.007976423,
0.0169535056,
0.0118431197,
0.0002492393,
0.0220570974,
-0.0091388579,
-0.0181539189,
0.0087430226,
-0.0086954907,
0.0403747149,
-0.0062163831,
0.0535223559,
0.0163047854,
0.0491667241,
0.0770207942,
0.056525033,
-0.0433347337,
-0.0121122189,
-0.0397799052,
0.0026205457,
-0.0332634337,
-0.033108905,
0.0093734805,
0.0181126427,
-0.0881948993,
-0.0045884806,
0.0870297179,
0.0411478467,
-0.0036454143,
0.0048425696,
-0.0382877216,
0.0453734435,
0.030319266,
0.0502311736,
-0.0843031406,
0.0054487735,
0.0054295468,
0.0211911723,
0.0109941093,
-0.0411089621,
-0.0300095733,
-0.132844314,
0.0452263579,
0.0248223394,
0.0085113551,
-0.0227203816,
-0.0026613378,
0.0074311849,
0.0461597927,
0.0054103541,
0.0438562445,
0.0079494771,
-0.0121492371,
0.010353012,
-0.0702544674,
-0.0044406601,
0.0331325606,
-0.0029571198,
0.0258940589,
0.0140831079,
0.0455424376,
0.0345523618,
-0.0358575806,
0.0062402263,
0.0031411764,
0.0200114902,
-0.0260560811,
-0.0042466195,
0.0299373362,
0.0073690293,
0.001917337,
-0.0263953451,
-0.0297362115,
-0.0290493555,
0.0180679131,
0.1248896867,
-0.0435544699,
-0.0290456451,
0.0110121872,
-0.0134715764,
-0.0050401664,
0.0342505276,
0.0165080037,
0.014345712,
-0.0550756305,
-0.0457049385,
-0.0085241757,
-0.0387909971,
-0.0376577377,
0.0590539612,
0.0293024369,
0.011583332,
-0.0668787807,
-0.0281421728,
0.0297734216,
0.0423180647,
-0.0016979284,
0.0409238264,
0.0275902227,
-0.0264403764,
-0.0351269208,
0.0103952205,
-0.0718887672,
0.0230773073,
0.010297358,
0.0415824912,
-0.0013054595,
-0.0024881696,
0.0018802618,
-0.0153565649,
-0.0129037341,
-0.0912027135,
0.0306466278,
0.0246849749,
0.0255165827,
0.0752328709,
-0.0289467461,
-0.0496838316,
0.0756311864,
0.0188368186,
-0.0390203856,
0.0005118515,
0.0267763175,
-0.0162824988,
-0.0018291327,
0.0471513756,
-0.0547243692,
-0.0259719603,
-0.00543345,
0.0542949066,
-0.0150869014,
-0.0475147404,
0.0423172526,
0.0929871649,
0.0061097476,
0.0057620625,
0.0075256424,
-0.0164290983,
0.0263268482,
-0.0498455241,
-0.0331423357,
-0.0267763063,
0.0189932063,
-0.0149053661,
-0.0367832184,
0.0259106252,
-0.0473747589,
-0.0222205501,
0.0232893005,
-0.0069250707,
-0.0181709733,
0.0218244232,
0.021709796,
0.0754887015,
-0.0101816263,
-0.005945961,
0.0082928482,
0.0177386235,
0.0371406451,
-0.0293447059,
0.0591831207,
0.0222829953,
-0.0299226642,
-0.0467021726,
-0.0092322612,
-0.0212074369,
-0.0831090137,
-0.0053726695,
0.0420246236,
0.0310390331,
0.0155923255,
0.0525168292,
-0.0541018099,
-0.0044867327,
0.0000452859,
0.014058575,
0.0267388038,
-0.0410269871,
0.0206955411,
0.0281019043,
-0.0141448574,
0.0018716626,
0.0326875411,
-0.0323773101,
0.0522837713,
-0.0027428912,
-0.0431243069,
-0.0340693183,
-0.0748043656,
-0.0272412933,
-0.0353348479,
-0.027320832,
-0.0234589223,
-0.1047467813,
-0.1011750996,
0.0034208302,
0.0118027646,
-0.0332808942,
-0.0167610161,
0.0309987646,
0.0931701437,
0.0331600085,
-0.0327782482,
-0.0374259241,
0.0262186173,
-0.0347677469,
0.0146302218,
0.0115926675,
-6.8864588e-33,
-0.0133847231,
-0.0566382781,
0.048690483,
-0.0278579574,
-0.0265395157,
-0.0431359857,
-0.0219829679,
0.0071122008,
-0.009637773,
0.0384016298,
-0.0416685455,
0.0268142819,
0.0156274606,
-0.0116934376,
-0.011008461,
-0.0000407034,
0.0331307948,
0.0047636288,
-0.0240303315,
0.0237648375,
0.0368713811,
-0.0090861805,
0.0491251424,
-0.0556979962,
0.0475720279,
-0.0124484431,
-0.0100523131,
0.0412165634,
-0.0644148961,
0.0398336649,
-0.0000492728,
0.0656171143,
0.0130562475,
-0.0229015425,
-0.0166554283,
-0.0205543041,
-0.0209626593,
-0.0364161059,
0.0504010133,
0.032687258,
0.0032189304,
-0.0159198288,
0.0509846248,
-0.0016280973,
0.0072440784,
-0.0242379438,
-0.0099221496,
-0.018098915,
-0.0336813889,
0.0344053321,
-0.0550721586,
0.0206503738,
0.0126752909,
0.010046633,
0.0007457021,
0.0230608471,
-0.0028402507,
-0.0711174235,
-0.0770750269,
0.0066374103,
-0.0032391225,
-0.0002094339,
0.0840769261,
0.0046664081,
-0.0001972172,
0.0104605891,
-0.0265651718,
0.0381673053,
-0.0369309448,
0.0021313464,
0.0057015214,
0.0711277276,
0.0482506417,
0.021810906,
0.0120296003,
-0.0293611474,
-0.0444897711,
-0.0061841533,
-0.0434228592,
0.0527288802,
0.0114160515,
0.0041769836,
-0.057125017,
-0.0329305492,
-0.0447133146,
0.0523462221,
-0.0435339659,
-0.0408263244,
0.0152718052,
-0.0301466342,
-0.0456206053,
-0.0260274969,
-0.0134183504,
-0.0612958521,
-0.0004599974,
0.0000993007,
-0.0387719758,
0.0031244578,
-0.0180531926,
0.0483868793,
0.0060533965,
0.006479091,
-0.0048065642,
0.0122556249,
0.0232161917,
0.0357741192,
-0.0233034231,
0.035213571,
-0.0501284823,
0.014699229,
-0.0549320802,
-0.0114640519,
0.0168610811,
-0.0396760367,
0.0543278679,
0.0209674872,
0.0096797412,
0.0224261452,
0.0367188565,
0.0109030241,
-0.0097617097,
0.0434934944,
0.0107999966,
0.0009914311,
-0.0214445367,
-0.0200206283,
-0.0425480753,
-0.0033380936,
0.036784783,
-0.036692109,
-0.019906478,
0.0179811958,
3.257e-7,
0.0286783092,
0.0695996508,
-0.002555304,
0.0322367251,
0.0042495267,
0.030165704,
0.0002153822,
-0.0533241071,
0.0372455753,
-0.0367466547,
0.0089688897,
0.0324661843,
0.0293273125,
0.0654688403,
-0.0787170902,
-0.0083498526,
-0.0459187925,
-0.0181456003,
-0.0434241183,
-0.028888097,
0.0540011674,
0.0147528397,
0.0192878451,
-0.0051990445,
-0.0255501363,
-0.0846006349,
0.0270176399,
0.051970724,
-0.025420161,
0.0255316496,
0.0838704854,
-0.0051500075,
0.0202659089,
0.050304383,
-0.0103864297,
-0.0107294135,
-0.0343915746,
0.0190488044,
-0.0329188593,
-0.0220657624,
-0.0288613457,
-0.0486119576,
0.0308255572,
-0.0636703447,
0.0709833801,
0.0029934447,
-0.0020795055,
-0.0283718873,
-0.0218676422,
-0.0431494303,
-0.011915477,
-0.0085238442,
0.0124192676,
0.0281458274,
0.009282412,
0.0239693727,
-0.0036691793,
-0.0524657033,
-0.0281625725,
0.0364792161,
-0.009425981,
-0.0339913815,
0.0018019587,
-0.0090580219,
-0.0039957198,
-0.0433371477,
0.043927826,
3.22780578e-34,
0.0178028531,
0.0149877155,
0.0324592143,
0.0124758082,
0.0489218161,
0.0135267377,
0.0001744139,
0.0310878977,
0.027112104,
-0.0615869313,
-0.0210698713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13307v2 | Rethinking Radiology Report Generation via Causal Reasoning and Counterfactual Augmentation | 2023-11-22T10:55:36 | 2023-12-05T10:25:23 | Xiao Song, Jiafan Liu, Yun Li, Wenbin Lei, Ruxin Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | Radiology Report Generation (RRG) draws attention as an interaction between
vision and language fields. Previous works inherited the ideology of
vision-to-language generation tasks,aiming to generate paragraphs with high
consistency as reports. However, one unique characteristic of RRG, the
independence between diseases, was neglected, leading to the injection of
disease co-occurrence as a confounder that effects the results through backdoor
path. Unfortunately, this confounder confuses the process of report generation
worse because of the biased RRG data distribution. In this paper, to rethink
this issue thoroughly, we reason about its causes and effects from a novel
perspective of statistics and causality, where the Joint Vision Coupling and
the Conditional Sentence Coherence Coupling are two aspects prone to implicitly
decrease the accuracy of reports. Then, a counterfactual augmentation strategy
that contains the Counterfactual Sample Synthesis and the Counterfactual Report
Reconstruction sub-methods is proposed to break these two aspects of spurious
effects. Experimental results and further analyses on two widely used datasets
justify our reasoning and proposed methods. | [
0.02805846,
0.0911869407,
0.0039454862,
-0.0134395659,
-0.0256636627,
0.0184144266,
-0.0139004868,
0.0404341631,
-0.0048402711,
-0.0306857247,
0.0356400162,
-0.0360128954,
0.0491269454,
0.0277751293,
0.0287962146,
-0.0882850066,
0.0289003924,
0.0059335525,
-0.0106773237,
-0.0031238592,
-0.0155732417,
0.0048241969,
-0.0210048128,
0.0046439399,
-0.0379665047,
-0.0014401287,
0.0337579735,
0.0183661431,
0.0201511551,
-0.0357688181,
-0.050579749,
0.0267883763,
-0.0095517067,
0.0046780775,
0.0000021991,
-0.0205357056,
-0.0298520178,
0.027699098,
0.0289752055,
-0.0339335017,
0.0065391599,
-0.0940306634,
0.0112945335,
0.0083767362,
-0.0187211465,
-0.0078594545,
0.0476850085,
0.0482361875,
0.0377588682,
0.0814034864,
-0.0253946632,
0.0072475863,
0.0020479094,
-0.018992126,
0.0226589907,
0.012995705,
0.0037760113,
0.0374470875,
-0.0054515405,
-0.0239393096,
-0.0420619436,
0.050637655,
0.0175404251,
-0.0057444377,
0.00192293,
0.0584012009,
0.0040641045,
-0.0273714121,
0.0159024224,
0.0444349647,
0.0207785908,
-0.0217954591,
0.0369203649,
-0.0226640124,
-0.0006011238,
0.0412185602,
-0.0398537256,
0.0362476483,
-0.0341696627,
0.0011490198,
0.0196342785,
0.0136698643,
0.0137499189,
0.0020497509,
-0.0069579352,
-0.0038880103,
0.0161857475,
-0.0055759945,
-0.0299423821,
0.0517931096,
-0.0112271244,
-0.0693847165,
0.0082332985,
0.0284271892,
-0.0807989538,
0.0139311487,
-0.0445505939,
-0.0427579992,
0.0687026009,
-0.0550070964,
-0.0196858477,
-0.0005445999,
-0.0459673516,
0.0223564021,
-0.0171293505,
0.0127925705,
-0.044666145,
0.0533286333,
-0.0636058524,
0.0135627082,
0.0016563722,
-0.0354384221,
-0.0238071308,
-0.0008846882,
-0.0066941925,
-0.0082060378,
-0.077631712,
0.0040118061,
-0.0015546234,
-0.0069673383,
0.0133439535,
0.043014355,
-0.1117827296,
0.0135789402,
-0.0029314216,
0.0297229625,
0.0096223159,
0.0036710289,
-0.0093094707,
-0.0004769361,
0.0032012425,
0.0465444438,
0.0094402237,
0.0044517913,
-0.0374835804,
0.0369688757,
-0.0169081986,
0.0354897492,
0.0285996702,
-0.0952928513,
-0.0303790662,
-0.0426580161,
0.0240853187,
-0.0764482021,
0.013410395,
0.0300148744,
0.0156634729,
-0.0146525148,
0.0205815621,
0.0011741706,
-0.046107471,
0.0385525189,
-0.0680308491,
-0.0062533775,
0.0044884477,
0.0121952472,
0.0468426161,
0.0233500712,
0.0507773012,
-0.0105782282,
-0.0053392905,
0.0156458709,
0.0231838897,
-0.0101323165,
0.0300919898,
-0.0222842991,
-0.0404298641,
-0.0414624736,
-0.0213169064,
0.0416679084,
0.0384565592,
0.0394231044,
-0.012121167,
0.0331756212,
0.0248461422,
-0.0047053453,
0.0316044688,
-0.0063268957,
0.0465175882,
-0.0540197976,
-0.0467973612,
0.097906366,
-0.0056331772,
0.0329968333,
0.0159395654,
0.0501695424,
-0.0200684182,
0.0112793772,
-0.0127448039,
-0.0406316444,
-0.0145954797,
0.0191534795,
-0.0191825572,
-0.0001987781,
0.0446914136,
0.0373338796,
-0.0336338952,
-0.0198429842,
0.0405943207,
-0.0437092856,
0.0069394163,
-0.0339224339,
-0.0237400606,
0.0608250797,
0.0825533122,
-0.0153030688,
-0.0161766969,
0.0032963848,
0.0380282104,
0.0536085069,
0.0322398618,
0.0132291373,
0.0127073349,
-0.031009987,
-0.0234361384,
0.0274904352,
0.0142350998,
0.0033639793,
-0.0303026084,
0.0138415229,
0.006397225,
-0.0153501648,
-0.0147028854,
0.0464655012,
-0.0465948582,
0.0219774358,
0.0017678265,
0.0219863541,
-0.019853387,
-0.0034321037,
-0.030203158,
0.0463083573,
0.0085554887,
-0.0191116408,
-0.0202792399,
0.0641640648,
-0.0499237292,
-0.0929908752,
-0.015286603,
-0.1041121557,
-0.0177145079,
-0.0059328796,
-0.0094434274,
-0.039710708,
0.0096434113,
-0.0507497564,
0.03813361,
-0.0140986098,
0.0234925188,
0.0829051286,
-0.0074985442,
-0.0144237187,
0.0542086065,
-0.0050307387,
0.005276517,
0.0266054012,
-0.0319774933,
0.0210872479,
-0.0697603747,
0.0112179341,
0.0186944883,
0.0103699742,
-0.0146596162,
0.0330056846,
-0.0037838253,
-0.0159217566,
-0.0291669238,
-0.0529789999,
-0.0193987098,
-0.000808929,
-0.0311078262,
0.0323359855,
0.0134194698,
0.0209194925,
-0.0374433994,
-0.03000471,
-0.0198751129,
0.0856760591,
0.0313167162,
0.0626523122,
0.0052157664,
0.0093898121,
-0.0297196228,
-0.0170322303,
-0.047197517,
0.0182069652,
0.0887619704,
-0.0662251413,
-0.0473534279,
0.0293939114,
-0.033953011,
-0.0133348322,
0.0066276793,
-0.044096522,
0.0225129109,
-0.0200001411,
-0.0012469942,
0.0361627154,
0.0097610541,
0.0098785944,
0.0456496403,
-0.0210981648,
-0.009981297,
0.0003715078,
-0.06178784,
0.0232667029,
0.0289442223,
-0.1034026593,
-0.0148786809,
0.0215375591,
0.0459308214,
0.0035934714,
-0.0418682285,
0.0037129174,
-0.024100678,
-0.0262680817,
-0.0203650277,
-0.0478334948,
-0.0191893205,
0.042656593,
-0.0229117423,
-0.0430483893,
0.0613731779,
-0.0001007085,
0.0345267169,
-0.0523937978,
0.0192411356,
-0.0281297453,
0.0425854325,
0.0456263274,
0.0347578973,
0.0535262004,
-0.0065362905,
-0.045083385,
0.0162721649,
0.0674535409,
-0.0138612762,
0.005631662,
-0.0494918264,
0.0237991773,
-0.01268603,
-0.0396317393,
-0.0426455177,
-0.0622628741,
0.050228592,
-0.0182474684,
-0.0081196278,
-0.0013826254,
-0.0641148984,
0.0523999371,
0.0206519812,
0.0382603072,
-0.0101208165,
-0.0162552521,
-0.0129254144,
0.0291686654,
0.0406209901,
-0.0070246607,
-0.0130254831,
-0.0508902818,
0.0030702183,
0.0487881638,
0.0118980743,
0.0639258102,
-0.0002043729,
-0.0026879227,
-0.0384211875,
0.0360905528,
-0.0383586511,
0.0079771243,
0.0067395088,
-0.047250662,
-0.0214030184,
0.0600783713,
0.0215888955,
0.0122056752,
0.0074899509,
0.0512491725,
-0.0120681291,
-0.0063812886,
0.0034709508,
-0.0237680282,
0.018753266,
-0.0088553727,
0.0208160058,
-0.0501254685,
-0.0244500563,
-0.0210569408,
-0.0408583209,
0.0664374605,
0.0050987685,
-0.0386246741,
-0.0653340295,
-0.0231327377,
-0.0364048034,
0.022325011,
-0.0728899762,
-0.0060210447,
-0.0142004918,
0.0157959796,
0.0316360965,
-0.0389209054,
-0.0405238383,
-0.0742278025,
-0.0319888704,
-0.0118817296,
0.0713531896,
0.0377696455,
-0.0169222075,
0.005933173,
-0.0197796449,
0.0195625573,
0.0190374423,
0.0067436229,
0.1163895726,
0.0182774719,
-0.0178826209,
-0.04889182,
0.0160425585,
0.0252184346,
-0.0392415673,
-0.0209696554,
0.0334416032,
-0.0434827916,
-0.0231977105,
-0.0366822369,
0.0729313195,
0.0279437285,
0.0563730672,
0.0010344865,
0.0246823374,
-0.0121321147,
0.0122628771,
0.0632782429,
-0.0675626099,
0.0151929185,
0.0114372605,
-0.0328914262,
-0.0735271424,
-0.0898041502,
-0.0523332991,
0.0117435073,
0.0448069833,
-0.0030790153,
0.0285296477,
-0.0081998082,
-0.0598109849,
-0.0398385972,
0.0311488751,
0.0292126685,
0.0048423856,
-0.0062007387,
-0.0509718619,
0.0020977771,
-0.0276689976,
0.0002368745,
0.0363039523,
-0.0607879274,
-0.0225978065,
0.0000218208,
0.033667285,
0.0307757612,
0.026079312,
0.0214007162,
-0.014245295,
0.0435649119,
0.0866284445,
-0.0021176946,
0.0469780117,
-0.0256968178,
-0.0461538844,
-0.0104127536,
0.0018916378,
-0.0260978099,
-0.0399650559,
0.0167785063,
0.0602965616,
-0.0129608558,
0.0052108574,
0.050455302,
0.0278410427,
0.0453777574,
-0.0649993643,
0.0467837341,
-0.0466769896,
-0.0146130715,
-0.0941025764,
-0.0199606996,
-0.035431616,
0.0301240981,
0.0009968264,
-0.0003499165,
-0.0070109102,
0.0183160212,
-0.0958710462,
0.0050794329,
-0.0340083726,
0.0314904563,
0.0160549711,
-0.033642374,
0.0484350584,
-0.0056896461,
0.0062962263,
-0.0119578876,
0.0185359679,
0.0382059813,
-0.0031990292,
0.0266215503,
0.0524705201,
0.0257969052,
-0.0494718738,
-0.0078810528,
-0.0668900087,
0.0117370635,
-0.0340054072,
0.0362368561,
0.0236569773,
-0.0062251599,
0.0253450442,
-0.0644239858,
0.0116768666,
-0.0028566851,
0.080305703,
0.0566776395,
0.0091626141,
0.0258506928,
-0.0224122219,
0.0086012669,
-0.0174064115,
0.1170464754,
-0.0154702859,
0.014941534,
-0.0356631614,
-0.0527094789,
-0.0266836286,
-0.0679247379,
0.035634432,
-0.0202725474,
-0.0321525782,
-0.0030459447,
-0.0738091543,
-0.0445590019,
0.0137511957,
-0.0118761258,
-0.0037218067,
-0.0133401034,
0.0309179872,
0.0309570767,
0.0051801447,
-0.013889499,
-0.0206305906,
0.0755575821,
-0.0122761466,
-0.0201877356,
0.0248853117,
-6.174679338e-33,
-0.0299627576,
-0.0637599155,
0.0264763683,
-0.0351182707,
0.0140839824,
0.0451757126,
-0.0528699793,
-0.0014138339,
0.0332826115,
0.0254933797,
-0.003259345,
0.0057761455,
0.0294484776,
0.0501626097,
-0.0168686472,
0.0108885756,
0.0364204869,
0.011288004,
-0.0334530547,
-0.0144731076,
-0.0167391989,
0.016810324,
0.0467825569,
-0.088487491,
0.0043695257,
-0.000621785,
0.0032855733,
-0.0354453363,
-0.0003984007,
0.0303508211,
0.0070791808,
-0.0001904079,
0.0313129947,
-0.0043046311,
-0.020873066,
0.0252221543,
-0.051728446,
-0.0433089659,
0.0360182449,
-0.0125888251,
-0.0753016546,
0.0056407619,
0.0231110714,
-0.0301496964,
0.0469733588,
-0.0217670817,
0.039329268,
-0.0223913901,
-0.0045759534,
-0.0029749235,
-0.0704629272,
0.0472205989,
-0.0011096824,
-0.0111872107,
-0.0129850442,
0.021566933,
-0.0152732357,
0.015554972,
0.0018846305,
0.0323762372,
0.0619143024,
0.0330985524,
0.0217304826,
0.0206127875,
-0.0326285735,
0.047899209,
0.0480620191,
-0.0080061955,
-0.028721489,
0.0250792671,
-0.0525341369,
0.0195082761,
0.0202721152,
0.0976550505,
0.0560965985,
0.0003824807,
-0.0909814611,
0.0545687675,
-0.052698642,
0.0280741472,
0.0247892123,
-0.0328261927,
-0.0432658978,
-0.0106372144,
-0.0009000449,
-0.031524919,
-0.0135373902,
-0.009824262,
0.0232871156,
0.0382234268,
-0.0172338169,
0.0327916741,
0.0262100808,
0.0102874199,
-0.007744492,
-0.0281865019,
-0.0135959089,
0.0067835655,
-0.0524421744,
-0.0003068741,
-0.0211171396,
0.011653753,
0.0662362427,
0.0715472624,
0.0434247591,
0.0323807225,
0.0704518408,
-0.0100043183,
-0.0326668434,
0.0151060717,
-0.0117941117,
-0.0061386665,
-0.0309386365,
-0.0187606346,
0.0295542777,
0.0238742251,
-0.017625697,
0.0158299804,
-0.0077303569,
-0.0000723107,
-0.0187774859,
-0.0512866713,
0.0026442227,
0.018824989,
-0.0358349234,
-0.0057815416,
-0.0159516986,
-0.0043771006,
0.0581345595,
-0.0495059565,
-0.0354804732,
0.0054321894,
2.845e-7,
0.0849522278,
0.0100255944,
0.0522324964,
0.0332784466,
0.0102539305,
-0.0172358658,
-0.0246101264,
0.029604014,
0.007611718,
0.0149347354,
0.0217788368,
0.0041036555,
0.0227142423,
0.0252800453,
-0.0447356068,
0.0204474144,
-0.0569929518,
-0.0351927914,
-0.0100546675,
-0.0299551673,
0.0806263685,
0.0091360239,
-0.062791355,
-0.0454577208,
0.0050412668,
0.0021423928,
0.0421476327,
0.0004660781,
-0.0125983767,
0.00274103,
-0.0023595882,
-0.0066214544,
0.0091791786,
0.0778700039,
-0.0480710976,
-0.0625420064,
0.0365968943,
0.0136901764,
-0.0371290781,
0.0080289533,
0.0168753341,
-0.0110967802,
0.0163939781,
-0.0113361459,
0.0387087278,
-0.0270511676,
-0.0210506935,
0.0181442741,
-0.0308797136,
0.0477743037,
0.0251562055,
-0.0319911838,
-0.0659864172,
0.0323459618,
0.0179037023,
0.055790253,
-0.0487325527,
-0.0424477011,
-0.043334879,
-0.0078160549,
-0.0095812334,
-0.066084601,
0.0311356038,
0.0111950645,
0.0099732103,
-0.0773993209,
-0.0259817839,
2.933727399e-34,
0.0533102453,
0.0494570211,
-0.014688069,
-0.0652847141,
0.0071768067,
-0.0290947612,
-0.0195061881,
0.0424040519,
0.024292089,
-0.0184932239,
-0.0465090051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13281v1 | Intention and Context Elicitation with Large Language Models in the Legal Aid Intake Process | 2023-11-22T10:04:29 | 2023-11-22T10:04:29 | Nick Goodson, Rongfei Lu | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) and chatbots show significant promise in
streamlining the legal intake process. This advancement can greatly reduce the
workload and costs for legal aid organizations, improving availability while
making legal assistance more accessible to a broader audience. However, a key
challenge with current LLMs is their tendency to overconfidently deliver an
immediate 'best guess' to a client's question based on the output distribution
learned over the training data. This approach often overlooks the client's
actual intentions or the specifics of their legal situation. As a result,
clients may not realize the importance of providing essential additional
context or expressing their underlying intentions, which are crucial for their
legal cases. Traditionally, logic based decision trees have been used to
automate intake for specific access to justice issues, such as immigration and
eviction. But those solutions lack scalability. We demonstrate a
proof-of-concept using LLMs to elicit and infer clients' underlying intentions
and specific legal circumstances through free-form, language-based
interactions. We also propose future research directions to use supervised
fine-tuning or offline reinforcement learning to automatically incorporate
intention and context elicitation in chatbots without explicit prompting. | [
0.0816390663,
0.0432989411,
-0.0338501036,
-0.0081464751,
-0.066887103,
0.0202778801,
0.010043826,
0.01281197,
0.049743861,
-0.0516800806,
0.0178367309,
-0.0340008959,
-0.0299888663,
0.0221590456,
-0.0335646607,
-0.0460596606,
0.0092258854,
-0.0126183862,
0.0771973059,
-0.0214796234,
0.0331373774,
0.0317269973,
-0.0146664828,
0.039839033,
-0.0336553864,
-0.0069319685,
-0.0518776253,
0.0152432313,
-0.0079183606,
0.0005104109,
-0.0240280852,
0.0780911148,
0.0147887729,
0.0173977837,
0.0000020153,
-0.0704269111,
0.0099036004,
-0.02564881,
-0.0770910606,
-0.0592568628,
0.0254472159,
-0.0418314971,
-0.0274314918,
0.0093352795,
-0.0356669873,
0.0198863167,
0.0152841555,
0.0382978767,
0.0323535725,
0.0858466327,
-0.0032592618,
-0.0164763704,
0.0231526475,
0.0014621791,
0.0359141491,
-0.0674212798,
0.0321245641,
-0.0014853866,
0.0437538736,
-0.0385178477,
0.0057771299,
-0.0083362712,
0.0265473481,
-0.0506664366,
-0.0411904529,
0.0117818713,
-0.0513535887,
-0.0385592431,
-0.0300465394,
0.0636468008,
0.0536864437,
0.0222308468,
-0.0168587491,
-0.0224635657,
0.0599633455,
0.0266659334,
-0.022834206,
0.0693011358,
-0.0228953399,
0.0106108645,
-0.0040933155,
0.0025481728,
-0.0063086813,
0.0394486226,
-0.0298459828,
0.0687910244,
-0.0251413193,
-0.0462960489,
0.0340592749,
0.0087986309,
0.0296704415,
-0.0997209921,
0.0004970254,
0.0613958724,
-0.0698925108,
0.0380842872,
-0.0133045362,
-0.0005566292,
0.0396485999,
-0.0358138457,
0.0150208352,
0.0333330519,
-0.01127489,
0.0622651316,
0.0105601437,
0.0001447948,
0.0198164098,
0.007784992,
-0.0044697071,
-0.0078740353,
-0.0490250997,
0.002196399,
-0.0567977726,
0.0359082595,
-0.094311133,
0.0067731119,
-0.0410805643,
0.0556962751,
-0.0171992332,
0.0314645469,
0.0125065725,
0.0004619991,
-0.021266317,
-0.0118338345,
-0.0769592524,
-0.030725209,
-0.0414734446,
0.0490652397,
0.0273107346,
-0.0818904713,
0.0091279242,
-0.0009046752,
0.0001797453,
0.0073845158,
-0.0135935191,
0.1047455817,
0.0047410675,
-0.0294778086,
-0.0362089872,
-0.0540077984,
-0.0155954612,
-0.0769483596,
-0.0338410512,
-0.0455146842,
0.0001093147,
0.0038521516,
-0.0222605057,
-0.0168540254,
0.0377593189,
0.0271571204,
-0.0108184461,
0.0818226263,
-0.0067593055,
0.0093295015,
-0.0073586898,
0.0196612347,
-0.0150839919,
0.052859731,
-0.0084310621,
0.0531464443,
0.033229351,
-0.0153097101,
0.0419421643,
0.0211245678,
-0.0227395911,
0.011780154,
0.0083227791,
0.0060252086,
-0.0298144314,
0.0425831974,
-0.0016760234,
0.019519981,
-0.0400117785,
0.0360297449,
0.048913151,
0.0821769536,
0.0039995103,
0.0200774837,
0.0238025412,
0.0284810495,
-0.0051938649,
-0.015926199,
-0.0630484372,
0.0322826356,
-0.0053970022,
-0.0119514707,
-0.032995563,
0.0146162752,
-0.0115001099,
-0.0485129394,
0.0284648314,
-0.0032424829,
0.0127585093,
0.0257844236,
0.0286074411,
0.0187920742,
0.007360456,
-0.0351837948,
0.0176816508,
-0.0187489148,
-0.0732760131,
-0.0728738904,
0.016777996,
0.0658046827,
0.0419375561,
-0.0072748205,
-0.0026952443,
-0.035527911,
-0.0193111971,
0.059538871,
0.0363786779,
0.0050144512,
-0.0046160538,
-0.0228012372,
-0.0462221578,
0.0641253218,
0.0071957232,
0.0282999557,
0.0012603702,
-0.0055811852,
0.0328001902,
-0.0011600956,
-0.00466114,
0.0191144794,
0.017254306,
-0.02264986,
0.008459839,
0.0155349476,
0.0645264834,
0.0124218669,
0.0173285734,
-0.0295824856,
0.0277305655,
0.0141973216,
-0.0056370902,
0.0278151184,
-0.0198164433,
-0.017225476,
0.0354865789,
0.0250592269,
-0.035369616,
-0.0426762179,
-0.0328785256,
-0.0112583553,
-0.027603168,
-0.0220613144,
0.0539222807,
-0.0641221181,
-0.0102904998,
-0.0005416532,
-0.0475159436,
-0.0218146294,
0.0523235351,
0.0077258968,
-0.0262408294,
0.0240120534,
-0.0050071655,
0.0088202152,
-0.0303689502,
0.0045604073,
-0.0121394759,
-0.0041930168,
0.0114780627,
0.0356942602,
0.0506808385,
-0.0704935715,
-0.0296493191,
-0.1064858958,
-0.0268853996,
-0.0239831675,
-0.0262833964,
-0.0092028314,
0.0062369211,
-0.0111435205,
-0.038890738,
-0.0268132351,
0.0153450668,
0.0192577951,
0.0076391459,
0.013768808,
-0.0147706438,
-0.0381869897,
-0.008519874,
0.0198752172,
0.0023463327,
-0.006339483,
0.0410418175,
-0.0162707362,
-0.0411221907,
0.0325905718,
-0.0157998968,
-0.003803933,
-0.0288219079,
-0.0318322778,
-0.0106649818,
0.0010059491,
-0.0216908269,
0.0511411689,
0.0547059327,
0.0263608582,
0.0283026379,
0.0157189295,
-0.0790246353,
0.0026965044,
-0.0021387329,
-0.0029065898,
-0.0605896637,
-0.0370224528,
-0.0046456349,
0.0062561356,
-0.0100664562,
0.034453135,
-0.0267339572,
0.0151939671,
0.0272071324,
-0.0270451363,
-0.0354417637,
0.0104881627,
-0.0452373102,
0.056354057,
0.0041868584,
-0.0832143202,
0.0954494923,
0.0220918301,
0.0057052709,
-0.0418834575,
-0.0366195403,
-0.0136142354,
0.0866119936,
0.0083978921,
0.0291322768,
-0.0132742487,
-0.0407953002,
-0.0098716458,
-0.0396024473,
0.0402171053,
-0.0443655066,
0.0523214005,
-0.0447353385,
0.0300384182,
0.0074962005,
-0.054088708,
-0.0676755384,
-0.0514573455,
-0.0255927518,
0.0185418613,
-0.0030227238,
-0.0124388728,
-0.023019651,
-0.0301873162,
0.0247583631,
0.0369192585,
0.0043545701,
-0.0516130291,
-0.0216970686,
0.005450577,
0.0085013825,
0.0277956855,
-0.0254227668,
-0.017605368,
0.0414832495,
0.0026501149,
-0.0063148029,
-0.0043338882,
0.0268167369,
0.0018173644,
0.0081986981,
-0.0152256535,
0.016543394,
0.0460551903,
0.0293674264,
-0.0414122529,
-0.0158120319,
0.09390755,
0.0208334811,
-0.0485358611,
-0.0218657348,
-0.0585351624,
0.0217709932,
0.0335584506,
0.02410933,
-0.1010059267,
-0.0290735159,
0.0046350001,
0.0292292275,
-0.0518268757,
-0.008572083,
-0.0041397247,
-0.0943357944,
0.0808680505,
-0.0053214193,
-0.0353834182,
-0.0300887991,
0.0204105396,
0.0138060842,
0.0133174341,
0.0065117865,
0.0025195309,
-0.0071262508,
-0.0229512174,
-0.0046001147,
-0.0116885677,
-0.0048788441,
0.0059931376,
-0.0554762036,
0.0997375324,
0.0509263128,
0.0318535939,
0.0041594571,
-0.0109306155,
0.0140107367,
0.0119205508,
0.0089678699,
0.0098161399,
0.0047259987,
0.0079247355,
0.0352148339,
-0.0538862124,
0.0444095619,
-0.0077661346,
-0.0174881388,
0.0626282245,
0.068978548,
-0.0719038025,
-0.0095527861,
0.0038379962,
0.0185701381,
0.0503281951,
0.0426885337,
0.0285548326,
-0.0398175865,
-0.0181715619,
-0.0517427288,
-0.0341812,
0.0230787359,
-0.0117057841,
-0.0021918693,
-0.0413186438,
0.0049758009,
-0.0191994645,
-0.0407401249,
0.0352208912,
0.0369571932,
0.0235287249,
0.0020930287,
0.0337976515,
0.0216746908,
0.0099178581,
0.0317352749,
-0.0359260589,
0.0244178418,
-0.0150860157,
0.0055041886,
-0.0152430646,
-0.0395942628,
0.0016585249,
-0.0036200706,
0.0480169244,
-0.0185154583,
-0.007820664,
0.0292544384,
0.0283699576,
0.03989584,
-0.0157930758,
-0.048245851,
0.0018219586,
0.0273441039,
0.0044559087,
0.0022356955,
0.0529499874,
0.0294365901,
-0.0134004867,
0.0287243929,
-0.0200657845,
0.053624399,
0.0027357221,
0.0224773306,
-0.073060751,
-0.0443905406,
0.0548707061,
0.052191291,
0.0117377043,
0.0119619146,
-0.0321126692,
-0.0256621297,
0.0266866591,
-0.0075784959,
-0.0288904533,
-0.0414108709,
-0.0353777371,
0.0079490105,
-0.0070117312,
0.0039099716,
-0.0116033573,
-0.0443593375,
0.0057537612,
0.0061507812,
0.017033508,
0.0337574072,
0.0176798068,
0.0229585804,
-0.0404876135,
0.0167173687,
0.026013026,
-0.0059469538,
0.0573255867,
0.0042724148,
0.1039019823,
0.0360352695,
-0.0176474545,
-0.0057769809,
-0.0136919552,
-0.0227166694,
-0.0957942158,
0.0370230861,
0.0775083899,
0.0477021262,
0.0151080675,
-0.0143500092,
-0.0489641204,
0.0194757991,
0.0057084351,
0.0222109817,
0.011331738,
-0.0529710278,
0.0323860683,
0.023311995,
-0.0380972065,
0.0120815123,
-0.0054661063,
-0.0765817538,
0.0183123797,
-0.0427417234,
-0.027900001,
-0.0201276317,
-0.022700021,
-0.012890351,
0.0371392109,
-0.0230836049,
-0.0120383753,
-0.0836168304,
-0.046786014,
-0.0792496055,
0.0176370461,
-0.0223364346,
-0.0222417358,
0.0540626012,
0.0460429639,
-0.0076319347,
-0.0332755111,
-0.0723291263,
0.0459347591,
-0.0341892168,
-0.0046365233,
-0.0358806141,
-5.628004302e-33,
-0.0336024277,
-0.0617105886,
0.0128428685,
0.0278626252,
-0.0208922867,
-0.0263505578,
-0.0171948653,
0.0163228549,
-0.0065532713,
0.0288241655,
-0.0202292316,
0.0325326696,
0.0177273918,
0.0060845194,
0.0061289701,
0.0094880788,
-0.0100567369,
-0.0015614827,
0.0003529224,
0.0047976244,
-0.0017561591,
0.0203906596,
-0.0181532931,
-0.0938632861,
0.022665482,
0.0382922851,
-0.017522864,
0.0244050082,
-0.0646507218,
0.0280222371,
0.0134698432,
0.0465110131,
0.0160032641,
-0.0514506809,
0.0328698158,
0.0842391253,
-0.0552426614,
-0.0162644181,
0.0349398628,
-0.0224733129,
-0.0433325544,
-0.0081812525,
0.0050532673,
-0.0273991507,
-0.0132118948,
0.0355255343,
0.0197605919,
-0.0346837938,
-0.0364097729,
-0.0137869902,
-0.0631718189,
0.0372992903,
-0.017517712,
-0.0166148506,
0.0225053634,
0.0228779018,
-0.0136257065,
0.0104219392,
-0.0230265744,
0.0184076503,
-0.016108105,
-0.0361372121,
0.0351222567,
-0.0356838591,
-0.0207058843,
0.0506906807,
0.0010071375,
-0.0173526835,
-0.0322006382,
-0.0628719181,
0.0040865894,
0.0568310879,
0.0110413507,
0.0299042519,
0.0008679258,
-0.037914075,
-0.0489923097,
0.0082195634,
0.0726816878,
0.0266885385,
0.027574148,
-0.0336679108,
-0.0407959744,
0.0074469559,
-0.0526381768,
-0.0172975399,
-0.0096552186,
-0.0254394226,
0.0264970697,
0.0256923921,
0.0436080806,
-0.0736928284,
-0.0210248977,
-0.0363705158,
0.0143969283,
0.0316117629,
-0.0035730198,
0.0047644912,
-0.0282852035,
0.0321552344,
-0.0215377472,
-0.0288451277,
0.0147204809,
-0.0658190027,
0.0154157085,
0.0067784814,
0.032193277,
-0.0119223697,
-0.0368459448,
-0.0061748005,
-0.0071765385,
0.0799758956,
-0.0122996522,
0.0412723608,
0.0206613839,
0.012119933,
-0.0077443304,
0.0323636755,
0.0295236856,
-0.0014214156,
-0.0563233458,
-0.0366227366,
-0.0236306302,
-0.007249359,
-0.0564400144,
0.0084688915,
-0.0100177182,
0.052480191,
0.0287973583,
0.0021631343,
0.0116845453,
0.0370068923,
2.792e-7,
0.0361737907,
0.040742781,
-0.0439639427,
0.0341033936,
-0.0026469093,
0.0618122928,
0.0074478495,
0.0231879056,
0.0435609706,
-0.0255685505,
0.0321178101,
-0.000380322,
0.0683531389,
0.0260594394,
-0.1126086265,
-0.0242094584,
-0.0285649821,
-0.0388327278,
-0.0542147793,
0.0656700358,
0.0440074578,
0.0964076445,
0.0099951755,
-0.0190787911,
0.0241106842,
0.0014918364,
0.017940307,
-0.0542143881,
-0.0051053073,
-0.0114171645,
0.0665169135,
-0.0520435125,
0.006234006,
0.0655767173,
0.0058666519,
0.0425374731,
-0.0664659813,
0.0855485648,
-0.0129613476,
0.0095901415,
-0.0107815703,
-0.0128160818,
0.034923777,
-0.0183394756,
0.0414973907,
-0.0646881312,
-0.010480836,
-0.0106248464,
0.0126534402,
-0.0631754771,
0.0194649324,
0.0008202288,
-0.0411672294,
-0.0010082476,
0.027894292,
-0.0306842458,
0.0369323045,
-0.0721441731,
0.0277760942,
0.0407954343,
-0.0120677575,
-0.0431931727,
-0.0123060998,
-0.0157495942,
0.0417843238,
-0.0622570626,
0.0256620608,
2.246177998e-34,
0.0158926193,
0.01812125,
0.0133765135,
0.0628403723,
0.0281235781,
0.0511051491,
0.0122596882,
0.0296762176,
0.0355297662,
-0.0629647598,
0.0276486259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13274v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13274v2 | Enhancing Summarization Performance through Transformer-Based Prompt Engineering in Automated Medical Reporting | 2023-11-22T09:51:53 | 2024-01-19T10:06:50 | Daphne van Zandvoort, Laura Wiersema, Tom Huibers, Sandra van Dulmen, Sjaak Brinkkemper | cs.CL | cs.CL | Customized medical prompts enable Large Language Models (LLM) to effectively
address medical dialogue summarization. The process of medical reporting is
often time-consuming for healthcare professionals. Implementing medical
dialogue summarization techniques presents a viable solution to alleviate this
time constraint by generating automated medical reports. The effectiveness of
LLMs in this process is significantly influenced by the formulation of the
prompt, which plays a crucial role in determining the quality and relevance of
the generated reports. In this research, we used a combination of two distinct
prompting strategies, known as shot prompting and pattern prompting to enhance
the performance of automated medical reporting. The evaluation of the automated
medical reports is carried out using the ROUGE score and a human evaluation
with the help of an expert panel. The two-shot prompting approach in
combination with scope and domain context outperforms other methods and
achieves the highest score when compared to the human reference set by a
general practitioner. However, the automated reports are approximately twice as
long as the human references, due to the addition of both redundant and
relevant statements that are added to the report. | [
0.076636292,
-0.0263742264,
-0.0017291059,
-0.0408155322,
-0.0343529917,
0.0050039012,
0.0141219581,
0.0061279065,
-0.0146131767,
-0.0344633646,
-0.0060631726,
-0.0441702902,
0.0336196534,
0.0440212414,
-0.0010633665,
-0.0791830346,
0.0314424783,
0.0154481605,
0.0291326791,
0.0160576217,
0.0052240766,
0.0062076282,
-0.0295377988,
0.0401124507,
0.0171205141,
0.0003443411,
0.0019469198,
-0.0015505332,
0.0164373741,
-0.0650329217,
-0.036027424,
0.0447270907,
-0.0315026045,
-0.0274151918,
0.0000020067,
-0.0803868696,
-0.0145775238,
0.0263180081,
-0.0308276471,
-0.0024919456,
0.0359401219,
-0.0479692742,
-0.0010561895,
0.0340392925,
-0.001047953,
-0.0492163673,
0.0111547643,
0.0617740788,
0.0834664032,
0.0408182479,
-0.0290827397,
-0.0035146577,
0.0074534812,
-0.0045187674,
-0.0124136694,
-0.0344487131,
-0.0076382887,
0.0189379361,
0.0730084628,
-0.0045921542,
0.0297775157,
0.0324877687,
-0.0148120411,
-0.0265496783,
-0.0017055889,
0.0195852537,
-0.02013487,
-0.0210818183,
-0.0081861867,
0.0346389674,
0.0467115082,
0.0253417883,
0.0083908252,
-0.0006382027,
0.0293625295,
0.0205403436,
-0.0654833838,
0.0431809239,
-0.030360857,
-0.0452061817,
-0.0076946882,
0.0401596725,
-0.03607985,
-0.014106608,
-0.0208192877,
-0.0270772483,
0.0235571861,
-0.0228162091,
-0.0127928089,
-0.0132443076,
0.0072293617,
-0.0601134971,
0.0266499277,
0.0436776392,
-0.0918924659,
-0.0081952503,
-0.0099606812,
-0.0328944176,
0.0664220005,
-0.0006206151,
0.0026539548,
0.014646641,
-0.0072956895,
0.0162649322,
-0.0015890551,
0.0381229632,
0.0201967694,
-0.010845989,
-0.058183521,
0.0235547163,
-0.0291907638,
-0.0318495035,
-0.0446513481,
0.0287496801,
0.0035874045,
-0.0124728177,
-0.0649360344,
0.0089976219,
0.0036696242,
0.036784783,
0.0137527557,
0.0140485866,
-0.0192191601,
0.0008945618,
-0.013843568,
0.0085911686,
-0.0200429298,
-0.0174949523,
0.0194291472,
-0.0365181714,
0.0181163624,
0.0349200591,
0.0145653691,
0.0366073921,
-0.034448918,
0.0390806347,
-0.0342732444,
-0.002223718,
0.0224794541,
-0.0599927269,
-0.0220604669,
0.0068015368,
-0.0332793407,
-0.0598967671,
0.0107255299,
0.0331738107,
-0.0087776799,
0.0095748594,
0.0220310353,
0.0410030745,
-0.02458819,
0.0288119875,
-0.0529378355,
0.0463629961,
0.0402271375,
0.0107554561,
0.0213126764,
-0.0107918214,
0.0064886822,
-0.0012329419,
-0.0016004572,
-0.0063404995,
0.051644139,
0.0020637724,
-0.0250289049,
-0.0227234252,
0.0169107914,
0.0165104438,
0.0155553147,
0.0210666452,
-0.0205800012,
0.0961332098,
0.0020381855,
0.0746550038,
0.0289165527,
0.0546648763,
0.009917574,
0.0038386765,
0.05209608,
0.0057807788,
0.0092077227,
0.0407881029,
0.0014356355,
0.0037294249,
0.0028266278,
0.0328180566,
0.0318549797,
-0.0019395088,
-0.0320635885,
-0.0382149108,
-0.034513317,
0.0080020186,
-0.0244779661,
-0.012401484,
0.0159472767,
0.0297135729,
-0.064263545,
0.0740714595,
0.0137628829,
-0.0328348912,
-0.0270319209,
-0.0532605499,
-0.0002471124,
0.0806534141,
0.0739865303,
-0.0216809958,
-0.025752943,
-0.043279212,
0.0062324903,
0.0263769608,
0.0439718813,
-0.0187978391,
-0.0297937226,
-0.0351639763,
-0.0240686107,
0.0403887928,
0.002462588,
-0.0087614506,
-0.0273397844,
-0.0032614241,
0.0222358555,
0.0346524827,
-0.0544359982,
0.0228970461,
-0.0438647717,
-0.014813846,
0.0132667935,
-0.0107340645,
0.0093676681,
0.0393913351,
-0.0104108825,
0.05234221,
0.0098813279,
-0.0122943409,
-0.0122611756,
0.025228193,
-0.056913238,
-0.0213192385,
-0.0075162267,
-0.0515867472,
0.0183236059,
-0.044584021,
0.0032034563,
-0.0520563945,
-0.0751411095,
-0.0792452917,
-0.0072972407,
-0.0053356844,
0.0648807436,
0.052178219,
-0.0188211687,
-0.0453847125,
0.0229371637,
0.0060197096,
0.0079513788,
0.0779093429,
0.0035093075,
0.0212776344,
-0.0340021737,
-0.001683532,
0.0119472435,
-0.0147694368,
0.0041030277,
0.0378620625,
0.0205991324,
-0.0120410221,
-0.042756848,
-0.1158424467,
-0.0378452912,
0.0037523836,
-0.0329253264,
0.0374932811,
0.0414347127,
-0.0172147099,
-0.0123976376,
-0.0473955721,
-0.0698499456,
0.0495880023,
0.017067451,
0.0413732976,
0.0461316966,
0.005229047,
-0.0226737019,
-0.0143596344,
-0.0284324419,
0.0194217749,
0.0698094964,
-0.0271475315,
-0.070628278,
0.039095208,
0.0054735378,
-0.0319289267,
0.0261384919,
-0.0248572119,
0.0234942827,
-0.0035540925,
0.0605895445,
0.0421605408,
0.0267052688,
-0.017544318,
0.034158498,
-0.0019145138,
-0.0124851037,
-0.0086426977,
-0.03061001,
-0.0196376331,
0.0523650348,
-0.0813535824,
0.0550795868,
0.0322228745,
0.0434131771,
0.0266291909,
-0.0204988103,
-0.0255400706,
-0.0110020991,
0.0131735178,
-0.0392652638,
-0.0432376824,
-0.0426676236,
0.0874770135,
0.0125142215,
0.0053907395,
0.0679414719,
-0.0252995696,
0.0155284945,
-0.0832267925,
0.005785231,
-0.0510705598,
0.0140534602,
-0.0123611102,
0.0136982147,
0.0463092886,
-0.04754401,
-0.0178706627,
0.0081302216,
0.0359684117,
-0.0227650851,
0.0586363114,
-0.0269841067,
0.0004195974,
-0.0109018432,
-0.0260126181,
-0.0573887788,
-0.0496578477,
-0.0057354039,
0.0149619747,
0.0146708349,
0.025952477,
-0.05136545,
0.0799771622,
0.0419153757,
0.0889055505,
-0.0130490037,
-0.0172494575,
-0.0051751123,
0.0280287974,
0.0256860852,
0.0033693553,
0.0128714051,
-0.0150687369,
0.0808233842,
0.0172610488,
-0.0147094931,
0.0385973528,
0.0214552768,
-0.0245344751,
-0.0031100898,
-0.0756964609,
-0.04342594,
0.0467255898,
0.0224624183,
-0.0356941111,
0.006134693,
0.1112245247,
0.0454190075,
-0.0443695262,
0.0008110216,
-0.027801821,
-0.0345875919,
0.0096488576,
0.0339965858,
-0.0466628149,
0.0082129268,
0.0008336788,
0.0244193934,
-0.0286972299,
0.0074971351,
0.0016651014,
-0.0906816944,
0.0430547558,
-0.0201361869,
-0.038704738,
-0.0520657785,
-0.0205882043,
0.0150548778,
0.0281795338,
-0.0129895173,
0.0339875445,
-0.0455980562,
-0.015544259,
0.0111844279,
-0.1033819839,
-0.0604525283,
-0.0047729085,
-0.004523478,
0.0095653273,
0.09616144,
-0.0090496736,
-0.0136905452,
0.0092893299,
-0.0114252334,
-0.0108068567,
0.0219466165,
-0.0000126056,
0.0716098025,
0.0130022876,
0.0010990252,
-0.0514807887,
0.0104791438,
0.0306130033,
-0.0184779838,
0.0297921728,
0.0405853428,
-0.0266971383,
0.0049000713,
-0.0409022309,
0.0734716877,
0.0121799931,
0.0539873317,
0.0421238244,
-0.0073598451,
0.0009947459,
0.0037032387,
0.0328488275,
-0.0056294948,
-0.0316842496,
0.032146465,
-0.0452093035,
-0.0632886961,
-0.0780001432,
-0.0456569791,
0.0512505807,
0.0044870498,
0.0276754275,
0.0177547839,
-0.0035889864,
0.0300393458,
-0.0220073722,
0.0123471078,
0.0275748018,
0.0057255342,
-0.0681117997,
-0.0156841297,
0.0561439618,
-0.0072168689,
-0.0184498038,
-0.0052124928,
0.0182803869,
0.0062389323,
-0.002362981,
0.0290181283,
0.0268843304,
-0.0141315972,
0.0050173202,
-0.0207463615,
0.0352465399,
0.0418082513,
-0.0185157917,
-0.0192207098,
-0.0198254175,
0.0437522084,
-0.0183124468,
-0.0115455436,
-0.0357673131,
0.0207627472,
-0.0234943554,
0.0420271307,
-0.018920254,
-0.0688810125,
0.0270874612,
0.0697307065,
0.017971972,
-0.0203447919,
0.0068816245,
-0.0230567958,
0.0148657607,
-0.0674077794,
-0.0246369466,
-0.0304852333,
0.0390673168,
-0.0321130045,
-0.0154565806,
0.0257153921,
0.0051319213,
-0.1056892499,
-0.0134050567,
-0.0340714753,
0.043624498,
-0.0228678733,
0.0063255038,
0.0050173146,
-0.0199415814,
-0.040075019,
-0.0290891584,
0.0175144859,
0.0190895237,
-0.0039794226,
0.0911552235,
-0.0086069088,
0.0215069372,
0.002177377,
0.050796777,
-0.0425148979,
-0.0353383422,
-0.0131679969,
0.0321009569,
0.0058946433,
-0.0069677262,
0.004706271,
-0.0327173285,
0.017085202,
-0.0234333817,
0.0410951711,
0.0323359817,
0.0207943209,
0.0219608042,
0.0147013022,
0.0214194469,
-0.0361206196,
0.0685138479,
-0.0445066206,
-0.028246168,
-0.0139282783,
-0.0505431443,
-0.0701175332,
-0.0195680931,
0.0288751498,
-0.0142544024,
-0.0423393101,
-0.0227028467,
-0.1032152474,
0.013902396,
0.0039424752,
-0.0206187684,
0.0002405692,
-0.0346059278,
0.0670446306,
0.0396945439,
0.0195653588,
-0.0254462771,
-0.0398615003,
0.0519771241,
0.0015407028,
0.0009795885,
0.0011142176,
-5.592709717e-33,
-0.0288218092,
-0.0447378978,
0.0070403931,
-0.0317495055,
-0.0031082651,
0.0116254119,
-0.0429775007,
0.0064093578,
0.0216004327,
0.0115268929,
-0.0515406281,
-0.0308067296,
0.0246763099,
0.0241688564,
0.001910525,
-0.0017326504,
0.0543428585,
0.0190663468,
-0.0504644141,
0.0264636073,
-0.0418821722,
0.0105045624,
0.0056871823,
-0.0478721038,
0.0357328914,
-0.0337877162,
0.0021860073,
-0.0254458468,
0.0360508896,
0.0562751293,
0.0004737667,
0.0026657782,
0.044246003,
-0.0594873987,
-0.0216860287,
0.0581668988,
-0.0543040894,
-0.0328417793,
0.0439037383,
-0.0121983038,
-0.0214708205,
-0.0317359678,
0.0125197191,
-0.0538810566,
-0.0068747997,
0.004911338,
0.0286683645,
-0.0336356983,
-0.0236175545,
-0.051121287,
-0.0574303642,
0.0494887084,
0.0187433455,
-0.0198499933,
-0.0303832255,
0.0850028098,
-0.039626766,
0.0077359118,
0.0197988227,
0.0308262408,
0.0638040751,
0.0254035182,
0.0144626526,
0.0003623135,
-0.0280530304,
0.0151038487,
0.0315645896,
0.0218731724,
-0.0362331755,
0.0097994041,
-0.0542348102,
0.0089856656,
0.0529415496,
0.0432512388,
0.011845855,
0.0028538443,
-0.0351084396,
0.085069485,
-0.043309968,
0.0422169082,
0.0388830118,
-0.0613600016,
-0.0642098337,
-0.0236352216,
-0.0152683342,
0.019779589,
-0.0113868779,
-0.0423101373,
0.0241649393,
-0.0019433701,
-0.021599872,
-0.0171608441,
0.0136112468,
0.0105860969,
0.0414059013,
-0.0370389149,
0.0040068454,
0.0506495759,
-0.0539350733,
-0.0308368206,
-0.0335459486,
0.0222513806,
0.0326154828,
0.0343115032,
0.0373098291,
0.0501410626,
-0.0038763527,
-0.0228957385,
-0.064994216,
0.0174482092,
0.0514651537,
0.0063119312,
-0.0351943001,
0.0095083592,
0.0118261417,
0.0239551403,
-0.0048700701,
0.0560366549,
-0.0203716904,
-0.0599664524,
-0.0353175104,
-0.0297652222,
0.0169905126,
0.0159337521,
-0.0556275435,
0.0287344586,
-0.0305381455,
0.0578741729,
0.0423645452,
0.0055446452,
-0.0134738488,
-0.0142294932,
2.695e-7,
0.0666299984,
0.0393635444,
0.0244841632,
0.0201721489,
0.0162818395,
-0.0048406571,
0.031839285,
-0.0080478191,
0.0257933363,
0.0147645362,
0.0594165251,
-0.0288110152,
0.0162124224,
0.03039442,
-0.1005227342,
-0.0554375648,
-0.0895275399,
-0.0134013677,
-0.0321120918,
-0.0055058957,
0.1073547825,
0.0325482227,
-0.0774759054,
-0.0193858184,
-0.0265828222,
-0.0148226395,
0.0199825391,
-0.0201974697,
-0.0286599211,
0.0514271446,
0.0501566269,
-0.0062410664,
0.0278414432,
0.0576833636,
0.0103047788,
-0.0250103623,
0.0221241992,
0.0617190711,
-0.0049760267,
0.0239224061,
0.0313307643,
0.0002875169,
0.0274845734,
-0.0331111811,
0.044977963,
-0.0636604279,
-0.0227775443,
-0.012611228,
-0.0528067611,
-0.0286193788,
0.0419219919,
-0.0314146578,
-0.0599468239,
0.0593085252,
0.0023606236,
0.010677862,
-0.0203151815,
-0.0462785028,
-0.0255176648,
-0.0073810797,
0.0080542108,
-0.0418567955,
0.0410892144,
-0.0638901517,
-0.0243820399,
-0.0595419295,
0.0121069746,
2.901190312e-34,
0.0489126407,
0.0081560798,
0.0065353308,
0.0107379938,
0.027004797,
-0.0089299027,
-0.0164957438,
0.0331612229,
0.0602511242,
-0.0751854032,
-0.0348846912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13273v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13273v2 | Comparative Experimentation of Accuracy Metrics in Automated Medical Reporting: The Case of Otitis Consultations | 2023-11-22T09:51:43 | 2024-01-08T14:19:29 | Wouter Faber, Renske Eline Bootsma, Tom Huibers, Sandra van Dulmen, Sjaak Brinkkemper | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) can be used to automatically generate
medical reports based on transcripts of medical consultations. The aim is to
reduce the administrative burden that healthcare professionals face. The
accuracy of the generated reports needs to be established to ensure their
correctness and usefulness. There are several metrics for measuring the
accuracy of AI generated reports, but little work has been done towards the
application of these metrics in medical reporting. A comparative
experimentation of 10 accuracy metrics has been performed on AI generated
medical reports against their corresponding General Practitioner's (GP) medical
reports concerning Otitis consultations. The number of missing, incorrect, and
additional statements of the generated reports have been correlated with the
metric scores. In addition, we introduce and define a Composite Accuracy Score
which produces a single score for comparing the metrics within the field of
automated medical reporting. Findings show that based on the correlation study
and the Composite Accuracy Score, the ROUGE-L and Word Mover's Distance metrics
are the preferred metrics, which is not in line with previous work. These
findings help determine the accuracy of an AI generated medical report, which
aids the development of systems that generate medical reports for GPs to reduce
the administrative burden. | [
0.0459560491,
0.0023611186,
-0.013819864,
-0.0458087698,
-0.0616935007,
0.0023915332,
0.0062281033,
0.0333042927,
0.0163265541,
0.009252537,
0.0426752269,
-0.015684668,
0.0592689626,
0.0360538736,
-0.0060868999,
-0.0426810347,
0.0057733408,
0.0549231991,
0.0281042587,
0.0265882611,
-0.03589876,
0.0327804387,
-0.0602172166,
0.06038782,
-0.0352393202,
0.0036734431,
0.0419055931,
-0.014223638,
0.0322561711,
-0.048754219,
-0.0464033745,
-0.012319427,
-0.0741344914,
0.0062816534,
0.0000019369,
-0.0519340858,
0.0144561976,
0.0436252877,
-0.0086996676,
-0.0454607606,
0.0208549798,
-0.0681600049,
-0.0213075485,
0.0402993187,
-0.0139950728,
-0.0164338145,
0.0524533503,
-0.0095974132,
0.0394711047,
0.0628756061,
-0.0427531786,
0.0172387231,
0.041788172,
0.0276913978,
0.0105302278,
-0.0320984311,
0.0121871969,
0.0418039858,
0.0018153355,
-0.0649127439,
0.0162114762,
0.0244945996,
-0.0239026342,
-0.0186573844,
-0.0005482355,
0.0398016199,
-0.0232504159,
-0.0380563848,
0.0355586633,
0.001766057,
0.0055313236,
-0.0171318464,
-0.0080901366,
-0.0277872477,
-0.0030603565,
-0.0250835754,
-0.0125954729,
0.0269930512,
-0.0565980822,
-0.0256016999,
0.0392269529,
0.0100682508,
-0.0035664106,
-0.0030401535,
0.0019123728,
-0.0382185727,
0.0175705254,
-0.0333147757,
0.0136709046,
-0.002729259,
0.0351596847,
-0.0590862669,
0.0287029706,
0.0587146766,
-0.070560649,
-0.0063499976,
-0.0235184617,
-0.0640669614,
0.0793382302,
-0.0534058027,
0.0120296758,
0.0126365134,
0.0046241004,
0.0272367429,
-0.0058928644,
0.0388578922,
0.0161746442,
0.0229447242,
-0.0307599809,
0.0182532538,
-0.0360060446,
-0.0174853466,
-0.0014816406,
-0.0035042195,
0.0181453936,
-0.0064721545,
-0.0736623555,
-0.0103899753,
-0.04395096,
0.0520940498,
0.0445400365,
0.0432129577,
-0.0493002571,
0.0106309326,
-0.0382130742,
-0.0277201533,
-0.0233661849,
0.03560514,
-0.0126986057,
-0.0092443004,
0.0435577221,
0.0408014394,
0.0350148939,
0.037514694,
0.0111067845,
0.046936933,
0.0042887293,
0.0023436812,
-0.0044460478,
-0.029576946,
-0.0062609226,
-0.0108204922,
-0.0454711057,
-0.0451694056,
0.0496480651,
0.0097698737,
-0.0157896858,
-0.0175113846,
0.0037769689,
0.0159127079,
0.005195396,
0.006547383,
-0.065864481,
0.0636852533,
0.0485089198,
-0.0146269118,
0.0180137083,
-0.0559693277,
0.0385884643,
-0.0037304796,
0.0098530985,
-0.0214162283,
0.050299231,
-0.0246555023,
-0.0058766394,
-0.050390359,
0.0238390472,
-0.0123810004,
-0.0391609408,
0.0746460557,
-0.0091020139,
0.103738904,
-0.0035635266,
0.0327057727,
0.016987877,
0.0343909748,
0.0471452661,
0.0369893946,
0.0658684447,
-0.0742514357,
0.0036911508,
0.018287871,
0.0141373649,
0.0018127508,
0.0251350217,
0.0179622173,
0.0107668843,
0.0042937892,
-0.00155967,
-0.058069557,
-0.0375435799,
-0.03166347,
-0.0564128533,
-0.0382077135,
0.024186464,
-0.0085908873,
-0.0506519303,
0.0058314339,
0.0187331866,
-0.0120419534,
-0.0240003653,
-0.0726318583,
-0.0015221358,
0.0904189721,
0.0674758404,
-0.0356493481,
0.0042137546,
-0.0202248916,
-0.0662950873,
0.0204794575,
0.0454262197,
-0.0386594646,
0.0005570186,
-0.0243454892,
0.0054217898,
0.044227723,
0.0170696955,
-0.0151776047,
-0.0064194761,
0.0589274429,
0.0051629422,
-0.0277860183,
-0.0486876927,
0.0291304328,
-0.0367665701,
-0.0275770705,
0.029142512,
0.0006580824,
0.0359724723,
0.0544586442,
-0.0346281007,
0.048463583,
0.004349452,
-0.005931362,
-0.032402467,
0.0113858143,
-0.0282554217,
0.0262949765,
0.0047940281,
-0.0555909611,
0.0328546353,
-0.0221240763,
0.0033805429,
-0.0266151261,
-0.0559472181,
-0.0675901473,
0.0227683298,
-0.0405253917,
0.0563000888,
0.0552391,
-0.0229924209,
-0.0019119885,
0.0324067213,
-0.0076427162,
0.0092053488,
-0.0037020487,
-0.0128849568,
0.0357231088,
-0.0204736777,
0.0231358968,
0.0186619367,
-0.0052963477,
0.0292805322,
0.0042439424,
-0.0018300604,
-0.0153391343,
-0.0555799007,
-0.1155385002,
-0.0596556589,
0.0080156848,
-0.0106298644,
0.0404730588,
0.0046226853,
0.0208667442,
0.0091196792,
-0.0297613777,
-0.0713841841,
0.0557957478,
-0.0190153271,
0.0571561046,
0.0274743792,
-0.0129045742,
-0.0518281795,
-0.0039781407,
-0.0405565761,
-0.0109331803,
0.0738168508,
0.0016304335,
-0.058586359,
-0.0078953383,
-0.060111668,
0.0047840616,
0.0306887403,
-0.017253615,
0.026916163,
-0.0056820889,
0.0289518144,
0.0585155636,
0.0229773112,
0.0002297718,
0.0478198454,
0.0204743315,
-0.0022473373,
-0.00191529,
-0.041505672,
-0.0016401646,
0.0151167987,
-0.1092628986,
0.0191015825,
0.0022757459,
0.0569393523,
0.006010069,
-0.0272921287,
0.0159070808,
-0.0181330815,
0.0176500492,
-0.0001042695,
-0.0195413027,
-0.0253600534,
0.081839107,
0.0090505369,
-0.0373930782,
0.0532641709,
-0.0149404323,
0.0599006489,
-0.0558677129,
-0.0045794914,
-0.0270689204,
0.0484791175,
-0.0011214392,
0.0425290093,
-0.0152133815,
-0.026898548,
-0.0040477864,
0.0206652135,
0.0810580999,
-0.0449488275,
0.0040330677,
-0.0143762305,
0.0217146147,
0.0064804778,
-0.0019158932,
-0.0472217686,
-0.0091476515,
0.0533869863,
-0.000466024,
0.0466684103,
-0.0066518784,
-0.0516294315,
0.0408709571,
0.0297118593,
0.0806340799,
0.0326116383,
-0.0087228408,
0.0189532563,
-0.0167427957,
0.0042057969,
0.0024747269,
-0.0352843478,
0.0254884753,
-0.0052945991,
0.0192069206,
0.0035224997,
0.0807861537,
-0.0113997012,
-0.057883352,
-0.062680237,
-0.0418471657,
-0.0359974019,
0.0365260541,
-0.0198474415,
-0.0051656854,
-0.0044904933,
0.0741648525,
0.0599466562,
-0.0034912482,
0.0058454666,
0.0112164542,
-0.0668568611,
-0.0130378651,
0.0193187892,
0.0007161848,
0.050379958,
-0.001631545,
0.0661354885,
-0.0609370731,
-0.0246365815,
0.0225866623,
-0.0601976067,
0.0417475663,
-0.0003587964,
-0.0219112318,
-0.123919934,
-0.030672757,
-0.0144294547,
0.0141127389,
-0.0394355059,
-0.0101351524,
0.0043195253,
-0.0056507825,
0.0153960763,
-0.1131144986,
-0.0593547821,
0.0008477606,
0.0052789422,
0.0158910286,
0.1008563563,
0.0361715145,
-0.0227439888,
-0.0477693565,
-0.070297502,
0.0191778783,
0.0041113966,
0.0087046791,
0.0840431228,
0.0293880422,
0.0167161133,
-0.0124931373,
0.0101602133,
0.0211355891,
0.0174345374,
0.0182516333,
0.0366478078,
-0.030387165,
-0.0182254985,
-0.0321491621,
0.0430813543,
0.0323334113,
0.0230509117,
0.0139570972,
0.0336886458,
-0.0311430246,
0.0280504916,
0.0696404353,
-0.03961033,
0.0140111493,
0.0470425934,
-0.0166017395,
-0.0865207613,
-0.0879655778,
-0.0455754586,
0.0002711347,
0.0226501226,
0.0406740606,
-0.0152049931,
0.0097448612,
-0.0114686033,
-0.0364261381,
-0.0349721499,
0.0685076565,
0.0358378962,
-0.0150809074,
-0.0276947748,
0.0239590332,
0.0207864735,
-0.0083181197,
0.0201271903,
-0.0163827483,
0.0140537983,
0.0165516287,
0.022463778,
0.0203666911,
-0.0527398065,
-0.0139267258,
0.0175133198,
0.0002179909,
0.0509604104,
-0.0357560627,
0.0000894503,
-0.0146627845,
-0.0077397334,
-0.0193213522,
-0.0250266194,
-0.0267636459,
0.0105158407,
-0.0177591462,
0.040977452,
0.0044030487,
-0.0199139193,
0.0414004028,
0.0630662739,
-0.0014077094,
-0.0408445187,
0.0478928722,
-0.0444429256,
0.0145700946,
-0.02245,
-0.0150900241,
-0.0077340878,
-0.0159754343,
0.0346797258,
0.0122674461,
-0.0085293064,
0.0268155076,
-0.0840020403,
-0.0566663109,
-0.0231385008,
0.0464762375,
0.0120700877,
0.048420459,
0.0183788966,
-0.027613366,
-0.0395255275,
-0.0518489257,
0.0315461084,
0.0378276296,
0.0155821657,
0.0403996594,
0.0009491811,
0.040752463,
0.0032286136,
0.0286676046,
-0.0090839732,
-0.0280158855,
-0.039395459,
0.0224251151,
0.0221198462,
0.024856532,
-0.0006566292,
-0.0609683022,
-0.000908837,
-0.0057146512,
0.0647298545,
0.0103688985,
0.0390188918,
-0.0193960182,
-0.0076760906,
0.011293184,
-0.0280472822,
0.0674109682,
-0.0548626892,
0.0014576049,
-0.04797858,
-0.0634524971,
-0.0429552533,
-0.0467412919,
-0.0292941835,
-0.0087583698,
-0.0117466375,
-0.025322089,
-0.0800341442,
-0.0562980883,
0.0010483755,
0.0100767352,
0.0231842492,
-0.0133954473,
0.0341729708,
0.0674819127,
0.0022454092,
0.0025057215,
-0.0317995586,
0.0397064239,
-0.0443095341,
0.0212553795,
-0.0041100136,
-5.379546306e-33,
-0.0122194709,
-0.0676233768,
0.0238304529,
-0.0201082155,
-0.001051721,
0.0215113927,
-0.0320755914,
-0.0152895674,
-0.0062786741,
0.020302834,
-0.0157126673,
-0.0244608093,
0.0166547038,
0.0125513067,
0.0292384736,
0.0196425077,
0.0370000526,
0.0138605414,
-0.0317834802,
-0.0122836307,
-0.040749263,
-0.005651921,
0.0119547537,
-0.09558101,
0.0093787191,
-0.0210013669,
-0.0042523984,
-0.0394045934,
-0.0041737589,
0.0355926193,
0.0214986727,
0.0112974709,
0.0270487051,
0.0121979397,
0.0133572696,
-0.019413285,
-0.0648323372,
-0.0369396992,
0.0014056872,
-0.0298745539,
-0.0335900374,
0.0135689573,
0.015204234,
-0.0236083977,
-0.013710198,
0.0050842338,
0.0372502692,
-0.0347168893,
-0.0236964989,
-0.0556126088,
-0.0445734002,
0.0594321564,
0.0028074174,
-0.003770354,
-0.0418798141,
0.0204347223,
-0.0234842002,
-0.0086312927,
-0.0176305771,
-0.0058537442,
0.0359577648,
-0.0141763603,
0.0177391768,
-0.0502369963,
-0.0261594541,
0.0164662246,
0.0651364774,
-0.0136553608,
-0.0596286096,
0.0474481434,
-0.0868993178,
0.0323675312,
0.0253830627,
0.0271730367,
0.0075394423,
-0.0452652201,
-0.0486761294,
0.0816520452,
-0.0619942211,
0.0609159544,
0.0050240001,
-0.0401268527,
-0.1068062633,
0.0117099825,
0.007984099,
-0.0407992229,
0.0050168778,
-0.0254962239,
0.0484543927,
0.0158503409,
0.0182541776,
-0.0028110996,
-0.0437897779,
-0.0030595665,
0.0729468316,
-0.046226237,
0.0167611316,
0.0337178893,
-0.0485772602,
-0.0386236571,
-0.0316639207,
0.0059528691,
0.0144758495,
0.0756212324,
0.0612539649,
0.0118028391,
-0.0084428899,
-0.0137808546,
-0.0560447872,
0.0281690154,
0.0439106263,
0.0194061827,
-0.0325417444,
-0.0167889167,
0.0186045449,
-0.0114923259,
-0.0074149328,
0.010950584,
-0.006122862,
0.0076854657,
-0.0345710404,
-0.0875355974,
0.0125623476,
-0.0132478634,
-0.0368971527,
0.0017776786,
-0.034011066,
0.014214294,
0.0370905176,
0.0121042654,
0.0117355436,
-0.0052165776,
2.736e-7,
0.0705157965,
0.0329507105,
0.0344140381,
0.0353871807,
0.0168920625,
-0.0160626341,
0.0245217439,
-0.0262896195,
-0.0034932564,
0.0310365502,
0.0662195981,
-0.0375031866,
0.0004007003,
0.0734485835,
-0.019270692,
-0.0096152425,
-0.0946997255,
-0.0220466163,
-0.022744609,
-0.0161409248,
0.0641645566,
-0.0007196448,
-0.015979968,
-0.054173965,
0.0160169415,
-0.0143956505,
-0.0155510232,
0.0144830532,
0.0094542345,
0.0211086497,
0.0777669325,
0.0153168179,
0.0438976698,
0.0666724816,
-0.0312468149,
-0.0249173101,
0.0125268381,
0.0444390662,
-0.0532984324,
0.0084364312,
0.0315198265,
-0.0044882949,
0.0354332998,
-0.0409430265,
0.0161811523,
0.0251446944,
-0.0127805322,
-0.0078819171,
-0.0293776132,
0.0309833456,
0.063385047,
-0.0360489935,
-0.0314588547,
0.0180089027,
0.0073938407,
0.0260315184,
-0.0084033739,
-0.0441323221,
0.0023239851,
0.0100849634,
0.01333501,
-0.0499400422,
0.0819604173,
-0.0242659282,
-0.0041349218,
-0.031546291,
0.0033292575,
2.094592491e-34,
0.0240817089,
-0.001968185,
0.0010336103,
-0.0510896333,
0.0206214059,
0.0045463108,
0.0309494194,
0.0163486172,
0.0187532622,
-0.0008953292,
-0.0327139124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13258v1 | ViStruct: Visual Structural Knowledge Extraction via Curriculum Guided Code-Vision Representation | 2023-11-22T09:23:34 | 2023-11-22T09:23:34 | Yangyi Chen, Xingyao Wang, Manling Li, Derek Hoiem, Heng Ji | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | State-of-the-art vision-language models (VLMs) still have limited performance
in structural knowledge extraction, such as relations between objects. In this
work, we present ViStruct, a training framework to learn VLMs for effective
visual structural knowledge extraction. Two novel designs are incorporated.
First, we propose to leverage the inherent structure of programming language to
depict visual structural information. This approach enables explicit and
consistent representation of visual structural information of multiple
granularities, such as concepts, relations, and events, in a well-organized
structured format. Second, we introduce curriculum-based learning for VLMs to
progressively comprehend visual structures, from fundamental visual concepts to
intricate event structures. Our intuition is that lower-level knowledge may
contribute to complex visual structure understanding. Furthermore, we compile
and release a collection of datasets tailored for visual structural knowledge
extraction. We adopt a weakly-supervised approach to directly generate visual
event structures from captions for ViStruct training, capitalizing on abundant
image-caption pairs from the web. In experiments, we evaluate ViStruct on
visual structure prediction tasks, demonstrating its effectiveness in improving
the understanding of visual structures. The code is public at
\url{https://github.com/Yangyi-Chen/vi-struct}. | [
-0.0001224207,
0.0486582071,
-0.0325663351,
0.07867378,
0.0033459251,
0.0341035649,
-0.0449020565,
-0.0069884136,
0.0329961106,
-0.0426692888,
0.0016228467,
0.0240162387,
0.0125262812,
0.0650936291,
0.0089726625,
-0.0936196744,
0.0161491632,
-0.0408530533,
-0.0186147783,
0.0334934033,
0.0064611984,
0.0021527964,
-0.0034976942,
0.0085364152,
0.000718183,
-0.0418032855,
-0.0231535304,
0.0047416044,
0.0278383475,
-0.0551635809,
-0.007932351,
0.0047496874,
0.0701375082,
-0.0499856509,
0.0000021802,
0.0063032173,
0.0138652511,
-0.0276327375,
0.0357543714,
0.0213868544,
-0.0135422833,
-0.0642875135,
0.0134576773,
-0.0349728279,
-0.0402977653,
-0.0115543641,
0.066166833,
0.0034347891,
0.0364067778,
0.0143292919,
-0.0180732589,
-0.0119853336,
0.0247285645,
-0.010825973,
0.0264089126,
-0.0101179359,
0.0166731458,
0.0937175304,
-0.0330198705,
0.0255642217,
-0.059699811,
0.0464740172,
-0.0038946555,
-0.0212249123,
0.0386701077,
0.0483819842,
-0.0359664075,
-0.0442053378,
-0.0084104082,
0.092218861,
0.003676676,
0.0036042058,
0.0340467095,
-0.0008948309,
0.0073155239,
-0.0121840704,
-0.0728358105,
0.0429597162,
-0.0266199708,
-0.0031967491,
-0.0282423366,
-0.0011372685,
-0.0148967868,
-0.0380189158,
0.0135930181,
-0.0674294829,
-0.0113608725,
0.0329625607,
-0.0474574976,
-0.0064395261,
-0.0167566296,
-0.0246344265,
-0.0342826992,
0.040559262,
0.0251219999,
0.0130006606,
-0.0198885649,
-0.0089854766,
-0.0324925333,
-0.0718824938,
0.0175464004,
-0.0011619371,
-0.0630969331,
0.077545315,
-0.0575010926,
0.0910231993,
-0.0216001142,
0.0437239781,
-0.0196022615,
0.0057390709,
-0.0766385198,
0.0018503178,
-0.0116006173,
0.0281594917,
-0.0378619321,
-0.0165532995,
-0.0060734614,
0.0196879767,
-0.040465638,
0.0379484557,
-0.0393008254,
0.0236465484,
-0.0296110809,
0.0294512995,
-0.0417126268,
0.0001712679,
-0.0109668877,
-0.0454559885,
-0.0692149699,
-0.0038829157,
-0.006413728,
0.0310306232,
-0.0004872875,
0.006387129,
-0.0203543585,
0.0653507933,
-0.0322381593,
0.0151723679,
-0.0623668097,
-0.0455712825,
-0.0014622512,
0.0233064722,
0.0786612108,
-0.0624517426,
0.0135668442,
-0.0205059629,
0.0080812452,
-0.0390850753,
0.0184811186,
-0.0087427534,
-0.0165429413,
0.0757161379,
-0.0476591401,
-0.0183656048,
-0.0238306671,
0.0255590566,
0.0209718347,
0.0210189,
0.0219495147,
0.0399631746,
0.0207753312,
-0.0184731018,
0.0077550383,
0.010759362,
-0.0023419468,
-0.0179503784,
-0.0643731654,
0.0392602012,
0.0386341065,
-0.0178458262,
0.0386561081,
-0.0065058107,
-0.0301586725,
-0.0113662118,
0.022474546,
0.0132534634,
-0.014982379,
0.0176057033,
0.0380566344,
0.0057372293,
0.0216661971,
-0.0063229064,
-0.0538289882,
0.0767350718,
0.0191404391,
0.0240649506,
-0.0901867598,
0.0037128082,
-0.0161399543,
-0.0758568347,
-0.000615371,
0.0030169429,
0.0017609189,
0.0041556447,
0.0561731495,
0.0133079337,
-0.0153904632,
-0.0005745817,
0.0298799835,
-0.0288596712,
0.0196700674,
-0.00559266,
0.0094946828,
0.0552734286,
0.0161582083,
-0.0453162268,
-0.0279542524,
0.017100336,
0.0512228683,
-0.0131284986,
0.0160716884,
-0.0535310879,
0.0196579378,
-0.034005519,
-0.0367371105,
-0.0448987223,
-0.0212146156,
0.0131639428,
0.0164040755,
-0.0392842367,
0.0157759469,
-0.0075599919,
-0.0446902253,
0.0501319394,
0.0431951433,
-0.0287872534,
-0.0697076991,
0.018127948,
-0.0132393111,
-0.0268267449,
-0.0065451348,
-0.0269721895,
0.0411315337,
-0.0372888185,
0.0385177471,
0.019943567,
-0.0431102291,
-0.0490745679,
0.0476773381,
-0.0756167024,
-0.027793156,
-0.0120711932,
-0.0534420982,
-0.0008438815,
0.0599912666,
-0.0020713122,
-0.0103880996,
0.004641972,
-0.0147189777,
0.0112706209,
-0.0296622384,
-0.0134693664,
0.0762499571,
-0.007942385,
-0.0381141417,
0.048568055,
-0.0108690411,
0.014492196,
0.027159119,
-0.001966621,
0.0085876342,
-0.0044313334,
0.0150377396,
0.0159987733,
0.0046453332,
-0.0514281467,
0.0181952436,
-0.0562835373,
-0.022090856,
0.0021079311,
-0.0236032326,
0.0152018294,
-0.0319932662,
0.0275453459,
-0.0481372625,
-0.0153857479,
0.0244625248,
-0.0805801898,
-0.0155897271,
0.0559389889,
0.0041497215,
-0.0410940535,
-0.0292701293,
-0.0033479373,
-0.0407873243,
0.0581193976,
0.06321311,
-0.0258126706,
-0.0090773171,
0.0183744691,
0.0035563335,
0.0402052291,
-0.0385757238,
-0.0336969383,
0.0055212891,
-0.0398913585,
0.0107622668,
0.0939076021,
-0.0255571008,
0.0627049357,
0.0358456336,
-0.0414670371,
-0.0265489966,
0.0149297668,
0.0097400146,
-0.0139178131,
-0.011983389,
0.0007061845,
-0.0156553127,
0.028756097,
-0.0063506174,
0.0398846939,
-0.0837689787,
0.006087963,
0.0097580347,
-0.0160146095,
-0.0454565659,
-0.0150337517,
0.0227783434,
0.0234828889,
-0.0468934178,
-0.0566770285,
0.0415899567,
-0.0305531081,
-0.0045406939,
0.0540548898,
0.0170888454,
-0.0425437167,
0.1269131601,
0.0489190668,
0.0077924794,
0.0211270396,
-0.0150199234,
-0.0531818084,
-0.0015342175,
0.0246626586,
0.0105795143,
0.0257468503,
-0.099938035,
-0.0115688266,
-0.0206913408,
-0.0216351319,
-0.04486949,
0.0530118607,
-0.0145984842,
0.0026990836,
-0.0115103759,
-0.0137111163,
0.0202358346,
-0.0051051057,
0.0113220569,
0.0084621981,
0.0171387475,
-0.0200893208,
-0.0276670791,
0.0274312329,
0.0443398133,
-0.0115087461,
-0.0529875718,
-0.0398006961,
-0.0130686443,
0.0602042936,
0.0086678406,
-0.0060421652,
-0.0750498846,
0.0507264957,
-0.0032649739,
0.0134380087,
-0.0002513324,
0.0327342898,
0.0302788615,
-0.0772286877,
0.0029767912,
0.0537476055,
0.020401651,
-0.0289409701,
-0.0118392436,
0.032215409,
0.0172031056,
0.0839339718,
0.014518518,
-0.0752685368,
-0.0302358903,
-0.0540816039,
-0.0245708004,
0.0499156937,
-0.0296259429,
-0.0206451956,
-0.0363068469,
0.0313598402,
0.0160479117,
0.0010916815,
-0.0788855776,
-0.0067025181,
-0.0116167739,
-0.0144696655,
-0.0752060488,
0.0042976793,
-0.0422234721,
0.0037330184,
0.0135502042,
-0.02954356,
0.0225530826,
0.0438479148,
-0.0328857377,
-0.0133904088,
0.0508627482,
0.0167401657,
0.0062854178,
-0.034021385,
0.0190249141,
0.0011028965,
0.0387171954,
-0.0092232423,
0.0672090277,
-0.015369474,
-0.0528566241,
0.0086019626,
0.0373835824,
-0.0286840741,
-0.0410440676,
0.023905538,
0.037519332,
0.011320265,
-0.0082529727,
-0.035633482,
-0.0162549857,
-0.0263397358,
0.0139045147,
0.0433578491,
0.020725349,
-0.0180824641,
-0.0249354746,
0.0292619132,
-0.0475470312,
-0.0244726129,
0.0170438401,
0.0156469345,
0.016719358,
-0.0674587712,
0.0075654192,
0.0640020072,
0.0159857459,
0.0077049383,
-0.0477078371,
0.0348302573,
0.0032800999,
-0.1076767966,
0.068833217,
-0.0410412289,
-0.0082996143,
0.0069945757,
-0.0219575558,
0.0078102262,
-0.038676668,
-0.0440492146,
0.0312902033,
-0.0683096498,
-0.0114595117,
-0.0476516187,
0.0831757337,
0.0021064025,
0.0684591681,
0.0387991741,
0.0002064701,
-0.0144492462,
0.0213958602,
0.0072224136,
-0.004184878,
-0.0017112831,
-0.0458185039,
-0.0067837313,
-0.0181123149,
-0.035188593,
0.0062428112,
-0.005027323,
0.0014053333,
-0.0110244825,
0.0458992533,
0.0314263254,
-0.0084568933,
0.0552072637,
0.0087566925,
-0.0034201508,
-0.0211588498,
-0.0023455108,
0.0104695819,
-0.0096390536,
-0.0588998683,
0.0427566878,
-0.0056206691,
0.0209238976,
0.0177811757,
-0.0062947124,
0.0228104964,
0.0212222375,
-0.0209376328,
0.0046100472,
0.0469179936,
-0.0020257114,
0.0237255041,
0.0098859919,
0.0048077451,
0.0466873683,
-0.0197243243,
0.0375229791,
-0.0114061916,
0.0384814143,
0.0263314992,
0.0122529073,
-0.0142126679,
0.0029601117,
-0.0137783596,
-0.0129019152,
-0.0215473175,
0.0136092361,
0.0676952153,
-0.0052075069,
-0.0054291682,
-0.0273626689,
0.0198425911,
0.0075315386,
0.0518468656,
-0.0016868199,
-0.0159760099,
0.0514804237,
0.052570492,
0.0061080554,
-0.0498706885,
0.0789198652,
0.0184651799,
0.0264082216,
-0.0068740309,
-0.0218417216,
-0.0354902372,
0.0058043865,
0.0493635051,
0.0130005348,
-0.0070833103,
0.0299768969,
-0.0299474373,
-0.0402531959,
0.0218463577,
0.0226091668,
0.0203932561,
0.0248351637,
0.0528607331,
0.0457120091,
0.0219138227,
-0.0383810736,
0.0136430711,
-0.023623012,
-0.0003326583,
-0.0042392714,
-0.0119548626,
-5.797783523e-33,
-0.0379069261,
-0.055064559,
0.0482698381,
0.0713608116,
-0.0002307326,
0.0511862896,
-0.0488134995,
-0.0006268786,
-0.0207107924,
0.0204460714,
0.0573508255,
-0.010561699,
-0.0131207192,
-0.0007757879,
0.0328454114,
0.0129280221,
0.0465952009,
0.0184942596,
0.0057320693,
0.0317529738,
0.0165766515,
0.0107049653,
0.0558123812,
-0.0965724289,
-0.011194176,
0.0115762921,
0.0216251723,
-0.0019818533,
0.0820971429,
0.0459701978,
-0.0171805769,
-0.0094822189,
0.0340449363,
0.0157235339,
-0.0280815531,
-0.0107453745,
-0.1284717172,
-0.0266761109,
0.0238311645,
0.0184723008,
-0.06666933,
-0.0159950387,
0.0146751693,
-0.0158252586,
0.0487971343,
-0.0711449161,
0.0900463983,
-0.0202572253,
0.0105272382,
-0.0287349671,
-0.0690685064,
0.0240152758,
-0.0623254776,
-0.015173356,
0.0687647164,
-0.0112435259,
0.0460022762,
0.0505015887,
-0.0116375824,
0.027630087,
0.0095621003,
0.0344145298,
0.0759020895,
0.0629653931,
0.0335461646,
0.0678393841,
0.0103600388,
-0.0224321336,
-0.0380268991,
0.0280045401,
0.0216924902,
0.1003507823,
0.0251820367,
0.0149513641,
-0.0035380307,
0.0393980742,
-0.0766257271,
-0.0095179174,
-0.0621090271,
0.0652089268,
-0.0508882031,
0.0227018725,
-0.0244851578,
0.0037828246,
-0.0192592815,
-0.0198411066,
-0.0264295749,
0.0108470386,
0.038876608,
0.0095270798,
-0.0116850184,
0.0388721451,
0.0112774335,
-0.0360825323,
0.0039170561,
0.0209605526,
-0.0125448518,
0.0523714051,
-0.0113376332,
0.0171797983,
-0.0382143408,
-0.0402284078,
0.0435872898,
-0.0211730842,
0.0663141683,
0.0292304251,
0.0581226088,
0.0135987336,
-0.0069621122,
-0.0145638129,
-0.0479246527,
-0.0437164642,
-0.0025595368,
0.0039118463,
0.0111906175,
0.0343778841,
-0.0580756143,
0.0145984823,
-0.0042588399,
-0.0098880054,
-0.0062595373,
-0.0275546834,
-0.0053567984,
0.0421609581,
-0.0159892365,
-0.054466255,
-0.0585280582,
-0.0083210943,
0.0343892127,
-0.0578697287,
-0.024886135,
0.0379290991,
2.67e-7,
0.0211617444,
0.0394705907,
0.0488973223,
0.0482596382,
0.0009121385,
0.046195209,
-0.0176435579,
0.0188798085,
-0.0178718716,
-0.077380456,
0.0060102269,
0.0497494005,
-0.0037746851,
0.0191569161,
-0.0266528986,
0.0301432293,
-0.0004140322,
-0.0528785251,
-0.0497275218,
-0.0082373852,
0.0805233493,
0.0265235696,
-0.0157176331,
0.0031962316,
0.0446429625,
-0.0475716703,
0.0495161079,
-0.0032028514,
0.0155566148,
0.0090948418,
-0.0661890656,
0.0399653986,
-0.0754522756,
0.0476625115,
-0.0308169387,
-0.039372161,
0.0273712091,
0.026845118,
-0.0390550271,
0.0507074445,
-0.0148631781,
-0.0038986513,
-0.0194425844,
-0.0275722668,
0.0456521884,
-0.0613916516,
0.0413249172,
0.0169398822,
-0.0459820256,
0.0296092145,
-0.0312968418,
0.0251226686,
0.0002250394,
0.0282466374,
-0.0127055412,
-0.0343124419,
-0.0343942381,
-0.0511752181,
0.0040254309,
-0.0021808231,
0.0163248125,
-0.0198882036,
-0.0437729992,
-0.0258682165,
-0.0080534313,
0.0127823604,
-0.0282424297,
2.300286095e-34,
0.0098763891,
-0.014951244,
0.003297304,
0.0124051329,
0.0487086475,
-0.0546934009,
-0.0493895821,
0.0178202763,
0.0081634512,
-0.0157398321,
-0.0278086253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14741v1 | @ve: A Chatbot for Latin | 2023-11-22T09:06:11 | 2023-11-22T09:06:11 | Oliver Bendel, Karim N'diaye | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.RO, I.2; K.3 | Dead, extinct, and endangered languages have been preserved primarily through
audio conservation and the collection and digitization of scripts and have been
promoted through targeted language acquisition efforts. Another possibility
would be to build conversational agents that can master these languages. This
would provide an artificial, active conversational partner which has knowledge
of the vocabulary and grammar, and one learns with it in a different way. The
chatbot @ve, with which one can communicate in Latin, was developed in
2022/2023 based on GPT-3.0. It was additionally equipped with a manually
created knowledge base. After conceptual groundwork, this paper presents the
preparation and implementation of the project. In addition, it summarizes the
test that a Latin expert conducted with the chatbot. A critical discussion
elaborates advantages and disadvantages. @ve could be a new tool for teaching
Latin in a memorable and entertaining way through dialogue. However, the
present implementation is still too prone to glitches for stand-alone use -
i.e., without the accompaniment of a teacher. The use of GPT-4 could be a
solution as well as the extension of the knowledge base. In conclusion, it can
be argued that conversational agents are an innovative approach to promoting
and preserving languages. | [
0.058261279,
0.0136557277,
-0.0361129418,
0.0296333693,
-0.0234925654,
0.0076415953,
-0.0119652124,
0.0274536796,
0.0488493852,
-0.000878037,
-0.0134381754,
0.0172994174,
0.011534947,
-0.0013498991,
0.0189221334,
-0.1006169766,
0.0332188606,
-0.0101441927,
0.0069318549,
-0.0228276607,
0.0555369891,
0.0282729492,
-0.0360718668,
0.0320224613,
-0.0284898598,
-0.0274854898,
-0.0501368046,
-0.0309907049,
0.0074259737,
0.020604128,
-0.0171552487,
0.004506479,
0.0298741255,
0.0962584391,
0.0000019966,
-0.036897704,
-0.0197905507,
-0.026450526,
-0.0199328624,
-0.0560100973,
0.0390725508,
0.0500484146,
-0.0554265045,
-0.0170912538,
-0.0676596537,
0.0341185257,
0.0499835163,
-0.0199884251,
0.0203547813,
0.0670756102,
-0.0171381272,
-0.0100471145,
0.0339221582,
0.0308797974,
0.0246233772,
-0.0409350879,
-0.0301788654,
0.0377160572,
0.0695334598,
0.0258120764,
-0.0148442499,
0.0523911156,
0.0051320354,
-0.0459993556,
-0.0406161025,
0.0164679363,
-0.0249996316,
-0.0395778604,
-0.0354672298,
0.0125643909,
0.052191902,
-0.0136521803,
0.0117172385,
0.0604018308,
0.0422938727,
-0.0214626733,
-0.0518196933,
0.0100999614,
0.000348753,
0.0007723761,
0.035918463,
-0.0266909972,
-0.0403387435,
-0.0044636508,
0.0341970176,
0.0167857315,
0.0382415242,
-0.0192198101,
-0.0039431038,
0.0170435756,
0.0104293395,
-0.0289774798,
0.0368487202,
0.0704714879,
-0.0091114724,
0.0556821115,
-0.0191105995,
-0.029886445,
-0.0018686031,
-0.0583497547,
-0.0361689031,
0.0431813151,
0.0137596782,
0.0352613851,
0.0101630082,
0.0462933257,
0.0455731191,
0.0160713363,
0.0248439554,
0.0191181898,
-0.0544746593,
-0.0359339155,
-0.0853547081,
0.0581211075,
0.0040834192,
0.025504861,
-0.0042043468,
0.0448586233,
0.0464689024,
0.0276677031,
-0.0435671993,
-0.0299176928,
-0.0215248,
-0.0193053763,
-0.0350411683,
0.032879822,
-0.0452196524,
-0.0253449362,
-0.0229990315,
-0.0920146853,
0.0324415304,
0.0149619253,
-0.0133745419,
-0.0241450705,
0.0030443333,
0.0704329014,
-0.0508008748,
-0.0469190627,
0.0186883155,
-0.0110828383,
-0.0012981074,
-0.0790007412,
-0.0197507478,
-0.0286037102,
0.0246023275,
-0.0133480271,
0.0198288113,
-0.0213871468,
0.0094628809,
0.0185124222,
0.0386139266,
0.0334160365,
-0.0543544404,
-0.0065953992,
0.0531111285,
-0.0129445465,
0.0080125248,
0.0422557555,
0.0375695415,
-0.0232870895,
0.0330289751,
-0.0224760119,
-0.0111408969,
0.0092180055,
-0.0205844007,
-0.0088074543,
0.0381637998,
-0.0140755037,
0.0272517428,
0.0348975696,
-0.0328562371,
0.0407564268,
-0.0281664785,
0.0386449955,
0.0514798686,
0.0423202105,
-0.0327283666,
0.0483002178,
0.0140416408,
0.0006797899,
0.0492593274,
0.0032991529,
-0.0127773248,
0.0068846722,
-0.0000975529,
-0.0202867985,
-0.0485180691,
0.0050244755,
-0.0036849922,
-0.0296737552,
0.0380401239,
-0.0166918188,
0.0762294084,
-0.0306568444,
0.0715726614,
0.0106790029,
-0.0395212062,
0.0035251502,
0.0150333773,
-0.0738941133,
-0.0347475745,
-0.0551929176,
0.048984699,
0.10525693,
0.0726267621,
-0.0307826549,
-0.0305855293,
0.0264450684,
-0.016782498,
0.0592592321,
0.0316327512,
-0.0175689179,
-0.0173951071,
-0.0404814407,
0.0141456462,
-0.0065677483,
-0.0011624858,
0.0332968608,
-0.0138619458,
0.0880778283,
0.0004468213,
0.0124983154,
0.0108603397,
0.0103625832,
-0.0180062521,
-0.0162550956,
-0.0893772319,
0.0059088287,
-0.0126290154,
0.053565558,
0.0017895226,
-0.012289877,
0.0227021873,
0.0314110965,
0.0248276908,
0.0587264895,
-0.0243500806,
0.0219059158,
0.0817509443,
-0.0819057301,
-0.0204872247,
0.0340725034,
0.0402799845,
-0.0396873802,
0.0078398958,
-0.0936301872,
0.0885197893,
-0.017395895,
0.0379056893,
-0.0440800786,
-0.0296250433,
0.0099355401,
0.0085323928,
0.0649894401,
-0.0268328954,
-0.001581535,
-0.0006679485,
0.0535449721,
-0.0449510925,
-0.0503147431,
0.0274288151,
-0.0001529843,
0.0089176083,
0.0398531668,
0.0348243341,
-0.0363494866,
0.0057050693,
-0.1061434969,
-0.0136416573,
-0.0145148784,
-0.0009263846,
0.0048508709,
0.010544844,
-0.0103620356,
-0.0376622416,
-0.0421292521,
0.0752410144,
-0.0159746949,
-0.0310149416,
0.0294803753,
-0.0028308271,
-0.0190440752,
-0.0345958471,
0.0286750644,
0.0210375357,
-0.0414905958,
0.0796204507,
-0.0640776902,
-0.0289283935,
0.0299312063,
-0.034141317,
0.0274170879,
-0.0019103517,
-0.0607298538,
0.0481569767,
-0.0401714817,
0.0021101893,
0.015970666,
-0.0032661315,
0.0273973756,
0.0123193702,
-0.0253674164,
-0.0226589292,
0.0122783771,
-0.0021914835,
-0.0287172627,
-0.0498368368,
0.0066103083,
-0.0032591973,
0.0085559972,
-0.0229179394,
0.0351314656,
-0.0771216974,
0.0102127278,
0.0007594956,
-0.0131782182,
-0.0068359212,
-0.0025901883,
-0.0355344526,
-0.0124420524,
0.0157215837,
-0.0131238867,
0.067632705,
-0.0117334044,
-0.0454584435,
-0.0711347312,
-0.0132222939,
-0.0062576854,
0.0447618254,
-0.0242140777,
0.0151995001,
0.0043390514,
-0.0521419309,
-0.0248608142,
0.0436477624,
0.0433847532,
-0.0395097099,
-0.0043408684,
-0.0446339548,
0.0082342224,
0.0027742344,
-0.007397512,
-0.0197182633,
0.0400435403,
-0.055813279,
-0.0352443382,
0.0522603951,
-0.0246216226,
-0.0402558893,
0.0067363661,
0.0076465951,
0.0478983,
0.0181604791,
0.0029180821,
-0.024426965,
-0.0459256507,
-0.0034109331,
0.0399807394,
-0.0357472003,
0.0064233416,
0.0645943731,
0.0363589898,
0.0088095553,
-0.0526518226,
-0.008119124,
-0.0392158628,
0.027232796,
0.0006411024,
-0.0683499649,
-0.0281230826,
0.0028097352,
-0.0366930775,
-0.0166747496,
0.070122987,
0.0052174809,
-0.0578156598,
-0.007426816,
-0.0510307588,
0.0088067492,
-0.0267172605,
0.0438049026,
-0.0772670805,
0.0104670115,
0.0015811246,
0.0248161498,
-0.0044622947,
-0.0017223225,
0.0073631797,
-0.0983638763,
0.0341121443,
0.0196339022,
-0.0582897663,
-0.0183213074,
0.0009766682,
-0.0306918174,
-0.0063486979,
0.0244886167,
0.026042968,
-0.0040721777,
-0.0042730505,
-0.0214060396,
-0.0181404352,
0.0071974699,
-0.0018058768,
0.0254670046,
0.0509615019,
0.0673504248,
0.0960162133,
-0.0139118079,
-0.0075188917,
-0.00987902,
0.0283003226,
0.0101515781,
-0.0045592962,
0.0680481717,
-0.0101602711,
-0.0146654211,
-0.0599211752,
-0.0167286359,
0.0227387678,
-0.0014693068,
0.0609050058,
0.0456976369,
-0.0417679399,
0.0184767041,
0.0083003705,
-0.0006219975,
-0.0199390743,
0.0191456806,
-0.0174598712,
-0.007512344,
-0.0272472594,
-0.0382544734,
0.0261921622,
0.0025147868,
-0.0625475273,
-0.0283193197,
-0.0535131358,
-0.0400779918,
-0.0959773064,
-0.0547010526,
0.056768164,
0.0413079821,
0.033608228,
0.0214345977,
0.0024459104,
0.0431249626,
-0.0133698136,
-0.0226743892,
-0.0295292605,
0.0059237098,
-0.0573943406,
-0.0605855547,
-0.0207443386,
-0.0386190638,
0.0090902923,
0.0114583094,
0.013356111,
-0.0504690111,
-0.0074172202,
0.0450179912,
0.0274354927,
0.0352781937,
-0.0314270407,
-0.0314105451,
-0.0039297258,
-0.0398210958,
-0.0022295443,
0.0176348034,
0.0408354066,
0.0019390265,
0.0079727015,
0.0079320446,
-0.0203665886,
-0.0570968725,
-0.0454437882,
-0.0163284149,
-0.0296522025,
-0.0218205769,
0.0231010672,
0.0661875457,
-0.0438106507,
-0.0289589502,
-0.0040728627,
-0.0047463663,
0.0108183604,
-0.0465101898,
0.0063558086,
-0.0299630929,
0.0426660664,
-0.0208720155,
-0.0057589766,
0.0419284478,
-0.0567452237,
-0.0404761583,
-0.0171992406,
0.0163932517,
0.0239798948,
0.0494827479,
0.000318706,
0.0033482006,
0.0472333059,
0.0122395977,
0.0409112833,
0.010306689,
0.0694228858,
-0.0034474463,
0.0570520982,
0.0063183196,
-0.0535937846,
0.0676421598,
0.014722744,
-0.0330141559,
-0.0555190407,
-0.0016183957,
0.0820635408,
0.0525794178,
0.0437066779,
0.0640351474,
-0.0754037723,
0.0232961383,
0.0069931587,
0.0196513254,
0.0280082077,
-0.0185156222,
-0.0543856993,
-0.0031655438,
0.0133448783,
-0.0278813262,
0.022225488,
-0.0540949404,
0.0342765413,
0.0226085298,
0.0076865293,
-0.0453293212,
-0.0124692461,
-0.0005903799,
0.0044462499,
0.0062015341,
-0.0121837286,
-0.0179592725,
-0.0428707786,
-0.0513853617,
0.0282509699,
-0.035432823,
-0.03352708,
0.0710670054,
0.0118337749,
-0.0168458913,
0.0151952626,
-0.0376238637,
0.0596291907,
-0.0458280481,
0.0146186128,
-0.0347005427,
-5.320155556e-33,
-0.0456602909,
-0.0321005061,
0.0148251345,
0.055741854,
-0.0458872356,
-0.0467935503,
-0.0512926914,
0.0178592056,
-0.0102888485,
0.0248907469,
-0.0195916854,
-0.004158183,
0.0199520774,
-0.0476813577,
0.0241091419,
0.0124144461,
0.0203485675,
-0.0055902116,
-0.0075913649,
0.0396621302,
0.072924614,
0.0184797514,
0.064459689,
-0.0864112526,
0.0632813871,
-0.056314934,
-0.0319938622,
-0.0098448843,
-0.0087978439,
0.0201441161,
0.0027962155,
0.0392802134,
0.0036675835,
0.0029266551,
-0.0215024017,
0.0597613454,
-0.0253335685,
-0.0435974784,
0.0475758016,
0.0829403922,
0.0279635768,
-0.0373221822,
-0.0365049094,
-0.047387477,
0.0012564864,
0.0584551804,
0.0257048644,
-0.00329841,
0.0181225985,
0.0100589562,
-0.0773925334,
0.0111781415,
-0.032560382,
-0.0490436628,
0.0416286364,
0.0324105993,
0.0023979906,
-0.0722129047,
0.0014206416,
0.0728944615,
0.0048398226,
-0.0286108013,
0.0196778532,
-0.0351769701,
-0.0054653394,
0.0125943683,
0.0225377027,
0.0127790216,
0.0150151243,
0.0367711745,
0.0319977403,
0.0293342918,
0.0718856528,
0.0470426977,
-0.0110506378,
-0.0101663722,
0.019472314,
0.0103499647,
0.090444684,
-0.005256176,
-0.0323258303,
0.006709693,
-0.0633938909,
0.0016569942,
0.0073044971,
0.0212418381,
0.0275090784,
-0.0787170678,
-0.0127731785,
-0.042535238,
0.0244905259,
-0.08835008,
-0.0201920047,
-0.027368756,
0.0039368081,
0.001152229,
-0.0333362557,
0.0341847613,
-0.0117831193,
0.0085021323,
0.0166347791,
-0.0282462034,
0.0249288492,
-0.005488486,
0.0082822777,
0.0282645132,
-0.0330392532,
0.0268411171,
0.0086876499,
0.0149424607,
-0.0036997953,
0.0166571811,
0.0226157811,
-0.0125087388,
-0.0074659633,
-0.0102314074,
-0.0032673518,
0.0054199337,
0.0505301952,
-0.000206946,
-0.0483343117,
0.0092425691,
-0.0223013926,
-0.0361303166,
-0.0564616732,
0.0026232188,
-0.0323937349,
0.0351318754,
0.0009202186,
-0.0466051064,
0.0011087438,
-0.0359189957,
2.851e-7,
0.0333315618,
0.0220540576,
0.0309948884,
0.0001668575,
0.007358348,
0.0298757125,
-0.0237383135,
0.0110404864,
-0.0123648196,
0.0005000783,
0.0185735859,
-0.0042642895,
0.0514841601,
0.0280418359,
-0.0885884613,
-0.0242491066,
-0.0099758375,
-0.0639301538,
-0.0545016676,
0.0542945936,
0.0403244384,
0.0299220402,
0.040188998,
-0.0218918975,
-0.0366808921,
0.0077529885,
0.0110559324,
-0.0259854384,
-0.0181921106,
-0.0057805725,
0.0031813984,
0.0255072974,
-0.0225727279,
0.016877858,
0.008118676,
0.0178374518,
-0.0047189808,
0.033700075,
-0.0036432492,
-0.0015203293,
0.0712683052,
-0.0119304368,
-0.0320997387,
-0.0244951919,
0.0392565653,
0.0198368356,
0.0005770377,
0.023418678,
-0.0182758849,
-0.0114678172,
-0.0334659964,
-0.0447740667,
-0.0422462113,
0.0068212436,
-0.0148991076,
-0.0212989971,
0.0154617243,
-0.0266942475,
0.0236714482,
-0.0156392381,
-0.038951505,
-0.1103839949,
-0.0178424194,
-0.0271562357,
-0.0036589052,
-0.0142035428,
0.0067499247,
1.912437244e-34,
-0.0026099873,
-0.0274020024,
0.0327391289,
0.0705299601,
0.0161250494,
0.0285762567,
0.0511726588,
0.0291564129,
0.0591099337,
0.0017626665,
-0.0371068008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13246v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13246v2 | CoachLM: Automatic Instruction Revisions Improve the Data Quality in LLM Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-22T09:04:57 | 2024-03-21T03:50:32 | Yilun Liu, Shimin Tao, Xiaofeng Zhao, Ming Zhu, Wenbing Ma, Junhao Zhu, Chang Su, Yutai Hou, Miao Zhang, Min Zhang, Hongxia Ma, Li Zhang, Hao Yang, Yanfei Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning is crucial for enabling Language Learning Models (LLMs) in
responding to human instructions. The quality of instruction pairs used for
tuning greatly affects the performance of LLMs. However, the manual creation of
high-quality instruction datasets is costly, leading to the adoption of
automatic generation of instruction pairs by LLMs as a popular alternative. To
ensure the high quality of LLM-generated instruction datasets, several
approaches have been proposed. Nevertheless, existing methods either compromise
dataset integrity by filtering a large proportion of samples, or are unsuitable
for industrial applications. In this paper, instead of discarding low-quality
samples, we propose CoachLM, a novel approach to enhance the quality of
instruction datasets through automatic revisions on samples in the dataset.
CoachLM is trained from the samples revised by human experts and significantly
increases the proportion of high-quality samples in the dataset from 17.7% to
78.9%. The effectiveness of CoachLM is further assessed on various real-world
instruction test sets. The results show that CoachLM improves the
instruction-following capabilities of the instruction-tuned LLM by an average
of 29.9%, which even surpasses larger LLMs with nearly twice the number of
parameters. Furthermore, CoachLM is successfully deployed in a data management
system for LLMs at Huawei, resulting in an efficiency improvement of up to 20%
in the cleaning of 40k real-world instruction pairs. We release various assets
of CoachLM, including the training data, code and test set
(https://github.com/lunyiliu/CoachLM). | [
0.0396622382,
0.0316866972,
-0.0343849696,
0.0359223261,
-0.0126937749,
0.0141226389,
-0.0025496809,
-0.0193348136,
0.0018699961,
-0.0483091399,
-0.0433062203,
-0.0215568412,
0.0058607254,
-0.0364989899,
0.017094085,
-0.0403564796,
0.0682737008,
-0.0377850421,
-0.0417167358,
0.0179664381,
-0.0175849535,
0.0230806228,
-0.0020128128,
0.0168636106,
0.0194117408,
-0.0029560577,
-0.0315601341,
0.0309610479,
0.0089427847,
-0.0243939646,
0.0390466414,
0.0535257533,
0.0132513,
-0.0100111365,
0.0000022829,
-0.0540291071,
-0.0296651162,
-0.0190762635,
-0.045520179,
0.0544787496,
0.0468622111,
0.0266984794,
-0.0582923256,
0.0551812761,
-0.0347428024,
0.0420139059,
0.0048359577,
-0.0108417319,
0.0892031267,
0.0948098972,
0.0255028792,
0.0102375904,
-0.0107289301,
0.0457355827,
-0.0040262826,
-0.0179007705,
0.0205631964,
0.0291031301,
-0.018859081,
0.0207863394,
-0.0085564507,
0.0008266881,
0.0321853198,
0.0054278369,
-0.029483214,
-0.0144781889,
-0.0418149345,
-0.0127771422,
-0.0263685118,
0.0572503023,
-0.0237892922,
-0.050205633,
-0.003900182,
-0.0171792265,
-0.0066704047,
-0.0231012274,
-0.0107191326,
0.0187403206,
-0.0137411049,
0.0409345627,
0.0045775617,
-0.0753184259,
0.0102356309,
-0.0097811911,
-0.0050184736,
0.0372037403,
-0.0193213839,
-0.0367015712,
-0.0045711934,
0.0019238283,
-0.0010834262,
-0.0250078831,
0.0192391183,
0.0643229783,
-0.0559613705,
0.052040264,
-0.0655592829,
-0.0144867422,
0.0116730183,
-0.0349267237,
0.0607598983,
0.0446591675,
-0.0243963823,
0.0015813848,
-0.0277485885,
0.0490784496,
0.0593609288,
0.0448524952,
-0.0445531346,
0.038151443,
-0.0455465168,
0.0186812989,
-0.0313049294,
0.030782979,
-0.0095426189,
0.0475160591,
-0.0488648154,
0.050607726,
-0.0049205348,
0.0290383268,
0.0123695144,
-0.0333375968,
-0.0291540902,
0.0223563388,
-0.0320115499,
-0.019554222,
-0.0026299627,
0.0195774529,
-0.02878635,
-0.0680076331,
0.0237496141,
-0.0032164108,
-0.0131114637,
0.0097294142,
0.0232838485,
0.0496915467,
-0.0217985269,
-0.0220659897,
-0.1054969132,
-0.0322516523,
0.0362209007,
-0.0409816653,
-0.0123745669,
-0.0580188632,
0.0055111768,
-0.0056297309,
-0.0354504958,
-0.0389196128,
0.0059364284,
0.0412687734,
-0.0182504877,
0.0208356306,
-0.0345748588,
0.0302698854,
0.0121569093,
0.0121741751,
-0.008556406,
0.0634994581,
0.042028714,
-0.018278081,
0.0588342063,
-0.0498498827,
0.0143491374,
0.0375125445,
0.0202615336,
0.0287835728,
-0.0192074254,
0.0049533453,
-0.0040616542,
-0.0052724709,
0.0393666998,
0.0309137907,
0.0022981949,
-0.0027175781,
0.0533869229,
-0.0021711334,
0.0085263448,
-0.0081214914,
0.0254094154,
0.0451991111,
0.0238962267,
0.0167041402,
-0.0539920889,
-0.0074994531,
-0.0105777578,
0.0057857167,
-0.0026199594,
0.0204035379,
-0.0104012061,
-0.074266091,
-0.0113818478,
-0.0183412004,
-0.0077669895,
0.0297657549,
0.0283532627,
-0.0154308788,
-0.0485069752,
0.0261241812,
0.0509369969,
-0.0403913334,
-0.0154774105,
-0.0789417028,
0.0126139494,
0.1173328534,
0.0298111457,
-0.0114453705,
-0.047920607,
-0.0056072189,
0.0367074125,
-0.0186212994,
0.0427080393,
-0.0264322776,
0.0186456852,
-0.0761235878,
-0.0557624772,
0.0219006725,
-0.0161525365,
0.0191888306,
0.0260471255,
-0.0128696142,
0.0119878734,
0.0007536066,
-0.1007233113,
0.0615394451,
-0.021530563,
-0.0509774014,
0.0004985853,
0.0166162476,
0.0124063184,
0.0229082461,
0.0041593481,
-0.0310511068,
0.0499905013,
0.0511764884,
0.0635129511,
-0.0309223142,
-0.0685275868,
-0.013895167,
0.0401686728,
0.0032311287,
-0.0235758964,
0.0082949689,
-0.056231916,
-0.0502247959,
-0.0436056852,
-0.017149562,
0.0276515912,
-0.0095998328,
0.0599522814,
-0.0245920364,
-0.0093715843,
-0.0208389536,
0.0258143637,
-0.0113723986,
0.0026726965,
0.0443662442,
0.0564959794,
0.0106999557,
-0.0555579253,
-0.0057436824,
-0.0055981292,
-0.0081750648,
0.0499117039,
-0.0061350092,
0.0524958633,
-0.06746234,
0.0093719848,
-0.0521775484,
-0.0055746413,
-0.0198953431,
0.026300218,
0.0370174646,
-0.027045453,
-0.0304605383,
-0.0330565795,
0.0000421516,
-0.0268987287,
-0.0053271167,
0.0033924095,
0.0067936732,
-0.0061298786,
-0.040691115,
-0.0318991989,
0.0144384922,
-0.0113885365,
-0.0211987309,
-0.0214371532,
0.0171556734,
-0.1139663458,
0.0605329536,
-0.002742447,
0.0223909114,
0.0053515015,
-0.070604533,
0.0090238033,
0.0054385415,
0.0266290884,
0.0795438215,
-0.0253085252,
0.0000536454,
0.0580163524,
-0.0134554552,
-0.0860734433,
0.0044753868,
-0.0095901322,
-0.0380340144,
-0.0320006572,
-0.0439375639,
-0.0112367822,
0.0568141639,
0.021638222,
0.002800443,
-0.0232913438,
-0.0027404765,
-0.0195162874,
-0.0125145847,
-0.0027748377,
0.018400209,
-0.0562867261,
0.0089931358,
-0.0275195129,
-0.0869547501,
0.0693317875,
-0.0081578018,
0.0193472262,
-0.0683889315,
-0.0279512536,
0.0073700864,
0.0098108249,
-0.0050142794,
0.0063752634,
-0.0025220946,
-0.0278665349,
-0.0452749468,
0.0192584358,
0.0225595739,
-0.045723103,
0.0222089924,
-0.0913485587,
-0.0206566155,
-0.0001441121,
0.010075531,
-0.0551918037,
0.0204097349,
0.0066926763,
-0.0171332825,
0.0334889889,
-0.0243680496,
-0.0090468079,
-0.0119049922,
0.0258755069,
0.0379971564,
-0.0051343036,
0.0075425846,
-0.0153337121,
-0.0527481027,
0.0036279503,
-0.0074050329,
-0.029351946,
-0.0356555656,
0.0345711038,
0.0306149703,
0.0725164339,
-0.0342561118,
-0.0135876685,
0.0155476909,
0.0290420856,
-0.0268415529,
-0.0166654643,
0.0574820042,
0.0755163059,
-0.0739956349,
-0.0000602205,
0.0995678008,
0.0419262983,
-0.0369696207,
-0.005321756,
0.0034966555,
0.0108157536,
0.0379545912,
0.0434914343,
-0.0764726177,
-0.0253290534,
0.0021592565,
0.0826052353,
0.0050556958,
-0.013697871,
-0.0354036689,
-0.1093724519,
0.0329233706,
0.023297891,
-0.0458922274,
-0.0178213995,
-0.0671205074,
-0.0156967379,
-0.0021838078,
0.0769552067,
0.0313915424,
-0.0234395452,
-0.0033575324,
0.0621520504,
-0.0417912565,
-0.0826398656,
0.0349808633,
-0.0294381585,
0.0608227402,
0.0700840652,
-0.0060699787,
0.0282235183,
-0.0254467484,
0.0291992519,
-0.0078037349,
0.0106748212,
-0.0342283286,
0.0363328606,
-0.0079077734,
0.0000181146,
0.0165014248,
0.0457928292,
-0.023417538,
0.0185159612,
0.0297316387,
0.0621846505,
-0.0334287211,
0.030450657,
-0.0066135018,
-0.0268764384,
0.0003850203,
0.0432327837,
0.0175267383,
-0.0511521921,
0.0062533328,
-0.0465921275,
-0.0248449333,
-0.0691236183,
-0.0087296739,
0.0547294095,
-0.1097960547,
0.007291757,
-0.0532352142,
-0.0635861903,
0.0579663962,
0.0058044125,
0.0257990286,
0.0088362601,
0.0114344256,
-0.0045968234,
-0.0368347391,
0.0068330336,
-0.036933355,
0.0357785001,
-0.1327241063,
-0.0853093192,
0.01148031,
0.0023606576,
0.0042898809,
-0.0076418105,
-0.0572176091,
-0.0820990577,
0.0216551069,
0.0730965883,
0.0113673182,
0.0649818629,
0.0161879305,
-0.0363003314,
-0.0088814972,
0.0217968691,
-0.0385852233,
0.0178040992,
0.0259807967,
0.0092307227,
-0.0160363391,
0.010491142,
-0.0402880162,
0.0224086437,
0.0184412189,
0.0174258891,
-0.0626834258,
-0.0023406758,
0.0300985929,
0.0228785239,
0.0271210484,
-0.0051609655,
-0.032585144,
-0.0214623511,
0.0583563186,
0.0220592394,
-0.0017786738,
-0.0151973832,
0.0362388045,
-0.0191562008,
-0.0161075927,
0.0076679778,
-0.0143268546,
-0.0281938296,
0.0029091341,
-0.0086182021,
0.0555603728,
-0.0099927569,
0.0452703498,
0.0380135365,
0.0161072742,
-0.018066071,
0.0176617,
0.0384761393,
0.036861591,
0.0195349343,
0.0743234828,
-0.0048499373,
0.0295628216,
-0.0039627627,
0.0142390281,
-0.0138568589,
-0.0127652576,
-0.0635607764,
-0.0032890621,
0.0320666432,
-0.0065895258,
0.0354538448,
-0.0243987869,
0.0182226915,
-0.0161246359,
0.0249400977,
-0.0245860387,
0.0115382439,
0.0160030928,
0.015562959,
-0.004383604,
0.0187367499,
0.0582012646,
0.0153077841,
0.0499576703,
-0.0303106196,
-0.0078462204,
-0.0614807233,
0.0037654473,
0.0521667153,
-0.0149404639,
-0.0212254096,
-0.014353238,
-0.0032687793,
-0.0453828387,
-0.0621840395,
0.0395513251,
0.0355075113,
-0.0589992888,
0.0324462354,
0.0567415468,
-0.0300100073,
0.0253516994,
-0.0467153192,
-0.0308050849,
0.0166527443,
-0.0235344861,
-0.017631989,
-6.243152618e-33,
-0.0243558809,
-0.0129113076,
0.0393123627,
0.0170199797,
0.0184952021,
-0.0182562936,
-0.0180818513,
-0.0097934743,
-0.0083312504,
-0.0352515727,
-0.0108798333,
0.0133229354,
0.0192292072,
-0.006333855,
0.0391956009,
0.0154236099,
0.0529218465,
-0.0292762034,
-0.0318358615,
0.0296260081,
0.0401884168,
0.0330402032,
0.075645566,
-0.0408245362,
0.0052630082,
-0.0216089599,
0.0250468198,
0.0227236785,
-0.0245381165,
0.0892593786,
0.0352870747,
0.0177584607,
0.0103149377,
-0.0276873335,
-0.0429211818,
-0.0286290813,
-0.0425503403,
-0.0501476191,
-0.0009206876,
0.0717403293,
-0.0000898362,
-0.0325282998,
0.0567273647,
-0.0215000622,
-0.0556744225,
0.0240422972,
0.0417081416,
-0.0204488765,
-0.0383648649,
-0.0040257936,
-0.0228507482,
0.0301399305,
0.0021877501,
-0.0465148278,
0.0189205687,
0.0098565239,
-0.0169289578,
-0.0394908898,
-0.0657972768,
0.0457970425,
0.0765978545,
0.0729181692,
0.0896944925,
0.0293959305,
-0.0071374215,
0.0039404058,
0.0295897555,
0.0183452684,
0.0639869869,
0.0085229892,
0.0540517233,
0.0484257378,
-0.025689194,
-0.0017229053,
0.0346098505,
-0.035483066,
-0.0168582331,
0.043485634,
0.0305226296,
0.0346850418,
0.0058860132,
0.0144667169,
-0.0404018536,
-0.0165015645,
-0.0231411122,
0.0200573877,
-0.0147675425,
-0.0380965769,
0.0498414338,
0.017333366,
-0.0537492856,
-0.0416557528,
0.030515125,
-0.0152748786,
-0.0217909683,
-0.0444426462,
-0.0368009955,
0.0032141188,
-0.012177025,
-0.0094585456,
-0.0754661933,
-0.057794258,
0.0136681115,
-0.0203437973,
0.0436865166,
0.0079786619,
0.0313416645,
0.0382374488,
-0.0645201355,
0.0282954425,
-0.0391953737,
0.0245605633,
-0.0052036266,
-0.0127694011,
0.0110951457,
-0.0065499418,
-0.0031547758,
0.0790907964,
-0.0040894849,
-0.0387480147,
-0.053497076,
-0.0159507617,
0.0018509611,
0.0375546478,
-0.0334469303,
0.0070725973,
-0.0497956946,
0.005014787,
0.0129141444,
-0.0359204113,
-0.0051499587,
0.0289645791,
2.86e-7,
-0.0096858684,
0.0666051805,
0.010132093,
0.0207502004,
-0.0139851235,
0.0236965641,
-0.0477320477,
-0.0247221533,
0.0131492373,
0.0095506888,
0.0181231741,
0.0096348953,
0.0420185588,
0.0328099839,
-0.0554083027,
-0.0023048087,
-0.0143880323,
0.0081909904,
-0.0573387258,
0.0260465033,
0.0292923059,
0.0667601526,
-0.0021738373,
-0.0133614838,
0.0056919162,
0.0205951836,
-0.0141150709,
-0.0265882518,
0.0094511211,
0.0295677148,
0.0345219709,
0.042264767,
-0.020949563,
0.0272837635,
-0.0464517735,
-0.0050741741,
-0.0726747215,
0.0630199686,
-0.0032663876,
-0.0293933749,
0.0626848266,
-0.046811223,
-0.0171598531,
-0.0200513452,
0.0387918651,
0.0043305773,
0.0238432251,
0.0106027918,
-0.0082112513,
-0.040115878,
-0.019662885,
-0.0157025978,
-0.0079137152,
0.0273185596,
0.0097949831,
-0.0225640368,
-0.0280450154,
-0.0366206728,
0.0074366126,
0.0160802286,
0.0110407574,
-0.0924018547,
-0.0243013166,
0.0098759839,
-0.0109622134,
-0.0260438044,
0.0093296692,
2.640933796e-34,
0.015044841,
-0.0399198718,
0.0389959887,
0.0396594331,
0.0215548836,
0.0122596547,
-0.0044918326,
0.0544293076,
0.021566486,
-0.0311882272,
-0.0292545147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14740v1 | AutoKG: Efficient Automated Knowledge Graph Generation for Language Models | 2023-11-22T08:58:25 | 2023-11-22T08:58:25 | Bohan Chen, Andrea L. Bertozzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Traditional methods of linking large language models (LLMs) to knowledge
bases via the semantic similarity search often fall short of capturing complex
relational dynamics. To address these limitations, we introduce AutoKG, a
lightweight and efficient approach for automated knowledge graph (KG)
construction. For a given knowledge base consisting of text blocks, AutoKG
first extracts keywords using a LLM and then evaluates the relationship weight
between each pair of keywords using graph Laplace learning. We employ a hybrid
search scheme combining vector similarity and graph-based associations to
enrich LLM responses. Preliminary experiments demonstrate that AutoKG offers a
more comprehensive and interconnected knowledge retrieval mechanism compared to
the semantic similarity search, thereby enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in
generating more insightful and relevant outputs. | [
0.0515294299,
-0.003152631,
-0.0222566929,
0.0747264996,
-0.0374861658,
-0.0039487402,
-0.0256386623,
0.0136832409,
0.0814132169,
-0.0500961691,
-0.0055161952,
-0.0093803769,
-0.0429663248,
0.023278283,
0.0164322872,
0.0102839107,
0.0285068452,
0.0310955029,
0.0083731329,
-0.0145156411,
0.004178864,
0.0645180792,
0.0156156681,
0.0104858018,
0.0040546004,
0.0354632549,
0.0114549445,
0.0224118438,
0.0172710381,
-0.0358912759,
-0.0186941382,
0.0270865951,
0.0151052643,
0.0408324525,
0.0000019556,
-0.0618037954,
-0.0484612584,
-0.014689194,
-0.0137255844,
-0.0129205119,
0.0490923002,
0.0044185207,
0.0530353524,
0.0165388416,
-0.0453936942,
-0.0018151393,
0.0320020467,
-0.0202317201,
0.041605372,
0.0723863915,
-0.0209978465,
-0.0438539386,
-0.011337393,
-0.0185079966,
-0.0142050907,
-0.0468623005,
0.0315366127,
0.073812142,
0.0349192098,
-0.0181646831,
-0.005581094,
0.0542841181,
-0.0444832109,
-0.0474236049,
0.0807416886,
0.0141638797,
-0.0309721641,
0.0050781583,
0.0363926478,
0.0992292166,
-0.0160641763,
-0.0429086573,
0.030433299,
-0.0040712808,
-0.0218837969,
0.0885708109,
-0.0453663543,
-0.0004138417,
-0.0173176304,
0.0300063025,
0.0080303065,
-0.0580385327,
0.0642694533,
-0.0065300763,
-0.0273296498,
0.082188189,
0.0280295294,
-0.0081414105,
0.0082220454,
-0.0317238234,
-0.0402781367,
-0.0372920148,
-0.015216249,
0.0284744631,
-0.0001075273,
0.041776415,
0.0193405468,
0.0070118955,
0.0172106083,
-0.0610065833,
0.0184169188,
0.0031331957,
0.063786529,
0.038812574,
-0.0744968504,
0.0271111149,
-0.0229682066,
0.0055743237,
-0.0737210363,
-0.0119635127,
-0.0605177991,
-0.0257851072,
-0.0250248909,
0.0290512443,
-0.0191026181,
-0.0227138866,
-0.0342698209,
0.039587047,
-0.0012208181,
0.0205061287,
0.0215838626,
-0.0051333834,
0.0575233549,
-0.0281861965,
-0.0530162714,
0.0216542818,
0.0255579855,
0.0040329611,
-0.0526558906,
0.0195168145,
0.0407414399,
-0.0067006242,
0.0171048958,
-0.0287923738,
-0.0035560131,
0.0687653124,
0.0090451092,
-0.0022900365,
-0.0570201427,
-0.0177006591,
0.0116373589,
-0.0120925885,
0.0181597788,
-0.1006912664,
0.0139368903,
0.0229324009,
-0.0219283309,
-0.0397234783,
0.0379550271,
0.012829924,
-0.067223981,
0.0577331148,
-0.0419285633,
0.035359513,
0.0201577712,
-0.0005988054,
-0.0067515001,
0.0405527838,
0.0096180243,
0.0096757384,
0.0419817083,
-0.0093160896,
-0.0518437028,
0.0203054696,
0.038401302,
0.0248081125,
-0.0159541257,
0.0201753378,
-0.0028704486,
0.0234407187,
0.0288618412,
0.021917155,
-0.0213769227,
-0.0077495705,
0.016522279,
0.0487790406,
0.0333106145,
0.0462186337,
0.0206114072,
0.0223879497,
-0.0147776883,
-0.0383754037,
-0.0086370772,
-0.0060117422,
-0.0712088719,
0.0171769112,
-0.0025723218,
0.0248730555,
0.000405032,
0.000599927,
-0.0160164014,
0.0212026983,
0.0566959791,
-0.0057559549,
0.0793805569,
0.0005916248,
-0.0274391677,
0.0650919899,
0.0575651303,
-0.0243304204,
-0.0019101712,
-0.0364616439,
0.0015630337,
0.076985389,
0.0551499464,
-0.0108082825,
-0.0353134908,
0.0288814418,
-0.0316279307,
0.0199917145,
0.0140868034,
-0.0248736739,
-0.0574142374,
-0.0609429218,
-0.0355693474,
0.0092876693,
-0.0099158473,
0.0329047255,
-0.000122921,
0.0288975611,
0.038622871,
-0.0797400549,
-0.0255893767,
0.0007887855,
-0.0443576872,
0.007194635,
0.0055177566,
-0.0063230651,
-0.0151730599,
0.0255837217,
-0.0041233366,
0.0441835374,
0.0238586832,
-0.0391106531,
-0.0547855422,
-0.0019620503,
0.0232706573,
-0.0201122928,
0.0461060591,
-0.0022713183,
0.0432385318,
-0.0078354301,
-0.0023242112,
-0.031067051,
0.0527128242,
0.0106537128,
0.1170598641,
-0.0142288283,
0.0172314197,
-0.0054252571,
-0.0127115725,
-0.0613877736,
0.0909541771,
0.0179047938,
0.0592346378,
0.0232101809,
0.0313097574,
0.0148338992,
0.002456683,
-0.0230667163,
0.00214236,
-0.0017672068,
0.0208287891,
0.0627680719,
0.0013877264,
-0.0366858393,
-0.0072823027,
-0.0802813396,
0.0338977873,
0.025859179,
0.0001585798,
0.008493715,
0.0195996687,
-0.0208349377,
-0.0254242439,
-0.0143015049,
0.0275225267,
0.0119212409,
-0.0074312207,
-0.0026118809,
0.0074774385,
-0.0348850712,
-0.0575255789,
-0.0393160284,
-0.0115026161,
0.060701374,
0.0186863672,
-0.0153342495,
-0.0058076112,
0.0737981573,
-0.0725746676,
-0.0005692402,
-0.0435831845,
-0.0115043269,
-0.0264049377,
-0.0554934479,
0.0126953041,
-0.0052040005,
0.0014913576,
0.0228864029,
0.0660211146,
-0.0409206823,
-0.0551823936,
0.0218278244,
-0.0351868607,
-0.0088966312,
-0.0292110164,
-0.0371062234,
-0.0000892564,
0.0158442389,
0.0262991786,
-0.0374119878,
-0.0395800583,
-0.0138982888,
0.0091832457,
0.0298674554,
-0.0554152466,
-0.0073494273,
0.0506681725,
0.0347340256,
-0.0103044817,
-0.0576516911,
0.0214492958,
-0.0095207682,
0.0530262701,
-0.0286055394,
-0.034800157,
-0.0104984939,
0.0974706039,
0.0247667097,
0.0266080052,
-0.0367544517,
0.0097724572,
-0.0238704886,
0.004299839,
0.0751791894,
-0.0429014526,
0.0527730174,
-0.0320385806,
0.0592990704,
0.0318436436,
0.0251748376,
-0.0241481364,
0.0084899496,
-0.053280659,
-0.0012144098,
0.0194212627,
-0.0070363027,
0.0107178027,
0.0072116037,
-0.0035346553,
-0.0226048399,
0.0134779261,
-0.0094241509,
0.0015519178,
0.0661689565,
0.06968382,
-0.0575658828,
0.0017973838,
0.0046458389,
0.0239157341,
0.0051006661,
0.0217139963,
-0.0052886009,
-0.0268812478,
-0.0392954201,
0.0172094833,
-0.0477032103,
-0.0361738093,
-0.0155025814,
-0.0267653354,
-0.0428544655,
0.0152818356,
0.1307085305,
0.0293671191,
-0.0539828688,
-0.0216420647,
-0.0191384219,
0.0235257354,
0.0318691656,
0.055743739,
-0.0609252974,
0.0032341641,
-0.0127891395,
-0.0013777368,
0.0342640653,
-0.0400233939,
-0.0027367703,
-0.0995736867,
0.0030086706,
0.0137957335,
-0.0122232605,
-0.0300459117,
-0.0829688385,
-0.0051387446,
-0.0310985986,
-0.0888641402,
0.0025712878,
-0.0468125828,
-0.0066175517,
-0.0073832883,
-0.0321253054,
-0.0196744446,
0.02968858,
-0.0412566401,
0.0529120415,
0.0303235333,
0.0538924485,
-0.023439547,
0.0011655398,
-0.0044939183,
0.0159225706,
-0.0143048121,
-0.0312809348,
-0.017324429,
0.019312771,
0.0055454848,
-0.01202334,
-0.0235620253,
-0.0328691602,
0.0023469953,
0.0041416609,
0.0790971592,
-0.0069202124,
-0.0210108198,
-0.0315284804,
-0.0194477402,
0.0039624274,
0.0554712191,
0.0010931606,
0.0310992263,
0.0106550809,
-0.0020476005,
0.0229109842,
0.0001794147,
-0.050573051,
0.0148441577,
-0.0623376183,
0.0550028384,
-0.0591757856,
0.0117990263,
0.0024328753,
0.0020142805,
-0.0176730696,
0.0379978754,
0.0432861075,
-0.0391071998,
-0.0962259695,
0.0153946849,
-0.0151227452,
0.0134856161,
0.0133625362,
-0.0306461919,
0.0501336157,
-0.0595262758,
-0.0456434749,
-0.0392634459,
-0.0423456505,
-0.0664160997,
-0.0596549399,
0.0080740349,
0.0123985149,
0.053547699,
-0.0082943533,
0.0059907278,
0.0335535407,
0.0189247578,
-0.0118209114,
-0.0225899909,
-0.0281549245,
0.0081131551,
-0.0071520461,
0.0434816703,
-0.0676792115,
0.0143417334,
0.0026460043,
0.0837325007,
-0.0406980067,
-0.0986674204,
0.0131912334,
0.0632660687,
-0.0067674392,
-0.0093707321,
-0.004177535,
-0.0864643753,
-0.0124560837,
-0.0149659272,
-0.0061827875,
-0.0372351333,
-0.0049676988,
0.0141417831,
-0.0382960737,
0.0075142891,
-0.0481315702,
0.0062598279,
0.0512375683,
-0.0155509375,
-0.0089814719,
-0.0216089431,
-0.0050455346,
0.0498672053,
-0.0076272576,
0.0079320092,
0.011048764,
0.0183735713,
0.0024630339,
-0.0388708301,
0.0361148119,
0.0086644599,
-0.0329487137,
-0.0176154859,
0.0107468907,
-0.0123155657,
-0.0537997708,
-0.0418551266,
-0.0010349759,
0.0771986917,
-0.0312935114,
0.0646481141,
-0.0535564572,
-0.0248584896,
-0.032599654,
0.0584811457,
-0.0193331167,
-0.029814668,
0.0296202153,
0.0308916233,
-0.0196955763,
0.0178066883,
0.0771421418,
0.0284128413,
0.0546299703,
0.0149660716,
-0.0733295903,
-0.0260055009,
-0.0269387644,
0.0511845239,
0.03141867,
-0.018803006,
0.0159473494,
-0.0442263,
-0.0889143869,
0.0030568265,
-0.0219656751,
-0.0487105846,
0.0205553845,
0.0513943285,
0.0521824434,
0.035063576,
0.0126038361,
-0.059385255,
0.019793639,
-0.0688519999,
-0.0199326687,
0.0012467389,
-6.277887007e-33,
-0.0293332655,
-0.0604368821,
0.0340282433,
0.016604187,
-0.0500184931,
0.0099380212,
-0.020235993,
-0.015324262,
-0.0488524176,
0.0323141441,
0.0240681004,
0.0089669889,
-0.0218249429,
-0.000911538,
0.0189278089,
0.0015422755,
-0.0114236502,
0.0441266224,
0.0496836789,
0.031880565,
0.0236576926,
0.040062245,
0.0277734771,
-0.0570035763,
0.0061539803,
-0.0236870218,
0.0205353796,
0.0298075806,
0.0108480221,
0.0546703823,
-0.027054606,
0.0405373909,
0.0197973866,
-0.0053744139,
0.0148969674,
-0.0321674086,
-0.0286443923,
-0.0378573723,
0.0182838775,
-0.0382934734,
0.0025654016,
0.0122774011,
0.0341919512,
0.0052962718,
0.0288211666,
-0.0302112233,
0.0807979032,
-0.0068455273,
-0.0633745492,
-0.0668540671,
-0.0341951661,
0.0449055992,
-0.0065650707,
-0.0178623348,
0.00928069,
-0.0252253003,
-0.0063754003,
0.0254128724,
-0.0282951854,
0.0231131427,
-0.0256813336,
0.0379519612,
0.0544032529,
0.0109431911,
0.0410496965,
0.0397730283,
-0.0341560319,
-0.0367448702,
-0.0195884667,
0.0311761219,
0.0342704803,
0.0516284145,
-0.0167535506,
0.0130076185,
-0.0348601304,
-0.0319282822,
-0.0808986276,
0.0022085737,
0.0050266958,
0.0232748967,
-0.0186670572,
0.0306263156,
0.0053199925,
-0.0440477729,
-0.0545389876,
-0.0046725478,
-0.0433804132,
-0.0437671021,
-0.0020276271,
-0.0276828762,
0.0208054371,
-0.0253957454,
-0.0147956004,
-0.0437382497,
-0.0048512318,
0.026467476,
0.000006907,
-0.0267213266,
-0.0073437933,
0.0315078683,
-0.0356648713,
-0.0292914528,
-0.0369954556,
-0.0363817289,
-0.0192338172,
0.0360178687,
-0.0227644462,
0.0153845046,
-0.0368227027,
-0.0021076386,
-0.0292990841,
-0.0500495546,
-0.0267935209,
-0.0088408608,
0.0019315516,
0.0383038409,
0.0198597219,
0.0621392727,
0.0610047132,
0.0419529639,
-0.0033931793,
0.0081551652,
0.0062540164,
0.0088640237,
-0.013541338,
0.0261739604,
-0.0399559811,
0.0492642894,
0.0279961545,
-0.0328352377,
-0.0230343547,
0.0048484877,
2.852e-7,
0.0679894239,
0.0511472002,
-0.0103758266,
0.0504602715,
-0.01240444,
0.0189500526,
-0.0119663738,
0.0241034199,
0.0147297531,
-0.0091706794,
0.0174837019,
0.019955432,
0.0142559819,
0.0471397042,
-0.0744129792,
0.0530537777,
-0.0685070083,
-0.0754347518,
-0.0396453291,
0.0003081646,
0.0269980729,
0.0302243289,
0.044677496,
0.0003913334,
-0.0386888012,
-0.0699481815,
0.054189682,
-0.0146615962,
-0.0094390605,
0.0364223346,
0.0343759395,
0.0172418691,
-0.0140276067,
0.0286615975,
-0.0310775451,
0.0406035818,
0.0098854862,
0.0056152446,
-0.0360026918,
0.0093118101,
0.0191048216,
-0.0525682531,
0.0175338667,
-0.0556883998,
0.047194697,
-0.027197225,
0.0304895379,
-0.0025902058,
-0.0314780958,
0.0130975218,
0.0063858791,
-0.0101955691,
-0.0168422852,
0.0355068967,
0.0259828847,
-0.0054531372,
0.0007349323,
-0.045941703,
-0.0059249122,
0.0377775356,
-0.0291518401,
-0.0165906567,
-0.0034121319,
-0.020736957,
0.0101698861,
-0.0205321461,
0.0541020855,
2.295829548e-34,
0.0269005671,
0.0081718378,
-0.032432355,
0.0305293426,
0.0337147936,
-0.0183437038,
-0.0802338198,
0.036381647,
-0.0057163537,
-0.1057616696,
-0.0000091923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13240v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13240v1 | On the Calibration of Large Language Models and Alignment | 2023-11-22T08:57:55 | 2023-11-22T08:57:55 | Chiwei Zhu, Benfeng Xu, Quan Wang, Yongdong Zhang, Zhendong Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models attract increasing attention and find widespread
application, concurrent challenges of reliability also arise at the same time.
Confidence calibration, an effective analysis method for gauging the
reliability of deep models, serves as a crucial tool for assessing and
improving their reliability. However, such investigation has been comparatively
underexplored. In this work, we conduct a systematic examination of the
calibration of aligned language models throughout the entire construction
process, including pretraining and alignment training. At each stage, we
investigate how different training settings, such as parameter scales and
training data, affect model calibration. To thoroughly assess model
calibration, we evaluate models on three most concerned aspects: generation,
factuality and understanding. Our work sheds light on whether popular LLMs are
well-calibrated and how the training process influences model calibration. | [
-0.0071224123,
0.0720082968,
0.012089802,
0.0455268212,
-0.0118570337,
0.0085830884,
0.0102050481,
-0.0288572423,
-0.0447208211,
-0.0113899019,
-0.0619327761,
-0.0912039354,
0.0425787605,
-0.0078624561,
0.0274937302,
-0.0015727363,
0.0329043418,
-0.0080374749,
-0.0210264288,
0.0002637119,
0.0019396686,
0.0000262625,
-0.0169825219,
0.0243951902,
-0.0360466279,
-0.0446358621,
0.0003960595,
0.0247973315,
0.0344389491,
-0.0000173659,
0.0264119077,
0.0559662506,
0.0164611228,
0.0896987319,
0.0000015412,
-0.0533931367,
-0.011300494,
-0.0010078161,
-0.0421449468,
0.0491223335,
0.0298214648,
-0.0185079053,
-0.0291945599,
0.0056746625,
-0.0245156698,
0.0160438064,
0.0864311978,
0.0144731542,
0.016743768,
0.0715327188,
0.0043481113,
-0.0326381661,
0.0605333894,
-0.0249238014,
-0.038960509,
-0.0349115394,
0.0136562875,
0.0331261232,
-0.0629581362,
-0.0051334617,
-0.0192227717,
0.0259131752,
0.0239803828,
-0.0099483952,
0.012109871,
0.0210158601,
-0.0530344807,
-0.0488154478,
-0.0151431561,
0.0562611781,
0.0030438462,
-0.0268795807,
-0.0394148305,
-0.0380089544,
-0.0085497443,
-0.0146935768,
-0.0067891409,
0.0319513343,
0.0486705787,
0.0471112393,
0.0195705798,
-0.0308586285,
0.0619441234,
-0.0075200135,
-0.0048126597,
0.0629653856,
0.0403596871,
-0.0383786373,
-0.0189361237,
0.0310019255,
-0.0021729539,
-0.0686335862,
-0.0232808888,
0.0129554598,
-0.0094994185,
0.0371882245,
-0.0667348653,
-0.0024436237,
0.0299718678,
-0.0423109792,
0.0384972394,
0.0418850631,
-0.0267988537,
0.0172216911,
-0.0213765372,
0.0861404017,
-0.025534397,
0.0215009935,
-0.0311579108,
0.0138555774,
0.0081785889,
0.0084196664,
0.0087835696,
-0.0373120569,
0.0131802429,
-0.0216420982,
-0.0754466057,
0.0192453191,
0.0319314487,
0.0419588536,
-0.0011358925,
0.0008168708,
-0.0417890362,
-0.0168406926,
-0.0120965606,
0.0480848551,
0.0050982423,
0.0351702124,
0.010875199,
-0.0818729401,
0.0050176312,
0.0343139283,
-0.0347286426,
-0.0405453369,
-0.0008574398,
0.0256360248,
-0.0046573617,
-0.0388918035,
-0.0126443254,
0.0113864839,
-0.0634340867,
-0.0810826942,
0.0049812347,
-0.0599054769,
0.0081853271,
0.0038567367,
0.008227393,
-0.0491597727,
0.019055387,
-0.0229991842,
-0.0196470395,
0.047241196,
-0.0194809772,
0.0225133505,
0.0009506205,
-0.025685003,
0.0289934371,
0.0692234114,
0.0755593553,
0.0052253711,
0.032433629,
-0.011265168,
-0.0039245198,
0.0547497012,
-0.0174308196,
0.0203809254,
-0.0310780816,
-0.0007135816,
0.027211979,
0.057904169,
0.0453260615,
0.0512279719,
0.0045795278,
0.007217675,
0.0806671008,
0.0226334855,
0.0416683666,
0.0156076895,
0.0093157003,
-0.0392913334,
0.0289857052,
0.0115290983,
-0.0709777549,
0.0037037409,
-0.0105745895,
0.033106368,
0.0321635418,
0.0448210053,
-0.0110765481,
-0.0329273567,
-0.069648914,
-0.0056943353,
-0.0151360035,
-0.0030959009,
0.0351602621,
-0.0504878126,
-0.0185042229,
0.0645504296,
0.0149726383,
-0.0332495347,
0.0105379233,
-0.0081736138,
0.0027732269,
0.0340531915,
-0.0049546203,
0.0095119774,
-0.0517332368,
0.014411266,
0.0133500434,
0.0544207431,
0.0811115131,
0.0143781491,
0.0231771134,
-0.0617832839,
-0.0319325142,
-0.0323182493,
0.0256607886,
0.0032441644,
0.0180105157,
0.0163094029,
0.0237046219,
-0.0498556308,
-0.0729207546,
0.0541178808,
-0.04970631,
-0.022995837,
-0.0293253064,
0.0164544582,
0.0179337114,
0.0090894001,
-0.0274281856,
0.0034258221,
0.0205864813,
0.0014452401,
0.0312761217,
0.0016041658,
-0.0193578415,
0.00901982,
0.0872099698,
-0.0186915472,
-0.0206520669,
0.0214454457,
-0.0231748074,
-0.0521552116,
-0.020304542,
-0.0227287356,
-0.0010211047,
-0.0375181772,
0.0713748112,
-0.0461447425,
0.0401538573,
-0.0603224821,
0.0216069892,
0.0039414344,
0.0281575918,
-0.0057959091,
-0.0073718396,
0.0426948518,
-0.0409683026,
-0.0446666107,
0.0052704141,
-0.0010806283,
0.0204377323,
0.0203162543,
0.0084154764,
-0.0479500778,
-0.0273459163,
-0.0637126938,
0.0294054467,
-0.0459861495,
0.0461842045,
0.0362400338,
-0.0267502647,
-0.014318157,
0.0113369478,
-0.0588747337,
0.0053510289,
0.006244448,
0.0102057597,
0.0551548637,
-0.0345448926,
-0.0394256003,
-0.069668524,
-0.0138832023,
-0.030179631,
0.0262137465,
0.0199002586,
0.0078547522,
-0.0696199089,
0.0518804081,
-0.0396647118,
0.0145968739,
0.0135412738,
-0.062428236,
0.0394896865,
0.0229575671,
-0.0005312593,
0.062511012,
0.001130815,
-0.003981506,
0.053907305,
0.0403038226,
-0.0370116271,
-0.0025747472,
-0.0223157834,
-0.0568168946,
-0.050392352,
-0.0404315069,
-0.0341664031,
0.0829187632,
-0.014834688,
0.0034212391,
-0.0409798063,
-0.0163867064,
-0.0082095861,
-0.0115167564,
0.0159315318,
0.0286946539,
-0.0358789675,
0.0497026965,
-0.0280069876,
-0.0878119916,
0.0551180132,
-0.069763869,
-0.0062992116,
-0.015541411,
-0.0179745983,
-0.0310141742,
0.029576024,
0.0138455853,
0.0200471748,
0.0105749387,
-0.0141223334,
-0.0778960884,
-0.0004044407,
0.033297278,
-0.038544137,
0.0511715785,
-0.0294942334,
0.0106488867,
-0.0326765999,
-0.025941167,
-0.0657919049,
-0.0198841393,
-0.0494993068,
0.0086924853,
0.0071234945,
-0.0361365862,
-0.0435082652,
0.0029826479,
0.0099020181,
-0.0032304826,
-0.0135956565,
0.0318922848,
-0.0238315333,
0.0196324047,
0.0570185483,
0.019881973,
0.0514080077,
-0.0594061203,
-0.0046601132,
0.0168419108,
-0.0058405977,
0.0801238194,
-0.0709888414,
-0.015181222,
0.0722666308,
-0.0124375978,
-0.0061089871,
0.0133329751,
0.0744568706,
-0.0246660057,
0.0044551115,
0.1119368747,
0.0116616553,
-0.0223272275,
-0.0012484947,
0.0015818897,
0.0298912637,
0.0137500772,
-0.0134581523,
-0.0671875104,
-0.0059328726,
0.000331618,
-0.0160556473,
0.032180313,
0.0096427472,
-0.0069957539,
-0.0907701775,
-0.0088471491,
0.0282535907,
-0.0357053839,
-0.0257199928,
-0.0370114222,
0.0317816064,
-0.0361806564,
0.0901094154,
0.0295486525,
0.0103110597,
-0.0157824289,
0.038043905,
-0.0516216196,
-0.0687460825,
-0.005764347,
-0.0884882212,
0.077343218,
0.0743749663,
0.0265523419,
-0.0297381915,
-0.0409967527,
0.0331739634,
0.0112928152,
-0.0180551205,
0.0608214848,
0.0367374793,
-0.0102760298,
-0.0227986872,
0.0337270983,
0.0136876609,
-0.0505886227,
0.0127459802,
-0.0286761504,
0.031680949,
-0.0024033985,
-0.0071877334,
-0.0076896017,
-0.0014681383,
-0.0068047098,
0.0738560408,
0.0134811215,
-0.0217223912,
-0.0097763529,
-0.0242514163,
0.0174833424,
-0.0101698292,
-0.0068658604,
0.0665685982,
-0.0141013926,
0.0024827365,
-0.0288899317,
-0.0253000129,
-0.0045130895,
0.0105443904,
0.0231413394,
-0.0269609969,
-0.0104303071,
-0.0239887349,
-0.0306022689,
0.0634007081,
-0.0162325911,
0.0380113535,
-0.0632046163,
0.0237383731,
0.0003824925,
0.000265369,
0.0160773452,
0.0116331941,
-0.115314275,
-0.0990668684,
-0.0007523112,
0.0180727579,
0.0231193956,
0.0381623842,
-0.0070976666,
-0.0473408066,
-0.0002924261,
0.0000393087,
0.0024590697,
0.0209106859,
0.013410667,
-0.0210751221,
-0.0125016738,
0.032910917,
-0.0449335165,
-0.0225251056,
0.051938653,
0.0469419621,
-0.0194742978,
-0.0794683471,
0.009177885,
0.0035234035,
0.0635112971,
-0.0575001016,
-0.0185696427,
-0.0192336217,
0.0140532358,
-0.0241397265,
-0.0058620451,
-0.0085660061,
-0.0096538579,
0.0626033023,
0.0146837411,
-0.0010742493,
0.015194918,
-0.0198266543,
0.0507424548,
-0.0409856327,
-0.0000267536,
-0.0027037538,
-0.0090825865,
0.0506126843,
0.0213268418,
-0.0404222906,
0.0357981399,
-0.0269915704,
0.0289863795,
0.0464594327,
0.0174833592,
0.0174690578,
0.0241714567,
-0.0208079796,
0.0042899759,
-0.0576218255,
-0.0265770536,
-0.0488011912,
-0.0028958875,
0.0768083632,
-0.0274293348,
0.0555153266,
-0.0284311809,
-0.0154034691,
-0.0308789816,
0.0273442976,
-0.0263597928,
0.0041373861,
0.0407913104,
0.0035928064,
-0.0337925479,
0.0140860993,
0.0256849099,
0.0266007427,
0.0241009686,
-0.0314117558,
-0.001365162,
0.0071068695,
-0.0126481159,
0.0195232332,
-0.0070704906,
-0.0406958908,
-0.0281326082,
-0.0207629427,
-0.071355857,
0.0442574881,
0.0388321951,
-0.0097200852,
0.0004164128,
0.0084025664,
0.0817850903,
-0.0556736141,
0.0214978997,
-0.0149979228,
-0.0250481535,
-0.0060748053,
-0.0022400969,
-0.0432148017,
-5.656347675e-33,
-0.0139446715,
0.0161826536,
0.0211981237,
-0.0238679443,
-0.0548899621,
0.0182397589,
-0.0155479917,
0.0342658609,
-0.0414608344,
0.0144271683,
0.0091103967,
0.0118928151,
0.0237380341,
0.0225102827,
-0.0066478993,
-0.0200903527,
0.0229812544,
-0.0067386925,
-0.0272744503,
-0.0568863153,
-0.0016878512,
0.0194684323,
0.1113610119,
-0.0541419834,
0.0307919346,
0.010060004,
-0.0203017723,
0.0273583904,
-0.0028559896,
0.0654351264,
-0.0194468964,
0.0235622879,
-0.0026509601,
-0.0218726248,
0.0002615826,
-0.0132651366,
-0.0177545995,
0.0009076654,
0.0356604271,
0.0447476208,
-0.029720949,
-0.0299785845,
0.0689806789,
-0.0285262484,
-0.0439318158,
-0.0283426531,
0.0306722727,
-0.0445959978,
-0.0202317443,
-0.0177281834,
-0.0556850396,
0.016560046,
-0.0093740262,
-0.0018526934,
0.004918112,
-0.0095332265,
0.0264689773,
0.0235468019,
-0.0602244996,
-0.0054607475,
0.0227502827,
0.0561265349,
0.1027245,
0.0689289868,
0.005849652,
0.077547498,
0.0147195049,
0.0017571641,
-0.0061642686,
-0.0084347446,
0.061999552,
0.0074433042,
0.0354284123,
0.0819092691,
0.0147102475,
0.0119425226,
-0.0877551138,
0.0082406541,
0.009162928,
0.0044658189,
0.0171283539,
0.0346901119,
-0.0491808876,
-0.0085392697,
-0.0510919727,
-0.0399437249,
-0.0348027311,
-0.0111226076,
0.0009472469,
-0.0049606916,
0.0142833972,
-0.0165451039,
0.0174695551,
-0.0424479023,
-0.0141684292,
0.0032161996,
-0.0186912492,
0.0097066201,
-0.0249841958,
0.0559007972,
-0.0400199182,
-0.0412953869,
-0.0267763846,
0.0276780222,
0.0285414476,
0.0100581683,
0.0441548526,
-0.0021498506,
-0.0424346365,
0.0167718418,
-0.0319806822,
-0.036481604,
0.0422336422,
0.0258917436,
0.0445107631,
-0.0285482537,
-0.0095889596,
0.0458802767,
0.0141329607,
0.0337040648,
-0.0126528498,
-0.0222028829,
0.0087521588,
0.0251944121,
-0.0261439662,
0.0077292826,
0.0044688103,
0.0089166816,
0.0479592681,
-0.0379400775,
-0.0182653833,
-0.0019252495,
2.164e-7,
0.0604547858,
0.0182522088,
0.0475791395,
0.0098047713,
0.0046414537,
0.0198993478,
-0.0352046154,
0.0239711776,
0.0043474631,
-0.0445864275,
0.0168939028,
0.0142155057,
0.0906631872,
0.0127219399,
-0.0558144525,
-0.0073754517,
-0.0696667135,
0.0256710071,
-0.0119483983,
0.0159046464,
-0.0102697648,
0.1178988516,
0.0082396036,
-0.0294566508,
-0.0122653693,
-0.0386317559,
0.0496759042,
-0.0466596298,
-0.0090940678,
0.0672567263,
0.0519866422,
0.0080157928,
-0.0081992708,
-0.0006429045,
-0.00325172,
0.0394839235,
0.0068894606,
0.0522940941,
-0.0014572472,
0.0014308674,
-0.0313176773,
-0.0154185509,
-0.0020641929,
-0.0710434318,
0.0389397368,
-0.0401164256,
-0.0150198983,
-0.066008091,
-0.0130265178,
-0.0063793547,
0.0732326657,
-0.0250338484,
0.009224291,
0.0355211236,
0.0307895467,
-0.0064106877,
-0.0433068015,
-0.0465789773,
-0.0611540452,
0.0202585068,
-0.0393245518,
-0.0615424663,
0.004660395,
-0.0338304788,
0.0274436735,
-0.0562897436,
0.0064571402,
1.824581094e-34,
0.0167338308,
-0.0199492648,
0.0209415685,
0.029830398,
0.0132341683,
-0.0263717584,
0.0120397396,
-0.0155980093,
0.0008810951,
-0.0749735013,
-0.0003675268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13230v1 | Enhancing Uncertainty-Based Hallucination Detection with Stronger Focus | 2023-11-22T08:39:17 | 2023-11-22T08:39:17 | Tianhang Zhang, Lin Qiu, Qipeng Guo, Cheng Deng, Yue Zhang, Zheng Zhang, Chenghu Zhou, Xinbing Wang, Luoyi Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have gained significant popularity for their
impressive performance across diverse fields. However, LLMs are prone to
hallucinate untruthful or nonsensical outputs that fail to meet user
expectations in many real-world applications. Existing works for detecting
hallucinations in LLMs either rely on external knowledge for reference
retrieval or require sampling multiple responses from the LLM for consistency
verification, making these methods costly and inefficient. In this paper, we
propose a novel reference-free, uncertainty-based method for detecting
hallucinations in LLMs. Our approach imitates human focus in factuality
checking from three aspects: 1) focus on the most informative and important
keywords in the given text; 2) focus on the unreliable tokens in historical
context which may lead to a cascade of hallucinations; and 3) focus on the
token properties such as token type and token frequency. Experimental results
on relevant datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method,
which achieves state-of-the-art performance across all the evaluation metrics
and eliminates the need for additional information. | [
0.043833483,
0.0528620146,
0.0007740133,
0.0496695526,
-0.0471766852,
0.0040976997,
-0.0432360545,
0.0240257271,
0.0035455022,
-0.0540258214,
0.0256004632,
-0.0669862628,
0.0104014222,
-0.0198176,
0.0101957349,
-0.0113036204,
0.0676049888,
-0.0502559245,
0.0373999551,
-0.0222711097,
0.0048393672,
0.0083266348,
0.0063821967,
0.0415812023,
-0.0566672571,
-0.0161446799,
0.0283468198,
0.0042630872,
-0.0046330085,
0.0003736887,
0.0001971769,
0.0650962219,
-0.0411495864,
0.1030020863,
0.0000020647,
-0.0539173856,
-0.0230914149,
-0.0084442999,
-0.0005877921,
0.0297145192,
0.0516497493,
0.034530241,
-0.0325820781,
0.0095906658,
-0.0147032747,
0.0064388271,
0.0277419519,
0.0783735216,
0.0485434234,
0.0615308061,
-0.0059945127,
-0.0104579646,
0.0249828491,
0.0371520109,
0.0378131568,
-0.0013165566,
0.0686394498,
0.0018938913,
-0.016397113,
-0.0193481427,
0.0183712617,
0.023772493,
-0.0293489136,
0.0013643698,
-0.0222097933,
-0.0014926784,
-0.1154071167,
-0.0224471763,
0.0219039749,
0.02588645,
-0.0617512092,
-0.0519301221,
0.0243758764,
0.0068520918,
0.0006718034,
0.0243703499,
-0.0043262029,
0.0251402464,
-0.0427741781,
0.0172664244,
0.0409168266,
-0.0124203674,
0.0481909104,
0.0287256781,
-0.0525457822,
0.1010452881,
0.0168787278,
-0.050598003,
0.00802135,
-0.0151395071,
-0.0181445424,
-0.0500110462,
0.0157501623,
0.0005435943,
-0.0634939075,
0.0025701202,
-0.0414063074,
0.0083057126,
0.0695576072,
-0.0997187272,
-0.0471419878,
-0.0074452385,
-0.0622855313,
0.0670342371,
-0.0219037589,
0.0320987105,
-0.004602131,
0.0343304202,
-0.0027408695,
-0.0174079519,
-0.0048856633,
0.00506128,
-0.0297038984,
0.0249127261,
0.0091726072,
-0.0236167964,
-0.0119047789,
0.0003959732,
-0.0338583663,
0.0388749167,
-0.0454580188,
0.0025505407,
0.0274939761,
-0.0242248122,
-0.0104699293,
0.0025970484,
-0.0022769941,
-0.0126407482,
-0.0283690207,
-0.0906349272,
-0.001978409,
0.0417621769,
-0.0281272735,
0.0046035852,
0.0029463419,
0.0110135712,
0.0411459245,
-0.0025837319,
-0.0521190725,
-0.0355837308,
-0.028145453,
-0.0434480496,
-0.0342762098,
-0.066515781,
-0.0338705517,
0.0002132985,
-0.0008408131,
-0.0404311344,
0.0286341701,
0.0281540658,
-0.0589155778,
0.0784731656,
-0.0537820049,
0.0122461375,
0.0315825865,
0.0154332928,
-0.0075387266,
0.0753533617,
0.0055478793,
0.0327383578,
0.0629579425,
0.0202730969,
0.0732371137,
0.0244883429,
-0.0099435374,
0.0225358289,
-0.0258106962,
-0.0217390582,
0.0188684519,
0.0032342093,
-0.0129043087,
0.0716879666,
0.0023507217,
-0.0224081483,
0.0498153567,
0.0151118068,
-0.0277917944,
-0.033282835,
0.01114373,
0.0183681101,
0.008912663,
0.0255509168,
-0.0642996877,
-0.0309359655,
-0.0243686717,
0.0054076859,
0.0821047872,
0.0006527486,
0.0153272655,
-0.033677265,
-0.0591239519,
0.001018927,
-0.0077870232,
-0.0154828578,
0.0349492878,
-0.0131662507,
-0.0530779213,
0.069694899,
0.0315349512,
-0.0142691685,
0.0019806311,
-0.0472287387,
0.009925562,
0.0760630742,
0.0736915693,
-0.0482928976,
0.0381581411,
-0.0407671258,
0.0489377379,
0.0537640862,
0.0237346999,
0.0155845685,
-0.0029134187,
-0.0487822667,
0.0200366564,
0.0385129228,
0.0638465211,
-0.0170521364,
0.0008809209,
0.009034209,
0.0015134666,
-0.0505042672,
-0.0564030632,
0.0347616896,
0.029720474,
-0.0032515882,
-0.0219213311,
-0.0282592662,
0.01980629,
0.0050234715,
-0.0202494282,
0.0413682126,
0.0038134675,
-0.031134773,
-0.0382372923,
0.000031206,
-0.0028845705,
0.0419233665,
0.0573061928,
-0.0009795048,
-0.0188242309,
-0.0134262471,
-0.0130344182,
-0.0250944123,
0.0114363926,
-0.0708059818,
0.0485417508,
-0.0476004332,
0.0624239407,
-0.0103579303,
0.0572158992,
-0.0093395263,
0.0902264044,
-0.0414707735,
0.0435759798,
0.0207402352,
-0.008048282,
0.0181992408,
0.0001251056,
-0.0450682305,
-0.0026574987,
-0.0056571085,
0.0335507691,
0.0095019368,
-0.0442926511,
-0.0326706469,
-0.0041662455,
-0.0557014011,
-0.0104531683,
-0.0351020657,
-0.0031228715,
-0.0073645469,
-0.018676972,
-0.0260441676,
-0.0015288607,
0.0158607457,
-0.0388238207,
-0.0003630603,
0.040732041,
0.0087952884,
-0.0174934547,
-0.0386451669,
-0.014610583,
0.0271946751,
-0.0121034486,
0.0493386276,
-0.0083207404,
-0.0512124151,
-0.0878930837,
0.0071766451,
-0.0367239416,
0.0235899147,
0.002046586,
-0.0087452866,
0.00500821,
-0.008200868,
0.0486618727,
0.0274484809,
0.0286849923,
-0.004124769,
0.0538354404,
-0.0407932252,
-0.0185830574,
-0.0321298279,
-0.0051021725,
0.0274971202,
0.0140956715,
-0.0565460809,
0.0173758436,
0.0122669386,
0.0355090015,
0.0034968732,
-0.0504225194,
0.0294545107,
-0.053146027,
-0.030436404,
0.012066476,
-0.0262276493,
-0.0431679189,
0.0394570641,
-0.0079494845,
-0.0252920762,
0.0687270537,
-0.054113239,
0.0305239111,
-0.0071052075,
0.0055109174,
0.0197431408,
-0.0065497323,
0.0052289483,
0.0059396746,
-0.0052987589,
-0.0332845189,
0.0001740172,
-0.0194489397,
0.0031114079,
-0.0706482604,
0.0389715247,
-0.0388070196,
0.0093342997,
0.0338825621,
0.0060170661,
-0.0630714595,
-0.0501463339,
-0.0301829521,
-0.0242065918,
-0.0065623764,
-0.0041756998,
-0.0444245748,
0.0285479371,
-0.0058224932,
0.0299020838,
-0.0100382343,
-0.0115485881,
0.0057842708,
-0.0070265895,
0.0516287871,
-0.026679853,
0.072226122,
-0.0073783258,
-0.0238809325,
0.075533472,
0.0417181291,
0.0270708464,
-0.0100404499,
-0.0609473437,
0.0121744135,
-0.0358842388,
-0.0142958602,
0.0008896843,
0.018200187,
-0.0454369597,
-0.0273192916,
0.1228501424,
0.0410321355,
-0.0369295664,
0.0013046821,
-0.0690560639,
0.0337287188,
0.0090369014,
-0.0241313055,
-0.0729582757,
-0.0167880431,
0.0171035938,
0.0142675154,
-0.0496168397,
-0.0253915675,
-0.0057487409,
-0.0818529427,
0.0267052688,
0.0119668953,
-0.0152375344,
-0.0391084552,
-0.0345489569,
0.0234071091,
0.0071137464,
0.0322821252,
-0.003526354,
0.0304778144,
-0.0290884227,
0.0052405335,
-0.0740177333,
-0.0380111784,
0.0204798337,
-0.0394419134,
0.0804675892,
0.0507058799,
0.0229923818,
-0.0133897541,
-0.0718023479,
0.0268452577,
-0.0285816323,
-0.0418687016,
0.0025618831,
0.0342410989,
0.0156541262,
0.0019540037,
-0.0044703577,
0.0032274765,
-0.0294356458,
-0.0147542795,
0.0063826079,
0.0671224594,
-0.035363242,
-0.024807144,
-0.0162064228,
0.032918565,
0.037046276,
0.0914616734,
-0.0107669998,
-0.0134085156,
-0.0365385413,
-0.0394738354,
0.0377834849,
-0.0128223691,
-0.0421577767,
0.0429211482,
0.0355869308,
-0.0487343222,
-0.083832182,
0.001408147,
-0.0164611731,
0.0045254705,
-0.0099907294,
0.0695773065,
0.0078156423,
-0.0119061656,
-0.0271987896,
0.0133356601,
-0.0376715325,
0.0318357386,
-0.0526107252,
0.0450351126,
0.0130938245,
0.0151568893,
-0.001628945,
0.0538826995,
-0.0680931956,
-0.0596234687,
0.0553853028,
0.0024515102,
0.0234454703,
0.0320812315,
-0.0634245351,
-0.0415524133,
0.0461617522,
0.0565436743,
-0.0117418021,
-0.0000422362,
0.0177185908,
0.0013409007,
0.0127341431,
0.0312154293,
-0.0272204354,
-0.0222281367,
-0.0258336589,
0.0170570705,
-0.0323097631,
-0.0062550134,
0.0263889693,
0.0288807098,
0.02853157,
-0.0326527134,
0.0141759701,
-0.0009660988,
-0.0054522464,
-0.0162374191,
-0.0372334458,
0.0136564132,
0.0264146905,
0.006437507,
-0.0386993177,
-0.012736382,
-0.0368133485,
-0.0470027886,
0.0080407355,
-0.0083722286,
-0.0412087478,
-0.006290907,
0.0333903208,
0.0536621399,
-0.0575738847,
-0.017846521,
0.0288762953,
-0.0012768661,
0.0401747786,
-0.003004513,
0.032864105,
0.0053352122,
-0.0438551903,
0.0086168274,
0.0004022177,
-0.0221797805,
-0.0438313335,
-0.0374339186,
0.0233573988,
0.0434475467,
-0.0014226977,
0.0690228865,
-0.0331686027,
0.0081794439,
-0.0222375207,
-0.0030758604,
0.0697290227,
-0.0136648072,
-0.0227686223,
0.029515624,
-0.0449374057,
0.0405025855,
0.0665335804,
-0.0142749762,
0.0290085468,
-0.0002567365,
-0.0659567267,
-0.0220898781,
-0.0500957891,
-0.0820359737,
0.026577156,
-0.0471046269,
-0.0146485968,
-0.084310092,
-0.0515303351,
0.00932902,
0.0095898956,
0.0056275432,
0.0154374894,
-0.0167633221,
0.0825586468,
0.0016842452,
-0.0115542933,
-0.0371596999,
-0.0015455156,
0.0652454942,
-0.0155928535,
6.949e-7,
-6.45466299e-33,
0.0238468945,
-0.0620718449,
-0.0357970558,
-0.0597798154,
0.0055397693,
-0.0100070508,
0.0023996888,
0.0082174828,
0.005600268,
0.0265456624,
0.0163409133,
0.0265261792,
0.0290434696,
0.0013695911,
0.0076441043,
-0.0184604712,
0.0350468904,
0.0385250971,
-0.021810675,
0.0077598169,
0.0684266612,
-0.0122465231,
0.0410826765,
-0.0802986622,
0.0632757097,
-0.037558075,
-0.0388948135,
0.0353226997,
0.0057019754,
0.0344781466,
-0.0288328175,
0.0621639937,
0.0055920477,
-0.0399665162,
-0.0126056438,
-0.0351115279,
-0.0167497713,
-0.0061539905,
0.0309118554,
0.0402329937,
0.030402977,
-0.0081169363,
0.0557781272,
-0.0108296536,
0.0075017656,
0.035657201,
0.0318561979,
-0.0443816669,
-0.0292923618,
0.0269744806,
-0.0441536494,
0.0422376879,
0.0238957889,
0.0144189009,
-0.0016018935,
0.0337751098,
0.0009210434,
-0.0233292505,
-0.0887528732,
0.0232875217,
-0.0235512443,
0.0088718664,
0.035823077,
-0.0195608716,
-0.0145085119,
0.0701526031,
0.0106013753,
-0.0070073903,
-0.0317879729,
-0.0185962319,
0.022939574,
0.0302623957,
0.0377743319,
0.0477155186,
0.0282227956,
-0.0184668321,
-0.0279260315,
0.0021913238,
-0.0095025599,
0.0268384796,
0.0832839087,
-0.0109729953,
-0.0796029642,
-0.0338929109,
0.0131095434,
0.0291486662,
-0.0414402112,
-0.0058769402,
0.0264894944,
-0.0118306549,
-0.0418024026,
0.0038238869,
0.0284897741,
-0.039176777,
-0.0268617608,
0.0342153758,
-0.0217781086,
-0.0132238604,
-0.0102718621,
0.0254582688,
0.0298719686,
-0.0045510079,
0.0224503987,
-0.0112354001,
0.0128636574,
0.0138081973,
0.0035182158,
-0.0209507048,
-0.0813213736,
0.0191825908,
-0.0083254809,
0.0338954106,
-0.018987244,
-0.0312914699,
0.0531416647,
-0.0142397657,
-0.0148418592,
0.0114064598,
0.0445182621,
0.0312758274,
0.013134581,
0.0175955929,
-0.0276739318,
0.0144661171,
-0.0394272134,
-0.0078205252,
-0.015408122,
-0.0075929067,
0.0178425927,
-0.0549405627,
-0.0065093776,
-0.0098487251,
2.754e-7,
0.0090175224,
0.0739237145,
0.012842902,
0.0231580455,
0.0048685228,
0.0303345248,
0.0154002216,
-0.0123447534,
-0.0085637439,
-0.0395766571,
-0.0345843174,
-0.0030217036,
0.044632934,
0.0668697879,
-0.0972857177,
-0.0380643569,
-0.0562856793,
0.001661037,
-0.0715569928,
-0.026662387,
0.0378633104,
0.0816453919,
0.050486844,
-0.0269562863,
-0.0076141022,
-0.0887462869,
0.0125981532,
-0.0009963656,
-0.0319194347,
0.0457716659,
0.0672314167,
0.0193254109,
0.0386269391,
0.0457957014,
-0.0086446665,
-0.0346607789,
0.0234915726,
0.0129355704,
0.0011463762,
-0.0323659442,
-0.0279151052,
-0.0433158614,
0.0213714223,
-0.0683823079,
0.0645844117,
0.0302499123,
-0.0031188375,
-0.024970917,
-0.0416760594,
-0.0132550411,
0.0540960282,
-0.0031224946,
-0.0511362478,
0.0359463021,
0.0143347457,
0.0595742427,
-0.0254852474,
-0.0474800318,
-0.0141590824,
-0.0055668605,
-0.0306381229,
-0.0312537737,
0.0221501999,
0.0000711185,
-0.0140857315,
-0.0703387484,
0.0323600918,
2.795078529e-34,
0.0630060881,
0.0138162421,
-0.0014392715,
0.0300983544,
0.0479763448,
0.0281411652,
0.0246098321,
0.0210452918,
-0.0114219524,
-0.0304601379,
0.013467175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03716v1 | Co-guiding for Multi-intent Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-11-22T08:06:22 | 2023-11-22T08:06:22 | Bowen Xing, Ivor W. Tsang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent graph-based models for multi-intent SLU have obtained promising
results through modeling the guidance from the prediction of intents to the
decoding of slot filling. However, existing methods (1) only model the
unidirectional guidance from intent to slot, while there are bidirectional
inter-correlations between intent and slot; (2) adopt homogeneous graphs to
model the interactions between the slot semantics nodes and intent label nodes,
which limit the performance. In this paper, we propose a novel model termed
Co-guiding Net, which implements a two-stage framework achieving the mutual
guidances between the two tasks. In the first stage, the initial estimated
labels of both tasks are produced, and then they are leveraged in the second
stage to model the mutual guidances. Specifically, we propose two heterogeneous
graph attention networks working on the proposed two heterogeneous semantics
label graphs, which effectively represent the relations among the semantics
nodes and label nodes. Besides, we further propose Co-guiding-SCL Net, which
exploits the single-task and dual-task semantics contrastive relations. For the
first stage, we propose single-task supervised contrastive learning, and for
the second stage, we propose co-guiding supervised contrastive learning, which
considers the two tasks' mutual guidances in the contrastive learning
procedure. Experiment results on multi-intent SLU show that our model
outperforms existing models by a large margin, obtaining a relative improvement
of 21.3% over the previous best model on MixATIS dataset in overall accuracy.
We also evaluate our model on the zero-shot cross-lingual scenario and the
results show that our model can relatively improve the state-of-the-art model
by 33.5% on average in terms of overall accuracy for the total 9 languages. | [
0.0175729692,
-0.0296815895,
0.003195955,
0.0439375192,
-0.0357511826,
-0.000382903,
0.0129544483,
-0.0566938631,
0.0278126318,
-0.0488984697,
-0.0573778711,
-0.0440106094,
0.0078953924,
0.0480813943,
0.0259038042,
-0.0276873428,
0.0596504807,
-0.0399562083,
0.0294867456,
0.0096926428,
0.0030009991,
0.0364397988,
-0.0238062497,
0.0376478061,
-0.0061248406,
-0.0470661931,
-0.0234652981,
0.0474368148,
-0.023750728,
-0.041238185,
0.0083509833,
0.0391117781,
0.0517948344,
0.0160618629,
0.0000023827,
-0.0367616676,
-0.033110857,
-0.0293188076,
-0.0637231767,
-0.0231705308,
-0.0138881179,
-0.021751564,
0.02388178,
0.0145722097,
-0.0038394283,
-0.0006003019,
0.0276043806,
0.0159306861,
0.0265641492,
0.0345346145,
-0.004745136,
-0.0560811646,
0.0058614146,
-0.0354197957,
-0.0013602455,
-0.078212969,
0.0036267454,
0.0341812782,
-0.0253832377,
0.0102717783,
-0.0551300757,
0.0631315485,
0.0223987978,
-0.0050692284,
0.023870822,
0.0267239325,
0.0304742325,
-0.0319739841,
-0.0381271988,
0.0953718796,
-0.0121246409,
-0.0101939244,
-0.0108047184,
-0.047826115,
-0.0147326682,
-0.0282782484,
-0.0275676399,
-0.0050164782,
-0.0268321242,
-0.0091454769,
0.0401234142,
-0.0059428443,
0.0251798723,
-0.0022765922,
-0.019703852,
0.0422733128,
-0.0159857292,
-0.0066499021,
0.0256793667,
-0.0130360164,
-0.0166190062,
-0.0432637148,
0.0129335467,
0.0241703764,
-0.0690279976,
0.0415283218,
-0.0240902044,
-0.0528963245,
0.0097527113,
-0.0302873179,
0.0246556085,
0.0542797744,
-0.0564351417,
0.0660197958,
0.0068360679,
0.0195110682,
0.0015588227,
0.0302079134,
-0.0750692263,
-0.0168253686,
-0.0376071744,
-0.0001038973,
-0.0622803085,
0.0412631184,
-0.0099167246,
-0.0191389974,
-0.0370839126,
0.0162017234,
-0.0069258465,
0.0269698836,
0.0530753657,
0.0050391117,
-0.0435132198,
-0.0153238438,
0.0318677984,
0.0790919513,
-0.0167580824,
0.0423932038,
-0.0194824729,
-0.0416272357,
-0.0243223216,
0.0478849113,
0.0094294343,
-0.0419326238,
-0.008973279,
0.0466861352,
-0.0143959364,
-0.0188800711,
-0.055591777,
-0.0361687168,
-0.042998381,
-0.0510749854,
-0.0317353122,
-0.0549547821,
0.046835456,
0.0086771036,
0.0065861517,
-0.0214516185,
-0.0013716067,
-0.0306936763,
-0.0340544805,
0.0723562464,
0.0161814578,
0.013671496,
-0.0020626832,
-0.0008872332,
-0.0581091456,
0.0593851879,
0.0039131953,
0.0100078098,
0.0147311008,
-0.0073064445,
-0.0557762235,
0.0182674956,
0.0305748377,
-0.0048530172,
0.0456501655,
-0.0019497985,
0.0315152407,
0.0186467208,
0.0461835265,
0.0439289175,
-0.0449386314,
-0.0480324998,
0.0386884287,
0.0212350897,
0.0585673787,
-0.0215336196,
0.0886808634,
0.0513882041,
-0.0454459451,
0.0397121087,
-0.0448580272,
0.0220357478,
-0.010333796,
0.0199904479,
0.0071708253,
-0.0201768875,
-0.0438572168,
-0.0371863656,
0.0224972479,
-0.0442049913,
0.0282942355,
-0.0005321061,
0.0762724653,
-0.0005095413,
-0.0758328587,
0.0334330276,
0.024691185,
0.006047708,
0.0128108552,
-0.0301622488,
-0.0029687253,
0.0549423732,
-0.0177635513,
-0.0085095055,
-0.0823512524,
-0.0372318327,
-0.0320969336,
-0.013906342,
0.0229311027,
-0.0144415265,
0.0414569676,
-0.0576644167,
0.0001967941,
-0.029114686,
-0.01158089,
0.072606273,
-0.0708868504,
-0.0113557344,
-0.0150280669,
-0.0280574579,
0.0347617045,
-0.0093906727,
0.0179054365,
0.0201466586,
-0.005255626,
0.0156059377,
0.0243577659,
0.0703925192,
0.0126110325,
0.0153148072,
0.0002143623,
0.0016825736,
0.0247453246,
0.0096709114,
-0.0678340569,
-0.0711748004,
0.020416785,
-0.0154895354,
-0.0485141724,
0.0050858017,
-0.0074538449,
-0.0825515166,
0.0553796105,
-0.007654178,
0.0251839235,
-0.0343212932,
-0.0096902158,
0.0569146313,
0.0083386153,
0.0080275927,
0.0618418232,
0.0062208218,
0.0168559756,
0.0805402473,
0.0065991143,
0.0364902653,
-0.0738942474,
0.0086799311,
0.0125159826,
-0.0375690497,
-0.0246138312,
-0.0178183429,
0.0083647892,
-0.0537350774,
0.0239055976,
-0.0727162436,
-0.0082157161,
-0.0419762544,
0.0092149777,
0.0124358749,
0.0094118258,
0.0119386157,
-0.0375989974,
-0.0017607471,
0.0160696581,
-0.0095830681,
-0.016066594,
-0.0342451334,
0.019583486,
0.0016982852,
-0.0279729646,
-0.0001293888,
-0.0308268908,
0.0148858968,
0.0043024044,
-0.0856866762,
-0.0368589461,
0.0364409126,
-0.0061145783,
0.0264689699,
-0.0196478087,
-0.0088521382,
-0.0126338489,
-0.0022258146,
-0.0195864439,
0.0437602066,
-0.02104632,
0.0105653834,
0.0280983057,
-0.0517207831,
-0.0614223368,
0.040232759,
-0.0033156339,
0.0245068446,
-0.0285285488,
0.0053759776,
-0.0029717572,
0.0784795061,
0.0521011092,
0.0200225674,
-0.0488693416,
-0.0916328654,
-0.0314218774,
-0.0359152369,
-0.0317425281,
0.0001981661,
-0.0264361855,
-0.0217637215,
-0.0308710448,
-0.0024460871,
0.0935538858,
-0.0107547678,
-0.0611584857,
-0.0323005505,
-0.0145778218,
-0.0363997705,
0.0502556078,
-0.0126385596,
0.0331927016,
0.0346172638,
-0.0771294311,
-0.0304922722,
-0.0147045581,
0.0283933003,
-0.0043821246,
0.0620323531,
-0.0171697885,
0.0220429432,
-0.0347713083,
-0.0151252644,
-0.0162404794,
-0.0262927618,
-0.0391882397,
0.0392803773,
0.0312689655,
0.0067586768,
0.0179893598,
0.0122029195,
0.0107715055,
0.0319822356,
0.0095456392,
0.0149301933,
-0.0192801952,
0.0257137343,
0.011950979,
0.0171861593,
-0.0536918268,
-0.0210261773,
0.0505672283,
0.0152902724,
0.0206842348,
-0.0349638388,
-0.0104809208,
0.0295026023,
0.0556654558,
-0.0036448517,
-0.0476103537,
0.0251783691,
0.0752698258,
-0.0423857123,
0.0260995571,
0.1048304513,
0.0209966358,
-0.0643386543,
-0.020109253,
-0.0407868288,
-0.0065769423,
0.0178242531,
-0.0069298679,
-0.1000375897,
-0.0797632709,
-0.0067950143,
0.0242158547,
0.05429345,
-0.0211682878,
-0.0346875638,
-0.0682116598,
0.0221649092,
0.0190725364,
-0.0514856689,
-0.0139072752,
-0.0227761287,
0.0211912282,
0.0036590951,
0.0059137666,
-0.0160436332,
0.0296115503,
-0.0331824049,
0.0399285294,
-0.0030076294,
-0.0056853523,
0.0359114669,
-0.0109419348,
0.0701053813,
-0.0190668199,
0.0428407602,
0.0124795819,
-0.0005609059,
0.0173363499,
-0.0480432883,
0.0059330976,
-0.0422287434,
-0.0035821791,
-0.0407061167,
0.0065865968,
0.0253566597,
0.0294879247,
-0.0445328727,
-0.038247481,
-0.0259634573,
0.0721480623,
-0.0305710416,
-0.0086704027,
0.0160656441,
0.0211353898,
0.0675861835,
0.0723214373,
0.0463953875,
-0.0172405019,
-0.0053011118,
-0.0261277314,
0.0198702049,
-0.0679068938,
-0.0009491854,
0.0286005251,
0.0012071879,
-0.0145093342,
0.0087053683,
-0.0467234254,
0.0279559512,
-0.0120706894,
0.005302852,
0.0550412573,
0.0659735277,
-0.0205385815,
-0.0051205414,
0.0155897159,
-0.0262976773,
0.0578460507,
-0.0547734648,
-0.0522777848,
0.0246241949,
-0.0566856228,
-0.0268190261,
0.0334027037,
-0.056367971,
-0.0509855971,
0.0008126963,
-0.0000424321,
0.0132902274,
0.0696735829,
-0.064602837,
-0.0040226886,
-0.041282177,
-0.0172819048,
-0.0224169716,
-0.0064702611,
0.0629237145,
0.0314958617,
-0.0126962233,
0.0360154621,
-0.044844918,
0.0285562575,
-0.0037592002,
0.0255793296,
-0.0791029781,
-0.0663811937,
0.014839164,
0.0088406736,
0.0591435507,
0.010634155,
0.0406004488,
-0.0703222454,
0.0295047425,
0.049208153,
-0.005732289,
-0.0301935803,
0.0044339374,
0.0256895032,
-0.0567983761,
-0.0123376576,
-0.0075608985,
0.0065047881,
-0.0361799449,
-0.0096235229,
0.03999874,
0.0514345244,
-0.0254057068,
-0.0113166086,
-0.0144773135,
-0.029858375,
0.0101473192,
0.0302534644,
0.0296476968,
0.0049082362,
0.0779205784,
0.011465406,
-0.0138362078,
0.0222900808,
0.0109196026,
-0.0097943209,
-0.0383317918,
0.0128859179,
-0.0367513821,
0.0584145151,
-0.0040966338,
0.0333244391,
0.0109085459,
0.0372398496,
-0.0311892238,
0.0850574672,
-0.0029877834,
-0.0312502235,
0.0657224059,
0.0086210128,
0.0164127387,
0.0363539495,
0.0677904412,
-0.0446947478,
0.0274897534,
-0.0006258317,
0.0080403686,
-0.0398478061,
-0.0423108861,
-0.005748312,
0.056515526,
-0.0520081557,
0.0218715221,
-0.049168475,
-0.0589212067,
0.004127054,
-0.0027458102,
0.016795285,
0.0194994714,
0.0518865697,
0.0217623487,
-0.0034655237,
-0.0191389639,
-0.0358306058,
-0.0186685976,
0.0081413044,
0.0179223344,
-0.0027530196,
-6.736346702e-33,
-0.0347142555,
-0.0229059737,
0.0074492479,
-0.0137200812,
-0.0126365647,
0.0191718638,
-0.0522641577,
0.0057406472,
-0.0504800491,
-0.0176364146,
0.024568595,
0.0293290578,
0.020334065,
-0.0012689966,
0.0077141402,
-0.0397248343,
0.0268142484,
0.0119979251,
0.0004731262,
0.0226038061,
0.0348607041,
0.0328637287,
0.0673764497,
-0.0537404642,
0.037848305,
0.0142966257,
0.0136022298,
0.0338928774,
0.0023138341,
0.0512494668,
0.0198852252,
0.0479150042,
0.0220922045,
-0.0484024808,
-0.0288513731,
0.0560637973,
-0.0754885077,
-0.0490067527,
0.0533706322,
0.0299039427,
-0.0575543903,
0.001124792,
0.0134644005,
0.037809398,
0.0439989083,
-0.0191260576,
0.0269027799,
0.0411825068,
-0.0216978099,
0.0165463388,
-0.038773343,
0.0318815336,
-0.0459290482,
-0.0327575728,
0.0299213901,
0.0652436912,
0.0060903532,
-0.0046181674,
-0.0786918923,
0.0208573025,
-0.0974316373,
-0.0041620652,
0.0580279455,
0.0455973856,
-0.0382890292,
0.0288841203,
-0.0106292162,
-0.0250018816,
0.0155066391,
-0.0285928808,
-0.0049175867,
0.0361658446,
-0.0162458885,
-0.0212926138,
0.000159179,
-0.006765462,
-0.0590975881,
-0.0144150164,
0.0344347768,
0.0555781536,
0.0144718913,
0.0449652933,
-0.0269281454,
-0.0190477073,
-0.047646109,
-0.0322500579,
-0.0456444882,
-0.0151353199,
0.0277865846,
-0.0071895081,
0.0022212181,
0.0336026512,
0.0759077072,
-0.006680198,
0.0101990039,
0.0425237045,
0.0210560504,
0.0364214517,
-0.0083618574,
0.0745950118,
-0.0907683745,
-0.0344803222,
0.0201775655,
0.0122932931,
0.0212418232,
0.02485268,
0.0244318061,
0.0135323163,
0.0024118093,
-0.009488849,
-0.0541229248,
-0.0357796699,
-0.0468976237,
-0.0112532834,
0.0829776376,
0.0328027047,
-0.0321925841,
0.0736864656,
0.0125859603,
0.0281609967,
-0.0187598132,
-0.0607936792,
-0.0076130149,
0.0438381173,
-0.031658724,
0.0042818198,
0.0027965845,
0.0071489667,
0.0247188285,
-0.0189964753,
-0.025173191,
0.0471060872,
3.103e-7,
0.0518104583,
0.0002482527,
-0.0007942139,
0.0548339598,
0.0090403054,
0.0559073724,
-0.0290735103,
0.0264878348,
0.0076535274,
-0.0517805293,
0.0236727912,
0.0388336033,
-0.0223649405,
-0.0085170362,
-0.0864528567,
0.0235380661,
-0.0084800925,
0.0320601761,
-0.0202506185,
0.0249066427,
0.0738048106,
0.0685156733,
-0.0098317284,
0.0171606094,
0.0135864783,
-0.0041771624,
0.0234979019,
-0.0015781705,
0.0066225799,
-0.0091324821,
0.0214598477,
0.0057037077,
-0.0396343544,
0.0609415695,
-0.0129239149,
0.0184300542,
0.0380440205,
0.0177535377,
-0.0259240419,
-0.0529996455,
-0.0218804795,
-0.0016236228,
-0.0116329826,
-0.0220771171,
0.0707939789,
-0.0345092528,
-0.0424905308,
0.00673712,
-0.0152839376,
0.0423319191,
-0.0159580745,
0.0269525331,
0.0001146875,
0.0048998776,
0.0036597617,
-0.022869708,
-0.0314410664,
-0.0565893315,
-0.0064489855,
0.0312869251,
-0.0201490093,
-0.0151108941,
-0.0176967978,
-0.0208365973,
0.0367751569,
-0.0686056763,
-0.0227444414,
2.503050375e-34,
0.0282551348,
-0.0196830556,
0.0253797881,
0.0176281277,
-0.0001896506,
-0.0405641682,
-0.0915138423,
0.0207626801,
0.0411409922,
-0.051197838,
-0.0423596762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13184v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13184v3 | Large Language Model-Enhanced Algorithm Selection: Towards Comprehensive Algorithm Representation | 2023-11-22T06:23:18 | 2024-05-16T02:54:25 | Xingyu Wu, Yan Zhong, Jibin Wu, Bingbing Jiang, Kay Chen Tan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Algorithm selection, a critical process of automated machine learning, aims
to identify the most suitable algorithm for solving a specific problem prior to
execution. Mainstream algorithm selection techniques heavily rely on problem
features, while the role of algorithm features remains largely unexplored. Due
to the intrinsic complexity of algorithms, effective methods for universally
extracting algorithm information are lacking. This paper takes a significant
step towards bridging this gap by introducing Large Language Models (LLMs) into
algorithm selection for the first time. By comprehending the code text, LLM not
only captures the structural and semantic aspects of the algorithm, but also
demonstrates contextual awareness and library function understanding. The
high-dimensional algorithm representation extracted by LLM, after undergoing a
feature selection module, is combined with the problem representation and
passed to the similarity calculation module. The selected algorithm is
determined by the matching degree between a given problem and different
algorithms. Extensive experiments validate the performance superiority of the
proposed model and the efficacy of each key module. Furthermore, we present a
theoretical upper bound on model complexity, showcasing the influence of
algorithm representation and feature selection modules. This provides valuable
theoretical guidance for the practical implementation of our method. | [
-0.0026643178,
0.0404896587,
-0.0437490642,
0.0477878824,
-0.0370786563,
0.0187571906,
-0.0064358255,
0.0200993679,
0.0299072769,
-0.0599839799,
0.0063674003,
0.0467882082,
0.0013250684,
0.0331576727,
-0.0010726976,
0.0022530621,
0.0027051137,
-0.053091269,
-0.0494010299,
0.006063757,
-0.0302417669,
0.0309499428,
0.0672512352,
0.04210243,
0.0486255065,
-0.0135363853,
0.0028915519,
-0.0235732999,
-0.0161846783,
-0.0152618317,
-0.0481509715,
0.0089683868,
0.0169179253,
0.0005866574,
0.000002446,
-0.0281363204,
-0.0461514294,
0.0225927122,
0.0026192679,
0.0381559767,
0.0415418372,
0.0209336746,
0.002186978,
-0.0146709681,
0.006007839,
0.0301102065,
0.0793713257,
0.0045956792,
0.053849604,
0.0224748086,
0.0029569166,
-0.0358135439,
-0.0115972757,
0.0594087653,
-0.0031740591,
-0.0394436084,
0.0264020711,
0.0432282463,
0.0427652411,
-0.0031652469,
-0.0124969436,
-0.001190176,
-0.0104872417,
-0.0042311754,
0.031328395,
0.0091553656,
-0.0223389026,
0.0122422017,
0.0163105503,
0.0519172996,
-0.0506473631,
-0.0566609837,
0.033253856,
-0.0152736902,
-0.0405875221,
0.0133279236,
-0.0396479331,
0.0082268147,
-0.0039689695,
0.0226979647,
0.0422700122,
-0.0055999509,
0.0311088655,
0.0223428737,
-0.0540148877,
0.05324772,
-0.0073837112,
-0.0012179936,
0.0356495976,
-0.0645737499,
-0.0344008319,
-0.0291532744,
0.0221415162,
0.0150453346,
-0.0421746671,
0.0051121023,
-0.012894704,
-0.0431534126,
-0.0073672622,
-0.0518994257,
0.0322256647,
0.0227669217,
0.0011090757,
0.0396870784,
-0.0496809185,
0.0704570785,
-0.0258921031,
-0.0299021211,
-0.0152329216,
0.0271469522,
-0.0470090769,
-0.0116368849,
-0.0031075308,
0.0759488493,
0.01605637,
0.0068800845,
-0.0273214541,
0.0336846933,
-0.0189477894,
0.0352836475,
-0.0283692088,
-0.0325625353,
0.0482111685,
0.0110430233,
0.0029858951,
-0.028688712,
-0.0189225245,
-0.0363413431,
-0.0664447695,
0.0136926202,
0.0249920841,
0.0376069881,
-0.0294067878,
-0.0205787756,
0.0328753404,
0.0857767239,
0.0236498024,
0.002574231,
-0.0172872785,
-0.014182061,
0.0187430624,
-0.0166481789,
-0.0127743445,
-0.0869261324,
-0.0409067646,
0.0073968903,
0.0252088234,
-0.0034746749,
-0.0112748239,
-0.0123104667,
-0.0184251014,
0.0649434999,
-0.0310943704,
0.0303303022,
0.0120852701,
0.0179767571,
0.0018142581,
0.0275697261,
0.0055866381,
0.02412856,
0.0279896576,
-0.0482720844,
0.0225961059,
0.0308483336,
-0.0559504852,
-0.0276326146,
-0.0077245431,
0.0290688276,
0.0591830052,
-0.0101555157,
-0.0124822473,
-0.0104159005,
-0.018435847,
-0.0387422666,
-0.0071280096,
0.0578557141,
0.0235306602,
0.0632307157,
0.0184942596,
0.0704626963,
0.0104562258,
-0.0316150635,
-0.0047598043,
0.0363151021,
-0.0530560575,
-0.0083820038,
-0.0092295539,
0.0580527671,
-0.0112751871,
-0.0166762453,
-0.0185922701,
-0.0114059597,
-0.034535829,
-0.0078222491,
0.0561701171,
-0.0224245023,
-0.0307013709,
0.0168265533,
0.0325715877,
0.0083053093,
-0.0552727915,
-0.0467467606,
0.0266128071,
0.0209007934,
0.0546424538,
-0.0840011314,
0.0486591905,
0.009838569,
-0.0054873428,
-0.0691633001,
-0.0021569142,
-0.0104581853,
-0.0231543481,
-0.0585142337,
-0.0435315035,
0.0091613028,
-0.0119080562,
0.0319810808,
-0.013027858,
-0.0158555508,
0.0313756913,
-0.0086383689,
-0.0950912461,
0.02921452,
-0.0017430456,
-0.0181708504,
0.0370426327,
-0.0011498943,
0.0696582273,
-0.016632311,
-0.0231801718,
0.0178968739,
0.0180396847,
-0.0472353958,
-0.0141547415,
-0.0316953249,
-0.0291354302,
0.0312510096,
-0.0021358305,
-0.0485467687,
0.0048313425,
0.0168362707,
-0.0309453886,
0.0129959155,
0.0486358888,
-0.0509384274,
0.0027601661,
0.0044264868,
0.0474121086,
-0.067887269,
-0.0358868539,
-0.0601235367,
0.0623906292,
0.0366164632,
-0.0078381225,
0.0346668623,
0.0205956474,
0.028226031,
0.0420202203,
-0.0477315262,
0.0552173145,
-0.0040021776,
0.0322651193,
0.0312979706,
0.0184507761,
0.0127585577,
-0.0162502807,
-0.0934763029,
0.0085649583,
0.0204479285,
-0.0003566235,
-0.0021985243,
0.001833385,
0.0136748673,
-0.0132788392,
0.0030259006,
0.011585542,
-0.0618296973,
-0.003788352,
-0.0029677434,
-0.0247980319,
-0.097617276,
-0.0218788311,
-0.0377022177,
-0.0084978519,
0.0967882127,
-0.0014459589,
-0.0268407688,
-0.0523907617,
0.1026916876,
-0.0032598495,
-0.0171595067,
-0.0607612208,
-0.0021858723,
-0.0251865163,
-0.0365050435,
-0.0539028086,
0.0483376309,
-0.016948713,
0.0098494897,
0.084812589,
0.0256790053,
-0.0585311837,
-0.0115607334,
0.0152254039,
0.0054182955,
-0.0096380208,
-0.0024069983,
0.0489170328,
0.0183325447,
-0.0181683619,
0.0027513886,
0.002122873,
-0.0039090905,
0.0197786037,
0.0429783799,
-0.0528175645,
-0.0313673727,
-0.0064746421,
0.0577284992,
0.0291045867,
-0.0922222808,
0.057232216,
-0.0134351943,
-0.0081683621,
-0.0569229424,
-0.0233932063,
-0.0430794805,
0.0583702736,
-0.0157633498,
0.0276454724,
-0.0310521126,
-0.0112252533,
0.00518507,
-0.0112043088,
0.0208755303,
-0.0392305739,
0.0440329574,
-0.0423323996,
0.0193546582,
0.0415519699,
-0.0113732517,
-0.0221435055,
-0.0040923171,
-0.0396709405,
0.012726821,
-0.0018385027,
-0.0149849039,
-0.0143465679,
0.0313792378,
0.0272057932,
0.0045267511,
0.0358714052,
-0.0200825687,
-0.005696286,
-0.0424252301,
0.0081510199,
-0.0388916209,
0.0412464365,
0.0259152297,
0.0772946328,
-0.0052800262,
0.0406680927,
0.0159188211,
-0.0745316222,
0.0314100608,
0.0274024401,
-0.0581150614,
-0.0585388318,
0.0843117163,
-0.0101326173,
-0.0560673587,
0.033407554,
0.0668786615,
0.0410927385,
-0.0607221201,
-0.0002868022,
-0.0265578963,
0.0204802491,
0.0393583179,
0.0491459034,
-0.0541266091,
-0.0224174596,
0.0222381949,
-0.0026699444,
-0.0505138189,
-0.000558449,
0.027849732,
-0.0927859545,
0.0435830392,
0.0232675076,
-0.0255125239,
-0.0583191849,
-0.081121996,
-0.0130887087,
-0.0280342866,
-0.0402003527,
0.0007659858,
-0.0227443743,
-0.0219513476,
-0.0359499343,
-0.0582066774,
-0.0024091739,
0.0653109252,
0.0007109422,
-0.0251189936,
0.084936142,
0.0348051861,
0.0033803803,
0.0187754501,
0.0285446066,
0.0126040289,
0.0179743245,
-0.0515383184,
0.0123125454,
0.0271916371,
-0.0179256145,
-0.0112041663,
0.0231101103,
-0.0300912336,
-0.001878119,
0.0328602754,
0.0919812769,
-0.028969815,
-0.0229960717,
0.0040721605,
-0.0122293243,
-0.015249799,
0.0521319956,
0.0324756652,
-0.0106568113,
-0.0396652296,
-0.0365003571,
-0.0475191958,
0.0151985325,
-0.0694398656,
-0.0221371427,
-0.0076733315,
0.0354313999,
0.0086082667,
0.0698687732,
0.0332178548,
0.0107361479,
0.0336602964,
0.0390797295,
0.0427518636,
-0.0104779126,
-0.0405191556,
0.0159400217,
-0.000873733,
0.0396037996,
-0.0132753933,
0.001097996,
0.032170292,
-0.0252876543,
-0.0556838363,
0.0214674324,
-0.0354865566,
-0.0105224485,
-0.0307721477,
0.0467665754,
0.0140123703,
0.00240708,
-0.0338395126,
-0.0458065942,
0.0281516518,
0.0133933406,
-0.0106011936,
-0.0058761849,
-0.0131653175,
-0.0330121033,
0.0130818095,
-0.0070274533,
-0.0308616031,
0.0121882372,
0.061035905,
-0.0487315021,
-0.0064456188,
-0.0013620163,
0.0229323767,
0.0752896443,
-0.0160678532,
0.0064712777,
-0.0519708879,
-0.00402943,
-0.0073531726,
0.029260762,
-0.04039279,
-0.0524773225,
0.0416708924,
-0.0204368308,
-0.0140986005,
0.0475950949,
-0.0019713147,
0.0094812755,
-0.0050180424,
0.0095381727,
0.0652127936,
-0.0269139074,
0.0611168854,
0.0600502566,
-0.0232777521,
-0.0051239538,
-0.0173731484,
0.0409254655,
0.0190801639,
-0.0108072637,
0.0487903059,
0.0003042143,
0.022617219,
-0.0409497768,
0.010715452,
-0.0086806528,
-0.0779081509,
-0.0222516507,
0.0206409171,
0.0361514054,
-0.029298164,
0.0217553731,
-0.0085517205,
0.009457035,
-0.0541267917,
0.0545788556,
0.004396141,
0.0193338152,
0.008632767,
0.0326111205,
-0.0522126965,
-0.025553951,
0.0603789315,
-0.0161508936,
0.0028402219,
0.0065147248,
-0.0429587401,
-0.015159077,
-0.0140233617,
0.0483346246,
0.0253216028,
-0.0547042005,
-0.0234314706,
-0.0502277426,
-0.0163019113,
-0.0098195001,
-0.0594236106,
0.0111195855,
-0.0021244849,
0.0517118163,
0.1025123149,
0.0214999281,
0.0150685124,
-0.028188752,
-0.02336758,
-0.017530445,
-0.0200528987,
-0.0332165658,
-5.833011619e-33,
-0.0008591068,
-0.0453696847,
-0.0225754678,
0.0052653556,
0.0016083294,
-0.0052386797,
-0.0329359509,
0.0090863025,
0.0273602232,
-0.0299856868,
0.0504166931,
-0.0350635499,
-0.0231446195,
-0.0468863472,
0.0279919524,
0.0305912327,
0.0023628648,
0.012377142,
-0.0279894583,
0.0124308681,
-0.0006880274,
-0.0071773226,
-0.0190319903,
-0.0909961984,
-0.042715732,
0.0132122124,
0.0423071496,
-0.0438857675,
0.010460061,
0.0780467018,
-0.0131030381,
0.001389591,
-0.0104687959,
-0.0756232142,
-0.0259868931,
-0.0216909889,
0.0366295241,
-0.0164385512,
0.0359486565,
-0.0065298481,
0.0625673681,
-0.0703282729,
0.0336714163,
0.0309316982,
-0.0311501417,
-0.0232311711,
0.0357919894,
-0.0302325971,
-0.0340213366,
-0.0135078048,
-0.0649540499,
0.0451016054,
-0.0505528115,
0.0277418159,
0.0568885505,
0.0272886753,
-0.0465555117,
0.0511624962,
0.0517008603,
0.027681144,
0.0241760742,
0.0240526292,
0.0656356737,
0.0190212391,
0.0411445163,
0.0499162041,
0.0179518331,
-0.0475040041,
-0.0286567546,
0.019117184,
0.0098289968,
0.0598578379,
0.0057503581,
-0.0043615294,
0.0297206212,
0.0468892902,
-0.0789480731,
0.0043244772,
-0.0413873494,
0.0153891128,
0.0625559241,
0.0205690954,
-0.044874981,
-0.0214754753,
-0.0452304035,
-0.0029920589,
-0.0486634187,
-0.0126120206,
0.0281962212,
-0.01918233,
-0.0357487649,
0.0410341397,
0.0016442835,
-0.0382368602,
0.0094603691,
0.0108186938,
-0.0410483629,
0.0067303395,
0.0185874049,
-0.002638485,
-0.0044259387,
-0.0698999092,
-0.010391999,
-0.0769294798,
0.083543621,
-0.0147612458,
-0.0119728269,
-0.0041640657,
-0.0343254805,
-0.0142493229,
-0.0161795244,
-0.1026247516,
-0.0106440168,
0.0513630286,
-0.0024357266,
0.0180142988,
0.0168746226,
0.0210967883,
-0.0180183407,
-0.0212012324,
-0.0113788275,
-0.0095207803,
0.0156852417,
0.008430155,
-0.0162247941,
-0.0273735896,
-0.039713189,
-0.0109789269,
0.024890298,
0.0262392666,
-0.0586887486,
0.0080162352,
3.132e-7,
-0.0024017491,
0.0352545939,
-0.0471256897,
-0.0048187082,
0.0038934476,
0.0461476408,
-0.0017697054,
0.0008710349,
0.0085988445,
0.0067712544,
0.0209790319,
0.0155692892,
0.0925886557,
0.0023461634,
-0.0335437059,
0.0465580411,
-0.0048851604,
-0.0224657301,
-0.0810224786,
-0.0072321123,
0.0341579095,
0.104788892,
-0.0017858975,
0.0127684427,
0.0066208867,
-0.0374626704,
-0.0019028481,
-0.0546382405,
0.0163967106,
0.0160051566,
-0.0395363197,
-0.0089580882,
-0.0310314,
0.0223556031,
0.0020973387,
0.0080899652,
0.0381416827,
0.0689806864,
0.0165746287,
0.0650258362,
0.049256321,
0.0000608198,
0.0128683802,
-0.0523187257,
0.0630259365,
0.0040744361,
-0.05335778,
-0.0538730323,
0.0115558682,
-0.0383391604,
-0.0079804305,
-0.0295011774,
0.0592151619,
0.0366044641,
-0.0097511727,
-0.0565969348,
-0.0044027837,
-0.0334693603,
-0.0160791911,
0.0302776154,
-0.0510766767,
-0.0213081036,
-0.0656432956,
0.0038625055,
0.0686779991,
-0.0144601762,
0.101475656,
3.22900584e-34,
0.0157498401,
-0.0138639435,
0.0001615027,
0.0626154393,
0.0305834971,
0.0027759823,
-0.017119512,
0.0355797857,
-0.0070114029,
-0.0488585271,
0.0310232732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13171v1 | ComPEFT: Compression for Communicating Parameter Efficient Updates via Sparsification and Quantization | 2023-11-22T05:28:59 | 2023-11-22T05:28:59 | Prateek Yadav, Leshem Choshen, Colin Raffel, Mohit Bansal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) techniques make it possible to
efficiently adapt a language model to create "expert" models that specialize to
new tasks or domains. Recent techniques in model merging and compositional
generalization leverage these expert models by dynamically composing modules to
improve zero/few-shot generalization. Despite the efficiency of PEFT methods,
the size of expert models can make it onerous to retrieve expert models per
query over high-latency networks like the Internet or serve multiple experts on
a single GPU. To address these issues, we present ComPEFT, a novel method for
compressing fine-tuning residuals (task vectors) of PEFT based models. ComPEFT
employs sparsification and ternary quantization to reduce the size of the PEFT
module without performing any additional retraining while preserving or
enhancing model performance. In extensive evaluation across T5, T0, and
LLaMA-based models with 200M - 65B parameters, ComPEFT achieves compression
ratios of 8x - 50x. In particular, we show that ComPEFT improves with scale -
stronger models exhibit higher compressibility and better performance. For
example, we show that ComPEFT applied to LLaMA outperforms QLoRA by 4.16% on
MMLU with a storage size reduction of up to 26x. In addition, we show that the
compressed experts produced by ComPEFT maintain few-shot compositional
generalization capabilities, facilitate efficient communication and
computation, and exhibit enhanced performance when merged. Lastly, we provide
an analysis of different method components, compare it with other PEFT methods,
and test ComPEFT's efficacy for compressing the residual of full-finetuning.
Our code is available at https://github.com/prateeky2806/compeft. | [
0.0113008674,
0.0900482535,
0.0017899113,
-0.0007354836,
0.0078375973,
0.0116819646,
0.0088966666,
-0.0034205769,
-0.0644279793,
-0.0432545133,
-0.0223102402,
-0.0226154849,
0.0041883872,
0.0378702059,
0.0403795727,
-0.0654843822,
0.0269128457,
-0.0316754878,
0.0124078384,
-0.0257559214,
-0.0172688793,
-0.0103136608,
0.0438883118,
0.0150933452,
0.0353728645,
0.0136079779,
-0.0568645634,
0.0162947383,
0.0088281361,
0.0386824459,
0.0011010827,
0.0791511014,
0.048634991,
0.0268855803,
0.0000024899,
0.0015715999,
-0.0279570911,
0.0132073369,
-0.0144636389,
0.043704465,
0.0461382754,
-0.0045869122,
-0.0220606122,
0.0030906415,
-0.0312137213,
-0.0127169862,
0.0849478096,
0.0101497853,
0.0826363042,
0.0513661914,
0.0064937277,
-0.0334036388,
0.0222426597,
-0.0340267867,
-0.011379079,
-0.0548677593,
0.0218340065,
0.0044965795,
-0.0089205448,
-0.0050890693,
-0.0231147539,
0.0075117596,
0.0142568899,
-0.0068781329,
0.0049954201,
0.0035625182,
-0.0117283994,
-0.0299256593,
0.0049301563,
0.0347475074,
-0.095212929,
-0.0403468423,
0.0072147772,
0.0217300393,
-0.0248126034,
-0.0351238623,
-0.0616966337,
0.0019593562,
0.0126100769,
-0.0059702094,
0.0037261925,
-0.0509686396,
0.0245695356,
0.014834513,
-0.0731996372,
0.0193917081,
0.037340913,
0.0242468435,
-0.0513748229,
-0.0585286543,
-0.0423523933,
-0.0665313154,
-0.0011103766,
0.0219735634,
-0.0497880541,
-0.0175887737,
-0.0815987363,
-0.0401622131,
0.0003678016,
-0.0032422575,
0.0679645687,
0.0668609142,
0.0213706978,
0.0262106732,
-0.0301833693,
0.0447731875,
-0.0326320566,
0.0071438858,
-0.0586291812,
-0.0207355302,
-0.0585181601,
-0.0057157981,
-0.053801097,
0.0352085568,
-0.0217318255,
-0.0100950152,
-0.0409743898,
0.0172876194,
-0.0194204822,
0.0092189908,
0.0066333599,
0.0150453467,
-0.0469670743,
-0.0065844515,
-0.0000982681,
0.0304936413,
-0.0427908413,
0.0002013972,
0.0217634533,
-0.0516841225,
0.0075878752,
-0.012570342,
-0.0103845848,
-0.0112984814,
0.0326010026,
0.0284093525,
-0.0264561884,
-0.0086311465,
0.0111297714,
-0.033754915,
0.0417520218,
-0.0766249299,
-0.0157433636,
-0.0698542893,
0.0699020326,
-0.0348629504,
0.001972141,
-0.0569878966,
-0.0138131194,
-0.0012100411,
-0.0427628234,
0.0628774762,
-0.0424696729,
0.0183680244,
0.0412684418,
0.0034818936,
0.0186671801,
0.1053758189,
0.0245762747,
0.0251996368,
-0.0056604003,
-0.0146724852,
-0.0177781936,
-0.0021006202,
0.0122416895,
0.0288074445,
-0.0571542904,
0.0014982439,
0.0106590912,
0.035025645,
0.0450475924,
0.0259646811,
-0.0546946265,
-0.0504895076,
0.0416270904,
0.0241625514,
0.0459797122,
0.040208213,
0.0394053012,
0.0088037364,
0.0224378016,
-0.0225103181,
-0.0428589657,
0.0408713929,
-0.0190484431,
0.0055551543,
0.0469160043,
0.0731883645,
-0.049464833,
-0.0308833346,
-0.0037264158,
-0.0019160551,
-0.013380453,
-0.0099992063,
0.0380500257,
-0.0130797746,
-0.0280522704,
0.0599003732,
0.0271411575,
-0.0350456685,
-0.0374146625,
-0.044087287,
-0.0170144066,
0.0709763393,
0.0165589005,
0.0042482917,
-0.075912565,
0.025100546,
-0.0112732742,
-0.0123594701,
0.0328012854,
0.0001430998,
0.0061407234,
-0.0581315011,
-0.0403166376,
-0.0035732919,
0.0183669813,
0.0437642485,
0.0320103057,
-0.0169026125,
0.0127676884,
-0.0331954807,
-0.0191159062,
0.0040393425,
-0.003292473,
-0.0201156158,
0.0139153963,
-0.0071945265,
0.0190096684,
-0.0069690072,
-0.0082036806,
-0.0079981536,
0.0328207687,
-0.001908017,
-0.0087317973,
-0.0308076628,
-0.0205130968,
0.0188952573,
0.0427784212,
0.0029980983,
0.0555071235,
0.0259080399,
-0.0711804703,
-0.0551990718,
0.0120566906,
-0.0127598224,
0.0231895614,
-0.0287880786,
0.0235039983,
-0.0090515837,
0.0088443244,
-0.0134801501,
0.021733053,
-0.021213742,
-0.0349476151,
0.0158530474,
0.0161154345,
0.0196690653,
-0.0546840094,
-0.0131753907,
0.0317365825,
0.0110502904,
0.0163298715,
-0.0099075269,
0.0055070361,
0.0023871649,
-0.0250598881,
-0.1155732498,
0.0286229849,
-0.0278582051,
0.0141972695,
0.0363053456,
0.0173675064,
0.0065210601,
0.0127755525,
-0.0103531014,
0.0238586012,
-0.0256323256,
0.0401299149,
-0.0004176768,
0.0316899419,
-0.0420700461,
-0.0407367572,
-0.0521256737,
0.0072832247,
0.068683818,
-0.0443033352,
-0.0556965992,
-0.0435643457,
0.0025845803,
-0.0638225377,
0.059873268,
-0.0155403325,
-0.063867569,
-0.0204381216,
-0.0440289453,
-0.0075264452,
0.0587334521,
-0.0145131266,
0.0053161248,
0.0660576671,
0.0103126001,
-0.0212218184,
0.0325808711,
-0.0228353012,
-0.0634742975,
0.0010965461,
0.0136230625,
-0.0265340395,
0.070371896,
-0.0561474822,
-0.0261980537,
-0.0750838369,
0.0129723698,
0.0207596347,
-0.0435057059,
-0.0261205658,
0.0156137533,
0.0136746094,
0.0462949723,
-0.0145277632,
-0.0634772778,
0.0462282188,
-0.0170403384,
0.0188781284,
-0.0024193707,
-0.0382122286,
-0.0138879586,
0.0119831292,
0.0293984432,
0.0539861061,
0.0052728374,
0.0010266714,
-0.0473900251,
-0.0043319915,
0.0140313832,
-0.030202562,
-0.0018689833,
-0.0315899104,
0.0161199216,
-0.0307998303,
-0.0298365895,
0.0105588613,
0.0545983799,
-0.0117872199,
0.0640186667,
0.0349589512,
-0.0578760095,
-0.0202443246,
0.0482604243,
-0.0309810378,
0.04915509,
-0.0343343504,
-0.0036359504,
-0.0282128826,
-0.0259839911,
0.0301926713,
0.0460269749,
0.0052464078,
-0.01514195,
-0.0067504016,
0.0513076857,
0.0360487141,
-0.0255416092,
-0.0658479556,
0.0194914695,
0.0290586762,
-0.0245384686,
-0.0366466157,
0.0312416889,
0.0075647905,
-0.0854064897,
0.021101417,
0.0599466562,
0.0204810984,
-0.0282085333,
0.0023464691,
0.0180736799,
0.0421576835,
0.0270852894,
0.0591130815,
-0.0875687227,
-0.0234050583,
0.0359490588,
-0.0169598497,
0.0063357227,
0.003282133,
-0.019170478,
-0.0909805968,
0.0481219143,
0.0311415214,
-0.0024157919,
-0.0146031426,
-0.0252807382,
0.0100183208,
-0.0132479407,
-0.0119959554,
0.04354278,
0.0075642481,
0.000371921,
0.0116058495,
0.0231386311,
-0.06220847,
-0.0031467336,
-0.0109935505,
0.0311247949,
0.0227353889,
-0.0031075177,
0.025305666,
-0.0175279044,
0.0010617161,
0.0444067977,
0.0134564154,
-0.0356110893,
0.013992195,
0.0060548619,
-0.0083504086,
0.0617215447,
-0.0034572554,
0.0147655578,
-0.0162240341,
-0.0432847366,
0.080155395,
-0.0234712493,
0.0092632612,
-0.014005078,
-0.0328493118,
-0.0414380282,
0.03228046,
-0.0031063624,
0.0082505448,
-0.0289204847,
-0.0234043729,
-0.0678303391,
0.0128181707,
-0.0170720387,
-0.0049962327,
-0.0180834085,
-0.0740787908,
-0.0224289838,
0.0051355031,
0.0324919187,
0.0551904663,
-0.018855283,
0.0135348337,
-0.0141461417,
0.0045843809,
-0.0912200734,
-0.0061854692,
-0.0321243554,
-0.012741101,
-0.0621309578,
-0.012586507,
0.0122608664,
-0.0134120472,
-0.0273856893,
-0.0207832232,
-0.124670811,
-0.0640450343,
-0.0092427153,
0.0635813549,
0.026082987,
0.0271063987,
-0.0031392174,
-0.08235614,
0.0463152044,
0.0771900043,
-0.0540668741,
0.0531942956,
0.0402084328,
-0.0499642529,
-0.0010744586,
0.0237469226,
-0.0611736551,
-0.0024165194,
-0.0197874773,
0.010862492,
-0.0159063824,
-0.0335448869,
0.0062580039,
0.0176529549,
0.0226016976,
0.0043148538,
-0.0339602083,
0.0018717692,
0.0596554726,
-0.0195699185,
0.0061336905,
-0.0489915162,
0.0170652643,
-0.010676723,
0.0345046818,
0.04667449,
0.0120014641,
0.061016798,
-0.0048931581,
0.0002542458,
-0.0299627818,
-0.0453652106,
-0.038799908,
0.0423562154,
0.0028415916,
0.0048474092,
-0.0006322417,
0.0093397936,
0.0212475155,
-0.0541121326,
0.0019866172,
0.0152969286,
0.0402254313,
-0.0620924532,
0.0473127067,
-0.0260504633,
-0.1227810904,
-0.059328448,
0.0317380056,
0.0829305798,
0.0320659615,
0.0268931389,
-0.0216636211,
-0.0188062098,
-0.0269529726,
0.005655312,
0.0277092885,
0.024356192,
0.0578043796,
0.021488253,
0.0073327012,
0.0013281632,
0.0642947182,
0.0146165453,
0.0607546344,
-0.0188969988,
0.003874867,
-0.0214273706,
-0.0182539579,
0.0004872195,
0.0200724211,
0.0017601802,
-0.0460648164,
0.0029453582,
-0.0105767846,
0.0028160219,
0.0017024589,
-0.0348833613,
0.0020091261,
0.0663246289,
0.0733600184,
-0.000146761,
-0.0077012149,
-0.0235235207,
-0.0495877527,
0.0244767088,
-0.0147728259,
0.0468771681,
-7.546490061e-33,
-0.0309823304,
0.0147203943,
0.0456951819,
-0.0478054248,
-0.0097539509,
-0.0185594372,
0.0040013166,
-0.0111508379,
0.0018671108,
0.0038036131,
-0.0203301888,
0.0065362821,
0.01324155,
-0.0200557765,
0.0096335141,
0.0128458068,
0.0748916119,
0.0015742987,
0.0066705686,
0.0163948927,
0.0104597434,
0.0375968069,
0.0520376712,
-0.0373998843,
-0.057578627,
0.0279406291,
-0.0174677707,
0.0261957906,
0.0096746106,
0.0531597324,
0.0007392361,
0.0114491135,
-0.0234449655,
-0.0319593698,
-0.0411820412,
-0.041351229,
-0.0462134406,
-0.0289723277,
0.0339622423,
-0.011137154,
-0.0186553728,
-0.0680702627,
0.0495213047,
0.0411728397,
0.0143492641,
-0.0506863445,
0.0041519101,
-0.0276246835,
-0.0258108266,
-0.0734065399,
-0.0347684175,
0.0172987878,
0.0274654031,
0.0164554808,
0.0687914416,
-0.0049239076,
-0.0184199605,
0.013684595,
-0.024209246,
0.0151558174,
0.077885434,
0.0883034989,
0.0634322092,
0.0015147646,
0.016204726,
0.0001572623,
0.0103173973,
-0.0142317088,
0.0082282843,
0.0402884744,
0.0421854258,
0.0726414993,
0.0237075407,
0.0239105597,
0.0702347904,
0.0094748335,
-0.0447183587,
0.0052961288,
-0.0022114287,
0.0537647791,
0.0078182071,
0.0665328279,
-0.0099482816,
-0.0255039502,
-0.0491539426,
0.0016720818,
-0.0455806106,
-0.042066399,
0.0236043092,
0.0302104522,
-0.0122453608,
-0.0148297288,
0.0416136011,
-0.0420482755,
0.0222565811,
0.0010871919,
-0.0468144715,
0.0223823097,
0.0289711747,
0.0203118548,
-0.0121874893,
-0.0547679923,
0.0311358254,
-0.0178322084,
0.0158859435,
-0.0109055247,
-0.0014704713,
0.075294368,
-0.0624242909,
0.0083756903,
-0.0271275099,
-0.0165970605,
0.0272263736,
0.0485034958,
0.0352625772,
0.0047619762,
0.0150838429,
0.0295401067,
-0.0167020652,
-0.0097473571,
-0.0217587147,
0.0244403873,
0.0250284448,
0.0341558792,
-0.0056187855,
0.0257959254,
-0.0570770763,
-0.0100176269,
0.0648985654,
-0.0372206494,
-0.0506305099,
0.0437547937,
3.243e-7,
0.0158772096,
0.0691028014,
0.0003064277,
-0.0047686226,
0.0023581106,
0.0232323874,
0.0054984326,
0.0243786741,
0.0130671449,
-0.0037184246,
0.0378054865,
0.0618693791,
0.0105806654,
0.0286260489,
-0.0558360554,
0.0016401893,
-0.0378364548,
-0.0087564765,
-0.0508101918,
-0.0536168143,
0.0027683547,
0.1384166479,
0.0231504403,
-0.0066686771,
0.0686765686,
0.0074079446,
0.035300158,
-0.022114804,
-0.0013282067,
0.0519952253,
0.038328357,
0.0327997729,
-0.0254538618,
-0.0006371023,
-0.0099963499,
-0.0046741953,
-0.0206190869,
0.1126876324,
-0.036709521,
0.027823424,
0.0417784527,
-0.0297079887,
-0.009430279,
-0.0409624763,
0.0485886261,
-0.0164430048,
-0.0092061628,
-0.0462694839,
-0.0079998691,
-0.0152737685,
0.0061889486,
-0.0215814058,
0.0419455804,
0.0394065194,
0.009914659,
0.0087619592,
-0.0230594389,
-0.0814522207,
-0.0220684372,
0.0370845981,
-0.035528101,
-0.0335287824,
-0.0590849966,
-0.0529303625,
0.0532288551,
-0.0288354214,
-0.0105139464,
3.501881701e-34,
0.040814057,
0.0005034573,
0.037569128,
0.0287614223,
0.0041017691,
-0.0219708271,
-0.0481525958,
0.018758608,
-0.0002649061,
-0.0598626174,
-0.0317865163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13133v1 | LIMIT: Less Is More for Instruction Tuning Across Evaluation Paradigms | 2023-11-22T03:37:01 | 2023-11-22T03:37:01 | Aditi Jha, Sam Havens, Jeremy Dohmann, Alex Trott, Jacob Portes | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models are traditionally finetuned on large instruction
datasets. However recent studies suggest that small, high-quality datasets can
suffice for general purpose instruction following. This lack of consensus
surrounding finetuning best practices is in part due to rapidly diverging
approaches to LLM evaluation. In this study, we ask whether a small amount of
diverse finetuning samples can improve performance on both traditional
perplexity-based NLP benchmarks, and on open-ended, model-based evaluation. We
finetune open-source MPT-7B and MPT-30B models on instruction finetuning
datasets of various sizes ranging from 1k to 60k samples. We find that subsets
of 1k-6k instruction finetuning samples are sufficient to achieve good
performance on both (1) traditional NLP benchmarks and (2) model-based
evaluation. Finally, we show that mixing textbook-style and open-ended QA
finetuning datasets optimizes performance on both evaluation paradigms. | [
0.0147255715,
0.0238990933,
-0.0126033993,
0.0130807348,
-0.0355298184,
0.0276690461,
-0.0108700637,
-0.0096132513,
-0.0293758269,
-0.0563972183,
-0.0409927815,
-0.0008381935,
-0.0056083342,
-0.0470887385,
0.032874126,
-0.0497144423,
0.0676554069,
-0.0480277687,
-0.0563268326,
0.0194929373,
0.008079553,
0.0153281055,
-0.0247785244,
0.0303742625,
0.0631346926,
-0.026210513,
-0.0255543776,
0.0188079737,
0.0160261951,
-0.0498771742,
-0.0011471555,
0.0489691831,
-0.0093204519,
-0.0112829832,
0.0000019659,
-0.0379243344,
-0.0065140193,
0.0194454901,
-0.0236825515,
0.0874132887,
0.0322572216,
0.0104327686,
-0.0212451033,
0.0249482673,
0.002194922,
0.0363121666,
0.0335646383,
0.0201603919,
0.0532036163,
0.0742021427,
0.0247606169,
-0.0140711712,
0.0316660218,
-0.016230572,
-0.0171786007,
-0.0636449158,
-0.0063726483,
-0.0130236512,
0.0515133813,
0.0243980344,
-0.0288120694,
0.0163598433,
0.0238207262,
0.0100184474,
-0.0365153849,
0.0101266364,
-0.0183981359,
0.0126718022,
-0.053205695,
0.087582916,
-0.0139214136,
0.0111026466,
-0.0133339074,
-0.0278335195,
-0.0121985544,
-0.0199971125,
-0.0337755643,
0.0338704064,
-0.0036163502,
0.0167146251,
0.041968409,
-0.0661067739,
0.0167250503,
-0.0013954126,
0.003231734,
0.072483398,
0.0300361384,
-0.0607162341,
0.0043276506,
0.0022658904,
-0.0608346313,
-0.0288851783,
-0.0329530239,
0.0140627353,
-0.0071535078,
0.0145779271,
-0.0596093908,
0.010906064,
0.0259569436,
0.0493562147,
0.1236552224,
0.0683052018,
-0.0245597549,
0.0093564382,
-0.0118624233,
0.0581758134,
0.003578064,
0.0651541501,
-0.0331882983,
0.0704683661,
-0.0635727271,
0.0327394828,
-0.0155900186,
0.0552054755,
-0.0554882661,
0.0240813214,
-0.0453546345,
0.0118327839,
-0.0027920427,
0.004237351,
0.0195561536,
-0.0397498794,
-0.0516242273,
0.0190200917,
-0.003006536,
0.0137522332,
-0.0456930846,
0.0225951616,
0.0006508795,
-0.0823064223,
-0.0248699225,
0.011768722,
-0.0239343867,
-0.0324173719,
0.0276211984,
0.0490117073,
0.0053343652,
-0.040914014,
-0.0366102755,
-0.0263424162,
-0.0115892114,
-0.0840357691,
0.0001636799,
-0.0715423077,
0.0239216741,
0.000632914,
0.0074008899,
0.0111354953,
0.0049804118,
0.0300270393,
-0.0062300107,
0.0499026515,
0.0092123458,
0.014918454,
-0.0456879996,
-0.0015968482,
0.0212130509,
0.0759335682,
0.0310876016,
-0.0227746032,
0.0336557403,
-0.0257774461,
-0.0355663933,
0.0440611057,
0.0135384705,
0.0141112888,
0.0103625469,
0.0219693426,
-0.0189234577,
0.0056280275,
0.0177273881,
0.0505921058,
-0.0342359133,
0.0057415394,
-0.004238524,
0.0363369435,
0.0218444094,
-0.0283820406,
0.0610336885,
0.0419655517,
0.0199734885,
0.0340805128,
-0.0625323132,
0.0190525539,
-0.014476154,
0.0258203223,
0.0344684385,
0.0222502463,
-0.023366224,
-0.0316655263,
-0.0008199846,
0.0299184266,
-0.0192152336,
0.0075514237,
0.011785889,
0.0035394125,
-0.0703236088,
0.0311561935,
0.0440488867,
-0.048719354,
-0.0176562127,
-0.0583030023,
-0.0139316311,
0.0624664389,
0.0418955311,
-0.0193142593,
-0.0685785785,
0.010569131,
0.0352753103,
0.0058173318,
0.0534244701,
-0.004737556,
0.0322190709,
-0.0452059135,
-0.018954983,
-0.0347838365,
0.0220668465,
0.0078099165,
0.0308650881,
-0.019410884,
0.0024755704,
-0.0268212836,
-0.042472925,
0.0442617014,
-0.0297508072,
-0.0758856013,
-0.0354136676,
0.012485289,
0.0345444977,
0.0154112503,
-0.0091054011,
0.0172100198,
0.0275084078,
0.0075070877,
0.0640371144,
-0.0481404923,
-0.026363112,
-0.058103133,
0.0407005623,
-0.0237499811,
-0.0261094514,
0.0341577753,
-0.053816177,
-0.0457247198,
0.00132325,
-0.0289125647,
0.0037693565,
-0.004145524,
0.0548738278,
-0.0127584971,
-0.013269267,
-0.0629433021,
0.0058504185,
-0.0173354801,
0.0583528951,
0.0501751266,
0.0167795718,
0.0228986628,
-0.0312074143,
-0.0305141062,
-0.0022219308,
0.0060262443,
0.0153384525,
-0.0174399242,
0.0615432039,
-0.0689488277,
-0.0634715185,
-0.0527041666,
0.0481046475,
-0.0263147783,
0.0620873645,
0.0515837744,
0.002311711,
0.0068604429,
0.0013630049,
0.0101065431,
-0.0247801021,
-0.0092984363,
0.0455842279,
0.0144697968,
0.0260203183,
-0.0620524734,
-0.0511368923,
-0.0347406827,
-0.0271772407,
-0.0261145439,
-0.0239948668,
0.0374812894,
-0.0661901161,
0.0412078686,
-0.0061891251,
0.0195188727,
-0.0146910287,
-0.0610119142,
0.0424472988,
0.0100260768,
0.025011085,
0.0708823875,
-0.0520889945,
0.0152543299,
0.0419028141,
-0.0198690314,
-0.0650309622,
0.0361044593,
-0.0147164855,
-0.0683775246,
-0.0355430767,
-0.024351405,
0.0037338308,
0.0547244884,
-0.0014162773,
-0.0005709249,
-0.0642997399,
0.0045728558,
-0.0209582318,
-0.0163824838,
0.0216991249,
0.0266562738,
-0.0210006963,
0.0141999843,
-0.0381405689,
-0.0620273687,
0.0763725191,
-0.0155931907,
-0.0063350252,
-0.0463191755,
0.020999508,
-0.0447190069,
0.0206453092,
-0.0120459357,
-0.008769027,
-0.0476231053,
-0.0386263914,
-0.0521960817,
-0.003324955,
0.0221043341,
-0.0327447169,
0.0783391222,
-0.0746942163,
-0.0038210852,
-0.0092240544,
-0.0152633972,
-0.0163911507,
-0.0161016155,
0.0016956885,
0.0060347058,
0.047447402,
-0.0155799985,
-0.0018210125,
-0.0121803544,
0.0211707409,
0.0019328123,
-0.0359243266,
-0.0012825781,
-0.0434730947,
-0.0316465199,
0.0316811725,
-0.0055286018,
0.0193388481,
-0.0500839949,
0.0241855364,
0.0211505219,
0.0537625626,
0.0035823481,
0.0027387429,
0.0445401035,
0.0624332502,
-0.0681457445,
-0.0355666988,
0.0754313767,
0.1125315651,
-0.0677980855,
-0.021587953,
0.1006382629,
0.0364246108,
-0.0126461703,
0.0132180247,
0.0030683791,
0.031034369,
0.0127286008,
0.0419575982,
-0.0700440407,
-0.0398293324,
-0.0011589153,
0.06527742,
0.0074494882,
-0.0083328886,
-0.0039245877,
-0.1060171947,
0.0326456651,
0.0089196544,
-0.024890339,
-0.0431010835,
-0.0255093239,
0.000063349,
0.0003134702,
0.0541999713,
0.0320528112,
-0.0619330294,
0.0175416581,
0.0387971401,
-0.0098045543,
-0.0767706409,
0.053330943,
-0.0291951522,
0.0607106797,
0.0674424917,
-0.0018552518,
0.0133743696,
-0.0654085577,
0.0311816223,
-0.0521355458,
0.0179734323,
-0.0226605088,
0.0608122945,
-0.0010712357,
-0.0127854636,
0.0047904444,
0.0060120756,
-0.0174234547,
0.0366593413,
0.0138761615,
0.0492994525,
-0.0236801468,
0.0178566072,
-0.003797926,
-0.0007209699,
-0.0222295988,
0.0403003879,
0.0348192044,
-0.032217402,
-0.0371796153,
-0.0371105559,
-0.0347936824,
-0.1063504964,
0.0037805412,
0.0401340574,
-0.0460843705,
0.0114286114,
-0.02637426,
-0.050606247,
0.0571747348,
0.0175667517,
0.0309028588,
0.013129578,
0.0261813123,
-0.0060240659,
-0.0174542628,
0.0308666937,
-0.0207030457,
0.025509771,
-0.1075919643,
-0.0432510711,
0.0275300499,
0.0367175378,
0.0022204923,
-0.008380482,
-0.0914849043,
-0.068320401,
-0.0021777214,
0.0622517355,
0.0120271416,
0.038644556,
-0.0040733013,
-0.0248820875,
-0.0637072474,
0.0193235558,
-0.0257312525,
0.0395112298,
0.0389797427,
-0.0316845402,
0.0031046949,
0.0279848035,
-0.0263221059,
0.0320329294,
0.0324141718,
0.0472091362,
-0.0011212836,
-0.0385065936,
0.0253356788,
0.063805379,
0.0142269637,
-0.0096934931,
-0.0014390071,
0.0016153137,
0.0130474707,
-0.0044609937,
0.0122998822,
-0.0462229736,
-0.0169067401,
0.012616233,
-0.0367670506,
-0.0227496196,
-0.0111257145,
-0.0213616602,
0.0356671549,
-0.0465964079,
0.075589031,
-0.0303737093,
-0.0144944871,
0.0230275095,
0.0091204103,
-0.0218876507,
0.0053338157,
-0.0044084121,
0.0595897362,
-0.0058113458,
0.0516844243,
0.0130890897,
0.0480337106,
-0.0001908841,
0.0477033891,
-0.0279996973,
-0.0179703701,
-0.0295532066,
-0.0159632415,
0.03971228,
-0.0184474718,
0.0625191331,
0.000834448,
-0.0014690586,
-0.0100463815,
0.0380618945,
-0.0190970097,
-0.0095073273,
0.020626748,
0.0573493727,
0.0130282929,
-0.0072596045,
0.0579699054,
-0.0088020368,
0.0386933275,
0.0301923901,
0.0380729139,
-0.0420138128,
-0.0152279641,
-0.0158609673,
0.0384017825,
0.0217633713,
0.0238056574,
-0.0289658438,
-0.0450052544,
-0.02320721,
0.0287619885,
0.0119972546,
-0.0362361223,
0.0302506052,
0.0219157841,
-0.0139066372,
-0.0506313182,
-0.0382011682,
-0.0339279249,
0.0052546388,
-0.0359541737,
-0.01629306,
-6.051658344e-33,
-0.0527588502,
0.012143895,
0.0467698909,
0.0188078042,
-0.0308364984,
-0.0122433081,
-0.0114522632,
0.0036175745,
-0.0245546419,
-0.0051508392,
-0.0194793921,
0.0107654752,
0.0055549955,
-0.003590123,
0.0317339711,
-0.0133633241,
0.0424260125,
-0.0143656489,
-0.029218927,
0.0179884173,
-0.0248000007,
-0.0135758948,
0.0742263943,
-0.0220094267,
0.0104256924,
-0.0020314979,
0.013593521,
-0.0299131889,
-0.0442205369,
0.0575536154,
0.0193886235,
0.0119018489,
0.0072991499,
-0.0439493023,
-0.0303828157,
-0.0437356122,
-0.0341174044,
-0.065059796,
0.0496408045,
0.0189186372,
-0.0282539129,
-0.0409333594,
0.015656786,
-0.0003013921,
-0.0761487037,
-0.0138721056,
-0.0063027199,
-0.0004660267,
-0.0179933012,
0.032141231,
-0.0509386845,
0.0229033958,
-0.0000563876,
-0.0459188111,
0.0341545343,
0.0078976862,
-0.0186017565,
0.0044703125,
-0.0189840067,
0.0039210552,
0.0738143697,
0.0830190927,
0.0696095899,
-0.0061685177,
-0.0033461661,
-0.0045405542,
-0.0107096881,
0.0336266235,
0.0296369512,
0.0095834006,
0.0284717996,
0.0815212503,
0.023730481,
-0.0001954933,
0.045989383,
0.0280934218,
-0.019373931,
0.0107711293,
0.0045892708,
0.0169520117,
0.013666166,
-0.0226214863,
-0.0728358701,
-0.0212292448,
-0.0548580214,
0.0303144157,
-0.0236323904,
-0.0073052878,
0.0663629547,
-0.007121651,
-0.0191824604,
-0.0075677633,
0.0153370518,
-0.0247625951,
-0.0270545576,
-0.0467294231,
-0.0361323953,
0.0348282792,
-0.0157477222,
0.0049294694,
-0.0799610168,
-0.0495256111,
0.0094826361,
-0.0301835183,
0.0521664843,
-0.0249181185,
0.0174771585,
0.0138506163,
-0.082342051,
-0.0102843177,
-0.0295597464,
0.0454462245,
0.0089222724,
0.0003606474,
0.0199168157,
0.012720081,
-0.0002546322,
0.078237094,
0.0056234407,
-0.0491497964,
-0.0220079031,
-0.0270500295,
0.0069010057,
0.0263050124,
-0.0096749654,
0.0079383841,
-0.0215670355,
0.0190335363,
-0.0244702566,
-0.0296466611,
-0.0348100401,
0.0477955602,
2.698e-7,
0.0248575304,
0.0580364205,
0.0420891196,
0.0559315123,
-0.0145344073,
-0.0004998102,
-0.0287581012,
-0.0297631118,
0.0225400664,
-0.0044295061,
-0.0076135141,
0.0267132595,
0.0393532813,
0.0021875519,
-0.0430235229,
0.0165612735,
-0.0008048952,
0.0581940487,
-0.0525709987,
-0.0203140788,
0.0235902257,
0.0578992181,
-0.0113773979,
0.0239765402,
-0.0086551178,
-0.0086901663,
0.0118150674,
-0.0075945696,
-0.0004638217,
0.0483758934,
0.0256658476,
0.0161391497,
-0.002250928,
0.0284670144,
-0.0123187313,
0.0104127591,
-0.0287089664,
0.0846681297,
-0.0102550657,
-0.0272165295,
0.0309457202,
-0.0400031619,
-0.0020555975,
-0.0208968595,
0.0500764996,
-0.0486441143,
-0.0081469435,
0.0101282354,
-0.0462513007,
-0.0135772098,
0.0061024893,
0.0014499738,
0.0312826335,
0.0313624665,
0.0306550879,
-0.0471411683,
-0.0292593352,
-0.0350517333,
-0.000211056,
0.0437121689,
0.0163284559,
-0.0756652206,
-0.0431517959,
-0.0219814349,
-0.028429538,
-0.0598845296,
-0.0377613008,
2.661741883e-34,
0.0359003544,
-0.0531458668,
0.0906519666,
0.0213283226,
0.0013737509,
-0.0009809971,
-0.0124984374,
0.0126364101,
-0.00038837,
-0.0852560773,
-0.0158872642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16173v2 | Conditions for Length Generalization in Learning Reasoning Skills | 2023-11-22T03:36:18 | 2023-12-06T16:31:50 | Changnan Xiao, Bing Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Reasoning is a fundamental capability of AI agents. Recently, large language
models (LLMs) have shown remarkable abilities to perform reasoning tasks.
However, numerous evaluations of the reasoning capabilities of LLMs have also
showed some limitations. An outstanding limitation is length generalization,
meaning that when trained on reasoning problems of smaller lengths or sizes,
the resulting models struggle with problems of larger sizes or lengths. This
potentially indicates some theoretical limitations of generalization in
learning reasoning skills. These evaluations and their observations motivated
us to perform a theoretical study of the length generalization problem. This
work focuses on reasoning tasks that can be formulated as Markov dynamic
processes (MDPs) and/or directed acyclic graphs (DAGs). It identifies and
proves conditions that decide whether the length generalization problem can be
solved or not for a reasoning task in a particular representation. Experiments
are also conducted to verify the theoretical results. | [
0.0255480316,
-0.005930915,
-0.0136708478,
-0.030591609,
-0.0649602637,
0.0288560949,
0.0363629088,
-0.0029217298,
0.0109189376,
0.0106069334,
0.058561448,
-0.0328008421,
0.0037601453,
0.0163353365,
0.0305021591,
-0.0394554436,
0.0444924533,
-0.0628147423,
0.0340177156,
-0.0268921219,
-0.0219328701,
-0.0383552089,
-0.0353320129,
0.0194164794,
0.0016756501,
-0.0088180881,
-0.0539960191,
-0.0770370215,
0.0013194756,
-0.0307942852,
-0.0911770016,
-0.0292153247,
0.0196899567,
0.0124830958,
0.0000016647,
-0.0528674535,
0.0183395855,
-0.0049098763,
-0.0358449817,
-0.0537992418,
-0.0018859701,
-0.0056848964,
0.0305266678,
0.0264939107,
-0.0171921179,
-0.0365311839,
0.0111065889,
0.0189180523,
0.0252156444,
0.0915106088,
-0.000751724,
-0.0487534329,
0.0331750736,
-0.0284134075,
0.0204334054,
-0.0299265292,
0.0440139957,
0.070213668,
0.0745940059,
-0.0518169962,
-0.0233119577,
-0.0003135599,
0.0315488987,
0.0191018861,
-0.0109589919,
0.0155206658,
0.0123476824,
0.0052876864,
0.0459265821,
0.0343328863,
0.0002930943,
0.00597151,
-0.0040268372,
-0.001827749,
0.0224428251,
0.0409920067,
-0.0580357052,
0.0188510846,
-0.0138127962,
0.0130298762,
-0.0027039174,
-0.0150050512,
0.0257245824,
-0.0241585094,
-0.0620596856,
0.1245414764,
-0.0132882334,
-0.0362537168,
0.017959062,
-0.0353167653,
0.0179351512,
-0.0465309024,
-0.0028936614,
0.0845443532,
-0.0121702272,
0.0468018427,
0.0238273554,
0.0475934073,
-0.0119748199,
-0.0448033512,
0.0518064983,
0.0326698646,
0.042157907,
0.0270494614,
-0.0638067871,
0.0780479163,
-0.0116378963,
0.0587006696,
-0.0548748598,
0.02917956,
-0.0887334421,
-0.0126782916,
-0.0367434919,
0.0560376793,
0.0446199812,
-0.0032952339,
-0.0340367071,
0.0364993364,
0.010956699,
0.0388701074,
-0.0139292302,
-0.0397540107,
-0.0220044721,
-0.0389641374,
-0.079942733,
0.011784425,
-0.0632405132,
0.0118231298,
0.0093460148,
0.0309164934,
0.00554258,
-0.0396622084,
0.0393484831,
-0.0305879135,
0.0152230747,
0.1024724841,
0.0168959741,
-0.0319521166,
-0.0498682559,
-0.0028020598,
-0.0281024538,
-0.0921241194,
0.0138851199,
-0.0296123549,
-0.0024892122,
-0.0063715405,
-0.0230592471,
0.0013466959,
0.0119007137,
-0.0235670246,
-0.0235993229,
0.0626736581,
0.0614831261,
0.0305765197,
0.0071847015,
-0.025162166,
-0.002224097,
0.0419001989,
0.0445627645,
0.0135291824,
0.0205623209,
-0.0134614361,
0.0076147108,
-0.0101075359,
-0.0082425959,
0.0054406072,
-0.0325883441,
-0.0078741238,
-0.0114173032,
0.0059647271,
-0.0295758117,
0.0348018445,
-0.0185986273,
-0.0443955138,
0.0162303373,
0.0484494604,
0.0102516469,
0.0027126393,
0.0982672647,
-0.0350506678,
0.0071392097,
0.0672913939,
-0.0103349341,
-0.0234099682,
-0.0121727316,
0.032918863,
-0.0243330654,
-0.0131276781,
-0.0437057689,
-0.0852401853,
-0.0335247107,
-0.0033451435,
0.0602624528,
-0.0033279997,
0.077638045,
-0.0024048947,
-0.0092042899,
-0.0307271071,
0.0062424401,
-0.0148024922,
0.0148888435,
-0.0420663059,
-0.0006057729,
0.0498436056,
0.0340768248,
-0.0465465188,
-0.0494966917,
-0.0171108004,
-0.0166519657,
-0.0134144472,
0.0374904945,
-0.0191296265,
-0.0134989861,
-0.0196449086,
-0.0026339616,
-0.0083901649,
-0.0031137755,
0.0083684362,
-0.0067521967,
0.0115662673,
0.0117246099,
-0.0430446155,
-0.0279004071,
0.0176603422,
-0.0354581773,
-0.0349537395,
-0.0428788699,
0.0251839422,
0.0226072259,
-0.0132232895,
-0.0094326502,
0.0332785137,
-0.008999804,
-0.0264768507,
-0.0074954778,
0.0438616984,
-0.0468384251,
0.0050966269,
0.0579690039,
-0.0407956801,
0.0268837605,
-0.0168486405,
-0.0059314189,
-0.0522999577,
0.0487430207,
-0.0539694466,
0.0344220698,
0.0458186977,
0.0579483248,
0.0067811245,
-0.0240336638,
0.0072923419,
0.0710379556,
-0.0044256737,
0.0056716441,
-0.010459831,
0.0170930158,
0.050551936,
-0.0886343569,
0.0043098107,
0.0425051078,
0.005867207,
-0.034340106,
0.0400021784,
-0.0565782972,
-0.036310751,
-0.0146951647,
-0.0202672146,
-0.035073895,
0.0247620977,
0.0240714885,
-0.0097487513,
-0.0079624932,
0.0043074447,
0.0152913267,
-0.064195022,
0.0287994333,
0.0295288209,
0.0128989872,
0.0462461635,
0.0467069261,
-0.0818388015,
-0.0144162718,
-0.0454912782,
-0.0354099423,
0.0422170572,
0.0210454147,
-0.0099964775,
-0.0356267057,
0.0433200523,
-0.0138350939,
0.052063033,
-0.0443662256,
-0.0176528115,
0.0230492204,
-0.0341800898,
0.0398283787,
0.1012700349,
-0.0043017422,
0.0337375104,
0.0472287573,
-0.0146081597,
-0.0153345978,
0.032613676,
-0.0528750122,
0.0040901871,
-0.0594614223,
-0.0335022062,
-0.0275058392,
0.0722624734,
-0.0091697453,
-0.0231258981,
-0.0678125694,
-0.0414180905,
-0.00871085,
0.0076435455,
-0.0000952762,
-0.0089114904,
-0.0079435054,
0.0342094079,
-0.026101632,
-0.0540544577,
0.0672244877,
0.0072266152,
0.0202116016,
-0.0398028679,
-0.0422028266,
-0.0332878679,
0.1036351994,
0.0497308634,
0.0053760451,
-0.0187454037,
-0.0343293361,
-0.0492587015,
-0.0291355308,
0.0345721692,
0.0028929138,
0.0246373918,
-0.0545833819,
0.0315147042,
0.0127688097,
-0.0142831653,
-0.045007199,
0.0687234476,
-0.0098386835,
0.0178697184,
-0.0065999655,
-0.0329488479,
-0.0294119716,
0.0248436723,
0.0280394722,
-0.0057592522,
0.0052986811,
-0.004571062,
-0.0183682609,
-0.0230565518,
0.024930058,
-0.0172652192,
-0.0039878692,
-0.0560216829,
0.0320279114,
-0.0220779404,
0.0524746217,
0.0013340702,
-0.0438884832,
0.0129804285,
-0.0405833572,
-0.0492788516,
-0.0493985452,
0.0438114628,
0.0194367841,
-0.0488730185,
-0.0261028316,
0.0679725036,
0.0310836695,
0.0040862234,
0.0236492865,
-0.0068381233,
-0.0039887493,
0.0268606674,
0.0218650717,
-0.0715383589,
0.0105173001,
0.0216688067,
-0.0151340803,
-0.0298208836,
-0.0587937832,
-0.0157374423,
-0.1237888709,
-0.0288696568,
0.0228445102,
-0.0017190245,
-0.0475943051,
-0.0200701039,
-0.018126769,
-0.0048944294,
-0.0115990313,
0.0065023559,
-0.0209549908,
0.0016142369,
0.0320235528,
-0.0333582684,
-0.0170381758,
-0.0044068899,
0.0254889447,
0.040859472,
0.0298465062,
0.0267705768,
0.0030552621,
-0.0558729544,
0.0354534723,
0.0546737202,
0.042625647,
0.0120566823,
-0.0012556118,
0.0415176824,
0.0129222954,
0.0144553306,
0.0245675184,
0.0146479858,
-0.0048966142,
0.0120124221,
0.0905195251,
-0.0156956296,
-0.0528913401,
0.0039014816,
-0.0037115675,
-0.0523704365,
0.0428189859,
0.0283649694,
0.0085061509,
-0.081685029,
-0.0260399897,
-0.0263313763,
-0.0421249941,
0.012665797,
0.0417250767,
-0.016732404,
0.0134422835,
-0.0401217639,
-0.0148333702,
0.0239149816,
0.0845990106,
-0.0073159304,
-0.0230612736,
0.0264621973,
0.0110829184,
-0.0296377596,
-0.0178693943,
-0.0217977911,
0.0243001468,
-0.0449818596,
-0.008001592,
-0.0276056547,
-0.0341386758,
-0.027215831,
-0.0452253781,
-0.0770378932,
-0.0786654353,
0.0081039136,
0.0029526183,
0.0386476889,
0.0418036431,
0.0001546863,
-0.0167728197,
0.0221219603,
-0.0695896596,
0.0091769556,
-0.0174331293,
0.0452700965,
0.0291393194,
0.0316435434,
0.0249538161,
-0.0197154265,
0.0410640799,
0.0182931833,
0.0176919624,
-0.0317230932,
0.0195391718,
0.0263473205,
0.0817382112,
-0.0429575741,
0.0620893985,
-0.0025484359,
-0.0312580615,
0.0229975786,
-0.0016910302,
-0.0106667802,
-0.0293896962,
0.026437046,
0.0268033855,
0.0164305177,
0.0234300978,
-0.0818518326,
-0.0121954661,
-0.0206589624,
0.0387627408,
0.0340339802,
0.0185669158,
0.0043893401,
0.0588142127,
-0.006830845,
-0.0058553256,
0.042655807,
0.0018693882,
0.0359458663,
0.0337579288,
0.0526621863,
0.0320904106,
0.0178980213,
-0.0843653381,
-0.0480600037,
-0.0723298937,
-0.0434799828,
0.0478522107,
0.038703084,
0.0429417789,
0.005590844,
-0.0434535779,
-0.052779749,
0.0319595896,
0.0249627307,
0.0137418108,
0.0304380991,
-0.0106772007,
0.0104686422,
0.0507113822,
-0.0113910167,
-0.0036447202,
0.0780980363,
-0.0193420071,
0.0753761306,
-0.0345721915,
-0.0125190644,
-0.0512128733,
-0.0380949043,
-0.0405272767,
0.0327178352,
-0.0006869021,
0.0359084867,
-0.0532678589,
-0.096186474,
-0.0364482328,
0.0194399115,
0.0475771166,
-0.0083895819,
-0.0056090048,
0.0292324908,
0.0004354062,
-0.0198246855,
-0.0220089629,
-0.0258593448,
0.0259860735,
0.0255788006,
0.0008664518,
-5.280128871e-33,
-0.0083498331,
-0.0281916745,
0.0587529764,
-0.0370051339,
-0.0170534179,
-0.0099540241,
-0.0107092177,
0.004282414,
-0.0262451954,
0.0134035777,
-0.0105538331,
0.0082055107,
0.0038534689,
-0.0043802033,
0.0024907461,
0.0007302894,
-0.0002733028,
0.0112518379,
-0.0133010028,
-0.0044405023,
0.0399534181,
-0.0123436861,
0.0056633051,
-0.0004491466,
0.0290069617,
0.0128088947,
-0.0118730506,
0.0365995727,
-0.0383943729,
0.0468939655,
0.0258602276,
0.0049597756,
0.0397417061,
-0.0211065058,
-0.0277316794,
-0.0096228831,
-0.0764026791,
-0.0287978258,
0.0326302648,
0.0053499355,
-0.0383132249,
-0.047127869,
0.0227299109,
-0.0011802515,
-0.0029800693,
-0.0178715102,
0.0438380837,
-0.0559242591,
0.0001460907,
0.0182841569,
-0.016093025,
0.0263165254,
-0.0324543193,
0.0292545184,
0.0234977175,
-0.0017731339,
-0.0214388222,
-0.0297775958,
0.0144707765,
0.0387959033,
0.0077902712,
-0.0025286535,
0.0250190794,
0.0096083311,
0.0426730961,
0.0228913892,
0.0462495759,
-0.0038123089,
0.005573472,
0.0000989078,
-0.0134736253,
0.055022411,
0.0069367746,
-0.0314312726,
0.0484926514,
-0.0032992521,
-0.0827276111,
-0.0426237695,
0.0466937758,
0.0763729513,
0.0081074657,
0.0333956257,
-0.0840857327,
-0.0163837615,
-0.0282752011,
0.0090076597,
-0.0092836991,
-0.0487084948,
0.0270753931,
0.0230173338,
0.0357655771,
0.0071532619,
0.022580089,
-0.017168697,
-0.000069279,
0.0248064734,
-0.0142106283,
0.0228457283,
-0.0079849875,
0.0124494871,
-0.0492086783,
-0.0532574542,
-0.0353317298,
-0.0025198672,
0.0023990341,
-0.0025837878,
0.0087131271,
0.0201098341,
-0.0392637216,
-0.0314103328,
-0.0298428982,
-0.006398607,
0.0513827614,
0.011868801,
0.0698716938,
0.0004118354,
-0.0083736014,
0.0441400409,
-0.0287112761,
-0.0247177333,
0.0220886804,
0.0467032269,
-0.0090939607,
0.0417899303,
-0.0223318674,
-0.0275802221,
-0.0223294329,
0.0258447938,
0.0268667936,
-0.036804989,
-0.0099354433,
0.0229737833,
2.558e-7,
0.0151711963,
0.029911574,
0.0655595362,
0.04793448,
0.011459427,
-0.0129542565,
-0.0393815637,
-0.0493278727,
-0.0242040418,
0.0156476889,
0.0115929786,
0.0535521582,
0.0149556817,
0.0225237478,
0.0018742417,
0.0194457583,
-0.0038876054,
-0.0012022314,
-0.0248821303,
0.0295647625,
0.0218987465,
0.0334304348,
0.0272458866,
0.0316109471,
0.024105737,
-0.1204706132,
0.0112850461,
0.0071530733,
0.0297392551,
0.0252248794,
0.0363738239,
-0.0250477977,
-0.0032029985,
0.0600126274,
0.0353937,
0.0334091932,
-0.0146199204,
0.0231956411,
-0.0022882565,
0.0125206327,
0.0034362325,
-0.0473497175,
-0.0069244867,
0.005496135,
0.08102718,
-0.0716204718,
-0.0679414794,
-0.0073926928,
0.011467956,
-0.0121229477,
-0.0269905534,
0.0480152518,
0.0355997533,
0.0105197793,
-0.0140171926,
-0.036093913,
0.0474697873,
-0.0918226391,
0.0200459249,
0.0448907763,
-0.0307212342,
-0.0437662154,
-0.0273864008,
-0.0003397029,
0.0376285873,
-0.0262856167,
-0.0275864042,
2.301593603e-34,
0.0455769598,
-0.0064341165,
-0.0006807023,
-0.0238419995,
0.0399221331,
-0.0637858883,
-0.0426136591,
0.0230397135,
0.0830246285,
-0.080261521,
-0.0419756025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13126v1 | Towards Better Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models: A Position Paper | 2023-11-22T03:28:34 | 2023-11-22T03:28:34 | Chengyu Wang, Junbing Yan, Wei Zhang, Jun Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper delves into the pressing need in Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning
(PEFT) for Large Language Models (LLMs). While LLMs possess remarkable
capabilities, their extensive parameter requirements and associated
computational demands hinder their practicality and scalability for real-world
applications. Our position paper highlights current states and the necessity of
further studying into the topic, and recognizes significant challenges and open
issues that must be addressed to fully harness the powerful abilities of LLMs.
These challenges encompass novel efficient PEFT architectures, PEFT for
different learning settings, PEFT combined with model compression techniques,
and the exploration of PEFT for multi-modal LLMs. By presenting this position
paper, we aim to stimulate further research and foster discussions surrounding
more efficient and accessible PEFT for LLMs. | [
0.010545617,
0.0620763898,
-0.0194151029,
0.0508358702,
-0.0176806636,
0.0075282296,
-0.0045949011,
0.0100596035,
-0.0608143546,
-0.0483544581,
-0.0712967142,
-0.0372025445,
0.0194634832,
0.0057449364,
0.0390237719,
-0.0349839665,
0.0388730243,
-0.0520927757,
-0.0082820095,
-0.0197199676,
-0.0053852266,
0.016703615,
0.0075035077,
0.0430070497,
0.0388104543,
0.0033878796,
-0.0089741284,
0.0336053185,
0.0076104687,
0.0426061451,
0.0064617787,
0.0679810196,
0.0270492323,
0.0451427214,
0.000001982,
-0.0211061072,
-0.0232004561,
0.0086524803,
-0.0193199459,
0.0514765866,
0.0842747316,
0.0229797624,
-0.0280530769,
0.0205867626,
-0.0075480011,
-0.0290696416,
0.0657142773,
0.0300503615,
0.0529835485,
0.0776259974,
-0.0019259898,
-0.0105303526,
-0.0008450507,
-0.029597152,
-0.0544928014,
-0.0190184489,
0.0285787582,
-0.0293727517,
0.000706523,
-0.008880293,
-0.0522977337,
0.0170069132,
0.0011864953,
0.0234932601,
-0.0489635281,
-0.0113072144,
-0.0124731036,
-0.0327725932,
0.0048034228,
0.0605058447,
-0.0541277193,
-0.0189511459,
0.0049584275,
-0.0049157436,
-0.0278419647,
-0.0002905879,
-0.0377232991,
0.0219340194,
0.0116060758,
0.0198730901,
0.0157036465,
-0.0560264215,
0.0396262594,
0.0194514524,
-0.0327482559,
0.015800491,
0.0582709424,
0.0107778963,
-0.0301003736,
-0.0433074944,
-0.0546379574,
-0.0262817144,
-0.0149083678,
0.0077010714,
-0.0436750799,
-0.0053933309,
-0.084070839,
-0.0226887297,
0.0111230751,
0.0199968033,
0.0693838894,
0.0330425724,
0.01049437,
0.0242714938,
-0.0286414754,
0.007179874,
-0.0312157702,
0.0361247435,
-0.0589642972,
-0.0167578664,
-0.0228484552,
0.029577801,
-0.0581931956,
-0.006990538,
-0.0331779569,
-0.010703627,
-0.0248318426,
0.0064377789,
0.0095174555,
0.0050040837,
0.0170489289,
-0.0380168483,
-0.0449886359,
-0.033576034,
0.0435831919,
0.0502315275,
-0.0368456431,
0.0326228924,
-0.021235846,
-0.0428481437,
0.0007837948,
0.0242441911,
0.0290721767,
-0.0070408741,
0.0129808327,
0.0306922682,
0.0172655899,
-0.0350030586,
-0.036686521,
-0.0211173519,
-0.0074057076,
-0.0774803534,
-0.0122248093,
-0.0615239069,
-0.0006257388,
-0.0066180001,
0.0312444754,
-0.0389897935,
-0.019969387,
-0.0159242917,
-0.0416956544,
0.0493291244,
-0.0149099473,
0.0171194095,
0.0159209948,
-0.0039673313,
0.0388843901,
0.1056533307,
0.0508767515,
0.0122502483,
0.0295251999,
-0.0286447052,
-0.0360320099,
0.0552274734,
0.0115260435,
0.0564818308,
-0.0372036621,
-0.0354114249,
0.0393336043,
0.0177431442,
0.0083826641,
0.0410080887,
-0.0344902687,
-0.0101566603,
0.0462009385,
0.0186892077,
0.0610311702,
0.0447668359,
0.0238166824,
0.0001494573,
0.0232277531,
-0.0012222931,
-0.0370098427,
0.0061422335,
-0.045514442,
0.0086204121,
0.0295771901,
0.0762386322,
-0.0284319781,
-0.0014633241,
-0.0169678107,
-0.0075709755,
-0.0161491055,
0.0187954083,
0.0373094901,
-0.009688247,
-0.0290205218,
0.0625258163,
0.0428314954,
-0.0305924825,
-0.0057438561,
-0.0737998933,
-0.0209858287,
0.0506311469,
0.0338920578,
-0.0158834495,
-0.0368804447,
-0.0009424898,
0.0302890856,
0.0103127277,
0.0361739509,
-0.0062258001,
0.0293141138,
-0.0632561371,
-0.0250551458,
0.0107555529,
0.0248866808,
-0.0087365443,
0.0140060615,
0.0017422242,
0.0176042691,
-0.0400009304,
-0.0113838147,
0.0266511515,
-0.0116523448,
0.0016028411,
0.0023120539,
0.0178337824,
0.019792702,
-0.022761846,
-0.0148034925,
-0.015377162,
0.0294891987,
-0.0213301331,
0.0376881361,
-0.0340005644,
-0.0117094032,
-0.0041376064,
0.0466421545,
-0.0032828161,
0.0351516046,
0.0326567814,
-0.0584237203,
-0.0605746694,
0.0114941522,
-0.0291705579,
0.0483342558,
-0.03566093,
0.0195538476,
-0.0666735992,
0.0322361887,
-0.0358221047,
-0.0186042264,
-0.0054789726,
0.0138895214,
0.0521829911,
0.02309829,
0.0087980228,
-0.012246279,
-0.046128571,
0.0299058333,
0.0069962782,
0.0253838375,
0.0008690123,
0.0220031869,
-0.0204640757,
-0.0546152145,
-0.0931821838,
0.0491389632,
-0.0396440029,
0.0111175245,
0.0261677951,
0.019935837,
-0.0196401998,
0.0125648528,
0.0042357156,
0.0589918345,
0.0022013946,
0.033708021,
-0.0033344638,
0.0041728751,
-0.067108795,
-0.043073874,
-0.0338139571,
0.0188474823,
0.0326641947,
-0.0434908122,
-0.0138399275,
-0.096192807,
0.0255233441,
-0.0081890421,
0.0478112064,
-0.0064338059,
-0.0705200583,
-0.0246722568,
-0.0377874337,
0.0282673333,
0.0642240271,
-0.0175212696,
0.0264956038,
0.0648582131,
-0.0086244754,
-0.0358496048,
0.0082617477,
-0.0275911558,
-0.069318153,
-0.0538215488,
-0.0077428562,
-0.0378029756,
0.0734403655,
-0.0363366567,
-0.0155367395,
-0.0559779964,
0.0189540498,
-0.0311147757,
-0.0130514354,
0.0060518216,
0.012393293,
-0.0193808414,
0.0289313067,
0.0115153696,
-0.0681919456,
0.0543827042,
-0.0552466027,
0.0051442408,
-0.0095791332,
-0.0168827549,
-0.0399598666,
0.0143936798,
0.0078007318,
0.029776359,
0.0144207925,
-0.0051824884,
-0.0763999373,
-0.0017447129,
0.0266834013,
-0.0207260996,
0.0586982146,
-0.0096188309,
0.0011774654,
-0.050023023,
-0.0339573175,
0.0206649695,
-0.04900508,
-0.023432605,
0.0250582639,
0.0225674845,
-0.0460615307,
-0.017904859,
0.0222393051,
-0.0169423353,
0.025961088,
-0.0352965184,
0.0053228918,
-0.0359719545,
0.0142136775,
0.0735334754,
0.0437709205,
0.0441583991,
-0.0358008444,
-0.0028959536,
0.0101891346,
0.0305627547,
0.0242426544,
-0.0323175527,
0.0119312089,
0.0620560236,
-0.0140872812,
-0.0181295369,
0.0261405651,
0.0457236841,
-0.0742939487,
0.0046568885,
0.1153840497,
0.0111685591,
-0.0482103117,
0.007404407,
0.0093174716,
0.0697259605,
0.0042237057,
0.0305028073,
-0.0459768958,
-0.0488944761,
0.0265027136,
0.035998635,
0.0005407748,
0.0088848155,
-0.007975596,
-0.0816640034,
0.0373283029,
0.0496163592,
0.0029652538,
-0.0395027064,
-0.0231152009,
0.0269427374,
-0.0056381822,
0.0170707908,
0.0127466982,
-0.0282677244,
-0.0195321329,
0.0111881215,
0.0077493484,
-0.083657369,
0.0221158098,
-0.0298711918,
0.05268915,
0.0070997607,
0.0046373671,
-0.0041051684,
-0.0277912505,
0.0245099366,
-0.0119869858,
-0.0050745588,
-0.059432853,
-0.0112008872,
0.0063296673,
-0.0221068263,
0.0277786851,
0.0340745524,
-0.0026386944,
0.002150839,
-0.0311552305,
0.0750106126,
-0.015223626,
0.0189743321,
0.0064762365,
-0.0180248432,
-0.012298326,
0.0524229854,
0.047069788,
-0.0394696966,
0.0104614031,
-0.0182590112,
-0.0350144468,
-0.0025023622,
-0.0225366987,
-0.0083281901,
-0.0062395856,
-0.009771469,
-0.0163687598,
0.0220991187,
0.0336776525,
0.0336380713,
0.0057702572,
0.0144490749,
0.0048691984,
0.0086472239,
-0.0568991564,
0.0167989917,
-0.0686614364,
0.0065328958,
-0.0784223601,
0.0111495033,
0.0625895709,
-0.0147100082,
-0.0085388618,
0.0190035608,
-0.1284172833,
-0.0703514442,
0.0106133791,
0.0366685726,
0.0173598863,
0.0444006659,
-0.0078107775,
-0.1006956026,
0.0148328692,
0.0135589959,
-0.0155701665,
0.0439728945,
0.0306221601,
-0.045710098,
-0.0178910811,
0.0676456168,
-0.0450705476,
-0.0000159313,
0.0204453543,
0.025882693,
0.0116467066,
-0.0929621458,
-0.0016762231,
0.0293860137,
0.0529599749,
-0.0260935426,
-0.0301042441,
-0.032837458,
0.0585403778,
0.0026350447,
-0.000958481,
-0.0371575542,
-0.008822795,
0.0045012552,
-0.0109954979,
-0.0149024799,
-0.0004106942,
0.0419757701,
0.0401111618,
-0.0107351365,
0.0728380531,
-0.0272898227,
-0.0195451546,
0.0523541346,
0.0092416285,
-0.0056645321,
0.0462061353,
0.0161938779,
0.0233676936,
-0.0536361001,
0.0542185679,
0.0071605477,
0.0135327997,
-0.1046346128,
0.039671246,
-0.0128849559,
-0.0907807946,
-0.0568435341,
0.033941187,
0.0549774244,
0.0030851914,
0.0500418469,
-0.0222871862,
-0.0401882827,
-0.0234427378,
0.0296559446,
0.0060253371,
0.0108125862,
0.0462204441,
0.0151174394,
-0.0161245465,
0.0253788158,
0.0509832427,
0.0129415225,
0.0510129668,
-0.0009131706,
0.0001463438,
-0.0191966612,
-0.0250157099,
-0.0241130274,
-0.0121767456,
-0.01447317,
-0.0018772427,
-0.0325407088,
-0.0455906242,
-0.015720062,
-0.0070992718,
-0.0247996803,
-0.0319915824,
0.0162510276,
0.0486281067,
-0.0097535895,
0.0021212627,
-0.0257369727,
-0.029570654,
0.0314454772,
-0.0136543196,
0.0152478935,
-6.448345443e-33,
-0.0491627865,
0.0198979434,
0.0075180111,
-0.0133365048,
-0.0385732949,
-0.016251741,
-0.0081551895,
0.0111904405,
-0.012161511,
-0.0078936489,
-0.011002277,
-0.0124810776,
0.0183079503,
0.015063717,
-0.0321687385,
0.0038524908,
0.0867387652,
-0.0182328541,
-0.010506996,
0.0218745377,
0.0179258529,
0.0098744193,
0.0394256637,
-0.0064379829,
-0.0496862456,
0.0112182405,
-0.032977134,
0.0375489071,
-0.0141323265,
0.0628066882,
-0.0068859621,
0.0334185436,
0.0046550548,
-0.038508337,
-0.0300272088,
0.0170367789,
-0.0628909916,
0.0018275473,
0.0302969664,
0.0102731334,
-0.0006207071,
-0.0370143689,
0.0617249236,
0.013121332,
-0.0240484271,
-0.0123202335,
-0.0094297891,
-0.0359772965,
-0.0344688185,
-0.0034387379,
-0.0688054189,
0.0246980153,
0.0149098122,
-0.0213239342,
0.0599845387,
-0.0025968354,
-0.0128096174,
0.0146202976,
-0.0138039831,
-0.0095309559,
0.0563110448,
0.1022234261,
0.0648553595,
0.037059132,
-0.0045064548,
0.0041637942,
-0.0079837544,
-0.0020036402,
0.0090518733,
0.0156670287,
0.1060165465,
0.050505884,
0.0278064962,
0.0696646869,
-0.0034571718,
-0.0225120168,
-0.058349736,
-0.01775226,
-0.0046110786,
0.0418480113,
0.0153007917,
0.0205205418,
0.0014260468,
-0.0224768054,
-0.1055215076,
0.0004298927,
-0.0359944627,
0.0077579808,
0.0108945342,
0.0140747959,
-0.0334669091,
-0.0215389356,
0.0597036071,
-0.0575553961,
0.0023727464,
0.0220967438,
-0.0217107758,
0.0403732024,
-0.0085636927,
0.0301851071,
-0.0421423391,
-0.0625524968,
0.0158838872,
-0.0289241076,
0.0168788563,
-0.0329206847,
0.0183129739,
0.0537357889,
-0.0672668442,
0.0083435904,
-0.014653638,
-0.0134051396,
0.0120520312,
0.0491373278,
0.0463034101,
-0.0119015751,
0.0186666902,
0.025408769,
0.0165392607,
-0.0130153745,
-0.0114548067,
-0.0196743272,
0.0256462116,
0.0355722681,
-0.0041413815,
0.0242374875,
-0.0430897847,
-0.0159127731,
0.0481941327,
-0.0456908271,
-0.0136819258,
0.0252626333,
2.637e-7,
0.0296936948,
0.0695805475,
-0.0069270972,
-0.0320430398,
0.0279437434,
0.033801727,
-0.0050990279,
-0.0086282445,
0.0221723076,
0.0097727934,
0.0293675922,
0.0371786766,
0.0584948882,
0.022616012,
-0.066320166,
0.0333066583,
-0.0253197979,
0.0626900792,
-0.0442267992,
-0.0261294376,
0.002923762,
0.131662786,
0.0105052674,
-0.025768131,
0.0161812566,
-0.0136890914,
0.0418366045,
-0.0443706848,
-0.0201893207,
0.0584781952,
-0.0102581829,
0.041504506,
-0.013151899,
-0.0152608622,
-0.0066622393,
0.0439634435,
-0.0368494578,
0.0978980735,
0.0081050908,
0.0085926726,
0.0295677502,
-0.0159346648,
-0.0271548405,
-0.0532820709,
0.0713765994,
-0.0464563034,
-0.0001984789,
-0.067780681,
0.0303154811,
-0.0221900903,
0.0127517488,
-0.0675850287,
-0.0157986246,
0.0516075455,
0.0183828473,
-0.022697052,
-0.0229239967,
-0.0899548158,
-0.0189130604,
0.0387870409,
-0.040516872,
-0.0393833183,
-0.034233734,
-0.0470518284,
0.05306793,
-0.0481532328,
0.0133038349,
2.785103587e-34,
0.0457427166,
-0.0467038639,
0.0410100929,
-0.0022618554,
0.0013220193,
-0.0035532799,
-0.028359795,
0.0260454435,
-0.003770198,
-0.1073461324,
-0.0204080231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13118v1 | Combatting Human Trafficking in the Cyberspace: A Natural Language Processing-Based Methodology to Analyze the Language in Online Advertisements | 2023-11-22T02:45:01 | 2023-11-22T02:45:01 | Alejandro Rodriguez Perez, Pablo Rivas | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI, 68T50, 62H30, 91C99, 68T068T50, 62H30, 91C99, 68T01, I.2.7; I.5.4; K.4.1; K.4.2 | This project tackles the pressing issue of human trafficking in online C2C
marketplaces through advanced Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques. We
introduce a novel methodology for generating pseudo-labeled datasets with
minimal supervision, serving as a rich resource for training state-of-the-art
NLP models. Focusing on tasks like Human Trafficking Risk Prediction (HTRP) and
Organized Activity Detection (OAD), we employ cutting-edge Transformer models
for analysis. A key contribution is the implementation of an interpretability
framework using Integrated Gradients, providing explainable insights crucial
for law enforcement. This work not only fills a critical gap in the literature
but also offers a scalable, machine learning-driven approach to combat human
exploitation online. It serves as a foundation for future research and
practical applications, emphasizing the role of machine learning in addressing
complex social issues. | [
0.0566251352,
0.0823054537,
-0.0257366803,
0.0255107079,
-0.0206972752,
0.0115194349,
0.0468462966,
-0.0069962488,
0.0263775177,
-0.0376442522,
-0.0232997946,
-0.0401523337,
-0.0113760494,
0.0486283973,
-0.0006839922,
-0.0461124182,
0.0060450002,
0.0023630485,
-0.0104838405,
0.044802025,
0.0158046205,
0.025929153,
0.0244303588,
0.0511848666,
0.005748135,
-0.0180853587,
-0.0103274761,
-0.0241482724,
0.0183329172,
-0.003661755,
0.0354730077,
0.0549797602,
0.0331107192,
0.0300118532,
0.0000017665,
-0.0489498042,
-0.0527588539,
-0.0107908128,
-0.0256686863,
-0.0221208036,
0.0576677993,
-0.0938980803,
0.0233267341,
0.0162162855,
-0.0508592166,
0.0438723862,
0.0524687544,
0.0693463087,
0.065547429,
0.0593793914,
-0.0175826754,
-0.0421899669,
0.0233710259,
-0.0053305007,
-0.0385490619,
-0.0315919183,
0.0461637862,
-0.0164851919,
-0.0290587544,
-0.0031556163,
0.0013823299,
-0.014250827,
-0.008406111,
-0.0197664071,
0.0099062482,
-0.0276669897,
-0.0772650465,
-0.0533134453,
-0.0299153496,
0.0410341248,
-0.0553475246,
-0.0116103627,
0.0235411488,
-0.0032215575,
-0.0274979677,
-0.0106687369,
-0.0287308525,
0.0449756086,
-0.0022213652,
0.0529131889,
0.0175297465,
0.0640799478,
0.025582144,
0.0611952096,
-0.0171752982,
0.0576111116,
-0.0397123918,
-0.0361238346,
-0.0094546145,
-0.0017424864,
-0.0063992478,
0.0256867763,
0.0470458046,
0.0030386178,
-0.0429698415,
0.0224849936,
-0.0015140862,
-0.0314454287,
0.0092161512,
-0.0885626599,
0.0213901158,
0.0064617782,
-0.046406664,
0.0214834455,
0.0109723918,
0.0278338213,
-0.0012024817,
0.0162583999,
0.0004521882,
-0.0226314589,
-0.0502274372,
0.0023051249,
-0.0309904683,
0.0036840537,
-0.030073503,
0.0539786853,
-0.0566933416,
0.0123620238,
-0.0644302219,
-0.0421360359,
0.0061665857,
0.0223723743,
-0.0298113767,
0.0226021279,
-0.0083867544,
0.0012494886,
0.0215869118,
-0.0066745658,
-0.0367169678,
-0.039950721,
0.0236493684,
0.0376655124,
0.0214909334,
-0.0436671749,
-0.0021218639,
0.0808395743,
0.0075288825,
-0.0361396149,
-0.0457508266,
-0.0375675596,
-0.0017899409,
-0.0175943784,
-0.0299839489,
-0.048824437,
0.0108090127,
-0.0100171315,
-0.0078225797,
-0.0528755225,
-0.0096698161,
0.010279539,
-0.0769415423,
0.0810555518,
-0.0059350063,
0.0172569435,
-0.0185363833,
0.0079897493,
0.0306629613,
0.0230199564,
-0.0087191109,
0.0858130306,
0.0724921525,
-0.0388851129,
0.0318291374,
0.0445237681,
-0.0265117008,
-0.0238465145,
0.0294871777,
0.0144148963,
0.003487346,
-0.0285529718,
0.0121115716,
-0.005633885,
0.0041724397,
-0.0032786194,
0.0474464558,
0.0719763562,
-0.0045044748,
0.0170044489,
0.0644238591,
0.0569781698,
-0.03600429,
-0.0136579759,
-0.0466164276,
-0.025872713,
0.0005360586,
-0.0539363846,
-0.0468272641,
0.0325478837,
-0.0061200568,
-0.0412782133,
-0.0218268074,
0.0015727145,
0.0455771014,
-0.011610968,
0.0520107709,
0.0373017155,
-0.0174067132,
0.0085519915,
0.0396379009,
0.012573747,
-0.007739936,
-0.0488400757,
-0.0225354116,
0.0519727021,
0.0145865642,
-0.0028544297,
0.0015148848,
-0.0555291586,
0.0303461403,
0.034237124,
-0.0136210248,
0.00747594,
0.0320778005,
-0.023400303,
-0.0332167596,
0.0428007543,
0.0012213306,
-0.0181857999,
0.0167831182,
-0.036547903,
0.0440880209,
-0.0011836706,
-0.0523749664,
0.0427632332,
0.0309333,
-0.0179813933,
0.0093552796,
0.0349332839,
0.026543051,
0.0029599739,
0.0234602839,
-0.0349220447,
0.0393650793,
-0.0065088496,
-0.0361119881,
-0.0001578346,
0.0218844619,
0.0364822261,
0.0115390932,
-0.0633915961,
-0.0266484283,
0.0234564114,
-0.0463769659,
0.0154010179,
0.0361366868,
-0.0222585164,
0.0174906347,
-0.0241252482,
-0.0114286887,
-0.0096207475,
0.0401291102,
-0.0263482854,
0.07824146,
-0.0149052367,
-0.0103498548,
0.0093507553,
-0.09032657,
0.0129357334,
0.0069939583,
0.0050733006,
-0.0223292746,
-0.0354014747,
0.0319352895,
0.049279321,
0.0291950423,
0.003660894,
0.0074014859,
-0.026685331,
0.0122352298,
-0.0281775184,
0.0012059303,
0.0429327004,
0.0197772402,
-0.00082166,
-0.0081769098,
-0.0034318136,
-0.0732519627,
0.0021290672,
0.0036557722,
0.0344027504,
-0.0332859978,
-0.0358050838,
-0.0013715342,
-0.0184901506,
-0.0161677562,
0.0718014687,
0.0200887006,
-0.0221412089,
-0.0377092175,
-0.0057054916,
-0.0077134534,
0.0044060764,
-0.0388704501,
-0.0099854032,
0.0036962579,
0.0214168802,
-0.0123880254,
-0.000106298,
0.0276687574,
0.0907693878,
0.0363757685,
0.027562635,
-0.0075969519,
-0.0447910167,
-0.0494102053,
0.0028918185,
-0.0432406999,
-0.077727519,
0.0180374645,
0.089149259,
0.0181127042,
-0.0038135464,
0.002933373,
-0.0366634466,
-0.0151345739,
-0.0580702387,
-0.0664696842,
-0.0122287022,
-0.0169589166,
0.0471693613,
-0.0220227167,
-0.0624347851,
0.0362140946,
0.0210765582,
0.0060706148,
-0.0056784055,
-0.0762425736,
-0.0420409217,
0.0460963994,
0.032996729,
0.0362685807,
0.031814523,
-0.0558857508,
0.026469443,
-0.0010028027,
0.0170199852,
-0.0232630316,
0.0250682048,
-0.0180344563,
-0.0150343562,
0.0401231945,
-0.0195653327,
-0.0797653496,
-0.0772994459,
-0.000594025,
-0.0015164482,
0.0246703643,
-0.0203357153,
-0.0382970348,
0.034910243,
-0.0016696687,
0.001708355,
-0.0101535693,
-0.0173347369,
-0.0311650876,
0.0537406579,
0.0397764593,
-0.0293050632,
0.0154049098,
-0.0032489349,
-0.017193025,
0.0286003258,
-0.0351468325,
-0.0189832468,
-0.0505974405,
0.053617321,
0.0137465103,
-0.0448861197,
0.0023338401,
0.0105522377,
-0.0255041402,
-0.0465182103,
0.0141788349,
0.0816206709,
0.0539591424,
-0.0203866232,
0.0366450809,
-0.0059938878,
-0.0104661155,
0.0117422212,
0.0223571509,
-0.0509000942,
0.0035105429,
-0.0174695086,
0.034763366,
-0.0722586438,
-0.0562229715,
-0.0008927969,
-0.0372275636,
0.076930277,
-0.0171812698,
-0.0087994132,
-0.0275208242,
-0.0887777805,
-0.037362244,
-0.077056177,
0.0261665098,
-0.0315538533,
-0.0490119681,
0.0003876629,
0.0259348135,
-0.0550114959,
-0.0303872675,
0.0001072141,
-0.0565041453,
0.0323073789,
0.0351073965,
0.0602661259,
-0.0380482413,
0.0107653942,
-0.032553032,
0.0024859912,
0.0096752224,
0.0063454136,
0.0614510365,
-0.0138931759,
-0.0261334274,
-0.0573553331,
0.0391611494,
-0.0415959768,
-0.0317183472,
-0.0102481926,
0.0900872499,
-0.038128145,
-0.01684759,
0.0127554573,
-0.0348304622,
0.0373502821,
0.0743505955,
-0.0103650456,
-0.0235456824,
0.0149036758,
-0.0475039855,
-0.0088834725,
0.0022704399,
-0.0933920369,
0.0116655305,
-0.0323098451,
-0.0303872656,
-0.0101407645,
-0.0315626673,
0.0190306697,
-0.0078600291,
0.0083971024,
-0.0069820345,
0.0329384767,
-0.0162675455,
-0.0743113607,
0.0537722372,
-0.0225080885,
0.0364481099,
0.0117649706,
0.0032595589,
-0.0145174954,
-0.048882097,
-0.0313161463,
0.0386749431,
-0.0639371946,
-0.0115516335,
0.0059439177,
0.0066697318,
0.0241338089,
0.020978462,
-0.0446209051,
-0.0345862247,
-0.0113366982,
0.056524042,
-0.0407528915,
-0.0483545847,
0.0577104352,
0.0031609095,
0.0073603271,
0.0137748979,
0.0173805077,
0.0259101316,
0.0231375452,
-0.0467739441,
-0.1043449789,
0.018157037,
0.0420479067,
-0.0187716465,
0.0731427893,
-0.0217839535,
0.0004993597,
-0.0255821086,
-0.0460566357,
0.0114943264,
-0.0284985602,
-0.0166770089,
0.0047095926,
0.0488127507,
0.0287669878,
-0.041739054,
0.0793314427,
-0.0638902783,
-0.0189785622,
-0.0403768867,
0.0301688444,
-0.0017177808,
0.0380480029,
0.0077893278,
0.0134615749,
0.024466306,
0.0415969305,
-0.0004628028,
0.0619484484,
0.0251605306,
-0.005955691,
0.0107745621,
0.039841488,
-0.012862605,
0.0372751728,
-0.0421989895,
-0.0186443999,
-0.0045845625,
0.0120130517,
0.0197869502,
-0.0354059748,
0.043083664,
-0.0030989705,
0.0023410374,
0.0272423401,
0.0521551967,
-0.0036368705,
-0.0548246205,
-0.0218690448,
0.0174177475,
-0.0367599055,
0.0409193002,
0.0702400133,
-0.0018010759,
-0.0093575912,
0.0264024809,
-0.0725314692,
-0.0351910107,
-0.000179946,
0.043924246,
0.005263736,
-0.0141472574,
0.0120480685,
-0.0348974839,
-0.0430589952,
-0.0241202395,
-0.0703309104,
0.0148610473,
-0.0061714901,
0.016080888,
0.0319909118,
-0.0293895286,
-0.0074034422,
-0.0661247596,
-0.0177990627,
0.0131991934,
-0.0252004545,
-0.0393687561,
-5.503077171e-33,
0.0306495242,
-0.0862011611,
-0.0166451856,
0.0226950515,
0.0038782621,
0.000955638,
0.0040336396,
-0.0263573341,
0.0244360808,
-0.0070898896,
0.0072648814,
0.0053775348,
0.0162870679,
0.0407690927,
-0.0190449189,
-0.0089289667,
0.0347269624,
0.0253502969,
0.0229657162,
-0.0079925982,
0.0349113122,
0.0531271733,
0.0800769478,
-0.1009278819,
0.0926291868,
-0.0078868801,
-0.0461273603,
0.0247074105,
0.0416614339,
0.046487689,
-0.0348940752,
0.0510945171,
0.0484859422,
-0.0637194887,
0.0189969763,
0.0192903075,
-0.0527636483,
0.0242902003,
0.0139306821,
0.0542475432,
-0.0079713762,
-0.0069950516,
0.0359181948,
-0.0394220576,
0.0276560914,
0.0272676703,
0.077144444,
-0.021241542,
-0.0067781615,
-0.0088403327,
-0.0510377176,
0.0172788221,
-0.0719644204,
0.0094558951,
0.0444469489,
0.0511555597,
-0.0105830105,
0.0215920582,
-0.0790334567,
0.0010628214,
-0.0180367604,
-0.029127311,
0.0301614199,
-0.0093961144,
-0.0208975542,
0.0406490602,
0.0052694012,
-0.0488876216,
-0.0192591213,
-0.0196742676,
0.0041843834,
0.0963790715,
0.0109534245,
0.0133485748,
0.011801254,
0.0193650331,
-0.0636826754,
0.0190893095,
0.0195625685,
0.0083724204,
0.0088064019,
-0.0008942,
-0.0569244064,
-0.0134527031,
-0.0145539287,
-0.0702284425,
0.0038963542,
-0.0296624508,
0.0025647327,
-0.0280276872,
-0.0639928728,
0.0681846812,
-0.0059839268,
-0.073723726,
0.0023517301,
0.0032065231,
0.0006405407,
0.0009997771,
0.0244272687,
0.0275674425,
-0.0286984425,
-0.0166097768,
0.0118781282,
-0.0273655951,
0.0410863496,
-0.0210266672,
0.0656637922,
0.0321552902,
-0.0201440305,
0.0190629791,
-0.0138628762,
0.0366967134,
-0.0025937662,
0.0725722015,
0.0108002359,
0.0175622907,
-0.02916505,
0.0339697376,
0.0423164926,
0.03427146,
0.020997351,
0.0227016751,
-0.0026582119,
0.0291612167,
-0.0092963763,
-0.0229477379,
-0.0313766114,
0.0143489065,
0.0601368211,
-0.0597361401,
-0.0239542462,
-0.0189611316,
2.41e-7,
0.0608184598,
0.0379913375,
-0.0118278349,
0.0304112956,
0.0075211059,
0.0475182012,
0.0664084181,
0.0532997549,
0.0020663538,
-0.057030037,
0.0000776798,
0.0245054532,
0.0269302707,
0.027353581,
-0.0507171005,
-0.0086120153,
-0.0142247034,
-0.0397206843,
-0.0567879342,
0.0154768778,
0.0052273697,
0.1062233299,
0.0608489625,
-0.028946938,
0.0039668591,
-0.0011252384,
-0.0006957696,
-0.0356678963,
-0.0071857874,
0.0099395858,
0.0292177722,
0.0475029498,
-0.0054542809,
0.0253588688,
-0.0256972536,
0.042497132,
0.0206417348,
0.0285901744,
-0.0156410933,
0.0276262555,
-0.0349075459,
-0.0813200623,
-0.0137961842,
-0.0554877184,
0.0887652487,
-0.0453485101,
-0.0411963686,
-0.0222761445,
-0.0131299635,
0.0054556075,
-0.0058350535,
-0.0219223592,
0.0049135294,
0.03100181,
0.0387558602,
-0.0444767959,
-0.0163112916,
-0.035634812,
0.0208890215,
0.006340256,
0.0049365284,
0.004802011,
-0.0028857379,
0.0273287371,
0.0671336576,
-0.0462619774,
0.029334344,
2.176923243e-34,
0.0204865746,
0.0385302193,
0.0159213357,
0.0019137543,
0.0299731921,
0.0270997938,
-0.056255769,
-0.0131576257,
0.0121391732,
-0.0451682396,
0.0241663456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13110v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13110v2 | White-Box Transformers via Sparse Rate Reduction: Compression Is All There Is? | 2023-11-22T02:23:32 | 2023-11-24T09:18:44 | Yaodong Yu, Sam Buchanan, Druv Pai, Tianzhe Chu, Ziyang Wu, Shengbang Tong, Hao Bai, Yuexiang Zhai, Benjamin D. Haeffele, Yi Ma | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we contend that a natural objective of representation learning
is to compress and transform the distribution of the data, say sets of tokens,
towards a low-dimensional Gaussian mixture supported on incoherent subspaces.
The goodness of such a representation can be evaluated by a principled measure,
called sparse rate reduction, that simultaneously maximizes the intrinsic
information gain and extrinsic sparsity of the learned representation. From
this perspective, popular deep network architectures, including transformers,
can be viewed as realizing iterative schemes to optimize this measure.
Particularly, we derive a transformer block from alternating optimization on
parts of this objective: the multi-head self-attention operator compresses the
representation by implementing an approximate gradient descent step on the
coding rate of the features, and the subsequent multi-layer perceptron
sparsifies the features. This leads to a family of white-box transformer-like
deep network architectures, named CRATE, which are mathematically fully
interpretable. We show, by way of a novel connection between denoising and
compression, that the inverse to the aforementioned compressive encoding can be
realized by the same class of CRATE architectures. Thus, the so-derived
white-box architectures are universal to both encoders and decoders.
Experiments show that these networks, despite their simplicity, indeed learn to
compress and sparsify representations of large-scale real-world image and text
datasets, and achieve performance very close to highly engineered
transformer-based models: ViT, MAE, DINO, BERT, and GPT2. We believe the
proposed computational framework demonstrates great potential in bridging the
gap between theory and practice of deep learning, from a unified perspective of
data compression. Code is available at: https://ma-lab-berkeley.github.io/CRATE . | [
-0.0388289802,
0.0923630595,
0.0016843356,
0.0427745879,
-0.0078925658,
-0.0058924835,
0.011929065,
0.0359016024,
-0.058959689,
0.0176333506,
-0.0423436835,
-0.0139821516,
0.0161924735,
0.031463176,
0.0061208755,
-0.0245824624,
-0.0102625759,
0.0601497144,
-0.0114908144,
-0.0112495674,
0.0086340969,
-0.028000718,
0.0167215075,
0.0682021379,
-0.0331591666,
0.0161360279,
-0.0348286778,
0.002595372,
-0.0177439488,
0.0129559552,
0.0119841183,
0.0356842503,
0.0616425313,
0.0179605614,
0.0000022078,
0.0193493087,
-0.0177810509,
-0.0154324807,
-0.0526059754,
-0.0085726548,
-0.0041093314,
-0.0282942187,
-0.0000409157,
-0.0269790553,
-0.0011692723,
-0.0753023475,
0.0812199265,
0.0939535946,
0.0601050891,
0.0454225615,
-0.0215135962,
-0.0430958569,
0.0016563099,
-0.0382991917,
0.0300906207,
0.0181255508,
-0.0191372875,
-0.0375474803,
-0.0250520017,
-0.0035780401,
-0.0473399386,
0.0193380509,
0.0744427443,
0.0197056886,
0.0461831987,
0.0234275479,
-0.0662732422,
-0.0331605859,
0.0268284548,
0.0343721025,
-0.0549176633,
-0.0200935192,
-0.0412730351,
0.0349193737,
0.0230893698,
-0.0689554885,
-0.0238791145,
0.0020526475,
0.0266573541,
0.0519328527,
-0.0708236098,
0.0478891805,
0.038924329,
0.0037150248,
-0.047066249,
-0.0105163502,
-0.0038325565,
0.0145213809,
-0.0271857679,
0.0247098636,
0.0048156516,
0.0020638474,
0.0201485194,
0.0285193343,
0.0289229397,
-0.0366887152,
-0.0454110466,
-0.0482368656,
-0.0078728525,
0.0427422449,
0.0069121891,
0.0169894453,
-0.0208830275,
0.028160166,
-0.0421033539,
0.0477107167,
-0.0464543141,
0.036767181,
-0.0263212472,
-0.003486238,
-0.0185385589,
-0.0185033083,
-0.0210299585,
0.0831086636,
0.0107064638,
-0.0117611941,
-0.0148165757,
-0.0131269386,
-0.0114690419,
-0.0050143213,
-0.0026326496,
0.0576226525,
-0.051088091,
-0.0367487743,
0.0345732681,
0.0368793197,
-0.0172384251,
0.029796131,
0.0084009077,
-0.021684913,
-0.0596860051,
0.0410010554,
0.0209953375,
0.0057181078,
0.0221217126,
0.0403174087,
-0.0597434565,
-0.0243703518,
-0.0161852539,
-0.0039217249,
-0.0098157143,
-0.003056532,
0.0282790456,
-0.0603297278,
0.0135304295,
-0.004018025,
0.0346804447,
-0.0897324234,
-0.0030845862,
-0.0018580022,
-0.0292738415,
0.0365519337,
0.0061543705,
-0.0508753061,
0.0259550828,
0.0337955579,
0.0286738817,
0.0351598859,
0.0169959124,
0.0478993133,
-0.0241908561,
-0.0159065425,
0.0227501411,
0.026850434,
0.0553116649,
0.0280628726,
-0.0233022608,
-0.0568492971,
-0.0453573242,
-0.0070187962,
0.0819768906,
0.0860733464,
-0.0551699847,
-0.0809811205,
0.0500162393,
0.0339069106,
0.0181686226,
0.0943231881,
0.0127764083,
0.0153894639,
-0.0198858939,
0.0472234637,
-0.0009416536,
0.0569784902,
0.0078333681,
-0.0422426872,
-0.011612922,
0.017577257,
-0.0744648576,
-0.0329218805,
0.0395736881,
-0.0371314846,
0.0376148932,
-0.0152770532,
0.0527270921,
0.0140422136,
-0.026759604,
0.1058339775,
-0.0132837612,
-0.0233505052,
0.0001139082,
-0.0647039041,
-0.0064130048,
-0.0524510853,
0.0153481038,
-0.0278466605,
0.0089404499,
-0.0117447181,
-0.0486593582,
-0.0099621294,
-0.0322426893,
0.0264165308,
0.034014456,
-0.0344572514,
-0.0418309979,
-0.0190793127,
0.0052335202,
0.0133849215,
-0.0356429107,
-0.0277351681,
0.0213117488,
-0.0156657919,
0.0280000195,
0.0080458857,
0.0600229688,
-0.0262361392,
0.0681371689,
0.021340372,
0.0409798138,
0.0015390498,
-0.0316624828,
-0.0003741515,
0.0641194507,
-0.0797521099,
-0.0190946497,
-0.0036568902,
-0.0683135688,
-0.0160890259,
0.0065114694,
-0.0777710527,
0.0300580561,
0.1004700288,
-0.0137004154,
-0.0336796865,
0.0251589175,
-0.0772553086,
0.0411015414,
-0.0405844897,
-0.0414366201,
-0.0067717279,
0.0703448951,
0.0080532124,
0.0383706652,
-0.0344468504,
-0.0088497549,
0.0195011441,
-0.0240390971,
0.0285376515,
-0.0083566904,
-0.0521717332,
-0.0407200791,
-0.0543491356,
0.0206403024,
0.0593249314,
-0.0155545576,
0.0287176035,
0.0092549929,
-0.0275374316,
-0.0240513869,
-0.0549166538,
-0.0214456655,
-0.009888771,
0.0255349204,
0.0601085126,
-0.0280333515,
-0.0326661319,
0.0412767828,
0.0150529398,
-0.024064986,
0.0280664284,
-0.0120826224,
-0.0333365984,
0.0066816593,
-0.0605056137,
0.0548538938,
0.0471137427,
-0.0271907393,
0.0187071003,
-0.0217371825,
0.0009002918,
0.0489365235,
0.0136396969,
0.0048085093,
-0.0731054991,
-0.0102505935,
-0.0355184972,
-0.0106949909,
0.0618701391,
0.0082610408,
0.0543687306,
0.0186616108,
0.0545664839,
-0.0183250029,
-0.0012195024,
-0.0439403504,
-0.0114386762,
-0.0427234545,
-0.0299272556,
0.0013126703,
0.0366294645,
-0.0106733264,
-0.0143280011,
-0.0779138282,
-0.0383536853,
0.0474234819,
-0.047100462,
-0.044812277,
0.0031326381,
0.006072199,
-0.009682714,
-0.0276205391,
-0.0351282023,
0.0259874463,
-0.013078534,
-0.0045978539,
0.0201274212,
-0.0310601983,
-0.0131232943,
0.0103090582,
0.0429223329,
0.0260602664,
-0.0076234802,
-0.0229349043,
-0.0475414097,
0.0344007872,
-0.0308688562,
-0.0124875242,
0.0334090032,
0.0063268989,
-0.0093077077,
-0.0316475742,
-0.0411414057,
-0.0152962059,
-0.030946685,
0.0183522329,
0.0504193604,
0.0523214862,
-0.0243785363,
-0.0907499269,
-0.0075927181,
0.0222552381,
0.042745892,
0.0172971096,
-0.0172748119,
0.0025841277,
0.0525493957,
-0.0010865674,
0.0631026775,
0.0502234772,
-0.0084636081,
-0.0174535885,
0.0636677817,
0.0406652056,
0.0315026529,
-0.0713556707,
0.0267608184,
0.02031653,
0.0420264527,
-0.0187773407,
0.0174136441,
0.0272511505,
-0.0212616641,
-0.0220866483,
0.0642514676,
-0.0198233686,
-0.1005185246,
0.0145000042,
0.0136862202,
0.0388120636,
0.0082737096,
-0.0054257326,
-0.0466096103,
-0.0389518142,
-0.0207597632,
0.0015498846,
0.0126260929,
-0.0131338406,
0.0306561533,
-0.0392761119,
0.0028562171,
0.0244071186,
0.0082803778,
-0.0499041975,
-0.0226756036,
-0.0056841224,
-0.0227888785,
0.0123079475,
-0.0444339663,
0.0290483795,
-0.0530568473,
0.0160148591,
-0.0025321692,
-0.035567373,
-0.0129556982,
-0.012933543,
0.0045688273,
0.0344008878,
-0.0095733758,
-0.0460950099,
-0.0480095185,
-0.0790922716,
0.0093275802,
-0.0109982649,
0.0173446089,
0.0411682874,
0.0077198059,
-0.0295732729,
0.0267557614,
0.0385639518,
-0.0527014583,
-0.0026071339,
-0.0521458276,
0.0466579571,
-0.0220579859,
-0.0123125035,
-0.0426529646,
-0.037473321,
0.0084552551,
0.054986041,
0.0166033693,
-0.0138597488,
-0.0112831015,
0.0008284119,
0.0452234335,
-0.016041277,
-0.0505135022,
0.0491859317,
0.0171864908,
-0.080261685,
-0.0063551851,
0.0071011242,
0.0094911167,
0.0236599836,
-0.0168170612,
-0.0651995018,
0.0100424718,
0.0025393332,
-0.0549033284,
0.0110888006,
0.0083906874,
-0.028390158,
-0.0582476035,
0.0045670234,
0.0136459516,
-0.0411049128,
-0.0019843974,
-0.0104948226,
-0.0670942366,
0.0119627286,
0.0187327489,
0.0396645442,
0.0064845933,
0.0256242976,
0.0305803269,
-0.0425124764,
0.0600084551,
0.0466630571,
-0.0317841433,
0.0226412937,
0.0409540534,
-0.1014375314,
-0.0122481203,
0.0400883183,
-0.037505351,
0.0814636722,
-0.0015186456,
-0.0314069837,
-0.048440434,
0.035719391,
0.0542017817,
-0.0294152219,
0.0301335026,
-0.0070140283,
0.044546105,
0.0438867807,
0.0199859012,
0.0553428493,
0.0061920877,
-0.0424571745,
-0.0183611307,
0.0338831358,
-0.0118596945,
0.0100024231,
0.0408169329,
0.0555930175,
0.0185909942,
-0.019556215,
0.0155219408,
-0.0114343325,
-0.073268272,
-0.0128878914,
0.0198625252,
-0.0051257433,
-0.0210799146,
0.0339853577,
0.0131575549,
0.0049020834,
-0.0049606408,
0.0220123045,
0.0355994403,
-0.049603574,
0.0317159295,
-0.0378383845,
-0.0241620094,
-0.0227110833,
-0.0052916473,
0.023259908,
-0.0218776409,
-0.0213691294,
-0.0141232144,
-0.0128697855,
-0.0337912329,
-0.0264974516,
0.0144677255,
-0.0004140046,
0.0009753788,
0.0003286869,
0.0188799128,
-0.0169208776,
0.0677559823,
-0.0184469316,
0.0188130569,
-0.0220405757,
0.0205534138,
-0.060042467,
-0.000072465,
0.0221554041,
0.0388271287,
0.0363249294,
0.0041498863,
0.0261527039,
-0.0449323878,
0.0163446628,
-0.023332458,
0.0445079692,
-0.0214876737,
0.0460143313,
0.0287261494,
0.0017928942,
-0.0023869232,
0.0516340882,
-0.0109866215,
0.0044781482,
0.0131101403,
-0.0035450496,
-6.679197105e-33,
0.0025678389,
-0.0090139229,
-0.0319523588,
-0.0057829618,
0.0097732684,
0.0424263962,
0.0006872193,
-0.0201873146,
-0.0218171924,
0.0280601326,
-0.0373870172,
0.0145586245,
-0.0070861047,
0.0728995055,
-0.0112249404,
0.0116882073,
0.0774744749,
-0.015624539,
-0.0144021455,
0.0336238369,
0.0266806688,
0.0033059854,
0.0324729346,
-0.0451927856,
-0.0669191405,
-0.0028688645,
-0.0342479013,
0.0056668567,
0.0294331219,
0.0283018444,
-0.0479562506,
0.0197811741,
0.0316229314,
-0.0588637404,
-0.0130028604,
0.0367388427,
-0.0679003671,
-0.0165796783,
-0.0474955216,
0.0144395372,
-0.0335223973,
-0.048309274,
0.0915307552,
0.0190094598,
-0.0189161152,
-0.0468662493,
0.0133524342,
-0.0118085155,
-0.0049222694,
-0.0452989526,
-0.0285708606,
0.0125224218,
-0.0551370196,
-0.033468008,
0.0459686406,
0.014359639,
-0.0369209461,
0.006807691,
-0.0699885339,
-0.0192161184,
-0.0387409106,
0.0556124449,
0.0325959139,
0.0108820815,
-0.0095596844,
0.0271020588,
0.0106509896,
-0.0155887539,
-0.0715410262,
-0.0363432504,
0.0481605418,
0.0326265097,
0.0553404577,
0.0086026182,
0.068205595,
-0.0433323346,
-0.0742007867,
0.035871923,
-0.0192950796,
0.0848677382,
0.0536518581,
0.0199666433,
0.0277043898,
-0.0168387126,
0.0016212557,
0.0081686284,
-0.0076488298,
0.0104041211,
-0.0208231322,
0.0440527983,
-0.0312292222,
-0.0003699964,
0.0350408517,
-0.0344869718,
0.0300794691,
0.0296535809,
0.0341612957,
0.036732994,
0.0385167822,
0.002976452,
-0.0264295507,
-0.0127906501,
0.0204671603,
0.0119563863,
0.0199421979,
0.0030214093,
0.0391127132,
0.0555685125,
-0.0177419316,
-0.0463646203,
-0.0130716674,
-0.0145764425,
-0.0066314428,
0.0119773652,
0.0406368226,
0.0216435511,
-0.0127521316,
-0.0052894694,
-0.0262194276,
0.0351302512,
-0.0053768368,
0.0256353114,
0.0656007528,
0.0209616609,
-0.0064037107,
-0.0311071128,
-0.0682491884,
-0.0285385363,
0.0675140247,
-0.0712829009,
-0.0209477153,
0.0053788698,
2.885e-7,
0.0091245351,
-0.0171780568,
-0.0044862838,
-0.0397505499,
0.0207499266,
0.0434444658,
0.0168868322,
0.0479208231,
-0.0356899649,
-0.0545997247,
0.0380736291,
0.0528541617,
-0.0014653214,
-0.0056049475,
-0.0438690074,
-0.0004984665,
-0.0449854843,
0.0023648909,
-0.0059515457,
0.0220133737,
0.0288332663,
0.1374256909,
-0.0293947197,
-0.0384693779,
0.0494954847,
0.0462588146,
0.0392687991,
-0.0061079608,
0.0707167089,
0.0057179676,
0.0417647399,
-0.001254025,
-0.0217331853,
0.0062208148,
0.0206081737,
-0.0002218347,
0.0053736027,
0.0227414183,
-0.0262166969,
-0.0480612218,
0.0136298332,
0.0320429653,
-0.0073995106,
0.0154139483,
0.0414346717,
-0.0360584483,
-0.0311826505,
-0.0277975835,
-0.0275482517,
0.0193780512,
0.0134304371,
-0.0166900512,
0.0142826531,
-0.0014954185,
-0.0039469474,
-0.0076325424,
-0.0148258563,
-0.0728759542,
0.0407883711,
0.0062726908,
-0.0896701217,
0.0080535561,
-0.0664187744,
-0.0535495095,
0.076315254,
0.0101406043,
-0.0038635104,
2.380464222e-34,
-0.0167582333,
0.0089167682,
0.0274724886,
0.0355890207,
-0.0338867418,
-0.0581086501,
-0.0012150902,
0.0011987304,
-0.002674964,
-0.0497501045,
-0.0273445863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09457v1 | Functional Analytics for Document Ordering for Curriculum Development and Comprehension | 2023-11-22T02:13:27 | 2023-11-22T02:13:27 | Arturo N. Villanueva Jr., Steven J. Simske | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, K.3.2 | We propose multiple techniques for automatic document order generation for
(1) curriculum development and for (2) creation of optimal reading order for
use in learning, training, and other content-sequencing applications. Such
techniques could potentially be used to improve comprehension, identify areas
that need expounding, generate curricula, and improve search engine results. We
advance two main techniques: The first uses document similarities through
various methods. The second uses entropy against the backdrop of topics
generated through Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA). In addition, we try the
same methods on the summarized documents and compare them against the results
obtained using the complete documents. Our results showed that while the
document orders for our control document sets (biographies, novels, and
Wikipedia articles) could not be predicted using our methods, our test
documents (textbooks, courses, journal papers, dissertations) provided more
reliability. We also demonstrated that summarized documents were good stand-ins
for the complete documents for the purposes of ordering. | [
0.021959601,
-0.0336506702,
-0.0320804864,
0.0101421801,
-0.0171568301,
0.045034267,
0.0220751464,
-0.0458133109,
-0.0013917095,
-0.0425750054,
0.0180263724,
-0.0181623138,
0.008691377,
0.0034984495,
0.0081376694,
-0.0778298005,
0.0124405874,
0.0027438384,
-0.0275872555,
0.0073883249,
-0.0103933224,
-0.0166811161,
-0.0180524848,
0.0151522746,
0.0453169756,
-0.0124721378,
-0.0390241779,
-0.0082903849,
0.0426295698,
0.0010494731,
-0.0142469127,
0.0438249856,
-0.0035877037,
-0.0106642405,
0.0000020779,
-0.0559872054,
-0.0764841884,
0.0085511906,
0.0544806793,
0.0436925478,
0.1089772731,
0.0321843773,
0.0002552553,
0.0109384377,
0.0041061249,
0.0332370102,
-0.0074948226,
0.0334763899,
-0.0108004427,
0.0139478166,
-0.0016246262,
-0.072862871,
0.0411271788,
0.0357141793,
0.057838887,
0.0064327628,
-0.0132926917,
0.0420345366,
0.0328856856,
0.0498153903,
-0.0084666442,
0.0107844286,
-0.0136085879,
-0.0389166102,
0.0860284865,
-0.0026282542,
0.0389450938,
-0.0063035116,
0.0321632251,
0.0377691835,
0.0305416323,
-0.0116660371,
0.0623227023,
-0.0264038164,
-0.0098045124,
0.0511238128,
-0.0882307068,
0.0011625955,
-0.0168387108,
-0.0348131731,
0.074884519,
-0.0174551308,
-0.0270491149,
0.0049108947,
0.0033736709,
0.0491476469,
0.0214520358,
-0.0353542827,
-0.0154995453,
0.0143625336,
0.0084808394,
-0.0058117653,
0.0125367641,
0.0291034933,
0.0368217342,
0.0141543895,
-0.0086183464,
-0.0701485276,
0.0535078123,
-0.0511375889,
-0.0409145243,
-0.0029455381,
0.0091278572,
0.0287187807,
0.0672770143,
0.0353066884,
0.0031268359,
0.00342199,
-0.0769190937,
0.0578208528,
-0.0257212128,
0.0080382721,
0.0433897115,
0.0058815149,
0.0136475945,
-0.0069004479,
-0.0259917844,
0.0202167928,
0.0204868857,
-0.0152145773,
-0.0317342542,
0.0144295339,
-0.0183151029,
0.0160994884,
-0.0160763748,
-0.0071968758,
-0.025279209,
0.020160405,
-0.0617997386,
0.0772976056,
0.0455572754,
0.0239378717,
-0.0117801977,
0.0230871588,
-0.0143376049,
-0.0097492663,
-0.0221530907,
-0.0145291602,
-0.0523341149,
-0.0392701626,
0.0526267812,
0.0209080242,
0.060297817,
-0.0943864211,
-0.0154372146,
0.034622632,
0.009680884,
0.0247713365,
-0.0344386846,
0.011533658,
-0.035919521,
-0.0023945302,
0.0145107554,
0.025461942,
0.0804320127,
0.0365776047,
0.0132443197,
0.0395545848,
0.0078580696,
-0.0103631523,
0.0407219045,
-0.0153189152,
-0.0314184427,
0.0033400997,
-0.0175160691,
0.0354506001,
0.0435523912,
-0.00105782,
-0.0200705007,
0.00730624,
-0.0002652547,
-0.006985473,
-0.0353236906,
0.0018261505,
-0.0125572933,
0.0787122846,
-0.0063529625,
-0.0172775649,
0.0140103158,
0.0276074819,
0.0441117398,
0.0921230018,
0.0226943828,
-0.011513046,
0.0325546451,
-0.0301572774,
0.0163290612,
-0.0146546382,
-0.0054665143,
-0.0453949645,
-0.0037256093,
0.0308854952,
-0.0013327559,
-0.0404029787,
0.0277429093,
-0.0034409813,
0.0173563529,
-0.0370370373,
0.023902474,
-0.0470224619,
0.0224891808,
0.0539586097,
0.0250585359,
0.1013317183,
0.0810738504,
-0.0804564059,
-0.0449260883,
0.0206163339,
0.020413205,
0.0190809183,
0.0168628991,
-0.0504193455,
-0.0371432193,
-0.0476181619,
-0.019414356,
-0.0025714373,
-0.0175978057,
0.0549987108,
-0.0121031711,
0.0316391774,
0.0220267903,
-0.0292970836,
-0.0401818417,
0.0418758318,
-0.0606069788,
-0.0097209513,
0.0038395324,
0.0019162486,
0.0189944189,
0.0456652604,
0.0125656705,
0.0235309061,
0.0246737543,
-0.0144251008,
0.0240308959,
-0.006608679,
0.0142516391,
0.0403842926,
0.0377862714,
-0.0641140193,
0.0020598259,
0.0148340911,
-0.0149622476,
-0.0410838425,
0.0465365648,
-0.0088286502,
0.0057618083,
0.0221226849,
0.0331147388,
-0.0154245384,
-0.0516503677,
-0.0305430032,
0.0601849146,
0.005762062,
0.0511049405,
0.0485514142,
-0.0197181106,
0.0160889775,
-0.0035340269,
0.0244914126,
-0.019534694,
0.0216766931,
-0.0042004175,
0.0509370863,
-0.0171762872,
-0.0499126948,
-0.0061819414,
-0.075417608,
-0.0125628831,
-0.0140915168,
0.0220146514,
0.0440017432,
-0.0372266248,
-0.008433518,
0.0134946564,
-0.0081322389,
0.0177812874,
-0.0228039417,
-0.0238496512,
0.0103783309,
-0.0019101679,
0.0122453775,
-0.0310949422,
-0.0335166045,
-0.0540139861,
0.0341939963,
0.0730136335,
0.0494341888,
-0.0437853672,
0.0409299098,
0.0200602468,
-0.0055243121,
-0.0147881908,
0.0288551599,
0.0018947844,
-0.0249058809,
0.0855681375,
0.0223297272,
0.0405244119,
0.0438301042,
0.0440761484,
-0.017831713,
-0.0496504642,
-0.0207005013,
-0.0392694175,
0.063019596,
-0.0354781151,
-0.0785804763,
0.0070509375,
-0.0217975229,
0.0161979906,
-0.0173682086,
-0.0075855581,
-0.0352142118,
-0.0587463826,
-0.0143865831,
-0.0697397515,
-0.0356001668,
0.0095410394,
0.0262470283,
0.0281441417,
0.0243467353,
0.0300209615,
-0.0095293829,
0.0724027902,
-0.1190403625,
0.0093302745,
-0.0362134501,
0.0430860445,
0.0394122601,
-0.0122712469,
-0.0339497291,
-0.0134046935,
-0.0815395266,
0.0182476602,
0.0608270392,
-0.0184297729,
0.0353885815,
-0.0195118152,
-0.0468142889,
-0.023297146,
0.036799036,
-0.0454176702,
-0.0349979885,
0.0591247268,
-0.0180589929,
0.0592426807,
-0.0206095986,
-0.0460832603,
-0.0382646248,
0.0282908399,
0.0333927795,
-0.0164002813,
-0.0209879093,
0.0020429036,
0.0805788934,
0.0656324178,
-0.0536837354,
0.0102727888,
-0.0228987802,
0.0036541405,
0.0661290884,
0.0508850664,
-0.0396519564,
0.0186063796,
-0.0290132128,
0.0009981503,
-0.0892174169,
0.0085707335,
0.0065885545,
-0.0373369753,
-0.0135200284,
0.0193380248,
0.1069000289,
0.0595528074,
-0.1025558114,
-0.0239622034,
-0.0537620001,
-0.0078713624,
-0.0018412446,
0.0227114353,
-0.0403255001,
0.0583826751,
-0.0180620588,
0.0717392415,
-0.0294582881,
-0.0189647172,
0.0098983152,
-0.0449916869,
-0.0092972387,
0.0052615949,
0.0136639131,
0.003996308,
-0.0586428978,
-0.0204545353,
0.0127505595,
-0.0636518523,
0.0100869462,
-0.0302689523,
0.0167247504,
0.0432030745,
-0.0293441378,
-0.0188614409,
-0.0220774561,
0.0103002572,
-0.015220223,
0.0022501219,
0.0276418999,
-0.017450599,
0.014374922,
-0.0001908642,
-0.0191608593,
-0.0150573533,
0.0147421872,
0.0316721871,
-0.0136902705,
0.0586006343,
-0.0435907766,
0.0419395231,
-0.0045916205,
-0.0330828875,
0.0786286965,
0.0514863543,
0.0017163131,
-0.0135004772,
-0.1182528734,
0.0293720569,
0.015211286,
0.0295234118,
0.0298406687,
-0.0097533371,
0.0254414082,
-0.0318272673,
0.0758981258,
0.0051098089,
0.0025726201,
-0.032030046,
-0.0324130543,
-0.0778914765,
-0.0651550815,
-0.0498757474,
-0.0207716729,
0.0189223252,
0.0366945192,
0.0421201028,
0.0328494646,
-0.0563072339,
-0.0829081908,
-0.0159580968,
0.0394823812,
-0.0054109464,
-0.0552024655,
-0.0623231642,
0.0176846795,
-0.0308642983,
-0.0251895152,
0.0184862111,
-0.0539424941,
-0.0350915231,
-0.0047462662,
-0.0213620719,
0.0113121318,
0.0133797759,
-0.0171193294,
-0.0354390666,
0.0065209037,
0.0336686149,
-0.0409024023,
0.0078673493,
-0.0317240916,
-0.0136602512,
-0.0156766083,
-0.0345035754,
-0.0360525586,
0.023916997,
-0.0350851193,
-0.0068308208,
-0.0367818587,
-0.0064183525,
-0.0297927447,
0.0371145234,
0.0352002345,
-0.0220851265,
-0.023269156,
-0.0536065884,
0.0206913464,
-0.0239220113,
-0.0254019722,
0.0327509344,
0.022550635,
0.0254580621,
0.0128304167,
-0.040590778,
0.0283445101,
-0.0309852287,
0.0241430867,
-0.0141276242,
0.0114960279,
0.0029943474,
0.0365173258,
-0.0283807721,
-0.0044969008,
-0.0223520678,
-0.0215133298,
-0.0062799999,
0.0574106611,
0.0226682927,
0.0357593782,
0.035260722,
0.0011962401,
0.0167279411,
0.0339083336,
-0.091579482,
0.0057336204,
-0.0177209117,
-0.0144068357,
-0.0070392783,
-0.0064548971,
0.0479606502,
-0.0582037717,
0.0070891874,
0.0027625156,
0.0240324028,
0.0062888833,
-0.0033644305,
-0.0502914339,
0.027864702,
0.0252294578,
-0.0123144938,
0.0690219179,
0.0541821159,
-0.0440667719,
0.0112988129,
-0.0574763753,
0.0029948722,
-0.0049087126,
0.0261965059,
0.0643174052,
-0.0174660832,
-0.0019596815,
-0.0552849285,
-0.0111230742,
0.0254595932,
0.0133915609,
0.0002163204,
-0.0116292974,
0.0489865765,
0.073403731,
-0.0225206185,
0.0364504047,
-0.0506627485,
0.0431061536,
-0.0583915524,
-0.0799505338,
-0.0018641198,
-5.909396711e-33,
-0.0282993186,
-0.046109017,
0.0079204664,
0.066827558,
0.0200700127,
-0.0189144872,
-0.0193260554,
-0.0010019839,
0.0170045272,
0.0133642219,
-0.0189921819,
0.0308365561,
0.0018946946,
-0.0283151921,
0.0438170172,
0.0125006596,
0.010707099,
0.0052257809,
-0.0224834401,
0.0501647256,
0.0624554604,
-0.0194683056,
0.0238307044,
-0.0329182036,
0.0118150087,
-0.0457819477,
0.0466025285,
-0.0408692472,
0.0483276807,
0.0054730522,
-0.0153691173,
0.0060856347,
0.0293618552,
-0.0382306688,
-0.0108396132,
0.0137295425,
-0.0446287058,
-0.0770219415,
0.0401613377,
-0.0051549114,
0.0127654606,
-0.0592536926,
0.0201218836,
0.0232479479,
-0.0392200612,
-0.0443550572,
0.1044266671,
0.0338774659,
-0.0337548964,
-0.0745560378,
-0.0608387366,
0.0222315863,
-0.0583485737,
0.0209452771,
-0.0011616622,
0.0271995459,
0.0216011629,
-0.020964222,
-0.0112491995,
0.0842862874,
0.0092938673,
0.0380864777,
0.0086790184,
-0.0198457427,
-0.0040013529,
0.0531607121,
-0.0208821818,
0.0326050296,
-0.0203769952,
-0.0089499475,
0.0401448868,
-0.0079556871,
-0.0031253851,
0.0106144743,
0.0128204692,
-0.0104256496,
-0.027658375,
0.1314224452,
0.0265468601,
-0.0180887748,
0.0002493333,
-0.0445033908,
-0.0516710058,
-0.0385925546,
0.0001825799,
0.0401644148,
-0.000356093,
-0.0092565967,
-0.0103923799,
-0.0462317243,
-0.0880324244,
-0.0446168073,
0.0144907916,
-0.0314900465,
-0.0083699692,
0.0945978686,
-0.0435158163,
0.0610875078,
-0.02240487,
0.0041276836,
-0.070239462,
-0.0266932677,
0.0105576636,
-0.0016588198,
-0.0001367487,
-0.012762473,
-0.0120556755,
-0.0093974946,
-0.0039275689,
-0.029113302,
0.011104607,
-0.0196009055,
-0.0161768999,
-0.0132752229,
-0.0003086466,
0.0243299864,
0.0116157187,
0.0320386365,
0.0289254151,
0.0241948068,
-0.0190483313,
-0.0370997377,
0.0217548944,
-0.0082713868,
0.0066106902,
-0.030805856,
-0.0189481676,
-0.0013220861,
0.0402863584,
-0.0678239018,
-0.008626637,
-0.0030510514,
2.783e-7,
0.0453424752,
0.0376062728,
0.0037585872,
-0.0181393735,
0.042742528,
0.0073498008,
0.0015645687,
0.0027641905,
0.0122411437,
0.0203826856,
0.0344704837,
0.00100722,
0.0078816982,
0.0512149259,
-0.0718129203,
-0.0677745342,
-0.0128868772,
-0.0300407019,
-0.0588714518,
-0.0068846508,
0.0072639505,
0.0021704703,
0.0075309044,
-0.0121616712,
-0.0287261475,
0.0274070818,
-0.0143950684,
0.0143260788,
-0.017700417,
0.0152901514,
0.0313474238,
-0.0140755279,
0.0007003319,
-0.0177241564,
-0.0171149559,
0.0099380016,
0.0096365837,
-0.0088262763,
0.0078894105,
-0.0172203444,
-0.0140212476,
-0.0378146432,
-0.0072464873,
-0.0359774046,
0.009753285,
0.0263505373,
0.0116558522,
0.0289263446,
-0.0616333261,
0.0153966481,
-0.040421173,
0.0320747197,
0.0122658117,
0.0403786637,
-0.0457853489,
-0.0725712255,
0.0321925133,
-0.0147642018,
0.0252937526,
0.0459771343,
-0.0297460817,
-0.0322828814,
-0.0163433421,
0.0266263597,
0.020347828,
-0.0392572992,
0.0151276598,
2.35479666e-34,
0.0523562096,
0.0108431941,
-0.0346208066,
-0.036715433,
-0.0040209685,
-0.0120889954,
-0.0361182168,
0.0565502308,
0.0269530788,
-0.0656321868,
-0.0241354574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13105v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13105v1 | Perceptual Structure in the Absence of Grounding for LLMs: The Impact of Abstractedness and Subjectivity in Color Language | 2023-11-22T02:12:36 | 2023-11-22T02:12:36 | Pablo Loyola, Edison Marrese-Taylor, Andres Hoyos-Idobro | cs.CL | cs.CL | The need for grounding in language understanding is an active research topic.
Previous work has suggested that color perception and color language appear as
a suitable test bed to empirically study the problem, given its cognitive
significance and showing that there is considerable alignment between a defined
color space and the feature space defined by a language model. To further study
this issue, we collect a large scale source of colors and their descriptions,
containing almost a 1 million examples , and perform an empirical analysis to
compare two kinds of alignments: (i) inter-space, by learning a mapping between
embedding space and color space, and (ii) intra-space, by means of prompting
comparatives between color descriptions. Our results show that while color
space alignment holds for monolexemic, highly pragmatic color descriptions,
this alignment drops considerably in the presence of examples that exhibit
elements of real linguistic usage such as subjectivity and abstractedness,
suggesting that grounding may be required in such cases. | [
0.0161316507,
0.0379129946,
-0.0065610544,
0.0563822165,
-0.016871402,
0.0154114105,
-0.0521379672,
0.0231052302,
-0.0621588752,
-0.0776437297,
-0.0663357079,
-0.0589933358,
0.0391519405,
0.0038661235,
0.0358462185,
-0.0534086451,
-0.0011306308,
0.0426269993,
0.0001673479,
-0.0118222404,
0.013455567,
-0.016007483,
0.0010109677,
0.0109691471,
-0.0103679765,
-0.0030195627,
-0.025431376,
-0.0170399155,
-0.0193809979,
0.0158700664,
-0.0169603731,
0.0284672976,
0.0018937318,
0.0014426097,
0.000001748,
-0.0635324195,
0.0416850075,
-0.0580630079,
0.0352271907,
0.0056011262,
0.0331854075,
-0.0406916104,
-0.0014362904,
-0.0487248152,
-0.0438615978,
-0.0234222729,
0.1004587337,
0.0766670257,
0.0136057334,
0.0109481029,
0.0025369094,
-0.0138774673,
0.003416976,
0.0186434947,
0.0211812425,
0.0189663712,
0.0334615149,
0.0492772646,
-0.0099727111,
-0.0170205254,
-0.0731660724,
0.0118423756,
0.0181298535,
0.0176694673,
0.0125490911,
0.0196372401,
-0.0374075323,
0.009140525,
-0.0047863144,
0.0803892314,
-0.0191702656,
-0.0314439796,
-0.037709754,
0.0178988539,
-0.0378463641,
-0.0045544729,
0.0017380842,
0.0531763434,
-0.0065552569,
0.0474059992,
-0.0243432112,
-0.0084979795,
-0.0014554345,
0.0199376103,
-0.0145995924,
0.0728147924,
0.0010733699,
-0.0300239269,
0.0019499641,
0.0073784525,
0.0006385656,
-0.052449733,
-0.022085283,
-0.0207122993,
0.0473822616,
0.0145671219,
0.0009959001,
0.0173870493,
-0.0029620526,
-0.0678505674,
0.044447042,
0.0470688567,
-0.0372960605,
0.0382354371,
0.0146892779,
0.0504438579,
-0.0240821857,
0.0323252194,
-0.0613821186,
0.0190308392,
-0.0076287151,
-0.0434650183,
0.0102802133,
-0.003001997,
-0.0036150019,
-0.0161981117,
0.0054134526,
-0.0323222838,
-0.0390517823,
0.0000979163,
-0.0438282564,
0.0195761174,
-0.0206995234,
0.0125260074,
-0.0623266175,
-0.0479665063,
-0.0041073035,
0.0329737514,
-0.0593302064,
-0.0589398108,
0.0212372933,
0.0190781187,
-0.0443064831,
-0.0209218469,
-0.0323860422,
0.0719997585,
0.0195596088,
0.0039668404,
-0.0224276707,
-0.0254471302,
0.0345943049,
-0.0074658613,
0.0431018919,
-0.0527287684,
-0.0077456636,
0.0247373972,
0.0102346987,
-0.0475444384,
-0.0109838322,
-0.0067246365,
-0.023879718,
0.092268981,
-0.0478017181,
0.0052956995,
-0.0177625902,
0.0120123522,
0.0286064334,
0.0717355162,
0.0238758866,
0.0051691257,
0.0144521995,
-0.0507150032,
-0.0123457992,
0.0038875674,
-0.023757657,
-0.0249263067,
-0.0614987016,
-0.0362912528,
-0.0004888303,
0.045508191,
0.0994671658,
0.0394397005,
0.0027687016,
-0.0899460241,
0.0380323716,
0.0927796289,
-0.0166275073,
-0.0012466684,
0.0514798462,
0.001998167,
-0.0016519002,
0.0875834003,
-0.0437976234,
0.0124258492,
-0.0275124852,
0.0166198742,
-0.0449450798,
0.0313782319,
-0.0339917652,
-0.0055413698,
-0.0460617915,
-0.001808961,
0.0655599684,
-0.0237853546,
0.0020503467,
-0.006762973,
0.0131653566,
0.0719236434,
0.0518252738,
-0.0397327244,
-0.0218327586,
-0.0186757036,
0.0168426111,
0.0440661423,
-0.0496616736,
-0.0071276133,
0.0041875392,
0.0143226627,
0.0349886157,
0.0765197501,
-0.0015691208,
0.0097758118,
0.0302997865,
-0.0458770767,
-0.0219703913,
-0.0601170957,
0.0061844611,
0.0268662293,
-0.0287163444,
-0.0090383943,
-0.0028479262,
-0.0449984819,
-0.0153877549,
0.0242968556,
-0.0346607156,
-0.0407996103,
-0.0565132946,
0.0364502184,
0.0283464137,
-0.0081959153,
-0.0241856761,
0.020658534,
-0.0281762537,
-0.0206962153,
-0.0056487536,
0.0834416151,
-0.0569959059,
0.0177702252,
0.0563729554,
-0.0846011713,
0.0016256378,
0.0021892055,
0.0173104927,
-0.0096104797,
0.0356065594,
-0.033985164,
0.0610638484,
-0.0210783463,
0.0138352802,
-0.0267998092,
0.0145388413,
-0.0312458463,
0.0310277287,
-0.0214137025,
0.0248232875,
-0.0204212051,
-0.0292951036,
0.0239691362,
-0.0236372054,
0.0015893442,
0.027265586,
0.0293428469,
-0.0016060381,
-0.0247763023,
0.0081675639,
-0.0806336477,
0.0518038906,
-0.0378124006,
-0.0279630832,
0.006726882,
-0.0308753699,
0.0389296561,
-0.0303194318,
-0.010125638,
-0.0073082144,
-0.0116725499,
0.0230990145,
-0.0082870275,
0.0314357206,
0.0265624821,
0.0025320034,
-0.0571260862,
-0.0013664206,
-0.0243690945,
-0.0211413782,
0.0660899282,
-0.0333570577,
-0.0416837633,
-0.0549798086,
0.0671691373,
-0.0423661843,
0.0390993357,
0.0196433906,
-0.0561616793,
0.0158691257,
-0.014831271,
0.0211091451,
0.0426842123,
0.012305093,
0.061815232,
0.0940742865,
-0.0670548826,
-0.0285626333,
-0.0465220399,
-0.0162105002,
0.0240122378,
0.0400124379,
-0.0182437748,
0.0265020411,
0.1015172526,
0.0418207422,
0.0015522687,
-0.0592135563,
0.0545064732,
-0.0239803065,
-0.0386417583,
-0.0424627922,
-0.0322439,
-0.0044854563,
0.068193607,
-0.0680946112,
-0.0701772049,
0.0796877891,
-0.0077136904,
0.0130477892,
0.0142867938,
-0.0123082418,
-0.0308720022,
0.0516964681,
0.0108620776,
0.024777377,
-0.0025651236,
-0.0293865297,
-0.036511071,
-0.0146565372,
-0.0030524281,
-0.0003227945,
0.0952018946,
-0.0567074046,
-0.0097429082,
-0.0249227528,
-0.0155874426,
-0.0284469388,
-0.0040760781,
-0.045943182,
-0.0053413482,
-0.0273023099,
0.0169580504,
0.0115274033,
0.052763924,
-0.0132841207,
-0.0349799655,
0.0091917831,
0.0114452429,
0.0039529498,
0.0071889986,
-0.0037096741,
0.0241912436,
-0.0005875394,
-0.007407682,
0.0252346229,
0.0449198373,
-0.0420402363,
0.0507924855,
-0.0322591066,
0.0254922099,
0.0640255809,
0.0205847453,
-0.0459024459,
-0.0179962814,
0.050035648,
-0.0153211383,
0.0005780892,
0.0778825507,
0.0361240692,
-0.0431618951,
0.0279051755,
-0.0381468423,
-0.0114638796,
0.0071236216,
0.0032992393,
-0.0403682142,
0.0284062605,
-0.0203716718,
-0.0575129166,
0.0118628358,
-0.0405459441,
-0.0260731876,
-0.0812661648,
-0.0150729818,
0.0391437337,
-0.0423103794,
-0.0648091882,
0.028177036,
0.0444215834,
0.0647349805,
0.0574793257,
-0.0078266673,
-0.0003541874,
0.0064379582,
0.0203248616,
-0.0359857455,
-0.0502876677,
-0.0080035953,
-0.0137436828,
0.0046130694,
0.0342539325,
0.0159246475,
-0.0384138115,
-0.1083525643,
0.0386676043,
-0.0049588075,
0.0021844127,
-0.0115891006,
0.0162468664,
0.0177946799,
-0.0071115587,
-0.0109508522,
0.0222376399,
-0.000072902,
-0.0380897149,
-0.0224253573,
0.0173813943,
-0.041336745,
-0.0190444048,
-0.0184513144,
0.0080868388,
-0.0080365669,
0.0622808002,
0.0817044005,
-0.0435411669,
-0.0109326961,
-0.0550194308,
0.0537831821,
0.0553837903,
-0.0712689459,
0.0026623141,
-0.0352674052,
0.0198113173,
-0.0297484305,
0.0004550251,
0.0062244274,
0.0306334645,
0.0219577383,
-0.0426326655,
-0.0058106156,
-0.0678486824,
-0.0439441539,
0.0795208961,
-0.0007477034,
0.019505484,
-0.0065826471,
-0.0386065952,
0.0181305353,
-0.0350617543,
0.0111990683,
-0.0507024564,
-0.0065003787,
-0.0485577472,
0.0422102846,
-0.007881809,
0.0235175304,
0.0125925355,
0.0442590676,
-0.0504804179,
-0.0363805294,
0.00437462,
0.0329802409,
0.0629903674,
-0.0208031107,
0.0258279685,
0.0405637883,
0.0265555717,
-0.0076043634,
0.0318607464,
0.0577993318,
0.01940725,
0.0063374606,
-0.0035198128,
0.0417771675,
-0.0117545323,
0.0791107044,
0.0092547219,
0.0195892174,
-0.0008240128,
-0.0207762998,
-0.01228665,
-0.0370270945,
-0.0262097083,
-0.0344387777,
0.0054110861,
0.0220812336,
-0.023215929,
-0.0037152749,
-0.0206986144,
0.0419932455,
0.0302571319,
-0.0020953009,
0.0292403698,
-0.0317413472,
0.0039097802,
0.0488089323,
-0.0225164816,
0.0133521259,
-0.042399168,
0.015815258,
0.0331757553,
0.0314731933,
0.053536579,
-0.0159867946,
-0.0464279726,
0.0304281265,
-0.0014594381,
-0.0103216218,
0.0221084394,
0.0121374391,
0.0394445509,
-0.0971860513,
0.0167355649,
-0.0241014306,
-0.0193997864,
0.0029780986,
0.0111384885,
0.0428684428,
-0.0337833241,
0.0943048075,
0.0276485197,
-0.0280440748,
-0.0282992609,
0.0284930691,
-0.0093414923,
0.0109278727,
-0.0174390208,
-0.0185140427,
0.0063465214,
0.0419409424,
0.0277560893,
-0.0086314278,
0.0271409582,
0.0428648964,
-0.0729809478,
-0.0573442131,
0.0228123646,
0.016640665,
-0.0019021505,
0.0297539644,
0.0617213286,
0.0625940785,
0.0259537436,
-0.0001462572,
0.0255393982,
0.005082278,
-0.0324020833,
-0.0090242466,
-0.0120050581,
-5.583859347e-33,
-0.0403951369,
-0.063490063,
-0.0283611007,
0.0269625597,
-0.0383944623,
0.0313077904,
-0.0181615371,
0.0068880036,
-0.0113741541,
0.0386635847,
0.0207180046,
-0.0078273797,
0.0081588086,
-0.0029510146,
0.0336234085,
0.0027373112,
0.0094672265,
0.0220864248,
-0.0332306996,
-0.083609201,
0.0215801913,
-0.0068882192,
0.0612435006,
-0.0901987404,
-0.0319287963,
0.0423710831,
0.0108911926,
0.0411719568,
0.0372221507,
0.0434958711,
-0.0507233813,
0.0627788082,
0.0457445569,
0.0391773656,
-0.0178187583,
0.0440907888,
-0.0071827169,
-0.0686375573,
0.0441871099,
0.0307276919,
-0.0707490593,
-0.0023931249,
0.0341487341,
-0.0274164975,
-0.0406247415,
0.0120749408,
0.0368670374,
-0.0460613295,
0.0203591101,
0.0279098898,
-0.0536681935,
-0.0049535511,
0.0189111792,
0.0136581669,
0.0315985903,
-0.0773640051,
0.0030444262,
-0.0120192934,
-0.0573361553,
0.0370327532,
-0.0331381559,
0.0075971629,
0.0583316758,
0.0894616693,
0.052082628,
0.0760132447,
0.0504994728,
0.0346203335,
-0.0422909036,
0.0276449695,
0.0224573389,
-0.0153048392,
-0.0125169447,
0.0105858827,
0.0214109719,
0.0075861486,
0.0285738092,
-0.0279221628,
0.0177230407,
0.0507380851,
-0.016465243,
0.0316595733,
-0.0487096086,
-0.0329308547,
-0.0185897145,
-0.0070626782,
-0.0218602158,
-0.0492024049,
0.0215353463,
-0.0560942516,
0.0270357449,
-0.0234848708,
-0.0098473327,
-0.0353713781,
-0.0459066592,
-0.0013035702,
-0.0319238566,
0.0290697031,
0.0156386662,
-0.0010486764,
-0.0305265803,
-0.0012012944,
-0.0359486602,
0.020413097,
-0.0005568649,
0.022700835,
0.0100870607,
0.0208221544,
-0.0492502153,
0.0075495136,
-0.0156479999,
-0.061434269,
0.0275469124,
-0.0439047292,
0.0457928404,
0.0156278275,
-0.0267240424,
0.0346123241,
0.0243072417,
-0.0330450684,
-0.000906152,
-0.0356066376,
-0.039222043,
0.043166969,
-0.0481083728,
-0.0215104502,
-0.0080445465,
-0.0319625437,
0.0755997673,
-0.0232724622,
-0.0100778127,
-0.0319150053,
2.488e-7,
0.0409385674,
0.0046198582,
0.0357435346,
0.004231642,
0.014425681,
0.0015215507,
-0.0260562152,
0.0240324624,
0.0013894781,
-0.0797205418,
-0.0639757663,
0.0359556824,
0.0085341418,
0.0150556332,
-0.0468624271,
0.0386653058,
-0.0108589921,
0.0265472364,
-0.0297140963,
0.0048702806,
0.0423818305,
0.0395211689,
0.0222633462,
0.0113499118,
-0.0256462768,
-0.0278232917,
0.0404012464,
-0.0635817721,
0.0351757221,
-0.0030326995,
0.0194322858,
-0.0004853373,
0.0061235526,
0.0274215415,
0.0623717271,
0.0216259435,
0.010035878,
0.0024316441,
0.0104566356,
0.0119342832,
-0.0412969664,
-0.0334035978,
-0.0067597935,
-0.0121313492,
0.0185008794,
-0.0009153249,
-0.0720772371,
-0.0785688534,
0.0103542442,
-0.0000356809,
0.005751865,
-0.0054463819,
-0.0276171919,
-0.0076866741,
-0.0064836228,
-0.0286892466,
-0.0397624671,
-0.0735329911,
-0.0348039307,
0.0109133013,
0.0008447762,
-0.0299572442,
0.0277604852,
0.0336978175,
0.057244882,
-0.018822128,
-0.0282396246,
2.093447991e-34,
-0.0103786495,
-0.0032928807,
0.048157379,
0.0221449416,
-0.0255092215,
-0.0531399474,
0.0186223909,
0.0103653362,
0.0513846502,
-0.0249260124,
0.0115425047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13102v1 | Detecting out-of-distribution text using topological features of transformer-based language models | 2023-11-22T02:04:35 | 2023-11-22T02:04:35 | Andres Pollano, Anupam Chaudhuri, Anj Simmons | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, math.AT | We attempt to detect out-of-distribution (OOD) text samples though applying
Topological Data Analysis (TDA) to attention maps in transformer-based language
models. We evaluate our proposed TDA-based approach for out-of-distribution
detection on BERT, a transformer-based language model, and compare the to a
more traditional OOD approach based on BERT CLS embeddings. We found that our
TDA approach outperforms the CLS embedding approach at distinguishing
in-distribution data (politics and entertainment news articles from HuffPost)
from far out-of-domain samples (IMDB reviews), but its effectiveness
deteriorates with near out-of-domain (CNN/Dailymail) or same-domain (business
news articles from HuffPost) datasets. | [
0.0251188725,
0.0258006658,
-0.010912749,
0.0674667582,
-0.019252833,
0.0018625692,
-0.0475943647,
0.0257214978,
0.0039443374,
-0.037254326,
-0.0205081161,
-0.0201801248,
-0.0008836419,
0.042083744,
-0.0002991268,
-0.0185680185,
0.0131207565,
0.0140991742,
0.0062080454,
0.0032122056,
0.0062331003,
0.021931123,
0.0477592349,
0.0241805688,
0.0381034091,
-0.0322868004,
0.017057782,
0.0306967441,
0.046564348,
0.03022944,
0.0166817941,
0.021395186,
0.0026345337,
0.0429132693,
0.0000016327,
0.0035038337,
-0.018844666,
0.0076857312,
0.0544161014,
0.0082349712,
0.0404835232,
-0.0449036285,
-0.0367595553,
0.0169834774,
0.0076752896,
0.0301744435,
0.0443820097,
0.0384985618,
0.0340711698,
0.0615104772,
-0.0140018184,
0.0114944195,
0.0389431976,
-0.0025340782,
-0.016198488,
0.017768912,
0.034157671,
-0.0141168386,
0.0100566363,
0.0036465577,
-0.0415382423,
0.0290855393,
-0.003166928,
0.0002359774,
-0.0151782921,
0.0399615988,
-0.0298626143,
0.020965727,
0.0156926736,
0.0792814568,
-0.0662295744,
-0.0475395434,
0.0176073853,
0.0168546308,
0.0103601729,
0.0787483156,
-0.0289998557,
0.0240874328,
-0.0079292804,
0.0347089842,
-0.0078964327,
0.002361794,
0.000926108,
-0.0126335556,
-0.0671921074,
0.0470002741,
0.0044246279,
-0.0453386083,
-0.0460220166,
-0.0125154983,
-0.022810597,
-0.032556694,
0.0485497974,
-0.0103453724,
0.0748304874,
-0.0028003529,
-0.0510130264,
-0.0524520501,
0.0062260991,
-0.037702363,
0.0379203074,
-0.019054709,
-0.0637614876,
0.0554260835,
0.0183254927,
0.0339409746,
-0.0212712791,
0.077870056,
-0.0329041742,
0.0106290663,
0.0002197101,
0.0190198384,
-0.0145864347,
0.0177082103,
-0.0135732796,
-0.0534917861,
0.0250191167,
0.0273881424,
-0.0131696593,
-0.0314588398,
0.0089463955,
0.0048384243,
-0.0141022075,
-0.0134779597,
0.0125021273,
0.027174158,
0.0086375931,
-0.0167487115,
-0.051745709,
0.0000581252,
-0.0374760702,
0.0675415695,
0.0054712892,
-0.0144384308,
-0.0102886781,
0.0358992293,
0.0288048517,
-0.0398493186,
-0.0147570875,
0.0235267915,
-0.0501332954,
-0.0286320727,
0.0382622294,
-0.0620406419,
-0.0456145406,
0.028962696,
-0.0066561964,
-0.0185892172,
0.0055083395,
0.0504496284,
-0.0682361796,
-0.0063720499,
0.0216232929,
0.008490867,
0.0209414959,
-0.015398005,
0.0240164921,
0.0405874215,
-0.0027707587,
0.0177447293,
0.0282229409,
0.0160883963,
0.0407814346,
0.0480943285,
0.0070700995,
0.0532806106,
-0.0333536565,
0.0273317583,
-0.0258606225,
-0.0016129373,
0.0646740347,
0.03792689,
-0.0068946616,
-0.0533285141,
0.0737247244,
0.0406524353,
0.0290663354,
0.009918089,
-0.0249263737,
0.0521550365,
-0.0296509173,
0.0446354486,
-0.028680712,
0.0287956726,
-0.0043446124,
-0.0004953687,
0.0031538226,
0.0174562968,
-0.0167741068,
0.0055995611,
-0.0217042919,
-0.0129734296,
0.0355701596,
-0.0375004634,
0.0537472963,
0.0396377146,
-0.0530130789,
0.0750817135,
0.01314764,
-0.0070786565,
0.008397121,
-0.0188447461,
-0.0249438658,
0.0163767543,
0.0566989742,
-0.0459991507,
0.0038793874,
-0.0283469148,
0.0235066805,
0.0488989353,
-0.0568618253,
0.0167142302,
-0.0553991497,
-0.0324819759,
-0.0196031723,
-0.0278162044,
0.0240976904,
0.0003157056,
-0.0106248222,
0.0110512413,
-0.0136887524,
-0.1138675138,
-0.026760228,
0.0169488452,
0.0287544131,
0.027454121,
-0.0298986528,
0.0184034593,
0.005864298,
0.0180093199,
-0.0319635831,
-0.0055632438,
0.0372585207,
-0.0269697495,
-0.0046185222,
-0.016964931,
-0.0177840497,
-0.0199915282,
0.0202785321,
-0.0977469236,
-0.0106799686,
0.0644561276,
-0.0017755167,
0.0213899463,
0.0292884391,
-0.0963169634,
0.0463379361,
-0.049319528,
0.0023021891,
-0.0242886581,
0.0128362756,
-0.0310277212,
0.0800777972,
-0.0526092649,
0.040516261,
0.0320722833,
-0.0158106145,
0.0203324948,
-0.0086096348,
-0.0255020112,
-0.0083712172,
-0.019274395,
-0.000464823,
-0.0005369746,
-0.0190514419,
0.017269766,
-0.0434442759,
-0.0252320524,
-0.0466111042,
-0.0441015251,
0.0402448662,
0.0578628927,
-0.0180668235,
-0.0034244647,
-0.0060413135,
-0.0219805986,
-0.0572182052,
-0.0235433429,
0.0046120686,
0.0323376022,
-0.0326529108,
-0.0117320949,
0.0378737412,
-0.0093107289,
-0.0294602495,
0.0823791474,
-0.0080535617,
-0.0322358534,
-0.079899177,
0.0037593362,
0.0004726242,
-0.0008050033,
-0.0135222124,
-0.0357779339,
-0.0343135446,
0.0322542302,
0.0871810392,
0.0664312094,
0.0411089435,
0.0050352644,
0.0472046062,
0.000689315,
-0.0020841602,
-0.0339748114,
-0.0247995909,
0.0087036127,
0.0036219305,
-0.0078004664,
0.0498163439,
-0.0006180007,
0.0095182387,
0.0035582143,
-0.0258556809,
-0.0044313893,
-0.0286449455,
0.0684571415,
0.0204484127,
-0.0042859367,
-0.0405927971,
0.0351043716,
-0.0193319637,
-0.0028341673,
0.0650830045,
-0.016721189,
0.0155302379,
-0.0645407066,
0.024800783,
-0.0331298895,
-0.0122573012,
-0.013032889,
0.0466594473,
0.0087218871,
-0.0798307508,
-0.0301050469,
0.0278849527,
-0.008481089,
-0.0241450835,
0.0870636851,
0.0402280316,
-0.0092519084,
0.0195601117,
-0.0243700929,
-0.0259834044,
-0.0791295767,
0.0254121814,
-0.0292972699,
0.0039617904,
-0.043282602,
-0.0466311947,
0.0477494672,
-0.0121766487,
0.0354182571,
-0.0123427808,
0.0083090588,
0.004632757,
0.1036539823,
0.0471348651,
-0.015160013,
-0.0227659848,
-0.0108605288,
-0.07548251,
0.0244826227,
-0.038102515,
0.0212089103,
0.0259038731,
-0.0394513719,
0.0290821753,
-0.0099590989,
-0.0082612522,
-0.0105936108,
0.0175921731,
-0.016669061,
-0.0379590504,
0.070308961,
0.0315968245,
-0.0297058802,
-0.0016446927,
-0.0072321496,
0.0002518244,
0.0153306741,
0.0041613588,
-0.0744375214,
0.0092763146,
-0.003167998,
-0.0057476913,
0.0242168978,
0.0058615557,
0.0319897011,
-0.1179877147,
0.0393008031,
-0.0019993829,
-0.0189587921,
-0.1049904972,
-0.035757415,
0.0432374142,
0.0185838882,
-0.002853821,
-0.0105391741,
-0.0120450836,
-0.0145564387,
-0.0019753957,
-0.0340277925,
-0.0640328377,
0.020009838,
-0.0165366884,
0.0112862196,
0.015983833,
0.0471330211,
-0.0258921757,
-0.0836632252,
0.003285971,
-0.0208751988,
-0.0112499837,
0.0175292231,
0.0663253963,
-0.0105101764,
-0.0058148857,
-0.0425089002,
0.0397176966,
-0.0088934116,
0.0047317673,
-0.0505041108,
0.1092162579,
-0.0129594719,
-0.0316396691,
-0.0494130552,
0.0480812527,
0.0425846092,
0.0591997392,
0.0333642326,
-0.049787011,
-0.0182359666,
-0.0501064099,
0.0040694969,
0.0181511063,
-0.0073435889,
0.0421309546,
0.0058987001,
-0.1185829639,
-0.0764981806,
-0.006843999,
-0.0450987667,
0.0092942473,
0.0245664138,
-0.0528101027,
0.0130015798,
-0.0182243008,
-0.0535692535,
0.0001496212,
-0.0274244547,
0.0028343746,
-0.0212732758,
0.0250411537,
0.0322615542,
-0.0000461571,
-0.0520136096,
0.0114023862,
-0.0767807364,
-0.0337540954,
0.0344645306,
-0.018159641,
0.010693958,
0.0087852357,
-0.0560365468,
0.0026521797,
0.0753893629,
0.0420619994,
-0.0309903808,
-0.0016364148,
0.027827289,
-0.0353558846,
0.016529059,
0.0505825803,
-0.0353740826,
0.0302323643,
0.0208363719,
-0.0250791516,
-0.0706467405,
-0.0099725248,
-0.0209050216,
-0.0354787037,
0.0606103837,
0.010257923,
-0.0296192002,
-0.0303249247,
0.0079063941,
0.0019621735,
-0.0157507434,
-0.0065984935,
0.0183977205,
0.0455113016,
-0.0107327756,
-0.0406429991,
0.0618123747,
-0.0479625762,
0.0139422473,
-0.0358028226,
0.0637441352,
0.0407306552,
0.0053830883,
0.0183713865,
0.0087026609,
-0.0336609185,
-0.017220879,
-0.0186724383,
0.0282008052,
0.007399024,
0.0367882922,
0.0338784046,
-0.0231726319,
0.0152905164,
0.0099957697,
-0.0480502918,
0.0729044303,
-0.0408085957,
0.0183868911,
0.0204795729,
-0.035082005,
0.0184047166,
0.0063312948,
-0.0234043542,
-0.0083504561,
0.0083927903,
0.0051584467,
-0.0516532734,
-0.0015794934,
-0.0005475245,
-0.0176233388,
0.0098215304,
0.0687987059,
0.0119036399,
-0.0253176298,
0.031500306,
-0.040369682,
-0.0236874968,
0.0387556702,
0.0004143059,
0.0308284536,
-0.0006026079,
0.0266905464,
-0.0522210896,
-0.0517134555,
0.0711710379,
-0.0149843572,
0.0056659239,
-0.0038458826,
0.0184003487,
0.0676494539,
0.0046831681,
0.0145356543,
-0.0348310471,
0.0139758503,
0.0169236604,
-0.0480309464,
-0.0368235484,
-5.982153567e-33,
0.019265281,
-0.0605748966,
-0.0620942749,
0.0109066423,
0.0018444095,
0.0081787976,
-0.0217271633,
-0.019358743,
-0.0320484117,
0.0094090924,
0.0020836587,
0.0424585417,
0.0064385007,
0.024971243,
-0.0228809547,
-0.0337190852,
0.0041409093,
0.0198513903,
-0.0394786894,
0.0257430524,
0.0339183286,
0.0406598188,
0.0660985708,
-0.0580178685,
0.0058550667,
-0.0388657711,
0.0037736571,
-0.0130760679,
0.0650161803,
0.0425026789,
-0.0050527998,
0.0505303591,
0.017823318,
-0.0512870215,
-0.0019052199,
0.0427242555,
-0.0462877192,
-0.0037635611,
0.0114623923,
0.0151244337,
0.0482562855,
-0.0047149332,
0.0502012894,
0.0014079437,
0.0119854165,
-0.0606394522,
0.0778900683,
-0.0253521167,
-0.004737718,
0.0071688816,
-0.0435338803,
0.0352910906,
-0.0132037615,
-0.0344254151,
0.0149688972,
0.0131082349,
0.0421144068,
0.0441166647,
-0.0742176026,
0.0134333568,
-0.0176808052,
0.0256949998,
0.0306919292,
0.0003569823,
-0.0147010069,
0.0532118231,
-0.0824193358,
0.031104736,
-0.0470756479,
-0.0278006345,
0.0619132668,
0.0173002686,
0.0240295585,
0.00244362,
0.0004696301,
-0.0078388071,
-0.0819239169,
0.0154453423,
-0.0306441728,
-0.0193291791,
0.0433561392,
-0.0002372076,
-0.0347106494,
-0.0208871271,
0.0306950174,
-0.0508967116,
-0.017621262,
-0.0055595455,
-0.0150521044,
-0.013414314,
-0.0188070647,
0.0395762511,
0.0122189429,
-0.0569134131,
-0.0060551963,
0.0249886848,
-0.0283934511,
0.0181607753,
-0.0103140501,
0.0225148816,
-0.0382501297,
-0.0006095395,
0.006075142,
0.0553742461,
-0.0111248111,
-0.0142663857,
0.0810158923,
0.0335914269,
-0.0916874632,
-0.0204482656,
-0.0056259353,
-0.0096408417,
-0.0416974574,
0.0862260833,
0.0284125675,
-0.0110323243,
0.0017484247,
0.0341266543,
0.0134802451,
0.0459267758,
-0.0283088032,
0.0432548001,
-0.0395143777,
0.0169669129,
-0.0418595858,
-0.0200909507,
0.0073915008,
0.0484431796,
0.0170699786,
-0.0727248192,
-0.0106252125,
-0.0004374737,
2.477e-7,
0.0764811411,
0.0643025413,
0.0307880063,
0.0135404952,
0.0220437348,
-0.0056816665,
0.0141131449,
0.0619767942,
-0.0046010884,
-0.0393380895,
0.0121770324,
-0.0142399631,
0.0038119915,
0.0046391366,
-0.1245412827,
0.0330584459,
-0.1103163585,
-0.0111316852,
-0.0289559457,
-0.0218501594,
-0.0044514309,
0.0879961774,
0.0190394241,
-0.0055267108,
0.018710006,
-0.0534970723,
0.0334511586,
0.0006964743,
0.0047967802,
-0.0144384746,
0.02627833,
-0.0313709341,
0.0335449465,
-0.0017222087,
-0.0113719748,
0.0326628424,
0.0512824394,
0.0441203788,
-0.0119898887,
-0.0398149118,
-0.0257022865,
-0.0140541913,
-0.0409621559,
-0.0872273743,
0.0572328344,
-0.0423018262,
-0.0406258442,
-0.0304897428,
-0.0433402918,
0.0010050961,
0.0190957561,
-0.0141900769,
-0.0298545808,
0.0230432153,
0.0354825705,
-0.0196460467,
0.0532148182,
-0.0605495758,
-0.0198774822,
0.0355047546,
-0.0660429224,
-0.0050939964,
-0.0168831758,
-0.0423264727,
0.0483004563,
-0.0331009142,
0.0117545919,
2.485538265e-34,
0.0584071353,
-0.0063509159,
-0.0229954757,
-0.0305996146,
0.0015454002,
-0.0138186188,
0.0673844442,
-0.0253770053,
0.0080327466,
-0.0562466793,
0.0101715801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13095v1 | Enhancing Logical Reasoning in Large Language Models to Facilitate Legal Applications | 2023-11-22T01:51:50 | 2023-11-22T01:51:50 | Ha-Thanh Nguyen, Wachara Fungwacharakorn, Ken Satoh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language serves as a vehicle for conveying thought, enabling communication
among individuals. The ability to distinguish between diverse concepts,
identify fairness and injustice, and comprehend a range of legal notions
fundamentally relies on logical reasoning. Large Language Models (LLMs) attempt
to emulate human language understanding and generation, but their competency in
logical reasoning remains limited. This paper seeks to address the
philosophical question: How can we effectively teach logical reasoning to LLMs
while maintaining a deep understanding of the intricate relationship between
language and logic? By focusing on bolstering LLMs' capabilities in logical
reasoning, we aim to expand their applicability in law and other
logic-intensive disciplines. To this end, we propose a Reinforcement Learning
from Logical Feedback (RLLF) approach, which serves as a potential framework
for refining LLMs' reasoning capacities. Through RLLF and a revised evaluation
methodology, we explore new avenues for research in this domain and contribute
to the development of LLMs capable of handling complex legal reasoning tasks
while acknowledging the fundamental connection between language and logic. | [
0.0768015534,
0.0577200949,
-0.0153959356,
0.0292169154,
-0.083290875,
0.0133578181,
0.0134415263,
0.0102466345,
0.0317334011,
-0.0537580326,
0.0189632252,
0.0121201575,
-0.0404127054,
-0.0079671014,
0.0235920623,
-0.0496647768,
0.0421121418,
-0.0258703679,
0.0848982558,
-0.0242706649,
0.0036657962,
0.0205503721,
0.0034513297,
-0.0049749995,
-0.0282408949,
0.0093619479,
-0.008781258,
-0.0117821842,
0.0036015934,
-0.0146918232,
-0.0351813063,
0.0300574973,
0.0485022105,
0.0576125793,
0.0000019833,
-0.0882853195,
0.0330292471,
-0.0050524562,
0.0054544793,
-0.0142713888,
0.0368097052,
-0.0411424078,
-0.0121357478,
0.0109297261,
-0.0331642926,
0.0486871153,
-0.0048376243,
0.0365108959,
0.0341362134,
0.0769740492,
0.0261213314,
-0.0558437854,
0.0162837449,
-0.0398317985,
0.0424037203,
-0.031776689,
0.0262063947,
0.0756983459,
0.0642377958,
-0.048692435,
-0.0020777818,
0.0004389833,
0.0574596822,
-0.0366030559,
-0.0307135805,
0.0187048949,
-0.0309490599,
-0.0012352356,
0.0091974232,
0.0341189057,
0.0527149513,
-0.0097220447,
-0.0154145882,
0.0151675623,
0.0489907861,
0.0179391541,
-0.0266780518,
0.1036719531,
-0.0179242156,
0.022259973,
0.0400992036,
-0.0093562668,
0.0241934545,
0.0529841557,
-0.0402032398,
0.1063486859,
-0.0168371294,
-0.0284552164,
0.0273834802,
0.029513441,
0.0006108352,
-0.036066398,
0.000516527,
0.0666458309,
-0.0565347038,
0.0501013212,
-0.0093598664,
-0.0040444774,
0.0592070296,
-0.0555739217,
0.0252322834,
0.0098260622,
0.0180344824,
0.0476233773,
-0.0604907461,
0.0024720621,
-0.0063861799,
0.0986219272,
0.0078772847,
-0.0111427624,
-0.0415210575,
-0.0292032938,
0.0024854024,
0.0532745272,
-0.0339679271,
0.0353089608,
-0.0042686975,
-0.0011736364,
-0.0551787727,
0.0491221361,
-0.0247454047,
-0.0123842657,
-0.0058063734,
-0.0584639795,
-0.0960353836,
-0.026026208,
-0.0396745428,
0.0425614603,
0.0152484765,
-0.010940602,
-0.0064106048,
-0.0259176288,
-0.0416671112,
-0.0011861394,
0.0248325951,
0.0891350731,
-0.0005748984,
0.0067257276,
-0.0692394897,
-0.0532973967,
-0.0100789787,
-0.0774120092,
-0.0130567905,
-0.0696103498,
-0.0227032881,
-0.0203228574,
-0.0099463193,
-0.0181212071,
0.0346600749,
0.0169902835,
-0.0088537643,
0.0655227005,
-0.0042324741,
-0.0164821204,
-0.0159752667,
0.0117516285,
0.0307978075,
0.037682578,
0.013714144,
0.0064450516,
-0.021734301,
0.0144805843,
-0.0181634799,
-0.0272898413,
0.0032283103,
0.0147770178,
-0.0668853447,
0.0068745869,
-0.0329461731,
0.0419336408,
0.0013814491,
0.039150171,
-0.0251559708,
0.0238406286,
0.0193815231,
0.051167164,
0.0119265178,
0.027440941,
0.0275654048,
-0.0285427254,
-0.0251616221,
-0.0194367617,
-0.0531181209,
0.0412823781,
-0.0057151513,
0.0036385683,
-0.0513030924,
0.0189320501,
-0.006204749,
-0.0515946299,
0.0170322284,
0.0174968373,
0.0276627708,
0.0369457118,
0.0333830677,
0.0311834477,
0.027458977,
0.0332641639,
0.048839312,
-0.0475648381,
0.0123242699,
-0.0574302226,
0.0415609814,
0.0455301031,
0.0420695394,
-0.0237037521,
-0.0059108851,
-0.0483797677,
-0.0086131059,
0.0629691333,
0.0280841868,
-0.0037683966,
-0.0438323431,
-0.0184041075,
-0.0203685574,
-0.0146359494,
0.0222440567,
0.0382553376,
-0.0100191487,
-0.0095206406,
0.017353002,
-0.0122707887,
0.0132305687,
0.032864511,
-0.0114626978,
-0.0119933169,
-0.0053457231,
-0.010297277,
0.0236927234,
0.0061601577,
-0.0023661354,
0.0119524039,
0.0197677836,
-0.0042523989,
-0.0303420853,
0.0274397545,
-0.0145438584,
0.0021140894,
0.0684024021,
-0.0418087095,
-0.0089584338,
-0.0079507586,
-0.0650851354,
0.0127669256,
0.046388384,
-0.0336126313,
0.0029314423,
-0.0386900231,
-0.0362123363,
-0.0181305632,
-0.0777346119,
-0.0313520394,
0.0668681115,
0.0101282205,
-0.0123381307,
-0.0078234179,
0.0213125963,
0.0370404609,
-0.0458014607,
0.0396909453,
-0.0000949054,
-0.0096152211,
0.0125271175,
0.0243709441,
0.0421388783,
-0.0329598971,
-0.046561785,
-0.0052786614,
-0.0104380827,
-0.0141912745,
-0.00860334,
-0.0125691062,
-0.036767859,
0.0065878076,
-0.0162767861,
-0.0211135112,
-0.0166549031,
0.0435357504,
-0.024674315,
0.0108767776,
-0.0155590605,
-0.0398886651,
0.0219835788,
-0.0069170897,
-0.0224911757,
0.0119479317,
0.0590902902,
0.0359834917,
-0.0417788103,
-0.0095965676,
-0.0466177724,
-0.0071712565,
0.0005258947,
0.0002170443,
-0.0012264958,
0.0027405024,
-0.0511278473,
0.0640300512,
0.0412250087,
0.0364578702,
0.0432460979,
-0.0206193496,
-0.0521297753,
0.0153019,
-0.0334492177,
-0.0008131147,
-0.0742605999,
-0.0202913657,
-0.0168005954,
0.0033883236,
-0.0232940596,
0.0054472075,
-0.039369192,
0.05811188,
-0.0060824631,
-0.0303247999,
-0.0178961921,
-0.0290963389,
-0.0121218925,
0.0504141971,
-0.0123852137,
-0.0594211332,
0.0825858042,
0.0616713911,
0.0520305969,
-0.0752246156,
0.006284805,
-0.0579383932,
0.0671731979,
-0.0145623153,
0.0033012219,
-0.0227825642,
-0.0411325544,
-0.0089012589,
-0.0376593955,
0.0854645371,
-0.0338521004,
0.0733873472,
-0.0625081137,
0.0136398831,
0.0015825827,
-0.0422514305,
-0.0509310924,
0.0122374101,
-0.0530960076,
0.0272453576,
-0.0433639176,
0.0155788921,
-0.031225048,
-0.0329327434,
0.0316303708,
-0.0614423268,
0.0181449894,
-0.0247468408,
-0.0390438139,
-0.0373250917,
-0.0047940449,
-0.0059079751,
0.0074039679,
-0.0380271599,
0.0077846786,
0.0019529818,
-0.0190122314,
-0.0102541726,
0.0202567261,
0.0504801907,
-0.0023314094,
-0.0165891331,
0.0287333075,
0.0490486808,
0.0051761256,
-0.036394354,
-0.0054420345,
0.103931509,
0.0319940634,
0.0234894231,
-0.0035304825,
-0.0573237762,
0.0281907935,
0.03757862,
0.0434728228,
-0.1088154614,
-0.0002951926,
0.0027874163,
-0.0079709059,
-0.0367008559,
-0.0383770168,
0.0057985261,
-0.1254333407,
0.0738228485,
0.0409531221,
0.0025622458,
-0.0573766157,
-0.0137712257,
-0.0090497481,
-0.0061465572,
-0.0002592851,
0.0186293293,
-0.009386884,
-0.0158750582,
0.0382836796,
0.0300705936,
0.0328868553,
0.0151015976,
-0.0482290946,
0.0395403355,
0.0548515618,
0.0416337438,
-0.0269728396,
-0.0604793467,
-0.0468271784,
0.0409030616,
-0.0057475208,
-0.0074460669,
-0.0126604382,
0.0181409977,
0.0112412339,
-0.0656674355,
0.0482543483,
0.0153527865,
-0.0499447323,
0.0361957066,
0.0793363079,
-0.03715856,
-0.0318393782,
-0.0360158458,
0.0268840529,
-0.0345700681,
0.0370899066,
0.0038663642,
0.0116778864,
-0.0475399271,
-0.0654910505,
-0.0670435205,
-0.0533218421,
-0.0300641898,
0.0107917376,
0.0132698435,
-0.0056835278,
-0.0240839981,
0.0049275309,
0.0063206465,
-0.0039526452,
0.0126950862,
-0.0239015054,
0.02663715,
-0.0025848905,
-0.0338460319,
0.009305222,
-0.0547857136,
0.0185654648,
0.0023094323,
0.033187788,
-0.0498869941,
-0.0466297679,
-0.0230074767,
-0.0037012412,
-0.0032505088,
-0.0324378684,
-0.0191504955,
0.0180528816,
0.0189402662,
0.0124289254,
-0.0183902308,
-0.0362667106,
0.029133467,
0.0344872586,
0.0076349122,
0.0058823917,
0.0569620505,
-0.0243416335,
0.0247646179,
0.0181551613,
-0.0043680868,
0.0268355645,
0.0297718197,
0.0419644564,
-0.0119329952,
-0.0232889298,
0.0656314865,
0.047115095,
-0.0274848342,
0.0223633368,
-0.0333220847,
-0.0212291963,
-0.018983962,
-0.0319588371,
-0.0341978334,
-0.003822566,
0.0022924256,
0.0085200351,
0.0031072162,
-0.0174513701,
-0.0255352985,
-0.0148986541,
0.0345436893,
0.0223047007,
0.0394524895,
0.0144094499,
0.0037296887,
0.0045523671,
-0.0406098105,
0.0261644144,
-0.0027759238,
-0.0374913886,
0.0646132231,
-0.0075911293,
0.0845833346,
0.0513095371,
-0.0176551193,
-0.0360600986,
-0.0516499653,
-0.0509002469,
-0.0485767573,
0.0522027761,
0.0204621628,
0.0480128825,
0.0283205304,
-0.0132241528,
-0.0622930266,
-0.0040683392,
0.0346282758,
0.0355956368,
0.0064304844,
-0.0523535162,
0.0421421714,
0.0268162638,
-0.0123788835,
-0.0317669325,
-0.0076542106,
-0.0370113328,
0.0187591054,
-0.0392436385,
-0.0029832781,
-0.0221125223,
-0.0637657642,
-0.0048103579,
0.0032440764,
-0.0145673091,
0.0117464652,
-0.0966135487,
-0.0519703105,
-0.0224448889,
0.0567415468,
0.0107991276,
-0.0023211092,
0.0116279349,
0.0549376793,
0.0199515671,
-0.0532615595,
-0.051041916,
0.0428664349,
-0.0050528115,
-0.0183349103,
-0.003439167,
-5.188050562e-33,
-0.0345167294,
-0.0411803015,
0.0337726846,
0.0074460013,
-0.0342890136,
-0.0721346736,
-0.0251318924,
-0.0049052653,
-0.0048260149,
0.063912943,
0.0172852166,
0.0237856861,
0.0037448821,
-0.0099909836,
0.0266237073,
-0.0156185692,
-0.0075003076,
0.021599805,
0.0068262336,
0.0135330856,
-0.01748145,
-0.0155136166,
0.0073411949,
-0.0488373376,
0.0170829594,
0.0652165264,
-0.0238767043,
0.0105082495,
-0.1354654878,
0.0278464947,
0.0119740814,
0.0352423675,
-0.0068723038,
-0.038962245,
0.0045582294,
0.0708059445,
-0.0530657396,
0.0082407864,
0.0441297665,
-0.026412705,
-0.0268629864,
-0.0400389992,
0.0240422487,
0.022538973,
-0.0175332967,
-0.0055500367,
0.0385439917,
-0.0526840799,
-0.0070980475,
-0.0238375887,
-0.0853736848,
0.0320201553,
-0.0337762237,
0.0046451744,
-0.0023270638,
-0.0070156413,
-0.0251410231,
0.0115272971,
-0.0178491194,
0.0406692885,
0.0174811576,
-0.0529583618,
0.0516139083,
-0.0069163595,
-0.0061276909,
0.0612245761,
-0.0149533954,
0.0032713576,
-0.053167522,
0.0286620874,
0.0238279384,
0.0877930075,
0.0498745143,
0.045003742,
-0.0043533947,
0.0030726944,
-0.098112531,
-0.0542018376,
0.0170170628,
0.0561441071,
0.0465693846,
-0.0197317116,
-0.0317339487,
0.0029264386,
-0.0405554585,
0.01013132,
-0.0203924421,
-0.0156129878,
0.0071331714,
0.0204800144,
0.0002279051,
-0.0286064837,
-0.0316416211,
-0.039854072,
-0.0244415067,
0.0175878033,
0.0150391795,
-0.010770998,
-0.0304671731,
0.012206519,
-0.0375813805,
-0.0316678211,
0.0189097617,
-0.030661393,
0.0105060721,
-0.011219522,
0.0521877669,
0.0012721785,
-0.0127308704,
-0.0104306787,
-0.0324219204,
0.0446964093,
0.0247995276,
0.0142605556,
0.006001988,
0.0506097265,
0.0103165098,
0.0059609725,
0.0182762295,
-0.0790642276,
-0.0172866248,
0.0187741332,
-0.0107127409,
-0.0020392812,
-0.0320800506,
-0.0042723627,
-0.0392329767,
0.0309185181,
0.0237271208,
-0.0253053419,
-0.002452434,
0.0365117751,
2.699e-7,
0.0441826619,
0.0392544307,
0.0010781167,
0.0630945638,
-0.0017092095,
0.0496408567,
-0.0074475156,
0.0260405373,
0.0528350137,
-0.0187656134,
0.0056440765,
0.0473324433,
0.0406441242,
0.0327976122,
-0.0274211001,
0.0065419432,
-0.0452735648,
-0.0767327026,
-0.0414136648,
0.0354473479,
0.0866442844,
0.0423917547,
0.0495603308,
-0.0329857543,
0.0293049999,
-0.034934435,
0.0425368957,
-0.0123377992,
-0.0070900111,
-0.0205626935,
0.0550602749,
-0.0428666845,
0.0204832722,
0.0401029401,
0.0288937781,
0.0095336614,
-0.0718918368,
0.0307300743,
-0.0081587713,
0.0292198397,
-0.0597686432,
-0.0295546409,
0.0166373998,
-0.0406981669,
0.0330523141,
-0.0453844517,
-0.0161237419,
0.011885345,
0.0032255489,
-0.0439863652,
-0.0087758526,
0.0026754329,
-0.0290132165,
-0.0162358154,
0.0388726182,
-0.0035228396,
0.0421798825,
-0.0650048554,
-0.004678729,
0.0488739759,
-0.0234003831,
-0.0023512985,
-0.0044061984,
0.035352923,
0.0243691728,
-0.0476544872,
0.0183153227,
2.255129892e-34,
0.0142036332,
-0.015285858,
0.0106308842,
0.0235750582,
0.0558367111,
0.0587276258,
-0.0476192832,
0.016165873,
0.0236376338,
-0.040271569,
0.0063860971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14737v1 | Positional Description Matters for Transformers Arithmetic | 2023-11-22T00:31:01 | 2023-11-22T00:31:01 | Ruoqi Shen, Sébastien Bubeck, Ronen Eldan, Yin Tat Lee, Yuanzhi Li, Yi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformers, central to the successes in modern Natural Language Processing,
often falter on arithmetic tasks despite their vast capabilities --which
paradoxically include remarkable coding abilities. We observe that a crucial
challenge is their naive reliance on positional information to solve arithmetic
problems with a small number of digits, leading to poor performance on larger
numbers. Herein, we delve deeper into the role of positional encoding, and
propose several ways to fix the issue, either by modifying the positional
encoding directly, or by modifying the representation of the arithmetic task to
leverage standard positional encoding differently. We investigate the value of
these modifications for three tasks: (i) classical multiplication, (ii) length
extrapolation in addition, and (iii) addition in natural language context. For
(i) we train a small model on a small dataset (100M parameters and 300k
samples) with remarkable aptitude in (direct, no scratchpad) 15 digits
multiplication and essentially perfect up to 12 digits, while usual training in
this context would give a model failing at 4 digits multiplication. In the
experiments on addition, we use a mere 120k samples to demonstrate: for (ii)
extrapolation from 10 digits to testing on 12 digits numbers while usual
training would have no extrapolation, and for (iii) almost perfect accuracy up
to 5 digits while usual training would be correct only up to 3 digits (which is
essentially memorization with a training set of 120k samples). | [
0.0154282134,
0.088831313,
-0.0009393498,
0.0038828694,
0.004064688,
0.0163661502,
0.0007347737,
-0.0180996675,
-0.1141482517,
-0.0460749008,
-0.032525029,
-0.054183621,
0.0645870119,
-0.0152836926,
0.0439133681,
-0.0372489356,
0.0447760969,
-0.0140802991,
-0.0153506473,
0.0119495224,
-0.0187892113,
-0.0296480991,
-0.0565733388,
0.0182324946,
-0.0234820619,
-0.018103946,
0.004492694,
-0.0992670134,
0.0089817625,
-0.0040046447,
-0.0083231609,
0.0036359341,
0.0408253819,
0.0702626035,
0.0000019125,
-0.0540016554,
0.0022096152,
0.0073489691,
-0.0592098534,
0.024640521,
0.0124944933,
-0.0447833315,
-0.0241384041,
0.0171937887,
-0.0424142107,
-0.0206201728,
0.0706429407,
0.0603370368,
0.0339159146,
0.0771471038,
-0.0057839598,
-0.0331000127,
0.0296897013,
-0.0182630643,
0.0600921884,
0.0196010172,
-0.0160327852,
0.0041620177,
0.0172001924,
0.028470397,
-0.0250565466,
-0.023739323,
0.0528414324,
0.0321672745,
-0.0193619151,
0.0476194285,
-0.0131312152,
0.0004321196,
-0.0188548975,
0.0271422639,
-0.0366661623,
-0.010417561,
-0.0110051855,
0.0051984368,
-0.0161548313,
-0.0612052269,
-0.0608166605,
0.0339184143,
0.0263469033,
-0.0062399423,
-0.0377147049,
0.0121128568,
0.0191954356,
-0.004972782,
-0.0113914572,
0.0667292476,
-0.0099342009,
-0.0202720612,
-0.0337463431,
-0.0194667149,
-0.0402898155,
-0.0215994045,
0.0114620067,
0.0499255434,
0.0265154615,
0.0052761529,
-0.0031952348,
-0.0535102338,
0.0212525316,
-0.0377309285,
0.0529524013,
0.0887913257,
-0.0159981679,
-0.003001279,
-0.071567677,
0.0972668082,
-0.0349983312,
0.0629236475,
-0.002028448,
0.0633611977,
0.0148809729,
-0.0424409546,
-0.0278548319,
0.0159410462,
-0.0300748702,
0.0010736935,
-0.0489163101,
0.0388962924,
0.0094677238,
0.0117605748,
0.0188287366,
0.0235437229,
-0.0023721512,
0.0000013851,
-0.0337454006,
0.0456820391,
-0.0413102768,
0.0420317836,
0.0017624937,
-0.0358380154,
-0.0359919965,
-0.0169952158,
0.0037087693,
-0.0129604749,
0.0336696468,
0.0822185501,
-0.0120427534,
-0.0068981219,
0.0006231418,
-0.0100255944,
-0.0045677368,
-0.0386012308,
0.025418222,
-0.0584131218,
-0.001628436,
0.0430037081,
-0.0060880077,
-0.0084093325,
0.041080147,
0.0493547693,
0.014237904,
0.0743015632,
0.0135160666,
-0.0046560545,
-0.0031727236,
-0.0193801653,
-0.0129729528,
0.0384616144,
0.0729846284,
-0.0096848728,
-0.0036546551,
-0.0128799789,
0.0138433846,
0.0424072854,
-0.0038167448,
-0.0313486271,
0.0067878757,
-0.0281816367,
-0.022271676,
0.0405187644,
0.0528522246,
0.0405174941,
-0.0586220436,
-0.0318491273,
0.0452777408,
0.0573616475,
0.0038564897,
0.0567806922,
0.0123719601,
-0.0257525556,
0.0293998662,
-0.0094652055,
-0.0762900263,
0.0397275463,
0.0042009037,
0.0347941518,
0.0127287181,
0.0217582788,
0.0006989413,
-0.0563852154,
-0.0215981379,
-0.0184201039,
0.0630361587,
-0.0247930996,
0.0302209184,
0.0151532451,
-0.0327929966,
0.0828338563,
-0.003620605,
-0.0963765159,
-0.0041870032,
-0.0360296965,
-0.0009848265,
-0.0096780835,
0.0197636615,
-0.0250905231,
-0.0084125269,
-0.0069598798,
-0.0520776026,
-0.0195554364,
0.0336358249,
0.0100629181,
0.0026819713,
-0.0435513444,
-0.0283855516,
-0.0267888121,
0.0461825132,
-0.0113746729,
0.0366301239,
-0.0367370062,
0.0314590633,
-0.0510804951,
0.0243802778,
0.0084562954,
0.0023486544,
-0.0637357682,
-0.0047371075,
0.0078258244,
-0.0349780209,
-0.00144054,
0.0170996599,
0.0744689852,
0.0318152718,
-0.013803537,
-0.0182312708,
-0.0032130035,
-0.0622023903,
-0.0108558638,
0.0655889213,
-0.0167359244,
-0.0051656188,
0.0675265044,
0.008665245,
-0.0237966273,
0.0437718853,
-0.1047048271,
0.0403386727,
-0.0096063651,
0.0295384564,
-0.0004203583,
0.002933369,
-0.0077239843,
0.0871385708,
0.0010980449,
0.044309482,
-0.0256098881,
-0.0208325814,
0.0151750371,
-0.0011513716,
-0.0061466368,
-0.0523261577,
-0.0215335228,
0.0344079919,
0.0245913789,
-0.043622002,
-0.0448702835,
-0.0334714167,
-0.0479767136,
-0.0080388067,
-0.0264583919,
0.0857936516,
0.0158675816,
0.0007195307,
0.0103628756,
-0.0362961702,
-0.0383303799,
-0.0187750608,
-0.0036804024,
0.0244663153,
0.0260606278,
0.0270322859,
-0.0099844635,
-0.0070696026,
-0.0322130732,
-0.0570448935,
0.0390739031,
0.0164576527,
0.0231752414,
-0.0609686747,
0.0202264413,
-0.0028790163,
0.0092639551,
-0.0168496836,
-0.0195468124,
0.0088604074,
-0.0047147544,
0.0198637582,
0.0047001685,
-0.030754691,
0.0338472985,
0.0349168442,
0.0350203514,
-0.0308846571,
-0.0022093595,
-0.0428393856,
-0.0268279612,
-0.0177624878,
0.0019898273,
-0.0516364463,
0.0967188105,
-0.0384219997,
-0.0275291633,
-0.0164165217,
0.0170301422,
0.0129538476,
-0.003008096,
-0.0069273058,
-0.0260834657,
-0.0316626281,
0.0456937142,
-0.0265349597,
-0.0253425222,
0.0278486647,
0.0033543941,
-0.043942824,
-0.0639880151,
0.0133877741,
-0.0466403887,
0.0565126576,
0.0295314938,
-0.0020942173,
-0.0027911391,
-0.0432963483,
-0.0470465794,
0.0336266644,
0.0324772261,
-0.0388085432,
0.0775395334,
-0.0100182649,
0.0183061268,
-0.0313129611,
-0.0544847585,
-0.0732928663,
-0.0088924747,
-0.0014417451,
0.0637032241,
0.0100535266,
-0.0574349351,
-0.0536047369,
-0.0231535621,
0.0765456706,
0.0845707431,
-0.0117166145,
-0.0139342221,
-0.0366877727,
0.0083463555,
0.0161052793,
0.0396639891,
0.0702219382,
-0.0351827666,
-0.0317328647,
0.0235688798,
0.0642118677,
0.026896961,
-0.0488478206,
0.0424439497,
0.0219634771,
-0.0443157032,
-0.0079189138,
0.0542881452,
0.0064217993,
-0.0534698255,
-0.0206285343,
0.0505651683,
0.0442531779,
-0.0435606577,
0.0374114849,
-0.0326048806,
-0.0145425461,
0.0372285545,
0.0210564453,
-0.0659698024,
0.0035378295,
0.024051683,
-0.0271075554,
-0.0242162049,
-0.0383828953,
0.0025480608,
-0.1283503026,
-0.020772865,
0.0166592691,
-0.0559237115,
-0.0508010536,
-0.0663321614,
0.0060244249,
-0.0105540147,
0.0302194357,
0.0248916037,
-0.0391726345,
0.0070642941,
0.0284768716,
-0.0108701019,
-0.0209025368,
0.0178525429,
-0.0074201995,
-0.0173397847,
0.058804933,
-0.0222547855,
-0.0320251845,
-0.0661661699,
0.0098314546,
0.0404914506,
0.0123233162,
0.0542344861,
0.048830729,
0.0565582067,
-0.0260378476,
0.0020314376,
0.0191960447,
-0.0445725545,
-0.0175919291,
-0.0666738898,
0.0741247311,
-0.0232439674,
0.0366512462,
0.0276132636,
0.0050223493,
-0.0181825608,
0.0149425231,
0.0353834629,
0.013093859,
-0.0180862341,
-0.0283267181,
0.0215189476,
-0.0297986418,
-0.0523262098,
0.0257403981,
0.062665917,
-0.0724148378,
-0.0606686026,
-0.023952039,
0.0100952005,
0.0172144957,
-0.0000227468,
-0.0674483404,
0.0336904675,
-0.0188151449,
-0.086221911,
0.0250860974,
0.0187108424,
0.0565927774,
-0.0233935248,
0.0216636173,
0.0256254971,
-0.0052809231,
-0.0149333375,
-0.0352828689,
-0.106001839,
-0.0420765281,
0.0123238005,
0.0566500314,
0.0245358963,
-0.0061325934,
0.0157615226,
-0.0298875626,
0.0152806826,
0.0460178405,
-0.0707596466,
0.0390700176,
0.0317180194,
-0.0169338901,
0.0072581284,
-0.030800581,
-0.0105195204,
0.0035630742,
-0.0118218604,
0.0375901647,
-0.0599337853,
0.0290298071,
0.0709642768,
-0.0031338201,
0.0443899408,
0.0080450922,
0.0722758323,
0.0156992786,
0.0278054588,
-0.0318323188,
0.0267092139,
-0.0134551581,
-0.0498813577,
0.0124767786,
0.0310862027,
-0.001371238,
-0.0000021291,
0.0381891206,
0.0159620252,
0.0186578315,
0.0333717726,
0.0025256192,
0.0115282172,
0.0019107084,
0.016488662,
-0.0049095112,
-0.0056804395,
-0.0002856317,
0.0468979031,
0.0164667442,
0.0266148578,
0.0004654832,
0.0194340255,
-0.0703445673,
0.0115499385,
-0.0453765206,
-0.0515616126,
-0.0169460159,
-0.0321220085,
-0.0012523433,
-0.0230009668,
0.0016035697,
-0.0599599183,
0.0105294138,
-0.0136175761,
-0.0269418508,
-0.0345958099,
-0.0093726516,
0.0056603239,
0.042842634,
0.0208117478,
-0.059410844,
0.043747168,
-0.0583624132,
0.0500310063,
-0.0198909137,
-0.0048989472,
0.0211789384,
-0.0419693217,
-0.0051867054,
0.0038020092,
-0.0215960275,
-0.0110133374,
-0.0407300368,
-0.0674618706,
0.0023333791,
0.0088043213,
0.0189587753,
-0.0378914624,
0.0636588484,
0.0198765267,
-0.0565423295,
-0.0162892342,
-0.0126944156,
-0.0057446063,
0.0385247916,
0.0189698339,
-0.0722655579,
-5.319273568e-33,
0.024215987,
-0.0179235544,
0.0375844985,
-0.0118723363,
-0.0124081289,
0.0052871439,
-0.0108895078,
0.0535666123,
0.0018591455,
0.0106112575,
-0.0164383519,
-0.0106946789,
0.016367428,
0.0241029281,
0.0101802936,
-0.0226097833,
0.0300430898,
-0.0136131607,
-0.0380843766,
-0.0487676933,
0.0349196717,
-0.0101805525,
0.1109535545,
-0.0535888486,
0.0256948341,
0.0391677767,
-0.0240358971,
0.009609458,
-0.017676644,
0.0726288632,
-0.0033301366,
0.0490730517,
0.0070930277,
-0.076288864,
-0.0499277711,
0.0135242017,
-0.060207665,
-0.0482981764,
-0.001885177,
0.0425577387,
-0.0165994838,
-0.0247281734,
0.0546256863,
-0.0281835049,
-0.0390562974,
-0.0143742142,
0.0130167715,
-0.0385547988,
-0.00081175,
-0.0045367475,
-0.0351294391,
-0.0022324068,
0.0031631514,
-0.0283332858,
0.0323689282,
0.0169751681,
-0.0267883576,
-0.0261031315,
-0.0585291348,
0.0501906648,
0.0421092808,
0.0380694494,
0.0096321544,
-0.0098634753,
-0.0182908271,
0.024291059,
0.0624469556,
-0.0093340883,
-0.0173684154,
-0.0416171178,
0.0365646146,
0.0094900858,
0.0558910519,
-0.0039979396,
0.1166734248,
0.0344470032,
-0.016961731,
0.0183373932,
0.0047086352,
0.0339907967,
-0.0152809033,
0.0030008454,
-0.033794418,
0.000156916,
-0.0327754766,
0.0714171901,
-0.0508737415,
-0.0327687562,
-0.0155252777,
0.0042633838,
0.0591078885,
0.0596211106,
-0.0062391791,
-0.0349649377,
0.0100819003,
0.001737845,
0.0106398324,
0.0546037965,
-0.0111920228,
-0.0207508728,
-0.0104250824,
-0.0026741219,
0.0002718851,
0.0113002537,
0.0246693753,
-0.0049895821,
0.0542330891,
0.045987349,
-0.0648778006,
-0.0144855212,
-0.0208564736,
-0.0128006591,
0.0434328392,
0.0377163179,
0.0253476109,
-0.0050844136,
-0.0050981618,
0.0093381628,
-0.0256499015,
-0.0027127156,
-0.0157960672,
0.0160722192,
-0.0195665844,
0.0485775694,
-0.0041202889,
-0.0524225533,
-0.0570897944,
0.031976819,
0.010490803,
-0.051828783,
-0.0134926038,
-0.0265505407,
2.664e-7,
0.0545147695,
0.0267237853,
0.0466567092,
0.0051023979,
0.0123049691,
0.0259282943,
0.0032545959,
0.0276738722,
-0.0262816865,
-0.0261317901,
-0.0043710326,
-0.0128290076,
-0.0199109428,
0.0034371552,
-0.0110528953,
-0.0196701623,
-0.0272215698,
0.0286541097,
-0.001362281,
0.0484598428,
0.025684759,
0.081549421,
0.0181009248,
0.0061527393,
0.0019610035,
-0.0009564064,
0.0648797899,
-0.0043968111,
0.0164998341,
0.0029414068,
0.007442872,
0.0032298667,
0.0106951138,
-0.0034858047,
-0.0277820528,
0.0247209407,
0.0235224497,
0.0328080952,
-0.0086584147,
-0.018440323,
-0.0185946245,
-0.0081833778,
-0.0392981246,
-0.0039527062,
0.0236130152,
-0.0893232226,
-0.0189985894,
-0.0031342804,
-0.0053556906,
0.0316961482,
-0.0075718001,
0.0163072124,
0.0096369684,
0.0106520606,
0.0165949762,
-0.0097689275,
-0.0004048027,
-0.084439598,
-0.0560985021,
0.0348603502,
-0.0449162424,
-0.0412051827,
-0.0430312604,
-0.0181940347,
0.060086634,
-0.0412651002,
-0.0309360195,
2.54804334e-34,
0.0252328031,
-0.0214117225,
0.025802156,
0.0428959168,
-0.0009176978,
-0.0314858593,
0.0338783041,
0.0369522832,
0.0633708909,
-0.0321550518,
-0.02457764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13061v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13061v1 | Attribution and Alignment: Effects of Local Context Repetition on Utterance Production and Comprehension in Dialogue | 2023-11-21T23:50:33 | 2023-11-21T23:50:33 | Aron Molnar, Jaap Jumelet, Mario Giulianelli, Arabella Sinclair | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models are often used as the backbone of modern dialogue systems.
These models are pre-trained on large amounts of written fluent language.
Repetition is typically penalised when evaluating language model generations.
However, it is a key component of dialogue. Humans use local and partner
specific repetitions; these are preferred by human users and lead to more
successful communication in dialogue. In this study, we evaluate (a) whether
language models produce human-like levels of repetition in dialogue, and (b)
what are the processing mechanisms related to lexical re-use they use during
comprehension. We believe that such joint analysis of model production and
comprehension behaviour can inform the development of cognitively inspired
dialogue generation systems. | [
0.0614705011,
0.0189822633,
-0.053537108,
0.0143545233,
-0.0347369686,
-0.0081360666,
0.0038303037,
-0.029910624,
-0.0182730332,
-0.0333990939,
-0.0516625345,
-0.0317799821,
0.0495765954,
0.0168349165,
0.048454091,
-0.0498475917,
0.040513698,
-0.0320783779,
0.0132689793,
-0.015583735,
-0.0108695207,
-0.0003118911,
-0.0054203235,
0.0601561368,
-0.0207979381,
-0.0051344796,
-0.0487415195,
0.010532612,
-0.0020928071,
-0.0175149832,
-0.0131072141,
0.0410656929,
0.002553785,
0.047844965,
0.000001636,
-0.053022664,
0.0180062111,
-0.0505816638,
-0.0519479923,
0.0320454575,
0.0050496655,
0.056335859,
0.013271993,
-0.0005094709,
-0.0295348372,
0.0242471416,
0.0427409932,
0.0447066501,
0.0611485057,
0.0205358025,
0.0034302997,
0.0077134906,
-0.0002906374,
-0.0086063482,
-0.0259084199,
-0.0476260409,
-0.0149567863,
0.0794855729,
0.0078120031,
0.0005466043,
-0.0118067106,
0.0451983362,
0.0110589499,
-0.0148907583,
0.0021824124,
0.0284344833,
0.0133640748,
-0.028897481,
-0.050639499,
0.0649136752,
0.0510982871,
-0.0378752835,
-0.0186432563,
0.003283727,
0.0314198136,
0.0194451865,
-0.0394761898,
0.0288855955,
-0.0038894946,
-0.000465888,
-0.0128211258,
-0.027898835,
-0.0090091908,
0.0015255997,
0.0340488069,
0.0179012492,
0.0121030118,
-0.0164967719,
-0.0478917919,
-0.0035821877,
-0.0313522369,
-0.1021634638,
-0.0075177578,
0.0323028788,
-0.0554906018,
0.0425918624,
-0.0527144819,
0.0058249109,
0.0343364961,
0.0036137905,
0.0662693903,
0.0414400287,
-0.0050032493,
0.0067917514,
0.0223457292,
0.0908992365,
-0.0319109112,
0.0064849826,
-0.0304203574,
0.0236667972,
-0.0536875799,
-0.0731561631,
-0.0646087155,
0.0311198998,
-0.0033900924,
-0.0462708846,
-0.0450609066,
0.0527036227,
0.012929705,
-0.0196704436,
-0.0132079208,
0.0101505667,
-0.0334294066,
0.0277367532,
-0.0272845663,
-0.0025176918,
-0.0451095924,
0.0442108512,
0.0419754125,
-0.0880122036,
-0.0239700302,
0.0295903217,
-0.017529238,
-0.0038412837,
-0.0593563095,
0.0085949106,
-0.0271369312,
-0.0120896436,
0.0105965519,
-0.0573749281,
-0.0664991364,
-0.0578346103,
-0.061956577,
-0.0210099425,
0.0218417775,
0.0211462248,
-0.0276323464,
-0.0374043621,
-0.0042883437,
0.013845874,
-0.0316685513,
0.0137353856,
0.0112855313,
0.0842780694,
0.0611528903,
0.0113229249,
0.0049719759,
0.0167086013,
0.0449168868,
-0.015130572,
0.0001868122,
-0.015828561,
0.0138609372,
0.0120307235,
0.0072152326,
-0.0228426978,
-0.0472123511,
0.0009068597,
-0.0112288073,
0.0361491032,
0.0547932759,
0.061370898,
-0.0674330965,
0.0018626173,
0.07110513,
0.0461002104,
0.0115744909,
-0.0066463533,
0.0637324527,
0.0144975251,
0.0224492438,
0.0414930806,
-0.0188248046,
0.0190094393,
0.0062076706,
0.0454004668,
0.0120269228,
0.0081855031,
-0.0347794034,
-0.0019109749,
-0.016417101,
0.0297218319,
0.0130854165,
-0.0034387973,
-0.0105698509,
0.0468158349,
-0.0237108581,
0.0607400835,
-0.0209998786,
-0.0608448163,
-0.0367585532,
-0.0449531488,
0.0270633399,
0.0443394668,
0.0320528001,
0.0690863952,
-0.0284580868,
0.0046959086,
-0.0145093156,
0.0416022986,
0.0662603974,
-0.011986915,
0.0186277404,
-0.0219742786,
-0.008077262,
-0.0218724739,
-0.0083064372,
0.02486155,
0.0130245946,
0.0063853534,
0.0155666266,
-0.0054348144,
-0.004219118,
0.0213695504,
-0.0521489531,
0.0060354453,
-0.048669681,
-0.001052406,
0.0116702849,
-0.0044174604,
-0.0095436573,
0.0374809392,
0.0213829372,
0.0254316963,
0.0119185532,
0.1046864688,
-0.0787658617,
-0.0396455266,
0.0275478028,
0.0168175958,
-0.0036133337,
-0.0254518539,
0.0565617271,
-0.071994327,
0.0300585069,
-0.0751105249,
0.0549508557,
-0.0566794276,
0.0409815721,
-0.0032092542,
0.0250408184,
-0.0433431827,
0.0286986083,
0.0012252502,
-0.0072810552,
0.0576138422,
0.0187763534,
0.025676148,
-0.0865874738,
0.0007850367,
0.0002090358,
-0.0246920548,
-0.0031721531,
0.0281784721,
-0.0244127512,
-0.0724249855,
-0.0436318368,
-0.083233431,
-0.0127651347,
0.0177064501,
-0.0129488856,
0.0345366001,
-0.007310153,
-0.0217796229,
-0.02013327,
-0.0459178649,
-0.0162577648,
0.02524372,
0.0251033623,
0.0192619935,
-0.0148378043,
-0.044619862,
-0.0370229483,
0.0243947022,
0.0134002622,
0.0242084954,
0.0039283009,
0.0157009792,
-0.0626228675,
0.0344214588,
-0.0206925198,
-0.0208515096,
0.0239817277,
-0.0290426761,
0.0664712265,
0.0820454285,
0.0781518072,
0.0420792177,
0.0340966061,
0.0625358596,
0.0019273541,
-0.0259932261,
-0.071283564,
0.009389258,
-0.0189442243,
-0.0379030816,
-0.0280152038,
-0.0321828052,
0.0142255649,
0.0710757747,
0.0668503046,
0.0551293753,
-0.0300377924,
0.0228053629,
0.0103069786,
-0.0870293006,
-0.0055670082,
-0.0746107623,
-0.0545108318,
0.0587242916,
-0.0108000599,
-0.0630951449,
0.0323419496,
-0.0341464952,
-0.0145703014,
0.0066384221,
0.0343603268,
0.0168633703,
0.0374313928,
-0.0277755931,
0.0332712084,
0.0232453607,
-0.0430961326,
-0.0534017421,
-0.0338316634,
0.040001221,
-0.0142514007,
0.0327620767,
-0.0268300641,
0.0057945312,
0.0451680236,
-0.0333484598,
-0.0834049731,
-0.0085080788,
-0.0219948161,
-0.0114980415,
-0.0177359432,
0.0040211682,
-0.0109298006,
0.0224532895,
0.0467421971,
0.0023781222,
-0.0182116237,
-0.0056500044,
-0.0050287391,
0.0611809455,
0.0419451855,
0.0506654307,
0.016471481,
-0.0362100601,
0.0351870134,
0.0079724258,
0.0194322467,
0.0450049117,
-0.0299486704,
0.020555852,
0.0326347873,
-0.0069315974,
-0.0498953126,
0.0306127984,
0.0870013908,
-0.0192953441,
-0.0279887654,
0.0937902033,
0.0122719146,
-0.0094241137,
0.017839238,
-0.0622601137,
0.0802860335,
0.0283121075,
0.0062279636,
-0.0548314564,
-0.0013367928,
0.0175980236,
-0.0341931172,
-0.0164742228,
0.0242921133,
-0.0252393,
-0.0933826417,
0.0344834551,
0.0061069396,
-0.085570462,
0.0226884559,
0.0058927136,
0.0124798669,
0.0353804901,
0.0319493189,
0.050996583,
-0.0115035856,
0.0106778806,
0.0241191704,
0.0074468111,
-0.0081439065,
-0.0126670999,
-0.0145803317,
0.0812866986,
0.0583312623,
0.0394472666,
0.0367140323,
-0.0247029383,
0.0277708769,
-0.0224723164,
0.0519302189,
0.0148299793,
0.0044796537,
0.0254218709,
-0.0099521894,
-0.0475526787,
0.0345781446,
-0.0136218229,
-0.0569054671,
0.0038980606,
0.0217807647,
-0.0344560631,
0.0205076728,
-0.0189864896,
0.0447077118,
0.0225675553,
0.0906248838,
0.0794273093,
-0.0315052755,
-0.0148018897,
0.0343143418,
0.0050793258,
-0.0430647731,
-0.002514157,
0.0492179357,
0.0137978895,
0.0111298552,
-0.0805332288,
-0.0644148886,
-0.0282655172,
0.0137514845,
0.0222442281,
0.0196906682,
-0.0212594774,
-0.0228244308,
-0.002840006,
-0.011574381,
-0.0101500852,
0.0092452625,
-0.0501240455,
-0.0312294737,
-0.0189102478,
-0.0566930398,
0.0077373325,
0.0048876395,
-0.0744606256,
-0.0684786737,
0.0010632016,
0.0112161608,
0.0349004716,
0.0529858954,
0.0422789231,
-0.0204141922,
-0.021169072,
-0.0529616214,
-0.0070924391,
0.0475587882,
-0.0106184427,
0.0144829191,
-0.0026353572,
0.0403240137,
0.0169355664,
0.0079209609,
0.0130551979,
0.033434175,
-0.0143284127,
-0.0819346905,
0.0391341932,
0.0269700587,
-0.0147122014,
-0.0309992097,
0.0250831377,
-0.011076468,
-0.0007772482,
-0.0150080556,
0.0009843921,
-0.0390498452,
0.0033578714,
-0.0007780563,
0.0045080241,
0.010059691,
-0.0832965523,
-0.0487485528,
0.081581369,
0.0033490914,
-0.0337651335,
-0.0289010443,
-0.0102717634,
-0.017575575,
0.0399846435,
-0.0123576289,
0.0494645499,
-0.0440466329,
0.0332205333,
0.0133866481,
0.1091249213,
0.0094650239,
-0.0342164598,
-0.0138025554,
0.0164728779,
-0.0435319431,
-0.0406965874,
0.0283212252,
-0.0307428427,
0.0107341288,
-0.0365232415,
0.0767790228,
-0.0527663268,
0.0388749987,
-0.0098027093,
0.0577801205,
-0.0244325511,
-0.0343330912,
0.009026343,
0.0137150194,
-0.0492511652,
-0.0127222221,
0.0787917525,
-0.0041224672,
-0.0018147632,
-0.0190679468,
0.0148757957,
-0.0425543487,
-0.0240823701,
0.0253949556,
-0.0014237664,
-0.0140396906,
0.0056902803,
-0.0510216169,
-0.0475377962,
0.004433732,
0.0066060717,
0.0429599993,
-0.018949315,
0.046376586,
0.0671012923,
-0.0299499836,
-0.0187074356,
-0.0153696556,
0.0211890433,
-0.015291431,
-0.0029568078,
-0.0460599661,
-5.451646721e-33,
-0.0375771821,
-0.0273034498,
0.0498354882,
-0.0171704646,
-0.0631404892,
-0.0138892848,
-0.0611653253,
0.0182849541,
-0.0003146174,
0.0047670584,
-0.0199181419,
-0.0002230155,
0.0158390291,
0.0068710474,
0.0305586979,
0.012621454,
0.0336851813,
0.0138799958,
-0.0423051491,
0.0136215352,
0.0443743393,
-0.0039020581,
0.009103993,
-0.0414247625,
0.0119099189,
-0.0018320126,
-0.0221839491,
-0.0117133819,
0.0055491598,
0.0684362948,
-0.0257017948,
0.0086903926,
0.0290019661,
-0.0358925276,
-0.0371191204,
0.0446550399,
-0.0005338615,
-0.0252923481,
0.0747828707,
0.0086479411,
-0.0292235594,
-0.0325815864,
0.0230612569,
-0.0556781664,
-0.0326680541,
0.0253616124,
0.0017085721,
-0.0131918723,
-0.0390866399,
0.0378097668,
-0.0868247598,
-0.0077044643,
-0.0335728824,
-0.0242294744,
-0.022361286,
0.0595741384,
-0.0451241098,
-0.0341652371,
-0.0037594875,
0.0471722819,
-0.0066040163,
0.0008135815,
0.0691456795,
0.041447714,
0.044129286,
0.0558877513,
0.0244424995,
0.0129562188,
0.0086430302,
-0.0277925134,
0.0192439593,
0.0414170362,
-0.0185478106,
0.0491789468,
-0.0033721637,
-0.0285558552,
0.0133420592,
-0.0217104796,
-0.0153217549,
0.0422070622,
0.0344658159,
0.0164785609,
-0.0298845768,
-0.0245404411,
-0.0459048562,
-0.0063609448,
-0.0206883159,
-0.059812285,
0.0523809455,
-0.0129242949,
0.0209041946,
-0.0351837166,
0.0481814221,
-0.0145748835,
-0.008353482,
-0.0155581022,
-0.048434034,
0.0120995073,
-0.0118972184,
0.0234813727,
-0.0286251437,
-0.0169613101,
-0.0034478542,
0.0466255099,
0.0211218614,
0.059584029,
0.0033024042,
0.0083505725,
-0.0418272577,
-0.0030635847,
-0.0349782743,
0.013656714,
-0.0431646407,
-0.0322422422,
0.0333718546,
0.0253729448,
-0.0545490459,
0.0240849853,
-0.0167950243,
-0.0478750095,
-0.0622403584,
-0.0181251876,
0.0028543053,
0.0349417292,
-0.0362554602,
0.0036587364,
-0.0248575751,
0.0028522834,
0.0487837978,
-0.018591661,
-0.0069862893,
-0.0168518648,
2.474e-7,
-0.0166332778,
0.0191811286,
0.0395908244,
-0.0077948282,
0.0395031348,
0.0090639368,
-0.0056353989,
0.0234397259,
0.024862675,
0.0038635398,
0.0015226925,
0.0060997866,
0.0375004821,
-0.0245529469,
-0.0470281206,
0.0138987685,
-0.1062048301,
0.0087154452,
-0.0075218645,
0.0153119853,
0.0085730916,
0.0242005456,
-0.0228850842,
-0.0110854376,
-0.0240963716,
-0.0266271234,
0.0584705174,
-0.0395340547,
0.0044250106,
0.0261011738,
0.037859235,
-0.0049695349,
0.0299198199,
0.0297942013,
0.0091626393,
0.011897278,
0.0026653116,
0.026460398,
-0.0061500757,
-0.051281698,
-0.0224304032,
-0.0184666216,
-0.0085205156,
-0.0759081692,
-0.0177269839,
-0.0372504592,
-0.0224004388,
-0.0293365847,
0.0157158412,
-0.0076004737,
0.0305596646,
-0.0313070901,
0.0058175116,
0.0526677147,
0.0101793678,
0.0327925123,
0.0124929417,
-0.0278010983,
-0.0343987532,
-0.0101354439,
-0.0632161498,
-0.0231152046,
-0.0383838341,
-0.0559554249,
0.0436669923,
-0.048634395,
-0.0261842404,
1.597574079e-34,
-0.0063164737,
0.0005726588,
0.0783808678,
0.0829005912,
0.0207307916,
-0.0296134893,
0.0299105588,
0.0569367856,
0.0349022038,
-0.055954162,
-0.0308959242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13053v1 | Beyond Text: Unveiling Multimodal Proficiency of Large Language Models with MultiAPI Benchmark | 2023-11-21T23:26:05 | 2023-11-21T23:26:05 | Xiao Liu, Jianfeng Lin, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of Large Language Models like ChatGPT has significantly
advanced language understanding and generation, impacting a broad spectrum of
applications. However, these models predominantly excel in text-based tasks,
overlooking the complexity of real-world multimodal information. This study
introduces MultiAPI, a pioneering comprehensive large-scale API benchmark
dataset aimed at expanding LLMs' proficiency in multimodal contexts. Developed
collaboratively through ChatGPT, MultiAPI consists of 235 diverse API calls and
2,038 contextual prompts, offering a unique platform evaluation of
tool-augmented LLMs handling multimodal tasks. Through comprehensive
experiments, our findings reveal that while LLMs demonstrate proficiency in API
call decision-making, they face challenges in domain identification, function
selection, and argument generation. What's more, we surprisingly notice that
auxiliary context can actually impair the performance. An in-depth error
analysis paves the way for a new paradigm to address these challenges,
suggesting a potential direction for future LLM research. | [
0.0056992006,
0.0380781218,
-0.0135628525,
0.0511070266,
-0.0434032343,
-0.003411077,
0.025114622,
-0.0060265213,
0.0207696818,
-0.0801038444,
-0.057904765,
-0.0464173742,
0.0064635994,
0.0120221637,
0.0497021303,
-0.0480379723,
0.0402403697,
-0.0508533865,
-0.007412706,
0.0114907892,
-0.0028531519,
0.025802549,
-0.0626582131,
0.0814379454,
-0.0274051726,
-0.0439809971,
-0.0248834621,
0.0293940958,
-0.019761255,
-0.0457858145,
0.017159529,
0.0293859039,
0.0355602317,
0.0495663472,
0.0000019157,
-0.0672086403,
0.0108889304,
-0.0130261509,
0.0022787959,
-0.0297552273,
0.0443855785,
0.025275467,
0.0041294396,
0.0162812024,
-0.0252569765,
-0.0085927239,
0.0555914119,
-0.0185272507,
0.0634996295,
0.0459445827,
-0.0012270458,
0.012534773,
-0.0147414207,
0.0088020526,
-0.0206310749,
-0.0309437234,
-0.0371638164,
-0.0057085659,
0.0499119386,
-0.0163523387,
-0.0061771423,
0.0351458266,
0.034792833,
0.0096245063,
-0.0477054492,
0.0298613925,
-0.0233039334,
-0.0388040356,
-0.0450187102,
0.0811276436,
0.0112714181,
0.0056743566,
0.008006582,
-0.0019976976,
0.0115756122,
0.0105278092,
-0.0632369667,
0.0438615754,
-0.028289184,
-0.0123261362,
-0.0172621794,
-0.0117610488,
0.0263058618,
0.0109529421,
0.0136773838,
0.051113449,
0.0118601294,
0.0184106417,
0.0152240284,
0.0023109629,
-0.0327161588,
-0.0731885433,
0.0037473415,
0.0487969071,
-0.0730514899,
0.0201923791,
-0.0439487658,
-0.0260662753,
0.0216410477,
-0.0232850406,
0.0470444858,
0.0542707928,
-0.070745647,
0.0163926464,
-0.0054111565,
0.0138027854,
-0.003498832,
0.0127346059,
-0.0048148623,
-0.0217270032,
-0.0351603143,
-0.0233893041,
-0.0054324563,
0.0208217781,
-0.0591753013,
-0.0375848524,
-0.0205670465,
0.0608218238,
-0.0089936219,
0.0227836519,
-0.0224270243,
-0.0008243509,
-0.0351584256,
0.0024837984,
-0.0164372809,
0.0278677959,
-0.0075652422,
0.0163022671,
0.0423022509,
-0.0741536319,
0.0054474059,
0.0409860723,
-0.0042253216,
-0.0237864126,
-0.0175988097,
0.1476266086,
-0.0288475603,
-0.0219753478,
-0.042274043,
-0.0616523139,
-0.0083122756,
-0.0665874556,
0.0272402074,
-0.0780472532,
0.0395694263,
0.0443506949,
-0.0089205317,
-0.0286657419,
0.0029856341,
0.016531419,
0.0304046031,
0.0591008142,
-0.0144936033,
0.0022810774,
0.058619462,
0.0332088396,
-0.0542201661,
0.1079773679,
0.0310798045,
0.0337360166,
0.0537451282,
0.0067516314,
-0.0098512853,
0.067623429,
-0.0447632633,
0.0005291604,
-0.0142064579,
-0.0129398536,
0.0112150218,
0.0430390202,
0.0391384624,
0.0254120361,
-0.0248939227,
-0.0042265407,
0.075050503,
0.0383067392,
0.0313842073,
-0.015188178,
0.0830462053,
-0.0171843953,
0.00533032,
0.0101916017,
-0.0688162372,
0.0442842059,
-0.0269591361,
0.0158166736,
0.0226300657,
0.0328881219,
-0.0046740458,
-0.0200897902,
0.0004856788,
-0.0101856077,
-0.0456209555,
-0.0113861039,
0.0233100671,
0.0007168065,
-0.0332509615,
0.0505327918,
0.0160464142,
-0.0552889667,
-0.0256305188,
-0.0441396721,
-0.0014361787,
0.0342429802,
0.0537167229,
-0.031295985,
-0.0715658516,
-0.0069670598,
0.0515914522,
0.076096423,
0.0584027842,
-0.0234747753,
0.0491341278,
-0.0316944234,
-0.02578694,
-0.0249955337,
0.0099138971,
0.0294649769,
0.013694861,
0.0112373093,
0.0053191367,
-0.0545064136,
0.0152294338,
0.0272246059,
-0.0167281926,
-0.0143514592,
-0.0184634216,
0.019250378,
0.0125658037,
0.0035093667,
-0.0021431386,
-0.0110112447,
-0.0041118455,
-0.0300891269,
0.0241095405,
0.0407737866,
-0.0672893301,
-0.0195517279,
0.0473459028,
-0.0079784635,
-0.0265307669,
0.0203647055,
-0.0257250164,
-0.0351884961,
0.0178950615,
-0.0327259824,
0.0416367128,
-0.0114510236,
-0.0039048272,
0.0241869353,
0.0130907707,
-0.0085769352,
0.0336502045,
-0.00266235,
0.0018822118,
0.0294667613,
0.060894154,
-0.0022562912,
-0.0107379127,
-0.0194971394,
0.0274155326,
-0.005357889,
0.0369067937,
-0.000248307,
0.0254567545,
-0.0389355645,
-0.0179022402,
-0.1337248832,
0.0159076098,
-0.0347945094,
0.0060311696,
0.0155255403,
0.0107462518,
-0.004624648,
-0.0068451893,
-0.0186048709,
0.0250652023,
0.0067904694,
0.0344519243,
0.0319363624,
0.0064422474,
-0.0257469937,
-0.0487498082,
0.0156560782,
-0.0186848734,
0.0517983027,
-0.0122393295,
-0.0384886712,
-0.0427136607,
0.0150833838,
-0.0231884457,
0.0182157252,
-0.0298473239,
-0.0062703285,
0.0604819395,
-0.0178085081,
0.0329368338,
0.0181673951,
-0.020408446,
0.0384629518,
0.0420072414,
-0.0386324413,
-0.0735083744,
0.0235674884,
0.0291402154,
-0.0353368632,
-0.0127309123,
-0.008975775,
0.0191655811,
0.0812252536,
-0.0070914668,
0.0341304131,
-0.0202713255,
0.008655603,
0.005456828,
-0.0455605276,
-0.0177237261,
0.0175707154,
-0.0369754136,
0.0548752062,
-0.012409104,
-0.0619117171,
0.0364328437,
-0.0503526144,
-0.0305429995,
-0.0076108016,
-0.028399935,
-0.025729768,
0.0987316146,
-0.0053364928,
0.0161406361,
-0.0086630285,
-0.0365315601,
-0.051812917,
0.022284016,
0.006919153,
-0.0102463607,
0.0946797505,
-0.1065209582,
0.009412081,
-0.0202658046,
-0.0402138457,
-0.0237290636,
0.0114497598,
-0.0450866558,
0.0016033225,
-0.0314689428,
-0.0236162171,
0.0012475984,
-0.0128569966,
0.024193367,
0.0455968156,
0.0014526577,
-0.0220182687,
-0.0454861559,
0.0132767148,
0.0344965011,
0.0595556498,
-0.0010080985,
-0.0273904894,
0.0109266667,
0.0360873677,
0.0333116874,
-0.0228689797,
-0.075217858,
0.0150850238,
0.0335203148,
-0.0332752019,
-0.0329529531,
0.0522022098,
0.0748751014,
-0.0761727169,
0.0165212378,
0.0792935193,
0.0104880529,
-0.0670828745,
0.008947121,
-0.0229919124,
0.0293332376,
0.0396975465,
0.0127753764,
-0.104920648,
-0.0756227076,
0.0109824026,
0.01497107,
-0.0023327519,
-0.0298708808,
-0.0247952789,
-0.1216461137,
0.0443370193,
-0.0082864081,
-0.0505650789,
0.0178857092,
-0.0020602932,
0.0274574365,
0.0285758004,
0.0341728441,
0.013595446,
-0.0218794737,
-0.0131567996,
0.0071514947,
-0.0147915622,
-0.0476015732,
-0.0042099427,
-0.0297047794,
0.040802557,
0.0207076427,
-0.0017223118,
-0.003892696,
-0.0038931351,
0.0812781379,
0.0298074055,
0.0212135185,
-0.0313998833,
0.0153623801,
0.0008561907,
-0.0034716248,
-0.0037954971,
0.0173679367,
-0.0389095284,
-0.0474220924,
-0.0014276671,
0.0589011014,
-0.052185569,
0.0272421706,
-0.0118280509,
0.0201191865,
0.0351984166,
0.0302280709,
0.0510646068,
-0.0366922505,
-0.0491090678,
-0.0548880734,
-0.0207742676,
-0.0554960631,
0.0022663348,
0.0074811755,
0.000503579,
-0.0053333715,
-0.0515793599,
-0.0169887058,
0.0394877903,
0.0465646833,
0.0057858853,
-0.0001711432,
-0.0277476124,
0.0152660431,
-0.0299659669,
0.0227468479,
-0.0054851519,
0.0361668617,
-0.054000251,
-0.0030044226,
0.0278509986,
-0.0386511311,
0.0098699229,
0.0682009161,
-0.0577287078,
-0.0772569701,
-0.0221231524,
0.0730174333,
0.0339013487,
0.0127530424,
0.0022594447,
-0.0553003512,
-0.0185687747,
0.0880413875,
-0.0305199549,
0.0319845192,
0.0183085017,
0.0597520396,
-0.0027551947,
0.0196621157,
-0.0683858544,
-0.0341400467,
-0.0103474241,
0.0563747175,
0.0111069335,
-0.037554387,
0.0027834193,
0.0159979407,
0.0024747264,
-0.045606941,
0.0068197558,
-0.0192333218,
-0.0101568596,
-0.006374652,
-0.0024721308,
-0.0594958067,
0.0036956868,
-0.0515050143,
-0.0274393503,
0.0342435092,
-0.0140574612,
-0.0018372093,
0.053877525,
-0.0152678899,
0.0422413461,
0.0109652551,
-0.009976388,
0.0251154993,
0.0094100116,
-0.0237650722,
0.012476299,
-0.0140850786,
0.0413907543,
-0.0297282804,
0.0953554139,
0.0072324066,
-0.0326942913,
-0.0014233055,
0.0503595695,
-0.0240364354,
-0.0746689662,
0.007787358,
0.0342323966,
0.0742046088,
-0.000896686,
0.0541307665,
-0.0469781719,
0.012351756,
-0.0106142536,
0.0623039491,
0.014214512,
-0.0038690742,
0.0332268476,
0.0136384023,
-0.009740131,
-0.021563137,
0.0832131729,
-0.0345457643,
0.0472960658,
0.0092890048,
0.01686012,
-0.0501145273,
-0.0573037528,
0.044558499,
0.0180512387,
-0.0218850821,
-0.0204676185,
-0.062785551,
-0.0594046451,
-0.0108124642,
0.0278798733,
-0.0089849327,
-0.0252477229,
0.0316913873,
0.0706472695,
0.0341678411,
-0.0038173394,
-0.0299627595,
-0.0067610112,
-0.0218403935,
-0.006071554,
-0.0175451413,
-5.71890124e-33,
-0.0559257194,
-0.0512108728,
0.0525648743,
-0.0038382786,
-0.0081239808,
-0.0068259267,
-0.0470211431,
0.042302005,
0.028586911,
-0.0215248093,
0.011962329,
-0.0294585638,
0.0096414806,
0.0160450097,
0.0169774964,
-0.0024409355,
0.00712755,
0.0100600393,
-0.0293788407,
-0.011096973,
0.0364891179,
0.0115430318,
0.0387986191,
-0.0720769987,
0.0118657835,
0.0290363245,
-0.0034988129,
0.0084829386,
-0.0065712458,
0.067682825,
-0.0083492687,
0.0465238914,
0.0340815,
-0.0152272722,
-0.0182931554,
0.0206109919,
-0.0262296926,
-0.0335325226,
0.0462323464,
0.0299475472,
-0.0583035983,
-0.035616409,
0.0362006128,
-0.0071276808,
-0.0151963588,
-0.0047791768,
0.0143983001,
-0.0055646594,
-0.0238328129,
0.0016113456,
-0.0610123053,
0.0198539756,
-0.0007564049,
-0.0266062785,
-0.005322739,
0.0572039261,
-0.0039370712,
0.0147553803,
-0.0401709005,
-0.0045967614,
-0.0390347689,
-0.0004239115,
0.1019593328,
0.0309216473,
-0.0154760554,
0.0707343221,
0.0120715462,
-0.0024445492,
-0.0166624412,
0.0035622853,
0.0137826223,
0.086856626,
-0.0088457838,
0.0514793992,
-0.0329698361,
0.0109688584,
-0.0141607486,
0.0342987329,
0.0177824069,
0.0073217577,
0.0040900386,
0.0077959257,
-0.0032661413,
0.0031312411,
-0.0241770297,
-0.0130933914,
-0.0279787071,
-0.0328908153,
0.044877883,
-0.0196957812,
0.0379494093,
-0.010314405,
0.0562230945,
-0.0110844355,
-0.0148273911,
-0.0351409279,
-0.046646893,
0.0640207231,
0.0027488607,
0.0218510311,
0.0045183976,
-0.0226443931,
-0.0050456845,
0.0074183107,
0.0658089742,
0.0044172937,
-0.0005717134,
0.0465410464,
-0.0508438349,
0.0142835444,
-0.0691917688,
0.0310465787,
0.0001068092,
0.0324206837,
0.0458054207,
-0.05209383,
-0.0476972312,
0.0509960949,
-0.0289246943,
-0.0188725404,
-0.0381977595,
-0.0371788889,
-0.0427536964,
0.0027382062,
-0.0580350645,
-0.0002852541,
-0.0236532725,
0.0008491898,
0.0332341343,
-0.0245347247,
-0.0060071512,
-0.0100854151,
2.6e-7,
0.0401408598,
0.0257052816,
-0.0086345999,
0.0475478992,
0.0236549526,
0.0478809215,
-0.0337990969,
0.0286395252,
-0.0196591578,
-0.0421425924,
-0.0355132632,
0.021273097,
0.0646289885,
0.0427921675,
-0.0538038015,
-0.0088143181,
-0.0198658779,
0.0187573265,
-0.0712113753,
0.0202829354,
0.0537600629,
0.0311129056,
-0.0187198985,
-0.0358194634,
0.0066969935,
-0.0402953029,
0.0489931144,
-0.0517420582,
-0.0160647705,
0.0164038278,
0.0380895734,
0.007777364,
0.0148453331,
0.0046638562,
-0.0082569225,
-0.0430797189,
0.0109287659,
0.0672727525,
0.0176124703,
-0.0343066975,
0.0153736928,
-0.0235391259,
0.0023434917,
-0.0420520268,
0.042344477,
-0.0308461133,
-0.022972336,
-0.0371082053,
0.0232305638,
-0.0235905778,
-0.0329431146,
-0.0405372456,
-0.010255307,
0.0306355972,
-0.0068242908,
-0.0270151328,
-0.0284334905,
-0.0601439327,
-0.0436889492,
0.0314519033,
-0.0353734344,
-0.0428528413,
-0.0693043619,
-0.0295242593,
0.0179251172,
-0.0674570277,
-0.0334569551,
2.464103171e-34,
0.0091147944,
-0.0141593097,
0.0339438878,
0.0562220141,
0.0360673405,
0.0145627195,
0.0079025161,
0.0252458099,
-0.0004036394,
-0.0161915906,
-0.0202067345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.13029v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.13029v1 | Systematic word meta-sense extension | 2023-11-21T22:30:37 | 2023-11-21T22:30:37 | Lei Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The meaning of polysemous words often varies in a highly productive yet
predictable way. Generalizing the regularity between conventional senses to
derive novel word meaning is crucial for automated processing of non-literal
language uses such as figurative expressions. We introduce a novel task called
systematic word meta-sense extension (SWORME) to test and improve language
models' ability to extend word meaning to denote new semantic domains (also
called meta-senses) that bear regular semantic relations with existing senses.
We found that language models prefer incremental lexical semantic change toward
conceptually similar meta-senses such as logical metonymy, and are much worse
at predicting highly non-literal meaning extensions such as metaphors. We
propose a novel analogy-based method of word meaning extension, and show that
it effectively improves language model systematicity in making both gradual and
radical types of meta-sense extension. We further demonstrate that learning
systematic meta-sense extensions benefits language models on multiple
benchmarks of figurative language understanding. | [
0.0489193499,
-0.0001536363,
-0.0487313271,
0.0444420017,
-0.0333520547,
0.0080668302,
-0.0542193763,
0.007422253,
-0.0523903482,
-0.0586641915,
-0.0162926223,
0.005032192,
0.0034713279,
0.0417402312,
-0.0015290714,
-0.0554662086,
0.0515495129,
0.0074844728,
-0.0208580792,
-0.0024242073,
-0.043854218,
0.0202425495,
0.0063719167,
0.0119315283,
0.0046024201,
0.0026918901,
-0.0113061788,
-0.0073359716,
0.0271600559,
-0.036368262,
-0.0607899018,
-0.0101796491,
0.0311440099,
0.0057570525,
0.0000018573,
-0.0881554782,
-0.0207727738,
-0.0190889351,
0.0068429583,
-0.0405925773,
0.1157556847,
-0.0459558479,
0.0205639359,
-0.0332473293,
-0.0345873497,
0.0162936468,
0.0309059806,
-0.0239133704,
0.0083124423,
0.0029721598,
0.0006127239,
-0.0345428772,
-0.0176691003,
0.0038188975,
0.0240790341,
0.0028708449,
0.0260706656,
0.0472220294,
0.0031035841,
-0.0501087382,
-0.0801571012,
0.0123096127,
0.0131440097,
0.0508088022,
0.0003353436,
0.0122013278,
-0.0037301665,
0.0279571973,
0.0201659836,
0.0232642833,
-0.00126861,
-0.022545116,
-0.0522149578,
-0.0188856572,
-0.0170552228,
0.0608170256,
-0.0130670313,
-0.0095242467,
-0.001977609,
0.003696471,
0.0324968733,
0.0165382754,
0.0125838956,
0.0510812514,
-0.0494918302,
0.0737063438,
0.0196993593,
-0.0076560886,
0.0149827441,
-0.0375147872,
-0.0578881875,
0.0205042697,
-0.0282762442,
-0.0059539918,
0.0053854808,
0.0756353885,
-0.0048323241,
-0.0342813581,
0.0169439409,
-0.0785857812,
0.0549636334,
0.0738298744,
-0.0155706592,
0.0542805232,
-0.0212376863,
-0.0496626422,
0.0288419183,
0.0449944958,
-0.0667287037,
-0.0133605385,
-0.05647026,
0.0095320065,
-0.059770409,
0.0188218933,
-0.0349018909,
-0.0168369729,
-0.0282735992,
0.0236797072,
-0.0017390973,
-0.0603607483,
0.0069786301,
-0.0021466669,
-0.0591967851,
-0.0178400967,
-0.0708107129,
-0.0338137597,
-0.0516929179,
0.0434585772,
-0.0723827183,
-0.0207381994,
0.0051233904,
-0.0167447198,
0.016372947,
-0.0386010855,
0.0061283549,
0.0974651426,
0.0264956355,
-0.0568651631,
-0.034094505,
-0.0270433892,
-0.0194654074,
-0.0051068082,
-0.0367532335,
-0.0198931601,
0.0161840674,
-0.0315221436,
0.0172990914,
-0.0458644442,
-0.0156098288,
-0.0277037658,
-0.0303518586,
0.0639496446,
-0.0533436723,
0.0040436764,
-0.0177659988,
-0.0034075391,
-0.0689275935,
0.0636616051,
0.0492843017,
-0.0016814932,
0.0261393823,
-0.0034181867,
-0.0595613346,
0.0006286637,
-0.007297677,
-0.0217795521,
-0.0598680414,
-0.0036130811,
-0.0150594162,
0.0588390902,
-0.0023380357,
0.0304699056,
-0.0249843113,
-0.0087527586,
0.0081213787,
0.0286963414,
-0.0036831824,
-0.0155180879,
0.0979027078,
-0.0285810418,
-0.0089561651,
0.0050590141,
-0.044024881,
-0.0120001929,
-0.0053239125,
-0.0133156925,
-0.0549456514,
0.0271203294,
0.0113863936,
-0.0100601735,
-0.023346385,
-0.0122227892,
0.0019719403,
-0.0276997294,
0.0531758964,
0.0440822057,
0.0303374715,
0.01134717,
0.0551298484,
-0.0015469947,
0.0579740554,
-0.0284476709,
-0.0112753864,
0.0743876174,
0.0320970155,
-0.0570410788,
-0.019274829,
-0.0129431505,
-0.0190758016,
0.0455514193,
0.0013097133,
-0.015917331,
0.0079126526,
-0.0171352327,
0.0076390659,
-0.0219460763,
0.0163920838,
0.019203376,
-0.0162106473,
0.0066559562,
0.0158086717,
-0.1125129461,
0.0087863375,
0.0345215201,
-0.0784795359,
-0.0250846725,
-0.0213406496,
0.023494374,
-0.0060058008,
0.0009025529,
0.009115397,
0.004619787,
0.009034452,
-0.0602256246,
-0.0448638387,
0.0987164155,
-0.0322549753,
0.0071922708,
0.032786563,
-0.063229613,
-0.0001824748,
0.0054930244,
-0.0001806011,
-0.003333109,
0.0415807068,
-0.0083963852,
0.1088725552,
-0.0693571046,
0.002253979,
-0.0403141603,
0.024441082,
-0.0182123184,
0.0715545118,
-0.0169506874,
-0.0078345146,
-0.0169540029,
-0.017936023,
-0.0090520838,
0.0748983398,
-0.0162003133,
0.0032733518,
0.0157724209,
0.0046751052,
0.0073575871,
-0.0462129153,
-0.0851433501,
-0.0151370186,
-0.0439550877,
0.0013022636,
0.0099457847,
-0.005529894,
0.0519253202,
0.0216715243,
-0.0249084253,
-0.0026148045,
0.039947845,
-0.007857413,
-0.034935616,
0.0377467237,
0.0182992369,
-0.0141511513,
-0.0216184948,
-0.0166400634,
-0.011218722,
-0.041348014,
0.0659168139,
-0.0163171571,
0.0537941903,
0.0292695984,
-0.0468487553,
-0.0558725111,
-0.0046215667,
-0.0024679562,
-0.0159478039,
-0.0182145499,
0.0081520686,
0.0295108911,
-0.0232636817,
0.038826555,
0.0456190594,
0.0833913013,
0.0004837147,
-0.034502577,
-0.0110892616,
-0.0013434124,
-0.0083880946,
-0.037457183,
-0.0304361302,
-0.0286704805,
0.0365729071,
0.0330285691,
-0.017615011,
-0.0384441763,
0.0746411532,
-0.0473599099,
-0.0399300158,
0.0087427394,
0.0220735725,
-0.0340965241,
0.0456396937,
-0.0245168321,
0.0037617136,
0.0685427412,
0.0114081865,
0.0032593319,
-0.0310987476,
-0.0062904935,
-0.023149671,
0.1138788089,
-0.0291480366,
0.0460462831,
0.0064386008,
0.0032210331,
-0.0354862995,
-0.0615755767,
0.0558656417,
-0.0285649151,
0.0733105913,
-0.0218666252,
0.0053818487,
0.0225861333,
0.0329349339,
-0.0527497828,
-0.0112789581,
-0.0456251055,
0.0047570276,
-0.0187015347,
0.0438423306,
-0.0040840674,
-0.0249086432,
-0.0313326903,
-0.0010266586,
0.0212066919,
-0.045382645,
-0.0240034834,
-0.0104689104,
0.0330341682,
0.0094719715,
0.0016872543,
0.019781135,
0.0516580231,
0.0019178236,
-0.0649815947,
-0.038775228,
-0.0538764745,
0.031699881,
-0.0124718053,
-0.079487063,
0.0234407708,
-0.0184025485,
-0.0146361645,
-0.0446029045,
-0.0034554435,
0.0685913265,
0.0659184083,
0.0030874624,
0.0626711622,
-0.0562691838,
0.0085073812,
0.0493949056,
-0.0193288382,
-0.0592529066,
-0.0485761501,
-0.0171127133,
-0.0255735163,
-0.0032821354,
-0.0638735816,
-0.0252235886,
-0.0640318692,
-0.0087711774,
-0.0240007918,
-0.0437107682,
0.0402821861,
0.0048297807,
0.0573618524,
-0.0005131229,
0.0015918742,
-0.0022365774,
-0.040375378,
0.0069468133,
-0.0192832276,
0.0369615182,
-0.0204770751,
0.045173876,
-0.0124100093,
0.0140699409,
0.0025663481,
0.0358496271,
-0.0235603135,
-0.0081611099,
0.0279212408,
-0.0035489262,
0.0177262444,
-0.0075560161,
0.0185158737,
0.0098934406,
0.0355176069,
0.0272476766,
-0.0108797057,
-0.0173483808,
-0.0564746447,
-0.0035959512,
0.0633840561,
-0.0108396346,
-0.0315828323,
-0.0535662808,
0.0142125096,
-0.0280259233,
0.0471144058,
0.0194900073,
-0.0520721078,
0.0347266495,
-0.0021587017,
-0.0321157351,
0.0139308758,
0.0027945274,
-0.0073048985,
-0.0346019864,
-0.0172271822,
-0.0466458537,
-0.0287420284,
0.0005645133,
0.0374386348,
0.0394145623,
0.0271745827,
-0.0288149342,
-0.0212716106,
-0.0832746923,
0.0337063074,
-0.0109971119,
0.0142109329,
0.0326133296,
0.0049330965,
0.0613062382,
-0.0617604665,
-0.0254938547,
0.0202028938,
-0.0184755437,
-0.0331240669,
0.0197071321,
0.0119831469,
0.0231452454,
0.019883791,
-0.0085967751,
0.0156451911,
0.0308037549,
0.0008497736,
0.0049064956,
0.0541396774,
0.040218927,
0.0188414026,
0.0058370312,
0.0513894632,
-0.0096581262,
0.0457534455,
0.0180922393,
0.027090637,
0.0212595146,
0.0119836265,
0.0596489683,
0.0062866816,
0.0197330974,
-0.0280442853,
-0.027015863,
-0.0069952682,
-0.0307633448,
-0.0120030725,
-0.0483599454,
0.0080332886,
0.0048597939,
0.0346856713,
0.0230793972,
-0.0399994664,
-0.0310286339,
-0.0386695527,
-0.0043768254,
0.0735972002,
-0.0024591894,
0.0327465124,
0.0231452305,
-0.023722209,
0.0141590033,
-0.0197548997,
-0.0346260034,
-0.0615958832,
0.0120904082,
-0.0482589751,
-0.0017259797,
0.011363755,
0.0023081342,
-0.0555028878,
0.0409518555,
-0.0206895079,
-0.0268113799,
0.0196643025,
0.045685146,
0.0179343503,
0.0101962518,
0.0125869988,
-0.0438662991,
0.0195084698,
0.0187918041,
0.0248891562,
0.0028749777,
-0.0242742561,
0.0159435999,
0.0194595959,
-0.0028196522,
-0.0355467573,
-0.0238060411,
-0.1186540276,
0.083050333,
0.0057988362,
-0.0003882208,
-0.0115657821,
-0.0177134387,
-0.0322233774,
0.0461737253,
-0.0031531905,
0.0444680303,
-0.1047770306,
-0.0626630709,
0.0744010955,
0.0379865393,
0.0096393805,
0.0112736868,
0.0274398234,
0.0177288093,
0.0286668707,
0.01473979,
-0.0296331458,
-0.0068507353,
-0.0003404157,
0.0239684526,
0.0073359362,
-5.677903303e-33,
-0.0407737792,
0.0105134221,
0.0092479829,
-0.0374134034,
-0.0354936235,
-0.0179240163,
-0.0302884821,
0.0066400524,
-0.0103866076,
-0.0005078538,
0.0228189789,
0.013258229,
-0.0009157977,
-0.0238797106,
0.0212535094,
0.0192033872,
0.0105955964,
0.0256315563,
-0.0125109488,
-0.0480854623,
0.0599421188,
0.0037250412,
0.055405546,
-0.0042589535,
0.0049484395,
0.0648054481,
-0.0118924594,
0.0013804107,
0.0158159919,
0.0529504046,
0.0035687741,
0.0619741417,
0.0370051302,
0.0488339104,
-0.0012054718,
-0.0428055301,
-0.0579746738,
-0.0705148354,
0.0829133987,
-0.0146020167,
-0.0352156945,
-0.0112336911,
0.0402971432,
0.0034078038,
-0.0050917086,
-0.0001909571,
0.0485039093,
-0.0413466878,
-0.0155938836,
0.0232447702,
-0.0714736879,
0.0120480508,
0.0192400981,
-0.0004533824,
-0.0193324909,
0.01896929,
0.0292871241,
0.0247579999,
0.0079423636,
0.0236637667,
-0.0460787825,
-0.01413061,
0.0080785928,
0.0044050761,
0.0005938957,
0.0750151202,
-0.005162992,
-0.0258566178,
0.0265398473,
0.0026276896,
0.0743209869,
0.0295091234,
-0.0310342778,
0.103859365,
0.1098068878,
-0.0275024772,
0.0216538496,
0.0020393054,
0.0272409189,
0.0324890837,
0.0327225551,
-0.0045376462,
0.00680411,
0.0397369713,
-0.0799984336,
0.0345893688,
-0.0371814333,
-0.052405715,
0.0359795801,
-0.0162826069,
-0.0065870928,
0.0214221235,
0.005484628,
-0.0454741456,
0.0330840424,
-0.0105232624,
-0.0351903811,
0.0060686693,
-0.0117389467,
0.0214389414,
0.0608970337,
-0.0700276121,
0.0160891749,
0.0209915526,
0.0115487287,
0.0058821901,
0.0374134369,
0.0005667954,
-0.0249894653,
0.0129563734,
-0.0084510315,
-0.0282844305,
-0.0290214885,
-0.0707337111,
0.0081434995,
0.0529305153,
-0.0175544005,
0.0000417011,
0.0590248853,
-0.0465053432,
-0.0410429165,
0.0314036198,
-0.0013826853,
0.0473683402,
-0.0339441746,
-0.0043987329,
-0.0007164482,
-0.0575894825,
0.0589104258,
-0.0644300357,
-0.0061366046,
-0.0056710872,
2.747e-7,
0.0820283145,
0.0355699882,
-0.0176242702,
0.0595671497,
-0.0035149853,
-0.016632678,
-0.0181027092,
0.0393893532,
-0.0125946822,
-0.0069881757,
0.0092866858,
0.0261995122,
-0.0298753101,
0.032355234,
-0.0397418812,
0.0378865376,
-0.0116501274,
0.0401890315,
-0.0282815676,
0.0138073144,
0.0788961351,
0.0653720498,
0.0504182726,
-0.0153418528,
-0.0299484152,
-0.0372146778,
0.0564794056,
-0.0479007736,
0.036371544,
0.0075839264,
-0.0028141115,
0.020290345,
0.0275512859,
0.0325082615,
0.0007433002,
0.0284970924,
0.0150581896,
0.0218699258,
-0.062143039,
0.0374080501,
-0.0113473525,
-0.0511135496,
0.0109372456,
-0.0028007017,
0.0481837243,
-0.053913828,
-0.0168749578,
-0.0527328998,
-0.0300031193,
0.052632045,
0.0269466769,
-0.0215964485,
-0.0280749146,
0.0181118511,
0.0352099389,
0.0058563636,
-0.0232582539,
-0.0555334799,
-0.0034795236,
0.0277817976,
-0.011481897,
-0.0141563863,
0.0253778547,
-0.0287474804,
0.021974491,
-0.0989178196,
-0.0040462189,
1.647660585e-34,
0.0464070179,
0.0323471241,
0.0233956277,
-0.0149742328,
0.0276139993,
-0.0314046293,
0.0603419021,
0.0278391801,
0.0203176625,
-0.0295527857,
-0.0124304984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12986v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12986v2 | Unsupervised Graph Attention Autoencoder for Attributed Networks using K-means Loss | 2023-11-21T20:45:55 | 2023-11-24T22:24:50 | Abdelfateh Bekkair, Slimane Bellaouar, Slimane Oulad-Naoui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, I.2.4 | Several natural phenomena and complex systems are often represented as
networks. Discovering their community structure is a fundamental task for
understanding these networks. Many algorithms have been proposed, but recently,
Graph Neural Networks (GNN) have emerged as a compelling approach for enhancing
this task.In this paper, we introduce a simple, efficient, and
clustering-oriented model based on unsupervised \textbf{G}raph Attention
\textbf{A}uto\textbf{E}ncoder for community detection in attributed networks
(GAECO). The proposed model adeptly learns representations from both the
network's topology and attribute information, simultaneously addressing dual
objectives: reconstruction and community discovery. It places a particular
emphasis on discovering compact communities by robustly minimizing clustering
errors. The model employs k-means as an objective function and utilizes a
multi-head Graph Attention Auto-Encoder for decoding the representations.
Experiments conducted on three datasets of attributed networks show that our
method surpasses state-of-the-art algorithms in terms of NMI and ARI.
Additionally, our approach scales effectively with the size of the network,
making it suitable for large-scale applications. The implications of our
findings extend beyond biological network interpretation and social network
analysis, where knowledge of the fundamental community structure is essential. | [
-0.0519926064,
0.0595775694,
-0.0119855078,
0.0183077063,
0.0322002769,
-0.0103424247,
0.0120434621,
-0.0076764021,
0.0601779819,
0.0273316577,
-0.0087593803,
0.0021462922,
0.026952792,
0.0348152928,
0.0588340871,
0.0093595609,
0.015199109,
0.0417775065,
-0.023720216,
-0.0334261693,
0.0106238667,
0.0205306392,
0.0575725473,
0.0239895508,
0.0074957605,
-0.0042802594,
0.0161147416,
0.0126562063,
0.0488348976,
-0.0255747549,
0.0138227968,
-0.0042790673,
-0.0053260014,
-0.0011971702,
0.0000021754,
-0.0034924776,
-0.0297617931,
-0.0515861176,
-0.0275101028,
0.0404614694,
0.0080381008,
0.0326748081,
0.0671352521,
0.004775479,
-0.0021876956,
-0.02370275,
0.0760706961,
-0.0214174055,
0.0281479638,
0.0378558859,
-0.0046103033,
-0.0421206988,
0.0087601924,
-0.0662979633,
-0.0266091302,
-0.0015064349,
0.0293892976,
0.0009475551,
-0.0005669733,
-0.0172975697,
-0.0574240796,
0.0203001946,
0.0095214713,
-0.0132450359,
0.0938961878,
0.0479416922,
0.0022948259,
0.0111012943,
0.0316232815,
0.1093312055,
-0.0096447309,
-0.013894462,
0.0621516109,
-0.007106883,
0.0026711989,
0.0265066046,
-0.016913116,
-0.0057317349,
0.0174955279,
0.0096799349,
-0.0388009176,
0.0517456494,
0.0754465461,
-0.0366305858,
-0.0359056778,
0.0622642152,
-0.000931752,
0.0644285902,
-0.0167784523,
-0.0062300013,
-0.0449328609,
0.0246039145,
0.0544762313,
-0.0034792032,
0.0294852685,
-0.0394253656,
0.0134652471,
-0.0026392422,
-0.0280104559,
0.0499639399,
0.0147804748,
-0.0267775767,
0.0042065769,
0.024378825,
-0.005133606,
-0.0243421737,
-0.0674385726,
0.0618694015,
0.001495574,
0.0082777049,
-0.0610020459,
0.0047803121,
0.0052766837,
0.0194145944,
0.0276288819,
-0.0254187919,
-0.0043497114,
0.0199770667,
-0.0708824173,
-0.0411538482,
0.0136926677,
0.0417148173,
0.0383920446,
-0.0134707829,
0.0345903151,
0.0159090124,
-0.039879065,
0.0514795631,
0.017551139,
0.0136064356,
-0.039643202,
0.0490903668,
0.0813137591,
0.0001835643,
-0.0199857298,
0.0388763808,
0.052290678,
-0.0266158748,
0.0082939873,
-0.0028429024,
-0.0261246916,
-0.0293023009,
0.0167139582,
-0.0331389755,
0.0451029949,
-0.0078807864,
0.0172716752,
-0.03890609,
-0.0048870184,
-0.0646292567,
-0.0510851964,
0.0169557873,
-0.0112966942,
-0.0017454705,
0.0268880632,
-0.0518224351,
0.0191050582,
-0.0204081573,
-0.0024036653,
0.0495099463,
-0.022129178,
-0.0114960866,
-0.0134984665,
0.0158600546,
0.0925653875,
-0.0422769487,
0.0512185581,
-0.01188605,
-0.038593512,
0.0154102799,
0.0620863177,
0.0458362699,
-0.0358286463,
-0.0477980785,
0.0126609216,
0.0011232632,
-0.0280928798,
0.051267311,
-0.0264518019,
0.0392944217,
-0.0236152969,
-0.0281119272,
-0.0374795347,
0.0444910005,
-0.0171591844,
-0.012512912,
0.0465536676,
0.0212432388,
-0.0410393402,
-0.0021906961,
0.0340360291,
-0.000674896,
0.0615651198,
-0.0056897118,
0.0614123605,
0.008872088,
0.0016593958,
-0.0074505033,
0.0130592082,
0.025460612,
0.0470859595,
0.001152792,
0.0114979465,
0.0102560306,
0.0225169025,
-0.0255665444,
0.0349729657,
-0.0393411927,
-0.0073482222,
-0.0596941151,
-0.0435219035,
-0.002200786,
-0.0268741865,
-0.0288925357,
-0.0219751503,
-0.0323302485,
0.015642127,
0.0390430689,
-0.0340613499,
0.0063932426,
0.0012687898,
-0.067569375,
-0.0467337184,
-0.0007779035,
0.0272062998,
0.0276744086,
0.0186138358,
0.0098614497,
0.0182343535,
0.0384547971,
0.0146844471,
0.00204401,
0.0181890521,
-0.0193771794,
-0.0367550552,
-0.0210741609,
-0.0125636123,
-0.0308392849,
0.0145569453,
-0.0579830371,
-0.0373854898,
0.0823594406,
-0.0067417747,
-0.0206563268,
0.1044533104,
-0.0923558697,
0.0149626955,
0.008306697,
-0.0475515798,
-0.030310275,
0.0327814892,
0.0067348359,
0.0285439622,
-0.0119721713,
-0.0277448855,
-0.0041047879,
-0.0240188036,
-0.0326016508,
-0.0668663159,
-0.0047565447,
-0.0469079725,
0.0122071132,
-0.0232772939,
0.0552643053,
-0.0444570221,
0.016483834,
0.0685123801,
-0.0194054227,
-0.0061717927,
-0.0272006951,
-0.0130820675,
-0.0011535708,
0.0027526799,
0.0427859277,
-0.0223689266,
0.0035836103,
0.0789579004,
-0.0114365648,
-0.0249249842,
0.0362137556,
-0.046108041,
-0.0286493003,
-0.017226303,
-0.0724999756,
-0.0292550121,
0.1171792075,
0.0374542437,
-0.0562256537,
0.0264802687,
0.0067475247,
-0.0272365976,
-0.062389534,
-0.0060272152,
-0.0106176948,
-0.0276411995,
0.0165747721,
-0.0210326258,
0.0598541424,
-0.0015273612,
-0.0017768857,
0.0328685232,
0.026101755,
-0.0106599731,
-0.0342386551,
-0.0700394064,
0.0240470767,
0.0020399024,
-0.0340305939,
-0.0047640456,
0.0549812317,
0.0247391555,
-0.0110304961,
-0.0163490549,
-0.0168724526,
0.0275057741,
0.012490713,
-0.0219538398,
-0.002314125,
0.0339334123,
-0.0016354384,
-0.0436657555,
0.0051088319,
0.0701510757,
0.0382728428,
-0.010571829,
0.0640660003,
0.0316069834,
0.0024115532,
-0.0008797536,
0.0787627175,
0.0449543782,
0.0072828154,
-0.0379201658,
0.0187480915,
0.020063702,
0.0347132497,
0.0047977818,
-0.0367784165,
0.041494634,
0.0040290551,
0.0469788201,
0.0055008293,
0.0000971794,
0.0650042668,
0.0172234885,
0.0142850094,
0.048063051,
0.0052776108,
-0.0350930952,
0.0061599677,
0.0258064214,
-0.0138653275,
0.0016877826,
0.0184509549,
-0.0006820969,
0.0912411138,
0.0095071336,
-0.0389604382,
0.0418256931,
-0.0289221667,
-0.0393098705,
0.0142373489,
-0.00487018,
0.005620508,
-0.0286057517,
-0.0041783755,
-0.0363701284,
0.0133771179,
0.0228865799,
-0.045305077,
0.0526977889,
-0.0026914862,
-0.0120857144,
0.0070657148,
-0.0156376008,
-0.0447607152,
0.0162719712,
0.0002450871,
0.0099025574,
0.0336206593,
-0.0135530699,
-0.0306476746,
0.0075266412,
-0.0311391074,
0.0501890518,
0.0575712137,
-0.0553987212,
0.0433410928,
-0.0192530528,
0.0098553179,
0.0560681969,
-0.074667573,
-0.0469997041,
-0.1082162112,
0.012220582,
-0.0833580345,
-0.0371311381,
-0.007706169,
0.0250938833,
-0.0006987178,
0.0056390832,
-0.0580936335,
-0.0018346049,
0.0004899919,
-0.031850487,
0.08387243,
-0.0088232104,
-0.0094832759,
0.0090689491,
0.0088978577,
-0.004453613,
-0.0064072963,
-0.0407961607,
0.0071241106,
0.0488898829,
-0.0027276629,
0.0035869966,
-0.0174484514,
0.0721133351,
-0.0538489521,
0.0053361398,
-0.0372127853,
0.1028504446,
0.002231709,
-0.0645749345,
-0.001194038,
-0.059169285,
-0.0067286366,
-0.0147942118,
0.0576109104,
0.0151567524,
-0.0415968709,
-0.0205822699,
0.0211625621,
-0.0501137935,
-0.0535108894,
0.0273533929,
0.013592422,
-0.049713254,
-0.0093755145,
0.0139795309,
0.0057166303,
-0.0237963051,
0.0002425775,
-0.0662892684,
0.0893407166,
-0.0657531172,
-0.1000289917,
0.0273474511,
-0.0438455269,
-0.0105421441,
0.0077033574,
-0.0379099362,
0.019701805,
-0.0157777816,
-0.0123100858,
0.0498138182,
-0.0541283004,
-0.0475457795,
0.0005120944,
0.0109775607,
-0.0050202054,
0.0668093488,
-0.0361557379,
-0.0387260355,
0.0387501828,
0.0021491644,
-0.0312476866,
-0.0063613798,
-0.012366035,
-0.0543902218,
-0.0466775633,
0.0345073529,
-0.0180950705,
0.0364474729,
0.0346632972,
-0.0050813681,
-0.0663932562,
-0.0396137275,
-0.0174738411,
0.0272023641,
0.0490714274,
-0.0002417244,
0.011199329,
-0.0681879222,
-0.0632079318,
0.0441243611,
0.0256940275,
0.0038570601,
-0.0416195467,
0.0461780801,
0.0165088158,
-0.0036232197,
-0.0318834521,
0.0211300049,
0.0145091973,
-0.0371966362,
0.0002653554,
-0.0321862735,
-0.0253373142,
-0.0126795126,
0.0384502001,
-0.02176724,
0.0097749056,
0.0057993098,
0.0178275276,
-0.0022537464,
-0.011848039,
0.0070396871,
-0.012139176,
-0.0460329615,
0.0102515547,
-0.0255695079,
0.042060975,
-0.0604460314,
0.0194804091,
0.0037595003,
-0.0160976909,
0.0418015383,
0.0117257098,
-0.0007109697,
-0.0809292197,
0.0481932685,
-0.0394786708,
-0.0571014732,
0.0059524658,
0.0029777254,
-0.0215653814,
0.031525746,
0.0553691201,
0.0335405543,
-0.0158408303,
-0.037579421,
-0.0386006385,
-0.0200063884,
-0.002348694,
-0.0138960155,
0.0228947457,
-0.038211789,
0.0224113856,
0.0065312702,
-0.0394097976,
0.0019638708,
-0.0471784212,
0.0039904071,
0.0404623039,
0.024020711,
-0.0296059549,
-0.012774026,
-0.0004151468,
-0.0081974911,
0.0519576296,
-0.0474089459,
0.0020040548,
0.0050983508,
-6.835519486e-33,
0.0034266133,
-0.0882746875,
-0.066701062,
-0.0007284827,
-0.0315113552,
0.01322533,
-0.0631255358,
-0.0212280285,
-0.004958713,
0.0013833402,
-0.0027054185,
0.0140685504,
-0.03693128,
0.0394446999,
0.0000668506,
-0.0012101472,
0.0208441112,
0.0200319067,
-0.0084641958,
0.073264882,
0.0256860945,
-0.0019622003,
0.018531803,
-0.0808974952,
-0.0045331065,
-0.0210268497,
0.0209435839,
-0.0167153459,
0.0217693914,
0.0070894444,
-0.0424430519,
0.046380505,
0.0009055694,
-0.0181204937,
0.0015659054,
-0.0314605236,
-0.0575674139,
-0.0098699499,
-0.0558683127,
-0.007179115,
-0.0205720924,
-0.0473919623,
0.0427628718,
-0.0025466888,
0.0355044007,
-0.0513803288,
0.064069517,
0.014611329,
-0.0195300393,
0.0142008513,
0.0060275998,
0.0175590515,
-0.0706568956,
0.0128314793,
0.0226555988,
-0.0239025448,
0.0017993298,
0.0458906218,
-0.0732204393,
0.0407448821,
-0.0729321539,
-0.024778448,
0.0299405139,
0.0360750034,
0.0326280445,
0.037920747,
0.0181443095,
0.0408413485,
-0.0385587141,
0.0425500534,
-0.0046858406,
0.0548125952,
0.019534627,
0.0148634305,
-0.0650649145,
-0.0310489684,
-0.0664606541,
0.0117074335,
-0.040448755,
0.0211628489,
0.0033974908,
0.049786929,
0.0162357632,
-0.0414460711,
0.0374854319,
-0.0818627551,
-0.0342622995,
0.0027784847,
-0.0512214676,
-0.0350913815,
-0.0884997696,
0.0560242049,
-0.011487483,
-0.0658715442,
0.0075215348,
0.0503651053,
0.0457259864,
0.0437456518,
0.0389177538,
0.0250938609,
-0.0568608753,
-0.0045974148,
0.0052719214,
-0.001346547,
0.0153860338,
-0.0036223091,
0.0127078239,
0.0218749978,
0.0301426034,
-0.0275469758,
-0.0159062222,
-0.0673188418,
-0.0370934792,
-0.0526823439,
0.0207923874,
0.0207669511,
0.002848471,
0.0535908379,
0.0574076585,
0.0428291857,
0.0061459658,
0.0194152091,
-0.0185624044,
0.0295560658,
-0.0402091891,
-0.0410340615,
-0.0202615559,
0.0108124688,
-0.0141883669,
-0.0405018404,
-0.0398079939,
-0.0546437167,
2.999e-7,
0.0471740402,
0.023468554,
0.0611946434,
-0.0420114622,
0.0149783334,
0.0007852138,
0.0205962174,
0.0804168135,
-0.0522203743,
-0.0210022647,
0.0611712933,
0.0529270098,
-0.0281467196,
-0.0202864893,
-0.0188549776,
0.0480825156,
-0.0220198631,
0.0258919578,
-0.0140021974,
-0.024300918,
-0.0420482792,
0.0530997589,
0.0396343544,
0.0462951474,
0.0296011809,
-0.0076191258,
0.0585941896,
-0.0010952844,
0.0105208587,
0.0075472966,
0.0121835005,
-0.0109833702,
-0.0510626398,
-0.0068494459,
0.0178493205,
0.0368768163,
0.052790083,
0.0067826482,
-0.0128536886,
-0.0136475349,
-0.0021687509,
0.001746084,
0.0188191347,
-0.0769542158,
0.0225054119,
-0.0672211125,
-0.0259845685,
0.0328460634,
-0.0355023518,
-0.0001511677,
0.0397124328,
0.0086173909,
0.0270277448,
-0.0054486981,
-0.0235394724,
-0.0089307018,
0.0313687772,
-0.060023196,
0.0312441047,
0.0143284574,
-0.0523806885,
-0.0439883135,
-0.0013846726,
0.0164381433,
0.0820411295,
0.0297234003,
0.0159751885,
2.125728857e-34,
0.0247544888,
0.0157176256,
-0.029815333,
-0.0153762633,
0.0016880431,
-0.0816864446,
-0.0441061221,
-0.019307496,
0.0287848692,
-0.042328313,
-0.0144119915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12983v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12983v1 | GAIA: a benchmark for General AI Assistants | 2023-11-21T20:34:47 | 2023-11-21T20:34:47 | Grégoire Mialon, Clémentine Fourrier, Craig Swift, Thomas Wolf, Yann LeCun, Thomas Scialom | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce GAIA, a benchmark for General AI Assistants that, if solved,
would represent a milestone in AI research. GAIA proposes real-world questions
that require a set of fundamental abilities such as reasoning, multi-modality
handling, web browsing, and generally tool-use proficiency. GAIA questions are
conceptually simple for humans yet challenging for most advanced AIs: we show
that human respondents obtain 92\% vs. 15\% for GPT-4 equipped with plugins.
This notable performance disparity contrasts with the recent trend of LLMs
outperforming humans on tasks requiring professional skills in e.g. law or
chemistry. GAIA's philosophy departs from the current trend in AI benchmarks
suggesting to target tasks that are ever more difficult for humans. We posit
that the advent of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) hinges on a system's
capability to exhibit similar robustness as the average human does on such
questions. Using GAIA's methodology, we devise 466 questions and their answer.
We release our questions while retaining answers to 300 of them to power a
leader-board available at https://huggingface.co/gaia-benchmark. | [
0.0106788659,
0.0661976039,
-0.032451313,
-0.0105232969,
-0.0247481968,
0.0146519765,
0.0165655799,
-0.008687295,
0.0429962277,
0.0026163654,
-0.0063225897,
-0.015040447,
-0.0618655011,
0.0458390042,
0.0002213632,
-0.0414902568,
0.0254108459,
-0.0280655492,
0.0293972623,
-0.0046078931,
-0.0129505359,
-0.004509741,
-0.0470826775,
0.031732738,
-0.0422481187,
0.0003603868,
-0.010479887,
-0.0205689166,
0.0160711333,
-0.0236907881,
-0.0032634838,
0.0095221484,
0.0015638265,
0.0147640742,
0.0000021696,
-0.0603278168,
0.0363714322,
0.0046961838,
-0.0551207848,
-0.0111164935,
-0.0058909697,
0.0259156879,
0.0109159583,
0.0423638076,
-0.0608525462,
0.0305105411,
0.0109746465,
-0.0113615151,
0.0187915806,
0.0604162849,
-0.0075222994,
-0.003446057,
0.0411519259,
-0.0331120528,
0.0238379128,
-0.1120751202,
-0.0337972119,
-0.0087585151,
0.0492753908,
-0.0828886405,
0.0291841682,
0.0261502396,
0.0577819385,
0.0000713382,
-0.0032417849,
0.0427281782,
-0.0390718393,
-0.006972956,
-0.0265998542,
0.0780078173,
-0.002631129,
0.010389016,
-0.0068044844,
0.0064627421,
0.0339067839,
-0.0027702544,
-0.0487542935,
0.0288767368,
-0.0246380102,
-0.0246738549,
-0.0082569821,
0.0032852676,
0.0223199502,
0.007239813,
-0.0294772107,
0.0719472244,
0.002189979,
-0.0226956364,
0.0759190693,
0.0150196552,
0.0146496212,
-0.049044814,
0.0009039269,
0.0833042413,
-0.074003391,
-0.0145755867,
-0.0171125997,
0.0167109985,
0.039439179,
-0.0038708944,
0.0383720547,
0.0632987171,
0.0051110839,
0.0544605479,
0.0024323249,
0.0864929333,
0.0042393398,
0.0235882066,
-0.025083812,
-0.0425254777,
-0.0750390217,
0.0019972008,
-0.0329062566,
0.0393630899,
-0.0305323731,
0.0138508109,
-0.0152240414,
0.0306150261,
-0.0494574346,
0.0431539491,
-0.0173464976,
0.0380232558,
-0.0211295672,
-0.0170323029,
-0.0375940613,
-0.0286366884,
-0.1057064459,
0.0537752174,
0.0367410108,
-0.0637023598,
0.005994475,
-0.008855883,
0.0126898894,
-0.0278728195,
0.0523944497,
0.0903166831,
-0.0096525224,
-0.0390255004,
-0.0107119903,
-0.0404114462,
0.0503813215,
-0.0780843571,
-0.0018810056,
-0.0079543497,
0.0631281883,
0.0229954813,
-0.0323477834,
-0.0268081129,
-0.0175773222,
0.0091294888,
0.0153988693,
0.070332028,
0.0268362872,
-0.0059017176,
0.0474831238,
0.0355714895,
-0.0820024237,
0.0324262343,
0.0141253732,
0.0385680646,
0.0278537795,
0.0218811557,
0.0705239624,
0.0201863144,
-0.0171978977,
0.0050331159,
0.0381785035,
0.0490442961,
-0.0490072668,
0.0565325059,
0.0028372412,
0.0458784923,
0.0214502402,
-0.0215456691,
0.0630292743,
0.0787760988,
-0.03639419,
0.045625858,
0.0314258374,
-0.0394010469,
0.0648688823,
-0.0064371363,
-0.0773423538,
0.028621519,
-0.0518556722,
-0.0053601647,
-0.044159472,
0.0330901146,
-0.032075353,
-0.0424044915,
0.014179037,
-0.0133976387,
0.0050539663,
-0.0004018238,
0.0314120911,
-0.0367678367,
-0.0295762066,
-0.0421549827,
-0.0299676806,
-0.0615188107,
-0.0213442929,
-0.080187194,
0.0293728746,
0.0380387269,
0.0498605333,
-0.069972381,
-0.0476848185,
0.0231959801,
-0.0029075078,
0.0104850866,
0.0389216803,
-0.0004190805,
0.0233444739,
-0.0284360182,
0.0038010573,
-0.0450825617,
0.0148712927,
0.0522750877,
0.0243690647,
0.0550458468,
0.0095005417,
-0.0526154451,
0.0115263211,
0.0204520468,
-0.0235648043,
-0.0357396789,
-0.0230213609,
0.00962961,
0.0324284434,
0.0146929855,
0.0038759408,
0.0092586922,
0.023829909,
-0.0139638595,
-0.0225026552,
0.0060859122,
0.0203333665,
0.0605659634,
0.0342782587,
-0.0669844225,
-0.0428470857,
0.0728276148,
-0.0401173308,
-0.0347588994,
-0.0051060794,
-0.0181616824,
0.0262825117,
-0.0068960292,
0.0006909699,
0.0091395611,
0.0037090033,
0.024135923,
0.0672702268,
0.0175654665,
-0.0385380499,
0.0055927304,
0.006541722,
0.0369030945,
-0.0551575907,
-0.0109964274,
-0.0100361388,
-0.0089473799,
0.0185511131,
0.0201857351,
-0.0001748735,
-0.0696295053,
-0.0017608198,
-0.0996911973,
0.0163598061,
-0.0068648783,
-0.0076315482,
0.0085211247,
-0.0160120428,
-0.0086246915,
-0.0238797907,
-0.0506348014,
0.0417410433,
0.0111420257,
0.0002346202,
0.0273668449,
0.0312825367,
-0.0052825632,
-0.0688776821,
0.0379597396,
-0.0232698116,
-0.0489398092,
0.0448358431,
0.0225910451,
0.0179250967,
-0.0032437022,
-0.037189573,
0.0392420739,
-0.0158587452,
-0.0422041938,
0.0285726059,
-0.0190386381,
0.0080131367,
0.1120774671,
-0.005937648,
0.0212923419,
0.0610190406,
0.0013618841,
-0.0301874168,
0.0385686941,
0.0113634048,
-0.0302330703,
0.0061585344,
-0.0207916759,
0.0130920513,
0.0255637802,
-0.0093487566,
0.0334780589,
-0.0246970356,
0.0525674447,
0.0041128723,
-0.0501728654,
-0.0321704037,
0.0131251626,
-0.0293406975,
0.052516032,
-0.0180728827,
-0.0485304445,
0.0551302023,
0.0221718643,
0.0167928748,
-0.0001261925,
-0.0161838755,
-0.0208679736,
0.0773500577,
-0.0035643494,
0.0132308025,
-0.0442624688,
0.0005968685,
-0.0586875491,
0.0133320577,
0.0179558694,
-0.0508959219,
0.0384837054,
-0.0825735703,
0.0194083489,
-0.0176872797,
-0.083777748,
-0.043890167,
-0.0013677656,
-0.0348649733,
0.0250679702,
0.0020001391,
-0.0449854732,
-0.0518683232,
-0.0439991765,
0.0070682284,
0.0296906196,
0.0012828851,
-0.0220117047,
-0.0074765291,
0.0055061691,
0.0232055318,
0.0423006453,
-0.0021073374,
0.0085903136,
0.0013703331,
0.0402629673,
0.0501351021,
-0.0090262461,
-0.0091691958,
0.0088049769,
-0.0020657056,
-0.0471479632,
-0.0077695944,
0.0278872829,
0.0269425604,
-0.0437379517,
-0.0140255382,
0.103080906,
0.0418275371,
-0.0315601639,
0.0089181075,
-0.0233861264,
-0.0221038051,
0.0301218163,
0.0607793666,
-0.0733497366,
-0.0198354833,
0.022846248,
0.043606177,
-0.0283662695,
-0.046817515,
0.0263110474,
-0.1098774597,
0.05046013,
-0.0289776735,
-0.0336323567,
-0.019210035,
-0.0317022055,
0.0086492877,
-0.0112256687,
-0.0057246094,
-0.0142622283,
0.0199780501,
-0.0122128911,
0.006034052,
-0.0203227922,
-0.0118247755,
0.060975913,
-0.0420764014,
0.0332257189,
0.0576298907,
0.0501598343,
-0.0340760536,
-0.0448634475,
0.0073641217,
0.03571444,
0.0080315359,
0.0178341363,
0.0555627085,
0.0154443961,
-0.0060516675,
-0.0129922312,
0.0492504835,
-0.0318830311,
-0.0038598897,
0.0557942465,
0.0750559792,
-0.0228659343,
-0.0164703298,
-0.0455063172,
-0.0301649198,
0.0069270963,
0.0757422671,
0.0182095747,
-0.0131663708,
-0.0765428096,
-0.0235834382,
0.0061424971,
-0.0210632477,
-0.0134780882,
0.0044666752,
0.0222450569,
-0.0022719831,
-0.0593631826,
-0.0651150942,
0.0388472565,
0.023850115,
0.0118719731,
-0.0503273085,
-0.0015533712,
0.0264174324,
-0.0371423922,
-0.0046898816,
-0.0166000444,
0.0003737768,
-0.0516618863,
-0.0117157539,
0.0152764646,
-0.0099734329,
-0.0286043677,
0.0231447518,
-0.0216639955,
-0.0123346997,
0.012877807,
0.0760956109,
0.0343543366,
-0.0154631212,
-0.0422195904,
-0.033218123,
0.0196269732,
0.0337200053,
-0.0332580805,
0.0249331668,
0.0272442866,
-0.0049015074,
-0.0040425053,
0.0346012525,
-0.070916146,
0.0174205936,
-0.0237675775,
-0.0137659116,
-0.0153111964,
-0.0336232223,
0.0133234551,
0.0627044961,
-0.0219916422,
0.0043537775,
0.0351521,
0.011301633,
0.0054853172,
0.0010257717,
0.0129510425,
-0.0159420967,
-0.0295129996,
0.0417023487,
0.0083448486,
0.0065102242,
0.031859681,
0.0004592667,
0.0000889261,
-0.0751843303,
-0.0198948979,
0.0093497606,
0.0509331375,
-0.0210926868,
-0.013940501,
-0.0189703405,
-0.0076656491,
0.0107562831,
0.0907290131,
-0.0121055171,
0.051065743,
0.0129181994,
0.0142152412,
-0.030137945,
0.0463330448,
-0.0870609358,
-0.1176854819,
0.0113740088,
0.039848417,
0.0450453237,
-0.0031424549,
-0.0044083013,
-0.0499408431,
-0.0083096987,
-0.0005928262,
-0.0262235496,
0.0304411352,
0.0213062428,
0.0112409946,
0.0229308289,
-0.0034481401,
0.0220928658,
0.060607966,
-0.0219316594,
0.0670709163,
-0.0043208934,
-0.0047528679,
-0.0466157496,
-0.0411256216,
-0.0137295444,
0.025454415,
0.0152301127,
-0.0358812958,
-0.0760635957,
-0.0489507243,
0.0044781407,
0.0246641431,
-0.0054464694,
0.0022850032,
0.0247655008,
0.0471602492,
-0.011113367,
-0.0333349183,
0.000399306,
-0.0131382728,
-0.0643504187,
0.0071257697,
-0.003505538,
-6.610335176e-33,
0.0025287317,
-0.0312564559,
0.0273624379,
-0.0014408238,
0.0260573477,
-0.0003476864,
-0.0391354412,
0.001596072,
-0.0678478181,
0.0124798194,
-0.0536804944,
0.0175343845,
0.0102128135,
-0.0251818076,
0.0398951955,
-0.0292180777,
-0.0053765024,
-0.0099517619,
-0.0437399596,
0.0270501524,
0.0118282605,
0.0042511518,
-0.0090815555,
-0.0958977565,
-0.005747926,
0.0035411236,
-0.0305577777,
0.0035064048,
-0.0570966639,
0.0219676197,
-0.0161707252,
0.0331490971,
0.0285579041,
0.0147897797,
0.0487182997,
0.0176249333,
-0.0490848161,
-0.0563197136,
-0.0352131203,
-0.0352484249,
-0.0292057004,
-0.0399170108,
0.0061947796,
0.0016456231,
-0.0260691829,
0.0031756437,
0.0412281677,
-0.0218309034,
0.0387447476,
-0.0048464308,
-0.0578662828,
-0.0192878079,
-0.0310576819,
-0.0170886256,
-0.0255423859,
0.0233215671,
-0.0201212969,
0.0125502478,
-0.036729496,
0.0035623766,
-0.0223879591,
-0.0370595232,
0.0440939143,
-0.047745645,
-0.0135325333,
0.0148645919,
0.0516712032,
-0.0145050595,
-0.045778878,
-0.0374622643,
-0.0124207111,
0.0906783938,
0.0517555214,
0.045655407,
0.0439131372,
0.0041807219,
-0.0570895672,
0.0698492154,
0.0490174815,
0.0375046544,
-0.0234452002,
0.0108309472,
-0.0980689377,
0.026048325,
-0.0312126204,
-0.018545527,
-0.0523572415,
-0.0184850842,
0.0597866215,
-0.001880007,
0.0028460771,
-0.024493752,
-0.0120714167,
-0.0141401906,
0.0595226996,
0.0002388218,
0.0047524306,
0.0363278762,
0.0225979388,
-0.0092190066,
-0.0367889479,
-0.0155324349,
0.0153249083,
0.0545318499,
0.0618704259,
0.0162202865,
0.0036398794,
0.02948476,
-0.0140269101,
-0.0122903669,
-0.0627290308,
0.0220575761,
0.0266337227,
-0.0284420736,
0.0137885204,
-0.0073795584,
0.0155558353,
0.0390721932,
-0.0146873537,
0.0306095295,
-0.0482954457,
0.0024673622,
0.002080149,
-0.032543283,
-0.0182118732,
-0.0171768777,
-0.0429181494,
0.0148324613,
-0.0058402601,
-0.0382724255,
-0.0068950471,
-0.0177779924,
2.947e-7,
0.0089493981,
0.028194759,
0.0213881657,
0.0596524701,
-0.0247534011,
0.0261483062,
-0.0318995751,
0.0238661058,
-0.0206505563,
0.034548264,
0.0369865708,
0.0324676,
0.0101886904,
0.0469212569,
-0.0331463292,
-0.0342241414,
-0.0253844261,
-0.0186675787,
-0.0602952354,
0.0094693583,
0.0340492204,
0.0437213369,
0.0308572315,
-0.0329459496,
0.0420169532,
-0.0916677341,
0.0413122326,
-0.0216169413,
0.0297633223,
-0.001418502,
0.0401346795,
0.0691025034,
-0.0278264787,
0.0309601612,
-0.0275013093,
0.0140037583,
-0.0067500058,
0.057541322,
-0.0045227278,
-0.0636122078,
-0.0010663945,
-0.0281122029,
0.0456354544,
-0.056262739,
0.0807839781,
0.023299614,
-0.0308534373,
-0.0035030316,
-0.0247595385,
0.0012341439,
-0.0092729824,
-0.0253373682,
-0.0059781298,
-0.0169963259,
-0.0264795069,
-0.0158266816,
-0.0188394282,
-0.0549548119,
0.0258594658,
0.0308187865,
-0.0198308397,
-0.0421651118,
-0.0551791452,
0.0254203845,
0.0411076359,
-0.0324708223,
-0.0010100249,
2.265577098e-34,
0.0045501799,
-0.0125550106,
0.0464690626,
0.0407859981,
0.048359409,
0.0543572232,
-0.0425033532,
-0.0172068644,
0.0339102782,
-0.030769838,
0.0127860513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14736v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14736v2 | Data Diversity Matters for Robust Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-21T19:12:18 | 2024-02-05T16:41:10 | Alexander Bukharin, Tuo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent works have shown that by curating high quality and diverse instruction
tuning datasets, we can significantly improve instruction-following
capabilities. However, creating such datasets is difficult and most works rely
on manual curation or proprietary language models. Automatic data curation is
difficult as it is still not clear how we can define diversity for instruction
tuning, how diversity and quality depend on one other, and how we can optimize
dataset quality and diversity. To resolve these issue, we propose a new
algorithm, Quality-Diversity Instruction Tuning (QDIT). QDIT provides a simple
method to simultaneously control dataset diversity and quality, allowing us to
conduct an in-depth study on the effect of diversity and quality on instruction
tuning performance. From this study we draw two key insights (1) there is a
natural tradeoff between data diversity and quality and (2) increasing data
diversity significantly improves the worst case instruction following
performance, therefore improving robustness. We validate the performance of
QDIT on several large scale instruction tuning datasets, where we find it can
substantially improve worst and average case performance compared to
quality-driven data selection. | [
0.015678443,
0.0384070016,
-0.0505760498,
0.010691708,
0.0026299388,
0.0141945919,
0.0091701001,
-0.0050569815,
-0.0179668237,
-0.0307113286,
-0.0069170692,
-0.0084403912,
0.0178881884,
-0.0030475559,
0.0062452401,
-0.0720282868,
0.0686469525,
-0.0445791073,
-0.0672277063,
0.0098551922,
-0.0276970826,
0.0119813392,
-0.0163174476,
0.0361333676,
0.021511009,
-0.014578118,
0.0021955466,
0.0386044458,
0.014566916,
0.0003200159,
0.03168815,
0.04891067,
0.0136321625,
-0.0241285078,
0.0000020199,
-0.0243394375,
-0.0207736697,
-0.0092558311,
-0.0060298597,
0.0561280549,
0.0047157835,
0.0361806341,
-0.0200779699,
0.0291102175,
-0.0028585969,
0.0346925072,
0.0265856087,
-0.0762771815,
0.0559988059,
0.0516963862,
0.0359107926,
0.018360272,
-0.0214682519,
0.0228120182,
-0.0079021296,
0.0001388122,
-0.0130316345,
0.0045194197,
0.0267506484,
0.0389810801,
-0.0642708838,
-0.0116021223,
0.0252273697,
0.0144191133,
-0.0127070155,
0.0087829521,
-0.0497667603,
0.0092905648,
-0.0286266897,
0.055620335,
-0.0309651271,
-0.0036587098,
0.0004242834,
-0.0298267733,
0.0063334336,
-0.0093428995,
-0.0056428825,
0.0254756678,
-0.0361323059,
-0.0155338226,
0.0199455786,
-0.032715451,
-0.0223355964,
-0.0345051102,
0.0025091129,
0.0255727209,
0.0166866351,
-0.0477309935,
-0.0222442634,
0.0176794939,
-0.0226920899,
-0.0212687124,
-0.0145000387,
0.0300139505,
-0.0383011587,
0.0287144948,
-0.0871602818,
-0.0264801402,
0.0134947803,
-0.0019805427,
0.0618569329,
0.070954904,
-0.0243696589,
-0.0060661361,
0.0045455694,
0.0283772405,
-0.0063127149,
0.0240349844,
-0.0170141309,
0.0480231158,
-0.0621180758,
0.031113781,
-0.0111061493,
0.0275224075,
-0.0252613891,
0.0566762276,
-0.0415968858,
0.0554037802,
-0.0073398994,
-0.0107380925,
0.019878922,
-0.0272703636,
-0.0696193948,
0.0407551676,
-0.0043216101,
0.0258507691,
-0.0547343977,
-0.0023518808,
0.0046420242,
-0.0809914023,
0.0038242333,
-0.0130374031,
-0.0256645847,
-0.0475921333,
0.0434951857,
0.0474577546,
-0.0177201964,
0.004573267,
-0.032195583,
-0.0423277915,
0.0069307266,
-0.0301702004,
0.0021370049,
-0.0562626831,
0.0166022442,
0.0130380914,
-0.0096428208,
-0.006056082,
-0.0119161028,
0.0281848311,
0.0048996103,
0.0020818308,
-0.0189866554,
-0.0108962646,
0.0305380169,
0.0063065649,
-0.0263573583,
0.0760703683,
0.0224997737,
-0.0318487883,
0.0575933531,
-0.0520255342,
-0.0074325115,
0.0134153962,
-0.0006075833,
0.0130943358,
0.0117536774,
0.0056916028,
0.037421383,
-0.0153358644,
0.0040412792,
-0.0100012952,
-0.009865609,
-0.0121321324,
0.007830319,
0.0230451245,
0.0201181695,
-0.0197569653,
0.0347940996,
0.0291872621,
0.0206948426,
0.0232699774,
-0.0403566957,
0.0461464226,
0.0202902667,
0.0052300151,
0.0094174342,
0.0965960994,
-0.005074962,
-0.0542875864,
0.0014698313,
0.0089881886,
-0.0147649776,
0.0097104786,
0.0363128781,
-0.0703875348,
-0.0398778208,
0.0134765124,
0.0714087486,
-0.0137961358,
-0.0272114929,
-0.0622634664,
-0.0041786348,
0.0740487576,
0.0433305241,
-0.0464037992,
-0.0677053332,
-0.0000765954,
0.0763453096,
-0.026293505,
0.0552973934,
-0.0075283591,
0.0439483114,
-0.0636891425,
-0.0750659108,
0.0105383499,
-0.0014010053,
0.0568732172,
0.0357285365,
-0.0204914175,
-0.0182182379,
0.0265220385,
-0.0850263834,
0.0498921424,
0.0062756916,
-0.0376837812,
-0.0021459833,
0.0102545358,
0.0118901292,
0.0144016361,
-0.0321630612,
-0.0249664057,
0.0067518163,
0.039460633,
0.0608209968,
-0.0457351618,
-0.0600346364,
0.0071258964,
0.0254539866,
-0.0525990613,
-0.0131858233,
0.0227427054,
-0.0458367616,
-0.0490759984,
0.0307305474,
-0.019669991,
-0.0252276417,
0.0602984987,
0.0572619997,
-0.0630966723,
0.0060907714,
-0.0378934145,
0.0412742049,
-0.0043220385,
0.0021537351,
0.0207596403,
0.0411536992,
0.0088760052,
-0.0311935879,
-0.0150562488,
-0.0251662564,
-0.0173664484,
0.0360099077,
0.0145327607,
0.0208314396,
-0.0346855968,
-0.0215861704,
-0.0217544679,
0.0342832729,
-0.02231667,
0.0205129143,
0.0347018689,
-0.0159674492,
0.0052375034,
-0.0045375628,
0.0179153495,
-0.0395514444,
-0.022883717,
0.0271830168,
0.0002359364,
0.0110765519,
-0.0562267378,
-0.0202751812,
-0.0505288653,
-0.0270871092,
-0.0222482607,
-0.0005738552,
0.0194609649,
-0.0738349408,
0.0261383541,
0.0049756928,
0.0203250758,
-0.0129193114,
-0.043803148,
0.0336819105,
0.0217759609,
0.0098826662,
0.1052526236,
-0.0319898948,
0.0053875684,
0.0663140342,
0.0107267722,
-0.065350391,
0.0281604808,
-0.003797289,
-0.0088940663,
-0.0069802995,
-0.0537700318,
0.0026514742,
0.0459131561,
0.0100091025,
-0.0140439821,
-0.0538897999,
-0.0217139777,
-0.0206620432,
0.0040177526,
-0.0073106932,
-0.0055416231,
-0.0133724054,
-0.0063784905,
-0.0411475077,
-0.058749605,
0.0828806236,
0.0309017655,
0.0171096381,
-0.0715858713,
-0.0019112723,
-0.0077359048,
-0.0358838588,
-0.0203645788,
-0.0157091543,
-0.0502617769,
0.0076264539,
-0.0603542477,
0.0300666559,
0.055703219,
-0.0294702053,
0.0677217022,
-0.0750891268,
-0.0344105251,
-0.0166428313,
-0.000214714,
-0.0307088271,
0.0451691449,
0.0554464981,
-0.0309625845,
0.1013404503,
-0.0467099659,
-0.0136138517,
-0.0400739871,
0.0362590924,
0.0467415825,
-0.0309292544,
-0.0010012435,
-0.0107124876,
-0.0595720559,
0.002652813,
-0.0212100502,
-0.0061568213,
-0.064492844,
0.0285759438,
0.0108415969,
0.0630273446,
-0.0623901673,
0.0301954094,
0.0396585017,
0.0406790338,
-0.0389707275,
-0.0354708284,
0.0932195857,
0.0855101719,
-0.0669293776,
-0.0317563936,
0.0394932441,
0.0450126193,
-0.0379387923,
-0.0070608021,
-0.0077102692,
0.0196074713,
0.0398383401,
0.0570348129,
-0.0505082794,
-0.0134430332,
-0.042240534,
0.0757002011,
-0.0043437546,
-0.0126200505,
-0.0240518078,
-0.0774036646,
0.0152746551,
0.0147840315,
-0.0512607805,
-0.050205294,
-0.0406297743,
-0.0065673827,
-0.0053054141,
0.0383736826,
0.0187035948,
-0.019658586,
0.0251690485,
0.0698635951,
-0.0036511302,
-0.0779245049,
0.017962167,
-0.0017568651,
0.0595988743,
0.0452719592,
-0.0274273083,
-0.0019842456,
-0.0266923923,
0.0364864878,
-0.0087175239,
-0.0011429794,
-0.0128122726,
0.0754599199,
-0.0123017235,
-0.0068112169,
0.000224166,
0.0111467736,
0.0017769925,
0.0265238862,
0.055531662,
0.0609659143,
-0.0210477281,
0.0416758284,
-0.0302161127,
-0.0443145707,
0.0203880314,
0.0200293101,
0.018065989,
-0.0647138506,
0.0178814586,
-0.0691329539,
-0.0468396693,
-0.128598243,
0.0088402405,
0.0431959666,
-0.069881767,
-0.0209266897,
-0.0241176523,
-0.0302078314,
0.0383701995,
0.0131984055,
0.0215328,
-0.0118813906,
0.0201154854,
0.0183516573,
-0.0277325939,
0.0253576245,
0.0002154964,
0.0114506772,
-0.1255072504,
-0.0860693157,
-0.0401434079,
0.0132747712,
-0.0039616949,
-0.0011194523,
-0.0487057343,
-0.0731839091,
0.0416051485,
0.0734590814,
0.0088771908,
0.0473328047,
0.0239106379,
-0.030652117,
-0.001285255,
0.0246500354,
0.0018368474,
0.0041101566,
0.0372729152,
-0.0563894063,
-0.0109958546,
-0.021558186,
-0.0559636876,
0.0335779712,
0.0628515333,
-0.0015201459,
-0.0127807055,
0.0281714909,
-0.0081664193,
0.0053381254,
-0.0283997357,
-0.0396041162,
-0.0274331961,
-0.0302136093,
0.0416990556,
-0.0107085668,
0.0149006834,
-0.0286996868,
0.0083561577,
-0.0083757741,
-0.0200375319,
0.0059895348,
-0.0010096782,
0.0087521216,
0.0344623625,
-0.0613165125,
0.0891177952,
-0.0352040008,
0.0555971228,
0.0414290726,
0.0127535323,
-0.0056654266,
0.0317048952,
0.0142286364,
0.0603602678,
0.0184741281,
0.0519547798,
0.0066208839,
0.0483098701,
0.011322855,
0.0289842151,
-0.0401021875,
-0.0061886264,
-0.0496994443,
-0.002320234,
0.0160162654,
-0.019363476,
0.0175950173,
0.0152482893,
0.0081367558,
-0.0115364287,
0.0057321899,
0.0175511409,
-0.0037144981,
-0.0161580555,
0.02736146,
0.0229096431,
-0.0458820164,
0.0579238161,
-0.03923871,
0.0397161022,
-0.021532869,
0.0100074578,
-0.0423668474,
-0.0020098076,
0.0230149217,
0.0191499982,
-0.0067509841,
0.0146870241,
-0.032999143,
-0.01835276,
-0.0420948379,
0.0243893564,
0.0619008467,
-0.019574726,
0.0421637781,
0.0229694974,
-0.0318979137,
-0.008620047,
-0.0219608266,
-0.0337957293,
0.0109422952,
-0.0066406424,
-0.0011191095,
-5.79019387e-33,
-0.0303298291,
0.0168493632,
-0.0088506294,
-0.0342564024,
0.0562544577,
0.0009881044,
-0.0125099532,
-0.0053789355,
-0.0499551855,
-0.0216465909,
-0.0052801562,
0.0204520319,
0.0139072854,
0.003259077,
0.0760171637,
0.0139348209,
0.0220429134,
-0.0126421312,
-0.0731528848,
0.037887305,
0.0409740247,
-0.0082570193,
0.0729009062,
-0.0041580037,
-0.007642807,
-0.0059733172,
0.0567912757,
-0.0168829914,
-0.0297361687,
0.0837438703,
0.052815184,
0.040379744,
0.0186548382,
-0.0712512806,
-0.0448093787,
-0.0409063064,
0.0020360081,
-0.0894135237,
-0.0155807184,
0.0312671401,
0.0330505744,
-0.0538621508,
0.0111218467,
0.014820978,
-0.0661545321,
-0.0502055623,
0.0531182103,
0.000703096,
-0.0043515111,
0.0026259292,
-0.0526021309,
0.0338782854,
-0.0288874991,
-0.0146981748,
-0.0146526676,
0.0117040081,
0.0125409178,
-0.0324088596,
-0.023707578,
0.0606166944,
0.0757382885,
0.0814210773,
0.0801164955,
0.0489894487,
-0.0107755195,
-0.0052569713,
0.0130297458,
0.0659120232,
0.0428086072,
0.0159150809,
0.0371834226,
0.0085667474,
0.020440463,
0.0038452039,
0.0357581377,
-0.0378170535,
-0.0439918712,
0.0214249007,
-0.001050525,
-0.0155935902,
-0.0066999085,
-0.0293464623,
-0.0982404128,
-0.0137925027,
0.007063299,
0.0246123355,
-0.0053032795,
-0.0095234411,
0.0483883508,
-0.0243161693,
-0.0597588383,
-0.0044293837,
0.0552837215,
-0.0119041679,
-0.0063591693,
-0.0038185983,
-0.0298111048,
0.0180108342,
0.0076522557,
-0.0123525308,
-0.0305491854,
-0.0917595252,
0.054428149,
-0.0326271616,
0.0574265085,
0.0055054673,
0.0106403138,
0.0108062867,
-0.0522984117,
0.0131769795,
-0.0494433567,
0.0425618999,
0.0299040433,
-0.0054698084,
0.0139353685,
0.0123046627,
0.0034857958,
0.0652413443,
0.0291596763,
-0.039619118,
-0.0513232835,
-0.0302877016,
-0.0206670836,
0.0232021436,
-0.0166712757,
0.002862704,
-0.0411549918,
-0.0213380661,
-0.0142654432,
-0.0306530166,
-0.0348901078,
-0.0182537269,
2.62e-7,
0.0088596847,
0.0581370816,
0.0157738104,
0.0322788619,
-0.0283331294,
0.0058346125,
-0.0213297494,
-0.0042323964,
0.0319631211,
-0.0016838564,
0.0114042303,
0.0294501539,
0.0125289541,
0.0307880044,
0.0048758802,
-0.0063969539,
-0.0060428353,
0.0610021278,
-0.0709757507,
0.0047758641,
0.039398808,
0.0625588149,
0.0031267027,
0.0014582688,
0.009788651,
0.0486915708,
-0.043232061,
0.0012831915,
0.0238712523,
0.0460863486,
0.0163371954,
-0.0081937276,
-0.0289297048,
0.034436442,
-0.0495793298,
0.013921937,
-0.056045182,
0.0632697269,
-0.0277056266,
0.0166477077,
0.0584724732,
-0.0296086725,
-0.0250445455,
-0.0024601291,
0.0447931588,
-0.0044240118,
0.0283698179,
0.0189598445,
-0.0199142229,
-0.008252129,
0.013343934,
-0.0226020534,
0.0189163461,
0.0139281359,
0.0043503339,
-0.0314572155,
0.0042599244,
-0.0253346302,
-0.0110233407,
0.0310179479,
-0.0087119481,
-0.0938488767,
-0.047333803,
0.0035775078,
0.0244518463,
-0.0146502797,
-0.0070826937,
2.68164539e-34,
0.0169711318,
-0.0189191513,
0.0773620978,
0.0016115601,
0.007069868,
-0.0160860699,
-0.0160822589,
0.034360379,
0.0272155814,
-0.0168851335,
-0.0565394349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14743v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14743v7 | A Baseline Analysis of Reward Models' Ability To Accurately Analyze Foundation Models Under Distribution Shift | 2023-11-21T18:41:26 | 2024-01-24T12:08:34 | Will LeVine, Benjamin Pikus, Anthony Chen, Sean Hendryx | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Foundation models, specifically Large Language Models (LLMs), have lately
gained wide-spread attention and adoption. Reinforcement Learning with Human
Feedback (RLHF) involves training a reward model to capture desired behaviors,
which is then used to align LLM's. These reward models are additionally used at
inference-time to estimate LLM responses' adherence to those desired behaviors.
However, there is little work measuring how robust these reward models are to
distribution shifts. In this work, we evaluate how reward model performance -
measured via accuracy and calibration (i.e. alignment between accuracy and
confidence) - is affected by distribution shift. We show novel calibration
patterns and accuracy drops due to OOD prompts and responses, and that the
reward model is more sensitive to shifts in responses than prompts.
Additionally, we adapt an OOD detection technique commonly used in
classification to the reward model setting to detect these distribution shifts
in prompts and responses. | [
0.0303404499,
0.0901897699,
-0.0186868478,
0.0104189143,
-0.0259252433,
0.0046523949,
-0.0502434485,
0.0012506433,
-0.0987320393,
-0.0187075008,
-0.0605153814,
-0.0476146899,
0.0116719762,
-0.0067238738,
-0.0264657997,
-0.0397237577,
0.0443786494,
-0.0220316723,
-0.0054756831,
-0.0029232986,
-0.0067789475,
-0.0084026773,
-0.0254958179,
0.0435847342,
0.0171599239,
-0.0168893635,
-0.0046591354,
0.0194023047,
0.003537324,
-0.0304507427,
0.0178283658,
0.0767835304,
0.0361180082,
0.0650149062,
0.0000019879,
-0.0424082614,
0.0100303357,
-0.0103904232,
-0.0696261302,
0.0211452171,
0.0547467805,
-0.0018800956,
-0.0289262217,
0.0391665362,
-0.0095469654,
-0.0011720093,
0.0706042349,
0.0087879514,
-0.0048740734,
0.0494714268,
0.0119727785,
-0.0135144349,
0.012841003,
-0.0430286378,
-0.0031920471,
-0.0028601454,
0.0311346799,
0.0125465859,
-0.0030271495,
-0.0201396067,
-0.066930674,
0.0019561038,
0.0109483935,
0.0181702282,
0.0191532075,
0.0517478995,
0.0218567122,
-0.0052412283,
-0.0491513647,
0.0389408767,
-0.0083927475,
-0.0268352367,
-0.0004258803,
-0.0404156521,
0.0250966735,
0.0465740263,
-0.0132349655,
0.0382904895,
0.0169814676,
0.0255533084,
0.0394716114,
0.0135593945,
0.0427512452,
0.0256414302,
-0.0593985394,
0.0879962221,
-0.0135963382,
-0.0340514146,
-0.0078742364,
0.0252784546,
-0.0238902494,
-0.0484275781,
-0.0226499047,
0.0062680603,
-0.021013489,
0.0248182509,
-0.0415960252,
0.0102748638,
0.0151422499,
0.0043784468,
0.0555699952,
0.029395584,
-0.0374995694,
0.0072599985,
0.0261320844,
0.0630984306,
-0.0333031714,
0.0368473344,
-0.0182547793,
0.053676784,
-0.0385153405,
0.0036351033,
0.0231021754,
0.0060916552,
-0.0323885493,
-0.0299600512,
-0.0661959201,
0.046661973,
-0.006995101,
0.0032800823,
-0.0154817784,
0.0226083193,
-0.026176,
0.0430565961,
-0.0403749309,
0.0531493053,
-0.0175538659,
0.0310501419,
0.0435462818,
-0.0238758307,
0.001025522,
0.0032479158,
-0.0294340383,
-0.0173255205,
-0.0045697764,
0.0644468069,
0.0193311777,
-0.0214382783,
0.0006675047,
0.0125582451,
-0.04701107,
-0.0512730479,
-0.0113265151,
-0.0582137778,
-0.0221952889,
0.0064554624,
-0.0049652653,
-0.0024079524,
-0.0020840527,
-0.0075524598,
-0.0220166259,
0.0447956473,
0.0452081226,
0.0188402347,
0.015243208,
-0.0313858315,
-0.014203893,
0.0770112351,
0.0514486693,
-0.0081566647,
0.0278912429,
-0.0120541612,
0.0044528842,
0.0522325188,
0.0212272014,
0.0407245867,
-0.0047062454,
-0.0114161158,
0.013323525,
0.0365228392,
0.0689889714,
0.0044812253,
-0.0253184773,
0.0013047211,
0.0853376016,
0.0719838813,
0.0102143977,
-0.0539947934,
-0.0133580342,
-0.0143840825,
-0.02162195,
0.0067110914,
-0.0876636952,
-0.0207942817,
-0.0203387737,
-0.0019999379,
-0.0175377354,
-0.021843927,
-0.0175138768,
-0.0242205821,
-0.0106669916,
-0.012977791,
0.0214173067,
0.041380398,
0.06583938,
-0.0348572396,
-0.0104819974,
0.0152065065,
0.0403471552,
-0.012243093,
0.0233246088,
-0.0886741579,
0.0669622794,
0.0200486369,
0.0169033017,
-0.0338090807,
0.0426796377,
-0.020180678,
-0.0156473182,
0.0637974516,
0.0373742059,
-0.0036324882,
-0.0175178889,
0.0045101917,
-0.0317593738,
0.0265632439,
0.0360986963,
0.0183069278,
0.0191771053,
-0.0049961936,
-0.0268867649,
-0.0233629551,
-0.0336245932,
0.0423586965,
0.0218447801,
0.0096245278,
0.0071339603,
-0.00394599,
0.0373220742,
0.0000696964,
-0.0081735048,
0.0180207361,
0.0046974644,
0.0099516101,
-0.008186263,
0.0054794112,
-0.0520468019,
-0.0079616169,
0.015707776,
0.0455838628,
0.0597126335,
0.0267128963,
-0.0208513401,
-0.0179938935,
0.035326913,
-0.0147892935,
0.0369937532,
-0.0184348263,
0.0476979353,
-0.0442830101,
0.0223372765,
-0.0777355358,
0.0283813402,
-0.0348508358,
0.0178469811,
-0.0249547698,
0.01488607,
0.0019480441,
-0.0574282631,
-0.0010213846,
0.0095370384,
-0.0242824685,
0.0399902649,
0.0415891036,
-0.0079619782,
-0.0245014988,
-0.0225770138,
-0.0411622897,
0.0254390761,
-0.032002829,
0.0558512323,
0.0407039113,
-0.0020632423,
-0.0139667206,
-0.0008069295,
-0.0439289734,
-0.0199893955,
0.0416861065,
0.0260980092,
0.0236071814,
-0.0039706309,
-0.0262173992,
-0.0501557589,
-0.0149990702,
-0.0139198387,
0.0437231846,
-0.0043201838,
0.0003342337,
-0.083886385,
0.019708449,
-0.0246630274,
0.0220060479,
-0.0007170952,
-0.0133291529,
0.0284316409,
0.0317520685,
0.015032528,
0.10926193,
0.0272325035,
0.0806431472,
0.0292328633,
0.0228415802,
-0.0762823001,
-0.0247887075,
-0.0426866189,
-0.0592926256,
-0.0347392298,
-0.026611872,
0.0155952284,
0.1037347913,
0.0271765236,
0.0208873227,
-0.0480447635,
-0.0135270888,
-0.0456978939,
-0.0336963609,
-0.0254388079,
0.0200020988,
-0.0408523008,
0.0377745852,
-0.0305531397,
-0.0659224018,
0.0564558133,
-0.0046609957,
0.0198341627,
-0.0303735081,
-0.012259963,
-0.0121893752,
0.0015368911,
-0.008138801,
0.0004902754,
0.0246304348,
-0.0323401727,
-0.0465653464,
-0.0561589003,
0.0209984668,
-0.0366803482,
0.0430520214,
-0.0437525697,
0.0069377222,
-0.0116553493,
-0.0469539911,
-0.0424259901,
-0.0698057339,
-0.0096007083,
0.0217582081,
-0.0325134732,
-0.0424869284,
-0.0083754687,
0.0075808889,
0.0186393969,
0.0144741302,
-0.039386455,
0.0181785654,
-0.0201458503,
0.0030018,
0.0585778877,
0.0322701782,
0.0239826515,
-0.0817411914,
-0.0284008123,
0.0089317011,
0.0458200239,
0.0417634249,
-0.0164601691,
0.0153220445,
0.0517523699,
-0.0278107263,
-0.027188221,
0.0510891266,
0.0451069847,
-0.0259471107,
-0.0048450781,
0.1018972695,
0.0351848789,
-0.0575582571,
0.0262888186,
-0.0312492792,
0.0636176318,
0.0096894195,
-0.0093716262,
-0.1207059547,
-0.0123679768,
-0.0006620662,
0.0457485653,
-0.0241175219,
-0.0195428077,
0.043140471,
-0.1182225123,
0.0145515678,
0.0000805292,
-0.0804035142,
0.019877864,
-0.022442447,
0.0348142944,
-0.0065094172,
-0.00480178,
0.0113255708,
-0.0003033199,
-0.0145025756,
0.055643294,
0.0097578727,
-0.0531718656,
0.0373888724,
-0.0690160468,
0.0639349893,
0.1305606812,
-0.0014655703,
-0.0386044048,
-0.0419999212,
-0.0155838616,
-0.0191284027,
-0.0102590965,
0.0174962021,
0.0164077375,
-0.0137022147,
0.0108311903,
-0.0014353308,
0.0352778696,
-0.0275179502,
0.0046433746,
-0.0021468187,
0.0630249828,
-0.0184392165,
-0.0185298286,
-0.0264676828,
-0.0127864685,
0.0408160426,
0.0604616441,
0.0052546319,
-0.0851188973,
-0.0346475206,
-0.0114481822,
-0.0417681299,
0.0040036454,
0.000001446,
0.0419314317,
0.0016320307,
-0.0520493798,
-0.0825654417,
0.0077320049,
-0.0385313742,
0.0164710432,
0.0136606777,
-0.0222587474,
-0.0203394536,
-0.0178315006,
-0.0424937308,
0.0504537374,
-0.0298731718,
0.0666179955,
-0.1144174635,
0.0096621839,
0.0023758796,
-0.0394775681,
-0.0237384215,
-0.0412583388,
-0.0667920783,
-0.0791402161,
0.0084165186,
0.0302077308,
0.0285633001,
0.0394592918,
-0.002142773,
-0.0176180955,
0.0577767938,
0.0089648329,
-0.028443275,
0.064972572,
0.0268433783,
-0.0047910986,
-0.034270227,
0.0018114687,
-0.0318331234,
0.0369509459,
0.0321924239,
0.0169524457,
0.0149093112,
-0.0302361213,
0.0159231611,
-0.0412731506,
0.070227176,
-0.015105024,
-0.0613842718,
-0.0226170439,
-0.0086868079,
0.0061562131,
-0.0107021555,
-0.0079689519,
-0.0561932623,
0.0639704466,
-0.0035411862,
0.0068284953,
-0.0244086087,
-0.0179974418,
0.0422353037,
-0.0404705144,
0.0072158752,
0.0347789377,
0.0582167208,
0.0110966563,
0.0418006219,
-0.0116831642,
-0.0057274099,
0.0001622363,
0.054065261,
0.0367298871,
0.0907368287,
0.0307464525,
-0.0021191956,
-0.0104214484,
0.0104993265,
-0.0534014888,
-0.0134224845,
-0.0092665851,
-0.0052666878,
0.0363822095,
-0.0005571789,
0.0177216567,
-0.0093928035,
0.0011776168,
-0.0358237661,
0.0323355906,
-0.0358522534,
0.0005699361,
0.0575103201,
0.0189345274,
-0.0042463117,
-0.0101940548,
0.0223588832,
0.0543168001,
0.0419400819,
-0.0524671748,
-0.0053203786,
-0.0008380163,
0.0205004811,
0.0387519598,
-0.0177056845,
-0.0378001854,
0.0190069042,
-0.0732559487,
-0.0526076891,
-0.0064101941,
0.0468285307,
0.0352730602,
-0.0389021263,
0.0242339913,
0.0532488897,
-0.0349103063,
-0.0297030527,
-0.0655500591,
-0.0050876252,
-0.0415252969,
0.0010286064,
-0.0565982684,
-6.127521076e-33,
-0.0308438987,
0.0092126783,
0.0026791622,
0.0068022204,
-0.0391222127,
0.0028028574,
-0.0095701339,
0.0446558818,
-0.0143730715,
-0.0204253774,
-0.012018119,
0.0147985658,
0.0184212048,
-0.001973277,
0.0108418586,
-0.0147332316,
0.0331818238,
-0.0351595879,
-0.0782538205,
-0.0183606762,
0.0305517111,
0.006986232,
0.0813929737,
-0.066257596,
0.0477697998,
0.0186736267,
-0.0038005665,
0.0011251819,
-0.0185132623,
0.0591646582,
-0.0054326118,
0.0328399427,
0.0042031007,
-0.0325442366,
0.0170498602,
0.0306970626,
-0.0617556572,
-0.00195585,
0.0394689552,
0.0284411907,
-0.0152292456,
-0.0017205969,
0.0142100863,
0.0031468472,
-0.0446723625,
-0.0004165235,
0.0148723638,
-0.0485577732,
-0.0079842908,
0.0412522107,
-0.0494129695,
0.0066373581,
0.0223152973,
-0.0313210413,
-0.0153850866,
0.0166827645,
-0.0264789332,
0.0051279515,
0.000925912,
0.0280748662,
0.053063821,
0.0345876552,
0.073531054,
0.1120585501,
0.026090268,
0.0508075356,
-0.0223539323,
0.0106166648,
0.0091990475,
-0.0257297177,
0.0676158443,
0.0077885352,
0.0257211495,
0.0501089841,
0.0492146946,
-0.0033391046,
-0.0489103757,
0.0042644953,
0.0275128614,
0.0070102694,
0.0469677672,
0.0147065176,
-0.0610925481,
-0.0370695405,
-0.0542329252,
-0.0308765117,
-0.0123892995,
-0.0395314246,
0.055413302,
0.0141544612,
-0.0023637742,
-0.0305449534,
0.0324712358,
-0.0499810763,
-0.0398000069,
0.0143911261,
-0.0156686809,
0.0350750349,
-0.0219263099,
-0.0208174624,
-0.0923668444,
-0.0266919099,
-0.0086906068,
0.0031508396,
0.0068326481,
0.0485817902,
0.0023213308,
0.0158041809,
-0.0370531827,
0.0044419337,
-0.0151030337,
-0.0040742983,
-0.0075431354,
0.0580391139,
0.045258753,
-0.0251136813,
-0.00492599,
0.0314276516,
-0.0097642122,
-0.0369944721,
-0.0393293835,
-0.0064985869,
-0.0117382752,
0.046084892,
-0.0425972454,
-0.0117958225,
-0.0154027957,
0.0281470083,
-0.004627367,
-0.05692745,
-0.0188812725,
-0.0259648636,
2.688e-7,
0.0452897251,
0.0323878527,
0.0082858428,
0.014481361,
-0.0004195198,
0.0406078696,
-0.0324083082,
0.0306137893,
0.0423777178,
-0.0262943357,
0.0137622021,
0.0139557673,
0.0358560532,
-0.0320987068,
-0.0661359504,
-0.0449032672,
-0.0729901195,
0.0423867777,
-0.0153651983,
-0.0214478914,
-0.0115724234,
0.0709107071,
0.0363086089,
-0.0182693005,
0.0034934357,
-0.0010857863,
0.0584060661,
-0.0345008895,
0.012072321,
-0.0148245068,
-0.0149448346,
-0.024777079,
-0.0000321057,
0.0291973501,
0.0163625795,
0.0529235974,
-0.0288371015,
0.0168697126,
-0.0429777391,
0.003338529,
-0.0447429605,
-0.0111017888,
0.003100967,
-0.0748670921,
0.0210248157,
-0.0678464398,
-0.0187791511,
-0.0451475941,
-0.0093979193,
-0.0397858582,
0.0321924239,
-0.0303650647,
-0.0052854903,
-0.0165540688,
0.0183434393,
0.0477537438,
-0.0087465672,
-0.0580182932,
-0.0375406072,
0.0478345454,
-0.0230390672,
-0.0615767539,
-0.0243299641,
0.0037929411,
-0.0408401527,
-0.0903165489,
-0.0039915587,
2.505735416e-34,
0.0330347009,
0.0127827143,
0.0080645699,
0.0065182475,
0.0160621163,
0.0135616502,
0.0135074053,
0.0084514096,
0.0601952188,
-0.0429283455,
0.0055360626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12735v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12735v1 | LowResource at BLP-2023 Task 2: Leveraging BanglaBert for Low Resource Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Language | 2023-11-21T17:21:15 | 2023-11-21T17:21:15 | Aunabil Chakma, Masum Hasan | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes the system of the LowResource Team for Task 2 of
BLP-2023, which involves conducting sentiment analysis on a dataset composed of
public posts and comments from diverse social media platforms. Our primary aim
is to utilize BanglaBert, a BERT model pre-trained on a large Bangla corpus,
using various strategies including fine-tuning, dropping random tokens, and
using several external datasets. Our final model is an ensemble of the three
best BanglaBert variations. Our system has achieved overall 3rd in the Test Set
among 30 participating teams with a score of 0.718. Additionally, we discuss
the promising systems that didn't perform well namely task-adaptive pertaining
and paraphrasing using BanglaT5. Training codes and external datasets which are
used for our system are publicly available at
https://github.com/Aunabil4602/bnlp-workshop-task2-2023 | [
0.052840095,
0.0477993041,
0.0141315376,
0.0181023963,
-0.0683800429,
-0.0208126232,
-0.0383957662,
-0.0084908679,
-0.0234517585,
-0.0291290302,
-0.04112266,
-0.0137117142,
-0.0057161003,
-0.0040427721,
-0.0080869012,
-0.0667931512,
0.0219339114,
0.042736318,
0.086478062,
-0.0088829836,
0.0554437675,
0.0350901745,
-0.0113700572,
0.0220566075,
-0.0567882061,
-0.0063223531,
0.0204361808,
0.037953157,
0.0085608736,
0.0020027151,
0.0460857451,
0.0697529688,
-0.0184820164,
0.0082359212,
0.0000018937,
-0.0653386638,
-0.0236334801,
0.0154555878,
0.026647104,
-0.0059242323,
0.0647926852,
0.0101743238,
0.0110933268,
0.043571312,
-0.018105844,
0.0057683825,
0.0624759644,
0.0585077778,
0.085292086,
0.076629281,
-0.0236922838,
-0.0437297076,
-0.0308193117,
0.0060760668,
0.0349549502,
0.0025153954,
0.0036444822,
-0.0550112836,
0.0489036329,
-0.0006341888,
-0.0159115586,
0.0010576625,
-0.010527757,
-0.0029469118,
0.0362816192,
-0.0305148736,
-0.0459761731,
-0.029254768,
0.023669377,
0.0481848046,
0.0124885952,
-0.0363877788,
-0.0076285591,
0.0155891832,
-0.009066443,
-0.0448606312,
-0.0170110352,
0.013746961,
-0.0176412109,
0.0341045633,
-0.0374739319,
0.0379729718,
0.0118297227,
0.0398151539,
0.048345428,
0.0198468119,
0.0023591225,
-0.0712276399,
-0.0393242985,
0.0458196923,
0.0231609587,
0.0261103716,
0.0253024381,
-0.0309398267,
0.0053374646,
0.0174096934,
-0.0362531878,
-0.044028338,
0.0298758317,
-0.0167367887,
0.015375956,
0.009533626,
-0.0498533249,
0.038857054,
-0.0134227853,
0.0109511185,
-0.0067980839,
-0.0077695362,
-0.0176306404,
-0.0328693539,
-0.0532429554,
0.0242676288,
-0.0220688134,
0.0462480113,
-0.0208885986,
0.004832577,
-0.0654208586,
-0.0120219663,
-0.0161886532,
-0.0393983275,
0.0186505821,
0.0181729533,
-0.0002093082,
0.0092205089,
0.0116254073,
0.0467288271,
-0.0307446551,
-0.0000516713,
-0.0089148199,
-0.0568346828,
0.0029136469,
0.0112370318,
0.0017590915,
-0.0516829006,
0.0167710409,
0.0213767141,
0.0314262025,
-0.032297872,
-0.0455107503,
0.0117135933,
-0.0436819568,
-0.0861512646,
-0.0192495137,
-0.0804595128,
0.0348659158,
0.0010557995,
-0.020092262,
0.0274655838,
0.0104128821,
0.0268270634,
-0.03555182,
0.0620626025,
-0.0454301834,
-0.0178854726,
-0.0157629456,
0.0126718907,
0.029037958,
0.0556625053,
-0.0125708273,
0.0258168932,
0.0396755226,
0.016523663,
-0.0390051603,
0.0095626814,
0.0144833485,
-0.0135207698,
-0.0212621503,
0.0067397053,
-0.0214680936,
0.0154585959,
0.0134098483,
0.0283297878,
-0.0210942775,
-0.0000308873,
0.0614569262,
0.0350314081,
-0.0178401489,
0.0593339838,
-0.0244895853,
0.0259702411,
0.0415240489,
-0.0193986464,
-0.0180879664,
0.001794261,
-0.0067315055,
-0.0069302469,
0.0738361776,
0.0276044793,
-0.0135442521,
-0.0150205083,
-0.0299426597,
-0.0385701656,
-0.0356429406,
-0.0263438318,
0.0426364802,
0.00430508,
-0.0301850028,
0.0665261149,
0.0489334203,
-0.0801693127,
-0.0190215912,
-0.0424201302,
0.0444337055,
0.0272891745,
0.0193283148,
-0.0258554872,
-0.041931469,
-0.0242416598,
0.0095043648,
0.0602385327,
-0.0009255031,
0.0103607234,
0.0079720179,
-0.0398452394,
0.017695412,
-0.0014693741,
0.0058486261,
-0.0062001012,
0.012942736,
0.0093708523,
-0.0136775533,
-0.0116947033,
-0.0149793727,
0.0001173586,
0.0321521051,
0.0222279783,
0.0182647612,
0.0056310846,
0.0672889203,
0.033770632,
-0.0316512883,
-0.0007885878,
0.0173206907,
-0.0414427072,
-0.0213045087,
0.0217190385,
-0.0012772504,
-0.0674694702,
0.0301634558,
-0.0559695736,
0.0249062181,
0.0501715206,
-0.0383225307,
-0.0468142256,
0.0569751449,
-0.0363492817,
0.0270113703,
-0.0287958663,
0.0067230808,
-0.0666771159,
0.0236057881,
-0.0126062576,
0.0200570244,
-0.0053367228,
-0.0081969826,
0.0052728783,
0.0136184469,
0.052644413,
-0.0292849708,
-0.0601078235,
0.0094107687,
0.0267614853,
0.0329096019,
0.0211389437,
0.0436094441,
-0.0496138372,
-0.0091119111,
-0.1248232946,
-0.002793177,
-0.0034693324,
-0.000976062,
0.0443579629,
0.0421902314,
-0.0126372669,
-0.0214840528,
0.0127921309,
-0.0064818403,
0.0194767043,
0.0146012288,
0.0370648392,
0.0065918537,
0.0087093934,
-0.043547973,
-0.0164787602,
-0.0017707435,
-0.0056159524,
0.0097224638,
-0.0018884633,
-0.0131983031,
-0.0391703434,
-0.0289081428,
-0.0234848484,
0.0315960348,
-0.0621082671,
-0.0070160874,
-0.0408908688,
0.0122080958,
0.0329599716,
0.0225869976,
0.0018525578,
-0.0275230687,
0.0346740149,
-0.0417686105,
0.0322144702,
-0.0103752296,
0.0262610298,
0.0225172136,
-0.0344941877,
-0.0120157562,
0.0268255249,
0.0094586676,
0.0092197275,
-0.0611087084,
-0.0125180362,
0.0016733182,
-0.0494597889,
-0.024191279,
0.0207844619,
-0.045455195,
-0.009772785,
-0.0280895568,
-0.0359764807,
0.0711885169,
-0.0012442549,
-0.0084680188,
-0.111469008,
0.0165180732,
-0.0213494748,
0.0120126754,
-0.0331280939,
0.0168696959,
-0.0157132596,
0.011421605,
-0.0119929006,
-0.0156461485,
-0.0038448558,
-0.0150948297,
-0.0242460798,
0.0097708674,
0.0363158137,
0.0077898554,
-0.0603740104,
0.0054898253,
-0.0791414082,
-0.0176025089,
0.0151821272,
0.0287602134,
-0.0166111439,
-0.0156242829,
0.0269203708,
-0.0105072837,
-0.052651301,
-0.0185265131,
-0.0035985645,
0.0225411374,
0.0278180894,
0.0383738428,
-0.0093951672,
0.0674498677,
0.011608772,
-0.0651071817,
0.0071279267,
0.0824520513,
0.0029152196,
-0.0373062566,
-0.0275991019,
0.0188229531,
-0.0204865076,
-0.022744352,
-0.0495417789,
0.045152884,
0.0074153231,
-0.0326021202,
0.1147154346,
0.0058859512,
-0.0247910824,
-0.023765659,
-0.0547343269,
0.023528086,
-0.0075873779,
0.0105423657,
-0.0347169116,
-0.0444016047,
-0.0156305302,
0.0393961444,
0.0189167745,
-0.036784824,
-0.003971504,
-0.1388897747,
0.0104433876,
-0.0243037585,
-0.0001164854,
-0.0276715904,
-0.0530819483,
-0.0023750167,
-0.0303701479,
0.036327716,
-0.0183281321,
-0.0131130405,
0.0091263708,
0.0299644191,
-0.0271991938,
-0.0489076301,
0.0313907266,
-0.0544777326,
0.023532832,
0.0502120964,
0.0401104167,
-0.0257937592,
0.0193437114,
-0.0136683434,
-0.0411792248,
-0.0329422429,
-0.0228569452,
0.0487555526,
-0.0137725333,
-0.0515678078,
-0.028837217,
-0.0116322646,
-0.0336424597,
0.031189885,
-0.013955716,
0.063752614,
0.013375924,
-0.0282466337,
-0.0439938717,
0.0454390571,
0.0292897411,
0.0608700886,
0.0449342951,
-0.0634815544,
-0.0363203324,
0.0359853916,
-0.0258042794,
-0.0833552554,
0.0091800336,
-0.008274883,
-0.0566228181,
-0.0403596275,
-0.0643553063,
-0.0638308376,
-0.0009368893,
0.0610359274,
-0.0232890081,
0.0264039952,
-0.0032617792,
0.0277497973,
-0.0129258251,
0.0447153933,
0.0097989403,
0.0317949727,
-0.0505827814,
-0.0349377282,
0.0507006757,
0.015718434,
-0.0088953357,
-0.0133543424,
-0.0355501212,
-0.0304176845,
0.0160234086,
0.0572927594,
0.0213184543,
0.0122755989,
-0.0485934578,
-0.0538280644,
0.0201988276,
0.052574221,
-0.0286453087,
0.0132765612,
0.0471819863,
0.0326102711,
-0.0044944934,
0.0652300194,
-0.0191817023,
0.0169460233,
0.0039090198,
0.0236805398,
0.0267436653,
-0.0090776943,
0.0112026315,
0.0290839598,
0.0476742648,
-0.0204219632,
-0.082120724,
-0.0157387629,
-0.0120903151,
0.0361173116,
-0.0270203799,
-0.0451052561,
-0.0096523575,
0.0180444121,
0.0364340618,
-0.0270024892,
0.0171782002,
-0.0277986731,
0.0073602898,
-0.0054326653,
0.0878547132,
0.0464108549,
0.0375173502,
0.0003342221,
-0.0036105895,
-0.0159303695,
-0.0128509542,
-0.0122699905,
-0.0074984431,
-0.0291590374,
0.0259255935,
0.0027890897,
0.0053812326,
0.0336284824,
0.0576569624,
0.000986642,
0.0472924337,
-0.0089450618,
0.0132057192,
0.0491023697,
-0.0233262796,
0.0920691416,
-0.0104361586,
0.0001481071,
-0.037407916,
0.0352609716,
-0.0525968783,
0.0203664284,
0.0252768379,
-0.0141942631,
-0.0116841458,
0.0263872892,
0.0556246154,
-0.0087636728,
0.0428447574,
0.0491522625,
0.0056764162,
-0.0264801662,
-0.0336583182,
0.043449752,
0.0327503718,
0.013487394,
0.0236892495,
-0.0406216532,
-0.0396866426,
0.0670687035,
-0.0577777326,
0.0083245737,
0.0202813894,
0.0484978035,
0.0603583828,
0.0168172121,
0.0518583953,
-0.0380693115,
0.0119398003,
-0.0061325012,
-0.0204303116,
-0.0180550255,
-6.296188719e-33,
-0.0055591371,
0.0312024709,
-0.0522071756,
-0.0700552464,
-0.010276393,
0.0019700467,
-0.0105893118,
-0.008649583,
-0.0207701009,
0.0140522905,
-0.0275363568,
0.0063752658,
0.0200695395,
0.0519598313,
0.0499597266,
-0.0341304839,
0.0366404578,
0.0284388307,
0.0009144323,
0.0309244823,
0.0427074954,
0.0726189762,
0.0742188618,
-0.0661307722,
-0.0052097337,
-0.0280236471,
-0.0479239151,
0.0112814261,
0.0452540591,
0.0499663763,
-0.0284603219,
0.0673228353,
0.0420061424,
0.0067597833,
-0.0315332823,
0.0104939193,
-0.0627594218,
-0.0002828377,
0.0528671779,
0.0485446826,
-0.0233870614,
-0.0155331949,
0.0349172242,
0.0038380171,
-0.049450662,
0.0338370129,
0.0274889581,
-0.0167114679,
0.0047218944,
0.021615928,
-0.064798519,
0.0286932457,
0.0050653773,
0.0084293708,
-0.017936917,
0.0262275282,
-0.0239730347,
0.0083338385,
-0.0348583683,
0.0107428515,
-0.0087320292,
0.0293159485,
0.0066870605,
-0.008349956,
-0.0068969508,
0.0217443816,
0.0390961133,
-0.0552026331,
0.0436191596,
-0.0173086785,
0.0196035691,
0.0441877767,
0.0352106988,
0.0873907432,
0.0024658181,
0.0019137644,
-0.0510584861,
0.0113291917,
0.110275127,
0.0355582945,
0.0515079536,
0.0003712512,
-0.0485148393,
-0.007615516,
0.0582233444,
-0.0217326228,
-0.0320470966,
-0.0245629344,
0.0361091644,
-0.0113454275,
-0.0143623846,
0.0026826714,
0.0178535879,
-0.0531204864,
0.0154258246,
0.0470593497,
-0.0170921087,
0.0273587443,
0.0069501963,
0.0370966978,
-0.0867114067,
-0.0017848487,
-0.0175773818,
0.0669159219,
-0.0171180274,
0.0049769417,
0.0566894189,
0.0101002399,
-0.0617193989,
0.0000615443,
-0.0328402258,
0.0155396909,
-0.0440251306,
0.0471821427,
-0.0074438583,
0.0003963128,
0.0047363979,
0.0334766321,
0.0180484429,
0.0572974496,
0.0222783033,
-0.0331918448,
0.0161183402,
-0.0335443914,
-0.0139172869,
-0.0239364393,
-0.014705413,
-0.0078952881,
-0.0407928564,
-0.0411113948,
-0.0014327717,
-0.0122425295,
2.75e-7,
0.0292015169,
0.045613341,
0.008040172,
-0.0611433163,
-0.0008821933,
0.0373574346,
-0.0358573832,
0.0292837918,
-0.0370959751,
0.0290333666,
0.0125757502,
-0.0129040536,
0.0280789752,
-0.0145473722,
-0.1513601542,
-0.0307895131,
-0.0839024037,
-0.0256735589,
-0.044977136,
0.0159150995,
0.0185739864,
0.1152975038,
0.0278894901,
-0.0343675017,
-0.0323450193,
-0.0304859802,
0.0334996879,
-0.0320139043,
-0.0311579611,
-0.0041621244,
0.0294738635,
0.0437776633,
-0.0172934663,
-0.0535319038,
0.0057035284,
0.0155949695,
0.003033957,
0.0539300106,
-0.0048260405,
-0.040142782,
0.0429284349,
0.025120277,
0.0049383678,
-0.0224043932,
0.0510396026,
0.0087315915,
-0.0629955456,
-0.0348015875,
-0.02398788,
0.0054023839,
0.0123780761,
-0.0199640356,
-0.0715194196,
-0.00880145,
0.0081367567,
-0.059472423,
-0.0756990761,
-0.0749232322,
0.0252422858,
0.0426022522,
-0.0489918105,
-0.0450233854,
-0.0172413588,
0.05555702,
0.0463934243,
-0.0815821663,
0.0508333407,
2.375247737e-34,
0.0716504231,
-0.0161653608,
0.027469283,
0.0187320728,
0.0124310208,
0.0020214671,
-0.0370069817,
-0.0186055247,
0.0266081057,
-0.0319995508,
0.0011195802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12727v2 | Soft Random Sampling: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis | 2023-11-21T17:03:21 | 2023-11-24T03:27:31 | Xiaodong Cui, Ashish Mittal, Songtao Lu, Wei Zhang, George Saon, Brian Kingsbury | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Soft random sampling (SRS) is a simple yet effective approach for efficient
training of large-scale deep neural networks when dealing with massive data.
SRS selects a subset uniformly at random with replacement from the full data
set in each epoch. In this paper, we conduct a theoretical and empirical
analysis of SRS. First, we analyze its sampling dynamics including data
coverage and occupancy. Next, we investigate its convergence with non-convex
objective functions and give the convergence rate. Finally, we provide its
generalization performance. We empirically evaluate SRS for image recognition
on CIFAR10 and automatic speech recognition on Librispeech and an in-house
payload dataset to demonstrate its effectiveness. Compared to existing
coreset-based data selection methods, SRS offers a better accuracy-efficiency
trade-off. Especially on real-world industrial scale data sets, it is shown to
be a powerful training strategy with significant speedup and competitive
performance with almost no additional computing cost. | [
-0.0345557593,
0.060669221,
-0.0205965564,
0.0190573502,
-0.0134965451,
0.0014321153,
0.0296988655,
-0.0176867656,
0.0045041973,
0.000242747,
-0.0003976965,
-0.0342271402,
-0.0117302639,
0.0083192978,
0.027987441,
-0.0135820517,
0.0059621315,
-0.0458912961,
-0.0417142175,
-0.0423067361,
-0.019135844,
0.0369517319,
-0.0282138437,
0.011839265,
-0.004786198,
0.0103970449,
-0.0088148378,
0.0286707394,
0.0125505356,
-0.0266333167,
0.0113204559,
0.0067856954,
0.0447086766,
0.0300905574,
0.000002031,
-0.0052286698,
-0.0199385379,
-0.0134367384,
-0.0535770059,
0.0257205982,
-0.0034260487,
0.0192177184,
-0.0141587788,
0.0014089018,
0.0039872145,
-0.0015915033,
0.0428509787,
0.0282400083,
0.0034532321,
0.0193740577,
0.0120369131,
0.0041058692,
-0.0214277003,
-0.0127317021,
-0.0534834825,
-0.0250944588,
-0.0023890606,
0.0066716867,
-0.008664364,
-0.0177572072,
0.0041209562,
-0.0078482861,
0.0595537089,
-0.0006499254,
0.0334582329,
0.055921685,
-0.1087300405,
-0.0009074537,
0.0050656949,
0.0777271986,
-0.0336425751,
0.0077143647,
0.0221003406,
-0.0375417732,
-0.0430489443,
-0.0282808617,
-0.0176509377,
0.0082197729,
0.0167404581,
0.0629913211,
-0.0472112186,
-0.0109367371,
0.0450534634,
0.0127769345,
-0.0250187591,
-0.0068192026,
-0.0104965372,
-0.0046957158,
0.0421077423,
0.0157116447,
-0.0536468923,
-0.0334125273,
-0.0084383562,
0.0062593799,
-0.0539358407,
-0.0070579736,
-0.0497880578,
-0.012867704,
0.004607799,
-0.0029128112,
0.0134337004,
-0.0432327725,
-0.016466938,
0.0835049078,
-0.0364014059,
-0.0175233297,
0.0072711958,
0.0359347723,
0.009870993,
-0.0112630147,
-0.0070862188,
0.0339465477,
-0.0385819562,
0.0767223835,
0.0123673799,
-0.028859891,
-0.0580791496,
-0.0390050374,
-0.0401384197,
-0.0215497054,
0.0193113852,
0.0299238153,
-0.0629484877,
0.0507270731,
0.0106554246,
-0.0038796794,
-0.005367416,
0.0440853648,
-0.0131025482,
-0.0980873108,
-0.0110093467,
-0.0327557735,
0.026171064,
-0.0319791734,
0.0053004306,
0.0432239845,
-0.0377667844,
-0.0380364358,
-0.0735472664,
-0.0166620407,
0.0237073191,
0.0085343393,
0.0014441846,
-0.0674075708,
0.0061361566,
-0.0546274446,
0.0407287553,
-0.0012782385,
0.0207608789,
0.00865064,
0.0103576537,
0.0497932471,
-0.0162443761,
-0.0213357043,
0.0133418711,
-0.0271206927,
0.0268808939,
0.083586961,
0.0206897948,
0.0224325173,
0.0303524751,
0.0264225528,
-0.0215419885,
0.0467138253,
0.0297816135,
0.0063779065,
0.0124951107,
-0.0037379931,
-0.001567638,
0.0313975811,
0.0302595086,
0.0002039063,
-0.0463667326,
-0.0237327144,
0.0094788894,
0.0068440023,
0.0003432217,
0.0318873078,
-0.0263727978,
0.0182558075,
0.0123562394,
-0.0573758259,
0.0067331358,
0.0278710667,
0.032186456,
-0.0389041826,
-0.0024474019,
0.014865024,
-0.0582365245,
0.0038934329,
0.0158054586,
-0.0463702567,
0.0170885492,
0.0358256958,
0.0739196464,
0.0026940906,
-0.0090061706,
0.0449553505,
0.0578676239,
0.0053097527,
0.0269601494,
-0.0332603641,
0.0101855295,
-0.0140195163,
0.0044695833,
-0.0822037011,
-0.0270514637,
-0.0425304621,
0.0176364295,
-0.0430100076,
0.032193996,
-0.0148786614,
0.0614195801,
-0.0451036245,
-0.0626681373,
0.0245074835,
-0.0349934697,
0.0432275496,
-0.0005489084,
0.0524036102,
0.0034221809,
-0.0319938697,
-0.0249131192,
0.0098981354,
-0.0102731334,
-0.0051673492,
0.0731336698,
0.0425599776,
0.0790061206,
0.0036707374,
-0.04275994,
-0.0592081733,
0.0168542136,
-0.0543977357,
-0.0060382225,
-0.047141429,
-0.0288643818,
0.0238455497,
0.0117964474,
-0.0489161722,
-0.0010574191,
0.0617198162,
-0.0286403913,
-0.0442969799,
0.0307843946,
-0.0193475727,
-0.0206698403,
-0.0380516611,
-0.036173299,
-0.0023960422,
0.0832656026,
-0.0459861904,
0.0010227835,
0.02186599,
-0.0363926142,
0.0324806683,
-0.0099314712,
0.0708668754,
-0.0781095028,
-0.0486795157,
-0.0057881484,
-0.0281421803,
-0.0073155924,
0.0277724937,
0.015461795,
0.0084357066,
0.037857879,
-0.0687335208,
-0.007928499,
-0.0578927621,
-0.0091341771,
-0.0044772592,
0.0238807816,
0.0068976572,
-0.0266382284,
-0.0247637946,
0.0163371209,
-0.0316862687,
0.0045318617,
-0.0052759922,
0.0019006595,
0.0083385995,
0.0215356629,
-0.0710935146,
0.0379776247,
0.0252713505,
0.0160413943,
0.0108955624,
-0.0201036595,
-0.019418234,
0.0018492567,
0.0209210701,
-0.0025680624,
-0.0128010605,
-0.0018702109,
-0.013649296,
-0.069103308,
0.054615166,
0.003269891,
-0.0260577463,
-0.0132274199,
0.0332510583,
-0.0356528163,
0.0159619655,
0.0028655026,
-0.0078122043,
-0.0082559967,
-0.0030281248,
-0.0200966895,
0.005174513,
-0.0040705255,
0.0108732693,
0.0053691696,
-0.021561943,
-0.0081402361,
-0.0254855156,
-0.0266768895,
0.0549094826,
-0.0131558897,
0.0319704935,
-0.0154358959,
0.0075143641,
0.0347273648,
-0.0089046294,
0.006835917,
-0.0429684669,
-0.0325485729,
-0.010949186,
0.0147852292,
0.0186030865,
0.0128246211,
0.0063563702,
-0.0328527875,
-0.024672782,
-0.035521619,
-0.0076953499,
0.0020507928,
0.0246243514,
0.001821359,
0.0443667099,
-0.0450996533,
-0.0449007712,
-0.0248890184,
-0.008078617,
-0.0139972465,
0.0279529728,
0.0017135675,
-0.0010577377,
0.0456333347,
-0.0065640239,
0.0316948853,
0.0450182445,
0.0051492029,
-0.0011338781,
-0.0444482453,
0.0188486204,
0.0701707825,
0.0169870257,
0.0340304151,
0.0095641641,
-0.0354497433,
-0.0072214021,
0.0663641468,
0.0534210317,
-0.0990433916,
-0.0082553988,
0.0266277753,
-0.0074468628,
-0.0046862499,
0.0060426025,
0.0464348532,
-0.0282702837,
0.0060849325,
0.0425095372,
-0.0372967385,
-0.031961076,
0.0435797013,
0.04980997,
0.015971452,
0.0054935212,
0.0072196792,
-0.0635677874,
-0.0565605462,
0.0116836326,
0.0323385522,
-0.0290995967,
-0.0380962193,
0.0416830219,
-0.0978127271,
0.0401306413,
-0.0377988331,
-0.0404458158,
-0.0422290079,
-0.0465453528,
0.0503247045,
-0.0447148196,
0.0418113172,
-0.0208263956,
0.0125680426,
-0.035406407,
0.0843595341,
-0.0112407198,
-0.0483959913,
-0.0053001186,
-0.0779419467,
0.0026484602,
0.0321399793,
-0.0017925279,
-0.0299427416,
0.0154714268,
0.0135744903,
-0.0087549277,
-0.0238523502,
0.0144072864,
0.0122197391,
0.0540796183,
-0.0651889071,
0.0251411088,
0.0596468896,
-0.0058667688,
0.0227046441,
0.0210610069,
0.0922120214,
-0.0160856135,
0.0157095045,
0.0033952657,
-0.0262268446,
0.0608544834,
0.0267604534,
0.0068150968,
-0.0093429331,
-0.0217317883,
0.0399233811,
0.0066839438,
-0.0503181405,
0.0000816545,
0.0178510249,
-0.0318614878,
-0.0333000347,
-0.0319819786,
-0.0062760902,
0.0318410136,
0.0618921742,
0.0151338177,
-0.0030441151,
0.0706449971,
0.0738043413,
-0.0149071151,
-0.0109558254,
-0.0456059426,
0.0354822911,
0.0165562555,
-0.032947056,
0.0031910699,
-0.0536910817,
-0.0256691054,
0.0469574183,
-0.0781285837,
-0.0129935248,
0.038342949,
-0.0117218262,
0.0055075027,
0.035941273,
-0.0022881597,
-0.0866437033,
0.1164008155,
0.038601581,
0.0012136401,
0.0102961538,
0.0186920464,
-0.0695018321,
-0.022961976,
0.0446572751,
-0.0744852126,
0.0310592782,
0.0443252251,
-0.0266896356,
-0.0369047374,
-0.0004915611,
-0.0371075571,
0.0333568752,
0.0260714404,
0.0178771969,
0.0291874334,
-0.0289094094,
0.0203332976,
0.0974121615,
0.0223323964,
-0.0294868574,
0.0030710662,
-0.0142223099,
-0.0240372308,
-0.0309324879,
0.0156888682,
0.0760873705,
0.0086838454,
-0.0060203089,
0.0032961755,
0.021963343,
0.0332140215,
0.009428543,
0.019797368,
-0.0015169693,
0.0188280065,
0.0513081066,
0.0158764087,
-0.0012927382,
0.0051244642,
0.0143778427,
0.0258864425,
-0.0441965684,
-0.0328482091,
-0.0260182619,
-0.0614143535,
-0.0263312832,
0.0186180864,
0.0428724475,
-0.0462988093,
-0.0162244849,
-0.0409425758,
0.0083899759,
-0.0110049313,
0.0048732767,
-0.0302551426,
0.0221408997,
0.0193069652,
0.0127313668,
0.02367731,
0.0483967029,
0.0505929329,
-0.0205686297,
0.0338298865,
0.0097932266,
0.0484960824,
-0.0394418687,
-0.0113073401,
0.0446835496,
0.0428810865,
-0.0055151354,
-0.0111120045,
0.0671837106,
-0.0202922039,
0.0414961763,
-0.0389610641,
0.0106434459,
-0.0349721722,
0.0616127178,
0.0396302007,
-0.0002910255,
0.0304505825,
0.0136489328,
-0.0059230556,
-0.0139007866,
0.000818698,
-0.0258529689,
-6.14186027e-33,
0.0492794923,
0.059523128,
-0.0231459718,
0.0375531949,
-0.0120509937,
0.0444787405,
0.030098943,
-0.0221879911,
-0.0049145152,
-0.00767085,
-0.0430221185,
0.0002347332,
0.0344556123,
0.0829534978,
-0.0077335299,
-0.0716379583,
0.0959071591,
-0.0738741234,
-0.0042742542,
0.0795324296,
0.0324631445,
0.0185740758,
0.0380805694,
-0.0550649203,
-0.0760605857,
0.0306549165,
0.0182427708,
-0.0335791633,
0.0223431904,
0.0300133787,
-0.0180183724,
0.0485804267,
0.0040561147,
-0.0700211227,
-0.0221628584,
-0.0082624713,
-0.0762400031,
-0.0127284378,
-0.0477923341,
0.0622682832,
-0.0137437126,
-0.0113928011,
0.080293484,
0.013532836,
-0.0031265055,
-0.0047235605,
0.0322488844,
-0.0073173274,
-0.0326128714,
-0.0547067858,
0.0336009189,
0.011268978,
-0.0239945315,
-0.0108700851,
0.0156536661,
-0.034853857,
-0.0743385181,
0.0671098903,
-0.0374848284,
-0.0123014925,
-0.0008373077,
0.0356644168,
-0.003778589,
0.0527274981,
0.0522146374,
0.0727676898,
0.0161295999,
0.0036183577,
0.0270451028,
-0.0156632587,
0.0241015349,
0.0483379997,
0.0083662402,
0.0444160029,
0.0634668544,
-0.0039685536,
-0.101470761,
-0.0222382061,
0.0682275891,
-0.0173893142,
0.0462036878,
-0.0266125649,
0.022571234,
-0.0141601991,
0.0181450732,
-0.0364463404,
0.011695263,
0.0253293328,
-0.0269003864,
0.0536611415,
-0.052938167,
0.051019907,
0.0478153452,
-0.0364226662,
-0.0219588131,
0.0022096776,
0.042624943,
0.0095421039,
0.0316980593,
-0.0471339673,
-0.0674877614,
-0.0678298697,
-0.0258549321,
-0.0021795307,
0.0397815295,
0.000113772,
0.0308654383,
0.0414195918,
-0.0159105808,
-0.0238964763,
-0.0233578123,
0.0630382821,
-0.0108530028,
0.0341092534,
0.0529703274,
-0.0338624492,
0.0376054645,
0.0321339294,
-0.0143819312,
-0.0084904842,
0.0041996045,
-0.0206118338,
0.0169076901,
-0.0018445321,
-0.0545913316,
-0.0154817021,
-0.0789359808,
-0.023650175,
0.0067667062,
-0.1079628915,
-0.0267134346,
0.0136892693,
2.828e-7,
-0.0472302921,
-0.0121666463,
-0.0051906351,
-0.0240769535,
0.0212336704,
0.0200053975,
0.0192740597,
0.0447038412,
-0.0255988576,
0.009518425,
0.0128615927,
-0.0007355194,
0.0172257256,
0.0210412815,
-0.0926157013,
0.0144437449,
-0.0283292234,
0.0572899915,
-0.0521785133,
-0.0364121869,
-0.0318788253,
0.1218323112,
0.0132906064,
-0.0549886189,
0.0739560649,
-0.0145478295,
-0.0199498553,
0.0062590456,
0.0200324599,
-0.0145290289,
0.0262549743,
0.0628992319,
-0.0292593706,
0.0499001369,
0.0006337159,
0.0171643347,
0.0541990474,
-0.0087477369,
0.0043467893,
-0.0342691503,
-0.0168389454,
-0.0291023124,
-0.0007008058,
0.0308501832,
0.0898409784,
-0.0615243576,
-0.0360534973,
-0.0335567333,
-0.0158112589,
-0.0461466312,
0.0150321024,
-0.0299290121,
0.0258216243,
0.0158802848,
-0.0132956663,
-0.0347328,
-0.0347814634,
-0.0647556186,
0.0657579973,
-0.0112078451,
-0.0705477744,
-0.020841172,
-0.0581661388,
-0.0300889611,
0.0470669493,
0.0073525165,
0.007892224,
1.914339042e-34,
0.0252351314,
0.0179284364,
0.0006438801,
-0.033442989,
-0.0359547175,
-0.0228424631,
-0.0219933074,
-0.0081310933,
-0.0159628559,
-0.0178830437,
-0.0504131429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12707v1 | Keeping Users Engaged During Repeated Administration of the Same Questionnaire: Using Large Language Models to Reliably Diversify Questions | 2023-11-21T16:20:49 | 2023-11-21T16:20:49 | Hye Sun Yun, Mehdi Arjmand, Phillip Raymond Sherlock, Michael Paasche-Orlow, James W. Griffith, Timothy Bickmore | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Standardized, validated questionnaires are vital tools in HCI research and
healthcare, offering dependable self-report data. However, their repeated use
in longitudinal or pre-post studies can induce respondent fatigue, impacting
data quality via response biases and decreased response rates. We propose
utilizing large language models (LLMs) to generate diverse questionnaire
versions while retaining good psychometric properties. In a longitudinal study,
participants engaged with our agent system and responded daily for two weeks to
either a standardized depression questionnaire or one of two LLM-generated
questionnaire variants, alongside a validated depression questionnaire.
Psychometric testing revealed consistent covariation between the external
criterion and the focal measure administered across the three conditions,
demonstrating the reliability and validity of the LLM-generated variants.
Participants found the repeated administration of the standardized
questionnaire significantly more repetitive compared to the variants. Our
findings highlight the potential of LLM-generated variants to invigorate
questionnaires, fostering engagement and interest without compromising
validity. | [
0.0435091332,
0.0453305356,
-0.0405253209,
-0.0643692911,
-0.0196338166,
0.017162472,
0.0467516184,
-0.0049826712,
0.0595960915,
0.0143010356,
0.016334584,
-0.0278273728,
-0.0066776802,
0.0248530656,
-0.0154077085,
-0.0350054614,
-0.0007222315,
0.0160509013,
-0.0037336757,
0.0090216538,
0.0080783023,
-0.0068002818,
0.0186325181,
0.0291383564,
0.0118083982,
-0.0323611237,
0.0061795465,
0.0188206472,
0.0296480898,
-0.0650910214,
0.0101781078,
0.0747322962,
0.0118204011,
0.0010993993,
0.0000022447,
-0.0392076299,
-0.011483252,
0.0246665888,
-0.0235077683,
-0.0368930176,
0.0695020556,
0.0237446446,
0.0611202121,
0.0283756275,
0.0095503265,
-0.0093822498,
0.0584428348,
0.0258979071,
0.0202504136,
-0.0071190428,
-0.0305859372,
0.0130549343,
-0.0392132849,
-0.017423097,
0.0204566512,
0.0440351702,
0.0132074412,
-0.0035273817,
0.0389600806,
-0.0221534148,
0.0002294729,
0.0062410608,
0.0107001457,
0.0393387526,
0.0412037298,
-0.0134401815,
-0.0131762894,
-0.0368127078,
0.0253307,
0.061346285,
0.0641473681,
0.0380551964,
-0.0214710385,
-0.0132321492,
0.0323407799,
0.0242368653,
-0.0504553691,
-0.0175320096,
0.0061516319,
-0.0449071266,
0.0128328418,
0.0210809205,
0.0196515843,
-0.0407967195,
-0.0135143334,
0.0086638657,
0.0272712875,
-0.0131067857,
0.038807895,
-0.0122668399,
0.0104067996,
-0.037867222,
0.0009909064,
0.0202731322,
-0.0494566448,
0.0241567139,
0.0293488819,
-0.0309927091,
0.0748290792,
-0.0066885678,
0.0095288903,
0.0471850932,
-0.071686469,
-0.0278958194,
0.0933390111,
0.0337211527,
0.0115330881,
-0.0377233513,
-0.0765618086,
0.0310785063,
-0.039679911,
-0.0164482333,
-0.009056055,
0.0316204689,
0.000181771,
-0.024526488,
-0.0650109649,
0.0458737984,
0.0056104469,
-0.020808449,
-0.0235205386,
-0.0021515074,
0.0107114641,
0.0459419042,
0.0017368277,
0.0836267322,
-0.0650336817,
0.0063145608,
0.0350858271,
-0.0490767844,
0.0651298761,
-0.0085189063,
-0.0111082904,
-0.0447471887,
0.0282016732,
-0.041372519,
0.0199430194,
0.0123291956,
-0.0142939826,
-0.0226747114,
-0.0157794766,
-0.0414623693,
-0.0213171355,
-0.052824568,
0.0332406536,
0.0311933085,
-0.0002324195,
-0.0541135445,
-0.0027588108,
0.022328496,
-0.0497789569,
0.052686546,
-0.0352278985,
0.0142929656,
0.0110145062,
0.0216457881,
0.0486504361,
0.0165901352,
0.0204031449,
-0.0036974486,
0.0291198865,
-0.0675519407,
0.0321333446,
0.0136025334,
-0.0426303037,
0.0373587534,
0.0377900191,
-0.0062243752,
0.003318104,
0.0353569984,
-0.0868770108,
0.0625573024,
-0.0103362901,
0.0756304786,
0.0953310132,
0.0535193868,
0.0412338264,
-0.0136774164,
-0.0034430977,
-0.01141157,
0.0017520593,
0.0309750903,
-0.0134852324,
-0.0106442953,
0.0314198174,
-0.0025505309,
-0.0019500855,
-0.0197811387,
-0.045832932,
-0.0660175756,
-0.0470276959,
-0.0228302535,
0.0520613305,
0.0505421609,
-0.0055565243,
-0.0574734211,
0.0181301683,
0.0242529325,
0.014221048,
-0.0558957905,
0.0045891418,
-0.0013174715,
0.0383889638,
0.0929434076,
0.0018499335,
0.0003414493,
-0.0121987714,
-0.0094240615,
0.0434043929,
0.0272480454,
0.0473902375,
-0.0031395631,
0.0065742824,
-0.0317504704,
-0.0309984498,
0.0254518855,
-0.0068757576,
0.009730774,
-0.0510551371,
0.0255673397,
-0.023266146,
-0.0435816944,
-0.0456605628,
0.0209367778,
-0.0469973497,
-0.0538614355,
0.0130445855,
0.0085090427,
0.032639917,
0.0447901934,
0.0062447283,
0.0380541272,
0.0325269029,
0.0062254276,
-0.0005764345,
0.0173589978,
0.0219959598,
0.0192572679,
0.0018509253,
0.0497889668,
0.0336824879,
0.0098617515,
0.0223867688,
-0.0098300623,
0.0001006447,
-0.0301033538,
0.0106925154,
0.0044053248,
-0.0235014912,
0.004606992,
0.0379982293,
-0.0847094879,
-0.0113065457,
-0.0056327763,
0.0009635337,
0.0061002043,
-0.0414765701,
-0.0207356494,
-0.04354316,
-0.0248342473,
0.043788664,
-0.0178075768,
0.0068947757,
0.0033518167,
-0.0021028088,
-0.0693896413,
-0.0382774286,
-0.1374623179,
0.0002969028,
0.0228817966,
-0.042955406,
-0.0063252607,
0.0406649932,
-0.0075564352,
-0.0110604698,
-0.0650922656,
-0.0186262913,
0.0624232404,
0.0743661076,
-0.0232550912,
0.0271737538,
-0.014838866,
-0.0295214355,
-0.015004701,
-0.0189153962,
0.0136112962,
0.0077902488,
0.0308297519,
-0.0146540804,
-0.0593500882,
-0.0789318383,
-0.0516647547,
0.0252997652,
-0.0054373979,
0.0387227051,
-0.0031183707,
0.0625771806,
0.0359265767,
-0.0083666351,
0.0160920862,
0.0402679928,
-0.0087794391,
-0.0390562825,
-0.0048036342,
-0.0232532769,
-0.0412197113,
-0.0269838087,
-0.0783178955,
0.0334847309,
0.0118015539,
0.0117031522,
0.0317084491,
-0.0227760784,
-0.0032977706,
-0.0194132775,
-0.0029517517,
-0.0281628277,
0.0045511504,
-0.0557211973,
0.0426036343,
-0.0020362728,
-0.0509049296,
0.0091925096,
0.0267598052,
0.0197473187,
-0.0707081705,
0.0163137168,
-0.0219484512,
0.0160537232,
-0.0257009212,
-0.0004101331,
0.0508927889,
-0.0135065466,
-0.027283255,
-0.0470506847,
-0.0438431427,
-0.0595036857,
0.0322952196,
-0.0556247644,
-0.0251988396,
0.0282662306,
-0.0297127478,
-0.0479440354,
-0.0172335338,
-0.0231522769,
-0.0176707897,
-0.0047508818,
0.0508080944,
-0.032090161,
-0.0416973531,
0.0380835533,
0.0121236751,
-0.0031642397,
0.0028185446,
0.0198064502,
0.0271009486,
0.0671465248,
0.0316063352,
0.0559541136,
-0.0220921822,
0.0482607558,
0.0269692894,
-0.0321483836,
-0.0080874562,
0.0290758591,
0.0449971706,
0.019189341,
-0.0203794166,
-0.0096844686,
0.0434116796,
0.0190601032,
-0.0110342605,
0.0148357665,
0.0975708812,
-0.0085607357,
-0.0333689898,
0.0160958599,
-0.0567389764,
0.0431454405,
0.0210593771,
-0.0160897765,
-0.0246012025,
0.0145580126,
0.012392343,
0.0562748015,
-0.045194488,
0.0003799495,
0.0102583049,
-0.0251091588,
0.0112474989,
0.0131528443,
-0.0226235092,
0.0393794626,
0.0080771875,
0.0286164582,
0.0225648917,
0.0023835099,
0.0087066283,
0.0125171682,
0.017755961,
0.0160246547,
-0.0721578822,
-0.0531274267,
0.0302714668,
0.0113804825,
0.055989325,
0.0536605567,
0.01112724,
-0.002353722,
-0.0319714509,
0.0196622089,
0.0067727789,
-0.0343045406,
-0.0092039239,
0.0475536846,
0.032259021,
0.0248039421,
-0.0506801456,
0.0748782903,
-0.0370079093,
-0.0145102413,
0.0100324648,
0.0542434081,
0.0288871322,
-0.0249456018,
-0.0239932444,
0.0070580267,
0.0506288707,
0.0047412156,
0.0220494866,
-0.0495799705,
0.0409228541,
0.0237340052,
-0.0129446387,
0.0011888526,
-0.0411852747,
0.0299633462,
-0.0406556204,
0.0224410202,
-0.0402781293,
-0.104549624,
0.0652337596,
-0.0189156774,
0.0018667397,
0.0475843996,
0.0237005018,
0.0006318813,
-0.0453307927,
0.0239885692,
0.0222882982,
0.0254398007,
-0.0341490395,
-0.0046675485,
-0.0049977181,
-0.0286791828,
0.0157808904,
-0.0228985325,
-0.0510017164,
0.0047262027,
0.0858877674,
0.0486286841,
0.0195506252,
-0.0477439091,
0.0391695574,
-0.0033830081,
-0.0371776,
-0.0472095832,
-0.0088034421,
0.0146412281,
-0.0684858784,
0.0692739934,
-0.0053486004,
0.0000764954,
-0.0253630597,
-0.0084799994,
0.0499721318,
0.0317931883,
0.0203044433,
-0.0294916369,
0.0385733247,
0.0477186106,
-0.0143042579,
-0.0294223465,
0.0290250201,
0.0088165244,
-0.036699865,
-0.048670318,
-0.024257442,
-0.023338208,
-0.012671072,
-0.0026115719,
-0.0111654131,
-0.0150783341,
-0.0192528665,
-0.0676333904,
0.007826928,
-0.0737534389,
-0.0270106681,
-0.0634693354,
-0.0048175436,
0.0013511591,
0.01821444,
-0.0276752654,
0.0521269068,
-0.0110321529,
0.036873579,
0.00183543,
0.0558594018,
-0.0316265747,
-0.0208646134,
-0.0272809435,
0.0190004501,
-0.0207071304,
-0.0754766315,
0.0067525385,
-0.0307640769,
0.000577669,
0.0117954323,
0.0174707863,
0.0081171626,
-0.000093232,
-0.0742734075,
-0.0409426428,
0.0231895931,
-0.0182577465,
0.0165653639,
-0.0077570188,
-0.0226613898,
-0.0628004372,
0.0252551157,
-0.0079650227,
-0.031877622,
-0.042640321,
-0.0173799451,
-0.0340144001,
0.0367469527,
0.0141176479,
0.0416512713,
-0.0869446918,
-0.0295473672,
-0.0699161291,
-0.053617999,
0.0214611515,
-0.0408177599,
0.0332782567,
-0.0317397155,
0.012692403,
0.0283832457,
-0.0310752951,
-0.0451181754,
-0.0327097699,
0.0580001362,
-0.0708181635,
-0.0271519199,
-0.0076688146,
-6.268514644e-33,
0.0042780777,
0.0120674372,
0.0201384723,
-0.0668036044,
-0.0349401645,
-0.0000478542,
-0.0204210449,
0.0380351432,
-0.0020751138,
-0.0212158263,
0.0105888434,
-0.0278085042,
0.0151124299,
0.036744643,
0.0616052188,
-0.0042225723,
0.0417484902,
0.0256181173,
-0.0335002281,
0.0047421288,
-0.0259015039,
-0.0004320526,
0.0225438625,
-0.0517372042,
0.0405749828,
-0.0069960691,
0.0461757667,
-0.0028708603,
0.0213511828,
0.0659466758,
-0.0013981926,
0.0579117239,
0.0571302623,
0.0170309506,
0.0113312248,
0.0372720249,
-0.045625262,
-0.0435820594,
0.0169872437,
-0.0022959823,
-0.0444992706,
-0.0529901497,
0.0318078324,
-0.0320517793,
-0.026277449,
-0.0244228113,
0.0169080235,
-0.0469445437,
0.0075773466,
-0.0161903165,
-0.0353336483,
-0.0248127487,
-0.0026794926,
0.0106408205,
-0.1267348826,
0.09763062,
-0.0716676861,
0.0262992419,
-0.0555536747,
0.0341058969,
0.000171776,
-0.0169970971,
-0.0048900167,
0.0227449816,
0.0118722674,
0.010773045,
0.0221680719,
-0.0005145014,
-0.0538797341,
0.0279537439,
0.0241038129,
-0.0049387915,
0.0501144826,
0.047263056,
0.0105608031,
-0.0525287911,
-0.0240672585,
0.0095660696,
-0.0035757937,
0.0003339036,
0.0297770407,
0.0272087753,
-0.001179287,
-0.045787964,
-0.0780189037,
0.0201195069,
-0.0429616459,
-0.0787301883,
0.0682887957,
0.0081199836,
-0.0000728972,
-0.0372728258,
0.0612079129,
-0.0058927499,
-0.0346264094,
-0.0372767448,
-0.018669188,
0.0517974533,
0.0096079307,
0.0071035246,
-0.0026679663,
0.0482771844,
-0.0245810319,
0.0191062707,
0.0452119708,
0.0311186928,
-0.0183244795,
-0.0467828624,
-0.0270709246,
-0.0148630999,
0.0336878188,
0.0117564639,
0.0519220307,
0.0145081915,
0.0153849712,
0.0332565792,
0.0163784977,
0.0677268133,
0.021111574,
-0.0310236178,
-0.0910975561,
-0.0266568512,
-0.0054356097,
0.0225917045,
0.0148859676,
0.0068453001,
-0.0629478768,
0.0044942028,
0.0594332069,
0.0105363484,
0.0075315312,
-0.0407918207,
2.974e-7,
-0.0224725492,
0.037602134,
-0.0534701906,
-0.024648793,
0.0260249004,
-0.0173341017,
-0.0015261282,
-0.0078498945,
0.0452518463,
-0.0058049699,
0.0398977213,
0.0030548791,
0.0331068523,
0.0364927389,
0.0008126704,
-0.048188623,
0.0241115466,
-0.0008023317,
-0.073632665,
0.0339669324,
0.0765928403,
0.0385233313,
-0.0307903346,
-0.0018500991,
-0.0289136302,
0.0086269034,
0.026981907,
-0.0155396098,
-0.0228021611,
0.0594454631,
-0.0013507175,
-0.0108830221,
0.0272740796,
0.0039462899,
0.0109704854,
-0.0491000786,
-0.0044976063,
0.0596579947,
-0.0178832449,
-0.0263642017,
-0.007894109,
0.0017578811,
0.0086034266,
-0.0552865751,
0.0445455909,
-0.0664041787,
-0.042975273,
0.0163044222,
-0.0320891477,
-0.0359550603,
0.0973693952,
-0.0494518541,
-0.0474838316,
0.0258784574,
0.0494375229,
0.04033871,
0.0084387548,
0.0134696672,
0.0169657711,
0.0213186666,
-0.0610233434,
-0.0557512157,
-0.020350419,
-0.0316995233,
-0.0787245184,
-0.0411217287,
0.0207316186,
2.581792885e-34,
0.0298236962,
0.0581391789,
0.0358864665,
0.0194454901,
0.0301811639,
-0.0384657942,
-0.0276537891,
0.0502353124,
0.0244198684,
-0.0901949033,
-0.009000171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12699v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12699v1 | Can Large Language Models Understand Content and Propagation for Misinformation Detection: An Empirical Study | 2023-11-21T16:03:51 | 2023-11-21T16:03:51 | Mengyang Chen, Lingwei Wei, Han Cao, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention for their
powerful ability in natural language understanding and reasoning. In this
paper, we present a comprehensive empirical study to explore the performance of
LLMs on misinformation detection tasks. This study stands as the pioneering
investigation into the understanding capabilities of multiple LLMs regarding
both content and propagation across social media platforms. Our empirical
studies on five misinformation detection datasets show that LLMs with diverse
prompts achieve comparable performance in text-based misinformation detection
but exhibit notably constrained capabilities in comprehending propagation
structure compared to existing models in propagation-based misinformation
detection. Besides, we further design four instruction-tuned strategies to
enhance LLMs for both content and propagation-based misinformation detection.
These strategies boost LLMs to actively learn effective features from multiple
instances or hard instances, and eliminate irrelevant propagation structures,
thereby achieving better detection performance. Extensive experiments further
demonstrate LLMs would play a better capacity in content and propagation
structure under these proposed strategies and achieve promising detection
performance. These findings highlight the potential ability of LLMs to detect
misinformation. | [
0.0449567549,
-0.0118269222,
-0.011156016,
0.0522845276,
-0.0351279415,
0.0215355381,
0.0044452385,
-0.0000037334,
0.0100972317,
-0.0556118451,
-0.0165359601,
-0.048659686,
0.0051358766,
0.0189354122,
0.0111113526,
-0.0149535444,
0.074660182,
-0.0232333727,
0.0408036783,
-0.0064763939,
0.0220521409,
0.0389244817,
0.0090070227,
0.0091425469,
-0.0256250314,
-0.035593275,
0.013389729,
0.0136131672,
0.0108057894,
-0.0383963883,
0.0231257267,
0.0397465825,
0.054888472,
0.1027152687,
0.000001699,
-0.0070313686,
0.004433515,
0.0027923605,
-0.0661075711,
0.0362089649,
0.051900629,
-0.0539801866,
-0.0043531219,
0.0297779497,
0.0016977437,
0.0215616208,
0.031751018,
0.074139148,
0.0847374126,
0.1024919301,
0.0082012499,
-0.0390069298,
0.0116954613,
-0.0030009875,
0.0212292001,
-0.0547889806,
0.0923301876,
-0.0086920913,
-0.0025869121,
0.0625832453,
0.0135460291,
0.0057484838,
0.0056529692,
-0.0249604695,
-0.0057332399,
-0.0101689985,
0.020380836,
-0.0456105471,
-0.0120793944,
0.0675607175,
-0.0096316645,
-0.0481383316,
-0.0153117841,
-0.0155488653,
0.0053908681,
0.020668963,
-0.012015325,
0.0284794532,
-0.027944088,
0.0226183664,
0.0201925617,
-0.0328226611,
0.0807556584,
0.0617005341,
0.0092287883,
0.0538520105,
-0.0158693809,
-0.0434128977,
0.0181262121,
-0.0000413099,
0.0064997287,
-0.0481612384,
0.0109882737,
0.0354246683,
-0.052722577,
0.0375937335,
-0.0680675507,
-0.0324194394,
0.0523862094,
-0.1119319499,
0.0069834748,
0.0011417106,
-0.004663852,
0.0680158883,
0.0030633092,
0.0200959332,
-0.0461454727,
0.0029627283,
0.0006135756,
-0.036250297,
-0.0304867271,
-0.0096073477,
0.0105394144,
0.0247835126,
-0.0263917297,
0.0054824087,
-0.0346534401,
0.0085369423,
-0.0252343342,
-0.0107321078,
-0.0143546024,
-0.0011819224,
-0.0133367078,
-0.0185247287,
-0.0221705399,
0.0392544083,
0.0129959313,
0.039059218,
-0.0130173108,
-0.0588379614,
-0.0009910258,
0.0209208727,
-0.0235912632,
0.0067849336,
0.0006007481,
0.0159017015,
0.0247897953,
-0.01261333,
-0.0493464619,
-0.0399899334,
-0.0302952994,
-0.0554489382,
-0.0079283295,
-0.0634826794,
0.0036596328,
-0.006132016,
-0.0188514609,
-0.0147084948,
0.0071549765,
0.0282563008,
-0.0943958536,
0.0525378808,
-0.0255411267,
0.0288950261,
0.0684979856,
0.0374219157,
-0.0017586263,
0.0710307434,
-0.0208453275,
0.073890537,
0.0454081073,
0.0198817812,
0.0105678337,
-0.0130658401,
0.0475284681,
0.0243124384,
0.022163054,
0.0026736071,
-0.0119785434,
-0.0177004319,
-0.0140784355,
0.0701823384,
-0.0069234283,
-0.0485052243,
0.0898388773,
-0.0293485243,
-0.0210376922,
0.0032134517,
0.0621988438,
0.0284088142,
-0.0084212339,
-0.0312359016,
-0.0655517802,
-0.0081560453,
-0.0536937267,
-0.0349047221,
0.0201644599,
0.0460385494,
-0.0165407751,
-0.0147005487,
-0.0439881161,
0.0014329281,
0.0053232838,
0.0104137147,
0.0108672958,
-0.0122041097,
-0.0363082923,
0.0567072928,
0.0554608181,
0.0172128864,
0.0035909077,
-0.0173345879,
0.0273544807,
0.0597745031,
0.0197668038,
-0.0040460238,
0.011099549,
-0.0387740918,
0.0402265973,
0.0257817749,
0.0543587431,
-0.0214319788,
-0.0068111802,
0.0038011768,
-0.0034028725,
-0.0131797362,
0.0170348659,
0.0024901952,
0.0481761582,
0.0107634012,
0.0010068103,
-0.0088229449,
-0.0663416237,
0.0260215662,
0.0010286378,
-0.0037323954,
-0.0135023398,
0.0184454191,
0.0236721653,
0.0101461001,
0.0003977031,
-0.0384985842,
0.0285868868,
0.0055230949,
-0.0610138588,
-0.0710560381,
-0.0436841883,
-0.0085669728,
0.0308408961,
0.0212142318,
-0.0552776679,
0.0078107999,
-0.0529098287,
0.0314925835,
0.0255521368,
-0.0602944791,
0.0068398891,
-0.0417592153,
-0.0152733494,
-0.0342454799,
0.0384103283,
0.0379317068,
0.0847275779,
-0.0347502753,
-0.0327174664,
0.028445771,
-0.021781275,
0.0042019938,
-0.0041208155,
0.0093692075,
-0.0216577761,
0.0124765411,
0.0032322118,
0.0010733946,
-0.0178961512,
0.0054080519,
-0.0181513634,
-0.0487914793,
-0.0338479541,
-0.0386816673,
-0.0114295306,
0.0485329106,
-0.0076338332,
0.0161605831,
0.0037737975,
-0.0026162188,
0.010911732,
0.0336079821,
0.0225279238,
-0.0006893944,
-0.0058854599,
-0.0067201057,
-0.0098970644,
0.0138549963,
-0.0294273924,
0.0262785554,
0.0219616536,
-0.0664530694,
-0.0522040166,
-0.0123587046,
-0.035348665,
0.0325370319,
-0.0146227451,
-0.0213753376,
-0.016191911,
0.032652203,
-0.0048500169,
0.0149350781,
0.029921921,
0.0770202875,
0.0509834439,
0.02037099,
-0.0108498801,
-0.0057649938,
-0.0348768197,
0.0171058215,
-0.0637519732,
-0.0551303551,
0.0218048859,
0.0511932783,
0.0371465385,
0.0012611079,
-0.0288418345,
0.0205495711,
-0.0160908289,
-0.0377467126,
-0.0246505756,
-0.0794414431,
0.0102436747,
0.020568585,
-0.0521862805,
-0.0526945256,
0.1016357616,
-0.0362402685,
0.0436108448,
-0.0269974321,
-0.0563681088,
-0.0048695114,
-0.0183312315,
-0.0019622273,
0.0503912792,
0.0024103611,
-0.0032578425,
0.001649302,
-0.0134014916,
0.0380354077,
-0.0005323675,
0.0190168358,
-0.0594281107,
0.0352853388,
0.048420053,
-0.046789404,
-0.0638615042,
-0.1197305173,
-0.0000233066,
-0.0013239986,
-0.0136240665,
-0.015235709,
-0.0812291205,
-0.0255588554,
0.0323367752,
-0.0291562285,
-0.0086254496,
0.0125362445,
-0.0044104201,
0.005937825,
0.0463252962,
-0.0316114314,
0.074132897,
-0.0624511056,
0.0150125036,
0.0411271192,
-0.0102666626,
-0.0000394912,
-0.0116563672,
-0.0308628455,
-0.0152541734,
-0.0282128081,
0.0005261158,
0.0007447184,
0.0419807546,
-0.0614363514,
0.0047945268,
0.1045630723,
0.0125055583,
-0.0079406174,
-0.0131171932,
0.0182243511,
-0.0261536408,
0.0244620387,
-0.0053219409,
-0.0575064011,
-0.0043655061,
0.0089527816,
0.0021365378,
-0.0130646899,
-0.0011957309,
-0.0106328875,
-0.0838668197,
0.0223514792,
-0.0030947507,
-0.0202704743,
-0.0643770248,
-0.0514043607,
-0.0127452053,
0.0283941664,
0.0442024395,
-0.0029629907,
0.0023255041,
-0.0430695266,
-0.0122618005,
-0.0230983458,
-0.0746738762,
0.0196024328,
-0.0031213998,
0.0676057935,
0.035386391,
0.0246070921,
0.004755382,
-0.0284045115,
0.0307264384,
-0.0103242509,
-0.0105329556,
-0.0255699754,
0.0436703637,
-0.0316973962,
-0.0105439723,
-0.0299617182,
0.0067080506,
-0.006391535,
-0.0053008576,
-0.0342301056,
0.0676361769,
-0.0019221177,
-0.0514837094,
-0.028012583,
0.0146786189,
0.0522109121,
0.076414749,
0.011009695,
0.0149147101,
-0.0261985473,
-0.042404443,
-0.0467311777,
0.0372735076,
-0.0235390738,
0.0631582662,
0.0073226546,
-0.0143305277,
-0.0112528997,
-0.0071176575,
0.0153652364,
-0.0215235054,
-0.0026034713,
0.024419589,
0.0169615541,
-0.0031612043,
0.0073917317,
-0.0133010801,
-0.0508715436,
0.0644908175,
-0.0092295753,
-0.005845116,
-0.0186717249,
-0.0136403302,
-0.011370129,
0.0110651478,
-0.099956058,
-0.084719263,
-0.0065125399,
0.0065214825,
0.0183340218,
0.0597006008,
-0.0451376252,
-0.0630377755,
0.0660739541,
0.0099573368,
-0.0421034768,
0.0323012322,
-0.0055876849,
-0.0071319733,
0.034308698,
0.0448178425,
-0.0353873484,
0.0289957765,
0.0210849475,
-0.0118853748,
-0.0512072705,
0.0112416428,
0.0127494792,
0.0116464617,
0.0191902258,
0.0231300648,
0.0057270885,
-0.0252748579,
-0.0196118336,
-0.0095983185,
-0.0455270521,
0.0315771624,
0.0311706997,
0.030960951,
-0.0252418332,
-0.007975677,
0.0062333588,
-0.0110351974,
0.0145699596,
-0.0224041324,
-0.0015471719,
0.0119231325,
0.0138184,
0.0549751222,
-0.0189605691,
-0.0231730305,
0.0228824448,
0.0119379805,
0.0046109604,
0.0114910966,
0.0096427025,
-0.0014276798,
-0.0255675688,
-0.0053209723,
-0.0586929321,
-0.0324260741,
-0.050254561,
-0.0120265717,
0.0330182537,
0.0372634269,
0.0027918338,
0.0189431012,
0.0020247733,
-0.0435912982,
-0.0230398141,
-0.0372780263,
0.0177509151,
-0.0318547077,
0.0519940518,
0.0080200098,
-0.0357245579,
0.0419340208,
0.0568599142,
0.0268951897,
0.0241280682,
0.0369772203,
-0.0723391399,
-0.0332036652,
-0.0034576589,
-0.0168296713,
0.0393110067,
-0.0305311251,
0.0529359393,
-0.0581019707,
-0.060689833,
0.0224657953,
0.0046530571,
0.0109940898,
0.002978551,
-0.0234862119,
0.0858325213,
0.0193270314,
0.0130707221,
-0.0560916215,
-0.0048280875,
-0.0038183669,
-0.0296607539,
0.0233009737,
-6.312583192e-33,
-0.0005730145,
-0.0398998111,
-0.0228776112,
-0.0055952612,
0.0079185786,
0.032407824,
-0.0111816796,
-0.0324036255,
-0.040062245,
0.0619136989,
0.0367373824,
0.0622094385,
-0.0047424817,
0.0043398258,
-0.0399719775,
-0.0268700272,
0.0746730492,
0.00410849,
-0.0049183415,
0.030536335,
0.0596036613,
0.0112663377,
0.004095458,
-0.0863520578,
0.0442182533,
-0.0234011058,
-0.0008313245,
0.0468629673,
-0.0305643659,
0.060065452,
-0.0091077089,
0.0645319074,
0.0546098948,
-0.0322756059,
0.0004846741,
0.037382666,
-0.0544910282,
0.0073021343,
0.0365201496,
-0.0109692877,
-0.0159278214,
-0.0138890706,
0.0455636345,
0.0006722977,
0.0199010037,
0.012339402,
0.0201986637,
-0.0042231209,
0.0174420625,
0.0319557153,
-0.0569059551,
-0.011860515,
0.0080395853,
0.0077679041,
-0.026108779,
0.0301752798,
0.0063011097,
0.0511123054,
-0.0964175686,
-0.0055976463,
-0.0175039656,
-0.0019461139,
0.0292317942,
-0.0326150544,
-0.0381624736,
0.0727995038,
0.0048448713,
0.0158948582,
-0.0627192408,
-0.0111660901,
-0.022939736,
0.0186378881,
0.0415262915,
0.0725409165,
0.001056088,
-0.0424981266,
-0.1261126399,
-0.0211079735,
0.0290237479,
0.0105018364,
0.0413401872,
-0.0262359269,
-0.0126997754,
-0.0010611871,
-0.0437365435,
0.0114239287,
-0.0514993407,
-0.0049667545,
0.0064012562,
0.0480894707,
0.0082211485,
0.0247371532,
0.0092935991,
-0.0649143383,
-0.0457779169,
0.058237303,
0.0195353702,
-0.0359059051,
0.0380324945,
0.0541538596,
-0.0775891691,
0.0103388727,
0.0125811063,
-0.0279718004,
-0.0322912894,
-0.0005537214,
0.0690335333,
0.0019992793,
-0.0542915724,
0.0013590174,
-0.0345936008,
0.0282927845,
-0.0264549814,
0.0072602001,
0.0499643199,
0.0174210649,
-0.003619638,
0.0179914366,
-0.0006964711,
0.0315877534,
0.0216231775,
-0.0020860317,
-0.0359238088,
0.0198042355,
-0.0333062485,
-0.0135545218,
-0.0406674035,
0.017516844,
-0.0044244137,
-0.092708528,
0.0202698614,
0.0207755994,
2.537e-7,
0.0200860798,
0.087576516,
-0.0273394939,
0.0182398688,
0.057147298,
0.0422569998,
-0.0112470994,
-0.0142954281,
-0.0198838133,
-0.0816758126,
-0.0211149286,
0.0761272162,
0.0114164259,
0.0408808328,
-0.0350623205,
0.0323902778,
-0.056617938,
-0.0251046512,
-0.0664542988,
-0.0039533735,
0.019469047,
0.1036519036,
0.0416267626,
-0.0320512727,
-0.0011976617,
-0.0210791063,
0.0637010857,
0.0344047137,
-0.0284006614,
0.0135642318,
0.0320374705,
0.0039439946,
0.0084502026,
0.0246860422,
-0.0071240282,
0.0006530899,
-0.0397175699,
0.0295926984,
-0.0115664341,
0.0063659744,
-0.0419713147,
-0.019607123,
-0.004272108,
-0.0640869215,
0.0590299964,
-0.0268364064,
-0.0457145534,
-0.056453798,
0.0018621552,
0.0012381183,
0.0051078522,
-0.0061588893,
-0.0135603379,
0.0082704239,
-0.0105841961,
-0.0029666517,
0.0005496946,
-0.0572983623,
0.0571826361,
0.0104627786,
-0.054359097,
-0.0297223907,
-0.0219587237,
-0.0108193755,
0.0719424412,
-0.0307039861,
0.0409507416,
2.064136167e-34,
0.0638182834,
-0.0489612035,
-0.0161602385,
-0.0135695422,
0.0408987701,
0.0320571586,
-0.0679196343,
-0.0234499574,
0.0044848863,
-0.0430534258,
0.0182090309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12689v1 | Fair Text Classification with Wasserstein Independence | 2023-11-21T15:51:06 | 2023-11-21T15:51:06 | Thibaud Leteno, Antoine Gourru, Charlotte Laclau, Rémi Emonet, Christophe Gravier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Group fairness is a central research topic in text classification, where
reaching fair treatment between sensitive groups (e.g. women vs. men) remains
an open challenge. This paper presents a novel method for mitigating biases in
neural text classification, agnostic to the model architecture. Considering the
difficulty to distinguish fair from unfair information in a text encoder, we
take inspiration from adversarial training to induce Wasserstein independence
between representations learned to predict our target label and the ones
learned to predict some sensitive attribute. Our approach provides two
significant advantages. Firstly, it does not require annotations of sensitive
attributes in both testing and training data. This is more suitable for
real-life scenarios compared to existing methods that require annotations of
sensitive attributes at train time. Second, our approach exhibits a comparable
or better fairness-accuracy trade-off compared to existing methods. | [
0.0263486169,
0.1214911416,
-0.0318340361,
0.0311694704,
-0.0175274611,
0.0345379412,
0.0361527987,
-0.0037355584,
-0.0020018695,
-0.0616749823,
-0.0288991164,
-0.0333037823,
-0.0292145498,
-0.0198773071,
0.0038243316,
-0.0316669121,
0.0189929884,
0.053782694,
0.026966149,
-0.0645757914,
0.0292687714,
-0.022328401,
0.0215979312,
0.0136552891,
-0.0078393379,
-0.01170443,
0.0536911413,
-0.0186176524,
0.0075015142,
0.0114579517,
0.0787955001,
0.0762001052,
-0.0175978821,
0.0589489341,
0.0000018383,
-0.0056710676,
-0.0062400969,
0.0108288787,
0.0131973885,
-0.0133575471,
0.0378541723,
-0.044150427,
0.0110605275,
0.0130035551,
-0.0328593813,
-0.0229737684,
0.0181006342,
0.0769870058,
0.0366470069,
0.0424590744,
-0.0211094394,
0.0006907092,
-0.0042610373,
-0.041423291,
-0.0043912786,
-0.0225418471,
0.0227144845,
-0.046992179,
-0.0793287233,
-0.000617702,
-0.0060810801,
0.0270346198,
0.0491354503,
0.0249450523,
0.0375718661,
0.0213732049,
-0.0369362906,
0.0017044313,
0.0047633317,
0.0552630015,
-0.0332345217,
0.014047646,
-0.0268844459,
-0.0334612615,
0.039470613,
-0.0216144565,
-0.0041940948,
0.0175236911,
-0.0471542515,
0.0439490266,
-0.0224884544,
0.0756668523,
0.0159166232,
0.0224231016,
0.0069592022,
0.0443882793,
0.0137706827,
0.0027689228,
-0.0066135372,
0.0673092008,
-0.0226927549,
0.0030232221,
0.0349730328,
-0.0577493906,
0.0380769782,
-0.033067286,
-0.0406463668,
-0.0533440635,
0.0160711575,
-0.0397049263,
0.0098327333,
-0.0060441662,
-0.0039588963,
-0.0175787285,
-0.0113113616,
0.0205715708,
0.0010358091,
0.0764976069,
-0.0069081192,
0.0037920405,
0.0153747946,
0.0057254578,
0.0169869307,
0.0246777479,
-0.0448622964,
0.0611602142,
-0.0154722538,
0.007017727,
-0.0546781011,
0.0052493848,
0.0000505082,
0.0490023904,
-0.0647061467,
0.0160505585,
-0.0100396592,
-0.0127392178,
-0.0522947311,
0.0384170189,
-0.020684287,
-0.0577024259,
-0.0098102698,
0.015145258,
-0.025167143,
-0.018179711,
0.0038987165,
0.0566761345,
-0.0013798104,
-0.0246275403,
-0.0389812142,
-0.0010701994,
0.0088521689,
-0.0164356884,
0.0158479232,
0.0050228597,
0.0113591617,
0.0112636872,
-0.0224260911,
-0.1006245762,
-0.028444998,
-0.0199765451,
-0.0299290959,
0.0993621647,
0.078199707,
-0.0771056712,
0.0492409915,
0.0428584032,
-0.0078718588,
0.0636907071,
0.0339742601,
0.0457205586,
0.0278124195,
0.0267998222,
0.0107699251,
0.0036686314,
0.0685717911,
0.0341184139,
-0.0245770793,
0.0115667032,
0.0008381305,
-0.0164505541,
0.0479446277,
0.0038967736,
0.0130664883,
-0.087660946,
0.0522141084,
0.0305624045,
-0.0217926819,
0.0587339289,
-0.0500775464,
-0.0005602209,
-0.0668279156,
0.0484428145,
-0.0496024527,
0.0374154113,
-0.0439762473,
-0.0490646474,
0.0032842834,
-0.0074110716,
-0.0504320525,
-0.049247168,
0.0280222297,
-0.019693099,
0.0452011935,
-0.0337215178,
0.0029694047,
0.0246374402,
0.0010642976,
0.0070384797,
0.0502048619,
-0.0259111747,
0.0271967035,
-0.0487511978,
0.0083643282,
0.0023173084,
0.0488879122,
-0.0650637448,
0.0733639225,
-0.0346166454,
-0.0135306427,
0.0352057777,
0.0317266136,
-0.0054243058,
0.0131282564,
-0.0563713945,
-0.0275629982,
-0.0156794526,
0.0360007286,
0.0557379052,
-0.0150992908,
0.0304360986,
-0.008613647,
0.002304466,
-0.0414255932,
0.0445856526,
0.0368669033,
-0.0829777494,
0.0393911675,
0.0293829031,
0.017862916,
-0.0055117956,
-0.0604068972,
0.0120828999,
-0.015192586,
-0.0415612347,
-0.0542488061,
-0.0300238281,
-0.0306870285,
-0.0457632504,
-0.0672791079,
-0.0607526004,
-0.0245022122,
0.040024329,
-0.0290696714,
0.0192116089,
0.0235706996,
0.0293056481,
-0.043472968,
-0.0122659151,
-0.0197004769,
-0.0045492817,
0.0463889912,
-0.0704248175,
0.0195911992,
-0.024027653,
-0.0016179642,
-0.0656265244,
-0.0381516851,
0.0031606704,
-0.0239358153,
0.003638326,
0.0483134016,
0.0250038579,
0.0529669262,
0.0339819156,
-0.0178302955,
0.0399374813,
-0.0135015966,
-0.0114580225,
-0.0115822274,
-0.0213616341,
0.0030733577,
-0.0210027769,
0.0241805594,
0.0159018412,
-0.0404064953,
-0.0420304723,
-0.0461984649,
-0.0254999362,
0.0073138699,
0.0098715657,
-0.0350583568,
0.0440005213,
-0.004983379,
-0.0517994687,
-0.0104742451,
0.0935411826,
0.0461718291,
0.0338161401,
-0.0276278779,
-0.0123962695,
-0.0140054189,
0.079210721,
-0.0248973742,
-0.0397316068,
-0.0101907048,
0.0320566073,
-0.0675799996,
0.0957866982,
0.0433659665,
0.0439477488,
0.0379140899,
0.0703639463,
0.0124030467,
0.0024246804,
-0.0016567189,
0.0525683835,
-0.000292763,
-0.0064535886,
0.0111152641,
0.0242639016,
0.0285812821,
-0.0332379118,
-0.080316104,
0.0263277479,
-0.0376188159,
-0.0556157194,
-0.0476017743,
-0.0100118695,
0.0082426183,
-0.0120752351,
-0.0533782504,
-0.0688357875,
0.0716985017,
0.0077075339,
0.0328668281,
-0.0587368831,
-0.0067224349,
-0.007886094,
0.0438547321,
0.0021930595,
0.025782669,
0.00735929,
-0.0047919462,
-0.0693641454,
-0.0208575446,
0.0601208918,
-0.0249103568,
0.0161508135,
0.0064163581,
-0.0141654769,
-0.0392217711,
-0.0694559142,
-0.0683836415,
-0.0799556747,
0.0271379575,
0.0176158808,
0.0265271924,
0.0145965908,
-0.0762734562,
-0.0096684881,
-0.0374516025,
0.0635869205,
-0.0267207213,
0.0318945497,
-0.0006016513,
0.032218311,
0.0115391631,
-0.0464590788,
-0.0183767118,
-0.0350406468,
0.0027657785,
0.0555709675,
-0.0007667883,
0.0557714216,
0.0387275442,
0.0141908079,
0.0252958965,
-0.0256588627,
0.0084486408,
-0.0482313111,
0.0172734652,
-0.0251446217,
-0.0045669968,
0.066493541,
-0.0057952874,
-0.0799022093,
0.0139513193,
0.0268439017,
0.0422036499,
0.0091285305,
-0.0252763256,
-0.0734502152,
-0.0170552861,
-0.0117749041,
0.0206706673,
-0.0463485681,
-0.0275845807,
0.0032439004,
-0.0385488272,
-0.0258911029,
0.045102451,
-0.0640889853,
-0.0510204993,
0.0447744727,
-0.0094210859,
-0.0071482407,
0.0466784239,
-0.0385506675,
0.0608760901,
0.0183340125,
0.0223828573,
-0.01085281,
-0.0138166519,
0.0037209855,
-0.066181235,
0.0213676151,
0.0473863594,
0.0339857489,
-0.0137357982,
-0.0593446195,
-0.0062427456,
-0.0204129554,
-0.0345013961,
0.0047603534,
0.0873036087,
-0.0626119971,
-0.0056730495,
-0.0427898765,
0.0510410964,
0.0356870778,
0.011744231,
0.0069863084,
-0.011925037,
-0.0130833006,
-0.0274479557,
-0.0382868387,
-0.0509377792,
0.0150920087,
0.0518161803,
0.0074525559,
-0.0576503538,
-0.031296771,
-0.0796024874,
0.0048902915,
-0.0530678108,
-0.037509501,
0.0658448339,
0.0336067155,
-0.0291650202,
-0.0424950011,
-0.0515231043,
-0.0399084575,
-0.0066824108,
-0.0250174757,
-0.0612981766,
-0.0342093483,
-0.0199478716,
-0.0531231239,
0.0171122644,
0.0177913196,
0.0275258515,
0.010690162,
-0.0146719227,
-0.004180965,
-0.0527087711,
-0.0325979926,
0.0045301975,
-0.0208057575,
-0.0529760793,
0.0249268319,
0.009206567,
0.008676365,
0.03451306,
-0.0301461089,
-0.0687947124,
0.0826508403,
0.068001464,
-0.0115403607,
0.007193679,
0.0636402965,
-0.0521770604,
-0.0011017649,
0.0247548316,
-0.0045395158,
0.0413551219,
0.0365960598,
-0.038140282,
-0.0003998646,
0.0149662197,
-0.0281153098,
0.0110753607,
0.0448071733,
-0.0024279952,
-0.0465855375,
-0.041959174,
0.012892684,
0.0034908946,
-0.0242926534,
-0.0000196451,
-0.0215561911,
0.0110542402,
0.0294929445,
-0.0638573095,
0.0173467826,
-0.0059336354,
0.0290238727,
-0.0197358001,
-0.0114765484,
0.0105944015,
0.0758054703,
-0.0207620915,
0.0204946566,
-0.0073684477,
0.0213198792,
0.028751241,
0.0253611971,
-0.0078186551,
0.002512163,
0.0402089134,
0.0080777491,
-0.0687822476,
0.0091092773,
-0.0484793372,
0.0463692024,
-0.0351164937,
0.0362695791,
0.0071573076,
0.0102496222,
-0.0160620399,
0.015062158,
-0.0241963994,
0.0205047578,
0.0086052762,
-0.0002887262,
0.0270885229,
0.0346358195,
-0.0175917037,
0.0143257966,
-0.0171332471,
0.0251165535,
0.0456463695,
0.062389046,
-0.0973718092,
-0.0353179649,
-0.0365154445,
-0.023997495,
0.0569627136,
-0.0009906366,
0.0002622383,
0.0234047771,
-0.056647025,
-0.0178543385,
-0.0008952767,
0.0223270115,
0.0620554201,
-0.0013415266,
0.0001329065,
-0.0038908017,
-0.0065176673,
-0.0566119738,
-0.01985633,
-0.0150730954,
-0.0104526188,
-0.0405215546,
-0.0133848963,
-5.775209256e-33,
-0.0141644832,
0.0047426196,
-0.0400435738,
-0.0021614155,
0.0028793628,
-0.0054031559,
0.0322912596,
-0.0581942573,
0.0005487469,
0.0091630844,
0.0170293227,
0.0386064798,
-0.0183277242,
0.0185947809,
-0.0112681221,
-0.0366188064,
0.0590519905,
0.0006593196,
-0.0270042401,
0.0284380428,
-0.0177427866,
0.0094263181,
0.0050392887,
-0.0508538522,
0.0432219058,
-0.0028142298,
-0.0149747645,
-0.0017976826,
-0.0196576733,
0.0116301561,
0.0025953525,
0.0525255091,
0.0604703836,
-0.0069094026,
0.0326354764,
0.037098892,
-0.0413577631,
-0.0178495888,
-0.0443007275,
0.0278891977,
-0.0185448118,
-0.0152697228,
0.0576583855,
0.0298864041,
-0.003909281,
-0.0480423719,
0.0424811728,
0.0260768998,
0.0314096846,
0.0057964092,
-0.0075109294,
0.0302988011,
-0.0034176952,
0.0183867645,
0.014517949,
-0.004981488,
0.0446031876,
0.0309608448,
-0.0398242474,
-0.0164182466,
-0.0185586903,
-0.0141871516,
-0.0141379349,
0.0228127316,
0.006045274,
0.0597765148,
0.0682668611,
0.0237179901,
-0.0210849252,
-0.0506175794,
0.0404818095,
-0.036317274,
0.0611059107,
0.095938988,
0.0607677102,
-0.0454332903,
-0.1053835154,
0.0109609189,
0.0244566128,
-0.0130275805,
-0.0022979549,
0.0216879323,
-0.0765155256,
-0.0266942196,
-0.0269818604,
-0.0871116444,
-0.0141815962,
0.0142593579,
0.0136410603,
-0.0095035275,
-0.0516625717,
0.0179263745,
-0.0044302251,
-0.0422276147,
-0.0065489458,
0.036007151,
-0.0003516659,
-0.0168157332,
0.0076480452,
-0.0263362136,
-0.0063244794,
0.0003184352,
0.0381689891,
0.0077140741,
0.0198735055,
0.0105766635,
0.0867916495,
0.0008200494,
-0.0271533132,
-0.0077409567,
-0.0324190222,
0.0474750511,
0.0638755113,
0.0391865671,
-0.020895768,
0.0227432605,
-0.009294264,
0.0161057953,
0.0138150919,
-0.0006415757,
-0.0320111886,
-0.0028068083,
0.022882035,
0.0213326905,
-0.0153142232,
-0.0270977113,
0.0448288433,
-0.0114250742,
0.0342149809,
-0.0908301249,
0.0014612051,
-0.0548829958,
2.443e-7,
-0.0147811687,
-0.0019629628,
-0.0070503284,
-0.0393559486,
0.0234859008,
0.0502095073,
-0.0030837026,
0.0910161138,
-0.0141791562,
0.0214513782,
-0.0143999597,
0.0364982858,
0.0240659807,
0.0336769894,
-0.0239261221,
0.0043826271,
-0.0572067238,
0.0356338583,
-0.0106985765,
-0.0044257916,
0.0246864613,
0.0447730049,
0.041842591,
0.0058495528,
0.0552742444,
-0.0129226735,
0.0241558515,
0.0241400674,
0.0317063257,
-0.0088923778,
0.0235267095,
-0.0003790981,
0.0364586823,
0.0588214956,
-0.026952073,
-0.0168615356,
0.0131362351,
0.0152868824,
-0.0467130207,
-0.0074354825,
-0.0343995243,
-0.0193428658,
-0.0073288451,
-0.0003617202,
0.0480153598,
0.028041169,
-0.0414359346,
-0.020545125,
-0.0053482722,
-0.008852209,
0.0603969693,
0.0259578116,
-0.0052495287,
0.001034091,
0.0125262178,
0.0332508162,
0.0195282865,
-0.0658257604,
-0.0118083339,
-0.0266635176,
-0.0348956548,
-0.0214363858,
0.0260938834,
0.0147216571,
0.0031644402,
-0.0150830401,
0.0319106244,
1.939948174e-34,
0.0078041144,
0.0185369942,
-0.0163294468,
-0.009015901,
0.0085677886,
-0.0051363218,
0.007941829,
-0.0354595557,
0.0539331399,
0.0309109129,
-0.0248118751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12664v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12664v2 | The DURel Annotation Tool: Human and Computational Measurement of Semantic Proximity, Sense Clusters and Semantic Change | 2023-11-21T15:14:54 | 2024-02-05T12:50:23 | Dominik Schlechtweg, Shafqat Mumtaz Virk, Pauline Sander, Emma Sköldberg, Lukas Theuer Linke, Tuo Zhang, Nina Tahmasebi, Jonas Kuhn, Sabine Schulte im Walde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present the DURel tool that implements the annotation of semantic
proximity between uses of words into an online, open source interface. The tool
supports standardized human annotation as well as computational annotation,
building on recent advances with Word-in-Context models. Annotator judgments
are clustered with automatic graph clustering techniques and visualized for
analysis. This allows to measure word senses with simple and intuitive
micro-task judgments between use pairs, requiring minimal preparation efforts.
The tool offers additional functionalities to compare the agreement between
annotators to guarantee the inter-subjectivity of the obtained judgments and to
calculate summary statistics giving insights into sense frequency
distributions, semantic variation or changes of senses over time. | [
-0.0070970021,
-0.0317395553,
-0.0390636139,
0.0145801418,
-0.0284607839,
0.0017623447,
-0.0110523039,
-0.0155688785,
0.0299149733,
-0.0326448157,
-0.0495156907,
0.0300787874,
0.0307330471,
-0.0116589973,
0.0220225323,
-0.0337501653,
0.0527699627,
0.0501240008,
-0.0391646586,
0.0456928015,
0.039515771,
0.0277503934,
-0.035708569,
0.0582941733,
-0.0499540493,
-0.0468114093,
-0.0001776338,
-0.0048722872,
0.0301578734,
-0.0528747849,
-0.034398634,
0.0427163579,
0.010105174,
0.0328587815,
0.0000020947,
-0.0453907028,
-0.01165473,
-0.0081260437,
0.0077174678,
-0.0170444418,
0.077335842,
0.0300480574,
0.042657394,
-0.0361257568,
-0.0607205704,
0.0216990095,
0.059430901,
-0.0738283545,
0.0194021389,
-0.0563953966,
-0.0262853559,
0.0204492174,
-0.0311012417,
0.0062778094,
0.0019871681,
0.0223642122,
-0.036561776,
0.0489603207,
0.022014128,
-0.0313322134,
-0.0440278463,
0.0144311106,
-0.0195882227,
0.0101559041,
0.0554476939,
0.0097217774,
-0.0010543576,
-0.0046765357,
0.0005150056,
0.0397318974,
0.0843795091,
0.0061994749,
-0.0251754113,
-0.0077093537,
-0.0432711355,
0.0602521636,
-0.0252926312,
-0.0677484572,
-0.013401838,
-0.0069370707,
-0.0344210342,
0.0388078019,
0.003709378,
0.0046266504,
0.0519386753,
0.0853891149,
0.0207920503,
-0.0160637684,
0.0133755198,
0.0049875663,
-0.0222285986,
-0.0028901896,
0.0568132699,
-0.0319932997,
0.0085721361,
0.0231848974,
-0.0149475411,
-0.0285617746,
0.0664311647,
-0.0556537099,
0.0367404744,
0.0074656885,
-0.0330835506,
0.0386316478,
0.0215625372,
0.0041066492,
0.0077755903,
-0.0291507971,
-0.0224713758,
0.0255766194,
-0.0424750857,
0.0183147434,
-0.0150948651,
-0.0130826226,
-0.0405587517,
-0.0497193038,
-0.0751805305,
0.0188008156,
-0.0243595708,
-0.03549999,
-0.0044679064,
0.0277456511,
-0.000771748,
0.033729516,
-0.0224899016,
0.0145634506,
-0.0583762899,
0.0756627023,
-0.0403471366,
-0.0433687866,
0.013286721,
0.0213668495,
0.0211144499,
-0.0490790866,
-0.0455370508,
0.0324025974,
0.005401053,
-0.0054246779,
-0.0342822634,
-0.085972257,
-0.0398983806,
0.0388292745,
-0.0612726584,
-0.0734539479,
0.0086765364,
0.0160039999,
0.0070111309,
-0.0731137395,
-0.0028918525,
0.0186478235,
-0.0179412235,
0.0693331882,
-0.0660340637,
-0.0011926743,
-0.0002086158,
-0.0146530578,
0.0000654784,
-0.0130391316,
0.0276491754,
0.0003664802,
0.0564681254,
0.0146185672,
-0.076787509,
-0.0047225179,
-0.0380200073,
-0.0174901672,
-0.0011918386,
-0.0426311679,
-0.0186532568,
0.0355639271,
0.0323296003,
0.0296945479,
-0.027536856,
-0.0255185664,
0.0517095104,
0.0891053081,
0.0334452577,
-0.053880062,
0.0230421573,
0.0376729742,
-0.019929124,
0.002430026,
0.0174244121,
0.0267541185,
0.0001385168,
-0.015796259,
0.027203951,
-0.0295585617,
0.003163229,
-0.0254456662,
-0.0429220013,
0.0018137223,
0.0582935214,
-0.0371117778,
0.0184819214,
0.0122111263,
0.023598047,
0.0082140611,
0.0397827365,
-0.0438995659,
0.0185360108,
0.0102230478,
0.0183642767,
0.100859873,
0.0117943902,
-0.03421719,
-0.0100353472,
0.0131461378,
-0.0191952623,
0.0096328575,
-0.0237665121,
-0.019217629,
-0.0148261134,
-0.0242472067,
-0.004716449,
-0.0052759247,
-0.0193541348,
-0.0218911115,
-0.0209687725,
0.0098215202,
0.0049195164,
-0.0973797366,
0.0257429704,
0.0398349948,
0.0301360302,
0.0144747198,
-0.0436198674,
0.0270498116,
0.0143524716,
0.0564123429,
-0.0017824139,
0.0412392393,
0.0158761088,
0.0017618892,
0.0354271755,
0.0483704284,
0.0111305928,
0.0278131906,
0.0426504649,
-0.0310609955,
-0.0110491915,
-0.0156656839,
0.0448678471,
-0.021621136,
0.0391458087,
-0.0346849933,
0.0482616648,
-0.0699269548,
-0.0309129208,
-0.0249485802,
0.0279277619,
-0.0344106443,
0.0311504733,
-0.0044946666,
-0.0067302794,
-0.0338637829,
0.0270578675,
0.0174497962,
-0.0115707526,
-0.035729561,
-0.0437083133,
0.0215704553,
0.0107256826,
0.0404427871,
-0.0248095542,
-0.0782558173,
0.0281293578,
-0.11334043,
-0.0187607445,
0.0046081813,
0.009606313,
0.0084120827,
0.004221675,
0.0058489772,
-0.0451100692,
0.0290232673,
0.0215767175,
-0.0616919622,
0.0527445599,
0.0489245579,
-0.0290039536,
0.0169933606,
-0.0646632612,
-0.01497012,
-0.0264644045,
0.0372348875,
0.0451826639,
-0.0529703908,
0.0218659341,
0.0076700198,
-0.0526135862,
-0.040501371,
0.0662438497,
0.0046831891,
0.0539759807,
0.0269546118,
0.0492772087,
0.0239889491,
-0.0023594205,
0.0650175288,
0.0721280947,
-0.0440057293,
-0.058264643,
-0.0187557861,
0.0099673625,
0.0240580644,
0.0015456678,
-0.0073372493,
0.0050007035,
0.028526362,
0.0579285696,
0.0040174797,
-0.0048915958,
0.0058054971,
-0.0803766921,
-0.0467074551,
-0.0379651114,
-0.0114328051,
-0.051227279,
0.0352005176,
-0.0121713355,
-0.025316691,
0.0495174639,
-0.0100930901,
0.0192012731,
0.0166224744,
-0.0220880788,
0.000065108,
0.096564576,
-0.0516785085,
0.0145695917,
-0.0517971851,
-0.0239449814,
-0.0198213402,
0.0106110647,
0.0566633493,
-0.0249270611,
0.0262436438,
-0.0556648746,
0.0050276122,
0.0246634968,
0.0160434842,
0.0090699494,
0.0222801622,
-0.0573645011,
0.0144140422,
0.0347633101,
0.0108335307,
0.049513761,
0.0224125478,
0.0111259455,
0.0055792509,
0.0382231101,
-0.017455481,
0.002559131,
0.030259693,
0.0157681294,
-0.0134538775,
-0.018433677,
0.0182215776,
-0.0584827065,
0.0598227754,
-0.0556304269,
-0.0415625088,
-0.0566684492,
-0.0079471339,
0.0281532742,
-0.035359554,
-0.0157758016,
-0.0278836973,
0.0388690606,
-0.0301136561,
0.0103989551,
0.0719529465,
0.048653733,
-0.0748984963,
0.0323460922,
-0.0351991393,
0.0023746102,
0.0392831601,
-0.0320197083,
-0.0785349607,
-0.0444250666,
-0.0428197198,
0.0167920459,
0.0059410264,
-0.0633140206,
0.0162843484,
-0.0292611197,
0.001850836,
-0.0242643729,
-0.0667114556,
0.0348794237,
-0.0306169782,
0.0637621209,
0.0114908796,
-0.0051802937,
-0.0206974912,
0.0027086614,
0.0390048921,
0.0505342335,
-0.0147833256,
0.0152111147,
0.0131897181,
-0.0284577869,
0.0321500711,
0.0372328497,
0.0871605352,
0.0258211717,
-0.0785648525,
0.0102188475,
0.0269386899,
0.0371569619,
-0.0174914356,
0.0120120281,
-0.0085125314,
0.0116730686,
-0.0354640856,
-0.0132162599,
0.0094032446,
-0.055699423,
0.0186616573,
0.0477276854,
-0.0343113244,
0.0434064157,
-0.0517373383,
0.0338106416,
0.0206266064,
0.0042288969,
0.0474248193,
-0.023846684,
0.0194926206,
0.0363728516,
0.0518110208,
0.0389633104,
-0.0467800461,
-0.0168582927,
-0.0312979594,
-0.0058939233,
-0.0751336068,
-0.0317001306,
0.0508848056,
0.0388468131,
0.0041404846,
0.0328904986,
0.0069432822,
-0.0051635965,
-0.0910981223,
0.0043123369,
0.0167134143,
0.0518782176,
0.0059058503,
-0.013168483,
0.0288273841,
0.0231059883,
-0.0203893017,
0.071965605,
-0.0343195722,
-0.0284198057,
0.034153942,
-0.0195537601,
0.019270217,
-0.0113882525,
-0.0120244613,
-0.0219936706,
-0.042211134,
0.0091961725,
-0.0379083045,
0.0253741965,
-0.035006322,
0.0114587722,
-0.0169651378,
0.004766,
-0.0139987506,
0.0165524576,
-0.0293236431,
0.0208036825,
-0.0459299795,
-0.0648592338,
0.0390172303,
-0.011580308,
0.0729650408,
-0.0134349251,
0.0324483253,
-0.0491838083,
-0.0373831093,
-0.0148841431,
-0.0072744247,
-0.0016036675,
-0.0335517228,
-0.0067052133,
-0.0215595961,
-0.0574195124,
0.0308684241,
-0.0188789908,
0.0234216005,
-0.0010118143,
0.0032232236,
0.0678482577,
0.012474631,
-0.0447395593,
0.0241016317,
-0.0182857104,
-0.0099067055,
-0.0541533343,
-0.0064055766,
0.0210044403,
0.0224387702,
0.0006637272,
-0.0282311328,
-0.0165207144,
0.0321609229,
0.0115726618,
0.0132837594,
0.0401203781,
-0.0217710566,
0.0180263463,
-0.0172115061,
0.0504001193,
0.0033891883,
-0.0121193836,
-0.0083152987,
0.0223798696,
-0.0349240191,
-0.0175508931,
0.0066814669,
0.0048228367,
-0.0029931983,
0.0123244068,
0.0226384997,
-0.1054122895,
-0.0000866094,
-0.0235803109,
-0.0872384682,
-0.0163139254,
-0.0086991303,
-0.001457379,
0.0656883791,
-0.0214298498,
0.0103162453,
-0.0858970806,
-0.0616977327,
0.0165025666,
0.0328496732,
0.0064518913,
0.0362932198,
0.0694325343,
0.0317935795,
0.0132067278,
-0.0372630954,
-0.0375555083,
0.0028317296,
-0.0529762618,
-0.0095567685,
-0.0353729054,
-6.111519292e-33,
-0.0439953804,
-0.0692196563,
-0.0220410191,
0.0226234458,
-0.0518667363,
0.008877744,
-0.0177217554,
0.0359667242,
-0.0052833315,
0.0430671647,
0.049260471,
0.015006627,
0.0071257246,
-0.0393880829,
0.0650191605,
0.0162085686,
0.049392838,
0.0388450213,
0.0067870747,
-0.008473983,
0.0806273371,
-0.0221909676,
0.0493545905,
-0.0921029225,
0.0479436703,
0.0638149977,
-0.0041656313,
0.0121652512,
0.0289554223,
0.0335385166,
-0.0171743017,
0.0847835168,
-0.0134134768,
0.0106051899,
-0.0144667365,
-0.0067067114,
-0.0419946946,
-0.0482198521,
0.0458918884,
-0.0004266381,
-0.0684276819,
-0.0257001873,
0.0398608483,
0.0087140705,
-0.0380186178,
0.0317016691,
0.0537742563,
0.0176784676,
-0.0435699299,
-0.005420757,
-0.0428938642,
0.0241068695,
-0.0191037748,
-0.0057150316,
-0.0039827228,
-0.0075163525,
0.015485811,
-0.0335633606,
-0.0745274648,
0.0579600446,
-0.0894170776,
-0.0108345272,
0.061039947,
0.0034958965,
0.0197694823,
0.0713400915,
0.0191470869,
-0.0271617565,
0.0397630334,
0.0325872302,
0.0563500673,
0.0405645147,
0.0014864639,
0.0751749724,
-0.0080622016,
-0.0316817462,
0.0143549368,
-0.0023184505,
-0.0020894716,
0.0447418541,
0.010339112,
0.037479572,
-0.0305817425,
0.0007401924,
-0.0140189193,
-0.0146489609,
-0.0518872477,
-0.0616209209,
0.024554465,
-0.0594792962,
0.0176174939,
0.0375012122,
-0.0233935732,
0.0214039367,
0.0264779329,
-0.0485848412,
0.003991799,
0.0236785747,
-0.005688793,
-0.0026067011,
0.0092873909,
0.013837113,
0.0021498469,
0.0176138636,
0.0667064115,
-0.0130279288,
0.0056864605,
-0.0290964879,
-0.0207805242,
-0.0245384648,
0.0145646138,
-0.0467502549,
-0.0312620476,
-0.1075677648,
0.040114224,
0.0230203904,
-0.0278414208,
0.0224556215,
0.0303834435,
0.011399975,
-0.0182599444,
-0.0479032844,
-0.0186728369,
-0.0058216196,
-0.0359116867,
-0.0155655257,
-0.0007786566,
0.012359499,
0.0263703186,
-0.0188911632,
-0.0149391051,
-0.0033927662,
2.861e-7,
0.0993610695,
0.0649576634,
0.012347687,
-0.0234276857,
0.0015643203,
-0.03703155,
0.0098577039,
0.059888728,
-0.0052500363,
-0.0087225586,
0.0221157633,
0.011551722,
-0.0109085767,
0.0554366224,
-0.028080523,
-0.000992296,
-0.0248287618,
0.0404242799,
-0.0425836518,
0.0266919937,
0.0750150904,
-0.0221173223,
0.0234241355,
0.0091709206,
-0.0359726846,
-0.0261204038,
0.006659986,
-0.0205682088,
0.0379620977,
-0.021245962,
0.0193452705,
-0.0414986275,
0.0368334875,
0.0492949523,
-0.0138561241,
-0.0275791679,
0.0711211488,
-0.0162753314,
-0.0699054226,
-0.0245385952,
-0.0328052454,
-0.0114129046,
0.0307215955,
-0.053834755,
0.0201295,
-0.0306178182,
-0.0225981995,
-0.0139362589,
-0.0168556124,
0.032335341,
0.0628489107,
0.020522343,
-0.0227484964,
0.0047928928,
0.0085587874,
0.0119214654,
-0.0647894219,
-0.0119956769,
-0.0304274838,
0.0365882814,
0.0031586562,
-0.0444528461,
0.0015124808,
-0.026213266,
-0.0265022665,
-0.0061632344,
-0.0019945181,
1.443310305e-34,
0.005467271,
0.0484826267,
0.0349178053,
-0.0071317591,
0.0160945076,
-0.0227579493,
0.0018699088,
0.0320965908,
0.0446876064,
-0.0129500581,
-0.0228784662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12649v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12649v1 | MathGloss: Building mathematical glossaries from text | 2023-11-21T14:49:00 | 2023-11-21T14:49:00 | Lucy Horowitz, Valeria de Paiva | cs.CL | cs.CL | MathGloss is a project to create a knowledge graph (KG) for undergraduate
mathematics from text, automatically, using modern natural language processing
(NLP) tools and resources already available on the web. MathGloss is a linked
database of undergraduate concepts in mathematics. So far, it combines five
resources: (i) Wikidata, a collaboratively edited, multilingual knowledge graph
hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation, (ii) terms covered in mathematics courses
at the University of Chicago, (iii) the syllabus of the French undergraduate
mathematics curriculum which includes hyperlinks to the automated theorem
prover Lean 4, (iv) MuLiMa, a multilingual dictionary of mathematics curated by
mathematicians, and (v) the nLab, a wiki for category theory also curated by
mathematicians. MathGloss's goal is to bring together resources for learning
mathematics and to allow every mathematician to tailor their learning to their
own preferences. Moreover, by organizing different resources for learning
undergraduate mathematics alongside those for learning formal mathematics, we
hope to make it easier for mathematicians and formal tools (theorem provers,
computer algebra systems, etc) experts to "understand" each other and break
down some of the barriers to formal math. | [
-0.0320523717,
0.0319707058,
-0.0372410081,
0.0401947051,
-0.0405382328,
0.046687603,
-0.0319594406,
-0.0063548773,
0.0030716308,
-0.034137845,
0.0375828892,
0.0097989636,
-0.0078819348,
0.0347910523,
0.0324368067,
-0.0755365193,
0.0125113651,
0.0008555245,
-0.0318526998,
-0.0181540977,
-0.0363410152,
0.0355083495,
-0.08193966,
-0.0085863583,
-0.0347150713,
-0.0656486601,
0.03622704,
-0.0582160428,
-0.0332824066,
-0.0066501335,
-0.0338884927,
0.0287027135,
-0.0799125582,
0.0378776304,
0.0000020666,
-0.0810202956,
-0.0490527749,
0.0171513166,
-0.0086618792,
-0.0238409806,
0.022129396,
0.0126631539,
0.0328143202,
-0.035199523,
-0.0590212159,
0.0050966409,
0.0214312207,
-0.0410962217,
0.0152591867,
0.0073609906,
-0.0018916841,
-0.1412817985,
0.0195874702,
0.0347312503,
0.0635405779,
-0.0346414559,
-0.0067119054,
0.0616839789,
0.0326112434,
-0.0385717377,
-0.0092058927,
0.0355256833,
0.0186628141,
-0.0347303338,
0.0766643286,
-0.0138940932,
-0.0205175187,
-0.0171767399,
0.00476682,
0.0170401949,
0.0427305438,
-0.0365660079,
0.0048587942,
0.0297247674,
-0.0128115946,
0.0670241788,
-0.058647681,
0.0341237076,
-0.0426206589,
-0.0155031905,
-0.0528608263,
-0.0272992756,
0.0091223093,
0.0139086461,
-0.0302287638,
0.1014714614,
0.0346955694,
-0.0069054971,
0.03115605,
-0.0215098802,
-0.0709730908,
-0.0205460992,
0.0177943092,
0.0274026133,
0.0578947961,
-0.0081120264,
0.007268318,
-0.0725254267,
-0.0036178716,
-0.0383215211,
-0.0102252858,
0.0268432032,
0.0233658012,
0.0111034336,
-0.0035564583,
0.0098187756,
0.0463462397,
0.0148493554,
-0.0403116606,
0.01800601,
-0.0750934184,
0.0228749458,
-0.017463265,
0.0494530909,
0.0708052516,
0.0619364418,
-0.0836563557,
0.0247160587,
-0.0746507123,
0.0398999229,
-0.0428862981,
-0.0728536397,
0.0033970315,
-0.0238794852,
-0.0568787605,
-0.0513190888,
-0.0146276467,
-0.0031214112,
-0.0568457022,
-0.0050014718,
0.0146378092,
0.0183629245,
0.0023754442,
-0.0221665632,
-0.0293740258,
0.0577600263,
0.063444145,
0.0324315652,
0.0221872479,
-0.0304199662,
0.0518536419,
0.0201582909,
-0.0191379897,
-0.0870614797,
0.0351159051,
0.0164462328,
0.0222932007,
-0.0286745392,
-0.0515361205,
0.0001979854,
0.0092123197,
0.0412587486,
-0.0669414699,
-0.0103440173,
0.0342220031,
0.0002847277,
-0.023559818,
-0.0056250244,
-0.0259474255,
-0.014008685,
0.0470087752,
-0.0235397257,
0.0227998812,
-0.0308770854,
0.0203679744,
-0.050630942,
-0.0157079045,
0.0079450682,
0.0286696404,
0.0174285751,
-0.0591846257,
0.058669813,
-0.0355139039,
-0.0086003048,
-0.0279638674,
0.0947871283,
0.0394956656,
0.0481874831,
-0.0010079002,
0.0310183913,
0.0392329916,
-0.0127420695,
-0.0198979508,
0.0173628069,
-0.0244253557,
0.0257761106,
-0.023759516,
0.012842562,
0.0321329199,
-0.0570963323,
-0.0388603508,
-0.0173837319,
-0.035228081,
-0.046375256,
0.0584081076,
-0.0157065243,
0.0686199367,
0.0138170198,
0.008884673,
-0.0157574713,
0.0263565108,
0.0312094744,
0.0090515651,
0.0051157898,
-0.0216234643,
-0.055848036,
-0.0286504906,
-0.0271816012,
-0.0092959749,
0.0514074452,
-0.0375993662,
-0.0379022956,
-0.0467322916,
-0.0078674899,
0.0289943274,
0.0175395049,
0.0133774681,
-0.0581548661,
0.024487922,
0.0439956672,
-0.0077106678,
-0.0284448825,
-0.0352746919,
0.0053318939,
0.0360457785,
-0.0440395139,
0.0082851043,
-0.0097647374,
0.0075013163,
0.0165034272,
0.0216497853,
0.0491118208,
0.0153882196,
-0.0136200441,
-0.0202106927,
-0.0167642757,
0.001632215,
0.0523748472,
0.0679535791,
-0.0578373037,
0.0267812628,
-0.0491086841,
-0.0221785009,
0.0005221227,
0.0740404576,
0.0046822941,
0.0639533475,
-0.0104910443,
0.0152875436,
0.0190475974,
-0.0258134101,
0.0158882197,
0.020178616,
0.0109498994,
0.0425356999,
-0.0095358985,
-0.0746254846,
-0.0121823959,
0.0674067736,
0.0411778651,
0.013429502,
-0.0100713121,
0.0342248082,
-0.0055046594,
0.0051271077,
-0.0158316102,
0.045240894,
0.0441534966,
-0.0203548651,
-0.0009689996,
0.0515327714,
0.048782438,
-0.0196224023,
0.0003913942,
-0.0025281548,
0.022525575,
0.0363692455,
-0.0190030411,
-0.0430167839,
0.0012799515,
0.0241330378,
-0.0224859845,
0.0065561184,
-0.0181916747,
-0.0238350891,
0.0264562685,
0.0055074627,
-0.0052886065,
0.0477365293,
-0.0409848727,
-0.0295838267,
-0.0343906321,
-0.0006434052,
0.0379711539,
-0.0148537783,
0.0060161003,
-0.0020362516,
0.0027193625,
0.0133837629,
0.0094118174,
-0.0403594859,
-0.0466104969,
0.0123451743,
-0.0207685884,
-0.0214265678,
-0.0166325439,
-0.037054576,
0.0189214889,
0.0034071619,
0.0029546735,
-0.0347922444,
-0.0215623602,
-0.0025879571,
0.0325568356,
-0.0820309222,
0.0352845751,
-0.0616172887,
0.0075568529,
-0.0218715407,
0.0199590661,
0.0356089137,
-0.0250818636,
0.0414919853,
0.0129304565,
-0.0193111505,
-0.0593224913,
-0.0329878405,
-0.0680200979,
0.0232613217,
-0.014909463,
0.0144932382,
-0.0094605871,
0.0104916487,
0.0164948348,
-0.0237238929,
0.0753208399,
-0.0202674456,
-0.0021644547,
-0.0244043358,
0.0238698758,
-0.0142930616,
0.0260010846,
-0.017910568,
0.0784278437,
0.0203781575,
-0.0180294085,
-0.0306341816,
-0.0421340354,
0.0146859838,
-0.0041999044,
0.0189595856,
-0.0385747291,
-0.0016081675,
-0.0067023714,
0.0264546704,
-0.0035084891,
-0.0086290287,
0.0059605031,
-0.0071778428,
-0.0223159138,
-0.011982426,
0.0297340676,
-0.0164367445,
-0.0215053335,
0.0483597554,
0.0069805356,
-0.0120905451,
-0.0890448615,
-0.0335916243,
0.0161226988,
-0.1046149507,
-0.0044123358,
0.0087349983,
0.0334404148,
0.0318414941,
-0.0167413279,
0.0226349346,
-0.0668976381,
-0.0072129075,
0.0098048765,
-0.0125760725,
-0.1378604174,
0.074815236,
-0.0455367155,
0.0103891687,
0.0135296173,
0.0123526193,
0.0292114131,
-0.0368643105,
-0.0114745777,
0.0276822299,
-0.0361416265,
0.0086456202,
-0.0065422659,
-0.0165550858,
-0.0005218539,
-0.0446620807,
0.0166362748,
-0.0466728993,
0.0500601642,
0.0417898186,
-0.0102685746,
-0.0509571098,
-0.0626174212,
-0.0021610521,
-0.0662110224,
-0.0696576089,
0.05168676,
-0.0899169296,
-0.060128212,
0.0411457382,
0.0319569372,
-0.0590290874,
-0.0219779499,
-0.0486759469,
-0.0193314012,
0.0219781715,
-0.0180763546,
0.0413707756,
-0.0489670038,
-0.0517594554,
0.0372761972,
0.0668340996,
0.0279144719,
0.0258323569,
-0.0116526987,
-0.0199734904,
-0.016773751,
0.0009529857,
-0.0190574788,
0.0604076535,
0.0057214983,
-0.013909026,
0.0139246462,
-0.0284072645,
-0.0860982239,
0.005564102,
0.0154142985,
-0.0461640768,
-0.0183129553,
-0.0020830545,
0.0400572233,
0.0094365636,
0.0165762305,
0.0245193578,
0.0367932096,
0.0225954466,
-0.070243746,
0.0274278708,
-0.0219995212,
-0.0168506037,
-0.0009232808,
-0.0365194604,
-0.0241537113,
0.0393442176,
-0.0646953583,
0.0370242484,
0.0099746659,
-0.0161941648,
0.0076673445,
0.0431766286,
0.0219221842,
-0.0275240634,
0.0052621639,
0.0361312255,
0.0201002583,
0.052865088,
-0.0633345768,
0.042721048,
0.0095181717,
0.007230307,
0.0103971502,
0.0196171906,
0.0290396549,
0.0058346372,
-0.0493068285,
0.0049147052,
-0.0199071094,
-0.0564524718,
0.0022921816,
0.0449777953,
-0.0521840863,
0.0150710391,
0.0047208429,
0.0346743166,
0.022136325,
0.0195025057,
-0.0094320141,
-0.0157764517,
-0.0037458928,
-0.0132220667,
-0.0066344142,
-0.016875606,
-0.023133859,
0.0354818664,
0.0316003039,
0.0513984524,
0.0526615418,
0.000446455,
-0.0057220543,
0.033992473,
-0.0214490462,
0.026539823,
-0.0444473624,
-0.0527616739,
0.0656989589,
-0.0274674557,
-0.0207540262,
0.0279728733,
0.0128242653,
0.0118912859,
-0.0021429365,
0.0062941541,
-0.0937186703,
-0.0296765137,
0.0041834842,
0.0318976641,
0.0400970578,
0.0243718121,
-0.0544802994,
0.0118207103,
-0.0030999156,
0.0180832222,
-0.0440048389,
0.0026951618,
-0.0066647246,
0.0221711565,
0.0354072116,
-0.028896004,
0.0463939719,
-0.0449716449,
-0.0041216556,
0.0393837951,
0.0233945884,
-0.0283362996,
0.004812405,
-0.0207850318,
0.0404070579,
0.0393982865,
-0.0011923295,
-0.1015573591,
-0.0477574803,
0.0775910988,
-0.0000235979,
0.0159515869,
0.0203652792,
0.0523246266,
0.0465644114,
0.0133736869,
0.0094199674,
0.0086550647,
0.0636973828,
-0.0696581379,
-0.0342251286,
0.0106632439,
-5.633846876e-33,
-0.0295192394,
-0.0600729585,
0.0166426953,
0.0635248125,
0.0089756995,
-0.0467004851,
0.04896231,
0.0211136397,
0.0079618888,
0.006159815,
0.0184417944,
0.0535230078,
0.0025655855,
0.0027663161,
0.0215624589,
0.0525142066,
-0.0022247457,
-0.0144485179,
-0.0011450168,
-0.0181764271,
-0.0058278064,
-0.0056378553,
0.1074941605,
-0.0534554534,
0.0373234302,
-0.0068949685,
0.0187933762,
-0.0152834104,
0.0288342275,
0.0597326681,
-0.0305110328,
0.0260023084,
0.004580427,
0.0483066514,
-0.0166531168,
-0.0309493672,
-0.0274997167,
-0.0634892508,
0.0064322283,
0.0293571129,
0.0171903018,
-0.0306231175,
0.0033179948,
-0.0139322663,
-0.0455558151,
0.0124291256,
0.0563748665,
0.0185828488,
-0.0429140739,
0.0247367583,
0.0048666089,
0.0456346832,
-0.0088702654,
0.0357604921,
0.0335005559,
-0.0448721163,
-0.0057440875,
-0.0451950319,
0.0185257234,
0.036248263,
-0.0445602313,
0.0336570404,
-0.0222981907,
-0.0601539053,
0.0164783113,
0.0094761197,
-0.0030569024,
-0.0345725603,
0.0337137468,
0.0253217202,
0.0403819121,
0.0744432136,
0.000193717,
0.0485261753,
0.0486262366,
0.0274787024,
-0.0285498742,
0.0237916317,
-0.0395785682,
0.0517367162,
-0.0353020541,
0.0154298488,
-0.0066847987,
-0.00129465,
-0.0076179709,
0.0023016445,
-0.0099380761,
0.0126041723,
-0.0502099805,
-0.0473905839,
-0.0267309137,
0.0504149608,
-0.0193114392,
0.001010441,
-0.0581958555,
-0.034703806,
0.0347340815,
0.02333498,
-0.0118384911,
0.0297030117,
-0.0321981497,
-0.0026259525,
-0.071922794,
0.0291470047,
0.0394077711,
0.0217927191,
-0.0391229689,
0.0208556335,
0.020180868,
-0.0168500617,
-0.0021205123,
-0.0514894724,
0.0211964734,
0.0177292675,
0.0295641255,
0.0734049156,
0.017042242,
0.0319173634,
0.0193314776,
-0.0019575316,
-0.0149015831,
0.022453066,
0.0101687312,
0.0181136299,
-0.0099491542,
-0.0542189889,
-0.0055000037,
-0.0541349649,
0.0671564564,
-0.0525989048,
0.0228615236,
-0.0307874624,
2.942e-7,
0.0586535074,
0.0470323004,
0.0355508178,
0.0476804487,
-0.0288923886,
-0.0402249545,
-0.0010386547,
-0.0150150014,
-0.0397341661,
-0.0258878656,
-0.0036626535,
0.0247242041,
-0.0293026846,
0.0659151822,
-0.0532995351,
0.0261243936,
-0.0149580343,
-0.0140544306,
-0.0390477329,
0.0215718206,
0.0645647049,
-0.0121399928,
0.0623600669,
0.0283946674,
-0.0568392128,
-0.0567229651,
0.0258042701,
0.0304084383,
0.0493226573,
0.0325563252,
0.0198173188,
-0.0020489453,
0.0420756489,
-0.0093608145,
0.0208799038,
0.0116894832,
-0.0027834368,
-0.0016767357,
0.033491727,
0.0413788073,
-0.0584969558,
-0.0760049969,
0.00168717,
-0.0148611227,
0.0151951211,
-0.0174974725,
-0.0112015801,
0.0283552781,
-0.057974413,
0.014644579,
0.018759178,
-0.0231786892,
0.0037682657,
0.0199878644,
0.03627472,
0.0021439455,
0.0173104648,
-0.000050017,
0.0166979786,
0.0707412884,
-0.0398488902,
-0.0202683713,
-0.0131310923,
0.0282971337,
0.0282246601,
0.0378077812,
-0.0120156892,
2.655857065e-34,
0.0242269952,
0.0029514194,
0.0380761549,
0.0641308129,
0.0009684565,
-0.0312516317,
-0.0556753203,
0.0232640579,
0.004218962,
-0.0175547581,
0.0059936033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12574v1 | IMGTB: A Framework for Machine-Generated Text Detection Benchmarking | 2023-11-21T12:40:01 | 2023-11-21T12:40:01 | Michal Spiegel, Dominik Macko | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the era of large language models generating high quality texts, it is a
necessity to develop methods for detection of machine-generated text to avoid
harmful use or simply due to annotation purposes. It is, however, also
important to properly evaluate and compare such developed methods. Recently, a
few benchmarks have been proposed for this purpose; however, integration of
newest detection methods is rather challenging, since new methods appear each
month and provide slightly different evaluation pipelines. In this paper, we
present the IMGTB framework, which simplifies the benchmarking of
machine-generated text detection methods by easy integration of custom (new)
methods and evaluation datasets. Its configurability and flexibility makes
research and development of new detection methods easier, especially their
comparison to the existing state-of-the-art detectors. The default set of
analyses, metrics and visualizations offered by the tool follows the
established practices of machine-generated text detection benchmarking found in
state-of-the-art literature. | [
0.0308913887,
0.0181144401,
0.0154159823,
0.08500164,
-0.0484113246,
0.0345559269,
0.0002899028,
0.0620866679,
0.0138362153,
0.0030334,
-0.0094480673,
0.0064184954,
-0.0095410775,
0.0503954664,
-0.0014579337,
0.0240986217,
0.0236812383,
0.0024649263,
0.0105752116,
0.076086536,
0.0369398594,
0.0091507873,
-0.0053611915,
0.00403002,
-0.0443461016,
-0.0199465845,
0.0173571762,
0.046001412,
0.056644626,
-0.0561315604,
-0.0005403713,
0.0397367589,
-0.0287838448,
0.1475280523,
0.0000018464,
-0.0323202014,
-0.0365310572,
0.0020516035,
-0.008571296,
0.0045259297,
0.095125258,
-0.0436912514,
-0.0516658835,
0.0160059668,
-0.0344199762,
0.02319731,
0.0421268493,
0.0298076682,
0.0085531035,
0.0979194194,
-0.0475086085,
0.0157317687,
0.0264581554,
-0.0008998085,
-0.0272749774,
-0.0236869156,
0.0308667384,
-0.0104522118,
-0.0178985111,
-0.006106216,
0.0269037504,
0.0257819835,
0.0112465071,
-0.0606570281,
-0.0016976527,
0.0299269687,
-0.033413142,
0.0022105258,
-0.0486238301,
0.0341630094,
-0.0552499592,
-0.0356600769,
0.0232729465,
-0.0366945378,
-0.0099379448,
-0.0071378341,
0.0131211001,
0.0108484617,
-0.0555021167,
0.0296036508,
-0.0091253333,
0.0299353432,
-0.0034857581,
0.0466404222,
0.0165923126,
0.0407865644,
0.0168547072,
-0.0417037942,
0.0030439647,
0.0093974192,
0.0084108477,
-0.0252110325,
0.0664218441,
0.0077168797,
0.0386227816,
-0.0156273451,
-0.0643675625,
-0.0866828933,
0.0226298235,
-0.0542171299,
0.0375553221,
0.0053781387,
-0.0194103569,
0.0513427891,
-0.0865448713,
0.052842848,
-0.0359473117,
-0.0052057481,
-0.0081013311,
0.0292605702,
0.0164269339,
0.010925754,
-0.0215334762,
-0.0486497059,
-0.0204573665,
-0.0241817385,
-0.0277163293,
0.0411281697,
0.0173705798,
-0.0026265341,
-0.0239966605,
-0.04413734,
-0.0234105997,
-0.0066812299,
0.0041153957,
-0.0168858394,
-0.016250819,
-0.0174530018,
-0.0042883293,
-0.0640736669,
-0.0125844041,
0.0666545108,
0.0552685,
-0.0061036036,
0.0187559314,
0.038675461,
-0.0405519567,
-0.065305829,
-0.0168325491,
0.0040175342,
-0.0260829274,
-0.0259789079,
0.0167787559,
-0.055964496,
-0.0112208137,
-0.0306681134,
-0.0141562279,
-0.0026343309,
-0.0034761524,
0.0293882247,
0.0434784815,
0.0322095193,
-0.0491313227,
-0.0436425507,
0.0238522254,
0.0068140118,
-0.0007257525,
0.0710827634,
-0.0063946019,
0.0976141095,
0.0341478772,
0.0039907023,
0.0361044817,
0.0776982307,
-0.0398352928,
0.0186440144,
0.0024349573,
-0.0218139589,
-0.0398335904,
0.020033652,
0.0332873166,
0.0225142725,
-0.0038615298,
-0.0201031733,
0.0575655252,
0.0342002027,
0.0084709777,
-0.0242585167,
0.0226421654,
0.0597348288,
0.0040459768,
0.0201640707,
0.0221931506,
-0.0361020826,
-0.0492385402,
-0.0135981198,
-0.0190056302,
0.0467252806,
0.0255857073,
-0.0209726021,
-0.0261392593,
-0.0103495577,
0.0188099984,
-0.0654456168,
0.090468131,
0.0204541218,
-0.0669068992,
-0.0393669493,
-0.0081137521,
-0.0535248816,
-0.0194689184,
-0.0684625208,
0.0546169765,
0.0341934264,
0.0662511736,
-0.0206256472,
0.0393194929,
0.0219066404,
0.0120755369,
0.086666733,
0.0022403644,
0.0247348379,
0.0025800241,
-0.0487130545,
-0.02590161,
0.0269371346,
0.0118089244,
0.035775464,
0.0488576069,
0.0324469171,
0.0208968278,
-0.0195929203,
-0.0385695472,
0.0809208825,
0.0258362573,
0.0109926173,
-0.0058199205,
0.0019741529,
0.0050997552,
0.0073548844,
-0.0400759391,
-0.0036011438,
0.0378380716,
-0.018866146,
0.0091310255,
-0.0189081784,
0.0257471055,
-0.0232469551,
-0.0086946879,
-0.0515473373,
-0.0276182499,
0.0173945874,
-0.0267486256,
0.0081720594,
-0.0281876381,
-0.0262194145,
0.0030431182,
-0.0653078333,
0.0076946816,
-0.0409745276,
0.0389276408,
-0.0177411325,
0.066798456,
-0.0077234777,
0.00076615,
0.0180529654,
-0.0064541823,
0.0516526811,
0.0039349128,
0.0097920941,
-0.0103837689,
-0.0392832756,
0.0031553728,
-0.0031499399,
0.0423575938,
-0.0404690877,
-0.035062544,
-0.0835170969,
0.0114255277,
-0.0438576862,
0.0170002002,
0.051853016,
-0.0088830478,
-0.0223285798,
-0.025800487,
0.0013566976,
-0.0022663334,
0.0407397002,
0.0056717629,
0.0387989059,
-0.020901382,
0.0332249068,
-0.0144278714,
-0.0031984935,
-0.0108038327,
0.0233486816,
0.0634706393,
-0.0886407942,
-0.0319935195,
0.0140522067,
0.0099876616,
-0.0013887876,
-0.0149169676,
-0.0469902381,
0.0141997011,
-0.0171390343,
0.0229103528,
0.0805948749,
0.0303601306,
0.0138526484,
0.0060036308,
0.0501490533,
0.0078946808,
-0.0013917607,
-0.0034814656,
0.0427767821,
0.0087061236,
-0.0603274703,
0.0564177744,
0.0524765737,
-0.0157328267,
0.0404959619,
0.0139400065,
0.0172865558,
-0.0415051989,
-0.0360923149,
-0.022220185,
-0.0118099535,
-0.031984143,
0.0424665026,
-0.0408952199,
-0.0727432892,
0.0110080689,
-0.0447367094,
-0.008981715,
-0.0285382122,
-0.0190371443,
-0.0269281771,
0.0055033755,
0.0411301143,
0.031574294,
-0.0000809737,
-0.0104911774,
0.0186439771,
0.0502737351,
0.0454999767,
-0.0236643087,
-0.0006105719,
-0.0104918806,
0.0190326292,
-0.0128071969,
0.0065936982,
-0.0489914343,
-0.021628933,
-0.0182273053,
-0.0583231449,
0.0412187241,
-0.0516915917,
0.0031041619,
0.0406358503,
-0.0136579704,
0.0854342133,
-0.0106407376,
-0.0133383963,
-0.0157275032,
0.0851461962,
-0.0101536568,
-0.0621029958,
0.041566506,
-0.0067457589,
0.005292729,
0.0632068887,
-0.0061434121,
-0.0002906019,
-0.0128476638,
-0.0134682041,
0.0169009231,
0.028106723,
0.0122237531,
-0.0096855043,
0.0398089178,
-0.0576122142,
-0.0185419824,
0.0743929148,
0.0285047237,
-0.0315967016,
-0.0312864631,
-0.0066833943,
0.0465734117,
0.0063959174,
-0.0130796172,
-0.0771094561,
-0.0265787989,
0.0253298059,
-0.0080587342,
-0.0576261319,
-0.0006173284,
0.0030682411,
-0.0794378966,
0.0323913358,
0.0170373805,
-0.0327242762,
-0.0211984962,
-0.0215808861,
0.0172631163,
-0.0036455374,
-0.0496098213,
-0.0101027116,
-0.0132388072,
-0.0137336543,
-0.0141615234,
-0.0533008091,
-0.0536620356,
-0.0636787117,
-0.0293685291,
-0.0184067544,
0.084182702,
0.0631199926,
-0.0132703446,
-0.0297178738,
0.0394838974,
-0.0271573197,
-0.0055512637,
-0.015818527,
0.0933754295,
-0.0077055963,
-0.0305708013,
-0.0341146402,
0.0037612703,
0.0139295692,
0.0100978985,
0.0276012141,
0.0031501828,
0.0265908185,
-0.0368203558,
-0.0375329815,
-0.0059206295,
0.0292284265,
0.0666379705,
0.0272824652,
-0.0353711918,
-0.0385037102,
-0.0331440233,
0.0333162211,
-0.0952520892,
-0.0106515558,
-0.0070339348,
-0.0310285799,
-0.0398894548,
-0.0790051892,
-0.025154423,
0.0068099406,
0.0181476418,
-0.0020999897,
0.0087552965,
-0.0602185763,
-0.0009931464,
-0.066562213,
-0.0041048662,
-0.0214157477,
0.0036430394,
-0.0630268976,
0.0151412599,
-0.0508226082,
-0.0247520991,
-0.0209082775,
0.0840547383,
-0.0764771327,
-0.0149361398,
-0.0076079671,
-0.008719801,
0.0168570038,
-0.0058273119,
-0.0553893074,
-0.0340151563,
0.0705662519,
0.001418472,
-0.004965133,
-0.0330047272,
0.0054386156,
-0.0358024389,
-0.0299768616,
-0.0080186985,
-0.0163758304,
0.0304310508,
0.0030708886,
-0.0489175357,
-0.0288598947,
0.0042323726,
0.0126994895,
-0.0029183042,
0.0333674923,
-0.0311083868,
0.0019554503,
-0.0246064197,
-0.0315576755,
-0.0097910762,
-0.0194267668,
-0.0521532558,
0.0253902301,
0.0542356856,
0.0050744284,
-0.0244415961,
0.0586395748,
0.0050004097,
0.0414626747,
-0.0285520907,
0.0153760491,
0.0091647757,
0.0742199868,
0.0360585898,
-0.0102440082,
0.0135720912,
0.0461827964,
-0.0091921901,
0.0090048332,
0.0136539489,
0.0661089271,
0.0166560039,
-0.0387207903,
0.0395452417,
0.0476961806,
-0.036024753,
0.0500333868,
-0.091703333,
0.0538598858,
0.0651099458,
-0.0035214096,
0.0763179138,
-0.0429386832,
-0.0222120248,
-0.0212627631,
0.0044634114,
0.0234851465,
-0.0171089657,
-0.0507336743,
-0.0118995979,
-0.0342215672,
-0.0225434694,
0.0382986926,
0.0227412339,
0.0357679501,
0.0172615219,
-0.0169357136,
-0.0466522463,
0.0114089781,
0.0054790033,
0.0014794657,
0.0016501965,
0.0130849862,
-0.0230072271,
-0.02546026,
0.0367930755,
-0.0146601852,
-0.0023590124,
0.0338176638,
-0.0030193543,
0.054261677,
0.0007396237,
0.0166600291,
-0.0185554158,
-0.0133632431,
-0.0303204022,
-0.017767936,
0.005053645,
-5.512250067e-33,
-0.0203534272,
-0.0721756965,
-0.045682203,
-0.0229321085,
0.0119603099,
0.037710961,
-0.0139689185,
-0.0264315512,
0.0196763054,
0.0084665203,
-0.0158988927,
0.0251644906,
0.0305047985,
0.0029140455,
-0.0572244413,
0.0020280567,
0.0393110737,
-0.0166379157,
-0.0697739348,
0.0035619291,
-0.0022805319,
0.0337271318,
0.0502461605,
-0.0390175283,
-0.0186683014,
-0.0113019785,
-0.0612515286,
0.0158633813,
-0.0192031264,
0.0677688196,
-0.017023772,
0.0206511542,
0.0436351188,
0.0199949127,
-0.0201866738,
0.0686601549,
-0.0265700463,
0.0072481516,
-0.0469629653,
0.0271825008,
-0.0500236787,
-0.0354343392,
0.0075408928,
-0.048516389,
0.0036212495,
0.0215995107,
0.030463092,
-0.0557719544,
-0.0043972791,
-0.0322265811,
-0.0709069818,
0.0666867346,
0.0209253822,
-0.0025563517,
0.0772441328,
0.0300906841,
0.0367851667,
0.0166461915,
-0.0579771399,
0.006146098,
0.0272191279,
0.0337396264,
0.0241099503,
0.0398735628,
-0.023050217,
0.0353039317,
0.0401082821,
0.0072400286,
0.0179167204,
-0.028704809,
0.0201724507,
0.0023223949,
0.0900859609,
0.0763277188,
0.0513763502,
-0.0104399519,
-0.0412043817,
0.045505289,
0.0087383287,
-0.0077977362,
0.0130359363,
-0.0023728488,
-0.0667059943,
0.0178994499,
0.000018311,
-0.069688499,
-0.029966535,
-0.0029461479,
0.0488406755,
0.0435842834,
-0.0537872128,
0.0053371913,
0.0005081838,
-0.0036974028,
0.0094180321,
0.0138054406,
-0.0351549461,
0.0232991762,
0.0011945413,
0.0312088169,
-0.0267677512,
-0.0132769085,
0.0509007201,
0.0375891589,
-0.0102329282,
-0.0448170081,
0.0495751426,
0.0028219139,
-0.0718227103,
0.0358116291,
-0.0523272417,
0.0358137339,
0.0386853404,
0.0113759208,
0.0168328416,
-0.0852781683,
-0.003830723,
0.0074592661,
0.0608299337,
0.0213070847,
-0.0350239091,
-0.0106174769,
-0.0349307582,
0.0029854737,
-0.0174916815,
0.0170273986,
-0.0256318264,
0.0048776688,
0.036345005,
-0.0529015064,
0.0191629697,
-0.0223386716,
2.293e-7,
0.0550239757,
0.0385471061,
0.0467983447,
-0.0107965535,
0.0285262093,
0.014479381,
-0.0226055346,
0.0035791553,
-0.0076277452,
0.0365332551,
-0.0108864158,
-0.0008035189,
0.0735243335,
-0.0193527211,
-0.0467409864,
0.007292361,
-0.0668541119,
0.0106943864,
-0.0501155518,
-0.0024326043,
0.0551411994,
0.0489784554,
-0.019435104,
-0.0336054787,
0.0278389044,
-0.0928562805,
0.031586837,
-0.0414784662,
0.0311012808,
0.0088337641,
0.0484199673,
0.0280196257,
-0.0078800982,
-0.0043846928,
-0.0110068154,
-0.0142459478,
0.0407841541,
0.0551198535,
0.0155323204,
0.0322177634,
0.0069160322,
0.0074181287,
0.0147011466,
-0.0407544002,
0.0715824813,
-0.0068937037,
0.0077736867,
-0.0381963253,
-0.022440413,
-0.0492219292,
0.0154062621,
-0.0416266397,
-0.0466051549,
0.0231728926,
0.0117894802,
0.0063310424,
-0.0441281535,
-0.0174337793,
-0.0368754938,
-0.0291545242,
-0.0176618621,
-0.0118042706,
-0.1009835377,
0.0145441601,
0.0021242073,
-0.0327447355,
0.0159630552,
2.108624037e-34,
0.0044134967,
-0.0239453632,
-0.0050188866,
0.0280472264,
0.017623255,
0.0100790681,
-0.0150080426,
-0.0212161914,
-0.0546820685,
-0.0262385458,
0.0511097535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12538v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12538v2 | In-Context Learning Functions with Varying Number of Minima | 2023-11-21T11:33:03 | 2023-11-22T08:44:34 | David Oniani, Yanshan Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven effective at In-Context Learning
(ICL), an ability that allows them to create predictors from labeled examples.
Few studies have explored the interplay between ICL and specific properties of
functions it attempts to approximate. In our study, we use a formal framework
to explore ICL and propose a new task of approximating functions with varying
number of minima. We implement a method that allows for producing functions
with given inputs as minima. We find that increasing the number of minima
degrades ICL performance. At the same time, our evaluation shows that ICL
outperforms 2-layer Neural Network (2NN) model. Furthermore, ICL learns faster
than 2NN in all settings. We validate the findings through a set of few-shot
experiments across various hyperparameter configurations. | [
-0.0162594263,
0.0605833605,
-0.005453113,
0.0383992828,
-0.0165450741,
-0.0081773801,
0.049116265,
0.0029943285,
-0.0107287988,
-0.0382145047,
-0.0420830846,
-0.065328598,
-0.007251773,
0.0120247453,
0.0285717454,
-0.0307655856,
0.0090000415,
-0.057479918,
-0.0127099315,
-0.0210728049,
-0.0167068839,
-0.0177145489,
0.0203749277,
0.0327529348,
-0.0310644694,
-0.030597236,
0.0145314569,
-0.0062651904,
-0.0024364355,
-0.0087496005,
0.0349662863,
-0.0121388445,
0.0221479554,
0.0498772934,
0.0000022628,
-0.0393278897,
-0.0103739435,
0.006417172,
-0.0134770842,
0.0049006725,
0.0273302682,
-0.0190837812,
-0.0129869794,
0.0083907433,
-0.0644960105,
-0.0127923684,
0.0411016718,
-0.0106012393,
0.0376832895,
0.0988012627,
0.0049053319,
-0.0354938731,
0.0052922782,
-0.0476725101,
-0.0106107704,
-0.0413108468,
0.0139437523,
-0.0102459341,
-0.0195864495,
-0.0574192889,
-0.0128923478,
0.0588671826,
0.0293689836,
0.0326121375,
0.0228276253,
0.0685485825,
-0.0027320602,
0.0102383718,
-0.011997059,
0.0745366961,
-0.0906879231,
-0.0305901282,
-0.0174662527,
-0.0333890393,
-0.0251751598,
-0.0259036776,
-0.0421853177,
-0.0009054783,
0.0120224943,
0.0477159023,
0.0011424845,
0.0244546402,
0.0618104376,
0.006516404,
-0.0105636464,
0.0482231751,
-0.0197919086,
-0.0243425835,
-0.0087138154,
-0.0331166089,
-0.072551854,
-0.0100064222,
-0.0100959474,
0.0523532629,
-0.0153922169,
0.0296906196,
-0.0538370982,
-0.0160029531,
-0.0019736222,
-0.0752038807,
0.0443230793,
0.0300106406,
0.0163095221,
0.0510227643,
-0.0238922909,
0.0374035053,
-0.0156499837,
-0.0303010512,
-0.0201020464,
-0.0043628691,
-0.0253692903,
-0.0028908427,
-0.0231091026,
0.0439653322,
-0.0405869298,
-0.020656731,
-0.0196919609,
0.0263539851,
-0.0193187203,
0.0229035784,
-0.0183129162,
-0.0066005015,
-0.0322756991,
-0.0206127483,
-0.0070059593,
0.0089395409,
-0.0278749783,
0.030317083,
-0.0331965461,
-0.0202241726,
0.0053437003,
0.016218368,
0.0320075937,
0.0144546935,
0.0194071699,
0.089241378,
-0.020658439,
-0.0108278692,
-0.0185681731,
-0.0495368056,
-0.0024375697,
-0.072570011,
-0.021332046,
-0.1151846945,
0.0063755987,
0.0313506946,
0.0056851818,
-0.0524609908,
0.0113469735,
0.0164963547,
-0.0029484963,
0.0753825679,
0.0005776269,
-0.0028737641,
0.0485383347,
-0.0072044325,
0.0247631315,
0.0821064264,
0.0145342462,
-0.0138258133,
0.00905097,
0.0093120839,
-0.0186933335,
0.0539291613,
0.0335784592,
0.0105458088,
-0.0459312499,
-0.0057075089,
0.0371582732,
0.0352265052,
0.0192431919,
0.0605106726,
-0.0431831591,
-0.0174234323,
0.084422484,
0.0540711284,
0.0359088294,
0.0492330417,
0.0348405838,
0.0004938383,
0.0138570433,
-0.0073301881,
-0.0651695132,
-0.0005045367,
-0.0261911005,
0.0142555879,
0.0134773795,
-0.023329651,
-0.0393064655,
-0.0493830889,
0.0085351327,
-0.023874471,
-0.0302010681,
-0.0199492406,
0.0171096921,
-0.0010468699,
-0.0552292764,
0.0367655419,
0.0142502561,
-0.0024436114,
-0.0171203446,
-0.0113320015,
0.0092436867,
0.0408787988,
0.0116318297,
-0.0580603555,
-0.0090247681,
-0.0060030888,
0.0406891368,
0.0330007151,
0.0208990257,
-0.0206121411,
0.0334681682,
-0.0442994609,
0.0507975928,
0.0025308321,
0.0152243143,
0.0105333924,
0.0070555992,
-0.0026518463,
0.0291123819,
-0.0249636248,
-0.0340526626,
0.0186644178,
-0.0484280325,
-0.0507765003,
0.0342472754,
0.0153877335,
0.0366301872,
-0.0179581475,
0.0076858117,
0.0263685714,
0.034152437,
-0.0560513847,
0.0284395292,
-0.0230956264,
-0.1023951843,
-0.0556178428,
0.0400198475,
-0.0019607246,
0.028327113,
-0.0099717202,
-0.0234177951,
-0.0275312159,
0.0029369337,
-0.0240380168,
0.0862993598,
-0.034024898,
-0.0029493766,
-0.0050713229,
0.0030208756,
-0.0169531032,
0.0754496157,
-0.0109760426,
0.0248960014,
0.0337869711,
0.0196154155,
-0.0117689101,
-0.0040410995,
-0.0163528025,
-0.0411598347,
-0.0118914396,
0.0591094084,
-0.0317705907,
0.03255862,
0.0020128642,
-0.0044408129,
-0.0806640685,
-0.0160454512,
-0.0341888145,
-0.0117826834,
0.0321054496,
-0.0027722064,
0.0247072466,
-0.0342057645,
-0.037799038,
0.0281778183,
-0.0112349773,
0.0032189314,
0.0578712635,
0.0447229519,
-0.0604510382,
-0.0657511279,
-0.016338544,
-0.0143674975,
0.0789978728,
-0.0384338796,
-0.0259483047,
-0.0403834581,
0.0535157993,
0.026286805,
0.0812561065,
-0.0446003377,
-0.0003764867,
-0.0122351823,
-0.0390281528,
0.0241943635,
0.056305293,
-0.0137682268,
-0.0001515094,
0.0551100969,
0.0357275531,
-0.0802501738,
0.0072576692,
-0.0230237674,
-0.0148634119,
-0.0472094081,
0.0326000415,
-0.004167147,
0.0481819957,
-0.0188593641,
-0.0037275704,
-0.0273875799,
0.0508430749,
0.0108250258,
-0.0405777097,
-0.0457606353,
-0.0252489857,
-0.038083896,
0.0367259793,
-0.0050705643,
-0.0685181171,
0.0265013129,
-0.020506097,
-0.0112964362,
-0.0241192598,
-0.0205489658,
-0.0561937951,
0.0374493822,
0.007053351,
0.0131586725,
-0.0098576825,
-0.0250475574,
-0.0560638048,
-0.0005974426,
0.0102750137,
-0.0146315303,
0.0676468685,
-0.0428790972,
0.0269192494,
0.0219509285,
-0.061647635,
-0.0509788617,
-0.0569024682,
-0.0119638043,
0.0452864468,
-0.0249809418,
0.0250678193,
-0.0158255007,
-0.0007548316,
-0.0160495117,
0.0711907074,
0.0012054198,
-0.0101331808,
-0.0319827087,
0.0171818491,
0.0062729386,
0.0070935311,
0.0072025484,
-0.0147552453,
0.0534682646,
-0.000733395,
0.0336470567,
0.02105546,
-0.0526959896,
0.0125691406,
0.0070382268,
-0.0311936662,
-0.04103522,
0.0541283861,
0.04379512,
-0.0724688321,
-0.026004849,
0.0917962417,
0.0003344609,
-0.1002972573,
0.0155298486,
-0.0065957783,
0.013038638,
0.0352643654,
0.0376621708,
-0.0441056527,
-0.018181188,
-0.009983426,
0.0227205697,
-0.0087177409,
-0.0105448468,
0.0044860928,
-0.1509706378,
0.0005319535,
0.0410806239,
-0.0536443256,
-0.0238726623,
-0.047842171,
-0.0066621518,
0.0053239046,
0.0121307867,
0.0310937669,
-0.0264528655,
-0.0301053282,
0.0293304529,
-0.0164768212,
-0.0763683319,
0.0283543449,
-0.0515903831,
0.0110593103,
0.0412905104,
0.0241448749,
-0.0079169124,
-0.016066255,
0.0659103319,
0.0109383147,
0.002984063,
-0.0020090872,
0.0206566211,
0.0048164395,
0.0003694542,
0.0377882533,
0.0649215281,
-0.0297639333,
0.0146273617,
-0.0039462885,
0.0682233945,
-0.0006828592,
0.0133476462,
0.0074047679,
-0.0147651527,
0.0470804386,
0.0344760008,
0.0349264368,
-0.0760025084,
-0.0110910684,
-0.015479045,
0.0124613326,
-0.0252029747,
-0.0043389997,
-0.0164054278,
-0.0046442621,
-0.0189027917,
-0.0567315519,
-0.0095009329,
0.0143630747,
0.0452972576,
0.0127693992,
-0.0040462175,
0.0209630113,
0.0251995008,
-0.0338930674,
-0.0235044528,
-0.0008873449,
0.0149498424,
-0.0313998871,
0.0306310207,
0.0550371185,
-0.0385797508,
-0.026450187,
0.0208722409,
-0.0969908163,
-0.0505487211,
0.011768138,
0.0467654988,
0.0173587427,
0.0898492336,
-0.017056372,
-0.0653185695,
0.0892689079,
0.0689690933,
-0.0268739108,
0.0199213885,
0.0374948233,
-0.0165808555,
0.0031420898,
0.054679513,
-0.0489893816,
0.0114061162,
0.0231833942,
0.0132532921,
-0.0660920143,
0.0209303256,
0.0414010249,
-0.0206252448,
0.0320196375,
0.0029902365,
-0.0295541659,
-0.0130163599,
0.0166568644,
0.015998425,
-0.012900807,
-0.0262878966,
0.0081032636,
0.0249400754,
0.0199268255,
-0.0103172325,
-0.0270922855,
0.0729386583,
0.0307864975,
0.0282575265,
0.0285722408,
0.0214862321,
-0.0010910657,
0.0575447567,
0.0131335435,
-0.045059599,
0.0196652059,
-0.0103423195,
0.0178381186,
-0.0353369825,
0.0026198048,
0.0210663807,
0.0175059494,
-0.0642302185,
-0.0153155308,
-0.0486444123,
-0.0476384908,
-0.0606110804,
0.0292328112,
0.0744536594,
0.0032229121,
0.021302009,
-0.0397377685,
-0.0069298204,
-0.053414844,
-0.0173661336,
0.0228943732,
-0.0189012159,
0.0204652585,
0.0303549506,
-0.011169822,
0.0106068449,
0.0808884054,
0.0202468429,
0.0419362634,
0.0113880495,
0.0544038601,
-0.0500033572,
0.0224687438,
0.0172170624,
0.0727492049,
-0.0066753211,
0.0013459034,
-0.0356367379,
-0.0397932678,
0.0063916403,
-0.015160298,
0.0013414082,
-0.0237880871,
0.0247487538,
0.0892816633,
0.0139193423,
0.0394293703,
-0.026369743,
-0.0037676715,
0.0190477204,
-0.0301696621,
-0.066256322,
-6.817847398e-33,
-0.0156514551,
-0.0328994654,
0.0116355438,
0.0235650912,
0.0171516202,
0.0283864643,
-0.0237861387,
0.0376615487,
-0.0107636806,
-0.0255655963,
-0.0281393621,
-0.008238079,
0.0074119815,
0.018894257,
0.017561838,
-0.0109547013,
0.03634087,
-0.0242479201,
-0.0083713578,
-0.005522755,
0.0421925783,
0.0256846435,
0.0496323928,
-0.0462328717,
-0.0218708776,
-0.0130257132,
-0.0182081144,
0.0340550207,
-0.0069856304,
0.0468640476,
-0.0271618441,
0.0695437938,
0.0234929211,
-0.0291928109,
-0.0172298886,
0.0047066864,
-0.0784004331,
-0.02224016,
0.0410356298,
0.0206135642,
-0.0099076945,
-0.0439335294,
0.1118754148,
-0.0072972551,
-0.0281140171,
-0.003051627,
0.0568642244,
-0.0207183473,
-0.0544964112,
-0.0676940084,
-0.07046514,
0.0271256678,
0.01683034,
-0.0042125122,
0.0299890079,
0.0393146947,
-0.0260872133,
-0.0124286655,
-0.0838640332,
0.0192546863,
-0.0207734182,
0.0662558526,
0.0296391789,
0.0405081175,
0.0111912861,
0.0474927649,
0.0161777604,
0.0103586875,
0.000201507,
-0.0462653339,
0.0648237467,
0.0198152959,
0.0292368755,
0.0474384502,
0.0654519871,
-0.0281532891,
-0.0722581819,
-0.0341980048,
0.0182012338,
-0.0044558984,
0.03760501,
0.0084995842,
-0.0312183872,
-0.0250560977,
-0.0552219227,
-0.0315725543,
-0.0275053568,
-0.0251738522,
0.0270144828,
0.0303419009,
-0.0104123149,
0.0187073052,
0.0171603207,
-0.0447393656,
-0.0201755557,
0.0015256848,
0.0063536908,
0.03654816,
0.0089506479,
0.017582586,
-0.0568395145,
-0.0244655311,
-0.0593583174,
0.0192148425,
0.0438231379,
-0.0090295961,
0.0534571782,
0.0126303378,
-0.066286847,
-0.0353593342,
-0.0332734548,
0.0108123291,
0.0165174045,
0.0551658273,
0.0605939068,
-0.0271112695,
-0.0006175191,
0.0235437881,
-0.0217205584,
-0.0267901253,
0.0010818064,
0.0005560715,
-0.0263663325,
0.0363318026,
-0.0491030402,
-0.0340684094,
-0.0399957076,
0.012801405,
0.0532050356,
-0.0298456009,
-0.0126380436,
0.0124491015,
2.906e-7,
0.0339290425,
0.0318390504,
-0.0014343827,
0.0324486494,
0.055018384,
0.0121503482,
-0.0130533669,
-0.0060206866,
0.0011387328,
-0.0118206618,
0.0295686852,
-0.0064982842,
0.0215487964,
0.0371297151,
-0.0908353031,
-0.013904524,
-0.0599794388,
0.0207133479,
-0.0194166899,
0.0049415831,
-0.0301561728,
0.0997903273,
0.0244165715,
-0.0068157939,
-0.0078481268,
-0.0622127801,
0.0582835376,
-0.0464032069,
0.0295132529,
0.0314780995,
-0.0398292653,
0.0275989827,
-0.0045976527,
0.0090016443,
0.0099604493,
0.0505384132,
0.0004681976,
0.0685763061,
0.013979611,
-0.0340515785,
0.027241461,
0.0187550485,
-0.0021793637,
-0.0750880688,
0.0689784884,
-0.0560735576,
-0.0160097834,
-0.0252843183,
-0.0069150603,
-0.0149337593,
-0.0024901689,
0.0009625978,
-0.010809618,
0.0006607357,
0.001521207,
-0.0145727945,
0.0042789839,
-0.0310210809,
-0.0555017926,
0.0433836393,
-0.0383240283,
-0.0500263274,
-0.0346103273,
0.0035785532,
0.0441107042,
-0.0276300609,
0.0098731946,
2.577174707e-34,
0.0443424731,
-0.0181111824,
0.0193250589,
0.0474331975,
-0.0092007583,
0.0064135054,
-0.0554484352,
0.0192064885,
0.0809883475,
-0.0595699623,
-0.0162273496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12537v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12537v1 | Oasis: Data Curation and Assessment System for Pretraining of Large Language Models | 2023-11-21T11:32:23 | 2023-11-21T11:32:23 | Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Pengfei Cao, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao, Shengping Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data is one of the most critical elements in building a large language model.
However, existing systems either fail to customize a corpus curation pipeline
or neglect to leverage comprehensive corpus assessment for iterative
optimization of the curation. To this end, we present a pretraining corpus
curation and assessment platform called Oasis -- a one-stop system for data
quality improvement and quantification with user-friendly interactive
interfaces. Specifically, the interactive modular rule filter module can devise
customized rules according to explicit feedback. The debiased neural filter
module builds the quality classification dataset in a negative-centric manner
to remove the undesired bias. The adaptive document deduplication module could
execute large-scale deduplication with limited memory resources. These three
parts constitute the customized data curation module. And in the holistic data
assessment module, a corpus can be assessed in local and global views, with
three evaluation means including human, GPT-4, and heuristic metrics. We
exhibit a complete process to use Oasis for the curation and assessment of
pretraining data. In addition, an 800GB bilingual corpus curated by Oasis is
publicly released. | [
0.0279316381,
0.0753311515,
-0.0150973126,
0.0227148756,
-0.0171841737,
0.0271827225,
0.0179712009,
0.0056886259,
0.0045844284,
-0.0183669236,
-0.0213342849,
-0.0132595822,
0.0011652235,
-0.0077221245,
-0.0063838414,
-0.0255637951,
0.0627012849,
0.010359616,
-0.0161518399,
-0.0170449466,
0.0370799564,
0.0197190177,
0.022673741,
0.010421453,
-0.0187675953,
-0.0057039731,
0.0129393237,
-0.0158094149,
-0.0046956348,
0.0149447946,
0.0443304628,
0.0600240603,
-0.0469114818,
0.0747647136,
0.0000022225,
-0.0523752831,
-0.0393530019,
-0.0056182472,
-0.0351313837,
-0.0058180355,
0.0576127432,
0.0104446951,
-0.0220749006,
0.0247388817,
-0.0161016323,
-0.0345126688,
0.0395226292,
0.0200376753,
0.0953756198,
0.0528021827,
-0.0124818208,
-0.0191104542,
0.015200587,
-0.0136359939,
-0.0631274208,
0.018068105,
0.006932871,
-0.0015670194,
-0.0110568665,
-0.0123051982,
0.0264859758,
0.0519129485,
0.0427326299,
-0.0180134252,
-0.0260956399,
-0.0330927148,
-0.0828121379,
-0.061656177,
0.0355670042,
0.0572772995,
-0.0316997953,
-0.0936632007,
0.013913135,
0.0006688368,
0.0075539714,
0.0147546884,
-0.0078929961,
-0.0073852236,
0.0194315165,
0.0392239727,
0.0245085713,
-0.0171529148,
0.0424519107,
0.018914232,
-0.019071497,
0.0064721997,
0.0268491376,
-0.0329713114,
0.0402251445,
0.0584114529,
0.0118368231,
-0.0490330644,
0.056888558,
-0.0226501059,
-0.0061531127,
-0.0144124217,
-0.0624475144,
-0.0575578175,
0.0384191945,
-0.0475038216,
0.0332107954,
0.010509246,
-0.0220077932,
0.0242801495,
-0.0002644869,
-0.0022592763,
0.0107526192,
0.0175458509,
-0.0548766591,
-0.0241930801,
-0.0320741162,
0.026287701,
-0.044004485,
0.0256717652,
-0.0010666308,
0.0295849927,
-0.0276760794,
-0.0150487861,
-0.0248946808,
-0.0203729346,
0.0274848472,
-0.0447920114,
-0.0188621767,
-0.0088906214,
-0.0048217778,
-0.0006384915,
-0.0275300182,
0.0071275337,
-0.0224394538,
-0.0855931416,
0.0015355989,
0.0119837867,
0.0062560854,
-0.0095624011,
0.0031562259,
0.0231147222,
0.0135501465,
-0.017540358,
-0.0353920944,
-0.0218008105,
-0.0112747131,
-0.0653846636,
-0.0276240148,
-0.0764787719,
0.019358201,
-0.0116438353,
0.0007553158,
-0.0654096007,
-0.0248458013,
0.0062188632,
0.0136498772,
0.0291490871,
-0.041035831,
0.0151061658,
0.058860302,
-0.0029855196,
0.0206222329,
0.0538463295,
0.0194128249,
0.0032970875,
0.0583877601,
0.0222008955,
0.0428096764,
0.0541462563,
0.0250977799,
0.0186123289,
-0.0338914506,
-0.0223543961,
-0.0195539296,
0.0051559256,
0.0555454828,
0.0618727729,
-0.0607796311,
-0.012539437,
0.0603752695,
-0.0054241549,
0.0539034903,
0.0289086569,
0.022785794,
0.0384195,
0.0215999465,
-0.0182494652,
-0.0253080856,
-0.0341864713,
0.010264623,
0.0039909831,
-0.0108341789,
0.049481824,
-0.0290886164,
-0.0485625081,
0.019246107,
-0.0055098985,
0.0134509159,
0.0113362707,
0.0322454236,
0.0066871215,
0.0061719944,
0.0432373248,
0.0173632782,
-0.0923458114,
0.009214174,
-0.032372918,
0.0474970043,
0.0642695948,
0.0741741955,
-0.0030701736,
-0.028789008,
-0.0052824421,
-0.0108258305,
0.0213131756,
0.056022957,
-0.0267398302,
0.048122216,
-0.0823335052,
-0.064324744,
0.0442388467,
0.0138269514,
0.0060057864,
0.0172748566,
0.0170527454,
0.0479596108,
-0.0192999952,
-0.0811397061,
0.0474099517,
-0.0169763621,
-0.0289677586,
-0.0033926093,
0.0076311976,
0.0570844896,
0.0222001281,
-0.0304721743,
-0.0275724754,
0.03785019,
-0.0077306312,
0.0161004048,
0.0009848102,
-0.0238378011,
-0.009304611,
0.0701943934,
-0.0223623216,
-0.0176543836,
0.0351951309,
-0.0496082306,
-0.0331237838,
-0.0289841201,
-0.0388187543,
-0.0179353487,
-0.0767812058,
0.0519175865,
-0.0183549784,
0.0144454474,
-0.0191415977,
0.0292105898,
0.0186856948,
0.0112755541,
0.0081087751,
-0.0465283729,
0.0601166636,
-0.0373700857,
-0.0495953001,
0.0103020435,
-0.0163554233,
0.0262724683,
0.0528429635,
0.0412036553,
-0.0501465276,
0.0099041807,
-0.0845179409,
0.0040965271,
-0.0083881803,
0.0292772409,
0.0049149659,
-0.0083591295,
-0.0271415543,
-0.0360288061,
-0.0161276031,
-0.0522536859,
0.0097846985,
0.0041657053,
0.0223598927,
-0.0193309374,
0.0003792307,
-0.0360416137,
-0.0326678865,
0.0345359221,
0.023288345,
-0.0111068645,
-0.0423677638,
-0.0237957742,
0.0264781713,
-0.0302332081,
0.0216582343,
0.0628936663,
-0.045210164,
0.0157787278,
0.0044072778,
0.033258114,
0.0382506587,
-0.0362135172,
-0.0438565612,
0.0479044095,
-0.0112261865,
-0.0684397072,
-0.0051332484,
-0.0185694471,
0.0366010368,
-0.0141356941,
-0.0013169432,
0.0140492478,
0.0416704044,
-0.016412681,
-0.0328903832,
-0.0253669545,
0.025717115,
-0.0366532765,
-0.0182925202,
-0.0133971823,
-0.0017914581,
-0.0225963406,
0.025506895,
-0.0353854075,
-0.0454294458,
0.0669675842,
-0.0221751779,
0.0140365455,
-0.0831578821,
0.0026592924,
0.0145000331,
-0.0064661261,
-0.0003988374,
0.0218543615,
0.0076332917,
0.0034656455,
-0.0545558259,
0.0148609374,
0.043790862,
-0.0550343134,
0.0148741798,
-0.0737504438,
0.0068874317,
-0.0022621679,
-0.0370085984,
-0.0266142748,
0.0033889508,
-0.0044501149,
-0.0129472939,
0.006423411,
0.01951438,
-0.0496297404,
0.0004155327,
-0.0134872412,
0.1091353819,
-0.0074094618,
0.0153209912,
0.0160244405,
0.0359432921,
-0.0105778072,
0.0164087415,
0.0230697356,
-0.0210275352,
-0.0120292408,
0.0400254503,
0.0038155762,
0.0010115224,
-0.0081172204,
-0.0001922447,
0.0559768081,
-0.05262978,
-0.0326907113,
-0.0349342376,
0.0293775313,
-0.088734217,
-0.014532228,
0.095366247,
0.0245267842,
-0.0605523996,
-0.0237105172,
0.015189223,
0.0238425303,
-0.0013951057,
0.0067170132,
-0.0751088411,
-0.024383964,
0.0353039689,
0.0053326976,
0.0088667469,
0.0147031741,
0.0074433526,
-0.1026515588,
0.0215403102,
0.0235302038,
-0.0155783501,
-0.0022441645,
-0.0324148796,
-0.0179941077,
-0.0721553788,
0.0303448103,
0.004146134,
0.0334798954,
0.0360806435,
0.0138947032,
-0.0006659638,
-0.0950330794,
-0.0311802439,
-0.0618041269,
0.0446031801,
0.0531470254,
0.0512448549,
0.0044405502,
-0.0053426283,
0.0433840491,
-0.0634468421,
-0.0611494705,
-0.0108698905,
0.0563713871,
0.0191918332,
-0.0120035829,
-0.0606013946,
0.0054150722,
-0.0109323896,
0.0060485117,
-0.0093245693,
0.0568603724,
-0.0093561811,
0.0229643527,
-0.0226543434,
-0.0091862092,
-0.0142015582,
0.0734836981,
0.0172453355,
-0.0290094651,
-0.0124193197,
0.0011576989,
0.0007991993,
-0.0513069071,
-0.0000702513,
0.0351875797,
-0.0678744242,
-0.0132526569,
-0.1016737595,
-0.0695527121,
0.0159450881,
-0.0071496209,
0.0227411035,
-0.0133254165,
0.0090635978,
-0.0123022757,
-0.0213372987,
0.04673234,
-0.0179432686,
-0.0105649838,
-0.0651362687,
-0.0174162537,
-0.0378049053,
0.0235425886,
-0.0228253342,
0.0577873699,
-0.0517495908,
-0.0498187281,
0.0612176545,
0.0401653014,
0.021382723,
0.0383998603,
-0.0352788866,
-0.0736802965,
0.0577716045,
0.0271121543,
-0.0520483851,
-0.0250276066,
0.0448217653,
-0.0526652932,
0.0067405025,
0.0423937291,
-0.0160899032,
0.0469344817,
0.0035366861,
-0.0169763472,
-0.0256951246,
-0.0287790112,
0.0073040137,
0.016517248,
0.0388458259,
-0.0304394439,
-0.0057906974,
-0.0728598833,
0.0162803177,
-0.0400198214,
0.0031137567,
-0.0354089402,
0.0625172555,
0.0620219186,
0.0051868116,
-0.0206521582,
0.0459296294,
-0.0298792478,
-0.0011509213,
-0.0169539824,
0.0034921507,
-0.0071137403,
0.0155858258,
-0.0075241337,
0.0204638001,
-0.0079770489,
0.0039720628,
-0.0042344248,
0.0177826602,
-0.050337702,
0.0018104394,
0.0033777175,
0.0322177783,
0.0010710891,
0.0492235348,
-0.0190412197,
0.006149102,
-0.0507017262,
0.0132070109,
0.0466617532,
-0.0447489582,
0.0827757046,
-0.0148112047,
-0.028779801,
-0.0318267494,
0.0022466471,
0.0035157274,
0.0347676203,
-0.0267418697,
-0.0114689413,
-0.0423946343,
-0.0134507036,
0.0837761387,
-0.0267412215,
0.0071467282,
-0.005221229,
-0.00439859,
-0.0204864629,
-0.0289342999,
-0.0021169398,
0.0096349418,
-0.0526633821,
-0.0486213788,
-0.0107235555,
-0.0495131016,
-0.0360429287,
0.0293061528,
-0.0219186954,
0.0004197402,
0.0471670516,
0.0569440909,
-0.0427246243,
-0.004925922,
-0.0132172629,
-0.0282776225,
-0.0300114919,
-0.0320500061,
0.0007103371,
-6.331441795e-33,
0.00710314,
0.0377144106,
-0.005743796,
-0.0171919577,
-0.0262358431,
-0.0271009468,
-0.0110184187,
-0.0425233208,
0.0013692864,
0.0342726894,
0.0045483895,
0.036860019,
0.0420560315,
0.0113691976,
-0.007956936,
0.035737399,
0.0932678878,
-0.0011468674,
-0.0301884823,
0.0228798762,
0.0118152155,
0.0372549221,
0.0708408132,
-0.0857402161,
-0.0034945589,
-0.0025122291,
-0.0136194257,
0.0130386529,
0.0033894393,
0.0552347861,
0.0014912243,
0.0494028218,
0.005625553,
-0.0329838768,
-0.0230804943,
-0.0050412929,
-0.0732441843,
-0.0555092804,
0.0040307739,
0.0293797757,
0.0175645128,
-0.0403315462,
0.0483998172,
-0.0201639868,
-0.0306985099,
0.0381096378,
0.015465742,
-0.0350879058,
-0.0245374907,
-0.0331878848,
-0.0315223783,
0.0571643263,
0.0191608798,
-0.0027707084,
0.0485545248,
0.0419270396,
-0.0200791303,
-0.009394723,
-0.0828617737,
0.0099075958,
-0.0025909038,
0.0533050559,
0.0439861342,
-0.0367855132,
0.0024416458,
0.0382598117,
0.039405901,
-0.03160768,
0.0791445673,
0.0226133484,
0.0511898883,
0.0262316111,
0.0462409332,
0.0718426183,
0.0646802187,
-0.0393670201,
-0.0274587944,
0.0526813343,
-0.0385173373,
0.0445674323,
-0.0143481558,
-0.011453731,
-0.0198126715,
-0.0115502728,
-0.0382425301,
-0.0164584592,
-0.0027193581,
-0.0171053056,
0.0186845232,
0.016881125,
-0.024677312,
0.0004992188,
0.0142597398,
-0.0364252664,
0.0016399763,
0.0130135454,
-0.0360977799,
-0.0116290236,
0.0186933111,
0.0284914672,
-0.059411142,
-0.0128697949,
0.0158623066,
-0.0072173183,
-0.011091589,
-0.0136856288,
0.0613508672,
0.03634312,
-0.0715980232,
0.0459997542,
0.0054724417,
0.0289505869,
0.0242128335,
0.0644266084,
0.0084207896,
0.0184302293,
0.0275807399,
0.0211347435,
0.0664760247,
0.0285562091,
-0.0391082317,
-0.0229484532,
0.0371519178,
0.0098442286,
-0.006509372,
-0.0154872676,
-0.039796751,
0.017131146,
0.0417688861,
-0.0671347901,
-0.0022403584,
-0.0060505541,
2.791e-7,
0.0436272994,
0.0422954783,
0.0130354641,
-0.0189876314,
0.0115735997,
0.0079634655,
-0.0115263127,
-0.0007863361,
-0.0043692044,
0.0692234114,
0.0145969503,
0.0020809856,
0.0850018933,
0.0582688637,
-0.0621794052,
-0.0423601978,
-0.0277341474,
-0.0211743321,
-0.0454158522,
-0.0145348944,
0.0069623133,
0.1306971461,
0.0166175719,
-0.0333297104,
0.0022235012,
-0.0508405231,
0.0321354419,
-0.0285606869,
-0.0245674457,
0.0421857797,
0.1345499605,
-0.0072499858,
0.0159851722,
0.0131142586,
-0.0525018945,
0.0072094151,
-0.0123660639,
0.0618320964,
0.0023356015,
0.0196577199,
0.0299695916,
-0.0419651233,
-0.0052097514,
-0.0716599524,
0.0585187003,
0.0021309205,
0.0094465837,
-0.0232347976,
-0.033345826,
-0.0456942692,
0.0641932338,
-0.0252110884,
-0.0474731438,
0.0373457149,
0.0523648299,
0.0140816281,
-0.0375396349,
-0.0555440597,
-0.0473765358,
-0.0017006195,
-0.0013624734,
-0.0378148854,
-0.0049731466,
-0.0446417741,
0.02536989,
-0.0350857638,
0.0559748523,
2.460181336e-34,
0.0478888974,
0.0010953763,
0.0347516313,
-0.0060924538,
0.0282549318,
-0.0273284502,
-0.0119514875,
0.0144785251,
-0.0475515835,
-0.0151471123,
0.0170987584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12534v1 | Evaluation Metrics of Language Generation Models for Synthetic Traffic Generation Tasks | 2023-11-21T11:26:26 | 2023-11-21T11:26:26 | Simone Filice, Jason Ingyu Choi, Giuseppe Castellucci, Eugene Agichtein, Oleg Rokhlenko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks aim to generate a single output
text given an input prompt. Other settings require the generation of multiple
texts, e.g., for Synthetic Traffic Generation (STG). This generation task is
crucial for training and evaluating QA systems as well as conversational
agents, where the goal is to generate multiple questions or utterances
resembling the linguistic variability of real users. In this paper, we show
that common NLG metrics, like BLEU, are not suitable for evaluating STG. We
propose and evaluate several metrics designed to compare the generated traffic
to the distribution of real user texts. We validate our metrics with an
automatic procedure to verify whether they capture different types of quality
issues of generated data; we also run human annotations to verify the
correlation with human judgements. Experiments on three tasks, i.e., Shopping
Utterance Generation, Product Question Generation and Query Auto Completion,
demonstrate that our metrics are effective for evaluating STG tasks, and
improve the agreement with human judgement up to 20% with respect to common NLG
metrics. We believe these findings can pave the way towards better solutions
for estimating the representativeness of synthetic text data. | [
0.0451395027,
0.0115791513,
-0.0240363684,
-0.0041426136,
-0.0335890874,
-0.0312306117,
0.0287928693,
-0.017801445,
-0.0100110881,
-0.0589930639,
0.0170615446,
-0.0816621259,
-0.0187275093,
0.0786518753,
0.0329381563,
-0.0351250432,
0.0089428872,
-0.0058424636,
-0.0237388518,
0.0229824279,
0.0231906418,
0.0214677826,
0.0086311325,
0.0693164691,
-0.0188803468,
0.0051545487,
-0.0123940837,
0.0129569303,
0.0181089099,
-0.0177804343,
0.0199147686,
0.0445393734,
-0.0226201937,
0.024485644,
0.0000018068,
-0.0551847927,
0.011594614,
-0.0056693442,
-0.0338083319,
-0.0088404017,
0.0443767682,
0.0724103376,
-0.0080855889,
0.0608151034,
-0.0584776215,
0.0293508675,
0.03588783,
0.0365496539,
0.0511361547,
0.0698202103,
-0.009103369,
0.0111694541,
-0.0003111464,
0.0090152184,
0.0200773906,
0.0045757848,
-0.01932754,
0.0329371244,
0.0284055024,
-0.0057553169,
0.0233050361,
0.0115201473,
0.0212268587,
-0.0367130972,
0.0412767269,
0.029113451,
-0.0436609238,
-0.0263163522,
-0.0189247504,
0.0925397426,
-0.0213675108,
-0.0323618837,
0.011776478,
-0.0030603397,
0.0101859299,
-0.0356625915,
-0.0197301749,
0.0046449783,
-0.0003769066,
0.0087087853,
-0.0346851461,
0.0210730303,
0.0004011433,
-0.0175656024,
-0.004194431,
-0.0211274363,
0.0256539658,
-0.0243567917,
-0.0374892727,
0.0071838703,
-0.0061214962,
-0.0564175583,
0.0148980264,
0.010734099,
-0.0728926808,
0.0183192417,
-0.054380767,
-0.0251941569,
0.0328232497,
-0.0404920988,
0.0487624072,
0.0157897435,
-0.0099612661,
-0.0130926901,
-0.0240075216,
0.0545671359,
0.0058297142,
0.0065595969,
-0.0526308566,
0.0280409809,
-0.029298069,
0.0108169122,
-0.0179321151,
0.0237624142,
-0.0561084338,
-0.0307597183,
-0.041704081,
0.0440040082,
-0.00891943,
-0.0135605484,
0.0157973934,
0.036545407,
-0.0336465761,
0.0161992218,
-0.0416037627,
-0.0399952717,
-0.0446004309,
0.013932609,
0.0455194823,
-0.078372106,
0.0281218924,
0.0503575951,
0.0189498104,
0.0072350451,
-0.0277098417,
0.0467532277,
-0.0191395767,
-0.0023440141,
-0.0523187928,
-0.0761606246,
-0.0145303169,
-0.0539484136,
-0.0434108451,
-0.0652065799,
0.0265888758,
-0.0079910327,
-0.0441793278,
0.0069713159,
0.0035704246,
0.0269379448,
0.002557822,
0.0201744176,
-0.0305414237,
0.0324599408,
0.0196460765,
-0.0202598739,
0.0465021245,
0.0419619679,
0.0474032462,
0.0367642678,
0.0324085578,
0.006586941,
0.0532515608,
0.0216104984,
0.0128253028,
0.0094527779,
-0.0007052512,
-0.0077110548,
-0.0202749893,
0.0273923613,
0.032256335,
0.0941863358,
-0.0466873981,
0.0120036136,
0.063138634,
0.0105017526,
0.0308085866,
0.002401175,
0.110063456,
0.0472867936,
-0.0196359511,
0.0280802865,
0.0187640842,
0.0132274562,
-0.0285718311,
0.030253835,
0.0708624646,
0.0253945049,
-0.0068731722,
-0.0537629798,
0.021003345,
-0.0197333433,
-0.0121667152,
-0.0246259626,
0.0074830661,
0.0352357775,
-0.0618394166,
0.0021667853,
-0.015906889,
-0.0766857862,
0.0250701103,
-0.0267512277,
0.0199791417,
0.0807312503,
0.042320855,
0.0545255803,
-0.0229063723,
-0.0172930043,
-0.0520127974,
0.0815666839,
0.0416212454,
-0.0229934435,
-0.0256555807,
-0.0586002097,
0.0019172244,
0.0071905321,
-0.0027237802,
-0.0003087057,
-0.00379797,
0.0019366764,
0.0472443327,
-0.0491187647,
-0.053190425,
0.0332546495,
-0.0157784522,
-0.0047724862,
0.0219757017,
-0.0113756498,
0.0282085147,
0.0220986567,
-0.038867563,
0.0320636779,
0.0112176882,
0.0021371704,
-0.0124838566,
0.044228185,
-0.0005283452,
-0.0026663258,
0.0059730299,
-0.0575602502,
0.0103834122,
0.012421418,
-0.0005982695,
-0.0537633896,
-0.004360442,
-0.0660888255,
-0.0009442056,
-0.0453338213,
0.0072371433,
0.0353495181,
0.0292785,
-0.0108041894,
0.050480634,
0.0174937751,
0.0363281779,
0.0278245248,
0.0320790447,
0.0453508385,
-0.0603985824,
-0.00970155,
-0.0075782733,
-0.0431216694,
0.049746912,
0.0531092882,
0.0265588704,
-0.0513208359,
-0.0160338469,
-0.0719492882,
0.0042055137,
-0.0343040973,
0.0205712132,
0.0412198752,
0.0019212922,
-0.0249906536,
-0.0078194551,
-0.0793046281,
-0.0119828898,
0.0458562188,
-0.0056325835,
0.0475615561,
-0.0122394525,
-0.0141600929,
-0.0421826504,
0.0288753957,
-0.0070160851,
0.0431220494,
0.0358674973,
0.0291763507,
-0.0575946346,
0.0253106076,
-0.0399496816,
0.0082656555,
0.0302274134,
-0.0721213594,
0.0365103558,
0.0214784835,
0.0749230087,
0.0267486125,
0.0793287233,
-0.0287438203,
0.01561445,
0.0091262357,
-0.0641257614,
-0.0028771698,
-0.0595546886,
-0.0056743473,
-0.0179685522,
-0.0770123973,
0.0721620768,
0.036337439,
0.0332343765,
0.0068345219,
-0.0647183433,
0.0182354543,
-0.0083689839,
-0.0423157513,
-0.0013439838,
0.0018457585,
-0.0530134216,
0.0744139329,
0.001945924,
-0.0305515528,
0.0385289714,
-0.0376439355,
0.0145806847,
-0.0565581396,
-0.0017529186,
-0.0029795712,
0.0106513333,
0.0055364361,
0.0422734283,
0.0063719139,
-0.0145347668,
-0.0229089949,
0.0385398231,
-0.0012421393,
-0.037953075,
0.0197121091,
-0.0390575938,
0.0151000936,
0.0144943465,
-0.0334820785,
-0.0657135248,
-0.0229642373,
0.0187282246,
-0.0335356891,
0.074469775,
-0.0301643331,
-0.0063143801,
0.0199737325,
-0.0155000156,
0.0409016944,
-0.0195097551,
-0.0246215239,
-0.0134963123,
0.0366776213,
0.0733681619,
0.0435860679,
0.0130806332,
0.0047788662,
0.0165722929,
0.0230204742,
0.0313520506,
0.0393702239,
-0.0268958863,
-0.0033914472,
0.0011969708,
-0.0178665444,
-0.0049187816,
0.0799741447,
0.0376755521,
-0.0116967838,
-0.043164134,
0.0853534639,
0.0322764665,
0.0050817211,
0.0206054933,
-0.000629881,
0.0647863001,
0.0199759156,
0.0346150286,
-0.079884626,
0.0063196355,
-0.0229790993,
0.047008872,
-0.0475437306,
-0.0141440853,
-0.0245869048,
-0.1399154961,
0.0482896678,
-0.0085081141,
-0.047955595,
0.0114450492,
-0.0313230529,
-0.0090886587,
0.0234014373,
0.037647292,
0.003175996,
0.0101544792,
0.0251075886,
0.0557993315,
-0.0437062532,
-0.0819273144,
-0.0199188776,
-0.031107353,
0.1053012386,
0.0472733304,
0.0310552381,
0.0270015318,
-0.0278389119,
-0.0067211664,
-0.0106340833,
-0.0006195115,
0.0297857989,
0.0613665618,
0.011157101,
-0.0206295252,
-0.0343901217,
0.0103092119,
-0.0214763209,
0.0151659185,
-0.0157005079,
0.000829483,
-0.0104964972,
-0.0214220006,
-0.0316091701,
0.0530621484,
0.0291254036,
0.0618809089,
0.0573847406,
-0.0560550615,
-0.0503841043,
-0.0289879479,
0.0193533357,
-0.1122460142,
-0.0310837366,
0.0330136679,
-0.0165191386,
-0.0331534669,
-0.1209292933,
-0.0727613643,
-0.0044334158,
0.0439675972,
0.0102135073,
-0.0147315413,
0.0177524909,
-0.0165143367,
0.0030174083,
0.006507216,
-0.0192678105,
0.0067413389,
-0.057006862,
-0.0072124111,
-0.0016016816,
-0.0707801804,
-0.0148177193,
0.0175405443,
-0.0564194247,
-0.0646451265,
-0.0008637448,
0.0420693941,
0.0289617535,
-0.0022901271,
-0.0336457454,
-0.0160370413,
-0.0074930075,
0.0581475757,
-0.0538330115,
-0.026980659,
0.0076891454,
0.0096025756,
-0.0153923389,
0.0140980994,
-0.0444726646,
0.0208703708,
-0.0415004306,
0.0614038371,
-0.0199061092,
-0.0418944098,
0.0436946712,
0.0504889712,
-0.0077023464,
-0.0359569378,
0.0228259005,
-0.0223506987,
-0.0239151735,
-0.0056665163,
-0.0128504029,
-0.0480773188,
-0.0031420232,
0.0084385509,
0.0242567137,
0.008894911,
0.0105253719,
-0.0710589066,
0.0158561151,
0.013677204,
-0.0600844212,
0.0091031408,
0.02241854,
0.0137937106,
-0.0139732976,
-0.0253170617,
-0.0223765932,
0.0094218524,
0.0486449488,
0.0118141081,
0.0325209312,
0.0128224781,
0.0074230963,
0.0187182128,
0.0365818888,
-0.0310135297,
-0.0177972075,
-0.0543906502,
0.0182764791,
0.0184744149,
0.0134867867,
0.0684702173,
-0.0243363325,
0.038191434,
-0.0216178969,
0.032215856,
-0.0030826149,
-0.0208749231,
-0.0092916498,
-0.0232267175,
-0.0321099758,
-0.017018415,
0.0836113691,
-0.0404652022,
0.0168146156,
-0.0355741754,
-0.0030408739,
-0.0695855692,
-0.0056545334,
-0.0122855948,
-0.0022054119,
-0.002445698,
-0.0223795753,
-0.0683273077,
-0.0504709966,
-0.0048581115,
0.0444550849,
0.0375478342,
0.0091362428,
0.0703838244,
0.0661501512,
-0.0222676285,
0.0515608862,
-0.0385178328,
-0.035379976,
-0.0463769026,
0.0195531715,
-0.0146696679,
-6.228109964e-33,
-0.0001139845,
-0.0548029244,
0.0275904778,
-0.0107794944,
-0.0257392507,
-0.0204062089,
-0.0460727215,
0.0163216982,
0.0066803386,
-0.01637692,
-0.0010325394,
-0.0370523818,
0.0165188052,
0.0248389374,
-0.0170184765,
-0.0218202118,
0.044602301,
-0.0168917235,
-0.0619530566,
0.0513720661,
0.0399786197,
-0.0139769772,
0.0039921519,
-0.0329903886,
0.0350003354,
-0.0300469194,
-0.0145344781,
0.0039089019,
0.0162110887,
0.0600891896,
-0.0256108344,
0.0757674351,
0.0233160276,
-0.0344217271,
-0.0233020429,
0.0337525159,
0.0175901074,
-0.0457852483,
0.0311344247,
-0.0011545862,
-0.0639016032,
-0.0135918772,
0.0391202047,
-0.0420883857,
-0.0463019721,
0.0707419813,
0.037413951,
-0.0131121008,
-0.0033281387,
-0.0593125671,
-0.0740909427,
0.0099954121,
-0.02137197,
-0.042483665,
-0.0157295447,
0.0897753388,
-0.0121208411,
-0.0286459886,
-0.0054397276,
0.0661245435,
0.0104712797,
-0.0065910341,
0.0739336908,
-0.0049542654,
-0.0068106237,
0.0650634766,
0.019533854,
0.014030084,
-0.0057919929,
-0.0023180803,
0.0127792703,
0.0389017984,
0.0213996675,
0.094758682,
0.0070782257,
-0.0054039294,
-0.0182759184,
0.0601693466,
0.0214334335,
-0.0323104113,
0.0227015018,
-0.0464156903,
-0.0411673598,
0.0023068809,
-0.050000865,
0.0155695658,
-0.0195681974,
-0.0479653142,
0.0509208925,
0.0194361005,
-0.0448085964,
-0.0560971722,
0.0260748845,
-0.0116147129,
0.0119464369,
-0.0321350135,
-0.0455264039,
0.0076505877,
-0.0067741731,
-0.0091438601,
-0.0419720821,
-0.0095286407,
0.0516060181,
0.0221353304,
-0.000782704,
0.0125693046,
-0.0068640998,
-0.0043185446,
-0.0464943945,
0.0424287468,
-0.0242752004,
0.0491058379,
0.0009357361,
-0.0193637013,
0.0212686136,
-0.0185517464,
-0.0520538241,
0.0096752793,
-0.0088547468,
0.0128702261,
-0.0163818747,
-0.0305230599,
0.0071058571,
0.03664786,
-0.0623849258,
0.0128154764,
-0.0634685904,
0.0293498915,
0.0321088135,
-0.0540409461,
-0.0156202195,
0.0126108369,
2.624e-7,
0.0112734446,
0.0449947342,
0.0322969705,
0.031380333,
-0.0086394427,
0.0245914776,
0.0370990485,
0.0313101597,
0.0186790843,
-0.0298557561,
-0.0259423535,
-0.0233084746,
0.019434426,
0.0153534692,
-0.086794652,
0.0016981657,
-0.0819996819,
0.0125229955,
-0.049937509,
-0.0098800855,
0.0714810416,
0.0406568199,
-0.0281318724,
-0.0097884638,
0.0271821246,
-0.0327940285,
0.0225203112,
-0.0032770471,
-0.0426674858,
0.0538295619,
0.0879453793,
0.0090204291,
0.0031927018,
0.0157401022,
-0.0158909876,
-0.0078338413,
0.0153881731,
-0.0040199859,
0.0427258499,
-0.0417919867,
-0.0039078486,
-0.0436756089,
0.0200192183,
-0.0550373271,
0.0177917816,
-0.0126574039,
-0.0039877584,
-0.0147690596,
-0.0338992998,
-0.0239109118,
0.0135859232,
-0.0528848767,
-0.0190270785,
0.0071206186,
0.0160839725,
0.0215079561,
0.0127779441,
-0.0228784028,
-0.0113417441,
-0.0071365498,
-0.0267178398,
-0.0537924469,
-0.0227896869,
0.0239446741,
0.0249578319,
-0.0120414589,
0.0205799397,
1.924576863e-34,
0.0328299664,
0.0272529889,
0.0420586765,
-0.0117204897,
0.0293826051,
0.0081469147,
0.0122953989,
-0.0036687448,
0.0160589498,
-0.0416625775,
-0.0394353196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12489v1 | Multilingual Word Embeddings for Low-Resource Languages using Anchors and a Chain of Related Languages | 2023-11-21T09:59:29 | 2023-11-21T09:59:29 | Viktor Hangya, Silvia Severini, Radoslav Ralev, Alexander Fraser, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | Very low-resource languages, having only a few million tokens worth of data,
are not well-supported by multilingual NLP approaches due to poor quality
cross-lingual word representations. Recent work showed that good cross-lingual
performance can be achieved if a source language is related to the low-resource
target language. However, not all language pairs are related. In this paper, we
propose to build multilingual word embeddings (MWEs) via a novel language
chain-based approach, that incorporates intermediate related languages to
bridge the gap between the distant source and target. We build MWEs one
language at a time by starting from the resource rich source and sequentially
adding each language in the chain till we reach the target. We extend a
semi-joint bilingual approach to multiple languages in order to eliminate the
main weakness of previous works, i.e., independently trained monolingual
embeddings, by anchoring the target language around the multilingual space. We
evaluate our method on bilingual lexicon induction for 4 language families,
involving 4 very low-resource (<5M tokens) and 4 moderately low-resource (<50M)
target languages, showing improved performance in both categories.
Additionally, our analysis reveals the importance of good quality embeddings
for intermediate languages as well as the importance of leveraging anchor
points from all languages in the multilingual space. | [
-0.0347658992,
0.0576458052,
0.0170074403,
0.0640595257,
-0.0460442752,
-0.0058199046,
0.0017898085,
-0.0071247336,
0.0203496329,
-0.0187757239,
-0.0234346949,
-0.0329516679,
0.0024177195,
-0.0398101993,
0.0395960361,
-0.035096433,
0.0338818692,
0.0044038277,
-0.0541970395,
-0.0348591097,
-0.0094935596,
0.0322131291,
0.0263126548,
0.0090421597,
-0.0452921614,
-0.0320249423,
0.042031385,
-0.0323019102,
0.0088630188,
-0.0223569851,
-0.0243734717,
0.0119762104,
0.0335192196,
0.0373665132,
0.0000017672,
-0.0250892416,
-0.0160137098,
0.0122050829,
0.0119793164,
0.0076277778,
0.0190984458,
-0.0960317254,
0.0040574619,
0.0096133715,
-0.0031941093,
-0.0545879193,
0.0399015509,
0.0311263166,
0.0288318079,
0.0432905108,
-0.0237274785,
-0.0297784191,
0.0236262251,
-0.042031996,
-0.0198939983,
-0.0141358115,
-0.0273726471,
0.0158388577,
-0.0161554627,
0.0044297082,
-0.0395390987,
0.0277210977,
0.0153103163,
0.0408635288,
-0.0273785759,
0.0223648828,
-0.0496181808,
-0.0296334811,
0.0099106887,
0.0623299107,
-0.1033887416,
-0.0223186929,
-0.0360380076,
-0.0066371784,
-0.0072004786,
-0.0097871255,
-0.0191328414,
0.0082304254,
0.0163349528,
0.0401171297,
0.0732468665,
0.0128670651,
0.0767409056,
-0.0162686277,
-0.0333847664,
0.0266803671,
0.0378252715,
-0.0480417088,
0.0349792577,
0.0276565887,
0.0342505351,
0.0222019982,
-0.0216633622,
-0.0374290235,
-0.0030571718,
0.0408382639,
-0.021002451,
-0.0113453558,
0.030169731,
-0.05175668,
-0.016851034,
0.0312653445,
-0.0525534786,
0.0595218726,
-0.0929083675,
-0.0376332626,
-0.0386173055,
-0.0193096418,
-0.0152307125,
-0.0487050228,
0.0014587474,
0.0049058762,
-0.0265463609,
-0.0185795762,
-0.0230220258,
0.001465819,
0.002283368,
0.0180125367,
-0.014619953,
0.0247588605,
-0.0085037239,
-0.0347469598,
0.0155311609,
0.0001406145,
0.0408683084,
0.0470811725,
-0.0626974106,
-0.0236439332,
-0.0567894392,
-0.039114926,
-0.0261897743,
0.0369788557,
-0.0035108463,
-0.0348728113,
0.0227400418,
0.0932258219,
0.0053001433,
-0.0467724837,
-0.0493895188,
0.0053952038,
0.0207761098,
-0.0420639776,
0.0194019973,
-0.0909247175,
0.0737842172,
0.0217681546,
0.0447605029,
-0.004746391,
0.0182347447,
0.0020704824,
-0.0610686354,
0.0545861423,
-0.003606217,
-0.0360502973,
-0.0062282719,
-0.0195356719,
0.0223053675,
0.1076843813,
0.0030230242,
-0.032792598,
0.0774055496,
0.0056241243,
-0.0820858181,
0.020818416,
0.0403502211,
0.0385497399,
0.0286490712,
-0.0215066578,
0.0414642766,
0.058015693,
0.046008721,
0.0078887763,
-0.0387288332,
0.0039936053,
-0.0158932172,
0.019353481,
0.0203312859,
0.0454806611,
0.0554260984,
-0.008119409,
-0.066095829,
0.0067718201,
-0.0096765049,
0.0150003489,
0.0156866051,
-0.007747991,
0.0666168481,
0.051635012,
-0.0242252816,
0.0100523997,
-0.0171177499,
-0.057197731,
0.0204095431,
-0.0259523168,
0.0588223524,
0.012960026,
-0.0391182117,
0.0786477253,
0.0687746778,
-0.0523075461,
0.0309159141,
0.0445245951,
-0.047579322,
0.0174146518,
0.003573288,
0.0030094127,
0.0108301546,
-0.0231872406,
0.0396973193,
0.0072392151,
0.0488935523,
-0.018023463,
0.0428167544,
-0.0688612908,
0.0002044017,
-0.020868266,
-0.0213907007,
0.0442475677,
-0.0057287645,
0.0400670543,
0.0066405842,
-0.0259807743,
0.0026128441,
0.0104989987,
-0.0541714914,
0.0163483452,
0.030203769,
0.0568063222,
-0.0009257308,
0.0458685793,
0.0186848305,
-0.0112983212,
0.0242790971,
-0.0667143464,
-0.0072535546,
0.0092434147,
-0.0327514596,
-0.0524764545,
0.045734264,
-0.0602335036,
0.0024431385,
-0.0179315079,
-0.0231845509,
-0.035073299,
0.0221287105,
0.0008698254,
0.0580996014,
-0.0489200912,
-0.0146310264,
-0.0008230879,
0.0551006384,
0.0152590415,
0.075916037,
-0.0079638427,
0.0756866485,
-0.020098038,
-0.0148198511,
0.0676966012,
-0.0295613334,
-0.0350413211,
0.0191528145,
0.0096604973,
0.0162425637,
0.013541257,
0.0289595202,
0.0042482344,
-0.0098833097,
-0.0707873777,
-0.0244609024,
-0.026046278,
0.0010247027,
-0.0398629904,
0.0160367023,
0.0204721745,
-0.0015513849,
-0.0296195745,
0.0005943868,
0.0036785339,
0.0443339907,
0.0167169981,
-0.0166923851,
-0.0003233242,
0.0150269102,
-0.0172084682,
0.0251220688,
0.0518731363,
-0.0435327664,
-0.0145986313,
-0.025458781,
-0.0365018286,
-0.0134369861,
0.0078843003,
0.0149887996,
-0.0216106419,
-0.0077394038,
0.0221932046,
0.0595452935,
0.0018093935,
-0.0364283808,
-0.00173585,
0.0627701283,
0.0020280692,
-0.0430238768,
0.0208344981,
0.0045841914,
0.0520752184,
-0.0257982612,
0.0078847641,
-0.0349519886,
0.0286951791,
-0.0026093447,
-0.0213506389,
-0.066556111,
-0.0455153063,
-0.0067930231,
-0.000387896,
-0.0173444897,
0.0220542997,
-0.0104521578,
0.0045864917,
-0.0060215117,
-0.0184317101,
0.0501725972,
-0.0177956615,
0.0039212909,
-0.0473584197,
-0.004216034,
-0.0278611388,
0.0150820287,
0.0008567932,
0.0513030365,
-0.0528878123,
0.0006550964,
-0.0199978705,
0.0410425924,
0.0149223218,
0.0037466283,
0.0374476053,
0.0140202381,
-0.0165790692,
-0.0213869922,
-0.0656185597,
-0.0162409302,
-0.0324684195,
-0.00381067,
0.0028342402,
0.0139552737,
-0.0023245213,
-0.0186995361,
-0.0128496485,
0.0443138778,
0.0069726706,
0.0450718515,
0.0178724546,
0.013294436,
0.0238954052,
0.0074652345,
-0.0302122924,
0.0099951932,
-0.0026924638,
0.0062431362,
-0.0128493859,
0.035340108,
-0.0062562628,
0.0080911638,
-0.0064890417,
0.04007449,
-0.0022699365,
-0.0612322874,
-0.0533154905,
0.0038428423,
0.0325946286,
-0.0015480345,
0.0516357273,
0.0126463836,
-0.047467757,
0.0192581769,
-0.0456650667,
0.018447157,
0.0371748097,
0.0048750574,
-0.0952438861,
-0.0044899411,
-0.0045281663,
-0.0230748244,
0.0366239697,
-0.0264361743,
-0.0199393295,
-0.1231026277,
-0.0182106271,
0.028243294,
-0.0555325374,
-0.0475959629,
-0.0810669661,
-0.0285235755,
-0.0024191386,
0.0143215703,
-0.0364238359,
0.0317321047,
-0.0532101765,
-0.0169761013,
-0.0107308216,
-0.0550693348,
0.0160747487,
-0.06278456,
0.0203535799,
-0.0109400833,
0.0666079596,
-0.0360523313,
-0.0272000078,
0.038451191,
-0.0458752811,
-0.0597426482,
-0.0089417128,
-0.0048361481,
-0.0143124601,
-0.0176052675,
0.0554019585,
0.0232719462,
-0.036070995,
0.0031246815,
-0.0036135437,
0.1306563914,
0.0229400788,
0.012784089,
0.0225707293,
-0.0036467873,
0.0417833179,
0.0436900035,
-0.0061458563,
-0.0534961261,
0.0274176672,
0.0207512435,
0.0140012978,
-0.023065757,
-0.015143929,
0.0386372767,
-0.0239378214,
-0.0266237631,
-0.0490190908,
-0.0700158551,
0.0088120103,
0.0622198544,
0.0032107313,
0.0547808073,
-0.0269530267,
-0.019827364,
0.0076961089,
0.0072065154,
-0.0157944504,
0.0080638686,
-0.021196289,
0.025947215,
-0.0034200924,
-0.025992427,
-0.0046212291,
-0.0200472437,
-0.0090205772,
-0.0358578973,
-0.0348663218,
0.0260124877,
-0.003604556,
0.0283616856,
-0.0216437113,
-0.0344999395,
0.0209311694,
0.0266143978,
-0.01272278,
-0.0205232296,
0.045267731,
0.0167570394,
0.0253487341,
0.060539268,
-0.0408457182,
-0.0102916621,
-0.0244875029,
0.0581537113,
-0.003674878,
-0.0112441806,
-0.0090415571,
-0.0235806797,
0.0319233276,
-0.0808721408,
0.026848631,
-0.053086713,
-0.0060134912,
-0.0399519354,
-0.0201180726,
-0.0082267076,
0.0219273847,
0.031759467,
-0.0429089628,
0.0007798749,
-0.044396352,
0.0289102849,
-0.0105242375,
0.0403244011,
0.0391277522,
0.0381344669,
0.0370960198,
0.008709128,
0.0215955414,
-0.0287243351,
-0.0282252878,
-0.0403762758,
-0.0010934578,
-0.0783114061,
-0.0001325158,
0.0084538776,
-0.0166442264,
-0.0075613982,
0.0107902875,
0.0224231463,
0.0290594921,
0.0069800271,
0.0108398153,
0.1140187904,
-0.0375954732,
0.0626111999,
-0.0186205935,
-0.0287967976,
-0.0025817552,
0.0165290479,
-0.0094663911,
-0.0688385069,
0.0137599558,
0.0044001499,
-0.0432487503,
0.0224471353,
0.0548588373,
-0.0051255771,
0.0097383158,
-0.0072986856,
0.0292639155,
-0.014167794,
-0.0162636768,
0.0097973505,
0.0315493643,
-0.0345132686,
0.0227638949,
-0.0651674196,
-0.0544482507,
-0.014567066,
0.0102320248,
-0.0484963916,
0.0511859469,
0.0006853503,
0.0777904168,
0.002731794,
0.0393081307,
-0.053453669,
0.0116366064,
0.0400810316,
-0.0463243909,
0.0407153815,
-5.424742227e-33,
0.0351713821,
0.0339836963,
-0.024626404,
-0.0337369367,
0.0038159944,
0.0196260363,
-0.0071658087,
0.0007123213,
-0.047923211,
0.014960153,
-0.0067600706,
-0.0307298955,
0.0106167858,
0.0255236737,
0.0178065822,
0.018384682,
-0.0112774521,
0.0216389075,
0.0031081422,
0.0091012977,
0.0751644075,
0.0239478201,
0.0943105519,
-0.056375362,
0.0434367806,
-0.017580485,
0.0379820168,
0.008417936,
0.0486872904,
0.0401763581,
-0.0245729424,
0.0487902947,
0.0308057815,
-0.0116825858,
0.0159882717,
-0.0157825295,
-0.0752081051,
-0.0459059328,
0.0228604265,
0.0082164127,
-0.0474903435,
-0.0266738869,
-0.0055667651,
-0.0130588822,
0.0428857133,
-0.0062907082,
0.0030584408,
-0.0005367285,
-0.0659459159,
0.0030129172,
-0.0764945522,
0.0393108688,
0.0479266085,
0.0145422397,
0.0377186686,
0.0637383088,
0.0283843726,
-0.0435021333,
-0.080679588,
-0.0170080569,
-0.0949012861,
0.0091406312,
0.0484735854,
-0.0267195106,
-0.0127245104,
0.0377824903,
0.0198590793,
-0.0163112655,
0.0535658039,
0.0292329695,
0.0214043129,
-0.01295505,
0.010119102,
0.0681131259,
0.0238139052,
-0.0325387456,
-0.080008477,
-0.0227659959,
0.0375456959,
-0.0049807001,
0.027695179,
-0.0021067283,
-0.0234708358,
-0.0144025413,
-0.0439948253,
-0.0630671978,
-0.014255641,
-0.0737634152,
0.0027077852,
0.016720552,
0.0044185682,
0.0032901389,
0.0501239337,
-0.0115101105,
-0.0546379983,
0.0695258677,
0.0227195639,
-0.0249786153,
0.0018380347,
0.0538251549,
-0.0338986777,
-0.0531034656,
-0.04529953,
-0.0195756555,
0.0375951491,
-0.0110763302,
0.0503723696,
-0.0029147747,
-0.0523860194,
-0.0103975609,
-0.0378723741,
-0.0346668214,
-0.0129545256,
0.0169198234,
0.0389922373,
-0.002663387,
0.010622099,
0.0427733473,
0.0717386827,
-0.0174885765,
0.0176096465,
-0.015278249,
-0.0054321303,
0.0378887504,
-0.0051423092,
-0.0030901851,
-0.0320442468,
0.0042472626,
0.0204782374,
-0.0801399946,
-0.0155116869,
-0.0043276078,
2.617e-7,
0.0349351242,
0.0069493209,
-0.0005961818,
0.0073946877,
-0.0233789422,
0.0047010016,
-0.035109777,
0.038779363,
-0.0622214563,
0.0075511006,
-0.0159472004,
-0.0043043266,
0.059675552,
0.0538250469,
-0.099761188,
0.0166954286,
-0.0300711263,
-0.0056604259,
-0.0347767882,
-0.0217228923,
0.0213048179,
0.129339233,
0.027902117,
0.0118279802,
-0.0340410098,
-0.0088066747,
0.0705041885,
-0.0142746987,
-0.0440467149,
-0.0402181298,
-0.0287694111,
0.0317828171,
-0.0074201678,
-0.0264684502,
-0.0578329861,
0.0762974098,
0.0433301553,
0.0170134325,
0.0177208073,
-0.0200364105,
0.0368784219,
-0.0420226268,
-0.0311340485,
-0.016482031,
0.0552712455,
-0.0016943861,
0.0028639289,
0.0091286395,
0.0174653996,
0.0528584868,
0.0913802013,
-0.0269088112,
-0.0592353344,
0.0228361767,
0.0558207184,
-0.0011510315,
-0.0314747915,
-0.0514698066,
-0.0264408477,
0.0599861816,
-0.0092197983,
0.0066578048,
0.0389072821,
0.0034544091,
0.0631336272,
0.0059066168,
0.0166443959,
2.009222673e-34,
0.0074615935,
-0.052227851,
0.0231756307,
-0.0088277133,
0.0130811175,
-0.0579508878,
-0.0110164536,
-0.0058262576,
0.0291318949,
0.0010360021,
0.0125920009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12480v1 | Speaker-Adapted End-to-End Visual Speech Recognition for Continuous Spanish | 2023-11-21T09:44:33 | 2023-11-21T09:44:33 | David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Different studies have shown the importance of visual cues throughout the
speech perception process. In fact, the development of audiovisual approaches
has led to advances in the field of speech technologies. However, although
noticeable results have recently been achieved, visual speech recognition
remains an open research problem. It is a task in which, by dispensing with the
auditory sense, challenges such as visual ambiguities and the complexity of
modeling silence must be faced. Nonetheless, some of these challenges can be
alleviated when the problem is approached from a speaker-dependent perspective.
Thus, this paper studies, using the Spanish LIP-RTVE database, how the
estimation of specialized end-to-end systems for a specific person could affect
the quality of speech recognition. First, different adaptation strategies based
on the fine-tuning technique were proposed. Then, a pre-trained CTC/Attention
architecture was used as a baseline throughout our experiments. Our findings
showed that a two-step fine-tuning process, where the VSR system is first
adapted to the task domain, provided significant improvements when the speaker
adaptation was addressed. Furthermore, results comparable to the current state
of the art were reached even when only a limited amount of data was available. | [
0.0166251455,
0.0008636587,
-0.0174921285,
0.0267602205,
0.0072514848,
-0.0335020833,
0.0020957207,
-0.0154039655,
-0.0125002237,
0.0232450068,
-0.0911758542,
-0.0122569436,
0.0510355718,
0.0228377748,
0.0538215078,
-0.0782929584,
-0.0229834262,
-0.0518241413,
0.0112728756,
-0.0101648383,
0.0257960707,
-0.0375937559,
-0.0265914015,
-0.0018345185,
-0.0146063911,
0.0009698212,
0.0094575398,
0.010078161,
0.0397756547,
0.0003348353,
-0.0665098727,
0.0024647156,
-0.0065283002,
-0.0408902504,
0.0000016869,
-0.0085168397,
-0.0260025822,
0.0094130598,
-0.0228033178,
-0.0393991396,
0.0166820046,
-0.0335918255,
-0.0149907051,
0.0205934439,
-0.021466352,
-0.0188400801,
0.0523722842,
-0.0187364388,
0.0380125083,
-0.0000055512,
-0.0257365126,
-0.0077029159,
0.0041900142,
-0.0141030978,
0.0041253259,
-0.0306660198,
0.008727395,
-0.0287659243,
0.0314221829,
-0.0731559545,
-0.0689992085,
0.0716786236,
0.0060706325,
0.0115623651,
0.0647358969,
-0.0153313745,
-0.0831497684,
-0.0309993047,
-0.0396171808,
0.0663537458,
0.0169422626,
0.0044006882,
0.0096067917,
0.0255443528,
-0.0261380859,
-0.0076826867,
0.0002416953,
-0.0103951907,
0.0009420539,
-0.0359865502,
-0.0541535467,
0.0129302191,
-0.0176971033,
-0.0625329092,
-0.0347990543,
-0.0604845472,
-0.0003453182,
-0.0320882238,
0.0474951565,
-0.0094790934,
-0.0051503014,
-0.0064129438,
0.0504496507,
0.03833564,
0.0046488997,
-0.0165334865,
-0.0193090662,
-0.065970324,
-0.0529364757,
-0.0517351255,
0.0181275662,
0.0455179513,
-0.1052259505,
-0.0065560928,
0.0022223864,
0.071896188,
-0.0347716101,
0.0364641584,
0.0056889649,
-0.0379125029,
0.0067324736,
0.0320801139,
-0.0788802058,
-0.0377154797,
-0.026960915,
-0.0178640485,
-0.0208101925,
0.0319046527,
-0.0289782863,
0.0023875793,
0.0113168331,
0.0162315872,
-0.039099548,
-0.0030116893,
-0.0051172706,
0.0633127317,
0.0259123109,
0.0055525298,
-0.026812328,
-0.0865452588,
-0.0087665021,
0.0606858209,
0.0552637875,
0.0215120502,
0.021377774,
0.0568946898,
0.0034546312,
-0.06143656,
0.0038383198,
0.0387901627,
-0.05919699,
-0.054941196,
0.0548599921,
-0.0428189114,
0.0070028012,
0.0169992112,
0.0262592249,
0.0035934392,
-0.0382638313,
-0.0372108817,
0.0036163428,
0.0524724461,
0.0001522859,
0.0056187762,
0.0228260346,
-0.0242494252,
0.0053273505,
0.0363922603,
0.0414308012,
-0.0355640799,
-0.0208349209,
-0.0214108005,
0.0286460854,
0.0737471357,
-0.0239858404,
0.004268643,
-0.0774013773,
0.0021857142,
0.0039016837,
0.0102555584,
0.0530501083,
0.0335648842,
-0.0030419556,
-0.0165361259,
0.0870218873,
-0.0017292041,
0.0410235003,
-0.0167202223,
0.0376929566,
-0.0126954569,
0.0391915105,
0.023752721,
-0.0192478336,
0.0179082621,
-0.0026823683,
0.020920001,
-0.0097449059,
-0.0080865296,
-0.0522049069,
-0.0102452757,
-0.0029255983,
0.0108439093,
-0.0153590869,
0.0335762799,
0.035164319,
0.0081414441,
-0.0183271188,
0.0104048122,
-0.0197362527,
-0.020640254,
0.0087431604,
-0.0161694605,
0.0036207165,
0.0590659529,
0.013718375,
-0.0112362076,
-0.0137736984,
0.0082368869,
0.0102697629,
0.0266991556,
-0.0142621705,
0.0145422127,
0.0594770014,
-0.0641070232,
-0.0139488215,
0.0588454939,
-0.0158659685,
0.0424201488,
-0.0544457883,
0.027613692,
-0.0159793943,
-0.0057726358,
0.0707908496,
-0.0039005319,
-0.0039074314,
-0.0099270782,
-0.0309675355,
0.0488293953,
0.0295563489,
0.0415594727,
-0.0404902548,
-0.0277341381,
0.0206585936,
0.0146627957,
0.0877504498,
0.0461404659,
-0.0306513142,
-0.0061465725,
0.028314421,
-0.0697582588,
-0.0084649073,
0.0505806431,
0.0434241034,
-0.0410269238,
0.0369646437,
-0.0439013876,
0.0402380303,
-0.0440206379,
0.0740543604,
0.0094512468,
0.0366528332,
0.0383829512,
-0.031810306,
-0.0225765705,
-0.0166902225,
0.0362644643,
-0.0074547529,
-0.0157889687,
-0.1369923949,
-0.0196956526,
0.0156057039,
0.0024654549,
0.0162368175,
-0.0275337975,
0.024253821,
-0.016968105,
-0.0243457481,
-0.0741872787,
-0.0298265144,
-0.016922906,
-0.0266251247,
-0.0256785695,
-0.0038401345,
0.0004478256,
-0.0645730719,
-0.0268043391,
0.0179091562,
-0.0032197838,
-0.0264671873,
-0.0361614525,
0.015451232,
-0.0437978059,
-0.0337879881,
0.0007002471,
0.0369330235,
0.0091517884,
-0.0452788249,
-0.1013067216,
-0.0227237251,
0.0036590493,
0.0304469652,
0.0758251846,
-0.0073214206,
-0.0221075285,
-0.0118874572,
0.0362525955,
0.0590603389,
0.0651166439,
0.0047598546,
-0.0077842511,
-0.0026961656,
-0.006541681,
0.0287758354,
0.027280122,
0.0450311005,
-0.0073600719,
-0.0311322752,
0.0290323664,
-0.0442919359,
0.0079052886,
-0.0052820803,
0.0568097681,
-0.0833229795,
-0.0185575206,
0.0001097651,
-0.0492009781,
-0.0056398115,
0.0330036394,
-0.0272679813,
0.0045804284,
-0.0087166345,
-0.0596341118,
0.0138052898,
-0.0763093233,
-0.0667029396,
-0.0065285377,
-0.0231110509,
-0.0117722899,
-0.0146313543,
0.0356432162,
-0.0101081934,
-0.0209099501,
-0.0178835336,
-0.0761192292,
-0.0343936831,
0.0143999597,
-0.0082613723,
0.0457064882,
-0.02060977,
-0.0362837911,
-0.015461769,
0.0021665834,
-0.008337535,
0.0255010314,
-0.0568035021,
-0.0092065707,
0.0204403996,
-0.0044338154,
-0.0182313621,
0.0260824431,
0.0539436005,
0.0524235368,
0.0092592044,
0.0105802771,
-0.0480286516,
0.0372512825,
0.0409553759,
0.0694870353,
-0.0379452892,
-0.0469630286,
-0.0058722217,
-0.0344860815,
0.037654981,
-0.0124472715,
-0.0430148281,
0.0275583025,
0.0591162592,
0.0659623891,
-0.0219892431,
0.0259007085,
0.0380843207,
-0.0347497687,
0.0243867636,
0.0231772512,
-0.0326997042,
-0.0644403398,
-0.0424933955,
0.0024846992,
-0.0099537633,
0.0185184628,
0.0062262695,
-0.0370499715,
-0.0063680662,
0.0219811182,
0.0340110399,
0.0185296237,
0.050703615,
-0.0719716847,
-0.0417730287,
0.0647588074,
0.0069227419,
-0.0467844233,
-0.0206567962,
-0.0241950229,
0.0326647758,
-0.0432436094,
0.0407085344,
0.0226247534,
-0.026672069,
-0.0449913852,
0.0432553999,
-0.03555464,
0.0119556002,
-0.0012998891,
-0.0310001969,
0.0208171755,
0.0229909904,
0.00048542,
0.0171867646,
-0.0457618497,
0.0137831196,
-0.0200989507,
0.0287505277,
-0.0071217571,
0.0817710757,
0.007471533,
-0.0525087155,
0.0432756208,
0.0145036718,
0.0300314017,
0.0281253494,
0.0272412095,
0.0385433435,
-0.0122950329,
0.0252703317,
0.0113721797,
0.0423505343,
-0.0149829071,
0.0176830869,
0.0473013557,
-0.0738261119,
0.0072806505,
0.0557898358,
0.0469297953,
-0.03177239,
-0.0106734522,
-0.0113479821,
-0.0125921993,
-0.060191378,
0.0210778881,
-0.0062888041,
0.0005500399,
0.067001462,
0.0341134705,
0.0013557593,
0.0267211869,
0.0389226153,
0.0025268104,
0.033528246,
-0.0303425025,
0.0250001885,
-0.0642589033,
-0.0236295555,
-0.0429026522,
-0.0805868879,
0.0174316056,
0.0021949401,
-0.040903978,
-0.0390938781,
0.0026254628,
0.0037892906,
0.018483134,
0.1110604927,
-0.0195951499,
-0.0817104727,
0.0550759546,
-0.0264005996,
-0.008965333,
0.0849742666,
0.0729407966,
-0.0187501181,
-0.0322964601,
0.0064948541,
-0.02676972,
0.0108057093,
-0.0005047792,
-0.0089751165,
0.0082865339,
-0.0549893156,
-0.0364266112,
-0.0157097373,
0.0771167651,
0.0046048933,
0.0413640328,
-0.0236110967,
0.0452258177,
0.0082276324,
0.0811609998,
-0.059416566,
-0.0409389511,
-0.0178597495,
0.063586764,
-0.0113516673,
-0.0187915713,
-0.0413141213,
-0.0209632702,
-0.0236849971,
0.0786964372,
-0.0015433183,
-0.0071493192,
0.0064571756,
0.0229987092,
0.019856004,
0.0159253646,
0.0047716699,
0.0069765244,
0.029103091,
0.0127918301,
0.0171803497,
-0.0271873735,
0.0088736229,
0.0635202676,
0.0077743856,
-0.0236026943,
-0.0099222232,
0.0167371109,
0.0091986787,
-0.0203309618,
0.007894705,
0.0446939208,
0.0073983674,
-0.0326530635,
0.0024281847,
-0.0363332704,
0.0059323763,
0.0232791323,
-0.025623396,
-0.010242871,
-0.0024522427,
0.0050029848,
0.0156510957,
-0.0313544795,
-0.0629662052,
0.0381566659,
-0.0403989814,
-0.0077766012,
-0.0282896794,
-0.057631392,
-0.0240333471,
-0.0178806614,
-0.0146527225,
-0.0698580295,
0.0512172766,
-0.0204061139,
0.0347239077,
0.0050277184,
0.0385223441,
-0.0377217159,
-0.0048915991,
-0.0171502773,
0.0379759185,
-0.0744708031,
0.0495271608,
0.0004973903,
0.0466340668,
-5.043623081e-33,
-0.0331963189,
-0.0065502278,
0.0429873131,
0.0056204186,
-0.0129487654,
0.0078429971,
-0.0427899957,
0.0066099889,
-0.001684444,
-0.0228485279,
-0.0072931512,
0.02467102,
0.0325709693,
0.0128647732,
-0.0293788556,
0.0095116617,
0.0782973841,
0.0043720957,
0.0104350159,
-0.0245510358,
0.015689835,
0.02093447,
0.0475454479,
-0.0795459077,
-0.0445173718,
0.0316226594,
0.02588691,
-0.022572061,
0.0473895632,
0.0612526312,
0.0161930341,
0.042555023,
-0.0225826986,
-0.0170628894,
-0.0078054294,
0.0245510135,
-0.0816896632,
-0.0003653452,
-0.004447748,
0.0862071961,
-0.0503596663,
0.0044503435,
0.0451058261,
0.0137036368,
-0.0166370347,
-0.0336801223,
0.0626720637,
-0.0461558849,
-0.0116934841,
0.0062450524,
-0.0141805401,
0.0386497788,
0.0045699431,
-0.0247145798,
0.0622190014,
0.0828546435,
-0.0225873329,
-0.0186340418,
-0.0223870594,
0.0436234176,
0.0104509573,
0.0079643372,
0.0540126748,
0.0568566583,
0.0206107106,
-0.0121689718,
0.0683184266,
-0.0812460259,
0.0440608598,
-0.0675780028,
0.0378522053,
0.0191637333,
0.0353609435,
0.0148831895,
-0.028996205,
-0.023331238,
0.010750887,
-0.0586781688,
-0.0632733926,
0.0175500922,
0.0206801984,
0.0074477699,
-0.0295280553,
0.0358818956,
-0.0233156588,
-0.0347730704,
-0.0391582139,
0.0052157352,
0.055836089,
-0.0130578494,
0.0263473578,
-0.0023121627,
0.0919457823,
-0.0428103805,
0.0578423254,
0.0011823429,
-0.0394524857,
0.0169763565,
0.0351511016,
0.0549279898,
-0.0500848703,
0.0117183095,
0.0695781261,
0.0576040372,
0.0016591265,
-0.0207662471,
0.0049499311,
0.0400550961,
-0.0435745567,
-0.0022760548,
0.021940127,
0.0596391857,
0.0322148353,
0.0605720654,
0.0199117009,
-0.0232781153,
-0.0270335637,
0.0555773526,
-0.002558778,
-0.0267871432,
-0.0173876509,
-0.0031354122,
0.0134320669,
0.0202519707,
-0.0483817905,
0.0423992872,
0.0230163448,
0.0010325792,
0.0036909969,
0.0046008308,
-0.0030901143,
0.0116814971,
2.556e-7,
-0.0346469805,
-0.0158641785,
0.0230381321,
0.017011039,
0.0096980464,
-0.0089990851,
-0.0044988915,
0.0113907158,
-0.0031033903,
-0.0116890064,
-0.0059981234,
0.0175931081,
0.0561807752,
-0.037509162,
-0.0289201923,
-0.0008721629,
0.0004095893,
0.0486042127,
0.0227035414,
0.0531339236,
0.0311443247,
0.0562079772,
-0.0270042922,
-0.0225475077,
-0.0072990265,
-0.0382593051,
0.0348892212,
-0.025695283,
0.0041555674,
-0.0329741128,
0.0386277623,
-0.0100328,
-0.068274945,
0.0256724097,
0.0004381382,
0.0517252497,
0.0126087433,
-0.0012768973,
-0.0461481065,
-0.0454283059,
0.0431362465,
0.0620178469,
-0.0548997633,
-0.0047065639,
0.0452910997,
-0.0238443986,
-0.0181793571,
0.0260522682,
-0.0299050584,
-0.0323765948,
0.0445094109,
-0.0006375182,
0.0033504998,
0.0171284974,
0.035646379,
-0.0188254006,
-0.0604151562,
-0.0309040882,
0.0251277313,
0.0063448427,
-0.0267554037,
-0.0532341078,
-0.027929293,
-0.0129909059,
0.0289220959,
0.0148716914,
-0.0219562408,
1.074702254e-34,
0.0248576123,
-0.0389281102,
0.0199170858,
-0.0684546307,
-0.0287374817,
-0.0598129518,
0.0060880128,
0.0187529046,
0.0338518396,
-0.0487217382,
-0.0324222371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12475v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12475v2 | PhayaThaiBERT: Enhancing a Pretrained Thai Language Model with Unassimilated Loanwords | 2023-11-21T09:37:42 | 2023-12-28T19:22:12 | Panyut Sriwirote, Jalinee Thapiang, Vasan Timtong, Attapol T. Rutherford | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While WangchanBERTa has become the de facto standard in transformer-based
Thai language modeling, it still has shortcomings in regard to the
understanding of foreign words, most notably English words, which are often
borrowed without orthographic assimilation into Thai in many contexts. We
identify the lack of foreign vocabulary in WangchanBERTa's tokenizer as the
main source of these shortcomings. We then expand WangchanBERTa's vocabulary
via vocabulary transfer from XLM-R's pretrained tokenizer and pretrain a new
model using the expanded tokenizer, starting from WangchanBERTa's checkpoint,
on a new dataset that is larger than the one used to train WangchanBERTa. Our
results show that our new pretrained model, PhayaThaiBERT, outperforms
WangchanBERTa in many downstream tasks and datasets. | [
0.0223284457,
0.0642054752,
0.0027409235,
0.031874489,
-0.0191135369,
0.0150134787,
-0.0183530618,
0.0265833996,
-0.0262035076,
-0.0077516618,
-0.0788877606,
-0.0278146081,
0.0186698306,
0.0126384236,
-0.0079070386,
-0.0482336432,
0.0543991178,
-0.0203816928,
-0.0286381207,
0.0152025465,
0.0131058423,
0.0006275145,
0.023803208,
0.0603519566,
-0.0239470582,
-0.0072837067,
0.0279619992,
0.0174367651,
-0.0036907501,
-0.0060085626,
-0.0110674901,
0.0560159236,
-0.0266989358,
0.0190118309,
0.0000019572,
-0.0261121634,
-0.0124176107,
-0.0211815704,
-0.008571839,
0.0250740871,
0.0678788722,
-0.0385697111,
0.0244666021,
0.0570748597,
-0.0191656686,
-0.0352555327,
0.0584941506,
0.0514256693,
0.0346151814,
0.034854915,
-0.0320915096,
-0.0165936481,
0.0174517427,
-0.021681685,
-0.0363136791,
-0.0314481445,
0.0336203501,
-0.0166051574,
-0.0082141841,
-0.0168264396,
-0.0572817661,
0.0537724234,
-0.0129696317,
0.017162988,
0.0488754287,
-0.0071802111,
-0.0154662579,
-0.0414470136,
-0.0069470624,
0.0202203579,
-0.042253945,
-0.0371015556,
-0.0317643173,
0.0168732516,
-0.003312394,
0.032052096,
-0.0188183431,
-0.0062039425,
-0.0128694847,
0.0567291565,
0.0433204509,
-0.0277083088,
0.0012555973,
-0.0043579019,
-0.0597105175,
0.0070451596,
0.0372948945,
-0.0334695503,
-0.0354905091,
-0.0062292148,
0.0203517694,
-0.029845532,
0.0300078038,
0.0140017085,
-0.0342169069,
0.0238094814,
-0.0143064735,
-0.028729951,
0.0112310573,
-0.0118833818,
-0.0003277759,
0.0516115576,
-0.0661403239,
0.0109867472,
-0.0436931327,
0.0616738051,
0.0053518349,
0.0837522671,
-0.0782957897,
-0.0406766795,
-0.0390002988,
-0.0101704197,
-0.0761871636,
0.0208082385,
-0.0289639141,
-0.0102186017,
-0.0506849475,
0.0062266844,
0.0388709828,
-0.0833574533,
0.0538616851,
-0.0427583754,
-0.0681193992,
0.0175626464,
-0.0049741473,
0.0338342078,
0.0294736996,
0.0298801027,
-0.0151639879,
-0.0588731468,
-0.0067435368,
0.0149355046,
0.0158872828,
-0.0356782153,
-0.0054511162,
0.0307196844,
-0.0420113318,
-0.0430694483,
-0.0046952078,
0.0512877852,
-0.0014381418,
-0.0227209851,
-0.0439707972,
-0.0527023152,
0.0356614776,
0.0285343975,
0.0304180179,
-0.0356658474,
0.0018347906,
0.0116930017,
-0.0410180129,
0.0995771959,
-0.0333581902,
0.031296514,
0.0034645577,
-0.0053455317,
-0.0197457969,
0.0465022959,
0.0014219262,
0.0017891491,
0.0415679403,
-0.0245135538,
0.0154443253,
0.073159799,
-0.0049580671,
-0.0078861136,
-0.0110032661,
-0.0293344576,
0.0397160351,
0.001416043,
0.026879834,
0.061032135,
-0.0107093547,
0.067925714,
-0.0027453864,
0.057854332,
0.0311548207,
0.0152921584,
0.0388705805,
-0.0131938607,
-0.0134009123,
0.0376789756,
-0.0204291455,
-0.0280087534,
-0.007869307,
0.0045994101,
-0.0187211055,
0.0615315139,
-0.0386249498,
-0.0186890773,
-0.0148319015,
-0.027520854,
0.0185186751,
-0.0472993776,
0.0713597238,
0.0456192307,
-0.0329598561,
0.1118052974,
0.0613404885,
-0.0429884009,
0.0390906967,
-0.0610875376,
-0.0062695537,
0.0421087518,
0.0145338196,
-0.0350168683,
0.0211009923,
0.0098040681,
0.0300577506,
0.0404098518,
0.0356382802,
0.0104017546,
-0.0014908639,
-0.0650361329,
0.0293538198,
0.0727520883,
0.0255940799,
0.0452391505,
0.0192909092,
0.0523709171,
0.0148507664,
-0.0066221305,
-0.0613716021,
0.0590985045,
-0.0604377873,
0.0054337466,
0.0211121123,
-0.0080343969,
0.0294992905,
0.0067504169,
0.0150567554,
0.0114383204,
0.02979297,
-0.0507237576,
-0.0002987079,
0.06101574,
-0.0325551964,
-0.0196058545,
0.050547678,
0.0107449442,
0.0332682431,
0.0348621756,
-0.0040824404,
-0.0410432667,
0.0176279396,
0.0243104529,
0.0173817202,
-0.0622245222,
0.087880224,
-0.0082198782,
0.0819452181,
-0.0074788206,
0.0208521876,
0.0216780379,
0.0079287495,
0.0074574864,
-0.0087540662,
0.0031076274,
-0.0051961979,
-0.0315850452,
0.0071438504,
-0.0256512705,
0.0132730287,
0.0002010862,
0.0093484176,
-0.0137898782,
-0.0359575599,
-0.0436481982,
0.0109532187,
-0.0281113125,
0.0165513419,
-0.0020639671,
0.0259279925,
-0.0236557461,
-0.0078635719,
-0.0037103663,
-0.006216045,
0.043866042,
0.0159762613,
-0.0133898072,
-0.0127989324,
-0.0011069763,
-0.017170433,
-0.0043999143,
0.0368599929,
0.0257811099,
-0.0009410184,
-0.0909437612,
-0.041461803,
-0.0234832261,
-0.0199448429,
-0.0170670506,
-0.0057725976,
-0.0496686399,
-0.0181673691,
-0.0196021665,
0.0621845275,
-0.0335677601,
-0.0012771767,
-0.0062468811,
-0.0040787552,
-0.0202338528,
-0.0290153492,
-0.0370456614,
-0.0042943517,
-0.0469852611,
-0.040713802,
-0.0313382074,
-0.0045540817,
0.0578035191,
-0.0108829336,
-0.0160226617,
-0.0580784306,
-0.0369693637,
-0.0532493778,
0.0000529644,
-0.0144763617,
-0.0072585363,
-0.0510542989,
0.0096792057,
-0.011104133,
-0.027958421,
0.0464919955,
-0.0411421061,
-0.0075482777,
-0.0826163664,
-0.0099235885,
-0.0422669873,
0.021518236,
-0.0125770196,
-0.0130590973,
-0.0095991101,
-0.0386683568,
-0.0020495527,
0.0079427119,
-0.0374156274,
-0.0486347117,
0.0383590534,
-0.0134221399,
-0.0070540956,
-0.0092938496,
-0.0023697771,
-0.0399597324,
-0.0348002203,
-0.0241251662,
0.0225435812,
0.0489367209,
0.0143126724,
-0.022079736,
0.073025234,
-0.0233864039,
0.0131840007,
-0.0060466509,
0.0340981819,
-0.0176605564,
0.0365263186,
0.0191769786,
0.0176483206,
-0.0091139423,
-0.0270268414,
0.0727112964,
-0.0159147773,
0.0350729302,
-0.0583050624,
0.0166624617,
-0.0160261411,
0.0368417837,
-0.0328337997,
-0.0106948782,
-0.0216745082,
0.0140352333,
0.0138639323,
-0.040898893,
0.0763800517,
0.0423191674,
-0.0322768912,
-0.0096373921,
-0.0675666332,
0.0352727957,
0.0107995467,
0.0004436837,
-0.081348069,
-0.0256406572,
0.0215002466,
-0.013254514,
0.053259518,
-0.0024210764,
-0.0231008641,
-0.1030692831,
0.0135533866,
-0.0062329303,
-0.0845282301,
-0.0300543681,
-0.0162311178,
-0.0101529034,
-0.0477272682,
0.0589311868,
0.0415549204,
-0.0190948453,
-0.0005084719,
0.0466332696,
-0.0217304509,
-0.040681269,
0.0111367032,
-0.0773892552,
0.0256657042,
-0.019931661,
0.0014102187,
-0.0294511095,
-0.0382957272,
0.0604755618,
-0.0232438147,
-0.0104602585,
-0.0035416265,
0.011811085,
0.0153130423,
-0.0342411064,
0.0293743275,
0.003066852,
-0.0440501198,
-0.0370797291,
0.0248678215,
0.0698436722,
0.0422337949,
0.0007529542,
0.0434885062,
-0.0142136179,
-0.0018086241,
0.0441733897,
0.0236464702,
-0.0470732599,
0.0022391083,
0.0040087658,
-0.011015201,
-0.0287013091,
-0.0214819368,
-0.0064679887,
-0.0430666022,
-0.0254688859,
-0.0833461285,
-0.0341340378,
0.0326520316,
0.029958101,
0.0172105525,
0.0381146148,
-0.0482861698,
0.0028585426,
-0.0094542941,
0.0274136681,
-0.0435421653,
0.0167468116,
-0.0491632782,
-0.014793084,
0.0386344641,
-0.0437610373,
-0.007248146,
0.007114552,
-0.0000604319,
-0.0309023056,
0.0373518765,
0.0297870412,
0.0255408213,
0.031151427,
-0.0235511307,
-0.0034803953,
0.0001644018,
0.0420007519,
-0.0473005064,
0.0035773793,
0.0513279401,
-0.0398496687,
-0.0164951868,
0.0502462983,
-0.0035043694,
-0.0049040001,
-0.0141986199,
0.0409625508,
0.0040303343,
-0.0378761068,
0.0177217871,
0.0203341171,
0.0596785434,
-0.0547936708,
-0.0076649603,
-0.0570708998,
0.0128526185,
-0.0342062078,
0.0218733139,
-0.0397619531,
-0.0190262869,
0.0550974272,
-0.0099956989,
-0.0336071365,
-0.0339788273,
-0.0614352748,
-0.0016193721,
0.0280781426,
0.022208849,
0.0164540745,
0.0395930819,
0.0376554392,
0.0187068917,
0.0272117276,
-0.0455708951,
0.0295295436,
0.0116793336,
-0.0490790196,
0.0440526009,
-0.0134106539,
0.0420844965,
0.0080513852,
0.0260263458,
0.0039942097,
-0.032255277,
-0.0161141511,
-0.0042912466,
0.0377631821,
-0.023944078,
0.0549143925,
-0.0090150181,
-0.0188162941,
-0.0082202535,
0.0165398605,
-0.027973095,
-0.0009411788,
0.0140913744,
-0.0194234401,
-0.0402122252,
0.0160641912,
0.0676695853,
-0.0023952085,
0.0261229891,
0.0087609887,
-0.0039102044,
-0.0083127962,
-0.0298705157,
0.0363801643,
-0.0035771136,
-0.0353823863,
-0.0422398001,
-0.034003403,
-0.0772064626,
0.0082201026,
0.000305637,
-0.0207308959,
0.023963144,
-0.007281601,
0.024047656,
0.0013564024,
0.0460558049,
-0.0371766351,
-0.0123080844,
0.0159687046,
0.0037716425,
0.0444445014,
-6.042094962e-33,
-0.0479042009,
0.015023794,
0.0060594631,
0.0094295731,
-0.0116425361,
0.0006934821,
-0.0109969014,
0.0036710675,
0.0013940723,
-0.0146292113,
-0.0515989959,
-0.0006986804,
0.0415152088,
0.0223196279,
0.0193769317,
0.0009748928,
0.0264910255,
0.032369826,
0.0029759451,
-0.0003369648,
0.0234585386,
0.063836962,
0.0878026336,
-0.0113868602,
-0.0139933946,
0.0130116343,
-0.0049113431,
0.0057117017,
0.0097267274,
0.0464677103,
-0.0539934933,
0.0678806677,
0.0020023817,
-0.0667082593,
-0.0435166247,
-0.0047529023,
-0.109513998,
0.0150494026,
0.0583003275,
0.0541757867,
0.0233113933,
-0.0171838515,
0.0109504443,
-0.0337080248,
-0.0124231949,
0.0111465389,
0.0128328325,
-0.0532444827,
-0.0132405953,
0.0422259495,
-0.0804468319,
0.025386326,
0.0282766409,
0.0027877945,
0.0458789952,
0.0087909447,
-0.0196430478,
-0.0171737,
-0.0642280132,
-0.0019026748,
0.0561391562,
0.0302313641,
0.0481280275,
0.035448242,
-0.0385848768,
0.0062739383,
0.0862093642,
-0.084637627,
0.0329905078,
-0.0157340597,
0.043686036,
0.0151296947,
0.0729412213,
0.0075566703,
0.0370052829,
-0.0766368508,
-0.0218692608,
0.0115292259,
-0.0300861672,
0.0429092199,
0.0349357724,
0.0301285591,
-0.0085371993,
-0.0462605469,
-0.0179782491,
-0.0273314789,
-0.0451822653,
-0.0345688947,
0.0474918969,
0.0286058802,
-0.0322364457,
-0.0095925052,
0.0722389072,
-0.0497647263,
-0.0238558538,
0.0332078449,
-0.018313067,
-0.0130831804,
-0.0763602182,
0.0103509147,
-0.0455401428,
-0.0603646524,
0.0002719982,
0.0155063104,
-0.0022585131,
-0.0143868057,
0.0301513374,
0.0042077084,
-0.0674572736,
0.0294324271,
-0.0204644483,
0.0396123193,
-0.0050378665,
0.0863294899,
0.0411026962,
0.0198485143,
-0.0086561376,
0.0173366163,
0.0430231839,
-0.0176997911,
-0.0477335677,
0.0239522923,
0.0185568966,
-0.005357476,
-0.0331256762,
0.0297799371,
-0.0278866049,
0.0530937575,
0.0178562533,
-0.0278652143,
0.0029704366,
0.0483804643,
2.653e-7,
0.047627084,
0.0395582393,
0.0532879755,
-0.0742570236,
-0.0135873416,
-0.0260673072,
-0.0587143525,
-0.0148021234,
0.0262335613,
0.018603351,
0.0284924507,
0.0218027104,
0.0701066405,
0.0273178872,
-0.0971388891,
-0.0340799466,
-0.0829068646,
0.0130340513,
-0.0454268642,
-0.0144115929,
0.0068788035,
0.130398199,
-0.026325766,
-0.0351937898,
-0.0432156213,
-0.024740437,
0.0196072385,
-0.0204172116,
-0.0172956865,
0.0326437578,
0.05983527,
-0.0019945377,
0.0220905598,
0.007302531,
-0.0411065146,
0.0422510728,
0.0570460521,
0.0481168404,
0.0017056515,
-0.0018978717,
0.0059191203,
0.0304199252,
-0.0412751213,
-0.0830765516,
0.0445926487,
-0.0127822226,
0.010685781,
-0.0060184179,
-0.0432609469,
0.0421347059,
0.0054805465,
-0.0065826164,
-0.0300309267,
0.0649228618,
0.0602357537,
0.034273386,
-0.0736937672,
-0.0259952396,
-0.0430653356,
-0.0089155305,
-0.0431568921,
-0.0115656508,
-0.0150950383,
0.0363525935,
-0.0033723023,
-0.0316079818,
0.0402658097,
2.206850135e-34,
0.0488866754,
0.0028220194,
0.0209226105,
0.0378388315,
0.0264441278,
-0.0451904237,
0.0642877743,
0.0772339627,
-0.043750342,
-0.0893062279,
0.0010196981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12474v1 | CSMeD: Bridging the Dataset Gap in Automated Citation Screening for Systematic Literature Reviews | 2023-11-21T09:36:11 | 2023-11-21T09:36:11 | Wojciech Kusa, Oscar E. Mendoza, Matthias Samwald, Petr Knoth, Allan Hanbury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Systematic literature reviews (SLRs) play an essential role in summarising,
synthesising and validating scientific evidence. In recent years, there has
been a growing interest in using machine learning techniques to automate the
identification of relevant studies for SLRs. However, the lack of standardised
evaluation datasets makes comparing the performance of such automated
literature screening systems difficult. In this paper, we analyse the citation
screening evaluation datasets, revealing that many of the available datasets
are either too small, suffer from data leakage or have limited applicability to
systems treating automated literature screening as a classification task, as
opposed to, for example, a retrieval or question-answering task. To address
these challenges, we introduce CSMeD, a meta-dataset consolidating nine
publicly released collections, providing unified access to 325 SLRs from the
fields of medicine and computer science. CSMeD serves as a comprehensive
resource for training and evaluating the performance of automated citation
screening models. Additionally, we introduce CSMeD-FT, a new dataset designed
explicitly for evaluating the full text publication screening task. To
demonstrate the utility of CSMeD, we conduct experiments and establish
baselines on new datasets. | [
0.0326469317,
-0.0182304941,
-0.0187039673,
-0.056750387,
0.0036973958,
0.0192140695,
0.060806267,
0.0225060098,
0.0027128679,
-0.0412210114,
-0.0058121844,
0.0175745375,
0.0273884647,
0.0336021669,
0.0150862401,
0.0107866293,
0.0113688642,
0.0408352055,
0.0488283969,
0.0085697211,
-0.0618460737,
0.0019006191,
-0.0108480779,
0.0564560331,
0.1110042334,
-0.0244296882,
0.035885822,
-0.0202554315,
0.0411366597,
-0.0729698986,
0.021275755,
0.0078786239,
-0.0058917613,
0.0275962763,
0.0000019896,
-0.0428738035,
-0.0046146587,
0.0170783568,
0.0112862037,
0.0163607653,
0.0849714503,
-0.0301390812,
0.051452931,
0.0137580121,
-0.0223547276,
-0.0296034086,
0.0274205636,
0.0165570863,
-0.0178031605,
-0.0108736102,
-0.0067043318,
0.0269651562,
0.0117702791,
-0.0316482708,
0.0165005587,
0.0174545553,
0.0638803914,
0.0168689471,
0.0231405199,
0.0290872175,
0.0363002867,
0.0078507755,
-0.0529629551,
-0.017222546,
0.072478883,
0.0222101044,
-0.0460436642,
-0.0199227873,
0.0056192968,
0.034456946,
0.0245808717,
-0.0462293811,
0.0558854863,
-0.0323704705,
-0.0078918077,
0.053176336,
-0.0233421065,
-0.0136189265,
-0.0082649449,
-0.0356095619,
0.0024730046,
0.0179564487,
0.0516088344,
0.0173570346,
0.0351996571,
-0.0082555888,
-0.0088846395,
-0.0407141522,
0.057194192,
0.0132456161,
0.0590836145,
-0.0219622385,
-0.0120210387,
-0.0103647346,
-0.0032916937,
-0.0495335422,
0.0411419794,
-0.0008511584,
0.1085728481,
0.0033609741,
0.0510087125,
-0.0662016794,
0.0049319407,
0.0387369171,
-0.0046587205,
-0.0497774892,
-0.0178305879,
0.0016308477,
0.0221345611,
0.0360060185,
-0.0555543154,
0.0089325821,
0.0510900207,
0.015485228,
0.0059515536,
0.0181507338,
-0.0922165886,
-0.0095545696,
-0.0366649888,
-0.0042014397,
0.0071198824,
0.0301823523,
-0.0042242608,
0.0395194814,
-0.026766615,
0.0104028936,
0.0029677828,
0.077232115,
-0.0685070902,
0.0204465501,
0.0091243088,
-0.0101453345,
0.0268833004,
0.0031232187,
0.0478229076,
0.0144049115,
0.0251792762,
-0.0599269979,
-0.0011515184,
-0.0079880161,
-0.0082321744,
-0.0402438827,
0.0576597154,
-0.0461758524,
0.0191222616,
0.0017659029,
0.0310943387,
0.0072170948,
-0.0270329919,
0.0178970601,
-0.002067571,
0.0236675125,
-0.082523115,
-0.0235446524,
0.0122028179,
-0.015762018,
0.008946565,
0.0181038938,
-0.013604356,
-0.0100730062,
0.0173825603,
-0.0100095943,
0.0055463361,
-0.0254605804,
0.004739271,
0.0137181636,
0.0586821064,
0.0071244063,
-0.0288285278,
0.0451772027,
-0.0425102711,
-0.0110654915,
-0.0446094684,
-0.0083938967,
-0.007730206,
0.0423933715,
0.0128863771,
0.0209794398,
0.0259464551,
-0.0081502059,
0.0325335599,
-0.0304635372,
0.0215609819,
0.011994266,
-0.0014129259,
-0.0047749053,
0.0094679035,
0.01993539,
-0.0087688938,
-0.0423428193,
-0.0247668047,
0.0163919274,
-0.0429473408,
0.0059651844,
0.0658000857,
0.0153001258,
-0.0007783374,
-0.0127007859,
0.0317271836,
0.0121984817,
0.0011167333,
0.0151287364,
0.0130533995,
-0.0142527316,
0.0768256709,
-0.0623456389,
0.0138874548,
-0.0490071326,
-0.0130328787,
-0.0122039532,
-0.0206814483,
-0.0159739479,
0.0324438997,
-0.0260776766,
-0.034429349,
-0.0001628135,
0.0191525985,
-0.0168033578,
0.0039056749,
0.0178355165,
-0.02675087,
-0.0691109374,
-0.0645201653,
0.0489841178,
-0.0331701525,
-0.0184106361,
0.0294411629,
-0.0588359907,
0.048668731,
0.0078016571,
-0.0307155438,
0.0063176793,
0.0600986443,
-0.0227915235,
-0.00824821,
-0.0112533132,
0.033443965,
0.0289535988,
0.0049678255,
-0.0847845823,
-0.005739816,
0.0330674015,
-0.0518861227,
-0.0036342302,
0.0149050513,
0.0231535938,
-0.0329223834,
0.0162053686,
-0.0123856068,
-0.0296090357,
-0.0128062423,
-0.0104965903,
0.0343566723,
0.009267522,
0.0420110002,
0.0537187792,
-0.0864959657,
0.0303256381,
0.0010636039,
-0.0321615338,
-0.0038964995,
-0.0446337983,
-0.0125768175,
0.0237077568,
0.0021131325,
-0.0081760827,
0.0022296228,
-0.05180154,
-0.0065193847,
0.0422852263,
-0.0105855279,
0.0040475731,
-0.0330834426,
0.0231998563,
0.011763623,
0.0102855191,
-0.0205434244,
-0.0157579221,
-0.0026998667,
0.0651820526,
0.000114123,
0.0254846029,
-0.0707130656,
-0.0386371613,
-0.0370476246,
0.065976806,
0.0485051721,
0.04723664,
0.0017738424,
-0.0102302646,
-0.0005899894,
-0.0266830269,
-0.0321897119,
0.0325382538,
0.0010186378,
0.0310170501,
-0.0794194043,
0.0634995624,
0.0002406457,
-0.0058224942,
0.0847291499,
0.0458606891,
-0.023781281,
-0.0111275231,
-0.0254293382,
-0.0078335423,
0.0058815838,
-0.0574511364,
0.0519583821,
-0.0001580494,
-0.0039244867,
0.0158165842,
-0.0077058482,
-0.0176759306,
0.0031919754,
-0.0049022371,
-0.0588555112,
-0.0124687431,
-0.0216100849,
0.0575241223,
0.0078000161,
-0.0369320065,
0.079901278,
-0.0125579145,
0.0122547429,
-0.0633484051,
0.0214999057,
-0.0556057692,
-0.0204515718,
0.0146017345,
-0.0213564243,
0.0305086803,
0.0405385084,
0.0036096282,
-0.0291420482,
0.038325198,
-0.0242404956,
-0.0067613274,
-0.0119733969,
0.015122667,
-0.0091789318,
-0.0096467463,
-0.0116334297,
-0.0177995637,
-0.0439389646,
0.0065448531,
0.0243698303,
-0.0137873832,
-0.0669303238,
0.0041161031,
0.032444559,
0.0441620052,
-0.019745836,
-0.0339946002,
-0.0067740367,
-0.0120894937,
0.0598175079,
-0.0839426219,
0.0141762542,
0.0077360473,
0.0116443848,
0.0224097222,
0.0057720644,
0.0231167432,
-0.0604750142,
-0.0117503563,
-0.0045544943,
-0.0803537294,
0.0232802331,
-0.0030733219,
-0.0218619015,
0.005253098,
0.0285604931,
0.0574515983,
0.0053158416,
-0.1119573191,
-0.0228560548,
-0.0321917385,
-0.0285787843,
0.0092129651,
-0.0131667405,
-0.0706380978,
-0.0104281465,
-0.0074671879,
0.0553742722,
-0.0311618578,
-0.0293006543,
0.0361741632,
-0.0363802873,
0.0541543812,
-0.0133211324,
0.0082474751,
-0.0384329706,
-0.067013137,
0.0179152228,
-0.0627123639,
-0.0602858737,
-0.0207006093,
-0.0699274987,
-0.003366499,
-0.0068017482,
-0.0547803715,
-0.0723939613,
0.0563883111,
-0.0313500278,
0.0194489881,
-0.0005295133,
0.0289896391,
-0.0086029815,
-0.0039434051,
0.012784929,
-0.0715216994,
-0.028492583,
-0.0142334616,
0.0958972052,
0.0253565144,
0.0371491611,
-0.0069994349,
0.0402436294,
-0.0379296802,
-0.0175114945,
0.0803766772,
0.0708322376,
-0.0295890905,
-0.0239539687,
-0.0722628236,
0.0435419083,
-0.0224616006,
0.0510695651,
0.0222315621,
-0.0007069469,
-0.0049581975,
0.0415302776,
0.0212721117,
0.0039405301,
-0.0252057277,
0.0203825235,
-0.0287025627,
-0.013545597,
-0.0403801799,
-0.0172688812,
0.0187647454,
-0.0218961928,
0.0270365346,
0.0420717224,
0.0206630919,
-0.0089053605,
-0.0486710481,
0.0335184932,
0.0196188353,
-0.0018717586,
0.0019273668,
0.0123358127,
0.0772831216,
-0.027531093,
-0.0112590734,
0.0223543979,
0.0411402434,
0.0074510304,
-0.0350189954,
0.0336737111,
0.0192898829,
0.022077458,
-0.0152469529,
-0.0313807875,
0.0736288428,
0.0290740915,
0.0054970048,
-0.0473712757,
0.0042236857,
-0.0461789966,
-0.0244199317,
-0.0543615259,
-0.0621079244,
0.0269918721,
-0.0356163532,
-0.0656240061,
-0.026666617,
0.0011302589,
0.023156656,
0.0083015217,
0.0741293877,
-0.0561650619,
-0.0085829804,
-0.0067845718,
-0.0070399763,
0.0273856614,
0.0078454632,
-0.0081725866,
0.0386861749,
0.0143047217,
0.0125468401,
-0.0303724241,
0.0413514152,
-0.0565369874,
0.0431667306,
-0.0437246449,
0.0678121373,
0.0083075697,
0.0871747509,
0.0199260451,
-0.0258581433,
-0.037007492,
-0.0553809553,
-0.0374524258,
-0.0067628617,
0.0120061589,
0.0097478339,
0.0050558015,
0.0282313358,
-0.0332076438,
0.017462451,
-0.0879129916,
0.0118923867,
0.0007615376,
-0.0549304038,
0.040047273,
-0.0166539401,
0.040258687,
-0.0256879758,
-0.0284531899,
-0.0501535125,
0.0287095644,
-0.0315070301,
0.0539941303,
0.0156087289,
0.0129742604,
-0.0340685062,
-0.0138775427,
0.0556545481,
0.0339134336,
0.0028512615,
0.0162943583,
-0.0596009195,
-0.0176011547,
-0.0470868498,
-0.0489899516,
0.0464786328,
-0.0044253827,
-0.0450561829,
-0.054267589,
-0.0004565471,
0.0354513861,
-0.0208871793,
0.0076160356,
-0.0192965791,
-0.0273946561,
0.0302139241,
0.0314788185,
-0.0249351524,
-0.0524602719,
0.020361051,
-0.0363269746,
-0.0205056351,
-0.0389795378,
-5.760753614e-33,
0.0600968562,
-0.0119617414,
-0.0180391781,
-0.0147883911,
0.0084384819,
0.0274829697,
-0.0209692921,
-0.0436523221,
-0.0138810603,
0.064237535,
-0.0308017749,
0.0074395845,
-0.0082432926,
-0.0010780408,
0.0715269744,
0.0406789482,
0.0437951684,
-0.0117344027,
-0.0190792494,
0.049929373,
-0.0297944751,
-0.0117663462,
0.0011344978,
-0.0558787361,
0.0266619045,
0.0349447876,
0.0012186611,
-0.0266367625,
0.0045009353,
0.0857451186,
-0.0312073026,
0.0436165705,
0.0242863558,
-0.0143626006,
0.0188330635,
-0.0014279117,
-0.1018515676,
0.0037377947,
0.0050272928,
-0.0566914789,
-0.0306748766,
-0.0058000763,
0.0301677249,
0.0079035619,
-0.0502106175,
-0.0444775634,
0.095061712,
-0.0394444615,
-0.0561888143,
-0.1114575639,
-0.0165894106,
0.0240632258,
-0.0233910792,
0.0411859713,
-0.0179816857,
0.092303969,
-0.0144990776,
0.0927981883,
-0.011296642,
0.0361437462,
0.0062196441,
-0.0040980666,
-0.0304175597,
-0.0205390155,
0.0008290039,
0.0545350946,
-0.0427505001,
0.0040507368,
0.0263395216,
-0.022419218,
-0.0075864629,
0.0071047512,
0.0333709046,
0.0730018243,
0.031175809,
-0.0025167358,
-0.0845727473,
0.044391185,
-0.0252353773,
0.0541383959,
0.054497201,
-0.0340276174,
0.0262432657,
-0.0085921325,
-0.0215604752,
-0.0531005003,
-0.0033975234,
0.0130493026,
-0.0059029018,
0.0079211127,
-0.0280485675,
0.0030137287,
0.0068137995,
-0.0171028171,
0.0019577316,
0.0708795711,
-0.0045476542,
0.020785166,
0.0359950401,
-0.0304579176,
-0.051217597,
-0.015977148,
0.0095399683,
0.0247860663,
0.0676587746,
-0.039025683,
0.0139759649,
-0.0272831731,
-0.0357451923,
-0.0173538886,
0.0116759269,
0.0074968389,
-0.0175595228,
0.0163962264,
-0.0150206676,
0.0262225196,
0.0212288238,
0.0226692278,
0.0093984781,
0.0302787889,
0.0138859795,
-0.0025437572,
-0.0165755842,
0.0233470406,
0.0110577326,
0.0004558628,
-0.0305185337,
0.038871251,
0.0505459607,
-0.0321078822,
0.0196426585,
-0.0280949865,
2.789e-7,
0.0643931329,
0.0301902667,
-0.0437491424,
-0.0510002933,
0.0380584113,
0.0331599489,
0.0153989913,
0.0056517851,
0.0291087348,
0.04219421,
0.0635345504,
-0.0385426357,
0.0178457499,
0.0055619827,
-0.0625264645,
-0.0430698395,
-0.0789460242,
-0.0212492514,
-0.0358080678,
-0.0295741428,
-0.0397449285,
0.0121148499,
-0.0103437025,
0.0070539149,
-0.0208795406,
-0.0366675705,
0.0157473013,
-0.0689501688,
0.0449846722,
0.0352224335,
0.0373220071,
-0.0087890783,
0.0080527011,
0.0356797613,
-0.039850004,
0.0118955187,
-0.0489146039,
0.0014652271,
0.0186267383,
0.0086483508,
0.0513214432,
0.0108204754,
0.0525185987,
-0.0405617841,
0.0439003222,
-0.0601199009,
-0.0248048436,
-0.0409569927,
-0.0554794297,
0.0089792684,
0.0880465135,
-0.0061108009,
0.0138384718,
0.0568829551,
-0.0452714488,
0.0113544548,
-0.0274705831,
-0.0439075567,
0.0171042178,
0.0877140909,
-0.0370077044,
-0.0174167063,
0.0236697793,
-0.0649441779,
0.0037642648,
-0.0708428472,
0.0477317572,
2.262986649e-34,
0.0609007925,
-0.0296853706,
0.0055056587,
-0.020333739,
0.0053834715,
-0.0048492602,
-0.0483644344,
0.0178473536,
0.016296275,
-0.0402993113,
0.0406894647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12468v1 | Analysis of Visual Features for Continuous Lipreading in Spanish | 2023-11-21T09:28:00 | 2023-11-21T09:28:00 | David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | During a conversation, our brain is responsible for combining information
obtained from multiple senses in order to improve our ability to understand the
message we are perceiving. Different studies have shown the importance of
presenting visual information in these situations. Nevertheless, lipreading is
a complex task whose objective is to interpret speech when audio is not
available. By dispensing with a sense as crucial as hearing, it will be
necessary to be aware of the challenge that this lack presents. In this paper,
we propose an analysis of different speech visual features with the intention
of identifying which of them is the best approach to capture the nature of lip
movements for natural Spanish and, in this way, dealing with the automatic
visual speech recognition task. In order to estimate our system, we present an
audiovisual corpus compiled from a subset of the RTVE database, which has been
used in the Albayz\'in evaluations. We employ a traditional system based on
Hidden Markov Models with Gaussian Mixture Models. Results show that, although
the task is difficult, in restricted conditions we obtain recognition results
which determine that using eigenlips in combination with deep features is the
best visual approach. | [
-0.0109041641,
-0.022402456,
-0.007764854,
0.0263205506,
0.0082705356,
0.0228613056,
-0.0053932662,
0.0084364358,
-0.0097433757,
-0.007168836,
-0.0465907268,
0.0050902339,
0.0656989515,
0.0268653762,
0.019999953,
-0.1012436077,
-0.0672073215,
-0.0616356805,
-0.0166618396,
-0.0343558118,
0.0322634429,
-0.0075636362,
-0.0881793201,
0.0406694114,
-0.065299429,
0.0240820311,
-0.0224029142,
-0.001179698,
0.0505002402,
0.0232104789,
-0.1048034206,
0.0187697448,
-0.015203814,
-0.0369364582,
0.0000016036,
-0.0233643893,
-0.0054486049,
0.0131116072,
-0.0134062497,
-0.0263288002,
0.0184222404,
-0.0584113076,
-0.0153272999,
-0.0002473902,
-0.0413742997,
-0.0260686278,
0.0504380725,
-0.0170925874,
0.0265428703,
0.0105221178,
-0.0231244341,
-0.0376215838,
0.0302400794,
-0.0050143972,
0.0594697259,
-0.0400587618,
0.0132114291,
0.0061788308,
0.0036564411,
-0.0498649739,
-0.0592992604,
0.0846677125,
-0.0357168131,
-0.02783335,
0.036700137,
0.0094565311,
-0.0802412555,
-0.0654740408,
-0.0150821414,
0.0655301958,
0.0071432414,
0.0239215381,
0.007971826,
0.0276911445,
-0.0261914693,
0.0555657856,
-0.0092659229,
0.0154637638,
0.0103034712,
-0.0075826892,
-0.0302659534,
0.0181290992,
0.0196705554,
-0.0593645871,
-0.0066642063,
-0.0047051935,
0.016474694,
0.0012870595,
0.0605180785,
-0.0165676195,
0.0450617671,
-0.016084861,
0.0218528379,
0.0039471406,
0.0757970884,
-0.0183176529,
0.0249326732,
-0.0406560339,
-0.0364685804,
-0.0391216911,
0.0110323848,
0.0328484625,
-0.0870759562,
0.0332595073,
-0.00799785,
0.035168048,
-0.0471534096,
0.0104288403,
0.016006507,
-0.0146571063,
-0.0115950517,
0.0096599022,
-0.0374686308,
-0.0100652566,
-0.0096156793,
-0.0063484106,
-0.0319958106,
0.0004743726,
-0.0189734083,
0.0054465327,
-0.0003767796,
0.0129944077,
0.0180714373,
0.0054766517,
-0.0365449227,
0.0456686132,
0.0067391032,
0.0119655989,
-0.0363777764,
-0.092338264,
0.0470742434,
0.0463626795,
0.0191256106,
0.0110276099,
0.0498419218,
0.0784319639,
0.0146451974,
-0.0631373376,
0.0242323261,
0.0438415855,
-0.0667199343,
-0.026791703,
0.041297473,
-0.0592140816,
0.013513986,
-0.0227162894,
0.0308041517,
0.0480860993,
-0.005566692,
-0.0514098816,
0.0251502208,
0.0527491681,
0.043750979,
-0.0024432051,
0.0397184975,
-0.0096852416,
-0.0184112079,
0.0271257926,
0.0297603626,
-0.0332313739,
-0.0120361466,
-0.0126117421,
0.0594110824,
0.0443846993,
-0.058166489,
0.0177273862,
-0.0554844923,
-0.031171361,
-0.0012404416,
0.0052578077,
0.0643848926,
0.0286510419,
-0.0148626696,
-0.0282810275,
0.0421067812,
0.0647821501,
-0.0125095882,
-0.0464522317,
0.0214869846,
-0.0279340614,
0.0698140115,
0.0093459059,
0.0342162177,
0.0113238851,
-0.0015906474,
-0.0165449344,
-0.0006768063,
-0.0071607423,
-0.059562441,
-0.0083799046,
0.0113605298,
-0.0094152605,
-0.035994228,
0.0364202447,
0.0475192219,
-0.0658836588,
-0.0201784261,
-0.0212837495,
-0.038635809,
0.0090366695,
-0.0224510469,
-0.053217236,
0.0244927648,
0.0210527424,
-0.0187261328,
-0.0253779851,
0.0023079435,
-0.004072166,
-0.0195346065,
-0.0137170134,
-0.0170544572,
-0.0023058848,
0.0682304054,
-0.0388367698,
-0.0172024313,
0.0461543016,
0.0399900079,
0.0422157533,
-0.0880344957,
0.0410420485,
-0.0088310363,
0.0055029406,
0.0609695874,
-0.0017778566,
0.0200165734,
0.0221519656,
-0.0300901625,
0.0534653515,
0.0257567614,
0.0422645584,
-0.0254864432,
-0.0081109637,
0.0308693107,
0.001781853,
0.1045568958,
0.0720808133,
-0.005235326,
-0.0156506263,
0.0536024272,
-0.1162054911,
-0.014937466,
-0.0105647808,
0.0348332077,
-0.0526389889,
0.0139801819,
-0.0605639331,
0.0494447537,
-0.0481999144,
0.0488199256,
-0.0111736096,
0.0078255106,
0.00369006,
-0.0369366072,
-0.0080835093,
0.0080585135,
0.0075587966,
-0.0368199237,
0.019434832,
-0.1134759933,
-0.0238310639,
0.0549682006,
-0.0176868159,
-0.0081715193,
-0.0230416898,
-0.0072591514,
-0.0059410725,
-0.02550737,
-0.0740779787,
-0.0313179009,
-0.0083436603,
-0.0507399514,
-0.0104753692,
-0.0295716431,
-0.0101505704,
-0.0283399522,
-0.0153528191,
-0.0016651689,
-0.0078250282,
-0.0458055511,
-0.0339370854,
0.0318988301,
-0.0386566892,
-0.03362168,
0.0002604249,
0.0091110785,
0.0076904385,
0.0190186929,
-0.0524478592,
0.0148949586,
-0.0429849438,
0.0289798714,
0.0411487333,
-0.0008190509,
-0.0163056925,
0.0025036337,
0.0055253888,
0.0716750473,
0.057044208,
0.0020955144,
0.0476122499,
0.0159798581,
-0.0136036407,
-0.0021845857,
-0.0064155618,
0.0155589497,
0.0386886597,
-0.0706933513,
-0.0186624192,
-0.0518540442,
-0.0224684067,
0.0375687554,
0.0384016894,
-0.0410135649,
-0.0382312797,
-0.0029644691,
-0.0753558874,
-0.0122845611,
0.0248065051,
-0.0384379327,
0.0247609019,
0.0140606444,
-0.0489308238,
0.0066889059,
-0.0808037072,
-0.0515031964,
0.0082276948,
-0.0501719303,
-0.0045693973,
-0.0000505176,
0.014207215,
-0.0221366249,
-0.0501665659,
-0.0495937765,
-0.0226125419,
-0.0048423754,
0.0261455439,
-0.0383660309,
0.0344852693,
-0.0352837294,
-0.0042076912,
0.0016518843,
0.056190297,
-0.0322127976,
0.0443901084,
-0.0687091872,
-0.0279294513,
0.0114508253,
-0.0079395771,
-0.0420926772,
0.0414699912,
0.0582971685,
0.033308465,
0.0237654075,
0.0216969792,
-0.0197495501,
0.0505802184,
0.0309818871,
0.0011270329,
-0.0560560487,
-0.0767629594,
0.0014842047,
-0.0445700884,
-0.0010440829,
0.0112950383,
-0.0527670905,
0.0372960754,
0.0282158609,
0.0426086411,
-0.0266314633,
0.0075875325,
-0.010037045,
-0.0069726915,
0.0599879995,
0.0566981062,
0.0028993899,
-0.0764903575,
-0.0456269383,
0.0445106067,
-0.0134340571,
0.0064248717,
0.019434819,
-0.0493138507,
-0.0043401136,
0.0453423299,
0.0086054374,
0.0319390707,
0.0347969718,
-0.0066902312,
-0.0230722688,
0.057917852,
0.0088328021,
-0.0383433811,
-0.0612627901,
-0.0329521075,
0.0144655108,
-0.0500054471,
-0.0086737014,
-0.0121069988,
-0.0094494242,
-0.0184269547,
0.0636700243,
-0.025013335,
-0.0156162288,
0.0234217774,
-0.0192517545,
-0.0124039063,
0.0268675126,
0.0231796876,
-0.0127832005,
-0.056045182,
-0.0156740192,
0.0079017421,
0.001999947,
0.0107426839,
0.0431215018,
0.0250567999,
-0.0395045765,
0.0214816052,
0.0229145437,
0.0394772664,
0.0344726369,
-0.0207617953,
0.0536382124,
-0.0634533912,
0.0000109838,
-0.0056866612,
0.0049091228,
-0.0258044582,
0.0177166443,
0.0248489026,
-0.0441098474,
0.0163072869,
0.0619437024,
0.0474944673,
0.0023078157,
-0.0220046137,
0.0076004621,
0.0303315837,
-0.0596504547,
-0.0039912392,
0.013859584,
0.0305950418,
0.0666388273,
0.0342027023,
-0.0062115761,
0.0463013686,
0.0273349565,
-0.0120182661,
0.0516315885,
0.0098715862,
0.0289664771,
-0.0504523963,
-0.0433613174,
-0.0260609742,
-0.0266585201,
-0.0019397939,
-0.011075465,
-0.0913148671,
-0.0270425864,
-0.0160438623,
0.0177518371,
0.0275873914,
0.0413369797,
-0.0230966415,
-0.0580935925,
0.0230229106,
-0.0290300772,
0.0273324531,
0.03566451,
0.002788306,
-0.0223637652,
-0.0154358335,
-0.0219487976,
0.0133133437,
-0.0450950414,
-0.0429124236,
-0.0405326709,
-0.0022920032,
-0.0727512315,
-0.0407546051,
-0.01208439,
0.051858969,
-0.014461712,
-0.0026221543,
-0.056088116,
-0.0074338294,
0.0248762146,
0.0716489851,
-0.0366470627,
0.0222256556,
0.0341461189,
0.0550216623,
-0.0169291738,
-0.0318560526,
-0.0002429724,
-0.0414893329,
0.0076798494,
0.0742074326,
0.0185654033,
-0.0210046452,
-0.0069980323,
0.053632088,
0.0301289242,
0.0360178798,
-0.0095656486,
-0.0014632209,
0.0588641353,
-0.0173613019,
0.0039061927,
-0.0567415394,
0.0395416468,
0.034829516,
0.0299528893,
-0.0131902294,
0.003483837,
0.0549003147,
0.0826598331,
-0.0582965948,
-0.003770642,
0.0211204998,
0.0089319739,
-0.0354197063,
0.058840394,
-0.0122915395,
0.0029128788,
0.0525399111,
-0.0008603603,
-0.0172816366,
0.0033635169,
0.0162844174,
-0.008765351,
-0.0287738871,
-0.0151075162,
0.0460170321,
-0.0455130078,
0.0403703451,
0.0271280818,
-0.0312561877,
-0.069352448,
0.0155147826,
-0.0180508606,
-0.085650593,
0.0469262041,
-0.0162894391,
0.0267066304,
0.0586700551,
0.0495705605,
-0.0357363001,
-0.0189852733,
0.0296385922,
-0.01646135,
-0.0437520966,
-0.0005378834,
0.0138802715,
0.0122068524,
-4.968571808e-33,
0.0254400391,
-0.0612304583,
0.0042920858,
0.0267859045,
-0.0276298784,
-0.0090536438,
-0.0058708177,
0.0251558367,
0.0052687665,
0.0276899226,
0.0309783313,
0.0220510736,
0.0216003805,
-0.0139182825,
-0.0105887093,
-0.0170962308,
0.0077319806,
-0.0175873972,
0.0178535879,
-0.0192479733,
0.0196477361,
0.034952011,
0.0382015929,
-0.0958569646,
-0.0408634432,
0.0613466837,
0.0080450121,
-0.003701142,
0.0389710106,
0.0368241109,
-0.0261381827,
0.0063322419,
-0.0208324026,
0.0178690553,
0.0245524384,
0.0172199942,
-0.0192794446,
0.0065719993,
0.0003928872,
0.1088568568,
-0.0439794511,
0.0153994374,
0.0200466514,
0.0140193198,
0.0205208957,
-0.0060347454,
0.0863584504,
-0.0661212504,
-0.0272127241,
-0.0095376791,
0.0070168925,
0.0560913682,
-0.0193325914,
-0.0293897856,
0.1030987203,
0.0910636038,
-0.0073077357,
-0.0251372289,
0.0096628759,
0.0524084866,
-0.0221103746,
0.0098281093,
0.0573077127,
0.0266383775,
0.0438560545,
0.0400050581,
0.0397051349,
-0.1279503703,
0.0170817357,
-0.0284376517,
0.0534432642,
0.0490685701,
-0.0112687862,
-0.0392710641,
-0.0227786899,
0.0211837646,
-0.0211536922,
-0.0307504237,
-0.018511828,
-0.0071461154,
-0.0155156786,
0.0104866894,
-0.0341825224,
0.0590039529,
-0.0472842455,
-0.0042212438,
-0.0397923887,
0.0154812587,
0.02375759,
0.0014765448,
0.0054749586,
0.0391839035,
0.0570486709,
-0.02800956,
0.0301073398,
-0.0143729132,
-0.009684246,
0.013724451,
0.027165845,
0.0206326153,
0.0010115217,
-0.0116144167,
0.0436762422,
0.0254540388,
0.0484609306,
-0.0095596332,
-0.0488459133,
0.0083476137,
-0.0363121107,
-0.0291149765,
0.0347768143,
-0.0029997977,
0.0245410185,
0.0820192322,
0.0206597243,
-0.035149537,
-0.023150038,
0.0578934923,
-0.031306453,
0.0119431512,
-0.0007591867,
0.0056867125,
-0.0170770232,
0.0157787912,
-0.0462592244,
0.0296069644,
0.0027538985,
-0.0348624997,
0.0028796329,
-0.0187166836,
0.0037432367,
0.0183459632,
2.544e-7,
-0.006767319,
0.0161260627,
0.0510639548,
0.0224774852,
0.0283566397,
0.0055761794,
-0.0256353132,
-0.0181828775,
0.0109207733,
-0.0438649766,
-0.0116917668,
-0.0139677003,
0.0421655141,
-0.0011218807,
-0.0490424894,
0.002989633,
0.0377108157,
0.0141909057,
-0.0053138318,
0.023930721,
0.0315314569,
0.0657388791,
-0.016055733,
-0.0018070933,
0.047151614,
-0.0068059857,
0.0576623417,
-0.0030696925,
0.0206013918,
-0.0414598659,
0.0558665842,
0.0093709799,
-0.0170383509,
0.0368503146,
-0.0062861238,
0.0189301334,
0.0302201603,
0.0106563102,
-0.0399660133,
-0.0712591931,
0.0273614861,
0.0670655817,
-0.0486731529,
0.0028380039,
0.0258123707,
0.0268771648,
-0.0196082406,
-0.0160168707,
-0.0235966146,
-0.0089693815,
0.0515105985,
0.0303718783,
-0.0312528946,
0.0516182557,
0.0249469709,
-0.0599061176,
-0.0078510744,
-0.0476629212,
0.0112329666,
-0.0235051457,
-0.0572351255,
-0.016256744,
-0.0079787159,
-0.0197502393,
0.0361396149,
0.0381579921,
-0.05152357,
1.120168975e-34,
-0.005155907,
-0.0212399866,
0.0146964164,
-0.0017694246,
-0.0444129929,
-0.0249434952,
0.004048869,
0.0099793142,
0.0030467988,
-0.0089519965,
-0.0399197116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.12457v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.12457v1 | LIP-RTVE: An Audiovisual Database for Continuous Spanish in the Wild | 2023-11-21T09:12:21 | 2023-11-21T09:12:21 | David Gimeno-Gómez, Carlos-D. Martínez-Hinarejos | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Speech is considered as a multi-modal process where hearing and vision are
two fundamentals pillars. In fact, several studies have demonstrated that the
robustness of Automatic Speech Recognition systems can be improved when audio
and visual cues are combined to represent the nature of speech. In addition,
Visual Speech Recognition, an open research problem whose purpose is to
interpret speech by reading the lips of the speaker, has been a focus of
interest in the last decades. Nevertheless, in order to estimate these systems
in the currently Deep Learning era, large-scale databases are required. On the
other hand, while most of these databases are dedicated to English, other
languages lack sufficient resources. Thus, this paper presents a
semi-automatically annotated audiovisual database to deal with unconstrained
natural Spanish, providing 13 hours of data extracted from Spanish television.
Furthermore, baseline results for both speaker-dependent and
speaker-independent scenarios are reported using Hidden Markov Models, a
traditional paradigm that has been widely used in the field of Speech
Technologies. | [
-0.0248539839,
0.0379989073,
0.0014498334,
0.0226064548,
-0.0010631729,
0.0024599584,
0.0121418471,
0.0033454457,
-0.0051202821,
-0.0159662794,
-0.0605859645,
-0.0181811266,
0.0263510682,
0.025464857,
0.0222820155,
-0.0808106512,
-0.0290926155,
-0.062346749,
-0.016531283,
-0.0318851806,
0.0345717594,
-0.0043879934,
-0.0861653537,
0.0138549041,
-0.0506349988,
0.0219927151,
0.0033106389,
-0.0163719598,
0.035895519,
0.0067446935,
-0.0781533942,
0.0135236457,
0.0170466863,
0.0045917244,
0.0000015941,
-0.0288743041,
-0.0130840056,
0.012958697,
-0.0167914499,
-0.0226877294,
0.0132656731,
-0.0516547635,
-0.0411255434,
0.0166771114,
-0.0276380386,
-0.0317740068,
0.0353271924,
-0.0450116247,
0.0260750651,
0.0056159007,
-0.0219881702,
-0.0588599928,
0.0444138348,
-0.0172159504,
0.0174065102,
-0.0211132783,
0.0056254142,
0.0038650334,
-0.00398813,
-0.060921777,
-0.0381380059,
0.08959914,
-0.0017098726,
-0.0240219329,
-0.0002486513,
-0.0020711517,
-0.0741471574,
-0.0446222462,
-0.0084439097,
0.0734050795,
0.011800346,
0.0150892949,
0.0217611156,
0.0157838278,
-0.0589652769,
0.0199725628,
-0.0139484601,
0.0479983352,
0.0162473973,
-0.0107957451,
-0.0316771679,
0.0238779839,
0.0451801494,
-0.0472656041,
0.0144073889,
0.0110184196,
0.0185852069,
-0.0019590384,
0.0605010055,
-0.0221802536,
0.0119152525,
-0.0204513855,
0.0439566411,
0.0069908961,
0.0586597957,
0.0069245738,
0.0162560083,
-0.0251492392,
-0.0323731191,
-0.0680188462,
0.0174444336,
0.031188935,
-0.1056143939,
0.014509541,
0.0012661853,
0.0306223389,
-0.0454625599,
0.0037602154,
0.0126658082,
-0.0171077289,
-0.0248938315,
0.0120744463,
-0.0340402983,
-0.0030794225,
-0.0267274696,
0.0203981325,
-0.0373453796,
0.0103531685,
-0.0410175808,
0.0041033621,
0.016468633,
0.0227497164,
-0.0266420636,
-0.0149349421,
-0.0203263201,
0.056673713,
0.0166626889,
0.0283942521,
-0.0138935195,
-0.1009365022,
0.0326883122,
0.0212566778,
0.0337817296,
0.007247522,
0.0256198235,
0.0760308877,
-0.0012676645,
-0.0305954814,
0.0048399959,
0.0167446546,
-0.0486618727,
-0.0460081249,
0.0421750136,
-0.0822698325,
0.0314487331,
-0.0256487932,
0.0212862901,
0.0247888509,
0.0023819683,
-0.0211818554,
0.0278834514,
0.0693470091,
-0.001993339,
-0.0199243929,
0.031055294,
0.0030642671,
0.0032316716,
0.0366837345,
0.0519154593,
-0.0317618214,
-0.0042331349,
0.0037031728,
0.0379486382,
0.0849744752,
-0.0129632466,
0.0186545309,
-0.0578846596,
-0.0269941632,
0.0008341289,
0.0278256796,
0.0431754515,
0.0414006487,
-0.0173127204,
-0.0029920028,
0.0669446737,
0.0448054224,
-0.0090261316,
-0.0190282352,
0.0369181745,
-0.0232129116,
0.0549398363,
-0.0070701656,
0.0234850422,
0.0022917124,
-0.0022153135,
-0.0033238532,
-0.0191299357,
-0.0293486677,
-0.0680383965,
-0.0102487877,
0.0047976207,
-0.0247515365,
-0.0302403159,
0.0380640179,
0.0719411522,
-0.0305564068,
-0.0088124378,
0.0227029081,
-0.0190874692,
-0.0178031083,
0.006726163,
-0.0320606492,
0.0069434396,
0.040809229,
-0.0014173727,
-0.0465541668,
0.0105046434,
-0.0242063571,
0.03565998,
0.0109533751,
-0.0254767705,
-0.0215058327,
0.0931920037,
-0.059936747,
-0.0104092928,
0.0563896783,
0.0070277364,
0.0659251735,
-0.0954062343,
0.0336804427,
-0.0269498136,
0.0098898197,
0.0582532324,
-0.0126739517,
-0.045352608,
-0.0006716,
-0.0032422242,
0.0438915864,
0.0448763892,
0.0679918453,
-0.0508873239,
-0.0325029232,
0.0610084012,
-0.0221586321,
0.0802593157,
0.052502241,
-0.0492547043,
-0.0052279965,
0.0456602015,
-0.0781523734,
0.0085871154,
0.0284850243,
0.0234270785,
-0.0461229533,
0.0131873759,
-0.0324526355,
0.0515363328,
-0.0551562011,
0.0245300364,
-0.0037146783,
0.0235125441,
0.01235162,
-0.0365797095,
-0.0248306859,
-0.0107820351,
0.0224620756,
-0.0278468374,
0.0211724527,
-0.1291324049,
-0.0281708855,
0.0315409154,
-0.0101902811,
0.0151497694,
-0.0036130731,
-0.0151621494,
-0.0023336019,
0.0069976216,
-0.0784090683,
-0.0195432957,
-0.0211247951,
-0.0275266524,
-0.0143168857,
0.0074521098,
-0.0117336242,
-0.0334571414,
-0.0083645238,
-0.0015579907,
0.0177656431,
-0.0292543247,
-0.0492918156,
0.0394480489,
-0.023603661,
-0.0367721021,
-0.0331338979,
0.0110855065,
-0.016169887,
-0.0128498441,
-0.0765063912,
-0.0029749814,
-0.0285973642,
0.0327188522,
0.0734047368,
-0.0236283876,
-0.0314591639,
-0.0135547994,
0.0193681139,
0.0511113293,
0.0391410924,
-0.0119876852,
0.0177296586,
0.037753839,
-0.0145516125,
-0.0023931018,
-0.0028881787,
0.0409841351,
0.0111799641,
-0.0792661533,
-0.0253778826,
-0.0677512586,
-0.0121216383,
0.0239037368,
0.0483285859,
-0.0398148932,
-0.0461833365,
0.000853517,
-0.0627120361,
-0.0009879903,
0.0252975281,
-0.0366594978,
0.0418732837,
0.0173469093,
-0.0375593491,
0.001600287,
-0.0649315864,
-0.0496652462,
0.0124666067,
-0.0550519191,
0.008539265,
0.0108554251,
0.0256117228,
-0.0089390464,
-0.0347046666,
-0.0332519785,
-0.0444500186,
-0.0316518247,
0.0206931364,
-0.0323807374,
0.0463197231,
-0.0542142205,
0.0037683209,
-0.004760324,
-0.0048760986,
-0.0494335853,
0.0111264056,
-0.0804346129,
-0.0210296512,
0.0065788315,
0.0032672842,
-0.0366894826,
0.0442157537,
0.0408950746,
0.0516583286,
0.0399925336,
0.0323456675,
-0.0403653234,
0.0636406168,
0.0349299759,
-0.0015712754,
-0.0323095284,
-0.0539810471,
0.0110884877,
-0.0224551819,
0.0161561426,
0.007437367,
-0.0735404342,
0.0297657829,
0.0220720954,
0.0438986272,
-0.0376811959,
0.017415747,
-0.0035387031,
-0.0296892133,
0.0356207415,
0.0580014512,
-0.0078646736,
-0.0573207587,
-0.0326061212,
0.0437803045,
-0.0117676938,
0.0036779372,
0.022069497,
-0.0746302456,
-0.0202345289,
0.0558261089,
0.038386073,
0.0304042809,
0.0167539194,
-0.0223667547,
-0.0713833347,
0.0408370942,
-0.0114319669,
-0.018936662,
-0.0394232348,
-0.0272821542,
-0.0135586523,
-0.0805341303,
0.0271650888,
-0.0064925458,
-0.0124431448,
-0.0274796877,
0.0687728226,
-0.0442739204,
-0.031591434,
0.0285854749,
-0.0371761024,
0.0436324403,
0.022495389,
0.0124586327,
-0.0213085618,
-0.0518510118,
0.0131247733,
0.0190525092,
-0.0037195273,
0.0125746075,
0.0541120432,
0.0198149402,
-0.0317317694,
0.0255235471,
0.0328511037,
0.0183246695,
0.0162102655,
0.0054515712,
0.06509725,
-0.0322797224,
0.0320614092,
-0.0133032417,
0.0231323466,
-0.0023181629,
0.0324086435,
-0.0190681741,
-0.0475686975,
0.0137438895,
0.0539772287,
0.0351806618,
-0.0351631679,
-0.022378087,
-0.0029639099,
0.003117492,
-0.0479549691,
0.0004394399,
0.0025577892,
-0.0049504675,
0.0585705675,
0.0235892162,
-0.0057424866,
0.0671025962,
0.0413531847,
-0.0296191275,
0.0301791131,
-0.0077113593,
0.0325178578,
-0.0463222638,
-0.0349697098,
-0.0115931034,
-0.0417446271,
-0.0054800846,
0.0001139012,
-0.0837037936,
-0.0351933539,
0.0147985229,
0.0364957862,
0.0313226283,
0.0928741395,
-0.0137605444,
-0.0598979294,
0.0359176323,
-0.0154103348,
-0.0188031625,
0.0253740884,
0.0368985459,
-0.004265781,
-0.0228875261,
0.0071010422,
-0.0259120893,
-0.0081317956,
-0.0413624421,
-0.003845423,
-0.0262187049,
-0.0291905291,
-0.0411704369,
-0.0284944009,
0.0643410161,
-0.0295740701,
0.0173065588,
-0.0650883839,
0.0133186523,
-0.0140016396,
0.0725752339,
-0.0478846729,
0.042270273,
0.0206186306,
0.0305727888,
-0.0138966935,
-0.0091215372,
-0.0111529194,
-0.0439286344,
-0.0002522532,
0.0582281128,
0.047179509,
-0.00545632,
-0.005814347,
0.0354567356,
0.0408968218,
0.0650052503,
0.0031020243,
0.0237947572,
0.0215257481,
-0.0018751364,
0.0065879039,
-0.0402141698,
0.028357327,
0.0273743402,
0.0157239418,
0.0022766707,
-0.0098568555,
0.0783030018,
0.0747599825,
-0.0563761555,
-0.0239068251,
0.0068170843,
0.0077831601,
-0.0495748073,
0.0318475738,
-0.0068596723,
-0.0003121666,
0.0599849634,
-0.0111065134,
-0.0176429879,
0.0400427729,
0.0362499729,
0.0280235671,
-0.0078079095,
-0.0147555545,
0.0438887626,
-0.0511854663,
0.021084046,
0.0114475023,
-0.0045811213,
-0.055753313,
-0.0268213786,
-0.0043910448,
-0.0852008164,
0.0316719748,
-0.0103127025,
0.0086135352,
0.0176256243,
0.0425624363,
-0.016687667,
-0.0156318843,
0.0174429324,
0.0007126816,
-0.0252042469,
-0.0221997835,
-0.018058287,
0.0353945009,
-4.771020064e-33,
0.009295322,
-0.0146915708,
0.0161911156,
0.0032852613,
-0.0057209795,
0.0023804582,
-0.015404921,
0.0143840127,
0.0163148381,
0.0060048266,
0.0059930254,
0.0308541395,
0.0340243056,
0.0093717119,
-0.0014158413,
-0.0310019162,
0.0328095667,
-0.0477300808,
0.0316196531,
-0.0211917963,
0.0241904408,
0.0577909127,
0.0565911457,
-0.0843312293,
-0.0406099334,
0.0274566021,
0.0090867309,
-0.0063965945,
0.0281206276,
0.0572367869,
-0.0058740019,
0.0293668229,
-0.0207552295,
-0.0034478507,
0.0076523442,
0.0176145751,
-0.0627908558,
0.0250751637,
0.0008782616,
0.0950770825,
-0.0515601262,
0.0311294105,
0.0042981384,
0.0259016491,
-0.0107166925,
-0.0156575311,
0.071083352,
-0.0691882148,
-0.0126202907,
-0.017177254,
0.0222291294,
0.0404535681,
-0.0075651067,
-0.0251205545,
0.0864497498,
0.0759417936,
-0.0059404699,
-0.0274163894,
-0.0344784856,
0.0299437214,
-0.0281542968,
0.027616458,
0.0840715319,
0.0400522575,
0.0207778178,
0.0437429287,
0.0810317397,
-0.1234317571,
0.0424952842,
-0.0182398278,
0.0556728467,
0.0414927378,
0.0146981906,
0.0200608876,
-0.0007773479,
-0.0043682652,
-0.0651152059,
-0.0315697081,
0.010807409,
-0.0166957993,
0.0039915857,
0.0091214767,
-0.0262589529,
0.0386876091,
-0.0394733511,
-0.0384198204,
-0.0095436228,
0.0208735876,
0.0152000356,
-0.0011593201,
0.0196125992,
0.0498836599,
0.0833080336,
-0.0451312587,
0.0190503504,
0.0143790524,
-0.0343037136,
0.0001092456,
0.011894363,
0.0570073724,
-0.0416917205,
-0.003026909,
0.0277683083,
0.0720943585,
0.0155616682,
-0.0169583149,
-0.0183127169,
0.0489506349,
-0.0343127437,
-0.0141609916,
0.0067014871,
0.0340605341,
0.0227749869,
0.0855721906,
0.0587536208,
-0.0093769375,
0.0079441806,
0.0756250247,
-0.0074047726,
0.0127108432,
0.0165365972,
0.0000101595,
-0.0218399856,
0.0171109419,
-0.0525378175,
0.0255117919,
0.0046512047,
-0.0218613613,
0.0086128833,
-0.0263740383,
0.0107190479,
0.0034618357,
2.366e-7,
-0.0150716463,
0.0051955869,
0.0526677668,
-0.0103611369,
0.0474075228,
0.0099722724,
-0.0179799516,
-0.0146603324,
-0.0075840852,
-0.0245424621,
-0.0086355498,
-0.0237337444,
0.0614838339,
0.00773104,
-0.0516741872,
-0.0274519045,
-0.0281865932,
0.0174310878,
-0.0076822373,
0.0167918708,
0.000613083,
0.1046536788,
-0.0110338712,
-0.034622442,
0.0334350914,
-0.0320474654,
0.0448291153,
0.0028867347,
0.0020111082,
-0.0335744061,
0.0428659506,
0.0222241879,
-0.0403655395,
0.0060385363,
-0.0123740919,
0.0226399265,
0.0301401727,
0.0383468531,
-0.0274604224,
-0.0707871318,
0.0298387799,
0.0430377126,
-0.0644024462,
0.0233546365,
0.047878895,
0.0065030549,
-0.0267144907,
-0.0002368138,
-0.046558924,
-0.028128216,
0.0063860281,
0.0271767657,
-0.0090925181,
0.0326231569,
0.0265310109,
-0.053305719,
-0.0498018041,
-0.0632918626,
0.0183607973,
-0.0061437925,
-0.0699167624,
-0.0240302831,
-0.0362782739,
0.0040151491,
0.0232799985,
-0.0174821094,
-0.0322030671,
1.121027062e-34,
0.0008776066,
-0.0076716635,
-0.0005805015,
-0.0637105927,
-0.0553333275,
-0.029209692,
0.0207905769,
0.0142966872,
0.0121879149,
-0.0259943008,
-0.0417077057
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.