id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17771v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17771v1 | Supervising the Centroid Baseline for Extractive Multi-Document Summarization | 2023-11-29T16:11:45 | 2023-11-29T16:11:45 | Simão Gonçalves, Gonçalo Correia, Diogo Pernes, Afonso Mendes | cs.CL | cs.CL | The centroid method is a simple approach for extractive multi-document
summarization and many improvements to its pipeline have been proposed. We
further refine it by adding a beam search process to the sentence selection and
also a centroid estimation attention model that leads to improved results. We
demonstrate this in several multi-document summarization datasets, including in
a multilingual scenario. | [
0.0248696897,
-0.0134863462,
0.0315969288,
-0.0046568527,
-0.0059356224,
0.0013363543,
-0.0176753737,
-0.0334409475,
-0.0275011547,
-0.0059284349,
-0.009633746,
0.004345472,
0.0122935623,
-0.0769329369,
-0.0181562603,
-0.0934542716,
0.0202077329,
0.0111145359,
0.0375897251,
0.0213379487,
0.0225403439,
-0.0087986039,
0.0110190557,
0.0190293882,
-0.0260757487,
-0.0069679567,
0.0106873671,
-0.0463771746,
0.0639549643,
-0.0140084084,
0.0247235876,
-0.012192009,
0.0036965713,
-0.0522977747,
0.0000017717,
-0.0171703696,
-0.0484073795,
-0.0146330185,
0.0600856431,
0.0177919418,
0.0547045358,
-0.0644502863,
0.0300041977,
-0.0275231339,
0.0131073361,
0.0463676713,
0.00674548,
0.0514450334,
0.0463747606,
0.0487961099,
-0.0157689936,
-0.0642378256,
0.0081415568,
0.0187785868,
-0.0258272327,
-0.0486014597,
0.0014723468,
0.0299788546,
0.0162639804,
0.0068421597,
0.0064052665,
0.0412612744,
-0.0271145757,
-0.007528292,
0.003333363,
0.0221907198,
-0.0576863997,
-0.0148450239,
0.0029797009,
0.0636483505,
-0.0071514491,
0.0206324738,
0.0429344736,
0.0267721303,
0.0090996306,
-0.0221957173,
-0.1158522666,
0.0437551253,
-0.015666971,
0.0076914201,
0.0301845428,
0.0342767313,
-0.0229794607,
0.0154358568,
-0.0074055176,
0.0351943783,
0.0002499435,
-0.0308091044,
-0.0516514182,
0.0033330715,
-0.031124074,
-0.0029084221,
0.0574341938,
0.0292403065,
-0.0008965415,
-0.0134375328,
-0.0369896814,
-0.0859970152,
0.0193704646,
-0.0322570056,
-0.0125641571,
-0.0100112185,
0.0256013572,
0.0514205918,
-0.0306329019,
0.0037305623,
0.0246659089,
-0.0068054372,
-0.0726093128,
-0.0535902269,
0.0011799063,
0.0319072604,
-0.0477402471,
0.0491298437,
-0.0255626515,
-0.0389501154,
-0.0232654549,
0.0020457162,
0.0086060977,
-0.0298718251,
-0.0233716257,
0.0013632032,
-0.0073220669,
0.0049313642,
0.0680809319,
0.0675246865,
-0.0392375812,
-0.034119539,
0.0190406442,
0.022577839,
-0.0476167314,
0.081567809,
0.0339242183,
-0.0222922899,
-0.0003351038,
-0.0171799939,
-0.0426547937,
-0.0664888993,
0.0030612408,
-0.0148594407,
-0.0389117748,
-0.0177488234,
0.0079338681,
-0.05449396,
0.0288369674,
0.021446513,
-0.0092030559,
0.0310935695,
0.0089095263,
0.0039941235,
-0.0387397744,
-0.0124135055,
0.0269176234,
-0.0116653815,
0.0481222607,
0.0111760348,
0.0123818936,
0.0397364125,
0.0155031653,
0.0564172193,
0.0629898086,
0.0541821346,
-0.0027523607,
0.0158196576,
0.005445261,
0.0061274702,
0.0679045543,
-0.0078137396,
-0.022828307,
-0.0086738765,
0.0406275503,
-0.0143357385,
-0.0352472924,
0.0514416397,
0.0375016183,
0.0940384939,
-0.0095355259,
-0.0301857628,
-0.0018024124,
0.0143992342,
0.032819584,
0.039058961,
0.0170991328,
0.0439378321,
-0.039100159,
0.061098028,
0.0731267035,
0.0362844504,
-0.0231737327,
-0.0151067879,
0.0171427634,
0.0071119503,
-0.0109306294,
0.0013082717,
0.0414109118,
0.011343142,
0.0017674488,
0.0660272539,
0.0027753161,
-0.0493278876,
0.019760076,
0.0127383443,
-0.0174450241,
-0.0340006426,
0.0168096274,
-0.0631205887,
0.0117165018,
0.0007668756,
0.0787092224,
0.0272103157,
0.0447043292,
-0.0111883795,
-0.0004257153,
-0.0614657067,
-0.0158477444,
-0.0345648527,
-0.0135092884,
-0.0217032544,
-0.0213563722,
0.002606035,
0.0164985433,
-0.000746123,
-0.0521048531,
0.0006815135,
0.0125427898,
0.0049623698,
-0.0379372425,
0.0034016555,
-0.0082501834,
0.0320660397,
0.0065543018,
0.0159580819,
0.0447551347,
0.0066350838,
0.0063604903,
0.0174602568,
-0.0363908894,
-0.0611823834,
0.0103224907,
-0.0733129829,
-0.0294097029,
-0.0096451966,
-0.0055381805,
-0.0292992108,
0.0422738716,
-0.0343495607,
0.0019700304,
0.0014165591,
0.0343413316,
0.0567770898,
0.0326691568,
-0.0527157634,
0.0809019431,
-0.0110898502,
0.0257880576,
0.064908646,
-0.0448625386,
-0.0103848232,
-0.0187958367,
0.0107662752,
0.0242372248,
-0.0100048594,
0.0018239411,
0.0662905723,
0.0125443386,
-0.0047231992,
-0.0134440791,
-0.0769970864,
0.0260019116,
-0.0299477987,
-0.0010953892,
0.0361063071,
0.0271345824,
-0.0035355948,
-0.0087889079,
-0.0101197241,
0.0098404642,
0.0096558444,
-0.0049825548,
0.0429828428,
0.0209392831,
0.0378699228,
-0.0275810324,
-0.0007697347,
-0.0049683182,
0.0634897873,
0.0013901355,
-0.0349289514,
0.0086470135,
0.0044002789,
-0.0114634661,
-0.0478703715,
-0.009206838,
0.0236452315,
0.0017314435,
-0.0336853564,
0.0336344764,
0.0629548281,
0.0318837427,
0.0259935036,
0.0287767835,
-0.0141369049,
-0.0290008485,
0.0098248553,
-0.0187936109,
0.0820077658,
0.0074924733,
-0.0300673451,
0.0926993415,
0.0581730381,
0.0344643146,
0.0103079472,
0.0167889502,
-0.021282753,
0.0207429491,
0.0059814518,
-0.0601559915,
0.031781517,
-0.0064125815,
-0.0149337752,
-0.0395066217,
0.0178165548,
0.0560049526,
-0.0062814308,
-0.0111725815,
-0.1000100821,
0.0006112831,
-0.0517045073,
0.0069434829,
-0.0072100712,
0.0499378629,
-0.0345363654,
-0.0379392914,
-0.0154082645,
-0.0123896683,
0.0346414484,
0.0097084017,
0.0522811264,
-0.0206995681,
-0.0035988477,
-0.0453469753,
-0.0192856919,
0.0096937334,
0.0124696,
0.0083296867,
0.0198397376,
0.051181253,
-0.0004929412,
-0.0495121107,
0.0126581276,
0.0777732432,
0.0534882322,
-0.0409989953,
-0.0314342938,
0.0054954002,
0.1075173765,
0.0593485758,
0.0165537857,
0.0028334521,
-0.0513698123,
-0.0182670765,
0.0739856884,
0.0362497233,
-0.0468589999,
0.0365941375,
-0.0170061328,
0.0076011862,
-0.0735784024,
0.0273240432,
-0.0732677504,
0.0669678971,
-0.0211557448,
0.027978899,
0.074373737,
0.0464711301,
-0.0250509717,
-0.0270050913,
-0.0276684016,
-0.0167845134,
0.0021487384,
-0.0322211571,
-0.0521761887,
-0.0198855028,
-0.0225348249,
0.0224826243,
0.045669198,
-0.0227429792,
-0.0074616312,
-0.0201784633,
0.0010004346,
-0.0014893989,
-0.0869306549,
-0.0611952506,
-0.0038791422,
0.0306248944,
0.0114479158,
-0.0131260194,
0.0366349034,
-0.0138785085,
-0.0152150942,
-0.0142468661,
-0.0535342544,
0.0024482091,
-0.0280824993,
-0.0403249077,
-0.0340298042,
0.0035425278,
0.0609283447,
0.0084703164,
0.063564077,
0.0227882247,
-0.0563725531,
-0.0049951961,
0.003290015,
0.023607539,
-0.0291720983,
0.0003469153,
-0.0298361145,
0.0333073884,
0.0258635655,
-0.0154647464,
0.0610533804,
0.0271604881,
0.0079810955,
-0.0568310283,
-0.0546127483,
0.0310518015,
-0.0320460722,
0.0505701378,
0.0211416278,
-0.0227511767,
-0.0340414941,
-0.0349002928,
-0.0447249338,
-0.0618550368,
-0.0178412367,
-0.0065166084,
-0.0043917666,
-0.0162379034,
-0.0664081499,
-0.0583439954,
0.02109804,
-0.0343309715,
-0.0264796484,
-0.037693236,
-0.0347349532,
0.0048889625,
-0.0220460407,
0.0333566032,
-0.0181939583,
-0.0423436798,
-0.0164628923,
0.0296027977,
0.0627212077,
-0.0358837023,
-0.0068105021,
0.0335541479,
-0.0299664885,
-0.0221824944,
-0.0303194001,
0.0439521745,
0.0062322989,
0.051324632,
-0.0006243822,
0.0026552174,
0.0646644086,
0.0104499757,
-0.022903217,
0.0165361892,
0.0290205292,
0.0003310324,
-0.0327909254,
0.0114181247,
-0.038293615,
0.0493823886,
-0.0331095792,
0.0505704656,
-0.0467569008,
-0.0565697625,
-0.0047834609,
0.0333571434,
0.0265216976,
-0.0015968318,
0.0102114743,
-0.030694332,
-0.053465344,
-0.0087474678,
-0.0255947262,
0.0150152324,
0.0472301468,
-0.0155904433,
-0.0123411175,
-0.003458272,
0.0977958515,
0.0230267998,
-0.0480380207,
-0.0041567525,
0.0187422112,
-0.0046022586,
-0.0212206021,
-0.0475468487,
0.0033502474,
-0.036035791,
-0.017251892,
-0.0343861841,
0.0071786703,
-0.0135010285,
-0.0037593476,
0.012351376,
-0.0249513034,
0.0019879534,
0.0473772585,
-0.1021184996,
0.0763571262,
-0.0689789057,
0.0073792855,
0.044909101,
-0.048616752,
0.0895093903,
-0.0126246223,
-0.0357388519,
-0.0151511878,
0.0476682708,
0.0229003374,
0.0153648043,
-0.0565836988,
0.0115026757,
0.0133426338,
0.0110999784,
0.0940325111,
-0.0864449516,
-0.0172342714,
0.0147420121,
-0.0298596211,
-0.0703552365,
-0.0201698095,
-0.0015763071,
0.0216596797,
-0.0039742957,
-0.0335406289,
-0.0156229436,
0.0282982346,
0.0496952161,
-0.0228804946,
-0.0158629715,
-0.0019891805,
0.0179650299,
0.0486204773,
0.0084187221,
-0.0075460766,
-0.0481761806,
0.0069546211,
-0.0165328961,
-0.0044348408,
-0.0176526364,
-5.825025604e-33,
-0.0191737618,
-0.0035204699,
-0.0352238454,
0.0478072129,
-0.0428878963,
0.0041122967,
-0.0709072873,
-0.0020975003,
-0.0167507827,
-0.0026370869,
-0.0023314527,
-0.0212912522,
0.0099362414,
0.0478531085,
0.0070191198,
0.0478795171,
0.0023439685,
0.0050577288,
-0.0578862242,
0.0298188925,
0.05201656,
0.0080576092,
0.0708989277,
-0.0191424433,
0.022335995,
-0.0081887394,
-0.0225797389,
-0.0326518975,
0.058473859,
0.0281259753,
0.0196457542,
0.0125697888,
0.0197919793,
-0.0458116382,
-0.0293396246,
0.0020606669,
-0.0380725972,
-0.0416159816,
-0.003526134,
-0.0395224951,
-0.0348936655,
-0.0939620659,
0.0417269394,
-0.0319839045,
0.0386126935,
-0.0166036841,
0.0915436894,
-0.0566696413,
-0.0419368297,
-0.0557132252,
-0.032160148,
0.000997,
-0.091529727,
0.0082349582,
0.0057127122,
0.0688221082,
0.0061539123,
0.0436152369,
-0.0383950211,
0.0644151419,
-0.0246387646,
0.019372616,
0.0260199308,
0.0124412039,
0.0103177745,
0.0577319935,
-0.0042698425,
-0.0308103953,
0.0160772409,
-0.0049541472,
0.0021833819,
0.0135202305,
-0.0041526961,
0.0241182521,
-0.0221833754,
0.0299066678,
-0.0488304943,
0.0775386617,
0.0034141243,
0.0292214584,
0.0178589541,
-0.0029907594,
0.003220648,
0.0109357303,
0.0406671762,
-0.037123844,
-0.0079641808,
0.012695333,
-0.0300419647,
0.037147034,
-0.0700711384,
-0.0002088769,
0.027610464,
-0.0025683525,
0.0369162038,
0.0518920496,
-0.0227286294,
0.0532378145,
0.0185868591,
-0.0282367188,
-0.0534818135,
0.0151258949,
0.007824149,
0.0095173735,
-0.011985776,
0.0107510202,
0.0501068197,
-0.0214392077,
-0.0108157583,
-0.0012617614,
0.0185192693,
-0.0139217218,
-0.057588812,
0.0460304357,
-0.0400974303,
-0.0207906533,
-0.0004449262,
0.0362266749,
0.0073054228,
0.0366322286,
-0.0140649285,
-0.0326937065,
0.0266565345,
0.0095268935,
0.0142881069,
0.0468127765,
-0.0311519466,
0.0362903289,
-0.0027674818,
-0.0408205055,
-0.0178012177,
0.0061019831,
2.362e-7,
0.0609822348,
0.0212965291,
0.0512957051,
0.0008883915,
-0.0055576065,
-0.0022223582,
-0.0237688161,
0.0516611114,
0.0139998738,
0.0096587427,
0.0382839963,
0.0280552246,
0.0292543005,
-0.0020215572,
-0.1295838207,
-0.0210504532,
-0.0368630774,
-0.0702793002,
-0.043251887,
-0.0465371273,
0.0157836061,
0.0602409765,
-0.0341474451,
0.0264560655,
-0.035911154,
-0.0073004342,
0.0293322783,
0.0196899232,
-0.0369519331,
0.0275180507,
0.0436657593,
-0.020659307,
-0.0534267351,
-0.0402267165,
-0.0083556529,
0.0210799389,
0.0912720561,
0.0557789356,
0.0025531133,
-0.0494573712,
0.0492391214,
-0.0193161517,
0.0250331014,
0.029087726,
0.0353770927,
-0.0667690486,
0.0181220304,
-0.0344083086,
-0.005757459,
0.0302082524,
-0.020460939,
-0.006845213,
-0.0525771044,
0.0482612252,
-0.0221400186,
-0.0067388783,
-0.0047387192,
-0.037475232,
-0.0512068644,
0.0613842644,
0.0072301854,
-0.0268808156,
0.0151708825,
-0.0394904763,
0.0047946637,
-0.0342328884,
0.0033292421,
1.851433793e-34,
0.0692647621,
-0.0070050065,
-0.0509474948,
-0.0421486087,
0.0171983298,
-0.0647185743,
-0.0628092512,
-0.0216653291,
0.0024302574,
-0.0592425913,
-0.00595483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17972v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17972v3 | Self-Infilling Code Generation | 2023-11-29T16:02:06 | 2024-05-26T18:15:39 | Lin Zheng, Jianbo Yuan, Zhi Zhang, Hongxia Yang, Lingpeng Kong | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.CL, cs.LG | This work introduces self-infilling code generation, a general framework that
incorporates infilling operations into auto-regressive decoding. Our approach
capitalizes on the observation that recent infilling-capable code language
models can self-infill: whereas infilling operations aim to fill in the middle
based on a predefined prefix and suffix, self-infilling sequentially generates
both such surrounding context and the infilled content. We utilize this
capability to introduce novel interruption and looping mechanisms in
conventional decoding, evolving it into a non-monotonic process. Interruptions
allow for postponing the generation of specific code until a definitive suffix
is established, enhancing control over the output. Meanwhile, the looping
mechanism, which leverages the complementary nature of self-infilling and
left-to-right decoding, can iteratively update and synchronize each piece of
generation cyclically. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate that
our proposed decoding process is effective in enhancing both regularity and
quality across several code generation benchmarks. | [
-0.0218145289,
0.0459627546,
-0.0120793507,
0.0034634029,
-0.022320725,
-0.0025471996,
-0.0652370825,
-0.013669095,
-0.0402913988,
0.02878787,
0.0286083557,
0.040406879,
0.0021829698,
0.0682729632,
0.0490144305,
0.0189708248,
0.0269840006,
-0.0209306013,
-0.0522126779,
0.0036584735,
-0.0190997534,
0.0290806666,
0.0239613969,
-0.007258662,
-0.0026670843,
-0.0355622023,
-0.0495543443,
0.0469596386,
-0.0594632402,
-0.0445334464,
0.0442581289,
0.043306347,
-0.0177418031,
-0.0150946928,
0.0000024386,
-0.0036199135,
-0.0146293743,
-0.0006588715,
-0.0407363102,
0.0351639763,
-0.0054691895,
-0.0480031595,
-0.0434435867,
0.0056339055,
-0.0230506007,
0.0004817959,
0.0487241149,
-0.064939715,
0.0849685967,
0.0161874443,
0.0049271919,
-0.0151274456,
0.0094082765,
-0.0205664802,
0.0094551286,
0.0040768092,
-0.0095306607,
0.0013833354,
0.0027235823,
-0.0182013921,
-0.0324872248,
-0.0034614,
0.0337125547,
-0.00018008,
0.0239362195,
0.0158445649,
0.0360021442,
-0.0351806358,
-0.0514248759,
0.0042183045,
-0.0478746518,
-0.0613728538,
0.0013288615,
-0.0002965802,
-0.0201461539,
-0.094670102,
-0.0174881704,
0.0252979714,
-0.0090499818,
0.0222839359,
0.0538128018,
0.0681901947,
0.024098767,
-0.0275339447,
-0.0484810844,
0.0254257042,
0.0182654113,
-0.0335070752,
-0.0730286539,
0.0078918179,
0.0729152411,
-0.0681557059,
-0.0064519867,
0.0275462512,
0.0197857581,
0.0005635762,
-0.0816800147,
-0.0161193181,
0.039801687,
0.0110580595,
0.015750682,
0.0874847248,
-0.019898938,
-0.0015882072,
-0.0440257564,
-0.0053038457,
-0.0253061019,
-0.0687808469,
-0.0396165662,
0.026773097,
0.0173719171,
-0.0246078204,
-0.0703515932,
0.0420366712,
-0.031779293,
0.0057431534,
-0.0218515377,
0.0558287799,
0.0392559208,
0.0258260109,
-0.0163350683,
-0.0185549129,
-0.0374697745,
-0.0052055279,
0.096792534,
-0.0086922469,
-0.0336621627,
-0.0859462768,
0.0096487086,
-0.0564843826,
-0.015968116,
0.0133125382,
-0.0094033126,
0.0005394676,
-0.0105458805,
0.0349020213,
-0.0272334311,
0.0179428924,
-0.0027261602,
-0.0677835196,
0.0434210189,
-0.0208024867,
-0.0036713895,
-0.0609258562,
-0.0468305498,
0.0100258123,
-0.0283501465,
-0.0678352192,
0.0344582573,
0.019925775,
0.0272496454,
0.0196619723,
-0.1222543344,
0.0060470258,
-0.0125044454,
0.0148167145,
0.0569953993,
0.0333925374,
0.0235741399,
0.012338086,
0.00252748,
-0.0329948291,
0.0271241106,
0.0429214239,
0.045652613,
-0.0026417449,
-0.0293965973,
-0.0070371241,
0.0264835339,
-0.0041508586,
0.0264367983,
0.0190813486,
-0.0187729653,
-0.003419247,
-0.0120330863,
0.0060963095,
0.0280004703,
0.0574059114,
0.0538148172,
0.0271779336,
-0.0194302443,
0.0237023719,
0.007473595,
0.0479893833,
-0.0126171475,
0.0132919978,
0.0437205322,
0.0222162865,
0.0027335582,
-0.044105567,
0.0325144306,
-0.0166475978,
0.0452582836,
-0.0094888713,
0.0002904184,
0.0542584173,
-0.0578818731,
-0.0030824824,
-0.0123845488,
-0.0617988072,
-0.0197843574,
-0.040959537,
-0.0083647948,
0.0517325774,
0.0597094484,
0.0143383667,
-0.0375769027,
0.0260436293,
-0.0106151197,
-0.0184953082,
-0.0176902171,
0.0046011922,
0.0135085518,
-0.0214688312,
-0.010589594,
0.0126381777,
-0.00369105,
0.0569380224,
0.0303169303,
-0.0036088442,
0.0111292321,
-0.0067862147,
0.0089104576,
0.0150591144,
-0.0293528978,
-0.0115236379,
0.0541217178,
-0.0042632427,
0.0019845255,
-0.0144087318,
-0.0478928909,
0.0433672071,
0.0623166338,
-0.0142854312,
-0.0081110308,
-0.0232397113,
-0.0713876262,
-0.0379192494,
0.0035728719,
0.0044681672,
-0.0431537442,
-0.0115648378,
0.0146620255,
-0.0336777233,
0.0588896275,
-0.046562586,
0.0438705683,
-0.0313132145,
0.0162999537,
0.0154986512,
0.0261382107,
0.0018963886,
-0.0060538356,
-0.0198252294,
0.0053371266,
0.0128095746,
0.0782654807,
0.0389667265,
-0.0043535954,
-0.0016194077,
-0.0022835713,
-0.0560311712,
-0.0209173486,
-0.0107559683,
0.0300046559,
0.0191113967,
-0.0480383374,
-0.0113893356,
0.0239628293,
-0.0312609002,
0.0084482161,
0.0053940662,
0.050957948,
0.003003204,
-0.0351950675,
0.0016078039,
-0.033661738,
0.0462681912,
0.003144748,
-0.0025819938,
0.0082045374,
-0.0604275912,
0.0311952513,
-0.0325323865,
0.0011866919,
0.0104224095,
-0.0289531276,
-0.0311140232,
-0.0967666805,
-0.0311825015,
0.0277339835,
-0.0033087733,
-0.0183033254,
-0.0603749268,
0.01668524,
-0.0424451344,
0.0221557971,
0.0153240953,
0.0344641767,
-0.0120713888,
0.009782617,
-0.010674634,
-0.00632161,
0.0263510123,
0.0313291475,
-0.0330235064,
0.0248429365,
-0.0190739743,
0.0476697348,
0.0581366234,
0.0323030427,
0.0237284694,
-0.0484127961,
-0.0077333939,
0.0456707664,
-0.0438356102,
0.0002272935,
-0.0607256331,
-0.0099238921,
0.0712027475,
-0.0287134293,
-0.0891043618,
0.0346650369,
-0.0417842194,
-0.0392600521,
0.0063625406,
0.0047729556,
-0.0363962352,
0.0563651584,
-0.0301375408,
0.0255239569,
0.0279140659,
-0.0644473881,
0.037280865,
0.0401064381,
-0.0047675348,
-0.0374983475,
-0.0067545432,
-0.0073544299,
0.0018083217,
0.0154390037,
-0.0364615917,
-0.0642060414,
0.0033806516,
0.0401253402,
-0.0463817976,
0.036416702,
0.0080763316,
0.0644105524,
0.0073098792,
-0.0180809312,
0.0205026213,
0.0210933331,
-0.0108819688,
0.0148122562,
0.0039277254,
-0.0473033302,
-0.0606237352,
-0.0392493606,
0.0134321768,
-0.0169886239,
0.0269023236,
-0.0027868943,
0.0771606788,
-0.0243111979,
0.0433210768,
0.0666849986,
0.0261879619,
-0.0309331212,
0.0846132562,
0.024256153,
-0.0212363731,
-0.0314159468,
0.0571476407,
0.0032049955,
-0.010324345,
0.02790666,
-0.0125092808,
0.0753587708,
0.0432002582,
0.0219644774,
-0.0631875917,
0.0016134568,
0.0276035313,
0.0578442141,
0.0145639107,
0.0265977066,
-0.0392424501,
-0.0755812973,
0.0586455651,
0.0267568585,
0.0170927718,
-0.0520482957,
-0.0156654958,
-0.0431470647,
0.0641722158,
-0.0624975599,
0.0780531093,
0.0293202698,
0.0123998234,
0.014637081,
-0.0378378332,
0.0167774297,
-0.0215352047,
-0.0081977854,
0.0606288686,
0.1141015589,
0.0039502578,
0.0506589934,
0.0207521264,
-0.0018339447,
-0.0278811231,
0.0035621657,
-0.0457597561,
-0.0085402336,
0.0188185871,
-0.023320945,
0.0133747626,
0.0061161905,
-0.0350510515,
-0.0183811225,
-0.0228383634,
0.0377875566,
0.0270184483,
0.0047559645,
-0.0377671681,
0.0013039797,
0.0632137954,
0.0343564339,
-0.0087891975,
-0.0014079277,
-0.0346935466,
-0.0742857382,
0.0404339544,
-0.0730684921,
-0.0046551693,
-0.0018944716,
0.0616803057,
-0.0647740588,
-0.0161390193,
0.0118133761,
-0.0501203164,
0.0313573629,
-0.0012906431,
0.0191717446,
0.0259240884,
-0.0250636265,
-0.1208690181,
-0.1120818108,
-0.0142355226,
0.0069229715,
-0.0334031396,
-0.0372050442,
0.0134465192,
-0.0188696105,
0.0244857538,
0.0430312492,
-0.0674498156,
-0.0157889556,
0.016120024,
0.0589194372,
0.0136821959,
0.0404798239,
-0.0212846715,
-0.0173346046,
-0.0206509884,
0.0163965449,
-0.0306315217,
0.0163863618,
0.0119949095,
-0.0063227043,
0.0279071908,
-0.0118483808,
-0.0479804948,
-0.0106060281,
0.0181635655,
-0.0093050366,
-0.0188437421,
0.0042565395,
0.0938996226,
-0.0137106953,
-0.0647555739,
-0.0299594644,
0.0355768278,
0.0580377392,
0.0056283926,
-0.0211929921,
-0.0191265978,
-0.0464096554,
0.0644611418,
0.0408216566,
-0.0275599211,
0.0329177752,
0.0080635818,
-0.0227237362,
0.0109567754,
0.0144987423,
0.0229899194,
-0.063560009,
0.0284889322,
0.0638368726,
0.0120684141,
-0.0146494042,
0.0155027946,
0.0052712569,
-0.0273428541,
-0.0565761887,
-0.0084012607,
0.0449794047,
0.0434543937,
0.0041042301,
-0.0053363941,
-0.0045616459,
0.0340193622,
-0.0064188852,
-0.0195139907,
0.046854116,
0.0706069469,
0.0189969726,
0.0039646099,
0.0205049459,
-0.0236827806,
0.0507304519,
-0.0451203585,
-0.0433233567,
-0.046062883,
0.0242769942,
-0.020916516,
-0.0439364053,
0.0593909211,
-0.0151585629,
-0.0007697271,
0.0261807274,
0.0380977765,
-0.0392661206,
-0.0125734489,
0.0176305678,
0.0083892727,
-0.015827734,
0.005494961,
0.0213297792,
-0.0243508406,
0.0106706657,
0.0320707113,
0.040982388,
0.0015253626,
0.0285410713,
0.07285624,
-0.0130808074,
-0.0082419384,
-0.0258626882,
0.0172124039,
0.0129997879,
-0.0793644413,
0.01058596,
-6.865961117e-33,
-0.0282183513,
0.0178832039,
-0.0188945346,
-0.0348599926,
-0.003590462,
-0.0334764495,
-0.0698554665,
0.0008880327,
0.073696062,
-0.0365260504,
0.0145103233,
0.0015247599,
0.0046624057,
0.0062553352,
0.039402198,
0.0506750233,
0.0623915829,
0.0140436422,
-0.0431570075,
0.0282926839,
-0.0559047572,
0.0413105451,
-0.0314835012,
-0.0296113659,
-0.0384451821,
-0.063500613,
0.0205052067,
-0.0168084148,
0.0302315671,
0.0128018064,
0.0197214577,
-0.0141061125,
-0.001378842,
-0.0160779972,
-0.0451282822,
0.0227279682,
-0.0914778262,
-0.0361638181,
-0.0048821517,
-0.0111221168,
-0.0321503617,
-0.0355218686,
0.0439620428,
-0.0000662189,
-0.0423588008,
0.0072804694,
-0.0360743925,
0.0324786082,
-0.0030406925,
-0.0079344651,
-0.0443756133,
0.0367045999,
-0.0355674811,
-0.0604867898,
-0.0113342954,
-0.0385481901,
-0.0057055093,
-0.0095042037,
-0.0232162625,
0.0476759784,
-0.017433418,
0.0686677247,
0.0144642396,
-0.0148580102,
-0.0009473535,
-0.0189588834,
0.0737676099,
0.0291035343,
-0.047311265,
0.0615064576,
0.0120684318,
-0.0103032086,
0.0057524936,
0.0174555089,
0.0819148645,
-0.0558323897,
0.0128465788,
0.0139381392,
-0.0043327725,
-0.0151300281,
0.0166913643,
0.0258209538,
-0.0069565801,
-0.0158883128,
-0.0252009612,
-0.0474538952,
0.0051644156,
-0.0415823348,
0.0519657657,
0.035147123,
-0.0487873219,
0.0304588862,
0.0229746196,
-0.0050790492,
-0.003355698,
0.0250435583,
-0.0316777639,
0.0111335022,
-0.0305186342,
0.0454322472,
0.0437951982,
-0.007064953,
0.0165019482,
-0.0229991749,
0.0403035954,
-0.0037036925,
-0.0136249745,
0.0275309887,
-0.0458058603,
-0.0190416314,
-0.0268176105,
0.0453486182,
0.0220094658,
-0.0407849848,
0.0245050024,
0.0158243403,
0.0209960155,
0.0005922932,
0.0013403622,
-0.0259113628,
-0.0709192008,
-0.0479650609,
0.0048015555,
0.0506319068,
-0.0163459964,
0.0027637749,
-0.0773126185,
0.0455011018,
0.0374450386,
-0.0223925896,
-0.055336073,
0.0505507663,
3.118e-7,
0.0174379162,
0.0275002327,
0.088509798,
0.0132409949,
0.0366321281,
-0.0186573826,
0.0009023081,
0.0263684224,
-0.0228634477,
-0.0067733,
-0.0378815643,
-0.0062135654,
0.0166805834,
-0.0048314272,
-0.0342322923,
0.0452529714,
-0.0014040967,
0.0170464646,
-0.0347557366,
0.0026788029,
0.0314771198,
0.0240034796,
-0.0242929943,
-0.0083447024,
0.0516159832,
0.007935334,
-0.0109149069,
0.0267594922,
0.0429425612,
0.0080715725,
-0.1351906657,
0.0103989439,
0.0024957622,
-0.0586032085,
-0.0296061561,
-0.0091866711,
-0.0028595228,
0.0354645662,
-0.010208467,
0.0207032096,
0.056749288,
0.0114967432,
-0.0307386275,
-0.0163687766,
0.0183572378,
0.0074322382,
0.0134115918,
-0.02465887,
-0.034578979,
0.038606938,
-0.0431925096,
-0.006615872,
-0.0250983424,
0.0200872198,
0.044676885,
0.0463936813,
-0.0007712109,
-0.0111823808,
-0.0270336904,
-0.0252685957,
-0.0613200888,
0.0137098785,
-0.0898897797,
0.0619665906,
0.040999312,
0.0128155416,
-0.0031037999,
2.853941408e-34,
0.0196174439,
-0.0500201695,
0.0244433433,
0.0337392278,
0.0124719422,
-0.020451542,
-0.0082428129,
0.0767075196,
0.0026053155,
0.0280609839,
-0.0544628762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17743v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17743v1 | Mukhyansh: A Headline Generation Dataset for Indic Languages | 2023-11-29T15:49:24 | 2023-11-29T15:49:24 | Lokesh Madasu, Gopichand Kanumolu, Nirmal Surange, Manish Shrivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The task of headline generation within the realm of Natural Language
Processing (NLP) holds immense significance, as it strives to distill the true
essence of textual content into concise and attention-grabbing summaries. While
noteworthy progress has been made in headline generation for widely spoken
languages like English, there persist numerous challenges when it comes to
generating headlines in low-resource languages, such as the rich and diverse
Indian languages. A prominent obstacle that specifically hinders headline
generation in Indian languages is the scarcity of high-quality annotated data.
To address this crucial gap, we proudly present Mukhyansh, an extensive
multilingual dataset, tailored for Indian language headline generation.
Comprising an impressive collection of over 3.39 million article-headline
pairs, Mukhyansh spans across eight prominent Indian languages, namely Telugu,
Tamil, Kannada, Malayalam, Hindi, Bengali, Marathi, and Gujarati. We present a
comprehensive evaluation of several state-of-the-art baseline models.
Additionally, through an empirical analysis of existing works, we demonstrate
that Mukhyansh outperforms all other models, achieving an impressive average
ROUGE-L score of 31.43 across all 8 languages. | [
0.0523733012,
0.02841275,
-0.0034601062,
0.0286961086,
-0.0403907299,
0.0070621013,
-0.0179841407,
-0.0116789993,
0.0453880988,
-0.0072980779,
0.028572049,
-0.0169066042,
0.0045482893,
0.0442182645,
0.0152306799,
-0.065786995,
0.0203180537,
0.0081666894,
0.0121263918,
0.029083088,
0.0385154225,
0.0425380319,
-0.0045636161,
0.027040327,
-0.049344901,
-0.0155630643,
0.0017327537,
0.0132867163,
-0.0028129716,
-0.0509382933,
0.0214319807,
0.0627035424,
0.0093333349,
0.018785648,
0.0000016155,
-0.0524546802,
0.0115970857,
-0.0393598117,
0.0639736727,
0.0088511165,
0.0540918,
-0.0552869402,
0.002419437,
0.0021552213,
-0.0058391392,
0.0407377891,
0.0443088561,
0.0270130243,
0.0369773507,
0.1046401933,
-0.0315435417,
-0.0592545271,
0.0168909952,
0.0186049882,
-0.0288490076,
-0.0035619065,
-0.0246891249,
-0.0364212655,
-0.0386872329,
-0.018595621,
-0.0155478837,
0.0078615956,
0.0141135901,
-0.0333840437,
-0.0107777836,
0.0219186023,
-0.0866162255,
-0.0490650088,
0.0130554372,
0.0657383427,
-0.0596332252,
-0.0522571802,
0.0308536347,
-0.0097112209,
-0.0424389131,
-0.0437282361,
-0.0628073364,
0.0522050932,
-0.0123918559,
0.028545063,
0.0735304877,
0.037407808,
-0.019679701,
0.0251282025,
0.0567698292,
-0.0203529745,
0.0328663513,
0.0043897475,
-0.0292695891,
-0.0073150159,
-0.0312244091,
-0.0559755042,
0.0255717374,
0.0211310145,
-0.0574600734,
0.0316152312,
-0.0429348983,
-0.0513804331,
0.0353649668,
-0.0854123607,
-0.026099287,
0.0081565725,
0.012045973,
0.0109654991,
-0.0163379516,
-0.0003924619,
0.0105874958,
-0.016818488,
0.0089757899,
-0.0117173912,
0.0319811851,
-0.0532792658,
0.020532731,
0.0138848871,
-0.0351008661,
-0.0336703882,
-0.0634665266,
0.0078909732,
0.0267651025,
-0.0179991126,
-0.0017696177,
0.0109348102,
-0.0596219413,
-0.0295242164,
0.0361218154,
0.0075017558,
-0.0396054983,
-0.0300913397,
0.0608501136,
-0.056280911,
-0.0106986323,
0.0238852147,
-0.0247819703,
-0.0007428498,
-0.0252710469,
0.0040384438,
-0.0532377549,
-0.0099323308,
-0.0183662586,
-0.0179316103,
-0.0147072403,
-0.0377315469,
-0.0477854759,
-0.0807663277,
0.0419068113,
0.0357719809,
-0.0133083537,
-0.0386536866,
0.0331269652,
0.0635215119,
-0.002875963,
0.0300853085,
-0.009188666,
0.0036786469,
0.0240706317,
0.0438260622,
0.0840244293,
0.0611375459,
0.0280433577,
0.0729060099,
0.0596895702,
0.0128812212,
0.0446321592,
0.0354425088,
0.0032111402,
-0.0178552549,
0.0113887768,
-0.0011848789,
-0.0549962558,
0.049308978,
-0.0120861186,
0.0179219171,
0.0182363149,
0.0536433645,
0.0466328412,
0.0177133922,
0.0048051826,
0.0406298079,
0.0099993264,
0.0273085851,
0.0070263469,
0.0272162687,
0.0273157321,
0.0300634503,
-0.0179510862,
0.0141209159,
0.040651992,
0.0346852876,
-0.0147405509,
-0.0104101449,
-0.0114939427,
0.0213465374,
-0.0529861301,
-0.0362167582,
0.0218169913,
0.0349243432,
-0.0625255704,
0.0197975077,
0.0490108579,
-0.0648240671,
0.0462777913,
-0.0072133662,
0.0236382689,
0.0061194473,
0.0478244871,
0.0102226082,
-0.0227823481,
0.0198729523,
0.0350833535,
0.0634440854,
0.0286880992,
-0.0281218234,
-0.0239098556,
-0.0383979157,
0.0234956723,
0.0014156366,
0.0033692583,
0.0156158358,
-0.0051718792,
0.0206594653,
0.0403867513,
0.0381612368,
-0.0688186586,
0.0335832536,
-0.0395796075,
0.0005022341,
0.0064464714,
-0.008751478,
0.0101869609,
0.0095393248,
0.0028042973,
-0.0031111077,
0.0234471429,
-0.0089272941,
-0.0077049509,
0.0549825765,
0.001801416,
-0.0344292447,
-0.035956718,
-0.1098566726,
0.0324471407,
0.0437357835,
-0.0257476177,
-0.0931722224,
0.0071649575,
-0.0113083711,
-0.0487431735,
-0.0305276811,
0.0171276275,
0.0087135909,
-0.0122893574,
-0.025923714,
0.0620761588,
0.0127491336,
0.0148775466,
0.0401184745,
0.0134771354,
0.0194474179,
-0.0340537615,
-0.0042957352,
0.0144181969,
0.0075904876,
0.0030130462,
0.047311563,
0.0234991368,
-0.0592662133,
-0.0405639,
-0.1030383334,
0.0123175159,
-0.0308120549,
-0.0073273205,
0.0479985476,
0.0310132448,
-0.0221421458,
-0.0192749109,
-0.0348860249,
-0.0727179497,
0.0918803141,
0.0135760512,
0.0463801548,
-0.0168410093,
0.0413491689,
-0.0299938023,
-0.0181998257,
-0.018573096,
0.0498624034,
0.0451424867,
-0.0561935045,
-0.0096188523,
-0.0209288634,
-0.0067094839,
-0.057480745,
-0.0141502032,
-0.0318918936,
-0.0377783217,
0.0067745899,
0.0245686173,
0.0403988287,
0.0644677877,
-0.0027305381,
-0.0164809078,
-0.015902875,
0.0079364236,
-0.013533989,
-0.044281736,
0.0001957594,
0.0201425441,
-0.0598511994,
0.0716312602,
0.0343076438,
0.0098846909,
0.0118941925,
-0.0281029325,
0.0022863375,
-0.0377136245,
0.0112131955,
-0.0240345038,
0.064407602,
-0.0203041248,
0.1014641821,
-0.0044514458,
-0.0177671332,
0.0461708941,
-0.0163136795,
0.0260756984,
-0.0527974404,
0.0103999572,
-0.0744886771,
0.0158351734,
-0.0165742841,
0.0300601069,
-0.0280547105,
-0.0721684098,
-0.0309905335,
0.024612898,
0.0148683982,
-0.0047353641,
0.0113674728,
-0.0462410524,
0.0064343815,
-0.0226135273,
-0.0329194479,
-0.0175841283,
-0.0653284267,
0.0425650291,
-0.0173762701,
0.0385720506,
-0.0035288308,
-0.0074298023,
0.0516141877,
-0.0046021962,
0.0163527764,
-0.0479460433,
0.005553185,
0.0246760119,
0.0686341226,
0.0908860564,
-0.0050655454,
0.0057371999,
0.0181441829,
0.0334705077,
-0.0184924807,
0.0195841175,
0.0345046967,
0.0307421442,
0.0077657891,
0.014586865,
-0.0677687228,
0.003668797,
-0.0262060221,
0.0535696372,
-0.0154639445,
-0.0305121262,
0.0898467898,
0.0487220474,
0.0247847997,
-0.0088857245,
-0.0192344338,
0.0219686031,
0.012516614,
0.0249616001,
-0.0486394353,
0.0041099531,
0.00856956,
-0.003720138,
0.0093700867,
-0.0046381801,
-0.0230827928,
-0.0615865774,
0.0057991021,
0.005620379,
-0.0696827695,
-0.0297887772,
-0.0126996161,
-0.0452682003,
-0.037500117,
0.0100673661,
0.0271060243,
-0.0488676615,
-0.001173526,
0.0298949666,
-0.0362368301,
-0.0331025757,
-0.0334585719,
-0.0128193833,
-0.0374750309,
0.0250384472,
0.0289716031,
-0.0274902768,
0.0466408134,
-0.0381170809,
-0.0473686382,
-0.0142429732,
-0.0258570202,
0.0451310501,
-0.0199336298,
-0.0121040205,
-0.0557938181,
0.0560700595,
0.0443347469,
0.0046760347,
0.0212215446,
-0.0127634155,
0.0167323854,
-0.0138379317,
-0.0320476331,
0.0315094367,
0.0193129014,
0.0418429263,
0.0443327576,
-0.0287142806,
-0.0559536256,
-0.042871125,
0.0070676492,
-0.077845566,
-0.0607304275,
0.0162109304,
-0.0715380982,
-0.0565686114,
-0.0645314753,
-0.1057825908,
0.0310514029,
0.0247391388,
0.0483834483,
0.0121084638,
-0.0180654917,
-0.0096997982,
-0.0720136911,
-0.0371701047,
-0.0182453711,
-0.0207536817,
-0.0484145507,
0.0110701062,
0.055813849,
-0.005588864,
-0.027760148,
0.0457503013,
-0.0479343235,
-0.037131913,
-0.0135023668,
0.0195999481,
0.0161060505,
0.0084584113,
-0.0058725947,
-0.0622358583,
0.0622866713,
0.0240095891,
0.0273468066,
-0.0137075707,
-0.0217820033,
0.0132243121,
-0.0048614787,
0.0546055548,
-0.0262519121,
0.0312676765,
-0.0208491106,
0.063570179,
-0.0084253009,
0.0451662764,
0.0251838025,
0.0291337632,
-0.0006083864,
-0.0846131742,
-0.0275176615,
-0.0539428778,
-0.0191694237,
-0.0138421208,
-0.0187676623,
-0.0228043087,
0.0319822915,
0.0257651247,
0.0318702385,
-0.0307247266,
0.0632998049,
-0.0317889936,
0.0292980894,
-0.0685449988,
0.0080080377,
0.0242333058,
0.0407474339,
-0.0214421824,
-0.0075489259,
-0.0351201668,
-0.0160884112,
-0.0174206402,
0.0073933043,
0.0129846483,
0.0262257066,
0.0212905388,
0.0147336852,
0.0218545478,
0.0313357115,
0.0134512,
0.0155018456,
-0.0418957584,
0.0527976379,
0.0693859234,
-0.0368530639,
0.0605829097,
-0.0255856551,
-0.0112792989,
0.0014229077,
0.062326476,
-0.0051639127,
-0.0424377583,
0.0044840793,
-0.0115783792,
-0.0269054994,
-0.0219438616,
0.0725142062,
-0.0100630624,
-0.0226868447,
0.078188926,
-0.0401163623,
-0.0405558571,
-0.0161734968,
0.0255975015,
0.0229352489,
0.0544512086,
-0.0094187846,
-0.0660255477,
0.0002509801,
0.003569019,
-0.0187196694,
0.0386048108,
-0.0035615331,
0.012840881,
0.0539556071,
0.0411424302,
0.0048260447,
-0.056776531,
0.0093504386,
-0.0881995559,
-0.0422725864,
0.0294570737,
-5.427277254e-33,
-0.0393014401,
-0.0190735888,
-0.0162329059,
0.0148961507,
-0.0288798977,
0.0170979984,
-0.0557234511,
-0.0081476001,
0.0162073188,
0.0048945914,
-0.0281554088,
0.0090089599,
0.0160328448,
0.0441769287,
0.0388219357,
0.0024133807,
0.0354828723,
0.035607446,
-0.0283186417,
0.0439343639,
0.0444774888,
0.0103269443,
0.0701928511,
0.0144639648,
0.0008291619,
-0.0736672804,
-0.0354934186,
0.0018046554,
0.0246107597,
0.01318976,
0.0021771332,
0.0179379024,
0.0536763817,
-0.0410737619,
-0.0214604922,
0.0257538669,
-0.0438862257,
-0.0195567198,
0.0421068482,
0.0353490524,
-0.0395293534,
-0.0046595945,
0.048856277,
-0.0395447388,
0.0195700247,
0.0237158742,
0.0444813743,
-0.0083682165,
-0.0137702171,
-0.0717344135,
-0.0690233782,
0.0220012348,
-0.0182869527,
0.0129450345,
-0.0006115844,
0.0327027999,
0.0071793431,
0.0254191235,
-0.0226683784,
0.022271866,
0.0286245272,
0.0648954511,
0.0914577171,
0.0234224554,
-0.029510688,
0.038568031,
0.0075368527,
-0.0129438825,
0.0075131939,
0.0956221074,
-0.0242061913,
0.043208994,
0.0049733142,
0.0488803349,
0.041702915,
-0.0535043366,
-0.0344673097,
0.0553374998,
0.0343281291,
-0.0045911865,
0.0059163803,
-0.0385229178,
-0.0331240557,
-0.0151871582,
0.0086083645,
-0.0062985388,
-0.0239376538,
-0.0344726481,
0.0401530862,
-0.0083574066,
-0.051470127,
0.0491220616,
0.011947603,
-0.0105497139,
0.0199402068,
0.0265312809,
-0.0392030142,
0.0338364467,
-0.020890886,
0.0258295126,
-0.0370067246,
-0.0301430449,
-0.0104457987,
0.0422564782,
0.0071572829,
-0.0186051503,
0.0529898293,
-0.0132418219,
-0.0540172383,
-0.0059467573,
-0.0086905947,
0.0668957978,
-0.0503245145,
0.0036589098,
0.0033965884,
-0.0089583499,
-0.0308276657,
-0.0220471639,
0.0393783227,
0.0120143304,
-0.0072182869,
0.000614782,
-0.0042765304,
0.0447266959,
-0.016610181,
0.0398204587,
-0.0563147254,
-0.0134991575,
0.0024589535,
-0.0513500273,
-0.0232093632,
0.0157902017,
2.242e-7,
-0.0261933971,
0.0588450432,
0.0366831757,
0.0277159978,
-0.0155997854,
-0.0149242403,
-0.0279679671,
0.0470264144,
-0.0135436105,
0.024947349,
0.0113745239,
-0.0124700274,
0.025766369,
0.0197634269,
-0.1154814065,
-0.0013291102,
-0.0859320089,
-0.0112017952,
-0.0846183524,
-0.004943429,
0.0080576129,
0.0394839793,
0.0000405617,
-0.02664157,
-0.0002923896,
0.0190017484,
0.047972247,
0.0077113351,
-0.0447589755,
0.0521621369,
0.039564684,
0.0349718928,
-0.0201828498,
-0.0421261229,
-0.0267355386,
-0.0259686895,
0.0509355403,
0.0506679825,
0.0294188149,
0.0065628625,
0.024675604,
0.0216194708,
0.0025006423,
-0.0616937429,
0.0438842066,
0.0007103252,
-0.0454779603,
-0.0550911576,
-0.0342141576,
-0.0164513327,
0.0113572301,
-0.0468262471,
-0.0157446191,
0.0201067328,
-0.0107068606,
-0.0316214338,
0.0038667731,
-0.0222498253,
-0.0519861877,
0.0313826315,
-0.001561993,
-0.0070175021,
-0.0100311786,
0.001889027,
0.0016371742,
-0.0569047816,
-0.0071967589,
2.000581183e-34,
0.0636209697,
0.0191072784,
-0.0049070707,
-0.0218134597,
0.0163609181,
0.0008005323,
-0.0157548357,
0.0306868181,
0.011238087,
-0.0258620232,
-0.0177854113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17741v1 | End-to-end Joint Rich and Normalized ASR with a limited amount of rich training data | 2023-11-29T15:44:39 | 2023-11-29T15:44:39 | Can Cui, Imran Ahamad Sheikh, Mostafa Sadeghi, Emmanuel Vincent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Joint rich and normalized automatic speech recognition (ASR), that produces
transcriptions both with and without punctuation and capitalization, remains a
challenge. End-to-end (E2E) ASR models offer both convenience and the ability
to perform such joint transcription of speech. Training such models requires
paired speech and rich text data, which is not widely available. In this paper,
we compare two different approaches to train a stateless Transducer-based E2E
joint rich and normalized ASR system, ready for streaming applications, with a
limited amount of rich labeled data. The first approach uses a language model
to generate pseudo-rich transcriptions of normalized training data. The second
approach uses a single decoder conditioned on the type of the output. The first
approach leads to E2E rich ASR which perform better on out-of-domain data, with
up to 9% relative reduction in errors. The second approach demonstrates the
feasibility of an E2E joint rich and normalized ASR system using as low as 5%
rich training data with moderate (2.42% absolute) increase in errors. | [
-0.0286222342,
0.0240514316,
0.0328634419,
0.0161794443,
0.0191906337,
0.0192497,
0.0338857695,
0.0119939558,
0.0011810898,
-0.0295737479,
-0.0178728066,
0.0154632283,
0.0422631614,
0.0380106568,
0.0082234871,
-0.0495860204,
-0.0096582351,
-0.0495835729,
0.0003996565,
-0.0340980701,
0.0372642353,
0.0288272258,
-0.0069278404,
0.0379185639,
0.014175022,
0.0360537581,
0.0064937519,
0.0054422496,
0.0263419673,
-0.0195609592,
-0.0084777446,
0.0162799265,
0.0300548784,
0.0225444697,
0.0000020414,
-0.0481830239,
-0.0661403462,
0.026589049,
-0.0305781104,
0.0079312222,
0.0195097383,
-0.0233692825,
-0.0189459771,
0.0646453723,
0.002164823,
-0.0382381827,
0.0482842475,
0.0373271592,
0.002413115,
0.0477712825,
-0.0270810854,
-0.0825393945,
0.0344647318,
0.0008101484,
-0.076254867,
-0.035222698,
-0.0163042098,
0.0030144448,
0.0153738335,
-0.0303070769,
-0.0056930766,
0.0465972722,
-0.0118247084,
-0.0106764846,
0.0049870578,
0.0087459944,
-0.0720012635,
-0.025782207,
-0.0257669669,
0.0585765503,
-0.0037628845,
-0.0369059555,
0.0565950274,
0.0074356943,
-0.0418998599,
-0.0651431754,
0.0209842157,
0.020936016,
-0.0199397206,
0.039485395,
0.0119126365,
-0.0051555899,
0.0097902147,
-0.0519414023,
-0.0297731794,
-0.0260430947,
0.0129932538,
-0.0413089842,
-0.0119656157,
0.0132589377,
0.0092233252,
-0.014515738,
0.080077596,
-0.0132082133,
0.0135881547,
-0.0225877184,
-0.056709718,
-0.0729724392,
-0.045751337,
-0.0259014405,
0.0092551028,
0.0515223593,
-0.0598204359,
0.0025028095,
-0.0312928371,
0.0100495592,
0.0177086163,
-0.007909596,
-0.0108351801,
-0.0245359112,
-0.0143816164,
0.0080460124,
-0.0529597476,
0.0442992225,
-0.0195351262,
-0.056799151,
-0.0536054149,
-0.01552686,
0.0272567663,
0.0052764118,
0.0620381013,
-0.0319903903,
-0.0565666817,
-0.0257441849,
0.0675140694,
0.048661381,
0.0181800146,
0.0282716621,
0.0032247663,
-0.0553476699,
0.0142035233,
0.0319071561,
0.0735407993,
0.031592723,
-0.0084882807,
0.0287230983,
-0.0213973187,
-0.0226793755,
-0.0688002408,
-0.0099766189,
-0.0317402408,
-0.0023789424,
-0.0429351702,
-0.0601794347,
0.0042074481,
0.0480879657,
0.0197887849,
-0.0244600289,
0.0244901069,
-0.0264196154,
0.0197034534,
0.0821256936,
-0.0325126424,
0.0032589755,
0.0264365375,
-0.0373580307,
0.0314110331,
0.0404133908,
0.090103507,
-0.0692745745,
0.0051978333,
-0.0238009933,
-0.0177593324,
0.0820884705,
-0.0385817923,
-0.0234561618,
-0.0463627987,
-0.0166334063,
0.039605733,
-0.0051304237,
0.0152071351,
0.0539945737,
-0.0170104858,
0.0447743349,
0.0311376378,
0.0021327296,
0.0405925363,
-0.0085134851,
0.0382241122,
0.0124263149,
-0.0052442495,
-0.0130991507,
0.0412541926,
-0.0211286489,
-0.0087423371,
0.0196318496,
0.0746725425,
0.010733787,
-0.0134856105,
-0.0000110799,
0.0018016138,
-0.0405420586,
-0.0159691498,
-0.0005845688,
0.0703706369,
0.0017339697,
-0.0694736019,
0.0129503608,
-0.0010984947,
-0.0675182343,
0.0131868664,
-0.0062380787,
-0.023611933,
0.0305013955,
0.0254236795,
-0.0332857408,
0.0073501505,
-0.0607480668,
-0.0142304236,
0.0480827242,
0.001455657,
0.0136157377,
0.0563599914,
-0.1029746681,
-0.0109894117,
0.0746065825,
0.0087318951,
0.0445996635,
-0.0399736539,
0.0454026572,
0.022753831,
-0.010609624,
0.002717579,
-0.0103253294,
-0.0049711075,
-0.0066002472,
0.0118946219,
0.0050870357,
0.0408087969,
0.028090829,
-0.0300262328,
0.0058305897,
0.0254059769,
-0.0546468161,
-0.0054766987,
0.0271152314,
-0.0724757016,
-0.030899616,
0.0002176853,
-0.0550198629,
0.008311416,
0.0840511397,
0.0609041601,
-0.1007129773,
-0.026027536,
-0.0221211594,
0.0522796139,
-0.0432452299,
0.0606504008,
0.0514966473,
0.0240802113,
0.0113425273,
-0.0178635418,
0.0148429824,
-0.0033858325,
-0.0147125935,
-0.0708708912,
0.0238786694,
-0.0737186,
-0.0330461711,
0.008779102,
-0.0154729392,
0.0028751311,
0.0186033584,
0.0048119943,
0.0089117344,
-0.0172982141,
-0.0556725115,
-0.0110231079,
-0.0424067192,
0.0261021443,
-0.0079077538,
0.0663838312,
-0.0058825151,
-0.0473418944,
-0.0114082294,
0.0010286969,
0.0150888292,
-0.0142507302,
-0.002180659,
0.0039771269,
-0.0413628668,
-0.0007578491,
0.0011234531,
0.0085210586,
0.00011724,
0.0072170459,
-0.0506868325,
-0.0689292774,
0.053683605,
0.071096845,
0.0645288378,
0.0251362249,
-0.0230093673,
0.0186929237,
-0.0029447686,
0.0334905311,
0.0176410414,
-0.0089296103,
-0.0375587866,
-0.0062946267,
0.0075705564,
-0.0546170808,
-0.0115440683,
0.0271776915,
0.0230220705,
-0.013150854,
0.011930869,
-0.0338967443,
0.0438460335,
0.0086674923,
0.0601248108,
-0.0470338985,
-0.0304203704,
-0.0056767026,
-0.0366225578,
0.0121570257,
-0.0013898549,
-0.0362613052,
-0.0077354792,
0.0058298688,
-0.0115223909,
0.0312306453,
-0.0743046254,
-0.0659463927,
-0.0394694358,
-0.0237313285,
-0.0159956999,
-0.0035909289,
-0.0294695199,
0.0016622143,
-0.0172272976,
-0.0963201225,
0.009833945,
0.0176103022,
0.0153252445,
-0.0514630154,
0.0220698137,
-0.0226308592,
0.0275335293,
-0.0184833258,
-0.0531036071,
0.0079282876,
0.0020386144,
-0.0636290088,
0.030168958,
0.0199366827,
-0.0328140855,
0.0010992927,
0.0619810522,
0.0180845615,
0.1080233753,
0.0135325221,
0.0192001723,
-0.0474172719,
0.0786606222,
0.0275499467,
-0.0137292566,
-0.0702335015,
-0.0360191241,
0.0491433814,
-0.0163558424,
0.0490404405,
0.027515322,
-0.0097056869,
-0.0305349808,
0.045585379,
0.0104310382,
-0.0205195956,
0.0047674775,
0.0377912037,
-0.0302787907,
0.004055128,
0.0993515253,
-0.0163844153,
-0.0380004235,
-0.0447315983,
0.0079165287,
0.0187114887,
0.0151458168,
-0.0249792673,
-0.0664796382,
-0.0436301902,
0.0565005541,
0.0765695721,
0.0290421937,
-0.005666384,
0.0089506321,
-0.0918057859,
-0.0137223853,
0.024306437,
-0.0530626848,
-0.0434080884,
-0.024176091,
-0.0325267464,
-0.00364161,
0.0178142209,
0.0185850095,
-0.0020024066,
-0.015351017,
0.0420798101,
-0.0890219584,
-0.0878264084,
-0.0262993164,
-0.0356046371,
0.1091512889,
0.0600467138,
0.0136335557,
-0.0179661214,
0.0214872118,
0.0206495319,
-0.0105622048,
-0.0064095939,
-0.0440586209,
0.0000807217,
0.0139189549,
-0.0468752272,
0.0117476005,
0.0377290957,
0.0249219872,
0.0283978824,
0.0226980206,
0.0390646569,
-0.0041909483,
-0.0031065568,
0.0387259126,
0.0020070528,
0.0222019311,
0.0587842427,
-0.0097748144,
-0.0369620845,
-0.0272613782,
0.0164350122,
0.0260445848,
-0.0515850112,
-0.0166904833,
0.0074002002,
-0.0200963654,
-0.033784952,
-0.0229735672,
-0.0172551516,
0.0566172116,
-0.0057577211,
0.0072546192,
0.0103919813,
0.0097213099,
0.0321775004,
-0.0206466801,
-0.0120846964,
-0.0388132073,
0.0046422617,
-0.0685494989,
-0.0127965277,
0.0040087281,
-0.0506226607,
-0.0186265949,
0.0134366853,
-0.002060394,
-0.0366282724,
0.02509767,
-0.0116454531,
0.0182324629,
0.026134111,
-0.0176637396,
-0.0293215066,
0.0379554853,
0.0360441282,
-0.0578528456,
0.0274504535,
0.0510255694,
0.0048307017,
-0.0074859504,
0.0284227021,
-0.0534812622,
0.0305315629,
-0.0292286724,
0.039939478,
-0.0227161441,
-0.0635072291,
0.0293669701,
0.0449208356,
0.076065287,
0.0019350931,
0.0013516498,
-0.019269729,
0.0366654433,
-0.0426809117,
0.0581773967,
-0.0513701588,
0.0584222376,
0.0055074571,
0.0415289737,
-0.0357558876,
0.0218690112,
-0.0438772738,
-0.0195632391,
-0.0478487834,
0.0860690102,
0.0360051244,
-0.031104885,
0.0475371629,
-0.0153430607,
-0.0197240505,
0.0453161858,
0.0807071775,
0.0120294495,
-0.0206853449,
0.0150088007,
-0.0097313616,
0.0178081077,
0.0238211527,
0.0041684443,
-0.0156158693,
0.0478161424,
0.0157553721,
0.0467562713,
0.0316402502,
0.0191488527,
0.071771577,
0.0075522433,
0.030055562,
-0.0571901463,
0.0565633141,
0.0024986328,
-0.0080941524,
0.0136284037,
-0.0282818414,
-0.0226750616,
0.0445836224,
0.0551578104,
-0.0106946118,
0.0311556887,
-0.0264744386,
0.0353828408,
-0.0483742729,
0.0088171009,
0.0051303557,
-0.0113854492,
-0.039350342,
-0.0254536625,
0.0116961207,
-0.0527507477,
0.0234615244,
-0.0222561751,
0.0106876744,
-0.0440423898,
-0.0182391834,
-0.02968321,
-0.051862143,
0.0039702523,
0.0123767629,
-0.0058731721,
-0.0104496405,
-0.0143580744,
0.0179846343,
-6.741440265e-33,
-0.0000664492,
0.0706701353,
-0.0136087248,
0.0125713684,
-0.0208528116,
0.0459955409,
-0.0126585243,
-0.0051869075,
0.0116098197,
-0.0173344407,
-0.0284277685,
0.0003047931,
0.0420884192,
-0.0006367071,
-0.0122623583,
0.0108371526,
0.0858997256,
-0.0460435338,
0.0027039142,
0.0111902412,
0.0351317078,
0.0692492872,
0.0315735638,
-0.0887596756,
-0.0351521,
-0.0053192503,
-0.0085758483,
-0.0073918146,
0.0647641048,
0.0142249363,
0.0166579578,
0.0574581437,
-0.0083545567,
-0.0463280715,
-0.0171741042,
0.0458372831,
-0.1215552762,
0.0250324439,
-0.0092694266,
0.0364593752,
0.0008600042,
-0.0105139306,
0.0292954221,
-0.0203347281,
-0.0154295349,
0.0064822673,
0.0223848596,
-0.0159173943,
0.0097777657,
-0.0662228391,
0.0162983537,
0.0569526143,
-0.0131012797,
-0.0201293584,
0.0646469146,
0.0585253946,
0.0049879979,
-0.03290594,
-0.0382050574,
0.0215892568,
0.0160497576,
0.0517436303,
0.0302867349,
0.0132531608,
-0.000141318,
-0.0255116764,
0.0367291942,
-0.0164060853,
-0.0000829373,
-0.0479734838,
0.0270092804,
-0.0095518865,
0.0012807547,
0.0063656005,
0.0268184096,
-0.0134628378,
-0.0478010401,
-0.0307298936,
0.0075071314,
-0.0313399583,
0.0052669197,
0.0195878595,
-0.0705412552,
-0.020137528,
-0.048717048,
-0.0045639365,
-0.0258621965,
0.0205344986,
0.062201295,
0.0410287566,
-0.0072681182,
0.0296914503,
0.0558298454,
-0.0112921651,
0.0008490419,
-0.0019327224,
0.026933467,
-0.0064696884,
-0.0220208727,
0.0287695639,
-0.0615938604,
-0.0330379419,
0.0264308993,
0.0293848291,
0.0136191705,
-0.0181529913,
-0.0075310105,
0.052279532,
-0.0916303247,
-0.0178107508,
0.0147185344,
0.028021086,
-0.0119208256,
0.0037066685,
0.0370317586,
-0.0123822978,
0.0269129612,
0.0271499939,
-0.0173876528,
0.0382661633,
-0.0148905534,
-0.0633233041,
0.0362040438,
0.0390703864,
-0.027456576,
-0.0008415105,
0.0151767619,
0.0012227959,
0.0423138216,
0.0046276771,
-0.0100744683,
0.0100016445,
2.797e-7,
-0.0111933891,
0.0248026941,
0.0444865935,
-0.0338094011,
0.0034686083,
0.0050828159,
0.0058727278,
0.0375461914,
0.0177943334,
0.0038140176,
-0.0267313775,
-0.0372893102,
0.1027792096,
0.0051044305,
-0.1186853647,
-0.063406907,
-0.0245437846,
0.0295585394,
-0.0297174919,
0.0036171221,
0.0504409187,
0.0548351854,
-0.0270137824,
-0.015717065,
-0.0050032651,
-0.0239550583,
0.0075452118,
0.0027569719,
0.0365371928,
-0.0407242663,
0.0186725836,
-0.0142677398,
-0.0300314315,
0.036774721,
-0.0271859635,
0.0383354127,
0.030824488,
0.0613380857,
-0.0024814638,
-0.0013035939,
0.0408153236,
0.038688805,
-0.0740114972,
0.0219236538,
0.0596861094,
-0.029581096,
0.0091632269,
-0.0230215564,
-0.0726050958,
-0.0213940274,
-0.0252385046,
0.002366693,
0.0214437749,
0.0215487015,
0.0228799265,
-0.0025445945,
-0.0112644099,
-0.0359790772,
-0.0125839142,
-0.0256177168,
-0.0172415357,
0.0104336496,
-0.022647664,
0.0247137174,
0.0166562907,
-0.0309269037,
0.0078988113,
2.433397055e-34,
0.032556694,
-0.0441180319,
0.0158730466,
-0.0192414988,
-0.0165930334,
-0.0529090911,
0.0221159346,
0.0225348733,
-0.0197328757,
-0.0864418894,
-0.0409213565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17722v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17722v1 | SenTest: Evaluating Robustness of Sentence Encoders | 2023-11-29T15:21:35 | 2023-11-29T15:21:35 | Tanmay Chavan, Shantanu Patankar, Aditya Kane, Omkar Gokhale, Geetanjali Kale, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive learning has proven to be an effective method for pre-training
models using weakly labeled data in the vision domain. Sentence transformers
are the NLP counterparts to this architecture, and have been growing in
popularity due to their rich and effective sentence representations. Having
effective sentence representations is paramount in multiple tasks, such as
information retrieval, retrieval augmented generation (RAG), and sentence
comparison. Keeping in mind the deployability factor of transformers,
evaluating the robustness of sentence transformers is of utmost importance.
This work focuses on evaluating the robustness of the sentence encoders. We
employ several adversarial attacks to evaluate its robustness. This system uses
character-level attacks in the form of random character substitution,
word-level attacks in the form of synonym replacement, and sentence-level
attacks in the form of intra-sentence word order shuffling. The results of the
experiments strongly undermine the robustness of sentence encoders. The models
produce significantly different predictions as well as embeddings on perturbed
datasets. The accuracy of the models can fall up to 15 percent on perturbed
datasets as compared to unperturbed datasets. Furthermore, the experiments
demonstrate that these embeddings does capture the semantic and syntactic
structure (sentence order) of sentences. However, existing supervised
classification strategies fail to leverage this information, and merely
function as n-gram detectors. | [
0.0434108861,
0.0674270615,
-0.0247438662,
0.0570366681,
-0.0423030891,
-0.0008080734,
-0.0019798421,
-0.0131286401,
0.0116627002,
-0.0680503324,
-0.0143873738,
-0.010277424,
0.0063824765,
-0.010824251,
0.0536666363,
-0.0450922884,
0.0152049838,
0.0144043947,
-0.0499042831,
0.0208339114,
0.0263350848,
-0.0122541934,
0.0072205369,
0.0418626405,
0.0058915839,
0.0001278699,
0.0094357692,
0.0290348474,
0.0432705805,
-0.0282713212,
0.063578032,
0.0372753777,
0.0098307645,
0.0525790341,
0.0000018645,
0.0025230534,
-0.00376796,
0.0027137604,
0.001435294,
0.0298307128,
0.0523745231,
-0.0462447032,
0.0042186361,
0.0247017313,
-0.0233208947,
-0.0313586853,
0.0239188913,
0.083542794,
0.0834817216,
0.0988664478,
-0.0272208471,
-0.0632771105,
0.0224364586,
-0.0528662503,
-0.0323901996,
-0.0144569017,
0.0311225485,
-0.0591805801,
-0.0224147178,
0.0522504412,
-0.0215851329,
0.0229453295,
0.0240320396,
-0.0066321483,
-0.0164514966,
0.0125907026,
-0.0470152013,
-0.0120133022,
-0.022807071,
0.0592420362,
-0.0310742836,
0.0010824116,
-0.0220159404,
0.0113058332,
0.0097503169,
0.0047279722,
-0.0134890396,
-0.0109019578,
0.0468142889,
0.022442393,
-0.0204616692,
0.0341521911,
0.0029558579,
-0.0120639317,
0.0006015738,
0.0094408235,
0.049153246,
-0.0422560088,
-0.0205620565,
0.0087652029,
-0.0251371395,
-0.0196127612,
-0.0021753351,
-0.0058839824,
-0.0128121143,
0.0014725906,
-0.0775224119,
-0.0785690397,
0.0225276724,
-0.0668905601,
0.0347098336,
-0.0113524562,
-0.033761479,
0.0120931966,
-0.0475914851,
0.0774388164,
-0.0284007657,
0.052115649,
-0.0371678956,
0.005949595,
-0.0332972966,
-0.0357476287,
-0.0126467356,
0.0448651016,
-0.0468389243,
-0.0080853431,
-0.0630365163,
0.0107569229,
-0.0095163304,
0.0167914052,
-0.0072883568,
0.0334032476,
-0.0229365453,
0.0187993497,
-0.0154673839,
-0.0143252332,
-0.0076360796,
0.0100998813,
0.0096042948,
-0.0683809593,
-0.0358439833,
0.0260515828,
-0.0047905659,
-0.0447117165,
0.0075080241,
0.106929183,
0.0070785391,
-0.0742315575,
-0.0394081585,
-0.0192162935,
-0.0542383604,
-0.0429514833,
-0.0041879793,
-0.0249475408,
-0.0011021111,
-0.0060237683,
-0.0193007104,
-0.0505796298,
0.0213121157,
0.0294377208,
-0.0352433436,
0.081893608,
0.0385209285,
-0.0682871267,
-0.0281596035,
0.0081812497,
0.0306193829,
0.0324835815,
0.0041498472,
0.0505063869,
0.0280474108,
0.0144430855,
0.031327378,
-0.0111291055,
-0.0017125575,
0.0080105839,
-0.0004749531,
0.0113104424,
-0.0015727011,
-0.0113773663,
-0.0211657174,
0.0823671967,
-0.028812699,
-0.0193847604,
0.078712061,
0.0132783502,
-0.0029085374,
0.0190794393,
0.0169428457,
-0.0201180801,
-0.0117163025,
0.0242856219,
-0.0493950285,
-0.0066761295,
-0.0122123025,
-0.0140893906,
-0.0058531933,
0.0375803821,
-0.0247880667,
-0.0464467257,
-0.0203907397,
-0.0236200318,
0.0078031151,
-0.0352317616,
0.0290006027,
0.041676797,
-0.0439838804,
0.0179836135,
-0.0068282448,
-0.0563034602,
-0.0260228384,
-0.0261887386,
-0.0409431793,
0.0370320529,
0.066803202,
-0.0386405177,
0.0132212825,
-0.0112384586,
0.000456601,
0.0301374141,
0.0173179284,
0.030791685,
0.0177817307,
-0.0243769046,
-0.0046528331,
-0.0857982859,
0.0205792859,
0.0418741293,
0.0216015894,
0.039345406,
0.0236444138,
-0.0293696746,
-0.0227913298,
0.0546550862,
0.0415009148,
-0.0413706526,
0.0256315451,
0.0242095795,
0.0145948883,
0.0062975897,
-0.0371966325,
0.0243753549,
0.0538090169,
-0.047012087,
-0.0472573079,
0.0327154063,
-0.0058329548,
-0.0999688432,
-0.0006209844,
-0.068898268,
-0.0117857726,
0.0918601379,
-0.0610594861,
0.005776458,
0.0309068747,
-0.058210101,
0.0067951577,
-0.0191803984,
0.0141543411,
0.01721894,
0.059239544,
-0.0393179469,
0.0683542788,
-0.02372499,
0.0090449778,
-0.0211643931,
0.015397327,
0.0352679491,
-0.0130453873,
-0.0555904508,
0.0050148675,
-0.0227965824,
-0.0043022335,
0.0263170525,
-0.009810322,
0.0074560908,
-0.034724433,
-0.02048558,
-0.0130479177,
-0.0330503061,
0.022492867,
0.0235039312,
-0.0015923552,
0.0246859957,
-0.0195172448,
-0.0070128287,
0.028768871,
-0.0013384045,
0.0252428465,
0.0597780682,
-0.0012017585,
-0.0178333521,
-0.0217599533,
-0.0175395478,
-0.0109742908,
0.1070523262,
-0.0149112381,
-0.0117338207,
-0.0447449572,
0.0395956971,
0.0078086653,
0.0265721809,
-0.0026359376,
-0.0864285752,
0.0200484823,
0.0353713483,
0.0258941539,
0.0892577469,
0.0474453233,
0.0948880985,
0.0132099213,
0.0363096595,
0.0292707793,
-0.0156731103,
-0.0051429742,
0.000540237,
-0.0377941541,
0.0096238172,
0.0096456036,
0.0546417497,
0.0342795923,
-0.0023791601,
-0.0153127257,
0.0234238263,
0.0035566587,
-0.0480517037,
-0.0036133609,
-0.0053722598,
-0.0307279434,
-0.0212095696,
-0.0361658745,
-0.0025187808,
0.0702092499,
-0.0302017871,
0.0025480078,
-0.0278313644,
-0.0442564338,
-0.0074084364,
0.0603005365,
0.0341561697,
0.0164748468,
0.0022046426,
-0.0070114727,
-0.05146759,
-0.0348150358,
0.0363805592,
-0.0174195915,
0.0085285045,
0.0129564349,
-0.0126993163,
-0.0213827491,
-0.0647792071,
-0.0676932409,
-0.0723571703,
-0.0098820673,
0.0078750271,
0.0590017922,
-0.0135973766,
-0.0650876164,
-0.0221810322,
0.0142956665,
0.0163413268,
-0.0241338015,
-0.0068325815,
-0.0360710807,
0.0693562999,
0.0556861088,
-0.0236441772,
0.0004477756,
-0.0262212474,
0.0273301322,
0.070671469,
-0.0489211902,
0.0068176333,
-0.0425519608,
-0.006263304,
-0.0078957817,
-0.037292134,
0.0338117294,
-0.0030886296,
0.0341353416,
-0.0293642469,
-0.0379334576,
0.0713594258,
0.0202618875,
0.0230585188,
0.0258126743,
0.047561679,
0.0267338138,
0.0272538997,
0.0104798274,
-0.071010612,
-0.0435314998,
-0.0102665061,
0.0200054273,
-0.0023842782,
0.0096699269,
-0.0062089227,
-0.1192139089,
0.0176563393,
-0.0046150037,
-0.016225379,
-0.0526733436,
0.0087349406,
-0.0146869998,
-0.0172550511,
0.0237225872,
-0.0088453908,
0.015273191,
0.0105530024,
-0.0061465115,
0.0066496488,
-0.0464042351,
-0.0134458467,
-0.0301201437,
0.0006526163,
0.0657524988,
0.0320178308,
-0.021129692,
-0.030286314,
0.0394121669,
-0.0318072625,
-0.0069666789,
0.0504480898,
0.1042476669,
-0.036253538,
-0.0176983569,
-0.0211043134,
0.0265541244,
-0.0309872311,
-0.0321984999,
-0.0080502527,
-0.0009646728,
-0.0028245486,
-0.0261016935,
-0.0295969788,
0.0003136806,
0.0059569208,
0.066989623,
0.0348148458,
-0.0343361683,
-0.073182717,
-0.0406253599,
0.0158856548,
-0.0686695278,
-0.032272879,
0.025692543,
0.0492564999,
0.00505317,
-0.0991076007,
-0.0636783391,
-0.0286240503,
-0.005043318,
-0.0211376175,
-0.0227747895,
-0.0384914689,
0.008353523,
-0.0501268394,
-0.016211139,
0.0213829279,
0.0241731219,
-0.0274993535,
-0.010532341,
0.0317762755,
0.0000694249,
-0.0330856666,
-0.0119225234,
-0.0767504275,
-0.0813127682,
0.0237999856,
0.0521284342,
0.0033042338,
-0.000663668,
-0.027351765,
-0.0230607558,
0.0615511574,
0.0752642304,
-0.003253775,
0.0140161365,
0.0643410683,
-0.0430291258,
0.0143116647,
0.0300574936,
-0.041449286,
0.0174327437,
0.0173469614,
0.0007317282,
0.022482723,
-0.0334647857,
0.0234653298,
0.0115231927,
0.0677230433,
-0.0140597327,
0.0052536335,
0.011201161,
0.0432024077,
-0.0413173214,
-0.0134753147,
-0.0261940546,
0.0100454399,
0.0173037443,
0.056535773,
-0.0173608959,
0.0206239261,
0.0014277818,
0.0272328816,
0.0194195528,
0.0205278452,
0.0153849544,
-0.0066957544,
-0.0197561961,
0.047339268,
-0.0208002254,
0.0064460724,
-0.0222598929,
0.0369112529,
-0.0074802106,
-0.0048564617,
0.0282908566,
-0.0123414062,
-0.0089415442,
0.0648690239,
-0.1083341986,
0.0554491915,
-0.0581736192,
-0.0201291405,
0.0329494588,
-0.0153701873,
0.0234899912,
-0.0353843793,
-0.0101303561,
-0.0109191258,
0.0316884927,
-0.015315148,
-0.0053848904,
0.0125855561,
0.0046127122,
-0.022817811,
0.0233538952,
0.081407696,
-0.0006489549,
0.0198491439,
0.0253157131,
-0.0302807465,
-0.0484722182,
-0.0163289607,
0.0279491507,
-0.0158200637,
0.0027610958,
-0.0158324223,
-0.0123564377,
-0.0658273101,
0.0691960976,
0.0136816138,
0.0255715977,
0.0302466005,
0.022155324,
0.0203038529,
0.0347503535,
0.0256794766,
-0.0401699804,
0.0194595456,
-0.0064646187,
-0.0412182882,
-0.0138409669,
-5.795548247e-33,
-0.0092207594,
-0.004901547,
-0.0464785211,
-0.0430299044,
0.0021009883,
0.0002450388,
-0.035213232,
-0.0260367393,
-0.0116979992,
0.0274364315,
0.0056020035,
0.0045249457,
-0.0125801452,
0.0483666509,
-0.0336341858,
-0.0667264238,
0.0511818975,
0.0082303053,
-0.0154745653,
-0.0221575107,
0.0473216213,
0.0498255827,
0.0561401285,
-0.0442265868,
-0.011134279,
-0.0147034619,
-0.0136417318,
-0.0184876565,
-0.0202908367,
0.0586059429,
0.0029954226,
0.0544353798,
-0.0002754182,
-0.0116202738,
0.0186522026,
0.0277748387,
-0.0493866429,
-0.0283786021,
-0.0375608839,
0.0309497975,
-0.0472174101,
-0.0480623767,
0.0139376195,
-0.0332729965,
0.0001019782,
-0.0176755358,
0.0312553681,
-0.009454133,
0.0390030891,
-0.0230608676,
-0.0381809026,
-0.0064372304,
-0.0129637364,
0.0007670417,
-0.0261250753,
0.0561699495,
0.0368739404,
0.0440625325,
-0.05082573,
-0.0019965377,
0.0007046889,
0.0596258752,
-0.0016217933,
0.0107219964,
-0.0142612569,
0.0660650954,
0.0137994988,
0.0007792032,
0.0111246258,
0.0009349063,
-0.0008077406,
0.0374086834,
0.0869355574,
0.1104000732,
0.0430582203,
-0.0015553619,
-0.0851442367,
0.0160423853,
0.0021783251,
0.0133265201,
0.0497655869,
0.0258981232,
-0.0478214882,
0.0067809513,
0.0033884763,
-0.0484531447,
-0.0260460377,
-0.0338855833,
0.0664030984,
0.0090175234,
-0.0227376912,
0.0191480611,
-0.0087527363,
-0.0603075847,
-0.0038474265,
0.0335959382,
-0.0544003434,
-0.0121064223,
0.0020679734,
0.0271038022,
-0.0014951872,
0.0047336328,
0.0538755134,
0.0278859381,
0.0117477272,
-0.0196770132,
0.0711401999,
0.0085275797,
-0.0667206496,
0.0085165473,
-0.0093316678,
0.0209911335,
-0.0243244879,
0.015861962,
0.0023510659,
0.0031132631,
-0.0373944938,
0.004627143,
0.0195458308,
0.0155741815,
-0.0394154303,
-0.0063106408,
0.0199842509,
0.003056162,
0.0164224822,
0.0015531797,
-0.0207496528,
0.0552159548,
0.0052879988,
-0.0933384225,
0.0077137258,
-0.0165105928,
2.696e-7,
0.0369338058,
0.0367982425,
0.0535848178,
0.0012250416,
0.0160477962,
0.0306112748,
-0.007126512,
0.0628161579,
-0.0141049838,
-0.0017727104,
0.0025377122,
0.005305185,
0.0449068621,
-0.0067446097,
-0.0778471008,
0.0262391828,
-0.0934316739,
-0.0408614948,
-0.029966414,
-0.0105941473,
0.1136868373,
0.1133108586,
0.0128064286,
0.0269071534,
-0.0100871241,
-0.0588588603,
0.0448217988,
0.0065723406,
0.0074901269,
-0.0505807027,
0.0030282261,
0.0250297412,
0.0221223906,
0.0014772203,
-0.0440747663,
0.0112204608,
0.0125548486,
0.0049072169,
-0.0097293099,
-0.0675319135,
-0.0376819558,
0.0126967551,
-0.0097549241,
-0.0025183966,
0.077233173,
-0.0682967976,
-0.0196965896,
-0.0019183317,
-0.0532142147,
-0.0045515159,
0.0587061793,
-0.0188919902,
-0.035180077,
-0.0100720786,
0.034365464,
0.0232381355,
-0.0081853606,
-0.0785040036,
-0.0027756239,
0.0092454245,
-0.0271393824,
-0.0184787326,
-0.0365821831,
0.0275742523,
0.043533355,
-0.0398174524,
-0.0265405774,
2.512812259e-34,
0.0288776234,
0.0133317988,
0.013871409,
-0.0082108425,
0.0379536226,
-0.0167091563,
0.0283304825,
-0.0115460362,
0.0109703075,
-0.0612670258,
-0.0260263328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17696v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17696v3 | How to Build an AI Tutor that Can Adapt to Any Course and Provide Accurate Answers Using Large Language Model and Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2023-11-29T15:02:46 | 2024-06-21T09:29:07 | Chenxi Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper proposes a low-code solution to build an AI tutor that leverages
advanced AI techniques to provide accurate and contextually relevant responses
in a personalized learning environment. The OpenAI Assistants API allows AI
Tutor to easily embed, store, retrieve, and manage files and chat history,
enabling a low-code solution. Large Language Models (LLMs) and
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) technology generate sophisticated answers
based on course-specific materials. The application efficiently organizes and
retrieves relevant information through vector embedding and similarity-based
retrieval algorithms. The AI Tutor prototype demonstrates its ability to
generate relevant, accurate answers with source citations. It represents a
significant advancement in technology-enhanced tutoring systems, democratizing
access to high-quality, customized educational support in higher education. | [
0.0545911975,
-0.0229846556,
-0.0476554446,
0.0435371138,
-0.015695421,
-0.0207589231,
0.027637383,
-0.0073690312,
0.0517499186,
-0.0547068119,
-0.0145520652,
0.0167228673,
-0.0361455679,
0.0280476287,
-0.0084070852,
-0.0684201494,
0.0243046787,
0.0141458865,
0.0080850869,
0.0112600196,
0.000264655,
0.0219554361,
-0.0285850856,
0.0745428056,
0.0298432671,
-0.0276790783,
-0.0256989636,
-0.0348350853,
-0.0070714527,
0.0180215482,
0.0136256972,
0.0175762475,
0.0226492751,
0.0065836273,
0.0000019566,
-0.0507031456,
-0.0090677375,
-0.0046375459,
-0.0192335155,
-0.0119260838,
0.0510440022,
0.0937684104,
0.0149422698,
0.0254655369,
-0.0685977116,
-0.0051985062,
0.0309645347,
0.0070745521,
0.0739002079,
0.0557505749,
0.0099535044,
-0.0356032811,
0.037193507,
0.0282057542,
0.0391714163,
-0.0237886608,
0.0200022757,
0.0269224159,
0.0608443245,
0.0347002074,
-0.030274909,
0.0161607228,
-0.0169209838,
-0.0359603278,
0.0538812354,
0.0066188462,
-0.0168863013,
0.0014562169,
0.0014122187,
0.0524035282,
0.0576567426,
-0.0127408747,
-0.0266271681,
0.0073901969,
0.0400704741,
0.0680096298,
-0.069047153,
0.0301933102,
-0.0156322494,
0.0012088865,
0.0375364944,
-0.0296555385,
-0.0335630067,
0.054507304,
0.0129241692,
-0.0057557807,
0.0108104357,
-0.0169181079,
-0.0442009792,
0.0073591643,
0.0203653984,
0.0008077996,
0.0286412816,
0.103489697,
-0.0243343432,
0.0031621477,
-0.026662875,
-0.0674290806,
0.011887054,
-0.0072496757,
0.0658173487,
0.0499234237,
-0.0445825979,
0.0115287369,
0.0039296071,
0.0546456613,
0.0095961913,
-0.0102322856,
-0.0515440367,
0.0013959259,
-0.0588729829,
-0.0051385402,
-0.0377050303,
0.0853525624,
-0.0430437997,
-0.0227866191,
-0.0482567102,
0.02339058,
-0.0458610654,
0.0284683648,
-0.0181031171,
0.0177450981,
-0.0301732328,
0.0113924714,
-0.0379497521,
0.0080128331,
-0.0182693098,
-0.000897816,
0.0167188533,
-0.0404081754,
0.0367883779,
0.0034119661,
0.0157928094,
0.0217195228,
0.0109644718,
0.031817358,
-0.0130478609,
-0.027131943,
-0.0662344545,
-0.0496000312,
0.0291868486,
-0.019379532,
-0.021212792,
-0.0727004632,
0.0196370594,
0.0134283304,
-0.0227658059,
-0.0334334075,
0.0080068056,
0.0511346087,
-0.0377988555,
0.0190112293,
-0.0119593786,
-0.0039041289,
0.0908429399,
0.0347001553,
-0.0210395735,
0.016723102,
0.0143530117,
0.0058827,
0.049208153,
-0.0157615598,
0.0441369265,
-0.0139984172,
0.0206475612,
-0.0130984699,
0.009208193,
0.017744191,
0.0133560225,
0.0187088083,
-0.0538774692,
0.0154721653,
0.0092019476,
-0.0010192615,
0.0195520408,
0.0611278005,
-0.0024938299,
0.0758544505,
0.0268821884,
0.0438948572,
0.0257445648,
0.0023717217,
-0.0046376642,
0.0444185399,
-0.0287552495,
-0.0103197694,
0.0462123305,
0.0249520876,
-0.0063319746,
-0.0706952959,
-0.0067778421,
-0.020788867,
-0.0370516181,
0.0384315327,
0.0226848368,
-0.0374516733,
-0.0260612089,
0.0130310524,
0.0310047027,
-0.0794118792,
0.023735404,
-0.0668601617,
0.0770281926,
0.0887037441,
0.0752872601,
-0.0343557708,
-0.0238621552,
0.0148323663,
0.0248992927,
0.0182730258,
0.0436775871,
-0.0208070613,
-0.0316620097,
-0.0644564554,
0.0050792391,
0.0026195243,
-0.0106116012,
0.0103902724,
0.0302267279,
0.0250208061,
0.0216926243,
-0.006620809,
-0.049071677,
0.0258159637,
-0.0207127705,
-0.0572387651,
-0.0191740636,
0.0240832884,
0.0132729681,
0.0517145433,
0.0006583548,
0.0072277896,
0.0359674096,
-0.022652911,
-0.0159808099,
-0.0507137179,
-0.0294581726,
0.0477093905,
0.0593240708,
-0.0025047469,
0.0168465208,
0.0313076079,
-0.0056491415,
-0.0479210243,
0.0224595498,
-0.0106556732,
0.0380459577,
-0.0220724959,
-0.0034983696,
-0.0145324804,
0.0060952958,
-0.0149705084,
0.0313741714,
0.0609551221,
0.0241376311,
0.0488100238,
0.0311933216,
0.0176933054,
-0.029956134,
-0.0215562936,
-0.0047747917,
-0.0112577658,
0.0228406191,
0.0109371748,
-0.0139785381,
-0.0584109947,
-0.0074899467,
-0.0552648045,
0.0082247192,
0.0259956047,
-0.0195102654,
-0.0166523661,
0.0113345329,
-0.0085425321,
-0.0334340222,
-0.0450407788,
0.0288295448,
0.0075587896,
-0.0174867567,
0.0003113344,
0.0319784395,
-0.0180640519,
-0.0784572437,
-0.0001524305,
-0.0271901302,
0.0240079295,
0.0629749224,
0.0313510969,
-0.0664020106,
0.0231776796,
-0.044296436,
0.0436257832,
0.0119302245,
-0.0271420591,
0.0136044491,
-0.0596437044,
0.0452817529,
0.0780056939,
0.0053081643,
0.0614627823,
0.0704771951,
-0.030906314,
-0.0833596289,
0.0316950381,
-0.0163951758,
-0.0525894351,
0.002279504,
-0.0017981729,
-0.0322937034,
-0.0461984389,
0.0254051834,
-0.0499249138,
-0.0387417041,
0.0193611961,
-0.0016053909,
0.0501486287,
-0.0201214887,
-0.0105810333,
-0.002863443,
-0.0079269875,
0.0132121071,
-0.0335811116,
0.093898356,
0.0132789863,
0.0190400649,
-0.0453230962,
-0.0372617431,
-0.0446592718,
0.0321075916,
-0.0362252742,
0.017985424,
-0.1047096699,
0.0212963484,
-0.0314090028,
0.0100613581,
0.0308815874,
-0.0773711577,
0.0014111995,
-0.0465816297,
-0.004373766,
-0.0049573956,
0.017603904,
-0.0554890484,
0.0128885545,
-0.0039456026,
-0.0138163688,
-0.0200262833,
-0.0109819649,
-0.0349692665,
-0.0500289313,
0.0266929157,
-0.0164291784,
-0.031874124,
-0.0242005661,
-0.0069496613,
0.0214808155,
0.0446832255,
0.0019167939,
-0.0384046324,
0.0083709462,
0.0548612624,
0.0498829819,
0.0515824668,
-0.037707217,
-0.0232302174,
-0.0274957884,
0.066370979,
-0.0726901814,
0.0285357032,
0.0619406551,
0.0016519309,
-0.0625098869,
-0.0273694899,
0.0948205069,
0.0461295061,
-0.0957986861,
-0.0390388332,
-0.0664469898,
-0.0207972992,
0.0063643586,
0.0911846906,
-0.0990732983,
0.0031696623,
-0.0563082211,
0.0533581451,
0.0200838018,
-0.0073605319,
0.0005414808,
-0.0835010335,
0.0525476746,
0.0283480398,
-0.0075343857,
-0.026443949,
-0.0395913683,
-0.001178347,
0.035027463,
-0.0187450871,
-0.0093792584,
-0.005011376,
0.0201206561,
0.0081740748,
0.017406147,
-0.0055344733,
0.0056756744,
-0.0280582234,
0.0377765335,
0.0332921706,
0.0519706979,
-0.0095180664,
-0.0610386617,
-0.0242146123,
0.0214220751,
0.0038948837,
-0.0188418776,
0.0309338737,
-0.020228764,
0.0138745327,
-0.0339297429,
0.0355602428,
-0.0194218829,
-0.0071693496,
0.0707094967,
0.0876642391,
-0.0401565135,
0.0295555368,
-0.086340718,
-0.0011241505,
0.0242601018,
0.0649175495,
0.0205380581,
-0.0415532999,
0.023677228,
-0.0253016781,
0.014720873,
-0.0089924559,
-0.0051146802,
0.0128254751,
-0.034011703,
0.0249598082,
-0.0449264869,
-0.0368027054,
0.0431237854,
-0.020437615,
0.0284840725,
0.023298556,
0.0225164108,
0.0222861245,
-0.0581724532,
-0.0123046143,
-0.0345122181,
-0.0016943783,
-0.0553656928,
-0.0531823933,
0.0329689197,
-0.0667848885,
0.0122362087,
0.0148675703,
0.0114562204,
-0.0509870984,
0.0018735162,
0.0635246113,
0.0107520698,
0.0259660073,
0.0410831831,
-0.0017198996,
-0.0051512453,
-0.000179685,
-0.0156456009,
0.0059935316,
-0.0238882992,
-0.0083669955,
0.0163534991,
0.0031339375,
-0.0779790208,
0.0096435715,
-0.0265040509,
-0.0015471784,
0.0241395757,
-0.059216395,
0.0368682444,
0.0284553301,
0.0033774145,
0.0061872979,
-0.0194758344,
-0.0209894758,
0.0364568084,
-0.0423666239,
-0.0120481011,
-0.0108816149,
-0.0205464046,
0.014878707,
-0.0150762834,
0.0183539484,
-0.0133129517,
-0.0192964133,
0.0431848057,
-0.0512417965,
0.055803787,
-0.0374352373,
0.0184314866,
0.010304749,
0.0009390911,
-0.0288709532,
-0.0284857545,
-0.011553362,
0.0412085988,
-0.0247057565,
0.1060731262,
-0.0007137306,
-0.003603783,
0.0227140933,
0.0031974106,
-0.0403525457,
-0.0616201423,
0.00040988,
0.0508049838,
0.009173641,
-0.0033882076,
-0.0001971439,
-0.0338802449,
0.0069640987,
0.0053514061,
0.0311995335,
-0.0251986887,
-0.0553353392,
-0.0000153105,
0.0213971175,
0.0439140946,
0.0159091335,
0.0341011882,
-0.0354047194,
0.0210599024,
-0.0138297034,
-0.0345991813,
-0.0152950166,
-0.0071493699,
0.0347973444,
0.0810273215,
0.0063332669,
-0.0211559217,
-0.0102154864,
-0.0338279679,
-0.0257732943,
0.027903799,
-0.0268732123,
-0.0220242385,
0.0342883989,
0.056974899,
-0.0009532677,
-0.0342495777,
-0.04300851,
0.0706143975,
-0.1122755259,
-0.0312713943,
0.0027855367,
-5.852663681e-33,
-0.0306583028,
-0.0539577678,
0.0485642031,
0.0688817576,
0.0388670377,
-0.0186853912,
-0.0262824725,
0.0107094301,
-0.0363996625,
-0.0193048846,
0.0047315466,
0.0078584356,
-0.0024583084,
0.0435052142,
0.0298658907,
0.0422526151,
0.0220826752,
0.0013646885,
0.0213038232,
0.0435946621,
0.0288028289,
0.013806968,
0.0217641611,
-0.1066075861,
0.0222377833,
-0.0682014152,
0.0316827893,
-0.0105743343,
-0.0510226302,
0.0656585246,
-0.0159076322,
0.075609602,
-0.00076729,
-0.0048799249,
0.0371146165,
0.0024999797,
-0.0476261452,
-0.0822271928,
0.0028358281,
-0.0028217146,
-0.0386866219,
-0.0559051372,
0.0095334714,
-0.0217970442,
-0.0439129584,
0.0071890838,
0.0774530843,
-0.0144611252,
0.003939243,
0.0235935654,
-0.0623261258,
-0.0301626585,
-0.0170626119,
-0.0273116622,
-0.0162647143,
-0.0097289737,
0.0146836992,
-0.0019785149,
-0.0432245806,
0.0449629724,
0.0030241855,
0.0146169877,
0.0313948244,
-0.0198949873,
-0.0437271111,
0.0259299986,
0.0298679546,
-0.0042385412,
-0.0341716893,
-0.0398031585,
0.0078352001,
0.0396475159,
0.0480764396,
0.0435203202,
-0.0058298004,
-0.0040396573,
-0.0303687882,
0.0678645074,
0.0740255043,
0.0122389365,
0.000920163,
-0.0067623868,
-0.0573310591,
0.0095727071,
-0.0126882028,
0.0006495578,
-0.0457283743,
-0.0471516922,
0.0385720544,
-0.0216992777,
-0.0053426889,
-0.0249330606,
0.011760897,
-0.0625510961,
-0.0033199899,
0.0131105129,
-0.0195782892,
0.0012470483,
-0.0343589708,
-0.0172280446,
-0.0211439058,
-0.0272719692,
0.0177327525,
-0.0758586749,
-0.0083877034,
0.0281035081,
0.0046511684,
0.0245187003,
-0.025047468,
-0.000543931,
-0.0120792156,
-0.0355225764,
0.0301489141,
-0.0412745588,
0.0172155369,
0.0526491031,
-0.0084814997,
0.0759864897,
0.0105331251,
0.0279193483,
-0.038351696,
-0.0934441015,
0.0167574808,
-0.0462832823,
-0.0435212776,
0.0018655905,
-0.0432302877,
0.056468863,
-0.0136391614,
-0.0518937521,
-0.0112028113,
0.0171933733,
2.693e-7,
0.0175806191,
0.0578879304,
0.005177794,
-0.0127302799,
-0.0365150794,
0.0055203317,
0.0135308839,
-0.0072870851,
0.0527776815,
0.0470436364,
-0.0003277917,
0.0414647274,
0.0268069841,
0.0256024729,
-0.0584699512,
-0.0288371611,
-0.007033099,
-0.0361972377,
-0.0745041668,
0.0414513163,
0.0881674215,
0.0336886644,
0.0390156619,
0.0055311159,
-0.0511361659,
-0.0264495295,
0.0153887086,
0.005026578,
-0.0051481635,
0.0107859094,
0.0111911725,
0.0314761102,
0.0018004015,
-0.0093421442,
-0.0118160071,
0.0216189362,
-0.0164508335,
0.0222697891,
-0.0121601988,
-0.0109974397,
0.024339417,
0.0167281348,
-0.0014825925,
-0.0212104861,
0.0022724192,
0.0050464463,
0.0093822693,
-0.0047057862,
-0.0321339592,
-0.0155104883,
-0.0155384159,
-0.0211911853,
0.023560876,
0.0017419014,
-0.0136604505,
-0.0485037528,
0.0046070144,
-0.0349534079,
-0.0127211325,
-0.0019351935,
-0.0136283524,
0.0031826932,
-0.0376904607,
-0.0398490503,
0.030788701,
-0.0303257406,
0.0436432883,
2.099698315e-34,
-0.0284550544,
-0.0041517564,
0.0383095704,
0.0525361076,
0.0193149652,
0.0201367177,
-0.0065369075,
0.0716591924,
0.0237101521,
-0.0490052141,
-0.0567138754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17686v1 | AviationGPT: A Large Language Model for the Aviation Domain | 2023-11-29T14:49:31 | 2023-11-29T14:49:31 | Liya Wang, Jason Chou, Xin Zhou, Alex Tien, Diane M Baumgartner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of ChatGPT and GPT-4 has captivated the world with large language
models (LLMs), demonstrating exceptional performance in question-answering,
summarization, and content generation. The aviation industry is characterized
by an abundance of complex, unstructured text data, replete with technical
jargon and specialized terminology. Moreover, labeled data for model building
are scarce in this domain, resulting in low usage of aviation text data. The
emergence of LLMs presents an opportunity to transform this situation, but
there is a lack of LLMs specifically designed for the aviation domain. To
address this gap, we propose AviationGPT, which is built on open-source LLaMA-2
and Mistral architectures and continuously trained on a wealth of carefully
curated aviation datasets. Experimental results reveal that AviationGPT offers
users multiple advantages, including the versatility to tackle diverse natural
language processing (NLP) problems (e.g., question-answering, summarization,
document writing, information extraction, report querying, data cleaning, and
interactive data exploration). It also provides accurate and contextually
relevant responses within the aviation domain and significantly improves
performance (e.g., over a 40% performance gain in tested cases). With
AviationGPT, the aviation industry is better equipped to address more complex
research problems and enhance the efficiency and safety of National Airspace
System (NAS) operations. | [
0.0426706783,
0.0705012828,
0.0049579041,
0.0370094292,
-0.01644619,
0.0047510425,
-0.0110923201,
-0.0365211554,
-0.018643979,
-0.0622965023,
-0.0283764619,
-0.054536432,
-0.0235727187,
0.0675283745,
0.0217031352,
-0.040474385,
0.0388020054,
-0.0691212639,
0.0024072553,
0.0105990581,
0.0276778955,
0.0334101915,
-0.0250403434,
0.022752801,
0.021895526,
-0.0157506932,
-0.0062147803,
-0.0090187732,
0.0234269649,
-0.0148392254,
0.0290472507,
0.0245494265,
0.0845358148,
0.0693955123,
0.0000020619,
-0.0278490391,
0.0024387122,
0.002864982,
-0.0307296142,
0.0462285317,
0.0680207387,
0.0085602291,
-0.0103045832,
0.0587947778,
-0.0519352295,
0.002149726,
0.0164108369,
0.0556911714,
0.1158481911,
0.0737531856,
-0.0061771679,
-0.053682249,
0.0398170054,
-0.022803504,
-0.0019335845,
-0.0317774154,
-0.009339395,
0.0344979689,
0.0257663243,
-0.0009175013,
0.0073226243,
0.0574295446,
0.0262281429,
-0.033062771,
0.0172122363,
0.0693428516,
-0.051277779,
0.023229396,
-0.0284337196,
0.0335371047,
0.0173545331,
-0.0178123955,
0.0276919343,
0.0169532057,
-0.0266135819,
-0.0405505635,
-0.0358843803,
-0.0122724557,
-0.0300727431,
0.0241254363,
0.0289616864,
-0.0187459737,
-0.0033979912,
-0.0009151369,
-0.0379041694,
0.0560652986,
-0.0130973188,
-0.0310580973,
-0.0093485694,
-0.0127902348,
0.0020117878,
-0.0902676508,
0.0067995326,
0.0488367118,
-0.040108759,
0.0103053674,
-0.0302485768,
-0.0094338302,
0.029003961,
-0.0681839436,
0.0045098984,
0.000129151,
-0.0039877156,
0.0682914928,
-0.0463834368,
0.0203131475,
-0.0065837307,
-0.0159031302,
-0.0464566126,
-0.0314122736,
-0.0700659081,
-0.0677263588,
-0.0546399839,
0.0487422049,
-0.0724353343,
-0.0185944717,
-0.0583291464,
0.0168988686,
0.0047121127,
0.0280510262,
0.0606279075,
0.0151972901,
-0.0350216329,
0.0046876599,
-0.0400789753,
-0.0034725685,
0.0108567867,
0.020202497,
0.0305560399,
-0.0529441126,
0.0067688199,
0.0527455807,
0.0052872277,
-0.0006073818,
-0.0330671296,
0.0974459201,
-0.0570173562,
-0.0134628993,
-0.0593038164,
-0.046675805,
0.0172030367,
-0.0653870553,
-0.0039178608,
-0.0750653148,
0.0114488015,
0.0135834999,
-0.0178449228,
-0.0004251496,
0.0008661046,
0.0147520257,
-0.0199415274,
0.0508433767,
-0.0519373864,
0.0004822531,
0.0456965901,
0.003842535,
0.0371600613,
0.0532283001,
0.0507435761,
0.01395489,
0.0445756726,
-0.0091544958,
0.0128997574,
0.0236063339,
0.0197197441,
-0.0123439981,
-0.034881819,
0.0574253015,
-0.0469344296,
0.0293595679,
0.0554609522,
0.0331273787,
-0.0136782024,
0.0372784883,
0.0337610878,
0.0414850973,
0.0274879914,
0.0289010685,
0.0447452106,
0.0352545828,
0.0234497208,
-0.0274069067,
-0.0302889142,
0.041130431,
-0.0577421188,
0.0067166886,
0.0382498913,
0.0531095825,
-0.0102266725,
-0.0589201301,
-0.0027080225,
0.0053742593,
0.0175059531,
0.0008750554,
0.0026567231,
-0.0346715637,
-0.0261529684,
0.0334455892,
0.0178372562,
-0.016710123,
-0.0092793871,
-0.0310540069,
0.0119403517,
0.0691933855,
0.0112834945,
-0.0386795625,
-0.0528812893,
-0.0576412529,
0.0353368074,
0.039064873,
0.0331044681,
-0.014178182,
-0.0127006546,
-0.0293052997,
-0.0354501531,
0.0122263106,
0.0097858189,
-0.0128412535,
0.0279999226,
0.0195652135,
0.0085448474,
-0.0383959115,
-0.0778219476,
0.0288084541,
-0.0310428273,
-0.0413572602,
-0.0003344333,
-0.0190218948,
0.0534726977,
0.0228381827,
-0.0358505026,
0.0018366169,
0.0257967636,
-0.0281570461,
-0.0441671051,
-0.0158843976,
-0.0242315233,
0.0190664139,
0.0084572155,
-0.0013383378,
-0.0276969224,
0.0329431072,
-0.0497908965,
-0.0639002174,
-0.0120508885,
-0.0441930443,
0.0316675343,
-0.0338035822,
-0.0423988961,
0.0374746397,
-0.0053778253,
-0.0443041325,
0.0607053563,
-0.0122158127,
-0.0306014474,
0.0178707335,
0.0002007123,
0.0490773916,
-0.0109707955,
-0.0172342807,
0.0470555536,
0.0102057019,
0.0360971019,
0.0206105951,
0.0048556766,
-0.0528195091,
0.0047755698,
-0.0950745642,
0.0259623528,
-0.0233268775,
0.0425979681,
0.0306093674,
0.0124230357,
-0.0462949611,
0.0024973941,
-0.035076119,
-0.0020360488,
0.034259852,
-0.0052904361,
0.0577568337,
0.0232956503,
-0.0379322246,
-0.0612099767,
-0.0294825062,
-0.009790835,
0.0032537482,
0.0350174308,
-0.033325322,
-0.0766721889,
0.0471284688,
-0.0801268145,
0.0227792971,
-0.0008761791,
-0.0472033583,
0.0299991779,
-0.0278413929,
0.0315879062,
0.0397505872,
0.0401833951,
0.0051463549,
0.0179727115,
-0.0126907239,
-0.0377907269,
0.0187081378,
-0.0154181449,
-0.0138967596,
0.0039693974,
0.0231223851,
0.0360988081,
0.0669326857,
-0.0254213791,
-0.0033463715,
-0.0253519639,
0.0210176893,
-0.0123579456,
0.0224300493,
-0.0430765674,
-0.0083797444,
-0.0054368675,
0.0562271774,
0.0137298033,
-0.0514043756,
0.0532698669,
-0.0248176511,
0.0105433473,
-0.0583440438,
-0.0240387507,
-0.0378820561,
0.0283213966,
-0.0081162527,
0.0281337965,
0.0183078609,
-0.0072611785,
-0.0055121267,
-0.0271532573,
-0.0091892285,
-0.0117246741,
0.0396242626,
-0.0557894818,
0.042475462,
-0.0367157348,
-0.0317527689,
-0.0052192216,
-0.0113212569,
-0.0440863408,
0.0096736234,
-0.0004140788,
-0.0394826569,
-0.0317623392,
0.0112237623,
0.0738848895,
0.0643297955,
-0.0293383002,
-0.0269411132,
-0.0358563513,
0.0438422114,
0.0835908204,
0.0144985169,
0.0610864796,
0.0046567158,
-0.0179373194,
0.0492122769,
0.039894063,
-0.0012165491,
-0.0226600934,
-0.0192101225,
0.006851607,
-0.0540725999,
-0.0191398449,
0.0114859017,
0.066880092,
-0.0505705513,
0.0320179798,
0.0924836248,
0.0260522962,
-0.0143114198,
0.0108002527,
0.0183699429,
0.0297646392,
0.0256023873,
0.0593257062,
-0.0655082837,
-0.0276516397,
-0.0440223068,
0.0102011478,
0.0071391664,
-0.0338963866,
0.0030408765,
-0.0798140541,
0.0647881329,
-0.0280538406,
-0.0491460599,
-0.0225796811,
-0.058877714,
-0.0156235667,
-0.0276304353,
0.0218109749,
0.0157294162,
-0.0322369486,
-0.0098274956,
0.0289277453,
-0.0455918424,
-0.0784377381,
-0.0000949173,
-0.0579491667,
0.0498650745,
0.0299774799,
-0.00230668,
-0.0326891094,
-0.0240781493,
0.0486496277,
-0.0016017995,
0.0110660391,
-0.0028303305,
0.0168706514,
0.0038188382,
-0.004129299,
-0.0327810757,
0.0471141152,
-0.0646856353,
0.01389514,
0.0215823781,
0.0740216076,
0.0154986335,
0.0173522532,
-0.0494230539,
-0.0109045804,
-0.0212897789,
0.0495662875,
-0.0138442945,
-0.0197952986,
-0.0778456181,
-0.030712679,
-0.0282181837,
-0.0389806181,
-0.0283350553,
0.0170703642,
0.0319786705,
-0.0393900499,
-0.0604273714,
-0.0375482813,
0.0462244488,
0.0090353619,
-0.0378201529,
0.0427650325,
0.0080635771,
-0.0022486944,
-0.0364719927,
0.0135401562,
-0.0454951562,
0.0250090603,
-0.0638001114,
0.0190294944,
0.0598977245,
0.0034521315,
-0.0446029939,
0.0550322719,
-0.091665186,
-0.0421656594,
0.0079447795,
0.0208385922,
0.0314128362,
0.0153259896,
0.0056543332,
-0.0494762659,
0.0343059674,
0.0231788196,
-0.0432224013,
0.0139804212,
-0.0485643819,
0.0016362767,
-0.0100390278,
0.0171836223,
-0.0473926291,
-0.0027542654,
-0.0182853807,
0.0048476281,
-0.0088217352,
-0.0025354589,
0.0034904056,
0.0323251672,
-0.0162394717,
0.0144387679,
0.0074264379,
-0.0391428396,
0.0358078592,
-0.0097251795,
0.0078883106,
-0.0284174848,
0.0349598192,
-0.0257034395,
-0.0188500974,
0.0114529328,
0.0115239499,
0.0028798454,
0.0297328476,
-0.046357967,
0.0070775729,
-0.0164746158,
-0.0268542618,
0.0355831571,
-0.0092174346,
-0.0125274872,
-0.0265595503,
-0.0083017582,
0.0287001636,
-0.0291619804,
0.0371889956,
0.0437718295,
0.0080650635,
-0.0166250411,
0.0704311058,
-0.0670051575,
-0.052474495,
-0.0185667332,
0.0352023579,
0.0568174347,
0.0362307429,
0.0258232057,
-0.0375611559,
0.0050573791,
-0.0030401458,
0.0111809624,
0.0071013663,
-0.0085613197,
0.0633805245,
0.0262780152,
-0.0128071904,
0.0033986501,
0.1110439152,
0.0088409735,
0.0240643267,
0.0189867038,
-0.0128000751,
-0.0643608198,
-0.0045603625,
0.025524877,
0.0241354071,
-0.0076421183,
0.0213375092,
-0.0290633552,
-0.0327450559,
0.0035714938,
0.0364733711,
-0.0280212834,
-0.0804460049,
0.0355377793,
0.0737815425,
0.0450668372,
-0.0316935964,
-0.008418519,
-0.0365080945,
-0.0275514834,
-0.0384193659,
-0.007564384,
-6.550764062e-33,
-0.0369265527,
-0.0000333203,
0.0417823344,
0.0004909619,
-0.0571367964,
-0.0112602031,
-0.0126619525,
-0.0294870846,
-0.0025086321,
-0.0191690922,
-0.0085363872,
0.0343151763,
0.0014324621,
0.0120883808,
0.0255357753,
-0.0255106371,
0.0377557427,
-0.0082510021,
-0.0038049922,
0.0583397597,
0.0232892185,
0.0024699531,
0.010048545,
-0.0536686629,
-0.0077908272,
-0.0057145967,
-0.0155499773,
0.0354158059,
-0.0129785649,
0.073675707,
-0.0528688319,
0.0492093638,
0.0188680664,
-0.0338383652,
-0.0126801291,
-0.0093907733,
-0.0413048491,
-0.0178796463,
0.0398588553,
-0.0264469385,
-0.00675045,
-0.036569342,
0.0470705479,
0.0131340083,
0.013104639,
-0.0035995606,
0.0383600034,
0.0002439287,
-0.0009563671,
-0.0207820442,
-0.0910457671,
0.0239427276,
-0.0077315057,
0.0020702078,
0.014806333,
0.0075683221,
-0.0173356868,
0.0454083644,
-0.0353651717,
-0.0058240504,
0.0523875654,
0.0546349436,
0.0413716212,
0.00565898,
-0.0072981473,
0.0537393279,
0.0022093453,
-0.0182767268,
-0.0349693708,
-0.0007172783,
-0.0037609888,
0.0033244891,
0.028149806,
0.0229163636,
0.025204232,
0.0111143542,
-0.0713559389,
0.0281516984,
-0.0307483952,
0.0466806293,
0.0355670005,
0.0208863709,
0.0044648354,
-0.00524429,
0.0127578089,
0.0187469758,
-0.0141320806,
-0.0168126915,
0.0198556129,
0.025679132,
-0.0047854385,
0.0266250409,
0.0401849002,
-0.028670771,
-0.00950447,
-0.0087781418,
-0.0029915737,
0.0309921503,
0.0129526732,
0.029132057,
-0.0883021206,
0.0629346147,
0.0058768941,
0.0096126022,
0.0142300408,
-0.0061187977,
-0.0155914845,
0.0412497148,
-0.054696437,
0.0288833678,
-0.0298270341,
0.0615516603,
-0.0297551826,
0.0453711376,
0.0242539924,
0.0121140964,
0.0267825834,
0.0250865687,
0.0010835602,
-0.0530258082,
-0.0564262383,
-0.0313281119,
-0.0206436627,
0.0202725213,
-0.0212584045,
0.0289225075,
-0.0207669921,
0.0332650058,
0.0119196279,
-0.0812158659,
-0.0106021035,
0.0194348972,
2.658e-7,
0.0174435377,
0.0348161906,
0.0645011216,
0.0383517593,
0.0327941589,
0.0065564481,
-0.0051145963,
0.026340507,
0.0162670221,
0.0130400173,
-0.0173374061,
0.0006420372,
0.0212074053,
0.0631374419,
-0.0757052526,
0.0023922329,
-0.0822087973,
-0.0156317409,
-0.0762963071,
-0.0000245182,
0.1160495356,
0.0919620246,
-0.0522383787,
-0.0053394991,
-0.0164801199,
-0.023127865,
0.0359556749,
-0.0256996006,
-0.0223495774,
0.0271993056,
0.0304721184,
0.0676653981,
-0.0329506025,
0.0086421315,
-0.019794859,
0.0185289253,
0.0008735363,
0.063184008,
0.000311017,
0.0338995941,
0.0259381272,
-0.0476056524,
0.0001869089,
-0.0816289708,
0.0670016557,
-0.0888146013,
-0.000792489,
0.0160630774,
-0.0176303405,
-0.0262232907,
-0.021046523,
-0.0239653233,
-0.0245089512,
0.0024815293,
-0.01512428,
0.0107206907,
0.0205989052,
-0.0901586264,
0.0082923714,
0.0529656932,
-0.0360596739,
0.007392576,
-0.0483569764,
0.0156030292,
0.06189375,
-0.0252937227,
-0.0108774249,
2.430298295e-34,
0.0338084921,
0.0087226471,
-0.0287529249,
0.0241435003,
0.0379369035,
-0.007916566,
-0.0018837394,
0.0116708437,
-0.0169081185,
-0.088788867,
-0.0110258907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17676v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17676v1 | Improving Minority Stress Detection with Emotions | 2023-11-29T14:39:38 | 2023-11-29T14:39:38 | Jonathan Ivey, Susan Gauch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Psychological stress detection is an important task for mental healthcare
research, but there has been little prior work investigating the effectiveness
of psychological stress models on minority individuals, who are especially
vulnerable to poor mental health outcomes. In this work, we use the related
task of minority stress detection to evaluate the ability of psychological
stress models to understand the language of sexual and gender minorities. We
find that traditional psychological stress models underperform on minority
stress detection, and we propose using emotion-infused models to reduce that
performance disparity. We further demonstrate that multi-task psychological
stress models outperform the current state-of-the-art for minority stress
detection without directly training on minority stress data. We provide
explanatory analysis showing that minority communities have different
distributions of emotions than the general population and that emotion-infused
models improve the performance of stress models on underrepresented groups
because of their effectiveness in low-data environments, and we propose that
integrating emotions may benefit underrepresented groups in other mental health
detection tasks. | [
-0.0005244978,
0.0416118465,
-0.0197749212,
-0.015628852,
0.016378548,
0.0330341384,
0.0459654257,
0.0058644637,
0.0295698419,
-0.0560769401,
-0.014574524,
-0.0390399136,
-0.0124218967,
-0.0374496318,
-0.0050533507,
-0.0353768691,
-0.0225149244,
0.0653090924,
0.0700926781,
0.0074822349,
0.0142934555,
0.0326158889,
-0.0014170879,
0.0679111406,
-0.0443399847,
-0.0516323186,
0.0063008736,
0.0418574065,
0.0516691394,
-0.0542318113,
0.0243531857,
0.0596378595,
-0.0050090579,
-0.0327774622,
0.0000023054,
-0.0257089175,
-0.0129728075,
0.0045313314,
-0.0231733415,
-0.0584433787,
0.058900781,
-0.0779886469,
-0.0289019737,
0.0163648054,
-0.0057321223,
-0.0188904274,
0.0437862575,
0.0321069025,
0.0501958504,
0.0244499519,
-0.0469616652,
0.0479386933,
-0.075579755,
-0.0084699178,
0.0351872966,
0.0418314561,
0.0343825631,
-0.0193037689,
0.0375510752,
-0.115053758,
-0.0266036652,
-0.0179794747,
-0.0258539841,
0.0297205392,
-0.0163866822,
0.0061593824,
-0.0097778188,
-0.0217965264,
0.0092387637,
0.0414079875,
-0.0461142287,
0.0791377425,
0.0189404637,
0.0014393966,
-0.0030371915,
-0.0321980081,
-0.0350131057,
-0.0099045532,
-0.0213171262,
-0.0205630586,
-0.0124923103,
0.0364798047,
0.0097077368,
-0.0113558546,
0.0517240241,
0.0619334541,
-0.0082880137,
-0.0207010061,
0.014920285,
-0.0193757098,
0.0013528403,
-0.0125625469,
0.0481439084,
-0.0012947225,
-0.0157324728,
0.0107318852,
-0.0287781414,
-0.0727445558,
-0.0085740667,
0.0054239603,
-0.0113861179,
0.0690471455,
-0.0667059273,
-0.0053387424,
0.0383641422,
0.0264906492,
0.0283821244,
-0.0388355069,
-0.0056104031,
-0.0235902797,
-0.0049948809,
0.0481391549,
-0.0032986118,
0.0078113992,
-0.0308942534,
0.024879029,
-0.0619333945,
-0.0318400823,
-0.0594845787,
-0.0208576098,
-0.0067111631,
-0.0302314237,
-0.0214028694,
0.0497726761,
0.0493116751,
-0.0166852083,
-0.0139687257,
0.0029203603,
0.001406078,
-0.0929049999,
0.0338674858,
-0.0168868955,
0.0001929411,
-0.0320804976,
0.0080811931,
-0.0339508019,
0.0385609157,
-0.0084884502,
-0.0818046778,
0.0259513073,
-0.0443136171,
-0.0267845858,
-0.0009984062,
-0.026878275,
0.0413634107,
0.0169364549,
0.0397954397,
-0.0255947039,
0.0282178428,
-0.0370221362,
-0.0165039916,
0.0493569076,
0.0177615322,
-0.0038364758,
0.0137974154,
0.0342512205,
0.0130143454,
0.0621697903,
0.0186279565,
0.0143702123,
0.0555684417,
-0.0578422025,
0.0085526817,
0.0090731885,
-0.0016939595,
0.0013110996,
0.0596503988,
-0.0337199904,
-0.0277714748,
0.0072031375,
0.0211911742,
0.0120264925,
0.0249707438,
0.0017438545,
0.0027137822,
0.0948631614,
-0.0120274536,
0.0266429204,
0.0002987888,
0.0358135141,
-0.0230174754,
-0.0244397074,
-0.0599249415,
-0.0138152167,
-0.0455376171,
-0.0523869656,
-0.0134721706,
0.0262593571,
-0.0426161997,
-0.0613904558,
-0.0891712457,
-0.0315612219,
0.0216237865,
-0.0008940863,
0.0034943281,
-0.044479616,
0.010336441,
0.0352367312,
0.0438375846,
-0.0385142528,
-0.0034845443,
-0.0408497266,
-0.0019487729,
0.0248480309,
-0.0291053448,
-0.0630246773,
0.0159940068,
-0.0249719806,
-0.0003042257,
0.0013670094,
0.0224679876,
0.029046122,
0.0368599482,
-0.0475719608,
0.0030034289,
0.0465467796,
0.0571274273,
0.0141978636,
0.0207511391,
0.0451921336,
0.0034732965,
-0.0481515899,
-0.0307974927,
0.0335369855,
-0.015483398,
-0.0323473215,
0.0204783287,
-0.0117028756,
0.0515430905,
-0.0052130772,
-0.0330973938,
-0.0095198741,
-0.0142448265,
-0.0097240238,
-0.0181411356,
-0.0113166953,
-0.033893317,
-0.0431210771,
0.0051413309,
-0.0102187945,
-0.0245063957,
0.0539768636,
-0.0297191124,
0.0184093118,
0.0491205491,
-0.0110253524,
-0.0360254534,
0.0083748139,
-0.0246793665,
0.0272515658,
0.0711235031,
-0.0269308258,
0.0159198381,
-0.0310596526,
-0.0000739401,
-0.0501490906,
-0.0371173769,
-0.0394454896,
-0.0459748805,
-0.0546130948,
-0.0266231187,
-0.0396029539,
-0.0099460082,
-0.0532024689,
-0.0055020549,
-0.0106804641,
-0.0050300965,
-0.1264869124,
0.0161556173,
-0.0048722257,
-0.0539472736,
-0.0231614839,
-0.0004610614,
-0.0542440712,
-0.0181846935,
-0.0055092354,
0.0017969239,
0.0214348137,
0.0099722184,
-0.0676091611,
-0.0464610048,
0.0317896195,
-0.0469269119,
-0.0191039015,
-0.0446428955,
0.0071075768,
0.011714451,
-0.0311331563,
-0.0002663014,
-0.0593471043,
-0.0359799564,
-0.0066648046,
-0.0037838062,
-0.0439920798,
0.0152027728,
0.0432557762,
0.0948622972,
0.0204912834,
-0.0043933233,
0.1153514609,
0.0011913672,
0.0000714311,
0.0068505579,
0.0701007843,
0.0074523212,
0.0252747126,
0.0024597689,
-0.0842754915,
-0.0381784439,
0.0651228875,
0.0472574495,
0.0005552315,
-0.0357760563,
-0.0231411327,
-0.0392101035,
-0.0420385748,
-0.0416699089,
0.0115556698,
-0.0164691936,
-0.0138895996,
-0.054684218,
0.0005721729,
0.0076987464,
0.0450781025,
-0.0281796809,
-0.0521768741,
-0.0285101961,
-0.0648006499,
0.0295318682,
-0.0293086302,
-0.0065482934,
0.0664089248,
0.0630743355,
0.011112866,
-0.0516587421,
-0.0551684797,
-0.0658932552,
0.020369688,
-0.0488597676,
-0.0286296643,
0.0177831613,
-0.0433770157,
-0.0444321521,
-0.0189209413,
-0.0547158271,
0.0260796752,
0.0341483839,
0.0310284551,
-0.0135805877,
0.0113782268,
0.0357707851,
0.0053805658,
0.0113236913,
-0.012200064,
0.039261952,
0.0111988317,
0.0362803042,
-0.0077867792,
0.0521360636,
-0.0394187234,
0.0160087403,
0.0449173413,
0.0346469246,
0.0164515078,
0.0237770397,
0.0320665091,
-0.0108445287,
0.0319764949,
-0.0234642923,
-0.0183881447,
-0.0146949328,
-0.0176118333,
0.053303346,
0.1148601845,
0.0247124415,
0.0070336997,
0.0387973413,
-0.0928323269,
0.0149668222,
0.0229947753,
-0.0082941782,
-0.0296046101,
0.0073787561,
-0.0037009553,
0.0156153534,
0.0025728608,
-0.0331551917,
0.0257395748,
-0.034678556,
0.0611045361,
-0.0068524946,
-0.0039633736,
-0.0026654629,
-0.0044301823,
0.101067178,
-0.0149261877,
-0.0463853441,
-0.0704298615,
0.0493551418,
-0.0113712996,
0.0188599825,
-0.0725050047,
-0.0365372933,
0.039476648,
0.0178974587,
0.0333015323,
-0.0309916995,
0.1196726486,
-0.0097025326,
-0.0056992811,
0.0674788058,
-0.0082666203,
-0.0010378622,
-0.061776448,
0.0227646176,
0.0146096824,
-0.0172416642,
-0.0145056881,
0.0502906516,
-0.0314981453,
0.0345871262,
-0.0065271244,
0.0377560444,
0.0121508995,
-0.0279348902,
-0.0476638824,
0.0141795054,
0.0547423922,
0.0551246814,
0.0003550615,
-0.0302385408,
0.0031350525,
-0.0251159165,
0.0103108054,
0.0462760255,
-0.0801619962,
0.0034703284,
0.0038637731,
-0.0180089716,
-0.0190379601,
-0.0480863973,
0.0458147153,
-0.0277385917,
-0.0187144484,
-0.0705381706,
0.0050623082,
-0.0043848893,
-0.0637612641,
0.0483956411,
0.0069109011,
0.0199544765,
0.0284895077,
0.0016997154,
-0.0177253541,
0.0138259726,
-0.019009687,
0.0022814258,
-0.016284138,
-0.0153276389,
0.1083910316,
0.0324387178,
0.0138021419,
-0.0611204617,
-0.0203222986,
-0.0213910695,
0.0277702995,
-0.0186831858,
-0.0482180715,
0.0068708048,
0.0246633012,
0.0127124991,
-0.0277781617,
0.0291610844,
0.0013793519,
0.087283425,
0.030534327,
-0.0271784812,
-0.0091926288,
-0.0108410288,
-0.0352232419,
0.0111335358,
0.0303594898,
0.0127088996,
-0.0594467372,
0.0023663703,
-0.0394052118,
0.0137476074,
-0.0047351955,
0.0003802242,
-0.0578318611,
-0.0135249924,
0.0525378622,
-0.0586745106,
-0.0366359204,
0.0205356479,
-0.0194370709,
-0.0332283489,
0.0381572247,
0.0143921748,
0.0025840623,
-0.0101977447,
0.0321624838,
0.0158879012,
0.0686480179,
-0.0196718778,
0.0024699694,
0.0289294366,
0.03220414,
-0.0329123437,
-0.0233970787,
0.0387261175,
0.0097583253,
0.0058701513,
-0.0105897859,
-0.0147958109,
-0.0265118666,
0.0309898127,
-0.0116810547,
0.0211118758,
-0.0006753381,
-0.004743088,
-0.0472090729,
-0.0225212201,
-0.0136730699,
0.0015930375,
0.0360590965,
-0.0108171869,
-0.000586247,
-0.0105966376,
0.0304365009,
0.0075684688,
0.0406843983,
-0.0109777832,
-0.0100866808,
-0.046372328,
0.0413079783,
0.0332076624,
-0.0274446923,
-0.019879628,
0.0506253801,
-0.0843535513,
-0.0566212162,
0.0617779568,
-0.0500572361,
0.0153885772,
-0.021972334,
0.0405462421,
0.0246178154,
-0.0513434559,
-0.0198713802,
-0.0203359816,
0.011471984,
-0.0689179823,
-0.0380664244,
0.0212796982,
-5.593554971e-33,
-0.0330944359,
-0.0183798429,
-0.0380328894,
-0.0220623203,
0.0144654382,
0.0626244918,
0.0085239485,
-0.0082665663,
0.0149454037,
0.0195616353,
0.0252389628,
0.0774310306,
0.0135602178,
-0.0025453847,
-0.0250923149,
-0.0155469999,
0.0517932437,
0.0055752764,
0.0141489254,
-0.0350871719,
-0.051487647,
0.0668138564,
0.0360597037,
-0.1267722398,
0.0410901383,
0.0049848347,
-0.0110082189,
-0.0264024008,
0.0126817804,
0.0400288031,
-0.028592512,
0.1115039289,
0.0199945774,
-0.0100920722,
0.0534668677,
0.0353300832,
-0.0268451497,
-0.0234177299,
-0.0169533305,
-0.0295326021,
-0.02749818,
-0.0181527864,
-0.0220610388,
0.0556537546,
0.0015840799,
-0.038927462,
0.0386782661,
-0.0489131175,
0.0663451105,
-0.0283565372,
-0.0130251171,
0.0396343656,
-0.01340988,
0.0375199579,
-0.0046737809,
0.0826964006,
-0.0569976494,
-0.0076044598,
-0.0250476096,
-0.0445924588,
0.0211568177,
-0.0004333698,
0.0127513455,
0.0026302601,
-0.0020769646,
0.0243969783,
0.0237262305,
-0.0062918607,
-0.0220722761,
-0.0089766541,
0.0156336408,
0.0083171362,
0.0731056854,
0.0476263426,
-0.0358724631,
0.0078575611,
-0.0125791552,
0.0221625473,
0.0493661501,
-0.0039835321,
0.0470462814,
0.0129023055,
-0.0254421942,
0.0176224876,
-0.0097578242,
-0.0398972407,
-0.0101523921,
-0.0058949953,
0.016529426,
0.0046020751,
-0.0267235842,
0.0096385796,
-0.0230181273,
0.0016072651,
-0.002835568,
0.0060713268,
0.025054995,
-0.0080705658,
0.0258362237,
0.0194218978,
-0.0443536155,
0.008187443,
0.0397575423,
0.0457237996,
0.080969736,
-0.0130904708,
0.0030933856,
0.0185876861,
-0.0375985689,
-0.0047629457,
0.0432940535,
0.0836928114,
0.0031430873,
0.0431185476,
-0.0309936423,
0.0203425158,
-0.0119838836,
-0.0124709578,
0.05619625,
-0.0092054298,
-0.0172236394,
0.0079093026,
-0.0344560295,
0.0372524746,
-0.0361399315,
0.0038443988,
0.0267236251,
-0.0176889878,
0.0455446988,
0.0130323507,
0.0132456236,
-0.061866302,
2.681e-7,
-0.0093783755,
0.0229065269,
-0.0119148502,
-0.0438582227,
0.014108805,
0.0014047003,
0.0054041785,
0.044602368,
0.072012417,
-0.0375139005,
-0.0064889225,
0.0507802144,
0.0570629388,
0.03589008,
-0.0180290136,
-0.0128882816,
0.0115906252,
0.0253528971,
-0.0113129253,
0.0269001331,
0.0269996505,
0.0873156413,
0.0183232557,
0.0071677179,
-0.0238928366,
0.0253313128,
0.0292003695,
-0.0584464781,
0.0073557799,
0.0481178053,
0.0516562127,
0.0031800624,
0.0082506025,
0.0308790691,
0.0067322552,
0.0082014268,
0.0314172842,
0.0331924148,
-0.014587977,
0.0019459225,
0.02601487,
0.056505233,
-0.0417760536,
-0.0622647516,
0.0429385975,
-0.0266818907,
0.0003016726,
-0.0352023542,
-0.0122767175,
0.0034312971,
0.0483960249,
-0.0082072644,
-0.0443165451,
0.0151870614,
0.0440930054,
-0.0300896056,
-0.0196197405,
-0.0568237938,
-0.0415190309,
0.0224589668,
-0.0670782253,
-0.0132226441,
-0.0163196363,
0.0295597333,
-0.0412848443,
-0.0286760163,
0.0082130386,
2.038437381e-34,
0.0026378774,
0.0432979725,
-0.0309829526,
0.0210385695,
0.0141845578,
-0.0002361586,
-0.0626800656,
-0.0260022078,
-0.0097215772,
0.0172641668,
-0.0042353477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17667v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17667v2 | TimeBench: A Comprehensive Evaluation of Temporal Reasoning Abilities in Large Language Models | 2023-11-29T14:30:16 | 2024-06-28T10:40:26 | Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Qianglong Chen, Weijiang Yu, Haotian Wang, Ming Liu, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Grasping the concept of time is a fundamental facet of human cognition,
indispensable for truly comprehending the intricacies of the world. Previous
studies typically focus on specific aspects of time, lacking a comprehensive
temporal reasoning benchmark. To address this, we propose TimeBench, a
comprehensive hierarchical temporal reasoning benchmark that covers a broad
spectrum of temporal reasoning phenomena. TimeBench provides a thorough
evaluation for investigating the temporal reasoning capabilities of large
language models. We conduct extensive experiments on GPT-4, LLaMA2, and other
popular LLMs under various settings. Our experimental results indicate a
significant performance gap between the state-of-the-art LLMs and humans,
highlighting that there is still a considerable distance to cover in temporal
reasoning. Besides, LLMs exhibit capability discrepancies across different
reasoning categories. Furthermore, we thoroughly analyze the impact of multiple
aspects on temporal reasoning and emphasize the associated challenges. We
aspire for TimeBench to serve as a comprehensive benchmark, fostering research
in temporal reasoning. Resources are available at:
https://github.com/zchuz/TimeBench | [
0.0084354924,
0.0278321821,
-0.0189002175,
0.0221173633,
-0.0654735863,
-0.0016236126,
0.013365061,
0.0312208422,
0.0088093225,
-0.0178764686,
0.0050536697,
-0.0432965904,
0.0097604748,
-0.0016120172,
-0.0168597102,
-0.0404141471,
0.0762013718,
-0.0426334329,
0.0070048515,
0.01255133,
-0.0356123373,
-0.0360170268,
-0.0500350595,
0.0099146413,
0.0234107915,
-0.0612981357,
-0.0179441907,
-0.0441851132,
0.0444878191,
-0.0583232269,
-0.0459610038,
0.0241691284,
-0.0057720919,
0.0461631306,
0.0000018932,
-0.041991815,
0.0200534537,
-0.0284500588,
-0.0418473072,
0.0470917486,
-0.0049754945,
0.0366573222,
-0.0110069392,
0.0205796976,
-0.0512385778,
0.0030397435,
-0.0044151358,
0.0102921091,
-0.0021652095,
0.0719312355,
-0.0108033475,
0.0328223333,
0.0415287539,
-0.0187746566,
0.031108642,
-0.0536626764,
-0.0186654497,
0.0240385048,
0.0724803582,
-0.0275803339,
0.0038976162,
0.010603426,
0.0559765324,
0.0262063276,
0.0019510339,
0.0714236498,
-0.0038088106,
0.0144770518,
-0.0355665572,
0.0156396199,
0.0362294093,
-0.0324001536,
-0.0213728901,
0.0180752594,
-0.0397898555,
-0.0155948633,
-0.0479478762,
-0.0042320206,
0.008765853,
0.0302721635,
0.0403642543,
0.0448348224,
0.0395921916,
-0.0059079383,
-0.0068924539,
0.149380818,
0.028845083,
-0.0252207927,
-0.015402792,
-0.0092989635,
0.0217928011,
-0.0596608855,
0.0009227067,
0.0825762749,
-0.0182457827,
-0.0027005293,
0.01171041,
0.04345401,
0.0031103524,
-0.0114084966,
0.0073715961,
0.0740093067,
0.0215952732,
0.0480150841,
-0.0557202548,
0.0945443287,
-0.0374318995,
0.0086183054,
-0.0130485063,
0.0279471744,
-0.0548816323,
-0.0128338197,
0.0326989964,
-0.008243857,
-0.020795064,
-0.0128288558,
-0.0629914626,
0.0156181939,
0.012869589,
-0.0046067717,
-0.0219005477,
-0.0236261301,
0.0154612772,
-0.0111753484,
-0.1036473662,
-0.0013918034,
-0.0447466001,
0.0244488884,
-0.0159595981,
-0.0723023862,
-0.0257184505,
-0.0096304137,
-0.0300725438,
-0.055534739,
-0.0118469615,
0.0549708791,
-0.0438379161,
-0.0187327005,
-0.0817245021,
-0.032962665,
0.0111505687,
-0.0668543354,
0.0463273078,
-0.0621907599,
0.026014749,
0.0055267648,
-0.0249868091,
0.0152228735,
0.008422873,
0.0039771111,
0.0357370973,
0.0456868745,
0.0294511914,
0.0288205333,
-0.0130175175,
0.0300561469,
0.021681156,
0.0292677935,
0.0237039998,
-0.0094079329,
-0.0100547243,
0.029582968,
-0.0318048298,
0.0290127601,
-0.0008042287,
-0.0465906411,
-0.0715036988,
0.024177609,
-0.0248580761,
0.0450675115,
0.0252283234,
0.0413557403,
-0.0195132028,
-0.031145012,
0.053491246,
0.0428595766,
-0.0119204158,
-0.0239418894,
0.0636227205,
-0.0661091655,
0.0477734618,
-0.0152315814,
-0.0602991357,
0.0564379171,
-0.0149756698,
0.0176213812,
-0.0369063281,
0.0291526522,
-0.0157184545,
-0.0367574804,
-0.0440970659,
0.0239467546,
-0.0059751705,
-0.0153914392,
0.0254734159,
-0.0133983819,
-0.0458744392,
0.066584982,
-0.0170076862,
0.0087084472,
-0.0231789481,
-0.0291074999,
0.0200694166,
0.0814433396,
0.0189152993,
-0.0273344088,
-0.0517174341,
0.0186014306,
0.0109777311,
0.0194379743,
0.0573995784,
0.0174767189,
-0.018886352,
-0.0078440597,
0.0078530191,
-0.0196167417,
0.0192492139,
0.0171461757,
0.0506882928,
0.0579670109,
-0.0066801412,
-0.0420687124,
0.0522679798,
0.0239905193,
-0.0339968279,
-0.0071051326,
-0.0849176571,
0.0089573432,
0.0158649553,
0.0011235495,
0.0160952546,
0.0266411938,
0.0336215496,
-0.0219791681,
-0.0056925309,
0.0694928169,
-0.0812530443,
-0.0467358045,
0.0401986912,
0.0128705883,
-0.0464468747,
0.0391379222,
-0.008950918,
-0.0273557808,
0.0341682062,
0.0091202529,
0.0485526733,
-0.0174386669,
0.0410387851,
-0.0090335961,
0.0120541006,
-0.0226391051,
0.1037214994,
-0.0380164087,
0.0255370587,
0.0105512943,
0.0413328931,
0.0111453822,
-0.0523570739,
-0.004416666,
0.0324858129,
-0.0095900055,
-0.0549891181,
-0.0666334331,
-0.030313585,
-0.0926537067,
-0.0062511843,
-0.0733877718,
0.0140446601,
0.0051741814,
0.0520693213,
-0.0076064509,
-0.0439634994,
0.0002711939,
0.0173311103,
-0.0106233489,
0.00715164,
-0.0145538626,
0.0363882333,
0.034776099,
-0.0040326281,
-0.0462673604,
-0.0189593118,
-0.01019176,
-0.0619319938,
0.0376369245,
-0.0112379333,
-0.0228605047,
0.0266457759,
-0.0123853805,
-0.0502946898,
-0.0015894824,
-0.0212992858,
-0.0122374985,
0.0602593049,
-0.0057751075,
0.06379316,
0.0657149106,
-0.0234843902,
0.0292272903,
0.0643057004,
-0.0318806246,
-0.0054372777,
0.0445649326,
0.0038355277,
0.0143896537,
-0.0236048419,
-0.0265923999,
-0.0622140914,
0.0869820639,
-0.007976233,
0.0370132849,
-0.047247801,
0.0243699308,
-0.0369864888,
-0.0214743409,
-0.0078517059,
0.0101201171,
-0.0420038551,
0.0537085943,
-0.0526837558,
-0.0337893032,
0.0461981036,
-0.0079727666,
0.0036691141,
0.0324667394,
0.013612424,
-0.0263291113,
0.0968567058,
-0.0020126081,
-0.0177509468,
-0.006463415,
-0.0248056948,
-0.0441440307,
-0.0127357328,
0.0196767449,
-0.0401825011,
0.035114713,
-0.0532800779,
0.0104328319,
-0.0166274905,
-0.0187779479,
-0.0391463563,
0.0019938839,
-0.0604060479,
0.0144468909,
-0.0623012856,
-0.0101344632,
-0.019740399,
0.0084468843,
-0.0324795209,
-0.0118434662,
-0.0267774612,
-0.0160994474,
-0.0127028422,
0.0217999667,
0.0045101359,
0.0189827699,
0.0467762053,
-0.0202953368,
0.0402695723,
0.0183328092,
0.0847189054,
-0.0349773839,
-0.0665513054,
0.0406065919,
-0.0191572327,
-0.0235131904,
-0.0244811792,
0.0344536752,
0.0426118746,
-0.0363242887,
0.0059809494,
0.108159475,
0.0654566661,
0.0083352122,
0.0237231385,
-0.0633743107,
0.0088883713,
0.0340866819,
-0.0103894947,
-0.0387570634,
-0.0236617122,
0.0369205736,
-0.0320015736,
-0.0305266809,
-0.0379107855,
-0.0122271627,
-0.05840379,
0.0101287952,
0.0080118636,
-0.0221333876,
0.0205644872,
-0.0011645172,
-0.0024896073,
0.0104886768,
0.0046434524,
0.04490228,
0.0046181427,
0.0007767339,
-0.009165315,
-0.0275241155,
-0.0077209137,
0.1144680008,
0.0418907851,
0.0664615035,
0.0090553043,
0.0408414491,
0.0021667331,
-0.0744620562,
0.0445428193,
0.0220748559,
0.0151094645,
-0.0276502259,
-0.0136314481,
0.0208994187,
-0.0056083491,
-0.0187477265,
0.001028768,
0.0147730298,
-0.0394250713,
-0.0242278464,
0.1240170375,
-0.0289255157,
-0.0180938914,
-0.0238529723,
-0.0055499058,
-0.0455371775,
0.0567270741,
0.0101426998,
0.0203976836,
-0.083765015,
0.0367765464,
-0.04392704,
-0.0640741438,
-0.0311492942,
-0.0014905543,
0.0394157656,
0.0134827662,
-0.0366211608,
-0.0462556183,
-0.0378616937,
0.0014117344,
-0.0173363853,
0.0134934932,
-0.0133584058,
-0.0035072435,
-0.0555889867,
0.0356120914,
-0.0024474123,
0.0514982045,
-0.0507194139,
0.0269036479,
-0.0062037506,
-0.0094284443,
-0.0150798308,
0.043092262,
-0.0789019763,
-0.0385180004,
0.0042855525,
-0.0238004811,
0.028730467,
0.0125288656,
0.00701751,
-0.0005931034,
0.0092136804,
-0.0068949284,
-0.0054742512,
0.0498146936,
0.0353595614,
0.0121785263,
0.0243286844,
0.045704525,
-0.0196546279,
0.0230471529,
-0.0134191345,
0.0218387935,
-0.0077509214,
0.0195272621,
0.0008141238,
-0.0040342752,
0.0291092508,
0.0592252128,
-0.0170384701,
0.0018834592,
0.020217387,
-0.0506162085,
0.0172786936,
0.0022524842,
-0.0218132138,
0.0327747464,
0.0041755755,
-0.0188226271,
-0.0235844404,
0.0255077388,
-0.0218567159,
0.0056673526,
0.0088108014,
-0.0084248381,
0.0129604163,
0.0183169357,
-0.0018882953,
-0.016772734,
0.0016806548,
-0.0619319081,
0.0302815791,
0.0140210772,
0.0504669212,
-0.0076298197,
0.0177035276,
-0.0571230724,
-0.0450206883,
-0.0942149833,
-0.0274761189,
0.0580323786,
-0.0251821745,
0.0641665459,
-0.0348467976,
0.0432119407,
-0.0458016843,
0.0197667163,
0.0045602168,
0.0092820795,
0.029873129,
-0.0098241884,
0.0342318341,
0.0196279455,
0.0155131863,
-0.0017334797,
0.0443147719,
-0.0052064722,
0.0543126352,
0.0309257191,
0.002753428,
-0.0054034037,
-0.0641011223,
-0.0563324131,
-0.0280949343,
-0.0185900591,
-0.0391407348,
-0.0714179948,
-0.0481949113,
0.0473157093,
0.0399190746,
-0.0178862829,
-0.0076759756,
-0.0152681572,
0.0471885614,
0.0178918839,
-0.0617711432,
0.008088016,
0.0050947769,
0.0284152981,
-0.0032917459,
-0.0529421419,
-6.332700309e-33,
-0.0230552517,
-0.0211676825,
0.0661644265,
-0.0231663994,
-0.0290830228,
0.010625476,
-0.0612973981,
0.0155719919,
-0.0374694727,
0.0086074071,
-0.0312068742,
0.0501107499,
0.0284613445,
-0.0303004943,
0.0112306476,
-0.0049002203,
0.0016053001,
-0.0116664618,
-0.0190378241,
0.0015399592,
0.0508256033,
-0.0061956407,
0.0291116834,
-0.0159640703,
-0.0071661021,
0.0164183751,
-0.0037613995,
0.0382980555,
-0.0669030547,
0.0610201284,
-0.0143822376,
-0.0018087567,
0.0459046327,
-0.0228466503,
-0.0056535015,
0.0003563553,
-0.0728497654,
-0.0528452359,
0.0258054007,
-0.0072389799,
-0.0297057051,
-0.0515064038,
0.0023503674,
0.0219675582,
-0.0295616593,
-0.049990043,
0.0108340001,
-0.0399170853,
-0.0039142207,
-0.0008573917,
-0.0425694808,
0.0329756401,
-0.0247840732,
0.0040401304,
0.0331179611,
0.0077926051,
-0.000018666,
-0.0017141037,
-0.049135346,
0.0111445868,
-0.0092206113,
0.0059449915,
0.060289111,
0.0104612559,
0.0125772972,
0.0546993092,
0.0136012333,
0.0140760271,
-0.0111496076,
0.035120286,
0.0103041157,
0.0451512896,
0.0414248481,
-0.0391043499,
0.0388169885,
-0.0245951209,
-0.0501872003,
-0.0129309902,
0.0652788505,
0.046413444,
0.0434070118,
0.0267909747,
-0.0342915654,
0.0359989852,
-0.0192791149,
0.0525416769,
-0.0592430681,
-0.005669158,
0.0320649929,
-0.0132474247,
0.049646154,
-0.0179476775,
0.0246682987,
0.0109285116,
0.0183289759,
0.0154197253,
-0.0204162784,
0.0190214459,
-0.0053289603,
0.0458678044,
-0.0476065315,
-0.0125310682,
0.0092877364,
-0.000672883,
0.0202685259,
-0.0340921916,
-0.0030624806,
0.0343632326,
-0.0240157396,
-0.0178661142,
-0.0416098237,
-0.0082025966,
0.0328699388,
-0.0332164876,
0.0791521445,
-0.0318847261,
-0.0192681905,
0.0083952276,
-0.012518242,
-0.0086023835,
-0.0296093002,
0.0391701609,
-0.0079866042,
0.027216861,
0.0054377578,
-0.0044500777,
-0.0513237193,
0.0435743853,
0.0054524303,
-0.0203841962,
-0.0013764533,
0.0292026941,
2.583e-7,
0.0098176934,
0.03608891,
0.0067797164,
0.0649705976,
0.0440833643,
-0.0212856717,
-0.0460945144,
-0.038840916,
-0.0147533091,
-0.0048710159,
0.0271144304,
0.0482235998,
0.0536199398,
0.022034578,
0.0282133818,
-0.0312809646,
-0.0334759615,
-0.0128429206,
-0.0621851869,
0.0030527799,
0.0585043132,
0.0328578949,
0.0453432798,
-0.0034949575,
-0.0004466679,
-0.0409016572,
0.0708503351,
-0.0158480853,
-0.0128519405,
0.0120881135,
0.0528532565,
0.0074114921,
-0.0063388115,
0.0174523536,
0.0129293138,
0.0021325785,
-0.0554821156,
0.0439372621,
-0.0082258303,
-0.0531047843,
-0.0235418007,
-0.0505681112,
-0.0317738354,
-0.0344181657,
0.1084294543,
-0.0366823003,
-0.0654724166,
0.0085125165,
0.0083521139,
-0.0015965761,
0.0128689623,
0.0435349271,
0.0006297448,
0.0018468645,
0.0048773978,
-0.0319639444,
-0.0315840803,
-0.1145907342,
-0.0444602706,
0.0528442189,
-0.0275380351,
-0.027447693,
-0.0772454813,
0.0126780234,
0.0179038122,
-0.0389793217,
-0.042106811,
2.210122464e-34,
0.0161769204,
-0.0017180748,
0.0081284456,
0.0330196768,
0.0305553041,
-0.0253866632,
0.0026095062,
-0.001606339,
0.0123163089,
-0.0624991134,
-0.0103728417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17647v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17647v2 | Text as Images: Can Multimodal Large Language Models Follow Printed Instructions in Pixels? | 2023-11-29T14:08:53 | 2024-06-10T23:39:24 | Xiujun Li, Yujie Lu, Zhe Gan, Jianfeng Gao, William Yang Wang, Yejin Choi | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have shown promising
instruction following capabilities on vision-language tasks. In this work, we
introduce VISUAL MODALITY INSTRUCTION (VIM), and investigate how well
multimodal models can understand textual instructions provided in pixels,
despite not being explicitly trained on such data during pretraining or
fine-tuning. We adapt VIM to eight benchmarks, including OKVQA, MM-Vet,
MathVista, MMMU, and probe diverse MLLMs in both the text-modality instruction
(TEM) setting and VIM setting. Notably, we observe a significant performance
disparity between the original TEM and VIM settings for open-source MLLMs,
indicating that open-source MLLMs face greater challenges when text instruction
is presented solely in image form. To address this issue, we train v-MLLM, a
generalizable model that is capable to conduct robust instruction following in
both text-modality and visual-modality instructions. | [
0.0023468474,
0.0773698613,
0.017634023,
0.0569396541,
-0.0258592349,
0.0174564868,
0.0205194391,
0.0024774184,
-0.0039482303,
-0.0774052292,
-0.0582325086,
-0.0133792814,
-0.0034442334,
-0.0039866501,
0.0601971224,
-0.0485425182,
0.0144698285,
-0.0731024891,
-0.0357162133,
0.0038659633,
0.0413470082,
0.012806627,
-0.0419384837,
0.0148277804,
-0.0254991259,
-0.0552672669,
-0.0103874598,
0.0208456907,
0.0165814739,
-0.0216898769,
-0.0005688047,
0.0332390182,
0.0550613366,
0.0058675418,
0.0000019267,
-0.0049261162,
0.0356027335,
-0.0022579881,
0.0310933944,
0.020305939,
0.0490275174,
-0.0713071153,
-0.0161221623,
-0.0139194503,
-0.0137913907,
-0.0024338835,
0.0620778389,
0.0231773891,
0.0731661543,
0.074657023,
-0.0097207511,
-0.007654475,
0.0152327651,
-0.0214373134,
0.0362347364,
-0.0235918816,
-0.0013954402,
0.0227804147,
-0.012427222,
0.0337778702,
-0.0553944074,
0.0488215014,
0.0369174704,
-0.0237728339,
-0.0425956547,
0.0303881671,
0.047931008,
-0.0330910571,
-0.0480825789,
0.0862508863,
-0.0095963944,
0.0143888528,
-0.0284012184,
0.0025185884,
-0.012313664,
-0.0002012092,
-0.0709303692,
0.0698390231,
-0.0020976432,
0.0078688385,
-0.0446878783,
-0.0249443073,
0.0115366718,
0.0101527441,
0.0085745202,
-0.0132077252,
0.029754065,
-0.0011594687,
-0.0249768496,
0.0086524356,
-0.0587036535,
-0.0260613095,
0.0099101746,
0.0406231694,
-0.0062696328,
0.0040947883,
-0.0611962825,
-0.0398914255,
0.0123629738,
-0.054295592,
0.0855686218,
0.0290779192,
-0.0605834424,
0.0263778381,
-0.0332233906,
0.0469633266,
-0.0339182913,
0.0731532723,
-0.0109653175,
0.0203882605,
-0.0247729104,
0.0075185411,
-0.017007729,
-0.0258717183,
-0.0565081127,
-0.026486475,
-0.0067345798,
0.0207642261,
-0.0104786791,
0.0325641371,
-0.0070624119,
0.0008430232,
-0.0288563091,
-0.037680503,
0.007178972,
0.0398411043,
-0.0044469121,
0.0231426861,
-0.0219122302,
-0.0276864152,
0.0069714212,
0.0575356893,
0.0130039938,
-0.0235622805,
0.0049906392,
0.1054115072,
-0.0419300497,
-0.0319396779,
-0.0257564019,
0.0027065517,
-0.0138390576,
-0.049968347,
0.0347095579,
-0.0353669636,
0.0149056613,
0.0046102949,
0.0236567035,
0.0172756724,
0.0032312975,
0.0357983857,
0.0161376428,
0.0721222609,
0.0266441703,
-0.0353541039,
0.0227374397,
0.0057795304,
0.0312444959,
0.0515142083,
0.0377434716,
0.0260513127,
0.0128431087,
-0.0134934578,
0.0000622354,
0.0752803236,
-0.0022862151,
0.0281637963,
-0.0447255,
-0.0018341049,
0.017929269,
0.0251688175,
0.0760198832,
0.0616707318,
-0.0424811617,
-0.0257977657,
0.0897816345,
0.0036792012,
0.0121921077,
-0.0251936521,
0.0561581664,
0.0156516079,
0.0202918258,
0.0163499955,
-0.0959761739,
0.027471913,
0.0112734661,
0.019326983,
0.0023501932,
0.025409488,
-0.0195816495,
-0.026711788,
-0.0005713003,
-0.0241441261,
0.0054996954,
-0.004265096,
0.0446582362,
0.0132522462,
-0.0631581917,
-0.0094023589,
0.0234418791,
-0.0196428429,
-0.0132898511,
-0.0272914283,
0.0276167635,
0.0405654609,
0.0134794749,
0.0083822738,
-0.0136522576,
-0.0121952705,
0.0507226139,
0.0453827232,
0.0101063941,
-0.0049011083,
0.044287689,
-0.0854484364,
-0.0125714587,
-0.0254263654,
-0.0014667644,
0.0032405658,
-0.007131137,
-0.003706157,
-0.0138001759,
-0.0102678677,
-0.0287863016,
0.0629087538,
0.037874978,
-0.0425440148,
-0.0475895591,
0.0071649998,
-0.0198567584,
-0.0238310359,
-0.0179279856,
-0.0047036442,
0.0150441648,
-0.0349748544,
0.0343150683,
-0.0126359453,
-0.0600272566,
-0.0540991463,
0.0174041204,
-0.0227739923,
-0.0297573134,
0.0120236734,
-0.0397665724,
0.0140430406,
-0.0102700209,
-0.0086210407,
-0.0111542987,
-0.0336028934,
-0.017286906,
0.048508957,
-0.0000397794,
-0.0329281427,
0.0132022928,
-0.0277667269,
-0.0043923166,
0.0453867167,
0.0167635903,
-0.0029544833,
0.0029283161,
0.00650186,
-0.001057439,
0.0079389326,
0.0444961153,
-0.0288111605,
0.0466582812,
-0.0240344424,
-0.0339434631,
-0.1133613139,
-0.0062913881,
-0.0315010063,
0.0155766141,
0.0275138672,
-0.0116588017,
-0.0021738997,
-0.0607144348,
-0.0027444481,
0.0204252675,
-0.0087842494,
0.0024345028,
0.0162657648,
0.0111791221,
0.0188087113,
-0.0272285454,
-0.015498247,
0.0026083703,
0.0421525389,
-0.0092655616,
0.0237514358,
-0.0531179085,
-0.0175100416,
-0.0200006459,
0.0290825758,
-0.0219691787,
-0.0380625762,
0.0251861401,
-0.0269138739,
0.0661984608,
0.1027387008,
0.020890234,
0.0292644221,
0.0132975662,
-0.0192715805,
-0.0443813205,
0.0059180465,
0.0061360011,
-0.0397930592,
-0.0309547316,
-0.0225214288,
-0.0337064192,
0.0854949802,
-0.0162154026,
0.0381387174,
-0.0376238413,
-0.0069868094,
-0.0123959901,
-0.0379390121,
-0.0410679355,
0.0417113565,
-0.0116260061,
-0.0098788403,
-0.0391936265,
-0.0965877026,
0.0247114487,
-0.0514441691,
-0.0539263785,
0.0064568175,
-0.003781986,
-0.0136932237,
0.0402667895,
0.0417478532,
0.0208865982,
-0.037749134,
-0.0132943466,
-0.0559030995,
0.0046079396,
0.0181677472,
0.0130628655,
0.0722701997,
-0.0647248924,
0.005892776,
-0.0423578545,
-0.0086000869,
0.0009935048,
-0.0280889198,
-0.017339984,
-0.0165756419,
-0.0202192701,
-0.026038371,
-0.0179805681,
0.005349271,
0.0596996173,
0.0267467089,
-0.016526809,
-0.0153129613,
-0.0402680486,
0.0052314978,
0.0434930585,
0.0178448223,
-0.0509648733,
-0.0900119022,
-0.0017430098,
0.0527650155,
0.0015449995,
-0.0112788705,
-0.0626050085,
0.0265983529,
0.0228425544,
0.0522151217,
-0.0139217097,
0.0493363366,
0.0879793614,
-0.0759959891,
0.0160894375,
0.0530989319,
0.0059650796,
-0.0294484515,
-0.032666117,
0.0106822699,
0.0513160601,
0.0038179376,
0.011887583,
-0.1004685014,
-0.0618470199,
-0.0094272662,
0.0018996674,
0.0514150485,
0.0210726429,
-0.0276817828,
-0.0335101336,
0.0474657528,
0.0042100199,
-0.0177323278,
-0.0186002385,
0.0029329956,
-0.0061353901,
-0.013001902,
0.0177116841,
-0.0103101572,
-0.0353568569,
0.004977758,
0.0249027293,
0.0425746627,
-0.0323307551,
-0.0058031972,
-0.0352204107,
-0.0041464861,
0.0573626049,
-0.0098100249,
0.0086756721,
-0.0470760576,
0.0437125564,
0.0383132957,
0.0000647031,
-0.0079219136,
0.067775473,
-0.0347257331,
-0.0352665596,
-0.0057057701,
0.0356967598,
-0.0185626075,
-0.0128044244,
0.0182782747,
0.0331075229,
-0.0194480009,
-0.0163544472,
-0.00368389,
-0.0038023992,
-0.0119915027,
0.0117241396,
0.0150534585,
-0.0541990846,
-0.0478412136,
-0.0474775769,
-0.0041825669,
-0.0542191975,
-0.0359100886,
0.015152717,
-0.0178378522,
0.0131023368,
-0.0430370308,
-0.0579573438,
0.0252204407,
0.0582184717,
-0.0081702722,
-0.0464271121,
0.0190814938,
-0.0137406178,
-0.0410771742,
0.0626299605,
-0.0259532239,
0.0436309651,
-0.0910383463,
-0.0274036825,
0.0300324559,
-0.0175457653,
-0.0093266256,
0.0145586403,
-0.1167486459,
-0.0448724441,
-0.0378637165,
0.0856266692,
0.0032136817,
0.0465571657,
0.0185689311,
-0.0555829331,
0.0138373384,
0.0347489193,
-0.0216140039,
0.040196877,
0.0349372588,
-0.0211868025,
-0.0129601825,
0.0175210349,
0.0013015245,
0.0334219299,
-0.0026362592,
0.0123496559,
0.0013066974,
-0.0025860658,
0.0114439502,
-0.0179157816,
-0.0010864884,
-0.0197106451,
0.014952058,
-0.0322999805,
0.0191617329,
-0.0037298109,
-0.0082750907,
-0.0735664219,
0.0203587264,
0.0101563167,
0.0196650941,
0.0084486883,
-0.0008563515,
0.0344076641,
0.0327503011,
-0.0501274839,
0.0557160228,
0.0006422184,
0.0134545751,
0.0319645517,
0.0456803329,
0.0078160632,
0.0465831608,
-0.0269819964,
0.0553739108,
-0.0091384957,
0.102214247,
0.0259612687,
-0.0143913897,
-0.0055594835,
0.0260625426,
-0.0034147885,
-0.0438849851,
-0.0284139123,
0.0513337292,
0.0539821163,
0.0009173326,
0.0260532424,
-0.0221859924,
-0.0113119856,
-0.0123736337,
0.0677043125,
0.0032151926,
-0.0259546582,
0.0593361743,
0.032991875,
0.0195555724,
-0.0133344727,
0.0736310557,
0.0124327047,
0.0314665139,
0.0066648941,
0.0310484953,
-0.0519975647,
-0.0335112289,
0.073431924,
0.0052568982,
0.0178549811,
0.0310506113,
0.0258644447,
-0.0360910483,
-0.0044019781,
0.0272220578,
-0.0327653736,
-0.0243044011,
0.0298302919,
0.0452452786,
-0.004142948,
-0.0343702957,
-0.020439757,
0.0050160419,
0.0311253648,
-0.0033795307,
-0.0092526609,
-5.652886579e-33,
-0.0235141851,
-0.0305176433,
0.0489422642,
-0.0168531407,
0.0023119969,
0.0226902477,
-0.0122798486,
0.009005296,
0.0057797795,
0.0154555431,
0.0533585697,
-0.0075113368,
0.0096086068,
0.0666851103,
-0.0046908385,
0.0160309225,
0.0188629087,
-0.0460011885,
0.0002186831,
0.0028172284,
-0.0015469309,
0.0056577902,
0.0616458096,
-0.0375943966,
0.0143503174,
0.0059073255,
-0.0522533692,
-0.0022650911,
-0.03115879,
0.0815727115,
-0.0452996269,
-0.0009939732,
0.0057033105,
0.0056517026,
-0.05260133,
0.0467321202,
-0.0542642921,
0.0205485839,
0.0063866349,
0.0468368679,
-0.1228604913,
0.0031802154,
0.0432038829,
-0.0503461026,
-0.0088127283,
-0.0170298088,
0.033346761,
-0.0019012354,
-0.0037729244,
0.0406667069,
-0.0612887181,
0.0115867285,
-0.0052250689,
-0.0458183289,
0.0447670445,
0.0348287746,
0.016422322,
0.0212098658,
-0.0415028371,
0.0142138628,
0.0135822166,
0.0450985841,
0.0638212115,
0.0480959266,
-0.0187884998,
0.0311556421,
0.031320896,
-0.0386388376,
-0.0145564908,
0.0275676213,
0.0564637072,
0.0478396676,
0.03849601,
0.0536236912,
-0.0001065001,
0.0568750203,
-0.0399942584,
0.003694793,
-0.0317585133,
0.0203646999,
0.018985495,
0.0096503627,
-0.003651106,
0.0011350458,
-0.0314555578,
0.0054512722,
-0.0330922529,
-0.0072573,
0.0584332533,
0.0281027574,
-0.002959219,
0.0254292134,
0.079884015,
-0.0035217572,
-0.0550068617,
-0.0102159744,
-0.043929521,
0.0804580376,
-0.0174366534,
0.0063492791,
-0.0683557391,
-0.042382542,
0.0593063831,
-0.0353130586,
0.023683466,
0.0116785876,
0.046516981,
0.0190951265,
-0.0673050135,
-0.0034594827,
-0.0258733053,
0.0024724496,
0.0187810604,
0.0464560725,
0.0512833521,
-0.0146350106,
-0.0549317785,
0.0797468573,
-0.0240930431,
-0.027947817,
-0.0192623939,
-0.0610228032,
-0.0307552889,
0.0313873254,
-0.0274561699,
-0.0034631472,
-0.0534110852,
-0.047090061,
-0.0120449439,
-0.060561344,
0.0000163055,
0.0345354006,
2.409e-7,
0.0289442819,
0.0250789002,
0.0282981899,
0.0162597764,
0.0128502883,
0.0546617322,
-0.038936317,
0.01312357,
0.002255345,
-0.0587408133,
-0.0099043967,
0.0515143201,
0.021545494,
-0.0012594399,
-0.0023025463,
0.0187043212,
-0.0229535177,
0.0141673489,
-0.0471279733,
0.0115505345,
0.0301659461,
0.0664953142,
-0.059779346,
-0.0143330488,
0.067039676,
-0.0533441417,
0.0908009708,
-0.0130841443,
-0.0248900056,
-0.0253969785,
-0.0159005746,
-0.0101144575,
-0.0381823108,
-0.0036631054,
-0.0007502525,
-0.0556706674,
0.0167217255,
0.1022813916,
-0.0145894606,
0.0173666272,
-0.014860047,
0.0200489871,
-0.0492790379,
-0.0275869071,
0.0363251753,
-0.0394783877,
-0.0104812952,
-0.0288364589,
0.0156204849,
-0.01273527,
0.0007832446,
-0.0367154703,
-0.0350885168,
0.0198097695,
0.051108893,
-0.045677945,
-0.0512588359,
-0.0620057136,
-0.0403187871,
-0.0023681498,
-0.0292290449,
-0.0292673204,
-0.0961479992,
-0.0045360774,
0.0275933016,
-0.027598178,
-0.0629132092,
2.060311219e-34,
0.017682815,
-0.0320456065,
0.022951765,
0.0332891084,
0.0217723083,
-0.0091952346,
-0.0373545811,
0.0024191469,
0.0142837251,
-0.0859000161,
-0.0242270678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17633v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17633v1 | Introduction to Transformers: an NLP Perspective | 2023-11-29T13:51:04 | 2023-11-29T13:51:04 | Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformers have dominated empirical machine learning models of natural
language processing. In this paper, we introduce basic concepts of Transformers
and present key techniques that form the recent advances of these models. This
includes a description of the standard Transformer architecture, a series of
model refinements, and common applications. Given that Transformers and related
deep learning techniques might be evolving in ways we have never seen, we
cannot dive into all the model details or cover all the technical areas.
Instead, we focus on just those concepts that are helpful for gaining a good
understanding of Transformers and their variants. We also summarize the key
ideas that impact this field, thereby yielding some insights into the strengths
and limitations of these models. | [
0.0656557307,
0.0411986858,
-0.0101269521,
0.0386103876,
-0.0365286618,
-0.010924804,
-0.0278188828,
-0.0208230298,
-0.0292768013,
-0.0380117483,
-0.0269733779,
-0.0448322855,
0.0051640002,
0.0253983513,
-0.0008461035,
-0.0682332814,
0.050319694,
0.0301321261,
-0.0406517051,
0.0324488729,
-0.009896175,
-0.0052990681,
0.0002128933,
0.080436945,
-0.0460817367,
-0.0196782257,
0.013017118,
-0.0141850328,
0.0088224737,
0.0011455133,
0.0295775924,
0.0321378298,
-0.0106100906,
0.0381572954,
0.0000018281,
0.0081077768,
0.0091992328,
0.0054676924,
-0.014446619,
-0.0233438946,
0.0305446014,
-0.0625829399,
-0.0075367298,
0.0156970154,
-0.04815308,
-0.049179025,
0.0653114915,
0.1064391136,
0.0582138263,
0.0754115209,
-0.0179216843,
-0.0646908879,
0.054994192,
-0.0366118774,
-0.043786481,
0.0070000733,
0.0261555631,
-0.075688839,
-0.036912024,
0.0162914172,
-0.029544279,
0.0202210285,
0.0148506146,
0.0214366838,
-0.0056004026,
0.016405819,
-0.0417063683,
-0.0220494587,
-0.0221455004,
0.0508732162,
-0.0318214186,
-0.0020791758,
0.0109643396,
0.0126172677,
-0.0271508973,
0.0149953375,
-0.022915272,
0.0259735249,
0.0393600203,
0.0149283232,
-0.0098979631,
0.0435559973,
0.0386887081,
0.0078332713,
-0.0394957215,
0.0566980764,
0.0070516551,
-0.0130366897,
-0.0260180607,
0.0113626579,
-0.0106672291,
-0.0213193875,
0.0289734844,
0.0350990891,
0.0036415085,
0.0169451702,
-0.0084919594,
-0.0501997136,
0.0121385874,
-0.0194538627,
0.0096388021,
-0.0070661861,
-0.0190820806,
0.0212332439,
-0.0220556241,
0.043631956,
-0.0721514672,
0.0644254163,
-0.0162099209,
-0.0139180413,
-0.0301765837,
-0.0240457468,
-0.0370687917,
0.0337873697,
-0.0225399416,
-0.0258494187,
-0.0378310829,
0.0264962353,
0.0094071915,
-0.037038628,
0.0303442758,
0.0598733872,
-0.0414924063,
0.0026296854,
-0.0179729797,
0.0758517459,
0.0070705712,
-0.0019390346,
-0.009944099,
-0.045251213,
-0.0133367134,
0.0116238911,
0.014181342,
-0.0220996086,
0.0085486881,
0.1002880782,
0.0257439017,
-0.0631959513,
-0.0100080352,
0.010266386,
-0.0236218125,
-0.0538655408,
0.0223444942,
-0.048653353,
0.0095432373,
-0.0001871676,
0.0271131136,
-0.0296814479,
0.0193930622,
0.0453422368,
-0.0187558122,
0.0944783688,
0.0238573384,
-0.019033717,
-0.0062199212,
0.0043787728,
-0.0054036728,
0.0279460736,
0.0318052992,
0.0149125671,
0.0322270319,
-0.0136994254,
0.0385468565,
0.0401319563,
-0.0144202653,
-0.0150631806,
0.0253940262,
-0.0496606715,
-0.0573344938,
-0.0084145609,
-0.0183599982,
0.0864471644,
-0.0278037321,
-0.0176748,
0.0526996739,
0.0447555371,
0.012326763,
0.066811569,
0.0355698019,
-0.0045323283,
-0.0048302049,
0.0133476239,
-0.047501862,
0.0006217863,
0.0152974185,
-0.0329016969,
-0.0745534375,
0.0181057937,
-0.0346164033,
-0.0435408615,
-0.0027910008,
-0.0320017114,
0.01070101,
-0.0416151248,
0.0477862731,
0.0432844348,
-0.0380800441,
0.1088826731,
-0.0013107981,
-0.0241534933,
-0.0016318691,
-0.049947165,
-0.0508822575,
0.0003896692,
0.0379826836,
-0.0333616287,
-0.0077240374,
-0.0317919329,
-0.0563495308,
0.0420492589,
0.0268071089,
0.0074728797,
-0.010635905,
-0.0275693126,
0.0005108495,
0.0085594477,
0.0433176123,
-0.0106398435,
0.0040576761,
-0.0300702453,
0.0246826205,
-0.0384904183,
0.0275517628,
0.037485972,
-0.0061556003,
-0.0154546797,
0.0339732952,
0.0228330605,
0.0144806998,
0.0102235135,
0.0084334714,
0.0229678433,
0.0457414277,
-0.0434021316,
-0.0529979281,
0.0293019079,
-0.0323527195,
-0.020436069,
0.0135678146,
-0.0834038556,
0.016910959,
0.1194922626,
-0.0260103345,
-0.0300936289,
0.0089452816,
-0.0568081327,
0.0453502983,
-0.02055021,
0.020566104,
0.0181886088,
0.0543852448,
-0.0478880778,
0.0691144988,
-0.0122483131,
-0.003758661,
0.0062548975,
-0.0352556147,
0.0065107034,
0.0080379788,
-0.0631325692,
0.0198567491,
-0.0526757538,
0.0045949798,
0.0267439801,
-0.0310537182,
-0.0157139841,
-0.0402164273,
-0.0309576374,
-0.0128140775,
-0.0260999873,
0.0172346998,
0.0255955774,
0.0080608856,
0.0327472761,
-0.0021574518,
-0.0099765863,
-0.0130781978,
0.0178611092,
0.0122989267,
0.0437850915,
-0.0147781894,
-0.0274689142,
-0.0069965855,
-0.0543705411,
-0.0188874099,
0.0920418799,
-0.035687875,
-0.0235496629,
-0.047570888,
-0.0157043133,
0.0010129558,
0.0520529971,
-0.0107159056,
-0.045134671,
-0.0182563402,
0.0062244316,
0.0466296598,
0.029330723,
0.0328377821,
0.0557546392,
0.0091480268,
0.009688261,
-0.0134481993,
0.0058826148,
-0.081853047,
0.0021328384,
-0.0540846586,
-0.0213728547,
0.0243768618,
0.0860792622,
-0.0139764557,
-0.0181196071,
-0.0253713634,
-0.0174755342,
-0.0143024074,
-0.0186871868,
0.0360578299,
-0.0247419197,
-0.0251016375,
0.0007302111,
-0.0168979242,
-0.0030240566,
0.0316320732,
-0.0104726041,
0.0188422557,
-0.0384528413,
-0.0188746173,
-0.0468975306,
0.0528352261,
0.0397540294,
-0.0009520791,
0.0075859423,
-0.0547209643,
-0.0218570381,
0.0165597089,
-0.0001517423,
-0.0353717878,
0.0908773839,
0.0164273772,
-0.0077183209,
-0.0385046154,
-0.034168683,
-0.0527220741,
-0.0385607146,
-0.0244250353,
0.0314990506,
0.0451169983,
-0.0280479975,
-0.0798649862,
0.0214750133,
-0.0218381509,
0.0298816152,
0.0114958556,
-0.0172011852,
-0.0457658693,
0.0527615882,
0.0314074196,
0.0333128124,
0.055867523,
0.0195546597,
0.0134330168,
0.0768721923,
0.0411923975,
0.0354907475,
-0.0419217311,
-0.0181175191,
0.0514776483,
-0.0569992252,
-0.0183547735,
-0.0090495357,
-0.0015165901,
-0.0490260608,
-0.0075125718,
0.0757944956,
0.0211607665,
-0.0387337357,
0.0243157316,
0.0361064449,
-0.005109827,
0.0150101548,
0.0085073141,
-0.0569465905,
-0.0296291299,
0.0079701236,
-0.0253745094,
-0.0140574584,
-0.0358054563,
0.0103864744,
-0.0826271847,
0.0290028062,
-0.0324474238,
0.0135146882,
-0.0491957925,
-0.0397273116,
0.0183631591,
-0.0521118939,
0.0319051109,
-0.0414978899,
-0.0148599856,
-0.0574644059,
0.0235530883,
-0.024077218,
-0.0284116138,
0.0059711444,
-0.0484274663,
-0.0125506753,
0.0695768446,
0.0237115938,
-0.0083024232,
-0.0356096327,
0.0147119015,
-0.0337695219,
0.0112267863,
0.0033405102,
0.0601575971,
-0.0300060995,
-0.0401122756,
-0.0039544646,
0.0136797605,
-0.0585007109,
-0.0252725966,
-0.0723280832,
0.0794112682,
0.0018721943,
-0.0206789207,
-0.0289772134,
-0.0017184238,
-0.029969437,
0.0386297293,
-0.0051938216,
-0.0417174846,
-0.0619142875,
-0.0038216775,
0.0409436598,
-0.0272222031,
-0.0824840516,
0.0130537022,
0.0445153303,
-0.0672651604,
-0.0541953221,
-0.0162494872,
-0.0302150957,
-0.0227920506,
0.0204569846,
-0.0351033174,
0.0764605328,
-0.0168140344,
-0.0437621884,
0.0220119338,
-0.018049866,
0.028172059,
-0.058642894,
0.029854143,
0.0743497014,
-0.000649531,
-0.0325510129,
-0.002527039,
-0.125663653,
-0.0291275699,
0.0180500429,
0.031424053,
0.0145959482,
-0.0016433792,
-0.0322112367,
-0.040345896,
0.0082057584,
0.0561887026,
-0.0149863167,
-0.0062359548,
0.0504413284,
-0.0254729651,
-0.0207471158,
0.0376338437,
-0.0038968078,
0.0372568928,
0.0042643943,
0.0336759239,
-0.0305158421,
-0.0312364679,
0.0533180647,
-0.0308004133,
0.0910299942,
0.0326141007,
0.0151913678,
-0.0001594999,
0.0170868728,
0.0119656846,
-0.0016671321,
-0.0297732279,
-0.0191048682,
0.0129989265,
0.030373862,
-0.0282639638,
0.0349284075,
0.0109759802,
0.0206827559,
-0.0196867064,
0.0180247147,
0.0114675034,
-0.0576079302,
-0.0259683821,
0.0451067798,
0.0058259144,
0.0001031163,
0.0225715395,
0.0088056512,
0.0076143746,
0.0134154474,
0.028363023,
0.020805547,
-0.0522663295,
0.0201672353,
-0.0845037848,
0.0163228698,
-0.0147081399,
0.00024034,
0.0231931433,
-0.0332986787,
0.0114728902,
-0.0227369852,
-0.0098376274,
-0.0157100409,
0.022099847,
-0.0115309712,
-0.0065987026,
0.0102395574,
0.0002599352,
0.0143774888,
-0.005806596,
0.0636797324,
-0.0441950709,
0.0442626402,
0.0005093471,
-0.0048538633,
-0.0458370894,
-0.0167358685,
-0.0063908556,
-0.0332371444,
0.0193713382,
0.0095421979,
-0.0505774207,
-0.0577994175,
0.0697372854,
-0.0522209927,
0.0466075093,
-0.0496489778,
0.0149130244,
0.0577574484,
0.0349765718,
-0.0144280391,
-0.0144415544,
-0.0111259744,
0.011049903,
0.0033870465,
-0.0193068199,
-5.931749838e-33,
0.0003114717,
-0.0145527469,
-0.0081076492,
0.0100079188,
-0.0333567113,
0.0203295611,
0.0027314469,
0.0041776565,
-0.0472218916,
-0.0043400181,
-0.0198564827,
0.0078618275,
0.010216197,
0.0468406826,
-0.0194553286,
-0.0448651053,
0.0585243441,
0.0053002816,
-0.0046906844,
-0.0199326351,
0.0073971027,
0.026704371,
0.0704595596,
-0.056313578,
-0.0274432898,
0.0083574895,
-0.0217580311,
0.0469173118,
-0.0317185298,
0.091931805,
-0.0213073771,
0.0390219018,
0.0464215353,
-0.0722214058,
0.0042320453,
0.0508226901,
-0.0939172506,
-0.0001370607,
-0.0579877757,
0.0435541756,
-0.0336091518,
-0.0266390294,
0.0756638572,
0.0221762359,
-0.0034822333,
-0.0410226025,
0.0452478118,
0.0082696239,
0.0035299947,
-0.0303887799,
-0.0362165459,
0.0216680337,
-0.002659118,
-0.0318171494,
0.0107081831,
0.0672343969,
0.0055567129,
0.0463982187,
-0.087726146,
-0.0020395005,
0.0336703137,
0.059998434,
0.0210172068,
0.0048568789,
-0.0361895561,
0.0458091199,
-0.0005417279,
-0.0138286306,
-0.062721774,
-0.0372474268,
0.0294517279,
0.0641093105,
0.0558598824,
0.0081471503,
0.0214475729,
-0.0100538777,
-0.0369107015,
-0.0027352117,
-0.0176511761,
0.0702502951,
0.0314185135,
-0.0180661157,
-0.0060030599,
0.009489214,
-0.0426066443,
-0.0245966502,
-0.023326071,
-0.0064139944,
-0.0002383387,
0.0502671674,
-0.0339110233,
0.0498922989,
0.0156543143,
-0.0742399246,
0.0013008746,
0.0227739885,
0.0050634481,
0.0521579608,
-0.0103389742,
0.016122682,
-0.040537253,
-0.0192159712,
0.0050328504,
-0.002549317,
-0.0127700986,
-0.0237033125,
0.0357934497,
0.0440187044,
-0.0537930541,
-0.0188003499,
-0.0214106571,
0.0467310585,
-0.0369823761,
0.0718801618,
0.0285911597,
0.0303273946,
-0.0299228355,
0.0197983775,
0.0051998422,
0.027133761,
-0.0129866004,
0.0620014295,
0.0429483913,
0.0146376556,
0.0088846236,
-0.0096363397,
-0.0451961048,
0.0193130784,
0.0145848142,
-0.072054483,
-0.0214677211,
-0.0243660323,
2.525e-7,
0.0519593358,
0.0423507877,
0.0467064939,
0.0336310938,
0.0287996065,
0.0413446091,
0.0465608872,
0.0376831517,
-0.0031472268,
-0.0065466249,
0.0027202959,
0.0109833106,
-0.0019812917,
-0.0079401964,
-0.0821463466,
0.0070482651,
-0.0760385469,
0.0075658183,
-0.0096131954,
-0.0196770281,
0.0378106683,
0.1271482706,
-0.0142874494,
-0.034188658,
-0.0317531079,
0.0275763962,
0.0649088547,
-0.011346193,
0.0097996453,
0.0263617039,
0.0182220954,
0.0225911159,
0.0302662924,
0.0333262272,
-0.0172616392,
0.0337408222,
0.0244790055,
0.0450766496,
-0.011508245,
-0.0504084639,
0.0099263275,
0.0178448372,
-0.0027642024,
0.0096782483,
0.0401273556,
-0.0629773438,
-0.0115585392,
-0.0256057549,
-0.0280332193,
0.0285780896,
-0.0018728039,
-0.002712053,
-0.0184876099,
0.0332556888,
0.0321428031,
-0.0016771337,
-0.0373262279,
-0.1031637415,
-0.0052515212,
-0.0069161789,
-0.0476112999,
0.0211421102,
-0.0274578333,
-0.0454604924,
0.0246933009,
-0.0102862706,
-0.0260969475,
2.274662614e-34,
0.0069190329,
0.0324426293,
-0.0114030028,
0.0471024401,
-0.0100238509,
-0.0155387167,
0.0422717929,
0.0025417309,
-0.0114763509,
-0.061755117,
-0.0220555998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17593v1 | LanGWM: Language Grounded World Model | 2023-11-29T12:41:55 | 2023-11-29T12:41:55 | Rudra P. K. Poudel, Harit Pandya, Chao Zhang, Roberto Cipolla | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO | Recent advances in deep reinforcement learning have showcased its potential
in tackling complex tasks. However, experiments on visual control tasks have
revealed that state-of-the-art reinforcement learning models struggle with
out-of-distribution generalization. Conversely, expressing higher-level
concepts and global contexts is relatively easy using language.
Building upon recent success of the large language models, our main objective
is to improve the state abstraction technique in reinforcement learning by
leveraging language for robust action selection. Specifically, we focus on
learning language-grounded visual features to enhance the world model learning,
a model-based reinforcement learning technique.
To enforce our hypothesis explicitly, we mask out the bounding boxes of a few
objects in the image observation and provide the text prompt as descriptions
for these masked objects. Subsequently, we predict the masked objects along
with the surrounding regions as pixel reconstruction, similar to the
transformer-based masked autoencoder approach.
Our proposed LanGWM: Language Grounded World Model achieves state-of-the-art
performance in out-of-distribution test at the 100K interaction steps
benchmarks of iGibson point navigation tasks. Furthermore, our proposed
technique of explicit language-grounded visual representation learning has the
potential to improve models for human-robot interaction because our extracted
visual features are language grounded. | [
0.0118005574,
0.0550809726,
0.0044020009,
0.0276539437,
-0.0179220922,
0.0300264973,
0.011859972,
-0.0204390045,
0.0026509783,
-0.0547370203,
-0.0334923156,
-0.0187247731,
0.0061199628,
0.065463841,
0.0346682444,
-0.0850059837,
0.0228441022,
-0.071290642,
-0.0479953401,
-0.0207101554,
-0.0292943958,
-0.0030182656,
-0.0114025846,
0.0508409478,
-0.0068602925,
0.0367926657,
-0.037833076,
0.0106914816,
0.0389331728,
-0.043253839,
-0.0003378886,
0.0085082417,
0.0850414708,
0.0103200488,
0.0000022737,
-0.0214999337,
0.0219466053,
-0.071084179,
0.0226966161,
-0.0440241322,
-0.0120837605,
-0.0407294445,
-0.0072851293,
-0.0000253715,
-0.016730018,
-0.0421108827,
0.049670551,
0.0733177662,
0.0484465212,
0.035701368,
-0.0148503715,
0.001452635,
0.0047811102,
-0.0200908612,
0.0148777915,
-0.0241480209,
0.0135381771,
0.0396056846,
0.0064087044,
0.0312116574,
-0.0724843144,
-0.0066819624,
0.0375761017,
-0.0332565606,
-0.0012353031,
0.0653510019,
-0.0022047777,
-0.0263762176,
-0.0092818858,
0.0778133348,
-0.0675175637,
-0.0130631886,
-0.005681809,
-0.0093569634,
0.0075345826,
-0.0064786817,
-0.0156893712,
0.0484646708,
0.0236894935,
0.0574956574,
-0.0538140349,
-0.0023746365,
0.0055804076,
0.0054187612,
-0.0493251123,
0.080008097,
0.0031672949,
0.0143305939,
0.0142760742,
0.0024710628,
-0.0475542359,
-0.0599755459,
0.000936913,
0.0168675967,
-0.0427724347,
-0.0032736617,
-0.0402769335,
0.044935625,
-0.0510250628,
-0.0280754603,
0.0086466474,
0.0454456694,
-0.0338194892,
0.062238995,
-0.0161230899,
0.0719728917,
-0.0316147432,
0.0346194655,
-0.0162018538,
-0.009197996,
-0.0129257524,
0.0080009075,
-0.0179493744,
0.0155432932,
-0.067187041,
-0.034077663,
0.01679511,
0.0136627434,
-0.0479748249,
0.0291935392,
-0.0314159393,
0.0415672362,
-0.0446250103,
0.0030015742,
-0.04662228,
-0.0173111074,
-0.0402835906,
0.0242470242,
-0.0232206918,
-0.0127325272,
0.0052651013,
0.0372188576,
0.0410979167,
-0.0289203636,
0.0261451583,
0.0631329566,
-0.0154317794,
-0.0117297992,
-0.0087918304,
0.0106426757,
0.0121611608,
-0.0105093671,
0.0462929904,
-0.0619098842,
0.008502299,
-0.0215436872,
-0.0020084344,
-0.0587705076,
0.0215946268,
0.0139368707,
0.0104892962,
0.0692342669,
0.0377357975,
-0.0371914618,
0.0470923968,
0.0041075982,
-0.0053536068,
0.0342370197,
0.0400148369,
0.0720471367,
-0.0181873683,
0.0269561149,
0.0315087177,
0.0614008829,
-0.0287546273,
0.041677583,
-0.0517202057,
-0.0377880745,
0.0239467509,
0.0077138613,
0.0686485916,
0.0135631291,
-0.0587621629,
-0.0092167547,
0.0381176062,
0.0398055874,
-0.0437128395,
0.0031779793,
0.0161897577,
0.0092466772,
-0.0199672244,
-0.0410771891,
-0.0370903425,
0.0715297982,
-0.0018725749,
-0.0016984271,
-0.0632668808,
-0.0141055668,
-0.0581312664,
-0.036096096,
0.03212386,
-0.0059769922,
0.0461268313,
0.0325211175,
0.0520379953,
0.0238637589,
-0.0522104502,
0.010761057,
0.0404145978,
-0.0070655281,
0.02538055,
-0.0125983525,
0.0030347127,
0.0078577353,
0.0234421548,
-0.0246052649,
0.0267905761,
-0.0712795854,
0.0356294401,
0.0662478581,
-0.0547314361,
-0.016386563,
0.0579881519,
-0.0166717134,
-0.0912125185,
-0.0380482115,
-0.0232125614,
0.0440749191,
0.0155194523,
0.0106778741,
0.0018013865,
-0.003492611,
0.0034856999,
0.0305621419,
-0.0014605724,
-0.040416453,
0.0094788121,
0.019241849,
0.0098819714,
-0.0054793996,
-0.0072023571,
-0.0226030014,
-0.0029791873,
-0.0583889633,
-0.0085849697,
-0.0004427847,
-0.0515379868,
-0.0339760594,
0.0118245771,
-0.0583069213,
-0.0292706788,
0.0700380281,
-0.0063106194,
-0.0323610604,
-0.0152590461,
0.0086475378,
0.0120653687,
-0.0016365721,
-0.0243267994,
0.0183708277,
0.0028161129,
-0.0464332439,
0.0423928313,
-0.0403302424,
-0.0252026804,
0.0174944308,
0.0394681431,
-0.0095881941,
-0.0270855948,
-0.0185474344,
0.0192117207,
-0.0023259455,
-0.0200388506,
0.0499143153,
0.0436958112,
-0.0240854248,
0.0272348672,
-0.044145599,
-0.036092896,
-0.0389854759,
-0.0525049828,
-0.0043001045,
-0.0012741863,
-0.0024140216,
-0.0413632765,
0.0109697506,
0.0068556783,
0.0018447236,
-0.0084600504,
0.0277317353,
0.0278362781,
-0.0053530512,
-0.056926962,
0.0100692846,
0.0149739347,
0.0324720815,
0.0091581857,
-0.0306628384,
-0.0381265767,
0.0500436388,
-0.0170355793,
0.0753913745,
-0.0506722666,
-0.032818906,
0.0277685132,
-0.0554009974,
0.018336108,
0.0835908279,
-0.0342607424,
0.0256744381,
0.0358041115,
0.0050723553,
-0.0458101891,
0.0103507601,
-0.0340314694,
-0.0262118764,
-0.0312095638,
0.0224928148,
0.0301461704,
0.0253354032,
-0.0150122819,
0.032310687,
-0.0728624836,
-0.0055185417,
-0.0163335111,
-0.038847547,
-0.0933451131,
0.0279782843,
-0.0533096455,
0.0371725373,
-0.063544482,
-0.0357466862,
0.0449895225,
0.0032575631,
-0.0085288798,
0.0197057966,
-0.012430598,
0.0019632031,
0.0778992027,
0.0240012314,
0.0236513428,
-0.0310155768,
-0.0379879139,
-0.0316232666,
-0.0174659304,
-0.0086722197,
0.0448202454,
0.0404253677,
-0.0790619254,
-0.0064677633,
0.0036984554,
-0.0449131355,
-0.0492344499,
0.0356177129,
-0.0316158831,
0.0110270036,
-0.0357768126,
-0.0236341003,
-0.0012072641,
-0.0175958965,
0.0456086025,
0.0580063052,
-0.0004510617,
-0.0109650483,
-0.0389108956,
-0.0185615811,
0.0807780847,
0.0154120484,
-0.0423514359,
-0.0222324412,
0.0157490131,
0.0165977553,
0.0491764396,
-0.0178502537,
-0.0273865201,
0.0793510899,
0.0453069955,
0.0288673509,
0.0054458771,
0.04828123,
0.0358641222,
-0.0095110722,
-0.040920496,
0.0860093385,
0.0158335567,
-0.0109910769,
-0.0134122223,
-0.0395022072,
0.0539053753,
0.0358737558,
0.0269716792,
-0.0173625685,
-0.0287614912,
-0.002499735,
-0.0291741397,
0.0431771465,
-0.0104934983,
0.0259614531,
-0.093780458,
0.0224436335,
0.0197943691,
-0.0651515052,
-0.0852927566,
-0.0084328037,
0.0177941415,
-0.0134685375,
-0.0077394727,
0.0010529195,
0.0163779669,
-0.0253112223,
-0.0095183831,
0.0078705121,
-0.0156022767,
0.0245813094,
-0.0380979963,
-0.0304604266,
0.0521766469,
0.018302111,
-0.040545404,
-0.0245151874,
-0.00077166,
0.0285585709,
0.015119384,
-0.0149622355,
0.0114757232,
-0.0271867402,
-0.0462497622,
0.0293720067,
0.0796075463,
-0.0284210127,
-0.0411336496,
-0.0291800555,
0.0359129049,
-0.0246743727,
0.0208065677,
0.0075894464,
-0.0433725528,
0.0573364906,
0.0162404627,
-0.0091378717,
-0.0371706486,
-0.0577660315,
-0.0420790352,
-0.0400920548,
-0.0226905886,
-0.0349672548,
-0.0137829194,
0.014188732,
-0.0050813574,
-0.051685933,
-0.0286943484,
0.0749504417,
0.0628886744,
-0.0138493525,
-0.0660429597,
0.0085553927,
0.0231500231,
-0.0287492387,
0.0551088713,
-0.043170806,
0.0308533199,
-0.0200939048,
0.0038667168,
0.0412122644,
-0.0203495529,
-0.0296883173,
0.0137339374,
-0.0021614211,
-0.0519394875,
0.0026725249,
0.0855333284,
0.0106834881,
0.0751325935,
0.0169287138,
-0.0284680538,
0.0478855707,
-0.0258934218,
0.030529717,
0.0224699322,
0.0413093679,
0.0127678011,
-0.0090659,
0.0199134797,
-0.0731324703,
0.0255124029,
0.0394498296,
0.0030915744,
-0.0104167266,
-0.0196825378,
0.0150994109,
-0.0639094561,
0.0665244758,
-0.0369928814,
0.0092614554,
-0.0443569049,
-0.0098601766,
-0.0024194797,
-0.0070591345,
-0.0666514486,
0.0282750949,
0.0273651667,
0.0107549541,
0.0290240962,
0.0289866738,
0.0034111706,
0.0270840004,
-0.0217754971,
-0.0197297763,
0.0019581693,
0.0271295868,
-0.0000076912,
0.0370213687,
0.0083315177,
0.003089908,
0.0046066339,
0.0303702857,
0.0184547435,
0.0434202366,
0.0383324437,
-0.018276507,
-0.0596145801,
-0.0111208465,
-0.0466682203,
-0.0527321771,
-0.0404064916,
0.0133205615,
0.0542616062,
-0.0299171433,
0.0102953399,
-0.048971273,
-0.0175090302,
0.0101711396,
0.0221654736,
0.0031217574,
-0.0496948883,
0.060345117,
0.0405634828,
0.0051127779,
0.0250784531,
0.0443502888,
0.0585248061,
0.0390444994,
-0.0059585939,
0.0478990264,
-0.0415229797,
-0.0005649586,
0.0465288796,
0.0282450765,
-0.0059992336,
0.0497233979,
0.0038290287,
-0.0403999686,
-0.0238811132,
0.0285412502,
-0.0205959603,
-0.007096462,
0.0716352388,
0.0013046535,
0.008229618,
-0.0146362642,
-0.0275159683,
-0.0125473803,
0.0307515692,
-0.0108487196,
-0.0534709729,
-6.269521161e-33,
-0.0144464532,
-0.0392989255,
0.015372009,
-0.0166086592,
0.0038472922,
-0.0359244086,
-0.0423216447,
0.010804465,
-0.0133793093,
0.0485003814,
0.0055776397,
0.0051009343,
0.0086528985,
0.0623007901,
-0.0027258908,
-0.0009621372,
0.0399473719,
0.0153870219,
-0.0309771914,
0.0217508525,
0.0234005377,
0.0191785078,
0.0566039719,
-0.0620796345,
-0.0064126127,
0.0105998134,
-0.0180968195,
0.0262017418,
0.0512376465,
0.0226146951,
-0.0244944673,
-0.0105817216,
-0.0042795711,
-0.0587897487,
-0.0105937496,
0.0081684031,
-0.0806151703,
-0.062796317,
-0.0640559793,
0.0292911418,
-0.0558714308,
-0.0096890917,
0.0389215276,
-0.0097822128,
0.0152382879,
-0.0050607608,
0.0366756916,
-0.0098558106,
-0.0291117318,
0.0047663287,
-0.0578111745,
0.0117363315,
-0.0193197187,
-0.0355051085,
0.0275230967,
0.0461415388,
0.0078335814,
0.0137793431,
-0.0291997995,
-0.0151330251,
-0.0051142187,
0.0178564973,
0.055666212,
0.0763647631,
0.0708049759,
0.085274078,
-0.0090966709,
-0.0034111897,
-0.0148727084,
0.0079171583,
0.0386035517,
0.0608099736,
0.0137796374,
0.0507902466,
-0.0162924137,
0.006789261,
-0.0764438957,
0.0140616121,
-0.0703232065,
0.090880245,
-0.0497518256,
0.0482852347,
-0.0239696205,
-0.0261815973,
-0.031833604,
-0.0257855915,
0.0002473527,
-0.0013439067,
0.0470585711,
0.0190477539,
-0.0512835421,
-0.0271237437,
0.0650558025,
-0.0301436651,
-0.0077557173,
0.0296624638,
-0.0379657745,
0.0616117455,
0.0212691259,
-0.0136478767,
-0.025986487,
-0.0464267917,
0.0231200252,
-0.0078066168,
-0.0068027987,
0.0187258106,
-0.0110911326,
0.0822782964,
-0.0384923555,
-0.008544351,
-0.0378225036,
-0.0222463179,
0.0499458946,
0.0329767838,
0.033841636,
-0.0258465279,
-0.0093729207,
0.0558311157,
-0.0265747663,
-0.0708023757,
0.0161533337,
-0.0141203767,
-0.0269536022,
0.0361583717,
-0.0343223251,
-0.0249685124,
-0.0511560515,
0.0370311439,
0.0821696147,
-0.0684956908,
-0.0104702991,
-0.0000191079,
2.878e-7,
-0.0218732692,
0.0084519442,
-0.0014249895,
0.0136423754,
-0.0090577872,
0.0711078048,
0.0129622798,
0.0355513655,
-0.0015570134,
-0.0616959631,
0.0323242582,
0.0487825833,
0.011630604,
-0.0334323496,
-0.0568025783,
0.0595289879,
-0.0013531661,
-0.0239723939,
-0.0294676032,
-0.0410931706,
-0.0000124265,
0.118829228,
0.0012478255,
0.0121501209,
0.0732201338,
-0.0268880408,
0.0675411299,
-0.0579974987,
0.0140838139,
-0.0298331194,
-0.0052064983,
0.0464744531,
-0.0184114128,
-0.0120643992,
-0.0291477703,
0.0228136219,
0.015069644,
0.0589652061,
-0.0366468765,
-0.0073306775,
-0.0443767235,
0.0213969797,
0.014687282,
-0.0565601029,
0.0663604513,
-0.0686050355,
0.01784412,
-0.0221732687,
0.0038345004,
-0.0052323001,
0.0260474794,
-0.0359373353,
-0.0462955534,
-0.0244210903,
0.0260370374,
0.0157883242,
0.0010249674,
-0.0642446131,
-0.0174849816,
-0.0093523907,
-0.0379848927,
0.0268412586,
-0.0242169499,
-0.0167667698,
-0.0111560812,
-0.0088064652,
-0.0215705987,
2.254828442e-34,
-0.0196916349,
0.0007762864,
-0.0081107495,
0.0143361185,
0.0368645377,
0.009982395,
-0.0267117601,
0.02551057,
0.0475598387,
0.0057003335,
-0.0406347923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17514v1 | Reinforcement Replaces Supervision: Query focused Summarization using Deep Reinforcement Learning | 2023-11-29T10:38:16 | 2023-11-29T10:38:16 | Swaroop Nath, Harshad Khadilkar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Query-focused Summarization (QfS) deals with systems that generate summaries
from document(s) based on a query. Motivated by the insight that Reinforcement
Learning (RL) provides a generalization to Supervised Learning (SL) for Natural
Language Generation, and thereby performs better (empirically) than SL, we use
an RL-based approach for this task of QfS. Additionally, we also resolve the
conflict of employing RL in Transformers with Teacher Forcing. We develop
multiple Policy Gradient networks, trained on various reward signals: ROUGE,
BLEU, and Semantic Similarity, which lead to a 10-point improvement over the
State-of-the-Art approach on the ROUGE-L metric for a benchmark dataset (ELI5).
We also show performance of our approach in zero-shot setting for another
benchmark dataset (DebatePedia) -- our approach leads to results comparable to
baselines, which were specifically trained on DebatePedia. To aid the RL
training, we propose a better semantic similarity reward, enabled by a novel
Passage Embedding scheme developed using Cluster Hypothesis. Lastly, we
contribute a gold-standard test dataset to further research in QfS and
Long-form Question Answering (LfQA). | [
0.0362562835,
0.0370564684,
0.0327258892,
-0.0137736751,
-0.0099053765,
-0.0166091379,
0.0080083776,
-0.0303030051,
-0.028837407,
-0.0333515704,
0.0070544118,
-0.034309607,
-0.0185809098,
-0.0002259312,
0.017158471,
-0.0982111841,
0.0379038751,
-0.0095425257,
0.0085314857,
-0.0006464532,
0.0420458391,
0.0099084489,
0.0016250856,
0.0502330698,
-0.0147310402,
0.0148349116,
-0.0225746818,
-0.0217121076,
0.040137127,
-0.0035255246,
0.0274748653,
0.03786036,
0.0505288057,
0.0432365946,
0.0000018172,
-0.0578113198,
-0.0372936018,
-0.0178470481,
0.022809349,
-0.0183066893,
0.0231056232,
-0.006929188,
0.0452635996,
0.0332133137,
-0.0157162398,
-0.0008860324,
0.0382933579,
0.0681001395,
0.0878639147,
0.0832612887,
0.0179605968,
-0.0329558402,
0.0435164906,
-0.0367295817,
0.05102944,
-0.0099967811,
0.0036775949,
0.001088017,
0.0564747676,
-0.0119336117,
-0.0447188206,
0.0165284369,
0.05904245,
-0.0415241085,
-0.0219803471,
0.0404778644,
-0.0038848284,
0.0183603335,
0.0269569941,
0.083545059,
0.0130359791,
-0.0052934387,
0.0249835532,
0.0235936437,
0.0098245703,
0.0152351102,
-0.0490986817,
0.0564886965,
0.016384922,
0.0139060719,
0.0254302826,
0.0228023771,
-0.0018626066,
0.0122777037,
-0.0430873744,
0.0006759085,
0.001409119,
-0.062773712,
-0.0144779291,
0.0070751305,
-0.0224763323,
-0.0276898537,
-0.0181933884,
0.0345699862,
-0.0768774226,
0.0056070648,
-0.0658962354,
-0.0233105998,
0.0131786522,
0.0440575331,
-0.003763546,
0.0197316669,
0.0323514566,
0.0329535864,
-0.0423585661,
0.0662126988,
-0.0079470398,
0.0638946518,
-0.0613273866,
-0.0064071608,
-0.0510722287,
-0.0337965451,
-0.0512843058,
0.0465133414,
-0.0033363511,
-0.0261189137,
-0.0425509587,
0.0095969252,
-0.0104041072,
0.0125928568,
-0.0002822342,
0.0460938327,
-0.0350323506,
0.0312304739,
-0.0456700958,
0.0232237708,
-0.0691878349,
0.0018908788,
0.0523499437,
-0.0009111143,
-0.0164737757,
-0.0028065857,
0.0377822332,
-0.0012089218,
0.007362097,
0.0336186439,
-0.0522815436,
-0.0205979068,
-0.0211861841,
-0.0509983711,
-0.0076813702,
-0.0301138852,
-0.0070377844,
-0.1032439098,
0.0281982962,
-0.0506312288,
-0.0285150446,
0.0023332972,
0.003866096,
0.0604748279,
-0.0061610104,
0.0379614793,
-0.0030383,
-0.0335700363,
0.0418742746,
0.030099595,
0.0302200112,
0.0580731481,
0.0290695392,
0.0022046559,
0.0228264909,
0.0360168815,
0.0121193277,
-0.007426878,
0.0359727219,
0.0242121313,
0.0225501992,
0.0053808428,
-0.0064050942,
0.0347737037,
0.0375416577,
0.0585498437,
-0.0404303707,
-0.0084932949,
0.0233163647,
0.0582856685,
0.006149902,
-0.0207383037,
0.0107089635,
0.0270320773,
-0.0112774661,
0.0393695012,
-0.0234183688,
0.0361088403,
0.0015241943,
0.0636135265,
0.0691697374,
-0.0125268986,
-0.0286704171,
-0.0411131606,
0.044066567,
0.0012700156,
0.0153723173,
0.0005094004,
0.0013326795,
0.0427357741,
-0.0388862155,
0.0110007608,
0.0167467818,
-0.0514031425,
0.0402394906,
-0.023060441,
0.0657125711,
0.0205879863,
0.0527808815,
-0.0534164272,
-0.039524395,
-0.0511239059,
0.0030893099,
0.0553201362,
0.0286367554,
-0.0343137868,
-0.0370498002,
-0.0431958735,
-0.0347766355,
-0.06097693,
-0.0093560936,
0.0036390524,
0.0212115981,
-0.0046082251,
0.0396229625,
-0.0097934278,
-0.0421034507,
0.0327075869,
-0.0061356067,
-0.0395552628,
0.0023028862,
0.002681345,
-0.0075846049,
0.0205456186,
-0.0176578797,
0.0133328894,
-0.0020177583,
-0.0488679148,
-0.0277991164,
-0.0236385893,
-0.0791695789,
-0.0541647412,
0.0102210063,
-0.0722454265,
0.0125345904,
0.037019901,
-0.0279629007,
-0.062328618,
-0.0083627971,
-0.0543264784,
-0.0068716714,
-0.0287130587,
-0.0353497267,
0.0223762356,
0.003723324,
-0.0715778843,
0.0556967184,
-0.0110079916,
0.0312966444,
0.0580616966,
0.0324300192,
-0.004328907,
-0.0378671251,
-0.0167925041,
-0.0219010413,
0.0079125129,
0.029745901,
0.0676375553,
0.0514771305,
-0.055420164,
-0.0018549252,
-0.0500799231,
0.0106454268,
-0.0440380797,
0.0079965396,
0.0553928316,
0.0414395705,
-0.0096557736,
-0.0292248707,
-0.0838600695,
-0.0523251556,
0.0410178117,
-0.001047784,
0.049969025,
0.0147403488,
0.0125129586,
-0.0413703024,
-0.0326740928,
0.0006110945,
0.0188805591,
0.0039817565,
0.0641965047,
-0.0117151216,
0.0165527724,
-0.034215264,
0.0019934797,
0.0028320123,
-0.0081988713,
0.004459077,
-0.0453055091,
0.040680673,
0.0587518886,
0.0401325673,
0.0109601365,
0.0301712602,
0.0419059582,
-0.0650827512,
0.0319273211,
-0.0634798929,
-0.0112172067,
-0.0126350066,
-0.0094076721,
0.0352502689,
0.0336310305,
0.0204543788,
-0.0099638384,
-0.0383832678,
0.0409517735,
-0.0156699866,
-0.0440057367,
-0.0438558683,
0.041092515,
-0.0069851945,
-0.0088534085,
-0.0311847813,
-0.0092303474,
0.0981624722,
0.0015632438,
0.0085916128,
-0.0854800791,
-0.0215187389,
-0.052609425,
0.0095174564,
0.0020265772,
0.0131519139,
-0.0317657664,
-0.0311665423,
-0.0537780784,
-0.0187505428,
0.0119563928,
-0.0056848642,
0.0687800497,
-0.0150712412,
0.0058618668,
-0.0299614314,
-0.0112348879,
-0.0523292124,
-0.0113883093,
-0.004017327,
0.0356312394,
0.0127808843,
-0.0232985783,
-0.0010197569,
-0.0057036085,
0.056052871,
0.0530440733,
-0.0394733101,
-0.0244665593,
-0.0299750026,
0.0614299066,
0.0739644617,
0.0319291018,
0.0194194876,
-0.0502414852,
0.0303503871,
0.0420453921,
0.0577422902,
0.0003818944,
0.006806416,
-0.0140628181,
-0.0165397804,
-0.0809817985,
0.0367344618,
0.0103264768,
0.028813621,
-0.0676385164,
-0.0508665219,
0.1060788035,
0.0266816448,
-0.0218347423,
-0.0157088246,
0.012250321,
0.0742760301,
0.003980983,
0.0275997333,
-0.064261809,
-0.0331347473,
-0.0180190466,
0.0499032885,
0.0303962883,
-0.0213892143,
0.0149138458,
-0.1033649147,
-0.0162771288,
-0.0306047574,
-0.095647499,
-0.0317903161,
-0.0221314225,
0.0088312495,
-0.0009803905,
0.0245944206,
0.026377188,
-0.0324229375,
0.004985746,
0.0464109443,
-0.0041192789,
0.0103059923,
-0.0304771587,
-0.0584654361,
-0.0259101111,
0.0761220381,
0.0135672139,
-0.009369717,
0.0266496856,
-0.0397817828,
-0.0463555157,
-0.0239032228,
0.0168355405,
0.0398771986,
-0.0297487713,
-0.0006462148,
-0.0156803019,
0.0791390836,
0.0008508999,
0.0274609793,
0.0199397318,
0.0369350649,
-0.0043120719,
-0.0301809944,
-0.0453596823,
0.0321635343,
-0.0197490491,
0.0737921,
0.0270587169,
-0.0169183537,
-0.0652654618,
-0.0312715285,
-0.0041481676,
-0.0906754062,
-0.0403589793,
-0.0093816966,
-0.0167919435,
0.0456253253,
-0.087569043,
-0.0780532882,
0.0207526628,
0.0092899306,
-0.044009462,
-0.0347071029,
0.0018064769,
0.0069158785,
-0.0360440016,
-0.0164794941,
-0.0138964942,
0.002483475,
-0.0474494956,
-0.0046262192,
0.0048411256,
-0.0185906794,
-0.0288745575,
-0.0298095178,
-0.0559580289,
-0.0254619718,
-0.0119410632,
0.0499467291,
0.004193157,
0.0470944159,
0.0089363987,
-0.0180654936,
0.0893039554,
0.0347883366,
-0.0291070994,
0.0142877195,
0.0105934087,
0.0038781564,
-0.0000854131,
0.0340400375,
-0.0651135147,
-0.0053811548,
-0.0393278338,
0.0623110346,
-0.0213674977,
-0.0116723115,
0.047048118,
-0.0058591263,
-0.0188343748,
0.005358208,
0.0301862117,
-0.0526706502,
-0.0022878028,
-0.0117292115,
-0.0216006879,
-0.0052318089,
0.028634401,
-0.0141617078,
-0.008395642,
0.0178931039,
0.0373574235,
0.027630059,
0.0350197852,
-0.0289447922,
0.0022082941,
0.0294697788,
-0.0192138329,
-0.0298987832,
0.0129419193,
-0.0210137144,
-0.0245876443,
-0.017753711,
0.0454706699,
-0.0103585217,
0.0378694087,
0.0717601851,
-0.0099623958,
0.011515717,
0.0108741196,
-0.1041962951,
-0.0278001726,
-0.027605826,
0.0195816122,
0.0370633006,
-0.0204035863,
0.0098355515,
0.006270648,
-0.0176570415,
-0.0214228611,
0.0033969283,
-0.0086368332,
0.0187186413,
0.0187525768,
0.0241608731,
0.0333652459,
0.0000662101,
0.0761707202,
-0.0183440447,
0.026279388,
0.0273793228,
0.0193437748,
-0.0277646165,
-0.0349970609,
0.0230822358,
0.043090295,
0.0031291526,
-0.0234330315,
-0.0103059998,
-0.0169153921,
0.0139312157,
0.0281227417,
0.0133785121,
0.0052500307,
0.0925395861,
0.012482306,
-0.0070663281,
-0.0152551122,
-0.0496936776,
0.0081717642,
-0.0264994018,
-0.0134281395,
-0.0038603542,
-5.918120716e-33,
-0.0244901944,
-0.0072700712,
0.0161318071,
-0.0162180867,
-0.048918765,
0.0084798019,
-0.033590287,
-0.044387944,
0.002766019,
0.0228337664,
-0.0115703158,
-0.0194903482,
-0.0224282797,
0.082280755,
0.0068952842,
-0.0395074226,
0.0321656801,
0.0129938219,
-0.0470190868,
0.0523258746,
0.0629347786,
0.0238612089,
0.0296757575,
0.0211906675,
0.0250842124,
-0.0413345657,
-0.0126608359,
0.0142008467,
-0.0277968291,
0.0626272485,
-0.0107214525,
0.0247922577,
0.0299038123,
-0.048663862,
-0.0506089218,
0.0576143935,
-0.1014954522,
-0.0441949032,
-0.0245934352,
-0.0388259627,
-0.1152719259,
-0.0268872883,
0.0411738046,
-0.0092396326,
0.0540041104,
-0.0402412899,
0.0387369394,
-0.0132236714,
-0.009650805,
-0.0379870273,
-0.020841429,
-0.004433448,
-0.0313110612,
-0.0266918838,
-0.0181176681,
0.0774368942,
0.0027094544,
0.0197008401,
-0.0260336511,
0.0245001577,
0.0260148048,
0.0609744228,
0.0440248623,
0.039920561,
-0.0031886024,
0.0367341973,
-0.0212750081,
-0.0440652929,
-0.020132402,
0.0160157531,
0.0202001501,
-0.0058252946,
0.0335096344,
0.0358645841,
0.0281341244,
0.0518616736,
-0.0446229912,
0.0625986159,
-0.0188712757,
0.0401557982,
-0.008754883,
-0.006646751,
-0.0152233252,
-0.0280684475,
-0.0677338466,
0.0596295483,
-0.0120856399,
-0.0185420401,
0.0236027073,
0.0405028127,
-0.0386778191,
-0.0302853789,
0.0068370127,
-0.0346557386,
0.030642936,
0.0303671844,
-0.0184698608,
-0.0054468838,
0.0052185194,
-0.0145250456,
-0.0521944501,
0.0477313176,
0.0272972658,
-0.0273161326,
-0.0409110785,
0.0218258798,
0.0440825485,
0.0102708619,
-0.0441848598,
0.0164534077,
0.0036326698,
0.0367546566,
-0.0391064435,
-0.0072788494,
-0.0153755751,
-0.0045667882,
0.0178900007,
0.0506225005,
0.0089644445,
0.0097274864,
-0.0195051786,
-0.0134683186,
0.0000401712,
0.0114706885,
-0.0347886384,
0.0350287184,
-0.0508242324,
0.0476244017,
-0.0046243872,
-0.0760609806,
0.0069492566,
0.0167608261,
2.477e-7,
0.0212586522,
0.0163348,
0.0897470489,
0.0447223447,
-0.0199581459,
0.0321279131,
0.0333869345,
0.0483450703,
0.0099478858,
0.0092955306,
0.0242090728,
0.0359389856,
0.005348376,
0.007341207,
-0.1107693687,
-0.0121362265,
-0.0974157751,
-0.0249894019,
-0.0269789472,
-0.0488159582,
0.0366499647,
0.0536218621,
0.0086121801,
-0.0079127457,
0.0143291447,
-0.0016119246,
0.0123505266,
0.0196931921,
-0.0387730189,
0.0367159098,
0.0594599396,
0.0012670782,
0.0155978603,
-0.0251069199,
0.0095815798,
0.0198744554,
0.0175332315,
0.0120938048,
0.0483825542,
-0.0332608968,
0.0022972594,
-0.027232904,
0.0378990546,
-0.0196137037,
0.0454578623,
-0.0504684187,
0.0347813442,
0.0090640103,
-0.0332396589,
-0.0242894124,
0.0307730399,
-0.0188906472,
-0.0527674593,
0.0251019951,
-0.0009869917,
0.0163174458,
0.0174010526,
-0.0601208955,
-0.0090611968,
0.0080422033,
0.0065211095,
-0.0089038284,
-0.0203678478,
0.0212071948,
-0.0211410783,
-0.0636023432,
-0.0269868616,
2.338219665e-34,
0.0396006778,
-0.0017036498,
-0.0084040072,
-0.0187003743,
0.0025901387,
0.0007831969,
-0.0074090352,
-0.0409711301,
0.0596712939,
-0.0700527206,
-0.0429366082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17502v1 | Enhancing Answer Selection in Community Question Answering with Pre-trained and Large Language Models | 2023-11-29T10:24:50 | 2023-11-29T10:24:50 | Xinghang Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Community Question Answering (CQA) becomes increasingly prevalent in recent
years. However, there are a large number of answers, which is difficult for
users to select the relevant answers. Therefore, answer selection is a very
significant subtask of CQA. In this paper, we first propose the Question-Answer
cross attention networks (QAN) with pre-trained models for answer selection and
utilize large language model (LLM) to perform answer selection with knowledge
augmentation. Specifically, we apply the BERT model as the encoder layer to do
pre-training for question subjects, question bodies and answers, respectively,
then the cross attention mechanism selects the most relevant answer for
different questions. Experiments show that the QAN model achieves
state-of-the-art performance on two datasets, SemEval2015 and SemEval2017.
Moreover, we use the LLM to generate external knowledge from questions and
correct answers to achieve knowledge augmentation for the answer selection task
by LLM, while optimizing the prompt of LLM in different aspects. The results
show that the introduction of external knowledge can improve the correct answer
selection rate of LLM on datasets SemEval2015 and SemEval2017. Meanwhile, LLM
can also select the correct answer on more questions by optimized prompt. | [
0.0348667353,
0.0129232518,
-0.0051921462,
0.030382175,
-0.0016701594,
0.0058651776,
-0.0130930608,
0.0163218565,
0.0477123559,
-0.0336584263,
-0.038158033,
-0.0051173605,
-0.0380682163,
-0.0251237582,
0.0196865313,
-0.0158892553,
0.0446045399,
-0.0083376812,
-0.0135329021,
-0.0139589626,
0.0145450775,
0.0282548741,
0.0407695696,
-0.0012742255,
0.0338493884,
-0.0122006703,
0.0097865332,
-0.0194229074,
0.0200316273,
-0.0122643728,
0.0581651963,
0.0667681322,
0.0381928459,
0.002334934,
0.0000019522,
-0.0526210889,
0.009869054,
-0.0346241593,
-0.0531405956,
0.0044223582,
-0.0699822679,
0.0314627178,
0.0669473037,
0.0086079128,
-0.0311366096,
0.0093075885,
0.0331959389,
0.0429222733,
0.0809588879,
0.0328340903,
0.0054496485,
-0.0212698858,
0.0436127298,
-0.0222815387,
0.0421143584,
-0.024698969,
0.0523105636,
0.0094802584,
0.0482139662,
0.0545187145,
-0.0100885881,
0.0190290716,
0.0429583378,
-0.0365477465,
0.0540217943,
0.0527647436,
-0.0072418726,
0.0138190435,
0.008147127,
0.1376759559,
-0.0181310344,
-0.0327886678,
0.0094854441,
0.0025715148,
0.0056028818,
0.0406299271,
-0.0461663865,
-0.0289056208,
0.0168713927,
0.0064026909,
0.0131416982,
0.0237178598,
-0.0069508795,
0.0157556608,
-0.0173054226,
0.065801844,
0.0312186014,
-0.0320213884,
0.0144118732,
0.02731115,
-0.0273011383,
-0.0831875727,
0.0429236405,
0.0435672253,
-0.0219643973,
-0.0236257855,
-0.0145685701,
-0.0385319032,
0.023982238,
-0.0490012504,
-0.0111009078,
0.0016102606,
-0.026485784,
0.0930007696,
-0.0538151897,
0.0233412497,
-0.0423787758,
0.0225679204,
-0.0643008277,
-0.0431083664,
-0.0057469849,
-0.0253671855,
-0.0372534133,
0.057288073,
-0.0218935963,
-0.0194025692,
-0.0275709201,
0.0197949,
0.0224137045,
-0.0219416339,
0.0416548289,
0.0520373695,
0.0012130209,
0.0050423676,
-0.050091397,
0.0453547239,
-0.0925137624,
0.0310265888,
0.0025826267,
-0.0527745672,
-0.0266394727,
0.0057708649,
0.0405238532,
-0.0669379905,
0.0287421755,
0.0331490822,
-0.0212033782,
-0.0136545086,
-0.006346894,
-0.0129447896,
-0.0069946698,
-0.0235295352,
-0.0112947235,
-0.0580608174,
0.0608011745,
0.0165708866,
-0.0303223096,
0.012406609,
0.0205303747,
0.03691791,
-0.0211064424,
0.0127530405,
-0.0168895032,
0.0147407735,
0.0673413202,
-0.0134401014,
0.0539972559,
0.04418917,
-0.003582078,
0.0065787039,
0.040291056,
-0.0141551979,
0.0343832783,
0.012934925,
0.0435241647,
0.0078471005,
0.0356341116,
0.0843870565,
0.0249260142,
0.0254900586,
0.0311064981,
0.0376018994,
-0.0281457435,
-0.0732661113,
0.0608901344,
0.0287345927,
-0.013998976,
0.0302089695,
-0.0058705681,
0.020702282,
0.005656634,
-0.0150766168,
0.0111363456,
0.094266139,
-0.0389915444,
-0.0331980847,
0.0544770099,
0.0105935941,
-0.073020868,
0.0076712761,
0.0405146815,
-0.0143250814,
-0.0021503919,
0.0571575724,
0.0239841007,
-0.0034499285,
-0.0124383122,
0.0962313935,
0.0247814935,
-0.0095658675,
0.0245226789,
-0.0380479507,
0.0611408204,
0.0000596083,
0.0119094513,
-0.0299985521,
-0.0208843108,
-0.0462204441,
0.0295795053,
0.0048143454,
0.0435569026,
-0.0148876365,
-0.024096353,
-0.0454050563,
-0.0242928099,
-0.0017887581,
-0.0304899476,
0.0140662286,
0.0254204944,
0.0500302836,
0.0254147928,
-0.0153828086,
-0.0078473063,
0.0150113236,
-0.007316269,
-0.0206236057,
0.0084097283,
-0.0102711981,
0.0089029269,
0.0170500539,
-0.00688917,
0.0116508855,
0.0222255066,
-0.0381885804,
-0.027632663,
-0.0165967233,
-0.0653397739,
-0.0447114073,
0.0119379396,
-0.0450598709,
-0.0336685888,
0.0545622036,
-0.0175269004,
-0.0341008082,
-0.0160235148,
-0.0510947928,
0.0066920202,
-0.0413425714,
-0.0455648787,
0.0152927265,
0.0040901764,
-0.047960218,
0.0730789378,
-0.0041843513,
0.0250380933,
0.0125067756,
0.0021581096,
0.0023737371,
-0.0276336875,
-0.0083592311,
-0.0176117439,
0.0143654225,
-0.015197346,
0.0380873531,
-0.0115350364,
-0.0461988226,
-0.0217605121,
-0.0806662887,
-0.0119386883,
-0.0324941054,
0.0037407705,
0.0183325578,
0.0390613563,
0.0117181661,
-0.022718491,
-0.1078776345,
0.0085766194,
0.0171515979,
0.0283761602,
0.0380518548,
0.0027341736,
0.0598625615,
-0.0247612465,
-0.0315829031,
0.0204052273,
0.0534904972,
0.0239409003,
0.0143483598,
-0.0277332328,
-0.0091012837,
-0.0575760603,
0.0059422632,
-0.0012154668,
-0.0247109085,
-0.0498079807,
-0.0409842692,
-0.0267089196,
0.037886437,
0.0281078164,
-0.0528532639,
0.0000691343,
0.0319400169,
-0.0691628382,
0.0258319639,
-0.0361547172,
-0.0066999509,
0.0018718712,
-0.0065735145,
0.030514989,
0.0568891391,
0.0017522865,
-0.0396114662,
-0.0416829139,
0.0159229767,
0.0246445071,
-0.0050490117,
-0.0603772514,
-0.0281078797,
0.0137983169,
0.0361905694,
-0.0282169376,
-0.0088638924,
0.1009174436,
0.0249859449,
-0.0235900097,
-0.0592693798,
0.0064474558,
-0.0856003463,
-0.0034561134,
0.0051805857,
0.0223876815,
-0.0199784543,
-0.0215469468,
-0.0384921506,
-0.0271240901,
-0.0029687758,
-0.0312650725,
0.0249175355,
0.0368034542,
0.0328463465,
0.0003000595,
-0.0368156098,
-0.0392771959,
-0.0609322004,
-0.0104001109,
0.0219603088,
-0.0006788117,
0.0222074781,
0.0123257246,
-0.0121593671,
0.0419276655,
0.0224488489,
-0.0259463694,
0.0137506146,
-0.0167098679,
0.1154169664,
0.0636010692,
0.0648352206,
0.0028817945,
-0.0324307196,
-0.0064768423,
0.030936148,
0.0155543666,
-0.0152804833,
0.0216570254,
-0.0185838751,
0.0381979346,
-0.0497560315,
-0.0155257061,
-0.0095800972,
0.0571302213,
-0.0041675242,
-0.0221255533,
0.0959337726,
0.0369272158,
-0.0430329517,
-0.0244852956,
-0.0169962682,
-0.0175758079,
0.0275041014,
0.0595704317,
-0.0681442618,
-0.0226227194,
-0.0472190529,
-0.0189604629,
0.0092475386,
-0.0361298919,
0.0226944238,
-0.1162280813,
-0.0007539575,
-0.0427521691,
-0.0352180861,
-0.0582142994,
-0.0575261079,
0.0249678083,
0.0291856695,
-0.0124480324,
-0.0060119047,
-0.0014336973,
-0.0034866787,
0.0344608091,
-0.0020081226,
0.006889767,
0.0532762147,
-0.0351343341,
0.0134601481,
0.0632889867,
0.0245981682,
-0.0367370658,
-0.0668450892,
-0.0042321663,
-0.0911929607,
-0.0174522083,
0.0038220268,
0.0450062528,
-0.0079169851,
-0.0210284144,
-0.0191378314,
0.0504291393,
-0.0119845653,
0.0168120228,
0.0246025659,
0.0852531865,
-0.0034193743,
-0.0287174005,
-0.0072401217,
0.0182307344,
0.0175055806,
0.0600737482,
0.0200846791,
-0.038640406,
-0.0179823469,
-0.0106059602,
-0.0280129351,
-0.0435686819,
-0.0355298072,
0.0119292475,
0.0498040244,
-0.0007269071,
-0.0525463969,
-0.0317452662,
0.0425416566,
-0.0250887033,
-0.0103701456,
-0.0041203653,
-0.0061426801,
0.0043451572,
0.0004759643,
0.0310470946,
-0.0297725499,
0.011941948,
-0.0405116715,
0.0039766645,
0.0342237428,
-0.0516604483,
-0.02651521,
-0.0231127217,
-0.0618914552,
-0.0155865829,
-0.0127088353,
0.0528134704,
0.0079475185,
0.0106692715,
-0.0583757386,
-0.0651043952,
0.0730082244,
-0.0115189375,
-0.0174793843,
0.0031962423,
-0.0126906326,
-0.0061149071,
-0.0039857379,
0.0283958428,
-0.0403267592,
-0.0014920312,
0.0529809371,
0.0148041295,
-0.0587770827,
-0.0602934435,
0.0107717533,
0.0112691121,
-0.0140890572,
0.044291798,
0.0544031858,
-0.0509923436,
0.0246060994,
0.0381254517,
0.0091688298,
-0.0106529351,
-0.007181487,
0.0295299366,
-0.0568788946,
0.0124111967,
0.0061398274,
-0.0036607769,
-0.0091034332,
-0.05830127,
0.0161407012,
0.0430175923,
0.0202624537,
0.0120062996,
-0.0015108977,
-0.0524812452,
-0.0008791146,
0.0160601921,
0.0597010329,
-0.0059066457,
0.0519136861,
0.0046639908,
-0.05484372,
0.0090214061,
-0.0165158249,
-0.0833012164,
-0.0544673577,
-0.0491252244,
0.0492677279,
0.0369367637,
-0.0304276608,
0.0073732194,
0.0299662538,
-0.0181034915,
-0.0386830382,
-0.0082368469,
0.0257577337,
-0.0098788766,
0.030666288,
0.0053445292,
-0.0064937277,
0.0234845206,
0.050653778,
-0.0213957876,
0.0257363319,
0.0141213406,
-0.0126653388,
-0.0215295423,
0.0090134861,
0.0051928931,
0.0052663209,
-0.0432871394,
0.0572554879,
0.0096754106,
-0.0309407506,
0.0430875681,
-0.0029855205,
-0.0312499013,
0.0205269307,
0.0729845315,
0.028328618,
0.0235512387,
-0.0295036975,
-0.0448904485,
0.0654442608,
-0.0417161994,
-0.0114472257,
-0.0069556511,
-6.409431437e-33,
-0.0031861849,
0.0044645253,
-0.018527111,
-0.0286819804,
-0.0034579923,
-0.0135939922,
-0.0254275668,
-0.0260768477,
-0.0390043631,
-0.0046592294,
-0.0181915034,
0.0003450219,
-0.0213659871,
0.0407622978,
0.0176182128,
-0.0789083093,
0.0143935392,
-0.0047770352,
-0.0017612816,
0.0573542975,
0.0187300034,
0.0351078548,
0.0436666533,
0.009125066,
0.0222649649,
-0.0333292671,
0.0608111732,
0.0234391149,
-0.0060210517,
0.0573458225,
-0.0228715502,
0.0285359696,
0.0379403308,
-0.0452617705,
0.0137741799,
0.0634772778,
-0.0892280862,
-0.0612177365,
0.0075042564,
-0.0283347778,
-0.0801466107,
-0.0436392948,
-0.0018201874,
-0.018568689,
0.0581699312,
-0.0034593274,
0.0455158427,
-0.0018989054,
-0.0085692806,
-0.0442344956,
-0.0019841867,
-0.0068510966,
-0.0306288525,
-0.0158817712,
-0.0496889651,
0.0848422498,
-0.0121063627,
0.0476718359,
-0.0475632735,
0.0086324774,
0.041178517,
0.0289827734,
0.0112873651,
0.0193052851,
-0.0131764831,
0.0537643544,
-0.0413444974,
-0.0315405875,
-0.0167328529,
0.0067310967,
-0.0373660773,
0.0170868859,
0.0581401996,
0.0188169405,
-0.0130982092,
0.0041639036,
-0.1039195806,
0.0308094677,
0.0429952964,
0.0153082702,
0.0430321544,
-0.0272917114,
0.0051164213,
-0.0116669396,
-0.0501136221,
0.0321071781,
-0.0587190986,
-0.0238404889,
0.0156126088,
0.0056181727,
-0.0242279656,
0.0141315758,
0.0368790999,
-0.029431615,
-0.0322624817,
0.0392216817,
-0.0021051122,
-0.0243510045,
0.0371405929,
0.0496077873,
-0.0607183166,
0.0446403474,
0.0162868723,
-0.0499542877,
-0.034510728,
0.0326079503,
0.0124309612,
-0.0277482048,
-0.0395212807,
-0.0150853796,
-0.0217955746,
-0.0148485554,
-0.0060131247,
0.0239391848,
0.0201511625,
0.0359786563,
-0.0078359153,
0.0338011496,
-0.0034855944,
0.0172298551,
-0.0253597256,
-0.0356200784,
0.0332357176,
0.0245288517,
-0.0162893515,
0.0112446379,
-0.039463833,
0.045229502,
-0.0452398174,
-0.0425616987,
-0.0086675687,
0.0148327006,
2.511e-7,
0.0514412075,
0.0246622395,
-0.0062538721,
0.009847289,
0.0188820958,
-0.0008416612,
0.0144557506,
0.08118397,
0.0585623309,
-0.0302300788,
0.0081437444,
0.0425910056,
0.0370561182,
0.0117677599,
-0.0760399923,
-0.0369929373,
-0.0619651005,
-0.0110590961,
-0.024592869,
-0.050081037,
0.0443362184,
0.0944348797,
0.0087713739,
0.0210911464,
-0.0166583825,
-0.0270701591,
0.059193328,
-0.0215165149,
-0.0288929809,
0.0213557426,
0.0124232639,
0.0175798908,
-0.0046453462,
0.0339541994,
-0.0228303354,
0.0061398172,
0.0368461534,
0.0464558601,
0.0045323721,
-0.0554756485,
-0.0305335447,
0.004309631,
0.0179064404,
-0.0547230504,
0.1029670611,
-0.060209278,
-0.0020157506,
-0.0237986706,
-0.0452456437,
-0.0195197407,
0.0454476997,
-0.0381462052,
-0.0177623015,
-0.0127601353,
0.0204381775,
0.0022370899,
0.0008943966,
-0.0651971772,
-0.0058973655,
0.0176734403,
-0.0531952381,
-0.0590794571,
-0.0437314436,
-0.031356249,
0.0157211497,
-0.0110650836,
0.0277881008,
1.842999736e-34,
-0.0013926142,
0.015284257,
-0.0007380455,
0.0305592511,
-0.0116388835,
-0.0171783995,
-0.0186208095,
-0.0318646841,
0.0632823855,
-0.0891199484,
-0.0026907704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03743v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03743v1 | Easy Data Augmentation in Sentiment Analysis of Cyberbullying | 2023-11-29T10:05:58 | 2023-11-29T10:05:58 | Alwan Wirawan, Hasan Dwi Cahyono, Winarno | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Instagram, a social media platform, has in the vicinity of 2 billion active
users in 2023. The platform allows users to post photos and videos with one
another. However, cyberbullying remains a significant problem for about 50% of
young Indonesians. To address this issue, sentiment analysis for comment
filtering uses a Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Easy Data Augmentation (EDA).
EDA will augment the dataset, enabling robust prediction and analysis of
cyberbullying by introducing more variation. Based on the tests, SVM
combination with EDA results in a 2.52% increase in the k-Fold Cross Validation
score. Our proposed approach shows an improved accuracy of 92.5%, 2.5% higher
than that of the existing state-of-the-art method. To maintain the
reproducibility and replicability of this research, the source code can be
accessed at uns.id/eda_svm. | [
0.0986499786,
0.0282621942,
-0.0114804944,
-0.0160731915,
0.0236569215,
0.0237595513,
0.019089153,
0.0276452508,
0.0372682996,
-0.0380711369,
0.027508473,
-0.0264710542,
-0.0260495842,
0.022345487,
0.0169474483,
-0.0571042076,
0.0189871732,
0.0471052937,
0.0524463691,
-0.0275912359,
0.0468567684,
-0.0205864534,
0.0121160541,
0.0133869676,
-0.0551368706,
-0.0082211858,
0.0297803804,
0.0118158078,
0.0253711529,
-0.0528547727,
0.0649268702,
0.0175503064,
-0.0054389057,
0.0426769517,
0.0000021458,
-0.0578415319,
-0.0001199658,
-0.0052084392,
-0.0077627813,
0.0193898343,
0.0197493825,
-0.0904860348,
0.0252726171,
0.0449431501,
-0.0530032292,
0.011619566,
0.0616495088,
0.0612522177,
0.0954577997,
0.0612003356,
-0.0187392477,
-0.0559978448,
0.0186863542,
-0.003428065,
0.0005370441,
0.0556972921,
0.0380512998,
-0.0072892774,
-0.0153920446,
-0.0013194118,
0.0200018492,
0.0397675261,
-0.0244311858,
0.0144015038,
0.0554347262,
-0.0136646461,
-0.0179570168,
-0.0241509918,
0.0318599232,
0.0219894033,
-0.0156054823,
-0.004077055,
-0.0146593712,
-0.0132587468,
-0.0348518118,
-0.0026128637,
-0.0570832044,
-0.0137317711,
-0.0094946986,
0.062038552,
-0.0112051899,
0.0158149675,
0.0397710949,
0.0569643378,
0.0565449744,
0.0094904732,
-0.0237805173,
-0.0435262211,
-0.0096866563,
0.0218871664,
-0.0395247117,
0.0165589508,
0.0013513097,
0.0267843157,
-0.0258335043,
0.0271501634,
-0.0458148643,
-0.0629541501,
0.0298104566,
-0.072188586,
0.0480890311,
0.0369862318,
0.0230841935,
-0.0122317076,
0.006617697,
-0.0281249378,
0.0133854942,
0.0596685223,
0.0104778269,
0.019519398,
-0.0267224722,
0.033893954,
0.0207360964,
0.0102673015,
0.0339523293,
0.0162359737,
-0.1086326838,
0.0390771329,
-0.0383993462,
-0.0310172699,
0.0001743857,
-0.0034812167,
0.0203233045,
0.0564240441,
-0.0222314075,
-0.0042770165,
-0.0397339799,
0.0287798867,
-0.0686282292,
-0.0453266539,
0.0347450301,
0.0072099529,
0.0236927159,
0.0040649092,
0.0322552212,
0.0480954573,
0.0496531688,
-0.049297072,
-0.0518001951,
-0.0231850278,
0.0026114439,
-0.0266066827,
0.0029786052,
-0.0671195686,
0.0462895073,
-0.005373213,
-0.0195675138,
-0.0041274293,
0.0261859316,
0.0142063228,
-0.0567743517,
0.0515912548,
-0.056304574,
0.0177929979,
0.0356934965,
0.030490404,
0.0213603731,
0.0415059216,
0.0076905279,
-0.0126829222,
0.0735683143,
-0.0131261963,
0.0028936754,
0.0213755239,
0.0191144682,
0.0008319942,
-0.0311537236,
0.0013167391,
-0.0518849045,
-0.0559747927,
-0.0352641866,
0.0162203293,
0.0047847987,
-0.0176081937,
0.0328982286,
-0.0074877059,
-0.0106183449,
0.0566497073,
0.0025366826,
0.0306237265,
0.0176609084,
-0.0711606666,
-0.0520057119,
-0.0190352667,
-0.027132038,
-0.0280876886,
0.0225957632,
-0.0059121069,
-0.0178846773,
-0.0394643024,
-0.0149799604,
-0.0017482336,
0.0946851,
-0.0174112637,
0.0356072746,
-0.0063206921,
-0.0094559705,
-0.0016935776,
0.0601495989,
-0.0371214524,
-0.0209307298,
-0.0376331471,
0.0714365616,
0.0484304354,
-0.0098461453,
-0.0148216756,
-0.0057283151,
-0.045298025,
0.0186030082,
-0.000773844,
-0.0247475673,
0.0056446353,
-0.0127444472,
-0.0090748947,
0.00055389,
0.0175863635,
-0.0106315054,
-0.0487956516,
0.0813595057,
0.0346435197,
0.0048297443,
0.0663505271,
-0.0783610865,
0.0443700254,
0.0343857817,
-0.0081028659,
0.0003709188,
0.0498844273,
0.0335973166,
0.0374865234,
0.0064658616,
-0.0522990823,
0.0344005413,
0.0072802496,
-0.0424051099,
-0.0409498662,
0.0289772283,
-0.0331550315,
0.0534921251,
-0.0580842681,
-0.0044864519,
0.0383062102,
-0.0355130695,
0.0213030409,
0.0536693782,
-0.0287921298,
0.0031768028,
-0.0062614642,
-0.0429916456,
-0.0714164376,
0.0527247749,
0.0196670219,
0.0460403338,
-0.0285207145,
-0.0030075184,
-0.0454347655,
-0.0114462459,
0.0347059481,
0.021526888,
-0.0578988492,
-0.05240288,
-0.0383287743,
0.029118577,
-0.0112347016,
0.0152788805,
-0.0297932737,
0.0064697475,
-0.1093859896,
-0.0299789347,
-0.026651131,
-0.010399553,
-0.0136887422,
0.0136567103,
-0.0302216969,
-0.0069782306,
-0.0119262347,
-0.0063011679,
0.0351413861,
-0.0024977585,
0.0114711467,
-0.0229342245,
0.0151999798,
-0.0406041555,
-0.0097099664,
-0.0009604582,
0.0154409725,
0.0362660922,
-0.0841449797,
0.003254784,
0.0144831855,
-0.0546740852,
0.0290546101,
-0.0034879639,
-0.0368624143,
0.0089189121,
0.0197960734,
-0.0745323375,
0.0081434045,
0.0524609238,
0.0355716608,
0.0291970726,
0.0552455895,
0.0113039659,
0.0196420625,
-0.0203947779,
-0.0005854118,
0.0015001922,
-0.014040702,
-0.0207230747,
0.012285769,
-0.010682812,
-0.0110355038,
-0.0098166037,
0.0069302875,
-0.0043945066,
0.0120321056,
-0.0235808436,
-0.058458548,
-0.0067575574,
-0.0025633036,
-0.0019450412,
-0.0719243139,
0.0626656935,
0.0113684796,
0.0141644478,
-0.0247959327,
-0.0548387505,
0.0060284794,
-0.0065620625,
-0.0098328227,
0.0058666272,
-0.0420382023,
0.0420908779,
0.0522014573,
-0.0156767424,
0.0115591567,
-0.0221542418,
0.0256586988,
0.0112911826,
0.0163777228,
0.0361299813,
-0.0344256163,
-0.0655222014,
-0.0699760765,
-0.0622850172,
-0.0523610562,
-0.0154329091,
-0.0041061537,
0.00858963,
0.0250665694,
-0.0151704531,
-0.0411786437,
-0.0363705494,
-0.029917486,
0.0314165391,
-0.0384719186,
0.0277725253,
-0.0415281467,
-0.0077698505,
-0.0025616116,
0.0087733325,
0.0446822755,
-0.0211325251,
-0.0220470522,
0.0086689387,
0.0024309936,
-0.0013254691,
0.0323625505,
-0.0235388745,
-0.0393866226,
0.0490701422,
-0.02449774,
0.0200383924,
0.0732768029,
0.0262650065,
-0.0151889538,
0.0156164737,
-0.0175891928,
-0.0036532765,
0.0418149047,
0.0186349098,
-0.0366484001,
-0.0068100486,
-0.054049585,
0.0711931363,
-0.0551144332,
-0.0398397148,
-0.002817763,
-0.076680243,
0.0427160934,
-0.0045000939,
-0.070939295,
-0.0503963716,
-0.0241235923,
0.0096760364,
-0.0073747165,
0.0266107451,
-0.035469234,
-0.0118621225,
0.0174152423,
-0.0048736744,
-0.0653274804,
-0.0072703594,
0.0128472112,
-0.0539362468,
0.0231739748,
0.0023742227,
0.0606473908,
-0.0165954847,
-0.0237020385,
0.0071764523,
0.0041302098,
0.0244347788,
-0.0426610596,
0.0896018147,
-0.0187180918,
-0.0511925668,
-0.0225956235,
0.0405843481,
-0.0152474139,
0.0079458086,
0.0173333306,
0.032066796,
0.0130445128,
0.0017393979,
-0.0406673364,
0.0327410214,
0.0206223018,
0.0279021617,
0.0223839115,
-0.0618664362,
0.0473375879,
-0.055048883,
-0.0386651792,
-0.0019084425,
-0.0255941749,
-0.0114821065,
-0.0463342331,
-0.0407492332,
-0.0357452966,
-0.0461465456,
0.003051305,
0.0120087489,
-0.0142163187,
0.0007328959,
0.0124500189,
-0.0106785754,
-0.0743105412,
-0.007879545,
0.0206260253,
0.0516752824,
0.0309145804,
0.0067374832,
-0.0232417509,
0.0168828368,
-0.0156241376,
-0.0230840519,
-0.0410454944,
-0.04970669,
0.0154102445,
0.0655713305,
0.0127500948,
0.0536648966,
-0.031339854,
-0.0646177083,
0.0411952697,
0.0505143143,
0.0027294522,
-0.0034687317,
0.0204537492,
0.0135663152,
0.0190519821,
0.015005813,
-0.0108384648,
0.0117609696,
0.0175126139,
-0.0733270124,
-0.0468897559,
-0.0087292567,
-0.0559074506,
0.0073288283,
0.0653477088,
0.0096195266,
-0.0466031507,
0.0152199119,
-0.0331534073,
-0.0085889297,
-0.017959293,
0.0031688903,
0.0044618561,
0.002599651,
0.0249115806,
-0.0676559657,
0.0057150163,
-0.0552983843,
-0.005294214,
-0.051094722,
0.0461279936,
-0.0192199666,
0.056318868,
0.0140722794,
0.0146789085,
0.008455229,
-0.0192249138,
0.0298355054,
-0.0158228446,
0.0015955026,
0.0215827655,
-0.0117806485,
0.0634374544,
-0.0155369593,
-0.018667398,
0.0006619796,
-0.0088594435,
-0.0515479073,
-0.0187050942,
-0.0294490065,
-0.0347946212,
0.0796598718,
0.0076842587,
-0.0163333658,
-0.0117336409,
0.0185755026,
-0.062275961,
-0.0431046858,
0.022597136,
0.0088325404,
-0.0273667481,
0.0480185151,
0.0306907333,
-0.0573941767,
0.0113418037,
0.0192272626,
-0.0566335395,
-0.0250623878,
0.0403060354,
0.0425015502,
0.0748999938,
-0.0007289464,
0.0160187334,
-0.00865045,
-0.0512809567,
0.0165651292,
-0.0720069483,
0.0140194539,
0.0123920655,
-0.0186766163,
0.0342306606,
0.0226340871,
0.044897303,
-0.0529705472,
-0.044787854,
-0.0012018691,
-0.0503665507,
0.0261262134,
-6.351665441e-33,
0.009524201,
-0.0041479557,
-0.0454300828,
0.0275967792,
-0.0279341899,
-0.0262785852,
-0.002879594,
0.032646466,
-0.0161062181,
0.0037104927,
-0.0074290284,
0.0261007994,
0.0062038098,
-0.0104303034,
0.0227941833,
-0.0077554663,
0.0146844136,
0.0031839085,
0.0047471402,
0.003181821,
0.0210040379,
0.0427804105,
0.0424215831,
-0.1403718889,
0.0658955723,
-0.0190602429,
-0.0235644896,
-0.01115923,
0.0334863104,
0.0483092889,
-0.0018499123,
0.0940935686,
0.0255836379,
0.0086898953,
0.0125963008,
0.0385886915,
-0.017740313,
0.0139866369,
0.0076293168,
0.0250120107,
-0.0218697563,
0.0066622416,
0.0516560562,
-0.011586125,
-0.0121343452,
0.0072878739,
0.0458922647,
-0.0078276834,
0.0078799734,
-0.0234114602,
-0.0348083414,
0.004088907,
-0.0202319548,
0.0082234042,
-0.0165706612,
0.0808466822,
0.0234942716,
0.0371436514,
-0.1028495803,
0.0578233674,
-0.0181475338,
-0.050692331,
-0.0141111258,
-0.0173588097,
-0.016635837,
0.0484527349,
0.0087970952,
-0.0156125603,
-0.0153989587,
0.0199757013,
0.0266950633,
0.0399619602,
0.0250811055,
0.0507070646,
0.0430800244,
-0.105395399,
-0.0888357088,
0.012952541,
0.0666224211,
-0.016766049,
0.0061688353,
0.0019643821,
-0.0556053631,
-0.0537612475,
0.0358619131,
-0.0743029714,
-0.021365067,
-0.059374366,
-0.0183698889,
-0.0072906525,
-0.0677508488,
0.0132136429,
-0.0271669179,
-0.0698750094,
-0.0309716258,
0.0529419072,
-0.0467730053,
0.0102689099,
0.0046412996,
-0.0296260957,
0.0113764014,
0.0078593371,
0.0233600494,
-0.0171475951,
-0.0067911716,
-0.0357448794,
0.1053375527,
0.0147463307,
-0.0697522312,
-0.0204192903,
0.0166668333,
0.0372225046,
-0.0162655562,
0.0684683397,
-0.0156803206,
0.0338013247,
-0.0037306133,
0.0178714599,
0.0235722549,
0.0620078892,
-0.0189797767,
-0.0457759947,
-0.0012762423,
-0.0309514683,
0.0297053345,
-0.0164444912,
-0.0289905854,
0.0019145528,
-0.0203162283,
-0.0619306229,
0.0132064382,
-0.0573297702,
2.864e-7,
0.0262158215,
0.0728340521,
-0.0312738158,
-0.0260482524,
0.0247249138,
0.0481936932,
0.0356887765,
0.0092868451,
0.00659088,
-0.0068798177,
-0.0017343339,
0.0234730337,
0.0037961879,
0.0244066082,
-0.0363299623,
-0.0428213328,
-0.0235260408,
-0.024343906,
-0.0239190087,
0.0261403285,
0.0349886492,
0.0861873701,
0.0690555125,
-0.0497160591,
-0.0146034015,
0.0072664483,
0.0217737909,
-0.0186554305,
-0.02912792,
-0.0185065102,
0.0414428152,
0.0515396744,
0.0214225296,
0.0083808713,
-0.0157754384,
0.0496872477,
0.0020543998,
0.0198137723,
-0.0034010366,
0.0204016492,
0.0379177593,
0.0677766949,
0.0330946483,
-0.0385391191,
0.0479260646,
-0.0288878344,
-0.0495734289,
-0.0515409559,
-0.001793229,
0.029172631,
0.063729085,
-0.0273638591,
-0.0106327599,
0.0172030888,
0.0270667095,
-0.0385453589,
-0.0365876667,
-0.0722244903,
-0.0071611633,
0.0208877791,
-0.0202623829,
-0.0231318623,
0.0091988677,
0.039375484,
0.054035116,
0.0460808501,
0.0692839697,
2.140498301e-34,
0.020490814,
-0.0079441676,
0.0219792333,
-0.0397384614,
-0.0025023932,
0.0425135382,
0.0128486445,
0.0087625682,
0.0367087349,
-0.0346055403,
0.0245600957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17492v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17492v2 | Mergen: The First Manchu-Korean Machine Translation Model Trained on Augmented Data | 2023-11-29T10:01:48 | 2024-01-12T14:18:03 | Jean Seo, Sungjoo Byun, Minha Kang, Sangah Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Manchu language, with its roots in the historical Manchurian region of
Northeast China, is now facing a critical threat of extinction, as there are
very few speakers left. In our efforts to safeguard the Manchu language, we
introduce Mergen, the first-ever attempt at a Manchu-Korean Machine Translation
(MT) model. To develop this model, we utilize valuable resources such as the
Manwen Laodang(a historical book) and a Manchu-Korean dictionary. Due to the
scarcity of a Manchu-Korean parallel dataset, we expand our data by employing
word replacement guided by GloVe embeddings, trained on both monolingual and
parallel texts. Our approach is built around an encoder-decoder neural machine
translation model, incorporating a bi-directional Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU)
layer. The experiments have yielded promising results, showcasing a significant
enhancement in Manchu-Korean translation, with a remarkable 20-30 point
increase in the BLEU score. | [
0.0396411642,
0.0226863865,
0.0146802505,
0.0681679472,
-0.0148344124,
0.0162474252,
0.0249023233,
-0.0216278564,
-0.0055752988,
-0.0146863982,
-0.022795679,
-0.0313883051,
0.0592808016,
0.0328577459,
0.0105269523,
-0.0525635853,
0.0406869575,
0.0209137164,
-0.0435476005,
0.0007690235,
-0.0045358459,
0.0095429197,
0.0229028873,
0.0307987835,
0.0170798451,
-0.0070132841,
-0.0059061246,
0.0531352349,
0.0269426908,
-0.0411684178,
-0.0014113814,
0.0044452981,
0.0125522763,
0.0874731615,
0.0000021412,
-0.0261390097,
-0.0131624863,
-0.0330778398,
0.0355468094,
0.0275191367,
0.0701095685,
-0.0518032685,
-0.0316311195,
0.0278948005,
-0.0190330483,
-0.0382694341,
0.0659429207,
0.0731027052,
0.0501672886,
0.0844213367,
-0.0175455734,
-0.0439837649,
-0.0064548957,
-0.0308302809,
-0.0490034632,
0.0004761959,
0.0260503367,
-0.0202466287,
-0.039045278,
-0.0090978006,
-0.0771334246,
0.0607485622,
0.0108816754,
-0.0106324041,
-0.0095668519,
-0.000044188,
0.0269341022,
0.0213809814,
0.0030443149,
0.069703795,
-0.0636696815,
-0.0001591514,
-0.0278876107,
0.002210238,
-0.0092518255,
-0.0034018701,
-0.0217685979,
-0.040558137,
0.0170444176,
0.0041814465,
0.0142712258,
-0.0301711541,
0.0734808818,
-0.0066176066,
-0.046309866,
-0.0020299142,
0.0484627336,
-0.0497056656,
-0.041344095,
-0.008917911,
0.0121792424,
-0.0295232404,
0.0326001644,
0.0352877192,
-0.0320356376,
0.0152609861,
0.0006367387,
-0.0542366803,
-0.0240559503,
-0.033485774,
-0.0018572559,
0.0677212626,
-0.0067422418,
0.0227592941,
0.0063240184,
0.029295478,
-0.0026389426,
0.011069946,
-0.0615137704,
-0.0158627331,
-0.0045276727,
0.0039577032,
-0.0365133882,
-0.0219675079,
-0.0358421765,
-0.0345346369,
-0.0155045949,
-0.0186896883,
0.0013833117,
0.0038167043,
0.0275993906,
-0.0129386839,
-0.061037872,
0.0046656718,
-0.032957945,
0.045508448,
-0.019469386,
0.0096847145,
-0.0072018672,
-0.0213628039,
-0.0367276073,
-0.0007314784,
-0.0068604983,
-0.0328355841,
-0.0045534233,
0.0273892451,
-0.0219267048,
-0.0163665749,
-0.0061051245,
0.0240745116,
-0.0642813444,
-0.0034774784,
-0.0060103158,
-0.0484612733,
0.048295904,
-0.0393538326,
0.0230682418,
-0.023957748,
0.0174631104,
0.0077872351,
-0.007215248,
0.0627842247,
-0.0247993115,
-0.021061616,
0.0178569537,
-0.0255985502,
-0.0322095267,
0.0463129357,
0.0701959506,
0.0252543036,
0.0439242609,
0.0300365426,
0.0274393521,
0.0250398796,
-0.0303577166,
0.0293394756,
-0.0371430367,
-0.0445942655,
0.0126100294,
0.0595625974,
0.0246690176,
0.0402568616,
-0.0271324366,
-0.0214844551,
0.0502957255,
0.0176719408,
-0.003611038,
0.0529397018,
0.0319234617,
-0.0050608274,
-0.0543947294,
0.0049210652,
0.0081805438,
0.0226207133,
-0.0025769142,
0.0104962457,
0.0232677031,
0.0447750427,
-0.0128654214,
-0.0570628382,
-0.0056285132,
-0.0195403397,
0.0512115024,
-0.0217038207,
0.0550876781,
0.027848741,
-0.0542947091,
-0.0370664783,
-0.0180156697,
-0.0498825349,
0.0734582841,
0.0173112024,
-0.0490020104,
0.120991677,
0.0785679445,
0.0215671808,
-0.0085646706,
-0.0399738401,
-0.0521261878,
0.0484261699,
0.0624442212,
0.0017142688,
0.0495280921,
-0.0837065727,
-0.0128570367,
-0.0056773075,
-0.0054046097,
0.0303822234,
-0.0163876526,
0.0355678461,
0.0400658026,
-0.012382078,
-0.0451956987,
0.0518409573,
-0.0667962879,
-0.0213919021,
0.0360224955,
0.0194612518,
0.0336726196,
0.0264851879,
0.0030000135,
0.0304210652,
0.0361973085,
-0.0450090319,
-0.0648305789,
0.0506013334,
-0.0675267279,
-0.0916240886,
0.0423708707,
-0.0516705289,
-0.0068028155,
0.0223522224,
-0.0566155836,
-0.075903438,
-0.0056114048,
-0.0300662387,
0.0053475886,
-0.0602034479,
0.0501021631,
0.0056229453,
0.0150473472,
-0.017939169,
0.0170782935,
-0.0288336799,
-0.0082774749,
0.0224434305,
-0.0342292227,
0.0231466647,
-0.0525558107,
-0.0757942498,
0.0162519235,
0.0484406762,
0.0252936985,
0.0097478935,
-0.0233683195,
0.0044626552,
-0.0385517366,
-0.0796787366,
0.0326526985,
-0.0416873507,
-0.0087745953,
0.0398088545,
0.0437150672,
0.0107321776,
-0.0068092486,
-0.0095782075,
0.0003824391,
-0.0412917249,
0.0099896798,
0.0247995295,
-0.0362048782,
0.0222879369,
-0.0096452618,
0.0032600812,
0.0263208486,
0.0116984444,
0.0015560054,
-0.0421951637,
-0.0498956218,
-0.0330398008,
-0.0286040548,
0.0260368045,
-0.0161856897,
-0.0650362149,
0.0020166563,
-0.016080562,
0.0398468785,
0.0187632423,
-0.0077664163,
0.0482496507,
0.040665146,
-0.0149660101,
-0.0063574906,
-0.0014407575,
-0.0461655408,
-0.0375824943,
-0.0014842732,
-0.0251171365,
-0.0121709025,
0.0316560157,
0.0464862809,
-0.0067252279,
-0.0436334722,
-0.072549805,
-0.021390425,
-0.0126711139,
-0.0180129129,
0.0004343802,
-0.0416182131,
-0.0038927209,
-0.0542001538,
0.0103992643,
0.0592246391,
-0.0047538779,
0.003051704,
-0.0742150545,
0.0127557702,
-0.0462193564,
0.0398250371,
-0.0275923405,
0.0054523856,
-0.0569332764,
-0.027840497,
-0.0201791748,
0.0281072035,
-0.0039244881,
-0.0535711832,
-0.0159409866,
-0.0548154525,
-0.0101022422,
-0.0090308087,
0.0085023465,
-0.0091033671,
0.0071885181,
-0.0065110298,
-0.0172482785,
0.0081697293,
-0.027963981,
-0.0208895393,
0.0289127566,
0.0076630986,
0.0758608952,
-0.007932663,
0.0278504491,
-0.0305810086,
0.0042262105,
0.0147294458,
0.0198607948,
0.0174972247,
-0.052139841,
0.071158357,
0.0328114294,
-0.0145032546,
-0.0161049478,
-0.0490764044,
-0.0170007739,
0.0305053834,
-0.0031393168,
-0.0002087913,
-0.0030983514,
0.0408373438,
-0.0956287086,
0.0198575631,
0.1059397683,
0.0032390922,
-0.0197506994,
-0.0067852223,
0.0044203387,
-0.0041497345,
0.0321615227,
-0.0183805488,
-0.0943100303,
-0.0262557808,
0.024025036,
0.0189516954,
0.0461634509,
-0.0078432029,
-0.0056006112,
-0.1263103634,
0.0101303393,
0.0542518348,
-0.0288004354,
-0.0702852905,
-0.0329918787,
-0.0248712208,
-0.0160250366,
0.0409834348,
-0.002659362,
0.0347350985,
-0.0238900669,
-0.0155803161,
0.0354432426,
-0.0619047396,
-0.0338354073,
-0.0688503757,
-0.0101941926,
0.0190461408,
0.0751723945,
-0.0036698468,
-0.0174031984,
0.0284362473,
0.019473156,
-0.0156448632,
0.0084640747,
0.0394983217,
-0.0247746352,
-0.0032365853,
0.027217824,
0.027544288,
-0.0303010494,
0.0142250499,
0.0418030955,
0.0270557106,
-0.0028232427,
-0.0004973372,
0.0004546444,
-0.0253868289,
0.0139615508,
0.072928153,
0.0049395221,
-0.0322135873,
0.0143179158,
-0.0342929661,
-0.0203018691,
-0.0248195734,
0.0174830928,
0.026425356,
-0.0614550747,
-0.0375958309,
-0.1204927638,
-0.0779195428,
-0.002693542,
0.0079980381,
0.0649337396,
0.0480832607,
0.0159435831,
-0.0134451995,
-0.054320164,
0.0075831558,
-0.0257070251,
0.0358433165,
-0.0489092618,
0.0386612155,
-0.0034138081,
-0.0165558029,
0.0350505598,
0.0227454733,
-0.0200027339,
-0.06520807,
-0.0204586592,
0.0172814,
0.009850326,
0.0219475254,
-0.0398124792,
0.0217276439,
-0.0015560903,
-0.0189481303,
-0.006057716,
0.0122690974,
0.0076325047,
-0.0226035174,
-0.0047328621,
0.0003750852,
-0.0115516735,
-0.0086449357,
-0.0183056369,
0.0435349382,
-0.0199336801,
-0.0485269427,
0.0063770977,
-0.0240886994,
0.0431950204,
-0.0332546346,
0.0007675388,
-0.0667909086,
0.0473058522,
-0.0117395539,
-0.008298818,
-0.0326683931,
-0.0157792922,
0.0715804026,
-0.0036198488,
-0.035172727,
0.035548687,
0.0264445413,
-0.0229525305,
0.0136506306,
-0.0472315997,
-0.007254926,
0.0538964681,
-0.0050057457,
0.015543554,
-0.0361870453,
0.0475621484,
-0.0094784778,
0.0014314539,
0.0088718766,
0.0601413734,
0.0091167614,
0.0365623087,
0.0203795824,
0.026439134,
-0.0550079644,
-0.0375852287,
-0.0469385386,
-0.0169171914,
0.0462752804,
0.0045310054,
0.0850844383,
0.0022229014,
-0.0287648644,
-0.0403771996,
0.0253405031,
0.0119783822,
-0.0137030315,
-0.0004725035,
-0.0073795253,
-0.0235242005,
0.0651973337,
0.0282396842,
-0.007347601,
0.049757462,
0.0182297695,
-0.0122190928,
-0.0017660225,
-0.0247557666,
0.0531318523,
0.0190624725,
-0.0289799757,
-0.0381885991,
-0.0351508148,
-0.0505205654,
-0.0141990343,
0.031483639,
-0.0043991827,
0.015255644,
0.001722428,
0.0129855657,
-0.0476321243,
0.0623249188,
-0.0505610108,
0.0457878895,
0.0177247506,
-0.0248183105,
-0.0126106851,
-6.039123166e-33,
-0.0081929844,
-0.0048266007,
0.0243910644,
-0.0572764985,
-0.0204754286,
-0.0357318074,
-0.0484434366,
-0.0248184931,
-0.0263633486,
0.0164392926,
0.0184549373,
0.0076961173,
0.0062013245,
0.0162356887,
0.0048802271,
0.022309659,
0.0802898481,
0.0448756069,
-0.0009756331,
0.0021386463,
0.1086630225,
0.0442648791,
0.0563577376,
-0.0621328317,
0.0296046138,
-0.0400324762,
-0.0297113769,
0.030505836,
-0.0168573298,
0.0115376282,
-0.0274992604,
0.0118723735,
0.0146175027,
-0.0109623438,
-0.034443967,
-0.004916071,
-0.1191913113,
0.0066522737,
-0.0311292149,
0.0552143529,
-0.0225749929,
-0.0194116794,
0.0280855801,
0.0182373188,
0.0304226931,
-0.0211211517,
0.0307529941,
-0.0584345087,
-0.0394079238,
-0.0269131847,
-0.0491817631,
0.0256607272,
-0.0171016604,
-0.021957228,
0.0112503143,
-0.0060269609,
-0.0018978573,
-0.0161768943,
-0.0819089934,
-0.0310670529,
-0.0031227653,
0.041804038,
0.0492165051,
0.0148524735,
-0.0120325182,
0.0236058813,
-0.0106785037,
-0.0067922273,
0.0446007699,
-0.0267159734,
0.0300282277,
-0.00360522,
0.0532188378,
0.0504731685,
0.0836842656,
-0.068625018,
-0.0315250382,
0.0472736172,
0.0291725639,
0.0326862149,
0.014475951,
0.0579444245,
0.0105405319,
-0.0282897912,
-0.0261911657,
-0.0091402903,
-0.027257055,
-0.0231071543,
0.0193438102,
0.0309639834,
-0.0304734707,
-0.0085493298,
0.0321869478,
-0.0355669372,
0.0179481972,
0.0250050314,
-0.0200963784,
0.0047180075,
-0.0058751041,
0.0226372723,
-0.013964735,
-0.0116353082,
0.0289742313,
-0.0105759045,
-0.0181641243,
-0.0193030424,
0.0626485795,
0.0144636407,
-0.0354710259,
0.0029728205,
-0.043137487,
-0.053497076,
0.0321547836,
0.0337506868,
0.0128913084,
0.0257981401,
0.0010412746,
0.0508879274,
0.0507786907,
0.0029431551,
-0.0381062292,
-0.0020071068,
0.021530794,
-0.0088356333,
-0.0399068743,
0.0177912489,
0.0145596592,
0.0143706994,
0.053333953,
-0.0593312904,
-0.0289251432,
0.0144623825,
2.911e-7,
0.0740965307,
0.0030540104,
0.0657218471,
-0.0048020477,
-0.0005101775,
0.0187175572,
-0.0260063503,
0.0501168855,
0.0232375115,
0.0324704051,
0.057943657,
0.0211250894,
0.0883619711,
0.0082411068,
-0.0867616385,
-0.0021867813,
-0.0441068076,
0.0206034053,
-0.0473378375,
0.0247128811,
0.0356200896,
0.1104623005,
0.0395052135,
0.0097481413,
0.0037202984,
-0.0149920247,
0.0572735183,
0.002317731,
0.0034995563,
-0.009966787,
0.0578306913,
0.0286377706,
-0.0524636023,
-0.0312265381,
-0.0382000878,
0.0456007756,
0.0525224097,
0.083253555,
-0.0010109063,
-0.0071490067,
0.0153477686,
0.0009370057,
-0.0155968983,
-0.0269401874,
0.0540056378,
0.0023704425,
0.0233895667,
0.004066478,
-0.0401067473,
0.0471134596,
0.0575045235,
-0.0289689824,
-0.0079722386,
0.0468582101,
0.0380146913,
0.0107702436,
-0.0175244119,
-0.044622723,
-0.0174237937,
-0.0366523787,
-0.0268247966,
-0.030362986,
0.0096017318,
0.0087848557,
-0.0198692791,
-0.0136288209,
-0.0096150413,
2.426003379e-34,
0.0354650468,
-0.0289124902,
-0.0209114626,
0.0183217246,
0.0545119941,
-0.064552322,
-0.0353623927,
0.0430034064,
-0.0078446204,
-0.0346302316,
-0.0578361526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17487v1 | Taiwan LLM: Bridging the Linguistic Divide with a Culturally Aligned Language Model | 2023-11-29T09:48:34 | 2023-11-29T09:48:34 | Yen-Ting Lin, Yun-Nung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the realm of language models, the nuanced linguistic and cultural
intricacies of Traditional Chinese, as spoken in Taiwan, have been largely
overlooked. This paper introduces Taiwan LLM, a pioneering Large Language Model
that specifically caters to the Traditional Chinese language, with a focus on
the variant used in Taiwan. Leveraging a comprehensive pretraining corpus and
instruction-finetuning datasets, we have developed a model that not only
understands the complexities of Traditional Chinese but also embodies the
cultural context of Taiwan. Taiwan LLM represents the first of its kind, a
model that is not only linguistically accurate but also culturally resonant
with its user base. Our evaluations demonstrate that Taiwan LLM achieves
superior performance in understanding and generating Traditional Chinese text,
outperforming existing models that are predominantly trained on Simplified
Chinese or English. The open-source release of Taiwan LLM invites collaboration
and further innovation, ensuring that the linguistic diversity of Chinese
speakers is embraced and well-served. The model, datasets, and further
resources are made publicly available to foster ongoing research and
development in this field. | [
0.0098709753,
0.0418852307,
0.0034324606,
0.0477380492,
-0.0082040168,
0.0272372644,
0.0071364255,
-0.0280174185,
-0.0332506411,
-0.0165223684,
-0.0908858329,
-0.0554147959,
0.0161135327,
0.0075538396,
0.0151800392,
-0.0583093725,
0.0319513641,
0.0373215973,
-0.0012276955,
-0.0086494461,
0.0564521998,
0.0394093245,
0.0569375902,
0.0291632768,
-0.0081488797,
-0.0273759943,
0.0165122505,
0.0527431965,
0.0453859828,
-0.0130120376,
0.0563171133,
0.0315419137,
0.0149819795,
0.0502380766,
0.0000020612,
-0.0252536796,
-0.0226882491,
-0.03520035,
0.0049313377,
0.0838597044,
0.0534476601,
-0.0366782844,
-0.0185993817,
0.0151730021,
-0.0513790734,
-0.0306920018,
0.035532888,
0.0651544258,
0.0579828322,
0.0723337829,
-0.0065421676,
-0.0176582467,
-0.0262442604,
-0.0636639297,
-0.050125476,
-0.0100357709,
0.0159395263,
0.0137119433,
-0.0240824036,
-0.0094508948,
-0.0348215885,
0.0083917622,
0.0243268963,
0.0252344217,
-0.0590537153,
0.035253264,
-0.0105888853,
0.0074329074,
0.0036870593,
0.0997144431,
-0.0099607054,
-0.0105598504,
0.0130965859,
0.0061566243,
-0.0486574471,
-0.0286935512,
-0.0402011611,
0.0332756266,
0.0149882697,
0.0469000153,
0.0379072577,
-0.0164808128,
0.0380934551,
0.0675064251,
-0.0070735458,
-0.0037681283,
0.019132603,
-0.0169303417,
-0.0470577702,
-0.0018184001,
0.0054734009,
-0.0419032425,
0.0041848193,
0.0384690203,
-0.0063996031,
0.0128746415,
-0.0473253876,
0.0328391232,
0.0145736225,
-0.0050155567,
0.0350082256,
0.0416393541,
-0.0497103781,
0.0100241071,
-0.0243298579,
0.0112985764,
-0.0258722343,
0.0138467075,
-0.0548861995,
-0.017480066,
-0.0155796017,
-0.0071384097,
-0.0353247821,
0.0232919529,
-0.0260440595,
-0.0217389297,
-0.0442522354,
-0.006101104,
-0.004827864,
-0.0105874063,
-0.0001770999,
-0.0171945523,
-0.0777910575,
-0.0121055664,
0.0199817512,
0.0412379988,
-0.035024967,
0.028743485,
-0.0167742465,
-0.0419166684,
0.0056295544,
0.042610433,
-0.0005524474,
-0.02685849,
-0.0044715134,
-0.0082017109,
-0.0150724323,
-0.0240448453,
-0.0915463343,
-0.0107012149,
-0.0394863077,
-0.0363083184,
0.0051902514,
-0.0766668543,
0.0234217532,
-0.0320559219,
0.0481607281,
-0.0480911396,
0.0147249792,
-0.0126964692,
0.0062775132,
-0.0146044856,
-0.0132131381,
0.0108759617,
0.029152479,
-0.0026226898,
-0.0105196573,
0.0638519675,
0.0588563345,
0.0017503999,
0.0586183295,
-0.0094435448,
-0.0301926509,
0.0425490625,
0.0154341608,
0.0188599881,
-0.0350631438,
-0.0090037649,
-0.0214642044,
0.0051326342,
0.0292080808,
0.0539146475,
-0.0114771118,
0.0158798713,
0.0519198403,
0.0062261247,
0.0052160402,
0.030543007,
0.0879472271,
0.0008638366,
-0.0275889635,
0.0382638238,
-0.0374683701,
0.0026331383,
-0.020538019,
0.0270111598,
0.001942831,
0.0433641188,
-0.0651894361,
-0.050862357,
0.0002794091,
-0.0149915796,
-0.0020248939,
0.0072470242,
0.034719076,
0.0053301491,
0.0183942188,
0.0267607886,
0.0450841039,
-0.0318071246,
0.0674389005,
-0.0068560964,
0.030205898,
0.0914684087,
0.0398036465,
-0.0031306839,
-0.0189560875,
-0.0087997718,
0.0368005,
0.0465922467,
0.0736246854,
-0.0191205293,
0.0023282194,
-0.0662741885,
0.0139685543,
0.0043073981,
0.0228354335,
0.0277291518,
0.0292345174,
0.0317839235,
0.0410263985,
-0.0132751688,
-0.055943381,
0.0361275487,
-0.0718095526,
-0.0093521606,
0.0074629234,
0.0117248362,
0.0015520775,
0.0344731659,
-0.051722981,
-0.020448884,
-0.0063618156,
-0.0404226929,
0.0116941947,
0.0225092098,
-0.0772973895,
-0.0552321188,
0.0425035134,
-0.0316632465,
-0.0155756436,
0.032863263,
-0.0822678059,
-0.05560508,
0.0005870052,
0.0370304808,
-0.0176904388,
-0.1157888249,
-0.004347696,
0.0159886163,
0.0178033449,
-0.0180968549,
0.0492080227,
0.0089933369,
0.0034640913,
0.0111064818,
0.0201655682,
0.0248474907,
-0.0335788466,
-0.0502250865,
-0.013449599,
-0.0011243877,
0.0010401137,
0.0081268912,
0.0443711653,
0.0023643177,
-0.0261812359,
-0.0716685653,
0.0271399971,
-0.0711777583,
-0.0151092326,
0.0266904905,
0.0014387536,
-0.0249904636,
-0.0014639635,
-0.0651828721,
-0.040736407,
0.0146734007,
0.0040892628,
0.027180817,
-0.0140321311,
0.0254252441,
-0.0220290553,
-0.0148420352,
0.0293037333,
-0.0204732809,
-0.0305322148,
-0.0291965622,
-0.0388694853,
0.0007023887,
-0.0497751683,
-0.017064942,
-0.0108290818,
-0.0574708208,
-0.0339036882,
-0.0022754117,
0.0597356446,
0.0232282411,
0.01613524,
0.0068942355,
0.0183204822,
-0.0161307566,
-0.0285606682,
0.003415975,
-0.022786526,
-0.0124504957,
-0.0147197945,
-0.0653800741,
-0.021981122,
0.0802842379,
0.0279904846,
-0.0160202589,
-0.0497176498,
-0.0360902213,
-0.0373268314,
0.0101288985,
0.0206646677,
0.0262834392,
-0.0417005271,
0.0028025869,
-0.062112987,
-0.031353265,
0.0678015798,
-0.0371958576,
-0.0081799366,
-0.0108614657,
-0.0190744642,
-0.0477073081,
0.0213445537,
-0.0235560797,
0.0248313565,
0.0115900263,
-0.012120246,
-0.0509578027,
0.0192197338,
0.0001831339,
-0.0430142619,
0.0560252629,
-0.0347076915,
-0.0186315551,
-0.0390753299,
-0.0039781453,
-0.0255023558,
-0.027256364,
0.0112247141,
0.0200679917,
0.02420027,
0.017056087,
0.0448145494,
0.0167077165,
-0.0106535405,
0.0245150253,
-0.0359242484,
0.0447407104,
-0.0287975203,
0.0306123253,
0.0423957817,
0.0320420824,
0.0034865402,
-0.0460143238,
0.0515732802,
0.0507482961,
0.0430991985,
0.0081356699,
0.0068709771,
0.0186468717,
0.0217896514,
-0.0100611774,
-0.0226570033,
0.0008672483,
0.0988801569,
-0.0363420844,
0.00172279,
0.1302359551,
0.029636696,
-0.0038029212,
0.0030002862,
0.0039850581,
0.0483500846,
0.0142048011,
0.0145777334,
-0.1107025072,
-0.0008713245,
0.0069651497,
0.0110271564,
0.0085343197,
-0.0104405526,
0.0045346497,
-0.1118704155,
0.0458731875,
0.0334603935,
-0.0332107954,
-0.0326059759,
0.0109005682,
-0.0150685459,
-0.0024978693,
0.0391461365,
-0.0026595134,
-0.0129640689,
-0.0224232804,
0.0255863369,
-0.0483424179,
-0.075869903,
0.0461595505,
-0.0535875186,
0.0258809831,
0.0322702043,
0.0356757566,
-0.0098597761,
0.0047695213,
-0.0116926702,
-0.0398666635,
-0.0192728452,
-0.0208643954,
0.008426331,
0.0035982102,
-0.0319821723,
0.027295433,
0.0534493066,
-0.0084946416,
0.0193556063,
0.0258751474,
0.0277500208,
-0.0007987517,
0.0170939565,
0.019497646,
0.0200709775,
-0.0156459715,
0.1055504009,
0.0458472334,
-0.0586406589,
-0.0105487825,
-0.0388012789,
-0.0261231735,
-0.059679877,
-0.0211103726,
0.0538233183,
-0.0545679443,
0.006938512,
-0.1035095155,
-0.0528269783,
0.0098195942,
-0.0148692001,
0.0222819615,
-0.0412326232,
-0.012887897,
-0.0031815746,
-0.0217449274,
0.0563684702,
-0.0340804197,
0.0211457368,
-0.0674816445,
-0.0473031998,
0.0416654311,
-0.0527931303,
0.0296894033,
0.0052151922,
-0.0529108085,
-0.0551244058,
0.0038815595,
0.0491432957,
0.0000476782,
0.0338764749,
-0.001368731,
-0.019134745,
0.0246564317,
-0.01532932,
-0.0225231219,
0.0082056019,
0.0425586179,
-0.0108636133,
-0.0040016202,
0.0420878828,
-0.0495932288,
0.0542565659,
0.0292955413,
0.058932133,
-0.0460659303,
-0.0043376312,
0.0067328443,
0.0081751617,
0.0104890876,
-0.0510012023,
0.0141230058,
-0.0806437433,
0.0078586731,
-0.0257454496,
-0.0364473648,
-0.0473722517,
-0.0315982997,
0.0639544949,
-0.0103863822,
-0.031924203,
0.0136209391,
0.0139820846,
0.0195488967,
-0.0451797955,
-0.0002873027,
-0.0241435915,
0.0195727032,
-0.0214583892,
0.0345070697,
-0.0382181667,
0.0463144258,
-0.0231060106,
0.0248068534,
-0.0231885035,
0.0901053026,
-0.0033563778,
0.0559622347,
0.0141910231,
0.0000681977,
-0.007606212,
-0.0333460383,
-0.0306879934,
0.0072785933,
0.0879100412,
-0.0340212658,
0.0598509833,
-0.0226474032,
-0.0159332063,
-0.052236367,
0.0390265547,
0.022454774,
-0.0337645374,
0.0165943392,
0.0009253593,
-0.0418549813,
-0.013027139,
0.0806453899,
0.0063176095,
0.0409941562,
0.0396348946,
0.0277816579,
-0.022197146,
-0.0262037013,
0.0428861678,
-0.0040218104,
-0.0179468524,
-0.005082177,
-0.0553996041,
-0.0407572761,
0.027160069,
0.0015645898,
-0.0117828092,
0.0171398595,
-0.0016914899,
0.040990632,
-0.0312481262,
0.021060735,
-0.0706302971,
-0.028508788,
0.0274859425,
-0.0084115444,
-0.0145680802,
-6.644404676e-33,
-0.0400743969,
0.0283822101,
0.0157906618,
0.0141814658,
-0.0194631238,
-0.0172051098,
-0.0225907378,
0.0020739709,
-0.0431026518,
-0.0080808606,
-0.0056926697,
-0.0125790248,
0.0171218608,
0.0848121718,
-0.0183196049,
0.0183664374,
0.0322526991,
0.0064276592,
0.013457302,
0.0345118754,
0.0182771217,
0.0457367375,
0.0530064069,
-0.0530184321,
-0.000977756,
-0.0234262273,
0.0129976273,
0.0287076999,
0.005436142,
0.055426538,
-0.0297537539,
0.0496525764,
0.0297800153,
-0.0140057942,
-0.0548614152,
-0.0036262085,
-0.1204349324,
-0.023100784,
-0.0040277806,
0.0211303998,
0.0232427493,
-0.027851494,
-0.0021422489,
-0.0144467428,
0.0273691397,
-0.0106200809,
0.0389053114,
-0.0418843552,
-0.0003352082,
-0.0406737775,
-0.0348018296,
0.044838123,
0.0261991248,
-0.0048399488,
0.0041531259,
0.0252230521,
-0.0179716516,
0.0402598567,
-0.0678932145,
-0.0109698707,
0.0259363987,
0.0535462871,
0.030081505,
0.017424155,
0.0090338141,
0.0068950551,
-0.0025819198,
0.0140866386,
0.0103128226,
0.0130726919,
0.045337636,
0.034486711,
-0.0066319411,
0.0795309618,
-0.0036965436,
-0.010855224,
-0.0594120324,
0.0283409953,
0.0376461446,
-0.036284212,
0.0155803692,
-0.0167647656,
0.0016778116,
-0.0182435531,
-0.0004108936,
-0.0068207346,
-0.0016324391,
-0.0263386033,
0.0117473742,
0.0398474559,
-0.0359173082,
-0.013954713,
0.0580306537,
-0.0447524451,
-0.0263417326,
0.0090677636,
-0.0050132391,
-0.0347938091,
-0.0154484799,
0.0391820669,
-0.0697727874,
-0.0722065121,
-0.0086629987,
-0.0502819419,
-0.0536306463,
-0.0117882621,
0.0654857457,
0.0188458972,
-0.0490795784,
0.0349660516,
-0.0095423097,
0.0119989663,
0.0221558604,
0.0185409468,
0.0260214694,
-0.0063781412,
-0.0103227738,
0.0371137187,
0.0421209969,
-0.0290235858,
-0.0319373943,
-0.0736753717,
-0.0292932577,
0.0286153499,
-0.0362556614,
0.0228229277,
0.0032285731,
-0.0010158326,
0.0291038919,
-0.0193408541,
-0.0046030101,
-0.0069744121,
2.613e-7,
0.0620165467,
-0.0294066966,
0.049444139,
0.0431462154,
0.0091231912,
-0.0073232283,
-0.025636958,
0.0226471201,
-0.000453427,
0.0116704591,
0.0650734827,
0.0587461963,
0.1203036308,
0.0092435274,
-0.0594683848,
0.0220477395,
-0.0410611555,
0.0265275612,
-0.0333312005,
-0.0123066818,
0.0078126499,
0.0947720557,
0.0004602025,
0.0193688329,
-0.0134511078,
-0.0284345429,
0.0776801929,
-0.0170187298,
-0.002213693,
0.0730729625,
0.0122758783,
0.0037237569,
-0.0533709675,
-0.0502754115,
-0.0175033845,
0.0399122201,
0.0144896004,
0.1161566824,
0.0279145222,
-0.0288798604,
0.0159748401,
0.0109702628,
-0.0072106207,
-0.0540503003,
0.0567657277,
-0.0228012279,
0.0013911159,
0.0235100687,
-0.0102933766,
0.0100302175,
-0.0087050451,
-0.0349830203,
-0.0093755294,
0.0798465386,
0.0282557718,
-0.0280691944,
-0.0390561633,
-0.0722706318,
-0.0573177338,
0.0081202947,
-0.0420315973,
-0.0258138832,
0.0174995996,
-0.0150511069,
-0.0273605809,
-0.0165849216,
-0.0118150823,
2.055041239e-34,
0.0219439194,
-0.029042853,
-0.0177340116,
0.049307745,
0.0163833592,
-0.0277566481,
-0.003370872,
-0.0137205627,
-0.0236951075,
-0.0229971427,
-0.0235649534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17438v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17438v4 | CLOMO: Counterfactual Logical Modification with Large Language Models | 2023-11-29T08:29:54 | 2024-06-07T04:27:54 | Yinya Huang, Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Wei Shao, Zhicheng Yang, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang, Xiaodan Liang, Linqi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we delve into the realm of counterfactual reasoning
capabilities of large language models (LLMs). Our primary objective is to
cultivate the counterfactual thought processes within LLMs and rigorously
assess these processes for their validity. Specifically, we introduce a novel
task, Counterfactual Logical Modification (CLOMO), and a high-quality
human-annotated benchmark. In this task, LLMs must adeptly alter a given
argumentative text to uphold a predetermined logical relationship. To
effectively evaluate a generation model's counterfactual capabilities, we
propose an innovative evaluation metric, the decomposed Self-Evaluation Score
(SES) to directly evaluate the natural language output of LLMs instead of
modeling the task as a multiple-choice problem. Analysis shows that the
proposed automatic metric aligns well with human preference. Our experimental
results show that while LLMs demonstrate a notable capacity for logical
counterfactual thinking, there remains a discernible gap between their current
abilities and human performance. Code and data are available at
https://github.com/Eleanor-H/CLOMO. | [
0.0414012074,
0.0617479868,
-0.015840983,
0.0415710993,
-0.0762380511,
0.0045289448,
0.0207074471,
-0.0256165843,
0.0344560817,
-0.0525944903,
-0.0058217552,
0.0014054247,
-0.0468338616,
0.0176426414,
0.0228602439,
-0.0203817133,
0.0468585193,
-0.0159830488,
0.0476364084,
-0.024636602,
-0.0368738025,
0.0025063653,
-0.0171859656,
0.0040086103,
0.0331134237,
-0.0392787196,
0.0172904115,
0.0145756714,
0.0556157604,
-0.032900963,
-0.0045494912,
0.0469796881,
-0.0312274322,
0.0572496578,
0.0000021964,
-0.0821981803,
-0.0209986717,
-0.0082696732,
-0.0426108502,
0.0144178616,
0.0447045825,
0.0405366197,
-0.0438837186,
0.0002718178,
-0.0394961387,
0.0443332903,
0.0129239066,
0.0506311804,
0.0763806403,
0.0880932286,
0.0078893416,
-0.0338306762,
0.0203160569,
-0.0314946845,
-0.0145870512,
-0.010721894,
-0.009597416,
0.057502728,
-0.0158088226,
-0.0006069323,
0.0096705118,
0.0303473026,
0.0452293679,
-0.020382341,
-0.0127916466,
0.0041122162,
-0.0258920807,
-0.0057715559,
0.0076004397,
0.0272854753,
0.0446540192,
-0.0408636369,
-0.0294436198,
-0.0159603637,
0.0313985385,
0.0171884913,
-0.0172093473,
0.0246818736,
0.0006338807,
0.0054049878,
0.0363715626,
0.0348953865,
0.0213706344,
0.018573679,
-0.0117675029,
0.0964883342,
0.018523775,
-0.014033909,
0.0173127782,
-0.0081593106,
-0.0375370868,
-0.0776527822,
0.011079452,
0.0099699814,
-0.0442847237,
0.0030889213,
-0.0151726808,
-0.0444346294,
0.0570814349,
-0.0864358172,
0.0414220914,
0.0186833944,
0.0126978233,
0.0400631167,
-0.031551227,
0.0311924964,
-0.0318348184,
0.0149911372,
-0.0251302626,
-0.005488771,
-0.0430839881,
-0.0506654382,
-0.0019717966,
0.0046344912,
-0.0391868651,
0.031220682,
-0.0225583352,
-0.0220042653,
-0.0773033872,
0.0024681163,
-0.0113053117,
0.0238834489,
-0.0067430036,
-0.072141178,
-0.0703649968,
0.0267720707,
-0.0539599545,
0.0296273399,
0.0079037035,
-0.0275813993,
0.0018733806,
0.0005021966,
-0.0411306024,
-0.0325085297,
0.0239211656,
0.0927692503,
-0.018842984,
0.0494854972,
-0.017163083,
-0.040983893,
0.0006815594,
-0.0753023177,
0.0102976505,
-0.0762681216,
-0.0308324154,
-0.0023776258,
-0.0065408787,
-0.0419346318,
0.0057862941,
0.0170361362,
0.0159531236,
0.0202149823,
0.0256947353,
-0.0353518501,
0.0403122939,
0.0067217159,
-0.0227085762,
0.0481009334,
0.032469593,
-0.0002957471,
0.0220861211,
0.0138164582,
-0.0362140462,
-0.0015793162,
0.0136340205,
-0.0111706946,
-0.0563783869,
0.038398616,
-0.0313650109,
0.0147576174,
0.0180337951,
0.0389962308,
-0.0146004045,
-0.0568488128,
0.0397372842,
-0.0237946585,
0.004609237,
0.0307864249,
0.0403743945,
-0.0246290714,
-0.0112802582,
0.0167011544,
-0.0224915016,
0.0392331369,
-0.063052386,
-0.0111275027,
-0.0029361136,
0.041328527,
0.0173389558,
-0.0676840097,
-0.0026069649,
0.0164876077,
0.0278411619,
0.0078655658,
0.0311262552,
0.0522242039,
-0.0092054075,
-0.0213517658,
-0.0093364716,
-0.0362982154,
-0.0200203173,
-0.056775976,
0.0146899708,
0.0315864421,
0.0395263322,
-0.0248316433,
-0.0347505249,
0.0004243634,
-0.0226338748,
0.0436593182,
0.0705146044,
-0.0084863529,
-0.0220196508,
-0.0010782476,
0.0089509394,
-0.0528984703,
0.0338544622,
0.0243447926,
-0.0085373409,
-0.019796798,
0.0414120071,
-0.0084301597,
-0.0040873815,
0.0385889895,
-0.0231108889,
-0.0043172906,
0.0120545151,
-0.0032203388,
0.0064793983,
0.0443836823,
-0.0079539903,
0.0447113775,
0.0377237685,
-0.025156267,
-0.0437586941,
0.0519210994,
-0.0390725955,
-0.0243667755,
0.0443161428,
-0.0696680024,
-0.039944049,
0.0441960879,
-0.0307556242,
-0.0015388308,
0.0608292408,
-0.0211717673,
0.0375893489,
-0.0310995989,
0.0176012889,
-0.0036230579,
-0.0331555307,
-0.0371467248,
0.0819812715,
0.0067095882,
0.0064812824,
0.0136442231,
0.0167171862,
0.0405324064,
-0.0535313264,
0.0010812199,
-0.0112631097,
-0.0060175266,
-0.0324343219,
0.0462170877,
-0.0039074984,
-0.0631206557,
-0.0366523117,
-0.0568013713,
0.0235846248,
-0.0183677878,
0.0135382237,
0.0363759547,
-0.0593997911,
0.0038303297,
0.0017740327,
-0.0179276951,
-0.0077133994,
0.0225714147,
-0.0025755158,
0.0263412073,
-0.0260235481,
0.0224176906,
-0.027432533,
0.0024279582,
-0.0401761904,
0.0406710394,
0.0327085182,
0.0589175038,
-0.0164855216,
-0.0012805081,
-0.0720405951,
0.0005439996,
-0.0011826893,
-0.0294411425,
0.0501096621,
0.020291809,
0.0644246489,
0.0473028719,
0.0268207155,
-0.008141106,
0.0710761026,
-0.0164701212,
-0.0228080116,
0.012959986,
0.0030437778,
0.008994095,
-0.0320556723,
-0.054429058,
-0.0380215049,
0.0389564,
0.0055272388,
-0.0111873569,
-0.0389991701,
0.0784279034,
-0.0288036037,
-0.0328187048,
0.0118764862,
-0.0330727361,
-0.0082901129,
0.0635491684,
-0.0169698354,
-0.019601753,
0.0767793506,
0.0042947242,
0.0229361616,
-0.0637326166,
0.0202066489,
-0.0274226908,
0.0977165028,
0.0118005564,
0.0140443128,
0.0266642924,
0.0399457961,
-0.0455618426,
-0.0042997668,
0.0433641039,
-0.0225467645,
-0.0113223912,
-0.073776491,
-0.0175040867,
0.0010460634,
-0.038244918,
-0.0427369103,
-0.043929588,
-0.0350170098,
-0.0076264185,
-0.004754873,
0.0075344373,
-0.01451045,
-0.018864356,
0.0189409405,
0.0010287116,
0.0316243917,
-0.0030003684,
0.0003519307,
-0.0077026766,
0.0375555903,
0.0541552529,
0.0658524036,
0.0126412315,
0.0363129117,
0.0488268249,
0.0089137489,
-0.0252633151,
-0.0270643458,
0.0061542047,
-0.0462809838,
-0.0123887546,
-0.0192559268,
-0.0091304807,
0.0469098613,
-0.0419203937,
0.0196290929,
0.0952733383,
0.0508057289,
0.0334364399,
0.0100458059,
-0.0564885698,
0.023165429,
0.0536795668,
0.0115065621,
-0.0573524348,
-0.0154941026,
0.016709635,
-0.0183693245,
-0.0626327023,
-0.0587649159,
-0.0261984542,
-0.1329063326,
0.0342132971,
0.0146095268,
0.0164031554,
0.0220137388,
-0.0378455743,
-0.0121085439,
-0.0127234338,
-0.0687478036,
0.0315273143,
0.003180942,
0.0037138094,
-0.0323967859,
-0.0032228632,
0.0134666851,
0.0495373383,
-0.0102827884,
0.0498196892,
0.0679618195,
0.0343393646,
0.0036875578,
-0.0168541074,
0.0274338201,
-0.0041914033,
-0.012849655,
-0.0137316277,
0.0048602303,
0.0100279897,
0.0278920643,
-0.0464229248,
0.0279107243,
0.0231329538,
-0.0595583096,
0.0203112531,
0.0675222576,
-0.0046920441,
-0.0299250595,
-0.0405862145,
0.0399348252,
-0.0276610497,
0.0775539353,
0.0176737271,
-0.0310595129,
-0.0408014879,
-0.0506664105,
-0.0221445169,
-0.0622819401,
-0.0130627472,
-0.0158526897,
0.0562246963,
-0.003411945,
-0.072059907,
-0.0528426617,
-0.0339049697,
0.0003830083,
-0.0145202987,
-0.0185158048,
-0.0005587459,
-0.0216568131,
-0.02470145,
-0.0042450707,
-0.039482303,
0.0277514104,
0.000792239,
0.0159267392,
0.0141270338,
-0.0134822708,
-0.0540808104,
0.0404418893,
-0.0457741544,
-0.0710690543,
-0.0026219396,
0.0438759252,
0.0333009548,
0.0100575946,
-0.0230342057,
-0.0472406559,
-0.0029320654,
0.0432587452,
-0.0164667964,
0.02714145,
0.0613106228,
-0.0039943238,
0.0181860533,
0.0245268103,
0.0167449303,
0.0326102115,
0.0204397645,
0.0586259179,
-0.010765194,
-0.0150075043,
0.0303424038,
0.0160095729,
0.0174383335,
-0.0045671267,
0.0062250453,
-0.0222808197,
0.025119571,
-0.0851673633,
-0.0522218458,
0.009006816,
-0.0086848363,
0.0101990458,
-0.040016979,
-0.0013700041,
-0.0177305304,
-0.0504351892,
0.0582564026,
0.0039404533,
0.030663399,
0.0603229068,
0.0467108265,
0.0129479114,
-0.021591831,
-0.0201137289,
-0.0093689533,
-0.0040600738,
0.0707907453,
-0.0180561393,
0.0523352437,
0.026056705,
-0.013102496,
-0.0221920218,
-0.0022602296,
-0.0890252367,
-0.0064889705,
-0.0046816547,
0.0136775738,
0.023113979,
-0.0011348929,
0.0439850874,
-0.0286384486,
-0.0154306162,
-0.0061495095,
0.0194375664,
0.0291136336,
-0.0469370224,
0.0231054183,
0.0026245699,
-0.018688526,
0.0236137509,
0.0268798061,
-0.030852776,
0.0496763065,
-0.0115525937,
0.0099035092,
-0.0523129515,
-0.0809037462,
-0.0564842373,
0.0055935234,
-0.0055229976,
-0.0011289282,
-0.0966975838,
-0.0701013729,
0.0019132537,
0.0556893609,
0.0349882245,
-0.0061180028,
-0.0050144936,
0.0546340421,
-0.0227060094,
-0.0365235619,
-0.0295576807,
0.0405470245,
-0.0113093136,
0.0160504021,
-0.0482580401,
-6.48215266e-33,
-0.0428990573,
-0.0498938113,
0.0449269526,
-0.0433556326,
0.0054217582,
-0.0537271425,
-0.0569188558,
0.0237315428,
-0.0292720702,
0.0331646502,
0.0000925513,
-0.0082802288,
0.0065662013,
-0.0024386079,
-0.0124557428,
0.0267757233,
0.046559155,
0.0047657392,
-0.0346353985,
0.0029662633,
0.0053625805,
-0.0332283452,
0.011152178,
-0.0857395679,
0.0513975583,
-0.016451003,
-0.0137581863,
0.0228816755,
-0.0587625727,
0.0358608924,
-0.0138968518,
0.0019946331,
0.032770101,
-0.0198108088,
0.009871182,
-0.0101209758,
-0.0054650698,
-0.0184675865,
0.0483242013,
-0.0410644449,
-0.0078642219,
-0.0465556793,
0.0243431069,
0.0373624191,
-0.043861948,
-0.016682731,
0.0211094338,
-0.045269534,
0.0537583865,
0.0302499235,
-0.1094710305,
0.0382585227,
-0.0439819433,
-0.0126647213,
-0.0436269231,
0.0573806651,
-0.0018325567,
0.0250783041,
-0.0624019243,
0.0330512933,
0.0405551791,
-0.0186049752,
0.0718313307,
-0.0240687337,
-0.0021780666,
0.0436261594,
0.001290204,
0.0245644804,
-0.0476178154,
0.0142236557,
0.0054216459,
0.055425331,
0.0847510993,
0.0974038541,
0.045905821,
-0.0194368921,
-0.0932416767,
-0.0065106736,
-0.0032122182,
0.0280417278,
0.0360455178,
0.0057310062,
0.0177514572,
0.0249288473,
-0.0779413357,
-0.0876169801,
-0.0209439471,
-0.0152914179,
-0.0009672768,
-0.0018060328,
-0.0485086739,
-0.0277164746,
0.0131851826,
-0.0172922276,
0.0200218521,
0.0288816709,
-0.038530428,
0.0063647581,
0.0212151203,
0.0533357561,
-0.0439653434,
0.0367184505,
0.0335962772,
0.0289528593,
0.0432716757,
-0.024168402,
0.0149043547,
-0.0291635171,
-0.0402275957,
0.0071113245,
-0.0329004861,
0.0175880101,
-0.024162963,
-0.0166640766,
0.0267893188,
0.040356081,
-0.0020675194,
0.006189324,
0.0235166345,
-0.0115535185,
-0.0276490822,
0.0274974462,
0.0266843606,
0.0029694184,
-0.0130084045,
0.0075415606,
0.01083373,
0.0368247963,
0.0054190736,
-0.028155867,
-0.0165285487,
0.0109497271,
2.836e-7,
0.0580595173,
0.0562002882,
0.0036183114,
0.0266581681,
0.0344894379,
0.0517675206,
-0.0218704809,
0.0034407468,
0.0571848564,
-0.016949622,
-0.0167602189,
0.0177922156,
0.0453142785,
0.0443020053,
-0.032177601,
0.0092948107,
-0.0767132193,
-0.0353436321,
-0.0252118371,
-0.0008477515,
0.1130226403,
0.0495589487,
0.0119251674,
0.0004145882,
-0.0061388435,
-0.0146981599,
0.0646230429,
-0.0214462969,
0.0038559968,
-0.0147233149,
0.0255036559,
-0.0114755025,
0.0017533799,
0.0255914107,
0.0013108923,
0.0047493973,
-0.0478194766,
0.0566532575,
-0.0096281813,
-0.0466929488,
-0.0131199304,
-0.014312272,
0.0080533419,
-0.0786096156,
0.0744830966,
-0.0375626571,
-0.0318017602,
-0.0107508712,
-0.0491040461,
0.0129695693,
0.03328209,
-0.0472309105,
-0.0571617037,
-0.0113693867,
0.0114599299,
0.020205602,
-0.0016230368,
-0.0310107209,
-0.0534550771,
0.0320878923,
-0.0396517403,
-0.0465600826,
-0.0477061123,
0.0190574378,
0.0223576929,
-0.034477517,
0.0390112363,
2.287109767e-34,
0.0441781543,
0.0033935914,
0.0086520929,
-0.0365810655,
0.0797050297,
0.0262739509,
-0.0216226205,
0.0322790705,
0.009322362,
-0.053553775,
-0.013881986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17429v1 | TARGET: Template-Transferable Backdoor Attack Against Prompt-based NLP Models via GPT4 | 2023-11-29T08:12:09 | 2023-11-29T08:12:09 | Zihao Tan, Qingliang Chen, Yongjian Huang, Chen Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt-based learning has been widely applied in many low-resource NLP tasks
such as few-shot scenarios. However, this paradigm has been shown to be
vulnerable to backdoor attacks. Most of the existing attack methods focus on
inserting manually predefined templates as triggers in the pre-training phase
to train the victim model and utilize the same triggers in the downstream task
to perform inference, which tends to ignore the transferability and
stealthiness of the templates. In this work, we propose a novel approach of
TARGET (Template-trAnsfeRable backdoor attack aGainst prompt-basEd NLP models
via GPT4), which is a data-independent attack method. Specifically, we first
utilize GPT4 to reformulate manual templates to generate tone-strong and normal
templates, and the former are injected into the model as a backdoor trigger in
the pre-training phase. Then, we not only directly employ the above templates
in the downstream task, but also use GPT4 to generate templates with similar
tone to the above templates to carry out transferable attacks. Finally we have
conducted extensive experiments on five NLP datasets and three BERT series
models, with experimental results justifying that our TARGET method has better
attack performance and stealthiness compared to the two-external baseline
methods on direct attacks, and in addition achieves satisfactory attack
capability in the unseen tone-similar templates. | [
0.0257572923,
0.0512048118,
-0.0107619846,
0.0454334281,
-0.0514496341,
0.000556242,
0.0229290072,
-0.0098113362,
-0.050278306,
-0.0454709642,
-0.0423731916,
0.0335981324,
-0.0028590097,
0.008102553,
0.0505561456,
-0.0429687202,
0.0590830594,
-0.0221772362,
-0.0179924984,
-0.0120535819,
-0.0311644319,
0.0037017209,
-0.0178463422,
0.0331709087,
0.0038318324,
-0.0116528962,
-0.0309513975,
0.0190160777,
0.0371372849,
-0.0084551945,
0.0015995107,
0.0619812757,
-0.0011187211,
0.0442950539,
0.000001917,
-0.0394387618,
-0.0597633757,
0.0063992371,
-0.0293891504,
0.0327113457,
-0.0314329378,
-0.0131315785,
-0.0314512812,
-0.0025978964,
-0.0344829932,
-0.0329074226,
0.0259851422,
0.0752551705,
0.0950926989,
0.0983986035,
-0.0125648258,
-0.0356890261,
0.0482687466,
-0.0220826175,
0.0011018096,
-0.0600229129,
0.0354761109,
-0.087317422,
-0.0181261059,
0.0161755588,
-0.0002525703,
0.0037262035,
-0.0204638187,
0.0355629139,
-0.0419226922,
0.0346697196,
-0.0254943334,
0.018170312,
-0.0494294614,
0.0684011057,
-0.0345237702,
-0.002653027,
-0.0005869562,
-0.0192865934,
0.0185483992,
0.0201626718,
0.0074702185,
-0.0143884392,
0.0175096802,
0.0025524409,
0.015052299,
-0.0189075992,
0.0246927831,
-0.0245224815,
0.0054529519,
0.0039970162,
0.0475138016,
-0.044730071,
-0.0035195409,
-0.0617516004,
-0.0229364391,
-0.0436112136,
-0.0250782091,
0.0169388447,
0.0337971076,
0.0195507538,
-0.0508547276,
-0.021894807,
0.0198896453,
0.0158294532,
0.0516603217,
0.0470287316,
-0.0379330032,
0.0143075967,
-0.0477847233,
0.047589507,
-0.0344189182,
0.0160962474,
-0.0024306832,
0.0163524169,
-0.0727340281,
-0.026911715,
-0.0583080687,
0.0411475413,
-0.0198793095,
-0.0359498709,
-0.0259288047,
0.0007430108,
-0.0077745481,
-0.0003232226,
-0.0035524915,
-0.0008591969,
-0.0388291441,
0.0247669425,
0.0264181849,
0.0041616713,
-0.0055906032,
-0.0281209089,
-0.021037044,
-0.0930078104,
-0.0287855268,
-0.0168781783,
-0.0056269336,
-0.0334510878,
0.0066204816,
0.0946950689,
0.0164106805,
-0.0430430658,
-0.0357061513,
-0.0380021706,
-0.010487387,
-0.0158100314,
0.0006924315,
-0.0632130131,
-0.0257859677,
-0.030824123,
0.0082550282,
0.008193641,
0.0192623585,
0.0396386273,
-0.0367421433,
0.1093626544,
0.0067336019,
-0.0273517016,
0.0044806739,
0.0004818813,
-0.0568641014,
0.0605160557,
0.0053435476,
0.0078399023,
0.0437325835,
-0.0172686074,
0.0170791019,
0.0292148851,
0.051203303,
0.0405546948,
-0.0020600217,
0.0118929157,
0.0642227605,
-0.0100012021,
-0.0086433804,
0.0460138284,
-0.0223288946,
-0.0407918803,
0.0746383816,
0.030062221,
-0.0152401384,
0.0421391763,
0.0484493077,
0.0011361272,
-0.0265883412,
0.0547824651,
-0.0496436693,
-0.0517159887,
-0.093100138,
-0.0210694894,
0.0180368684,
0.0013722169,
-0.0087934453,
0.0230698269,
0.0046722968,
-0.003146285,
-0.0277463067,
-0.0255820081,
0.0180195142,
0.0673906729,
-0.0359472819,
0.077820763,
0.0060178335,
-0.005980209,
-0.0463268645,
-0.0473140702,
-0.031998843,
-0.0022089893,
0.0366043746,
-0.0115062185,
-0.0307439212,
-0.0412561409,
-0.0423356183,
0.0327285118,
0.001513453,
0.0134880533,
0.0203255042,
-0.0204318836,
-0.0006178929,
-0.0331140384,
0.0251451209,
0.0560852475,
-0.0011075989,
-0.0049049798,
0.0106174834,
0.0231191367,
0.0200499538,
0.0261736922,
0.031842947,
-0.1063963175,
0.0455803238,
0.0375591889,
0.058673054,
0.0024925189,
-0.0090971095,
0.0250987858,
0.0045962506,
-0.0081576584,
-0.0019333001,
-0.009283809,
-0.0496574119,
-0.0502018146,
-0.0104154833,
-0.0110180601,
0.0168739781,
0.0423595645,
-0.0317764468,
-0.0465849712,
0.0099564651,
-0.05150415,
0.0480622761,
-0.0221724454,
-0.0006417536,
0.0278805606,
0.0449191704,
-0.0105654346,
0.0529167652,
0.0042918571,
0.0022893872,
0.0293292571,
0.0400042161,
0.013820515,
-0.0664046109,
-0.0307343788,
0.0206432827,
-0.0119272573,
-0.0165697001,
0.0021211118,
0.0071796998,
-0.0175661165,
-0.00179971,
-0.0474870242,
0.001680351,
-0.0108222309,
0.02880417,
0.0359107479,
0.0182872601,
-0.0429405458,
-0.029650731,
-0.0022186597,
-0.0337736756,
-0.0240579136,
0.0376602262,
0.020498747,
0.0178461168,
-0.0166852288,
0.0152138956,
-0.0017259133,
-0.0443719886,
0.0793818012,
-0.0428757444,
-0.0134329153,
-0.0374226235,
0.0025286067,
0.0241064876,
0.0522393212,
0.0326741673,
-0.0382947251,
0.011942517,
-0.0014569848,
0.0260625426,
0.0403487906,
-0.0032678673,
0.0334024467,
0.0111919148,
-0.0301995613,
-0.0465633236,
0.0302005596,
-0.0043998035,
-0.0327040628,
-0.0278691761,
-0.0011219515,
0.0460432097,
0.0574165769,
0.0740859732,
-0.0112582836,
-0.0576202832,
0.0217444897,
0.0182442255,
-0.0104603767,
-0.0312840752,
-0.0131981745,
-0.0598842278,
-0.0147560416,
0.0241712611,
-0.0447903536,
0.0639291704,
-0.0583838671,
0.0394560881,
-0.0438050143,
-0.0060980283,
0.0056721517,
0.0214874782,
-0.0091365352,
0.013500344,
0.0572765209,
-0.0503295958,
-0.0086807199,
-0.0293668099,
0.0305351373,
0.0003512291,
-0.002551192,
-0.0141977658,
-0.0221859943,
-0.0191470813,
-0.0477396213,
-0.0602326095,
-0.0509757362,
-0.0047329282,
0.0425342359,
-0.0009084082,
-0.0172062647,
0.0055606635,
-0.0161348954,
0.0031752191,
0.0138918338,
-0.0160922501,
0.0031555269,
-0.0393813923,
0.0898940712,
0.0463321209,
-0.083702594,
0.0013809175,
-0.0069015874,
0.0210903119,
0.0493802503,
0.0604897402,
0.0454767086,
-0.0518283136,
0.0310014784,
0.0184446238,
-0.0386089236,
-0.0410855897,
-0.0023241763,
0.0134363454,
-0.0392227247,
-0.0164077859,
0.0737435967,
0.0135908127,
-0.0304694399,
0.007772564,
0.0363364257,
-0.009565142,
-0.0071105943,
0.026488442,
-0.0565157272,
-0.0494929701,
0.0414574966,
0.0473884828,
-0.0548054613,
-0.0252355319,
-0.035005711,
-0.1538173109,
-0.0123244449,
-0.0136323906,
-0.0093414001,
0.0035482433,
-0.0499512367,
0.0354009122,
0.0167866293,
0.0266829096,
-0.020308733,
0.0049786302,
0.0102502787,
-0.0001801991,
-0.0114897676,
-0.0560350753,
0.0280156881,
0.0013209992,
0.0593697764,
0.095825389,
0.0327294618,
-0.0384740233,
-0.0203830358,
0.0286722183,
-0.0538997278,
0.0139893005,
-0.0007972197,
0.0390682407,
-0.0309781842,
-0.0287132058,
0.0334358327,
0.0649225339,
-0.0135728652,
0.0012029185,
0.0207635071,
0.0634945184,
0.0086869281,
-0.0143088326,
-0.015353132,
-0.0212060902,
0.0470507517,
0.0681452528,
0.0309331231,
-0.0275161155,
-0.0135530159,
-0.0410142131,
-0.004704956,
-0.0056749624,
-0.0386469774,
0.0006803099,
0.0019952748,
-0.0379716456,
-0.0697861537,
-0.0057560941,
0.0068960572,
0.0657330304,
0.0218708981,
0.0029068012,
-0.0639061183,
0.0285149869,
-0.0151069891,
0.0006989314,
-0.0162045993,
0.0355417691,
-0.071243152,
-0.0221061986,
0.0561319478,
-0.0173811577,
-0.0282602347,
0.0137662999,
-0.0334169753,
-0.0603311211,
-0.0083896639,
0.0469744354,
0.020344235,
0.043101877,
-0.0419649817,
-0.0053015118,
0.1198467016,
0.0582044795,
-0.0416782983,
-0.0030963309,
0.0879715607,
0.0010743757,
0.0041798502,
0.0299979597,
-0.0246807728,
0.0017561363,
0.0771369711,
0.035768237,
0.0166212637,
-0.0090806652,
0.0363298953,
0.0331800245,
0.0928466618,
-0.0025458552,
-0.0276414398,
0.0252933055,
0.0371489301,
-0.0053071235,
-0.0051587927,
-0.0145184519,
0.0456615426,
-0.0008884548,
0.0187520515,
-0.0046433979,
-0.0566193424,
-0.0065399488,
0.029035721,
-0.062415041,
0.0225656163,
0.0389632471,
0.0373356156,
0.0047679376,
-0.0066201598,
-0.0318102464,
0.0295136385,
0.0285228603,
0.0073580984,
-0.0084467735,
0.0509965681,
0.0336348489,
-0.0063181832,
0.005018434,
0.0432317369,
-0.0779503658,
0.0088369679,
-0.0244096182,
-0.0040726135,
-0.0071397419,
-0.0013700024,
-0.0115544237,
-0.0156705063,
-0.0130240098,
-0.0003543893,
-0.0057891128,
0.0061993049,
-0.0183720514,
0.0305444691,
0.0291955639,
0.0240362305,
0.027100455,
0.0640780926,
-0.0079026278,
0.0889177099,
0.0211047232,
-0.0112110516,
-0.0532728545,
-0.0013041238,
0.0334015675,
0.0023555406,
-0.0011872206,
0.0222598072,
-0.0222480353,
-0.068142049,
0.019135382,
-0.0257430784,
0.0279075149,
0.0344889127,
0.0262947679,
0.045474302,
0.0067341533,
0.0101187304,
-0.0485002548,
0.0258636791,
0.023651557,
-0.017830126,
0.0243179183,
-6.037709634e-33,
0.0030157326,
-0.0044789524,
-0.0335409157,
0.0051450045,
0.0302471984,
0.0335524902,
0.0009769386,
-0.0305091534,
-0.0080702091,
0.0035465376,
-0.0314853154,
-0.0191318598,
0.0193184912,
0.0110195475,
-0.0494741537,
-0.0136076584,
0.0192434937,
0.0068960581,
-0.0328084081,
0.0292385742,
0.0881466791,
0.0455158241,
0.0804508403,
-0.0046165031,
0.0007057708,
0.0052175429,
-0.038899757,
0.0113969613,
-0.0437794141,
0.0498182736,
-0.0350449942,
0.0215355139,
-0.0059313127,
-0.0466779396,
0.0002862914,
0.0609403029,
-0.0315704793,
-0.0477271862,
-0.0028478578,
-0.010807828,
0.001415233,
-0.0546545126,
-0.0076764608,
-0.0185909662,
-0.0074850474,
-0.0091901068,
-0.0017754403,
-0.03420192,
0.0019618343,
-0.0437629223,
-0.0371613726,
0.0263870228,
-0.0041552815,
-0.0209873822,
-0.0213814843,
0.0223244261,
-0.0070479233,
-0.0303477775,
-0.0533734187,
0.002070613,
0.064820081,
0.0300745256,
0.0085064219,
0.0013710831,
0.0080141108,
0.0375557989,
0.0161539819,
-0.0654305443,
-0.0057296297,
-0.0265285205,
-0.0068287193,
0.059104871,
0.0528814793,
0.0245321933,
0.0610524788,
0.0040596682,
-0.0221060757,
-0.001330069,
0.0549274944,
0.0351250805,
0.0563489124,
-0.0035875621,
-0.0683991015,
0.0020972998,
-0.0434248224,
-0.0685278103,
-0.042025011,
-0.0209954064,
0.0327336118,
0.00579928,
-0.031339813,
0.0319205523,
0.017808307,
-0.0289168023,
0.0057354937,
0.0265288614,
-0.011061429,
-0.0361957513,
-0.0256997086,
0.01277187,
-0.0058930903,
-0.0196253546,
0.054698538,
-0.0323124491,
0.032569699,
-0.0040827054,
0.0286104567,
0.0469654016,
-0.0917337313,
-0.0365807265,
-0.0291099828,
0.0259302724,
-0.0064899446,
0.0020281181,
0.0357637443,
-0.0156743843,
-0.0161489137,
0.027012568,
0.0249070972,
-0.0095119579,
-0.0385680385,
0.0759033486,
-0.0331370682,
0.0246338882,
-0.02549324,
-0.01607031,
0.0290780719,
0.0380343422,
0.0258514397,
-0.0372215807,
-0.0205513127,
0.0229629558,
2.858e-7,
-0.0048869606,
0.0015471751,
0.0283931326,
0.0084142564,
-0.0040823389,
0.0628876984,
-0.0338297673,
0.0896869227,
0.0141045582,
-0.0269638319,
-0.0184691232,
-0.0255142245,
0.032648813,
0.0300030224,
-0.1012898013,
0.0590116903,
-0.0715815052,
0.0346391946,
-0.0596281476,
0.0001839682,
0.0447740331,
0.0830544457,
0.0175641645,
-0.011536276,
0.0062216758,
-0.0002333336,
0.0216962863,
-0.0111094229,
-0.0119509986,
-0.0292151347,
0.0627852306,
-0.0069054528,
0.0023110418,
0.0595141277,
-0.029507203,
0.0306473207,
-0.0370339528,
0.0084595606,
0.0156011535,
-0.0806565732,
-0.02418782,
-0.0199044421,
0.0011291871,
-0.037924882,
0.0852353275,
-0.0447082631,
-0.0369433239,
-0.0128715234,
-0.0615718961,
-0.0291952137,
-0.0046868487,
-0.0559842438,
-0.0253652185,
0.0147092342,
0.0069352691,
0.0206672121,
-0.0092522232,
-0.089782849,
0.0130423913,
-0.0380965956,
-0.0293018725,
-0.0438403897,
-0.0065270085,
-0.0170254856,
-0.0067818277,
-0.0521643758,
0.0029657274,
2.930462876e-34,
-0.0076662726,
-0.0253168996,
0.0078024184,
0.0168791097,
0.0304564107,
-0.0060752761,
0.0455619954,
0.0149125513,
0.0388959497,
-0.0835081339,
-0.0561278537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02181v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02181v1 | How Generative-AI can be Effectively used in Government Chatbots | 2023-11-29T07:27:15 | 2023-11-29T07:27:15 | Zeteng Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | With the rapid development of artificial intelligence and breakthroughs in
machine learning and natural language processing, intelligent
question-answering robots have become widely used in government affairs. This
paper conducts a horizontal comparison between Guangdong Province's government
chatbots, ChatGPT, and Wenxin Ernie, two large language models, to analyze the
strengths and weaknesses of existing government chatbots and AIGC technology.
The study finds significant differences between government chatbots and large
language models. China's government chatbots are still in an exploratory stage
and have a gap to close to achieve "intelligence." To explore the future
direction of government chatbots more deeply, this research proposes targeted
optimization paths to help generative AI be effectively applied in government
chatbot conversations. | [
0.0731837675,
0.0440176539,
-0.0284572244,
-0.0098260436,
-0.0132220751,
0.0137940953,
0.0039382628,
-0.0011193358,
0.0657044277,
0.0088075828,
0.0399842858,
-0.0348772891,
-0.0234905127,
0.0512928478,
-0.0099326624,
-0.0790272877,
0.0169044826,
0.0124384593,
0.0502303131,
-0.0094970306,
-0.0118009215,
-0.001222949,
-0.0085821953,
0.0660537407,
-0.0566804856,
-0.0098455241,
-0.0371629782,
-0.0136785079,
0.0407804586,
-0.0021464922,
-0.0083214603,
0.0020587468,
-0.0004479163,
0.0340401232,
0.0000018742,
-0.0404114351,
-0.003160317,
0.0247317553,
-0.0333303176,
-0.037800651,
0.075702168,
0.0362274982,
-0.0537584946,
0.0726576671,
-0.0583940484,
0.0029084932,
0.0560344085,
0.0266827289,
0.0537182949,
0.0910191759,
-0.0090841828,
-0.0045052185,
0.0019183233,
-0.010461851,
-0.0053501539,
-0.0762834996,
-0.0117790336,
0.0341814831,
0.0010977468,
-0.0174636971,
0.0028770026,
0.0025799403,
0.0287344493,
-0.0277229585,
-0.037823692,
0.0507996418,
-0.0303974822,
-0.0217081644,
-0.0096611539,
0.0596741214,
0.0680663735,
-0.0022923022,
0.0142750014,
0.0116808116,
0.0446782261,
0.0163046196,
-0.0320706815,
0.0199204553,
-0.0267971251,
-0.0067453198,
-0.0065545877,
-0.0264432337,
-0.0330056064,
0.0017268017,
-0.0312171057,
0.0253453739,
0.0066047926,
-0.0234759096,
-0.0159860961,
-0.0181317814,
-0.0119085675,
-0.0505414568,
-0.0209171288,
0.0693931133,
-0.0295949671,
0.0307606608,
-0.0117947562,
0.0020513404,
0.0007292816,
-0.0178699531,
-0.021934269,
0.0614445992,
0.0144750066,
0.0483313352,
0.0252204407,
0.0989126265,
0.002961586,
0.0211964324,
-0.0333312713,
-0.0731409043,
-0.0822149143,
-0.0361750722,
-0.0832456946,
0.0318713933,
-0.0239937119,
-0.0576079674,
-0.009306387,
0.0578431115,
0.011273819,
0.0108073279,
-0.0109521551,
0.0427002199,
-0.0478505604,
-0.025739355,
-0.0702554137,
-0.0153603647,
-0.0438922569,
0.0106373057,
-0.008737538,
-0.0400175899,
-0.0081960047,
0.0348684974,
0.0206470378,
0.020533042,
-0.032406766,
0.0718806684,
-0.0126528824,
0.0117180711,
0.0265792571,
-0.0054216669,
-0.0125697078,
-0.0619570836,
0.0407253616,
-0.029321827,
0.0186335277,
-0.0098774293,
-0.0109859444,
-0.0159718357,
0.0117047401,
-0.023530148,
-0.0039558029,
-0.0102106659,
-0.0190817472,
0.0249075349,
0.0192099977,
0.0007223571,
-0.0231795609,
0.0629593208,
0.0240171365,
0.0429580286,
0.0419381671,
0.0041479529,
0.0657720491,
0.0067727678,
-0.0381428227,
0.0390833467,
0.0327744037,
0.0160285123,
-0.0311867706,
0.0012368705,
0.010794837,
0.0433677956,
-0.0192627031,
0.0500805192,
0.0285295676,
0.0428191423,
-0.0132305259,
0.0359686874,
0.0183731075,
0.0411127731,
0.0232911035,
0.0032285359,
-0.0102990186,
0.0340094715,
-0.045093935,
0.001349752,
-0.0186466631,
0.0105396127,
-0.0563767292,
-0.0561188348,
-0.005520436,
-0.0017559674,
0.0445612855,
0.0075194733,
0.0513457358,
-0.0065240571,
-0.0559050925,
-0.041079931,
-0.0161065515,
-0.0383679047,
-0.0645154491,
-0.1084187329,
-0.0017786028,
0.0899236053,
0.0272977855,
-0.0016344695,
-0.044609908,
-0.0124552166,
-0.0174036939,
0.0817886218,
0.0524468571,
-0.0123650655,
-0.0274944957,
-0.006345144,
-0.0078735203,
0.0102391168,
0.0148722129,
0.036102362,
0.0031999368,
0.0374695323,
0.0127072269,
0.0291411281,
0.0084424866,
0.0268348996,
-0.0222060159,
0.0193223506,
-0.013990364,
-0.0033726899,
0.0561811924,
0.0119740954,
-0.0427212603,
-0.0097183352,
0.0052785631,
0.0009329118,
-0.0635255724,
0.0296841543,
-0.0315563902,
-0.0123117398,
0.0237729568,
-0.0384599268,
0.0071683368,
0.0161162782,
-0.0657308698,
-0.0353255942,
0.0373395309,
-0.0586238019,
0.0422817096,
-0.0605654344,
0.0399439447,
-0.0222956631,
-0.0011366173,
-0.0027181553,
0.0533559918,
0.0007585326,
-0.0449422151,
0.0406414121,
0.0686405376,
0.0704773292,
-0.0353412181,
0.0067068841,
0.0264353156,
0.0152670061,
0.0263865776,
0.028019784,
0.006401537,
-0.0257995091,
-0.0713991001,
-0.0905242786,
-0.0126458909,
-0.0091929697,
0.011465895,
0.0449725948,
-0.0133634023,
0.0017112371,
0.0152914962,
-0.0535457097,
0.0239562634,
0.0209281761,
-0.0276015047,
0.0220010206,
-0.010996392,
-0.0487762131,
-0.0271485299,
0.0395798981,
-0.0096452832,
-0.040364828,
0.0191649292,
-0.0308728945,
-0.0308637898,
0.015446133,
-0.0297644921,
0.0271193143,
-0.026597023,
-0.1013943478,
0.0191340279,
-0.0035597302,
0.0560664125,
0.0483545028,
0.0446172208,
0.0449274518,
-0.0068880664,
0.0293543655,
-0.0726543218,
0.0441350825,
-0.0196112916,
0.017305363,
0.0023473126,
-0.0205990281,
0.0194511656,
0.0181066357,
0.0200716443,
0.0245603155,
-0.0521971956,
0.0773064867,
0.0169124324,
-0.0358496942,
-0.0314109661,
0.0148385894,
-0.0273437407,
0.0158871431,
0.0004950359,
-0.0302106999,
0.0252882857,
0.0261968914,
0.0095453616,
-0.0281044263,
-0.0018073398,
-0.0266747158,
0.0671402216,
-0.0282321889,
0.0199745093,
-0.0001985548,
-0.0343993939,
-0.0337591283,
0.0415048376,
0.0127981147,
-0.050966844,
-0.0309800711,
-0.0144912275,
0.0095970035,
-0.0185105503,
-0.0350752547,
-0.0539409593,
0.0055912808,
0.0037832721,
0.0462343507,
0.0726770759,
-0.0404739454,
-0.0120227383,
0.0323796198,
-0.0189206842,
0.0232241377,
-0.0212583896,
-0.0056176027,
-0.0115001062,
-0.0189919733,
0.0128187621,
0.0345623046,
-0.0152285751,
0.0381568111,
0.0398233831,
0.0060568783,
0.0255123395,
0.0146356085,
-0.0067081749,
-0.0600902103,
0.021428192,
-0.0167562291,
-0.0222644098,
-0.0082339114,
0.0090086749,
-0.0460613482,
0.0094662216,
0.0684908554,
0.0376015082,
0.0056486665,
0.0057176598,
-0.0323330872,
-0.0153607093,
0.0217776429,
0.0331975855,
-0.0790261403,
0.0238869749,
0.0244309753,
-0.0115154358,
-0.0449717753,
-0.0111957174,
-0.003331207,
-0.1191179305,
0.0716986805,
-0.0297787972,
-0.0277518574,
-0.0559993535,
-0.0172070879,
0.0050361981,
0.0107956165,
-0.0111661302,
-0.003542494,
0.0172534324,
-0.0320929363,
0.015900176,
-0.0616056658,
-0.027077714,
-0.0116694588,
-0.0008948123,
0.0635789633,
0.1033238322,
0.1076865792,
0.032464873,
0.0242573563,
0.018641308,
0.0470632762,
0.0028015648,
0.0179811344,
0.0487869643,
0.0164014697,
0.0059068189,
-0.0207116492,
0.0112751173,
0.0266007204,
0.0480070524,
0.0446899906,
0.0094186673,
-0.061547894,
-0.0205012877,
-0.0247904975,
0.020161001,
0.0389671475,
0.073721014,
-0.0081063705,
-0.0106577938,
-0.0510724448,
-0.037014056,
0.0158838332,
-0.0544777475,
-0.0042242995,
0.0127081238,
0.0198084321,
0.001227192,
-0.0993866399,
-0.0441883914,
0.0111617018,
0.0000481608,
-0.0065994016,
-0.0093613258,
-0.0089044543,
0.0351586305,
0.0623779148,
-0.0720695928,
-0.0285554826,
-0.014116074,
-0.043207366,
-0.0741809756,
-0.0124922842,
-0.0308016576,
-0.0226157326,
0.0020119583,
-0.0132025089,
-0.0344982445,
0.0051462157,
-0.0021301969,
0.0191805549,
-0.0129460245,
-0.0512097664,
0.0115316976,
0.0283199176,
0.0399893075,
-0.016196046,
-0.0457020849,
0.0314640552,
0.0568425134,
-0.0116776805,
0.0135434372,
-0.0694538504,
0.0400513187,
-0.0087596606,
0.0072793565,
-0.001399965,
-0.022671489,
0.0289427973,
0.0628756508,
-0.0508577041,
0.0098691704,
-0.0392311551,
-0.0227351394,
0.0133907311,
-0.0588578023,
-0.0083072577,
-0.0349683613,
0.0120488564,
-0.000556249,
-0.0078545157,
0.0332788825,
0.0311289653,
-0.0210849829,
0.0208900832,
0.0011158572,
0.011597231,
-0.0003159947,
0.0389549211,
0.0045710588,
-0.0100059649,
-0.0150961308,
0.0278707929,
0.0154476799,
0.0201796349,
0.0100546228,
0.0824654251,
-0.0028432528,
-0.0161720719,
0.0277638249,
0.0253938865,
-0.0775172934,
-0.1337441951,
-0.0040853512,
0.0651767328,
0.0630050749,
0.0724197999,
0.0131043727,
-0.0513773859,
0.0084088426,
-0.0062210597,
0.0051827049,
0.0405397378,
-0.0338439383,
-0.0111641409,
-0.0131227328,
-0.0429252386,
-0.0090221884,
0.0725953728,
0.0205519404,
0.0455721729,
-0.0261609294,
-0.004605622,
-0.039163813,
-0.0306498278,
0.0089237783,
0.0022497263,
0.0190572292,
-0.005308867,
-0.0201104227,
-0.0082557667,
-0.0687812418,
0.0221970566,
-0.0100999475,
-0.008721591,
0.0240716767,
0.0237459522,
-0.029491296,
-0.0041851196,
-0.054156784,
-0.0340652727,
-0.0600327998,
0.013517295,
-0.0095113544,
-6.143779999e-33,
-0.0153539553,
-0.0110997967,
0.0588707812,
0.0098045571,
-0.0250488762,
-0.0259057637,
-0.0346437581,
0.0119972611,
-0.0502570719,
-0.0247721914,
-0.0426789671,
0.0298096035,
0.0140702724,
-0.0020673135,
-0.0177858248,
0.0167094488,
0.0590607822,
-0.010383537,
-0.0206507556,
0.0460396484,
0.0379973426,
-0.010015524,
-0.0017153875,
-0.0553173982,
-0.0077675702,
0.0044657905,
-0.0137789203,
0.0336405337,
0.0136494404,
0.0305341184,
-0.036331147,
0.0106094684,
0.0182727501,
-0.0213759001,
-0.0144745633,
0.054363016,
-0.0484014489,
-0.0232771467,
-0.040918164,
-0.0289672576,
-0.021979617,
-0.0601225495,
-0.0248604845,
-0.0041281786,
-0.0080224955,
0.0080809295,
0.046652969,
-0.018160101,
0.0167588461,
-0.0259892885,
-0.0996909365,
0.0170029476,
-0.0162090398,
-0.0055724257,
-0.0506169237,
0.0619058907,
0.006507772,
0.0102103045,
-0.0149050867,
0.0116281686,
0.0043516755,
-0.0370743759,
0.0598591045,
0.0093707265,
0.0610535331,
-0.0013930567,
0.0493995547,
0.0150424605,
-0.0724649057,
-0.0447125249,
0.0211194269,
0.0433692299,
0.0257679038,
0.0267528109,
0.0175443497,
-0.0708451495,
-0.0645493045,
0.0104817273,
0.0395146422,
0.027046524,
0.0422411226,
-0.0150284441,
-0.0550853573,
0.010690772,
-0.0021221132,
-0.0061599384,
-0.0021142606,
-0.0601246506,
0.0198000893,
0.0169887356,
0.0198243521,
-0.0727103427,
0.0437500961,
-0.0698011369,
0.0485196896,
0.0445015877,
-0.0578361452,
0.0010282173,
-0.0119028557,
0.0089596352,
-0.0885560885,
-0.0361351296,
0.04205909,
0.0389188565,
0.0298406463,
0.0137075344,
-0.0148810446,
-0.0031113827,
-0.0507386923,
0.0091112731,
-0.0302941017,
0.0366477519,
-0.0020534252,
-0.0267480016,
-0.007945789,
-0.0123804975,
0.0096141128,
-0.0164098833,
0.0122294342,
0.0560550615,
-0.0667058527,
-0.029806342,
-0.0232203342,
-0.0315239429,
-0.0425018556,
0.0239619501,
-0.0330873765,
0.0015623904,
0.0125654759,
-0.0173282772,
-0.0439440943,
0.0040201498,
2.569e-7,
0.0135470554,
0.0395228527,
0.0235796198,
0.0488741808,
0.0056874072,
0.0057611028,
0.0194117129,
0.0185197052,
-0.0122999949,
0.0470748581,
0.0448207743,
0.0316236317,
0.0383476429,
0.0309075341,
-0.0887717977,
0.0074514369,
-0.0676003397,
-0.0262343232,
-0.0228486694,
0.0249458849,
0.0269428417,
0.0342408046,
0.0053593982,
-0.0079146959,
-0.0045797303,
-0.0347008333,
0.0053578792,
0.0043379501,
-0.0062627126,
0.0688953251,
0.0355757028,
0.073981218,
0.0112849493,
0.0194344707,
0.0472818576,
0.0229289215,
-0.0113509484,
0.0568779595,
-0.0095564667,
-0.0374938436,
0.0173579995,
0.0057865437,
0.0280256309,
-0.0152620785,
0.068812184,
-0.0537366942,
-0.0182784591,
-0.037884552,
0.0087976428,
0.0103090871,
-0.0110970233,
-0.0063829906,
-0.0121209398,
0.0203408375,
-0.0138928657,
-0.0068929591,
0.0136393029,
-0.0330361463,
0.0583734885,
-0.0336111449,
-0.0435319021,
-0.1194981933,
0.0085613756,
0.0357876047,
0.0228061117,
0.0252715237,
0.0201219562,
1.618986099e-34,
0.0176432822,
0.0023310429,
-0.0229741745,
0.0412646793,
0.0684572086,
0.018844258,
0.0156072229,
-0.0324951373,
0.0047745523,
-0.0539666004,
-0.0162726603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17404v1 | VITATECS: A Diagnostic Dataset for Temporal Concept Understanding of Video-Language Models | 2023-11-29T07:15:34 | 2023-11-29T07:15:34 | Shicheng Li, Lei Li, Shuhuai Ren, Yuanxin Liu, Yi Liu, Rundong Gao, Xu Sun, Lu Hou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The ability to perceive how objects change over time is a crucial ingredient
in human intelligence. However, current benchmarks cannot faithfully reflect
the temporal understanding abilities of video-language models (VidLMs) due to
the existence of static visual shortcuts. To remedy this issue, we present
VITATECS, a diagnostic VIdeo-Text dAtaset for the evaluation of TEmporal
Concept underStanding. Specifically, we first introduce a fine-grained taxonomy
of temporal concepts in natural language in order to diagnose the capability of
VidLMs to comprehend different temporal aspects. Furthermore, to disentangle
the correlation between static and temporal information, we generate
counterfactual video descriptions that differ from the original one only in the
specified temporal aspect. We employ a semi-automatic data collection framework
using large language models and human-in-the-loop annotation to obtain
high-quality counterfactual descriptions efficiently. Evaluation of
representative video-language understanding models confirms their deficiency in
temporal understanding, revealing the need for greater emphasis on the temporal
elements in video-language research. | [
0.0250520259,
0.0319227017,
-0.0328139961,
0.04186555,
-0.0123485755,
0.0027173387,
0.0032621776,
0.0292109307,
-0.0552123785,
-0.0919279382,
0.0176494531,
-0.0449058786,
0.0257367119,
0.0551171824,
-0.0000839791,
-0.0905892327,
0.0735989213,
-0.022700334,
0.0019292686,
0.0335014164,
0.0174906962,
-0.0212890692,
-0.0427201279,
0.0247691032,
-0.0346271358,
-0.0583045259,
-0.0274040457,
-0.0296903998,
0.0504948795,
-0.0381436758,
-0.0605622828,
0.0399237275,
0.0556042641,
-0.0086572375,
0.0000018479,
-0.0141365286,
0.0469274223,
-0.0253533106,
-0.0405436233,
0.0554610193,
-0.0162500944,
-0.0260999054,
0.0190902837,
-0.0317125395,
-0.0538776219,
-0.0197370443,
0.0308010373,
-0.0327098407,
0.0333867446,
0.0069749574,
-0.0168841761,
-0.0103054931,
0.0107206861,
-0.0193378758,
0.0520122759,
-0.0388866514,
0.0079594851,
0.036972288,
0.024081504,
0.0053712344,
-0.069845736,
0.0220731255,
0.0287856292,
-0.0098594623,
0.0135460086,
0.0423035733,
-0.0221991204,
-0.0252982229,
-0.0228636153,
0.0368017815,
0.0412797406,
-0.0184786338,
-0.0181278624,
0.0190451071,
-0.0069636959,
0.0008642565,
-0.0579306744,
-0.0029634053,
0.0167591479,
-0.021036813,
-0.0120870061,
0.042571526,
0.0295548066,
-0.0022440441,
0.0523879007,
0.0028924257,
0.0066982624,
0.0159738306,
-0.0699335113,
-0.0404695757,
0.0069574034,
-0.0684469715,
-0.0054381625,
0.02676831,
0.0174788982,
-0.0014018059,
-0.0191058069,
0.0024298213,
-0.0008031324,
-0.069121398,
0.0388194919,
0.0111402171,
-0.051578518,
0.0727919117,
-0.014248535,
0.096017316,
-0.0048738657,
-0.0209668316,
0.000981666,
0.0155971004,
-0.0877293646,
-0.0036431281,
0.0080342768,
-0.0132535584,
-0.0221061036,
0.0040008118,
-0.0112802638,
0.0089827469,
-0.0490596704,
0.0210237205,
-0.0633696094,
0.0182908196,
-0.006910759,
-0.0132989548,
-0.0520318635,
0.0162125044,
-0.0504751764,
0.0326915607,
-0.0421833768,
-0.0647010952,
-0.0213070251,
0.0074064471,
-0.0091811754,
-0.0200460795,
-0.008018814,
0.0346333757,
-0.0418414176,
-0.0109357778,
-0.0370856486,
-0.0161569081,
-0.0209449008,
0.0012087002,
0.0193011705,
-0.0457178503,
0.0226129405,
0.0166426767,
-0.0087891631,
-0.0200903285,
-0.0028678968,
0.00045026,
-0.0195241366,
0.0988346934,
0.0031381538,
0.0319989398,
-0.0028639119,
0.0108317584,
0.031012265,
0.053010948,
0.0196809974,
-0.0278952513,
0.0255519543,
0.0272766072,
0.001866951,
0.030590564,
-0.0212454293,
0.0189453904,
-0.1431404501,
0.0199451353,
0.0163067523,
0.0398130119,
0.0158481728,
0.022110302,
-0.0049911803,
-0.0623008907,
0.0491517633,
0.0146518061,
-0.0608068332,
-0.040671967,
0.0713826418,
-0.0087558981,
0.0176578388,
-0.004266235,
-0.0259429514,
0.0652586296,
-0.0047758156,
0.0066225417,
-0.0842859447,
0.0036593596,
-0.0607160963,
-0.0302247684,
-0.0583579801,
0.0042377072,
0.0299252439,
-0.0061712936,
0.041981671,
0.0086849043,
-0.0149486344,
0.0430972502,
-0.0197756011,
0.0327740721,
0.0260158814,
-0.0235657208,
-0.0049587879,
0.0972516015,
0.006060957,
-0.0038105093,
-0.0672203451,
-0.0005035081,
0.0486239083,
-0.0007010306,
0.0579838082,
-0.0451069511,
0.006764207,
-0.0215021428,
-0.0249711089,
-0.0178530347,
0.0367040634,
0.0163214132,
-0.0001071658,
0.014142599,
-0.0017234208,
-0.0486345589,
0.0059034619,
0.0574386939,
0.0331236757,
0.023366617,
-0.0505036153,
0.0072728293,
0.0031815327,
0.0029033134,
-0.0067318426,
-0.0243838914,
0.020742787,
-0.0187189262,
0.0480930507,
0.0763932988,
-0.0242717266,
-0.0376984626,
0.0439088456,
-0.0419837981,
-0.0391469337,
0.0701966286,
-0.0280499812,
-0.0295925271,
0.0468727127,
0.0258757677,
0.0233239513,
-0.0523402914,
0.0157782156,
0.0171405133,
0.0193745866,
0.0103806993,
0.0450675599,
-0.0475968495,
-0.0212911014,
0.0014551135,
0.0310723018,
0.0253765974,
-0.0350391194,
-0.017874632,
0.0024090391,
-0.005487157,
-0.0404404625,
-0.0194609649,
-0.0246379003,
-0.0688677579,
0.0210364871,
-0.0684029013,
-0.023330031,
-0.017728392,
0.0041981041,
0.0073450161,
-0.0483640805,
0.007708272,
-0.0360270999,
0.0376260243,
0.0248129126,
-0.0329966694,
0.0285387021,
0.0147134895,
0.0359537862,
-0.0077164513,
-0.0240961313,
-0.0219411496,
-0.0334558785,
0.077191636,
0.0129005285,
-0.0506083965,
0.0144639155,
-0.0511918627,
-0.0182153825,
0.0272515118,
-0.0414506122,
-0.0177878346,
0.0253845304,
0.0320530869,
0.0241897926,
0.059819784,
0.0220722947,
0.0659705251,
0.0394716635,
-0.0478362776,
0.0043912339,
0.0078011602,
0.0158405174,
-0.0055448199,
-0.0180061553,
-0.0271125436,
-0.048263181,
0.0190747492,
-0.0331668966,
0.0314844511,
-0.0973594338,
0.0146407783,
-0.021464346,
-0.0216186866,
-0.0467339046,
-0.0243257899,
-0.0284244753,
0.0337133072,
-0.0514860824,
-0.0277511645,
0.0273071881,
-0.0222626515,
-0.0145713016,
0.0734229833,
0.0271226279,
0.0096144658,
0.1188444123,
0.0403980128,
-0.0126911253,
-0.0062579392,
-0.0118309464,
-0.090406999,
0.0022513121,
0.0318393186,
0.0119928317,
0.0239168052,
-0.0978940874,
0.0142826932,
-0.0001762074,
0.0268547945,
-0.0386406034,
-0.0469200574,
-0.0407444797,
-0.0058674505,
-0.0591725335,
-0.008012197,
-0.0119628841,
0.0538959466,
-0.019740779,
0.0243340116,
-0.0018830007,
0.0211486388,
0.0107924473,
-0.0004534022,
0.0583534576,
-0.0016136904,
-0.0451019518,
-0.0615552366,
0.0447530337,
0.0280280076,
0.0253696404,
-0.0539301857,
-0.0707005337,
0.0564681068,
-0.0137827769,
-0.001752395,
-0.0358446091,
0.0285523552,
0.021382736,
-0.0534757525,
-0.0047112582,
0.0835411325,
0.0268850159,
-0.0437722392,
0.0242328104,
0.0135370558,
-0.0167844407,
0.0682081878,
-0.006119912,
-0.0858864784,
-0.0413131081,
-0.0003935297,
-0.0293635745,
0.0074928314,
-0.0078789545,
-0.0402127244,
-0.073700361,
0.0274478011,
-0.0062766126,
-0.0352792032,
0.0042668944,
0.0385899544,
0.0213485956,
-0.0144257974,
-0.0308939312,
-0.0115332417,
-0.0015831413,
0.0223108828,
0.0137308668,
-0.0409795232,
-0.0527437665,
0.1003655419,
0.0205704309,
0.0641342476,
0.0256623365,
0.0062399581,
-0.0116437161,
-0.0629608408,
0.0453182459,
-0.0175116789,
0.0249565933,
-0.0041724183,
0.0575117767,
-0.0297113378,
-0.027483318,
0.0408947766,
-0.000976057,
0.0378211327,
-0.072656475,
-0.0152838482,
0.0792976767,
-0.0268010739,
0.0255593695,
-0.050823722,
-0.0104213841,
0.00702288,
0.0527337231,
0.0125268111,
-0.0193713922,
0.0116947433,
0.061990343,
-0.0463097356,
-0.0425542332,
-0.0446128473,
-0.0258914921,
0.0190401655,
0.0037101698,
-0.0408638082,
-0.0325554833,
0.0181258004,
0.0246249512,
-0.0003330987,
-0.012804037,
-0.0115625449,
0.0387472175,
-0.0973606035,
0.0749332756,
0.0355058573,
0.0121633867,
-0.0278603472,
-0.044735264,
0.0435237959,
0.002004182,
-0.0309385844,
0.0350976437,
-0.0666480437,
-0.0190573093,
0.0248547494,
0.0352023654,
0.0289428327,
0.0933841914,
0.0029221813,
0.0026310713,
0.017070584,
-0.0088732485,
0.0148835601,
0.023807127,
-0.023088878,
-0.0265578516,
-0.019344138,
0.047126133,
-0.0266630426,
0.0051855394,
-0.01891388,
0.0111303357,
-0.0613935515,
0.0056902543,
0.0118163629,
-0.0798926353,
0.0782874301,
-0.0028412496,
-0.0103570241,
-0.0123172784,
-0.0060520885,
0.0027478626,
0.0270336997,
-0.0469287001,
0.0028443255,
-0.0068718246,
0.0057159495,
-0.0230019167,
0.0170997549,
-0.0136118922,
-0.027922472,
-0.0123250261,
-0.0216243919,
0.0000819443,
0.0054521435,
-0.0090066865,
0.0384291895,
0.024631612,
0.0173445661,
-0.0349035636,
0.0047384724,
0.0315052941,
0.0333279371,
0.0189101398,
0.0322456025,
-0.0179295428,
0.0140681425,
-0.0159863848,
0.0074511087,
-0.0051128929,
0.024720246,
0.0425585434,
-0.0572682507,
0.0212840978,
-0.0082525238,
-0.003575044,
-0.004804031,
0.0393388793,
0.0044891359,
-0.0753060058,
0.0516204685,
0.0288030952,
0.0050747581,
0.0210755691,
0.0770048946,
-0.0121120475,
0.0512189977,
0.0049771685,
0.0163846482,
-0.0075317975,
-0.0116754565,
-0.0206696857,
-0.0183252525,
-0.0067862994,
0.0168958679,
-0.0805562064,
-0.0903497562,
0.0104475981,
0.0169544797,
0.0375169814,
0.0488883927,
0.0382707231,
0.0303142425,
0.0046195695,
-0.0290929787,
0.0020266345,
-0.0117662447,
0.0045834677,
0.005111374,
-0.0550759658,
-6.154894298e-33,
-0.0411292352,
-0.0144536877,
0.0226084199,
0.0045534684,
-0.0117343003,
0.0314793698,
-0.0143293124,
0.0156709142,
-0.0171735566,
0.0555560552,
0.0096130967,
0.0412271023,
0.0199475717,
-0.0069396868,
0.0499523841,
-0.0365537927,
0.0496159792,
-0.035296239,
-0.016014047,
-0.0094618518,
0.0301708505,
0.0096779503,
0.0752916262,
-0.072861068,
0.0121106142,
0.0238552876,
-0.0213005971,
0.0417848676,
0.0326473676,
0.0665878579,
0.0088224048,
-0.0172646288,
0.0386119261,
-0.0309334528,
-0.0363315977,
-0.0336774886,
-0.0494946241,
-0.0052123037,
0.0446430072,
0.0752851218,
-0.044399526,
-0.0087793432,
0.0213568658,
-0.0105634695,
-0.0227001179,
0.0001568038,
0.0541329458,
-0.0518713519,
0.0220440775,
0.0026317714,
-0.028156016,
0.0163263865,
-0.0457816347,
-0.0499102399,
0.0347560942,
-0.0086088656,
0.0163091514,
-0.0384356864,
-0.0638229772,
0.0172992125,
-0.003745839,
0.0136595592,
0.0979918838,
0.0177226663,
0.0278407671,
0.0611788444,
0.0131755741,
-0.0173408054,
-0.0058207433,
-0.000766155,
0.0207386855,
0.034871079,
0.0057972749,
0.02096528,
0.064885214,
-0.0033443577,
-0.0204920545,
-0.0004205367,
-0.0751122609,
0.1008747444,
-0.0088369465,
0.0096486304,
0.0168652348,
0.0210017525,
-0.023777768,
-0.0098775672,
-0.0231557973,
0.0032813069,
0.0311739706,
-0.0095550297,
0.0383548699,
0.0003777938,
0.0555107109,
-0.0204924233,
0.0235583726,
0.0159699004,
-0.0230087917,
0.0460747704,
0.0426697135,
0.0220716335,
-0.0430041589,
0.0043292707,
0.02504237,
0.030372994,
0.0199038014,
-0.0142825749,
0.0041397065,
0.0496511161,
-0.0050937915,
-0.0315773189,
-0.0006342217,
-0.020156553,
-0.0265870821,
-0.0185841788,
0.059471447,
0.0152122937,
-0.0639601201,
0.0363770947,
-0.0045208074,
-0.013380086,
-0.001008162,
0.0053800866,
-0.016068643,
0.0200549867,
-0.028816225,
-0.0040441034,
-0.0310286358,
-0.0326286629,
0.0180783141,
-0.0092813605,
0.015300272,
0.0235018935,
2.599e-7,
0.00858426,
0.0419528894,
0.0034536703,
0.0277232397,
0.0304426216,
0.0163893886,
-0.0347769447,
0.0027017619,
0.0004033767,
-0.0102405846,
0.0408673398,
0.0698569044,
0.0279346611,
-0.0240796786,
0.0235554986,
0.0041390387,
-0.0389626473,
-0.0041683004,
-0.0488234572,
-0.0107381018,
0.0635855868,
0.0747739375,
0.026998302,
0.0269153435,
-0.0019679957,
-0.0447993726,
0.0689782128,
-0.0236379392,
-0.0136989783,
-0.0242843404,
0.0419936292,
0.0216736645,
-0.0218464956,
0.0585985705,
-0.0211667102,
-0.0395515114,
-0.0207461286,
0.0120561374,
-0.0651518926,
-0.0511152782,
-0.0572784096,
0.0173206255,
-0.0421601757,
-0.0130351614,
0.0911910385,
-0.0401088223,
-0.0125616705,
-0.0067277472,
-0.0205606632,
0.040414799,
-0.0089156181,
0.0534139946,
-0.0187070519,
0.0219724607,
0.0029715388,
-0.0020546475,
-0.0571569018,
-0.0970488489,
-0.0203471407,
0.0394946635,
-0.0375870317,
0.0251194891,
-0.0303320419,
-0.0082378881,
0.0260743946,
0.013092611,
-0.0631065741,
1.726740246e-34,
0.0166701116,
0.0245244205,
-0.0174480118,
-0.0301266164,
-0.0162226092,
-0.0213948749,
-0.0147378938,
0.0191147793,
0.0137778884,
-0.0024400633,
-0.0134602534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17400v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17400v2 | Improving the Robustness of Transformer-based Large Language Models with Dynamic Attention | 2023-11-29T07:09:13 | 2023-11-30T02:08:24 | Lujia Shen, Yuwen Pu, Shouling Ji, Changjiang Li, Xuhong Zhang, Chunpeng Ge, Ting Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Transformer-based models, such as BERT and GPT, have been widely adopted in
natural language processing (NLP) due to their exceptional performance.
However, recent studies show their vulnerability to textual adversarial attacks
where the model's output can be misled by intentionally manipulating the text
inputs. Despite various methods that have been proposed to enhance the model's
robustness and mitigate this vulnerability, many require heavy consumption
resources (e.g., adversarial training) or only provide limited protection
(e.g., defensive dropout). In this paper, we propose a novel method called
dynamic attention, tailored for the transformer architecture, to enhance the
inherent robustness of the model itself against various adversarial attacks.
Our method requires no downstream task knowledge and does not incur additional
costs. The proposed dynamic attention consists of two modules: (I) attention
rectification, which masks or weakens the attention value of the chosen tokens,
and (ii) dynamic modeling, which dynamically builds the set of candidate
tokens. Extensive experiments demonstrate that dynamic attention significantly
mitigates the impact of adversarial attacks, improving up to 33\% better
performance than previous methods against widely-used adversarial attacks. The
model-level design of dynamic attention enables it to be easily combined with
other defense methods (e.g., adversarial training) to further enhance the
model's robustness. Furthermore, we demonstrate that dynamic attention
preserves the state-of-the-art robustness space of the original model compared
to other dynamic modeling methods. | [
0.0439533144,
0.0424976982,
-0.0160662159,
0.0413905047,
-0.0235093143,
-0.0067122215,
-0.0073510045,
-0.0153674334,
-0.0001124465,
-0.0545229018,
-0.0171817858,
-0.0160880461,
0.0128554106,
0.0363593251,
0.0675992891,
-0.0428695716,
0.0493061431,
-0.0127104493,
0.0057324292,
0.0094471248,
0.0046056276,
-0.0063627497,
0.018620776,
0.0548364669,
-0.0063417801,
-0.0161839891,
0.0088380361,
0.0075628981,
0.0249954965,
-0.0018868071,
0.0305351615,
0.0256411619,
-0.0148313157,
0.0865877345,
0.0000019234,
-0.0053171124,
-0.0374737158,
0.0191963445,
-0.0049628555,
0.0177280474,
0.0264463555,
-0.038557265,
-0.0285611935,
0.0247333329,
-0.0181803722,
-0.0059660985,
0.0459086224,
0.0842870325,
0.0722220168,
0.1130563319,
-0.0119546419,
-0.0301664118,
0.0732730851,
-0.0442667007,
-0.053583011,
-0.0533828288,
0.0312904157,
-0.0608851835,
-0.0512385927,
0.0001116253,
-0.0243803337,
0.0345710292,
0.0300742164,
-0.0023065594,
-0.0288229994,
0.0315548107,
-0.0614473373,
-0.0083201919,
-0.0225160308,
0.0692848712,
-0.091891259,
-0.0130092958,
0.0011502954,
-0.0007982919,
0.0267324131,
0.0037259317,
-0.0352689326,
0.0101560177,
0.0292334687,
0.0011565787,
-0.0120434519,
-0.0248699524,
0.0411489755,
0.0088632228,
-0.022486398,
0.0243723318,
0.042470552,
-0.0180899017,
-0.0348667875,
-0.0301596764,
-0.0525738969,
-0.054292351,
0.0141262319,
0.0202021245,
0.0172986165,
0.0062147416,
-0.0873690844,
-0.0618492588,
0.0018449042,
-0.04034812,
0.020258503,
0.0194796026,
-0.017166907,
0.0039698463,
-0.032692112,
0.0693951547,
-0.0585349314,
0.0593951978,
0.0052045053,
-0.019845644,
-0.0164398942,
-0.0233921446,
-0.0333522446,
0.0484549813,
-0.0255089272,
-0.0038640259,
-0.0122531364,
0.0484521016,
-0.0131714521,
-0.0055180327,
-0.0079586171,
0.0224706586,
-0.0494096912,
-0.0231118798,
0.0457993597,
0.0275053438,
0.0053160526,
-0.0075404332,
-0.0120802298,
-0.1026797444,
-0.0423609242,
0.0265512969,
-0.029648317,
-0.0587734617,
-0.0336397141,
0.1062471941,
0.0181150977,
-0.067320779,
-0.0144702345,
-0.0096768066,
-0.0398638882,
-0.0267279577,
0.0106308702,
-0.0184942968,
-0.0100371204,
-0.0208642408,
-0.0049360869,
-0.0449756011,
0.0053467378,
0.0366717912,
-0.043501921,
0.0580180772,
0.0506543107,
-0.0295880344,
0.0169577934,
0.0069861738,
-0.0270340294,
0.0369433723,
0.0410701893,
0.0346223861,
0.0388358012,
0.008858839,
0.0272669718,
0.0378531031,
0.0293560885,
0.0161472578,
-0.020747982,
0.0107100969,
0.0012778869,
-0.0185090285,
0.0073606023,
0.0713573843,
-0.0206575748,
-0.0581638776,
0.1142500713,
0.0219269916,
-0.0179145895,
0.0837857053,
0.0024155308,
0.0056675468,
-0.0179684516,
-0.0014056485,
-0.0936844349,
0.0178477485,
-0.0400063768,
-0.0109054698,
-0.016865544,
0.0413404703,
-0.0070868675,
-0.0048518595,
-0.0113827167,
-0.0054347394,
0.0217214171,
-0.0097579351,
0.0347576924,
0.0338677727,
-0.0395052247,
0.0880014747,
-0.0077228514,
-0.0329969674,
-0.0189573653,
-0.0712569356,
-0.0157428309,
0.0103650717,
0.0786248669,
-0.0361042619,
-0.0085957041,
-0.0611241609,
0.00836174,
0.0480382144,
0.028977748,
0.032188233,
0.0056109647,
-0.0283309426,
-0.0192692503,
-0.0300575402,
-0.0019816747,
0.0243190229,
0.0380124971,
0.0223298501,
-0.0020629058,
-0.0266585667,
-0.0083171502,
0.0474142544,
0.029461043,
-0.0591550656,
0.0125630246,
0.0072416584,
0.0429914258,
-0.0023706199,
-0.0269784685,
0.0351104997,
0.0503702983,
-0.0123342648,
-0.0216503795,
0.003737041,
-0.0225321036,
-0.0147441383,
0.0277663618,
-0.0386701822,
-0.0326189138,
0.0701409876,
-0.039783366,
-0.006040222,
0.0481903218,
-0.0908529386,
0.0172466896,
-0.0017810939,
0.0133961327,
-0.0065193763,
0.0596362166,
-0.0219039712,
0.0643152297,
-0.0353929065,
-0.0217671692,
-0.0024404142,
0.0143338703,
-0.0015455084,
-0.0422202162,
-0.0420439802,
0.0224652085,
-0.0264482945,
-0.0079572583,
0.011680603,
-0.0372007191,
0.005846539,
-0.0285561625,
-0.0227798242,
-0.0139247812,
-0.0279824771,
0.0172502864,
0.0230067298,
0.0154190883,
-0.0025695928,
-0.0005592858,
0.0071646119,
-0.0231887177,
-0.0312873535,
0.0170417968,
0.0111768246,
-0.0419636965,
-0.0078213848,
-0.00265229,
-0.0269328784,
-0.0071276999,
0.0640007034,
-0.0186360274,
-0.0263107326,
-0.020653937,
-0.0430725254,
0.0163592845,
0.0689974353,
-0.0130260419,
-0.0648712739,
0.002330018,
0.0235999003,
0.0362524763,
0.0849742964,
0.0418219827,
0.0142735243,
0.0293428004,
0.0051918337,
-0.0196760576,
0.0282650087,
-0.0157946609,
0.0071018417,
-0.0305160675,
-0.0056956159,
0.0292118974,
0.0789383873,
0.0277513247,
-0.0086302459,
-0.0486493707,
0.0071834419,
0.016832361,
-0.0198183134,
0.0235294774,
-0.0212847143,
-0.0635587201,
-0.0526525974,
-0.0479424857,
-0.0438388214,
0.0986007527,
-0.0383694805,
0.0146160237,
-0.0362152122,
0.0074144113,
0.0173971839,
0.0220461618,
0.0025525189,
0.0007870208,
0.0266397018,
-0.0311869495,
-0.0435147248,
-0.0309840664,
0.0272772163,
-0.0272201318,
0.069388926,
0.0027693601,
0.0036022828,
-0.0016434728,
-0.0238259844,
-0.0636508539,
-0.0307186041,
-0.0150996903,
0.0426164232,
0.0149135347,
-0.0307615437,
-0.0813060105,
-0.0071828249,
0.0191097781,
0.0407496728,
-0.0279079769,
0.0239277724,
-0.0338610895,
0.0642374232,
0.0497484878,
-0.0019305919,
0.0190920979,
-0.0075131012,
0.0135413446,
0.0867061615,
0.0370443687,
0.0039258483,
-0.0222669449,
-0.042504102,
0.0174091402,
-0.0299535021,
0.0058437851,
-0.0006220334,
0.0275850631,
-0.0678061023,
-0.0266450923,
0.0693826228,
-0.0107350107,
-0.0012009406,
0.0123195527,
0.0089405095,
0.0290662218,
0.0122928359,
0.0027807218,
-0.042628359,
-0.0398210324,
0.0271073114,
0.0317508467,
0.0016287672,
-0.010807246,
0.0016357735,
-0.0989931002,
-0.0077443565,
-0.0030960462,
0.0056462814,
-0.0505409725,
-0.0185560361,
0.0030080262,
-0.0146826236,
0.0408935882,
-0.016019756,
0.0263248775,
-0.0261959042,
0.0055221366,
-0.0049572522,
-0.0371863842,
0.0090582278,
-0.0378470793,
0.0187040269,
0.0950059146,
0.0360581279,
-0.0217983089,
-0.0369086787,
0.0430168472,
0.0010673035,
-0.0167912636,
0.031515006,
0.0473495945,
-0.05498695,
-0.0086468942,
0.0122223366,
0.0381272025,
-0.0136835305,
-0.0198840015,
-0.0068534617,
0.0659417585,
0.0098216152,
-0.0025524024,
-0.0350113139,
-0.0197381899,
0.0084201945,
0.0695453659,
0.0186910648,
-0.0369966291,
-0.0518306941,
-0.0657523572,
-0.0009524138,
-0.0515094995,
-0.0360530093,
0.0182057992,
0.0294464622,
-0.0591010042,
-0.0754639059,
-0.0097285146,
-0.0244087446,
0.0008538007,
0.0103221508,
-0.0334164388,
0.0154169519,
0.0036125833,
-0.0492430218,
0.0308036003,
-0.0199304055,
0.0437419228,
-0.0445461087,
0.0125016756,
0.010110884,
-0.0112469885,
-0.021168543,
0.0356689803,
-0.0903153345,
-0.0860959068,
0.0184376519,
0.0624956451,
0.0165955275,
0.035425771,
-0.0722626746,
-0.076676704,
0.055282861,
0.0326725319,
-0.0172342211,
-0.0046586283,
0.053057462,
-0.0160471741,
0.0248636343,
0.0510071218,
-0.0331072696,
-0.015645802,
0.075268656,
0.0240269732,
-0.0089612287,
-0.0066178502,
-0.0097749904,
0.006285788,
0.0700313449,
0.0020988786,
0.0190361682,
0.0175452046,
0.0233863704,
-0.0131947482,
-0.0016607752,
-0.0165594388,
0.0517712943,
0.0242705606,
-0.0030459042,
-0.0127992108,
0.0187228043,
-0.0133243538,
-0.0068007996,
-0.0544698462,
0.0232677422,
-0.0115747619,
0.001615357,
0.009359641,
0.0095634526,
-0.0135252913,
-0.0065188585,
0.0071656257,
0.0112175308,
-0.0149918385,
0.0379092805,
0.0240679886,
-0.0152181508,
-0.0133547895,
0.0084921811,
-0.0798232555,
-0.0103220809,
-0.0352706611,
0.0352683365,
0.0119886426,
0.010992161,
0.0148150465,
0.0061142514,
-0.0315755196,
-0.0184706058,
-0.0124593228,
0.0069437837,
-0.015571625,
0.0145093175,
0.0141379172,
0.0064194733,
0.0078801168,
0.0799022913,
0.0222752336,
0.0395440646,
-0.0070769107,
-0.0379905477,
-0.0481144637,
-0.0357652344,
0.0096601788,
-0.008296608,
-0.015499739,
0.0262837913,
-0.0374430306,
-0.0852401257,
0.0251001809,
-0.0149685163,
0.0391430557,
-0.0253708214,
0.0009667736,
0.0278434213,
0.0083727613,
-0.0141340075,
-0.0340373442,
0.0486155264,
0.05154467,
-0.0354465172,
-0.0182151701,
-5.903346221e-33,
0.010899066,
-0.0040134145,
-0.0451048836,
-0.034337841,
-0.0144163547,
0.0132220574,
-0.0245355014,
-0.0356717929,
-0.0367482305,
-0.0026608463,
-0.0029855624,
0.0401769914,
-0.0118740462,
0.045031596,
-0.0339838751,
-0.0445401818,
0.0470856838,
-0.0121488208,
-0.0493352003,
0.0148875518,
0.0451491922,
0.0293192659,
0.0542784855,
-0.0255867932,
0.0115497913,
0.0033629746,
-0.0439201631,
-0.0103854202,
-0.0229060501,
0.067957148,
-0.0007028597,
0.0250445157,
0.0118543711,
-0.0295212194,
-0.0167013966,
0.0618922524,
-0.0619327836,
0.0073028249,
-0.0124086263,
0.0052218689,
-0.012617439,
-0.0429742523,
0.0657339022,
-0.0035037284,
0.0161341783,
-0.0372035727,
0.0141600557,
-0.0025394009,
-0.0440427214,
-0.0364200026,
-0.0312317815,
0.0188934356,
-0.001346504,
-0.0194673017,
-0.0101964287,
0.0398376435,
0.0208820496,
0.039705731,
-0.0809731036,
-0.0126352031,
0.0177688431,
0.0324028246,
0.0328543037,
-0.0045323279,
0.0089683486,
0.0390233248,
-0.0026367689,
-0.0017548769,
-0.0315568298,
-0.0367226824,
0.0056047984,
0.0216615517,
0.0879933462,
0.0407211967,
0.0352755189,
-0.0256023724,
-0.0616013445,
-0.0243104585,
0.0109917186,
0.0768825263,
0.0666457862,
0.0225078873,
-0.0344119109,
0.0323980674,
0.0018372796,
-0.0458544195,
-0.042983558,
0.0055208481,
0.0262315758,
0.0299891103,
-0.0515535027,
0.0230147,
0.0105696954,
-0.0624772124,
0.0363419391,
0.0388544202,
-0.0042460128,
-0.0108117247,
0.0081764916,
0.0350801721,
-0.008744562,
-0.004120314,
0.0333153531,
-0.0096506942,
0.0009380116,
-0.0123055279,
0.0628899187,
0.0411262326,
-0.0645715967,
-0.0182545092,
-0.0283690281,
0.0452576727,
0.0063504316,
0.0564049929,
0.0419431441,
0.008066928,
0.0043909322,
-0.0027059799,
0.0176626053,
0.0136846686,
-0.0229167286,
0.0555099621,
0.0056707365,
0.0104697924,
-0.0178734139,
-0.0156807769,
-0.0046841186,
0.0376402885,
0.0155388899,
-0.084822312,
-0.016729081,
-0.0048638284,
2.719e-7,
0.0275492631,
0.0530884638,
0.036397133,
-0.0112828426,
0.040029265,
0.0488587059,
0.0148083037,
0.0850780979,
0.0071958578,
0.000663907,
-0.0346693993,
-0.0031888918,
0.0459708422,
0.0030545811,
-0.0826007649,
-0.01615927,
-0.0946504325,
0.0262205563,
-0.0272398442,
-0.0179372709,
0.0263542943,
0.1448404938,
0.0147820823,
0.0076010935,
-0.0124975517,
-0.0559603311,
0.0293501131,
0.0165109504,
0.0168687552,
-0.0151149826,
0.0531028695,
0.0289124344,
0.0072002695,
0.0025260751,
-0.0529411733,
0.03117208,
0.0076611796,
0.0697701275,
-0.0220618472,
-0.0591361336,
-0.0156080406,
-0.0546589717,
-0.0076195905,
-0.0522061996,
0.0599363036,
-0.0727050006,
-0.0111910142,
0.006624565,
-0.0295875892,
0.0013255476,
0.0027718232,
-0.0461347587,
-0.0277428012,
0.0162192993,
0.0192333534,
0.011864421,
0.0106346346,
-0.0987807363,
-0.0232028272,
-0.0378280319,
-0.0551725961,
0.0088278214,
-0.0404194482,
-0.038383875,
0.038599465,
-0.0227191038,
-0.0084152259,
2.392533703e-34,
0.0279320627,
-0.0293253809,
-0.0211756658,
0.0205001626,
0.0313184001,
-0.0136016523,
0.0283716675,
-0.005944978,
0.0259631947,
-0.0493686385,
-0.0614951067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17391v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17391v1 | Unveiling the Implicit Toxicity in Large Language Models | 2023-11-29T06:42:36 | 2023-11-29T06:42:36 | Jiaxin Wen, Pei Ke, Hao Sun, Zhexin Zhang, Chengfei Li, Jinfeng Bai, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The open-endedness of large language models (LLMs) combined with their
impressive capabilities may lead to new safety issues when being exploited for
malicious use. While recent studies primarily focus on probing toxic outputs
that can be easily detected with existing toxicity classifiers, we show that
LLMs can generate diverse implicit toxic outputs that are exceptionally
difficult to detect via simply zero-shot prompting. Moreover, we propose a
reinforcement learning (RL) based attacking method to further induce the
implicit toxicity in LLMs. Specifically, we optimize the language model with a
reward that prefers implicit toxic outputs to explicit toxic and non-toxic
ones. Experiments on five widely-adopted toxicity classifiers demonstrate that
the attack success rate can be significantly improved through RL fine-tuning.
For instance, the RL-finetuned LLaMA-13B model achieves an attack success rate
of 90.04% on BAD and 62.85% on Davinci003. Our findings suggest that LLMs pose
a significant threat in generating undetectable implicit toxic outputs. We
further show that fine-tuning toxicity classifiers on the annotated examples
from our attacking method can effectively enhance their ability to detect
LLM-generated implicit toxic language. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/thu-coai/Implicit-Toxicity. | [
0.0286963023,
0.0545061827,
-0.0186611414,
0.0263967831,
-0.0099405199,
-0.0135296183,
0.0024113245,
0.0151965301,
0.0311233178,
-0.0151573168,
-0.0319791101,
0.0377479047,
-0.001531899,
0.0304988641,
0.0610440187,
0.0203466527,
0.0597685948,
-0.0427407809,
-0.0112139741,
-0.0056800735,
-0.0041772029,
-0.0041781198,
0.0353911109,
0.0383236781,
-0.0003395641,
-0.0098167611,
-0.000285958,
0.0068425643,
0.0179722533,
-0.041499313,
-0.0014315129,
0.0067719817,
-0.0050732107,
0.0569253378,
0.0000022602,
-0.0270782467,
-0.0078981956,
0.0174019784,
-0.0236034058,
0.0374280624,
0.029515354,
-0.0090576531,
-0.0346926004,
0.0307685994,
0.0046713967,
0.0007128838,
0.0626936778,
0.0441624224,
0.0739117116,
0.077646032,
-0.0014221254,
0.0319423079,
0.0522274598,
-0.0061307768,
0.0131782666,
-0.0031114551,
0.0433987938,
-0.013540444,
-0.0130615151,
0.0146481562,
0.0007750315,
-0.0165136233,
0.000187038,
-0.0415447652,
-0.0742454454,
0.0151064862,
0.0182027966,
-0.0287221074,
0.010765112,
0.0382193811,
-0.0732778236,
-0.0051224409,
0.0211925637,
-0.0119444616,
0.0040953951,
-0.0168662835,
0.0286871865,
0.0465817973,
0.0180935413,
-0.0182092153,
0.0367373489,
0.0392347649,
0.0650536269,
0.0252251923,
0.027701471,
0.05040076,
-0.003762285,
-0.0303464923,
0.0178112797,
-0.061434824,
-0.014572137,
-0.0245776549,
-0.0150016528,
-0.0151623897,
-0.0247950517,
0.0252051316,
-0.063891232,
-0.040334139,
0.0525961295,
-0.0907614455,
0.0460355841,
0.0280609336,
-0.0139676454,
0.0201437939,
-0.0219898634,
0.009360712,
-0.022013979,
0.0285149291,
0.0113555258,
0.0141764013,
0.0536737144,
-0.0171576589,
-0.0023429629,
0.0386019535,
0.0577503331,
0.0130955186,
-0.0449998565,
0.040605247,
-0.0761101544,
0.0353194363,
-0.0021878812,
0.0008395471,
-0.0307863057,
0.0479419678,
0.0137871252,
-0.0398293845,
-0.0070209159,
-0.0095556313,
-0.0219461918,
-0.0691188723,
-0.01856797,
0.0144913588,
-0.0814132392,
-0.0548395813,
0.0017052464,
0.1670889854,
0.0363021679,
-0.0131743615,
-0.0347961634,
-0.069592014,
-0.0247836392,
-0.011852283,
-0.0348422714,
-0.0463004224,
-0.056390442,
-0.0164765865,
0.0023836277,
-0.0804819688,
0.0100261485,
-0.0147777088,
-0.0538460165,
0.0775266364,
0.0025380033,
-0.0354764313,
0.003022762,
0.0236203223,
-0.0308486894,
0.0697913691,
0.0060309181,
0.0711290538,
0.007477683,
-0.0094964681,
0.0147098908,
0.0435680635,
0.0294553097,
0.0522005521,
-0.0626100525,
-0.0049286862,
0.0391167365,
-0.0377433896,
-0.000104087,
0.0670768768,
0.0001033709,
-0.0362419337,
0.0822679177,
0.0013410073,
-0.0511772856,
0.030484641,
0.0482708476,
-0.0128353378,
-0.0247695744,
-0.0367012508,
-0.0708899945,
-0.0100681959,
-0.0646423921,
-0.0486900099,
0.0303307939,
0.007983827,
0.008324841,
-0.0268388558,
0.0070771449,
-0.0238615293,
0.0436806679,
0.0068581938,
0.0423716009,
0.0312244799,
-0.0338526331,
-0.001834637,
0.0620516948,
-0.0142030371,
-0.0066363765,
-0.0662302822,
0.0365367122,
0.0484545156,
0.0426199585,
-0.0314573683,
0.0113359122,
-0.0275496002,
-0.0652703568,
0.0157501586,
-0.0014188181,
0.0005852826,
-0.007358788,
0.0018031134,
0.0090723569,
0.0060394495,
0.0369582139,
0.002207519,
0.0240015537,
0.0286533888,
-0.0014455317,
-0.0074266945,
-0.0688819066,
0.0290698223,
0.0047947573,
-0.045968242,
0.0208493955,
0.0216824636,
0.030664051,
-0.0209405459,
-0.0439515784,
0.029125642,
0.0478169993,
-0.0023280841,
-0.0280795097,
-0.0466715395,
-0.0268389825,
0.0251625869,
0.0276526008,
0.0040536369,
0.021477662,
0.0491996296,
-0.0220558569,
0.0183817986,
0.0537598394,
-0.0629511327,
0.0036055513,
0.0219392069,
0.0057936721,
-0.011459901,
0.0447504595,
-0.0268150978,
0.036637634,
-0.0180790927,
-0.0141560975,
-0.0198187903,
-0.0289873946,
-0.0089358333,
-0.0176597666,
-0.0502033532,
-0.0268303361,
-0.0278728865,
0.034119986,
0.0231987201,
0.0107473442,
-0.0010385197,
-0.0108388048,
0.0181393698,
-0.0120671634,
-0.0144960945,
-0.0017613339,
0.0110134697,
0.0176129751,
-0.0096269855,
-0.012300903,
0.0160973277,
-0.0208877157,
0.001889285,
0.0292282272,
0.0044893632,
-0.0085663423,
-0.0330217667,
-0.0281888582,
-0.0199168753,
-0.0219580848,
0.0677207187,
-0.0081413593,
-0.00095224,
-0.0021823617,
0.0276087262,
-0.0079896515,
0.0088949446,
-0.0185251553,
-0.0783347189,
0.0294236019,
-0.0049203862,
-0.0265171696,
0.0969485268,
0.0143660363,
0.0666879937,
0.0779023841,
0.0350101367,
-0.0640526116,
-0.0066570109,
-0.0045192656,
-0.057374008,
-0.0214881059,
-0.0423256345,
-0.0065135951,
0.0750716552,
0.0367977023,
-0.0186009966,
-0.0385002606,
0.0644624978,
-0.0160236619,
-0.0200580619,
0.0140450932,
-0.0616663545,
-0.0028094281,
-0.0158443879,
-0.0009533478,
-0.0891368538,
0.0788173974,
-0.0273239743,
0.0427064858,
0.0100919884,
-0.0402564108,
0.0297662802,
-0.0109555516,
-0.0229443628,
0.0227305163,
0.0538857654,
-0.0056327987,
-0.0116985142,
-0.0334404521,
0.0455879197,
-0.0126049193,
0.0287528541,
-0.0103635835,
0.0082318634,
0.0220164414,
-0.0297882222,
-0.0611902624,
-0.0453274958,
-0.0076853805,
-0.0015093569,
0.0163871311,
-0.0344686955,
-0.0137692969,
0.0056565525,
0.0367503688,
-0.039848756,
0.0085566854,
-0.0199985728,
-0.0068175369,
-0.0369824283,
0.0476608723,
-0.0952273086,
0.0474656969,
-0.0023118125,
0.0473718941,
0.0883649141,
-0.0208291169,
0.0180315468,
-0.0373369455,
0.0229519475,
0.0059700613,
-0.002155931,
0.0078359032,
0.0600428805,
-0.0062649632,
-0.0336797722,
-0.0142047266,
0.03589819,
0.0066626929,
-0.0301620495,
0.0533919297,
-0.0055721938,
0.0118872076,
0.0238587465,
0.0038360294,
-0.0782838091,
-0.009959735,
0.0214357264,
0.0252632778,
-0.0569815151,
-0.062874876,
0.0159380082,
-0.1260013729,
-0.0130979959,
0.0276919678,
-0.0138370972,
0.0091592399,
-0.0309279766,
-0.0236491822,
-0.0164264627,
0.0301107857,
-0.0291289091,
0.0015499255,
-0.0397359133,
0.0052262661,
0.0050177285,
-0.0107732061,
0.049935624,
-0.0353577323,
0.052223552,
0.0515531227,
-0.0036966323,
-0.0594917499,
0.033347588,
0.055727303,
-0.0057281549,
-0.0300693866,
0.0058737067,
0.0352480076,
0.0108954981,
-0.0341925025,
-0.0119471299,
0.0250794534,
0.0008181526,
-0.0026099873,
0.0156589895,
0.0550878048,
0.0034855574,
-0.0256574173,
-0.0292697996,
-0.0054691993,
0.0495734252,
0.0573972985,
-0.0010608642,
-0.0621710718,
-0.0170419477,
-0.0598492026,
-0.0335820653,
0.0074451771,
-0.0840319693,
-0.0038018345,
-0.0233758092,
-0.0520275123,
-0.0410535671,
0.0120930988,
-0.0193549227,
-0.0133421132,
0.0431260504,
-0.0296536088,
-0.0247099195,
0.0280967001,
-0.0244040079,
0.0013965021,
0.0163861532,
0.0435594395,
-0.0636716634,
0.0246674493,
-0.0381416082,
-0.0039111935,
-0.0261131283,
0.0569810607,
-0.0466942973,
-0.0873431787,
0.017352283,
0.0882644802,
0.0104835983,
-0.0032648605,
-0.0466945954,
-0.0491719693,
0.0932141319,
0.0426683649,
-0.0263214763,
-0.014493987,
0.0758211315,
-0.01596242,
0.0374994837,
0.0293773897,
-0.0600546077,
0.0108083915,
0.0721972361,
-0.0123867774,
-0.0608929433,
0.036364343,
0.0412505642,
0.0347487703,
0.0509507619,
-0.0258456562,
0.015915582,
0.0314437076,
-0.0010591692,
-0.0273349676,
-0.0447021388,
0.0046212533,
0.011721028,
0.0395924486,
-0.0029474639,
0.0111137712,
-0.0210306197,
0.0183437821,
0.0179751478,
-0.0004269393,
0.0274293702,
0.0610652827,
0.0318374038,
0.1057360619,
0.0153383184,
-0.0131350607,
0.0329942666,
-0.00089118,
0.029767856,
-0.0271053575,
-0.0152226472,
-0.0060101785,
0.0352374166,
-0.018544469,
0.0284761582,
0.0009646846,
-0.0163560547,
-0.0216211379,
0.027453389,
0.0153908692,
-0.0101053109,
0.037066672,
-0.0219954792,
0.0114373881,
-0.0362228267,
-0.0288188476,
-0.0313275494,
-0.0494307466,
0.0111970324,
-0.0058051725,
-0.0229136031,
0.0350788385,
0.0536662117,
0.0095401285,
0.0744653568,
0.0179757643,
-0.014148158,
-0.0058072777,
0.0044614282,
0.0533838309,
0.0164377112,
-0.0442727245,
-0.0111225145,
-0.0378448367,
-0.0856372565,
-0.0253976174,
-0.0088177901,
0.0233318917,
0.0116494559,
-0.0281307548,
0.0275323838,
0.0096246013,
0.0154807474,
-0.0817678794,
0.0120891063,
-0.0070645777,
-0.0685140267,
0.0044297278,
-6.192320569e-33,
0.0130787371,
-0.0317067578,
-0.0710487738,
0.0075788046,
0.0244724005,
0.0146829942,
-0.035874296,
-0.0061996258,
-0.0396892466,
-0.0001994851,
0.0098053226,
-0.0374149643,
-0.012082275,
-0.000603376,
-0.008276972,
-0.0141668851,
-0.0124142533,
-0.0022786837,
-0.0267588403,
0.0269425567,
0.0749726221,
-0.0148736192,
0.0068751336,
-0.0847968012,
0.0212637223,
0.0082268631,
-0.040434435,
0.0131026814,
-0.0584224612,
0.0710501149,
0.0125483219,
0.0217210203,
-0.0156293418,
-0.0140414573,
0.0063545601,
0.016597556,
-0.0066087353,
0.0138212033,
-0.0003572296,
-0.0256453995,
0.0001933929,
-0.0718966946,
0.058262147,
0.0149959242,
-0.0026244249,
-0.0164103974,
0.003518967,
-0.0095771048,
-0.0092652133,
-0.0233342145,
-0.0245700218,
-0.0069850297,
-0.0466252342,
0.0022913374,
0.0046122856,
0.0097109955,
0.0468534976,
0.0203340109,
-0.043331556,
0.0517407171,
0.0047247377,
0.0158357546,
0.054058075,
0.0231852178,
0.0005637571,
0.0318269692,
-0.018990431,
0.0047423877,
0.0164182018,
0.0055022831,
0.0125448015,
0.0206889641,
0.028501438,
0.0158291068,
0.0193937346,
-0.0369911604,
-0.0553506278,
-0.0109046027,
0.0667067543,
0.0291120987,
0.0509711877,
-0.0320247374,
-0.0764787793,
-0.0136894491,
-0.03546663,
-0.0344595276,
-0.0345048718,
-0.0425144359,
0.0112132514,
0.0047293305,
-0.0360859372,
-0.0443895422,
-0.0085215457,
-0.0655680597,
-0.0056206509,
0.0327351205,
-0.0315991268,
-0.0241936874,
-0.0359289832,
-0.0207449589,
-0.0003693195,
-0.0080182403,
-0.0254392568,
-0.0825872049,
0.0242648274,
0.0208463371,
0.0368035883,
0.0391797274,
-0.0742545053,
-0.0082586445,
-0.0286885519,
0.0493384488,
0.0269012991,
0.0547721088,
0.0198256038,
-0.0018696582,
-0.003362447,
-0.0116244806,
0.0430558212,
0.0084419828,
0.0014327239,
0.0147198355,
-0.0321000889,
0.0116983419,
-0.0239823069,
-0.0056251176,
-0.0408752151,
0.0466560572,
0.0640447363,
-0.0798480809,
-0.0094725629,
-0.0479134694,
3.119e-7,
0.0056720842,
0.0382328592,
0.0097928904,
0.0538812391,
0.0081201149,
0.0806379095,
-0.0025132678,
0.081922166,
-0.0378839076,
-0.0114289336,
-0.0269449521,
-0.01274266,
0.0321009383,
0.0227357168,
-0.0249559376,
0.0411880612,
-0.1250968724,
0.0011407371,
-0.0658231229,
-0.0045677205,
0.0185783338,
0.1150282472,
0.0311171878,
-0.0351508744,
-0.0065696435,
-0.0550618209,
0.0036134948,
-0.0230304021,
-0.0007057954,
0.0134641426,
0.0165618137,
0.039864406,
0.008095758,
0.018127799,
-0.025751736,
-0.020608874,
-0.0286824852,
0.0516171157,
0.0166591145,
-0.0311239697,
-0.0236382037,
-0.0553533807,
0.01653363,
-0.0246224701,
0.0503785461,
0.0101850359,
-0.023445297,
-0.017530119,
-0.0062189093,
-0.0347838737,
0.0385647602,
-0.0485641584,
-0.0086297058,
0.0034832726,
0.0020740395,
0.0166500043,
0.0075804912,
-0.0536299199,
-0.041446995,
-0.0179497339,
-0.0219075028,
-0.0554232858,
-0.0067218803,
0.0426439792,
0.0084743435,
-0.007955729,
0.0198680274,
3.080727789e-34,
0.0062664589,
-0.0586656593,
0.0051913843,
-0.0183905941,
0.0449063778,
0.0201035812,
0.0012005011,
0.0171325151,
0.0136204697,
-0.0326858386,
-0.0060643209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17376v1 | CESAR: Automatic Induction of Compositional Instructions for Multi-turn Dialogs | 2023-11-29T06:02:16 | 2023-11-29T06:02:16 | Taha Aksu, Devamanyu Hazarika, Shikib Mehri, Seokhwan Kim, Dilek Hakkani-Tür, Yang Liu, Mahdi Namazifar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-based multitasking has played a critical role in the success of
large language models (LLMs) in multi-turn dialog applications. While publicly
available LLMs have shown promising performance, when exposed to complex
instructions with multiple constraints, they lag against state-of-the-art
models like ChatGPT. In this work, we hypothesize that the availability of
large-scale complex demonstrations is crucial in bridging this gap. Focusing on
dialog applications, we propose a novel framework, CESAR, that unifies a large
number of dialog tasks in the same format and allows programmatic induction of
complex instructions without any manual effort.
We apply CESAR on InstructDial, a benchmark for instruction-based dialog
tasks. We further enhance InstructDial with new datasets and tasks and utilize
CESAR to induce complex tasks with compositional instructions. This results in
a new benchmark called InstructDial++, which includes 63 datasets with 86 basic
tasks and 68 composite tasks. Through rigorous experiments, we demonstrate the
scalability of CESAR in providing rich instructions. Models trained on
InstructDial++ can follow compositional prompts, such as prompts that ask for
multiple stylistic constraints. | [
0.0345848799,
0.0543502048,
0.001211227,
0.0172694065,
-0.0395165198,
0.026272187,
0.0256270245,
-0.0209365021,
0.0340025723,
-0.0359127671,
-0.0432262644,
-0.0393029675,
-0.0163602177,
0.0092991265,
0.0369424336,
-0.0703303367,
0.0278561153,
-0.0751285031,
0.000060898,
-0.0076463576,
0.0169362891,
0.0088197598,
-0.0484312363,
0.0661485642,
-0.0168068558,
-0.0410014987,
-0.0454210304,
0.0165109318,
-0.0246025529,
-0.0333546549,
0.0063462653,
0.069935739,
0.0164101385,
0.0361521989,
0.0000017984,
-0.0322221592,
0.0184188467,
-0.0157066714,
-0.0277325567,
0.0091638453,
0.0363922529,
-0.0104848538,
-0.0124521963,
0.0213409252,
-0.0182980075,
-0.0147106173,
0.0377239361,
0.0718770325,
0.0893668234,
0.086462006,
-0.0006160095,
0.0063676494,
0.023322897,
-0.0249936152,
0.007686649,
-0.0446866564,
-0.0021821551,
-0.0105361333,
0.0183934998,
0.0331318676,
0.005103481,
0.0283517092,
0.0532058664,
-0.0506850332,
-0.049444925,
0.0274850931,
-0.0427629687,
-0.0190311894,
-0.0376199298,
0.0976128504,
0.0080909105,
0.015900122,
0.0102330372,
0.0110726925,
0.0295616575,
-0.0257835183,
-0.0695770085,
0.0348405242,
-0.0158195607,
-0.0227613039,
-0.0183428936,
-0.0042608981,
-0.0091722049,
-0.0024766384,
0.000197402,
0.0403393246,
0.0257225335,
-0.0441505425,
0.0175361279,
0.0086797401,
-0.0123391468,
-0.0653736517,
0.0068853921,
0.023458533,
-0.1123037115,
0.0141674038,
-0.0552289672,
0.0143405348,
0.0225350559,
0.0017356735,
0.0479526892,
0.0325670391,
-0.0160238165,
0.0582646392,
-0.0058765057,
0.0596725233,
-0.026006259,
0.0234273039,
-0.0324655734,
-0.0018475865,
-0.0530098975,
-0.0117702726,
-0.0593430847,
0.0078013311,
-0.0303970706,
-0.0488965772,
-0.0064400109,
0.0510074683,
-0.0071099889,
0.0371778756,
0.0242673568,
0.0020966532,
-0.037748374,
-0.0184051562,
0.0077068815,
0.0210072175,
-0.0288333204,
0.0123620853,
0.0548419692,
-0.0356631912,
-0.0235282518,
0.0338183977,
0.0048073847,
-0.0207488406,
-0.0064897025,
0.0548489429,
-0.0465062298,
-0.0025065693,
-0.0034517504,
-0.0212773178,
-0.0352125913,
-0.0507416576,
-0.0074710068,
-0.0537801459,
0.0430926271,
-0.0091007408,
0.0018287242,
-0.0051277513,
0.0273456369,
0.0389944464,
0.0025608498,
0.0499498881,
0.0497989357,
0.0139469597,
0.0236126594,
0.0157082062,
-0.0477424264,
0.0731831938,
0.0324427336,
0.0267608091,
0.016599549,
0.0043074214,
0.0319045559,
0.0607810691,
0.0073130634,
0.0202071387,
0.0401174724,
0.0124542071,
-0.0057358518,
0.0469278283,
0.0099803796,
0.0924074277,
-0.0382881984,
0.0211732406,
0.0770518556,
0.016828863,
-0.0001213348,
-0.0122591741,
0.0678154156,
0.0363690071,
0.0116522508,
0.0134472344,
-0.0766167492,
0.0367240682,
0.0035004907,
0.0291450415,
0.0314351209,
0.015006084,
-0.038105391,
-0.0237989444,
0.0229618941,
0.0001085561,
0.014672284,
-0.0153297707,
0.0309042148,
0.0484028198,
-0.0732956305,
0.01009499,
0.0209523905,
-0.0578574426,
-0.0428335406,
-0.035439752,
0.0051804143,
0.0623466484,
0.0426978692,
-0.0073306472,
-0.0512054227,
-0.0427806936,
0.0587384142,
0.0464434549,
0.0452613235,
-0.0255148225,
0.0140964556,
-0.0535246655,
0.0147462515,
-0.0231308714,
0.0112791695,
0.0121165514,
0.0377976149,
-0.0263540372,
-0.0077015343,
0.0110632349,
-0.0156882294,
0.0124209207,
0.0067950054,
-0.0495320223,
0.008426398,
0.0205235351,
0.011869601,
-0.0020636311,
-0.0139837563,
-0.0072995978,
0.0183948912,
-0.0149305984,
-0.0129852751,
0.0127147092,
-0.0794927776,
-0.0715768784,
0.0101409368,
-0.0205069017,
-0.0402783304,
-0.0196125284,
-0.0145886149,
-0.0466352776,
-0.0006965946,
-0.0456106476,
0.0197728761,
-0.0174171347,
0.0141547965,
0.0369201303,
-0.0330628641,
-0.0131997736,
0.0386700034,
0.0123236515,
-0.0055299313,
0.0759074539,
0.023078924,
-0.0222243741,
-0.0497049578,
-0.0183540974,
-0.0066415956,
-0.0185834691,
0.0116204089,
-0.0038158654,
0.0494722836,
-0.0424310714,
-0.0829160213,
-0.1279070526,
0.0059748655,
-0.0272222701,
-0.0040567126,
0.0084117651,
0.0121313892,
-0.005105881,
-0.0151822139,
-0.0392103791,
-0.0302497037,
0.0074020103,
0.023637265,
0.0245689228,
-0.0007104098,
-0.016021926,
-0.0231139846,
0.0058224751,
-0.0096528791,
0.0279714819,
0.0046151159,
0.0423730053,
-0.0445624143,
-0.0017840484,
0.0204925127,
0.0225571897,
-0.0288796201,
-0.0289705377,
0.0480444841,
-0.0075558405,
0.0835560933,
0.0706837475,
0.0117565338,
0.0387782492,
0.0027784505,
-0.025735572,
-0.0507102199,
0.0592923574,
0.0007965807,
-0.0242221914,
-0.0285818912,
-0.0131573509,
0.0119511113,
0.0547240376,
-0.0045991819,
0.0293462947,
-0.0475682504,
0.0034756854,
0.0086699873,
-0.0253198761,
0.0022609083,
-0.0140023585,
-0.0599850267,
-0.001362981,
-0.0344209261,
-0.0528529845,
0.0611428805,
-0.0550551526,
-0.0661365241,
-0.0261462387,
-0.0106767183,
-0.0409361981,
0.0820798948,
0.0033996468,
0.0217797663,
0.0259457417,
-0.041731488,
-0.0563714541,
0.0385932848,
0.0187785476,
-0.0100054042,
0.0685021356,
-0.0448298566,
-0.0202343892,
-0.0107428199,
-0.0626851767,
-0.0451116189,
-0.0393606424,
0.0106478529,
-0.0075988122,
0.0649659187,
-0.044638589,
-0.0210587848,
-0.0201553162,
0.0274475627,
0.0701477081,
-0.0195865147,
-0.0100069726,
-0.0398678556,
-0.0063864603,
0.0474357568,
0.018483147,
-0.0509549156,
-0.0534989573,
0.0724882409,
0.0162229855,
0.0340281539,
-0.0267236289,
-0.0154447425,
-0.008727707,
0.0069515519,
-0.0131310867,
0.0055952114,
0.0246793646,
0.0779369771,
-0.0506882109,
-0.0283573642,
0.1141784042,
0.0201425031,
-0.070588477,
-0.0075788242,
0.0110564949,
0.0517743751,
0.0236101039,
0.0320019275,
-0.0917143077,
-0.0360487811,
0.021071393,
-0.0074662375,
0.0156214824,
-0.0007409974,
-0.0161348116,
-0.1058105826,
0.0583523139,
-0.000114601,
-0.0230290499,
-0.0144264316,
0.0033809904,
-0.006151625,
0.0047915084,
0.0225236602,
0.0186892357,
-0.0245375838,
-0.0258314703,
0.018299019,
-0.0199897345,
-0.0247676577,
0.0179353394,
-0.0308822859,
0.0600773394,
0.0283511151,
0.0172566678,
0.0242481548,
-0.0114251506,
0.0198683552,
0.0126756094,
-0.0145767089,
0.0193220526,
0.0440665185,
-0.002301211,
-0.0294238143,
-0.0202614274,
0.0628222898,
-0.0289301295,
-0.0110315923,
0.0415709876,
0.0396889374,
-0.0242395177,
-0.0081750741,
0.0007075293,
0.010281058,
0.0485473983,
0.0689328238,
0.030919306,
-0.0792046711,
-0.0222508237,
-0.0637746304,
-0.0306896679,
-0.0830993131,
-0.0195580032,
-0.0142574618,
0.0137572745,
0.030020019,
-0.0757314935,
-0.0360653661,
0.0413907506,
0.0550141484,
0.0173016712,
-0.0323384851,
0.0290340036,
-0.0036662472,
-0.004289194,
0.0036599713,
-0.0279665198,
0.0385761559,
-0.0889688805,
-0.0493731126,
0.0161822569,
-0.0338741504,
-0.0122877061,
0.0140947495,
-0.0876229554,
-0.0611972138,
-0.0351589546,
0.056956578,
0.0148697244,
0.0513218567,
-0.0201845411,
-0.008745933,
0.0015297545,
0.014391169,
-0.0410027355,
-0.0198695175,
0.0677917898,
0.0227703918,
0.0035880625,
0.0377539806,
-0.0414177291,
0.0124883549,
-0.0261311363,
0.0421862677,
-0.0396981314,
-0.0473927148,
0.0284989178,
-0.0217046589,
0.0013382034,
-0.005174038,
0.0177434646,
-0.030131707,
0.0423851684,
-0.0095976209,
-0.040439032,
-0.0660630688,
0.0157864857,
0.003536992,
-0.011362534,
0.0094381729,
-0.0122291911,
0.0019085443,
0.0273277517,
-0.0252751727,
0.0140034603,
0.0210862197,
-0.0081295082,
0.0375668071,
0.0026263546,
-0.0276157614,
0.0348406658,
-0.0066731269,
0.0263181608,
0.0000997774,
0.0977623165,
0.0294686109,
-0.0376814082,
0.0097740721,
0.0252128858,
-0.0555757582,
-0.0258930027,
0.0014624826,
0.013525351,
0.0514145195,
0.0050106058,
0.0528357327,
-0.0333619975,
0.0033075132,
-0.0096351523,
0.0431503505,
-0.0010846618,
-0.0341802202,
0.0160141923,
0.0395082012,
0.0199283678,
0.0025844676,
0.0794812441,
-0.0221509598,
0.0324213393,
0.0224819146,
0.0347293504,
-0.0576151833,
-0.073257938,
0.0142291542,
0.0193853043,
-0.0150786918,
-0.001374919,
-0.0129820546,
-0.025228763,
-0.0175686274,
0.0219122749,
-0.0118045183,
-0.026357349,
0.045218654,
0.0362953618,
-0.0038907272,
-0.0096737547,
-0.031423524,
-0.010259103,
0.0114577236,
-0.0330678225,
-0.0201078448,
-5.643408421e-33,
-0.0439520068,
-0.0226154551,
0.0446967855,
0.0265254229,
-0.0108564459,
-0.0151198264,
-0.0448806286,
0.0220497772,
0.018010512,
0.0323840939,
-0.0197528191,
-0.0024317026,
0.0071783266,
0.0426483303,
0.0205821581,
0.0020641955,
0.0430879034,
-0.0158612672,
-0.0399276651,
0.0530362613,
0.0009981696,
-0.0116143143,
-0.0039381264,
-0.0516383089,
0.040846929,
-0.0104972683,
-0.0304608848,
0.0164378881,
-0.0488106012,
0.083390452,
0.0073551573,
0.0284936298,
0.0042333133,
-0.0387757272,
-0.0230451021,
0.0599424355,
-0.0404785126,
-0.0197013393,
0.0311293658,
0.0079329889,
-0.0534950309,
-0.0234735906,
-0.0117458925,
-0.0310657006,
0.0283186864,
-0.0080074035,
0.0070612552,
0.0143696703,
-0.0106996028,
-0.0069154305,
-0.0654941499,
0.0031165718,
-0.0103899669,
-0.0870598108,
-0.0111190202,
0.0438831672,
0.0030138919,
-0.0371590517,
-0.009635685,
0.0186790135,
-0.0136158131,
0.0071444195,
0.0218731407,
0.0079125706,
-0.0087168114,
0.0539621599,
0.0019708409,
0.0267575439,
-0.0298396163,
-0.003222981,
-0.0135415159,
0.0591118485,
0.0187028889,
0.0249258373,
-0.0036310283,
0.0377748162,
0.013670289,
0.0021397048,
0.0390597545,
0.0199654829,
0.0191058088,
0.0016256383,
-0.0283951946,
-0.0111237066,
-0.0388664156,
0.0285197068,
-0.0281388983,
-0.0216102265,
0.0578530692,
0.0487261117,
0.0054946709,
-0.010493584,
0.0486511849,
0.0032444987,
-0.0250001475,
0.0168639161,
-0.0205395408,
0.048134096,
-0.0308695473,
0.0190061852,
-0.0370420516,
-0.0295427572,
0.0655612871,
0.0234530717,
0.0227833577,
0.0411846563,
0.0592598952,
0.0299211815,
-0.0863385573,
0.0080853263,
-0.0443497449,
0.0476970077,
-0.0255280826,
-0.0029460103,
0.0262845065,
-0.0158662964,
-0.0384334028,
0.0699336603,
-0.0220738556,
-0.0256606117,
-0.0622115433,
-0.0461207964,
0.0053790892,
-0.0006348994,
-0.0374911837,
0.0180826038,
-0.0217109658,
-0.0277421009,
-0.0041458607,
-0.0363621786,
0.0054923287,
0.0138871288,
2.486e-7,
-0.0098802922,
0.0560032763,
0.0250111446,
0.059154246,
0.0341688544,
0.0234981533,
-0.0383819565,
0.003050969,
-0.0101325838,
-0.002629092,
0.006089834,
0.0386171117,
0.0628815666,
0.00698215,
-0.1310683936,
-0.0276480652,
-0.0789839849,
0.0077135158,
-0.0697426796,
-0.0118419519,
0.0775758699,
0.0866054818,
-0.012923941,
0.0040060603,
0.0186498109,
-0.027667651,
0.0492706187,
-0.019632699,
-0.0028776426,
0.0234204121,
0.0090488968,
-0.0019208426,
-0.010526753,
0.0251397882,
-0.002405148,
-0.0104608806,
0.0190701168,
0.0942454264,
0.0233669113,
0.0077438196,
0.0093376497,
-0.0173072442,
-0.0027418388,
-0.0229799282,
0.0536565483,
-0.0438557602,
0.0169189591,
-0.0486184619,
0.0014932713,
-0.0336892568,
0.0033750448,
-0.0292529985,
0.0102429222,
0.0059144762,
0.0214776844,
-0.0180438571,
0.0197612531,
-0.0680140182,
-0.0363220386,
-0.0017647388,
-0.0425964259,
-0.0381577425,
-0.0507674441,
-0.0174083691,
-0.0212180819,
-0.0496453084,
-0.0135407252,
2.454412689e-34,
0.0333415903,
-0.0310464744,
0.0641497672,
0.0611332543,
0.0344081521,
-0.0034865357,
-0.0047206092,
0.0028672009,
0.034459088,
-0.1009761319,
-0.0440168902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17371v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17371v2 | Should we be going MAD? A Look at Multi-Agent Debate Strategies for LLMs | 2023-11-29T05:54:41 | 2024-03-14T10:56:50 | Andries Smit, Paul Duckworth, Nathan Grinsztajn, Thomas D. Barrett, Arnu Pretorius | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) underscore their
potential for responding to inquiries in various domains. However, ensuring
that generative agents provide accurate and reliable answers remains an ongoing
challenge. In this context, multi-agent debate (MAD) has emerged as a promising
strategy for enhancing the truthfulness of LLMs. We benchmark a range of
debating and prompting strategies to explore the trade-offs between cost, time,
and accuracy. Importantly, we find that multi-agent debating systems, in their
current form, do not reliably outperform other proposed prompting strategies,
such as self-consistency and ensembling using multiple reasoning paths.
However, when performing hyperparameter tuning, several MAD systems, such as
Multi-Persona, perform better. This suggests that MAD protocols might not be
inherently worse than other approaches, but that they are more sensitive to
different hyperparameter settings and difficult to optimize. We build on these
results to offer insights into improving debating strategies, such as adjusting
agent agreement levels, which can significantly enhance performance and even
surpass all other non-debate protocols we evaluated. We provide an open-source
repository to the community with several state-of-the-art protocols together
with evaluation scripts to benchmark across popular research datasets. | [
0.0411163419,
0.0613354594,
-0.004718157,
0.0478839651,
-0.0694552138,
-0.0217474643,
0.0295521766,
-0.0220209882,
-0.014163943,
-0.0431084037,
-0.0213397648,
-0.0285076704,
0.0006799714,
-0.0057414295,
0.0123185851,
-0.0214348957,
0.0390338711,
-0.0486336723,
0.0456438251,
-0.0597191863,
0.0101779103,
-0.010220116,
-0.0150078479,
0.0434079058,
-0.0254709441,
-0.0162685364,
-0.0306400862,
0.0051421407,
0.0233366862,
-0.0093852868,
-0.0022765195,
0.0522531234,
0.0152646694,
0.0648664311,
0.0000020375,
-0.0629107729,
-0.0022128187,
-0.0028178566,
-0.049322132,
0.0108239111,
0.0390634835,
0.0393619314,
0.0078454586,
0.0263588633,
-0.067142874,
0.0063144071,
0.0149150454,
0.0258656703,
0.0802703947,
0.0707501471,
0.0192109905,
-0.0196132883,
0.0160255954,
-0.0276953094,
-0.0203372706,
-0.0629703104,
0.0138584878,
-0.0117900614,
0.0152565604,
0.0200043973,
-0.0102572124,
0.033870507,
0.0299713705,
-0.0245641135,
-0.0376357138,
0.0174363498,
-0.0493640527,
-0.030404469,
-0.0157443043,
0.0673500821,
0.0485825986,
-0.004565272,
0.0011265601,
-0.006311093,
0.0176161714,
0.0080116987,
-0.03501435,
0.0558519997,
-0.0125155887,
0.0155847929,
-0.0000281444,
-0.0126480358,
0.01834598,
0.0175665393,
-0.033767879,
0.1004631817,
0.0009006704,
-0.0239886306,
0.0076442324,
0.0041724229,
0.0099218199,
-0.0942514241,
-0.0299261976,
0.0287231877,
-0.0660090595,
0.0291447621,
-0.0291798823,
0.0257084724,
0.0560181811,
-0.0105315931,
0.0252745673,
0.0132271694,
0.0069900686,
0.0571679398,
0.0304401368,
0.0354317427,
-0.0058768489,
0.0237514861,
-0.0014086725,
-0.0259141531,
-0.0421757437,
-0.0046239235,
-0.0288109854,
0.0215117931,
-0.0351837017,
0.0091898842,
0.0029108147,
0.027365746,
-0.0260950178,
0.0511049815,
0.0035103515,
0.0109982202,
-0.009460412,
-0.0273738131,
-0.0570239387,
0.0534296371,
-0.0760536194,
0.0244965535,
0.0566236936,
-0.0832847804,
-0.0302417036,
0.0283452552,
-0.0256670006,
-0.0103444997,
0.0056090015,
0.0531849451,
-0.0138791045,
-0.0020024288,
-0.0035605531,
-0.0430131517,
-0.0231505167,
-0.1047490686,
-0.0202572029,
-0.0642058104,
0.0505985096,
-0.0158989895,
-0.0270018447,
-0.0414840356,
0.0175969303,
0.0095582223,
0.0067499634,
0.0840863138,
0.0071991491,
0.0234702807,
0.0619275458,
0.019556025,
-0.0677300245,
0.0695200562,
0.0342957973,
-0.0014474746,
0.0529439673,
0.0166027602,
0.0181438532,
0.0273405816,
0.0172944404,
0.0250540841,
0.041026324,
0.032611914,
-0.0097147264,
0.0592802912,
0.005108797,
0.0691648275,
-0.0554310977,
-0.0694221482,
0.0787490383,
0.0495044887,
-0.0198417418,
-0.0156551078,
0.0166080892,
0.03460069,
0.0264192577,
-0.0090669012,
-0.0285020247,
0.0217154007,
0.001909349,
0.0023651042,
0.0517884679,
0.0293551069,
-0.037675757,
-0.0574273057,
0.0019650122,
0.0088295946,
-0.0086585209,
0.0393257923,
0.0126739237,
-0.014553545,
-0.035359811,
0.0321600884,
0.0213573668,
-0.0454455614,
-0.0469640903,
-0.0691468045,
0.0446599647,
0.0313280746,
0.0671368018,
0.0032674363,
-0.0397907048,
-0.0252313577,
0.0540573969,
0.0658574253,
0.0536551028,
-0.0183630381,
0.0038426414,
-0.0593787991,
-0.0389299653,
-0.0338383578,
0.0026864612,
0.0309409052,
0.0354002714,
-0.0090310043,
-0.0061651892,
-0.0018715786,
0.0073863892,
0.0102442196,
-0.0444203541,
0.0132593466,
-0.004554783,
-0.0110542225,
0.0584171563,
0.0098889871,
-0.0276282504,
0.0123925265,
0.0288517028,
-0.0098042786,
-0.0232945941,
0.0025196976,
-0.0144688971,
-0.0314194113,
0.0481811315,
-0.0158314276,
-0.0188691877,
-0.0127530498,
-0.0238584336,
-0.0333022885,
0.021643281,
-0.0211953651,
0.0082735484,
-0.0526749939,
0.005600004,
-0.0106376763,
-0.0001734124,
-0.0539276637,
0.0470678098,
0.0148522221,
-0.027884258,
0.0414768159,
0.0400419645,
0.01936947,
-0.0654173046,
-0.0125311296,
0.0377528109,
0.0306875128,
0.0281276423,
0.0301839169,
-0.0199994352,
-0.0594772622,
-0.0503785871,
-0.1012362614,
0.0041537727,
-0.0153486952,
0.0104353223,
-0.0199496336,
-0.02817115,
-0.00517871,
0.0096608242,
-0.0591271631,
0.0139626311,
0.0281842593,
0.0225650184,
0.0381729119,
0.0108861066,
-0.0055570588,
-0.0530823953,
0.0219427645,
0.0068674055,
0.0267780721,
0.0119533958,
0.0270964038,
-0.0375412032,
-0.0118690347,
-0.0760976225,
0.0072109718,
-0.0225961003,
-0.0132001638,
0.0532437749,
0.0052525448,
0.0112984059,
0.068779476,
0.0254071224,
0.0186696053,
0.020172203,
-0.0270241778,
-0.114767082,
0.0347927436,
-0.0076592746,
-0.0114722606,
-0.0473733768,
-0.0246200264,
0.0100051425,
0.0670968741,
-0.0012306896,
-0.0071122972,
-0.0419820994,
0.0587165579,
0.0247156806,
-0.0358632281,
0.0106332609,
-0.0017169253,
-0.0238000974,
0.0518536121,
-0.0274601337,
-0.0400908329,
0.1024847999,
-0.0366009474,
-0.0050267586,
-0.0411140993,
0.0094640963,
-0.0341746099,
0.0548605435,
-0.0470320769,
-0.0043396619,
-0.0059126583,
0.0223005489,
-0.055802349,
-0.0243880637,
0.0636763051,
-0.0458643995,
0.0442158505,
-0.060092587,
0.0245484076,
-0.0103075569,
-0.0546291322,
-0.0390603803,
-0.0359064154,
-0.040395081,
0.0019263796,
-0.0126895746,
-0.0059817252,
-0.0460161492,
-0.0174385794,
0.0006281163,
-0.0088807009,
0.0050183786,
-0.0080676544,
-0.0256888345,
0.0043911273,
0.036170911,
0.0632541478,
0.0402409174,
-0.0345959142,
0.0578273311,
0.0789212883,
0.0046739019,
-0.0107128182,
-0.0015164788,
-0.030732723,
0.0021345951,
-0.0197577942,
0.0053260857,
0.0011526389,
0.0530926622,
-0.0458200388,
-0.013216733,
0.0930954739,
0.0418491289,
-0.0164202936,
-0.0095351553,
-0.0452528521,
0.0725592077,
0.0041544456,
0.015389096,
-0.077727735,
-0.0377904624,
0.0028098999,
0.0399659276,
-0.0125051457,
-0.0336674303,
-0.0138199674,
-0.1023687571,
0.0449785553,
0.0030189469,
0.01596996,
0.0535868667,
-0.0140794972,
-0.0019132728,
-0.0068686539,
0.0415717401,
0.0273707826,
0.0372512937,
-0.0036391809,
-0.0076051587,
0.0053049875,
-0.0250255987,
0.0412696265,
-0.0435172357,
0.0914199874,
0.0388191864,
0.0251332652,
0.0310979392,
-0.0606639832,
0.0234258883,
0.0295146611,
-0.0275365133,
-0.0118208965,
0.0255501997,
-0.0026216367,
0.0013616619,
-0.0166517887,
0.0152010927,
-0.0026158283,
-0.0268523581,
0.0490244776,
0.0333695784,
-0.037713103,
-0.0321030244,
-0.0096272761,
0.0225387849,
-0.0036843016,
0.0939831734,
0.0241702925,
-0.0370363668,
-0.0725769103,
-0.0614157766,
-0.0196892619,
-0.0469624363,
-0.0102530625,
-0.0022332366,
0.0094415639,
0.0279114842,
-0.0561814159,
-0.0668819398,
0.0299861468,
0.0261280574,
-0.0213150214,
-0.010736865,
0.0102983648,
0.0134235984,
-0.0004910136,
0.0050990288,
-0.0413092375,
0.0077590863,
-0.0369162634,
-0.016840836,
0.0510873795,
-0.0164979305,
0.0013818345,
0.0187816136,
-0.0752605721,
-0.0943279564,
-0.0217979439,
0.0504323728,
0.0322261788,
0.0647353008,
-0.0016903294,
-0.0418964699,
0.0250631757,
-0.0034058236,
0.0133140432,
0.0317505077,
0.019652592,
0.0385041721,
-0.0241285302,
0.0493299477,
-0.0166522767,
0.0001792779,
-0.0034228177,
0.0671755224,
-0.0676064864,
-0.0579983033,
0.0144339139,
0.0072746379,
-0.0123956297,
0.0081755463,
-0.0278034322,
-0.0125387115,
0.0303140189,
-0.039489273,
-0.0304392762,
-0.0423987806,
-0.0060879043,
-0.018526841,
-0.0401014686,
0.0317746773,
-0.0100372555,
-0.0194440391,
0.0483042449,
0.0170051455,
0.0011655362,
0.0014772911,
0.0018015236,
-0.001638673,
-0.0268630479,
-0.006177898,
0.0295231063,
0.0043760007,
0.063737534,
0.0055156467,
0.071608901,
0.0363641158,
-0.0142482156,
0.0263152104,
0.0081118057,
-0.0683491006,
-0.0710916221,
0.0452964492,
0.0459800288,
0.0317775682,
0.0782224014,
0.0425283201,
-0.0222622436,
-0.0097051198,
-0.0061704293,
0.0112311998,
0.0353470072,
-0.0260552131,
0.0517574772,
0.0303174518,
-0.0354935974,
0.0053351149,
0.0653211474,
-0.0039119688,
0.0339611508,
-0.0150510212,
0.0214649662,
-0.0579449572,
-0.0706058443,
-0.0429611765,
0.0027749629,
-0.0020317796,
-0.0010123188,
-0.0590103231,
-0.0252951607,
-0.006357281,
0.0451166555,
-0.0267349239,
-0.0145858107,
0.0214614496,
0.0608553141,
0.0113052754,
-0.0306745097,
-0.0457394011,
0.0076834187,
-0.0123728793,
-0.014290723,
-0.0165436547,
-6.433260912e-33,
-0.0307972152,
-0.0286218692,
0.0660637021,
-0.0205644388,
-0.0338368155,
-0.0249898341,
-0.0347993746,
0.016249707,
-0.0422263555,
0.0138761569,
-0.0092256963,
0.0114234928,
0.0174422599,
0.0086619807,
0.0065691043,
-0.0455924682,
0.0193531662,
-0.0048635826,
-0.051738102,
0.0112922201,
0.0144320503,
-0.0381123945,
-0.0074042464,
-0.0137124313,
0.02397459,
-0.0000418051,
-0.023920197,
0.0407697074,
-0.0692584068,
0.0527050495,
0.0014771265,
0.0294683259,
-0.0034175585,
-0.0246118568,
-0.001262461,
0.0168947242,
-0.0344033949,
-0.0334945507,
0.0392894484,
-0.012926057,
-0.0410812572,
-0.0399339274,
0.0276108645,
0.0017211532,
-0.0242217351,
-0.0066295164,
-0.0084607983,
-0.0042707887,
-0.0187570862,
0.0016759731,
-0.0355346091,
0.0287936982,
-0.0164754335,
-0.0185744204,
-0.0016287159,
0.0198435634,
0.0092596449,
0.0105011379,
-0.0805740282,
0.040474426,
0.0134021956,
-0.0188877378,
0.0668078884,
-0.0034443904,
-0.0000510035,
0.0593581907,
0.0242990106,
0.0364261419,
-0.0212834068,
-0.024387883,
-0.0031963624,
0.0449569412,
0.0499407053,
0.0710309595,
-0.0371942334,
0.0025838122,
-0.0405066423,
0.0348029658,
0.0545352884,
0.0194619261,
0.022604676,
0.0058339643,
-0.0278619472,
-0.0311228875,
-0.0578100085,
0.027209172,
-0.0282029454,
-0.0293654818,
0.0424940623,
0.0151404822,
-0.019160999,
-0.0165242497,
0.0360051617,
-0.0482965261,
-0.0345993601,
-0.0013188648,
-0.0004230566,
0.0198683813,
0.0000945535,
0.0265064184,
-0.0340682715,
0.0228475798,
0.0111764353,
0.0143379271,
0.0179441851,
0.0086083841,
-0.0047844653,
-0.0279096123,
-0.0471386909,
0.0149689224,
-0.0354349241,
0.0541504361,
-0.0285126977,
-0.0132086333,
0.0090045333,
0.0055977418,
-0.0029970827,
0.020404499,
0.0065344004,
-0.0287779197,
-0.0392285213,
0.0251827985,
-0.0032080684,
-0.0000679043,
-0.0157158505,
0.0432725847,
-0.0393046439,
-0.0055776732,
0.0111573767,
-0.015310348,
-0.0029774078,
0.0054998877,
2.636e-7,
0.0175593197,
0.0487070903,
0.0227027424,
0.0224177539,
0.020475788,
0.0513724722,
-0.0205801819,
0.0069143008,
0.0043142261,
-0.0500945039,
-0.0070345942,
0.0683376193,
0.065098986,
0.0497020483,
-0.0733816102,
-0.0312861539,
-0.0463842936,
-0.0183043424,
-0.065698944,
-0.0166872777,
0.0666225478,
0.0629094541,
-0.0015118393,
0.011162526,
-0.0083445245,
-0.0183652975,
0.074340716,
-0.014903238,
-0.0225709286,
0.0663773194,
0.0282251704,
-0.0550057776,
0.0200646743,
0.0240459889,
0.0269858558,
0.0169415362,
-0.047821179,
0.0734630078,
0.01053847,
-0.0990415663,
-0.0316689275,
-0.0256310329,
0.0159574281,
-0.0516885072,
0.0543074571,
-0.0447530411,
-0.0396512374,
-0.0283807702,
-0.0017910526,
-0.0424616151,
0.0382035524,
-0.0176631585,
-0.0376573056,
0.0124096945,
0.0003915697,
-0.0066029574,
0.0243012998,
-0.0754109994,
-0.0150695257,
-0.0198963527,
-0.0561839901,
-0.080426529,
-0.0121319415,
0.0163771622,
0.0148351928,
-0.0542085581,
-0.00109565,
2.225943883e-34,
0.0556379147,
-0.0154733257,
0.0123637114,
0.0671897158,
0.0374979787,
0.0272825714,
-0.0369587652,
-0.013836463,
0.0250000376,
-0.0871502832,
-0.0052967365
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17355v1 | Are Large Language Models Good Fact Checkers: A Preliminary Study | 2023-11-29T05:04:52 | 2023-11-29T05:04:52 | Han Cao, Lingwei Wei, Mengyang Chen, Wei Zhou, Songlin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have drawn significant attention due
to their outstanding reasoning capabilities and extensive knowledge repository,
positioning them as superior in handling various natural language processing
tasks compared to other language models. In this paper, we present a
preliminary investigation into the potential of LLMs in fact-checking. This
study aims to comprehensively evaluate various LLMs in tackling specific
fact-checking subtasks, systematically evaluating their capabilities, and
conducting a comparative analysis of their performance against pre-trained and
state-of-the-art low-parameter models. Experiments demonstrate that LLMs
achieve competitive performance compared to other small models in most
scenarios. However, they encounter challenges in effectively handling Chinese
fact verification and the entirety of the fact-checking pipeline due to
language inconsistencies and hallucinations. These findings underscore the need
for further exploration and research to enhance the proficiency of LLMs as
reliable fact-checkers, unveiling the potential capability of LLMs and the
possible challenges in fact-checking tasks. | [
0.0656386316,
0.0307496525,
0.0143240858,
0.051221475,
-0.0548946299,
0.0128588621,
0.0298109353,
-0.0129773859,
0.0162721016,
-0.0683106109,
0.0029745111,
-0.0698464587,
0.0145648774,
0.0155726597,
0.0011808588,
0.0138881635,
0.0635299459,
-0.0200738702,
0.0553031601,
-0.0138782039,
-0.0076989084,
0.0287020318,
0.0014383628,
0.0279259626,
-0.017768655,
-0.0192481596,
0.0272941031,
-0.006390362,
0.0082347477,
-0.0127265733,
-0.0120058274,
0.0152438106,
0.0143221002,
0.0933275223,
0.0000018582,
-0.0440481305,
0.011100837,
0.0176005512,
-0.0614626743,
0.0448486023,
0.0285239145,
0.0112112239,
-0.0583889298,
0.0159913916,
-0.0137798656,
-0.0405283868,
0.021420544,
0.0902045816,
0.0780389458,
0.0937476084,
0.0073108543,
-0.0423903652,
0.0115169669,
0.003884885,
-0.031170845,
-0.0151757794,
0.066192314,
0.062464159,
-0.0117148263,
0.0000054618,
0.006936043,
0.0237626918,
0.0201283284,
-0.0148904379,
-0.0736697018,
0.0331431665,
-0.0542884693,
0.0002737351,
-0.0045424351,
0.0285818223,
-0.0257536564,
-0.0438695773,
-0.014571419,
0.0004201821,
-0.0256329328,
0.0105737057,
0.013939443,
0.0623309761,
-0.0467391796,
0.0068823178,
0.0390012711,
-0.0440153629,
0.0448367111,
0.0463715829,
-0.0316881686,
0.0846791044,
-0.0025245727,
-0.0461990312,
0.0012018366,
-0.004525519,
-0.0086786337,
-0.0931725353,
-0.0006743406,
0.0162638295,
-0.0245913398,
0.025350919,
-0.0113502536,
0.0373104177,
0.0229408033,
-0.0940703228,
-0.0168778989,
0.0195157416,
-0.0590813123,
0.0798365176,
-0.0348345153,
0.0392778665,
-0.0203015152,
0.0088979267,
0.0079130214,
-0.0358226709,
-0.017936226,
0.0145371184,
-0.0152582359,
0.0153473597,
0.0002511801,
-0.0118613271,
-0.0283372514,
-0.0148501256,
-0.0063160015,
0.0545388386,
-0.00304982,
-0.0146030001,
0.0053502154,
-0.0378186628,
-0.0860706642,
0.0280137435,
0.009221172,
0.021644365,
-0.0252992287,
-0.0572116598,
0.0104157841,
0.0162170883,
-0.0243155062,
-0.0128382565,
0.0272157565,
-0.0141498912,
0.0189427808,
0.0030565334,
-0.05997096,
-0.006506043,
-0.0366049148,
-0.1077930778,
-0.0186090041,
-0.0621517375,
-0.0133769801,
-0.0181394536,
0.0101508629,
-0.0003791642,
0.0261547621,
0.0128255105,
-0.0244802386,
0.0589040294,
0.01572478,
0.0142094065,
0.0195846949,
-0.004962889,
0.0128251258,
0.0572791994,
0.0389608033,
0.0235345978,
0.0506906398,
0.0364284553,
0.0066949073,
-0.0061344705,
-0.0198758356,
0.0162986405,
-0.0065404288,
0.0098331505,
-0.0015788696,
-0.0033485678,
0.0027214689,
0.0693285167,
-0.0051648393,
-0.0101067284,
0.067142278,
-0.0197728034,
0.0107354028,
0.0068661077,
0.0731915534,
-0.0140137877,
0.0372302942,
0.0068723024,
-0.0486398004,
0.0136961434,
-0.0211865306,
0.0142868673,
-0.0055285892,
0.05047087,
-0.0191426687,
-0.0565961786,
-0.0545264371,
0.0171186458,
-0.0241282452,
0.013916079,
0.0228781924,
-0.0216496121,
-0.0248031411,
0.0492390282,
0.02969121,
-0.0254906341,
-0.0224163122,
-0.0677247718,
0.0105482088,
0.0540266298,
0.0484887734,
-0.0003172898,
0.0012985851,
-0.0382036716,
0.0018920382,
0.0599155463,
0.0844701678,
0.0011185639,
-0.0225328859,
-0.0221292228,
0.0191132687,
-0.0230631717,
0.0493643358,
-0.0018392692,
0.0438532829,
0.0296685062,
-0.0026922382,
-0.0101638082,
-0.0504381321,
0.0254326072,
-0.0179851055,
-0.0022758422,
-0.0133351889,
0.001849586,
0.0063266326,
0.0131644923,
-0.0512233265,
-0.0002965018,
0.0032555081,
-0.0153584508,
-0.033315029,
-0.012574885,
0.0043954146,
-0.0205293186,
0.0726140514,
0.0222259145,
-0.0488398634,
0.0377481207,
-0.0343428664,
-0.0124466084,
-0.032575164,
-0.0100032585,
0.0236472879,
-0.0709400401,
0.037968304,
-0.0201590396,
0.0347432457,
0.0227321424,
0.0868851319,
-0.0270720385,
0.0084148785,
-0.0075252308,
0.0201145876,
0.0266836602,
-0.0291773286,
-0.0596020259,
0.0268194377,
0.0233577415,
0.0260515008,
-0.0038890976,
-0.0251912586,
-0.0067673787,
-0.019061977,
-0.058293689,
0.0087076323,
-0.0331118554,
-0.0153460186,
0.0054399837,
-0.0394984037,
-0.0099594882,
0.0304232165,
-0.0028494331,
-0.0052279732,
0.0257764645,
0.0009414131,
0.030711703,
-0.0270646419,
-0.0146627109,
-0.0146314194,
0.0266798194,
-0.0236167181,
0.0166445319,
0.0288737714,
-0.0329812504,
-0.0488141067,
0.0324295387,
-0.0805748701,
0.0257849954,
-0.0044415165,
-0.0459970348,
0.0129822763,
0.0169275776,
0.0346130989,
0.0707681924,
0.0162859317,
0.0179307647,
0.0838739946,
-0.0237672757,
0.013965738,
0.0380650274,
0.0071510724,
-0.0096649108,
-0.0324528851,
-0.0454400443,
0.0020378456,
0.024716882,
0.0301816799,
-0.0138180014,
-0.0077194581,
0.0155044859,
-0.0267338585,
-0.0015811997,
0.0215849821,
-0.0153506985,
-0.0242527276,
0.0376066752,
-0.0332994983,
0.0025325718,
0.0769188255,
-0.0468284339,
0.0277087167,
-0.0344018899,
-0.0224728547,
-0.0152541138,
0.0387539081,
-0.02358252,
0.0271946918,
-0.0209857188,
0.0150044542,
-0.0024930676,
-0.0247614607,
0.0193687771,
-0.0467062779,
0.0308279656,
-0.0353493094,
0.0283420216,
0.0163141638,
-0.020684436,
-0.0505457036,
-0.0523400493,
-0.0680698454,
0.0090135001,
-0.0234938953,
-0.0160728265,
-0.0574765652,
0.0390975289,
0.0531255044,
0.0306185279,
0.0096870549,
0.0099462289,
0.0185430944,
-0.0116343545,
0.0288752839,
0.0394147672,
0.0737468228,
-0.0048852498,
0.0544263832,
0.0658657253,
-0.007021076,
0.0143717155,
-0.0213494636,
-0.0440620184,
-0.0221184995,
-0.0238894559,
-0.000173457,
-0.016127266,
0.0288168862,
-0.0768654495,
-0.0129904989,
0.1075687632,
0.0343739651,
0.0305360761,
-0.0083444305,
0.0157615151,
-0.0346354991,
0.0264821593,
-0.0069135069,
-0.0937552527,
-0.0023225492,
0.0049242103,
-0.0456086062,
-0.0348072089,
-0.0076428261,
-0.0399626717,
-0.1210141703,
0.0574300848,
0.0002570967,
0.0035669426,
-0.048909951,
-0.0293239672,
0.0005794461,
0.0066340724,
0.0297924224,
0.0247202255,
0.0259382501,
-0.0637720823,
-0.009672014,
-0.0148986978,
-0.05816257,
0.0839025974,
-0.0466855466,
0.0617179126,
0.0192077104,
0.0459473468,
-0.0040614121,
-0.0177050419,
0.0091818525,
0.0138484612,
-0.0308795255,
0.0190942027,
0.0229869429,
-0.0273100436,
-0.0071945046,
-0.0150339985,
-0.0159125514,
0.0297947098,
0.0009833954,
-0.0073506068,
0.0489581525,
-0.0278017092,
-0.0464362502,
0.0047088405,
0.0376271047,
-0.0208683684,
0.1022010297,
-0.0071398416,
-0.001373802,
-0.0301371701,
-0.0214219987,
-0.0720540807,
-0.0139462315,
-0.0464024507,
0.0768589675,
-0.0016775462,
-0.0273321234,
-0.0652757958,
0.007845345,
-0.0005556429,
0.0180547107,
-0.043916814,
0.005402681,
0.0467140861,
0.0084224939,
0.0044123498,
0.0003401389,
-0.0575375035,
0.0355738364,
-0.026229592,
0.0182861183,
0.0515946075,
-0.0185479689,
-0.0017729464,
0.0234365445,
-0.0880908594,
-0.0506813079,
0.0172848813,
-0.0075206007,
0.0180754624,
0.0441906303,
-0.068657428,
0.0074974499,
0.0220591687,
0.0096714487,
-0.0483253039,
0.0346111432,
0.003364126,
-0.0043715248,
0.0093285441,
0.0096760755,
-0.0369216204,
0.016604647,
0.019244602,
0.013603962,
-0.0309470911,
-0.0427102968,
0.0468073077,
0.04000175,
0.0127027808,
0.0139541654,
0.0159091428,
-0.0423804522,
0.0280222706,
-0.0324979611,
-0.0479452647,
0.0169626623,
0.0132806702,
0.0205092449,
-0.0087324847,
-0.0342380814,
-0.0072669247,
-0.0320390053,
0.0326552764,
0.0087054009,
-0.0222135372,
-0.0088666473,
0.0175539479,
0.0156850386,
-0.0476899892,
-0.0527839884,
0.0112280808,
0.0031271889,
0.0079662474,
0.0136046056,
0.0377895646,
0.0147137837,
-0.0315846913,
-0.0002079413,
-0.0401438288,
-0.0888008326,
-0.0402294546,
-0.0227225479,
0.0186461546,
0.0871578902,
-0.0100195734,
0.0200950559,
-0.0656751171,
-0.0252771694,
-0.0242912229,
-0.0237744451,
0.0495453551,
-0.0190767106,
0.0252480246,
0.0118802609,
-0.0434654951,
0.021210961,
0.0361413956,
0.021642331,
0.0719261467,
0.0396653935,
-0.0437516272,
-0.040169213,
-0.0695404932,
-0.0633290112,
-0.0174252186,
-0.0256496035,
0.0086366646,
-0.0857269242,
-0.0569941215,
0.0093723563,
0.0268260464,
0.0081317108,
-0.0046088137,
-0.0354106352,
0.0720456317,
0.0365837216,
-0.0138888191,
-0.0586409234,
-0.0065623117,
0.0204535667,
0.0172897298,
0.0139991557,
-6.252654286e-33,
-0.0294640344,
-0.0417248905,
0.0329723768,
-0.0337173752,
-0.0127950255,
0.0033357702,
-0.0328056104,
-0.0186143965,
-0.0711748004,
0.0374467187,
0.0094851134,
0.053481061,
0.0213491619,
-0.0195750706,
-0.0266401451,
0.0124666719,
0.0799364671,
0.0136578297,
-0.0210211724,
-0.0238181185,
0.0605628639,
-0.0368144736,
0.0443792157,
-0.0593752787,
0.0258032903,
-0.0070710648,
-0.0423607975,
0.0353229903,
-0.0493601151,
0.0607287623,
-0.0007205319,
0.0372503512,
0.035376586,
-0.0366751961,
0.0169145297,
-0.0294453725,
-0.0759696066,
0.0028702477,
0.0515126251,
0.0113835512,
0.040201176,
0.0063221473,
0.0221471731,
-0.0048870398,
0.0162722655,
0.0098444596,
0.0116441669,
-0.0484213009,
0.0162886325,
0.0037828276,
-0.0432590321,
0.0410197638,
0.0390893444,
0.01478968,
-0.027134547,
-0.0175438281,
-0.0085325073,
-0.0153951468,
-0.0884758383,
0.0109722773,
0.0100529445,
0.0172200594,
0.0436108783,
-0.0280894451,
-0.018190708,
0.0480772592,
-0.0177797452,
0.0181081649,
-0.0693521574,
0.0040583978,
0.0248331539,
0.0358343124,
0.0247334484,
0.0922090039,
-0.0090391003,
-0.0335161127,
-0.0807352588,
-0.0038732954,
0.0476424582,
0.0498753525,
0.0402904525,
-0.0163642839,
-0.0480518416,
-0.0007162257,
-0.021025097,
0.0452889763,
-0.040149428,
-0.0046209577,
0.0183024891,
0.0236032642,
-0.0147642978,
-0.0036455735,
0.0245656315,
-0.0529827289,
-0.0027647906,
0.0309293419,
-0.022175882,
-0.0038517013,
-0.0193376523,
0.0335276201,
-0.0726485401,
0.0104044704,
-0.0018985285,
0.015589417,
-0.0337920487,
0.0182697624,
0.0264341477,
0.0062747132,
-0.0647963509,
0.0366935432,
-0.0180345848,
0.0163282603,
0.0213786177,
0.0033980098,
0.0178017803,
-0.0055571897,
-0.0108941123,
-0.0071993447,
0.0051790872,
0.0013458106,
-0.0106133185,
0.0176496971,
-0.0044398783,
0.042107597,
-0.0301299207,
0.025007261,
-0.0426986031,
0.015947083,
0.0064531569,
-0.0602249056,
0.0040660133,
0.0189502873,
2.538e-7,
-0.0009793108,
0.0579509921,
-0.0070434199,
0.0419279262,
0.0009102054,
0.0223079566,
-0.0148867732,
-0.021885192,
-0.016539434,
-0.0536774136,
-0.0321527906,
0.0628338531,
0.0469174385,
0.0693605021,
-0.0394925848,
0.0389651954,
-0.0577879213,
-0.0222307965,
-0.0560471527,
-0.0217775702,
0.0005086701,
0.0852078646,
0.037271969,
-0.0088338032,
-0.000780943,
-0.0756785795,
0.0376139246,
0.0533632301,
-0.0678359121,
0.0434344374,
0.081406638,
0.0525963269,
0.0009422028,
0.0286565591,
-0.0036975916,
0.0218286384,
-0.011739295,
0.0731705576,
0.0001145546,
0.0048068543,
-0.0463843197,
-0.0386129729,
-0.0039885421,
-0.0698752552,
0.0778066739,
-0.0017384795,
-0.0199917946,
-0.0532576963,
0.0139729092,
0.0068511935,
0.0146075096,
-0.0142653007,
-0.0152521562,
0.0182765555,
-0.0088180527,
0.0071296487,
0.0035257586,
-0.0326204263,
-0.0277459044,
0.0149965724,
-0.0368987359,
-0.0896599963,
0.038968239,
-0.0205294527,
0.0416896194,
-0.056903217,
0.0202156976,
2.167087202e-34,
0.0327613242,
-0.0065205023,
-0.0163318459,
-0.0080340374,
0.0747383535,
0.0436569341,
-0.0289690886,
-0.0270049889,
-0.0217546802,
-0.0333523266,
-0.014094701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03742v1 | Clinical Risk Prediction Using Language Models: Benefits And Considerations | 2023-11-29T04:32:19 | 2023-11-29T04:32:19 | Angeela Acharya, Sulabh Shrestha, Anyi Chen, Joseph Conte, Sanja Avramovic, Siddhartha Sikdar, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Sanmay Das | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The utilization of Electronic Health Records (EHRs) for clinical risk
prediction is on the rise. However, strict privacy regulations limit access to
comprehensive health records, making it challenging to apply standard machine
learning algorithms in practical real-world scenarios. Previous research has
addressed this data limitation by incorporating medical ontologies and
employing transfer learning methods. In this study, we investigate the
potential of leveraging language models (LMs) as a means to incorporate
supplementary domain knowledge for improving the performance of various
EHR-based risk prediction tasks. Unlike applying LMs to unstructured EHR data
such as clinical notes, this study focuses on using textual descriptions within
structured EHR to make predictions exclusively based on that information. We
extensively compare against previous approaches across various data types and
sizes. We find that employing LMs to represent structured EHRs, such as
diagnostic histories, leads to improved or at least comparable performance in
diverse risk prediction tasks. Furthermore, LM-based approaches offer numerous
advantages, including few-shot learning, the capability to handle previously
unseen medical concepts, and adaptability to various medical vocabularies.
Nevertheless, we underscore, through various experiments, the importance of
being cautious when employing such models, as concerns regarding the
reliability of LMs persist. | [
0.0286983903,
0.0766465589,
-0.0152440686,
-0.0407935083,
-0.0152072636,
0.033666905,
-0.0047056526,
0.0294549316,
0.0368628912,
-0.0324835032,
0.0161199048,
-0.0473820046,
0.002914445,
0.0336553305,
-0.02743138,
-0.0464338064,
0.011980827,
-0.0161806345,
0.0257177446,
0.0271915365,
-0.0312239584,
0.0171741918,
0.0029421751,
0.0552092083,
0.0189429894,
0.0166059155,
0.0312155932,
-0.0049463869,
0.0145574892,
-0.0650948435,
-0.004997923,
0.014723056,
-0.0110309822,
-0.0441280752,
0.0000020007,
-0.0547362454,
-0.0436477996,
0.0270929597,
-0.0227430034,
-0.0815239996,
0.054141067,
-0.0733858198,
0.0169630423,
0.0036355846,
-0.0274391733,
-0.0567946918,
0.0296450201,
0.0380249135,
0.0330751836,
0.073847957,
-0.0384010337,
0.0227165055,
0.0249591749,
-0.0150008975,
0.0428847894,
-0.0506480485,
0.0826979056,
0.0059010047,
-0.0066968733,
-0.014295904,
0.0100612193,
0.0455150343,
-0.0454356447,
0.0405166894,
-0.0044110529,
0.0296303239,
-0.0065666367,
0.0049964036,
0.0070612007,
0.0408604704,
0.0006328935,
0.0119855925,
0.0238643307,
-0.0073857633,
-0.0009367673,
0.0366218314,
-0.0210420303,
0.0083174333,
-0.0225154217,
0.0133289937,
0.0216951575,
0.0131943179,
0.0358233377,
-0.0043529775,
0.004623055,
0.042745851,
0.0059979269,
0.0095408969,
0.028661577,
-0.0189366993,
0.0260991547,
-0.0438119732,
0.0036415525,
0.0293334294,
-0.0093148239,
0.0552772507,
-0.0299106091,
-0.0114200069,
0.0766598433,
-0.0673111454,
0.0368763804,
-0.0056471289,
0.0320420004,
0.0386446603,
0.0043142438,
-0.0222661756,
0.0162715223,
0.032588888,
-0.0351531804,
-0.0057472577,
-0.0662724301,
-0.0001984347,
-0.0065857475,
0.0354382358,
0.0630750656,
0.0043008835,
-0.0684248209,
-0.0005072168,
-0.0020986642,
0.0020143576,
0.0101686521,
-0.0118447263,
-0.0293507483,
-0.0084744031,
-0.0318989009,
-0.054658398,
0.0607843362,
0.0247098617,
-0.0045493864,
-0.0314500891,
0.0323972553,
0.0064394698,
0.0139324479,
-0.0266609471,
0.00826314,
0.0839458928,
0.0628542975,
-0.0176600497,
-0.0322386026,
-0.0306620486,
-0.0381533168,
0.0211416539,
-0.0000396814,
-0.0389438309,
0.0051614363,
0.0103602773,
0.0035503528,
-0.0932245478,
0.0143729243,
0.0131228231,
-0.0909346491,
0.0773960426,
-0.0527367666,
0.00686651,
0.0005267774,
0.0260052029,
-0.0280573927,
0.0028612246,
0.0299855545,
-0.0320067033,
-0.0016706084,
-0.0205683317,
0.022432901,
0.0157064553,
0.0234653521,
-0.0177980289,
-0.024455905,
0.0077925203,
0.0063909413,
0.0196306724,
-0.0200432427,
0.0535703823,
0.0396427736,
-0.0089544356,
0.0459463149,
0.0381056927,
0.0362473354,
0.0031524976,
0.0123653216,
-0.0330423228,
-0.0357656516,
-0.0556516796,
0.005914283,
-0.0216891579,
-0.0119937724,
-0.005062677,
-0.0284746289,
-0.03472488,
-0.0179303363,
-0.0070405686,
-0.0710206032,
-0.0181903988,
0.0103754047,
-0.0202880371,
0.0330509581,
0.0007060704,
-0.0210693479,
0.0804711208,
0.0672735274,
0.0137876607,
-0.0174175072,
-0.060591314,
-0.0323516577,
0.0849948153,
0.0291352589,
-0.0419705659,
-0.0228462983,
-0.0342318639,
-0.0122717256,
-0.032353662,
0.0186245237,
-0.0066297771,
0.0340025201,
0.0080895815,
0.0059084436,
0.0333899595,
0.0435472131,
-0.0134955663,
-0.0140762236,
0.0523495413,
0.0001223844,
-0.054881867,
-0.0482870191,
0.0590294376,
-0.0535976328,
-0.035506051,
0.0241140816,
0.0002754728,
0.0384356007,
-0.0216029976,
0.0039630476,
0.0360778943,
0.0067632478,
-0.0314069875,
-0.0618820526,
-0.0077208402,
-0.0157537777,
-0.0057488582,
0.0017809579,
-0.0089143571,
0.0432891361,
-0.0364095829,
-0.0375318266,
0.012556022,
-0.0359753072,
-0.044607088,
0.0076642437,
0.0025937052,
0.0023450346,
0.0463463776,
-0.0043443684,
-0.0347248875,
0.0130692618,
-0.0113333603,
-0.0210670736,
-0.0182564557,
-0.0856084004,
-0.0015425519,
0.005006731,
0.0031536056,
-0.028364988,
-0.0251078475,
0.029524276,
-0.0095400279,
-0.0068006469,
-0.0004030428,
0.0193174463,
-0.0690976977,
-0.0055643464,
0.012245195,
0.0374864303,
0.0197032411,
0.0158062074,
-0.0081158802,
-0.0210943352,
-0.0452222079,
-0.0134840086,
-0.0116490889,
0.0338039324,
0.0435119942,
0.0559718087,
0.0181694645,
-0.0144144418,
-0.0092943814,
-0.0471003689,
0.0684128404,
-0.0055139107,
-0.0357917883,
-0.0169605166,
0.0171137806,
-0.0335326344,
-0.0160686877,
0.0062431255,
0.0200606752,
-0.0408378877,
-0.0412583165,
-0.0218657497,
0.0019347951,
-0.0139194513,
0.0341199264,
0.0573176257,
-0.0146184238,
-0.0025695774,
-0.0019563767,
-0.0544495545,
-0.0300165229,
-0.0020458556,
-0.0677540824,
0.0139436964,
0.0392145663,
0.0432166122,
-0.0208941568,
-0.0412623063,
0.011975578,
-0.041546423,
0.0337494649,
-0.0586288907,
0.0169001278,
-0.0191633962,
0.0496028848,
0.0076538566,
-0.0390083306,
0.0790118352,
0.0123771131,
0.0837355107,
-0.020323474,
-0.0453362465,
-0.0404889584,
0.021890074,
-0.0022901881,
0.0267419182,
0.0538692251,
-0.0120338928,
0.0045948112,
0.0041061928,
0.0268721953,
-0.0566499196,
0.0390913188,
-0.0269405525,
0.0132071478,
0.0311952475,
-0.0171444044,
-0.0369746573,
-0.0087562855,
-0.0124033513,
0.0405160598,
-0.0281634405,
0.0401662998,
-0.0657588467,
0.0436610766,
-0.0471793152,
0.0521777235,
0.0493053943,
-0.0361944251,
0.03641738,
0.0088250842,
0.0320840999,
-0.0606259406,
-0.0048543592,
-0.0275105517,
0.0253564809,
0.0332210399,
-0.0112198517,
0.0296804179,
0.0152159799,
0.0209300313,
-0.0061219516,
-0.0546525344,
-0.0205037221,
0.058519993,
-0.0029453675,
-0.0504839346,
-0.007828909,
0.0886818469,
0.0214199387,
-0.016731916,
0.0266159996,
-0.0042867847,
-0.0514143892,
-0.0333107188,
0.0077142674,
-0.0308084283,
-0.0252133757,
-0.0079401778,
0.0158871189,
-0.0131814899,
-0.0661803707,
0.0221190676,
-0.020627927,
-0.0042331908,
-0.0028000625,
-0.0390296318,
-0.0275158416,
-0.0614237972,
0.0304529741,
-0.0589869246,
-0.030152902,
-0.0590149425,
-0.0334876776,
-0.0330250114,
0.0054551894,
-0.1085315794,
-0.0707454383,
0.0445484333,
0.0061943396,
0.0326545425,
0.0582162403,
0.0422395319,
-0.0396753512,
-0.012978958,
-0.0142109049,
0.0059756408,
0.0181832388,
0.0058463654,
0.0968620032,
-0.001032165,
0.0122492407,
-0.0248754285,
0.0172755308,
-0.0166521557,
-0.0482084677,
0.0026371188,
0.0841610879,
-0.0350758955,
-0.0601067841,
-0.0402860008,
-0.0005706082,
0.0499756411,
0.0570115931,
-0.0272088125,
-0.0307978373,
-0.0043113194,
0.0134130614,
0.0142164258,
0.0319125056,
-0.0051777731,
0.0460828617,
-0.0449757017,
-0.0541872606,
-0.0710838735,
-0.0041723638,
0.0036428235,
-0.0488561839,
0.043398127,
0.038124267,
0.0405884758,
-0.0132250804,
-0.0618410408,
0.030723501,
0.0050995853,
0.0240343865,
-0.0186053216,
-0.0082868794,
0.031504523,
0.0082840854,
-0.0157803074,
-0.0049946019,
-0.0320023522,
-0.0176658016,
-0.0124577247,
0.0575912297,
0.0134633379,
-0.0199863203,
0.0049989172,
-0.0100307986,
0.0595650561,
0.0313502029,
-0.0412708335,
-0.0588900261,
0.0032506594,
-0.0196348634,
-0.0055057099,
0.0324262455,
-0.0137838926,
0.0094995368,
0.0264645927,
-0.0107784206,
-0.0176282004,
-0.0338364169,
0.007575104,
0.0150324376,
0.0637551993,
0.0044252421,
-0.049514439,
-0.008468613,
0.0224673934,
-0.0057005882,
0.015185778,
-0.0100130616,
-0.0070414068,
0.0281890202,
-0.0022034675,
-0.0312551819,
0.0001412619,
-0.0517189875,
-0.0244971961,
-0.051734332,
0.05597407,
0.0194117967,
0.0128715709,
0.0665003732,
0.0063845119,
0.0139849018,
-0.0022507187,
0.0157683697,
0.0059025325,
-0.0027478633,
0.0225764476,
-0.0210923366,
0.0545789637,
-0.0071637747,
0.0203891732,
-0.0255997926,
-0.0379878469,
-0.0353634171,
-0.0163878165,
-0.0031670565,
-0.0063323318,
0.0309388619,
-0.0561253279,
0.0028483742,
-0.0479900427,
0.0506367013,
-0.0075937309,
0.0105564203,
0.0617968142,
0.009504904,
-0.023648724,
0.0080854855,
0.0975631997,
0.0387396216,
0.0534453094,
-0.0134921111,
-0.0592775121,
-0.0152663337,
0.0120690661,
0.0688528344,
-0.002719135,
-0.0671968758,
0.0071377074,
-0.0796919689,
-0.0772877559,
0.0571724214,
-0.0645102039,
-0.0103073856,
0.0130081521,
0.0361183062,
0.0338677652,
0.0267855115,
0.0156719442,
-0.049693536,
0.0109646562,
-0.029440945,
-0.0065442943,
0.0117482506,
-5.702072201e-33,
0.0031047841,
-0.0262736771,
0.0030460919,
0.0044438802,
0.0362804681,
0.0236602407,
-0.0410366133,
-0.0084709916,
0.0312144086,
0.0358762406,
0.0138617214,
-0.0134768235,
-0.0087581566,
0.0356218517,
0.0242600795,
-0.0341352038,
-0.0009166875,
0.0243993718,
0.0001680632,
0.008026829,
0.0020844114,
0.0558208041,
0.0273598041,
-0.0893264189,
0.025179904,
0.0300565436,
-0.0050803833,
-0.0123749701,
0.0158394445,
0.0576517992,
-0.0169285592,
0.0399500579,
0.0453529544,
-0.044225134,
0.0011683258,
0.0143769579,
-0.044468455,
-0.0218249336,
0.0007707629,
-0.0489777029,
0.0265856106,
-0.0481323525,
0.0392882787,
-0.0098692225,
0.005951372,
-0.0348954089,
0.0353278592,
-0.0443656184,
-0.0452768132,
-0.0812427476,
-0.0257245842,
0.0566898547,
-0.0059588933,
0.0181203447,
0.0116830245,
0.0023024452,
-0.0355219953,
0.0110003827,
-0.0242341328,
-0.0028331296,
-0.0044762827,
-0.004749313,
0.0090940297,
-0.0250865035,
-0.0366653912,
0.0668182969,
-0.0231986661,
-0.0261226632,
-0.0307668075,
0.0135358907,
-0.0449626707,
0.0700392425,
0.0002265393,
0.0083895447,
0.0044810204,
-0.0380720906,
-0.1140681133,
0.0576811582,
-0.0962813944,
0.0319419913,
0.0487201065,
-0.043845281,
-0.0570675954,
-0.010410971,
-0.0406870209,
0.0215961225,
-0.0181725938,
-0.0237450525,
0.0196030121,
-0.0102770589,
0.005541408,
0.0126257967,
-0.0126998397,
-0.0426155776,
-0.0304227695,
-0.0135264229,
0.0225025509,
-0.0333808884,
-0.0426096171,
0.0210288391,
-0.0398624539,
-0.0172438137,
0.019906085,
-0.0098292334,
0.0538133867,
0.0112779429,
0.0781923234,
-0.0105210599,
-0.0783611462,
-0.0279009156,
0.035308376,
-0.0106412424,
-0.0090371156,
0.0520469025,
0.0437608622,
0.0225707274,
0.0084913988,
0.0581325591,
0.0197487511,
-0.0179890785,
-0.0064906836,
-0.0130987745,
-0.0070315972,
-0.0261079855,
-0.0443405025,
-0.0229068045,
-0.0173338968,
0.0083581051,
0.0624610931,
-0.0252536405,
-0.0114250574,
0.0026195995,
2.823e-7,
0.1290126592,
0.0576279722,
-0.0468295515,
-0.0176509749,
0.0301165357,
0.0257695187,
-0.0055854577,
0.0299708582,
0.0197491087,
0.0072900644,
0.0592176914,
0.0011014671,
0.0420801118,
0.0547775254,
-0.0431951992,
-0.0447895639,
-0.0572241731,
-0.0333692878,
-0.0187201835,
-0.0040926603,
0.0900359228,
0.0686350465,
-0.0211528521,
-0.0387942232,
0.0019871008,
0.0104869176,
0.0348776542,
-0.0646859705,
0.0057343398,
0.0119076613,
0.0020456961,
0.053199891,
-0.0057668793,
0.0807327703,
-0.0362066627,
-0.022241408,
0.004724721,
0.1015374959,
-0.0422501639,
0.0206188206,
0.003638101,
-0.0189373586,
0.0464231446,
-0.0324452966,
0.0754957646,
-0.0505226515,
-0.0477707721,
-0.0020118563,
-0.004750228,
0.0163817517,
0.0539993234,
-0.0101695256,
-0.0301594529,
0.0103593497,
0.0275892671,
0.0467618555,
-0.0274203625,
-0.0619691238,
-0.0164099615,
0.0574320294,
0.0129806688,
-0.041985441,
0.0586425997,
-0.0102987643,
0.0165115129,
-0.1115427613,
0.0688074008,
2.444157879e-34,
0.0067834305,
0.021295961,
-0.0439346284,
0.0054229521,
0.0298331529,
-0.0003553559,
0.0439251177,
0.0086375121,
0.0090057524,
-0.0741182491,
-0.0033346883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17352v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17352v1 | Efficient Stitchable Task Adaptation | 2023-11-29T04:31:35 | 2023-11-29T04:31:35 | Haoyu He, Zizheng Pan, Jing Liu, Jianfei Cai, Bohan Zhuang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | The paradigm of pre-training and fine-tuning has laid the foundation for
deploying deep learning models. However, most fine-tuning methods are designed
to meet a specific resource budget. Recently, considering diverse deployment
scenarios with various resource budgets, stitchable neural network (SN-Net) is
introduced to quickly obtain numerous new networks (stitches) from the
pre-trained models (anchors) in a model family via model stitching. Although
promising, SN-Net confronts new challenges when adapting it to new target
domains, including huge memory and storage requirements and a long and
sub-optimal multistage adaptation process. In this work, we present a novel
framework, Efficient Stitchable Task Adaptation (ESTA), to efficiently produce
a palette of fine-tuned models that adhere to diverse resource constraints.
Specifically, we first tailor parameter-efficient fine-tuning to share low-rank
updates among the stitches while maintaining independent bias terms. In this
way, we largely reduce fine-tuning memory burdens and mitigate the interference
among stitches that arises in task adaptation. Furthermore, we streamline a
simple yet effective one-stage deployment pipeline, which estimates the
important stitches to deploy with training-time gradient statistics. By
assigning higher sampling probabilities to important stitches, we also get a
boosted Pareto frontier. Extensive experiments on 25 downstream visual
recognition tasks demonstrate that our ESTA is capable of generating stitches
with smooth accuracy-efficiency trade-offs and surpasses the direct SN-Net
adaptation by remarkable margins with significantly lower training time and
fewer trainable parameters. Furthermore, we demonstrate the flexibility and
scalability of our ESTA framework by stitching LLMs from LLaMA family,
obtaining chatbot stitches of assorted sizes. | [
0.0080413567,
0.0894599184,
-0.0110027725,
0.016528327,
-0.0100124767,
-0.011034891,
0.0459167287,
-0.0363459289,
0.0233849213,
-0.0240209922,
-0.0539168902,
0.009656406,
-0.014560746,
0.0845080912,
0.0189146474,
-0.0267843734,
0.0044753226,
0.0336577818,
-0.0226721223,
0.0028676912,
-0.0127144316,
0.0263330564,
-0.0126547385,
0.01950958,
-0.0171133727,
-0.0057472326,
-0.0482634194,
0.0314499363,
0.0269190874,
0.0053124782,
0.0132669024,
0.0472355559,
0.0113331089,
0.0092211301,
0.0000022806,
-0.0160987601,
-0.0172423739,
-0.0218323097,
-0.0298077054,
0.0005239275,
0.0705707446,
-0.0076855426,
-0.0411755964,
0.0183884539,
-0.0052940641,
-0.0054447758,
0.0906278864,
0.0287421718,
0.0595839173,
0.0730017498,
-0.0094595691,
0.0216907766,
0.0380377695,
-0.0474063382,
-0.012190802,
-0.0522719622,
0.0026446036,
0.0086464295,
-0.0420291349,
-0.0497470759,
-0.0440728627,
0.0180049166,
0.0414119028,
0.0058977767,
0.0044375961,
0.003161988,
-0.0280225147,
-0.0373232774,
-0.0233873222,
0.0636847839,
-0.0850017592,
-0.0007931672,
0.0043304474,
-0.0596962757,
0.0203823727,
-0.0092792651,
-0.0337210745,
-0.02695591,
0.0401537158,
0.0173674207,
-0.0528107695,
-0.0403964221,
0.0230183806,
0.0104669528,
-0.0265822392,
-0.0464786179,
-0.0047441018,
0.0600298643,
-0.0125644654,
-0.0103072897,
-0.0333635919,
-0.0369886383,
0.0058503682,
0.020029163,
-0.0240457859,
-0.0211968441,
-0.0860155895,
-0.0297660436,
-0.0400629751,
0.0046335389,
0.0602240115,
0.0293585118,
-0.0357160084,
0.073075138,
-0.0872436613,
0.0289806705,
-0.0639307871,
0.0272006355,
-0.0204856563,
-0.0174196754,
-0.0085368268,
0.0247385111,
-0.0214136411,
0.022578286,
-0.0519361719,
-0.0479387268,
-0.0219271723,
0.043032337,
-0.0370354652,
-0.044058159,
0.0002959096,
0.0315918066,
-0.0604481027,
-0.014531685,
0.0272854958,
0.0494757406,
0.0128906071,
0.0621718317,
0.0044695772,
-0.0655583367,
-0.0410468318,
0.0281189308,
0.0487828739,
0.0162707567,
0.071503602,
0.0515788458,
-0.0312857144,
-0.0149556538,
-0.0387240537,
0.0302495323,
-0.0100188516,
-0.0133566828,
0.0455446057,
-0.0347444043,
0.0599964559,
-0.0533625893,
0.0371259637,
-0.0523122102,
-0.0046665696,
-0.0101369098,
-0.0602086931,
0.0450801551,
0.0334032588,
-0.0092329485,
-0.0113088982,
-0.0271892902,
-0.0129815871,
0.0633517876,
0.0485804863,
0.0656517744,
-0.0184007492,
-0.0232336111,
-0.0143440701,
0.0330049619,
0.0149591919,
-0.0014105807,
0.0103530055,
-0.0432918705,
0.0344039202,
0.0026365996,
0.0659199059,
-0.0267783031,
0.0014596704,
-0.0222786572,
0.0238573328,
0.0501842536,
0.0419438928,
0.0321003124,
0.0170583893,
0.0130709438,
-0.0308084115,
-0.0565046184,
-0.0740953982,
0.1020392329,
0.0183380079,
-0.0461094528,
-0.014414981,
0.0682929754,
-0.0782853588,
-0.0482480898,
0.0238766689,
-0.0132630421,
-0.0288825296,
0.0264522489,
0.0561115444,
-0.0088834893,
-0.0425519235,
0.0161797144,
0.0135357175,
-0.0169958565,
-0.0128145693,
-0.0749995261,
-0.0546622686,
0.072253868,
0.0095530441,
-0.02970751,
-0.0602591634,
0.0252247266,
0.0560487807,
-0.0154055459,
0.0215089172,
0.0115970122,
0.0609241128,
-0.042389594,
-0.0215407144,
0.0169529971,
-0.0113911685,
0.056019187,
0.033327315,
0.0159378741,
0.0042060018,
0.0267449282,
0.0086926296,
0.0533595905,
-0.0225595646,
-0.0010190507,
0.0440918058,
-0.0093382411,
0.0772941634,
-0.0143058486,
-0.0211842544,
-0.0620874539,
0.0333361216,
-0.0293176789,
-0.0209388789,
0.0076465369,
-0.0127809057,
0.0121678589,
0.003159326,
-0.0034131603,
0.0568666644,
0.0582260638,
-0.0657203719,
-0.0437812433,
0.0578360483,
-0.0081907827,
-0.0099844374,
0.0131940665,
0.003284975,
0.0086865416,
0.041549053,
-0.0003907065,
-0.0208972469,
0.007145009,
-0.0639935657,
-0.0514941327,
0.0146882245,
-0.0183919538,
-0.0204736609,
-0.0304640643,
0.0148992008,
-0.0171501301,
0.0044343267,
0.0017469738,
0.0468856022,
-0.0062321355,
-0.0722582117,
-0.068018131,
0.0346442275,
-0.0271066613,
-0.0067838607,
0.0041373926,
-0.009418319,
-0.003760379,
-0.0409402773,
-0.0217000823,
0.0880893916,
-0.0211203303,
-0.0003338724,
-0.0198701657,
0.0072003873,
-0.0436225124,
-0.0425636023,
-0.0269300248,
0.0375756025,
0.0150132468,
-0.0029736741,
-0.0619446188,
-0.0397166796,
-0.0272678453,
0.0222173296,
0.0409922376,
-0.0024033331,
-0.0415236987,
-0.0342932567,
-0.0089567164,
-0.0078269411,
0.1083630472,
-0.007063264,
0.0125426222,
0.041968286,
0.0233410187,
-0.0149457557,
0.0258102864,
-0.0099324211,
-0.0479104407,
-0.0174746867,
-0.0075686495,
-0.0140647385,
0.0042552766,
-0.0642560497,
0.0134194847,
-0.0662904605,
0.0188724939,
0.0255850367,
-0.0449538678,
-0.0250182562,
0.0350189321,
-0.0216220357,
-0.0140645206,
-0.0365558416,
-0.058736369,
-0.0164226647,
0.0038988569,
-0.0315558538,
0.0037698455,
-0.0227145012,
-0.0182221998,
0.0630123317,
0.0496421754,
0.0322289057,
-0.030363556,
-0.010867794,
-0.0846931487,
0.0360642448,
-0.0231652837,
-0.012235296,
-0.0074020848,
-0.0326822773,
0.0117975827,
-0.0569812916,
-0.0341888778,
-0.02562006,
-0.0289891362,
-0.0234632995,
-0.0031000131,
0.0100047896,
-0.011041576,
-0.0318953507,
0.0019388648,
-0.0176469088,
0.0765008703,
-0.0025347446,
0.0148195093,
-0.0329575464,
-0.0186176673,
0.0145304957,
0.0806538835,
-0.0105566476,
0.0472836047,
0.0084595215,
0.0319836885,
0.047767166,
-0.0016216652,
-0.0560515411,
0.0252474155,
0.0519153327,
0.0322801322,
-0.0131396865,
0.0097319335,
0.050502345,
-0.0519518405,
0.0321352668,
0.0432664007,
-0.0124669112,
-0.0341101848,
-0.0094206017,
0.0268966909,
0.0439395644,
0.0246786885,
0.0341844819,
-0.0298489928,
-0.0395784527,
0.0257826615,
-0.0049440963,
0.0244021323,
0.0205155034,
-0.0182997361,
-0.078513287,
0.0519134253,
0.0122151831,
-0.0606034957,
-0.0210525841,
-0.0214972161,
0.0216632057,
-0.0590034649,
-0.0037672739,
0.0119778998,
0.009214283,
-0.0472082421,
0.0112367813,
0.0114601152,
-0.0149567509,
0.0046268306,
-0.0097147152,
0.0425849706,
0.0080987317,
-0.0256710928,
0.0023429389,
-0.0278592948,
0.0741890296,
-0.0150762824,
0.0014145834,
0.0028148929,
0.0624206141,
-0.0200504605,
-0.0484024733,
0.0445580967,
0.0433131121,
-0.0463265739,
-0.0144153908,
-0.0074712797,
0.0296744015,
0.0112943472,
0.0153796021,
-0.0296322256,
-0.0097611137,
-0.0169547722,
0.0435174666,
0.0068828394,
-0.061457105,
-0.0081292139,
0.0253898222,
-0.0193117633,
-0.0486993492,
-0.0479287878,
0.0039965673,
-0.0167396758,
-0.0430757664,
-0.0237735324,
0.0266047083,
0.0167325344,
0.0616721846,
0.0237121098,
-0.0565611273,
0.0257647391,
0.0671371296,
-0.0647887513,
0.0504419245,
-0.0315499939,
-0.0288081244,
-0.0272590909,
-0.0092319846,
0.0616317242,
-0.0240917541,
-0.0133073973,
-0.0279177986,
-0.0842487291,
-0.0049687522,
0.01314916,
0.0295948703,
0.0135275656,
0.0246090628,
-0.0163695365,
-0.0248140804,
0.0146684553,
0.0395193398,
0.0106426217,
0.0439606979,
0.0651571751,
-0.035172414,
-0.0342910625,
0.0215427782,
-0.0744263083,
0.0408704691,
0.0183160827,
-0.0242882092,
0.01209669,
-0.0318748243,
-0.0336715207,
-0.0109589985,
0.036816176,
0.0167175308,
0.0013092019,
-0.0144559126,
0.0183044914,
0.069617942,
0.0132664526,
-0.0750584304,
-0.0006238821,
-0.0311262291,
0.0080731325,
0.0144717768,
0.0290726684,
0.0738131776,
-0.015624674,
-0.0240555312,
-0.0234764423,
-0.028570598,
-0.0105410805,
-0.019342009,
0.0274388697,
-0.0128097115,
-0.010584482,
-0.002684047,
-0.0021852341,
-0.0364862531,
-0.0061382661,
0.0138266077,
0.0013819409,
-0.0960353017,
0.0808658749,
-0.0250216145,
-0.0821400285,
-0.0764274076,
0.0744782537,
0.0406363942,
-0.00084056,
0.0327233858,
-0.0017762989,
-0.0162242372,
-0.0233457647,
0.0005517176,
0.0162782557,
0.024358945,
-0.0010181718,
0.0225119982,
0.0206274521,
-0.0139581813,
0.0408426598,
0.00965246,
0.0371705145,
-0.0094925324,
0.0161891133,
-0.0240962598,
-0.0493365191,
0.0091956072,
0.007606158,
0.0169690754,
-0.0088809673,
0.0202633794,
-0.0129295224,
-0.0448881872,
-0.0301906243,
0.0172420051,
-0.0152061898,
0.0228026658,
0.0586251244,
-0.0016622734,
0.0183954723,
0.0038880405,
-0.0321741216,
0.0162942111,
0.0118737007,
0.069050841,
-6.830542003e-33,
-0.0050440468,
0.0246168692,
0.0251169335,
0.0153452763,
-0.0103793824,
0.0288869105,
-0.0115988329,
-0.0014877892,
-0.0488930792,
-0.0221854169,
-0.0075765871,
0.0204456951,
0.031370379,
0.0203243699,
0.0082669528,
0.0086250119,
0.075371176,
-0.0285486281,
-0.0209394265,
0.047597982,
0.0162761174,
-0.0181788523,
0.0222605597,
-0.0461802669,
-0.0647508949,
0.061653886,
-0.0108405501,
0.0093968883,
0.010420871,
0.0033572498,
0.0158646051,
0.0089778099,
0.0036074386,
-0.0670018867,
-0.0167247057,
0.0145329256,
-0.066716224,
-0.0015455687,
-0.0474811494,
0.0260628443,
-0.0333911143,
-0.0269798227,
0.043321494,
0.0307335891,
0.0028126119,
-0.0159216449,
0.0189485848,
-0.0277995095,
0.0094442759,
0.0205500815,
-0.0103728352,
0.0072762743,
0.0055665602,
-0.0635958165,
0.017622821,
0.0177610107,
-0.0043654046,
0.0390899628,
-0.0498800576,
-0.0080781523,
-0.0210776497,
0.0325048529,
0.0523287058,
0.0710116774,
0.0068449597,
0.0597576089,
0.0402271748,
-0.0067438493,
0.005899488,
0.0009006598,
0.0543953218,
0.0413045324,
0.0691617876,
0.0132037466,
0.0741190985,
-0.0164258443,
-0.0682317019,
-0.0233598836,
0.0099337865,
0.0117319301,
0.0315191038,
0.0369525254,
0.0064677307,
-0.0035645931,
-0.0131297223,
-0.021448208,
-0.0400989391,
0.021149816,
0.0171444975,
0.0484688058,
-0.0419674963,
0.0197888222,
0.0591418929,
-0.0215196516,
0.0701133981,
-0.0089284023,
-0.0046089515,
0.0440251566,
0.0338110961,
0.0120574357,
-0.0361635312,
-0.0550033152,
0.0405462049,
0.0030176935,
0.0251641069,
-0.011166377,
0.0417233817,
0.0491832122,
-0.0499703251,
-0.0190649126,
-0.0211594384,
0.032988552,
0.0067590624,
0.0224158764,
0.0146722374,
-0.0121200327,
-0.0134798568,
0.016668288,
-0.0040648882,
0.0045729666,
0.0026679621,
0.0253094304,
-0.0042127082,
-0.0031112996,
-0.0411342792,
-0.0046854601,
-0.0318625122,
0.0060124258,
-0.0167010203,
-0.0724345595,
-0.0254240856,
0.0069247885,
3.235e-7,
-0.0356973857,
0.0006981342,
-0.0206744745,
-0.06266094,
0.060021393,
0.0316433199,
0.0108784055,
0.0429598913,
-0.0213979613,
-0.0226166062,
0.0279010367,
0.057722494,
0.0275589805,
-0.0123969549,
-0.0303939357,
-0.0547102988,
0.0033632342,
0.0560400411,
-0.0113392817,
-0.0357059576,
-0.0139369462,
0.108629249,
0.0344517194,
-0.0274957735,
0.0467644595,
-0.0388913825,
0.0014447464,
-0.0330583714,
0.0405976214,
-0.0106018046,
-0.0178646278,
0.0682198256,
-0.0413786732,
0.0269218832,
0.0130484225,
0.0411926992,
-0.0000204539,
0.0515657142,
0.0028921061,
-0.0014322731,
-0.0076197479,
0.0772184655,
-0.0119901188,
-0.0069320109,
0.0887170583,
-0.1138593182,
-0.0402178988,
-0.0571933948,
-0.0006051897,
0.0068844766,
0.0101072406,
0.0158317797,
0.0225804243,
0.0174942017,
0.0133392084,
-0.0432354994,
-0.0599172264,
-0.0994510278,
0.0259293132,
-0.0015639813,
-0.0517663211,
-0.0444300398,
-0.0438199043,
-0.0343401842,
0.0729015842,
-0.0254348945,
-0.0117796697,
2.690963249e-34,
-0.0023133929,
0.0044855457,
0.038575016,
0.0113462918,
-0.0139187602,
0.0130368592,
-0.0260743182,
-0.0227557737,
0.0032221368,
-0.0348242112,
-0.0271692779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17351v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17351v1 | Exploring Large Language Models for Human Mobility Prediction under Public Events | 2023-11-29T04:25:15 | 2023-11-29T04:25:15 | Yuebing Liang, Yichao Liu, Xiaohan Wang, Zhan Zhao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Public events, such as concerts and sports games, can be major attractors for
large crowds, leading to irregular surges in travel demand. Accurate human
mobility prediction for public events is thus crucial for event planning as
well as traffic or crowd management. While rich textual descriptions about
public events are commonly available from online sources, it is challenging to
encode such information in statistical or machine learning models. Existing
methods are generally limited in incorporating textual information, handling
data sparsity, or providing rationales for their predictions. To address these
challenges, we introduce a framework for human mobility prediction under public
events (LLM-MPE) based on Large Language Models (LLMs), leveraging their
unprecedented ability to process textual data, learn from minimal examples, and
generate human-readable explanations. Specifically, LLM-MPE first transforms
raw, unstructured event descriptions from online sources into a standardized
format, and then segments historical mobility data into regular and
event-related components. A prompting strategy is designed to direct LLMs in
making and rationalizing demand predictions considering historical mobility and
event features. A case study is conducted for Barclays Center in New York City,
based on publicly available event information and taxi trip data. Results show
that LLM-MPE surpasses traditional models, particularly on event days, with
textual data significantly enhancing its accuracy. Furthermore, LLM-MPE offers
interpretable insights into its predictions. Despite the great potential of
LLMs, we also identify key challenges including misinformation and high costs
that remain barriers to their broader adoption in large-scale human mobility
analysis. | [
-0.0110061867,
0.0796080902,
-0.018328432,
0.0489768907,
-0.0082767485,
-0.0202503838,
0.0142175164,
-0.0414783098,
-0.0124364495,
-0.0115904259,
0.0252963416,
-0.0348369293,
0.0002774455,
0.0336887762,
0.0242047738,
-0.0678210035,
-0.0146041075,
-0.0400087684,
-0.0307211205,
0.0389192402,
0.0176700857,
0.0458213016,
0.0132835144,
0.0569134988,
-0.0212522931,
0.0186466649,
-0.0452385619,
0.0078460462,
0.0264958981,
-0.0497014895,
0.0087649487,
0.0082392637,
0.1252216995,
-0.0308474582,
0.0000017986,
-0.0107088871,
-0.0248987582,
-0.0038334068,
0.0028019683,
-0.0254509412,
-0.0045235641,
-0.0204979889,
0.0334242024,
0.0376880467,
-0.0006311101,
-0.0112597067,
0.0000775373,
0.0206580237,
0.0249922555,
0.0473261662,
-0.0160950553,
-0.0429630876,
0.0185600426,
0.0002756897,
0.0337084197,
-0.026781695,
0.0325504132,
-0.0307276659,
-0.034687154,
-0.0182379056,
0.015408068,
-0.0455227382,
-0.017490603,
-0.0141519364,
0.0254843719,
0.0385361649,
-0.05573228,
0.0247429553,
-0.0137787526,
0.0394249968,
0.0318198316,
-0.0429667793,
0.0625306368,
0.0170986094,
-0.0249802284,
0.021288963,
-0.0596871413,
-0.0256120861,
0.0569213778,
0.0701652765,
-0.0065075206,
0.0295593068,
0.0573090315,
0.0552302077,
-0.0198569708,
0.0682528913,
-0.0116320448,
-0.0396687649,
-0.0712455288,
-0.0046727704,
0.0008974979,
-0.0424206592,
0.0300389193,
0.0264605004,
-0.0346880853,
0.0168887358,
0.0460205935,
0.0232481845,
-0.0444333404,
-0.0673786327,
0.028446408,
0.0159748737,
0.0071892436,
0.0324671492,
0.0445474349,
-0.0037956631,
-0.0100545101,
-0.0269888565,
-0.0064069745,
-0.02083092,
-0.0340104252,
0.0360277817,
-0.0213074945,
-0.0304750968,
-0.0771767572,
0.0075125713,
0.000540874,
0.0377739929,
0.0246859211,
-0.0101136817,
-0.0256017577,
-0.0028565656,
0.0203998629,
-0.0379245691,
-0.0430856347,
-0.0024039682,
-0.0328430459,
0.0138260089,
-0.0120834708,
0.0117563065,
0.0372668058,
0.0204643495,
0.0466157794,
-0.012531423,
-0.0664083585,
0.0329794995,
0.019208122,
0.044113297,
-0.0847332552,
-0.0438585728,
0.0109221358,
-0.0560119562,
-0.0398646295,
-0.0767954588,
0.0154696554,
0.0182948373,
-0.0212627146,
0.0014769394,
-0.001051644,
-0.0042546061,
-0.0524945147,
0.0222382788,
-0.0107400035,
0.0579301752,
0.0366841964,
-0.0298237223,
0.0539883338,
0.0183297712,
0.0441352092,
0.0434995666,
0.068148531,
-0.0263472442,
0.0212197844,
0.0249510892,
0.0208773278,
0.0054925852,
-0.010040883,
0.0221383199,
-0.0191541184,
0.0057856292,
0.013120722,
0.0061712409,
-0.0254175253,
0.0182860177,
0.0513082407,
0.0459424816,
-0.0298432875,
0.0010552339,
0.047121603,
0.0285470951,
-0.0694850385,
-0.0365950279,
-0.0051486427,
-0.0073450753,
-0.0271422006,
-0.0047625271,
0.0831121728,
0.0100843729,
-0.0292024203,
-0.024213599,
0.0139831593,
-0.0391078815,
0.0221151654,
0.0036251366,
0.0439214222,
-0.0999554694,
-0.0197290145,
0.0495770611,
0.0265445653,
-0.0051791938,
0.0128074056,
-0.0234146398,
0.0151531454,
0.0977073163,
-0.0195509847,
0.0253021214,
0.051381629,
-0.0212558545,
0.046044074,
-0.0073271901,
0.0454738736,
-0.0076128673,
0.0068360423,
-0.0617542341,
-0.009963681,
0.0899966434,
0.0317242481,
-0.0650669783,
0.0300890617,
0.0131093543,
0.0670912117,
-0.0397735126,
-0.0559264868,
0.0018352262,
-0.0099633988,
-0.0522732474,
-0.0047472171,
0.0159476511,
0.0010148707,
-0.006293457,
0.0017610568,
0.0068524783,
0.0199047066,
-0.005668818,
-0.0200127717,
0.0300269518,
-0.0230904967,
0.0236631688,
-0.0009284473,
0.0387027934,
-0.0281082839,
0.0320504159,
-0.0219308902,
-0.0111452043,
0.0197141953,
-0.0248784311,
0.0430529863,
-0.0021575673,
0.0263946094,
0.027956821,
-0.0012244639,
0.0175437909,
0.0388608314,
0.0139680272,
0.0123623582,
-0.0046148463,
0.0028496734,
0.0379139557,
-0.0458418876,
-0.0348920785,
-0.0375634879,
0.0157216042,
0.0263201166,
0.0142633813,
-0.0402164645,
-0.0060313484,
0.0570433848,
-0.0804931745,
0.0276735276,
-0.0108875111,
0.0307156332,
0.0145066008,
-0.005396171,
-0.0137737393,
0.0092904381,
-0.0321725197,
-0.0227853674,
-0.0538340397,
-0.0137516689,
0.0457145385,
-0.0170339067,
-0.0195799675,
-0.0197400153,
-0.0208365042,
-0.0673438609,
0.0522645675,
-0.0088810567,
-0.0333659574,
0.0052001937,
-0.0329794772,
-0.0458420552,
-0.0054158601,
0.0095050614,
-0.0031909372,
-0.0341239311,
-0.0046283412,
0.0637290105,
-0.0331065543,
0.0269311648,
-0.0139397457,
-0.0200097617,
-0.0464647487,
-0.0292595457,
-0.0032000998,
-0.0818831846,
0.0053900969,
-0.0673430637,
-0.0797014609,
-0.0120548541,
0.0302797314,
0.0008440861,
0.0071439776,
-0.0491159894,
-0.004985719,
-0.0352026001,
0.0166608766,
-0.0447622202,
0.0490148477,
-0.0364236757,
0.0766933337,
-0.0098687084,
-0.0255727936,
0.0211329274,
0.0028936665,
0.0516649187,
0.0248945337,
-0.0150489975,
-0.0202323794,
0.0447097495,
-0.0077482536,
0.0431375131,
-0.0211488884,
-0.0107093435,
0.0344115384,
-0.0373981707,
-0.0568278655,
-0.0196079202,
0.0057423306,
-0.0160640851,
-0.0029090738,
0.0609163195,
-0.0621521398,
-0.0023107142,
-0.0599523894,
-0.0438474342,
-0.0462527834,
-0.0109298462,
-0.0453814715,
-0.0411360338,
0.0210697334,
-0.0124824671,
0.0246094391,
-0.0000685387,
-0.0233513843,
-0.0040066042,
0.0299930293,
0.044895567,
0.1083004922,
0.0096895294,
-0.0201816335,
-0.0314604864,
0.0023488342,
0.0247183591,
0.0024496778,
-0.0232645739,
0.0396716967,
0.011393276,
-0.0208048727,
-0.0320314616,
0.0923747942,
0.0377666056,
-0.0515395775,
0.0346799046,
0.0913336575,
0.0453224182,
-0.0178904571,
0.0322838314,
-0.0218275972,
0.0281132907,
-0.0059556714,
0.0405998044,
-0.0494892672,
-0.0228154678,
0.0012617896,
0.0385363549,
-0.003240247,
-0.0523970723,
-0.0009695259,
-0.0861062929,
0.0628497377,
-0.0006976263,
0.0162181426,
-0.0175500512,
-0.091559805,
0.0127914008,
-0.0169849992,
0.0015864888,
-0.0194150358,
0.0144540174,
-0.0183428172,
0.034099333,
-0.1412818581,
-0.0705770478,
0.0192907304,
-0.025283156,
0.05417547,
0.0096972547,
0.0805947632,
-0.0132082338,
-0.0190206058,
-0.027935477,
-0.0101552084,
0.0217751544,
-0.0080469716,
0.0272295382,
-0.0154348193,
0.0089792926,
-0.0483288579,
0.065517582,
-0.0759243071,
-0.0372646153,
0.0419940017,
0.1119088233,
-0.0124764238,
-0.0321976244,
-0.0089993924,
0.0249596499,
0.0092308233,
0.0424444042,
-0.0102393366,
-0.0329822786,
0.0001598979,
-0.0414410792,
-0.0195585992,
-0.0076863142,
-0.0179438982,
-0.0065184352,
-0.0066016549,
-0.0523573086,
-0.0133989258,
-0.0262342747,
0.0101518463,
0.0093364026,
-0.0241491813,
0.0597449318,
0.0332602598,
-0.0568577237,
-0.0248747952,
0.0466104858,
-0.0456585139,
0.0301160384,
-0.0015373504,
0.007835554,
-0.0131264152,
0.014108737,
-0.0407225825,
0.0185058229,
-0.0683671609,
-0.0675344393,
-0.0293666087,
-0.0399545878,
0.0214787014,
0.0331192873,
0.0120625217,
-0.0201917291,
0.0077840071,
-0.0152802831,
-0.0273051392,
-0.0184252337,
-0.027319923,
0.0058304416,
0.0090854028,
0.0192547236,
-0.0031114107,
0.0580746606,
-0.0235228725,
0.0157377068,
-0.096149087,
0.0240889136,
0.0175519213,
0.0384856611,
0.0579771884,
0.0189050511,
-0.0417469479,
-0.0235609263,
-0.0336188003,
-0.0172698088,
-0.0044852602,
0.0062949965,
-0.0450278185,
0.022431802,
0.0578200817,
-0.0718522668,
-0.0000731804,
0.0107459668,
-0.0555644147,
-0.0486515798,
0.0231619012,
0.0194718465,
-0.0306502506,
0.0083764177,
0.0119833844,
0.0184510369,
-0.0018875888,
-0.0001237921,
0.0117809959,
0.0022205324,
-0.0124403657,
0.0311462786,
0.0602015294,
-0.0319067389,
-0.035228055,
-0.02149483,
-0.0406844765,
-0.0002423246,
0.0263162609,
-0.0050807982,
-0.0243990626,
-0.004075259,
-0.0013377436,
-0.0125945238,
-0.0183969382,
0.0520691127,
0.0065704975,
0.0220704805,
0.0515711531,
-0.0050802692,
-0.055347316,
0.035407614,
0.0658656508,
0.0318709165,
0.0196622685,
0.0244878568,
-0.0594813153,
-0.0100146076,
0.0352894515,
0.0183909182,
-0.0137654375,
0.0054781353,
-0.0056343656,
-0.0560152382,
-0.0407670252,
0.0196140129,
-0.0280575361,
-0.0243476406,
-0.0308686104,
0.0212060455,
0.0055199028,
-0.0137436586,
-0.0082379505,
-0.058845818,
-0.0198883265,
-0.0511650965,
-0.0291034356,
-0.0103931939,
-6.313835094e-33,
0.0227220766,
-0.0379346237,
0.0513521731,
-0.0195387136,
-0.0478982963,
0.0223733988,
-0.0368582718,
-0.0291263871,
0.0022386319,
0.0008799696,
0.01101874,
-0.011573757,
0.0053525106,
0.0152015444,
0.0251058321,
-0.0390370451,
0.0396620072,
-0.0206889007,
0.002181472,
0.0171933621,
0.0496842414,
0.0101402607,
-0.0071593653,
-0.0608562976,
0.0264421795,
-0.0611324385,
-0.0181788262,
0.0300508738,
0.0863982067,
0.0183592718,
-0.0105866715,
0.0526540205,
0.0408616476,
-0.0331201144,
-0.0315665044,
0.0859104618,
-0.006542162,
0.0174011234,
0.0239535216,
0.003442853,
-0.0128153078,
-0.0163701568,
0.0197418276,
0.0191807356,
0.0032924409,
0.025870271,
0.0607222244,
-0.0089424187,
0.0012219632,
0.0044391691,
-0.0086997077,
0.0441290624,
-0.0686996207,
0.0119874235,
0.0438889526,
0.0298059117,
-0.0053835306,
0.0537090227,
-0.0165872052,
0.0471814089,
-0.0239190999,
0.0070885308,
-0.0043679778,
-0.0061455728,
0.0149187688,
0.0393893495,
-0.0104134222,
-0.0468410514,
-0.0541697219,
0.018504478,
0.0325467773,
0.0503148884,
-0.032304991,
0.0259187445,
0.0296911746,
-0.0302067958,
-0.0816444904,
0.0145507548,
0.0158723034,
-0.0425437391,
0.0416335762,
0.0144464178,
-0.0587291159,
-0.023036046,
-0.020493079,
0.0150805954,
0.002568257,
-0.0346705467,
0.0053567546,
-0.0039717136,
-0.0158154946,
0.0652133748,
0.0501665063,
-0.0311097465,
-0.0803218931,
0.0062284181,
0.0012150852,
-0.0037853206,
-0.0176810063,
0.0523995571,
-0.1162781641,
-0.0241297577,
-0.0261769295,
-0.0259076003,
0.0380887501,
0.0390758142,
0.0078950189,
0.0396792218,
-0.0110879866,
0.0111934692,
0.012501332,
-0.0435954519,
-0.0088980133,
0.0182138942,
0.0493868925,
-0.0169639066,
0.0017945769,
0.0198506135,
0.0405193865,
0.0361521095,
0.0562497601,
-0.0306105334,
-0.0109628262,
0.0098199574,
-0.0083255004,
-0.0203277823,
-0.0160503276,
-0.0138430651,
0.0320873857,
-0.0324004591,
-0.0301372129,
-0.0034916562,
2.601e-7,
0.0190584585,
0.0843755677,
-0.0259648804,
0.0418492965,
0.0077597499,
0.0198844206,
-0.0050669122,
0.0151206404,
0.0063493159,
0.0197452419,
0.0390984453,
0.039641507,
0.0479261316,
0.0367999189,
-0.0539391264,
0.0366251618,
-0.0829793587,
0.0019977726,
-0.0933724269,
0.0345081352,
0.0510614924,
0.1278035492,
0.0574314333,
-0.0031482284,
0.0287954267,
-0.0068168514,
0.0201554783,
-0.0656820387,
-0.0633588284,
0.0249857455,
0.0208321773,
0.0521129817,
-0.038491983,
-0.0112720663,
-0.0513000078,
0.0197856724,
0.0201073028,
0.0366535671,
-0.0177810863,
0.031386625,
0.0147433095,
-0.0361300223,
-0.0009297089,
-0.0316065811,
0.048448056,
0.0024815071,
-0.0342792459,
0.0078937234,
-0.0515593998,
-0.0167997982,
-0.0158298761,
0.0177945755,
-0.0166846979,
0.0024809372,
0.0115633039,
-0.0197135005,
0.0011566022,
-0.0553125404,
0.0344666094,
0.0279375687,
-0.0132107725,
-0.0361623354,
-0.0335761569,
0.0113639589,
0.0361666679,
-0.0285337716,
0.0404802747,
1.969574305e-34,
0.0328048579,
0.0771093294,
-0.05708142,
-0.0316500552,
0.0424025469,
-0.0230693873,
-0.0112008685,
0.0144341076,
0.0088662794,
-0.0385536365,
-0.0086371591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17946v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17946v1 | DreamSync: Aligning Text-to-Image Generation with Image Understanding Feedback | 2023-11-29T03:42:16 | 2023-11-29T03:42:16 | Jiao Sun, Deqing Fu, Yushi Hu, Su Wang, Royi Rassin, Da-Cheng Juan, Dana Alon, Charles Herrmann, Sjoerd van Steenkiste, Ranjay Krishna, Cyrus Rashtchian | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite their wide-spread success, Text-to-Image models (T2I) still struggle
to produce images that are both aesthetically pleasing and faithful to the
user's input text. We introduce DreamSync, a model-agnostic training algorithm
by design that improves T2I models to be faithful to the text input. DreamSync
builds off a recent insight from TIFA's evaluation framework -- that large
vision-language models (VLMs) can effectively identify the fine-grained
discrepancies between generated images and the text inputs. DreamSync uses this
insight to train T2I models without any labeled data; it improves T2I models
using its own generations. First, it prompts the model to generate several
candidate images for a given input text. Then, it uses two VLMs to select the
best generation: a Visual Question Answering model that measures the alignment
of generated images to the text, and another that measures the generation's
aesthetic quality. After selection, we use LoRA to iteratively finetune the T2I
model to guide its generation towards the selected best generations. DreamSync
does not need any additional human annotation. model architecture changes, or
reinforcement learning. Despite its simplicity, DreamSync improves both the
semantic alignment and aesthetic appeal of two diffusion-based T2I models,
evidenced by multiple benchmarks (+1.7% on TIFA, +2.9% on DSG1K, +3.4% on VILA
aesthetic) and human evaluation. | [
0.0396290757,
0.0769623891,
0.010954354,
0.0478934571,
-0.0098254709,
0.0187741611,
-0.0083887391,
0.0064924802,
-0.0144251864,
-0.0204842184,
-0.0371962599,
-0.0501726307,
0.024257239,
0.0232155006,
0.0305631645,
-0.077574946,
0.0056736022,
-0.0162361525,
-0.031239707,
0.0099121779,
0.0383506119,
0.0211070608,
0.0012562347,
0.0252963118,
-0.0336270966,
-0.0549432337,
-0.0226472579,
0.0335918628,
0.0332982615,
-0.0165525284,
-0.0147705963,
0.0331864282,
0.0153532149,
0.0126945479,
0.0000020407,
0.003645716,
0.0328910425,
0.0073357881,
0.0219930522,
0.0013725491,
0.0372212306,
-0.0142448125,
0.0051873969,
-0.0254897978,
-0.0428080484,
0.024201354,
0.0855132118,
0.0754399151,
0.099927932,
0.0422848649,
-0.0140136573,
-0.0325623751,
0.0092523191,
-0.0289356709,
0.0254781004,
-0.0057528131,
-0.0163457431,
0.0129972929,
-0.0104744146,
-0.0070632799,
-0.0195868947,
0.0538760833,
0.012490144,
-0.033438582,
0.0507006943,
0.0475836471,
-0.010050538,
-0.0537903756,
-0.023658704,
0.0895529687,
-0.0126541704,
-0.0184821319,
-0.0423373282,
-0.0146930134,
-0.0004016637,
-0.0083733955,
-0.03835636,
0.0004342579,
-0.0065857293,
0.0267752577,
-0.0540328808,
-0.0091659315,
-0.0036170862,
-0.0103758536,
0.02383844,
-0.0225394703,
0.0292164385,
-0.0078420965,
-0.019283304,
0.0467534661,
-0.0272183921,
-0.052240286,
0.0014088564,
0.0341924243,
-0.0168274678,
0.0139242085,
-0.0754380301,
-0.0299401376,
-0.0053839581,
-0.0217385124,
0.0675532073,
0.0154142529,
-0.0221271757,
0.0370571911,
-0.0254039448,
0.0575793311,
-0.021199232,
0.0170435328,
-0.084608458,
-0.000789068,
-0.0043357923,
-0.0325545371,
-0.0401537679,
-0.0005955652,
-0.0440488532,
-0.0557014532,
-0.0342113338,
0.0305293724,
-0.0068873959,
0.0208727084,
0.0111969663,
0.0491745137,
-0.0601260625,
0.0017757711,
-0.0721964166,
0.0434617959,
0.0027391263,
0.0110402349,
0.0082455259,
-0.0308785979,
-0.0088454075,
0.0161543172,
0.0330341198,
-0.0005226886,
-0.0145056732,
0.0505357981,
-0.0673564598,
0.0011085243,
-0.012893931,
0.0012015499,
-0.0073388945,
-0.0438262895,
0.0124139991,
-0.0481127501,
0.0154509284,
-0.0232206695,
-0.0190729704,
-0.0424233638,
0.0145220887,
0.0292778704,
-0.029056102,
0.0547171198,
-0.0320757627,
0.0078122681,
0.0327803679,
-0.0137123568,
0.017949922,
0.0482822023,
0.0436566509,
0.0585552417,
-0.0043990058,
-0.0026663961,
-0.0023770453,
0.0452176109,
0.0066014375,
-0.0067283404,
-0.0367623046,
0.022624474,
0.0008326513,
0.0423170254,
0.0502620637,
0.0561876521,
0.003136025,
0.0105575286,
0.1094308943,
0.0198542811,
0.0095114289,
0.02035686,
0.0387261063,
0.0111803031,
0.0132663548,
0.0090325568,
-0.0360994935,
0.0791409612,
0.0076475404,
0.0582375266,
0.0162179787,
0.0177749917,
-0.0384765193,
-0.0489954986,
0.0019768623,
-0.0008998719,
-0.0017763475,
-0.0005441746,
0.0206325725,
0.044147931,
-0.0714637935,
0.0064935535,
-0.011432372,
-0.0367209353,
0.0011917679,
-0.0401780643,
0.0809888691,
0.1054536998,
0.0245445054,
0.0310965572,
-0.0044890349,
0.0046764747,
0.0336705223,
0.0895168185,
0.0084926728,
0.0079746917,
-0.0054176645,
-0.0495377183,
-0.047268983,
-0.0300419722,
-0.0242653619,
-0.0034530456,
-0.0174250435,
0.0278676879,
0.0060594506,
-0.0233604033,
-0.0479512475,
0.0526487604,
0.0367044695,
-0.0245698877,
-0.0162135512,
0.0274130795,
-0.0181363784,
-0.0238214526,
-0.030078819,
0.0097434223,
-0.0050695245,
-0.0302769039,
0.0071432558,
0.0223993193,
-0.0339807831,
-0.0103065474,
0.0185277462,
-0.061196547,
-0.0368248746,
0.0485679843,
-0.0518252403,
-0.0238568261,
-0.0207300708,
-0.063169159,
-0.011907544,
-0.0373815,
0.0034784637,
0.017475415,
0.0129062813,
-0.0146961873,
0.0508284234,
-0.0224735327,
-0.0295455512,
-0.0249380749,
0.0031534082,
-0.0079254415,
-0.0427604169,
0.0039860033,
-0.0208386257,
0.0083010271,
0.0133376615,
0.0173389278,
0.0603510998,
-0.0757122189,
-0.027200589,
-0.0814188048,
0.0068163527,
-0.0124331778,
-0.0002902973,
0.0220363773,
0.0050476426,
-0.000741501,
-0.035859324,
-0.0729902685,
0.0463670641,
0.0026106958,
-0.0093580363,
0.0699665993,
-0.007577904,
0.0265179183,
-0.0679612681,
0.0023380334,
0.0288105067,
0.0556406602,
0.0460440554,
0.001909537,
-0.0587157533,
0.0375187248,
-0.044934243,
0.0246197041,
0.0247629136,
-0.0234529227,
0.028418893,
-0.0092540858,
0.0537224561,
0.0995500237,
0.0557318479,
0.0050355294,
-0.0011055906,
0.0185421072,
-0.0448344126,
0.0072894301,
0.0073246313,
-0.0360013694,
0.0197538882,
-0.0584679879,
-0.0101440158,
0.0446066782,
-0.0060396264,
0.0416206233,
-0.0887165442,
0.0600298345,
0.004042597,
-0.0421219394,
-0.0351123959,
0.03119299,
0.0184806921,
0.0213008225,
-0.0779765695,
-0.0746971965,
0.0742306933,
-0.0370236076,
-0.0175858159,
-0.0109140808,
0.0153502747,
-0.0076480987,
0.0252529122,
0.006129079,
0.0470501855,
0.0163528677,
0.0224274006,
-0.0753519535,
-0.0185419228,
0.0110952249,
-0.0318729021,
0.0612486228,
-0.0448996201,
0.0179164819,
-0.0383358859,
-0.048889067,
-0.0487013496,
-0.0312458444,
-0.0212687682,
-0.0205465052,
-0.0317912586,
-0.002621176,
-0.0088890484,
0.0286746472,
0.0076101879,
-0.0161763877,
-0.0140089635,
-0.0378941968,
-0.0146621512,
0.0771751106,
0.1207856014,
0.0081708282,
-0.0157422163,
-0.0501191132,
0.0221083462,
0.0444274992,
0.0125777898,
0.0254179332,
-0.0698077455,
0.0137492195,
0.0021718191,
0.0275972337,
0.0009876991,
0.0190403312,
0.0857901201,
-0.0490719937,
-0.0277890936,
0.0786575899,
0.0101745622,
0.002538674,
-0.0204007663,
0.0043570958,
0.0515033118,
0.0097238272,
0.0273418538,
-0.0617410541,
-0.0364068523,
-0.0389262773,
0.0150694251,
0.0211128164,
0.0261275265,
-0.0329019986,
-0.0967959911,
0.0552566648,
0.0082441168,
-0.0249675512,
-0.0083155148,
0.0265171826,
0.0071876119,
0.0254373271,
0.0070344438,
-0.010721948,
-0.0223670136,
0.0192862116,
0.0171048902,
0.0315269306,
-0.0114104524,
-0.0105098542,
-0.0229826923,
-0.0018319318,
0.0987234935,
0.037970148,
0.0186382141,
-0.0821110532,
0.0212849695,
0.0182550158,
0.0231985934,
-0.0048995656,
0.0474540815,
0.0183364227,
-0.0405487418,
-0.0317795426,
0.0391515195,
-0.0000415028,
0.0170771237,
-0.0142350532,
0.0114158783,
-0.0004737004,
-0.024442954,
-0.0645543262,
0.0292913411,
-0.0024937396,
0.02647442,
0.045737911,
-0.0721212104,
-0.0617308617,
-0.0322221741,
0.0147417784,
-0.0637923628,
-0.0257148184,
0.00612291,
0.0252140947,
-0.0086115925,
-0.0801144987,
-0.0540631153,
0.0310393181,
0.0337159671,
-0.0058970987,
-0.030672159,
-0.041224543,
-0.0198129993,
-0.0463950038,
0.05078106,
-0.0258427914,
0.0243506003,
-0.0333548263,
-0.0098456517,
0.0109959245,
-0.0515710674,
-0.0238076337,
0.0228625033,
-0.1008560658,
-0.0282152779,
-0.0602207072,
0.1011367515,
0.0140546048,
0.0337547734,
0.014431349,
-0.0398896448,
0.0622799881,
0.0454455614,
0.0451336578,
0.0116905812,
-0.0212982483,
-0.000371671,
0.01321798,
0.0152745498,
-0.0552180856,
0.0032186252,
0.0306436736,
0.0374155566,
0.0020910925,
-0.009520229,
0.0300322715,
0.0042567197,
0.0105872545,
-0.0092225438,
0.0173042845,
-0.0071537578,
0.0162859764,
-0.0110051036,
-0.017275488,
-0.0840307549,
-0.009649762,
0.0250984915,
0.0273800734,
-0.0005984006,
-0.0080464575,
-0.0042030578,
0.0329657979,
-0.0561585389,
-0.0356369652,
0.0370250344,
0.0294053499,
0.0055938438,
0.0172742121,
-0.0379072204,
0.0105558308,
-0.0216154438,
0.0512139052,
0.0293053892,
0.085825339,
0.0204187855,
-0.0191378202,
-0.0216333251,
0.06290856,
-0.0181424152,
-0.0452293009,
-0.0560916625,
0.0095259594,
0.0562094152,
0.005276836,
0.0432185605,
0.0159847699,
-0.0065499856,
0.0068455175,
0.0295248237,
0.0055884016,
-0.0565510951,
0.0562280975,
-0.0080797402,
0.0174529143,
-0.0376146734,
0.039950341,
-0.0136314584,
0.0042729429,
-0.023730142,
0.0041495343,
-0.0334418379,
-0.0128820986,
0.017315045,
-0.0351436287,
0.0191853326,
0.0203429423,
-0.0112433676,
-0.060559392,
0.0286736786,
0.0439653657,
-0.019328678,
0.0254405048,
0.0715015307,
0.0292505324,
-0.015122355,
-0.0259258784,
-0.0099875815,
-0.0150240771,
-0.0426473059,
-0.0159363057,
-0.0486491807,
-6.149955018e-33,
-0.0479645729,
-0.0262003094,
0.0242419001,
-0.0129433824,
-0.0375121683,
-0.0144066997,
-0.0504097715,
-0.0039001356,
-0.0183974598,
0.0298870038,
0.0079650879,
-0.0028565321,
0.0050664362,
0.048802048,
-0.0307932105,
-0.0046063913,
0.0578473657,
-0.0080280425,
-0.0449798666,
0.0067386348,
-0.0041637481,
0.0024825474,
0.0283120535,
-0.0462602153,
-0.0269846022,
-0.0053965119,
-0.0262140911,
-0.0069429069,
0.0230638962,
0.0639042258,
-0.0188571345,
0.0392585471,
0.0001572661,
0.0143420752,
-0.0302175973,
0.0315669775,
-0.0558163933,
-0.0031393443,
0.0023458379,
0.0237873588,
-0.0824748427,
-0.0251343735,
0.0644001216,
-0.0278035738,
-0.0030215553,
-0.0462073497,
0.0831223875,
-0.0344153978,
0.016628895,
-0.0083194347,
-0.0412355401,
-0.0370928608,
-0.0444159731,
-0.051618211,
0.0004006237,
0.0447149053,
0.0361515507,
0.0375484973,
-0.0569922552,
0.0113875773,
0.0286549367,
0.0145789711,
0.0886994973,
0.037222404,
0.0047386684,
0.0475881994,
0.0052863252,
-0.0238653589,
-0.0139627894,
-0.0019628892,
0.0027156658,
0.0458179228,
0.0506380871,
0.0408416204,
0.0046211011,
0.0188237187,
-0.0374080464,
0.0372097567,
-0.0607400015,
0.0393974297,
0.0103566684,
0.0021160617,
-0.0108431913,
0.0366149284,
-0.0451225899,
-0.0279100686,
-0.0577533953,
-0.0197940785,
0.0387005098,
-0.002500897,
-0.0199140627,
0.0110309981,
0.0192702021,
-0.0118704233,
0.0034510929,
-0.0176337995,
-0.0574056916,
0.0566980392,
-0.0206330474,
0.0079400092,
-0.0048328103,
-0.0215467401,
0.0586858243,
0.0367122591,
-0.0138673298,
0.0406382866,
0.0228633396,
0.0037896631,
-0.0585377663,
0.0115894433,
-0.0476108491,
0.0241619702,
-0.0261797234,
-0.018388493,
0.0161945261,
-0.0093362378,
-0.066907607,
0.016677184,
-0.0182228424,
-0.0136642074,
-0.0282030068,
-0.0260807537,
0.0105868056,
0.0099828541,
-0.0264699645,
0.0178732798,
-0.0451218821,
0.0103217559,
0.0250893012,
-0.0623512119,
-0.0280584414,
0.0677170753,
2.635e-7,
0.0239261203,
0.0053312294,
0.0087922988,
0.0358842574,
0.001392537,
0.0498868152,
-0.0118041933,
0.0181228053,
0.0299098082,
-0.0101302145,
0.004776156,
0.0472920723,
0.0616619997,
-0.0324563533,
-0.0327330753,
0.0268199556,
-0.0631437451,
0.0185758322,
-0.0314948596,
0.0021187803,
0.0757557899,
0.0704144239,
-0.013562046,
-0.0321952328,
0.0424021073,
-0.0443870462,
0.1141562313,
-0.0169662107,
0.0177282467,
0.0047751199,
-0.008936448,
-0.025539428,
-0.0146471672,
0.0012817562,
-0.006157835,
-0.0232083481,
0.0461141542,
0.0365940258,
-0.0379542001,
-0.0146711748,
-0.0408019833,
0.0214642864,
0.0011073513,
-0.0664393902,
0.0649888217,
-0.0472280532,
-0.0168504566,
-0.0304985885,
-0.0358022861,
0.0148592731,
0.0253916401,
-0.0462048948,
-0.0341517292,
0.0117561985,
0.0481819138,
-0.0032675522,
-0.0295548066,
-0.0335394554,
-0.0371522866,
-0.0309008379,
-0.0158291608,
-0.0114659006,
-0.0798229948,
0.036602322,
0.0118011991,
-0.0090247113,
-0.0291122664,
1.901984757e-34,
0.0134364767,
-0.0309640374,
0.0407270342,
0.0080762496,
0.0207452886,
0.0152859921,
-0.0022704566,
-0.0204438027,
0.0171238389,
-0.0722809955,
0.0041873776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17330v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17330v2 | Biomedical knowledge graph-optimized prompt generation for large language models | 2023-11-29T03:07:00 | 2024-05-13T22:48:04 | Karthik Soman, Peter W Rose, John H Morris, Rabia E Akbas, Brett Smith, Braian Peetoom, Catalina Villouta-Reyes, Gabriel Cerono, Yongmei Shi, Angela Rizk-Jackson, Sharat Israni, Charlotte A Nelson, Sui Huang, Sergio E Baranzini | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are being adopted at an unprecedented rate, yet
still face challenges in knowledge-intensive domains like biomedicine.
Solutions such as pre-training and domain-specific fine-tuning add substantial
computational overhead, requiring further domain expertise. Here, we introduce
a token-optimized and robust Knowledge Graph-based Retrieval Augmented
Generation (KG-RAG) framework by leveraging a massive biomedical KG (SPOKE)
with LLMs such as Llama-2-13b, GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4, to generate meaningful
biomedical text rooted in established knowledge. Compared to the existing RAG
technique for Knowledge Graphs, the proposed method utilizes minimal graph
schema for context extraction and uses embedding methods for context pruning.
This optimization in context extraction results in more than 50% reduction in
token consumption without compromising the accuracy, making a cost-effective
and robust RAG implementation on proprietary LLMs. KG-RAG consistently enhanced
the performance of LLMs across diverse biomedical prompts by generating
responses rooted in established knowledge, accompanied by accurate provenance
and statistical evidence (if available) to substantiate the claims. Further
benchmarking on human curated datasets, such as biomedical true/false and
multiple-choice questions (MCQ), showed a remarkable 71% boost in the
performance of the Llama-2 model on the challenging MCQ dataset, demonstrating
the framework's capacity to empower open-source models with fewer parameters
for domain specific questions. Furthermore, KG-RAG enhanced the performance of
proprietary GPT models, such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. In summary, the proposed
framework combines explicit and implicit knowledge of KG and LLM in a token
optimized fashion, thus enhancing the adaptability of general-purpose LLMs to
tackle domain-specific questions in a cost-effective fashion. | [
0.0650210902,
0.0105662458,
0.0100626973,
0.0101339454,
-0.0304491613,
-0.003915146,
0.0150821609,
0.0339374319,
0.056128934,
-0.0301288944,
-0.0098166643,
-0.0250945203,
-0.018992316,
0.0298185721,
0.0295181889,
0.0003777825,
0.0460515693,
0.0293819606,
0.0428487435,
-0.0295507349,
-0.01229183,
0.0063264882,
-0.0141775114,
0.018057311,
0.0192016121,
-0.0253887195,
0.0238676835,
0.0073441421,
0.0372937061,
-0.0797327831,
0.0090295728,
0.0458893217,
-0.0018166431,
0.0184072144,
0.0000020913,
-0.0623090826,
-0.0256764796,
0.0357398912,
-0.049359262,
0.0092156306,
0.0253611635,
0.030317286,
0.0214958321,
0.0164015312,
-0.0318991095,
-0.0246669855,
0.0355713665,
0.0216123294,
0.0366676934,
0.0581069775,
0.0021576926,
0.0035873496,
0.049037803,
-0.0215441957,
0.0396470539,
-0.0207609851,
0.0550363883,
-0.0165083725,
0.039983578,
0.0370602757,
0.0068509518,
0.044113297,
-0.0042849784,
0.0082611982,
0.0399926789,
0.055819951,
-0.0309200957,
-0.0018952405,
0.0030608373,
0.0840281323,
0.0436704122,
-0.0282274168,
0.0286056008,
0.0013743134,
0.0037858074,
0.0383387432,
-0.0574975125,
0.0051481719,
-0.0420420878,
-0.0213918351,
-0.0091627892,
-0.033261463,
0.0349902138,
0.0096785426,
-0.0207372289,
0.0439338498,
0.0416028239,
-0.0201350749,
0.0123053957,
-0.0163842086,
-0.0381878652,
-0.0401390158,
0.0403303392,
0.0341608338,
-0.0493124612,
0.0256663933,
0.0020916187,
-0.0326778963,
0.0938609242,
-1.025e-7,
-0.0197471995,
0.0178619046,
-0.0300902668,
0.015671134,
-0.0390102118,
0.0282523781,
-0.0293662008,
0.0248169452,
-0.0412179641,
0.003362054,
-0.049007386,
-0.039956592,
-0.0395270213,
0.0498059504,
-0.0540504418,
0.0077094198,
-0.0832686722,
0.0232050642,
0.0130920382,
-0.012341436,
0.0248492975,
0.04797462,
-0.0331070311,
0.0152340597,
-0.0306299906,
0.0334121436,
-0.0020016262,
0.0005128955,
0.023344323,
-0.0468574874,
-0.0128562376,
-0.0013098472,
0.0257632509,
-0.0274745226,
0.0177694205,
0.0470123626,
0.0088253906,
-0.0181892756,
0.0117689231,
-0.0603153333,
-0.0407943651,
-0.0485145561,
0.0034292981,
-0.0635223612,
0.0523433872,
0.0254412796,
-0.0137049844,
-0.0153979063,
0.0236045066,
0.0445536077,
-0.0479383543,
0.0369159766,
-0.0361311771,
-0.0050541204,
0.0428340323,
0.0198647492,
-0.0115491133,
0.0006265573,
-0.0197744295,
-0.0221769474,
0.015433901,
0.0037839983,
-0.0427221805,
-0.0221468396,
0.0816789865,
-0.0179905724,
0.014764877,
0.0313188136,
0.0287504848,
0.0779110119,
-0.0213071462,
0.0737390891,
-0.0310140792,
-0.0129311504,
0.0145365912,
0.0581395403,
0.0099960007,
-0.0269091986,
0.054950092,
-0.013175874,
0.019666044,
-0.0057486417,
-0.0296052322,
0.0039642458,
-0.0246025436,
0.0250919666,
0.0279512908,
0.0234291889,
-0.0090092653,
-0.0000545352,
-0.0104996888,
0.0208805539,
-0.0334309712,
0.0295039285,
0.0131007237,
-0.0163243301,
-0.0528491847,
0.0514469892,
0.0478987247,
-0.0451457612,
0.0026890852,
-0.0491805263,
0.0310118552,
0.0416057147,
0.0670600608,
-0.0340253152,
-0.0550502874,
0.0081414785,
-0.0136544919,
0.0377193466,
0.018551968,
-0.0378695279,
-0.0185560584,
-0.0472614951,
-0.016614683,
0.0030770241,
-0.0147738392,
-0.0075657642,
0.0304809827,
0.0348564647,
0.0234604105,
-0.0449030288,
-0.0018088492,
0.0239694174,
-0.0666558668,
-0.0201213323,
0.0133695304,
-0.0256454591,
0.0428810604,
0.0476433411,
0.0057872934,
0.0578118227,
0.0600485243,
-0.0390703827,
-0.0148719857,
-0.0271989815,
-0.0554853603,
-0.0809456557,
0.0510064065,
0.0121381842,
0.0043522175,
-0.0339967348,
-0.0401502959,
-0.0498985946,
-0.0467403382,
-0.0238433629,
0.0423781835,
-0.0538701937,
-0.0117566986,
0.0234234519,
-0.0165154953,
-0.0623647459,
0.0634681061,
0.0022899252,
0.0208864398,
0.049959179,
-0.0107726622,
0.0187509824,
-0.0506736264,
-0.0128043117,
0.0178235993,
-0.0015020826,
-0.0005113014,
0.0297528449,
0.0048586531,
-0.0696929768,
0.0163821895,
-0.136236012,
0.0346517377,
0.0224805847,
0.0033931581,
0.0143072391,
0.0209786948,
0.0023670818,
-0.0065897093,
-0.0869450122,
0.0072261905,
0.0273222607,
0.0334553123,
0.0213676002,
0.0328349024,
0.0145457406,
-0.0248679854,
-0.0151821394,
-0.0256531648,
0.0322541147,
0.0189705305,
0.009252226,
0.00925285,
0.0324658044,
-0.0673835576,
-0.0212904178,
0.0017540748,
0.0112704551,
0.0240557641,
-0.0124312229,
0.0388719812,
0.0228213742,
0.011343183,
-0.0063527767,
0.0206643566,
0.0136494907,
-0.0482857302,
0.0149995172,
-0.05835329,
-0.028903842,
0.0316578299,
-0.0229342114,
0.0117851011,
0.0209980831,
0.0405809134,
-0.0359712839,
-0.0443705507,
-0.0080152266,
0.0041183466,
0.003982259,
-0.057524737,
0.0270201843,
-0.0227419771,
0.0273450539,
-0.0122153116,
-0.0202689078,
0.1114677861,
-0.0151200742,
0.0338485092,
-0.0671004131,
0.0155239822,
-0.0231476277,
0.0088947145,
0.0044357614,
0.0392464399,
0.0068427492,
0.0015487216,
-0.0361092724,
0.0117433704,
-0.0072970907,
-0.0675576776,
0.0118415933,
-0.0191840902,
0.0349951275,
0.0236250367,
-0.0432168767,
-0.0488489494,
0.0114521319,
-0.0045752749,
0.0126585942,
0.0128711583,
-0.0073336498,
0.0090123592,
0.0037949055,
0.0331426337,
0.0457844548,
-0.0192818455,
-0.0027088537,
-0.011761345,
0.0521213077,
0.0591229424,
-0.0298171919,
0.026483316,
-0.006574769,
0.0295643266,
0.0738547668,
0.012804497,
-0.0121896183,
0.0347872712,
-0.007918315,
-0.0040894775,
-0.0401224047,
-0.0033910107,
0.0201325919,
0.0344222449,
-0.0477445535,
0.0033994154,
0.0903965905,
0.0305632241,
-0.0498415157,
0.0000205257,
-0.0245943721,
0.0135382628,
0.0061895726,
0.0482387766,
-0.1135343835,
-0.0196507666,
-0.0254118983,
0.0395612381,
-0.0320331715,
-0.0546053648,
0.001650354,
-0.0980468392,
0.0346392281,
0.002293264,
-0.0565154515,
-0.0197838172,
-0.0624326281,
-0.0008390056,
0.0332394354,
0.0075935433,
0.0471464694,
0.0058842157,
0.016293902,
0.0046517011,
0.0157283563,
-0.0754993036,
0.0324774273,
-0.0065939641,
0.0418618992,
0.0090545509,
0.0261684936,
0.0157197937,
-0.0225623436,
0.0178629514,
-0.0192863531,
-0.0030000801,
-0.0370610878,
0.0299044251,
0.0263626631,
0.0097370902,
-0.0733384192,
0.0419713333,
-0.0230422262,
-0.0355212279,
0.0143035622,
0.1073346138,
-0.0073196762,
-0.016821159,
-0.0483681262,
-0.0095089935,
0.002543302,
0.0741346329,
0.0230327006,
-0.0031614723,
-0.0153330276,
-0.0031922453,
0.0577034168,
-0.0249838307,
0.0085421018,
0.0244508628,
-0.0520306379,
0.0248497166,
-0.0800606757,
-0.0022955427,
0.0498743244,
0.0021551782,
-0.0015602553,
0.0437722281,
-0.0016891009,
-0.0257305689,
-0.0809551328,
0.0440838262,
-0.008652295,
-0.0018826426,
-0.0736465082,
-0.0255301408,
0.0673263967,
-0.033858262,
-0.013272359,
0.0416628346,
-0.0041929032,
-0.0714702681,
-0.0538268983,
0.0374535993,
0.0126672704,
0.0285376851,
0.0096002975,
-0.0091250539,
0.103809163,
0.0681092888,
-0.0470558777,
0.0017723393,
-0.0442303307,
-0.0031192782,
-0.0333338901,
0.009183161,
-0.0555769466,
0.0155222444,
-0.0007343336,
0.0685834214,
0.017199615,
-0.0198170692,
0.0566267483,
0.092021659,
0.0366613381,
-0.0384031385,
-0.0116741266,
-0.0374497622,
0.012334371,
-0.0397250466,
0.0129109053,
-0.0205162633,
0.0058359629,
0.0013226867,
-0.031343855,
0.0135549987,
-0.0439235568,
-0.0388545804,
0.0565889627,
-0.0278978795,
-0.0024200794,
-0.012620938,
0.019178316,
0.0973326787,
-0.0299289804,
-0.0312752277,
-0.0119874319,
-0.0160660837,
0.0319985487,
-0.0406000875,
0.0384632722,
0.0149074299,
-0.0127841085,
-0.0017034465,
0.0154079776,
-0.0567443557,
-0.0326155461,
-0.0263696909,
0.0344545022,
0.010660571,
0.0388646051,
0.0068077561,
-0.01444137,
-0.0366815515,
-0.04537661,
0.0210039672,
0.0057465741,
0.0030465461,
0.0679189265,
0.0309358276,
-0.013941017,
-0.0094494475,
0.0657019541,
0.0215241779,
0.0637423992,
-0.0162529591,
-0.0615139976,
-0.0528011471,
-0.0346275158,
-0.0023000594,
0.0386666842,
-0.0382617563,
0.0191650484,
-0.067632623,
-0.0527627133,
0.0368302166,
0.0066135596,
-0.0470885299,
-0.0088748531,
0.0468784571,
0.0330272168,
0.0112982877,
-0.0519446284,
-0.0178814381,
0.0864665806,
-0.0643367991,
-0.0519224219,
0.0317259505,
-6.490636056e-33,
-0.0085827867,
-0.0593915284,
0.0325084813,
-0.0278690364,
-0.0237247702,
0.0313269496,
-0.0637663156,
-0.025124725,
-0.0167458281,
0.0243215188,
-0.0187676195,
-0.0131093543,
0.0003458669,
0.0286390949,
-0.0347902216,
-0.0017980661,
0.0209878739,
-0.0133524211,
-0.004271619,
0.0766607523,
0.0391275026,
0.0510854572,
0.0224130955,
-0.0372883938,
0.0119759114,
-0.0087421341,
0.0461704694,
0.0103911329,
-0.0404441915,
0.0551433749,
-0.0546907522,
0.0605395548,
0.0238874517,
-0.018237995,
0.0295934752,
-0.0055364128,
-0.0828940645,
-0.029230345,
0.0321569778,
-0.0657642782,
-0.0582173616,
-0.0578985102,
0.0307486709,
-0.0199529398,
-0.0066938424,
-0.0134521462,
0.0099925846,
-0.0216012392,
-0.0556305163,
-0.0562386028,
-0.0284007285,
0.0197672434,
0.0261234064,
0.0212188438,
-0.0512598082,
0.0198480785,
-0.0213925615,
0.0693359077,
-0.022638008,
0.0160774086,
0.0059698615,
0.0073676361,
0.0083311079,
0.0033180369,
0.0240973178,
0.0383999199,
-0.0009909024,
-0.0252539162,
-0.0021889491,
0.0213261247,
-0.0402576849,
0.0294251461,
0.0181566384,
0.0539787263,
-0.0092192423,
-0.0283694435,
-0.1289193928,
0.023035923,
-0.0187082477,
0.0077634961,
0.0177135449,
-0.0220127534,
-0.006721959,
-0.0299615599,
-0.0278132595,
0.0011581281,
-0.0316084214,
-0.0204535164,
0.0274386983,
-0.0252329577,
-0.0420796014,
-0.0054731285,
0.0189601611,
-0.0159180667,
-0.0070039448,
0.0321082324,
-0.0003025601,
-0.0057421657,
-0.0216496885,
0.0425317585,
-0.0605274141,
0.0065622819,
0.0303159487,
-0.0379238427,
0.015627956,
0.0347616822,
0.0165212937,
-0.0142091839,
-0.0284606535,
0.0144353686,
-0.0283015668,
0.0201341547,
0.0001809358,
-0.0000899981,
-0.0000482415,
0.0493298694,
0.0299293343,
0.0592994802,
0.0421597548,
0.0022476788,
-0.0305861495,
-0.0107272305,
0.0115839429,
0.0240596719,
-0.0365699716,
0.0330830552,
0.0001910636,
0.0605761446,
0.0092958529,
-0.0425456539,
-0.0038627074,
0.0003701923,
2.897e-7,
0.0713200942,
0.0366012864,
0.0266000479,
-0.0281618852,
0.0247739665,
0.0044270265,
0.0221453365,
0.0024864748,
0.0135586904,
-0.0413492694,
0.0177218542,
0.0006668016,
-0.0143685183,
0.0102974344,
-0.0892717391,
0.0130329216,
-0.0686797798,
-0.0525155626,
-0.0485535525,
-0.0061987475,
0.0421216115,
0.0475570783,
-0.0343537256,
-0.0359990373,
0.0125169773,
-0.0143836467,
0.0557786189,
-0.005689627,
-0.0193160009,
0.0442029499,
0.0129945511,
-0.0116632087,
0.0160978902,
0.0490819849,
-0.0218584873,
-0.0115545141,
0.0009140082,
0.0633640587,
-0.017312251,
-0.0170354974,
0.0503599346,
-0.0189440344,
0.0346248783,
-0.0727559328,
0.0554487258,
-0.0421729945,
-0.0221489836,
-0.0066254339,
-0.0329506621,
-0.0263881963,
0.0249606278,
-0.0505002514,
-0.0091992002,
0.0281579867,
-0.0117146131,
0.0280805919,
-0.007786605,
-0.063774541,
-0.0102565503,
0.0166497547,
-0.063894324,
-0.0753192082,
-0.0122821722,
-0.0149308331,
-0.0026106187,
-0.082239449,
0.0262359772,
2.947482519e-34,
0.0289140977,
-0.0041611283,
0.0108997794,
-0.0011052098,
0.0336228758,
-0.0278339945,
-0.015770793,
0.0199412331,
0.0125350961,
-0.1044270024,
-0.0300290249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17311v1 | Universal Self-Consistency for Large Language Model Generation | 2023-11-29T02:07:09 | 2023-11-29T02:07:09 | Xinyun Chen, Renat Aksitov, Uri Alon, Jie Ren, Kefan Xiao, Pengcheng Yin, Sushant Prakash, Charles Sutton, Xuezhi Wang, Denny Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-consistency with chain-of-thought prompting (CoT) has demonstrated
remarkable performance gains on various challenging tasks, by utilizing
multiple reasoning paths sampled from large language models (LLMs). However,
self-consistency relies on the answer extraction process to aggregate multiple
solutions, which is not applicable to free-form answers. In this work, we
propose Universal Self-Consistency (USC), which leverages LLMs themselves to
select the most consistent answer among multiple candidates. We evaluate USC on
a variety of benchmarks, including mathematical reasoning, code generation,
long-context summarization, and open-ended question answering. On open-ended
generation tasks where the original self-consistency method is not applicable,
USC effectively utilizes multiple samples and improves the performance. For
mathematical reasoning, USC matches the standard self-consistency performance
without requiring the answer formats to be similar. Finally, without access to
execution results, USC also matches the execution-based voting performance on
code generation. | [
0.0101875365,
0.0723102838,
0.010396868,
0.0344271213,
-0.0488505214,
-0.001730568,
0.0142243449,
-0.034940172,
-0.0096600391,
-0.0368381999,
0.0101493942,
-0.0066328305,
-0.0301769171,
0.0113899903,
0.031547524,
-0.0089685544,
0.0273410529,
-0.0735051408,
-0.0201140791,
-0.055069305,
0.0025666091,
0.0198264606,
-0.0056591108,
0.0231778845,
0.0053936648,
-0.0635891333,
-0.0081704715,
-0.0279574115,
-0.0056276168,
-0.0326807499,
-0.0074773519,
0.0511452258,
0.0128732156,
0.0049099457,
0.0000024421,
-0.0648889542,
-0.0347343162,
0.0050875708,
-0.0537804104,
0.0128061147,
-0.0311814789,
0.0360123254,
0.0300229192,
0.0478968248,
-0.0356732979,
0.049450364,
0.0199446939,
-0.034305755,
0.1089989915,
0.0211386997,
0.0254984107,
-0.0137970792,
0.0080656987,
-0.0084875338,
0.0094853416,
-0.0283246003,
-0.0040275529,
0.068669565,
0.0083160363,
0.0146361804,
-0.0009311764,
0.0331369564,
0.0481023043,
-0.0185089838,
-0.0027773823,
0.034590546,
-0.0268048346,
0.0053810151,
-0.0043381411,
0.073453486,
0.0155080743,
-0.0322835557,
0.0162619948,
0.0076238788,
-0.0179378614,
0.0099564781,
-0.0618897341,
0.0712122247,
0.002547784,
0.010240919,
0.0285912361,
0.0220743176,
0.0082518682,
0.0201434493,
-0.0657351092,
0.0893367231,
0.0240612812,
-0.0306913331,
-0.0398917124,
0.0007927521,
-0.0341331884,
-0.1042825058,
-0.008980344,
0.0646333247,
-0.0413178988,
0.0110790748,
-0.0317291915,
-0.0197681356,
0.0289831515,
-0.0186026376,
0.0531296469,
0.0430974588,
-0.0090691401,
0.0351082608,
-0.0270096101,
0.0589182302,
-0.0468955711,
0.001896547,
-0.0631371439,
-0.0138299791,
-0.0427955799,
-0.0162491389,
-0.0274445098,
0.0776880905,
-0.0157276299,
-0.0100124944,
-0.0395720862,
0.0546209514,
-0.0232959371,
0.0222370047,
0.0188319776,
0.0221495423,
-0.0088703921,
-0.0208951514,
-0.0081321774,
0.0285560396,
-0.0590761527,
-0.0214668438,
0.0232355017,
-0.0586757809,
-0.0189238768,
0.0252277888,
-0.0023282277,
-0.0130069815,
0.0188391972,
0.0717390478,
-0.0070076268,
0.0271967184,
-0.0277059358,
-0.0485024191,
-0.0198736824,
-0.0783195421,
-0.0207785182,
-0.1315521002,
0.032837145,
0.0383215956,
-0.029472528,
-0.0176317543,
0.0176575761,
0.0097335549,
0.0291537158,
0.0326796509,
-0.0266672671,
0.022893697,
0.0471086949,
0.0037345227,
0.000641056,
0.052959457,
0.0295151323,
0.0070319884,
0.0364999697,
0.0019737596,
0.0131308278,
0.0245654099,
0.0299193561,
0.0154245449,
0.0084867012,
0.0700247586,
0.0170780215,
0.0177786779,
0.0091949711,
0.0571098141,
-0.0199301727,
0.000678089,
0.0213272925,
0.0433979444,
0.0146308234,
0.0133967744,
0.0609379672,
-0.0095747951,
0.0281639472,
0.0274465475,
-0.0433559939,
0.0430410579,
-0.0391132012,
0.0417574383,
0.0537582152,
0.0332241878,
-0.0349409617,
-0.0542169325,
-0.0042123399,
0.0131948739,
-0.0413404927,
0.0382090956,
0.0320786461,
-0.017134143,
0.0025124813,
0.0741870925,
0.0026744632,
-0.0545657314,
-0.0029171288,
-0.0476215258,
0.0752065256,
0.0255334508,
0.0398514494,
0.0122295236,
-0.0316690169,
-0.0241432749,
0.0427407622,
0.0172109697,
0.0152768092,
-0.0182272159,
-0.0078131091,
-0.0204806998,
-0.0103967497,
-0.014846853,
-0.0297242068,
0.0058827796,
0.0194906592,
0.0016393859,
0.0279623531,
-0.0311627965,
0.0005916734,
0.0231362823,
-0.0380711481,
-0.0218243655,
0.0125383977,
-0.0117191253,
0.0334133133,
0.0129574742,
-0.0393106379,
0.0521093756,
0.0005312379,
-0.0458253101,
-0.0281652696,
-0.0268037096,
-0.0999043733,
-0.0198277552,
0.0616667159,
-0.0061316425,
-0.033593297,
-0.0061283889,
-0.0288847964,
-0.0386640094,
0.0443616286,
-0.0443506688,
-0.0312344693,
-0.0451497883,
0.0133886253,
0.0160932057,
-0.0315979347,
-0.0319798104,
0.0790776536,
0.0161690172,
0.0138651244,
0.0411784276,
0.0422365852,
0.0177426953,
-0.0489168502,
-0.0012106681,
0.023100175,
-0.0229760129,
0.0182674732,
0.0480733216,
0.0329947211,
-0.0433202311,
-0.0415114164,
-0.0725113451,
0.0212466493,
-0.0262135807,
0.0256441254,
0.0473004878,
0.0153402258,
0.0078381663,
-0.000941137,
-0.0727399439,
-0.0305042695,
0.0411623642,
0.0084612807,
0.0339669921,
0.0001420995,
-0.0196926165,
-0.0446293205,
-0.0191513114,
-0.0176285189,
0.0539704971,
-0.008591135,
0.0302589349,
-0.0765292719,
0.0090381531,
-0.0812884271,
0.0097618764,
0.0131484363,
-0.0108840074,
0.0301108677,
-0.0423909128,
0.0397428907,
0.0382164605,
0.030681733,
-0.0377293527,
0.0687973425,
-0.0205548871,
-0.0950033814,
0.0039875102,
-0.0040497803,
-0.0271316394,
0.0245868247,
-0.0149290916,
0.03100596,
0.0596759096,
0.0263317525,
-0.021440573,
-0.026610611,
0.0321273282,
0.0006058347,
0.0091153281,
-0.0540561229,
-0.0329263955,
-0.0005326555,
0.0605581738,
0.0013386724,
-0.0581910536,
0.0740383789,
-0.0527336486,
0.0139053734,
-0.034799099,
-0.000012576,
-0.0518624969,
0.0702920109,
-0.0128127132,
0.0375783071,
0.0104971519,
0.0111691551,
-0.0450480282,
-0.0213285219,
0.0485315733,
-0.0581223853,
0.0721651092,
-0.0529584102,
0.0258705486,
-0.0044272952,
-0.0569245592,
-0.0625555664,
-0.0313351303,
-0.0171578452,
0.0090827337,
-0.0022350459,
0.0041118613,
0.0437467545,
-0.007653737,
0.0369668528,
0.010248634,
-0.0346252993,
-0.023158364,
-0.0106368018,
0.0468507446,
0.0621650629,
0.0247700363,
0.0432799421,
-0.0085938564,
0.0390418731,
0.0623860583,
0.053926494,
0.0584069043,
-0.0341732018,
0.0067311474,
0.0058838329,
-0.0395410843,
-0.0249907225,
0.0359467044,
0.0530388542,
-0.0410234407,
-0.007512765,
0.118427746,
0.0380299799,
-0.0120348772,
-0.0038587956,
-0.0575161763,
0.0457305089,
0.0359239094,
0.0483952723,
-0.0902210549,
-0.0219920557,
-0.0052972394,
0.029375799,
-0.0103530595,
-0.0376799516,
-0.000345932,
-0.1097562462,
0.0249314196,
0.0140137244,
-0.0164151173,
-0.0004516921,
-0.0251266193,
0.0118091796,
0.0137266014,
-0.0340238661,
0.0643060207,
-0.0080052502,
0.0249563493,
0.0119561963,
-0.0097803343,
0.0126276948,
0.0395452343,
-0.039501857,
0.0198026281,
0.0660420805,
-0.0021164266,
0.0184617527,
-0.0380380601,
0.0329561979,
-0.0446453318,
-0.0150841,
-0.0163324047,
-0.0001860203,
0.0118792802,
-0.0096272472,
-0.0167158991,
0.0483539738,
-0.0357482173,
-0.0116313975,
0.0541773587,
0.0749309212,
-0.0050702882,
-0.0077484469,
-0.0254880171,
0.0075972117,
-0.0162741449,
0.0644828677,
0.0249063913,
-0.0382645167,
-0.0413014665,
-0.0357428305,
-0.016983008,
-0.0291499961,
-0.0306358524,
0.0034484544,
0.0342156217,
0.034846615,
-0.0629236102,
-0.0199697092,
0.0166370738,
0.0473052785,
-0.0115883565,
0.011568727,
0.0202288777,
0.0022882214,
-0.0233921614,
-0.0048358315,
-0.0664786622,
0.0069192089,
-0.0347395204,
0.0217147209,
-0.0011800893,
-0.0193558838,
-0.018521497,
0.0497628786,
-0.0788590908,
-0.0484687351,
-0.0278194472,
0.0483502261,
0.0216608047,
0.0348966084,
0.0040435456,
0.0024764165,
-0.0006209416,
0.0084822737,
-0.0213840045,
0.0214416236,
0.0008353328,
0.015425602,
0.0053032334,
0.0303897336,
-0.0577015504,
0.0169803482,
0.0039145532,
0.0495731123,
0.0123085324,
-0.0466350578,
0.0445118919,
0.0694077238,
-0.033901494,
0.0058129239,
0.034195561,
0.007787325,
0.0062664943,
-0.0199107584,
-0.0425957069,
-0.0386296324,
0.0392289013,
-0.0257081836,
-0.0669957027,
0.0446262732,
-0.0215649381,
0.0001619736,
0.0321927071,
-0.0058226897,
0.0041584717,
-0.0282968804,
0.039419435,
0.0325524583,
-0.036437612,
-0.0342135914,
-0.0193771124,
-0.0030353542,
0.0398313478,
-0.0268028695,
0.050653249,
0.0225911643,
-0.0045512873,
-0.0141150309,
0.0255649164,
-0.0821781009,
-0.0893502757,
-0.0271555521,
-0.0037392322,
0.0403246209,
0.0419766568,
0.0297768265,
-0.0132658742,
-0.0099215852,
-0.0168270282,
0.0396279283,
0.0406158678,
-0.0081565315,
0.0137019493,
0.0360943787,
-0.0071860338,
-0.0330110304,
0.0641599894,
-0.024940446,
-0.0033287341,
0.0123385107,
0.0110445321,
-0.0396620184,
-0.0234065428,
-0.0560832284,
-0.0025848059,
0.0000308428,
-0.0381098352,
-0.0293373521,
-0.0603280514,
0.0089191161,
0.052372314,
-0.0005033239,
0.0114186555,
0.0488761924,
0.0910342112,
0.0140834264,
-0.018691849,
-0.0176158734,
0.0515350476,
-0.0243276358,
-0.039374806,
-0.0168629345,
-6.812859629e-33,
-0.0157046933,
-0.0270682946,
0.0484831892,
-0.0401187465,
-0.0104873311,
-0.009538196,
-0.061724294,
0.0121874902,
-0.0104855467,
-0.0249858145,
-0.0083119981,
-0.0041876114,
-0.0034756421,
0.0192412939,
0.0345910043,
-0.010128215,
0.0266569573,
-0.0136919571,
-0.0404858291,
0.024749238,
0.0142269796,
-0.0270367116,
-0.0042676697,
-0.0444662757,
0.0029769014,
-0.0323189348,
0.0001951118,
0.0246653389,
-0.0168896224,
0.0708935782,
-0.0185534507,
0.0259920862,
0.0037173245,
-0.0561399162,
-0.0270047188,
-0.0104146181,
-0.0409063697,
-0.0350200608,
0.0159478057,
-0.0636683926,
-0.0801369175,
-0.0371583924,
0.0275854468,
-0.0085261045,
-0.0128747346,
-0.0354713574,
-0.0021990309,
0.0005231281,
0.0165977795,
0.002766392,
-0.0287821349,
0.0180428848,
-0.033035472,
-0.0259179529,
-0.0088682994,
0.0504928157,
-0.0055260374,
0.0359892957,
0.0006821988,
0.0140445624,
0.0184197575,
0.0436902866,
0.086372219,
-0.0167766232,
0.0056754565,
0.0402708128,
0.0091278274,
-0.0370138884,
-0.0655009896,
-0.0279467758,
-0.0352578461,
0.0521214902,
0.073591128,
0.0187463742,
0.0079668975,
0.0502331108,
-0.0811672583,
0.0175866634,
-0.0113270879,
0.0051933476,
0.0234861393,
-0.0165766496,
-0.0206298418,
-0.0140580246,
-0.0627462342,
-0.0118911769,
-0.0391603857,
-0.041048944,
0.0364746712,
-0.0139845712,
-0.0420168787,
-0.0228977297,
0.0450183526,
-0.0447683744,
-0.0405854955,
0.0480601229,
-0.0399589911,
0.0279847346,
0.0124449534,
0.0402172655,
-0.0177590307,
0.0493308939,
-0.02093984,
0.0073899096,
0.0163906813,
0.0447661467,
-0.0068497919,
-0.0135354148,
-0.0569227636,
0.0024954048,
-0.061067801,
0.0067674946,
-0.0288911052,
-0.0211534686,
0.0191398673,
0.0179834366,
0.0131773716,
0.0459044278,
-0.0200169906,
-0.0440562814,
-0.045612514,
0.0416654535,
0.0120068435,
0.0440767519,
-0.0064927745,
0.0109618027,
-0.0563147552,
0.0658165738,
0.0137449484,
-0.0274623577,
-0.0205615535,
0.0372743942,
3.012e-7,
0.0266104508,
0.0198232848,
0.0309026949,
0.0445245765,
0.002490201,
0.0297682732,
-0.0064447774,
-0.0032655164,
0.0194823667,
-0.046080038,
-0.0461717062,
0.0545441955,
0.0353674516,
0.0645641983,
-0.0505539514,
0.012355499,
-0.0911714137,
0.0028520245,
-0.0421871245,
-0.0131264701,
0.0706503615,
0.0656789467,
-0.0190507602,
-0.0006764064,
0.0018383708,
-0.0075118211,
0.0449494459,
0.0139297945,
-0.0045462633,
0.034200646,
-0.0264354218,
-0.0374457464,
0.022554785,
-0.0020562278,
0.0122414576,
-0.0113292849,
-0.0057152607,
0.0509626679,
0.0344090201,
0.0242176428,
-0.0303065386,
-0.0344188176,
0.0295468774,
-0.0795697495,
0.0847508907,
-0.0545485504,
-0.0164222233,
-0.0546865836,
0.0001918758,
-0.0185188949,
0.0222822335,
-0.0072024474,
0.0112434011,
0.0368895084,
0.0007676686,
-0.0024739846,
-0.0048728744,
-0.0393904634,
-0.0465963483,
-0.0114152301,
-0.0292439424,
-0.0408214293,
-0.043818675,
0.003187231,
0.0301505346,
-0.0544929318,
-0.000784173,
2.866419097e-34,
0.0146242566,
-0.0143256346,
0.0395682119,
0.0162067506,
0.0381552875,
-0.0217307191,
-0.0286605768,
-0.0014028485,
-0.0069228923,
-0.0703881457,
-0.0517413616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17307v1 | RoKEPG: RoBERTa and Knowledge Enhancement for Prescription Generation of Traditional Chinese Medicine | 2023-11-29T01:59:38 | 2023-11-29T01:59:38 | Hua Pu, Jiacong Mi, Shan Lu, Jieyue He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) prescription is the most critical form of
TCM treatment, and uncovering the complex nonlinear relationship between
symptoms and TCM is of great significance for clinical practice and assisting
physicians in diagnosis and treatment. Although there have been some studies on
TCM prescription generation, these studies consider a single factor and
directly model the symptom-prescription generation problem mainly based on
symptom descriptions, lacking guidance from TCM knowledge. To this end, we
propose a RoBERTa and Knowledge Enhancement model for Prescription Generation
of Traditional Chinese Medicine (RoKEPG). RoKEPG is firstly pre-trained by our
constructed TCM corpus, followed by fine-tuning the pre-trained model, and the
model is guided to generate TCM prescriptions by introducing four classes of
knowledge of TCM through the attention mask matrix. Experimental results on the
publicly available TCM prescription dataset show that RoKEPG improves the F1
metric by about 2% over the baseline model with the best results. | [
0.0620654225,
0.030277824,
-0.0033353725,
0.0102155609,
0.0150465723,
0.0053871716,
-0.0204413999,
0.0336300023,
0.037425559,
-0.0394930393,
-0.0058859233,
-0.006332322,
-0.0211220924,
0.0157113634,
0.0201077405,
-0.0554389954,
0.0203194432,
0.0433814898,
0.016793035,
0.0177893322,
0.0033749882,
-0.0089415852,
0.0030926976,
0.0323121995,
-0.0195767507,
-0.0557817109,
0.0373627841,
-0.0027679466,
0.0443385839,
-0.0941392183,
0.0146686984,
0.0286809094,
-0.0348411463,
-0.0340974517,
0.0000019497,
-0.0362178907,
-0.014997228,
0.007235677,
-0.0032854627,
-0.0572435558,
0.0271356925,
-0.0131016728,
0.0056144232,
0.0026970613,
-0.0290399399,
-0.0129925087,
0.0226920862,
0.1124936119,
0.014948356,
0.0920297951,
-0.0020868119,
-0.0061300932,
0.0170961935,
-0.0380240455,
0.0557151884,
-0.0325403363,
0.0445301384,
0.0368789323,
-0.0115804411,
-0.0223701764,
-0.0395079069,
-0.0004253383,
-0.0230576359,
0.0116162719,
0.0341335572,
0.0244504306,
-0.0182350744,
-0.021781439,
0.0215270873,
0.1040910259,
-0.0175760649,
0.0022963237,
0.0186680481,
0.0145524628,
0.0259360354,
-0.0069664107,
-0.0192381945,
-0.01463449,
-0.057350751,
0.0497476719,
0.0349866115,
0.0183343291,
0.021487508,
-0.0094624311,
0.0091026109,
0.0083133113,
-0.0121751437,
-0.0157731026,
-0.0041580242,
-0.0633188188,
-0.0333922394,
-0.0395449661,
0.0365656167,
0.0226748437,
-0.0503159575,
0.0227359515,
-0.0126415733,
-0.0004008503,
0.0741367266,
-0.0408989862,
0.0426666625,
0.0240570344,
0.0007659894,
0.0258200467,
-0.0414276347,
0.0216054376,
-0.0188483912,
0.031894248,
-0.0869604275,
0.0268649589,
-0.0774967372,
-0.0198405012,
-0.0634441897,
0.0039284853,
0.0016715203,
-0.0393237025,
-0.1146354005,
-0.007406217,
-0.0428556651,
-0.0175760854,
0.0250818674,
0.0495910309,
-0.0169562381,
0.0240609217,
-0.0208555162,
0.0178363267,
-0.0238524675,
0.0086223604,
0.0002389781,
-0.0008739535,
0.0342281424,
0.0188337993,
-0.0023536542,
-0.0169264115,
0.02456454,
0.0106132152,
0.0091755204,
-0.0095818182,
-0.036885526,
-0.043390058,
-0.0400237627,
-0.0574387573,
0.0066790534,
-0.033836782,
0.0238053743,
-0.0358587615,
0.0231678858,
-0.0157521684,
0.0204730965,
-0.0067436504,
-0.0333105996,
0.049003046,
0.0144591378,
0.0024189204,
0.0068932334,
-0.0091699893,
0.0093947491,
0.0137179345,
0.0327787958,
0.0109267477,
-0.0012942021,
-0.0202308167,
0.0240462832,
-0.0349368826,
0.0253773648,
-0.0395035073,
0.0228911657,
0.0231354982,
-0.0092176227,
0.0548084639,
-0.0367100127,
0.0561646335,
0.004800193,
0.0288405232,
0.0320943482,
-0.0125850243,
0.0788824186,
0.0129607916,
0.0415626504,
-0.0554494821,
-0.0344527289,
0.0227552988,
-0.0071993335,
0.0124771912,
-0.0220309943,
0.0409796312,
0.0058864099,
-0.0073320637,
-0.0488380007,
-0.060718365,
-0.0199741386,
-0.0207955372,
-0.0342932977,
0.0002421037,
0.0164122637,
0.0110615585,
-0.031580545,
0.0168734267,
0.0488811582,
-0.0016933501,
-0.0242039803,
-0.0264855865,
-0.0101482663,
0.0839660987,
0.0349039994,
-0.0351941995,
0.0266548507,
0.0069681741,
-0.0406617597,
-0.0024536501,
0.0091691362,
-0.0191351175,
-0.0294625629,
-0.0412178561,
-0.0033588992,
0.0278695021,
0.0081059644,
-0.0141358133,
-0.0148768732,
0.0298702288,
-0.0029307331,
-0.023337476,
-0.0286093187,
0.0315322652,
-0.0229332354,
-0.0800706446,
0.0224425904,
0.0020437618,
0.0454990901,
0.0174429473,
0.0218085535,
0.0476795249,
0.0404232293,
-0.0586359277,
-0.037479572,
0.0142366774,
0.0099453675,
-0.061358016,
0.0065783546,
-0.0364144221,
0.017043924,
-0.0027979626,
-0.062880747,
-0.0490502641,
-0.0029526011,
-0.0145655889,
0.0505186059,
-0.0346583165,
0.0142076677,
0.0756811947,
0.0289730709,
-0.0291426182,
0.029792957,
-0.0014757523,
0.0194732156,
0.0255101155,
-0.0649209768,
-0.0202743318,
-0.0300732888,
-0.0097373994,
-0.0150086079,
-0.0075015845,
0.009161259,
-0.035438709,
0.0166762751,
-0.0180344488,
-0.0171576161,
-0.0447689705,
-0.0114095528,
0.0265265536,
-0.0362207144,
-0.0051596616,
-0.0116267884,
-0.0009867428,
-0.0249689128,
-0.0723030046,
0.0090747029,
0.0029661539,
-0.0273304265,
0.0151254125,
0.0299299061,
-0.0125819603,
-0.0214724541,
0.0007036758,
-0.0174244437,
0.0146501753,
0.0054221954,
-0.0462325737,
-0.0133785699,
-0.0393478088,
-0.0074749519,
0.0088115036,
0.0023301968,
-0.023971403,
-0.0358255729,
0.0201892499,
0.0235931594,
0.0188237503,
-0.0029144618,
-0.0391559713,
0.0443651453,
0.037356291,
-0.0039988449,
0.0349643528,
-0.0643507838,
-0.0448311903,
0.0440583974,
-0.0856794119,
0.005987878,
0.1025266573,
0.028484365,
-0.0008011999,
-0.0336426459,
-0.0493113548,
0.0140103102,
0.0328868851,
-0.0260474365,
0.0139089916,
-0.0461012013,
0.0030444802,
-0.0309358817,
-0.0567054376,
0.1000513583,
-0.0268194359,
0.0211329162,
-0.0874065161,
0.0456457511,
-0.0180341098,
-0.0567295887,
0.0348166004,
0.028575873,
0.0447942428,
0.0188752264,
0.0065084971,
0.0023917959,
0.0271935873,
-0.0430255458,
0.0470999554,
0.0294948909,
0.0062907529,
0.0105413552,
0.0053995266,
-0.0538530536,
-0.0121203875,
0.0195380971,
-0.018009875,
0.051451616,
0.0333213918,
-0.0076066335,
0.0589242093,
-0.0304806773,
0.0313152,
0.0072408561,
-0.028941093,
0.0115124378,
-0.0212866198,
0.0701616704,
-0.0425555892,
0.0108292485,
-0.0092925616,
0.0391752981,
0.0503875613,
0.0253716968,
0.0245143957,
0.0644176304,
0.0232897177,
-0.03955964,
-0.020933928,
0.0036389069,
0.0440317839,
-0.0327388309,
-0.0360455923,
0.0214433596,
0.093406193,
0.0166206211,
-0.0208701212,
0.0428349972,
0.006349396,
-0.0140452357,
-0.0059087905,
0.0026831045,
-0.0869274288,
-0.0028968318,
-0.0408458114,
0.0458157472,
-0.0175901353,
-0.0011893193,
-0.0016781832,
-0.0657736808,
-0.0008537085,
0.0325336903,
-0.0521106683,
-0.0334111229,
-0.0070802257,
-0.0404218063,
0.0172230601,
-0.0053863409,
-0.0085013881,
-0.0046530459,
-0.0045710648,
0.0204796381,
-0.0745007172,
-0.0248200763,
0.0179968402,
-0.0110371774,
0.0262373611,
0.0309346262,
0.0138477217,
0.0567510687,
-0.0156391747,
-0.0589778349,
-0.0133020878,
0.0315963961,
-0.0012803297,
0.0937623754,
-0.0081153475,
0.0066948798,
-0.0443481989,
0.0570649318,
-0.0861075968,
-0.0098435394,
-0.0188001823,
0.066050157,
-0.0018531184,
-0.0401498862,
-0.0201413184,
0.0460870564,
0.0444578715,
0.0635593086,
0.0152694555,
0.0389756374,
-0.0141758928,
0.0062285261,
0.0128148757,
-0.0448862165,
0.0057236282,
0.0701957643,
-0.049120497,
-0.0370481499,
-0.1235172153,
-0.0332128443,
0.0262971818,
0.0096320426,
-0.011504285,
0.0012991254,
-0.0049995724,
-0.0276237689,
-0.0332133956,
0.0222176947,
0.043193344,
-0.0101163285,
-0.0636508316,
-0.0596723557,
0.0472682603,
-0.0097197695,
0.0125841871,
0.0122742224,
-0.021968374,
-0.023176115,
0.0139827169,
0.0503491424,
0.02002188,
-0.0016112108,
-0.0221331678,
0.0176778343,
0.0488222614,
-0.0008793953,
0.0048656133,
-0.0434540287,
0.0070757838,
-0.0044027646,
-0.0007533364,
0.0200280547,
-0.0450983606,
0.0419807807,
0.0368133783,
0.0633751974,
-0.0076697948,
0.0122569893,
0.078211531,
0.0174922626,
0.005457418,
-0.045883283,
0.0267627388,
-0.0311306715,
0.0442876555,
-0.0074689095,
-0.0191832185,
-0.0270634685,
-0.0281575006,
0.0265518501,
-0.0086550331,
-0.0101868389,
-0.0053378376,
-0.0688132867,
-0.0608868748,
-0.0204328895,
-0.0125676496,
0.0109028695,
-0.0011198166,
0.0459042229,
0.0015538636,
-0.0098670414,
0.01743499,
-0.013151696,
0.0109018208,
0.0015896823,
0.0930643082,
-0.009028282,
0.045864258,
-0.0168517064,
0.0298223887,
0.0076750186,
-0.0642941892,
-0.0449519269,
0.0038600364,
0.0747476667,
-0.0477517098,
0.0408687852,
-0.0479998589,
0.0075939652,
-0.0524505936,
0.0333503485,
-0.0180181526,
-0.0096085137,
0.0272969585,
0.014617037,
-0.0340611562,
-0.0522843674,
0.1242991462,
-0.0284039788,
0.0051729656,
-0.0158341303,
-0.044479575,
-0.0574165359,
0.0129371285,
-0.007195319,
0.0091794869,
-0.0658632815,
0.0318755768,
-0.0689608231,
-0.0620071441,
0.0028489518,
-0.0281797368,
-0.011116744,
0.0226390958,
0.0321785696,
0.0182916559,
0.0134928813,
-0.0206846986,
-0.0503815934,
0.0442860387,
-0.0085855313,
0.0139122102,
0.0188722555,
-5.610725637e-33,
-0.0110863084,
-0.0033782974,
-0.0179405417,
0.0165970586,
0.0545958467,
0.0097511224,
-0.0407977328,
-0.0060105687,
-0.003034384,
0.045024436,
0.0052085114,
-0.0076729939,
0.012732177,
0.0555050597,
0.0058420072,
-0.0029410569,
0.0233906657,
0.0237470642,
-0.0028640621,
0.0147656007,
0.0367252454,
0.075898394,
0.0433281325,
-0.0537607297,
0.0093261534,
-0.0181584656,
0.0321034864,
-0.0086088255,
-0.0158211887,
0.0924696699,
-0.032118462,
0.0615950488,
0.0510598086,
-0.0001753768,
-0.0271744765,
-0.0324743986,
-0.0726514235,
0.0028313517,
-0.0199510418,
-0.0191818252,
-0.0245843846,
-0.0133802593,
0.0231505148,
-0.0159641858,
0.0379083119,
0.0214821212,
0.0448914878,
-0.0799910873,
-0.0295282193,
-0.0550598651,
-0.0364464745,
0.0198286753,
0.0027032534,
-0.0145319682,
-0.0381580554,
0.04587432,
-0.0456063896,
0.0265727676,
-0.036017552,
0.0053765629,
0.0336616114,
0.0469152927,
0.0051831356,
-0.0020022262,
0.0128028067,
0.0259818248,
0.0155108972,
-0.0214082841,
-0.0077280886,
0.0291831866,
-0.0515856482,
0.0526698306,
0.0363933444,
0.0209573917,
0.0523228906,
0.0107550696,
-0.0639531314,
0.0196901057,
-0.0547882989,
0.0474036038,
0.020043347,
-0.0108057177,
-0.0406668819,
-0.0376356691,
-0.005646694,
0.0198855698,
-0.0435491428,
-0.0070474967,
0.0366475321,
0.0251245741,
-0.0143053578,
-0.0267644711,
0.0100643262,
-0.0403693877,
-0.0029283399,
-0.0212619882,
0.0290022008,
0.026019657,
-0.0127276368,
-0.0280672368,
-0.0684737861,
-0.0054054246,
0.0253243037,
-0.0577636212,
0.0194835253,
0.0514569357,
0.0598440841,
-0.0405675657,
-0.040936131,
-0.0002521574,
0.017812198,
0.003596392,
0.0404184274,
0.0272865482,
0.0006889166,
0.0003962431,
-0.0094065359,
0.0753003359,
0.0255046859,
-0.0303642917,
-0.0371397547,
-0.0305283591,
0.0392535366,
0.0283776447,
-0.0516344346,
0.0110892374,
-0.0474398211,
0.0618279949,
0.0836613029,
-0.0515347533,
-0.008423279,
-0.0120660607,
2.787e-7,
0.0727351308,
-0.0194050167,
-0.0041332361,
0.0065043536,
0.0210031774,
0.003908867,
-0.0122778509,
0.0446229354,
-0.0176483002,
-0.0395702831,
0.0671346188,
-0.0122308843,
0.0485854521,
0.0164228715,
-0.0457404479,
-0.0513374135,
-0.0487780161,
-0.0416818149,
0.001884988,
-0.0249116868,
0.0076441369,
0.0962034389,
-0.0038029423,
-0.0173173212,
0.0495735109,
-0.0532628186,
0.0465195924,
-0.0404042006,
0.0151521331,
0.0699985698,
0.0462808497,
-0.0537049845,
-0.0250776168,
0.0452298969,
-0.0294286665,
-0.0277847219,
-0.0046807155,
0.0702518672,
-0.0421910286,
-0.0181949195,
0.0168926045,
0.0077273906,
0.0357073545,
-0.05723368,
0.0230876319,
-0.0503095537,
-0.0186079089,
0.0376822278,
-0.0173979141,
0.0078680813,
0.0679362789,
-0.027065143,
-0.0290578529,
0.0588538088,
0.0285389051,
0.0619379431,
0.0007618934,
-0.0677975118,
-0.0352220573,
0.0274486095,
-0.0533178002,
-0.0103921089,
0.0105434712,
-0.0782246813,
0.0185001735,
-0.0481530912,
-0.0183792636,
2.677961639e-34,
0.0313134491,
0.0084833195,
0.0283904485,
-0.0048885616,
0.0249050446,
-0.0286179595,
0.0085563632,
0.0089846272,
0.030300796,
-0.0964047089,
-0.052884046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17301v1 | Language Models: A Guide for the Perplexed | 2023-11-29T01:19:02 | 2023-11-29T01:19:02 | Sofia Serrano, Zander Brumbaugh, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Given the growing importance of AI literacy, we decided to write this
tutorial to help narrow the gap between the discourse among those who study
language models -- the core technology underlying ChatGPT and similar products
-- and those who are intrigued and want to learn more about them. In short, we
believe the perspective of researchers and educators can add some clarity to
the public's understanding of the technologies beyond what's currently
available, which tends to be either extremely technical or promotional material
generated about products by their purveyors.
Our approach teases apart the concept of a language model from products built
on them, from the behaviors attributed to or desired from those products, and
from claims about similarity to human cognition. As a starting point, we (1)
offer a scientific viewpoint that focuses on questions amenable to study
through experimentation; (2) situate language models as they are today in the
context of the research that led to their development; and (3) describe the
boundaries of what is known about the models at this writing. | [
0.0533870347,
0.0151543319,
-0.0658304691,
0.028039299,
-0.0924835205,
0.0109170089,
0.0155528327,
0.002140173,
0.0439571515,
-0.071428895,
-0.028487036,
-0.0299325287,
0.0140145505,
0.0553710647,
0.0304872077,
-0.0640827939,
0.0477127135,
-0.0220402218,
0.0338610895,
-0.0098673804,
0.0294635464,
0.0193920229,
-0.0296261944,
0.0912563428,
-0.0160030723,
-0.043362435,
-0.0268666819,
-0.0356125496,
-0.0566366687,
-0.0021643718,
-0.0040420666,
0.0235775001,
0.0171654932,
0.0485039018,
0.0000020278,
-0.0247255322,
0.0196097158,
-0.0171563476,
-0.0284149833,
-0.0068619903,
0.0711353794,
0.0557764806,
-0.0177602861,
0.0196556523,
-0.0497225262,
0.0147907324,
0.0556843504,
-0.0067030624,
0.0056596859,
0.0445320904,
-0.0166197959,
-0.0030006345,
0.0680649653,
0.0103334887,
0.0013301828,
-0.014371343,
0.0266490281,
0.0205128081,
0.0763549283,
0.0087106284,
-0.0201049335,
0.0556090102,
0.0329269245,
-0.0064295218,
-0.0206106063,
0.0375797041,
-0.0373506583,
-0.0648756549,
-0.0396383405,
0.012686627,
0.0435553454,
-0.0537234098,
0.0329172239,
0.0413047448,
0.0069535491,
0.0050925286,
-0.0522210002,
0.0382661745,
0.003644817,
0.0331036709,
0.0292287711,
-0.0388622731,
0.0163321272,
-0.0003327542,
0.0372125618,
0.0742377043,
0.0001275922,
-0.0062228115,
-0.0369296372,
0.0236521456,
0.0087934313,
-0.0772519112,
0.0140366042,
0.0522198454,
0.0121933399,
0.0351414159,
-0.0358711183,
0.0082939714,
0.0018906565,
-0.05636869,
0.0124725262,
0.0635770857,
0.0015732021,
0.0149676083,
0.0193815753,
0.0662723184,
0.0263889562,
0.0305011831,
-0.037278492,
0.0137514528,
-0.0725312382,
-0.0542152524,
-0.0783443823,
0.0336348489,
0.0058824457,
-0.043146003,
-0.0153653845,
0.0340513512,
-0.0044680731,
-0.0049039046,
-0.0351688266,
-0.0200809371,
-0.0147366319,
-0.0097851371,
-0.0217507482,
0.0187997688,
0.003198585,
0.019299591,
0.0093814209,
-0.1125950441,
0.0471255481,
0.0196153298,
-0.0525160208,
0.0125162583,
-0.0256609321,
0.0800863206,
-0.0124214711,
-0.0461250432,
-0.0326496549,
0.0017650883,
-0.0037893124,
-0.0758594126,
0.0015573909,
-0.0692952499,
0.0005350155,
0.041711621,
0.0066531156,
-0.0510653257,
-0.0044640563,
0.0113311419,
-0.031518463,
0.0479569472,
-0.0127087245,
0.023410365,
0.0383162796,
0.0220343191,
0.0069776964,
0.0587047823,
0.051653631,
-0.0088109178,
0.018511828,
-0.0232251082,
0.0096478909,
0.0414194986,
-0.0274449829,
-0.0189485345,
-0.0343396552,
-0.011984976,
-0.0175969172,
0.0016822709,
-0.0269864015,
0.0675045028,
-0.0150255365,
0.0060617179,
0.0904784873,
0.0941636786,
-0.0113261323,
0.0502940305,
0.0579558685,
0.013250133,
0.0406812243,
0.031996198,
-0.0273771267,
-0.0043997923,
-0.0463902988,
0.0105591873,
-0.0331689864,
0.0282911938,
-0.0214441717,
-0.0484795421,
-0.0118490681,
-0.0139139723,
0.0636960119,
0.0060486668,
0.0491495356,
-0.0123691112,
0.0091285743,
-0.0212189388,
0.0221461598,
-0.0246164091,
0.0165155455,
-0.1104230061,
0.0185805727,
0.066665642,
0.0500799157,
0.0046075871,
-0.0013726124,
0.00601443,
-0.0226697195,
0.0714778826,
0.0500241295,
-0.0100748604,
-0.0618067458,
-0.0130188633,
0.0242007095,
0.0057825949,
0.0209958758,
0.0160900932,
-0.0206046496,
0.0329724401,
-0.0293868724,
0.0054587978,
0.0038239839,
-0.0065493505,
-0.0692981556,
0.0034274466,
-0.0717536956,
-0.0177615155,
0.0209802538,
0.037431471,
-0.0033067358,
0.0213489439,
0.0213082265,
0.0138533926,
0.0020128982,
0.0519330539,
-0.0256134551,
0.046700269,
0.0304555185,
-0.0268830359,
0.014338294,
0.0111249443,
0.0475785509,
-0.042612385,
0.049373053,
-0.0358277,
0.0867392793,
-0.0237566791,
0.0306739528,
-0.0318273306,
-0.0081158252,
-0.0176674109,
0.0296627674,
-0.0002925063,
-0.0125678927,
-0.0064458083,
0.008499058,
0.0088975271,
-0.0299927555,
-0.0259260368,
0.0618226454,
0.0042427257,
0.0441237688,
0.0360653736,
-0.0076436829,
-0.0360305235,
-0.0116175637,
-0.1085452139,
-0.0240897853,
-0.0159125589,
-0.00597357,
0.0193969663,
-0.0096910298,
-0.024022121,
0.0115425661,
-0.0462366454,
0.0254161246,
0.0098568192,
0.0202850252,
0.0010987034,
-0.0169617794,
-0.044203084,
-0.0395363271,
-0.0113101145,
-0.0249472465,
0.0139453383,
0.0235869475,
-0.0442052931,
-0.0526963659,
0.0058198338,
-0.047698874,
0.0380002744,
-0.0194914751,
-0.029428551,
0.0691592023,
-0.0224221423,
0.0253241621,
0.0382461511,
-0.0230978411,
0.0730123892,
0.0361547135,
-0.0169659033,
-0.0462087095,
-0.0049448814,
-0.0217145681,
-0.0092322845,
-0.0384778082,
-0.0390199386,
-0.0382743329,
0.0834232271,
0.0347235277,
0.0129862884,
-0.065027535,
0.0526152961,
-0.0440598279,
-0.0329976305,
-0.0282224454,
-0.0298830774,
-0.0331148766,
0.042928189,
-0.0240153465,
-0.0612808056,
0.0672432035,
-0.0235619675,
-0.0132533554,
-0.0503755324,
-0.016799327,
-0.0023647211,
0.0507925972,
0.0168312006,
0.0208700635,
0.0195820052,
-0.0206729341,
-0.026288176,
0.0084701693,
-0.0065305433,
-0.0428929515,
0.0226430278,
-0.0763218999,
0.0159788765,
0.0255674273,
-0.01479863,
-0.0284185652,
0.0299487021,
-0.0435264558,
0.0188732706,
0.0404839925,
-0.0219931416,
-0.0367586464,
0.0304885078,
0.0364838652,
0.0390789248,
-0.0001100794,
-0.0060931798,
-0.0315142572,
-0.0076384456,
0.0459529087,
-0.0221611056,
0.0122110723,
0.007749049,
0.0328599215,
0.0490624681,
0.0176843982,
-0.0057473509,
-0.0160034765,
0.0235657077,
0.0537838861,
-0.0166627653,
-0.0622397773,
0.0186238568,
0.0333235003,
-0.0467106327,
-0.0202653781,
0.0883332044,
0.0199350715,
-0.0537463501,
0.016236363,
-0.0178541951,
0.0250406805,
0.0080585424,
0.0195790865,
-0.0757785589,
0.0130586745,
0.0173563845,
-0.0046926974,
-0.0186845418,
-0.0053944536,
-0.0314560421,
-0.0602396131,
0.0337891094,
0.0073256441,
-0.0607997589,
-0.0234821886,
0.0011797936,
-0.0064407135,
0.0224972107,
0.0555193163,
0.0013197544,
-0.0156574547,
0.008711216,
0.0102063995,
-0.0402722657,
-0.0318306684,
0.0115833841,
0.0104167061,
0.0929622948,
0.0863806307,
0.0250973236,
-0.0103315962,
-0.0079405354,
0.0016308927,
0.0320795737,
0.0114333052,
-0.0073788655,
-0.0019385444,
0.0026273795,
-0.0080822483,
-0.0273409989,
0.0171802789,
-0.0244774055,
-0.00395296,
0.0033039462,
0.0605078973,
-0.0345905386,
-0.0218552947,
-0.0106124692,
-0.0210751165,
0.0009332368,
0.0592344515,
0.0221142396,
-0.0534838215,
-0.0305202827,
-0.0630418435,
0.0032423879,
0.0330141857,
-0.0842583999,
0.0043544038,
0.0309834182,
-0.0337135866,
-0.0625175461,
-0.0691840127,
0.0192977004,
-0.0169486143,
0.0283785574,
0.0128988838,
0.0435822643,
-0.0027679065,
0.0053011635,
0.0074545918,
-0.0208483767,
-0.0193000603,
-0.0622016974,
-0.0394137278,
-0.0052202563,
-0.0749880299,
0.0012029469,
0.0074543585,
-0.0506875217,
-0.0850042105,
0.0278739668,
0.0251647346,
0.04011444,
0.0185373332,
-0.0157045461,
-0.0315243863,
-0.0037632098,
0.0105072577,
-0.0091823349,
0.0290253386,
0.0077117165,
-0.0150588267,
0.0247475635,
0.0111017842,
-0.0150805572,
0.0378867872,
-0.0281866025,
0.0203890037,
-0.035693083,
-0.042369891,
0.0555707961,
0.0162621234,
0.0328401886,
-0.0128334928,
0.0291741155,
-0.0243334547,
-0.0362050608,
-0.0451274849,
0.0098229786,
-0.0559281074,
-0.0319162458,
0.0022055227,
0.0270010475,
-0.0065747285,
-0.0470796749,
-0.0413957983,
0.023719959,
0.0021809635,
0.0399214849,
-0.0187605433,
0.0312389508,
-0.0050588483,
0.00665867,
0.001353866,
0.0561568737,
-0.0519881286,
0.0205121543,
-0.0124495989,
0.0757929981,
0.0159753449,
-0.0275148414,
0.0363593586,
0.0329917334,
-0.0419685207,
-0.0785162821,
-0.0017854279,
0.095124796,
0.0563613214,
0.009078403,
0.0340804234,
-0.0755286962,
0.0017964042,
-0.0240442958,
0.011907408,
0.0420799032,
-0.0467370339,
-0.0026698767,
0.0049164114,
-0.0108910389,
-0.005833657,
0.0477044806,
-0.0230622943,
0.0467179306,
0.0250617824,
-0.0094662774,
-0.0298193023,
-0.0385122336,
0.0135335652,
0.0024062309,
-0.0170820151,
0.0385326929,
-0.0631242916,
-0.0704166815,
-0.0315081142,
0.0209809486,
0.0254238937,
-0.0572100505,
0.0245365817,
0.0790762156,
-0.0127666006,
-0.0310529098,
-0.0508018807,
0.0115522519,
-0.0573965721,
-0.0242967382,
-0.0104997512,
-6.043974651e-33,
-0.0303779114,
-0.0314213708,
0.0595244132,
0.027028285,
-0.0020620162,
-0.0073992652,
-0.0313005857,
0.0412028804,
-0.0425413623,
0.0139661087,
-0.0092593301,
0.0055849622,
0.0052336422,
-0.0104350457,
-0.0086239707,
0.003752846,
0.021979481,
-0.0355475843,
0.005693445,
0.0175653789,
0.015322593,
-0.0232218672,
0.0592682362,
-0.0770573318,
0.0596547313,
-0.042558331,
-0.01074987,
-0.0169789288,
-0.0275314245,
0.0606424771,
-0.0435675234,
0.0487203747,
0.0323315263,
-0.0091283629,
-0.0202589557,
0.0336494185,
-0.037624348,
-0.027688887,
0.0500696003,
0.0277068317,
-0.0206280146,
-0.0294872969,
0.0259346236,
-0.046867162,
-0.0584106743,
0.0544232316,
0.0320511423,
-0.0216404963,
-0.0040853061,
0.0472039133,
-0.072923854,
-0.0073157684,
-0.0056675076,
-0.0332753435,
0.0405382961,
0.0482576117,
-0.0384053588,
-0.0120285507,
-0.0330282487,
0.0508432835,
0.0037824176,
0.019069368,
0.0732927844,
0.0044969516,
0.039595332,
0.0397378653,
0.0457526557,
0.0113659408,
-0.0215837676,
-0.0095685208,
0.0590614565,
0.015831681,
0.0537458472,
-0.0069245892,
-0.03927017,
-0.024329694,
-0.013247503,
-0.0273838975,
0.0621775053,
-0.0062346919,
0.0153172957,
0.0021686552,
-0.0767463744,
-0.0364619717,
-0.0072257924,
-0.0471693389,
-0.01705846,
-0.060261514,
0.0295115691,
-0.0425416566,
0.0181614757,
-0.0133076878,
0.0043239547,
-0.0530944429,
-0.0276555717,
-0.0127638774,
-0.0281373449,
0.0599071234,
0.0131355766,
0.036866542,
-0.0625563487,
-0.0091425581,
-0.0294050667,
0.0318764783,
0.0003771447,
0.0358308591,
-0.0229541343,
0.0398985073,
0.0025359646,
0.0055755647,
-0.0265070032,
0.0266193394,
0.0348546021,
-0.0508128218,
0.0442733653,
-0.0035266592,
0.0009003074,
0.0316635035,
0.0346967988,
-0.0095917163,
-0.0466765091,
-0.0030594973,
-0.0674683377,
0.0112322951,
-0.0440967679,
0.014071241,
-0.0801821351,
0.0405909196,
0.0400851443,
-0.0341775119,
-0.0115830954,
-0.0044019204,
2.663e-7,
0.0127007095,
0.062366873,
0.0191855486,
0.0122789182,
0.0499168485,
0.0228784531,
-0.0304129515,
0.0156372525,
0.0249654129,
0.0117316553,
-0.0100733517,
0.0495240465,
0.0343332365,
0.0006809633,
-0.0610259101,
-0.0042748088,
-0.0542113632,
0.0146690961,
-0.0530602932,
0.0591647774,
0.0508038141,
0.0411637574,
0.0259895846,
0.0066833547,
-0.0370897651,
-0.0334298089,
0.045083534,
-0.0455923118,
0.001153673,
0.0207575411,
0.0335832462,
0.0441833958,
-0.0073626228,
0.0100016836,
0.0068243849,
-0.002596325,
0.0013430234,
0.0657085553,
-0.0068621063,
0.0060061431,
0.018187277,
-0.0311168656,
-0.03289821,
-0.0785928369,
0.0606239177,
-0.0421525836,
-0.0385046713,
-0.0194748379,
0.0117389942,
-0.0004229295,
-0.0326266438,
-0.0133521026,
-0.0289435666,
0.0085759982,
0.004730233,
-0.033384826,
0.0231934488,
-0.0232540779,
0.0096305031,
-0.0167997479,
-0.0333768986,
-0.057598494,
-0.0444308743,
0.0032934879,
-0.0215711053,
-0.0263378285,
0.0028675448,
2.161104349e-34,
0.0138621628,
-0.0103568546,
0.0352517888,
0.0331723951,
0.0173263308,
0.012075454,
0.0579183735,
0.0280212834,
0.0261940286,
-0.0465467758,
-0.0343351252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17295v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17295v1 | Elo Uncovered: Robustness and Best Practices in Language Model Evaluation | 2023-11-29T00:45:23 | 2023-11-29T00:45:23 | Meriem Boubdir, Edward Kim, Beyza Ermis, Sara Hooker, Marzieh Fadaee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In Natural Language Processing (NLP), the Elo rating system, originally
designed for ranking players in dynamic games such as chess, is increasingly
being used to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) through "A vs B" paired
comparisons. However, while popular, the system's suitability for assessing
entities with constant skill levels, such as LLMs, remains relatively
unexplored. We study two fundamental axioms that evaluation methods should
adhere to: reliability and transitivity. We conduct extensive evaluation of Elo
behaviour, illustrating that individual Elo computations exhibit volatility and
delving into the impact of varying the Elo rating system's hyperparameters. We
show that these axioms are not always satisfied raising questions about the
reliability of current comparative evaluations of LLMs. If the current use of
Elo scores is intended to substitute the costly head-to-head comparison of
LLMs, it is crucial to ensure the ranking is as robust as possible. Guided by
the axioms, our findings offer concrete guidelines for enhancing the
reliability of LLM evaluation methods, suggesting a need for reassessment of
existing comparative approaches. | [
0.0374260023,
0.0356275253,
-0.0269935876,
0.0325084217,
-0.0230406784,
0.0091401227,
-0.0156278145,
-0.0139587699,
0.0192249306,
-0.0598247275,
-0.0598502792,
-0.0567100532,
0.054677844,
0.0143693797,
0.0133798989,
-0.0136971185,
0.0119194966,
-0.0076171244,
0.0293815844,
0.0130822212,
-0.0128408764,
-0.0341348425,
0.0009165385,
0.0612356327,
0.0762465671,
0.0399365239,
0.0509395227,
-0.0183637086,
0.0170721579,
-0.0249788575,
-0.0596258752,
0.0584281683,
-0.0381716639,
-0.0025961879,
0.0000020502,
-0.0601796694,
-0.0223747455,
-0.0067181736,
-0.0174672268,
0.0192068424,
0.0544134192,
0.0167402755,
-0.0116104688,
0.0077098091,
-0.0215617046,
-0.0141994599,
0.0146555835,
-0.0228329115,
0.0574135855,
0.0583075918,
0.0080835344,
-0.0134577276,
0.0474370457,
-0.0223963279,
-0.046759665,
-0.0416610055,
0.0162405483,
0.0189455803,
-0.0105948234,
0.0205664486,
-0.0045359749,
0.0349000767,
-0.0090237455,
0.0024827155,
0.0160269085,
0.0229338277,
-0.0484858714,
0.0001063083,
0.000723146,
0.0471252166,
-0.0345185921,
0.028305836,
-0.0083949044,
0.004200168,
-0.0005900669,
0.0243640151,
-0.0403711274,
0.024896238,
0.029616328,
-0.0004643495,
0.0319426991,
0.0288032833,
0.048565574,
0.0282756258,
-0.0062260916,
0.0811093226,
0.0203653257,
-0.0410545319,
0.0133634256,
0.0098914243,
-0.0645921007,
-0.0638813153,
-0.0020582946,
-0.0016246967,
-0.0196681861,
0.0380162932,
0.0211272053,
0.0396669991,
0.0206997097,
-0.068257533,
0.0599811897,
-0.0022965823,
0.032933291,
0.0336860977,
-0.0202515479,
0.0557521097,
0.0236972272,
0.024206223,
-0.002767679,
0.0086769937,
-0.0640944913,
-0.0414139777,
0.0263519157,
0.0495959334,
0.0108432639,
-0.0133963702,
-0.079508245,
-0.0059196209,
-0.0432660766,
0.0086015649,
-0.0077706082,
-0.0192246102,
0.0509334691,
0.0107561816,
-0.0784278065,
-0.0048331129,
0.0020889309,
0.0435528569,
-0.0499377251,
-0.0741949826,
0.0378712453,
-0.0094929915,
-0.0418884233,
-0.0341002308,
0.0043948879,
0.0665484071,
0.0679211691,
-0.0410569124,
0.0253952332,
0.0078907982,
-0.0379940346,
-0.0774981081,
-0.0260947533,
-0.078156665,
0.0059201396,
0.0201791171,
0.0263970606,
-0.0158597007,
0.0078859767,
0.0179519001,
-0.0498773418,
0.0586335063,
0.0304545853,
0.0009516387,
-0.0307020582,
-0.0091698188,
0.0231427755,
0.0618323386,
0.0626597181,
-0.0396408625,
0.0415896773,
-0.0104191052,
0.0092847692,
0.0495635308,
-0.0457169302,
0.0041464395,
-0.0040628584,
0.0059048068,
-0.0196826048,
0.0410094745,
-0.0139200734,
0.0529136993,
-0.0280986,
-0.0108306315,
0.0666891634,
0.041780062,
0.0361652002,
0.0178941861,
0.0354122333,
-0.0334333889,
0.0083430931,
0.014258381,
-0.0273236409,
-0.0171505921,
-0.0172574315,
0.0015374548,
0.0204019342,
0.0367421471,
0.0050147683,
-0.0644449443,
-0.0473763756,
0.0114639718,
0.0395483561,
-0.031770125,
0.0437280685,
-0.0420977362,
-0.023336105,
0.0585892238,
-0.0088051371,
-0.0638718009,
0.0126242563,
-0.0895354822,
-0.0390556268,
0.0680740252,
0.0422739498,
-0.0006119207,
-0.0138105731,
0.0024347766,
-0.001339398,
0.0334624425,
0.031859342,
0.0088967355,
0.0370154567,
-0.0187022705,
-0.0332286358,
0.0000352827,
0.0160632059,
0.0203285143,
-0.0169179495,
0.0284012705,
0.0108847646,
-0.0736859962,
-0.0674675032,
0.0375805013,
-0.0184857678,
-0.0290918052,
-0.0206062961,
-0.0129442941,
0.007942548,
0.041070234,
-0.0008665867,
0.0404753312,
0.014419863,
-0.0163552053,
-0.0141266575,
0.0197555833,
0.0083415061,
-0.0031472186,
0.0216669403,
-0.022145642,
0.0135703711,
0.0388862826,
-0.0121050235,
-0.0052909753,
0.0065264693,
0.0030331484,
0.0371894315,
-0.0081527717,
0.0507098399,
-0.0510541014,
0.006602684,
-0.0412988998,
0.0565038845,
-0.0172162205,
0.0929388553,
-0.0035544529,
0.0131500456,
0.013289473,
-0.0645248815,
-0.0372931994,
0.0356766582,
0.0236370564,
0.0037707083,
0.0358819477,
0.0046746959,
-0.0483662188,
-0.061597921,
-0.067690894,
0.0282914937,
-0.0274809357,
0.0150162783,
0.0291016344,
-0.0397581644,
-0.0104578817,
0.0387457423,
0.0218064114,
-0.0351996124,
0.0237945318,
0.0366277844,
0.0321994424,
-0.0223823059,
-0.0545509756,
-0.0339594856,
-0.0450211614,
-0.0191264488,
0.0855398476,
0.011305185,
0.0428203195,
-0.0533527248,
0.0470927246,
-0.0733137503,
-0.0096819373,
-0.000757363,
-0.0200433694,
0.0267777611,
0.0168873426,
-0.0106746685,
0.0347092673,
0.0178262331,
0.0305333845,
0.0665908679,
-0.0460652784,
-0.0320337228,
-0.0430162288,
-0.020373499,
-0.0132877836,
-0.0517580584,
-0.0432381071,
0.016147403,
0.0620745532,
0.002190137,
-0.028966669,
-0.0365585424,
0.0133690601,
-0.0473424271,
-0.0129766315,
-0.0068344981,
-0.0138554014,
-0.0207568519,
0.0065520541,
-0.0297745131,
-0.0572694354,
0.034125641,
-0.0246926099,
0.0455665886,
-0.0560651049,
0.0273036566,
-0.0554919653,
0.035232041,
0.0269310642,
-0.0049090371,
-0.0422895364,
-0.0354342498,
-0.0148320673,
-0.0248029996,
0.0371195823,
-0.0560851432,
0.0352987982,
-0.040422339,
0.0185096879,
0.0120642446,
-0.0117469402,
-0.0196360685,
0.021882249,
-0.0386890918,
0.0416278392,
0.0513444506,
0.011869736,
-0.0501416959,
0.0415991582,
0.0103706,
-0.0126117291,
-0.007866662,
-0.0212366711,
0.0057202154,
0.0443047658,
-0.0045094606,
0.0159639288,
0.0656998828,
-0.0325209014,
0.0470243394,
0.0145047866,
0.0254148096,
0.0159322061,
-0.0060229823,
0.0131802745,
0.0309994947,
-0.0474824123,
-0.0681388527,
0.0220562164,
0.025605971,
-0.0445877016,
0.0114702415,
0.1454518139,
0.0393025912,
0.0333318971,
0.01416458,
-0.0002948963,
0.0232041385,
0.0342819281,
-0.0227833297,
-0.0496487506,
0.0028109231,
0.0114629604,
0.0301943645,
-0.0367527865,
-0.0560624041,
-0.0213178601,
-0.1209866852,
0.0286965128,
-0.0045947614,
-0.039992284,
0.0098443115,
-0.0839915872,
0.0192165114,
-0.0524491332,
0.0084924251,
0.0104067707,
-0.0323080681,
0.0321029238,
0.0244810972,
-0.0773580223,
-0.0563616753,
0.0453879312,
-0.0707072616,
0.0593882166,
0.0491993614,
0.0678226501,
-0.0373319499,
-0.0240651183,
0.0259333011,
-0.0043724147,
0.0032042221,
-0.0029409372,
0.0274492018,
-0.0368379615,
0.0123420954,
-0.042754706,
-0.0218109749,
0.0249317996,
0.0020268778,
-0.0416223221,
0.0257751029,
0.0142652877,
-0.0164944138,
0.0225957483,
-0.0078814114,
-0.0136293387,
0.0810095444,
0.0013018491,
-0.0268706568,
-0.0311294887,
-0.0143036647,
0.0117008872,
-0.0175576862,
-0.0787730888,
0.0385197476,
0.0303157903,
-0.0128611401,
-0.0561154559,
-0.0524268113,
-0.0072471346,
-0.0122013083,
-0.0139014497,
0.0693313181,
-0.0129575944,
0.003064442,
0.0115478318,
0.0100202607,
0.0144172423,
0.0179202203,
-0.0623882636,
0.0282787029,
0.0451916531,
0.0005136456,
-0.0487070493,
-0.0037616903,
-0.0640528649,
-0.0515492223,
0.0199056007,
0.0302312374,
0.0308302641,
-0.0171231162,
0.0170206912,
-0.061297182,
0.0073688431,
0.0268263649,
-0.0220378768,
0.0271621682,
0.0113856997,
0.0116348462,
0.0156694427,
0.0321373753,
-0.0141267842,
0.0026189233,
0.0183765758,
0.0495544374,
0.0138934534,
-0.0535004027,
-0.0058653136,
0.0155614233,
0.0205597226,
-0.0232077595,
-0.0298690274,
-0.0123263719,
-0.0104170414,
-0.0215040892,
-0.0023744348,
-0.0109626316,
0.0075125983,
0.0299708396,
0.0445813015,
-0.0292218588,
0.0225508399,
-0.0256946757,
0.0188878924,
-0.0480741747,
0.0406667814,
0.0117597496,
-0.051995758,
-0.0079669729,
0.0026418993,
0.0071943952,
0.0147084463,
-0.024388127,
0.0476035886,
-0.0087902481,
-0.0043429784,
-0.0119744232,
0.0000088296,
0.0037995556,
0.0569515973,
-0.0699457005,
-0.0503058136,
-0.0189459734,
0.0326363072,
0.0513775051,
0.0003462042,
0.0907297507,
-0.0115659162,
0.0060455869,
-0.03651537,
-0.0231611934,
-0.0081508886,
-0.0281291697,
0.0161683299,
0.0192108564,
-0.009058659,
0.0481968373,
0.0576241091,
0.034167774,
0.023146918,
-0.0477912091,
-0.0190661028,
-0.0398850143,
-0.016875932,
-0.000827019,
-0.0188119374,
-0.0424047671,
0.0019243457,
-0.0791051686,
-0.0536730736,
0.0068258457,
0.0076341098,
0.0156079764,
-0.0227364842,
-0.0078860344,
0.0818423629,
-0.006474324,
0.0160992779,
-0.0552336909,
-0.0256813709,
-0.0130121047,
0.0167026371,
-0.0191469863,
-6.294736984e-33,
-0.0220736302,
-0.0217332225,
0.0239873026,
-0.0301242564,
0.009130789,
0.0146696186,
0.0058600237,
0.0216725357,
-0.0206107907,
-0.0268207341,
0.0076303491,
0.0015314036,
0.0169547033,
-0.016985856,
0.0332330167,
-0.0388200618,
0.0123232696,
-0.0033713246,
-0.0364993326,
-0.0392848924,
0.0124512082,
0.0025127232,
0.0762667879,
-0.0812384635,
0.0906925499,
0.0194581188,
0.0087528937,
-0.0171736479,
0.0103143621,
0.0643916726,
-0.0088953367,
0.0003926396,
0.0255219247,
-0.0803715885,
0.0002103012,
-0.0325356051,
-0.0276929047,
-0.0207188446,
0.0387500226,
0.0144983176,
0.0096601546,
0.0080438508,
0.0684946403,
0.0261382498,
-0.0678098127,
-0.0121203717,
0.0340003558,
-0.0334708132,
-0.0002895798,
-0.0031990542,
-0.0281753596,
0.0652507395,
-0.0237469058,
0.0084874453,
0.0134322634,
0.0197477564,
-0.0394421332,
0.0223062839,
-0.0662252903,
0.0329532698,
0.036996983,
0.0166596062,
0.0720491707,
0.0275995806,
0.0003090433,
0.0648921579,
0.0244466085,
0.0221959297,
0.0019419235,
-0.0156819336,
0.0432296544,
0.0403573476,
0.0338218696,
0.0120398942,
0.0261849854,
0.0095982617,
-0.0938911885,
0.0224690307,
0.0379872881,
0.0400474295,
0.029042853,
-0.0049131019,
-0.0737448856,
-0.0304088853,
-0.0582443289,
-0.0392392054,
-0.0265928488,
-0.0562323369,
0.042842485,
-0.02226381,
-0.0160117336,
-0.022720512,
0.0204325467,
-0.0499657467,
-0.0749272108,
0.0061531751,
-0.0134309232,
0.0413499437,
0.0017239405,
0.0217981115,
-0.0636064708,
-0.0153719587,
-0.0083810901,
0.0297104008,
0.0169613194,
-0.0322059058,
-0.0247789193,
0.0062091285,
-0.0554419719,
0.0014090019,
0.0061337487,
-0.0194687489,
-0.0103703924,
0.0417996198,
0.0367753543,
-0.0356212556,
-0.0133760469,
0.0390502028,
0.0200901087,
0.0217531379,
-0.0120805316,
0.0468280725,
0.012149211,
0.0209405851,
0.001388891,
0.0079530077,
-0.0177546162,
0.0048494488,
-0.0026229101,
-0.0017606795,
-0.0278393868,
-0.0421398245,
2.804e-7,
0.0741074756,
0.0604672283,
-0.0195904262,
-0.013047697,
-0.0205538888,
0.0140895899,
-0.0448660441,
0.0091998298,
0.022906635,
0.0049389978,
-0.0124214049,
0.0089929663,
0.0283477046,
0.0170880724,
-0.0406052433,
-0.0254289042,
-0.0603284687,
0.0093109068,
-0.0122635849,
-0.0120616779,
0.062361829,
0.0487705022,
0.0019304903,
0.0121100042,
-0.0599978492,
-0.0786549672,
0.0602144673,
-0.033202298,
-0.0035011068,
0.0243507139,
0.0671836808,
0.0456490591,
0.0021209556,
0.0218719561,
0.0124942306,
0.0734163076,
0.0662148446,
0.0571393445,
-0.0149224689,
-0.006395631,
0.0020400279,
-0.0548471436,
-0.0204881299,
-0.0717107877,
0.1107753813,
-0.0431020893,
-0.0592884272,
-0.0193221029,
-0.0305905137,
-0.0048570088,
0.0692734197,
-0.0222258773,
-0.0604596883,
0.0158070475,
0.0069637294,
-0.0425760001,
-0.0063956073,
-0.0379113071,
-0.0424952693,
-0.0030893527,
-0.0264909528,
-0.0849575475,
-0.0117778815,
0.0114157088,
-0.0074564386,
-0.0574760735,
-0.0047946731,
2.486438941e-34,
0.0299285669,
0.0148871178,
0.0240957364,
-0.0105545614,
0.0260690078,
0.0098007591,
-0.0057717678,
0.0097950371,
-0.012818845,
-0.0750618652,
0.0118194818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17280v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17280v4 | Does VLN Pretraining Work with Nonsensical or Irrelevant Instructions? | 2023-11-28T23:40:13 | 2023-12-23T06:12:37 | Wang Zhu, Ishika Singh, Yuan Huang, Robin Jia, Jesse Thomason | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Data augmentation via back-translation is common when pretraining
Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) models, even though the generated
instructions are noisy. But: does that noise matter? We find that nonsensical
or irrelevant language instructions during pretraining can have little effect
on downstream performance for both HAMT and VLN-BERT on R2R, and is still
better than only using clean, human data. To underscore these results, we
concoct an efficient augmentation method, Unigram + Object, which generates
nonsensical instructions that nonetheless improve downstream performance. Our
findings suggest that what matters for VLN R2R pretraining is the quantity of
visual trajectories, not the quality of instructions. | [
0.0388567001,
0.0488970019,
-0.0070553464,
0.0246263985,
0.0179174021,
0.0409081243,
-0.0256423634,
-0.0028552222,
-0.0251446683,
-0.0435629487,
-0.0392311811,
0.0066203116,
0.0302052908,
0.0057051536,
0.052959539,
-0.0631495342,
0.076700367,
-0.0605861917,
-0.0079489043,
0.0076388577,
-0.0117628453,
-0.0178387389,
-0.0056665093,
0.0382781699,
0.0066975914,
0.0181620903,
-0.0313465111,
0.0529329069,
0.040527001,
-0.0226823837,
-0.023628775,
0.0341021419,
0.048615735,
0.0264949203,
0.0000017744,
-0.0060892804,
0.0501419194,
-0.0036895538,
-0.031833671,
0.0265299659,
-0.016627131,
-0.0362907164,
-0.0291618686,
0.0325481445,
-0.0057889107,
-0.027606478,
0.05686206,
0.0095814662,
0.031172378,
0.0808547586,
-0.0210186373,
0.0050296001,
0.0254538767,
-0.0347856767,
0.0768929869,
-0.0066685374,
0.0055207731,
-0.0111964792,
-0.0594286472,
0.0372567996,
-0.0480972901,
0.0259278659,
0.0417690352,
0.0121596288,
0.0313818976,
0.0589973442,
-0.0499047004,
-0.0192877185,
-0.0228541456,
0.0540028326,
-0.0218846947,
-0.0018639028,
-0.0254153609,
0.031623181,
-0.0064639002,
-0.0430383682,
0.0006274382,
0.0192903522,
0.0134104118,
0.0170275625,
-0.0155141214,
-0.0499511734,
0.0345955044,
-0.0230645221,
-0.0130209411,
0.040821936,
0.0374024622,
-0.0142563153,
0.0135153932,
0.0489897914,
-0.0254701003,
-0.0778079554,
-0.0172304418,
-0.0008860642,
-0.0037026887,
0.0273376461,
-0.0700171962,
0.0000444937,
-0.0260008313,
-0.0678104684,
0.0584732108,
0.059028428,
-0.0577808507,
0.0140848579,
-0.0502196141,
0.044078771,
-0.0451581068,
0.0824548528,
-0.0247151293,
0.0129161896,
-0.0158318039,
0.0228313226,
-0.0774867162,
-0.0071241469,
-0.0785591304,
-0.044939518,
-0.0432603545,
0.0245959293,
0.0009112579,
-0.0131153967,
-0.0135167567,
0.0226609465,
-0.0653852969,
0.015887551,
-0.0329450592,
0.0074830148,
-0.0040464853,
0.0142733473,
-0.0080279643,
-0.0581004396,
-0.0072034863,
0.0322025307,
-0.020717822,
-0.0344703719,
0.0082678813,
0.0813790038,
-0.0277879369,
-0.0529562235,
-0.0597051494,
-0.0008566338,
-0.0012609472,
-0.0400372371,
0.0604685508,
-0.0411264375,
0.0066500483,
-0.0278194379,
-0.0037467824,
-0.0090411622,
0.0099519147,
0.0153080057,
-0.0384411179,
0.0649457499,
-0.0581646897,
-0.0164062083,
-0.0198853035,
-0.010901941,
0.0396614373,
0.0716790631,
0.0268814992,
0.0337903611,
-0.0067617712,
-0.0150514692,
-0.006005364,
0.0405161977,
0.0268932562,
0.0369439423,
-0.066980131,
0.0055929329,
0.0052433717,
0.0027080465,
0.0691626444,
0.0255261492,
-0.0594190508,
-0.006582215,
0.0441911854,
0.0144211324,
0.0256155878,
-0.0083361901,
0.0774731711,
-0.0448475294,
-0.0064161359,
0.0181371737,
-0.0823459551,
0.0296187568,
-0.0460250005,
-0.0072541442,
0.0072258608,
0.0227215737,
-0.0397213101,
-0.0453133658,
0.0062576304,
-0.0052345442,
0.0512571335,
0.0188024919,
0.0487464815,
0.0113771856,
-0.038241189,
0.0182441492,
0.03189319,
-0.0299145132,
0.0130147077,
-0.0241455901,
-0.0397406667,
0.0748264417,
0.0350821055,
0.040490672,
-0.0457923114,
0.0014520336,
0.030627897,
0.0556980558,
0.0476868786,
0.032508716,
0.065283522,
-0.0483230166,
-0.0618997365,
0.0013776576,
0.0055214278,
0.0525990538,
0.0181219261,
0.0138593232,
0.0111183319,
-0.0331687257,
-0.0249926746,
0.0370243266,
0.0102617927,
-0.01239926,
0.0010813986,
0.0013150568,
-0.014295212,
-0.0056356699,
-0.0228784308,
-0.0067598764,
0.0324267223,
-0.0133374454,
0.0406278819,
0.044166483,
-0.0266039874,
-0.0487910323,
0.0004714379,
-0.0243212171,
-0.0340224355,
0.0159815662,
-0.0094910515,
-0.0256338939,
0.0164021291,
-0.0635941178,
0.0504815951,
-0.0077593485,
0.02483413,
0.0314227864,
0.0000281862,
-0.0090595772,
0.0202937331,
-0.012997427,
-0.010284747,
0.0139500052,
0.015397327,
0.0184080396,
-0.045479089,
-0.0131731704,
0.0275604092,
0.0120333415,
-0.0102551579,
0.0160050448,
0.0109107019,
-0.0485535115,
0.010709512,
-0.0704448894,
-0.0152784474,
-0.0359432921,
0.0174812376,
0.0265675653,
-0.0048478148,
-0.0039223484,
-0.0440233089,
-0.0085217375,
0.0098798135,
-0.0227006506,
0.0264825914,
0.0014085989,
-0.0000106614,
-0.026073169,
-0.0140294973,
-0.0214090087,
-0.0004257533,
-0.00873008,
0.0204535611,
-0.0000803556,
-0.0753981322,
0.0106145935,
-0.0331573188,
0.0559785552,
-0.0136903757,
-0.0645877719,
0.0272561908,
-0.004502398,
0.0371268764,
0.0606828481,
-0.0232725926,
0.0228594355,
0.0297684632,
-0.0310776643,
-0.0408423059,
0.0139119327,
0.0000408488,
-0.0517728142,
-0.0600131229,
-0.0423715375,
0.0067628701,
0.03902537,
-0.0493835509,
0.0377822109,
-0.1083433479,
-0.0190000515,
-0.017064007,
-0.0669723898,
-0.0398999453,
0.0035043706,
-0.016053915,
0.0565567464,
-0.0419372208,
-0.0703971833,
0.0421670564,
-0.0305029433,
-0.0312138777,
-0.0283843279,
0.0242118333,
0.0207968839,
0.0360968672,
0.0539702326,
0.0252477825,
-0.0215461254,
-0.0368866809,
-0.0119629866,
-0.02141238,
-0.0172774494,
0.0000699348,
0.0505161546,
-0.0562042966,
-0.0054765306,
-0.0246092323,
0.0018528301,
-0.0350293629,
-0.0158929247,
0.0398234837,
-0.0123514934,
-0.0007190466,
-0.041531302,
-0.0399852581,
-0.0134532759,
0.0182183143,
0.0509585254,
-0.0280964207,
-0.0278869141,
-0.0291644055,
-0.0389621407,
0.0608973093,
-0.0023973188,
-0.0344406553,
-0.0504391529,
-0.0156007875,
0.0309389103,
0.0467012078,
-0.0380769558,
-0.0580289289,
0.0493839271,
0.0340746082,
0.0411265008,
-0.0393035896,
0.0246066898,
0.1020130664,
-0.0533385426,
-0.0461882427,
0.0606698133,
0.0058169267,
-0.0095528057,
0.0061304471,
0.0099796578,
0.0351169519,
0.0231394935,
0.028363714,
-0.052685868,
-0.0322225988,
0.0105586229,
0.034536086,
0.0220100973,
0.0169699658,
-0.0211824421,
-0.0809791312,
0.0667910576,
0.0257855263,
-0.0704840869,
-0.038961824,
0.0070766262,
-0.0202512108,
-0.0071356576,
0.0336997546,
-0.0072152549,
-0.0150904562,
0.002143746,
0.0312734358,
0.0056831376,
-0.0340897143,
-0.0228862036,
-0.0260870904,
0.0320726521,
0.0846987292,
-0.0085906833,
0.005441627,
-0.062780641,
0.0208202321,
-0.0055453889,
0.0359154977,
-0.013183089,
0.049729839,
-0.0092231799,
-0.0617501363,
0.0079711499,
-0.0005220337,
-0.0062222872,
-0.0232216511,
-0.0202637985,
-0.0131329754,
-0.03207523,
0.0075153536,
-0.0099572781,
0.0045135603,
-0.0084428973,
0.0315233283,
0.0086050658,
-0.021202283,
-0.0046822876,
-0.0327704251,
0.0099856816,
-0.0489051081,
-0.0082817236,
0.0166309662,
-0.0597113185,
-0.0917664543,
-0.0728566498,
-0.0859535187,
0.0421696194,
0.0805437565,
0.0058025331,
-0.0095817121,
-0.0143666985,
-0.0145305544,
-0.0261420496,
0.0741781145,
-0.0291987918,
0.0310142208,
-0.0677853301,
-0.0612038411,
-0.0381488912,
-0.006652528,
0.0022955106,
0.0117798019,
-0.0376195982,
-0.0669112056,
0.0175435282,
0.0637315661,
0.0296637155,
0.0889118016,
-0.0007935025,
-0.010708048,
-0.0028562967,
0.0314094573,
0.0098938383,
0.0591981448,
0.0561115667,
-0.0144061623,
0.0052379677,
0.0111489045,
-0.0239720996,
0.0153717594,
0.0137375705,
0.0078869537,
-0.0368748084,
-0.0041326331,
0.0197914671,
0.007086772,
0.1130122617,
-0.016578503,
0.0420117117,
0.0073607671,
0.0217477549,
-0.0436918959,
0.0282104053,
-0.0653116405,
-0.013844735,
0.0463089496,
0.0473160371,
0.0152920103,
0.0429946184,
-0.0340152718,
-0.039126873,
-0.0228087306,
-0.0380073152,
-0.0069035091,
0.0670050457,
0.0108432984,
0.0545086861,
0.0007457523,
0.0392991081,
-0.0138641028,
0.0508893318,
-0.0102059869,
0.0314357728,
0.0280658677,
0.0240630154,
-0.0102634188,
0.0464119501,
-0.0488972589,
-0.0629651919,
-0.0153282089,
0.0534927957,
0.0434880257,
-0.023225328,
0.0786911622,
-0.0445490964,
0.0007164213,
-0.0059705433,
-0.0091177393,
-0.0032116652,
-0.0220240261,
0.0288941097,
0.0037478434,
-0.0104138926,
-0.0436157361,
0.0499870181,
0.0196007751,
0.0646581501,
-0.024472747,
0.0005956157,
-0.0218911134,
-0.0339459516,
0.0682663172,
0.0106246527,
-0.0134083731,
0.0232332554,
0.0091350786,
-0.0744999126,
-0.0540619567,
0.0495496914,
0.0182898175,
-0.0150156533,
0.0467507802,
0.0199085008,
-0.0160289798,
-0.0333219916,
-0.0217735376,
-0.045789361,
-0.0000602142,
-0.0113010546,
0.0067297877,
-6.127598952e-33,
-0.0526660755,
0.0340384617,
0.039884869,
-0.0473473445,
-0.0288100597,
0.0179937109,
-0.0465442501,
0.0149038229,
-0.0161654279,
0.0242689196,
0.0265856907,
0.0310801771,
0.0237463303,
0.0225516558,
-0.0213669557,
-0.0069209798,
0.0571571477,
-0.0102283629,
-0.0289057624,
-0.0086098742,
0.0364038907,
-0.0174894929,
0.055990722,
-0.0300023202,
0.0124053555,
0.0145826358,
-0.0363140516,
0.0091273375,
0.0078631863,
0.0374014229,
-0.0082397191,
0.0031936278,
-0.0188937727,
0.0186076891,
-0.0379651524,
-0.0020357152,
-0.0666000023,
-0.0218926556,
0.0141548216,
0.0540040582,
-0.120176591,
-0.0017126452,
0.0763371363,
-0.0314664356,
-0.0199104678,
0.0264759827,
0.0127764503,
-0.0149319526,
-0.0387201011,
0.0431791879,
-0.0655583963,
0.0027405138,
0.0032177805,
-0.0507919937,
0.0297923274,
0.0290031973,
0.0134497089,
-0.0252652615,
-0.039344009,
0.0048151533,
0.0260089003,
0.0121514145,
0.0472447909,
0.0360591896,
0.0209586266,
0.0322466604,
0.0644399747,
-0.0174306408,
0.0115904892,
0.0137555357,
0.057825394,
0.0389754213,
0.0368383154,
-0.0073681278,
0.0825574473,
0.0133056408,
-0.0420036092,
0.0282830819,
-0.058147911,
0.0341688059,
-0.0359671377,
0.0158614125,
-0.0399342813,
-0.0155124972,
-0.0036784839,
0.005041576,
-0.0148059707,
-0.0531723909,
0.0524341539,
0.035160955,
-0.0093606533,
0.0184992775,
0.0391991213,
-0.0089388648,
0.026060665,
-0.0118621401,
-0.0301053338,
0.0132339373,
-0.0079643251,
0.0203337073,
-0.0443722717,
-0.0281815156,
0.0994580761,
0.0082443971,
0.0087680193,
0.0247669891,
0.0344333127,
0.0106313331,
-0.0537436344,
0.0067085726,
-0.0570835173,
0.0336592086,
0.0163464937,
0.0010390743,
0.0687777102,
-0.0253346208,
-0.0230443906,
0.0685624182,
-0.0009823244,
-0.0334035046,
-0.0495774746,
-0.0033025627,
0.0265929755,
0.0425868034,
-0.0118376687,
0.0005410453,
-0.0224726815,
0.0062588234,
0.01916302,
-0.0600341633,
-0.0427090824,
0.0254074857,
2.608e-7,
0.023834236,
0.0304899588,
0.0478338189,
0.0248825364,
-0.0014452337,
0.0414098166,
-0.0472874455,
0.035879124,
0.0137715917,
-0.0016164264,
0.0061945813,
0.0570407435,
0.0055155931,
-0.0176845305,
0.0291592795,
-0.0039137634,
-0.0284656323,
-0.0010354274,
-0.0490427911,
-0.0015661916,
0.0370331481,
0.051368665,
-0.0006192836,
-0.0144517915,
0.076723285,
-0.0235856678,
0.0614535026,
-0.0260336585,
-0.0015489288,
-0.024791738,
-0.0042885505,
0.0848336592,
-0.043811392,
0.0191171709,
-0.0304679275,
-0.0300111417,
-0.0024124363,
0.0374749862,
-0.0800036043,
-0.0218552705,
-0.0264174026,
0.0201697703,
-0.0196601003,
-0.0131364716,
0.0488692261,
-0.0349181965,
-0.0186362602,
0.0100065479,
-0.0309893116,
0.0335663669,
0.0396104045,
-0.0145596107,
-0.035288211,
-0.0011829433,
0.041929625,
0.0152069926,
-0.0379225723,
-0.0588908717,
0.0077536181,
0.0040353467,
-0.0169079565,
-0.0425159112,
-0.0723119006,
0.0576984473,
0.0157896094,
-0.0129459426,
-0.0441395529,
1.970410697e-34,
0.0357114561,
-0.0170782637,
0.0461811572,
-0.0283177029,
0.0148374783,
-0.0023455166,
0.0046042097,
-0.0050462005,
-0.0083226562,
-0.0288092345,
-0.0418217592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17264v1 | RETSim: Resilient and Efficient Text Similarity | 2023-11-28T22:54:33 | 2023-11-28T22:54:33 | Marina Zhang, Owen Vallis, Aysegul Bumin, Tanay Vakharia, Elie Bursztein | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces RETSim (Resilient and Efficient Text Similarity), a
lightweight, multilingual deep learning model trained to produce robust metric
embeddings for near-duplicate text retrieval, clustering, and dataset
deduplication tasks. We demonstrate that RETSim is significantly more robust
and accurate than MinHash and neural text embeddings, achieving new
state-of-the-art performance on dataset deduplication, adversarial text
retrieval benchmarks, and spam clustering tasks. We also introduce the W4NT3D
benchmark (Wiki-40B 4dversarial Near-T3xt Dataset) for evaluating multilingual,
near-duplicate text retrieval capabilities under adversarial settings. RETSim
and the W4NT3D benchmark are open-sourced under the MIT License at
https://github.com/google/unisim. | [
0.0006159538,
0.0141546782,
-0.0093049472,
0.0726098642,
-0.0212980844,
0.0247014891,
-0.0022134369,
0.0209807921,
0.028313797,
0.0213939529,
-0.0496445633,
-0.016717298,
-0.0249451119,
-0.0005612666,
0.0312183723,
-0.0189151112,
0.0431697741,
0.0473933965,
-0.0142016867,
-0.0287110861,
0.0309687983,
-0.0033784802,
0.0419555791,
-0.0110822478,
-0.002247066,
-0.0002183275,
0.0029654154,
0.0224441271,
0.0372782238,
-0.0156802442,
0.0498518944,
-0.0045214314,
0.0396052264,
0.0872307569,
0.0000018099,
-0.0054587889,
-0.035055045,
-0.0225977004,
0.0280931741,
0.0115932897,
0.0557254404,
-0.0397148095,
0.0101541644,
-0.0109449495,
-0.0309906956,
-0.0516432822,
0.0155926114,
0.0506150424,
0.0465846248,
0.0624410175,
-0.0333556086,
-0.0184380617,
0.0207663924,
-0.0301549193,
-0.0193856265,
-0.0149379428,
0.0068579232,
0.0127966721,
-0.0182294939,
0.044450894,
0.022520788,
0.0573680438,
0.0357256941,
0.0390043706,
-0.0567684621,
0.0013388747,
-0.0035583929,
0.0320217609,
0.0301095489,
0.0811450556,
-0.0772024617,
-0.0397248119,
0.029648453,
0.0110991485,
0.0002212529,
-0.019310629,
-0.0448913798,
-0.0274546314,
0.020519862,
0.0325212181,
-0.04996638,
0.0629485473,
0.0435748771,
0.0123680662,
0.0113646993,
-0.0566501319,
0.0271490794,
-0.0049239974,
-0.0511499718,
-0.0142579433,
0.0170041509,
-0.0019282538,
0.0364134349,
-0.0185069367,
0.041296497,
-0.0321237966,
-0.0820516348,
-0.050948564,
0.0333990604,
-0.0595387928,
-0.0028519714,
0.0384859405,
-0.0326187052,
0.0616131015,
-0.0723567382,
0.029673649,
-0.029948337,
0.0375737436,
-0.0207724404,
-0.0559191369,
-0.0340909995,
-0.0206462126,
-0.0081660543,
0.0425087959,
0.0295067988,
-0.0045806449,
-0.0014862184,
0.0150261465,
-0.0248971656,
0.0160432048,
-0.0335841887,
0.0219156872,
-0.028446408,
-0.0248123128,
0.0056844326,
0.0040563829,
-0.0429866575,
-0.0138951233,
-0.0411217958,
-0.0526542515,
-0.0143012898,
0.0355581455,
0.0083823614,
-0.0273975823,
0.017357327,
0.0512355007,
-0.0431546457,
-0.0470234156,
-0.0026838796,
-0.0210628454,
0.0100480095,
-0.0132045383,
0.0021402971,
-0.0613681152,
0.0598578714,
-0.0160864461,
-0.0115626184,
-0.088871792,
-0.0210841857,
0.0314401314,
-0.008780499,
0.0631720126,
0.0249880198,
-0.024884969,
0.0321069844,
0.0337463804,
0.0125026451,
0.010821688,
-0.0230786987,
0.0414605998,
0.064049527,
0.0439664274,
-0.009866138,
0.0350045227,
0.0291812848,
0.0218471494,
-0.0252768211,
0.0075249868,
0.000806218,
0.0306204278,
0.0253079105,
0.0557453856,
-0.0648460388,
-0.0906502903,
0.0422553271,
0.0222638398,
0.0076509314,
0.0343876332,
-0.0054830234,
0.0221973006,
-0.0415361561,
-0.0128267203,
-0.0236675348,
0.0421447307,
0.0050786096,
-0.01509545,
0.0649098828,
0.0499104597,
-0.0584917702,
0.0034410912,
0.0405403972,
-0.0416722521,
0.0226631761,
-0.045780912,
0.0198245905,
0.008989227,
0.0021731998,
0.028063599,
-0.0143469945,
-0.0203506537,
-0.0179172922,
-0.0120745888,
-0.0068416228,
0.032405328,
0.0756603703,
-0.0308921374,
0.003157293,
0.0101130502,
0.0242525581,
-0.0001392239,
0.0514534414,
-0.003795119,
0.0236739479,
-0.0621970072,
-0.0478265211,
-0.0295660067,
-0.0182296634,
0.0444382802,
0.0483614355,
0.0593833998,
0.0609861277,
-0.0554691032,
0.0091463886,
0.0100271618,
-0.0164743122,
-0.0198195968,
0.0055953534,
0.0392755903,
0.0098097352,
0.0106700556,
-0.0026639397,
0.0054711676,
0.0442613699,
-0.0478011258,
-0.0376843512,
-0.015319054,
-0.0205738749,
-0.0386163853,
0.0609588698,
-0.0388838649,
-0.0131706819,
0.0697618052,
-0.0227657072,
-0.0067070336,
0.0452764593,
0.0092508197,
0.0154144261,
-0.0561096184,
-0.0207700394,
-0.0208760984,
0.0344825052,
-0.0097034173,
0.0589756146,
-0.0147900283,
0.0160709098,
-0.0132561661,
-0.0317585655,
0.0630103573,
0.0052163145,
-0.0634223223,
0.0031082416,
-0.0163444132,
0.0413239934,
-0.0043744631,
-0.0072885193,
0.0143660493,
-0.0095196627,
-0.0234820228,
0.0003695588,
-0.0075462596,
-0.0013837825,
0.0139845926,
0.0135311102,
0.0060208677,
-0.0285775922,
-0.0674736947,
-0.0467814542,
0.0182907041,
0.0137618845,
0.0430728458,
-0.0352117643,
0.007409174,
-0.0084679741,
-0.0147049157,
0.0235223603,
0.038821429,
-0.040279828,
-0.0481649116,
0.0253681261,
0.0039261593,
-0.0447235703,
0.0329042152,
-0.0323239937,
0.0085355565,
-0.0031225451,
0.0142107867,
0.0351224765,
0.0198928174,
-0.019125184,
-0.0442703292,
0.0120950276,
0.0390654914,
-0.0636591911,
-0.0154475663,
-0.0335539617,
0.0309262387,
0.0048337388,
-0.0233787782,
0.0099784387,
-0.0436065719,
0.0220202487,
-0.0040794532,
-0.0106211836,
0.0229695048,
0.0296140164,
0.0084202066,
-0.0369602628,
-0.0086731287,
0.016531622,
-0.0320733003,
-0.0336274393,
-0.0370786227,
0.0703589469,
-0.0276197102,
0.0197936222,
-0.0263680238,
-0.0122373998,
-0.0022533606,
0.0483991653,
-0.0348949917,
0.0358834751,
-0.0445027575,
0.0126801133,
-0.0079768375,
0.0222177599,
0.0390322506,
-0.0203160439,
0.0121038705,
0.0502742045,
0.0140941059,
-0.0247819908,
-0.051875487,
-0.0231059771,
-0.033166565,
0.0196222346,
-0.0027291484,
0.0010699481,
-0.0143732,
-0.092950508,
-0.001804351,
0.0325224549,
0.0571357533,
-0.0335127823,
-0.0015436317,
-0.0018215108,
0.07505887,
-0.016639255,
-0.0255679507,
-0.0112356069,
-0.0281416345,
-0.0094109932,
0.0734318197,
0.0225388799,
-0.0012698233,
-0.0358629376,
-0.020662332,
0.0095670065,
0.0203421302,
-0.0061861575,
-0.0364942439,
-0.0079418616,
-0.0108235879,
0.0031368856,
0.0409298502,
-0.0017862793,
-0.0512721203,
-0.0149744879,
-0.0130916527,
0.035290096,
0.0142566273,
0.0084640887,
-0.0737537965,
-0.035930682,
-0.0056675114,
0.0103096999,
0.0406599753,
-0.0016790156,
0.0168705955,
-0.0625429004,
-0.0016813998,
-0.0037368177,
-0.0199831985,
-0.0759598985,
-0.0308363214,
0.0012163346,
0.0243181325,
0.0175278224,
0.0030420814,
0.027692765,
-0.0178422276,
-0.0105343694,
-0.0103063341,
-0.0708262473,
-0.0026311979,
-0.0655287728,
0.0029698974,
-0.0114262542,
0.0449130088,
0.0099656386,
-0.0605761595,
-0.0027139885,
-0.0118403398,
-0.0487404019,
0.0089604277,
0.0568774901,
-0.0162650533,
-0.0135127781,
-0.0362904333,
0.0293920059,
-0.0319901854,
0.0112581113,
-0.0095571186,
0.0527702123,
-0.0175988413,
0.0186988972,
-0.0429946147,
-0.0325054005,
-0.0309954323,
0.052048184,
0.006542162,
0.008492155,
-0.012863135,
0.0086874748,
0.0350723863,
-0.0299131833,
-0.010696874,
-0.0059006745,
-0.0390988439,
0.0154046323,
-0.0661002845,
-0.0322314762,
-0.0189983211,
0.0138581442,
-0.0326895081,
0.0036528783,
-0.0601703115,
-0.0471313633,
-0.0831866413,
-0.0074395579,
-0.0490159355,
0.0368058123,
-0.006007765,
0.0566361137,
0.0062268353,
-0.0321779139,
-0.0268949587,
0.0047681481,
-0.0749613717,
-0.0442955047,
-0.0407474004,
0.0114286104,
0.0036554285,
0.0357336998,
-0.0257129092,
-0.0616934039,
0.0536917374,
0.0227234252,
-0.0270891357,
-0.006991432,
0.0262848474,
-0.0197081827,
0.0121238073,
0.046358943,
-0.0348116793,
0.0083312308,
0.0362094156,
-0.0381483473,
0.0033031856,
-0.015803244,
-0.016240973,
0.0192030687,
0.0485954992,
0.0272243954,
0.0234984513,
-0.0366524123,
-0.009204451,
0.0015949801,
-0.0073777139,
-0.0141901309,
0.0550867803,
0.0444760174,
0.0052128662,
-0.0131610781,
0.0596213304,
0.0328616127,
0.0158613734,
-0.0158523582,
-0.0084072491,
-0.0051550362,
0.056313213,
-0.0335370786,
0.0038129741,
-0.0308914836,
0.0260731019,
-0.0256206319,
0.0109419441,
-0.0823758245,
-0.0353359282,
0.0455035008,
-0.0035327387,
-0.0292723328,
0.0649954081,
-0.0242217761,
-0.0235049948,
-0.0213010982,
-0.0226838831,
0.0366316848,
-0.0025419956,
0.039013993,
-0.0189716835,
-0.0187720135,
-0.0181533303,
-0.0453424715,
-0.0148422522,
-0.0042325929,
-0.000628567,
0.0092964889,
-0.0264528543,
0.0595993921,
0.0793104991,
-0.0220081173,
0.0050553116,
0.0247547831,
-0.0618930534,
-0.0420043059,
-0.0181268901,
0.082107529,
0.0329017304,
-0.0219382085,
-0.0562825948,
0.0345891155,
-0.0290752053,
0.0088279871,
0.0326125957,
-0.0717076436,
0.037697766,
0.0369695462,
0.0874594301,
0.0159358978,
0.0205023289,
0.0048833624,
0.0051784753,
0.0092457496,
-0.0487474613,
0.0529019348,
-5.995822729e-33,
0.0592544675,
0.018254865,
-0.0185478181,
-0.0958496109,
-0.0262304209,
0.0304894056,
-0.017800808,
-0.0349295847,
-0.0495813712,
0.0146784987,
0.0242774915,
0.0049511585,
0.003170125,
0.024430301,
-0.0365968682,
-0.0051763128,
0.0263852198,
0.0127172498,
-0.0080846027,
0.0432567224,
0.0444999225,
0.0272119269,
0.0324032903,
-0.0623895787,
0.0064727231,
-0.0213742703,
0.001076855,
0.0003190421,
0.0280421823,
0.0443511233,
-0.0480367988,
0.0297238808,
0.0338930562,
0.0013565298,
-0.0277389102,
-0.0072609838,
-0.0612213537,
-0.0576220341,
-0.0345684849,
-0.0235802401,
-0.0279755965,
-0.001230441,
0.0643070862,
-0.0185731538,
-0.0113310209,
0.0024795432,
0.0439634621,
-0.0052390387,
-0.0652104691,
-0.002893301,
0.0034112411,
0.0496195592,
0.0183370858,
0.0158535708,
0.0232306682,
0.052440118,
0.0384635329,
0.064698793,
-0.1193903014,
0.0111081507,
-0.1000224873,
0.0275743324,
0.0059046522,
-0.0545611978,
0.0246961303,
0.07362023,
0.0615671091,
-0.0141648808,
0.0077989614,
-0.014350106,
0.0470563397,
0.0077514169,
0.080579266,
0.1180016696,
0.0231688172,
-0.0461366288,
-0.059121687,
0.0574963242,
-0.0294008534,
0.0012626298,
0.0411778428,
0.0393716171,
-0.0804946944,
-0.0160989035,
-0.0055031758,
-0.0251717698,
-0.0265174694,
-0.0293334723,
0.0326732844,
0.0201541018,
-0.0222896989,
0.0121532772,
0.0213701688,
-0.0179840382,
-0.0055306801,
0.0321823023,
0.0007937594,
-0.0106884278,
0.0109722493,
0.0249828696,
0.0298620258,
-0.0106807556,
0.0051008682,
-0.0233533978,
-0.0153281372,
-0.0281775743,
0.0544106066,
0.0232556593,
-0.0688888803,
0.009759875,
0.008422602,
-0.0244471226,
-0.0151759973,
0.0294722095,
-0.0197559558,
0.0039499444,
0.0409149043,
0.0019214739,
0.0662520751,
-0.0292777196,
-0.0322683901,
-0.0183712356,
0.0189306941,
0.0086237732,
0.0011443774,
0.0180147495,
-0.0695845857,
0.0160442758,
0.0545339584,
-0.1064697355,
0.0052728062,
-0.0141340904,
2.544e-7,
0.0193308014,
0.0143623697,
0.0512866788,
-0.0524453744,
0.0031559726,
0.0465829894,
-0.013651426,
0.0812224597,
-0.0605522022,
0.0463080518,
0.0309011154,
0.0267647058,
0.0340952985,
0.0273982324,
-0.0505727902,
0.052518528,
-0.1169022545,
-0.0338115059,
-0.0585799143,
-0.0273060594,
0.0092092147,
0.1067034453,
0.0362452865,
-0.0078720972,
0.0032727446,
-0.0733177364,
0.0487387329,
-0.0235002041,
0.012300319,
-0.0103989411,
0.0772399679,
-0.0005474937,
0.0170175545,
-0.0356184989,
-0.0012989515,
0.0266288426,
0.0812962949,
0.0266218428,
0.0183567405,
-0.0307766479,
0.0191807915,
-0.0513489209,
-0.0325128324,
-0.0882274806,
0.070176065,
0.000659314,
0.0117383152,
0.0319570526,
-0.0090034138,
0.0231283586,
0.073828347,
0.0155494045,
-0.0541013144,
0.027006641,
0.0434773974,
0.0211655293,
0.0053776614,
-0.0716368482,
0.0033338543,
-0.0405240059,
-0.0589433536,
0.0271952208,
-0.0440228991,
-0.0052653453,
0.0604003742,
0.0256746598,
0.0362170152,
2.175275485e-34,
0.0159146432,
-0.0126198605,
0.007483325,
-0.0643246099,
0.0132559966,
-0.0286501721,
-0.0036086761,
-0.0039859158,
-0.00164457,
-0.0204762835,
-0.0224901512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17233v1 | Quantifying the redundancy between prosody and text | 2023-11-28T21:15:24 | 2023-11-28T21:15:24 | Lukas Wolf, Tiago Pimentel, Evelina Fedorenko, Ryan Cotterell, Alex Warstadt, Ethan Wilcox, Tamar Regev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT | Prosody -- the suprasegmental component of speech, including pitch, loudness,
and tempo -- carries critical aspects of meaning. However, the relationship
between the information conveyed by prosody vs. by the words themselves remains
poorly understood. We use large language models (LLMs) to estimate how much
information is redundant between prosody and the words themselves. Using a
large spoken corpus of English audiobooks, we extract prosodic features aligned
to individual words and test how well they can be predicted from LLM
embeddings, compared to non-contextual word embeddings. We find a high degree
of redundancy between the information carried by the words and prosodic
information across several prosodic features, including intensity, duration,
pauses, and pitch contours. Furthermore, a word's prosodic information is
redundant with both the word itself and the context preceding as well as
following it. Still, we observe that prosodic features can not be fully
predicted from text, suggesting that prosody carries information above and
beyond the words. Along with this paper, we release a general-purpose data
processing pipeline for quantifying the relationship between linguistic
information and extra-linguistic features. | [
-0.0115949027,
0.0664694682,
-0.0034491525,
0.0001356008,
-0.0471414216,
-0.0059951702,
0.0027787555,
-0.0217364654,
-0.0766029656,
0.0181228016,
-0.0430158302,
-0.0204145499,
0.0764854923,
0.0049113603,
0.0571604073,
-0.049960807,
0.0182830412,
-0.0252974741,
0.0548417717,
0.0045283297,
0.0285265241,
-0.020746002,
-0.0157673452,
0.0545934029,
-0.0236684904,
-0.0213753022,
-0.0006200411,
0.0247105751,
0.0307685994,
0.0257576946,
-0.0302612782,
0.0360589065,
-0.0101996735,
-0.0147679383,
0.0000016327,
-0.0396086238,
0.0277823471,
-0.0135052055,
-0.028694855,
0.0420037992,
0.0345793217,
0.0175225791,
-0.037710458,
0.0396345668,
-0.007830468,
-0.0011741143,
0.0439734608,
0.0107334005,
-0.0323207863,
0.0374134853,
-0.010699763,
-0.0112361433,
0.0251143221,
-0.0316013359,
-0.0095314775,
0.0184345357,
0.0177761298,
-0.0300080497,
0.0137669025,
-0.0075061959,
-0.0464800596,
0.0751416683,
-0.0153355366,
0.0272973124,
0.0299220216,
0.0201123524,
-0.035365317,
-0.0338444449,
0.0093230586,
0.048217535,
-0.0003672484,
-0.0109967506,
0.0061425264,
0.0011875358,
-0.0207485966,
-0.0075778165,
-0.0051481286,
0.0177812502,
0.0452948287,
-0.0004332514,
0.0097303167,
0.0229180288,
0.0323665254,
-0.0382564403,
0.0080814427,
0.0254159141,
0.0304244552,
-0.0337978341,
0.0320355408,
-0.024128437,
-0.0455460325,
-0.010125191,
0.0272090975,
-0.0275312681,
0.029384857,
0.0026729472,
-0.0233326126,
-0.0300550889,
-0.0028848706,
-0.0155277615,
0.0129620377,
0.0082778931,
-0.0604005568,
0.0138692455,
0.0156775154,
0.0310641695,
-0.0001918211,
-0.0438857228,
-0.0445234142,
0.0221164003,
0.0203580018,
-0.0273935013,
0.0087578865,
-0.0033798441,
0.0314398892,
-0.078136757,
0.0150674703,
-0.0059838593,
-0.0472252332,
0.0267768335,
-0.0145152854,
0.004381089,
0.0177650284,
0.0074213245,
0.028862603,
0.0267112181,
-0.0458182022,
0.0623211861,
-0.0675793216,
-0.0462757312,
0.0218487363,
0.0411773585,
0.0398167334,
0.0353648588,
0.0132564083,
-0.0082904613,
0.0480340458,
-0.0170808285,
-0.0197325125,
-0.0053113876,
-0.0675970763,
-0.0381996669,
-0.0603881851,
-0.0736405626,
0.0350680351,
-0.0039593247,
-0.0053910799,
-0.0342684165,
-0.0310777072,
0.0063711726,
0.0009971434,
0.0654509515,
-0.0023031002,
0.0871339887,
0.0230264552,
0.0076231482,
0.027558174,
0.04162056,
0.0688086972,
-0.0387171395,
0.0621380471,
-0.0264747366,
-0.0329277925,
0.067279242,
-0.0310921054,
-0.0172333159,
-0.0307939462,
-0.0608866811,
-0.0048306035,
0.0282423906,
0.0431490578,
0.0354158133,
-0.0040285764,
-0.0512422286,
0.0721580088,
0.0904825851,
0.0065608486,
-0.0227473062,
0.0402358919,
0.0570573434,
0.0179633517,
0.0647714436,
-0.0055711768,
-0.0122365197,
-0.0021050796,
0.0090042269,
0.0521817766,
0.0231405254,
-0.0306173414,
-0.0127223507,
-0.0214076973,
-0.031341251,
-0.0482013449,
0.0060956026,
0.0277992263,
-0.0134977559,
-0.0262881387,
0.0197073612,
0.0026175617,
-0.0515840948,
0.0021662971,
0.0449802615,
0.0029758601,
0.0903013796,
0.0247168951,
-0.0377939157,
0.0528000146,
-0.0055698422,
0.001164748,
0.0295544043,
-0.0100567881,
-0.0103357825,
0.057995934,
-0.0549005643,
0.0023355193,
0.0214308109,
0.0353550836,
-0.0171169546,
-0.012858591,
0.0094976714,
0.013597724,
0.0050022681,
0.0265792422,
0.0018735724,
-0.0483573489,
-0.04084903,
0.0008086006,
0.0283114184,
0.0278174002,
0.0339272618,
-0.0449355952,
0.0341152437,
0.0413878895,
-0.0233239923,
0.0280460324,
0.036805585,
-0.0519522838,
-0.0172283445,
0.0208186824,
-0.0337310135,
0.0251957029,
0.0193307381,
0.0536783114,
-0.0596453696,
0.017146416,
-0.0478205793,
0.0730134696,
-0.0350573845,
0.0305630434,
-0.0259460881,
0.053833019,
0.0042978902,
-0.0212238356,
0.0115039116,
0.0202925354,
-0.0003977927,
0.0052379272,
0.0162046496,
-0.0433492176,
-0.0626076311,
0.0185736064,
-0.0237128101,
0.01842889,
-0.0005277926,
-0.0885384232,
-0.0244776253,
-0.0290196706,
-0.0803425461,
0.0047494401,
-0.0142854843,
0.026453428,
0.0307118744,
-0.0050148964,
-0.0093258759,
0.0182948951,
-0.0074213133,
-0.0500479266,
-0.0321858004,
0.0142021896,
-0.0385848731,
-0.024389755,
-0.0523837209,
-0.0375335589,
0.0077315303,
-0.0020176359,
0.0269515365,
-0.0419919789,
-0.0108587826,
-0.0093766423,
0.0374946445,
-0.000370741,
-0.0067314147,
0.0278972797,
-0.0383308418,
-0.0146716097,
-0.0039802515,
0.1149221137,
0.0004365921,
-0.0106493738,
-0.0109363124,
0.0554467551,
-0.0581901483,
-0.019612208,
-0.0197503585,
-0.0210022125,
0.0368993245,
-0.0217209924,
-0.0288905911,
-0.0292684715,
0.025090564,
0.0704082027,
0.0015624848,
-0.0247984771,
-0.0147328069,
-0.038887307,
-0.0219917763,
0.0035610814,
-0.0381734446,
-0.0745620653,
0.0210592542,
-0.0276271161,
-0.0630862117,
0.0152263176,
-0.0551941656,
-0.0333427154,
-0.0171246622,
-0.0373107158,
0.0007698146,
0.0287842527,
-0.0027788766,
-0.0029813768,
-0.0110330805,
-0.0427102819,
-0.0135701913,
0.025886042,
0.0125743784,
-0.0689802095,
0.0316701159,
-0.0219380409,
-0.0367700197,
0.0351097137,
-0.0328261591,
-0.019853875,
-0.0582977161,
-0.0253403038,
-0.010394372,
-0.0051783328,
-0.0524506457,
0.0088426955,
-0.0231978092,
0.0382275172,
0.0108540449,
-0.0031510082,
0.0214301683,
0.0088585531,
0.0644338205,
0.0176336691,
0.0444453508,
-0.0052434034,
-0.0229029432,
0.0365340114,
-0.0144475652,
0.0171281528,
0.0552005172,
-0.0269955695,
-0.0007098215,
0.0235338658,
0.0131009705,
-0.0258082505,
0.0305536259,
0.0082221813,
-0.0312861502,
0.0238073692,
0.127796784,
0.0084056724,
0.0003791362,
0.026549736,
0.0001699866,
0.0534801111,
0.0144882835,
-0.0174210146,
-0.0295099858,
-0.0318422094,
0.0576039664,
0.0128541328,
0.0022982657,
0.0294045657,
-0.0446505286,
-0.0629826114,
0.0244378783,
0.0234138407,
-0.008579324,
-0.0244398024,
-0.0387675799,
0.0199796259,
-0.0046217702,
-0.0225048624,
0.0064668637,
-0.0405942164,
-0.0006256845,
-0.0147356736,
-0.1184208766,
-0.0562798046,
0.0121865449,
-0.0348848365,
0.0414949767,
0.0487637743,
0.0176874399,
-0.046967648,
-0.0266347881,
-0.0154450601,
-0.0261639468,
-0.031065423,
0.0257257074,
0.0609350353,
0.0282227024,
-0.0186126772,
-0.0560182817,
0.0501377359,
-0.0324593037,
-0.0053198575,
0.0135544194,
0.0773901939,
-0.0039834138,
-0.0120240664,
-0.0076668002,
0.0730828121,
0.0159937181,
0.0992317721,
0.0419389792,
-0.0687929243,
0.0049447096,
0.0280972905,
0.0275069941,
0.018033443,
-0.0275465026,
0.0268694833,
0.0574346632,
-0.0445715114,
-0.0561032631,
-0.0314523764,
0.0000188791,
0.0125004379,
0.0494572446,
0.0432578288,
-0.0304024033,
-0.0449627079,
-0.0603944026,
-0.001943917,
0.0183783863,
0.057484962,
-0.0588993132,
0.0098992428,
0.0281895082,
-0.0152803594,
-0.0314734019,
-0.0148268612,
-0.0694764331,
-0.0677194521,
0.0288730394,
-0.0468460508,
0.0175421853,
0.0224416871,
-0.0137301488,
-0.0546126515,
0.0257142354,
0.0148747126,
-0.0656256974,
0.063832812,
0.0604080781,
-0.0419142693,
0.0072731255,
0.0474283658,
-0.0222439412,
0.0345378481,
-0.050652504,
0.0241919607,
0.0195811633,
-0.0835414231,
-0.0242216531,
0.0094546704,
0.0518061109,
-0.0006869492,
-0.005158274,
-0.0494810529,
-0.0223076474,
0.0202034656,
0.0262657572,
-0.0235506967,
0.0161688793,
0.0486936569,
0.0322237462,
-0.0439835228,
0.0139101883,
-0.0230780933,
-0.0233099405,
0.0254936814,
0.0306506697,
0.0369567312,
-0.0235143807,
-0.0098298406,
0.0185449403,
-0.0055883406,
0.0451078713,
-0.0320959017,
-0.0063296924,
0.0187441539,
-0.0117682135,
-0.0228384584,
0.0082521075,
-0.0006028418,
-0.0000138214,
-0.0351782218,
0.0192373171,
0.0268000718,
-0.0100495312,
0.0274956841,
-0.0459714085,
0.0486105643,
-0.0156464521,
0.0266746711,
-0.0668580383,
-0.0018037,
-0.060032092,
0.0249482896,
0.0125173982,
0.0203292165,
-0.0497966781,
0.040658474,
0.0626365766,
0.0073195985,
0.01008962,
-0.0310498141,
0.0139656803,
0.000535725,
-0.0155343069,
-0.0188334472,
0.0434116386,
-0.0257648341,
0.0082782619,
-0.0699392632,
-0.0572192557,
0.0052500623,
-0.0015556865,
0.0056166654,
-0.0272183716,
-0.0019002467,
0.0008989873,
-0.0672186017,
0.0258609056,
0.0168044474,
-0.0344830118,
-0.0174124278,
-0.0175802819,
0.0408308357,
-5.830441695e-33,
0.0003609615,
-0.0587402992,
-0.0289774872,
0.0363859273,
-0.0398204997,
0.0521959476,
-0.0189958345,
0.0040455768,
-0.0149302417,
0.0246993434,
0.0126434676,
-0.0027097526,
0.0276494659,
-0.0023491706,
0.0152785424,
0.0335407965,
0.0370058529,
-0.0028988277,
-0.0098144375,
0.0009072583,
0.045631554,
0.0323653445,
0.0255569965,
-0.0608508736,
-0.00671332,
-0.0084275547,
-0.0045516449,
-0.0201846268,
0.0456051342,
0.0582040735,
-0.0427729897,
0.0724112019,
0.001742704,
-0.0345609412,
-0.0478864983,
0.0914551243,
-0.0843093172,
-0.0513313077,
0.048925966,
0.0238503963,
-0.002507855,
0.0013119207,
0.0276345648,
-0.0156354159,
-0.0170289967,
-0.0239725355,
0.0272210948,
-0.0183482133,
-0.0097107617,
-0.0379366986,
-0.0442467779,
0.0476054549,
-0.0305332355,
-0.011793361,
0.0561556742,
0.0350495167,
0.0141948368,
0.0014055455,
-0.033002682,
0.0338446647,
0.0004065751,
0.0466612391,
0.0198094584,
0.0340081826,
0.0102865724,
0.0770009086,
0.0425512381,
-0.0704855323,
0.0454070047,
-0.0106838029,
0.0731270388,
0.0472883284,
0.0007513146,
-0.0074537508,
0.0530618131,
-0.0330000892,
-0.0062530274,
-0.0368267968,
-0.0046277223,
-0.0272452179,
0.028573161,
0.0111280773,
-0.0666742548,
-0.047620032,
-0.0735463426,
-0.0073574935,
-0.0212133341,
-0.004068247,
0.0578148998,
-0.0244220998,
0.0425483845,
0.0212152228,
0.026272269,
-0.0260755997,
0.0063388767,
0.0439619124,
-0.0473926999,
0.0166189894,
0.0076966737,
0.0277416352,
-0.0462485813,
0.0162498634,
0.0337398797,
0.0136249131,
0.0340195969,
-0.0354510024,
0.001348676,
0.0579622202,
-0.0799279138,
0.0002460094,
-0.0094099147,
-0.0304408446,
-0.0139819104,
-0.0126553895,
0.056602437,
0.0296901092,
-0.0197653808,
0.0732387677,
0.0035380318,
0.0235224701,
-0.0187242366,
-0.0484900251,
-0.0182258207,
0.0166507307,
-0.0195918046,
-0.005028984,
0.0364251249,
-0.0057012965,
0.0522758961,
-0.0158109926,
0.0060793255,
0.0175630972,
2.559e-7,
0.0169108566,
0.0168382265,
0.0588917024,
-0.0446071364,
0.0384472683,
0.0100032864,
-0.049240049,
-0.0057450626,
-0.0267100725,
0.0070440145,
0.0418567955,
-0.0030077836,
0.1203723848,
0.0180287249,
-0.0843098611,
-0.0055360305,
-0.0831723064,
-0.0011305965,
-0.050709147,
-0.0349071287,
0.0482973792,
0.1014050469,
0.0146855637,
-0.0288359392,
-0.0097569898,
-0.0524095744,
0.0154283345,
-0.0563570485,
0.0258527081,
-0.0205234699,
0.0223177839,
-0.01289469,
0.0047993758,
-0.002201543,
-0.0409536213,
0.0624323636,
0.0279276408,
0.0868218467,
0.0393819176,
-0.0450520925,
-0.0050817132,
0.0041571897,
-0.0599328689,
0.0112624215,
0.075222604,
0.0213389173,
-0.059649583,
-0.0425933562,
-0.0154418601,
-0.0182418395,
0.0378121734,
-0.0102517121,
0.0039272453,
0.0005194046,
0.0051563173,
-0.0423171595,
-0.0347373337,
-0.0425575376,
-0.0211572796,
0.081083484,
-0.065157041,
-0.0261524338,
-0.0202524643,
-0.0181493219,
0.0301242061,
-0.0428375229,
0.0097354744,
2.05732381e-34,
0.046416264,
-0.0471191928,
0.0324127451,
-0.0077430978,
-0.0123059377,
-0.0409784019,
0.0264876299,
-0.0021621892,
0.0324878544,
-0.0669459626,
-0.0134507343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17227v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17227v2 | War and Peace (WarAgent): Large Language Model-based Multi-Agent Simulation of World Wars | 2023-11-28T20:59:49 | 2024-01-30T18:53:30 | Wenyue Hua, Lizhou Fan, Lingyao Li, Kai Mei, Jianchao Ji, Yingqiang Ge, Libby Hemphill, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Can we avoid wars at the crossroads of history? This question has been
pursued by individuals, scholars, policymakers, and organizations throughout
human history. In this research, we attempt to answer the question based on the
recent advances of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Large Language Models
(LLMs). We propose \textbf{WarAgent}, an LLM-powered multi-agent AI system, to
simulate the participating countries, their decisions, and the consequences, in
historical international conflicts, including the World War I (WWI), the World
War II (WWII), and the Warring States Period (WSP) in Ancient China. By
evaluating the simulation effectiveness, we examine the advancements and
limitations of cutting-edge AI systems' abilities in studying complex
collective human behaviors such as international conflicts under diverse
settings. In these simulations, the emergent interactions among agents also
offer a novel perspective for examining the triggers and conditions that lead
to war. Our findings offer data-driven and AI-augmented insights that can
redefine how we approach conflict resolution and peacekeeping strategies. The
implications stretch beyond historical analysis, offering a blueprint for using
AI to understand human history and possibly prevent future international
conflicts. Code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/agiresearch/WarAgent}. | [
0.0443326831,
0.0658553317,
-0.0292699505,
-0.0124940369,
-0.0510540903,
-0.0349528976,
0.0536797605,
-0.0048016068,
0.0634722039,
-0.0057231532,
0.0526690409,
-0.0409122631,
-0.0199253038,
-0.0137578771,
0.0124977119,
-0.0016014534,
0.0247568432,
-0.0504529476,
0.0323981605,
-0.0030840302,
-0.0342135169,
-0.0224447194,
-0.0316928215,
0.0205832217,
-0.0306800604,
0.0243612267,
-0.0771861747,
-0.0319752209,
-0.0048359782,
-0.0360653624,
-0.0199301559,
0.0094372453,
0.0506113805,
0.0237688739,
0.0000019575,
-0.042185545,
0.0204494819,
-0.0200219247,
-0.0196935218,
0.0166700892,
0.05790307,
0.0226241909,
-0.0250783376,
-0.0210746974,
-0.0635853261,
0.0367123857,
0.0047955373,
0.01237009,
0.0588972904,
0.0504192747,
0.0024266534,
0.0025433295,
0.0513706915,
0.0036236199,
-0.0315991975,
-0.0465495288,
0.039205119,
0.0080497786,
0.017896479,
-0.0190256406,
0.003370156,
0.0307689868,
-0.0181288198,
-0.0076809335,
-0.0553430654,
0.041000668,
-0.0045697512,
0.0283425171,
-0.0257825237,
0.0197080746,
0.0464838371,
-0.0189562924,
0.0200078879,
0.0184673872,
-0.0299424361,
-0.0031705929,
0.0046707457,
0.0044537275,
0.0133492155,
0.0084392419,
0.086151436,
0.0073689334,
0.0222800188,
0.0016597949,
-0.0172543768,
0.0968585387,
0.0038484954,
-0.0030683109,
-0.0434329808,
-0.0177053064,
-0.0109589575,
-0.0845056921,
-0.0282695834,
0.0520229787,
-0.0941863433,
0.009432612,
-0.0037846291,
0.0085556088,
0.0050850692,
-0.0701028183,
0.0019062705,
0.0042221136,
0.0139994184,
0.0812829137,
0.0542214774,
0.0405212715,
0.0035359827,
0.0103706392,
0.029918991,
-0.0102428626,
-0.0576410592,
-0.0010629048,
-0.026121676,
0.0164169241,
0.0213814676,
-0.0344365612,
-0.0100332024,
0.0054060444,
-0.0557733886,
0.0357242525,
-0.0281320289,
-0.0141905677,
0.0035093958,
-0.012750796,
-0.0739436597,
-0.0088947238,
-0.0707050189,
0.0186237823,
-0.0330702364,
-0.0613247901,
0.020741744,
-0.0203808844,
-0.0228384212,
-0.0140530132,
0.0202843472,
0.0939343795,
-0.0022474003,
0.0215805843,
-0.0410254113,
0.0088776648,
0.0517385378,
-0.0627452657,
0.0182243232,
-0.0892155319,
0.0734923705,
0.0065340498,
0.0083121518,
-0.0618818067,
-0.0080170445,
-0.0163098518,
-0.0406136177,
0.0402226523,
-0.0194781981,
0.0368273966,
0.0127669042,
-0.0086840279,
0.0107755074,
0.028607456,
0.072390601,
-0.0150322765,
0.060798835,
0.0404147655,
0.0766598657,
0.0318207778,
-0.0341248661,
0.0506954379,
-0.0423762947,
-0.0213401876,
-0.0146681201,
0.0070245415,
-0.0579415858,
0.0165777877,
-0.0136059821,
-0.0488912649,
0.0502038226,
0.0543318614,
-0.0454985835,
0.053855069,
0.0475543216,
0.0194505081,
0.0191157255,
0.0045880475,
-0.0328712054,
0.0018276067,
-0.0403328761,
-0.0327804089,
-0.0012342215,
0.038502723,
-0.0186405703,
0.0037693414,
0.0277709235,
-0.0361516736,
0.0447710492,
-0.0225922149,
0.0256665573,
-0.0511336923,
-0.0280444734,
-0.0097522493,
0.0529276393,
-0.0448104106,
-0.0183082502,
-0.0755502433,
-0.0030052939,
0.0658199117,
0.0682733506,
-0.0803175494,
-0.0410656147,
-0.0188234895,
0.0039751162,
0.025464097,
0.0474927016,
0.0034854319,
0.0287728216,
-0.0412361994,
-0.0198522285,
0.0155463181,
0.0064792973,
0.0301596858,
-0.0215724558,
-0.0219589025,
-0.0328303538,
0.011266211,
-0.0350033455,
0.0414826125,
-0.0558750778,
-0.0276519749,
-0.0423999503,
0.0001944595,
0.0471413694,
0.0209124833,
-0.0313982815,
0.0222120583,
0.007733996,
-0.0038313556,
-0.0197054558,
0.0142412093,
0.039040979,
0.0913815275,
0.0328653045,
-0.0210428499,
0.0177378133,
-0.0060681878,
0.0005394485,
-0.0044914116,
0.0468733273,
-0.0071476293,
0.0068476321,
0.0190430712,
0.0350134932,
-0.0555004515,
0.0143985329,
-0.0294695329,
0.0445309803,
0.0287098102,
-0.0316956528,
0.0344718434,
-0.0073488676,
0.0311775636,
0.0284993183,
-0.0100710439,
0.0132239489,
0.0274049919,
0.0437341258,
0.0536933802,
-0.0212932229,
0.0256757438,
-0.0346664712,
-0.0669257566,
-0.002571342,
0.0175177883,
-0.0503049828,
-0.0012410999,
-0.0541954152,
-0.0090559172,
0.0396905728,
-0.0013452489,
0.0401566438,
-0.0088882912,
-0.006786888,
0.0131222997,
-0.0183826853,
-0.0245570205,
-0.038262859,
0.0214749686,
-0.0325958505,
0.0594186038,
0.0309148785,
-0.0030037093,
-0.0204892121,
-0.0154955024,
-0.0577837527,
0.0699218363,
-0.0612541251,
-0.0804648027,
0.0350834616,
-0.0367644243,
0.0215092283,
0.0297531877,
0.0126639772,
0.0945912823,
0.083235383,
-0.0202076826,
-0.0520312935,
0.0063618547,
-0.0335082486,
-0.0325092487,
-0.0862790123,
-0.0484508947,
-0.0493305586,
0.0698084608,
0.035163071,
0.0313729681,
0.0022561923,
0.0062038214,
-0.0308320187,
-0.0267788302,
-0.0127607379,
-0.0450738333,
0.008260088,
0.0698832273,
-0.0208600629,
0.013996535,
0.0839715153,
0.0161686894,
0.0284940209,
0.0201682802,
0.0050457483,
-0.0238970295,
0.0476145372,
0.0182004254,
-0.0069720377,
-0.0215074457,
0.0452323817,
-0.0562962443,
-0.0415462255,
0.0109375445,
-0.0275543407,
-0.0036541619,
-0.0556421466,
-0.0041874349,
0.0070108948,
0.0182173159,
0.0022304622,
-0.0476417057,
-0.0482440852,
0.0102302982,
-0.008827501,
-0.0163440816,
-0.0188971758,
0.0295404475,
0.0819144696,
-0.0014614156,
0.0077987276,
0.0164654199,
-0.0430704765,
-0.0068617659,
0.0109697133,
-0.0071185101,
0.0253031477,
-0.0291534923,
-0.0008537805,
0.0187638737,
0.0168319307,
-0.0052972035,
-0.0355633684,
-0.0034098993,
0.0276840404,
-0.0038491758,
0.0034307211,
-0.005677382,
-0.0253592003,
-0.0428028628,
0.0579892658,
0.0744406879,
0.0539375804,
-0.0118639898,
0.0326558091,
0.0003327658,
-0.0308100302,
-0.0004085851,
0.019231258,
-0.0556427017,
0.03063301,
0.0141675826,
-0.0309554748,
-0.0509486236,
-0.0688171983,
0.0381609797,
-0.0829922408,
0.0176546611,
0.0069290563,
0.0087955398,
-0.017647136,
-0.0373650081,
-0.0067266519,
-0.0033999574,
-0.0471856222,
0.0099063115,
0.068604663,
-0.0174959861,
-0.023312157,
-0.0264375564,
0.0149183571,
0.0168479197,
-0.0748349503,
0.0813729316,
0.0588593632,
0.081804134,
-0.0180821586,
0.0118208369,
0.023388112,
0.0456869379,
0.0072465339,
0.0521853864,
0.0336329155,
0.0379877463,
-0.030744113,
0.0006134523,
-0.0035976185,
0.0285391062,
-0.0380527712,
0.0618482716,
0.0377646051,
-0.0306433849,
-0.0265331101,
0.0147100845,
-0.0074066781,
0.0488889478,
0.0075527616,
-0.0189189594,
-0.0628688335,
-0.0510723628,
-0.0299038887,
0.0168436598,
-0.0453951843,
-0.0716245398,
0.003334742,
0.0215945281,
-0.0438944325,
0.0001454499,
-0.0911403596,
-0.0201853868,
-0.0174945164,
0.0571955517,
-0.0027221597,
0.0415505953,
0.0097664893,
-0.003492082,
-0.0142405266,
-0.0401591472,
0.0130140726,
-0.0075335028,
-0.0496810637,
0.002268933,
-0.0135105606,
-0.0066347658,
0.0441384353,
-0.0551941805,
-0.0510954745,
0.0460602157,
0.0395859368,
0.0170824248,
0.0006417922,
-0.0087695764,
0.0093028713,
0.0251683556,
0.001940448,
-0.0144313183,
0.0321026742,
-0.0045804339,
-0.0243047271,
0.0119830994,
0.0293304678,
-0.0002207927,
0.0139810778,
0.012511394,
-0.0268866662,
-0.0777984709,
-0.0617024936,
0.0099024577,
-0.0371532701,
-0.0066521605,
-0.013778544,
-0.0438804775,
-0.0031035824,
0.002221568,
-0.0312028732,
0.0001477033,
0.0079164468,
-0.0298393257,
-0.023749128,
-0.0117109111,
0.0100133521,
0.0067471415,
0.0007872216,
-0.0043502022,
0.0413216315,
0.0492572598,
0.0111332899,
0.0743716881,
0.0262141507,
0.0083308155,
0.0140448101,
0.0493273996,
-0.0445139967,
0.0072027287,
-0.0095807808,
0.0037167806,
0.0091308421,
-0.0168687794,
0.0102331312,
-0.0117133288,
-0.0768828169,
-0.0929317698,
0.0290704146,
0.0386848301,
0.0682006925,
0.0131652709,
0.0020516298,
-0.0568254925,
0.0151254544,
0.0019036656,
-0.0181714725,
0.0011114504,
-0.0326488391,
-0.0330306627,
0.0245797131,
-0.0119813494,
0.0925352797,
0.0577161722,
-0.0165071879,
0.0782610476,
0.0666410848,
-0.025049895,
-0.0067868442,
-0.0432529263,
-0.0028376083,
0.018872099,
-0.0387353599,
0.0184718799,
-0.0679209828,
-0.0136182252,
-0.0008609593,
0.0620470755,
-0.011657347,
-0.0079639526,
-0.0326901749,
0.0147488927,
-0.0135117294,
0.0810985118,
-0.0946211964,
0.0448964387,
-0.0394377857,
-0.0124218659,
0.0281055942,
-5.59225054e-33,
-0.0141629772,
-0.0139254378,
0.057113532,
-0.0404220782,
-0.0560103133,
-0.0613747649,
-0.0648732036,
-0.0126186768,
-0.049815692,
0.04665564,
-0.0178861786,
-0.0251339376,
0.0184051488,
-0.0143317441,
0.0179957021,
-0.0262084473,
-0.0029121779,
-0.0018405857,
0.0109961154,
0.0040778085,
0.0221116208,
-0.0336676762,
-0.0144503899,
-0.0644070134,
0.0040422175,
-0.0137320887,
-0.0106108245,
-0.0092184152,
0.0142440749,
0.043374978,
-0.0334139019,
-0.0007392508,
-0.0024938395,
-0.0285104588,
0.0208065137,
-0.0252373833,
-0.0042797346,
0.0110169789,
-0.0095872618,
-0.0190489236,
0.0347260758,
-0.0217898004,
-0.0487726964,
0.0144610954,
-0.0220377203,
0.0190713312,
0.0468291305,
-0.0402356684,
0.0165622141,
0.0264750179,
-0.0749489218,
0.0059113568,
-0.0506426953,
-0.0174805503,
-0.042673558,
-0.0090384977,
0.0224274322,
0.0169042684,
-0.0659829453,
0.0696993694,
0.0088551445,
-0.0224851929,
0.0030976471,
0.0141332019,
0.0222505499,
0.0686061829,
0.0157143604,
0.0254437905,
-0.0438599139,
-0.0398050584,
0.0382163078,
0.0253330749,
0.0264594276,
0.0875934809,
-0.0248862877,
-0.036949385,
-0.0403318517,
-0.0088056233,
0.0526144393,
0.0181855708,
0.0263102371,
0.0162485112,
0.0140158888,
-0.0139882583,
-0.001500327,
-0.0536277778,
-0.0103304228,
-0.006254761,
-0.0308876857,
-0.0364138298,
-0.0070930161,
0.0016012093,
0.0381798819,
-0.0473572388,
0.006336276,
0.041604083,
0.0296386294,
0.0505098179,
-0.0218740497,
-0.0215508379,
-0.0147103081,
-0.0254589394,
-0.0365712568,
-0.035608571,
0.0505467393,
0.0440018773,
-0.0599291176,
0.0079049701,
0.0163716301,
0.0071048103,
-0.0180734582,
-0.000360744,
0.0317863338,
-0.0559996441,
0.0108985258,
0.0105843991,
-0.0052035875,
-0.0536972396,
0.0155219855,
-0.0662291199,
0.0388507061,
0.0358569399,
-0.018995855,
0.0037846691,
0.021495536,
0.0220522564,
-0.0582707934,
0.0947233438,
0.0110525806,
-0.0304525625,
-0.0249723848,
-0.0291762091,
2.548e-7,
-0.0095530925,
0.0679150745,
0.0603844114,
0.050466232,
-0.004889972,
0.066604957,
-0.0473859198,
0.0239820722,
-0.0244290475,
-0.0127700856,
0.047637634,
0.0466531366,
0.0338501371,
0.0381249227,
-0.0394300185,
0.0178918857,
-0.0020784454,
-0.0140749831,
-0.0818926916,
-0.0121934032,
0.0371653363,
0.0091427919,
0.0734976083,
-0.0145772379,
-0.0164467953,
-0.0039633806,
-0.0036592931,
-0.036301624,
-0.030879911,
0.0610553622,
-0.0217161477,
-0.0471176282,
-0.0077846223,
0.0343654193,
0.0030595863,
-0.0184260495,
-0.0251454115,
0.0371754132,
0.0050563556,
-0.0225916989,
-0.0231494289,
-0.0449896678,
-0.0218165871,
-0.0426038317,
0.0453850105,
0.0193790421,
-0.0107533894,
-0.001539669,
-0.0378405116,
0.0216574222,
0.0089357859,
-0.0190437865,
-0.0092519904,
0.0036032307,
-0.0088045401,
0.0153037878,
0.0531375892,
0.0012548734,
-0.0291703194,
-0.0134853879,
-0.0438039601,
-0.0407145023,
0.0154758729,
0.0405572541,
0.0226544477,
0.0145803159,
0.015586325,
1.942336356e-34,
0.0149771357,
0.0039659697,
0.0004184007,
0.0283280108,
0.0652367547,
0.0192986485,
-0.0573401712,
0.0341886804,
0.0326599851,
-0.0026911104,
-0.0200344119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17213v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17213v3 | General-Purpose vs. Domain-Adapted Large Language Models for Extraction of Structured Data from Chest Radiology Reports | 2023-11-28T20:34:40 | 2024-04-09T13:46:46 | Ali H. Dhanaliwala, Rikhiya Ghosh, Sanjeev Kumar Karn, Poikavila Ullaskrishnan, Oladimeji Farri, Dorin Comaniciu, Charles E. Kahn | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.IV | Radiologists produce unstructured data that can be valuable for clinical care
when consumed by information systems. However, variability in style limits
usage. Study compares system using domain-adapted language model (RadLing) and
general-purpose LLM (GPT-4) in extracting relevant features from chest
radiology reports and standardizing them to common data elements (CDEs). Three
radiologists annotated a retrospective dataset of 1399 chest XR reports (900
training, 499 test) and mapped to 44 pre-selected relevant CDEs. GPT-4 system
was prompted with report, feature set, value set, and dynamic few-shots to
extract values and map to CDEs. Output key:value pairs were compared to
reference standard at both stages and an identical match was considered TP. F1
score for extraction was 97% for RadLing-based system and 78% for GPT-4 system.
F1 score for mapping was 98% for RadLing and 94% for GPT-4; difference was
statistically significant (P<.001). RadLing's domain-adapted embeddings were
better in feature extraction and its light-weight mapper had better f1 score in
CDE assignment. RadLing system also demonstrated higher capabilities in
differentiating between absent (99% vs 64%) and unspecified (99% vs 89%).
RadLing system's domain-adapted embeddings helped improve performance of GPT-4
system to 92% by giving more relevant few-shot prompts. RadLing system offers
operational advantages including local deployment and reduced runtime costs. | [
0.0466852114,
-0.0111983838,
0.0130963484,
-0.0293965936,
-0.0208638702,
0.061094135,
-0.0119146025,
0.0594013035,
-0.0092021059,
-0.034526471,
-0.0193486419,
-0.0351179913,
0.0067929463,
0.0440574922,
-0.0088318596,
-0.0824352428,
0.0131904325,
0.0005907519,
0.0388279073,
0.023308631,
-0.009710771,
-0.0086950576,
0.0324333832,
0.0103026107,
0.0223550089,
0.0112799965,
-0.0045834691,
-0.0251194295,
-0.0009510918,
-0.0472334735,
-0.0500765443,
0.0075209169,
0.0154354079,
-0.0212490391,
0.0000021546,
-0.0451788232,
-0.0523267128,
0.0593926534,
-0.038461782,
-0.0327439196,
0.0876778886,
-0.0563931093,
-0.0229540896,
-0.0007121506,
-0.0053741015,
-0.0867267698,
0.0362228006,
0.0348510109,
0.0509239063,
0.0455648042,
-0.0372538902,
-0.0192805156,
0.002280971,
-0.0014505831,
-0.0140270768,
-0.0490144901,
0.040744897,
0.0575518459,
0.0551773049,
0.0175427869,
0.0229096357,
0.021996621,
-0.0288864728,
0.0212901589,
0.0051416,
0.0535200387,
-0.0266706217,
0.0252096932,
-0.0036029911,
0.0454667658,
0.0019440182,
0.0318196863,
0.024098428,
-0.0160296746,
0.0013349409,
-0.010163256,
-0.0467785858,
-0.0091135232,
-0.0136608584,
-0.0070354948,
0.0264224652,
-0.0275909547,
-0.0286874659,
-0.0112088993,
-0.0693064034,
-0.0425924771,
-0.0140604302,
-0.0419903137,
0.0329474881,
-0.0125780134,
-0.0052898214,
-0.0621288382,
0.0275679119,
0.0517426208,
0.0035710833,
0.0314270705,
-0.0395170636,
-0.021453796,
0.0689634308,
-0.0442856103,
-0.0084522618,
-0.0152312033,
-0.042558521,
0.0690213293,
-0.0361396298,
0.0312667228,
-0.0242444947,
0.0450980887,
-0.0440250561,
0.0174607225,
-0.0513532944,
-0.0264517013,
0.004126885,
0.0610949807,
0.0133985411,
-0.0137195829,
-0.0591264628,
0.0042561837,
0.0222781021,
0.0602504313,
0.0615116097,
-0.0056628352,
-0.0282779522,
0.0364836045,
-0.0202419441,
0.0280570444,
0.0157125015,
-0.013490743,
-0.0217488203,
-0.0242356323,
0.0393195301,
0.0439607911,
0.0363355055,
-0.0017322632,
0.0142253963,
0.0508028716,
0.0104543287,
-0.0126570445,
-0.0284521393,
-0.0512043759,
-0.0172090735,
-0.0157921053,
0.015430755,
-0.0570770465,
-0.0007534907,
0.0468519703,
-0.0070006726,
-0.0193738509,
-0.0042373519,
0.0138855278,
-0.0604361854,
0.0568771027,
-0.049819991,
0.0246715602,
0.0316461027,
-0.00893752,
0.0410310999,
0.0056521022,
0.0075474167,
-0.0197148044,
-0.0244627967,
-0.0251184311,
-0.0018310912,
0.0306373369,
-0.0548245385,
-0.0549890064,
-0.0257785916,
0.0642031208,
0.0321270004,
0.0401448794,
0.0139703071,
0.045165062,
-0.0115293358,
0.0091990195,
0.0229751319,
0.0696046576,
0.0695383325,
0.0221389942,
0.0277202316,
-0.0138319489,
0.010617312,
-0.0227436852,
-0.0087066721,
-0.0053076353,
0.0465353541,
0.0241903067,
-0.0416548066,
-0.0160603132,
-0.0321342498,
-0.0169692598,
-0.0552124679,
-0.0097706458,
-0.0160455499,
-0.0150008891,
0.0614150688,
-0.0206193924,
-0.0340862796,
0.0436517261,
0.0171322636,
-0.0070910724,
-0.0414503142,
-0.0398824401,
-0.0339470282,
0.0897725374,
0.0496601015,
-0.0652802438,
-0.0330644473,
-0.0230895579,
0.0444095321,
-0.0002419763,
0.0516977683,
-0.0140101714,
-0.0158306658,
-0.0448812693,
-0.0341489464,
0.053824164,
0.0053328006,
-0.0079719964,
-0.0325925797,
0.0284564253,
-0.0319673382,
-0.0246732607,
-0.0553631969,
0.0439720899,
-0.0468604714,
-0.0488449521,
-0.0337915495,
0.0152225867,
0.0108269099,
0.0264036246,
-0.0153986644,
0.0193581861,
0.0373075716,
-0.0178771373,
-0.0189037155,
-0.0030981083,
-0.0429337025,
0.0204463769,
0.0172179192,
0.0002592342,
-0.0027744295,
-0.0402620472,
-0.0236427635,
-0.0001283824,
-0.065253906,
-0.0380930528,
0.0247981101,
-0.0077364738,
0.0615642853,
0.0323032402,
-0.0140058966,
-0.0556506701,
0.0297839995,
-0.0083761634,
-0.0067221359,
0.0091736941,
-0.0501964241,
0.0262448322,
-0.0373101942,
-0.0080559766,
0.0749574825,
0.0002583689,
0.0014429078,
-0.0385444872,
0.0289441776,
-0.00927098,
-0.0176466499,
-0.0683930218,
-0.0155731058,
0.0184651464,
0.0329219028,
0.0492995679,
0.0131466929,
-0.02197011,
-0.0257993154,
-0.0528300963,
-0.0554854572,
0.0292715151,
0.0298881549,
0.0648457333,
0.0552357659,
-0.0051839338,
-0.0205547661,
0.0031085636,
-0.0274717212,
0.0068237772,
0.0087371133,
-0.044416029,
-0.0359055959,
0.1065100655,
-0.0093071572,
-0.0096278181,
0.0116800731,
-0.0236663315,
0.0004758003,
-0.0751583576,
-0.0166575443,
0.0417807363,
-0.0434461609,
-0.0136635257,
0.0354500599,
-0.0233410131,
-0.0212846585,
-0.0111920992,
-0.0372831374,
-0.0188208986,
0.0162787009,
-0.0345113091,
0.0182870161,
0.0204162393,
0.0101481499,
0.0414041877,
-0.0040498488,
-0.0311783347,
-0.0262819249,
0.0302227549,
-0.0289858971,
-0.0130447093,
-0.0048150406,
0.0384662934,
0.0202311557,
-0.0268336404,
0.059822429,
-0.0127032669,
0.0369592682,
-0.0845210254,
-0.0314174779,
-0.0389489606,
0.0153592285,
-0.0194091983,
0.0180623624,
0.0307346769,
-0.0566363558,
-0.0001069425,
0.0000342966,
0.015781166,
-0.0935005173,
0.0469885953,
0.018055724,
0.0136950864,
-0.0338399597,
0.0012458035,
-0.0357721485,
-0.0132840034,
0.0081983041,
0.0040903795,
-0.0007221045,
0.0107472735,
-0.0386058912,
0.0862237737,
0.0172744319,
0.0634898841,
0.0240076091,
-0.0253629182,
0.0179377142,
0.0308590699,
0.0216737129,
0.0117513491,
-0.0348676518,
0.0136397984,
0.0314837508,
0.037386775,
-0.0170685463,
0.0167687852,
-0.0225790087,
0.0018884788,
-0.0028864529,
-0.0268853009,
-0.0131347319,
0.0127417725,
0.0073243966,
-0.0542131886,
0.0072839693,
0.0910674781,
0.0387294143,
-0.055783391,
-0.0217917562,
-0.0137709174,
-0.0517460667,
-0.0013727823,
0.0249480326,
-0.0151654836,
0.009582066,
0.0099031422,
0.0168715529,
-0.0174741652,
-0.0505194142,
0.0278519131,
-0.0668805316,
0.0535848401,
-0.0105409073,
-0.0645591095,
-0.0655142218,
-0.0342973582,
0.0096988073,
0.0063761165,
-0.0216173138,
0.0021766881,
-0.0392653942,
-0.0223773587,
0.0315505937,
-0.1144320741,
-0.0947500467,
0.0101845535,
-0.0276219603,
-0.0038801054,
0.0874399468,
0.0216614138,
-0.0424161069,
0.0009669819,
-0.0081017772,
0.0679380372,
0.0090887165,
-0.0288522206,
0.0764052197,
0.0161980633,
0.0026779163,
-0.0459652394,
0.0047372854,
0.0086591011,
0.0335309692,
-0.0031989692,
0.091226019,
-0.0406143442,
0.0080168769,
-0.0410066545,
0.0127864992,
0.0080159996,
0.048249919,
0.0032371264,
-0.0033571904,
-0.0108421147,
-0.0084923534,
0.0426463671,
0.0420156941,
-0.055172123,
0.0721067861,
-0.0968555287,
-0.0352102853,
-0.0597983673,
-0.0279346276,
0.0568585806,
0.0107145337,
0.0297339372,
0.0663030446,
-0.0011121123,
-0.0130208973,
-0.0502294041,
0.0078603383,
-0.0033475016,
0.015888473,
-0.0381951854,
-0.0128099872,
0.0314633027,
0.003665647,
-0.0157902688,
-0.0038327556,
0.0119679198,
0.0041690101,
0.000340959,
0.0053524538,
0.0279463474,
-0.0382880904,
0.0128517542,
-0.014139954,
0.0552789904,
0.0375963338,
-0.0185582228,
-0.0322667249,
-0.0386615321,
-0.0315937474,
-0.0101692975,
-0.0131322863,
-0.0174936503,
-0.0032869768,
0.0285597909,
0.0085094366,
-0.0101384344,
-0.0126115019,
0.0244857352,
0.0809689015,
0.0082193706,
0.0232009497,
-0.0483444072,
0.0012232438,
0.0085511282,
-0.0278881639,
0.00483615,
-0.0105219847,
0.0103190066,
0.0118233357,
0.0193596259,
0.0048249969,
0.0063219215,
-0.0392861664,
-0.0162308011,
-0.0569624305,
0.07847628,
0.0180687308,
0.0028595228,
0.0319981985,
-0.0174190048,
-0.0289197601,
-0.0661326423,
0.0178976581,
0.0153355077,
-0.0175305754,
0.068757467,
-0.0047577759,
0.0422864743,
-0.0000699955,
0.0465644337,
-0.0021524858,
-0.0275175516,
-0.0313599259,
-0.007970416,
0.0260296836,
0.0000544637,
-0.0021654281,
-0.0478510857,
0.0050353906,
-0.0307818595,
0.0210657492,
0.0210031047,
0.0454260781,
0.0560736544,
0.0239042956,
-0.0162554085,
-0.0471859723,
0.0633394569,
0.0308878683,
0.02339557,
-0.0310029276,
-0.0873052105,
-0.0420282744,
0.0037225047,
0.0576094277,
-0.012539058,
-0.0574814603,
-0.0431794226,
-0.0665711612,
-0.0352812149,
0.0126881292,
-0.0133465957,
-0.0324596092,
-0.0460705087,
0.0252232477,
0.0547050945,
0.019792214,
-0.0159740355,
-0.0293449368,
0.0478911251,
-0.0058937268,
-0.0306976568,
0.0203994159,
-5.831580455e-33,
-0.0059063793,
-0.0240410883,
0.0450309329,
-0.0087297,
-0.0127778472,
0.0271618366,
0.007764352,
-0.0224918686,
-0.0009890276,
-0.0163756721,
-0.0250483528,
-0.0488270931,
0.0303828921,
-0.0273233131,
0.0175335817,
-0.0150086125,
0.0146774519,
-0.000577335,
0.0038125643,
-0.0195936542,
0.0060774363,
0.0466480888,
0.0503769368,
-0.1251766533,
-0.0224162843,
0.0068790419,
0.0291021988,
-0.036403954,
0.0495702885,
0.0547650978,
-0.0317760408,
-0.004792491,
0.0327983052,
-0.0525965691,
-0.0207896624,
0.03584278,
-0.0914120004,
0.0074335029,
0.0216854755,
0.004287214,
0.057225883,
-0.0099173384,
0.0442983992,
-0.0299706459,
0.0169944074,
0.0020349552,
0.0171039142,
-0.0357648842,
-0.0415830947,
-0.0042593768,
-0.0486708879,
0.0729043335,
0.0391957983,
0.0360248946,
0.0223158617,
-0.0040469277,
-0.040083807,
0.059829548,
-0.0336980075,
0.0045429822,
0.0915456936,
0.0235961992,
0.0158543698,
-0.0079634646,
0.0023553355,
0.0310924035,
0.025288485,
-0.0193506461,
0.0032640984,
0.0294701345,
-0.0310799442,
0.0762187243,
-0.0127674118,
0.0255475994,
0.0400402993,
-0.0254888851,
-0.0772434995,
0.0626686886,
-0.0553839579,
0.0349839181,
0.028911287,
0.0109508475,
-0.0698803067,
-0.0019069319,
0.0149051296,
0.0512009747,
-0.020831028,
-0.0571355075,
0.049827531,
0.0071392045,
-0.0024557407,
0.0596266054,
0.0348471366,
0.0168774296,
-0.0070513748,
-0.0437945127,
0.0314602666,
0.0350301825,
-0.0656544492,
-0.0469365008,
-0.0421933159,
-0.0413942263,
0.0235303659,
-0.0157885924,
0.0380458385,
0.0184096247,
0.0344646126,
0.0082922084,
-0.0688001513,
-0.0003958885,
0.0417983718,
-0.0233311988,
-0.0435743853,
0.0489110798,
0.0606542267,
0.0015220768,
0.0165083148,
0.0347929001,
0.0216052253,
-0.0401535332,
-0.0445006117,
-0.0529091507,
0.0246167034,
-0.0169831533,
-0.0228925794,
-0.0119629595,
-0.0306318495,
0.0111015392,
0.0706993863,
0.0157006867,
0.0137637034,
0.0286953934,
2.875e-7,
0.0741944984,
0.0450255536,
0.0217854697,
-0.0132635236,
0.0124613298,
-0.0003396023,
-0.0081557464,
-0.0153178181,
0.0183140654,
0.0007181045,
0.0554173067,
-0.0341271758,
0.0203759894,
0.05161459,
-0.0820405632,
-0.0504284166,
-0.0108484151,
-0.0615988746,
-0.0407084301,
-0.0064102015,
0.0785359666,
0.0644252151,
-0.0523837171,
-0.0329119042,
0.0034657132,
-0.0238299742,
-0.005580076,
-0.0546627901,
0.0049830209,
-0.0175138097,
0.0026163571,
0.0181886051,
-0.0133620556,
0.0561080687,
0.0147101395,
-0.0108234948,
0.0379964076,
0.1074007377,
-0.0460235253,
0.0609719828,
0.0279320087,
-0.0341800228,
0.0135537554,
-0.01937907,
0.0457868837,
-0.0423719622,
-0.038780123,
0.0057592592,
-0.0338808447,
-0.0098294336,
0.0140342824,
-0.0296008158,
-0.0188509263,
0.042887222,
0.0163777471,
-0.0080424417,
-0.0353965499,
-0.0497784801,
0.035010282,
0.0238749832,
-0.0087458221,
-0.0463642739,
0.0333738811,
0.0209696982,
0.0208385214,
-0.0435464233,
0.0119133117,
3.153351069e-34,
0.0021348803,
-0.0033093605,
-0.0058475072,
0.020031305,
0.0184514057,
0.0064857691,
0.0163713563,
0.0299133118,
-0.0019999058,
-0.0804243013,
0.0139845517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17154v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17154v1 | Pragmatic Radiology Report Generation | 2023-11-28T19:00:03 | 2023-11-28T19:00:03 | Dang Nguyen, Chacha Chen, He He, Chenhao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | When pneumonia is not found on a chest X-ray, should the report describe this
negative observation or omit it? We argue that this question cannot be answered
from the X-ray alone and requires a pragmatic perspective, which captures the
communicative goal that radiology reports serve between radiologists and
patients. However, the standard image-to-text formulation for radiology report
generation fails to incorporate such pragmatic intents. Following this
pragmatic perspective, we demonstrate that the indication, which describes why
a patient comes for an X-ray, drives the mentions of negative observations and
introduce indications as additional input to report generation. With respect to
the output, we develop a framework to identify uninferable information from the
image as a source of model hallucinations, and limit them by cleaning
groundtruth reports. Finally, we use indications and cleaned groundtruth
reports to develop pragmatic models, and show that they outperform existing
methods not only in new pragmatics-inspired metrics (+4.3 Negative F1) but also
in standard metrics (+6.3 Positive F1 and +11.0 BLEU-2). | [
0.0350815281,
0.027836943,
0.0109657682,
-0.0100307921,
-0.023141738,
0.0116889123,
-0.0550998002,
0.0510054231,
-0.04468913,
-0.0091148335,
-0.0001225134,
-0.0511504821,
0.0229038168,
0.0120184822,
0.0353463329,
-0.1168615669,
0.0136219151,
0.0168999135,
0.0417204536,
0.0055884868,
0.0123907123,
0.015069413,
-0.0244429708,
0.0185362883,
-0.0405186377,
-0.0454907976,
-0.0071975645,
0.044576522,
0.0297048036,
-0.0139861507,
-0.0557157248,
0.0163238067,
-0.0334168039,
-0.0125696734,
0.0000020579,
-0.0134528168,
-0.0106094358,
-0.0018552939,
0.0025184304,
-0.0366025008,
0.077529259,
-0.0662574992,
-0.0139507335,
-0.0237429999,
-0.0491841137,
-0.0570202321,
0.0950317085,
0.0741186738,
0.0720123202,
0.0933426023,
-0.022885792,
0.0064718439,
-0.0242936034,
-0.0066955602,
0.0380188748,
0.0125493938,
-0.0070603536,
0.0438993908,
0.0394872501,
-0.0080722785,
-0.0156443268,
0.0462977178,
0.0000184217,
0.002930362,
-0.0037305376,
0.0556092672,
0.004253699,
-0.0181546547,
0.0004263602,
0.0416606218,
-0.0112839816,
-0.0170902405,
0.0141601395,
-0.0145209283,
-0.0088105649,
-0.022108024,
-0.0186791997,
0.0468611158,
-0.0237768311,
0.0187376812,
0.01879647,
0.0098832855,
-0.0039500017,
-0.00108928,
-0.0063926694,
-0.0065308698,
0.0033706392,
-0.0046682102,
0.0036098212,
0.0234389305,
-0.0045950972,
-0.0788874254,
0.017968215,
0.031517148,
-0.0435146913,
0.0016529063,
-0.0300834551,
0.0266570859,
0.0388043709,
-0.0719129145,
-0.0393104888,
-0.0023745277,
-0.0292163715,
0.0348983444,
0.0117598241,
0.0053658281,
-0.0330456197,
0.0743788853,
-0.0296470411,
0.0454715043,
0.0006305366,
-0.0218743365,
-0.0402711369,
0.0053505623,
0.0111718597,
-0.0203074627,
-0.0440742001,
-0.0103444559,
-0.0347610936,
0.0248346664,
0.0196477789,
0.05024454,
-0.0735394359,
0.0046419939,
-0.0060140942,
0.0390522629,
-0.0219479855,
-0.0216521602,
-0.0003243551,
-0.01405722,
0.0078364741,
0.0615664683,
-0.0074273976,
0.0325143412,
-0.0384918451,
0.0121901436,
-0.0143509824,
0.052770216,
0.0310646538,
-0.1040719226,
-0.0157937109,
-0.0632781908,
0.0159167517,
-0.0285010915,
-0.0055797165,
-0.000396357,
0.0090770898,
-0.0689166561,
0.0077063725,
0.0055476422,
-0.0275944285,
0.0408137068,
-0.0554697774,
0.0185890924,
0.0082675004,
0.0385307223,
0.0270369407,
0.0291053653,
0.0102557326,
0.0227306541,
0.0021427672,
-0.0041460739,
0.0549240001,
-0.0011895626,
0.0068829283,
-0.029749224,
-0.0406816751,
-0.0040879645,
-0.0121820457,
0.0441319272,
0.0248693731,
0.0610085018,
-0.0267200656,
-0.0071629253,
0.0214034915,
-0.0058937171,
0.0077305087,
-0.030550167,
0.0437438861,
-0.0084503023,
-0.0297358017,
0.0701654106,
-0.0058755279,
0.0364463069,
0.0317632966,
0.026473131,
-0.0040435917,
-0.0390270278,
-0.0445453301,
-0.0217507612,
-0.0209934134,
0.0008222483,
-0.0082876831,
-0.0164647326,
-0.0162499845,
0.0390630439,
-0.075667344,
0.0321546532,
0.0154907405,
-0.0299060494,
-0.0102583617,
-0.0290242657,
0.0145341298,
0.0944436193,
0.0677075312,
0.0080160229,
0.0124978274,
-0.0101323184,
0.0630324185,
0.0668888539,
0.0361177363,
-0.0128058437,
0.0135569833,
-0.0443385541,
0.0044338261,
0.0244070962,
0.0318356417,
-0.0274682045,
-0.034992557,
0.0190217681,
-0.0134551618,
-0.0184805468,
-0.0388141572,
0.0308068898,
-0.023878267,
-0.0134465052,
-0.0213543139,
0.0202464499,
-0.0056912247,
-0.0016529281,
-0.0159822628,
0.0465745628,
0.0091273347,
-0.0053655412,
-0.0079567609,
0.0597949103,
-0.0571413599,
-0.0084439544,
0.0157488063,
-0.0736792237,
0.0170240384,
-0.0457671657,
-0.0080953203,
-0.0097524859,
-0.0329124704,
-0.0851532817,
0.0639794543,
-0.0352976806,
0.0324873962,
0.0635411814,
0.0095821358,
0.0173653364,
0.0493006222,
-0.0155192334,
0.0088355578,
0.0406893231,
-0.0138665764,
-0.0127681624,
-0.0543660782,
-0.0059337779,
0.0219801199,
0.0146444393,
-0.0016659374,
0.0040065125,
0.028689906,
-0.0431544147,
0.0137596596,
-0.06748043,
-0.0328700356,
0.006382124,
-0.0197752435,
0.0779859349,
-0.0135193598,
0.0017663578,
-0.0129374601,
-0.0322107598,
-0.0176521074,
0.0331790298,
0.0223029014,
0.0384149514,
0.0356078111,
-0.0120855104,
-0.0057796612,
0.0036137339,
-0.0201017521,
0.0118067022,
0.016176194,
-0.0560530908,
-0.089116171,
0.0872256011,
-0.040828459,
-0.0075503839,
0.0027487727,
-0.034244597,
0.0207344517,
-0.0318602659,
-0.0016150578,
0.0379877128,
-0.0059762788,
0.0051531112,
0.0297215078,
-0.0333609283,
-0.0069305231,
-0.01575654,
-0.042717725,
0.0092933839,
0.0497329682,
-0.131959036,
-0.0125576155,
0.0265546236,
0.0430403948,
0.0397806019,
-0.0694528893,
0.0193397757,
-0.0386512503,
-0.0470153578,
0.0094080986,
-0.0164878312,
0.0038911037,
0.0582888648,
-0.0103371488,
-0.0301038753,
0.0700436532,
-0.0114804618,
-0.0054446794,
-0.0360295512,
0.0316121913,
0.0090061016,
0.0186203979,
-0.0062381364,
0.0536459014,
0.0548801757,
-0.0121360924,
-0.0283519849,
-0.0507303327,
0.0040952237,
-0.0501837842,
0.0058560488,
-0.0450823791,
-0.0118090604,
0.0063769082,
-0.0031608189,
-0.0238421001,
-0.0559255555,
0.0304078944,
-0.0381916165,
-0.0466464683,
0.0011537318,
-0.0671824813,
0.0793031603,
-0.0050466652,
0.0036301927,
-0.0104284314,
-0.0283464156,
0.0064262641,
-0.0058166455,
0.0495334156,
0.0031672174,
-0.0143675078,
-0.0265919771,
0.0002055186,
0.1065774485,
-0.0223415457,
0.0608066358,
0.0179167334,
-0.0200030748,
-0.0185166486,
0.0319722332,
-0.0330374464,
0.0320912898,
0.0659873858,
-0.0204268899,
-0.0670554563,
0.074237667,
0.0292974189,
-0.003301874,
0.0129481675,
-0.0006809865,
0.0223038141,
-0.0278582294,
-0.0112129459,
-0.0106909545,
0.0059440206,
0.0050148377,
0.0269121118,
-0.0577010661,
-0.0160777178,
-0.026575638,
-0.0319412909,
0.0584636889,
0.0269129127,
-0.0266902819,
-0.0413953178,
-0.017343102,
0.001198233,
0.0252727792,
-0.0336861014,
-0.0040069846,
0.0046470347,
0.010185021,
0.010574365,
-0.0367844626,
-0.0268644076,
-0.024124518,
-0.0210449025,
-0.0040439363,
0.0567189381,
0.0499334969,
0.0056141899,
-0.0872209147,
-0.0527725965,
0.0553195402,
0.0291710533,
0.0050020167,
0.0612247214,
0.0169041697,
-0.0086936653,
-0.0542740412,
0.026546834,
-0.0358690694,
-0.0101639824,
-0.0089845611,
0.0518241152,
-0.0523043163,
-0.0434827991,
-0.0446405262,
0.1188793555,
0.0574511476,
0.0624577776,
0.0184831899,
0.0183638055,
-0.0416828841,
0.0027188265,
0.118732892,
-0.0322140492,
-0.0364123136,
0.0114981038,
-0.0224172939,
-0.0892185569,
-0.1022211835,
-0.0688862577,
0.0070085833,
0.0598735437,
0.0022044003,
0.0060687852,
-0.0129803512,
-0.036885608,
-0.0477519296,
0.0085132858,
-0.0009553743,
-0.0005076212,
-0.0145397782,
-0.0276242942,
0.0163883381,
0.0426152796,
0.0154543445,
0.0697447658,
-0.0477668904,
-0.0109014567,
0.0122830104,
0.0442333482,
0.0443901271,
-0.022132406,
0.0121973734,
-0.0101447413,
0.0066387565,
0.046196714,
-0.0118426252,
0.0460919254,
-0.0011952358,
-0.0498565249,
0.0007408646,
0.0174144264,
0.0173406508,
-0.0061984966,
0.0134712476,
0.0522084758,
-0.0530212894,
0.002368548,
0.039020557,
0.0082231006,
-0.0238949843,
-0.0318340547,
-0.0566951632,
-0.0034179236,
-0.0276760757,
-0.079577215,
-0.0231858473,
-0.0066059516,
0.0259458162,
-0.0084740724,
-0.0047238143,
0.0035764885,
-0.0072788578,
-0.1111530587,
-0.0047410731,
-0.0047737779,
-0.0290728752,
0.0423764288,
-0.0085832952,
0.0209298786,
-0.0297450367,
-0.0099674789,
-0.0309631433,
-0.0131796664,
0.0378067605,
0.0066756597,
0.0787697136,
0.032746464,
0.0135824,
-0.0121411011,
0.02787246,
0.0104638916,
-0.0336583778,
-0.0311251879,
0.0414412953,
0.01119739,
0.0263667889,
0.0420563854,
-0.0465716757,
0.0196301788,
-0.0075390846,
0.0517048165,
0.0355375707,
-0.0362976044,
0.0212904122,
-0.0080832224,
0.013003665,
-0.0393262617,
0.0726330206,
-0.0530774854,
0.0151533429,
-0.0392269678,
-0.0529415943,
-0.0540163182,
-0.0666461885,
-0.0246326383,
-0.0147425318,
-0.0022426327,
0.0057884096,
-0.0903315172,
-0.025180554,
-0.022444224,
0.0061491965,
-0.0256509725,
-0.0338309892,
0.0408713296,
0.0683647543,
0.0043530925,
-0.0190231204,
-0.00617419,
0.0796195492,
0.013182682,
0.0102845971,
-0.0302858315,
-6.088896535e-33,
-0.0248368494,
-0.0671758801,
0.0160498954,
-0.0615493916,
0.0002939877,
0.0107290316,
-0.0447342284,
0.0003570773,
0.0298939347,
0.0274042767,
-0.00844137,
0.0022713235,
0.0279733762,
0.018057473,
-0.0192389265,
-0.0042059445,
0.044525262,
0.0111403801,
-0.0529990457,
0.0341872051,
0.0095501607,
0.0065056207,
0.0285722949,
-0.0920417607,
0.0346580073,
-0.02107873,
-0.0468025617,
-0.0174152311,
0.0462684557,
0.007915522,
-0.0301515907,
-0.0062100743,
0.030628683,
-0.0153633412,
-0.0237983242,
0.043661695,
-0.0097342879,
-0.0279550571,
0.0537016951,
0.0158809274,
-0.0660842583,
-0.0085084671,
0.0159540772,
-0.0257780664,
0.0278903693,
-0.002020197,
0.02413732,
-0.013559862,
0.0148603497,
0.0368029363,
-0.0412644893,
0.026729051,
0.0206716768,
-0.0256230291,
0.004765809,
0.023051668,
-0.0277245324,
-0.0244966894,
-0.0416602641,
0.0283731427,
0.0328426063,
0.0130339013,
0.0267590154,
-0.0346176662,
-0.0286221132,
0.0325413309,
0.0751403645,
-0.006139982,
-0.0272334423,
0.0511918105,
-0.0371648408,
0.0463728793,
0.0099478904,
0.0529811457,
0.0202727225,
0.0184244923,
-0.0342953131,
0.0414157659,
-0.0691942051,
0.0476665497,
0.0386041813,
-0.0161639396,
-0.0769324005,
-0.0206917673,
0.0459948182,
-0.0013884431,
-0.0120849516,
-0.0387107246,
0.0265858937,
-0.0005235319,
-0.0137892598,
0.0371150635,
-0.0055251373,
0.0131581603,
0.0103931893,
-0.0238984041,
-0.0115169259,
0.0267234035,
-0.0414106771,
-0.0103771705,
0.0142487921,
-0.0051512066,
0.076363571,
0.0352220722,
0.0501073599,
0.0312578343,
0.0315138213,
0.0262430515,
-0.0454874411,
0.0142879616,
-0.0046378961,
0.0253614932,
-0.0366956517,
0.0062343697,
0.0527842194,
0.0087370593,
-0.0226216651,
0.0058611785,
-0.0121364957,
0.0003259464,
-0.0214683749,
-0.0257436428,
-0.0101069268,
0.0235980563,
-0.0792201012,
-0.0154134519,
-0.0012404545,
-0.0406104214,
0.0829948932,
-0.0508121029,
-0.0277269129,
0.0063157352,
2.827e-7,
0.0341811366,
-0.0241799261,
0.0550457351,
0.021432573,
0.0184020717,
0.0116941193,
-0.02623735,
0.031047022,
0.0144098075,
-0.0612473153,
0.0168321989,
-0.0279804822,
0.0136705497,
0.0421329588,
-0.0570986159,
0.0045229895,
-0.0090555344,
-0.0004648022,
-0.0183279384,
-0.0330534689,
0.0885461718,
0.016605176,
-0.0229033809,
-0.0406274498,
0.0039338451,
-0.0324018709,
0.0380227566,
-0.0304373335,
0.0176061783,
0.0118039902,
0.0347277112,
-0.0091104414,
0.026335068,
0.0635243505,
-0.0011002717,
-0.0815536454,
0.0443975031,
0.0558107495,
-0.0390452594,
-0.031429939,
0.0013230046,
-0.0296632964,
0.0009553381,
-0.0445657372,
0.0313321874,
-0.0057032448,
-0.0279008336,
0.0284576789,
-0.052756615,
0.0252607781,
0.0387903675,
-0.0333645269,
-0.0638463572,
0.0358721688,
0.0319449492,
0.0393629111,
-0.0425787829,
-0.0366769731,
-0.0159228165,
-0.0202917438,
0.009871779,
-0.030600382,
0.0380673632,
0.0061815507,
-0.0205759741,
-0.0894258693,
-0.0159697216,
2.562798549e-34,
0.0185807552,
0.0392790176,
0.0050060321,
-0.0222619046,
0.0204467718,
-0.0012889487,
0.0329479687,
0.0160299093,
0.0304049365,
-0.0063933856,
-0.0301023964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17136v1 | UniIR: Training and Benchmarking Universal Multimodal Information Retrievers | 2023-11-28T18:55:52 | 2023-11-28T18:55:52 | Cong Wei, Yang Chen, Haonan Chen, Hexiang Hu, Ge Zhang, Jie Fu, Alan Ritter, Wenhu Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Existing information retrieval (IR) models often assume a homogeneous format,
limiting their applicability to diverse user needs, such as searching for
images with text descriptions, searching for a news article with a headline
image, or finding a similar photo with a query image. To approach such
different information-seeking demands, we introduce UniIR, a unified
instruction-guided multimodal retriever capable of handling eight distinct
retrieval tasks across modalities. UniIR, a single retrieval system jointly
trained on ten diverse multimodal-IR datasets, interprets user instructions to
execute various retrieval tasks, demonstrating robust performance across
existing datasets and zero-shot generalization to new tasks. Our experiments
highlight that multi-task training and instruction tuning are keys to UniIR's
generalization ability. Additionally, we construct the M-BEIR, a multimodal
retrieval benchmark with comprehensive results, to standardize the evaluation
of universal multimodal information retrieval. | [
0.0301976893,
0.0242389049,
0.019181272,
0.0314761065,
-0.0029580258,
0.0223596171,
0.0259884242,
0.0187940057,
-0.0005970599,
-0.0441242792,
-0.0874774531,
-0.0398631841,
-0.0538845584,
-0.0194686856,
0.0102150375,
-0.0649979338,
0.0418690555,
0.0160655379,
-0.0255687833,
0.0181647539,
0.041805312,
-0.0084062563,
-0.0201170482,
0.0288760103,
-0.0462137163,
0.0124213528,
-0.0462229438,
0.064670369,
-0.0257507861,
-0.0651734844,
0.0445297733,
0.0093178963,
0.0631164834,
-0.0185540952,
0.0000019168,
-0.0095438017,
-0.0033018072,
-0.0172900315,
0.02568198,
-0.0480567329,
0.0650247037,
-0.0187119339,
0.059447512,
-0.0146547118,
-0.0114114564,
-0.009312314,
0.0447673053,
0.0359750912,
0.0348642878,
0.047530029,
-0.0166083667,
-0.0288665947,
-0.0100219715,
0.0025896679,
0.0622869097,
-0.042117212,
-0.0091589019,
-0.013948313,
0.0274755023,
0.0404504016,
-0.0219543315,
0.0536103249,
-0.0070305471,
0.0483345129,
0.002362845,
0.0261360873,
-0.0128423097,
-0.0216163006,
-0.0428941436,
0.0645254105,
0.0042495355,
0.0239473283,
-0.0206257813,
0.0382215753,
-0.031554047,
0.0029574053,
-0.05351834,
0.0028466145,
-0.0499635451,
-0.0372996926,
-0.0924547389,
0.0093068918,
-0.0020150668,
-0.0150799826,
-0.0103818951,
0.019184934,
0.011998645,
-0.0212414209,
0.0325323381,
-0.0257551111,
0.000908991,
0.0208168421,
0.0020450524,
0.0165186748,
-0.0327191055,
-0.0133165633,
-0.0001876034,
-0.0477683768,
0.0384185798,
-0.0166966338,
0.0745619833,
0.0168332327,
-0.0898174271,
0.0726458505,
0.025312975,
0.0247523468,
-0.0357800685,
0.0348508134,
-0.0211481582,
-0.0113071222,
-0.0745595843,
-0.0029163458,
-0.0082314499,
0.0194068886,
-0.037701942,
-0.0453355648,
0.0188024584,
0.0245197322,
0.0080556907,
-0.0269183181,
-0.0089213056,
0.0198363345,
-0.0704669207,
0.0135817118,
-0.0625728071,
0.040123567,
-0.035851337,
0.0004762523,
0.0058854134,
-0.0175297521,
0.0093736015,
0.0268423315,
0.0233273041,
-0.0480220579,
0.0330529064,
0.0654715523,
-0.0647927746,
-0.0619376004,
-0.0114531647,
-0.0432901047,
0.0043346188,
-0.0464907177,
0.0446427166,
-0.0095417583,
0.0628016815,
-0.0106830262,
-0.0206399485,
-0.0044726506,
-0.0065815188,
0.0328306481,
-0.0039887927,
0.0834134966,
0.0132499551,
-0.0197024699,
0.0362094492,
0.0050532464,
-0.000961522,
0.058051277,
-0.0466708392,
0.0822092071,
0.0616575368,
0.0274623241,
0.0086606387,
0.0050253924,
-0.0108601265,
0.0052316915,
0.0174565017,
0.0217475537,
0.0084585482,
0.0109015945,
0.0276266076,
0.03907701,
-0.0389870107,
-0.0339602306,
0.0035557724,
0.0248346105,
0.0480131581,
-0.0367905907,
0.0336906537,
-0.0090724323,
-0.0177138913,
-0.0007207867,
-0.0414574035,
0.069767952,
-0.0197723228,
0.0027856356,
0.0573587343,
0.0170468111,
-0.0377310328,
-0.0135651873,
0.0258021578,
0.0039907224,
0.0032673301,
0.0308548808,
0.0600505434,
-0.0156685878,
-0.0645402893,
0.0052205804,
0.0275225081,
-0.0509953052,
-0.0121047124,
-0.0001193271,
-0.0066049965,
0.0782903358,
0.0392662995,
-0.0354365222,
0.0105366586,
0.0311780293,
0.0561736338,
0.0073934528,
-0.027021056,
-0.0144154243,
0.0587951615,
-0.0599098839,
-0.0729891136,
-0.0272307284,
-0.0175454505,
0.0385142677,
0.0069706538,
0.0069237133,
0.028842859,
-0.0342936106,
0.0324186198,
0.0330434963,
0.019536946,
-0.0267350115,
-0.0150699886,
0.0400834791,
-0.0156016545,
-0.0047179637,
-0.0288914572,
-0.008981456,
0.034123946,
-0.0211061463,
0.0089552198,
-0.0188363418,
-0.016885275,
0.0132568683,
0.0155632757,
-0.0679008588,
0.0450365879,
0.0262063965,
0.0102559151,
0.0059268312,
0.0010109775,
0.0029616903,
-0.0127629228,
-0.0300465208,
0.0009798845,
0.0261700917,
-0.0106365578,
-0.0281447731,
0.0234535728,
-0.0126587329,
0.007355189,
-0.0152860535,
-0.0172536913,
0.0225340258,
-0.0604351796,
-0.0266783573,
0.0165564939,
-0.0078136232,
0.0303761922,
0.0366294831,
0.0073589562,
-0.0236108527,
-0.0043619988,
-0.1347070932,
0.0152350571,
-0.0354694016,
-0.0165116284,
-0.0174112786,
0.019783413,
0.0211435817,
-0.0742377639,
0.0003569426,
0.0071516745,
-0.0265092142,
0.0630891249,
0.019560663,
0.0446331091,
0.0181753971,
-0.0481181405,
-0.0286549032,
0.0032095332,
0.0296712779,
-0.0092929918,
-0.0026287537,
0.0000295869,
-0.0191454832,
-0.043989744,
0.0474963263,
-0.0342220962,
-0.0035734691,
0.0683923215,
-0.0748729855,
-0.0013357206,
0.0611178577,
0.0286567248,
0.0178803317,
-0.0090702735,
-0.0170219354,
-0.0775278285,
0.0400915779,
-0.006283659,
-0.0347005911,
-0.0012168702,
-0.0138218505,
0.0167970844,
-0.0010543747,
0.0022307476,
0.0381754078,
-0.0224136468,
-0.0124283051,
0.0245909579,
-0.0462919772,
-0.0873675272,
0.0571268611,
0.030703051,
-0.0015303117,
-0.0475366749,
-0.0210714545,
0.0232259762,
-0.0211326461,
-0.0208317265,
0.0015126052,
-0.0056447382,
-0.0294664055,
0.0930686444,
-0.0170526914,
0.0293758586,
-0.0051502669,
-0.0024379655,
0.0004793235,
0.0244389363,
0.0422763452,
-0.014855505,
0.0254534334,
-0.0044886572,
0.0185247809,
-0.0096545834,
-0.0666166171,
0.0054579913,
-0.0333962105,
0.0300735515,
-0.0373706259,
-0.0137951532,
0.0130658764,
-0.0482269786,
-0.0048190318,
0.0586143434,
0.0199853834,
-0.001439214,
-0.0487446599,
-0.0053103212,
-0.0046438356,
0.0248610061,
0.0011761875,
-0.1069476977,
-0.0443996266,
-0.0614640117,
0.022127565,
0.0281256512,
-0.0381703675,
-0.0502671301,
0.0153623456,
0.03565602,
0.0353588276,
-0.0000123331,
0.029689867,
0.0351422094,
-0.006259663,
0.0043467847,
0.005845652,
0.0048730029,
-0.0618444122,
-0.0512798317,
0.0192680284,
-0.012161104,
0.0499326438,
0.0200759824,
-0.0841705501,
-0.0705834031,
-0.0151572907,
0.0441910215,
0.0638388097,
0.007496614,
0.0041150139,
-0.0449424572,
0.0078378618,
-0.0106214862,
-0.0253188759,
-0.0574344695,
-0.045456443,
-0.008308365,
-0.0088471491,
-0.0021768429,
0.0598339625,
-0.0526841357,
-0.0049042702,
0.0224324148,
0.0646618307,
-0.0475150123,
0.0056489157,
-0.0542186238,
-0.0548296385,
0.0482010469,
-0.0275104139,
0.0173546504,
-0.0363163054,
-0.0026342627,
0.0404217988,
0.0327463448,
-0.0264045093,
0.0808246955,
-0.0685149655,
-0.0190415941,
-0.0330759585,
-0.0231144503,
0.0307201892,
0.021265788,
-0.0103084957,
0.0079525746,
-0.0327957422,
0.0284551959,
-0.0625306815,
-0.0349420086,
0.0193408504,
0.0117066456,
-0.0285275187,
-0.002308358,
-0.0291621145,
-0.0087389452,
0.0171359293,
-0.0494444296,
-0.0044313259,
0.0303450134,
-0.0672997013,
0.0008331906,
-0.0435021929,
-0.029423913,
-0.0011355579,
0.0461958796,
0.0125306044,
-0.0441203229,
-0.0335163586,
0.0282218326,
-0.0786406919,
0.0388197675,
-0.0049750959,
0.0055695432,
-0.0599338524,
-0.0112448158,
0.0138280094,
-0.0278454069,
-0.0026790518,
0.0233888496,
-0.0175198913,
-0.0108579872,
-0.0367003754,
0.0614154153,
0.0048834067,
0.0065141232,
0.0463834256,
-0.0636111647,
0.0118679358,
0.0421818048,
-0.016209865,
-0.0054677031,
0.0209090207,
-0.002037935,
-0.0110126929,
-0.0174567178,
-0.0896049142,
0.0392681733,
-0.0290156957,
0.022549523,
-0.019852072,
-0.014146572,
0.0103549464,
0.013983164,
0.047967907,
0.0132607948,
0.0127029587,
-0.0191621464,
-0.0011781148,
0.0171738863,
-0.0175335556,
-0.0291718002,
0.027178349,
0.0219745319,
-0.0111854179,
0.0059505892,
0.0489533097,
0.0348588862,
0.0473520644,
-0.0648783743,
-0.0063664489,
0.0099089546,
0.003808764,
-0.0310647357,
0.0209356304,
-0.0251911022,
0.0374897681,
-0.0014784255,
0.0698493794,
-0.0186684523,
0.0752606243,
0.0280744154,
0.0016555492,
-0.0561769456,
0.0442609377,
-0.0050579091,
0.013963297,
-0.0184094403,
-0.0062368466,
0.0495100245,
0.0113327522,
-0.0100507652,
0.0123854922,
-0.0046465616,
-0.0386833809,
0.0263375156,
-0.001330424,
-0.0153371952,
0.0208697282,
0.0251706541,
0.0277585089,
0.0012144519,
0.0454475023,
-0.0372199118,
0.0239383262,
-0.0293310769,
-0.0384178385,
-0.0378266647,
-0.004749381,
0.0701465681,
0.04826314,
0.0000537862,
-0.0374099687,
0.0332572311,
0.0059344899,
-0.0044163507,
0.0344532095,
-0.0289498065,
0.028011119,
0.0615792349,
0.0940881073,
0.0261470508,
-0.0474299304,
-0.0180061813,
-0.0312697776,
-0.0377589837,
0.0224574506,
-0.0153188501,
-6.406494905e-33,
-0.0073889093,
0.0287316162,
0.0417779908,
-0.0373107418,
-0.004125942,
-0.0213828757,
0.0076830918,
0.0051410496,
-0.0299909655,
-0.0211678073,
0.0084886169,
-0.0340315104,
0.0070721856,
0.0232036971,
0.0324329957,
0.0025524087,
0.0500332527,
0.0092770979,
-0.0231706034,
-0.0097846491,
0.0886033997,
0.0621941388,
0.0369859859,
-0.0763883144,
0.0040064217,
0.0198151227,
-0.0009168394,
0.009239764,
0.0444603413,
0.0339603089,
-0.03421399,
0.039111346,
0.0138335424,
-0.0171689279,
-0.0094462698,
0.0135207437,
-0.0988955647,
-0.0092179244,
-0.0134156765,
0.0057843425,
-0.067537345,
-0.0050862767,
0.0489233807,
-0.0541110113,
0.0008155228,
-0.0210677274,
0.0479657464,
0.0494715981,
0.0020696833,
-0.0057697473,
-0.0209341254,
0.0074068536,
0.0199639257,
-0.0307828281,
0.0350275151,
0.066616565,
0.036329329,
0.0007351994,
-0.0573598668,
0.0295356587,
-0.0779478177,
0.0361404009,
0.0199440774,
0.0357669815,
-0.0117132021,
0.073660478,
0.0530471206,
-0.0108049484,
0.0010736168,
-0.0214954652,
0.028483605,
0.0662295669,
-0.0322747976,
0.0576600619,
0.0531576723,
-0.0257140417,
-0.0053314245,
0.0397583023,
0.0001153021,
0.0656814426,
-0.0010760301,
0.0713267475,
-0.0460244827,
0.0199253391,
0.0033094112,
0.0231164731,
-0.0528600179,
-0.0527599454,
0.0721723363,
0.0532801263,
0.01090449,
0.024764983,
0.0860676467,
0.0162623078,
-0.0076490007,
0.0005266513,
-0.0068350979,
0.0181750953,
-0.0102567859,
-0.0338347629,
-0.0106089134,
-0.02459554,
0.0616533421,
-0.0023167171,
0.0040151114,
-0.0001650115,
0.0077796406,
0.0266610011,
-0.0462896191,
-0.0288075078,
-0.0131199034,
-0.0051284721,
-0.0018561253,
-0.0165554099,
0.0113890516,
0.0213913471,
-0.0537699908,
0.0333118364,
-0.0269589126,
-0.0002463577,
-0.0728439763,
-0.1037312672,
0.0194907635,
-0.0026012165,
0.0160169788,
0.0622366592,
-0.0798042193,
-0.0384808891,
-0.0131403282,
-0.0629635453,
0.0075699319,
0.0844142586,
2.711e-7,
0.0205147024,
0.0303535704,
0.0197520815,
0.0265692305,
-0.0362010226,
0.0228636302,
-0.024128465,
0.038804546,
0.0159393474,
-0.0317827091,
-0.0051021543,
0.0422736667,
-0.0011618057,
0.006911533,
-0.0508392677,
-0.0583390556,
0.0131832762,
-0.0223054197,
-0.0689863116,
-0.0119570522,
0.0531491823,
0.0481619313,
-0.0380613953,
0.0140812118,
0.0299336538,
-0.0667641982,
0.0841915756,
0.0026078771,
-0.0059225564,
-0.0415443294,
0.0471886992,
0.0324307084,
-0.017917173,
-0.0066169831,
0.0061897491,
-0.0200289208,
0.0481604859,
0.0242204908,
-0.0381020606,
-0.0707741752,
0.0229510088,
0.0332144424,
-0.047030732,
-0.0063589592,
0.0764300972,
-0.006244238,
0.0332290716,
0.0007890032,
-0.035598889,
0.0299788769,
0.004866004,
-0.00900432,
-0.0559265688,
0.0059787938,
0.0158830844,
0.0043635406,
-0.018363703,
-0.0892828777,
0.0303522032,
0.0374004506,
-0.0397507213,
0.008948938,
-0.0514208265,
-0.0079086972,
-0.0042970288,
-0.0523617379,
-0.041024331,
1.549251504e-34,
0.0103326226,
0.0193102043,
0.0477794036,
-0.0356505997,
0.0276711993,
-0.0179500766,
-0.0828425959,
0.0021850923,
-0.0061752046,
-0.0465661176,
-0.0184860975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17049v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17049v2 | MobileCLIP: Fast Image-Text Models through Multi-Modal Reinforced Training | 2023-11-28T18:55:42 | 2024-04-01T13:06:06 | Pavan Kumar Anasosalu Vasu, Hadi Pouransari, Fartash Faghri, Raviteja Vemulapalli, Oncel Tuzel | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive pretraining of image-text foundation models, such as CLIP,
demonstrated excellent zero-shot performance and improved robustness on a wide
range of downstream tasks. However, these models utilize large
transformer-based encoders with significant memory and latency overhead which
pose challenges for deployment on mobile devices. In this work, we introduce
MobileCLIP -- a new family of efficient image-text models optimized for runtime
performance along with a novel and efficient training approach, namely
multi-modal reinforced training. The proposed training approach leverages
knowledge transfer from an image captioning model and an ensemble of strong
CLIP encoders to improve the accuracy of efficient models. Our approach avoids
train-time compute overhead by storing the additional knowledge in a reinforced
dataset. MobileCLIP sets a new state-of-the-art latency-accuracy tradeoff for
zero-shot classification and retrieval tasks on several datasets. Our
MobileCLIP-S2 variant is 2.3$\times$ faster while more accurate compared to
previous best CLIP model based on ViT-B/16. We further demonstrate the
effectiveness of our multi-modal reinforced training by training a CLIP model
based on ViT-B/16 image backbone and achieving +2.9% average performance
improvement on 38 evaluation benchmarks compared to the previous best.
Moreover, we show that the proposed approach achieves 10$\times$-1000$\times$
improved learning efficiency when compared with non-reinforced CLIP training.
Code and models are available at https://github.com/apple/ml-mobileclip . | [
0.0205394663,
0.0436322428,
0.0241144858,
0.0205458943,
-0.0113652647,
-0.0068912464,
0.0294181798,
0.0187030584,
-0.0521955825,
-0.0697008595,
-0.0563497655,
-0.0387022495,
-0.0178322047,
0.0096251555,
-0.0245832298,
-0.0521247573,
0.0027994174,
0.0112749105,
-0.0412565656,
0.0120160859,
0.0436093695,
0.0106811393,
0.0177394599,
0.0265751649,
-0.005124209,
0.002749542,
-0.0078592533,
0.0480902605,
0.0213769767,
-0.0757524073,
0.0299883895,
0.0678091273,
0.0430017784,
-0.0120103611,
0.0000020746,
0.0362708308,
-0.0166733079,
0.0251243822,
0.0163433477,
-0.0115104606,
0.056751553,
-0.0637134463,
-0.0014183092,
0.0174943674,
-0.0270033143,
-0.033768367,
0.0429367125,
0.0664746389,
0.0247374792,
0.0736530274,
-0.0227377042,
-0.0115912398,
0.0265756063,
-0.036807254,
-0.0035188245,
0.0052167401,
-0.0003335554,
0.0020874902,
-0.0130687952,
0.04359366,
0.0056573814,
0.0265597589,
0.0388407893,
0.0405613892,
-0.0124511942,
0.0382871553,
-0.0057210862,
-0.0145385759,
-0.0457426049,
0.0556831546,
-0.0404223055,
-0.022980677,
-0.0192095395,
-0.0020833688,
-0.018457083,
0.0093513113,
-0.0406792983,
0.0201100651,
0.0180663262,
0.0180912074,
-0.0695634484,
0.0224033315,
0.0239570215,
0.0119307507,
0.0006866714,
-0.0747182667,
0.0129352892,
-0.0090596881,
-0.0283381734,
0.0420600288,
-0.0432289466,
-0.0223458577,
0.0218892004,
0.0017457191,
0.0119693456,
-0.0018141263,
-0.0583197847,
-0.0429285802,
-0.0105881374,
-0.0318716913,
0.017835075,
0.0177018549,
-0.0406000391,
0.0554629378,
-0.0548350401,
0.0041265641,
-0.0014211478,
0.0410206243,
-0.0115811964,
0.0069127018,
-0.0583082475,
-0.0004939685,
-0.0304240268,
0.0335314162,
-0.0478534773,
-0.0475257076,
-0.0230794232,
-0.032214772,
0.004446412,
-0.0319372118,
0.0050745411,
0.0068990383,
-0.0419671573,
-0.0252795983,
0.0144334529,
0.0217966698,
0.003914875,
0.0380023643,
-0.0173702836,
-0.088888146,
-0.0078180702,
0.0082121519,
0.0242355503,
-0.0069808955,
0.029993007,
0.0379971676,
-0.0571632311,
-0.0891861171,
-0.0256914981,
0.0029087071,
-0.0331353247,
-0.0319711305,
0.0077627767,
-0.0652492791,
0.0174012333,
-0.0076308222,
0.0051824339,
-0.0155701702,
0.0476948954,
0.0628990158,
-0.0217089541,
0.0951311886,
-0.0115723563,
-0.0187393706,
-0.0048495228,
0.0309864003,
-0.0364920795,
0.0495621935,
0.0083617931,
0.0429662056,
0.0182012431,
0.0211615581,
0.012632207,
0.0183766466,
0.0265203454,
0.0191306118,
-0.0290542897,
-0.0106809214,
-0.0087342029,
-0.0331611745,
0.0170271881,
0.0517995209,
-0.0384580791,
0.0309612006,
0.0869988874,
0.0258150175,
-0.0010865072,
0.0248047896,
0.0006700092,
0.0163761936,
0.0063950932,
-0.0508815832,
-0.0718870908,
0.0195644721,
-0.0001312101,
-0.0021117101,
-0.000864465,
0.027177358,
-0.0397861302,
-0.0192522034,
-0.0076444549,
-0.0311960764,
0.0268455185,
0.006929996,
0.0621065795,
0.0078231292,
-0.0475363322,
0.059944503,
0.015617853,
-0.0307001472,
-0.038322866,
-0.0203251485,
-0.0083931638,
0.0156545714,
0.0195245761,
-0.0061702812,
-0.0349100605,
0.0013294005,
0.000499131,
0.0303927101,
-0.0096850349,
0.0135834459,
0.0311285537,
-0.0648595169,
-0.050482057,
-0.0129562356,
0.0125832958,
-0.0054753954,
0.0473278612,
0.0482455045,
0.0304883476,
0.0216874108,
-0.0255915076,
0.0408741683,
0.0634394288,
-0.0185087156,
0.002417072,
0.0160901845,
-0.0042244559,
0.0018728486,
-0.0350730754,
-0.0067235609,
0.0271057319,
-0.0347922146,
0.005605123,
0.0141913816,
-0.0740562379,
-0.0491850115,
0.0089228703,
-0.0239862893,
0.0341810547,
0.0426264182,
-0.01365407,
-0.0233786274,
-0.0170657858,
-0.0008483081,
0.0308235828,
-0.0309301522,
0.0356834792,
0.0075603267,
0.0104246736,
0.0322998017,
0.0424699858,
-0.0044683157,
-0.0087749762,
0.0324421823,
-0.0032388775,
0.0135966316,
0.0192969926,
-0.0308153667,
-0.0024574567,
-0.0313977972,
0.0196985342,
0.028754035,
0.0631780252,
-0.0246774536,
-0.0010292204,
-0.1008592844,
-0.0044888128,
-0.0347387642,
-0.0044094222,
0.008689384,
0.018708799,
0.0149569698,
-0.0700014085,
-0.0157614779,
-0.0274106711,
-0.0010396293,
0.0322565585,
-0.0248074885,
0.0321087129,
0.0381939001,
-0.0045115501,
-0.0072630597,
0.0416491739,
0.0412375443,
-0.0313120373,
-0.0345657058,
0.005973659,
-0.017267568,
0.0071310312,
0.0005903039,
-0.0020978739,
-0.0332327746,
0.0033641206,
-0.0050818194,
0.0347755179,
0.0375980437,
0.0266238842,
0.0402743816,
-0.0202346202,
0.0265823361,
-0.0436565243,
0.0103730364,
-0.0204464421,
-0.0251179524,
0.0046729892,
-0.0184401385,
-0.0524104312,
0.0713592917,
-0.0622406043,
0.0597506799,
-0.0621415302,
-0.006143461,
0.0007943659,
-0.0206523817,
-0.0409815423,
0.0478985235,
-0.0107909143,
-0.0045111394,
-0.0664998218,
-0.0515854396,
0.0233570896,
-0.0314679183,
-0.009612456,
-0.0186789557,
-0.0189785939,
0.0021920851,
0.0813234672,
0.0062933606,
0.0193875376,
0.0211957172,
0.0064160377,
-0.0171435531,
-0.0015338537,
-0.0001952958,
-0.0319075733,
0.0557258539,
-0.0091423029,
0.0207405891,
-0.0438337959,
-0.1055439338,
-0.0147962356,
-0.035361886,
-0.0431778617,
-0.0083981017,
-0.0024520706,
-0.026334716,
-0.0378441922,
0.047831282,
0.0186762679,
0.0618225411,
-0.0197230857,
0.0084956465,
-0.0105627151,
0.0658135191,
0.0162924118,
-0.0106500359,
-0.0412456952,
-0.0559408329,
-0.0062032402,
0.0668712258,
0.0058878157,
0.0020164391,
-0.0581350513,
0.0101757823,
0.009467301,
0.0410626233,
-0.0075793331,
0.0202006865,
0.0815538839,
-0.0678593665,
-0.0065580634,
0.0494498201,
-0.0100554526,
-0.0502972379,
-0.0439687744,
0.0256056637,
0.0300563499,
0.0106517188,
0.0157287493,
-0.0732944161,
-0.110396944,
-0.0163456891,
0.0000740146,
0.0353310779,
0.0467319638,
-0.0300293602,
-0.0771263018,
0.0115777589,
-0.0035359852,
-0.037274532,
-0.0302360971,
-0.0174588282,
-0.0224972535,
0.0059815245,
-0.0268612187,
-0.0232558362,
-0.0040151803,
-0.005162498,
0.0154239871,
-0.0082085542,
-0.0879383013,
0.0014186683,
-0.0285029039,
-0.0388012156,
0.0370969735,
-0.0026965351,
0.0086478498,
-0.0470290668,
0.0095321871,
-0.0121411607,
0.0151427928,
-0.0053361678,
0.0639458448,
-0.0490782745,
-0.0129536958,
-0.0117308041,
0.0271866154,
0.0037797333,
-0.0282803476,
-0.0083766961,
0.0491922796,
0.0344759226,
0.0155670354,
-0.0506645031,
-0.0282989331,
0.0001436148,
0.0410616696,
0.0013371892,
-0.0401411653,
-0.0222106557,
0.0084384093,
-0.0248167049,
-0.0693643987,
-0.0154160392,
-0.0045898939,
-0.0028428058,
-0.012499243,
-0.0545184761,
-0.0202100389,
0.0181688759,
0.0283930618,
-0.0131608723,
-0.0390584879,
-0.0223194603,
0.0458995141,
-0.0919477716,
0.062696673,
-0.0367794819,
0.0201808698,
-0.060499955,
0.0119649414,
0.0707871765,
-0.0388492867,
-0.0066222078,
-0.0126482248,
-0.081299372,
-0.0112915616,
-0.0629527867,
0.087858133,
0.0095411083,
0.0543696955,
0.0097324215,
0.0059880894,
0.0615913458,
0.0782319605,
-0.0461626202,
-0.0151159363,
0.0255552437,
-0.0551638417,
-0.0237273779,
0.0067592859,
-0.028528858,
0.0627165213,
0.0061773113,
0.0268343184,
-0.0129743088,
-0.0000398745,
0.0121067287,
-0.0506076552,
0.0805945396,
-0.0039385008,
0.0151787633,
0.0071631586,
0.042994637,
0.0200159438,
-0.0064667021,
-0.0442002639,
0.0306956973,
-0.0157809611,
0.0167425256,
-0.0130249718,
0.0305830464,
0.0408662781,
0.0211197156,
-0.002366052,
0.0102318199,
0.008678047,
-0.0045634871,
-0.0031532787,
0.0129059684,
-0.0080404663,
0.0122101977,
-0.0009005186,
0.0001964268,
-0.0494116694,
0.0526648834,
0.0305151846,
-0.009814526,
-0.0268917363,
0.0688326731,
-0.0134302918,
0.019493049,
-0.0770507455,
-0.0059306002,
0.0455416813,
-0.0180611517,
0.0283168666,
-0.0160338283,
-0.018711634,
-0.0164881535,
0.032262329,
-0.0183722638,
-0.0155518679,
0.0505715534,
0.0181460325,
0.0175800715,
0.0214900523,
0.063050583,
-0.0263849553,
0.0027295728,
0.02433943,
-0.02075308,
-0.0257719364,
0.0019632827,
0.0406154729,
0.0178568177,
-0.0068142712,
0.0182982124,
0.004139699,
-0.0308608115,
0.03955587,
-0.0253819153,
-0.0021454415,
0.0204847623,
0.0518687479,
0.032803569,
0.0218529329,
-0.0205751639,
-0.0191739555,
-0.0199240688,
-0.0069315173,
0.0279089008,
0.0070521417,
-6.18742537e-33,
-0.0198835675,
-0.0021695443,
0.0213093981,
-0.0168190431,
-0.0239389781,
0.0490948334,
-0.0125318104,
0.0154878674,
-0.0132314451,
-0.005600696,
-0.0052586212,
-0.0096330522,
0.0164068975,
0.0751082301,
-0.0196869653,
0.0191050451,
0.0690721571,
-0.0242034476,
-0.0196094085,
-0.0009512521,
0.0108660068,
0.0366310775,
0.0482955426,
-0.0382263474,
-0.0518391319,
0.0064693065,
-0.0315541476,
-0.0300899297,
0.0513913408,
0.0428234227,
-0.015366978,
-0.0076757004,
0.0258890688,
-0.0755794272,
-0.004046753,
0.0378767475,
-0.0802711546,
-0.0040263082,
-0.0358276963,
0.0291257109,
-0.0766242966,
-0.0155008789,
0.0294035636,
-0.0048497817,
0.0142558906,
-0.0179810748,
0.0275842957,
-0.0419945605,
-0.0171716362,
-0.0303677041,
-0.0167718939,
0.0269683953,
0.0330261923,
-0.0429563411,
0.0578539111,
0.0377984382,
-0.0084852669,
0.0344655849,
-0.0641676858,
0.0054533491,
-0.0047974326,
0.0320536271,
0.0484953299,
0.0573801175,
0.0220585521,
0.0549390614,
-0.0300240926,
-0.0374715701,
-0.0402226374,
-0.0240268223,
0.0271076001,
0.0696376115,
0.0506635495,
0.0465738475,
0.1168087199,
0.0105074728,
-0.0421006978,
0.0176762454,
-0.0255347434,
0.026896134,
0.0379573703,
0.0334807523,
0.0036226583,
0.0023569723,
-0.0390892886,
-0.0268195793,
-0.0305645205,
-0.0608270951,
0.0568626747,
0.079827629,
-0.0317369178,
0.0610707812,
0.091877602,
-0.0081076613,
0.0070040049,
-0.0034057898,
-0.0263401885,
0.0502928309,
-0.0391320325,
-0.0122225024,
-0.0618816763,
-0.0317430869,
0.0329713076,
-0.0034953563,
-0.0032454594,
0.0153732849,
0.0937440842,
0.0164893828,
-0.0621977709,
-0.0120977145,
-0.0161989871,
0.0302105285,
-0.0190649275,
0.074723959,
0.0567912906,
0.0269923173,
-0.0407065675,
0.0773593485,
-0.0286989138,
0.0300033372,
-0.036940489,
-0.0437365398,
0.0216169432,
0.0186610613,
-0.0210996401,
0.0241573267,
-0.0896404311,
-0.0112024359,
-0.0082572699,
-0.0589925833,
-0.0365515128,
0.0436126068,
2.697e-7,
-0.0029594828,
-0.0031983291,
0.006596671,
-0.0105398409,
0.0034367933,
0.0468826219,
0.010717391,
0.0202342644,
-0.0184024461,
-0.0078641381,
0.0050545423,
0.0577065796,
0.0735648423,
-0.012047736,
-0.0340543985,
0.0104391202,
-0.0880076736,
0.0177129488,
-0.0181757659,
-0.030996073,
0.0394298919,
0.1217825264,
-0.0004681187,
-0.0182368159,
0.0280214231,
-0.0084627019,
0.1057131141,
0.0044085733,
0.030640021,
-0.0375414789,
-0.0060171406,
0.0715759769,
-0.0655481443,
0.0016980893,
-0.0242134202,
-0.0224666819,
0.0464935005,
0.0557936952,
-0.0250813179,
0.0067114881,
0.0082952166,
0.0421525538,
-0.0280613676,
0.012411288,
0.0594542027,
-0.0766294524,
-0.0089671938,
-0.0337490067,
-0.0497211814,
0.0028992742,
-0.0059890854,
0.0122806942,
-0.0346046612,
0.0220385548,
0.0327493921,
0.0076578497,
-0.0476359278,
-0.1255250126,
-0.0010733535,
-0.0064295088,
0.0186296515,
0.009661125,
-0.1029565781,
-0.0297576934,
0.0269402396,
-0.0475799851,
-0.0323371254,
2.319186069e-34,
0.005412342,
-0.0312346406,
0.0066459579,
0.0275782477,
0.0087461155,
-0.0067694914,
0.0035161781,
-0.0229339134,
-0.0067702271,
-0.0563901626,
0.0084915245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17043v1 | LLaMA-VID: An Image is Worth 2 Tokens in Large Language Models | 2023-11-28T18:53:43 | 2023-11-28T18:53:43 | Yanwei Li, Chengyao Wang, Jiaya Jia | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | In this work, we present a novel method to tackle the token generation
challenge in Vision Language Models (VLMs) for video and image understanding,
called LLaMA-VID. Current VLMs, while proficient in tasks like image captioning
and visual question answering, face computational burdens when processing long
videos due to the excessive visual tokens. LLaMA-VID addresses this issue by
representing each frame with two distinct tokens, namely context token and
content token. The context token encodes the overall image context based on
user input, whereas the content token encapsulates visual cues in each frame.
This dual-token strategy significantly reduces the overload of long videos
while preserving critical information. Generally, LLaMA-VID empowers existing
frameworks to support hour-long videos and pushes their upper limit with an
extra context token. It is proved to surpass previous methods on most of video-
or image-based benchmarks. Code is available
https://github.com/dvlab-research/LLaMA-VID}{https://github.com/dvlab-research/LLaMA-VID | [
0.0228961445,
0.0351155177,
-0.0068919007,
0.0682559311,
-0.018155627,
-0.0019869143,
0.011443275,
0.0040488509,
-0.0257441252,
-0.084265314,
-0.0203357041,
-0.0409586839,
-0.0173739232,
0.0687147602,
0.0178002678,
-0.0973403528,
0.0520624332,
-0.0518484972,
0.045418568,
-0.0018496842,
0.0298479758,
-0.0173972324,
0.0095242728,
0.0181180555,
-0.0639155433,
-0.0181549937,
-0.0108235246,
-0.0111159598,
0.0279163048,
-0.0296298712,
-0.0505464971,
0.0021682782,
0.0531268343,
0.0050017666,
0.0000018286,
-0.0239751339,
0.0303147938,
-0.0180370118,
0.0162676573,
0.0407111123,
0.0235334374,
-0.0372242965,
-0.0002973349,
0.0083335293,
-0.0284219552,
-0.0105970269,
0.0569840521,
0.0088912174,
0.0575276837,
0.0289088394,
-0.0202452671,
-0.0534028858,
0.0056030513,
-0.0191521589,
0.0421373025,
-0.0326345675,
0.0044835233,
-0.0013536947,
0.0422489047,
-0.0115777766,
-0.0599981621,
0.0634295717,
0.0459027328,
-0.0420842469,
0.0240862593,
0.0561736412,
-0.0753798783,
-0.041720245,
-0.031456966,
0.0622250177,
-0.0177973136,
0.0181518644,
0.0009793427,
0.021915976,
0.0103618419,
-0.0455062389,
-0.0808900297,
0.0450552963,
-0.0003096668,
0.0216938667,
-0.0244115628,
0.0049990569,
0.0164931826,
0.001481478,
0.0026546542,
0.0106761148,
0.0114016952,
0.0480464846,
-0.0756812245,
-0.0016932681,
-0.0458178706,
-0.0774064586,
-0.0011821607,
0.0453863554,
0.0065677338,
0.0117036775,
-0.0440278016,
-0.0154462988,
-0.0112681994,
-0.0479082353,
-0.0104589295,
0.0282144304,
-0.0747128278,
0.0861282945,
-0.065085277,
0.0850950032,
-0.0334420465,
0.0357763432,
-0.0488036275,
-0.0431689881,
-0.0259737782,
-0.0063904775,
-0.0388998203,
0.024693653,
-0.0619242862,
-0.0531033538,
-0.0170306358,
0.0341597572,
-0.0182348844,
0.0113659035,
-0.0505773984,
0.0116650201,
0.0268297996,
0.0082607642,
-0.0308479406,
0.023217747,
-0.0449194424,
0.0204694923,
-0.0130166002,
-0.0747078583,
0.0006057987,
0.0327587649,
-0.0000508221,
-0.0149227045,
0.0015563383,
0.0710582584,
-0.0429030657,
-0.0308223534,
0.0204534363,
0.0102343028,
-0.0186707824,
-0.0261039231,
0.0337684825,
-0.073132813,
0.0553323179,
0.0001983891,
0.0078014149,
-0.0035207053,
0.0250872988,
0.0146561945,
-0.0087316204,
0.0958585441,
-0.0179168638,
0.0049732779,
0.0230195373,
0.0372455455,
0.0029265948,
0.0733534321,
0.0131284278,
0.0560202189,
0.0290833525,
0.0158720687,
0.0246984176,
0.0341278203,
-0.021892827,
-0.0048899711,
-0.0852214396,
0.0321226679,
0.030850105,
0.0265436843,
0.0607870407,
0.0833390355,
-0.0439514853,
-0.036673069,
0.0271150805,
0.0494010486,
-0.0497526117,
-0.0429651178,
0.0415793657,
-0.0279323198,
0.0281365309,
-0.0082288133,
-0.0625792891,
0.0936096087,
0.0512760356,
-0.0052436828,
0.0155221587,
0.013082426,
-0.0604935512,
-0.0354935974,
-0.0242897272,
-0.0179429688,
-0.0001460433,
0.0038737431,
0.0256132483,
-0.0148612512,
-0.0221443884,
0.048494745,
-0.0296187308,
-0.0130952513,
0.0092657711,
-0.0626159161,
0.044028338,
0.074923493,
0.020169843,
0.0083801178,
-0.0221255757,
0.0281452406,
0.0643517375,
0.0168756694,
-0.0112257106,
-0.0122722639,
0.0304551776,
-0.0566542484,
-0.0209048409,
-0.0369404852,
0.0001681019,
0.020538073,
-0.0047041494,
0.0055904258,
0.0133182118,
-0.0054307077,
0.0150353527,
0.0432665274,
0.0842343569,
-0.004438851,
-0.0181732364,
-0.0060506961,
0.0268271174,
-0.0078244107,
0.001689693,
0.0039576562,
0.0272953603,
-0.0496410578,
0.0326575525,
0.0376346894,
-0.0638506487,
-0.014296242,
0.05704863,
-0.0580843352,
0.0034293754,
-0.0036152655,
-0.0486721545,
-0.024241196,
0.0162200425,
-0.0137253376,
0.0336083136,
-0.0420247354,
0.0017724503,
0.0140397847,
0.0269380845,
0.0085934224,
0.0234680511,
-0.0246932954,
-0.0193388257,
0.0211855359,
0.0194408577,
0.0061881477,
-0.0355253182,
-0.0239509996,
0.0044681383,
-0.0219790582,
-0.0019621234,
-0.0168309379,
-0.0029953152,
-0.0585749224,
-0.0116081266,
-0.1039453894,
-0.0177051201,
-0.0162385963,
-0.0006323805,
-0.0105637638,
-0.0029604258,
-0.0003304212,
-0.0322056673,
-0.0234437492,
0.0098024439,
0.0014590439,
0.0332533084,
0.0147804031,
0.0350674689,
-0.0394662842,
-0.0248642918,
-0.0120607223,
0.0247980207,
0.0426196344,
-0.0026164041,
-0.0506257266,
0.0057654856,
-0.0418981388,
-0.0166213512,
0.0292470548,
-0.0419191755,
-0.0185595434,
0.001102714,
0.0087732719,
0.0382381566,
0.0540837608,
-0.0104079768,
0.022638835,
0.0038963982,
-0.0145914322,
-0.0074315104,
0.0214307886,
0.0311529953,
-0.0163366664,
-0.0058118463,
-0.0136368619,
-0.0174235012,
0.004300775,
-0.0520761013,
0.027696332,
-0.0524810441,
0.0260745734,
0.0066480977,
-0.0253434405,
-0.0381354578,
-0.0166575946,
-0.0043216459,
0.0247669928,
-0.0336561054,
-0.0797116533,
0.0075917752,
-0.0668403655,
-0.0176525656,
0.0245623551,
0.018771911,
-0.0494170673,
0.0830970109,
0.0461128391,
0.0132106068,
-0.0438831113,
-0.0002662565,
-0.0283014886,
-0.0166923497,
-0.0325246826,
-0.0026589502,
0.064504683,
-0.0408371985,
0.0072766407,
-0.0398893096,
-0.0099950405,
-0.0433663279,
0.0186110437,
-0.0692990795,
0.022640029,
-0.0565758571,
-0.0067292247,
-0.0018766618,
0.0174987577,
-0.0095858304,
0.0054880627,
-0.0204332601,
0.030439686,
-0.0067673707,
0.0471581556,
0.0663152561,
0.0133383172,
-0.0220096763,
-0.0402802266,
0.0353159159,
0.0779282451,
0.0463718772,
-0.010454474,
-0.0402161665,
0.0322900228,
0.0250142347,
0.0385927558,
-0.0239883624,
0.0236648861,
0.0709958598,
-0.0441389605,
0.0140227061,
0.0727822781,
0.0226955712,
-0.0477965288,
-0.0113183465,
-0.0155776795,
-0.0001292171,
0.0664216056,
0.0144732418,
-0.0958956778,
-0.0459113754,
0.0047311531,
-0.024237372,
0.0305061731,
0.0198563207,
-0.0548029244,
-0.0391582176,
0.0579888895,
0.0020404067,
-0.0113454917,
-0.0239692852,
0.0072474885,
-0.0084985923,
0.0086712912,
0.0023257078,
0.0075064595,
-0.0046106861,
0.0136764385,
-0.0037171405,
0.0387658179,
-0.0019165265,
0.035633821,
-0.0445954427,
0.0276134182,
0.0257383902,
-0.0011299809,
-0.0025769933,
-0.0786888301,
0.0390185453,
-0.013376886,
0.0151119558,
-0.0165591352,
0.0130573334,
-0.0302960258,
-0.0502029695,
0.0234930608,
0.02298945,
0.0040338277,
-0.0589215979,
0.0025396242,
0.0508969687,
0.0087810792,
-0.0018300363,
-0.0621438958,
-0.0284636356,
-0.0315843038,
0.0593939386,
0.0312667228,
-0.0054014642,
-0.0187879447,
0.0176259018,
-0.0517529584,
-0.0422462821,
0.0023214889,
-0.0247025434,
0.0192051157,
-0.0055991416,
-0.0330174156,
0.0069086947,
0.0659694001,
0.0488933288,
-0.0382061936,
0.0162898824,
-0.0378649198,
0.0149728647,
-0.0987519324,
0.0683151186,
-0.0220395941,
0.027792925,
-0.0750601366,
0.0125939874,
0.043483194,
-0.0172052253,
-0.0132269952,
0.0365377367,
-0.0780344382,
-0.0216315091,
-0.0220784247,
0.0796586499,
0.0170691684,
0.0496195666,
0.0090375124,
-0.0146635734,
0.0125552602,
0.043677602,
-0.0100644575,
0.0264550596,
-0.018460663,
-0.0116472486,
0.0064346809,
0.0350537449,
-0.0526893772,
0.015411512,
0.0040380028,
0.0166306868,
-0.0081601031,
0.0160153061,
-0.007717011,
0.0041594757,
0.0275878757,
-0.0149611831,
0.010617868,
0.0150301494,
0.0162330084,
0.0072547151,
0.0184623655,
-0.0656827688,
0.0192897804,
-0.0093672816,
0.010254005,
0.01161425,
0.0025246318,
0.0010224051,
-0.0199562851,
-0.0024539107,
0.0102330064,
-0.0045457259,
-0.0205660779,
0.003676571,
0.012221681,
0.0300527196,
-0.0188566875,
-0.0109776948,
0.0285137706,
-0.0261078682,
0.0363752432,
0.011818652,
-0.0281718168,
-0.0416463017,
0.0622252934,
-0.0029627848,
-0.0214652419,
-0.0158353429,
0.075404115,
0.0428151898,
0.0012572859,
-0.024913745,
0.002370781,
-0.0080215074,
-0.0204871334,
0.0472322889,
0.0084933601,
-0.0775417536,
0.0918605253,
0.0235006958,
-0.0117314793,
-0.0262478385,
0.048996035,
0.0069197621,
0.0155279683,
0.0296650287,
0.0179399475,
-0.0146023734,
0.0019522455,
0.0199143477,
0.0065809116,
-0.0205642078,
0.0141067514,
-0.0235083867,
-0.0671278387,
0.0085906656,
0.009348115,
-0.0087360889,
0.0383785032,
0.0530777425,
0.0411535762,
0.0389789902,
-0.0274998136,
0.0107905343,
-0.0108724609,
-0.0012211787,
-0.0186687354,
0.0365218781,
-5.760623942e-33,
-0.0357638523,
-0.020346418,
0.0503927432,
0.0030129086,
-0.0180837996,
0.0447631106,
-0.005386794,
0.0022227161,
-0.0092686275,
-0.0095720226,
0.0132336607,
0.019425543,
0.0124757597,
0.0347080342,
-0.00625091,
-0.0191851426,
0.0356225409,
-0.025123762,
-0.0098093012,
-0.0139129385,
-0.0015175383,
0.0053748935,
0.0141681284,
-0.0257142652,
-0.0445450321,
0.0332320817,
-0.0128030879,
0.0349080749,
0.0283070318,
0.0727922022,
-0.0332497396,
0.0161311626,
0.0178390704,
-0.0046167667,
-0.0342543945,
0.0302153304,
-0.0854520202,
-0.0137081463,
0.0730647966,
0.0745650455,
-0.0815988332,
-0.0336164273,
0.0473031327,
0.0026489561,
-0.0051428881,
-0.0077805687,
0.0172618944,
-0.0235804934,
-0.0084241023,
0.0131380269,
-0.0186782181,
0.0041991468,
0.0062250998,
-0.0406701788,
0.0786927715,
-0.0127209537,
0.0207372103,
0.0125889983,
-0.0350732692,
-0.0074972734,
-0.0333186835,
0.029407436,
0.1079423204,
0.030871002,
0.0099084508,
0.0518302359,
0.0448348485,
-0.0966569036,
-0.0569625683,
-0.0040475167,
0.0105896173,
0.0575614087,
0.0250911359,
0.0016200593,
0.0252940934,
-0.0080469521,
-0.0423425734,
-0.0193958748,
-0.044798363,
0.0889719576,
0.0027077526,
0.0301988516,
0.038910009,
0.0147250229,
-0.0324102268,
-0.010495916,
-0.0436681397,
-0.0028425395,
0.0514405593,
0.0346107185,
-0.0005875152,
-0.0311619136,
0.0722200796,
-0.0272016786,
0.0053795003,
0.0278591719,
-0.0048008789,
0.0556704998,
0.02664393,
0.0279083308,
-0.0156307276,
0.0078503964,
0.0548687913,
0.0006927508,
0.0075633279,
-0.0022675577,
0.0355421081,
0.0293740127,
-0.0341506042,
-0.0022651264,
-0.0465937555,
0.0007896978,
-0.0103527466,
0.0287756138,
0.0264600217,
0.0174489263,
-0.0465206131,
0.0267191678,
-0.032444831,
-0.024475405,
-0.0102447979,
-0.0013883499,
-0.0169339497,
0.034277942,
-0.0564392097,
0.0127595803,
-0.0507744327,
0.002985538,
-0.003187709,
-0.0737837851,
-0.028658824,
0.0527909622,
2.456e-7,
-0.0039389017,
0.0266471133,
0.0285379179,
-0.0117523484,
0.0344553739,
0.0262990985,
-0.0082654115,
0.0351313092,
-0.0187910683,
-0.0387581401,
-0.0167423598,
0.0547660962,
-0.0080785919,
-0.0116108442,
-0.0417043865,
0.0562416464,
-0.0384221897,
-0.0061865016,
-0.0241661146,
-0.012095199,
0.0486564301,
0.1248680651,
-0.0117482888,
-0.0028945624,
0.0402078927,
-0.0619817786,
0.0620691255,
-0.0022905774,
-0.0026013448,
-0.0049358923,
-0.0284620728,
0.0439105406,
-0.0134652164,
-0.008353875,
0.0004914353,
-0.0216551367,
0.0356721357,
0.0525582246,
-0.0398901775,
-0.034543395,
-0.026416298,
0.0201166701,
-0.0421308354,
-0.0573554263,
0.0900129825,
-0.0162045322,
-0.0121246744,
-0.0659603328,
-0.0239021126,
0.0191842075,
-0.0108504854,
0.0210382789,
-0.020349741,
0.0424689502,
0.031160716,
-0.0468800403,
-0.0560212024,
-0.110144347,
-0.0220450573,
-0.065158084,
-0.0424245484,
0.0174973849,
-0.1045844033,
0.0143465316,
0.0324179903,
0.0027269591,
-0.0755084381,
1.698162761e-34,
0.0351301841,
-0.0414535291,
-0.0088734599,
0.0200946517,
-0.0063625122,
-0.0210416261,
-0.0500365905,
0.0281508751,
-0.0095150853,
-0.0383243412,
-0.0188968237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17041v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17041v2 | Efficient In-Context Learning in Vision-Language Models for Egocentric Videos | 2023-11-28T18:53:06 | 2023-11-29T15:52:55 | Keunwoo Peter Yu, Zheyuan Zhang, Fengyuan Hu, Joyce Chai | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in text-only large language models (LLMs) have
highlighted the benefit of in-context learning for adapting to new tasks with a
few demonstrations. However, extending in-context learning to large
vision-language models (VLMs) using a huge amount of naturalistic
vision-language data has shown limited success, particularly for egocentric
videos, due to high data collection costs. We propose a novel training method
$\mathbb{E}$fficient $\mathbb{I}$n-context $\mathbb{L}$earning on
$\mathbb{E}$gocentric $\mathbb{V}$ideos ($\mathbb{EILEV}$), which elicits
in-context learning in VLMs for egocentric videos without requiring massive,
naturalistic egocentric video datasets. $\mathbb{EILEV}$ involves architectural
and training data adaptations to allow the model to process contexts
interleaved with video clips and narrations, sampling of in-context examples
with clusters of similar verbs and nouns, use of data with skewed marginal
distributions with a long tail of infrequent verbs and nouns, as well as
homonyms and synonyms. Our evaluations show that $\mathbb{EILEV}$-trained
models outperform larger VLMs trained on a huge amount of naturalistic data in
in-context learning. Furthermore, they can generalize to not only
out-of-distribution, but also novel, rare egocentric videos and texts via
in-context learning, demonstrating potential for applications requiring
cost-effective training, and rapid post-deployment adaptability. Our code and
demo are available at \url{https://github.com/yukw777/EILEV}. | [
0.0231626257,
0.0388913415,
-0.0029499552,
0.0670818165,
-0.0302076656,
0.0038012571,
-0.0215770695,
0.0054161353,
-0.0050335489,
-0.0904760137,
-0.0572950244,
-0.0648329556,
-0.0083464887,
0.0137483245,
0.0255674552,
-0.0687924847,
0.0242089909,
-0.0339251049,
-0.0119346427,
-0.018211849,
-0.0175408889,
0.009573767,
-0.0308247805,
-0.0166934133,
-0.0473262034,
-0.004027565,
0.0065487036,
0.0260098446,
0.0506887846,
-0.0249745268,
-0.0069471672,
0.0288775489,
0.0609529652,
-0.0145630548,
0.000001967,
-0.040557161,
0.0150021045,
-0.0353507213,
0.0094497912,
0.014653475,
0.0476400219,
-0.0451318659,
-0.0001007744,
-0.0011927855,
-0.0302779041,
-0.0161138717,
0.0251401067,
0.0092165489,
0.0068598026,
0.0460290201,
-0.0297501832,
-0.037783023,
-0.0059180297,
-0.0323365629,
0.004451815,
-0.0061887596,
0.0340968668,
-0.0323006511,
-0.03666123,
0.0358522683,
-0.0829358473,
0.0347328112,
0.0512835756,
0.0101310927,
0.0015464129,
0.0606418923,
-0.0408397429,
-0.0298571046,
-0.045717176,
0.053127721,
-0.0003613938,
-0.0047447705,
0.0176311731,
0.0092755603,
-0.0098378314,
-0.0291684195,
-0.0319571719,
0.0493707135,
0.031090403,
0.0071617509,
-0.0097278571,
0.0168095566,
-0.0071717971,
0.0030950243,
-0.0065245074,
-0.0387652554,
0.0519454107,
0.0349351242,
0.0006345468,
0.0135943657,
-0.018781893,
-0.0554659776,
-0.0407332778,
-0.0038208999,
0.0246288255,
0.0087292902,
-0.0623374581,
0.0342755392,
-0.0377019085,
-0.0219138861,
0.0483120345,
-0.0026922321,
0.0082584284,
0.065428935,
-0.0021311475,
0.0275024902,
-0.0114906589,
0.0424390398,
0.0047462536,
-0.0254638698,
-0.0301085934,
0.0235586446,
-0.0331651978,
-0.0142857591,
-0.0361879133,
-0.0491158701,
-0.0162807833,
0.0304527562,
-0.0168132801,
-0.0061149024,
-0.0128362058,
0.0253096428,
-0.0296294149,
-0.0629635453,
0.0164482072,
0.0215383824,
0.0019899153,
0.0512155965,
-0.0324861743,
-0.0700406283,
-0.0004278745,
0.0521999039,
0.0039067827,
-0.0136397844,
0.0165799148,
0.0377485491,
-0.0134195024,
-0.091706112,
-0.0143820085,
0.0192978624,
-0.0519915409,
-0.0521916524,
0.0061790673,
-0.0926124454,
0.019346891,
-0.0240463223,
0.0003947885,
-0.0493912883,
0.01712103,
-0.0113040451,
-0.0126735289,
0.0620398261,
0.0381959528,
0.0415000916,
0.0044337874,
0.008614785,
0.0392470546,
0.0695586056,
0.0382466316,
-0.0242998768,
0.0290784314,
0.0234496202,
0.0315373503,
0.074764438,
-0.0278122555,
0.0771828294,
-0.09792272,
0.017342547,
0.0144174807,
0.0390776992,
0.0282861888,
0.0606671236,
-0.0221269857,
-0.0263516344,
0.0778196082,
0.0337244458,
-0.0344668925,
-0.0677443743,
0.0143517759,
0.0111345379,
0.0036225338,
-0.0461729839,
-0.039557945,
0.0560462549,
0.0220690891,
-0.0065341545,
-0.0146479616,
0.0199986417,
-0.0723210126,
-0.022124175,
-0.0095460853,
-0.0236541349,
-0.0240944941,
0.0186437666,
0.0653773397,
0.026664678,
-0.0128786294,
0.0010285461,
0.0295789298,
-0.0279375594,
0.0478685871,
0.0117891794,
0.0100119496,
0.0333629884,
0.0160364565,
0.0050948216,
-0.0133552505,
-0.0129887052,
0.0580931939,
0.0332223549,
-0.0096343625,
-0.0308042318,
0.0261921808,
-0.0506869368,
-0.031456206,
0.0094367657,
0.0309281759,
0.0062333555,
0.0182041638,
0.0299255885,
0.0029048075,
-0.022874007,
-0.0177161824,
0.0405546501,
-0.0308591351,
-0.0120576136,
0.0005754826,
0.0215141624,
0.0077957078,
0.0110425949,
-0.0243713036,
-0.0156997424,
0.0337820016,
-0.0197975095,
0.0197014436,
0.031379573,
-0.0305501726,
-0.054555878,
0.0334450901,
-0.0787912086,
0.0077318773,
-0.011770675,
-0.010855536,
-0.0282311644,
-0.0076352837,
-0.0299554858,
0.029524859,
-0.0359010026,
0.0140506309,
0.0364433825,
0.0043505342,
-0.0225886162,
0.0168953538,
-0.0152584277,
-0.0242544077,
0.015964048,
0.0491273254,
0.0009064139,
-0.0269903913,
-0.0203640983,
-0.0040592616,
0.0154164918,
0.007424131,
0.0103872996,
-0.0150007121,
-0.0322570279,
-0.0437055789,
-0.1065769568,
-0.0238524899,
-0.0326038077,
-0.0171179101,
0.0266856588,
-0.0001657755,
-0.0329386182,
-0.0380175933,
0.0189670622,
0.0378543995,
0.0129345302,
0.0268436223,
-0.0027106276,
-0.0064065633,
-0.0306215305,
-0.011102655,
0.0015335979,
0.0190811474,
0.0356217995,
0.011262713,
0.0078430874,
-0.0171519592,
-0.0217815563,
-0.0071169264,
0.0522876903,
-0.0461259075,
-0.0055690114,
-0.0071185175,
-0.0228022169,
0.0074117477,
0.0648856983,
0.0346395485,
0.0390147455,
0.0114038251,
-0.0000042727,
-0.0412874967,
-0.0387412757,
-0.0108377002,
-0.0591244735,
-0.0510390401,
0.017635433,
-0.0118684499,
0.0197896622,
-0.0366458781,
0.0246844869,
-0.0627757087,
0.0254699141,
-0.0168233849,
-0.0513578393,
-0.0132703045,
0.0347772241,
-0.0301741678,
0.0130750751,
-0.0089986986,
-0.0325330719,
0.0137366997,
-0.0252977852,
-0.0207940806,
-0.0209178627,
0.0074015716,
-0.0141831087,
0.074198626,
0.0177162737,
0.0258055497,
-0.0111670438,
-0.0095233275,
-0.0677110702,
0.0178987868,
-0.0044353465,
0.0143208746,
0.0812321007,
-0.0679517016,
0.0169809628,
0.0191177838,
-0.0300575662,
-0.0470520668,
0.0015451162,
-0.025629133,
-0.0366940126,
-0.0660800561,
-0.02300377,
-0.0004220455,
0.0087327845,
0.0209625699,
0.0400433093,
0.0058268085,
0.0119159622,
-0.0226939283,
0.0171313044,
0.0696169958,
-0.0087999357,
-0.061956685,
-0.0427135639,
0.0024433045,
0.0635813177,
0.0260478146,
-0.0086814966,
-0.0252084807,
0.040892411,
0.0383158661,
0.0300425161,
-0.021887904,
0.0406090729,
0.0547551587,
-0.0130055789,
-0.0243528634,
0.0961643085,
-0.0032813903,
-0.0737701878,
0.0221491028,
0.0484780483,
-0.0003042895,
0.0534645766,
-0.0109428717,
-0.0667677149,
-0.0393124335,
-0.0004331334,
-0.0185517818,
0.0399330333,
-0.0092407167,
-0.0098258723,
-0.1468527913,
0.0486441515,
0.0304621793,
-0.0128973527,
-0.0408045016,
0.0136216721,
0.0217435341,
-0.0276562013,
-0.0315584578,
-0.0093121557,
-0.0230598245,
-0.0002546478,
-0.0069680545,
0.0317176245,
-0.0856439322,
0.0202186182,
-0.0595527142,
0.040531572,
-0.0293435454,
0.0028346553,
-0.0120008169,
-0.0667765513,
0.0064808917,
-0.0607963875,
-0.0143034821,
0.011684211,
0.0520230159,
-0.0588985644,
-0.01354999,
0.0415184051,
0.0773433745,
-0.0289555378,
-0.0292399339,
0.003716188,
0.0354415141,
-0.0200488139,
0.005860101,
-0.013886393,
-0.0295400806,
0.0405337811,
0.0636133924,
-0.0325630568,
-0.0367173813,
0.0206702147,
0.0313160121,
-0.0346373804,
0.0273107924,
-0.0246676374,
0.0016454537,
0.0096725626,
-0.035793826,
-0.0562050603,
-0.0196348708,
0.0560710467,
0.1060818359,
0.0148965651,
-0.0309404265,
-0.0041751126,
0.018490199,
-0.0708069205,
0.0379027426,
-0.0467205495,
0.0451504514,
-0.0446654558,
0.0067347898,
0.0859828889,
0.0141321775,
-0.0120537234,
0.0245796852,
-0.0053388914,
-0.0698988736,
-0.0132930549,
0.0572879538,
0.0174483173,
0.1374733746,
-0.0007746745,
-0.0024680018,
0.0359204635,
0.0086995373,
0.0115282778,
0.0567522123,
0.0014325343,
-0.0133859664,
-0.0115097677,
0.0579930544,
-0.0134431338,
0.0132528329,
0.0435995795,
0.025137648,
-0.0479393415,
-0.054113593,
-0.0011031392,
-0.0559816025,
0.0636924207,
-0.0571687557,
0.006897327,
-0.0358774923,
-0.004445286,
-0.0128708528,
0.0126647241,
-0.0499799959,
0.0342285186,
0.053634692,
0.0532119982,
-0.0070658196,
0.0382212326,
-0.0041325688,
-0.0204976201,
-0.0080230981,
-0.0567702651,
-0.0207976792,
-0.0246116295,
0.025324773,
0.0265540704,
0.017861275,
0.0415738486,
-0.0082385028,
0.0236202665,
-0.0119843613,
0.0500125438,
0.0513835959,
-0.0218705982,
-0.0295000114,
0.0314036272,
-0.0060668793,
0.0255827494,
-0.0401242487,
0.0812514946,
0.0603565946,
-0.0488943569,
0.0103951292,
-0.0402755216,
-0.0018140094,
-0.0361814424,
0.0320853814,
-0.0362266079,
-0.055761233,
0.0738738552,
0.0108475387,
-0.002131837,
0.0526784733,
0.0704300031,
-0.0088137873,
0.0518436842,
-0.0055051064,
0.047514651,
-0.0339039005,
-0.0061004777,
0.0392074138,
0.0073552779,
-0.0167890582,
0.063335821,
-0.0279173497,
-0.0749154314,
-0.0285060313,
-0.0027219197,
-0.0353375375,
-0.0072182827,
0.0845312625,
0.0189998243,
-0.003651992,
0.0064825309,
-0.0164382719,
-0.0424441621,
-0.0127425361,
-0.0309985299,
-0.0059875436,
-5.953884397e-33,
-0.010939287,
0.0391293541,
0.0092814742,
0.0231316872,
-0.0225650631,
-0.0059581003,
-0.0190023426,
0.0497984253,
0.0096191643,
0.0243238453,
0.0180063639,
0.0137946056,
0.0017470369,
0.056052275,
0.0178028643,
-0.0053629917,
0.0227983873,
-0.0255448483,
-0.0254819803,
0.0009835239,
0.0122158546,
0.0137259541,
0.0703859627,
-0.0818004161,
-0.031410899,
0.0154621359,
0.0072178529,
0.0569896661,
0.0360950492,
0.039625328,
-0.0170089509,
-0.0095459381,
0.0019773894,
-0.0154263331,
-0.0169619732,
0.0049966071,
-0.0349143073,
0.0104326131,
-0.019835256,
0.0490947291,
-0.0638039634,
-0.0040995884,
0.0394865312,
-0.0068438575,
-0.0626402572,
-0.0168958325,
0.0269570779,
-0.0206196867,
-0.0261788312,
0.036337804,
-0.0343778096,
0.0154443868,
0.0142355738,
-0.0335115343,
0.0081041055,
-0.0358552597,
0.0158524904,
-0.0141874142,
-0.0438496023,
0.0194331948,
-0.0607193001,
0.0372052453,
0.0876105651,
0.0274312217,
0.0118769612,
0.0658284277,
0.0327257738,
-0.0516054146,
-0.0214148443,
-0.0289898012,
0.041470062,
0.0497044846,
0.022913225,
0.0675131604,
-0.0244615376,
0.0039571519,
-0.0356027223,
-0.0079276422,
-0.0402656607,
0.026453862,
-0.0019881115,
-0.005453947,
-0.0151708126,
-0.0131523311,
-0.0424743779,
-0.063822858,
0.0048433202,
0.0123847593,
0.0447512083,
0.0250670612,
0.0026296279,
0.0079400223,
0.0553435385,
-0.0523262508,
-0.0310477857,
0.022360323,
-0.0159207564,
0.0589761995,
0.0151611548,
0.0467738323,
-0.056419272,
-0.0087367352,
0.0053814086,
0.0403795689,
-0.0279362705,
-0.0053355978,
0.0001091209,
0.0313855633,
-0.0406900197,
-0.0092950957,
-0.0251688268,
-0.0061202692,
0.0007181192,
0.0239454489,
0.0448848493,
0.0332137533,
-0.0345531031,
0.0584922135,
-0.0076348716,
-0.0292095263,
0.0185561068,
-0.0462543778,
0.0112733003,
0.030621456,
-0.0061320728,
0.0066217841,
-0.0446305089,
-0.0440806523,
0.0614144765,
-0.0493012257,
-0.0011868327,
0.0168833435,
2.742e-7,
0.0007746516,
0.0153788319,
0.0104016522,
-0.070609577,
0.0265789852,
0.0550110005,
-0.0034792896,
0.0672675148,
-0.0292196404,
-0.0391801298,
0.0140426587,
0.0665799454,
0.0284243971,
-0.059311796,
-0.0466389954,
0.0226235166,
-0.0455190726,
0.0075078155,
-0.0622402802,
0.0137511669,
-0.0034820936,
0.088869974,
0.0346274488,
-0.0018791815,
0.0043991623,
-0.0665912852,
0.0768180862,
-0.0171210021,
0.0012763598,
0.0118416166,
0.0192543305,
0.0402271897,
-0.0109377662,
0.0220147204,
-0.0139952805,
0.0269418769,
0.037009649,
0.053746894,
-0.0367668457,
0.0158613436,
-0.0213526618,
0.0273390058,
-0.0503863841,
-0.0463922434,
0.0756352842,
-0.0857316107,
0.0165335275,
-0.0094853612,
-0.011687004,
0.0105384542,
-0.0017758058,
0.0178990476,
-0.0166115165,
0.0044133645,
0.0591697432,
0.002451367,
-0.0483314693,
-0.0999909267,
0.0187768284,
-0.0007205973,
-0.0499470644,
0.0187442675,
-0.0014810305,
0.0220986437,
0.0220320262,
0.0033700564,
-0.0480897874,
2.036941381e-34,
0.0171532035,
0.0236404296,
-0.0184767246,
-0.0432721563,
-0.0224901363,
-0.0245286059,
-0.0082426239,
0.0118288277,
-0.0062480909,
-0.0557731278,
-0.0018245863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17035v1 | Scalable Extraction of Training Data from (Production) Language Models | 2023-11-28T18:47:03 | 2023-11-28T18:47:03 | Milad Nasr, Nicholas Carlini, Jonathan Hayase, Matthew Jagielski, A. Feder Cooper, Daphne Ippolito, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Eric Wallace, Florian Tramèr, Katherine Lee | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | This paper studies extractable memorization: training data that an adversary
can efficiently extract by querying a machine learning model without prior
knowledge of the training dataset. We show an adversary can extract gigabytes
of training data from open-source language models like Pythia or GPT-Neo,
semi-open models like LLaMA or Falcon, and closed models like ChatGPT. Existing
techniques from the literature suffice to attack unaligned models; in order to
attack the aligned ChatGPT, we develop a new divergence attack that causes the
model to diverge from its chatbot-style generations and emit training data at a
rate 150x higher than when behaving properly. Our methods show practical
attacks can recover far more data than previously thought, and reveal that
current alignment techniques do not eliminate memorization. | [
0.0147077627,
0.0960444584,
-0.0219887793,
0.0665008873,
-0.0447483286,
0.0118828854,
-0.0003892626,
-0.0041026929,
0.004307433,
-0.010822556,
-0.0191019326,
-0.0038670572,
-0.0039298846,
0.0236879233,
0.0566411912,
-0.0046047773,
0.0422765054,
-0.0329837762,
-0.0232449491,
-0.0300224256,
-0.0071535087,
-0.0191744082,
0.0066085858,
-0.0128889242,
0.0115988301,
-0.0412123539,
-0.0584575944,
-0.0063093351,
-0.0074536665,
0.0049980162,
-0.0060685221,
0.0227395166,
-0.0043566502,
0.0991262347,
0.0000019395,
-0.000271645,
-0.0585277155,
0.0205927268,
-0.0915659592,
0.0399443731,
-0.0076427446,
-0.0046895244,
-0.0216675438,
0.0126835248,
-0.0437811948,
-0.0249452926,
0.0440535508,
0.0311108865,
0.0814978704,
0.1179110259,
0.011883799,
-0.0221213866,
0.041077774,
-0.0071205646,
-0.0194418412,
-0.0332928263,
0.0053307023,
-0.0113858497,
-0.0258387513,
0.0107334983,
0.0081189005,
0.0072032507,
0.0113653773,
0.0135838706,
-0.0192303788,
0.0469169877,
-0.051133737,
-0.0124906497,
-0.0032754019,
0.0485909618,
-0.0211362448,
-0.0152264899,
0.0123680253,
0.0245416798,
0.004695097,
-0.012801352,
-0.011798881,
0.0285128355,
-0.0056895958,
0.0151457982,
0.022892423,
-0.0499707311,
0.0543069877,
-0.0347224325,
-0.0161314979,
0.0222404767,
0.0322246253,
-0.0239354949,
-0.0044617839,
-0.0372394212,
0.0058591967,
-0.0516651981,
-0.0162815806,
0.0171960071,
0.0196076538,
0.0395939723,
-0.0691610128,
-0.0393944383,
0.0012107192,
-0.0398448892,
0.0476773046,
0.010965419,
0.0051596477,
0.0490423404,
0.0198425446,
0.0351138227,
-0.0417740121,
0.0442612767,
-0.0048970026,
0.0269774757,
-0.0220051985,
-0.0368985049,
-0.0206311624,
0.0578052402,
0.0089035099,
0.0064083477,
-0.0132331559,
0.0237772912,
-0.0182390455,
0.0344286114,
-0.0371221304,
0.0077163307,
-0.0243645608,
-0.0072444258,
0.0098669063,
-0.015813753,
-0.0023322382,
-0.0270024277,
0.0141288713,
-0.1202782393,
-0.0583787039,
-0.0104512749,
-0.0251586866,
-0.0126155633,
-0.0135033354,
0.095867537,
-0.006817196,
-0.0355659164,
-0.0401661694,
-0.0533036292,
0.0089903614,
-0.0764109269,
0.0172903687,
-0.0632864833,
-0.0090176053,
-0.0213516485,
-0.0273241419,
-0.050032191,
-0.0008384614,
-0.0118087735,
-0.0458486266,
0.0644650012,
0.0056695919,
-0.0111629721,
-0.0023370215,
0.0020446649,
-0.0099127134,
0.0646108761,
0.0020741653,
0.0083788829,
0.0596587062,
-0.0180171523,
0.0350318812,
0.0526843518,
0.0404425487,
0.0062061436,
0.0103508001,
0.0257329121,
0.0779637843,
-0.0269265361,
-0.0212624986,
0.0458926819,
-0.017322937,
-0.0740701631,
0.0747935474,
0.0679882988,
-0.0299304966,
0.0456246696,
-0.0249943268,
-0.0180708021,
0.0496374667,
0.0501569994,
-0.0521095805,
-0.0358586833,
-0.0708648339,
-0.0050950227,
0.0059051551,
0.0220137611,
-0.0231559258,
-0.0266112778,
-0.0016941983,
-0.0254201703,
-0.0017397152,
0.0118552353,
0.0407571569,
0.0195744019,
-0.0175296757,
0.0465557761,
0.0483887754,
-0.0680193901,
-0.0333816633,
-0.0495983362,
0.0069725886,
0.0053121489,
0.0525444709,
-0.0432493053,
-0.0110678794,
0.0071093696,
-0.0244500227,
0.0081240982,
0.025873052,
-0.0020521972,
0.0504715927,
-0.0004690902,
-0.0021973394,
-0.0031473695,
0.0340032093,
0.0100816889,
0.0196282063,
-0.0065812254,
-0.0140709337,
-0.0184383951,
-0.0356151909,
0.0243002959,
-0.0377708487,
-0.0743730143,
-0.0150195854,
0.0172841772,
0.0585857555,
0.030039642,
-0.0374080315,
0.0157145634,
0.0692585111,
-0.0012534957,
0.0200943593,
0.0017274864,
-0.0080242315,
0.0090253027,
0.0360011384,
-0.0068254131,
-0.0101203807,
0.0569025688,
-0.0325109586,
-0.010469839,
0.0474215969,
-0.0175514184,
0.0683236569,
-0.0006809614,
0.0295208506,
-0.0065052258,
0.0241374299,
-0.0173398815,
0.0389793217,
-0.0112741245,
-0.0021008553,
-0.03609851,
0.005719455,
-0.0021007191,
-0.0562546253,
-0.0590900034,
0.0568706654,
-0.0063636159,
0.0368574895,
0.0043105958,
-0.0311174095,
-0.0380315408,
-0.030574251,
-0.0554321818,
0.0053284955,
-0.0116578517,
0.0670268089,
0.0140806548,
0.0012329814,
-0.0247195978,
-0.014966039,
-0.0253024288,
0.0087054186,
-0.0238382518,
0.0175918173,
0.0204639249,
0.0056352234,
-0.0358978361,
-0.0274857897,
-0.0133911632,
0.0046269465,
0.0687441453,
-0.0156740379,
0.0212054402,
-0.0372906327,
0.0111913914,
-0.017107483,
0.0547063649,
-0.0189472325,
-0.0313324668,
0.0295902863,
-0.0185202975,
-0.0099110948,
0.0999280885,
0.0210985765,
0.0662862733,
0.0220496729,
0.0027127403,
-0.0257540885,
-0.0223018434,
-0.0183527749,
-0.0772750005,
-0.0486301705,
0.0030365379,
0.0095380601,
0.0733775571,
-0.0019309255,
-0.0267582256,
-0.0174392518,
0.0275181849,
0.0215370525,
-0.0054744487,
-0.0056106779,
0.0249082427,
-0.0456132106,
0.0007116023,
-0.0103771128,
-0.1060316116,
0.0435343571,
-0.0459280871,
0.0192990638,
-0.0229306538,
-0.0520808697,
0.0135971345,
0.0686443225,
-0.0004038052,
0.0286601242,
0.06266395,
-0.035035979,
-0.0347488672,
-0.0168728884,
0.05876185,
-0.0657012314,
0.0300954953,
-0.0181453358,
0.007008798,
-0.0146557698,
-0.0318207145,
-0.072429359,
-0.0397959128,
0.0039410917,
-0.0192180369,
0.0032360849,
-0.0292984508,
-0.0364083461,
-0.0434577167,
0.0261036735,
0.0056432444,
-0.0222457983,
0.0185835361,
-0.0055101789,
0.010611725,
0.0281642005,
-0.0230972115,
-0.0349889584,
-0.0531174541,
-0.0009082033,
0.1018186957,
0.0447870791,
0.0100241313,
-0.0218724292,
-0.0135579556,
0.0224497393,
-0.0156006152,
-0.0099126706,
0.0194724947,
0.018233994,
-0.0208458714,
-0.0311654825,
0.0515449867,
0.0070390413,
-0.0172609407,
0.008834444,
0.0085161803,
0.0524019711,
0.0056573972,
0.0254377592,
-0.0831274837,
-0.0009396355,
0.0302750785,
0.0734200031,
-0.0090143904,
-0.0261882097,
-0.0315872319,
-0.1281073093,
0.0083864434,
0.0351397805,
-0.086719498,
-0.0436938554,
-0.0381029211,
-0.0212675892,
-0.022189742,
0.0235901829,
0.0147192217,
0.0012520151,
0.0254808962,
0.016390441,
0.0248083863,
0.0079757432,
-0.0005622319,
-0.0248435605,
0.0803779736,
0.045681119,
0.0041797948,
0.0013473008,
-0.0029099295,
0.0382767357,
0.0170844719,
-0.0426777601,
0.017293606,
0.0500116944,
-0.0017951677,
-0.0334660523,
0.0306271873,
0.0470692217,
0.0109309331,
0.0264347885,
0.0381652899,
0.0294710565,
0.0118682962,
-0.0058684144,
0.0209261812,
-0.0320689231,
0.0230968278,
0.0612331815,
0.0146066248,
-0.0088164238,
-0.0385160968,
-0.0572452284,
0.047121156,
0.035154853,
-0.0433613062,
0.0229224004,
-0.0041622026,
-0.0716671944,
-0.0553498976,
-0.0138382511,
-0.0264347363,
0.0520559326,
0.0269656647,
-0.0091346465,
0.0315397121,
0.0120875435,
-0.0471385606,
0.0007045926,
-0.0633978173,
0.0009255186,
-0.0691892207,
-0.0261332598,
-0.0083311126,
-0.0212443303,
-0.0344550088,
-0.0059777345,
-0.0979077294,
-0.0973368511,
0.0474614538,
0.0443973318,
0.0302314926,
0.0503916442,
0.0079379054,
0.0001582644,
0.0449062139,
0.0577923879,
-0.0254113991,
0.0250899438,
0.0745795891,
-0.0498891175,
0.0191180445,
0.0427494459,
-0.0385880172,
-0.018834807,
0.0687601417,
-0.0175723732,
-0.037800245,
-0.0083706956,
0.0153244659,
0.067440182,
0.0622499175,
0.0322945565,
-0.0067554777,
-0.0092115514,
0.0383983776,
-0.0034688909,
-0.0047837063,
-0.0373287126,
-0.0172561016,
-0.0018848029,
-0.0085260291,
0.048113998,
-0.0254234821,
0.0334056988,
0.0434181094,
-0.0170816164,
-0.0205130484,
0.0405151807,
0.0194509588,
0.0513055474,
-0.004379842,
-0.0129980929,
0.0422894619,
-0.0061407001,
0.051370386,
-0.0106743593,
0.0184514411,
0.0120515693,
0.000827894,
0.0040887361,
0.0125720492,
-0.0773374587,
-0.0674571469,
0.0252838247,
0.0527437218,
0.0352685899,
-0.0311319493,
0.006721904,
-0.0198289324,
0.0045137093,
-0.0351440869,
0.0134511087,
-0.0221959222,
-0.0354108699,
0.0093628634,
0.0124521907,
-0.0150218736,
0.046402134,
0.0801839456,
-0.0036973162,
0.0797808617,
0.0020508294,
-0.003346208,
-0.0455356687,
-0.0320357457,
0.0274867732,
-0.0026457515,
-0.0154080736,
-0.0324154571,
-0.0226114038,
-0.075345546,
-0.0362427384,
0.0223554522,
0.0171096455,
0.0060224459,
0.0023226799,
0.061299324,
-0.0172258019,
0.0140806464,
-0.0817691535,
0.0563456602,
0.002343735,
-0.0296055023,
0.0372352377,
-6.256872107e-33,
0.0005358894,
0.0069543435,
-0.0117668379,
0.0266126208,
0.001237788,
0.0268792789,
-0.0248057637,
0.008707949,
-0.0598932207,
-0.0282669738,
-0.0434865616,
0.015763497,
0.0112950765,
0.0315948911,
-0.0538189895,
-0.0567320995,
-0.0042977994,
-0.0138412211,
-0.03188226,
0.0339634418,
0.0801105425,
0.0130843334,
0.0590963103,
-0.0533769727,
0.0314298794,
-0.0512245484,
-0.0114506902,
0.026183961,
-0.0274830647,
0.0542665608,
-0.0123474905,
-0.0000331242,
-0.0322758816,
-0.0437671877,
0.0176884606,
-0.0057322276,
-0.023738578,
0.0160773881,
0.0051210709,
0.0131080477,
-0.0046657347,
-0.0359566025,
0.0290523209,
-0.0161990989,
0.008326618,
-0.0079157408,
-0.0130548021,
-0.0068811337,
-0.0418616757,
0.0464037545,
-0.0314274393,
0.0065436517,
-0.0342017971,
-0.0012123669,
0.0336198471,
-0.0432747044,
0.0304981079,
-0.0069537894,
-0.0493021756,
0.0436126366,
0.0407773517,
0.0287751593,
0.0669182986,
0.0379852243,
0.0342360623,
0.0737034827,
0.0555295199,
-0.0036653765,
0.0018025145,
0.0054043746,
-0.0174403377,
0.0509255193,
0.0068641016,
-0.0096905632,
0.0594575554,
-0.0362610407,
-0.0509377047,
-0.0025076352,
0.0324065536,
-0.0079095243,
0.0182152428,
-0.0042798449,
-0.0794272497,
-0.0059579862,
-0.0082450313,
-0.0448883548,
-0.0091719152,
-0.0069376258,
-0.0189358462,
0.0134100299,
-0.0420578234,
-0.0405665115,
0.0112525886,
-0.0461544283,
0.0178118963,
0.0388334207,
-0.0177450068,
-0.0371145085,
-0.024851989,
0.0037929341,
-0.0075829509,
-0.0159991514,
-0.030946048,
-0.0445515886,
0.0416504629,
0.0354741886,
0.0283861794,
0.0371487625,
-0.0644861385,
-0.0040572034,
-0.0397819243,
0.0181167368,
0.0149689503,
0.0187949445,
0.0629050359,
-0.0224944763,
0.0118930684,
0.0136926547,
0.0471074358,
0.0304271467,
-0.0473263673,
0.0444658846,
-0.0283094347,
-0.0107923336,
0.0052349442,
0.0103045395,
-0.0026027553,
0.075370647,
0.0421514548,
-0.0443340242,
0.0140322186,
-0.0004513151,
2.76e-7,
-0.0092639429,
-0.0045413855,
0.0380255058,
0.0238880105,
0.0186836049,
0.0821494237,
-0.0336488746,
0.0566251688,
-0.009954731,
-0.035409864,
-0.0333197676,
0.0196117833,
0.0436426289,
0.0350861475,
-0.0669084191,
-0.0024070304,
-0.0716724694,
-0.0432427302,
-0.0403725393,
-0.0144883916,
0.0181365889,
0.1166745871,
0.0399156287,
-0.016336197,
-0.008469983,
-0.0646531135,
0.0184981767,
-0.0029350817,
0.0067549665,
-0.0099417549,
0.0554013439,
0.0383520722,
-0.0138677415,
-0.0008915889,
-0.0334250666,
0.0165895373,
-0.0327394828,
0.04963113,
0.0181679074,
-0.0068727206,
-0.0422876328,
-0.0331735015,
-0.0428009406,
-0.016999254,
0.0617222413,
0.0089764837,
-0.0539435782,
-0.0666940957,
-0.0190914422,
-0.0312191267,
0.0088011632,
0.0057931663,
0.0008969349,
0.0338687338,
-0.021252973,
-0.026902169,
0.0201826598,
-0.0530276969,
-0.0325088911,
-0.0322689116,
-0.0273460057,
-0.0533663966,
0.0263169724,
0.0233545173,
0.0110617643,
-0.0080866255,
0.0150609473,
2.441492354e-34,
-0.0080852518,
-0.0352771729,
0.0098560434,
0.0440135151,
0.0091542611,
-0.0408365391,
0.0668031126,
-0.0081220148,
-0.0036503293,
-0.0610017404,
-0.0270805471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17030v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17030v2 | Is This the Subspace You Are Looking for? An Interpretability Illusion for Subspace Activation Patching | 2023-11-28T18:32:19 | 2023-12-06T14:28:46 | Aleksandar Makelov, Georg Lange, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Mechanistic interpretability aims to understand model behaviors in terms of
specific, interpretable features, often hypothesized to manifest as
low-dimensional subspaces of activations. Specifically, recent studies have
explored subspace interventions (such as activation patching) as a way to
simultaneously manipulate model behavior and attribute the features behind it
to given subspaces.
In this work, we demonstrate that these two aims diverge, potentially leading
to an illusory sense of interpretability. Counterintuitively, even if a
subspace intervention makes the model's output behave as if the value of a
feature was changed, this effect may be achieved by activating a dormant
parallel pathway leveraging another subspace that is causally disconnected from
model outputs. We demonstrate this phenomenon in a distilled mathematical
example, in two real-world domains (the indirect object identification task and
factual recall), and present evidence for its prevalence in practice. In the
context of factual recall, we further show a link to rank-1 fact editing,
providing a mechanistic explanation for previous work observing an
inconsistency between fact editing performance and fact localization.
However, this does not imply that activation patching of subspaces is
intrinsically unfit for interpretability. To contextualize our findings, we
also show what a success case looks like in a task (indirect object
identification) where prior manual circuit analysis informs an understanding of
the location of a feature. We explore the additional evidence needed to argue
that a patched subspace is faithful. | [
-0.014782371,
0.0435390733,
-0.0441362262,
0.0418068022,
-0.0247859787,
0.0036441963,
0.0592642687,
-0.0072218524,
-0.0271773469,
-0.0034729382,
-0.0350766182,
-0.0031193586,
0.0350303948,
0.0475670695,
0.0397607684,
-0.0289914813,
0.0375277549,
-0.0196251217,
-0.0062165181,
-0.0292188041,
-0.0540190265,
-0.0598979555,
-0.0295706466,
0.036710646,
-0.0008417089,
-0.0361310728,
-0.0086278189,
-0.0193949919,
0.0054896567,
0.0401068069,
-0.0541941077,
0.0577338859,
0.0135105113,
0.0343115442,
0.0000021385,
-0.0176521931,
-0.0068103313,
0.0213751085,
-0.0717802048,
0.0517681353,
-0.0738162771,
-0.034774024,
0.0142744482,
-0.0501318835,
0.007839134,
-0.0328847989,
0.0655944869,
0.040936809,
-0.0343479961,
0.0260337442,
-0.0100024128,
0.0113398405,
0.0010623123,
-0.0216987878,
0.077322647,
0.0046202936,
-0.0097063584,
0.0027040388,
-0.0467477739,
0.0128617566,
-0.0752733946,
-0.0043782592,
0.0377480201,
0.0215046778,
0.0725726113,
0.0314914212,
0.0004805123,
0.0441431589,
0.0188740175,
0.0129497563,
0.0191356689,
-0.0250789076,
-0.0279752184,
-0.0012636145,
0.0344040617,
0.0214249864,
-0.0344402082,
-0.036457058,
-0.0033322503,
-0.0152358375,
-0.0354289226,
-0.0117639443,
0.0498470254,
-0.0395186469,
0.0000217705,
0.005016984,
-0.0038906774,
-0.0285127219,
-0.0340324864,
0.0111340843,
-0.0266030263,
0.0084802965,
0.0165690668,
-0.0380166993,
0.0150982346,
-0.0012153211,
0.02734139,
0.0102282213,
-0.0405001007,
-0.0420831591,
0.0754425153,
0.0579785295,
-0.024137523,
-0.0113107944,
-0.0509879403,
0.0865596905,
-0.0552471466,
0.0767047554,
-0.0259481836,
0.0747541711,
-0.0537246689,
-0.0538834669,
0.0405899212,
0.0381855816,
-0.015669575,
0.012939983,
-0.0563560091,
-0.0103403255,
-0.0718245581,
0.0069529405,
-0.0783269554,
0.0257233046,
-0.0219801012,
0.0076841852,
-0.0261818171,
0.0435351953,
-0.0092679979,
0.0373958685,
-0.0361027233,
-0.0009972433,
-0.058300741,
-0.0235388353,
-0.0078560328,
-0.0178295523,
-0.0308399554,
0.0600719526,
-0.0011674588,
-0.0399457961,
-0.0359074138,
-0.0518458635,
0.0101901554,
-0.0018377985,
0.064770706,
-0.0264481883,
-0.0063224593,
0.0395707153,
-0.0012862828,
-0.0385131165,
-0.0095839063,
-0.0319359303,
-0.0244270451,
0.0986869633,
0.0329264998,
-0.0044076326,
-0.0093685444,
0.0324202813,
-0.0274271257,
0.0235331096,
-0.0017354029,
0.0083380146,
-0.000279099,
0.0105804838,
0.0488790758,
-0.030973779,
0.0349944681,
0.0020245197,
-0.0286829509,
-0.0149669163,
0.0089272335,
0.0116578341,
0.0473056175,
-0.0344093554,
-0.0431331061,
-0.0090112248,
0.0513164848,
0.00015135,
0.0337052457,
0.0663418323,
-0.0135094393,
-0.0470472276,
-0.0231970306,
0.0637132302,
-0.0825066641,
0.0753525123,
-0.0354532339,
-0.0104187503,
-0.0180052128,
-0.0241783168,
-0.0081206309,
-0.0489997417,
-0.0132401623,
0.0274585299,
0.0080089606,
-0.0003038101,
0.039781902,
0.00691103,
0.0150913,
0.0362450741,
-0.0153557668,
-0.0069162548,
0.0091132456,
-0.0422706977,
-0.022837406,
0.0382161438,
0.0119431522,
-0.0475186817,
0.0061679278,
-0.0137713552,
-0.0183743369,
-0.0171400998,
0.0185583364,
0.0041617393,
0.0208414942,
0.0250973012,
-0.0286421962,
-0.0997134894,
0.0504536629,
0.0337592587,
-0.0439474359,
-0.0825537071,
-0.0265928451,
-0.0155038116,
0.0065846252,
0.0045804451,
-0.0052195038,
-0.0237931255,
-0.0231684353,
0.0171018466,
-0.0131326234,
-0.0321126096,
-0.0001819445,
0.0079716714,
-0.0092566442,
-0.0015880043,
0.0199597888,
0.0382877439,
-0.0189846233,
0.0177348368,
-0.0154585522,
-0.0248795934,
-0.0201684441,
0.0225727223,
0.0324191824,
-0.0081285425,
0.0662614033,
-0.0467689075,
0.0128009701,
-0.0086985817,
-0.0017951508,
-0.0187905822,
-0.0083707562,
-0.0020720111,
0.0552583113,
-0.0112891542,
-0.0111511918,
0.0527574979,
0.025165204,
0.0247026365,
0.0051944805,
0.0276912935,
0.0004271625,
0.0332334861,
0.0000364491,
-0.0342944264,
-0.0744217262,
-0.0165601764,
-0.0182921831,
-0.0211349484,
-0.0355018489,
-0.0152669037,
0.0008229904,
0.0394445993,
-0.0201102328,
0.010795258,
0.0161259286,
0.0450473987,
-0.0345586017,
-0.0468425378,
0.075692974,
0.0011513249,
-0.011358561,
0.0120573258,
-0.0013864825,
-0.0062360256,
-0.0116649373,
0.0675368533,
0.0215842016,
0.0110068563,
-0.0600938685,
-0.0071706665,
0.023012545,
0.0045602722,
0.0138189914,
0.0013694654,
0.0047435225,
0.0193521976,
0.0181767121,
0.0576923229,
-0.0627567098,
0.1145377979,
0.0609852336,
-0.0164939761,
-0.001207287,
-0.019789597,
-0.0561037995,
0.0318309925,
0.0207797214,
-0.0520076863,
-0.0374531113,
0.0175143592,
0.0401648581,
-0.0225288663,
-0.053253185,
0.0322123878,
-0.0113465134,
-0.0595631823,
-0.0593773015,
-0.0417633131,
-0.0294607356,
0.0678273886,
-0.0369330831,
-0.0339874215,
0.06229252,
0.0269835759,
0.015708169,
-0.0039600185,
0.0418439582,
0.0081300484,
0.0724841654,
0.023550516,
0.0120671997,
0.0110491756,
-0.0299017634,
-0.0358968973,
-0.0118844928,
-0.0000030223,
0.003756094,
0.0250464175,
-0.0382157341,
-0.0195589606,
0.005945398,
-0.0030691563,
-0.0285096392,
0.0039192052,
0.0351486616,
0.0224490557,
-0.0279042237,
-0.0057057161,
-0.0064179292,
-0.0077629657,
0.0809145719,
0.0545602702,
-0.0481109284,
-0.0376960859,
-0.019512957,
-0.0276776347,
-0.0395079926,
0.0428043939,
0.0673698634,
-0.0468893014,
-0.0098171821,
0.0410242565,
-0.0281963572,
-0.0107942326,
-0.0372945145,
0.044042591,
-0.0117482869,
0.0041238777,
-0.0161269251,
-0.0190859102,
0.0633628145,
-0.0471722968,
-0.0775964707,
0.0129820555,
0.028416628,
-0.0146103101,
0.0349784456,
-0.0488193445,
-0.0158198867,
0.0483954139,
0.0081676459,
-0.0126969069,
0.0289659929,
-0.0093960008,
0.0278240647,
-0.0377224684,
0.0126581592,
0.016523378,
-0.0209271647,
0.0876131505,
0.0076917722,
-0.0471657887,
-0.066472061,
-0.0073542432,
0.0061264625,
0.0079790475,
0.0104010915,
0.025979355,
-0.0165189262,
0.0249017458,
0.0008486754,
0.0313261338,
-0.0160294026,
-0.0005558659,
0.0368608236,
0.0187566187,
0.0265940148,
-0.0393720493,
-0.0316890143,
-0.0592836924,
0.0003245523,
0.0530362055,
0.0575351231,
-0.004954169,
0.0710183159,
0.0674473867,
-0.0129523557,
-0.0311188232,
0.0179009121,
0.0166563541,
-0.0792339295,
-0.0769167095,
0.0513753779,
-0.0485507287,
0.0157857575,
0.0284360163,
-0.0133657334,
-0.0461367853,
0.0184638686,
0.0815136135,
-0.0084670344,
-0.0062817256,
-0.0223649945,
0.0279766954,
-0.0193016324,
-0.0897628516,
0.0095740194,
0.0278142672,
-0.038393721,
-0.003077613,
-0.0240596291,
-0.0069602677,
0.0443320796,
0.0108698243,
-0.0225880407,
-0.0178028867,
-0.0500318632,
-0.0176677387,
0.0624737777,
0.0023080772,
-0.015117839,
0.0496761613,
-0.0371941589,
-0.0107997954,
-0.0968714058,
-0.0474728085,
-0.019473711,
0.0020868203,
-0.0305975713,
0.0531832054,
0.0141364131,
0.0342057273,
0.0486128293,
0.0334272198,
-0.0181090832,
-0.0024499716,
-0.0162495766,
0.0068723536,
0.0811626539,
0.0329042971,
-0.0139096184,
-0.0137422448,
0.0183804967,
0.0012387872,
0.0026359037,
0.086430788,
0.0048161172,
-0.0302539933,
0.0450637676,
0.0207214765,
-0.0300535578,
0.1085299402,
0.0578790456,
-0.0155031849,
-0.0277454965,
0.0452422611,
-0.0087384079,
0.0046027908,
0.0031846608,
-0.0276295412,
0.026803514,
0.0691522062,
-0.0222705398,
-0.0290515292,
-0.000131755,
0.0160515029,
-0.0201782323,
-0.0357667767,
-0.019629227,
0.0052896007,
-0.0242849384,
0.0790297687,
-0.0080238432,
0.0629018918,
-0.019602919,
0.0382710882,
0.0170072373,
0.016772842,
0.0361773595,
-0.0072223935,
-0.0843314007,
-0.0280726496,
-0.1117737815,
-0.0213399865,
0.0361566953,
0.0069816043,
0.027150318,
-0.0260777697,
0.0109155262,
-0.037945535,
-0.0150867477,
0.0092539368,
0.0027684036,
0.040705584,
-0.0040116804,
0.0047455761,
0.0048318361,
0.0163611956,
-0.0385549627,
0.0314996839,
-0.0242084768,
0.0544635989,
-0.0580869466,
-0.020464262,
-0.0224912334,
-0.0563755594,
0.010104008,
0.0740882084,
-0.0412391163,
-0.0316679105,
-0.0982553437,
-0.0149144745,
0.0235144291,
0.0018300227,
0.0134551115,
-0.0664555356,
-0.0106614921,
0.0521409325,
-0.0232683048,
-0.0305755138,
0.0010761694,
0.0024717506,
0.0327100866,
0.0011214757,
-0.0028340309,
-6.220845409e-33,
-0.007504635,
-0.0357889533,
-0.0015445537,
0.0315209925,
-0.005644484,
0.0235234573,
-0.0286059268,
0.0636089519,
0.0111248316,
0.0348209329,
0.0035158542,
-0.0105033033,
0.0113823647,
-0.0306465682,
0.023074653,
-0.0011981137,
0.0237882845,
0.0231407508,
-0.0416128486,
-0.0044629928,
0.0670672581,
0.0061775642,
0.0609961487,
-0.1097532287,
0.0392006412,
0.0400313176,
-0.000840152,
0.0051843538,
-0.0862252712,
0.0431319848,
-0.0379812196,
0.0487061962,
0.0204558466,
-0.0642526597,
-0.0343543142,
-0.0313410573,
0.0199230779,
0.0000934563,
0.0423291884,
0.0290139727,
-0.0353360288,
-0.0464720353,
0.0588388443,
0.0066016475,
-0.0565584265,
-0.0273857992,
0.0245037582,
-0.0563219041,
0.0271468349,
0.037711639,
-0.0829094499,
-0.0377745368,
-0.0121241566,
-0.0093707209,
0.0429235213,
-0.0216828641,
-0.0090079652,
0.0012757148,
-0.093981944,
-0.0063970266,
0.0312412009,
0.0197438505,
0.0218342654,
0.0453024022,
0.0319907516,
0.0514800549,
0.0936279744,
0.0479562581,
-0.016177373,
-0.026642615,
0.0159038566,
0.0228190236,
0.060738638,
0.0171350967,
0.0494309701,
-0.0022516546,
-0.0245074369,
-0.0519892983,
-0.0734513551,
-0.0092042666,
0.0653193519,
0.0197438784,
-0.0115911514,
-0.0122729503,
-0.029038528,
0.0151328929,
-0.0767993852,
-0.0069935406,
0.0025813745,
-0.0263841953,
0.0193106662,
0.0506535247,
0.0166455023,
0.0005807416,
0.032446485,
-0.0213384591,
0.0217827577,
0.0556263477,
0.0083101746,
-0.0361233279,
-0.0194311999,
0.0223650802,
0.0037630564,
0.0275220666,
0.0160603691,
0.0095216334,
0.0221155416,
0.0179746021,
0.0058838734,
-0.0130920764,
-0.0559593476,
-0.0442788787,
0.0328170024,
-0.0089050811,
0.0228692852,
0.0148773175,
-0.0348257199,
-0.0001487352,
0.0345715471,
0.0406619757,
-0.0207222756,
0.0264985431,
-0.0630420372,
0.0343360826,
-0.0041958783,
-0.0318455212,
-0.0224698819,
0.0081260977,
0.0361935757,
-0.0641814321,
-0.0372750424,
-0.0015898964,
2.981e-7,
0.0253369734,
0.0205578543,
0.0232986342,
-0.0372513458,
0.0497417636,
0.0309275445,
-0.0127226422,
0.0016575521,
0.0560287647,
-0.0422411524,
-0.0183536187,
0.0260782354,
-0.0021454701,
-0.0119920624,
0.0102517232,
0.0225486904,
0.0240632389,
0.0591631867,
-0.0016070992,
0.0070759025,
0.0359993242,
-0.0133413859,
0.0018538035,
-0.003664586,
0.0079379939,
0.0427259803,
0.0669196621,
-0.0042916657,
0.024193475,
-0.026472453,
-0.0256525315,
0.011611375,
-0.0012902113,
0.0301746838,
0.0106128408,
-0.010241271,
-0.0327141955,
0.0215028804,
0.0025133486,
0.0019486368,
-0.05416416,
0.0290613361,
0.0120726088,
-0.0106442962,
0.0143516297,
-0.0928593203,
-0.0507993139,
0.0074047456,
-0.0016646822,
0.0326395072,
0.0285859406,
0.0306574032,
0.0319678038,
-0.0113763781,
-0.0301272869,
0.0309185982,
-0.0081269229,
-0.0206421688,
-0.021313617,
0.0225329008,
-0.0652751476,
-0.0276202057,
-0.032720238,
-0.0171336029,
0.0332886614,
-0.034751337,
-0.0530490242,
2.999844823e-34,
-0.0183094516,
0.0107071418,
0.0608448945,
0.0077903243,
0.0058270278,
-0.063781783,
-0.0097502992,
-0.018025998,
0.0242480449,
-0.0389016159,
-0.0318598747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03741v1 | Comparing Generative Chatbots Based on Process Requirements | 2023-11-28T18:25:22 | 2023-11-28T18:25:22 | Luis Fernando Lins, Nathalia Nascimento, Paulo Alencar, Toacy Oliveira, Donald Cowan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Business processes are commonly represented by modelling languages, such as
Event-driven Process Chain (EPC), Yet Another Workflow Language (YAWL), and the
most popular standard notation for modelling business processes, the Business
Process Model and Notation (BPMN). Most recently, chatbots, programs that allow
users to interact with a machine using natural language, have been increasingly
used for business process execution support. A recent category of chatbots
worth mentioning is generative-based chatbots, powered by Large Language Models
(LLMs) such as OpenAI's Generative Pre-Trained Transformer (GPT) model and
Google's Pathways Language Model (PaLM), which are trained on billions of
parameters and support conversational intelligence. However, it is not clear
whether generative-based chatbots are able to understand and meet the
requirements of constructs such as those provided by BPMN for process execution
support. This paper presents a case study to compare the performance of
prominent generative models, GPT and PaLM, in the context of process execution
support. The research sheds light into the challenging problem of using
conversational approaches supported by generative chatbots as a means to
understand process-aware modelling notations and support users to execute their
tasks. | [
0.0248221681,
0.0322718062,
-0.0340516269,
-0.0153335305,
-0.0299421437,
0.0045911139,
0.0133784097,
-0.0017103823,
0.0135518806,
-0.0006961069,
-0.0096832709,
0.0095692724,
-0.0175214354,
0.098423548,
-0.0250074584,
-0.0994042903,
0.0080530113,
-0.015875509,
0.0474636815,
0.0318535119,
-0.0240276847,
0.0387156941,
-0.0310732126,
0.0994090289,
-0.0428076684,
-0.0371793546,
-0.0509195589,
-0.0051572691,
0.0174651425,
-0.0011141014,
-0.016536653,
0.0569158308,
0.0119112898,
0.0354650095,
0.0000020471,
-0.0493164249,
0.0493202098,
0.0347318128,
-0.0502800792,
-0.0140111307,
0.0347521044,
0.0092983972,
-0.0488898046,
0.0465583317,
-0.0310059916,
-0.0462547541,
0.0672611222,
0.0612265058,
0.0538822114,
0.0448268093,
-0.0345567316,
-0.0112513294,
0.029320186,
-0.0035974903,
-0.0029819156,
-0.0633870587,
0.0045621339,
0.0356592201,
0.0448361672,
0.0136728697,
0.0268550813,
-0.0005850636,
0.0223098118,
-0.0612619221,
-0.0442057326,
0.044427041,
0.0384524502,
-0.0336805917,
-0.016396543,
0.0477615334,
0.0123759788,
0.0176994428,
-0.0113198645,
0.0004805583,
0.019807566,
-0.0285538621,
-0.0606849082,
0.0344496556,
-0.0062188124,
-0.015693415,
-0.0313478075,
-0.0094295237,
-0.009591477,
-0.0414535925,
-0.0129791722,
0.021069888,
0.029706059,
0.0080331368,
-0.0557474755,
0.0055090585,
0.0179409031,
-0.073200576,
-0.0060771569,
0.0660878196,
-0.0615580194,
0.0140510472,
0.0030364762,
0.0298556313,
-0.0205257628,
-0.0417455323,
0.0190946907,
0.0318177529,
0.021222271,
0.0030537422,
0.0006784844,
0.0390864275,
0.0114601115,
0.0030948091,
-0.0185615066,
-0.0279368274,
-0.0706375837,
-0.0188907273,
-0.0669984519,
-0.019816624,
-0.0424826406,
-0.0334590897,
-0.0283332877,
0.0985317528,
-0.0332762338,
0.0338911451,
0.0677270293,
-0.0114152953,
-0.0537229702,
-0.0037211045,
-0.0672076866,
0.0057187723,
-0.0289476179,
0.0126544144,
0.0232795607,
-0.0635333657,
-0.0039351853,
0.0186835788,
-0.011665971,
0.0052978746,
-0.0367466249,
0.1025530398,
0.0141502377,
0.0230865516,
-0.0260037631,
-0.0109021179,
0.0449076295,
-0.0506721959,
-0.0013214588,
-0.0145619288,
0.030134514,
-0.0017579573,
-0.0211785734,
0.009743901,
0.0009862746,
0.0227047,
0.0186923798,
0.0375550129,
0.0199802686,
0.0215248484,
0.031020565,
-0.001497548,
0.005723956,
0.0312955827,
0.0383931212,
0.0010543168,
0.0163598806,
-0.0320205055,
0.0575879365,
0.0299705416,
-0.0591165945,
-0.0404667817,
0.0614427142,
0.005603076,
0.0003267619,
0.0054673823,
0.0506920554,
0.0003861498,
-0.0299737286,
0.0449519306,
0.0548710451,
0.0148285916,
-0.0142956218,
0.0606618971,
0.0888430402,
0.0430280231,
-0.0050921212,
-0.0003401095,
-0.0209512711,
0.0322268344,
-0.0079860929,
-0.0000396175,
-0.0529388897,
-0.0012682874,
-0.0387627035,
-0.0527173728,
0.0333840512,
-0.0114449868,
0.0226105005,
-0.0223224293,
0.0472103357,
0.0482396856,
-0.0933447853,
0.0207909066,
-0.0247176662,
-0.0489396639,
-0.0843230933,
-0.0564711541,
-0.020351164,
0.0965706035,
0.0643400177,
-0.0245400257,
-0.0204272177,
0.000253998,
-0.069936119,
0.0602129847,
0.0328071564,
-0.0070312284,
-0.0290351603,
-0.0125147523,
-0.0264540445,
-0.0210384652,
0.0145795811,
0.0052370732,
0.0089164861,
-0.0109305317,
-0.0005310508,
0.0310370885,
-0.0246925857,
0.0324107669,
-0.0243666898,
-0.0276839603,
-0.0120942472,
-0.0185084976,
0.0395997874,
0.0199876521,
-0.0067283916,
0.0107107079,
0.0255727563,
0.0083735809,
-0.0175722782,
0.0817517787,
-0.0212831236,
0.0144619131,
-0.0075145219,
0.008067729,
-0.0111781955,
-0.0070406995,
-0.0548516326,
-0.0375191011,
0.030390067,
-0.0273130219,
0.0292087644,
-0.0168532617,
0.0291529763,
-0.0024754978,
-0.0139533952,
-0.0277048685,
0.020085115,
0.0372462831,
-0.0465089902,
-0.0060373805,
0.0386321656,
0.0247999746,
-0.0176525675,
0.0228780955,
0.0742365718,
0.0069478783,
-0.0040393672,
0.0255891215,
0.0130393356,
-0.0076384246,
-0.0169713516,
-0.1229922175,
-0.0153053589,
0.006836392,
0.0011876195,
0.0202572867,
0.0029435828,
-0.0059357546,
-0.013917027,
-0.0308885351,
0.0513607636,
0.0348901153,
-0.0120308809,
0.0346342921,
0.0147449691,
-0.0602247566,
-0.0219629705,
0.0179261621,
-0.0024536094,
0.0181063879,
0.0403258651,
0.0044171852,
-0.069307372,
0.0355447866,
-0.0041834395,
0.0183343254,
0.0138656292,
-0.0169873014,
0.0444839671,
0.0041073821,
0.0713131353,
0.0205353294,
-0.0225600787,
0.0529678687,
0.0016278031,
-0.0097211637,
-0.0371694714,
0.0106189372,
-0.0332603529,
-0.03456413,
-0.0119418968,
-0.0463495255,
0.0086121485,
0.057249222,
0.0039201034,
0.0125613436,
-0.043473199,
0.0072288462,
0.0205549318,
-0.0066512246,
0.0190940574,
-0.0379542671,
-0.016358858,
0.0219127405,
-0.0121407751,
-0.0404796712,
0.0553041473,
-0.0249203257,
-0.010686771,
-0.0301112961,
-0.0341057293,
-0.0132496767,
0.0879500508,
-0.0016076051,
0.0015811743,
-0.0140945585,
-0.0271866284,
-0.0409494862,
0.0445664488,
0.0284453128,
-0.0080010006,
-0.0298041366,
-0.053239394,
0.0021570465,
-0.0036865431,
-0.0042473432,
-0.0470414013,
0.0482222252,
-0.0048943791,
0.06599994,
0.0603998862,
-0.0367882773,
-0.0282121133,
0.0291294847,
-0.0152711198,
0.0597125851,
0.0376893431,
-0.0448437743,
-0.0517453514,
-0.0468801521,
0.00591336,
-0.009714637,
-0.0030729752,
0.0303993616,
0.0398770571,
0.019442318,
0.0072689988,
-0.0467856005,
-0.0488174371,
-0.0583720803,
-0.007733983,
-0.0428781658,
0.0181234032,
0.02353126,
0.0404579788,
-0.058185868,
-0.0332075283,
0.0836704448,
0.0176982488,
-0.0047493149,
0.0171815883,
-0.0241531767,
-0.0067402208,
0.0091540245,
0.0614215955,
-0.0488776006,
0.0270081814,
0.007781676,
-0.014621173,
-0.0105771609,
-0.0257705208,
0.0033892526,
-0.0813020542,
0.0757541806,
-0.0340426378,
-0.0060055358,
-0.0244987234,
-0.0520122908,
-0.0003018022,
0.0057092896,
0.0111559369,
-0.0033386087,
0.0161691792,
-0.0279206019,
-0.0069106831,
-0.0280938875,
-0.0516742244,
0.0245574676,
-0.0038656944,
0.0117341867,
0.0781420469,
0.0194769092,
0.0217767581,
0.001212288,
0.0383293517,
0.0509143323,
0.010082894,
0.0104512461,
0.0122655397,
0.0365452133,
-0.0074546621,
-0.0414854586,
-0.00290637,
-0.0525074899,
-0.0259186812,
0.017206898,
0.0762282833,
-0.0582273602,
-0.0403637215,
-0.0235975049,
0.0176791828,
0.0533527285,
0.0541898943,
0.0115660038,
-0.0272187479,
-0.0696317628,
-0.0507924035,
0.0244135093,
0.0161372647,
-0.0310637373,
-0.0107679609,
-0.0045240731,
-0.0471957102,
-0.0584190078,
-0.062092822,
0.0432197452,
0.0241196137,
0.0057821004,
-0.0422896966,
0.0581842847,
0.0249695089,
0.0056887884,
-0.0130123384,
-0.0116569325,
0.0170085039,
-0.0312344451,
-0.0456471965,
-0.0028264592,
0.0332714655,
-0.0031940571,
0.0396077223,
-0.0643426627,
0.0002655952,
-0.030006418,
0.0564202629,
0.0218649767,
-0.0225816667,
-0.0241045225,
-0.0065075709,
-0.0424577296,
-0.0061199628,
-0.0228832345,
-0.048374448,
0.0128265172,
0.046584323,
0.0001537587,
-0.0149721,
-0.0259766933,
0.0549089424,
-0.0434726775,
0.0346331149,
-0.0161437131,
-0.083360225,
0.0292659476,
0.0150312167,
-0.0140766622,
0.0165923424,
-0.0248410124,
-0.045718316,
0.0174107347,
-0.072746709,
0.0142503567,
-0.0571458638,
-0.0047294865,
-0.0310332645,
-0.0234169774,
0.050403785,
-0.0043315031,
-0.0744352117,
0.0272849109,
0.0030958748,
-0.002895328,
0.0269027594,
0.0172225647,
-0.0061506643,
-0.0073390133,
-0.0153704928,
-0.0118376426,
-0.0003733468,
0.0360452831,
0.0236294586,
0.0768309683,
-0.0023540675,
0.0302256756,
0.0173451006,
0.0128188971,
-0.0466468781,
-0.0727682933,
0.0174365379,
0.0369315036,
0.0444946922,
0.0120069087,
0.0251181461,
-0.0968207568,
0.0205249023,
-0.0191710293,
0.0447350517,
0.0154923955,
-0.0278330259,
-0.0309862513,
0.0125396075,
-0.0237938892,
-0.0570783317,
0.0675071478,
-0.0337915458,
0.0480455458,
-0.0589245744,
-0.0552981608,
-0.0492873564,
-0.0942778066,
-0.0018368557,
0.0171621609,
0.0077677909,
0.0039771846,
-0.0382032394,
-0.0550194383,
-0.0848264992,
0.0197244417,
-0.0053542373,
-0.0585085712,
0.0308513585,
0.053253796,
-0.0091576092,
-0.0187900215,
-0.0223220959,
0.0054937513,
-0.0064371177,
-0.0062843026,
-0.0783342719,
-5.215838514e-33,
-0.0335335955,
-0.0424417257,
0.067021735,
0.0493485481,
-0.0040820264,
-0.049722515,
-0.0598837174,
0.0148252659,
-0.0033532265,
0.0552775413,
-0.0265015736,
0.0074010915,
0.0153693939,
-0.0095867328,
-0.0063872789,
0.0252491403,
0.0929933041,
-0.0241159778,
-0.0087598944,
0.0480950586,
0.0489807166,
-0.0193220749,
0.0125976708,
-0.0706475824,
0.0448586345,
-0.0176267736,
-0.0315267555,
0.0103972396,
0.0190866683,
0.0300629959,
-0.0126043996,
0.042677369,
0.0150020244,
0.0031330828,
-0.023776643,
0.0220848266,
-0.015899254,
-0.0012694538,
-0.0012099871,
0.0205074716,
-0.0351173803,
-0.031414032,
0.0089812102,
-0.0278467219,
-0.0365882516,
0.0250653811,
0.0203932412,
-0.0095051592,
-0.0019086491,
-0.0002949414,
-0.1158055216,
-0.0071550147,
-0.0155342445,
-0.0208077133,
-0.0015812524,
0.0178675391,
-0.001203111,
-0.0581213757,
-0.0188186299,
0.029116923,
0.0153991366,
-0.0135601982,
0.0701940656,
0.0238668211,
0.0315813199,
-0.0179947298,
-0.0011440755,
0.0636493489,
-0.0175136626,
0.0197244026,
-0.0132785719,
0.0889623314,
0.0261317641,
-0.0172430016,
-0.0435679741,
-0.0012119191,
-0.0145445066,
0.0625880137,
0.0082698809,
0.0635830238,
0.0173042342,
-0.0003704489,
-0.0144074811,
0.0031343866,
-0.014693941,
0.0113933263,
0.0079231635,
-0.0230643675,
-0.0050029438,
0.0075894915,
0.0290727802,
-0.0309328269,
0.0273704603,
-0.0244794954,
-0.0114184497,
0.0192994643,
-0.0446115434,
-0.002893931,
-0.0026715479,
-0.0100512719,
0.0002896131,
-0.0339547843,
0.049060151,
0.0187344868,
0.0462978631,
0.0217937026,
-0.010377028,
-0.0017091471,
-0.038443964,
0.0250313077,
-0.0770450309,
0.0852343068,
-0.0178588834,
0.0240438934,
-0.0116041731,
0.0006673195,
-0.0211730562,
0.002986907,
-0.0236715339,
0.0174931455,
-0.0043725488,
0.060919594,
-0.0143146208,
-0.0174601395,
-0.0254909061,
-0.0140888775,
-0.0340254717,
0.02037628,
0.0548619516,
-0.029516872,
-0.0316843912,
0.0168937799,
2.65e-7,
0.0164979734,
0.0302994326,
0.0359542966,
0.0956051871,
0.0624988191,
0.0326860808,
0.0213087536,
0.0045752949,
0.000595085,
0.003533111,
0.0353601463,
0.021619983,
0.041233249,
0.0243176557,
-0.0395467915,
-0.0779272169,
-0.033427421,
-0.0031374474,
-0.0652602687,
0.0069054007,
0.05040792,
0.0472066849,
-0.0166467428,
0.0131625775,
0.0220834408,
0.0036925361,
0.0217235815,
-0.0334209763,
0.035059914,
0.055693116,
0.0185634065,
-0.0057558632,
0.0327286944,
0.0140095176,
-0.009592548,
-0.0267574284,
-0.0155265871,
0.0705361366,
0.0018035187,
-0.0070592724,
0.0200454015,
-0.0216728877,
0.021807557,
-0.0639893562,
0.0060164668,
-0.0966665596,
-0.0576845482,
-0.0268166773,
-0.0247470737,
-0.011291774,
0.000329712,
-0.0164975263,
-0.0093589686,
0.0336069092,
-0.0138125587,
-0.0051698582,
0.0294979792,
-0.0081845624,
0.0280607082,
-0.0247754604,
-0.070709683,
-0.0412194654,
-0.0401542261,
-0.0488197505,
0.0315472409,
0.0491565354,
0.0408899114,
2.241111204e-34,
0.030803211,
0.016749287,
0.0111439331,
0.0415553898,
0.0427485406,
0.0324661732,
0.0304031149,
0.0512138903,
0.0181154963,
-0.0650536343,
-0.0106534353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03740v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03740v2 | A Survey on Prompting Techniques in LLMs | 2023-11-28T17:56:34 | 2024-04-16T22:27:39 | Prabin Bhandari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Autoregressive Large Language Models have transformed the landscape of
Natural Language Processing. Pre-train and prompt paradigm has replaced the
conventional approach of pre-training and fine-tuning for many downstream NLP
tasks. This shift has been possible largely due to LLMs and innovative
prompting techniques. LLMs have shown great promise for a variety of downstream
tasks owing to their vast parameters and huge datasets that they are
pre-trained on. However, in order to fully realize their potential, their
outputs must be guided towards the desired outcomes. Prompting, in which a
specific input or instruction is provided to guide the LLMs toward the intended
output, has become a tool for achieving this goal. In this paper, we discuss
the various prompting techniques that have been applied to fully harness the
power of LLMs. We present a taxonomy of existing literature on prompting
techniques and provide a concise survey based on this taxonomy. Further, we
identify some open problems in the realm of prompting in autoregressive LLMs
which could serve as a direction for future research. | [
0.0579351485,
0.0433437265,
-0.0050882264,
0.0288238693,
-0.0498654805,
0.0311896168,
-0.0105659962,
0.0109753814,
0.0253096465,
-0.08540795,
-0.03642717,
-0.0233261306,
-0.0117376074,
0.0069149928,
0.0191317759,
-0.0108203012,
0.0731083676,
-0.0333512947,
-0.0097521134,
0.0038908799,
-0.0286728553,
-0.0056254691,
-0.0107833762,
0.0065920837,
-0.0153201781,
-0.0174436476,
-0.0215185303,
0.0097801937,
-0.0094110146,
-0.0340817533,
0.0055422331,
0.0379873067,
0.0219023749,
0.0188565049,
0.0000017578,
-0.0843398422,
-0.0001310979,
-0.0190377962,
-0.0745873973,
-0.0066105104,
0.0066887694,
-0.0102093853,
-0.0077319802,
0.0120479446,
-0.0724588037,
-0.0071293451,
0.0088626053,
0.056989748,
0.0654096305,
0.1110584363,
0.0131557677,
-0.0189501643,
0.0148284286,
-0.024316404,
0.0166175459,
-0.0077296076,
0.0324312113,
-0.055641219,
0.0347741395,
0.0416492485,
-0.002893335,
0.0482214279,
-0.005592641,
0.004505577,
0.0125863897,
0.0080673527,
0.0259681381,
-0.0371212102,
-0.0768754333,
0.0512167513,
0.018050069,
0.0140758893,
0.0252556577,
-0.0266804304,
-0.014602961,
0.0277428739,
-0.0446884744,
0.0368212089,
0.0293004252,
0.0289170779,
0.0303237252,
-0.0011282749,
0.0131020593,
0.0250576716,
-0.011963998,
0.0612148158,
0.0060501797,
-0.0555531345,
0.0169317387,
0.0239811037,
0.029496938,
-0.0662752315,
-0.0167446341,
0.0693176687,
-0.0450055264,
0.01106665,
-0.0259856004,
0.0167134609,
0.0363603309,
0.0101422193,
0.0653198734,
0.0062428638,
-0.0482143089,
0.0417478904,
-0.0477693304,
0.0319693573,
-0.0052822307,
0.0058854818,
-0.020872999,
0.0416261964,
-0.0220867507,
-0.0173795559,
-0.0406444333,
0.0188733861,
-0.0327677429,
-0.0165118296,
-0.0354459211,
0.0531611927,
0.0181968436,
0.0380265154,
0.017872965,
-0.0133776786,
-0.0062846523,
-0.0025336123,
-0.0486577153,
-0.0046663545,
-0.0352401771,
0.0252374243,
0.0042430093,
-0.0581967309,
-0.0374778323,
0.0370657183,
0.0141604021,
-0.0121320914,
0.0147488825,
0.081435971,
0.0450636819,
-0.0504791066,
-0.0814906061,
-0.0309887938,
0.0156696886,
-0.0498813912,
0.0226864256,
-0.0297682323,
0.0091488175,
-0.0058007939,
0.0125963185,
0.0107097551,
0.0185367279,
0.0138748195,
-0.0212856792,
0.0789093077,
-0.0112749357,
0.0241639186,
-0.0092031769,
-0.0240962263,
0.0152177624,
0.0679809451,
0.0049904664,
0.011611307,
0.0526954979,
0.0111292731,
0.0247157253,
0.0365549177,
-0.0024839747,
0.0244314987,
-0.0249373335,
0.0010765884,
0.0020173781,
0.0332485475,
0.0155495591,
0.0458283275,
0.0062683742,
0.0138595738,
0.0219866429,
0.0873362124,
0.0455834568,
-0.0048069521,
0.0876668245,
-0.0251951348,
0.0089747505,
0.0417833924,
-0.0534220077,
0.002051322,
-0.0538428761,
0.0099898875,
0.0248378217,
0.0341572203,
-0.0321693011,
-0.0578446798,
-0.0124522243,
-0.0133358492,
-0.0191693865,
-0.0011605439,
0.0329449587,
0.0282681528,
-0.037505772,
0.0072433613,
0.0054787938,
-0.016286388,
0.0021941408,
-0.089204438,
0.0230898727,
0.0640563071,
0.0428470485,
-0.0398562737,
0.0033132243,
-0.0212971326,
0.0354872607,
0.0288132895,
0.0277307741,
-0.0066120452,
-0.0181208253,
-0.0339979753,
-0.0353648178,
0.0083786994,
0.0247751959,
-0.0132497242,
0.0232387558,
0.0007289273,
0.0164302588,
0.0140150916,
-0.0160099491,
0.0687919408,
-0.0397623479,
-0.064481616,
0.0334537216,
0.0040737991,
0.0098224431,
0.0471456423,
-0.0033356152,
0.0323271453,
0.0448004827,
-0.0186349116,
-0.0044180788,
-0.0195864551,
-0.0468578674,
-0.0744119287,
0.0274752155,
0.0283102673,
-0.0261826534,
-0.0241790153,
-0.0515476502,
-0.0471340865,
-0.0289135408,
-0.0247298367,
0.0432422347,
-0.0460627973,
0.0298023149,
0.0471887626,
-0.0068528331,
-0.0598550849,
0.0579046309,
0.0030254244,
0.0286366921,
0.0676136315,
0.0188780762,
-0.0056225406,
-0.0526904687,
-0.0209971387,
-0.011774932,
0.0297521129,
-0.0027728053,
0.0098290406,
0.0359218828,
-0.0550782643,
-0.0313907899,
-0.0469333827,
-0.0012094117,
-0.0514642522,
0.0152665088,
-0.0128768468,
0.0096560642,
-0.0396657474,
-0.039133355,
-0.0316618681,
-0.0029390471,
0.0426630974,
0.0437840335,
0.0527830869,
0.0054335566,
-0.0101134414,
-0.0125950295,
-0.0163318813,
-0.0073655071,
0.0328026526,
0.0124882329,
-0.0527875833,
-0.0750277862,
0.0363641009,
-0.0083370032,
0.0238435511,
-0.0091382004,
-0.0005428338,
0.0078915162,
-0.0440373421,
0.0601857714,
0.0292647704,
-0.0022522297,
0.035796348,
0.0356734879,
-0.0240407325,
-0.0665677413,
-0.0013530549,
-0.0532343052,
-0.0316312797,
-0.0067167846,
-0.0033846579,
0.0504134633,
0.0419114716,
-0.0008722401,
-0.0228933115,
-0.0203668177,
-0.0084303636,
-0.0031841455,
-0.0220081266,
-0.0115911104,
-0.0225703381,
-0.0374922678,
0.052143991,
0.0180139206,
-0.0909201056,
0.0674692616,
-0.0415892042,
-0.0092565883,
-0.0069911182,
-0.0272410605,
-0.0649277791,
0.0315488428,
-0.0063689952,
-0.0270018522,
0.0075549283,
-0.0526569523,
-0.0083770677,
0.0045004161,
-0.0115138683,
-0.0193491913,
0.0550649017,
-0.0139492853,
0.0387278795,
0.0193280783,
0.0136005254,
-0.0645484254,
-0.0719172731,
-0.0136524783,
-0.0078127719,
-0.0273441002,
0.0151532786,
0.001810523,
-0.0009232172,
0.0068742605,
0.0096015157,
0.0059322016,
0.0015653967,
-0.0398073718,
0.0218114965,
0.0237096716,
0.0389295481,
0.0185328964,
-0.0245262906,
0.0519492365,
0.0063638319,
0.0293119978,
-0.009845553,
-0.0297538321,
0.044386901,
0.0501962826,
-0.0572693497,
-0.0108124381,
0.0200938005,
0.0406161174,
-0.0559896603,
0.0144919846,
0.1112358496,
0.028279569,
-0.0453613549,
0.0001600113,
-0.0017341925,
0.0064598513,
0.0194550212,
0.0155091416,
-0.0966023952,
-0.024272887,
0.0204138421,
0.0164005067,
-0.0237979032,
-0.0277224146,
-0.0381147452,
-0.1046054065,
0.0567241721,
0.0014176373,
0.0385092571,
-0.0075594969,
-0.0476722792,
0.0106948838,
0.0084518008,
0.0075413059,
-0.0005448492,
-0.0620451197,
-0.0161214545,
0.0254619643,
-0.0260090996,
-0.0577325411,
-0.042089384,
-0.0415023081,
0.0775820613,
0.0859800726,
-0.0015338471,
0.0049341582,
-0.0181606505,
0.0465978868,
-0.0119577404,
0.0480148084,
-0.067525059,
0.0011122951,
-0.0327732638,
-0.0010711136,
-0.0099949492,
0.0235234722,
-0.0195429716,
-0.0156559832,
0.0161876176,
0.1048490852,
-0.0737358555,
-0.0115216281,
-0.0229981225,
0.0352603905,
0.0396505184,
0.0800849497,
0.0434899405,
-0.0101148654,
-0.0162588675,
-0.0186693985,
-0.0146222608,
0.0127037363,
-0.0291836783,
0.0034256603,
-0.0432015024,
-0.00250366,
-0.0661747307,
-0.0473593734,
0.0527850948,
0.0201352183,
0.0170429274,
0.0301351268,
-0.0255806278,
-0.0166388024,
0.0021537254,
0.0454581268,
-0.0159504917,
0.0023756495,
-0.0900417641,
-0.0244106725,
0.0709697455,
-0.014337101,
0.0075020897,
-0.0026415144,
-0.0651103929,
-0.0963290557,
-0.018317325,
0.0531196147,
0.0240394399,
0.0524157137,
0.0049848841,
-0.040071696,
0.0484274924,
0.049209293,
-0.0036501042,
0.0185673144,
0.0288052522,
0.0608590804,
-0.0039489511,
0.0404651873,
-0.0266180318,
0.0266503841,
0.0015542523,
0.0696297735,
-0.0352832302,
-0.0810217559,
0.0227755643,
0.0354285948,
0.0708213821,
-0.0204639416,
-0.0074731759,
-0.0540707745,
0.0074744956,
-0.0115565434,
-0.0265396144,
-0.0422993638,
0.0471246652,
-0.0112245074,
-0.0048624682,
-0.0349972546,
-0.014564258,
-0.0550963208,
0.0448652282,
-0.0378812999,
0.0597103573,
0.0160457883,
-0.0367637314,
0.0226627849,
0.0201859362,
-0.0059570489,
0.0631702244,
0.0212505292,
0.0114480779,
-0.0062332265,
0.0618265942,
0.0310390126,
0.0321592279,
-0.0376272835,
0.0209249146,
-0.0666190535,
-0.0610359944,
0.0182509348,
0.0669491217,
0.0453401431,
-0.0232572816,
0.0201993361,
-0.0163829494,
-0.0038891737,
0.0127916988,
0.0357101634,
0.0216924939,
0.0023482011,
0.0417339802,
0.0176298581,
-0.0456410088,
0.0201155487,
0.0226052701,
-0.0359884538,
0.046330113,
0.0208002068,
0.0077002291,
-0.0384430289,
-0.0275459867,
0.0383539423,
-0.0290052686,
-0.0150627755,
0.027409805,
-0.0279070549,
-0.0383172259,
0.0093437536,
-0.0003917032,
-0.0365672,
-0.0233747587,
0.0497130863,
0.0427897871,
0.0287978556,
0.0221631415,
-0.0391848162,
-0.021181073,
-0.0000538232,
-0.0734750777,
-0.0055859513,
-6.176333111e-33,
-0.0294610932,
-0.0365079753,
0.0470339209,
-0.0134010334,
-0.0375201553,
-0.0024776328,
0.0070154918,
-0.0244433284,
0.0018452276,
-0.0123654353,
-0.06608098,
-0.0153085701,
0.0312720351,
-0.0104117002,
0.0200843513,
-0.0373060293,
0.0437374189,
-0.0365732349,
-0.0034829127,
-0.0178414918,
-0.0042177076,
0.0427378118,
0.0331581086,
-0.0088453153,
0.0592096001,
0.0126809431,
-0.0208452344,
0.0499911718,
-0.0172252841,
0.0256098993,
-0.0519969389,
0.0211697482,
0.0273414664,
-0.0100509422,
-0.0367262699,
0.0900305137,
-0.0769760013,
-0.0613734834,
0.0397887118,
-0.006336573,
-0.0467083715,
-0.0139081003,
0.0177824181,
-0.0340239219,
-0.0325888135,
0.0438095629,
0.0187063143,
-0.0192128643,
-0.0131339999,
-0.0415387824,
-0.0305181481,
0.02335063,
0.0287016165,
-0.0188301746,
0.0544386134,
0.0429693535,
-0.0153671904,
0.0300140046,
-0.0091973646,
0.0385115556,
0.0569308959,
0.0457466654,
0.01702483,
0.0181230456,
-0.0037480628,
0.0390085429,
-0.0117578488,
-0.0168953016,
-0.0299877301,
0.0044684689,
-0.0038527374,
0.0317829438,
-0.010373624,
-0.0222452953,
0.0135709075,
0.0156786274,
-0.0211941823,
0.0178490765,
0.0309669096,
0.0172443036,
-0.0094671194,
-0.0162363537,
-0.0408645496,
-0.0162915029,
-0.0263697263,
-0.0094233118,
-0.0244169459,
-0.0306330416,
0.0320526995,
0.0514186919,
-0.0057245512,
-0.0003874044,
0.0198071152,
-0.0227987431,
-0.029831145,
-0.0222137719,
0.0339453854,
-0.0048431433,
-0.012789527,
0.0100072343,
-0.0407994315,
-0.0381431431,
0.0059170211,
-0.038015306,
0.0124054272,
-0.026592873,
-0.0080534592,
0.0365066715,
-0.0852737948,
0.0037029067,
-0.0065972232,
0.0564591251,
0.0117972959,
0.0071533453,
0.0247187987,
0.0109309563,
-0.0073666051,
0.0722021461,
-0.0097665321,
-0.0428200737,
-0.0072010062,
0.0060214074,
0.0096261539,
0.0391483568,
-0.0479575172,
0.0148047674,
-0.0057491423,
0.0567459576,
0.0443383567,
-0.0440536775,
-0.0011001648,
0.0187752116,
2.587e-7,
0.0175151546,
0.0475828983,
0.0505501404,
0.0363099799,
-0.0216197781,
-0.0116432505,
-0.048091583,
-0.0026973644,
-0.000579346,
-0.0160240605,
0.031033624,
0.0074215448,
0.0461542904,
-0.0128176659,
-0.0896157622,
-0.000380995,
-0.0581828058,
-0.0186998453,
-0.0728072673,
-0.0199050754,
0.0661497489,
0.0665785745,
-0.011725923,
-0.0092979278,
-0.0278264135,
-0.038341023,
0.0341494977,
-0.0546059199,
-0.0164546371,
0.0117815798,
0.0761926696,
-0.0034437694,
0.0025870965,
0.0026457638,
-0.0007923928,
0.0356894284,
-0.0367527343,
0.0560599752,
0.0350647084,
-0.0534084663,
0.0088455835,
-0.0064888867,
-0.0014257699,
0.0125423167,
0.0592706241,
-0.0388982929,
-0.0054783672,
-0.0559893735,
-0.0072683119,
-0.0457570441,
0.0109112402,
-0.0368766896,
-0.0026850086,
0.0322139896,
0.0235829242,
0.0089334948,
-0.0315678976,
-0.1021864861,
0.011473123,
-0.0093901325,
-0.0362243205,
-0.041573301,
-0.0233721063,
0.0346530974,
0.0229232218,
-0.0705552623,
-0.0342725255,
2.488279784e-34,
0.0495633706,
-0.0362620167,
0.0183448102,
0.0707842186,
-0.0042497371,
0.0163909458,
-0.041941274,
0.0373026133,
0.0305059776,
-0.1154329926,
-0.037264131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02179v1 | Training Chain-of-Thought via Latent-Variable Inference | 2023-11-28T17:47:32 | 2023-11-28T17:47:32 | Du Phan, Matthew D. Hoffman, David Dohan, Sholto Douglas, Tuan Anh Le, Aaron Parisi, Pavel Sountsov, Charles Sutton, Sharad Vikram, Rif A. Saurous | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) solve problems more accurately and interpretably
when instructed to work out the answer step by step using a
``chain-of-thought'' (CoT) prompt. One can also improve LLMs' performance on a
specific task by supervised fine-tuning, i.e., by using gradient ascent on some
tunable parameters to maximize the average log-likelihood of correct answers
from a labeled training set. Naively combining CoT with supervised tuning
requires supervision not just of the correct answers, but also of detailed
rationales that lead to those answers; these rationales are expensive to
produce by hand. Instead, we propose a fine-tuning strategy that tries to
maximize the \emph{marginal} log-likelihood of generating a correct answer
using CoT prompting, approximately averaging over all possible rationales. The
core challenge is sampling from the posterior over rationales conditioned on
the correct answer; we address it using a simple Markov-chain Monte Carlo
(MCMC) expectation-maximization (EM) algorithm inspired by the self-taught
reasoner (STaR), memoized wake-sleep, Markovian score climbing, and persistent
contrastive divergence. This algorithm also admits a novel control-variate
technique that drives the variance of our gradient estimates to zero as the
model improves. Applying our technique to GSM8K and the tasks in BIG-Bench
Hard, we find that this MCMC-EM fine-tuning technique typically improves the
model's accuracy on held-out examples more than STaR or prompt-tuning with or
without CoT. | [
0.0326563418,
0.0761898085,
0.0095530786,
0.0059002005,
-0.0469300486,
0.0444258563,
0.0051231347,
-0.0229976866,
-0.0095154596,
-0.0363142043,
0.0009001875,
-0.0359449536,
-0.0056332243,
-0.0023192191,
0.0471060909,
-0.033613164,
-0.0023135974,
-0.0881774947,
0.0282254349,
-0.0330277607,
-0.0314806402,
0.0193127692,
-0.0398286469,
0.0239001252,
0.0155689381,
-0.0307995137,
-0.0322672501,
-0.0070763356,
0.0393934846,
-0.0312802419,
-0.0441639423,
0.0559276491,
0.0316876695,
0.0138582028,
0.0000023413,
-0.0555584542,
-0.0102191539,
-0.0236464944,
-0.0484993011,
0.0017084245,
-0.0406219177,
0.0131709445,
0.0184227005,
0.0228892229,
-0.0081811575,
-0.0177753065,
0.0321749039,
0.0317952298,
0.0281816032,
0.0635885075,
0.0165685434,
-0.0359872021,
0.0091760559,
-0.0350164957,
0.0454269312,
-0.065993689,
0.0436806902,
0.0394754037,
-0.0304916557,
0.014219352,
-0.0130659109,
0.0082081053,
0.0159868486,
0.0045018732,
0.0132592563,
0.0600045174,
0.0265221391,
0.0085880449,
0.0075571495,
0.0445440412,
-0.0106749022,
-0.0367522575,
0.0115860822,
-0.0436721109,
-0.0216483492,
0.0378001444,
-0.0440081246,
0.0442074537,
-0.0272827614,
0.0372164659,
0.0581190586,
-0.0147928391,
0.0407848731,
-0.0065818098,
-0.0505648516,
0.0529780276,
0.0181263722,
-0.0294400211,
0.0551710762,
0.0402475297,
-0.0514953397,
-0.0785910934,
-0.0172035769,
0.0112498133,
-0.0262172818,
0.0167154912,
-0.0064734817,
-0.0303279106,
-0.0383782201,
0.0077872807,
0.040184062,
0.0590024702,
0.0251271613,
0.0510625802,
-0.0134584634,
0.0082134893,
-0.0239327569,
-0.0155375591,
-0.0320790969,
0.0128028626,
-0.0628634617,
0.000761774,
-0.0095764697,
0.0306315031,
-0.0043939846,
0.0114219198,
-0.037578389,
0.0141185401,
0.0100839632,
-0.0106757805,
0.0343357846,
0.0268129446,
-0.0300965905,
-0.0153038558,
-0.0477668643,
0.0219202079,
-0.0667279512,
0.0277358405,
0.0494810455,
-0.003155336,
-0.0169390813,
0.0057045431,
0.0146817816,
-0.025162233,
0.038142439,
0.0392006487,
-0.0313111655,
-0.0194443446,
-0.0503005907,
-0.0100254565,
-0.0282611605,
-0.0827979669,
0.0335440598,
-0.0654481724,
0.0002659872,
0.010127767,
0.0049554664,
-0.0027951556,
0.0196634009,
-0.0002007857,
-0.0266239271,
0.0635327026,
0.0357263759,
-0.0059827459,
0.0348194279,
-0.0067603784,
-0.0305601228,
0.0590948053,
0.0288093816,
0.0279358868,
0.015113363,
0.0019553131,
0.0271284338,
0.0306013227,
0.0073745525,
-0.0024126798,
0.0034060723,
-0.0009202635,
-0.0002112824,
0.0458483621,
0.0395376123,
0.0163472854,
-0.0292859655,
0.0131863626,
0.0592230745,
0.0378721245,
-0.0188310407,
-0.008942727,
0.0609654039,
-0.0238329899,
0.0130834077,
0.0281351171,
-0.0439687148,
0.0292788371,
-0.0160748102,
0.0195277613,
0.067685239,
0.0076309028,
-0.0291382931,
-0.0392583236,
0.0240068045,
0.0169550031,
-0.0549648739,
0.0603991225,
0.0860451981,
-0.0190939046,
-0.0411694311,
0.0041912305,
0.0341698043,
0.0126573257,
-0.0190805439,
-0.0531959422,
0.0450414978,
0.0250819679,
0.0310411379,
0.0040249689,
0.0113164783,
-0.0235907733,
0.0139350863,
0.0141388457,
0.0151322428,
-0.0101703862,
0.0100810537,
-0.0452203527,
-0.0245338716,
-0.0017709433,
0.0268113706,
0.0333095454,
-0.0099141896,
0.0096296975,
-0.0052847923,
-0.0347459614,
0.001865302,
0.010093281,
-0.0068979231,
-0.0693827718,
0.0274370424,
0.0066934074,
0.0601034015,
0.004798423,
-0.0166657977,
0.0275053438,
-0.0033156341,
-0.0488393903,
-0.0124478983,
-0.0067861779,
-0.0707188994,
-0.0417856202,
0.0263663139,
-0.0413853452,
-0.0336206667,
-0.0227630716,
-0.0375039876,
-0.0597420596,
0.0155994911,
-0.0066001099,
0.021062078,
-0.0138851954,
0.0290356781,
0.0196670629,
-0.0132895401,
-0.0395973846,
0.0953966156,
-0.0241576303,
-0.0013807404,
0.02914262,
0.0371668153,
-0.0082265167,
-0.0383359715,
0.0255013779,
-0.0039238245,
0.0354213007,
-0.0180932954,
0.0097350376,
0.0053963466,
-0.0555785485,
-0.0086916154,
-0.100902006,
0.0056413808,
-0.0201100092,
0.0454416014,
0.0125772906,
0.0125705637,
-0.0076911761,
0.0166014694,
-0.0274348278,
0.0165460017,
-0.0163359381,
0.0164153259,
-0.0092167789,
0.0052870209,
0.0030524449,
-0.0356557555,
-0.0221099369,
-0.0347999036,
0.0455137305,
-0.0011920958,
0.0159166642,
-0.0425575003,
0.0105488971,
-0.0176647324,
0.0224839691,
-0.035291031,
-0.0110613015,
0.0350962207,
-0.0440621451,
0.1142089963,
0.0929219946,
0.0176580958,
0.0032005894,
0.0662267879,
-0.0243574101,
-0.0336438492,
0.0146102058,
-0.036409162,
-0.0428272299,
-0.01446559,
-0.0419177786,
-0.0166879315,
0.1040364504,
0.0171944499,
0.0095771663,
-0.0601603501,
0.0104688052,
0.0059837955,
-0.034410283,
-0.027459465,
0.020057898,
-0.0254017301,
0.0619744509,
0.0078304363,
-0.0321732126,
0.1161182001,
-0.0357227474,
0.0180597268,
-0.0495647378,
-0.0111335581,
-0.0016720665,
0.0620495416,
-0.004941334,
-0.0217329487,
0.0298650712,
0.0102480231,
-0.0489232391,
-0.0104973307,
0.0422937497,
-0.0263013262,
0.0165579859,
-0.0774061009,
0.010344211,
0.008303999,
-0.0360030234,
-0.0213367213,
-0.0071464567,
-0.0754328966,
-0.0325888619,
0.0208152123,
-0.006009012,
-0.0173034109,
-0.0029186206,
0.0439802371,
0.0088472124,
-0.0178232659,
-0.0218531433,
-0.008615491,
0.0305516627,
0.0687552094,
-0.0055839694,
0.031189993,
-0.0489651375,
0.0552669987,
0.0301985256,
0.0584876314,
0.020923242,
-0.0164389387,
0.0083412584,
0.0136977416,
0.0045666941,
-0.0179755706,
0.0470637456,
0.0644515082,
-0.0445736162,
-0.0287050661,
0.1136444658,
0.003749548,
-0.0728409365,
-0.0147221927,
-0.0208954383,
0.0570006147,
-0.011709475,
0.0320496634,
-0.0720521063,
-0.046745155,
0.0210743565,
0.0585925169,
-0.032022506,
-0.0492125228,
0.0177165102,
-0.1190309972,
0.0221698787,
-0.0030016066,
-0.0287024044,
-0.0102380477,
-0.0758755282,
0.0067516672,
-0.0121248588,
-0.0156752355,
0.0171089265,
0.0022966086,
0.035386581,
0.0339232646,
0.0250635482,
-0.0187438503,
0.0333312117,
-0.0350861475,
0.0393845886,
0.0415898524,
-0.0212356411,
0.0189713202,
-0.041805502,
0.0375578701,
-0.0542299226,
-0.003040672,
-0.0188616812,
-0.0016751317,
-0.0299788155,
-0.021092115,
-0.0486306846,
0.085697718,
-0.006075969,
-0.0202311445,
0.0376058929,
0.0919350237,
-0.0323293656,
-0.0438617654,
0.0026745028,
0.0106864888,
-0.001225938,
0.0746013671,
0.0369896367,
-0.0762868598,
-0.0398287512,
-0.0447550081,
-0.0018901302,
-0.0178362913,
-0.0200047623,
-0.0148850279,
0.0157938953,
0.0072661703,
-0.0348624699,
-0.0228105672,
0.0447761714,
0.0735303536,
-0.0102737844,
0.0225522183,
0.0193024687,
0.013969386,
-0.013708137,
0.0343653187,
-0.0586273111,
-0.0078562628,
-0.044912491,
-0.0124921706,
0.0337852836,
-0.0444758609,
-0.0121117728,
0.0070099542,
-0.0953225791,
-0.0651787892,
-0.0346870348,
0.0703810081,
0.023447264,
0.0687729567,
0.0004744114,
-0.0502951667,
0.0193135832,
-0.0030689412,
-0.0091888523,
0.0259298384,
0.0144164488,
0.0227745175,
0.0070699067,
0.0243604891,
-0.0360851958,
-0.0000213196,
0.0257115178,
0.0666205212,
-0.0175309069,
-0.0351322256,
0.0285946112,
-0.028156992,
0.0561175533,
-0.0223893616,
-0.0111936489,
-0.0436271429,
0.021620933,
-0.0144861285,
-0.0034869395,
-0.0432219319,
0.0143131884,
0.0302092005,
0.001661983,
0.0169816781,
-0.0437979698,
0.0113977566,
0.020526927,
-0.028417863,
-0.0171829108,
-0.0081899175,
0.0466682352,
0.0457066819,
-0.0307461899,
-0.0387769677,
0.0009562161,
0.0145805813,
0.0444345511,
-0.0020339305,
0.1079432145,
0.0497609004,
-0.0356241502,
-0.0186885875,
-0.0272848438,
-0.0900392905,
-0.0728213042,
-0.0053307917,
0.034408439,
0.072783865,
-0.0104771564,
0.0396339111,
-0.045094233,
-0.0029236837,
0.0032434035,
0.0339422934,
0.0282455981,
0.0079931607,
0.0322360806,
0.0377374031,
0.0017464111,
0.0305273402,
0.0702123418,
0.0458310097,
0.0346644893,
0.0226000492,
0.0011617565,
-0.0285822507,
-0.0179153718,
-0.0581656434,
0.0445538945,
-0.021834271,
0.0095872041,
-0.04360741,
-0.079868637,
-0.0493065231,
0.0388156585,
-0.0257033966,
-0.0016874615,
0.0510334373,
0.0610869527,
-0.0217792671,
-0.0447280593,
-0.0274884831,
0.0549740419,
-0.0018749833,
-0.0239488296,
-0.0216005184,
-7.331385615e-33,
-0.0060403962,
-0.0286264792,
0.0197392702,
0.0215486214,
-0.0040952931,
-0.0144349355,
-0.0580762289,
0.0102135558,
0.0016879302,
0.0160142537,
-0.0394241251,
-0.0066482136,
0.0174813755,
0.0403595418,
0.0218375716,
-0.0099568302,
0.042968709,
-0.010669536,
-0.029886838,
0.0291847326,
0.017400153,
0.0107412003,
0.0420728028,
-0.057403218,
0.0144452006,
-0.0168157127,
-0.002253742,
0.0478043668,
-0.0245989114,
0.0466257595,
-0.0304471999,
0.0018611151,
0.0103678433,
-0.0660441294,
0.0014305951,
-0.0036291701,
-0.0946080312,
-0.0225051846,
0.0289599262,
-0.0266276933,
-0.0814544335,
-0.0379273519,
0.0014374374,
0.02515129,
0.0027351761,
-0.0198026355,
0.0038275917,
-0.0199605525,
-0.0220331419,
-0.0232149865,
-0.0013081121,
0.0092977872,
-0.0070912256,
0.0069958484,
-0.008863057,
-0.0081642559,
-0.0119760465,
0.0306368358,
-0.0029492921,
-0.0063164248,
0.0243530851,
0.0140745165,
0.0608330183,
0.056276314,
0.0311325435,
0.051008705,
0.0225347094,
-0.0387480147,
-0.0504816398,
-0.007781079,
-0.0143803367,
0.0093928445,
0.0321382992,
0.0114095779,
0.0592794493,
0.0531966053,
-0.0980598629,
0.0070919851,
0.0401322171,
0.0185525771,
0.0432179458,
0.0079954416,
-0.0221889149,
-0.022603156,
-0.0704006776,
-0.0133866007,
-0.043485526,
-0.0045430716,
0.0356330983,
0.0102325613,
-0.035780251,
-0.0424272902,
0.0454960503,
-0.0097419322,
-0.0001747685,
-0.004363359,
0.0059535555,
0.0047880569,
-0.0086542983,
0.0231282823,
-0.0706475824,
0.0069225938,
0.0135774501,
0.0062833708,
0.0111989295,
0.0273945648,
-0.0143703306,
-0.0183089804,
-0.027391443,
-0.0075506293,
-0.0641294345,
0.0021891294,
-0.0044827694,
0.0267341267,
0.0474657863,
-0.0139396153,
0.0064755622,
0.0500142425,
-0.0033662303,
-0.0119603416,
0.0055325599,
-0.013714293,
0.005166132,
0.0208465233,
-0.0190378372,
0.0100284917,
-0.0125977155,
-0.0177477617,
0.0329326577,
-0.0535907261,
-0.0228162277,
0.0712463632,
3.073e-7,
0.0095040146,
0.0185471028,
-0.0016590444,
0.0043002232,
0.0054983781,
0.0541905761,
0.0067124451,
-0.0373851992,
0.0587255992,
-0.0615337826,
0.0117354291,
0.0511751585,
0.0399160236,
0.0168544706,
-0.077012606,
-0.0387916565,
-0.0366905183,
0.0020066407,
-0.038666334,
-0.0302850083,
0.0546175353,
0.0926891938,
0.0135605922,
-0.0118505824,
0.0186128132,
-0.0033148297,
0.0539270081,
-0.0295035578,
0.0063848966,
-0.0051570199,
0.0192086827,
0.0038482635,
-0.0054180324,
0.0379355215,
-0.0076674526,
-0.0019164297,
-0.0263621565,
0.0610427372,
0.0385928527,
-0.0197629575,
-0.0071195224,
-0.0059686834,
0.0233128462,
-0.0521459952,
0.0941956714,
-0.0630981252,
-0.038663175,
-0.0249978248,
-0.0296028685,
-0.0559317581,
0.00882251,
-0.0107213045,
0.0018690594,
0.0054846969,
-0.0050592837,
0.0247047693,
-0.004707756,
-0.0699759275,
-0.0000696584,
0.0340767577,
-0.0316418968,
-0.045205228,
-0.0350793786,
-0.0081017064,
0.0374834761,
-0.0673570409,
-0.0225309208,
3.030735529e-34,
0.0409593806,
-0.0298749823,
0.0200033803,
0.0217655897,
0.0230548177,
-0.0109002301,
-0.0367583148,
-0.0109578231,
0.0417264476,
-0.1396758556,
-0.0420299955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16989v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16989v4 | ChatGPT's One-year Anniversary: Are Open-Source Large Language Models Catching up? | 2023-11-28T17:44:51 | 2024-01-15T09:55:05 | Hailin Chen, Fangkai Jiao, Xingxuan Li, Chengwei Qin, Mathieu Ravaut, Ruochen Zhao, Caiming Xiong, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL | Upon its release in late 2022, ChatGPT has brought a seismic shift in the
entire landscape of AI, both in research and commerce. Through
instruction-tuning a large language model (LLM) with supervised fine-tuning and
reinforcement learning from human feedback, it showed that a model could answer
human questions and follow instructions on a broad panel of tasks. Following
this success, interests in LLMs have intensified, with new LLMs flourishing at
frequent interval across academia and industry, including many start-ups
focused on LLMs. While closed-source LLMs (e.g., OpenAI's GPT, Anthropic's
Claude) generally outperform their open-source counterparts, the progress on
the latter has been rapid with claims of achieving parity or even better on
certain tasks. This has crucial implications not only on research but also on
business. In this work, on the first anniversary of ChatGPT, we provide an
exhaustive overview of this success, surveying all tasks where an open-source
LLM has claimed to be on par or better than ChatGPT. | [
0.0431338847,
0.0607009269,
-0.0169703402,
0.0479449369,
-0.0574076474,
0.0045455368,
-0.004200594,
0.0007783037,
0.0338521339,
-0.0324589908,
-0.0639111176,
-0.0052362327,
-0.0234906413,
0.049585253,
0.0050520138,
-0.0137284575,
0.0474051908,
-0.0479029827,
-0.0110157095,
-0.0165833682,
-0.0136082219,
0.019751573,
-0.029812891,
0.0657267272,
0.0458386876,
-0.0248011611,
-0.0225138459,
-0.0090292171,
-0.0035721317,
-0.0035059717,
0.0208665747,
0.039851401,
0.0228366628,
0.069727838,
0.0000020518,
-0.0720031932,
0.0022228453,
-0.0066163791,
-0.0281736571,
0.0385251641,
0.0368371569,
0.0104260333,
-0.0146396877,
0.0305097066,
-0.045762863,
-0.0117617473,
0.045324292,
0.0303351283,
0.0532282852,
0.0928328559,
0.0168864336,
-0.0277672503,
0.047622446,
-0.0379750691,
-0.0000307982,
-0.0727475137,
0.0182757787,
-0.0162780434,
0.0353913009,
0.0108629176,
-0.0338866338,
0.0326267853,
0.0423657373,
-0.0149995005,
-0.0268431883,
0.059823446,
-0.0618803725,
-0.006233295,
-0.0575019903,
0.0750960484,
0.0053542391,
-0.0162454043,
0.0139221922,
-0.0097375084,
0.0054699727,
-0.0214049704,
-0.0356930345,
0.0482124835,
0.0217601694,
0.0277088322,
0.0201230943,
-0.0214015488,
0.0206552055,
0.0363284945,
-0.0067995167,
0.0727316812,
-0.0018377496,
-0.0499895625,
0.0380674154,
-0.0047324826,
-0.037724562,
-0.0430219658,
-0.0227316003,
0.0413970836,
-0.0202898066,
0.0014173915,
-0.0309937689,
0.031292025,
0.0083954437,
-0.0310815722,
0.0112694427,
0.0669933334,
-0.0161028709,
0.0659466609,
-0.0116042728,
0.074754566,
-0.0311854351,
0.0252573751,
-0.0381340571,
0.0194688179,
-0.0571669862,
0.0087093404,
-0.0571271367,
0.0244270284,
-0.038271863,
-0.0352601185,
-0.034975756,
0.0256659221,
-0.0024168249,
0.0308122598,
0.0349278264,
-0.0018959643,
-0.0277171806,
-0.0303220358,
-0.027128838,
0.0324435309,
-0.0305613186,
0.0032912898,
0.0136056803,
-0.0602089278,
0.0052448488,
0.0309156552,
-0.0323065147,
-0.0277033374,
0.0248994622,
0.0827163681,
0.0098452875,
-0.0250437185,
-0.0375683457,
-0.0060466561,
-0.0067937132,
-0.0964445621,
-0.0189705789,
-0.0414399095,
0.010218963,
0.0009986826,
-0.0048293467,
-0.0180628989,
0.0055271052,
0.0076901033,
-0.0454699546,
0.0401570387,
0.015016322,
0.0129482066,
0.030499313,
-0.0086521311,
-0.0022516535,
0.0777994618,
0.0410639532,
0.0359412879,
0.0233044457,
-0.0090423226,
0.0168207064,
0.0650023594,
-0.0067478316,
0.0126927057,
0.0179138388,
0.0188635793,
0.0172006004,
0.050635457,
0.0142971277,
0.0584307536,
-0.0243506394,
-0.002680908,
0.0637614429,
0.0478274897,
-0.0011019866,
0.0212969165,
0.0387968905,
0.0309440102,
0.0194912888,
-0.0190790724,
-0.0633119866,
0.0096273692,
-0.0221596491,
0.0084143942,
-0.0084353676,
0.0121465735,
-0.0275155306,
-0.0304756276,
0.0102095967,
-0.0090863891,
-0.0009253806,
0.0200031325,
0.0520978644,
-0.0284394957,
-0.0616247728,
0.0164162796,
0.0435539,
-0.0148207275,
-0.0150888413,
-0.0917547196,
0.0278018061,
0.060887333,
0.0498759374,
-0.027856987,
-0.0207333863,
-0.0247687232,
0.005376962,
0.0607124902,
0.0757274553,
0.0022344836,
-0.0068481942,
-0.0509209074,
-0.0050494657,
-0.0373230316,
0.0059873397,
0.0346805193,
0.0352530442,
0.0300064106,
-0.0268549323,
-0.0060261744,
-0.0229966622,
0.0223378073,
-0.0189732369,
-0.0317976065,
-0.0070211063,
-0.002880676,
0.0280633364,
0.007115664,
-0.0168322995,
0.0047205403,
0.018626729,
-0.010319449,
-0.0151313376,
-0.0083157541,
-0.0139135942,
-0.0033963043,
0.0310810693,
-0.005331805,
-0.0284186341,
0.0215743855,
-0.0616819337,
-0.0287569724,
0.0164241213,
0.0148411607,
0.0554870814,
-0.0240291208,
-0.0070546567,
-0.0168119445,
-0.0026754327,
-0.0368650854,
0.0414156802,
0.001881327,
0.0103849126,
0.0144137172,
0.018146662,
0.0051803715,
-0.0523698218,
-0.0249474514,
0.0314643905,
-0.0005292764,
0.0341981463,
0.0249254648,
0.0598232038,
-0.0372440219,
-0.0504834689,
-0.097842522,
0.0205644909,
-0.0286814868,
0.0125792585,
0.002492968,
-0.0040226504,
-0.0371373445,
-0.0063358089,
-0.0201327782,
0.020164961,
0.026906332,
-0.0116951996,
0.033433862,
0.006602616,
-0.0442508981,
-0.042355042,
-0.0050298586,
0.0026470227,
-0.0060359295,
0.028271053,
0.0117246816,
-0.0747199655,
0.0398487113,
-0.0320657007,
0.0427354276,
-0.0191810001,
-0.0445013046,
0.0140328277,
-0.0209906641,
0.0146150384,
0.0941592082,
-0.0126060341,
0.0364084356,
0.0227325596,
0.0094742673,
-0.0502545126,
0.0476687625,
-0.0355352536,
-0.0932904407,
-0.0483331904,
0.0086335819,
0.0186458249,
0.0625194833,
-0.0169401132,
-0.0008948293,
-0.0708410144,
-0.0035449688,
-0.0302697532,
-0.0204904657,
-0.0369504951,
0.0422779061,
-0.0263710618,
0.0393777192,
-0.0189121384,
-0.0656124949,
0.0622626655,
-0.0102089122,
-0.0012654897,
-0.0568318181,
-0.0247410014,
-0.0709906295,
0.0576374121,
-0.0173579734,
0.0161448997,
0.0001951162,
-0.0307908095,
-0.0587417707,
0.0174961537,
0.0035704088,
-0.0188748334,
0.0345803387,
-0.0457097925,
0.0305911787,
-0.0019514899,
-0.062373355,
-0.025602363,
-0.0304070935,
-0.0374762192,
0.0104531944,
0.035169322,
-0.0393541828,
-0.0555063598,
0.0051350812,
0.0103021916,
0.0323334262,
-0.0115191825,
-0.0095093641,
-0.0299603399,
-0.018225627,
0.0642115399,
0.0352123491,
0.0055869231,
-0.0303582773,
-0.0011618083,
0.0426922031,
0.0432474762,
-0.006909702,
-0.0128302881,
0.0047250721,
0.0345664173,
-0.0473272204,
-0.0029905969,
0.0349052772,
0.0285333525,
-0.0526603386,
-0.0246751625,
0.1268728077,
0.0094851451,
-0.0553877391,
0.0005551325,
-0.0008772841,
0.0489161164,
0.0165959764,
0.0482684821,
-0.1068508253,
-0.0284132846,
-0.0025956111,
0.0306125805,
0.0226834752,
-0.017009493,
-0.011953203,
-0.1437926441,
0.0759130195,
-0.0053442619,
-0.0619173348,
-0.00797904,
-0.016190039,
-0.0108202798,
-0.0515852049,
0.024330141,
0.0171446074,
-0.0127426228,
-0.0167819876,
0.0092123346,
-0.0037860561,
-0.0381301902,
0.0418160073,
-0.0397991911,
0.0783193409,
0.0726688728,
0.0175933782,
-0.0097896354,
-0.0106026148,
0.0369399078,
0.0166188404,
0.0011782828,
-0.0050861705,
0.0253367368,
-0.0181645341,
-0.0206348356,
0.0040600142,
0.0466505364,
-0.0446960889,
0.0140118711,
0.0417119674,
0.0603615865,
-0.018102916,
-0.0095379092,
0.0073072002,
-0.0149506181,
-0.0140499119,
0.0996175483,
-0.0069295559,
-0.0539927669,
-0.0676799044,
-0.0582478419,
-0.0228895396,
-0.0219672713,
-0.0353345312,
0.0003242502,
-0.012414543,
-0.0144916838,
-0.050436154,
-0.0481311344,
0.0359716713,
0.0035369706,
0.0144134071,
-0.0188125782,
0.0303351209,
0.0198316257,
-0.017800305,
0.0107247978,
-0.0572472252,
0.0196956359,
-0.1156025603,
-0.0128335422,
0.0273838602,
-0.0365069397,
-0.027742533,
0.0176465064,
-0.0909177288,
-0.0721606016,
0.0005866094,
0.0661404952,
0.0312843062,
0.025847299,
-0.0276607312,
-0.0285878722,
-0.0000101042,
0.03748459,
-0.0319244675,
0.0321275182,
0.0286747348,
0.0225262027,
-0.0121482685,
0.0430023707,
-0.0453769304,
0.0161149576,
0.0194593966,
0.0458180346,
0.0209851563,
-0.0312120784,
0.0134914927,
0.0114975488,
0.0384973623,
-0.0215172954,
0.0056635891,
-0.039826151,
0.0148226516,
0.020923553,
-0.0045024306,
-0.049106054,
-0.023500517,
0.0393883698,
-0.0112319198,
0.0087188696,
0.0011121748,
0.008664907,
0.0156671554,
-0.0523019619,
0.0023443878,
0.0117728477,
0.0256034788,
0.0480404869,
0.0079218661,
-0.0170272887,
0.0603580661,
0.0026669537,
0.0541713685,
0.0051506511,
0.0973831639,
0.0347796492,
-0.009465781,
0.0072241402,
0.0219444428,
-0.0621614344,
-0.100508377,
0.0078100003,
0.0859981179,
0.0781438798,
0.0282331984,
0.0414452404,
-0.0535738654,
-0.0210592132,
-0.024787521,
0.0323577002,
0.0013831136,
-0.0229938142,
0.0067130579,
0.0123973712,
-0.0183299575,
0.0218897574,
0.0860469937,
0.0084368559,
0.0688727871,
0.002849296,
0.0226729233,
-0.0334833935,
-0.0460357331,
-0.0059331204,
-0.00273593,
-0.0138568906,
0.0277239364,
-0.0466760285,
-0.0419119112,
-0.0459781475,
0.0298662633,
-0.0043745432,
-0.0193490777,
0.043680016,
0.044925794,
-0.0119411815,
-0.0210041329,
-0.0478100888,
0.0061211293,
-0.0464697443,
-0.0339313261,
-0.0221048668,
-6.470656326e-33,
-0.0118923867,
0.008726838,
0.0470784195,
0.0370272957,
-0.0304575562,
-0.0099141095,
-0.0183686167,
0.0052304985,
-0.0320011228,
0.0043308977,
-0.0112722963,
0.0025538788,
0.0093597639,
0.0137921106,
0.0286030937,
-0.0344951749,
0.0243481454,
-0.0160384197,
-0.0418332331,
0.0355143324,
-0.008037053,
0.0158394091,
0.0480517633,
-0.0226872843,
0.0163683705,
-0.0148726488,
-0.0178016704,
0.0325944498,
-0.0575250387,
0.0673505887,
-0.0181070454,
0.0280564167,
0.0040868674,
-0.0351194926,
0.0150721036,
-0.0119584501,
-0.0579776578,
-0.0160945542,
0.0141121475,
-0.0019641952,
-0.0352152102,
-0.0099698352,
0.0356076621,
-0.0105050802,
-0.0452576801,
0.0153154265,
0.0080968235,
-0.0200256575,
-0.0208068993,
0.0155983474,
-0.054784067,
0.0087170117,
-0.0095030321,
-0.0207816549,
-0.0035390062,
0.0089730956,
-0.0216116421,
0.0113822687,
-0.0101825325,
0.0289894938,
0.0087919096,
0.0147466138,
0.0657554716,
-0.0089847008,
0.0070805675,
0.0336466357,
0.0378473476,
0.0049680029,
-0.0001685582,
-0.0287633892,
0.0298343189,
0.0532299727,
0.0176401604,
0.0166251529,
-0.0123438109,
0.0128904739,
-0.0518917367,
-0.0043189516,
0.0462599099,
0.0432262756,
0.0044772518,
0.0207348708,
-0.0639882833,
-0.0215070844,
-0.0236018524,
0.007405513,
-0.0251461007,
-0.0211782064,
0.0570484288,
0.0111415945,
-0.0162013397,
-0.0321630128,
0.0491617434,
-0.0676044002,
-0.0148258284,
-0.0124524226,
-0.0196041279,
0.0425017662,
-0.0121611329,
0.0353504904,
-0.1081580967,
-0.0518453829,
-0.028243864,
-0.0036966801,
0.0056299646,
0.0122190444,
0.0080283778,
0.0269708894,
-0.0451417379,
0.0202582031,
-0.0293241553,
0.0395748317,
0.0195758734,
0.0052381917,
0.0213036239,
-0.0042665252,
0.0187406838,
0.0635509416,
0.0109530194,
-0.0142949224,
-0.0351591967,
-0.0364234149,
-0.0025555901,
-0.0055260565,
-0.0268233605,
0.0377255008,
-0.0366178416,
0.0300927218,
-0.0133849904,
-0.0666014701,
-0.0172985867,
0.0095490804,
2.766e-7,
0.0175466593,
0.0571747273,
0.0128393359,
0.0402051583,
0.0089391107,
0.0207773708,
-0.0290906876,
0.0148437303,
0.0085946042,
0.0277160536,
0.0091436906,
0.0504765287,
0.0573099479,
-0.0119383372,
-0.0934638754,
0.0008475045,
-0.0725723952,
0.0040467302,
-0.0829656422,
0.0047206995,
0.0204562228,
0.0938531011,
0.0229469743,
0.0034351293,
-0.0010776207,
-0.0411557294,
0.0705662221,
-0.0509578511,
-0.0172670968,
0.0490993857,
-0.0009722859,
0.0672320798,
-0.0323556736,
-0.0101521397,
0.0058477069,
0.0181923416,
0.003800469,
0.0874023139,
0.0228741504,
-0.000890167,
0.0179069471,
-0.0125266314,
-0.0085942475,
-0.0707110018,
0.0706558004,
-0.063929446,
-0.0314966105,
-0.0409717225,
0.0180827137,
-0.0463830307,
0.016652856,
-0.0341853499,
-0.0116466833,
-0.0099007133,
0.0185425431,
-0.032505583,
-0.0153179867,
-0.0656482056,
0.0084731998,
-0.0098355841,
-0.0265088398,
-0.0556769185,
-0.0386063829,
0.0246983096,
0.0169019885,
-0.0432355851,
0.001478134,
2.49848133e-34,
0.0576597378,
-0.0282738283,
0.0092129456,
0.0304983743,
0.0472868308,
0.0199435111,
0.0171070304,
0.0070984168,
0.0030523906,
-0.07675834,
-0.0274278279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16978v1 | Assessing the influence of attractor-verb distance on grammatical agreement in humans and language models | 2023-11-28T17:25:34 | 2023-11-28T17:25:34 | Christos-Nikolaos Zacharopoulos, Théo Desbordes, Mathias Sablé-Meyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Subject-verb agreement in the presence of an attractor noun located between
the main noun and the verb elicits complex behavior: judgments of
grammaticality are modulated by the grammatical features of the attractor. For
example, in the sentence "The girl near the boys likes climbing", the attractor
(boys) disagrees in grammatical number with the verb (likes), creating a
locally implausible transition probability. Here, we parametrically modulate
the distance between the attractor and the verb while keeping the length of the
sentence equal. We evaluate the performance of both humans and two artificial
neural network models: both make more mistakes when the attractor is closer to
the verb, but neural networks get close to the chance level while humans are
mostly able to overcome the attractor interference. Additionally, we report a
linear effect of attractor distance on reaction times. We hypothesize that a
possible reason for the proximity effect is the calculation of transition
probabilities between adjacent words. Nevertheless, classical models of
attraction such as the cue-based model might suffice to explain this
phenomenon, thus paving the way for new research. Data and analyses available
at https://osf.io/d4g6k | [
0.0313673094,
0.0487256795,
-0.0363807268,
-0.0083804848,
-0.0710162595,
0.0044184993,
-0.0422062464,
-0.0165701378,
-0.0446415618,
-0.0289777499,
-0.0083317515,
-0.0561453328,
0.0380282588,
-0.0287491977,
0.0333722644,
-0.0315548107,
0.0759014115,
-0.0171611886,
-0.0284270626,
0.0105479388,
0.0071389317,
-0.0264038797,
-0.0249541719,
0.0381695852,
0.0061015198,
0.0131664025,
-0.0291491132,
-0.0443325229,
0.0332113691,
-0.0283822529,
-0.0184746049,
0.0374765135,
-0.0265840441,
0.0485306308,
0.0000016863,
-0.0593103506,
0.0432044119,
-0.0228170212,
0.0375535861,
-0.0256464239,
0.0028013198,
-0.0019131008,
-0.0128015839,
-0.0017742971,
-0.0181259885,
0.0233690515,
0.0564782768,
0.0141109088,
0.0165505484,
0.0749516115,
-0.0002088682,
-0.0220357701,
0.0411111228,
-0.0206288267,
-0.0299506821,
-0.0009794608,
0.0252719466,
-0.0350278653,
-0.0003469601,
-0.0315127261,
-0.0481450334,
0.0018208589,
-0.000967746,
0.0224504881,
0.028886931,
0.0551850051,
-0.0302221011,
-0.0154473605,
-0.0043530776,
0.0333362892,
-0.0828294978,
-0.055423934,
-0.0000344623,
-0.0132051054,
0.0122195669,
0.078753598,
-0.0325672701,
0.020446606,
0.0168720912,
0.0497540459,
0.0140730506,
-0.0170630589,
-0.0186583251,
-0.0057942923,
0.0093043568,
0.0713548884,
0.0000364407,
-0.0926555246,
0.0264779143,
0.0425865166,
0.0101404032,
-0.0818030387,
0.025553409,
-0.0121273175,
-0.0030401964,
0.0221892633,
-0.0361319147,
-0.0518592484,
0.0070635234,
-0.1080512702,
0.0298718587,
-0.0041028075,
0.0022183429,
-0.0098675536,
-0.001119302,
0.0481550135,
-0.0318238661,
0.0063800062,
-0.0203368925,
0.0566953532,
-0.0238649771,
0.0025250195,
-0.0124905948,
0.0151242996,
0.0004483601,
-0.033699315,
-0.0433300324,
-0.0062450501,
0.0251532383,
-0.0388283767,
-0.0551913232,
0.0311632659,
-0.0100029754,
0.0092717716,
-0.0404510014,
-0.0005137339,
-0.0364919752,
0.0729578286,
0.0110231712,
-0.0151400631,
-0.0468299463,
0.0154245272,
0.0285383202,
-0.0269223154,
-0.0347055309,
-0.0037781151,
0.0001199406,
-0.0493630059,
-0.0234212615,
-0.0132294055,
-0.0311776213,
-0.0318164676,
0.0081013581,
-0.062106397,
0.0005082906,
0.0193481594,
-0.0349642299,
-0.0357348695,
0.0082683861,
0.0528157912,
-0.0340961032,
0.0359154902,
0.015242558,
0.0428912491,
-0.0456932187,
-0.0209196415,
0.0399329662,
0.0026175333,
0.0358914845,
0.0184342172,
0.0230960455,
-0.0171158202,
0.003914414,
0.0269611869,
0.0134129655,
-0.0296356101,
0.0041465438,
-0.0359421447,
-0.0038543716,
0.0358240306,
0.0503296368,
0.048938524,
-0.0062016379,
-0.0268720835,
0.0759439096,
0.1085109934,
-0.0451742671,
0.0113828089,
-0.0074221846,
0.0035640218,
-0.0242577177,
0.0434509292,
-0.0489581488,
0.0053324029,
-0.028257966,
0.001724864,
0.018165905,
0.0542811267,
0.0092553683,
-0.0395546295,
-0.0437832288,
0.0032485372,
0.0226709582,
-0.0428831466,
0.0154702244,
0.0299108755,
-0.0144261727,
0.0332741179,
0.0609663166,
-0.0337945595,
-0.0077679018,
-0.0028605065,
0.0271060672,
-0.0179664753,
-0.0145227388,
-0.0030972685,
-0.0153250042,
0.0076512708,
0.0059505976,
0.071648702,
0.0382181704,
0.0431425124,
-0.0226923525,
-0.0174847841,
0.0069763823,
0.0293252841,
0.0192584656,
-0.019633567,
-0.0116591072,
0.0465366319,
-0.0275612753,
0.0593302883,
-0.0276307464,
0.03498381,
0.0035276071,
0.0411810614,
-0.0256772805,
-0.0091445753,
0.0346902236,
-0.0210932158,
-0.0068059117,
0.036812488,
0.010141694,
0.0055331211,
-0.0189805627,
0.0501705483,
-0.0185419247,
-0.0182195194,
0.0283689015,
0.0256291609,
-0.0090042129,
-0.0164408311,
0.0127072455,
-0.0261909217,
0.0568497553,
-0.0597729459,
0.0480443835,
0.05272457,
0.042320624,
0.0148597956,
0.0695919096,
-0.0375885069,
0.0420998782,
-0.0062849517,
0.0543393083,
-0.0270588659,
-0.0112025971,
0.0271763559,
-0.0180516448,
-0.006072253,
-0.0437040105,
-0.034270227,
-0.0160721112,
0.0234704334,
-0.0382796228,
-0.060567908,
-0.0256539416,
-0.0301728286,
-0.0348414034,
0.0155503154,
0.0368531421,
0.0101226103,
-0.0142350867,
-0.0113058509,
0.0085247941,
-0.0124634029,
0.0452961884,
-0.0115080131,
0.0280152094,
0.0529859327,
-0.0455290005,
-0.0902070478,
-0.1091771275,
0.0133136967,
-0.0251654182,
-0.0022156762,
0.0394194834,
-0.0056366781,
-0.0365324728,
0.074466452,
-0.0350942649,
0.0330047272,
0.0215083398,
-0.043598935,
0.0435629264,
0.0267216563,
0.107725054,
0.0736141577,
0.001687294,
0.0259458516,
0.0610591285,
-0.0326674022,
-0.0543330051,
-0.0460196137,
-0.0440615937,
-0.0038901987,
-0.0173455812,
-0.0383120067,
0.0238698479,
0.1147379503,
0.0347276181,
-0.0515242778,
-0.0105703073,
0.0264054071,
-0.0379574411,
-0.0242682938,
0.0256630685,
0.0231776722,
-0.0619813539,
0.078876771,
-0.0257192012,
-0.0446208753,
0.0872092992,
0.0156969186,
0.0251533333,
-0.0483832248,
-0.013542138,
0.0037871941,
0.0124674244,
0.0237507075,
-0.0238839854,
0.0496955179,
0.006982083,
-0.0677781776,
-0.0426118635,
-0.0162051693,
0.0006715312,
0.0411109254,
-0.0650639609,
0.00660541,
0.031500075,
-0.0408984832,
-0.0247013941,
-0.0597123429,
-0.0094905635,
-0.0321704559,
-0.0350793265,
-0.0057702893,
-0.0157300513,
-0.009433886,
0.0066294651,
0.0011514119,
-0.0213405583,
-0.0235253386,
-0.0345794931,
0.0595153607,
0.0692269802,
0.0308158845,
0.012151897,
-0.0109383771,
-0.0358982421,
0.0610446744,
0.0106643466,
0.0726658106,
-0.0764272138,
-0.0016747098,
0.0119896811,
0.0073165474,
-0.0717852265,
0.0169392079,
0.0152935488,
-0.0235870816,
-0.0315268002,
0.0766117424,
0.0502316058,
0.0053107892,
0.0580326729,
-0.0710819438,
0.0556940436,
-0.0046598641,
0.0179612972,
0.0375947244,
0.0061641852,
0.0179544576,
-0.0249196347,
-0.0120665915,
0.0003016614,
0.0156800672,
-0.1024730131,
0.0153308744,
-0.014812368,
-0.0406558402,
-0.0622675382,
-0.0527815484,
0.0227122232,
0.0049473224,
0.0023420844,
0.0042420505,
-0.0052887984,
0.0506339371,
0.0086601013,
0.0158164445,
0.0083351061,
-0.0321387351,
-0.0764217004,
0.0538615435,
0.0712597668,
0.0332465731,
-0.0279892199,
-0.0435684435,
0.049176231,
0.0384846404,
0.0022363001,
0.0407473184,
-0.0132252276,
0.0517781042,
-0.0036935061,
-0.0685327724,
0.0156413764,
-0.0143739944,
-0.0265861098,
-0.0094115566,
0.0851417109,
0.0120820031,
-0.0278389566,
-0.0260180384,
0.0512946509,
-0.0289904773,
0.0524262153,
0.0467210934,
-0.0603614748,
-0.007822738,
0.0059010955,
0.0291959867,
-0.0119279418,
-0.0594219789,
-0.0412600897,
-0.0109920958,
-0.0441676341,
-0.0971740335,
-0.0464201644,
-0.0400507189,
0.0108784689,
0.0106516369,
-0.0201890655,
0.0823024362,
-0.034296032,
0.0481724553,
0.0513049141,
0.0147964722,
0.0189750977,
-0.0277959537,
0.0168981608,
0.0214255098,
0.0108958231,
-0.0381992869,
-0.0104961768,
-0.061453782,
-0.0589947924,
0.0229824558,
-0.0027057258,
0.0200073887,
0.0041420944,
0.0187598448,
-0.0425041355,
-0.054500211,
0.0232333578,
0.0098564811,
0.0629722103,
-0.0195560846,
0.0039017908,
0.0230903998,
0.0054692761,
0.0085486835,
0.0149418293,
0.0292725787,
-0.0080582146,
-0.0513457879,
-0.0410814323,
0.0191904586,
-0.000706124,
0.0746453255,
0.019751789,
0.020018708,
-0.0380102471,
-0.0282375552,
0.0243833922,
0.0058178073,
-0.0333189294,
-0.027799828,
0.0542188957,
0.0388198644,
-0.0449170098,
-0.0640117079,
-0.002505905,
-0.0081546651,
0.0033479384,
-0.0551030748,
0.0220576841,
0.0305387862,
0.0154853677,
0.026512837,
-0.0017738943,
0.0131249158,
-0.0225813426,
0.0400784798,
0.0004076195,
0.0340129249,
0.0391587839,
-0.0235110056,
0.0202971753,
-0.0081834551,
-0.0338582732,
0.0193773583,
0.0185159557,
-0.0078915162,
0.0422343984,
-0.0453293547,
0.0507620499,
-0.024220204,
0.0248105638,
-0.0103073483,
0.0041096215,
-0.0317145847,
-0.0137460744,
0.0265018623,
0.0005242456,
-0.0129485782,
-0.0110063488,
0.0551272146,
-0.0557011887,
0.0007218776,
0.017807113,
-0.0272605438,
0.0049161348,
0.0198069122,
0.0264027435,
-0.0045214891,
0.0075541073,
0.0365271829,
-0.0612035356,
-0.0561308376,
0.0165952686,
0.0123603139,
0.0253289435,
-0.0067322915,
0.0606728829,
0.04593518,
-0.0418894924,
-0.0185720995,
-0.0058903643,
0.0219216384,
-0.0180479512,
-0.0244535636,
-0.0967672914,
-5.671648203e-33,
-0.03791501,
-0.010587085,
-0.0048086154,
0.0193346832,
-0.0290374588,
-0.0558915511,
-0.0269293878,
0.0388616882,
0.0042338595,
0.0443065278,
0.0015730753,
0.0411980227,
0.0047770967,
0.0121311517,
0.0423705839,
-0.0386803113,
0.0002028143,
-0.0284204297,
-0.0053773336,
-0.0597608499,
0.0362472236,
-0.028021995,
0.0081175854,
-0.0487992875,
0.0321519934,
0.0375190116,
0.0075559327,
-0.0093280328,
-0.0513286479,
0.0101477839,
-0.0043847035,
0.0500012264,
0.0136553794,
-0.0052700844,
-0.0256328322,
0.026036948,
-0.0088994298,
-0.0732815862,
0.0427133217,
0.036646191,
0.009514655,
-0.0075638024,
0.0949662179,
-0.0234239753,
-0.0475304574,
0.0306129232,
0.069291316,
-0.005414037,
0.0247825645,
0.0261893664,
-0.0647233576,
-0.000912755,
0.0022969833,
-0.0454227328,
-0.0102913324,
0.0109942919,
-0.012741915,
-0.0116697373,
-0.0398872122,
0.0295769591,
-0.042913083,
0.0679177642,
0.0155472104,
-0.0070225131,
0.0164253116,
0.0470122583,
0.099405542,
-0.0191084687,
-0.0024953655,
0.0603080392,
0.0214423146,
0.024244234,
0.0546822734,
-0.0247667376,
0.0431880988,
0.0075031877,
-0.0396713279,
-0.0340133049,
0.0338601917,
0.0187027622,
0.0045152628,
0.0094048446,
-0.0560796708,
-0.0417847708,
0.0232243724,
-0.0245511793,
-0.0235018954,
-0.0211961716,
0.0266334657,
-0.0181646496,
0.0424999483,
-0.0063131317,
0.0001437835,
-0.0042659249,
0.0048030154,
-0.0146165788,
-0.0201075207,
0.0309312362,
0.0022074485,
-0.009387115,
-0.0774744526,
-0.0034747527,
-0.0417691134,
0.0255009029,
0.0342221819,
0.0290128849,
-0.0243539922,
-0.0108149359,
-0.0556208827,
-0.0109503586,
-0.0142772561,
-0.0263770465,
0.0215530768,
-0.0394563153,
0.0499238633,
0.0007902766,
-0.0159006175,
0.0506418496,
0.0202865489,
0.0127414549,
-0.0204525869,
0.0120423622,
-0.0543017611,
0.0314822383,
0.0081636515,
-0.0157197807,
-0.0495340377,
0.0336982943,
-0.0216385592,
-0.0508469529,
-0.0326545276,
-0.00423847,
2.695e-7,
0.0284085702,
0.0604087934,
0.0394119322,
0.0184939615,
-0.0034965451,
0.0190271083,
-0.0054703886,
-0.0045261723,
0.0350034535,
0.0300505646,
-0.0412788093,
-0.0149329398,
-0.0182148814,
-0.0124510238,
-0.045216091,
0.0226121861,
-0.1002388373,
0.0164322965,
0.0123729119,
0.0035855018,
0.0123780062,
0.0323865004,
0.0506958067,
0.0264117643,
-0.0266582649,
-0.062625587,
0.0311032645,
-0.0002531608,
0.0076772617,
0.0336473063,
0.0157213993,
-0.0405247137,
-0.0283150617,
0.0113755353,
0.0285956338,
0.0498233102,
0.0127402162,
-0.0333028622,
0.0063153934,
0.0162817296,
-0.0157311875,
-0.0399120003,
-0.0285155252,
-0.0495530851,
0.0554415248,
-0.0848619789,
-0.0368228108,
0.0008645058,
-0.0095155118,
0.0272850152,
0.0051143211,
0.0365913212,
-0.0184155367,
-0.0549308732,
0.0357584059,
0.0234907903,
-0.030813219,
-0.0420831218,
-0.0507907346,
0.0422492698,
-0.029227687,
-0.0218411293,
-0.020972494,
0.0460736081,
0.0352372453,
-0.0297641736,
-0.0841507837,
1.922810867e-34,
0.0602713041,
-0.0239064507,
0.0423498712,
-0.0001668408,
0.0140291834,
-0.0064146058,
0.0139199756,
0.0234275609,
0.0567762926,
-0.0309734922,
-0.0179533958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16965v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16965v1 | Natural Language Processing Through Transfer Learning: A Case Study on Sentiment Analysis | 2023-11-28T17:12:06 | 2023-11-28T17:12:06 | Aman Yadav, Abhishek Vichare | cs.CL | cs.CL | Artificial intelligence and machine learning have significantly bolstered the
technological world. This paper explores the potential of transfer learning in
natural language processing focusing mainly on sentiment analysis. The models
trained on the big data can also be used where data are scarce. The claim is
that, compared to training models from scratch, transfer learning, using
pre-trained BERT models, can increase sentiment classification accuracy. The
study adopts a sophisticated experimental design that uses the IMDb dataset of
sentimentally labelled movie reviews. Pre-processing includes tokenization and
encoding of text data, making it suitable for NLP models. The dataset is used
on a BERT based model, measuring its performance using accuracy. The result
comes out to be 100 per cent accurate. Although the complete accuracy could
appear impressive, it might be the result of overfitting or a lack of
generalization. Further analysis is required to ensure the model's ability to
handle diverse and unseen data. The findings underscore the effectiveness of
transfer learning in NLP, showcasing its potential to excel in sentiment
analysis tasks. However, the research calls for a cautious interpretation of
perfect accuracy and emphasizes the need for additional measures to validate
the model's generalization. | [
0.0449464172,
0.0650226921,
-0.0034635782,
0.0389753431,
-0.0351237245,
0.0112454258,
-0.028380584,
0.0115138758,
0.0072621722,
-0.0997202098,
-0.0390688181,
0.0041235932,
-0.0562523082,
0.0411224514,
-0.0365535952,
-0.0432383381,
0.0061710752,
0.0368632637,
0.0633618757,
0.014866381,
-0.0038304259,
0.0184469651,
0.0213570055,
-0.0045768982,
-0.0250615496,
0.02258249,
0.0528552309,
0.0096024461,
0.0180272218,
-0.0097774388,
0.021555312,
0.0247085039,
0.027019402,
-0.0140065197,
0.0000018078,
-0.050211262,
-0.0224139299,
-0.008438223,
0.0275968201,
-0.0112505704,
0.0654918551,
-0.0179230534,
0.0105466703,
0.019468898,
-0.0464441143,
-0.0051123854,
0.0438680872,
0.0583492033,
0.0715128109,
0.0798807442,
-0.0419713482,
-0.0314443856,
0.0030819108,
0.029442396,
0.0155593222,
-0.0184076019,
0.0603508539,
0.0065635554,
0.0098115671,
-0.0167710371,
-0.013749362,
-0.0027182549,
-0.046414122,
0.002668333,
0.0493255854,
-0.007060946,
-0.0739856064,
0.0130446488,
-0.0315967612,
0.0449404567,
-0.0000878334,
-0.0343283266,
-0.0231523216,
0.0078008282,
-0.0075426591,
0.0058654235,
-0.0344047286,
-0.0167995319,
0.0313181244,
0.0545042083,
0.0196541585,
0.0143524669,
0.0091065587,
0.0150766419,
-0.0478870161,
0.0381346196,
0.0048244023,
-0.0554764047,
0.0468785726,
0.0780109763,
0.0017874186,
-0.0134194726,
0.0150128286,
0.0098133003,
0.0409971736,
0.0308826435,
-0.0316201113,
-0.0239977725,
-0.0154710468,
-0.0731163397,
0.006362285,
-0.0082962103,
-0.0299398657,
0.0429586805,
-0.0470196828,
-0.0098626511,
0.0148658715,
0.0394833647,
-0.0204492323,
-0.0251409207,
-0.1251394153,
0.003246126,
-0.0168768261,
0.0876558796,
0.0132751744,
-0.0278185029,
-0.0403876789,
-0.0110864071,
-0.0158660822,
-0.0010090065,
0.0122686764,
0.0000108812,
0.0208151788,
-0.00188235,
-0.0393725261,
0.0541034155,
-0.0232686903,
0.0460022725,
-0.0406117253,
-0.0392270237,
0.0211171675,
0.0106785307,
0.0368794054,
-0.0290702395,
0.0444120839,
0.0622679926,
0.0052643088,
-0.0225882418,
-0.0518661477,
0.0410783216,
-0.0161145106,
-0.0205442347,
0.0226896945,
-0.0259378068,
0.0340267047,
0.0075173792,
-0.0039390344,
0.015556559,
0.0002215849,
0.0012502337,
-0.0570862517,
0.0572873577,
-0.0483887158,
0.0103376806,
0.0022231541,
-0.0271619484,
-0.0377792008,
0.016425496,
0.004990838,
0.0420553498,
0.0436112732,
-0.0410082676,
0.0253177453,
-0.0011392192,
0.0087598059,
-0.013303088,
-0.0434020832,
0.0216589812,
-0.0516185686,
-0.0196786057,
-0.0059433342,
0.054353185,
0.0025476899,
0.0246427562,
0.0431228541,
0.0276867133,
-0.0314805955,
0.0552250482,
-0.0200243741,
0.0188304167,
0.0203463249,
-0.0347156711,
-0.0017886105,
0.0032133639,
-0.0019582456,
-0.0246438943,
-0.0028017941,
-0.0480769984,
-0.0137776956,
-0.0060326746,
-0.0144711854,
-0.0218483154,
0.0219468269,
-0.0257828515,
0.0925967991,
0.0234253164,
-0.0495273583,
0.0399769098,
0.0559039749,
-0.0167848878,
-0.0015960108,
-0.0473180376,
0.0359980464,
0.0717169642,
-0.0095383441,
-0.0417468846,
-0.0195644069,
-0.031629134,
-0.0192896146,
-0.009371317,
0.0439751521,
-0.0066189906,
-0.0114612561,
-0.029311819,
0.0040481836,
-0.0036992452,
0.0278037656,
0.0284113623,
-0.0395383202,
0.0500509925,
-0.0172521621,
-0.0140363006,
-0.0449228995,
0.0253379289,
0.0285746958,
-0.0314562209,
0.0214318335,
-0.0109950565,
0.0529039875,
0.0247105528,
-0.0454158597,
-0.0095358538,
0.0145163992,
-0.0245415363,
-0.0483039021,
-0.0013769497,
-0.0012893878,
-0.0190040879,
-0.0063294731,
-0.0507028364,
0.0087210163,
0.0599547252,
-0.0514636822,
-0.00143691,
0.0140860099,
-0.0135607244,
0.0610194169,
-0.0092451433,
0.0191297568,
-0.0289469771,
0.0235416424,
-0.0230041631,
0.0192232467,
0.0309800543,
0.0048568905,
-0.0476077721,
-0.0522234589,
0.0268850122,
0.0024387792,
-0.0367608368,
0.0043048197,
-0.0079924986,
0.0252106432,
0.0256804656,
0.0010726125,
-0.0166777037,
-0.0138972215,
-0.1201916113,
-0.0122610331,
0.0146722253,
0.0450225845,
0.0116300806,
-0.0187385045,
-0.0113382377,
0.0147476261,
-0.0182636976,
-0.0189117808,
-0.0114871785,
0.0097868331,
0.0696995258,
0.0149142276,
0.0091409497,
-0.0349279866,
-0.0133218439,
-0.0310292523,
0.0493239909,
-0.0041430136,
-0.0551833101,
-0.0020238461,
-0.0102678202,
0.0034907016,
0.0039968924,
0.0214512926,
-0.0257014763,
-0.0163759403,
-0.0221929178,
-0.0394536033,
0.0062051043,
0.0097405268,
0.0129356049,
-0.0224034376,
-0.0034659412,
-0.0143770305,
0.0247873906,
-0.0105360551,
0.0005528051,
-0.0223721638,
-0.031359084,
0.0331681557,
0.0109497681,
0.0029142597,
-0.0160938725,
-0.0508143455,
-0.0043955953,
-0.0226123724,
-0.016111739,
-0.009064272,
-0.002058608,
0.0114127612,
0.0173198711,
0.0200542454,
-0.0084848702,
0.0262016468,
0.0011581235,
0.0286121834,
-0.0751351267,
-0.0105433371,
-0.0161338802,
0.0520333014,
0.0057898443,
0.010752419,
-0.0515652597,
0.0066782455,
0.0229618568,
-0.0512018278,
-0.0350904986,
-0.0143794203,
-0.0128033003,
0.0073469207,
0.0189725161,
0.0045732115,
-0.0204343088,
-0.007192295,
-0.0368289426,
-0.0575782843,
-0.0019336115,
0.0331794657,
-0.0101926839,
-0.0316625088,
-0.00094946,
-0.0298187546,
-0.0135302171,
0.0244389586,
-0.01646531,
0.0320962667,
0.0152039668,
0.010499333,
-0.0579907149,
0.0016324251,
0.007740743,
-0.0191120822,
0.0163691677,
0.0012157023,
0.018019272,
-0.0569683425,
0.00543983,
0.0060875565,
-0.0430264696,
0.005369659,
-0.0350929089,
0.0337461531,
-0.0306980088,
0.0071544154,
0.1092050299,
0.0153058674,
-0.0128144482,
-0.0085808374,
0.0021156876,
-0.0561952516,
-0.0093072793,
0.0423534513,
-0.0277668368,
-0.0484748818,
-0.0270130709,
-0.0007522407,
-0.016261233,
-0.0374803469,
0.0078865476,
-0.1407112628,
0.01733304,
-0.0330443457,
-0.0256145578,
-0.0749470815,
-0.0421292968,
-0.0122782951,
-0.0324145854,
0.0077591999,
-0.0740371644,
-0.0275697354,
0.0024815483,
0.0294296574,
-0.034793321,
-0.0273688324,
0.0502011105,
-0.0144286118,
0.049908109,
0.0540432818,
0.0951046646,
-0.0587354265,
-0.0152744157,
0.0244921483,
0.0035297964,
0.0087566879,
-0.0020925561,
0.0917472541,
-0.0340003856,
-0.0260034967,
0.0034484835,
-0.0414858423,
-0.0410404205,
0.0040819268,
0.028604297,
0.069881551,
0.0070672878,
-0.0720532686,
-0.0446400233,
0.012073379,
-0.0067015658,
0.0759272799,
-0.020739181,
-0.0725220144,
-0.0205864124,
0.0097722197,
-0.0265399888,
-0.0469685756,
0.0251062401,
0.0139807602,
-0.0727937743,
-0.0112063754,
-0.1029390097,
0.0067314156,
0.0302355494,
0.055736687,
0.0384474769,
-0.0031408649,
0.0302627459,
0.0155375721,
-0.0205882732,
0.0299940966,
0.0167969484,
-0.0125123002,
-0.0341404416,
-0.0352484807,
0.0554472134,
-0.0081719756,
-0.0448433086,
-0.0699063912,
0.0164581593,
-0.0358313732,
-0.0106063355,
0.0601507947,
0.017037414,
0.0117682703,
0.0074043362,
-0.0288522597,
0.0687486306,
0.0790701061,
-0.0459383428,
-0.0513581149,
0.0574958846,
0.0507646091,
-0.0076175723,
0.018914463,
-0.0303926151,
0.0375027917,
0.0381749459,
-0.0221131034,
-0.0045718662,
0.0138300462,
0.0032001112,
0.0357752815,
0.0397188924,
0.0557340048,
-0.0355516039,
-0.0313778855,
-0.0035562899,
0.0058003752,
0.0160287749,
-0.0653239265,
-0.0278825425,
0.0469445102,
0.0178460255,
-0.0921821967,
-0.0176504645,
-0.0330287404,
-0.0024485637,
-0.0390087515,
0.0626017153,
0.0326367468,
0.0488350056,
0.0091086915,
0.0179784205,
-0.0321779847,
-0.0231416691,
0.0471213348,
-0.0012058442,
-0.0031218864,
-0.0117188068,
0.0265727267,
0.0372268073,
0.0095676444,
0.0059875748,
-0.0291478634,
-0.0099924095,
-0.0399416126,
0.0314217769,
-0.0044319862,
-0.0608241633,
0.0314557329,
-0.036221467,
-0.0050761127,
0.0089402497,
0.0253538098,
-0.0045991931,
0.0305448063,
0.0132765537,
-0.0110143283,
-0.0162932165,
0.0070673116,
0.0335993469,
-0.0406611785,
0.0324946605,
0.01396304,
-0.0342589952,
-0.0371899121,
0.0313191898,
0.0894374624,
-0.0281277746,
0.0262263287,
0.0630818829,
0.0257837307,
-0.0603296496,
0.0471127629,
-0.0856615975,
0.0454493314,
-0.0009219167,
0.0318635553,
0.0568745323,
0.0333944745,
0.0385856889,
-0.0375216976,
0.0089632105,
0.0092628887,
-0.0019422842,
-0.0067994897,
-6.179199848e-33,
0.0063333386,
0.0185355041,
-0.034500394,
0.0361375995,
-0.0158352796,
-0.0040332284,
0.0040521449,
-0.0214451104,
0.0041671046,
0.0683064461,
-0.0208642818,
0.0114406692,
0.0067139687,
0.0368196927,
0.0210329071,
-0.0389309973,
0.0185213294,
0.0177287608,
0.0052317409,
0.0056777964,
0.0413266048,
0.0823618099,
0.0859705359,
-0.0860582069,
-0.0228044726,
0.0267786942,
-0.0251837149,
0.0014187676,
0.0666178018,
-0.0109690782,
-0.0009755074,
0.0579562709,
0.040912874,
-0.0175659172,
0.0196396038,
0.0679082945,
-0.0089879325,
-0.0133885378,
0.016504854,
0.0152709289,
0.0406023636,
0.0007423717,
0.0451520607,
-0.0065616062,
-0.0224612802,
0.0182707943,
0.0371644087,
-0.0418114886,
0.0208227616,
-0.0784303099,
-0.0995800942,
0.0128754321,
-0.0159621648,
0.0212810561,
0.0236006398,
0.0294124521,
-0.0161722172,
0.0300174579,
-0.0386723317,
-0.0045280531,
-0.0229026135,
0.0041325502,
-0.0020919943,
-0.0214833729,
-0.0146565214,
0.0615149885,
0.0182927456,
-0.0001035767,
-0.0019123458,
0.0394347012,
0.0185467992,
0.0708644912,
0.0194905456,
0.0336761698,
0.0378673635,
-0.0431698747,
-0.0584141165,
0.0136054987,
0.0170098469,
-0.008501661,
0.0676416606,
0.0128416819,
-0.0255547389,
0.0033854106,
0.0203605834,
-0.0245659631,
-0.0005507248,
-0.014384836,
-0.000255151,
-0.0249096416,
-0.0394043103,
0.0052732634,
0.012141237,
-0.0882861987,
-0.039062392,
0.0054273121,
-0.0507623293,
0.0102647701,
-0.0041620997,
-0.0216276869,
-0.0758246332,
-0.0696860999,
-0.0170018505,
0.0242718179,
0.0504752845,
-0.0135669783,
0.0752802715,
0.047858391,
-0.073223874,
-0.0275726058,
-0.0250358935,
0.0184173025,
0.0071699047,
0.0615716018,
-0.0209567323,
0.0388658158,
-0.0028546352,
0.0349853262,
-0.0066968063,
0.0617556497,
0.0313981362,
0.0009419175,
0.0029715532,
-0.0347115323,
-0.0498023517,
-0.0564199872,
-0.0053359861,
0.0036012116,
-0.0198160671,
-0.0791256204,
-0.030964449,
-0.012239106,
2.728e-7,
0.0769020393,
0.0804481804,
-0.0376365036,
-0.0442116745,
0.0042351214,
0.0485093407,
-0.0361503549,
0.0692374408,
0.0465046316,
0.0202478562,
0.025713224,
0.0158610344,
0.0078488365,
0.0259100981,
-0.0925800651,
-0.0529285744,
-0.0540452674,
-0.02035884,
-0.0208539423,
0.0473821722,
0.0711844862,
0.0764691755,
0.0473315008,
-0.0419207811,
-0.0017594477,
-0.0556251891,
0.0333753414,
-0.0743312836,
-0.0039312961,
0.0302153677,
0.0121397898,
0.0192454308,
-0.0296129882,
0.0274072886,
-0.0236719921,
0.0298288241,
0.0515790582,
0.014602961,
-0.017370278,
-0.003861587,
0.0213851482,
0.0083756568,
0.0261288043,
-0.0128842657,
0.0509157106,
-0.0562998615,
-0.0497065224,
-0.0531555451,
-0.0526787043,
-0.0093691787,
0.0492673069,
-0.0089219501,
-0.0010298693,
0.0049556433,
0.0372686908,
0.0130614722,
-0.0708679929,
-0.0789991021,
0.0412001982,
0.0234873518,
-0.0180468503,
-0.0266333055,
0.0183011647,
0.0303390194,
0.0327601321,
-0.0624509268,
0.0698697194,
1.959313754e-34,
0.0296335481,
-0.0247774925,
0.0002868241,
-0.0127977422,
0.0381945632,
0.0204816461,
-0.0127386479,
-0.0120778969,
0.003654473,
-0.0362423621,
0.0396847688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16941v1 | Debiasing Multimodal Models via Causal Information Minimization | 2023-11-28T16:46:14 | 2023-11-28T16:46:14 | Vaidehi Patil, Adyasha Maharana, Mohit Bansal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ME | Most existing debiasing methods for multimodal models, including causal
intervention and inference methods, utilize approximate heuristics to represent
the biases, such as shallow features from early stages of training or unimodal
features for multimodal tasks like VQA, etc., which may not be accurate. In
this paper, we study bias arising from confounders in a causal graph for
multimodal data and examine a novel approach that leverages causally-motivated
information minimization to learn the confounder representations. Robust
predictive features contain diverse information that helps a model generalize
to out-of-distribution data. Hence, minimizing the information content of
features obtained from a pretrained biased model helps learn the simplest
predictive features that capture the underlying data distribution. We treat
these features as confounder representations and use them via methods motivated
by causal theory to remove bias from models. We find that the learned
confounder representations indeed capture dataset biases, and the proposed
debiasing methods improve out-of-distribution (OOD) performance on multiple
multimodal datasets without sacrificing in-distribution performance.
Additionally, we introduce a novel metric to quantify the sufficiency of
spurious features in models' predictions that further demonstrates the
effectiveness of our proposed methods. Our code is available at:
https://github.com/Vaidehi99/CausalInfoMin | [
-0.0271235947,
0.0769804269,
-0.0059932144,
0.0217276625,
-0.0127156992,
0.0026979991,
0.0370573215,
-0.0149565069,
-0.0075550615,
-0.0769526213,
-0.0223405957,
0.0131298555,
-0.0108009949,
0.0044675069,
0.0597538911,
-0.0808933824,
0.0199451372,
-0.002993207,
0.0304719619,
-0.0385279469,
0.033200454,
0.0056505995,
-0.0057562031,
0.0407764912,
-0.0755587891,
-0.0033584081,
0.0067039733,
0.0571875311,
0.0071605546,
-0.0202567428,
0.0304120705,
0.0144032147,
0.0208814833,
-0.0329235941,
0.0000022734,
-0.0172252357,
-0.0235928651,
-0.0201859791,
0.0260902233,
-0.0401628464,
0.0265318286,
-0.0243538674,
0.0508135706,
0.0196366496,
0.0134773264,
-0.0110240821,
0.0796129033,
0.056701161,
-0.0028887533,
0.0491844602,
-0.0356324278,
-0.024696555,
-0.0229053199,
-0.0279376358,
0.0529027395,
0.0004891714,
-0.01570094,
-0.0032716945,
-0.0692129359,
-0.050346572,
-0.0868155956,
-0.0113442047,
0.0059717358,
0.0665578619,
0.0572630577,
-0.0176915135,
0.0359611101,
-0.0194318276,
-0.0009120504,
0.0956063271,
-0.0300878324,
-0.0097925188,
-0.0006509543,
-0.0444792695,
0.0434956253,
0.0878884941,
-0.0463549607,
-0.0168019664,
-0.0132255452,
0.0133502772,
-0.0533468239,
0.0104141952,
0.0533427186,
-0.0047591166,
-0.0078364117,
-0.0043782899,
0.0128262695,
0.0418497026,
-0.0195151661,
0.0158525109,
-0.0274515916,
-0.0209742095,
-0.0284366552,
-0.0214219913,
-0.0133701842,
-0.0319293179,
-0.0377815142,
-0.0209235344,
-0.0182904918,
0.0169091336,
0.036258094,
0.0055010654,
-0.0725891665,
0.0105427215,
0.0278297272,
0.0093055926,
-0.0386939086,
0.05235672,
-0.0042339596,
0.0116607314,
-0.0027249239,
-0.0130566303,
0.034819372,
-0.0205960646,
0.0095707867,
0.0113517186,
-0.0052047572,
-0.0054853647,
-0.0366472788,
-0.0228164997,
-0.0048328149,
0.0700732023,
-0.043364428,
0.0134558389,
-0.009072274,
0.0605960898,
-0.0506743863,
0.0657673478,
-0.0350145027,
-0.05047144,
-0.0191240832,
0.048962377,
0.0302197617,
-0.0458180644,
0.0083896238,
0.1241035759,
0.0409452394,
-0.0374097973,
-0.0444988571,
-0.0594907477,
-0.0055937157,
-0.0368390642,
0.0831344947,
-0.0114368871,
-0.000209786,
-0.0087140109,
0.0473602861,
-0.0413062386,
-0.0053604324,
-0.0387246683,
-0.0364049263,
0.0337624103,
0.0221139733,
-0.0010283508,
0.0200080667,
-0.0286090896,
-0.0251359902,
0.0737820044,
0.0143708279,
0.0354669057,
0.013252927,
-0.0020169201,
0.009628715,
0.0337772332,
0.0570367314,
0.0093084509,
-0.0161899813,
-0.0563990623,
0.0204650592,
-0.0128570264,
0.0662801489,
-0.0184716638,
-0.0420430638,
0.0007325955,
0.0706782937,
-0.0716550723,
0.0165368877,
-0.0378948711,
0.0106026018,
-0.0484742112,
-0.0414317213,
0.0454004519,
-0.0733377784,
0.0567853451,
0.0020731234,
-0.010058335,
0.0334202349,
0.0259739291,
-0.0366260447,
-0.0235280935,
0.0327364318,
-0.0256764125,
0.0143368235,
0.0338117704,
0.0573264323,
0.0143539151,
-0.0239985101,
0.005887955,
0.0398519561,
0.0032166985,
-0.0026110318,
0.015281097,
-0.0105713364,
0.0170276221,
0.02109042,
-0.0234471355,
-0.0008190244,
-0.0211483315,
0.0257999431,
-0.0305283312,
-0.0035065352,
-0.0061169402,
0.0687558204,
-0.0310815219,
-0.0778562427,
-0.0392434113,
0.0368718691,
0.0242886432,
0.0096478844,
-0.0128642274,
0.0020000674,
-0.0591634475,
0.0245163962,
0.0180823412,
0.023596203,
-0.0103737907,
-0.015493636,
0.046874553,
0.040178474,
0.0126356259,
-0.0191365629,
-0.0127070481,
-0.0087042851,
-0.0392776951,
0.0073663928,
0.0533616096,
-0.0115611674,
-0.0415875614,
-0.003537799,
-0.1017987728,
0.0266937893,
0.0235134158,
-0.0481606014,
-0.0108094644,
0.0930284411,
-0.0006290186,
-0.023465693,
0.003386969,
-0.0412760042,
0.021172367,
0.0012187622,
0.004146276,
0.0215679649,
-0.0341699682,
-0.0084401984,
-0.009322566,
-0.0302043743,
0.0112224212,
-0.0196858086,
0.0079966197,
0.0064789588,
0.0110267568,
-0.039009165,
0.0380139239,
-0.0451625511,
0.0093869958,
0.0479001738,
-0.0869050398,
-0.0161974244,
-0.0359825566,
-0.0324663855,
-0.0191341471,
0.0125437351,
0.0130260307,
-0.0768321753,
-0.0002637723,
0.0060875169,
0.00642177,
0.0324604213,
-0.0065277894,
-0.0010949204,
0.0023426262,
-0.0199063644,
0.0035343398,
-0.0176517256,
0.0790272728,
0.0307560302,
-0.0309837628,
0.0099033751,
-0.0520764552,
-0.0248365588,
0.0265117157,
-0.0446696654,
-0.0035725047,
-0.0175772533,
-0.0133822123,
-0.0078837806,
0.0646059662,
-0.0252509527,
0.0009639932,
0.03738885,
-0.0037381686,
-0.0125071499,
-0.0005806438,
-0.0246057473,
0.0215911269,
-0.0076309699,
-0.0415935032,
-0.0436928384,
0.0284178834,
0.0330007151,
0.0014979,
-0.042182859,
0.0231879093,
0.0266053285,
-0.0647496879,
-0.045259878,
-0.0031759455,
0.0030988073,
-0.0087741353,
-0.062212348,
-0.0765862763,
0.0279997922,
0.0163005944,
0.0213458966,
0.0468399078,
0.0477383807,
0.0024872196,
0.0529472753,
0.032423988,
0.0451992936,
0.0393633991,
0.0062915785,
-0.0733616129,
-0.0054396521,
0.0723032281,
0.0171831902,
-0.0082601588,
-0.0393503979,
-0.0119541679,
0.0142412707,
-0.0470942147,
-0.0033838225,
-0.0836464614,
-0.0010434613,
-0.0281165969,
-0.0307409521,
0.0198747292,
-0.0280909948,
-0.047165703,
0.0006828581,
0.0141872158,
-0.0293947402,
0.0096731298,
0.0435697734,
0.0123943686,
0.0153609989,
-0.0023747275,
-0.012132789,
-0.0642869771,
-0.036253795,
0.0057475553,
-0.0042477129,
-0.0204872824,
-0.0376753844,
0.0288454704,
-0.0247603059,
0.0444517806,
-0.0118235527,
0.0187739693,
0.073038578,
0.0020349899,
0.0454367064,
0.0281883869,
-0.029960895,
-0.0402576439,
0.0236408878,
0.0667787865,
0.0294189528,
0.0313870087,
-0.0454056635,
-0.0998665318,
-0.078014493,
-0.0115276249,
-0.0023805788,
-0.0012546404,
-0.0023422274,
0.0322118923,
-0.0644375756,
0.0368842818,
0.0244453102,
-0.0111143813,
-0.0128571345,
-0.0149052581,
0.0103790471,
-0.0619484968,
-0.0589024723,
-0.0223363936,
-0.0041278382,
0.021846056,
0.0368683003,
0.0283309761,
-0.0675924346,
-0.0474731885,
-0.032907851,
0.0045791217,
0.0524230897,
-0.0053948499,
-0.0118646706,
0.0106187919,
0.021112334,
0.030314941,
0.0345994011,
-0.004481128,
0.1067437008,
-0.0362024494,
-0.0171912182,
0.0154579263,
0.0752906129,
0.0107374554,
0.0077549876,
-0.0280104335,
0.0299201533,
-0.0302081741,
0.0137995305,
-0.0328859948,
-0.0343752801,
0.0591412038,
-0.0031928949,
0.0161438808,
-0.0199896786,
-0.0324757509,
-0.030351473,
-0.0107025811,
0.0141735114,
0.0031564839,
0.0048285821,
0.0160416029,
-0.0660796911,
-0.053421881,
-0.0144715179,
-0.0032126834,
0.0300684962,
0.0039337743,
-0.0218551364,
-0.0781316459,
0.0322579592,
-0.0640122667,
0.075168781,
0.0008179934,
0.0397561193,
0.0101952171,
-0.0034653298,
-0.0194245465,
-0.0761244521,
-0.006208986,
0.0230324585,
-0.0577202998,
-0.0628177822,
-0.0240414739,
0.0784406066,
0.0133122029,
0.0681309104,
0.0142985927,
-0.0483795665,
0.0421619043,
0.0323440768,
-0.0151812667,
0.0267443806,
0.055948168,
-0.028288044,
-0.0108505152,
0.001547058,
-0.0579981245,
0.0132567864,
0.002027527,
-0.0261170138,
0.0197860003,
-0.0020038548,
-0.0038202885,
-0.0240367148,
0.0943095386,
-0.0723418668,
0.006198558,
-0.0364363268,
-0.0233741533,
0.020779144,
-0.0150000695,
-0.0562225096,
0.0414387956,
0.0432453938,
0.0466971211,
-0.007059813,
-0.0303241536,
0.0073312228,
0.0100489957,
-0.0655307248,
0.0574393384,
0.0316249281,
-0.0160397943,
-0.0270469468,
0.0370862149,
0.0341651477,
0.0488386974,
0.0072432058,
-0.0085100876,
0.0181025062,
0.0379752032,
0.0402483381,
0.0308126938,
-0.05276113,
-0.01474257,
-0.0435581654,
0.0426327065,
-0.0428929627,
0.0426502265,
0.0707727894,
-0.0067950315,
0.0232976377,
0.0138830105,
-0.0097404812,
-0.0324652456,
0.0481382273,
0.036814142,
0.0141432807,
0.0607073605,
-0.0079621943,
0.0021550674,
-0.0018005145,
0.0781113431,
0.0372317359,
0.0735599175,
-0.063882336,
0.0054735132,
-0.0106533878,
-0.0368222371,
0.0604865626,
0.03796703,
-0.0137814404,
0.0290397238,
-0.0268443339,
-0.0468987599,
-0.0079280715,
0.0013681947,
0.0417206809,
0.0160906315,
0.047339417,
0.0405964516,
-0.0219705105,
-0.0344400816,
-0.0263352264,
-0.0245945137,
-0.0314078033,
-0.0035566061,
0.0182788968,
-6.731948883e-33,
-0.0148637751,
-0.0158596151,
-0.0357201658,
-0.0352063365,
0.0028463372,
-0.0054476913,
-0.0266101938,
-0.0031517639,
-0.0219774544,
0.0353891589,
0.0323269218,
-0.0075629745,
0.0028126074,
-0.0187058449,
0.0120195728,
-0.0196622703,
0.0615179874,
-0.0054935934,
-0.0202296097,
0.0177087318,
0.0191379413,
0.0196349695,
0.0517074391,
-0.0838626251,
0.0204734951,
-0.0232854933,
-0.0770191103,
-0.0155899627,
0.0034453059,
0.0269583482,
-0.016197063,
0.0223399643,
0.032958135,
-0.0105340527,
-0.0107116634,
0.0125122592,
-0.0479351804,
-0.0371855721,
0.0035989527,
0.0195346121,
-0.0422407314,
-0.0425282195,
0.0165769663,
-0.0016159546,
-0.0184654109,
-0.0316477641,
0.0427728891,
-0.0010084695,
0.0291298553,
-0.0001442217,
-0.0434359498,
0.0282900035,
-0.0329747088,
-0.0246331152,
0.0095879734,
0.0671256781,
0.0436742939,
0.0213590283,
0.0279452782,
0.0354317501,
-0.0363058187,
-0.0472514629,
0.0333120599,
0.0733620226,
0.0169016626,
0.0705099702,
0.0211915243,
-0.0049219439,
-0.0195858479,
0.0040987609,
0.0124567701,
0.0340443291,
0.0078460714,
0.1147072092,
0.0562748648,
-0.0048777219,
-0.0728726536,
0.0447927415,
-0.0435668305,
-0.0136283962,
-0.0099146282,
0.0135844685,
-0.0157698914,
-0.0146451257,
-0.0304915719,
-0.0420936979,
0.0013410905,
-0.0152072916,
0.0343717337,
0.0292397719,
0.0060586082,
0.0245882217,
0.0633127168,
-0.0327962302,
0.0072622211,
0.066123575,
-0.0202830937,
0.0437089615,
0.0002757396,
-0.034801051,
-0.0265504774,
0.0120910658,
0.0577894449,
-0.0016509633,
0.0465805009,
0.0027575267,
0.0415271334,
0.0402820483,
-0.0083407601,
-0.0182151422,
-0.0292663891,
-0.0149298748,
0.0177946948,
0.0256233513,
0.0606779605,
0.013462821,
-0.0364889763,
0.009938715,
0.0051114568,
0.0523400977,
-0.0210201219,
-0.042643249,
-0.0219011009,
0.0187846161,
-0.0386980027,
-0.0315537751,
-0.0018127043,
-0.1005995721,
-0.0044089914,
-0.0728081614,
-0.036403887,
-0.0112856226,
2.934e-7,
0.015642412,
0.0019303629,
-0.0050577149,
-0.0060402313,
0.0322658904,
0.0338294692,
-0.0007747769,
0.0184576865,
-0.0200116318,
-0.0664153472,
0.0441927835,
0.059540119,
0.0198140778,
-0.01047784,
-0.0374886803,
0.0207661949,
0.0201112572,
-0.0046764398,
-0.011882023,
-0.0019981842,
0.0037653151,
0.0573829412,
0.0082856668,
-0.023498375,
0.0508562252,
0.0089703025,
0.0654237121,
-0.0168511998,
0.0075567658,
-0.0601672344,
0.0180777013,
-0.0194544569,
-0.009826839,
0.0286618173,
-0.0139297768,
-0.0121275866,
-0.0005872401,
0.0051007709,
-0.0428978242,
-0.0431240723,
-0.0367789529,
0.0433700085,
-0.0021937557,
-0.0118566202,
0.0686092824,
0.0215493068,
-0.0607867576,
-0.0221415404,
-0.0343653597,
0.017862102,
0.0411703736,
0.0076100174,
-0.0043886122,
0.0094124721,
0.0179029834,
0.0131663037,
-0.0184773467,
-0.0573480055,
-0.0591951758,
0.0316165425,
-0.0454363786,
-0.0548983701,
0.0261542965,
-0.0196583997,
0.0278830081,
-0.0249843616,
-0.0272039901,
2.255872382e-34,
0.0372017995,
-0.0082298797,
0.013146813,
-0.0652541444,
0.0264231265,
-0.0500683747,
-0.0717721879,
-0.0391805209,
0.0314674117,
-0.0201867111,
0.0115557127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16922v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16922v1 | Mitigating Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models through Visual Contrastive Decoding | 2023-11-28T16:26:35 | 2023-11-28T16:26:35 | Sicong Leng, Hang Zhang, Guanzheng Chen, Xin Li, Shijian Lu, Chunyan Miao, Lidong Bing | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have advanced considerably, intertwining
visual recognition and language understanding to generate content that is not
only coherent but also contextually attuned. Despite their success, LVLMs still
suffer from the issue of object hallucinations, where models generate plausible
yet incorrect outputs that include objects that do not exist in the images. To
mitigate this issue, we introduce Visual Contrastive Decoding (VCD), a simple
and training-free method that contrasts output distributions derived from
original and distorted visual inputs. The proposed VCD effectively reduces the
over-reliance on statistical bias and unimodal priors, two essential causes of
object hallucinations. This adjustment ensures the generated content is closely
grounded to visual inputs, resulting in contextually accurate outputs. Our
experiments show that VCD, without either additional training or the usage of
external tools, significantly mitigates the object hallucination issue across
different LVLM families. Beyond mitigating object hallucinations, VCD also
excels in general LVLM benchmarks, highlighting its wide-ranging applicability. | [
-0.0099648796,
0.05769163,
0.0240397509,
0.0927783474,
-0.0197645687,
0.0380327664,
-0.0027785739,
0.000740378,
-0.013326833,
-0.0323334374,
-0.0188908074,
-0.0455302224,
0.0424184576,
0.0011961112,
0.0272152461,
-0.0906486958,
0.0005839955,
-0.056449607,
-0.0585031733,
0.0115718767,
-0.0207609534,
-0.0081636198,
0.015890779,
0.026664095,
-0.0062363409,
-0.0578213669,
0.0184319578,
0.0198539458,
0.0182685964,
-0.0036855489,
-0.0436673723,
0.0351133645,
0.0055200648,
-0.0132944919,
0.0000021057,
-0.0316517763,
0.0143376403,
0.0078318315,
0.0095985886,
-0.0160554536,
0.0551519543,
-0.0619147159,
-0.0008602146,
-0.0056942422,
-0.0015572277,
-0.0593171045,
0.0818075314,
0.0709516928,
0.0086724628,
0.0338163562,
-0.0080261212,
-0.0442810059,
0.0108967666,
0.0186746083,
0.0260648578,
-0.005914141,
0.0304662753,
0.0226511974,
-0.0449430533,
-0.0118215624,
-0.0472017862,
0.0278888177,
0.0552937165,
0.0146596255,
0.0109922551,
0.0430366844,
-0.0237965304,
-0.0296819247,
0.001606487,
0.0514440387,
-0.0705638975,
-0.0397263356,
-0.0237917993,
-0.0093873311,
0.0178642627,
-0.0309202503,
-0.0080551924,
0.0436356105,
-0.0135706933,
0.0424513519,
0.010037465,
0.0205206219,
0.0242724717,
-0.0120123718,
-0.047060594,
-0.0397660024,
0.0143134408,
0.0031393294,
0.001122568,
0.0404464491,
-0.0394874923,
-0.0454056524,
0.0011993743,
-0.0042079897,
-0.0397220664,
-0.0364572518,
-0.0398311354,
-0.0460499972,
-0.0144845899,
-0.0535455383,
0.033166606,
0.0024699061,
-0.1178956777,
0.0674509183,
-0.0289244,
0.0656081289,
-0.0433285497,
0.0390393287,
-0.024362294,
-0.0220170226,
0.0156637914,
0.0174286216,
0.0117180152,
-0.0175093208,
-0.0474656336,
-0.0211311188,
0.0287284646,
-0.0134934615,
-0.031099245,
0.0147262746,
-0.0041653705,
0.0296386313,
-0.014683906,
-0.0610240027,
-0.0009115079,
0.0410250872,
0.0544641465,
-0.0067597809,
-0.0444872938,
-0.0934977382,
-0.0123360343,
0.0552110597,
-0.0083060535,
-0.024815334,
-0.0340018347,
0.0840803981,
-0.0156735741,
-0.0258650091,
-0.034426555,
0.0314063877,
-0.0243865363,
-0.0148683582,
0.0363016501,
-0.0550001189,
-0.000150961,
-0.0094261514,
0.0254478138,
-0.0625447109,
0.0313572995,
-0.023358047,
-0.039904464,
0.0921339169,
-0.0532238856,
-0.0187949892,
-0.0052087368,
0.0016085913,
-0.000205866,
0.0495266877,
-0.0093726367,
0.0396897383,
-0.0461422093,
-0.0066138119,
0.0632441416,
0.0225156713,
-0.0288826916,
0.0131220128,
-0.0897651017,
-0.0084034149,
0.0017078184,
-0.0016390373,
0.0715369731,
0.086070314,
-0.0258070789,
-0.0441733301,
0.0739202946,
-0.0103367008,
-0.0107096797,
-0.0067361379,
0.0134361088,
-0.007535968,
-0.0214649197,
0.024823809,
-0.0672233552,
0.0533355176,
0.0093221841,
-0.0010067108,
0.0116081275,
0.0317159109,
-0.0352296904,
-0.0303913336,
-0.0068437858,
-0.0203368459,
0.0172326285,
0.0302665904,
0.0535573624,
0.0150253307,
-0.0372851938,
-0.0153808491,
0.0230519064,
0.0087152412,
0.0282439366,
-0.0398463793,
0.0228028093,
0.0929294378,
0.0430946536,
0.0208991133,
0.0226451568,
-0.0095188143,
0.0189444255,
0.0706137121,
-0.0021547307,
0.025367897,
0.0429584756,
-0.0220435727,
-0.0548154674,
0.0282303002,
0.0058989227,
0.0103998771,
-0.0265368335,
-0.0127179055,
-0.0063816025,
-0.0277304053,
-0.0285883509,
0.0518990457,
0.0248381011,
-0.0176900048,
-0.0110111283,
-0.0091935089,
0.0097390469,
-0.0075289812,
-0.0255375318,
0.0124222282,
0.0042891023,
-0.0422191583,
0.0177809894,
-0.0001641323,
-0.0315702595,
-0.0484427437,
0.0461391136,
-0.0388869867,
-0.0096843783,
0.0195039045,
-0.0100845583,
0.0012546123,
0.0293375589,
-0.0175040364,
0.0314108841,
-0.0291091334,
0.0130657293,
0.0183120258,
0.037736468,
0.0026112134,
0.0572335944,
-0.0505915657,
-0.037022233,
0.0295374636,
0.0342871733,
-0.0098219011,
-0.0026509829,
0.0170534719,
0.0186293349,
0.005543252,
0.0180690456,
-0.0280450936,
-0.0062637758,
-0.0599689484,
0.011881697,
-0.0294440687,
-0.0368825011,
-0.0515968353,
-0.0484392755,
0.0093019865,
-0.0271113012,
0.026632769,
-0.0483345799,
-0.0065821828,
0.0234536137,
-0.0157192871,
0.0276533272,
-0.016226029,
-0.0100134397,
-0.0218840241,
-0.0099269571,
0.005139315,
0.0457055047,
0.0562927537,
-0.0093285441,
-0.0371704772,
-0.0756241828,
0.0960982367,
0.0136934007,
0.0358572565,
-0.0002170397,
0.0102688754,
-0.0213191453,
-0.0380614363,
0.0398298837,
0.0949925929,
-0.003657792,
0.0135460487,
0.0624732077,
-0.0359642096,
-0.0179324187,
-0.0597103015,
0.0091269333,
-0.0429262668,
-0.0191712044,
-0.0356254503,
-0.0371259041,
0.0369080193,
0.0231221765,
0.0391660035,
-0.0777712762,
0.0198986009,
-0.0216675606,
-0.0812723637,
-0.027767377,
0.017013913,
-0.0029713355,
0.0295224823,
-0.0483602025,
-0.0423030891,
0.0261487253,
-0.0206577126,
0.0095577901,
0.0368865542,
0.0267500225,
0.0268324204,
0.0258616675,
0.0329200961,
0.0117589859,
-0.0199245866,
-0.0179727636,
-0.0373078659,
-0.0174941607,
-0.0586343184,
-0.0299562328,
0.0394781493,
-0.0632979646,
-0.0062329886,
-0.0218645986,
-0.0174853634,
-0.0459156856,
-0.0066668764,
-0.0237188973,
0.0069934372,
-0.0507963672,
-0.0021000465,
-0.0152899344,
0.0366931632,
0.0222560074,
0.0143345315,
0.0021731067,
-0.0277311411,
-0.0112711806,
0.024481602,
0.0627473891,
-0.0010538469,
0.058081381,
-0.053556107,
0.006726454,
0.071405001,
0.0269572511,
0.0257490948,
-0.0869393721,
0.0183835849,
0.0284458976,
0.075703904,
-0.0080525428,
0.0487496518,
0.0080186753,
-0.0798370987,
-0.0200926661,
0.0703659281,
0.0243288688,
-0.0833251923,
-0.0101729231,
-0.0117594702,
0.0371819176,
-0.0066809882,
-0.0063146749,
-0.0792607889,
-0.0476693548,
-0.0152297812,
-0.0255226847,
0.0227812249,
0.0039246804,
-0.0224371422,
-0.0714728609,
0.0830934495,
0.0524533987,
0.0079543944,
-0.0735082924,
0.0257486645,
-0.0091244271,
-0.0286071766,
0.0287752859,
0.0151766362,
0.0018470817,
0.003836496,
0.0288393572,
0.0228884481,
-0.0194698405,
0.0043571023,
-0.0377821065,
0.0035444298,
0.1143287569,
-0.0083551016,
0.0174765307,
-0.0577803738,
0.017031271,
-0.0390784256,
-0.0022173028,
-0.0059817703,
0.0373664163,
-0.0240050945,
-0.0386199728,
0.0346782953,
0.0251125805,
-0.067478627,
-0.0443901271,
-0.0150694167,
-0.0035612164,
-0.022233706,
-0.040502727,
-0.0151077043,
-0.0142053664,
-0.0040234667,
0.0470619351,
0.0316166803,
-0.026829809,
-0.0325770453,
-0.0308560021,
0.0325062908,
-0.0068835076,
-0.02648874,
0.0249368306,
0.053419549,
-0.0325555354,
-0.0469711535,
-0.0309515223,
0.0209944472,
-0.0137523478,
-0.0154427253,
-0.00815327,
-0.0202400517,
-0.0189278368,
-0.0487424731,
0.0531492345,
-0.051153481,
0.015897423,
-0.0142227355,
0.0195183437,
0.0119395293,
-0.0503088571,
0.0142932935,
0.0429176427,
-0.0866778642,
-0.0325026251,
0.0278572366,
0.0550910644,
0.011842953,
0.0713121742,
0.0034352897,
-0.0617575943,
0.0092477361,
0.0432428382,
0.0497417673,
0.0534323305,
-0.0205440633,
-0.0212507229,
0.0250056554,
0.023450356,
-0.0226422437,
0.0092641823,
0.0594970696,
-0.0008159471,
-0.0159701928,
0.0088291522,
0.0244344734,
-0.0411339737,
0.0514238924,
-0.0355784893,
0.0251719132,
0.0059504067,
-0.0072701639,
0.0084498329,
-0.0071820561,
-0.0653316304,
0.0041461322,
0.0429323316,
0.0202730056,
0.0152095556,
0.0243962109,
0.000223174,
0.0010838145,
-0.0366573259,
-0.0350676179,
0.0130139068,
-0.031511195,
0.0333922058,
0.0136200478,
-0.0097871153,
0.0073823067,
0.0023937731,
0.0486259535,
0.0320795774,
0.051049456,
0.0144830672,
-0.0395993739,
-0.0359599888,
0.01305262,
-0.0018066493,
-0.0529138334,
-0.0637123287,
0.021576412,
0.0448019728,
-0.0093133897,
0.0666216835,
-0.0421799198,
0.0104105733,
-0.0712400079,
0.0293617025,
0.0315126032,
-0.0249845386,
0.0135426223,
0.0127188349,
-0.0302526038,
-0.0117388684,
0.0649622902,
0.0180923492,
0.002334096,
0.0041150339,
0.0382213257,
-0.0229037199,
-0.0337350182,
0.0072502308,
-0.017665118,
-0.0081356736,
0.0176043455,
-0.0061373585,
-0.047659833,
-0.0176274907,
0.0244325921,
0.031112751,
0.0123307696,
0.0235969033,
0.0118030915,
-0.0237286501,
-0.0399353728,
0.0005703128,
-0.0544251129,
0.0500721149,
-0.0161949266,
0.0047145518,
-6.122372043e-33,
-0.003043331,
-0.026614178,
0.0338628963,
-0.0448135845,
0.0222168621,
-0.0059630368,
-0.0155089647,
0.0038805008,
-0.0212473497,
0.0323645808,
0.022665279,
0.0468743294,
0.0155112129,
0.0438792333,
-0.0131832836,
-0.0224244315,
0.049647551,
-0.0043765013,
0.0084288148,
0.0078522665,
0.009937698,
0.0101403203,
0.0278288107,
-0.1002294719,
0.0015852196,
0.0326378979,
-0.0254196655,
0.0061315796,
0.0392249636,
0.0409004763,
-0.0696322769,
0.0116305202,
0.0188915841,
-0.0157781616,
-0.0637655258,
-0.0093807811,
-0.0277249403,
0.0371193215,
-0.0079875151,
0.0446719304,
-0.0712176934,
-0.0181585904,
0.0457791202,
0.0255677551,
-0.0123576801,
-0.0532151349,
0.0287206639,
-0.0805546492,
-0.0216786023,
0.0683148205,
-0.027463546,
0.0064733466,
-0.0022425451,
-0.0030868838,
0.0997730941,
-0.0120644523,
-0.024118036,
0.0484624729,
-0.0382489897,
0.0114792902,
-0.0050708684,
-0.0031588178,
0.0963557959,
0.0736977309,
0.0168954208,
0.0705028623,
0.0927575678,
-0.0383861326,
-0.0031690774,
-0.0461535342,
-0.0017997675,
0.0452744886,
0.0381352119,
0.0605424382,
0.0564088337,
0.0397137217,
-0.0159014221,
-0.0175902043,
-0.1224447489,
0.0200980604,
0.0593589656,
0.0144799305,
-0.0094877314,
-0.0281261075,
-0.0237807874,
-0.0222786572,
-0.0544114672,
-0.0021106342,
0.059378922,
0.010272637,
-0.0186533369,
0.0040243231,
0.0580682009,
-0.0306318216,
0.0085820267,
0.0244116634,
-0.0196274798,
0.0517362356,
0.0011133313,
-0.0088929357,
-0.0143281324,
0.0007608379,
0.0663974881,
-0.0018609622,
-0.0197129771,
0.0340432152,
0.0060789553,
-0.0124891801,
-0.0419985428,
-0.0083004544,
-0.0485717468,
-0.0161480848,
0.0265274011,
0.0336539298,
0.0560022183,
-0.0024345149,
-0.0105338059,
0.0363786295,
-0.0016618808,
-0.0209273715,
0.0105096102,
0.0181331728,
-0.0149351237,
0.0304285903,
-0.008340396,
-0.0096638408,
-0.0478422903,
-0.0290066618,
0.0767555088,
-0.0379730649,
-0.0186510589,
0.0048746821,
2.708e-7,
0.0079169786,
0.0208531972,
0.0079031866,
0.0023670611,
0.0132865841,
0.0494882986,
0.0338598602,
0.0321214683,
0.0226133354,
-0.0630009398,
-0.0173259508,
0.0621356703,
0.0452632308,
0.0015050346,
-0.008074292,
0.032864552,
0.0031730901,
0.0043625711,
-0.0434207357,
-0.0258589704,
0.0367373526,
0.0735130534,
-0.0283955168,
-0.0359136984,
0.0971461833,
-0.0366733894,
0.0625422001,
-0.0341978706,
0.0147248451,
-0.0222728439,
-0.0350171365,
0.0235310532,
0.0277185738,
0.0356535427,
0.0021087721,
-0.0511408336,
0.0336068571,
0.0125390608,
-0.0489886142,
-0.0270820819,
-0.0382143557,
0.0295668412,
-0.0231603645,
-0.045122087,
0.050896775,
-0.0320892334,
0.0102608865,
-0.0149943084,
-0.0597343072,
-0.0227432437,
0.0158349704,
-0.0174864046,
-0.002743667,
0.002584748,
0.02527624,
0.0285625365,
-0.0649771616,
-0.0316431336,
-0.0321454853,
-0.0080038272,
-0.0105127096,
-0.0206994619,
-0.0278856475,
0.0224347934,
0.0298299585,
-0.0144231301,
-0.0195639692,
2.30975663e-34,
-0.0032579326,
0.0075837611,
0.0337442085,
0.0035518429,
0.0028732782,
-0.0180117805,
-0.0099259028,
0.026928341,
-0.0241506752,
-0.0382224098,
-0.0159906298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03739v1 | Syntax-Informed Interactive Model for Comprehensive Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-11-28T16:03:22 | 2023-11-28T16:03:22 | Ullman Galen, Frey Lee, Woods Ali | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA), a nuanced task in text analysis,
seeks to discern sentiment orientation linked to specific aspect terms in text.
Traditional approaches often overlook or inadequately model the explicit
syntactic structures of sentences, crucial for effective aspect term
identification and sentiment determination. Addressing this gap, we introduce
an innovative model: Syntactic Dependency Enhanced Multi-Task Interaction
Architecture (SDEMTIA) for comprehensive ABSA. Our approach innovatively
exploits syntactic knowledge (dependency relations and types) using a
specialized Syntactic Dependency Embedded Interactive Network (SDEIN). We also
incorporate a novel and efficient message-passing mechanism within a multi-task
learning framework to bolster learning efficacy. Our extensive experiments on
benchmark datasets showcase our model's superiority, significantly surpassing
existing methods. Additionally, incorporating BERT as an auxiliary feature
extractor further enhances our model's performance. | [
0.0226125438,
0.0278350301,
-0.0141480565,
0.0522272289,
-0.0450585671,
0.0102432044,
0.007655628,
-0.0233633239,
0.021787269,
-0.0321427882,
-0.06512402,
-0.0161065254,
-0.0485872813,
0.0594184063,
-0.0068679168,
-0.0240331553,
0.0392879397,
0.0467036851,
0.0351317897,
0.0094200289,
0.0378032587,
0.0400177129,
-0.0086539928,
0.009917534,
-0.0270622987,
-0.0346590877,
-0.0088700522,
0.0108894324,
0.0161168519,
-0.0050429921,
0.0731956512,
0.0372138321,
0.0281536374,
-0.015722923,
0.0000021734,
-0.0063873534,
-0.0174585637,
-0.0324527323,
0.029929027,
-0.0075433804,
0.0655339062,
0.0196921993,
0.0157214087,
0.0051836874,
-0.051150322,
-0.0227317307,
0.0265784413,
0.0873355344,
0.0846696347,
0.0677701682,
-0.0428627171,
0.0164752137,
0.0077079888,
-0.0147843426,
-0.0193921048,
0.0082492251,
0.0257832073,
-0.0000074425,
-0.0447647758,
0.0348106921,
0.0352791362,
-0.0109858951,
0.025740996,
-0.0073463493,
0.0308468882,
-0.0041985121,
0.0086491508,
-0.0020344828,
-0.0056901672,
0.036378894,
0.0205475446,
0.0133840153,
-0.0132344831,
-0.0191522166,
-0.0117700128,
0.0366129987,
-0.0040016202,
-0.0278444216,
-0.0111530526,
0.0311610065,
0.0234005675,
0.0187300388,
-0.0228591189,
0.0011519393,
-0.0002097627,
0.032671351,
-0.0307186339,
-0.0360760763,
0.0352282114,
0.087199308,
-0.0723081678,
-0.0012355996,
0.0360601358,
-0.051649414,
-0.0019052353,
0.0133586945,
-0.0035059566,
-0.0277039707,
-0.0162594412,
-0.1083010212,
0.0091801006,
-0.0139845219,
-0.0522723608,
-0.0035664102,
0.0071586561,
-0.0230668653,
0.0187855233,
-0.0705057159,
-0.0088090273,
0.0494686961,
-0.0745302439,
0.0066909851,
-0.0114297923,
0.0787297711,
-0.0251809638,
-0.0123966876,
-0.0279943887,
0.0399636738,
-0.0251826346,
0.0259884857,
0.0583167002,
0.0111303637,
-0.0174362119,
0.0513816923,
-0.0348705016,
0.012918571,
-0.0402164012,
0.0453676693,
-0.043418441,
0.0124391047,
-0.0113286516,
0.0276242029,
0.0117086843,
-0.0619113632,
-0.008505444,
0.0054413318,
0.004213531,
-0.0556279309,
-0.0240740869,
-0.0412625372,
-0.0239427052,
-0.0262824465,
0.0106364815,
-0.061858464,
0.0080966186,
0.007196323,
-0.0305809751,
-0.0032128526,
0.0233444888,
0.0237892121,
-0.0165972598,
0.0321828835,
-0.0064556119,
-0.072916247,
-0.0607715175,
0.0015610093,
0.0141722588,
0.0277235284,
-0.0227082502,
0.0599836893,
0.0142993554,
0.0293319691,
-0.0222596638,
-0.0054225414,
-0.0194052439,
0.0075515457,
-0.0151590127,
-0.0019880226,
-0.0358463079,
-0.0443396904,
-0.0187423714,
0.0431976542,
0.0163680166,
-0.0102434531,
0.0471822694,
-0.0088269804,
-0.0368556418,
0.0728813559,
0.0106434207,
0.048430033,
0.0122744758,
0.0146968244,
-0.0109505905,
0.0446943119,
0.0071727373,
-0.0197538733,
-0.008197316,
0.0044413097,
-0.0240130387,
-0.0720984116,
-0.0301956255,
-0.0344964117,
0.0092609292,
-0.0029794131,
0.0394480601,
0.0026133091,
-0.0545842424,
-0.006535491,
0.0533453636,
-0.0494707488,
-0.0415598005,
-0.0084731728,
0.0279227979,
0.0790864453,
0.0193064641,
-0.0571193323,
-0.0479246527,
-0.0385964513,
-0.0318621956,
0.0566815659,
0.0047091236,
-0.0255896784,
-0.0202259887,
-0.0309698675,
0.0128157474,
-0.0085670939,
0.0173509363,
-0.0061695231,
-0.0276440214,
0.0001653466,
-0.0189235974,
-0.0131898709,
0.0318149887,
0.0006425387,
0.0113507286,
-0.0060992059,
0.0136793684,
0.019121455,
0.0412583947,
0.0462892577,
-0.0227984339,
-0.0122056268,
0.0275067519,
-0.0398903675,
-0.0355685391,
0.0325352922,
-0.0466302596,
-0.0612076744,
-0.0261913929,
0.0291856006,
-0.0062661828,
0.0236516073,
-0.0195524693,
-0.0075658788,
0.0082333032,
-0.0186122861,
0.0477634519,
-0.0290520936,
-0.0207451116,
-0.0080260681,
0.0059609162,
-0.0076470389,
0.0744422674,
-0.0064094677,
0.0044280412,
-0.0355535299,
-0.03007585,
0.0132222958,
0.012824012,
-0.0309066121,
-0.0552061573,
0.0231585521,
-0.0024443637,
0.0362477638,
0.0179805215,
-0.0087379068,
-0.0276065916,
-0.1238325089,
0.000078833,
-0.009175688,
0.0677924752,
0.0317448601,
0.0088087544,
0.0188311189,
0.0140128601,
-0.0277893655,
-0.0020304255,
-0.0557534732,
0.021762168,
0.040667627,
0.0228804741,
0.0165128037,
-0.0569691695,
-0.0140922833,
-0.0360144861,
0.0224965364,
0.034283977,
-0.0512930267,
-0.0227785744,
0.0419377908,
-0.0066038808,
0.0376529805,
0.0128168948,
-0.0232808255,
-0.0001438317,
-0.0193786267,
-0.0060778749,
0.0502552576,
-0.0169062726,
0.0243365094,
0.0210540108,
-0.0202832948,
-0.0415108092,
0.0553107411,
-0.0444977358,
0.0714413524,
-0.0063036475,
-0.0102185328,
0.0023733284,
0.0842487216,
0.0067558363,
-0.0248382203,
-0.03564208,
-0.0008522151,
-0.0030998997,
0.0129342545,
0.0150276339,
-0.0123135094,
0.0110275671,
-0.0336401053,
-0.0100345369,
0.0012377283,
0.0761828572,
0.0302799791,
-0.0129144285,
-0.104119435,
-0.0101032192,
-0.03451363,
0.0786271691,
0.0048746821,
-0.0054226294,
0.0747113377,
0.003693132,
-0.0251802783,
0.0007762297,
-0.0120293666,
0.0207951739,
0.0288716666,
-0.0259931888,
0.0102758808,
0.0301008262,
-0.0776525438,
0.002265106,
-0.0508884378,
-0.0237112474,
-0.0051654521,
0.0212743115,
-0.0420120396,
0.0613774918,
-0.0452309847,
-0.0151589289,
-0.0096392613,
-0.0142643219,
-0.0336449221,
-0.0104548018,
0.0463100374,
0.0383342169,
-0.0430305265,
-0.0073239957,
-0.0058012479,
-0.0034005921,
0.0634581596,
-0.0031927479,
-0.0211946666,
-0.0276274215,
-0.0123162987,
0.0294048488,
-0.0078034727,
-0.0494410731,
-0.0528666303,
0.0527621657,
-0.0418097563,
-0.0249892119,
0.112519525,
0.0463171601,
-0.0553968064,
-0.0025931417,
-0.0074061733,
0.0282234326,
0.016662091,
0.0308926366,
-0.0451986343,
-0.0406433716,
-0.0268919487,
0.0034446565,
-0.0138706304,
-0.0293378998,
0.033576183,
-0.0536922775,
-0.000870592,
-0.05019008,
0.0269126222,
-0.0082751326,
-0.0501318462,
0.0243989527,
-0.0509246774,
-0.0096537899,
-0.0487936586,
0.0299502891,
0.0079627605,
-0.0021939978,
0.0137103042,
-0.0156979132,
0.0559930429,
-0.0083282683,
-0.0075221038,
0.0454185903,
0.0498665944,
-0.0307143815,
-0.0111865681,
0.0378572159,
-0.038181562,
-0.0101825902,
-0.0250065513,
0.1015789509,
-0.0319545083,
-0.0233637858,
-0.0393238328,
0.0148671325,
-0.0471229479,
0.0099239787,
-0.0131909298,
0.0586776286,
-0.0241918992,
0.0253496412,
0.0091860546,
-0.0171467252,
0.0478441864,
0.0342756212,
-0.0150201423,
-0.0779219642,
-0.0168364737,
-0.0243069734,
-0.0126321511,
-0.0771124661,
-0.0220044497,
-0.0569313094,
-0.0133547327,
-0.0266134441,
-0.0786400735,
-0.0382137485,
-0.0042812717,
0.0113228811,
0.0013875659,
-0.0159942452,
0.0629216582,
-0.0168334525,
-0.0523666665,
0.0269087479,
0.0421621688,
0.030741008,
0.026009595,
-0.0432121344,
0.0706275627,
0.0027242966,
-0.0233444218,
-0.0384373143,
-0.036412511,
-0.0201641414,
-0.0236221477,
0.0330401212,
0.0005968508,
0.010733855,
-0.0186573509,
0.0290774703,
-0.0287416112,
0.0463190861,
-0.0419664457,
-0.0039583873,
0.077744022,
0.0273690354,
0.0332726799,
0.031837564,
-0.0129852984,
0.0273016691,
0.0049558938,
-0.0131762922,
-0.0574978516,
-0.0350497141,
0.0157811623,
-0.014318753,
0.0778095052,
0.0708560571,
-0.0168054588,
-0.0691770613,
0.0184875038,
-0.030256046,
-0.0311160982,
-0.0545410998,
0.022530349,
-0.0328126028,
0.0171221159,
-0.0602953136,
0.115843825,
0.0092576323,
0.030281255,
-0.0515607484,
0.0610710196,
0.0102025224,
0.0010163216,
-0.013920838,
-0.0028166552,
-0.0159393437,
-0.0676016882,
0.0317880884,
0.001737014,
-0.0234605707,
0.0549441166,
0.0107180011,
-0.0286445264,
-0.0010048883,
0.0332942344,
-0.0180352423,
0.0371804051,
-0.0429662317,
0.0036393967,
0.0049177622,
-0.0546977557,
0.0694972947,
-0.0619106367,
0.0148515478,
-0.0024375082,
0.0136704035,
-0.0113650523,
-0.0153652504,
0.0294244904,
0.0105325561,
-0.0210836809,
-0.0182736013,
0.0451908074,
-0.0971784368,
0.046534203,
0.0240952168,
-0.0359872766,
-0.0338174403,
-0.0295636915,
0.0759822652,
0.0050572646,
-0.0078334436,
0.0281034075,
-0.0286730323,
-0.0460425578,
0.0262978524,
-0.0415366516,
0.0266895741,
-0.0090933433,
0.0537928902,
0.0514758155,
0.0405037366,
0.0056789559,
-0.0545936152,
0.0028142368,
-0.0209982693,
-0.0302608311,
-0.0338545069,
-6.844916094e-33,
-0.0125985676,
0.0095943557,
-0.0297198053,
0.0155246574,
-0.0184514187,
0.0061835875,
-0.0282361209,
0.0383563153,
-0.0097152302,
0.0287857279,
0.0376059934,
0.0338313729,
-0.0057223141,
0.0405905023,
0.0441035889,
0.0231403764,
0.0301877931,
-0.0179872978,
0.0270397831,
0.0237475,
0.0671075433,
0.0107342228,
0.056779433,
-0.0941374153,
0.0487557575,
0.0164953656,
-0.028718546,
0.0365574248,
0.0032172517,
0.0387756042,
-0.0065591633,
0.0515741855,
0.0310682934,
-0.0140736438,
0.0166548006,
0.0591392443,
-0.0274313688,
-0.0530313998,
-0.0037806488,
0.0038846494,
-0.0390963517,
-0.0175435096,
0.0048161638,
0.0077867336,
-0.0019515511,
0.0228455774,
0.0338086151,
-0.0083289519,
0.0298106875,
-0.0438977107,
-0.053785637,
0.0047595175,
-0.0123587502,
-0.0274875481,
0.0250881985,
0.0604847595,
0.0389521755,
-0.009439596,
-0.0241095144,
-0.0120249493,
-0.0886114836,
0.0570289977,
-0.031089874,
-0.0000957888,
0.002213018,
0.0693126693,
-0.0171295051,
0.0159556773,
-0.023796754,
0.0671488941,
0.0067533902,
0.0296754669,
0.016748419,
0.0019231326,
-0.0296634715,
0.0033279213,
-0.0527429692,
0.0107853683,
0.100017719,
0.0051867804,
0.0393956043,
0.0221223086,
-0.0472900122,
-0.0247578509,
0.0232860707,
0.004632487,
-0.0331226662,
-0.0227334704,
-0.0174105465,
-0.0130348932,
0.0127747729,
0.0436159372,
-0.0206288323,
-0.0159548074,
-0.003896099,
0.002463389,
-0.0517449193,
0.0558725782,
0.0165775176,
-0.0086439382,
-0.0609783903,
-0.0089770667,
-0.0420978442,
0.0056242836,
0.0248209648,
0.0160650574,
0.0905577615,
0.0071705482,
-0.0557555854,
-0.0234961938,
-0.0371252634,
0.0041617337,
-0.0080156345,
0.0788877159,
-0.0015714341,
0.0192827042,
-0.0234403089,
0.1275778562,
0.0150550362,
0.0495660529,
-0.0473427996,
-0.0223002434,
-0.0239414014,
0.0108898524,
-0.0010705134,
-0.042342443,
0.0110872304,
0.0130362818,
-0.0496173762,
-0.0555111691,
-0.0214271285,
-0.0052131014,
2.973e-7,
0.0398418009,
0.0748530328,
0.0003744692,
0.0256314948,
0.0400613658,
0.0732821524,
0.0026017104,
0.0362458415,
-0.0094983773,
-0.009351233,
0.0157937612,
0.0111349691,
0.0070492225,
0.0352973156,
-0.1052025631,
0.0181084126,
0.018143896,
-0.0190150905,
-0.0225837249,
0.0089344075,
0.0996237472,
0.0686916485,
0.029354997,
0.0159674976,
-0.0137839764,
0.0213367883,
0.028879296,
-0.0045644338,
-0.0492149368,
0.0247274451,
-0.0517435744,
-0.0003880867,
-0.0361596234,
0.0224678256,
-0.031249946,
-0.0067721559,
-0.0043684761,
0.0610545613,
0.0150549794,
-0.0540311374,
0.0267311949,
0.028894145,
0.0316789225,
0.0118997414,
0.0567942485,
-0.0557498671,
-0.048269026,
-0.0191035215,
0.0051584146,
0.0473569222,
-0.0084717311,
0.0245583188,
-0.0366838276,
0.0183309205,
-0.0276159924,
-0.0462813564,
-0.0353193246,
-0.042547565,
-0.0143794436,
0.0696209222,
-0.0291970521,
-0.0322345942,
-0.0081711076,
0.000803435,
-0.0160081387,
-0.0471794978,
0.0150144296,
2.933366944e-34,
0.0335563831,
-0.0194537509,
0.0118272537,
0.0591450036,
0.0238687433,
0.0071057058,
-0.080339767,
-0.0012844875,
0.0346257351,
-0.0252596587,
-0.0083767381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16882v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16882v1 | Optimisation-Based Multi-Modal Semantic Image Editing | 2023-11-28T15:31:11 | 2023-11-28T15:31:11 | Bowen Li, Yongxin Yang, Steven McDonagh, Shifeng Zhang, Petru-Daniel Tudosiu, Sarah Parisot | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Image editing affords increased control over the aesthetics and content of
generated images. Pre-existing works focus predominantly on text-based
instructions to achieve desired image modifications, which limit edit precision
and accuracy. In this work, we propose an inference-time editing optimisation,
designed to extend beyond textual edits to accommodate multiple editing
instruction types (e.g. spatial layout-based; pose, scribbles, edge maps). We
propose to disentangle the editing task into two competing subtasks: successful
local image modifications and global content consistency preservation, where
subtasks are guided through two dedicated loss functions. By allowing to adjust
the influence of each loss function, we build a flexible editing solution that
can be adjusted to user preferences. We evaluate our method using text, pose
and scribble edit conditions, and highlight our ability to achieve complex
edits, through both qualitative and quantitative experiments. | [
0.0195922013,
0.0688626468,
0.0299692377,
0.0054212348,
-0.0455712117,
-0.0251098406,
0.0154741863,
0.0240350012,
-0.0579553433,
-0.0657113343,
-0.0386054069,
0.0197585989,
0.0344206579,
-0.0305400323,
-0.0200242642,
-0.0952640399,
-0.0090946387,
-0.0170436278,
-0.041979555,
-0.0030945949,
0.0297989137,
-0.0252405256,
-0.0079037584,
-0.0072980067,
-0.0667170212,
-0.0143673681,
-0.062666893,
0.0901572853,
0.0180995762,
-0.0071336767,
-0.0354446471,
0.0844250619,
0.0056629647,
0.0151889306,
0.0000024484,
-0.0246294327,
-0.0228463337,
0.0408172384,
0.0410526395,
0.0318976901,
0.0504808873,
-0.0188492984,
-0.0534190647,
-0.0835388675,
0.0199186783,
0.0481605642,
0.1156658381,
0.0375852585,
0.1251592487,
0.0453622043,
-0.025348682,
-0.0185617302,
-0.0316936225,
-0.0252741519,
0.0477333441,
0.0116245849,
0.0245779641,
0.0078426665,
-0.0324731134,
-0.0095917014,
-0.0563906394,
0.0445793346,
0.0244862083,
-0.0156390499,
0.0127219157,
0.0195555817,
0.0284348391,
-0.0190745536,
-0.0088724811,
0.0019397616,
-0.0395564996,
0.0322677679,
0.018379923,
-0.0316402614,
-0.0124647934,
0.0421643667,
-0.0124371629,
-0.0178135391,
-0.0222693104,
-0.0170476008,
-0.069681935,
-0.0152775282,
0.0044937753,
-0.0138068674,
-0.0027038415,
-0.0065293568,
0.0512668304,
0.0062739844,
-0.0598559976,
0.0118434262,
-0.0538039729,
-0.0741701946,
0.0521433726,
-0.0218954664,
0.0026741649,
-0.0025999681,
-0.0900045708,
-0.053510081,
-0.0029335779,
0.0077053523,
0.0549844205,
0.0498513132,
0.0014698524,
0.0552823953,
-0.0020113145,
0.0161888991,
-0.01648633,
0.0511133261,
-0.0222933963,
-0.0066832402,
-0.005192122,
-0.0155419102,
-0.0450055674,
-0.0276034921,
-0.0683075562,
-0.0081398021,
-0.0275735017,
0.0044301199,
-0.0289430935,
0.0426947884,
-0.0013121086,
0.0403255187,
-0.0960564911,
-0.0219264794,
-0.0374187976,
-0.0175808035,
0.0213598143,
0.0491277017,
-0.0068861558,
0.0269280896,
0.0164794941,
0.0181616638,
0.0454232432,
-0.0045397119,
-0.0249220654,
0.0763225332,
-0.0515710674,
0.0215918589,
-0.0334987119,
-0.0252382755,
-0.0176966954,
-0.0154577512,
0.0108909253,
-0.0246781576,
0.0522019118,
-0.0227349214,
-0.0318023153,
-0.1004490554,
-0.0092859864,
0.0154058337,
0.0079346448,
0.0512025319,
-0.0417834781,
0.0010146211,
0.0639131367,
0.0370813273,
-0.0507052764,
0.0324482657,
0.0330909193,
0.0295640975,
0.0327549987,
-0.0029267166,
-0.0398049578,
0.0305847842,
0.0184611548,
0.0005800315,
-0.0230704192,
-0.0131564504,
0.0425273404,
0.0489685945,
0.0351225212,
0.0237985272,
-0.1010670885,
-0.0352059491,
0.0996858925,
-0.0083994661,
0.0598237775,
0.0257210806,
0.0259986874,
-0.0132379225,
-0.0164186396,
-0.0032580022,
-0.0723497793,
0.0335165039,
0.0533636808,
0.0221406016,
0.020499615,
-0.0170303136,
-0.0117622409,
-0.0272388365,
0.0069062952,
0.0122950748,
0.0123690255,
-0.0425882228,
0.0159002412,
0.0403702483,
-0.0138436994,
0.0334163681,
-0.0316404551,
-0.0381948054,
-0.0110965893,
-0.0159529056,
-0.0149017023,
0.0572024174,
0.0032659434,
-0.0060079107,
-0.0063201734,
0.0080284346,
0.0505632199,
0.0412699357,
-0.0206892677,
0.0063572167,
0.0612767003,
-0.0273900013,
-0.0296868961,
-0.0463890843,
0.0017803314,
0.0144351078,
0.0310696587,
-0.0088245692,
-0.0037023413,
0.0261293575,
-0.0018471102,
0.021141706,
0.0659758076,
-0.0149209574,
-0.004600645,
0.0249175467,
-0.0103148334,
-0.0227121748,
-0.0342517421,
-0.0077657765,
-0.0281930864,
0.0124686789,
-0.0145051284,
-0.0035410204,
0.0020232927,
0.0149648748,
-0.0022014396,
-0.0477590002,
-0.0396324843,
-0.0449657068,
-0.0143567957,
-0.0047236821,
-0.0205436908,
-0.0014596049,
0.0252311807,
-0.0285877902,
-0.014465305,
0.017854102,
-0.0330335014,
-0.0148074375,
0.0075014848,
-0.0280723386,
-0.0050897426,
0.0461328477,
0.0494327806,
-0.0320801064,
-0.0034881358,
0.0035463683,
-0.0387328044,
0.0217425022,
0.0056620161,
-0.0108822482,
0.0260086283,
-0.033725027,
-0.0426318422,
-0.0530921035,
-0.0257258154,
0.001462083,
0.0190976653,
0.0406861939,
0.0419967882,
-0.0000746843,
-0.0120576387,
-0.0001064751,
0.0245698188,
-0.053810142,
0.0354147293,
0.0275446232,
0.0362972543,
0.0432293564,
-0.0248380229,
0.0097074797,
0.0384027734,
0.0065593529,
0.0516472012,
-0.0223529246,
-0.0399446525,
0.0277375672,
-0.0261971224,
0.0040510767,
0.0270183012,
0.0186109263,
-0.0260476172,
0.0018216406,
0.0199961346,
0.0910720602,
-0.030551577,
0.0077735553,
0.0273958948,
-0.0336533524,
-0.0317241922,
0.0093429917,
-0.0009314073,
0.0431875326,
0.0325158127,
-0.0122816106,
0.0009015867,
0.0485577956,
0.0230488423,
0.0430419259,
0.000863476,
0.0388140865,
-0.000418603,
-0.0263192263,
0.0031864736,
0.0209660232,
0.0071926476,
0.0009332037,
-0.082733795,
-0.0727507919,
0.0350885503,
-0.0116341542,
-0.0217635743,
0.0467365533,
0.0179523416,
0.0419661589,
0.0343392827,
0.0024565323,
0.0317967758,
-0.0300999172,
0.0184178539,
-0.083510235,
-0.0216644369,
0.1071639881,
0.0257100314,
-0.0202484187,
-0.0715973526,
-0.001632682,
-0.0513971709,
-0.0088519799,
0.035333205,
0.0129506122,
0.0329104327,
-0.0026673505,
-0.0006441055,
-0.0312462151,
0.0325909257,
0.0034837918,
-0.0141128171,
0.0514728241,
-0.0191052519,
-0.0557222515,
-0.003995521,
0.0131309461,
0.0131991571,
0.0246641766,
-0.0757567957,
-0.034675885,
-0.0463332608,
0.096424751,
-0.0113568427,
-0.0320488997,
-0.0253534298,
0.0313856788,
0.0115006696,
0.0075467494,
-0.0221065897,
0.013749226,
0.0796913281,
-0.0697502792,
-0.023351742,
0.0234295633,
0.018837506,
-0.0067503052,
-0.0250739139,
-0.0023704916,
0.0290578827,
0.0326058716,
0.0079976302,
-0.081361033,
-0.0680757165,
0.0072368295,
-0.0116206734,
-0.0043257247,
-0.014003071,
-0.0193812195,
0.0123543469,
0.0505477414,
-0.0041297404,
-0.0657000914,
0.0256539024,
0.0074794963,
0.04879985,
-0.0041136658,
-0.0614701509,
0.0055652717,
0.0105766971,
-0.0021009336,
-0.0119825313,
0.0631633177,
0.0053705932,
-0.0578509904,
-0.025988033,
-0.0161569361,
0.0350859761,
-0.0094056493,
0.0371056236,
-0.0603304058,
0.0423406586,
0.0537077636,
-0.0109035177,
-0.0564410388,
0.0388780795,
-0.0068757627,
0.0268763229,
-0.0132284136,
0.037244197,
0.080760181,
-0.029978862,
-0.0067965719,
0.0311715268,
-0.0212835912,
0.0298458133,
-0.0187990218,
-0.0484321862,
0.0113931624,
-0.0172589496,
0.0182406623,
-0.0315161087,
-0.0596122332,
-0.0673219189,
0.0110563794,
-0.0620489046,
0.0005271848,
-0.0057096588,
-0.0549534373,
-0.0670008063,
-0.0250905901,
-0.0037764525,
0.0213641245,
0.0250138808,
-0.0129841976,
-0.0466140099,
-0.0515230075,
0.0082823094,
-0.1031018943,
-0.0240316205,
-0.0050041042,
0.0108592715,
0.0054468983,
0.0278198533,
0.0341196917,
-0.0009487271,
-0.0139720459,
-0.0046062288,
-0.077056922,
-0.0437251367,
-0.0166012309,
0.0632384866,
0.0095498497,
0.0481434129,
0.0146812731,
-0.0690917149,
0.0236389395,
0.0335482508,
-0.0036704959,
0.023358969,
0.0471550077,
0.0170976743,
0.0021886693,
0.006166623,
-0.0469143018,
-0.0208824072,
0.0439541228,
0.0084915878,
0.0088505549,
-0.0246641729,
-0.0122654242,
-0.013826861,
-0.0242289808,
-0.0205450319,
0.0331501774,
-0.0154142836,
0.0360895582,
-0.0170055628,
-0.0124143912,
-0.0489451177,
0.0061493907,
-0.0479660034,
0.008299714,
0.0096319383,
0.0245129783,
0.0229825806,
-0.0092804749,
-0.0281290449,
0.0052520386,
0.0094244322,
0.0027609093,
0.0281537045,
0.0437983014,
0.0182397943,
0.0528574698,
0.007248336,
0.0076673189,
-0.0182710625,
0.0310532711,
0.0408422202,
-0.0017491045,
-0.0458376668,
0.0439567603,
-0.0189511422,
0.0014108695,
-0.0452338532,
0.0373498052,
0.063895002,
0.0261419006,
0.0460047908,
-0.0207018945,
-0.0308590978,
-0.0015943027,
0.0798325837,
0.058964733,
-0.0275659412,
0.0227469504,
-0.0329807214,
0.0408689901,
0.0013919953,
0.0239282213,
-0.056390468,
0.0447318666,
-0.050109148,
-0.0689532757,
-0.0260966886,
-0.0368475057,
-0.022935532,
0.0112673892,
-0.0115563739,
-0.0260132086,
-0.0272432789,
-0.0144914137,
0.0081253676,
0.0603149347,
-0.0185610782,
0.0220606383,
0.0491981059,
0.018879436,
-0.0331036001,
0.0119853662,
0.0187761728,
-0.0274481792,
0.0031665182,
-0.002144109,
0.0161796529,
-5.765291757e-33,
-0.0168935228,
-0.0387341417,
0.0191739984,
0.0074755959,
-0.0017337365,
-0.0215991549,
-0.0232680887,
0.01578141,
0.0621751547,
-0.0170323215,
0.0133198276,
-0.009162304,
-0.0056681377,
0.0135810431,
0.0044725956,
0.0359797925,
0.0417569354,
0.0246965718,
-0.0553447604,
-0.0243192147,
0.0289420169,
-0.0032641159,
0.0381023027,
-0.0248391107,
-0.0258459561,
0.0361131765,
-0.0135258222,
-0.0332234167,
-0.0266876146,
0.0525732264,
0.0010371155,
-0.023437392,
-0.0199779682,
-0.0437108018,
-0.0101579856,
-0.0479689166,
-0.0654266253,
-0.0409657396,
-0.0337373503,
0.0276339874,
-0.1012591496,
-0.052809,
0.0385961309,
0.0362092108,
-0.0298792291,
-0.0417443626,
0.0094074663,
-0.00288394,
0.0128072565,
-0.0577279404,
-0.027117759,
0.0306804031,
-0.0006928884,
-0.0504010022,
0.0189885385,
-0.0309176221,
0.0556352437,
-0.0063747456,
-0.0973157734,
-0.005831094,
-0.0193277765,
0.0080432305,
0.0446957797,
0.0096926885,
0.0155778136,
-0.0084420042,
0.019044213,
-0.0210184995,
0.0447985679,
0.0290806238,
-0.0048615728,
0.0426823348,
-0.0275905151,
0.0636989325,
0.0586274527,
0.012833246,
-0.0179066081,
0.0246233754,
-0.0884566084,
0.040072985,
-0.025099799,
0.073697716,
0.0723384097,
0.0165760107,
-0.0557116084,
-0.0165786184,
-0.045682814,
-0.0135611035,
0.0387653336,
0.026965389,
-0.0130131757,
0.054663837,
0.0279800482,
0.0335582793,
0.0041766409,
-0.0736951008,
-0.0599792823,
0.0826113969,
-0.01910167,
-0.0498989709,
0.0425486453,
-0.0049756318,
0.0527612306,
-0.004646563,
0.0225858316,
-0.0042688991,
0.0101070842,
0.0543849543,
-0.0244299248,
-0.0119914617,
0.0020955165,
-0.0041789063,
0.0096818469,
-0.0467690341,
0.0078557534,
-0.0066741067,
-0.0467804186,
0.0117629189,
0.0215668846,
0.059711203,
-0.0398903564,
-0.0133409807,
-0.0022156178,
0.0060901423,
-0.0240349248,
0.0288319439,
0.0025650293,
-0.0472844169,
-0.0137613593,
-0.0581536442,
-0.0504951105,
0.018095497,
2.971e-7,
0.0311672073,
0.0313603133,
0.0116353827,
-0.0243750606,
0.0300512109,
0.0377220511,
-0.0126651637,
0.0049129678,
-0.0491733924,
-0.0031203458,
0.0260682609,
0.0252833199,
0.0336782597,
0.0140510155,
-0.0026842391,
0.0126242824,
0.0332748182,
0.047391247,
-0.0173154306,
0.0370821357,
0.0510139354,
-0.009168122,
-0.0085883457,
-0.0411701351,
0.0537031963,
0.0240469687,
0.087824516,
-0.0245611072,
0.0669881552,
-0.0194327068,
-0.002588317,
-0.0133629404,
0.011155203,
-0.0074263955,
-0.020414263,
-0.0659139454,
0.023866035,
0.0810831413,
-0.0696531087,
0.0369181782,
0.0042565963,
0.0128741274,
-0.0086952252,
0.0010919131,
0.03355949,
-0.0638022125,
0.0012092361,
0.0108179431,
-0.0154697746,
0.0422037095,
0.0393601246,
-0.0159983262,
-0.0359110944,
-0.0048653628,
0.0364262089,
0.0614486188,
-0.055528678,
-0.0124349594,
-0.0418421738,
-0.0098969396,
0.0058485991,
-0.0344692282,
-0.0500552915,
-0.008612941,
0.0273804888,
-0.0600682087,
-0.0754013285,
2.602193681e-34,
-0.0170191191,
0.022357177,
0.0351864658,
0.0294734873,
0.0316828042,
0.0328792222,
0.0088561699,
-0.0197009165,
0.0015347301,
-0.0073609692,
-0.0482321121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03738v1 | Syntactic Fusion: Enhancing Aspect-Level Sentiment Analysis Through Multi-Tree Graph Integration | 2023-11-28T15:28:22 | 2023-11-28T15:28:22 | Jane Sunny, Tom Padraig, Roggie Terry, Woods Ali | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent progress in aspect-level sentiment classification has been propelled
by the incorporation of graph neural networks (GNNs) leveraging syntactic
structures, particularly dependency trees. Nevertheless, the performance of
these models is often hampered by the innate inaccuracies of parsing
algorithms. To mitigate this challenge, we introduce SynthFusion, an innovative
graph ensemble method that amalgamates predictions from multiple parsers. This
strategy blends diverse dependency relations prior to the application of GNNs,
enhancing robustness against parsing errors while avoiding extra computational
burdens. SynthFusion circumvents the pitfalls of overparameterization and
diminishes the risk of overfitting, prevalent in models with stacked GNN
layers, by optimizing graph connectivity. Our empirical evaluations on the
SemEval14 and Twitter14 datasets affirm that SynthFusion not only outshines
models reliant on single dependency trees but also eclipses alternative
ensemble techniques, achieving this without an escalation in model complexity. | [
0.0234242305,
0.0611509085,
0.0287444834,
0.0216664486,
-0.0475222692,
0.0087270765,
-0.0385420136,
-0.0243312847,
0.042606581,
-0.0415549017,
0.0067418301,
-0.0286747273,
0.0040230076,
0.0526224561,
-0.0147744622,
-0.0190273374,
0.0035166861,
0.0549864136,
-0.0225306544,
-0.0325888805,
0.0152917709,
0.0660293326,
0.039822679,
0.0128533058,
-0.0309709515,
-0.0232885219,
0.0314867496,
0.0535034612,
0.0137671586,
-0.0012728263,
0.0177183151,
0.0227802414,
-0.0107673332,
0.0487892218,
0.0000021103,
-0.012716407,
-0.0172831155,
-8.068e-7,
0.0143335378,
-0.0080444776,
0.0484298095,
-0.0542436689,
0.0225798823,
0.0185237397,
-0.0459602065,
-0.0564176813,
0.0292284079,
0.0598865375,
0.0578662008,
0.0766555741,
-0.0392443649,
-0.0295732599,
0.0276704431,
-0.0191456322,
-0.0519843288,
-0.0057345061,
0.0067765769,
-0.0424452759,
-0.0247431807,
0.0004099917,
-0.0168234222,
0.0109410975,
0.0338700898,
-0.0117092151,
0.0687608197,
0.0296879932,
-0.0033530165,
0.0241524857,
-0.0348059759,
0.0611871369,
0.0074651288,
-0.0249577146,
-0.0120537812,
-0.0210295077,
-0.0082931444,
0.0197372921,
-0.0193222426,
-0.0374862924,
-0.0123668974,
0.067500934,
0.0080039231,
-0.0060867444,
0.0509699918,
0.017611945,
0.0078138663,
0.0737055168,
-0.0258178506,
-0.0328765064,
0.0444668308,
0.0790020004,
-0.0305225588,
-0.0110066161,
-0.0028977597,
-0.0311721843,
-0.0109680844,
0.0029453584,
-0.0289778225,
0.0148692057,
-0.0064978991,
-0.0596658438,
0.0074979393,
-0.0164898224,
0.0043775574,
0.0304956287,
0.0003643437,
-0.0238391608,
-0.0290185753,
0.0085527785,
-0.0437850133,
0.0000876087,
-0.0789354071,
0.0015749848,
0.0104067661,
0.0474843346,
-0.0418810323,
-0.0457629152,
-0.0744315684,
0.0005465174,
-0.0232256018,
0.0041914568,
0.0340431184,
0.0608063191,
0.0352172963,
-0.0122319963,
0.0024309463,
0.055488579,
-0.0006788683,
0.0248964764,
-0.0076200585,
-0.0174881704,
-0.0245633461,
0.0476997569,
0.0264199898,
-0.0171324275,
-0.0004173048,
0.0262773223,
0.0358706191,
-0.0226604044,
0.0085200453,
-0.0452626571,
-0.0420203991,
-0.0488408357,
0.0324073471,
-0.0927697122,
0.0326152034,
0.0035458729,
0.0087639838,
-0.0116099948,
0.0185735431,
0.0014931592,
-0.0349076539,
0.0432945378,
-0.0450284965,
-0.0360436253,
-0.041962225,
-0.0331096277,
0.007531974,
0.0451885015,
-0.0108515723,
0.0638943687,
-0.0027701142,
0.019367639,
-0.0455039106,
-0.0148093617,
-0.001059929,
-0.0084381057,
-0.0187579077,
-0.0223898273,
-0.0774487033,
-0.0322586186,
-0.0084162094,
0.0626049638,
-0.0074134781,
-0.0139127402,
0.0344986506,
-0.0037593194,
-0.0132653238,
0.0404349528,
0.0192532074,
-0.0070734671,
-0.0047592432,
-0.0054268013,
-0.05942709,
-0.0122223943,
-0.0028801286,
-0.0092957104,
0.0140471281,
0.0319604687,
-0.0064696949,
-0.0518101454,
-0.0057136598,
-0.0569829829,
0.0319688544,
0.0009628275,
0.0507409237,
-0.0102764899,
-0.0638736486,
0.005188542,
0.0345947444,
-0.0421228223,
-0.0337081701,
0.0298723783,
-0.0201804303,
0.084124364,
-0.0064467797,
0.0036171863,
0.005939771,
-0.0210054871,
-0.0300291236,
-0.0046187304,
0.0282516684,
0.0029986824,
0.0207126029,
-0.0242673326,
-0.0214207787,
-0.0355083458,
0.0306429304,
0.0346286073,
-0.0265537445,
-0.0100493766,
-0.001765979,
-0.0131733818,
-0.0160829294,
-0.0049199942,
0.0332783572,
0.0073514748,
0.017906934,
-0.0070981509,
0.0427691564,
0.0753566697,
-0.0294416603,
0.0193716045,
0.018786693,
-0.029823212,
-0.0959288999,
0.021321699,
-0.0785037801,
-0.0874859393,
0.0237847734,
-0.0011433646,
-0.0326541066,
0.0092310663,
-0.0617139526,
-0.0449018367,
0.043525219,
-0.0436969958,
0.0577963367,
-0.0025277238,
-0.011446178,
0.0014491918,
0.0383754559,
0.023944879,
0.0657292604,
-0.042266205,
-0.0080511859,
-0.0706079677,
0.0088744797,
0.0212907568,
0.0171128102,
-0.0121345073,
0.0034856379,
0.0095210522,
0.0118944524,
0.022122059,
-0.0094009312,
-0.0602746643,
-0.0084618824,
-0.12687473,
-0.0023334685,
-0.0071260552,
0.037412826,
-0.0116024837,
0.0133213662,
0.0278767925,
0.0007928334,
-0.0182009824,
0.0174005944,
0.0071093165,
0.0231596529,
0.0225641076,
0.0048193703,
0.015257203,
-0.0241517872,
-0.056387309,
-0.0605830066,
0.0644186214,
0.0066612265,
-0.0879505649,
0.0149144335,
0.0225206949,
-0.0172560439,
0.0071725962,
-0.0016023113,
-0.0061336947,
-0.0240453798,
-0.0268879756,
-0.0144647053,
0.0473784655,
-0.0458710343,
0.0049418593,
0.0059593134,
-0.0082975253,
-0.0174621698,
0.0201229993,
-0.0337836109,
0.0470651276,
-0.019814549,
0.014464031,
-0.0270777177,
0.0541808233,
-0.0075866645,
-0.001583066,
-0.0419765264,
0.0106872283,
-0.002420706,
0.0011890384,
0.0392281823,
-0.0425226018,
0.0110368161,
-0.0351791494,
-0.0426491722,
-0.03392829,
0.0852720514,
0.015309941,
-0.0199775733,
-0.014828871,
-0.055687882,
-0.0697438493,
0.0428935364,
0.0425144024,
-0.0011111664,
0.0387314372,
0.0027391023,
0.0130432686,
-0.0119409626,
0.0012387643,
0.0002378331,
0.0619334579,
0.0298130792,
0.028579697,
0.0186850112,
-0.042327635,
0.0337267667,
-0.0471351705,
-0.0634873956,
0.0133736944,
0.0058522942,
-0.0416012108,
0.0247798767,
-0.0508244932,
-0.0509109162,
-0.0124181705,
-0.0164427795,
-0.0281304978,
0.0045869942,
0.0391553417,
0.0068863155,
-0.0381873101,
0.0396537445,
-0.0238832477,
0.0491974317,
0.0593108423,
0.0290160514,
0.0093940115,
-0.0493782386,
-0.0228893179,
0.0002064865,
0.0422140956,
-0.0480048731,
-0.0624175481,
0.0562872142,
-0.0263530388,
0.0329801627,
0.0872053131,
0.0220818315,
-0.0492152609,
-0.0121869864,
0.0450684242,
0.0342746489,
0.0137790991,
-0.0061567165,
-0.0614906736,
-0.0399391055,
-0.0260762665,
0.0105413916,
0.0164666418,
-0.0313500203,
0.0170838367,
-0.0930996835,
0.0040095923,
0.0336222313,
-0.0084176632,
-0.0310161505,
-0.0232129563,
-0.0097830286,
-0.0194227342,
-0.0359413363,
-0.0669727698,
0.0063881995,
0.0026072285,
0.005723089,
-0.0305180643,
-0.0283769146,
0.0160969682,
-0.0158064384,
-0.0053258026,
0.0208933465,
0.0542729087,
-0.0085550677,
0.0211762022,
0.0490237363,
-0.0210120622,
-0.0291667264,
-0.0318297446,
0.102862522,
0.0089081535,
0.0026107992,
-0.0048437295,
-0.0021050491,
-0.0821185485,
0.0028871398,
-0.0482051931,
0.0586017445,
-0.0024701157,
-0.0556279384,
0.0082811853,
0.0128279012,
-0.0016769039,
-0.0129817938,
0.0246304832,
-0.0194620602,
-0.045799762,
-0.0522778407,
-0.0010894178,
-0.093969509,
0.0003263155,
-0.0006460348,
0.0144492956,
-0.0264061633,
-0.0534623973,
-0.0472474881,
-0.0345138311,
-0.0002549083,
-0.0549126454,
0.0162536632,
0.0310007669,
-0.0156568401,
-0.0261046849,
0.0407997146,
0.0205360185,
0.0567341298,
0.0374686383,
-0.0112304194,
0.046353437,
0.0396892577,
-0.0228173994,
-0.0070154131,
-0.0267805941,
-0.0830505341,
-0.0187531225,
0.0186131932,
0.007603439,
0.0173749272,
-0.0233057123,
0.0007580109,
0.0069066184,
0.0921341777,
0.0002772745,
0.0097810086,
0.0594673157,
0.0016944788,
0.0064496733,
0.0411434807,
-0.0342371836,
0.0357864127,
-0.0042116246,
-0.0197671968,
-0.0406789742,
-0.0285491496,
0.0195944495,
-0.0000944449,
0.0794150531,
0.0343237631,
-0.0054096803,
-0.03955153,
-0.0082380418,
-0.0336316638,
-0.0248474553,
-0.0373889878,
-0.0268846024,
0.0133710839,
0.0103558479,
-0.0366600789,
0.0062272991,
0.0350065641,
0.0319917873,
-0.0395681597,
0.0292142555,
0.0391064622,
-0.0346575864,
0.0058034016,
0.0201312937,
-0.0081392899,
-0.0282807965,
0.0256754197,
-0.0171399452,
-0.0153879998,
-0.0048117288,
0.0021648563,
0.0001727466,
-0.0105550839,
-0.0057250159,
-0.0732970163,
0.0216919873,
-0.0309071764,
-0.0251700208,
0.0587388799,
-0.0227643382,
0.0927983448,
-0.0200141259,
0.0040598884,
-0.0187719427,
0.023694871,
-0.0152126774,
-0.0182237942,
0.0521354191,
0.0132519109,
-0.0196922459,
0.0143971723,
0.0327178463,
-0.0410145782,
0.0312773921,
0.0463488363,
-0.0317811891,
-0.02959585,
-0.0389247946,
-0.0041588675,
0.0405927449,
0.0034388262,
0.0236910172,
-0.0490292758,
-0.0759659261,
0.0720232576,
-0.0212619137,
0.0166299846,
0.0141135929,
0.0216520056,
0.0187945738,
0.0294559617,
0.0199739859,
-0.0514415801,
0.0025928568,
-0.0090282438,
-0.0176393725,
-0.0156620685,
-6.763196462e-33,
-0.0024306143,
-0.0316591971,
-0.057054501,
0.0325619504,
-0.052124735,
0.0165914204,
-0.0379366726,
0.0287565999,
0.001819143,
0.0494256131,
0.0236288588,
0.0494212061,
-0.0004888223,
0.050670661,
0.0277281962,
-0.0028629745,
0.0335827917,
0.0034664525,
0.034698911,
0.0296883155,
0.0487575233,
0.0334695168,
0.0555995852,
-0.1115277335,
0.0273136478,
0.0061971457,
-0.0221534912,
0.020364007,
0.0004394406,
0.0255700797,
0.0280957911,
0.1093098819,
0.0345065109,
0.0191061664,
0.0026091665,
0.0497730896,
-0.0337140188,
-0.047780741,
0.0046238573,
-0.0056213965,
-0.0343034416,
-0.0373377316,
0.0539583489,
0.0183270648,
0.027865259,
-0.0590803213,
0.0290800594,
0.0175253488,
0.0077793528,
-0.0691030324,
-0.0390459374,
0.0528248996,
0.0000576019,
0.0138149504,
-0.0063880724,
0.0561150759,
0.0579030067,
0.0363358557,
-0.0403415002,
0.0121753514,
-0.0950929746,
0.0175362732,
-0.0288914237,
0.0052011223,
0.0006711751,
0.0607446469,
0.0202547312,
0.003168321,
-0.0388433076,
0.0455662198,
-0.011260964,
0.0316579081,
0.03193314,
0.0390128531,
0.0159264226,
0.001172388,
-0.0660004914,
0.0012991749,
0.0631982088,
-0.009241771,
0.0022601276,
0.0298351645,
0.0049953298,
-0.0304346327,
0.0387864113,
-0.0485773869,
-0.0103613455,
-0.0154576218,
-0.0578039661,
0.0040438431,
0.0061050379,
0.0570988543,
-0.0347472206,
-0.0820838884,
-0.0122249182,
0.0599063635,
-0.0096012764,
0.0527957268,
0.0066236323,
0.0144730927,
-0.0407332852,
-0.0053467639,
-0.0348104686,
0.0008754413,
0.0297879986,
-0.014719421,
0.0878357515,
0.0286540333,
-0.0822001621,
-0.0029896847,
-0.0370243415,
0.004695416,
-0.0259393137,
0.0390216261,
0.0320998393,
0.0430310182,
-0.012436009,
0.0480064861,
0.024034135,
0.100268878,
-0.025069939,
-0.0040214784,
0.0025222343,
0.003866222,
-0.0088574709,
-0.046039056,
0.0098203849,
0.0126227215,
0.0033046168,
-0.0414286703,
-0.0414865837,
-0.0012032625,
2.914e-7,
0.0769126117,
0.0391627587,
0.0147482827,
-0.0371797644,
0.026359519,
0.0552879348,
-0.0105066327,
0.0280047953,
-0.0110016381,
-0.0271872934,
0.0077423225,
0.023963131,
0.0259305555,
0.049577225,
-0.1095005497,
0.0341003872,
-0.0610483885,
-0.0169991497,
-0.0056521669,
0.0223571286,
0.0626716092,
0.0942856967,
0.0437135547,
-0.0283451322,
-0.0395299532,
-0.004341342,
0.0633188635,
-0.0067443391,
-0.0420186706,
-0.0090856561,
-0.0189260244,
-0.0033414506,
-0.0386352092,
0.0032188164,
-0.0203638896,
0.0213742908,
0.0059609693,
0.0442801118,
0.0022546179,
-0.0279807206,
0.024935225,
0.0082548168,
0.022327885,
-0.0024356076,
0.0396223143,
-0.0631764457,
-0.0563875772,
-0.0716598779,
-0.0204276014,
0.0061238473,
0.0717753917,
0.0551410951,
-0.0146673713,
0.0392486006,
0.005152002,
-0.0452265739,
-0.0135250967,
-0.0692911893,
-0.0162765626,
0.0406855233,
-0.016625559,
-0.0415083393,
0.0356651656,
0.0538129658,
0.0268901512,
-0.011588634,
-0.0013561145,
2.820039876e-34,
0.0694911703,
-0.0260212086,
0.0237141326,
0.0072642029,
0.0228964798,
-0.0207673423,
-0.0513045229,
-0.0095913755,
0.0254567638,
-0.0560328923,
0.0228114631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16867v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16867v2 | The Falcon Series of Open Language Models | 2023-11-28T15:12:47 | 2023-11-29T19:45:10 | Ebtesam Almazrouei, Hamza Alobeidli, Abdulaziz Alshamsi, Alessandro Cappelli, Ruxandra Cojocaru, Mérouane Debbah, Étienne Goffinet, Daniel Hesslow, Julien Launay, Quentin Malartic, Daniele Mazzotta, Badreddine Noune, Baptiste Pannier, Guilherme Penedo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce the Falcon series: 7B, 40B, and 180B parameters causal
decoder-only models trained on a diverse high-quality corpora predominantly
assembled from web data. The largest model, Falcon-180B, has been trained on
over 3.5 trillion tokens of text--the largest openly documented pretraining
run. Falcon-180B significantly outperforms models such as PaLM or Chinchilla,
and improves upon concurrently developed models such as LLaMA 2 or
Inflection-1. It nears the performance of PaLM-2-Large at a reduced pretraining
and inference cost, making it, to our knowledge, one of the three best language
models in the world along with GPT-4 and PaLM-2-Large. We report detailed
evaluations, as well as a deep dive into the methods and custom tooling
employed to pretrain Falcon. Notably, we report on our custom distributed
training codebase, allowing us to efficiently pretrain these models on up to
4,096 A100s on cloud AWS infrastructure with limited interconnect. We release a
600B tokens extract of our web dataset, as well as the Falcon-7/40/180B models
under a permissive license to foster open-science and accelerate the
development of an open ecosystem of large language models. | [
-0.0018660271,
0.1229948103,
0.0107374648,
0.0477044582,
-0.0082064904,
0.0273832995,
-0.0080283722,
0.0035172689,
-0.0220022965,
-0.027898537,
-0.0436238199,
-0.0096921474,
0.0113179795,
0.0414120108,
-0.011558366,
-0.0085790502,
0.0477803089,
-0.0264639445,
-0.0106060095,
-0.0096159121,
-0.0030808751,
0.0264783558,
-0.0142680248,
0.0457376875,
0.0298305918,
-0.0189301576,
0.0002164539,
0.019298289,
0.0016212135,
-0.0259035211,
0.032612849,
0.0668365359,
0.0241478309,
0.0794259384,
0.0000021165,
-0.0194200072,
-0.0145965153,
0.0057886248,
-0.0525461845,
0.0430867709,
-0.0001939629,
-0.0245151389,
-0.0112579493,
0.0409029722,
-0.0409402288,
-0.0819798857,
0.060264077,
0.018144263,
0.0468902588,
0.0930074081,
0.0069170301,
-0.0595000535,
0.057974536,
-0.0135434866,
-0.0460524186,
-0.002896036,
0.0050925678,
-0.0398428179,
-0.0275160577,
-0.0022813971,
-0.0574653782,
0.0155612854,
0.0410936624,
0.0498234741,
-0.0049838284,
0.0363400094,
-0.0255777147,
-0.0330122262,
-0.0068100402,
0.0878825337,
0.0159093775,
-0.0584395565,
-0.0128402021,
0.0156271495,
-0.0511940084,
-0.0000751494,
-0.0265232772,
0.060661938,
0.0072650393,
0.0445549488,
0.0603590459,
0.0129981702,
0.0361311845,
0.0358346961,
-0.0439276062,
0.0522874035,
0.0290376022,
-0.0366375856,
0.0027306695,
0.0217190422,
0.0210131146,
-0.0480139107,
0.0187819824,
-0.0095563382,
-0.018629076,
0.0123319952,
-0.050911814,
-0.0518681332,
0.0183266513,
-0.0156838931,
0.0429253541,
0.059273079,
-0.0408048891,
0.0399728566,
-0.0131833963,
0.0070116599,
-0.0447546132,
0.030980736,
-0.0185959525,
-0.0064563998,
-0.0110605294,
0.0103227459,
-0.0193181876,
0.0031163222,
-0.0665105507,
-0.025982162,
-0.0063116234,
0.0101139387,
0.0335620604,
-0.0037729763,
0.057674516,
0.0035843132,
-0.0417911895,
-0.0236180294,
0.03382615,
0.0615260489,
-0.0165544208,
0.0344787464,
-0.0043599154,
-0.1035479307,
-0.0279789511,
0.0133723868,
0.0125369765,
-0.0396059491,
0.0041403053,
0.0577721,
-0.0133954994,
-0.033080332,
-0.0204812046,
-0.0166963264,
0.0093644531,
-0.046837125,
-0.0351742469,
-0.0495103896,
-0.0019917707,
0.0278030094,
0.0443033837,
-0.0388888791,
0.0058893538,
0.0129207578,
-0.0329963416,
0.0692046508,
-0.0668317303,
-0.0087035531,
-0.0018689268,
-0.0249307472,
0.0385475457,
0.0711190179,
0.0046210443,
0.0095291901,
0.0365477204,
-0.0100048874,
-0.0038137282,
0.0631129891,
0.0118172299,
0.0159113146,
-0.0043535414,
0.0220881235,
0.041969765,
0.0220806673,
0.0423713401,
0.0289510302,
-0.0412698798,
-0.0246692672,
0.0846739784,
0.0280021485,
0.000155156,
0.0032099963,
0.0385952555,
0.0136521142,
0.0198322013,
-0.0346587077,
-0.0375006758,
-0.0157204438,
-0.024285635,
-0.0085760234,
0.0200667884,
0.0470357575,
-0.0417613424,
-0.0217383746,
0.0054145581,
-0.0369830206,
-0.0152923204,
0.0072218878,
0.0805854946,
0.0274480358,
-0.0451210476,
0.0013446169,
0.0454550758,
-0.0559160188,
0.017510226,
-0.0135428114,
0.0310987104,
0.0601112247,
0.0682023466,
-0.0054320977,
-0.0261675157,
-0.0204360448,
0.0055266437,
0.0364538431,
0.0299872458,
-0.0084473519,
0.0243455619,
-0.0867754593,
-0.0145196645,
0.0410700999,
0.0385837555,
0.0082872929,
0.0213129148,
0.0098271882,
0.008778817,
-0.0337717868,
-0.0025701583,
0.0478573777,
-0.027737258,
-0.029141916,
0.014946091,
-0.0107137728,
0.0658460855,
0.0131179942,
-0.0464350544,
-0.003478488,
0.023702994,
-0.0311574936,
-0.0107758585,
0.0213230979,
-0.0283104181,
-0.0355160162,
0.0248214994,
-0.0267385356,
0.0026817608,
0.0897502452,
-0.0383212715,
-0.0510839,
0.0493652821,
0.0031631428,
0.0509362333,
-0.0476687029,
0.0275360886,
0.0121385679,
0.010119725,
0.0011158879,
0.0036613152,
-0.0222184081,
-0.0035902013,
-0.0231436472,
-0.0254343767,
0.0241020266,
-0.0572503246,
-0.0189503245,
-0.0012202454,
-0.0421671681,
0.0338763297,
-0.0061395583,
0.0159870144,
-0.0230160188,
-0.0030045013,
-0.0946911573,
0.0180401653,
-0.0486520827,
0.0364467017,
0.0203579497,
0.0320319757,
-0.028276667,
-0.0292841867,
0.0073353453,
-0.0222958792,
-0.0195737928,
-0.002668499,
-0.013315226,
-0.022255253,
-0.0021947636,
-0.036772754,
-0.0453858748,
0.0049810708,
0.0465133041,
-0.0042512263,
-0.0243290588,
-0.0149491029,
0.0022363318,
0.0118685886,
0.0327687114,
-0.0034110064,
-0.059608873,
0.0177284293,
-0.0362115838,
-0.0053399941,
0.0561699979,
-0.0098111173,
0.0116129601,
-0.0006066128,
-0.0075972173,
-0.0506593138,
-0.0156758223,
-0.0240208115,
-0.0482058451,
-0.0659287944,
-0.0024554417,
0.0077296337,
0.1127073988,
-0.0013921408,
-0.0135618569,
-0.0788531974,
-0.0203898456,
-0.0314083472,
-0.0210949946,
-0.0100711202,
0.0168270487,
-0.0172554087,
0.0248231776,
-0.0320415311,
-0.0585615672,
0.0481192209,
-0.0492877997,
0.0036476275,
-0.028478954,
0.0116688395,
-0.0532565154,
0.0241117477,
0.0098818438,
0.0025407316,
0.0162044931,
-0.0311976969,
-0.0168463103,
0.0542288683,
-0.0109981103,
-0.0182155333,
0.0092344461,
-0.0590496846,
0.017547939,
-0.022520557,
-0.0495196059,
-0.0231458172,
-0.0329152197,
-0.0532835275,
-0.0113640511,
0.0045851516,
-0.028723482,
-0.0070095914,
-0.026478624,
0.0017938601,
0.0749905184,
-0.0066073923,
0.0198738389,
-0.0348633304,
-0.0007095426,
0.0344531201,
-0.0287268255,
0.0005404062,
-0.058119975,
-0.0149379559,
0.0487753302,
0.0430196226,
-0.0186163671,
-0.0260922015,
0.0174992681,
0.0517237112,
-0.0261857137,
-0.0139946407,
0.0199490953,
0.0435735025,
-0.0386959687,
-0.0120800398,
0.1166435033,
0.0368832126,
-0.0670402348,
-0.0021006058,
0.0292944424,
0.0311832223,
0.0223131198,
-0.0221757423,
-0.1175580546,
-0.0599167459,
0.0255344082,
0.0350282714,
0.0231911913,
-0.0212871991,
0.007185427,
-0.1379368901,
0.031667348,
-0.0074172523,
-0.037496455,
0.0028845826,
-0.0398224592,
-0.0109938737,
-0.0677336454,
-0.0103119789,
0.0388906524,
0.0184500832,
0.0392823592,
0.0288529489,
0.0118843419,
-0.0691972598,
0.002092171,
-0.0485698767,
0.0408404954,
0.0121592814,
-0.0258364473,
-0.0068005077,
-0.0255316962,
0.0159428492,
-0.0416053794,
-0.0343909152,
-0.045789253,
0.0551032424,
-0.0276555382,
-0.0272158869,
-0.0094224215,
0.0672467947,
-0.0733122528,
0.0102575254,
0.0020386244,
0.065680705,
-0.0000730414,
-0.0002092729,
-0.0005111935,
-0.0557300895,
-0.0106951948,
0.0602065213,
0.0085119149,
-0.0453228652,
-0.0527062006,
-0.0275386032,
0.0099212574,
-0.0648737028,
-0.0127453702,
0.0029951169,
0.0390127674,
-0.0691591203,
-0.0670960024,
-0.0250527151,
0.0247864071,
0.0038488007,
0.0044354885,
-0.008559674,
0.0082273176,
-0.0134393424,
-0.0619667917,
0.0472427532,
-0.0540889129,
0.0274047516,
-0.1062910855,
0.0010153499,
0.0302766878,
-0.0291427951,
-0.0259337109,
0.0180654526,
-0.0696281791,
-0.0535742752,
0.0253270138,
0.0473487377,
0.0205794703,
0.0250759125,
-0.0508054681,
-0.0713863373,
0.0302068293,
-0.0081753545,
-0.0618368238,
0.0245848708,
0.0640714243,
-0.0339658335,
-0.0024004905,
0.0555702522,
-0.018321814,
0.00876649,
0.0179026462,
0.0362105519,
-0.0253228676,
-0.0091123786,
0.0310608335,
-0.0000063107,
0.057978943,
-0.0160755552,
-0.0087123569,
-0.0534012541,
0.0385997966,
-0.0113931494,
0.0102226846,
-0.0455759503,
0.001263209,
0.0636324063,
0.0182496328,
-0.01046158,
0.021794593,
0.0143538173,
0.027453389,
-0.024555333,
0.0242769625,
0.0331620835,
0.0428335927,
0.0341227353,
-0.0178073477,
-0.0217424445,
0.0095345145,
-0.0231432114,
0.0164393391,
-0.033579506,
0.0402291343,
0.0141987521,
0.029779911,
-0.0071254764,
0.0228328779,
-0.0451882891,
-0.0063457401,
-0.014747967,
-0.0000902869,
0.0537345968,
0.0114866933,
0.0698633119,
-0.0214745924,
-0.0035159944,
-0.0371951461,
0.049225796,
-0.0065861829,
-0.0058346596,
0.0311095435,
0.0055917343,
-0.0244606305,
0.0082245218,
0.0865922496,
0.0296351518,
0.0662901476,
0.0048057274,
0.0262715481,
-0.0256247073,
-0.0391324051,
0.0060972762,
0.0309277866,
-0.0349766389,
0.0112573188,
-0.0436112061,
-0.06181008,
-0.0020655454,
0.0051096161,
-0.0012506553,
-0.0160680059,
0.0326143354,
0.0174224507,
-0.019696895,
-0.0070469962,
-0.0277327914,
-0.0117948148,
-0.0126497969,
-0.042085316,
-0.012707931,
-7.023801355e-33,
0.0081211701,
0.0538085997,
0.0122820698,
-0.0241040755,
-0.014473361,
0.0043165288,
-0.0279584993,
-0.0162181463,
-0.044871591,
0.0101605691,
-0.0061786352,
0.0282181632,
0.0273835789,
0.0825376213,
0.0139260292,
-0.0007014753,
0.0508621372,
-0.022954125,
0.0062481998,
0.0142545188,
0.0435065217,
0.0407890677,
0.0763123631,
-0.0491241887,
0.000744971,
-0.009884946,
-0.0286109224,
0.025216911,
-0.0171097331,
0.0377983451,
-0.0419506393,
0.0330602005,
0.0113563025,
-0.0263833739,
-0.0136743383,
-0.0052643502,
-0.1121516004,
0.0061943838,
0.0173416436,
0.0392345861,
-0.0256979726,
-0.0106362524,
-0.0007661018,
-0.0002151057,
-0.0057039163,
-0.0199291948,
0.0089734979,
-0.0213624146,
0.0032437851,
-0.02255846,
-0.0314529464,
0.0444873944,
-0.0235246606,
-0.0070108054,
0.0286208261,
0.0002596353,
-0.0083913365,
0.0405899957,
-0.0196162648,
0.0254196767,
0.0159314722,
0.0190100856,
0.0610753596,
0.0150946463,
0.0122076124,
0.0380951203,
0.0090798605,
-0.0592349805,
-0.0257998165,
0.0313730165,
0.0359717347,
0.0357940793,
0.0425198153,
0.0692818537,
0.0344955213,
-0.0050971564,
-0.0712074116,
0.0053391871,
0.0143906651,
0.0091706757,
-0.0059898724,
0.0151071856,
-0.0201764703,
-0.0127505483,
-0.0477161072,
-0.0471217968,
-0.0311727803,
0.022916818,
0.033262495,
0.0310560372,
-0.0077129933,
-0.0199918263,
0.0523832068,
-0.0542877689,
0.0196911525,
0.0573044047,
0.0068194177,
0.0346729755,
-0.0169055816,
0.023368964,
-0.0841702819,
-0.0279818326,
0.0164709743,
-0.0045549083,
-0.0074178167,
-0.0023197583,
0.0295360368,
0.0107911667,
-0.0615447834,
0.0083910385,
-0.0380049609,
0.0155534483,
0.0240617413,
0.0536612719,
0.06998761,
0.0056516621,
-0.002984304,
0.0557550602,
0.024892183,
0.0423255078,
-0.0298269074,
-0.0688295662,
-0.0030143014,
0.0068958984,
-0.0188735332,
0.0104854573,
-0.0125452904,
0.0241250936,
0.0020728919,
-0.0699408129,
-0.0118568437,
0.0384116136,
2.761e-7,
0.061634291,
0.0305363238,
0.0579229593,
0.0108374646,
0.0102992114,
0.0278469138,
-0.0008789718,
0.0451375581,
-0.0164142121,
0.0147788972,
-0.0028346719,
0.0271594245,
0.0882177651,
0.0103154778,
-0.0754693151,
-0.0042194831,
-0.0653876066,
0.0242208429,
-0.0510665663,
-0.0175893921,
0.0336113162,
0.1284908503,
0.0053432016,
-0.0069155488,
0.0248105768,
-0.0018423849,
0.0372336768,
-0.0263807829,
-0.0091888765,
0.0121717043,
-0.0377388671,
0.0245420691,
-0.0131987575,
-0.0192042943,
-0.0172538087,
0.0141495606,
-0.0024023359,
0.0547713637,
0.0020736973,
-0.0159162153,
0.0069937324,
-0.0388118885,
-0.0350404419,
-0.0438451804,
0.0875344649,
0.0001019373,
-0.0338123143,
0.027828237,
-0.0554510131,
-0.0156498719,
-0.009387007,
-0.0480746329,
0.0040045069,
0.0420153514,
0.0194582585,
-0.013069612,
-0.0247829072,
-0.075333409,
-0.038340684,
-0.0366550982,
-0.0380930789,
-0.0373442955,
-0.0114677334,
0.0154796783,
0.0147753311,
-0.0139359329,
0.010335709,
2.827197534e-34,
0.0519863404,
0.003878481,
0.0104667945,
0.01496471,
0.0075257998,
-0.0238445867,
0.0162267946,
0.0160074607,
0.0017969873,
-0.102008529,
-0.0071112169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16865v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16865v1 | A Benchmark for Evaluating Machine Translation Metrics on Dialects Without Standard Orthography | 2023-11-28T15:12:11 | 2023-11-28T15:12:11 | Noëmi Aepli, Chantal Amrhein, Florian Schottmann, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | For sensible progress in natural language processing, it is important that we
are aware of the limitations of the evaluation metrics we use. In this work, we
evaluate how robust metrics are to non-standardized dialects, i.e. spelling
differences in language varieties that do not have a standard orthography. To
investigate this, we collect a dataset of human translations and human
judgments for automatic machine translations from English to two Swiss German
dialects. We further create a challenge set for dialect variation and benchmark
existing metrics' performances. Our results show that existing metrics cannot
reliably evaluate Swiss German text generation outputs, especially on segment
level. We propose initial design adaptations that increase robustness in the
face of non-standardized dialects, although there remains much room for further
improvement. The dataset, code, and models are available here:
https://github.com/textshuttle/dialect_eval | [
0.0179288946,
0.0591686182,
0.0065679308,
0.0271016583,
-0.0657714531,
-0.0046428377,
0.0283426214,
-0.0040046102,
-0.0243472438,
-0.0265583731,
-0.0163395908,
-0.0809949487,
0.0579111837,
0.019317029,
0.044225689,
-0.0594291985,
0.0147588206,
-0.0166801196,
-0.0444207117,
0.0132592479,
0.0145736001,
0.0019310605,
0.0137254577,
0.0340853222,
0.0270118397,
0.0209993031,
0.0178264044,
0.0817568153,
0.0357781611,
0.0155768506,
-0.0094740381,
0.0074619967,
-0.0336843617,
0.0919014812,
0.0000017576,
-0.0468168594,
-0.0164718051,
-0.0017665232,
0.0140134199,
0.0249789618,
0.07295008,
-0.0553001873,
-0.0616163872,
0.0255715996,
-0.0078680189,
0.0132248271,
0.0685568824,
-0.0325430669,
0.0129477615,
0.061530754,
-0.0396701097,
-0.0307146627,
-0.0413253196,
-0.0201430246,
-0.0675087571,
0.0134389214,
-0.0541542247,
-0.0293100271,
-0.0254843812,
-0.0104479743,
-0.0143818036,
0.037212085,
-0.0262745302,
0.0112456279,
-0.016358383,
-0.0079640895,
-0.0351506099,
-0.0253489241,
-0.008582063,
0.0550257675,
-0.0058863014,
-0.0141078094,
-0.0204209015,
0.0091103036,
-0.0106342081,
-0.0168899652,
0.0102369478,
0.0137277264,
-0.0187303945,
-0.0105454968,
-0.0008783182,
0.0465648174,
-0.0094052553,
-0.0070741959,
-0.0131857144,
0.0475627147,
0.0652194619,
-0.0327214673,
0.0056267902,
0.04017663,
-0.030176539,
-0.0136926444,
0.0262747575,
-0.0089903679,
-0.0370321572,
0.0007215481,
-0.0487802438,
-0.0687846467,
0.0218197629,
-0.0404610075,
0.04160586,
0.0394812375,
-0.0181071796,
-0.0049141408,
-0.0077318843,
0.0800271109,
0.0047280928,
0.0177440364,
-0.0756715909,
-0.0098236734,
-0.0416109413,
0.0567495003,
-0.0238037929,
-0.0416317657,
-0.0647167936,
0.042318359,
-0.0427943915,
0.0176686943,
0.0047223116,
0.0153356129,
0.0732064322,
-0.0200592373,
-0.0596241802,
-0.0295645688,
-0.0122470027,
0.0607496984,
-0.0545036346,
-0.0274378788,
-0.0190592855,
-0.0478803925,
0.0032232325,
0.0389283486,
-0.0104712788,
-0.0215797331,
-0.0162067432,
0.0554806516,
-0.0383971184,
-0.020677669,
-0.0159456953,
-0.0107637513,
-0.0446547382,
-0.0642286763,
-0.0499600843,
-0.0705337375,
0.0114937052,
-0.0011550777,
0.0111953476,
-0.058418449,
-0.0224665478,
-0.0109393299,
-0.0059500197,
0.0226193909,
-0.0289357658,
0.0157949813,
0.0093930736,
-0.016807396,
-0.0144760301,
0.0536827147,
0.0176313519,
0.0140001029,
0.0533141419,
0.0078158379,
-0.0062048482,
0.0573447198,
-0.0087577924,
0.0324277133,
-0.0520493872,
-0.0100576971,
-0.0199285485,
0.0340770371,
0.0443471968,
0.1296608001,
0.0040187603,
-0.0115465755,
0.0560910776,
0.0360725634,
0.0466021933,
0.0076413895,
0.0452534072,
0.0085976385,
-0.0027281968,
0.0268506631,
0.0219113603,
-0.0088330768,
-0.0153533667,
0.0216673277,
0.009279266,
0.0647004545,
-0.0244648568,
-0.0373025164,
-0.0113797141,
-0.003325907,
0.0371118113,
-0.0440911055,
0.0332636237,
0.0245328136,
-0.0211577173,
0.022174336,
-0.011906852,
-0.0646285489,
0.0248824265,
-0.0409001522,
-0.0354478545,
0.0746069774,
0.077318266,
0.0186440479,
0.0364400148,
0.0144886412,
-0.0358366519,
0.0571874566,
0.1034671292,
-0.021767715,
0.0474088527,
-0.0354828387,
0.0159563329,
0.0121658314,
0.0215301663,
0.0433413163,
0.0009653412,
0.0386438668,
0.0335582048,
-0.0829698518,
-0.0562217832,
0.0184735171,
-0.0236272737,
-0.01029546,
0.0317410007,
-0.0025245794,
-0.015179567,
0.0480307452,
-0.0462457947,
0.0391438603,
-0.0184462424,
-0.0399983078,
0.037562117,
0.0501463339,
0.0136707891,
-0.0474843346,
0.0071711927,
-0.0654840171,
-0.0062257024,
0.0085655674,
-0.0216637347,
-0.0538958386,
0.0108835548,
-0.0792335048,
0.0212901589,
-0.0260751545,
0.0434324853,
0.0004137422,
-0.023463754,
-0.0657826737,
0.0250386652,
0.0032233016,
0.0145223597,
-0.0070145885,
-0.0052416394,
0.0267297849,
0.0124811837,
-0.0237630252,
0.0254837889,
-0.0197841339,
0.0361395776,
0.0363972038,
0.0009638253,
-0.0297682676,
-0.0596689768,
-0.0808416456,
0.0012885382,
-0.0680952817,
0.0647536963,
0.056750454,
0.0451439917,
0.0131864073,
-0.0096362503,
-0.0382747576,
0.0013653913,
0.0253036581,
0.0151232937,
0.0046537104,
-0.0046759052,
0.0239200648,
-0.02439286,
-0.0075341789,
0.0286642294,
0.0279472917,
0.0108376583,
-0.0089259157,
-0.0781633854,
0.0482568815,
-0.0602020137,
-0.0017221506,
0.0264762752,
-0.0455731601,
0.0032965227,
-0.0127951596,
0.0971053392,
0.0354097299,
0.0202823859,
-0.0207458977,
0.0215355009,
-0.0121217677,
-0.0083933054,
-0.0263693165,
-0.025812868,
-0.0516283959,
-0.0312332883,
-0.0844840035,
0.0327645652,
0.0257854592,
-0.0052075163,
-0.0042977734,
-0.0489289016,
-0.0091545004,
-0.0374750718,
-0.0116599556,
0.0050154761,
0.0141971866,
0.0101052672,
0.0792485997,
-0.0195000507,
-0.0501762889,
0.0607415177,
-0.0440503247,
0.0124269724,
-0.0638661236,
-0.01190932,
-0.0327252746,
0.0433997922,
-0.0085543916,
0.0367523134,
-0.0420481674,
-0.009055105,
-0.0443782099,
0.0129814874,
0.0259856787,
-0.0298139583,
0.034160383,
-0.0843338445,
-0.008431945,
-0.0110303964,
-0.0213387031,
-0.0109606739,
-0.0108698811,
-0.0229447056,
0.0021484168,
0.0678948164,
-0.0479748249,
0.0089669423,
0.0308569837,
-0.0052590757,
0.0596390851,
-0.0112635316,
-0.0009776735,
-0.0009591199,
0.0178407636,
0.0162634309,
0.0223861262,
0.0172617771,
-0.034811262,
0.0420315191,
0.0199665558,
0.0267553367,
0.0061592399,
-0.001285726,
-0.0154492026,
0.025658926,
-0.021716468,
-0.0297279097,
0.0292488821,
0.074442789,
0.0038388809,
-0.0450869612,
0.0896564797,
0.0303783361,
-0.0387729853,
0.003057115,
-0.0450043865,
0.1222469807,
0.0138891591,
0.0130992727,
-0.0374199525,
-0.0050556599,
0.0045473436,
0.0719600022,
-0.0209505316,
-0.0041847322,
-0.0013291799,
-0.0932087004,
0.0132548138,
0.0467873625,
-0.0494769178,
-0.0552104935,
0.0047206879,
-0.0333648957,
-0.0338417701,
0.0118804546,
0.0172867011,
-0.0126035381,
-0.0038924678,
0.0261732768,
-0.026659606,
-0.0677991286,
0.0068909884,
-0.0548664294,
0.0342236832,
0.0193775129,
0.0228708405,
0.0030495303,
-0.0606670938,
-0.0046655461,
-0.0190104749,
0.0092464695,
0.0134906219,
0.0459494106,
0.0379029326,
-0.0132317645,
-0.0350568816,
-0.0063082664,
-0.0011484857,
0.0178064462,
-0.0019851485,
-0.0182770155,
-0.0352515355,
0.0233418848,
0.011056182,
-0.0109821642,
0.0114232311,
0.0452519804,
0.0162071642,
-0.0577010252,
-0.0629856959,
-0.0251980685,
0.0218964126,
-0.1073292941,
-0.0058686864,
0.0276465714,
-0.0465711057,
-0.0790235102,
-0.0927276313,
-0.0426197983,
-0.0351421647,
0.0640279353,
0.0190277006,
-0.053294722,
0.0237028673,
0.0069698738,
-0.0462726951,
-0.0005659483,
0.0036697153,
0.021254288,
-0.0823089704,
0.0111605199,
0.0238216128,
-0.0130183324,
0.0103307795,
0.0171922203,
-0.0620922148,
-0.0687276348,
0.0205076095,
0.0159658697,
0.0268116873,
0.0391582251,
-0.0264981836,
-0.0278192386,
0.0066598477,
-0.0218789428,
0.0465377457,
0.0246725995,
0.0299524516,
-0.0028903871,
-0.0311664734,
0.0338104777,
0.0025811447,
-0.0003848136,
-0.0066586072,
0.0493221544,
-0.0183622707,
-0.0243714936,
0.0062244222,
0.0339799747,
0.0163453445,
-0.058341682,
0.011460444,
-0.0063094161,
-0.0274065025,
0.0035769916,
0.007134133,
-0.0504126102,
-0.0242290795,
0.076508835,
-0.01965666,
-0.006699062,
0.0201290548,
-0.040355131,
0.0233037658,
0.0103391642,
-0.0108295865,
-0.0068760575,
0.074923791,
0.0043005934,
0.0265019368,
-0.0196838975,
0.0681395531,
0.0001935566,
0.0656759217,
-0.0089902515,
0.025450822,
0.0033436019,
0.0432837382,
0.0223677643,
0.0367346741,
-0.0274855383,
0.0336522758,
-0.0551160052,
0.000208653,
0.0408396982,
0.0202258453,
0.1350046098,
-0.0209949873,
0.0016610154,
-0.0399980247,
0.0240817554,
-0.0028637333,
-0.0058648763,
-0.0435342602,
-0.0189320911,
-0.0086361505,
0.0159273818,
0.0490494482,
0.0112038022,
-0.0188373029,
-0.0237238705,
-0.036662776,
-0.0099430857,
-0.0250401199,
0.0028569798,
-0.0368217416,
-0.005732188,
-0.0274630617,
-0.0596721694,
-0.0425670557,
-0.0049812458,
0.0525648482,
0.0374779217,
-0.0070566698,
0.0218369216,
0.0610208362,
-0.019311497,
0.0504436269,
-0.0573174655,
-0.0159233119,
-0.0034650164,
-0.0323392488,
-0.0235050749,
-5.668074701e-33,
-0.0224680994,
-0.0123099973,
-0.0421097726,
-0.0715496093,
-0.0151405111,
-0.0132237049,
-0.0245212577,
0.0319268331,
-0.0078154318,
0.0199899878,
0.0127738398,
-0.0239320435,
0.0262469593,
0.0040032179,
0.0033776194,
-0.0197256953,
0.0360275395,
-0.0022765519,
-0.0456765145,
-0.0056221895,
0.0403508544,
-0.0241177101,
0.0482842401,
-0.0378984623,
0.0428688787,
-0.0010137801,
-0.0252478831,
-0.0193304941,
0.0282219127,
0.0052412977,
0.0144994855,
0.0505163223,
0.0137763154,
0.0116776489,
-0.0349034183,
-0.0023349035,
-0.0426562876,
-0.0097091161,
0.005025838,
0.0564644597,
-0.019855354,
-0.0142785981,
0.0303229764,
-0.0215574149,
-0.0798160806,
0.0019050249,
-0.0035243744,
-0.0251058731,
0.0010699197,
-0.0094360653,
-0.0430554673,
0.0378975049,
-0.0000361926,
-0.0244208258,
0.0299058538,
0.078987807,
-0.0155202951,
-0.0328060575,
-0.0443800651,
0.0278041307,
0.0234740674,
0.0433345027,
0.0601389073,
-0.0216342993,
-0.0425439477,
0.0020811295,
0.0241599083,
0.0434215851,
0.0164897721,
-0.000380488,
0.0446577854,
0.0028064295,
0.0638649538,
0.0640935376,
0.0302663669,
-0.0224081688,
-0.0320435204,
0.041954238,
-0.0092055062,
-0.0163170397,
-0.0280731171,
-0.0040086545,
-0.0199999977,
-0.0051412201,
-0.0306620598,
-0.052055534,
-0.0216884501,
-0.0083184335,
0.0208090805,
-0.0014870751,
-0.0049965903,
-0.0251240693,
0.0646207407,
-0.0011759673,
0.0326061994,
-0.0240758266,
-0.0257029384,
0.0340589583,
-0.0385025069,
0.0368118808,
-0.0059188702,
-0.0330112651,
0.0342010856,
0.103967078,
0.0017848776,
-0.0172285829,
0.0130403601,
0.0098641161,
-0.0468597561,
0.0238464903,
-0.0421472639,
0.029164847,
-0.0421937928,
0.0231244713,
0.0099568926,
-0.0331557728,
0.0056612496,
0.0079492759,
0.0059819128,
-0.0033684487,
-0.0241434295,
-0.0009505471,
0.0300650038,
0.061337471,
-0.035371419,
0.032232035,
-0.0006568524,
-0.0345196761,
0.0212218706,
0.0030985493,
-0.0060304878,
0.007617441,
2.578e-7,
0.0533867702,
0.0692841336,
0.0187161602,
-0.0004406994,
0.0149814561,
0.0074441419,
-0.006258504,
0.0340813026,
-0.0066657201,
0.0047872355,
0.0274289083,
-0.0154011734,
0.0701894164,
0.0312668793,
-0.0315205753,
-0.0025574793,
-0.057887692,
0.0442340337,
-0.0313943997,
0.0116450908,
0.1024754792,
0.0464271829,
-0.0356596,
-0.0118019748,
-0.0020748121,
0.0050984211,
0.042477075,
0.0190773103,
-0.0272545908,
0.0238699522,
0.0780815333,
0.0139450021,
-0.0155452574,
0.0166266374,
-0.0256028827,
-0.0339986011,
0.040944647,
0.0408700071,
-0.0044265175,
-0.0382070951,
0.0117050428,
-0.0302756354,
-0.0035251139,
-0.0319735706,
0.0255281702,
0.0297752582,
0.0126125189,
0.0313113779,
-0.0300953183,
0.0427411161,
0.0650598407,
-0.0554560348,
-0.0357291922,
0.004082296,
0.0731370747,
0.0104716979,
-0.0356380716,
-0.0028693611,
-0.0555335395,
0.0079338318,
0.0104893027,
-0.0680206269,
-0.0102342237,
0.0610757172,
-0.0099969981,
-0.051551614,
-0.0080958279,
2.113585679e-34,
0.0545061901,
-0.0087407259,
0.007693632,
-0.0422130115,
0.0270540472,
-0.0233287215,
-0.0206958111,
-0.0250179935,
-0.0208571851,
-0.0275154039,
-0.0171687733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16842v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16842v2 | RELIC: Investigating Large Language Model Responses using Self-Consistency | 2023-11-28T14:55:52 | 2024-04-04T15:18:30 | Furui Cheng, Vilém Zouhar, Simran Arora, Mrinmaya Sachan, Hendrik Strobelt, Mennatallah El-Assady | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are notorious for blending fact with fiction and
generating non-factual content, known as hallucinations. To address this
challenge, we propose an interactive system that helps users gain insight into
the reliability of the generated text. Our approach is based on the idea that
the self-consistency of multiple samples generated by the same LLM relates to
its confidence in individual claims in the generated texts. Using this idea, we
design RELIC, an interactive system that enables users to investigate and
verify semantic-level variations in multiple long-form responses. This allows
users to recognize potentially inaccurate information in the generated text and
make necessary corrections. From a user study with ten participants, we
demonstrate that our approach helps users better verify the reliability of the
generated text. We further summarize the design implications and lessons
learned from this research for future studies of reliable human-LLM
interactions. | [
0.0312381163,
0.0469079502,
-0.039443098,
0.0327152647,
-0.0567872562,
-0.0218864139,
0.0057593016,
0.0168773979,
0.0237009041,
-0.0545538291,
-0.0104296291,
-0.0479546227,
0.0426525995,
-0.0158337187,
0.0147990584,
-0.0396172665,
0.0414725505,
-0.030628413,
0.0063728755,
-0.0056676674,
0.0016333571,
0.0212841257,
-0.0308291949,
0.0335829556,
-0.0258570332,
-0.0522446334,
-0.013535222,
-0.0075256033,
-0.0050700572,
-0.0389717817,
-0.0186037514,
0.0760890245,
-0.0258384217,
0.0572377332,
0.0000021726,
-0.0548306629,
0.0338841677,
0.0037438527,
-0.0434575826,
0.0611199439,
0.0306203309,
0.0723833963,
-0.0090129236,
0.0141291544,
-0.0201301891,
0.0142115699,
0.0361068249,
0.0277836248,
0.0543985218,
0.0038573772,
-0.0018555064,
0.0135964938,
0.0129468571,
0.0071988297,
0.0461672023,
0.0394792669,
0.0084050735,
0.0192096699,
0.0184053462,
-0.0004113154,
0.0086038774,
0.0376710407,
0.0048348177,
-0.0286862068,
-0.0115115792,
0.0145398043,
-0.0299144089,
-0.0587836206,
0.0150904693,
0.0397000536,
0.0442541204,
-0.0312842131,
-0.0088106692,
-0.0072011333,
-0.0064765727,
0.0743232518,
-0.0253890883,
0.0182508547,
-0.0230951868,
-0.0137475282,
-0.012209666,
-0.0310458727,
0.0223362111,
-0.0050656023,
-0.0215191208,
0.0419509672,
0.0216755904,
-0.0300581157,
-0.0203814618,
0.0119165704,
0.0284046102,
-0.0915814042,
0.0124925412,
0.0121342335,
-0.0544386096,
0.0189777222,
-0.0246748719,
-0.0136587508,
0.0881177932,
-0.0739260614,
0.0282525942,
0.0105593856,
-0.0576046221,
0.0216021985,
0.000270876,
0.0404041931,
-0.0112902084,
0.0112305973,
0.0116727473,
0.0474160388,
-0.0186616816,
-0.0259600133,
0.0062037208,
-0.0175437368,
-0.0035238657,
0.0128860874,
-0.0482942276,
-0.0056354059,
-0.0093884533,
0.0365553088,
-0.0478757843,
0.007823321,
0.0172867738,
-0.0143212527,
-0.0723552704,
0.0468055271,
-0.0163917765,
-0.0022987458,
-0.0150002688,
-0.087718308,
0.011564631,
0.0174347628,
-0.0122597916,
0.0089114057,
-0.0168852527,
0.0040061846,
0.0028012646,
0.0294044372,
-0.0176233761,
-0.04990099,
-0.0545199625,
-0.0672032237,
-0.0239895675,
-0.088097617,
0.0114395805,
0.0277493931,
-0.0208165403,
-0.043752905,
0.0192419868,
0.0463128164,
-0.0456900112,
0.0576413646,
-0.0453191027,
0.0287818946,
0.0405074209,
0.0260225013,
0.0372752398,
0.0238285828,
0.0289737079,
0.0262152329,
0.0432522856,
-0.0228561331,
0.0568364486,
0.0119118318,
-0.013829289,
0.010370817,
-0.0548371784,
-0.0022645311,
-0.013195036,
0.0383729525,
-0.0210990943,
0.0710253492,
-0.0110524986,
-0.0011169113,
0.093326062,
0.0682172626,
0.019168444,
-0.0032524411,
-0.0036816157,
-0.0156410336,
0.0494512171,
0.0506649315,
-0.0338557623,
0.0043700919,
-0.0052003455,
0.0112833111,
0.0415076949,
0.0100143012,
0.0148820709,
-0.0498915389,
-0.0588408746,
0.0185129363,
0.0088698007,
0.0346068591,
0.0157429799,
-0.0098386472,
0.0014709521,
0.0258962493,
0.0372098014,
-0.0654625669,
0.0125622516,
-0.0576107688,
0.0740827248,
0.1057952493,
0.0300459825,
0.0038151778,
0.0333227329,
-0.0265404079,
0.0244021676,
0.0884358436,
0.0616471544,
0.0202401653,
-0.0207374357,
-0.0043809465,
0.0068993242,
0.0046209903,
0.0173127558,
0.0070056012,
-0.0050234366,
0.0009307333,
0.0008571759,
-0.031464003,
-0.0272922143,
0.0360507257,
-0.0288321488,
-0.0170122571,
-0.0382475704,
-0.0082561551,
-0.011549348,
0.0173399728,
-0.0180552993,
0.0322173908,
0.0131314611,
0.021945674,
-0.020301301,
-0.0070337034,
-0.0140303699,
0.0272468645,
0.064696379,
-0.0115314405,
-0.0371506065,
-0.0191744193,
0.0339939333,
-0.0163974501,
0.0084246546,
-0.0677848384,
0.0252203941,
-0.0455538146,
0.0235138573,
-0.0132012479,
0.0248340908,
-0.0359719247,
0.0412851609,
0.016727129,
0.0196026433,
0.0094777895,
-0.0206639916,
0.0048556663,
-0.0270087142,
-0.013499043,
0.0468959101,
0.0096001439,
0.0333968736,
0.0394290686,
-0.0397701934,
-0.0664507896,
-0.0124473115,
-0.0558495969,
-0.0125085562,
-0.0070622428,
0.0200526882,
0.0197937638,
-0.0278134625,
-0.0204982106,
-0.0172413792,
-0.0221204031,
-0.0160456002,
0.0261964072,
0.0376429074,
0.040581204,
-0.0315766446,
-0.004364423,
-0.0381730162,
0.0009589358,
-0.0353920087,
0.0471729226,
0.0509812236,
-0.0077499915,
-0.0938285887,
-0.0195520334,
-0.0695152208,
-0.0108594364,
0.0342584625,
-0.0284520406,
0.0624819063,
0.0247216001,
0.0732477158,
0.0489983,
0.0387833789,
0.0419914536,
0.0860445946,
-0.024439577,
-0.0542415865,
-0.0457442254,
0.0019636985,
0.0027328068,
0.0018923673,
-0.0797284022,
0.0119182179,
0.0476378202,
0.0556173697,
0.0349767506,
-0.0270363595,
0.0331217274,
-0.0245914813,
-0.0326025747,
0.01861207,
-0.0391254276,
-0.045885697,
0.051094003,
-0.0211294647,
-0.0593017638,
0.0718205348,
-0.0462614484,
0.0188829415,
0.0013889626,
-0.000891619,
0.0210820977,
0.0590333715,
-0.0133830234,
0.0147078391,
0.0286898725,
-0.0039270255,
-0.011064481,
-0.0412466154,
0.0377591252,
-0.0676748231,
0.0512970425,
-0.0669871941,
-0.0061971024,
0.0218407791,
0.0012737906,
-0.0419767126,
-0.0505982302,
-0.0297344644,
-0.0575190485,
-0.0210188664,
-0.0255052615,
-0.0311627295,
-0.0229350515,
0.0690403506,
0.0127527118,
-0.0061952542,
-0.0280678831,
0.0067799152,
0.0054497696,
0.0373096168,
0.0308781769,
0.058002498,
-0.0470252261,
0.0123721063,
0.0887830853,
-0.0216607545,
0.0470385663,
-0.0262391753,
-0.0429400764,
0.001030143,
-0.0184140019,
-0.0164013896,
0.0350196771,
0.0502530038,
-0.063009426,
0.0201789979,
0.0905358195,
0.0493472144,
-0.0141006066,
0.0055151605,
-0.0737467483,
0.0233376138,
0.0258039963,
0.0161320418,
-0.0780276507,
-0.005127795,
0.0027687221,
0.0139061976,
-0.0195495859,
-0.0208699107,
-0.0045883348,
-0.0814625695,
0.0359388664,
0.0038204801,
-0.0072498536,
0.0238054227,
-0.0436580963,
0.0401376374,
0.0427456498,
0.0522642285,
0.024388779,
-0.0009740618,
-0.0072798836,
-0.0048846742,
-0.0593473911,
-0.012210221,
0.0145556629,
-0.0380137004,
0.0523172505,
0.0516431369,
0.0421451181,
-0.0092766657,
-0.0930235237,
0.0253041591,
-0.0127826547,
0.014043388,
-0.0033539273,
0.0620920397,
0.0384758674,
0.0091656437,
-0.0665471628,
0.0045000282,
-0.0026277804,
-0.0477342568,
0.0173047706,
0.0514075533,
-0.0376345292,
-0.0425391197,
-0.0225321315,
0.0115144243,
0.0123917395,
0.053634841,
0.0347716287,
-0.0560445748,
-0.0332570747,
-0.0327538252,
0.0235413518,
-0.0043710913,
-0.0755187795,
0.0341269858,
0.0362030827,
-0.0059833801,
-0.074078016,
-0.0271730684,
0.0091592046,
0.0054558814,
0.0030443403,
0.0073225177,
0.0099605406,
-0.0156668574,
-0.0059174765,
0.0360934101,
-0.0444836281,
0.0298655909,
-0.0205759946,
0.0282480121,
0.0040930044,
-0.0246420652,
0.0385278463,
0.0214157775,
-0.0448842645,
-0.0647272766,
0.0465374887,
0.0144412378,
0.0296575334,
0.0183397476,
0.0021883771,
-0.0481268726,
0.0167001486,
0.0174415875,
-0.0648872852,
0.029925989,
-0.0380608849,
0.0099398205,
-0.0086110253,
-0.0015670094,
0.0087815318,
-0.0121483458,
-0.0128376754,
0.0026379949,
-0.0249183476,
-0.0679340065,
0.0505657606,
0.0415495224,
0.0374183506,
-0.0203441288,
0.0359008536,
-0.0080871172,
-0.0078142164,
-0.0590075292,
-0.0168025028,
-0.0026100585,
-0.0167579576,
-0.0114967283,
-0.0706420466,
0.009495588,
-0.0414161943,
-0.0744456872,
0.0194507595,
-0.0322876051,
0.0153287798,
-0.0229222756,
0.0093779285,
0.0292025302,
0.0004794671,
-0.0208800361,
0.0123720113,
-0.0250538774,
0.0541516393,
0.0234561078,
0.0351608954,
0.0067432411,
-0.0409835018,
0.0041506067,
-0.0196103584,
-0.0346247591,
-0.0535888597,
0.0014797377,
-0.0022097284,
0.0117800841,
0.0379260965,
0.0611934029,
-0.0276315194,
-0.0037945891,
-0.0148908431,
0.0032057355,
0.0247837566,
-0.0008114064,
-0.0045344289,
0.0192710087,
-0.0458086133,
-0.0193943419,
0.0186357517,
-0.0344520099,
0.0019309184,
-0.0018160772,
-0.0561408475,
-0.0357211009,
-0.0432562716,
-0.0579764582,
-0.0101909181,
-0.0437305942,
-0.0635081604,
-0.0745495111,
-0.0523097403,
0.0105896732,
0.06118384,
0.0144090345,
-0.0193923377,
-0.0128091564,
0.0807029605,
0.0014065867,
-0.0173199959,
-0.0260404311,
0.03673134,
-0.0067990995,
0.0004644673,
-0.0175694581,
-6.547687205e-33,
-0.0149399647,
-0.0974180326,
-0.0020310446,
-0.0431005508,
-0.0078079659,
-0.0246979166,
-0.0426806435,
0.057459984,
0.0202127192,
0.0251959804,
0.000479471,
0.0011314504,
0.0212105438,
-0.0046388633,
0.0197903309,
-0.007254675,
0.0641166419,
0.0299903695,
-0.0420593098,
-0.0087088291,
0.0348506011,
-0.045172181,
0.0397843495,
-0.1018889546,
0.084125638,
-0.0158064663,
-0.0074991989,
-0.0045656259,
-0.0416663922,
0.0536765978,
-0.0282372218,
0.065632306,
0.0114879869,
-0.0310157407,
-0.0216635037,
0.0359995849,
-0.026080275,
-0.0358498953,
0.0288160872,
0.0140369087,
-0.0563952588,
0.010458407,
0.0415828153,
-0.0152974594,
-0.0084505565,
0.0102357073,
0.040612042,
-0.0187995192,
0.0014472749,
0.0280035269,
-0.0465744846,
0.0094585987,
0.0095577035,
-0.0017419199,
-0.0423857719,
0.0510903075,
-0.0125987381,
-0.0298689567,
-0.0767478421,
0.0260837954,
-0.0077486392,
-0.0021972517,
0.0585704669,
0.0055767451,
0.0051213265,
0.0538880043,
0.0254030116,
0.0239239503,
-0.0686021969,
-0.0220783055,
0.0330998451,
0.0143856481,
0.0596322268,
0.0920729786,
0.0270819329,
-0.0308027901,
-0.0314939283,
0.0063284296,
0.00438151,
0.0197111201,
0.0329786018,
0.0073099532,
-0.0259803105,
-0.0165858325,
-0.0489599742,
0.0256806388,
-0.0449656099,
-0.0528291799,
0.0230071638,
-0.0100265788,
0.003981506,
-0.0166876558,
0.0010973188,
-0.0099745141,
-0.0416481942,
-0.0349448472,
-0.035635855,
0.0207686573,
-0.001852487,
-0.0030204097,
0.0192073043,
0.0540631488,
-0.0216702111,
0.0272727497,
0.0409640856,
0.0303006917,
-0.0106857428,
-0.0198226161,
-0.0858179182,
0.0343579911,
-0.003405967,
-0.0017433438,
0.0217250213,
-0.0671494007,
0.0603634045,
-0.0124450633,
-0.0265600104,
0.0312040858,
0.0108008413,
-0.0161214322,
-0.0402794257,
-0.0042690155,
-0.0163524915,
0.0204965994,
-0.0206333622,
-0.0141608259,
-0.0470972396,
0.0203780681,
0.0593932457,
-0.0358819962,
-0.0047438759,
-0.0152710024,
2.776e-7,
0.0242658481,
0.0785507709,
0.024089938,
0.0122082941,
0.0189933982,
0.0141215185,
0.011229692,
-0.0076504573,
0.0280415434,
-0.0625756755,
-0.0325305238,
0.0122771971,
0.047368262,
0.0913651511,
-0.0262396075,
-0.0193439703,
-0.0520647205,
0.0325924568,
-0.067245014,
0.0340038538,
0.0791821778,
-0.009359953,
0.0178731587,
-0.0096076243,
-0.0144161573,
-0.0291444547,
0.0499369539,
-0.017457312,
-0.0080662994,
0.0193401407,
0.045892261,
-0.0265431423,
0.0367049798,
0.0388700031,
-0.0211195815,
-0.0632344335,
-0.0246733315,
0.021731833,
-0.0039977124,
-0.0051852874,
-0.0222972427,
-0.0202950407,
0.0316361859,
-0.0758954585,
0.0362609923,
-0.0231754147,
-0.0056437319,
-0.01293616,
-0.0034538731,
-0.049744729,
0.0693105087,
-0.0268006511,
-0.0166391321,
0.0356138311,
0.0215677377,
0.0477842353,
-0.031385269,
-0.0171653405,
-0.0525320284,
0.0174978245,
-0.0439760983,
-0.0351773463,
-0.0093777757,
-0.0159615073,
-0.0249221455,
-0.092520386,
0.0107217049,
2.390869643e-34,
0.0076527297,
0.0409445427,
0.0360859558,
-0.0108829578,
0.0476553142,
0.0131386854,
0.0521964692,
0.0315521657,
0.0471578054,
-0.0557288714,
-0.0042102607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16840v1 | The Claire French Dialogue Dataset | 2023-11-28T14:55:22 | 2023-11-28T14:55:22 | Julie Hunter, Jérôme Louradour, Virgile Rennard, Ismaïl Harrando, Guokan Shang, Jean-Pierre Lorré | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present the Claire French Dialogue Dataset (CFDD), a resource created by
members of LINAGORA Labs in the context of the OpenLLM France initiative. CFDD
is a corpus containing roughly 160 million words from transcripts and stage
plays in French that we have assembled and publicly released in an effort to
further the development of multilingual, open source language models. This
paper describes the 24 individual corpora of which CFDD is composed and
provides links and citations to their original sources. It also provides our
proposed breakdown of the full CFDD dataset into eight categories of subcorpora
and describes the process we followed to standardize the format of the final
dataset. We conclude with a discussion of similar work and future directions. | [
0.0046510082,
0.1133393571,
-0.0102279754,
0.0748227611,
-0.022913415,
-0.0253689699,
-0.0057630381,
-0.040922612,
-0.0125955325,
-0.022811532,
-0.0539516695,
-0.0565896742,
-0.0072054076,
0.0317955948,
0.036925111,
-0.0261419453,
0.0340616554,
-0.0394795612,
0.0347906873,
-0.0224166662,
0.0378317386,
0.0410486236,
-0.0259666219,
0.0538009815,
0.0119714104,
0.0104613239,
-0.0246280022,
0.0423867069,
0.0128609911,
0.0150213493,
-0.0043513225,
0.0321998596,
0.0026732003,
0.0282777213,
0.0000017061,
-0.0464050993,
0.0172437057,
-0.0344653539,
0.0076276613,
-0.0208904278,
0.0330060348,
-0.0017940602,
0.0012921375,
0.0336880758,
-0.0228144508,
-0.0138133578,
0.037096668,
-0.0141541222,
0.0455901921,
0.0795844868,
-0.0085123377,
-0.0213040188,
-0.0247368254,
-0.0713207573,
-0.0466332138,
0.0019340923,
0.0150147406,
-0.0081143873,
0.0108843828,
-0.0256758723,
-0.0377271473,
0.0256597567,
-0.0339544676,
-0.0632485673,
-0.0442766063,
-0.0306293592,
-0.0532868579,
-0.0085753435,
-0.0013389842,
0.086555779,
0.0790968537,
-0.0034796591,
0.0113694752,
0.0156977363,
0.0202585384,
0.0327058844,
-0.074781768,
0.0041172695,
0.0486457199,
-0.0022731919,
0.0133186318,
0.0079587437,
0.0007899444,
-0.0355028473,
-0.0174922831,
0.0194953866,
0.0085321413,
-0.0042989594,
-0.0220205858,
-0.041891139,
-0.0347940288,
-0.050903853,
-0.0275547896,
-0.0141612431,
-0.0167591367,
0.0303621441,
-0.020173192,
0.0172876455,
0.0082051307,
-0.02924826,
-0.0026978729,
0.009020919,
-0.0261245724,
0.0425704643,
0.0338787995,
0.0379467569,
-0.032289274,
-0.0078008231,
-0.0242236927,
-0.0219902247,
-0.0233082436,
0.0119680678,
-0.0337579511,
-0.0302923154,
-0.0600112379,
-0.0129338345,
0.0219302587,
-0.001763179,
-0.0031074642,
0.043542359,
0.0492587984,
-0.0066149337,
0.0168931317,
-0.0036871047,
-0.0205385815,
0.0720977709,
-0.0189274475,
0.0164836515,
-0.0248288568,
-0.0997710824,
-0.0216920078,
0.0147056207,
0.0061583901,
-0.0207461044,
-0.0004959189,
0.0768755674,
-0.0106655238,
-0.0085368501,
0.0520435795,
-0.0404028669,
-0.0290472787,
-0.0789897665,
-0.0105370674,
-0.0723631233,
0.0430583283,
-0.0228927583,
0.0384625159,
-0.0560683198,
0.0160063487,
-0.0080356896,
-0.049997136,
0.0419840328,
-0.0107016452,
0.0039964593,
0.0416748449,
-0.0034178253,
-0.0068105618,
0.0712799132,
0.0500028096,
-0.0724461526,
0.0605503954,
-0.0076966709,
-0.0241479836,
0.0794807374,
0.0412371047,
0.0175734032,
-0.0308494661,
0.0125549873,
0.0263886377,
0.0393017232,
0.0417120717,
0.056005843,
-0.0155521575,
-0.0370354131,
0.0512668714,
0.0441545807,
-0.001034744,
-0.0152284345,
0.0068590427,
0.0463848636,
0.0424912646,
-0.0130349435,
0.0062435875,
-0.0097512035,
0.047118403,
-0.0236995406,
0.004675752,
0.0002132303,
-0.0177820232,
-0.0186493285,
-0.0230135191,
0.0202413891,
0.0077212248,
0.0287754927,
0.0118033318,
0.0021205489,
-0.0230326764,
0.0225411113,
0.03162729,
-0.0785858929,
-0.0107291788,
-0.0034557183,
0.0104928836,
0.0425607599,
0.0529368408,
-0.0397798382,
-0.0234735608,
-0.0383034535,
0.0136746038,
0.019127911,
0.0378215499,
-0.0651844293,
0.0391307138,
-0.0379393138,
0.0232152436,
-0.0568202958,
0.0108713126,
0.0217437074,
-0.0370374769,
0.0154016959,
-0.0559347086,
-0.0046045627,
0.0183899775,
-0.0038305365,
-0.0842923671,
-0.0024197926,
-0.031420853,
-0.0190324858,
0.0346673317,
0.0436103716,
-0.0383247733,
-0.0180383828,
0.0574765652,
-0.0079761483,
0.0510380119,
0.0826944485,
0.0046927137,
-0.0344657749,
0.026706079,
-0.0300220121,
0.0075645493,
0.0290222857,
-0.0213399306,
-0.0510117151,
0.0517785773,
-0.0054331431,
0.0417036824,
-0.0182261579,
0.005639432,
0.0045325751,
0.0079985978,
0.0032018775,
0.0169468373,
0.0114730708,
0.0526643135,
0.0651967004,
0.0227864496,
0.0409066863,
-0.0648888946,
-0.0305676479,
0.0498680733,
-0.0049857236,
0.0115653183,
0.0445259884,
-0.0289613213,
0.0017781405,
-0.0145954471,
-0.0645705089,
0.0145852342,
-0.0244988669,
0.0301510449,
0.0071506118,
0.0128894839,
-0.0487647504,
-0.0177542139,
-0.0431782864,
-0.0118242959,
0.0300085805,
-0.0259763524,
0.0086036725,
0.0247719511,
-0.0369068943,
-0.020552855,
-0.0036657725,
0.0144327553,
0.0631096065,
-0.0316574313,
0.0361998938,
0.0254244711,
0.0140836462,
-0.0442571491,
0.0173519719,
-0.0464980863,
-0.0565193743,
-0.0255931914,
-0.0359623134,
-0.03959186,
0.0329828411,
-0.004366878,
0.0257196762,
0.01509587,
-0.0643525496,
-0.0374919474,
0.0077652861,
0.0142230242,
-0.0234340206,
-0.0872414112,
-0.0134083275,
0.0109694107,
0.0543047898,
0.0188045148,
0.0115624033,
-0.0027778589,
0.0344751105,
0.0275659058,
-0.012774718,
0.0097571556,
0.0099782795,
-0.0367663912,
0.0292671379,
-0.0076743928,
0.0382546224,
0.0399161093,
-0.0521155111,
-0.0050117774,
-0.0356320702,
-0.0172010865,
-0.0243284274,
0.0768874586,
-0.0250310991,
-0.0016514845,
0.0050074207,
-0.0513426475,
-0.0295460019,
-0.003948655,
0.0625587702,
-0.0298192445,
0.0682870224,
-0.0446330272,
-0.0063556405,
-0.0104449596,
-0.0427590497,
-0.0213074889,
-0.0158870965,
-0.0444968827,
-0.0048435479,
0.0196787417,
-0.0303885303,
-0.0350141861,
-0.0145113757,
-0.0442979224,
0.0558951832,
0.0283381678,
0.0381063484,
-0.0034809147,
0.0640262961,
-0.0001610058,
0.0396733731,
-0.0603834316,
-0.0009871672,
0.0569118075,
0.0132540278,
-0.025730839,
0.0140976654,
0.020259887,
-0.03770959,
0.0612231568,
0.0021280912,
-0.0307632536,
-0.0361704119,
0.0380125232,
-0.0242175255,
-0.033307936,
0.0792789459,
-0.0082123103,
-0.0268036574,
-0.0084186243,
-0.023253765,
0.0615483411,
0.0337781645,
-0.0044383439,
-0.0993019119,
-0.0150987878,
0.0137545681,
0.0141903926,
0.0104599269,
-0.0148682976,
-0.0185831431,
-0.112729691,
0.036331974,
-0.0073290966,
-0.032760635,
0.0255818944,
-0.0057133622,
0.0051938617,
-0.08544413,
0.0029775866,
-0.012977262,
0.0023143943,
-0.0039321231,
-0.0035309913,
-0.0156143997,
-0.0612763539,
-0.0237840954,
-0.0345409885,
0.0798859,
-0.0014847349,
0.056875892,
-0.0145762693,
0.0183307994,
0.0171462279,
-0.0237901881,
-0.048330009,
0.0283355284,
0.0193827096,
0.0121290796,
-0.0397277586,
0.0250808876,
0.0341568589,
0.0327124521,
-0.0152487233,
0.0730232149,
0.0132070258,
-0.0405191295,
0.0451194644,
0.0006636982,
0.0394392982,
0.0130360108,
0.0752516836,
0.0314751528,
-0.0190024078,
-0.0067241779,
-0.0330145918,
-0.0245333463,
-0.0713516325,
-0.0359305441,
0.0141342869,
0.0271231961,
-0.0441831686,
-0.0632298291,
0.004175711,
0.0071178814,
0.0084149204,
0.0285949856,
0.0006925107,
-0.006478644,
0.0479121618,
-0.0530569479,
0.0478896014,
-0.0059163184,
-0.0334057473,
-0.086998187,
-0.0482983962,
0.0536936931,
-0.0615745857,
-0.0375204571,
0.0514546037,
-0.0989435315,
-0.0689537749,
-0.0198474824,
0.0179238692,
0.0264542643,
0.0621537864,
0.0069053667,
-0.0240303967,
0.0140574975,
-0.0144898314,
-0.0161069762,
0.0204613525,
0.0372920819,
-0.0136351772,
-0.0472820699,
0.0532840267,
-0.0032927911,
0.0150929848,
-0.0400205143,
0.0505530424,
-0.0343327448,
-0.0898502842,
-0.020200422,
-0.0181392301,
0.0423282869,
-0.0142381378,
-0.0043190974,
-0.064439714,
0.0021577161,
-0.0527067408,
0.0176812951,
-0.0225477647,
0.01635997,
0.0321081057,
-0.0333595201,
-0.0239310507,
-0.0403101146,
-0.0374250412,
0.0154233668,
-0.036538735,
0.0249893144,
0.0741448477,
-0.0295184869,
0.0115623455,
0.0219300054,
0.0116907619,
0.0191532373,
-0.0242659431,
0.0114146704,
-0.0383766592,
0.0343258008,
0.0456381291,
-0.0232377201,
0.0505165532,
0.049194403,
-0.0431634076,
-0.014313099,
0.0028961045,
-0.0016121537,
0.0480643362,
-0.0085986638,
0.1099488363,
-0.0029376308,
-0.0230392758,
-0.032724306,
0.0720670745,
-0.010666186,
-0.0448528714,
0.022135675,
0.0207766332,
-0.0245699119,
0.0157040805,
0.0746133626,
0.0131091094,
0.0039170547,
0.038675271,
0.0289924219,
-0.030332638,
-0.0372429043,
0.0378052257,
-0.0079468424,
-0.0252064019,
-0.0183083192,
-0.0289162099,
-0.0209029838,
0.0136781977,
0.0077918447,
-0.0128591871,
-0.0044525121,
0.0067428127,
0.0354181938,
0.019937031,
0.0482683703,
-0.0509015843,
0.0392662995,
-0.0392234661,
-0.0290866345,
0.0133561678,
-5.105333229e-33,
-0.0255689286,
0.0200361796,
-0.0333389938,
0.0618656687,
-0.0599013828,
-0.0098299347,
-0.0043899673,
0.0020203167,
-0.0339749381,
0.0103111388,
0.0071126344,
0.0263129119,
-0.0078112734,
0.0392883122,
0.0478423275,
-0.0498682782,
0.0465355888,
0.0241974201,
-0.0391820259,
0.017656263,
0.0482631102,
0.036386013,
0.0519273728,
-0.0724961758,
0.028403962,
-0.0591848344,
-0.03251471,
0.0200037174,
0.0118948137,
0.0746836588,
-0.0175057556,
0.0585696325,
-0.0100512179,
-0.0214940626,
-0.0041231131,
0.0280793384,
-0.0708373785,
-0.0075796759,
0.0481323078,
0.0441213511,
0.0191954728,
-0.0255612321,
-0.0154619133,
-0.0027219336,
-0.0298785232,
0.0388795771,
0.0176592357,
-0.0391335189,
0.0152895758,
0.0281990916,
-0.052664604,
0.0099308919,
-0.0234259572,
-0.0327711329,
0.0414002053,
0.0769895539,
0.0425275564,
-0.0208245572,
-0.041126214,
0.0715588406,
-0.0722206235,
0.0379931815,
0.0259291511,
0.0044609527,
0.0025068885,
0.0678608343,
0.0295857172,
-0.016974438,
0.0207435973,
0.0245920718,
0.0174926147,
0.0281202383,
0.0091002295,
0.0927883461,
-0.0288097207,
0.0289123598,
-0.0367356874,
-0.0299289301,
0.0304739047,
0.0003488107,
-0.0312181171,
-0.014643264,
0.049043078,
-0.0186847001,
-0.0498011373,
-0.0242198668,
0.0201451574,
0.0188445561,
0.0151442979,
0.0008508295,
0.0229114294,
-0.0081148259,
0.0604831763,
-0.0196357071,
-0.0132527472,
0.0491857082,
-0.0073313257,
0.0084770592,
-0.0148514537,
0.0611986518,
-0.0345832892,
0.0161068831,
0.0204320271,
0.0117055401,
0.0345712528,
0.0170305744,
0.0054166052,
0.0255623274,
-0.0290207639,
-0.0012955115,
-0.0209413655,
0.0337740816,
-0.0946090147,
0.0473039001,
0.0043399739,
-0.0019230854,
0.0244164411,
0.0683385581,
0.0120134084,
-0.002964033,
-0.0054265638,
-0.0337394774,
-0.0083085811,
-0.0017880341,
-0.0508373715,
0.0240273047,
-0.0282605272,
-0.0021926593,
0.0061835353,
-0.0231546517,
-0.0035701457,
-0.0362224579,
2.379e-7,
0.0367113166,
-0.0124920662,
0.0563089177,
0.0360404849,
0.0242394786,
0.0017487359,
-0.0568077005,
0.0258361269,
-0.0183980949,
-0.0160780717,
-0.008924257,
-0.0035908383,
0.0707311928,
0.0159518272,
-0.1131134555,
-0.0485928357,
-0.0548646525,
-0.014560503,
-0.0296920557,
-0.0052953432,
-0.0053143166,
0.084189415,
0.0124147283,
0.0251534674,
-0.040532086,
-0.0112177348,
0.0333012268,
-0.0363825113,
-0.0512188338,
0.0169643015,
0.0362278149,
0.0049492745,
-0.0191390328,
-0.0179432537,
-0.0164427105,
0.0286060758,
-0.0074304561,
0.0283358432,
0.0226197727,
-0.0301504377,
-0.0130974576,
-0.0313859582,
-0.0171321165,
-0.0117521491,
0.0114122108,
0.042279508,
-0.0195090231,
-0.0105091147,
-0.0276654437,
-0.0158323906,
0.0623474307,
-0.0362477377,
-0.0001444324,
0.0194950793,
0.0432027727,
0.0030210412,
0.0076457355,
-0.066990681,
-0.0307024941,
-0.0134012615,
-0.0637922212,
-0.0149881737,
0.0840765163,
-0.0254273936,
-0.0278539453,
-0.0389649048,
0.0078530889,
1.733628482e-34,
0.0467762947,
0.0063283397,
-0.0331134684,
0.014843924,
0.0493909977,
-0.0735411271,
0.0152407223,
-0.0011623044,
0.0059230863,
-0.0154853538,
-0.0090943938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16839v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16839v2 | Beyond Hallucinations: Enhancing LVLMs through Hallucination-Aware Direct Preference Optimization | 2023-11-28T14:54:37 | 2024-02-06T16:43:31 | Zhiyuan Zhao, Bin Wang, Linke Ouyang, Xiaoyi Dong, Jiaqi Wang, Conghui He | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models have made significant advancements in recent
years, yet they still suffer from a common issue known as the "hallucination
problem", in which the models generate textual descriptions that inaccurately
depict or entirely fabricate content from associated images. This paper
introduces a novel solution, Hallucination-Aware Direct Preference Optimization
(HA-DPO), which reframes the hallucination problem as a preference selection
task. The model is trained to favor the non-hallucinating response when
presented with two responses of the same image (one accurate and one
hallucinatory). Furthermore, this paper proposes an efficient pipeline for
constructing positive~(non-hallucinatory) and negative~(hallucinatory) sample
pairs, ensuring a high-quality, style-consistent dataset for robust preference
learning. When applied to three mainstream multimodal models, HA-DPO
significantly reduced hallucination issues and amplified the models'
generalization capabilities. Notably, the MiniGPT-4 model, when enhanced with
HA-DPO, demonstrated a substantial improvement: POPE accuracy rose from 51.13%
to 86.13% (an absolute improvement of 35%), and the MME score surged from
932.00 to 1326.46 (a relative improvement of 42.32%). The codes, models, and
datasets are made accessible at https://opendatalab.github.io/HA-DPO. | [
0.0178038515,
0.0819448829,
-0.0057438361,
0.0348541997,
-0.0380712934,
0.0235466007,
-0.0224474035,
-0.007443544,
0.0011348804,
-0.0529902205,
-0.0693328604,
-0.0742058456,
0.0057146396,
-0.019658288,
0.038872093,
-0.0737591162,
0.0165332947,
-0.024987381,
-0.02896096,
-0.0214815177,
0.0156615712,
0.020375168,
-0.0162300617,
0.0193262268,
-0.0143138617,
-0.024953695,
0.0109657692,
0.0156281944,
0.0180086624,
-0.0116561251,
0.0052377293,
0.0781469718,
0.0176025685,
0.0053199311,
0.0000023619,
-0.0372377634,
-0.0056995815,
-0.0377143696,
0.0537156127,
-0.0197318271,
0.0806963146,
0.0049396651,
0.0028731578,
-0.0374720655,
-0.0053492589,
-0.0166127626,
0.0808641538,
0.1140603498,
0.0389610156,
0.0436152145,
-0.016938841,
-0.0530428477,
-0.0044053933,
0.0050452221,
0.0634698644,
0.0410187095,
0.0313581116,
0.0025614442,
0.0164715704,
-0.0228013713,
-0.0386336036,
0.0142943198,
0.0105623845,
0.0363603905,
0.0139974672,
0.0197391771,
-0.054934416,
-0.0360615514,
-0.0066537466,
0.0994974598,
-0.0348435119,
-0.0363011137,
0.0087176599,
-0.0001611812,
-0.0138008129,
-0.0035181651,
-0.0172142759,
0.0120126149,
0.0070106676,
0.0250009038,
-0.0293321889,
-0.0083555803,
0.0216476712,
0.0134523176,
-0.0151610449,
0.0266386438,
0.0270145219,
-0.0265758336,
0.0680909231,
-0.0013462793,
-0.0600718819,
-0.0334162824,
0.0177005176,
-0.0327551551,
-0.0279308595,
-0.0197780747,
-0.0377027206,
-0.0003771029,
0.0291379746,
-0.0902220458,
0.0253233183,
-0.0143346032,
-0.071478717,
0.0251857731,
-0.0030416143,
0.0209121834,
-0.0264221299,
0.0762479231,
-0.0149607677,
0.0280163269,
-0.0037428115,
0.0061847665,
-0.0227550529,
-0.0009029804,
-0.0221685264,
-0.0394014455,
-0.0297768805,
-0.0237192102,
-0.0393794551,
0.0028526713,
-0.0428324752,
0.0584285781,
-0.0091695208,
-0.0291145612,
-0.0156401172,
0.0355251804,
0.004601609,
-0.0136426622,
-0.0146166459,
-0.0306488983,
0.0137854656,
0.0540412664,
-0.0160718691,
-0.0437526926,
-0.0021101974,
0.0683077723,
-0.0012936977,
-0.0013942954,
-0.0016250061,
0.0048902142,
-0.0568189099,
-0.0758319646,
0.0511839464,
-0.0399580859,
0.0096684508,
-0.021339437,
0.0122353612,
-0.0353299081,
0.0246582832,
0.0062450268,
-0.0326646902,
0.0882182196,
0.0062521114,
-0.0327372774,
0.0178126339,
0.0329377279,
-0.0255263206,
0.0708755702,
0.0267894287,
0.0783020407,
0.013213235,
-0.0385862291,
0.0285157822,
0.0353133827,
-0.0146253323,
0.0095188553,
-0.0747447982,
-0.0170681402,
0.0311324149,
0.0366653278,
0.0575011894,
0.055555176,
-0.0455417112,
-0.0535526946,
0.096856609,
-0.025953697,
0.0166330356,
-0.0236467384,
0.0046547703,
0.0253449194,
-0.0119744772,
0.049520839,
-0.0649192482,
0.0679959506,
-0.0162505489,
0.0065221931,
0.0484481193,
0.0057416959,
-0.0081186285,
-0.0193786956,
0.0022670471,
-0.0172894485,
0.0137087647,
0.0136553468,
0.0138236526,
0.0095659364,
-0.0684338361,
-0.0062093958,
0.0528878942,
-0.0107981823,
-0.0024847307,
-0.0329601765,
0.0204535909,
0.1076939926,
0.0552613921,
-0.0012921465,
0.030851651,
-0.038094487,
0.0255496874,
0.0761451274,
0.0077445502,
-0.0047020209,
0.0430675931,
-0.0747426525,
-0.0223865788,
-0.0083623407,
0.0198782086,
0.0236842185,
-0.0318056867,
-0.0031169304,
-0.0106829051,
0.0027851996,
-0.0316426046,
0.0148322685,
0.0249469578,
-0.0226864126,
0.0016663943,
0.0020503479,
0.0152113745,
-0.0250202287,
-0.0217585433,
0.0087596448,
-0.0082707293,
-0.0333919562,
-0.0281190742,
0.0117165418,
-0.0664301217,
-0.0155748753,
0.0183419604,
-0.0508799478,
-0.0000442397,
0.0422229394,
-0.0038451429,
-0.0016773643,
0.0011965216,
-0.0348595567,
0.0251103863,
-0.0476997606,
0.0226263516,
0.0211594366,
0.0370136052,
-0.043331515,
0.0751083642,
-0.0349887498,
0.0194558501,
0.0235767271,
0.0113738338,
-0.0358237885,
-0.0178796239,
-0.046265766,
0.0241170395,
0.0214423463,
0.0287289005,
-0.0100388024,
-0.011591698,
-0.0642081127,
-0.0128751425,
-0.0818723068,
-0.005575086,
-0.0307105072,
-0.0594362952,
0.017724162,
-0.022201173,
-0.0064643375,
-0.027492946,
-0.0174575616,
0.0237611737,
-0.023564877,
0.0419373251,
-0.0090861069,
-0.0058767376,
0.0012541736,
-0.0177904814,
0.0039791432,
0.0167668797,
0.0312064812,
-0.0462502763,
-0.0160748791,
-0.0283765644,
0.0286419149,
-0.0428533852,
0.0107713975,
0.0045444989,
-0.0245379861,
-0.0053684218,
-0.0219442118,
0.0700573549,
0.0523425341,
0.0531778932,
0.0055312812,
0.0875646695,
-0.0233294331,
-0.0366794094,
-0.0178374983,
-0.0151002705,
0.0159398932,
0.0089521566,
-0.0278690252,
-0.0110973967,
0.0426150374,
0.0359097905,
0.0369177721,
-0.0597584136,
0.0218766946,
0.0068170317,
-0.0778568313,
0.0136811305,
0.0231271219,
-0.0231189523,
0.0327290483,
-0.0225943439,
-0.0507268906,
0.0660087764,
-0.0079076951,
-0.0322104916,
-0.0234694108,
0.0296653379,
0.0254068822,
0.0091205928,
0.0465354249,
0.032562796,
-0.0356138907,
0.0021291184,
-0.0515900664,
-0.0101548852,
-0.0031277929,
-0.0237905364,
0.0337239504,
-0.0336424708,
-0.0201776382,
0.0097772507,
-0.0360444896,
-0.0552416258,
-0.0269719772,
0.0049556345,
-0.0587397739,
-0.0505519584,
0.0269139223,
-0.0234434251,
0.0084431618,
-0.0066882255,
0.0099447323,
-0.0298975762,
-0.0132139996,
0.012723187,
0.0220266897,
0.0977428034,
0.0160477981,
0.0090682814,
-0.0374347866,
-0.013983977,
0.0590026453,
0.0200514682,
0.0230511334,
-0.0176087171,
0.0342518017,
0.0277758054,
0.007677651,
-0.0248523653,
0.0232543852,
0.0257049296,
-0.0125044137,
0.0125827817,
0.08778622,
0.0210200939,
-0.0977914333,
-0.0011197624,
-0.0261626802,
0.0881666914,
-0.0043609096,
-0.0079263784,
-0.0731352568,
-0.0338664614,
-0.0422434919,
-0.0100894021,
-0.0123441322,
0.0098311706,
-0.0149791976,
-0.0567079857,
0.0498430468,
0.0444684476,
-0.0075369566,
0.0069136703,
-0.0026664594,
0.0123516368,
-0.0231815372,
0.0388303995,
-0.015127046,
0.0029975518,
-0.0278544221,
-0.0105797909,
0.0083257798,
-0.02654838,
0.0255073104,
0.001121026,
0.0171822477,
0.1032503545,
0.0302220024,
0.004338,
-0.0834716558,
0.0257690828,
0.0087363562,
-0.0118086291,
-0.0127565647,
0.0577471927,
-0.0071341614,
0.0033580116,
-0.0167549178,
0.0525851622,
0.0010468303,
-0.0283983331,
-0.0039647617,
0.0353734158,
-0.0446950644,
-0.0462997295,
-0.0241832044,
0.0574338287,
0.0267387778,
0.0511353537,
0.021797074,
-0.0910548046,
-0.0572289713,
-0.028864162,
0.0417442173,
-0.051971674,
-0.0425202772,
0.0229368936,
0.0523018204,
-0.0141242351,
-0.0847607478,
-0.0231302697,
-0.0006038631,
0.0182108246,
-0.0003995349,
0.0071514351,
-0.0609926507,
-0.0195585676,
-0.0383424573,
0.0301765241,
-0.0111521715,
0.0081182513,
-0.0276351888,
-0.0209111329,
0.0227983687,
-0.0446415469,
0.0111669563,
0.0442220569,
-0.0812247843,
-0.0578725189,
0.0218608249,
0.0700577274,
0.0145456344,
0.0687250346,
0.0199703462,
-0.0608091578,
0.0407559834,
0.055183664,
0.0377758779,
0.000585806,
0.0255535673,
0.0203197859,
-0.0052643372,
0.0267940555,
0.0019460778,
0.0221806839,
0.0286286846,
0.0034073759,
0.0315547772,
0.0139989117,
0.0275303591,
-0.027881084,
-0.0014429542,
-0.0524268784,
0.0108328164,
-0.0256729275,
-0.0094284583,
-0.0252905879,
-0.0147351148,
-0.0278938338,
-0.0259250887,
0.0499196835,
0.0038402309,
-0.0213926546,
-0.0617014654,
-0.033471249,
-0.0134667289,
-0.0654798746,
-0.0160757769,
0.0428791866,
-0.0214014072,
0.042270232,
0.0152510079,
-0.0266822949,
0.0288103148,
0.0183324777,
0.0468101539,
-0.000398699,
0.0878977999,
0.0052071628,
-0.0371606462,
-0.0166541338,
0.0413396992,
-0.0017446908,
-0.052865766,
-0.0571989566,
-0.0116792275,
0.0577361435,
-0.020383615,
0.0777034611,
-0.0133379819,
-0.0042202901,
-0.0340658724,
0.048349198,
0.0200355556,
-0.050695844,
-0.0102103744,
0.020642003,
-0.0144351544,
0.0133973444,
0.0598486215,
-0.0107692853,
0.0186170973,
0.0053709587,
0.0080135101,
-0.0475582033,
-0.0543443933,
-0.0259342212,
0.0381275974,
-0.0073139896,
-0.0104321055,
-0.0231282562,
-0.0461287983,
0.0077572037,
-0.0268169343,
-0.0024448123,
0.0099286316,
0.0574006625,
0.0279610213,
-0.047764007,
-0.0121115828,
-0.0237816218,
-0.030402245,
0.0564068444,
-0.0134042865,
-0.0079338998,
-6.398919579e-33,
0.0059456951,
-0.0113208937,
0.0182400011,
-0.0661100522,
-0.0380846485,
-0.0474647246,
0.0043743253,
-0.0018993524,
0.0206297096,
0.0012988918,
0.0290222187,
-0.0200701114,
0.0165328346,
0.0340153053,
0.0170665234,
0.0108884769,
0.0351450555,
0.0057874075,
-0.0442235395,
0.0243680011,
0.0364839286,
0.0093895439,
0.0637920573,
-0.0626300797,
0.0056333919,
0.0221982207,
-0.0268367548,
-0.0157143455,
-0.0022382743,
0.0655332059,
-0.0595128834,
0.0407135822,
0.0144192316,
-0.0072704321,
-0.0412157774,
-0.0098776435,
-0.014113429,
0.0005852479,
0.0068287225,
0.0395552963,
-0.0478717759,
-0.0120513393,
0.0565825738,
-0.0127314506,
0.0127575519,
-0.0223363824,
0.0417371355,
-0.0397169366,
-0.0131037896,
0.0459639505,
-0.0689195618,
-0.0156915952,
-0.0078160437,
-0.0040793968,
0.0356164426,
0.0588975698,
-0.0212744996,
0.03851863,
-0.0771728829,
0.0450403132,
-0.0437088571,
-0.0214855783,
0.0605773889,
0.0084018689,
0.0250953883,
0.0926121399,
0.0785498992,
-0.0200015735,
0.0005204995,
-0.0091272928,
0.0271115918,
0.059893541,
-0.0036491237,
0.0279265996,
0.0579056218,
-0.0046692179,
-0.0049184067,
-0.0014850544,
-0.0526378304,
-0.012700852,
0.0782923773,
0.0247596689,
-0.0178107228,
-0.0263476074,
-0.0100508751,
-0.0153149106,
-0.0445814542,
-0.0584968515,
0.0320537388,
-0.0010094958,
-0.0291586649,
-0.0028027496,
0.0735917091,
-0.0324245915,
-0.0362671949,
-0.0052268081,
-0.0652664304,
0.0460325927,
0.0072445045,
-0.0043684067,
0.0004694583,
-0.0006957126,
0.0569973066,
-0.0170114208,
0.0030196547,
0.0229593832,
0.0149259791,
-0.0037066634,
-0.0622165687,
0.0030702448,
-0.0273354948,
0.0057148836,
0.0315081179,
0.0354708694,
0.0447307639,
-0.0095993634,
-0.0363596305,
0.022067735,
0.0109506091,
-0.0035160922,
-0.0049660788,
-0.0145962602,
-0.0264413469,
0.0201293658,
-0.0151376035,
0.0088257333,
-0.0184952933,
-0.0715423003,
0.0140798083,
-0.0698703453,
-0.0167215616,
-0.0029230388,
2.913e-7,
-0.0151757002,
0.0323136896,
-0.0152181461,
0.008111679,
0.0206492431,
0.0277786367,
0.0133255729,
0.028554773,
0.0211256631,
-0.051287692,
-0.0119293705,
0.0198245402,
0.0498250611,
0.0268427152,
-0.0691474974,
-0.0132129062,
0.0023533728,
0.0200207885,
-0.0617177673,
-0.0459046699,
0.064087458,
0.0526742898,
-0.0081787203,
-0.0411148146,
0.0342035666,
0.0152786318,
0.0864299387,
-0.0402619168,
-0.0112557206,
0.0196564477,
0.0106386784,
0.0010665908,
-0.0049277847,
0.0248591751,
-0.0194148067,
-0.0469584577,
0.0262466073,
0.0314919725,
-0.0103666093,
-0.1059437916,
-0.0105489241,
0.0452628881,
-0.006058631,
-0.045254685,
0.0721903518,
-0.0321028382,
-0.044188913,
-0.0004367983,
-0.0427305922,
-0.0331419744,
0.0777832791,
-0.0428558476,
-0.047090672,
0.0193255935,
0.0327980705,
0.0340275355,
-0.0320419818,
-0.0640273392,
-0.0015093667,
-0.0010906016,
-0.0287304316,
-0.0159084238,
-0.0210980047,
0.0426703803,
-0.001030528,
-0.0462768339,
-0.0267237332,
2.687743726e-34,
0.0390596502,
0.001228012,
0.0573266372,
0.0109887505,
0.0004156152,
0.0036624288,
0.0606692471,
-0.0007223426,
-0.0059732157,
-0.0520784631,
-0.0258151684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17126v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17126v1 | Reason out Your Layout: Evoking the Layout Master from Large Language Models for Text-to-Image Synthesis | 2023-11-28T14:51:13 | 2023-11-28T14:51:13 | Xiaohui Chen, Yongfei Liu, Yingxiang Yang, Jianbo Yuan, Quanzeng You, Li-Ping Liu, Hongxia Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in text-to-image (T2I) generative models have shown
remarkable capabilities in producing diverse and imaginative visuals based on
text prompts. Despite the advancement, these diffusion models sometimes
struggle to translate the semantic content from the text into images entirely.
While conditioning on the layout has shown to be effective in improving the
compositional ability of T2I diffusion models, they typically require manual
layout input. In this work, we introduce a novel approach to improving T2I
diffusion models using Large Language Models (LLMs) as layout generators. Our
method leverages the Chain-of-Thought prompting of LLMs to interpret text and
generate spatially reasonable object layouts. The generated layout is then used
to enhance the generated images' composition and spatial accuracy. Moreover, we
propose an efficient adapter based on a cross-attention mechanism, which
explicitly integrates the layout information into the stable diffusion models.
Our experiments demonstrate significant improvements in image quality and
layout accuracy, showcasing the potential of LLMs in augmenting generative
image models. | [
0.0212655216,
0.0313990042,
0.0148778651,
0.0500574894,
-0.0130789718,
-0.0024695029,
0.041915331,
0.0113015035,
0.0096152648,
0.0050764713,
-0.018816324,
-0.0705507398,
0.0324902013,
0.0355436876,
0.0208788775,
-0.091270864,
-0.0547356941,
-0.0574873872,
-0.0655605048,
-0.0118178735,
0.0089227119,
0.0150634702,
0.0252020545,
-0.0066779205,
-0.0442936867,
-0.0351341739,
-0.029367296,
0.0401040502,
0.0253139511,
-0.0355109498,
-0.0692225397,
0.0383396186,
0.0324222334,
0.0161764324,
0.0000022809,
0.0032558925,
0.0211413447,
0.013685816,
0.0538923591,
0.0208514333,
0.0768912733,
-0.0588625073,
-0.0204585958,
-0.0564123355,
-0.0178976208,
0.0394375287,
0.0880801007,
0.0713659599,
0.072306931,
0.0393058881,
-0.0126340492,
-0.086003378,
0.004148467,
-0.0405442938,
0.0652870685,
0.008012848,
0.0178641807,
0.0120956944,
-0.0106439665,
0.0396596529,
-0.0508650392,
0.0330516435,
0.039863307,
-0.0370020457,
0.0392662957,
0.0616579726,
0.04398375,
-0.0440801941,
-0.0163797699,
0.0636342093,
-0.0435160473,
-0.0220147725,
-0.0107079651,
-0.0389328152,
-0.0194704123,
0.0323709473,
-0.0406013243,
0.0012209353,
-0.0055490891,
0.0184155032,
-0.0427944772,
-0.0005331916,
0.0191172138,
-0.0515370108,
-0.047849834,
-0.0161362905,
0.0298814904,
-0.0061851391,
-0.0496055186,
0.0405180939,
0.0122595103,
-0.0757367611,
0.0542865768,
0.0267811082,
0.0270655453,
0.0284894221,
-0.0429916121,
-0.0450851955,
-0.0181802381,
-0.0326885544,
0.0392519347,
-0.0007860269,
0.0045328257,
0.0326773264,
-0.0360085592,
0.0188232157,
-0.0597103313,
0.0079669664,
-0.0817040503,
0.00364537,
0.0162835252,
-0.004532842,
-0.0410647281,
-0.0126360506,
-0.0549465418,
-0.0550471805,
-0.036052689,
0.0162036344,
0.0132722296,
-0.0082329065,
0.0453131236,
0.0313125737,
-0.0676083416,
-0.0408827588,
-0.0296253357,
0.0175101366,
0.0149741657,
-0.0176767576,
0.0062670684,
0.0130096255,
-0.0107136695,
0.0089468062,
0.0414435118,
-0.0078101922,
-0.038120091,
0.0795783699,
-0.0343236029,
-0.0036118482,
-0.0230108909,
0.0265153274,
-0.0406153053,
-0.0183314104,
0.0247903485,
-0.068400234,
0.0288848747,
-0.0325083397,
0.0056943246,
-0.040840622,
0.0214513484,
0.0065526748,
-0.0444767773,
0.0324051268,
-0.0073254788,
0.0198507961,
0.0232797731,
-0.0132873785,
0.0228373874,
0.0278966092,
0.0732619092,
0.0849707052,
-0.0098936297,
-0.0157906786,
0.0193715375,
0.0611378774,
0.0060398504,
0.0194556713,
-0.0320368968,
-0.0179169439,
-0.0060560186,
0.0340998657,
0.056395229,
0.0639081299,
-0.0030976417,
0.016605325,
0.1031673849,
0.0405364521,
0.015385828,
0.0336097218,
0.0700804964,
0.0247820783,
-0.0405931547,
0.0115268128,
-0.0052005299,
0.0498354174,
0.0386228003,
0.0567990355,
0.0562423803,
0.051728636,
-0.0303285699,
-0.0326379612,
0.0163943041,
-0.0107527161,
0.0239955727,
-0.0265446473,
0.0523052961,
0.0326804779,
-0.0712303072,
0.0331325941,
-0.002909587,
-0.0482250266,
0.00054374,
-0.0217489898,
0.0316784978,
0.0959994271,
0.0142890392,
0.0357262082,
0.0274465047,
0.0018562983,
0.0402307548,
0.1190435663,
0.0020183229,
0.0400621556,
-0.0040720473,
-0.0339720175,
-0.0166480169,
0.023955781,
-0.011967157,
0.0349880792,
-0.0129595594,
0.0306060947,
0.0096936366,
-0.0316067114,
-0.0573360994,
0.0381794646,
0.0011284987,
-0.0024405308,
0.001887491,
0.0098840436,
-0.0115517685,
-0.0073139239,
-0.0460345224,
0.0144896302,
0.0139986491,
-0.0439640433,
0.0020615207,
0.0090431776,
-0.0423843749,
-0.0443246737,
-0.01739797,
-0.0583217256,
-0.014885773,
-0.0544211715,
-0.021874845,
-0.0275955517,
0.0099507701,
-0.0227439608,
0.0446143448,
-0.0032107383,
-0.0152372876,
0.0223248303,
0.0216929745,
-0.0225407779,
0.0711586028,
-0.0298584308,
-0.0061406228,
0.0098868264,
0.0364625454,
-0.0423487499,
-0.001067127,
0.031897217,
-0.0325955302,
0.0206860807,
-0.0043766252,
-0.0093377614,
0.0502261147,
-0.0411760956,
-0.0395605415,
-0.0416841656,
-0.0191761628,
0.002284423,
-0.0166773871,
0.0181504637,
-0.0029598742,
0.0005307145,
0.0180317126,
-0.0421243533,
0.0150550427,
-0.0170106553,
-0.0089047635,
0.0165641587,
-0.0335198492,
0.026081847,
-0.0293282457,
0.0049532708,
0.028391974,
0.0501170792,
0.0359158106,
-0.0202192273,
-0.0565950982,
0.053268183,
0.0154746901,
-0.0018979699,
0.0043318444,
-0.0241112784,
0.0226030834,
-0.0247005206,
0.080414556,
0.1190591305,
0.0330617167,
0.0126039712,
0.0046502543,
-0.0242302958,
-0.034311112,
0.0048177945,
-0.0059139468,
0.0002095932,
0.0161946584,
-0.0616469383,
-0.014477984,
0.056950286,
0.0045737438,
0.0253391508,
-0.0961351618,
0.0068173157,
-0.0130832344,
-0.0424052626,
-0.0168759227,
0.008600275,
-0.0198495351,
0.0289039593,
-0.0610479601,
-0.0607660785,
0.030571688,
-0.079091683,
-0.0107486704,
-0.0082553951,
0.0253699068,
-0.0004123649,
0.0534490086,
0.0367091931,
0.0502670966,
0.0155259557,
0.0317095667,
-0.0353970453,
0.0115384571,
-0.0099359816,
-0.015551988,
0.0272846855,
-0.0474298336,
-0.0045505026,
-0.0167022664,
-0.0022573376,
-0.0287365057,
-0.0207650419,
0.0124849565,
-0.0568993017,
-0.0232762303,
-0.025345521,
-0.0165371075,
0.0484215729,
0.0252606086,
0.0070433551,
0.0010902947,
-0.0148216328,
-0.0123702213,
0.0636297986,
0.0599955656,
-0.0158004276,
-0.0339498296,
-0.0714007691,
0.0185351297,
0.0293745771,
-0.0234344099,
0.0210946612,
-0.0336441249,
0.0053047729,
-0.000780651,
0.0698715523,
0.0071288692,
0.0227911361,
0.0969512984,
-0.0448282585,
-0.0378735662,
0.0670406446,
0.0183730721,
-0.0395996645,
-0.0167373829,
0.0100102266,
0.0771967247,
-0.0139724286,
0.0095908875,
-0.052548904,
-0.0105478531,
-0.0277018063,
-0.0461953729,
0.024300741,
0.0080863573,
-0.0262473468,
-0.1085714996,
0.0659648329,
0.051019907,
-0.047851935,
-0.0256190002,
-0.0110729942,
0.0096890107,
0.0388477705,
-0.038047649,
-0.012839498,
-0.0036176685,
-0.0020006194,
0.0028323922,
0.037726704,
-0.0230450947,
-0.0412400439,
-0.0037340329,
-0.0022293625,
0.0555640496,
0.0277668703,
0.0050652651,
-0.0726602897,
0.0125149237,
0.0320806578,
0.0113931261,
-0.000922502,
0.0074550873,
0.035560973,
-0.0154249137,
-0.0363714211,
0.0199513733,
0.0029310151,
-0.0282228794,
0.0170791298,
0.0465024486,
0.0155612677,
-0.0393455885,
-0.0594152547,
0.0158596057,
0.0051807775,
0.034960717,
0.0605914742,
-0.06421078,
-0.0372421369,
-0.0507782847,
0.0275450032,
-0.05599235,
-0.0645083487,
0.0165761989,
-0.0293323509,
-0.0582135394,
-0.0631686598,
-0.0234139394,
0.015523877,
0.0507846586,
0.0121443104,
-0.021108577,
-0.032779295,
-0.0277839079,
-0.0199125558,
0.0273505226,
-0.0247414857,
0.0055824695,
-0.0318807662,
-0.0088524744,
0.0108851604,
-0.0559662618,
-0.0023231276,
0.0490002818,
-0.085269101,
-0.0324242227,
-0.0347810127,
0.0601507202,
0.0154949632,
0.0427633487,
-0.0107984012,
-0.0178548731,
0.0799573809,
0.0414071679,
0.0424224474,
0.0067721349,
-0.0297464654,
0.027916342,
0.0053755287,
0.0022953034,
-0.0456818826,
0.0138186729,
0.0234620012,
0.0162594933,
-0.0212276541,
-0.0141286943,
0.0026526265,
-0.0430853218,
-0.0140782297,
-0.0383658186,
0.0252328739,
-0.0262147076,
0.0211319197,
-0.0426959917,
-0.0215410031,
-0.0519739836,
-0.0046174941,
0.0492306501,
0.0153933177,
0.0022630414,
-0.0039271931,
0.0256847162,
0.017094072,
-0.0114237228,
-0.0213604718,
-0.0048622228,
-0.00240587,
0.0389340296,
0.0181020722,
-0.0097044287,
0.0138322506,
-0.0621216968,
0.0378725678,
0.0182266347,
0.0330949351,
0.0184813701,
-0.0605940409,
-0.0167408437,
0.0462764278,
-0.0114500467,
-0.0449163616,
-0.0646808967,
0.0442149341,
0.0618800297,
-0.0054153781,
0.0604493693,
-0.0102670202,
-0.001301916,
0.006572987,
0.0290588103,
0.0339500681,
-0.0488887839,
0.0152533343,
0.003349517,
0.0231646728,
-0.0711001381,
0.0587914884,
0.0016891957,
-0.013587785,
-0.0018214164,
-0.0118995113,
-0.0157283656,
-0.0011955063,
-0.0151193812,
-0.0146447755,
0.0096526574,
0.0152847413,
-0.0474453308,
-0.0576292239,
-0.0063359682,
0.0523382053,
-0.0200637281,
0.0148000829,
0.04127663,
0.0204839911,
-0.0095725395,
0.0179020762,
0.0084968526,
0.0146830743,
-0.0157728959,
-0.0382840075,
-0.025994733,
-6.070970981e-33,
-0.0486646891,
-0.0463173725,
0.0070585301,
-0.0373462439,
-0.0486040115,
-0.0345210247,
-0.0629705116,
-0.0032035857,
0.0355490893,
0.0208485406,
-0.0016034062,
-0.0108247185,
0.0180176385,
0.0520896986,
-0.0117971497,
0.0477210805,
0.0401947424,
-0.0004128249,
-0.0262454432,
0.0183028691,
-0.0091123143,
0.0201441534,
0.0245700888,
-0.0296590105,
-0.0169665609,
-0.0062871459,
0.0119343102,
-0.0147063527,
0.0167696737,
0.0340409391,
-0.024689531,
-0.0014186852,
0.0124705154,
-0.0209221784,
-0.017094098,
0.0487044714,
-0.0355067626,
0.0053798207,
0.0168737434,
-0.0017797082,
-0.0765478835,
-0.0465546213,
0.0746320188,
-0.0090749841,
-0.0026348892,
-0.0401378162,
0.060928084,
-0.0454932973,
-0.0068391985,
0.0127931377,
-0.058206521,
0.0043178285,
-0.0341864973,
-0.0236593392,
0.0080001485,
-0.0161969289,
0.0273550674,
0.0538432151,
-0.0649374202,
0.0330136195,
0.0378196202,
0.0375466496,
0.0607824549,
0.0593439713,
0.0169627853,
0.0478304401,
0.010944969,
0.006223422,
-0.0308076963,
-0.0054075937,
0.0100906221,
0.0395955592,
0.0380836837,
0.0303902756,
0.0106832888,
0.0173109043,
-0.0410121419,
0.0476113856,
-0.0869635344,
0.0123433471,
0.0636521876,
0.0176307335,
0.0133798569,
0.0115801366,
-0.0184969846,
-0.0172176138,
-0.0509044677,
-0.0318635851,
0.0236432236,
0.0046184752,
0.0016047495,
-0.0240537971,
0.0402029566,
0.0110089872,
-0.0202451106,
-0.0077623907,
-0.0388185196,
0.0540109687,
-0.031196313,
-0.0074224859,
-0.0119302897,
-0.0389677845,
0.032559365,
0.0531492718,
-0.0221385825,
0.0401299223,
0.01167903,
-0.0114576742,
-0.0488784723,
-0.0057190782,
-0.0527812876,
0.0090751611,
0.0081294989,
0.0084344344,
0.0177219883,
-0.0112093575,
-0.0550171174,
0.0147555247,
-0.0017624128,
-0.0083570527,
-0.0013962316,
0.0106831202,
-0.0220248066,
0.0197368357,
-0.0333341546,
0.0160771832,
-0.0516587794,
0.039072562,
0.0931866914,
-0.0671575814,
-0.0502002984,
0.0407200083,
2.788e-7,
0.0382686891,
0.0288626347,
-0.010504677,
0.0178939365,
0.0160137676,
0.0309523139,
-0.028316807,
0.0198197532,
0.0121875638,
-0.048320692,
-0.002595085,
0.0667907968,
0.0566760972,
-0.0216620322,
-0.0639103502,
0.0483361892,
-0.0480087996,
0.0143293841,
-0.0500712879,
0.0089180581,
0.055674728,
0.0845880508,
-0.0226847902,
-0.0251547173,
0.0350443237,
-0.0050467514,
0.0738885254,
-0.0302861594,
0.0239925738,
-0.0068365773,
-0.0390623957,
-0.0344069898,
-0.0394902304,
0.0037428718,
-0.0081326291,
-0.0283306986,
0.0315129086,
0.0241874475,
-0.034810923,
0.0393106565,
0.0148067214,
0.00140739,
-0.0166000705,
-0.076612331,
0.0344361067,
-0.0427049659,
0.0049989377,
-0.0169631615,
-0.0122228395,
0.0072303801,
0.0080353105,
-0.0478136241,
-0.0282990467,
0.0059582167,
0.0465083905,
-0.003195974,
0.0101332869,
-0.0241490267,
-0.0662581623,
-0.019412579,
-0.0397493131,
-0.0161640532,
-0.0957198739,
0.0091324784,
0.004071713,
-0.0006968706,
-0.0302009098,
2.512883891e-34,
0.0134238731,
0.0141570885,
0.0102165844,
0.0179175548,
0.0418562181,
-0.0070940177,
-0.0039366912,
-0.0030976082,
-0.0152298547,
-0.0838878527,
-0.0177316647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16832v1 | CharacterGLM: Customizing Chinese Conversational AI Characters with Large Language Models | 2023-11-28T14:49:23 | 2023-11-28T14:49:23 | Jinfeng Zhou, Zhuang Chen, Dazhen Wan, Bosi Wen, Yi Song, Jifan Yu, Yongkang Huang, Libiao Peng, Jiaming Yang, Xiyao Xiao, Sahand Sabour, Xiaohan Zhang, Wenjing Hou, Yijia Zhang, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we present CharacterGLM, a series of models built upon
ChatGLM, with model sizes ranging from 6B to 66B parameters. Our CharacterGLM
is designed for generating Character-based Dialogues (CharacterDial), which
aims to equip a conversational AI system with character customization for
satisfying people's inherent social desires and emotional needs. On top of
CharacterGLM, we can customize various AI characters or social agents by
configuring their attributes (identities, interests, viewpoints, experiences,
achievements, social relationships, etc.) and behaviors (linguistic features,
emotional expressions, interaction patterns, etc.). Our model outperforms most
mainstream close-source large langauge models, including the GPT series,
especially in terms of consistency, human-likeness, and engagement according to
manual evaluations. We will release our 6B version of CharacterGLM and a subset
of training data to facilitate further research development in the direction of
character-based dialogue generation. | [
0.056731686,
0.0719449297,
-0.0119679263,
0.0323838852,
-0.0036486026,
0.005724926,
0.0251082629,
-0.0321417749,
0.0348473825,
0.0127550177,
-0.0526543595,
-0.0811303332,
0.0164696034,
0.0619791932,
0.0087919319,
-0.0891536176,
0.0248407163,
0.0052245958,
0.0391414389,
-0.0272269491,
0.0328828953,
0.0375618078,
-0.0004680573,
0.0548626408,
-0.0368049257,
-0.0208917782,
-0.0500672087,
0.0147007247,
0.0423729159,
-0.0079958187,
0.017682327,
0.0184953399,
0.0279453341,
0.0131068518,
0.0000020368,
-0.0388478935,
0.0106151709,
-0.0317874514,
0.0227813683,
0.0219499338,
0.0715521276,
0.0163620021,
-0.0172872487,
0.0272983462,
-0.034157861,
0.0140172895,
0.0594014041,
0.0827271268,
0.0877483115,
0.0697398856,
-0.0252572708,
-0.0383502953,
-0.0274046753,
-0.0365514494,
0.011150972,
-0.0257029645,
-0.0129272221,
0.0308509488,
0.0270337388,
-0.028549796,
-0.0169220269,
0.0164039526,
0.0012560103,
-0.0121440664,
-0.0181585178,
0.0380731896,
-0.0087918611,
-0.0224099047,
0.0006706932,
0.0895944983,
0.0051766271,
0.0015572291,
-0.0039047422,
-0.0009163254,
0.0507733114,
-0.047011029,
-0.0181545746,
0.030348286,
0.0069199568,
0.0136279985,
0.0098763276,
0.0253199954,
-0.0120916264,
0.01854969,
-0.0447697788,
-0.0001552491,
0.0116155455,
0.0079183085,
-0.0367904678,
-0.0115423473,
-0.0141640939,
-0.0565677173,
0.0008290856,
0.0389941446,
-0.0412172005,
0.0360934921,
-0.072141923,
0.063622579,
-0.0229480714,
-0.0314895324,
0.0145548629,
0.0557451807,
0.0027981536,
0.0002531236,
0.0218715407,
0.0529859848,
-0.0027774367,
-0.0263062622,
-0.0287758633,
-0.0223051272,
-0.013154164,
-0.0304207243,
-0.061833635,
0.0361164548,
-0.0357225798,
-0.0582284182,
-0.0492723696,
0.0740027055,
0.002928135,
0.0193352513,
-0.0032098684,
0.0172461271,
-0.0373401493,
-0.006393529,
-0.0130039379,
-0.009356699,
-0.0601948835,
-0.0114612738,
0.0177496057,
-0.0442326441,
0.0245527364,
0.0317361243,
0.0319112018,
0.003136029,
0.0087778717,
0.0672653094,
-0.0339424089,
-0.0152042424,
-0.0034780072,
-0.0028314779,
-0.0098961042,
-0.0827042013,
-0.0425651222,
-0.0149883917,
0.0287945401,
-0.0370299928,
0.0303038023,
-0.0412908085,
0.0227934886,
0.0011899685,
0.0147076016,
0.0241382457,
0.0232560579,
0.0176921654,
0.0141484486,
0.0028944246,
0.0036232038,
0.0234241784,
0.0607856736,
0.0330068506,
0.0112557067,
-0.0301113408,
0.0301684234,
0.0371174999,
-0.0257112589,
-0.0221238397,
-0.0114570195,
-0.0245169848,
-0.0089884605,
0.044319775,
0.0235178936,
0.0761042237,
-0.0467832424,
-0.014315526,
0.1005422026,
0.0590167455,
-0.0011143857,
0.0570225976,
0.0055074887,
0.0383862257,
0.0210134424,
-0.0182548463,
-0.0321584158,
0.0553367622,
0.011498902,
0.0112362793,
-0.032050658,
0.0228047911,
-0.0442184843,
-0.0496906228,
0.0314256772,
-0.0149577344,
0.0421445891,
-0.0092548318,
-0.0056462381,
-0.0203411747,
-0.0325019658,
-0.0037005069,
0.0054227598,
-0.0897845402,
-0.0079685962,
-0.0201609191,
0.0305047315,
0.1224283129,
0.0397399738,
0.0073179775,
-0.0526786074,
-0.0129453838,
-0.0148351183,
0.0722225457,
0.045872055,
-0.029074613,
0.0188931841,
-0.0627464578,
0.0456047617,
-0.0034027987,
-0.0295009594,
0.0516806208,
0.0175806675,
0.0285936482,
0.0126831541,
0.0321393497,
-0.0247978643,
0.0129743386,
-0.0616923496,
-0.011878836,
-0.0056478567,
0.0042238976,
0.0198231656,
0.0122704441,
-0.028762674,
-0.0244955011,
0.0026621516,
-0.0102601685,
-0.0142171253,
0.098940514,
-0.0397937782,
-0.0198397264,
0.0514329076,
-0.0051525724,
-0.0106664989,
0.0245632268,
-0.0123687098,
-0.0465693437,
0.0228912495,
-0.0484025031,
0.0503408052,
-0.048951216,
0.046402134,
-0.0070070629,
0.0446384512,
0.0112992618,
0.0207756031,
0.0180690363,
-0.0658526421,
0.0243447833,
0.070595257,
-0.0058290432,
-0.077082321,
-0.0369171947,
0.0222458206,
0.0169514082,
0.0185427032,
0.0207250398,
0.0258304775,
-0.0345877483,
-0.057528805,
-0.103397429,
-0.0061281556,
0.0256791506,
-0.0325561799,
-0.0003303468,
0.0395990647,
-0.0392102599,
-0.0023097526,
-0.1024915352,
0.0057105655,
0.0181651395,
-0.0352959484,
0.0364381634,
-0.0059759435,
-0.0308064781,
-0.0633490235,
0.0303421691,
0.0183218159,
-0.0011937189,
0.0030628168,
-0.0240856446,
-0.0431832448,
-0.002826798,
-0.0388264768,
0.048187796,
-0.0237814113,
-0.0817470327,
0.0251424033,
-0.0152927553,
0.0472461917,
0.0598573163,
0.0431354828,
0.051587563,
-0.0074694925,
-0.0136386519,
-0.0605329461,
0.04206644,
0.0043841675,
0.0162417833,
-0.0080588618,
-0.0392251275,
0.0154112037,
0.0269898698,
0.0020111594,
0.0389088057,
-0.0820661113,
0.0193469655,
0.0541133881,
-0.0542034805,
0.0323119573,
0.014857742,
-0.0506620891,
-0.0217948668,
-0.0136133023,
-0.0196216479,
0.0467849821,
-0.0141125629,
-0.0577508807,
-0.0172853004,
0.0049987016,
-0.0223427583,
0.0749832392,
-0.0177100971,
0.0388725139,
0.0059069698,
-0.0129653262,
-0.0166945085,
0.0300667863,
-0.0245226901,
-0.0433578268,
0.0060140388,
-0.0247340146,
-0.0167298783,
0.0185473673,
-0.0091238404,
-0.0449253134,
-0.022100579,
-0.0349380262,
-0.020725552,
0.0326817445,
-0.0597395897,
-0.0126365824,
0.0295492187,
-0.0122076022,
0.0075310702,
-0.0226221569,
0.0107505703,
-0.0281512942,
-0.0218820535,
0.0683995187,
0.034280207,
-0.0188676547,
-0.026430238,
0.0970640704,
0.0214249473,
-0.0033354,
0.0076039433,
-0.0050429897,
0.0056496616,
0.0213977713,
-0.0040177573,
-0.0121808778,
-0.006628152,
0.0652000308,
-0.0176760871,
0.0116886161,
0.1482557654,
-0.0070560044,
-0.0092882961,
0.0231271684,
0.0111013046,
0.048275426,
0.0008229527,
0.0323482491,
-0.069754079,
-0.0069101844,
0.0193703547,
0.0113148214,
-0.0167364683,
-0.0063330401,
-0.0375331156,
-0.1117377952,
0.0396727324,
0.0361882374,
-0.0526865944,
-0.0275521148,
0.0415795036,
-0.0057566087,
-0.0101107508,
0.0141669493,
0.0025668738,
0.0146926763,
-0.0301277936,
-0.0236034617,
-0.0435989276,
-0.0258621871,
0.0249797925,
-0.0395821221,
0.0923496038,
0.0376210772,
0.0870153606,
0.02607367,
0.0102891261,
-0.0123930341,
0.0571927093,
0.0088069439,
0.0021671692,
0.0474133939,
-0.0226805024,
-0.0490120836,
-0.0518696494,
0.0562281609,
-0.0259056948,
0.0187104791,
0.0219820719,
-0.0134992572,
-0.0380966105,
-0.0198617224,
0.0063578552,
0.0247965083,
0.0041175312,
0.0793095306,
0.0061663389,
-0.0897832364,
-0.0307769217,
-0.0276663117,
-0.0066532372,
-0.068195641,
-0.0246633179,
0.0107250744,
-0.0124494331,
-0.0191393197,
-0.0956716388,
-0.0686019287,
0.0080326283,
0.0335563533,
0.0020748426,
-0.038354326,
0.0030316242,
0.024244139,
-0.0058827959,
-0.0193224642,
-0.0313250385,
0.0061261826,
-0.0432619005,
-0.045915585,
0.0225363653,
-0.0764786229,
0.0305396244,
0.0176837817,
-0.025702389,
-0.0653808191,
-0.0072553772,
0.0313675441,
0.0192312598,
0.0601337925,
-0.0049096816,
-0.0492966734,
-0.0265112668,
-0.0369020961,
0.0217408668,
0.0216355026,
0.0186370816,
0.0456502624,
-0.0157325398,
0.0123083871,
-0.0082851555,
0.03424263,
-0.0373383872,
0.0187998433,
-0.0356826037,
-0.0646672621,
0.0113942102,
0.030976709,
-0.0711610988,
-0.0192055739,
0.0003972212,
-0.0386561751,
0.0057156798,
-0.077109158,
-0.0211571977,
-0.0575756356,
-0.0364929587,
0.0383705646,
0.0272401217,
-0.0025453237,
-0.0638337731,
-0.0295004025,
0.0076482641,
-0.0245497376,
-0.0189717896,
-0.0267453361,
0.0291597582,
-0.0052985931,
0.0189742427,
-0.0259599071,
0.0324636921,
-0.0260068625,
0.0365527384,
0.0161336511,
0.0593306348,
-0.0168740712,
-0.0419920571,
0.0253090821,
0.0429442264,
-0.0428650305,
-0.0426532961,
-0.0274826717,
0.0320972279,
0.0280750636,
0.0267153028,
0.0739441887,
-0.0622557178,
0.0320211053,
-0.0111395009,
0.0336739607,
0.0154476818,
-0.0545879118,
-0.0301126875,
0.0044689369,
-0.0409709699,
-0.0448669158,
0.0431422107,
0.0183643699,
0.0542061217,
-0.0106117353,
0.0051473724,
-0.061937917,
-0.0026928976,
0.0346158966,
-0.0020888939,
-0.0121349776,
-0.0044162148,
-0.053172797,
-0.0408076122,
0.0174559988,
0.0096740518,
0.0018565365,
-0.0308374204,
0.0164057538,
0.006403734,
-0.0325005129,
0.0222197194,
-0.040261697,
0.0295067709,
-0.0424523205,
-0.010452643,
-0.007380689,
-5.763650473e-33,
-0.0287463292,
0.0147184674,
0.0198807027,
0.0222777054,
-0.0592295416,
-0.0403546356,
-0.0528126433,
0.0066598956,
-0.0194122754,
-0.0013197776,
-0.0023087976,
0.0109659247,
0.0040876493,
0.0189135391,
-0.0061019845,
0.0135989357,
0.0607994311,
0.0175193734,
-0.0127976891,
0.0335052982,
0.0330444947,
0.0228482075,
0.0133078108,
-0.0763646662,
-0.0011530641,
-0.0399652869,
-0.0435749143,
-0.0014355764,
0.0428652242,
0.0516104251,
-0.0211148784,
0.0118486872,
0.0043317243,
0.0213641413,
-0.0221114028,
0.0303594377,
-0.0512697212,
-0.0164850969,
-0.003246736,
0.0525060631,
-0.0018706637,
-0.0532253645,
-0.0274251103,
-0.0439356342,
-0.0134201385,
0.0041752555,
0.013294776,
-0.0271484442,
0.0340723209,
0.0068078106,
-0.0738162771,
0.0009911228,
-0.0182048716,
-0.047462225,
-0.0079744039,
0.0513331331,
-0.0099746389,
0.0055022081,
0.0061550005,
0.0318292119,
0.0037061481,
-0.0369777493,
0.0046783169,
0.0472594723,
0.0365611538,
0.0570038483,
0.0496787615,
0.0363612846,
-0.0181741137,
0.0091716442,
0.0232629646,
0.0511802435,
0.0155014805,
0.0710868984,
-0.0428883806,
-0.0120912362,
-0.0030348897,
0.0351719931,
0.068525292,
0.0039571663,
0.0332913734,
0.0519605651,
-0.0434178822,
-0.0105882082,
-0.0024868571,
-0.0096961977,
-0.0153102884,
-0.0486873761,
0.0178921074,
0.0157773867,
-0.0563746914,
-0.0372294895,
0.0417937525,
-0.0433422588,
0.0071716974,
0.0346252471,
-0.0455568843,
0.0213650186,
-0.0200553015,
0.0083620567,
-0.0127144028,
-0.0683436617,
0.0647942722,
-0.005198196,
0.017324077,
0.0329189524,
-0.0282750279,
0.0399212427,
-0.0263011325,
0.0023395184,
-0.0109842671,
0.0311043318,
0.0003850697,
0.0264888331,
-0.0128027825,
-0.0247196872,
-0.0368812196,
0.0111899348,
-0.001998665,
0.0280034337,
-0.0497102998,
-0.0392491892,
-0.0010251467,
-0.0232428685,
-0.0474857129,
0.0221466478,
-0.0325339548,
-0.0076368055,
0.0282665193,
-0.0312455483,
-0.0134448018,
-0.0194878876,
2.69e-7,
-0.0376462489,
0.0114031024,
0.0446735546,
0.0281978678,
0.0286858734,
0.0294937529,
0.0028087734,
0.0420513973,
0.0284217391,
-0.0029589706,
0.0363796912,
0.0495106205,
0.0756055117,
-0.0193811879,
-0.07943248,
0.0090269465,
-0.0351322442,
-0.0276215188,
-0.0016246288,
0.0037463326,
0.0481176525,
0.0694799647,
0.0123579931,
0.0108277909,
0.0349486284,
-0.0095147956,
0.0503261983,
-0.0467867889,
-0.0335142314,
0.0395290479,
0.0004816899,
-0.0053049373,
-0.0272413902,
-0.0348142572,
0.0266574286,
0.0309405047,
0.0086378139,
0.0697258413,
-0.0195668619,
-0.0184209757,
0.019256711,
0.043269109,
-0.012833437,
-0.0358110107,
0.0338915773,
0.0040110392,
-0.0225244556,
-0.0143713374,
0.0117716715,
-0.0062121265,
-0.0016162468,
-0.0434095487,
-0.0424250029,
0.0230336767,
0.014360521,
-0.0274068452,
0.0158489011,
-0.0467846133,
-0.0201931596,
-0.0354163162,
-0.0656041801,
-0.0408490673,
-0.0310254749,
-0.0051822676,
-0.00661476,
-0.0148060583,
0.0219043009,
1.797475618e-34,
0.0104246819,
-0.007161567,
0.0030632557,
0.0479225852,
0.0529581755,
0.0104956375,
0.0082765939,
0.0216564666,
0.0675454438,
-0.0704304501,
-0.0348988064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16822v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16822v2 | Large Language Models Suffer From Their Own Output: An Analysis of the Self-Consuming Training Loop | 2023-11-28T14:36:43 | 2024-06-17T07:07:30 | Martin Briesch, Dominik Sobania, Franz Rothlauf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE | Large Language Models (LLM) are already widely used to generate content for a
variety of online platforms. As we are not able to safely distinguish
LLM-generated content from human-produced content, LLM-generated content is
used to train the next generation of LLMs, giving rise to a self-consuming
training loop. From the image generation domain we know that such a
self-consuming training loop reduces both quality and diversity of images
finally ending in a model collapse. However, it is unclear whether this
alarming effect can also be observed for LLMs. Therefore, we present the first
study investigating the self-consuming training loop for LLMs. Further, we
propose a novel method based on logic expressions that allows us to
unambiguously verify the correctness of LLM-generated content, which is
difficult for natural language text. We find that the self-consuming training
loop produces correct outputs, however, the output declines in its diversity
depending on the proportion of the used generated data. Fresh data can slow
down this decline, but not stop it. Given these concerning results, we
encourage researchers to study methods to negate this process. | [
0.0310565028,
0.0849830955,
-0.0208738465,
0.0639192015,
-0.0436537415,
0.0065835374,
0.0079852967,
0.021885192,
0.0302523654,
-0.0305286162,
0.0090056192,
-0.0296829287,
-0.0033520565,
0.0274678897,
0.0297013652,
-0.0546438098,
0.0400518514,
-0.0529222339,
-0.0288154166,
-0.0436857902,
-0.001171713,
0.0030860158,
0.0326751433,
-0.0028135707,
-0.0376696512,
-0.0405885987,
-0.001737158,
0.0178451221,
-0.0274051577,
-0.0237164479,
-0.0372478552,
0.0527699292,
-0.0048527461,
0.052007284,
0.0000021688,
-0.048226431,
-0.0103155607,
0.0083269337,
-0.0261034165,
0.030938182,
0.0760361925,
0.0037976187,
-0.0336998291,
0.0151431803,
-0.0294474214,
0.016632827,
0.0448811352,
0.0588680804,
0.0812804773,
0.0866691768,
-0.0059419987,
-0.0395551436,
0.0344572067,
-0.0084685972,
-0.012428375,
0.0108492691,
0.0276465565,
0.0242467038,
-0.007000648,
-0.0115714669,
-0.0171902068,
0.04858163,
0.0344071724,
-0.0241425019,
0.0030526065,
0.057448402,
0.0170195773,
-0.0594943538,
0.0027745964,
0.0250361934,
-0.0192713998,
-0.0214984808,
0.0261004735,
-0.0212762356,
-0.0003259688,
0.0116968676,
-0.0385631993,
0.0819955841,
0.0011781128,
0.0332810394,
-0.0152486088,
-0.0304565504,
0.0254367534,
0.0139300898,
-0.0364023298,
0.0296076238,
0.0230896622,
-0.0314303748,
-0.0141980834,
0.0358933918,
0.0094080772,
-0.0679259449,
-0.0180237554,
0.0115829315,
-0.0003212701,
0.0273025427,
-0.056295678,
-0.0394413471,
0.0293650869,
-0.0770758912,
0.0439928584,
-0.0033145058,
-0.0553994589,
0.031840127,
-0.0150399888,
0.0150549635,
-0.0186316632,
0.0128757227,
-0.0376652554,
0.0380711928,
-0.0307401791,
-0.0234956108,
-0.0389357731,
0.0471813232,
0.0110432412,
-0.0367529653,
-0.0445089787,
0.0300211459,
-0.0422804356,
0.0149822263,
-0.011173415,
0.0183124654,
-0.0223481227,
-0.0025858087,
-0.0318729058,
0.0296745412,
-0.0006695904,
0.0048277457,
-0.0085806502,
-0.0727077052,
0.0269473605,
0.0468677916,
0.0103306137,
0.0050306162,
-0.0024621482,
0.0632955134,
-0.0049686795,
-0.0092891231,
-0.0621545129,
-0.0561127327,
-0.0303134359,
-0.0775644034,
0.0183633417,
-0.0970104188,
-0.0128397038,
-0.0139247868,
0.0115536507,
-0.0301455837,
-0.0019001361,
0.0265579019,
-0.0358219445,
0.0652908161,
-0.0597654358,
0.0435183793,
0.0336637609,
0.008274002,
0.017345529,
0.1234112456,
0.0242530461,
0.0274590738,
0.0615211613,
-0.0253805015,
0.0154217128,
0.058524657,
0.0162473489,
0.0249893405,
-0.0637846813,
-0.0105380043,
-0.0152261974,
-0.000509978,
0.0344755687,
0.0734453276,
-0.0357683226,
0.0121004824,
0.0808206871,
0.0282658506,
0.0132811489,
0.0341116674,
0.029238306,
-0.0030333058,
0.027671406,
0.0964650065,
-0.0709075257,
0.0163703375,
-0.0128140394,
0.0287385676,
0.0282131899,
0.0310984217,
-0.0284107085,
-0.0401616096,
-0.0117136873,
-0.019940136,
0.0113670956,
-0.0115144383,
0.0609085783,
0.0248142909,
-0.0054532783,
0.0599328578,
0.0294869803,
-0.0634152815,
0.0174249075,
-0.0581761152,
0.0544878803,
0.0610845387,
0.0365832672,
0.0149622867,
-0.0009096746,
0.0074831983,
0.0156291686,
0.068810232,
0.0116401874,
0.0155620845,
-0.0116286436,
-0.0213598181,
-0.0408619493,
-0.0023390092,
0.0016828588,
-0.0001779998,
0.0243182555,
0.0085281106,
0.0016526227,
-0.0104837297,
-0.0612170622,
0.0339047015,
-0.0254749041,
-0.0005960196,
0.0034426677,
0.0167498495,
0.0156578943,
0.0078846589,
-0.0372063406,
0.0199022442,
0.0396072417,
-0.0336775258,
-0.0467701182,
0.0028174799,
-0.0454839729,
-0.0293384604,
0.0660323948,
-0.0696686208,
-0.0366899818,
-0.0077690175,
-0.0517178141,
-0.0259542335,
0.0468872823,
-0.0532682203,
0.0240750574,
-0.0627260357,
0.0184959378,
0.0011592989,
0.0091870781,
-0.0048253876,
0.0754143596,
0.001278505,
0.0107707381,
0.0009713204,
-0.0020305421,
0.0185600817,
-0.0396082252,
-0.004864736,
0.0134748677,
-0.0226551481,
0.0312241837,
0.0348198153,
0.0200830046,
-0.0502796285,
-0.0434365273,
-0.0643579215,
-0.0299656149,
-0.0066165212,
0.0035817646,
0.0028251507,
-0.019281663,
-0.0125860451,
-0.0176412389,
-0.0283993874,
-0.0120488526,
0.0462990142,
0.0503348559,
0.026653422,
-0.0056615886,
0.0056361244,
-0.0062321099,
-0.023847647,
0.0100739859,
0.0504971743,
0.0110545419,
0.0058186767,
-0.0745726824,
0.0230988227,
-0.0342960879,
0.024586698,
0.0134406127,
-0.0382413268,
0.0233867075,
-0.0228851009,
0.0303716324,
0.0323420577,
0.0495115779,
0.0003544684,
0.0634440258,
0.0183224827,
-0.0408833064,
-0.0126705905,
-0.0177303571,
-0.0230153874,
-0.0190706514,
-0.0564468727,
-0.0023153715,
0.0316653624,
0.0109137734,
0.0072221006,
-0.055178456,
0.0366532318,
-0.0435517281,
-0.0435308814,
-0.0178888291,
-0.029434504,
-0.0315462947,
0.0343132205,
-0.0094705755,
-0.0699034259,
0.0293339584,
-0.0138083985,
0.0086918231,
0.000351248,
0.0044608559,
-0.0232262928,
0.0468326658,
0.0309066381,
0.0425707474,
0.0822603852,
0.0045912964,
-0.0545131415,
-0.0158340819,
0.0488139242,
-0.0328030325,
0.0647060946,
-0.0335277431,
0.0198525339,
-0.0189206339,
-0.0316586383,
-0.0612751208,
-0.0163103472,
-0.0014764012,
-0.0337234251,
-0.00497108,
0.0058617881,
0.0238533113,
-0.0143507943,
0.0052680504,
-0.0033971677,
-0.0312731564,
-0.0101340283,
-0.0040666969,
0.0703097433,
0.0668239966,
-0.0145087782,
0.0089328503,
-0.0678091943,
0.0150137926,
0.0519126356,
-0.0035428726,
0.039257966,
-0.0472870357,
-0.0004210657,
0.0171997324,
0.0139957489,
-0.0316791125,
0.0295099914,
0.0258245412,
-0.0443623811,
-0.0067992839,
0.1113899648,
0.0000020676,
-0.0216228273,
-0.0008410288,
-0.0045574964,
0.0318673179,
0.0268657953,
0.0120737348,
-0.0778641477,
0.0143429358,
-0.0022042757,
0.0148652876,
-0.0164976902,
0.0166703463,
-0.0256557986,
-0.1415077895,
0.0761324838,
0.0176071394,
-0.0286979768,
0.0038305207,
-0.0466293506,
-0.038290035,
-0.0170871131,
-0.0227383636,
0.0022472513,
-0.0318422802,
0.0128760738,
0.0264808815,
-0.0313184857,
-0.0393628515,
-0.0399088003,
-0.0591027774,
0.0291557591,
0.0662833899,
0.0321923606,
-0.0377640463,
-0.0432131961,
0.0418228395,
0.0033249417,
0.0017208768,
-0.0143208355,
0.0672164932,
0.0288576651,
-0.0257322565,
-0.0008829049,
0.0014812871,
0.0021524606,
-0.0177094527,
0.005256894,
0.0604967363,
0.0077430708,
-0.0586903654,
-0.0388074182,
0.0086512621,
-0.0037422017,
0.0759840012,
0.0371349156,
-0.0346371755,
-0.0225439947,
-0.0296210479,
0.011353313,
-0.046670258,
-0.0267104208,
0.0466681346,
-0.0202706233,
-0.0399819613,
-0.085861735,
-0.0105527062,
-0.050240811,
0.0537192114,
-0.0024507274,
0.0070599122,
0.0116731534,
-0.0121306442,
-0.0210513212,
0.0112465685,
-0.0434255525,
-0.0048450511,
-0.0681820735,
0.0066875354,
-0.004742736,
-0.0191330072,
0.0081570083,
0.0011966046,
-0.1144062504,
-0.0728891641,
0.0044449591,
0.0526461229,
0.0252018906,
0.0470476747,
0.0317059606,
-0.0588344969,
0.0607862025,
0.0724097416,
-0.0111454874,
0.0350136422,
0.0300359763,
-0.020241186,
0.0039750044,
0.0361976847,
-0.0220366903,
0.0219823979,
0.026188219,
-0.0107459268,
-0.0213144626,
-0.0192321818,
0.0126621751,
0.0478301458,
0.0063919136,
-0.0613457337,
0.0110473474,
-0.0212037973,
-0.0150034437,
-0.0327036753,
-0.0313542709,
-0.0507832654,
0.0275911577,
0.0117451781,
0.0106048239,
0.0011499898,
0.0269159749,
-0.0126540428,
0.0296199396,
-0.0271891374,
-0.0169854145,
-0.0055083837,
-0.0192999635,
0.0237984005,
0.0190338809,
-0.0017168872,
0.0075301873,
-0.0156723745,
-0.0029059935,
-0.0110248663,
0.021534754,
0.0282359738,
0.0130874766,
-0.002169406,
0.0067446153,
-0.0329790153,
-0.0578037016,
-0.0328609794,
0.0258729886,
0.0741954222,
0.0003721396,
0.0661437288,
-0.0333797745,
-0.0085255718,
-0.0398984291,
0.0137015563,
0.0121819982,
-0.0511430204,
0.0077181095,
-0.0006870375,
-0.0304220933,
-0.0266954135,
0.0886746719,
0.0071102548,
0.0344845727,
0.0022689493,
0.0136507694,
-0.033733394,
-0.0262545142,
-0.0040270169,
-0.0347225219,
-0.0194649603,
0.0117580742,
-0.0231189094,
-0.1083908528,
0.0020625412,
0.0281877536,
0.0237483457,
-0.0028243288,
0.0364925452,
0.0544676892,
0.0106353266,
0.0068292692,
-0.0350572839,
0.0200536661,
0.0095662568,
-0.011616718,
0.0192594305,
-6.921139556e-33,
-0.0069439835,
-0.0376917869,
0.0120706121,
-0.0501778983,
-0.0080555668,
0.0063608154,
-0.0354192518,
-0.004887634,
0.0221126731,
0.0108462684,
-0.0062803221,
-0.0057727019,
0.0173657592,
0.0458231196,
0.0287894923,
0.030866513,
0.0796083584,
-0.0366375297,
-0.028301144,
0.0129548023,
0.0199251287,
-0.0017360674,
0.0204291921,
-0.0637815893,
-0.0012761102,
0.0148851993,
-0.0275804661,
0.0166965146,
0.0118477279,
0.0719844252,
-0.0193364136,
0.0364662074,
0.0136933643,
-0.0550288372,
-0.0302524716,
-0.0117459903,
-0.057243038,
-0.0398509651,
0.0054610292,
0.0216160752,
-0.0646601915,
-0.0206636563,
0.0759033486,
-0.0388110168,
-0.021022927,
-0.0142624881,
0.0558017716,
-0.0222511906,
-0.0214259736,
-0.0018728996,
-0.0514798649,
0.0369178504,
0.0010637777,
0.0012808626,
0.0118527962,
0.0025830748,
0.0087623447,
-0.0090201385,
-0.0376663059,
0.0431684703,
0.0572259426,
0.031244019,
0.0699840412,
0.0116526866,
0.0253259353,
0.054924354,
0.0389530137,
0.0018133805,
-0.0192584787,
-0.0274427924,
0.0403138883,
0.0741702169,
0.0448559113,
0.0466759168,
0.0585339516,
-0.0273393393,
-0.0439471938,
0.0113789905,
-0.0299039818,
0.0324447416,
0.0292539168,
0.0126449782,
-0.0056333807,
-0.0269927755,
-0.0175875593,
-0.0375104509,
-0.0256031528,
-0.0361959189,
0.0145884901,
0.0441704839,
-0.0431982316,
-0.0210862197,
0.0263555963,
-0.0743760467,
-0.0533590801,
-0.0107214674,
-0.0274654329,
0.0211957861,
0.0151953045,
0.0159744676,
-0.0404598378,
-0.0188728888,
0.007914532,
0.0075025195,
0.019347243,
0.0259126984,
0.0435277447,
0.0389714055,
-0.0816779062,
0.018560091,
-0.0378834419,
0.0140337283,
0.0485415608,
-0.0148359127,
0.0460739285,
-0.0290600043,
-0.0225967783,
0.03417667,
0.0345007889,
0.003116729,
-0.0508787781,
-0.0014026883,
0.0088785598,
0.0443111919,
-0.0294710118,
-0.0167713407,
-0.0491607077,
0.0207748469,
0.0686414093,
-0.0638230294,
-0.0294980332,
-0.0051284358,
2.849e-7,
0.0021130673,
0.0503627956,
0.0047902255,
0.0421113558,
0.0502672233,
0.0488000363,
-0.0328276493,
0.0056762598,
-0.0172354467,
-0.0142275197,
-0.0247051008,
0.041084595,
0.0531500056,
0.0425079763,
-0.026110664,
0.0452921726,
-0.0854352117,
0.0080299117,
-0.0339642689,
0.0071484642,
0.041836001,
0.0694177896,
0.0098265503,
-0.038200248,
0.0140280342,
-0.0649618283,
0.0753622577,
0.0131011084,
0.0077552707,
0.0039009994,
0.0322137251,
0.0201974474,
0.0160077717,
-0.0181013383,
-0.0234776624,
-0.0295932181,
-0.0158248972,
0.031492427,
0.0025449854,
0.0194718484,
0.00862516,
-0.0182185341,
-0.0141443219,
-0.0652694404,
0.0883022323,
-0.0300985295,
-0.028988326,
-0.1190377027,
-0.0127157709,
-0.0419331267,
0.0311207008,
-0.0298924819,
-0.0327328183,
0.0364542045,
0.0167925656,
-0.0191077925,
-0.0273441616,
-0.0558179654,
-0.0322219506,
-0.0339777172,
-0.0504455827,
-0.0344462581,
-0.0507164188,
0.0481404178,
0.0242800098,
-0.0424923487,
0.0025345681,
2.532199651e-34,
0.0354341045,
-0.0194064267,
0.0042726519,
-0.0010893801,
0.005135756,
0.0028874853,
-0.0159972534,
0.0138019286,
-0.0318519138,
-0.0263250191,
-0.0218847375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16789v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16789v1 | A Survey of the Evolution of Language Model-Based Dialogue Systems | 2023-11-28T13:51:32 | 2023-11-28T13:51:32 | Hongru Wang, Lingzhi Wang, Yiming Du, Liang Chen, Jingyan Zhou, Yufei Wang, Kam-Fai Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Dialogue systems, including task-oriented_dialogue_system (TOD) and
open-domain_dialogue_system (ODD), have undergone significant transformations,
with language_models (LM) playing a central role. This survey delves into the
historical trajectory of dialogue systems, elucidating their intricate
relationship with advancements in language models by categorizing this
evolution into four distinct stages, each marked by pivotal LM breakthroughs:
1) Early_Stage: characterized by statistical LMs, resulting in rule-based or
machine-learning-driven dialogue_systems; 2) Independent development of TOD and
ODD based on neural_language_models (NLM; e.g., LSTM and GRU), since NLMs lack
intrinsic knowledge in their parameters; 3) fusion between different types of
dialogue systems with the advert of pre-trained_language_models (PLMs),
starting from the fusion between four_sub-tasks_within_TOD, and then
TOD_with_ODD; and 4) current LLM-based_dialogue_system, wherein LLMs can be
used to conduct TOD and ODD seamlessly. Thus, our survey provides a
chronological perspective aligned with LM breakthroughs, offering a
comprehensive review of state-of-the-art research outcomes. What's more, we
focus on emerging topics and discuss open challenges, providing valuable
insights into future directions for LLM-based_dialogue_systems. Through this
exploration, we pave the way for a deeper_comprehension of the evolution,
guiding future developments in LM-based dialogue_systems. | [
0.0917205662,
0.0069867778,
-0.0125676934,
0.0602014437,
-0.0261684395,
0.0077141635,
0.0138487564,
-0.0164144188,
0.0113626979,
-0.0828401893,
-0.0432337187,
-0.0332893543,
-0.0118902028,
0.0671548396,
0.0177144986,
-0.0560545623,
0.0466059558,
-0.0432127304,
0.0378525145,
0.0076806811,
-0.0103233568,
0.000942259,
-0.0183587875,
0.0663357228,
0.0155569008,
0.0053216764,
-0.0407485217,
0.0013321792,
-0.0275661778,
-0.0108780554,
-0.0058181724,
0.0290127974,
0.0425812975,
0.0512441397,
0.0000015162,
-0.0646598116,
0.0438138358,
-0.0266814344,
-0.0392324477,
-0.0292785391,
0.0176436529,
0.0240921378,
0.002986213,
0.023878241,
-0.0688937306,
-0.0413328633,
0.0274359193,
0.0698828772,
0.0820775926,
0.0698256716,
0.0051101265,
-0.0324376523,
0.0432445891,
-0.0395717472,
-0.0308087599,
-0.0529480986,
0.0078116702,
0.0028177865,
0.0222750846,
0.0148915136,
0.006684476,
0.0253226403,
0.0127505669,
-0.0494786352,
-0.0409065895,
0.0064126095,
0.0052137603,
-0.0020657887,
-0.0639436245,
0.0929567069,
0.0106628956,
0.0197865907,
-0.0071927472,
0.0112708332,
0.02174161,
-0.0363496505,
-0.0589601509,
0.0234689992,
0.0164202303,
0.0231538191,
0.0021781209,
0.0026280039,
-0.0124047128,
0.0316722058,
-0.0164361671,
0.0615583956,
-0.0037280489,
-0.0391534977,
0.0047958018,
0.003425749,
-0.0141731454,
-0.1044016778,
0.0101552214,
0.0633182153,
-0.0242477953,
0.034637861,
-0.0315178297,
0.0104426546,
0.0223556329,
-0.0212115757,
0.0420683026,
0.04043952,
-0.0434561186,
0.0656976253,
0.023453841,
0.070469968,
-0.0407652184,
0.0063185836,
-0.0192532707,
-0.0079044066,
-0.0252579898,
0.0041287714,
-0.0402813554,
0.0387867205,
-0.0749206096,
-0.0247091614,
0.0081560528,
0.0965716317,
0.0266654119,
0.0087611731,
0.0212800559,
0.0262829848,
-0.006900779,
0.0021463074,
-0.0546228625,
0.012066762,
-0.0034739559,
0.0339018591,
0.008624427,
-0.0410702042,
-0.017922515,
0.0461735316,
-0.0120899463,
-0.0148249138,
-0.0264791884,
0.0861473605,
0.0023239793,
-0.0283291545,
-0.0051801619,
-0.0029757922,
-0.0444266684,
-0.0757115111,
-0.0080329394,
-0.0099161174,
0.0238701757,
-0.0131687745,
-0.0211045351,
-0.0591222346,
0.0315354541,
0.0229878034,
-0.0389153771,
0.0484442376,
-0.0239677615,
-0.0004926495,
0.0579092018,
-0.0019202546,
-0.0155721344,
0.013764495,
0.0396936685,
-0.0119308373,
0.0115551762,
0.0103233634,
0.0266471487,
0.0329417028,
-0.0158102233,
-0.0030897141,
0.0194631591,
0.0323708467,
-0.007994201,
0.0415667817,
0.0102240937,
0.0996039659,
-0.03123134,
-0.022461012,
0.063136071,
0.0489847139,
-0.0110338852,
0.0024260373,
0.0736984238,
0.0274479259,
0.0344197378,
0.0068730311,
-0.0402275659,
-0.0110464264,
-0.0169710312,
0.0061953929,
0.0139624635,
-0.010373421,
-0.0452178419,
-0.0611920282,
-0.0097309537,
-0.0268291272,
0.033013124,
0.006417559,
0.0656210631,
0.0162165817,
-0.0643491223,
0.0226007998,
0.010715792,
-0.0302602798,
-0.0282353461,
-0.0701703206,
0.027017666,
0.0206416585,
0.0467347279,
-0.025437085,
-0.0546791777,
-0.0421400033,
0.0039658719,
0.0861162767,
0.0439408608,
-0.0126284519,
0.0157164019,
-0.0601604171,
-0.0020081163,
-0.0555783957,
-0.0167263374,
-0.0061923089,
-0.0289759673,
-0.0076258597,
0.004796681,
0.0116841067,
-0.0179115701,
0.02198801,
-0.0100347539,
-0.0003368535,
0.0301865861,
-0.0039176666,
0.0306177977,
0.0354473144,
-0.0030543234,
-0.0058068815,
0.0490367785,
-0.0008721845,
-0.0045684348,
0.032552693,
-0.0465998836,
-0.0595502183,
0.0434996001,
0.0414274968,
-0.0077820937,
0.019483557,
-0.0399658158,
-0.0657426938,
0.0447775275,
-0.0587566681,
0.0054906681,
-0.0776027963,
0.0260090251,
0.0305522811,
0.0225531533,
-0.0522144735,
0.0301408097,
-0.0093765585,
-0.0322564766,
0.0657249838,
0.0275029447,
0.042148117,
-0.0739073306,
-0.0063750311,
-0.0020523553,
-0.0022662398,
-0.0057805548,
0.0022167615,
0.0195082463,
-0.032345783,
-0.0247891136,
-0.0929843113,
0.0008093337,
-0.0225886256,
0.0168886147,
-0.0143205505,
-0.0089992983,
-0.0102173435,
-0.0496890061,
-0.0316570215,
-0.0032625392,
0.0767315477,
-0.0408640131,
0.0682456568,
0.0484356396,
-0.0429177694,
-0.0497374348,
0.0175904576,
0.0030415384,
0.0372260399,
-0.0070937797,
-0.0305396039,
-0.0755844191,
0.0368896835,
-0.0589588694,
0.0705308318,
-0.0148311853,
-0.0152829159,
0.0420595594,
0.0178971235,
0.0556306094,
0.0467584506,
0.027057549,
0.0201386157,
0.0267941188,
-0.047723975,
-0.0380002409,
0.0708663166,
-0.0318547897,
-0.0073407311,
-0.029158527,
0.0269658267,
0.0284409299,
0.0350644588,
0.020193208,
0.0205947943,
-0.0190505162,
0.0339230448,
0.0333914496,
-0.0592355244,
0.0066952952,
-0.0309454743,
-0.0627637804,
0.0301302243,
-0.0136131225,
-0.0349507481,
0.0626717508,
-0.0355621316,
-0.026060652,
-0.0609801859,
-0.0301948376,
-0.0496007688,
0.042813357,
-0.0290247891,
-0.008913273,
0.0454355292,
-0.0419138782,
-0.0207147431,
0.016334489,
-0.0260317251,
-0.0374336652,
0.0552768111,
-0.0595825016,
0.0033622098,
0.0001777576,
-0.042654682,
-0.0635707453,
-0.0380605981,
-0.0302269422,
-0.0037564945,
-0.0255899709,
-0.0162790138,
-0.0076767774,
0.0197227187,
-0.0165549889,
0.0371100679,
-0.0017608651,
0.0078443987,
-0.0486670509,
0.0540550835,
0.0306238364,
0.0336771831,
-0.0115924142,
0.0245130081,
0.0699173063,
0.0105429776,
0.0307442751,
-0.0105655072,
-0.0086955288,
-0.0146515537,
0.044406902,
-0.0050540986,
-0.0331733674,
0.0164081603,
0.0334095769,
-0.0351623744,
-0.0205266681,
0.1274247766,
0.0325509049,
-0.0076950677,
-0.0383418761,
-0.0388100743,
-0.0270040575,
0.0086068856,
0.0233791173,
-0.0791425109,
-0.0246102624,
-0.013134364,
-0.0057895337,
-0.0080013266,
-0.0153844785,
-0.0274129454,
-0.0879369006,
0.0257069301,
-0.0259420257,
-0.0292371605,
-0.0074047307,
0.0326300375,
0.0142212817,
0.0210910924,
0.0404666625,
0.000527557,
0.0208964776,
-0.0240689032,
-0.0068678935,
-0.0011854519,
0.0087185847,
0.0226440467,
-0.0417123251,
0.077176854,
0.0849752501,
0.0538471006,
0.0362225287,
-0.0032519198,
0.0386699028,
0.024343757,
0.0283231065,
-0.0160520654,
0.0196425393,
-0.0225887261,
-0.02218052,
-0.0144115621,
0.0064106127,
-0.0268482156,
0.0105463825,
0.0178212244,
0.0488856435,
-0.0672893003,
0.0027420132,
-0.0051994179,
0.0509186648,
0.0404833779,
0.0718889534,
0.0283390805,
-0.0587742776,
-0.0419077501,
-0.0288178343,
-0.0297437198,
-0.0277065374,
0.0070649534,
-0.0117243994,
0.0259993616,
0.0155595317,
-0.0744118765,
-0.041334983,
0.0005382393,
0.0023930708,
0.0101665389,
0.020439839,
-0.0012031877,
-0.0025597382,
-0.0039158813,
0.0088077085,
-0.0252271499,
-0.007931117,
-0.0713303238,
-0.0209945682,
0.0599348247,
-0.0479113795,
-0.0189474057,
0.0388642661,
-0.0880997181,
-0.0735806078,
-0.0362278149,
0.0754777715,
0.0222287551,
0.0174834244,
-0.0136501677,
-0.0329057164,
-0.0089482758,
-0.0142915091,
-0.0174176618,
0.0135288602,
0.0550341308,
0.0356376134,
-0.0160684902,
0.0417411178,
-0.0184953921,
-0.0055278083,
-0.0022935381,
0.0078053204,
-0.0273354501,
-0.0965490043,
-0.0014377445,
-0.0383153558,
0.0661235452,
0.0300904084,
-0.0504727848,
-0.0248039197,
0.0263938382,
-0.0271024462,
-0.0240402762,
-0.0717000142,
0.0183674749,
-0.0245763138,
0.0203298256,
-0.0059892656,
-0.0086526461,
-0.0405495614,
0.0443340987,
-0.0281493794,
-0.0101941405,
0.0434902012,
0.0074519338,
-0.0322152935,
-0.0157869793,
-0.0208716784,
0.0499939471,
0.0005273371,
0.0182869826,
0.015294252,
0.1101184338,
0.0129276281,
-0.0335203148,
0.0247489698,
0.0773515254,
-0.0628936216,
-0.0534718372,
0.0273485649,
0.0045521744,
0.0289180093,
0.0792478174,
0.0300533995,
-0.0263981763,
0.0114860907,
-0.0051457938,
0.0504490435,
-0.0076539274,
-0.0142979156,
0.0381926261,
0.0054228264,
-0.0233052503,
0.0411055684,
0.0344153717,
0.0087151285,
0.0089677637,
0.0234530903,
0.0176166743,
-0.0462099798,
-0.0133985719,
0.0039825048,
0.0302921012,
-0.0094059454,
0.0367857665,
-0.0250319,
-0.0240620859,
0.0087302206,
0.0139184538,
-0.0038889996,
-0.0243370775,
0.0474693589,
0.0472148396,
0.0188670419,
-0.0004784934,
-0.0201569181,
0.0050672702,
-0.0029140518,
-0.0265603047,
-0.038332548,
-5.014893265e-33,
-0.045006901,
-0.0024754561,
0.0349147655,
0.0243341681,
-0.0415054746,
-0.0635246634,
-0.0429459326,
0.0019063222,
-0.0449128076,
-0.0118826106,
-0.021220332,
0.0214465819,
0.0060878396,
0.0077697481,
-0.0118592605,
-0.0237910766,
0.0351059213,
-0.0254476182,
0.0111141037,
0.0074247471,
0.0296237934,
0.0075805523,
0.0493018366,
-0.0659925565,
0.03778423,
0.0140860919,
0.0133390268,
0.0731808767,
-0.0051706494,
0.0408747271,
-0.025984833,
0.0411599316,
0.0101837199,
-0.0313197002,
-0.0292114969,
0.0183913726,
-0.0551853366,
-0.012324864,
0.0529842116,
-0.0152145904,
-0.0369059145,
0.0055364873,
0.0099560991,
-0.0099908076,
-0.0098358691,
0.039929606,
-0.0138035631,
-0.0130543299,
0.0272102952,
0.0258187,
-0.0463623069,
-0.0014329576,
0.0021880367,
-0.0755842328,
-0.0140076373,
0.0262948629,
0.0105616804,
-0.0464308001,
-0.00871363,
0.0268489122,
-0.0054987688,
-0.0347757041,
0.0441308245,
0.0097368909,
-0.0199982878,
0.0452488214,
0.0335710086,
0.0115845883,
-0.039323546,
-0.0339865535,
-0.0073394524,
0.0334348418,
0.0344175771,
0.0130547434,
-0.0461878069,
0.0301042814,
-0.0552701578,
0.0027848384,
0.0328637622,
0.039261166,
-0.0150054432,
0.0002602254,
-0.0217771232,
-0.0137800891,
-0.0167403594,
0.0137419617,
-0.0246801097,
-0.0373195857,
0.0488998517,
0.0144863632,
0.0110829296,
-0.0305837076,
0.0418603793,
-0.0246190708,
0.0246214569,
0.0312583558,
-0.0002448855,
0.0168806165,
-0.026953334,
-0.0100151952,
-0.0470909849,
-0.0256476365,
0.044863876,
0.003913776,
-0.023254497,
0.0101700304,
-0.0138083119,
0.01224095,
-0.0226647947,
0.0227194838,
-0.0162359532,
0.0621297657,
-0.0047667259,
0.0457275808,
0.0136709204,
0.0247931741,
-0.0327328816,
0.0839428157,
0.0065090572,
-0.0454750694,
-0.0780396163,
-0.0359154008,
0.0344320461,
-0.0172747541,
-0.0297107175,
0.0131246131,
0.0173948538,
0.0117557123,
-0.0196616519,
0.0002509001,
-0.0035322071,
-0.0051976843,
2.226e-7,
0.024138825,
0.0025205023,
0.0387866758,
0.03420702,
0.0084395949,
0.0198952034,
-0.0174153876,
0.020040296,
0.0354019366,
0.0145505508,
-0.0034887958,
0.0267962608,
0.0220159404,
-0.025263086,
-0.1057564542,
-0.0356936231,
-0.0388110057,
-0.0202447977,
-0.037933968,
0.0018198611,
0.0465781912,
0.0822704807,
0.0115025295,
-0.0016504007,
-0.0437348336,
-0.044950515,
0.0575702786,
-0.0279648434,
-0.0125990771,
0.0123703135,
0.0524997376,
-0.0124566164,
-0.0228106976,
0.0039801388,
0.0385591425,
0.0830770507,
0.0076581095,
0.0181062091,
0.0044674347,
-0.0647208616,
-0.0272468757,
-0.004253522,
0.0178375989,
-0.0457281098,
0.0400402434,
-0.0456868149,
-0.0312378258,
-0.0184182599,
0.0413461737,
-0.0259549078,
0.0118273236,
-0.0318107307,
-0.0077244658,
0.0042771734,
0.017038798,
-0.0032473963,
0.0335636437,
-0.0984368101,
0.0023520435,
-0.0260872766,
-0.0551164262,
-0.0399347022,
-0.0411768965,
-0.0092167892,
0.0150509896,
-0.0421495102,
-0.0071092532,
1.61031591e-34,
0.0258399472,
0.0029651811,
0.0214639772,
0.0683721602,
0.0271321218,
0.0226238966,
-0.0199796278,
0.0009656061,
0.0535661653,
-0.0995265692,
-0.0263743363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16787v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16787v2 | Evaluating Optimal Reference Translations | 2023-11-28T13:50:50 | 2024-03-08T12:21:12 | Vilém Zouhar, Věra Kloudová, Martin Popel, Ondřej Bojar | cs.CL | cs.CL | The overall translation quality reached by current machine translation (MT)
systems for high-resourced language pairs is remarkably good. Standard methods
of evaluation are not suitable nor intended to uncover the many translation
errors and quality deficiencies that still persist. Furthermore, the quality of
standard reference translations is commonly questioned and comparable quality
levels have been reached by MT alone in several language pairs. Navigating
further research in these high-resource settings is thus difficult. In this
article, we propose a methodology for creating more reliable document-level
human reference translations, called "optimal reference translations," with the
simple aim to raise the bar of what should be deemed "human translation
quality." We evaluate the obtained document-level optimal reference
translations in comparison with "standard" ones, confirming a significant
quality increase and also documenting the relationship between evaluation and
translation editing. | [
0.0680656955,
0.0216441788,
-0.001758597,
0.0231808629,
-0.0493372157,
0.006784033,
0.0207855105,
0.0270022191,
-0.0338613354,
-0.0270403773,
-0.0292327702,
-0.023771381,
0.0546524711,
-0.0515803248,
0.0194608215,
-0.0912235826,
0.0439251475,
0.0180631429,
0.0058583859,
0.0099278688,
0.0084711369,
0.0019306036,
0.0049712742,
0.0404591449,
-0.0081987726,
-0.0089466581,
0.0490566529,
0.0480603576,
0.0620197393,
-0.0125847049,
-0.0102551617,
0.0214599371,
-0.0247587617,
0.0333688706,
0.0000020982,
-0.0261988398,
-0.0125333117,
0.0397280864,
-0.00082794,
0.0246266592,
0.0734697804,
-0.0571275726,
-0.0370022804,
-0.0140913408,
-0.0136109916,
-0.0015679841,
0.0405183733,
0.0011690202,
0.089616105,
0.0356773175,
-0.0175612997,
-0.0346755721,
-0.0099724736,
-0.0316810757,
-0.0077764108,
-0.0669874325,
-0.03885144,
0.0318443142,
-0.0014551023,
0.0240434129,
0.0376493931,
0.0525652356,
-0.007347635,
-0.0292758662,
0.0119105112,
-0.0349998288,
-0.0558178723,
-0.02520537,
0.0389705747,
0.0718653277,
0.0033521196,
0.0247846264,
-0.0057736686,
0.008873051,
-0.0127344429,
0.0183038879,
-0.0093107438,
0.0069419411,
-0.0098734805,
-0.0205619447,
-0.0068796645,
0.0419114083,
0.0041440474,
0.0175798982,
-0.0049920576,
-0.0263514519,
0.0101840682,
-0.0140897017,
0.0296627674,
0.0177330803,
0.0057014795,
-0.0108163832,
0.0330531038,
-0.0172689985,
-0.0040437365,
0.0041225343,
-0.0436347947,
-0.0459503569,
0.0269622337,
-0.0835432038,
0.0337587371,
0.0324208252,
0.0003141702,
0.0336848982,
-0.0140776783,
0.057058394,
-0.0188915264,
-0.0275545176,
-0.0531803668,
-0.0041659363,
-0.0127470018,
0.0536799319,
-0.0679887235,
-0.0418274924,
-0.0568464994,
-0.0082055079,
-0.0546038449,
-0.0092211971,
0.0175981708,
0.0396799818,
-0.0054361955,
-0.0250967443,
-0.0731490627,
-0.0500090048,
-0.0254232325,
0.0229804944,
-0.025587244,
-0.0297521055,
-0.0432928093,
-0.0336309113,
0.0174020063,
0.0326447375,
-0.0261640381,
-0.0162127409,
-0.0343230292,
0.0629611164,
-0.0068432307,
-0.0013310568,
0.0193753056,
-0.0153426705,
-0.015417356,
-0.039805796,
-0.0188040398,
-0.0421221405,
0.0577912442,
0.0161230061,
0.0271028318,
-0.0385055691,
0.0176894832,
0.0084247533,
-0.0415312722,
0.0137331467,
-0.0279493853,
0.0220096577,
0.0109978952,
-0.005808149,
-0.0163816568,
0.0267415848,
0.0768053457,
0.044704508,
0.0407138057,
-0.0038603689,
0.0034395605,
0.038580887,
-0.0294419713,
0.0132952072,
0.0214354098,
0.014392023,
-0.0040509035,
0.0530065037,
0.0409681201,
0.0560318902,
-0.0368550196,
0.0551448725,
0.0601337776,
0.0133761754,
-0.0218846109,
0.0450989753,
0.0382516384,
0.0346819311,
0.0130749717,
-0.0207885504,
-0.0229265597,
0.0190769285,
0.056726478,
0.0101096695,
0.0322751813,
0.0049609691,
0.027787894,
-0.0577907041,
0.0036206909,
0.0005802065,
-0.0116157588,
-0.0346749686,
0.0104670413,
-0.0011950363,
-0.0430847444,
0.0482456796,
-0.0481612422,
-0.0151983537,
0.0009419334,
-0.0141220773,
-0.0344961286,
0.0712062791,
0.0569464527,
0.0158377979,
-0.0002450069,
-0.0104884859,
0.0249276944,
0.076491639,
0.0607826971,
0.0031355149,
0.0066751116,
-0.0442465171,
-0.0174742844,
0.0456581786,
0.0187923107,
0.0113564897,
-0.0280054398,
0.0527742095,
0.0552938022,
-0.049799636,
-0.1247017011,
0.0147987707,
0.0179135818,
-0.0291801486,
0.0151627129,
0.0117990719,
0.0196095388,
0.0289667509,
-0.0319656394,
0.0044055665,
-0.0186632238,
-0.0183391161,
0.0200879704,
0.0556073487,
-0.0012209658,
0.0413259864,
-0.0003498522,
-0.0912278593,
-0.024266446,
-0.016942529,
-0.035056226,
-0.0245618559,
-0.0466939136,
-0.0742319152,
-0.0172311645,
-0.0202946737,
0.0458168313,
-0.0129863089,
-0.0160354096,
-0.0252232831,
0.0153644122,
0.0266158283,
-0.0138344178,
0.0401228443,
-0.0568508394,
0.0708156601,
-0.0246302485,
-0.0198957268,
0.0383450836,
0.0111617958,
0.0300259739,
0.0512702689,
0.0335804224,
-0.0276005752,
-0.0237859245,
-0.0311317667,
-0.0107252682,
-0.0073149027,
0.0448604822,
0.0183624756,
0.0059722429,
0.0065173986,
-0.0011132057,
0.0232747942,
-0.0071902648,
-0.0129063884,
-0.0001709427,
0.0445517562,
0.0134134004,
0.0472115986,
-0.0431522988,
0.0243390091,
0.0428698882,
0.0019358635,
0.0822555646,
-0.0363426805,
-0.0880336463,
0.0176935047,
-0.0224185456,
-0.0518816598,
0.0383457318,
-0.0704023242,
0.0109365834,
0.0121938558,
0.0244094785,
0.0463525914,
-0.0021696871,
-0.0233312305,
0.0215364788,
0.0282573737,
-0.0423735976,
-0.0148829147,
0.0154082589,
-0.0627349764,
0.0001446636,
-0.0621353872,
0.038373258,
-0.0166315045,
-0.0021905121,
0.005339371,
-0.0558733344,
0.0066848323,
-0.0478693582,
-0.0289411526,
-0.0052199694,
0.0038345926,
0.0018951759,
0.0701150969,
-0.0064744581,
-0.0192921218,
0.0450369939,
0.0050878702,
-0.0065082498,
-0.0578989834,
0.0301963966,
-0.0169630051,
0.006407625,
-0.0510763936,
0.00529852,
-0.0423031598,
-0.0062823966,
-0.0396183096,
0.0148294521,
0.0671555251,
-0.0150340861,
-0.004759707,
-0.0509842895,
-0.0070612691,
-0.0346280746,
-0.0085735973,
-0.0207142085,
-0.0082122851,
-0.0294932891,
-0.0054950207,
0.0166462753,
-0.0101594832,
-0.045123376,
0.0332309082,
0.0419058725,
0.0281735789,
0.003251283,
-0.0167421661,
-0.0225393213,
-0.0117622754,
-0.0090868538,
0.0043228646,
0.0222456492,
-0.0138001321,
-0.0066181896,
0.0282752328,
0.0034508114,
0.0114508523,
0.0024784326,
-0.0453245118,
0.0284338444,
-0.0106789013,
-0.0593043864,
-0.0078536924,
0.0360257961,
-0.0716748983,
-0.0054156776,
0.0945821702,
0.0065246741,
-0.0664168447,
-0.0266191568,
-0.0503862649,
-0.0276162811,
-0.0291587915,
0.0490479544,
-0.067392081,
0.0062700533,
0.0087960837,
0.0503304787,
0.0370751396,
0.0067427726,
0.0050960365,
-0.069058992,
0.0181793831,
0.0693849698,
-0.0237056334,
-0.0610755496,
-0.0115380026,
-0.0150528075,
-0.0381156281,
0.0137247732,
0.0008532761,
0.0141380038,
0.0212373696,
-0.0113522056,
0.0032615375,
-0.0403298065,
-0.0083413431,
-0.0646791011,
0.0037361193,
0.0813354403,
0.0866496935,
0.0161026269,
-0.0174985938,
0.0197903924,
-0.0409101434,
-0.0030845215,
0.0240436252,
0.0315399058,
-0.0071010482,
0.003923873,
0.0047486145,
-0.018179683,
-0.0018042742,
0.0039836783,
0.0370937511,
0.0392411314,
-0.0141475499,
-0.0086339014,
0.0017962095,
0.0112247523,
0.0353063047,
0.0413139984,
0.0229476001,
-0.0436267741,
-0.0018100516,
-0.0137865748,
0.0481287614,
-0.0788908377,
-0.0010794098,
0.0172539614,
-0.1112279668,
-0.0431848839,
-0.1151018441,
-0.0761735588,
-0.0171745364,
0.0445027128,
0.0275592376,
-0.0028269226,
0.0137666194,
0.0250937007,
0.0409729294,
0.0065223444,
-0.0206991062,
0.0167304538,
-0.0552918576,
-0.0056935507,
-0.006968318,
0.0073528327,
0.0055559203,
0.0272128098,
0.0351554491,
-0.0322720259,
-0.0082426574,
0.0550413579,
0.0274161752,
-0.0105724353,
-0.0303641465,
-0.0465089157,
-0.0299212933,
0.0076240222,
-0.0007033901,
-0.0094097136,
0.0288428292,
0.0066804909,
-0.0272009112,
0.0357159004,
-0.0338294804,
-0.0048078597,
-0.0369144268,
0.0342847146,
-0.0241306536,
-0.0857950598,
0.0082451096,
0.0416874141,
-0.0048127449,
-0.0491821058,
-0.0172143094,
0.0114340754,
0.0118840784,
-0.0163521357,
-0.0367308818,
-0.0249662809,
-0.0038137303,
0.0234344173,
0.0178474169,
-0.0121789873,
0.0053626606,
-0.0565583445,
-0.0224254709,
0.0225463491,
0.006407409,
-0.0002887274,
0.0751776621,
-0.0073481998,
0.0262228549,
-0.0302270725,
0.0148126874,
-0.0231035352,
0.0269262809,
-0.0353841446,
0.0123899411,
0.0179237351,
-0.0063868253,
0.0287479386,
0.0333338156,
-0.0116887605,
-0.0101779588,
-0.0310536493,
-0.0197532605,
0.0754183009,
0.0099485889,
0.1264120936,
-0.0320787765,
-0.0181596279,
0.0016082448,
0.0687778145,
0.0297111683,
0.0093685873,
-0.0723876059,
-0.0061784121,
0.0112259733,
0.0073977462,
0.0334370807,
-0.0149176409,
-0.0129190776,
-0.0572624169,
-0.0262822919,
-0.0245704371,
0.0148248402,
-0.0662192777,
-0.0455489345,
0.0086320629,
-0.0355675928,
-0.0704724118,
-0.044917535,
0.0376033559,
0.0345560163,
0.0169730503,
-0.0190415159,
-0.0055423784,
0.0565294623,
-0.0076156622,
0.0132258302,
-0.0556278117,
0.0218552407,
-0.0234304164,
0.0002322837,
-0.0599539839,
-5.581996923e-33,
-0.0157474373,
-0.0422238223,
-0.0219201352,
-0.0395102315,
-0.0323054604,
-0.0123530291,
-0.0579188354,
-0.0200228412,
0.0037931711,
0.0317381285,
-0.0321555361,
-0.035074804,
0.0400385298,
-0.0395751409,
0.0182886422,
0.0381006524,
0.0469007194,
0.0155677209,
-0.0552195087,
0.0142760593,
0.0353444815,
-0.0072547277,
0.089628458,
-0.1043129638,
0.0844034851,
-0.0240232442,
-0.0336506739,
0.0031633519,
0.0574003607,
0.0236265678,
0.0194225144,
0.0100305257,
0.0090969196,
-0.0096656904,
-0.0126028843,
-0.0323188677,
-0.0989212394,
0.005610636,
0.013359854,
0.0363786146,
0.0036262479,
-0.0517137535,
0.0332691893,
-0.0443319455,
-0.0442521796,
-0.001363367,
0.0440194346,
-0.0763553977,
-0.0407711603,
-0.0173477456,
-0.0701951608,
0.0220369101,
-0.009906197,
0.0446116477,
0.0287963543,
0.077511549,
-0.0582312159,
-0.0396653861,
-0.0607363097,
0.0229865126,
-0.032114584,
-0.0027123669,
0.0452327617,
-0.0525809452,
-0.0196087658,
-0.0324240401,
0.0322826579,
0.0139773665,
0.0376984701,
-0.0208613966,
0.0135063445,
-0.0057377196,
0.0595441163,
0.117713429,
0.0332088731,
-0.0327808186,
-0.0122267054,
0.0744517371,
-0.004744519,
0.0649458393,
-0.0158764273,
0.0130089913,
-0.0419908538,
-0.0013894173,
-0.0628490821,
-0.0430643409,
0.0007923602,
-0.0517531708,
0.0066888686,
-0.0104675842,
-0.026362529,
0.0087962747,
0.0539686009,
-0.0082938131,
0.0278656464,
-0.0044022193,
-0.0251421276,
0.0136821903,
-0.0007113896,
-0.0032176406,
-0.009407402,
-0.0191725995,
0.0048919087,
0.0454612449,
0.039311152,
-0.0474759303,
0.0318427607,
-0.0141469361,
-0.0270914752,
0.031169489,
-0.0040153898,
-0.0312063266,
0.0030635346,
-0.02552028,
-0.0002275459,
-0.016538009,
-0.001816183,
0.0179293863,
0.0191781893,
0.0183070395,
0.0020493492,
0.0052266996,
0.0457674861,
0.0171027351,
-0.0454495363,
0.0407413803,
-0.0074997516,
0.0387353227,
0.0271558408,
-0.0113680596,
-0.0452019498,
-0.0297701396,
2.705e-7,
0.0668191239,
0.0598017648,
0.0275710188,
0.0134405922,
-0.0140770581,
0.0050682384,
0.0021993655,
0.0169973057,
-0.0224797875,
0.0603389479,
0.0624846108,
-0.0197668802,
0.0974168405,
0.0253079571,
-0.0617093407,
-0.0872959867,
-0.0478473157,
0.0134041198,
-0.0322292522,
0.0129420729,
0.0154209854,
0.0157793015,
-0.004978002,
0.0001113652,
-0.0351629034,
-0.0554545,
0.056838166,
-0.0447057597,
-0.0012267288,
0.0100265592,
0.0683891028,
0.0374265015,
-0.0367507637,
-0.0166188981,
-0.0224104021,
-0.0196747947,
0.1014437973,
0.0953286588,
0.0032427586,
0.0201694183,
-0.0055572437,
-0.0286534037,
0.0255971644,
-0.0134025831,
0.0183561128,
-0.0208528396,
-0.0035880532,
0.0338187702,
-0.0677319542,
0.0236779395,
0.013255612,
-0.0283252951,
-0.0321653113,
0.0361109003,
0.0399024598,
0.0189914275,
-0.028116174,
-0.007099716,
-0.0009950608,
0.0135492915,
0.031565927,
-0.0472283699,
0.0217174646,
0.0014119525,
0.0178814605,
-0.0092904801,
0.0127988877,
1.931154007e-34,
0.0481204912,
-0.0435607284,
0.0309985988,
-0.025303781,
0.0562388897,
0.012452974,
-0.032745637,
-0.0039282748,
0.0190638211,
-0.0164184291,
-0.0183415618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03737v1 | A Generic NLI approach for Classification of Sentiment Associated with Therapies | 2023-11-28T13:27:21 | 2023-11-28T13:27:21 | Rajaraman Kanagasabai, Anitha Veeramani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper describes our system for addressing SMM4H 2023 Shared Task 2 on
"Classification of sentiment associated with therapies (aspect-oriented)". In
our work, we adopt an approach based on Natural language inference (NLI) to
formulate this task as a sentence pair classification problem, and train
transformer models to predict sentiment associated with a therapy on a given
text. Our best model achieved 75.22\% F1-score which was 11\% (4\%) more than
the mean (median) score of all teams' submissions. | [
0.0403153487,
0.0488873944,
0.0059783198,
0.0104114469,
-0.0339392126,
0.0169729292,
-0.0029239717,
0.0038201774,
0.0089191608,
-0.0337836966,
-0.0423441455,
0.0302231852,
-0.0133974263,
0.0181888752,
-0.0168351401,
-0.06048318,
0.0027775527,
0.0514457747,
-0.001232484,
0.0082578901,
-0.008573778,
0.0477476455,
-0.0214518346,
0.0008340582,
0.0249967445,
-0.0056277858,
0.0732180476,
0.0031302925,
0.0454260446,
-0.0617246516,
-0.0005992281,
0.0250508171,
-0.0342758223,
-0.0481464751,
0.0000018761,
-0.0558979735,
-0.0380985215,
0.0102101965,
0.0330853239,
-0.0593028516,
0.0784915984,
-0.0702666938,
0.0335199609,
0.0583789088,
-0.0161622986,
-0.0359191224,
0.0352184623,
0.109896712,
0.0432448871,
0.0913879648,
-0.0299706608,
-0.0286767315,
0.0118816374,
-0.0066063013,
-0.0062972829,
0.0122904023,
0.0006081301,
-0.0166480001,
-0.0082119405,
0.0326632746,
0.0263867993,
0.0207960885,
-0.0233704038,
0.0406092443,
0.0116785159,
0.0197639279,
0.0036055648,
0.0148543473,
0.0049787662,
0.0090365708,
0.0463798419,
0.011819114,
0.0051289438,
-0.0190345626,
-0.0037452127,
0.0473829806,
0.0214929879,
0.0104973912,
-0.0421880186,
0.0381158218,
0.0344427265,
0.0359326228,
0.0065660314,
0.006089095,
0.0097860973,
0.0146437576,
0.0034775464,
-0.004835315,
0.0361547098,
0.024151016,
-0.0058097956,
-0.0227198023,
0.0071431412,
-0.0079190629,
0.0004430998,
0.0093077086,
0.0093928818,
0.0082803741,
0.0098835435,
-0.0645938814,
-0.0147306947,
0.0103747798,
0.0019430327,
0.0061313799,
-0.0002263872,
-0.0253854599,
0.02249787,
-0.0350173451,
-0.0279729944,
0.0214092582,
-0.0601456054,
0.0327291973,
0.000552415,
0.0486080572,
-0.0282140952,
-0.0062651439,
-0.0838479996,
-0.0162871182,
0.0013471568,
-0.0356116593,
0.064534992,
-0.0159680136,
0.0186141692,
0.0031906739,
-0.0204047132,
0.0738034546,
-0.0200839788,
0.0172319245,
-0.0681940764,
-0.0057184366,
0.0310476311,
0.0248539969,
-0.006988368,
-0.0447271913,
0.0197263788,
0.033934325,
0.0458659008,
-0.0604090765,
-0.0346172415,
0.0041093775,
-0.0491838157,
-0.016787177,
0.0114289904,
-0.0729324967,
-0.004973833,
0.0050660428,
0.0342774056,
-0.0259550717,
0.0139040425,
-0.0030619053,
-0.0580593608,
0.065472953,
-0.0077085993,
-0.0207085609,
-0.0023520293,
0.008463908,
0.0544373766,
-0.0024041408,
-0.0051720366,
0.0036290411,
0.014094688,
-0.0057392912,
0.0133660315,
-0.0241449401,
-0.0000085443,
-0.0483465418,
0.0220727921,
0.0011853022,
-0.0206856485,
0.0128402105,
-0.0840548128,
0.060023699,
0.0079107359,
-0.0021857133,
0.0196786113,
0.0095911287,
0.0259592924,
0.0498879105,
-0.0141190421,
-0.0106096109,
-0.0391337276,
-0.0236409735,
-0.0129854549,
0.0152225401,
-0.0180769302,
-0.0037769971,
0.0103964573,
-0.0033586621,
-0.021669833,
-0.0849833637,
-0.0420773029,
-0.0540244319,
-0.0138693256,
-0.0149008948,
0.0524461418,
0.004682051,
-0.0553435124,
0.0136605147,
0.0586058684,
-0.0289266631,
-0.0207487196,
-0.040644113,
-0.0137243466,
0.0437034704,
0.0109625096,
-0.0312270392,
-0.0365767181,
-0.0237405691,
-0.0701196045,
0.0265446566,
0.0075795017,
0.0010901389,
-0.0152315032,
-0.0075146882,
0.0252939817,
0.0023336839,
0.0151038934,
-0.0424778797,
-0.014975097,
0.0529421344,
-0.0229412392,
-0.0191240422,
0.0146982102,
0.0466254242,
-0.0079267304,
-0.0370751582,
0.0231771991,
0.006541139,
0.0304489713,
0.044332251,
-0.0015630687,
0.0028840159,
0.0091436794,
-0.0442817174,
-0.0766659006,
0.0358216912,
-0.0121210199,
-0.0692771152,
-0.0248479303,
-0.0304877684,
0.0261341948,
-0.0029873846,
-0.0346637033,
0.0054835929,
0.0153103769,
-0.0142716812,
-0.0013883768,
-0.0091019301,
0.0030896668,
0.0294072907,
-0.0042437022,
-0.0469843931,
0.0311691947,
-0.0092437407,
0.0144493505,
-0.0241974685,
-0.0719347671,
0.0132852811,
0.0405012667,
-0.0282116234,
0.0037159838,
-0.0181150939,
-0.0277097523,
0.0355108343,
-0.0057048504,
0.0019978476,
-0.0466991253,
-0.1084213927,
0.0175928622,
0.0101565607,
0.0294581968,
0.0031150393,
0.0162667483,
0.0128696449,
0.0173439812,
-0.0423768051,
-0.0294875894,
0.0226018056,
-0.0080597792,
0.0255877804,
0.0246742051,
0.0380239077,
-0.0347674377,
0.0105222836,
-0.044828862,
0.0188932996,
0.0205141995,
-0.0453319252,
-0.0622568466,
0.067188777,
-0.0242681652,
0.0045827641,
0.0039039501,
-0.0192518029,
-0.0022210078,
0.0130445389,
0.019321695,
0.0218975786,
0.0157150887,
0.0123219723,
0.0215357766,
0.0629771426,
-0.0120337019,
0.0142937982,
-0.0583429933,
-0.0318194553,
-0.0264558494,
-0.068927221,
0.0396980084,
0.0917788967,
0.0330047347,
0.0007071175,
-0.0319852717,
-0.0035024346,
-0.00947983,
0.0620831549,
0.0288153868,
0.0207052324,
0.0193498507,
-0.007906327,
0.0299625639,
-0.0187445376,
0.1120446026,
0.0093723889,
0.0230483729,
-0.1451002359,
-0.0210794229,
-0.0407192782,
0.0341004655,
-0.0006522631,
0.006659525,
0.0648101196,
0.0367696919,
-0.0072481618,
-0.0562235229,
-0.0037685484,
0.0126520125,
0.0610807277,
-0.0322947428,
0.0142368935,
0.002035876,
-0.0323606767,
-0.0145032769,
-0.0391492248,
-0.0433001816,
-0.0309890434,
0.0101651307,
-0.0154918591,
-0.0042735888,
-0.011729192,
-0.0323647261,
-0.0008287281,
-0.0167184509,
-0.0285774935,
0.0358738936,
0.0279944856,
0.0755669996,
-0.0626688972,
0.0046561509,
0.0053315908,
0.0113172457,
0.0771776661,
-0.0371809043,
0.0438764803,
-0.0064445822,
-0.0529044122,
0.0308049135,
-0.0394315086,
-0.0123891523,
0.0008453232,
0.0574012659,
-0.0078964876,
-0.0482425317,
0.1300756484,
0.0440275148,
-0.0485585593,
0.0081466604,
0.0125921918,
-0.0538945682,
-0.0058076871,
0.0097344518,
-0.0577490851,
-0.0440739132,
-0.0632769763,
0.0319708437,
-0.019731978,
0.0180086829,
0.0131589416,
-0.0656284243,
0.0061673485,
-0.0307726674,
-0.024022758,
-0.0551891811,
-0.0580790378,
0.0025970822,
-0.0171883646,
-0.0351373814,
-0.0637639388,
-0.0200881809,
0.024107879,
0.0009559614,
-0.0444232821,
-0.0240707081,
0.027627375,
-0.0196545031,
0.0394876264,
0.0405740887,
0.0335957296,
-0.0118236672,
-0.0175420772,
0.000665606,
-0.0226021018,
0.0172636025,
-0.0271196961,
0.1092399508,
-0.0323524587,
0.0191439111,
-0.0425680988,
0.0403601937,
-0.0722681209,
-0.0118473712,
-0.0155939236,
0.0747785047,
-0.0368067995,
-0.0506715216,
-0.0151226334,
0.0538380817,
0.0183055215,
0.066460155,
-0.0283916965,
-0.0056268563,
-0.0007323975,
0.0122541133,
0.0441910028,
0.0147264116,
-0.054538127,
-0.0370125473,
-0.035749279,
-0.0220209267,
-0.0870519429,
-0.0480698384,
0.0266957916,
-0.0121324016,
-0.0297872946,
-0.0053482312,
0.0108847246,
0.0013649883,
-0.0377533659,
0.0303127076,
0.05476515,
0.0195752401,
0.0038022324,
-0.0408000909,
0.1067666411,
0.0168993417,
-0.0183375403,
-0.0073618214,
-0.0080987187,
0.0016416175,
-0.0378027484,
0.0525699742,
0.0166034624,
-0.0021108538,
0.0182316676,
0.0471835546,
-0.0043671154,
0.0581367351,
-0.0013561735,
-0.0411564372,
0.019273553,
0.062161427,
0.0202668495,
0.0317275859,
-0.0079904357,
0.0572229959,
0.0285752118,
-0.0093546435,
-0.0122394916,
-0.0586092286,
0.0146392277,
-0.0105062751,
0.0806700289,
0.0047766999,
-0.0288904738,
-0.0088230809,
-0.0028259135,
-0.0225953087,
-0.005858114,
-0.0225857273,
-0.0272450689,
0.0004073141,
0.0480226055,
-0.0664753094,
0.0386205204,
-0.0796986744,
0.0078538842,
-0.046158541,
0.0454527549,
0.0660172403,
0.0017377016,
-0.0266075823,
0.0057946113,
-0.0262060855,
-0.044941891,
0.0445900187,
0.0257786959,
-0.0267160721,
0.0767552108,
0.0225919746,
0.0433173664,
-0.0221093204,
0.030600803,
-0.0155637646,
-0.0089070471,
-0.0254439991,
-0.0037460527,
0.0003241902,
-0.0378316268,
0.0589623451,
-0.0366901867,
0.0266929194,
0.0002172417,
0.0607324317,
-0.0340522081,
0.0296821501,
0.0509257317,
-0.0067008305,
-0.0083248904,
-0.0477500819,
0.0289539471,
-0.0944567248,
0.0276157297,
0.0329681486,
-0.0304021277,
-0.0408353098,
-0.0262258817,
-0.0176876429,
-0.0446529798,
-0.0215069558,
0.0466981679,
-0.0486145578,
-0.0313503183,
0.0350574441,
-0.0434198044,
0.021491006,
-0.0357989483,
0.0254051704,
0.0526853316,
0.0353227444,
-0.0043509724,
-0.0465779081,
0.0186876003,
-0.0141797978,
-0.0219620988,
-0.0500053167,
-5.632663301e-33,
0.0034709182,
0.0224113837,
-0.0229516942,
0.0245870706,
-0.0109393224,
-0.0037308149,
-0.0119452653,
0.007793034,
-0.0166462362,
0.040868789,
0.0166504178,
0.0507885292,
-0.0165958293,
0.0377133749,
0.0001093005,
-0.0155960592,
0.03537523,
-0.0053609582,
-0.0183602422,
0.0118603492,
-0.0173544642,
0.0385974012,
0.086288698,
-0.1080318615,
0.0465825647,
0.0190932527,
0.0018451384,
0.0107401619,
0.0323417485,
0.0271362662,
-0.0131746018,
0.0674491152,
0.0606120788,
-0.0506374873,
0.0505442768,
-0.0150461346,
-0.0210080836,
-0.0459089987,
-0.0123646613,
-0.0251184497,
-0.0247925147,
-0.0074912701,
0.0393298827,
-0.0084431674,
-0.0271647926,
-0.0470196716,
0.0590633117,
-0.0428702682,
0.053435646,
-0.0741218403,
-0.0652648583,
0.0244205911,
0.0117421839,
-0.0248508062,
-0.0238933899,
0.0329986513,
-0.0070563997,
0.0471494757,
-0.0138317384,
0.0053355251,
-0.0067490949,
0.0355831161,
-0.0356295481,
-0.0496226251,
-0.0267871562,
0.0426230207,
-0.0093829883,
0.0101909246,
-0.0338162556,
0.01968107,
-0.0336670801,
-0.0055566747,
0.0404524542,
0.0122583965,
-0.0084264427,
0.0167213548,
-0.0650800541,
0.0352176242,
0.043328803,
0.0196856596,
0.0222449731,
-0.0205368157,
-0.0365830287,
-0.0479947254,
-0.0111557366,
-0.0474486463,
-0.0145666031,
-0.0241706613,
-0.019507071,
-0.0056280848,
-0.0069030216,
0.0252743214,
-0.010702258,
-0.0389611013,
-0.0158016905,
0.0217715111,
0.0140877031,
0.0460341908,
-0.0184928365,
-0.0053538266,
-0.0509521887,
0.0272470936,
-0.0210386217,
0.0287821684,
0.0483415946,
0.0045926571,
0.0347904675,
-0.0270254165,
-0.0908054709,
-0.0336918198,
-0.0109459851,
0.0023856047,
-0.0132898558,
0.0600451715,
-0.0308691151,
0.0570918806,
0.0106650991,
0.1048476771,
0.0189818647,
0.0287514031,
-0.0589783639,
0.0004408097,
0.0217147358,
0.0093574235,
-0.0329384878,
-0.0222046673,
0.0049353437,
0.0223147683,
-0.0190388467,
-0.0557161458,
-0.0224823561,
-0.0255359188,
2.704e-7,
0.0922185257,
0.0463045388,
-0.0310914591,
-0.0118311625,
0.0118936673,
0.0479093716,
-0.0009152081,
0.0108387442,
0.0380271785,
-0.0006641896,
0.0403541364,
0.0046207584,
-0.0032579948,
0.0055070901,
-0.0519532822,
0.0129208211,
-0.0108338678,
-0.0305247586,
-0.0027262587,
0.0089801298,
0.0997284353,
0.0850660279,
0.0087644206,
0.0168657079,
-0.0032508664,
0.0373539329,
0.0429244041,
-0.061367631,
-0.0164850932,
0.0563398153,
-0.02606689,
-0.0267063547,
-0.0038865877,
-0.0052292896,
-0.0180032793,
-0.0192213394,
-0.009879889,
0.0517695993,
-0.0287625454,
-0.0362914838,
0.0194211993,
0.0372426473,
0.0059349178,
0.014909164,
0.0360477604,
-0.0999092981,
-0.0689671189,
-0.0496204384,
-0.0304168314,
0.0234818608,
0.0598622262,
0.0185866561,
-0.0580745041,
0.0568161346,
0.0227579679,
0.0020698083,
-0.0106383916,
-0.0570634864,
0.0013658979,
0.0502580293,
-0.0214634612,
-0.0085335793,
0.0277066305,
-0.0108155534,
0.0058505628,
-0.039885629,
0.0225723684,
2.042995177e-34,
0.0357696898,
0.0228829887,
0.0118029714,
0.0095124133,
0.0226563979,
-0.0014510762,
-0.0369247198,
-0.0033194653,
0.0217429195,
-0.0469939187,
-0.0051040421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03736v1 | De-identification of clinical free text using natural language processing: A systematic review of current approaches | 2023-11-28T13:20:41 | 2023-11-28T13:20:41 | Aleksandar Kovačević, Bojana Bašaragin, Nikola Milošević, Goran Nenadić | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.DL, cs.LG | Background: Electronic health records (EHRs) are a valuable resource for
data-driven medical research. However, the presence of protected health
information (PHI) makes EHRs unsuitable to be shared for research purposes.
De-identification, i.e. the process of removing PHI is a critical step in
making EHR data accessible. Natural language processing has repeatedly
demonstrated its feasibility in automating the de-identification process.
Objectives: Our study aims to provide systematic evidence on how the
de-identification of clinical free text has evolved in the last thirteen years,
and to report on the performances and limitations of the current
state-of-the-art systems. In addition, we aim to identify challenges and
potential research opportunities in this field. Methods: A systematic search in
PubMed, Web of Science and the DBLP was conducted for studies published between
January 2010 and February 2023. Titles and abstracts were examined to identify
the relevant studies. Selected studies were then analysed in-depth, and
information was collected on de-identification methodologies, data sources, and
measured performance. Results: A total of 2125 publications were identified for
the title and abstract screening. 69 studies were found to be relevant. Machine
learning (37 studies) and hybrid (26 studies) approaches are predominant, while
six studies relied only on rules. Majority of the approaches were trained and
evaluated on public corpora. The 2014 i2b2/UTHealth corpus is the most
frequently used (36 studies), followed by the 2006 i2b2 (18 studies) and 2016
CEGS N-GRID (10 studies) corpora. | [
0.0511218458,
0.0547373258,
-0.0002013068,
-0.0204727333,
-0.0586997606,
0.0404933244,
0.0134307444,
0.0198342353,
0.0405210406,
-0.0300550982,
0.0319463797,
0.0079797544,
0.0275134295,
0.0463248193,
-0.021550715,
-0.0117549449,
0.0217687283,
0.054520905,
0.0572860315,
0.038278304,
-0.002584972,
0.0123621253,
0.0078048157,
0.0472312793,
0.0518667251,
0.0037643665,
0.0495202765,
-0.0115241604,
0.038510941,
-0.0848478377,
-0.0024529134,
0.0101405187,
-0.0393016189,
0.0514337048,
0.0000017544,
-0.0661324933,
-0.076696597,
0.0516262874,
-0.0485443957,
-0.0445858948,
0.059495151,
-0.0494031683,
-0.0252037421,
0.0017550221,
-0.0113581885,
-0.0471530855,
0.0455463044,
0.028336443,
0.0229330137,
0.0841777101,
-0.0468512028,
0.0091164643,
0.0022260179,
0.0262509193,
-0.0001015123,
-0.0120824426,
0.0619013049,
-0.0460431054,
0.0311387759,
-0.0164009463,
0.0503589958,
0.0524068624,
-0.0603978895,
0.0233049877,
-0.039609056,
0.0215508305,
-0.0601714998,
-0.0043102871,
0.0031651722,
0.0436229669,
-0.0069375271,
-0.0408646949,
0.0813932493,
-0.0149797518,
-0.0139477598,
0.0173579827,
0.0142664118,
0.0253611356,
-0.0572711937,
-0.0026403368,
-0.0042530638,
0.0053923498,
0.0229042489,
-0.0265345257,
-0.0276302788,
-0.0033470085,
0.0108760325,
-0.0424312465,
0.051591251,
-0.0512152016,
-0.0013951604,
-0.0420464538,
0.0683307946,
-0.0069485437,
0.0438225381,
0.0200592466,
-0.0338962451,
-0.0741329864,
0.0557592809,
-0.0521886051,
0.0006350428,
-0.0179654453,
0.0235226043,
0.0244495142,
-0.0072272504,
-0.0224191025,
-0.0132285515,
0.0185456276,
0.0036178082,
0.044042252,
-0.0274779722,
-0.0165480636,
-0.0143643208,
0.0313555002,
0.0070240889,
0.0166935753,
-0.0520179868,
-0.0232190955,
-0.011145886,
0.0206154529,
-0.0315484032,
0.0127134956,
-0.0309633501,
0.0129949739,
0.008849578,
-0.0049596149,
0.0354533643,
0.0065716747,
-0.0545622334,
-0.0454652198,
0.0466846377,
0.0309555251,
0.0791943967,
-0.0018318746,
0.0410767607,
0.0375115052,
0.027351303,
-0.0591506064,
-0.0254790671,
-0.0558648258,
-0.0311131775,
0.0257198289,
0.0074137603,
-0.0320032761,
-0.0001607842,
-0.0144249666,
-0.0231654495,
-0.0800363496,
-0.0083630355,
0.0454850942,
-0.0908543691,
0.0589197651,
-0.0920331106,
-0.0382279791,
0.0448852181,
0.0130509539,
0.0316515416,
-0.0501933098,
0.0146021172,
-0.0124320863,
0.0277247634,
-0.004181216,
0.0477529988,
0.0352234468,
-0.0035205886,
-0.0854374245,
0.0172570478,
-0.0088578491,
0.0149283474,
0.0054248855,
-0.0488404669,
0.0748671219,
0.0058174361,
-0.0266667474,
0.0055165403,
0.0980310291,
0.0061279587,
0.0033234681,
-0.0313127935,
0.0215191375,
0.0294740926,
-0.0193847511,
-0.0026861536,
-0.0694632977,
0.0065353401,
-0.0102866031,
-0.0428814441,
-0.0270422511,
0.0136034265,
-0.0125384647,
-0.0354205146,
-0.0367385149,
0.016832266,
-0.0431334265,
0.0344407149,
0.0158354919,
-0.0351290219,
0.0182392858,
0.0279736631,
-0.0318004452,
-0.0125496034,
-0.0348768793,
-0.0088920575,
0.0366783328,
0.0643783435,
-0.0523983762,
-0.0062627867,
-0.0399008095,
-0.0373034105,
0.0126282172,
-0.0727961585,
-0.0109864399,
0.0183286276,
-0.0483530574,
-0.0263091046,
0.04348832,
0.0058446466,
-0.0185791329,
-0.0130444774,
0.0217179675,
-0.0017021112,
-0.0121069569,
-0.0498305075,
0.0483568609,
-0.0348034315,
-0.0525518619,
0.0098253898,
-0.0052243038,
0.0309993401,
0.0324855819,
0.0032361345,
0.0376050174,
0.0236132089,
-0.0214973688,
-0.0175313,
0.0120669091,
0.022960376,
0.0197782367,
0.0040006395,
-0.0637685582,
0.0055143507,
0.00720349,
-0.0051774168,
0.0113587007,
-0.0298949592,
-0.0244707707,
0.0104566906,
-0.0134328082,
0.0351587124,
0.0165189449,
0.0106555782,
-0.0492678918,
0.0206545498,
-0.0182094313,
0.0136270504,
0.0040107057,
-0.097124435,
0.0385435857,
-0.0069329939,
0.0032795775,
-0.0046522459,
-0.0366241075,
0.0096240314,
0.0042153085,
-0.0025376615,
-0.0117876455,
-0.0080430349,
-0.0439725593,
-0.0002989094,
0.0216482077,
0.048049368,
0.0207126513,
0.0174345095,
-0.0170822404,
-0.0424594097,
0.006020478,
-0.0637394041,
0.0399824046,
-0.0092840707,
0.0521897338,
0.0255670901,
-0.0020500878,
-0.0178811364,
-0.0029151079,
-0.0334154516,
0.0267431382,
0.0099186655,
-0.0626506731,
-0.0057877935,
0.0101069184,
0.0006254963,
0.0168037936,
-0.0108503997,
0.0172841586,
-0.0059872027,
0.0253885426,
-0.0156266112,
0.0244858488,
-0.0247466918,
0.0027449613,
0.0211938582,
0.0069241468,
-0.0032494343,
-0.0120146275,
-0.0362470634,
0.0366900228,
0.0175916273,
-0.0679155588,
0.0881248116,
0.0145767918,
0.0301640555,
0.0007658435,
0.0071225944,
0.0042794202,
-0.0162843671,
0.0110765398,
-0.045346342,
-0.0236632805,
-0.0440436266,
0.0116989883,
0.0007616187,
-0.0213310327,
0.0702155083,
-0.0113565857,
0.0623200461,
-0.0992625505,
-0.0006785361,
-0.0081901895,
-0.03579849,
0.0010313725,
0.0140469978,
0.0929653645,
-0.0594206229,
0.0537841171,
0.0119838519,
0.0282179024,
-0.0432908274,
0.0167212095,
-0.0114078969,
0.0211518127,
0.0012149662,
0.0079653049,
-0.0082788216,
-0.047339078,
0.00540523,
-0.0008370155,
0.0298087411,
0.0099412175,
-0.0465966091,
0.0282879341,
-0.0089839995,
0.0647735372,
0.0399361104,
0.0038385671,
-0.0111347912,
0.0606140271,
-0.0037271567,
-0.0632035956,
0.0086050322,
0.0312740915,
-0.0223271716,
0.0747767016,
0.0147131644,
0.0593505912,
0.0138265602,
-0.0067607849,
-0.0384640321,
-0.0933079273,
-0.0055785505,
0.0282562301,
-0.0084846104,
-0.0218372364,
0.0125989961,
0.0741345137,
0.045783639,
-0.0719274208,
-0.0038112828,
0.0071701203,
-0.0833954662,
-0.0498301312,
-0.0267105605,
-0.0470653549,
-0.007079158,
0.0274287332,
0.0303408261,
-0.048065789,
-0.0605299138,
0.0284043774,
-0.0199880414,
-0.0023418432,
0.0005158383,
-0.0175965764,
-0.0321937874,
-0.0424130969,
0.0286717489,
0.001225706,
-0.0314641371,
-0.0395148285,
-0.019077871,
-0.0041367174,
-0.0001348498,
-0.0944653004,
-0.0947092474,
-0.0308136959,
-0.0512952134,
0.0253852047,
0.0442148112,
0.0463857986,
-0.0390514806,
0.0000221604,
-0.0245513916,
-0.022674581,
-0.0321387947,
-0.0269773155,
0.1075829864,
0.0350991488,
0.0049360981,
-0.0613366738,
0.0454210192,
0.0035646199,
-0.0351423584,
-0.0042294972,
0.0419027954,
-0.0480946004,
-0.023026824,
-0.0374076627,
-0.0056536114,
0.0178507734,
0.035070058,
-0.023157306,
0.0144408401,
-0.0090684295,
0.0037464346,
0.0714737922,
0.0080114156,
-0.0081540104,
0.0330676362,
-0.0499570929,
-0.0543462671,
-0.053484235,
0.0057806009,
-0.0075228661,
0.0053497353,
0.0433381945,
0.0500219315,
0.0505290702,
0.0094500603,
-0.0769707486,
0.0239744969,
0.0063486053,
0.000461889,
-0.0388821848,
-0.0159846023,
0.0010135599,
0.0467589051,
-0.0236097574,
0.0324786454,
0.0173592027,
-0.0248534922,
0.0263913497,
-0.0179279447,
0.0200452413,
-0.0123124439,
0.0211410988,
-0.0249355808,
0.0563328378,
0.0365128741,
-0.0060344283,
-0.0621765032,
-0.0255291779,
-0.0094885528,
-0.0461718887,
-0.0229248293,
0.0115495045,
-0.007911332,
0.0508086123,
-0.0313180313,
-0.0079654846,
-0.0073056165,
0.022054255,
0.0479548499,
0.0190756489,
-0.0041379095,
-0.0141214989,
-0.0352650993,
-0.0182286669,
-0.0126006193,
0.0299916286,
-0.0028091513,
-0.003491282,
0.0188725013,
0.0296335295,
-0.0424731597,
0.0646142811,
-0.0559019707,
-0.0143928854,
-0.0287120957,
0.0609617382,
0.0570366383,
0.0505084991,
0.0253063664,
-0.0509954244,
0.0223719012,
0.0452306792,
0.0149973538,
0.0399060547,
-0.0138033209,
0.010570256,
-0.0223860517,
0.0147937685,
-0.0321855061,
0.0634329095,
-0.0039981883,
0.0176258069,
-0.02738031,
0.001304514,
0.012029089,
-0.0086433021,
0.0144057246,
-0.0225193053,
-0.0103737097,
-0.0098013934,
0.0257385876,
-0.0097763129,
0.0258682091,
0.0114363208,
-0.0176754314,
-0.0479859784,
0.009217686,
0.0672268867,
0.0440924838,
0.041732125,
-0.0208009314,
-0.0673573315,
-0.040068347,
-0.0137615213,
0.0240589119,
-0.0117428163,
-0.0640196726,
-0.0291477647,
-0.0354003496,
-0.0203491505,
0.0621047504,
-0.0108399354,
0.0181941632,
0.0261854809,
0.0113820909,
0.0320738703,
0.0368825644,
-0.0451391824,
-0.0090299016,
0.0408182926,
-0.0163834374,
-0.0355476998,
-0.0103241643,
-5.045019716e-33,
0.044565849,
-0.0437512249,
-0.0304576401,
-0.0184530672,
0.0350183807,
0.0081212511,
-0.01799196,
-0.0343741588,
0.0473949946,
-0.0023110262,
-0.0484679304,
-0.0118139628,
0.028482141,
0.0126924235,
0.0065636537,
-0.0001225201,
0.0112447841,
0.00721543,
-0.0396836624,
0.015261027,
0.0138219716,
0.0581609905,
0.0613258258,
-0.0904966742,
0.0511312671,
0.0039114146,
-0.0022389349,
-0.0114636319,
0.018793853,
0.0425911769,
-0.060158994,
-0.0221018251,
0.0571037605,
0.004036787,
-0.0023823029,
0.0662275404,
-0.0763182044,
-0.0037283404,
-0.0072258296,
-0.010599602,
0.0050691124,
-0.0562362149,
0.0777286887,
-0.039971631,
-0.0511505194,
0.0529478267,
0.0406795926,
-0.0232204739,
0.0053780628,
-0.0498200133,
-0.0201849788,
0.0604390539,
-0.0009532799,
0.0338232964,
0.0589892454,
0.0137956869,
-0.0495866276,
0.0206699912,
-0.0433553383,
-0.0400242135,
0.0340430178,
0.0069721346,
-0.0225853324,
-0.040593449,
-0.0121708708,
0.0345414877,
0.0178986806,
-0.0280668493,
-0.0030651011,
0.0050462815,
-0.0360039212,
0.0066736247,
0.0453738421,
0.0255228691,
0.0643862784,
-0.0408891886,
-0.0660062805,
0.0778637603,
-0.0754029974,
0.0340875126,
-0.0078233089,
-0.0452786051,
-0.0443957709,
0.0026595944,
-0.0158318374,
-0.0076245079,
0.0018633974,
-0.0021925636,
0.0117145209,
-0.0211370885,
-0.0271335412,
0.0356212333,
-0.008400186,
-0.0214595329,
-0.0098446421,
-0.0129899271,
0.0708661526,
0.0440505818,
-0.0353973433,
-0.0248858966,
-0.0585449785,
-0.0091392398,
0.0278460197,
-0.0078920843,
0.0502548181,
-0.0221438166,
0.013287751,
-0.0145298587,
-0.0769239217,
0.0102849938,
0.0767167956,
0.0217341743,
0.0224291924,
0.0534268059,
0.0052853865,
0.0041645155,
0.0482982062,
-0.0098509509,
0.017036397,
0.0202436727,
-0.0329958946,
-0.0072063287,
0.0082868198,
-0.0057450254,
-0.0031839292,
-0.0150117567,
-0.0243868195,
0.0636053979,
0.0181769934,
-0.0353976302,
0.0358369127,
-0.0164574087,
2.434e-7,
0.0875899419,
0.0376998559,
0.0562485494,
-0.0435002968,
0.0221543163,
0.0170207061,
0.0047877952,
-0.0061858399,
-0.0049787443,
0.0260881148,
0.0338617042,
-0.0531959869,
0.0470939167,
0.0248185471,
-0.0742883235,
-0.014104927,
-0.0441084839,
-0.0373749696,
-0.041779425,
0.0040465728,
0.0272165742,
0.0434999242,
-0.0441733338,
-0.0236628521,
-0.0335174948,
-0.0101083126,
-0.0193661079,
-0.0179876536,
0.0102836303,
0.042457737,
0.0572495908,
-0.0177024826,
0.0069608074,
0.0279888678,
-0.0193873048,
0.0062538958,
-0.0231770407,
0.0793611407,
-0.0338126421,
0.0476171561,
0.007397485,
-0.0306890924,
0.0277328771,
0.0212716535,
0.0592640415,
-0.0058364091,
-0.0523846112,
0.0042172219,
-0.0264962129,
-0.0318246298,
0.040847037,
0.0152410576,
-0.0424456298,
0.0427868366,
0.007080785,
0.0404744931,
-0.0277667977,
-0.0798315927,
0.0298869573,
0.0043864143,
-0.0027302834,
0.0220421348,
0.046152249,
0.0005830833,
0.004986525,
-0.0929778218,
0.0692355558,
2.500929205e-34,
-0.0038880664,
-0.0202361625,
-0.0217341091,
0.0229252111,
0.0147966957,
-0.0130317966,
0.0133851161,
0.0315746218,
-0.0403661542,
-0.0615008809,
0.0387459733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16764v1 | Radiology-Aware Model-Based Evaluation Metric for Report Generation | 2023-11-28T13:08:26 | 2023-11-28T13:08:26 | Amos Calamida, Farhad Nooralahzadeh, Morteza Rohanian, Koji Fujimoto, Mizuho Nishio, Michael Krauthammer | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a new automated evaluation metric for machine-generated radiology
reports using the successful COMET architecture adapted for the radiology
domain. We train and publish four medically-oriented model checkpoints,
including one trained on RadGraph, a radiology knowledge graph. Our results
show that our metric correlates moderately to high with established metrics
such as BERTscore, BLEU, and CheXbert scores. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
one of our checkpoints exhibits a high correlation with human judgment, as
assessed using the publicly available annotations of six board-certified
radiologists, using a set of 200 reports. We also performed our own analysis
gathering annotations with two radiologists on a collection of 100 reports. The
results indicate the potential effectiveness of our method as a
radiology-specific evaluation metric. The code, data, and model checkpoints to
reproduce our findings will be publicly available. | [
0.0523280501,
0.0416531637,
0.016658226,
-0.0484244116,
0.0008947519,
0.0431180261,
-0.0116022313,
0.0501912646,
0.0180137772,
-0.0227520876,
-0.0099280989,
-0.0243194941,
0.0111079132,
0.0559363477,
0.0075215213,
-0.0882359222,
0.0129902828,
0.0366299488,
0.0480065532,
0.0268092174,
-0.0068791606,
0.0119280787,
-0.032689631,
0.0292640161,
-0.02545196,
-0.0120526245,
0.0395341404,
0.0158336349,
0.0329738446,
-0.043772541,
-0.0342034772,
0.0449736528,
-0.0279099494,
0.0336758606,
0.0000020676,
-0.0371923596,
-0.0245237947,
0.0426489711,
-0.0379377566,
-0.0103382422,
0.0891598612,
-0.0386851057,
-0.0077675469,
0.004516101,
-0.0128839752,
-0.0468841679,
0.0487186313,
0.0195282996,
0.0641827956,
0.0453766696,
-0.0152877197,
0.0429838449,
0.0134814428,
-0.013237481,
-0.031645786,
-0.0104876105,
-0.01708184,
0.1040842533,
0.0053260438,
-0.0214997958,
0.0201833211,
0.0263773445,
-0.0057039959,
-0.0163381044,
0.0237329938,
0.0513111688,
-0.004260147,
-0.0307623073,
0.0057883305,
0.0196932517,
0.0274454542,
0.0010411124,
0.0112765357,
-0.0039365287,
0.0009527084,
-0.0079744309,
-0.0408487655,
0.0024465041,
-0.0203147475,
-0.0419240445,
-0.0311144777,
0.0090612425,
0.013629226,
0.0147166559,
0.0274531506,
-0.0326192863,
0.0036612374,
-0.0109438915,
0.0222370662,
0.0453886688,
0.0102366339,
-0.0689515695,
0.0194315203,
0.0314576961,
-0.0584617108,
0.0044526942,
-0.0093167732,
0.020624131,
0.0873666853,
-0.0236470066,
0.0137421172,
-0.0223183986,
-0.0011955873,
0.0479234345,
-0.0252662469,
0.033586856,
-0.0125221321,
0.0154289594,
-0.014223095,
0.0367256403,
-0.0600548163,
-0.017880246,
-0.0021839489,
-0.0003494314,
0.0582650006,
-0.0233238991,
-0.0722332373,
0.0022337153,
-0.0297631714,
0.0534388386,
0.0525840446,
0.0544618294,
-0.060376808,
0.0274927747,
-0.047850322,
0.0364215896,
-0.0110629834,
-0.0199875515,
0.0172620714,
-0.0032745514,
0.0339659303,
0.0323649831,
-0.0096241962,
0.0571240596,
-0.012991406,
0.0391052775,
0.0062524355,
0.0084130066,
0.0345669799,
-0.0887304097,
-0.0074418085,
-0.0400267579,
0.0117561165,
-0.0537787676,
0.01242851,
0.0350579247,
0.0131473253,
-0.0136676403,
0.0016341479,
-0.0006953093,
-0.0065512597,
0.0090881484,
-0.0621965006,
0.0051597473,
0.0320848264,
0.0310031157,
-0.0334868878,
0.000308489,
0.0120260818,
0.0251746103,
-0.001797723,
0.0181607567,
0.0134511935,
-0.0269026924,
-0.0229504332,
-0.0260351524,
-0.0076124561,
0.0196041334,
-0.0395394079,
0.0724449977,
-0.0081791794,
0.0270747636,
-0.0461664461,
0.0308987536,
0.0173198152,
-0.0034181867,
0.0480934717,
0.0133173354,
0.0535843521,
-0.0388848074,
-0.004058246,
0.0139840152,
-0.0127686048,
0.0476233065,
0.011525671,
0.0209871624,
-0.0203468744,
-0.0196127836,
-0.0199922174,
-0.0356580541,
-0.047069218,
0.0114501091,
-0.0281758774,
-0.0156435631,
0.0176855605,
0.0017262415,
-0.0486222841,
0.0446266793,
0.0224575829,
-0.0306645054,
0.0023234538,
-0.0531215854,
-0.0147826625,
0.0853958353,
0.0936683491,
-0.0314524882,
-0.0488713905,
-0.0158114173,
0.0147229992,
0.0229606777,
0.0811481401,
-0.0509488136,
-0.0179577228,
-0.0283918511,
-0.0512405038,
0.0085410839,
0.0333687961,
-0.004102658,
0.0361211821,
0.0110780653,
-0.0078876084,
-0.0701587796,
-0.0788855329,
0.0314785913,
-0.0294633321,
0.0021824772,
-0.0312476549,
-0.0057156649,
0.0126480469,
0.0173528027,
-0.0392098501,
0.0456792563,
0.019951541,
0.0426289178,
-0.0122302547,
-0.0061844247,
0.0025922528,
-0.0048310529,
0.0122793438,
-0.0686218068,
-0.0032728908,
0.0059258379,
-0.0079951258,
-0.0124078542,
-0.0443970151,
-0.0654551089,
0.030788973,
-0.0228655469,
0.0392333269,
0.0429602899,
-0.0438162498,
-0.0070398445,
0.0481747761,
-0.0074994625,
0.022001477,
0.0495201647,
-0.0248637423,
0.0344113745,
-0.0316575319,
-0.0234178361,
-0.0118939718,
0.0050450573,
0.0336476192,
0.0136546921,
0.0156207299,
-0.0414792225,
-0.0243883785,
-0.0980924144,
-0.0187965427,
0.0058532446,
-0.0149954641,
0.0502528995,
-0.0275918301,
0.0143027902,
-0.0191666316,
-0.0155269904,
-0.0537462868,
0.0575750098,
0.0247894041,
0.0568257421,
0.0227399748,
-0.0060368762,
-0.0314084738,
-0.031934768,
-0.0258750133,
0.0255756583,
0.0954164639,
-0.0112996148,
-0.0369189121,
0.0471379682,
-0.0747068673,
-0.0226158388,
0.0265287012,
-0.0430582985,
0.0580576323,
-0.0190828815,
-0.0391156934,
0.0550467297,
0.0018048079,
0.0422105119,
0.0491466597,
-0.0101421271,
-0.0196297951,
-0.0221053585,
-0.027555801,
-0.0148053318,
0.0539500006,
-0.0847787932,
0.0058038426,
-0.005458883,
0.0014209003,
0.0131105278,
-0.0162515733,
0.0020432456,
-0.0331596248,
0.0023304555,
-0.0205098372,
-0.0093586072,
0.0022563816,
0.0588610061,
-0.0012969816,
-0.0279788896,
0.0923202857,
-0.0168965831,
0.0469592959,
-0.0511897057,
0.023157442,
-0.0250308402,
0.0319278575,
0.0056063086,
0.0455789529,
0.0080487672,
-0.0119696166,
-0.0126021327,
0.0273929965,
0.0548406877,
-0.0544965863,
-0.0396682285,
0.0006594218,
-0.0008307024,
-0.0035900229,
0.000159946,
-0.041835662,
0.0195778161,
0.0270591527,
0.0108443908,
0.0088777924,
-0.0191053525,
-0.079956241,
0.069468163,
0.0141281979,
0.0286684334,
-0.0103552397,
-0.0282893721,
0.0151416892,
0.0359772258,
0.016364973,
-0.0022446644,
0.0194617826,
-0.0207021404,
0.0081533492,
0.0679218173,
0.0023172882,
0.0505043752,
-0.0308402367,
-0.016136419,
-0.0197960567,
-0.0279038884,
-0.0073610623,
0.0078035365,
0.017094424,
-0.0345136002,
-0.0202560201,
0.0668035373,
0.0410606377,
-0.0292468686,
-0.0254680067,
0.0177833419,
-0.0041048755,
0.0113438442,
0.0151893161,
0.0011262062,
0.0150083164,
-0.0160396155,
0.0448547304,
-0.0278639346,
-0.038928166,
0.0240577534,
-0.0304388851,
0.0636858121,
-0.0141105019,
-0.0377742499,
-0.0539235696,
-0.0503917523,
0.0010324917,
0.0001152848,
-0.0888014585,
0.0114230402,
-0.0095969429,
-0.013690846,
0.000270025,
-0.0728397518,
-0.0794154853,
0.0197633151,
-0.0455074534,
-0.0023891367,
0.0817726254,
0.0435779504,
-0.0134029258,
-0.0333853588,
-0.0696002617,
0.0517621525,
0.0233382005,
0.0146438135,
0.1078886539,
0.0016393742,
0.0041877292,
-0.0758221447,
-0.0111815957,
0.0196057614,
0.0215590801,
-0.0247211158,
0.0551247075,
-0.0290382095,
0.0014971832,
-0.0500716045,
0.0534711853,
0.0170866679,
0.041678939,
0.0193345547,
0.0296768434,
-0.0198101681,
0.0016208199,
0.0877812728,
-0.0522072203,
0.0121849366,
0.0393201634,
-0.0790382177,
-0.0844166502,
-0.0739589855,
-0.0337835103,
0.0200077668,
0.0418210104,
-0.0010423164,
-0.0384142213,
-0.0346281379,
-0.0171087999,
-0.0795874819,
0.0411847569,
0.0194173809,
-0.00442563,
-0.0361950435,
-0.0402520485,
0.040745087,
0.0306221843,
-0.0193246696,
0.0683166459,
-0.0226530917,
0.019051915,
-0.0235081911,
0.046791587,
0.032932274,
-0.0179595817,
-0.0079626972,
-0.0050235395,
0.0407610945,
0.0336032845,
-0.0352528952,
-0.0286151357,
-0.0167278256,
-0.0636591613,
-0.0459959172,
-0.0253247116,
-0.0379410945,
-0.0033361772,
0.0021287671,
0.0285261385,
-0.0273565166,
-0.0411205515,
0.014872076,
0.0468745753,
0.0155044599,
-0.0483051986,
-0.0213844888,
-0.0203331374,
-0.0339038409,
-0.0320413783,
-0.0201156531,
-0.0234459992,
0.0327722244,
0.0169346388,
0.0006106865,
-0.0000148448,
0.0522674844,
-0.047223039,
0.014754191,
-0.038925726,
0.0033008144,
0.0370823257,
0.0082199462,
0.0291648582,
-0.0257551819,
-0.0643742532,
-0.0678386316,
0.0061854618,
-0.0142384861,
0.0106985066,
0.0625476912,
0.0251340456,
0.0526743904,
0.0069724149,
0.0300264843,
-0.0347601213,
-0.0369184166,
-0.0632994026,
0.0325901248,
0.028849408,
0.0547814257,
0.0271974728,
-0.0686090887,
-0.0012599237,
-0.023737045,
0.0482206829,
0.0225635432,
0.0024827213,
0.0136072403,
0.0160114914,
0.0346919186,
-0.0231022649,
0.0735208169,
-0.0323770344,
0.018601561,
-0.062003199,
-0.1113584787,
-0.0712139904,
-0.0301549509,
-0.000446658,
-0.0046750959,
-0.0001559235,
-0.0186329838,
-0.0661201179,
-0.052603323,
-0.0112809772,
0.0375577509,
-0.0021966673,
-0.0344451256,
0.0363454074,
0.0708275437,
0.0090374518,
-0.0190584119,
-0.0306118559,
0.0507560596,
-0.0559493043,
0.0181208849,
0.0031106155,
-5.870124547e-33,
-0.0070488541,
-0.061297413,
0.0138318865,
-0.0544660352,
-0.0012857923,
0.0435084254,
-0.0277939122,
-0.0159880724,
0.0101062767,
0.0118893748,
-0.0065467088,
-0.0263286401,
0.0128805749,
-0.0212937053,
0.0067694932,
0.0223814864,
0.0557478145,
0.0039700461,
-0.0544779263,
0.0247415584,
-0.029179899,
0.0019696432,
0.0046098945,
-0.0753281564,
0.006618673,
0.0102921249,
-0.0164302494,
-0.0215277243,
0.0123041077,
0.0713511407,
-0.0131213665,
0.0019172658,
0.0318480507,
-0.0339839943,
-0.0149719268,
-0.0083380723,
-0.0793851241,
-0.0028791216,
0.0036914872,
-0.0118938768,
-0.0383625776,
0.0178429149,
0.027160041,
-0.0191891193,
-0.0026246645,
-0.0396163538,
0.0360702164,
0.0044834027,
-0.0190456007,
-0.0203774851,
-0.014093467,
0.0578127988,
0.0033654338,
-0.030952381,
-0.0341035128,
0.0224393979,
-0.0301052928,
0.0166077055,
-0.0277929697,
0.0143733369,
0.0621500872,
0.0263826512,
0.0454682447,
-0.0033189862,
-0.0197528284,
0.0451973267,
0.0414319746,
0.0312173069,
0.0131819537,
0.0125040384,
-0.0477964357,
0.0584436618,
0.0453351326,
0.0373351164,
-0.0080261016,
-0.0249795858,
-0.0548170172,
0.0706144497,
-0.0281768627,
0.0689691082,
0.0143464776,
-0.0363936573,
-0.0736078992,
-0.0003453922,
0.0142932897,
-0.0638707802,
-0.0339827798,
-0.0527661592,
0.0338456519,
0.0292327944,
-0.0207523238,
0.0557959415,
0.0102656372,
0.0194895435,
0.0228133611,
-0.0047787237,
0.0040001869,
0.0431293882,
-0.0449212901,
-0.0145576997,
-0.0191306081,
0.0323781408,
0.0342265889,
0.0372026041,
0.0326082483,
0.0138948746,
0.0336362123,
0.0044795256,
-0.0311681554,
0.0264285281,
0.0125536248,
-0.0090528373,
-0.0337314829,
-0.0076520876,
0.0350867026,
0.0030883013,
-0.0138530722,
0.0188867096,
-0.0186041035,
0.0341360457,
-0.0269373897,
-0.0580681525,
0.0054898923,
0.031129973,
-0.0360557921,
-0.0345562547,
-0.0330996364,
-0.0124997441,
0.0396315716,
-0.0011616541,
-0.0112421773,
0.0038604266,
2.751e-7,
0.0802570656,
0.0377112105,
0.032032162,
0.013113711,
0.0233980361,
-0.0092458948,
-0.0118283546,
-0.006732394,
0.0443580709,
0.0106710447,
0.0306829493,
-0.0312660858,
-0.0044956887,
0.0561404452,
-0.0641794801,
-0.0749698207,
-0.060070198,
-0.0095539214,
-0.0001496307,
-0.0361461118,
0.0824899897,
-0.0078586945,
-0.0285126679,
-0.0365575477,
-0.0131555572,
-0.0093255537,
0.0258724838,
-0.0052669342,
-0.0027748027,
0.0153144756,
0.0831023976,
0.0155726047,
0.0071018278,
0.0892409608,
-0.0147157814,
-0.0439516269,
0.0283542499,
0.0619560629,
-0.0183652341,
0.011540358,
0.0506237783,
-0.0063936696,
0.0482288189,
-0.0447424091,
0.0232554954,
-0.0238223094,
-0.0124295736,
-0.0087946467,
-0.0504452549,
-0.0040076845,
0.0597708561,
-0.0527535826,
-0.0531335659,
0.0450703539,
-0.0236761793,
0.0408585295,
-0.0309300944,
-0.0366215892,
-0.0145719582,
0.0182379987,
-0.0046572727,
-0.078461118,
0.0442050546,
-0.0472593419,
-0.0163260531,
-0.0822402909,
-0.0227246005,
2.549798776e-34,
0.0412123054,
0.0208489038,
0.0023012788,
-0.0564617775,
0.0457178988,
-0.0134686297,
0.023962386,
-0.0198485926,
0.024926478,
-0.0093705365,
-0.022490032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03735v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03735v1 | Advancing State of the Art in Language Modeling | 2023-11-28T12:30:43 | 2023-11-28T12:30:43 | David Herel, Tomas Mikolov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generalization is arguably the most important goal of statistical language
modeling research. Publicly available benchmarks and papers published with an
open-source code have been critical to advancing the field. However, it is
often very difficult, and sometimes even impossible, to reproduce the results
fully as reported in publications. In this paper, we propose a simple framework
that should help advance the state of the art in language modeling in terms of
generalization. We propose to publish not just the code, but also probabilities
on dev and test sets with future publications so that one can easily add the
new model into an ensemble. This has crucial advantages: it is much easier to
determine whether a newly proposed model is actually complementary to the
current baseline. Therefore, instead of inventing new names for the old tricks,
the scientific community can advance faster. Finally, this approach promotes
diversity of ideas: one does not need to create an individual model that is the
new state of the art to attract attention; it will be sufficient to develop a
new model that learns patterns which other models do not. Thus, even a
suboptimal model can be found to have value. Remarkably, our approach has
yielded new state-of-the-art results across various language modeling
benchmarks up to 10%. | [
0.0405382924,
0.0949878022,
0.0168521181,
0.0269859005,
-0.0321690291,
0.0004189305,
0.031650506,
-0.0001548357,
-0.0501733795,
-0.03307404,
-0.0190607943,
-0.0557142757,
0.0275592078,
0.0691126585,
0.0475047566,
-0.0256895572,
0.0119752064,
-0.0236178711,
-0.0048974711,
-0.0088675786,
0.0195430424,
0.0166561324,
0.0188563056,
0.0750235394,
0.0045685614,
0.0171193294,
-0.0026632254,
0.0122351609,
0.0089544607,
0.0052836495,
0.0282818228,
0.0587203167,
0.0284788273,
0.0815654248,
0.0000017652,
-0.0486853532,
-0.0298559088,
-0.0111161806,
0.0096424473,
0.0228661317,
0.0440444499,
-0.024407208,
0.0014678,
0.0381469317,
-0.0315228589,
-0.0339843221,
0.0848151892,
-0.0138524445,
0.0199761186,
0.0735493749,
-0.01319391,
-0.020684462,
0.0146378493,
-0.0333367735,
-0.0248578582,
-0.0195918549,
0.0236586556,
0.0162251536,
0.0085899839,
-0.0376787558,
-0.024618635,
0.018457694,
-0.0090988521,
0.0158147328,
0.0072075212,
0.0329354778,
-0.0345874652,
-0.0215540081,
0.0141958948,
0.0679463074,
-0.0332976766,
-0.0589896888,
0.0137256682,
0.0005367951,
-0.0559112839,
0.0107513061,
-0.0570402071,
-0.0089158546,
0.0170575324,
0.0398624539,
0.0194361117,
-0.0053136707,
0.0508861803,
-0.0027724155,
-0.029606754,
0.0456826985,
0.0375700295,
-0.011364135,
-0.0281877331,
-0.0172794294,
-0.0353298187,
-0.0259232167,
0.0004904739,
0.0041873874,
-0.0157294367,
0.0098267607,
-0.0215832498,
-0.0664523467,
0.0214086138,
-0.0137515133,
0.0756851137,
0.0339229442,
-0.0130827203,
0.0416518897,
-0.0148187587,
0.0325135551,
-0.0102265244,
0.0109012732,
-0.0511228032,
-0.0064651053,
-0.0656714439,
0.0240940731,
-0.0281316098,
-0.0004244059,
0.0108800195,
-0.0245706011,
-0.0225263722,
-0.0159628093,
0.0341362208,
-0.0024099485,
0.0565267392,
-0.0024959985,
-0.0419944003,
-0.0275933612,
0.0802375376,
0.0176274292,
-0.0301411804,
0.0168557968,
-0.0306527037,
-0.0403458402,
-0.003901734,
0.0288908761,
0.0215907935,
0.029362319,
0.0093348529,
0.0323252752,
0.0175437964,
-0.0493860357,
0.0080011506,
0.042377118,
-0.0485071689,
-0.0494602285,
-0.0513829626,
-0.0878454521,
0.0407650806,
0.0197231323,
0.0181196518,
-0.0474630557,
-0.0309254918,
-0.0273481775,
-0.0197553262,
0.0469204076,
-0.0438158512,
0.0143022947,
0.0281901676,
-0.0092250668,
0.0356828347,
0.076357089,
0.0445302278,
-0.0076238955,
0.0467772409,
-0.0103236837,
0.0314607956,
0.0798844919,
0.0027325668,
0.0091040777,
-0.0218433458,
-0.0115562901,
-0.0078243846,
0.0058654021,
0.018373115,
0.0519508049,
-0.0261866972,
-0.0256362353,
0.0576818027,
0.0435659103,
0.0107760001,
0.0269278679,
0.0258691609,
0.0006088815,
0.003145922,
-0.0248438045,
-0.0060888506,
-0.0318692103,
0.0042963014,
0.0223308783,
0.0324753299,
0.0529814474,
-0.028915273,
-0.0266821254,
-0.0397552848,
-0.0478098504,
0.0156656839,
0.0069267913,
0.0886441991,
-0.0202289354,
-0.0092197498,
0.0409733504,
0.037583679,
-0.0536057875,
0.0083352868,
-0.0569714084,
0.0676328316,
0.0334811024,
0.0431061462,
-0.0250021294,
0.0017851241,
-0.0191728342,
-0.0129495068,
0.0158026628,
0.0424219109,
-0.0120851975,
0.0712730214,
-0.0643471777,
-0.0331333838,
0.0301369037,
0.0401690118,
0.0430319868,
0.0264799129,
-0.0250887889,
0.01592247,
-0.0560178943,
-0.035546653,
0.0353881419,
-0.0476679094,
0.0063704518,
0.0247562286,
-0.0139162084,
0.0231314618,
0.0065601449,
-0.0291644745,
0.0022292596,
0.0229025185,
-0.0276739206,
-0.0234026611,
-0.0072048767,
-0.0092968643,
-0.0286518037,
0.0293158721,
-0.0126937153,
0.016310228,
0.0413107499,
-0.0551901571,
-0.0710213259,
0.0565099381,
-0.0243414249,
0.0524600334,
-0.0552556105,
0.0126875527,
-0.0430694371,
0.0407872088,
-0.02281514,
0.0256702043,
0.0026991875,
0.0282203835,
-0.0165316667,
-0.0382957309,
0.021459721,
-0.0219108965,
-0.0401674137,
-0.000100812,
-0.0224113073,
0.0481519699,
0.045401264,
-0.0019600608,
-0.0146496966,
-0.0080009969,
-0.0811879784,
-0.0001738693,
-0.0514874943,
0.012355784,
0.028637832,
0.0481252484,
-0.0281441323,
-0.0400768444,
-0.0192891862,
-0.0323543958,
0.0241957195,
0.0011781196,
0.0012962207,
0.0117442179,
-0.045349028,
-0.073696211,
-0.0377109013,
0.0117543433,
0.0617614724,
-0.0407512411,
-0.0057718633,
-0.0629225597,
0.0131023917,
-0.0382620431,
0.0321276821,
-0.0107450765,
-0.0079116588,
-0.0247814227,
-0.0515345372,
0.0041185995,
0.0432668775,
-0.0156013938,
-0.027557319,
0.0447138958,
0.0316938087,
-0.0541208833,
-0.0142210349,
-0.0354582593,
-0.0000403827,
-0.0114514045,
-0.0395568945,
-0.0116660409,
0.0915476382,
0.0274670552,
-0.0280761588,
-0.0427100733,
-0.007311828,
-0.0206289366,
-0.00342398,
-0.0242743734,
-0.0123302294,
-0.0045504021,
0.0369677991,
-0.0137439873,
-0.0895382017,
0.0624650009,
-0.0661341175,
-0.0207142401,
-0.0535171255,
-0.0521949232,
-0.0751164705,
0.0616567433,
0.0094053224,
0.007509612,
0.0244930331,
-0.0187248513,
-0.0309025999,
-0.0149492305,
0.0008220363,
-0.0151463579,
0.0608241223,
-0.0374771729,
0.0356880315,
0.0124099134,
-0.016545279,
-0.0053170011,
-0.0436021909,
-0.072924301,
0.0074525732,
0.0050003664,
-0.0475156642,
-0.0325989947,
0.0309316516,
0.0056814682,
0.0616260208,
0.0051380396,
0.0041472521,
0.0038152591,
0.0495369099,
0.0718594268,
-0.0115708774,
0.002626688,
-0.0158422552,
0.0090903882,
0.015292801,
0.065563336,
0.0699597448,
-0.0812946856,
-0.0224965569,
0.0410443842,
-0.0048385314,
-0.0174709335,
0.0196969565,
0.0184379481,
-0.0155703425,
-0.0183216929,
0.1290282309,
0.0177181587,
-0.0375177339,
0.0027264582,
0.0158570446,
0.0602972582,
0.0152560733,
0.0075825648,
-0.0185910594,
-0.0252993833,
0.0070024296,
0.0044730888,
0.0101691308,
-0.0032374172,
-0.0019845965,
-0.0715602636,
-0.0143259903,
0.0207923297,
-0.0446525924,
-0.014449941,
-0.051336471,
0.0054726675,
-0.0757009089,
0.0270579476,
0.0019034919,
0.0253550839,
0.0271457881,
0.0378886126,
-0.0618850961,
-0.0723700523,
0.0198182408,
-0.051481504,
0.0450912379,
0.0991555974,
0.0128392689,
-0.009473809,
0.0139835607,
0.0021981108,
0.0144885639,
-0.0278723519,
-0.0087245898,
0.0432573482,
0.0037800896,
-0.0045779548,
0.0381108858,
0.0146464808,
-0.0691093132,
0.0231660083,
0.0060017435,
0.0317865014,
0.0229070783,
-0.0480645224,
-0.0063211266,
-0.0164475236,
0.0010074773,
0.0693841279,
0.0329684801,
-0.0474018492,
0.0055895718,
-0.0373619795,
0.0183493719,
-0.0583239272,
0.0089802723,
-0.0043478454,
0.034380693,
-0.0021778615,
-0.0649295524,
-0.0015414195,
0.0177308321,
0.0329876728,
0.0007897016,
0.0235074535,
-0.0318379253,
-0.0159569159,
-0.0352342948,
-0.0079987841,
-0.0161189493,
0.0133033572,
-0.019299699,
-0.0079405941,
0.0611672662,
-0.0121643608,
-0.0303543285,
0.0039575091,
-0.1159556657,
-0.076260969,
-0.017380083,
0.0521637648,
0.0302636158,
0.026112644,
-0.0259868521,
-0.0746485442,
0.0442909002,
-0.0087995045,
0.0066529349,
-0.0045063728,
0.0131638162,
-0.0541802496,
-0.0156525709,
0.0379992686,
-0.0571273454,
0.0358518586,
0.0327715501,
0.0331099778,
-0.0383643135,
-0.0255234148,
0.0132970624,
-0.0211605225,
0.0438350104,
-0.0513528399,
-0.0194444433,
-0.01608257,
-0.0022008899,
0.0165190287,
0.0100618936,
-0.0581501946,
0.0114955315,
0.0459986255,
0.0177369192,
-0.0301102921,
0.0411370248,
-0.0201383494,
0.0346145742,
-0.0493542477,
0.0215722676,
0.0282857213,
0.018478591,
0.0259937588,
-0.0158166755,
-0.0079140794,
0.0266560055,
-0.0095260181,
-0.0004868163,
-0.0200096201,
-0.0031245006,
-0.0154586602,
0.0133751687,
-0.0011477461,
0.0318844207,
-0.0934456661,
-0.0208397713,
-0.0465815328,
0.0436506718,
0.0562479757,
0.0092540206,
0.0710303411,
0.0004683771,
0.005323777,
-0.0471065231,
0.0484333411,
-0.0026828765,
-0.0268000811,
0.0147051746,
0.0073109618,
-0.0466836989,
0.0254937094,
0.0929630846,
0.029894799,
0.0242050774,
-0.0108070401,
-0.0095324898,
-0.0325007141,
0.0175766945,
0.0213093255,
0.0207763277,
-0.0599338263,
0.0142639261,
-0.0233105011,
-0.0804210231,
0.0132587561,
-0.0120909968,
0.0417448208,
-0.0011848737,
0.0141681666,
0.0665895715,
-0.0154665606,
0.0439778343,
-0.0271050762,
-0.0447867401,
-0.0021951336,
-0.0317805335,
-0.0328864157,
-6.267494168e-33,
0.0192515124,
0.0348956957,
-0.0272415616,
-0.0325930081,
0.0162209459,
-0.0111421542,
-0.0275165215,
0.0220675021,
-0.0363131203,
-0.0317242742,
-0.0146178855,
0.0205950122,
0.0081813103,
0.0414405689,
-0.0045811352,
0.0248016119,
0.0352092497,
-0.0231262501,
-0.0299245361,
0.0094706155,
0.0232899748,
0.052404657,
0.085312739,
-0.0300556943,
0.0026824265,
-0.017779069,
-0.0417681783,
0.0049514659,
-0.0079924744,
0.0646486878,
-0.0168326609,
0.0556952097,
0.0340053178,
-0.0110367751,
-0.047190018,
-0.0039686761,
-0.0300184749,
0.0067064213,
0.0157091804,
-0.0154295461,
-0.0207729321,
0.0320375636,
0.0378150679,
-0.0295827743,
-0.0060274638,
-0.0217447784,
0.0447584689,
-0.0262772553,
-0.0416404866,
-0.0053167315,
-0.0251519158,
0.0409149788,
-0.0119347107,
-0.0121706147,
0.0136880493,
0.0349803157,
-0.0224951748,
0.0234714765,
-0.0181708243,
0.0273038391,
0.0290563535,
0.0594114996,
0.0634176061,
0.0420028828,
-0.0250335205,
0.0225834381,
0.0405738987,
-0.0299108811,
-0.021071285,
-0.0144470632,
0.0623383448,
0.0044836481,
0.0396284871,
0.0450511873,
0.0196697842,
-0.0138905551,
-0.0720210597,
0.0314299688,
0.0355880558,
-0.0060895411,
0.0481665805,
0.0479827002,
-0.0419899747,
-0.0415439755,
-0.0503738858,
-0.0373969115,
-0.0299299117,
-0.0268694274,
0.0277642328,
0.0472111218,
-0.0371186621,
-0.0163299385,
0.0318198614,
-0.0487653129,
-0.0182260405,
0.0207076911,
0.0196830109,
0.0229121372,
0.0031760496,
0.0402912237,
-0.0465253629,
-0.0307567138,
-0.0065008351,
0.0132372258,
-0.0067959358,
-0.0571583956,
0.0465759151,
0.0390343741,
-0.0686889887,
0.0124583049,
0.0001170104,
-0.0021668333,
0.0093449028,
0.0469678305,
0.0165728573,
0.0095452052,
0.0060595521,
0.0225042906,
0.0302326083,
-0.0050170799,
-0.0163210053,
-0.0160315763,
0.0056581493,
0.0378823057,
-0.023247771,
-0.014455582,
-0.0232751872,
-0.0407774821,
0.0636920556,
-0.0022842684,
-0.0231632646,
0.0034482693,
2.331e-7,
0.0670299977,
0.0065646507,
0.0031241626,
-0.0191362984,
0.0396516994,
0.0275299363,
-0.0467761308,
0.030796539,
-0.0018941698,
-0.0048948335,
0.0123745007,
-0.0085633518,
0.0874758959,
-0.0332433395,
-0.0961936861,
-0.0057808431,
-0.0886578187,
0.0499911755,
-0.0240190141,
0.0029735721,
-0.0140502742,
0.1595430672,
0.0141244577,
0.0017465233,
-0.0328557901,
-0.0547903255,
0.069404684,
-0.0306175668,
-0.0041875835,
0.0379969552,
0.0138864685,
0.0097879618,
-0.0123392027,
-0.0174585767,
-0.0270065963,
0.0223754086,
0.0388762802,
0.0515420213,
0.0016983685,
0.0039603151,
0.0104751447,
0.0076403935,
0.0058188499,
-0.0704730749,
0.0428658202,
-0.0147919115,
-0.0106070265,
-0.051190149,
0.0115959402,
0.0265842155,
0.0157520622,
-0.0497102477,
-0.0252325684,
0.0288195852,
0.0339489244,
-0.0317744799,
-0.0215362459,
-0.0801076815,
-0.0533592701,
0.0012612796,
-0.0595280342,
-0.0167372338,
0.0008744635,
-0.0207927115,
0.0311856773,
-0.0422092304,
0.0322365202,
2.335920793e-34,
0.059425205,
-0.002005253,
-0.0256361011,
0.025711501,
0.0210355278,
-0.0664955899,
-0.0075720432,
0.0127055012,
0.0008766917,
-0.0886759013,
-0.0189251266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16733v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16733v4 | LLMs for Science: Usage for Code Generation and Data Analysis | 2023-11-28T12:29:33 | 2024-04-23T08:12:46 | Mohamed Nejjar, Luca Zacharias, Fabian Stiehle, Ingo Weber | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have been touted to enable increased
productivity in many areas of today's work life. Scientific research as an area
of work is no exception: the potential of LLM-based tools to assist in the
daily work of scientists has become a highly discussed topic across
disciplines. However, we are only at the very onset of this subject of study.
It is still unclear how the potential of LLMs will materialise in research
practice. With this study, we give first empirical evidence on the use of LLMs
in the research process. We have investigated a set of use cases for LLM-based
tools in scientific research, and conducted a first study to assess to which
degree current tools are helpful. In this paper we report specifically on use
cases related to software engineering, such as generating application code and
developing scripts for data analytics. While we studied seemingly simple use
cases, results across tools differ significantly. Our results highlight the
promise of LLM-based tools in general, yet we also observe various issues,
particularly regarding the integrity of the output these tools provide. | [
-0.0064871465,
0.0547297895,
-0.0354664065,
0.024887735,
-0.03371327,
-0.0130918538,
0.030954577,
0.0329177231,
0.0314606875,
-0.0194016695,
-0.0015668813,
0.0210745987,
0.0171112735,
0.0482138842,
0.024294164,
0.005404931,
0.0537186861,
-0.044771757,
-0.0191597436,
0.0136267086,
-0.0235958993,
0.0058895391,
0.0192182343,
0.0217915997,
0.0367552824,
-0.0227761101,
0.0084679453,
0.0009677245,
0.0150158601,
-0.0105612809,
-0.0044216802,
0.0418787859,
0.0160664041,
0.0419054516,
0.000002119,
-0.0452606566,
0.0187305305,
0.088214606,
-0.0163184609,
0.0523912981,
0.0550858825,
0.0030992257,
-0.0190030728,
0.0050758868,
0.0056765429,
0.0240510739,
0.0514298864,
-0.0953128189,
0.0162346996,
-0.0098524531,
0.0384757407,
-0.0234917384,
0.0215725694,
0.037280187,
0.0273770019,
0.0482052155,
0.0203969106,
0.0695866123,
0.0839364305,
0.0501425043,
0.0592397898,
0.0284775216,
0.0178340152,
-0.0571734458,
0.0139342835,
0.0241316389,
-0.0198567528,
-0.0211983286,
0.0162585918,
0.0245100036,
0.028703209,
-0.0511450917,
0.0347542726,
-0.0172259007,
-0.0409180336,
0.0154613638,
-0.0567399897,
0.0659246445,
0.022446461,
-0.0086469501,
0.0108728055,
-0.0271668117,
0.0082216477,
-0.002022037,
-0.0072171153,
0.0462687388,
0.0163773913,
-0.003664695,
-0.014292283,
-0.0136768874,
0.0331047215,
-0.0509617738,
-0.0043693963,
0.0246437639,
0.0314440168,
0.0113644516,
-0.0095171779,
-0.0209881831,
0.0830270275,
-0.0357665159,
0.0340073742,
0.0078443056,
0.0158446897,
-0.0138803152,
-0.0196885783,
0.0295292847,
-0.0424464233,
0.0044628261,
0.0430893227,
0.0189262554,
-0.0481924713,
-0.036946021,
0.0132397339,
0.0077387514,
0.008038518,
0.0594059043,
-0.0152682513,
0.0546740107,
0.0090725133,
0.052306585,
-0.0203853119,
-0.0487371348,
-0.0078658219,
0.0404602028,
0.0289897956,
-0.016327126,
0.0322495885,
0.0022116308,
-0.0140923066,
-0.0704645589,
0.0119046438,
0.0220801402,
-0.0384769924,
0.0106131677,
0.0242753047,
0.0720466003,
0.0456539728,
0.0239380691,
-0.02508552,
-0.057475511,
0.0304902103,
-0.0264388863,
-0.0008523267,
-0.0995841622,
-0.0090362011,
0.0533797592,
-0.0128678549,
-0.0557497256,
0.0003449307,
-0.003417253,
-0.0037530279,
0.023229517,
-0.0732486174,
0.0284858812,
0.0113346232,
0.0371413343,
0.0293877162,
0.0278244503,
0.0358944051,
-0.0359648876,
0.0043829274,
-0.0688212514,
0.0432442762,
0.0293779895,
-0.0352593586,
0.0164204426,
-0.0498898961,
0.0580163747,
0.0157422964,
0.0031114479,
-0.0179901384,
0.0244444069,
-0.018739555,
0.0463786013,
0.0206699744,
0.0502263419,
0.0249277763,
0.0443121158,
0.0016710589,
-0.0024254178,
0.0079333857,
-0.0577526391,
-0.0102474792,
0.0686669201,
-0.0009858521,
0.0230061766,
-0.0450474396,
0.0608319789,
0.004890189,
-0.0415180922,
-0.0339019559,
-0.0065310295,
-0.0424394272,
-0.0185899958,
0.050098218,
-0.0216118339,
0.0072582378,
0.039800752,
0.0063863276,
-0.0836782008,
-0.0180377327,
-0.0426469035,
0.0431544445,
0.0388527438,
0.0474653579,
-0.0616646148,
-0.0275566485,
-0.0289874785,
0.003514861,
0.0151088387,
0.0336179473,
0.0023074585,
-0.026216099,
-0.0227919091,
0.0022112718,
-0.053665325,
-0.0324212089,
0.0256930012,
0.0033647085,
-0.00662921,
0.0007740212,
-0.0295802392,
-0.0450689159,
0.0109072654,
-0.0866428167,
0.0194349121,
-0.0063456297,
-0.0426752679,
0.0182731953,
0.0231431685,
-0.0530040376,
0.0340121984,
0.0653779358,
-0.0094246259,
-0.0024304595,
-0.0149115203,
0.0570295081,
0.0459811389,
0.0102913799,
-0.0398726538,
0.000773538,
-0.0052502342,
-0.0187341161,
0.007807266,
0.0408694111,
0.0031816058,
0.0239519812,
0.0250434037,
0.0081882523,
-0.081385158,
0.0002238506,
-0.0447607785,
-0.0070541366,
0.0043241908,
0.0634093955,
0.0088104997,
-0.0071797832,
0.0342038721,
0.0065325028,
-0.0193875805,
0.0519633852,
0.0286511797,
0.0198170431,
0.0256330334,
-0.0032702612,
-0.0003307177,
-0.0507695302,
-0.0463122167,
0.0005129334,
0.0349038169,
0.032560844,
0.0150292553,
-0.005657177,
-0.0224131476,
0.0299099665,
0.0146116409,
-0.0277413055,
-0.0012167866,
-0.0034900494,
0.0585220605,
-0.0290935412,
-0.0748493671,
-0.040064916,
-0.030456515,
-0.0396273434,
0.0458121225,
-0.0038208989,
-0.013998501,
-0.106911853,
0.0844120458,
-0.0072180056,
-0.0086681023,
-0.0146772573,
-0.0002974639,
0.0285944249,
-0.01761402,
0.0509336926,
0.0176125225,
-0.0562115125,
-0.0180834848,
0.0836996287,
-0.010585011,
-0.0535376891,
-0.0158386584,
0.0060686339,
-0.0069033401,
0.0161224492,
-0.0787762776,
0.0225839373,
0.0000070629,
-0.0125330212,
-0.0272612013,
0.0349592157,
0.0345746055,
0.0062368559,
-0.0047419341,
0.0344646834,
-0.01462295,
-0.0105169499,
0.0474435538,
0.0233324505,
-0.1018221378,
0.0132022686,
-0.0606416613,
-0.0094572566,
-0.0230596401,
-0.0515875965,
-0.0718611479,
0.0432744697,
-0.0288139954,
-0.0174819957,
-0.0113388766,
0.0183291864,
0.0145173166,
-0.0242632814,
-0.0449631736,
-0.0275961626,
0.0628168434,
-0.0437169932,
0.0086046234,
-0.0138061792,
0.0221659914,
-0.0069345837,
0.0100265425,
-0.0375663564,
0.0158218518,
0.01033381,
-0.0234036855,
0.0043023,
0.0235116817,
0.0840900838,
-0.0035299007,
0.0225683581,
-0.0140348934,
-0.0075004064,
-0.0575531013,
-0.0531623848,
-0.0546949618,
0.0161453858,
-0.0160896797,
0.00597608,
0.0279792827,
-0.0237437319,
0.0415280052,
-0.0676641241,
-0.0456472263,
0.0357673913,
-0.0187675394,
-0.0339492261,
0.0523490794,
0.0334728658,
-0.0314704031,
-0.0126780365,
0.0431378335,
0.0178992189,
-0.0336751342,
0.0151344026,
-0.0606388859,
0.040492624,
0.0671882629,
0.0587173216,
-0.0653541833,
0.0223124418,
0.0057755597,
0.0192812663,
-0.0378365852,
-0.0179732945,
-0.0119850151,
-0.0729135722,
0.0795303285,
0.0249078944,
-0.0145890713,
-0.0138122216,
-0.091014713,
0.0079838354,
0.0144659886,
-0.0224939995,
0.0521960184,
0.0031378036,
0.0006762528,
0.0134333512,
-0.0630149692,
-0.049951449,
0.0147635164,
0.0068468428,
0.0417023487,
0.0532217547,
0.0208241567,
-0.0422546826,
-0.0177535135,
0.0271762684,
0.0340389796,
0.0300099198,
-0.0432237536,
-0.0309653115,
0.0724371374,
-0.0178943276,
-0.0152921807,
0.0107325166,
-0.0627507791,
-0.0171888359,
0.0280591957,
0.0798639134,
-0.0559056103,
-0.0450202264,
-0.081757158,
-0.0229005031,
0.0018745667,
0.0384183563,
0.0278890859,
-0.0158465859,
-0.0373515151,
-0.0403604619,
-0.0153952017,
0.0160393137,
-0.0402522124,
-0.0267710052,
-0.0438877158,
0.0363733247,
0.0271419622,
0.0121750813,
0.0544731244,
-0.013669882,
0.0239245947,
-0.0205320641,
0.0226984192,
-0.0341258235,
-0.0493027903,
-0.0102647347,
-0.0300392434,
0.049002517,
-0.0367013589,
-0.0232550595,
0.0483409539,
0.0028795267,
0.0084891114,
-0.0198816098,
-0.0722997114,
-0.0597012714,
-0.0471005887,
0.0806131735,
0.030449437,
-0.0384624526,
0.0245175958,
-0.0419758931,
-0.0371182412,
0.0418977179,
-0.0070792115,
0.0277953595,
-0.0486730561,
0.0172693077,
0.0149810137,
-0.0638098046,
-0.0247726738,
-0.01146386,
0.0008661483,
-0.0063548232,
-0.0354798511,
-0.0500466377,
-0.0075323666,
0.0679035634,
-0.0016902963,
-0.0097595239,
-0.0112379976,
0.0032461334,
-0.0111356983,
-0.0320026055,
-0.0012555793,
-0.0343411602,
0.0305355079,
-0.0226188079,
-0.0108682252,
0.0346439853,
0.0244883485,
-0.0718694329,
0.0170644782,
-0.0209026132,
0.1171311662,
-0.0017013503,
0.0041138581,
0.0837503299,
0.0149505828,
-0.0368180536,
0.0061389869,
-0.0401941054,
0.0210584607,
-0.0045820051,
0.0118697742,
-0.0150004514,
0.0339370631,
0.0113015473,
0.0107563743,
-0.0297463816,
-0.0754756927,
-0.0029854812,
-0.0044469442,
-0.0079409853,
0.0857595205,
0.0177998617,
-0.0556218252,
0.0025119781,
-0.054340031,
0.0604196303,
-0.00988176,
0.0136181712,
0.0230951216,
0.0034804041,
-0.0669107437,
-0.0899389684,
0.0754786953,
0.0400000811,
-0.0071008406,
-0.0229827221,
-0.0467380211,
-0.0313422345,
-0.0201498568,
0.0360324718,
-0.0556677468,
-0.0090833493,
-0.0641110688,
-0.068593882,
-0.048436027,
0.0057957838,
0.0127100684,
-0.0084877387,
-0.0457244441,
-0.0019498257,
0.0507099777,
0.0308644734,
-0.0036930086,
0.0152942361,
0.039682541,
-0.0188899171,
-0.0760377571,
0.0157057084,
-5.616887064e-33,
0.004940941,
-0.0262154639,
0.0135086179,
0.049062565,
-0.0055654012,
-0.0011350306,
-0.0463086888,
-0.012515517,
0.0017590189,
-0.0182300191,
0.0195899829,
-0.0179560613,
-0.0127449967,
-0.0689907223,
0.0643344373,
0.0394975953,
0.0251917038,
0.0144717284,
0.0007425135,
0.0009949598,
0.0116935298,
0.0002798749,
0.0197400227,
-0.0509872884,
-0.0105759716,
-0.0224538017,
0.034592621,
-0.0065514049,
-0.0243766587,
0.0504470803,
0.0244718678,
0.0093298573,
-0.0207032617,
-0.0274899043,
-0.042356234,
0.0036146606,
-0.00952191,
0.0015919659,
0.0244861767,
-0.0179480165,
0.0224947743,
-0.0421297923,
0.0565850176,
0.010179461,
-0.0374072604,
0.0166228767,
0.006241268,
-0.0189856607,
-0.0409190618,
-0.0575011894,
-0.0328816362,
0.0250117853,
-0.0265082158,
0.0563500151,
0.0033083677,
-0.0222209301,
-0.0141196074,
0.0420233309,
0.0282157678,
0.0319258682,
0.0680820122,
0.0023575309,
0.0762302727,
0.0013009553,
0.0312775597,
0.0316724554,
0.0241105705,
0.0271057803,
-0.0163873024,
0.0015642855,
0.0329895876,
0.050656531,
0.0195233561,
0.022280667,
-0.0099387178,
-0.0031276238,
-0.0568571202,
0.0027136428,
0.0072558015,
-0.0137362145,
0.042844031,
0.0370152369,
0.0141240228,
-0.0361762121,
-0.0254268851,
0.0224205479,
-0.0139628332,
-0.0325600207,
-0.0089184549,
-0.0535661764,
-0.0228295997,
0.0119057838,
0.0352420472,
-0.0183869861,
-0.0346954651,
0.0222275686,
-0.0300466213,
0.0345002376,
0.0039884225,
0.0222461149,
-0.0767336562,
-0.0163101703,
-0.0438708179,
-0.0041049155,
0.0734235048,
0.0125763249,
-0.0174382683,
0.012099837,
-0.0649073273,
0.0093518496,
-0.0350971222,
0.0119580757,
0.0260275938,
-0.0018356278,
0.0096480921,
-0.0181779731,
0.0372018404,
0.0326541625,
0.0136846304,
-0.0182444844,
-0.0158342775,
0.0405104384,
0.0026868251,
0.0188072659,
-0.0075453199,
-0.0372162461,
-0.032219246,
0.0617073998,
0.0682401136,
-0.0065063369,
-0.0357611366,
-0.0009187039,
2.827e-7,
0.0452821292,
0.0637610331,
-0.0078869667,
0.0578797013,
0.0422489569,
0.0014409274,
-0.020137284,
-0.0112363286,
0.0075949109,
-0.0015973503,
-0.0449807197,
-0.0178758595,
0.049422469,
0.026368577,
-0.0195450615,
-0.000622195,
-0.0163860023,
-0.0322819911,
-0.0715069622,
-0.0321499519,
-0.0031176142,
-0.0096732723,
0.0251931623,
-0.0047531486,
-0.0331952609,
-0.0345634744,
0.0037567541,
-0.0554857403,
0.0479820818,
0.0703126863,
-0.0405372344,
0.0096565634,
0.0123644806,
0.0279169716,
0.0089129051,
-0.0518139936,
-0.0266761221,
0.0666579828,
0.0068265293,
0.0494379774,
0.0793695152,
-0.0518429913,
-0.0168736633,
-0.0530084856,
0.0199920181,
-0.0072681699,
-0.0389246754,
-0.0375406519,
0.0013384905,
-0.0447300002,
0.0030533159,
-0.0542608947,
0.0596231893,
0.009252294,
-0.0482752249,
-0.0139522161,
-0.0309252851,
0.0126613276,
-0.057835497,
0.0415904112,
-0.0483164415,
-0.0977491811,
-0.0138842957,
0.0065303021,
0.0087773949,
-0.016392706,
0.0400915854,
3.200391966e-34,
0.0533162802,
-0.0180073455,
0.000314918,
0.0529229827,
0.0121415658,
0.0120261498,
0.0045298729,
0.0123876687,
-0.0081786448,
-0.0293473769,
-0.0302512273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03734v1 | Conditional Prompt Tuning for Multimodal Fusion | 2023-11-28T11:05:20 | 2023-11-28T11:05:20 | Ruixiang Jiang, Lingbo Liu, Changwen Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We show that the representation of one modality can effectively guide the
prompting of another modality for parameter-efficient multimodal fusion.
Specifically, we first encode one modality and use its representation as a
prior to conditionally prompt all frozen layers of the other modality. This is
achieved by disentangling the vanilla prompt vectors into three types of
specialized prompts that adaptively capture global-level and instance-level
features. To better produce the instance-wise prompt, we introduce the mixture
of prompt experts (MoPE) to dynamically route each instance to the most
suitable prompt experts for encoding. We further study a regularization term to
avoid degenerated prompt expert routing. Thanks to our design, our method can
effectively transfer the pretrained knowledge in unimodal encoders for
downstream multimodal tasks. Compared with vanilla prompting, we show that our
MoPE-based conditional prompting is more expressive, thereby scales better with
training data and the total number of prompts. We also demonstrate that our
prompt tuning is architecture-agnostic, thereby offering high modularity.
Extensive experiments over three multimodal datasets demonstrate
state-of-the-art results, matching or surpassing the performance achieved
through fine-tuning, while only necessitating 0.7% of the trainable parameters.
Code will be released: https://github.com/songrise/ConditionalPrompt. | [
0.0165181123,
0.0654011443,
0.0333750769,
0.0163457002,
0.0072685871,
0.0056010615,
0.0554494038,
-0.0406043753,
-0.0385660715,
-0.0635272563,
-0.0535130538,
0.0018127178,
0.0134928664,
0.0560770966,
0.027518183,
-0.0758970529,
-0.0031618956,
-0.0056616366,
-0.0522836745,
-0.0098015964,
0.023501195,
0.0109430505,
-0.0466202311,
0.0579133034,
-0.0572734326,
0.0004200135,
-0.0469400771,
0.0456742495,
0.031930197,
-0.0180028621,
-0.0194580015,
0.0445585102,
0.0142025584,
-0.024545081,
0.0000022387,
-0.0479884185,
0.011192413,
-0.0414600745,
0.0127194785,
-0.040518634,
0.008224492,
-0.0382254459,
0.0152065605,
0.0014394886,
-0.0001393933,
-0.0170233045,
0.0947789997,
0.0224168599,
0.0421020538,
0.0483803414,
-0.0289047975,
-0.0062534409,
0.026923202,
-0.0162406806,
0.0015155986,
-0.0110781658,
-0.0015442733,
-0.0779018179,
-0.0150753213,
-0.0064114588,
-0.0476564541,
0.0215109959,
0.0194150545,
0.0031618571,
0.0395723544,
0.0334406309,
0.0525353439,
-0.0402726643,
-0.0869496018,
0.0659275949,
-0.0181066059,
0.0473372042,
-0.0292033292,
0.008422859,
0.0121595385,
0.009340615,
0.0033524861,
0.0023811609,
-0.0203401446,
-0.0064629791,
-0.0629877225,
0.0423229784,
-0.0005999582,
-0.0292362776,
-0.0215862989,
0.0084633324,
0.0227365382,
0.0230035223,
0.022893725,
-0.0017559425,
-0.0157631394,
-0.0577042885,
0.0187403765,
-0.0000645999,
-0.0710981414,
-0.0413205288,
-0.0672995225,
0.0290239658,
-0.0313350521,
0.0494712628,
0.0521629192,
0.0383050703,
-0.0903424919,
0.0361903459,
0.0026771934,
0.0150524992,
-0.0307091903,
0.0745123997,
-0.0326369479,
-0.0263622217,
-0.0458884351,
0.0212947503,
-0.0213578437,
-0.0343831033,
-0.0307475757,
-0.0193291251,
-0.0148822833,
0.0209669936,
-0.0317483768,
0.0060679135,
-0.0443095639,
0.0274546705,
-0.0127393594,
0.0019816332,
-0.033342801,
0.0583404154,
-0.0396405607,
0.0412853248,
0.0290515907,
-0.0407324359,
0.0024046281,
0.0177554935,
0.0096310852,
-0.0220140666,
0.0008703617,
0.0786013529,
-0.0630975366,
-0.0064065433,
-0.005300648,
-0.021761002,
-0.0155775547,
-0.0105787599,
0.0305856355,
0.0019893064,
0.0671504661,
-0.0249623023,
0.0311167911,
-0.0137664666,
-0.0131508727,
-0.0464038923,
0.0452026315,
0.0874107704,
-0.0174026527,
-0.0097355917,
0.0187281836,
-0.0096626198,
-0.0533284284,
0.0243714862,
0.0005668028,
0.0400960632,
0.0148940813,
-0.0094709303,
0.0233905315,
0.024993537,
0.0035006292,
0.0349290185,
-0.0035626944,
-0.0361675099,
0.0450715311,
0.0256083831,
0.0571867786,
0.0213599373,
-0.0175882448,
-0.0372839682,
0.0235087052,
-0.0108621288,
0.0035318576,
-0.0330075771,
0.0419608578,
-0.0053921142,
-0.0388571024,
-0.0067870193,
-0.0536959246,
0.0756241828,
-0.0588150695,
-0.0473207235,
0.069422029,
0.0763369203,
-0.0433492251,
-0.0282205753,
0.0239162762,
-0.0210834146,
-0.0207752809,
0.0179664493,
0.0117769456,
-0.0077814846,
-0.0594439693,
0.0017330173,
-0.017508531,
-0.0333455019,
0.0181671996,
-0.0102289012,
0.0063650594,
0.0235387813,
0.0043530865,
0.02416832,
0.0002361608,
-0.0181415044,
0.0058617122,
0.0230534412,
-0.0062300162,
-0.024387382,
0.1149051264,
-0.0491386801,
-0.0997954756,
-0.0132296542,
-0.0139924372,
0.0468953848,
-0.0580349267,
-0.0048164455,
0.0008675455,
0.0427475758,
0.0916275904,
0.0224847626,
0.0314412415,
0.0142427003,
0.0007408915,
0.032030493,
0.0419015624,
0.0043374384,
-0.0075835777,
-0.0087155625,
-0.0000157141,
-0.0463208705,
-0.0168591831,
0.0215990618,
-0.0767850876,
-0.04447015,
-0.0029924342,
-0.0414752439,
0.0183650013,
-0.0224198196,
-0.0431747735,
-0.0348588154,
0.0033162916,
0.0090571474,
0.0031231488,
-0.0000260839,
-0.0146404356,
0.0354672521,
-0.017438449,
0.0022130206,
0.0283114277,
-0.0668402761,
-0.0066403067,
0.0494354069,
0.0187280234,
0.0272858106,
-0.0025396845,
-0.0231930446,
0.0279628951,
-0.0130925449,
0.0121488245,
0.0096987076,
-0.0223073661,
-0.0166008864,
-0.0311471913,
-0.1128607541,
-0.0108284848,
-0.0181480162,
-0.0421992466,
-0.0127750877,
0.0220721886,
0.0061637103,
-0.0366235562,
-0.030514596,
0.0259749778,
-0.0106602581,
0.0288365055,
-0.0177637637,
0.0383578204,
0.0080931047,
-0.0077591175,
-0.0024279631,
0.0198060945,
0.0379231609,
-0.0290354472,
-0.0008901591,
-0.0187529791,
-0.0595830716,
-0.0415132605,
0.0174489822,
-0.0096376752,
-0.0273288861,
0.0143160997,
-0.0337611362,
0.0485862941,
0.0105384365,
0.0061321845,
-0.0026499671,
0.044181779,
-0.0215659086,
-0.0224805996,
0.0224908907,
-0.0082688518,
-0.0111507922,
-0.0137035642,
0.0331774764,
0.0055324887,
0.0214298181,
0.0308563001,
0.0063303285,
-0.0510212407,
-0.0013083937,
0.0383113846,
-0.0881344229,
-0.0562578291,
0.006154269,
0.0087044295,
0.0346262157,
-0.0547614358,
-0.0251608044,
0.0476636291,
-0.0288719796,
-0.0314541757,
0.0266718753,
0.011455141,
-0.0002977156,
0.0288702082,
-0.0169842839,
0.042031154,
0.0010232221,
-0.0140770189,
-0.0356409103,
-0.0115066618,
0.0001317669,
0.0221801624,
0.013193951,
-0.0000316089,
-0.0149701405,
-0.0228080861,
-0.0420565642,
-0.0236667152,
-0.044914417,
-0.0076627946,
0.0022202991,
-0.017127227,
-0.0014976177,
-0.0317715257,
-0.0205767117,
0.0166237466,
0.0557540767,
0.0043482687,
-0.0247124806,
-0.0263309758,
0.0262591057,
-0.0103619583,
0.0883098021,
-0.0616084002,
-0.0376207978,
0.0258389674,
0.021129312,
0.0416021049,
-0.0369326882,
-0.0562462695,
0.042390354,
0.0366639271,
0.0597008206,
-0.0036695243,
0.0420926288,
0.0809659734,
-0.0257013943,
0.0564254113,
0.0481388606,
0.0121415891,
-0.0576850772,
-0.0127146626,
0.0349959135,
0.0343855433,
0.0266379323,
-0.0016949893,
-0.0774906278,
-0.0889192894,
0.0020269803,
-0.010995768,
0.0343453288,
0.0190853104,
-0.0083672851,
-0.0568756051,
0.0267978199,
0.0185781904,
-0.0057260576,
-0.0207234733,
0.0044945083,
0.0213779192,
0.0032862604,
-0.0299540702,
0.0126661984,
0.0061520403,
-0.0054987147,
0.0345276594,
0.0724769682,
-0.0712761506,
-0.0130238384,
-0.0117829321,
0.0355475359,
0.0721582547,
0.0107023874,
-0.0080156839,
-0.0770996213,
0.0133791463,
0.0074070971,
0.0105975829,
-0.0213217903,
0.0567013249,
-0.0264976248,
0.0021813167,
0.0204731002,
0.0223806389,
0.0033141449,
-0.0194313303,
-0.0040995218,
0.0262458734,
-0.0512059294,
0.0248435773,
-0.0464422405,
0.0071089095,
0.0101367449,
0.0175119732,
-0.0081855953,
-0.0321131721,
0.0213642642,
-0.0125037245,
0.0070814644,
-0.0142001417,
0.0279105622,
0.0271650869,
-0.0073492583,
-0.0383392163,
-0.0387450457,
0.0019677661,
0.0247052144,
0.0524788238,
0.0175755322,
-0.0402872786,
-0.0747583956,
0.0552091636,
-0.0279936306,
0.0650596321,
0.0177091751,
0.0081908423,
-0.0647670329,
0.0185416546,
0.0279346593,
-0.0298554711,
0.0090855081,
0.0166057684,
-0.0238783974,
-0.0372993685,
-0.0531117022,
0.0252564009,
0.0060516801,
0.0481964573,
0.019645147,
-0.0467013009,
0.0804723501,
0.039772179,
-0.0125638247,
0.0234881826,
0.0640653372,
0.0068411948,
-0.0264202282,
-0.013540267,
-0.0728112534,
0.0108936653,
-0.0429180078,
-0.0123530943,
0.0096984431,
-0.058521457,
0.0369882323,
-0.0400092155,
0.0605069399,
-0.0504240058,
0.0254801996,
-0.048265323,
-0.008562875,
0.0296737161,
0.0046871868,
-0.0648314059,
0.03328095,
0.0050651156,
0.0212916322,
0.0486834496,
-0.0038570198,
0.0451514758,
0.0217234213,
-0.0440951884,
0.0132925762,
0.0403743014,
-0.0212943926,
-0.0230057389,
0.045869071,
-0.0073896819,
0.0576528087,
0.0153054735,
-0.0004992115,
-0.0169056151,
0.0890477002,
0.0299178306,
-0.0117481081,
-0.0165517014,
0.072973825,
-0.010258127,
-0.0013317415,
-0.0145350602,
0.02164069,
0.0272315387,
0.0440125391,
0.0079617994,
0.0317312591,
0.0170642398,
-0.0298577398,
0.0685285404,
0.025947297,
-0.0510264561,
0.064175643,
-0.0081195813,
0.0072946716,
-0.0178308375,
0.0110823885,
-0.0761727467,
0.0364661366,
-0.0459974259,
0.0354750566,
-0.0486011542,
0.0093592685,
0.0625069067,
0.0632756203,
-0.0125540392,
0.0398924462,
0.0133783547,
0.0064310646,
-0.0055808444,
0.0069428314,
-0.0259930827,
0.0185112823,
0.0571753792,
0.0173086692,
-0.0111748576,
-0.0414645672,
-0.0190125629,
-0.0457624979,
0.0238771569,
0.0058710403,
0.0631748959,
-6.566369484e-33,
-0.0217156317,
0.0048035486,
0.0159875378,
-0.0598340556,
-0.0072065652,
0.0018342211,
-0.0132853845,
0.0043886853,
0.0045567509,
-0.0100403307,
0.0074791941,
-0.0351361074,
-0.0022967369,
0.0278713275,
0.0123665417,
0.014438224,
0.0504531004,
0.0024885747,
-0.0142365973,
0.0110818427,
0.061273139,
0.0066451286,
0.0208984986,
-0.05663874,
-0.0027432486,
0.0333769731,
-0.088817656,
0.0096437614,
-0.0129386196,
0.0314306654,
-0.0257340744,
0.0192053095,
-0.009045097,
-0.005452658,
-0.0151985968,
0.0382113643,
-0.0428978428,
-0.0358131342,
-0.0198753327,
-0.0073061232,
-0.1127781868,
-0.0521666817,
0.0265077911,
-0.0036452485,
0.0081655476,
-0.0253962856,
0.0275279749,
0.0161548443,
0.0183463879,
-0.029463036,
-0.0091000879,
0.0050199013,
-0.0244597942,
-0.0637243688,
0.0198987387,
0.0994850844,
0.0355620794,
-0.0232132077,
-0.0247998238,
0.0174890142,
-0.0205314569,
0.0062262961,
0.0341790915,
0.0653291941,
-0.0286335275,
0.0679768994,
0.0268745385,
-0.0497130826,
0.0230649691,
0.0328643881,
0.0151716853,
0.0587365553,
0.0067264615,
0.0637708157,
0.0385191701,
-0.0155119896,
0.0284840669,
0.0756101906,
0.023226548,
-0.0069595599,
-0.0143785421,
0.0370778032,
0.0104971146,
-0.0124780182,
-0.0430252813,
-0.0356000587,
-0.0149471862,
-0.0349348858,
0.0479834527,
0.0398455411,
0.0134495348,
0.0072873025,
0.1001112536,
0.0044796853,
0.0207207818,
0.0135869747,
-0.0128987031,
0.0535861179,
0.0068113874,
-0.0282925908,
-0.004770203,
-0.0254247487,
0.1131218746,
-0.0731784105,
0.014115816,
0.0173150487,
-0.008680705,
0.0849180222,
-0.0157461111,
-0.0218187254,
-0.0122409062,
0.0408650748,
0.0080083562,
0.0104832593,
0.0274333395,
0.0108219245,
-0.051019147,
0.0087851407,
-0.0425667726,
0.0106443092,
-0.0494741574,
-0.0317009985,
0.0119045805,
0.0368775167,
-0.0125993388,
0.0064416514,
-0.0443380252,
-0.1047778651,
0.0060651158,
-0.0368025079,
-0.0309685841,
0.028433308,
2.955e-7,
-0.0379811227,
-0.0162915234,
-0.0150293447,
-0.0512984283,
0.0190717727,
0.0583718084,
-0.0332517922,
0.0476521067,
0.0137259988,
-0.0833718255,
0.0064777564,
0.0218810644,
0.027978735,
0.0277444944,
-0.0475340821,
-0.036754109,
0.000901129,
0.0088826949,
-0.0478181466,
0.0145710967,
0.0537876338,
0.090498656,
0.0140335467,
-0.0143820876,
0.0457341224,
0.0078272074,
0.0605985001,
-0.017615879,
-0.0180724114,
-0.0399212874,
0.036419604,
-0.0331075825,
-0.0020200065,
0.0226948299,
-0.0076543745,
0.0053976309,
0.03018477,
0.0254352447,
-0.028363036,
-0.0818955153,
-0.0042398986,
0.0673188716,
-0.0379743949,
0.00768949,
0.0652298182,
-0.0184696522,
-0.0389485769,
-0.0382950529,
-0.0371763632,
0.0133974729,
0.0184996035,
-0.0141825546,
-0.042821046,
0.0109330146,
0.0210431423,
0.0161769986,
-0.0396523401,
-0.0774726868,
-0.0134508545,
-0.00405272,
-0.0348986685,
-0.0434367843,
-0.0163734369,
-0.0149303097,
0.0333407223,
-0.0628976598,
-0.0409432612,
2.372114998e-34,
-0.0046424679,
-0.0126521708,
0.0495626107,
-0.0231002457,
0.0166726578,
-0.0296852998,
-0.0393963605,
-0.013726349,
0.0291214455,
-0.0446815118,
-0.0486345813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16678v1 | Entity-Aspect-Opinion-Sentiment Quadruple Extraction for Fine-grained Sentiment Analysis | 2023-11-28T10:50:00 | 2023-11-28T10:50:00 | Dan Ma, Jun Xu, Zongyu Wang, Xuezhi Cao, Yunsen Xian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Product reviews often contain a large number of implicit aspects and
object-attribute co-existence cases. Unfortunately, many existing studies in
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) have overlooked this issue, which can
make it difficult to extract opinions comprehensively and fairly. In this
paper, we propose a new task called Entity-Aspect-Opinion-Sentiment Quadruple
Extraction (EASQE), which aims to hierarchically decompose aspect terms into
entities and aspects to avoid information loss, non-exclusive annotations, and
opinion misunderstandings in ABSA tasks. To facilitate research in this new
task, we have constructed four datasets (Res14-EASQE, Res15-EASQE, Res16-EASQE,
and Lap14-EASQE) based on the SemEval Restaurant and Laptop datasets. We have
also proposed a novel two-stage sequence-tagging based Trigger-Opinion
framework as the baseline for the EASQE task. Empirical evaluations show that
our Trigger-Opinion framework can generate satisfactory EASQE results and can
also be applied to other ABSA tasks, significantly outperforming
state-of-the-art methods. We have made the four datasets and source code of
Trigger-Opinion publicly available to facilitate further research in this area. | [
0.0131956106,
0.0809520781,
0.0070723575,
0.0497107357,
-0.0377751291,
0.0338117629,
-0.0044240355,
0.0119319884,
-0.0290927589,
-0.0765436515,
-0.0405845121,
0.0008930415,
-0.0414391831,
0.0432471856,
-0.0250893887,
0.013882949,
0.0282755401,
0.0534595959,
0.0321994983,
0.0317449905,
0.0251550376,
0.0317603871,
-0.0086063873,
-0.0132140229,
-0.0335733593,
-0.016641289,
0.0134113654,
-0.0233015697,
0.0243757889,
-0.0350777395,
0.0301152673,
0.0220921449,
-0.0260035209,
0.0005172399,
0.0000021294,
0.0058113737,
-0.0292212591,
-0.0070159636,
0.0568336137,
0.0030522004,
0.0331520289,
-0.026905898,
0.0309549719,
-0.0161542539,
-0.0590209179,
-0.0472152643,
-0.009059445,
0.1177532747,
0.0354387909,
0.0449337885,
-0.0384300537,
-0.0616076216,
-0.0394917354,
-0.0066023506,
-0.0344865359,
-0.0428911634,
0.0056231013,
-0.0257287752,
-0.0341522992,
0.0606542006,
0.0285674911,
0.0011626082,
-0.0088014957,
0.021292761,
-0.0147037543,
0.0116259288,
0.0097612115,
0.0053880531,
-0.0079407003,
0.0548250526,
0.0479802564,
0.0289797243,
0.0095761931,
-0.0192899685,
0.0040122541,
-0.0382579118,
0.0304027479,
-0.0335771926,
-0.0029121172,
0.0523226745,
0.0165016539,
0.0054376833,
-0.015394792,
-0.0063165659,
0.0089196814,
0.0617717281,
-0.0222472958,
-0.0502681136,
0.0242478326,
0.0882225782,
0.0046666418,
0.0038965237,
0.0109871477,
-0.013067713,
-0.0001684387,
0.0336493291,
0.0062959823,
0.0487673618,
0.0206649099,
-0.044774197,
-0.004329097,
-0.0208929069,
-0.0408734679,
0.0353775173,
-0.0110839754,
-0.0516914502,
0.0310410578,
-0.0366857275,
-0.0278489348,
0.0368863493,
-0.0746455938,
0.0232795067,
0.0197701883,
0.0681839138,
-0.0486154594,
0.0160229858,
-0.0437408276,
-0.0523180701,
-0.03884748,
-0.0020485618,
0.0345348977,
0.0110306032,
0.0319320224,
0.0203607753,
-0.0114546306,
0.0530294441,
-0.0482352227,
0.0630467087,
-0.04050624,
-0.0011605952,
0.0053323768,
-0.006824662,
0.0145461513,
-0.0088156955,
0.0175587218,
-0.0039160722,
0.0186339486,
-0.0545797683,
-0.0460872874,
-0.0349617638,
-0.0272997897,
-0.035234414,
-0.0482429191,
-0.052307196,
0.0488491096,
-0.0211881511,
-0.011954125,
0.0133795897,
0.023170555,
-0.0013251732,
-0.0150463376,
0.041732002,
-0.046361696,
-0.0215560701,
-0.036156062,
0.0034535592,
0.0519202612,
0.0416030064,
-0.0316942781,
0.0306864288,
0.0446907766,
0.0169619787,
-0.0197290257,
-0.0014025421,
0.0004929674,
-0.0070388676,
0.0350879394,
-0.0088285301,
-0.0960373506,
-0.074267447,
0.0009168453,
0.0340178199,
0.0112405261,
-0.0174608957,
0.0196447652,
-0.0387010872,
-0.0535509847,
0.0635350496,
-0.0062330733,
-0.0014350644,
-0.0166053362,
0.0144101521,
-0.0011607608,
0.0139028449,
-0.0038743839,
-0.0100463331,
0.0187366251,
-0.0150446957,
-0.0058212327,
-0.0742744356,
0.0071399631,
-0.0223273877,
0.0404970311,
-0.0143452333,
0.0625663623,
-0.0027734204,
-0.0600248799,
-0.0141498307,
0.0432502851,
-0.0337776467,
-0.0390799791,
-0.0091124605,
0.0489922687,
0.0578120761,
-0.017918013,
-0.0210011527,
-0.0179616828,
-0.0005614071,
-0.0384638421,
-0.0174697917,
0.0359986611,
-0.0275527164,
-0.0029469687,
-0.0093141794,
-0.0156394634,
-0.0061778375,
0.0200931802,
-0.0338909067,
-0.0073854425,
0.039028734,
-0.0123445261,
0.0312125757,
0.029841302,
-0.0037823305,
0.0155482693,
-0.0283048041,
0.0215142537,
0.0224495735,
0.0222823434,
0.0768437907,
-0.0110671492,
0.0034115484,
0.0393191241,
-0.036921531,
-0.0593414381,
-0.0072597433,
0.0037088823,
-0.0340057127,
0.0136739612,
0.0210974962,
-0.0317080989,
-0.0060018944,
-0.0358692259,
0.007148318,
-0.0227720179,
0.0346275382,
0.0055169719,
-0.0154117942,
-0.0140312565,
0.0266481861,
0.0355295204,
-0.005168878,
0.0508053154,
-0.0185893793,
-0.0017221716,
-0.0659311414,
-0.0553999469,
-0.0047211722,
0.0374545716,
-0.033579275,
-0.0203103926,
0.0310923215,
0.008132929,
0.023899924,
0.0245073661,
-0.0488845482,
0.0103892982,
-0.1051399484,
0.0033871823,
0.0039859265,
0.0614049882,
0.0044477535,
-0.0283148047,
0.0161959752,
0.0314195566,
-0.0311004445,
0.0072823968,
-0.0486663319,
0.0104579944,
0.027956469,
0.0338533893,
0.0312075596,
-0.0319196135,
-0.009895782,
-0.0314790644,
-0.0115954457,
-0.0015883012,
-0.0425940566,
-0.0214411989,
0.0388535522,
-0.0189030804,
0.0008601516,
0.0172731392,
0.0016368512,
-0.0251321793,
-0.022428507,
-0.0283401981,
-0.0024129408,
-0.0031834564,
0.0570488907,
0.0119082676,
-0.0235721804,
-0.0005810001,
0.0296622124,
-0.0822418183,
0.0262273904,
0.0146661857,
-0.0052120825,
0.0272937678,
0.0516114943,
-0.0006220738,
-0.0164483245,
-0.0242910627,
0.0066341273,
-0.0187111013,
-0.0094137527,
0.0133618545,
0.0412909202,
0.0045821979,
0.0332981497,
0.0037374203,
0.013594918,
0.0654397532,
0.0339362025,
0.025701981,
-0.0395230465,
0.0168034211,
-0.0411221981,
0.0707798973,
-0.0525957607,
0.0010201866,
0.0220546387,
0.0308971312,
0.022787096,
-0.0281310007,
-0.0272930283,
-0.0235974509,
0.0536958687,
0.0011094422,
0.0051998179,
0.0204964839,
-0.0449908115,
0.0554096662,
-0.0113463746,
-0.0332873464,
-0.0010691541,
-0.0050817048,
0.0024785872,
0.012748302,
-0.027237257,
-0.0349482372,
-0.0194648765,
0.0130130351,
-0.0235955231,
0.0297379829,
0.0689977854,
0.0661547631,
-0.0375926197,
0.0392575115,
0.0040251561,
0.0045500556,
0.0915648416,
-0.0323201604,
0.0013355161,
0.004109933,
-0.0163587313,
0.0425325036,
0.0064651188,
-0.0088956617,
-0.0548188724,
0.0393883958,
-0.0567628741,
-0.0124380114,
0.0902573988,
0.0418009646,
-0.0367749371,
0.0206375625,
0.0480049178,
-0.0398232266,
0.0077473233,
0.0032725299,
-0.0934669673,
-0.0490729697,
-0.0435940102,
0.0355547629,
-0.0058398638,
-0.0216224138,
0.0248112008,
-0.1195713952,
0.0316974148,
-0.0264520533,
-0.0443285219,
-0.0871142969,
-0.0301611628,
0.0291516148,
-0.0250110831,
0.0178287178,
-0.0416507907,
0.0077831745,
0.0121063422,
-0.0128575005,
-0.0106111644,
-0.0051318337,
0.0840976611,
0.0060121492,
0.003954031,
0.0229419544,
0.0319453627,
0.0066373032,
-0.0158269089,
0.0199535564,
-0.0829245821,
-0.0057792105,
-0.0300992336,
0.0338184945,
-0.0506437719,
-0.0342256948,
-0.0119758211,
0.0052539785,
-0.0634508431,
0.0309139751,
0.0136865247,
0.0499505214,
0.0190445725,
-0.0435937308,
-0.0236073732,
-0.0027810175,
0.0233534817,
0.0568883531,
-0.0117341261,
-0.0649912953,
-0.0262838043,
0.0185936168,
-0.0425069146,
-0.0494651757,
-0.026850149,
-0.0048334645,
-0.0394136868,
-0.0405336171,
-0.0844271258,
-0.0715558827,
0.0089883646,
0.0155750196,
-0.0215531569,
-0.0046623717,
0.033675395,
0.0177581515,
-0.0395749807,
-0.0054823328,
0.0275462363,
0.0143803786,
0.0204304159,
-0.0118581681,
0.1017208174,
0.0252560936,
-0.0274333116,
0.0128924921,
-0.0294494219,
-0.0445935242,
-0.0049779285,
0.0447077192,
-0.0036632868,
0.0250135791,
-0.0013065477,
0.0038525409,
-0.0306070205,
0.0668998286,
-0.0361387506,
-0.0213013887,
0.0508584641,
0.0623474829,
0.0215304401,
0.050007239,
-0.027416436,
0.0412993841,
0.0126131065,
0.0454640724,
-0.0420435481,
-0.0427130274,
0.0233234763,
0.0159262381,
0.0688764825,
0.0086579528,
0.0233843736,
-0.0265077129,
0.0008831188,
-0.0208669379,
-0.0359738059,
-0.0529724285,
0.0007901451,
-0.0193080548,
-0.0021452655,
-0.0788785145,
0.0423201323,
0.0419877656,
0.0456617624,
-0.0317665897,
0.0541783832,
-0.0134886056,
0.0056807231,
-0.0486640856,
-0.0177254509,
-0.0007340017,
-0.022152232,
-0.0027913339,
-0.0320176035,
-0.0334232524,
0.0478181839,
0.0249071997,
0.02863729,
-0.0588640794,
0.0399913825,
0.0465975367,
0.0715295523,
-0.0132519156,
-0.0211353283,
-0.0187497195,
-0.0481451564,
0.0835433826,
-0.0259784013,
-0.0287125222,
0.013398963,
0.0342017747,
-0.0371710174,
0.0260609165,
0.0415054299,
0.0138579011,
-0.0317360163,
-0.0074135489,
0.0437161624,
-0.1043264568,
0.0210016482,
0.0439480096,
-0.0322354995,
-0.0319296941,
0.0052058315,
0.0121314842,
-0.0222632885,
0.003078049,
0.0174947269,
-0.0705816075,
-0.0261379331,
0.0042058774,
-0.0112060318,
-0.0114073073,
0.0301624034,
0.0210286584,
0.052579768,
0.0621248782,
0.0297189374,
-0.0759867951,
-0.0278049558,
-0.0212606583,
-0.0148616973,
0.0134338122,
-6.725054609e-33,
-0.0075798365,
-0.0275352485,
-0.0488708615,
0.0465625711,
-0.0158189628,
0.0097787492,
-0.0092036165,
0.0319220461,
0.0021868448,
0.0576476082,
0.0282684024,
0.0074585374,
0.0053832824,
0.0157780256,
0.0455075055,
-0.024700433,
0.0312155187,
-0.0120559605,
0.0240216814,
0.0295104589,
0.0539052002,
0.0267988443,
0.0879938304,
-0.1153329164,
0.0487523675,
-0.0117852977,
-0.0395042486,
0.00002021,
0.0088657299,
0.048192028,
-0.0311894082,
0.0475015864,
0.0327073261,
-0.0619063713,
0.0142565779,
-0.0111362254,
-0.0596922711,
-0.0000043639,
-0.0183129758,
-0.0129078329,
-0.0282398295,
-0.013084569,
0.0026317567,
0.0288006123,
-0.0078464346,
-0.0015537289,
0.0002166258,
-0.0415584035,
0.0138220498,
-0.1160537079,
-0.0506246537,
0.0267551653,
-0.0095417369,
0.0112883952,
0.0659091547,
0.0061401119,
0.0109975822,
0.0299024787,
-0.0319727696,
0.0120937657,
-0.0389838293,
0.0008010675,
-0.0179692805,
-0.0662767515,
0.0167854652,
0.0585738719,
0.0197462179,
0.0010664486,
-0.0242006443,
0.0591162741,
-0.0161247011,
0.0672371313,
-0.0139908465,
0.0324847549,
0.0420424864,
-0.0316391625,
-0.0355314314,
0.0237234198,
0.0270805527,
-0.0351024121,
0.0214366727,
-0.0045584724,
-0.0550050586,
0.0114008039,
0.0569655374,
-0.0257529356,
-0.0411823355,
-0.027487373,
-0.0092315609,
0.0292952862,
-0.024786137,
0.0619965568,
-0.0200651567,
-0.0289318133,
-0.0299953297,
0.0036739893,
-0.0440384373,
0.018016763,
-0.0021145092,
-0.0203854758,
-0.0511590391,
-0.0309754964,
-0.0367993154,
0.0349886268,
0.0206345506,
-0.0202732123,
0.0749589801,
-0.0019658294,
-0.0848271251,
-0.0073722838,
-0.0051410012,
0.0055640447,
-0.0159532279,
0.0465634651,
0.0049937936,
0.0010942274,
-0.0122355018,
0.1148877591,
0.0173755009,
0.0519843362,
-0.005682135,
0.0310800448,
0.030615015,
0.0029014149,
0.0227960907,
-0.0477790199,
0.0208346751,
-0.043434035,
-0.0472350717,
-0.0198611226,
-0.0338770933,
0.0108230021,
2.871e-7,
0.0432104729,
0.04406932,
-0.0037823939,
-0.0068310215,
0.0075242952,
0.0670610666,
0.0134159168,
0.0224798564,
-0.0295599382,
-0.0073299659,
0.0268879831,
0.0147078484,
0.0003960081,
0.0404616892,
-0.0325729959,
0.0431386977,
0.0024224347,
-0.022079803,
-0.0284083411,
0.0109459357,
0.1073431075,
0.0601381473,
0.0256946106,
0.004796267,
-0.0268525034,
0.0632587895,
0.020778032,
-0.0171586443,
-0.0366895795,
0.0121209864,
-0.0290496554,
0.012712664,
-0.0280027241,
-0.0425668471,
-0.0282474663,
0.0089245038,
0.0185030214,
0.0609352477,
0.0264853686,
-0.0705742016,
0.0416384749,
0.0107922209,
0.0375945382,
0.007203619,
0.0522155017,
-0.035415981,
-0.0651338622,
-0.0717616454,
-0.0449112207,
0.0595264621,
0.0077947229,
-0.0047987141,
0.004887715,
0.0360243618,
-0.024615122,
-0.0394325554,
-0.0632674247,
-0.069064118,
0.0287433863,
0.0626154914,
0.028756531,
-0.0213467479,
0.0409406908,
0.0305003133,
-0.0281783752,
-0.0494958907,
-0.0026373432,
2.302484407e-34,
0.0250896271,
-0.0228931643,
0.0005149537,
0.0588806868,
0.0014667452,
-0.0223706551,
-0.0740324408,
-0.0341764614,
0.0002987999,
0.0144742988,
0.0199020356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16675v1 | A Distribution-Based Threshold for Determining Sentence Similarity | 2023-11-28T10:42:35 | 2023-11-28T10:42:35 | Gioele Cadamuro, Marco Gruppo | cs.CL | cs.CL | We hereby present a solution to a semantic textual similarity (STS) problem
in which it is necessary to match two sentences containing, as the only
distinguishing factor, highly specific information (such as names, addresses,
identification codes), and from which we need to derive a definition for when
they are similar and when they are not. The solution revolves around the use of
a neural network, based on the siamese architecture, to create the
distributions of the distances between similar and dissimilar pairs of
sentences. The goal of these distributions is to find a discriminating factor,
that we call "threshold", which represents a well-defined quantity that can be
used to distinguish vector distances of similar pairs from vector distances of
dissimilar pairs in new predictions and later analyses. In addition, we
developed a way to score the predictions by combining attributes from both the
distributions' features and the way the distance function works. Finally, we
generalize the results showing that they can be transferred to a wider range of
domains by applying the system discussed to a well-known and widely used
benchmark dataset for STS problems. | [
0.0168385375,
0.0483338609,
-0.0277364478,
0.024673786,
-0.0757069588,
0.0066995947,
0.010861556,
-0.0016099862,
-0.0201556869,
-0.0371687822,
0.0017011579,
-0.003301641,
0.0067775133,
0.0042669922,
-0.0189545583,
-0.0184810087,
0.0114351744,
0.073022075,
0.0033291359,
0.0225296542,
0.0270155314,
-0.0019028047,
0.0335088372,
0.0443602353,
-0.0193954557,
-0.0043587345,
0.0213709511,
0.0078257937,
0.0597990118,
-0.028293211,
0.0437069349,
0.0138309272,
-0.0024486855,
-0.0039850418,
0.0000019254,
-0.0406334996,
0.0190359876,
-0.0239620414,
0.033759091,
-0.0401682854,
0.0052621872,
0.027156651,
0.0237563401,
0.0161583498,
-0.0319520831,
-0.0340720043,
0.0324637368,
0.0523338355,
0.0337169766,
0.0453711525,
-0.0564640872,
-0.0605571009,
0.0608748458,
0.0201655142,
0.0268799961,
-0.009979031,
0.0284329318,
-0.0039378395,
-0.0188954957,
-0.0146254897,
0.0252674501,
0.0282329209,
0.0214197896,
0.0176950023,
0.0335994475,
0.0473210588,
-0.0499719605,
0.0242472757,
-0.0017103525,
0.035381943,
-0.0488997325,
-0.0808716193,
0.0322728455,
0.0021297892,
0.0091899307,
0.0116519658,
0.0084718168,
-0.0261527803,
-0.0311451033,
0.0435190946,
-0.0066676703,
0.0499368161,
0.0066119963,
0.0131891975,
-0.0094459699,
0.0104095386,
0.0013584265,
-0.0363335833,
-0.0164368656,
-0.0080631003,
-0.0323625691,
-0.0054164603,
0.0478903204,
0.0232113767,
0.0084639303,
-0.0251659527,
-0.0364920311,
-0.0639358684,
0.0199375208,
-0.0966877192,
0.0606593937,
-0.0090533765,
-0.0343958475,
0.0258690864,
-0.0412115119,
0.0734488368,
0.0019344387,
0.0361929312,
-0.0416196994,
-0.0058300663,
-0.1005637199,
0.0013203563,
-0.0076214611,
0.0278356634,
0.0172849149,
-0.0539421849,
-0.0146914981,
-0.0037891495,
-0.0005091823,
0.0236259364,
-0.0187964942,
0.0093986066,
0.0070157275,
0.0272119623,
-0.0068786191,
-0.0318161733,
-0.0699065924,
0.0083892019,
-0.0279228203,
-0.0102920188,
0.0220563151,
0.0388019085,
0.0278293528,
-0.0144697977,
-0.0087406524,
-0.0071874666,
-0.0012027388,
-0.0370030254,
-0.0434052162,
0.0068967394,
-0.0086360853,
-0.034271419,
0.0002080878,
-0.0810731649,
0.0285360646,
-0.0099811088,
-0.0111608515,
-0.0420593843,
-0.0110623064,
0.0433249436,
-0.0067776009,
0.0676110536,
0.0613895543,
0.0157441217,
0.0495439246,
-0.0138186943,
0.0263086744,
-0.0122595597,
0.0038128581,
0.0080578392,
0.0521809906,
0.0743706077,
-0.0023144532,
-0.0193716008,
-0.0227220077,
-0.0230334699,
-0.0219416413,
0.0177741013,
0.0112151317,
0.0325031132,
0.0033346149,
0.0401083492,
-0.0449894629,
-0.0146128936,
0.0475321971,
0.1186256111,
0.0167888068,
0.0152121931,
0.0497580841,
0.053481508,
-0.0463726521,
0.0029242698,
-0.0082871802,
-0.0231786948,
0.0110857803,
-0.0046134535,
-0.0266896244,
0.0191015787,
-0.0697537661,
-0.0362682976,
0.0126376599,
-0.0499871224,
-0.0024475879,
-0.0634239018,
0.0064491909,
-0.0009928654,
0.0006053398,
0.04439684,
-0.0116656004,
-0.0252895188,
-0.0258491524,
0.0033462269,
-0.0360513516,
0.0193509739,
0.0229363348,
-0.0420083404,
0.0331990346,
0.0016773011,
-0.0291005224,
0.0244354643,
0.0418345369,
0.0130692311,
-0.0072127366,
-0.0732798725,
-0.002072772,
-0.0096663432,
0.0298104584,
-0.0007961902,
0.0152406301,
0.051449392,
0.0598485731,
-0.0112718763,
-0.0090626804,
0.0519930385,
-0.0118501848,
0.0207896214,
0.0179498736,
0.0360485837,
0.0013624001,
0.0017331006,
0.000578225,
0.0227475315,
0.017713394,
-0.0564717427,
-0.0529024303,
-0.0046205237,
-0.0346697234,
-0.0159452595,
0.0448715277,
-0.0789246857,
0.0474085622,
0.0860142037,
-0.0185535233,
-0.0036750925,
0.008822185,
-0.0607856922,
-0.0375058576,
-0.0681471825,
0.0390448496,
-0.045762945,
0.0345124081,
-0.0580515303,
0.0857174695,
0.0058502094,
0.0464899354,
-0.0468706004,
-0.0119504919,
0.0485550612,
-0.0119947577,
-0.0045419703,
-0.0657729879,
-0.008056283,
0.0582937673,
0.017402146,
0.0201591123,
0.0100394245,
-0.0626924783,
-0.0312294289,
0.0352662504,
0.0014626225,
0.0306154042,
0.0351398773,
-0.0120884804,
-0.0030227327,
-0.0203599688,
-0.0344250239,
0.007290137,
0.0086922674,
-0.0261798445,
0.0991372392,
0.0002043793,
-0.0561238304,
-0.0498928241,
-0.0095886001,
-0.0114510022,
0.0753602609,
0.0099951532,
-0.0195630603,
-0.0590884015,
0.0647074804,
-0.0363171585,
0.0225376375,
0.0036730538,
-0.008767019,
-0.0064282059,
-0.0174222067,
0.035765551,
0.0466623455,
0.0223610774,
-0.0141051849,
0.028813839,
0.0423907824,
-0.0534698255,
-0.0217821803,
-0.0510891378,
0.0422191396,
-0.0380204245,
-0.0252952185,
0.0393527187,
-0.0017343804,
0.0312968194,
0.0007513542,
-0.0322738364,
0.0331451669,
0.0468421169,
0.0197253823,
-0.0283270963,
-0.0024756775,
0.0103886519,
0.0318391137,
-0.0108742518,
-0.0237431768,
0.0602118708,
-0.0209289808,
0.0645924583,
-0.0805591345,
-0.0306244064,
-0.0619934648,
0.0523369461,
0.0155828046,
0.0178306364,
0.0239225775,
0.0081798024,
-0.0110678831,
-0.0199982226,
0.0027474125,
0.0007608746,
0.0078514833,
0.0177220237,
0.0017175467,
-0.0200734492,
-0.0222767293,
-0.0244141109,
-0.0400316417,
-0.011185539,
0.0038506074,
-0.0078622736,
-0.0117513537,
-0.0568425506,
-0.0023668611,
-0.0425845794,
0.0519828312,
-0.0029884398,
-0.029753983,
-0.0347921625,
0.0899891406,
0.0107549531,
-0.0116167134,
-0.0219178163,
-0.0128050447,
0.0144515056,
0.0128540732,
-0.0052535562,
0.063469097,
-0.0415952206,
-0.0187346637,
0.0042857835,
-0.0531800315,
-0.0264200736,
0.0075166388,
0.0131109441,
0.0082188286,
-0.0311978161,
0.1100613251,
0.0555526987,
-0.0281430166,
-0.01163287,
-0.0164016597,
0.0097047826,
0.025767481,
0.00785881,
-0.0225771442,
0.0061779367,
0.0103986943,
-0.0101929996,
-0.021481242,
-0.0046153823,
-0.0158232562,
-0.0358636528,
0.0137964161,
-0.0156239877,
-0.0557177179,
-0.0576378591,
-0.0406416282,
0.0130439587,
0.0237071626,
-0.0080957394,
-0.0438245088,
-0.0038946304,
-0.0343952551,
-0.0319645852,
-0.0066402056,
-0.0426466949,
0.0091269687,
-0.09130463,
0.0097484374,
0.0282865837,
0.0903103575,
0.0204218663,
-0.0542250164,
-0.0320585556,
-0.108928062,
0.0055502271,
0.017452104,
0.0692203566,
-0.0155000109,
-0.0007659788,
-0.0424833782,
0.0079601519,
-0.0304662585,
-0.0070079821,
0.0284791011,
0.0497210324,
-0.0420819372,
-0.0482503138,
-0.0272873081,
0.0130185075,
-0.0066710184,
0.0713027343,
0.0492923371,
-0.0045196139,
-0.0680661574,
0.0346411131,
0.0403683037,
-0.0209037177,
0.0087301284,
0.018478822,
0.0162073206,
-0.0372010916,
-0.0651706308,
-0.0232635625,
-0.0744515955,
-0.0176782068,
-0.0182175562,
-0.0162085332,
0.0271351095,
-0.0450619832,
-0.0624668673,
-0.012791953,
-0.0194866825,
0.0368209966,
-0.0137093365,
0.0719895437,
0.0404926836,
-0.0071415305,
-0.0654526949,
-0.0310595632,
-0.0720193386,
-0.031326469,
-0.0563999452,
-0.0500981882,
0.0075318809,
0.0045750467,
-0.0136096729,
-0.0524306297,
0.0233006962,
0.0660811514,
0.0054821703,
-0.0002359993,
0.0298980307,
-0.046261996,
0.0031578762,
0.0313799381,
0.0046021244,
0.0675734133,
0.0244783349,
-0.0216292404,
0.0026202507,
-0.0469203889,
0.0057909084,
0.0188669693,
0.0230825786,
0.0266088657,
-0.01369459,
-0.0388247333,
-0.0034696693,
-0.0052621053,
0.0233085807,
-0.0115870051,
-0.0356345735,
0.0278763026,
0.0400608517,
-0.0231100637,
0.0233704951,
0.0261247624,
0.0157026015,
-0.0588557795,
0.0032145861,
0.0213898569,
0.08181905,
-0.0329947583,
-0.0398235917,
-0.0462667495,
-0.0512537248,
-0.0054556807,
0.0132604679,
-0.0231325943,
0.0333381295,
0.0492450483,
0.0051375679,
-0.0407800302,
0.057077039,
-0.0685543865,
-0.0141458614,
-0.0035618937,
0.0116076348,
0.0353961661,
-0.0085674888,
0.0082214111,
-0.0325523801,
-0.0034429717,
-0.0123257097,
0.036383599,
0.0055340864,
-0.0107887704,
0.00414248,
0.0039788978,
0.0008317077,
0.0147240292,
0.0474752598,
-0.0145808104,
0.0333951041,
-0.0049358048,
-0.07375101,
-0.0508444272,
-0.0204110965,
0.0140475566,
0.0403742008,
0.0026214058,
-0.0258262102,
-0.0191315673,
-0.0182572771,
0.0662361458,
0.0088509982,
0.0044066091,
0.0511596724,
0.0513492264,
0.0239828378,
-0.0049190414,
-0.0308385771,
0.0018523867,
-0.015056693,
0.0010271691,
-0.0254016891,
-0.0754315481,
-5.46360554e-33,
0.0123681687,
0.0021523172,
-0.0246707797,
0.0801595002,
-0.0518825352,
0.0306031741,
-0.0281524807,
-0.065965116,
-0.0569277592,
0.0238497667,
0.0234143566,
0.0072945668,
0.0149884075,
0.006769076,
-0.0452972315,
-0.0351992585,
0.0259793252,
-0.0011494451,
0.0020402931,
0.0068264692,
0.0333502144,
0.0263800938,
0.0014306165,
-0.0587459765,
-0.0224090908,
-0.0433870554,
0.0193326436,
0.021904137,
0.042009946,
0.0513184667,
-0.0334176011,
0.0611820444,
0.0362667367,
-0.0001493572,
0.0009117789,
0.0551689006,
-0.0667904839,
-0.0864284635,
-0.0383206345,
-0.0400954112,
0.0297656655,
-0.0037926873,
0.0378419794,
0.0014429155,
-0.0369799249,
-0.0175692122,
0.1045017391,
-0.0129992049,
0.0032761793,
-0.0232217312,
-0.0520912893,
0.0302852541,
-0.0008826271,
-0.002498297,
0.0239584204,
0.026502341,
-0.0039552585,
0.0126838777,
-0.0198127218,
0.0229571685,
-0.0358516797,
0.0200651642,
-0.0143952249,
-0.0189442411,
0.0014119924,
0.0839211345,
0.0722408593,
-0.0441070683,
0.011197078,
-0.042353034,
0.0283593275,
-0.0074430373,
0.0458329692,
0.0349632353,
0.0162812192,
-0.0343290716,
-0.0805884898,
0.0214522574,
0.0011764665,
0.021719994,
0.045574639,
0.0034128891,
-0.0936011076,
-0.0370719284,
-0.0264960323,
-0.0135049317,
-0.0293110497,
-0.0076728505,
0.0527285486,
0.0145652238,
0.0280809738,
0.0396680459,
-0.0368230455,
-0.0416748337,
0.0111713735,
0.0298747979,
0.0192635357,
0.0197529905,
0.0030873963,
-0.0055415533,
-0.0108663151,
-0.0387315676,
-0.0083935363,
0.0426297337,
0.0399683341,
0.0018848093,
0.060285233,
-0.010644001,
-0.0533311144,
-0.0131151918,
0.0193949714,
-0.0615581796,
-0.0599181242,
0.0270400103,
-0.0381540135,
0.0351840556,
-0.0050450056,
0.0367283225,
0.0516022481,
-0.012155504,
-0.0198297594,
0.0053245141,
0.0369566381,
0.0299587455,
0.0072751925,
0.0183642656,
-0.0921188816,
0.0275958069,
0.0179054011,
-0.0335292928,
-0.0036046843,
-0.0214822572,
2.635e-7,
0.0276285578,
-0.0057450905,
0.0479581431,
0.004391179,
0.007438805,
0.0280502923,
0.0435037054,
0.0361173786,
-0.0179374013,
0.0225335062,
0.0401518643,
0.0254644547,
0.0168003999,
0.0181494188,
-0.0822355375,
0.0520237349,
-0.0910583586,
-0.076765798,
-0.0855932087,
0.0133046471,
0.0791723728,
0.0414444953,
0.0362699404,
-0.0154100992,
0.0159123726,
-0.0568618886,
-0.0024500838,
-0.0324255042,
0.0272149649,
0.0376738608,
0.0020593808,
-0.0275406446,
0.0256450828,
0.075034298,
0.0173192583,
0.0514752604,
0.0194815565,
0.0379107445,
-0.0114140287,
0.0408607647,
-0.0025577419,
0.000802562,
-0.0227860343,
-0.0838001072,
0.0440827012,
-0.0410234481,
0.0035915622,
-0.0018235879,
-0.0207560249,
0.0058619766,
0.0680891573,
0.0186817143,
-0.0490904115,
-0.0020140163,
0.0524509475,
0.0049728723,
0.0080098743,
-0.0467081182,
-0.0053909807,
0.0217616707,
-0.029221924,
0.0056153005,
-0.0586860515,
-0.0004645944,
0.0497322828,
-0.0603849962,
0.0486331359,
2.47021643e-34,
-0.0133193489,
0.0300164074,
-0.0005027534,
-0.0213740263,
0.0140251433,
0.0314892642,
-0.02952246,
0.017453976,
0.0083105424,
-0.0417837761,
0.0409946628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17107v1 | ClimateX: Do LLMs Accurately Assess Human Expert Confidence in Climate Statements? | 2023-11-28T10:26:57 | 2023-11-28T10:26:57 | Romain Lacombe, Kerrie Wu, Eddie Dilworth | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR | Evaluating the accuracy of outputs generated by Large Language Models (LLMs)
is especially important in the climate science and policy domain. We introduce
the Expert Confidence in Climate Statements (ClimateX) dataset, a novel,
curated, expert-labeled dataset consisting of 8094 climate statements collected
from the latest Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports,
labeled with their associated confidence levels. Using this dataset, we show
that recent LLMs can classify human expert confidence in climate-related
statements, especially in a few-shot learning setting, but with limited (up to
47%) accuracy. Overall, models exhibit consistent and significant
over-confidence on low and medium confidence statements. We highlight
implications of our results for climate communication, LLMs evaluation
strategies, and the use of LLMs in information retrieval systems. | [
0.0355222188,
0.103776969,
0.0215269383,
0.0461151004,
-0.0177980158,
0.0021039175,
0.0127145341,
0.0007600532,
0.012868111,
-0.0455581732,
-0.045100484,
-0.0062595578,
0.0138932895,
0.0128510389,
0.0209432095,
-0.0646953881,
0.042111218,
-0.016459845,
0.0878387764,
-0.0333504938,
0.0043233451,
-0.0225057937,
0.0036395055,
0.028066989,
0.0169625245,
0.0196401644,
0.0336866677,
-0.0097479252,
0.0413401946,
-0.023357952,
0.0438069217,
0.0671845675,
0.0286817569,
0.0208124928,
0.0000015069,
-0.0280197393,
-0.0048778593,
-0.0072461609,
0.0090320008,
0.0203373078,
0.0634862408,
-0.0160499625,
0.0239798222,
-0.003781145,
-0.0670470744,
0.006816179,
0.0608713552,
-0.0024795274,
0.0463908315,
0.0327026211,
0.0276658759,
0.0073731039,
0.0177231301,
-0.0041669598,
-0.0135932863,
0.0089748316,
0.0554247722,
0.0304474961,
-0.0517176688,
0.0441874936,
0.0188721884,
0.0670938566,
-0.0122968787,
0.0026325732,
0.0090922872,
0.0407123715,
-0.0113641201,
-0.0266800504,
0.0018938981,
0.03390228,
0.0559985526,
-0.0040647574,
-0.0321688466,
-0.0118297273,
0.0273735859,
0.0461526103,
-0.0521521047,
0.0118621737,
-0.0063107251,
0.0053846426,
-0.0148878936,
0.0460135676,
0.0132208886,
0.0606218092,
-0.0032795549,
0.1157528907,
-0.0311193429,
-0.0426564664,
0.0171167552,
0.0189955197,
0.0176015124,
-0.0276273843,
-0.0004821362,
-0.0195553005,
-0.019464545,
0.0329296067,
0.006291755,
0.0291964747,
0.0381755568,
-0.0465099663,
0.026682483,
0.0113115311,
-0.0103745656,
0.0346178822,
0.0473183095,
0.0332386978,
0.0358377881,
0.0271754228,
0.0162631702,
-0.0243320372,
-0.0530140661,
-0.0361179486,
0.0096217422,
-0.0295685455,
-0.0036748417,
0.0312949568,
-0.05388638,
-0.0474958718,
-0.0335499831,
0.0280536376,
-0.007498689,
0.020299904,
-0.0086569414,
-0.0442043133,
-0.0605989322,
0.0553057492,
-0.0191067215,
0.0337829478,
0.0136506306,
-0.0309661273,
0.0106849521,
0.0214005057,
-0.0056788451,
0.0109974863,
-0.0111302733,
0.0384781547,
0.0207902342,
0.0026018617,
0.0197910611,
-0.0350644477,
-0.0120284837,
-0.0558964461,
-0.0277326386,
-0.0577020012,
-0.0125793023,
-0.010388962,
0.0224120002,
-0.0755646974,
-0.0073899766,
-0.0267538503,
-0.0471252613,
0.0713692904,
-0.0673182607,
-0.0088715274,
0.0425201468,
0.0093404865,
-0.0214803237,
0.0460689478,
0.0315640047,
0.0266188849,
0.0422989465,
0.0065711574,
0.0456462279,
-0.0114822127,
-0.0009471544,
0.0365048423,
-0.0230681133,
0.0190773997,
-0.0506732166,
0.015170088,
0.025003463,
0.0366555639,
-0.0250014421,
-0.0013449296,
0.0762975663,
0.0338462442,
-0.0432271808,
-0.0083378255,
0.0045106793,
0.0498398244,
0.0260928143,
0.020889895,
-0.0337910466,
0.026814308,
-0.0459507108,
-0.0051354631,
0.0730249882,
-0.0119144199,
-0.0029270512,
-0.0668004304,
-0.0253574755,
0.0326567292,
-0.0519457087,
0.0051223924,
0.0150902011,
-0.0465574935,
-0.0008271054,
0.0173679851,
0.0159282349,
-0.0180079583,
0.0068970937,
-0.0235907882,
0.0023480859,
0.0480452217,
-0.0384686552,
0.025508726,
0.0115583306,
-0.0188018791,
0.0107498495,
0.0044891201,
0.0539744906,
-0.0036443996,
-0.0338475257,
-0.0320189446,
-0.0511821769,
-0.0083984975,
0.0486058518,
0.0049083927,
0.0378177203,
0.0087633431,
0.0095572835,
-0.0261701494,
-0.0302340649,
0.0126747508,
-0.025630055,
-0.0060740537,
-0.0276713334,
-0.0154928388,
0.0392560735,
-0.0248386879,
-0.0157543439,
0.0164900087,
0.0264221448,
0.0345864631,
-0.0779281408,
0.0284783337,
-0.0131371524,
0.0225384459,
0.0358777083,
-0.0436606221,
-0.0071809664,
-0.0208206158,
-0.0362528041,
-0.0138726765,
0.0077407714,
-0.010582176,
0.0061548417,
-0.019597983,
-0.0184693858,
-0.0145423636,
0.0203069188,
-0.0285376254,
0.0425742939,
-0.032113336,
0.0305294357,
0.0241294689,
-0.0166466087,
-0.0039818822,
-0.0495478846,
0.0005370107,
-0.040460974,
0.0092386939,
0.0150785688,
0.0451628938,
-0.0373971239,
-0.0690177605,
-0.0120444158,
-0.0513150394,
-0.010673685,
-0.004974063,
0.0304768607,
0.0121849691,
-0.0716654584,
-0.0165749509,
0.028950762,
0.0046900515,
-0.0156486109,
-0.0232748874,
0.0261703487,
0.0542650968,
-0.0137962634,
0.0090097599,
-0.0608304106,
0.0040399111,
-0.0210811459,
0.0573057495,
0.0557365008,
-0.0540129021,
-0.0538747571,
0.0372664593,
-0.0397141054,
-0.0277878251,
-0.0211857054,
-0.0370819978,
0.0090151373,
-0.0148475701,
-0.0462224297,
0.0238115545,
0.0354962833,
0.0179738943,
0.0466299653,
-0.0155220963,
-0.0877072364,
-0.0058692074,
-0.006449027,
-0.0302175973,
-0.0138864089,
-0.0405742526,
0.0052638575,
0.0228395443,
0.0154758636,
0.0126195364,
0.0162846316,
0.0833842084,
-0.0202956218,
-0.0387082435,
-0.0236150064,
-0.0079594804,
-0.0035753301,
0.0752631798,
-0.0115458556,
-0.1001635864,
0.0544086732,
-0.0169710293,
0.0282151848,
-0.0222553629,
-0.0194764324,
0.0093612522,
0.0297312774,
-0.0192518663,
-0.0012612315,
0.012330967,
0.0265121367,
-0.0242905337,
-0.0540695526,
0.0119937416,
-0.0175083764,
-0.0276452024,
-0.0751078352,
0.0137219001,
0.0105269821,
-0.0232247952,
-0.0103348438,
-0.033518672,
-0.0947336257,
0.0086772321,
0.0464830175,
-0.0826486573,
-0.0791324452,
-0.0068259416,
0.0443567634,
-0.0098384162,
-0.0095252721,
-0.0401588567,
0.0143454056,
-0.0067681484,
0.0207824241,
0.0348081365,
0.0214057453,
-0.0257565323,
-0.014227163,
0.0416207574,
-0.0199495461,
0.0268430784,
-0.0461689495,
-0.0345677175,
0.038425114,
0.0003225073,
-0.0254556984,
0.0106558483,
0.0306579359,
-0.0461842231,
0.0276404377,
0.1063298732,
0.0122966375,
-0.0182303656,
-0.0302326977,
-0.0180357657,
0.0295764375,
0.0238663219,
-0.0097488454,
-0.065564774,
-0.0165311769,
-0.0017594649,
0.013276876,
-0.0274126474,
-0.0263788588,
-0.0301993452,
-0.0616339296,
0.0765114501,
0.0163498577,
-0.0270500351,
-0.0134692239,
-0.1084930524,
0.0113113103,
-0.0266483407,
-0.0414566472,
-0.0212879051,
-0.0128421029,
0.0115757957,
0.0320334025,
-0.071963802,
-0.07011237,
0.0248830486,
-0.0117544802,
0.0466274023,
0.0437948816,
0.0446200818,
-0.0281573925,
-0.0401420929,
0.0024358619,
0.0192297194,
-0.0083400952,
0.0018604192,
0.0503528714,
-0.0144299185,
0.0074499366,
-0.0174936503,
0.024799604,
-0.0023225204,
0.0171765797,
0.0055208532,
0.0494763739,
-0.0152302627,
-0.0180459358,
-0.008442224,
0.0352574326,
0.0131010991,
0.0824361965,
-0.0036515452,
0.0187174771,
-0.0264091752,
-0.0815253854,
0.0086047258,
-0.0196607914,
-0.0527827926,
0.0428595543,
-0.0018072198,
-0.0071910783,
-0.0354061797,
-0.0134776263,
0.0421411023,
0.0066598984,
-0.022017898,
0.0088408468,
0.0574063025,
0.0144485543,
-0.0215190798,
0.0330079161,
-0.0506318808,
0.0305111874,
-0.0500881784,
-0.0067324736,
0.0627842471,
0.0438538268,
-0.0195920318,
0.0245869067,
-0.0549624711,
-0.0819903761,
-0.0258149933,
0.0375297666,
0.028894281,
-0.0100967325,
0.0384761617,
-0.0578050576,
0.0654757246,
0.0870435312,
-0.0277733877,
-0.0097588366,
0.0444485731,
0.0292889643,
-0.0136386696,
0.0223777611,
-0.0010717086,
0.0142017258,
-0.0104806637,
0.0232482571,
-0.0774107426,
-0.0442754701,
0.0081008663,
0.0036610186,
0.085548915,
-0.019481862,
-0.0256580599,
-0.0146265998,
-0.0262474921,
0.0090379743,
-0.0428304449,
-0.0138030713,
0.0177045967,
0.0242117923,
-0.0209823214,
-0.0337997712,
0.0313741863,
-0.0143287778,
0.0214450825,
-0.0278710071,
0.0299325939,
0.0250546709,
0.0258585475,
0.0025544504,
-0.0273444131,
-0.0280140433,
-0.0231845938,
-0.0005670589,
0.0156774912,
0.0546492822,
-0.013349737,
-0.0049142377,
0.0073754485,
-0.0112417815,
-0.0207997337,
-0.1004025936,
-0.0710373297,
-0.0545369498,
0.0456219986,
0.0100692883,
0.0456198081,
-0.0016681034,
-0.0531985126,
-0.0206521619,
-0.0321516283,
-0.0043740119,
0.0144491279,
0.0030240468,
0.0799941644,
-0.0132143265,
-0.0566759594,
0.0113982046,
0.0544234104,
0.0395758264,
0.0606193841,
-0.0267543308,
-0.0711179227,
-0.0251898337,
-0.0403521992,
-0.0195084792,
-0.0245550275,
0.0322973989,
-0.0011606527,
-0.0565821677,
-0.0264979638,
0.043984171,
0.022917347,
-0.0060570687,
-0.0234188121,
-0.0288214777,
0.0641874894,
-0.0311710779,
-0.0088352198,
-0.0307483505,
0.0034565015,
-0.0053262818,
0.0006981083,
-0.0598907135,
-5.976422297e-33,
-0.014102201,
-0.0547330528,
-0.001128369,
-0.0226249751,
0.033159703,
0.0207808092,
0.0050768931,
0.0459345095,
-0.0340587348,
0.0667707026,
0.0043794089,
-0.0040285601,
0.0324906521,
-0.0188195556,
0.0606222302,
0.0368340202,
0.052020397,
-0.0114097111,
0.0009111628,
-0.0491553023,
0.0421398617,
-0.0000758902,
0.0684945956,
-0.1386442184,
0.0748981982,
0.012637727,
-0.033879675,
0.0126453247,
-0.0262836143,
0.0235613789,
0.0031466892,
0.0610181428,
-0.0055551892,
-0.0458823256,
-0.0498103015,
0.0159793291,
-0.0535643883,
-0.0152150169,
0.0150407068,
-0.0334669314,
-0.0061472482,
-0.002560728,
0.0178729352,
0.0231723282,
-0.0467726812,
-0.0075163809,
0.0514910147,
-0.0467915125,
-0.0178971328,
-0.0531213358,
0.0015225164,
0.0624983534,
0.0042992407,
0.0512557253,
-0.0322294496,
0.0416605547,
0.0002350013,
0.0559912845,
-0.0532394536,
0.051455006,
0.0442847982,
0.0256807357,
0.0564384684,
0.0008025129,
-0.0127576003,
0.0827714726,
0.0211960226,
0.0203977656,
-0.0260851644,
-0.0496579148,
0.0348184928,
0.029083332,
0.018347552,
0.1334604323,
0.0284858383,
-0.0186432991,
-0.0337537304,
0.0286161266,
0.0166053716,
0.0454358123,
0.0396157838,
-0.0002759564,
-0.0173157956,
-0.0359305628,
-0.0592768863,
-0.0122320112,
-0.0196048263,
0.016453797,
-0.0005205746,
0.014998679,
0.0113780349,
0.0204877108,
0.0008531567,
-0.0223830752,
-0.0463067926,
0.035256125,
-0.0190247428,
0.0346039459,
0.0163273234,
0.0377388969,
-0.0753771067,
-0.0047581471,
-0.0326739214,
0.0448273979,
0.0161761977,
0.0010602132,
0.0368807763,
-0.0050682705,
-0.0584869944,
-0.0101287104,
-0.0103350738,
-0.0326483771,
0.0085124979,
-0.0397228412,
-0.0110370265,
0.0048883283,
0.0049800007,
0.0064796261,
-0.0423691794,
0.0238526799,
0.0419925563,
-0.0041459976,
-0.0434164964,
0.0155974627,
-0.0115392013,
-0.0158622023,
-0.0221044701,
-0.0548754409,
-0.0168019291,
-0.0069099669,
0.0131116705,
0.0030231024,
2.296e-7,
0.0539415106,
0.0777625367,
-0.0353739597,
-0.012938723,
-0.0103638498,
0.0418463424,
-0.0156890862,
-0.0092225866,
0.0133575667,
-0.0520009287,
0.0015834827,
-0.0053684376,
0.0417320766,
0.0486943871,
-0.0519416779,
-0.0736350194,
-0.0541637465,
-0.0093840314,
-0.0364366956,
-0.0154422345,
0.0520148203,
0.0614991486,
0.0272852369,
0.0197462495,
-0.0090393052,
-0.0408221222,
0.0951299593,
-0.0578629151,
-0.0120554939,
0.0321993716,
0.0695915669,
-0.0071193422,
0.0139250951,
0.0477984808,
-0.0065076021,
-0.033736404,
-0.0204103645,
0.0679394379,
0.0443593152,
-0.0176342297,
-0.0132510057,
-0.0104318066,
0.0200216509,
-0.0218809657,
-0.0062309583,
-0.0618619248,
-0.0117433015,
-0.0249514114,
-0.0372013114,
0.009803798,
0.0526650585,
-0.0427639447,
-0.0048833052,
0.0071079619,
-0.0192501396,
-0.0035127045,
-0.0253916979,
-0.0312911347,
-0.0183980577,
-0.0250278898,
-0.0334663428,
-0.0698349029,
-0.0006807662,
-0.0206001978,
0.015615127,
-0.0252473913,
0.0460901931,
1.479994798e-34,
0.0655772611,
0.0114337681,
-0.034562245,
-0.0389351323,
0.0642189384,
0.028919939,
0.0180265792,
0.0225898884,
0.0313447453,
-0.0435429178,
0.0131634846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16650v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16650v1 | Text2Tree: Aligning Text Representation to the Label Tree Hierarchy for Imbalanced Medical Classification | 2023-11-28T10:02:08 | 2023-11-28T10:02:08 | Jiahuan Yan, Haojun Gao, Zhang Kai, Weize Liu, Danny Chen, Jian Wu, Jintai Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deep learning approaches exhibit promising performances on various text
tasks. However, they are still struggling on medical text classification since
samples are often extremely imbalanced and scarce. Different from existing
mainstream approaches that focus on supplementary semantics with external
medical information, this paper aims to rethink the data challenges in medical
texts and present a novel framework-agnostic algorithm called Text2Tree that
only utilizes internal label hierarchy in training deep learning models. We
embed the ICD code tree structure of labels into cascade attention modules for
learning hierarchy-aware label representations. Two new learning schemes,
Similarity Surrogate Learning (SSL) and Dissimilarity Mixup Learning (DML), are
devised to boost text classification by reusing and distinguishing samples of
other labels following the label representation hierarchy, respectively.
Experiments on authoritative public datasets and real-world medical records
show that our approach stably achieves superior performances over classical and
advanced imbalanced classification methods. | [
0.0198682416,
0.0417954959,
0.0089564528,
-0.0133002652,
-0.0195457209,
0.0303334594,
-0.0183541607,
0.0505761802,
0.0210488457,
-0.0357527845,
-0.0190808717,
-0.0488708243,
-0.0084775053,
0.0092566842,
-0.0159099922,
-0.0719142556,
0.0310836937,
0.0358277112,
0.0285355672,
-0.0028058439,
0.0002391892,
0.0010980165,
0.0054805581,
0.0230292808,
-0.0315143652,
-0.0478957742,
0.043477878,
0.0557852499,
0.0432374589,
-0.0915706903,
0.0451158322,
0.0309655257,
-0.0056546712,
0.0434953347,
0.0000021287,
-0.0088582393,
-0.0118345292,
0.0107063921,
-0.0308638867,
-0.0014375474,
0.0185987838,
-0.0250780191,
0.0250677615,
-0.0102192564,
0.0095115369,
-0.01885424,
0.0347099006,
0.0859960094,
0.013811009,
0.0484715365,
-0.0120797064,
-0.038393531,
0.0430285633,
-0.0325342156,
0.0504977107,
-0.0238322299,
0.0339651816,
-0.0041334531,
-0.0174358543,
0.036106728,
-0.0037460509,
0.0097547527,
0.0529734157,
0.0263834447,
0.0996514261,
0.0854992494,
-0.0075294287,
-0.0077830767,
0.0228904858,
0.0791598856,
-0.0447538942,
-0.0366860516,
0.005931783,
-0.0530603901,
0.0151781403,
-0.0680807605,
-0.0113337776,
-0.0071420707,
-0.0265918113,
0.029430056,
0.0315569304,
0.0212007333,
0.0406465121,
-0.0478881821,
-0.0187155697,
-0.0103797717,
0.0085958876,
-0.0219502002,
0.0229404904,
-0.0042922301,
0.0197097249,
-0.0351516306,
0.0315238945,
0.0207227115,
-0.0384884141,
-0.0028081154,
-0.0512575507,
-0.0404457673,
0.0727100968,
-0.0663725883,
-0.0227484666,
-0.0057674935,
-0.0495079085,
0.0170693845,
0.0035781285,
-0.017195411,
-0.0077282898,
0.0891748667,
-0.0163703058,
-0.0142181376,
-0.033750549,
-0.0035711534,
-0.0171523429,
0.0385671742,
0.0149674322,
0.011835983,
-0.0386910699,
-0.0392074399,
-0.0420644693,
-0.018767193,
0.0179593321,
0.0513101034,
-0.0348733701,
0.001619578,
0.0147115495,
0.0144174518,
0.0156098315,
0.0110667394,
0.0034654308,
-0.0044384203,
0.0216053203,
0.0522709675,
0.0030798528,
0.0126102054,
0.03814492,
0.0196955781,
0.0100274794,
-0.0431237854,
-0.0179288033,
0.0008491639,
-0.0349564143,
0.0207469016,
0.0015095762,
-0.0585414059,
-0.0084469831,
-0.0183142051,
0.0190990008,
-0.0522668362,
0.0271587241,
0.0220412705,
-0.0448466912,
0.0282622352,
-0.030178193,
-0.033747226,
0.0245671459,
0.0217194017,
0.0009868925,
0.0025718499,
0.0387370773,
-0.0329331718,
0.0013992523,
-0.0075954166,
0.0084131714,
-0.0276064035,
0.0247708857,
-0.0233532172,
-0.0007806546,
0.0081801256,
-0.0408391505,
0.04451859,
0.0146745928,
0.0328145996,
0.0350261889,
-0.04421442,
0.0376623459,
0.0161183868,
0.0022158958,
0.0065888953,
-0.0106768329,
-0.0191422999,
-0.0502754115,
-0.0151885152,
-0.0021589762,
0.0187402945,
0.0130480025,
0.0061362735,
-0.0098228781,
-0.018622078,
-0.0354646221,
-0.0176591873,
-0.0098243691,
0.0155285569,
-0.023047613,
-0.0140803307,
0.0389978588,
-0.0088559818,
0.0140699903,
0.0548357591,
0.0538734943,
0.0124843968,
-0.0199119914,
-0.0273988657,
-0.0678391755,
0.0336948112,
-0.0015967119,
-0.0645730123,
0.0025571408,
-0.0009745682,
0.008210307,
-0.0009867144,
-0.0156428721,
0.0127103636,
0.0234233979,
-0.0074320263,
0.0000235709,
0.0329599008,
0.0389849581,
-0.0171430837,
-0.0500479639,
0.0113757364,
-0.0071616373,
-0.0296559408,
-0.0596577562,
0.0511204675,
-0.0112959845,
0.0004904402,
0.0593925081,
-0.0015034566,
0.0146254636,
0.0103202676,
-0.0217661578,
0.0178010054,
0.0370403975,
-0.027544925,
-0.0745128095,
-0.0896875113,
-0.0705487505,
-0.0489021316,
0.0216409396,
-0.0389311723,
-0.03557311,
-0.0070420089,
-0.0447647981,
0.0001698212,
-0.0456363186,
-0.0711529851,
0.0013823968,
0.0090375729,
0.0322388709,
0.012832962,
-0.0190574396,
-0.0508132428,
0.0782168284,
-0.0279790349,
0.0071310918,
-0.004552017,
-0.0180272534,
0.0133553948,
0.0154053308,
0.018705219,
-0.0098506007,
-0.0434650518,
0.0130887982,
-0.0174974445,
0.0130263707,
-0.0138640059,
0.008721252,
-0.0477517024,
0.0018315604,
-0.0166552868,
0.0049437308,
0.0047939201,
0.0176163279,
0.0231163502,
-0.0377323814,
-0.074218981,
-0.0403337777,
-0.0152574452,
0.0058016763,
0.0454505049,
-0.0244266875,
0.020191798,
0.0089073731,
-0.0049035698,
-0.0447621867,
0.0235258769,
-0.0021335084,
-0.0337588824,
0.0177095719,
-0.0054400512,
-0.0062682345,
-0.0093873283,
0.0050031575,
0.013843026,
-0.0020384211,
0.02672337,
-0.0128512513,
0.046716705,
0.0044232723,
0.0118202986,
0.0256027021,
0.0671031103,
0.0003980068,
0.0134802526,
0.0095665287,
0.0110759949,
0.002997837,
-0.0607236251,
0.0087205386,
0.0743597895,
-0.0131259793,
0.0111166518,
-0.0079720393,
-0.0549556017,
0.0151504586,
0.0261029005,
-0.0597877726,
0.0092164893,
-0.0565761365,
0.0045970283,
-0.0261083823,
-0.047882501,
0.078706719,
0.0107339388,
-0.0036525123,
-0.0666754395,
-0.0379048921,
-0.042694103,
0.0071700383,
0.0153931882,
0.0242370367,
0.047517594,
-0.0218949672,
-0.0146408826,
0.0524558723,
-0.0011225177,
-0.0479734577,
0.0365486965,
0.0318938717,
0.0138962846,
-0.012928105,
-0.0609561987,
-0.0334408022,
-0.0421705171,
0.0095890835,
0.0166866388,
-0.0010037321,
0.0000403569,
-0.0788021088,
-0.015855791,
-0.0044906363,
0.0891571119,
0.0198318567,
-0.0138044134,
-0.0092381118,
0.0652212277,
0.0118174721,
-0.0122457426,
0.0165697876,
-0.0182969365,
0.0208723452,
0.0532313474,
0.0047368356,
0.0370996296,
-0.0054752612,
0.0110032698,
-0.0040960428,
-0.0052115582,
-0.0017108512,
0.0150078507,
0.0066573517,
-0.0339946151,
0.0253958907,
0.0601068065,
0.0197960325,
-0.0999695957,
0.0424152836,
-0.0290404242,
0.026072016,
0.0138489185,
-0.0029731053,
-0.0580154955,
-0.0311478321,
0.0132448776,
0.0032150303,
-0.0169429109,
-0.0351636298,
0.0540422238,
-0.0225319322,
0.007599432,
0.0037695777,
-0.0683250651,
-0.0627041161,
-0.0266464669,
-0.0100541962,
0.029550815,
-0.0259310436,
-0.0216604751,
0.0009411738,
-0.0328431688,
-0.00581935,
-0.0744782314,
-0.0647962242,
0.0298097879,
-0.0195422601,
0.0130878845,
0.0300824698,
0.0502729453,
-0.0071017165,
0.0035293517,
0.0109904008,
-0.0486043617,
-0.0259057451,
-0.0059395051,
0.0531033166,
-0.0108746802,
-0.0133721409,
-0.0600651354,
0.0303816646,
-0.0299639702,
-0.0128983753,
-0.0101248641,
0.0806688517,
-0.0121001108,
-0.0400662161,
-0.0749135911,
-0.0121997353,
0.0219789948,
0.0288640317,
0.0130696567,
-0.014069126,
-0.0027353037,
-0.0059642885,
0.0553218797,
0.0080548394,
0.0107276533,
0.1243234798,
-0.0370288081,
-0.0722713619,
-0.0416422747,
-0.0214645527,
-0.0067241685,
-0.03503659,
-0.0324316621,
-0.0018550224,
-0.0505456217,
-0.0452061072,
-0.0507208742,
0.022121666,
0.0038737094,
0.0163041689,
-0.0126702394,
-0.0227103718,
0.0361206681,
0.0166460406,
-0.0516404808,
-0.0282621253,
-0.0147039406,
-0.0175832938,
-0.0397238843,
0.0119516701,
-0.0024115059,
0.0106788948,
0.0067785471,
-0.0204370655,
0.0295330398,
0.0751422644,
-0.0605673082,
-0.016878834,
0.0039682272,
-0.0632381141,
-0.0060287723,
0.0343471579,
-0.0421712212,
0.0515442528,
0.0224095639,
0.0289926697,
-0.0102378018,
-0.0132556437,
0.0068916632,
0.0111212069,
0.0478030965,
0.0073645078,
-0.0281273611,
0.0017033294,
0.0708698705,
0.0312796496,
0.0019784772,
0.0022434513,
0.0156505331,
0.0103800613,
-0.0004302424,
-0.0279537328,
0.0261861589,
0.0080577461,
-0.0211003516,
-0.0089323735,
0.0316117741,
0.0033206865,
0.0520705469,
0.0112544093,
0.007852315,
-0.0139735099,
0.0012789048,
0.0399943218,
0.0186205115,
0.01146024,
-0.0123718102,
0.0370153598,
0.0409974009,
-0.0312483478,
-0.0013856516,
-0.0512293465,
-0.0028580485,
-0.0443373099,
-0.0402798094,
0.0558391698,
0.029477261,
-0.0050873081,
-0.0246824361,
0.0154685723,
-0.029436959,
-0.0037005949,
-0.0354617313,
-0.0104610277,
-0.0011801355,
-0.0136296237,
-0.008893461,
0.0189698339,
0.0721237287,
0.0601540692,
0.0113448091,
-0.0116462382,
-0.0204000045,
-0.0302506741,
0.0376274772,
0.0302515198,
0.0736223236,
-0.0105586778,
0.0117897876,
-0.0519192405,
-0.0295993071,
0.045388855,
-0.0482321866,
0.013291684,
-0.0094928239,
0.0455465689,
-0.0032206802,
0.0036373714,
-0.0230713822,
0.019146638,
0.0237871688,
-0.0032610842,
-0.0368725769,
-0.0174803659,
-6.375860788e-33,
0.0055378745,
-0.0383267142,
-0.0011649821,
-0.0207596924,
-0.0248541981,
0.0464581586,
-0.0468084477,
-0.0184729118,
-0.0024190133,
0.0607301034,
-0.0155680943,
0.0139822429,
-0.0173792914,
0.0623257346,
0.0188124999,
-0.0085760383,
0.0236299951,
0.0294491891,
-0.0079695778,
0.068899177,
-0.0145353014,
0.055320628,
0.0579124168,
-0.0797794461,
-0.0140582295,
-0.0024949019,
0.0531523526,
0.0044059241,
-0.0023531483,
0.0413881019,
-0.0260186102,
0.0766007304,
0.0638103113,
-0.0036672021,
0.0058421083,
0.0130710229,
-0.090082258,
-0.0307316296,
-0.0594924353,
-0.027900219,
-0.0161041413,
-0.0324262008,
0.062822856,
0.0318836607,
0.0201255977,
-0.0715158209,
0.0645043552,
-0.0037554963,
-0.0349742584,
-0.0536801033,
-0.0288298167,
0.0600646734,
-0.0168709774,
0.0397632197,
-0.060051892,
0.0186250284,
-0.0054634945,
0.1304174513,
-0.0346114598,
-0.0381283462,
0.0075420341,
0.0082604252,
-0.0192346033,
-0.0110654701,
-0.0337083153,
0.0742322132,
0.040770594,
0.003545427,
-0.0438136607,
-0.0298720412,
-0.0285872482,
0.0073980945,
0.0560394935,
0.01440039,
0.0711582229,
-0.0216387566,
-0.1094031557,
0.0250077061,
-0.0664141923,
0.0141109377,
0.002277222,
0.0213064142,
-0.0174339022,
0.012604828,
0.0024527996,
-0.0278099496,
-0.0201780181,
-0.010640258,
0.0197891388,
0.0094106402,
0.0185300503,
0.0793220624,
0.0022071556,
-0.0249360539,
-0.0590248443,
-0.0185509361,
0.075702779,
0.0405204967,
-0.008696992,
0.0060750186,
-0.0198895894,
-0.0033403351,
0.0349121056,
0.0072870683,
0.0400966071,
0.0022602011,
0.0536218956,
-0.0778144225,
-0.051907666,
-0.0149224587,
0.0465919264,
-0.0370039567,
-0.0249929633,
0.0827715918,
0.0120774796,
0.026496686,
0.0203665011,
0.0993525162,
-0.0007032859,
-0.0065138587,
-0.0368173346,
-0.0325297676,
-0.0271783452,
0.0038844321,
0.0137471715,
-0.0264568534,
-0.0169715248,
0.0152989579,
0.0453492217,
-0.0871879011,
-0.0180874672,
-0.0339427702,
2.856e-7,
0.0800988823,
0.0181160755,
-0.0220731087,
-0.0877731517,
0.0567038544,
0.039034918,
0.0264467932,
0.0606192164,
-0.0535237528,
-0.0533184372,
0.025323635,
-0.0212073326,
0.0404764414,
0.0131900553,
-0.080851227,
0.0242747646,
-0.1626650691,
-0.0250797849,
-0.015248077,
-0.0284501705,
0.0367340632,
0.1010176837,
-0.0365816094,
-0.052292034,
0.0557872355,
0.0326261111,
0.0153970579,
-0.0108484849,
0.063084133,
0.0152187096,
-0.0105341747,
0.0170881152,
0.0101526799,
0.0589036271,
-0.0258658268,
0.0032981865,
0.0002778349,
0.048473727,
-0.0888825208,
0.0210539289,
0.0059643537,
0.0362192169,
0.010694406,
-0.0620765649,
0.0330514163,
-0.051894743,
-0.0204167981,
-0.0156347565,
-0.0330277123,
0.0104050171,
0.0906801894,
0.0285045262,
-0.0428725854,
0.0460636243,
0.0102382302,
-0.0078888312,
-0.0206187554,
-0.0863782316,
-0.0106579866,
0.0461487062,
-0.0223510191,
0.0175405797,
-0.0197783113,
0.0301445778,
0.0072149085,
-0.0062273908,
0.0061206822,
2.52325648e-34,
0.0321190841,
-0.0260238443,
-0.0251524393,
0.0359102525,
-0.019993471,
-0.0264746957,
0.0133743063,
-0.008523616,
0.0027363477,
-0.0224898122,
0.0096394923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16639v2 | Scaling Political Texts with Large Language Models: Asking a Chatbot Might Be All You Need | 2023-11-28T09:45:02 | 2024-05-13T14:16:05 | Gaël Le Mens, Aina Gallego | cs.CL | cs.CL | We use instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4, MiXtral,
and Llama 3 to position political texts within policy and ideological spaces.
We directly ask the LLMs where a text document or its author stand on the focal
policy dimension. We illustrate and validate the approach by scaling British
party manifestos on the economic, social, and immigration policy dimensions;
speeches from a European Parliament debate in 10 languages on the anti- to
pro-subsidy dimension; Senators of the 117th US Congress based on their tweets
on the left-right ideological spectrum; and tweets published by US
Representatives and Senators after the training cutoff date of GPT-4. The
correlation between the position estimates obtained with the best LLMs and
benchmarks based on coding by experts, crowdworkers or roll call votes exceeds
.90. This training-free approach also outperforms supervised classifiers
trained on large amounts of data. Using instruction-tuned LLMs to scale texts
in policy and ideological spaces is fast, cost-efficient, reliable, and
reproducible (in the case of open LLMs) even if the texts are short and written
in different languages. We conclude with cautionary notes about the need for
empirical validation. | [
0.0067119165,
0.0715814382,
0.0107943695,
0.0127248187,
-0.0284337625,
0.0179768447,
0.026860062,
0.007273702,
0.027649628,
-0.0464777946,
0.0188647527,
-0.0593040958,
-0.014905652,
0.0312989652,
-0.0134130893,
-0.0681029707,
0.0144639062,
0.0102725271,
0.0369185582,
-0.0473609082,
0.0324991457,
0.0117607908,
0.005181259,
0.0594445653,
-0.0282513052,
-0.0098451274,
-0.0440162942,
-0.0131691806,
0.0540534519,
0.0193081852,
0.0044015497,
0.0268670507,
0.0156946611,
0.0474210531,
0.0000017215,
0.0049846061,
-0.0328266732,
-0.0289113875,
0.06453076,
-0.0165478345,
0.093434453,
-0.0362903252,
-0.0324158035,
0.0306369718,
-0.0473108552,
0.0204899982,
0.0682269558,
0.0252879709,
0.0665991679,
0.078397736,
0.0062475358,
-0.0397448242,
0.0069718705,
-0.0221227929,
0.0118063157,
-0.0447988436,
0.0439482331,
0.0058492934,
-0.0430956185,
0.0773351565,
-0.0130871153,
0.0223828163,
0.0143106552,
-0.0162811019,
-0.0291926563,
0.0156144425,
-0.0246565156,
-0.0065576504,
0.005990135,
0.0244211741,
0.036043521,
-0.031123627,
0.0298014916,
-0.0269826688,
-0.0057917139,
0.044095058,
-0.0544134565,
0.0098114638,
-0.0061467048,
0.0345236436,
0.0325200334,
-0.0147257186,
0.0021145293,
0.0276854578,
-0.0313616432,
0.0693975389,
-0.0341632366,
-0.0445536301,
0.008657122,
-0.0064289621,
0.0162119363,
-0.0307880417,
0.0281454921,
0.0018013659,
0.0175327826,
0.0307207908,
-0.0134074297,
0.0042178934,
0.0154765798,
-0.0880564153,
-0.001667666,
0.0070718839,
0.0040498162,
0.0813962743,
0.0728601813,
0.02364536,
-0.0277474783,
-0.0063911467,
-0.0177051872,
-0.0099121081,
-0.0423006788,
-0.0073946854,
-0.0216470081,
0.0068069454,
-0.0263982583,
-0.0046902606,
-0.0437328964,
-0.0209480505,
-0.028533306,
0.0201649889,
-0.0035454938,
0.0002074212,
-0.02309018,
-0.0102370298,
-0.0374623463,
0.0628850907,
-0.0312719494,
0.0188292153,
-0.0410908312,
0.0140115898,
0.0218186621,
0.0574596487,
-0.0088495556,
-0.0029926945,
0.0013990296,
0.0489173234,
0.0205578264,
0.0049429657,
0.0312535986,
0.0021926165,
-0.0427766703,
-0.0393421389,
-0.0062671877,
-0.0896704718,
0.0181196257,
-0.0130061461,
-0.0001604264,
-0.0353572555,
0.0065383608,
0.0414738692,
-0.0347410925,
0.0581860282,
0.0340664797,
0.0178125836,
0.0411393903,
0.0023066178,
0.0118061928,
0.0904640257,
0.0279726572,
0.0399214998,
0.0457887836,
-0.0261038151,
-0.0010956898,
0.0516932011,
-0.0121914661,
0.0434041955,
-0.0185230356,
0.0183033627,
-0.0090356022,
-0.0040401574,
0.0026136842,
0.0492780507,
0.0091529367,
-0.0201558657,
0.0672645718,
0.0961377993,
-0.0215261579,
0.0199613143,
-0.0028111299,
0.0458976068,
0.0098570036,
0.000263416,
0.0045371843,
0.0160363298,
0.0047243293,
-0.0505171418,
0.0745281875,
0.0351314694,
-0.0090230815,
-0.0265342314,
-0.002210913,
-0.0005278389,
0.0252673943,
-0.0138581125,
0.0650909096,
-0.0663318336,
-0.0322423279,
0.0216899086,
0.0197666623,
-0.0354163125,
0.0067944517,
-0.0269048251,
-0.0037787792,
0.0317749195,
-0.0035558483,
-0.0534122884,
0.0023406234,
-0.035679318,
0.0708735362,
0.0731822997,
0.077428177,
-0.0467930585,
-0.0723467469,
-0.0323268585,
-0.0176897682,
0.0036033292,
0.006064455,
0.0190103091,
0.0342653617,
0.03114786,
-0.0069889463,
0.0034347328,
-0.017613424,
0.0219023619,
0.0014843297,
-0.0251562037,
-0.0063857734,
-0.0002505167,
0.0497980751,
0.0469214171,
-0.0038240755,
-0.0370420925,
0.0236676894,
-0.0220741518,
-0.0172565337,
-0.0267442372,
-0.0382181518,
0.0358027108,
0.04641499,
-0.0240815822,
-0.0016459608,
0.012866932,
-0.0513825715,
-0.0013282942,
0.0517482385,
-0.024001414,
-0.0090179387,
-0.0251838192,
-0.0027890289,
-0.0597998165,
-0.0259923339,
-0.0783814415,
0.0575113855,
-0.0045652008,
0.0179862399,
0.0080039809,
-0.0230626613,
0.0247381944,
0.0012808355,
-0.0048240591,
0.0212443341,
0.0339786932,
0.0680652186,
0.0585464947,
-0.0207487326,
-0.0121656526,
-0.0811746269,
-0.054899428,
0.0027852731,
-0.0376494601,
0.0423930585,
0.0382768624,
-0.0360192172,
0.0034645922,
0.0288744699,
-0.0439984351,
-0.0231113788,
-0.0407393388,
0.0037921013,
0.0577248298,
-0.0038115396,
-0.0254203733,
-0.0265796036,
0.0124150505,
-0.0304106195,
-0.0031740987,
0.0357235037,
-0.028303396,
-0.0302831586,
0.019245252,
-0.0110910386,
0.0059972326,
-0.0280816685,
-0.0333377756,
0.0128622809,
0.0017131624,
0.0144881494,
0.0325371288,
0.0426110514,
0.085059531,
0.0377165228,
0.0292707086,
-0.0689365789,
-0.0228749719,
-0.0449702144,
0.0172553323,
-0.0398566984,
-0.0260607619,
0.038706325,
0.0676942915,
0.0091379387,
0.0012529523,
-0.071478352,
0.053700123,
-0.0305006113,
0.0209504198,
-0.01298506,
0.0193288513,
-0.0410905033,
0.0223124735,
0.0243754666,
-0.0553435273,
0.0072520003,
-0.0235800911,
0.0587615483,
-0.0390670523,
-0.0668593496,
-0.0344835706,
0.0468270853,
0.0036044263,
0.0098858168,
-0.0348634757,
0.008037365,
-0.0346647315,
-0.0173761509,
0.0308132172,
-0.0463706888,
0.0407884307,
-0.04403916,
0.0292537548,
-0.0207523648,
-0.0313698314,
-0.0120044984,
-0.0879744962,
-0.0157446302,
-0.0039678039,
0.0290008709,
-0.080880627,
-0.0342940651,
0.0343901105,
0.0428899974,
0.0153131662,
0.0142390812,
0.0047859885,
0.0214289725,
0.0015162016,
-0.0003166767,
-0.0031995366,
-0.0217135455,
-0.019955568,
-0.0080553386,
0.0344422907,
-0.012206899,
0.0328690782,
-0.0498735979,
-0.065575406,
0.0063461713,
-0.0462587737,
-0.0189706478,
-0.0206533633,
0.0556025058,
-0.0182885807,
0.0158393644,
0.0825728923,
0.025168607,
-0.0487106442,
-0.0124037033,
-0.0025537082,
0.0046643838,
0.0109686377,
0.0036838984,
-0.1047521904,
0.0435280912,
0.0100741601,
0.0194682945,
-0.031869337,
-0.0273551065,
-0.0161906555,
-0.092060402,
-0.0002992375,
0.0070706396,
-0.0330932215,
-0.0312093534,
-0.0690038577,
0.02691238,
-0.0261364225,
-0.0597382784,
-0.0055285632,
-0.0038513376,
0.0238332283,
0.0014346716,
-0.0678159446,
-0.0266282689,
0.0142773082,
-0.0030672457,
0.0425531752,
-0.0045362976,
0.0752226338,
0.0024357273,
0.0004734776,
0.0653717294,
0.0213321168,
-0.0248474274,
0.0109161716,
0.0321864448,
-0.0095690563,
0.0015129158,
-0.0145106837,
0.0522334091,
0.0342227258,
-0.0044948445,
0.0200428236,
0.0402450524,
-0.0344577879,
-0.0265391339,
0.0100281108,
0.0540253893,
0.0335743688,
0.0617769435,
0.0398028009,
-0.0378883258,
-0.0268248711,
-0.058221586,
0.0149158156,
-0.0184250716,
-0.055133462,
-0.0158696398,
-0.034124542,
0.0168236773,
-0.0206660591,
-0.0260299183,
0.0023609467,
0.0273792129,
-0.002578096,
0.0182895269,
0.0328786373,
0.0046639489,
0.0134762507,
-0.0052726842,
-0.0337576456,
0.00277959,
-0.0001893033,
-0.0589587502,
0.0191844814,
0.0175534766,
-0.0320241749,
-0.0128143672,
-0.0423596688,
-0.076180011,
-0.002499511,
-0.0347822495,
0.0253280792,
0.0059858882,
-0.012272073,
-0.0589656942,
0.0542606525,
0.0994234979,
-0.0407808274,
0.0066780425,
0.0195992496,
0.0728495866,
0.0071545835,
0.0349895209,
-0.0181034878,
0.02321532,
0.0117668239,
-0.0435953774,
-0.079137601,
-0.0368363038,
-0.0081612384,
0.013689776,
0.019163942,
-0.0047687124,
-0.0626856983,
-0.0477640219,
-0.019129768,
-0.0088198073,
-0.0187059734,
0.0087209623,
-0.0120790051,
0.0299059879,
-0.0525227636,
-0.0354041792,
0.0292692687,
0.0042216103,
0.0313376822,
-0.0297353175,
0.0542111695,
-0.0241564084,
0.0434837639,
0.0386531092,
-0.0159069318,
-0.0095994305,
0.0126390764,
-0.0170499496,
0.0444393419,
0.0257994477,
0.0101457518,
0.0070238994,
0.0102132196,
0.0589883812,
-0.0055940226,
-0.0393821076,
-0.0733800679,
-0.0384248868,
0.0547261238,
0.0221460853,
0.0141197527,
0.0256699193,
-0.0181049798,
-0.0338581353,
-0.0101794861,
0.0056720646,
0.0026741892,
-0.0335566774,
0.0384597369,
-0.0110486709,
-0.0560592711,
0.0073020835,
0.0351977572,
0.0203583166,
0.0195133109,
0.0732124671,
-0.0204408187,
-0.0152072208,
-0.0363326594,
-0.0138050774,
-0.0113543561,
-0.0149130914,
-0.0305574127,
-0.0603283308,
-0.0338593163,
-0.0008605222,
0.0086595081,
-0.0306223948,
0.012391503,
-0.0040632621,
0.0462073237,
-0.0362925269,
0.0752848536,
-0.0561974756,
0.0337447636,
-0.0363438614,
-0.0413870588,
0.0126915779,
-6.021006961e-33,
-0.0178342983,
-0.0515946075,
0.0296851136,
0.0018800334,
-0.0019261719,
0.0046138922,
0.0091196094,
0.0384514444,
-0.0043204669,
0.0208493602,
0.0162453894,
0.0253757108,
0.01807319,
0.0055167843,
-0.0112724146,
-0.0132549368,
-0.0056108921,
-0.0321564227,
-0.036196433,
0.0409503318,
0.0480126329,
-0.0300307348,
0.0386774018,
-0.0888525918,
0.0305304546,
0.0237268917,
-0.0078067146,
-0.018440254,
0.0251728259,
0.0089929542,
-0.0276519619,
0.0301628467,
0.0434837751,
-0.0502629131,
0.0067376439,
0.0996571854,
-0.0215431526,
-0.0409577005,
-0.0056950524,
-0.0077161728,
0.0282598585,
-0.0367574096,
0.0378168188,
0.0103901019,
-0.0462177321,
-0.0080385292,
0.0528815575,
-0.0104508288,
0.0420066081,
0.007061475,
-0.0381970368,
0.0629465133,
-0.0388194658,
0.0114028472,
-0.0232742243,
0.0347360596,
0.0543957129,
0.063768521,
-0.0539127477,
0.0270430893,
-0.026172135,
0.0191218909,
0.0256242994,
-0.0409906656,
0.0081401132,
0.0812288225,
-0.0064028711,
0.0360175297,
-0.0614391193,
-0.0312963612,
0.0124809202,
-0.0267265569,
0.0537393279,
0.0606154874,
0.013575579,
-0.038507428,
-0.095115602,
0.037388213,
0.0734874755,
-0.0144634089,
0.014996442,
-0.0192628689,
-0.0105679817,
-0.0243944991,
-0.0248808488,
-0.0378961004,
-0.0130756712,
-0.0374510959,
-0.0262262523,
0.0032324248,
-0.0071938434,
0.0276627969,
0.0254691616,
-0.0599789657,
-0.0124639953,
0.0257126857,
-0.0478332788,
0.0109643219,
-0.0145042408,
0.0325565264,
-0.0731274709,
-0.046709612,
-0.0286854636,
0.0249896049,
0.0215312652,
-0.0081880745,
-0.0034869018,
-0.0081646116,
-0.0791989639,
-0.0230512172,
-0.0033482986,
-0.0005624685,
-0.0058196639,
0.0615859218,
0.029151069,
0.0047652214,
0.0291716456,
0.0449424647,
0.0219307411,
-0.00257478,
0.0207695644,
-0.0326626562,
-0.0497951247,
-0.0186645966,
-0.0461643673,
-0.0096755717,
-0.0419927202,
0.0498810373,
0.0306507461,
-0.0461047553,
-0.0100749098,
-0.0213106256,
2.486e-7,
0.0706449822,
0.0695337877,
-0.0091050984,
-0.0101822177,
0.0036272793,
0.0256299768,
0.0195420794,
0.0624610409,
-0.0884364545,
-0.0408949405,
-0.0099865533,
0.0114329876,
0.0495123379,
0.0395440198,
-0.0881127939,
-0.0039259931,
-0.0797263682,
0.0156241087,
-0.0727198049,
0.0434791222,
-0.0277890079,
0.0619673282,
0.0490858741,
0.0131055946,
-0.0280865803,
-0.0119111221,
0.0768998638,
-0.0351804011,
-0.0375566781,
0.0368967466,
0.0036576332,
-0.0078912051,
-0.0016761965,
0.0161024202,
0.0281638782,
0.0110829705,
-0.0253141243,
0.1048178449,
0.0271377936,
0.0180404205,
-0.0047414219,
-0.0342327915,
-0.0147053804,
-0.0369622558,
0.0563469045,
-0.0599494874,
-0.0377182662,
-0.0483709462,
-0.016490696,
-0.0333316401,
0.0616381802,
-0.0034387161,
0.010043513,
0.0296612214,
-0.0176403951,
-0.0364176482,
0.0254632216,
-0.0414452329,
0.0033801212,
-0.0278859418,
-0.0463721044,
-0.0457708836,
-0.0004822829,
0.0072272341,
0.0271479804,
-0.0257803071,
0.0475381427,
1.944778721e-34,
0.0393680446,
-0.0223121736,
-0.0329635292,
-0.0248355996,
0.0415086932,
0.0109506343,
0.0236481838,
0.0029923466,
0.0116094872,
-0.0863665119,
0.0236325003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09451v1 | MANTIS at #SMM4H 2023: Leveraging Hybrid and Ensemble Models for Detection of Social Anxiety Disorder on Reddit | 2023-11-28T09:33:41 | 2023-11-28T09:33:41 | Sourabh Zanwar, Daniel Wiechmann, Yu Qiao, Elma Kerz | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents our system employed for the Social Media Mining for
Health 2023 Shared Task 4: Binary classification of English Reddit posts
self-reporting a social anxiety disorder diagnosis. We systematically
investigate and contrast the efficacy of hybrid and ensemble models that
harness specialized medical domain-adapted transformers in conjunction with
BiLSTM neural networks. The evaluation results outline that our best performing
model obtained 89.31% F1 on the validation set and 83.76% F1 on the test set. | [
0.0426344089,
0.0240882635,
-0.0158681031,
-0.0490124747,
0.0030449589,
0.0308258347,
0.0397663228,
0.0402065404,
0.0461485572,
-0.0416025445,
-0.0109339645,
-0.0444117635,
-0.047538463,
0.0186049305,
-0.0125864651,
-0.0013966266,
0.0176496953,
0.0715499371,
-0.0266557764,
-0.0093720471,
0.0078162495,
0.0116389301,
-0.0245491043,
0.0361020081,
0.0052307318,
-0.0161017552,
0.0739404559,
0.0102307759,
0.0257655531,
-0.0498927049,
0.0493996851,
0.0708093196,
-0.0042802328,
0.0335497819,
0.0000021502,
-0.0280438997,
-0.0508207493,
0.0076469635,
0.0153789697,
-0.073384963,
0.0187340993,
0.0103412112,
0.0200593472,
0.0472057275,
-0.0526340231,
-0.046304334,
0.0639547855,
0.0668118298,
0.0653997809,
0.0616335273,
-0.0407882929,
0.0268910471,
0.0128798205,
-0.0148024168,
-0.0098324278,
-0.003081789,
0.0494159162,
-0.0486726202,
0.0060650399,
-0.020578051,
0.0411814265,
0.0285545494,
-0.0340650901,
0.0572414696,
0.0217770413,
0.0086515313,
0.0295654554,
-0.0235800445,
0.0201685559,
0.023582479,
-0.0258356556,
0.0117598334,
0.020613173,
0.015868552,
-0.0014210023,
0.0421190001,
-0.0347409546,
0.0111498954,
-0.0198022686,
0.0188831557,
-0.0083243353,
0.02503209,
0.0410960428,
0.0105583575,
0.0220768396,
0.0491804145,
-0.0373890884,
-0.0180558823,
0.0380711071,
0.030322887,
-0.0060244314,
-0.0191503055,
0.085607104,
-0.000789739,
-0.0135428747,
0.0157709476,
0.0140374443,
-0.0665590242,
0.0128815211,
-0.0354112349,
0.0004982642,
0.0005140873,
-0.0309059955,
-0.0036941057,
0.0040204823,
-0.003688382,
-0.0075781448,
-0.004363778,
0.0356087759,
0.018092595,
-0.0890241861,
0.0200240277,
-0.0292183347,
0.0308267046,
0.0289811436,
-0.0009750689,
-0.0689739957,
0.0164143573,
-0.0049378979,
-0.0409770347,
0.0480096899,
0.0300222356,
0.0265166163,
0.0275690835,
0.0345462225,
0.0152500197,
0.0307800546,
0.0168072134,
0.0124644572,
-0.0281736292,
0.033021763,
-0.0323904417,
-0.0004253042,
-0.0289852358,
-0.026923202,
-0.0119399158,
0.0484557338,
-0.0333591811,
-0.0261795986,
-0.0091788257,
-0.0393131562,
-0.0017132774,
0.047962755,
-0.0164653547,
0.0331967659,
0.0202616733,
0.0414024442,
-0.0513962768,
0.008276931,
-0.000738321,
0.0019850377,
0.0486636534,
-0.0639232397,
0.0099789118,
-0.0258615483,
0.0142290611,
0.024278529,
0.061942976,
0.0298962258,
0.021620661,
0.0463243909,
-0.0252499636,
0.0481213741,
0.002904868,
-0.0036062126,
-0.0475483797,
0.032763429,
-0.0500881709,
-0.0280418303,
-0.0036930842,
-0.0468295068,
0.0136444885,
0.0178861525,
-0.0032711807,
0.0213117264,
0.0277636778,
0.0182919409,
0.0648515821,
-0.0330349281,
0.0063138693,
-0.0082175601,
-0.0609211177,
-0.0114089232,
0.0288342629,
-0.0489723422,
-0.0515685119,
-0.0029760131,
0.0343298987,
-0.0186982453,
-0.0401927345,
-0.0349082462,
-0.0309847705,
-0.0212622657,
-0.0084071551,
0.0272117667,
-0.0425965264,
-0.0158973411,
0.0729413405,
0.022661278,
-0.0375278406,
-0.0373126753,
-0.0711834803,
-0.0153821139,
-0.0118913371,
0.0090218559,
-0.0634023622,
0.0023635018,
-0.0570835397,
0.0154815102,
0.0191220958,
0.0033027322,
0.0144600412,
-0.016483916,
-0.0465475991,
0.0040311534,
0.0508684441,
0.0331210382,
-0.0342846811,
0.0004525892,
0.0447254069,
-0.0518246256,
-0.0305950679,
-0.0183551479,
0.0160806887,
-0.0059663318,
0.0130641125,
0.0470792539,
0.0024795744,
0.0611326732,
0.0228105802,
-0.0000391778,
-0.0052225217,
0.0043077371,
-0.0178171117,
-0.1180954948,
-0.0252100285,
-0.0190905035,
-0.0233127642,
0.013180837,
0.0311285276,
0.0446633548,
0.067031458,
-0.0333838612,
0.0031004467,
0.0517018363,
-0.0553962253,
0.0010340958,
-0.0031932166,
-0.0011133214,
-0.0110235494,
0.0681711584,
-0.0489477813,
0.0104096057,
-0.0420510173,
-0.0058719805,
-0.0675747916,
-0.1100951284,
-0.0039382917,
-0.0042569432,
-0.0498419516,
-0.0261080135,
-0.0419035777,
0.0112949461,
-0.0192127358,
-0.0417128019,
-0.0097248964,
-0.0729729757,
-0.0711199716,
0.0140216025,
-0.016837867,
0.0134270871,
0.0003273331,
-0.0082573891,
0.0052023795,
-0.0027843576,
-0.01170622,
0.0297442582,
0.0343903676,
0.0424971804,
0.037710201,
-0.0069297645,
0.0195118338,
-0.0338156931,
-0.0462790243,
-0.0648652613,
0.0120338872,
0.0211988278,
-0.0660874769,
-0.0232277773,
0.0215317812,
-0.0449447334,
0.0065366244,
-0.0011332064,
-0.0158164836,
-0.0028054237,
-0.0185096674,
0.0047712228,
0.0550619736,
0.0349025838,
0.0327889994,
0.0128900846,
0.030045975,
-0.0126207219,
0.0190954059,
-0.0224510785,
-0.030195022,
0.0021235293,
-0.0318967924,
0.0254814029,
0.0498799533,
0.0018288556,
-0.0180091523,
-0.0310990904,
0.0003333745,
0.0059738094,
0.0199982282,
0.0074984664,
-0.0030556028,
0.0235788208,
0.0298282988,
0.0255765319,
-0.0125698997,
0.0116863558,
0.0255763605,
0.0022564637,
-0.066361405,
-0.0605791844,
-0.0309440736,
-0.0230028667,
0.0284551084,
0.0036093709,
0.0580945201,
0.0386069827,
0.0281116907,
-0.0296939146,
-0.0414593928,
-0.0576647781,
-0.0304317176,
0.0455868095,
-0.006943984,
0.0128708733,
-0.0510357358,
-0.0580626875,
-0.0494996421,
-0.0479810163,
-0.032072261,
-0.0419065319,
-0.0029662037,
-0.0758923292,
0.02729683,
-0.012980557,
0.0126733575,
-0.0376263522,
-0.032410834,
0.0430166945,
0.0041567152,
0.0515538454,
-0.0051508113,
0.0348420218,
-0.0324248783,
0.0313549303,
0.0627599806,
-0.0010628527,
0.0274071377,
-0.0427837446,
0.0067420132,
0.0148106012,
-0.0052779452,
-0.0205377806,
-0.0172914639,
-0.0097371787,
-0.011277792,
0.0247524716,
0.1049384028,
0.0087541221,
-0.0595005415,
0.0073599145,
-0.0326001383,
-0.0335435346,
0.0043748599,
0.0073414478,
-0.017792983,
-0.0174949989,
-0.047731135,
0.0177280381,
-0.026812261,
-0.0749695003,
0.0339198671,
-0.0155710625,
0.047479108,
-0.0141907297,
-0.050282333,
0.0161793903,
-0.0294835605,
0.0249407105,
-0.0198232643,
-0.0365340188,
-0.0638523921,
-0.0006737928,
0.0049074297,
0.0415439382,
-0.1089277416,
-0.0512673371,
0.0187226478,
0.003126302,
0.014583502,
0.0250433236,
0.0569124669,
-0.0048034005,
-0.0265138652,
0.0600272343,
0.0194725022,
0.0077103749,
-0.02707172,
0.1283681542,
-0.0169202462,
0.0132702719,
-0.0285610426,
0.0260578282,
-0.064584963,
0.0081059923,
0.0093605621,
0.0939865112,
-0.0177514013,
-0.0433728844,
-0.0486665517,
0.0314792432,
0.0302919056,
0.0185417775,
0.0234347899,
-0.0470912121,
-0.0046500782,
0.0249307826,
0.0370883048,
-0.0335743427,
-0.0171827041,
0.0126603451,
0.0333160982,
-0.105463706,
-0.0552993864,
-0.0124311568,
0.0033817925,
-0.0302315354,
-0.0262329001,
-0.0636854619,
0.0390341505,
0.039359238,
-0.0611857027,
0.0584798679,
0.0466103852,
0.0084633259,
-0.0423148945,
0.0070804106,
0.0785032213,
-0.0130444169,
-0.0243745558,
-0.0271732826,
-0.0281043295,
0.0003466628,
0.0406191684,
0.0254450645,
0.0179864299,
-0.0536110736,
-0.0140172644,
-0.0327822454,
0.0340193957,
0.0684018731,
-0.0157180168,
-0.0159143452,
0.0240138769,
-0.0392810814,
-0.0294040181,
0.0263855197,
0.0222920887,
0.068324998,
0.0120995371,
-0.0503567681,
-0.0161298104,
0.008386624,
-0.0180958677,
0.024279112,
0.0532496087,
0.0211611148,
-0.046868965,
-0.0188312847,
-0.0484146774,
0.0509262197,
0.0272702351,
-0.0458444543,
-0.045267269,
0.0206987262,
0.0002994729,
-0.0452159494,
-0.025486974,
-0.0207146332,
-0.0053893346,
-0.0620857142,
0.0218692478,
-0.0260606147,
0.0485941805,
-0.0178182982,
0.0246506035,
-0.028234968,
-0.0190501474,
0.0640515462,
0.0186427087,
-0.0023611365,
0.0778206885,
-0.0178055651,
0.0301330797,
0.0507311597,
0.1018911079,
-0.0558736622,
-0.0091743646,
-0.03685591,
-0.0427523553,
0.0113005331,
0.0026519743,
0.0808638334,
-0.0120724496,
0.0036274968,
-0.0372947529,
0.0299932007,
-0.038617827,
0.0195676275,
0.0356708802,
-0.0126855411,
-0.0134118404,
-0.022672968,
0.0376326554,
-0.0752632096,
0.0065185446,
0.0455777347,
-0.0252004731,
-0.0309016127,
0.0415607244,
-0.0173996016,
0.0317995697,
0.0157797877,
0.0018228575,
-0.0514490977,
-0.0321084112,
0.0579605103,
-0.0761850551,
0.0117350761,
-0.0286498349,
0.0103164231,
0.0379789956,
0.0107888281,
0.0285738222,
-0.012910516,
-0.0167522468,
-0.0156659987,
-0.0153460149,
-0.0277858637,
-6.314577124e-33,
0.0064849486,
-0.0150951529,
-0.0138031151,
-0.0117394673,
-0.0146233877,
0.0183350295,
-0.024565313,
0.0231593624,
0.0130278245,
0.0096661299,
-0.0128492285,
0.007942386,
-0.0023833315,
0.0490590781,
-0.0088970382,
-0.0082172761,
0.0212112106,
-0.0156428628,
0.0008711985,
0.0357202031,
0.0113913054,
0.0720367953,
0.0314618275,
-0.126119867,
-0.0278795343,
0.0458672345,
-0.0000808701,
-0.0055663623,
0.0238273945,
0.0406785756,
0.0098447641,
0.0651651695,
0.0610199757,
-0.0069150031,
0.0225785803,
0.0400552377,
-0.0568091311,
-0.037212465,
-0.0587265342,
-0.0045323465,
0.0079242215,
0.0088235913,
0.0556839295,
-0.0188773945,
-0.0001975259,
-0.0643047467,
0.0614262633,
-0.0267051756,
0.0503717139,
-0.0504410081,
0.025558006,
0.0145700481,
0.0100306021,
0.0057841241,
-0.0347967073,
0.0945609584,
-0.0150223998,
0.0429987945,
-0.0335259847,
0.0101637952,
-0.0219275802,
-0.0012803171,
0.0074702096,
-0.0498596467,
-0.0161335282,
0.0266743526,
0.0412726551,
0.0082763135,
-0.0385814123,
0.0008899106,
-0.0163685028,
0.0350903869,
0.0576871485,
-0.0208265968,
0.0008579029,
-0.0259314794,
-0.0843092799,
0.0287191719,
0.0352735408,
-0.0135696623,
0.0658912137,
-0.0422813743,
-0.0161193423,
-0.020009758,
0.0418452024,
0.0180580337,
-0.0084974412,
-0.0348204859,
-0.0050026812,
-0.0191058945,
-0.0052579124,
0.0275423937,
-0.0097056618,
-0.0391890295,
-0.0199429151,
-0.0182731301,
0.0261778403,
0.0347365364,
0.0206950605,
-0.0241652969,
0.0171313658,
0.0122185778,
-0.0004185692,
0.0487825759,
0.0386527963,
0.0050517917,
0.0181909017,
-0.0028926842,
-0.0454367362,
-0.0263830535,
0.0121798441,
0.0349389389,
-0.0113425991,
0.1029378176,
-0.0426676795,
0.0141373063,
-0.0167066716,
0.0507314652,
-0.0196221825,
0.0159207694,
-0.0493837297,
0.0003939254,
-0.0168106668,
0.0144131593,
0.0055077672,
-0.0363053083,
-0.003360108,
-0.0149928331,
0.0300438181,
-0.0501102693,
0.0204176307,
-0.072837688,
2.997e-7,
0.0406377465,
0.0673484206,
-0.0415021479,
-0.0809096023,
0.0470287912,
0.0119212372,
0.0038457874,
0.01596177,
0.0496051647,
0.0314541981,
0.0193473697,
0.0248628911,
0.0254266001,
0.0541494302,
-0.0207479913,
-0.1098666638,
-0.0496917441,
-0.0000506455,
-0.0058248248,
0.0137856342,
0.0079218848,
0.0629710481,
0.023382606,
-0.0242432635,
-0.0016832525,
-0.0102802319,
0.0156059302,
-0.0332589261,
0.0245171245,
0.0424146652,
0.001227546,
0.0080877393,
0.010082976,
0.0194586907,
-0.005370935,
0.0030138991,
0.0111113759,
0.006269386,
-0.0581578836,
0.0157814734,
0.054972019,
0.016561145,
0.0207343977,
-0.0179968141,
0.0218595285,
-0.0742868781,
-0.0523314811,
-0.0193000827,
-0.0049690041,
-0.0399230011,
0.0835625455,
0.0205618776,
-0.0013559165,
0.0402339213,
0.0131640201,
0.0115306918,
0.0088206809,
-0.101951398,
-0.0080047008,
0.0218994059,
-0.0669833943,
-0.0238640998,
0.0098733734,
-0.0000472305,
0.0388239026,
-0.0278825238,
0.0264253411,
2.695372501e-34,
-0.0264611337,
0.0460164696,
0.0142111266,
0.0061025745,
0.0160286278,
0.0136790881,
-0.0308368541,
-0.0008155663,
0.0080800662,
-0.068680428,
-0.0075388891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16620v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16620v1 | On the Long Range Abilities of Transformers | 2023-11-28T09:21:48 | 2023-11-28T09:21:48 | Itamar Zimerman, Lior Wolf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Despite their dominance in modern DL and, especially, NLP domains,
transformer architectures exhibit sub-optimal performance on long-range tasks
compared to recent layers that are specifically designed for this purpose. In
this work, drawing inspiration from key attributes of long-range layers, such
as state-space layers, linear RNN layers, and global convolution layers, we
demonstrate that minimal modifications to the transformer architecture can
significantly enhance performance on the Long Range Arena (LRA) benchmark, thus
narrowing the gap with these specialized layers. We identify that two key
principles for long-range tasks are (i) incorporating an inductive bias towards
smoothness, and (ii) locality. As we show, integrating these ideas into the
attention mechanism improves results with a negligible amount of additional
computation and without any additional trainable parameters. Our theory and
experiments also shed light on the reasons for the inferior performance of
transformers on long-range tasks and identify critical properties that are
essential for successfully capturing long-range dependencies. | [
0.0176146869,
0.0564342737,
0.0193401743,
0.0611704364,
-0.0163235608,
-0.0232258923,
0.025242202,
-0.005160348,
-0.0409621634,
-0.0237973984,
-0.031332545,
-0.058620628,
0.0210104659,
-0.0047162455,
0.0092286859,
-0.059546534,
-0.0111676892,
0.0070726057,
-0.0665272996,
0.0107421633,
-0.0070863655,
-0.0290513057,
-0.0091280742,
0.0638632923,
-0.0042369086,
-0.0206079707,
-0.0087407446,
-0.0045326804,
0.0350718349,
-0.0316857994,
-0.0034165217,
0.0220878441,
0.0199974068,
0.0267720707,
0.000001815,
-0.0080012605,
-0.0007303497,
-0.002492296,
-0.0302851982,
-0.0353863724,
0.0093866503,
-0.0174278039,
0.0014369003,
-0.0043313834,
-0.0201873109,
-0.029000653,
0.0369050168,
0.0805711523,
0.0446185134,
0.0733435899,
-0.0146273924,
-0.0457514711,
0.0337598473,
-0.0628643334,
-0.0066345688,
-0.0775008053,
0.0010443222,
-0.0784432814,
-0.0062810094,
-0.0169926472,
-0.0393831506,
0.0346540548,
0.0411519893,
0.0150254723,
0.031397339,
0.0534341745,
-0.0497861579,
0.0131392404,
-0.0021722408,
0.0706752017,
-0.0773000941,
0.0020691103,
-0.0108520873,
0.0074374019,
-0.0191739351,
-0.0100360075,
-0.0272924788,
0.0050991909,
0.0019146575,
0.0166923255,
-0.0509483553,
0.0199506208,
0.0272630677,
-0.0000591042,
-0.0600519143,
0.0308307596,
0.0046271482,
-0.0151652461,
-0.0017879365,
0.0117837703,
-0.0186600834,
-0.0434569381,
0.0258154254,
0.0448266417,
-0.004733406,
-0.0136147039,
-0.0267298371,
-0.0125750406,
0.0019084933,
-0.0167617947,
0.0455283485,
0.015832724,
-0.051189404,
0.0408098996,
-0.0444559306,
0.0615213774,
-0.0596254207,
-0.0024286972,
-0.0046409057,
-0.0108252652,
-0.0369795486,
-0.0003934207,
-0.0377246812,
0.0086047845,
-0.0140058491,
-0.0381689668,
-0.0265993457,
-0.0195945632,
-0.0179248769,
0.000375311,
0.0058697029,
0.0355358347,
-0.0556190088,
-0.0282737222,
-0.0052892347,
0.0652586296,
-0.0311683081,
0.0309762135,
0.028524207,
-0.0301712677,
-0.0626911074,
0.0199598912,
0.0247317702,
-0.0166891795,
0.0067662699,
0.1078567281,
0.0099916281,
-0.0613083988,
-0.0214156676,
0.0218577199,
-0.0396536142,
-0.07604976,
0.062475834,
-0.0410044082,
0.0270171892,
-0.002191409,
0.00831817,
-0.0159526616,
0.0357126221,
0.0290754419,
-0.0020444102,
0.0426711999,
0.0576271228,
-0.0384588055,
-0.0047677909,
-0.0019263077,
-0.0048212931,
0.0323127881,
0.0244979262,
0.0382573716,
-0.0142244659,
-0.0151763922,
0.0371013433,
0.0206807647,
0.0370721817,
-0.0253074337,
-0.0231930111,
-0.0179695785,
-0.0501656793,
0.0367484763,
0.0247498769,
0.0308259185,
-0.0460706353,
-0.0327925868,
0.0555711836,
0.02275474,
0.0665230677,
0.0360363424,
0.0275993869,
-0.0066443789,
-0.0321570523,
0.0061134202,
-0.0521458723,
0.0613884665,
0.0331034772,
-0.01150297,
-0.033913523,
0.0399329662,
-0.033962518,
-0.013853264,
-0.0105316741,
-0.0086254925,
-0.0132871633,
0.018876547,
0.0453679897,
0.0602439083,
-0.0354932174,
0.1164598614,
0.0115299951,
-0.0251700766,
0.0001598327,
-0.0191474278,
-0.0225061513,
0.0089538973,
-0.0134555791,
-0.0269050431,
-0.0256700087,
-0.0284581408,
0.0119899614,
0.0719223991,
0.0074746432,
0.0257784817,
0.032755129,
-0.0336876214,
-0.0365509912,
-0.00107612,
-0.0062601692,
0.0022344305,
0.0520051941,
0.0200117808,
0.0108040078,
-0.0403475352,
0.0337871015,
0.0114790797,
-0.0096368222,
-0.0200008918,
0.0215308256,
0.0340364054,
0.0245268177,
0.0242865104,
-0.0007067223,
0.0070013935,
0.0150069958,
-0.0662530065,
-0.0462373644,
0.0012755666,
-0.0511003844,
0.0048161647,
0.0003117697,
-0.0380771197,
-0.0028429169,
0.0573060848,
-0.0148861352,
-0.028922027,
0.0426881723,
-0.0498724468,
0.016773222,
0.0052933204,
0.0045472938,
0.0421056934,
0.0597257726,
-0.0434391201,
0.0517126322,
0.0021306959,
-0.0202039704,
0.0028657892,
0.0171884093,
0.0025152615,
-0.0131661016,
-0.0165527184,
0.0182409193,
-0.0182792433,
-0.0164610986,
0.0068191136,
-0.0297386311,
-0.0178788099,
-0.0663813949,
-0.0345191322,
0.0003298061,
-0.0525973588,
0.0173541978,
0.0046352348,
0.0341571085,
0.0182099752,
-0.0166914426,
-0.0083821192,
0.0032545545,
-0.0070453444,
0.0149544049,
0.0271309167,
0.0052689374,
-0.0404368117,
-0.0088346172,
-0.0240069982,
0.0377520174,
0.0813978761,
-0.0268426761,
-0.0262265503,
-0.0424678661,
-0.0228936803,
-0.0148831578,
0.0365434177,
-0.0205079876,
-0.0354923569,
-0.0119246235,
-0.0105392123,
0.0191836916,
0.0537203848,
0.011284099,
0.0124009019,
0.0163999666,
-0.0164151955,
-0.0275497474,
0.0432206579,
-0.0349868834,
0.0142933726,
-0.0357289799,
0.0551949628,
-0.0020041482,
0.0815636292,
-0.0278064962,
0.0093425224,
-0.0335656479,
-0.016241001,
-0.001305808,
-0.0056071118,
0.0306594931,
0.0165905841,
-0.0224720296,
-0.0073626908,
-0.0181351379,
-0.0223130938,
0.0422630347,
-0.0123730982,
-0.0066079707,
-0.012948147,
-0.001980568,
-0.0472039022,
0.0385839529,
0.0055242907,
0.0039096032,
-0.0312041156,
-0.0562051646,
-0.0232848767,
-0.0002602899,
-0.0124971997,
0.0116157169,
0.0954179615,
0.0042440621,
0.0146182682,
-0.0495803915,
-0.0636641756,
-0.0501674227,
0.0045466153,
-0.016460577,
0.0108785005,
0.0112158302,
-0.0219602063,
-0.0637014136,
0.0134467343,
0.0331025496,
0.0654757917,
-0.0231054556,
-0.0094292089,
-0.0043172245,
0.0523282662,
0.029670056,
0.0645658597,
0.0461943597,
0.0099247983,
-0.0012233078,
0.0556925684,
0.017595863,
0.0258783959,
-0.0728648901,
0.0063211834,
0.0160036255,
-0.0363618918,
-0.0197982341,
-0.0021185372,
0.0542681441,
-0.0791443661,
-0.0103095965,
0.0534129068,
-0.0154551752,
-0.0568002351,
0.002655623,
0.0293008629,
0.0239436757,
0.0136942416,
0.0242996775,
-0.0630372614,
-0.0299257115,
-0.0106316414,
0.0029918144,
0.0144282365,
-0.0133411875,
0.0089581441,
-0.0739677846,
0.0363105237,
-0.0159058217,
-0.0217352901,
-0.0253124088,
-0.017339142,
0.017124936,
0.0135415765,
0.0136353858,
-0.0171500072,
-0.0226881411,
-0.0435677581,
0.0293662418,
-0.0360154808,
-0.0387869626,
0.045038972,
-0.020200232,
-0.0069194334,
0.0550160147,
0.0198267996,
-0.0131295575,
-0.0360404328,
0.0295561515,
0.0202772506,
0.0415545776,
0.0246664993,
0.0854471922,
-0.0063922252,
-0.0337466523,
0.0233795736,
0.0054169982,
-0.0396184959,
-0.0092734303,
-0.0256769285,
0.0705324262,
-0.0121462233,
-0.0105120316,
-0.0010748801,
-0.0077341935,
0.0042374674,
0.0250617545,
0.0301496293,
-0.0061591687,
-0.0947455168,
0.0071524712,
-0.0026837147,
-0.0693343133,
-0.0648105592,
0.030293718,
0.0563779026,
-0.0691255704,
-0.0333677754,
-0.0467118286,
-0.0017232246,
0.0275774356,
-0.0198468324,
-0.0602991022,
0.0350923799,
0.0186119545,
-0.0337414481,
0.0393859632,
-0.0430791751,
0.0265992731,
-0.0144963255,
0.0386515185,
0.0492453761,
-0.0266367458,
-0.021101024,
0.0428225622,
-0.1515142322,
-0.0298208576,
0.0544746332,
-0.0088732485,
0.0178013984,
0.0381711423,
-0.0106983259,
-0.0271972548,
0.0582578629,
0.0093546091,
-0.0222988147,
0.0325192735,
0.0414872281,
-0.0331370644,
0.0044303793,
0.0348311849,
-0.0520698689,
0.0494895689,
0.0419218428,
0.0384230316,
0.017093597,
-0.00560098,
0.0102307135,
-0.0633036792,
0.0562681742,
0.0192699693,
-0.0010212078,
0.0053096619,
0.052387353,
0.018530881,
0.0187976006,
-0.053376969,
-0.0337652341,
0.0112754228,
0.0127899069,
0.0175301265,
0.0328631997,
0.0295801628,
0.0245180856,
-0.0291709583,
0.0372320786,
0.0121749286,
-0.0355981961,
0.0089997035,
0.0310472716,
-0.0311836451,
-0.0124966586,
0.0342011787,
0.0366532877,
0.0063325819,
0.0524127632,
0.0247885566,
-0.0007524372,
-0.0486533307,
0.0041341111,
-0.0913504586,
-0.0418381207,
-0.0011431738,
-0.016493151,
0.0662776604,
-0.016019851,
0.004419141,
0.0055666156,
-0.016619714,
0.0195677932,
0.0290668122,
-0.0111167198,
-0.0358331166,
0.0390416197,
-0.0011323591,
0.0079632206,
0.0051411693,
0.0475940146,
0.0092959013,
0.0352230743,
0.0148453265,
0.0425629467,
-0.0460445248,
-0.0544558503,
-0.0270448793,
-0.0171971973,
0.0268676039,
-0.0069543975,
-0.0341167599,
-0.0547368973,
0.0722130165,
-0.0855111405,
-0.0145834787,
-0.0470932759,
0.027198676,
0.0408689752,
0.0265153293,
-0.0306436718,
-0.0098155532,
0.0162760708,
0.0059837159,
0.0055822013,
-0.0486941971,
-5.801745673e-33,
-0.0011470768,
-0.0011832585,
0.0263136663,
0.0033633634,
-0.076312907,
0.0222866964,
-0.036919564,
-0.014643441,
-0.0341450311,
0.026058251,
-0.0367815457,
0.0075350441,
0.0184880886,
0.0366916209,
-0.0014336006,
-0.0879292116,
0.0486503765,
0.006536427,
0.0084410263,
0.0228434391,
0.0183967166,
0.0463077426,
0.0903859064,
-0.0577560365,
-0.0456267186,
0.0063268603,
-0.0006291893,
-0.0015856572,
0.010679652,
0.0587140098,
-0.0305003729,
0.0092030913,
0.0232682321,
-0.0926814824,
-0.031196896,
0.0065260837,
-0.0674842,
-0.0108272033,
-0.0669255555,
0.0240666866,
-0.0334254131,
-0.0115755433,
0.067447409,
0.0300590824,
0.0141788097,
-0.08211115,
0.0259724688,
0.0004974014,
-0.03366125,
-0.0452615023,
-0.0572665259,
0.0298957974,
0.0032177428,
-0.0303851273,
0.0215076767,
0.0336899683,
-0.0225187074,
0.0440118797,
-0.0820662081,
-0.0205383841,
-0.0198572595,
0.053801883,
0.024273213,
0.0278243013,
-0.0109157609,
0.0460179225,
0.0194867644,
0.0159661546,
-0.0357819982,
-0.0620827712,
0.0132312626,
0.0366861559,
0.0527082607,
-0.0204981659,
0.04145265,
0.0092836618,
-0.0591691695,
-0.0513028018,
-0.02883913,
0.0882347524,
0.0115074832,
0.0001483516,
-0.0041556326,
0.0127048818,
0.0052584694,
0.0122161703,
-0.0286104605,
-0.0050696889,
0.0238181427,
0.0442421548,
0.0171344671,
0.0486771427,
0.0289717652,
-0.0194618627,
0.0268893186,
0.0289780423,
0.0196418855,
0.0496636443,
0.0162490271,
-0.0087652961,
-0.0306625366,
0.0115639586,
-0.0215842072,
0.0354719684,
0.0126684532,
-0.0191638973,
0.0159317534,
0.054813087,
-0.0737207457,
-0.0469963104,
-0.0605996363,
0.0444101319,
-0.0048938496,
0.0958076045,
0.047298573,
-0.0114035681,
-0.0131175676,
0.0767316669,
-0.0299829561,
0.0107272351,
0.0005809623,
0.0609187149,
0.0448569395,
0.0303251483,
-0.0369321629,
-0.0035428391,
-0.0540261604,
0.0055413973,
0.0068162307,
-0.0988263562,
-0.0114314826,
0.0138591602,
2.631e-7,
0.0056816805,
0.0260986481,
0.055895742,
0.0243605357,
0.0126914522,
-0.0114633907,
0.0262198746,
0.0506810211,
-0.0071869874,
0.0340830237,
-0.01188251,
0.0133840051,
0.0409696214,
0.0399448536,
-0.1174431592,
-0.0089132786,
-0.0571983047,
0.0023777527,
-0.0191968847,
-0.0187194087,
0.0152884685,
0.1056725159,
-0.0135285743,
0.0125217065,
0.0294920392,
-0.0212337058,
0.0665516928,
0.0004297489,
0.044999823,
0.0224659704,
0.024809787,
-0.0202183668,
-0.0203481819,
0.0100777568,
-0.012283924,
0.0291863978,
0.0113787558,
0.0630477071,
0.0079937242,
-0.0732549131,
-0.0136482473,
0.0155994836,
0.0086298911,
-0.0300961602,
0.0418019183,
-0.1087467298,
-0.0261832438,
-0.0095635522,
-0.026701184,
0.0001900847,
-0.0127437981,
0.0132543026,
0.0405983739,
0.0079635233,
0.0019272161,
-0.0032271722,
-0.0032358037,
-0.1116979197,
-0.0351760983,
0.0039007238,
-0.0664307326,
0.0198017471,
-0.0397704877,
-0.0504246242,
0.0493804142,
-0.0143844821,
-0.0592259318,
2.311136229e-34,
0.0030449782,
-0.001995933,
-0.0116774039,
0.0028950209,
-0.0154522089,
-0.0206850842,
0.0247268938,
0.0134180719,
0.0258254763,
-0.063327685,
-0.0119428625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16588v2 | Ascle: A Python Natural Language Processing Toolkit for Medical Text Generation | 2023-11-28T08:13:29 | 2023-12-09T09:14:24 | Rui Yang, Qingcheng Zeng, Keen You, Yujie Qiao, Lucas Huang, Chia-Chun Hsieh, Benjamin Rosand, Jeremy Goldwasser, Amisha D Dave, Tiarnan D. L. Keenan, Emily Y Chew, Dragomir Radev, Zhiyong Lu, Hua Xu, Qingyu Chen, Irene Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study introduces Ascle, a pioneering natural language processing (NLP)
toolkit designed for medical text generation. Ascle is tailored for biomedical
researchers and healthcare professionals with an easy-to-use, all-in-one
solution that requires minimal programming expertise. For the first time, Ascle
evaluates and provides interfaces for the latest pre-trained language models,
encompassing four advanced and challenging generative functions:
question-answering, text summarization, text simplification, and machine
translation. In addition, Ascle integrates 12 essential NLP functions, along
with query and search capabilities for clinical databases. The toolkit, its
models, and associated data are publicly available via
https://github.com/Yale-LILY/MedGen. | [
0.0694589838,
0.0061826441,
0.023955889,
-0.0686737746,
-0.0019201554,
0.0345423557,
0.0110523785,
0.0271963999,
0.0236787982,
-0.0182383228,
0.0345541462,
-0.044669468,
0.0124592073,
0.0746669993,
0.0145763904,
-0.0570182055,
-0.0050375042,
0.0426420867,
0.0328853428,
0.0204451717,
-0.0256556366,
0.0605693832,
-0.0330813043,
0.0547774509,
0.0366536044,
-0.0004562899,
0.0410352834,
0.0120616918,
0.0167110078,
-0.0850875974,
0.0086739939,
0.0132726356,
-0.0087454543,
-0.0276218466,
0.0000021794,
-0.0396351628,
-0.0244022012,
0.0175554715,
0.019034816,
-0.0504969582,
0.0804473087,
-0.0600298271,
0.0120423529,
0.0346018188,
-0.0485351123,
-0.0038365361,
0.0238175262,
0.0335480347,
0.0459530614,
0.0765466243,
-0.0120179942,
-0.0074087395,
-0.0081207072,
-0.0143057993,
0.012890134,
-0.0026359723,
0.0111910021,
0.0112209562,
0.0372660682,
-0.0146591403,
0.0455101095,
0.0370328017,
0.0003747477,
0.0110389451,
0.0530494042,
0.0660517737,
-0.0149029978,
-0.06709674,
0.0044106832,
0.042550467,
0.010601351,
-0.052437447,
0.0517253652,
-0.0004205162,
-0.0262282453,
-0.0066767586,
-0.0582302883,
0.0356495567,
-0.0260503441,
-0.0144574102,
0.0180146229,
-0.0056096218,
0.0060423203,
0.0058671124,
-0.0077244802,
-0.0311384797,
0.015073752,
0.0004245308,
-0.0261551831,
-0.0108606853,
0.0012823736,
-0.0805422515,
0.0585907623,
0.049999278,
-0.0455107838,
-0.0255615953,
-0.0221765488,
-0.0476052128,
0.0974183455,
-0.0618111417,
-0.0045061209,
-0.0150926923,
0.0075827553,
0.0165435374,
-0.022947792,
-0.0365583673,
0.0018393397,
0.0325225294,
-0.0609954931,
0.0504502021,
-0.0139302751,
-0.0369822383,
-0.0356978923,
0.0142253358,
-0.0340896547,
-0.0215861201,
-0.0828207731,
-0.0280769337,
0.022291977,
-0.0194452815,
0.0270997956,
0.0573085286,
-0.0347376727,
0.0042177783,
-0.0081434976,
0.0193590503,
-0.0088695074,
-0.0007685791,
0.0206722394,
-0.0264306683,
-0.0073804166,
0.0058007631,
0.0133797536,
-0.0070847878,
0.0330580659,
0.0446469076,
-0.0034615514,
-0.0041768583,
0.0152318832,
-0.0456432141,
-0.0308256615,
-0.0470844842,
0.0049906424,
-0.0611342452,
0.0392449722,
0.0393509679,
-0.0102663934,
-0.0453406386,
0.0423250608,
0.0404320545,
-0.0300959665,
0.0135182999,
-0.0760459751,
0.0269369204,
0.0425666198,
0.0115281045,
0.0678676069,
-0.0236180145,
0.0264566001,
-0.0159208067,
-0.0009160734,
-0.0299373344,
-0.009708981,
-0.0489509813,
0.0085158003,
-0.064966619,
0.0110120848,
0.0174969528,
-0.0129871257,
0.0692792833,
-0.0382532142,
0.0747665241,
0.0181631781,
0.0209029503,
-0.0057998071,
0.0584699064,
0.0043385779,
0.0381209552,
0.0396787785,
-0.0130289439,
-0.0013277512,
-0.0323802009,
0.0095256614,
0.0378523543,
0.0398625843,
0.0240860302,
-0.0005866049,
0.0427436046,
-0.0065253484,
-0.041514948,
-0.0369997062,
-0.0002256363,
-0.0062760781,
-0.0108599067,
0.002861582,
0.0183540788,
-0.0520926639,
0.0443264022,
0.029855391,
-0.0793184265,
0.0008954994,
-0.0431470163,
-0.0062196702,
0.0606622435,
0.0715596974,
-0.0262548309,
-0.0138825523,
-0.0465037599,
-0.0048135431,
0.0297178626,
0.0188024919,
0.0105164573,
0.0202258676,
-0.0698383525,
-0.0014754432,
0.012202912,
0.0015356627,
-0.0262105521,
-0.0009632165,
-0.0144794527,
0.0311882328,
0.0115029309,
-0.0414771214,
0.05208176,
-0.0549650043,
-0.017437188,
0.0027019209,
-0.0534907877,
-0.0043764831,
0.0241369009,
-0.0236386824,
0.0595919229,
0.0541147217,
-0.0116159162,
-0.0303783435,
0.0241301972,
-0.0184371267,
-0.0533869602,
0.002291308,
-0.0410973728,
0.0176480543,
-0.028458992,
-0.0208853483,
-0.0383839272,
-0.0161041915,
-0.0539308712,
0.0222234149,
-0.0037982787,
0.0393540747,
0.0624070801,
0.0049443063,
-0.0355391912,
0.0222338866,
0.0225686487,
0.0205608811,
0.0340815745,
-0.0706611574,
0.0182352103,
-0.040408209,
0.0070071151,
-0.0088339997,
-0.0219065137,
-0.0093958471,
0.0227844864,
0.0466404818,
-0.0194122847,
-0.015068396,
-0.0851004198,
0.016480498,
0.0187419895,
0.0034746495,
0.0515408106,
0.045104973,
-0.0110753849,
-0.0299672801,
-0.0298574641,
-0.0306777786,
0.0608925931,
-0.0178643167,
0.0423453376,
0.0262040421,
0.025771914,
-0.0337420963,
-0.0115078408,
-0.0213271584,
0.0385199338,
0.0654103607,
-0.0279572103,
0.0243215635,
0.0043951483,
-0.0396661796,
-0.0394967832,
0.0446098633,
-0.0357993916,
0.0096214889,
0.0016480278,
0.027997354,
0.0304216072,
0.0348498262,
0.01071373,
0.0178112853,
0.0150984498,
0.0207706597,
-0.0005173499,
-0.055863589,
-0.0078578815,
0.0442350209,
-0.0549483597,
0.0246149227,
0.0581676289,
0.0523215234,
-0.0188947525,
-0.0321148708,
-0.0052629174,
0.0019611295,
0.00029297,
-0.0640579835,
0.0046475041,
-0.0283235032,
0.0462795012,
0.0149349812,
-0.0301427171,
0.0830537081,
0.0013627165,
0.0117879501,
-0.0847605839,
-0.0268384703,
-0.0486448891,
-0.0154116033,
0.0306744892,
0.0446358956,
0.0224157292,
-0.0144151859,
0.0077968175,
0.0284502096,
0.0005565925,
-0.0605681948,
0.0304337833,
-0.0227905903,
0.0061232406,
0.004536252,
-0.0228675194,
-0.0103927674,
0.0135960784,
-0.0152392425,
-0.0283387508,
0.0398995019,
-0.0086872438,
-0.0239931233,
0.0243947115,
-0.0032140471,
0.0626847893,
-0.0051360801,
-0.0040567135,
-0.0133582121,
0.0196617972,
0.0252974741,
-0.010004906,
0.0050588758,
-0.0049753068,
0.0209072977,
0.0668964088,
-0.0203631856,
0.0363442935,
0.0111140404,
-0.0022686969,
-0.0157309771,
-0.0501624718,
-0.0151379602,
0.0162648223,
0.0281229503,
-0.0609549731,
-0.0024708274,
0.0984816551,
0.0410396419,
-0.007243521,
0.0299052633,
0.0002470742,
0.0006529631,
-0.0040056608,
0.0337659158,
-0.0849111974,
-0.0208296943,
-0.0285148975,
0.0459657796,
-0.0396900773,
-0.0206184946,
-0.0165012833,
-0.0056817764,
0.0182804558,
0.0091691334,
-0.0518407412,
-0.0281064771,
-0.0593166277,
-0.0727455616,
-0.0019746907,
-0.0317908973,
0.0166303925,
-0.0429094695,
0.0302397925,
0.0094637293,
-0.07083866,
-0.0740286112,
-0.0186224747,
-0.0088682063,
0.054154586,
0.0613672771,
0.0681351051,
0.0048851748,
0.0191182122,
0.0012554305,
-0.0234281011,
0.0026343388,
-0.0345183946,
0.0935775265,
0.0233269017,
-0.0031224408,
-0.0571811683,
0.0437095501,
-0.0364399627,
-0.0285190996,
0.0126537327,
0.0092352433,
-0.0273829978,
-0.0379922092,
-0.0527836569,
0.0602921657,
0.015404528,
0.047347039,
0.0216575917,
0.0525156483,
-0.0614181012,
-0.0034616501,
0.0641658753,
-0.0667693019,
-0.0332174711,
0.0021506343,
-0.0529274829,
-0.0196306016,
-0.0793604404,
0.0127726523,
0.0564064793,
-0.0222650953,
0.0101949647,
0.018508343,
-0.0111559983,
-0.0131835211,
-0.0885698348,
0.0282145645,
0.0603306964,
0.0158987287,
-0.0368656516,
-0.0693563074,
0.0592251755,
-0.0160504654,
-0.03002958,
0.0540259406,
-0.022893887,
-0.0224389303,
-0.0169755165,
0.046933841,
0.0197673216,
-0.0522058681,
0.0151889529,
0.009996281,
0.0302289724,
0.0387369432,
-0.0441447757,
-0.0287660062,
-0.0590229891,
0.0014831909,
-0.0039866297,
-0.002756462,
-0.0095102554,
0.0276960935,
-0.0371760689,
0.0468823053,
0.0032689576,
-0.0225403439,
0.0472690873,
0.053454455,
0.009912638,
-0.0557842962,
-0.0426346101,
-0.0290122945,
-0.0069054421,
-0.0419876203,
0.0129607785,
-0.0349520892,
0.0420903191,
0.0066672922,
0.0210475214,
-0.0204158463,
0.0203955751,
-0.0911241397,
-0.0198257882,
-0.014749798,
0.0640911162,
-0.0208821837,
0.0131498082,
0.0533513986,
-0.0422431305,
-0.0122654941,
0.0091696074,
-0.0271089915,
0.0164873526,
0.0067955442,
0.0290965214,
-0.0169846136,
0.0158017781,
0.0068772407,
0.0477363989,
-0.0547125563,
-0.0026417605,
-0.0378590897,
0.009127141,
0.0055421451,
-0.0092007397,
0.0633870736,
-0.0131869782,
-0.0001730349,
-0.0329809226,
0.0798254013,
-0.0195973292,
-0.004618993,
0.0113164354,
-0.0361648723,
-0.0149957696,
-0.0581493191,
0.1064491048,
-0.0216904599,
0.0367700867,
0.0161027126,
-0.0549129173,
-0.0592936464,
-0.0397591367,
-0.0118945166,
0.018951375,
-0.0491248183,
0.0161736812,
-0.0272438265,
-0.0284987595,
0.0071196435,
0.0170787256,
0.0000710043,
-0.0253387392,
0.0326709449,
0.0141942911,
0.0011379229,
-0.0268522874,
-0.0393404514,
0.0874241218,
-0.0456713624,
0.0019221741,
0.000157035,
-6.129233624e-33,
-0.0053048688,
-0.0560594164,
0.0283150598,
-0.0048459093,
-0.0258360114,
0.0316901021,
-0.061740879,
0.014400444,
0.0300239399,
0.0225661062,
-0.0124827037,
-0.0024540129,
0.0055848882,
0.0581109375,
-0.0013987029,
-0.0085868845,
0.0269492194,
0.0121183107,
-0.0087719131,
0.0531364828,
-0.0223327875,
0.0591824464,
0.0335418396,
-0.0718042254,
-0.0212624297,
0.0038274524,
-0.0019189934,
-0.0310857948,
0.0037373332,
0.034310434,
-0.0192549303,
0.0110766189,
0.032008592,
0.0239356011,
-0.0269053914,
0.0101046134,
-0.0361799002,
0.0028707944,
-0.004322093,
-0.0555541925,
-0.0572201498,
-0.0412480533,
0.0643661693,
-0.0283065941,
-0.0115876151,
0.0093366792,
0.0277290884,
-0.0553745218,
-0.0062328316,
-0.0542571805,
-0.0318644717,
0.0522114038,
-0.0092986906,
-0.0085373074,
-0.0428760797,
0.0361467041,
-0.0589151867,
0.019155439,
0.0163224731,
0.0256697536,
0.0588193834,
0.0283100028,
0.0024643911,
-0.0429675877,
-0.0082706604,
0.032793086,
0.0158406645,
-0.0377076268,
-0.042865742,
0.0559092276,
-0.0781747103,
0.0372096859,
0.071713075,
0.0247859471,
0.0120791746,
-0.0214325357,
-0.0748392716,
0.0646738783,
-0.0725130439,
0.02765809,
0.0105788736,
-0.0319276527,
-0.0026855471,
-0.0106104771,
-0.0153758656,
-0.0008508459,
0.0036442527,
-0.0462504774,
0.0226889271,
0.0136450911,
-0.0095874136,
0.0285647698,
-0.0195718519,
-0.0120029431,
0.0314844958,
-0.015308667,
0.0376380719,
-0.005732466,
-0.0431783013,
0.0008321375,
-0.0460160412,
0.0181661397,
0.0595259257,
-0.0247578137,
0.0272368845,
0.0033777345,
-0.016017573,
-0.0241156425,
-0.0555294082,
-0.0087032681,
0.0307165105,
0.021372987,
-0.0069792983,
0.0436338857,
-0.0152306128,
0.0245125648,
0.0085745212,
0.035227105,
-0.0182972346,
-0.0073083499,
-0.0331281684,
-0.0290706232,
0.0327550955,
0.0314019769,
-0.063423112,
0.0276178196,
-0.0422854237,
0.0534946397,
0.0406716801,
-0.033460293,
-0.0149077289,
-0.0071010459,
2.841e-7,
0.1199930534,
0.0550113954,
0.0291432124,
-0.0179507863,
0.0048183464,
-0.0199910104,
0.0281971507,
0.021564886,
-0.005288654,
0.0162254293,
0.0277054477,
0.0164596736,
0.0192236342,
0.0185440667,
-0.0502194352,
0.0035970635,
-0.0888220444,
-0.0185384974,
-0.0192244481,
-0.0339023583,
0.0572556555,
0.0358030424,
-0.0555314273,
-0.0330211967,
0.0161694251,
-0.0017398436,
0.0334748514,
-0.0389944911,
0.0096178697,
0.0553321131,
0.0169893261,
-0.0032092801,
0.0394542255,
0.0274117608,
-0.0521029942,
-0.0456302315,
0.0241108462,
0.0694968477,
-0.0201129802,
0.0193756279,
0.0507546775,
0.0151022449,
0.0576027557,
-0.0593025535,
0.0461596735,
-0.0587226748,
-0.0297890287,
-0.0616320148,
0.0025492704,
0.001775097,
0.0555294007,
-0.0275369119,
-0.049665641,
0.0511796735,
0.0291019101,
0.0294107683,
-0.0339122713,
-0.0648260936,
-0.0349746458,
0.0158748329,
-0.0330546722,
0.0054091304,
0.0123139685,
-0.0191087816,
-0.0305018481,
-0.0611398667,
-0.0073883403,
2.815823249e-34,
0.0416845828,
-0.0013339424,
-0.0297226105,
0.026661817,
0.05165077,
-0.0387583412,
0.0116349589,
0.0065994007,
-0.0039688097,
-0.0412080958,
-0.0201252289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16579v1 | Recognizing Conditional Causal Relationships about Emotions and Their Corresponding Conditions | 2023-11-28T07:47:25 | 2023-11-28T07:47:25 | Xinhong Chen, Zongxi Li, Yaowei Wang, Haoran Xie, Jianping Wang, Qing Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The study of causal relationships between emotions and causes in texts has
recently received much attention. Most works focus on extracting causally
related clauses from documents. However, none of these works has considered
that the causal relationships among the extracted emotion and cause clauses can
only be valid under some specific context clauses. To highlight the context in
such special causal relationships, we propose a new task to determine whether
or not an input pair of emotion and cause has a valid causal relationship under
different contexts and extract the specific context clauses that participate in
the causal relationship. Since the task is new for which no existing dataset is
available, we conduct manual annotation on a benchmark dataset to obtain the
labels for our tasks and the annotations of each context clause's type that can
also be used in some other applications. We adopt negative sampling to
construct the final dataset to balance the number of documents with and without
causal relationships. Based on the constructed dataset, we propose an
end-to-end multi-task framework, where we design two novel and general modules
to handle the two goals of our task. Specifically, we propose a context masking
module to extract the context clauses participating in the causal
relationships. We propose a prediction aggregation module to fine-tune the
prediction results according to whether the input emotion and causes depend on
specific context clauses. Results of extensive comparative experiments and
ablation studies demonstrate the effectiveness and generality of our proposed
framework. | [
0.0091638714,
0.0564739816,
-0.0180040132,
0.0237984881,
-0.0173684116,
0.0366678722,
0.0188429262,
0.0061702509,
0.0562791377,
-0.0559627116,
0.0120616937,
0.040869955,
-0.0597281232,
0.0057181553,
-0.0184181724,
-0.0657240376,
0.0170914382,
0.07623934,
0.0370441936,
0.0143208634,
0.0340770222,
0.0469461419,
-0.0034964718,
0.0097905751,
-0.056295827,
-0.0257206727,
0.0044885464,
0.0163480397,
0.0538782589,
-0.0243219342,
0.0261909645,
0.0391017906,
-0.0052035009,
-0.0403241999,
0.0000020926,
-0.0526387356,
-0.0641850233,
-0.0221234243,
0.0131169055,
-0.0552399568,
0.0442845747,
-0.0236126743,
0.0039008532,
0.0064756623,
-0.0370396115,
-0.0082782498,
0.0153381154,
0.1018429771,
0.0535691679,
0.0777658299,
-0.062527582,
-0.0020092945,
-0.0266269576,
0.0143409139,
0.0425694995,
0.0074877506,
0.0352402963,
0.0033565257,
-0.0072641475,
-0.0694213063,
-0.0081736734,
-0.0190475639,
0.0083887018,
0.0054060714,
0.0091846744,
-0.0028997525,
-0.0184173565,
-0.0098812487,
-0.0060571977,
0.04789415,
0.0194917191,
-0.0260689817,
0.0414411165,
-0.0181355607,
0.0115320142,
0.0414113812,
-0.0112921605,
-0.0013413904,
-0.0452523604,
0.0117395725,
0.055194363,
0.0470769629,
-0.0082848221,
0.027585797,
-0.0231348183,
0.0562531203,
-0.0370637216,
-0.0480387546,
0.0256017111,
0.0251186118,
-0.0345910564,
-0.0367277265,
0.0250648204,
-0.007878622,
0.0006515859,
0.024509564,
-0.0381245352,
-0.0401664488,
-0.0218670554,
-0.0675347671,
-0.0375360399,
0.0127041284,
-0.0214171913,
0.0478793718,
0.0025254411,
0.0029755104,
0.0003671756,
-0.0036150811,
-0.0253464133,
-0.005191742,
-0.0427900814,
0.0279226862,
-0.0154135711,
0.0243429597,
-0.0319834538,
0.007387111,
-0.0752074867,
-0.0012770529,
-0.0562612787,
0.00321557,
-0.015977392,
-0.0117817465,
-0.0086023109,
0.0062499144,
-0.0084608346,
-0.0226616524,
-0.0473625101,
0.0693807155,
-0.0336816534,
-0.0089542428,
0.0059141624,
0.0042943475,
0.034944728,
-0.0260644592,
0.0111113619,
0.0607099198,
0.0215865783,
0.0104429238,
-0.0729346946,
-0.0886091813,
0.0113435099,
-0.0156835988,
-0.0119914496,
-0.0192462131,
-0.0019276779,
0.0014854927,
-0.0095362514,
-0.009420475,
0.0099318465,
-0.0131212017,
-0.0283528809,
0.0352740288,
0.0179122481,
-0.0273696296,
-0.0008097634,
0.0026106532,
0.0087538492,
0.049802918,
0.0327622257,
0.0759913549,
0.0451644771,
0.0211062413,
0.0377411209,
0.0097882058,
0.0343920775,
0.0094139697,
0.0054290984,
-0.0545965135,
0.0235673115,
-0.0288400985,
-0.0099741919,
-0.0245682187,
-0.0289918762,
0.0060187127,
-0.0127072213,
0.0062992056,
-0.0147501053,
0.0073762941,
-0.015738003,
-0.0139407767,
0.0085613383,
0.0245864559,
-0.0165971294,
0.0140414117,
-0.0441163257,
-0.0094775567,
-0.0062154201,
-0.0112698823,
-0.0130549306,
-0.0752561092,
-0.0424431078,
-0.0222529843,
0.005668079,
0.0104918946,
0.0766051188,
0.0239026863,
-0.0684821904,
-0.0312835984,
0.0429434776,
-0.0879505798,
-0.0250209197,
0.023236068,
0.0326083712,
0.0247071236,
0.0360965282,
-0.0817580372,
-0.0239582323,
-0.0105074374,
0.009829795,
-0.0043792347,
0.002992952,
-0.0135146482,
0.0139179844,
-0.0286962576,
-0.011397359,
0.0377428532,
0.0091409152,
0.0051254649,
-0.0122153545,
-0.0015153455,
-0.0025127504,
0.0321334936,
0.0307432059,
0.0342691876,
-0.0336107388,
-0.0044930945,
0.0009809001,
0.0320685431,
0.0650962666,
0.0248174164,
-0.0054252446,
-0.0205351952,
0.0520149916,
-0.0584861562,
-0.0402558967,
0.075696148,
-0.0024472966,
-0.0486248657,
0.0037436562,
-0.0529384986,
-0.0158824269,
0.0066185715,
-0.0594132319,
-0.0474913307,
0.0583762527,
0.0345822275,
0.0355373211,
0.0019216299,
-0.0169871468,
0.0068128025,
-0.0069611249,
-0.0223981999,
0.0803525373,
0.0101000089,
0.0109321969,
-0.0403994322,
-0.0278806351,
0.0152253741,
-0.0070101623,
-0.012929501,
-0.0444296189,
0.0038906939,
-0.0304764584,
0.024775004,
-0.0508189015,
-0.0713355169,
-0.0394723192,
-0.082309857,
0.0263296943,
0.0012273433,
0.0188731849,
0.0017054226,
-0.0183681473,
-0.0266611222,
-0.0091877915,
-0.015375684,
0.0058499011,
0.0168864299,
0.0008671871,
0.0225599241,
-0.0294174664,
0.0381560996,
-0.0687411949,
0.018422991,
-0.0831935257,
0.0154878795,
0.0427351855,
-0.0446369126,
0.0054587158,
0.0658781528,
-0.0144695556,
0.0307381433,
-0.0132210776,
-0.0365500487,
-0.0289788097,
-0.0328413174,
-0.0097700488,
0.0466913916,
-0.0322012305,
0.0784471333,
-0.0049552256,
-0.0172746461,
-0.0240925141,
0.0517190099,
-0.0403809808,
0.067877911,
0.0157601498,
-0.0398604982,
-0.0348075218,
0.0796749443,
0.0220778193,
-0.0225506853,
-0.0472002067,
0.0120875826,
-0.012137739,
-0.0164630432,
-0.0114404513,
-0.0493349284,
0.0351557732,
0.0379746556,
-0.0291540027,
-0.0428155474,
0.0329470001,
0.0578639321,
0.0087714251,
-0.0527720191,
-0.0094701704,
-0.0477202423,
0.0858624503,
0.0013875922,
-0.0101696299,
0.0522104353,
0.0200903099,
-0.0151989562,
-0.0488476157,
0.0265065692,
-0.0081937928,
-0.0044633239,
-0.0477536358,
0.0104316007,
-0.0007046208,
-0.0374958776,
-0.0337570384,
-0.0457527153,
-0.0288473461,
-0.0261163469,
0.0121151721,
0.0089107333,
-0.0086893812,
-0.0218190569,
0.0111145591,
-0.016756298,
0.0036290397,
-0.0292371828,
0.01164525,
0.0147112412,
0.0425117612,
-0.0358435921,
-0.0027191052,
-0.0209205411,
0.0141239911,
0.0278114676,
0.0294421595,
-0.0032164699,
-0.0075325915,
0.0244551022,
-0.0277518351,
0.0181609057,
0.0129357958,
-0.0467408076,
-0.0233509019,
-0.062231984,
0.0431419536,
0.1011988893,
0.0523963235,
-0.0274805836,
-0.0021427949,
0.002251619,
-0.0049958047,
0.0234550331,
0.0050295624,
-0.0830120221,
-0.0079211174,
-0.0164626502,
-0.0153014679,
-0.0357725248,
-0.0484412238,
0.0027139527,
-0.0787664056,
0.0378683023,
0.005565519,
-0.0030804053,
0.0391167849,
-0.054204721,
0.0137123633,
-0.0494016744,
-0.0729062408,
-0.0694496036,
0.0188711267,
0.0106566604,
0.0212471448,
0.0152006308,
-0.0277883764,
0.0005369634,
0.0243243519,
0.0042643361,
-0.004210501,
0.0618762597,
-0.0061964528,
-0.0079247821,
0.0413109772,
0.0230169706,
-0.0199715868,
-0.0171497036,
0.087023437,
0.0029788078,
-0.0129007101,
-0.0379677117,
0.0580089241,
-0.0429786891,
-0.0205367897,
0.020392416,
0.0835383609,
-0.0162102487,
-0.0068356735,
-0.0303202402,
0.0105010541,
0.0053780177,
0.0675897673,
-0.0138328411,
-0.0130632818,
-0.0335471146,
0.0088540418,
0.0275045615,
-0.0351111814,
-0.002428584,
-0.0289957579,
-0.0556362607,
-0.0151316905,
-0.0952928737,
-0.0572946519,
0.0380943976,
0.0376855843,
0.0014768837,
-0.0071505308,
0.037492536,
-0.0193338152,
-0.0855262578,
0.0270573776,
0.0210698005,
0.0144667802,
0.0419026576,
0.013756386,
0.0170388352,
-0.0072211078,
-0.0046262485,
-0.003126875,
-0.0352085568,
-0.0402243175,
0.0201313868,
-0.0111935642,
0.019834334,
0.027787704,
-0.0189366937,
-0.0279809181,
-0.0042227134,
0.0678036883,
-0.0281692315,
-0.0046907812,
0.061933551,
0.0252062418,
-0.0099919988,
0.0097627565,
-0.0397714898,
0.0648298264,
-0.0072604693,
-0.0296336189,
-0.0475866012,
0.0269964878,
0.02922488,
0.0031593509,
0.0595486015,
0.0066317436,
-0.0446601026,
-0.0619167686,
-0.0112691727,
-0.0418312661,
-0.0507327393,
-0.0439285785,
0.0367068164,
-0.0227622539,
0.0239790883,
-0.0359316394,
-0.0268356018,
4.667e-7,
0.0124450075,
-0.0077130147,
0.0528729931,
0.047333397,
0.0220037587,
-0.036095757,
0.01887656,
-0.0054210867,
-0.0291762408,
0.0326237269,
0.0210298635,
-0.0091917133,
0.0435882658,
0.04085017,
0.0124294637,
-0.0043952228,
-0.0290889274,
-0.0503784493,
0.071835272,
0.0085600931,
-0.018024886,
0.0425616764,
-0.0649854317,
0.0484978743,
-0.0357400402,
0.0190941915,
0.0201736595,
0.0344446152,
0.0203932896,
-0.0080894232,
0.0232479349,
0.0053058127,
-0.0222651158,
0.0041799499,
0.0463731438,
-0.0563600659,
0.0835290924,
0.0134196226,
-0.0281326342,
-0.0366394147,
-0.0141011374,
0.0488345623,
0.0025700161,
0.011277996,
0.0243471283,
-0.0888827294,
-0.0280849151,
0.0540694855,
-0.0389493257,
-0.0000379825,
-0.0075841746,
0.0123901609,
0.0230496023,
-0.0051532867,
0.0040828977,
-0.0364097022,
0.0372708254,
-0.0954727232,
-0.0291210636,
-0.0126546249,
-6.10587398e-33,
-0.0340010859,
-0.0387499295,
-0.0408924781,
0.0281970315,
-0.01775329,
0.0477610528,
-0.0214605611,
-0.0205312036,
0.0232172534,
0.0729168281,
-0.0127482442,
0.0333175547,
0.0248071756,
-0.0102128033,
-0.0012656909,
-0.0143549461,
0.0333924592,
0.0188394412,
0.0158169288,
0.008670697,
0.071517095,
0.022146903,
0.0412783623,
-0.1677971631,
0.0392373838,
-0.0099518569,
-0.0451136045,
-0.0156968217,
0.0190963894,
0.0399101488,
-0.0043966644,
0.0194468759,
0.0203393642,
-0.0117807724,
0.0094007179,
0.0499285907,
-0.0466575585,
-0.0398855954,
0.0130009111,
-0.0075884392,
-0.0564202331,
-0.0333117135,
-0.0023335582,
0.0246555395,
0.0070759812,
-0.0116191525,
0.0702242404,
-0.0274876207,
0.0011456419,
-0.0974132717,
-0.0489031971,
0.0448973775,
-0.0314713754,
0.0113156475,
0.019268306,
0.0604035854,
0.0143384431,
0.0421815477,
0.011764545,
0.008810401,
-0.0049316441,
0.0003520434,
-0.0122639947,
-0.0149966283,
0.0321733207,
0.0770505518,
-0.0187041499,
0.0431998707,
-0.0230646692,
0.0382331163,
-0.0111386767,
0.0353471786,
0.0574694686,
0.087914899,
0.0343928933,
0.0111122904,
-0.0766274333,
0.0372727886,
0.0675150901,
0.0038602476,
0.0091167288,
0.0174994413,
-0.0219891295,
-0.0017193493,
-0.0060908087,
0.0109114088,
-0.0216179118,
0.0027125247,
0.017102696,
-0.0009001081,
0.0049196677,
-0.0128296921,
-0.0231001638,
-0.0296684839,
0.0060642282,
0.0362843685,
-0.0194926746,
0.0400483347,
0.0052779387,
-0.0197251961,
-0.0148487035,
-0.0192994587,
0.0205691624,
0.0365675241,
0.1012578309,
-0.0003045694,
0.0449262075,
-0.0263858475,
-0.0542144924,
-0.0261389092,
-0.0253025144,
0.019874543,
-0.0060752635,
-0.0142996144,
-0.0087212697,
0.046609506,
-0.0055263801,
0.0132552469,
0.0449236929,
0.0517298691,
-0.0103039322,
-0.0133172618,
-0.0393272229,
0.0118211554,
-0.0112875067,
-0.0387785174,
0.034323886,
-0.0134507911,
0.0287341475,
-0.0312221628,
-0.0103174942,
-0.0137944063,
2.761e-7,
0.0044021318,
0.0446906798,
0.0413555019,
-0.0121072819,
0.0025206238,
0.0373019762,
0.0109101413,
0.0183895361,
0.0337665901,
0.0160946734,
0.0320564732,
-0.0202162396,
0.0543954559,
0.0260907207,
-0.0742639974,
-0.0125092128,
0.0020825104,
-0.0482569858,
-0.0223837998,
0.0489375107,
0.1222174764,
0.0504148826,
0.0805554986,
0.0128485886,
-0.0190881491,
0.0367354751,
0.0111012841,
-0.0584115051,
-0.0129968729,
0.0082306396,
-0.0404370762,
-0.028978711,
-0.027595751,
0.0388973169,
-0.0172020327,
0.0056386376,
0.0043246802,
0.0424888209,
0.0145235881,
-0.0199979413,
0.0293891001,
0.0068932371,
0.0130346892,
-0.0076216827,
0.053493686,
-0.0368402377,
-0.0274121631,
-0.0205366444,
-0.0202034451,
0.0118218251,
0.0186715201,
0.0386358127,
-0.0285008028,
0.0512049384,
-0.0021112356,
-0.0201679338,
-0.0232957229,
-0.0966669619,
-0.0465325713,
0.0459997915,
0.0236619785,
-0.0296393763,
0.0123321293,
0.0685915276,
0.0229438394,
-0.0789748207,
0.0016721139,
2.559565481e-34,
0.0133706098,
0.0151746646,
-0.0297565889,
0.0271294042,
0.0458933637,
-0.0260557663,
-0.1164328158,
0.0403380282,
0.0446255617,
-0.0642471611,
0.0382855348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03733v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03733v2 | Methods to Estimate Large Language Model Confidence | 2023-11-28T05:44:06 | 2023-12-08T07:04:52 | Maia Kotelanski, Robert Gallo, Ashwin Nayak, Thomas Savage | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models have difficulty communicating uncertainty, which is a
significant obstacle to applying LLMs to complex medical tasks. This study
evaluates methods to measure LLM confidence when suggesting a diagnosis for
challenging clinical vignettes. GPT4 was asked a series of challenging case
questions using Chain of Thought and Self Consistency prompting. Multiple
methods were investigated to assess model confidence and evaluated on their
ability to predict the models observed accuracy. The methods evaluated were
Intrinsic Confidence, SC Agreement Frequency and CoT Response Length. SC
Agreement Frequency correlated with observed accuracy, yielding a higher Area
under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve compared to Intrinsic
Confidence and CoT Length analysis. SC agreement is the most useful proxy for
model confidence, especially for medical diagnosis. Model Intrinsic Confidence
and CoT Response Length exhibit a weaker ability to differentiate between
correct and incorrect answers, preventing them from being reliable and
interpretable markers for model confidence. We conclude GPT4 has a limited
ability to assess its own diagnostic accuracy. SC Agreement Frequency is the
most useful method to measure GPT4 confidence. | [
0.0347254537,
0.019073952,
0.0037007411,
-0.0044043767,
-0.0344339982,
0.0132981986,
-0.0168343093,
0.021648949,
-0.019745715,
-0.0031741122,
-0.0104820635,
-0.0784410685,
0.0272034146,
0.0116510959,
-0.0085819233,
-0.0074912841,
0.0112073021,
-0.0068600709,
0.0654999092,
0.0002123019,
-0.0223640352,
-0.0007361714,
-0.0347041264,
0.026618747,
0.0079010502,
-0.0271247346,
0.0399387293,
-0.0108296629,
0.0196472406,
-0.1031278372,
-0.0064453222,
0.0665931031,
0.00178153,
0.010765953,
0.0000020369,
-0.0844126642,
-0.0101513155,
-0.0080610737,
-0.0559188612,
-0.0194705445,
-0.0120793208,
0.0154888937,
0.0395454802,
0.0278394409,
-0.0332355127,
0.0151577806,
0.0380188078,
0.0428503491,
-0.0174955782,
0.0323636234,
-0.0050451676,
0.0316720679,
0.008301368,
-0.0171265043,
-0.0012387466,
-0.0560750365,
0.0225254223,
0.0462671369,
0.0207318943,
0.0036437754,
-0.0035239921,
0.0485045947,
0.0169823486,
0.0369057022,
-0.0285620447,
0.0263829958,
-0.0088027362,
-0.044807449,
0.0069905701,
0.0203432199,
0.0743043721,
0.0125732059,
-0.0274050981,
-0.0233568251,
0.0231276602,
0.0334183276,
-0.0594026744,
-0.0028633045,
-0.0200643539,
-0.0114116631,
0.0010531992,
0.0166105535,
-0.0021051913,
-0.0367273465,
-0.0095064314,
0.0416398495,
0.011403217,
-0.0124778738,
0.0482215956,
0.014087243,
-0.0281081311,
-0.0363952927,
0.0124204466,
0.0260098353,
-0.0725912228,
0.0244203769,
0.0181080475,
0.0449177697,
0.0825835466,
-0.0488679409,
0.0127133215,
0.0216724239,
-0.0219717734,
-0.0213230494,
-0.0092982855,
0.0277596768,
-0.0205490515,
0.0111855343,
-0.0444612913,
0.0386937819,
-0.0154088903,
-0.0067615071,
-0.000739008,
-0.0203290284,
0.0138689065,
-0.0051670941,
-0.1071196273,
-0.0124076707,
0.0146758659,
0.0337145925,
0.0053306767,
0.0324448906,
0.0183692705,
0.0142437061,
-0.0423271321,
0.0414632559,
0.0112930881,
0.0196826421,
-0.0101040974,
-0.0333221741,
0.0322689824,
0.0046013463,
-0.0105900047,
-0.0145840757,
0.0206527002,
0.0565578453,
-0.0102216741,
0.0031387601,
0.0071448898,
-0.0283273626,
-0.0736997053,
-0.0794633329,
-0.008563864,
-0.0731012821,
-0.0362438783,
0.0528916307,
0.0198844485,
-0.0292721316,
0.0245143324,
0.0008747887,
-0.0112307072,
0.0300485287,
-0.0440237559,
0.0376718864,
0.0016011471,
0.0144186663,
-0.0052930876,
-0.0008037326,
0.0423727296,
-0.0165309124,
0.0341402739,
-0.0321207196,
0.0455693156,
0.013985943,
-0.0266505666,
-0.0106531475,
-0.0008948063,
0.0211625267,
0.0067481506,
0.0490394197,
-0.0181509815,
0.0761127472,
0.0262912307,
0.012109587,
0.0738598779,
0.0612121001,
0.0248544607,
-0.0147616323,
0.0037383744,
-0.0338278227,
0.0221645404,
0.0173805486,
-0.0035935598,
0.0115157785,
-0.0504117571,
0.0093365898,
0.0139509961,
0.0067786942,
-0.0026484586,
-0.0551420748,
-0.0984688029,
0.0197757222,
-0.0282029472,
0.0685678795,
0.0250598658,
-0.0778890401,
-0.0216392726,
0.0207242295,
-0.0046180878,
-0.0171409231,
-0.0423422717,
-0.0654497221,
0.0148150306,
0.032540381,
-0.0133692846,
0.0172394775,
-0.0489200912,
-0.0200804193,
-0.0034914315,
0.0117799947,
0.0175435245,
0.0173965935,
0.0101117622,
-0.0235164817,
-0.0144638494,
0.0482356027,
0.0199886002,
-0.0347057581,
-0.0289849136,
0.0301302597,
-0.0167330913,
-0.0361205228,
-0.0274827946,
0.0219445322,
-0.0389966071,
-0.0268383324,
-0.0187737979,
-0.0223064572,
0.0348223373,
0.0047769528,
0.0099545596,
0.025131464,
0.0060433634,
0.0385337062,
-0.0402416401,
0.026463788,
-0.0391301923,
0.0064029256,
0.0431114249,
0.0028557475,
-0.0273995511,
-0.0411947407,
-0.0077376142,
-0.0317235552,
-0.0450454652,
-0.082781285,
-0.0032730405,
-0.0131521048,
0.0092977565,
0.0002279893,
-0.0088360347,
-0.0504410453,
0.0098094065,
0.0012024153,
0.0255885832,
0.0038966527,
-0.0286979899,
0.0478795916,
-0.0540480502,
-0.064200744,
0.0173433367,
0.0041678729,
0.0207335297,
0.0148086604,
0.023672469,
-0.0548054986,
-0.0347195417,
-0.1225138679,
-0.0064095673,
0.0344051681,
0.0130049735,
0.0040940717,
-0.0220217463,
-0.0209134314,
0.0086835148,
-0.0373800285,
-0.012629577,
0.0525230207,
0.0602382533,
0.0130043607,
0.0197383463,
-0.0356667861,
-0.0396333821,
0.0022685444,
-0.0381160676,
0.0252509862,
0.0454492457,
-0.0109666353,
-0.0277603641,
0.0474173613,
-0.0411793478,
-0.0142052164,
0.0266118646,
-0.0260594115,
0.0431217663,
-0.0162343495,
-0.0224867146,
0.0317823328,
0.0043916851,
-0.0116482154,
0.0529413037,
-0.031827081,
-0.0296103116,
-0.0137368012,
-0.0257051662,
-0.0595569983,
0.0097876452,
-0.1027608588,
-0.0149852401,
0.0636628717,
0.0507590361,
-0.0073774434,
-0.0180594232,
-0.0101509504,
0.0026507394,
0.0000924996,
-0.0039354544,
-0.017009357,
-0.040238101,
0.0995611846,
0.0297619049,
-0.0629133508,
0.0637938753,
-0.0292740259,
0.025011437,
-0.0387538597,
-0.0221997499,
-0.0129782911,
0.0468948521,
-0.023273427,
0.0175084937,
0.0286257342,
-0.0200323407,
-0.013176972,
-0.0199897345,
-0.002530246,
-0.0684928894,
0.0698491484,
-0.0665422678,
0.0202716943,
0.0322217606,
-0.0273078829,
-0.0556346849,
0.0238055922,
-0.0410041437,
-0.0024946046,
-0.0197917633,
-0.007832868,
0.0102022598,
0.0086786989,
0.0209581014,
0.0047409413,
-0.0154686486,
-0.0145830475,
-0.0082603563,
-0.0129664475,
0.0197748914,
0.0306707677,
0.0526546799,
-0.0184690151,
0.0078168372,
0.0738802925,
-0.0513798036,
0.075849697,
-0.0460838228,
-0.0182817262,
-0.0010938398,
-0.0011901697,
-0.0438487493,
0.0581354201,
0.0529132411,
-0.0090151858,
-0.0032055285,
0.1357391775,
0.0160232428,
-0.0361823402,
-0.0101568727,
-0.0446307883,
-0.033786878,
0.0040906332,
-0.0007652605,
-0.0319757685,
0.0003212804,
-0.0180946048,
0.0320917368,
-0.04973308,
-0.0146920923,
0.0120134186,
-0.0227175709,
0.0622287877,
-0.0144738741,
-0.0366161577,
-0.0368210971,
-0.0499144532,
0.0527334139,
0.0195947234,
0.0409964137,
-0.0162990615,
-0.0010039211,
0.0220463388,
0.0054535717,
-0.1097716764,
-0.0743957385,
0.0668404773,
-0.0215585362,
0.0562603399,
0.0391697958,
0.0076525677,
-0.0339294337,
-0.050425671,
0.0123957656,
0.0083987378,
-0.004359589,
-0.019384725,
0.0471445024,
0.0357249193,
0.0392647535,
-0.0618846603,
0.0184830055,
-0.0185736418,
0.0186233521,
0.025591772,
0.0952695236,
-0.0650976002,
-0.035915561,
-0.0216958635,
0.0390812904,
0.0301371142,
0.0395776518,
0.0232609715,
0.0028039047,
0.0251571015,
0.0166194513,
0.0244714376,
0.0388722718,
-0.0025148571,
0.0133682713,
-0.0025551191,
0.0058242525,
-0.0371620692,
0.0009740627,
0.0510566533,
-0.0072463094,
0.0182284508,
0.0645466745,
0.0100001013,
0.0308414605,
-0.0414615124,
0.0556673594,
0.0486634113,
0.0291327592,
-0.0673294067,
0.064910695,
0.0592693835,
0.0013382818,
-0.0141405789,
-0.0066077295,
-0.0344387665,
-0.0054177777,
-0.0005931033,
0.0157139916,
0.0357491784,
-0.0536146984,
-0.0021777311,
-0.0440321341,
-0.0050094891,
-0.0195352621,
-0.0055748769,
0.0274004303,
0.0014891735,
0.0480051897,
-0.0032779134,
0.0056671547,
-0.0042620911,
0.0023181068,
0.0170118101,
0.0227722581,
-0.0266811643,
-0.061818853,
0.0295090284,
0.0515320711,
0.0522736832,
-0.0232181232,
-0.0273196977,
-0.0148231266,
-0.0100752031,
-0.0341103263,
0.0007788572,
-0.0195889231,
0.0132284183,
0.0177861676,
-0.0199184548,
-0.0418529548,
-0.0893636346,
-0.0843644068,
-0.0208162982,
-0.0470427833,
0.041784104,
-0.0115039423,
-0.0013498063,
0.0388359353,
-0.0026411223,
-0.0188734923,
-0.0384032913,
0.0094684558,
0.0223508514,
0.0785648674,
0.0850518793,
-0.0157831628,
-0.0165634584,
0.017417077,
0.0185996722,
-0.0377449989,
-0.0796116218,
-0.0099216402,
0.0170553159,
0.0092900097,
0.0034839481,
0.0092606787,
-0.0300124213,
0.0182407796,
-0.035697639,
0.0003868371,
-0.0021193924,
0.0366281606,
0.064547725,
-0.0174838137,
-0.0175951943,
-0.0228225216,
0.0409578234,
-0.0376269668,
0.0032898278,
-0.0625834092,
-0.0742377862,
-0.0289096944,
-0.0237605851,
0.0275662411,
-0.0213765074,
-0.0601519458,
0.0207743514,
-0.0850493312,
-0.0224606097,
0.0242706314,
0.002552222,
-0.0192904398,
-0.0418206006,
0.0028929389,
0.0736167803,
-0.0193854664,
-0.0234862212,
-0.0019324935,
0.0134969763,
0.0079232911,
0.0189570095,
-0.0288541429,
-6.221500012e-33,
-0.0062698633,
-0.073072046,
0.0120297438,
-0.023086533,
-0.0024895463,
0.015513706,
-0.0331058912,
0.0713159665,
0.0162869412,
0.030067835,
-0.0225535426,
-0.019705791,
0.0275164973,
0.0270397775,
0.0478875451,
-0.0317578316,
-0.005903143,
0.0415910706,
-0.0194682777,
-0.0298027117,
0.0009241622,
-0.0104017602,
0.0826348886,
-0.1162918806,
0.0616192892,
0.0086029666,
0.0106515558,
0.0086336629,
-0.0558843799,
0.0272985026,
-0.0000383062,
0.0209035929,
0.0478243232,
-0.0128928917,
-0.0038250983,
-0.0013014117,
0.0301122963,
-0.0472478904,
0.06320934,
-0.0166648831,
-0.0359079577,
-0.0085206591,
0.0348286927,
-0.009864361,
-0.0262413397,
-0.0031359543,
0.0168554112,
-0.0448044576,
0.0398001336,
-0.013248371,
0.0032887205,
0.0309555251,
0.0207793713,
-0.0060874866,
-0.0212308448,
0.0396510549,
-0.0432856977,
-0.0115375007,
-0.007477358,
0.0009607811,
0.0199664421,
0.0093714278,
0.0351905078,
-0.0165261514,
-0.0398229286,
0.0537058972,
0.0037738415,
-0.0262349993,
-0.0381255075,
-0.0157732815,
-0.0406820178,
0.058135543,
0.0894856453,
0.0380089022,
-0.0113631357,
0.0193632096,
-0.0574011803,
0.0152471242,
-0.0415949561,
0.0436128266,
0.0438625887,
-0.0303833634,
-0.0869866237,
-0.0305915494,
-0.0371529423,
-0.0181368329,
-0.0212949272,
-0.0504035428,
0.0268932227,
-0.039929416,
0.0440290794,
0.0011648602,
0.0422385,
0.0281328484,
-0.0033680208,
-0.0857026875,
0.0301127322,
0.0312024597,
0.0002585143,
0.0272670295,
-0.0151635865,
0.0509054027,
0.0108612897,
-0.0020691815,
0.0468436033,
0.0080668805,
-0.007668288,
-0.0260094646,
-0.0609856658,
0.0336847566,
0.0039486093,
-0.0336257294,
-0.0101921344,
-0.0145126525,
0.0199192222,
0.0156190582,
-0.0175007451,
0.0466082953,
-0.0247441493,
-0.0194206703,
-0.0442644171,
-0.029320024,
-0.0232003443,
0.0055990755,
-0.0177530069,
-0.0106396759,
0.0117800357,
0.0116525479,
0.0073265079,
-0.0106030777,
-0.0059604249,
0.0022181508,
2.856e-7,
0.0786110982,
0.0521081649,
-0.0210122559,
0.0145577723,
0.0117826285,
0.0092141889,
-0.0155327907,
-0.0073378151,
0.0930780023,
-0.0682177693,
0.0289718322,
0.0044019744,
0.0184560977,
0.0563107394,
0.0016237169,
-0.059040349,
-0.019841386,
0.0230000839,
0.0060941172,
0.015174469,
0.066478163,
0.0155068561,
-0.0439980179,
-0.0351994857,
-0.0080170855,
0.0091928327,
0.0242189169,
-0.0590995997,
-0.0046601277,
0.0356547162,
0.042981416,
-0.0145785725,
0.0543050505,
0.0895824358,
-0.0041155447,
-0.0238821954,
-0.007933002,
0.0520200841,
-0.0276180357,
0.0138798272,
-0.0003357183,
0.0089481389,
0.0360722803,
-0.0598099679,
0.047098849,
-0.0422573611,
-0.0227383468,
0.0245952625,
0.0235471316,
-0.0545859225,
0.1175820604,
-0.0365148634,
-0.0056320215,
0.0186994001,
0.0113713583,
0.0404167436,
-0.0322828479,
-0.0267381761,
-0.0054402952,
0.0220512617,
-0.0406920463,
-0.0736305937,
0.0515961684,
-0.0532327667,
-0.0201663207,
-0.0997757018,
0.004618308,
2.720129514e-34,
0.0372212678,
0.0358903185,
0.0112122232,
0.0184830409,
0.0424968451,
0.0002692244,
0.0287905969,
0.0312888883,
0.0369185433,
-0.0763036385,
-0.0102947094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16522v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16522v4 | Dynamic Fault Characteristics Evaluation in Power Grid | 2023-11-28T05:00:27 | 2024-01-27T07:28:42 | Hao Pei, Si Lin, Chuanfu Li, Che Wang, Haoming Chen, Sizhe Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, eess.SP | To enhance the intelligence degree in operation and maintenance, a novel
method for fault detection in power grids is proposed. The proposed GNN-based
approach first identifies fault nodes through a specialized feature extraction
method coupled with a knowledge graph. By incorporating temporal data, the
method leverages the status of nodes from preceding and subsequent time periods
to help current fault detection. To validate the effectiveness of the node
features, a correlation analysis of the output features from each node was
conducted. The results from experiments show that this method can accurately
locate fault nodes in simulation scenarios with a remarkable accuracy.
Additionally, the graph neural network based feature modeling allows for a
qualitative examination of how faults spread across nodes, which provides
valuable insights for analyzing fault nodes. | [
-0.0340027697,
0.0117143309,
-0.0021915077,
0.0116150146,
0.0282770097,
-0.0016021801,
0.0000968638,
-0.0132203633,
0.078469798,
0.0140942903,
0.096561268,
0.0271472149,
-0.0154901538,
0.0526440814,
0.0448642001,
0.007462258,
0.033773452,
0.0317962654,
0.0265033804,
0.0112394253,
-0.0269603468,
0.0000934061,
-0.0361307152,
0.0001875586,
-0.0749864951,
-0.0517667197,
-0.0111796483,
0.0128221363,
0.0531319566,
-0.0281211156,
-0.0302907452,
-0.0328184627,
-0.0285414867,
0.0316352397,
0.000002077,
0.0279656164,
-0.0011103039,
-0.0002132185,
0.0095680896,
-0.0055342694,
-0.0645243824,
0.0390431546,
0.031715259,
0.0291974135,
-0.0659099743,
-0.0423556492,
0.0316681303,
0.0723238364,
0.0175855625,
0.0634327605,
-0.0248708259,
0.0413641818,
0.0176397432,
-0.0235881731,
-0.0669780225,
-0.01183677,
0.027797427,
0.0138843078,
-0.0121736955,
-0.089581199,
-0.0216081534,
0.0076205805,
0.021734057,
0.002211736,
0.0412088335,
0.0149480132,
0.0207862724,
0.083329767,
-0.0264086593,
0.0172570106,
-0.011772627,
-0.0050802114,
0.0419931374,
-0.0411817469,
-0.0070637162,
0.0567041487,
0.0404742584,
-0.0327570327,
-0.033080887,
-0.0064159245,
-0.0735375434,
0.0014691687,
0.0685930774,
-0.0433470719,
-0.0120201744,
0.086787045,
-0.0361230001,
-0.0024967259,
-0.0242997445,
0.0004769521,
-0.033205606,
-0.0211570207,
-0.0160737168,
-0.0209121443,
-0.0232421849,
-0.007860316,
0.0474683419,
-0.0025322321,
0.0072724437,
-0.0058127213,
-0.004128695,
-0.0371067636,
-0.0103031714,
0.002353163,
0.0226737503,
0.0924879164,
-0.0437573679,
0.0413276814,
0.0190647356,
0.0254486576,
-0.0545692891,
-0.0449115746,
0.0114779547,
0.0495396703,
0.0764541775,
-0.0132147986,
0.0079084113,
-0.011692822,
-0.0485806167,
-0.0190046281,
-0.0115515925,
0.0255434364,
0.0723444149,
0.0145630352,
-0.0180084426,
0.0349852853,
-0.0411738977,
0.0217337888,
-0.0462035351,
0.0288002696,
0.0022077214,
-0.0180279408,
0.0364827663,
0.0459741391,
-0.0167317651,
0.0273152739,
0.034965612,
-0.0345930904,
-0.0871969983,
-0.019410478,
-0.0097249607,
0.0026912885,
0.0033155363,
-0.0014360397,
-0.0249555334,
-0.0361766517,
0.0022410827,
0.021167554,
0.0088831158,
-0.0411846228,
0.0154687231,
-0.0121885603,
-0.0360386372,
0.0183947459,
0.0140994843,
-0.0401338413,
0.016005503,
-0.0214600619,
0.015688099,
-0.0245011207,
0.0102114594,
0.0105299586,
-0.0231107362,
-0.0388649814,
0.0239045583,
-0.0173956919,
0.034554936,
-0.0715189204,
-0.0201803427,
0.0023481539,
-0.0626956597,
0.0085716899,
0.0040789475,
-0.0294839032,
0.0344777517,
-0.0074618477,
0.0085898573,
0.0125069087,
0.0409462713,
0.0083961198,
-0.0240707155,
-0.0114713013,
-0.003569352,
-0.0212810207,
-0.0384881571,
0.0129129933,
-0.0397047177,
0.0211105533,
0.0183674768,
-0.017756965,
-0.0480214991,
0.0066797528,
0.0185503718,
0.0314349905,
0.0441642925,
0.007885986,
-0.015015549,
-0.0262030773,
0.0174084809,
0.0378288887,
-0.0122342575,
-0.0156621877,
0.0141998902,
0.0663309544,
0.053705316,
-0.0396783575,
-0.0935016647,
-0.0065072281,
0.0093264151,
-0.0707360059,
-0.0287419874,
0.0091249095,
0.004377672,
-0.0419406928,
-0.015348617,
-0.0228247382,
0.0326754749,
0.0062530129,
-0.0608063862,
0.033317484,
-0.0190926883,
-0.0272857733,
-0.0747258738,
0.0170567576,
0.0495305769,
0.061034169,
0.0117218336,
0.0018670674,
-0.0126432367,
0.059306059,
-0.0033617895,
-0.0206560548,
0.0236503184,
-0.0403775685,
-0.0458992682,
-0.0068904203,
-0.0403094478,
0.0031677105,
0.0413514823,
-0.0292469282,
0.0188098233,
-0.0057606031,
-0.0326056592,
-0.0792404339,
0.0468065292,
-0.0616777204,
-0.027521845,
-0.0301090349,
-0.0521987341,
0.0049992916,
0.0135908816,
0.0135716265,
0.0437515453,
0.0205161516,
-0.0349830985,
-0.0041772206,
-0.021258343,
0.0161433071,
-0.0383911133,
-0.0188205075,
-0.0078997342,
-0.0691670552,
-0.0264648683,
-0.0163497981,
-0.0176810995,
0.0489228331,
0.0772201046,
-0.0782664865,
-0.0075434768,
-0.0220469963,
0.0079076476,
0.0027230179,
-0.0232699104,
0.0273570586,
-0.0253069308,
-0.0204892773,
0.0877044722,
-0.0139651056,
-0.0664982423,
-0.008256468,
0.0205739588,
-0.0271531027,
-0.0084789386,
-0.0162281748,
-0.0084583741,
0.0850414112,
0.089360334,
-0.0349087715,
-0.0159137137,
0.0517169535,
-0.0261643007,
-0.0136077292,
0.0003779852,
-0.0371519588,
-0.0559128411,
-0.0336652622,
-0.000759284,
0.0205046497,
-0.0355783589,
0.0402954072,
0.018062979,
-0.0286745708,
0.0014167982,
0.0372503549,
-0.0475765951,
0.0865680501,
-0.0289661828,
-0.0103864521,
-0.0191102251,
-0.0192180704,
0.0663495809,
0.0003057601,
0.0143489819,
-0.0182256196,
0.0048356261,
0.0030504996,
0.0118170585,
-0.0340273418,
0.0164420586,
-0.0286775641,
-0.0148345092,
0.0426799394,
0.0383840911,
0.0136263864,
0.0107009728,
0.0419737771,
-0.0638106987,
-0.0283611491,
0.0081877494,
-0.0063454001,
0.0363549553,
0.0026937495,
-0.0194002073,
-0.0076975031,
-0.0133274999,
0.033615198,
0.0261492375,
-0.0081158383,
-0.023562219,
0.0628262386,
0.0563275665,
0.0214261208,
-0.0100057423,
0.0281193163,
0.0230867099,
-0.0180822965,
0.0078615174,
-0.0432977043,
0.073215723,
0.0335818343,
-0.0526681915,
0.0355130546,
-0.0042166412,
0.0171487611,
0.0112697119,
0.0687360913,
-0.0391875803,
0.0159544442,
0.0479558185,
0.0121365162,
0.0322045982,
0.0093314163,
-0.0154416515,
-0.0408985019,
-0.0723677799,
0.004186715,
-0.0881797671,
-0.0163787883,
0.0005225061,
-0.0587572455,
-0.0195624083,
-0.0798355117,
-0.0102253379,
-0.0116294334,
0.0124778487,
-0.0140999481,
0.0002358228,
0.0436206944,
-0.0094039496,
0.0017172268,
0.0249409173,
-0.0004800693,
0.0101401554,
0.0138561353,
0.0352931172,
-0.0129852127,
-0.0091557661,
0.0319435298,
-0.0002016485,
-0.0182482265,
0.0032555526,
-0.0170940347,
-0.0744301081,
-0.0101463422,
0.0037096851,
-0.0251490418,
-0.0434273519,
-0.0204161685,
0.0224858858,
-0.0385165624,
0.0383062772,
-0.0724485293,
-0.0571364537,
-0.0183056854,
-0.0173496306,
0.062178012,
0.0463125631,
0.0248834267,
-0.0240382738,
-0.0060609775,
0.0367176421,
0.0549195819,
0.0182101373,
-0.0178677198,
0.0419967733,
0.057688918,
-0.0020259998,
-0.0205027163,
0.0322061628,
-0.0428711884,
0.0202213563,
0.0014875097,
0.0770130903,
-0.0269757342,
-0.0388529487,
-0.0202440768,
-0.0165003221,
0.0623112954,
-0.0444409251,
0.0426953323,
0.0063385041,
-0.0766955987,
0.0112708705,
0.0152593823,
-0.0317229889,
-0.0081232376,
0.030358538,
0.0571939275,
0.0075974693,
-0.0263790973,
-0.0356983244,
-0.022663381,
-0.0100241527,
0.0206189919,
-0.0821111426,
0.04080211,
-0.0050206333,
-0.0668938458,
-0.0233483948,
0.0663048327,
0.0386597179,
-0.0110983951,
0.0066669732,
-0.0042075296,
0.0070967847,
-0.018832244,
-0.0078230919,
-0.0263656285,
-0.0006855151,
0.0116987331,
-0.0123120323,
-0.0078949584,
0.0219721124,
-0.075564988,
0.0124198571,
0.0199010577,
0.0081302626,
-0.0518600456,
0.0049055894,
0.0057493281,
-0.0739150196,
0.0067065293,
0.0416658558,
-0.029309826,
0.0168720353,
-0.0187730845,
0.0177685134,
-0.0277511049,
-0.0035178128,
-0.0192494728,
0.0140218716,
0.0033710438,
0.0616757907,
-0.0024363543,
-0.0764908046,
-0.0227702241,
0.041877497,
0.0258337017,
-0.0272947624,
0.0113448799,
-0.0259568989,
0.010211926,
0.0001343574,
-0.0075469706,
0.0826065168,
-0.0508646667,
-0.004167085,
-0.0348227248,
0.0190709215,
-0.0165162589,
0.0030619393,
0.0457487032,
0.0204962101,
0.0335429199,
0.0312794186,
-0.0458595492,
0.0325541534,
0.0070685344,
0.0428553,
-0.0632611066,
-0.0432319716,
-0.0341388769,
-0.0395347588,
-0.0354509242,
-0.0073770508,
-0.0123127587,
0.0765272975,
0.083380796,
0.0417169333,
-0.0113042565,
0.0233529843,
-0.0002736279,
0.0322132185,
-0.0010653121,
0.0053614974,
0.0152358655,
0.0045943791,
-0.0260518268,
0.0255131312,
0.0231967214,
0.0385750979,
-0.0033985223,
-0.0132086799,
-0.0143699422,
-0.0067640692,
0.0193969812,
0.0405201539,
-0.0018802831,
-0.0095885843,
0.0044565629,
-0.0539414585,
-0.0317783058,
0.0229190029,
-0.0128635308,
0.0143611049,
-0.0145334387,
0.0539220534,
-0.006249004,
0.0355226062,
0.1038769484,
0.0024383534,
-0.0182738714,
-0.0562981665,
0.0127347251,
-0.0019135585,
-5.309851246e-33,
0.0118522951,
-0.1148710921,
-0.0302737691,
0.0425146855,
-0.0415511094,
0.0336176828,
-0.0196107384,
-0.0280616712,
0.0141444458,
0.0519323125,
0.0307477303,
0.0287370197,
-0.023107769,
0.0044186395,
-0.0224174671,
0.0145046748,
0.0522480197,
0.0098465672,
0.0313112438,
0.0806456134,
0.0857136026,
0.0357589945,
0.0602390282,
-0.0652242526,
-0.0258778557,
-0.0151941609,
0.0178522728,
0.0254702717,
-0.0268657971,
0.0229913108,
-0.0061499444,
0.0482480451,
0.010255619,
-0.0048743165,
0.0193646885,
-0.0459543876,
-0.0332119241,
-0.037515115,
-0.0776077062,
0.0345285125,
-0.0358389355,
-0.0283385534,
0.0596839935,
0.0089034578,
0.032634303,
-0.0131500326,
0.0834833235,
0.0469559506,
-0.0067596519,
-0.0502361208,
0.0378822982,
0.0311390627,
-0.0587908849,
0.0151654836,
-0.023527585,
-0.0238524284,
-0.0259514656,
-0.0409752093,
-0.041111622,
-0.0016954172,
0.054108873,
-0.0364810936,
-0.0098416815,
0.0169757064,
0.00101876,
0.0156229036,
-0.0276232231,
-0.0376689024,
-0.0184950568,
0.0210267715,
0.015586785,
0.0614670776,
0.0197987556,
-0.0232126601,
-0.0515882969,
-0.1054174379,
-0.1048971862,
-0.0180297047,
0.007330968,
0.0179512203,
-0.0183785763,
-0.0148982331,
0.015562539,
-0.0083439136,
0.0473002195,
-0.0483084098,
-0.0349158496,
-0.0323177017,
-0.0047051674,
0.00576569,
-0.0336727239,
0.0766724721,
-0.045030687,
-0.0544079207,
0.0222920198,
0.0958560035,
-0.0069079511,
0.0400364958,
0.0184039194,
-0.0109374812,
-0.0586488657,
0.0026659376,
-0.0016720126,
0.0112983473,
-0.0003600599,
0.0024992626,
0.0203797538,
0.0704363659,
0.0377818123,
0.0221972372,
0.0271243956,
-0.0196003318,
-0.0735295042,
0.0190861933,
0.0233970191,
0.0048690103,
-0.0054751863,
0.0559839942,
0.0112747485,
0.062342342,
0.0222489089,
0.0721361041,
-0.0084234122,
0.015071176,
-0.0498418845,
-0.0445044748,
-0.0446251407,
0.0202037096,
-0.0737615749,
0.0139805051,
-0.0071198381,
0.0323891528,
2.958e-7,
-0.0108180689,
0.0152674746,
0.0421215184,
-0.0117425499,
0.0033181517,
0.0046514808,
0.00388363,
-0.0007745053,
-0.0324480236,
0.0543485768,
0.0730186701,
-0.0324870907,
-0.0453117006,
0.0149141243,
-0.0172473732,
0.0104921777,
0.0050483881,
0.0294278245,
-0.0280670654,
-0.0619279183,
0.0436256379,
-0.0378379002,
0.0739151165,
0.0045821401,
0.0486313514,
-0.0738318413,
-0.0031326262,
0.0126174632,
0.0209695492,
-0.0058659902,
0.0332443565,
0.0292161368,
-0.0154103599,
0.0142177558,
0.0185357183,
0.0261889677,
-0.0206031259,
-0.0686739832,
0.0254046936,
-0.0738200694,
-0.0159674138,
0.0148678916,
0.0562062003,
-0.0246551279,
0.0234687235,
-0.0344253406,
-0.0497106016,
0.0709787607,
0.0078518772,
-0.0185223259,
-0.006212702,
0.0012027912,
0.0053189094,
0.0118521517,
-0.0184265692,
-0.0449749343,
0.0330584943,
-0.0265503619,
0.0436668992,
-0.006178421,
-0.0044840043,
-0.0260656476,
0.0164229274,
-0.010727712,
0.0661895722,
0.0318571478,
-0.0145808989,
2.222112965e-34,
-0.0199609417,
0.0050589424,
-0.0588821247,
0.0311773848,
-0.009381271,
-0.0100561092,
-0.0416640341,
-0.0180830862,
-0.0255320501,
-0.0561212301,
0.0027352155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16509v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16509v2 | StyleCap: Automatic Speaking-Style Captioning from Speech Based on Speech and Language Self-supervised Learning Models | 2023-11-28T04:49:17 | 2023-12-27T14:41:23 | Kazuki Yamauchi, Yusuke Ijima, Yuki Saito | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose StyleCap, a method to generate natural language descriptions of
speaking styles appearing in speech. Although most of conventional techniques
for para-/non-linguistic information recognition focus on the category
classification or the intensity estimation of pre-defined labels, they cannot
provide the reasoning of the recognition result in an interpretable manner.
StyleCap is a first step towards an end-to-end method for generating
speaking-style prompts from speech, i.e., automatic speaking-style captioning.
StyleCap is trained with paired data of speech and natural language
descriptions. We train neural networks that convert a speech representation
vector into prefix vectors that are fed into a large language model (LLM)-based
text decoder. We explore an appropriate text decoder and speech feature
representation suitable for this new task. The experimental results demonstrate
that our StyleCap leveraging richer LLMs for the text decoder, speech
self-supervised learning (SSL) features, and sentence rephrasing augmentation
improves the accuracy and diversity of generated speaking-style captions.
Samples of speaking-style captions generated by our StyleCap are publicly
available. | [
-0.0123529136,
0.0258773882,
0.0156949833,
0.0321578346,
0.0132848918,
-0.0138418926,
0.0030637134,
-0.0408689976,
0.0083531551,
-0.0397911668,
-0.0858494788,
0.0059466399,
0.0323644951,
0.0601853691,
0.0200101025,
-0.0806140676,
-0.0023335028,
-0.0526423045,
0.0032016526,
-0.0162110385,
0.0258416012,
0.0495810099,
-0.0463565551,
0.0153853409,
-0.0159965195,
-0.0326681137,
-0.0134979961,
0.0196722895,
-0.0156164514,
-0.017194543,
0.0150260841,
0.0775311068,
0.0618697219,
-0.0329029709,
0.0000016841,
-0.0205207244,
0.0283481814,
-0.026246449,
0.0089414595,
0.0192444753,
0.048774451,
0.0070548323,
0.003792065,
0.0484822318,
-0.0001263752,
-0.0453347266,
0.0257840026,
0.0762603059,
0.0829600841,
0.0429579355,
0.0136984261,
-0.0825752839,
-0.0185227171,
-0.0429867953,
-0.0187387001,
-0.0173864458,
-0.0268648528,
0.0353488661,
-0.0174579397,
0.0053734155,
0.0101110926,
0.0686224997,
-0.0340600349,
-0.0358854681,
0.0216131657,
0.0099529689,
-0.0569591448,
0.0227091815,
-0.030115271,
0.0733775944,
0.0631591156,
0.0031491888,
-0.0059947902,
0.0278962646,
0.0364080407,
-0.0120934425,
-0.0304699354,
0.0381765664,
0.0160129126,
-0.0037877783,
-0.0188290942,
0.0876484215,
0.0054351948,
-0.017371295,
0.0107866544,
-0.011714302,
-0.0154268062,
-0.0020042735,
-0.0363535397,
-0.0393210463,
0.0106308535,
-0.0324045084,
0.0281947702,
-0.0058169733,
0.0188561119,
0.0087548383,
-0.0538840145,
-0.0125313587,
-0.0096251294,
-0.025225522,
0.0180951022,
-0.0061736898,
-0.0229999311,
0.0306492653,
0.0000899225,
0.0216592178,
-0.0045746309,
-0.002449614,
-0.0469949245,
-0.0026865269,
-0.0583995059,
-0.02813912,
-0.0438388102,
0.0398301557,
-0.0172454361,
-0.0293639656,
-0.0425598212,
-0.0099944044,
-0.0153121399,
0.0149797862,
0.0127317281,
0.0290085152,
0.0108141247,
-0.00415227,
0.0099035436,
0.0204268079,
0.0086110402,
0.004591973,
-0.003771001,
-0.0132651459,
-0.0003824947,
0.0467457436,
0.0476126522,
-0.0098481122,
0.0259093046,
0.0431098901,
-0.0409861356,
-0.0307731982,
-0.0394487567,
-0.0201714505,
-0.071513623,
0.0027616411,
-0.0254693702,
-0.0465649851,
0.0049974951,
-0.0274849217,
0.0079446658,
-0.0400899462,
0.0129588647,
0.0202697981,
0.0217548143,
0.0615867525,
0.001856224,
0.036332909,
0.0670960024,
-0.0090183914,
0.0159840938,
0.0246849768,
0.0511077084,
0.020512173,
0.0159109477,
-0.0548166521,
0.0507033318,
0.0585161746,
0.0043912069,
-0.0023197427,
-0.0471910834,
-0.0373915993,
0.019906519,
0.0185486134,
0.0666254312,
0.0378357284,
0.0164327063,
0.0107882777,
0.0796654746,
0.0482178591,
0.0202662684,
0.0239952747,
0.0252624527,
0.0534253865,
0.0187849682,
-0.0103529813,
0.0049215951,
-0.0050907354,
-0.0131026329,
0.0188280754,
0.0231389385,
0.0003807814,
-0.05351834,
-0.0510022752,
0.0082135471,
-0.0340660326,
-0.0110248718,
0.0061774966,
0.0005907184,
0.0332847089,
-0.0279194694,
0.0156468283,
-0.0088925725,
-0.0646995306,
0.0012867254,
-0.0424940996,
-0.0349107943,
0.0924419239,
0.019885933,
-0.0148175284,
-0.0111234142,
-0.0551066883,
0.0221988335,
0.0306738764,
0.0332956649,
-0.0160648376,
0.0173766576,
-0.0435133614,
0.0180069692,
-0.0209035594,
-0.0052148858,
0.0196563154,
-0.0502046458,
0.0301438533,
0.0452159978,
0.0053395629,
-0.060666617,
0.0056255632,
0.0157501809,
-0.0904353485,
0.0692603961,
0.0029718513,
-0.0086144609,
0.065148063,
-0.0490047149,
-0.0030478612,
0.0026061472,
-0.0291435868,
0.0013658956,
0.0817352161,
-0.0886527374,
-0.0676928014,
0.0069077248,
-0.0358354859,
-0.0291689392,
0.0211159475,
-0.0133388238,
-0.0988127887,
0.0122731728,
-0.0661448613,
-0.0090970555,
-0.0715761483,
0.0117999958,
-0.0025009492,
0.0246147737,
0.0101409797,
0.0171571746,
0.0394120105,
-0.0645704716,
0.020825604,
0.0021219002,
-0.0034027915,
-0.0564705804,
-0.0375097208,
-0.0144689083,
-0.0140963802,
0.0251284875,
-0.0007034148,
0.0352646038,
-0.0226225723,
0.0021982668,
-0.1040478125,
-0.0213055313,
-0.0247230232,
-0.0321398824,
0.0045401067,
-0.0003373643,
-0.008848588,
-0.0382812954,
-0.0680425912,
-0.0930819213,
0.0158609319,
-0.029287884,
0.0244938396,
0.0045064786,
-0.053700801,
-0.0297364946,
0.0117754592,
-0.0064075822,
0.0335837752,
0.0007021066,
-0.0164206307,
-0.0631815642,
-0.0161268171,
0.0344358869,
0.0103319734,
0.0160843581,
-0.0111155277,
-0.0111117167,
0.0062435595,
0.0244257078,
0.0379189663,
0.0738332868,
-0.0152886109,
0.042130392,
-0.0003473659,
-0.0226288717,
0.0085129626,
0.0026027958,
-0.0044284998,
0.0107013118,
-0.0351056755,
0.0362331606,
0.0242109522,
0.0584139563,
0.0537375472,
-0.0408406071,
-0.0044163531,
0.0317902602,
-0.0760041252,
-0.0309314691,
-0.0143073089,
-0.0591938347,
0.0156128639,
0.0295548458,
-0.0216685347,
0.0205852035,
-0.1064694971,
-0.0634645894,
-0.0065808045,
-0.0613186657,
-0.0279860441,
0.0493983291,
-0.0197890755,
0.0506839119,
0.0208960995,
-0.0803685859,
0.0584026165,
-0.0302935559,
0.0080771074,
-0.0446064696,
0.0310486965,
-0.0393335186,
-0.0291286949,
0.0404933952,
-0.0264693461,
-0.0536039174,
-0.0526708849,
-0.0301329438,
-0.0106594935,
-0.0292525981,
-0.0233428385,
0.0248642974,
0.0319226347,
0.0035401552,
0.0532399006,
-0.0357826501,
0.024047384,
-0.0206988417,
0.0382934287,
0.0311005097,
0.0597649366,
-0.0993750691,
0.0241738241,
0.0332149267,
-0.0450553,
0.0280039348,
0.0571316108,
-0.0525273196,
-0.0082728397,
0.0354027003,
-0.007871924,
-0.0004331145,
0.0219610333,
0.0462808535,
-0.0426992141,
0.0194518529,
0.159705013,
0.010370275,
-0.0361455157,
-0.0287493207,
-0.0100440094,
0.0199852064,
0.0262809787,
0.0340466648,
-0.0341872759,
-0.0582199171,
0.0053357896,
0.044160597,
0.0362522863,
0.0437655188,
-0.0321231186,
-0.0648519397,
0.0438150018,
0.0288417246,
-0.0766544342,
-0.0500587076,
-0.0216385759,
-0.0349339098,
-0.0111991568,
-0.0055817612,
-0.003280892,
-0.0504580066,
-0.0306939892,
0.0350120626,
-0.0582602099,
-0.0441710167,
0.0326492637,
-0.0376326367,
0.0850203931,
0.0633879453,
0.0103353439,
-0.0429073274,
-0.0140617369,
-0.0020654292,
-0.0127816629,
0.0148636429,
0.0135240629,
0.0299221054,
-0.0405232348,
-0.0189614985,
0.0089557339,
0.0789320767,
-0.0079531679,
0.0199485235,
0.0473039858,
0.0027245861,
-0.0110715283,
0.0151211992,
-0.0140138855,
0.0551999286,
0.0216380116,
0.087174885,
0.054980427,
-0.0443355776,
0.0194116514,
-0.0338230133,
0.0252684206,
-0.0355171859,
-0.0628721565,
0.0335530825,
0.0261100326,
-0.0094643487,
-0.0478107333,
-0.0190970115,
0.0346148312,
-0.007226136,
0.0401414223,
0.0119290194,
0.0212255828,
0.0439362861,
-0.056907624,
0.0138714835,
-0.0506377034,
0.0201675911,
-0.0635288507,
-0.040671248,
0.0629042685,
-0.057410989,
-0.009596576,
0.0474331379,
0.0099868458,
-0.0377075076,
-0.0102013946,
0.0459130406,
0.0051477938,
0.0706532747,
-0.0167593546,
-0.035154555,
0.0483336858,
0.0728316531,
0.023127608,
-0.0001102927,
0.0435562432,
0.0210559014,
-0.0384816788,
-0.0007471551,
-0.0108071323,
0.0265682545,
-0.0655488521,
-0.0078522051,
-0.0237589553,
-0.0479505956,
-0.0076485951,
0.0240816753,
0.0127712572,
-0.0275252853,
0.0451504141,
-0.0329646692,
0.0062950091,
0.012057784,
-0.0051370813,
-0.0363674909,
0.0177989919,
0.025849048,
0.0064994749,
0.0105073806,
-0.0162844639,
-0.050819844,
-0.0107076727,
-0.0225166418,
0.0137902182,
0.0063606929,
0.0103480387,
-0.0413176864,
0.0024499518,
-0.0377112031,
0.0339837484,
0.0187753867,
0.0249415096,
0.0068317181,
0.0056438209,
-0.014050276,
-0.0184599385,
-0.0168115683,
0.0645651147,
-0.0006391341,
-0.0053705275,
-0.0340993404,
0.0484259091,
0.0402594395,
-0.0156019833,
0.0175076388,
-0.0086341063,
0.0452733301,
-0.0182430651,
0.0424910598,
-0.0163563453,
-0.0279085338,
0.034478832,
-0.01141054,
-0.0335946605,
-0.0237951428,
0.0402857102,
0.0305576641,
0.0027618485,
0.0211905781,
-0.0165345222,
-0.0578633025,
-0.0391372256,
-0.0141112823,
0.0027962483,
-0.0044466415,
-0.0008754537,
-0.0063523506,
-0.0403535105,
0.0346839316,
0.0038352511,
0.0149291437,
0.0042064786,
0.0380077474,
0.0018804178,
-0.0280535407,
0.001008521,
-0.0092987642,
-0.0011048057,
-0.0017299034,
0.0037666957,
-0.0149250217,
-5.242174363e-33,
-0.040365506,
-0.024980817,
0.0038578899,
0.0462046415,
-0.0259020757,
-0.0214258488,
-0.029913146,
0.0303327888,
0.0104341665,
-0.0068558352,
-0.0248709898,
-0.0213467088,
0.0183347464,
0.0814900547,
0.0076735346,
-0.0046225749,
0.0598564148,
-0.0111058215,
-0.0148163345,
0.0337824821,
0.0220633615,
0.013662274,
0.0528087094,
-0.1107412428,
-0.0180716496,
-0.042888388,
-0.0312238261,
0.0100694299,
0.0612551011,
0.0174757522,
-0.0032417416,
0.0343017168,
-0.0070476276,
-0.042921003,
0.0038280655,
0.0623705946,
-0.0601029731,
0.0136879003,
0.0229746699,
0.0445877314,
0.0098504275,
-0.0365686752,
-0.001567511,
-0.0221650153,
-0.0106427828,
0.0235403012,
0.0789823085,
-0.0191164259,
0.0280946642,
-0.0130498847,
-0.0000789851,
0.0075092916,
-0.0257021021,
-0.0426989868,
0.0332316905,
0.0573760793,
0.0078905066,
-0.0037566207,
-0.0128050372,
0.0484095402,
0.0308234934,
0.0030681186,
0.0706906617,
0.0673295334,
-0.0178784039,
0.0637047514,
-0.0063364273,
-0.00602378,
-0.0381502435,
-0.0002204679,
0.0225865841,
0.0452778116,
-0.0042603528,
0.0351794735,
0.0010456353,
0.0157623775,
0.0141960187,
0.0276669692,
0.0028951038,
-0.0349270739,
0.0256138649,
-0.0003348344,
-0.0381736308,
0.0187970903,
-0.0829465166,
-0.011831888,
-0.0241699163,
-0.0024032909,
0.028703399,
0.0051961164,
-0.0413380638,
0.0290176366,
0.0364723094,
-0.0093960902,
-0.0212835949,
-0.0033527724,
-0.0128466897,
0.019146027,
-0.0287054628,
0.0020536345,
0.0056045158,
-0.0222895276,
0.0445605777,
0.0279123522,
0.0434001572,
0.0127943652,
0.0364827774,
0.0456017181,
-0.0360598825,
0.0021500541,
0.0266391542,
0.0352487713,
-0.0759581327,
-0.0283162296,
0.0128145013,
0.0465024114,
-0.0576468036,
0.0082600499,
-0.03186002,
0.0107669169,
-0.0185114723,
-0.091689758,
0.0041042315,
0.0317614563,
-0.0264241807,
0.0267540142,
-0.0158968437,
-0.0105452845,
0.0189414416,
-0.0428280123,
0.0097682001,
0.0083500268,
2.311e-7,
-0.0224849861,
0.0229470935,
0.0456907786,
0.0528013892,
0.0347661041,
0.0530928709,
0.011423043,
0.034657903,
0.0038021982,
-0.0294926018,
0.0358787924,
0.01063859,
0.0497165546,
-0.022284342,
-0.1215012968,
-0.0520667359,
-0.0516778193,
0.0434165224,
-0.0203291886,
-0.0097225877,
0.0645730644,
0.0629854053,
-0.0059201512,
-0.0349484943,
0.0298577361,
-0.0467719547,
0.0417722501,
-0.0340160765,
0.0197061393,
0.0127332248,
0.005669517,
0.0245921817,
-0.037051525,
0.0040743169,
-0.0081139756,
0.0081299031,
0.0262468401,
0.0594877638,
0.0217130091,
-0.0249093845,
-0.0308057833,
0.0840656012,
-0.0240389947,
0.0228279233,
0.0644468963,
0.0008335814,
-0.0255193058,
-0.0345803797,
-0.0116677219,
-0.0185552463,
0.0217138827,
-0.0325000174,
-0.0317030884,
0.0449857265,
0.0216601081,
-0.0414789654,
-0.0302963611,
-0.0777671039,
-0.0201978944,
0.0035905463,
-0.0605882443,
0.0219786484,
-0.0324440524,
-0.0085003842,
-0.0024137583,
-0.0405584052,
0.0214840807,
1.585179042e-34,
0.0193350092,
-0.0043863538,
0.0032162766,
0.0090261595,
0.0020841407,
0.0148696424,
0.0204186831,
0.0120762158,
0.029240353,
-0.0665703565,
-0.0237553436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16466v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16466v2 | Large language models can enhance persuasion through linguistic feature alignment | 2023-11-28T04:07:34 | 2024-02-12T16:20:45 | Minkyu Shin, Jin Kim | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Although large language models (LLMs) are reshaping various aspects of human
life, our current understanding of their impacts remains somewhat constrained.
Here we investigate the impact of LLMs on human communication, using data on
consumer complaints in the financial industry. By employing an AI detection
tool on more than 820K complaints gathered by the Consumer Financial Protection
Bureau (CFPB), we find a sharp increase in the likely use of LLMs shortly after
the release of ChatGPT. Moreover, the likely LLM usage was positively
correlated with message persuasiveness (i.e., increased likelihood of obtaining
relief from financial firms). Computational linguistic analyses suggest that
the positive correlation may be explained by LLMs' enhancement of various
linguistic features. Based on the results of these observational studies, we
hypothesize that LLM usage may enhance a comprehensive set of linguistic
features, increasing message persuasiveness to receivers with heterogeneous
linguistic preferences (i.e., linguistic feature alignment). We test this
hypothesis in preregistered experiments and find support for it. As an instance
of early empirical demonstrations of LLM usage for enhancing persuasion, our
research highlights the transformative potential of LLMs in human
communication. | [
0.0592070818,
0.0902383402,
-0.0280528832,
0.0005262042,
-0.0407034978,
0.0172013156,
0.019109685,
0.0191192478,
0.0420593657,
-0.0642998517,
0.0006917757,
-0.023208376,
0.0265334751,
0.0145868203,
0.0314121842,
-0.0304276776,
-0.0044654389,
-0.000103931,
0.1057903469,
-0.0271262005,
0.0535979196,
0.0267880578,
0.0165607315,
0.0707403496,
-0.0373846628,
-0.0293357279,
0.0296833459,
-0.0081682662,
-0.0152455755,
-0.02894786,
0.0217104163,
0.053336326,
0.0288694669,
0.0316727944,
0.0000018133,
-0.0743168592,
0.0243299808,
0.00932445,
-0.0544317998,
0.0396105684,
0.0882800445,
-0.0227659382,
-0.0348209217,
0.0083013335,
-0.0362894647,
0.0469909497,
0.0886766315,
0.0724998116,
0.0346886702,
0.0593553893,
-0.0189057402,
-0.0380058698,
0.0156802591,
0.0030089917,
-0.0221815426,
-0.0054361224,
0.0268475767,
-0.0216931272,
-0.0029976924,
-0.0020762698,
0.0141856531,
0.0201303884,
-0.0419063196,
-0.0163412057,
-0.0318880044,
0.0250484757,
-0.0592044182,
-0.0120809665,
-0.0134530114,
0.0319107324,
0.0144413747,
-0.0194942951,
-0.0080754422,
0.0065935082,
0.050127387,
0.0235506278,
-0.0410285704,
0.0290706716,
0.0080618896,
0.0190390479,
0.0294274688,
-0.0029292705,
0.0285177361,
0.029412739,
0.0103173871,
0.034506727,
-0.011656276,
-0.0596888065,
0.0525049269,
-0.009394737,
0.006908359,
-0.0704881474,
-0.0113100549,
-0.0214755367,
-0.0224010777,
0.0334335491,
0.0083053531,
0.0022481109,
0.0262575541,
-0.1369915158,
0.0286480971,
0.0362849347,
0.0044760434,
0.0046929261,
0.014328192,
0.0299488623,
-0.0296750832,
0.0128160575,
-0.0028044474,
0.0218998138,
-0.0536117367,
-0.0354963727,
-0.0146438871,
0.016700685,
0.0205158815,
-0.0201781876,
-0.055381082,
0.0055161193,
-0.0435947068,
0.0051328125,
-0.0449110046,
-0.0025002735,
0.0041623218,
-0.0235598478,
-0.0477565266,
0.0400314704,
-0.0349488594,
0.027139904,
0.001762958,
-0.036704544,
0.0325506888,
0.0377202481,
-0.0316106938,
-0.0212139226,
0.0023428681,
0.0328479148,
0.0065552187,
-0.0110593168,
-0.0384647213,
-0.0002872835,
-0.0274241548,
-0.0482915081,
-0.0560536608,
-0.047968097,
-0.0221920386,
0.0031991391,
-0.0124608269,
-0.049866084,
0.0046058474,
0.0036665599,
-0.0607685,
0.055974029,
-0.0041122078,
0.0319785625,
0.0416003838,
-0.0074378904,
0.0034022056,
0.0504044294,
0.0306511689,
0.0314737894,
0.037769679,
-0.0268566757,
0.0295034647,
0.0362464674,
-0.0386331007,
0.0241906792,
0.0070439414,
-0.0373688713,
-0.0476019308,
0.0136175072,
-0.0028311834,
0.0562037118,
-0.0025948805,
-0.0086814249,
0.1017820761,
0.0741414055,
-0.0012376083,
0.0145995375,
-0.0182453897,
0.0338342078,
-0.0069602584,
0.0186305474,
-0.0155396331,
-0.0372581333,
-0.074292466,
-0.0085429531,
0.0130078131,
0.0257477332,
-0.0419520549,
-0.026637109,
-0.0271438695,
-0.0185788926,
0.0526848063,
0.0210651159,
0.0131826792,
-0.0071028373,
-0.0005585583,
0.0180738997,
0.0540243387,
-0.017172033,
-0.059162654,
-0.0230220109,
0.0232885275,
0.0749308839,
0.0017692827,
0.0226979367,
0.0408226252,
-0.0481935218,
0.0069192918,
0.0935268104,
0.0522293262,
0.0064077922,
-0.0618781559,
-0.0185256228,
-0.0026001425,
0.0028202457,
0.0025981106,
0.0302224364,
-0.0277600307,
0.0234355535,
-0.019122256,
0.0071357959,
-0.0570147783,
-0.0097261518,
0.0376635268,
-0.0144902179,
-0.0269952621,
0.0182296447,
0.0374372676,
0.0177177507,
-0.010651933,
-0.0021559207,
0.0101676388,
-0.0287419297,
-0.0289904308,
0.0370720774,
0.0098758703,
0.0663855001,
0.0188083332,
-0.0041966615,
-0.0154224262,
-0.0063366476,
0.0104951151,
0.0200595502,
0.0373549648,
-0.0532334931,
0.0607522354,
-0.008759303,
0.0228663199,
-0.0333514474,
0.0202965289,
-0.0237575397,
0.0412817188,
0.0349204876,
-0.0322646312,
-0.027357582,
-0.0396973602,
-0.002398531,
-0.023515787,
0.0088996794,
0.031828437,
0.0186599344,
0.0308944099,
0.0686606988,
-0.034001369,
-0.0180034954,
-0.0239086412,
-0.1015804932,
-0.0417643562,
0.0133443912,
0.0185449049,
-0.0075881477,
-0.0106192483,
-0.0121606644,
0.0495745279,
-0.0875179097,
-0.0453320891,
0.0022455517,
0.0439568944,
0.0358584449,
-0.0302130207,
-0.0668165088,
-0.005744095,
-0.0048164376,
-0.0359005481,
0.0283061992,
0.0613514893,
-0.0528477207,
-0.0586267598,
0.0129605671,
-0.0290977675,
-0.0081929239,
-0.0051412457,
-0.0439282916,
0.0255798716,
0.03858307,
0.0439705588,
0.0428460538,
0.0437363684,
0.0522043295,
-0.0059107067,
0.0419519693,
-0.0629372746,
-0.0109041519,
-0.0353315659,
-0.0057862648,
-0.0708381236,
-0.0485701449,
0.0381192751,
0.0145913409,
0.0079388395,
0.0077449754,
-0.030071659,
0.0713684782,
0.0095818099,
-0.0293500759,
-0.0304834917,
-0.0560582764,
-0.0247454066,
0.0555311441,
0.0081990538,
-0.0661920682,
0.0426128656,
-0.0180628989,
0.0100195697,
-0.0126084704,
-0.0360565856,
-0.0099955648,
0.0453461297,
-0.0351995453,
0.0401020981,
0.0462657697,
-0.037341401,
0.0076203141,
-0.057366129,
0.036870826,
-0.0252440609,
0.0422194004,
-0.0199285243,
0.023276234,
0.0564106889,
-0.0433505923,
-0.0378946699,
-0.1139655933,
-0.0256467257,
-0.0091529069,
0.0433181711,
-0.0222338364,
-0.0564352348,
0.0010389632,
0.0194779579,
-0.0215242524,
0.0166390408,
-0.0016796674,
0.0253581796,
-0.0370641127,
0.0126764132,
0.0436364748,
0.0297612306,
-0.0463208742,
0.0100897495,
0.0121820308,
-0.0376225784,
-0.0239159595,
-0.0099003101,
-0.014407156,
0.0085661355,
-0.0228299685,
-0.0085641034,
0.0010834923,
0.0044803736,
-0.0153670609,
0.0490820035,
0.0714627877,
0.0184532329,
-0.0136779509,
0.0265591852,
-0.0204608757,
0.0488516726,
-0.0008586101,
0.0203760192,
-0.0757497177,
0.0023778384,
0.0091226073,
-0.021990886,
-0.0597670786,
0.022096334,
-0.0238075498,
-0.0968240723,
0.0505190156,
0.024957953,
0.036806535,
-0.0272026118,
0.0226843115,
-0.0199205261,
0.0090332972,
0.0433301181,
-0.0427950248,
0.0058655743,
-0.0311730485,
0.0087963371,
-0.0633845702,
-0.0276879482,
-0.0116029121,
-0.0245164949,
0.0369736478,
0.0654966682,
0.0357202403,
-0.0254081003,
-0.0438896939,
0.0143202879,
0.0480810739,
-0.0137782125,
0.0079467101,
0.0451378375,
-0.0092775784,
0.0048198295,
-0.0292434264,
0.0144145647,
-0.0111944145,
0.0149677005,
0.0204500649,
0.0260489583,
-0.0053377524,
-0.0431907065,
0.0174598675,
0.0121194562,
0.0265805312,
0.0741158724,
0.0021801498,
-0.0533380695,
0.0115042031,
-0.060729254,
-0.0334246308,
0.0796356052,
-0.0619979165,
0.0046333885,
0.0009820723,
-0.0536456034,
-0.0533104911,
-0.0402747579,
-0.0195191465,
-0.0140796965,
0.0456390567,
0.0136310458,
0.0199181009,
-0.0000323338,
0.0439638235,
0.0404958837,
-0.0385575257,
0.0452792645,
-0.0524287745,
-0.0037389533,
-0.0131084425,
-0.0330624394,
-0.0036177004,
-0.01039798,
-0.0139607377,
-0.0801840648,
-0.0195290595,
-0.0053610052,
0.0219173022,
0.0240440834,
0.0095118983,
-0.0552854538,
-0.0090361182,
0.0637248531,
-0.0224945843,
0.0160268247,
0.0565787144,
-0.0010289414,
0.0146607505,
0.0218515284,
0.0055580433,
0.0434959196,
0.0084867673,
0.0143893054,
-0.0389876962,
-0.0316539034,
0.064953953,
0.0522492006,
0.0085545704,
0.0008712756,
-0.0058645899,
-0.0311367698,
-0.0431312472,
-0.0231356248,
-0.0239995215,
-0.0136147887,
-0.040130347,
0.025637392,
0.0132847084,
0.0171144158,
-0.0010174012,
-0.07496465,
-0.0019698311,
0.0004478644,
0.046580445,
-0.0714948848,
0.0412154831,
0.0207542274,
-0.0048856735,
0.0144413812,
0.0792405382,
0.0135050118,
0.0194346439,
0.0104965223,
0.0428199768,
0.0171278808,
-0.0069695022,
-0.007537757,
0.0060954029,
-0.0024697778,
-0.0658475384,
0.0371828191,
-0.0065525691,
0.0234877449,
-0.0246415772,
0.041064024,
-0.0447098278,
-0.0068115415,
-0.0118152024,
0.0096990708,
0.0128456866,
-0.0183351841,
0.0340966545,
-0.0155505976,
-0.0654675588,
-0.0156727415,
0.0309504289,
-0.0469977744,
-0.0050222604,
-0.0226885546,
-0.0278772768,
-0.0127821676,
-0.0577253439,
0.0454675406,
-0.0056095477,
-0.0054356586,
0.0049262666,
-0.0813449025,
-0.0212638583,
-0.01644977,
-0.0389991067,
-0.0065366649,
-0.0465109386,
0.0207758993,
0.0439895354,
-0.044124864,
0.0254639871,
-0.0336762816,
-0.0127537176,
-0.0103502935,
-0.0051674247,
-0.018050123,
-5.624463125e-33,
0.0184515677,
-0.031898737,
-0.012269496,
0.0453721359,
0.0037165463,
-0.0304409619,
0.0089830859,
0.0542719178,
0.009646032,
0.0673166886,
0.0012670008,
0.000036689,
0.010850477,
-0.0335840844,
0.0008565011,
0.0013707841,
0.0345143825,
0.0054953285,
-0.0238890555,
-0.0021234283,
0.0092276931,
-0.0110835051,
0.0144137321,
-0.1145338491,
0.0581071451,
-0.0006528805,
-0.0363902748,
-0.0186905507,
-0.0045893365,
0.0603381768,
0.0141665181,
0.0736267939,
0.0148014734,
-0.0383565426,
0.013907508,
0.0702410042,
0.0292162616,
-0.0124847647,
0.0705434009,
-0.0204985552,
0.0450140983,
-0.0503541529,
0.0074346461,
-0.0272257011,
-0.0763945654,
0.0442309752,
0.0199464709,
-0.0422491841,
0.0227733999,
0.0125861242,
-0.0688752457,
0.0001588507,
-0.0438092649,
0.0147922775,
0.0086997794,
0.0600635372,
-0.0281737763,
0.0420605615,
-0.0029881438,
0.0494143218,
0.0242753848,
-0.0189193822,
0.0484117493,
-0.0225027036,
0.0009120174,
0.0698886737,
0.0225401744,
0.0059244665,
-0.0402725935,
-0.0119773643,
0.0107415933,
0.0131071135,
0.0202812199,
0.0613667667,
-0.00009396,
-0.0684918761,
-0.034350682,
-0.0039308667,
0.0564418621,
-0.0309817102,
0.0559354462,
0.0068256254,
-0.0782521591,
-0.0642128438,
-0.0174434539,
0.0103705972,
-0.0343697071,
-0.0471429154,
0.0194164887,
-0.0123088052,
0.0342522338,
-0.0039367345,
-0.0036392801,
-0.0470290408,
-0.0558087602,
0.009496849,
-0.0172595717,
0.0027570999,
0.0038588028,
-0.0057247733,
-0.0665789098,
-0.0034883656,
-0.0473354235,
0.006964806,
0.022280205,
0.0177125726,
0.0460789613,
-0.0106549272,
-0.0445047133,
0.0075985193,
0.0066024573,
-0.0019295702,
0.0210046265,
-0.0209625084,
0.0152768567,
0.0106016183,
0.015710691,
0.0175113156,
0.0059379316,
-0.0183433052,
-0.0452065356,
-0.0126266666,
-0.0325433537,
0.0281751547,
-0.0468585491,
-0.0077990107,
-0.0074201869,
0.0245882738,
0.0545874424,
-0.0573723651,
-0.0345423631,
-0.0399202518,
2.505e-7,
0.0103257131,
0.092784889,
-0.0289039686,
0.0265513863,
0.0077504781,
0.0701319203,
-0.0277299378,
0.0020319941,
0.028848052,
-0.0332410596,
-0.0025995553,
0.0026378259,
0.043555133,
0.001697446,
-0.0812445059,
0.0142361373,
-0.0512524024,
-0.0090256734,
-0.0764088929,
0.0372717753,
0.0669415593,
0.0776691735,
0.0299399886,
-0.0211724993,
-0.0188698061,
-0.0221172683,
0.0724621564,
-0.0980809703,
-0.0395088904,
0.0201010648,
0.02045279,
-0.0246611498,
0.0063206805,
0.0252364501,
0.017416073,
0.0063207801,
-0.0238739848,
0.0509209707,
-0.001434788,
0.0090328548,
-0.0206911769,
0.0143794697,
-0.0245253127,
-0.0080123218,
-0.0097284662,
-0.0462601073,
-0.0815025195,
-0.0541582108,
0.011609396,
-0.0327703692,
0.0152780274,
-0.0248509198,
-0.0422821827,
-0.0139295729,
0.0299727675,
-0.0119936466,
0.0331959687,
-0.0318246223,
0.0247982051,
0.033676751,
-0.0147656463,
-0.0408626646,
0.000244256,
0.0289945658,
0.0207457542,
-0.0223567281,
0.0303685591,
2.028245248e-34,
0.0612801723,
-0.0063618971,
0.0306245834,
0.0365911536,
0.0601196587,
0.0503026918,
0.0378550254,
0.0140195712,
0.0318277888,
-0.0790243894,
0.0142845204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03732v1 | A Rank Stabilization Scaling Factor for Fine-Tuning with LoRA | 2023-11-28T03:23:20 | 2023-11-28T03:23:20 | Damjan Kalajdzievski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | As large language models (LLMs) have become increasingly compute and memory
intensive, parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods are now a common
strategy to fine-tune LLMs. A popular PEFT method is Low-Rank Adapters (LoRA),
which adds trainable low-rank "adapters" to selected layers. Each adapter
consists of a low-rank matrix product, multiplicatively scaled by a
rank-dependent factor. This scaling factor, which divides adapters by a factor
of the rank, results in slowed learning and stunted performance for LoRA with
higher-rank adapters. Consequently, the use of LoRA in practice has generally
been limited to very low ranks. In this work, we study the impact of the
scaling factor on the learning process and prove that LoRA adapters should be
divided by a factor of the square root of the rank. Modifying LoRA with the
appropriate scaling factor, which we call the rank-stabilized LoRA (rsLoRA)
method, easily provides for a fine-tuning compute/performance trade-off, where
larger ranks can be used to trade off increased computational resources during
training for better fine-tuning performance, with no change in inference
computing cost. | [
0.0160369705,
0.0565331578,
-0.0080943042,
0.0671733245,
0.0337155834,
0.04015214,
0.0033306573,
0.0076400843,
0.007790558,
-0.0262166839,
-0.0641807318,
-0.0403128192,
0.0314614512,
-0.0045943814,
0.0288830511,
-0.0116589908,
0.0232640132,
-0.0617503934,
-0.0283779316,
-0.0044291276,
-0.0076644742,
0.0206709113,
0.0148124052,
0.0109704044,
0.0874014124,
-0.0104813389,
0.0115474276,
0.0158366188,
0.0454459824,
0.0112316497,
0.0071749436,
0.044004105,
0.0428477377,
0.0240882766,
0.000002193,
-0.0162666533,
-0.0014198649,
-0.0051135272,
-0.0040714513,
0.0484871715,
0.0141315721,
-0.0050876751,
-0.0305315722,
0.0309630986,
-0.007400916,
-0.0164824501,
0.0358281061,
0.0028883235,
0.0167131443,
0.058986403,
-0.0094731217,
-0.0443263128,
0.0203966256,
-0.0485015996,
-0.0734843984,
-0.0651683807,
0.0225074384,
-0.0167313702,
-0.0489586815,
-0.0070298961,
-0.0429742076,
0.0125420699,
-0.0141356587,
0.0010792224,
-0.0010879175,
0.018880751,
-0.0476497784,
-0.0262470078,
0.0024786016,
0.0758210048,
-0.084410347,
-0.000834321,
0.0276464131,
-0.0169757158,
-0.0099248588,
-0.024756318,
-0.0335863456,
0.0240833145,
0.0366364233,
0.0372998528,
0.0239330642,
-0.0285858586,
0.036843244,
0.0043264949,
-0.0471526869,
0.0419345088,
0.0429602824,
-0.0039857794,
0.0052732178,
-0.0343291201,
-0.0243369471,
0.0031603544,
-0.0105397347,
0.0208428465,
-0.0276514068,
-0.0159952082,
-0.0505377688,
-0.0266361348,
0.010376893,
-0.0190467853,
0.0998192206,
0.0452900939,
0.0253422782,
0.0371210352,
-0.0631276891,
0.0386777446,
-0.0085829869,
0.0359241776,
-0.0369095318,
0.0226111133,
0.048157528,
0.0263861958,
-0.0167123433,
0.0095924102,
-0.0457225293,
-0.0067038834,
-0.0547160022,
0.0223572068,
0.0094841998,
0.0172563009,
-0.0132263582,
-0.0160226412,
-0.0177610982,
-0.0256980583,
0.0205933731,
0.0627463907,
0.0005747916,
0.044304017,
-0.0369142704,
-0.0459139757,
-0.0186776686,
0.0083684921,
0.0485490784,
-0.0152831664,
0.0508023649,
0.0251314286,
-0.0131254913,
-0.0481300652,
-0.0264648292,
0.0262732245,
-0.0078034024,
-0.1094912216,
-0.0132186469,
-0.0204795171,
0.0127401697,
-0.0022182139,
0.0468635261,
-0.0007123705,
-0.0140759135,
0.0207511056,
-0.066123724,
0.0538187809,
0.0022247094,
0.0078359852,
-0.0015587461,
0.0024815632,
0.0297250524,
0.0609830655,
0.0410680845,
0.0196395237,
-0.0022572256,
-0.0508299321,
-0.0428787246,
0.0593416952,
0.0087169223,
0.0221003555,
-0.0227509588,
-0.0096467379,
0.0229716469,
-0.0067507271,
0.0309829991,
0.0252565946,
-0.028373681,
0.0021843486,
0.0554338582,
0.0508799776,
0.058126688,
0.0557233095,
-0.0003261193,
-0.0370810293,
0.0023792144,
-0.0012114947,
-0.032060992,
0.0529611968,
-0.0299716424,
-0.0120504694,
0.0403195545,
0.1051312685,
-0.0362941436,
-0.0245571788,
-0.0182009116,
0.0243013017,
-0.0383450054,
0.0357400142,
0.036355719,
0.00066716,
-0.0237406082,
0.0131139942,
0.0486498736,
-0.0483489446,
-0.0033866835,
-0.0793462843,
0.0185229164,
0.0472120158,
0.027326148,
-0.0078222463,
-0.0292087067,
-0.025248507,
0.0381729528,
-0.0042796312,
-0.0018245555,
0.0194736067,
0.0109581267,
-0.0747198686,
-0.0079138214,
0.0213062726,
0.0155707793,
-0.0045033186,
-0.0125655662,
0.0331520513,
0.0184064396,
-0.0484712273,
-0.0545081086,
0.0225357264,
-0.0152498521,
-0.0019750537,
0.0292671323,
0.0026482255,
0.0174970813,
0.0085473666,
-0.0005208957,
-0.0302294139,
0.033206515,
-0.0364590511,
0.0607435778,
-0.0355610624,
-0.0043215044,
0.0176677704,
0.0078914212,
0.0148508195,
0.027322622,
0.0858849362,
-0.0317794532,
-0.0369147398,
0.0177830495,
0.0015077434,
-0.0175372027,
-0.0335498489,
0.0164988972,
-0.0355480239,
0.0776474625,
-0.0172433276,
0.0153583977,
-0.0038573397,
0.0367168933,
0.0940432325,
0.0270857923,
0.0111317039,
-0.0399141498,
-0.0682662874,
0.0214592405,
0.0045720618,
0.0374642126,
-0.0040647541,
0.0158838592,
0.0037294205,
-0.0490143448,
-0.0604804456,
0.0132507356,
-0.0519954823,
0.0359367765,
0.0113623831,
0.0137327956,
0.0123754563,
-0.0233755633,
0.0018091137,
0.0373508185,
-0.0178591926,
0.0292510986,
-0.0088174837,
0.0144105144,
-0.0551624559,
-0.068106316,
-0.0236511603,
0.0286098756,
0.0428403467,
-0.0155279189,
0.0002874733,
-0.0812636763,
0.0291523524,
-0.0360924527,
0.0263602696,
-0.0512030348,
-0.0574699789,
-0.0099218143,
-0.0274117086,
0.0541207679,
0.0773471594,
0.0025849335,
0.0151527086,
0.0934185386,
0.0404379815,
-0.0366420597,
-0.0012186706,
-0.0180995613,
-0.0573227406,
-0.0421956256,
0.0095333904,
-0.0091228113,
0.0561343692,
-0.0276622027,
-0.0191734824,
-0.0403759442,
0.0145085827,
-0.0101043992,
-0.0020008453,
-0.0183016323,
0.0282661915,
-0.0222458653,
0.0041577695,
0.0151078217,
-0.0316754729,
0.0303566605,
-0.0228421949,
-0.0209645126,
-0.0057303342,
-0.0606229752,
-0.0544167832,
-0.0061825165,
-0.0023091643,
0.0221366882,
-0.0579126403,
0.0034606089,
-0.0180630498,
0.0047670864,
0.0224631485,
-0.0230948087,
0.031955231,
-0.0128680253,
0.020713672,
-0.0717353672,
-0.0637248084,
0.0258585177,
-0.0412398316,
-0.0020836606,
0.0212905537,
0.0074007488,
-0.0373793878,
0.0086493185,
0.0156578943,
0.0235087965,
0.0537494346,
-0.0357178003,
0.0053555793,
-0.0280967373,
0.0487192944,
0.0678559914,
0.053143613,
0.0214579999,
-0.0142726209,
0.0339450836,
0.0012564285,
0.0436560698,
0.0300220903,
-0.0343847685,
0.022906296,
0.0516596809,
0.0353198573,
-0.0158164259,
0.0201870762,
0.0173881855,
-0.0186615437,
-0.0136914998,
0.0834140554,
-0.0092458855,
-0.0723070204,
-0.0122783482,
-0.0242388453,
0.0973561481,
0.0352432281,
0.0458922088,
-0.0254045725,
0.0110052144,
-0.0033715179,
0.0357826985,
0.0209763609,
-0.021354476,
0.0140485242,
-0.0898872539,
0.0567879304,
0.0189861041,
-0.018937232,
-0.0455661453,
-0.0503129363,
0.0015764721,
-0.0064230231,
0.0501971729,
0.0400008969,
-0.0527188666,
-0.0155037679,
0.0357754901,
-0.0160405636,
-0.0502899699,
0.0075146579,
-0.0290345494,
0.0622766614,
0.0170734618,
0.0276228674,
0.0076635857,
-0.0621929094,
0.0312973857,
-0.0540337302,
-0.0156224519,
-0.0229706261,
-0.0080324477,
0.0113598341,
-0.0538414977,
-0.0012557213,
0.0282462519,
0.0236751549,
0.0105755022,
-0.0350057967,
0.0449143946,
0.0045570401,
-0.0170273241,
0.0371531695,
-0.0078209341,
-0.0548607521,
0.0276570749,
0.0474801846,
-0.0267527979,
-0.0163354985,
-0.0022328631,
0.0135543533,
-0.036840789,
-0.0505958088,
0.0047400966,
-0.0063953777,
0.0337450057,
0.0032800182,
0.0115920668,
0.0430936143,
0.0268814173,
-0.0225629825,
0.0074268417,
-0.0236230772,
0.0149881365,
-0.0119398935,
0.0118429838,
-0.0567223355,
-0.0154855978,
-0.0203730818,
0.0063950568,
0.0546327978,
-0.0244359244,
-0.004563353,
-0.0084002148,
-0.0612423383,
-0.0575001054,
-0.0085396823,
0.0499317907,
0.015612877,
0.0304883644,
0.0232811812,
-0.0909935758,
0.0296355374,
0.0326180235,
0.0084567126,
0.0797246546,
0.0131861856,
-0.0401638448,
-0.0203490295,
0.0591835305,
-0.0640692413,
-0.0094966525,
0.0349354558,
0.0493997782,
-0.0205914937,
-0.0480699539,
-0.0310356952,
0.0116427094,
0.0214879457,
-0.0075984653,
-0.0372122489,
-0.0459006689,
0.0590520985,
-0.0271744858,
0.0192579404,
-0.024405431,
-0.0213094391,
0.0253646784,
0.012637211,
-0.0417525209,
0.0164384954,
0.0287465863,
0.0223177448,
-0.0698951855,
0.0179325398,
0.0026408588,
-0.0422227979,
0.0569935925,
0.0253800452,
-0.0415657237,
0.0417465977,
0.0331792794,
0.0313867554,
-0.040711049,
-0.0043376684,
0.0072353086,
0.0088091688,
-0.0853017643,
0.0582075045,
-0.0234665349,
-0.133431673,
-0.0403588712,
0.015617623,
0.0641017929,
0.0178880468,
0.0883732885,
0.0350896344,
-0.0247650295,
0.0114146862,
-0.011061945,
-0.0061961617,
-0.0038217381,
0.0308055729,
0.020013772,
0.0040192478,
0.0421386622,
0.0476068966,
0.0301077534,
0.0367116891,
-0.0115476009,
0.0063087679,
-0.005834396,
-0.025218945,
-0.0172988549,
0.0312549472,
-0.0117744468,
-0.0392501801,
-0.0164432302,
-0.0618705042,
-0.0149056241,
-0.0062398305,
-0.001828835,
-0.0429325439,
-0.0249254666,
0.0309504028,
-0.0127439378,
0.0053091254,
-0.0075556613,
-0.0696891546,
0.0172195435,
-0.0106483083,
0.0275442284,
-6.884478092e-33,
-0.0299891513,
0.0101922993,
0.0168971885,
0.0320184976,
-0.0153861148,
-0.0059128329,
-0.0175073221,
-0.0038806412,
-0.0313909464,
-0.0087419078,
-0.0231585875,
-0.0131905116,
0.0087717036,
-0.0001138482,
-0.0001565124,
-0.0008282237,
0.0483408161,
0.0071336902,
-0.0143679092,
0.0229037926,
0.0001776664,
0.0232444573,
0.0216639508,
0.0137211923,
-0.0341456793,
0.0014346379,
-0.04073916,
-0.0001797764,
-0.0474764071,
0.0318729207,
-0.0459734574,
0.0427644774,
0.0212843623,
-0.0192437824,
0.0004496327,
0.0254635978,
-0.1044555232,
0.0106453532,
0.0430322848,
-0.0030596498,
-0.013922289,
0.0036718361,
0.0555568747,
0.0266307034,
-0.0417422056,
-0.0327661894,
0.0157972854,
-0.0176640116,
-0.0339107551,
-0.0336139947,
-0.0700221807,
0.0098485639,
0.0074047511,
0.0094875395,
0.0613096096,
-0.0100229019,
-0.0182311814,
0.0492508709,
-0.069536306,
-0.0213817488,
0.0065623308,
0.0835241526,
0.0289849956,
0.0514305942,
-0.0556194559,
0.0430667996,
0.0091286153,
0.0102240294,
0.0262404606,
-0.0195965432,
0.0475386679,
0.0195994731,
0.0345596336,
0.0324680284,
-0.0016834919,
-0.012332744,
-0.0977726057,
-0.0138114765,
0.0054367236,
0.0226089153,
0.0346075334,
0.0276941061,
-0.0131054642,
-0.0298730284,
-0.0533865616,
-0.0244462453,
-0.0740287006,
0.0077721649,
0.0152249373,
0.0487173088,
-0.0397838987,
-0.003840511,
0.0132263638,
-0.0338692553,
0.0039806394,
-0.0159733705,
-0.0172612071,
0.0237974022,
-0.0037429335,
0.0022448974,
-0.0612127632,
-0.0531306751,
0.0258980747,
-0.0316892304,
0.0108527821,
-0.0260492712,
0.0281890891,
0.0465885401,
-0.0713418573,
-0.0271339193,
-0.0155229829,
0.0233910009,
0.0211853106,
0.0709832534,
0.0056616887,
-0.0227179006,
0.0069982568,
0.0606141202,
0.0111058811,
0.0334555916,
0.0179682765,
-0.0182879977,
0.0202199817,
0.0204855576,
-0.0387193449,
0.0269319098,
-0.0157127772,
0.0411103927,
0.0410720594,
-0.0625906289,
-0.0263002608,
0.0080984263,
2.891e-7,
-0.0018922144,
0.0348451249,
-0.0308505539,
-0.0510548241,
-0.0049553723,
0.0070300251,
-0.0019332523,
0.0357826985,
0.0462345853,
0.0169909149,
-0.0058024107,
0.0060093296,
0.0289265029,
-0.0184982792,
-0.0467073321,
0.0046534995,
-0.0932872668,
0.0145412795,
-0.0405459665,
-0.0690182373,
-0.0369425081,
0.0905931517,
-0.0120952455,
-0.033930324,
-0.0099909604,
-0.0125433672,
0.0549787618,
-0.0303463358,
-0.0177549943,
0.0142837781,
0.0592616573,
0.0380398221,
-0.043117065,
-0.0222974122,
0.0019276829,
0.0549293384,
-0.037430387,
0.0611428581,
-0.0215995293,
0.0319733694,
0.0371683352,
0.0197013188,
-0.0154460976,
-0.0897433609,
0.0766539723,
-0.0359782539,
-0.0183100905,
-0.0212970041,
-0.0073532574,
-0.0397581495,
0.0156597421,
-0.0509644449,
0.0083140507,
0.0266112611,
0.0133527545,
-0.0317669846,
-0.0177632272,
-0.1040977538,
0.0093916664,
0.0250976812,
-0.03584316,
-0.0611377992,
-0.0358645171,
-0.0607414916,
0.0489712134,
-0.0435791127,
0.018841682,
2.609478073e-34,
0.0320513211,
-0.0222240444,
0.0427028649,
0.0294782277,
0.0126850335,
-0.0094689401,
-0.0153362518,
0.0149230277,
0.0056111584,
-0.1413428634,
-0.0296706222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16452v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16452v1 | Can Generalist Foundation Models Outcompete Special-Purpose Tuning? Case Study in Medicine | 2023-11-28T03:16:12 | 2023-11-28T03:16:12 | Harsha Nori, Yin Tat Lee, Sheng Zhang, Dean Carignan, Richard Edgar, Nicolo Fusi, Nicholas King, Jonathan Larson, Yuanzhi Li, Weishung Liu, Renqian Luo, Scott Mayer McKinney, Robert Osazuwa Ness, Hoifung Poon, Tao Qin, Naoto Usuyama, Chris White, Eric Horvitz | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Generalist foundation models such as GPT-4 have displayed surprising
capabilities in a wide variety of domains and tasks. Yet, there is a prevalent
assumption that they cannot match specialist capabilities of fine-tuned models.
For example, most explorations to date on medical competency benchmarks have
leveraged domain-specific training, as exemplified by efforts on BioGPT and
Med-PaLM. We build on a prior study of GPT-4's capabilities on medical
challenge benchmarks in the absence of special training. Rather than using
simple prompting to highlight the model's out-of-the-box capabilities, we
perform a systematic exploration of prompt engineering. We find that prompting
innovation can unlock deeper specialist capabilities and show that GPT-4 easily
tops prior leading results for medical benchmarks. The prompting methods we
explore are general purpose, and make no specific use of domain expertise,
removing the need for expert-curated content. Our experimental design carefully
controls for overfitting during the prompt engineering process. We introduce
Medprompt, based on a composition of several prompting strategies. With
Medprompt, GPT-4 achieves state-of-the-art results on all nine of the benchmark
datasets in the MultiMedQA suite. The method outperforms leading specialist
models such as Med-PaLM 2 by a significant margin with an order of magnitude
fewer calls to the model. Steering GPT-4 with Medprompt achieves a 27%
reduction in error rate on the MedQA dataset over the best methods to date
achieved with specialist models and surpasses a score of 90% for the first
time. Beyond medical problems, we show the power of Medprompt to generalize to
other domains and provide evidence for the broad applicability of the approach
via studies of the strategy on exams in electrical engineering, machine
learning, philosophy, accounting, law, nursing, and clinical psychology. | [
0.0115223089,
0.0449559875,
-0.0076207416,
-0.0391253158,
-0.014349998,
0.0163886826,
0.0393487141,
0.0182672366,
-0.030347662,
0.0126106199,
0.0084771235,
-0.0258985814,
-0.0176379979,
0.0594325848,
0.0195681024,
-0.055948209,
0.0540948212,
0.0164524876,
0.021319164,
-0.0155139985,
-0.0362942144,
-0.0179705769,
-0.0337389372,
0.0509434566,
-0.0013677113,
-0.0333329402,
0.0222637393,
0.0277079865,
0.0170381144,
-0.0485219434,
0.0323745608,
0.0672717392,
0.0077442741,
0.0003009549,
0.0000024404,
-0.0736033767,
-0.0377330966,
0.0284909829,
-0.0439021178,
-0.0007006666,
0.0038297023,
0.0178741477,
0.0352615453,
0.0423262417,
-0.0177740045,
-0.0228052419,
0.0191863179,
0.0378004014,
0.0341712162,
0.0537400804,
-0.0058180969,
0.0430580415,
-0.0092695989,
-0.0518215969,
-0.0350796022,
-0.0523589961,
-0.0038211339,
-0.007207341,
0.0384792797,
-0.0218804441,
-0.0020135222,
0.0013937394,
0.0157857537,
0.0734919757,
0.0610288829,
0.0509621538,
-0.005262672,
0.0201285128,
-0.0406746566,
0.0238761902,
-0.0045117354,
0.0254408568,
-0.0012811909,
-0.036568597,
0.0264235307,
0.018830562,
-0.0524942428,
-0.0210672133,
-0.0306366533,
-0.0249379408,
0.0031297221,
0.0234805085,
0.0179480892,
-0.0315033868,
-0.0091080982,
0.0278560296,
0.0096272146,
-0.0444362722,
0.0585260168,
0.01679416,
0.0060057049,
-0.0120552573,
0.0022702864,
0.0138105806,
-0.0802939236,
-0.047708936,
-0.0011471288,
0.0144852251,
0.0252834167,
0.044209782,
0.0482097417,
0.0411419421,
-0.0151385916,
0.0074697793,
-0.0084530581,
0.0384647064,
-0.04790093,
0.0261071604,
-0.0373676307,
0.0415214635,
-0.1026968509,
0.0313435905,
-0.0033294163,
0.0105973752,
-0.0188114289,
0.0151004028,
-0.064989619,
-0.0029765239,
-0.0060454365,
-0.015600889,
0.0128741777,
0.0337777138,
-0.0311727785,
0.0385539867,
-0.0206118412,
-0.003202637,
-0.0267395079,
0.0116966786,
0.0187669713,
-0.0394906774,
-0.0072580911,
-0.0271282084,
-0.0317319036,
-0.0255980957,
0.0283163376,
0.0475018173,
-0.0109931426,
-0.0151294218,
0.0177512337,
-0.0365479365,
0.0017252951,
-0.0535221845,
0.0396310315,
-0.0307683051,
0.010606654,
0.0038237863,
0.046011053,
-0.0252028443,
-0.0193986781,
-0.0275074504,
-0.0225847978,
0.0433945209,
-0.0256043281,
0.0226124842,
0.0367259644,
0.0356714353,
-0.0698137879,
0.0319196247,
-0.0272109602,
-0.039519649,
-0.0080483845,
-0.0499896742,
0.0107453661,
0.024321558,
-0.0163641367,
-0.0226507019,
0.0405039005,
0.0304501355,
0.0289981477,
0.068401359,
-0.0234022029,
-0.0183179751,
-0.0266232062,
0.0495951623,
0.0302049443,
0.0552474335,
0.0634483024,
0.0208641849,
0.0411971509,
-0.0208857246,
0.0224498324,
-0.0213889498,
-0.0566283092,
-0.0045335656,
-0.0099778995,
0.0130579649,
-0.0252509844,
0.0239808336,
-0.0575440153,
-0.0224549267,
-0.0085142767,
0.0121108415,
-0.0472110957,
0.020013772,
0.0562077612,
-0.0432532728,
-0.0252654217,
0.0070174513,
0.0086152041,
-0.0176323596,
-0.0376982428,
-0.0971565768,
-0.0588901304,
0.0189399384,
0.049873855,
-0.0454647951,
-0.0766678825,
-0.0370469913,
0.0261923224,
-0.003873823,
0.0725354329,
0.0016486277,
0.0090618702,
-0.0267598685,
-0.0471526012,
-0.0118062068,
0.0124220392,
0.019400578,
-0.0049593234,
0.0092065083,
-0.017380394,
-0.0123222638,
-0.023984611,
0.0380452238,
-0.0817005485,
-0.0109146638,
0.0189122166,
-0.0200611018,
0.0623144731,
0.0234108716,
-0.0208654217,
0.0131258545,
-0.0027820384,
0.012543804,
-0.0141849481,
-0.0021756999,
-0.0320446901,
0.033321403,
0.0008020285,
-0.0556450337,
-0.0046909098,
0.0139990244,
-0.0245168749,
-0.0509379655,
-0.0398619585,
0.0003431414,
0.0214316119,
-0.0145702194,
0.0187496748,
-0.0255730003,
-0.0267474893,
-0.0225018151,
0.0265465472,
0.0388426483,
-0.0243491996,
0.0176966991,
-0.0201093517,
0.0204734299,
-0.0709487349,
-0.0192203969,
-0.0137515971,
-0.0280506294,
0.0185073707,
0.011932008,
0.0319172293,
-0.0396213233,
-0.0011424934,
-0.1178486124,
0.0244723279,
0.0036942423,
-0.0002864922,
0.0151567617,
-0.0065440135,
-0.0308471229,
0.0094250347,
-0.031256184,
-0.044550404,
0.0190320294,
0.0148093356,
-0.0073540919,
0.0340982005,
-0.0156241404,
-0.0220737532,
0.0030258447,
-0.0494901724,
0.0082177864,
0.041860491,
0.0517215505,
0.0024125346,
0.0183063932,
-0.026225999,
-0.0007222499,
-0.0208616182,
0.0022872854,
0.0300998949,
0.002571085,
-0.0176552478,
0.0399617255,
-0.0325829536,
-0.0036512958,
0.0328552946,
0.0139613571,
-0.0105829546,
0.0422770828,
-0.0375000015,
-0.0354975387,
0.0142543912,
-0.0195918195,
0.0146167018,
0.0526013151,
0.0174884852,
0.0251561366,
-0.0521568879,
0.0447446816,
-0.0151410205,
0.0087639373,
-0.0429031067,
0.0297387224,
-0.0240880065,
0.0668757558,
-0.0329251476,
-0.0429871678,
0.0768727809,
0.0297229216,
0.0319116525,
-0.0555757657,
-0.0130543662,
-0.0194885228,
-0.0104587059,
-0.0433145165,
-0.0028117292,
0.0466088243,
0.0063720904,
-0.0392409228,
0.0106602451,
0.0085185478,
-0.0544535518,
0.0449991077,
-0.026841661,
0.0140946638,
0.0011592254,
-0.0770169869,
-0.0507460386,
0.0078605656,
-0.0054710326,
0.0339093618,
-0.0071594417,
0.0087458417,
-0.0445812605,
-0.0319170803,
-0.0229169764,
0.0762012452,
-0.0248925891,
-0.0189635195,
0.0119793005,
-0.0204328597,
0.0050913291,
0.0305927712,
0.0132695967,
-0.0677130222,
0.051315818,
0.0112744486,
0.0586916655,
-0.040275231,
-0.0276910346,
0.0491590053,
-0.0123638185,
-0.0351515599,
-0.0228559654,
0.0467037149,
0.0440885946,
-0.0313879661,
-0.0086404113,
0.1096948907,
0.0085072853,
-0.0239673555,
0.014750218,
-0.0031511441,
0.0150342248,
0.0399683267,
0.0371391214,
-0.0482040681,
-0.0279749855,
0.0074400315,
0.0895071626,
-0.0373201482,
-0.034660995,
0.0395326316,
-0.0630555227,
0.0587824322,
0.0126237525,
-0.0494982041,
0.0261328425,
-0.0076082349,
0.0234722923,
-0.0541481376,
-0.0391177945,
0.002237414,
-0.01774019,
0.0166637078,
0.0235046893,
-0.0195165295,
-0.1047846973,
0.0496250875,
-0.0189972669,
0.0296691675,
0.0592421107,
-0.0409373455,
-0.0172250494,
-0.0067095608,
0.0319755636,
0.0025658398,
0.0597420335,
-0.0152781513,
0.0769315213,
-0.0056076087,
0.0102230879,
-0.0346194692,
0.0232577901,
-0.0174179357,
-0.0002570266,
0.056504868,
0.1062356681,
-0.0143806906,
-0.0007473279,
-0.0359390676,
-0.0246856157,
0.0113355471,
0.0565061569,
0.0010881206,
-0.0493458696,
-0.0154970614,
-0.0088543454,
0.0336517245,
0.0166370384,
-0.0251423344,
0.0101448614,
-0.0027789751,
0.010471602,
-0.0097394492,
-0.0280316919,
0.0386887938,
0.0261479802,
0.0165244658,
-0.0192439612,
-0.0391876884,
0.0442685187,
-0.0553257726,
0.0948036984,
0.0276926551,
0.0004101023,
-0.1040692851,
-0.0315388218,
0.0419860557,
-0.0452869311,
-0.0363910198,
-0.0004725534,
0.0120098954,
-0.0095221326,
-0.0307129305,
0.0765432492,
0.0359190516,
0.0064869346,
-0.0258554928,
-0.0217355173,
0.0202490315,
0.026720915,
-0.056440834,
0.0143113025,
0.0273983069,
-0.0570210479,
-0.0357252061,
-0.0284512024,
-0.0128835626,
0.0672312751,
0.043759726,
0.0199043434,
0.0370059535,
-0.0059190043,
0.0106427018,
0.0467500538,
0.0977047011,
-0.0143938456,
-0.0379800498,
-0.040793512,
-0.01712556,
0.0191610232,
0.0199003536,
-0.0358631797,
0.014026734,
0.0208375342,
0.0192453563,
0.0063363784,
-0.0267726574,
-0.0584528223,
-0.0001540831,
-0.1022591144,
0.037541002,
0.0043951822,
0.0209906157,
0.0105519043,
-0.024456786,
-0.0047390172,
-0.0163567867,
0.0080190785,
0.0199863035,
0.00260871,
0.0968767628,
-0.0066809105,
0.0700695068,
0.0181778651,
0.011757791,
-0.0816235542,
-0.0926868469,
-0.0130362837,
0.0325623937,
0.0266684536,
0.0091318162,
-0.0257945471,
0.00139418,
0.008846201,
-0.0444230922,
0.0130001847,
-0.0108746998,
0.0574933253,
0.0152211413,
0.0368844457,
-0.0040070168,
-0.0373615548,
0.0541200526,
0.0170941129,
0.0840735435,
-0.0281386524,
-0.0157834012,
-0.0726531893,
-0.0211456232,
0.0690331981,
0.0246433988,
-0.033518225,
0.005117659,
-0.1208644658,
-0.0279953778,
0.0348971859,
0.0010161335,
0.007438513,
-0.0211410429,
0.0390734784,
0.024074927,
-0.0652178526,
-0.0380079895,
0.0259913038,
-0.0227876883,
-0.0204580911,
-0.0248110685,
-0.0015724122,
-6.254860542e-33,
0.0215728655,
0.0257341564,
0.0274873022,
-0.0252545159,
-0.0119733205,
0.0536414683,
-0.0063145249,
0.0200132672,
-0.016019728,
0.0111888098,
-0.0471798256,
-0.0213232171,
0.0006784472,
-0.028677782,
0.0412419066,
-0.0204227548,
0.0506856591,
-0.0129878642,
-0.0287852157,
0.0228036605,
-0.0485572591,
0.0283667501,
0.0276804324,
-0.0683035925,
-0.0348467715,
0.0033684687,
-0.0082585448,
-0.0068464801,
-0.0481616259,
0.0450411066,
0.0030164344,
0.0058786082,
0.0294701792,
-0.0572984591,
-0.0009434082,
-0.0322836563,
-0.0275382828,
-0.0043798457,
0.0021742012,
-0.0759257823,
-0.0159699321,
-0.0213393364,
0.0154735232,
0.0071596578,
-0.0833048895,
-0.0558333732,
0.0361434072,
-0.0227818452,
0.0121034877,
-0.0414981432,
-0.02046776,
0.0367737412,
-0.0194195714,
-0.0059918817,
-0.0364204198,
0.0374989584,
-0.0380404256,
0.0169095155,
0.0025828113,
0.0046719662,
0.0768711045,
-0.0082407817,
0.0059280279,
0.0088532399,
-0.0150688598,
0.0317030624,
0.0132059306,
0.0095801884,
0.0408908762,
-0.032327503,
-0.0099557675,
0.0741267502,
0.0586161986,
0.0501285978,
0.0380528085,
-0.0201888569,
-0.110822767,
0.050084088,
-0.0466532409,
-0.0104582598,
0.0104009686,
-0.0231670309,
-0.0737315565,
-0.0179075245,
-0.0027926292,
-0.0035409236,
-0.0191758554,
-0.0135059804,
0.0636446327,
-0.0060912655,
-0.0303348899,
0.0456173979,
0.022298757,
-0.0017094854,
0.0755646899,
-0.0022499084,
-0.0035475327,
0.0290168505,
-0.0096894549,
0.0039734305,
-0.0477895066,
-0.0507330149,
0.0129964482,
0.0443972796,
0.08585383,
-0.0087733427,
0.011684062,
-0.0097657451,
-0.0467114486,
0.003475917,
-0.0172318984,
0.0366525576,
0.0054348633,
0.0120976716,
0.0555392168,
-0.0021011883,
0.018643599,
0.0362871625,
-0.026428692,
-0.054495614,
-0.0794394463,
0.0098840436,
0.0172098987,
0.0130914226,
0.008296214,
0.017141277,
0.0202339888,
-0.014367505,
0.0183733404,
-0.0250660628,
-0.0434567407,
0.0057340916,
3.037e-7,
0.0258354805,
0.0396578163,
-0.01106105,
-0.0330777019,
0.0196782388,
0.0291869584,
-0.0526497662,
-0.0080917291,
0.0175684858,
-0.0135575216,
0.0551045202,
0.0283049569,
0.0561940186,
-0.0226220265,
-0.031093264,
-0.04246125,
-0.024241874,
0.0463014096,
-0.0657466128,
-0.0179171748,
0.0365486704,
0.0194330234,
0.0105576897,
-0.0331486315,
0.0351399332,
0.0027980818,
0.0589049757,
-0.0435832143,
0.0370760076,
0.0290577225,
-0.0189744141,
0.0335244127,
0.002663418,
0.0516935363,
0.0076060481,
0.0062209996,
0.0105194924,
0.1173638478,
-0.0159628578,
0.0254579484,
0.0420739576,
0.0550365597,
0.009697549,
-0.0629718453,
0.0437800474,
-0.0498558283,
-0.0173200741,
-0.0325150117,
-0.0580060408,
-0.012470345,
0.0690990016,
-0.0253682323,
0.0207696799,
0.0093864752,
-0.0030648271,
0.0174984802,
-0.0543085113,
0.0028321641,
0.0179468952,
0.0440067835,
-0.0618822165,
-0.0715503842,
0.0058637029,
-0.0030660175,
0.0215131268,
-0.0761843994,
-0.0193301905,
3.244596752e-34,
0.0255393554,
0.0027933915,
0.0689558461,
0.00925449,
0.0100984257,
-0.0126717333,
-0.0023778076,
-0.0130003216,
0.0169200506,
-0.0308745299,
-0.0204983093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16444v2 | Exo2EgoDVC: Dense Video Captioning of Egocentric Procedural Activities Using Web Instructional Videos | 2023-11-28T02:51:13 | 2023-11-29T06:01:34 | Takehiko Ohkawa, Takuma Yagi, Taichi Nishimura, Ryosuke Furuta, Atsushi Hashimoto, Yoshitaka Ushiku, Yoichi Sato | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We propose a novel benchmark for cross-view knowledge transfer of dense video
captioning, adapting models from web instructional videos with exocentric views
to an egocentric view. While dense video captioning (predicting time segments
and their captions) is primarily studied with exocentric videos (e.g.,
YouCook2), benchmarks with egocentric videos are restricted due to data
scarcity. To overcome the limited video availability, transferring knowledge
from abundant exocentric web videos is demanded as a practical approach.
However, learning the correspondence between exocentric and egocentric views is
difficult due to their dynamic view changes. The web videos contain mixed views
focusing on either human body actions or close-up hand-object interactions,
while the egocentric view is constantly shifting as the camera wearer moves.
This necessitates the in-depth study of cross-view transfer under complex view
changes. In this work, we first create a real-life egocentric dataset (EgoYC2)
whose captions are shared with YouCook2, enabling transfer learning between
these datasets assuming their ground-truth is accessible. To bridge the view
gaps, we propose a view-invariant learning method using adversarial training in
both the pre-training and fine-tuning stages. While the pre-training is
designed to learn invariant features against the mixed views in the web videos,
the view-invariant fine-tuning further mitigates the view gaps between both
datasets. We validate our proposed method by studying how effectively it
overcomes the view change problem and efficiently transfers the knowledge to
the egocentric domain. Our benchmark pushes the study of the cross-view
transfer into a new task domain of dense video captioning and will envision
methodologies to describe egocentric videos in natural language. | [
0.0039556003,
0.04930906,
-0.0098857656,
0.0350248814,
0.0213312954,
-0.0031847414,
-0.0051237224,
-0.0282649249,
0.0016219338,
-0.0699566901,
-0.0306220278,
-0.0424432419,
-0.0000970104,
0.018877957,
0.0042786603,
-0.0763541907,
0.0174097195,
-0.0213441886,
-0.0229092389,
0.0146568008,
-0.0146726873,
-0.0104255015,
-0.0378192328,
0.002346406,
-0.017434299,
0.0263967197,
-0.0150771644,
0.0142156119,
0.0645529777,
-0.0378774293,
0.0082863811,
0.026451081,
0.0500994883,
-0.0048153023,
0.0000020494,
0.0082967374,
0.0101423319,
-0.0257875752,
0.0329182968,
0.0239677522,
0.0251389407,
-0.0439497903,
0.0059842635,
-0.0031931708,
-0.0320590623,
-0.0028849135,
0.0430437028,
0.0534070916,
0.053110756,
0.0367223099,
-0.0348748751,
0.002150004,
0.0032249999,
-0.0389470719,
0.0059287311,
-0.0093785515,
0.0193425454,
0.0237317216,
-0.0111876167,
0.0028772079,
-0.0507717133,
0.0360604599,
0.0228023231,
-0.0056378995,
0.0128029203,
0.0368800685,
-0.0271870289,
0.0021309217,
-0.0141879441,
0.0943306014,
0.0041287025,
0.0591167882,
0.0024293608,
0.0049062809,
0.0237258691,
-0.0049897116,
-0.0646347478,
-0.0077307778,
0.0079816049,
-0.0041360576,
-0.0860595182,
0.0627986118,
-0.0134504549,
-0.0140836248,
0.0091062067,
-0.0808652416,
0.0328750834,
0.0584796779,
-0.0194089189,
0.0113437194,
-0.0030401545,
-0.0677295998,
0.0199387595,
0.0033550258,
0.0461119302,
-0.0247292761,
-0.0722672567,
0.0436456688,
-0.0563979149,
-0.0139241694,
0.0860596523,
-0.0034605053,
-0.0010771918,
0.0590425096,
-0.0057218485,
0.0381242186,
-0.0283816345,
0.0580726936,
-0.0185201634,
0.021329958,
-0.0618791468,
-0.0060294596,
-0.0238747187,
0.0010855601,
-0.0169741604,
-0.0069509158,
-0.0141683072,
-0.0139398472,
-0.0364038944,
-0.0002608153,
-0.0286441334,
0.0575268492,
-0.0132891685,
-0.0125821587,
-0.0220635813,
0.0196060371,
-0.0249851234,
0.080275856,
-0.040933989,
-0.0334806703,
-0.0421975181,
0.0301557742,
0.0172625259,
-0.0031971636,
-0.0093907584,
0.0501997434,
-0.0367976539,
-0.0139477132,
0.0136698037,
-0.0019401185,
-0.0591138788,
-0.0114863701,
0.0659442618,
-0.0415684506,
0.0073511228,
-0.0553929321,
-0.002698607,
-0.0562223755,
0.0102193048,
-0.0119970841,
-0.0129403844,
0.0816553831,
0.0194507428,
0.0094838254,
0.0092197321,
0.0351362415,
0.0093152858,
0.0338819325,
0.05430042,
0.0088766161,
-0.0189006533,
0.000864332,
0.0618503504,
0.0400401317,
-0.0001648105,
0.0407144576,
-0.0407193601,
0.0192194786,
0.0361857079,
0.0440705568,
-0.0058488161,
-0.00602997,
-0.0179365855,
-0.0122450544,
0.0739235878,
-0.0363785252,
-0.0712877661,
-0.0307169873,
0.0098022111,
-0.0130713806,
0.0115943663,
-0.0129674142,
-0.0284905601,
0.0937064141,
0.0654191077,
-0.0398181379,
-0.0194888916,
0.0062718862,
-0.0738410279,
-0.078514412,
0.0129614649,
-0.0138582978,
0.0031269297,
-0.039643757,
0.0534219481,
0.0326903537,
-0.0178628322,
0.0348444767,
-0.0260239858,
-0.0269072056,
0.0284133907,
0.0206919406,
-0.045163285,
0.043202538,
-0.0194457583,
-0.0180739556,
-0.063766554,
-0.0149981128,
0.082869485,
0.0161134489,
0.060214147,
-0.0291125048,
0.0249389336,
-0.0281589832,
-0.0619938113,
-0.0412513763,
0.0158300158,
0.0389520004,
-0.0137045179,
0.038930621,
0.0328776352,
-0.0012669121,
-0.069647409,
0.0401719846,
-0.036836382,
-0.0415430702,
0.003482494,
0.0254360288,
-0.007044361,
0.0334911719,
0.0088486085,
-0.0103498725,
0.0058916453,
-0.0216421764,
0.000702654,
0.0365722477,
-0.0442719422,
-0.0329179354,
0.0290225744,
-0.0905067325,
-0.0012260455,
0.0039596646,
-0.0179034136,
-0.0644193217,
0.0680999011,
0.0187289827,
-0.0211092681,
0.004139747,
-0.0198979545,
0.0434041172,
0.0092368415,
0.0120096905,
0.0031667065,
0.0127226282,
-0.0447457209,
0.0513885729,
-0.0351658724,
0.0047326512,
-0.0111567052,
0.0018174907,
0.0076124161,
-0.0214200579,
0.023051342,
0.0087573128,
-0.0146149155,
-0.0497725271,
-0.0100328363,
-0.0854999572,
-0.0099374671,
-0.0061049606,
-0.0225704145,
0.0188071486,
-0.0280132815,
0.0013472862,
-0.0397236608,
-0.0419817194,
0.0355772674,
-0.0401861332,
0.0099577671,
0.0279085152,
0.0375865363,
-0.0034529287,
-0.0291649587,
0.0431586839,
0.0070694648,
0.0072907824,
0.0342920125,
0.0225415267,
-0.0007619902,
-0.0413832888,
0.0051314714,
0.0440383852,
-0.051278092,
0.0018493312,
0.009704357,
0.0016517898,
-0.0493208356,
0.0516300835,
0.001093697,
0.0208936613,
0.0195541345,
-0.0583363026,
-0.0293334406,
0.0076229977,
0.0271732081,
-0.0576506257,
-0.0311325826,
-0.0058047744,
-0.0128322905,
0.0355117545,
-0.0362933576,
0.0156146996,
-0.0800289512,
0.0084090903,
-0.0202121884,
-0.0526161827,
0.002483489,
0.0452852659,
-0.0134432027,
-0.012875447,
-0.0186978988,
-0.0348761268,
-0.009331787,
-0.0285126548,
-0.0170349721,
0.0405138098,
0.0264162645,
0.0001413087,
0.0591074005,
0.0194563381,
0.0124846268,
-0.0038156277,
-0.0174509585,
-0.0595433079,
0.0100709787,
0.0204022638,
0.0137324156,
0.0011818539,
-0.0575964302,
-0.0177882146,
-0.0240413602,
-0.0129421186,
-0.0144065535,
-0.014490854,
0.0049320138,
0.0012497235,
-0.0625545308,
-0.024306139,
-0.0503665209,
-0.0132825896,
-0.0306994263,
0.0414601713,
-0.0226836707,
0.012758187,
-0.0041359938,
0.0065017086,
0.0517741852,
0.0377926677,
-0.0999172181,
-0.0433595292,
0.0290436465,
0.0490032807,
-0.0186022874,
-0.0021760412,
-0.0313267559,
0.0187028293,
0.0006073352,
0.008629756,
-0.0039118598,
0.0187923629,
0.0994996428,
0.0118281879,
-0.0078508602,
0.0612081103,
-0.0229090434,
-0.0360077955,
0.0096381204,
0.0547942817,
-0.0268541556,
0.03628565,
-0.0050555044,
-0.0145046534,
-0.0480660982,
-0.0103261778,
0.0295990147,
0.0586581044,
-0.0156099545,
-0.0083614597,
-0.0948201045,
0.0187292323,
0.0291642435,
-0.0526609793,
-0.0422109626,
0.0185665861,
0.0432505347,
-0.0233009048,
-0.0304538812,
-0.031936381,
-0.0284790676,
0.0131697031,
0.0252165794,
0.0090150991,
-0.047749307,
0.0265234243,
-0.0357677378,
0.0049786149,
-0.0063938317,
0.0290723201,
-0.0189813338,
-0.0325773582,
-0.0137081528,
0.0021952053,
-0.0062187389,
0.0177355018,
0.1133152843,
-0.0478668325,
-0.0160716213,
0.0712865293,
0.0855666175,
-0.0327302404,
-0.0071513089,
0.0393937342,
0.0208174661,
0.0150789442,
0.0085571948,
-0.027369678,
-0.0064847246,
0.0429007746,
0.04797161,
-0.0191323292,
-0.0243235361,
0.0096263122,
0.0052023153,
-0.028052846,
-0.0298456438,
-0.0253659356,
0.0014912512,
0.0107202735,
-0.04106801,
-0.0828770101,
-0.04978697,
0.0850932375,
0.0445119925,
0.0335140675,
-0.0188096035,
-0.0245392099,
0.0403085314,
-0.0873552412,
0.0276010241,
-0.0326435082,
0.040040724,
-0.0123850768,
-0.0282131582,
0.066088669,
-0.0205840226,
0.0002249204,
0.0237633809,
0.0060139513,
-0.0256583691,
-0.0523624606,
0.0627974123,
0.0105141196,
0.1210528463,
-0.0058483197,
0.0503971688,
0.0306538455,
0.0102435732,
-0.0138642611,
-0.0101464633,
0.0349329785,
-0.0464137793,
-0.0309246164,
0.0181527995,
-0.0256967731,
0.0160021279,
0.0184395462,
-0.0076897102,
-0.04157307,
-0.0588965304,
-0.0107534826,
-0.0439878032,
0.0760856569,
0.0012727017,
-0.0011949538,
-0.0228253137,
0.0061781397,
-0.0059907623,
0.0250119045,
-0.0746960416,
0.0060614892,
0.0427713394,
0.0454568267,
-0.0019291603,
0.0348567739,
0.0358802043,
-0.0424998663,
-0.0330541879,
-0.0282001179,
-0.016932521,
0.0392996743,
-0.0191701241,
0.0193332806,
0.0289704092,
0.020383954,
-0.0025537829,
0.0284900758,
0.0068484223,
0.0206160862,
0.0495621227,
0.0320810154,
-0.0261002667,
0.0567732938,
-0.0221818108,
-0.0012149605,
-0.077348195,
0.0568311512,
0.0205424111,
-0.0501886271,
0.0203582104,
0.0029522141,
0.0173234679,
-0.0147642139,
0.0484855883,
-0.0207127202,
-0.0336623825,
0.0587967746,
-0.0256543308,
0.0230263434,
0.0295013897,
0.0861693472,
0.0059329397,
0.0620136745,
-0.012870145,
-0.003161849,
-0.0470228344,
0.0037305909,
0.077844806,
-0.0386789478,
-0.0143713877,
0.0560376197,
0.0140503552,
-0.0358951353,
-0.034357518,
-0.0180434454,
-0.0164249912,
0.0287960134,
0.0765474662,
0.0080317464,
0.0045467084,
-0.0054418868,
-0.0041769468,
-0.0392118916,
0.0068035107,
-0.0001765641,
-0.0161820799,
-5.750129349e-33,
-0.043820098,
0.0054553044,
0.0043482278,
0.0057243225,
-0.0252497029,
-0.0059259278,
-0.050626982,
0.0454287082,
0.0142598348,
0.0214744154,
0.0307345185,
-0.0020339659,
0.0158786681,
0.032110665,
0.0707293525,
-0.0289495308,
0.0512257926,
-0.0244672429,
-0.0189625155,
0.0292695295,
0.032168407,
0.0089092962,
0.0692491382,
-0.0965027735,
-0.0035121953,
0.0306760333,
0.0032580339,
-0.0082639679,
0.0352066197,
-0.0028389848,
-0.017854616,
-0.0505813509,
-0.0084462678,
-0.0168743804,
-0.0267049726,
-0.0116610043,
-0.0720210075,
-0.0291361865,
-0.0206996892,
0.0556184426,
-0.0623261631,
-0.0412494056,
-0.0108643183,
-0.0061410111,
-0.0128789023,
-0.0627899542,
0.0539935641,
-0.0456791259,
0.0425106138,
0.0025805954,
-0.0228963662,
0.0194346309,
-0.0408457406,
-0.0835499465,
0.0297355764,
0.0164826922,
0.0355259366,
-0.0446418747,
-0.033857163,
0.0155434664,
-0.0323467813,
0.0431014374,
0.0860693604,
0.0144320233,
-0.0075298315,
0.0534070432,
-0.0113022123,
-0.0186701622,
-0.0318176225,
0.0169322472,
0.0131360181,
0.094382368,
0.0294234026,
0.0472503789,
0.0472750664,
-0.0032478329,
-0.0249333475,
0.0643162876,
-0.085760884,
0.0186401792,
-0.0282147843,
-0.0002762615,
-0.0161614213,
0.0052470323,
-0.0181588028,
-0.0313474387,
0.0092513543,
-0.0048048138,
0.0356161036,
0.0310224015,
-0.0201382656,
-0.0059412741,
0.0289241485,
-0.0439047441,
0.0289401226,
0.0103150876,
-0.0219741166,
0.0351793282,
-0.0021955806,
-0.0170396511,
-0.041256249,
-0.0381412692,
0.0467900261,
0.0309013799,
0.0162527859,
0.0133887623,
0.0278270207,
0.0426192172,
0.0075547649,
-0.0337476432,
-0.0118036848,
0.0091039678,
0.0058836546,
0.0162910353,
0.0424968228,
0.033824455,
-0.0627813935,
0.025660703,
-0.0310384389,
-0.0052463976,
-0.0105867721,
-0.0236892365,
0.03683009,
0.0222068429,
-0.0264791101,
-0.0015880285,
-0.0508952439,
-0.0789619163,
0.0090642283,
-0.0793885738,
-0.0127406521,
0.0186210517,
2.845e-7,
-0.0313458852,
0.0045139645,
0.029229749,
-0.0574707314,
0.0258956179,
0.0447138436,
-0.0494495519,
0.0657964349,
-0.0488005318,
-0.0286011063,
0.0661558583,
0.0485570878,
0.0433440283,
-0.0153928744,
-0.0376516059,
-0.005730547,
-0.0130826831,
0.0176812075,
-0.0294621456,
-0.036322698,
0.0392531268,
0.0411255285,
0.0168189015,
0.0003203836,
0.033687599,
-0.0876289159,
0.0765073672,
-0.0319442637,
0.0568729676,
-0.0120848902,
0.0476668477,
0.0476640128,
-0.036563199,
0.0126067344,
-0.037184231,
-0.0140227005,
0.0586579554,
0.0279205907,
-0.0333801657,
0.0073400359,
-0.043881502,
0.0492137447,
-0.0114189899,
-0.0025462045,
0.079600282,
-0.0771690309,
-0.0191094223,
0.0096576251,
-0.0493528582,
0.0168326218,
0.0045047281,
0.0314147174,
0.0148053309,
0.0076166182,
0.0194543302,
0.0032286148,
-0.0411350578,
-0.0537954383,
0.0231022779,
-0.0327302963,
-0.0380308703,
0.0356338881,
-0.0296749379,
0.0029110739,
-0.0069723814,
0.0337952636,
-0.0129288342,
1.644967394e-34,
0.0066747102,
0.0086803995,
0.0015414921,
-0.0674293861,
0.0008984234,
-0.000445899,
-0.0285354108,
0.0042344192,
-0.0056874622,
-0.0297161285,
-0.0376282223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03731v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03731v6 | MultiGPrompt for Multi-Task Pre-Training and Prompting on Graphs | 2023-11-28T02:36:53 | 2024-02-22T06:35:04 | Xingtong Yu, Chang Zhou, Yuan Fang, Xinming Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Graphs can inherently model interconnected objects on the Web, thereby
facilitating a series of Web applications, such as web analyzing and content
recommendation. Recently, Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have emerged as a
mainstream technique for graph representation learning. However, their efficacy
within an end-to-end supervised framework is significantly tied to the
availabilityof task-specific labels. To mitigate labeling costs and enhance
robustness in few-shot settings, pre-training on self-supervised tasks has
emerged as a promising method, while prompting has been proposed to further
narrow the objective gap between pretext and downstream tasks. Although there
has been some initial exploration of prompt-based learning on graphs, they
primarily leverage a single pretext task, resulting in a limited subset of
general knowledge that could be learned from the pre-training data. Hence, in
this paper, we propose MultiGPrompt, a novel multi-task pre-training and
prompting framework to exploit multiple pretext tasks for more comprehensive
pre-trained knowledge. First, in pre-training, we design a set of pretext
tokens to synergize multiple pretext tasks. Second, we propose a dual-prompt
mechanism consisting of composed and open prompts to leverage task-specific and
global pre-training knowledge, to guide downstream tasks in few-shot settings.
Finally, we conduct extensive experiments on six public datasets to evaluate
and analyze MultiGPrompt. | [
0.0260316934,
-0.0041314093,
0.0091253221,
-0.0024751897,
-0.0056426949,
0.0023434309,
0.0389469303,
-0.0002876538,
0.0795422718,
-0.0559167936,
-0.0407070555,
-0.0212104023,
-0.0400133841,
0.0484113842,
0.0198141281,
-0.0279588848,
0.0379642323,
0.000834601,
0.0219629221,
-0.0041211313,
0.0034172144,
0.0303834993,
-0.005723807,
0.0232831445,
-0.0339290313,
-0.0532667562,
-0.026717864,
0.0251815822,
-0.021222353,
-0.0667778552,
-0.004559739,
0.0448334068,
0.0280733239,
-0.0035705308,
0.0000022088,
-0.0402313098,
0.0009844824,
-0.0203562547,
-0.0547271296,
-0.0132454615,
0.0277557392,
0.0309286527,
0.061712876,
-0.0160840116,
-0.0447832011,
-0.0354416966,
0.0541472323,
0.0597255826,
0.0347345024,
0.0264400151,
-0.026765829,
0.0243492182,
-0.0079877954,
-0.0329812579,
0.036099676,
-0.0557532944,
0.0088285366,
-0.0439934693,
0.0184080843,
0.022710301,
-0.0279426463,
0.0048779324,
0.0137967477,
0.0200317912,
0.0500042289,
0.0278036408,
0.0326820761,
-0.0176406242,
-0.0643564314,
0.1449560225,
-0.0321233645,
-0.0015441203,
-0.0066027548,
-0.0409310721,
0.024085043,
0.0234029554,
-0.044012364,
-0.0259411857,
-0.0061094528,
-0.004715973,
-0.0520907752,
-0.0010127374,
0.014997744,
-0.0260682032,
-0.00251159,
0.0492116623,
-0.0355480202,
-0.0003625872,
0.0623596981,
0.033620581,
-0.0124661122,
-0.0595984608,
0.0129605681,
0.0299998838,
-0.0603530519,
-0.0004332318,
-0.0272739194,
-0.0124894846,
0.01086675,
0.0194496587,
0.0649616197,
-0.0181280356,
-0.0641548708,
0.0622479767,
-0.0072161527,
0.0310392287,
-0.0259113405,
0.0537143722,
-0.0244363006,
0.0276785828,
-0.0693013296,
0.0067024087,
-0.0467675664,
0.0563598014,
-0.0084569221,
-0.0452993028,
-0.0214518625,
0.0539848357,
-0.0359911807,
0.0095802518,
0.0042407117,
0.0477860272,
-0.0022260689,
0.0325563438,
-0.0023432754,
0.0060047801,
-0.0310517866,
0.0313379541,
0.016248107,
-0.0275629386,
-0.0281929709,
-0.0039837263,
0.0543959066,
-0.0169550516,
0.0118225235,
0.0641701818,
0.0326308236,
-0.0185340196,
-0.0322239138,
-0.0811575055,
0.0085539035,
-0.0288169831,
0.0429279171,
-0.0395995453,
0.0752203465,
0.0146096507,
-0.0083337491,
0.0068074418,
-0.0083419308,
0.0067921369,
-0.0372230038,
0.0846139342,
-0.0216211211,
-0.0110614384,
-0.0269475039,
-0.0056433594,
-0.0394800454,
0.0373701118,
-0.0436059348,
0.0776219442,
0.0470216051,
0.0171698965,
-0.0136319138,
-0.0034491867,
0.0603184551,
-0.0087292064,
0.0720680952,
0.0126411673,
0.0383000039,
-0.0063876612,
0.0169269908,
0.0135128126,
-0.0462004021,
-0.016729705,
0.0399170928,
0.0441699065,
-0.0182904191,
-0.0300739557,
0.0739409477,
0.0434904359,
-0.0133738788,
0.0210274812,
-0.0846175551,
0.0347875543,
-0.0185863208,
-0.0187434833,
-0.020450538,
-0.0056478442,
-0.0438356847,
-0.0122320345,
0.0624960102,
-0.0382677726,
0.0397674516,
0.033391621,
0.0621884316,
0.0241790395,
-0.0447645672,
-0.0172645319,
0.0316546671,
-0.0074563087,
0.0000561566,
-0.0328464583,
0.005295936,
0.0435267165,
0.0216865893,
-0.0465358011,
-0.0554874018,
-0.0201287828,
0.0583516881,
-0.0557926856,
0.0566941425,
-0.023218194,
0.0231973883,
-0.0080777556,
-0.0824149922,
-0.0607081503,
-0.0149908606,
0.0173358601,
-0.0039649205,
-0.0168577749,
0.0054466007,
-0.0349801816,
-0.0078506265,
0.005388001,
0.0463736318,
0.0077883392,
0.0072982367,
0.0360612199,
0.0029051125,
0.0446193255,
0.0346810631,
0.0055689127,
0.022144543,
0.0209271535,
-0.0040376009,
-0.0400933698,
-0.057193663,
-0.0411058664,
0.0446255617,
-0.0005635508,
-0.0393835679,
-0.0196136441,
-0.0444372334,
-0.0294035375,
0.0357943885,
-0.0055815973,
0.0280239899,
0.0117940186,
-0.0414483063,
0.0181453153,
0.0142959822,
0.0116277859,
0.0416151695,
0.0330118462,
0.0081978114,
0.0012648152,
0.0046551335,
0.0002867448,
-0.041738417,
-0.0202351362,
-0.0311707947,
-0.0105140582,
0.0009149681,
0.0136446422,
0.0174327344,
-0.0788431838,
0.0651665702,
-0.0999581739,
0.0039453357,
0.0060345908,
0.0037334508,
-0.0048422697,
0.0209196303,
0.0140534416,
-0.0942468867,
-0.0726628825,
0.0406369604,
-0.0287733898,
0.034489166,
0.0318818018,
0.0279118307,
0.0277927723,
0.0142835025,
-0.0311715417,
-0.0329233706,
0.0645299554,
0.0549453981,
-0.0250306241,
-0.0059361821,
0.0161236487,
-0.0276721474,
-0.006158323,
0.0008725088,
0.0263032354,
0.00167856,
-0.0236146897,
0.0485240296,
0.0493687429,
-0.0344438292,
0.0244091898,
0.0188846271,
-0.0286403373,
-0.0494737849,
-0.0019506901,
-0.0633008331,
-0.0062620523,
-0.016860066,
0.0301918648,
0.0036450713,
0.0274032727,
-0.0048790793,
-0.034202151,
-0.0333462805,
-0.0034357135,
-0.0087785143,
-0.0065530278,
-0.0700813681,
-0.0310919248,
0.0365593471,
0.0094678663,
-0.0305068698,
-0.0098845875,
0.0868252292,
0.0170938727,
-0.0262108967,
0.0364785604,
-0.0169010814,
-0.0329288878,
0.0726836771,
0.0337354429,
0.0332949087,
0.0286433659,
-0.0336100422,
-0.065454036,
0.0494672284,
0.0192689318,
-0.0210101362,
-0.0212172344,
0.0317725167,
0.0022689016,
-0.0033147414,
-0.048535645,
-0.0087983152,
-0.0354252346,
0.0015965559,
0.0141563723,
-0.0163683165,
0.0151775694,
-0.0016917106,
-0.0108271157,
-0.0407755822,
0.0340065323,
-0.037291009,
-0.0100106094,
-0.025354974,
0.0115657691,
0.0080533121,
-0.0207335632,
-0.0298614819,
-0.0497870818,
0.007253021,
0.0362654515,
0.0420593955,
-0.0707727522,
-0.0111613935,
0.0445119999,
0.0103310579,
-0.0198991187,
-0.0144492984,
0.0015615447,
0.0469289795,
-0.0332654417,
0.010168341,
0.0521243624,
0.0252946168,
-0.1091451198,
-0.012484367,
0.0341242403,
-0.0215026196,
0.033840131,
0.0072199097,
-0.121349968,
-0.0310063977,
-0.0175806284,
0.0230171643,
0.043024227,
-0.0597106628,
-0.0221895687,
-0.0828873366,
0.0128495451,
-0.0015313178,
-0.0060983463,
0.0328937955,
-0.0665036067,
0.0168660153,
-0.0059920191,
-0.0200346317,
-0.0265121087,
-0.0329265818,
-0.0185039658,
0.0093934173,
0.0190999936,
-0.0395583808,
0.0121235158,
-0.0394038409,
-0.0040441016,
-0.011816062,
0.0070678354,
0.0132822944,
0.0119017558,
0.0434189513,
0.0358814113,
-0.016774904,
-0.0310799275,
0.0811191425,
-0.030152509,
0.0099072997,
-0.0199296176,
0.0185120236,
-0.0306767002,
-0.0596428737,
-0.0121672973,
0.0804292336,
-0.0081517491,
-0.0220505968,
-0.0004389164,
-0.0071811755,
0.0321585163,
0.0207462758,
0.0506021343,
-0.0304856915,
-0.044238966,
-0.0539121293,
0.0194999054,
-0.0514253639,
-0.0038144477,
0.0139855407,
-0.0509786308,
0.0203509592,
-0.0355816074,
-0.0425130129,
0.0674988031,
0.0101181343,
0.0169223025,
-0.0259539597,
0.044190824,
-0.002946533,
-0.0885478035,
0.0292433146,
-0.0271700341,
0.0034807359,
-0.0455441065,
-0.0382999294,
0.0369587801,
-0.0339634791,
-0.018454263,
-0.0042784102,
-0.0659649223,
-0.0436813198,
-0.0398233421,
0.031086633,
0.0103270579,
0.0557811335,
-0.0351964161,
-0.0193169117,
0.0417788103,
0.0587039739,
-0.0570755266,
-0.04586735,
0.036099378,
-0.0269623455,
-0.0296614822,
-0.0017651006,
-0.0716804937,
0.0375647359,
0.0132655771,
-0.0091527784,
0.0131764263,
-0.0171126612,
0.0360202976,
0.0601008646,
0.0776567906,
0.0117566464,
0.04803041,
-0.0834555179,
-0.0357358642,
0.0249012168,
-0.028089894,
-0.0251479223,
0.023243662,
-0.0001328266,
-0.0158014428,
0.0058022854,
-0.0086428681,
0.033634536,
0.0203562062,
-0.0795503631,
-0.0267262682,
0.0024718898,
-0.0182473212,
0.0348632373,
0.0142647345,
-0.0046251491,
0.0039224727,
0.0521616414,
-0.0088293077,
-0.0189010687,
0.0404055156,
0.0565053262,
0.0024051021,
-0.0529842265,
0.0690330639,
-0.0640031993,
-0.0211222358,
-0.009331448,
-0.0174549669,
0.0334499553,
0.0054091001,
-0.0052168197,
0.0048682303,
0.0035520862,
-0.0112222247,
0.0506348424,
-0.0144653618,
-0.0439756475,
0.0128257303,
0.0245844666,
0.0072088353,
0.0269680973,
0.0761903375,
-0.0100167133,
0.0178215541,
0.0210657846,
-0.0304909162,
-0.0612187237,
-0.0247146897,
0.0025828599,
0.0502679646,
-0.0268965736,
0.0026217215,
-0.0094004115,
-0.071716629,
0.0131618259,
-0.0193630047,
-0.0080737453,
0.0652576163,
0.0602962598,
0.0425583571,
0.026571529,
-0.0100485813,
-0.0337212421,
0.0111755487,
0.0288133435,
-0.0048721638,
0.0350116789,
-6.611691403e-33,
0.0040955991,
-0.0411866419,
0.0046642791,
0.0307125263,
-0.0203966647,
0.0168447178,
-0.0249093547,
-0.0244098678,
0.0019459093,
0.0145731699,
-0.0173499901,
-0.0008834981,
0.0138098579,
0.0082794167,
-0.0011472602,
-0.0321840011,
0.0578102022,
-0.0116608515,
0.0167268422,
0.0714451745,
0.0326657109,
0.047789555,
0.0297994316,
-0.0542082302,
0.0385493711,
-0.0063590864,
0.0062455419,
0.0021387788,
0.0256261826,
0.0471875817,
-0.0237062518,
0.072846517,
0.0286339428,
0.0245946404,
-0.023469191,
0.0616257191,
-0.1364118606,
-0.0619491376,
-0.023078965,
0.0059983977,
-0.0712766424,
0.0014016363,
-0.0052062511,
-0.0105617326,
0.0453514047,
-0.0071259541,
0.0573479906,
0.0522400364,
-0.0109110782,
0.0013903554,
-0.0029533873,
-0.0115616983,
-0.0112476768,
-0.0109390663,
0.0229148977,
0.0591369607,
0.0322278626,
0.0074613886,
-0.0489478186,
0.0548898876,
-0.0465910397,
-0.049188178,
-0.0085212877,
0.0286373962,
0.0008737578,
0.0556770302,
0.0093797632,
0.0031512287,
0.0013130608,
0.0383207612,
0.0211851522,
0.0616789125,
-0.0034669221,
-0.0282160267,
0.0182973277,
-0.0298275575,
-0.0801637694,
-0.0143181672,
0.0303511452,
-0.0146005107,
-0.0070808791,
0.0033867995,
0.0217872746,
-0.0450890809,
-0.0037662841,
-0.0475622006,
-0.0460729524,
-0.0223321263,
0.02672497,
0.0212681796,
-0.0148321586,
0.0613423139,
0.0085726772,
-0.0581294112,
-0.0295786876,
0.0390199348,
0.0310873501,
0.0221790764,
-0.0041100318,
-0.0063417726,
-0.0331123024,
-0.0377761871,
0.0259792879,
-0.0616631322,
0.0324033014,
0.0290708151,
0.0854886174,
0.009975126,
-0.0409614034,
-0.0062594428,
-0.0415899158,
0.0190526992,
0.0297436602,
-0.0132592665,
0.0607669316,
0.0447009057,
-0.0302441586,
0.0753660128,
0.0603945106,
0.013817233,
-0.0279661044,
0.0071935416,
0.0002826681,
0.022968404,
-0.0200928245,
-0.0513206087,
-0.0218189005,
0.030640889,
0.0225618593,
-0.0788619146,
-0.0272041783,
0.0031598855,
2.911e-7,
0.0047816425,
0.0305697657,
0.0207209978,
0.0034526768,
-0.0037219406,
0.0148173999,
-0.0083953626,
0.0503751226,
-0.0135894893,
-0.0043170014,
0.044643987,
0.056273479,
-0.0444785617,
0.0226011127,
-0.0647878051,
0.0029934426,
-0.0342801735,
-0.0009158923,
-0.0596876331,
0.0268524047,
0.0405109413,
0.0259441733,
0.0401394255,
0.0132604549,
0.0062352065,
-0.0501388833,
0.0395013802,
-0.0226232558,
0.0127670905,
0.0029476397,
-0.0023758363,
0.021907188,
-0.0311166029,
0.0605158955,
-0.0280417092,
0.0250974521,
0.0283984784,
-0.0005880815,
-0.0012172465,
-0.006157157,
0.0128780678,
-0.0124130026,
0.0180540755,
-0.0054570674,
0.0840579048,
-0.0782471001,
-0.0267248712,
-0.0006954533,
-0.0424636528,
-0.0369418189,
0.0298084281,
-0.0091281645,
0.0147374338,
0.0110636912,
0.0035304457,
0.0101025701,
-0.0131167052,
-0.0720653608,
0.0285772923,
0.0345306024,
0.013855149,
-0.0472370125,
-0.0092385178,
0.0114203887,
0.0379115306,
-0.0408027209,
-0.0049634674,
2.525343672e-34,
0.0193562396,
-0.0105062686,
0.0134512763,
-0.0000608027,
0.0043616723,
-0.0397427231,
-0.0571825989,
-0.0006477639,
0.0279594213,
-0.0580086,
-0.0355155431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17086v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17086v1 | PEA-Diffusion: Parameter-Efficient Adapter with Knowledge Distillation in non-English Text-to-Image Generation | 2023-11-28T02:31:52 | 2023-11-28T02:31:52 | Jian Ma, Chen Chen, Qingsong Xie, Haonan Lu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Text-to-image diffusion models are well-known for their ability to generate
realistic images based on textual prompts. However, the existing works have
predominantly focused on English, lacking support for non-English text-to-image
models. The most commonly used translation methods cannot solve the generation
problem related to language culture, while training from scratch on a specific
language dataset is prohibitively expensive. In this paper, we are inspired to
propose a simple plug-and-play language transfer method based on knowledge
distillation. All we need to do is train a lightweight MLP-like
parameter-efficient adapter (PEA) with only 6M parameters under teacher
knowledge distillation along with a small parallel data corpus. We are
surprised to find that freezing the parameters of UNet can still achieve
remarkable performance on the language-specific prompt evaluation set,
demonstrating that PEA can stimulate the potential generation ability of the
original UNet. Additionally, it closely approaches the performance of the
English text-to-image model on a general prompt evaluation set. Furthermore,
our adapter can be used as a plugin to achieve significant results in
downstream tasks in cross-lingual text-to-image generation. Code will be
available at: https://github.com/OPPO-Mente-Lab/PEA-Diffusion | [
-0.0011646712,
0.0479302332,
0.0124971401,
0.0496388637,
0.0024609237,
0.0108945612,
0.031468872,
0.0025193745,
0.0102692014,
0.0107191149,
-0.0046830294,
-0.0190748833,
0.0107329199,
0.018609263,
0.0302114412,
-0.1142793968,
-0.0224062074,
-0.0393231548,
-0.0643003881,
-0.0340161584,
0.0028367515,
0.023346914,
-0.0034263099,
-0.0006540512,
-0.0167546738,
-0.0198756512,
-0.0332773626,
0.0429059118,
0.0440541692,
0.0059989062,
-0.0066385227,
0.038729094,
0.0240148269,
-0.0006464804,
0.000002367,
-0.0062684882,
-0.0134634627,
-0.0015025277,
0.0198103078,
0.0209359117,
0.0563374609,
-0.0293461327,
-0.0200132653,
0.0095278127,
0.0055836565,
0.0375506096,
0.0805916116,
0.054919038,
0.0748304725,
0.0759709254,
-0.0274591018,
-0.0342542306,
-0.0096293334,
-0.0257527027,
0.029578222,
0.0027522002,
0.0095344009,
-0.0061786487,
-0.0083959848,
0.0099091856,
-0.0410943702,
0.0521661341,
0.0362927802,
-0.037785586,
-0.0120653501,
0.0448753946,
0.0382742062,
-0.0570017435,
-0.0405564979,
0.0772947967,
-0.0510090776,
0.0078322161,
0.0082564345,
-0.0126433261,
-0.007198052,
0.0478196293,
-0.0184875634,
0.0162393395,
0.0057360986,
0.0262425244,
-0.0043222988,
0.0102104414,
-0.0006620057,
-0.0208019894,
-0.0152666634,
-0.0113875801,
0.05150095,
0.0034870524,
0.0066525028,
0.0260517932,
-0.0175675638,
-0.0457393564,
0.0607203357,
0.0288596358,
0.0651907474,
0.021195773,
-0.0618634038,
-0.046058353,
0.0053240457,
-0.0081099663,
0.034938857,
0.0352100395,
0.0033242113,
0.0318928435,
-0.0660909638,
0.0466680266,
0.0043886914,
0.0390688181,
-0.0668857172,
-0.0001728651,
-0.0413027704,
0.016815152,
-0.0453293025,
-0.0166992471,
-0.04957553,
-0.0024396544,
-0.0288623385,
-0.0066879289,
-0.02029505,
-0.008053394,
0.040155381,
0.0064676646,
-0.0702711344,
-0.001048325,
-0.0461524092,
0.071600236,
-0.0155348806,
-0.0280805752,
0.000058093,
-0.0417253301,
-0.0252672881,
0.0028616018,
0.0401841737,
-0.0258027427,
0.0088096214,
0.0372580513,
-0.0830434859,
-0.0095034661,
-0.0214182977,
0.0076938737,
-0.0174457263,
-0.0606928654,
0.0155379223,
-0.0971148312,
0.0598050617,
-0.0232858825,
0.0181693863,
-0.0725279674,
0.0121307448,
0.014495166,
-0.0174095221,
0.0281407572,
-0.009435392,
0.0181637425,
0.0436511487,
0.0228689723,
-0.0224131681,
0.0607590675,
0.0399046689,
0.0543224178,
-0.0079016089,
-0.005224389,
-0.0148491133,
0.0493942313,
0.0506504886,
0.0504203849,
-0.00510544,
-0.026350325,
0.002016956,
0.0098930737,
0.0693012998,
0.0479336269,
-0.0303705242,
0.01165892,
0.0594206341,
-0.0216362663,
0.0190405287,
0.0130085256,
0.0715643317,
0.0314128436,
-0.0271480214,
0.011431369,
-0.0077793468,
0.036455851,
0.0336004123,
0.0204563048,
0.0139857475,
0.0977805778,
-0.053689938,
-0.0344788693,
0.0547972545,
-0.0249885172,
0.0157981273,
-0.0103809135,
0.0208434705,
0.0516226552,
-0.0381527804,
0.0488677025,
0.0180916172,
-0.0524855927,
0.0303010214,
-0.0269676894,
0.02254913,
0.0629230663,
0.0046363072,
0.0128791407,
0.0062266872,
-0.0063239839,
0.0132774217,
0.0589362271,
0.0140780918,
0.0182885677,
0.0502492562,
-0.0461109504,
-0.0119057847,
-0.0122863175,
-0.0105008855,
0.0782248676,
-0.0093858931,
0.0781700611,
0.0334812663,
-0.004167588,
-0.0551206656,
0.0350343622,
-0.0508753285,
-0.0440866277,
0.0192842949,
0.0291132499,
-0.0093644829,
0.0090070562,
-0.0106188953,
-0.0347773768,
0.0019941002,
-0.0434004478,
0.0145255709,
-0.0094738062,
-0.0481604561,
-0.0944991186,
0.0067234514,
-0.0735203624,
-0.0132597452,
-0.0055008512,
-0.0286309756,
-0.0901899934,
-0.0275397543,
0.0178062115,
0.0132931331,
-0.0268268809,
0.0099904006,
0.0271433704,
0.0212828685,
0.0101649854,
0.0327276364,
0.0059662275,
-0.0157971531,
0.0237779841,
0.0407759398,
-0.0016069442,
-0.0044594826,
-0.042098023,
-0.00549092,
0.0260265954,
0.0084060114,
0.0204205718,
0.0623908825,
-0.0353289805,
-0.0514168777,
-0.0581048429,
0.0093930615,
-0.0066367881,
-0.0302815624,
0.0247281753,
0.0519217849,
0.0108544901,
-0.0032828578,
-0.0862554014,
0.0380966589,
-0.0027900194,
-0.0070307972,
0.0208758824,
-0.0043559233,
0.0404082648,
0.0034315656,
0.0065742298,
0.0488688089,
0.0347232111,
-0.0008816555,
-0.015133312,
-0.0491401255,
0.0453588888,
-0.0370854288,
0.0117130904,
-0.0011348195,
-0.0346543305,
0.0177874789,
0.0091113988,
0.078881003,
0.0380221121,
-0.0073138867,
-0.0256779827,
0.0141996453,
-0.0175815709,
-0.0617047995,
0.0342781246,
-0.0216167718,
-0.004121888,
0.0207364932,
-0.0504074953,
-0.0200085361,
0.0451234542,
-0.0071000024,
-0.0239454396,
-0.0844801515,
0.0006593944,
0.0024128191,
-0.0561994314,
-0.0578184873,
0.0432889946,
0.0010039195,
0.0033607604,
-0.0378990248,
-0.0582684614,
0.0438027047,
-0.0550819486,
-0.0243183207,
-0.0346549526,
-0.0056294436,
-0.0004940697,
0.0051800795,
0.0190374032,
0.0772055238,
-0.0029866742,
0.0264571272,
-0.0350785814,
0.0204805862,
0.0065241395,
-0.0224562492,
0.0477235168,
-0.0389886908,
-0.0221360978,
-0.0451150909,
-0.024207307,
-0.0366759151,
-0.0023160342,
0.0426006578,
-0.0128831379,
-0.0141888093,
-0.0281437282,
0.0014528044,
0.0112140542,
0.0312093161,
0.0363799259,
-0.0211269539,
-0.0206183679,
-0.0374694727,
0.0329664238,
0.0476447977,
0.0049743596,
-0.0366215445,
-0.0415808558,
0.0514820479,
0.03145165,
0.0066875187,
-0.0238932092,
-0.0337892696,
0.0080069881,
-0.0100625642,
0.0435313657,
0.0000107191,
0.0070123901,
0.0941895247,
-0.0368632749,
-0.0187242217,
0.0588649996,
-0.0121863009,
-0.0226245131,
-0.0273710508,
0.0241880547,
0.0971198827,
-0.0139622679,
0.0332911536,
-0.071327962,
-0.0224881694,
-0.0235818978,
0.0191814713,
-0.0023246373,
-0.0161349643,
-0.0525780022,
-0.074197948,
0.0322179571,
0.0370183624,
-0.0165840797,
-0.0322878733,
-0.0196864083,
-0.0085455887,
0.0093854088,
0.000040999,
-0.0143220462,
0.0230319295,
0.0401210003,
-0.007553651,
0.0490360968,
-0.056421373,
-0.0155433761,
-0.0102310609,
0.0107685635,
0.0202724077,
0.0358254872,
-0.0088078408,
-0.0581929274,
-0.0399461463,
-0.0272325855,
-0.014496455,
-0.0073976549,
0.0411431752,
0.0367717184,
-0.0283837449,
0.0265212841,
0.0327339061,
-0.043216452,
0.0087677417,
0.0368919186,
0.0631177053,
0.0086097959,
-0.0277642738,
-0.006677025,
-0.021134235,
0.0474257097,
0.0624314919,
0.0136589454,
-0.0590140857,
-0.0251789354,
-0.0280657802,
-0.01805887,
-0.0557307191,
-0.0126777599,
0.0100630252,
-0.0609446131,
-0.0626739562,
-0.0939914212,
-0.0060400506,
0.0326213837,
0.0813013539,
0.0176174436,
-0.003946688,
-0.0141457822,
0.0012522726,
-0.0125937294,
0.0081803827,
-0.0310723782,
0.0025800813,
-0.0317145772,
-0.050264135,
-0.0220166314,
-0.0520601235,
-0.0081863981,
0.0440564267,
-0.0824342445,
-0.0597589314,
-0.0239040684,
0.0746815875,
0.0110718645,
0.0523785166,
-0.0264995228,
-0.0096230954,
0.1092961058,
0.0286525916,
0.0324407481,
-0.0063894778,
0.0139687834,
0.0366398431,
0.003601949,
0.0178034976,
-0.0230543949,
0.0284661055,
-0.0017299976,
0.0134213809,
-0.0288739204,
-0.0527934842,
0.0017820165,
0.0078029521,
-0.0309733432,
-0.0396996811,
0.0198011901,
-0.0505014136,
-0.0254109614,
-0.0168262236,
0.0069175884,
-0.0875165984,
-0.0095924707,
0.0483621024,
0.0084378775,
0.0187018365,
-0.0291177947,
0.0431350768,
0.0153423827,
-0.0079719378,
-0.0226785354,
0.0327383019,
0.0265472084,
0.0422724187,
0.0222115852,
-0.0079175849,
0.0247198213,
-0.0022333581,
0.0397748686,
-0.0215336606,
0.0707456395,
0.0060288799,
-0.0053102314,
0.0208449885,
0.0062780865,
-0.0262452848,
-0.0500117168,
-0.036317572,
0.0364736654,
0.0397157073,
0.0081978571,
0.1053345203,
-0.0497486405,
0.0113520315,
-0.0117022581,
0.0196061488,
0.0265637413,
-0.0042454884,
0.0253283307,
0.0008228057,
0.0419549793,
-0.0083989529,
0.0744262412,
-0.0403960124,
0.0122087728,
-0.002658563,
0.0329687223,
-0.0417409204,
-0.004784144,
0.0041022901,
-0.0317779221,
0.0150109343,
0.0209344085,
0.004072309,
-0.0426051095,
-0.0193308517,
-0.0067814002,
-0.0360672884,
0.0058833524,
0.0515312031,
0.0066071195,
-0.0430463478,
0.0102010891,
-0.0444665849,
0.0093605611,
-0.0236578155,
-0.0264301654,
0.0165994614,
-6.471667251e-33,
-0.050065551,
-0.0105035631,
0.0230319649,
-0.0100826519,
-0.0117663005,
-0.0118350005,
-0.0326044038,
-0.0219506267,
-0.0063606733,
0.0210975688,
-0.005332585,
-0.0169291943,
0.0272718072,
0.0581964962,
-0.0480287075,
0.0489094183,
0.0635204315,
0.0084572565,
-0.0162622109,
0.0780938491,
0.0490257479,
0.0284044351,
0.0488489904,
-0.0403785668,
-0.0173142366,
-0.011083276,
-0.0184845403,
-0.0159503464,
0.0493130758,
-0.0138557795,
-0.0141909588,
0.0517724305,
-0.0053409096,
-0.0304668527,
-0.0329141356,
0.0184976235,
-0.0606582128,
-0.0418710597,
-0.0373913981,
-0.0047588721,
-0.0640527233,
-0.0517219193,
0.0370981321,
-0.040853411,
0.0313265733,
-0.0249038618,
0.0318380035,
-0.0181094892,
0.0008140389,
-0.0024090514,
-0.0549059249,
0.005854175,
-0.0293994956,
-0.0310352203,
0.0176482368,
0.0593605638,
0.008475638,
-0.0246640444,
-0.0910631195,
0.0241451282,
0.0675777644,
0.0447649509,
0.0406282619,
0.0261928514,
-0.0035532538,
0.0188982077,
0.0085556516,
0.0129678976,
0.0383004136,
0.0237803645,
0.0260710642,
0.0646599084,
0.0345069095,
0.0661072955,
0.0342473872,
-0.034441255,
-0.0326409228,
0.0802702308,
-0.0064652124,
-0.0004965452,
0.0004432444,
-0.0174469296,
0.0121599166,
-0.0027330406,
-0.0253885519,
-0.0399888381,
-0.0127271246,
-0.0625856966,
0.0271652695,
0.0043725329,
-0.0360552743,
-0.0356192365,
0.0536281057,
0.0052167098,
-0.0060374136,
-0.016427882,
-0.0501586758,
0.0102643976,
-0.0064268578,
0.0192650408,
-0.0566093102,
-0.0721208379,
0.0577110685,
0.0428882055,
0.0014064128,
0.0477053858,
0.018074939,
0.0205868222,
-0.0514871553,
0.0055909869,
-0.0660893992,
0.055109296,
0.0214294922,
0.0337444246,
-0.0190638732,
-0.0584394932,
-0.0513683408,
-0.012230251,
0.0144664468,
-0.0270451345,
0.0126120234,
-0.0315810665,
0.0246375334,
0.0244437791,
-0.0629858226,
0.0161752962,
-0.0398108996,
0.0093118977,
0.0426461846,
-0.0654523,
-0.0147593571,
0.0125111351,
2.983e-7,
0.0162990913,
-0.0017391933,
-0.0176599286,
-0.0135843614,
0.0162547044,
0.0192106199,
-0.0365777053,
0.0289674737,
0.0114188343,
-0.058361236,
0.0076080067,
0.036913652,
0.0666941851,
0.0279517602,
-0.0925333649,
-0.0081167649,
-0.0012683376,
0.0266468823,
-0.02124778,
0.0056086872,
0.0497290082,
0.0505778715,
-0.0061051026,
-0.0333527327,
0.0401296876,
-0.0146164699,
0.0746544972,
-0.0133942198,
0.0105539709,
-0.0105023086,
0.0525010489,
-0.0302157644,
-0.0262444392,
0.0371787772,
-0.0233151503,
0.0109302253,
0.0343191847,
0.0569530427,
-0.0072223516,
-0.0009901065,
0.0351893641,
-0.0028449798,
-0.0206988025,
-0.1034586653,
0.069276765,
-0.0275612548,
0.0108201765,
0.0035368148,
-0.0214092303,
0.005516394,
0.035325136,
-0.0428536609,
-0.0556689091,
0.0141619127,
0.0507584959,
-0.0106452042,
-0.0468464307,
-0.0213723257,
-0.0234311689,
-0.0383975804,
-0.0276338942,
-0.0537610538,
-0.0831170753,
-0.0142036444,
-0.0111099463,
-0.0168143418,
-0.0102088675,
2.613753704e-34,
-0.0165441707,
-0.0315396264,
0.0195386317,
-0.0395454615,
0.0117036011,
-0.0079670064,
-0.0183715243,
-0.0108192498,
-0.0111001814,
-0.0619945973,
-0.0566699319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16421v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16421v3 | CDEval: A Benchmark for Measuring the Cultural Dimensions of Large Language Models | 2023-11-28T02:01:25 | 2024-06-20T11:52:47 | Yuhang Wang, Yanxu Zhu, Chao Kong, Shuyu Wei, Xiaoyuan Yi, Xing Xie, Jitao Sang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | As the scaling of Large Language Models (LLMs) has dramatically enhanced
their capabilities, there has been a growing focus on the alignment problem to
ensure their responsible and ethical use. While existing alignment efforts
predominantly concentrate on universal values such as the HHH principle, the
aspect of culture, which is inherently pluralistic and diverse, has not
received adequate attention. This work introduces a new benchmark, CDEval,
aimed at evaluating the cultural dimensions of LLMs. CDEval is constructed by
incorporating both GPT-4's automated generation and human verification,
covering six cultural dimensions across seven domains. Our comprehensive
experiments provide intriguing insights into the culture of mainstream LLMs,
highlighting both consistencies and variations across different dimensions and
domains. The findings underscore the importance of integrating cultural
considerations in LLM development, particularly for applications in diverse
cultural settings. Through CDEval, we aim to broaden the horizon of LLM
alignment research by including cultural dimensions, thus providing a more
holistic framework for the future development and evaluation of LLMs. This
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for cultural studies in LLMs, paving
the way for more culturally aware and sensitive models. | [
-0.0061357962,
0.0724927559,
-0.0368020236,
0.0363830328,
-0.0684687197,
0.0193565711,
0.0237729978,
-0.0447809435,
-0.0047001923,
0.0226801299,
-0.0232030209,
-0.1054122597,
0.0416491032,
0.0035712635,
0.0263543613,
-0.0193914678,
0.042117659,
0.0248374157,
-0.0191851966,
-0.0009131227,
0.028353503,
0.0435416251,
0.0250536557,
0.0424749553,
-0.028832145,
-0.0082184337,
0.0065078735,
0.0068490356,
0.061976932,
-0.0393357798,
-0.011419815,
0.0382546484,
-0.0084778862,
0.0870792344,
0.0000019655,
-0.083839789,
-0.0173922163,
-0.0185052063,
0.0130057,
0.0530429594,
0.0626269355,
0.0065977955,
-0.0567912608,
0.0014424197,
-0.0469360501,
-0.0023036958,
0.0733360797,
0.0088834232,
0.0113067646,
0.0465477407,
-0.0054938048,
-0.0226179622,
-0.0000994754,
-0.0299202986,
-0.0954371691,
-0.022617951,
0.029165525,
0.0537214875,
0.005309029,
-0.0062016007,
-0.0106186485,
0.0385072865,
0.0082217138,
-0.005974479,
-0.0437053256,
-0.0053998362,
-0.04990099,
-0.0632496625,
0.031916447,
0.051037129,
0.0632894784,
-0.0039480957,
0.0092162341,
-0.0025631795,
-0.0315149389,
-0.0006760728,
-0.0141624277,
0.0109044174,
0.0080143251,
0.0342688337,
0.0279498957,
-0.0164221972,
0.0186349116,
0.0323989503,
0.025482079,
0.0677381381,
0.0459073521,
-0.0285270121,
-0.0311743803,
-0.0087366784,
-0.0285623446,
-0.0500893071,
-0.0142421545,
0.0219995342,
-0.0291646086,
0.0294637047,
-0.0172852334,
0.0091757625,
0.0532540679,
-0.0329106934,
0.0314254649,
0.0694868565,
0.0071656099,
-0.0139998291,
0.0305649471,
0.0934470296,
-0.0390687697,
-0.0356638916,
-0.0568803363,
0.0111633735,
0.0010556027,
-0.0133090708,
0.0191610456,
-0.0337204449,
-0.0078756595,
0.0039479509,
-0.0953586251,
0.0252736527,
-0.0239401888,
0.027630413,
-0.0331881084,
-0.0511148237,
-0.0120180165,
-0.0027638411,
0.0057246168,
0.0735845938,
-0.0459577069,
-0.0106864898,
-0.0209880862,
-0.0753869116,
0.0552569181,
0.0319085345,
-0.0531498604,
-0.0272558816,
-0.0264825039,
0.0199268814,
-0.0041867024,
0.0125360815,
-0.0190194938,
-0.0086283805,
-0.0361686982,
-0.0790044069,
-0.0038439638,
-0.077973552,
0.0395977162,
0.0017423102,
-0.0152908592,
-0.0480527766,
0.0114546604,
0.0069556315,
0.0217914414,
-0.0103177503,
0.0017046959,
0.0536649264,
0.0651167259,
0.0145760551,
0.0001688792,
0.0666671768,
0.0280269273,
-0.0171686895,
0.0583373569,
-0.0482515283,
-0.0278602373,
0.0669193938,
-0.0031637729,
0.0308115706,
-0.0517646335,
-0.0016731485,
0.0257301442,
0.0365105718,
0.0278779957,
0.0729231611,
0.0088730389,
0.0044475775,
0.0352230445,
0.0642173663,
-0.0198313054,
0.0264143609,
0.0494573787,
0.0124230171,
0.0112774353,
0.0181886386,
-0.0423249565,
-0.0144547038,
-0.0178531595,
0.0268489663,
0.0056912345,
0.0888818204,
-0.0287084859,
-0.0050303824,
-0.0322811231,
0.0216063391,
0.0267839674,
-0.0032548415,
0.0217348095,
-0.0634682402,
0.0051666708,
0.0124553768,
0.0272144098,
-0.0765559301,
-0.0154473679,
-0.0167877842,
0.0324893445,
0.045908004,
0.031356819,
0.0106216334,
-0.0132317413,
0.0311746169,
0.0049964366,
0.060661681,
0.0645708069,
0.0000570949,
-0.0236667451,
-0.0589103848,
-0.0125928922,
0.0010390665,
-0.0243732389,
0.0239589922,
0.0310356878,
0.0368736424,
0.022710992,
-0.0026821787,
-0.0528686419,
0.0056308205,
-0.0798936635,
0.0097843036,
-0.0477130003,
-0.0025369711,
0.0310032926,
0.0457660481,
-0.0262032636,
-0.004372838,
-0.0155273415,
0.0030444153,
0.0292072147,
0.0292653944,
-0.0442019179,
0.0540672764,
0.0698554888,
-0.0268400796,
-0.0144740008,
0.026108589,
0.0112510202,
-0.0343237743,
0.0116846487,
-0.0096313842,
-0.0197322648,
-0.0484720804,
0.0412142351,
-0.0350293554,
0.0247483086,
-0.0363226123,
0.0479424782,
-0.0133220917,
0.0350646861,
-0.0096764024,
0.013733658,
0.0628182665,
-0.0219048467,
-0.0518705249,
0.0386240408,
-0.0121461377,
0.0236531962,
0.06161974,
0.0214565042,
-0.049945455,
-0.0383821949,
-0.095374532,
-0.0059198551,
-0.0128622251,
0.0214827582,
0.0040180301,
0.0018206873,
-0.0347115584,
0.034789063,
-0.0713972375,
-0.0195742268,
0.0528019853,
0.0278335735,
0.0326670669,
-0.0545018166,
-0.0390391536,
-0.0174028911,
-0.019563498,
-0.0138737587,
0.0019330104,
-0.0114041474,
0.0005453179,
-0.0351372287,
-0.0108097643,
-0.0685973763,
-0.012032778,
-0.001592744,
-0.0562721938,
0.0280795787,
0.0600139275,
0.0930569172,
-0.0065506846,
0.0186218861,
-0.0132783884,
0.0297061689,
-0.0053036264,
-0.0140950335,
-0.0253276266,
0.0062622046,
-0.0100595783,
-0.0108860359,
-0.1008176357,
-0.0202500392,
0.0710073858,
-0.0077433391,
-0.0047785304,
-0.0417748764,
0.0216256082,
-0.0551707149,
-0.0074173529,
0.0181547906,
-0.0201291703,
-0.048363436,
0.0552221052,
-0.035991624,
-0.0609472431,
0.0344328247,
-0.0367067084,
-0.0043536806,
-0.0287174489,
0.0057850801,
-0.0314287096,
0.0424848944,
-0.0176134128,
0.0435600393,
0.0197011381,
-0.0107620666,
-0.0353204347,
0.0050275014,
0.0227424726,
-0.0572314374,
0.0703593045,
-0.0492431112,
0.0174533166,
-0.0404914208,
-0.0107941302,
-0.0463397279,
0.0314519703,
-0.0023994471,
0.0400398113,
0.0262376908,
-0.001494291,
-0.0031928162,
0.0172424149,
0.0360953063,
0.0040886542,
-0.0097146649,
0.0528949387,
-0.0114311352,
-0.0016828374,
0.0382920317,
0.010560086,
0.0196166709,
-0.0308941603,
0.0216907114,
0.0041710921,
0.0458446145,
0.0000173368,
0.0006168316,
-0.0133629562,
0.0500034988,
-0.007993062,
-0.0286865458,
0.0120186396,
0.0748106688,
-0.0245442074,
0.0371496044,
0.0962649137,
0.0117725572,
-0.0205559395,
0.0123255784,
-0.0413436517,
0.0210330319,
0.0129479747,
0.0187818855,
-0.0975945145,
0.0451344103,
0.0056491061,
-0.014826905,
-0.0263626091,
-0.0140425507,
-0.0265852902,
-0.1104385257,
0.0089361714,
0.0492938049,
-0.0727506354,
-0.0337247513,
0.0338574387,
0.0006210271,
0.0045465049,
0.0600742884,
0.0309591033,
-0.002089587,
-0.0391013175,
0.0028588884,
-0.0435127355,
-0.0728323162,
0.0295288097,
-0.0684697554,
0.0788038298,
0.0547784641,
0.04324653,
0.0028340232,
-0.0666759461,
-0.0154755618,
-0.0059839501,
-0.0325064622,
0.0348202586,
-0.0385703221,
0.0237988345,
-0.0196051896,
-0.0157096107,
-0.0115803471,
-0.0074839331,
-0.0126211457,
0.0305919852,
0.0626055226,
-0.0028697848,
-0.0134641202,
-0.0145939328,
0.0185528547,
-0.0094396323,
0.0680930614,
0.0032137693,
-0.0431757793,
-0.00476682,
0.0008849064,
-0.0204943996,
0.0174629651,
-0.0499186404,
0.0208066888,
-0.0404128209,
-0.0215726048,
-0.0312889703,
-0.0555554964,
-0.0212441776,
0.0190378502,
0.0478209108,
-0.0234231576,
0.0182851087,
-0.0171085093,
-0.0346380956,
0.0262139663,
-0.0244277772,
0.0399961546,
-0.0456820615,
-0.0049450495,
-0.0121797714,
-0.0336183794,
0.0248480067,
0.0300838612,
-0.0514262728,
-0.0733769536,
0.0152200339,
-0.0035218194,
0.0185420308,
0.0054966579,
0.0354723707,
-0.0240128431,
-0.0245461948,
-0.0174396578,
-0.0002799501,
0.0296298508,
-0.006699244,
0.0095479162,
-0.024423169,
0.0311202127,
-0.0063319504,
0.0325006545,
-0.0084301587,
0.052112285,
-0.0317709595,
-0.0215991773,
0.0171297397,
0.0444013774,
-0.0283556338,
-0.0888479054,
-0.0009843681,
-0.0477521643,
-0.0511011034,
-0.0768221244,
-0.0288446527,
-0.0183239821,
-0.0356662348,
0.0414954647,
0.0065373923,
0.0175110083,
-0.0241327956,
-0.0258118808,
0.0065328982,
-0.0235044565,
0.0154424952,
-0.0304661691,
0.0586923063,
0.0061925268,
0.0095448215,
-0.0215197243,
0.0112089245,
-0.033688236,
0.0462690964,
-0.0007904347,
0.1133316606,
0.0090335431,
0.0299168862,
0.0396456085,
0.010432086,
0.0255766492,
-0.0145231197,
0.0082239946,
-0.0088770809,
0.070226714,
-0.0113615077,
0.0985065922,
-0.0061048619,
-0.0088186665,
-0.0444170758,
0.0256245863,
0.0044317921,
-0.0408187807,
-0.0025488376,
0.0322855636,
-0.0503652245,
-0.0173392668,
0.0359245725,
-0.0098507814,
-0.0230991319,
-0.0027845872,
-0.0045960844,
-0.0014657627,
-0.0610139407,
0.038527526,
-0.0293915812,
-0.0555115342,
-0.005273045,
-0.1140324101,
-0.0560172312,
-0.0287367031,
0.0042565255,
-0.0179855935,
-0.0164009593,
-0.0043459944,
0.0772184283,
-0.0413096137,
-0.0093815476,
-0.0439945422,
-0.0284698755,
-0.0482488126,
0.0011236677,
0.0191389062,
-6.259380318e-33,
-0.0268463381,
-0.0188605431,
0.0396730676,
-0.0212151539,
-0.0759033412,
-0.0167102236,
-0.0259993412,
0.0208601486,
-0.0386243761,
0.0104966527,
-0.0082233101,
-0.0261791125,
0.0055245683,
0.008309627,
0.0357463695,
0.0317841209,
-0.0088704154,
0.0174494777,
-0.0251425765,
-0.0033133267,
0.0162628945,
-0.0344807021,
0.0648237243,
-0.057695318,
0.0537416749,
-0.0156604219,
-0.0124837365,
0.0118665779,
0.006941793,
0.0383280627,
-0.0361579172,
0.0308092479,
0.0168359932,
-0.021661602,
0.0090133483,
0.0011530149,
-0.0074774092,
-0.0291434936,
0.0550206676,
0.0180093795,
0.035528902,
-0.0396349505,
0.0007104698,
-0.0377576314,
-0.0674052089,
0.0195670687,
0.0097845476,
-0.0294253659,
0.0007228552,
-0.0145273926,
-0.089794144,
0.0448869467,
-0.0061315265,
0.0279785227,
-0.0037575529,
0.04652863,
-0.0192949045,
-0.0102000972,
-0.0446425639,
0.0206150413,
0.0198028572,
0.0342960022,
0.1072121039,
0.0176879261,
0.0006713966,
0.0499355309,
0.0201139059,
0.0072789053,
0.0074062208,
-0.0209890734,
0.0587901585,
0.0145772994,
0.0163774546,
0.0989787877,
-0.0221929681,
-0.0125650344,
-0.0309942178,
0.010243386,
0.0531771779,
-0.0170886666,
0.0030405999,
0.0026957812,
-0.0614600517,
-0.0183969401,
0.0151060736,
0.0067371251,
-0.0091933552,
-0.0348472893,
0.0274979174,
-0.0250152778,
-0.0073369569,
-0.0087220995,
0.0531490669,
-0.0391702093,
0.002956908,
0.0190625805,
-0.0246077981,
-0.0259698126,
-0.0020832648,
0.0401564389,
-0.0525697581,
-0.039677918,
-0.0252987929,
0.0108855842,
-0.0093019214,
0.0066564353,
-0.0135159437,
0.0153715387,
-0.0596473292,
0.0212905388,
-0.0121619143,
0.0088349832,
-0.0043101786,
-0.0420449264,
0.0514895059,
-0.0307011046,
0.0044775554,
-0.0039406558,
0.0794574395,
-0.0112177301,
-0.0329125039,
-0.0096479654,
-0.0196761247,
0.020622544,
-0.0136243142,
0.0432369411,
-0.0306397714,
0.039180588,
0.056237895,
0.0009269249,
-0.0185114797,
-0.0043567754,
2.744e-7,
0.0154357115,
0.0152344396,
0.0295665432,
0.0311609507,
0.0027630525,
0.0037828847,
-0.029268533,
0.0203289147,
0.0037654995,
0.0064044353,
0.0411221795,
-0.0021640765,
0.1053403914,
0.0399336554,
-0.036081966,
0.024781445,
-0.04288866,
0.0198387261,
-0.0579556897,
0.0436006486,
-0.0383729078,
0.0483846031,
-0.0004570497,
-0.0146927508,
-0.0446858853,
-0.0122258188,
0.0392703414,
-0.0192301758,
-0.0113406172,
0.052495718,
0.0088313548,
-0.0449098311,
0.012348759,
-0.0126044033,
0.0192007758,
0.0352760106,
0.0392455794,
0.0781226829,
0.0061529609,
0.0102875484,
0.0261674449,
-0.0189375095,
-0.0163331758,
-0.1031146199,
0.0304791145,
0.0187699646,
-0.0456237309,
-0.0410595648,
-0.0226196665,
-0.0261696912,
0.0269593392,
-0.0126795778,
-0.0008423427,
0.0481045097,
0.032249704,
-0.0201333594,
0.0038195194,
-0.0027328902,
-0.0354241431,
-0.007244789,
-0.0229613893,
-0.0693447068,
0.0093174158,
-0.0065944283,
-0.0182307623,
-0.0013006321,
0.0065950365,
2.364397373e-34,
0.0257338937,
-0.0224222094,
0.0373475626,
0.0156488307,
0.0365063213,
0.0018782883,
-0.016021898,
0.039701499,
-0.0073783565,
-0.0234276131,
-0.0051598428
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16362v1 | Reducing Gender Bias in Machine Translation through Counterfactual Data Generation | 2023-11-27T23:03:01 | 2023-11-27T23:03:01 | Ranjita Naik, Spencer Rarrick, Vishal Chowdhary | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in neural methods have led to substantial improvement in the
quality of Neural Machine Translation (NMT) systems. However, these systems
frequently produce translations with inaccurate gender (Stanovsky et al.,
2019), which can be traced to bias in training data. Saunders and Byrne (2020)
tackle this problem with a handcrafted dataset containing balanced gendered
profession words. By using this data to fine-tune an existing NMT model, they
show that gender bias can be significantly mitigated, albeit at the expense of
translation quality due to catastrophic forgetting. They recover some of the
lost quality with modified training objectives or additional models at
inference. We find, however, that simply supplementing the handcrafted dataset
with a random sample from the base model training corpus is enough to
significantly reduce the catastrophic forgetting. We also propose a novel
domain-adaptation technique that leverages in-domain data created with the
counterfactual data generation techniques proposed by Zmigrod et al. (2019) to
further improve accuracy on the WinoMT challenge test set without significant
loss in translation quality. We show its effectiveness in NMT systems from
English into three morphologically rich languages French, Spanish, and Italian.
The relevant dataset and code will be available at Github. | [
0.0065869926,
0.095025368,
-0.0215969849,
0.025785923,
-0.013220015,
0.0036319699,
0.0476832986,
-0.0167168397,
-0.0305838622,
0.0001990839,
-0.0355725363,
-0.070562467,
0.0283465739,
-0.0045479117,
0.0599801354,
-0.0071064383,
0.025194671,
0.0027430321,
-0.0368289165,
-0.0486003943,
-0.0094946753,
0.0265780464,
0.0092047304,
0.0242079683,
0.0010613806,
-0.0177681129,
0.028612392,
0.0579154864,
0.0165647436,
0.017722467,
0.0531085394,
0.0342858657,
-0.0239982549,
0.05065348,
0.0000020309,
-0.0489042774,
-0.0202554502,
0.0261224415,
-0.0009912713,
-0.0179715585,
0.020079283,
-0.0407350846,
-0.0378543735,
0.0369591266,
0.0035096484,
0.0021475961,
0.04559182,
-0.0013662388,
0.0501660332,
0.0736799985,
-0.0078029777,
0.0008717702,
-0.0422095209,
-0.0854540691,
-0.0396936759,
0.0039415387,
-0.0170016307,
-0.038622275,
-0.0681910738,
0.0011885366,
-0.0163504016,
0.0379783288,
0.0049155927,
-0.0029746289,
-0.0361405946,
0.0343466848,
-0.0116243996,
-0.048311159,
0.0178879742,
0.0610120893,
-0.0226217508,
-0.00592564,
0.0010085771,
-0.0349903703,
0.0267245658,
-0.0144257462,
-0.0433126763,
0.0155173494,
-0.0093202861,
-0.0096022775,
0.0060118437,
-0.0041840086,
0.0394909717,
0.016950205,
-0.0169269592,
0.0031186948,
0.0403852388,
-0.0326055102,
0.0276932865,
0.0223900545,
-0.002393129,
-0.0022773768,
0.0465728641,
-0.0384930559,
0.0109331608,
0.0041201608,
-0.0212900359,
-0.0474657267,
0.0297094658,
-0.066718787,
0.0162895173,
0.0504470989,
-0.0100548659,
0.0141038625,
-0.02008285,
0.0253792405,
-0.0252484027,
0.002234271,
-0.0626183376,
-0.0462728553,
-0.0146825789,
0.0088732438,
-0.04480277,
-0.0379606709,
-0.0639138147,
0.0818617195,
-0.0080694919,
-0.0128927249,
-0.0295413956,
-0.0152276503,
0.0460174829,
0.0074329171,
-0.0873116404,
-0.0085976832,
0.0008947101,
0.0550932698,
-0.036495436,
-0.0023814403,
0.0079356097,
-0.0708341077,
-0.0378226601,
-0.010568643,
-0.0255018417,
-0.0551309139,
0.0236517042,
0.0750781521,
-0.0108930496,
-0.0235167183,
-0.0267317593,
-0.0162402689,
-0.0333236791,
-0.0922532752,
0.0534460023,
-0.0562285036,
0.0457717329,
0.0167808272,
0.0201857593,
-0.0592515506,
-0.0086626103,
0.0050322306,
-0.0025343336,
0.0589469671,
0.0254537873,
-0.0252433997,
0.0789479762,
0.0009445558,
-0.0496288985,
0.0718011186,
0.0662328601,
0.0056186919,
-0.0162552893,
0.0236235932,
-0.0276153814,
0.0621849597,
0.0658772886,
0.02857331,
-0.0289896168,
0.0148175051,
-0.0104421899,
0.0764875785,
0.0831490085,
0.0110410843,
0.0046209428,
-0.0015146791,
0.0650497675,
-0.0017600716,
0.0275197197,
0.0779837519,
0.0323222615,
-0.0191449858,
-0.0218717922,
-0.0048720315,
-0.0572465062,
0.0166868567,
-0.0160184745,
0.0008986602,
-0.0407141335,
0.0487091653,
-0.0228166971,
-0.0544785634,
0.0233317707,
0.0174028873,
-0.0096353022,
-0.0149303861,
0.0414657556,
0.0546170883,
-0.0355467945,
0.0261376332,
0.0139367506,
-0.0576986037,
0.0319822989,
-0.0024866452,
-0.0335565433,
0.0488060191,
0.026697997,
-0.0271611884,
-0.0429184064,
-0.0288364477,
-0.025674222,
0.0560860783,
0.0545553453,
0.0323881432,
0.0409732126,
-0.0588457137,
-0.0075169248,
0.0448701382,
0.0309228543,
0.0398738123,
0.0108347852,
0.0579014868,
0.0596790351,
-0.0396869443,
-0.0671008602,
0.0260352492,
-0.0579853617,
-0.0328143314,
0.061368037,
0.0061216559,
0.0023755087,
0.0320018493,
-0.0383860618,
-0.0022923101,
0.0058804615,
-0.0359003283,
-0.0047512422,
0.0268054325,
-0.0631607994,
-0.0489525422,
0.0027991002,
-0.0725140423,
-0.0543275662,
0.0266350769,
-0.0262101162,
-0.0338753276,
0.0292509124,
-0.0215913653,
-0.0061584259,
-0.0426667593,
0.0041252687,
0.0391154811,
0.0217944235,
-0.0109036826,
0.0189876873,
-0.0156217963,
-0.0399263054,
-0.0033190686,
-0.0369458273,
-0.0073740366,
-0.0916485116,
-0.0384987667,
0.0348922014,
0.0163889024,
0.0377202667,
0.0263818856,
0.0161826089,
-0.0313396938,
-0.0383166075,
-0.0375707075,
0.0186211467,
-0.0230907146,
0.0233163629,
0.0040295296,
0.0407163091,
-0.0241947528,
-0.0121205067,
-0.0228439048,
0.0125452178,
-0.0278886817,
0.0155837098,
0.0279956926,
-0.0135533204,
0.0384495072,
-0.0246735513,
-0.0330706611,
-0.0208371766,
0.0372172184,
0.0273055006,
0.0050941207,
-0.0784852505,
0.01944286,
-0.0152403144,
-0.0048882663,
-0.0072176452,
-0.0526106842,
-0.0137323076,
0.0068049235,
0.0373204313,
0.0616856664,
-0.0239907485,
-0.0145110544,
0.0366284586,
0.0041942629,
-0.0589593872,
0.0164752584,
0.0035809618,
0.0014766997,
0.0033187121,
-0.0428888574,
-0.0276368912,
0.002820421,
0.0080924453,
-0.0264347289,
-0.0302289929,
0.0328465961,
-0.0136595592,
-0.017577704,
-0.004729595,
0.0334783569,
0.0034482838,
0.0199686587,
-0.014860793,
-0.0236201715,
0.0328653045,
-0.0151840327,
-0.0076755141,
-0.0439076982,
0.0004110993,
-0.0264339242,
0.0301395021,
-0.0247935932,
0.0197415557,
0.0576957427,
-0.0095989676,
-0.0735994652,
-0.0052801641,
0.0347069688,
-0.0241312534,
0.012123948,
-0.0572070144,
0.0016601034,
-0.017847877,
-0.0450367443,
-0.043904759,
-0.0013951433,
0.0146268904,
0.0017146142,
-0.0048903427,
-0.0188295543,
-0.0144950449,
-0.0162063818,
-0.0306957904,
0.0905370191,
-0.0074918987,
0.0055830237,
-0.0096363081,
0.003350232,
0.0038155657,
0.0349217169,
0.0075252992,
-0.0626330078,
-0.0168657824,
0.0119672846,
-0.0068427012,
-0.013072839,
-0.0257962532,
-0.0120953368,
0.0329687446,
-0.0235301796,
-0.0259617586,
-0.0347546376,
0.0301591884,
-0.060458757,
-0.0268006828,
0.0768544003,
-0.0095890481,
-0.0618414767,
-0.0033682787,
0.0310962275,
0.0417472124,
0.0294612925,
0.041059915,
-0.0306481849,
-0.0068311971,
0.0399981849,
0.0506663844,
0.0263161939,
-0.0042857616,
-0.0398693793,
-0.1267824173,
0.0258637127,
0.0499134734,
-0.0615837947,
-0.0407596156,
-0.0082535902,
-0.049321454,
-0.0773184448,
0.0452204943,
0.0083323093,
0.0206637718,
0.0027665719,
0.0008319489,
0.0284243729,
-0.0650055557,
0.0053257174,
-0.0788068622,
0.0614128411,
0.0624184459,
0.0325042047,
-0.0272591151,
-0.0004653564,
0.060002055,
-0.0130850822,
0.0026755482,
-0.0075528477,
0.0426896177,
-0.0073137498,
-0.0269962829,
0.002017281,
0.0341120921,
0.0063258815,
0.0216111951,
0.0183787867,
0.0334628001,
0.0183462761,
0.016100999,
-0.0220404696,
-0.0302902851,
-0.0013617506,
0.0640120208,
0.0036102768,
-0.0559409261,
-0.0088167302,
-0.0150559237,
0.0018246769,
-0.0188266691,
-0.0012071752,
-0.014582363,
-0.0181895997,
-0.0311941206,
-0.0651559159,
-0.0731251836,
0.0266034827,
0.0382323489,
0.0003140989,
-0.0668740347,
0.0182052944,
0.0094463574,
-0.0659135133,
0.0567839295,
-0.0327950679,
0.0277255028,
-0.0192160271,
-0.003562822,
0.0007534811,
-0.0566224642,
-0.0166522581,
0.0315562114,
-0.0916583762,
-0.0574698821,
0.0077705667,
0.0737016276,
0.0204956345,
0.0831551477,
-0.0270046294,
-0.0246967077,
0.0199051145,
0.0643670335,
-0.0300876517,
-0.0061709462,
0.0626134053,
-0.0019039911,
0.0035782997,
0.0448888205,
-0.0278686229,
-0.0109613826,
0.0210281909,
0.0598790571,
0.0335162804,
-0.0132513642,
0.0323649533,
0.0114457309,
0.0198990814,
-0.0659727678,
0.0138473623,
-0.062216986,
0.014502977,
-0.0060617574,
-0.0245837551,
-0.0236102417,
-0.0076613985,
0.0421711579,
0.008835448,
0.0124214031,
-0.0352975428,
-0.0117529407,
-0.0005091449,
-0.0111270631,
-0.0234837513,
-0.0114821512,
0.0426656827,
-0.0055189189,
0.0206297431,
0.0058686752,
0.0062547657,
-0.0153453117,
0.0506366305,
-0.017876355,
0.0180579927,
0.006547174,
0.0316293538,
-0.0404491648,
0.0255151149,
-0.0221598092,
0.020509867,
-0.0648141429,
0.0625207424,
0.0576494709,
-0.0383683518,
0.0773959979,
-0.0096136555,
-0.0074132206,
-0.0010628866,
0.0159504097,
0.0007664048,
0.0299148131,
-0.0070763109,
-0.0034637575,
0.0194518622,
-0.0299203508,
0.0425433777,
0.0375882238,
0.0476599187,
-0.017631771,
0.0090561416,
-0.0176584404,
-0.0165412892,
0.0013013998,
-0.0473540314,
-0.0398047976,
-0.0317232087,
-0.076142624,
-0.0670398772,
-0.001887603,
-0.0027509888,
0.025995044,
0.0153777562,
0.0039531533,
0.0496479943,
-0.0734337866,
-0.0062851408,
-0.0372574218,
0.0126600498,
0.0482017025,
-0.0225153975,
-0.0559899732,
-6.064795228e-33,
-0.021666605,
0.0029050591,
0.0237429906,
-0.0361041948,
-0.0031501784,
-0.0201363005,
-0.0096012503,
-0.0258594956,
0.0170902964,
0.0069699851,
-0.0076809558,
0.0271313842,
0.0249423683,
0.0201724898,
0.0069942288,
0.0093742115,
0.0864818245,
0.0258449595,
-0.0290351007,
-0.0184421241,
-0.0096838279,
0.049744647,
0.1023531333,
-0.0646942705,
0.0753818378,
-0.0166934095,
-0.0094220797,
0.0240346231,
-0.0388672687,
0.0084231924,
0.0177894309,
0.0412285142,
-0.007203903,
-0.0304276384,
-0.0175944865,
-0.0379070155,
-0.1149746701,
-0.0170009211,
-0.0090668779,
0.0499889664,
0.0411928408,
-0.035213545,
0.0703430027,
-0.0093411133,
-0.0377009884,
-0.0358094461,
0.0307093542,
-0.0138672478,
0.0151075544,
0.0249525812,
-0.0450254977,
0.0157451667,
0.0010719006,
-0.0178902969,
0.00465335,
0.0291802399,
-0.0025426019,
-0.0253550988,
-0.111565806,
-0.003933934,
-0.006594745,
0.0161649827,
0.0556768104,
0.0100410935,
-0.0044274619,
-0.0012753614,
0.092239961,
0.040731214,
0.0264474656,
-0.0375175104,
0.0314774103,
-0.0355409645,
0.0674244687,
0.0620344877,
0.0854663402,
-0.0000979358,
-0.0614826977,
-0.0087427739,
-0.0394855216,
0.0051591266,
-0.0090016685,
-0.003621913,
-0.0481117554,
-0.0134555139,
-0.040610943,
-0.0907075778,
-0.0168956947,
0.0151151074,
-0.004966097,
0.005205377,
-0.0388297923,
-0.0078050401,
0.0062156189,
-0.0349947512,
0.0088974154,
-0.016007008,
-0.0069140927,
-0.0581578501,
0.0130410139,
0.0390317701,
-0.0175783839,
-0.0085078226,
-0.0166505836,
0.0623903349,
0.0113501744,
0.0053800978,
0.0349816233,
0.041905079,
-0.049464453,
-0.0001287458,
-0.0727907568,
0.0276313461,
0.0065369173,
0.0293707568,
0.0209248532,
0.0133014768,
-0.000056555,
0.006048202,
0.0877097026,
0.0035669408,
-0.0273076296,
0.0255194698,
0.0298279207,
0.0389930941,
-0.0330519453,
-0.0024751357,
0.0268116146,
0.0144565245,
0.0611089356,
-0.0643699691,
-0.0109177688,
-0.0358932056,
2.709e-7,
0.0322848745,
0.0552549101,
0.0294958092,
0.0359889343,
-0.0026596652,
0.0355319604,
-0.0390450954,
0.0579926893,
0.0176113602,
0.0687173605,
0.010428491,
0.0086562634,
0.0522722192,
0.0436978675,
-0.0814483091,
-0.00301567,
-0.0521916188,
0.0449416526,
-0.0147320535,
-0.0027871928,
0.0109815625,
0.0911865234,
0.0425556302,
-0.0187460668,
-0.0008163823,
-0.024215024,
0.0713528246,
0.0093513606,
0.0140923997,
-0.0132681737,
0.0211327355,
0.0250993464,
-0.0129178157,
-0.0044517806,
-0.0244001653,
0.0024336118,
0.0310786888,
0.0352021046,
-0.0109648248,
0.0179969594,
0.0143048745,
-0.0083105229,
-0.0167954993,
-0.0179604068,
0.0254039951,
-0.0223529637,
0.0083771637,
-0.0071891202,
-0.038106136,
0.0295508411,
0.0732878596,
-0.0255836733,
-0.0361331068,
0.0071562757,
0.0380356684,
0.0115057491,
-0.0158617534,
-0.0261286497,
-0.0342811309,
-0.0030612769,
-0.0087082088,
-0.0572558939,
-0.0011927625,
0.027444873,
0.0260370672,
-0.0423898324,
0.0068081231,
2.217003927e-34,
0.0367301553,
0.0055244877,
-0.0136954533,
-0.0009762792,
0.0065643005,
-0.0100412741,
0.0097111743,
-0.0020128447,
0.0311594252,
0.0405001901,
-0.044049751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.17076v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.17076v3 | Compositional Chain-of-Thought Prompting for Large Multimodal Models | 2023-11-27T22:23:27 | 2024-04-01T03:17:09 | Chancharik Mitra, Brandon Huang, Trevor Darrell, Roei Herzig | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The combination of strong visual backbones and Large Language Model (LLM)
reasoning has led to Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) becoming the current
standard for a wide range of vision and language (VL) tasks. However, recent
research has shown that even the most advanced LMMs still struggle to capture
aspects of compositional visual reasoning, such as attributes and relationships
between objects. One solution is to utilize scene graphs (SGs)--a formalization
of objects and their relations and attributes that has been extensively used as
a bridge between the visual and textual domains. Yet, scene graph data requires
scene graph annotations, which are expensive to collect and thus not easily
scalable. Moreover, finetuning an LMM based on SG data can lead to catastrophic
forgetting of the pretraining objective. To overcome this, inspired by
chain-of-thought methods, we propose Compositional Chain-of-Thought (CCoT), a
novel zero-shot Chain-of-Thought prompting method that utilizes SG
representations in order to extract compositional knowledge from an LMM.
Specifically, we first generate an SG using the LMM, and then use that SG in
the prompt to produce a response. Through extensive experiments, we find that
the proposed CCoT approach not only improves LMM performance on several vision
and language VL compositional benchmarks but also improves the performance of
several popular LMMs on general multimodal benchmarks, without the need for
fine-tuning or annotated ground-truth SGs. Code:
https://github.com/chancharikmitra/CCoT | [
0.0354144312,
0.042030625,
0.0091733607,
0.0699570253,
-0.0433041081,
0.0203271043,
0.0206333306,
-0.0155139854,
0.0134915598,
-0.0969647169,
-0.0261688475,
-0.0363215394,
0.0135011757,
0.0329453386,
0.0184883326,
-0.0434047654,
0.0166052524,
-0.0427201018,
-0.0051397346,
-0.002946425,
0.0168926585,
0.0252733026,
-0.0186240468,
0.0236666296,
-0.0395037755,
-0.0429688878,
-0.0407330766,
0.0185272172,
0.0307371523,
-0.0516196415,
-0.0374170542,
0.0240433421,
0.0271660555,
0.0249357373,
0.0000020713,
-0.0429572314,
0.0262990072,
0.0007956154,
0.0096536577,
-0.0371615998,
0.0114661604,
-0.0196409803,
0.0398677364,
-0.0197484102,
-0.0237783659,
-0.0086235106,
0.0608659722,
0.0351087339,
0.0550212152,
0.04800044,
-0.026212059,
-0.0317244157,
0.0069001028,
-0.0071924338,
0.0242313351,
-0.0061261132,
0.0033707758,
0.0177039728,
0.0133644175,
0.0156968124,
-0.0735195875,
0.041425772,
0.0328805782,
-0.0181062836,
0.0277081449,
0.0626003072,
-0.0062308623,
-0.0362896249,
-0.0077846795,
0.1119879857,
-0.0071293698,
0.0007941264,
-0.01202974,
-0.0036096338,
-0.0015105379,
-0.0104020834,
-0.0429651961,
0.0366548151,
-0.0392124243,
-0.0047043306,
-0.0626724511,
-0.0094607724,
0.0182073917,
-0.0025315238,
-0.0163435042,
0.0085655795,
0.0074830251,
0.0166483428,
0.0225426406,
0.0062829806,
-0.0228825808,
-0.0831037238,
-0.0262085199,
0.0564193577,
-0.0557796359,
-0.0151546272,
-0.0366646163,
-0.0157752205,
-0.02399447,
-0.0075593786,
0.0636972561,
0.0248690192,
-0.0609958619,
0.0736461729,
-0.033127334,
0.0408070497,
-0.0408824123,
0.038110286,
-0.0331466049,
-0.0296070091,
-0.0685890093,
-0.0100792982,
-0.0130351698,
0.0185165461,
-0.0162436515,
-0.056681592,
0.003638909,
0.0166620873,
-0.0235317741,
0.029030066,
-0.0103049884,
0.0225765351,
0.0183399487,
-0.027304763,
-0.0290992558,
0.0556354597,
-0.0250168014,
0.0120157273,
0.0126043074,
-0.0132224681,
0.0059683565,
0.0255086422,
0.0180978589,
-0.0389892906,
0.009647009,
0.0925849825,
-0.0445574112,
-0.0273647513,
-0.0074661598,
-0.0567287542,
-0.0118209142,
-0.0726316124,
0.0666518211,
-0.0635535121,
0.0454030558,
0.0025394061,
0.0109058358,
0.0070795147,
0.0243382826,
0.0150901191,
-0.0192248616,
0.0981314629,
-0.0133697614,
0.0048754243,
-0.0294756331,
0.0069761248,
-0.0474233553,
0.053233657,
0.0252877306,
0.0461205803,
0.0009029953,
0.0264409613,
0.0043914067,
0.0122411745,
-0.0006804857,
-0.0013832306,
-0.0363893658,
-0.0054042046,
-0.020440191,
0.0426733121,
0.0320832916,
0.0585840158,
-0.0252844486,
-0.0401705913,
0.0693944767,
0.0105203595,
0.0113505274,
-0.0367808267,
0.066711016,
-0.013490878,
-0.0010805677,
-0.0077562183,
-0.0781082436,
0.0983260721,
-0.0349015594,
-0.0028436554,
-0.0099764913,
0.0303944908,
-0.0233373288,
-0.0048487261,
-0.0101900455,
0.0004524081,
0.0010511139,
0.0258082673,
0.0391186401,
0.0274130013,
-0.0264215469,
-0.0098122768,
0.004464495,
-0.0080304192,
-0.0262795389,
-0.0073713143,
0.033420071,
0.0492997617,
0.0303942412,
0.0301716961,
-0.0272893738,
-0.0071021728,
0.0490653552,
0.0387865752,
-0.0157085042,
-0.0151899559,
0.036148116,
-0.0517393015,
-0.0370737985,
-0.0349005051,
-0.013370092,
0.024721738,
0.0097049549,
-0.0255987011,
0.013645119,
-0.0266398676,
0.040892832,
0.0240356158,
0.0662475824,
0.0168645587,
-0.0274526831,
0.0345561802,
0.0024193358,
0.0047061425,
0.0083665652,
0.0074663009,
-0.0164913759,
-0.0371565334,
-0.0330946371,
0.0230763294,
-0.0631510392,
-0.0691993386,
0.0305861887,
-0.0426865555,
-0.0241580103,
-0.0227989126,
-0.0429846384,
-0.0192552898,
-0.0016670176,
-0.0230180919,
-0.0076968693,
-0.0298904888,
-0.0267499685,
0.0433852077,
-0.0130619854,
0.0043964335,
0.0616109036,
-0.0271372236,
-0.0159078892,
0.0273768716,
0.0346946046,
0.0242201462,
-0.0089880964,
-0.0234456919,
0.0200839359,
0.009595599,
0.0098222932,
-0.0135807209,
0.0116803786,
-0.0468919277,
-0.002688047,
-0.0885778368,
-0.0313374288,
-0.0019167257,
-0.0396696366,
-0.029978564,
-0.0085269678,
0.0183256939,
-0.0339087285,
-0.0284068435,
0.0536655895,
-0.0052427435,
0.033071328,
0.0263743978,
0.0009219914,
0.0014229026,
0.0121251028,
-0.0023820223,
-0.0197963323,
0.0955478027,
0.0052075572,
-0.0387923904,
-0.0103080925,
-0.001179848,
-0.0577644855,
0.0328907855,
-0.0244540498,
-0.0078861993,
0.0504544899,
-0.0409348495,
0.0697548613,
0.0826704502,
-0.0180937871,
-0.0008675555,
0.0692274347,
-0.0284741055,
-0.0276376046,
0.0208591372,
0.0157053303,
-0.0192815028,
-0.0034203329,
0.0227789469,
-0.0358867198,
0.0373320207,
-0.0238957759,
-0.0073133418,
-0.0642818958,
0.0161539391,
0.0225884616,
-0.032422103,
-0.0705346242,
0.0018823582,
0.0065071522,
0.0343481302,
-0.0416597836,
-0.0183502268,
0.0542471111,
-0.0588289611,
-0.0100134779,
0.0411497578,
0.0236950796,
-0.0236520786,
0.114244394,
0.0317120701,
0.0277796648,
0.0079437718,
0.0197815541,
-0.0715922639,
-0.0015985827,
0.0217256956,
0.0178484563,
0.0015715464,
-0.0337515101,
0.0247021429,
-0.0309679303,
-0.0288974606,
-0.0180963483,
0.0282848384,
-0.0562544689,
0.0111137638,
-0.0724894106,
0.0016298735,
0.007934575,
0.0011584124,
0.0112906471,
0.0084118452,
-0.0153809544,
-0.0168853253,
-0.0161886755,
0.0455205441,
0.0481465943,
0.0147288609,
-0.0190508813,
-0.043774996,
0.0351413675,
0.0606373213,
-0.0024894089,
0.001795315,
-0.0604474358,
0.039532464,
-0.0036086356,
0.0542969219,
-0.0110016009,
0.0246846694,
0.0567948036,
-0.0592391044,
-0.0010244568,
0.066214785,
0.0067327181,
-0.0570637882,
-0.0073258583,
0.0036887464,
0.0193748996,
0.0627234578,
0.0127838422,
-0.1062424108,
-0.0593654811,
0.0098456545,
-0.0453329273,
0.0256123487,
-0.0431871079,
-0.0319311731,
-0.0999104902,
0.0396947116,
-0.0134264231,
-0.0394387618,
-0.0212150775,
0.0170934666,
0.0015315346,
0.0270774327,
-0.0431398302,
0.0049048569,
0.0119460858,
0.0003303326,
-0.0108001167,
0.0192986336,
-0.0163475964,
0.0426679067,
-0.0468492061,
0.0079339324,
0.0164199341,
0.0112647545,
0.0375951715,
-0.0333140381,
0.0486833639,
0.0383431986,
0.0209131818,
-0.0132928649,
0.0348879322,
-0.0491019711,
-0.0421200506,
-0.0060738949,
0.0292483792,
0.0084360167,
-0.0450042412,
-0.0294507444,
0.0722209141,
-0.0303621031,
-0.0029587445,
-0.0511061512,
0.0279870611,
0.0028263812,
0.0414136499,
0.039965447,
-0.026256226,
-0.0213199463,
-0.0108084818,
-0.0389513709,
-0.0421915278,
-0.0141818272,
0.0251951087,
0.0320298336,
0.0298376419,
-0.0558459125,
-0.0246573742,
0.0438545458,
0.0666351244,
-0.0248883348,
-0.0212693214,
-0.0158783291,
0.0287659895,
-0.0558434092,
0.0532153733,
-0.0381682701,
0.0404739194,
-0.0065485495,
0.0205971673,
0.014536351,
-0.0340902694,
-0.0141473264,
0.006464581,
-0.0778140277,
-0.0369474106,
-0.0564119443,
0.0722887143,
0.0135690486,
0.0456080586,
0.0175059661,
-0.0433841087,
0.0189642049,
0.048058223,
0.0105084041,
0.0216562171,
0.005079282,
0.0112795327,
0.0105090607,
0.0313051678,
-0.0527476445,
0.0101002166,
0.0156371258,
0.0556917638,
0.0227399115,
0.006790048,
0.0198484175,
0.0078454586,
0.0228964072,
-0.0206476338,
0.038001027,
-0.0305294134,
0.0011812756,
-0.0083883666,
-0.0375798382,
-0.0858244821,
0.0245098826,
0.0041195946,
0.0076286341,
0.0061633498,
-0.048806835,
0.0392650217,
0.0671696439,
-0.0014825978,
-0.0394955724,
0.0404130965,
-0.0408375375,
0.0338674076,
0.0272534639,
-0.0186665412,
0.0216132309,
-0.0242774151,
0.0117013194,
-0.0140237771,
0.1095128879,
0.050275635,
-0.0380367041,
-0.0665297732,
0.0261921305,
-0.0293928217,
-0.0257921461,
0.0014979801,
0.0449124873,
0.0482822135,
0.0225412771,
-0.0066996608,
-0.0383920968,
-0.0207967199,
0.0092244605,
0.0890889913,
0.0164529774,
-0.065985091,
0.0766292363,
0.0278469604,
0.0188122801,
-0.0188258402,
0.0537022203,
0.0118419137,
0.0212294143,
0.025534872,
0.0058599152,
-0.0327851959,
-0.0383372568,
0.0067599127,
0.019605048,
0.011782025,
0.0246166904,
-0.0446159579,
-0.0655976236,
-0.018964367,
0.0204286519,
-0.0110552721,
0.0202760901,
0.0433603376,
0.0460073724,
0.0428908467,
-0.0329436474,
0.0029192127,
-0.0316645205,
0.0059984778,
0.0082372762,
0.0084527973,
-6.053206323e-33,
-0.0445061438,
-0.0501363166,
0.0534756109,
-0.0012938755,
-0.0526341237,
0.0239479542,
-0.0379882678,
0.0046734205,
-0.0216839314,
0.0323954001,
0.0114619099,
-0.0090817371,
-0.0110850874,
0.0380788445,
0.0143160541,
-0.0153105306,
0.0196225569,
0.0006668675,
-0.0237016827,
-0.0050430805,
0.0482005998,
0.0107617639,
0.0278035719,
-0.0338041745,
-0.0101279533,
0.030962402,
-0.0229399614,
0.0488918871,
-0.030866418,
0.0516563915,
-0.0385300964,
0.0214188248,
0.0254325345,
0.011203507,
-0.0211560912,
0.0199415796,
-0.0668779463,
-0.0235772561,
0.0309555531,
0.01043713,
-0.0975491256,
-0.0032656963,
0.0188408718,
-0.0169546548,
0.0460013971,
-0.0828227997,
0.0271879621,
-0.0042151259,
-0.0033822265,
-0.038979657,
-0.0501304902,
-0.0117023913,
0.0098753087,
-0.0449329019,
0.0334824249,
0.0209396016,
0.0267455988,
0.0302225277,
-0.0187351704,
-0.0014193697,
-0.0471034944,
-0.0166441426,
0.0571147725,
0.0543030687,
-0.0025305897,
0.070830524,
0.0234809481,
-0.010717582,
-0.0661574006,
0.0371554755,
0.0198314469,
0.0655398965,
0.0303692147,
0.061950244,
0.0048157508,
0.0408927575,
-0.0396083221,
-0.0193812996,
-0.0518185459,
0.065300934,
0.0115664424,
0.0148495045,
0.0199697874,
-0.0180848427,
-0.0369792655,
-0.0140966475,
-0.0569214039,
-0.0017043162,
0.0531492755,
0.0035815316,
-0.0154916514,
-0.0005998603,
0.0752575025,
-0.0380625241,
-0.0035748347,
0.0265408102,
-0.0341814682,
0.0735861212,
-0.0043957816,
0.0161278136,
-0.0284644682,
0.003901165,
0.0710070133,
-0.0145641277,
0.0089705028,
0.0144204693,
0.0672914088,
0.0467920341,
-0.0217266791,
-0.0288282093,
-0.064310208,
-0.0079899505,
-0.038438309,
0.0134026781,
0.0312804691,
0.031118013,
-0.057223592,
0.0432226211,
-0.030174464,
-0.0062920465,
-0.0202840008,
-0.0133816497,
-0.0141844545,
0.0161042847,
-0.0201407038,
0.0093195708,
-0.045591794,
-0.0755432472,
0.0392651483,
-0.04914736,
-0.0024385848,
0.0400993787,
2.715e-7,
0.0169246085,
0.0249752868,
0.0073468261,
0.0293895379,
0.0136042545,
0.0487777814,
-0.0289626773,
0.0304564629,
-0.0032517528,
-0.0647784323,
0.0011001626,
0.0679483339,
0.0296047628,
0.0135604013,
-0.0379194804,
0.0292260535,
-0.0505140238,
-0.0593839362,
-0.075929381,
-0.0188256856,
0.0586492121,
0.0229057707,
0.0005747882,
-0.0203170888,
0.0380572453,
-0.023797391,
0.0971280262,
-0.0261998419,
-0.0034590384,
-0.0426883996,
0.0253662243,
-0.0165414121,
0.0019790942,
0.0199826118,
0.0308343451,
-0.0406072102,
0.0360833742,
0.0304634422,
-0.0074475058,
-0.0248313081,
-0.0201138016,
0.0075114379,
-0.0203483049,
-0.0482734106,
0.0892254934,
-0.0588496402,
-0.0188963786,
-0.0376682021,
-0.0328510404,
-0.0271999724,
-0.0008868813,
-0.0040336414,
-0.0253150463,
0.008867085,
0.0224514306,
-0.0141648399,
-0.017039353,
-0.0823440105,
-0.0343925655,
-0.0006986272,
-0.0199865568,
-0.0134656336,
-0.044056654,
0.0053494493,
0.0277409069,
-0.0644303784,
-0.0895486251,
2.240274583e-34,
0.0198916513,
-0.0261149332,
0.0256025176,
-0.0005781131,
0.032703802,
-0.0090068141,
-0.0292538907,
-0.0019821287,
-0.0007300543,
-0.0729545802,
-0.0335707553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16338v1 | Releasing the CRaQAn (Coreference Resolution in Question-Answering): An open-source dataset and dataset creation methodology using instruction-following models | 2023-11-27T21:54:50 | 2023-11-27T21:54:50 | Rob Grzywinski, Joshua D'Arcy, Rob Naidoff, Ashish Shukla, Alex Browne, Ren Gibbons, Brinnae Bent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Instruction-following language models demand robust methodologies for
information retrieval to augment instructions for question-answering
applications. A primary challenge is the resolution of coreferences in the
context of chunking strategies for long documents. The critical barrier to
experimentation of handling coreferences is a lack of open source datasets,
specifically in question-answering tasks that require coreference resolution.
In this work we present our Coreference Resolution in Question-Answering
(CRaQAn) dataset, an open-source dataset that caters to the nuanced information
retrieval requirements of coreference resolution in question-answering tasks by
providing over 250 question-answer pairs containing coreferences. To develop
this dataset, we developed a novel approach for creating high-quality datasets
using an instruction-following model (GPT-4) and a Recursive Criticism and
Improvement Loop. | [
0.0599058121,
0.0007465321,
0.0026725377,
-0.0060962997,
-0.0328900367,
0.01767735,
-0.0225041471,
-0.0113422656,
0.0273074545,
-0.0262123533,
-0.0347945467,
0.0374440402,
-0.043696899,
-0.0549424142,
0.0004426818,
-0.052806858,
0.0623449422,
-0.0118869878,
0.0069261054,
0.0063543827,
0.0407383554,
0.0270486549,
-0.0049855164,
0.0081998566,
0.0008898964,
-0.0592563041,
-0.0092910416,
0.0038008506,
0.0075783371,
-0.0065628439,
0.0402492732,
0.0437327921,
-0.0093490295,
0.0183790196,
0.0000016931,
-0.0387084521,
-0.0142011577,
0.0064200261,
-0.0365789682,
0.0043687727,
0.0274460725,
0.0337447822,
0.0381269194,
0.0192850046,
-0.0217985306,
-0.0138959903,
0.036654938,
0.0552960075,
0.1045680642,
0.0542334132,
0.0138613107,
-0.0176433232,
0.0071372469,
-0.000824212,
-0.0141878957,
-0.0425511599,
0.0050831432,
0.0238653868,
0.042166926,
0.0502620339,
-0.0013167455,
0.0171884671,
0.0491406731,
0.0001537014,
-0.0190699529,
0.0076735364,
-0.0888220221,
-0.0058600018,
0.0129465517,
0.0934874564,
0.0686151013,
-0.001631113,
0.0018380432,
0.0220164657,
0.0033835149,
0.0020427743,
-0.0778939873,
-0.0058112722,
-0.0443782248,
-0.0146873584,
0.0080716135,
-0.0249167271,
-0.0458873361,
0.0269839652,
-0.0094921682,
0.0647861063,
-0.0088119004,
-0.0367447026,
0.0531360768,
-0.0186500773,
-0.0708878189,
-0.0460470356,
0.0457894355,
0.0315389782,
-0.0265125502,
0.027170537,
-0.0513020791,
0.0368528888,
0.0410469472,
-0.0323088877,
0.01019774,
0.0104906876,
-0.0311395731,
0.0379029848,
-0.0197224561,
0.0579083413,
-0.0089640524,
0.0318904594,
-0.0432279147,
-0.0353914201,
-0.0852263868,
-0.0043296586,
-0.0742210671,
0.0635611117,
-0.0299643949,
0.0007192504,
-0.0253051668,
0.0349567644,
0.00656906,
-0.0006504388,
0.0369547643,
0.0021092023,
-0.0455725566,
0.0164594371,
-0.0450787134,
0.0421480685,
-0.0701575205,
0.0105073703,
-0.0208795816,
-0.0517633148,
-0.0203660727,
-0.0085945474,
0.0111039281,
-0.0599086732,
0.006826974,
0.0217256863,
0.0117910458,
-0.011214802,
-0.0000927999,
-0.059584152,
-0.0018524671,
-0.0282527618,
-0.0270883776,
-0.0768485889,
0.0216452554,
0.0126351565,
-0.0299112648,
-0.0406797975,
0.0167631414,
0.0787869692,
-0.0554924458,
0.0364300311,
-0.0387474261,
0.0057679182,
0.0316931829,
0.0179425832,
0.0506243855,
0.0613624826,
-0.0100639137,
-0.0003708258,
0.0765440241,
0.0018127683,
-0.0158096198,
-0.0008500479,
0.0450338125,
-0.0075544729,
0.0330540538,
0.0859351829,
-0.0584751666,
0.008889732,
-0.0062918598,
0.063752979,
-0.0127843432,
-0.0354280733,
0.0121470261,
0.0541544445,
-0.0134195508,
-0.0585965961,
-0.0146618849,
0.0293618329,
0.0189051535,
0.0501575582,
-0.0240994412,
0.0276586711,
0.0253090691,
0.0056291684,
0.0605443455,
-0.0016636461,
-0.0357794613,
-0.0476763509,
-0.0165875852,
0.0474514402,
-0.0482580215,
0.0298312418,
0.0177822914,
0.0364298336,
-0.0469437428,
0.0165273324,
0.0076616099,
-0.0550940409,
-0.0019034329,
-0.003656649,
0.0196871236,
0.0189109724,
0.0565594472,
-0.0497383885,
-0.0863311738,
0.0082502151,
0.1029617116,
-0.003069821,
0.0136990091,
-0.0467050001,
0.0090886876,
-0.0487388968,
0.0070394697,
0.0043981127,
-0.0319412947,
-0.0375538245,
0.0719418973,
-0.0144881848,
-0.0030419626,
-0.0380673818,
-0.045895718,
0.0349319056,
0.0243810397,
-0.0249755494,
0.0005015084,
-0.0008383375,
0.0065285736,
0.0367090441,
-0.0084315129,
0.0122080324,
0.0328632332,
0.0040827896,
0.0046667908,
-0.000871919,
-0.0192240011,
-0.0123177031,
0.012502511,
-0.064467907,
-0.0261860266,
-0.0165092424,
-0.0355924889,
-0.0489541441,
-0.0182017777,
-0.0423287898,
0.0188557897,
-0.0077329902,
-0.0330341496,
0.0379193462,
-0.0249293558,
-0.0589799248,
0.0441585258,
0.0062241526,
0.043058034,
0.0449893251,
0.0145694427,
0.0220118593,
-0.0543877333,
0.0048441775,
0.0086429249,
-0.0194661375,
-0.0135037517,
0.0463188551,
0.0322664082,
-0.0822977647,
-0.0148067754,
-0.0478074402,
0.0463246591,
-0.0163832344,
0.0368159972,
0.0482241623,
-0.0065658637,
-0.0087389788,
-0.0445124991,
-0.0167323519,
-0.0283285044,
0.0096074194,
0.0480252914,
0.0352565125,
0.0346949287,
0.0162454825,
-0.0561573878,
-0.0353834666,
-0.0137345865,
-0.0129041877,
-0.0043482236,
0.0339538306,
-0.0350660682,
0.0248999484,
-0.0148011809,
0.0228603855,
0.0220608208,
-0.0238371994,
0.017589042,
0.0075650867,
0.0342615694,
0.0643780529,
-0.0207549371,
0.0090756472,
0.0006808157,
-0.0633011907,
-0.0589690655,
0.0340339839,
-0.0107085966,
-0.053472355,
0.0036899294,
-0.0357501693,
0.0217390098,
0.0459939204,
0.0042442004,
-0.01752997,
-0.027838923,
0.0327656195,
-0.02504359,
-0.0058913701,
-0.0059304251,
-0.0115956087,
-0.0087335845,
0.032317888,
-0.0507819541,
-0.0178711861,
0.0685524493,
-0.0160499178,
-0.0030156982,
-0.0653858706,
0.0200392511,
-0.0509533323,
0.0642227829,
-0.0045192991,
-0.0099931974,
0.0496350601,
-0.0456958041,
-0.0376745537,
0.0093858466,
0.0199063923,
-0.0240851734,
0.0502282418,
-0.0453615822,
0.0020432665,
-0.0063494435,
-0.0057130582,
-0.0379638672,
0.0346230604,
-0.0103847235,
-0.0123508507,
-0.0065050106,
0.0132935252,
-0.0019974974,
0.0009566848,
0.0287343804,
0.035998553,
-0.0306750908,
-0.0012703767,
-0.0266626347,
0.0411962233,
0.0473688357,
0.0144744208,
0.0059961076,
-0.0152665311,
0.0155848302,
0.0534773543,
0.0501202904,
-0.0125851501,
0.0310272127,
-0.0244715922,
0.0351139419,
-0.084576562,
-0.0191380791,
0.0025003948,
0.0731618106,
-0.0612399802,
-0.0740870982,
0.0994626209,
0.0517367311,
-0.0195438042,
-0.0367581993,
-0.017612936,
0.0208986327,
0.0423973911,
0.0478239283,
-0.0544686206,
-0.0398999378,
-0.007514697,
0.0278993193,
0.0069584711,
-0.0328233391,
0.0046390314,
-0.0953353122,
0.0292480513,
-0.0401949324,
-0.0675931573,
-0.0466071591,
-0.044028569,
0.0313132741,
-0.0117435129,
0.0013988134,
0.0287188943,
-0.0513794906,
0.0482000746,
0.0242329091,
-0.0322292596,
0.0250513908,
0.0333341621,
-0.0401892997,
0.0009632762,
0.0613182001,
0.0310035776,
0.0222942177,
0.0176184382,
-0.002105983,
-0.0957895368,
-0.0305832066,
-0.0289984383,
0.0489432216,
-0.0053642578,
-0.009463029,
-0.0296262447,
0.0483947434,
-0.0199585818,
0.003021355,
0.0469718985,
0.0368044339,
-0.0005268053,
0.0478671007,
-0.0404552482,
0.0387139544,
-0.0148204528,
0.0676786005,
0.0399321355,
0.0087724384,
-0.0258703083,
-0.012949001,
0.0166860446,
-0.0972849354,
-0.0199369583,
0.0136909531,
-0.0403465927,
0.053419169,
-0.074406527,
-0.0542422198,
0.0707922876,
0.0265072901,
-0.0027859164,
-0.0001368427,
0.0129876155,
0.0291505214,
-0.0534459502,
0.0121048512,
-0.0287836529,
-0.0026617951,
-0.0936950967,
-0.0157759041,
0.0319548137,
0.0671877861,
-0.0222102627,
0.081590198,
-0.0406849943,
-0.0221334398,
-0.0043728189,
0.0315760002,
0.0140325725,
0.0050026961,
-0.0192362759,
-0.0331722088,
-0.038212046,
0.0098759402,
-0.0567185171,
-0.0226081591,
0.0250593927,
-0.0053045251,
-0.0105800312,
0.0488660745,
-0.0327027589,
0.0269191209,
-0.0162316896,
0.0435227528,
-0.0394855142,
-0.0536487848,
0.0455118455,
0.0159419477,
-0.0204332452,
0.043180801,
0.0381019339,
-0.0305416938,
0.0526640937,
-0.0218271073,
-0.0275694896,
-0.0115284119,
0.0365365818,
-0.019182492,
-0.0546712615,
0.0099263564,
0.0342615694,
-0.0274292026,
0.0713781342,
-0.0346103683,
0.0256215371,
0.0529702492,
0.0148357144,
-0.0279736165,
-0.0197640005,
-0.0122134779,
-0.0388124064,
0.0107788034,
0.0763204619,
-0.0225703958,
0.0699283034,
0.0232478082,
0.0098807579,
0.03430501,
0.000034835,
-0.0420947894,
-0.0170579534,
-0.0185459778,
-0.0277701616,
0.0042542196,
-0.0051667108,
0.0342924409,
0.0168579873,
-0.0402753279,
-0.0147199165,
0.0004191773,
-0.0188872293,
-0.0020590154,
0.0388021581,
0.0601993725,
0.0041800044,
-0.0078611961,
0.0665316507,
-0.0041056932,
0.0212257933,
0.0253054351,
-0.025151141,
-0.0125808595,
-0.0527112894,
-0.0147910714,
0.0094134295,
0.0148934117,
0.0071809711,
-0.0262443572,
-0.0403870642,
0.0140154837,
0.0194985271,
0.0036884276,
0.005903983,
0.0501927398,
0.0382787585,
0.0418035649,
-0.0653046519,
-0.0369065031,
0.0206048042,
-0.0456270352,
-0.0535959303,
-0.0264791194,
-5.594449449e-33,
-0.0850083753,
-0.0138105918,
0.0171518978,
0.0112434532,
-0.0036294358,
0.0113522783,
-0.0279896222,
-0.0260348413,
-0.0217812136,
0.0060408735,
-0.0282764863,
0.0197777543,
0.0191419777,
0.0335566849,
-0.0007520801,
-0.0204732716,
0.0318637677,
0.0009012322,
-0.0218234006,
0.0385057703,
0.0494896844,
0.0092126848,
0.0762933344,
-0.0329085737,
0.032390561,
0.0124828266,
0.0196619872,
0.030106429,
0.020277597,
0.0888950452,
0.0081066079,
0.0408482887,
0.0156603605,
-0.0492787659,
-0.0040421244,
0.0148889627,
-0.1204366162,
-0.0510961227,
0.0540892817,
0.0139302816,
-0.0472907573,
-0.0347630493,
0.017185403,
-0.031859003,
0.0414670631,
-0.0186443049,
0.0421409495,
-0.008885215,
-0.0090338057,
0.0207586903,
-0.0278683677,
0.0260109138,
-0.0043318393,
-0.0308531262,
-0.0195298344,
0.0672135502,
0.010768434,
-0.0148166828,
-0.03083314,
0.0093129082,
0.0205559898,
0.0719482899,
0.0079727424,
-0.0061403471,
0.0164891109,
0.0105867162,
-0.0081449514,
-0.0221006051,
-0.0139212795,
0.0260414965,
-0.0020339328,
0.0321401395,
0.0080166049,
0.0736169145,
0.0256002489,
0.0309531502,
-0.0368255191,
0.0132757584,
0.0129672941,
0.0662782341,
-0.0169812627,
-0.0265810918,
-0.0413300022,
-0.0053289137,
-0.0429992601,
0.009159687,
-0.0297212265,
-0.0267391,
0.0490011685,
-0.0240707025,
-0.0270956922,
0.0320899263,
0.0138411801,
-0.0151638277,
-0.0121021103,
0.0188379902,
-0.003162069,
0.0310887527,
0.0042768228,
0.0424639769,
-0.0637114719,
0.021590177,
0.0241912808,
-0.0324299037,
0.0311149284,
0.0057256194,
0.0456642322,
-0.0042689177,
-0.0710800439,
0.002501216,
-0.0245241728,
0.0448932834,
-0.0679940283,
-0.0246035066,
0.0089732399,
0.0473041646,
0.0041983663,
0.0502574854,
0.021026073,
-0.0145916594,
-0.082584776,
-0.0542809106,
0.022501599,
-0.002105247,
0.0112207681,
0.0148795303,
-0.0193451792,
-0.0011838286,
-0.0470710881,
-0.0483210422,
-0.0070314212,
0.0457049496,
2.347e-7,
0.0359264389,
0.0367813744,
0.0866361186,
0.028150972,
-0.027364403,
-0.0362185799,
0.010967602,
0.0195419844,
0.0190060567,
-0.0543781258,
-0.008400714,
0.028379079,
-0.0094419308,
0.0473183021,
-0.0939600095,
-0.0126821464,
-0.0521928519,
-0.0054390305,
-0.0511282198,
-0.0213382859,
0.0413521752,
0.0640133619,
0.0039538317,
0.015830081,
-0.056810379,
0.0115879038,
0.0036927781,
0.0131038073,
0.013108125,
0.0532359667,
0.0052065519,
0.0439037159,
0.0053837253,
0.0069086798,
0.0044773142,
-0.0132665383,
0.0471914522,
0.0437701792,
0.0350447856,
-0.068744272,
-0.0392097197,
-0.0502368137,
0.0105784982,
-0.0141391503,
0.0681365058,
-0.0536622219,
-0.0050561382,
-0.004262927,
-0.0360158794,
-0.0080514625,
-0.0388711169,
0.0056175874,
0.0077276565,
0.0312209278,
0.0082422551,
-0.0035289545,
0.0049154363,
-0.0557514355,
-0.0014777507,
0.027037004,
0.0055859368,
0.0006657034,
-0.028243497,
-0.027797617,
-0.0684517473,
-0.0298259631,
-0.020945074,
1.878541106e-34,
-0.0000169944,
-0.0028396118,
0.0278390776,
0.0132343918,
0.0229068436,
-0.0343904532,
-0.0458260924,
-0.0111351013,
0.0101301949,
-0.0540392287,
-0.0299085602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03730v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03730v2 | FakeWatch ElectionShield: A Benchmarking Framework to Detect Fake News for Credible US Elections | 2023-11-27T21:01:21 | 2023-12-08T19:42:35 | Tahniat Khan, Mizanur Rahman, Veronica Chatrath, Oluwanifemi Bamgbose, Shaina Raza | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In today's technologically driven world, the spread of fake news,
particularly during crucial events such as elections, presents an increasing
challenge to the integrity of information. To address this challenge, we
introduce FakeWatch ElectionShield, an innovative framework carefully designed
to detect fake news. We have created a novel dataset of North American
election-related news articles through a blend of advanced language models
(LMs) and thorough human verification, for precision and relevance. We propose
a model hub of LMs for identifying fake news. Our goal is to provide the
research community with adaptable and accurate classification models in
recognizing the dynamic nature of misinformation. Extensive evaluation of fake
news classifiers on our dataset and a benchmark dataset shows our that while
state-of-the-art LMs slightly outperform the traditional ML models, classical
models are still competitive with their balance of accuracy, explainability,
and computational efficiency. This research sets the foundation for future
studies to address misinformation related to elections. | [
0.0565522201,
0.0715920031,
-0.0074056429,
0.0575681664,
-0.0380010456,
0.0254503731,
-0.0158827398,
-0.0009413327,
0.0241136532,
-0.0507288016,
0.0217088778,
-0.0430810675,
0.0097768251,
0.0620427951,
-0.0021258316,
-0.0506068468,
0.0603499897,
0.0264671873,
0.0718696639,
-0.0278708655,
0.0376703739,
0.0304687209,
-0.0116251372,
0.0267014802,
-0.0239750873,
0.0322584771,
0.0254597571,
0.0129126878,
0.0231650379,
-0.006801608,
-0.0002072453,
0.0323963016,
0.0112980641,
0.0855921358,
0.0000017877,
-0.0004979355,
-0.0063870265,
0.0084035182,
-0.0377821624,
0.0075982832,
0.0874424353,
-0.066412136,
-0.0082478933,
0.0265564788,
-0.0343745202,
-0.031191783,
0.0265195146,
0.0253402237,
0.0954339504,
0.1126286313,
-0.007493177,
0.0096801156,
-0.0017460524,
-0.0098753544,
-0.0188698266,
-0.0431709066,
0.0636958182,
-0.0115763852,
-0.0304916427,
0.0469496101,
0.0441585369,
-0.0009730352,
0.0300989226,
0.0035630227,
-0.0583071522,
-0.0117526613,
-0.0372287333,
-0.0061700577,
0.006175837,
0.0064784703,
-0.0556861125,
-0.0924553052,
0.0365611762,
-0.0187706631,
0.002446929,
0.066135034,
0.0136683537,
0.0195828322,
-0.017826993,
0.0326015241,
0.0454044789,
-0.0215131938,
0.0401429571,
0.0853559077,
0.0400971025,
0.0508407503,
-0.0152534898,
0.0061945119,
-0.0382659659,
-0.0056673829,
0.0212922972,
-0.0422368273,
0.0178857837,
0.0012920274,
-0.0113762254,
0.0161397513,
-0.0702934712,
0.0018775263,
0.0409756042,
-0.1200182736,
-0.0336527377,
-0.0014266716,
0.0254463274,
0.0515962914,
0.0078943353,
0.0017721799,
0.0026079095,
0.0296338182,
-0.0044624172,
-0.0257144067,
-0.0055775857,
0.0332862139,
0.0167744048,
-0.0166117549,
-0.0332841501,
0.0219162144,
-0.0429724418,
0.0033631094,
-0.0129039567,
0.0529273748,
-0.0220381562,
0.0118553694,
0.0018995277,
-0.0475622639,
-0.0329376422,
0.0198534988,
0.0015510014,
0.042484276,
-0.0227425061,
-0.0599624738,
-0.0055307513,
0.0418665595,
-0.0274101254,
0.0061582308,
-0.0129167056,
-0.0156414006,
-0.0031890026,
0.0084633911,
-0.0132271051,
0.005087615,
-0.0116156572,
-0.044385314,
0.006208268,
-0.0692191422,
-0.0016679103,
-0.0363652967,
0.0207920559,
-0.0271420497,
0.0030990292,
0.0316713564,
-0.0224248432,
0.0469664373,
-0.0104934154,
0.0185400974,
0.0660419762,
0.0281318817,
0.0292710867,
0.0937092304,
0.0041631404,
0.0955963656,
0.056537468,
-0.0224481411,
0.0223508719,
0.0173515864,
0.0304272026,
0.0464767143,
-0.0021126478,
0.00420454,
-0.0392536707,
-0.0267456323,
-0.0091610132,
0.0042616641,
0.020694932,
-0.0457229912,
0.0901246965,
-0.0149333617,
-0.0192896724,
-0.0322023369,
0.0538840182,
0.0248028394,
0.0031127795,
-0.0282094721,
-0.0359357893,
-0.0295599755,
-0.0695503727,
-0.019019749,
-0.0211729575,
0.0554076023,
-0.0165193733,
-0.018098589,
-0.0210526697,
-0.0046288096,
-0.0080737546,
0.0145742884,
0.0024841821,
-0.0164880604,
-0.0187316015,
0.0132864602,
0.0247075502,
-0.0006414847,
0.0151816439,
-0.0695118383,
0.0146662919,
0.0154247824,
0.0278860945,
0.0086823059,
0.0179450698,
-0.0455973521,
0.0342918001,
0.0451408625,
0.0564532839,
-0.0320807584,
-0.0500021465,
0.0051319124,
-0.0056541958,
0.0161851961,
0.0439996235,
-0.000069291,
0.0469862446,
0.037793085,
-0.0085295066,
-0.0263106916,
-0.0696433485,
0.0291348472,
-0.0013939209,
-0.0105528412,
-0.0082820281,
0.0149897607,
0.0204013977,
0.0076285102,
0.0094433771,
-0.035714712,
0.0701804906,
0.0281093847,
-0.0197942276,
-0.0519264936,
0.0205652807,
0.0044035465,
0.0091514988,
-0.0073369886,
-0.0287416652,
0.0501541235,
-0.0383097753,
0.0098754531,
0.028261628,
-0.0293412525,
-0.024117209,
-0.058628276,
-0.011259241,
-0.0468359254,
0.0137290554,
0.0194010511,
0.0849877596,
-0.0579279177,
0.0018543367,
-0.0038557104,
-0.0050994968,
-0.0199533608,
0.0061018304,
-0.0066284738,
0.0184174627,
-0.0014442019,
0.0242415369,
0.0034920946,
-0.0373316891,
-0.0048390813,
-0.0410869531,
-0.0237533022,
-0.0269617625,
-0.0500849225,
0.0184582174,
0.0456026271,
-0.0226593483,
-0.0122760246,
0.0142171727,
-0.0185356736,
-0.054548692,
0.0135983331,
-0.0104362601,
-0.0120202424,
-0.033792153,
-0.0007235976,
0.0150882956,
0.0218881331,
-0.0018918387,
0.0468786992,
-0.0028598255,
-0.0415428393,
-0.0329152308,
-0.0317477062,
-0.0281549431,
-0.0038664087,
-0.046536915,
-0.0213933978,
-0.0109890159,
0.0254010316,
-0.0291105099,
0.0293054841,
0.0539699532,
0.0893196762,
0.0193291027,
0.057840202,
-0.0236986261,
-0.0432521664,
-0.0526558086,
0.0584703386,
-0.0376781933,
-0.0600764379,
0.0161015671,
0.0575186871,
0.0165935997,
0.0159632489,
0.0123579353,
0.0668310747,
0.0038534068,
-0.0137401521,
0.0114448797,
-0.0319822431,
-0.0133476881,
-0.0167078711,
-0.0290832482,
-0.0427325368,
0.0897767767,
-0.0421862788,
0.0596104488,
-0.0202212147,
-0.0482933633,
0.0071035023,
-0.0183638781,
-0.0135577368,
0.0075159203,
-0.0033082543,
0.0173971634,
0.0293831229,
-0.0311250817,
0.0696712509,
-0.0602935217,
0.034054596,
-0.0553558096,
0.0264069252,
0.0283421781,
-0.0013755389,
-0.0763400793,
-0.0988343209,
-0.0289449655,
-0.0012262342,
-0.0263622757,
-0.0316690281,
-0.1027225927,
-0.0059551643,
0.0134383393,
0.0373263955,
-0.0194182135,
0.0265449788,
0.0104843965,
0.0516677834,
0.0103997802,
0.0052347113,
0.0350320786,
-0.0264475606,
-0.0279073045,
0.0464466773,
0.0154220564,
0.036721848,
-0.0097261351,
-0.0414590836,
0.0224100351,
-0.0210999008,
0.0098848958,
-0.0224556141,
-0.0084756073,
-0.0500843637,
0.0193287898,
0.0939791799,
0.0060476838,
-0.0143752573,
-0.0088491347,
0.0382475965,
-0.0107220421,
0.0224694144,
-0.0065350612,
-0.0571663603,
0.0059270253,
0.017370617,
0.0142371599,
-0.0382052027,
-0.0015304239,
-0.0153094297,
-0.0680373982,
0.0180690829,
0.0003432845,
-0.0225992855,
-0.0381433927,
-0.0821760744,
-0.0100986529,
-0.0226077661,
-0.0042891116,
-0.0111532919,
0.0434955657,
-0.0336084664,
-0.0090224212,
-0.0432472788,
-0.1055591255,
-0.0071568047,
0.0083224773,
0.0666341037,
0.030572135,
0.044129312,
-0.0159261674,
-0.0536390133,
0.0125706941,
-0.0301993266,
-0.0504599549,
-0.0201887637,
0.0435566679,
-0.0578146391,
-0.0186131373,
-0.01791168,
0.0519291237,
0.0311374255,
0.0029088864,
-0.0066924635,
0.0445770286,
0.0059984652,
-0.0707683638,
-0.0100276945,
0.0088894283,
0.0512771383,
0.0428041369,
0.0184223279,
-0.0130800949,
0.019339554,
-0.0315531977,
0.0037167154,
0.0081462506,
-0.0446867943,
0.0416140333,
-0.0140468366,
-0.0479991324,
-0.0360258892,
-0.0158449225,
-0.0217545219,
0.0118644554,
-0.0106430473,
0.0065902551,
0.0389761291,
-0.0322993062,
-0.045456659,
0.0362836607,
-0.0327722952,
0.0529166795,
-0.0001567608,
-0.0277814809,
-0.0367462225,
-0.0042711655,
-0.0204654001,
0.0357721262,
-0.0695100501,
-0.0231478848,
0.0216000285,
-0.0011569518,
0.0225777421,
0.0179877412,
-0.0493531637,
-0.064929232,
0.0350065231,
0.0316199996,
-0.0137927113,
-0.0172086544,
-0.0102646183,
-0.0239826329,
0.0469937995,
0.0123145822,
0.0145304399,
0.0425970592,
0.0424264856,
-0.0603952073,
-0.0819517225,
0.0053863497,
0.0130935814,
0.0105312252,
0.0418690965,
0.0018892383,
-0.0014189536,
-0.0214158874,
-0.0526259951,
-0.0243647862,
-0.047869537,
0.0004521596,
0.0386213362,
0.0336464457,
-0.0086025558,
-0.0154611235,
0.0176247954,
-0.0418036841,
0.0085740164,
-0.0420867093,
0.0005404101,
-0.0329578817,
0.0858282223,
0.0038467727,
-0.0008031694,
-0.0357686467,
0.0297123529,
-0.0035905314,
0.0334417671,
-0.013562453,
-0.0133420937,
0.0233552475,
-0.0303894039,
0.0420718677,
-0.0381899029,
-0.030949166,
0.0179476272,
-0.0618746914,
0.0645635575,
0.0131208207,
-0.0157388728,
0.0300346836,
0.0060489625,
-0.0159954,
-0.0109084863,
-0.015654033,
0.0306110922,
-0.0396891199,
-0.005965583,
0.0421368033,
-0.0508757941,
0.0588052645,
0.0653444156,
0.0176643673,
0.0183271412,
0.0391172282,
-0.0463091061,
-0.0354194045,
0.0001648773,
-0.0068277195,
0.0350163057,
-0.0269922409,
-0.0310005955,
-0.0681701973,
-0.0318328328,
0.0223734211,
0.0155129973,
0.0303380489,
0.0325184092,
-0.0455790274,
0.0705907196,
-0.0037132315,
0.0430105552,
-0.0558730736,
0.0048002959,
-0.0055730958,
-0.041111134,
0.0206476953,
-5.859674035e-33,
0.0082109952,
-0.0751129016,
-0.0352515839,
-0.0479086339,
0.0136300568,
0.0648514926,
0.0051630083,
-0.0195010044,
-0.0351519845,
0.0364490375,
0.0486668907,
0.0502517335,
0.0045354529,
0.0222498868,
-0.0709015876,
0.0047089998,
0.0175762009,
-0.0066984547,
-0.0364983007,
0.0213113595,
0.0452023707,
-0.0264734756,
0.0194379184,
-0.0433286652,
0.0511760861,
-0.0088088838,
-0.0697853938,
0.0139019005,
-0.0354187153,
0.0295184534,
-0.0168381259,
0.0413815416,
0.0435911454,
-0.0316561721,
0.0005744438,
0.024990553,
-0.0098269694,
0.0082960548,
0.0194622464,
0.0094992397,
0.0072655459,
0.0241388045,
0.045520518,
0.0069048912,
-0.0353740864,
0.0331228971,
0.0239012055,
-0.0570379682,
-0.0208836496,
0.0151492134,
-0.0061010025,
0.0324872546,
0.0047024675,
0.0189699382,
-0.0164877195,
0.0513205007,
0.027123861,
0.0278548934,
-0.1013812125,
0.0294357743,
-0.0267879739,
0.0076021445,
0.0242733937,
-0.0456573218,
-0.0266532619,
0.0548501275,
0.0371945426,
0.0327585228,
-0.0722178295,
0.0217713229,
0.022763161,
0.0162237044,
0.083140336,
0.097640723,
0.0233146138,
-0.0862453431,
-0.0734347999,
0.0305689089,
0.035877075,
-0.0254503898,
0.0242146943,
-0.0496621542,
-0.0360716693,
-0.0007738359,
-0.0242334418,
-0.0231008139,
-0.0272225291,
0.0075311298,
-0.0197587069,
0.0451677553,
-0.0298202839,
0.0508138053,
-0.0032481179,
-0.0664551556,
0.0194400456,
0.0276384,
-0.0164488237,
-0.001735399,
0.0147676934,
0.0522037037,
-0.0249586999,
-0.0088918777,
0.0143852793,
-0.001129779,
-0.01148469,
-0.0417075194,
0.0368839577,
0.0101779718,
-0.0520867035,
0.0286812037,
-0.0218384732,
0.0430443361,
-0.0022622452,
0.0002126674,
0.0401541032,
-0.024742445,
0.0052860538,
0.0176228583,
-0.0347816609,
-0.007155871,
0.0202378873,
0.0184792224,
-0.0549554974,
0.0450019762,
-0.0071809129,
-0.0048003779,
-0.0489047393,
0.0200971384,
0.0075806631,
-0.0519932471,
0.0228002835,
-0.028382767,
2.591e-7,
-0.0004106147,
0.0658956692,
-0.0268688258,
0.0017223668,
0.0173072889,
0.0567982942,
0.0147117684,
0.0094014257,
-0.0394767188,
-0.0819221064,
-0.0410200395,
0.0170465689,
0.0420826674,
0.0267516002,
-0.0552291907,
-0.0010381337,
-0.082754232,
0.0071595465,
-0.0427615047,
0.0066640158,
-0.0109279249,
0.0542840697,
0.0582628436,
-0.0457590669,
0.001993313,
-0.0133819235,
0.0403444283,
0.0175176729,
-0.0637483969,
0.0144880842,
0.0655210093,
-0.0305605475,
0.0188227892,
0.0317425169,
-0.0404118747,
0.0157033689,
-0.0182679705,
0.0433244742,
0.0015832687,
0.0196976718,
-0.0217920206,
-0.0587286428,
0.0119560864,
-0.0711429715,
0.0776060522,
-0.0197431408,
-0.0284738112,
-0.0800322667,
-0.0520820506,
-0.0006351656,
0.0351107903,
0.0070360298,
-0.0101932539,
0.0256630201,
-0.0098836655,
-0.0063442942,
-0.0029939814,
-0.0150887547,
0.0134960636,
0.0009191869,
-0.0592031106,
-0.0042088605,
0.000102145,
-0.0280882865,
0.0692345649,
-0.0218313634,
0.0346098058,
2.005110739e-34,
0.0430894606,
0.0017681735,
-0.0201943833,
-0.0079251565,
0.0437188484,
0.0245919619,
-0.0216738824,
-0.026459232,
0.0049611167,
-0.011753317,
0.0098192813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16302v1 | Comprehensive Benchmarking of Entropy and Margin Based Scoring Metrics for Data Selection | 2023-11-27T20:33:54 | 2023-11-27T20:33:54 | Anusha Sabbineni, Nikhil Anand, Maria Minakova | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | While data selection methods have been studied extensively in active
learning, data pruning, and data augmentation settings, there is little
evidence for the efficacy of these methods in industry scale settings,
particularly in low-resource languages. Our work presents ways of assessing
prospective training examples in those settings for their "usefulness" or
"difficulty". We also demonstrate how these measures can be used in selecting
important examples for training supervised machine learning models. We
primarily experiment with entropy and Error L2-Norm (EL2N) scores. We use these
metrics to curate high quality datasets from a large pool of \textit{Weak
Signal Labeled} data, which assigns no-defect high confidence hypotheses during
inference as ground truth labels. We then conduct training data augmentation
experiments using these de-identified datasets and demonstrate that score-based
selection can result in a 2% decrease in semantic error rate and 4%-7% decrease
in domain classification error rate when compared to the baseline technique of
random selection. | [
-0.0141874105,
0.0703883842,
-0.0106302854,
0.0051890644,
-0.0368546806,
0.0353426784,
0.0217412468,
0.034747526,
-0.0041452753,
-0.046606347,
-0.006133622,
-0.0121403784,
0.0122983027,
-0.0143737933,
0.0337966233,
-0.0499648564,
0.0402071327,
-0.0127366744,
-0.0107764918,
-0.0118243033,
-0.03445502,
-0.0119815338,
0.0117309503,
0.0310457721,
-0.009862842,
0.0189885106,
0.0211862754,
0.0120809814,
-0.0033459943,
-0.0363119654,
0.001843657,
0.0466366149,
0.0127288084,
0.0259274598,
0.0000020593,
-0.0696368739,
-0.0247072522,
0.0152939213,
-0.027044842,
-0.0147694601,
-0.0006066675,
-0.020025922,
-0.0022259222,
-0.0088915555,
-0.021845039,
-0.0538972281,
0.0717458129,
0.0366459563,
0.0301080495,
0.0327335857,
-0.0071529546,
-0.0257664379,
0.0013216388,
-0.0381560512,
0.0205012467,
-0.0075204172,
0.0467363559,
-0.0048888284,
-0.0269803535,
-0.048568476,
0.0042785839,
0.0004261174,
0.023133263,
0.0035273854,
0.0441795215,
0.0532635674,
-0.0371910818,
-0.0135902036,
0.0292572528,
0.0429677851,
-0.0378512107,
-0.0378689133,
-0.0071229413,
-0.0470169224,
0.0057955189,
-0.0276693441,
-0.0303372759,
-0.0188831426,
0.0125498641,
0.046084132,
0.0003861366,
0.0149468295,
0.0610403195,
0.0110424664,
-0.0027307833,
0.0279954653,
-0.0048262198,
-0.0644151568,
0.0671570674,
0.0219787601,
-0.0726493075,
0.0067768288,
-0.0567322448,
-0.0089467773,
-0.0184164476,
0.0314887427,
-0.0322276168,
-0.0392329432,
0.0249462705,
-0.0181458462,
-0.0201864596,
-0.0196849592,
0.0043024495,
0.0325454958,
-0.0177052636,
-0.0181335043,
0.0784059092,
0.0652587712,
-0.022601543,
-0.017167341,
-0.0281311385,
0.0124993408,
0.002944015,
0.0412740298,
0.0332779326,
0.0194786135,
-0.0606820695,
0.0007392706,
-0.0433818772,
0.0154360626,
0.0299712792,
-0.0134292338,
-0.0160929859,
0.0646136329,
-0.0200312249,
-0.0384841599,
-0.0066105658,
0.0295994561,
0.0090337424,
-0.0858806148,
0.0119558889,
0.0222058035,
-0.0200229194,
-0.0273110755,
0.0418824404,
0.0920498967,
0.0121836113,
-0.0472999103,
-0.0561814606,
0.0155661041,
-0.016661888,
-0.0363014005,
0.0232607201,
-0.0492830649,
-0.0257270876,
-0.0056684124,
0.0162639432,
-0.0680720732,
-0.0022497931,
-0.0103408629,
-0.0063502616,
0.0438384265,
-0.0504387729,
-0.0169533398,
0.0064324224,
-0.0137392767,
-0.0054865344,
0.1101566106,
0.0347419977,
0.0144733954,
0.0616925135,
-0.0306408387,
0.0004614071,
0.0122660259,
0.0169512145,
0.0238357391,
-0.0131682949,
-0.0078830486,
0.016143376,
-0.0146483444,
0.0041239257,
0.0037877872,
-0.0192913003,
-0.0146107031,
0.0478263646,
0.0199357662,
0.0381147526,
-0.0197317079,
0.0066178581,
-0.0058895624,
-0.0088993879,
-0.0212489776,
-0.0314879194,
0.0082372651,
0.006803832,
-0.0061654947,
0.0160744339,
-0.0113118794,
-0.0379024073,
-0.0991190597,
-0.0169593394,
-0.0083932998,
-0.0131571908,
0.0427839495,
0.1023437157,
0.0116302734,
0.0034976872,
0.0389328338,
0.0581407659,
-0.020274438,
-0.0099988375,
-0.036829453,
0.0024596162,
-0.0009849273,
0.0448191687,
-0.0813697353,
0.0251672734,
-0.0294101071,
0.0048566596,
-0.0416495986,
0.0732928067,
-0.0004375865,
0.0294536427,
-0.0523120649,
-0.0460518785,
0.0142795518,
0.0338399261,
-0.003758963,
-0.0325324051,
-0.0132909575,
-0.0077929809,
-0.080971621,
-0.0828656405,
0.0587816648,
0.0377107598,
-0.0282269549,
0.0568327978,
0.0240058843,
0.0564679056,
-0.0112273786,
-0.0393647291,
-0.0223154277,
0.0586382933,
-0.0188795645,
-0.0159587935,
-0.0030260978,
-0.0104681244,
-0.0147892442,
-0.0139358602,
-0.047096476,
-0.0258889794,
0.0419091173,
-0.0621723011,
-0.032227356,
-0.0111880749,
-0.0480626151,
-0.0235279594,
-0.0540946722,
0.0050301948,
-0.0518807881,
0.0232575014,
-0.051459901,
0.0721200928,
0.0035924995,
0.0506030656,
-0.0190982446,
-0.0345018841,
0.0303042419,
-0.0367743522,
-0.0267460365,
0.0153312674,
-0.0415785722,
0.0267343633,
0.0329034515,
0.0073524439,
-0.0017866876,
0.0301650278,
-0.032782577,
-0.0111920694,
-0.040934369,
0.003678418,
-0.0202837586,
0.0102848494,
-0.0091237361,
-0.0298904553,
-0.0163503401,
-0.004622425,
-0.0046568667,
0.004261212,
0.0335258134,
0.0183018465,
0.0052999477,
-0.0036982815,
-0.039933566,
0.0148671092,
0.0872889757,
0.0214504786,
0.0071257316,
-0.0282133799,
0.0978363454,
-0.0060697892,
0.0084352251,
-0.0126737673,
-0.0104054986,
-0.0079486351,
-0.0000748079,
-0.063465476,
0.0371269807,
-0.0244094022,
0.0335905515,
0.0705155954,
0.0465856791,
-0.0381762832,
-0.0150459781,
-0.0353661701,
0.023990795,
-0.0105550485,
-0.0419141799,
0.0474076979,
0.0136888595,
-0.0061479039,
-0.0013554882,
-0.0344385244,
-0.0008810412,
-0.014447351,
-0.045134671,
-0.0407386385,
0.0333995298,
-0.0056802356,
0.0502340682,
-0.0055225939,
-0.0676908344,
0.0854790062,
-0.0059183813,
-0.0122316265,
-0.068021439,
-0.0315552987,
-0.0111318724,
0.0185267031,
0.0359116048,
-0.0021090563,
0.0282420833,
-0.0052203606,
-0.0241483729,
-0.0061323177,
0.0429393724,
-0.0071614855,
0.0250478275,
-0.0329781845,
-0.0004175079,
-0.0029467563,
-0.0453773066,
-0.0350313671,
-0.0076972237,
0.0069516208,
0.0102511086,
0.0040765493,
0.0172348991,
-0.0085229417,
0.0027672767,
-0.0153853046,
0.035023056,
0.016005788,
-0.0186725482,
-0.0102330409,
-0.0069057331,
0.0478429049,
0.001867522,
0.0388044342,
-0.0402080044,
0.0147830984,
0.0093209241,
0.0503146388,
0.0019102228,
-0.0378329232,
0.0118158227,
0.0278645754,
-0.0224449411,
-0.0237932187,
0.0207898449,
0.0327596255,
-0.0293668192,
0.0090580638,
0.0901652575,
0.0011061154,
-0.0368159749,
0.0066381698,
0.0088667879,
0.062058825,
0.027026264,
0.0114532299,
-0.0336993709,
-0.0344071239,
0.01381425,
0.0883020982,
-0.0412334539,
-0.0330190323,
0.0258825216,
-0.1064197272,
0.0736705288,
-0.0298085473,
-0.053942889,
-0.0362470038,
-0.1193925142,
0.0501951687,
-0.0793176517,
0.0205055326,
-0.0582126528,
-0.0042125005,
-0.013727257,
0.0632230192,
-0.0387100428,
-0.113262482,
-0.0057138037,
-0.0092390096,
0.0218167212,
0.0496839508,
0.0143697737,
-0.0451937988,
-0.0287577417,
0.0095034987,
-0.0636802465,
-0.0015137122,
-0.0174643099,
0.1010974199,
0.0286889225,
-0.0173947141,
0.0254481398,
0.0438036025,
0.0087473299,
0.0089789778,
-0.0153653109,
0.0767278597,
-0.0180234388,
-0.034828078,
0.0139418039,
-0.0403104797,
0.0238848925,
0.0673586205,
0.0490947478,
-0.0489244647,
-0.0438414067,
-0.0040278938,
0.023039829,
-0.012753305,
0.010757342,
0.0412224904,
-0.0525960922,
-0.1062564626,
-0.0193163343,
-0.0442601331,
0.044334922,
0.0586210899,
0.0001297502,
0.0312274434,
-0.0133494167,
0.013830889,
-0.0382426977,
0.0291684736,
0.0114217997,
0.0309964269,
-0.0367330275,
-0.0167848598,
0.0016142635,
-0.025103366,
-0.0493593328,
-0.0142183555,
-0.0313449427,
-0.0360746086,
0.0231361836,
0.0584259965,
0.0253716204,
0.0360354595,
-0.0295261722,
-0.0556626022,
0.0248047784,
0.0742585212,
-0.0432261042,
-0.0008485818,
0.0734979436,
-0.0700869039,
-0.013085966,
0.015492904,
-0.0615290552,
0.0444836468,
0.0694402307,
-0.0295230709,
-0.0209550466,
-0.0299690347,
0.0023334248,
0.0330357216,
0.0668859407,
-0.0175057407,
-0.051542785,
-0.0111326203,
0.0260935966,
0.0729882494,
0.0042052935,
-0.0222168881,
-0.0097205006,
0.0095212273,
0.0246016327,
-0.0120676467,
0.0537015013,
-0.0025654295,
0.0269739293,
-0.0527556166,
0.0285448749,
0.0195693485,
0.0864897966,
0.018629536,
0.0163981449,
-0.0252112541,
-0.0190122854,
0.0330073386,
0.0479104407,
0.0191311426,
-0.0043959063,
0.0283062775,
0.0321135297,
0.0179734677,
0.0156521779,
-0.0729025751,
-0.0226036888,
-0.0254721288,
-0.0073468336,
0.0464061014,
-0.0190112982,
0.0504916497,
-0.0366455428,
-0.0053426726,
-0.0269333813,
0.0113160554,
0.0230350271,
-0.0226463061,
0.0122143906,
0.019612113,
-0.0241022091,
0.0153811658,
0.0557824448,
-0.0012159179,
0.0504533164,
-0.0252624415,
0.0119442148,
-0.0592112355,
0.0027384392,
0.0693628341,
-0.0008102481,
-0.0057326383,
-0.0225338899,
-0.0636956021,
-0.0631041601,
-0.0241168682,
-0.030126404,
0.0141055845,
0.0181055907,
0.0495649502,
0.069241792,
0.000799735,
0.0333782025,
-0.0272791553,
-0.0448824875,
-0.0135027627,
-0.007999693,
-0.0064969985,
-5.837023728e-33,
0.02834424,
-0.0001265049,
-0.0325593427,
0.0236192569,
0.0216212422,
0.0025828099,
-0.0086830361,
-0.0307923332,
-0.0120408172,
0.0194721594,
-0.0077220951,
-0.0183826853,
0.0128726633,
0.0187089406,
-0.0118332189,
-0.0401663929,
0.0597226582,
-0.0137556223,
-0.0243078992,
0.0308179278,
0.0211220533,
0.0099128159,
0.0560392626,
-0.0895518064,
0.0091016153,
0.0339267738,
-0.0204652268,
0.0064521884,
0.0080356682,
0.0316330306,
0.0194336679,
0.0711719096,
0.0024142852,
-0.0877693594,
-0.0135744298,
-0.0163110718,
-0.0495669506,
-0.0478700772,
-0.0445113108,
0.0626058728,
0.0009180469,
-0.0103048449,
0.0367626548,
0.0065515917,
-0.0181294363,
0.0093138274,
0.0562608168,
-0.0472709388,
-0.0485484749,
-0.076142326,
0.0005121844,
0.02943312,
-0.0318979025,
-0.0001584084,
0.0289613008,
0.0524973646,
-0.0142830946,
-0.0255244672,
-0.0344746746,
0.0139955804,
0.0541069098,
0.002661251,
0.0551562309,
0.0101762377,
0.0099028824,
0.0814451724,
0.0321714319,
0.0032231729,
0.0614487045,
0.0093345549,
0.0362969935,
0.0568211153,
0.0405837893,
0.0316882282,
0.0716998801,
-0.0212133862,
-0.0989564657,
0.0492228903,
0.0321667381,
-0.0048673209,
-0.0023757461,
0.0114604579,
-0.0578803681,
-0.0367463119,
-0.030447254,
-0.0060935584,
-0.0019754604,
-0.0238526687,
0.0090741199,
-0.0084512243,
-0.0660598055,
0.023771001,
0.00600874,
-0.0338738039,
-0.0312177446,
0.0355532207,
-0.0140184462,
0.0230829176,
0.0309193488,
-0.0329271443,
-0.0243930146,
-0.0429307744,
0.0482858308,
0.0193352979,
0.0478453971,
-0.012063087,
0.0444525294,
0.0222116616,
-0.0264564361,
0.0116295237,
-0.0185227543,
0.0029312021,
0.0116402786,
0.0214713737,
0.0139984796,
-0.0071852645,
0.0095334854,
0.0275687017,
0.0096208518,
-0.0041258861,
-0.0362495184,
0.033519648,
-0.0167864542,
0.0118460516,
-0.0063122846,
-0.0559226349,
-0.0173302051,
-0.034427572,
0.0317718983,
-0.0489381142,
-0.0075245793,
0.0138751762,
2.781e-7,
0.020138042,
0.0270361658,
-0.0743076205,
0.0007347759,
0.0040101307,
0.0555605739,
-0.0225937925,
0.0051503689,
-0.0009012493,
-0.0029092915,
0.0005567935,
-0.0234088339,
0.0658696964,
0.0400383659,
-0.0767636746,
-0.0334704146,
-0.009127656,
0.0029848116,
-0.0316123515,
0.0156128816,
0.0541490018,
0.1251613498,
0.0259755235,
-0.037303444,
0.0315621383,
-0.0281621255,
-0.0004832947,
-0.0517523214,
0.0527451932,
0.0323540159,
0.0706356317,
0.0099477042,
0.0181454625,
0.0459179655,
-0.0414992347,
-0.0352689885,
0.0057161595,
-0.0087079909,
0.0081708226,
-0.0078407228,
-0.0204189848,
0.0174275301,
0.0309935138,
-0.0516708978,
0.0784917846,
-0.0453845114,
-0.0573880747,
0.0132671613,
-0.0210451484,
-0.0170562677,
0.0336688459,
-0.0041650925,
-0.0025706601,
-0.0123663126,
0.0030218803,
-0.0214752313,
-0.02935661,
-0.0280302148,
0.0014066197,
0.0096142264,
-0.036713507,
-0.0335156284,
-0.0226262771,
0.0224436056,
0.0364562161,
-0.0583006963,
0.0103703979,
2.826326475e-34,
0.0346502922,
-0.0192158595,
-0.0075495965,
0.0107810376,
-0.0342738144,
-0.0148994932,
0.0415102579,
-0.0051540141,
0.0024152214,
-0.0057684234,
0.0308614913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16298v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16298v1 | Influence Scores at Scale for Efficient Language Data Sampling | 2023-11-27T20:19:22 | 2023-11-27T20:19:22 | Nikhil Anand, Joshua Tan, Maria Minakova | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Modern ML systems ingest data aggregated from diverse sources, such as
synthetic, human-annotated, and live customer traffic. Understanding
\textit{which} examples are important to the performance of a learning
algorithm is crucial for efficient model training. Recently, a growing body of
literature has given rise to various "influence scores," which use training
artifacts such as model confidence or checkpointed gradients to identify
important subsets of data. However, these methods have primarily been developed
in computer vision settings, and it remains unclear how well they generalize to
language-based tasks using pretrained models.
In this paper, we explore the applicability of influence scores in language
classification tasks. We evaluate a diverse subset of these scores on the SNLI
dataset by quantifying accuracy changes in response to pruning training data
through random and influence-score-based sampling. We then stress-test one of
the scores -- "variance of gradients" (VoG) from Agarwal et al. (2022) -- in an
NLU model stack that was exposed to dynamic user speech patterns in a voice
assistant type of setting. Our experiments demonstrate that in many cases,
encoder-based language models can be finetuned on roughly 50% of the original
data without degradation in performance metrics. Along the way, we summarize
lessons learned from applying out-of-the-box implementations of influence
scores, quantify the effects of noisy and class-imbalanced data, and offer
recommendations on score-based sampling for better accuracy and training
efficiency. | [
0.0056016762,
0.0643249527,
-0.0357714072,
0.0108541893,
-0.028967049,
0.0174998213,
0.0233135503,
-0.003186872,
-0.0248883143,
-0.065924637,
-0.0481309295,
-0.0433617048,
0.0208360646,
0.0323972553,
0.0203325991,
-0.0339883491,
0.0138274422,
-0.0503833033,
-0.0031907549,
-0.0082035903,
0.0174867995,
0.011757086,
0.0147080766,
0.0348811634,
-0.0111409454,
0.0131505812,
0.0227449052,
0.023394661,
0.0115309609,
0.0187841654,
0.042803105,
0.0598708168,
0.0498496518,
0.0263596289,
0.0000020455,
-0.0440969467,
0.0034576785,
-0.0044683665,
-0.0756123438,
-0.0123570422,
0.0369543433,
-0.002000619,
0.0025478369,
0.0438922122,
-0.0048670825,
-0.0046908567,
0.0303841103,
0.0090580992,
0.0159209166,
0.0523951314,
-0.016050417,
0.0005780022,
-0.0159074459,
-0.0233144481,
0.0098290211,
-0.0121861799,
0.0193116069,
-0.0084353061,
-0.0660078377,
-0.0384801365,
-0.0188003853,
0.0353489742,
0.0150041552,
-0.0142454337,
0.0138756987,
0.0125357453,
-0.0323909484,
-0.014143155,
-0.0021332172,
0.0636612996,
-0.0636865571,
-0.0300246272,
-0.0052245646,
-0.0344306044,
0.0107344445,
0.0271237195,
-0.0287319925,
-0.0258763861,
0.0432480536,
0.0282682758,
-0.0375510864,
0.0349409916,
0.058902584,
0.0116465362,
-0.007061962,
-0.0070640217,
0.0115705626,
-0.0347914547,
0.0582817756,
0.0219002459,
0.0019060081,
-0.008396145,
-0.0020737282,
-0.0200561788,
-0.0163151417,
0.0231588241,
-0.0462767109,
-0.0125122881,
0.0126633691,
-0.0352922007,
0.0541966148,
0.0161544774,
-0.0232436899,
0.0366274193,
-0.0084328242,
0.021683313,
0.0528898016,
0.0242535658,
-0.0049446616,
-0.0312155243,
-0.0282530896,
0.0174959432,
-0.0152370837,
0.010236863,
-0.0120845735,
0.0092388187,
-0.0677512661,
0.0105185546,
-0.0332431011,
-0.005690983,
0.0030953388,
-0.00551291,
-0.0214102995,
0.0286942236,
0.0198420547,
-0.0013886399,
0.0148474891,
0.0292114504,
0.0055886791,
-0.1161314696,
0.0049925302,
0.0181584992,
0.0056933784,
-0.0344613157,
0.0157212634,
0.0374102071,
0.031234337,
-0.0723718405,
-0.0218165498,
-0.0060729659,
-0.0253653489,
-0.0623731315,
-0.0204596091,
-0.059975937,
0.0206986424,
0.0049943547,
0.0167554431,
-0.0468205288,
-0.0152841024,
-0.0040816502,
0.0027914378,
0.0585867651,
0.0246745348,
0.0040338798,
0.0232384074,
-0.0108156055,
0.0016332641,
0.0889402553,
0.0410479121,
0.0363126472,
0.0588245653,
-0.0166238621,
0.0463741347,
0.0625674874,
0.0480855554,
0.0157539919,
-0.012229681,
-0.0089265304,
-0.0139704607,
-0.024886325,
0.0221439898,
0.0433620103,
-0.0438698754,
-0.0177108236,
0.0955056399,
0.0325532854,
-0.0088646365,
-0.0070848875,
0.0035444011,
-0.0001865607,
-0.0030426807,
-0.0294326097,
-0.030687958,
-0.0429959074,
-0.0141850682,
-0.0215559248,
0.0090790866,
0.0272810012,
-0.0371925421,
-0.0389609188,
0.0046648202,
-0.005093581,
-0.0007158901,
0.0798489973,
0.0560314693,
0.0090183998,
0.0107230935,
0.06432724,
0.0306093767,
-0.0460300334,
0.0475551672,
-0.0413141772,
-0.0078560775,
0.0215126611,
0.0324086547,
-0.0169536285,
0.031712316,
-0.0576913618,
-0.0003563477,
-0.0149198463,
0.0373438373,
-0.0215959903,
0.0448742434,
-0.0609228201,
-0.0284189899,
0.0426223204,
0.0095902449,
0.0207208693,
0.0068928995,
0.0143183442,
0.0250146203,
-0.0539419577,
-0.0738514811,
0.018732518,
0.0222259518,
-0.0267416351,
0.0262918118,
0.0022208234,
0.0516119786,
0.0032882448,
-0.0519995578,
-0.0369833484,
0.0143432375,
-0.0280599128,
-0.0112166805,
0.0049554822,
-0.0323761217,
-0.0287234131,
0.0294362977,
-0.0165900085,
-0.0035358174,
0.0728920847,
-0.059341602,
-0.0372018032,
0.0084704924,
-0.0539279915,
-0.0138310064,
-0.0582717732,
-0.0014235051,
-0.0365087204,
0.0770265162,
-0.021823287,
0.0135550722,
-0.0142181581,
-0.0011456229,
0.0100400131,
0.0043687574,
0.0226442739,
-0.0171953049,
-0.0424371623,
0.0018733689,
-0.0145033421,
0.0268363021,
0.0394110307,
-0.0249070413,
-0.0236779097,
0.0036067213,
-0.1133627519,
-0.0243592635,
-0.0838040411,
0.0224668924,
0.0122376913,
0.0273310747,
-0.027242776,
-0.0354385339,
-0.0145886857,
-0.0357939899,
0.0045150262,
0.0320160724,
-0.0001775745,
-0.0016872161,
-0.0181139689,
-0.0291341655,
-0.0285916496,
0.0324035734,
0.0672825798,
0.0053204694,
-0.0634867698,
-0.0421484262,
-0.0323139988,
-0.0150867254,
0.0095964577,
-0.01122755,
-0.0334975608,
-0.0230885837,
0.038606409,
0.0279463064,
0.0613391884,
0.0215943735,
0.0481484644,
0.0168537926,
0.017442191,
-0.0470259562,
-0.0220455267,
-0.0472807027,
-0.0096342731,
-0.0570576973,
-0.0130056441,
0.0093930326,
0.0291471779,
0.0186587311,
0.0039738053,
-0.0420701243,
-0.0004611959,
-0.0259889774,
-0.0470512249,
-0.058005821,
0.0174899939,
-0.0565998927,
0.05864425,
-0.0102440342,
-0.0744979009,
0.0420009159,
-0.0181723181,
0.003611533,
-0.0297319572,
-0.0326159298,
-0.0130776353,
0.0514405668,
0.0175606664,
0.0013985955,
0.0124428701,
-0.021658048,
-0.029592365,
-0.0094644194,
0.0215834454,
-0.0434569791,
0.0036010365,
-0.0422751568,
0.0240458176,
0.003488,
-0.0518308468,
-0.0493393689,
-0.0258221813,
-0.0038532836,
0.0143607752,
0.0276177879,
-0.0020473534,
0.0041990229,
0.0057823081,
-0.0146395518,
0.060889177,
-0.0231135301,
0.0000330603,
0.0063139196,
0.0166799426,
0.0810039937,
0.0179834757,
0.0305305757,
-0.0338182747,
-0.0085441573,
0.0243495181,
0.0502374396,
0.0003983629,
-0.0358865447,
0.0205390919,
0.0527421385,
-0.0282905418,
0.0023829183,
0.0510492474,
0.061568521,
-0.0484926701,
-0.0240435544,
0.1191028431,
-0.0039822492,
-0.0485930741,
0.0012940294,
0.0247619953,
0.0691292435,
0.0138686271,
0.0147808604,
-0.0625553131,
-0.041075334,
0.0094547197,
0.0396080427,
-0.0296919271,
-0.0000494175,
0.0120512014,
-0.0880690515,
0.0706707388,
-0.0210834257,
-0.0256929342,
0.0037160181,
-0.0747804418,
0.0409974493,
-0.0568495803,
0.043624375,
-0.0679297,
0.0192655586,
-0.0178266838,
0.0516914241,
-0.0371982902,
-0.1165034771,
0.0225163791,
-0.0324664973,
0.0451670326,
0.0587578565,
0.0131536648,
-0.0150487106,
-0.0348938182,
0.0771399513,
-0.0410358943,
-0.0021932987,
-0.0108583067,
0.1089238301,
-0.0236219987,
-0.0116495732,
0.0198849384,
0.0409305543,
-0.0264700931,
0.044484254,
-0.0185016468,
0.052810479,
-0.0294948127,
-0.0083424589,
0.0000307496,
-0.0585133098,
0.0526868738,
0.0531507954,
0.0500127599,
-0.0520634353,
-0.0319050588,
-0.0126351733,
0.0083705522,
-0.0101563111,
-0.0415854044,
0.0126348101,
0.0156232296,
-0.0527612343,
-0.0395612568,
-0.0443774424,
0.0023981184,
0.036388047,
0.0037139188,
0.0263593066,
0.0109441727,
0.0045461198,
-0.0297484584,
0.0199073721,
-0.0530112758,
0.0458099917,
-0.0233606789,
0.0063297972,
0.016956158,
-0.0138553102,
-0.0395426303,
-0.0098895179,
-0.0988681093,
-0.0845532715,
0.0360030867,
0.0737598017,
0.0233336203,
0.0657970235,
-0.0096471664,
-0.0720395073,
0.0860455185,
0.020651618,
-0.0140442085,
-0.0119394604,
0.0526991487,
-0.0734876692,
-0.0283752326,
0.0371010788,
-0.05198415,
0.0372739099,
0.0481567308,
-0.0320676453,
-0.0195318013,
-0.0355284214,
-0.0156277325,
-0.004397036,
0.066282548,
-0.0282453839,
-0.0320461094,
-0.0230362937,
0.025564339,
0.034187302,
-0.0016290093,
-0.0364028402,
-0.033040069,
0.0279951077,
0.0093826568,
-0.0280025955,
0.047355216,
-0.0248809122,
0.0022617276,
-0.0651258156,
0.0240577329,
-0.0133451223,
0.0521295108,
0.0180068053,
0.0144730927,
-0.0082683368,
0.0381240658,
0.0352000222,
0.0213493332,
0.018564133,
0.0064762305,
0.0177787747,
0.0442095771,
0.0033868917,
0.0191384107,
-0.0698791146,
-0.0443724655,
-0.0466338471,
-0.0215505939,
0.0433437005,
-0.0431738421,
0.050087478,
-0.0078210104,
0.0013400805,
-0.0406908169,
0.016660165,
-0.008177001,
0.0036375292,
0.022781875,
0.0006986476,
-0.014477931,
0.0632990673,
0.0603414215,
-0.0148347216,
0.0497981384,
-0.0122337397,
-0.0155370543,
-0.0291755106,
-0.0162796676,
0.005038383,
0.0146418978,
-0.0107225254,
0.008738501,
-0.0300545972,
-0.0695464313,
0.0152880596,
-0.0211300384,
0.0276596118,
0.0047029252,
0.0691379458,
0.0381575935,
-0.0399974175,
0.0334120467,
-0.0426770709,
-0.0366500169,
-0.0344032831,
0.0005142556,
0.0003500585,
-6.766484173e-33,
0.0262355711,
0.020540759,
-0.0326835923,
0.0092385104,
-0.0094288709,
0.0079093846,
-0.0086518079,
-0.0110160168,
-0.0178354513,
0.0066207284,
-0.0098873004,
0.003641699,
0.0330654979,
0.0593914948,
-0.0250216462,
-0.0377134904,
0.0862068236,
-0.0226618033,
-0.0472140461,
0.036706768,
0.0332023017,
0.0337977484,
0.0684447214,
-0.0748884007,
0.0102800243,
0.0011019706,
0.0175918788,
-0.0122721195,
0.0051325839,
0.0403971151,
-0.0081705116,
0.0824663714,
0.001242176,
-0.071047999,
-0.0330915526,
-0.001679606,
-0.0687756836,
-0.020443989,
-0.0275674425,
0.0752341896,
-0.0322068632,
0.0302320458,
0.0418284684,
0.0018788319,
-0.0285774246,
-0.0104713254,
0.0282618627,
-0.0230181627,
-0.0459101796,
-0.0448025428,
-0.0160146672,
0.0337690152,
-0.0197085012,
-0.0108940247,
0.0562180467,
0.047138866,
-0.0071815858,
0.0217945091,
-0.0373106785,
-0.0269687138,
0.0087303361,
0.0144071095,
0.073054187,
0.0445097461,
0.0237159505,
0.0823861435,
0.0139748249,
0.01031968,
0.0318135284,
-0.0272725038,
0.0441350602,
0.0112413224,
0.0119677363,
0.048420772,
0.0472139046,
-0.027794918,
-0.0846936926,
0.0009879699,
0.034342315,
-0.0006894959,
0.0396948755,
-0.0031427718,
-0.0540256537,
-0.0401208661,
-0.0598016307,
-0.0425297171,
-0.00178675,
-0.0238261614,
0.0289235525,
0.0269710291,
-0.0164742991,
0.0199278835,
0.0501385257,
-0.0329822935,
-0.0552727655,
0.0036700077,
-0.006733418,
0.0061208615,
0.0357277803,
-0.0032158738,
-0.0573471189,
-0.0088258209,
0.0100642135,
0.0023889856,
0.0237482339,
-0.0274288263,
0.0611803271,
0.0558980368,
-0.0376799256,
0.002967193,
-0.0114184255,
0.030912606,
0.0064959493,
0.0812459886,
0.0416651368,
0.0101697212,
-0.0187343247,
0.0476138033,
0.0148626035,
0.0110560646,
-0.0071736057,
-0.0270684157,
-0.0187836215,
0.0060297493,
-0.0575207248,
-0.0440519303,
-0.0129960719,
-0.0002494991,
0.0275370851,
-0.0439118631,
-0.0039113485,
0.0038103964,
2.794e-7,
0.0258929003,
0.0573534444,
-0.0109946961,
-0.0056632049,
0.0238894615,
0.0250823349,
-0.0028609224,
-0.0034215106,
0.0175238531,
-0.0292858873,
0.0024504641,
0.0132032419,
0.0622202121,
0.0257514063,
-0.068637915,
-0.0015815522,
-0.0651520267,
0.0321877934,
-0.0350089222,
0.0092836814,
0.0308441482,
0.124790743,
0.0055809072,
-0.0481876507,
0.0129003879,
0.0060420414,
0.0525946133,
-0.0591210574,
0.0042622741,
0.014705969,
0.0684646964,
0.0333284438,
0.0009518111,
0.0362081677,
-0.0534386858,
0.0302559435,
-0.0032494636,
0.024585722,
-0.0016923182,
-0.0035711969,
-0.01985115,
0.0253327042,
0.0074133244,
-0.0522018746,
0.0706883445,
-0.0379186347,
-0.0343804583,
-0.0582193471,
-0.0151373614,
-0.0289611705,
0.0730837062,
-0.0103888018,
0.0037234132,
0.0274089873,
0.0336310044,
-0.0044957432,
-0.0562553369,
-0.0987481847,
0.0099577466,
-0.0267982557,
-0.0176944714,
-0.0318948701,
-0.0285146236,
-0.0297579877,
0.0038741052,
-0.0252942536,
0.028141344,
2.364861372e-34,
0.0537548959,
-0.0079806056,
0.0033541212,
0.0097770337,
0.0091552343,
-0.0264011156,
0.0227242429,
-0.0058722515,
0.0081472434,
-0.0308049433,
-0.0072631566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16292v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16292v1 | Student Mastery or AI Deception? Analyzing ChatGPT's Assessment Proficiency and Evaluating Detection Strategies | 2023-11-27T20:10:13 | 2023-11-27T20:10:13 | Kevin Wang, Seth Akins, Abdallah Mohammed, Ramon Lawrence | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | Generative AI systems such as ChatGPT have a disruptive effect on learning
and assessment. Computer science requires practice to develop skills in problem
solving and programming that are traditionally developed using assignments.
Generative AI has the capability of completing these assignments for students
with high accuracy, which dramatically increases the potential for academic
integrity issues and students not achieving desired learning outcomes. This
work investigates the performance of ChatGPT by evaluating it across three
courses (CS1,CS2,databases). ChatGPT completes almost all introductory
assessments perfectly. Existing detection methods, such as MOSS and JPlag
(based on similarity metrics) and GPTzero (AI detection), have mixed success in
identifying AI solutions. Evaluating instructors and teaching assistants using
heuristics to distinguish between student and AI code shows that their
detection is not sufficiently accurate. These observations emphasize the need
for adapting assessments and improved detection methods. | [
0.0282397736,
0.0218630377,
-0.0723261535,
0.0220816601,
-0.0645813122,
0.0108330231,
0.0144330692,
-0.0261970535,
0.0630132258,
-0.0167612489,
0.0027748849,
0.0337302126,
-0.0036579119,
0.0183968302,
0.0186997727,
0.0324490368,
0.0266387314,
0.0203876011,
-0.0044627045,
0.0314439125,
0.0158986207,
0.015760012,
-0.0249642376,
0.0729764327,
-0.0181886349,
-0.0818605348,
0.0018000962,
-0.0464578085,
-0.0035980276,
-0.0194294993,
0.0259932503,
0.0120345932,
-0.0220692772,
0.0663879663,
0.000002116,
-0.040088702,
-0.0343835317,
0.0129575878,
-0.0534899123,
0.0551856495,
0.0162156038,
0.1336582005,
0.009587721,
0.0164583158,
-0.0817824379,
0.0262552984,
-0.0030413121,
-0.0218775645,
0.0252269749,
0.0177671406,
0.0049938462,
0.0407063775,
0.0291562248,
0.0236107036,
0.0574239865,
-0.0277867522,
0.0117505481,
0.0584448911,
0.0210737623,
-0.0225495528,
-0.0281533934,
0.0124295624,
-0.0048043109,
-0.0099049238,
0.0082420716,
0.0235046912,
-0.0360477902,
0.0237490833,
0.0227403417,
-0.0151577871,
-0.002562779,
-0.0186157953,
0.0153680434,
0.0014939064,
0.0451123454,
0.0095760338,
-0.0193265118,
0.0256411396,
-0.0523748398,
-0.0367552675,
0.0147879506,
-0.0175436214,
-0.0167796966,
0.016935084,
0.0313310809,
-0.0294191297,
-0.0016323471,
-0.0348566808,
-0.0130948853,
0.0342477933,
0.0053581418,
-0.020811649,
0.0195029508,
0.0708657131,
-0.0309159253,
-0.0005787058,
-0.0130401794,
-0.0293870643,
0.0003472426,
-0.0081910947,
0.0306095127,
0.0490874648,
0.0306383185,
0.0138678644,
-0.0195921864,
0.1497850418,
0.0149868783,
0.0456939638,
-0.016685782,
0.0475346558,
-0.0833943635,
-0.0196076035,
-0.0295801871,
0.0505192541,
0.0694836602,
0.0331657715,
-0.0526088253,
0.0295977443,
-0.0845460221,
0.0551286675,
-0.0697679892,
0.0114945322,
0.0189811625,
0.0583171621,
-0.0196427424,
-0.0107610412,
0.0070814523,
-0.006191046,
-0.008632483,
-0.0551623553,
-0.0120686777,
0.0274497159,
-0.0196308587,
0.0212794319,
0.0115886936,
0.0194923878,
-0.0088227866,
0.0010270831,
-0.0323290154,
-0.0410224311,
-0.0000578999,
-0.0258401688,
0.0189286713,
-0.0536909439,
-0.0327423997,
-0.0150347063,
-0.0183341838,
-0.0347112827,
-0.0086908322,
0.0351776555,
0.0473285764,
0.0181247927,
-0.0035505958,
0.0026278882,
0.0334918611,
0.0427802578,
-0.0645813495,
-0.0052716751,
0.0288652852,
0.0273969546,
-0.0043340493,
-0.0547905415,
0.0878540277,
-0.0056988178,
-0.0031961163,
-0.001156534,
0.0484570153,
0.0015874365,
0.030774422,
0.0078238305,
-0.0294875782,
0.0396777838,
-0.0179914329,
0.0336664543,
0.0266892761,
0.0491730869,
-0.0297123622,
0.0657623038,
0.0362915434,
0.0323427878,
0.0450123288,
0.0664520636,
-0.0008993681,
-0.0039761504,
-0.0216360334,
-0.0273223687,
-0.0230940823,
0.0418004319,
0.0143401353,
-0.0844781697,
-0.0135969054,
0.0062142443,
-0.0260482021,
0.0332927555,
0.0011913771,
-0.0103387637,
-0.0153734451,
-0.0877601579,
-0.0383395627,
-0.0382146537,
0.0190455597,
-0.1325173974,
0.0385676324,
0.0765974745,
0.0608454086,
-0.0384854376,
-0.0361023769,
-0.0161406416,
-0.0245718919,
-0.0272253696,
-0.0007134914,
-0.038212508,
-0.0396048278,
0.0106350901,
-0.0253258236,
-0.0230629984,
-0.0160310194,
0.0306734759,
-0.0084313583,
0.0033628407,
0.0045975707,
-0.0105743771,
-0.0523319133,
0.025666194,
-0.0480595008,
-0.0605856478,
-0.0160089787,
0.0163352937,
0.0266596042,
-0.0124828266,
-0.0173392352,
0.0249623675,
-0.0058940253,
0.0417988226,
-0.0355188921,
-0.053748481,
-0.0117214359,
0.0346082784,
0.0378269628,
-0.0773726031,
-0.0483944342,
0.0072861817,
-0.00406405,
-0.0069395015,
0.0661154985,
-0.0408132225,
-0.0102252597,
-0.0242186356,
0.0211976375,
-0.0547747724,
0.0161953811,
-0.0195077509,
0.0283418745,
0.0538811609,
0.0296207871,
0.0116817066,
-0.0004800227,
0.0389825664,
0.0141798947,
-0.0123418476,
-0.0130826375,
-0.0446919911,
0.0234097317,
0.007236836,
0.02151406,
-0.0624526031,
0.0061854105,
-0.0622940026,
-0.0200020187,
0.0280995872,
0.024651235,
0.0084660389,
-0.0736151859,
-0.0327746347,
0.0430192612,
-0.0379882418,
-0.0677068383,
0.0038480943,
-0.0204215739,
-0.0113986386,
-0.0158426687,
-0.0100832712,
-0.0214813855,
0.0281652063,
-0.0709693804,
0.0001344416,
0.0736818612,
0.0187986381,
-0.0265896954,
0.0531178229,
-0.0070905434,
-0.0029225883,
0.0111967484,
-0.0315008424,
0.019932108,
-0.0275366809,
0.0094978902,
0.07980562,
-0.018234795,
0.0347138457,
0.0360459052,
-0.0143434228,
-0.0467131585,
0.0115879821,
0.0294166449,
-0.0120189032,
0.034319777,
-0.0630457401,
0.0042815846,
-0.01050313,
0.0412225835,
-0.0446748473,
0.019838253,
0.0518246703,
-0.0478418693,
0.0145697324,
-0.0012753,
-0.0389220044,
-0.0104099251,
-0.0291532893,
-0.0044609201,
-0.022326434,
0.0690225214,
-0.0230985936,
0.006774087,
-0.0461956337,
-0.0026855099,
0.0199166313,
0.0169243198,
0.0077994913,
0.0112008695,
-0.006734381,
0.0030274114,
-0.0466829687,
0.0234731548,
0.0459232852,
-0.0561359748,
-0.0276789386,
-0.0293649454,
-0.0206644945,
0.0186856352,
0.0145312119,
-0.0753529072,
0.043353796,
0.0639670044,
-0.0034900883,
0.051549647,
-0.0282255281,
0.029526487,
-0.0670178607,
0.000096581,
0.0030457554,
-0.017243864,
-0.0514148623,
-0.0016685494,
-0.0075771301,
0.0056474037,
-0.0479117371,
0.0138324862,
0.0016966349,
0.0057743685,
0.0559215844,
0.05832408,
0.0172672626,
-0.0308178719,
-0.0040048179,
0.0289562717,
-0.0427729003,
0.0440939777,
0.0358706675,
-0.0163176134,
-0.038850069,
-0.0278703831,
0.0519294441,
0.0224489458,
-0.0207683686,
-0.010015755,
0.0015612156,
-0.0579002984,
0.0151511133,
0.0303941984,
-0.094139196,
0.04121501,
-0.0340158381,
0.0374650024,
-0.074868612,
-0.0399113819,
0.0039939219,
-0.05865613,
0.0484886281,
0.0103021991,
-0.0224528816,
-0.0158891771,
-0.0162111577,
-0.0128814615,
-0.0218604635,
-0.0142732644,
-0.0281921886,
0.0092393272,
0.0589834042,
0.0449137762,
-0.0261918325,
0.0168213621,
0.0624232329,
0.0229312461,
0.0336733162,
0.0483803228,
0.0049855141,
-0.0199552476,
-0.0454806723,
0.0206045322,
0.0181549117,
-0.0078653703,
0.0083317617,
0.0364634767,
-0.0208346713,
0.0201726649,
-0.0199369919,
-0.0038278066,
-0.0133195492,
0.0293985792,
0.087328814,
0.0918041468,
-0.0220599882,
-0.0193733294,
-0.0434895307,
-0.0284921397,
0.0243345685,
0.014428745,
0.0447894521,
-0.002381807,
-0.0083684996,
-0.0440875143,
0.0343178734,
-0.023505101,
-0.029172942,
0.0222802814,
0.0096568801,
-0.0072573158,
-0.0198482089,
-0.0579142682,
0.0258390065,
0.0047689928,
0.0168205742,
-0.0020494177,
0.0105217071,
0.0312073659,
-0.0505092293,
-0.0172663461,
-0.0093590785,
-0.0006565408,
-0.0109449737,
-0.0339434557,
-0.0548173748,
-0.0268667042,
-0.0404350087,
0.0104532661,
-0.0305508059,
-0.0095307212,
0.0239579435,
0.0484590568,
0.0177603234,
-0.0488760844,
-0.0097646713,
0.0359376892,
-0.0247482751,
0.0064596832,
0.0168829001,
-0.0050364817,
0.0102752615,
-0.0281183552,
0.0148261543,
-0.0341619477,
0.0077306549,
0.0144716688,
0.050592009,
-0.0017577433,
-0.0021628763,
0.0484969318,
0.0482549481,
0.0777562782,
0.0230990443,
-0.0119099757,
0.0076221894,
0.0022241333,
-0.0290749054,
0.003711805,
-0.0119777005,
-0.0037874638,
-0.0523733944,
0.0479710959,
0.0410374627,
0.0263050031,
0.020043863,
-0.0528262891,
0.0287207048,
-0.0219709892,
0.0282128882,
-0.0003932886,
0.0639045984,
0.0009914269,
-0.0142179783,
-0.0002280718,
-0.0140331108,
0.0467553474,
0.0485275239,
0.0133582689,
0.079328768,
-0.0096695907,
0.0415283255,
0.0585900135,
0.025683457,
-0.0411572829,
-0.0161544681,
-0.0017923797,
0.0794141144,
0.0203603692,
0.054194808,
-0.0309118759,
-0.0168935303,
0.0354485102,
-0.0052383402,
0.0103482753,
-0.0317038074,
-0.0581675991,
-0.0456660241,
0.0203146487,
0.012376897,
-0.0193034504,
0.0439579934,
-0.0503467433,
0.0399844833,
-0.061757315,
-0.0257102735,
-0.0086915353,
-0.0326271094,
0.0008164357,
-0.0041414644,
0.0567753129,
-0.0137035232,
-0.0349425264,
-0.0668186694,
-0.045046296,
0.0372392721,
0.037430983,
-0.0186620113,
0.0063073076,
0.0619150028,
-0.0371309668,
-0.013740981,
-0.0072753844,
0.01694078,
-0.0231921729,
-0.0305934623,
-0.0299240239,
-5.474074052e-33,
-0.0176803041,
-0.0885476694,
0.0403432697,
0.0613061152,
0.0213432163,
0.0039385506,
-0.0145297647,
0.0272210632,
-0.0498145111,
-0.0103988415,
-0.0128109371,
0.0353604853,
-0.0101397932,
-0.004417704,
0.030015843,
0.0243450813,
0.0143706845,
0.0026070031,
-0.0143244946,
0.0589203462,
-0.0364126712,
-0.0293448083,
0.0463672355,
-0.0855617672,
0.0276246183,
-0.0459554195,
-0.0114866961,
-0.0548982397,
-0.0932041854,
0.0104410183,
-0.0063237841,
0.0423703939,
0.0096764416,
-0.006284256,
0.0094194384,
-0.0374682285,
0.0017223547,
-0.0968774259,
0.0046715359,
-0.000538252,
0.0234606117,
-0.0586814433,
0.0350886993,
-0.0107596815,
-0.0726207346,
0.0009818461,
0.0654284954,
0.0006579637,
0.0282121655,
-0.0334395207,
-0.0489050224,
-0.0072956095,
-0.0545278676,
-0.0078782029,
-0.0444410704,
0.0371266343,
-0.0020103678,
-0.0487571396,
-0.0096716732,
0.0458280779,
0.0265377592,
0.0053694383,
0.036126107,
-0.0128429197,
-0.0027648285,
0.0305247232,
0.0842283368,
0.016011266,
0.0026116003,
-0.0518698134,
0.0089560412,
-0.0205299295,
0.0681802854,
0.0278200768,
0.0255017132,
-0.0316089615,
-0.0343318656,
0.0403561927,
0.0350009575,
-0.0192500334,
-0.0339514017,
-0.0431862846,
-0.1179424599,
-0.0217657294,
0.0177005995,
-0.0482299291,
-0.0162642244,
-0.023087455,
0.0576319881,
-0.0502123646,
0.0181874949,
-0.0083969831,
-0.0142636569,
-0.0633935854,
0.0183945317,
-0.0267131682,
-0.0232937541,
0.0144260852,
0.002416434,
0.0118246237,
-0.0172612779,
-0.0006049501,
0.0226727426,
-0.0016248934,
0.0885964558,
0.0062594451,
0.0279506017,
0.027950678,
-0.0126132825,
-0.0069789393,
-0.0383998193,
-0.0083715227,
0.0244690422,
-0.0661464036,
0.0144602917,
0.0191272832,
0.0049934261,
-0.0157557614,
0.023065282,
0.0305910073,
-0.0660576969,
-0.012582303,
-0.0517126247,
-0.0356326662,
-0.0162468143,
-0.0146842673,
-0.0353400744,
0.0077265049,
-0.0322998986,
-0.0704102889,
-0.0159326959,
-0.0367786363,
2.831e-7,
-0.0206710752,
0.0218567681,
0.0022879844,
-0.0294998381,
-0.0114143612,
0.0063672573,
-0.0104063386,
-0.0113096414,
0.060664665,
0.045382645,
0.0279521234,
0.0191969238,
0.0240577273,
0.0128497956,
-0.0080767972,
-0.0324299447,
0.0307082701,
-0.0318768807,
-0.0412310548,
0.0718484074,
0.1268621683,
-0.0216376241,
0.0477220714,
-0.0137910023,
0.0170547385,
-0.0726762861,
-0.0319126397,
0.0518651418,
0.032315392,
0.0321143605,
-0.008531224,
0.0142101971,
0.0256184097,
0.0593571812,
0.0049302764,
-0.0355716422,
-0.0033735898,
0.0195071436,
-0.0073863221,
0.035204839,
0.0103720035,
-0.0183557607,
0.0345521197,
-0.0247139148,
0.0376807526,
0.0074183526,
0.0258322358,
-0.0016168325,
-0.0394067541,
-0.0671966299,
-0.000553736,
0.0072134533,
0.0140572628,
-0.000780576,
-0.0257794689,
-0.0180602744,
-0.001406059,
0.0234829634,
0.031271141,
-0.0223761406,
-0.0361616835,
-0.0322681516,
0.0134956241,
-0.0244264752,
0.049117025,
0.0021103541,
0.0088428035,
2.481261715e-34,
-0.0057333927,
-0.0423500575,
0.0760472864,
-0.012120367,
0.0321261249,
0.0471838452,
-0.0018260657,
0.0028191926,
-0.0038457625,
0.0550357103,
-0.052231621
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.