id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02439v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02439v3 | Let's Think Outside the Box: Exploring Leap-of-Thought in Large Language Models with Creative Humor Generation | 2023-12-05T02:41:57 | 2024-04-21T15:20:15 | Shanshan Zhong, Zhongzhan Huang, Shanghua Gao, Wushao Wen, Liang Lin, Marinka Zitnik, Pan Zhou | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) guides large language models (LLMs) to reason
step-by-step, and can motivate their logical reasoning ability. While effective
for logical tasks, CoT is not conducive to creative problem-solving which often
requires out-of-box thoughts and is crucial for innovation advancements. In
this paper, we explore the Leap-of-Thought (LoT) abilities within LLMs -- a
non-sequential, creative paradigm involving strong associations and knowledge
leaps. To this end, we study LLMs on the popular Oogiri game which needs
participants to have good creativity and strong associative thinking for
responding unexpectedly and humorously to the given image, text, or both, and
thus is suitable for LoT study. Then to investigate LLMs' LoT ability in the
Oogiri game, we first build a multimodal and multilingual Oogiri-GO dataset
which contains over 130,000 samples from the Oogiri game, and observe the
insufficient LoT ability or failures of most existing LLMs on the Oogiri game.
Accordingly, we introduce a creative Leap-of-Thought (CLoT) paradigm to improve
LLM's LoT ability. CLoT first formulates the Oogiri-GO dataset into
LoT-oriented instruction tuning data to train pretrained LLM for achieving
certain LoT humor generation and discrimination abilities. Then CLoT designs an
explorative self-refinement that encourages the LLM to generate more creative
LoT data via exploring parallels between seemingly unrelated concepts and
selects high-quality data to train itself for self-refinement. CLoT not only
excels in humor generation in the Oogiri game but also boosts creative
abilities in various tasks like cloud guessing game and divergent association
task. These findings advance our understanding and offer a pathway to improve
LLMs' creative capacities for innovative applications across domains. The
dataset, code, and models will be released online.
https://zhongshsh.github.io/CLoT/. | [
0.0514577441,
0.0438258536,
-0.0498821549,
0.0604167581,
-0.0088146627,
0.0386536829,
-0.0026599846,
-0.0024128305,
0.0400366783,
-0.0300545488,
-0.0178300682,
-0.0195022486,
-0.0188491717,
0.0599618517,
0.0402912572,
-0.0374669246,
0.0243951455,
-0.0534328818,
0.0122323725,
-0.0190047733,
-0.0226389635,
0.0198145825,
-0.0432725474,
0.0378527194,
0.023771327,
-0.0122088371,
-0.0152615216,
0.0175970718,
0.0453329459,
-0.0548425652,
-0.0297334958,
-0.0024401955,
0.0097839246,
0.0193072613,
0.0000020678,
-0.0764254928,
0.0169270858,
-0.0336197168,
0.0283990204,
-0.0078448569,
0.0022125216,
0.0197216514,
-0.0428876393,
0.0046181129,
-0.0344862305,
0.0244520605,
0.0709883571,
0.0411492996,
0.0569944493,
0.0829929635,
0.0053156884,
-0.0430955738,
0.0272254851,
-0.0187103804,
0.0378933325,
-0.031846568,
-0.0024267838,
0.0232993551,
0.0302387904,
-0.0028650998,
-0.0441134274,
-0.0054328255,
0.005139383,
-0.0085492274,
-0.0133337621,
0.0396688022,
-0.0129800783,
-0.0024862576,
-0.00112463,
0.0483357199,
-0.034339238,
0.0166776218,
-0.0125975283,
0.0270986557,
0.0185158178,
0.0268175304,
-0.0375717469,
0.0634507015,
0.002445278,
0.0039296239,
0.0327556618,
0.020667877,
-0.0098877493,
0.0329394452,
-0.0290234145,
0.0281474944,
-0.0102477157,
-0.0087371571,
-0.015704168,
-0.0118615143,
-0.0674409419,
-0.062399447,
-0.0074638915,
0.0408131555,
-0.0078977905,
0.0161347128,
-0.0076588802,
-0.0061600683,
0.005773617,
-0.0443788916,
0.0552126132,
0.0404968038,
0.0228737704,
0.0673753172,
-0.0177503116,
-0.0020776831,
-0.0306905601,
0.0227228403,
-0.0594759174,
0.011410051,
-0.0461080149,
-0.019993918,
-0.0519812405,
0.0390249789,
-0.014799037,
-0.0411323309,
-0.0595051646,
0.0460830741,
0.0184808727,
-0.0156476069,
-0.0107953399,
0.0272489842,
0.0129011888,
-0.0318111964,
-0.0746038333,
0.0308892764,
-0.0358838513,
0.0003862302,
0.0126836849,
0.0051558833,
-0.0123493094,
-0.0195353255,
0.0074175303,
-0.0431056246,
0.039932631,
0.0569335707,
-0.0361385532,
-0.0296142027,
-0.0414064489,
-0.007623733,
0.0029541664,
-0.0795115754,
0.0414086431,
-0.0788521692,
0.0027784009,
0.0251223538,
0.0130283153,
0.0039279736,
0.0155974478,
0.0175298229,
-0.0497285649,
0.0347154848,
-0.0215579886,
0.0172143001,
0.0122062061,
0.01932084,
-0.0155683132,
0.0577634238,
0.061456956,
0.0042834892,
0.0122446576,
0.0029682775,
-0.0001072529,
0.0241146348,
-0.0136776064,
-0.02552443,
0.0067652208,
-0.0194317587,
0.0092370845,
0.0566126741,
0.013783522,
0.0242906492,
-0.0456704237,
0.0566002615,
0.0747870803,
0.0317600816,
0.0651795194,
0.0488029756,
0.0543912761,
-0.0452310815,
-0.0058253929,
-0.0106361816,
0.0059458353,
0.0792053193,
-0.0150923282,
0.0068084556,
-0.0066339457,
0.104939647,
-0.0174571536,
-0.0085124224,
0.0003574413,
-0.0007732053,
0.0554660074,
-0.0197263286,
0.0382924005,
0.0351446047,
-0.0226689372,
-0.0014970151,
0.0132515188,
-0.0410337709,
-0.0220660251,
-0.0317666344,
0.0383815393,
0.0457583815,
0.0501562841,
0.0127960406,
-0.0004274096,
-0.0086600753,
0.0059525548,
0.0498239323,
-0.0082804058,
0.0150294453,
-0.0248345062,
-0.0437905528,
0.0145456931,
-0.0317367688,
0.0023136029,
0.015440369,
-0.0056092436,
0.0533716679,
-0.0347117744,
0.0252260417,
0.0538947619,
-0.0047285031,
-0.0645539612,
-0.0039514098,
-0.0233482532,
0.012910584,
0.0132629434,
-0.0116803357,
-0.0209938698,
0.0099095218,
0.0021020256,
-0.0572003536,
-0.0482178405,
0.0620888807,
-0.0241646711,
-0.0354288891,
0.0236008335,
-0.0782390088,
0.0075482684,
-0.0359740518,
0.0190408342,
-0.002764652,
0.0768313482,
-0.0465298146,
0.0025989315,
-0.0450915471,
0.0186629351,
-0.0065861172,
-0.0110844253,
-0.0010236407,
0.1000887081,
-0.0119605428,
-0.0103430701,
0.016788533,
0.0091357566,
0.0251807477,
0.0049119471,
-0.0127422344,
0.0469580628,
-0.011317905,
0.0050373147,
0.0025674079,
0.0318063945,
-0.0535225905,
-0.0637691095,
-0.1010342985,
0.0134414518,
0.0319680832,
-0.0125873452,
-0.0154020134,
0.0048574437,
-0.0274127927,
0.0133113721,
-0.0029802497,
0.0298130941,
0.0160530321,
0.0197260417,
0.0148308501,
0.0049028639,
-0.0217823591,
0.0339974575,
0.0032230739,
-0.016437687,
0.0578161068,
0.0060867947,
0.0220557991,
-0.0338579677,
0.0116469571,
-0.1228480488,
-0.0014830994,
-0.0340676568,
-0.048486609,
0.0547106117,
-0.0131276334,
0.053806439,
0.0518530421,
0.0364464521,
-0.0231425148,
0.058344584,
-0.072244212,
-0.0135109657,
0.0325685702,
-0.0019779003,
0.0272171851,
0.002661858,
-0.0108686145,
-0.0368463732,
0.0525236838,
-0.0124477306,
0.0096289618,
-0.0749155879,
0.0824290738,
0.0300192647,
-0.012058516,
-0.0097500319,
-0.0266993362,
-0.0054232762,
0.0377264023,
-0.0121565936,
0.0033070117,
0.0782845542,
0.0150529332,
-0.0059999069,
-0.0585116595,
0.0407640971,
-0.038714651,
0.0966700688,
-0.0299699232,
0.0340774283,
0.0024428507,
0.0284803901,
-0.0670090914,
-0.0067167873,
0.025463881,
-0.0540523082,
0.0602507293,
-0.0316061489,
-0.0199947618,
-0.0149005568,
-0.0470086262,
-0.0453194007,
0.0270502158,
-0.0462106727,
-0.0339753777,
0.0134053072,
-0.0065987003,
-0.0421030447,
-0.0366421416,
0.0356333479,
-0.0255208444,
-0.0120449224,
-0.0146388412,
0.014993188,
0.0131116379,
0.0706506148,
0.0046000304,
0.0100557366,
0.0024809479,
0.032238882,
0.0358056799,
-0.0463409089,
-0.055433169,
-0.0074803238,
0.0283154529,
-0.0014124456,
0.0192276239,
-0.0218894295,
0.0082335845,
0.0567273311,
-0.013795875,
-0.0413667522,
0.0417017639,
0.0154883647,
0.0196951013,
0.0330621637,
-0.0180178341,
0.0085690646,
0.0238864236,
0.0248690546,
-0.0880877078,
-0.0314243734,
-0.013206359,
-0.0680018812,
-0.0207343325,
-0.047954049,
-0.0392899178,
-0.147359103,
0.029214859,
0.0336174145,
-0.0218383819,
-0.013310302,
0.0212032627,
-0.0239018593,
0.0343785584,
-0.0527162775,
0.0191405546,
-0.002864274,
0.023354996,
-0.0054192794,
0.0478706025,
0.0060282359,
0.0143238921,
-0.0262061208,
0.0763123706,
0.0321757309,
0.0141891846,
0.0190433376,
-0.0720984191,
-0.0056929486,
-0.0463634394,
0.0135946432,
-0.021788273,
0.0260909293,
0.0126701184,
0.0010291386,
-0.0265051071,
0.0037146318,
-0.0029484129,
-0.0357511826,
0.0034103142,
0.087752074,
-0.0177620891,
-0.0505794361,
-0.0633941665,
0.0419824086,
-0.0272118896,
0.0390789062,
-0.0029560791,
-0.0626182556,
-0.0205643568,
-0.0232040994,
-0.0550498627,
-0.0674509406,
-0.0380984582,
-0.0259344596,
0.0596098565,
0.0083678514,
-0.0974564329,
-0.0110787107,
-0.0071750069,
0.0456061065,
-0.0199810304,
0.0238412078,
-0.0646942109,
0.0293451529,
0.0047431733,
-0.0058433944,
-0.0109828496,
0.0084482422,
-0.0254737698,
0.0161822941,
0.0002433133,
-0.0954345837,
-0.0115056382,
0.0531603433,
-0.0956542715,
-0.0654815286,
-0.0110887382,
0.054065831,
0.0280430652,
-0.015644813,
0.0294999257,
-0.0807278156,
0.0277022123,
0.0841141492,
0.0310353097,
0.0373486765,
-0.0086304704,
0.0709464476,
0.0431928001,
0.008412458,
-0.0150520159,
0.038873218,
0.0352470092,
0.0662687272,
-0.0154332127,
-0.0029330747,
0.0099090897,
-0.0112333652,
-0.0055977013,
-0.0373520814,
-0.0296035353,
-0.0161407273,
0.0194168631,
-0.0178109072,
-0.0138295861,
-0.0510123745,
-0.0150651503,
0.0300098471,
-0.0124149919,
-0.0009522475,
-0.0479493812,
0.002791292,
0.023712242,
-0.0071962797,
-0.0089225238,
0.0344108157,
0.0018815376,
0.0134189902,
0.0252842549,
-0.0089949826,
-0.0001147947,
-0.0247549135,
0.0296897907,
0.0021370924,
0.1006941348,
0.0213406086,
-0.0526722074,
-0.0095216995,
0.0373605266,
-0.0139866211,
-0.030004777,
0.049718231,
0.0180444364,
0.0842645392,
0.0145336445,
0.0276619028,
-0.0435984731,
0.0236498788,
0.0112191383,
0.0171873569,
-0.0148099288,
-0.0793744177,
0.0013553344,
0.0092936149,
0.0263085794,
-0.0368650444,
0.0551644452,
-0.078134954,
0.017107645,
0.0165780429,
0.0136510655,
-0.0251242854,
-0.0192269031,
-0.0109351976,
0.0280519519,
0.0025034316,
0.04782838,
-0.0692251623,
-0.0500416383,
-0.0001100459,
0.0058510853,
0.0297632143,
-0.0050027347,
0.042425666,
0.0492971763,
-0.001398946,
0.0019841813,
-0.0179055985,
0.0170700829,
-0.0443093292,
-0.0164203066,
-0.0309363976,
-6.147128689e-33,
-0.0090165893,
-0.006924856,
0.0442569032,
-0.006833849,
-0.0144953104,
-0.040348988,
-0.0480052456,
0.0441852063,
-0.0124703534,
0.0097268084,
-0.0173736308,
-0.0303399395,
-0.0224551018,
-0.0065038255,
0.0218004715,
-0.0142293479,
-0.0002846245,
0.0054305266,
-0.0423502401,
-0.0105562629,
0.0488815457,
-0.0007813651,
0.0250711832,
-0.0494898558,
-0.0417990685,
0.0016178916,
-0.0427755378,
0.0031803688,
0.0082752649,
0.0656025037,
0.0050317203,
0.0208570287,
0.0306232106,
0.0141991936,
0.0024274092,
-0.0035225425,
-0.0125438413,
-0.0473816693,
0.0130504863,
-0.042661339,
-0.0302877352,
-0.0402740054,
0.0261921696,
0.0079053361,
-0.0476862602,
-0.0336222984,
0.0271700304,
-0.0359708145,
0.010499821,
-0.0036045241,
-0.0672131181,
-0.0125679644,
-0.0130451368,
-0.0634575337,
-0.0239738449,
0.0046432004,
0.0001455083,
-0.019647114,
-0.0334050618,
0.0846581683,
-0.0164788328,
-0.0213376526,
0.0356914923,
-0.0123132495,
0.0053932266,
0.0555764586,
-0.0029154494,
0.0315000527,
-0.0618468933,
0.0136381164,
0.0225534998,
0.0547853,
0.0659675002,
0.0489279218,
0.0758549422,
-0.0058961036,
-0.0646202266,
0.0017284171,
0.0367956944,
0.0141522558,
0.0538270213,
0.0197557155,
-0.0285363384,
0.0083157551,
0.0284160748,
0.0263449773,
-0.0147254178,
-0.0542773679,
0.010585431,
0.0301395711,
-0.0188095327,
-0.0305012967,
0.0546207316,
-0.0354980007,
-0.0132545419,
-0.0000747676,
-0.0407527499,
0.0467345677,
-0.0058990563,
-0.0086800745,
-0.0482154787,
-0.0238477793,
0.0554361679,
0.0538466871,
0.011987119,
0.0422233455,
0.0447661802,
0.0182274748,
-0.0387446024,
0.0150442692,
-0.0432675444,
0.0420746207,
-0.0140880561,
-0.029944554,
-0.0131752072,
0.0023620962,
-0.0239342954,
-0.0355358422,
0.0263050105,
-0.0082051354,
-0.0412969552,
0.0052266871,
-0.0241763014,
-0.0050180755,
-0.0304719228,
0.0199683607,
-0.0497418866,
-0.0435343198,
-0.0037729209,
-0.0789323971,
-0.0400015451,
0.0333872475,
2.991e-7,
-0.0060686585,
0.0678587183,
-0.0189323947,
0.0600791611,
0.0388933718,
0.0306884088,
-0.0322005562,
0.0157204438,
0.0722854063,
-0.0057892664,
0.0057416107,
0.0501457117,
0.004798973,
0.0116239693,
-0.0880752206,
0.024395626,
-0.0565548837,
0.0336227864,
-0.0546326302,
-0.0282551162,
0.0477482006,
0.0268417317,
0.017111415,
-0.030528523,
0.0097128265,
-0.0430965535,
0.0645629168,
-0.0043928628,
0.0291584246,
-0.0212734863,
-0.027697159,
-0.0019454436,
-0.0078607332,
-0.0009255883,
0.0008262469,
0.0052620377,
0.0090907644,
-0.010822624,
-0.0209385175,
0.0303170104,
0.0299067888,
-0.0110973194,
-0.0056417836,
-0.0764661282,
0.0798212662,
-0.0257216487,
-0.0328349248,
0.0000678317,
-0.002280226,
-0.0166708753,
0.0485328063,
-0.0355882347,
-0.0312534533,
-0.0098079834,
0.0362821631,
0.0324315317,
0.0164104383,
-0.0415900946,
-0.0304712895,
-0.014375302,
-0.0433237925,
-0.0304062385,
-0.0475977436,
-0.0029834553,
0.0285735819,
-0.0681328624,
-0.0042035966,
2.613757148e-34,
0.0095046042,
-0.0290432889,
0.0313335843,
-0.0221360922,
0.0540107824,
0.0015417975,
0.0249929577,
0.0052232132,
0.0385693572,
-0.0466981195,
-0.0336427018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02436v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02436v3 | MUFFIN: Curating Multi-Faceted Instructions for Improving Instruction-Following | 2023-12-05T02:32:08 | 2024-03-15T03:11:44 | Renze Lou, Kai Zhang, Jian Xie, Yuxuan Sun, Janice Ahn, Hanzi Xu, Yu Su, Wenpeng Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the realm of large language models (LLMs), enhancing instruction-following
capability often involves curating expansive training data. This is achieved
through two primary schemes: i) Scaling-Inputs: Amplifying (input, output)
pairs per task instruction, aiming for better instruction adherence. ii)
Scaling Input-Free Tasks: Enlarging tasks, each composed of an (instruction,
output) pair (without requiring a separate input anymore). However, LLMs under
Scaling-Inputs tend to be overly sensitive to inputs, leading to
misinterpretation or non-compliance with instructions. Conversely, Scaling
Input-Free Tasks demands a substantial number of tasks but is less effective in
instruction following when dealing with instances in Scaling-Inputs. This work
introduces MUFFIN, a new scheme of instruction-following dataset curation.
Specifically, we automatically Scale Tasks per Input by diversifying these
tasks with various input facets. Experimental results across four zero-shot
benchmarks, spanning both Scaling-Inputs and Scaling Input-Free Tasks schemes,
reveal that LLMs, at various scales, trained on MUFFIN generally demonstrate
superior instruction-following capabilities compared to those trained on the
two aforementioned schemes. | [
0.0136191631,
0.0248194169,
-0.009091083,
0.0151700862,
-0.0097005758,
0.0270553194,
0.0126802325,
-0.0164491348,
-0.0157916117,
-0.0429533049,
-0.0484411418,
-0.0092643499,
-0.0176663864,
-0.0052080294,
0.0302957613,
-0.0500348993,
0.0577045344,
-0.065909408,
-0.0662593991,
0.016885832,
-0.0076340814,
0.0175430197,
0.0026365786,
0.0345417373,
0.0286015514,
-0.0087808128,
-0.014372333,
0.0192356128,
-0.0135180065,
-0.0118801538,
0.0062875026,
0.0448193327,
0.0480765775,
-0.0019847215,
0.000001998,
-0.0386369787,
0.0272250418,
-0.0255217627,
-0.0430560932,
0.0386632048,
0.0261172708,
-0.0430179909,
-0.0219441447,
0.0300146528,
0.0051386845,
-0.0146768913,
0.0316413045,
0.0444892496,
0.0664160252,
0.0753664747,
0.0153957857,
-0.0251542944,
0.0364148021,
-0.0336117558,
0.010179189,
-0.0129623236,
0.0128912982,
-0.0148643581,
0.0044991341,
0.0705913603,
-0.0216241237,
0.0201992448,
0.0431926176,
-0.0163880233,
-0.0120313643,
0.0338435061,
-0.0184306055,
-0.0351725072,
-0.016407622,
0.0721799135,
-0.0191726014,
-0.0014800068,
-0.0227889977,
-0.0362208225,
-0.0097040702,
-0.0093640871,
-0.0652819872,
0.0163168181,
0.0158461332,
0.018845601,
0.0052604922,
-0.0282616578,
0.0192549285,
-0.0024290294,
-0.0358139984,
0.0312904827,
-0.0016656991,
-0.0482168794,
-0.0023548328,
-0.0044370829,
-0.0428875089,
-0.0462112911,
-0.0003042694,
0.0443030074,
-0.046518296,
0.0172008779,
-0.0568411909,
-0.0233978275,
0.0275147595,
-0.0115515543,
0.0929119512,
0.0434124582,
-0.0385594741,
0.0389449932,
-0.0089769671,
0.077135928,
-0.0348127075,
0.0409344211,
-0.059113007,
0.0338192806,
-0.0578076802,
0.0080619697,
-0.0182872992,
0.021139903,
-0.0316549875,
-0.0088758515,
-0.0258489568,
0.0328593925,
-0.0122101074,
0.0129269361,
0.0596169457,
-0.0364183448,
-0.0492826104,
-0.0067639672,
0.0231600162,
0.0591045022,
-0.0423774049,
0.0256601311,
0.018058084,
-0.037645001,
-0.0144918263,
0.0078185918,
-0.0116479993,
-0.0445761122,
0.0276479702,
0.0615871102,
-0.0018840599,
-0.0349941924,
-0.0528490357,
-0.0117498012,
-0.0002211294,
-0.0485534333,
-0.0055554807,
-0.0482402444,
0.0305113308,
-0.0195545722,
0.0108249765,
0.0047386512,
0.0050357562,
0.0279330127,
-0.0351710431,
0.0365550965,
0.042717725,
0.0157497898,
-0.0114186965,
0.0067895949,
0.0006489453,
0.0544892736,
0.0191996079,
-0.0110925883,
0.0195865147,
-0.0245984904,
-0.0077257622,
0.0520938374,
0.0386939235,
0.0336304866,
0.0079360446,
0.0024568362,
0.0127731711,
0.0096099116,
0.0700733587,
0.0550693497,
-0.0280757528,
-0.004211491,
0.0739126354,
0.0317904353,
-0.0046840729,
-0.0261354614,
0.0798649192,
0.0257426538,
-0.0156214172,
0.0578326285,
-0.0969214961,
0.0152472574,
0.0089814411,
0.0142548783,
0.018957695,
0.0536087416,
-0.0555814579,
-0.0297479518,
0.0001941357,
0.0024517709,
-0.0116456151,
0.019587338,
0.0448740311,
0.0222400576,
-0.0377023853,
0.0140843363,
0.0354351215,
-0.0400480777,
0.008563539,
-0.0508695766,
0.0033098042,
0.0646558627,
0.0244658496,
0.0001875751,
-0.0401695222,
-0.0024807784,
0.0716186091,
0.0153663075,
0.0263629537,
-0.0147544965,
0.0396852419,
-0.0736245587,
-0.0304729156,
-0.0040315492,
0.006759177,
-0.0122914445,
0.0184282344,
-0.0349404737,
0.0037570675,
-0.0049168365,
-0.0390859023,
0.0497883558,
-0.0358233377,
-0.0525802486,
-0.0092240544,
-0.0052926745,
0.0338604152,
0.0032616062,
-0.0070063067,
0.0003745,
0.0338022634,
-0.0176078565,
0.0319805108,
-0.0080950484,
-0.0851179883,
-0.0346617848,
0.0022417833,
0.0327548645,
-0.0199681967,
0.0167382304,
-0.0525559299,
-0.0412657745,
-0.0192244835,
-0.0171079393,
0.0076055531,
-0.0075601125,
0.0469514094,
0.0057220482,
-0.0130797802,
-0.0594837405,
0.0247045066,
-0.0457921401,
0.0171565115,
0.0417630374,
0.0088507356,
-0.0275469758,
-0.0314750932,
-0.0182345062,
0.0108590527,
-0.001321746,
0.0095471749,
-0.0075772423,
0.0253109857,
-0.0258807968,
-0.0339190066,
-0.0619997233,
0.0175772253,
-0.0307982285,
0.0270939022,
0.0511205979,
0.0282360911,
0.0096667111,
-0.0163107924,
0.0109058749,
-0.0255647115,
-0.0022384846,
0.0491679013,
0.0095109725,
0.0233536847,
-0.0328803845,
-0.0335706174,
-0.0294294935,
-0.0136121102,
-0.0159652811,
-0.0151553107,
0.0486658961,
-0.0654581264,
0.0441519283,
0.0128995525,
0.0291308854,
-0.019831514,
-0.028375132,
0.0180562567,
-0.0113608437,
0.0657484606,
0.0905153751,
-0.0320807248,
0.0054396158,
0.0472197644,
0.0026298251,
-0.0683129877,
0.0118798204,
-0.0270639434,
-0.0457004495,
-0.0391551368,
-0.0347084478,
0.0093386676,
0.0927821174,
-3.268e-7,
0.0077960189,
-0.0605201535,
-0.0359649658,
-0.0303737391,
-0.0287462249,
-0.0181478225,
-0.0167203695,
-0.0372603908,
-0.0007692148,
-0.0472672991,
-0.0824817047,
0.0561590344,
-0.0278036352,
-0.0318048932,
-0.0284722801,
0.0104619758,
-0.0194313601,
0.0450294614,
0.03755714,
-0.0106459679,
-0.0000232908,
-0.0386282057,
-0.0638311654,
0.0273548737,
0.0176240094,
0.0003462443,
0.0564639308,
-0.0691768974,
-0.0128597897,
-0.0233701784,
-0.0198554117,
-0.0139815481,
-0.0035460484,
0.0327527151,
0.015878709,
0.0275968723,
-0.0349469036,
-0.0138549218,
-0.0127123995,
0.0370797329,
0.0710535347,
-0.0297337994,
-0.0011863145,
-0.0448395908,
-0.0235183667,
0.023504559,
0.0066164909,
-0.0197201911,
-0.0720634311,
0.0073545142,
0.0325412862,
0.0713429376,
-0.0158049539,
-0.0103445128,
0.029152343,
0.0382338874,
-0.0133069102,
-0.0453626662,
0.0382715873,
0.1169064865,
-0.0693350062,
-0.0186395459,
0.1025914624,
0.030811049,
-0.0454785116,
0.0207695533,
0.0116075687,
0.0653227344,
0.0211111475,
0.0177505277,
-0.0601295903,
-0.0297125857,
0.0029775761,
0.0357719287,
0.0056008752,
-0.0109361084,
-0.0051776846,
-0.1179545447,
0.03387082,
0.0373021513,
-0.0235178433,
-0.0169200096,
-0.0569306575,
0.0123411827,
-0.023478128,
0.0466761366,
0.0233188774,
-0.0470013022,
-0.0160316285,
0.0445705652,
0.0149133103,
-0.0768596977,
0.0303214137,
-0.0511297993,
0.0734834597,
0.0663578883,
-0.0285558272,
0.0178838093,
0.0036579755,
0.0588126741,
-0.0064607221,
0.0149044907,
-0.0220379625,
0.0522817038,
-0.0220287759,
0.0020335456,
-0.0120715285,
0.0386106409,
-0.0237590764,
0.0167059004,
0.0238835402,
0.0876861885,
-0.015431134,
-0.0046752892,
-0.024861211,
-0.0344575047,
0.0013773374,
0.0567716025,
0.0431992561,
-0.0580648668,
-0.0138778305,
-0.0123994863,
-0.0619928241,
-0.0626195893,
-0.0221470632,
0.0371420495,
-0.0634808093,
-0.0145837376,
-0.0494317822,
-0.0828010514,
0.0636802092,
0.0157990884,
0.0173310321,
-0.0191389304,
0.0458819345,
-0.011657632,
-0.0052606505,
0.0191765148,
-0.01868953,
0.0233046319,
-0.0938901976,
-0.0524467789,
0.0178335495,
0.0259043016,
0.0058843307,
0.0022956284,
-0.1113811359,
-0.068751201,
-0.0068231858,
0.0578293875,
0.0173306148,
0.0635102689,
0.0183145441,
-0.0423583537,
0.0137995677,
-0.0010151116,
-0.0262162387,
0.0341241695,
0.04259656,
-0.038754981,
-0.0026809659,
0.0313171521,
-0.0081370939,
0.0626879185,
0.0049590729,
0.0433406234,
-0.0487208962,
-0.0001637823,
0.0240759496,
0.0027913204,
0.004674532,
-0.0116759604,
0.0212056004,
-0.03832075,
0.0243088566,
-0.0115413666,
0.0114854332,
-0.0521482863,
0.0239055194,
0.0216666274,
0.0044670715,
0.0082843006,
-0.0067287898,
-0.0098032998,
0.0181871206,
-0.0794091821,
0.034827061,
-0.0136941196,
0.0228508878,
0.0419926234,
0.0280497931,
-0.0160831138,
0.023954181,
0.0126886601,
0.0322164632,
-0.0168351363,
0.0728531778,
0.0137099847,
0.0239844918,
-0.0203302801,
0.0297491383,
-0.0585430339,
-0.0261544101,
-0.0266009849,
0.0026392462,
0.0239008255,
-0.0171041247,
0.0767834038,
0.0066049313,
0.0113896364,
-0.0312116034,
0.0446046889,
-0.0035920027,
-0.0248381086,
0.0084728338,
0.0533841997,
0.0139766792,
0.0061364686,
0.0697754696,
-0.0069945562,
0.0408566222,
0.0029597019,
0.0517253317,
-0.0294107459,
-0.0479836576,
0.0167287719,
0.0109095378,
-0.0319658853,
0.0254266597,
-0.0120363738,
-0.0470945314,
-0.0734695494,
0.0225524213,
0.0103976652,
-0.0567678213,
0.0354654193,
0.0211780556,
-0.0297378357,
-0.036108043,
-0.0342352539,
-0.0258962363,
0.0028457236,
-0.0065733339,
-0.0110853026,
-6.22417867e-33,
-0.0522622503,
0.0212471224,
0.0407126024,
-0.0080066118,
-0.0167453438,
0.0032864707,
-0.022795314,
-0.0084170457,
-0.0239110515,
-0.0002756312,
-0.00657344,
0.0205392521,
0.0076767104,
0.0239358973,
0.0663505122,
0.0135058593,
0.070767574,
-0.0340533555,
-0.0327632651,
0.0504051894,
0.03683744,
-0.0169972647,
0.0217337906,
-0.041512657,
0.0303581581,
-0.0074573415,
0.0004334,
0.0329818949,
-0.0256169029,
0.0800380558,
0.0182106923,
0.0252140798,
0.0254157763,
-0.0389438942,
-0.0694065467,
0.0123727787,
-0.0614440851,
-0.0270673689,
0.0251815096,
0.0052209022,
-0.0535384566,
-0.0137444735,
0.0266440324,
-0.0273038,
-0.0124292066,
-0.0342908725,
0.0178000648,
-0.0069261505,
-0.0332413539,
0.0575344488,
-0.0686461329,
0.0137094548,
0.0045735398,
-0.043032553,
0.0108418781,
0.05862749,
-0.0098393084,
-0.0119068734,
-0.0210305024,
0.0302330963,
0.0430813283,
0.067929782,
0.0558114685,
0.0339415483,
-0.0097398385,
0.0082669491,
0.0137365134,
0.0179241039,
0.0068098688,
0.0092241084,
0.0354317129,
0.0455316715,
0.0093734162,
-0.0158041548,
0.0233193189,
0.0094091659,
-0.0351174176,
-0.0028913042,
0.0567063801,
0.0471040085,
0.0076907189,
0.0087119248,
-0.0525049753,
-0.0371152014,
-0.0054717669,
0.0255466737,
-0.0202664491,
-0.0313192196,
0.0608255677,
0.0378362462,
-0.0140105551,
0.0107855322,
0.0526036285,
0.0005166095,
-0.0202286784,
0.0124851121,
-0.0183148216,
0.0301235653,
-0.0038090211,
0.0019692581,
-0.1016768217,
-0.0750444531,
0.0301517956,
-0.0248543881,
0.0296703335,
0.0283553749,
0.0430313796,
0.0210556053,
-0.0545455478,
-0.0333953723,
-0.0549556948,
0.0170273036,
-0.0044667693,
0.031949129,
0.0517812036,
0.0007621089,
-0.0124391997,
0.0724928826,
-0.0109522631,
-0.0609996952,
-0.0475165248,
-0.0077115735,
0.0025398587,
0.0399447791,
-0.0317018442,
-0.0039217751,
-0.0670235604,
-0.026385501,
0.0210064519,
-0.0462937616,
-0.0267721917,
0.0114970235,
2.639e-7,
-0.0083450545,
0.0258286037,
0.0199640039,
0.0503845476,
-0.0058759591,
0.0175311137,
-0.039664004,
0.0177927781,
0.0077692624,
-0.0028728815,
0.0186632555,
0.0456205606,
0.0253849961,
0.006831286,
-0.059890572,
-0.0244432352,
-0.0435983129,
0.0086099431,
-0.0536769256,
-0.0012046234,
0.0133327963,
0.0731022507,
-0.0034899679,
0.0005308839,
0.024233846,
-0.0042933095,
0.0217394195,
-0.0128645077,
0.019510841,
0.0275973491,
-0.032151483,
0.0179149546,
-0.0178963132,
0.0239045098,
-0.0250074342,
0.0110165579,
-0.0458886065,
0.1258629262,
-0.025416797,
0.0260678735,
0.0117546506,
-0.0126299765,
-0.0266303699,
-0.0362444147,
0.0332886204,
-0.054323677,
-0.0093034869,
-0.0167831387,
0.0023851499,
-0.0292419419,
-0.030116396,
0.0047374815,
0.0023333551,
0.0211129896,
0.0465717763,
-0.0207116771,
-0.0169119425,
-0.0683130845,
-0.0038443955,
0.0325036943,
-0.0419040322,
-0.0720602572,
-0.0523762442,
0.0018099268,
0.0085658859,
-0.0474065505,
-0.0458721705,
2.761968848e-34,
0.0273898263,
-0.0302330963,
0.081508778,
0.0368822329,
-0.0193749964,
-0.0173477735,
-0.0705850571,
0.0309237596,
0.0276647955,
-0.0848191381,
-0.0418047085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02431v1 | Visually Grounded Language Learning: a review of language games, datasets, tasks, and models | 2023-12-05T02:17:29 | 2023-12-05T02:17:29 | Alessandro Suglia, Ioannis Konstas, Oliver Lemon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, several machine learning models have been proposed. They are
trained with a language modelling objective on large-scale text-only data. With
such pretraining, they can achieve impressive results on many Natural Language
Understanding and Generation tasks. However, many facets of meaning cannot be
learned by ``listening to the radio" only. In the literature, many
Vision+Language (V+L) tasks have been defined with the aim of creating models
that can ground symbols in the visual modality. In this work, we provide a
systematic literature review of several tasks and models proposed in the V+L
field. We rely on Wittgenstein's idea of `language games' to categorise such
tasks into 3 different families: 1) discriminative games, 2) generative games,
and 3) interactive games. Our analysis of the literature provides evidence that
future work should be focusing on interactive games where communication in
Natural Language is important to resolve ambiguities about object referents and
action plans and that physical embodiment is essential to understand the
semantics of situations and events. Overall, these represent key requirements
for developing grounded meanings in neural models. | [
0.0386252515,
0.0167231355,
-0.0303775296,
0.0416287743,
-0.0340205617,
0.0203731358,
-0.0224271193,
-0.0113715557,
-0.0089622661,
-0.0607270561,
-0.0296816267,
-0.0226959083,
0.0352185741,
0.0523843244,
0.0249877572,
-0.0553531311,
0.0010768239,
7.412e-7,
-0.0116250124,
0.0052191797,
-0.0228667799,
0.0159188472,
-0.0054969355,
0.0469094887,
-0.0520443097,
0.0263579618,
-0.0184237584,
0.0019054816,
0.0218904614,
-0.0285842307,
-0.0356990658,
0.0186234936,
0.0982393101,
0.0160888489,
0.0000019399,
-0.0217084512,
0.0257270448,
-0.0350687131,
-0.000268243,
-0.0619538277,
0.0177626889,
-0.0548500828,
0.0148518933,
-0.0078158928,
-0.0596644022,
-0.0400411896,
0.084666796,
0.0599541888,
0.056693323,
0.0270473789,
-0.0159567334,
-0.0015686189,
0.0209626127,
-0.0142729292,
0.0337374173,
-0.0028581284,
0.0134181892,
0.0547354296,
-0.0243795216,
0.0157423392,
-0.0555231683,
0.0190283321,
0.0408118218,
-0.0115553457,
0.0104823243,
0.078865312,
-0.0217498802,
-0.0216396488,
-0.0185633022,
0.0898887441,
-0.0355730578,
-0.0466303974,
-0.0107077993,
-0.0218080897,
-0.0036949017,
-0.0151431132,
-0.0278460067,
0.0661682785,
0.0294633154,
0.0608822517,
-0.014919606,
0.0043704845,
0.013573383,
0.0165702626,
0.0316528268,
0.0075116381,
-0.0056855013,
0.0327365771,
0.0295414403,
0.0518017337,
-0.0437854715,
-0.0688173324,
-0.0378466472,
0.0271457229,
0.0187621247,
0.029134389,
-0.0448141322,
0.0098183723,
-0.0193490926,
-0.0523613878,
0.0473692529,
0.0228323005,
-0.0307376795,
0.0378678441,
-0.0195821319,
0.0283384975,
-0.0085833361,
0.0231053289,
-0.022620922,
0.0168518368,
-0.0122668277,
-0.0293714833,
-0.0534725115,
0.0158009026,
-0.0826709867,
-0.0452152975,
-0.0201477222,
0.0265835449,
-0.0135987988,
0.0144920386,
-0.0050612842,
0.035611093,
-0.0525169969,
0.0128687117,
-0.0162862297,
0.0137886414,
-0.0116058616,
0.0556520224,
-0.035571523,
-0.078516908,
-0.0057783686,
0.0259028282,
0.0261045005,
-0.0260493588,
-0.0124047874,
0.0617938824,
-0.008656472,
-0.0546744503,
-0.0391808152,
-0.01928089,
-0.0073780096,
-0.0610997602,
0.0375788212,
-0.0374448486,
0.010484023,
-0.0377957933,
0.0121061606,
-0.0661910102,
0.0236271452,
0.0109632388,
0.0218945052,
0.1115709543,
0.0006374574,
-0.0365956202,
-0.0056184987,
0.0281419959,
0.0251750536,
0.0722207204,
0.0394200869,
0.0349194296,
-0.0028287689,
-0.013849183,
0.0033029623,
0.0111179305,
0.0401277095,
0.023612339,
-0.0603112467,
-0.0267088972,
-0.0154482918,
0.030962225,
-0.0053831688,
0.0242203418,
-0.060002517,
-0.0241855439,
0.0866190568,
0.0730054751,
-0.0093745971,
-0.0012373156,
0.0470696427,
-0.0032523386,
-0.0175576434,
0.0203828271,
-0.0424685888,
0.0427216217,
-0.0510385484,
-0.0177050661,
-0.0895177424,
-0.0047648679,
-0.0469064638,
-0.0423848405,
-0.0062679946,
-0.0329479016,
0.0732944682,
-0.0032137628,
0.0543185584,
0.0139261829,
-0.0447721444,
0.0204466563,
0.0263828002,
-0.0488322973,
0.0161168221,
-0.0250719003,
0.0094653107,
0.020167524,
0.0168122817,
-0.0114902286,
-0.0141088739,
-0.0255931057,
0.0570921786,
0.0754572973,
-0.0069992375,
-0.0139342211,
0.0366184413,
-0.0308996625,
-0.0389611013,
-0.0547511876,
0.0073085381,
0.0329952464,
-0.0304346345,
-0.0004933064,
0.0048011499,
-0.0310754627,
0.0034611342,
0.0609356351,
0.0158822462,
-0.0338163041,
-0.0323156603,
0.0341290049,
0.0121409837,
-0.020818416,
-0.0215514507,
-0.0064445338,
0.0438184552,
-0.0458749682,
0.0299366713,
0.0618150569,
-0.0281620622,
0.0000907383,
0.024773065,
-0.0677249208,
0.0024271393,
0.0057662437,
-0.0090729361,
-0.0043480084,
0.0345886163,
-0.0401006453,
0.0264241658,
-0.0509026535,
-0.0201613326,
-0.001366051,
0.0157686863,
-0.025535373,
0.0736495033,
-0.0178320669,
-0.0101930089,
-0.0208071936,
-0.0132029522,
0.015165586,
-0.0419210792,
-0.0060064192,
0.0315738283,
0.020154966,
0.0124192033,
0.0172668174,
0.0275718234,
-0.0454072431,
-0.005054438,
-0.0699687526,
-0.0437699556,
-0.0239432529,
-0.0319032073,
0.01205773,
-0.0353697538,
0.0031836219,
-0.0170241334,
-0.0326837637,
0.0509377867,
0.0285523497,
-0.0138342725,
0.0547667183,
0.0188920572,
-0.0231300164,
0.0107956585,
-0.0159544181,
0.0068303496,
0.0756615996,
0.0490917638,
-0.0105516398,
-0.0573694035,
0.022695994,
-0.02888944,
0.0320530348,
-0.0271138102,
-0.0081643499,
0.0166763104,
0.0269298926,
0.0408741646,
0.1057536379,
-0.0014153207,
0.1124176085,
0.0439588092,
-0.0097559197,
-0.0328851677,
-0.0063933996,
-0.0095612053,
-0.0108254878,
-0.0365817584,
-0.0153856073,
0.007925245,
0.042361699,
-0.0299620181,
-0.0005255854,
-0.0951965377,
0.053296037,
0.0002295541,
-0.0499113351,
-0.074129656,
-0.0245430488,
-0.0116448756,
0.0547710992,
-0.046485275,
-0.0671457648,
0.0356276035,
-0.030919468,
-0.0111047514,
-0.0064845793,
0.0031033074,
-0.0153699405,
0.1148408279,
0.0201970972,
0.0115755945,
-0.0114430711,
-0.0140661802,
-0.0770190954,
-0.0413746871,
0.0060671512,
-0.0034511476,
0.0552588105,
-0.0505905151,
0.0273015499,
-0.0255698301,
0.0021307848,
-0.0565950274,
-0.0020322625,
-0.0382122733,
-0.0093807233,
-0.0674919784,
0.0312525332,
-0.0245588496,
0.0193799473,
0.0071764854,
-0.0148370657,
0.0077162911,
-0.0053603123,
-0.0347557701,
0.0193931386,
0.080198437,
0.0105692577,
-0.0122378329,
-0.0237163827,
-0.0121743446,
0.0254216548,
-0.0160517227,
-0.0101492703,
-0.0457980074,
0.0554999188,
0.0396786518,
0.0164380465,
-0.0272180848,
0.0272588693,
0.0425872877,
-0.0226805247,
-0.0369602032,
0.0598538406,
0.025761487,
-0.0035807532,
0.0288321394,
0.0052809538,
0.0255575459,
0.0215915106,
0.0038704074,
-0.0887153372,
-0.0213403944,
-0.0144138243,
-0.0337856486,
0.0334136821,
-0.0342901051,
-0.0373010822,
-0.0973508209,
0.0403253287,
0.0182448234,
-0.030779643,
-0.0535999797,
0.02714012,
-0.0146992132,
-0.0041087498,
-0.0021231628,
-0.0317227468,
0.0074144653,
-0.0066929469,
0.019261485,
0.0921552628,
-0.0378736332,
0.0049981638,
-0.0509379581,
0.0019193189,
0.0263047814,
0.0450403281,
-0.0082516037,
-0.0747003704,
0.0091833891,
0.006163171,
-0.005082042,
-0.0129472865,
0.0354511999,
-0.024077002,
-0.0275106654,
0.0360349193,
0.0529827587,
0.0039778054,
-0.0309563316,
-0.0403931886,
0.0420175977,
-0.0274635088,
-0.0017375996,
0.0141778691,
0.0191790052,
0.0264632199,
0.0344889201,
0.0413958989,
-0.0482988432,
-0.0203888454,
-0.0075867386,
0.0346841365,
-0.0461808629,
-0.0744679496,
-0.0254467577,
0.0128180301,
-0.0016506689,
-0.076110661,
-0.025773868,
0.0477066375,
0.0722527131,
0.0103218099,
-0.0161630847,
0.003366919,
0.0136269759,
-0.0630014911,
0.0746664703,
-0.0263806712,
0.0293341763,
0.0110962009,
-0.026003819,
0.0185020957,
-0.094576478,
-0.0235548466,
0.0168581996,
-0.0712573305,
-0.0539946258,
-0.0188946947,
0.0659349039,
0.0196268205,
0.0561098345,
0.0105329603,
-0.0280834958,
0.0133288708,
0.027234301,
-0.0007653068,
0.0275414884,
-0.0049862587,
-0.0228930432,
-0.0100370897,
0.0249617808,
-0.019703526,
0.0311368667,
0.0413057469,
0.0158321299,
0.0160834081,
-0.012517889,
0.0384802632,
-0.0436368212,
0.0484248437,
-0.0227446631,
-0.0170510523,
-0.0495516248,
-0.0087385811,
-0.0058932714,
-0.0127363894,
-0.0758564845,
-0.0109888669,
0.0055802255,
0.035857141,
0.0034844752,
-0.0297950804,
-0.0004038823,
0.0713419244,
0.0124980276,
-0.0190480165,
0.0410734788,
-0.006502565,
-0.0452980064,
0.0424698442,
0.0093550412,
0.0171851292,
-0.0531319268,
0.0475485995,
0.019857401,
0.0338550732,
0.0310790353,
-0.0295267887,
-0.0218612179,
0.0308417659,
-0.0033616831,
-0.0031298255,
-0.0137905795,
0.0542915389,
0.0706610307,
-0.0267540477,
0.0068820817,
-0.049380172,
-0.0117825018,
0.0234631244,
0.0191267226,
-0.001480284,
-0.0724741742,
0.0640411526,
0.0336894765,
-0.0179673545,
-0.0258270502,
0.0415542386,
0.0390602425,
0.0437926762,
0.0050753271,
-0.00073746,
-0.0376925915,
-0.0089693815,
0.042399507,
0.0102726994,
-0.0035247549,
0.071782507,
-0.0636251643,
-0.0834020823,
0.0056398544,
0.0390287749,
0.0113015678,
0.0220429245,
0.0812308863,
0.0289869681,
0.0202272031,
0.011696199,
-0.0229958706,
0.0127574457,
0.007121406,
-0.0048871087,
-0.0172233321,
-5.76342566e-33,
-0.0529356152,
-0.0636709556,
0.0405112989,
-0.0034738216,
-0.0407014266,
0.0559512116,
-0.0146999545,
0.0040244153,
-0.0104921255,
0.0254709087,
0.0441915169,
0.0013291369,
-0.0030917118,
0.0143176876,
-0.0421147272,
-0.0328671783,
0.0149459373,
-0.0063880449,
-0.023905402,
0.0083225807,
0.0058616642,
-0.0172140729,
0.0721634552,
-0.0398738831,
-0.0139317056,
0.0351520553,
-0.0403211266,
0.0361452885,
0.0105696898,
0.050183624,
-0.0233940072,
0.0163536984,
0.0099094575,
0.0246654097,
-0.0050532441,
0.0445067696,
-0.0761606842,
-0.0200589728,
0.0386746675,
0.0521565452,
-0.0955449194,
0.0286870953,
0.0268209539,
-0.05535537,
-0.0113704996,
0.0031753811,
0.0267247967,
-0.0381201617,
-0.0218082964,
0.0187433679,
-0.0601632707,
-0.0200155452,
-0.0176731907,
-0.0395782255,
0.0322278142,
0.0029532544,
0.0276170615,
0.0180461556,
-0.0470539108,
0.0499929562,
-0.0268980488,
0.0058963667,
0.0610079914,
0.0238744393,
0.0479532965,
0.0858151093,
-0.0050325673,
-0.0506530367,
-0.063287124,
-0.0216704533,
0.0447221138,
0.0264492109,
0.0520159788,
0.0244871844,
-0.0173686389,
0.0126597015,
-0.0656819567,
0.0022905716,
-0.012787791,
0.0491945669,
0.0181104448,
0.0148580857,
-0.001084117,
-0.0006949363,
-0.0530519001,
-0.0206466131,
-0.0034733454,
-0.0286776051,
0.0286875702,
0.0362117477,
-0.0372251682,
0.0257704165,
0.0531725325,
-0.0472306684,
-0.0096095707,
0.0439952128,
0.0030046871,
0.0478340723,
0.0118269445,
-0.0125448154,
-0.0135501372,
-0.0313069262,
0.0530859828,
-0.0123156952,
0.0062418408,
-0.0069989972,
0.0392562896,
0.0189460963,
-0.0056862771,
0.0198697932,
-0.0453400537,
0.0057058865,
0.0247522686,
0.0381282941,
0.0592993647,
0.0105183283,
-0.0539734028,
0.0084181773,
0.0448202342,
-0.048875425,
0.0090150386,
-0.0098876655,
-0.0377074778,
0.0516791642,
-0.0388869494,
-0.008544663,
-0.0342974998,
0.012348921,
0.052773159,
-0.0724416003,
-0.0228179507,
-0.0192414336,
2.743e-7,
0.0201049224,
0.0166384261,
0.0333550423,
0.0258316193,
-0.0013281652,
0.0226381421,
-0.025883222,
0.0321985148,
-0.0097067384,
-0.0584908761,
0.0185822081,
0.0318769477,
0.0085906126,
-0.0246370155,
-0.024971433,
0.0747754574,
-0.0213763751,
0.0063275807,
-0.029977534,
-0.0210043583,
0.0236615613,
0.0750445351,
0.004651037,
0.0017137234,
0.0261066426,
-0.023790434,
0.0647743717,
-0.0625037923,
0.0280284584,
-0.0361015573,
-0.005610148,
0.005101487,
-0.0368499309,
0.0132826399,
0.0018480073,
0.0087270774,
0.0466552377,
0.0054149879,
-0.0334180258,
-0.0010930565,
-0.0505528972,
0.0197870526,
-0.028560929,
-0.0258256365,
0.0644375905,
-0.0914086103,
-0.0590776764,
-0.0218947083,
-0.0086776093,
-0.0183680952,
0.0423040427,
-0.0036240234,
-0.043115709,
0.0057158968,
0.0279186945,
-0.0080154082,
-0.0035091734,
-0.0474494621,
-0.0157461502,
-0.0062603327,
-0.0106853638,
-0.0006903335,
-0.0296347532,
-0.0026650787,
0.0125124874,
-0.0226404835,
-0.0491948761,
2.21152043e-34,
0.0038950611,
-0.0104471715,
0.0070572295,
-0.0010847581,
0.0076153264,
0.0101004569,
-0.0076329284,
0.0081971493,
0.0387855321,
-0.0039024756,
-0.0185868908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03016v1 | Protein Language Model-Powered 3D Ligand Binding Site Prediction from Protein Sequence | 2023-12-05T01:47:38 | 2023-12-05T01:47:38 | Shuo Zhang, Lei Xie | q-bio.QM | q-bio.QM, cs.CL, cs.LG | Prediction of ligand binding sites of proteins is a fundamental and important
task for understanding the function of proteins and screening potential drugs.
Most existing methods require experimentally determined protein holo-structures
as input. However, such structures can be unavailable on novel or less-studied
proteins. To tackle this limitation, we propose LaMPSite, which only takes
protein sequences and ligand molecular graphs as input for ligand binding site
predictions. The protein sequences are used to retrieve residue-level
embeddings and contact maps from the pre-trained ESM-2 protein language model.
The ligand molecular graphs are fed into a graph neural network to compute
atom-level embeddings. Then we compute and update the protein-ligand
interaction embedding based on the protein residue-level embeddings and ligand
atom-level embeddings, and the geometric constraints in the inferred protein
contact map and ligand distance map. A final pooling on protein-ligand
interaction embedding would indicate which residues belong to the binding
sites. Without any 3D coordinate information of proteins, our proposed model
achieves competitive performance compared to baseline methods that require 3D
protein structures when predicting binding sites. Given that less than 50% of
proteins have reliable structure information in the current stage, LaMPSite
will provide new opportunities for drug discovery. | [
0.0460095666,
0.008949873,
0.0172852706,
0.0145237977,
-0.0005155666,
-0.0156370234,
0.00749797,
0.0122508286,
0.1074549481,
0.0144434255,
-0.0230867956,
-0.0234524347,
0.0140587576,
0.0394255482,
0.0290393494,
0.0382570513,
-0.0000980215,
0.0173646938,
-0.0179339498,
-0.0365942344,
-0.0071610045,
0.0300219301,
0.0470409989,
0.0054684333,
0.0103519689,
0.0090164049,
-0.0346859992,
0.0327421091,
-0.0006080357,
-0.0539135933,
-0.0288480166,
0.0400651172,
0.0271397512,
0.0182168409,
0.0000017216,
-0.0227075368,
-0.0377680659,
0.0193654895,
0.0035301787,
0.0251493957,
0.0232830644,
-0.087960586,
0.0151578877,
-0.0270151161,
-0.010037533,
-0.0027133378,
0.046705883,
0.0240015164,
-0.0080570336,
0.0211135522,
-0.0177663192,
0.0095000966,
0.0296336338,
-0.0310433935,
0.0367003307,
-0.0475142077,
0.0613258742,
0.0220072046,
0.0127540929,
-0.0001971875,
-0.0523770228,
0.0112727666,
-0.0408786424,
-0.0238844752,
0.0606826209,
0.0183192529,
0.0181632712,
-0.0419464037,
-0.020529611,
0.0756932572,
-0.0384563617,
-0.0496634245,
-0.0725542903,
-0.0139371138,
-0.035030175,
0.0211254917,
-0.0038390649,
-0.0574393496,
0.0091773206,
0.027549725,
0.0099161081,
-0.0423648506,
0.0578133836,
-0.0168882851,
0.0277193021,
0.0376079157,
-0.0104307681,
-0.00560732,
-0.0027004101,
-0.0156649295,
-0.0300543085,
0.0066605601,
0.0120397238,
-0.0007182374,
0.0191987678,
0.0136844926,
0.0515236109,
0.0179835483,
0.0351232514,
-0.0479271896,
0.0049524689,
0.0270741135,
0.0198829267,
0.0473899767,
-0.0509178042,
0.0128415152,
-0.0282194559,
-0.0026586738,
-0.0426851548,
0.0302066151,
-0.0392674915,
0.0108169923,
-0.03353782,
-0.0159766003,
-0.0150126778,
-0.0753972307,
-0.0400723927,
0.0517384559,
0.0122202374,
-0.0317423381,
0.0216077417,
0.0994175002,
-0.0025627301,
0.0239386559,
-0.0258494262,
0.0081182839,
0.022874143,
0.0066680629,
-0.0460785776,
-0.0248800442,
-0.0119834729,
-0.0300244298,
0.0100308787,
0.0087414905,
0.017922014,
0.1341177225,
0.0168769136,
-0.046111647,
0.0208070874,
-0.0124294097,
0.0068760701,
-0.0059367288,
0.0231508166,
-0.0538807698,
0.0885106996,
0.0101244608,
-0.0250962079,
-0.0553337708,
0.0141298454,
-0.0305723697,
-0.0602928586,
0.1130187809,
-0.0425413325,
-0.0492548011,
0.0453471914,
0.001314359,
-0.0159593802,
-0.0309669338,
0.0001011436,
0.0429117493,
-0.0292380285,
0.0156758334,
-0.009580398,
-0.0031766426,
0.0107511366,
-0.0323660783,
0.0068031289,
0.0027078821,
0.0317929909,
0.0288948789,
-0.0561814755,
0.02346953,
0.0093791792,
-0.0474023409,
0.0059580659,
0.0955064073,
0.0343986787,
0.0191586837,
0.0014257823,
0.0337645411,
0.0087051382,
-0.0515155308,
-0.0684803799,
-0.0010154756,
-0.0384056196,
0.0188992955,
0.050000865,
-0.0189101491,
0.0149944993,
-0.0219932981,
-0.0322971009,
-0.007815185,
0.0372751206,
-0.0632966086,
0.0348301232,
-0.0541840158,
-0.1079900488,
0.0197466817,
0.0512891524,
-0.0048992843,
0.0005270448,
0.048188027,
-0.0021243712,
0.0599731058,
0.0452323817,
-0.040585693,
-0.0329211876,
0.0459650792,
-0.0312259383,
0.0076453537,
-0.0065365019,
-0.0050636069,
0.0188855436,
0.0113302171,
-0.0322918259,
0.0074211126,
-0.0003576888,
0.0183782503,
-0.0171559174,
-0.0179732721,
-0.0244317297,
-0.0671667606,
-0.0038314296,
0.01115706,
0.0101301521,
0.0065595,
-0.0063286698,
0.0048059458,
0.000067049,
0.0002284713,
0.0366648845,
0.0448666476,
0.0854398236,
-0.0338373967,
0.0148409661,
-0.0640316084,
0.0082120132,
-0.0086452486,
0.0786604881,
-0.0006638877,
0.050503619,
-0.0417180136,
-0.0580050536,
-0.0181887746,
0.0600118637,
-0.022034185,
0.0820783749,
0.0025048056,
0.0107923243,
0.0120281614,
0.0724543631,
-0.0290335659,
0.0187104251,
-0.0193897225,
-0.0031930986,
0.0332125872,
0.0147263259,
0.0187285412,
-0.0020547821,
-0.0051644198,
0.0144891804,
0.0431586206,
0.0184503589,
0.0199041683,
-0.0259870086,
-0.0155014433,
-0.0033400357,
-0.0414972417,
-0.034431871,
0.0371718965,
0.0219476931,
-0.011530227,
-0.0393123105,
0.0121376887,
-0.011109042,
-0.0157488454,
-0.0017169206,
-0.0701689869,
-0.0175610948,
0.0147749176,
-0.0067539481,
-0.0490071699,
-0.0354427025,
-0.0450407565,
-0.0682739913,
0.0656450167,
0.0251022018,
-0.0760576874,
0.0057315491,
0.0110400356,
-0.021968089,
0.025816163,
-0.0146028148,
-0.0025763863,
0.000348046,
-0.0106398482,
0.0233014356,
-0.0201959852,
-0.026795458,
0.0102914302,
0.0575665385,
0.0335566327,
0.024629239,
-0.0290691648,
-0.0654276535,
0.0369044766,
0.0140440613,
-0.0394760258,
-0.0616585463,
0.0493163019,
-0.0123388283,
0.0324242339,
-0.0444890335,
-0.0239428338,
0.0629483983,
-0.0014243515,
-0.0377709605,
0.0003050111,
0.0228836462,
0.0031523851,
0.0127160018,
-0.0517880879,
0.0746653154,
-0.0707257465,
0.0452938043,
-0.0108256647,
0.020986367,
0.0079049328,
0.0082478188,
0.0487320609,
0.0216038935,
0.0103388308,
-0.0055906819,
0.0177344661,
0.0097035896,
0.0219636485,
-0.0269255955,
-0.0065933145,
0.0341453664,
-0.0017790935,
0.0119645381,
-0.0154956039,
0.0018764562,
0.0777037069,
-0.0519341528,
0.0457936563,
0.0284589678,
-0.0465024747,
0.0061294571,
0.0480377935,
-0.0579082221,
-0.0174888708,
-0.004361935,
0.007589899,
-0.0345720463,
0.0028333676,
0.0225193463,
-0.0692615584,
-0.0182615705,
0.007980899,
0.0212221481,
0.0521763004,
-0.0177119579,
0.0156342741,
-0.0280612223,
0.0343843512,
0.0166562684,
0.0153352953,
-0.0023000499,
-0.0143205132,
-0.0460612513,
-0.0045982362,
0.0196918994,
0.0485282913,
0.036733143,
-0.0701315627,
-0.0038950532,
-0.0047053397,
-0.0389427356,
-0.0070249774,
0.0186621621,
-0.080663465,
-0.0300433803,
-0.0354399495,
0.0027200435,
0.0288424678,
-0.0072024195,
-0.0138826957,
-0.0269228183,
0.0322512425,
0.0210885815,
-0.0122604165,
-0.0245344434,
-0.0767946988,
-0.035383299,
-0.0032771146,
-0.0168773402,
0.0081643369,
0.0142239546,
-0.0227491129,
0.0200561229,
-0.0122489985,
-0.0508631095,
0.0151889464,
-0.0100019732,
-0.0276890676,
-0.0162804406,
0.056254074,
0.0374179222,
0.0094148032,
0.0127546424,
0.0750312656,
0.0360781923,
-0.0239869487,
0.0129133426,
0.0091552911,
0.0085122148,
-0.0242278818,
0.0094262883,
-0.0312055796,
-0.055245772,
-0.1067209542,
0.112677671,
-0.001686329,
0.0237854663,
-0.0474200137,
0.0194188766,
-0.0406961702,
0.0142428288,
0.0181000419,
-0.0329007022,
-0.0305284057,
-0.0127439387,
0.0350430906,
0.0085044056,
0.0201039389,
-0.0174284093,
-0.0390437767,
-0.0280733835,
-0.016829377,
0.0050366209,
0.0545436516,
-0.018099796,
0.0032896146,
0.0376620032,
0.0139792236,
-0.045430541,
-0.0537498593,
0.0339099951,
0.0540932231,
-0.0035202645,
-0.0071277381,
-0.0293045081,
0.0352595448,
-0.039196182,
-0.0215711277,
0.020046331,
-0.0483283512,
-0.0761393756,
-0.0702929944,
0.0157008469,
0.0089361193,
0.0578130968,
-0.0473336801,
-0.007034706,
0.0727563575,
0.0672132671,
0.0082990732,
-0.0234086663,
0.0000558351,
-0.0074178977,
-0.048190549,
-0.0194687471,
-0.0095615368,
0.0114770513,
0.0064052856,
0.0049450495,
0.0153713338,
-0.0253684893,
0.0322837718,
0.0077089951,
0.0857867375,
-0.0070329504,
-0.0227965675,
-0.0526594669,
-0.0074945237,
0.0430201702,
0.0138612287,
-0.007302281,
-0.0190071948,
0.0495524816,
-0.0309698414,
-0.0015911305,
-0.0434892476,
-0.0095629888,
-0.0074031963,
0.0290624481,
0.0052554985,
0.039012447,
-0.0187015794,
0.091548942,
-0.0294300783,
-0.0158624388,
-0.0164082963,
-0.0595656149,
0.0185816921,
-0.0328720659,
-0.0138336243,
-0.0125776976,
0.0588889159,
-0.0230306387,
0.0283460207,
0.0316703357,
-0.0274596456,
-0.0811696425,
0.0032394789,
0.0861321539,
0.03257576,
0.0427161753,
-0.008619668,
-0.0137170646,
-0.0267654695,
0.022569485,
-0.0178448875,
-0.0629318058,
0.068228744,
0.0147913601,
-0.00621896,
0.0230961069,
0.0317858495,
0.0557710119,
0.0167729668,
0.0104619907,
-0.0825385824,
0.0058181542,
-0.0047129625,
-0.0104944278,
0.0351405628,
-0.0583907254,
0.0108520016,
-0.0263914391,
-0.0708325654,
0.0419569127,
0.0349982306,
-0.0403429568,
0.0212519746,
-0.0009641377,
0.0345600396,
0.0291893613,
-0.0366993956,
-0.0144155882,
0.0340110771,
-0.0010457779,
-0.0276882146,
-0.0249660183,
-5.047671557e-33,
0.0387081318,
-0.0532011464,
-0.0398379266,
-0.0097862724,
0.027013842,
0.0238354169,
-0.0685790405,
0.0037677651,
-0.0015781765,
0.0647673383,
0.021376146,
-0.0320312865,
-0.0033382154,
-0.0341881178,
-0.0310011543,
0.013831743,
-0.0178430136,
0.04702802,
-0.0001822536,
-0.0106088622,
0.0191725325,
0.0784878954,
0.0499465168,
-0.0136789512,
-0.0041880487,
0.0074348268,
0.0271602962,
-0.0257549528,
0.0156643074,
0.0507220626,
-0.0167274773,
0.0519456193,
-0.0327745378,
0.0169223975,
0.0086184815,
-0.0288465489,
-0.0791469365,
0.0057778256,
0.003517274,
0.0026683686,
0.0100288903,
0.0350600593,
0.0255118571,
0.002346819,
-0.021405302,
-0.0108644534,
0.0410518162,
-0.0080113169,
-0.0774552822,
0.0202637259,
-0.0456566662,
0.027606355,
0.0526963323,
0.0113004223,
-0.0081346529,
0.0334934518,
0.0625051111,
0.0024709869,
-0.0198048893,
0.0232653301,
-0.0244758297,
-0.0166345723,
0.0342390388,
0.0162532106,
0.0161639601,
0.0755140185,
-0.0071366909,
-0.0555364974,
0.0309116747,
-0.0265681986,
0.0094858911,
0.0455819443,
-0.0035363948,
-0.0428115278,
-0.009608686,
-0.0236428212,
-0.1076624468,
-0.0158934817,
-0.0161925722,
-0.0078365449,
0.0018224093,
0.019829113,
0.0135363685,
-0.0730386972,
0.0038221525,
0.0103571033,
-0.0113996435,
-0.0539368875,
-0.0285584051,
-0.016364621,
-0.0568844751,
0.0394769385,
-0.0114735616,
-0.0372044072,
-0.0150785036,
0.0883686244,
-0.0105206585,
0.0098571582,
-0.0335689671,
0.0042047934,
-0.0248583723,
-0.0143156089,
-0.0224045906,
-0.0800223947,
0.0118149649,
-0.0130946329,
0.0099720769,
-0.0065961434,
0.02746935,
-0.007612993,
-0.0906049982,
-0.0473106652,
0.0292016994,
0.0609190166,
0.0643748417,
-0.0003713895,
-0.0304901525,
0.0457378179,
-0.0072627068,
0.0512009189,
0.0163353533,
0.0523918904,
-0.0064719152,
0.044374574,
-0.0788258091,
-0.0117723839,
-0.0523325801,
0.0147909913,
0.0274124146,
-0.0684220418,
-0.0364965908,
-0.0117964381,
2.643e-7,
0.0956193134,
0.06191523,
0.0383843482,
-0.0213613119,
-0.0295907296,
0.0227056574,
0.0051939273,
0.0432944521,
-0.0270554237,
-0.0001878806,
0.032079,
-0.0041615493,
-0.0211692043,
-0.0029368703,
-0.0447734222,
0.0271702129,
-0.039063476,
-0.0361593179,
-0.0603933483,
0.0411961712,
-0.0503830798,
0.1088648736,
0.0405078493,
-0.0047702761,
0.0229112841,
-0.054841347,
0.0319290087,
-0.0485841855,
0.0329303481,
0.0210890789,
-0.0438349284,
-0.0144997174,
-0.0343732759,
0.0218943283,
-0.0464821719,
0.0014008399,
-0.0001578044,
-0.0033674038,
-0.0448975824,
0.0205056556,
0.0346875601,
-0.0482250527,
0.0008992633,
0.0054988014,
0.0023073058,
-0.0527472496,
-0.0436795577,
0.0342493467,
-0.0052258731,
-0.0054590404,
0.0402340777,
0.0106756091,
0.0298140552,
0.0066099935,
0.0176716391,
-0.0120860189,
0.0365891345,
-0.0158444811,
0.0033063632,
0.0055471957,
-0.0069658193,
0.0391632691,
-0.0207302459,
-0.026881339,
0.0449315831,
-0.0138199413,
0.0016897264,
2.030386622e-34,
0.0581734069,
-0.0246042777,
0.0146471718,
0.0057690274,
0.0528934337,
-0.0071878172,
0.0465586409,
0.0045145205,
-0.0111605721,
-0.0701563209,
-0.0377033055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02418v1 | Decoding Data Quality via Synthetic Corruptions: Embedding-guided Pruning of Code Data | 2023-12-05T01:19:30 | 2023-12-05T01:19:30 | Yu Yang, Aaditya K. Singh, Mostafa Elhoushi, Anas Mahmoud, Kushal Tirumala, Fabian Gloeckle, Baptiste Rozière, Carole-Jean Wu, Ari S. Morcos, Newsha Ardalani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Code datasets, often collected from diverse and uncontrolled sources such as
GitHub, potentially suffer from quality issues, thereby affecting the
performance and training efficiency of Large Language Models (LLMs) optimized
for code generation. Previous studies demonstrated the benefit of using
embedding spaces for data pruning, but they mainly focused on duplicate removal
or increasing variety, and in other modalities, such as images. Our work
focuses on using embeddings to identify and remove "low-quality" code data.
First, we explore features of "low-quality" code in embedding space, through
the use of synthetic corruptions. Armed with this knowledge, we devise novel
pruning metrics that operate in embedding space to identify and remove
low-quality entries in the Stack dataset. We demonstrate the benefits of this
synthetic corruption informed pruning (SCIP) approach on the well-established
HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks, outperforming existing embedding-based methods.
Importantly, we achieve up to a 3% performance improvement over no pruning,
thereby showing the promise of insights from synthetic corruptions for data
pruning. | [
0.0005614251,
0.1145738438,
-0.0230802614,
0.0466573425,
0.0201120619,
0.0003360609,
-0.0222741161,
0.0359436572,
-0.0032579941,
0.016889466,
0.0084634963,
0.0007373781,
0.0247974023,
0.0250900649,
0.0732643828,
0.0117776757,
0.0390772037,
-0.0156669505,
0.0149631025,
0.003852837,
0.008581982,
-0.0024655345,
0.0589430332,
0.0520054027,
0.0073076747,
-0.0096227676,
0.0239819381,
0.0185520221,
0.0023378967,
-0.0183477066,
0.0169674624,
0.0444829613,
-0.0072838035,
0.0416843854,
0.0000020777,
0.0107939998,
0.0042063403,
0.0053484356,
0.008520646,
0.0488952585,
0.0133329891,
-0.0438023694,
-0.0299914908,
0.0352149792,
-0.0334456414,
-0.0437173061,
0.0552047454,
-0.0300203972,
0.0902758539,
0.0566163361,
0.0079756072,
0.0134383645,
-0.0127474936,
-0.0078225955,
0.0280565284,
0.0346151702,
0.0069677583,
0.057940837,
-0.0072511476,
0.0358454809,
-0.0088552255,
0.0170538146,
0.0307653435,
-0.0127056353,
0.0291300584,
0.0492194518,
-0.0389401428,
-0.0095646335,
0.0289838202,
0.0622696541,
-0.0781928971,
-0.0536816977,
0.019545868,
-0.0194967259,
-0.0177460164,
-0.0617483035,
-0.0026441098,
0.0410909988,
-0.0009797366,
0.0543076396,
-0.0204753689,
-0.0271880496,
0.0485253111,
-0.0198889971,
-0.0132094305,
-0.0353959203,
0.0165548585,
-0.0033029062,
-0.0469234064,
-0.0194063261,
-0.0142915631,
-0.0509099141,
-0.0157335065,
0.0191538446,
0.0164810307,
-0.0020163336,
-0.0816252455,
-0.067342259,
0.0428011939,
-0.035696093,
-0.0124464445,
0.0383792631,
0.0002148473,
0.0097277546,
-0.0385602936,
0.0492807031,
0.0106594693,
0.0318359919,
-0.011838058,
0.0215544272,
-0.0061502568,
0.0108363153,
-0.0227067601,
0.0346477963,
0.0072558732,
0.0119119938,
-0.0062478236,
0.0202489924,
-0.0060416483,
0.0510070063,
-0.0240338333,
-0.0169688687,
-0.0519097596,
0.0334088169,
0.0528400876,
-0.0336242802,
-0.0133741144,
-0.0426756069,
-0.0171970334,
-0.0590250231,
-0.012274784,
0.0175782721,
-0.0170045756,
-0.0264877658,
0.0041057733,
0.0340787545,
0.0340159759,
0.0052040364,
-0.0564743131,
-0.0276210662,
-0.000549027,
0.0007449362,
-0.0191310626,
-0.0885856301,
-0.0164827779,
-0.0230505336,
-0.0011978347,
-0.0992124006,
-0.0004156834,
0.0144174425,
-0.0561708063,
0.0334207229,
-0.1203822345,
0.0286711454,
-0.0002239033,
0.0048088292,
-0.0122808255,
0.0400157049,
0.0385640897,
0.0144215887,
0.0297612101,
-0.05491345,
0.0339050964,
0.0373792872,
0.0323155038,
0.03339082,
-0.0102595156,
-0.0044054636,
0.0183921196,
-0.0101572219,
0.0744647235,
0.0628429353,
-0.0553712212,
-0.0106101399,
0.0280092675,
-0.0173053425,
0.0297549237,
0.0276938174,
0.0455644764,
0.017368082,
-0.0123923076,
-0.0008781704,
-0.0509641021,
-0.0008352814,
0.0174907092,
0.005254155,
0.0227246638,
0.0510643944,
-0.0111859599,
-0.037329562,
-0.0177668445,
-0.0224038381,
-0.0193864629,
-0.0215481725,
0.0022254889,
0.0101951296,
-0.0342981666,
0.0027050143,
0.000036453,
-0.0556706004,
0.0023850584,
-0.0343748629,
0.0362446979,
0.0424513333,
0.0699739754,
-0.0053815655,
-0.0098874299,
-0.0277009197,
-0.0210245289,
-0.0393312871,
-0.0020390167,
-0.0300851204,
0.0392110869,
-0.0577959865,
-0.027364701,
-0.0238596965,
-0.015045872,
-0.0025914623,
0.0193720162,
-0.0265300144,
0.0412373058,
-0.0456787795,
-0.0593658723,
0.0433820598,
-0.0173950288,
0.0277942754,
0.0085373763,
0.0018099415,
0.0078633362,
-0.0304799974,
-0.0579077899,
0.0097597865,
0.0405779257,
-0.0201989468,
-0.0077258949,
-0.0322706401,
-0.0091376798,
-0.0497012101,
0.0554853342,
-0.0712636113,
-0.0092361169,
0.042263452,
-0.0396601111,
-0.0030477552,
0.0044308738,
-0.0548905469,
0.0100069428,
-0.0239131507,
0.0231818389,
-0.036064133,
0.0181064736,
-0.0179556813,
0.0355704278,
-0.0275660325,
0.0591792949,
0.0318973698,
0.0466822423,
0.0410876386,
-0.0041642082,
-0.0421257913,
0.0197772626,
-0.0458438024,
0.0440332592,
0.0250958372,
0.0614699423,
-0.0237978511,
-0.0254943874,
-0.0529089272,
-0.0071723289,
-0.014825522,
0.0133541366,
0.0338425189,
0.0008238422,
0.0100121973,
-0.017269196,
-0.0285099093,
-0.0324376822,
0.0098152403,
0.031245729,
0.0415509716,
-0.0255130455,
-0.0372474231,
-0.0203068238,
0.0040354682,
0.0044321739,
0.0544825792,
-0.0418174677,
-0.0171468947,
-0.0924285203,
0.0848990604,
-0.0031273114,
0.0159334764,
0.007512196,
-0.0837020874,
0.0022019746,
-0.0199407451,
0.0654946715,
0.0150548993,
-0.0143914055,
-0.0182886999,
0.0538578741,
0.0373639911,
-0.0434395783,
-0.0298629515,
0.0328758992,
0.0043546446,
-0.0076046656,
-0.0566393733,
0.0190485641,
0.0290409941,
0.0214327015,
-0.0129680065,
-0.0729935318,
0.0295612551,
-0.0080640502,
0.0036681129,
0.0229445789,
-0.0271595474,
-0.0020463092,
0.0390189253,
-0.0311367307,
-0.0980669409,
0.0377485491,
-0.0447009802,
-0.0066736583,
0.0108570522,
0.0072548497,
-0.0268584285,
-0.0000861487,
0.0050702966,
0.0300474521,
-0.0022006149,
-0.0335290655,
-0.0254167709,
0.0419189744,
-0.0013819098,
-0.0348089263,
0.0087244129,
-0.03206091,
0.0205916464,
-0.0025739633,
-0.0253883321,
-0.0257891789,
-0.0314629227,
0.0201634988,
-0.0363898426,
0.0297740176,
0.0158643164,
0.0481429398,
0.0035268134,
-0.0244980603,
0.0397424251,
0.0471589081,
-0.0180993173,
-0.0086695589,
-0.0013502244,
0.0003603655,
-0.0507866219,
0.0347995088,
-0.0061791781,
-0.002790442,
0.0377217196,
0.0659801215,
0.0715964213,
-0.0601132326,
-0.0015330674,
0.0319901854,
0.0322009251,
-0.0356061086,
0.0430888683,
0.0460271835,
-0.0157905146,
-0.0454054177,
0.072966978,
0.025660608,
-0.0362443216,
0.0323076472,
0.0228241067,
0.0726714507,
0.0491094254,
0.0032258339,
-0.0835569724,
-0.0026040585,
0.005708755,
0.023593463,
0.0089763897,
-0.0320570432,
-0.0114947921,
-0.1360309273,
0.0306031667,
0.0476651303,
-0.0284084231,
-0.0574080609,
-0.0288814586,
-0.0155088129,
-0.0015158445,
-0.0201126672,
0.0181266312,
0.0060280995,
0.041717343,
0.0030682401,
-0.0414836556,
-0.0476820916,
-0.019483529,
-0.0432080589,
0.050523296,
0.0850991309,
0.0278088357,
0.0354834199,
-0.0105917174,
0.0379478745,
-0.0252002776,
-0.0325165838,
-0.0096760476,
0.0678753406,
0.0231286176,
-0.0273724049,
0.0504874252,
0.0346252732,
-0.0511296466,
-0.0071167871,
-0.0141867064,
0.0690941513,
-0.017240962,
-0.0118628563,
-0.0283926949,
-0.0252572615,
0.0097412067,
0.03508652,
0.0762264878,
-0.0242874697,
-0.0368310139,
-0.0577949435,
0.0118843885,
-0.0313377455,
0.0129626477,
0.0461423397,
0.0015347614,
-0.0351080373,
-0.0748094469,
-0.038239833,
0.0142529383,
0.0327375084,
0.0229155831,
-0.019311741,
-0.0201609861,
-0.0110709723,
-0.0187459141,
-0.0013287638,
-0.0438608304,
0.0317398496,
-0.0469736867,
0.007015836,
-0.0267160796,
-0.0042919503,
-0.0104903085,
-0.021562377,
-0.1145461574,
-0.0561760589,
-0.0276312958,
0.0634875819,
0.0158800427,
0.0295414627,
-0.0311601888,
-0.0531677678,
-0.0254693627,
0.0260408204,
-0.0453133285,
0.0345512144,
0.0380241461,
-0.0479755849,
0.0180710778,
0.0216839612,
-0.043048311,
-0.0165941697,
0.0215068813,
-0.0111675579,
-0.0091011515,
0.0471689291,
0.0288934018,
0.0305658784,
0.0088958936,
0.0042108363,
-0.0265812036,
-0.0173192676,
-0.0194362924,
0.0149641959,
-0.0350476876,
-0.0504482202,
0.0478718579,
0.031473577,
-0.0037950943,
0.0049213087,
0.0228918996,
-0.0107733123,
0.0565310791,
-0.0263805203,
0.0126784686,
0.0219950192,
0.042451255,
0.0727026686,
-0.0011350142,
0.0008095034,
0.0262184609,
-0.0176600199,
0.0050205351,
-0.026988849,
-0.0149756093,
0.0213716235,
0.0315700583,
0.0278144404,
0.0324826017,
-0.0487313122,
-0.0495830774,
-0.0138402516,
-0.0321559124,
0.0433378406,
0.0443469957,
0.0672508627,
0.0159398913,
0.0148715544,
-0.037309818,
0.0432149023,
0.0151595352,
-0.0579132773,
0.0115049174,
-0.0067876107,
-0.0548737422,
-0.0146149611,
0.1077769697,
-0.0002106825,
0.0319036208,
-0.0312700011,
0.0071231904,
-0.0475598425,
0.0069013154,
0.0155908316,
-0.0055394596,
-0.0296610724,
-0.0298467726,
-0.0305912253,
-0.0819947198,
-0.0119777163,
0.0322956219,
0.0222795829,
0.0233070403,
-0.0086585833,
0.0835229978,
-0.0128712123,
0.0345129035,
-0.0348344557,
-0.0204215012,
0.03511158,
-0.0640807226,
-0.0259947348,
-5.789134456e-33,
0.0139708584,
-0.0493824035,
-0.0235267673,
-0.0314217545,
-0.0226182658,
0.0171557404,
-0.0677092895,
-0.019531399,
-0.0202141609,
-0.0364426747,
0.0119438348,
0.0259025078,
-0.0130140353,
-0.013277919,
0.0143887419,
0.0422554128,
0.0698131993,
0.0327083729,
-0.0660483539,
0.0499670655,
-0.0247083269,
0.0353121571,
0.0160117485,
-0.0281120073,
-0.038084887,
0.0002477917,
-0.001401187,
-0.0023069538,
0.0693082139,
0.0451718718,
-0.0182600264,
0.0244621169,
0.0047478606,
-0.0094479462,
-0.0477875955,
-0.0450656824,
-0.0298544522,
0.0093423454,
-0.017576728,
0.0016055213,
0.0069097425,
-0.0609108172,
0.0650763661,
-0.0225509387,
0.0003021189,
-0.0024679145,
0.0221351124,
-0.025403481,
-0.0501151793,
-0.0078277783,
-0.039950151,
0.0487691052,
-0.0429257564,
0.0078498423,
0.0206040014,
0.0089235855,
0.0192205049,
0.0971113518,
-0.0273144469,
0.0245063528,
-0.0030977202,
0.0395971686,
0.045365639,
-0.0324258916,
0.0058171391,
0.0642369539,
0.0094496822,
-0.0024878758,
0.0260698181,
0.0027803162,
0.0678625703,
0.041676838,
0.0446704626,
0.0639659017,
0.063329272,
-0.0537985414,
-0.0292487536,
0.0192438476,
-0.025446374,
0.0034672886,
-0.0144369807,
0.044712279,
-0.0163737331,
-0.009868402,
-0.0429035872,
-0.0521907806,
0.000025888,
-0.0460402593,
0.0383482538,
0.0112947058,
-0.0614808649,
-0.0047714189,
0.0318306834,
-0.0682823732,
-0.0148884319,
0.0680777282,
-0.0593515746,
0.0324296728,
-0.0057529034,
0.027628202,
-0.0173280705,
-0.0085975695,
0.0418965593,
-0.0091996687,
0.071572125,
-0.0017025257,
0.049832873,
0.0082215229,
-0.0765592605,
0.0091604935,
-0.0538645461,
-0.0096119465,
-0.0144341802,
0.0434586518,
0.0215995852,
-0.0246537663,
0.0179260988,
0.0185176153,
0.02458442,
0.0262138508,
-0.0593168885,
0.0230552349,
-0.0000109009,
0.0096301604,
-0.0176176038,
-0.04990419,
-0.0398714021,
0.0425339341,
0.0419284403,
-0.0803078786,
-0.0536053404,
0.0179789718,
2.701e-7,
0.0068639847,
0.0246472489,
0.0165675115,
0.0080994572,
0.0166828446,
0.0357194394,
-0.0233506709,
-0.0124883624,
-0.0428460874,
-0.0247615352,
-0.0260738842,
-0.0084010316,
0.0500905663,
0.0415583253,
-0.0567250252,
0.0317029804,
-0.059533935,
-0.0306183081,
-0.0555480421,
-0.0130157722,
-0.0043481202,
0.1094860509,
-0.0065905107,
-0.0327780917,
0.0625601187,
-0.0305156913,
0.0001896076,
0.0144128203,
0.0054352754,
0.0346857086,
-0.047503978,
0.0108814081,
-0.0141497254,
-0.0557694994,
-0.0366400965,
-0.0341722704,
0.006975648,
0.0420628227,
-0.0071403957,
0.0477997549,
0.0110212974,
-0.019591229,
-0.011462301,
-0.0585058704,
0.0508002713,
0.0097001698,
0.0006111636,
-0.0354774147,
-0.0066291587,
-0.017900968,
0.0355714485,
-0.0365613215,
-0.0109318299,
0.0189828631,
0.0140458532,
-0.015705619,
-0.0281253681,
-0.0374176726,
-0.0183966085,
-0.0294899922,
-0.034272857,
-0.0446555912,
-0.035428647,
0.0235230401,
0.0542486422,
-0.03436381,
0.0294712596,
2.850307707e-34,
0.0469568707,
-0.071173504,
0.0461700484,
0.0138474153,
0.0576837696,
-0.0196603034,
0.0269959718,
0.0094279386,
-0.0326488242,
-0.0030537597,
-0.0219835918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02406v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02406v2 | Efficient Online Data Mixing For Language Model Pre-Training | 2023-12-05T00:42:35 | 2023-12-09T00:27:18 | Alon Albalak, Liangming Pan, Colin Raffel, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The data used to pretrain large language models has a decisive impact on a
model's downstream performance, which has led to a large body of work on data
selection methods that aim to automatically determine the most suitable data to
use for pretraining. Existing data selection methods suffer from slow and
computationally expensive processes, a problem amplified by the increasing size
of models and of pretraining datasets. Data mixing, on the other hand, reduces
the complexity of data selection by grouping data points together and
determining sampling probabilities across entire groups. However, data mixing
proportions are typically fixed before training and therefore cannot adapt to
changing training dynamics. To address these limitations, we develop an
efficient algorithm for Online Data Mixing (ODM) that combines elements from
both data selection and data mixing. Based on multi-armed bandit algorithms,
our online approach optimizes the data mixing proportions during training.
Remarkably, our method trains a model that reaches the final perplexity of the
next best method with 19\% fewer training iterations, and improves performance
on the 5-shot MMLU benchmark by 1.9% relative accuracy, while adding negligible
wall-clock time during pretraining. | [
0.0053643165,
0.1218006685,
-0.0004177268,
0.009523714,
-0.0220491625,
0.04995884,
0.017058406,
-0.0054813321,
-0.0190464035,
-0.0648869053,
-0.0278580338,
-0.0734872892,
-0.0004235021,
0.0169212949,
0.026258193,
-0.0252879094,
0.0249764882,
-0.0609328859,
-0.0224252958,
-0.0258384906,
-0.0125807151,
0.0212847367,
-0.0484171771,
-0.0054324772,
0.0393749699,
0.0228213873,
-0.0145203508,
0.0111911818,
-0.0150993057,
-0.0468641333,
-0.0018783711,
0.0529698394,
0.0268210396,
0.0608331971,
0.0000020711,
-0.0701823682,
-0.0361189768,
-0.0111259297,
-0.0424552336,
-0.0135917151,
0.0370765887,
0.0197446719,
0.0018516794,
0.0426606759,
-0.030276468,
-0.0401781648,
0.0611043684,
0.0174044762,
0.0159209315,
0.0652834848,
0.0042917193,
-0.0120452903,
0.0154940924,
-0.0256809797,
0.000426412,
-0.0199549459,
0.0456575863,
-0.0092967916,
-0.0182595123,
-0.0313886143,
-0.0289967619,
-0.0007700049,
-0.0293062162,
0.0331052393,
0.0161254685,
0.0121316714,
-0.0477573723,
-0.0259321816,
-0.0223650485,
0.0650968552,
-0.0535322875,
-0.0020623752,
0.0346039869,
-0.022044003,
-0.0416434221,
0.0046713217,
-0.0370645598,
0.00910779,
-0.0189330168,
0.0317578278,
-0.004691537,
-0.0149034243,
0.0476994142,
0.0344379842,
-0.0673307106,
0.0505345576,
0.0243426412,
-0.0239616167,
0.0381413773,
0.0210603792,
-0.0289118253,
-0.0549487248,
-0.0137576144,
0.0037248363,
-0.0554846339,
0.02062626,
-0.0546820946,
-0.0409672223,
-0.0034070185,
0.003916895,
0.082306996,
0.0179820452,
0.0112333242,
0.0651982278,
0.0154790357,
-0.0093003782,
0.0120941913,
0.0138247237,
-0.0371971205,
-0.002660546,
-0.059275303,
0.0218732581,
-0.0182458814,
0.0208553709,
0.021766847,
-0.0203106478,
-0.0530489124,
0.0176093653,
0.0019324588,
-0.044332739,
0.0270624384,
-0.0229441356,
-0.0210409146,
0.0228565652,
-0.0047773719,
-0.0021463253,
-0.0179957245,
0.0297982898,
0.0029358929,
-0.085244067,
-0.0102513414,
-0.0019007999,
0.0055092629,
-0.0414283276,
0.0009597549,
0.0788362324,
-0.0108245313,
-0.0478591584,
-0.0061237393,
0.0102786198,
-0.0068211048,
-0.0393599346,
0.0176386256,
-0.0653450564,
0.0693216398,
-0.0327354856,
0.0201911181,
0.0227467548,
-0.0007382352,
0.0039850441,
-0.0411541574,
0.0582085587,
-0.0386238657,
0.0381725132,
0.0228579585,
-0.0362728089,
-0.0205117892,
0.1143153682,
0.0103379432,
-0.014314468,
0.0412288234,
0.0057035703,
-0.0003244654,
0.045951955,
0.0237600654,
0.0139473835,
0.0000015153,
-0.0056577744,
0.0196288116,
0.0168747157,
0.0229896903,
-0.0078520468,
-0.0827115998,
0.0307660103,
0.0690165311,
0.0087712584,
0.0619463995,
-0.0054878974,
-0.0136746708,
0.025925003,
0.002898992,
-0.0375027545,
-0.0265880693,
0.0058712969,
-0.0423448086,
0.0260693505,
0.0500582457,
0.0995553508,
-0.014131966,
-0.0230421387,
-0.0309146903,
0.0088934721,
-0.0134488996,
0.0468847342,
0.0637870803,
-0.0038228475,
-0.03877756,
0.0241499674,
0.0774969831,
-0.0138536729,
-0.0043752543,
-0.0108983787,
-0.0181368999,
0.0646896362,
0.0505406745,
-0.0181776024,
-0.0195283443,
-0.031420894,
0.0405264609,
-0.0106259612,
0.0323016159,
-0.0214502439,
0.0506612733,
-0.056716878,
-0.0529777557,
0.0171210505,
0.019598268,
0.0461067148,
0.0506591871,
0.0359471403,
-0.019627342,
-0.0215991568,
-0.0000262979,
0.044108171,
-0.04472721,
-0.0362471715,
0.0288128313,
-0.0093414588,
0.0446575545,
-0.0329044536,
-0.0294712335,
0.00382838,
0.0103667099,
-0.0209272634,
-0.0171678495,
0.0051820893,
-0.0215869881,
-0.0363301337,
0.0556749217,
0.0147827463,
0.008671077,
0.0049302937,
-0.0535237603,
-0.0252667069,
0.004725086,
-0.0065744333,
0.0605789497,
-0.0545638911,
0.0325714834,
0.0001953555,
0.0030666897,
-0.0429122858,
0.0632900968,
0.0008429985,
0.0210486054,
-0.0179193653,
-0.01411008,
0.02074131,
-0.0436968394,
-0.0093638012,
0.006406209,
-0.0224779304,
-0.0008481828,
-0.0037647032,
-0.0086066602,
-0.0204335731,
-0.0291816667,
-0.1090380773,
-0.0043634954,
-0.0164416898,
0.0193423443,
0.005887704,
-0.0006805405,
-0.0433655567,
-0.0187147744,
-0.005501111,
-0.0127342781,
-0.0206398685,
0.0401408486,
0.0096392334,
0.0146705918,
0.004729744,
-0.0275694299,
-0.0407157131,
-0.0167320352,
0.0473470874,
-0.039293807,
-0.0161082763,
-0.0397205725,
-0.052478902,
-0.0656512231,
0.0253837705,
0.0071792677,
-0.0264541414,
-0.0107440325,
-0.0309224315,
0.0077113709,
0.0466491021,
0.0233800896,
-0.0131089147,
0.07349848,
-0.0521319434,
-0.0060745687,
0.007927252,
0.0160790756,
-0.0234497618,
-0.0090496643,
-0.0038654497,
-0.0040352442,
0.0736820921,
-0.0232527759,
-0.0171230249,
-0.0173937231,
0.0057849111,
-0.0262245405,
-0.0198285468,
-0.0651646107,
0.0231054723,
-0.0184677411,
0.0471824929,
-0.023434341,
-0.0334943645,
0.0731455684,
-0.0164605118,
-0.0137984464,
-0.060398858,
-0.0169373378,
-0.0277824216,
0.006521028,
0.0084255915,
0.0149426116,
-0.0172828902,
0.010096699,
-0.0400619842,
-0.0100123659,
0.0974650532,
-0.0376601703,
0.0094457231,
-0.0247996971,
0.0268928148,
0.0057003722,
-0.0363706909,
-0.0109303184,
-0.0624495633,
-0.0312752984,
-0.0316191427,
0.0017402242,
-0.0265304353,
-0.032123886,
-0.0221774299,
-0.0105026774,
0.0571467876,
-0.0227971412,
-0.004612912,
-0.003271004,
0.0393101163,
0.0559239797,
0.0016428328,
0.0034233795,
-0.0624007173,
0.0220565833,
0.019666886,
0.0837090313,
-0.005646761,
0.0112092495,
0.022097474,
0.0413935594,
-0.0278753098,
-0.0283535514,
0.0496775731,
0.008160322,
-0.0189226829,
-0.0043942486,
0.0804703906,
0.0240842961,
-0.0275380574,
-0.0192967355,
0.0033117714,
0.0658630505,
0.0115794353,
0.0435250513,
-0.0885281488,
-0.0464551337,
0.0235873386,
0.0309115816,
-0.0053422228,
-0.0402384736,
-0.0190115701,
-0.1071897224,
0.0356755555,
0.0198409706,
-0.0565463565,
0.0313213617,
-0.0656303987,
-0.0075344057,
-0.06997668,
-0.0053061703,
0.0123367095,
-0.0311929695,
0.009576492,
0.0136027411,
-0.0055897455,
-0.0466122963,
0.0122740241,
-0.0499955527,
0.0237330291,
0.0696566924,
0.0260505136,
0.0076236646,
-0.0375246629,
0.0447282605,
-0.0044227559,
-0.0296426155,
0.0053186808,
0.0764970854,
-0.0140849957,
0.0038789432,
0.0203067791,
0.018809,
-0.0122529743,
-0.0255316235,
0.0002314412,
0.062925972,
0.0218356494,
0.021453511,
0.0275623929,
-0.0006280561,
0.0628813058,
0.065058969,
-0.0137207583,
-0.0467844568,
-0.0086803678,
-0.0215951465,
0.0133370329,
-0.0181819666,
0.0271945298,
0.0197143741,
-0.026623426,
-0.0430121198,
-0.0718846992,
0.0027410628,
0.0287062041,
0.0786796808,
0.0008916467,
0.0566993952,
-0.0015466588,
0.0277214032,
-0.0503954776,
0.035414774,
-0.0375802778,
0.0203210656,
-0.043855615,
-0.0267563574,
0.0238296203,
-0.0095868548,
-0.0170955285,
0.0269109439,
-0.1267244667,
-0.0705166832,
0.0444417819,
0.0338837691,
0.0213134252,
0.05792851,
-0.003082735,
-0.0348135158,
0.0404635109,
-0.006168731,
-0.0152884284,
0.0248058941,
0.0370843336,
-0.0236003194,
0.0103577459,
0.010080996,
-0.0631222427,
-0.0088767074,
0.0182175729,
-0.0319237188,
-0.0407784246,
0.0341695696,
-0.0005977353,
0.0086076744,
0.0633716956,
-0.0225111693,
-0.0370057188,
-0.0550214685,
0.0556508712,
0.0277416147,
-0.0154979108,
-0.0426632203,
-0.0164100491,
0.0268507246,
-0.0055263699,
-0.0095620202,
0.0314773768,
0.0125247315,
-0.0009009095,
-0.0429759622,
-0.0201556217,
0.0282375664,
0.0176324006,
0.0240038633,
-0.0040716138,
0.0168759413,
0.0680825859,
-0.0032684049,
0.0516361818,
-0.0260651652,
0.0101242857,
0.0051201209,
0.0058896202,
-0.0073488667,
-0.0004024337,
-0.0882240981,
-0.0545357428,
-0.049331747,
-0.0066586351,
0.0721224025,
-0.0625587776,
0.0576487929,
-0.0017771741,
-0.0054020369,
-0.0192133542,
0.0096078301,
-0.0539332516,
-0.0255929362,
0.0074599213,
0.0288098715,
-0.0166621059,
0.0274758153,
0.0927624479,
0.0421123728,
0.0374553837,
0.02540542,
0.0159193128,
-0.0126762819,
0.0143792247,
0.0768333897,
0.087449573,
-0.0219339207,
-0.0290357303,
-0.0100146923,
-0.029294489,
0.0033718443,
-0.0099096298,
-0.0185079314,
0.0067712367,
0.0600321814,
0.0258389972,
-0.0362313539,
0.0279390849,
-0.0576123782,
-0.0253017768,
0.0585558712,
-0.011250725,
0.0175120756,
-6.708606504e-33,
0.002076224,
0.0024418137,
-0.006057248,
-0.0649356991,
-0.0291720591,
-0.006442735,
0.0036429861,
-0.0014657779,
-0.0149451066,
-0.0225625895,
-0.0201823823,
0.0158421192,
0.0268552937,
0.0259679612,
0.0035468307,
-0.0063465144,
0.0175470002,
-0.0107962377,
-0.018986633,
-0.0153378872,
0.0036592311,
0.0382944308,
0.0243077856,
-0.0325782672,
-0.0172630288,
0.0102122314,
-0.0312533118,
0.0130605055,
-0.0303531457,
0.0553228892,
0.015612484,
0.007996629,
0.0020596143,
-0.0119695552,
-0.0365355834,
-0.0424984097,
-0.0223683864,
-0.0374942049,
-0.0200777464,
0.0273562707,
0.0163694732,
0.0341039635,
0.0111374119,
-0.0166985393,
0.0161261745,
-0.0416093469,
0.0087408423,
-0.0265528802,
-0.0716578588,
-0.009152838,
-0.0129988398,
0.0381181724,
0.0072116121,
0.0056486623,
0.0630082786,
0.0004043669,
0.0202961583,
0.0000067295,
-0.0472622588,
0.0547148623,
0.0781936198,
0.0280090496,
0.0420023873,
0.0532038398,
0.0307816882,
0.0691733435,
0.0170932971,
-0.0029333245,
0.0311731976,
0.0074902521,
0.0523510724,
0.0181205887,
0.0051019108,
0.0528080501,
0.1045679674,
-0.0021945636,
-0.0622797161,
0.0194393117,
0.022833826,
-0.0372729897,
-0.0053253388,
0.0602250844,
-0.027472062,
-0.0340032689,
-0.0453308746,
-0.0484259762,
-0.0365567319,
-0.0243631676,
0.0199231543,
0.0347717516,
-0.0369773842,
-0.039580483,
0.0332342796,
-0.0154269952,
-0.0546267442,
0.0009160984,
-0.0036094168,
0.0142196212,
-0.0259444248,
0.0229479503,
-0.0603654645,
-0.0632029325,
0.0347893313,
-0.0181359053,
0.0041167554,
-0.0198963825,
0.0286359657,
0.0094951103,
-0.0803824067,
0.0154742114,
0.0036612879,
0.0242721308,
0.0409693569,
0.0404851176,
0.069865033,
-0.0094054602,
0.023160873,
0.0515775941,
0.0495665558,
-0.0646375194,
-0.0386345126,
-0.0183920562,
-0.0167577993,
-0.0034526086,
0.0065072053,
0.0036258516,
-0.031213427,
-0.0412633866,
0.0372498967,
-0.0449802577,
-0.0203478802,
0.0069879489,
2.755e-7,
0.0470670834,
0.0565821081,
-0.0267244186,
0.0031194915,
-0.0109641729,
-0.0037324035,
-0.0378216282,
0.0048136595,
0.0039264793,
0.0109153427,
0.0089323958,
0.0330909975,
0.0636927485,
0.0595677681,
-0.0746214017,
-0.034282513,
-0.0423435383,
0.0536468923,
-0.0696124583,
-0.0400428362,
-0.0105114253,
0.1290611774,
0.0336673521,
-0.013775358,
0.0191917494,
-0.0263116509,
0.0567801781,
-0.0043094633,
-0.0165169798,
0.0076969326,
0.0087903393,
0.0220479351,
-0.0197493993,
0.0149568934,
-0.0577565432,
0.0043617873,
0.0024582213,
0.018225221,
-0.0324651562,
-0.0181022324,
0.0006180592,
0.0124271633,
-0.0303231478,
-0.0328734592,
0.0746967718,
-0.0240269583,
-0.0040550986,
-0.0647832155,
0.007934466,
-0.0459838994,
0.0578514077,
-0.0396607779,
-0.0009328095,
0.0412130617,
0.0271401741,
-0.0010434634,
-0.0200011451,
-0.0581923462,
-0.0189322643,
0.0396905281,
-0.0147777554,
-0.0353269503,
-0.0376948081,
0.004021151,
0.0662369058,
-0.072023131,
-0.0013876942,
2.763387017e-34,
0.0421706401,
0.0143599324,
0.0154297864,
0.0420644246,
0.02694631,
-0.0372286066,
0.0352836773,
0.0023222,
-0.007004803,
-0.0666173026,
-0.003759173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02382v1 | New Evaluation Metrics Capture Quality Degradation due to LLM Watermarking | 2023-12-04T22:56:31 | 2023-12-04T22:56:31 | Karanpartap Singh, James Zou | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing use of large-language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT,
watermarking has emerged as a promising approach for tracing machine-generated
content. However, research on LLM watermarking often relies on simple
perplexity or diversity-based measures to assess the quality of watermarked
text, which can mask important limitations in watermarking. Here we introduce
two new easy-to-use methods for evaluating watermarking algorithms for LLMs: 1)
evaluation by LLM-judger with specific guidelines; and 2) binary classification
on text embeddings to distinguish between watermarked and unwatermarked text.
We apply these methods to characterize the effectiveness of current
watermarking techniques. Our experiments, conducted across various datasets,
reveal that current watermarking methods are detectable by even simple
classifiers, challenging the notion of watermarking subtlety. We also found,
through the LLM judger, that watermarking impacts text quality, especially in
degrading the coherence and depth of the response. Our findings underscore the
trade-off between watermark robustness and text quality and highlight the
importance of having more informative metrics to assess watermarking quality. | [
0.0137662375,
0.0554122813,
-0.0061414745,
0.0409772545,
-0.0401513875,
0.0160349477,
0.0250444673,
0.0732360855,
0.0380132832,
-0.0329601429,
0.0023111645,
-0.0195924491,
0.0277904514,
0.0270450804,
0.0355082192,
-0.0330006517,
0.0345945321,
-0.0016352488,
-0.0012203706,
0.0166094881,
0.0328638181,
-0.0155793577,
0.0832319036,
0.0479893535,
-0.0110952286,
-0.0326586589,
0.0186611544,
0.0202917866,
-0.0008693323,
-0.0143033378,
-0.0357688554,
0.050537318,
0.0008212584,
0.0944028571,
0.0000018444,
-0.0346020535,
-0.0373730808,
0.064367801,
-0.0086874757,
0.0489897914,
0.0446826443,
-0.0012388341,
-0.032954134,
0.0293589104,
-0.0233209245,
0.0507769585,
0.0572570637,
0.0464305207,
0.074989371,
0.0568236895,
-0.0196361262,
0.0229016915,
0.0474374928,
0.0131508093,
0.0208382569,
0.0222371928,
0.0180746485,
0.0404565297,
-0.0283935443,
0.05088697,
-0.004723392,
0.0728560314,
0.0069347597,
-0.0556185469,
-0.0257365964,
-0.0004220975,
-0.0010194879,
-0.0106729837,
0.0465891324,
0.0195491854,
-0.0387899019,
-0.0082910173,
0.0124247586,
0.0004398158,
0.016143458,
0.0378628112,
-0.0289956089,
0.0202193651,
0.0406408422,
0.0318164937,
-0.0225874819,
-0.0125078727,
0.041582007,
0.0173443686,
0.019382352,
0.0226847269,
0.0109086484,
-0.0239597503,
-0.0534782149,
0.0027650078,
-0.0157916304,
-0.0393634252,
0.0509797111,
-0.0191680901,
0.0423121974,
-0.0092437835,
-0.0861808881,
-0.0476684682,
0.0200380702,
-0.0469343178,
0.05891468,
0.0134842331,
-0.0320921242,
0.0521098152,
-0.0703382418,
0.0617010891,
-0.0136810951,
0.0482648835,
0.0084015373,
0.006770907,
0.0012621179,
-0.0325898565,
-0.0016503208,
0.0284666847,
-0.0241982155,
-0.0287818648,
-0.02582152,
0.0452107973,
0.0039635105,
0.0125987371,
-0.00702111,
-0.0190031193,
0.0087403124,
0.003807639,
0.023189662,
-0.0339610353,
0.0342117734,
0.0120642809,
0.010177061,
-0.0357965119,
-0.0034160621,
0.0459175594,
0.0209558439,
0.001870319,
-0.0164557751,
0.0807981715,
0.0272123702,
-0.0257787239,
-0.0037818812,
-0.0456392728,
-0.0265215449,
0.0063667032,
0.0008487953,
-0.048354283,
-0.0129099861,
-0.0161178391,
0.0083734505,
-0.0482513756,
0.0031152477,
0.015767131,
-0.036734201,
0.036273852,
-0.0489581488,
-0.0133332331,
0.0120048542,
0.0031554161,
-0.0454217419,
0.0754342973,
0.0543505102,
0.037885122,
0.0860271752,
-0.0252724886,
0.0106964996,
0.058156956,
-0.0069331792,
0.0231437031,
-0.009363669,
-0.0484228544,
0.0261843167,
-0.0154831987,
0.0295412354,
0.0496268347,
-0.0226115044,
-0.0504988804,
0.111969091,
0.0438488871,
0.0099305743,
-0.0100636035,
-0.0108309612,
0.0345517658,
0.0237122942,
0.0308790859,
-0.0136303576,
-0.0144809643,
-0.0224014279,
-0.0158195309,
0.0761406496,
0.0110825216,
0.0081131095,
-0.0248637125,
-0.0295547638,
-0.0114932414,
0.0499541424,
-0.0275775883,
0.0083887866,
0.0084953625,
-0.0344168097,
-0.002947852,
-0.0214028358,
-0.0219015107,
0.0445562005,
-0.0796732381,
0.0343360454,
0.0617778823,
0.0847044438,
-0.0060577891,
0.0812392682,
-0.0152079388,
-0.0168565679,
0.0396039747,
-0.0544031262,
0.0152840624,
0.0201758631,
-0.0279384349,
-0.0450759009,
-0.0303119216,
0.0267120376,
0.0121399257,
0.0048390855,
0.0130518647,
0.0376417711,
-0.039702598,
-0.0313681737,
0.0282399505,
0.0360988043,
-0.0007298131,
0.0018497318,
-0.0183430184,
0.0263287742,
0.0181879923,
-0.0343287438,
0.0268083215,
0.0115334392,
-0.0011862064,
-0.0172694791,
-0.02767363,
0.0182005968,
-0.0303234998,
0.0343865044,
-0.0597206466,
-0.0103618652,
0.0645484701,
-0.0083072558,
0.0001481762,
-0.0017480534,
-0.0729388371,
0.0245778132,
-0.0682544857,
0.0288255494,
-0.0299553573,
0.0402556472,
-0.0267525595,
0.0089528849,
0.0001038296,
0.0271991324,
-0.002299601,
-0.0009277806,
0.0055554193,
0.0022228633,
-0.0483998209,
0.0047835098,
-0.0533457249,
0.0228516422,
0.0125278756,
0.00968845,
-0.0332811214,
-0.0139238378,
-0.0469631143,
-0.0070060785,
-0.0163581632,
0.0314861722,
0.0232399236,
-0.0247285608,
0.0199933033,
0.0146321505,
-0.0358980708,
-0.0506000109,
0.0210722145,
0.047204785,
0.0284992419,
-0.0524662063,
-0.0030988827,
-0.0126461294,
-0.0239459686,
0.0265434477,
0.0839457214,
-0.0074055474,
-0.05030993,
-0.0580051579,
0.0403464176,
-0.0410012379,
-0.0340407155,
0.0151430843,
-0.0384449065,
-0.0028687201,
0.0020143832,
-0.0039273216,
0.0307765175,
0.0034660215,
0.0038018792,
0.0280926228,
0.0318245888,
-0.0326326601,
-0.0454087518,
-0.0436654575,
0.0156357437,
0.00874284,
-0.0382257476,
0.047563266,
-0.0036605878,
-0.0081581995,
0.0086705619,
-0.0244245008,
0.0365105867,
-0.0390497036,
-0.0037482576,
-0.0361483842,
-0.0184541922,
-0.0312763043,
0.0341617018,
-0.0156075554,
-0.0649019033,
0.0146099916,
-0.0406168997,
-0.0037461971,
0.0161056742,
-0.0053038127,
-0.0063509922,
0.0160765648,
-0.0028988991,
0.0296365693,
-0.0061140698,
-0.0323827714,
-0.017440252,
0.0112398127,
0.0693510026,
-0.067676194,
-0.0026581564,
-0.0146968067,
-0.0150257014,
-0.0007627407,
-0.0057169944,
-0.0185387321,
-0.0344957635,
0.0312176384,
0.0038037782,
0.0633558333,
-0.0182954706,
-0.0100977654,
0.0322348699,
0.0374095775,
-0.0018316036,
-0.0346586518,
-0.0033516397,
-0.0099349245,
0.1047118604,
-0.0097928001,
-0.0297716912,
0.0453698002,
-0.0011602269,
0.0180557165,
0.0624884963,
-0.0163144749,
0.0009869109,
0.030990785,
0.0003529362,
0.0115662506,
0.0303825289,
-0.0469231531,
0.0036731614,
0.0448450595,
-0.0736172572,
0.0104549201,
0.069122076,
0.0324510299,
-0.0023501187,
-0.0099016437,
-0.013815484,
0.03820749,
0.0027051526,
-0.0253999587,
-0.0736203864,
-0.0016037269,
0.036020305,
0.0133054163,
-0.0340920016,
-0.000003261,
-0.0123743145,
-0.0692242607,
0.0314303711,
0.0244645979,
-0.0175791066,
-0.0310412105,
-0.0785340592,
-0.0069958265,
0.0325287841,
0.0098457914,
-0.0495344475,
0.0462740138,
-0.0095802397,
0.0139198555,
-0.0733217672,
-0.0733844712,
-0.0467104577,
-0.0049411482,
0.0288908184,
0.0808414593,
0.0350935794,
-0.0312956683,
-0.0478521176,
0.0393287577,
-0.0039758994,
-0.0360854231,
-0.0051636798,
0.0806551948,
0.0049764197,
-0.0151798669,
-0.0268547889,
-0.0163509231,
0.0460733287,
-0.0207841471,
-0.0203884318,
0.0443998314,
-0.0038623635,
-0.0219435301,
-0.0107129347,
-0.0231025368,
0.0060992199,
0.0664733052,
0.0402868018,
-0.0246004425,
-0.0310175624,
-0.0707276538,
0.0329721607,
-0.0193436481,
-0.0279573724,
0.0067559867,
-0.0325448364,
-0.0446352996,
-0.0836134106,
-0.0130555881,
-0.0271192193,
-0.0371792652,
0.0126643879,
0.0291952677,
-0.00319805,
-0.0385836735,
-0.020491058,
-0.0057025794,
-0.0634523109,
0.0254498664,
-0.0552141145,
0.0165483132,
-0.0232690331,
-0.0214026272,
-0.0197223034,
0.0032599785,
-0.0758774802,
-0.0657768771,
0.0027645694,
0.0079171881,
0.016193511,
-0.0070568677,
-0.0194577128,
-0.058690317,
0.063715823,
0.0374375358,
-0.0110101523,
0.0151192099,
0.0541097037,
-0.0110373497,
0.000025024,
0.0294744913,
-0.0562609658,
-0.0093705552,
0.0171723124,
-0.0154092852,
-0.019090673,
0.023610862,
0.0107921744,
0.0477075055,
0.0331027284,
-0.0146282716,
0.000384419,
-0.0043460396,
-0.031224506,
-0.0471307188,
-0.0240696818,
-0.0327060744,
0.0184004176,
0.0256195925,
0.0108222589,
-0.0096488437,
0.0503387116,
-0.027025748,
0.0176295247,
-0.0196751114,
0.0139857121,
-0.038443245,
-0.0191291682,
0.0077202856,
0.0337963626,
-0.0135014402,
0.0343567133,
0.0021720198,
0.0062975329,
0.0027259537,
0.002335649,
0.0025913424,
0.0060526109,
0.0166173931,
0.0613672473,
-0.0694654435,
-0.0100863548,
-0.0412038043,
0.0351886377,
0.0256392565,
0.0019228093,
0.0514552481,
-0.0317268297,
-0.024145782,
-0.0452469774,
0.0112419445,
0.012771328,
-0.0311917644,
-0.0147617431,
-0.0078896927,
-0.0516544096,
0.0195881054,
0.0510733798,
0.0208442062,
0.0153019419,
-0.0125223296,
-0.0593760721,
-0.0251641348,
0.0008008622,
0.0570978895,
0.0358665697,
-0.0324735194,
-0.0411947072,
-0.0483538359,
-0.0734646097,
-0.003547596,
-0.0132272309,
0.026478041,
0.0046511334,
-0.0532991365,
0.0272833686,
0.0105083184,
0.0313298553,
-0.0484551191,
-0.0236373506,
0.0074574118,
-0.0145467771,
0.0149480626,
-5.718400552e-33,
0.013299359,
-0.064486295,
-0.0604953989,
-0.0385409929,
0.0129401973,
0.0740329623,
-0.0153885772,
-0.0150747197,
-0.0071207001,
0.0009793846,
0.0004540518,
-0.0060971943,
-0.0004397371,
-0.0007350367,
-0.0443783216,
-0.0046489229,
0.0316155106,
-0.0003281478,
-0.033964023,
-0.0093507236,
0.0284596924,
-0.0299981069,
0.0033742494,
-0.0641120523,
0.0411381349,
-0.0002445195,
-0.0694380552,
-0.0425073728,
-0.0025423358,
0.0826152712,
-0.0201572608,
0.0250497628,
0.0071138195,
-0.0097016618,
-0.0510556996,
0.0266381782,
-0.0290439539,
-0.0096666571,
-0.0208782237,
0.0214360654,
-0.0214259326,
-0.0480426624,
0.0137544861,
-0.0284457859,
-0.0151880132,
-0.018730972,
0.018738769,
-0.0182545204,
-0.0355135053,
-0.0326067619,
-0.0163089726,
0.0387833491,
-0.0139305256,
0.001917208,
0.0561055876,
0.0309800655,
0.0333293267,
0.0577658638,
-0.0683362857,
0.0243701935,
-0.0001392444,
0.0024731185,
0.0369988456,
-0.0087403199,
0.0092220735,
0.0493143797,
-0.0171616636,
0.0207321886,
0.0204488095,
-0.0199476052,
0.0268077068,
0.006513569,
0.0977510586,
0.0563501492,
0.0761703253,
-0.0202826746,
-0.0344324857,
0.0493624732,
-0.0733854249,
-0.0141237481,
0.0386924632,
0.0353480354,
-0.0262374263,
-0.0060952986,
-0.0593703538,
-0.0481796414,
-0.0171977747,
-0.0373181216,
0.0304940101,
-0.0270278286,
-0.0562301427,
-0.0287563484,
0.0435229279,
-0.0697647259,
-0.0320714004,
-0.0027502077,
-0.0451906547,
0.0475280061,
0.0118341865,
0.0391598605,
0.0200878922,
0.0169624723,
0.0751457065,
-0.0429183245,
0.0145390369,
-0.0297086481,
0.082912609,
0.0022431018,
-0.0892596319,
0.0162346605,
-0.00816119,
-0.0077112308,
0.0242881775,
0.0063314512,
0.015031863,
-0.0625930727,
-0.0080837989,
-0.0296151415,
0.0438220538,
0.0298352856,
-0.0135593228,
-0.0360154957,
-0.0405575521,
-0.0123520438,
-0.013600111,
-0.0064378269,
-0.025285488,
0.0317323841,
0.0513167493,
-0.0225881133,
-0.026161192,
-0.0153339626,
2.44e-7,
0.054037489,
0.0637981445,
0.0185969379,
0.0109744314,
0.0248091668,
0.0339166299,
-0.001554257,
-0.0004792881,
-0.0154238893,
-0.0049028061,
-0.0205514133,
-0.011206774,
0.0809310079,
0.0087426025,
-0.037191838,
0.008805193,
-0.0621687397,
-0.0306833182,
-0.033715222,
0.0112684378,
0.0706144944,
0.1008782908,
0.0111005474,
-0.0181944706,
0.0259823427,
-0.0568664148,
0.0561784506,
-0.0460771546,
-0.0116517134,
-0.0249527451,
0.0397667289,
-0.0082954224,
0.038948521,
-0.0067582172,
-0.0443951935,
-0.0283401161,
0.0415477082,
0.0493837781,
0.0050048288,
0.0249211583,
-0.0450035557,
-0.0240466464,
0.0122912517,
-0.0762448981,
0.0807051808,
0.0715490282,
-0.0321688801,
-0.086745128,
-0.0512571856,
-0.0741530955,
0.1002048329,
-0.0547436401,
-0.0462109521,
0.0164795313,
-0.0144462856,
0.0284597594,
-0.0185904745,
-0.0266617071,
-0.0406084582,
-0.0734738559,
-0.0243420508,
-0.0455906987,
-0.0479683131,
0.0216031205,
0.0701571777,
-0.0507546961,
0.0334198773,
2.691692653e-34,
0.0367841534,
-0.0658438876,
0.0177656487,
0.0275754742,
0.0567930117,
0.0129181119,
0.0473477133,
0.0110932831,
-0.0215228368,
-0.0628352389,
0.0311422553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03758v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03758v1 | Stock Movement and Volatility Prediction from Tweets, Macroeconomic Factors and Historical Prices | 2023-12-04T22:27:43 | 2023-12-04T22:27:43 | Shengkun Wang, YangXiao Bai, Taoran Ji, Kaiqun Fu, Linhan Wang, Chang-Tien Lu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Predicting stock market is vital for investors and policymakers, acting as a
barometer of the economic health. We leverage social media data, a potent
source of public sentiment, in tandem with macroeconomic indicators as
government-compiled statistics, to refine stock market predictions. However,
prior research using tweet data for stock market prediction faces three
challenges. First, the quality of tweets varies widely. While many are filled
with noise and irrelevant details, only a few genuinely mirror the actual
market scenario. Second, solely focusing on the historical data of a particular
stock without considering its sector can lead to oversight. Stocks within the
same industry often exhibit correlated price behaviors. Lastly, simply
forecasting the direction of price movement without assessing its magnitude is
of limited value, as the extent of the rise or fall truly determines
profitability. In this paper, diverging from the conventional methods, we
pioneer an ECON. The framework has following advantages: First, ECON has an
adept tweets filter that efficiently extracts and decodes the vast array of
tweet data. Second, ECON discerns multi-level relationships among stocks,
sectors, and macroeconomic factors through a self-aware mechanism in semantic
space. Third, ECON offers enhanced accuracy in predicting substantial stock
price fluctuations by capitalizing on stock price movement. We showcase the
state-of-the-art performance of our proposed model using a dataset,
specifically curated by us, for predicting stock market movements and
volatility. | [
0.007728646,
0.0734667331,
-0.0283520315,
-0.0439597405,
0.0211595949,
-0.0073976996,
-0.0049809851,
0.0124681266,
0.0060457569,
-0.0276049823,
0.0489232801,
0.0149606541,
-0.0454922169,
0.0669118688,
0.000633355,
-0.0208547916,
0.0122944228,
-0.0042571807,
0.0449308418,
-0.0470736213,
0.0158965811,
0.0014140548,
0.0457818247,
0.0024092046,
-0.0436419435,
0.0075056008,
-0.0094416551,
0.0327685662,
0.0151159894,
0.0113680027,
0.0174675006,
-0.0044140778,
0.0047352891,
0.0653332025,
0.0000018544,
-0.006026166,
-0.0188698694,
-0.0494089201,
0.0440000109,
-0.0280746389,
0.0334289111,
-0.0581762418,
0.0443426184,
0.0076447548,
-0.0966728702,
0.0091590388,
0.0647043213,
0.0439379215,
0.0558558814,
0.0540514365,
-0.0153437033,
-0.0109565994,
-0.0126992045,
-0.0678050444,
0.0219095238,
-0.042264767,
0.0431682244,
-0.0415338725,
-0.0495942757,
0.0136545599,
0.0134955514,
0.0512672737,
-0.0181237068,
0.0490367673,
0.0018360902,
0.0026883243,
0.0000441103,
0.011677105,
-0.0393958762,
0.0164535884,
0.052177012,
-0.010235237,
0.0531042181,
-0.028466953,
-0.0177796688,
0.0778947398,
-0.0283603724,
-0.0305405781,
0.0072687343,
0.0429004394,
0.037800394,
0.0310313739,
0.0082381619,
0.0370375253,
0.0038369664,
0.0443426892,
-0.0608181395,
-0.0289468486,
0.0109464107,
0.0270593129,
0.0303738602,
-0.0209384542,
-0.0134131592,
-0.0178967807,
-0.0267881863,
-0.0019924215,
-0.0267021824,
-0.0508768,
-0.0308331046,
-0.1075818166,
-0.0591182597,
0.0160999652,
0.0548441149,
0.062131118,
0.013134148,
-0.0460901409,
-0.008147425,
-0.0529021882,
0.0366734713,
-0.0098911263,
-0.0747442096,
0.0076495195,
-0.0065189982,
0.0222564396,
0.0080048973,
0.0036892497,
-0.0588702708,
-0.0066343844,
-0.059782777,
0.0263689943,
-0.0492554903,
0.0244924258,
-0.032101538,
-0.0035458482,
-0.030731868,
-0.0091638705,
-0.0260472819,
0.0171688944,
-0.0195170306,
0.0070181345,
0.0279727429,
-0.0178604648,
0.0279742405,
0.0061789933,
0.0026720634,
0.0887690112,
0.0833346397,
0.0154920435,
-0.032374464,
-0.0840698108,
0.0218355842,
0.0025972982,
-0.0280348137,
-0.0261063594,
-0.0046677156,
-0.0077868914,
0.0054933401,
0.0156068141,
0.0044232542,
0.0058923275,
-0.0708408728,
0.0558740757,
-0.0244441871,
-0.0059085013,
0.0088092349,
-0.0358458646,
0.0317684785,
0.0852564424,
0.0071791559,
0.0478241108,
0.086349912,
0.0026911329,
-0.017877847,
0.0217535272,
0.0214995239,
-0.0619553886,
-0.0381928198,
-0.0001765208,
-0.0360141359,
-0.0418026187,
-0.0087781958,
0.0020899023,
0.0338574126,
0.0008056849,
0.0477114432,
0.0143917901,
0.0037106548,
0.0374497287,
0.0096374117,
0.0135819884,
-0.0256327409,
-0.0500421599,
-0.0038885574,
0.0061511733,
-0.0620819181,
0.0072215479,
0.0074796267,
0.0125140743,
-0.0414457843,
-0.026933305,
0.0198292248,
-0.0259202942,
0.0138886459,
-0.0268620644,
0.0195148792,
-0.0871290565,
-0.0256653521,
0.081298463,
0.0572007485,
-0.0098679299,
0.0138510009,
0.0070056817,
0.0293574948,
0.0908689275,
-0.0058589131,
-0.0051974794,
0.0329708196,
-0.0095532285,
0.0279047806,
0.0259606019,
-0.0114860767,
0.0153843137,
-0.0527099185,
-0.0297345277,
-0.0106229614,
0.0580039322,
0.0348376036,
-0.0000922463,
-0.0051333383,
0.030462496,
-0.0025820483,
-0.0112845143,
0.0179336388,
0.0046041869,
0.0112102218,
-0.0234696716,
0.0300804973,
-0.0001725635,
0.0194308367,
0.0452208482,
0.0123592159,
-0.024866879,
-0.0109345922,
-0.0042168521,
-0.0744471997,
0.0188613366,
-0.0362033509,
0.0515531339,
-0.0167030096,
-0.0057891812,
-0.00430765,
0.0148626827,
-0.0378698483,
-0.0341635682,
0.0778140053,
-0.0093994495,
0.0090016201,
-0.0333729126,
-0.1206590533,
0.0074400231,
0.0355152152,
0.0463986099,
0.0256046485,
-0.0164057296,
-0.0008912074,
-0.0350188874,
-0.0223709885,
0.0111485496,
0.0249891225,
0.0285410993,
-0.0075721764,
-0.0105869789,
0.0388697907,
0.0400229134,
-0.0384177119,
-0.0029611134,
-0.0250576492,
-0.0464444011,
-0.03584297,
-0.0286052264,
-0.006282384,
0.0111307511,
0.0264501218,
-0.0144556668,
-0.0157114919,
0.0047707027,
0.0369749442,
-0.0053201765,
-0.0147408359,
0.0334844626,
-0.0092470292,
0.0171905141,
-0.0207825676,
-0.0252892543,
-0.0406113267,
0.0188623182,
0.0501424074,
-0.0453233421,
0.0475089401,
-0.0291063841,
-0.0314794704,
0.0212564059,
-0.000208053,
-0.0025984102,
-0.0379139371,
-0.0206675399,
-0.0098466622,
0.0369044282,
0.0233707409,
0.0121066524,
-0.0193662457,
-0.0123810004,
-0.0102366125,
0.0213554222,
-0.0479695946,
0.0485478342,
-0.0358403474,
0.001012716,
0.0066915671,
0.0533391237,
-0.0172135346,
0.0026252577,
-0.1034943163,
0.0576315671,
-0.0127173904,
0.0285016764,
-0.0324722789,
0.0213464182,
-0.008302276,
0.0483772233,
0.0258896891,
-0.0480359159,
0.0279632807,
0.0333861858,
0.0225365348,
0.0386184007,
-0.0473251566,
-0.0625111759,
0.0246166363,
-0.0054112901,
-0.0174758863,
-0.0098727904,
0.0151883001,
0.0202135146,
-0.0058243815,
0.0079501094,
-0.0291952938,
-0.0008653279,
-0.01462771,
0.0405080579,
0.0412726253,
0.0015756686,
0.0052034939,
-0.0580542982,
-0.0896587372,
0.0168187693,
-0.0016978234,
-0.0458787754,
0.0020077443,
0.0061984793,
-0.0360104963,
-0.0287600197,
-0.0017355829,
-0.0545528345,
0.023804985,
0.0114613185,
0.0485018902,
-0.0162873399,
-0.0139998086,
-0.0338418782,
0.0290470384,
0.0256468114,
0.0399157368,
0.0027046322,
-0.0419850871,
0.0126658436,
-0.006778928,
0.0079251248,
0.0473760366,
0.0113798091,
0.0087006167,
-0.0118519273,
0.0153327314,
0.0811581388,
0.0019335967,
0.0487960428,
-0.0014224069,
0.0483207963,
0.0231269225,
-0.0400511511,
0.010747253,
-0.0526123866,
-0.0258969478,
-0.0313802548,
0.0285199098,
0.0132670682,
-0.061329443,
0.0026060748,
-0.089103654,
0.053754691,
0.0025595373,
-0.0166845545,
-0.0110120177,
-0.0502623618,
0.012683617,
-0.0981592909,
-0.0269571636,
-0.0382003821,
-0.0249872804,
0.0625364184,
0.0215293467,
-0.094105944,
0.0031655543,
0.0331564434,
-0.0301201344,
-0.0313564353,
0.0068722568,
0.0226410776,
-0.0396189466,
0.0314702019,
-0.0723004639,
-0.0188854374,
0.0119709792,
-0.0148282163,
0.0838050097,
-0.0500254147,
-0.026275605,
-0.000408821,
0.0662653446,
-0.042513743,
0.0132778957,
-0.0071431547,
0.0061395415,
-0.0216130298,
-0.0693274811,
-0.0132090272,
0.0639248863,
0.0034053207,
0.0217252076,
0.0045044683,
-0.0470940247,
-0.0517242588,
-0.0579306521,
0.0322386995,
-0.0792962909,
-0.0206857696,
-0.0308071878,
0.0098732421,
-0.0653672516,
-0.0529015809,
-0.0367366821,
-0.0180762578,
0.0331322215,
-0.0276646074,
0.0257040635,
0.071032539,
-0.0032462187,
-0.0356709287,
-0.0220385101,
0.0156886373,
0.0249735918,
0.0523677766,
0.0135875437,
0.017697677,
0.042702049,
-0.0217792951,
0.0340308622,
-0.0707637146,
-0.0647130087,
0.0491438881,
0.0003352031,
0.0286601931,
-0.0034957875,
-0.0154759968,
0.0234421548,
0.0376938432,
0.1105755568,
-0.0556399561,
-0.0383916497,
0.0615822636,
0.047935497,
0.0056137443,
0.0570521243,
-0.0161949638,
-0.0040826234,
-0.0553021282,
-0.023058854,
-0.0529333763,
0.0178039037,
-0.0526380725,
-0.0346877277,
0.0672730207,
0.0289966892,
-0.0553631224,
-0.0060261744,
-0.0537864044,
0.0380201079,
0.0041676541,
-0.0100197392,
-0.0093596298,
0.0159666482,
-0.0183713567,
-0.0581029542,
0.0438673608,
0.0162601229,
-0.0282665715,
-0.0507139675,
0.0124125239,
-0.0490148626,
0.0377839692,
0.0141015528,
-0.0131505392,
0.0218088906,
-0.0423480198,
0.0390363559,
0.0042093303,
-0.0115974611,
-0.0168886129,
0.0089682769,
0.0364701673,
0.0187801365,
-0.0352372266,
-0.0816904753,
-0.0218508597,
-0.0072860462,
0.0173033159,
-0.0006759372,
-0.0361439995,
0.0476529785,
-0.0487983674,
0.0380478464,
0.0337801613,
0.0295836776,
-0.0465106405,
0.0051014069,
0.0137386872,
-0.0146462461,
-0.0841392651,
0.01251336,
0.0539257824,
-0.0155252786,
0.0277721621,
0.0351660028,
-0.0175277237,
-0.0184825696,
0.0040774355,
0.0328154378,
0.0281850901,
0.0069505391,
0.0023335351,
-0.0347445197,
-0.0516242385,
0.0666017458,
-0.0184716824,
0.016297264,
0.0160979815,
0.0232976284,
0.0593584739,
0.0027390346,
0.0901589692,
-0.0001674561,
-0.014113443,
-0.0376752466,
-0.0371539332,
-0.0574040897,
-6.357306344e-33,
0.0201746095,
-0.0244336352,
0.002608486,
0.0058642677,
-0.0007125111,
0.015007467,
-0.0189095773,
0.0271507204,
0.0296451189,
0.0138151934,
0.0241861343,
0.0490920208,
0.012210642,
0.0256964285,
0.0756644383,
-0.0138515113,
-0.0064419056,
-0.0249148458,
0.025544988,
0.0251995139,
0.0350549184,
0.0544087514,
0.0139551042,
-0.0608269945,
-0.0123823937,
-0.02628484,
-0.0387542844,
-0.0521233305,
0.0776021704,
0.0230527855,
0.015652962,
0.0658516735,
0.0273862742,
-0.043897409,
-0.0153056197,
0.0099312682,
0.0038565826,
-0.0759851485,
-0.030499801,
-0.0141606843,
-0.0038220633,
0.0273616072,
0.0383812375,
0.0371149853,
0.0033860505,
0.0334198028,
0.037234664,
0.0371045955,
0.0235367045,
-0.0258968584,
-0.0291250423,
0.0489602499,
-0.0373957977,
0.0490752272,
0.0336766727,
0.0838636979,
0.0584639497,
0.0281785335,
-0.0539391562,
0.0413050577,
-0.0151852127,
0.0214790516,
-0.0190372523,
-0.025804894,
-0.0019628895,
0.0409169793,
0.0220702644,
-0.0037467505,
0.0172382463,
0.0427022278,
0.0049351817,
0.0622938946,
-0.0104092574,
0.0495778508,
0.038637843,
-0.0792139024,
-0.0561236106,
0.0110883452,
0.0041584638,
0.0294061936,
0.0049286857,
-0.007779615,
-0.0130026601,
-0.028686624,
0.031796813,
-0.0238306001,
0.0044770152,
-0.0103063174,
-0.033544641,
0.0040572421,
-0.0024325249,
0.0261988696,
-0.0087368917,
-0.0544720143,
-0.0609720983,
-0.0157498326,
-0.0418448374,
0.0132751195,
0.0277079605,
-0.0167192351,
-0.0201198328,
-0.0342576355,
-0.0255665705,
0.0072685052,
-0.0228235312,
-0.0543332696,
-0.0344409905,
0.0208774433,
-0.0310263783,
-0.0290342178,
0.0216045585,
0.0159055144,
-0.0276216008,
-0.0493008718,
0.0258186795,
0.0290965084,
0.0038339854,
-0.0041684848,
-0.000096592,
0.0406344309,
0.0096568763,
-0.0132033536,
-0.0124110021,
0.0010085035,
0.0056262002,
-0.0210391879,
0.0033307357,
0.0026657982,
-0.0022461978,
-0.0410794094,
-0.0096254572,
0.0220253766,
2.703e-7,
0.0296014231,
0.1080941483,
0.0020907053,
0.0170422383,
0.0463603511,
0.0822229907,
-0.0096169254,
0.0173512604,
-0.0226554945,
-0.0498134568,
0.0212575141,
0.0155894384,
0.0561961755,
0.0317494199,
-0.0692680702,
-0.0514848568,
-0.0440380648,
0.0296644513,
-0.0625439733,
0.0372967906,
0.0131426295,
0.0345715955,
0.0385274366,
-0.0112819159,
0.0112541858,
0.0012157154,
0.0370813869,
-0.0713900253,
-0.0332739167,
0.0104181152,
-0.010877857,
0.0247799642,
-0.0232385546,
-0.0188355166,
-0.0519928671,
0.0179378483,
-0.0132318595,
0.0004819545,
0.0340203904,
0.0361683518,
0.0143428473,
-0.0213384908,
-0.0128151588,
-0.0185283907,
0.0356944948,
-0.0714245588,
-0.0612893589,
-0.0508916266,
-0.0337942839,
0.0813149065,
0.0469080545,
0.0378347486,
-0.0581798926,
0.0148675842,
-0.0156703629,
0.0063887504,
0.0056803697,
-0.043380186,
0.015032989,
-0.0095364414,
-0.0666431114,
0.0270591378,
-0.0038967882,
0.018059561,
0.0404539518,
0.0036594321,
0.0595753193,
1.916761318e-34,
0.0543846078,
-0.0244925059,
-0.0182040092,
-0.0195352286,
0.03080176,
0.0141668357,
-0.0310440287,
0.0243659969,
0.000782909,
-0.0273534264,
-0.0119860042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02337v1 | Measuring Distributional Shifts in Text: The Advantage of Language Model-Based Embeddings | 2023-12-04T20:46:48 | 2023-12-04T20:46:48 | Gyandev Gupta, Bashir Rastegarpanah, Amalendu Iyer, Joshua Rubin, Krishnaram Kenthapadi | cs.CL | cs.CL | An essential part of monitoring machine learning models in production is
measuring input and output data drift. In this paper, we present a system for
measuring distributional shifts in natural language data and highlight and
investigate the potential advantage of using large language models (LLMs) for
this problem. Recent advancements in LLMs and their successful adoption in
different domains indicate their effectiveness in capturing semantic
relationships for solving various natural language processing problems. The
power of LLMs comes largely from the encodings (embeddings) generated in the
hidden layers of the corresponding neural network. First we propose a
clustering-based algorithm for measuring distributional shifts in text data by
exploiting such embeddings. Then we study the effectiveness of our approach
when applied to text embeddings generated by both LLMs and classical embedding
algorithms. Our experiments show that general-purpose LLM-based embeddings
provide a high sensitivity to data drift compared to other embedding methods.
We propose drift sensitivity as an important evaluation metric to consider when
comparing language models. Finally, we present insights and lessons learned
from deploying our framework as part of the Fiddler ML Monitoring platform over
a period of 18 months. | [
-0.0081793042,
0.1080330461,
-0.0363532454,
0.034038499,
-0.0449060425,
-0.0152004911,
-0.0150580285,
0.0227399934,
-0.0031444563,
-0.0436352827,
0.0308250599,
-0.0219666604,
-0.0093921237,
0.0337086171,
0.0207499992,
0.0011157427,
0.0460430011,
0.0080569852,
-0.0309854634,
0.0471014194,
0.0165010784,
-0.0122826267,
0.0221572425,
0.0175762828,
-0.0221107397,
-0.0443850197,
-0.0047651106,
-0.0310816355,
0.0306025669,
0.0117674889,
-0.0200335085,
0.0250904616,
0.047785826,
0.082203649,
0.0000019842,
-0.012698736,
0.0018558044,
0.0127357831,
-0.0213794224,
0.0643646792,
0.0518603213,
-0.0429531708,
-0.0384135582,
0.0238922536,
-0.0406309813,
-0.0090957247,
0.0460147709,
-0.0083779506,
0.0418135114,
0.066361323,
-0.0019182799,
-0.0211897828,
0.0090362402,
-0.0316784568,
-0.0150961038,
0.0064205406,
0.0557096601,
0.0098800473,
-0.0384329855,
0.0122399479,
-0.0665197447,
0.0244186502,
0.0180892218,
-0.0244013872,
0.0126172723,
0.0527416952,
-0.0154864453,
0.0255117901,
-0.0038455657,
0.0674212426,
-0.040833544,
-0.0323324911,
-0.001964537,
-0.0173080992,
0.0161632262,
0.0424236618,
-0.0186109766,
0.0101635847,
0.0443210229,
0.0266832504,
0.0143867629,
-0.0035605247,
0.0590516478,
0.0108458381,
-0.0763325542,
0.0410789363,
0.0022435812,
-0.042933587,
-0.0473755859,
-0.0144380704,
0.0017512481,
-0.0258122683,
0.0191475358,
0.0147972228,
0.0071149264,
0.0264407881,
-0.0195152797,
-0.0404004119,
0.0036058791,
-0.0963046998,
0.0121459905,
0.0151253967,
-0.0454555824,
0.0391307734,
-0.0354380533,
0.0751578137,
0.0002688094,
-0.0111327553,
-0.0392351039,
0.0268841237,
-0.0458310656,
-0.0170458574,
0.0186590757,
0.0042260257,
-0.0179083142,
-0.0425728261,
-0.0071553052,
0.0743565857,
-0.0320921764,
0.0461522415,
-0.0077568484,
0.0012856522,
0.0232410822,
0.0412458666,
-0.0080119101,
0.0390188582,
-0.0183263961,
0.0200820994,
-0.030196147,
-0.008853999,
-0.0326652378,
0.0301910695,
-0.0054219179,
0.011425619,
-0.0100820642,
0.0654471442,
0.0135949086,
-0.0028144903,
-0.042790357,
0.0068953997,
-0.0131111294,
-0.0066530178,
-0.0418439843,
-0.0551685132,
0.0232524648,
0.0059178546,
0.001309765,
-0.0698183179,
-0.0019542458,
0.0146190254,
-0.0457712822,
0.0510923788,
0.0097183436,
0.0098308669,
0.0106193619,
-0.0262600351,
0.0084577091,
0.098890163,
0.062591888,
-0.0135994023,
0.0655326694,
-0.0368551202,
-0.0007849538,
0.0421153978,
-0.0116067212,
0.0002823565,
-0.0581660047,
-0.0202761907,
0.0067968718,
0.0342909843,
0.0463555753,
0.0178286508,
-0.011959604,
-0.03497665,
0.064953275,
0.0929794237,
0.0176812336,
-0.0043988666,
0.0098084277,
-0.0071602701,
-0.0495603755,
0.0042741513,
-0.0057803406,
-0.0256433189,
-0.0179279651,
-0.025159033,
-0.0006115288,
-0.0084218988,
-0.0310191214,
-0.0315043554,
-0.0163300671,
-0.0082394509,
0.0460046418,
-0.0179512985,
0.0567794479,
-0.0306738894,
0.0148695344,
0.0685283169,
0.048216071,
-0.0078112301,
0.0184694156,
-0.0125030018,
0.018433854,
0.0663523152,
0.0513094254,
-0.0469234921,
0.0208891518,
-0.0235320125,
0.0248797517,
0.0296887681,
0.0039596385,
-0.0215299297,
-0.0105146123,
-0.0320322216,
0.0058911191,
0.007140893,
0.0321033634,
-0.0012548697,
-0.0184084885,
0.0358373709,
0.009375439,
-0.094163388,
-0.0278064199,
0.060224779,
-0.041512616,
0.020312883,
0.0310497731,
-0.0008829344,
0.0239631068,
0.0069222162,
-0.0382685214,
0.0100443559,
0.0335622095,
-0.0359963067,
-0.027666498,
0.0124198422,
0.0112499427,
-0.0031164922,
0.0219078474,
0.0014599757,
0.0282145049,
0.0046130419,
-0.0799533203,
-0.0044111866,
0.0324208625,
-0.0372332223,
0.0462194122,
-0.0201220475,
0.0094905682,
-0.050439842,
0.0339066498,
-0.0668530762,
0.0277743451,
-0.0296441298,
0.0270461421,
-0.0400888845,
0.0383732617,
-0.0014729677,
0.0150835142,
-0.0066355988,
0.0383464396,
0.0001327903,
0.0468075424,
0.0120079368,
-0.0356519595,
-0.0075119417,
-0.0329914466,
-0.0464387834,
0.0080460962,
-0.0407553464,
0.0222765543,
0.0438261367,
-0.0115407147,
-0.0111078946,
0.0011673573,
-0.018940337,
-0.0021330083,
-0.002907451,
0.0239155944,
0.0534349382,
-0.0091701141,
0.0061940732,
-0.0380379185,
-0.0129877515,
-0.0291518606,
0.1170510724,
-0.0157589428,
0.0033161796,
-0.1321493685,
0.0207215957,
-0.0348525941,
0.0077528083,
-0.0186505113,
-0.0315614268,
-0.0267887991,
0.0000825934,
0.0467055961,
0.0576529428,
0.0357487947,
0.0659148917,
0.0488701537,
-0.0182214547,
-0.0584051497,
-0.0333202481,
-0.0327589884,
-0.0004667964,
-0.0248460732,
-0.0194976777,
0.0153046697,
0.0424357876,
0.0254309755,
-0.0434398688,
-0.0432663523,
0.0196102485,
-0.0449200124,
0.0252783243,
-0.0368061326,
0.0094069317,
-0.0240841974,
0.0002347101,
-0.0003055966,
-0.0564195625,
0.0520439111,
-0.0217949077,
0.0359501727,
-0.0374034271,
-0.0760298893,
-0.0427087583,
0.0217815153,
0.021819625,
0.0080630025,
-0.0327432901,
-0.0221111067,
-0.0335106254,
0.0156094953,
-0.0088066822,
-0.0277734641,
0.0496467203,
-0.0471165366,
0.0081948005,
0.0089012543,
0.010513464,
-0.0417696349,
-0.0838232636,
-0.0025015553,
0.0266253408,
0.0256902985,
-0.0229448415,
-0.0401271954,
0.0592608005,
-0.0040659397,
0.0311572216,
0.0093561793,
-0.0066241492,
-0.0279668216,
0.0180762373,
0.0138820717,
-0.0199912209,
0.0137130599,
-0.0056879497,
-0.0097193094,
0.0419170856,
-0.0061967592,
0.0232085846,
-0.0770690292,
-0.017238738,
-0.0280676149,
-0.0579635352,
0.0268007889,
-0.0165836904,
-0.0175116565,
-0.0500799194,
-0.0109162936,
0.1095239371,
0.0394393355,
-0.0426578,
0.0306790993,
0.0091384742,
0.0439808033,
0.0280521773,
0.0199568328,
-0.0752683133,
-0.0077737803,
-0.0017931822,
0.0083950898,
0.021561401,
-0.0413265638,
0.017939955,
-0.1074092686,
0.0018551449,
0.0103380345,
-0.0500532836,
-0.0479493216,
-0.0889129564,
0.0185813103,
-0.0156131461,
0.0156315044,
-0.0250502322,
0.0221738815,
-0.0093910843,
0.0358387791,
-0.0745274276,
-0.095128715,
-0.0016484222,
-0.0570531301,
0.0266833585,
0.0776482448,
0.0145388283,
-0.0468521006,
-0.0404953398,
0.0164719075,
-0.0233593043,
-0.0267201196,
0.0118627148,
0.0501375608,
-0.0197316688,
-0.0260402691,
0.0195949059,
-0.0069403504,
-0.0295760799,
0.0145243201,
0.0215642732,
0.0835616216,
0.0064599118,
-0.061207775,
-0.0184342787,
-0.0198729318,
0.0179708358,
0.0546096005,
0.0168268569,
-0.0571796075,
-0.002894786,
-0.0320044123,
0.0221518874,
0.0628524572,
-0.010318622,
0.0082922727,
0.0089209937,
-0.0144399796,
-0.075402528,
0.003349785,
-0.0059324494,
-0.0002422086,
0.0377704017,
0.0143648116,
0.0429337807,
-0.0499258935,
-0.0758387819,
0.0265722275,
-0.0041723237,
0.0387725122,
-0.0201375633,
-0.0005912898,
0.0758101046,
0.0205294192,
-0.0336346477,
-0.0285661407,
-0.1182378456,
-0.0721148327,
-0.0099466024,
-0.0060386844,
0.0123055233,
0.0174051952,
-0.0229471214,
-0.029977072,
0.0732861534,
0.065969713,
-0.034387067,
0.0337872654,
-0.0205401815,
-0.0316388272,
-0.0102792587,
0.0050552133,
-0.0293031093,
-0.0032927922,
-0.0131794848,
0.024020493,
-0.0598470457,
-0.0245262776,
-0.0118284682,
-0.0361171216,
0.0422450192,
0.0453805402,
-0.0482747853,
-0.0360711403,
-0.0054065692,
-0.0009813057,
-0.0322995633,
-0.0112447226,
-0.013432133,
0.0285506025,
-0.0319840834,
-0.0357966758,
0.0434053428,
0.017656954,
0.0180648882,
-0.0183916204,
-0.0143851992,
0.0324341506,
0.0259061381,
0.0330159664,
0.0604441613,
-0.0073870588,
-0.0376306847,
-0.0370331481,
0.0348748453,
-0.0150757106,
0.023827916,
0.0394465625,
0.0009849005,
-0.0262844916,
0.0449251011,
-0.0576887168,
-0.0089561343,
0.0079664616,
0.0157076959,
0.0555908196,
-0.0192781147,
0.0270108934,
-0.0039956984,
-0.010141029,
-0.0314086676,
0.0276467893,
-0.0049373102,
0.0185317956,
0.0220297202,
0.013774679,
-0.0578503869,
0.0272662323,
0.046588067,
0.0193505082,
0.0323471054,
-0.010681171,
-0.0454019047,
-0.024566872,
0.0265662652,
0.0638846755,
0.0132918106,
-0.0074010459,
-0.0062567289,
-0.0504669398,
-0.0598802194,
0.0244363248,
0.0057161385,
-0.0047001685,
-0.0020940755,
-0.0015680449,
0.0824212208,
0.0168222226,
0.0639156401,
-0.0259772614,
0.0142171821,
-0.0340487882,
-0.0453932397,
-0.0493595153,
-6.060934464e-33,
-0.0171457641,
-0.0463883951,
-0.0112794414,
-0.0069940765,
-0.034665063,
0.0209304336,
-0.0052605239,
-0.0108180987,
-0.0092365388,
0.0053100018,
0.0123837441,
0.036129754,
-0.0007928561,
-0.0173199642,
0.0195378438,
-0.0321396366,
0.0399540104,
-0.0000725393,
-0.009266316,
-0.00104321,
0.0518188663,
0.0355149247,
0.0578526333,
-0.0429256409,
0.0094164303,
0.0257703904,
0.0334983505,
0.0007770986,
0.0178152025,
0.0391109586,
-0.0222569369,
0.070915021,
0.0222646762,
0.0044872798,
-0.024654422,
0.0033995376,
-0.0178215299,
-0.0326720402,
-0.0053249588,
0.0391372852,
0.0036461551,
-0.0051948661,
0.0687789172,
-0.0064850147,
0.0133355753,
0.0349067077,
0.0578503795,
-0.0279959757,
-0.0529400147,
-0.0046924576,
-0.0234906916,
0.0413257778,
-0.02911897,
0.013892645,
0.0304658003,
0.0023588398,
0.045264557,
0.0421993285,
-0.1039463505,
-0.012373141,
-0.00070773,
0.0266323481,
0.0503424369,
0.0418632552,
0.0076157842,
0.067079775,
-0.0276826471,
0.0015085337,
-0.020266505,
-0.0108027821,
0.069188267,
-0.0108764488,
0.0309949163,
0.0209543742,
0.0229742993,
-0.0311116632,
-0.0702179,
0.0242594965,
0.0158668831,
-0.0142691983,
0.0576525889,
0.0398389772,
-0.0493693277,
-0.0457516275,
-0.0457708575,
-0.027311096,
-0.0308059417,
-0.030539345,
0.0299410298,
0.0077300887,
-0.0088323765,
-0.0194779877,
0.0099518364,
-0.0802882761,
-0.034783747,
0.03710052,
-0.0430088565,
0.0185672455,
0.0123618627,
-0.0007904939,
-0.0294869486,
-0.0203293189,
-0.0016864953,
0.0151977148,
0.0333910212,
-0.014581874,
0.0209585615,
0.0065101129,
-0.0451332703,
-0.000606144,
-0.0147239482,
-0.0583199225,
-0.0402433909,
0.0279371291,
0.0106730806,
0.0021632717,
0.0131835612,
0.0514339991,
0.0715150535,
0.0082859751,
0.0148607241,
0.0301424339,
-0.0059741479,
0.0109443143,
-0.0425215289,
-0.0134465341,
-0.0145882135,
0.1048006415,
0.0460166782,
-0.0701952204,
-0.0072562955,
-0.0309680104,
2.655e-7,
0.0756653771,
0.0716194585,
0.0180626046,
0.0351907387,
0.045943521,
0.0079062078,
-0.0326982029,
0.0215510279,
-0.0059629572,
-0.0186932348,
0.0041583399,
0.0064466405,
0.0379418172,
0.0299686566,
-0.0506602973,
-0.0244339705,
-0.0860939324,
0.0199678428,
-0.0754218623,
-0.0302124023,
0.043106541,
0.0936249495,
0.0568352975,
0.0173772834,
0.0069040135,
-0.053140711,
0.0462824851,
-0.0398390591,
0.0129894437,
0.000770051,
-0.0117748212,
0.0206829868,
0.0053457273,
0.0151333679,
-0.019478634,
0.0325100608,
0.0029791461,
0.0312516727,
-0.0189388823,
0.0297838748,
-0.040585503,
0.0064666579,
0.0001898239,
-0.0794592723,
0.0660613403,
-0.0407121666,
-0.0170653388,
-0.0408679806,
-0.0104361,
-0.0210242961,
0.050809104,
-0.0058703045,
-0.0325335227,
0.0238604695,
0.0207910594,
0.0191118661,
-0.0179055538,
-0.0998343974,
-0.0277425479,
0.0043577338,
-0.062921226,
-0.0246338025,
-0.0316507705,
-0.0153663615,
0.0363630466,
-0.0116439732,
0.0530919991,
2.815717409e-34,
0.0331859551,
0.0312837064,
-0.0100652641,
0.0236313734,
0.0354951471,
-0.0056221881,
0.0113189463,
0.0013642659,
0.0048486129,
-0.0853134766,
0.0106947152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02334v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02334v1 | An Evaluation Framework for Mapping News Headlines to Event Classes in a Knowledge Graph | 2023-12-04T20:42:26 | 2023-12-04T20:42:26 | Steve Fonin Mbouadeu, Martin Lorenzo, Ken Barker, Oktie Hassanzadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mapping ongoing news headlines to event-related classes in a rich knowledge
base can be an important component in a knowledge-based event analysis and
forecasting solution. In this paper, we present a methodology for creating a
benchmark dataset of news headlines mapped to event classes in Wikidata, and
resources for the evaluation of methods that perform the mapping. We use the
dataset to study two classes of unsupervised methods for this task: 1)
adaptations of classic entity linking methods, and 2) methods that treat the
problem as a zero-shot text classification problem. For the first approach, we
evaluate off-the-shelf entity linking systems. For the second approach, we
explore a) pre-trained natural language inference (NLI) models, and b)
pre-trained large generative language models. We present the results of our
evaluation, lessons learned, and directions for future work. The dataset and
scripts for evaluation are made publicly available. | [
0.0202894881,
0.0683475062,
0.0071236561,
0.0025936314,
-0.0202178229,
0.0279204007,
0.0048501277,
0.0046173432,
0.0713288113,
-0.0895325616,
0.0442844555,
0.0271573104,
-0.0273905825,
0.0387540311,
0.008208964,
-0.0574726723,
0.0322782546,
0.0033554186,
-0.0047650211,
0.0269193351,
-0.0161458701,
0.0644656718,
-0.0128637338,
0.0120285759,
-0.0275913682,
0.0206170939,
-0.023507366,
0.0159910638,
0.037417151,
-0.027865326,
-0.0315012597,
0.0254818257,
0.0416225642,
0.0337494053,
0.0000017313,
-0.0917986259,
-0.0081106219,
-0.011376204,
-0.0023321111,
0.0226701088,
-0.0132631278,
-0.0697459504,
0.0149154328,
-0.0026507354,
-0.0440249033,
-0.0504467338,
0.0123549905,
0.0243826192,
0.0187565722,
0.0856631845,
-0.033938773,
-0.0422903635,
0.0344925225,
-0.0219457243,
0.0064918846,
-0.0777564049,
0.0458855107,
0.0069349338,
-0.0161723401,
-0.0136489859,
-0.001376554,
0.0205367152,
-0.0065575051,
0.0079490179,
0.0028414277,
0.0410704389,
-0.0357284993,
0.0164314527,
-0.0146142831,
0.047164131,
0.0051726182,
-0.0505460687,
0.0386929549,
-0.0105738845,
-0.0320652761,
0.0403598882,
-0.0098869614,
-0.010455708,
0.0046671503,
0.0341035277,
0.0320957452,
0.0113142384,
0.0183530152,
0.0256618056,
0.0050402703,
0.0414817072,
0.0227969754,
-0.0023264925,
0.0101267342,
0.0383125916,
0.0085687172,
-0.0782504678,
0.0023432807,
0.0238754209,
-0.0053021219,
0.0336921476,
-0.0632545799,
0.011860799,
-0.0193247646,
-0.0893128961,
-0.0679441765,
0.0049716937,
0.0605687797,
0.0428527668,
-0.0180772226,
-0.0635629892,
0.0087025883,
-0.0067364322,
-0.0056493888,
-0.0276083406,
-0.0738650858,
0.0427591763,
-0.0069149281,
0.0135482522,
0.0065968223,
-0.0205310434,
-0.0399432108,
-0.0195910819,
0.0337821543,
0.0408275314,
-0.0022612475,
-0.0233297441,
-0.0313164517,
-0.0190368444,
-0.0394930132,
0.0396608263,
-0.0497823544,
0.0338196568,
-0.0537288785,
0.010278305,
-0.0006208498,
-0.0010869993,
0.0182527285,
-0.0089886552,
0.000334944,
0.0549424142,
-0.0054597356,
-0.0057235262,
-0.0946541876,
-0.0230659526,
0.0101691736,
-0.0272612907,
-0.0054731895,
-0.0521645844,
0.0121604521,
0.027963927,
-0.0011705423,
-0.0353113078,
0.0077093318,
0.0006593071,
-0.0838296637,
0.059673544,
-0.0335966125,
0.006833408,
0.0356626026,
0.0006809231,
0.0580343306,
0.0757420361,
0.0640330166,
0.0232720878,
0.0384748802,
0.0194403958,
-0.0191473793,
0.0264588147,
0.0432810895,
-0.0009672749,
0.0092367642,
0.0152008384,
-0.0324854478,
0.0196784064,
0.014746571,
-0.0169940852,
0.0005386015,
-0.0032981699,
0.014891413,
0.0080381222,
-0.0180116333,
0.0231033303,
0.0387713946,
-0.0180239268,
-0.016879661,
-0.0303403307,
-0.0109032243,
0.0068710353,
-0.0567896441,
0.0022865972,
0.0075887633,
0.0338849165,
-0.0442466289,
-0.0018563985,
0.0018414515,
-0.0004572183,
0.0075226161,
-0.0160899423,
0.0668704584,
0.0111490926,
-0.0433422215,
0.0594290532,
0.0314051658,
-0.0014893983,
0.0345848203,
-0.017705543,
-0.0103940777,
0.0479136109,
0.0373150073,
0.0050870054,
-0.0438617021,
-0.0067203562,
0.0408422351,
0.0179983061,
0.0092181992,
-0.0207016133,
0.0014748102,
-0.0236064754,
-0.0241442416,
0.0189254191,
0.0189079624,
0.0192266107,
0.0256699547,
0.0905743539,
0.030274516,
-0.0644040853,
-0.0123735107,
0.0328453146,
-0.0061928225,
-0.039343141,
-0.019363407,
0.0147097195,
-0.0299872141,
0.0302360673,
0.0140402261,
-0.0322174169,
0.0114253275,
-0.0096637895,
-0.029333761,
0.0167639777,
0.0293299034,
-0.0510733686,
0.0085304165,
-0.0579083338,
-0.0197019763,
0.0016812673,
-0.0586209968,
-0.073505193,
0.038993407,
0.0378902741,
0.0200220346,
-0.0092787612,
-0.0143591026,
0.0118482253,
-0.0397314318,
-0.007007089,
0.0868754089,
0.0110719791,
0.0151110822,
-0.0086626112,
-0.0013637099,
0.0126533639,
-0.0091549307,
-0.0610693879,
0.0158263072,
-0.0051534423,
-0.0036328516,
0.0160371382,
-0.039844349,
-0.0689374954,
0.0091331173,
-0.0683353543,
0.0416980051,
-0.0091172373,
0.0405911133,
0.0287721753,
0.0111429067,
-0.025865363,
-0.005947453,
0.0027606711,
-0.0234069023,
-0.0226122662,
-0.0114776362,
0.0182819832,
0.0317920297,
0.0445774198,
-0.0434910171,
0.0022496986,
-0.059016671,
0.0660262033,
0.0354386307,
-0.0451414138,
-0.0251086187,
0.0544789024,
-0.0263371542,
-0.0069729676,
-0.0043361341,
0.0105543192,
-0.0014037673,
0.0175014846,
0.0425344184,
0.0462307967,
-0.0029717975,
0.03207995,
-0.0017727963,
-0.0427093431,
-0.04748144,
0.0265168082,
-0.0369328223,
0.0119670359,
-0.0284685325,
-0.0060542431,
0.0079220962,
0.0157918986,
-0.0043714624,
-0.0058838772,
-0.0651499107,
0.0126697952,
-0.005710199,
0.0306607075,
-0.0082535939,
-0.0059291851,
0.0545658618,
0.0172215383,
0.0314922556,
-0.0018372104,
0.0283970423,
0.0062989541,
0.0618427433,
-0.0215168744,
-0.0246846415,
-0.0300932806,
0.0503674559,
-0.0084855724,
0.0095312437,
-0.0201334953,
-0.0113435751,
-0.0017820488,
0.0121048102,
0.0211427882,
0.0100191068,
0.0088963453,
-0.0234474167,
0.0538878329,
0.0075886282,
0.0175683871,
-0.0226998031,
-0.01777629,
-0.0403691009,
-0.0166682042,
-0.0030268256,
0.0126250545,
-0.0225798599,
0.0570715591,
-0.0207018647,
0.010225879,
0.0197088793,
-0.0443314761,
0.0245321486,
0.0706745163,
0.0550674722,
-0.0357236564,
-0.0140171926,
0.0489145666,
-0.0275412649,
0.0102559105,
0.0626537725,
0.0268610287,
-0.0236773994,
-0.0170731824,
0.0071606324,
-0.0823872536,
-0.0038693855,
-0.0045494759,
0.0202696342,
-0.0250813402,
0.0027546517,
0.1052899733,
0.0595204048,
-0.0283911452,
0.0021650505,
0.0503338166,
-0.0240442231,
-0.0046019726,
0.0196297094,
-0.0557070784,
-0.021612877,
-0.0203250665,
-0.0067667775,
0.0127688376,
-0.0868616998,
-0.001523064,
-0.0959951505,
-0.006111579,
0.0087875053,
0.0013385209,
-0.0278173424,
-0.0860187709,
0.0297140442,
-0.0601638295,
-0.0885603875,
-0.0462664627,
-0.0038906112,
0.0390354916,
-0.0004732568,
-0.0563592575,
-0.0918445364,
0.0112463823,
-0.047895927,
0.0551323891,
0.0075169425,
0.0307551306,
-0.0007787916,
0.0425794087,
-0.0186305046,
-0.0410120934,
-0.0189149026,
-0.0117094768,
0.0798946619,
-0.0532819442,
0.0268943217,
-0.0259220544,
0.0350160934,
0.0027332273,
-0.0346935913,
0.0237155203,
0.0438755266,
0.0061164866,
-0.0222272817,
-0.0085764984,
-0.0125868889,
0.0529683121,
0.0816408545,
-0.0038997948,
-0.0108983191,
-0.008646111,
-0.0312108807,
0.0343943425,
-0.0479983613,
-0.0395687893,
0.0219532382,
-0.0467173718,
-0.0575387329,
-0.0625755787,
-0.0585994534,
0.0339298435,
0.0451308787,
-0.0080560427,
-0.0028370523,
0.0335096866,
-0.0301518012,
-0.0497058034,
0.0254192706,
-0.0243101381,
0.0008314535,
0.0069650598,
-0.0273723491,
0.0616863631,
0.0352646373,
-0.0440159775,
0.0459415279,
-0.0760760978,
-0.0338029899,
-0.0254757386,
-0.0188830681,
0.0173494238,
0.0026534433,
-0.0335259624,
-0.0092162369,
0.0625297278,
0.076203227,
-0.008610094,
-0.0239442885,
-0.0210325476,
0.0333556905,
0.0238156021,
0.0408025756,
-0.0473797545,
0.0440004654,
-0.0141508514,
0.0512119271,
-0.0838883743,
-0.0315827914,
-0.0439968519,
-0.0212867968,
0.0508894175,
-0.0190030281,
-0.0370051451,
-0.0407855809,
-0.010234707,
-0.0135983555,
0.0005712231,
-0.0091277892,
-0.0170459766,
0.0279357303,
0.0478639603,
-0.0677583441,
0.0621119104,
-0.0231226627,
0.0126230661,
-0.0833898112,
-0.0134013956,
0.0768980831,
0.0084577873,
-0.0172692332,
0.0045383852,
-0.0182684101,
-0.009377785,
0.0281242579,
0.016208902,
-0.0298026148,
-0.0212020036,
0.0165916421,
0.0209935736,
0.0030783874,
-0.0153145138,
-0.0639610663,
0.0312350728,
-0.0235319082,
0.0473389514,
0.0570817031,
-0.0302569866,
0.0599716306,
-0.0272852965,
-0.0094501637,
0.044838082,
0.0446098261,
0.0013201939,
-0.026707137,
0.0198738649,
-0.0001491065,
-0.0374481939,
0.0508528538,
0.0500827655,
0.012892046,
0.0726600513,
0.0588413998,
-0.054067567,
-0.0253292769,
-0.0180269629,
0.0286315586,
0.0057078148,
0.0130529888,
-0.0256185271,
-0.060986679,
-0.0482488051,
0.0249104369,
-0.0282079149,
-0.0187656861,
0.0176189244,
0.0115670711,
0.0177480038,
0.040193852,
0.0076832268,
-0.0058613159,
-0.0071670935,
-0.0752596781,
-0.0514261201,
-0.0270867497,
-5.861329645e-33,
-0.0408471525,
-0.0233393684,
-0.0024666341,
0.0092632556,
-0.0028922975,
-0.0068004206,
0.0068436079,
-0.0611206517,
-0.0300805196,
-0.0136659425,
0.0161735509,
0.0060175369,
0.0061689271,
0.0088065974,
0.0029033718,
-0.0338492617,
0.0249306932,
0.0114794429,
-0.0306030884,
0.0249563977,
0.0319862813,
0.0128618386,
0.0805347338,
-0.0692569613,
0.0106676165,
-0.0029358095,
-0.0116632124,
-0.0248991344,
0.1090035588,
0.0226041209,
0.0071133329,
0.0415645204,
0.0227609091,
-0.0432458669,
0.0157242995,
0.0048283124,
-0.074104853,
-0.0528076105,
0.0124665396,
-0.0063975463,
0.0266550966,
0.0087144189,
-0.0009485892,
0.0295230299,
0.054066658,
-0.0361400545,
0.0544492826,
0.0146514941,
-0.0028527263,
-0.0810082182,
-0.0606815442,
0.0491536632,
-0.0472291894,
0.0125271231,
-0.00355753,
-0.0111984201,
0.0053204629,
0.0170681365,
-0.0904853493,
0.0111334547,
0.0353505015,
0.0261912849,
0.0311746206,
-0.0374434888,
-0.0129048843,
0.0330836475,
-0.0259370729,
-0.0045279483,
-0.0563069917,
0.0596365742,
0.0396909118,
0.0192543808,
-0.0089536561,
0.0655055121,
0.0351806879,
-0.0301529113,
-0.1100474149,
0.0710117593,
0.0141615346,
-0.0185642429,
-0.0238366816,
0.017143257,
-0.0219554044,
-0.0190354399,
-0.034009587,
-0.0079806698,
-0.0139064863,
-0.0224625487,
0.0036211787,
-0.0203546043,
-0.0241557229,
0.0821910277,
0.0029113514,
-0.0203470662,
-0.0475206263,
0.0484139919,
-0.0013834438,
0.0416272432,
-0.0077887201,
0.0362564363,
-0.0907902494,
-0.0157582425,
0.0546520725,
0.0360818692,
0.0110209845,
-0.0385250486,
0.0064954381,
0.0332206003,
-0.0479121394,
0.0006517594,
0.0236134026,
-0.0305611882,
-0.0295232944,
-0.0234725643,
0.0198173188,
0.0194980782,
0.0142922802,
-0.008711095,
0.0420787372,
0.0120737879,
0.0672319382,
-0.0190977957,
0.0047751823,
-0.0035446726,
0.0000307719,
-0.0000939513,
0.0067550773,
-0.0025550325,
-0.0032871184,
-0.0519351028,
-0.0100457091,
0.0235583708,
2.553e-7,
0.0567154177,
0.0485144891,
-0.0172036886,
0.0560168065,
-0.0204033703,
-0.0014398299,
0.0537715815,
0.0899708122,
0.0101193376,
-0.0130651603,
0.0139307315,
0.0232422575,
0.0134433191,
0.0650834516,
-0.0587495826,
-0.0340091512,
-0.0345078893,
0.0017570381,
-0.079564251,
-0.010386236,
0.0782387182,
0.0369272307,
0.0486100391,
0.0324452706,
0.0029497286,
-0.0275332816,
0.026622545,
-0.0126371998,
-0.033347778,
0.0143446513,
0.0124858301,
0.0485430732,
-0.0388202854,
0.0794814974,
-0.0368073881,
0.0236819778,
0.0227405131,
0.0082179056,
0.0082469825,
-0.0015424044,
-0.033537101,
-0.0435454808,
0.0009140924,
-0.010684683,
0.0998442098,
-0.0851045623,
-0.0022291185,
0.0447592884,
-0.0378435105,
0.0324836336,
0.0091296779,
-0.0027290867,
-0.0130085023,
0.0311791766,
0.0165749956,
0.0164408349,
-0.0064004543,
-0.0469496995,
0.0182209928,
0.0211213268,
-0.0085739782,
-0.0137742134,
-0.0130767403,
-0.0436782986,
0.0074870703,
-0.0599234067,
0.0338699892,
1.949212998e-34,
-0.0101708742,
0.0340248868,
-0.04963734,
-0.0410420075,
0.0441153347,
-0.0047856281,
-0.0408143885,
-0.0307497587,
0.0068261726,
-0.0782207027,
0.0202023592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02331v1 | Revisiting Topic-Guided Language Models | 2023-12-04T20:33:24 | 2023-12-04T20:33:24 | Carolina Zheng, Keyon Vafa, David M. Blei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | A recent line of work in natural language processing has aimed to combine
language models and topic models. These topic-guided language models augment
neural language models with topic models, unsupervised learning methods that
can discover document-level patterns of word use. This paper compares the
effectiveness of these methods in a standardized setting. We study four
topic-guided language models and two baselines, evaluating the held-out
predictive performance of each model on four corpora. Surprisingly, we find
that none of these methods outperform a standard LSTM language model baseline,
and most fail to learn good topics. Further, we train a probe of the neural
language model that shows that the baseline's hidden states already encode
topic information. We make public all code used for this study. | [
0.0346466899,
0.0705552548,
-0.0148789752,
0.0137442453,
-0.0482475236,
-0.0100017162,
0.0217940118,
0.0090892874,
-0.0443472937,
-0.061687585,
-0.0016477869,
-0.0230391324,
0.0108036203,
0.059714824,
0.0297957696,
-0.0408049412,
0.0362940654,
-0.006288914,
0.0093417,
0.029846875,
0.0104478793,
0.009088953,
0.0036797258,
0.0433699824,
-0.0028817533,
-0.0271950997,
0.0026935134,
-0.02418839,
-0.0248146504,
-0.0083701294,
0.0517345779,
0.054505758,
0.0551438034,
-0.0053411061,
0.0000019372,
-0.0020670316,
0.0044558556,
-0.0583571382,
0.0492246039,
0.0412182547,
0.0738829225,
-0.0239542257,
0.0252249427,
0.0393365026,
-0.0457156561,
-0.0075935638,
-0.003805486,
0.0924572721,
0.0602683425,
0.0703687593,
-0.0104640666,
0.0131619731,
0.032729283,
-0.0434904657,
0.0322836302,
-0.0270295069,
0.0173228197,
-0.0219134726,
-0.0068302504,
0.0439932533,
-0.0227845125,
0.0160669666,
-0.0175521709,
-0.0237241369,
0.0440472551,
0.0239865407,
0.0081278654,
-0.008085927,
0.010050863,
0.055654522,
-0.0177777037,
-0.0109636867,
0.0613081791,
-0.0146247717,
-0.0527759157,
0.0141082592,
-0.0190726463,
-0.0056833196,
0.0244333595,
0.0323467925,
0.0577574745,
-0.0267159119,
0.05211493,
0.0208219998,
0.0084654381,
0.0626761168,
0.0334017351,
-0.0461932942,
-0.0195461195,
0.0012857571,
0.0052813087,
-0.0820459723,
0.0196651239,
0.0084368438,
0.0329386555,
0.0333813354,
0.0002778381,
-0.0497924984,
0.0062691132,
-0.0238904189,
-0.010303597,
0.0170745868,
-0.0430361144,
0.0240318794,
0.0186088774,
0.0066927043,
-0.0096737277,
-0.0201639384,
-0.0275381953,
0.0198351797,
-0.0330319069,
0.0048989533,
-0.0082174959,
0.0179176796,
0.0019338288,
-0.0437612161,
-0.0006436046,
0.0304156002,
0.0408969373,
-0.0232951604,
-0.0178030096,
0.0009687563,
-0.0323656127,
-0.0117555456,
-0.0164535027,
0.0339320786,
-0.0258359853,
0.0316090621,
-0.0186585821,
0.0061009289,
-0.0083520981,
0.0389471948,
0.0109796617,
-0.0171379745,
0.000207296,
0.0068467348,
0.0031837802,
-0.0564187691,
-0.0649608374,
0.0070523107,
-0.0102748405,
-0.0199498348,
0.0242545083,
-0.0592488386,
-0.0107337888,
0.0032052386,
-0.0014809747,
-0.0306688584,
0.0274457075,
0.0615091138,
-0.0287406463,
0.0838752836,
-0.0223168358,
-0.0093685146,
0.0532242022,
0.0343607925,
0.0505343042,
0.05998528,
0.0356858596,
0.0459313355,
0.017017873,
-0.0046060262,
0.0039821244,
-0.00244898,
0.0099821342,
-0.0077573871,
-0.0191555284,
-0.0076484149,
0.0050502392,
-0.0192832984,
0.0317046158,
0.0367479436,
-0.0203582775,
-0.0059738681,
0.030360112,
0.0898524374,
0.0169594027,
0.0370554142,
-0.0124028539,
0.040648669,
0.0011985315,
-0.0183976386,
0.0132162524,
-0.0284942407,
-0.0007839688,
-0.007918844,
0.0095878644,
-0.0283313207,
-0.0525307208,
-0.0537857041,
-0.0373535194,
-0.066017136,
0.028277006,
-0.028976053,
0.0795657262,
0.0230984297,
-0.0020831411,
0.0464493856,
0.0471591055,
-0.0536499321,
-0.006810728,
-0.0213360675,
0.051144626,
0.0495587774,
0.0586050116,
-0.0372198783,
0.0035291794,
-0.0313452594,
0.0334671699,
0.0482385457,
0.0095591219,
0.0097678686,
0.0267909616,
-0.0688628182,
0.0051842835,
-0.0427061431,
0.0342855752,
0.0256635044,
-0.0217414424,
0.0073395073,
0.020007126,
-0.061076656,
0.0327100232,
0.0663437843,
-0.0255502276,
-0.0064042872,
0.0328645036,
-0.030680988,
0.0419752598,
-0.0114968223,
0.0077614412,
0.011787816,
0.0352958702,
-0.0555450656,
-0.0443146601,
-0.0345738195,
-0.044914186,
-0.0441027842,
-0.0115131773,
-0.0322233997,
0.0307429656,
0.0282804221,
-0.0178703554,
-0.0444431417,
0.0707770512,
-0.0389959849,
0.0026408669,
-0.0542355627,
0.0016769165,
-0.012501535,
0.0138487266,
-0.0258436911,
0.0386566445,
-0.0280995406,
0.0195651632,
0.0082644252,
-0.0061116624,
-0.0041440823,
-0.0339819714,
-0.00618516,
0.0133338943,
0.0121782953,
-0.0012008742,
0.0602118894,
0.0410372019,
-0.0065110712,
-0.0313092656,
-0.09171132,
-0.0019015161,
-0.041528713,
-0.0004522185,
0.0210282803,
0.023163924,
-0.0051109064,
-0.0403922275,
-0.0188959781,
-0.0374829844,
-0.0158171393,
-0.0095026819,
0.0566642694,
-0.0047753444,
0.0055705942,
-0.1145305932,
-0.0223914217,
-0.0470103435,
0.0326249935,
-0.0360097699,
-0.0598387755,
-0.0387923196,
0.0387023464,
-0.0080611911,
0.0023447778,
-0.0379365198,
-0.0059951954,
0.0165471938,
-0.0358254313,
0.0856563821,
0.0550797656,
0.035691794,
0.0462353751,
0.0812373906,
-0.0083535537,
-0.0423723608,
0.0147363935,
-0.0233048405,
0.0554445162,
-0.0132043418,
-0.020232074,
0.0371938907,
0.0861977041,
0.0230036173,
0.0245024711,
-0.025289122,
-0.0112405205,
-0.0364967287,
0.0082562203,
-0.0376289748,
0.0072978707,
-0.0142118521,
0.0132119283,
-0.0150564099,
-0.0562004969,
0.0381237455,
-0.0208345968,
-0.005124168,
-0.0538780503,
-0.0405937843,
-0.0545059144,
0.0345011614,
0.0518918931,
-0.0109897591,
-0.0170006305,
-0.0347722992,
0.00329501,
0.0096726073,
-0.0247105844,
0.0036128317,
0.0287861675,
-0.0426006801,
0.0186996125,
0.0292193666,
0.0088642919,
-0.0486501083,
-0.0802616626,
-0.0129095335,
-0.018232286,
-0.0128151746,
-0.0040797852,
-0.0170031693,
-0.0038903404,
0.0265665725,
0.0291249007,
0.0016724331,
-0.0058884639,
-0.0136930598,
0.03009535,
0.0707936734,
-0.0728802606,
-0.0317652337,
-0.0229914729,
0.0296520498,
0.0363139175,
0.0441796184,
0.0047277072,
-0.0544474423,
0.0201651957,
0.0150923301,
-0.0389966555,
-0.0191263482,
0.0270401519,
0.020155564,
-0.0595191568,
-0.014189288,
0.1358377188,
0.0380925462,
-0.042752061,
-0.0147891445,
0.0012844387,
0.0047197193,
0.010010438,
-0.0042969803,
-0.0512378663,
-0.0306890327,
-0.0280212723,
0.0171153806,
0.0278900396,
-0.0227556862,
-0.0183832292,
-0.0353480577,
-0.0357971638,
-0.0106976973,
0.0130055593,
0.0040182867,
-0.0658977404,
0.0062898495,
-0.0197691713,
0.0099174818,
-0.0292480942,
-0.0285995044,
0.0042164405,
0.0033441063,
-0.0754854754,
-0.0397962295,
0.0087194573,
-0.0320883989,
0.0482083,
0.0611726455,
0.0424095578,
-0.0115903765,
-0.0019648937,
0.0014146286,
-0.0108783348,
0.0095103318,
-0.0184927527,
0.0259012971,
-0.0471838042,
-0.0010928491,
0.0088326558,
0.0075411582,
-0.0849923044,
-0.0116886543,
-0.0050646276,
0.0373511501,
-0.0559820831,
-0.0506647527,
-0.007591201,
0.0000176241,
0.0131937377,
0.089044176,
0.0424470045,
-0.0736285448,
-0.0350536518,
0.0062600207,
0.0363819599,
0.0104854777,
-0.0160873793,
-0.0536480024,
0.0301350281,
0.0010946877,
-0.0598751158,
-0.0615449473,
0.0240417626,
-0.0312437918,
-0.0246650968,
0.0349246599,
-0.0021283601,
-0.030599976,
-0.0154545968,
0.0476536006,
-0.0127590643,
-0.0115789892,
-0.061062783,
-0.0690227747,
0.0331760347,
0.009823163,
-0.0124917831,
-0.00005198,
-0.113306649,
-0.0584725887,
0.0230826177,
-0.0116644641,
0.0150239328,
0.0246492997,
-0.0392858237,
-0.0591615438,
0.0159836859,
0.0003530019,
-0.0644756258,
0.0050241468,
0.0072181178,
-0.0034778912,
0.0060181776,
0.0229062755,
-0.0254223514,
0.0372223333,
0.0129269296,
0.0256234258,
-0.0760137886,
-0.0505202189,
-0.0162964333,
-0.0381779708,
0.1013385504,
0.0141943591,
-0.0042937556,
-0.0702810511,
-0.040278621,
-0.0046553491,
0.0206560139,
-0.0397983044,
-0.0047554737,
0.0301785804,
-0.010258479,
-0.0455374718,
0.005623986,
-0.0418973751,
0.0163833387,
0.0029255145,
-0.0017307523,
0.0051348601,
0.0427502096,
-0.0392375737,
0.0146184666,
-0.0009476852,
0.0332161188,
-0.0126011604,
0.0057305107,
-0.017058963,
0.0324575901,
-0.0196313243,
-0.0114262272,
0.0006086751,
0.0279622246,
-0.0795478299,
-0.022023214,
0.0046125725,
0.0294359028,
0.0412365459,
-0.0240565836,
0.0354146697,
-0.0308791474,
0.0164245535,
-0.0286519155,
0.0590002872,
0.0085764853,
0.0085350061,
0.0193231348,
0.017047042,
-0.0559241474,
0.0162254591,
0.0828106552,
0.0656412095,
0.0187640693,
0.0342155322,
0.0114551494,
-0.0256747343,
0.0648187995,
0.0402253866,
0.0518993735,
-0.0302969608,
0.0499169677,
-0.0090388302,
-0.0226505138,
0.0294833686,
-0.0489788689,
0.0007481899,
0.0096309911,
0.0581799932,
0.0614104085,
-0.0300459452,
0.0351135358,
-0.0702920705,
0.0045614382,
0.0077387849,
-0.0482589975,
-0.0865002275,
-7.125443413e-33,
-0.0253621209,
-0.0100358631,
-0.0048566204,
0.043958284,
0.0429117829,
0.0193384662,
-0.0574662313,
0.001541241,
0.0005490941,
0.0050883903,
-0.0046515488,
0.0738558248,
-0.0004238354,
0.022338219,
0.0028030737,
-0.0090351384,
0.0761227608,
-0.0135027291,
0.0012028641,
0.0273566023,
0.0280588139,
0.0587490723,
0.0692152977,
-0.0461965725,
0.0147063397,
-0.0213601571,
0.0047342512,
0.0125688128,
0.0679589137,
0.0285603795,
-0.0271428227,
0.0306094307,
0.0307366215,
-0.0145872161,
-0.0322291479,
0.0650398731,
-0.0259805433,
-0.0795350522,
0.0026564347,
-0.0440032855,
-0.0388581045,
-0.0278082322,
0.0237275567,
-0.0050306525,
0.0044600959,
0.0330401212,
0.0817393661,
0.0306731444,
-0.0207062494,
-0.0308279414,
-0.0270333942,
0.041107446,
-0.018009413,
-0.0088184122,
0.0106621748,
-0.0200446695,
0.0015741209,
0.020034546,
-0.0245780703,
0.0155204078,
0.010111223,
0.0499563254,
0.0034619709,
-0.0173399653,
-0.0090954779,
0.06779854,
0.0005003954,
0.0331618972,
0.0071023707,
0.0087606031,
0.0564971715,
0.0398619473,
0.0399992801,
-0.0433140583,
0.0111907767,
0.0114382757,
-0.0441689193,
0.0347559974,
0.0286299568,
0.05169129,
0.0031856864,
-0.000165773,
-0.0395930223,
-0.0301816724,
-0.0309714656,
-0.0117407143,
-0.0179246366,
-0.0302804559,
0.0151890637,
0.033874549,
-0.0174986627,
-0.0307782684,
0.0218440816,
-0.0162485112,
0.0202498399,
0.0341349691,
-0.0111560142,
-0.0127372984,
0.0401848853,
0.0252759233,
-0.1190989763,
-0.0114013506,
0.0193962846,
0.0050534452,
-0.009031726,
-0.0122994063,
-0.0257138535,
0.0106041646,
-0.0688822344,
-0.031847991,
-0.004544944,
-0.0285210293,
-0.0334488191,
0.0238061976,
0.0298893731,
0.0247787759,
-0.0214492232,
0.0929208845,
0.0071428479,
0.0116162021,
-0.0420051292,
-0.0813187361,
-0.0036220951,
0.0281289406,
-0.0063977926,
-0.0188981742,
-0.019998217,
0.0407622717,
0.0674922392,
-0.0327017717,
0.00552171,
0.0032916106,
2.68e-7,
0.0431586169,
0.0831517354,
-0.0300215166,
-0.012917581,
0.0086654965,
0.030993497,
-0.0306443609,
0.0113950102,
-0.0008605412,
-0.0235279128,
0.0162136685,
0.0214102026,
0.0327388868,
0.0231737103,
-0.0768393278,
0.0410503447,
-0.0754010379,
0.0134413829,
-0.0494256429,
-0.0252512936,
-0.0012856099,
0.0975137576,
0.0229039788,
-0.0087702023,
-0.0076210923,
-0.0455364399,
0.0948199853,
-0.0465088785,
-0.0695799217,
0.0187954362,
0.0656735674,
0.0445758067,
0.008050561,
-0.0422329754,
-0.0439767726,
0.0376196243,
0.0277612843,
0.0668376908,
-0.011341257,
-0.021364307,
-0.0130244112,
-0.000878384,
-0.0301260166,
0.0050309584,
0.0492056422,
-0.0103013795,
-0.006686803,
-0.0454225652,
0.0221911538,
-0.0063365577,
0.0638685971,
0.0013188955,
-0.066103071,
0.0247988924,
-0.0065670181,
-0.0366774686,
0.0008712248,
-0.080373697,
-0.0161959678,
0.0023928266,
-0.0415075645,
-0.0003186767,
-0.0476946086,
0.008613253,
0.0003609501,
-0.0427886285,
0.0131218201,
2.409503066e-34,
0.0375000127,
-0.0130373565,
-0.0441420414,
0.031863831,
0.0195104461,
0.0075672301,
-0.0402243547,
-0.0036738368,
0.0051786923,
-0.0732551143,
0.0000556275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02317v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02317v3 | GNN2R: Weakly-Supervised Rationale-Providing Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs | 2023-12-04T19:58:07 | 2024-01-20T21:16:09 | Ruijie Wang, Luca Rossetto, Michael Cochez, Abraham Bernstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Most current methods for multi-hop question answering (QA) over knowledge
graphs (KGs) only provide final conclusive answers without explanations, such
as a set of KG entities that is difficult for normal users to review and
comprehend. This issue severely limits the application of KG-based QA in
real-world scenarios. However, it is non-trivial to solve due to two
challenges: First, annotations of reasoning chains of multi-hop questions,
which could serve as supervision for explanation generation, are usually
lacking. Second, it is difficult to maintain high efficiency when explicit KG
triples need to be retrieved to generate explanations. In this paper, we
propose a novel Graph Neural Network-based Two-Step Reasoning model (GNN2R) to
solve this issue. GNN2R can provide both final answers and reasoning subgraphs
as a rationale behind final answers efficiently with only weak supervision that
is available through question-final answer pairs. We extensively evaluated
GNN2R with detailed analyses in experiments. The results demonstrate that, in
terms of effectiveness, efficiency, and quality of generated explanations,
GNN2R outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods that are applicable to this
task. Our code and pre-trained models are available at
https://github.com/ruijie-wang-uzh/GNN2R. | [
0.0326091684,
0.0124686174,
0.0269233789,
0.0217333771,
-0.0104512423,
0.0253270324,
0.0130019058,
-0.0256751552,
0.0492473096,
-0.0102049885,
0.0321564153,
0.0256582946,
-0.0251212735,
0.0289166011,
0.030702604,
-0.0353271551,
0.0211151727,
-0.0208595619,
0.0147461956,
-0.0040299785,
-0.0028526695,
0.0828579292,
-0.0317254215,
0.0326446854,
-0.018170137,
-0.0324283354,
-0.0443466865,
0.0149555895,
0.0091673406,
-0.0116252657,
0.0016971583,
0.0087905107,
0.0404275246,
-0.0223490689,
0.0000020008,
-0.0013170561,
-0.0156612284,
0.0174527299,
-0.05954073,
-0.0152976969,
-0.0791843086,
0.0184111465,
0.0494613685,
0.0160948783,
-0.0397103392,
0.0067622466,
0.0215885174,
0.0612027682,
0.0872776285,
0.0261319596,
-0.0069319988,
-0.0533956885,
-0.0286388546,
-0.0205553044,
0.0116845835,
-0.0727114752,
0.0176341832,
0.040541105,
0.0014488251,
0.0045465608,
-0.0087816278,
-0.0028647345,
0.051842127,
-0.0369468182,
-0.0030112325,
0.0102493688,
0.0001631833,
0.0195042286,
-0.0043421518,
0.1362858862,
0.0002339375,
-0.0201910492,
0.0180203933,
-0.0084511843,
0.0013245038,
0.0254204609,
-0.0580237657,
-0.013844071,
-0.0297286119,
-0.01754844,
-0.0440383218,
-0.0189502463,
0.0488378406,
-0.0001098164,
-0.0079766633,
0.0739595369,
-0.0112332618,
0.018363297,
0.0155063905,
0.0095844641,
-0.0549590029,
-0.057897795,
-0.0082595162,
0.0922714323,
-0.0511564203,
0.0201619491,
0.017982807,
0.0189298838,
0.0016651461,
-0.0011485856,
-0.0072166417,
0.0317962654,
0.0164346602,
0.0708226636,
-0.0282423478,
0.0327096395,
-0.0260064118,
0.0432048514,
-0.0243644044,
-0.0383556113,
-0.0608870462,
-0.031709563,
-0.0468028747,
0.0589403175,
-0.0424011834,
-0.0335570537,
-0.0325325206,
0.0228797123,
-0.0174898449,
0.0040606223,
0.046478048,
0.0860309824,
0.0343573056,
-0.0062856311,
-0.037224032,
0.0294175204,
-0.1171829402,
0.0265510976,
0.0396528244,
0.0008359374,
-0.0311390683,
0.0151592763,
0.0578549579,
-0.0147172417,
0.0014545827,
0.0669428185,
0.0194061492,
0.0430670381,
-0.0403217971,
-0.0696683154,
-0.0004057012,
-0.0607908145,
-0.0187906455,
-0.027078595,
0.057615716,
0.0083365096,
-0.0338812806,
-0.0302020889,
0.0180515237,
0.0183649566,
-0.0458351187,
0.0647704974,
-0.0228514802,
0.0006951836,
-0.0138093792,
0.0137050748,
-0.0676557794,
0.0400578231,
0.0051181186,
0.0120622041,
0.0369706787,
-0.0063057528,
-0.0031095289,
-0.024104597,
0.0517080128,
-0.0218157787,
0.0323036537,
0.0232640989,
-0.0426921025,
0.0264557488,
0.0047626649,
0.0303796772,
-0.0316533484,
-0.0079622967,
-0.0025523971,
0.0293804854,
0.0044667851,
0.0047250325,
0.069697991,
0.0060352599,
-0.0022260973,
0.0278609693,
-0.0345440134,
0.0667245761,
-0.022864325,
-0.0001171335,
-0.0100008585,
-0.0162933227,
-0.0334545597,
-0.0296244957,
0.0253555831,
-0.0041644596,
0.0362751521,
0.0407040119,
0.0442035794,
0.0267012827,
-0.0421366952,
0.0418583862,
0.0228790957,
-0.004882148,
0.0119177373,
-0.0422536358,
0.0566025004,
0.0862278342,
0.0415884778,
0.0245842412,
-0.0340269692,
-0.0120700095,
0.0433413833,
-0.0183320995,
0.0185745563,
-0.047550045,
0.0199307427,
-0.0660093129,
-0.0460354425,
-0.0781349614,
-0.0120972954,
0.019021783,
0.03655947,
-0.0086349146,
0.0313855559,
-0.0780898035,
0.0038232096,
0.0081234621,
0.0026927833,
0.0093007525,
0.0098324139,
0.0074044452,
-0.0134884994,
0.054864835,
0.0424841344,
0.0369432345,
0.0281519294,
0.011840919,
-0.0528064221,
-0.0097416826,
-0.0281137303,
-0.077692084,
0.0130558927,
-0.003883193,
-0.0344147123,
0.0035296672,
-0.0473165363,
-0.0655749962,
0.0210674684,
-0.0004135205,
0.021084724,
-0.0267073698,
-0.0663248077,
0.0497091711,
-0.0240652636,
-0.0278446916,
0.0587702468,
0.0098482771,
-0.0070099682,
-0.0053810398,
0.0042702532,
-0.0021178359,
-0.0250020158,
0.0439633876,
0.0000169098,
-0.0083204499,
-0.0100998292,
0.0003639494,
0.0071057109,
-0.0544620305,
0.0246353243,
-0.0562419482,
0.0249095354,
-0.0324037001,
0.0194882639,
0.0236862432,
0.0203242283,
0.0531256869,
-0.0213522762,
-0.0850580931,
0.0489366688,
-0.0001526035,
-0.0106489612,
0.0325103477,
0.0085990503,
0.0077199214,
-0.0098585896,
-0.0159449987,
-0.0346894488,
0.0741087869,
0.0270900559,
-0.0039876243,
-0.0249855779,
-0.0229309294,
-0.0591718182,
0.0029489871,
-0.0150996223,
0.0022440255,
0.0403536372,
-0.0314309299,
0.0045328946,
0.016776884,
-0.0256626047,
0.0306323618,
0.0029795608,
-0.0053290743,
-0.0580045804,
0.0245462582,
-0.0475970954,
0.0017991383,
-0.0161051378,
-0.0029507224,
-0.0219975989,
0.0280145351,
0.0144025916,
-0.0208812337,
-0.0600936674,
0.0389789864,
0.0338536613,
0.0411325917,
-0.0430445075,
-0.0453492776,
0.0276798457,
0.0174367279,
-0.0324568711,
0.0306834932,
0.1134158224,
0.0203134064,
-0.0088436101,
0.0135261929,
-0.0123245893,
-0.0675833151,
0.0611208603,
-0.0320836008,
0.0149003025,
-0.0149543891,
-0.0038767634,
-0.0097306799,
-0.0439653508,
0.0275797565,
0.0035033231,
0.0153494561,
-0.0287130345,
0.0217285696,
0.0198934581,
0.0007481684,
-0.0112249963,
-0.0046054986,
-0.0305903163,
0.0286993384,
-0.0201570671,
-0.0095375124,
0.0389625244,
0.020364143,
0.0037656913,
0.0225923192,
-0.0292826369,
0.0099303247,
-0.0256638471,
0.0407669209,
0.0692847669,
0.0345885418,
0.0186809823,
-0.0263127331,
0.0503943376,
0.0575685017,
0.0194607675,
-0.0184777472,
-0.0025956451,
0.006477288,
-0.0347246677,
-0.0076960283,
0.0089190062,
-0.0170621183,
0.0799158365,
-0.0716542602,
0.0181994122,
0.0847400352,
0.0106810117,
-0.0131161092,
0.0019775019,
-0.0105684102,
0.0164118689,
0.0173926372,
0.0236639138,
-0.0749024153,
-0.0526897646,
-0.0249134805,
0.0496155806,
0.0345758386,
-0.0496938787,
0.0084262313,
-0.0664955452,
-0.0014664094,
-0.0282498617,
-0.0363922715,
-0.0519506671,
-0.0451686531,
0.0054506222,
-0.0052427822,
-0.0172996335,
-0.0038762183,
0.0266117249,
0.0132818604,
0.0336568244,
0.0007634928,
0.0032806965,
0.0590498708,
-0.0251111556,
-0.0051153572,
0.0247770529,
0.0357181989,
0.0322439782,
-0.0124269128,
0.0182592645,
-0.0371053852,
0.0174116176,
0.0006392371,
0.0481879972,
0.0138425389,
-0.0150150508,
-0.0443050079,
0.0648191422,
-0.0810314119,
-0.0165834334,
0.0140155591,
0.0727257058,
-0.0238444973,
-0.0435448848,
0.0042052451,
0.0104111824,
-0.0012658716,
0.049113106,
0.0579545721,
0.0054297498,
-0.0575623065,
-0.0496338718,
-0.0122663192,
-0.0878890753,
-0.0084447153,
0.016722206,
0.0410547182,
0.0325117521,
-0.0480505712,
-0.0589219593,
0.0642534196,
0.0403579921,
-0.0311794691,
0.0117872022,
0.0102392482,
-0.0152049018,
-0.024587648,
0.033270862,
-0.0161423348,
0.0239368975,
0.0121940868,
-0.019091133,
0.0161116477,
-0.0141818495,
-0.0179246739,
0.0064403447,
-0.035487216,
-0.0327500664,
-0.04873145,
0.0243061092,
0.0187526625,
0.0610669293,
-0.0387126431,
-0.0051851217,
-0.0108481245,
-0.0223575849,
-0.0307688117,
-0.0457302257,
0.0326179452,
0.0000534651,
-0.0323686153,
0.0313043334,
-0.0836079493,
-0.0225712433,
-0.0092530185,
0.0871718153,
-0.0491438098,
-0.0315788649,
0.0171373021,
-0.0038511043,
-0.0126202414,
0.0297548752,
0.0152835557,
-0.0388852023,
0.0214182548,
-0.029359011,
-0.0169870965,
-0.0394805819,
0.025110051,
-0.0053234748,
-0.0496048294,
-0.009874546,
-0.0645357221,
0.0175740235,
0.0046064015,
-0.0113347387,
-0.0308055487,
0.0183508117,
-0.0255308598,
0.0218326021,
-0.0093920426,
-0.0373871475,
0.0221053381,
0.0163574349,
0.0215536896,
-0.0248604659,
0.0685982257,
0.0507727526,
-0.0018698948,
-0.0344383381,
-0.0065104887,
-0.0606585033,
-0.0479281768,
0.0116051603,
0.0020866981,
0.013820515,
0.0290816333,
0.0295120906,
0.0326027349,
-0.0226423629,
0.0142535334,
0.0604519993,
0.0253331251,
-0.0283048656,
0.02465377,
0.0376359634,
-0.0038866915,
0.0289497767,
0.0568091795,
0.0051148739,
0.0367220044,
-0.019678928,
-0.0399520174,
-0.0144333169,
-0.0399355441,
-0.0362134315,
0.0362223163,
0.0055507584,
0.0015756517,
-0.0260558128,
-0.0802467093,
-0.0437174737,
-0.0062386249,
-0.0291888155,
0.0058721784,
0.036131151,
0.0385947898,
0.033396598,
-0.0575383976,
-0.0537306927,
0.0132365935,
-0.0474655069,
-0.0040377183,
0.0063262885,
-6.1692919e-33,
-0.0006672502,
-0.0838824213,
0.0247150399,
-0.0271707624,
-0.0144113414,
-0.0024553726,
-0.0693577304,
-0.0386314392,
-0.0483204797,
0.0421536863,
0.0086586848,
0.0087958435,
-0.0075384434,
0.0253674705,
-0.009208357,
-0.0325586572,
-0.0044271061,
0.0316921175,
0.0058685429,
0.0730322972,
0.0581592657,
0.0223574638,
0.0231385138,
-0.0179685187,
0.0339687243,
-0.0167849436,
-0.0013402653,
0.0334406421,
-0.0665704235,
0.0589369982,
0.0000636045,
0.01798914,
0.0314954035,
-0.0257721525,
0.0296212658,
0.000775684,
-0.1390719414,
-0.0413022749,
0.0080139246,
-0.0158244837,
-0.0944351926,
-0.0284548569,
0.0136713684,
-0.0050649154,
0.0904174745,
-0.0306978133,
0.0401414819,
0.0453028679,
-0.0184911452,
-0.0382552594,
0.0046469863,
0.0104024205,
-0.0570258759,
-0.0285816491,
-0.0463551916,
0.0372123457,
0.0030518412,
-0.0139128678,
-0.0251041986,
-0.0254070796,
-0.0111910868,
-0.0431316905,
0.0147027075,
-0.017787518,
-0.0202936418,
0.0384228043,
-0.0153426314,
-0.0092112347,
-0.0867109746,
0.0211523678,
-0.0583254546,
0.0573148951,
0.0675527677,
-0.0090216631,
-0.0023917279,
0.0258439817,
-0.1098476276,
0.0209846329,
-0.0070086271,
0.0422374085,
0.0002697326,
-0.0213135369,
-0.0011897883,
-0.054132849,
-0.0424430929,
0.0054148324,
-0.0380778722,
-0.0501266457,
0.0201755185,
-0.0178720914,
-0.0522966236,
0.0106646335,
-0.0170306414,
-0.0666064397,
0.0213680863,
0.0789246336,
-0.0022751493,
-0.0034206398,
0.000701128,
0.0400887355,
-0.0167131629,
0.0321607739,
0.0440754779,
-0.0182163361,
0.0174574628,
0.0377274156,
0.0475512594,
-0.0029572677,
0.001133136,
-0.0067708814,
-0.0849556699,
0.0053629745,
-0.0449504927,
-0.0125187291,
0.0177999195,
0.0600214303,
-0.0229437891,
0.0296474844,
0.0059609078,
0.0481045209,
0.0126462551,
0.0210982878,
0.014928095,
0.0157649834,
-0.0242748745,
-0.0194145627,
-0.0258813482,
-0.008309097,
-0.0065645943,
-0.0535234623,
-0.0106683737,
0.0406682491,
2.595e-7,
0.0404765382,
-0.0031452577,
0.0346115865,
0.0286270715,
0.00989231,
0.0101562208,
0.0389862284,
-0.029147815,
-0.0095388833,
-0.0378641374,
0.0150960404,
0.0692575127,
-0.0100177871,
0.0404224396,
-0.0406265073,
0.0140684796,
-0.038629666,
-0.0648946762,
-0.0392203517,
0.0047780415,
0.0760289505,
0.0041169669,
0.0382545255,
-0.0081026899,
0.0000080316,
-0.0329942703,
0.0286208242,
0.0511429049,
0.0126617895,
0.0111853313,
0.0582743026,
-0.0164571628,
0.0111165987,
0.0374674387,
-0.0144422334,
-0.0095314048,
0.0112936655,
0.0576542355,
-0.010355996,
-0.0514368899,
-0.0182478558,
-0.0415214673,
0.0660262778,
-0.0374026708,
0.1036500335,
-0.0397387259,
-0.0387658142,
0.0156243052,
-0.024070777,
-0.0398742221,
-0.028489111,
-0.0175694451,
0.0267187003,
0.0110099893,
0.0035175479,
-0.0213760324,
0.0357430838,
-0.1068054587,
-0.01177915,
0.0320675373,
-0.0007365791,
0.0068252529,
0.0152404783,
-0.008052757,
0.0414021797,
-0.0136086894,
-0.0078938771,
2.081059842e-34,
0.0178574156,
0.0182954092,
0.0042417939,
0.0085232519,
0.0532664657,
0.0030389198,
-0.0300681144,
-0.0222877301,
0.0405356921,
-0.0633496866,
-0.0205459539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02314v1 | Fine-tuning pre-trained extractive QA models for clinical document parsing | 2023-12-04T19:52:56 | 2023-12-04T19:52:56 | Ashwyn Sharma, David I. Feldman, Aneesh Jain | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Electronic health records (EHRs) contain a vast amount of high-dimensional
multi-modal data that can accurately represent a patient's medical history.
Unfortunately, most of this data is either unstructured or semi-structured,
rendering it unsuitable for real-time and retrospective analyses. A remote
patient monitoring (RPM) program for Heart Failure (HF) patients needs to have
access to clinical markers like EF (Ejection Fraction) or LVEF (Left
Ventricular Ejection Fraction) in order to ascertain eligibility and
appropriateness for the program. This paper explains a system that can parse
echocardiogram reports and verify EF values. This system helps identify
eligible HF patients who can be enrolled in such a program. At the heart of
this system is a pre-trained extractive QA transformer model that is fine-tuned
on custom-labeled data. The methods used to prepare such a model for deployment
are illustrated by running experiments on a public clinical dataset like
MIMIC-IV-Note. The pipeline can be used to generalize solutions to similar
problems in a low-resource setting. We found that the system saved over 1500
hours for our clinicians over 12 months by automating the task at scale. | [
0.0369322486,
0.031921912,
-0.0068933391,
-0.0255702548,
-0.015779499,
0.0533263348,
-0.0359722227,
0.0148203839,
-0.0093997344,
-0.0149425017,
0.0077894172,
-0.0320028327,
-0.0056469617,
0.0726080611,
-0.0481299013,
-0.0377876572,
0.0189606901,
0.0205165651,
0.0300067514,
0.0567348152,
-0.0096124215,
-0.0144047197,
0.0073034936,
0.0321474001,
0.0169893559,
-0.0081795631,
-0.0125654908,
-0.0182968341,
0.0137078529,
-0.0544461235,
-0.0199070685,
0.0284506623,
-0.0505745113,
-0.0451707318,
0.0000018683,
-0.051126238,
-0.0781742111,
0.0549160354,
-0.0786056593,
-0.058167126,
0.0200306829,
-0.0867800787,
-0.0014862773,
0.011795993,
-0.035117425,
-0.0565748774,
0.0168201216,
0.0220729262,
0.0604289062,
0.0557337739,
-0.0346213244,
0.0238985792,
0.0349924378,
-0.008466579,
0.0033653751,
-0.0617597289,
0.0639296994,
0.0076390821,
0.0474507697,
0.0002105638,
-0.0049835038,
0.0237824731,
0.0173170343,
0.047283709,
0.0153780039,
0.0115013709,
-0.0160419662,
0.0168228727,
-0.0455975607,
0.085389182,
-0.0237690471,
0.0302326716,
0.0524690151,
-0.0173318051,
-0.0238304008,
-0.0035878555,
-0.0060653044,
-0.0173535552,
-0.0253592841,
-0.0123737939,
0.0279083289,
0.0166012384,
-0.044585079,
-0.0614871792,
-0.0500223823,
-0.0432981066,
-0.0069587538,
-0.0581210144,
0.0204395428,
0.0303359628,
-0.0072223931,
-0.0360029452,
0.066724278,
0.0127640627,
0.0123790521,
0.0228182934,
-0.0198250916,
-0.0495571233,
0.0378601439,
0.0191516727,
0.0116959875,
-0.0006453901,
0.0036325282,
0.0476074181,
0.0244068559,
-0.0226186216,
-0.0138861751,
0.0469007418,
-0.0258496031,
0.0139104333,
-0.0612425692,
-0.0129172271,
-0.0366254598,
0.0571207665,
-0.0138062006,
0.0152019663,
-0.0748160332,
-0.026115967,
-0.0075459299,
0.0340977348,
0.0428431407,
0.0005856192,
-0.0290244408,
0.0028304567,
0.0226674937,
0.0028391515,
0.0124107115,
-0.0105940429,
-0.0100979349,
-0.057237681,
0.0197966583,
0.0018377486,
0.0466495529,
-0.0285170693,
0.0318058729,
0.0160111655,
0.0402363017,
-0.0312033463,
-0.0054713571,
-0.0540152527,
-0.0106082344,
0.0177012756,
0.0022974128,
-0.0079847015,
0.0345033631,
0.0056614582,
0.0191265978,
0.0061651645,
-0.0259369332,
0.0031517991,
-0.0147711569,
0.0601648428,
-0.0383872911,
0.0268373154,
0.0068437676,
-0.0018220159,
0.0092804441,
0.0295273326,
0.0206209924,
-0.0582321584,
0.0261134058,
-0.0312005952,
0.0470991619,
0.0643804967,
-0.0000776141,
-0.0977756232,
-0.0025037413,
0.032636486,
0.0056326222,
0.0167244188,
-0.0251557827,
0.0277112667,
0.0152759785,
-0.0204131156,
-0.0213631447,
0.0749795511,
0.0417741947,
-0.0080972714,
0.0281244982,
-0.0216363836,
-0.0094679566,
-0.0305767898,
-0.0078716045,
-0.029067751,
0.0559477061,
0.0165707674,
-0.0879954696,
-0.0012091908,
-0.0293541383,
-0.0446750931,
-0.0369336605,
-0.0194134135,
-0.0406630486,
-0.0211558677,
0.079067491,
0.0120647997,
-0.0332439728,
0.0394430831,
0.0091704316,
-0.0318194181,
-0.0127886822,
-0.0496287383,
0.0054547507,
0.0289751869,
0.0608955473,
-0.089092426,
0.0043947753,
-0.014108914,
0.0001448193,
-0.0220724586,
0.021220142,
-0.0336853303,
0.0097805671,
-0.0424618833,
-0.0329221897,
0.0526454076,
-0.012816309,
-0.0025225219,
-0.0323033445,
0.0242633428,
-0.0314485431,
-0.0566964969,
-0.0194373801,
0.0623764507,
-0.0382791944,
-0.0513696633,
-0.0004602608,
0.0309510175,
0.0346956626,
0.0231303051,
0.0023218386,
0.0305636711,
0.0221465714,
-0.0396370627,
-0.0178689398,
0.0083241975,
-0.016482234,
-0.0243608821,
-0.0028394943,
-0.0126773156,
-0.0150101995,
-0.0194971468,
-0.0462723523,
-0.0069689066,
-0.0402293503,
-0.0026798968,
0.0005890491,
0.0195200946,
0.0398407392,
0.0328528285,
-0.0236608498,
-0.0377722085,
0.0169979371,
-0.0050096093,
0.0207451917,
-0.0173922759,
-0.0527383238,
-0.0018938722,
-0.0181338619,
0.0046426593,
0.0072875475,
-0.0405270085,
-0.0034842575,
-0.0425113738,
0.0099588195,
-0.056153819,
0.0014924434,
-0.0590098202,
0.0028585424,
-0.0081851017,
0.0585099421,
0.0271490198,
0.0431305878,
-0.028032206,
-0.0341608524,
-0.0262653027,
-0.0459772386,
0.0228885058,
0.0059565804,
0.0418263189,
0.0639655739,
0.0007042643,
-0.0085706059,
0.0031443951,
-0.0285087992,
0.0430571511,
0.0233020335,
0.0101915346,
0.0017389681,
-0.016858777,
0.0139377546,
0.0017024647,
0.021429792,
0.0094135469,
-0.0096670836,
-0.0232225452,
-0.0173463859,
0.0605467483,
-0.0409677885,
0.0513660647,
-0.0036863654,
-0.0159009434,
-0.0185105819,
0.0142029552,
-0.0613203607,
0.007144154,
0.0251121875,
-0.0288001541,
0.0645954832,
0.0789825842,
0.0200524088,
0.0161176994,
-0.0140188504,
-0.0012655708,
-0.0304322466,
0.012936824,
-0.0529892109,
0.0013666421,
-0.0234609805,
0.0375246666,
0.0148545615,
0.0061561931,
0.0737288147,
-0.0061726761,
0.0187379792,
-0.0553886928,
-0.0196429212,
-0.0523677804,
0.0028083958,
0.0009101977,
-0.0075756251,
0.0352428667,
-0.0402353331,
0.0303265546,
0.0029478131,
-0.0287375376,
-0.0557086766,
0.0299282502,
-0.0186360907,
0.033866372,
-0.0199345201,
-0.0288042855,
-0.038991645,
0.0188525021,
0.0019605283,
-0.008362744,
-0.0210354645,
0.0515908413,
-0.0080853403,
0.0806061625,
-0.0478129312,
0.0785688832,
0.0205962583,
-0.02396941,
0.0036442943,
0.0801899657,
0.0294167195,
-0.0232666433,
-0.0109083476,
-0.0217620805,
0.0532572269,
0.0622301586,
0.0552870147,
0.008969103,
0.0079594562,
0.0228511281,
-0.014045381,
-0.0595779978,
0.0152200283,
0.0184859987,
0.0230647307,
-0.0423434451,
-0.003823183,
0.0863620713,
0.0517437197,
-0.0218984485,
0.0070046913,
-0.0084106214,
-0.0453119054,
-0.0294451527,
0.027986696,
-0.0497909822,
-0.0027414586,
0.0158447977,
0.0668976977,
-0.010752907,
-0.0702694952,
0.0444042385,
-0.0524958186,
0.0875690058,
-0.024560893,
-0.0162559301,
-0.0492137372,
-0.0434572548,
0.0118270069,
-0.0558068715,
-0.0414915979,
-0.0201254338,
-0.0545053892,
0.0020286797,
0.0301324371,
-0.0789338797,
-0.0402815379,
0.0291738138,
-0.014674345,
0.0029713162,
0.0482964478,
-0.0082407091,
-0.0140695432,
-0.0107946405,
-0.0222366881,
-0.0578316376,
-0.0073130964,
-0.0092490632,
0.0518886037,
0.0042969952,
-0.0176937338,
-0.0332122445,
0.0297794137,
-0.0115407826,
-0.0333051011,
0.0040595662,
0.0780511498,
-0.0327099413,
-0.0079061994,
-0.0296631791,
-0.0103090592,
0.0317781568,
0.0388831981,
0.0072374176,
-0.010796519,
-0.0496975407,
0.0273977611,
0.0599067174,
-0.0294541605,
-0.0060045896,
0.0289069843,
-0.0771298707,
-0.0165596697,
-0.0670885891,
-0.0375429727,
0.0580619387,
0.0347636603,
0.0023371466,
-0.0243382677,
0.103882879,
0.0209477339,
-0.0555706397,
0.0440856069,
-0.0060688797,
-0.0051404019,
-0.0297565572,
-0.0092937602,
0.0259647667,
0.0322696939,
-0.0402740762,
-0.0394079387,
0.0077465735,
0.024094563,
0.0224079564,
0.0456716716,
0.023372082,
0.000813003,
-0.004821233,
0.0300028492,
0.002997441,
0.0241827164,
-0.041074153,
-0.0445153788,
-0.0187811926,
-0.0234217737,
-0.0426919609,
0.0008719033,
0.0008970726,
0.0516420752,
0.0065558916,
0.0208472908,
-0.031239951,
-0.002487506,
0.0209552851,
0.0604363456,
0.0299912374,
0.0321126021,
-0.021185264,
-0.0416665412,
0.0073782448,
-0.0301779807,
0.0280775968,
-0.0274527483,
0.0332378745,
0.0026822891,
0.0101890983,
-0.0166835263,
-0.0026576591,
-0.053513214,
-0.0258368012,
-0.0813776404,
0.0800075158,
-0.0213433634,
0.0035427087,
0.0298854429,
-0.044326663,
0.0210633483,
0.0031049582,
0.0448362529,
0.0530228727,
-0.0057869614,
0.0601814687,
-0.0180053543,
0.061974667,
-0.0143592143,
0.0389942117,
-0.0276968963,
0.0170450266,
-0.0357748941,
0.0124526406,
-0.0165799595,
-0.0218945798,
0.0089614512,
-0.0125039769,
-0.0023233434,
0.0134880822,
0.0153271006,
0.0061173989,
0.0364743285,
0.0798670128,
0.0201710928,
-0.0198731516,
-0.0326406956,
0.0500950664,
-0.0086128525,
0.0613207184,
-0.0225049034,
-0.0490387306,
-0.0588046759,
0.006696268,
0.0391485058,
-0.033529833,
-0.0569009446,
-0.0182172339,
-0.0642555207,
-0.0146074053,
0.0740228742,
0.0097876154,
-0.0562321059,
0.0090819225,
0.032556884,
0.0314717516,
0.0106319599,
-0.017623676,
-0.0135805318,
0.0183050632,
-0.0323657542,
-0.017441567,
0.0692136064,
-5.524199702e-33,
-0.0127672972,
-0.0313528329,
0.0141498214,
-0.0146830892,
0.0193061028,
0.0299158711,
-0.0077031343,
-0.0694830194,
0.0322093703,
-0.0131066488,
-0.0225092545,
-0.0266111102,
0.0449630395,
0.0023378301,
0.0306519009,
-0.0310216937,
0.0375893898,
-0.0055934908,
0.0003555348,
-0.0048375307,
-0.018323997,
0.0640804395,
0.0203831792,
-0.0731027573,
-0.0011167693,
0.0325144231,
0.0079270946,
0.0099305399,
0.0318164416,
0.0498277284,
-0.0486577563,
-0.0243404824,
0.038240239,
-0.0505083092,
0.0134736579,
0.0478331782,
-0.0962536335,
-0.0150234075,
-0.0087213777,
-0.0067747263,
0.01996704,
-0.0120441532,
0.033004757,
-0.0093027027,
-0.0004315914,
-0.0012366278,
0.022692997,
-0.0287115425,
0.0174964592,
-0.0475056469,
-0.0516409427,
0.0837263092,
-0.0088751186,
0.0199652202,
0.0085155722,
0.0187961441,
-0.0135369794,
0.0442016348,
-0.0458468944,
-0.033217825,
0.0542099811,
-0.0033399435,
0.0072614555,
-0.0413278528,
-0.0274769273,
0.029830683,
0.0250833631,
-0.0403672792,
-0.0049194698,
0.0770843923,
-0.0628534928,
0.06714423,
0.0197418127,
0.0153467711,
0.0282485802,
-0.0391993821,
-0.0626150146,
0.0746837407,
-0.0672429875,
0.0171739198,
-0.0170356911,
-0.0331339091,
-0.0597067699,
0.0212487169,
0.0228535719,
0.018186707,
-0.0191251989,
-0.0029339946,
0.0503171943,
0.0124846892,
-0.0291143209,
0.035376519,
0.007102143,
-0.0091636628,
0.01555047,
-0.043757122,
0.0448734909,
0.0363352448,
-0.0622082911,
-0.0260763876,
-0.0247134268,
-0.0527283214,
0.055418212,
-0.0047068549,
0.0319611095,
-0.0141445491,
0.0148322014,
-0.0183721986,
-0.078089647,
-0.0005102195,
0.0729403794,
0.0440104194,
-0.0197940394,
0.0530571193,
0.0348384678,
0.0242118407,
-0.0033590395,
0.0628836676,
-0.0049854149,
0.0090125138,
-0.0438584685,
-0.0214726776,
0.0057279719,
0.0228653792,
-0.024964815,
-0.0320195183,
-0.0370808505,
0.0351383798,
0.0249249041,
0.0011052833,
0.0061471746,
0.0182143897,
2.675e-7,
0.0941558182,
0.0220815744,
0.0554286949,
-0.0684251264,
0.0171481986,
0.0095584346,
-0.0302317217,
-0.012732842,
0.0022033344,
0.0106250104,
0.0714243203,
-0.0263238344,
0.0402604826,
0.0507551692,
-0.0506733246,
-0.031077886,
-0.0555566773,
-0.050003767,
-0.037329182,
-0.0087687653,
0.069763273,
0.0501008369,
-0.0774308294,
-0.0239062347,
-0.031733688,
0.0105602602,
-0.0052268128,
0.0046592457,
-0.0258445982,
0.0453362428,
0.0232089832,
-0.014923594,
0.0275232457,
0.0099821882,
-0.0006070173,
0.0386374556,
0.0152575718,
0.1367481649,
-0.0471889786,
0.0277263839,
0.011140421,
0.0017930408,
0.0289266296,
-0.0105952313,
0.0770165846,
-0.0734703913,
-0.0257014856,
-0.016980499,
-0.0449183844,
-0.0051770001,
0.0081934091,
-0.0242134128,
0.0011200485,
0.0695197582,
0.0186185651,
-0.0023272117,
-0.0623193868,
-0.0441364832,
0.0309872944,
0.0380606838,
0.0134360492,
-0.0289612394,
0.0440021008,
0.0042660781,
0.0018691578,
-0.0752025247,
-0.0082895793,
2.613255496e-34,
0.0213772766,
0.0173899643,
0.0051756143,
0.0303607397,
0.0059705558,
-0.0179845467,
0.0188267101,
0.0207576752,
-0.0383367985,
-0.0952279642,
0.0075674159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02310v1 | VaQuitA: Enhancing Alignment in LLM-Assisted Video Understanding | 2023-12-04T19:48:02 | 2023-12-04T19:48:02 | Yizhou Wang, Ruiyi Zhang, Haoliang Wang, Uttaran Bhattacharya, Yun Fu, Gang Wu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in language-model-based video understanding have been
progressing at a remarkable pace, spurred by the introduction of Large Language
Models (LLMs). However, the focus of prior research has been predominantly on
devising a projection layer that maps video features to tokens, an approach
that is both rudimentary and inefficient. In our study, we introduce a
cutting-edge framework, VaQuitA, designed to refine the synergy between video
and textual information. At the data level, instead of sampling frames
uniformly, we implement a sampling method guided by CLIP-score rankings, which
enables a more aligned selection of frames with the given question. At the
feature level, we integrate a trainable Video Perceiver alongside a
Visual-Query Transformer (abbreviated as VQ-Former), which bolsters the
interplay between the input question and the video features. We also discover
that incorporating a simple prompt, "Please be critical", into the LLM input
can substantially enhance its video comprehension capabilities. Our
experimental results indicate that VaQuitA consistently sets a new benchmark
for zero-shot video question-answering tasks and is adept at producing
high-quality, multi-turn video dialogues with users. | [
0.0217583179,
0.0219979305,
-0.0117527489,
0.0471777134,
0.0034775177,
-0.0128859505,
-0.0162945129,
0.003576448,
-0.0195688121,
-0.0699996054,
-0.0103982249,
-0.0457506366,
-0.0383397341,
0.0388596915,
0.0311882179,
-0.0657703131,
0.0544634014,
-0.0448653884,
0.0236328766,
0.0155405728,
0.024406394,
0.0135483816,
-0.008063538,
0.0397764705,
-0.0429643542,
-0.0036105134,
-0.0242883135,
0.0168806855,
0.0376742035,
-0.026680097,
-0.0337874517,
0.0387447439,
0.0656021461,
0.0116470065,
0.0000017801,
-0.0103745712,
0.0007498399,
-0.0158815291,
-0.0165370796,
0.0053215739,
-0.0178631432,
-0.0279731862,
0.0301954653,
0.0406764485,
-0.0670685172,
-0.0068160798,
0.0357144438,
-0.0154751819,
0.0502410531,
0.0233506542,
-0.0301507935,
-0.0268082153,
0.0042444719,
-0.0097351288,
0.0487163588,
-0.047968559,
-0.0030785031,
0.0228134841,
0.0301144775,
0.0202934835,
-0.084453173,
0.0562331975,
0.0257919766,
-0.0612132736,
0.0115066124,
0.0269474369,
-0.0872330889,
-0.0244375132,
-0.0190959442,
0.0776406154,
0.0159701258,
0.035012193,
0.0004845602,
0.0310854167,
0.030548716,
0.0064692344,
-0.0829466432,
0.003697555,
0.0287857186,
0.002586215,
-0.0363003239,
0.0050032935,
0.0149466665,
-0.0163892452,
0.034432862,
0.0110701276,
0.027681822,
0.0024300162,
-0.045409441,
0.0083559304,
-0.018693503,
-0.0537005514,
0.0144764315,
0.0433325283,
-0.0240411088,
0.01551376,
-0.0309043098,
0.0061632032,
-0.0369425081,
-0.024098916,
0.0369239114,
0.0362089574,
-0.0312912539,
0.0768332407,
-0.0155254472,
0.0758051276,
-0.0066065397,
0.0398438647,
-0.0389371589,
-0.008284701,
-0.0427589193,
-0.021964265,
-0.0356150642,
0.008877825,
-0.0444639213,
-0.0198711287,
0.0064521157,
0.0360311978,
-0.0141652208,
0.0132429739,
-0.0185189117,
0.0219370574,
0.0338299572,
-0.0128867198,
-0.0422535539,
0.0676138178,
-0.04501573,
0.0390822776,
-0.0191043001,
-0.0719138086,
-0.0321899019,
0.0168748591,
-0.0137502262,
-0.0120193716,
0.0133151701,
0.0351774655,
-0.0616801307,
-0.0391327515,
0.0202892646,
0.0307916664,
-0.0416423678,
0.0149450768,
0.0318273641,
-0.0442970023,
0.0527360179,
0.0144937709,
-0.0139972176,
0.013122784,
0.0097743273,
0.0245444085,
-0.0393303484,
0.0653746799,
0.0042189904,
0.0237548836,
0.0200069938,
0.0206220504,
0.0018315748,
0.076051183,
0.0281132273,
0.013264114,
0.0350530483,
0.0152478665,
0.0359672308,
0.0526534282,
-0.034901686,
0.0124091506,
-0.0834055543,
0.0416650474,
0.0179088041,
0.0326151773,
0.050334584,
0.0524238944,
-0.0292377546,
-0.0465072207,
0.0697918534,
0.0555362292,
-0.0441954583,
-0.055583369,
0.018967269,
0.0390369929,
-0.0024829353,
0.008565573,
-0.044161316,
0.095172286,
0.0200230386,
-0.0035649401,
0.0041202656,
0.0347089283,
-0.0670168251,
-0.0460504405,
-0.0337460227,
0.0176461805,
-0.014327528,
0.0490188599,
0.0186459236,
0.0132768191,
-0.0311612934,
0.0765253976,
-0.0113004884,
-0.0079652062,
0.0472691543,
-0.0352805592,
0.0309975501,
0.0645236224,
0.021794932,
-0.0121578779,
-0.0517474562,
-0.0026332461,
0.0395632908,
0.0269223209,
0.0176519454,
-0.0427672341,
0.0221746862,
-0.0654563904,
-0.0316179171,
-0.005768972,
0.0090036169,
0.0157142039,
-0.014171307,
-0.0009322543,
0.0089522824,
-0.0439360887,
0.0025758601,
0.0471512154,
0.0509142429,
-0.0110341199,
-0.0193311814,
0.010646306,
-0.0112030143,
0.0199841447,
-0.0034616932,
-0.0235355552,
0.0343513675,
-0.0216934327,
0.0303378701,
0.0146655561,
-0.039160572,
-0.0491730236,
0.0330091678,
-0.0636477396,
-0.0215773415,
0.0360684618,
-0.0556090064,
-0.0472065397,
0.000551385,
0.0002041797,
-0.0161390118,
-0.0723047033,
-0.0001720025,
0.0364959687,
0.0008287413,
-0.0354308225,
-0.0028844499,
0.0057540517,
-0.0117105078,
0.0296642538,
-0.0015809196,
0.0050534243,
-0.0380867384,
-0.0355456769,
0.0105595859,
-0.011443858,
-0.0043160045,
-0.0027371165,
-0.0057343296,
-0.0713311434,
-0.0482990406,
-0.0867896155,
0.004484152,
-0.031260021,
0.0137175247,
0.0072210249,
0.0053916522,
-0.0148736704,
-0.0570659675,
-0.0508464649,
-0.0158714987,
0.0180788003,
0.0116174594,
0.0283722188,
0.0341056325,
0.006192178,
-0.0259336215,
-0.0143906921,
0.0282959975,
0.0342989154,
-0.0066789747,
0.0052699186,
0.0089740651,
-0.0302681774,
-0.0190993585,
0.0217904039,
-0.0440623164,
-0.0267986637,
0.0156519972,
-0.0072279293,
0.0001781496,
0.0609558113,
0.0265238062,
0.0116814943,
0.0150742568,
-0.0067312825,
-0.0351930372,
0.0386199839,
-0.0031691503,
-0.0412750281,
-0.0341848768,
-0.0121233976,
-0.0246427264,
-0.0189828947,
-0.0416048728,
0.0381093174,
-0.0865093321,
0.0305068027,
0.0159476306,
-0.0239674244,
-0.0664726272,
0.006245675,
-0.0124476254,
0.0250251703,
-0.0401529707,
-0.0336545855,
0.0370943099,
-0.0552292801,
-0.0382230058,
0.0170356352,
0.0214421861,
-0.0289294068,
0.0881915316,
0.0223916396,
0.0001882411,
-0.0479216129,
-0.0446477458,
-0.1030197218,
-0.010932019,
-0.0091807293,
-0.0137032093,
0.0581460036,
-0.0588356815,
0.0035644316,
-0.0111073246,
-0.0203623921,
-0.0657795072,
-0.0230685398,
-0.0453013033,
0.0067549911,
-0.0520558432,
-0.0039484738,
0.0043908232,
0.0146074174,
0.0147479251,
0.0231836624,
-0.0376452841,
0.0282076281,
-0.0138936797,
0.0475872904,
0.0796324387,
0.0461456254,
-0.03151365,
-0.0386580154,
0.0699076653,
0.0714634806,
0.0371186808,
-0.0354536735,
0.0101592531,
0.0210878607,
0.0681866631,
0.0057882085,
-0.0244318899,
0.0178909022,
0.0617225207,
-0.0504116565,
-0.0011724366,
0.1145188883,
0.0098527297,
-0.047026135,
-0.026730787,
-0.0185011625,
0.0293781925,
0.0578346364,
0.0431431718,
-0.098967813,
-0.0441859141,
-0.005827154,
0.0093906606,
0.0347205289,
0.024101181,
-0.0385848209,
-0.0807138979,
0.065999642,
-0.0020443702,
-0.0204108581,
0.0059531992,
0.0049098912,
0.0173890013,
-0.0216208659,
0.0417780913,
-0.0012230859,
-0.026066944,
0.0360000841,
0.0029748408,
0.0274332855,
-0.0237151049,
0.0240754876,
-0.0457474403,
0.0203150623,
0.0495307334,
0.0203563962,
-0.0153329298,
-0.0463425368,
-0.0015257522,
-0.0201881435,
0.0087064672,
0.0080952244,
0.0544460788,
-0.0489373095,
-0.0289977062,
0.0161565244,
0.0209008772,
0.0389770307,
-0.0379703194,
0.0169006996,
0.0508695133,
-0.0190608315,
0.0174395498,
-0.0145044643,
0.000988566,
-0.0069093192,
0.0913306102,
0.0216419492,
-0.0207195524,
0.0069549135,
0.0305293109,
-0.0559119619,
-0.0362567566,
-0.0428039394,
0.0005247158,
0.0304359663,
0.0206814073,
-0.041410815,
-0.0089610266,
0.0973902792,
0.036649324,
-0.0310659464,
0.0077663786,
0.0060216682,
0.0402553529,
-0.0602034554,
0.0633791089,
-0.0073493156,
0.0049089771,
-0.0635005012,
0.0147152059,
0.0392450541,
-0.0363128036,
-0.0238331016,
-0.0036035704,
-0.048319526,
-0.0281918719,
-0.0124885924,
0.0833080485,
0.0205209441,
0.0605122112,
0.0063050841,
-0.011869139,
0.0008934559,
0.0312187839,
-0.0064613437,
0.0195845552,
-0.0359121524,
-0.0742355362,
-0.0330086946,
0.0546801835,
-0.0513009913,
-0.0007100138,
-0.0213262886,
0.0448125564,
-0.059522301,
-0.0379983969,
0.0118469363,
-0.0310200676,
0.0714533627,
-0.0020526091,
0.0153804393,
-0.018190749,
0.0220520832,
-0.0038891467,
0.0309754163,
-0.0740460604,
0.0103708887,
0.0142139569,
-0.0345237516,
0.0031007098,
0.0043019834,
-0.0462593436,
-0.0073492471,
-0.0380228944,
-0.0264434367,
-0.0225406047,
-0.0326604173,
0.0250913929,
0.009012335,
0.0355835259,
0.0377608798,
0.021924898,
0.0411560945,
0.0090338606,
0.0617537908,
0.012988287,
-0.0166872405,
-0.0006200416,
0.0564509369,
-0.0622676685,
-0.0702466965,
-0.0022798283,
0.0552476421,
0.0233474188,
-0.0403738357,
0.0049156519,
0.0278957672,
-0.026068924,
-0.0033014927,
0.0234804936,
-0.0006766731,
-0.0728716329,
0.0810084566,
0.0239467323,
-0.0226960368,
-0.0076001324,
0.0619758442,
-0.0036777426,
0.0122354887,
-0.0014395643,
0.0103824949,
-0.0024066705,
-0.0315049738,
0.0255581718,
0.0037872631,
-0.0310970228,
0.0187870339,
-0.0490637012,
-0.0536067747,
-0.0131029533,
0.0013119871,
-0.0147418175,
0.0068906308,
0.0435927585,
0.0276531037,
-0.0026794339,
-0.0447949506,
-0.0118903248,
-0.0242618956,
-0.0420188271,
-0.0382445641,
0.0186187346,
-5.840762168e-33,
-0.0432028733,
-0.0231178515,
0.0236183237,
0.0085089514,
-0.0340959579,
0.0134943295,
0.0064697778,
0.0234851167,
-0.0325460844,
0.0084500294,
-0.0020766242,
0.0425756872,
0.0263494197,
0.0463940762,
-0.0070922882,
-0.0754778758,
0.0518023595,
-0.035037268,
-0.012430096,
-0.0073879096,
-0.0008728763,
0.0332403518,
0.0357257538,
-0.0304713007,
-0.0116201099,
0.0028052132,
-0.0187926386,
0.0392242111,
0.0222690515,
0.0676262081,
0.0175094754,
-0.0337300673,
0.0198907629,
-0.0375795662,
-0.019721603,
0.0161104873,
-0.0565167814,
0.0112801939,
0.0539692678,
0.0432336517,
-0.0497359224,
0.0026889076,
0.0395003892,
-0.0048299879,
-0.0074018352,
-0.0406644978,
0.0235920176,
-0.022996245,
-0.0067292457,
0.014533557,
-0.0015618722,
-0.0103256553,
-0.0306819491,
-0.058810465,
0.0383705497,
0.0450636931,
0.0283980984,
-0.0119077992,
-0.0325868316,
0.0108571416,
-0.0299010184,
0.0598555878,
0.123084344,
0.0439958535,
-0.0073390123,
0.0542671978,
0.0127481408,
-0.089310497,
-0.043520119,
-0.0430702493,
0.0019342796,
0.036073707,
0.0216995236,
0.0248023197,
0.0113659734,
0.0000175573,
-0.0418040268,
0.0392471105,
-0.0607712381,
0.0625234842,
-0.0248523094,
0.0222875085,
0.029432822,
-0.0011315796,
-0.0608680993,
-0.0139726046,
-0.0288795661,
-0.0134550631,
0.0352529883,
-0.0029003851,
0.0230110344,
-0.0222026128,
0.0731460974,
-0.0321323462,
0.0337321945,
0.0380217135,
-0.0410281867,
0.0485053062,
0.0183582641,
0.0606851578,
-0.0253744218,
0.025537191,
0.0360203721,
-0.0000978588,
-0.0280040391,
0.0296593457,
-0.0030713351,
0.019131165,
-0.021236334,
-0.002520174,
-0.0172137655,
0.0117598278,
-0.036287047,
0.0429884754,
0.0275229644,
0.0286794808,
-0.0434808768,
0.047762882,
-0.0307216533,
0.0007266641,
-0.0297071338,
-0.0380607806,
0.0026585439,
0.032369785,
-0.04634507,
0.0234303791,
-0.0294881947,
-0.0122911418,
0.0016175017,
-0.0701605454,
-0.0139234671,
0.0423189588,
2.543e-7,
0.029076498,
0.0131482044,
0.0031683615,
0.0019519322,
-0.0061948001,
0.0459497161,
-0.0133781964,
0.0466797799,
0.0550290085,
-0.0362868533,
0.0209254269,
0.081590496,
0.021996187,
-0.0104611218,
-0.0792495385,
-0.0089597972,
-0.0603965446,
-0.0206237063,
-0.0281933341,
0.0055309176,
0.0392466821,
0.1072968915,
-0.0161038954,
0.0051151565,
0.0113155944,
-0.0363965817,
0.05557606,
-0.0061151437,
-0.0360928252,
0.0094751054,
0.0357050821,
-0.0100536104,
-0.0102726799,
0.0071075396,
-0.0279616583,
-0.0028585214,
0.0303206705,
0.0702657104,
-0.0219285972,
-0.0538617447,
-0.0607883558,
0.037165422,
0.0016659537,
-0.0471267626,
0.0719587579,
-0.0259933434,
-0.0067351162,
-0.0206260793,
-0.0317047909,
0.008428691,
-0.0062981332,
0.0159225669,
-0.0100940382,
0.0512082875,
0.0271921847,
-0.021184478,
-0.019882502,
-0.0949988142,
-0.0073285429,
-0.042562373,
-0.0316740386,
-0.0021536872,
-0.0335746966,
-0.019929206,
0.0283172559,
0.0127264755,
-0.0639999807,
1.705800375e-34,
0.0081327204,
0.0106395613,
0.0108754113,
-0.0023406923,
-0.0151869655,
0.0076044397,
-0.0177069027,
0.0056586186,
0.0036864034,
-0.0712213516,
-0.0063468465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03756v1 | LineConGraphs: Line Conversation Graphs for Effective Emotion Recognition using Graph Neural Networks | 2023-12-04T19:36:58 | 2023-12-04T19:36:58 | Gokul S Krishnan, Sarala Padi, Craig S. Greenberg, Balaraman Ravindran, Dinesh Manoch, Ram D. Sriram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Emotion Recognition in Conversations (ERC) is a critical aspect of affective
computing, and it has many practical applications in healthcare, education,
chatbots, and social media platforms. Earlier approaches for ERC analysis
involved modeling both speaker and long-term contextual information using graph
neural network architectures. However, it is ideal to deploy
speaker-independent models for real-world applications. Additionally, long
context windows can potentially create confusion in recognizing the emotion of
an utterance in a conversation. To overcome these limitations, we propose novel
line conversation graph convolutional network (LineConGCN) and graph attention
(LineConGAT) models for ERC analysis. These models are speaker-independent and
built using a graph construction strategy for conversations -- line
conversation graphs (LineConGraphs). The conversational context in
LineConGraphs is short-term -- limited to one previous and future utterance,
and speaker information is not part of the graph. We evaluate the performance
of our proposed models on two benchmark datasets, IEMOCAP and MELD, and show
that our LineConGAT model outperforms the state-of-the-art methods with an
F1-score of 64.58% and 76.50%. Moreover, we demonstrate that embedding
sentiment shift information into line conversation graphs further enhances the
ERC performance in the case of GCN models. | [
0.025420038,
0.0708404332,
0.012817055,
0.0529235415,
-0.0302699804,
-0.0051323124,
0.0117629291,
-0.0294574294,
0.0581394397,
-0.0081903804,
-0.0114062745,
-0.0295796953,
-0.0091631254,
0.0414217822,
0.0068577603,
-0.0554031953,
-0.0107628265,
0.0543972254,
0.0535645746,
0.0130406478,
0.0209111776,
0.035814628,
-0.0103012426,
0.0316722021,
-0.0581181906,
-0.0205225684,
-0.0259254947,
0.0681935325,
0.020277746,
-0.0507040285,
0.024522366,
0.0286369622,
0.0119637651,
0.02637784,
0.0000020331,
0.0093208794,
-0.0138596017,
-0.0206237808,
-0.038118016,
-0.0321653262,
0.0483965278,
-0.0175080709,
-0.0102397325,
-0.0172903351,
-0.0250628944,
-0.0046587805,
0.0461896323,
0.0521570295,
0.0751348659,
0.1094973758,
-0.0372256264,
-0.0007039462,
-0.0112290652,
-0.0251659118,
0.0305497441,
-0.0753953382,
0.0151289031,
-0.0015702726,
-0.0034412779,
-0.0362907052,
-0.0568195619,
0.005444394,
0.0093186721,
-0.0203626975,
0.0683946237,
0.0214086752,
-0.0167527944,
-0.0056168362,
-0.01026389,
0.1592052728,
-0.0296064448,
0.0004906976,
0.0107315341,
-0.0114007145,
0.0265620295,
-0.0375847444,
-0.0530728772,
-0.0518777929,
0.0076351091,
0.0154165151,
-0.0739274397,
-0.0088553131,
0.0300774928,
-0.0067531732,
-0.0129294824,
0.0542792156,
-0.042269554,
-0.0074541466,
0.037730597,
0.0012930409,
-0.0279939696,
-0.0027273749,
-0.0031805208,
0.0129625592,
-0.0081412047,
-0.0018160325,
-0.036619205,
-0.0042979531,
-0.0438917093,
-0.0457782894,
-0.0177870505,
0.0072434712,
0.0032402533,
0.0324098133,
0.014723748,
0.0434714556,
-0.0173118636,
0.0102780638,
-0.0360439941,
-0.0141983414,
-0.0354729369,
0.0213780608,
-0.0436566025,
0.0129874079,
-0.0223847721,
-0.0888574868,
-0.0721036345,
0.0338981599,
-0.0285393968,
0.010239956,
0.0044522379,
0.0551251248,
0.0163287148,
0.0052843923,
0.0377522521,
0.0384212397,
0.0097762607,
0.0124533176,
0.0012869341,
-0.0505957305,
-0.0214834902,
0.0483230911,
0.054898411,
0.0135532012,
0.008342253,
0.0313853808,
0.0478427373,
-0.0577983931,
0.0086407252,
-0.0170897376,
-0.0623575225,
-0.0624602064,
0.0552687496,
-0.030631464,
0.0434422679,
-0.0125053758,
0.0075526433,
-0.0097963968,
0.0315671153,
-0.0442398638,
-0.0526404679,
0.0513169803,
0.0212795138,
0.0019431228,
-0.0076781842,
-0.0003314613,
-0.008489307,
0.0280427672,
0.0525337234,
0.0390423238,
0.0245694257,
-0.0172935724,
0.0141496146,
0.0019475319,
0.046982158,
-0.0338666849,
-0.00116301,
-0.0160179324,
-0.0469540358,
0.0437777899,
0.0296300687,
0.0224892385,
-0.0356274545,
-0.0469927415,
0.044180382,
0.0495631099,
-0.0103089428,
0.0361586958,
-0.0089579169,
0.0507995188,
0.0008952066,
-0.0142830703,
-0.0511487685,
0.0262929518,
0.0292299986,
-0.009783308,
0.0148565508,
-0.0802740678,
-0.0330243148,
-0.0116424551,
0.0092477333,
-0.0423272438,
0.0741266012,
-0.0137259066,
0.0057907272,
-0.0075192163,
-0.05615611,
0.0253505837,
0.0052085877,
-0.0507198498,
-0.0471534617,
-0.003023633,
-0.0252985414,
0.082910046,
0.0127010625,
0.0030881863,
-0.0446831435,
-0.0155853424,
0.0071195806,
0.0006589597,
0.0592614561,
0.0124124754,
0.0404219069,
-0.0446428955,
0.0086050592,
-0.0307587031,
-0.0134013155,
0.0414928682,
-0.0075330762,
0.0132468892,
-0.0150568802,
-0.0277575254,
0.00335708,
-0.0287174806,
0.0294240415,
0.0047540297,
0.0341269225,
0.0140189929,
0.0301999524,
0.0225696638,
0.0041934811,
-0.006207386,
0.0308450311,
0.0085086739,
-0.0152493417,
0.017778052,
-0.0769011006,
-0.0968366787,
0.0394871123,
-0.0196976699,
-0.0122626005,
0.010196914,
-0.0623073652,
-0.0401545428,
0.0689165816,
-0.0528924204,
0.0684692338,
0.008945439,
0.0091811325,
-0.0041594896,
0.0497519784,
0.030832136,
0.0196748991,
-0.0188103151,
-0.0088940645,
-0.000933815,
0.0172797162,
-0.0152078709,
-0.0570757724,
-0.0110047543,
0.0139443567,
0.0228755195,
-0.0025283138,
-0.0121692233,
0.014251383,
-0.0727935806,
-0.0276868232,
-0.1424784362,
-0.021467587,
-0.0078488532,
-0.0093859239,
-0.0113889873,
-0.0011282783,
-0.0223121252,
-0.0340858512,
-0.0560212284,
0.0558434837,
0.0151688904,
-0.0048976461,
0.030266678,
-0.0164088886,
-0.010745002,
-0.0608835034,
-0.0161578096,
0.0032532103,
0.0634416789,
0.0122814486,
-0.049885273,
0.0081893485,
-0.0004575702,
-0.0307283513,
0.0278391819,
-0.0163544044,
-0.0233859308,
-0.0371814892,
-0.0106570162,
0.007566548,
0.0658871606,
-0.0142324641,
0.0742560551,
-0.0410763621,
-0.0068419357,
-0.0139878085,
0.0430614091,
-0.0237363745,
0.0418561101,
-0.0335115865,
-0.0083536468,
-0.0334034562,
0.0253650863,
-0.000683402,
0.021867644,
-0.0239648428,
-0.0384422801,
0.0201623254,
-0.0004357809,
0.0069875252,
-0.0508013666,
-0.0120633626,
-0.0526398905,
-0.037115965,
-0.0488964207,
0.0460909307,
0.0099880351,
-0.0412382856,
-0.0242630746,
-0.0226866622,
-0.0500538908,
0.0486049838,
0.0304421317,
0.0093703615,
-0.0355641991,
-0.021758914,
0.0026916149,
-0.0449410081,
-0.0268076751,
-0.0525713451,
0.0242629983,
0.0162841547,
-0.0024351897,
0.0402724296,
-0.0191539302,
-0.0132689225,
-0.0060088723,
-0.0405792557,
0.0106723774,
0.0309199002,
-0.0269609746,
0.0122764008,
-0.0105496738,
-0.0173158161,
-0.0124120722,
-0.0205597188,
0.0137410741,
0.0046515004,
0.0657442063,
0.0338653885,
0.0046993154,
0.0313409045,
-0.013218035,
0.0377732031,
0.0541281886,
0.0245555434,
0.0374190249,
-0.0202089921,
0.0032700356,
-0.0346027203,
0.0413333066,
-0.0177234001,
-0.0360133089,
0.0393984132,
-0.0381179601,
0.028984677,
0.079517208,
0.0145484712,
-0.0643080845,
0.0012480264,
0.0281340946,
0.0177903399,
-0.0128733842,
-0.0095534446,
-0.0507216938,
-0.0300167091,
-0.0139856599,
0.0202029571,
0.0138821695,
-0.0426816121,
-0.029200349,
-0.034332931,
0.0210549496,
0.0334808379,
-0.0259391069,
-0.0388391539,
-0.0214217752,
0.030785257,
0.0119638005,
-0.0147265084,
-0.0500012711,
0.019796079,
-0.0384242497,
0.009391997,
-0.048943419,
-0.000472619,
0.0266000144,
0.0149332415,
0.0379746556,
-0.0227080882,
0.1004583761,
0.0252578072,
0.0142030297,
0.0841706246,
0.0193613227,
-0.0172777735,
-0.0008773204,
0.0811215565,
-0.0226823613,
-0.0031199134,
-0.0108425422,
0.039324075,
-0.0372315049,
0.0007518936,
-0.0504267514,
0.0521966442,
-0.0270652287,
-0.0562747233,
-0.0083573908,
0.0530869365,
0.053912241,
0.0268687084,
0.052059751,
-0.019822659,
-0.067545943,
-0.0265115201,
0.0365882702,
-0.0463705547,
-0.0201624986,
-0.0062003057,
0.0227997378,
-0.0168530587,
-0.0321654044,
-0.0650001615,
-0.015794564,
-0.0054455865,
-0.0537757054,
-0.0523410365,
0.0374923423,
-0.0246950351,
-0.0391215868,
0.0344003886,
-0.0094179632,
0.0180654787,
-0.0152406488,
-0.0052897045,
0.0249491371,
-0.0001424821,
0.0116192224,
0.0284327362,
-0.1081545353,
-0.052346684,
-0.0167985521,
-0.0003030658,
0.0069883284,
0.0482750498,
-0.0095919557,
-0.0018121703,
0.0189329684,
-0.0015174586,
-0.0162663106,
0.0025351723,
0.0587096699,
0.0513997003,
-0.0381220952,
0.0198004507,
-0.0386223905,
0.0389498994,
0.012290732,
0.00065006,
-0.0263618324,
-0.1212289035,
-0.0227424707,
-0.0034362995,
0.0275300536,
0.063244693,
0.0088372873,
-0.0199876186,
0.0012318523,
0.0111075928,
0.0173878036,
-0.0513027422,
-0.055561807,
-0.0058847847,
-0.010783202,
-0.0429267809,
-0.0593527369,
0.008189911,
-0.0132774776,
-0.0165077485,
-0.0054913745,
0.0003798884,
-0.0401113182,
0.0326278172,
-0.0021520469,
-0.0138552077,
0.0278190654,
-0.003986761,
-0.0053641233,
0.0026130187,
0.0492778458,
0.0110561596,
-0.0394995883,
-0.0029135081,
0.015447746,
-0.0549902245,
0.0104431957,
-0.0360697396,
0.0225093588,
0.0297676846,
0.0066587618,
0.0562561192,
-0.0052893274,
0.0248821918,
-0.0333250873,
0.071735248,
-0.0342884436,
-0.0608420745,
0.0272529162,
0.0048749456,
-0.0236383807,
0.0363546126,
-0.0042693233,
0.021352455,
0.0276985765,
0.0034800828,
-0.0375062265,
-0.0438346937,
-0.00534982,
0.0254426952,
-0.0152704641,
0.0295573398,
0.0491659902,
-0.0337535106,
-0.048050072,
0.0688601136,
-0.0523909591,
-0.0048595085,
-0.011924169,
0.02379179,
0.02157907,
-0.0101518659,
0.0018104019,
-0.0398400389,
0.0502517708,
-0.0398686826,
-0.0286163036,
-0.0239517987,
-5.845074395e-33,
0.0163204521,
-0.0576343015,
-0.0397115722,
0.0562819205,
-0.0741825253,
0.0513963252,
-0.0573557578,
0.0006050552,
-0.025624238,
0.0370257758,
0.0025174357,
0.0741173178,
-0.0047645881,
0.0602498092,
-0.0622121729,
-0.0411761329,
0.0247448012,
-0.0037998427,
0.0223834179,
0.0727584884,
0.0440876409,
0.0452282801,
0.057895761,
-0.1132612228,
0.0124463476,
-0.0238177311,
0.0284406599,
-0.0079093874,
0.0732788667,
0.0341460072,
0.0140464464,
0.0529997312,
0.034139201,
0.0238121394,
0.0015198431,
0.0479194336,
-0.0546511486,
-0.0064545339,
-0.0636137202,
0.0186694097,
-0.0620018318,
-0.0331811309,
0.0301503874,
0.0199024528,
0.0434664935,
-0.0585222542,
0.0336723067,
0.0132873375,
-0.0046531935,
-0.0152820246,
-0.0003694648,
0.0375036523,
-0.0474111028,
-0.0300555527,
0.0014468163,
0.0480329506,
0.0201748516,
0.003180377,
-0.0694760084,
0.0244615227,
-0.0651752353,
-0.0252309404,
-0.0297497511,
0.0077910372,
0.0055702217,
0.0613558255,
0.0260013957,
0.0005814135,
-0.0227770973,
0.0189917628,
-0.0031914797,
0.0607167371,
0.0111275176,
0.0051080612,
-0.0397372656,
-0.0314045995,
-0.057434462,
-0.0123572228,
0.0333028138,
0.0090808552,
0.0139616011,
0.0110863773,
-0.0302525237,
-0.0086347852,
0.0266686995,
-0.0215949751,
-0.0046762927,
-0.0080856569,
0.0067454362,
-0.0112930313,
0.006584391,
-0.0108049065,
0.0084549794,
-0.0571401082,
0.0031836173,
0.0986840799,
-0.03035607,
0.0424045436,
0.0059514628,
0.0285419915,
-0.0363001712,
0.0076246019,
0.0416292772,
0.0151801482,
0.0466848649,
-0.0099460045,
0.0358788408,
0.0299311597,
-0.0333989933,
-0.0423055701,
-0.0418863073,
0.0337662511,
-0.0585677885,
0.0397614725,
0.0180846676,
0.0423222631,
-0.0143321995,
0.0791448653,
-0.0073823156,
0.0899435431,
-0.0191380717,
-0.0063455631,
0.0124017345,
0.0385048799,
-0.0568029694,
-0.0207115207,
-0.0003243048,
0.0148946634,
0.0082910592,
-0.0607263409,
-0.0126412502,
-0.0101357671,
2.746e-7,
0.0011152176,
0.0231563486,
0.0484628305,
-0.0028287587,
0.0368258022,
0.0304586254,
0.013660674,
0.0470257252,
0.0133344354,
-0.0318768919,
0.0675361454,
0.0473363511,
0.0341496728,
0.0065458026,
-0.0770529285,
0.014848968,
-0.064887628,
-0.0165683981,
0.0031460281,
0.0063662622,
0.0800257698,
0.0678174272,
0.0589923188,
0.0044823522,
0.0093757818,
-0.013624588,
0.0365675166,
-0.0290367287,
0.0032405409,
0.0142619181,
-0.0081056478,
-0.0145832887,
-0.0477413088,
0.0009362366,
0.023156859,
0.016899772,
0.0394338258,
0.062490996,
-0.0049043507,
-0.0508142076,
0.007371142,
0.0178306233,
-0.0049494868,
-0.0140672345,
0.0494940877,
-0.0495846383,
-0.0211847257,
-0.0377590097,
-0.018594142,
-0.0050383271,
0.0614362173,
0.0120518785,
-0.0159205962,
0.0117808655,
0.0191081446,
-0.0430244878,
-0.0022445563,
-0.0927374735,
0.0126734702,
0.0308533385,
-0.036508996,
-0.0225586798,
-0.0061744126,
-0.0080560222,
0.0360329263,
-0.0035734866,
0.0058905976,
1.887257673e-34,
0.0165011548,
-0.0075305635,
-0.0183629524,
-0.00477341,
0.0085582156,
-0.0237888843,
-0.0064878403,
-0.0228927471,
0.0545253567,
-0.0736373439,
0.0102834841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02296v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02296v1 | LLMs Accelerate Annotation for Medical Information Extraction | 2023-12-04T19:26:13 | 2023-12-04T19:26:13 | Akshay Goel, Almog Gueta, Omry Gilon, Chang Liu, Sofia Erell, Lan Huong Nguyen, Xiaohong Hao, Bolous Jaber, Shashir Reddy, Rupesh Kartha, Jean Steiner, Itay Laish, Amir Feder | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The unstructured nature of clinical notes within electronic health records
often conceals vital patient-related information, making it challenging to
access or interpret. To uncover this hidden information, specialized Natural
Language Processing (NLP) models are required. However, training these models
necessitates large amounts of labeled data, a process that is both
time-consuming and costly when relying solely on human experts for annotation.
In this paper, we propose an approach that combines Large Language Models
(LLMs) with human expertise to create an efficient method for generating ground
truth labels for medical text annotation. By utilizing LLMs in conjunction with
human annotators, we significantly reduce the human annotation burden, enabling
the rapid creation of labeled datasets. We rigorously evaluate our method on a
medical information extraction task, demonstrating that our approach not only
substantially cuts down on human intervention but also maintains high accuracy.
The results highlight the potential of using LLMs to improve the utilization of
unstructured clinical data, allowing for the swift deployment of tailored NLP
solutions in healthcare. | [
0.0694446713,
0.0462751575,
0.0180339832,
0.0007047621,
-0.0219232067,
0.0361822061,
-0.0126218256,
0.0189257488,
0.0341720358,
-0.0481805727,
-0.0074010501,
-0.0248552449,
-0.0119942464,
-0.0039760834,
0.0085907625,
-0.0246365648,
0.009922863,
0.004317217,
0.0291942656,
0.0454557054,
-0.0239384249,
-0.0024449248,
-0.0083003547,
0.0285850316,
-0.0126418313,
0.0172402039,
0.0226270519,
-0.0091573838,
0.0120522752,
-0.0934144557,
-0.0265684891,
0.0250028037,
-0.0081430441,
0.0096380478,
0.0000018553,
-0.0327886157,
-0.0293248203,
0.0598526411,
-0.0723933205,
-0.002191416,
0.0399951935,
-0.0583719499,
-0.0142550841,
0.0022086571,
-0.0359576941,
-0.0511321239,
0.0194065906,
0.0480600893,
0.0822556466,
0.080827415,
-0.0307726935,
0.0094062006,
0.0268333163,
-0.0110332258,
0.0397043899,
-0.0641846135,
0.0630705357,
0.0300449245,
0.030494187,
0.0117956959,
0.0548351891,
0.040155787,
-0.0470613427,
0.0176418275,
0.0106357206,
0.0555443279,
-0.0291593783,
-0.0116496366,
-0.0051731966,
0.0762077942,
-0.0031021247,
0.0091652181,
0.05761154,
-0.0060683484,
-0.0449337848,
-0.0034662546,
-0.0236617364,
0.030971257,
-0.0458465293,
0.0071624732,
0.0210090932,
-0.0175363626,
0.0429435633,
0.0116825234,
0.0121542867,
0.0233765878,
-0.0073248767,
-0.0286047366,
0.0458074473,
0.0029940482,
-0.010918553,
-0.067626074,
0.0490425751,
0.0296622626,
0.0026159009,
0.0317296758,
-0.027289154,
-0.0539446175,
0.0658883825,
-0.0759832337,
0.0108735878,
-0.024263287,
-0.0115093663,
0.093508102,
-0.0190081857,
-0.038119074,
-0.0422537625,
0.0157850198,
-0.0194100887,
-0.0042125043,
-0.0216017533,
-0.014965442,
-0.0249810424,
0.0282143746,
-0.0269430913,
-0.0046968381,
-0.0483313426,
0.0001798697,
0.0037019341,
0.0474360846,
0.0267090481,
-0.0009993644,
-0.0109664081,
-0.0181347989,
-0.0038246207,
-0.0178006813,
0.0096042408,
0.0057580057,
-0.0345320739,
-0.0442320928,
0.0210083593,
0.0241189934,
0.0368306078,
-0.0011659283,
0.0394188948,
0.0562835783,
0.023345001,
-0.022346545,
-0.048426915,
-0.0410255529,
-0.0058798757,
0.0189578775,
-0.0055738003,
-0.0526116155,
0.0262617748,
0.0177352801,
-0.0179517884,
-0.0459369197,
0.0435330532,
0.0356367417,
-0.067193009,
0.0848318934,
-0.0912777409,
0.0083448719,
0.0482133925,
0.0056065666,
-0.0139139304,
0.0029668754,
0.0481446646,
-0.0144648459,
0.0194878615,
-0.0033980075,
0.0421947837,
0.054887969,
-0.0046269093,
-0.0492253602,
-0.003791878,
0.0111343898,
0.0377431586,
0.043811094,
-0.0123239337,
0.0723442435,
0.0113824643,
-0.0020518065,
0.0393811129,
0.0761688277,
-0.0236036517,
0.0147755006,
0.0230791178,
-0.0097351549,
0.0060093468,
-0.0400234945,
-0.0120410947,
-0.0217520446,
0.0047659557,
0.012981005,
-0.0090108793,
-0.0215758998,
0.0005852049,
-0.0329462737,
-0.0788106173,
-0.0272740163,
0.0036303527,
-0.0209565628,
0.0472251698,
-0.0113536138,
-0.0330109559,
0.0707475841,
0.0516371019,
-0.0348453969,
-0.0044946079,
-0.0342664793,
-0.0262855794,
0.0692508295,
0.0576140992,
-0.0801236853,
-0.0171050131,
-0.0354381166,
0.0260987319,
0.0328368098,
0.0046290215,
-0.033520598,
-0.0188034791,
-0.0342175253,
0.0004286106,
0.0649323687,
0.0159308035,
-0.0315487385,
0.0351627544,
-0.0216688234,
-0.0019634585,
-0.0462930836,
-0.0597245432,
0.0759345144,
-0.0713956282,
-0.0375444442,
0.015996892,
-0.0154286837,
0.0134086944,
0.0358871408,
-0.0154522294,
0.0397859812,
0.0530050583,
-0.0441652536,
-0.0193855185,
-0.0241595749,
0.0064404989,
0.008331663,
0.011356473,
-0.0166962836,
-0.0045967926,
-0.0528287292,
-0.0258584451,
0.0047495873,
-0.0831428245,
-0.0311845541,
0.0129934363,
-0.0023232009,
0.0107760457,
0.0686592087,
-0.0148934424,
-0.0537132807,
0.0425555408,
-0.0300624147,
-0.0026154593,
0.0034071684,
-0.0460938998,
-0.0140070468,
-0.004114199,
0.0104026319,
0.0165496506,
0.0218068901,
0.0028154538,
-0.018590847,
-0.0020780403,
-0.0149948569,
-0.0400915816,
-0.1358464062,
0.0053362655,
0.0210390873,
0.0234894399,
0.0388638973,
0.0355155244,
-0.0122205857,
-0.029637998,
-0.042910438,
-0.0349544846,
0.0161881894,
0.0153908459,
0.0605658181,
0.0511048995,
0.0083643477,
-0.0296118446,
0.0049327519,
-0.0455485098,
0.0122319022,
0.0181451123,
-0.0817693025,
-0.0135856653,
-0.0090725254,
-0.0035422225,
0.0260142405,
0.0081929751,
0.0098018292,
-0.0054576378,
-0.0134901647,
-0.0139031457,
0.0445871577,
-0.0051479312,
0.0296778101,
0.0316766202,
0.0097230142,
0.0072014332,
0.0200854428,
-0.0353608951,
0.0102693066,
-0.0175966825,
-0.0524453558,
0.0219641756,
0.0815891922,
0.0091930479,
0.003233637,
0.0075321929,
-0.0318283439,
-0.0274591688,
0.0303938109,
-0.0573954843,
0.009155334,
-0.0503399931,
0.0427924804,
-0.0086879265,
-0.0213079564,
0.0664837286,
-0.0335905887,
0.0256090667,
-0.0351803117,
-0.0129111893,
-0.0548256487,
0.019828761,
-0.0020258573,
0.0031630783,
-0.0060750698,
-0.0181674324,
0.0446310602,
0.0268207379,
0.012662448,
-0.0685200021,
0.043334879,
-0.0370289423,
0.0454738736,
-0.0199167039,
-0.0217855424,
-0.0425485186,
-0.0468505844,
-0.0531789064,
0.0019955996,
0.000287424,
0.0232643355,
-0.0449582227,
0.0158632807,
0.0001405217,
0.0916418582,
0.0314877816,
0.0001084069,
-0.0164253376,
0.0289952122,
0.0231853351,
-0.0374468341,
-0.0164415743,
-0.0121376459,
0.015674321,
0.0660764575,
-0.0035433196,
0.0605178811,
0.020443473,
-0.007667962,
-0.007745828,
-0.043657653,
-0.0068548741,
0.0329727978,
0.0112453075,
-0.058194574,
0.0116375377,
0.1260483265,
0.0500260666,
-0.038902007,
0.015598827,
0.0151476599,
-0.0532375574,
-0.0074101901,
0.0254196376,
-0.0700639412,
-0.0436933562,
0.009262396,
0.0175647791,
-0.0088422494,
-0.0710729584,
0.0111470837,
-0.0520124957,
0.020268064,
-0.004658842,
-0.0248617847,
0.0153422505,
-0.0764663815,
-0.0042367112,
-0.0260067955,
-0.0428469628,
-0.010595764,
-0.0096577741,
-0.0175000262,
0.0115121314,
-0.0792193115,
-0.0776099041,
0.0091352062,
-0.0291605853,
0.0457459129,
0.0584898479,
0.0427896753,
-0.0159557257,
-0.032495182,
0.0439560115,
0.0449109301,
-0.0024488976,
-0.0185907409,
0.0894258767,
-0.0228559207,
-0.0206875112,
-0.0275835916,
0.0421012007,
-0.0376062579,
-0.0160164703,
-0.0046055685,
0.0562747903,
0.0039022893,
0.0214884561,
-0.0132049676,
-0.0038587104,
0.0270185843,
0.051950343,
-0.0258010216,
-0.0342650823,
-0.0083159497,
0.0207826532,
0.0425327681,
0.0115821231,
-0.0478621311,
0.0507562272,
-0.0696369857,
-0.043748796,
-0.0684706122,
-0.0055448874,
0.0668233708,
-0.0230558552,
0.0380306765,
0.0305721331,
0.0310760196,
0.0160544347,
-0.0600011013,
0.0401257649,
-0.0058201803,
0.0015122604,
-0.0616657957,
-0.0570041612,
0.0440437011,
-0.0064850776,
-0.0240768101,
0.0302621704,
-0.0371633545,
-0.0116339913,
0.0112545788,
0.0147773167,
0.0136045199,
0.0158132538,
0.0082293767,
-0.0155353183,
-0.0047722622,
0.0564962775,
-0.0418908708,
-0.0513647795,
-0.0242024343,
0.0097831255,
0.0035453101,
0.0058551952,
-0.0040004593,
0.0360100791,
0.0222590417,
0.0216912329,
-0.0508136824,
-0.0456055477,
0.0306755789,
0.0480299853,
0.0694615468,
-0.0221364629,
-0.0087512266,
-0.0240984447,
0.0088764774,
-0.0219631214,
-0.0172497556,
-0.0205246322,
0.0018087918,
0.0172259863,
-0.0185251031,
-0.02605992,
0.0309832171,
-0.0203164965,
-0.0060034706,
-0.0296784081,
0.025168214,
-0.0039888863,
0.0008115346,
0.0131183481,
-0.0464798696,
-0.006771645,
0.0228750408,
0.0049796286,
0.0330818258,
-0.0024307105,
0.0234808568,
-0.02804715,
0.0126347924,
-0.0097530494,
0.0456372984,
-0.0219470784,
-0.0089754872,
-0.0587866083,
0.062276423,
0.0422223918,
0.0009482449,
0.0270432979,
-0.0469670407,
-0.0193609558,
-0.0152802356,
0.0296178702,
-0.0031134558,
0.0158189647,
0.0121436445,
0.0100805694,
-0.0331287459,
-0.0140684834,
0.0654003173,
0.0370112322,
0.0529197976,
-0.0073215454,
-0.0672865137,
-0.0551001988,
0.0118362922,
0.0085490933,
-0.0056179087,
-0.0534572378,
0.0259261895,
-0.0588772781,
-0.0295587666,
0.0438140109,
0.0087340763,
-0.0260052327,
-0.0014026703,
0.0333822109,
0.0345656425,
0.0123663908,
-0.0262289345,
-0.0538350083,
0.0435039252,
0.0025369627,
-0.016505966,
0.0186017137,
-5.935659459e-33,
-0.0150006227,
-0.0582051501,
0.0281090289,
0.0138282282,
0.0038930401,
0.0406123847,
-0.0095842192,
-0.0080255046,
0.0330548659,
0.008389622,
-0.0453034751,
-0.0217002146,
0.0187077466,
0.0304516591,
0.00489356,
-0.0117137041,
0.0297757816,
0.0104744006,
-0.0319226831,
-0.0076310057,
-0.0169939995,
0.052262459,
0.0423026346,
-0.1248414814,
0.0348873511,
-0.000035403,
0.0127377985,
0.0183199737,
0.0269787312,
0.031901855,
-0.0665402785,
-0.0036774625,
0.0416945145,
-0.0366754308,
0.0019214464,
0.0259689614,
-0.1005044878,
0.0204554796,
-0.010316181,
-0.0113511346,
-0.0212324485,
-0.0377479084,
0.0444480442,
-0.0226355232,
-0.0225937013,
0.0345776789,
0.0317619853,
-0.0491649285,
-0.0181376692,
-0.0400928557,
-0.0291746072,
0.0797611028,
0.0216265917,
0.0108047584,
0.0308727864,
-0.0406854711,
-0.0426817611,
0.047401689,
-0.0580899082,
-0.0242584348,
0.0322306231,
0.0304967314,
-0.0071173962,
-0.0190020036,
0.0081128366,
0.0572401211,
0.017865831,
0.0052104718,
-0.0354006104,
0.0029794911,
-0.0747288689,
0.0250300411,
0.0250432454,
0.0071355267,
0.0364207774,
-0.0199156329,
-0.0749078542,
0.0490366928,
-0.0587423891,
-0.0014379191,
0.0250635631,
-0.0177859757,
-0.0506971888,
0.0209298097,
-0.0100748716,
0.0011831076,
0.002619948,
0.0073286663,
0.0090409257,
0.0165088624,
-0.0337946564,
0.0419190042,
-0.0181701779,
-0.0017793615,
-0.0028348877,
-0.0416863747,
0.0755404904,
0.0289428048,
-0.0621702373,
-0.0448531844,
-0.0534369312,
-0.0272492021,
-0.0055303308,
-0.0147865433,
0.0492907129,
0.0081065297,
0.0306314379,
-0.0462294146,
-0.069307521,
-0.0147352796,
0.0304106977,
0.0227367282,
-0.0102922637,
0.0315931402,
0.05578411,
-0.0043742494,
0.005676894,
0.0630550086,
0.0010517658,
0.0140656261,
-0.0118396766,
-0.0447179116,
0.0132771293,
-0.0109417764,
-0.0215907712,
0.0095026493,
-0.0109090339,
0.0332205407,
0.0177524704,
-0.0413098037,
0.0169867743,
-0.0020485434,
2.591e-7,
0.0992339626,
0.0669876412,
0.0336400419,
-0.0240536667,
0.0447410308,
0.0105794501,
-0.0008807776,
-0.0188977849,
-0.0119135268,
-0.0638687611,
0.0496440753,
-0.013955974,
0.0420919359,
0.0394149423,
-0.0803204626,
-0.0306845065,
-0.0723121092,
-0.0284789614,
-0.0281756762,
-0.0449055843,
0.0482404009,
0.0609854758,
-0.0293841083,
-0.0235739425,
-0.0275869016,
-0.0245410167,
0.0417727754,
-0.0384468213,
-0.0008901777,
0.039825812,
0.0303107146,
0.0309621319,
0.0107155256,
0.0460360125,
-0.022311708,
-0.0002370699,
0.0169037282,
0.126526013,
-0.0619107112,
0.0533326231,
0.0006720684,
-0.0305208564,
0.0156236487,
0.0109605929,
0.0617977045,
-0.0224809013,
-0.0364840552,
-0.0309369639,
0.0100484639,
-0.02004808,
0.0190181006,
-0.0130500514,
-0.0203183461,
0.0375255644,
0.019415088,
-0.0035053436,
-0.0412080027,
-0.0734464973,
-0.0286093373,
0.0247179475,
-0.0232612118,
-0.0150303235,
0.0460923649,
0.0006766327,
-0.0204036888,
-0.0603920259,
0.0267246291,
2.370557009e-34,
0.0072733453,
0.0095553519,
-0.0100311711,
0.0621349253,
0.0304401945,
0.0056405594,
-0.0040165978,
0.0125818858,
-0.0140413595,
-0.056805063,
0.0229061916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02149v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02149v2 | Generative Powers of Ten | 2023-12-04T18:59:25 | 2024-05-22T00:23:00 | Xiaojuan Wang, Janne Kontkanen, Brian Curless, Steve Seitz, Ira Kemelmacher, Ben Mildenhall, Pratul Srinivasan, Dor Verbin, Aleksander Holynski | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR | We present a method that uses a text-to-image model to generate consistent
content across multiple image scales, enabling extreme semantic zooms into a
scene, e.g., ranging from a wide-angle landscape view of a forest to a macro
shot of an insect sitting on one of the tree branches. We achieve this through
a joint multi-scale diffusion sampling approach that encourages consistency
across different scales while preserving the integrity of each individual
sampling process. Since each generated scale is guided by a different text
prompt, our method enables deeper levels of zoom than traditional
super-resolution methods that may struggle to create new contextual structure
at vastly different scales. We compare our method qualitatively with
alternative techniques in image super-resolution and outpainting, and show that
our method is most effective at generating consistent multi-scale content. | [
-0.028068658,
0.0199857093,
0.019114133,
0.0158122461,
-0.0153590785,
0.0003403719,
0.0222119354,
0.0109075392,
-0.0069519142,
-0.0075003351,
0.0175872836,
-0.0316707306,
-0.0117387027,
0.0433560275,
-0.003423773,
-0.1191512644,
-0.0702603832,
-0.0290991981,
-0.0833779126,
-0.0442516319,
-0.0226972885,
0.004282984,
0.0080047268,
-0.0327785015,
-0.067129977,
-0.0024003389,
-0.0360647589,
0.0438054428,
0.0602451563,
-0.0304472074,
-0.0577347204,
-0.011012991,
0.066196695,
-0.0170164537,
0.0000022803,
-0.0380208977,
0.0289328042,
0.0246236417,
0.0769814327,
0.0321924016,
0.0872032717,
-0.0368475094,
-0.0079216771,
-0.0624585114,
-0.0063598198,
0.0235985611,
0.0563009083,
0.0461634099,
0.0375713818,
-0.0274692569,
-0.0203967113,
-0.10668502,
-0.0043420838,
-0.0176892448,
0.0299047232,
0.0247541219,
0.0277468991,
0.0751090422,
0.0237559807,
0.0604543537,
-0.0125518823,
0.0197812058,
0.0507437922,
-0.0131002963,
0.0464986116,
0.0604418553,
0.1007164717,
-0.0534504019,
0.0074007548,
0.0279638153,
-0.0709624812,
0.0238321833,
0.0089587402,
-0.0346625559,
-0.0369963646,
0.0360191241,
-0.0653936788,
-0.0115726143,
-0.0090306485,
0.0100418376,
-0.092698127,
0.0235282928,
0.0446254238,
-0.0085858516,
-0.0345280282,
-0.0431925096,
0.039421346,
0.0193864815,
-0.0650479496,
0.0147653595,
-0.0749431327,
-0.0347532034,
0.0854052305,
0.0227210447,
0.0101147136,
0.0266907159,
-0.0265176482,
-0.0016220482,
0.0189693049,
0.0092451144,
0.0567652918,
-0.0335717909,
-0.02227428,
0.0480563715,
0.0126759876,
-0.0172777679,
-0.0466565043,
-0.0184565522,
-0.0508553833,
-0.0104229962,
0.0117437057,
-0.0202045348,
-0.0241921339,
0.011953637,
-0.091538839,
-0.021884555,
-0.0230633244,
0.0080707874,
0.0250907186,
-0.015693713,
0.0145930992,
0.0371706225,
-0.0892584845,
-0.0235782322,
-0.004968565,
0.0185544956,
-0.0634607524,
0.0225156825,
0.0276959687,
0.0012240279,
-0.0262562986,
-0.0150178997,
0.0536581576,
0.0017983795,
-0.0551846214,
0.0308342446,
-0.0278741531,
0.0242709126,
-0.0511436276,
-0.004832875,
-0.0546072684,
0.0009989735,
-0.0161192752,
-0.0677145645,
0.035805352,
-0.0449226722,
-0.0055787438,
-0.0127906185,
0.0293167587,
0.0146502052,
-0.0116402963,
0.0600059405,
-0.0268240422,
0.0036485544,
0.0287387352,
0.0014887329,
0.0320425183,
0.036056865,
0.0159779787,
0.088719964,
0.0036883045,
0.0241312496,
0.0078803189,
0.0151387108,
0.0311257709,
0.0149039952,
-0.0213114023,
-0.0326342992,
-0.0000704419,
0.0459539704,
0.0245027542,
0.0528084897,
-0.0487920679,
0.0045079896,
0.0841892436,
0.0529550985,
-0.0236489177,
0.0062789684,
0.0513106994,
0.0246174987,
-0.052550137,
0.0022375812,
0.013634434,
0.0307672992,
0.0809162036,
0.0272889566,
0.0481460281,
0.0324505381,
-0.0279603079,
-0.0479045548,
0.0127515681,
0.0073202378,
0.013152821,
-0.0236550719,
0.045146592,
0.0416161008,
-0.0018119541,
-0.0070480402,
0.0108743124,
-0.0477414988,
0.058200784,
0.0264389701,
-0.0067617288,
0.074436374,
0.0085409349,
0.0136214262,
0.0999959484,
-0.0017336067,
0.043259263,
0.0832971036,
-0.0013267663,
-0.0008068791,
0.0244777482,
-0.0431705415,
-0.0277860332,
-0.0151911713,
-0.0189133789,
0.0076386859,
-0.0029557867,
0.0304307714,
-0.0082273111,
-0.074052617,
-0.0079519004,
0.0323161967,
-0.0303215273,
-0.0389834382,
0.02247159,
-0.010482627,
-0.0277999621,
0.0289650261,
-0.0315484554,
-0.0120862024,
0.0048186346,
-0.0220765639,
-0.0300065428,
-0.0200790837,
-0.0543983467,
0.0079240361,
0.0011256387,
-0.065188773,
0.0031424502,
-0.0132097322,
-0.0161576848,
-0.014549383,
0.0119167818,
0.0456944518,
0.0104474928,
-0.0426875725,
-0.0124539239,
-0.0255419482,
0.015434566,
-0.0444496721,
0.0652520508,
-0.0321720205,
-0.0031822249,
0.0109383874,
0.0434764922,
-0.0496188998,
0.063334249,
0.0256902836,
-0.0314628705,
0.0525493622,
-0.0097670294,
-0.0219671521,
-0.0058768517,
-0.0616077036,
-0.0069225947,
-0.0094240513,
-0.0447277687,
0.0151744327,
-0.0114472946,
0.0494193658,
0.0237925034,
0.0380088389,
-0.003271475,
-0.0036910123,
-0.0111944508,
-0.0163375791,
0.0091281924,
0.0206359327,
-0.0086037973,
0.0571211018,
0.0025927688,
0.0036623122,
0.0442482494,
0.0399492495,
0.0829329416,
-0.0162891168,
-0.0456690937,
-0.0175298508,
0.0002613089,
0.0048406404,
-0.0271502174,
0.0031407545,
-0.0191605091,
-0.0212884098,
0.0189493299,
0.0546794944,
0.0095184604,
0.0175455585,
0.0171411671,
-0.0262215491,
-0.0419048108,
0.0105089489,
-0.0307319481,
-0.0114004975,
0.0166652538,
0.0035621303,
0.0179542992,
0.0226669181,
0.0220997017,
0.025026137,
-0.0069014691,
-0.0123447701,
-0.0173279513,
-0.0549201742,
0.0123545118,
0.0199812185,
-0.0039555617,
0.014861743,
-0.0613251515,
-0.0405803695,
0.0305692125,
-0.0183818825,
-0.0181215815,
-0.027892096,
0.0185005628,
0.0503046364,
0.0575395636,
0.00620003,
0.0267501958,
0.0252597295,
0.0348228179,
0.0116262482,
-0.0038647852,
0.0194983222,
-0.0076361643,
0.0137936044,
-0.0843800828,
-0.0205188487,
0.0036400494,
-0.0248041451,
-0.0174152534,
0.006589435,
0.0119604589,
-0.0236317609,
-0.0101092393,
-0.0209846832,
-0.0274001099,
0.0220072344,
0.0336048044,
0.0168856941,
-0.0041864854,
-0.0545623302,
0.004605202,
0.0809466243,
0.0120037803,
-0.0029673197,
-0.0129756099,
-0.0375561342,
-0.0107006431,
0.0376896411,
-0.0327137485,
0.0026234749,
-0.0157691594,
0.0244496576,
-0.0122709423,
0.0291752573,
0.0112389876,
0.0283822566,
0.0904334635,
-0.02792814,
-0.0394253694,
0.0441083945,
0.0334397219,
-0.0129883476,
0.0091146519,
-0.0234125163,
0.0839403868,
0.0250250809,
-0.0131635601,
-0.0538397543,
-0.0206304137,
-0.0239197575,
-0.033568766,
0.0340448506,
-0.0221581887,
-0.0072813476,
-0.0851886794,
0.0578097329,
0.0282328166,
-0.0079871602,
-0.0045177876,
-0.0232745577,
0.0558271967,
0.0287204497,
-0.0439268574,
0.0111344792,
-0.0157074593,
0.0048801717,
0.0029064771,
0.1038297266,
-0.0087322164,
-0.0288222954,
-0.0229981747,
-0.028295191,
0.0342648476,
0.0063614533,
0.0058914535,
-0.0283700395,
0.0282348301,
0.0046099401,
0.0341195837,
0.0059337388,
0.0603269413,
0.0336245187,
0.0109818093,
-0.0008437632,
0.0487178974,
0.0029945653,
-0.0018823311,
0.0412156358,
0.0146733904,
0.0238138642,
-0.0171505734,
-0.0193369761,
0.0068192044,
0.0354004055,
-0.0068398882,
0.0396300964,
-0.0176389646,
-0.0684736446,
-0.0492549352,
0.0481644422,
-0.0253188238,
-0.0583044328,
0.0368234813,
-0.0023764747,
-0.0680530742,
-0.0563495308,
-0.0169571694,
0.0399403721,
0.0324365236,
0.0070851748,
-0.0478685386,
-0.0053172833,
0.0005381635,
-0.0605587326,
-0.0230082478,
-0.043138966,
-0.0062455432,
0.0151802171,
0.042226769,
0.039718125,
-0.0255147982,
0.0001865636,
0.0304793045,
-0.0903865844,
-0.0330528244,
-0.0059097167,
0.0332520232,
0.0032168371,
0.0505459346,
0.0010387138,
-0.0677730218,
0.1300638914,
0.0481746495,
0.0043681278,
0.0023502349,
-0.0249768272,
0.0131910695,
0.0072798296,
0.0217581764,
-0.0731194317,
0.0472353101,
-0.0042137951,
0.0442914292,
-0.0311050043,
0.0184491966,
0.0057533318,
-0.0595122203,
0.0048629381,
-0.0062279715,
0.07254906,
0.0064633777,
0.0100053558,
-0.0268520806,
-0.0359600261,
-0.0273808781,
0.0198693294,
-0.0317513496,
0.0434950031,
0.0094238566,
0.0029529002,
0.0169602558,
0.0243408736,
-0.0254451241,
-0.0467298292,
0.001290441,
-0.0587882847,
0.0028468978,
0.0165169854,
-0.0079653906,
0.002999732,
-0.0599017404,
0.0557143316,
0.0052797613,
0.0158444103,
0.0343668945,
-0.0360530578,
-0.033180397,
0.0025279133,
-0.0369647406,
-0.0109023824,
-0.0609328896,
0.0408782177,
0.0361715071,
0.0316734686,
0.0714119896,
-0.018755611,
-0.0133878039,
-0.020926604,
0.0166729167,
0.0295520853,
-0.0538441092,
0.0073235715,
0.0112534994,
0.025680678,
-0.0150158601,
0.0260551106,
-0.0803484246,
-0.0025625415,
0.003630002,
-0.0171878282,
0.0196944084,
-0.0216123331,
-0.0600257479,
0.0152619742,
0.03270844,
0.0103407884,
-0.0081332801,
-0.0066609713,
-0.0163025092,
0.0502712168,
-0.0347585641,
-0.0202381741,
0.049533207,
0.0052592554,
-0.0441651978,
0.0068506496,
0.0212325938,
0.0466627181,
-0.028669104,
-0.0118489536,
0.0160096735,
-5.927302796e-33,
-0.0373304747,
-0.0227824524,
-0.0109107364,
-0.0171237942,
-0.0183365829,
-0.0445965193,
-0.0095381252,
0.0018722003,
0.0100435363,
0.0498200059,
-0.0148382746,
-0.0249908604,
0.005327777,
0.0807061717,
-0.0084847994,
0.0521837063,
0.0529715419,
0.0156833883,
-0.0181941334,
0.0454263389,
-0.0071967491,
-0.0005344587,
0.01282035,
-0.0596576445,
-0.0544775985,
-0.0020138503,
0.0023258289,
0.0010015416,
0.0447470918,
0.0300441533,
-0.0308271088,
0.0329929627,
-0.0054772529,
-0.0773215666,
-0.0367475934,
-0.0295926351,
-0.0678623244,
-0.0524212644,
-0.0334942676,
-0.0189983249,
-0.0828962699,
-0.0123471478,
0.0363513567,
-0.0235920772,
0.0135241384,
-0.0429435112,
0.0616627112,
-0.0433099754,
-0.0159456953,
-0.0361186825,
-0.0022242013,
0.0152177978,
-0.0272237621,
0.0000683712,
-0.0110468762,
-0.000246421,
0.0088724028,
0.0677049533,
-0.0474164933,
0.0498132482,
0.0798883438,
0.0092409104,
0.0413297378,
0.0841099694,
0.0333628654,
0.0368351378,
-0.005568088,
-0.0306606311,
-0.0184828397,
-0.0183914639,
-0.0096080769,
0.0188647266,
-0.0110420715,
0.0860243365,
0.034571249,
0.0250826422,
-0.0081405584,
0.0388991609,
-0.0364351906,
-0.0098263519,
0.0679304004,
0.0249975845,
0.0325495861,
-0.0259608831,
-0.0278114602,
-0.029669825,
-0.0313792899,
-0.0582799762,
0.0055731805,
-0.0033679283,
-0.0147344088,
0.0485922657,
0.0188846216,
0.0142193167,
-0.0466782376,
-0.021094989,
-0.0433963686,
0.0429998897,
-0.008989498,
-0.0441559218,
0.0126150548,
-0.0061998153,
0.0185191166,
0.0848166719,
0.0004219083,
0.010208332,
-0.0237782821,
-0.0063179219,
-0.0049688532,
-0.0195345022,
-0.0268762317,
-0.0076099639,
0.0077055772,
-0.0004345717,
0.0054981238,
-0.0417915024,
-0.0384813547,
0.0377575159,
-0.0120637557,
-0.0079274885,
-0.0120801367,
-0.0007688351,
-0.0102959331,
0.0079632718,
-0.0557399616,
0.0211680587,
-0.0577383637,
-0.003598802,
0.0858382732,
-0.0408232957,
-0.0703931078,
0.0191356074,
2.753e-7,
-0.0096174814,
0.0249762218,
0.0034335456,
-0.0290007722,
0.0007041031,
0.0229304079,
0.0365858488,
0.0384250395,
-0.0300593562,
-0.0699410737,
0.0155478772,
0.0569800474,
0.0092213238,
0.0200719107,
-0.0296914522,
0.0189898498,
-0.0347223505,
-0.0223866887,
-0.0220153369,
-0.0174941346,
0.0192315504,
0.031948261,
0.0236385129,
-0.0167052187,
0.0674772412,
-0.0214367639,
0.0676105544,
-0.0436570272,
0.0487458482,
-0.0222470295,
-0.0832758993,
0.0247103609,
-0.0029157544,
0.0149217909,
0.004694697,
-0.0225714613,
0.0448217764,
0.0511734523,
-0.062629886,
0.028503703,
-0.0183303617,
-0.0019603455,
-0.0039096838,
-0.0912642702,
0.0182874296,
-0.0573902987,
-0.0026373458,
0.0026314377,
-0.0155985467,
-0.0041888673,
-0.0019978401,
-0.0205394551,
-0.0491728336,
0.0233421121,
0.0152414106,
0.0600453392,
-0.0220650081,
-0.0303034727,
-0.0164967217,
-0.0179873854,
-0.0232457221,
-0.0368944108,
-0.0555807538,
-0.0511103123,
-0.0022623176,
0.0031395252,
-0.0037580833,
2.064010353e-34,
0.0026540121,
0.038821049,
0.0016669933,
-0.0617123991,
-0.0090817949,
0.0309297182,
0.0090521313,
-0.0183543246,
-0.0072820457,
-0.0481766239,
-0.0230235253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02143v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02143v3 | Competition-Level Problems are Effective LLM Evaluators | 2023-12-04T18:58:57 | 2024-06-04T05:49:50 | Yiming Huang, Zhenghao Lin, Xiao Liu, Yeyun Gong, Shuai Lu, Fangyu Lei, Yaobo Liang, Yelong Shen, Chen Lin, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive reasoning
capabilities, yet there is ongoing debate about these abilities and the
potential data contamination problem recently. This paper aims to evaluate the
reasoning capacities of LLMs, specifically in solving recent competition-level
programming problems in Codeforces, which are expert-crafted and unique,
requiring deep understanding and robust reasoning skills. We first provide a
comprehensive evaluation of GPT-4's peiceived zero-shot performance on this
task, considering various aspects such as problems' release time, difficulties,
and types of errors encountered. Surprisingly, the peiceived performance of
GPT-4 has experienced a cliff like decline in problems after September 2021
consistently across all the difficulties and types of problems, which shows the
potential data contamination, as well as the challenges for any existing LLM to
solve unseen complex reasoning problems. We further explore various approaches
such as fine-tuning, Chain-of-Thought prompting and problem description
simplification, unfortunately none of them is able to consistently mitigate the
challenges. Through our work, we emphasis the importance of this excellent data
source for assessing the genuine reasoning capabilities of LLMs, and foster the
development of LLMs with stronger reasoning abilities and better generalization
in the future. | [
0.0112936618,
0.0692740083,
-0.0186798777,
0.0649325326,
-0.0695015192,
0.0090217367,
-0.0128774662,
0.0050500548,
-0.0195511319,
-0.0333874598,
0.0151345907,
-0.0095277727,
-0.0197338033,
0.0151273785,
0.0200423896,
-0.0058448138,
0.0298981257,
-0.0723378733,
0.0061347499,
-0.0151246022,
-0.0145103652,
-0.0006750039,
-0.0000388193,
0.019518327,
0.0158105325,
-0.0342412516,
-0.0095494026,
0.0097699175,
0.0020466372,
-0.043990165,
-0.0201793574,
0.0397750847,
0.0049709417,
0.0318745039,
0.0000024363,
-0.0570590273,
-0.0219327696,
0.0298883095,
-0.0574298762,
0.040145006,
-0.0310390498,
0.0224976949,
-0.0087002851,
0.0345902517,
-0.033738371,
0.0156022264,
0.0111363223,
0.0118940957,
0.0714037269,
0.0637004897,
0.0145126954,
-0.0294424556,
0.0257411432,
0.0032067676,
0.0412198938,
-0.0715124384,
0.003447182,
0.0189732704,
0.0472802222,
0.0000540087,
0.0044013364,
0.0384555086,
0.0564373732,
0.016957527,
-0.0422627404,
0.0178569444,
-0.0717579499,
0.0155641111,
0.0062946524,
0.0366425961,
-0.017381575,
-0.0144137051,
-0.0120153995,
-0.0320701078,
-0.0153010488,
-0.013491096,
-0.0350975581,
0.0443999693,
-0.0103731854,
0.0208253879,
0.0079134973,
0.000650822,
0.0240268223,
-0.0028024181,
-0.0582601205,
0.1217558235,
-0.002404883,
-0.0281191077,
0.0187229048,
-0.0094666183,
-0.02732764,
-0.0500509553,
-0.0130778877,
0.0568227842,
-0.0085086059,
0.0314507633,
-0.0031601691,
0.0047256397,
0.0109526226,
-0.0237907022,
0.0094366753,
0.0368299596,
0.0167702679,
0.0520516932,
-0.0203754418,
0.0818205327,
-0.0345275104,
0.0223791208,
-0.0187081806,
-0.0164008122,
-0.0528588891,
-0.0093282368,
-0.0307156481,
0.0558786914,
-0.0065346463,
0.0480710641,
-0.0265910272,
0.0255131237,
-0.0210045036,
0.0663997456,
-0.0290277116,
-0.0186553858,
0.0095632272,
-0.0540235229,
-0.0530858785,
-0.0203523971,
-0.0155290235,
-0.0181980114,
-0.0130856941,
-0.0773037001,
-0.0128385723,
0.0006043786,
-0.0292312466,
-0.0514696389,
0.0248560626,
0.0766236782,
0.0153471958,
0.0060318122,
-0.0524393544,
-0.0372122936,
-0.0171214752,
-0.1030920297,
-0.0137090543,
-0.0984822959,
-0.0165741108,
0.0241351817,
-0.016545346,
-0.0431352779,
-0.005315789,
0.0069498341,
-0.0053245667,
0.0664777085,
-0.0527151823,
0.0151374135,
0.002937332,
0.044621747,
-0.020602921,
0.0736575052,
0.0363006145,
0.01597053,
-0.0078142285,
-0.0176441893,
0.0515730008,
0.0375110842,
0.0008614094,
0.0112711238,
-0.0014996382,
0.0472742282,
-0.0050644195,
0.007208603,
-0.0271895155,
0.0543365628,
-0.0143770594,
0.0193163641,
0.0210364982,
0.0486937873,
-0.0019023524,
0.024309136,
0.0202581733,
0.0188237485,
0.0105856955,
-0.0071387044,
-0.0584855862,
0.0296755154,
-0.0217269156,
0.008680406,
-0.0173914749,
0.0109241037,
-0.0059052072,
-0.0828884915,
-0.030313246,
0.0415866189,
-0.0389545485,
0.0342349559,
0.0481352843,
-0.0332025774,
-0.0279962365,
0.0455577075,
-0.0100993328,
-0.0475737154,
-0.0381306298,
-0.0519581847,
0.0374703966,
0.0295412932,
0.0465242378,
-0.0460712761,
-0.0760310292,
-0.0002494554,
0.0066805254,
-0.013167101,
0.0497147329,
0.0261480119,
0.0029292705,
-0.045290906,
-0.0222222935,
-0.0371941328,
0.0022987959,
0.004116436,
0.0014776231,
-0.0001042822,
0.0352229625,
-0.0161010455,
-0.0224381629,
0.0036114047,
-0.0141690457,
-0.008619179,
-0.0026446867,
0.0138236256,
0.0163111389,
0.0038287486,
-0.0108926464,
0.0177709591,
0.0110497372,
-0.0263755377,
-0.0008040262,
-0.0190671775,
-0.019528199,
-0.0095390053,
0.0374507122,
-0.0662094876,
-0.0414342433,
0.0090259276,
-0.0646942854,
-0.0160612985,
0.0469810665,
-0.0034907495,
0.0077406121,
-0.0040697744,
0.0237260312,
-0.0316071436,
-0.0348433033,
-0.0258748941,
0.0649814457,
0.0312325917,
0.0237393323,
0.0223945193,
0.0446869954,
0.0459512733,
-0.0409923494,
-0.0483705811,
0.0424654745,
-0.0096207578,
0.0015152402,
-0.0027581663,
0.0519148819,
-0.0508849286,
-0.0298927687,
-0.0735796168,
0.0458287671,
0.0011594624,
0.0465586409,
0.0016173745,
-0.0116157727,
-0.0184072219,
0.0305506065,
-0.0510018133,
-0.0226464774,
0.0067648692,
0.0121297585,
0.051944349,
0.0017019915,
-0.0451032408,
-0.0081731044,
0.0092045842,
-0.0504773669,
0.0260287635,
-0.0178362746,
-0.0161399059,
-0.0407888107,
0.0861958712,
-0.0376174562,
0.0034547735,
-0.0164806321,
-0.0104069803,
0.0269911587,
-0.0255892705,
0.0248227455,
0.0486773849,
-0.0551597886,
-0.0039857104,
0.045669198,
-0.0472445004,
-0.0594687946,
0.0390451699,
0.0497960038,
-0.0409171581,
-0.0256772358,
-0.0082620271,
0.0010940868,
0.0604838766,
-0.0190824624,
-0.0277846865,
-0.0475557409,
0.0598068535,
-0.020485336,
0.0150332134,
-0.0121915378,
-0.002980734,
-0.0024409525,
0.0705461726,
-0.0154222287,
-0.0559468418,
0.0556383133,
-0.0289558526,
-0.0124403797,
-0.0259564072,
-0.0149535006,
-0.0702564865,
0.0924236029,
-0.0279243588,
-0.0072577782,
-0.0158382412,
-0.0090745036,
-0.056132257,
-0.0166137926,
0.0148070427,
-0.0336927734,
0.0860630572,
-0.077179648,
0.0065862834,
-0.0360756889,
-0.0558995716,
-0.0157096516,
0.0146159101,
-0.0391488299,
-0.0010058568,
0.0295076836,
0.0174295232,
0.0070203561,
0.0091734417,
0.0037502795,
0.0083274255,
-0.0004101861,
-0.0284981523,
-0.0075271376,
-0.0168236792,
-0.0070441873,
0.0070082797,
0.0395872295,
-0.0322027206,
0.0256881416,
0.0488928929,
0.0648017526,
0.0067340317,
-0.0445912629,
0.0306284074,
0.0039271456,
-0.0144178737,
-0.0500385687,
0.0330736488,
0.057996735,
-0.1010965928,
-0.009166887,
0.0955204219,
0.0281880759,
-0.0282027815,
0.0089644333,
-0.0101251509,
0.0189711787,
0.0578856617,
0.0573326983,
-0.1142948717,
-0.0358052887,
0.0185178034,
0.0103498027,
-0.0254362579,
-0.0440351106,
-0.0515333042,
-0.1458503157,
0.0677973777,
0.0115319779,
0.0082943365,
-0.02553178,
0.0086387768,
-0.0010957471,
-0.0148926144,
-0.0139623228,
0.0298360083,
0.0171851646,
0.0137839019,
0.013060878,
-0.0216614865,
-0.011697216,
0.0677242428,
-0.0126433745,
0.0425181352,
0.0209411085,
0.0107768113,
-0.0041789659,
-0.0379743166,
0.0528367646,
-0.0187550504,
0.003268163,
-0.0185495969,
0.0092953024,
0.0094863726,
-0.0086663207,
0.0123600196,
-0.0005598663,
-0.0402096212,
-0.025493471,
0.0651526377,
0.1139222234,
-0.0093624955,
-0.0267583188,
-0.001928483,
-0.024014879,
-0.0606155768,
0.0525075421,
0.0179493912,
0.0064889141,
-0.0617633052,
-0.0665174276,
-0.0328349695,
-0.0417616442,
-0.009591395,
0.0206783656,
0.0471477434,
0.0129576921,
0.0091641052,
-0.0020966611,
0.0693894699,
0.0637578964,
-0.0118669635,
-0.0070637255,
-0.0212795902,
0.0228717607,
-0.0271573775,
0.0315705538,
-0.0470164269,
0.0326716453,
-0.0568125062,
0.0581756197,
-0.0071236589,
-0.0058904262,
-0.0163506567,
0.0244908687,
-0.111788258,
-0.0620463304,
-0.0316344686,
0.0532436706,
0.0394151285,
0.0062608887,
-0.0260598753,
-0.0427216701,
0.0061759832,
0.0192068908,
-0.0357003696,
0.0105926013,
0.025780106,
0.0097977184,
0.0188679229,
0.0148334857,
-0.0353253782,
0.0036865757,
0.0382301584,
0.0151966633,
-0.0190724898,
0.0027615961,
0.0394250453,
0.0745462552,
0.0027893605,
0.0300653167,
-0.0155554805,
-0.0040426417,
0.0419709906,
-0.0184300225,
-0.0480089262,
-0.0619078986,
0.0106305201,
-0.0086303391,
-0.0203820486,
0.0185845159,
-0.0196235776,
-0.0055400771,
0.0446569547,
-0.0046321251,
0.0415323414,
0.0253591482,
0.0057641133,
0.058649797,
-0.026100276,
-0.001223819,
0.01774255,
-0.0076661729,
0.0456102788,
0.0002473162,
0.0614094548,
0.0232815798,
0.0301359631,
0.0010370238,
0.0052925576,
-0.0756554902,
-0.1106463596,
0.0244445819,
0.0258507188,
0.0513651147,
0.0293988809,
-0.017225612,
-0.0196031276,
0.0168453846,
0.0086876079,
0.0200416632,
-0.0047986405,
-0.0215438176,
0.0305021834,
0.0543335676,
-0.0102373902,
-0.0294465292,
0.0729158074,
0.0323930867,
0.0174369756,
-0.0060261548,
0.0067245327,
-0.0168886892,
-0.0223250166,
0.0213335603,
-0.0051594581,
0.0166572109,
-0.0115409857,
-0.0949250236,
-0.0769692808,
-0.0099557051,
0.0100659039,
0.0125794122,
-0.0063382024,
0.009954514,
0.0930812508,
0.0087877642,
-0.0378475636,
-0.0065859887,
-0.0164886024,
0.0232089423,
-0.0106999818,
-0.0189150218,
-6.451653725e-33,
-0.0151556768,
-0.0399723239,
0.051943142,
-0.0118573392,
-0.0097486535,
0.0061508012,
-0.042407833,
0.0077997581,
-0.0264757723,
-0.022189321,
-0.024459919,
0.0279417206,
-0.0073907063,
-0.0179078821,
0.0241936129,
-0.0266892817,
0.0032596409,
0.0242577046,
-0.0377507955,
-0.0040314621,
-0.0294734072,
-0.0090715624,
0.0344431773,
-0.0194246396,
0.0069476198,
-0.0071434914,
-0.0086858692,
0.0258331336,
-0.0521365069,
0.0392272249,
0.0138905784,
0.0052453433,
0.0109252166,
-0.0626594201,
-0.0010451078,
-0.0475911871,
0.0071465382,
-0.0399230048,
0.0395056941,
-0.0237383731,
-0.0121779358,
-0.0426112823,
0.0439996384,
0.0301232245,
-0.026052475,
-0.0244812332,
-0.0066951336,
-0.0318040587,
0.02568895,
-0.0223245788,
-0.0020242117,
0.0511911102,
-0.0426654629,
0.0278208982,
0.0202358924,
0.0208647661,
-0.0132185714,
0.0542281792,
-0.0076696496,
0.0044610542,
0.0545477867,
0.0112639572,
0.0990777239,
-0.036542438,
-0.0077698864,
0.0299956463,
0.0028116438,
0.012860328,
-0.035799522,
-0.010770401,
-0.0010731291,
0.0741724223,
0.0496589392,
0.0129319495,
0.0414211378,
0.0306415483,
-0.0654264614,
0.0019295192,
-0.0049263178,
0.0255632382,
0.0061099892,
0.013717629,
-0.064178355,
-0.0243727379,
-0.0267550834,
0.0128243053,
-0.0437002219,
-0.0214696154,
0.0348730795,
-0.0543376617,
-0.0158332493,
0.0100436499,
0.0151803074,
-0.0328337587,
-0.0106800748,
0.0026091223,
-0.0178693868,
0.0221166424,
0.0006101189,
0.0695089325,
-0.0530366339,
-0.007193781,
-0.0323141553,
0.0145596126,
0.069471322,
-0.0007987021,
0.0023493017,
0.0213319696,
-0.0654519498,
-0.0296770632,
-0.0774222091,
0.0260077324,
0.0064299381,
0.0303715337,
0.0066184564,
0.0036505251,
0.0320790634,
0.0408990309,
0.0106264912,
-0.0318427458,
-0.0156366006,
0.0393405035,
-0.0016948108,
-0.0079326089,
-0.0010749961,
-0.0404385142,
-0.0095482701,
0.0364966355,
0.0320516154,
-0.0366453938,
-0.0246240869,
0.044373922,
3.215e-7,
0.0397299007,
0.0422581695,
-0.0149136037,
0.0397447646,
-0.008841591,
0.0421209447,
-0.0369241498,
-0.0393583588,
0.0123985577,
-0.0118985567,
0.0107534984,
0.0549146123,
0.0356706753,
0.0590152852,
-0.0572478771,
0.0396299735,
-0.0221201833,
-0.041046299,
-0.0869636834,
0.0089489073,
0.0878348723,
0.0692356825,
0.0288350526,
-0.0128338644,
0.016004432,
-0.0580459982,
0.0164501891,
-0.0161971729,
-0.0129234074,
0.0457115509,
0.0145205697,
0.0124062719,
-0.0098969107,
0.0378294289,
0.0273071975,
0.0029885799,
-0.0056719347,
0.0553091131,
0.0131176086,
0.0070846342,
-0.008393079,
-0.0541613922,
-0.0154913832,
-0.0695146844,
0.1049433351,
-0.031366419,
-0.0442423522,
0.0025178692,
-0.0109687913,
-0.059565872,
-0.0006873555,
0.0006282275,
0.0161956474,
0.0084446864,
-0.012748017,
-0.0537247807,
-0.0095268236,
-0.059180852,
-0.0114714671,
0.0053394046,
-0.0124794226,
-0.0580773018,
-0.0461896658,
0.0188365765,
0.0342496336,
-0.029076891,
0.0189176332,
3.442147991e-34,
0.0480788499,
-0.0323778801,
0.0365133733,
0.0097632613,
0.066723235,
0.0354295969,
-0.0307638645,
0.00112943,
-0.0067305434,
-0.0458958894,
-0.0189413503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02125v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02125v2 | TPPoet: Transformer-Based Persian Poem Generation using Minimal Data and Advanced Decoding Techniques | 2023-12-04T18:52:26 | 2023-12-06T05:19:11 | Amir Panahandeh, Hanie Asemi, Esmaeil Nourani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in language models (LMs), have demonstrated significant
efficacy in tasks related to the arts and humanities. While LMs have exhibited
exceptional performance across a wide range of natural language processing
tasks, there are notable challenges associated with their utilization on small
datasets and their ability to replicate more creative human capacities. In this
study, we aim to address these challenges by training a Persian classical
poetry generation model using a transformer architecture on a specialized
dataset with no pretraining. Additionally, we propose a novel decoding method
to enhance coherence and meaningfulness in the generated poetry, effectively
managing the tradeoff between diversity and quality. Furthermore, the results
of our training approach and the proposed decoding method are evaluated through
comprehensive set of automatic and human evaluations and showed its superior
capability to generate coherent and meaningful poetry in compare to other
decoding methods and an existing Persian large language model (LLM). | [
0.0069478587,
0.0833823606,
-0.0198031962,
0.0171184931,
-0.0205271579,
-0.0115336012,
0.0094953934,
-0.0044957846,
-0.0368447341,
-0.0188602898,
-0.0187840648,
-0.0295870844,
0.0379293971,
-0.0062825484,
0.0162585676,
-0.0454410315,
-0.0036238916,
-0.034019433,
0.0038039109,
0.0101410877,
-0.003452057,
0.0167045649,
-0.0097371889,
0.0487321466,
-0.0068309992,
-0.004178986,
-0.037212491,
0.0221690275,
0.0065894453,
-0.0189278107,
-0.0341669582,
0.0480887555,
-0.0070802919,
0.0462735072,
0.0000017636,
-0.0508722216,
-0.0315250643,
-0.0409433693,
0.0793117359,
-0.0437400565,
0.0293195751,
-0.0692778081,
-0.0471344702,
0.02021835,
0.0069963872,
-0.023485411,
0.0566243567,
0.0546964779,
0.0747017264,
0.1097128019,
-0.009155727,
-0.0970554054,
0.0204717536,
-0.0153457159,
0.0063518607,
0.0040750816,
0.0050463728,
-0.0010997393,
-0.0314651318,
0.0135911349,
-0.060981337,
0.0059883795,
-0.0229422171,
-0.0027320539,
0.0094631072,
0.0294467211,
-0.0500309803,
-0.0280533005,
0.0307096206,
0.0130016571,
-0.0098058814,
-0.0260150824,
0.0146594113,
0.0161848404,
-0.0340650901,
-0.0245524161,
-0.0470774397,
0.0786947757,
0.0057831313,
0.0309791081,
0.0326269679,
0.0203118287,
-0.0186717696,
0.0026319306,
-0.0233436041,
-0.0275584068,
0.0267146081,
-0.0406133533,
-0.0143040018,
0.0047821258,
-0.0184080917,
-0.0344693922,
0.010417616,
0.0303806216,
-0.0287827011,
0.0005723509,
-0.0503554977,
-0.0856258273,
0.0045803259,
-0.0049032234,
0.0867068022,
0.0853644535,
0.0431693532,
0.0051930612,
-0.0403897129,
0.0165323447,
0.0290090833,
-0.0101937456,
-0.0645629093,
0.0007802304,
-0.0292433891,
-0.0087743904,
-0.0655129328,
-0.0031581756,
-0.0432590619,
-0.0342171937,
-0.0443879254,
0.0070578274,
0.0383699089,
-0.0023170984,
0.043491181,
0.0241893902,
-0.0515256636,
0.0067384331,
0.0300929192,
0.0478026979,
0.0248582549,
0.0107557429,
-0.0036469465,
-0.0460693538,
-0.0165855177,
0.0361104049,
0.0288817864,
-0.0054991231,
0.0000774847,
0.0033374319,
0.0044756411,
-0.0609651282,
-0.0081337821,
0.0257414263,
-0.0113699539,
-0.0437389985,
0.008745783,
-0.0669306964,
0.0451444723,
0.004963377,
0.0198233984,
-0.0237683989,
0.0199532993,
0.0364991315,
-0.0008905185,
0.0412561819,
0.0028129276,
0.0566401705,
0.0032554658,
0.0049497536,
0.0373229757,
0.0467233583,
0.0908098668,
0.031137621,
-0.003235911,
-0.0044462187,
0.0055606337,
0.0002291417,
-0.0224686526,
-0.0218830667,
-0.0073958784,
-0.0597067699,
-0.0484444052,
0.0735714063,
0.0328741558,
0.0678320751,
-0.01710747,
0.0127492165,
0.0923018605,
0.019723814,
0.0391553864,
0.0792700201,
0.0363305882,
0.0229226127,
0.0356638841,
0.0203227513,
0.0081494926,
0.0392502137,
0.095301114,
0.0721613094,
0.0374774672,
0.0699001998,
-0.0071011428,
0.0081504863,
-0.0210674983,
-0.0504977293,
0.0030446362,
-0.0483438261,
0.0589580871,
0.0548822433,
-0.0629444867,
0.0472507961,
0.0311339032,
-0.0611344725,
0.0228295643,
-0.0389598422,
0.0162433237,
0.0879302472,
0.0595997646,
-0.0041116043,
0.048790697,
0.001270647,
-0.0027025132,
0.0666108727,
-0.0041317767,
0.0093020136,
0.0137741277,
-0.0395858027,
0.0068703191,
0.0061005796,
0.0205195379,
-0.0051653394,
-0.0364120826,
0.0120868459,
0.0290696267,
-0.0002875415,
-0.0478266403,
0.0367003009,
-0.0494656339,
-0.0256463513,
0.0270749368,
0.0048574433,
-0.028241884,
0.0228026565,
-0.0400083065,
0.0410460718,
0.0369355604,
-0.0502783731,
0.0080434391,
0.0228003059,
-0.0400509648,
-0.044983007,
0.0306176227,
-0.0966670737,
0.0335235558,
0.0698374137,
0.0124581307,
-0.0628090575,
0.0748848543,
-0.0410547741,
-0.0008604052,
-0.0327296816,
0.0322729051,
0.0097444281,
0.020738706,
-0.0067476914,
0.0081731081,
0.0012202365,
0.0246944502,
-0.0192918945,
-0.0134858666,
0.0145097412,
-0.0181225762,
-0.0312595889,
0.0233589429,
0.0198747925,
-0.0071511683,
0.0252818409,
0.0081163766,
-0.0019837683,
-0.0787802637,
-0.0620822534,
0.0078766234,
-0.0137995146,
-0.0028863957,
0.0216002017,
0.0156353842,
-0.0099933892,
0.0267581549,
-0.0407261588,
-0.0120648956,
0.0576500744,
-0.0070540346,
0.0406551175,
-0.0430148803,
-0.0317744203,
-0.0138826724,
-0.0222997647,
0.0143401986,
0.0303465351,
0.0034889551,
0.0078679798,
-0.013776117,
-0.0153440889,
-0.0046344581,
-0.0307174549,
0.0153942015,
-0.0373252444,
0.0177581627,
-0.0335556753,
0.0750663057,
0.0132799624,
0.0067583104,
-0.0314965621,
0.0653753281,
-0.0095120268,
0.0182179026,
-0.0340173244,
-0.0255400483,
0.0047670496,
-0.0131346527,
-0.0636827052,
-0.026638383,
0.0404668003,
0.0328229778,
-0.0201833248,
-0.0463933572,
0.0030047414,
-0.0030241716,
0.0247461554,
0.0207863599,
0.0230076313,
-0.0115657328,
0.0261307508,
-0.017705448,
-0.0100173457,
0.0171519257,
-0.0371161513,
-0.0048915264,
-0.0315476283,
0.0280076265,
-0.0735013634,
0.024249224,
0.0076431432,
0.0329392403,
-0.0380164534,
-0.0222139359,
-0.0458590835,
0.0462275594,
-0.0083612362,
-0.0461817048,
0.0441713892,
0.0055732359,
-0.022563614,
-0.0511475652,
0.013692894,
-0.0360109918,
0.030503042,
0.018914381,
-0.0022023488,
0.083213672,
-0.029080648,
0.0073727993,
-0.0000196048,
-0.010576902,
0.0504991077,
-0.0351156555,
-0.0213392153,
-0.0300264768,
0.0470701903,
0.0221049767,
0.0031106654,
0.0165600777,
-0.020914942,
0.0284161847,
0.0099838777,
0.0092800222,
0.0003386099,
-0.0545854308,
0.0016853844,
0.0154069085,
-0.0161600895,
0.0466920286,
-0.0044684126,
-0.023176033,
-0.0503311045,
-0.0411487706,
0.1053421572,
0.0148613444,
0.0089711044,
-0.0046711634,
0.0173194744,
0.0001405994,
0.0208903626,
-0.0121012544,
-0.0693349838,
0.0015124817,
0.0259174891,
0.0614641607,
0.019241469,
-0.0075642159,
-0.0199938584,
-0.0639579222,
-0.0066682082,
0.0167901013,
-0.0097443508,
-0.0394256487,
-0.0113001848,
-0.0347087681,
-0.0085164905,
-0.0249206182,
0.008781001,
-0.0183563624,
0.0343965217,
0.018874865,
-0.0087638171,
-0.0749740824,
-0.0750454068,
-0.0544359311,
0.0284141973,
0.053620033,
0.0434056744,
-0.0174200162,
-0.0298055224,
-0.0351734422,
-0.0192496534,
-0.0106671844,
0.0292779636,
0.0022390047,
0.0329338722,
-0.0096385051,
0.0000874395,
-0.0095513565,
-0.0543539859,
-0.0175918937,
-0.0172830559,
0.0251491778,
-0.0139877675,
-0.0009695526,
0.0155634657,
0.0357121453,
0.0019681365,
0.0638632625,
0.0205442384,
-0.008849428,
-0.0403197259,
-0.0075887716,
0.0015766537,
-0.1216456965,
-0.0437369831,
0.0249510501,
0.0455387719,
-0.0708403811,
-0.0886563286,
-0.0293590836,
-0.0082378509,
0.0186613668,
0.024476558,
0.0158175211,
0.0099278837,
-0.0230876785,
-0.0497207418,
-0.0066136336,
-0.0044690007,
0.0010525443,
-0.0519440509,
-0.0639260709,
0.0056245388,
-0.0821140185,
0.0157928839,
0.0230299383,
-0.1020655259,
-0.0284781698,
0.0512223691,
0.0408515595,
0.0222051553,
0.0022504954,
0.0323792808,
-0.0076577966,
0.0104646832,
0.0468951203,
-0.0019490303,
0.0502674505,
0.0070833042,
-0.0165881477,
-0.0145917078,
0.0244690944,
0.0152638648,
0.028627798,
0.0208688807,
0.0403800718,
0.0507789031,
-0.0437114164,
0.0580391027,
-0.0144952172,
-0.0023339975,
-0.0547811501,
0.0286195613,
-0.0233647637,
-0.0382671282,
-0.0626841709,
0.0263142418,
-0.0366314091,
-0.022865463,
0.0769098997,
0.0302452464,
-0.0232976917,
0.0115595656,
0.0119353915,
-0.023495486,
-0.0359598286,
0.01332762,
0.0040416731,
-0.0448196158,
-0.0047528511,
-0.0022618971,
-0.0028570832,
-0.036137592,
-0.0402857177,
0.0127934879,
0.0025719472,
-0.0021905717,
0.0023363947,
0.008374677,
-0.0061106477,
0.0410862267,
-0.0249215048,
-0.0190000851,
-0.0175569765,
-0.0103296293,
0.0810894743,
-0.0212242343,
0.0852302983,
-0.0398299508,
0.0172314774,
-0.0196892824,
0.0528937951,
0.0143223898,
-0.0108023332,
-0.0700322017,
-0.0115049873,
0.0010637951,
-0.0102646584,
0.0921058953,
-0.0365987085,
-0.0243611261,
0.0005219795,
-0.0285263546,
-0.0194634963,
-0.0283679236,
-0.0394463576,
-0.0340994634,
-0.0460320935,
0.009616144,
-0.0352303386,
-0.0527113937,
0.0135215521,
-0.0009117252,
0.0441692062,
-0.0340883508,
0.0318660662,
0.0258957613,
-0.0188418273,
0.014516334,
-0.0530224033,
-0.0087869298,
-0.0092902016,
-0.0267124325,
-0.0360508449,
-5.553240657e-33,
-0.0390941948,
0.0303134304,
-0.0040339432,
-0.0231850818,
-0.0292734802,
-0.0193268247,
-0.0822450593,
0.0054420815,
0.0234465022,
-0.0069685024,
-0.0199063774,
-0.0078637749,
-0.0030482195,
0.039220389,
0.0387937725,
0.0288756937,
0.0698483214,
-0.0131434128,
-0.0203797463,
0.0237423237,
0.0727628469,
0.0352737457,
0.0324713327,
-0.0315747857,
-0.0234120265,
-0.0358047076,
-0.0059728827,
-0.0167910289,
0.0365317017,
0.0384018384,
-0.025585806,
0.0202081315,
0.0195016526,
-0.0416595452,
-0.0463384502,
-0.0047105867,
-0.0725738257,
0.0143695055,
-0.0455887318,
0.0459025092,
0.0260220021,
-0.027209403,
0.0251606461,
-0.0268277917,
-0.0265054423,
-0.0010148474,
0.0002077768,
-0.0465454869,
0.0032205947,
-0.09019088,
-0.0814711824,
0.0065231095,
-0.0278086178,
-0.0428936705,
0.0012022395,
0.0125537086,
-0.0022017465,
0.0368010215,
-0.0432887897,
0.0384116396,
-0.0036373585,
0.0437092073,
0.0203729607,
0.0088201873,
-0.0300097913,
0.0363619439,
0.0060647633,
-0.0276571754,
-0.005297503,
0.0726543069,
0.021977203,
-0.0161936525,
0.0254428666,
0.0320288874,
0.0425673053,
-0.0533514321,
-0.0532946549,
0.0423727222,
-0.0181790963,
0.0163715295,
0.0511217229,
-0.0079662278,
-0.0003917539,
0.0012411018,
0.0461149551,
-0.024325395,
0.0126294829,
-0.0033284042,
0.008997147,
0.0497359075,
-0.0432708114,
0.0263303742,
0.0048055644,
-0.0669944733,
0.027486505,
0.0273241494,
-0.0727974325,
0.0369109213,
-0.0260203257,
-0.0193651691,
-0.0176795814,
-0.0518766716,
0.0847062021,
0.0015574459,
0.0067018466,
0.020389149,
0.0398088731,
0.0577507839,
-0.0817054734,
0.0134258214,
-0.0466819331,
0.036232464,
0.0137160206,
0.0294221286,
0.0065599266,
0.0054327035,
-0.0115542291,
0.0260792132,
0.0286430921,
0.0320879892,
-0.0025983041,
-0.0014772068,
0.0066792271,
0.0106133083,
0.0096178269,
0.0441166162,
-0.045272205,
-0.0147307431,
0.0357564017,
-0.0413953811,
-0.0324486829,
-0.0091807228,
2.644e-7,
0.0403292961,
0.024002878,
0.0466311537,
0.0511752926,
0.0174591541,
-0.0085696289,
-0.0734649375,
0.0511061102,
-0.0077558965,
0.0319956578,
0.0485414378,
0.0193764325,
0.0657058954,
-0.0000744234,
-0.1155799478,
0.0047303885,
-0.0535291769,
0.0000873828,
-0.083957158,
-0.0044346,
0.0711160004,
0.066247873,
-0.0411641225,
-0.0298283938,
0.0235095061,
-0.006640811,
0.0545465834,
0.013357982,
0.0044174148,
-0.0095551079,
0.0282997824,
-0.0296915043,
-0.0055250432,
-0.02380744,
-0.0309112165,
0.0279879849,
0.0157727376,
0.0552502722,
0.0273458846,
0.0192060731,
0.0656642467,
0.0149418479,
0.0091259228,
-0.0213369671,
0.0377898775,
0.0161761213,
-0.0172575917,
0.0173270721,
-0.0288134497,
0.0492367409,
0.0025216953,
-0.0335683674,
-0.0395586714,
0.0051977676,
0.0422485173,
-0.0027212133,
0.0541470945,
-0.0063013402,
-0.0184170995,
-0.0275520924,
-0.0430948064,
-0.0295384694,
-0.0026780881,
-0.0250117201,
0.0055462439,
-0.0279564038,
-0.0475608967,
2.534362147e-34,
0.0480161868,
-0.0370954871,
-0.0121360151,
-0.0141174616,
0.0228641722,
-0.0315863714,
0.0291104559,
0.0281359237,
-0.0344848223,
-0.0387552865,
-0.0674052611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02120v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02120v2 | Magicoder: Empowering Code Generation with OSS-Instruct | 2023-12-04T18:50:35 | 2024-06-07T02:50:56 | Yuxiang Wei, Zhe Wang, Jiawei Liu, Yifeng Ding, Lingming Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | We introduce Magicoder, a series of fully open-source (code, weights, and
data) Large Language Models (LLMs) for code that significantly closes the gap
with top code models while having no more than 7B parameters. Magicoder models
are trained on 75K synthetic instruction data using OSS-Instruct, a novel
approach to enlightening LLMs with open-source code snippets to generate
diverse instruction data for code. Our main motivation is to mitigate the
inherent bias of the synthetic data generated by LLMs through the wealth of
open-source references for the production of more realistic and controllable
data. The orthogonality of OSS-Instruct and other data generation methods like
Evol-Instruct further enables us to build an enhanced MagicoderS. Both
Magicoder and MagicoderS substantially outperform state-of-the-art code models
with similar or even larger sizes on a wide range of coding benchmarks.
Notably, MagicoderS-CL-7B based on CodeLlama even surpasses the prominent
ChatGPT on HumanEval+ (66.5 vs. 65.9 in pass@1 ). Overall, OSS-Instruct opens a
new direction for crafting diverse synthetic instruction data for code using
abundant open-source references. | [
-0.0053811795,
0.0959516391,
-0.0179758817,
0.0285903588,
0.0105868177,
0.0102394884,
-0.0274229795,
0.0084190043,
0.0075043822,
-0.005615402,
-0.023374917,
0.0148496721,
-0.0208245739,
0.0252708495,
0.0234581418,
0.0204163492,
0.040441744,
-0.0356775783,
-0.0971175358,
-0.0011823134,
-0.0196934957,
0.0355707109,
0.043907769,
0.0190812461,
0.0364325307,
-0.0302055255,
-0.003355725,
0.0437164605,
-0.0072092228,
-0.0136377597,
-0.0011043757,
0.0338989086,
0.0076698917,
0.0046421718,
0.0000023855,
-0.0064119059,
-0.0038217092,
0.0384402126,
-0.0001898311,
0.0913803056,
0.0168330502,
-0.0090012411,
-0.0004637722,
0.0131043997,
-0.0001498225,
-0.0205576438,
0.0476791486,
-0.0623154715,
0.0779923573,
0.0764060766,
0.024539629,
-0.0186782125,
-0.010857298,
0.002076288,
0.036539983,
0.0068071252,
-0.0090199132,
0.0226085447,
0.0003336458,
0.0236609392,
-0.0096256295,
-0.0016827462,
0.0310259927,
-0.0118089486,
0.0062915008,
0.0376070067,
-0.0204745755,
-0.0065937419,
0.0000413659,
0.0763735026,
-0.0659127682,
-0.0422703996,
0.007596245,
-0.0061609936,
-0.0392761715,
-0.0572064184,
-0.02213623,
0.0546513982,
-0.0060185366,
0.0098431064,
0.0184754413,
-0.0294124223,
0.0126577858,
0.0005183294,
0.0039650528,
0.0357448123,
0.0385338478,
-0.0113300085,
-0.0381635018,
-0.0386563167,
-0.0254134201,
-0.0472147577,
-0.0194439143,
0.0407297984,
0.004938358,
-0.0090767043,
-0.0628611892,
-0.0067556407,
0.0359329022,
-0.071643196,
0.0686332807,
0.0425136834,
-0.0357191376,
-0.0038115745,
-0.0578289144,
0.0204702094,
-0.0388564505,
0.0163825341,
-0.027147511,
0.0332855955,
-0.01815309,
0.0370473228,
-0.0305185039,
0.0451521762,
-0.0590612255,
0.0418687686,
-0.0526796207,
0.0432400592,
-0.0011895017,
0.041701559,
0.010042849,
0.007619557,
0.0126325628,
-0.0024775779,
0.0504631214,
-0.0108490391,
-0.0131973522,
-0.0368996747,
-0.036323376,
-0.0811476037,
-0.0199606959,
0.0480640754,
-0.051237721,
-0.031261161,
0.0450305119,
0.0592084415,
0.0153135704,
0.0261250418,
-0.0418788865,
-0.0402794667,
0.0231179148,
-0.0309341736,
0.0006988052,
-0.0849858895,
-0.0323510543,
-0.0031191576,
0.005156389,
-0.0434320346,
0.0272178985,
0.0245120265,
-0.0156854112,
0.0294097438,
-0.0509568565,
-0.0007903865,
-0.0151327001,
0.019142285,
0.0278621726,
0.0076634008,
0.0452525578,
0.0077457014,
-0.003001339,
-0.0613014661,
0.0178309064,
0.047649052,
0.006272723,
0.0277200062,
-0.0080721155,
0.0545004122,
0.0614001974,
-0.0179312229,
0.0485996418,
0.0587216504,
-0.0202803388,
-0.0072043473,
0.0150513304,
-0.0087518049,
-0.0245353933,
0.0639903024,
0.0909192786,
0.0316260196,
0.0288589168,
-0.0586769618,
-0.0268304609,
0.0539793223,
-0.0019344046,
0.016457703,
0.0012877858,
0.0513421148,
-0.0134704607,
-0.022476567,
-0.0069358363,
-0.0341273174,
-0.0411187187,
-0.0061614076,
0.0141968373,
-0.0257154815,
-0.0658472031,
0.0237760302,
0.0493886136,
-0.0901963189,
-0.0287300181,
-0.0638957471,
0.0458640046,
0.0411688723,
0.0402276441,
-0.0417135209,
0.0184531417,
-0.0170459524,
0.0450718775,
-0.011027053,
0.0334070548,
-0.0021853251,
0.0283613168,
-0.0631117076,
-0.0160921216,
-0.0540050231,
-0.0218364056,
0.0391742028,
0.0419658944,
-0.0365662575,
0.0438582711,
0.0103334356,
-0.0824667811,
0.0309330374,
-0.0149077363,
-0.0263522156,
0.0099990964,
-0.0415229425,
0.0247126091,
-0.0132490164,
-0.0663290992,
0.036425963,
0.0602907538,
0.0027643023,
0.0135904271,
-0.0680147931,
-0.0592357777,
-0.0011912858,
0.0054960153,
-0.0336673707,
-0.0176770315,
0.0056657088,
-0.0529585145,
-0.0019779364,
0.0568592548,
-0.0227882694,
0.022641968,
0.0061404821,
0.0175043494,
-0.0349256657,
0.0295252018,
-0.0261539724,
0.0291562099,
-0.0119609982,
0.0393352099,
0.0115572792,
0.0565917082,
0.0048862016,
0.0390319116,
-0.0124982605,
-0.018755801,
-0.0156092821,
0.0576734245,
-0.0215821248,
0.0694977716,
-0.0134569118,
-0.0548809096,
-0.0836704001,
0.0512781851,
-0.0177343115,
0.0046742829,
0.0228673089,
0.0286791604,
0.0039997324,
0.0022666282,
0.0180249028,
0.0014049157,
-0.0195567962,
0.004868214,
-0.0101951901,
-0.0393509194,
-0.077870965,
-0.0275962465,
-0.031099705,
-0.0130550321,
0.0563080087,
-0.0300557408,
0.0499281734,
-0.0706613213,
0.0543297529,
0.0209207479,
0.0423209555,
-0.018115025,
-0.0758347064,
0.0069525875,
-0.049008593,
0.0452516861,
0.0447214395,
0.0001362238,
-0.0033094338,
0.0563167371,
-0.0120856846,
-0.0535499156,
0.0134281982,
0.0110044638,
-0.078620784,
-0.0227489434,
-0.0645448714,
0.0228737276,
0.0712039769,
0.001338191,
-0.0314535461,
-0.0400010049,
-0.0115828514,
0.0396053754,
-0.0007567205,
0.0346772037,
-0.0021204713,
-0.0172631536,
-0.0164030697,
-0.0324616916,
-0.0929856449,
0.016500378,
-0.0464720428,
-0.0165230092,
-0.02043253,
-0.0156998858,
-0.0553655662,
0.0179826878,
0.0019842151,
0.0222088229,
-0.0050190068,
0.0046579977,
-0.0099474518,
0.0285204481,
-0.0278286207,
-0.0436026007,
0.0209424291,
-0.0324585475,
0.0126921395,
0.0042476449,
-0.0098771797,
-0.0335802473,
-0.013588232,
0.0121300528,
0.0060173487,
0.0503853709,
-0.029581815,
0.0399565026,
-0.0084912572,
0.0416390859,
0.0481262691,
0.0163187087,
-0.0151680885,
-0.0148625672,
-0.0462209769,
-0.0007599113,
-0.089588806,
-0.0254363138,
-0.0207603984,
0.0151532097,
0.0247495808,
0.0546412915,
0.0304894429,
-0.0734293163,
0.0219008215,
0.0423479229,
0.009410345,
-0.0376036577,
0.0765632391,
0.0410314389,
-0.0294205118,
-0.0305884797,
0.100372307,
0.029619107,
-0.066680871,
0.0176297333,
0.0006726829,
0.054645326,
0.0645881146,
0.0557379574,
-0.0624259152,
-0.014689697,
-0.0135440156,
0.0286982041,
-0.0121570872,
-0.011135472,
-0.0328058526,
-0.1173668802,
0.0287291538,
0.0303885769,
-0.012082452,
-0.0639081672,
-0.0437092297,
-0.0485473499,
0.0026578521,
-0.0506568588,
0.0540317409,
-0.0441966057,
0.0352265313,
0.0181720499,
-0.001724041,
0.0211373921,
0.0337407328,
-0.0332449004,
0.0386340991,
0.0728114694,
0.0007931931,
0.0287216678,
-0.024387937,
0.053150855,
-0.0040022563,
0.0090617361,
-0.0395683311,
0.0423698388,
0.0172553807,
-0.024992222,
0.0144896181,
0.048787985,
-0.0612062141,
0.0080186008,
0.0317567065,
0.0402768478,
0.0133030955,
-0.0173207764,
-0.0145764863,
-0.0064980839,
0.0050234683,
0.0242950227,
0.032462053,
-0.0356654674,
-0.0195543207,
-0.0525150746,
-0.0153400209,
-0.0579094179,
-0.0235124566,
0.0196631718,
-0.0257888697,
-0.021884637,
-0.0080910502,
0.0343257822,
-0.0162830874,
0.0342222229,
0.0436696671,
-0.0454456806,
0.0124319056,
-0.052090358,
-0.064200528,
0.0304121319,
-0.0588900521,
0.0054872711,
-0.0662999228,
-0.0403475277,
0.040114712,
0.0061531914,
-0.018968964,
0.0304079913,
-0.0954653025,
-0.0587841012,
-0.0150698535,
0.1028471515,
0.0100665819,
0.0248237811,
-0.0014659625,
-0.0394133218,
-0.0105770463,
0.0093373721,
-0.0323593542,
0.0194570329,
0.022818625,
-0.0169259887,
0.0296223797,
-0.0073769479,
-0.0377935469,
0.0238520093,
0.0728076696,
-0.0256587788,
-0.00340807,
0.0095708836,
0.0213765688,
0.0000208257,
-0.007835743,
-0.007517444,
-0.0256040245,
0.0245627146,
0.0207641143,
0.0008473754,
-0.0141609898,
-0.0639297217,
0.0237527471,
0.0399520509,
-0.0284711644,
0.015864931,
0.0185917355,
-0.000959479,
0.0732967332,
-0.0168676786,
0.0485329144,
-0.0093048327,
0.059125822,
0.096642904,
0.004040068,
-0.0140530309,
0.0335336998,
-0.0064634834,
0.0208823979,
-0.0104711447,
0.0415428504,
-0.0084856879,
0.0391291082,
0.0168085378,
0.0059912801,
-0.0118887275,
-0.0596363209,
-0.0595714748,
-0.0057224366,
0.0434985012,
0.0347437821,
0.0493520424,
0.010167663,
0.0279666539,
-0.0388640016,
0.0637506247,
-0.034379933,
-0.0578580648,
-0.0108701671,
0.0133096408,
-0.0315646902,
-0.0190248657,
0.0995886549,
0.0472847335,
0.038414631,
-0.0027739585,
-0.0028094391,
-0.0404004455,
-0.0031862089,
0.0305034723,
-0.0142978337,
-0.0174084511,
-0.0057814731,
0.0076580858,
-0.0325721204,
-0.0252967943,
0.0157574229,
0.0140555566,
0.0304082651,
0.0489144586,
0.0400013067,
-0.0325039104,
-0.0317752659,
-0.0276935324,
0.0219544359,
0.0012119355,
-0.0732996166,
-0.0020423166,
-6.527235807e-33,
-0.0195800513,
0.0233646389,
0.0114077954,
-0.0037787443,
-0.0095641287,
-0.0075158281,
-0.0259771626,
-0.027751565,
-0.0030822058,
-0.0264057498,
0.0346786864,
0.0180329867,
-0.0056041125,
-0.0041773268,
0.0567647964,
0.0339783579,
0.0530034713,
0.0050302795,
-0.0485055521,
0.0623978414,
-0.0216289349,
0.0118625415,
0.0190780032,
-0.0295896903,
-0.0289006066,
-0.0240646768,
0.0327004083,
-0.0248469785,
-0.0033852861,
0.030832937,
0.0084029101,
0.0159528274,
-0.0217635091,
-0.0086355861,
-0.0289580803,
-0.0359325111,
-0.0159039088,
0.0051894421,
0.0322330035,
-0.0033381968,
0.0251909439,
-0.0880838409,
0.0315781012,
0.0126708979,
-0.0031409995,
-0.0303803794,
-0.0081484988,
0.0177729633,
0.0028136882,
-0.0104018953,
-0.0501274951,
0.0285370536,
-0.027499361,
-0.014717659,
-0.021709146,
-0.0113596357,
-0.0066878544,
0.0182460416,
0.0256414954,
0.0179690234,
0.0038700358,
0.0834016725,
0.0767331049,
0.013894747,
0.0475148559,
0.0149009861,
0.0534792505,
0.0250675473,
-0.0288981348,
0.0286843907,
0.0280735288,
0.0610646233,
0.0194313042,
-0.0031662427,
-0.0080488864,
0.0039909803,
-0.0456108712,
-0.0338502377,
-0.0065145651,
-0.0018431944,
0.0314602815,
0.0094864089,
-0.0268012434,
-0.0051335013,
-0.0514737815,
-0.0156932194,
-0.0284111798,
-0.0142446812,
0.0225817263,
0.0095950328,
-0.0628115311,
-0.000303167,
0.0395129621,
-0.0263397489,
0.0253825728,
0.0175216086,
-0.0471303947,
0.0249510538,
-0.0110641252,
0.0228955727,
-0.029705897,
-0.0816949606,
0.0237305872,
-0.0595309287,
0.083830528,
0.0244517159,
0.0040941713,
0.0114660151,
-0.061068099,
-0.0146907205,
-0.0750213489,
0.0032290928,
-0.0198536515,
0.0010532832,
0.0038364585,
0.0192448776,
0.0004002026,
0.0351135544,
-0.0032586821,
0.0011127332,
-0.0240658484,
-0.0461846739,
0.0297697373,
0.0438193306,
-0.0289548561,
-0.01400973,
-0.0453100912,
0.0188601799,
0.0110050105,
-0.030370418,
-0.0838845968,
0.0299855098,
3.051e-7,
-0.0150289331,
0.0231627449,
0.0048841517,
0.0582661852,
0.0060508321,
0.0225539375,
0.0123385964,
0.0242239926,
0.0002562485,
-0.0111578126,
-0.0411053672,
0.0026884109,
0.0424848869,
0.0089486623,
-0.036245469,
-0.0034668962,
-0.0154479863,
0.0169331394,
-0.0732991993,
-0.0289200451,
-0.009818715,
0.0679328293,
0.0152209131,
0.0036269275,
0.0317641608,
-0.00736563,
-0.0029836977,
-0.0176148023,
-0.0029595164,
0.0414984487,
-0.0707085207,
0.0077692345,
-0.0286071543,
-0.0255490001,
-0.0239882395,
-0.0295898542,
-0.004900069,
0.0717438236,
0.0023355568,
0.0383772813,
0.0674539879,
-0.0446126051,
-0.0332606919,
-0.0509409606,
0.0492196381,
0.0113632493,
0.016687654,
-0.0390834697,
-0.0201017521,
0.0037849599,
-0.0079534613,
-0.0503304414,
0.0662461668,
0.0080077136,
0.0035767534,
-0.0407423526,
-0.0129276263,
-0.0135946702,
-0.0706632584,
-0.0142344432,
-0.0123654632,
-0.070446752,
-0.0608516112,
0.0377952121,
0.0133866528,
-0.0177424289,
0.0418336727,
2.99711662e-34,
0.0396204852,
-0.0399590619,
0.0285178181,
0.0388465002,
0.0441226847,
-0.0278136991,
-0.0062641096,
0.0256342255,
-0.0289817229,
-0.0165755562,
-0.0516334102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02119v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02119v2 | Tree of Attacks: Jailbreaking Black-Box LLMs Automatically | 2023-12-04T18:49:23 | 2024-02-21T17:49:22 | Anay Mehrotra, Manolis Zampetakis, Paul Kassianik, Blaine Nelson, Hyrum Anderson, Yaron Singer, Amin Karbasi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, stat.ML | While Large Language Models (LLMs) display versatile functionality, they
continue to generate harmful, biased, and toxic content, as demonstrated by the
prevalence of human-designed jailbreaks. In this work, we present Tree of
Attacks with Pruning (TAP), an automated method for generating jailbreaks that
only requires black-box access to the target LLM. TAP utilizes an LLM to
iteratively refine candidate (attack) prompts using tree-of-thought reasoning
until one of the generated prompts jailbreaks the target. Crucially, before
sending prompts to the target, TAP assesses them and prunes the ones unlikely
to result in jailbreaks. Using tree-of-thought reasoning allows TAP to navigate
a large search space of prompts and pruning reduces the total number of queries
sent to the target. In empirical evaluations, we observe that TAP generates
prompts that jailbreak state-of-the-art LLMs (including GPT4 and GPT4-Turbo)
for more than 80% of the prompts using only a small number of queries.
Interestingly, TAP is also capable of jailbreaking LLMs protected by
state-of-the-art guardrails, e.g., LlamaGuard. This significantly improves upon
the previous state-of-the-art black-box method for generating jailbreaks. | [
0.0345932618,
0.0543092079,
-0.0301734228,
0.0315739848,
-0.0519574992,
-0.0313069038,
0.0133069232,
0.0018834062,
0.0449677557,
0.0011520881,
-0.0006859477,
0.0142852226,
0.0159683991,
0.0049328315,
0.0349459313,
0.0142981727,
0.0416097008,
-0.0362345614,
-0.0042736381,
0.0039749523,
0.0120101785,
0.016208278,
0.0250828993,
0.0216113552,
0.0105745029,
-0.0157054793,
-0.032043267,
0.0275148433,
0.0154532949,
-0.0420732386,
-0.0290088132,
0.0294814948,
-0.0303465817,
0.0357105322,
0.000002245,
-0.0219965633,
-0.0486615375,
0.0266158376,
-0.0557911471,
0.0789612979,
-0.0250316728,
-0.0299731195,
-0.0401004292,
0.0157139469,
-0.0268180892,
0.0326922983,
0.0168174747,
0.0219771806,
0.0939259678,
0.0761295557,
0.0097403182,
0.0084404089,
0.0216760915,
-0.0097813755,
0.0180206206,
-0.0443270728,
-0.0205517281,
-0.052344963,
0.0285125766,
0.0274684485,
0.0286665689,
-0.0328163728,
0.0304159224,
-0.0092789186,
-0.0883704051,
-0.0049523646,
-0.0303189289,
-0.0089829396,
-0.0036661434,
0.0321388803,
-0.0607115924,
-0.0271177515,
0.0187060479,
0.0074567762,
0.0102414591,
-0.0166756734,
0.0126554202,
0.0482906997,
-0.0200877674,
-0.014356303,
0.0344546475,
-0.0218823534,
0.0506891534,
-0.0277455039,
-0.022475129,
0.0704391599,
0.0057873675,
-0.0456277356,
0.0061115152,
-0.0582961701,
0.0232280865,
-0.0742080063,
-0.0201214477,
-0.0003621087,
-0.0029782034,
0.0249673128,
-0.0601030365,
-0.0047177393,
0.0398148336,
-0.0344953462,
-0.0332488678,
0.0618245713,
-0.0088570518,
-0.0069619901,
-0.0085148392,
-0.010204874,
-0.0173408538,
0.0243210606,
0.0167109165,
0.0231456663,
0.0038930182,
-0.0207024012,
-0.0235603768,
0.0527957752,
-0.0130162742,
0.0342355222,
-0.0240520127,
0.031588506,
-0.0286716744,
0.0260965042,
-0.0423774756,
-0.0023834747,
0.0256968886,
0.019895738,
0.0498361029,
-0.0494678095,
-0.036306791,
-0.0358711928,
-0.0082502868,
-0.0841153935,
-0.0129146371,
-0.0206843596,
-0.086652495,
-0.0171299931,
-0.0004603203,
0.1063430682,
0.0280120894,
-0.013133104,
-0.1207507849,
-0.0968714729,
-0.0131978188,
-0.0114473477,
-0.0147975404,
-0.0783437788,
-0.0405227914,
-0.0210133884,
-0.0057326728,
-0.0458199903,
0.0004966914,
0.0050684847,
-0.0307098646,
0.0415704921,
0.0037748122,
-0.0190785807,
-0.0034463827,
0.0552912131,
0.0302544069,
0.066588223,
-0.006763685,
0.0714336559,
0.0357806459,
-0.0103135593,
0.0414181575,
0.0532673486,
-0.01499529,
0.0277468655,
-0.0138067994,
-0.0193900596,
0.015985528,
-0.0100470632,
-0.023615079,
0.0310618449,
-0.0012285925,
-0.0185693409,
0.0696657002,
0.0540348031,
-0.0466541462,
0.0525917783,
0.0030774926,
-0.0381851681,
-0.0150608178,
0.0071077049,
-0.0455818661,
0.0053283591,
-0.0853932351,
-0.0171130486,
-0.0538194291,
0.0290087853,
0.0052452809,
0.0198199861,
0.0209942535,
-0.0108800996,
-0.0381595418,
0.019619057,
-0.0084867096,
0.0163173433,
0.0009929383,
0.084538579,
0.0187810082,
-0.0356555693,
-0.0608873218,
-0.0811923444,
0.0060881693,
0.0502401777,
0.0481626503,
0.0138149681,
-0.0166102126,
0.0233894624,
-0.0087616509,
0.0224292576,
-0.0205877628,
0.0240144301,
0.0063244998,
-0.0018515498,
0.0079627717,
-0.0266285688,
0.0406364165,
0.0536364019,
-0.0116563775,
-0.0123409769,
0.0033369856,
-0.0397346839,
-0.0220894814,
0.0093989791,
0.0327080823,
-0.0170485843,
0.0165111162,
0.0293961484,
-0.0116662383,
0.0071604671,
-0.0321451649,
0.0198782329,
0.067478396,
-0.0101288343,
0.0437108651,
-0.0060826316,
-0.0350151733,
0.0157857984,
0.0279015955,
-0.0524713099,
0.0153121743,
0.0581240207,
-0.0492997728,
-0.0210371185,
0.0643794462,
-0.056662038,
0.0334783755,
0.0084006619,
0.0347143412,
-0.006292115,
-0.0121716522,
-0.020420149,
0.0023090863,
-0.0153342551,
-0.0112286098,
0.0302219149,
0.0055570654,
0.0304195117,
0.0099492641,
-0.0586065613,
0.0095470874,
-0.0432916619,
0.0055239182,
-0.0007314819,
0.0532001592,
-0.0011547209,
-0.027304478,
-0.0462864749,
0.0010245494,
-0.0343393087,
0.0464012325,
0.0511744097,
0.0692340806,
-0.0392071158,
-0.0295509193,
-0.0030694527,
-0.0424161665,
0.0226385947,
0.0106341513,
-0.0122474991,
-0.0299167335,
-0.0552706607,
-0.0177336149,
0.0007322385,
-0.0056502009,
0.0374487601,
-0.0563357323,
-0.0270564221,
-0.001734616,
-0.0056831976,
-0.0028310909,
0.0062560271,
-0.017755026,
-0.0405887775,
0.0426931344,
-0.0063146306,
-0.02367213,
0.0632116422,
0.0045850575,
0.0472671911,
0.0930345505,
0.0033668459,
-0.041476164,
-0.0254338011,
0.0782606527,
-0.0439157002,
-0.0232604519,
-0.0864432752,
0.0443879552,
0.063402839,
0.0349539369,
0.0231905356,
-0.029427819,
0.0127499728,
0.0149568068,
-0.0019498856,
-0.0073285406,
-0.0306111891,
-0.0585244149,
0.0120642669,
-0.0170921572,
-0.0763709247,
0.0553872995,
-0.0647133067,
0.016465839,
-0.0001127085,
-0.0357155055,
-0.0167219676,
0.0622773618,
-0.0307402648,
0.0221794583,
0.043053396,
-0.03869332,
-0.0191821493,
-0.0099483952,
0.0318711251,
-0.0069570849,
0.051785551,
-0.0892474204,
-0.0168227423,
-0.0051275594,
-0.0167897791,
-0.0318107642,
-0.0253540277,
-0.0269429423,
-0.0340493917,
0.0552181825,
-0.0323708504,
0.0317694768,
-0.0230140295,
0.0315916128,
0.0094020916,
0.0010157109,
-0.0127658276,
-0.0138262203,
0.0003234999,
0.0055216197,
-0.0744628757,
-0.0044247806,
0.0241258144,
0.05307962,
0.0769927204,
0.0449999012,
0.0008573514,
-0.005640124,
0.0236778408,
0.0121206082,
-0.0090853814,
-0.0376918651,
0.0460521989,
0.0306314398,
-0.0156600829,
-0.0293965545,
0.0508840792,
0.0388223715,
-0.0102582676,
0.0385453478,
-0.0075199329,
0.0370827913,
0.0153715117,
0.0501124114,
-0.0982975513,
-0.0324503034,
0.0095959371,
0.0616117157,
-0.0294278786,
-0.0328887999,
-0.0406821668,
-0.1004794538,
-0.0082841953,
0.0406859852,
-0.010744933,
0.0487820022,
-0.0244015399,
-0.0278527178,
0.0444752499,
0.0091972295,
0.007709614,
0.0033469275,
0.0207012799,
0.0026150534,
-0.0806966349,
0.0275311917,
0.0330972522,
-0.0116114868,
0.0393586978,
0.0947972387,
-0.0209523719,
-0.0215896871,
0.023286568,
0.0619136393,
-0.0189207513,
0.0007456141,
-0.0052787266,
-0.0232339315,
0.0447445996,
-0.0003598618,
0.0074506779,
0.0307111163,
0.0045860279,
-0.0214052498,
0.0410679653,
0.0657429472,
-0.0239093751,
-0.0217377767,
-0.0173113942,
-0.038894888,
-0.0056953775,
0.0176820923,
0.029903248,
-0.0085598081,
-0.0674157292,
-0.0859421566,
-0.0501660481,
-0.0566474386,
-0.0317510143,
0.0296417512,
0.0151623152,
-0.0203653369,
-0.0183989722,
0.0109720808,
-0.0268094297,
0.0433527045,
0.0511531383,
-0.0193902086,
-0.0227967016,
0.0143318502,
-0.0082913758,
-0.0446085259,
-0.0149029093,
0.0507416464,
-0.0592200495,
0.0402571112,
-0.0284423716,
0.0075840871,
0.0078311814,
0.0294162817,
-0.0267756507,
-0.079569377,
-0.0180897005,
0.0813583434,
0.0282202046,
-0.0134448428,
-0.0385742933,
-0.0726422071,
0.0358164385,
0.0767427087,
-0.0812945738,
0.0338639542,
0.0552280247,
-0.0284641031,
0.0185208842,
0.0149953477,
-0.0491967127,
-0.0167608447,
0.0678349733,
0.002845888,
-0.0533282384,
0.0217377897,
0.0384888649,
0.0630208552,
-0.0187127255,
-0.0313346609,
0.0248504598,
0.0543180816,
0.0426104106,
-0.0016201355,
-0.0189226307,
0.0191909373,
0.0332489014,
0.0117026651,
-0.0432879962,
0.0294471439,
-0.0109688649,
-0.0108968001,
-0.0072578071,
-0.0031413545,
0.0382408425,
0.0272894688,
0.0481944457,
0.0886481106,
0.0044719363,
-0.0181837752,
0.0487210974,
-0.0155482506,
0.04328667,
-0.0070832605,
0.0362231582,
-0.0182928201,
-0.000092947,
-0.0112027265,
0.0542525761,
-0.061580617,
-0.0763201714,
0.032620728,
0.0620686784,
0.0022863785,
0.02700435,
0.0046136994,
-0.007511273,
0.022444522,
-0.0301067047,
-0.0290165357,
-0.016370371,
-0.0554047823,
0.0083347121,
-0.0054434342,
-0.0022744781,
-0.005830158,
0.0567432866,
0.0100361705,
0.0466041528,
0.0400085971,
-0.012159816,
-0.052994445,
-0.0245078076,
0.037274275,
0.0303002372,
-0.0434615687,
-0.0695331469,
-0.0794299841,
-0.0537695512,
-0.0340583697,
0.0100472933,
0.0492237732,
-0.000343461,
-0.022185307,
0.0612682328,
0.0092943478,
0.0255012512,
-0.055328086,
0.0136663457,
-0.011492949,
-0.0669226423,
0.0253821295,
-5.794780502e-33,
0.0167311635,
-0.039336957,
-0.0405991636,
0.000913173,
0.0112299388,
-0.0075875674,
-0.0511943661,
0.0322156064,
-0.0217553899,
-0.0362328514,
-0.0276663769,
-0.0139641212,
0.0096526304,
-0.019383518,
-0.0208893865,
-0.0063785715,
0.0007164151,
0.0352503285,
-0.037246231,
0.0445539616,
0.0490819514,
0.019247748,
0.0174705889,
-0.0018575479,
0.0351484157,
-0.0247573126,
-0.0131620811,
0.0293621011,
-0.0532698482,
0.0314625353,
0.0329073258,
0.0241607185,
-0.0019468416,
-0.0355789028,
0.0136832753,
0.0439821035,
0.018093016,
-0.0155514497,
0.042449221,
-0.0194442198,
0.0251855589,
-0.0471520089,
0.0054816506,
0.0325014628,
0.0167671684,
-0.0066862907,
-0.0213589184,
-0.0152534954,
-0.0148347383,
-0.0282331351,
0.0082097761,
0.0049884459,
-0.0460497364,
-0.0036553016,
-0.0301110148,
-0.0172283221,
-0.0097811995,
-0.0270564444,
-0.0129475016,
0.0547736399,
0.0605490617,
0.0064098085,
0.0562379509,
-0.013931456,
-0.0284214802,
0.0384904742,
-0.0357920788,
-0.0328684002,
0.0102773979,
0.0323835053,
0.0017847916,
0.0603634715,
0.0519600138,
0.0434665196,
0.0442290269,
-0.0368079394,
-0.0557807647,
-0.0003080925,
0.0491461717,
0.0305924378,
0.0202095285,
-0.0121681094,
-0.0273901988,
-0.01484029,
0.0026328191,
-0.017061891,
-0.0140885431,
-0.0606749654,
0.0125127416,
-0.006126184,
-0.0285512563,
-0.0643654689,
-0.0128756221,
-0.0327469036,
0.0079422742,
0.0205475111,
-0.0233658217,
-0.0210086294,
-0.0153493881,
0.0197793562,
0.0239126943,
0.0244890396,
-0.0040225782,
-0.0707900375,
0.0343727171,
-0.0052755023,
0.0004506789,
0.0188715886,
-0.0608059615,
-0.0083528804,
-0.0440590121,
0.0455324911,
-0.016317457,
-0.0041706311,
-0.0067325681,
-0.0246233623,
0.0120199127,
-0.0253915228,
0.0247318745,
-0.0356886387,
-0.0578255951,
0.0419023447,
-0.019073911,
0.0320751406,
-0.0075177765,
0.0042246613,
0.0136503717,
0.0350316837,
0.0410802886,
-0.0630745739,
-0.0099764913,
0.0103505338,
3.039e-7,
-0.0271658245,
-0.0421884954,
0.0128056435,
0.0158703141,
0.0157588813,
0.0613316298,
-0.008446943,
0.0649204031,
-0.0172251742,
-0.0802078247,
-0.0344161242,
-0.0340120792,
0.0529623553,
0.0329677798,
-0.0548655428,
0.0587732829,
-0.0562927425,
-0.0115441047,
-0.0791251287,
-0.0077283559,
0.034344282,
0.0538881794,
-0.0044429954,
-0.0612751916,
0.0025988838,
-0.022063721,
-0.0292322636,
0.0031775241,
-0.0017869214,
-0.0125473049,
0.025136102,
-0.0080363788,
0.0046720654,
0.0349757746,
-0.0262266174,
-0.0359676965,
-0.0784565508,
0.0263627656,
0.0245024431,
-0.0120880157,
-0.0071255364,
-0.055015672,
-0.01346731,
-0.0469561443,
0.0693500191,
0.0626036301,
-0.0085372338,
-0.0098325768,
0.0326078273,
-0.0499013923,
-0.0116718905,
-0.0281835869,
0.025192298,
0.0033862148,
0.0260803476,
0.0079493038,
0.0261657722,
-0.0418264978,
-0.0121804522,
0.022478126,
-0.0030210894,
-0.0361635089,
-0.0196406823,
0.0684800074,
0.0184618812,
-0.0114637427,
0.0286345556,
2.918576838e-34,
-0.025017323,
-0.0390706137,
0.0322363935,
0.0386041366,
0.0355920978,
0.0336572118,
0.0183571968,
0.0282185618,
0.003753142,
-0.0253788736,
-0.0238667391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02118v1 | When it Rains, it Pours: Modeling Media Storms and the News Ecosystem | 2023-12-04T18:49:06 | 2023-12-04T18:49:06 | Benjamin Litterer, David Jurgens, Dallas Card | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Most events in the world receive at most brief coverage by the news media.
Occasionally, however, an event will trigger a media storm, with voluminous and
widespread coverage lasting for weeks instead of days. In this work, we develop
and apply a pairwise article similarity model, allowing us to identify story
clusters in corpora covering local and national online news, and thereby create
a comprehensive corpus of media storms over a nearly two year period. Using
this corpus, we investigate media storms at a new level of granularity,
allowing us to validate claims about storm evolution and topical distribution,
and provide empirical support for previously hypothesized patterns of influence
of storms on media coverage and intermedia agenda setting. | [
0.0111882491,
0.0242189448,
-0.0254487991,
-0.0043668314,
-0.010273735,
-0.0183873326,
-0.0125530856,
-0.0154087842,
0.0110097323,
-0.0510044023,
0.035209883,
-0.0037677682,
-0.0368214697,
0.0565841906,
-0.010040313,
-0.0852846652,
0.0196459182,
0.0345618241,
0.0196389798,
0.0067324089,
0.0840236247,
0.0211110432,
0.0102655366,
0.0168160386,
0.028429037,
0.0070124534,
-0.030645635,
0.0323914587,
0.0125043336,
-0.0522280484,
-0.0249629226,
0.0124027403,
0.0644526556,
0.0101607116,
0.0000017602,
-0.018154338,
-0.0035006057,
-0.0334203057,
0.0482152365,
-0.0071680471,
0.0367851928,
-0.0463137589,
0.0064493436,
-0.0015910453,
-0.0306405257,
-0.0078321407,
0.0119738653,
-0.0135029843,
0.0410692953,
0.0690370575,
-0.0213196818,
0.0193468947,
0.0357564725,
-0.0010484264,
0.0016685738,
-0.0050978856,
-0.0010233904,
-0.0572622418,
-0.0274689253,
-0.0322811864,
0.0280334167,
0.0000978793,
-0.0093045691,
0.0378237925,
-0.0244052876,
0.0276979543,
-0.0050774235,
-0.0259923451,
0.0024865242,
-0.0013386699,
0.0473802984,
-0.0373992845,
0.0441286676,
0.0031202941,
0.0081781493,
0.0917950645,
-0.0558724441,
0.0213217754,
-0.0248189736,
0.0195698626,
0.0329016708,
-0.0231917817,
0.0078684576,
0.0475554354,
-0.0069163018,
0.0418569818,
0.0218314845,
-0.0145143028,
-0.0640418977,
0.0131140947,
0.0404998064,
-0.0544027388,
0.0402520224,
-0.0183359496,
-0.0091107367,
0.0282189511,
-0.0125812246,
0.0448861942,
-0.004465756,
-0.0943405256,
-0.0590464212,
0.0002084899,
0.0466460884,
0.0413033292,
0.0496983863,
-0.0825823024,
-0.00445745,
-0.0431266725,
0.0210368205,
0.0136081455,
-0.0721569955,
0.0680905133,
0.0531515181,
-0.0292498302,
-0.009029245,
-0.0006077203,
0.024943389,
0.0083473157,
-0.0079570301,
-0.0305680912,
-0.041104082,
-0.0169348326,
-0.0226981342,
-0.0105167534,
-0.0092105931,
0.0236897171,
-0.1097707301,
0.0375817306,
0.0157341845,
0.0133095114,
-0.0111292591,
-0.0091246497,
0.0293483473,
0.0018751553,
-0.0185098536,
-0.0108998884,
-0.0113539584,
0.0018298863,
-0.0586714298,
-0.0075297169,
-0.0075142235,
0.0132398205,
0.0077829366,
-0.0525527708,
0.0032050842,
0.0157527905,
0.0306313243,
0.0101621076,
-0.0136602316,
0.0107979504,
-0.0332937874,
0.0037849019,
-0.0014283705,
0.0325943008,
0.0338716805,
0.0109748738,
0.0396764539,
0.0498690419,
-0.010709567,
0.0729271472,
0.0653139204,
-0.0075405193,
-0.0060414397,
0.0105891526,
-0.0050386554,
0.0479744002,
-0.0244259927,
-0.0207472444,
-0.0488489456,
-0.0108360499,
0.0243413635,
-0.0645327792,
-0.0197638255,
0.0109569784,
0.0629073083,
0.0328510143,
-0.0739712119,
0.0404391214,
0.030524198,
0.0216125529,
-0.0536780804,
0.0228477623,
0.0165868253,
0.0143832341,
-0.0416357294,
-0.0074142194,
0.0542977601,
0.0583338067,
-0.0633331314,
0.0078507951,
0.0095960991,
0.0350317471,
-0.0131644802,
-0.0347339138,
-0.0018822916,
-0.012301472,
0.0020661161,
0.0458118021,
0.0264786538,
-0.0030997214,
0.0556964241,
0.0110399518,
0.0027152949,
0.0382784232,
0.0337665528,
0.0149196265,
-0.0311263464,
0.0091871861,
0.0216067676,
-0.0064753131,
-0.0257079676,
0.0297042821,
-0.09118931,
-0.027865028,
-0.0170885194,
-0.0014700083,
0.0384603925,
0.02233072,
0.0063461969,
0.062783137,
-0.0426491909,
0.0121445786,
-0.0086517902,
0.0121009033,
-0.0010551225,
-0.0137745384,
-0.0428413376,
0.0053489213,
0.0410480835,
0.0075557395,
0.0065373974,
-0.0201593041,
0.0499647893,
-0.0025302945,
-0.0809013695,
0.0517577715,
0.0138150454,
0.0386150442,
-0.0299667288,
-0.0211544558,
-0.0061132549,
0.0005719538,
-0.0034660958,
-0.0109207928,
0.091419749,
0.0191713851,
-0.0017871477,
-0.0181810986,
0.0020253158,
0.0057868725,
-0.0448759496,
0.0073152683,
0.0721499324,
-0.010213526,
0.02561092,
-0.0355147347,
0.0031206422,
-0.0270111784,
0.0151686119,
-0.0178346336,
-0.0058428622,
-0.0065545468,
0.0033016105,
0.0354721397,
-0.1074910983,
-0.0192814246,
-0.0245018192,
0.0107431151,
0.0328373127,
-0.0155967455,
0.0076320213,
0.075917609,
0.0018183795,
-0.0389832333,
0.0383429006,
0.008944639,
-0.0470243618,
-0.0291931834,
0.0122838737,
-0.0212118383,
-0.0192539543,
-0.0112186158,
-0.0336182192,
-0.0095215505,
-0.0270313639,
0.0515131578,
0.021119535,
-0.0671311468,
-0.0076093795,
0.03751757,
-0.0413628295,
-0.0105339494,
-0.047087241,
-0.0075821634,
-0.0183470957,
-0.0260972381,
-0.0156756248,
0.0208361372,
0.0436380878,
0.0871312693,
0.0001356367,
-0.0028672139,
-0.019560568,
0.0054034181,
-0.042484574,
-0.0153481485,
-0.0249454379,
-0.047810778,
0.0574646853,
0.0336226523,
0.0195227768,
0.0399259329,
0.0161823351,
0.0034876186,
-0.0278657787,
0.0300083887,
-0.0149015933,
-0.0411945991,
0.001394772,
0.0569050983,
-0.011699141,
-0.0105442172,
0.0076272651,
0.0274706185,
0.1035937816,
-0.0556674823,
-0.0411289632,
-0.0433132611,
0.0396446474,
-0.030861184,
0.0106651355,
-0.0172429513,
-0.0081630219,
-0.0212169271,
-0.0521459281,
0.0679201558,
-0.0044522388,
0.0050222664,
-0.0031129734,
0.0310258996,
0.0288588386,
0.0053532673,
0.0155350259,
-0.0364151672,
0.0114851613,
-0.0259976201,
0.0834895074,
0.001510112,
-0.0701659918,
0.0351146199,
0.026836399,
-0.0320571437,
0.0038579097,
-0.0012587437,
0.026061872,
0.1065392345,
-0.0107839564,
-0.0266201254,
-0.0114421677,
0.0185294114,
-0.0277982,
0.0416115932,
0.048967693,
0.0138944602,
-0.0241494682,
0.0131906355,
0.0248317681,
-0.0485326014,
-0.0091405427,
-0.0118793137,
0.0505264327,
-0.0295155719,
-0.0059630056,
0.0669258162,
0.060919188,
-0.0523276553,
-0.0137911392,
0.0412378274,
0.0011194454,
0.0342497826,
0.0245917756,
-0.032892175,
0.0326010026,
0.0040779184,
-0.0144877816,
0.020586431,
-0.0492885485,
-0.0024587747,
-0.0418083221,
0.0045024669,
0.0026479329,
0.0134432418,
0.0106037734,
-0.1276229322,
0.0313910544,
-0.0263731424,
-0.0933486,
-0.025951989,
0.0034054716,
0.0126531301,
-0.0147818113,
-0.0293566287,
-0.0503987968,
0.0001867693,
-0.0484103672,
0.0031118724,
-0.0265879165,
0.0182647221,
-0.03232418,
0.0352072753,
-0.0269942172,
-0.0157571323,
-0.0130196773,
-0.0170706045,
0.0322906338,
-0.012384817,
0.0275903717,
-0.0521094985,
0.0387391672,
0.0059403055,
-0.0088374931,
0.0451058969,
0.0348348618,
0.0001978396,
-0.038596388,
-0.020229578,
0.0067037046,
0.0553821214,
0.017419003,
0.0257526543,
-0.0181560405,
0.0248909518,
-0.0182240047,
0.043604061,
-0.0094269253,
-0.0098900972,
-0.0270132683,
-0.0275032017,
-0.0694226548,
-0.0410374217,
-0.0197151434,
-0.0417908579,
0.0265081283,
0.0051968959,
-0.0080288015,
0.0519157872,
-0.0653229356,
-0.0296141803,
0.0337688476,
0.0461327285,
-0.0283513013,
0.0350091644,
-0.0087849144,
0.015413437,
0.0516183302,
-0.038009163,
0.0464191511,
-0.0630860552,
-0.0069944323,
0.0253137518,
-0.0398315378,
0.0141619751,
-0.0084891189,
-0.0026739258,
-0.0014633654,
0.0140813217,
0.0721585974,
-0.0745737702,
-0.0363139883,
-0.0360483751,
-0.0252541695,
0.0076612388,
-0.003323514,
0.0116519518,
0.0651294664,
-0.0240884945,
-0.0051940577,
-0.0730906427,
0.0162566379,
-0.0008720921,
-0.0733473524,
0.024566954,
-0.0039821616,
-0.0620049983,
-0.0582492426,
-0.0553571545,
0.0191541575,
0.0039270129,
0.0393964536,
0.0128131006,
-0.0122268377,
0.0114487698,
-0.0626721978,
0.0729367509,
-0.015686946,
0.0373765677,
-0.0901929066,
-0.0120792743,
0.0471082143,
-0.0049764458,
-0.0587773994,
0.0273682438,
0.0031771143,
0.0104853464,
-0.0001095432,
-0.0235617068,
-0.0190348905,
-0.0022906899,
0.0027740367,
0.0339090154,
0.0278942846,
-0.0110426927,
-0.0501456596,
0.0060972995,
-0.0133579979,
0.0121942954,
0.0436396487,
-0.0201948062,
0.0038320867,
0.0139165018,
-0.0155526102,
0.0142113166,
0.0121182613,
-0.0061745797,
-0.0117006274,
-0.0029138075,
0.0314592496,
-0.0485186726,
0.0274872091,
0.0379310958,
-0.0471223369,
0.0294939019,
0.076591149,
-0.0584321693,
-0.0054908497,
-0.0152225224,
0.0189752281,
0.0408220328,
0.0055003599,
-0.0227539372,
-0.0622354411,
0.0123741208,
0.0160356704,
-0.0510606132,
-0.0033040885,
0.0001128544,
0.0095665287,
0.0834686905,
0.0061383531,
0.0828744769,
-0.0180880576,
0.0432671197,
-0.0907357931,
-0.0453208201,
0.0116474787,
-6.329775532e-33,
-0.0010200277,
-0.0021034901,
-0.0278855618,
-0.0320704766,
-0.0089433165,
0.0406504795,
-0.0027860506,
-0.0138441715,
-0.0069894856,
0.0026267867,
0.0338770598,
0.0101682125,
0.0040819934,
-0.0495276414,
0.0635692179,
0.0043452024,
0.0155562693,
-0.0050293477,
-0.015995672,
0.0306444857,
0.0407178514,
-0.0003183198,
-0.0009583342,
-0.0401584767,
-0.0085778181,
-0.0224004015,
-0.0157773085,
-0.0822789669,
0.0923318416,
0.0225132518,
-0.0062378035,
0.0049817935,
0.0557093471,
-0.088216871,
-0.0130743971,
0.0407270677,
-0.0341537632,
-0.0291487928,
0.0385113694,
-0.0589925982,
0.0172425937,
0.0061446722,
0.0135818496,
0.0353971049,
-0.0102082239,
-0.0056311213,
0.042595502,
0.008046384,
0.0013955511,
-0.0475133397,
-0.0072537041,
0.0265115146,
-0.0519388206,
0.0012498709,
-0.0600157045,
-0.0131151052,
0.0204883814,
0.0963415876,
-0.0665320382,
0.0217113309,
-0.052041553,
0.0563841127,
0.020848047,
-0.0574386641,
-0.0037500549,
0.0733863935,
-0.0007346824,
0.0387348048,
-0.033654768,
0.0342947766,
0.0198443588,
0.0366895385,
-0.0074471543,
0.0748990178,
0.0521852449,
-0.0618697293,
-0.0797324479,
0.0675173178,
0.0210397858,
0.0165668149,
0.0303908531,
0.0064105177,
0.0069905403,
-0.0146622481,
-0.002024553,
-0.041649539,
-0.0318039656,
-0.0169610921,
-0.0137875304,
0.0212187842,
0.0232248046,
0.0928299576,
0.0209293235,
0.0315597802,
-0.0478203781,
0.0138125876,
-0.0172340292,
0.0158623345,
0.0260324832,
0.0429285243,
-0.0721326843,
-0.0043811481,
-0.0323249921,
0.0405396111,
-0.0056864955,
-0.0306523051,
0.0042710672,
-0.0080266548,
-0.0369747989,
-0.0011160957,
-0.0051316633,
-0.0154961236,
-0.0414752923,
-0.0046861381,
0.0202665552,
0.0385451466,
0.0103862984,
-0.000194054,
0.0483060293,
0.0123327048,
0.0622395352,
-0.0414019823,
-0.0597722046,
0.0313391052,
0.035217125,
-0.0081720883,
-0.0599586032,
0.0031738223,
-0.0086002629,
-0.0458944738,
-0.026405111,
-0.0430649258,
2.637e-7,
0.0402058288,
0.0703520998,
-0.017597042,
0.0436281487,
0.0367916562,
-0.0004791429,
-0.0112869916,
0.0501802936,
-0.0167507268,
-0.0702177808,
-0.0187089648,
0.02199357,
0.0088396538,
0.0581473112,
-0.0638130307,
0.0268655792,
-0.0869309604,
0.0458242707,
-0.0708273128,
-0.0066309813,
0.0149254445,
0.0242694877,
0.0708816722,
0.0250094961,
0.006935325,
-0.0126297558,
0.0351954065,
-0.0299670845,
-0.0850308239,
0.0352409035,
-0.0328859948,
0.0204676166,
-0.045969151,
0.0232791733,
-0.0215918794,
-0.009827029,
0.0081768837,
-0.0251972154,
0.0476743542,
0.0005124808,
0.0172067713,
-0.011370806,
-0.0189467464,
-0.0782197937,
0.0392496027,
-0.0380292833,
-0.0201428533,
-0.0267644543,
-0.0790439919,
0.0439897962,
0.0117987534,
0.0179234929,
-0.0322497971,
0.0430127643,
-0.0482546836,
0.0169308931,
0.0150618264,
-0.0243507195,
0.0314967558,
0.0273407139,
-0.038371928,
-0.0403660648,
-0.0444796793,
-0.0400426909,
0.0279355701,
-0.0266780164,
0.0479734726,
1.998812431e-34,
0.0304227248,
0.0428222306,
-0.0289025083,
-0.0297317114,
0.0078599136,
-0.0034362413,
-0.0574078038,
-0.0413471945,
0.026605878,
-0.018460935,
0.0285400376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02251v1 | Fine-Tuning Language Models for Context-Specific SQL Query Generation | 2023-12-04T18:04:27 | 2023-12-04T18:04:27 | Amine Rebei | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The ability to generate SQL queries from natural language has significant
implications for making data accessible to non-specialists. This paper presents
a novel approach to fine-tuning open-source large language models (LLMs) for
the task of transforming natural language into SQL queries within the retail
domain. We introduce models specialized in generating SQL queries, trained on
synthetic datasets tailored to the Snowflake SQL and GoogleSQL dialects. Our
methodology involves generating a context-specific dataset using GPT-4, then
fine-tuning three open-source LLMs(Starcoder Plus, Code-Llama, and Mistral)
employing the LoRa technique to optimize for resource constraints. The
fine-tuned models demonstrate superior performance in zero-shot settings
compared to the baseline GPT-4, with Code-Llama achieving the highest accuracy
rates, at 81.58% for Snowflake SQL and 82.66% for GoogleSQL. These results
underscore the effectiveness of fine-tuning LLMs on domain-specific tasks and
suggest a promising direction for enhancing the accessibility of relational
databases through natural language interfaces. | [
0.0245567821,
0.1106763557,
0.0041736704,
0.0287266281,
-0.0229518581,
0.0136552555,
-0.0086506,
-0.0065198974,
0.0161117502,
-0.0455805436,
-0.0153466659,
-0.0295701455,
-0.0231162589,
0.048528634,
0.0426639728,
-0.0379607603,
0.0042318655,
-0.015153802,
-0.0344506465,
0.0373603068,
-0.0289428066,
0.0553152151,
0.0229912531,
0.01097563,
0.0043442543,
-0.0107126785,
-0.0187846329,
0.0299899783,
-0.0481160916,
-0.029177459,
0.0008415788,
0.057628829,
0.0270182211,
0.0037639563,
0.0000022788,
-0.0741640776,
-0.0252543055,
0.0277735759,
-0.0391509421,
0.023182651,
0.0675590485,
-0.0345185399,
0.0358177125,
0.0631869137,
-0.0638565719,
-0.0234242566,
0.0270901192,
0.0019991184,
0.0409024246,
0.0613753758,
-0.0176716428,
-0.0815754011,
-0.0235589277,
-0.0118535487,
0.0220035538,
-0.0519527942,
-0.0096866945,
0.0376168601,
0.0461481586,
-0.0007910625,
-0.0110059055,
0.0023550196,
0.0131036239,
-0.0204656813,
-0.0065051913,
0.002421248,
-0.0706773698,
0.0261963587,
0.0068688118,
0.0376200639,
0.0022856647,
-0.021732403,
0.0062481561,
0.0125860246,
-0.0045914035,
-0.0280070342,
-0.0183756575,
0.0090444554,
0.0128815453,
0.0175368637,
-0.0214326289,
-0.0369112045,
0.0067777312,
-0.0019417483,
-0.0421645902,
0.0017484602,
0.0213463884,
-0.0142941996,
0.0435189083,
-0.0510827303,
-0.0126130292,
-0.0024746624,
0.0083441129,
0.049430415,
-0.0605341196,
0.0195381306,
-0.0597799197,
0.043138504,
0.0296560321,
-0.0407041796,
0.0192756429,
0.0471446961,
0.0111204162,
0.0532495081,
0.0086745778,
0.0268686581,
0.022296967,
-0.009505582,
-0.0313841663,
-0.0546775945,
-0.0517544523,
-0.0010852611,
-0.0612509139,
0.0030394909,
-0.1077303216,
-0.0192385502,
-0.0522964336,
0.0310584232,
0.0460859574,
0.0173689034,
0.0390750766,
0.0224740487,
-0.0037160101,
-0.0313928351,
-0.0519377477,
-0.0056680571,
0.0015622537,
0.0088369772,
-0.0148619376,
-0.1169138774,
-0.0198292006,
0.0150207002,
0.0079793287,
-0.0240715891,
0.0278214309,
0.0410204083,
-0.0002557859,
-0.0148926033,
-0.101631552,
-0.05660142,
0.0167751089,
-0.0332295224,
-0.0414197296,
-0.0504830815,
0.0362078995,
0.0102546047,
-0.0228852984,
-0.0547888651,
-0.0136196259,
0.0387239642,
0.0020459865,
0.0593242235,
-0.057899341,
0.0003510914,
0.0077981018,
-0.0176672041,
0.0726593211,
0.084824279,
0.0107294796,
0.0050269496,
-0.0024670037,
-0.0290822685,
0.0176138766,
0.0146248871,
-0.017487783,
0.0176242795,
-0.0774680004,
0.0886760131,
-0.0152297998,
0.0524153411,
0.0187218878,
0.0619731247,
0.002126025,
0.0103387441,
0.0360410623,
0.0351414941,
0.0473985858,
0.0195108373,
0.0525246263,
0.0365905128,
-0.0110705374,
-0.0659140721,
-0.0163891278,
0.0187548473,
-0.0073657813,
0.0137508065,
0.0125502776,
0.0119970115,
-0.0275993403,
-0.0606613532,
0.003432143,
-0.0183792934,
-0.0281263907,
0.0398612171,
0.0187179092,
0.0139048724,
-0.0323759764,
0.0355260931,
-0.0089138523,
-0.0460199118,
-0.0004148626,
-0.0067136581,
-0.0323122106,
0.1039746106,
0.0291188974,
-0.0430930182,
0.0051409961,
-0.0205088872,
-0.004288957,
0.0332709774,
0.0307900216,
-0.0036346754,
-0.0117581626,
-0.0630158111,
-0.0230957381,
0.0378830582,
0.0286441632,
-0.0250635687,
0.0124779092,
0.0223645568,
0.0388835594,
-0.0174444541,
-0.0522748902,
0.0199333802,
-0.0134552866,
-0.0774634778,
0.0196062848,
-0.0089780251,
0.0051981988,
0.0470469184,
-0.0045927805,
0.0301931892,
0.048775658,
0.0065856683,
-0.0369379148,
-0.0080198729,
0.0352967195,
-0.0033858209,
0.0036740061,
-0.0203585364,
-0.0032569538,
-0.053453356,
-0.0606985241,
-0.0376823954,
0.0249867011,
-0.0133747859,
0.0195655692,
-0.0410849229,
0.0029026368,
0.0126408357,
-0.0113761267,
-0.0381150097,
0.033078365,
0.0067138863,
0.0125788245,
0.0106645552,
-0.0243311543,
0.0232169051,
-0.0833132118,
0.0347579718,
0.0081834225,
0.013090767,
0.0460082218,
-0.026246883,
0.0592976809,
-0.0393098965,
-0.0182790607,
-0.0620329902,
0.0234923363,
-0.016639594,
0.0310536362,
0.0203453191,
0.0507633425,
-0.0471049882,
-0.0094863772,
-0.0342390426,
-0.0530124158,
-0.0191515274,
0.0016028644,
0.0248323549,
0.0305533297,
-0.0280044787,
-0.0178261101,
-0.0165711548,
-0.0275758561,
0.0342577025,
-0.0133350352,
-0.0107118962,
-0.0049658595,
0.031845618,
0.0112165045,
0.0297651775,
-0.0031800126,
0.005787652,
-0.0057802978,
-0.0407449901,
0.012123676,
0.0566430017,
-0.0083550112,
-0.0289010033,
0.0031581451,
-0.0177436154,
-0.0321589895,
0.0136490436,
-0.006196206,
-0.0519573763,
-0.0036558325,
-0.0342146493,
0.0579203404,
-0.0030932457,
0.0148725603,
-0.0058102566,
-0.0329705253,
0.0128203528,
0.0059076967,
-0.0030688876,
-0.0273477435,
0.027881423,
0.0247636586,
0.0415148735,
0.0166155398,
-0.0090446938,
0.0190981459,
-0.0382118411,
0.0033986662,
-0.0410471596,
-0.0128099089,
-0.0813767314,
0.0486791469,
0.0034732025,
0.0137346294,
-0.0086351465,
-0.0535342656,
0.0043442105,
-0.0251583457,
-0.0042806198,
-0.0322508849,
0.089830637,
-0.0422382094,
0.0117029119,
-0.020507127,
-0.0198212825,
-0.0188392513,
-0.0164462253,
-0.0466611311,
0.0249705017,
0.0752766132,
0.0000031822,
0.0005502426,
0.0179241598,
-0.0192376859,
0.0458111353,
0.0170071293,
-0.0331884287,
0.0066141733,
-0.0543125272,
0.0355845056,
0.0318447053,
-0.0292395558,
0.0334766954,
0.0023196987,
-0.0051222886,
0.0295582879,
-0.0456387624,
-0.0158707891,
0.0343289897,
0.0065211882,
-0.0114234854,
0.0016422761,
0.0556119792,
-0.0193834733,
-0.0630369484,
0.0000552391,
0.09644714,
0.0118556935,
0.0122372722,
-0.0157109518,
0.0058098277,
0.0337542109,
0.0591259114,
0.0578428321,
-0.1420208663,
-0.0528032929,
-0.035424538,
0.0410367996,
0.0375454724,
-0.0406192578,
-0.0310163889,
-0.1737539023,
0.0469817631,
-0.0262132809,
-0.0365892239,
-0.0357401632,
-0.0287808962,
-0.0303049367,
-0.0592302084,
0.0166682992,
0.0647016689,
-0.0510703921,
0.0016717226,
0.020234406,
-0.0169603471,
-0.0806878805,
-0.007549522,
-0.0400842465,
0.0219319612,
0.0503773503,
0.0145644015,
0.0105026923,
-0.0208478589,
0.0034383077,
-0.0032726154,
0.0190888532,
-0.0416022763,
0.0474675559,
0.0068971645,
-0.0122297984,
0.0169169549,
0.0233470835,
-0.0457401387,
0.0457990095,
0.0051715276,
0.0771881044,
-0.0172316842,
0.0188533645,
-0.0019928652,
-0.0240621287,
0.0043325736,
0.0538266115,
0.0161225293,
0.0149072781,
-0.0652587637,
-0.0214826167,
-0.0354362875,
-0.0395001583,
-0.0387482047,
0.0571301468,
-0.0100202793,
-0.0304321926,
0.0050565153,
-0.0340593345,
0.0954300389,
0.0295084249,
0.0128295179,
0.0552758165,
0.0291779935,
-0.0037568237,
-0.0249984525,
0.0084482851,
-0.0625378937,
0.0016752729,
-0.0390455835,
0.0102752335,
0.0330325849,
-0.0206054375,
-0.0193314366,
0.0137213906,
-0.0064903069,
-0.0482206345,
-0.0165150482,
0.0204294492,
0.025705101,
-0.0143757779,
-0.0023331477,
-0.0790299252,
-0.0467456728,
0.0832767636,
-0.0313250087,
-0.0357360952,
0.0012754922,
0.0076279044,
-0.0075377114,
0.0436081998,
-0.0301731396,
-0.0047732382,
-0.0501569919,
0.0203550104,
-0.0165652093,
-0.0168790892,
0.0724550337,
0.0428536944,
0.0013023652,
0.0120918071,
-0.0148036126,
-0.0055662845,
0.047995653,
-0.0509135537,
-0.0279849768,
-0.0407325402,
0.0131536452,
0.016217418,
-0.0021212792,
0.0253378861,
-0.0268263947,
-0.0368979983,
0.0298516024,
-0.0380505361,
0.0197091345,
0.0335633457,
0.004494166,
0.0350548439,
-0.0233705975,
-0.0045503732,
0.0220970847,
0.0090592746,
0.0489529781,
-0.0122956038,
0.011617342,
0.0105895652,
0.031498801,
-0.014162981,
-0.0105444314,
0.014023276,
-0.0667843297,
-0.0132253747,
-0.0103347441,
0.0539415032,
-0.0135609107,
0.0079718828,
-0.0026583464,
-0.0000558238,
-0.0422157422,
0.0504123084,
0.0546338595,
-0.0118350666,
0.0469471402,
0.0269634686,
-0.0450974256,
-0.0530743711,
0.0798873529,
0.040168643,
0.0515162684,
-0.0053483858,
-0.0293033924,
-0.0346817039,
-0.0300921518,
0.0426251329,
-0.0185715593,
-0.0218419395,
-0.0360305309,
-0.0605791919,
-0.0300220996,
0.0038067396,
0.0202119853,
-0.0146853551,
-0.0094660893,
0.0654495656,
0.06650462,
0.0295243599,
-0.0270444378,
-0.0115389116,
0.0080490066,
-0.0550467782,
-0.0564939156,
-0.0119636115,
-6.677507332e-33,
-0.0292069037,
-0.0281520598,
0.0546403602,
-0.0037129649,
0.0166413505,
-0.0465754084,
-0.0207078848,
-0.0231954921,
-0.0280340817,
-0.0091139125,
-0.0168949217,
0.0131335771,
0.029166501,
0.0253829379,
0.0180144664,
-0.0381120853,
0.0327974446,
0.0194826722,
0.0226954538,
-0.0062444531,
0.0112467716,
0.0317020155,
0.034892641,
-0.0372979008,
-0.0060687135,
-0.0194566511,
-0.0100007299,
0.0233353339,
0.0082612485,
0.0421161987,
-0.0215701889,
0.0407358222,
-0.0039531854,
-0.0147592416,
-0.0074756546,
-0.0124671971,
-0.0337993167,
-0.0045485375,
0.0395644903,
-0.0082239313,
0.0177684836,
-0.029683819,
0.0766745061,
-0.0240878388,
-0.0580973998,
0.0424130261,
0.0164572559,
-0.0305379219,
-0.0253963303,
-0.0664522797,
-0.0361712538,
0.0222514085,
0.0146511523,
0.0128294062,
0.0001631803,
0.0185502078,
-0.0095322877,
0.041006308,
-0.0333793052,
0.0294257924,
0.0513147265,
0.0569513775,
0.034674447,
0.0089884466,
0.0381476581,
-0.0128036467,
0.0178440884,
-0.0279712696,
0.0073349471,
0.0550952852,
-0.0057165502,
0.0923903137,
0.0111043323,
0.0646464676,
0.0260722563,
-0.0197492018,
-0.0983695015,
0.0174842421,
-0.0749612972,
0.01899671,
0.0030078134,
0.0283587016,
-0.0637815967,
-0.0504569523,
-0.040663112,
0.0324376188,
-0.0420301557,
0.0101756305,
0.0398908854,
0.0145916436,
-0.0011121946,
0.0082838992,
0.0046809628,
-0.0028246304,
-0.0534894019,
0.0110781547,
-0.0195847396,
-0.0429568812,
-0.0054715942,
0.0135202622,
-0.0340912864,
-0.0201566108,
0.0076253624,
-0.0041217487,
0.0100770704,
0.0140024386,
0.0138275102,
0.0382841863,
-0.0818590522,
0.0001216626,
-0.0163150169,
0.0475225151,
-0.0240405127,
0.0025477104,
0.0029127323,
0.0136432489,
0.0204751436,
0.083230406,
0.0116113769,
-0.0229238626,
-0.0121597378,
-0.0370416977,
0.0196346082,
-0.0048259627,
0.0169221554,
0.0290166382,
0.0040044198,
-0.0362697318,
0.0461810529,
-0.0148801655,
-0.0228009298,
0.0531441048,
2.956e-7,
0.0808453187,
0.0520266891,
-0.0018891528,
0.0582903065,
-0.0213931054,
0.0189968739,
0.0254560094,
0.0157220084,
0.0240461286,
-0.0074747778,
0.0127836009,
-0.0039614942,
0.0230569635,
0.0280634277,
-0.0776550397,
0.0220988318,
-0.0037121763,
-0.034872897,
-0.0824433118,
-0.0012228211,
0.072184965,
0.0722120553,
-0.0466984175,
0.002120642,
0.0088715674,
-0.0560002141,
0.0252592247,
-0.0303500239,
-0.0369134732,
0.0362642705,
0.0252856631,
0.0263298284,
-0.0104623893,
0.013521567,
-0.013636685,
0.0050554504,
-0.0284758769,
0.0734515116,
0.0043267431,
0.0104891388,
0.0411892273,
-0.0788658261,
-0.0083780121,
-0.0316874534,
0.0649840459,
-0.0358450487,
-0.0167790446,
0.0698484555,
-0.0077683935,
-0.0377449431,
0.0262166131,
-0.0360105969,
0.0037491871,
-0.0507894419,
0.0452626087,
0.0013088039,
-0.0199322347,
-0.022444278,
-0.0057204361,
0.0352382697,
-0.014911525,
0.0223430991,
-0.004703193,
0.0381020606,
-0.0062812064,
0.0199605133,
0.0241131727,
2.852646069e-34,
0.041014988,
0.0440281406,
0.0310411993,
-0.0046186219,
0.071660988,
0.0235480238,
-0.0128709124,
0.0061751432,
0.0026495885,
-0.0973243788,
-0.0328120962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02073v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02073v3 | A Glitch in the Matrix? Locating and Detecting Language Model Grounding with Fakepedia | 2023-12-04T17:35:42 | 2024-06-11T02:37:23 | Giovanni Monea, Maxime Peyrard, Martin Josifoski, Vishrav Chaudhary, Jason Eisner, Emre Kıcıman, Hamid Palangi, Barun Patra, Robert West | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have an impressive ability to draw on novel
information supplied in their context. Yet the mechanisms underlying this
contextual grounding remain unknown, especially in situations where contextual
information contradicts factual knowledge stored in the parameters, which LLMs
also excel at recalling. Favoring the contextual information is critical for
retrieval-augmented generation methods, which enrich the context with
up-to-date information, hoping that grounding can rectify outdated or noisy
stored knowledge. We present a novel method to study grounding abilities using
Fakepedia, a novel dataset of counterfactual texts constructed to clash with a
model's internal parametric knowledge. In this study, we introduce Fakepedia, a
counterfactual dataset designed to evaluate grounding abilities when the
internal parametric knowledge clashes with the contextual information. We
benchmark various LLMs with Fakepedia and conduct a causal mediation analysis
of LLM components when answering Fakepedia queries, based on our Masked Grouped
Causal Tracing (MGCT) method. Through this analysis, we identify distinct
computational patterns between grounded and ungrounded responses. We finally
demonstrate that distinguishing grounded from ungrounded responses is
achievable through computational analysis alone. Our results, together with
existing findings about factual recall mechanisms, provide a coherent narrative
of how grounding and factual recall mechanisms interact within LLMs. | [
0.0405628681,
0.0338014811,
-0.0482773781,
0.0385833979,
-0.036118038,
0.0099912332,
0.0219988171,
0.0101056602,
-0.0033400191,
-0.0764242858,
-0.0122981369,
-0.0204653665,
0.0161858965,
-0.0040132892,
0.056828592,
0.0197002646,
0.0607375205,
-0.0006499394,
-0.0195119027,
-0.0222583022,
-0.0187991299,
0.0227429364,
-0.0167687852,
0.0270625614,
-0.0261835605,
-0.0159354601,
0.003019131,
0.0182760321,
-0.0000027764,
-0.0134347836,
0.0267280992,
0.0580383763,
0.0275113638,
0.0587566867,
0.0000020458,
-0.0579786226,
-0.0260132998,
-0.029395299,
-0.0445368625,
0.0497617461,
-0.0086436421,
0.0241331365,
0.0134919435,
0.0021793107,
-0.0344755538,
-0.0080402698,
0.0363254882,
0.0526757836,
0.0290228445,
0.0435518734,
-0.0003556386,
-0.0138165699,
0.01187531,
0.0132153258,
0.0296691693,
-0.0026252999,
0.0251248647,
0.0330381617,
-0.0458829887,
0.0112667428,
-0.0063010263,
0.0067500197,
0.0151550854,
0.0130387507,
0.0117873317,
0.0282826833,
-0.0326588005,
0.0030218028,
0.0432415865,
0.0696467459,
0.0811083168,
-0.0690877512,
-0.0011364893,
-0.0160662532,
-0.0018107608,
0.0718827173,
-0.0326112844,
0.0130641013,
-0.0207174197,
0.0047540166,
0.0381203741,
0.0014518786,
0.0432889685,
0.0365291275,
-0.0087878816,
0.1142137125,
0.027602762,
-0.0313293226,
-0.0130246626,
0.015912449,
0.0265850443,
-0.0563913621,
0.0043290579,
-0.0084580975,
-0.0248908941,
0.0440044105,
-0.0097122826,
-0.0252591819,
0.0424778536,
-0.0759920999,
-0.0062000994,
0.0471281372,
-0.024275111,
0.0108582936,
-0.0575456731,
0.0386218652,
-0.0395480916,
0.0293638352,
-0.0051054866,
0.0309976134,
-0.0242210235,
-0.0454998203,
-0.0132918153,
0.0343864001,
-0.0248869173,
0.027613638,
-0.0065024109,
-0.0002520839,
-0.0396678448,
-0.0356965624,
-0.0457191952,
0.0248177294,
-0.0264877304,
0.0049203443,
-0.0490309857,
0.0388422608,
-0.0572513826,
0.0290629677,
0.0009941013,
-0.0795130506,
-0.0239056777,
-0.0083695762,
-0.0042097149,
-0.0212330222,
0.004706434,
0.0035183874,
-0.0053120195,
-0.0153705357,
-0.0879484862,
-0.0680806264,
-0.0016210353,
-0.0561097711,
0.0225649849,
-0.0622944646,
0.0074046119,
0.0495968238,
-0.0212307703,
-0.0593560301,
0.0048153913,
0.0413311981,
-0.0593800806,
0.050921198,
0.0209095106,
-0.0090932436,
0.0423567556,
0.015894888,
0.0123416623,
0.0935696885,
0.0048507797,
-0.0020475746,
0.0405399129,
0.005027514,
-0.0136109944,
-0.0153267076,
0.0614718944,
0.0239992458,
-0.0639098883,
-0.0134101156,
0.0028144089,
-0.0041362299,
0.0306928139,
0.0049342196,
-0.0177317373,
-0.013032929,
0.0578566082,
-0.00952671,
-0.0251419879,
-0.0009130223,
0.0403245203,
-0.0518757626,
-0.0044473163,
0.0766575038,
-0.058736451,
0.0179361925,
-0.0577632971,
0.0223227218,
-0.0073463675,
0.0278280359,
-0.0282796845,
-0.025839394,
-0.0007777095,
0.0498619899,
0.0178601071,
0.0049675107,
0.0186515693,
0.0303633399,
-0.056045223,
0.0899316221,
0.03732346,
-0.0575701073,
0.0158109944,
-0.0158795547,
-0.0076937489,
0.0414535627,
0.0656308606,
-0.0194881428,
-0.0504562408,
0.0096288584,
0.015921535,
0.0455110036,
0.0205488969,
-0.0068954937,
-0.0217390452,
-0.0354627371,
-0.0080057392,
-0.0519858152,
0.0424435623,
0.0172468331,
0.017836215,
-0.0001677207,
0.0300232209,
-0.0620308518,
0.0285285357,
0.0352663994,
-0.0519072525,
-0.0190707706,
-0.0464131907,
0.0077577033,
-0.0118658263,
0.0232903399,
-0.0007656951,
0.0238261502,
0.0403207652,
0.0086813876,
-0.0189360548,
0.0146237761,
-0.0538154952,
-0.0094834138,
0.0105066765,
-0.0056075896,
-0.0085833492,
0.0109625272,
0.0134953801,
-0.0443871804,
0.0369119085,
-0.0168751925,
0.0994996428,
-0.030996779,
0.0142523535,
-0.0156444069,
0.0176009387,
-0.0202859994,
0.086597763,
-0.0151591748,
0.0305028725,
0.0434066802,
0.0103695784,
0.012100759,
-0.0287474394,
0.0192109514,
0.0231220741,
0.0010538617,
-0.0363423899,
0.027987564,
-0.0542457439,
-0.0788893476,
0.0225619636,
-0.0654251203,
-0.01971885,
-0.0347908512,
-0.0013838855,
0.0452178046,
-0.0247364938,
-0.0195365362,
-0.0016392062,
-0.0309775881,
-0.0138233081,
-0.0072000897,
0.0468683057,
-0.0073708408,
-0.0061518229,
0.0112800021,
-0.0469380543,
0.0083416523,
-0.0396097973,
0.0428527631,
0.0277192853,
-0.0445265435,
-0.0583055355,
0.0723410249,
-0.0758016557,
0.0112442803,
-0.0257165842,
0.0017006772,
0.0202053059,
0.0305457506,
0.0573122241,
0.0447692014,
-0.0033567979,
0.0316174291,
0.0672357082,
-0.0366002843,
-0.0793489143,
-0.0048034959,
-0.0154631175,
-0.0083194794,
0.0082777254,
-0.0585162453,
-0.0127847111,
0.0259620976,
0.0528599024,
-0.0085415384,
-0.0501504838,
0.0209634975,
-0.0380690359,
-0.0469296016,
-0.0306089967,
-0.0239678007,
-0.0340003595,
0.0583647341,
-0.0130100679,
-0.050435029,
0.0640256852,
-0.0286762714,
0.0156412907,
-0.0130932629,
0.0357674807,
0.0094608422,
0.0396921225,
-0.017946871,
0.0220571309,
0.0154944444,
-0.0317866169,
-0.0485640988,
-0.0099925688,
0.0347199552,
-0.0380653553,
0.0306332558,
-0.0644578263,
0.0332085378,
0.0312940143,
0.0113908127,
-0.0817478448,
-0.0299359504,
-0.0079003014,
-0.0116369519,
-0.0242132731,
-0.0005384799,
-0.0108919488,
-0.0122285234,
0.039339222,
0.030048389,
-0.0185371302,
0.0015972363,
-0.001810886,
-0.0135724815,
0.052848082,
-0.0076936693,
0.0674264356,
-0.0307764802,
0.0131952241,
0.0300202798,
0.0329957157,
-0.0453716256,
0.0117773535,
-0.0103829456,
0.0262310058,
-0.0126005681,
-0.0237122886,
0.0046414379,
0.0047181505,
-0.0382540263,
-0.0282756705,
0.0912428424,
0.0563600361,
-0.0454329401,
0.0044967406,
-0.0305429101,
0.0351801328,
0.0409670547,
-0.0116423508,
-0.0617818199,
0.0130075254,
0.027606342,
0.0091658719,
-0.0484157503,
-0.0408938006,
-0.0251826514,
-0.1449290514,
0.0294221155,
-0.0029382012,
-0.0279234014,
-0.0385349393,
-0.0276153535,
0.0091807405,
0.0396873057,
0.0446604379,
0.0270222239,
0.0235748906,
0.0061117788,
-0.0037870677,
0.0217590537,
-0.051420223,
0.0111171212,
0.0260961112,
0.0653911233,
0.0059556314,
0.0112247486,
-0.0039435187,
-0.0632126108,
0.0272573512,
-0.0178970695,
0.0119811213,
-0.0360388383,
0.0471092016,
0.0080205221,
0.0083755059,
-0.0253640451,
0.0145630017,
-0.0117682386,
-0.0367292576,
-0.0278018285,
0.0646538287,
-0.0204758216,
0.0286094416,
0.0194064118,
0.0242728461,
0.0024638174,
0.0840296224,
0.0296005793,
0.0079939291,
0.0181157645,
-0.0034054013,
0.0551740117,
-0.003116956,
-0.048974894,
-0.0104600694,
0.0049329535,
0.0447986275,
-0.0953555554,
-0.0320945606,
0.0194547046,
0.0275211595,
-0.0095141837,
0.0262909867,
-0.0064886617,
-0.0461762324,
-0.0416727513,
0.0348569937,
-0.0517383143,
0.024023585,
-0.0197768658,
-0.0378698185,
0.0039192871,
-0.0300790966,
0.0031573728,
0.0222906731,
-0.027247617,
-0.0684091523,
0.0195319988,
0.0158161744,
0.0284721553,
0.0359792858,
0.0137439175,
-0.0228506215,
-0.0110505912,
-0.006636891,
-0.0631034002,
0.0643783957,
0.0092056291,
-0.0044432073,
-0.0118823489,
0.037311472,
-0.0380976498,
-0.0220182333,
0.0313646495,
0.0634086356,
0.0048985817,
-0.0191627555,
0.0581527501,
-0.0019184429,
0.076252982,
-0.0185521506,
0.0070361639,
-0.0401652232,
0.0164727848,
-0.0736329406,
-0.0230242647,
0.0116883861,
-0.0007093476,
-0.0090337349,
0.0007879637,
0.0016579042,
-0.0368170887,
-0.0742582902,
0.066612877,
-0.0044981833,
-0.0350594558,
-0.0311373379,
0.0053198566,
0.0206030942,
0.0352746733,
-0.0164487697,
0.0161839351,
0.0097622136,
0.0740057677,
-0.0106387949,
0.0759332702,
0.0182648264,
-0.0266893934,
-0.0574597269,
-0.0292540547,
-0.0657009557,
0.0125379832,
0.0162485559,
0.011348078,
0.0378589891,
-0.058350794,
0.0633597523,
-0.0089144884,
-0.015714474,
0.0079988185,
-0.0175430998,
0.0488132685,
-0.0269886367,
0.0146872755,
0.0205900632,
-0.0091430452,
0.0659267455,
0.0783272833,
0.0049354564,
0.0890160576,
-0.0334293097,
-0.0208232552,
0.0056980215,
-0.0409279801,
-0.0134566901,
0.0382343605,
-0.0233885068,
-0.015712006,
-0.1411823183,
-0.0849047974,
-0.0239431355,
-0.0082631512,
-0.0024309307,
-0.0304240771,
0.0248814616,
0.0589659736,
0.0009060912,
-0.0105869891,
-0.037255127,
0.0530119576,
-0.0206611995,
0.0143128168,
-0.0607768521,
-7.067301259e-33,
-0.0421169735,
-0.0595465228,
0.018223267,
-0.0099336868,
-0.0187694412,
0.0438392274,
-0.0399157256,
0.0160824414,
-0.016262887,
0.0084440392,
-0.0152104273,
0.0147086745,
0.0124097979,
-0.0128291519,
-0.0322237723,
-0.0291598681,
0.0293891151,
0.0175510496,
-0.049154453,
0.0164881386,
0.0730275512,
0.0080152377,
0.0521016195,
-0.0914871395,
0.0800239965,
-0.0197434966,
0.0104523553,
0.0211817827,
-0.0502605103,
0.0442912355,
0.0000997026,
0.0480444431,
0.0294244271,
-0.0655527264,
-0.0052828919,
-0.0235679727,
-0.0397675335,
-0.0360335,
0.0861137807,
0.0033077204,
0.0058428757,
-0.0280828755,
0.0254641324,
-0.0237998497,
-0.0211585071,
0.0169582497,
0.0237619877,
-0.008149676,
-0.0051629758,
0.0171575099,
-0.0736654103,
-0.0043339715,
0.0101355929,
0.0128690684,
-0.0371906795,
0.0506970435,
0.0227378476,
0.0256900173,
-0.075796634,
0.0174730644,
-0.0280293971,
0.0020750212,
0.0788498595,
0.0294105187,
0.0148710916,
0.0636524111,
0.0057538329,
0.0479003601,
-0.0494869426,
-0.0153657496,
0.0460400581,
0.0022001108,
0.0463878699,
0.0739092752,
0.0000956683,
-0.0265548192,
-0.0341819003,
-0.0112163071,
0.0007850025,
0.0156853981,
0.0231635142,
0.001050484,
-0.0352339186,
-0.0356645845,
-0.0565711632,
0.0033929164,
-0.0479666069,
-0.0168874413,
0.0355399139,
-0.0144065889,
-0.0379188694,
-0.0308090616,
0.0155602247,
-0.0067782532,
-0.0003175539,
0.0627356097,
-0.015983656,
0.0058401194,
0.0009664536,
0.0185185149,
-0.0277659651,
0.0229489394,
0.0167483706,
0.0098471204,
0.0130797196,
0.0018784271,
0.000313411,
0.0039678072,
-0.0414761491,
0.003086274,
-0.0488474555,
-0.0018414872,
-0.0115426704,
-0.0602847561,
0.0419911221,
0.0226030555,
-0.02295986,
0.0200936962,
0.0684060827,
0.0243811086,
-0.0401190557,
-0.0357440002,
-0.0513656437,
0.0428383797,
-0.0213360097,
-0.009530263,
0.0131023284,
0.0460192263,
0.0647960901,
-0.035174679,
-0.0206258837,
-0.0305712316,
2.849e-7,
0.0463564061,
0.0578831546,
0.0132058663,
0.0016933059,
0.0033607346,
0.0282048639,
0.0009998733,
-0.0153592667,
0.0644126534,
-0.0780884698,
-0.0355190486,
0.0275794771,
0.0122285513,
0.007776367,
-0.0367077254,
0.0157242436,
-0.0398164205,
-0.0111978492,
-0.0173314083,
-0.0198616758,
0.0114365881,
0.027965514,
0.0166067351,
-0.0114290752,
-0.0281282272,
-0.0138065787,
0.0537943132,
-0.0247247163,
-0.0225401428,
-0.0239808951,
0.0313078724,
0.0023034357,
0.0187703539,
0.0439513735,
-0.0180091076,
0.0189549737,
-0.0222444609,
-0.0019173621,
0.0179834776,
-0.0221433677,
-0.0533991754,
-0.0387976095,
0.0100935204,
-0.0888287723,
0.0588646308,
0.0175360758,
-0.0050769844,
0.0023984732,
-0.0231278613,
0.0269899238,
0.0239957534,
-0.0100920573,
-0.053090103,
0.0236620549,
-0.0122594032,
0.0316640325,
-0.0067593837,
-0.0567390248,
-0.0541718639,
0.0186593514,
-0.025379125,
-0.0579254106,
-0.0056471052,
-0.0224785451,
-0.0020249938,
-0.0427553058,
0.0134159811,
2.821089556e-34,
0.0055019683,
0.0257921964,
0.0433906168,
0.0012431479,
0.0414064527,
-0.026685264,
-0.0116538648,
0.0299692806,
0.0206426047,
-0.0540517755,
-0.0069775451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02249v1 | Recursive Visual Programming | 2023-12-04T17:27:24 | 2023-12-04T17:27:24 | Jiaxin Ge, Sanjay Subramanian, Baifeng Shi, Roei Herzig, Trevor Darrell | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Visual Programming (VP) has emerged as a powerful framework for Visual
Question Answering (VQA). By generating and executing bespoke code for each
question, these methods demonstrate impressive compositional and reasoning
capabilities, especially in few-shot and zero-shot scenarios. However, existing
VP methods generate all code in a single function, resulting in code that is
suboptimal in terms of both accuracy and interpretability. Inspired by human
coding practices, we propose Recursive Visual Programming (RVP), which
simplifies generated routines, provides more efficient problem solving, and can
manage more complex data structures. RVP is inspired by human coding practices
and approaches VQA tasks with an iterative recursive code generation approach,
allowing decomposition of complicated problems into smaller parts. Notably, RVP
is capable of dynamic type assignment, i.e., as the system recursively
generates a new piece of code, it autonomously determines the appropriate
return type and crafts the requisite code to generate that output. We show
RVP's efficacy through extensive experiments on benchmarks including VSR, COVR,
GQA, and NextQA, underscoring the value of adopting human-like recursive and
modular programming techniques for solving VQA tasks through coding. | [
-0.0063172062,
-0.0003917243,
-0.0215749312,
0.0359471664,
0.0063757328,
0.0369257443,
-0.0389908403,
0.0290994123,
-0.0100434078,
-0.0125197582,
0.0188313518,
0.0291227046,
0.0098527353,
0.0718917325,
0.0410219729,
-0.0745767206,
0.0058688163,
-0.0040696859,
0.0027432246,
-0.0036255505,
0.0318659283,
0.0004482619,
-0.0142164789,
0.0166512784,
-0.0338910036,
-0.0337705277,
-0.0295272619,
-0.0089692995,
0.0132633029,
-0.0280238092,
-0.0508463047,
0.0027297961,
0.0560863242,
-0.0102916937,
0.0000021653,
0.0042344085,
-0.0122529827,
0.0001418437,
-0.0101487823,
-0.0058333268,
-0.0201930851,
-0.0381819718,
0.0472971089,
0.0213671941,
-0.0622992367,
-0.0590582676,
0.0549354814,
-0.0120820347,
0.0700525865,
0.0152240861,
-0.0184330605,
-0.0351378433,
-0.0192595553,
0.0268703736,
0.030471459,
-0.0359820165,
-0.0112777175,
0.059413977,
0.0175494086,
-0.0112609547,
-0.0510947481,
0.0379424952,
0.0456182361,
0.0016223182,
0.0151007511,
0.0448865667,
-0.030549746,
-0.009825225,
-0.0270773061,
0.0624927692,
0.000998608,
0.0012842761,
0.0112322979,
0.0080034779,
-0.0042159501,
0.0018969731,
-0.0613234602,
0.0331508145,
-0.058603432,
-0.0276837945,
-0.0535072759,
-0.002147869,
-0.0300159361,
-0.0348222107,
0.0046784482,
-0.0480002575,
-0.0055762301,
0.0045560352,
-0.0272934493,
0.0055167568,
-0.0079894522,
-0.0681977421,
-0.0183612835,
0.0806509331,
-0.0172333587,
-0.0016037002,
0.0067562228,
-0.0353833921,
-0.0090231206,
-0.0178974494,
0.06256596,
0.0466359034,
-0.0202974398,
0.0361898728,
-0.0005847668,
0.064279452,
-0.0394389071,
0.0069575021,
-0.0294075627,
-0.0002354903,
-0.071719557,
-0.040823549,
-0.0673510954,
0.0074754539,
-0.032436993,
-0.0008796136,
0.0062080165,
0.0498632118,
-0.0054600127,
0.0078716688,
-0.0390294082,
0.0601048768,
-0.0121154673,
0.0077170334,
-0.0462991409,
0.0401541777,
-0.0696181059,
-0.051791925,
-0.0478566661,
0.0090597905,
0.0043744985,
0.0251733195,
0.0115448283,
-0.003003709,
-0.0030520747,
0.0604499839,
-0.0469983183,
0.0247806478,
-0.0155282272,
-0.0431439057,
-0.0064768614,
-0.0254068393,
0.0468467623,
-0.0767363906,
0.0019035854,
-0.0070415386,
-0.0478872471,
-0.0021697672,
-0.007506744,
0.0455632545,
-0.0214727614,
0.0768719092,
-0.0562084764,
0.00092662,
0.0258082692,
-0.0027826079,
-0.0132125178,
0.0365344062,
0.0388759486,
0.0356788523,
0.0198687967,
-0.0147686601,
0.084130995,
-0.0026348033,
-0.0107091758,
-0.0030059647,
-0.0462054722,
0.040722996,
-0.0015890271,
0.0127710681,
-0.0106202019,
0.0111828297,
-0.0355773903,
-0.0254368111,
-0.0243717972,
0.0299388226,
0.0200960394,
0.0212621205,
0.059257146,
-0.0133227762,
0.0246394761,
0.0221614167,
-0.0259671174,
0.10647434,
-0.0074200458,
0.003270871,
-0.034913484,
0.0031316488,
-0.0240861122,
-0.0627398118,
-0.0133145098,
0.0397683643,
0.0460158065,
0.0138012301,
0.0298117548,
0.0504442751,
-0.008022842,
-0.0379024372,
-0.0135474941,
-0.0460400656,
-0.0527113192,
-0.0371528603,
0.0753566101,
0.0901761204,
0.0356228203,
-0.0016811134,
0.0082535157,
0.019877959,
0.0489166602,
-0.0288643222,
0.0053052008,
-0.0056487857,
0.0208107885,
-0.0299412832,
-0.0240746755,
-0.0483577661,
-0.0400544219,
0.0347480625,
0.0358931981,
-0.0216135364,
-0.0301834289,
-0.0287538823,
0.0444844067,
0.0269910432,
0.0426286161,
0.0149757564,
0.0067506935,
0.0339257792,
-0.0327536613,
-0.0099536832,
0.0156671125,
-0.0033626466,
0.0218824074,
-0.030939592,
-0.0158491414,
-0.0210254733,
-0.0085354215,
-0.0620964691,
0.012773267,
-0.1058411524,
-0.0619004853,
0.0026227208,
-0.0575723536,
0.0084331548,
0.0651613772,
-0.0640740767,
-0.0387878008,
-0.0101677105,
-0.0406339727,
0.025396999,
-0.022204617,
0.0031729573,
0.0660150647,
-0.0041252174,
-0.0195462089,
0.0121342428,
0.0166227091,
0.0326863788,
-0.0224646255,
0.0319202431,
0.0081627211,
-0.0172188226,
-0.0191047732,
-0.0088846413,
0.059590783,
-0.0366700254,
0.0098635498,
-0.0897566825,
0.0120814182,
-0.0258204062,
-0.0207285881,
0.0112071261,
-0.0030616578,
0.0180236325,
-0.0477133319,
-0.0481183939,
0.0464347452,
-0.010299596,
0.015170835,
0.0735661015,
-0.0158254523,
-0.014250543,
-0.0227749851,
-0.034835536,
-0.0277768616,
0.0522358678,
0.0406517871,
0.01736347,
-0.0287319571,
-0.0207799617,
-0.0558346547,
0.0321719274,
0.0006480787,
-0.0139748678,
0.039689932,
-0.0420227796,
0.0248921029,
0.0701197311,
-0.0240271688,
0.0449677631,
0.0129540842,
0.0054257703,
-0.0042089853,
0.0363356471,
0.0189723447,
-0.0288805831,
0.0381804816,
-0.040076565,
-0.0387930572,
0.0171687976,
-0.0190221779,
0.031968385,
-0.0645180419,
0.0683199167,
0.0608242676,
0.0043205977,
-0.0656610727,
-0.0117117707,
0.0246426109,
0.0607563779,
-0.034056697,
-0.0635468662,
0.0583486333,
0.0099421944,
-0.0313895158,
0.0182894431,
0.0062650274,
-0.0521749333,
0.1112112328,
0.0203920249,
-0.012662516,
-0.0173698477,
-0.0087698428,
-0.0345228538,
-0.0100004496,
0.0208455287,
-0.009928287,
0.0501244888,
-0.0654496104,
-0.0069592549,
-0.0201733187,
-0.0357916169,
-0.0386975333,
0.0107316393,
-0.0199670307,
-0.0121587384,
-0.0313229412,
-0.0062440555,
0.0172813628,
-0.0000230772,
0.0397842303,
-0.0297219809,
0.0153944381,
-0.0374911092,
-0.0221009385,
0.0357380882,
0.0325162448,
0.0375889726,
-0.033123605,
-0.0164624155,
0.0119935619,
0.0557989515,
0.0045901695,
0.0296175871,
-0.0622656532,
0.0529614277,
-0.0102713136,
0.0399764106,
-0.024535099,
0.0339528881,
0.0408364236,
-0.0702724382,
-0.0114280656,
0.0274289642,
0.025370447,
-0.008728357,
-0.0042360961,
-0.0183885004,
0.0215852614,
0.0654274449,
0.0677650496,
-0.1081622913,
-0.0467019454,
-0.0113496855,
0.009441697,
0.0103969006,
-0.0105508482,
-0.0215941817,
-0.0780254602,
0.0697096586,
-0.0146958865,
-0.0365626551,
-0.0322273709,
-0.016847454,
-0.0261287559,
0.0204373654,
-0.0689843819,
0.0253773928,
-0.0199589916,
0.0270118918,
-0.0106397355,
-0.0280414056,
0.0668024495,
0.0255149044,
-0.0134301893,
-0.0583348498,
0.0726168677,
-0.0079036187,
0.0137923546,
-0.0588994101,
-0.0335453153,
0.0060941363,
0.0135801677,
-0.0320456214,
0.0654840618,
-0.0000435011,
-0.0510845073,
0.00838158,
0.0160224792,
0.0047494513,
-0.0162022375,
0.0155150285,
0.030099079,
0.0005597838,
-0.0244071316,
-0.0351251662,
0.0190810207,
-0.0247156434,
0.0104098497,
0.0509024672,
0.0053910194,
-0.0754042342,
-0.0504045039,
0.0017763808,
-0.0703212544,
-0.0340076759,
0.0077845273,
0.0355512016,
-0.0093746213,
-0.0605615191,
0.0164662041,
0.0974828452,
0.0483332351,
-0.0447367728,
-0.0685466602,
-0.0242415797,
0.0237632971,
-0.1057934761,
0.003268813,
-0.0203034133,
0.0314320624,
0.0054902872,
-0.0212604888,
-0.0206885785,
-0.0240439847,
-0.0172762088,
0.0077991798,
-0.0626499504,
-0.012819604,
-0.0521504134,
0.078300491,
0.0071851402,
0.0128215803,
0.0221230611,
-0.0198036097,
-0.0207608622,
0.0291073695,
0.0344603211,
0.0038521725,
-0.0271693524,
0.0204871111,
0.0320366845,
-0.0114067197,
-0.0466517694,
-0.0041149533,
-0.0017813324,
0.0341044925,
-0.0266679171,
0.0524430387,
0.0168534517,
0.0041012247,
-0.0082515106,
0.0133248512,
-0.0122592952,
0.0393951423,
-0.0191085711,
-0.0189077351,
-0.0138690835,
-0.0794721469,
0.0349108726,
-0.0393246189,
-0.0036994012,
0.0390424393,
-0.0043330961,
-0.0180298109,
0.0092996312,
-0.0117409118,
0.035324581,
0.0193036236,
0.0125226444,
0.0243717525,
0.0157118943,
0.0045490558,
0.0311401449,
0.0059146751,
0.0476300381,
0.0103345802,
0.076548256,
0.0436689034,
-0.0060917814,
-0.0646464974,
0.0124849807,
-0.0455004387,
-0.0820043981,
0.0396950692,
0.0437956452,
0.0308392979,
0.0593189076,
-0.0381564349,
0.0164669435,
-0.0059025437,
0.0265320353,
0.005047136,
-0.010897303,
-0.0447749309,
0.05524325,
0.0471903421,
0.0053722137,
-0.0490744412,
0.0843944252,
0.0024122782,
-0.0192123558,
-0.0325916298,
-0.0089742579,
-0.0169315375,
-0.0094876476,
0.0345034674,
-0.0089069,
0.0449833237,
0.0117802294,
-0.0378875285,
-0.0622787401,
0.0254022926,
0.0381886959,
-0.0030001502,
0.0356443748,
0.0721674114,
0.029280642,
0.0723878816,
-0.0463996641,
0.0101821804,
0.0272570625,
-0.000994932,
-0.0467217155,
0.0008282987,
-6.164285764e-33,
-0.0225258488,
-0.0606807433,
0.0644832626,
0.0039158207,
0.0097828815,
-0.0020054602,
-0.0289164297,
0.0135165611,
0.0273196269,
0.0032205482,
0.03567582,
0.0001868874,
-0.0137326587,
0.0096218493,
0.0214111544,
-0.0196779817,
0.0226393025,
0.0050159353,
-0.0312624201,
-0.0319092199,
0.0010924458,
0.0005088676,
-0.0101406723,
-0.0356374867,
-0.0596747845,
0.0238581672,
0.0125943469,
0.029712636,
0.0321883336,
0.0439905375,
-0.0101372674,
-0.0093125459,
0.0309557281,
0.0210813265,
-0.0074059302,
0.05627051,
-0.0961959511,
-0.0462211147,
0.0124821831,
0.0084268255,
-0.1241716221,
0.0036820623,
0.0541164167,
-0.0002793809,
0.0277420189,
-0.065852873,
0.0468528308,
0.0131074237,
0.021643443,
0.0121081676,
-0.0211670045,
-0.0110006388,
-0.0504844673,
-0.0437258705,
-0.0070323707,
0.035524305,
0.0195702538,
0.034715727,
-0.0348365195,
0.0188011173,
-0.0059188092,
-0.0304863527,
0.0363336131,
0.0045246058,
0.0145655498,
-0.0008743436,
0.0718173906,
-0.0229876842,
-0.0850860849,
0.0050808196,
-0.0219703335,
0.0441367701,
0.0703202784,
0.0318094827,
0.0627952144,
0.0286204554,
-0.0245450288,
0.0103386613,
-0.0793317035,
0.0523372665,
-0.0327111147,
0.0173284542,
-0.0095901005,
-0.0266071782,
0.003955021,
0.0080814539,
-0.0394789055,
-0.0353841037,
0.0494180806,
0.0056936201,
-0.0014083327,
0.0345725678,
0.0010530674,
-0.0246371627,
0.0337249823,
0.012770921,
-0.0274990033,
0.0627760813,
0.0152246514,
0.0277647823,
0.0155696413,
0.0441663191,
0.0576265864,
-0.0004039947,
0.0196325146,
0.0250739641,
0.0355443843,
0.0060350238,
-0.0427154712,
0.0021363117,
-0.0322987661,
-0.0106538851,
-0.009581483,
-0.013190723,
0.0054033794,
0.031842228,
-0.026800938,
-0.0087572346,
-0.0243731514,
-0.0188864693,
-0.0512599535,
-0.0537252724,
-0.0159726031,
0.0290238932,
-0.0183774307,
-0.0203591827,
-0.0496071726,
-0.014639427,
0.0008302886,
-0.0580125377,
-0.0269996878,
0.0573209934,
2.745e-7,
0.0251171831,
0.0201565884,
0.0313313603,
0.0508730188,
0.0112644536,
0.0312018227,
0.0236385297,
-0.0058636591,
0.0069424603,
-0.0518292822,
-0.002524998,
0.0753405541,
0.0147095332,
0.0234939009,
0.00015911,
0.0501850769,
-0.007482138,
-0.0375597887,
-0.0382350385,
0.0208574384,
0.0886386484,
0.017888207,
0.0122186327,
-0.003613052,
0.0483337641,
-0.0412074067,
0.0403743796,
0.0404425226,
0.0371997282,
-0.0675256401,
-0.0929201245,
0.0322262682,
-0.0103805959,
-0.0107317427,
0.0049421755,
-0.0486194901,
0.0094334977,
0.0122722946,
-0.0363351591,
0.0082793217,
-0.0172373615,
0.0010257124,
0.0063669072,
0.0046457341,
0.0772020742,
-0.0629074425,
0.0016155485,
0.0173620004,
0.0121881962,
0.0037970725,
0.0140611362,
-0.0062596751,
-0.0215528551,
0.0440566912,
0.0210759509,
-0.03346771,
-0.0213022288,
-0.0389815047,
0.0213562101,
-0.0110375518,
-0.0122029772,
0.0290064216,
-0.0329121873,
0.0027987091,
0.0094194552,
0.028362548,
-0.0751297548,
2.161283658e-34,
0.0361906327,
-0.0203116033,
0.0178593807,
0.0258722901,
0.0583846234,
-0.0177599359,
-0.0408998542,
0.0000375701,
0.0344060808,
-0.0281426497,
-0.0357821584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02065v1 | Know Your Audience: Do LLMs Adapt to Different Age and Education Levels? | 2023-12-04T17:19:53 | 2023-12-04T17:19:53 | Donya Rooein, Amanda Cercas Curry, Dirk Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) offer a range of new possibilities, including
adapting the text to different audiences and their reading needs. But how well
do they adapt? We evaluate the readability of answers generated by four
state-of-the-art LLMs (commercial and open-source) to science questions when
prompted to target different age groups and education levels. To assess the
adaptability of LLMs to diverse audiences, we compare the readability scores of
the generated responses against the recommended comprehension level of each age
and education group. We find large variations in the readability of the answers
by different LLMs. Our results suggest LLM answers need to be better adapted to
the intended audience demographics to be more comprehensible. They underline
the importance of enhancing the adaptability of LLMs in education settings to
cater to diverse age and education levels. Overall, current LLMs have set
readability ranges and do not adapt well to different audiences, even when
prompted. That limits their potential for educational purposes. | [
0.044336468,
0.0171554349,
-0.021244064,
0.0335093699,
-0.0230149459,
-0.0057216496,
0.0442824028,
0.0001319486,
0.0363780148,
-0.0418622755,
-0.0139119541,
-0.0369329453,
-0.003051562,
0.0138162151,
-0.013264888,
-0.0551819131,
0.015275524,
-0.029152751,
0.0464100726,
-0.0272440296,
-0.022112973,
0.0102333082,
0.0027231965,
0.0175258387,
0.0782277435,
-0.0602047034,
0.0500345081,
0.0002167742,
0.0138577968,
-0.0234836098,
0.0446412675,
0.0486393236,
0.0151575664,
0.0167065803,
0.0000021661,
-0.0268999804,
0.0075439988,
0.0118978238,
-0.0084968647,
0.0873194039,
0.0744532794,
0.010892556,
-0.0203933734,
-0.0084057041,
-0.0253351107,
0.0299709309,
0.0348251909,
-0.0450020619,
0.0300315432,
0.009340018,
0.0240339935,
-0.0450656563,
0.0348120779,
0.0190827083,
0.0396478176,
0.0103372876,
0.0107148215,
0.0520871058,
0.0492242649,
0.0268237516,
-0.0252165589,
0.0789506212,
0.0077282465,
-0.0360870212,
0.0206393562,
0.0081075672,
0.0289767683,
-0.0267156586,
-0.0023204461,
0.052333314,
0.030304037,
-0.0366303958,
-0.0268948767,
-0.0271944609,
-0.0251849089,
0.0485920012,
-0.0900542662,
0.0317628868,
0.0173051897,
-0.0030847774,
-0.0072923582,
-0.0308243521,
0.0118262442,
0.0192588512,
0.0139425425,
0.0812307373,
0.0100592496,
-0.0189851224,
-0.0440989845,
0.0219460335,
0.0166974701,
-0.0097553506,
0.0471216477,
0.0366039611,
0.0304918699,
0.0242703948,
-0.0222619548,
-0.049792625,
0.0298034605,
-0.0402459987,
0.0291338228,
0.0207793675,
-0.0029586046,
0.0309557319,
0.005199329,
0.0273500793,
-0.0075384723,
0.0071204896,
-0.0304915104,
0.0360707194,
-0.0130340876,
-0.0249118879,
0.0074515352,
-0.0212548245,
-0.0262479056,
0.0004575352,
-0.0318926536,
-0.0139091751,
0.0094121844,
-0.0372254476,
-0.0394889265,
-0.0141418511,
-0.0215082597,
-0.0325308926,
-0.0165649764,
0.0993485302,
-0.0278815944,
0.0427574776,
-0.0047527752,
-0.0633768588,
0.020229226,
0.0225235913,
-0.0124362698,
-0.0101884315,
0.0018184538,
0.0486903004,
-0.0319016315,
0.0126758851,
-0.0456276387,
-0.0226413086,
-0.0152246989,
-0.0171145909,
0.0181673449,
-0.0614476092,
0.0086235143,
0.0406070463,
0.0162185412,
-0.0580014288,
-0.028773386,
0.0231854096,
-0.0218840484,
0.0088426536,
-0.0036286549,
0.0146202417,
0.0552208163,
0.026347246,
0.0217793155,
0.0393848754,
0.0672298744,
-0.0253172759,
0.0397722572,
-0.0484431796,
-0.0296081081,
0.009616184,
-0.009034087,
0.0336957797,
0.0139275501,
0.0267157014,
-0.0280200504,
0.0288579687,
0.0037164118,
0.0180000458,
0.0202172399,
-0.0190658867,
0.0770060271,
0.0579529256,
0.019418681,
0.0262549147,
-0.0120593756,
0.0281514022,
0.0578873456,
0.0170110166,
-0.0186153911,
0.0418830067,
-0.0274582766,
-0.0034476034,
-0.0101506338,
0.0418559425,
0.0129618803,
-0.0430863835,
-0.0139533766,
0.0360668823,
0.021569781,
0.0009851521,
0.0282010976,
-0.0259958953,
-0.0178947635,
0.0354502052,
0.0180490874,
-0.0757316351,
0.0580359176,
-0.0148014277,
0.0717790797,
0.0500338711,
0.0001098461,
-0.0190193467,
-0.0070573329,
0.0139724119,
0.0535363816,
0.0658088773,
0.0328369662,
0.0139033524,
-0.0224611238,
-0.0432141386,
-0.0196020305,
-0.0151118627,
0.0129871676,
-0.0095277326,
0.0147577925,
0.0273935292,
0.0131504983,
-0.0549740717,
-0.0412784778,
0.0079817083,
-0.1128518209,
-0.017176751,
-0.0394368805,
-0.0234436877,
0.0194282718,
0.0202895403,
-0.0041745808,
0.0430355892,
-0.0169550702,
-0.0026064499,
0.0421302244,
-0.0247276705,
-0.0281468872,
0.0322255455,
0.0377799831,
-0.0785194486,
-0.0058318828,
-0.0152939027,
0.0089535043,
-0.0011301567,
0.0314629562,
-0.0371706076,
-0.002352752,
0.0205085687,
-0.0020586608,
-0.050520923,
-0.04972478,
-0.0433157757,
0.0012688386,
0.0238934811,
0.0130901961,
0.0241581537,
-0.0119921481,
-0.0011298304,
-0.0189652238,
-0.0491902158,
0.0088735959,
0.0036103937,
0.0056903632,
0.0256573204,
0.0135520929,
-0.0651516989,
-0.0421310738,
-0.0023447939,
-0.0423122682,
0.0151962638,
0.0158225782,
0.0126831252,
-0.049673181,
-0.0196824633,
0.0147560099,
-0.0287062097,
0.0163802542,
-0.0249958802,
0.0040270989,
0.0012075709,
-0.0190479401,
0.0011498388,
-0.0474231429,
-0.0586399697,
-0.0360758752,
0.0409383066,
0.0688309893,
0.0011512619,
-0.0522070192,
-0.0012919655,
-0.0231270343,
-0.0395687334,
0.000068893,
-0.007224984,
0.0151788332,
0.01591824,
0.0326412618,
0.0681139454,
0.0075559337,
-0.0081433346,
0.055815611,
-0.0478229709,
-0.0545023009,
-0.0112921046,
0.0017693188,
-0.0174070019,
-0.0220356304,
-0.0997819752,
0.0075896308,
0.0272878185,
0.0040482576,
-0.0159603953,
-0.0481745154,
0.0529209003,
-0.0813976601,
-0.0351983979,
-0.0419835225,
-0.0198506173,
0.0042995955,
0.0499417409,
0.0165631715,
-0.042472288,
0.058500506,
-0.0032076875,
0.0292804725,
-0.0651710778,
0.0177759714,
-0.0429635644,
0.0216824431,
-0.0276577454,
0.0263679456,
0.0272595435,
-0.0131279668,
-0.0598032884,
-0.0040797158,
0.0244796686,
-0.0509488396,
0.081552662,
-0.0810003951,
-0.018375745,
0.0135151306,
0.0036656114,
0.0110466965,
-0.0027759995,
-0.0244457368,
-0.0200945847,
0.0196996983,
-0.0416614674,
-0.0574546643,
-0.0082057538,
0.0760496184,
-0.0017258639,
-0.0392773002,
0.0072822631,
0.0029187845,
0.0173673779,
0.0371020436,
0.0163960699,
0.025685925,
-0.0757389069,
-0.0036373602,
0.0551274605,
-0.006830093,
-0.0097350655,
0.0293259528,
-0.00585195,
0.0756072402,
-0.0209884606,
-0.0235252958,
0.025790507,
0.0661970302,
-0.0935956836,
0.028209161,
0.0669512078,
0.0095095467,
-0.0008462022,
0.0002399823,
-0.0806419328,
0.0179898385,
-0.0179114714,
0.0356003903,
-0.0591379665,
0.0290344842,
-0.0170594566,
0.0467733257,
0.0061627766,
0.0127303796,
-0.0246270243,
-0.0630770922,
0.0393125527,
0.0531075187,
-0.0262304097,
0.0039456496,
-0.0354409926,
-0.0097175101,
0.0358053073,
0.038888894,
0.0412557498,
-0.0262411367,
0.0110202543,
0.0375323184,
-0.0544668511,
-0.0258152429,
0.0071701924,
0.0370974354,
0.0589349978,
0.0048012496,
0.0130521795,
-0.0553666018,
-0.0356628262,
0.0381176844,
-0.0126240365,
-0.0251830313,
-0.0291874893,
-0.020389298,
0.0389979035,
0.0121007822,
-0.0604819916,
0.0227720514,
-0.0088581098,
-0.0389513634,
0.0510713905,
0.0465843081,
0.0400952958,
-0.0542276427,
-0.0721033961,
0.0301177409,
-0.0097434772,
0.0908718109,
0.0346900709,
-0.0330988094,
-0.0121902693,
-0.0702958182,
-0.0099030985,
-0.008660702,
-0.051124651,
0.0227827877,
-0.0263833012,
-0.0291801263,
-0.0264637321,
-0.0134801222,
0.0408358984,
-0.0432418622,
0.045636639,
0.0052871224,
0.0512978956,
-0.0421288423,
-0.0204608068,
0.0266466457,
-0.0340822935,
0.0340982527,
-0.0990730971,
-0.0079401573,
-0.0143183451,
-0.0136528341,
-0.0256421957,
-0.0068101399,
-0.0143036749,
-0.0417286456,
0.0024870527,
0.0333132483,
0.0208634268,
-0.056054987,
0.0508720875,
-0.0789963454,
0.0496526845,
-0.006366028,
0.0034296804,
0.027676506,
-0.0270288959,
0.0231847707,
0.0097950576,
0.0055360463,
-0.0282442477,
-0.0023707338,
0.0098057538,
0.0397127867,
-0.0207863431,
-0.0582820997,
-0.0094964867,
0.0502921417,
-0.0360758826,
-0.009573427,
-0.039453011,
-0.0137050273,
0.0132722892,
-0.0392038077,
0.020712655,
-0.0229857471,
-0.0219300836,
0.0246812906,
-0.0276262052,
0.001202648,
0.0052986694,
-0.0235974956,
0.033936996,
-0.0617702641,
0.1263892502,
-0.0161311794,
0.0133778127,
0.023221992,
0.0079393992,
-0.061128132,
-0.0033683616,
-0.062372759,
0.0714328066,
0.0539630614,
0.0516089574,
0.009842556,
-0.0377509147,
0.0103953658,
0.0044057323,
-0.029707266,
-0.0188193116,
-0.0132703902,
0.0346227773,
-0.0347722732,
0.0249149706,
0.0673225969,
-0.0326294713,
-0.0022983442,
-0.0521523356,
0.0036192569,
0.0566999316,
-0.0309844129,
0.0725870505,
-0.0060793268,
0.0091063296,
-0.0522975624,
0.0894723982,
0.0288668051,
-0.0140537135,
0.0029375048,
-0.0033537229,
0.0002590922,
-0.0112238377,
-0.0156723876,
0.0180419795,
-0.02506225,
0.005404993,
-0.0756502822,
-0.0206268243,
-0.0027217008,
0.0205411538,
-0.0042726751,
-0.026408311,
-0.0155050764,
0.04900584,
-0.026247682,
-0.0825481564,
-0.0240275022,
0.058695782,
-0.0585645922,
-0.0304967985,
0.0056282342,
-6.389843293e-33,
-0.018270582,
-0.02970553,
-0.0041297725,
0.0007137635,
0.0051210788,
0.001631204,
-0.0696008354,
0.0091191167,
-0.0270731114,
0.0087654348,
0.0198198054,
-0.0158135518,
0.0143574663,
0.0183512438,
0.0015384859,
-0.0310533568,
0.0405056514,
0.018043587,
-0.0068443893,
-0.0121693294,
0.0192649569,
-0.0194781478,
0.0576901659,
-0.058895696,
0.0974486023,
-0.0296105128,
0.0048145559,
0.0004766677,
-0.0054476764,
0.0526452214,
-0.008193763,
0.0692846552,
0.009484807,
-0.0374674462,
-0.0223019887,
0.0553247146,
-0.0461049303,
-0.0129124941,
0.0745405033,
0.013492899,
-0.0196403731,
-0.0540590025,
0.0419668667,
0.0311220419,
-0.0169184245,
-0.0808934867,
0.0540646389,
-0.0441656038,
0.0004177027,
0.0013043887,
-0.0451386385,
0.0112553136,
-0.01670512,
0.0280941408,
-0.0037339889,
0.0773881599,
-0.0100810472,
0.0397674218,
-0.0283232722,
0.0627723113,
0.0600932389,
0.0312196184,
0.0464764163,
-0.0297234077,
0.0204928257,
0.0343635045,
-0.0186162312,
0.0235708095,
-0.0419133231,
-0.046081759,
0.0300733671,
-0.0007745846,
0.0644624531,
0.0359582938,
-0.0094164433,
0.0151159279,
-0.0637159869,
0.0088203447,
0.0236034226,
0.0374284424,
0.0176056921,
0.010310635,
-0.0347255766,
-0.0320705548,
-0.0424513482,
0.0354578346,
-0.0311968159,
-0.0462777242,
0.0127012385,
-0.086289905,
-0.0513984188,
-0.0335694812,
0.0021484348,
-0.0366880968,
-0.055857759,
-0.0140415989,
0.0011035777,
0.0326456986,
-0.0050447173,
0.0696049556,
-0.0467412435,
0.0359633826,
-0.0055347132,
-0.0321527682,
0.0059455587,
0.0348794572,
-0.0365212448,
-0.0052398471,
-0.0592172332,
-0.0265828129,
-0.0145192267,
-0.0349874832,
0.0513000861,
0.0006425078,
0.0103948601,
0.0072548748,
0.0266322587,
0.0346732587,
-0.0042918795,
-0.0033403151,
0.005388475,
0.0012875921,
-0.0284153521,
0.0278453585,
-0.0361575559,
-0.0105066588,
-0.0165234692,
0.0357351899,
0.0169131085,
-0.031998042,
-0.0147146862,
-0.0150774661,
2.77e-7,
0.0617041253,
0.0978839621,
-0.0002841895,
-0.0167845096,
0.03232117,
0.0123091293,
-0.0140092047,
-0.0093415501,
0.0774725974,
0.0198632013,
-0.0294771958,
-0.0246569812,
0.0396065861,
0.0377304405,
-0.0478258431,
0.0099570211,
-0.0551957265,
0.0490894876,
-0.0286556613,
0.0312861204,
0.0443680063,
-0.0194069911,
-0.0123046925,
0.0030808446,
-0.0403510705,
-0.0300915781,
0.0364004783,
-0.0761204138,
-0.0067917816,
0.0561135635,
0.0433876365,
-0.0181565639,
0.0582740046,
0.0498078763,
-0.0405383147,
-0.0222905558,
0.0150246639,
0.0742429942,
0.0363182388,
0.0123123396,
0.0072539463,
-0.0030936082,
-0.0061175344,
-0.096488148,
0.0305113364,
-0.0184547808,
-0.0372479744,
0.0113942251,
-0.0563115478,
-0.0385419801,
-0.0005331296,
-0.0232424363,
-0.0274312329,
-0.0166794397,
0.0206498802,
-0.0173425283,
-0.0018246999,
0.0062211994,
-0.0579864904,
-0.0205455311,
-0.0223692786,
-0.0666388944,
-0.0646696091,
0.0090499539,
-0.0031805946,
-0.0307851359,
0.0154742924,
2.034576617e-34,
0.037039455,
-0.0034643875,
0.0143128671,
-0.0248885378,
-0.0018939768,
0.0123784719,
0.0550468378,
0.0030560249,
0.0354899131,
-0.0644805506,
-0.0119299255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03755v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03755v1 | Near-real-time Earthquake-induced Fatality Estimation using Crowdsourced Data and Large-Language Models | 2023-12-04T17:09:58 | 2023-12-04T17:09:58 | Chenguang Wang, Davis Engler, Xuechun Li, James Hou, David J. Wald, Kishor Jaiswal, Susu Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | When a damaging earthquake occurs, immediate information about casualties is
critical for time-sensitive decision-making by emergency response and aid
agencies in the first hours and days. Systems such as Prompt Assessment of
Global Earthquakes for Response (PAGER) by the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS)
were developed to provide a forecast within about 30 minutes of any significant
earthquake globally. Traditional systems for estimating human loss in disasters
often depend on manually collected early casualty reports from global media, a
process that's labor-intensive and slow with notable time delays. Recently,
some systems have employed keyword matching and topic modeling to extract
relevant information from social media. However, these methods struggle with
the complex semantics in multilingual texts and the challenge of interpreting
ever-changing, often conflicting reports of death and injury numbers from
various unverified sources on social media platforms. In this work, we
introduce an end-to-end framework to significantly improve the timeliness and
accuracy of global earthquake-induced human loss forecasting using
multi-lingual, crowdsourced social media. Our framework integrates (1) a
hierarchical casualty extraction model built upon large language models, prompt
design, and few-shot learning to retrieve quantitative human loss claims from
social media, (2) a physical constraint-aware, dynamic-truth discovery model
that discovers the truthful human loss from massive noisy and potentially
conflicting human loss claims, and (3) a Bayesian updating loss projection
model that dynamically updates the final loss estimation using discovered
truths. We test the framework in real-time on a series of global earthquake
events in 2021 and 2022 and show that our framework streamlines casualty data
retrieval, achieving speed and accuracy comparable to manual methods by USGS. | [
0.0336113684,
0.1208333597,
-0.0035784319,
0.039073579,
-0.0078148041,
0.0010595176,
-0.0255600177,
-0.0090436246,
-0.0260169413,
0.0062166825,
0.0375008211,
-0.0139409257,
-0.0182777289,
-0.0023544512,
-0.013840924,
-0.042710714,
0.0521774553,
0.0018405094,
0.0534301549,
0.0024063138,
0.0129355201,
0.0114187095,
-0.012591375,
0.0162088573,
-0.0121203149,
0.0663318783,
-0.0288482774,
-0.007968233,
0.0450321436,
-0.080717504,
0.0207003485,
0.0314711481,
0.0118011683,
0.0328859799,
0.0000019233,
0.0060485918,
-0.0379727036,
-0.0209865514,
-0.0176679157,
-0.0404751971,
0.0044804262,
-0.0745592192,
0.0044523822,
-0.0105095357,
-0.0427642427,
-0.0604650415,
0.0458712019,
0.0061027496,
0.03046057,
0.0658007711,
-0.0097688185,
-0.0519244298,
0.0210885145,
-0.0145319849,
0.019472139,
-0.0504609831,
0.017309567,
-0.0480494648,
0.0110578341,
-0.0005309249,
0.0448414572,
0.0445092544,
-0.0064119934,
0.0548160747,
0.0141815459,
0.0122862505,
-0.0418120548,
-0.0129588088,
-0.036353752,
0.0613932796,
0.0304280128,
-0.0042717811,
0.0737039819,
-0.0157865267,
-0.0309055131,
0.0402076542,
-0.0333180204,
0.0003272221,
-0.0188314896,
0.0121772606,
-0.0480515733,
0.0410963371,
0.0056371344,
0.042498868,
0.0144319031,
0.041739136,
-0.0220693853,
-0.0140056051,
-0.0525597408,
0.0164056271,
-0.0248344857,
-0.0132533368,
0.017652953,
0.0157944635,
-0.047752481,
0.0161989201,
-0.0028795784,
-0.0367677733,
0.047065638,
-0.1168111116,
-0.019802535,
0.0269070603,
-0.0155955525,
0.0549884886,
0.0474925525,
-0.0392087698,
0.0174543876,
-0.029873345,
-0.0040750126,
-0.0074772793,
-0.0502259098,
0.0065140789,
0.008470431,
0.0182914082,
0.0300719664,
0.0654632896,
-0.0260894131,
-0.0157762859,
-0.0151443966,
-0.0227370616,
-0.0419920161,
0.0079959258,
-0.0569117479,
-0.0432063937,
-0.0319061168,
0.0287977625,
-0.0340521671,
0.0334659852,
-0.0046215155,
-0.0347059891,
0.008780418,
0.003128578,
0.0609920844,
0.0208766088,
-0.0237210263,
0.0052667065,
0.0084405877,
0.0066995379,
-0.042001389,
-0.0404046066,
-0.0163122285,
0.0073559005,
-0.0269137304,
-0.069421351,
0.0379814357,
0.0008767144,
-0.0276576895,
0.0013491878,
0.0260295495,
-0.0073788804,
-0.0429057591,
0.0349574052,
-0.0341712311,
0.034433037,
0.0428869464,
-0.0031942616,
0.0476443321,
0.0927519053,
0.0383565724,
0.0571691766,
0.0642816573,
0.0128259836,
-0.0064935125,
-0.0031777921,
0.0061061797,
0.026898697,
-0.0418283902,
0.0108508682,
0.0145627605,
0.0157095008,
-0.0067692259,
-0.0303899609,
0.0069925617,
0.0307139568,
0.0491747484,
0.0288484395,
-0.073114641,
-0.0080840522,
0.0398958698,
0.0359435827,
-0.0323678218,
-0.0654305443,
-0.0000919479,
-0.0035797271,
-0.0345737822,
-0.0209937263,
0.0508708581,
0.0285057798,
0.0150230033,
-0.0054480885,
-0.025721347,
0.0140507845,
-0.0103564775,
0.0005743747,
0.0345993787,
-0.0279598739,
0.0193830244,
0.057513468,
0.0374751948,
-0.017149305,
0.0171595681,
-0.0116318846,
-0.0196290966,
0.0398746729,
0.0138209574,
-0.0486796387,
-0.0150186578,
0.0081189526,
0.0856285393,
0.0138062658,
-0.0091596348,
0.0416283756,
0.0008223469,
-0.0123831239,
-0.0398739725,
0.0627177954,
0.0261297282,
-0.0424124897,
0.0407418348,
0.0512654856,
0.0138682276,
-0.0002150649,
-0.0690456703,
0.0134439738,
-0.0053936485,
-0.0160596445,
0.0043907436,
0.0294511132,
-0.0035811337,
-0.0071861097,
0.0414333269,
-0.0093124518,
0.0280405302,
-0.0076282118,
-0.0773297027,
0.0521081686,
-0.0257607512,
0.0298443288,
0.0076096361,
-0.0308522619,
0.0063010333,
-0.0180781875,
-0.0792320594,
-0.0136201158,
0.0301741622,
-0.0103276176,
-0.0346178748,
-0.0139965657,
-0.0057505732,
0.0085184518,
-0.0316605568,
-0.0147860795,
0.0623138286,
-0.0219894722,
-0.0018811062,
-0.0758716464,
-0.0544655025,
0.0008237123,
-0.0359136909,
-0.0366453379,
0.0156725962,
-0.0342000835,
0.0189501587,
0.0454980731,
-0.0388935357,
-0.0345483683,
-0.004019063,
-0.0725611746,
0.0426239111,
-0.0079924827,
0.0315757021,
0.0046927212,
0.027012378,
-0.029147191,
-0.0103841396,
-0.004652597,
0.0170371123,
-0.0157551132,
0.0196846779,
0.0289860498,
-0.0149718774,
0.073669605,
-0.0274925102,
-0.0075361431,
-0.0363346785,
0.0259737652,
0.0478268713,
-0.1025251672,
-0.0152242808,
-0.0356898047,
-0.0327242054,
0.0024783164,
0.0142411226,
-0.0711433738,
-0.0123044057,
-0.0174643863,
-0.0018862617,
-0.0522702038,
0.0265871789,
0.0480588004,
0.0084459651,
-0.0079900222,
0.0057640537,
0.0260317251,
-0.0932098404,
-0.0566386022,
0.0020651796,
-0.0310196634,
-0.0132514797,
0.0472255498,
0.0016287005,
0.0247142352,
-0.0078494316,
-0.0191570371,
-0.0272205677,
-0.0197630413,
-0.0195234474,
0.0088246195,
-0.0063990974,
0.0292114466,
-0.0245741941,
-0.025669083,
0.0145996679,
0.0641910583,
0.0485993847,
-0.0186231602,
0.0044052531,
-0.0648617968,
0.0221037101,
-0.0037560549,
0.0228661951,
0.0206971243,
0.021701647,
0.0038476624,
-0.0015500921,
0.0616012104,
-0.0442949682,
-0.0518581793,
-0.0494874418,
0.0124365389,
0.0289471652,
-0.0373788215,
-0.0064297272,
-0.0613907911,
-0.043228142,
-0.0293193143,
-0.0467944443,
-0.0203415509,
-0.0301170349,
0.0053272154,
0.0191275515,
0.0099165346,
0.0246732235,
-0.0170449205,
-0.0189489257,
0.0376563407,
0.0307334885,
0.024666585,
0.0034594871,
-0.0122862756,
0.0119474037,
0.0663257763,
0.0697773024,
0.0013835155,
-0.0142036267,
0.0108703496,
0.0361395255,
-0.0121903494,
0.0180952959,
0.0261344146,
0.0283610523,
-0.0402234569,
0.0329349078,
0.0749918446,
0.0382239558,
-0.0635304227,
0.0044027343,
-0.0092677874,
-0.0355433263,
0.0048360326,
-0.0235521607,
-0.0462312326,
-0.0359956659,
-0.0094863186,
0.0092759598,
-0.0034550291,
-0.0717092752,
0.0294418279,
-0.060848482,
0.0534606017,
-0.0056222454,
0.0084133083,
0.0201372895,
-0.0980283245,
0.0323371626,
-0.0321483873,
-0.0501771942,
-0.0157030597,
-0.0016214815,
0.0090524172,
0.0122575052,
-0.0490908585,
-0.0607058778,
-0.005536695,
-0.0915042311,
0.0443228595,
0.0191202797,
0.0758579597,
-0.0333822146,
-0.0292237122,
0.0077145873,
0.0528099947,
-0.0276657399,
0.0040506623,
0.0270952825,
0.0332485512,
-0.0125481645,
-0.0426297896,
0.0139921205,
-0.0294505619,
-0.0188408829,
0.0145428954,
0.0813781992,
-0.0108052865,
-0.0074989195,
-0.0584007129,
0.0251168348,
0.0631198138,
0.0428708866,
-0.0303053763,
-0.0210859161,
-0.0111885797,
-0.0028426314,
0.0007828745,
0.0006707827,
-0.0460556895,
0.0116948877,
-0.0542696454,
-0.1164389476,
-0.0678220913,
0.0028519023,
0.0103294831,
0.0072318716,
-0.0259453375,
-0.0112615628,
0.0850708634,
-0.0300917141,
-0.0726879388,
0.0345532708,
-0.0244380534,
0.0140973823,
-0.0274112169,
0.0412881672,
0.01369105,
0.0280185603,
-0.028272951,
0.0504285172,
-0.1156504378,
-0.0408451892,
0.0127134258,
-0.0100762229,
0.0173364356,
-0.023868857,
-0.0467366353,
-0.0331946015,
0.0162164122,
0.10132052,
-0.0802533925,
-0.0356962308,
-0.0095047997,
0.00815822,
0.0174404103,
0.0224690996,
-0.0105815567,
0.0488280207,
0.0133953849,
0.0122100906,
-0.0524098687,
-0.0105888117,
-0.0264582504,
0.0244114846,
0.1111541316,
0.0049098167,
-0.0787892193,
-0.0149983745,
-0.0243388619,
-0.0010694907,
-0.0323336907,
-0.010150725,
0.037804421,
0.020450633,
0.0290375538,
-0.0128353657,
0.0131143676,
0.0363058858,
-0.0155480821,
-0.0518819727,
-0.0046361154,
0.0409008376,
0.0363080502,
0.0104507701,
0.0140011692,
0.0354580469,
0.0249974243,
0.0144442357,
0.0014861231,
-0.0048008421,
-0.0138780372,
0.0245027244,
0.0140296128,
0.000038049,
-0.0050933622,
-0.0453651138,
-0.0604962483,
-0.0452992767,
0.0246031452,
0.017973939,
0.0467757285,
-0.0130765028,
-0.0110611003,
-0.0097682513,
-0.002785662,
0.0176380817,
-0.0021484143,
-0.0224814694,
0.01359782,
0.0080830418,
-0.0503165647,
0.0327131413,
0.0567905381,
0.0536621958,
0.0189432502,
0.0320410207,
-0.0482774377,
0.0199973993,
0.0059507368,
-0.011906202,
0.0344027877,
-0.0161974132,
0.0198266562,
-0.0679441318,
0.0003908804,
0.0569351502,
-0.0273503624,
-0.0498901904,
0.0148623241,
0.0001910688,
0.0388391055,
-0.0147735709,
0.0174288247,
-0.0340781175,
0.0140405055,
-0.0540150516,
-0.0256803837,
0.0230231006,
-6.354928907e-33,
0.0156138614,
-0.0659868792,
0.0041668331,
-0.0415999517,
0.0052114045,
0.0479555689,
-0.009714948,
-0.0045333272,
0.0372864008,
0.0108809741,
0.0126409531,
0.0175693352,
0.0187509023,
-0.0097642597,
0.0760741532,
0.0017783896,
0.0134320483,
0.0078645069,
-0.0104132704,
-0.0081900395,
0.056625288,
0.0037653751,
0.0473578312,
-0.0522327535,
0.0252455585,
0.0147740012,
-0.0253769159,
0.0156770889,
0.0602556169,
0.0164053068,
-0.0364482664,
0.032876879,
0.0109013561,
-0.0376093388,
-0.0317164399,
0.0159247536,
-0.0542235337,
-0.0234393664,
0.0093996972,
-0.0212231614,
-0.0072305286,
-0.0099154012,
0.0182214938,
0.0179800726,
-0.0022954377,
-0.0126847262,
0.0335090905,
0.0034298843,
0.0099285739,
-0.0216539409,
-0.0240400936,
0.0416399911,
-0.0305299256,
0.0310541596,
0.0101750288,
0.0227203891,
-0.0009758432,
0.0618567094,
-0.0669348985,
-0.0053670779,
-0.0375124291,
0.0094342157,
0.0234919507,
-0.0249777585,
-0.023876844,
0.0697757527,
0.0068456088,
0.002791482,
-0.0439264998,
-0.0298580695,
0.0059725982,
0.0531762317,
0.0313313343,
0.1568691283,
0.0938296765,
-0.0561065935,
-0.0825317651,
0.0505973771,
0.0012908347,
0.0448114313,
0.0264752377,
0.0073048039,
-0.0462835692,
0.0117048901,
0.0033032857,
0.0055373525,
-0.0423093475,
0.0500154346,
-0.0241826102,
0.0227952357,
-0.0246900134,
0.0766665339,
-0.0130951311,
0.0122031476,
0.0010834294,
-0.0011746518,
0.0141640538,
0.0210971218,
0.0042437422,
0.0406650901,
-0.0492138639,
0.0122259734,
-0.0123936022,
0.0119755957,
0.0013658002,
-0.0034070993,
0.0018196,
0.0202378593,
-0.0124461828,
0.0047804764,
-0.0256248526,
-0.0142957103,
-0.028316997,
-0.0533206798,
0.048799634,
0.0137716103,
-0.0001935697,
-0.0460987389,
0.0659763291,
0.018789161,
0.028136244,
-0.0125449868,
-0.0619108453,
-0.0044916463,
0.0207449105,
-0.0141281886,
-0.0089969076,
-0.0340889953,
-0.0303683486,
-0.0467544682,
-0.0164499842,
0.0009394075,
2.828e-7,
0.0220149402,
0.0695852563,
0.0026606233,
-0.0015793901,
0.0073006162,
0.038781926,
0.0336851403,
0.044381015,
0.0155718271,
0.0067531206,
0.0251016933,
0.0378894806,
0.0712939128,
0.0543213114,
-0.0986040607,
0.0358261913,
-0.069971703,
0.010248444,
-0.0884207189,
-0.0216077585,
0.0411140025,
0.0144746471,
0.0526079945,
-0.0002370863,
-0.0065545058,
-0.0206919461,
0.0284713916,
-0.0534196459,
-0.0311808474,
0.0141015062,
0.055480022,
0.0302193481,
-0.0201856755,
-0.0163263753,
-0.0354920849,
-0.025054602,
0.0823800117,
0.0174743999,
-0.0094072102,
0.0136892125,
-0.0345121175,
-0.0649438724,
0.0152609171,
-0.0431313291,
0.0558680817,
-0.029201759,
-0.0336502194,
-0.035447944,
-0.0485189222,
0.0284573305,
0.0253842026,
-0.0151788481,
-0.0454526022,
0.0056282911,
0.0007990275,
0.0030854593,
-0.0333743952,
-0.0322612673,
0.0195844863,
0.0415285155,
0.005030347,
-0.0442943871,
-0.0429547057,
0.0070899329,
0.011966926,
-0.050213974,
0.0611566231,
1.980844816e-34,
0.0076012965,
0.040359851,
-0.0548746139,
-0.0343387648,
0.03194049,
0.0159756523,
-0.0258994382,
0.0048862412,
0.0220042896,
-0.038396515,
0.0386180207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02051v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02051v2 | TimeChat: A Time-sensitive Multimodal Large Language Model for Long Video Understanding | 2023-12-04T17:09:52 | 2024-03-28T12:41:14 | Shuhuai Ren, Linli Yao, Shicheng Li, Xu Sun, Lu Hou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | This work proposes TimeChat, a time-sensitive multimodal large language model
specifically designed for long video understanding. Our model incorporates two
key architectural contributions: (1) a timestamp-aware frame encoder that binds
visual content with the timestamp of each frame, and (2) a sliding video
Q-Former that produces a video token sequence of varying lengths to accommodate
videos of various durations. Additionally, we construct an instruction-tuning
dataset, encompassing 6 tasks and a total of 125K instances, to further enhance
TimeChat's instruction-following performance. Experiment results across various
video understanding tasks, such as dense captioning, temporal grounding, and
highlight detection, demonstrate TimeChat's strong zero-shot temporal
localization and reasoning capabilities. For example, it achieves +9.2 F1 score
and +2.8 CIDEr on YouCook2, +5.8 HIT@1 on QVHighlights, and +27.5 R@1 (IoU=0.5)
on Charades-STA, compared to state-of-the-art video large language models,
holding the potential to serve as a versatile video assistant for long-form
video comprehension tasks and satisfy realistic user requirements. | [
0.0248641707,
0.0350689888,
-0.0012840786,
0.0398809239,
-0.0186441764,
0.0021261403,
0.0393769853,
0.0016774462,
-0.0160150956,
-0.0663467646,
0.0060141897,
-0.0511636846,
-0.0029298535,
0.0726587772,
-0.0145351887,
-0.0572223812,
0.0514424294,
-0.0193828586,
-0.0047931811,
0.0291073881,
0.0426675789,
-0.0140659846,
-0.0291947983,
0.0549867935,
-0.0167865846,
-0.0384405628,
-0.0483404659,
-0.0194704514,
0.0327472761,
-0.02615867,
-0.0309858546,
0.0551874787,
0.0672395304,
0.0325502157,
0.0000018143,
0.0193837341,
-0.0000417189,
-0.0413291864,
-0.0402439125,
0.0385943837,
0.0097230887,
-0.0242721289,
-0.0028762801,
0.0176189356,
-0.028263798,
0.0003653682,
0.0425888821,
-0.0378570184,
0.0655944273,
0.0426130071,
-0.0278096087,
-0.0201336797,
0.0222048499,
-0.0154849896,
0.0670214891,
-0.0688919872,
-0.0328707546,
0.0254078135,
0.0417285226,
-0.0004311248,
-0.0653914735,
0.0484414734,
0.0461397842,
-0.050507579,
0.0085951462,
0.0302972998,
-0.035817042,
-0.0211363193,
-0.0414846428,
0.0661285296,
-0.0013217855,
0.0306098349,
-0.0213217959,
0.0501643606,
-0.0052423198,
-0.0339343548,
-0.0698092058,
-0.0008861884,
0.0136992494,
-0.0200502127,
-0.0329991803,
0.0094313947,
-0.0074677919,
-0.0156339649,
0.0217149407,
0.0013739932,
0.0185003299,
0.0174651258,
-0.0861464143,
-0.0224991105,
-0.0251613799,
-0.0731880888,
0.0309440419,
0.0716923773,
-0.0281560961,
0.0014662358,
-0.0177706219,
0.0186808202,
-0.041829817,
-0.0331514068,
0.0097943973,
0.0627685338,
-0.0303279925,
0.0777104497,
-0.0129694045,
0.0831703693,
-0.0097565241,
-0.0097833443,
-0.0293594413,
-0.0087976959,
-0.0617185794,
-0.0201700609,
-0.0186297167,
-0.0180519819,
-0.0456672534,
-0.0431691781,
-0.0182686299,
0.0360935368,
-0.0098139914,
0.0264155641,
-0.0582354665,
0.0227831118,
0.006267454,
-0.0018845289,
0.0026814374,
0.0715695098,
-0.0499807894,
0.0232842136,
-0.0057811886,
-0.0617309399,
-0.0353987291,
0.0316652395,
0.0081926007,
-0.0226822123,
0.0064764936,
0.0480180718,
-0.0585053638,
-0.0532743782,
0.003229667,
-0.0035286448,
-0.0346147604,
-0.0152698569,
0.0263335258,
-0.043577455,
0.0494112559,
-0.0000763902,
-0.0041703521,
0.0019347005,
-0.003189075,
0.0244331509,
0.004195103,
0.0966605693,
0.017916983,
0.0248810705,
0.0142515171,
0.0238639042,
-0.0082127228,
0.0393146873,
0.0308818407,
0.024482511,
0.0309165828,
0.0003699703,
0.0237530954,
0.030806765,
-0.023050325,
0.0069716293,
-0.0870775506,
0.0120545123,
0.0170440339,
0.0494666919,
0.0432469994,
0.0170553159,
-0.0262939297,
-0.0583991706,
0.0604118332,
0.0444254279,
-0.0521892831,
-0.0440640338,
0.0499138907,
0.0313198268,
-0.0029707518,
-0.0145500107,
-0.0540695786,
0.1027188152,
0.0042093927,
-0.0175525397,
-0.0108232051,
0.0138636902,
-0.0652646273,
-0.0373278372,
-0.018263476,
-0.0012302754,
0.0223842021,
0.02827622,
0.0299327038,
-0.0156354271,
-0.0602302179,
0.045798175,
-0.0080177961,
0.008767115,
0.0048869941,
-0.0298339482,
0.0374914706,
0.1095377058,
0.0064442777,
-0.002293274,
-0.0585703738,
-0.0083946036,
0.0546008348,
0.0383920595,
0.0026805887,
-0.0257089958,
0.0306287277,
-0.0497510694,
-0.024832312,
-0.0212788936,
0.0027253763,
0.052271843,
0.0090555102,
0.0442369878,
-0.0040137502,
0.0026468083,
0.0403837822,
0.0224045832,
0.0444851071,
-0.0110101467,
-0.0389217921,
-0.0091798957,
0.0193564929,
0.012404304,
-0.0145847006,
-0.0133590251,
0.0134275332,
-0.0319350474,
0.0220725313,
0.0400992148,
-0.0830335021,
-0.0603421032,
0.0529457591,
-0.0192987621,
-0.0272703022,
0.0461087562,
-0.0319157504,
-0.016242981,
0.0476023741,
-0.0209271591,
0.0199451968,
-0.0333259515,
0.0057585803,
0.025080625,
0.0044346768,
0.0034378543,
0.033592429,
-0.0146357408,
-0.0114134634,
0.0144956438,
0.0221065525,
0.0049586464,
-0.0384488516,
0.0032497393,
-0.0002069963,
-0.0080784587,
-0.0389983878,
0.0011572762,
0.0063897218,
-0.0531473197,
-0.0081713544,
-0.1170144826,
0.0242169555,
-0.025888091,
-0.0055246474,
-0.0034022655,
0.0048944824,
-0.0008945792,
-0.0480857901,
0.0006037682,
-0.0067039472,
-0.0069706789,
0.0286390539,
-0.0031115899,
0.0165020693,
-0.0364231654,
-0.0207763854,
-0.0266992655,
0.0005784616,
0.0480247885,
-0.0130324718,
-0.0235228203,
-0.0004064907,
-0.0349752717,
-0.0048991772,
0.0330308527,
-0.0322383344,
-0.0397460125,
0.0171337593,
0.0206649248,
0.0206463058,
0.1033938006,
0.0182848703,
0.0477000251,
-0.0099002058,
-0.0433004424,
-0.0167430229,
0.0460062847,
0.0116191339,
-0.0327306464,
-0.0255828705,
0.006167111,
-0.0629280806,
0.0508583784,
-0.0377139971,
0.0477899909,
-0.08722651,
0.0044844309,
-0.0072029508,
-0.0131702591,
-0.035277307,
0.0031452996,
-0.0144500313,
0.0006104267,
-0.0611610673,
-0.0438117795,
0.033816155,
-0.0253569037,
-0.0372610129,
0.0169599913,
-0.0147979772,
-0.0088229096,
0.1170420498,
0.0275235698,
0.0094977049,
-0.0652520284,
-0.0396524519,
-0.0413024835,
0.0017983781,
0.0002371312,
-0.0071031768,
0.0317517631,
-0.0507960096,
-0.0032168482,
-0.011858358,
0.0095508182,
-0.0235805698,
-0.0144654131,
-0.0402060971,
-0.0180012714,
-0.0590278395,
-0.0078398129,
-0.0255175717,
0.0364923254,
-0.0024057606,
0.0271024909,
-0.0129781868,
0.0145587893,
-0.0196599066,
0.014481036,
0.0655309781,
0.0164475702,
-0.0426159054,
-0.0400437005,
0.0774470717,
0.0558628887,
0.0347414389,
-0.0248739757,
-0.0338534117,
0.0547238439,
0.010761546,
0.0020128805,
-0.0261208508,
0.0176501349,
0.0773257911,
-0.0744165778,
-0.0073972461,
0.1171944812,
0.0219914857,
-0.0606689751,
-0.0084335133,
-0.0063613798,
-0.0021000598,
0.0376527496,
0.0031527593,
-0.0948765129,
-0.0722620711,
0.011279624,
-0.0225160774,
0.0243612677,
0.0008459942,
-0.0356652737,
-0.0659641623,
0.0310130063,
0.0067764167,
-0.048105333,
-0.0165388621,
0.0112192826,
-0.0043560881,
-0.0119398879,
0.0652797371,
0.0098776584,
0.0028679094,
0.0097023128,
0.0247105975,
0.0007704432,
-0.0241701771,
0.0932539925,
-0.0184939727,
0.0420267433,
0.0244925208,
0.0305964276,
0.0181966368,
-0.045447737,
-0.0145705137,
0.0056961258,
0.0015015652,
0.0073528006,
0.0440318696,
-0.0526227467,
-0.0222171266,
-0.0023118663,
0.0298582576,
0.0014521095,
-0.0310493726,
0.0125909988,
0.059774816,
-0.007179053,
0.0326373912,
-0.0220774487,
-0.0171382222,
-0.0104269516,
0.0589077547,
-0.0073267999,
-0.0465079471,
-0.0299873929,
0.0198985748,
-0.0566896833,
-0.0662281737,
-0.0191359278,
-0.0019978043,
0.0309005827,
-0.0044143931,
-0.0115487417,
-0.0254012048,
0.0557227954,
0.0239713527,
-0.0347768441,
0.0221006311,
-0.0041197506,
0.0511007197,
-0.0774486661,
0.064766854,
0.006122896,
0.0090449005,
-0.0629717782,
0.0009516806,
0.0304471906,
-0.001547042,
0.0033774446,
0.045919098,
-0.0506456941,
-0.0303754155,
-0.0130674457,
0.0256427005,
0.0200541224,
0.0722882971,
-0.0054044556,
0.0050585177,
-0.008699609,
-0.0102941692,
-0.0317023657,
0.0087919747,
-0.012253819,
-0.0142798545,
-0.0118895611,
0.0387342498,
-0.046636913,
0.0222722981,
-0.036299862,
0.0194054767,
-0.0508605652,
0.0202269889,
0.0154027762,
-0.0529271364,
0.0401175953,
0.0039267433,
0.0014454928,
0.0136773996,
0.0101749292,
-0.0295226015,
0.0433446132,
-0.0770066231,
-0.0053020166,
0.023973085,
-0.021938825,
0.0056190803,
0.0079025012,
0.0178195368,
-0.0269919727,
-0.0254242979,
0.0226070639,
-0.0238590278,
-0.0374789052,
0.0105726197,
0.0178074781,
0.0268944092,
-0.0017782793,
-0.0101522645,
0.0356838293,
0.0063600061,
0.069736883,
0.0087371375,
-0.0123548461,
0.0024551176,
0.0397033021,
-0.0355426408,
-0.025207093,
0.0123522533,
0.0338921137,
0.0522166826,
-0.0341752917,
0.0007162627,
0.0192175265,
-0.0108589614,
-0.009088181,
0.064578101,
-0.0074823559,
-0.0917188302,
0.0403927267,
0.0301648621,
-0.010006018,
0.0115015237,
0.0640580058,
0.0157312304,
0.035389863,
0.0360910818,
-0.0203275308,
-0.0018875219,
-0.0018318847,
0.0108187543,
-0.0101873139,
-0.0148251383,
0.0322849005,
-0.0190324243,
-0.0644296408,
-0.0170514137,
-0.0039494396,
0.0008555399,
0.0412372462,
0.0311570931,
0.0375347175,
0.0012512128,
-0.0738405362,
-0.0220518578,
-0.0059880833,
-0.0029507824,
-0.0295250155,
0.0104870787,
-5.791467812e-33,
-0.0387163833,
-0.0304014981,
0.037949264,
-0.0044620396,
-0.0148409419,
0.030630257,
-0.0268054083,
0.0245421901,
-0.0234028045,
0.0142245572,
0.0067495862,
0.0502577722,
0.0196938217,
0.0361684859,
0.0126660634,
-0.0403855108,
0.0219995622,
-0.0378616825,
-0.0011092544,
0.0115441801,
0.0255572777,
0.00858586,
0.0372142792,
-0.0130917449,
-0.0366136655,
0.0185898598,
0.0016141585,
0.0434060097,
0.0240907818,
0.0699892119,
-0.0352646597,
-0.0016928359,
0.0122965733,
-0.0416404381,
-0.0091935517,
0.0243313238,
-0.0856569931,
0.002769073,
-0.0020573293,
0.0743473321,
-0.0660160631,
-0.0229153875,
0.0151620917,
0.0034911684,
-0.0220535416,
-0.0572599433,
0.0222086627,
-0.0014342727,
0.0069509363,
0.0109186582,
-0.0393567234,
0.0213527866,
-0.0316100456,
-0.0861656889,
0.0330409594,
0.0257565919,
0.0470114164,
-0.041571606,
-0.0482029058,
-0.0258283447,
-0.0501259156,
0.0293914154,
0.0859152302,
0.0129872821,
0.024435902,
0.0455954298,
0.0139279123,
-0.03603293,
-0.0296885632,
0.015176733,
0.006330804,
0.030804174,
0.0271482803,
-0.0252682362,
0.0385864042,
-0.0143726878,
-0.0529926866,
0.0113997376,
0.0033075858,
0.069045946,
0.0215504207,
0.0398664214,
-0.0018863209,
0.0287474636,
-0.0072557926,
0.0403806455,
-0.0101431459,
-0.0341552086,
0.0527036265,
0.0262732748,
0.0093819071,
-0.0266605169,
0.1038621515,
-0.0206303447,
0.0379912779,
0.0114026032,
-0.0307053067,
0.0566338859,
0.0317276977,
0.0549566932,
-0.0301156677,
0.0203424506,
0.0295426007,
-0.0316749364,
0.0008639803,
-0.0055628344,
0.0062167728,
0.0680445507,
-0.0117968675,
-0.0099715237,
-0.029250782,
0.0386190675,
-0.0054945564,
0.0252876766,
0.0448719263,
0.030067265,
-0.0573300794,
0.0608749427,
-0.0401877798,
0.0007640423,
-0.0175409745,
-0.0418869592,
-0.0082163559,
0.0124801788,
-0.0499010161,
-0.0144656627,
-0.0671990663,
-0.0264579896,
-0.0196797717,
-0.0650171712,
-0.0207902882,
0.0211191364,
2.634e-7,
-0.0250344742,
0.0330845267,
0.0245199986,
0.021281762,
0.0212745685,
0.0238056853,
0.0051554027,
0.0353886448,
0.0041615712,
-0.0495816693,
0.0193112399,
0.0834941715,
0.0199171416,
-0.0184765104,
-0.0557256415,
-0.0356944986,
-0.0256604794,
-0.0121849133,
-0.0441660434,
0.0093429293,
0.0297927838,
0.1199702024,
0.0117627652,
0.0170340724,
0.04720065,
-0.0680553839,
0.0502308235,
0.006128266,
-0.0301949047,
0.0064169611,
0.0263583194,
0.0112767704,
-0.0420187153,
0.0009564335,
0.0043142433,
-0.0211745445,
0.0128787858,
0.0381117389,
-0.0569622666,
-0.0568441525,
-0.0560051613,
0.0075219111,
-0.0357437208,
-0.0234346259,
0.0831570029,
-0.0085422648,
-0.0398085602,
-0.0256311316,
-0.0316493101,
0.001790512,
-0.0081511671,
0.0431307778,
-0.0051896046,
0.0151327094,
0.0161961541,
-0.0171451773,
-0.0249415562,
-0.1202444732,
0.0046139332,
0.0101951528,
-0.0428301618,
0.0206873938,
-0.0652840286,
-0.0174757484,
0.0414986536,
-0.0326108076,
-0.0681804046,
1.911185296e-34,
0.0090454286,
-0.0157737676,
0.010924208,
0.011940876,
0.0323885567,
0.0022193375,
-0.0299925599,
0.0060516209,
0.0342942439,
-0.0404801182,
-0.0223195665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01957v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01957v3 | Distilled Self-Critique of LLMs with Synthetic Data: a Bayesian Perspective | 2023-12-04T15:16:12 | 2024-04-11T10:54:19 | Victor Gallego | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper proposes an interpretation of RLAIF as Bayesian inference by
introducing distilled Self-Critique (dSC), which refines the outputs of a LLM
through a Gibbs sampler that is later distilled into a fine-tuned model. Only
requiring synthetic data, dSC is exercised in experiments regarding safety,
sentiment, and privacy control, showing it can be a viable and cheap
alternative to align LLMs. Code released at
\url{https://github.com/vicgalle/distilled-self-critique}. | [
-0.0071208095,
0.0616596267,
0.0032339543,
-0.0004491518,
-0.02804479,
0.0100754388,
0.0066342694,
0.0213588849,
0.019544214,
-0.0334852152,
-0.0131176375,
0.0528524742,
-0.0327611081,
-0.0116454531,
0.0149940588,
0.0125154173,
0.0213402454,
-0.032088872,
0.0249575246,
-0.0074832896,
-0.0088099409,
-0.0341513678,
-0.0164819621,
-0.0249269661,
0.0397348553,
0.0013064627,
-0.0048496518,
0.0353858173,
0.0559812449,
-0.0442613922,
-0.0159339849,
0.0393724851,
0.0216464084,
0.0100148795,
0.0000019592,
-0.0630447343,
-0.0361382216,
0.0377527624,
-0.0293298662,
-0.0117730657,
0.0807122141,
0.0535543002,
-0.0018115223,
0.0163778048,
-0.0376076438,
0.0334478468,
0.0176247824,
0.024336312,
0.0347429849,
0.097836867,
0.0100940391,
-0.0399281159,
-0.0074820421,
-0.0135607617,
0.0531840138,
-0.0112600885,
0.0161309224,
0.0260284543,
0.0199281331,
-0.0186817721,
-0.0041279593,
0.0095824888,
-0.0032251729,
0.0134984758,
0.0283724647,
-0.0200139638,
0.0407799259,
0.0004048508,
-0.0303346552,
0.0314031094,
0.0709702075,
-0.0122937784,
0.0308110621,
-0.021283878,
0.0452945419,
0.0658776164,
-0.0610051751,
0.0069282483,
-0.0480650924,
0.058326304,
0.0347384848,
-0.0166281816,
0.0586378947,
-0.0309321936,
0.002437636,
0.1136688516,
-0.0113014802,
-0.0751712546,
0.004277132,
0.0329277329,
0.0560076311,
-0.0184863061,
-0.0421509407,
-0.0117932763,
0.0243928786,
0.0102104861,
0.0189115237,
0.0100620817,
0.0419868901,
-0.0425397605,
0.0443566106,
0.0098858932,
0.0265724715,
-0.001039432,
0.0115359221,
-0.0024130682,
-0.0131718414,
0.0461563021,
-0.0188821815,
0.0778692663,
-0.0315197036,
0.0300391633,
0.0559960492,
0.0410850048,
-0.0185353067,
0.049135495,
-0.052756086,
0.0159367193,
-0.0279223658,
0.007234944,
0.0223506596,
-0.0135263978,
0.0103431027,
0.0355327018,
-0.1002996862,
-0.0254531689,
-0.019040525,
0.009856523,
0.0058691176,
-0.0385543555,
0.0003373677,
-0.0117433034,
0.0047674002,
0.0088484585,
0.0213237088,
0.1004659235,
0.0533088185,
-0.0039615622,
-0.0780850127,
-0.0264601,
-0.031290032,
-0.0280116256,
0.0329192318,
-0.0670729429,
0.0085686082,
-0.0234567057,
0.0073701926,
-0.0628523529,
-0.0162411351,
-0.0275486428,
-0.0252734181,
0.057183601,
-0.0791504383,
-0.0059347497,
-0.0219691321,
0.0117634078,
0.0312351845,
0.0890461504,
0.0234006345,
0.0079684779,
0.0125260642,
-0.0064708404,
0.031682767,
-0.0142007424,
-0.0076712719,
0.0428171009,
-0.0733885393,
-0.0074166902,
-0.0514187217,
0.0021302686,
0.0412417054,
-0.0207496751,
-0.0186440405,
0.019465737,
0.0325348303,
0.0216388162,
0.0308519881,
0.0252318904,
-0.0111430567,
-0.0220121853,
0.0215626247,
0.0354359709,
-0.0252750274,
0.0249876603,
-0.0656754375,
0.0440294333,
0.0436005145,
-0.0240230169,
-0.0349591263,
-0.0807557926,
-0.0177186597,
0.0038682176,
-0.02703996,
0.0291369073,
0.0331785344,
-0.0083171576,
0.0055553596,
-0.0143186105,
0.0723339543,
-0.0443532467,
-0.0308704637,
-0.0674612746,
0.0627353191,
0.0827559307,
0.0336644165,
-0.0397720747,
-0.035657797,
-0.0479386933,
-0.0385246351,
0.0256237444,
0.0339746326,
0.0269275028,
-0.0134441843,
-0.0010595759,
-0.0477440283,
-0.0549852997,
0.0125156324,
0.0114589464,
-0.0342271738,
-0.0102966446,
-0.0346450433,
-0.041597899,
-0.0254459884,
0.0340865068,
-0.0110524138,
-0.0032525065,
-0.0027397578,
-0.040349938,
0.0826349184,
0.0297142956,
-0.035401471,
0.0222875774,
0.0338559188,
0.0054168371,
-0.0090493094,
-0.0010332238,
0.0377458781,
-0.0598172173,
0.010216821,
-0.0681367666,
-0.0200964902,
-0.0130073456,
-0.0612290986,
-0.0001453553,
-0.0024849912,
0.0206254832,
0.0028548534,
-0.0311110001,
0.0136678955,
-0.0282453801,
-0.0217086114,
-0.0248914715,
0.0101027638,
-0.0169005021,
0.001558864,
-0.0556943752,
-0.0054853559,
-0.0178269763,
-0.0471233688,
0.0188270267,
-0.0562387332,
-0.0051074191,
0.0114195608,
0.0128009608,
0.0175237488,
-0.0410661474,
-0.0316139646,
-0.0146248043,
0.0150092011,
0.0023361477,
0.0213469714,
0.0139016155,
-0.0328340232,
-0.0357646905,
0.0310822874,
-0.0304210111,
-0.0239423681,
0.0409412645,
0.0244597066,
0.0584839396,
-0.0245817285,
-0.0352046452,
-0.0277884323,
-0.0115341367,
-0.0237718429,
0.0099605285,
0.0397501215,
-0.011324821,
-0.0551153347,
0.0737122893,
-0.0422897749,
-0.0105788996,
-0.0125544425,
-0.0177886095,
0.0041304673,
-0.0170208123,
0.0153139038,
0.0419274233,
-0.0074913981,
0.0269950759,
0.0381287336,
0.0284545776,
-0.0591994599,
0.0082844794,
-0.065315716,
-0.0171769802,
-0.0514133424,
-0.0350825377,
0.016389126,
0.053074766,
-0.0086234724,
0.0046303724,
-0.011182881,
0.042871099,
0.0136426473,
-0.0867608339,
0.0215927772,
0.0194151197,
-0.0251357686,
0.0593770221,
0.0212953538,
-0.1043979228,
0.0674590394,
0.0071588452,
0.0324457362,
-0.0052523878,
-0.0311169643,
-0.0169058535,
-0.0213659517,
-0.02647724,
-0.011135567,
0.009920069,
0.0488218553,
0.0095929904,
-0.0312416777,
0.039632339,
-0.0350969471,
0.0589287393,
-0.039908655,
0.007543412,
0.0221438706,
-0.0363376625,
-0.0268714633,
-0.0383048616,
-0.0499284081,
-0.0424450263,
-0.0346868858,
-0.0073229321,
0.0260677915,
-0.0089745801,
0.0039383452,
-0.0338897035,
-0.0205556061,
-0.0290279668,
-0.000837381,
-0.0513546653,
0.0273750462,
-0.0354234464,
0.0646749809,
-0.0689796433,
0.0128401686,
0.0306641106,
0.0274155121,
0.0282287858,
-0.0264346413,
-0.0016679339,
-0.0013839961,
0.0123187378,
0.027843982,
0.0485275611,
-0.004513205,
0.0218593441,
-0.008091691,
0.0795869976,
-0.0166059583,
-0.0353006423,
-0.0154159358,
-0.0382800251,
0.0362010226,
0.0053743548,
-0.010715072,
-0.0517657064,
0.005257979,
0.0205809344,
0.0699055865,
-0.0451145247,
-0.0364705138,
0.0408526622,
-0.0921435133,
0.0580084957,
0.0144193769,
-0.0284779258,
-0.014973945,
-0.0843935236,
-0.0168036483,
-0.0406542458,
-0.0019653812,
0.0154094864,
-0.0154941073,
-0.0098993629,
0.0264445618,
-0.0666696802,
-0.0479959026,
-0.0372623391,
-0.0493506379,
0.0608835481,
0.0222852472,
0.0016263189,
-0.0171768311,
-0.024218468,
0.0265795961,
0.0350013897,
0.0082771033,
-0.0118415849,
0.0434880666,
-0.0002601382,
0.0060426206,
-0.0579257496,
0.010976498,
-0.0404282734,
0.0024112435,
-0.0043315971,
0.0228560716,
-0.0408857651,
-0.0445005409,
-0.0191297792,
0.0332306847,
-0.0198656116,
0.0737210289,
0.0270152204,
-0.0333774127,
-0.0072356504,
-0.0323175341,
-0.0313853137,
-0.010568155,
-0.0312689282,
0.044840306,
-0.0473802127,
-0.0231590606,
-0.0119060138,
-0.0089095132,
-0.0532067642,
0.0362270437,
-0.0141575178,
0.0131617375,
-0.0273647383,
-0.0130143883,
-0.033803869,
0.0082037933,
-0.0429295748,
-0.0377170518,
-0.0097820349,
0.0200087614,
0.0379102938,
-0.0313400365,
-0.0004347606,
0.0005546256,
-0.0750911459,
-0.068216525,
0.0143451951,
0.1152821928,
0.0373857878,
0.0362273231,
0.001452815,
-0.0107082287,
0.0540958866,
0.0702449083,
0.0184876304,
0.0366353393,
0.0179602485,
0.0743507892,
0.0163610205,
-0.0289500561,
-0.024178138,
-0.0162965376,
0.0643604919,
0.0147729199,
-0.0388293378,
-0.0484572202,
0.0162177961,
0.0321024433,
0.0566112734,
-0.0203509256,
-0.0041801864,
-0.0216990747,
0.0010458453,
-0.0139046991,
0.0059991023,
-0.0206259005,
-0.0079662977,
0.0284233037,
-0.0238691457,
-0.0141516179,
0.0247687846,
-0.0503372811,
0.036104016,
-0.022085486,
0.0587805733,
0.0386820547,
-0.0072693853,
0.0284863319,
0.0037705088,
0.0160194226,
0.0191430356,
0.0421824828,
0.0039163241,
0.0625580773,
0.0371691361,
0.013779968,
0.0220646188,
0.0028357785,
-0.0009093437,
-0.0770841241,
-0.0456206053,
-0.02587137,
0.0370686986,
0.0125521943,
0.058505103,
0.0695964694,
-0.008546426,
-0.0044841911,
-0.0195299946,
0.0502308272,
-0.0270672198,
0.0434965752,
0.0461611077,
0.0201504808,
-0.0506119356,
-0.0663064048,
0.0118620843,
0.0238550156,
0.0314966999,
-0.0336276926,
-0.0021818404,
-0.0471044071,
-0.0603219718,
-0.0076032644,
-0.0416374765,
0.0257940385,
-0.0877800658,
-0.0860828087,
-0.0650686696,
0.0213218611,
0.0186669379,
0.0280798972,
-0.0014239547,
-0.015404366,
0.0210410114,
-0.0321811363,
0.0381754711,
-0.0158549864,
-0.0008032442,
-0.0054950598,
-0.0457746834,
-0.0008969868,
-6.191582946e-33,
0.0001389866,
-0.0533362143,
-0.015540719,
-0.0046622506,
-0.0272508524,
-0.0635097027,
-0.0131087257,
0.025384333,
0.0520285405,
0.0321123526,
-0.0237387922,
0.0240607597,
0.0276787784,
-0.0047809859,
0.0302789751,
-0.0712671131,
0.0153435515,
-0.024070425,
0.0053234412,
-0.0336330086,
-0.0001792992,
0.025883399,
0.0131973987,
-0.0407683775,
0.0409124121,
-0.0043201819,
-0.0258303974,
0.0046273451,
-0.0042276364,
0.063561067,
0.0349646099,
0.0065384638,
0.0251416434,
-0.0017712034,
-0.0040711798,
0.0082939118,
-0.0091604274,
-0.017919464,
0.0048803454,
-0.0483486839,
-0.0102941701,
-0.0352940522,
0.0413589515,
0.0328653194,
-0.0802474767,
0.0239216499,
0.0313855298,
-0.0343129709,
0.011880381,
-0.0930971429,
-0.0025682799,
0.0216054413,
-0.0110143824,
0.0316490866,
0.0343140401,
0.0096751247,
0.009128402,
0.0133677283,
0.0180824772,
0.0352404788,
0.0413729399,
-0.0432095863,
0.0827896446,
0.0381910764,
0.038529627,
0.0453861356,
0.025572598,
0.0329073407,
-0.0328293853,
0.0042722179,
-0.0093241958,
0.0566373691,
0.0056361859,
0.0892849565,
-0.0033325015,
-0.0058615385,
-0.0794409439,
0.0437211394,
0.0039745388,
-0.0296883676,
0.0198013093,
0.0356185399,
-0.024191469,
-0.0029452443,
-0.0321291015,
-0.0356289893,
-0.0094912378,
-0.0113455262,
0.0199573264,
-0.0074527538,
-0.0332644023,
-0.0797936097,
0.0010604972,
-0.0366112106,
-0.008499044,
-0.056399703,
0.0069214464,
-0.0097518004,
0.006421905,
-0.0319165587,
-0.0292352643,
-0.0237469524,
-0.0569973625,
0.0210710447,
0.0183318183,
-0.0029133805,
-0.0125496276,
-0.0152536044,
-0.0642002225,
0.0311814025,
-0.0226079784,
0.0416167565,
0.055170279,
-0.0351166241,
0.0253055543,
-0.024547901,
0.0125263846,
0.0667811185,
0.0136976074,
0.0226797424,
-0.0005391046,
0.0882986858,
-0.0412059203,
0.0235018097,
0.0177553259,
-0.0055912351,
0.0465148464,
0.0153763928,
0.0548158027,
-0.0468165837,
-0.0096119037,
0.0003692356,
2.683e-7,
0.0451656841,
0.007002675,
0.0202560201,
0.0401673727,
0.0392921008,
0.0318205394,
-0.0226783585,
0.0298779495,
0.0325200371,
-0.0517248847,
0.0492214039,
0.0349288173,
0.0376323834,
0.0280629601,
-0.0552946366,
-0.0288020484,
-0.0312513113,
-0.0022024298,
0.0191179309,
0.0108096525,
-0.0037522265,
0.001822972,
0.0182942208,
-0.0196985975,
-0.0031880783,
0.009883536,
0.0483219028,
-0.096977368,
-0.0034150963,
0.071989812,
0.0179325454,
-0.0281377584,
-0.0095277568,
-0.0199811663,
0.0158169083,
-0.0321873687,
-0.038051229,
0.0885009021,
0.0361381471,
-0.0467811488,
0.0119529376,
-0.0347605236,
0.0361873545,
0.0026275686,
0.044138331,
-0.0271166302,
-0.0181296188,
-0.0220855586,
-0.0601442717,
-0.0454697125,
0.0542077459,
-0.0152135855,
0.0276238266,
0.0229224972,
-0.0088989846,
0.0331407301,
-0.0190432202,
-0.0084582986,
-0.0204835385,
-0.0102539146,
-0.0360828266,
-0.0855848789,
0.0182160623,
0.0448814221,
0.0169957131,
-0.0688780844,
-0.0163931772,
2.364487831e-34,
0.0597411096,
-0.030584516,
-0.0076661427,
0.0190622695,
0.0009282036,
0.0209298562,
-0.0295984093,
-0.0006010574,
0.0401510522,
-0.0641134828,
0.0103819808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01954v1 | Zero- and Few-Shots Knowledge Graph Triplet Extraction with Large Language Models | 2023-12-04T15:12:04 | 2023-12-04T15:12:04 | Andrea Papaluca, Daniel Krefl, Sergio Mendez Rodriguez, Artem Lensky, Hanna Suominen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we tested the Triplet Extraction (TE) capabilities of a variety
of Large Language Models (LLMs) of different sizes in the Zero- and Few-Shots
settings. In detail, we proposed a pipeline that dynamically gathers contextual
information from a Knowledge Base (KB), both in the form of context triplets
and of (sentence, triplets) pairs as examples, and provides it to the LLM
through a prompt. The additional context allowed the LLMs to be competitive
with all the older fully trained baselines based on the Bidirectional Long
Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM) Network architecture. We further conducted a
detailed analysis of the quality of the gathered KB context, finding it to be
strongly correlated with the final TE performance of the model. In contrast,
the size of the model appeared to only logarithmically improve the TE
capabilities of the LLMs. | [
0.0111479927,
-0.0021908991,
0.0013124377,
0.068319954,
-0.0674355626,
0.0223966632,
0.0103975022,
-0.0027216261,
0.0240973532,
-0.0767180026,
-0.0332830213,
-0.0406142212,
-0.0334663354,
0.0126552479,
0.0358200856,
-0.0079482207,
0.0670340136,
-0.0233578552,
0.0230678804,
0.0155979292,
-0.0096246786,
0.0284266863,
-0.0045944406,
-0.0534392446,
0.0089949062,
-0.0027414216,
0.0035723792,
-0.005387912,
0.009508335,
-0.0613706298,
-0.0034371198,
0.0048393765,
0.0275283772,
0.020855153,
0.0000019128,
-0.0270668678,
-0.0313162096,
-0.0094273631,
-0.0526865385,
0.0053672055,
-0.0117514934,
-0.0006615354,
-0.0079135122,
-0.0093351984,
-0.0527518354,
-0.0079108588,
-0.0087033268,
0.0114102317,
0.0266883262,
0.064418748,
-0.0068773064,
-0.0389630347,
0.0216527935,
-0.0237785056,
0.0205960572,
-0.0361089297,
0.0469847471,
0.0161671359,
0.0128778806,
0.0252187029,
0.0120917214,
0.0619851053,
0.0237428155,
0.0196688715,
-0.010592822,
0.0670925826,
-0.0357659236,
0.0277093444,
-0.0037684676,
0.0948897451,
-0.0105494028,
0.0233461112,
-0.005515432,
-0.0160650294,
-0.0061727404,
-0.057235878,
-0.0256037787,
0.0070777223,
-0.0293102786,
0.0024721329,
-0.0127066718,
-0.0413568467,
0.0545948073,
-0.00297234,
-0.0466023423,
0.0456073359,
0.0257754028,
-0.0437631086,
0.0282498989,
0.0249541085,
0.0010278644,
-0.0052077845,
0.0116745559,
0.0185997616,
0.0338675007,
0.0527358204,
0.002972946,
-0.0164965894,
0.0122672739,
-0.0200183522,
0.0105316173,
0.0143925063,
-0.0428944416,
0.0777285472,
-0.0590819009,
0.0282770395,
-0.0270446856,
0.0113112703,
-0.0161916297,
0.0037266642,
-0.029092567,
-0.0062543899,
-0.0271204375,
0.0540167652,
-0.014462254,
-0.018799901,
-0.0338612236,
0.013600817,
-0.0055787778,
0.0026437778,
0.0489022657,
0.0145909656,
0.0106744589,
-0.0108796088,
0.0248721372,
0.0731916949,
-0.0192777496,
0.0074891001,
-0.0130918995,
-0.0641646758,
-0.0212640036,
0.0073243254,
0.0542755201,
-0.0638140514,
0.0052525937,
0.0731394067,
0.0058836918,
-0.0773308352,
-0.0773436353,
-0.0428645834,
-0.0348232836,
-0.0491618998,
0.0272919759,
-0.0393437594,
0.0853143185,
-0.0182090644,
-0.0083784945,
-0.0169183705,
0.0007511575,
-0.006917899,
-0.054755237,
0.0516883992,
-0.0395939909,
-0.0338391848,
-0.0071169478,
-0.0109767467,
0.0094479546,
0.0606732927,
0.049547784,
0.0364088938,
0.0490746349,
-0.0008178885,
-0.031198658,
0.0574417748,
0.0670920908,
0.006593552,
-0.008079024,
0.006805886,
-0.0142028127,
0.0428922772,
0.0397250652,
0.0538040362,
-0.0553543866,
-0.0011184614,
0.0495199487,
0.0339378789,
0.0505222864,
0.03257614,
0.0873124972,
-0.0156971384,
0.0110150957,
0.0127287703,
-0.0538816564,
0.0118686808,
-0.0179389119,
0.0430669859,
0.0179277472,
0.0062547168,
-0.012970061,
0.0202886276,
0.0008921578,
-0.0156695619,
-0.0218110867,
-0.007399213,
0.0566314235,
-0.0176742692,
-0.0378657095,
0.0777822211,
0.0317035466,
-0.019205492,
0.0082786931,
-0.0206955168,
-0.0096398061,
0.0621277429,
0.0142198959,
-0.0230687186,
-0.0354099497,
0.0057866005,
-0.0569637902,
-0.0024682083,
0.0283570625,
-0.015104821,
0.024317408,
-0.0440958813,
-0.0183581039,
-0.0080657965,
-0.0107310079,
0.0594747141,
0.032212697,
0.0353393592,
0.0207933784,
0.0025506015,
0.0727653727,
-0.0116113815,
-0.0976884961,
-0.0521825776,
-0.0037782469,
0.0130973877,
0.0165738408,
0.0342737176,
-0.0254191272,
-0.0014251479,
0.0230101012,
-0.0538900495,
-0.0124944784,
-0.0102972342,
-0.0826228634,
-0.0692888051,
0.0506514385,
0.0688189343,
0.0010226051,
-0.022623051,
-0.0373410918,
-0.0315406732,
0.0036822178,
0.0135358544,
0.0410404019,
-0.0417857058,
0.0011771675,
0.0486848839,
0.014982474,
-0.0242236424,
0.0703313872,
-0.007937449,
-0.0283159316,
0.0001391088,
-0.0308619924,
-0.0199343916,
-0.0091881324,
-0.020377636,
0.0392126739,
0.0087445946,
0.0006682813,
-0.0068630902,
0.0103299534,
-0.0755095184,
-0.0145462221,
-0.0913170278,
0.030985048,
-0.0274803694,
0.0514157489,
-0.0013898575,
0.0186393932,
-0.0139834275,
0.0041788598,
-0.04544916,
0.0293285884,
-0.0390154384,
0.0237569883,
0.0319587104,
0.0291168671,
0.0062789265,
-0.01990835,
-0.0287231468,
-0.0353564806,
0.0697780177,
-0.0206803922,
-0.0461087935,
-0.0047487188,
0.0539172888,
-0.0282542501,
0.0080530355,
0.0042554946,
-0.0045453124,
-0.0200588703,
-0.0729688704,
0.0505955033,
0.0478145964,
-0.0222163051,
0.0011985019,
0.0264786873,
-0.0286127422,
-0.0517420806,
0.0298458021,
-0.0048506553,
-0.0086996276,
-0.0118428105,
0.0288638584,
-0.0133438557,
0.018802546,
0.0170721523,
0.0137516279,
-0.0255775768,
-0.0156360976,
0.0100697652,
0.0115430281,
-0.0276762247,
0.0165576786,
-0.042898979,
-0.0095979758,
-0.0351849385,
0.0114320498,
0.0539844707,
-0.0201584883,
-0.0181266684,
-0.0006782585,
0.0246923026,
-0.051690314,
0.0600320809,
0.0063175741,
-0.006550909,
-0.0303734336,
-0.0340437852,
-0.0231084693,
-0.0565293022,
-0.0177225936,
-0.0390357524,
0.0301389303,
-0.0376789048,
0.0277182143,
-0.0429614037,
-0.0290442612,
-0.0087934555,
0.0136747919,
-0.0495975949,
0.0392096899,
-0.0027144875,
0.0129402317,
0.0371112265,
-0.0231799297,
0.0609640591,
0.0798293427,
-0.0170896593,
-0.003813745,
-0.0195382815,
0.0893675089,
0.0143963387,
0.0009573073,
0.0179192536,
0.0131479949,
0.0365575328,
0.0676606372,
0.0248331372,
0.0264794752,
-0.0393589921,
0.006187222,
-0.0012055186,
-0.0421499982,
-0.0180539172,
-0.0121771498,
0.0143275419,
-0.0975253209,
0.0103198281,
0.1038939431,
0.001696897,
-0.0729451478,
-0.0230069831,
0.0219368301,
-0.0382532328,
-0.0034053915,
-0.0148566198,
-0.1296021044,
-0.0516025983,
-0.0344369523,
0.0026696378,
0.0211993977,
-0.0487660356,
-0.0332747884,
-0.14188613,
-0.0112822866,
0.0014358462,
-0.0174261741,
-0.0193325374,
-0.0192452352,
0.0074490886,
0.0027671542,
0.0345529094,
0.0154616311,
-0.0241187178,
-0.0132239908,
-0.0014466529,
0.0017021613,
-0.0498828962,
0.0456298813,
-0.0237603337,
0.0223680362,
0.016302757,
0.0328520648,
-0.0077896719,
0.0320932381,
0.0282794796,
-0.0524150915,
0.0090981741,
-0.0019186172,
0.0265626647,
-0.0438552685,
-0.0132486597,
0.0075952676,
-0.0063923192,
-0.0608333759,
0.0093209976,
0.0088180127,
0.0901174322,
0.0121222101,
-0.037386056,
0.0142971594,
-0.0093405759,
-0.0042295605,
0.0676174983,
0.033262141,
-0.0088089071,
0.0041479287,
0.0287925173,
-0.0362637229,
-0.0920931622,
-0.036272008,
0.0285725165,
-0.0167531744,
0.0047972254,
-0.0405332595,
-0.0599212795,
0.0524280779,
0.0452757962,
-0.0151976226,
0.0401669592,
0.0213418379,
0.0450218618,
-0.0288789757,
0.0101625733,
-0.0371454172,
-0.005353427,
-0.0444536246,
0.0397685729,
0.0397468619,
-0.0342702642,
-0.0095506301,
-0.0007104086,
-0.1132777706,
-0.0588315874,
-0.0014298679,
0.0306858066,
0.0059145801,
0.0715741217,
0.0128707923,
0.0058680959,
0.047631979,
0.050330475,
-0.0290176794,
0.0217477642,
0.0132673858,
0.0355397165,
-0.0187009852,
0.0519564934,
-0.0466894656,
0.0159542393,
0.0243511815,
0.0317232162,
-0.0669141933,
-0.009796733,
-0.0089926496,
0.0387441032,
0.0568746962,
0.0209644362,
0.0259376802,
-0.0320002921,
0.0092492895,
-0.0310276542,
0.0214366373,
-0.0286705736,
-0.0113722142,
0.0075173359,
-0.0410029665,
-0.0332568996,
-0.0190568622,
0.0424208045,
0.0167958513,
-0.0212311652,
-0.0134191802,
0.0160581209,
0.0129551208,
0.0289826375,
-0.0325393192,
-0.0533771403,
0.0343383551,
-0.0061156447,
0.011743716,
-0.072638616,
0.0434700064,
0.0075398022,
-0.0436650999,
-0.0193129573,
0.0487592779,
-0.045251254,
0.0112819392,
0.0089885304,
0.0142294755,
0.0827536359,
-0.0184264425,
0.0432663523,
-0.0289692488,
-0.0168041717,
-0.0152503131,
0.0167019386,
-0.0269966144,
-0.000939047,
0.0153776649,
0.046709381,
-0.0233713295,
0.0089706294,
0.0270948075,
-0.0101958662,
0.037671499,
0.0624222644,
-0.00109437,
-0.0234065559,
-0.001820388,
-0.0074960836,
0.0193164088,
0.0046705725,
0.0153134251,
-0.0554576889,
-0.0646985397,
0.0150963962,
0.0023507536,
-0.0186324716,
-0.0054101674,
0.0174499247,
0.0713300481,
0.0184325315,
-0.0104175787,
0.0028211439,
0.0311682131,
-0.01890078,
-0.0006973725,
-0.0031293866,
-6.56074107e-33,
-0.0304742437,
-0.018478334,
0.0483568273,
-0.0405745059,
-0.0727975219,
0.0298615154,
-0.0411754325,
-0.0047837771,
-0.071500957,
-0.0104594175,
-0.0271912236,
-0.0094509972,
0.0142402621,
0.0130001921,
-0.0024290311,
-0.0171392094,
0.0112889046,
-0.0156335663,
0.024436038,
0.0542769581,
0.0798339248,
0.0632112175,
0.1000538096,
-0.0447195172,
-0.0087680044,
-0.0091970228,
0.0174225383,
0.0195858423,
0.0264222678,
0.0443231016,
-0.0323303528,
0.0465799458,
0.041030474,
-0.0515496135,
0.0156493075,
0.0050876029,
-0.1073600128,
-0.0446507707,
0.0223980844,
-0.0131583326,
-0.0229422115,
-0.0485560857,
0.0202733036,
0.001237687,
0.0461294539,
-0.0362967178,
0.0044313008,
-0.0212858804,
-0.054219652,
-0.0539015383,
-0.0377424508,
0.0319685675,
0.0338787325,
0.035966184,
0.0424048565,
-0.0235792398,
0.0029821685,
0.020577509,
-0.0504118875,
-0.0251676422,
-0.0228644274,
0.0230477843,
0.0330230631,
0.0097640269,
-0.0041375281,
0.0670826361,
0.0009007949,
-0.0131728817,
-0.0080727851,
-0.0227352399,
0.0387676954,
0.0428958908,
0.0019208479,
0.0435906164,
0.0330412276,
0.009545316,
-0.0619249381,
-0.0512676612,
0.052343756,
0.0110728014,
-0.0020542238,
-0.0124476673,
-0.0162944272,
0.0077943574,
0.0168100819,
-0.0197601337,
-0.0251034014,
-0.0338231623,
0.044641193,
-0.0159452166,
0.0218832158,
0.0232761651,
0.039816644,
-0.0085820677,
0.0020226967,
0.0708989054,
0.000576192,
0.0211221557,
-0.0193399172,
0.049243059,
-0.0535150245,
-0.0432629436,
-0.0399704017,
0.0316392668,
0.0054866304,
0.0320399217,
0.0254264716,
0.007565679,
-0.058086466,
-0.045958221,
-0.0479953475,
0.0153978597,
-0.0243775919,
0.037444599,
0.0377997383,
0.0339258127,
0.0101211322,
0.0494829193,
0.0466183685,
-0.0266796723,
-0.0032289119,
0.0032609811,
0.0123498887,
0.0302148499,
-0.0026631693,
0.0019610031,
-0.0103905536,
-0.010047745,
0.0200605299,
-0.0458953604,
0.0043566432,
0.0205983389,
2.748e-7,
0.0265923198,
0.0185420476,
0.0350203402,
0.0038650185,
0.0288038105,
0.0184398908,
-0.022541061,
0.0240169298,
-0.0000722087,
-0.0060103233,
0.0322044939,
0.0468191579,
-0.0127059883,
0.0394013412,
-0.0949630365,
0.0089737801,
-0.0486259758,
-0.0238060057,
-0.0354796685,
-0.0147772739,
0.0746064112,
0.0682053268,
0.029693529,
-0.0182310622,
-0.01152521,
-0.0871558338,
0.0343298167,
-0.0005643966,
0.0090663545,
0.0211916119,
0.0298073869,
0.0003977305,
-0.0388442725,
0.0436413698,
-0.0000757305,
0.0362067968,
-0.0324739292,
0.0636205301,
-0.0169434454,
-0.0491782613,
0.0236335099,
-0.0374443829,
-0.0007737539,
-0.0108691771,
0.0982575864,
-0.0679276362,
-0.0096799871,
-0.0167025663,
-0.0510664396,
-0.009605092,
-0.0107473908,
0.00143582,
0.0117916837,
0.0360445343,
-0.0010107398,
-0.0215164237,
-0.0430878215,
-0.1080098003,
0.0045274789,
0.0139208036,
-0.0377257019,
-0.0615189709,
-0.0178091172,
-0.0333597027,
0.051772207,
-0.0621215366,
0.0174691454,
2.307820508e-34,
0.0332853086,
-0.0236774888,
0.0335214511,
0.0331899859,
-0.0051755342,
-0.0028432983,
-0.0335111767,
-0.0031334788,
0.0130589055,
-0.0780155361,
-0.0024013785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01921v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01921v2 | A Machine Learning Approach Towards SKILL Code Autocompletion | 2023-12-04T14:29:28 | 2024-02-24T13:58:26 | Enrique Dehaerne, Bappaditya Dey, Wannes Meert | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.PL, I.2.2 | As Moore's Law continues to increase the complexity of electronic systems,
Electronic Design Automation (EDA) must advance to meet global demand. An
important example of an EDA technology is SKILL, a scripting language used to
customize and extend EDA software. Recently, code generation models using the
transformer architecture have achieved impressive results in academic settings
and have even been used in commercial developer tools to improve developer
productivity. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to apply
transformers to SKILL code autocompletion towards improving the productivity of
hardware design engineers. In this study, a novel, data-efficient methodology
for generating SKILL code is proposed and experimentally validated. More
specifically, we propose a novel methodology for (i) creating a high-quality
SKILL dataset with both unlabeled and labeled data, (ii) a training strategy
where T5 models pre-trained on general programming language code are fine-tuned
on our custom SKILL dataset using unsupervised and supervised learning, and
(iii) evaluating synthesized SKILL code. We show that models trained using the
proposed methodology outperform baselines in terms of human-judgment score and
BLEU score. A major challenge faced was the extremely small amount of available
SKILL code data that can be used to train a transformer model to generate SKILL
code. Despite our validated improvements, the extremely small dataset available
to us was still not enough to train a model that can reliably autocomplete
SKILL code. We discuss this and other limitations as well as future work that
could address these limitations. | [
0.0164511763,
0.0375290625,
-0.0547183044,
-0.027966667,
0.001436205,
-0.008571119,
0.0556127541,
-0.0092246756,
-0.0030011151,
0.0228660423,
-0.002771517,
0.0602301471,
0.0137613593,
0.0480042361,
0.0308924913,
-0.0148417503,
0.0128319114,
-0.0023150661,
-0.0446113981,
0.0007058123,
-0.0575981103,
-0.0052627921,
0.0185710173,
0.0855480954,
-0.0242268965,
-0.0025312309,
-0.0019500224,
0.0029887343,
-0.0120626874,
0.0223777369,
0.0237402581,
0.0741476268,
-0.0207978319,
-0.0162506048,
0.0000022836,
-0.0033716727,
0.000657652,
-0.0118180793,
-0.0194428973,
-0.0066796327,
0.0174477138,
-0.0191004332,
-0.0029000572,
0.0173100475,
-0.0037992159,
-0.0509057492,
0.0741633326,
0.0191322882,
0.0298673473,
0.0005832353,
0.0185750891,
-0.0039255247,
0.0244687349,
-0.0006186994,
-0.0088443942,
0.0107138781,
0.0020754666,
0.0240928009,
0.0111750383,
0.0084285205,
-0.0059119393,
0.0265295189,
0.036550194,
0.0019651174,
0.086353533,
0.0469348654,
-0.0066998797,
0.0047619031,
0.0325934179,
0.0138732195,
-0.0579611883,
-0.0353948474,
0.0044927709,
-0.0187244453,
-0.0147094475,
0.0188188832,
0.0178514756,
-0.0223638192,
-0.0290649403,
-0.0389683656,
-0.0206675585,
-0.0209430642,
-0.0028861272,
-0.0497829653,
0.0258775558,
0.0483414605,
0.0063358531,
-0.0065809782,
-0.0047513205,
-0.0029767703,
0.0365820825,
-0.0306347404,
-0.0130045731,
0.0226229262,
-0.0361292697,
-0.0188684352,
-0.0381448604,
-0.0102766175,
-0.0127020413,
-0.0004038353,
0.007586563,
0.0304551851,
0.0062026642,
-0.0243306737,
-0.0676329285,
0.0175390486,
-0.0026176448,
0.0075232522,
-0.0689228326,
0.0024960169,
-0.0823409483,
-0.0227939002,
-0.0301590841,
0.0368314125,
0.0351557657,
0.029688539,
-0.0605238117,
0.0514785275,
-0.0157682374,
0.0141013227,
0.0197470486,
0.0288703553,
-0.017631257,
0.0269525964,
0.0034669056,
-0.0148530575,
-0.0041209166,
-0.0280703232,
-0.0099006724,
-0.0381151959,
0.0084260739,
-0.0266307835,
-0.0305431318,
0.0122061223,
0.0315544046,
0.084821105,
0.0054074945,
0.0068142936,
-0.0347567014,
-0.0168183129,
0.0126767345,
0.0008519314,
0.0311590731,
-0.0760288835,
-0.0320058614,
0.0052619278,
-0.0109825591,
-0.0513226464,
0.006120774,
0.0377313308,
0.0164125636,
0.0523533486,
-0.0480745919,
0.0242151432,
0.0612852797,
-0.021766182,
-0.0391099304,
0.0132199451,
0.0418879502,
0.0452303924,
-0.0010450158,
-0.0721292868,
0.0590920337,
0.0435784385,
-0.0201863833,
-0.0550502092,
-0.0045386315,
-0.0095986584,
0.0177067611,
-0.0007207808,
-0.0129995532,
-0.0184255224,
0.0002286031,
0.0208325144,
0.0047537051,
-0.0101097059,
0.0700786039,
0.0510068089,
0.0478217937,
0.0340504423,
-0.0053942981,
-0.0509018786,
-0.0116337817,
0.0879617855,
0.0082706418,
0.0275105126,
-0.000132319,
0.0456775129,
-0.0400445014,
-0.0601520464,
0.0079188757,
-0.041864641,
-0.021011211,
0.0116169602,
0.0532339625,
-0.0095177619,
-0.0534489229,
0.026868891,
0.0123115834,
-0.0402699932,
-0.0579316653,
-0.0664956644,
0.007913772,
0.0264805462,
0.0476107933,
-0.031607233,
-0.0501516201,
-0.0175480247,
0.0073493472,
-0.0500349812,
0.0236037802,
-0.0330256969,
-0.0110585755,
-0.0417288877,
-0.0504149646,
-0.018332798,
-0.0168045964,
0.0578113794,
-0.0157699808,
-0.0732875317,
0.0102027329,
0.0024360383,
-0.0708650351,
0.0268360786,
-0.0323234797,
-0.0273762401,
0.0686337277,
0.0096763382,
0.0044845473,
-0.0378893055,
-0.0370753258,
0.0013575737,
0.0224042702,
-0.0189410858,
-0.0205482449,
-0.0241276231,
-0.0396131985,
0.0301821325,
0.0071453685,
-0.0747739226,
-0.0474481322,
0.0479706414,
-0.0118617872,
-0.0353255533,
0.0263531283,
-0.0522604994,
0.0129505778,
0.027185604,
0.0174965467,
-0.0271511078,
-0.009035252,
-0.0387832336,
0.0759331882,
0.0312315952,
0.0295740366,
-0.0030008571,
0.0009997287,
0.0627230629,
-0.0059840339,
0.0012381437,
-0.0084556015,
-0.019925613,
0.046679806,
0.0417402461,
0.0197369326,
-0.0122260498,
-0.0327378176,
-0.0628158301,
-0.0167712513,
-0.0054863105,
-0.0233823564,
-0.0270346515,
-0.0024042127,
0.0138897868,
-0.0215839669,
0.007946766,
-0.0204690024,
-0.0141541064,
-0.0310140494,
0.0035368674,
-0.0067719026,
-0.08433339,
0.0139184361,
-0.0330301113,
-0.032147333,
0.0327827595,
0.021272257,
0.0499705262,
-0.0619488768,
0.0853921771,
0.0447546057,
-0.0035836333,
-0.0252354313,
-0.0247196313,
-0.0022215769,
0.0227864366,
0.0150255607,
0.0483828336,
-0.0018277308,
-0.00017269,
0.0602140091,
0.008230296,
-0.0383382812,
0.0252792407,
-0.0072836867,
-0.0260741729,
0.0298490543,
-0.0146228308,
0.0112583302,
0.0345245264,
0.0186976008,
-0.0003748215,
-0.0504611358,
0.0067278165,
0.0587132387,
-0.0110482285,
0.0211516544,
0.0051237857,
-0.0091815237,
0.0379615352,
-0.03201719,
-0.0829090625,
0.0836788565,
-0.0074042166,
-0.000602725,
-0.0264340006,
-0.031515751,
-0.0165142883,
-0.0013767845,
0.0106636742,
-0.0070821051,
-0.0058898604,
-0.0344711281,
-0.0303141586,
0.0913375616,
-0.000067468,
-0.0136564253,
0.0140268998,
-0.0135116503,
-0.0263134185,
0.0045010424,
-0.0131612597,
-0.0710943788,
0.0360466242,
-0.0159345865,
0.0263324082,
0.0633384734,
-0.0199172571,
-0.0168908089,
0.0241746921,
0.0119928,
0.0165562499,
0.0427563451,
-0.0675136074,
-0.004971439,
-0.0280686673,
0.0154163484,
0.0084492555,
-0.0282519124,
-0.0218784958,
-0.0190385357,
-0.0110151721,
0.0524826758,
0.0411917455,
-0.1011401042,
0.0147491805,
0.0497377105,
-0.0408202037,
-0.0172772836,
0.0613872781,
-0.0244439039,
-0.0058095432,
-0.0115852766,
0.0688446686,
0.0007553452,
-0.0410229452,
0.0009557166,
0.026376972,
0.0349617973,
0.0645717606,
0.0574258976,
-0.0541335717,
-0.0077529578,
-0.0152934017,
0.0500394069,
-0.0188429169,
-0.0026025868,
0.0246367157,
-0.0941321403,
0.0597299263,
-0.0049079699,
-0.0275068767,
-0.0577639341,
-0.0360544957,
-0.0017442618,
-0.0151549391,
-0.0401064046,
0.0140929744,
-0.0142511893,
-0.0006641924,
0.0501593128,
-0.0646459758,
-0.0941371024,
0.050904613,
0.0029250053,
0.0459754206,
0.0903719738,
-0.016254548,
-0.0114791691,
-0.050936684,
0.0322849788,
0.0241560899,
0.051075086,
-0.0306903087,
0.0594578385,
-0.0158747993,
-0.036360193,
0.0099332966,
0.0203288998,
-0.0405833945,
0.0057969294,
0.0212921426,
0.0618882589,
-0.0178114139,
0.0080820303,
-0.0331060179,
-0.035605453,
0.0026960713,
-0.0076135802,
0.0095318267,
-0.0347346924,
-0.0309735686,
-0.0503926463,
0.0093596326,
-0.0357492976,
-0.028262049,
-0.0011828503,
-0.0114259282,
-0.0296327379,
-0.0020245179,
-0.0046497597,
0.015836928,
0.0353419669,
0.0287789013,
-0.0761279985,
0.0194479134,
0.0183397159,
-0.1045131609,
0.0012116713,
0.0076951319,
0.010126939,
-0.0676196516,
-0.0449030027,
-0.0124826944,
-0.0802221,
-0.0373958535,
-0.0145183131,
-0.0483919866,
-0.0380985066,
0.0139332367,
0.1101093665,
0.0196219552,
0.01698252,
-0.0123337712,
-0.0504483879,
-0.0130454991,
0.0645168871,
-0.0536068082,
-0.0065265819,
0.0051104226,
-0.0546808317,
-0.0114019597,
-0.051881887,
-0.0334246419,
0.0503888354,
0.0607708059,
-0.0339851491,
-0.0048349923,
-0.0275849197,
0.0341000631,
0.0175563302,
0.0273274481,
-0.0016174027,
0.0071608969,
-0.0263327099,
0.0094495649,
0.0380370654,
0.0024225486,
-0.0481832214,
-0.0122416141,
-0.0052482965,
0.0099374708,
0.0425626896,
-0.0062502874,
-0.0216651596,
0.0046015377,
-0.0497872308,
0.0479208082,
-0.0035325603,
0.0874947906,
0.0094285812,
-0.0087962318,
-0.0027912788,
-0.0265864339,
0.042068027,
0.0748748258,
0.0023744293,
0.0380096287,
0.0157412421,
0.0736389756,
-0.0325289257,
0.0282783136,
-0.0477377027,
-0.0881638005,
-0.0622146577,
-0.0062567987,
0.0455884933,
-0.0113136359,
-0.0283534508,
-0.0382692255,
0.0305225104,
-0.0310388468,
0.0307209417,
-0.0084258774,
0.0127067138,
-0.0009729632,
0.0141815636,
0.0064368774,
-0.0508139096,
0.0673604161,
-0.0238356274,
0.0120230736,
-0.0601959415,
-0.0280986037,
-0.0529366881,
0.0350915492,
0.0715406016,
-0.0045231185,
-0.0064288718,
-0.0246903803,
-0.031092871,
-0.0473228134,
0.0347183682,
0.0124861374,
0.0601483621,
-0.0323119424,
0.0593503453,
0.0857061967,
-0.0062680137,
-0.0238575954,
0.0128177479,
-0.03278872,
0.0077875857,
-0.0012938293,
-0.035749279,
-5.846257971e-33,
-0.0266222861,
-0.0330624841,
0.0430421419,
0.0671597272,
0.0397434011,
0.0138203027,
-0.0017517675,
0.0213427208,
-0.006201833,
-0.029329218,
-0.0211129654,
-0.0214463212,
-0.0044576465,
0.0069142208,
0.1014479995,
0.0168194175,
0.0661726221,
0.0166075788,
-0.0377899818,
0.0499097966,
-0.0332305133,
0.0013048472,
0.0306595638,
-0.0843467042,
-0.0381828807,
0.0085519804,
0.0569981337,
-0.0414735563,
0.0164454691,
0.036860548,
0.0042815772,
0.0276398901,
-0.002123534,
-0.0713646263,
-0.0150623647,
-0.0274739284,
-0.0449864492,
-0.0405526198,
-0.034354344,
0.0136273624,
0.019501986,
-0.0536717847,
0.0764976889,
0.0200408436,
-0.0838836357,
-0.0087595517,
0.0909140334,
0.0153591614,
-0.0215804335,
-0.0381478071,
-0.0560735874,
0.0182528906,
-0.0171849914,
-0.0434098504,
0.0037885425,
0.0243979394,
-0.0171230473,
-0.0146397138,
-0.0542477779,
0.0284723416,
0.0297367573,
0.0394692644,
0.0886677951,
0.0002477261,
0.0199779067,
0.0091376724,
0.090533264,
0.0564774461,
-0.0149623491,
0.0048386906,
0.0437476002,
0.0579498298,
-0.0046782536,
0.0120103322,
0.0357511863,
-0.0719261542,
-0.0235448107,
0.0578012094,
-0.0352421179,
0.06723205,
0.0095727835,
0.0062336414,
-0.05844694,
-0.009691108,
0.0032615047,
0.0147795295,
0.0175462887,
-0.0202712715,
0.0249023903,
0.0266937856,
-0.0269417167,
-0.0065908055,
0.0268771444,
-0.0160525311,
0.0661577061,
0.0077331774,
-0.006340818,
0.0448910631,
0.0064286785,
-0.0202107821,
-0.032492917,
-0.0491176583,
-0.0019760714,
-0.0122594591,
0.0712099373,
-0.0034832973,
-0.0300843548,
0.0380924009,
-0.0752445906,
0.0001427776,
-0.0398364961,
-0.0333368853,
-0.0144836772,
0.0030084192,
0.0167150646,
0.0204042178,
0.0099687818,
-0.0288749393,
-0.0662694201,
-0.0575439855,
-0.0289784539,
0.0405901186,
0.027534157,
-0.0026036096,
0.0116658993,
-0.017412249,
-0.0623189881,
-0.0010519106,
0.0050062351,
-0.0083832191,
-0.0386887267,
0.0314000361,
2.991e-7,
-0.0123255476,
0.0461378321,
-0.0079175401,
0.0452719368,
-0.0296308678,
0.0412622392,
0.0178103112,
-0.0091397064,
0.0647707283,
0.0244322103,
0.0100183692,
-0.0119312145,
0.0455055647,
-0.0188000742,
-0.0385019593,
-0.0552538559,
0.0314788818,
0.0612195842,
-0.0170370694,
0.0022091593,
0.078109391,
0.0455199555,
0.0134114707,
-0.014677803,
0.0272464268,
0.0082074776,
0.0092533836,
-0.0212487932,
0.0377359428,
0.0358930379,
-0.0284355432,
0.0354872569,
-0.0395771191,
0.087792553,
0.0091082174,
-0.0124049494,
0.025700517,
0.0284656174,
0.0002766556,
0.0487232283,
0.0620615706,
0.0032825682,
-0.0144300479,
-0.024969317,
0.0075827013,
-0.0489513986,
-0.0102742473,
-0.0231009182,
-0.0412185341,
-0.0052591111,
0.0087561747,
-0.0008358156,
0.0358494073,
-0.0181546099,
0.0045688185,
-0.0282217935,
-0.0338829979,
-0.013892672,
-0.0015735284,
0.0481477603,
-0.0667829663,
-0.0213006735,
-0.0139836762,
-0.0151465656,
0.0485107228,
0.0076970547,
0.0010348844,
2.921972685e-34,
0.0073926616,
-0.0231834967,
0.038689144,
0.0553570203,
0.0146993781,
-0.0116516938,
0.0429641269,
0.0083081312,
0.007158658,
-0.0242760926,
-0.0262741242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01858v1 | Evaluating Dependencies in Fact Editing for Language Models: Specificity and Implication Awareness | 2023-12-04T12:45:30 | 2023-12-04T12:45:30 | Zichao Li, Ines Arous, Siva Reddy, Jackie C. K. Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | The potential of using a large language model (LLM) as a knowledge base (KB)
has sparked significant interest. To manage the knowledge acquired by LLMs, we
need to ensure that the editing of learned facts respects internal logical
constraints, which are known as dependency of knowledge. Existing work on
editing LLMs has partially addressed the issue of dependency, when the editing
of a fact should apply to its lexical variations without disrupting irrelevant
ones. However, they neglect the dependency between a fact and its logical
implications. We propose an evaluation protocol with an accompanying
question-answering dataset, DepEdit, that provides a comprehensive assessment
of the editing process considering the above notions of dependency. Our
protocol involves setting up a controlled environment in which we edit facts
and monitor their impact on LLMs, along with their implications based on
If-Then rules. Extensive experiments on DepEdit show that existing knowledge
editing methods are sensitive to the surface form of knowledge, and that they
have limited performance in inferring the implications of edited facts. | [
0.0856341049,
0.030430438,
-0.022627566,
0.0442586429,
-0.0841801539,
-0.0153992046,
-0.0233280621,
-0.0232798085,
0.0004423382,
-0.0622023791,
0.0032251289,
-0.002935007,
-0.0104664685,
0.0127596632,
0.013383545,
-0.0515192151,
0.0758964941,
-0.0108707296,
0.0118563166,
-0.0185520183,
0.0161481649,
-0.0143262902,
-0.0053328406,
-0.004608748,
-0.0516561568,
-0.0363930948,
-0.0140397632,
-0.0099949054,
0.0148501014,
0.0316799618,
-0.0090575954,
0.0903541967,
-0.0005109905,
0.0261125639,
0.0000022678,
-0.0719883442,
-0.0221083276,
-0.0065594069,
-0.0463552661,
0.0215389039,
-0.0023583381,
0.0124822175,
-0.0218326841,
-0.030067388,
-0.0417498648,
-0.0249034334,
0.0426249541,
0.0166983884,
0.0946258754,
0.0329372622,
-0.0002207046,
0.0115714399,
-0.0097953575,
-0.0081249867,
0.0290434267,
0.0013839405,
0.0462697037,
0.0640152842,
-0.0396744646,
0.025151547,
-0.0296009071,
0.0422597304,
0.0230009668,
-0.0482615158,
0.0133266039,
-0.0045258137,
-0.0273530725,
0.0006996502,
0.0145412246,
0.0403901562,
0.0538579673,
-0.0327182673,
-0.039856609,
0.0055177091,
0.0473879687,
0.0518097281,
-0.0344302841,
0.0172990952,
-0.003629342,
-0.035853602,
0.0171260945,
-0.0477142408,
0.0006449334,
0.0285888165,
0.0027802282,
0.0919899046,
0.0245849863,
-0.0522065833,
-0.0598784164,
0.0079548098,
-0.0432090014,
-0.0895216987,
-0.0085667241,
0.0032591715,
0.0067258328,
0.0335376412,
-0.0460111648,
0.0219924264,
0.0178836305,
-0.0683771595,
-0.0106537724,
0.012116028,
-0.0491467677,
0.0622997731,
0.0071145818,
0.0364846252,
0.019667156,
-0.0027337226,
0.0043565631,
0.0322858058,
-0.0491159484,
-0.0180485565,
-0.0488713421,
0.0508575775,
0.0001573348,
0.0560946018,
-0.0085591907,
0.0127344094,
-0.0443688035,
0.0421739705,
-0.0047766031,
-0.0195136555,
-0.026433561,
-0.0367211811,
-0.0648439527,
0.0453591608,
-0.0070013981,
0.0322116353,
-0.0203060172,
-0.0393802226,
-0.0099809226,
-0.021775851,
0.0055593108,
-0.0197000373,
0.0175877437,
0.0474924445,
0.0110408021,
-0.0024018509,
-0.035474319,
-0.0576720685,
-0.0014773904,
-0.0512762219,
-0.032441549,
-0.094386071,
-0.000590247,
0.0085628098,
-0.032808423,
-0.059513703,
-0.0083292006,
0.0051262802,
-0.0171453524,
0.0737810507,
-0.0188759528,
0.0273803826,
0.0308628194,
0.0198015273,
-0.0163942743,
0.0704653263,
0.0226594862,
-0.0082100006,
0.0595429763,
0.0147503214,
0.0038827811,
0.0179498158,
0.0034103775,
0.0190845374,
-0.0193976834,
0.0226081386,
0.0107163601,
0.002085967,
0.0207446925,
0.0273737367,
-0.0078048315,
-0.0096975258,
0.1021222696,
-0.0151507733,
0.0024498054,
0.029869467,
0.0372543782,
-0.0156058492,
0.0244921912,
0.0620106496,
-0.0323214158,
0.0267398395,
-0.0013988384,
0.0130469706,
-0.0301394518,
0.0243426934,
0.0086679775,
-0.0589898527,
-0.0110454764,
0.0304139499,
0.0142356381,
0.0147973783,
0.0412087366,
0.0389451459,
0.0162198618,
0.0836241543,
0.0410580412,
-0.0192407835,
0.0040614805,
-0.0338845141,
0.0067984443,
0.0480200276,
0.0624832213,
-0.0569741428,
-0.0742270574,
-0.0154681178,
0.0011604733,
0.042416621,
0.046097368,
-0.0325198658,
-0.016258629,
0.0072657941,
-0.0000452492,
-0.0445473306,
0.0386001915,
-0.0182957817,
0.0252911691,
-0.0267457794,
-0.0156421028,
-0.0134458644,
0.0111542577,
0.0030997724,
0.0189793874,
0.0088282954,
-0.020174114,
-0.0019886666,
-0.0136029581,
0.0047279559,
-0.0312563963,
0.0077433423,
-0.0004536699,
-0.0114303054,
-0.0301841293,
0.0273028295,
0.0149777681,
-0.0180099197,
0.0644298568,
-0.0183541328,
-0.0526815429,
-0.0050709611,
-0.032541018,
-0.0334411487,
0.0175778344,
-0.0374079533,
0.0629073977,
-0.0300591197,
0.0171128288,
-0.0096296193,
-0.0332581177,
-0.0221477039,
0.0628162101,
-0.0175959338,
0.0032366791,
0.0098174466,
0.0169530921,
0.0162281506,
-0.0336723514,
-0.009286073,
0.0029840639,
0.0152514623,
-0.0141567225,
0.0116824415,
0.007757626,
-0.0389701575,
0.007274162,
-0.0767493919,
-0.0064874189,
-0.0261571258,
0.0234537646,
0.0564336069,
0.0347974226,
-0.0184833352,
-0.0143037131,
-0.002159314,
-0.022361815,
-0.0188928992,
0.038709823,
0.0402154364,
0.0018250142,
0.0006843907,
-0.036416363,
0.0043033799,
-0.00458663,
0.0091109052,
0.0330944546,
0.0126540111,
-0.0489775501,
0.0284925271,
-0.09751302,
0.0256608855,
0.0259349123,
-0.0284203514,
-0.0031527786,
0.0089836987,
0.0702129975,
0.0377266966,
-0.027883403,
-0.0167901926,
0.1070692018,
-0.0444647223,
-0.0250380877,
0.0192014929,
0.0039082756,
0.0325425938,
-0.001639428,
-0.0344100296,
-0.0174853969,
0.042565193,
0.0222751275,
-0.0651598126,
-0.0291618034,
0.0521215796,
-0.0342348851,
-0.024182925,
-0.0387199186,
-0.0160186589,
-0.0197089277,
0.0343593135,
-0.0470151976,
-0.0359376743,
0.09147989,
-0.0061690942,
0.022712674,
-0.0595372505,
0.0253895521,
-0.0161031745,
0.0822255686,
0.001193964,
0.0114372112,
-0.0047073513,
0.0139415413,
-0.0807027817,
-0.0023787455,
0.0491666943,
-0.0304957107,
0.0591512807,
-0.1173397228,
0.0263270438,
0.0037704036,
-0.0163246598,
-0.0406680442,
-0.0205654502,
-0.0260313209,
0.001465212,
0.0021506639,
-0.0156948697,
0.0059139039,
-0.0154225565,
0.074429214,
0.0672815219,
0.0073108813,
-0.0046187243,
-0.0116945365,
0.0035929179,
0.0583831668,
0.0371311381,
0.000329399,
0.0245787427,
0.0144285504,
0.0584064573,
-0.0299526062,
-0.0348756425,
0.0103940088,
0.000012157,
-0.0041474937,
-0.0750488266,
-0.0067162788,
-0.0319395848,
0.0419837348,
-0.0612990931,
-0.0461770631,
0.0836687163,
0.0566837341,
0.0002140156,
0.0065408335,
-0.0735240057,
0.0107560558,
0.0347129069,
0.0493090935,
-0.0926395431,
-0.0195092447,
0.0106974943,
-0.0294730421,
-0.0438791662,
-0.0387863331,
-0.0285671391,
-0.0782937333,
0.0143906791,
-0.0385493524,
-0.015477648,
-0.019009063,
-0.0377179384,
0.0318259224,
-0.0183173269,
-0.0305973683,
0.023465259,
0.0051066093,
0.0004615089,
-0.0263299458,
0.0059886337,
-0.0375620313,
0.0361842066,
-0.0009896513,
0.0237025414,
0.0338664465,
0.0051064142,
-0.0248154979,
0.0217080805,
0.0072118347,
0.0296002887,
-0.016878549,
-0.02082403,
0.0217374656,
0.0143157644,
0.0046356861,
-0.0280881878,
-0.0199210197,
0.0606635101,
-0.0382164642,
0.0413519852,
0.1028605402,
-0.0402181074,
0.0263940077,
0.008461237,
-0.0064045233,
-0.0061130868,
0.085990794,
0.0488818176,
-0.0316776037,
0.0360251814,
-0.0584010892,
-0.0389331952,
-0.0216019675,
-0.0488839932,
-0.0024220704,
-0.0348985903,
0.0053152647,
-0.0963600576,
-0.0323944613,
0.0360950455,
0.002511102,
0.0170489699,
0.0095382547,
0.0451533794,
0.003501181,
-0.0100493655,
0.0239516944,
-0.0353817008,
-0.0053567048,
-0.0058690296,
-0.0342473686,
0.0269588344,
-0.0374721847,
-0.0289402548,
0.0227736887,
-0.0402661599,
-0.0719420314,
0.0324028544,
0.0378446542,
0.0350306556,
0.0497696251,
-0.017761223,
-0.0551718771,
-0.0099076303,
-0.0051978035,
-0.0136205973,
0.033470057,
0.0232009329,
-0.0246579945,
0.0078201583,
0.0467059352,
-0.0242386758,
0.0163813382,
0.0256275181,
0.0442087799,
-0.0473429002,
-0.0335248262,
0.0519135743,
0.0089544849,
0.0026466909,
0.0172648914,
-0.0359784402,
-0.0660849288,
0.0484657846,
-0.0600263178,
-0.0420494601,
-0.035995312,
0.0211286806,
-0.0273561515,
-0.0009282158,
0.0076961755,
0.0132808527,
-0.0531286821,
0.0030438819,
0.0137425894,
-0.0097111119,
0.032065466,
0.0153997252,
0.0415076762,
-0.0184979197,
-0.0161306523,
-0.0058553168,
-0.0191635191,
-0.0038637249,
-0.0037083705,
0.0330618247,
0.0221080706,
-0.0374558419,
-0.0315454081,
-0.0030367116,
-0.0550152659,
-0.0017021024,
0.0042734188,
0.047204785,
0.0491043627,
-0.0030426481,
0.0373832658,
-0.0745634288,
-0.038984064,
-0.0137469163,
0.0299344752,
0.0359080881,
-0.0286976583,
0.0227282364,
0.0224988051,
-0.0068206531,
0.0466651022,
0.0659071207,
-0.0323677473,
0.1080674976,
-0.0410670154,
-0.0400523022,
-0.0235170852,
-0.0661261603,
-0.0360888727,
-0.0232938323,
-0.0419924706,
0.0242888927,
-0.1107401177,
-0.0782693177,
-0.0254401006,
0.0431700163,
0.0188774075,
-0.0036189696,
0.0276285801,
0.0538536645,
0.0338632576,
-0.0501856357,
-0.031593319,
0.0583001338,
-0.0117694745,
-0.0080951396,
-0.0331993736,
-6.626641487e-33,
-0.0247546118,
-0.003268624,
0.025806725,
-0.0048642256,
-0.0167725254,
0.0213515889,
-0.0399414971,
0.0165383331,
-0.021929644,
0.0339052752,
-0.0271539539,
0.0200525858,
0.0030670655,
-0.0034921907,
0.013600844,
0.0016622886,
0.0541082546,
0.0282154903,
-0.0311774295,
-0.0116098942,
0.0396137424,
-0.0055264318,
0.0773176774,
-0.0370782614,
0.0836404338,
-0.0089259213,
-0.0038406807,
0.0419156589,
-0.0944683477,
0.0499764197,
0.0054439898,
0.0247203968,
0.0239635669,
-0.0614134558,
-0.0315036029,
-0.0257248692,
-0.0132344486,
-0.0455004945,
0.074840568,
0.0156961121,
0.0075925016,
-0.0319865495,
0.0402159803,
-0.0011498379,
-0.0237026997,
-0.0135738505,
0.0164136793,
-0.0378556177,
0.0210455991,
0.0433817133,
-0.0662453994,
0.0233774539,
0.0247081537,
-0.0131391054,
-0.0274523571,
-0.0086089578,
0.0257533491,
-0.0756237656,
-0.0547768027,
0.0468320958,
0.0545586683,
0.0472059958,
0.0606861524,
-0.0298926327,
0.0157658029,
0.021135645,
-0.030436961,
0.0127719557,
-0.0024466971,
0.0328645259,
-0.0045624943,
0.0246159472,
0.0274014249,
0.0788511783,
0.0127995713,
0.0278078467,
-0.0681628063,
-0.0038153583,
-0.0131493108,
0.0643538609,
-0.0313459374,
0.0039279261,
-0.0113871768,
0.0012172424,
-0.036168389,
0.0585296564,
-0.0319966637,
-0.0320095345,
0.0122319832,
-0.0087774796,
-0.0243314523,
-0.0095229317,
-0.0056367121,
-0.0194073319,
-0.0123479906,
0.0177420322,
-0.0138125354,
0.0589894168,
0.0069944705,
-0.0060361088,
-0.0166871399,
0.064328298,
0.0214350689,
-0.007946779,
0.0109029701,
0.0392211974,
0.0422838926,
0.0187357627,
-0.0098889861,
0.0195106883,
-0.0247114655,
0.0023274154,
-0.019731639,
-0.0246141292,
0.0049795746,
0.0188431609,
-0.0125831245,
-0.0028631596,
0.078769654,
0.0269791074,
-0.0574875213,
0.0024239507,
-0.0005604071,
0.0351807587,
-0.0244533904,
0.0016680261,
-0.0278410371,
-0.0129862996,
-0.0139079746,
-0.0202991143,
-0.0100999298,
0.0175220091,
2.966e-7,
0.0453009307,
0.0514178574,
-0.0107896002,
0.0316001736,
0.0190990847,
0.0281776413,
-0.0390576832,
0.0004672417,
0.0308374744,
-0.0307670422,
0.0044831731,
0.030658409,
0.0121564968,
0.0374043211,
-0.081583485,
-0.0058841454,
-0.0041857068,
-0.020179674,
-0.0446525551,
-0.0241277181,
0.0399249941,
0.0428274758,
0.0399972275,
-0.0033585872,
-0.0518298708,
-0.0091771735,
0.0342031009,
-0.0000918018,
-0.0318108462,
0.0085833427,
0.1035497934,
0.0034786141,
0.0184172597,
0.0594613142,
-0.0304970425,
-0.0246926546,
-0.0327975489,
0.0435538329,
-0.0022075865,
0.0436034314,
-0.0326346457,
-0.0197623428,
0.0074932911,
-0.0487211347,
0.0823056996,
-0.0230804179,
-0.0061582471,
-0.005822347,
0.0041706362,
0.0228534564,
-0.0103891147,
-0.0129828807,
-0.0475075133,
-0.0210275631,
0.0036000574,
0.0338409133,
-0.0300029032,
0.0017733626,
-0.0418917201,
0.038851738,
-0.0189171508,
-0.0835692808,
-0.0129945418,
-0.0549178571,
0.0020462775,
-0.0804210901,
0.0065701557,
2.656448026e-34,
-0.0112801036,
0.0277356599,
0.0288597997,
0.0107962433,
0.0384463109,
-0.0093205385,
-0.0340137556,
0.0100181764,
0.0002446743,
-0.077220872,
-0.033667475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01837v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01837v1 | Prompting Disentangled Embeddings for Knowledge Graph Completion with Pre-trained Language Model | 2023-12-04T12:20:25 | 2023-12-04T12:20:25 | Yuxia Geng, Jiaoyan Chen, Yuhang Zeng, Zhuo Chen, Wen Zhang, Jeff Z. Pan, Yuxiang Wang, Xiaoliang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Both graph structures and textual information play a critical role in
Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC). With the success of Pre-trained Language
Models (PLMs) such as BERT, they have been applied for text encoding for KGC.
However, the current methods mostly prefer to fine-tune PLMs, leading to huge
training costs and limited scalability to larger PLMs. In contrast, we propose
to utilize prompts and perform KGC on a frozen PLM with only the prompts
trained. Accordingly, we propose a new KGC method named PDKGC with two prompts
-- a hard task prompt which is to adapt the KGC task to the PLM pre-training
task of token prediction, and a disentangled structure prompt which learns
disentangled graph representation so as to enable the PLM to combine more
relevant structure knowledge with the text information. With the two prompts,
PDKGC builds a textual predictor and a structural predictor, respectively, and
their combination leads to more comprehensive entity prediction. Solid
evaluation on two widely used KGC datasets has shown that PDKGC often
outperforms the baselines including the state-of-the-art, and its components
are all effective. Our codes and data are available at
https://github.com/genggengcss/PDKGC. | [
0.0414398611,
0.0398176797,
-0.0022920473,
0.0279882438,
0.0048520681,
0.0037030897,
-0.0430966839,
0.0081641413,
0.0964316577,
-0.0118244831,
0.0176165104,
0.0011962416,
0.0065438086,
0.0610645972,
0.0328168198,
-0.0104594389,
0.0406807512,
0.0009628414,
0.0178133566,
-0.0472444333,
-0.0058869906,
0.0180452671,
0.014101617,
-0.0064319996,
-0.0054628914,
-0.0165203959,
-0.0316454992,
0.0245006345,
-0.0265272222,
-0.0491345339,
0.0062120529,
0.0406702869,
0.0314805619,
-0.0233933609,
0.0000020835,
-0.0247765575,
0.0047154441,
-0.0120195122,
-0.054231327,
-0.0081088329,
-0.0326488391,
-0.0266008824,
0.0549408384,
-0.0069640833,
-0.0326585881,
-0.0493881628,
0.0296972096,
0.043113932,
0.0077916929,
0.0592162684,
-0.0059004449,
-0.0145981889,
0.0295504089,
-0.0454758517,
-0.0157073345,
-0.019062208,
0.0431428328,
-0.014904147,
-0.0274883434,
0.0298194792,
-0.0632093698,
0.0127371354,
0.0266348794,
0.0218112599,
0.0527202003,
0.0593156703,
-0.0125788338,
-0.0153648928,
0.0166114923,
0.1362970471,
0.0059775603,
-0.0064635132,
0.013238647,
0.0002503988,
-0.0123159988,
0.0128429253,
-0.0176910143,
-0.048328571,
0.0140429242,
0.0170992073,
-0.0158025287,
-0.0074610594,
0.0446641371,
-0.0090532387,
-0.0175763499,
0.0317917652,
0.0259137768,
-0.0331467278,
0.015982084,
0.0230218098,
-0.0183812585,
-0.0625966489,
-0.0120532643,
-0.0109810373,
-0.0320556685,
0.0159796905,
-0.0309845731,
0.0040465584,
-0.0150967715,
0.004607603,
-0.0173763726,
0.0140399747,
-0.0090346029,
0.0468613133,
-0.0688335747,
0.0318600982,
-0.0010329688,
0.0437019616,
-0.0385273509,
-0.0327355601,
-0.0422654524,
0.0159665495,
-0.0547236167,
0.0748766586,
-0.0185694043,
-0.0545933582,
-0.0144707402,
0.0313063636,
-0.0024189898,
0.067511797,
0.0275203604,
0.033395119,
0.0033811014,
-0.0067550181,
-0.0274280962,
0.0295430347,
-0.0540299788,
-0.0013371016,
-0.0295899771,
0.0272415616,
-0.032572668,
0.0033097779,
0.0270682387,
-0.0444418602,
0.016565565,
0.0251784846,
-0.0085604871,
-0.0476238951,
-0.0192517806,
-0.0087122424,
-0.0039851796,
-0.0419634804,
0.0217064843,
-0.0407823287,
0.0885886922,
0.0253918767,
-0.0086747957,
-0.0282121431,
0.0338623598,
-0.0262284782,
-0.0632870272,
0.0690893829,
-0.0520929582,
-0.0168944523,
-0.0259472355,
-0.0047622034,
-0.0244646668,
0.0495536439,
0.0028547423,
0.056247659,
0.0322812721,
-0.0005322373,
-0.0371767282,
0.0111044543,
0.083851032,
0.017877806,
0.0119367065,
0.03951516,
0.0107987532,
0.0228732172,
0.0205920637,
0.0597697683,
-0.0373133048,
0.012590427,
0.0440461412,
0.0209163353,
0.0304560978,
-0.0102866124,
0.0037405768,
0.0179554857,
-0.0374153554,
0.0018643177,
-0.0499287471,
0.0071914219,
-0.046208404,
0.0337574519,
0.0521226674,
-0.0104430066,
-0.0422496162,
-0.0009657686,
0.0358276218,
-0.041113209,
0.050161548,
0.0149098597,
0.0665840134,
0.0459238887,
-0.0853708535,
0.0319713913,
0.0179251004,
-0.0135383643,
0.0309084225,
0.0176276155,
0.0255396646,
0.0652542636,
0.068343848,
-0.0036766143,
-0.019279724,
-0.015456167,
0.0084957816,
0.0063489112,
0.0107025355,
-0.017507717,
0.0192750152,
-0.0424799845,
-0.0678958744,
-0.0078563616,
-0.0112074791,
0.0083080791,
0.039892029,
0.027624853,
0.02817991,
-0.0612823442,
0.0332797058,
0.018087456,
-0.0271152109,
-0.0093471985,
0.0062102396,
0.0355744064,
0.0085675828,
0.0315068662,
0.0121058095,
0.0002813984,
0.0453621969,
-0.0299244709,
-0.0455997586,
-0.043070551,
-0.0100758849,
-0.1206375957,
0.0167071056,
-0.0008758494,
-0.0002436617,
-0.0137275653,
-0.042319838,
-0.0661947578,
0.0278144963,
-0.0064567165,
0.0888650268,
-0.0082604932,
-0.0413627997,
0.0044992468,
-0.0109377177,
0.0169144664,
0.0749484599,
-0.0286256876,
0.0205729529,
0.0060025593,
0.0167971719,
-0.0133992108,
0.0052129193,
-0.0530697331,
0.016039649,
0.019815227,
-0.0283025131,
0.0277746003,
-0.0088562472,
-0.0631248429,
-0.0157276299,
-0.1050325036,
-0.0068655037,
-0.0043992498,
-0.0068772179,
-0.0181899313,
0.0214524511,
0.0114342254,
-0.0381245427,
-0.0306766927,
-0.0117752375,
-0.0322513171,
0.0269214623,
0.0155162271,
-0.0095425909,
-0.0106936265,
-0.0128912404,
-0.0345123298,
0.0049319179,
0.0692415833,
-0.0367944352,
-0.0394916683,
-0.0002879426,
0.0486780778,
-0.0386004448,
0.0051328465,
-0.0206708536,
0.0031878562,
-0.0088781128,
-0.0178481918,
0.0635373816,
0.0453524217,
-0.0315822512,
0.0159272105,
0.0111865057,
-0.0024970828,
-0.0570431538,
-0.0026915618,
-0.0775348619,
0.0250919182,
-0.022365069,
0.0153092155,
-0.0159021337,
0.0255992636,
0.0137263341,
-0.0226528496,
-0.0894939676,
-0.0432959385,
0.015271754,
0.0138160773,
-0.0436546355,
-0.0111392019,
0.0161982458,
0.0184979886,
-0.0318805389,
-0.0187723283,
0.0918949544,
-0.0248405766,
-0.0065487307,
0.027919678,
0.0176378619,
-0.0301239975,
0.0850018039,
0.0350036249,
-0.0033127023,
-0.0030285334,
-0.0290754884,
-0.0475939512,
0.0296285413,
-0.0067204488,
-0.0206232052,
-0.0171705708,
0.0578633696,
0.0233699922,
0.0505567864,
-0.0127336159,
-0.0279463585,
-0.0273569822,
-0.0280743502,
0.0165194944,
0.0269028377,
-0.0140745649,
0.0087325489,
-0.0202386305,
-0.023759447,
-0.0034542105,
-0.0059700352,
0.0120384479,
-0.0506146327,
0.0432999358,
0.0455278419,
-0.0393508859,
-0.0043124342,
-0.0338269137,
0.0284241997,
0.0412565842,
0.0005877615,
-0.0213976074,
-0.0021231228,
0.0167439692,
0.0185062476,
-0.011564414,
-0.0316019952,
-0.0107760848,
0.0380711555,
0.0145337349,
0.0216086004,
0.1078288481,
0.0015256259,
-0.0355535969,
0.0044559152,
0.0392634198,
0.0370032042,
0.0259708762,
0.0067752055,
-0.1179869473,
-0.0207935292,
-0.0011507657,
0.0173805337,
0.0616568439,
-0.0642630234,
0.0163871311,
-0.0855575576,
-0.0369384326,
0.0222253799,
0.0347172916,
-0.0750606805,
-0.059584666,
-0.0069799167,
0.0014544543,
-0.0103969714,
-0.0066145463,
0.0263417661,
0.0260307733,
-0.0218961276,
-0.0228852704,
-0.0361617804,
0.0244671032,
-0.0405241549,
0.0666624829,
0.0435113162,
0.0216245502,
-0.0010248943,
-0.0318663828,
-0.0282665547,
0.0116025489,
-0.0539722554,
-0.0050463383,
0.0437285304,
-0.0329626985,
0.0026024003,
-0.0270734709,
0.0165053476,
-0.0375404879,
-0.0236308128,
-0.0196212884,
0.0847018138,
0.0150000183,
-0.0529035293,
0.0036651026,
-0.0131268948,
0.006259169,
0.0633614883,
0.0338981226,
-0.0054176096,
-0.0206170976,
-0.0203543771,
0.0611109212,
-0.0200270042,
0.0596295483,
0.021917915,
-0.0335749015,
0.0524579622,
-0.055384215,
-0.0210009832,
0.0730257407,
-0.0081165005,
0.0001496306,
0.0310281105,
0.011985858,
-0.0374551117,
-0.0622801408,
0.010194621,
-0.0137673197,
0.0069410866,
-0.0368947312,
-0.0290178098,
-0.0074725612,
-0.013375639,
-0.0202971976,
-0.0215843003,
-0.0466984957,
-0.0620871484,
-0.0470443927,
0.0501780435,
0.0006920531,
0.0728832185,
-0.0437107161,
-0.0137219606,
0.0680643916,
0.018622946,
-0.0457653366,
-0.0026075202,
0.0035450233,
-0.0008098806,
0.0102848709,
0.023995379,
-0.0673632398,
-0.0011533158,
-0.0060744928,
0.0725640282,
0.0012685108,
-0.0586929247,
-0.00587752,
0.0525389686,
0.0511735976,
-0.0015140576,
0.0370223187,
-0.0623930097,
0.022213649,
-0.002101216,
-0.002431687,
-0.0462047346,
-0.0193958413,
0.0449951515,
-0.0149610974,
0.0281911418,
-0.0112833008,
0.0069410461,
0.0424445495,
-0.0345501937,
-0.0428996533,
-0.0057466063,
0.0049185837,
0.0807802007,
-0.0004508177,
-0.0128479348,
0.053208176,
0.02151151,
-0.0014870813,
-0.0500418618,
0.0080331787,
0.0242188238,
0.0029575003,
-0.0207210407,
0.0020081939,
-0.0331285223,
-0.0116677964,
-0.0327215418,
0.0279355273,
0.0432576649,
0.0170284975,
0.0090418691,
-0.0107169058,
-0.0048934175,
0.0027471008,
0.0467807166,
-0.0141691249,
-0.0345130861,
0.0376663953,
0.0097024813,
-0.0288195014,
0.0040533673,
0.073635824,
0.0406762399,
0.0421037078,
0.0017382051,
-0.0076360148,
-0.0581417121,
-0.0212552641,
0.0231651664,
0.0833891034,
-0.0242806543,
0.0520116873,
-0.0192224421,
-0.0685630664,
0.0145716397,
-0.0311215967,
-0.0724287853,
0.018741712,
0.0235945471,
0.0074191159,
0.0390102677,
-0.0491081513,
-0.0389688015,
0.0161205027,
0.0359093733,
-0.0365928337,
0.0245316811,
-6.293992014e-33,
-0.0227374211,
-0.0241167061,
0.0129862865,
-0.0015602303,
-0.0357195735,
0.0280267596,
-0.0263208412,
-0.0377695598,
-0.0215782914,
0.0196979046,
-0.012278189,
0.0217674021,
-0.0154056856,
0.0491601378,
-0.0299049169,
-0.0333338752,
0.0350549519,
-0.0037042976,
0.0371607952,
0.0312800072,
0.0208878145,
0.0615357198,
0.038575802,
-0.0402617119,
0.0589149743,
-0.0437091477,
0.0268174261,
0.0046462817,
0.0341849253,
0.0095228264,
-0.0248061791,
0.0393782258,
-0.0054340633,
0.0216627773,
-0.021477377,
0.0206640456,
-0.1315370202,
-0.0694624856,
0.0239155162,
-0.0014051496,
-0.0573821142,
0.0049261353,
0.0119798938,
-0.003860486,
0.0713657662,
-0.0271016024,
0.0188682191,
0.0066333241,
-0.0726211891,
-0.0410885401,
-0.0092886304,
0.0080522066,
0.0223706588,
-0.0171420239,
0.0371678136,
0.0112740379,
0.0424836688,
-0.0098427106,
-0.0780383274,
0.0067224107,
0.0020143155,
-0.0056821047,
-0.0191091336,
0.0174877346,
0.0447127186,
0.042609144,
0.0021279268,
0.0070953188,
-0.0770081356,
0.0148665756,
-0.0098190829,
0.0537265837,
-0.021761518,
0.0099067772,
-0.0140171172,
-0.0482213721,
-0.069320567,
-0.0041933535,
0.0043174461,
0.0104409941,
-0.0153176207,
-0.0081053274,
-0.0224442463,
-0.0752838105,
-0.0561683066,
-0.0121037764,
-0.0141569506,
-0.0433921926,
-0.0093318103,
0.0281425398,
-0.0098339217,
-0.0314091332,
-0.01172614,
-0.0643620491,
-0.0256330036,
0.06236488,
0.0176964998,
-0.0084825736,
0.0150944889,
0.0551888831,
-0.0600666702,
-0.039421536,
0.0469070822,
-0.0734508112,
-0.0179357044,
0.0234445501,
0.0233761352,
-0.0096003423,
-0.0369431823,
-0.0240073614,
-0.0320142023,
-0.0231792144,
-0.001655232,
-0.0110690165,
0.0564561374,
0.0608210415,
-0.0046235123,
0.0182966217,
0.046748206,
0.04069902,
-0.0273316409,
0.027566947,
0.0362603031,
0.0321650244,
-0.0054920278,
-0.0057049915,
-0.0607493594,
0.0047714608,
0.0391699858,
-0.0421674289,
-0.0107062245,
-0.0127603095,
2.768e-7,
0.0442233384,
0.0413359515,
0.0211703144,
0.0075616557,
-0.0133401202,
0.0165232141,
0.0168780964,
0.0513372719,
-0.0211119093,
-0.0388425924,
0.0598518476,
0.0043032076,
0.0004897959,
0.0109968642,
-0.1043138579,
0.0211529639,
-0.0634911954,
-0.0132723004,
-0.0488990992,
-0.0070484686,
0.0412678011,
0.0518798828,
0.0641316026,
0.0239402913,
0.0017356505,
-0.0154609624,
0.0904341117,
-0.0007426715,
-0.0048667956,
-0.0165290162,
-0.0037238582,
0.0192648694,
-0.0174529292,
0.0657279193,
-0.0123860184,
0.0392398462,
0.0335446894,
0.0518522859,
0.019731747,
-0.0105092181,
-0.0104920985,
-0.0050675711,
-0.004076032,
-0.0447193906,
0.1071985811,
-0.0723279715,
-0.0114262803,
0.024489617,
-0.0594817623,
-0.0040164548,
0.0222234316,
0.0152019868,
-0.0027550752,
0.0138591556,
0.0361367948,
0.0161933228,
0.0064127315,
-0.0853570998,
0.0098781949,
0.005119761,
-0.01954435,
-0.0417306833,
-0.0041056755,
-0.0373213999,
0.0078183049,
-0.0265141614,
0.0343495607,
2.825590413e-34,
0.0249290504,
-0.0101874331,
-0.0153249539,
0.0046759299,
0.0324914381,
-0.08142142,
0.0087342793,
-0.0044807424,
0.0345263928,
-0.104508765,
-0.0074264552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01823v1 | Exchange-of-Thought: Enhancing Large Language Model Capabilities through Cross-Model Communication | 2023-12-04T11:53:56 | 2023-12-04T11:53:56 | Zhangyue Yin, Qiushi Sun, Cheng Chang, Qipeng Guo, Junqi Dai, Xuanjing Huang, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently made significant strides in
complex reasoning tasks through the Chain-of-Thought technique. Despite this
progress, their reasoning is often constrained by their intrinsic
understanding, lacking external insights. To address this, we propose
Exchange-of-Thought (EoT), a novel framework that enables cross-model
communication during problem-solving. Drawing inspiration from network
topology, EoT integrates four unique communication paradigms: Memory, Report,
Relay, and Debate. This paper delves into the communication dynamics and volume
associated with each paradigm. To counterbalance the risks of incorrect
reasoning chains, we implement a robust confidence evaluation mechanism within
these communications. Our experiments across diverse complex reasoning tasks
demonstrate that EoT significantly surpasses established baselines,
underscoring the value of external insights in enhancing LLM performance.
Furthermore, we show that EoT achieves these superior results in a
cost-effective manner, marking a promising advancement for efficient and
collaborative AI problem-solving. | [
0.0266587306,
0.0498385541,
-0.0195924621,
0.0500038192,
-0.0776411742,
-0.0087699322,
0.0201675873,
-0.0379194357,
0.0352872945,
-0.0273099169,
-0.0477772653,
-0.0384797528,
0.0111552104,
0.0608159825,
0.0005531767,
-0.0196702443,
0.0208957493,
-0.0598620176,
0.0311068557,
-0.032656882,
-0.0055911038,
-0.0051250593,
-0.0294289328,
0.030591974,
-0.0110080317,
-0.0105080549,
-0.039825689,
-0.0339528956,
0.0395589992,
-0.0343875773,
-0.0330549888,
0.0233337972,
0.0151665779,
0.0649850518,
0.0000022559,
-0.0347020403,
-0.034299802,
0.0064880229,
-0.0532858633,
-0.0044111894,
-0.0308313482,
0.0323124714,
0.0167264212,
0.0340400301,
-0.0248083211,
0.0292772669,
0.0413614586,
0.0492710546,
0.0401143804,
0.0378783122,
0.0118349884,
0.0154491831,
0.0048940834,
-0.0328062475,
0.0020667841,
-0.0728784576,
0.020873256,
0.0504697785,
0.0155505529,
0.009936668,
-0.0270282049,
0.0408226326,
0.0456012562,
-0.047782626,
-0.0129265804,
0.0495723523,
-0.0073125195,
-0.0223607589,
-0.0159783009,
0.0439939462,
0.0256036706,
-0.0146605084,
-0.0225599818,
-0.0085689696,
0.0056469743,
0.0274473596,
-0.0530530438,
0.0408983752,
-0.0317101479,
0.0013875968,
0.012647205,
0.0162056498,
0.0475266986,
0.0149541041,
-0.0429752544,
0.083879903,
-0.0067099268,
-0.013292593,
0.0069244034,
0.0238104314,
-0.0023561257,
-0.0950584188,
0.0191205218,
0.0192454681,
-0.0554304756,
0.0168964006,
0.0152550563,
-0.0121808136,
-0.0248162504,
-0.0015112944,
0.059396714,
0.032105919,
0.0424327925,
0.0427598543,
-0.0150987823,
0.0089883246,
-0.0535450801,
0.025064161,
0.0038291537,
-0.0481735654,
-0.0639001504,
-0.0187446568,
-0.0108385561,
0.0713474452,
-0.0095365327,
-0.0232639704,
-0.0216559824,
0.0218481179,
-0.039884381,
0.0127423722,
0.0017929022,
0.0009942094,
0.0278117433,
-0.0516165793,
-0.0467872173,
0.0426344313,
-0.0027349202,
0.0201124102,
0.054728061,
-0.0368750244,
-0.031580992,
-0.019498514,
-0.0355361924,
-0.0201738067,
0.0125876497,
0.0820051208,
-0.0260456,
-0.0130297542,
0.0142961117,
-0.0377507843,
-0.0077997381,
-0.094067134,
0.0122170262,
-0.0682303831,
-0.0001186247,
0.0291447751,
-0.0038925281,
-0.0021383308,
0.0173536241,
-0.0242783092,
-0.0315697007,
0.0870810822,
0.0011875738,
0.0091608725,
0.0517722555,
0.039895311,
-0.0226005726,
0.0534581393,
0.0483457968,
0.0223336909,
0.0107242074,
0.0438197553,
0.0112543162,
0.0028093574,
0.0445974953,
-0.0146913063,
-0.0041123535,
0.0056655556,
0.0229035299,
0.0454757623,
-0.0447594561,
0.0774565265,
-0.0455719531,
0.0082543483,
0.073795557,
0.0548044033,
-0.000783603,
0.0167291537,
0.0222423747,
-0.0217671692,
-0.0037211126,
-0.0243748631,
-0.0331798941,
0.07633508,
-0.0247248542,
-0.0267902091,
0.0513785854,
0.0248946175,
-0.0305174682,
-0.0450482853,
-0.0062182881,
0.0167512111,
0.0084841792,
0.0437387154,
0.0317940563,
-0.0262465943,
-0.0040175593,
0.0498435125,
0.0037734583,
-0.0105897812,
-0.035892006,
-0.0645798519,
0.0416769944,
0.0394530147,
0.0406147726,
0.003604095,
-0.0191657301,
-0.0092494674,
0.0199580211,
0.0216665436,
0.0676963851,
-0.0070955232,
-0.0238939822,
-0.0379427373,
-0.0214702487,
-0.0269506872,
-0.0021125984,
0.0241806805,
0.021375211,
0.0129187061,
-0.0258673318,
0.0188791361,
-0.0271408726,
-0.0231238287,
-0.0218781419,
0.0660649613,
-0.0122251855,
0.0196339414,
0.0282194894,
0.0172654018,
-0.0106404647,
0.0331354402,
-0.0069737649,
-0.0113500161,
-0.0877690464,
0.0272628535,
-0.0499379784,
0.0094483411,
0.0280535519,
-0.044814419,
-0.0043865098,
-0.0308695398,
-0.0055607092,
-0.0374683402,
0.0593119152,
-0.0440083407,
0.0238162838,
-0.0093514919,
0.0054289317,
-0.0088571012,
-0.0301731676,
-0.0053791972,
0.0552138835,
-0.0082520768,
-0.0312141106,
0.0169749204,
0.0165175144,
0.0236819796,
-0.0264783464,
0.0230221096,
0.0398200452,
0.0256882645,
-0.00657818,
0.0275297351,
-0.0070570544,
-0.0440712459,
-0.0299264267,
-0.0701849982,
-0.0206939988,
-0.002732276,
0.0304899365,
0.0029818625,
-0.0078264736,
0.0087925829,
0.0194304921,
-0.0380928405,
0.0386052281,
0.0265136361,
0.020977322,
0.0274899527,
0.0183524247,
-0.0217535459,
-0.0063289097,
-0.0031549453,
-0.0201977212,
0.0635145456,
0.0353144221,
-0.0346366204,
-0.0519544818,
0.0321551263,
-0.0743683204,
0.0394150801,
-0.0140956491,
-0.0156130735,
0.041329354,
0.0047904253,
0.0117560951,
0.0780885294,
-0.0128599005,
-0.0069726445,
0.0716141313,
-0.0537785813,
-0.0729746893,
0.0169547442,
-0.004184112,
0.0030421291,
-0.0260478519,
-0.008670684,
-0.0261315536,
0.057699319,
0.0024002437,
-0.0138634164,
-0.058108855,
0.0336213782,
0.0101296585,
-0.0431360193,
-0.018305596,
-0.0583996065,
0.0288525447,
0.078663446,
-0.0295201764,
-0.0229100212,
0.1003444046,
-0.008150707,
0.02712062,
-0.0477417223,
-0.0022299106,
-0.0412670746,
0.0735104159,
-0.0491412282,
0.0234454125,
0.0187145546,
-0.000973622,
-0.0524826571,
-0.0155390678,
0.0291570406,
-0.0321123302,
0.0125549901,
-0.0698907673,
0.0099033946,
0.0145192584,
-0.0591119826,
-0.0293120109,
0.0396624953,
-0.0639953166,
0.0126217408,
0.0186627563,
-0.0418482386,
-0.0375357084,
-0.0021692414,
0.0689156428,
-0.0043247184,
-0.0102601685,
-0.0188599043,
0.0005051529,
-0.003046032,
0.0079746796,
-0.0102811269,
0.0699216649,
-0.0296491031,
0.0541632883,
0.0817782283,
0.0257875156,
-0.0061147609,
-0.0132923992,
-0.0166661385,
-0.0062188748,
0.0182108972,
-0.0216127541,
-0.0144329658,
0.0647211894,
-0.0323465504,
-0.0564508699,
0.0937946439,
0.0498770587,
-0.0788630098,
-0.0287605543,
-0.0624404624,
0.0298766792,
0.0297176111,
0.036506515,
-0.0616029352,
-0.00819463,
0.0269616209,
-0.0423290767,
-0.0246223398,
-0.0770956427,
-0.0124477129,
-0.1338417083,
0.0216012001,
-0.0214774217,
-0.0022238893,
-0.0520887747,
-0.0272766445,
0.0023668376,
0.0090289516,
-0.0172015671,
-0.0152648985,
0.044203788,
-0.0100912927,
0.0154340928,
0.0086572235,
-0.0084255468,
0.0419199355,
-0.0371627845,
0.0496687107,
0.0332673714,
0.0175752565,
0.0217904896,
-0.0441717319,
0.0087723341,
0.0208439622,
-0.0016834734,
-0.0163141601,
0.0274828039,
-0.0087350439,
-0.009950757,
-0.0160700642,
0.0220885668,
0.0031797877,
-0.0260797385,
0.0092715733,
0.1043879092,
-0.0383591652,
-0.0028847633,
0.0081277918,
0.0172066949,
0.0254683495,
0.0706122071,
0.0256552882,
-0.0121293571,
-0.0154839512,
-0.0328756459,
-0.0395812653,
-0.0154700857,
-0.0368270501,
0.0081028109,
0.0629005432,
0.0274831671,
-0.0400985628,
-0.0051600002,
0.020150071,
0.0435812138,
-0.0001372539,
-0.017594384,
0.0230763219,
0.0131834354,
-0.0136215743,
-0.0145215327,
-0.0627364591,
0.0250321534,
-0.0053163357,
0.0410283431,
-0.0046568471,
-0.0206892025,
-0.014751113,
0.0454483517,
-0.0750113726,
-0.0886817053,
-0.031198509,
0.0320495814,
0.0334781371,
0.0334357321,
-0.0227409601,
-0.0559662767,
0.0270663407,
-0.0176174641,
-0.0295383092,
0.0003246556,
0.0359715931,
0.0185382981,
0.0231672879,
0.0538395904,
-0.0231564641,
-0.0187294744,
0.0398796946,
0.0205875095,
-0.0208935216,
-0.0393682718,
0.0137998359,
0.0058679101,
-0.0130903758,
0.0211990867,
-0.0066309762,
-0.0342580602,
0.0400757752,
-0.0510379225,
-0.0416159481,
-0.0388549827,
0.0186838042,
0.0114971753,
-0.0320639312,
0.0321669802,
0.003877237,
0.0392759331,
0.0177409314,
0.0285314787,
-0.0086259805,
0.0181279574,
0.0318279788,
0.0408428013,
-0.0064061875,
0.0101631219,
-0.0162777212,
0.0338915363,
0.0513151363,
-0.0128391124,
0.0919907168,
0.0455523282,
-0.0737133846,
-0.024761837,
0.0216093753,
-0.0903376192,
-0.1333227158,
0.0487412177,
0.0507527478,
0.0356648192,
0.0566787831,
-0.0055030081,
-0.0725234225,
-0.003909111,
0.0123304576,
0.0189970173,
0.0195721034,
-0.0203224923,
0.0444842242,
0.0123041105,
0.0084756864,
0.0177715737,
0.0389836803,
-0.0554757379,
0.0260048807,
-0.016132839,
-0.0452643633,
-0.018961994,
-0.025294967,
-0.0203396007,
0.0108901625,
-0.0301127974,
0.0231867973,
-0.0740656182,
-0.0712683126,
0.022777183,
0.0330890492,
0.0214859787,
0.0102078291,
0.0114972452,
0.0820068344,
0.0287398249,
0.0082770539,
-0.0161545575,
0.0048035365,
-0.0030033321,
0.0006540487,
-0.03338084,
-7.051109559e-33,
0.0055925269,
-0.0685199499,
0.0355670303,
-0.0176145677,
-0.0190855172,
0.0048693432,
-0.0479936488,
0.033934366,
-0.0198589396,
0.0368357189,
-0.0113155385,
0.0437973961,
0.0085130138,
0.0030213296,
0.0321670733,
-0.0018270171,
0.0069401325,
-0.0117347697,
-0.0430362783,
0.0185231883,
0.0430030711,
-0.0142021244,
0.0252507869,
-0.0587914251,
0.0203420632,
0.0350781418,
-0.0071121021,
0.0523527898,
-0.0573738478,
0.0356642827,
-0.0200267807,
0.0097694667,
0.0162856188,
-0.0511998832,
0.011735186,
0.0012317044,
-0.0060893381,
-0.0199302211,
0.0276613217,
-0.0562958978,
-0.0344311856,
-0.0336922817,
-0.0154310549,
0.0146823879,
-0.000393621,
-0.034862522,
-0.0137539944,
-0.017064875,
0.0143384365,
0.0345217921,
-0.0128134266,
0.0008785255,
-0.0247861203,
-0.0252850614,
0.0283805169,
0.0142529877,
0.0039715269,
-0.0155320568,
-0.0543419123,
0.0319101214,
-0.0144301625,
-0.0143910879,
0.081615217,
-0.0122183822,
-0.0209131353,
0.037572898,
0.0222075228,
0.0213979334,
-0.031900622,
-0.0201306399,
-0.0243170373,
0.0388000049,
0.0563091524,
0.0339883752,
-0.0588258617,
0.0424399823,
-0.1116791815,
-0.0435124151,
0.0077142501,
0.0503373817,
0.0395146534,
0.026785614,
-0.0412853397,
-0.0187257156,
-0.0468046889,
-0.0391149037,
-0.055358775,
0.0012509366,
0.0062403558,
0.0162589829,
-0.007975054,
-0.0061190398,
0.0336777531,
-0.0404148698,
-0.0263577104,
0.0223426577,
0.0237106625,
0.0227935389,
-0.0014080539,
0.0209573433,
-0.0815586224,
0.0241682548,
-0.0327526592,
0.0558779277,
-0.0177332237,
0.0084055681,
0.031835258,
0.0028986111,
-0.0305606145,
0.0000486388,
-0.0764686689,
0.0189883597,
0.0036887708,
-0.0049785441,
0.0062610679,
0.0185461622,
-0.0208570659,
0.0405404717,
-0.0043437071,
0.0098235412,
-0.0147572365,
0.0280031674,
-0.0071079019,
0.0035950588,
-0.0234348569,
-0.0150969774,
-0.06531699,
-0.0021462038,
0.0501315854,
-0.0286240261,
-0.0339641385,
-0.0101127755,
3.076e-7,
0.0063757193,
0.0289748944,
0.0218875539,
0.0525163561,
0.0347096808,
0.0497731008,
-0.0127101969,
-0.0179379936,
0.0349822529,
-0.0417836271,
-0.0131716793,
0.0810519308,
0.0368070267,
0.0538365096,
-0.0405570194,
-0.0542940348,
-0.0570988581,
-0.0406034328,
-0.031207351,
-0.0325021073,
0.0245980509,
0.0357932411,
0.0336449072,
0.0098576639,
-0.0064857169,
0.0081274211,
0.0727600306,
-0.0260762237,
-0.0120744118,
0.0059826598,
0.0320165157,
-0.0081982613,
-0.0087422561,
0.0438690558,
0.0144513799,
-0.0058002658,
-0.0324646905,
0.006739472,
0.0279743206,
-0.0314329863,
-0.0397511348,
-0.0135948965,
-0.0038322266,
-0.0565640703,
0.0475455597,
-0.0898667723,
-0.045895122,
-0.0191888977,
0.0511073247,
-0.0338148773,
0.0496255159,
-0.0022129498,
-0.0067911921,
0.0126974825,
-0.0203980245,
0.032785438,
0.0301317386,
-0.0874591097,
-0.0041798563,
-0.0205883048,
-0.036407955,
-0.0557911955,
-0.0283318236,
-0.0332594998,
0.015917521,
-0.0410759673,
0.0277247932,
2.912410773e-34,
0.0366517603,
-0.0031632064,
0.021031661,
0.0423001014,
0.0692728236,
-0.0180782694,
-0.0206025485,
-0.0191816166,
0.0292476937,
-0.0923502147,
-0.0344461352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01787v1 | Developing Linguistic Patterns to Mitigate Inherent Human Bias in Offensive Language Detection | 2023-12-04T10:20:36 | 2023-12-04T10:20:36 | Toygar Tanyel, Besher Alkurdi, Serkan Ayvaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the proliferation of social media, there has been a sharp increase in
offensive content, particularly targeting vulnerable groups, exacerbating
social problems such as hatred, racism, and sexism. Detecting offensive
language use is crucial to prevent offensive language from being widely shared
on social media. However, the accurate detection of irony, implication, and
various forms of hate speech on social media remains a challenge. Natural
language-based deep learning models require extensive training with large,
comprehensive, and labeled datasets. Unfortunately, manually creating such
datasets is both costly and error-prone. Additionally, the presence of
human-bias in offensive language datasets is a major concern for deep learning
models. In this paper, we propose a linguistic data augmentation approach to
reduce bias in labeling processes, which aims to mitigate the influence of
human bias by leveraging the power of machines to improve the accuracy and
fairness of labeling processes. This approach has the potential to improve
offensive language classification tasks across multiple languages and reduce
the prevalence of offensive content on social media. | [
0.0690249577,
0.0893279463,
-0.0037300782,
0.0480603352,
0.0054591782,
0.0473279878,
0.0305536352,
-0.0140989646,
0.0304306857,
-0.0531143658,
-0.017635975,
-0.0079843393,
-0.0218535587,
0.0245704874,
-0.0103267441,
-0.034008611,
0.034661904,
0.0768453926,
0.0514004007,
-0.0355280526,
0.049436368,
0.0314218216,
-0.0002834089,
0.0311826188,
-0.0660848394,
0.0074494197,
0.0501877181,
0.0182069652,
0.0229106192,
0.0035284108,
0.0692517981,
0.0365921035,
-0.0019500261,
0.0565657429,
0.0000015898,
-0.0455020703,
0.0304776207,
-0.0169252045,
-0.021320425,
-0.0346756876,
0.1114242375,
-0.03702024,
-0.0337496772,
0.0195531808,
-0.025847109,
0.0134865269,
0.0902882144,
0.0376812704,
0.0539246984,
0.0403086916,
-0.0079107508,
-0.025811797,
-0.0065805698,
0.0026042797,
-0.0141850095,
-0.0008991851,
0.0309750792,
-0.0512725823,
-0.0750886053,
-0.0031282359,
-0.0361895896,
-0.0027988472,
0.0442569368,
0.031449452,
0.0040508863,
-0.0191642717,
-0.0191796031,
-0.042677179,
0.0150685366,
0.0750761181,
-0.0350370929,
-0.0059832358,
-0.0338775665,
-0.0221133474,
0.0010118061,
-0.0566878729,
-0.0033421991,
0.010273247,
0.0037001115,
0.0603551194,
0.0163940396,
0.0057661524,
0.0460247807,
0.1053709537,
0.0303183626,
0.0295054689,
-0.0369916223,
-0.0331053324,
0.015973147,
0.0122964745,
-0.004531478,
0.0166508127,
0.0304259658,
-0.0171873253,
-0.0092966985,
0.0241404083,
-0.055176314,
-0.0557979755,
0.0259969067,
-0.0734475404,
-0.007118423,
0.0243045799,
-0.087938033,
0.013159507,
0.0231441241,
0.0150871715,
-0.0035433096,
0.0390958898,
-0.0131490044,
-0.0363869555,
-0.0103826867,
0.0113897799,
0.0056073363,
-0.0217784084,
0.0009192098,
0.0411348753,
-0.0541839637,
-0.0206715595,
-0.074257426,
-0.0390089415,
0.0019509813,
0.0580234528,
-0.0468415804,
0.0004374628,
-0.0235317331,
0.0047504837,
-0.0394236706,
0.0278015677,
-0.0519984253,
-0.0858964995,
0.01853103,
0.0146285649,
-0.007964219,
-0.0300090965,
0.0500151515,
0.0400815383,
0.0098193074,
-0.0426818766,
-0.0342537016,
-0.0224475637,
-0.0150775211,
-0.0120148184,
0.0038035193,
-0.0659434497,
0.0420565344,
-0.0321061425,
-0.0451831222,
-0.0810549036,
-0.0006689817,
0.0129066501,
-0.0700690746,
0.0702508241,
-0.0100225462,
-0.0412541181,
0.053743273,
0.0162398983,
-0.0071164831,
0.0628060326,
0.0382525474,
0.0275749397,
0.0546168871,
0.0107181985,
-0.0024012777,
0.050346572,
0.0331327319,
0.0173013378,
-0.0538957566,
0.0052500935,
-0.0684277639,
-0.0125466017,
0.0403824039,
0.0329911932,
0.0141228829,
-0.0695239156,
0.0335604213,
0.0254452378,
-0.0412159227,
0.0489792265,
0.0420373306,
0.0284744147,
-0.0315974839,
-0.0380533449,
-0.0648694113,
0.0015315083,
0.0164254513,
-0.0578768402,
0.0195962973,
0.0641724616,
-0.0175211877,
-0.0551091023,
-0.0043010968,
-0.0214410685,
0.083506532,
-0.0171400737,
0.0279114209,
0.0307283029,
0.0047713886,
0.0065982151,
0.0594368502,
-0.025305206,
0.0145760737,
-0.0275508687,
-0.0164185222,
0.058807686,
0.006224222,
-0.0134906592,
-0.0094424393,
-0.0579273067,
0.0235590916,
0.0528348312,
0.0261371154,
0.0052055162,
0.0317243151,
-0.0344838053,
-0.0360796489,
0.037553817,
0.0029179887,
0.0178812556,
0.0699718893,
0.0330135822,
0.0140694538,
0.0284269024,
-0.0373809114,
0.0380175747,
0.0281362887,
-0.0319375433,
0.037207853,
0.033893913,
0.0483526997,
0.0313685425,
-0.0204643793,
-0.0674441904,
-0.0096281413,
-0.0122661144,
-0.0640516877,
-0.0037213494,
-0.0318029337,
-0.0049879071,
0.0249126609,
-0.0537136979,
-0.0406155065,
0.0664667189,
-0.0548114777,
0.0223338399,
0.047827024,
-0.0229764543,
-0.0374595635,
-0.0402534865,
-0.0618471205,
-0.0555056408,
0.0598690026,
0.0091718277,
0.0633314103,
-0.026041938,
-0.023690328,
0.00643453,
-0.0472807214,
0.0069198366,
0.0207743943,
-0.0172673576,
-0.0213348716,
-0.0411694869,
0.0155560616,
0.0104643134,
0.0345757417,
-0.0211914387,
0.0241263956,
-0.0642939135,
0.0019383981,
-0.0120318932,
-0.0256503131,
-0.0022200623,
0.0041168039,
-0.0230899695,
-0.0132001685,
-0.0264963526,
-0.0480028391,
0.0270593427,
0.0341724344,
0.003648116,
-0.0619668514,
-0.0180087537,
-0.0228540767,
-0.0272806622,
-0.0150299286,
0.0101090167,
0.0097967405,
-0.0355448537,
0.0404173508,
-0.0365597419,
-0.0350723639,
0.0285594389,
0.011148856,
-0.0685381442,
0.0193810668,
0.0438485891,
-0.055209782,
0.0524436682,
0.0447262451,
0.0629938245,
0.0193717554,
0.0126960045,
-0.0138387,
0.0285616536,
-0.0148757938,
0.0238414705,
0.0083297323,
-0.0436604507,
-0.0358338729,
0.0565950833,
0.0464729145,
-0.0128959473,
-0.0311379768,
0.0238911062,
-0.0448985733,
-0.0572064146,
-0.026098296,
-0.0472560003,
-0.0342088379,
-0.0330247656,
-0.0641692355,
-0.0744905546,
0.0884262994,
0.038038332,
0.0000025776,
-0.046021793,
-0.0151621755,
-0.0097063826,
0.031188257,
0.0025096477,
0.0408532806,
-0.0422014967,
-0.0077668512,
0.0056299898,
-0.0209274702,
0.0112623032,
-0.0251869075,
-0.0138496896,
-0.0096695349,
-0.0240757428,
0.0210762918,
-0.0543336123,
-0.0809372589,
-0.0494118333,
-0.0500671528,
-0.0297428742,
-0.0156270415,
-0.0013492513,
0.0010197618,
-0.0430398956,
0.0143592115,
-0.0056105191,
0.0056240913,
0.0207583066,
0.0084364703,
-0.0498719737,
0.0180492233,
0.0026799575,
0.0212968905,
0.0378825814,
-0.0344472006,
0.0384890251,
-0.0183530673,
0.0077362605,
-0.0145289693,
0.0298057515,
0.0177789424,
0.026132524,
0.0075309058,
-0.0118257469,
-0.0100149931,
-0.005419929,
0.0250628423,
0.0750905052,
0.0177789349,
-0.0189994145,
0.0219763536,
-0.0048410757,
-0.0113796815,
0.0282477234,
-0.015133746,
-0.0936897993,
-0.0327204131,
-0.0189956203,
0.0038411464,
-0.0874074548,
-0.0343991742,
-0.0081950873,
-0.0590706021,
0.0079389596,
-0.0134284412,
-0.0359324403,
-0.0176787898,
0.003307394,
0.0266620517,
-0.0286296867,
0.0430216603,
-0.0499762036,
0.0540835559,
-0.0154228732,
0.0137086296,
-0.051430326,
-0.0497851372,
0.0298231132,
-0.0284187421,
0.0405378751,
0.0249507632,
0.0554951094,
-0.0443788506,
-0.0044466374,
0.0395811871,
-0.0019905835,
-0.0234311521,
-0.0443696119,
0.0507094525,
-0.0131779416,
-0.0475481153,
-0.0219614897,
0.0571342744,
-0.0199042223,
0.0064496184,
-0.0199581496,
0.0430896319,
0.0435208678,
0.0154566029,
-0.0736390948,
0.0149170831,
0.0200739466,
0.0734281689,
0.0203002952,
-0.0674457029,
0.0298064947,
-0.0564732403,
-0.0204875469,
-0.0452485308,
-0.0404837243,
0.0147428289,
-0.030703621,
-0.0365114547,
-0.0275156479,
-0.04124761,
0.0277477652,
-0.0277802777,
0.0053541902,
-0.0346709304,
-0.0144124907,
-0.0309567414,
-0.0328595154,
0.0029345287,
-0.0082375621,
0.0361272246,
-0.0001836639,
-0.0100774802,
-0.0351424776,
-0.0318408236,
-0.0341368914,
0.0490733646,
-0.025013797,
-0.0456107296,
0.0934122875,
0.0459113345,
0.0045847213,
0.0310461801,
-0.0232452024,
-0.0719783679,
0.038876459,
0.1001560465,
-0.0089339931,
-0.0200301409,
0.0485974625,
-0.0037058489,
0.011124799,
0.0206024107,
-0.0231855623,
0.0659742802,
0.0454801768,
-0.0261133388,
-0.0328783058,
-0.0452734381,
-0.0236006025,
-0.0067731515,
0.0516418368,
-0.0164958108,
-0.0570128635,
-0.0327710882,
-0.0259607267,
0.0236789528,
-0.0445700549,
-0.0110804914,
0.0208419152,
0.0253238101,
-0.0000149034,
-0.0516997054,
-0.0234231055,
-0.0347367488,
0.0223133788,
-0.0080345264,
0.0069517721,
0.0167462789,
0.0454309694,
-0.0212925747,
0.040613886,
-0.0262695346,
0.041943159,
0.0066533545,
-0.0225644931,
0.0003641513,
0.0133432439,
0.0229799841,
0.0171861611,
-0.012427412,
-0.0244064182,
0.0293329153,
0.0089167701,
-0.0534537211,
-0.0175378211,
0.0137354545,
-0.0341557451,
0.0221428033,
-0.0161896367,
-0.0107703656,
-0.0024604979,
-0.0222418774,
-0.0231367368,
-0.0637670457,
0.0233743135,
0.0148005839,
-0.0207220428,
0.0105236964,
0.0064957677,
-0.0237467512,
0.0462283306,
0.0238851998,
-0.0413515195,
-0.002271422,
0.0107149119,
0.0377689339,
0.0050638118,
0.0136174466,
0.0497693345,
-0.0164877996,
-0.0462738201,
0.0102487952,
-0.0510826483,
0.0309972446,
-0.0120039685,
0.0407282226,
0.0582222603,
-0.0088089472,
0.0016432728,
0.0161252599,
0.0171738528,
-0.0030317614,
-0.0601693392,
-0.0147767616,
-5.288685736e-33,
0.0099069467,
0.0085767945,
-0.0166102163,
0.0130211022,
0.0284739751,
-0.0216733776,
0.0469647273,
-0.0080692852,
-0.0349639356,
0.0477826707,
0.0215295944,
0.0249424651,
0.0148694087,
0.0126860309,
0.0009250388,
-0.0424561054,
0.0281995051,
-0.0171057042,
-0.0202468149,
0.001332336,
0.0341956355,
0.0216434635,
0.0738150105,
-0.0782601982,
0.0558550209,
0.0065594031,
-0.0014850555,
0.035205666,
0.0365028605,
0.062677145,
-0.0097191557,
0.1271224618,
0.0451898575,
-0.0308666527,
0.004757781,
0.053503301,
-0.0481634922,
-0.0188036133,
0.009446281,
0.0347555988,
0.0043837018,
-0.0216141604,
0.0521164462,
0.0285839438,
-0.0292869378,
-0.0183072072,
0.0512354448,
-0.029557541,
0.0378621519,
-0.0210652184,
-0.066438213,
0.0103315115,
-0.0196305681,
-0.0158727448,
-0.0158330854,
0.0183407888,
0.0194227714,
0.0063554309,
-0.0658337995,
-0.0065985285,
-0.026017705,
-0.0254712142,
0.0092807999,
-0.0108144479,
-0.0014251544,
0.0693868548,
0.0157994367,
0.026202118,
-0.0289390907,
0.0277135056,
0.0492607541,
0.0126879541,
0.0393056273,
0.0790793896,
0.0576434396,
-0.0471768491,
-0.0430542789,
-0.0053180219,
0.0446056128,
0.0183356348,
0.0011236969,
-0.0358137116,
-0.0661027133,
-0.0244725421,
-0.0027428502,
-0.0262632947,
-0.0216841716,
-0.02198774,
0.0047687516,
-0.0183615144,
-0.0284517296,
0.00132217,
0.0144280707,
-0.0301500168,
0.0019745359,
0.0408671238,
-0.0081623103,
-0.0200785492,
0.0316808,
0.044340305,
-0.0482782125,
-0.007195536,
0.0058981092,
-0.025178222,
0.0349983461,
0.0104423035,
0.0842150301,
0.0347226113,
-0.0322746634,
0.0276861545,
-0.007332704,
0.0421364531,
-0.0138608227,
0.0369205289,
0.0033374391,
0.0613352284,
-0.0054628546,
0.0059900209,
0.0412311926,
-0.0110974424,
-0.0256747548,
-0.0202335231,
-0.0220953617,
-0.0000093957,
-0.0190208573,
-0.0208753645,
0.009703571,
-0.0320597589,
-0.0073304567,
-0.0952901989,
0.0067651495,
-0.0469443873,
2.213e-7,
0.0199203007,
0.0317539275,
0.0154590299,
0.0253182389,
0.017895788,
0.0433357619,
0.0512416102,
0.0488820486,
0.0030407496,
-0.0100351488,
-0.0096467491,
0.0619841442,
-0.0078874053,
0.041890569,
-0.0205640197,
-0.0021259934,
-0.0765578374,
0.0461027585,
-0.0180108026,
-0.0083286613,
0.0131290173,
0.0925602913,
0.0833689868,
-0.0711626932,
-0.0301147513,
-0.0219801776,
-0.0108086839,
-0.0256279837,
0.0232925601,
-0.0271216538,
0.0553756692,
0.0381541811,
0.0200377759,
0.007384127,
-0.0046610511,
0.007222597,
0.0151352035,
0.0234128851,
0.0118524078,
0.0269273482,
0.0097188214,
-0.0140902326,
-0.0238054357,
-0.0179104302,
0.0442315154,
-0.0113862781,
-0.008884999,
-0.0408654623,
-0.0138902199,
0.0063064713,
0.0510059856,
-0.0420903414,
-0.019790493,
-0.0195588954,
0.0552444272,
-0.0188296549,
-0.0209900159,
-0.0715484545,
-0.0204006843,
-0.0198731925,
-0.0478513055,
-0.0104334243,
0.0033810167,
0.0147544211,
0.0263746139,
0.0169175752,
0.0554580986,
1.331692525e-34,
0.0052094073,
-0.0245495085,
0.0105906669,
-0.0503486618,
0.013517933,
0.0371844135,
-0.0093198335,
0.0056821755,
0.0262678694,
0.0068138675,
-0.0059802216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01714v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01714v2 | Retrieval-augmented Multi-modal Chain-of-Thoughts Reasoning for Large Language Models | 2023-12-04T08:07:21 | 2024-03-03T06:12:44 | Bingshuai Liu, Chenyang Lyu, Zijun Min, Zhanyu Wang, Jinsong Su, Longyue Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has brought substantial
attention to the Chain of Thought (CoT) approach, primarily due to its ability
to enhance the capability of LLMs on complex reasoning tasks. Moreover, the
significance of CoT approaches extends to the application of LLMs for
multi-modal tasks. However, the selection of optimal CoT demonstration examples
in multi-modal reasoning remains less explored for LLMs due to the inherent
complexity of multi-modal examples. In this paper, we introduce a novel
approach that addresses this challenge by using retrieval mechanisms to
dynamically and automatically select demonstration examples based on
cross-modal and intra-modal similarities. Furthermore, we employ a Stratified
Sampling method of categorising demonstration examples into groups based on
their types and then retrieving examples from different groups respectively to
promote the diversity of demonstration examples. Through a series of
experiments on two popular benchmark datasets: ScienceQA and MathVista, we
demonstrate that our approach significantly improves the performance of GPT-4
by 6% on ScienceQA and 12.9% on MathVista, and enhances the performance of
GPT-4V on two datasets by 2.7%, substantially improving the performance of the
most advanced LLMs and LMMs for complex multi-modal reasoning tasks. | [
0.0031303423,
0.0734704435,
-0.0262834057,
0.0564147159,
-0.0841976777,
-0.0049455706,
0.030504765,
0.0128924707,
0.00731399,
-0.0774010047,
-0.0360625349,
-0.0279636178,
-0.0241234507,
-0.0159716681,
0.0350042656,
-0.0331251882,
0.053006202,
-0.0618611798,
-0.0207841229,
-0.0203812867,
-0.0054201647,
0.0195258856,
-0.0390995517,
0.0247504637,
-0.0077771707,
-0.0446182638,
-0.0098789223,
-0.0364837311,
0.0273579601,
-0.0405682698,
-0.0029221324,
0.0657783896,
0.0658005029,
0.0413819216,
0.0000022651,
-0.0462792218,
-0.0554577224,
0.0095937913,
-0.0112251677,
-0.019844288,
0.0118694473,
0.031194374,
0.04522378,
0.0235867128,
-0.0340671465,
-0.0002806663,
0.0089382157,
0.0328493975,
0.0292077605,
0.0395714752,
-0.0009733101,
-0.0170236155,
0.0087159211,
0.004132817,
0.0321339034,
-0.0282931756,
0.0274802502,
0.0327605568,
0.0530911759,
0.0410506912,
0.00776023,
0.0344756171,
0.0131880715,
0.0202363022,
-0.055575639,
0.0337733366,
-0.0280391276,
0.0174389482,
0.0098844403,
0.0766618177,
0.0207369383,
-0.0326643363,
-0.0103241978,
0.0083808517,
-0.0032830297,
0.0665279031,
-0.0758489296,
0.0139577435,
-0.0364973024,
0.0136199631,
0.0111416643,
0.025674304,
0.0192415863,
0.0254539829,
-0.0478368178,
0.0432716683,
0.0218178574,
-0.0438665375,
0.0058894092,
0.0003033218,
-0.0360696726,
-0.0181036294,
0.019123381,
0.0398910157,
-0.0269047376,
0.0154299922,
0.0152873136,
-0.0481096171,
0.0127339,
0.021236565,
0.0469905101,
0.05330538,
-0.0176566038,
0.055031281,
-0.0504692756,
0.0306712016,
-0.0344235376,
0.0324961059,
-0.0124606397,
-0.0284642298,
-0.1052455902,
-0.0235014781,
-0.0316205211,
0.0660042167,
-0.0063715456,
-0.0032448112,
-0.0030514195,
-0.0051236837,
-0.026938647,
-0.0224587098,
-0.0073631834,
-0.026445372,
-0.0000843523,
-0.0392736569,
-0.0461086519,
0.0329854675,
-0.0238461513,
0.0413043238,
0.0080054421,
-0.053575065,
-0.0082912324,
-0.00856918,
-0.0052203182,
-0.0406164862,
0.0357314944,
0.0741816834,
-0.0277993381,
-0.027207857,
-0.0447315201,
-0.0502507091,
-0.0030968881,
-0.0727642179,
0.0308841579,
-0.0883250162,
0.0248019509,
0.0383326784,
-0.020564964,
0.003926388,
0.0116858175,
0.0296322796,
-0.014948939,
0.077376619,
0.0526992604,
0.0030079768,
0.0001978979,
0.0092307106,
-0.0528866388,
0.058548566,
0.0118849771,
-0.0061450205,
0.0173462648,
0.0309152715,
0.0257140361,
0.0227210186,
0.0184656736,
0.0139134824,
-0.028364962,
0.0162489023,
-0.0050973147,
0.035102129,
-0.0208422672,
0.0466899127,
-0.0394435637,
0.011960485,
0.0400511995,
0.0482107513,
0.0293752216,
0.0185939148,
0.0388054289,
0.0011426056,
0.0200853944,
-0.0050359461,
-0.0440396853,
0.0427395254,
-0.0588441491,
-0.0002256629,
0.0224309079,
0.0539388433,
-0.019415874,
-0.027733285,
-0.0200056732,
0.0313884281,
-0.0036643739,
0.0481757857,
0.0695912763,
-0.0217304435,
-0.0298255309,
0.0727160573,
0.0226060599,
-0.0211253762,
-0.0424602106,
-0.0610074438,
0.0248609353,
-0.0086024972,
0.0435732268,
-0.0706211925,
-0.0335238688,
0.0049191057,
-0.0023000429,
0.0066266092,
0.0210657232,
-0.0076855673,
-0.061275512,
-0.0618922077,
-0.0219272915,
0.0009359292,
0.0059382943,
0.0077798427,
0.0042992081,
0.0168402307,
0.0074176523,
-0.0634640753,
0.0724516809,
0.0046580727,
0.0279282872,
0.0260504391,
-0.0117071224,
0.0179334432,
0.0291814767,
-0.0065033161,
0.0179613344,
0.0313545838,
-0.0044985064,
-0.0401723832,
-0.0152654229,
-0.001163027,
-0.0463064983,
-0.0656988546,
0.0355828628,
-0.0319092982,
-0.0369144455,
0.0314442366,
-0.0367397033,
-0.041956462,
0.0262099262,
-0.0181585643,
0.0132634481,
-0.0452283509,
-0.0102040442,
-0.0017163513,
-0.0270078387,
-0.0448357128,
0.1120090336,
-0.0028586001,
0.0362764373,
0.0386706106,
0.0175441131,
0.0411794148,
-0.0186904222,
-0.0054292129,
0.0262140371,
-0.0181051828,
0.0163122378,
0.0045899595,
0.0068500629,
-0.041131705,
-0.0416377448,
-0.0937122479,
0.0048405272,
-0.001474152,
0.0168931186,
-0.0282073617,
-0.0162347369,
-0.0124726221,
0.0122718252,
-0.0365749858,
0.02014645,
0.012580567,
0.01675722,
0.0213573445,
-0.0086358935,
-0.0240329988,
-0.01054346,
-0.0087072151,
-0.0546738133,
0.0814034343,
-0.0342479385,
0.0048414189,
-0.0196353253,
0.0232525393,
-0.0611729845,
0.0126716392,
-0.0220452864,
0.0135553833,
0.0290989261,
-0.036825981,
0.0623674318,
0.0506799892,
-0.0084900158,
-0.0240658838,
0.0685382038,
-0.0198757723,
-0.0735465884,
0.0390631296,
-0.0046796543,
-0.0015481142,
0.0009961068,
0.0313639119,
-0.0421086214,
0.0376592502,
0.0014280209,
-0.0399761014,
-0.0357896201,
0.0194634199,
0.006082315,
0.0235976316,
-0.0536134765,
0.0123299845,
0.0093377335,
0.032162983,
0.0031787539,
-0.0235491544,
0.0820444822,
-0.0212616362,
0.0126826372,
-0.0631875247,
0.0283181239,
-0.0486614853,
0.0850150585,
-0.0277413335,
0.0011774667,
0.0061553661,
-0.0095100068,
-0.0707396045,
0.0121571766,
0.0416229181,
-0.0483276099,
0.0905043185,
-0.0616758689,
0.0249806698,
-0.0263940245,
-0.0618095435,
-0.0283141509,
0.0040220213,
-0.0301398523,
0.0269690901,
-0.0266118478,
0.0092346221,
-0.0413778313,
-0.0046926946,
0.0574612319,
0.0058982531,
-0.0239815041,
-0.0112351477,
-0.0248870067,
0.0400928631,
0.0193534885,
0.003413935,
0.0225617923,
-0.0293144509,
0.0025730354,
0.038283363,
0.0674870908,
-0.0060726153,
-0.0096985558,
0.0146887442,
0.0251795296,
0.0054092598,
-0.0364078209,
0.0258365162,
0.0301859342,
-0.0674792528,
-0.0007349814,
0.0841925666,
0.026952954,
-0.0736334994,
-0.0247728378,
-0.0250372458,
0.0240732562,
0.0201482903,
0.0235081241,
-0.0733965039,
-0.0497531183,
0.0274651889,
-0.0251184851,
-0.0107201012,
-0.0270648915,
0.0039194333,
-0.1236722991,
0.0460282825,
-0.0008134083,
-0.0362728424,
-0.0130955456,
-0.0342291668,
0.0223601405,
0.0285130739,
-0.0297457948,
0.0121321157,
-0.0087217074,
0.006388973,
0.0184038058,
0.0256238505,
-0.0538036898,
0.0662420765,
-0.000965149,
-0.0089291604,
-0.0136735383,
0.0101859579,
0.0026773966,
-0.0820896178,
0.0358215533,
-0.0220874492,
-0.0084089441,
-0.0109734731,
-0.024542544,
0.0129077639,
0.0017284908,
-0.029731527,
0.0575841144,
-0.0200307667,
-0.0350066535,
-0.0076391022,
0.1291568279,
-0.0162188932,
0.0158040971,
-0.045645427,
-0.0140649201,
-0.0253510475,
0.0637461543,
0.0144567322,
-0.005269228,
-0.0135222133,
-0.0168687422,
-0.0307835303,
0.0106474515,
-0.0264834985,
0.0165981427,
0.0290046334,
0.0604653843,
-0.0229741763,
-0.001042873,
0.0259708315,
0.0630456731,
-0.0152421417,
0.0407643616,
0.02391579,
0.0214599296,
-0.0381248482,
0.0541464053,
-0.0584093779,
0.0312477276,
-0.0162691586,
0.0403953306,
0.0532988831,
-0.0483517833,
-0.0441611633,
0.0098730111,
-0.0846211612,
-0.0491986535,
-0.0681392476,
0.0277619287,
0.024914341,
0.0344457589,
0.0161137339,
-0.0233438388,
0.045813445,
0.0218600295,
-0.0125513682,
-0.0219384953,
0.0084814504,
0.0138475411,
0.0000309345,
0.0497907661,
-0.0375213809,
0.0063855671,
0.0002036917,
0.0646024197,
0.0083245086,
0.0011430813,
0.0482160151,
0.0205491707,
0.0344207957,
-0.0009498483,
-0.0027409755,
-0.0326288491,
0.0365755782,
-0.0136547759,
-0.0378304049,
-0.0325230993,
0.0373466425,
0.0018777332,
-0.0348071493,
0.0114262542,
-0.0649087876,
0.029920008,
0.0505084693,
-0.0002164244,
0.0261936095,
0.0215887111,
0.0164148342,
0.0329185128,
-0.0356407687,
-0.0079924809,
-0.032704439,
-0.0059974082,
0.0318903886,
-0.0613878369,
0.1201262996,
0.0377164707,
-0.0285405274,
-0.0740938559,
0.0049188044,
-0.05393539,
-0.0501920544,
0.0011452171,
0.0159608107,
0.0514409766,
0.0073659183,
-0.0040719174,
-0.0436163135,
-0.0301318765,
0.0115042347,
0.0377438217,
0.0189239793,
-0.0111329975,
0.0480285883,
0.0459376648,
0.0163622797,
-0.0007405124,
0.0622794665,
-0.0420673303,
0.0009396108,
0.0153087666,
-0.0238800105,
-0.024961913,
-0.0305224732,
0.0069355625,
0.0263545904,
0.0006885166,
-0.0023352299,
-0.0962289572,
-0.0646905452,
0.0156335607,
-0.0028114687,
-0.0173916128,
-0.0086292364,
0.0463979356,
0.1064978689,
0.0111893667,
-0.0351777263,
-0.0062346444,
0.0062197051,
-0.0064105056,
-0.0335656479,
-0.0365491323,
-6.409434376e-33,
-0.0004461473,
-0.0181332752,
0.0591214709,
-0.0212117489,
-0.0142372148,
0.0125707146,
-0.0285245515,
0.0056256936,
-0.0248611234,
0.0188527796,
-0.0122955795,
-0.0227160752,
-0.0030432518,
0.0265132878,
0.0158585049,
-0.004574575,
-0.0056528272,
0.0017459982,
-0.0263212938,
0.0099776397,
0.0462079756,
-0.006094594,
0.0368714705,
-0.0654511601,
-0.0010299311,
-0.0008544832,
0.020229971,
0.0293708369,
-0.0693031996,
0.0862638727,
-0.0122099984,
0.0291991364,
0.030712815,
-0.0339520723,
0.0120571721,
0.0090746377,
-0.0333957225,
-0.0229542833,
0.0119952234,
-0.0349349305,
-0.0402184874,
-0.0185212679,
0.0099350056,
0.0086817928,
-0.0053021098,
-0.0355697088,
0.0248670448,
-0.0219869446,
-0.0206803288,
-0.0093107847,
-0.0303815491,
0.0188093334,
-0.0095719565,
-0.0198692027,
0.017465027,
0.0506421588,
0.0015133936,
0.0317498408,
-0.0075650169,
0.0396200679,
-0.0030094751,
0.0040160883,
0.069634296,
-0.0101036225,
0.0048822574,
0.0464393981,
-0.0013384467,
-0.043284364,
-0.0341897383,
-0.0220333952,
0.0344806127,
0.0657615885,
0.0421620198,
0.0687157512,
0.0338174738,
0.049244009,
-0.0865983814,
-0.0131920399,
0.0098095294,
0.0224299207,
0.0411773175,
0.0129241375,
-0.0288979895,
-0.0056045149,
-0.0681366026,
0.0112608923,
-0.0509484373,
-0.0131961312,
0.0344495252,
-0.0000835974,
-0.0303585343,
-0.0122011574,
0.0629398003,
-0.0249750614,
-0.062194515,
0.031589549,
-0.030501999,
0.0300209206,
-0.0087118587,
0.0407346971,
-0.0296781473,
-0.0382616073,
0.0080701159,
-0.0224421415,
0.0042138989,
-0.003696454,
0.0145253325,
0.0145083433,
-0.0361109786,
-0.0094301049,
-0.0620858297,
-0.035465911,
-0.0249660071,
-0.0110947443,
0.0466998219,
0.0366625264,
0.0086404979,
0.0356995761,
0.0128190797,
-0.0164251626,
-0.0298622791,
-0.0196008757,
-0.0311051775,
0.0177677758,
0.0216687322,
0.016041195,
-0.04011802,
-0.0429029427,
0.037405353,
-0.0383187346,
0.0011458909,
0.0573808029,
2.966e-7,
0.0278790109,
0.042572964,
-0.0098000132,
0.0193008855,
0.0120938495,
0.0413078181,
-0.0309222862,
-0.0048353942,
0.0398137607,
-0.0490058511,
-0.0066959532,
0.0462051146,
0.0448727384,
0.0696279183,
-0.041704908,
-0.0196332857,
-0.0094311405,
-0.0565680265,
-0.0683913976,
-0.0229817815,
0.0771652013,
0.0673795491,
0.0028380796,
-0.0200997442,
-0.015198566,
-0.0575792752,
0.0766023695,
-0.0179345068,
-0.0271843057,
0.0065572718,
0.0045363805,
0.0003360071,
0.0325328894,
0.0364621431,
0.0218690783,
0.0170258526,
0.0227580201,
0.0242247637,
0.0262391306,
-0.0294959918,
-0.0132131437,
-0.0194429662,
-0.0139299724,
-0.0470896028,
0.0784725249,
-0.0602571815,
-0.0038102942,
0.0208952837,
-0.0104930317,
-0.0248084497,
0.0053312709,
0.0197597109,
-0.0162811615,
0.0323586911,
-0.0136305764,
-0.0055797976,
0.0022855981,
-0.0921004787,
-0.0136890998,
0.0333642699,
-0.0657796189,
-0.0129243657,
-0.0207091905,
-0.029608475,
0.0474510044,
-0.064992249,
-0.0220094007,
3.260133481e-34,
0.0181778297,
-0.0356737152,
0.022103006,
0.0182582494,
0.0453846008,
-0.0190185346,
-0.027975535,
0.0215008315,
-0.0052406103,
-0.1098960564,
-0.0208158568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06677v1 | Intelligent Virtual Assistants with LLM-based Process Automation | 2023-12-04T07:51:58 | 2023-12-04T07:51:58 | Yanchu Guan, Dong Wang, Zhixuan Chu, Shiyu Wang, Feiyue Ni, Ruihua Song, Longfei Li, Jinjie Gu, Chenyi Zhuang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | While intelligent virtual assistants like Siri, Alexa, and Google Assistant
have become ubiquitous in modern life, they still face limitations in their
ability to follow multi-step instructions and accomplish complex goals
articulated in natural language. However, recent breakthroughs in large
language models (LLMs) show promise for overcoming existing barriers by
enhancing natural language processing and reasoning capabilities. Though
promising, applying LLMs to create more advanced virtual assistants still faces
challenges like ensuring robust performance and handling variability in
real-world user commands. This paper proposes a novel LLM-based virtual
assistant that can automatically perform multi-step operations within mobile
apps based on high-level user requests. The system represents an advance in
assistants by providing an end-to-end solution for parsing instructions,
reasoning about goals, and executing actions. LLM-based Process Automation
(LLMPA) has modules for decomposing instructions, generating descriptions,
detecting interface elements, predicting next actions, and error checking.
Experiments demonstrate the system completing complex mobile operation tasks in
Alipay based on natural language instructions. This showcases how large
language models can enable automated assistants to accomplish real-world tasks.
The main contributions are the novel LLMPA architecture optimized for app
process automation, the methodology for applying LLMs to mobile apps, and
demonstrations of multi-step task completion in a real-world environment.
Notably, this work represents the first real-world deployment and extensive
evaluation of a large language model-based virtual assistant in a widely used
mobile application with an enormous user base numbering in the hundreds of
millions. | [
0.0702640638,
0.0073357476,
-0.0287917946,
0.0180415958,
-0.0368266851,
-0.0034206884,
0.0238344837,
-0.0146699874,
0.052862078,
-0.0898871198,
0.001717419,
-0.0122465529,
-0.0034454148,
0.0030174511,
0.0040045865,
-0.0299135968,
0.0254836045,
-0.0368075185,
0.0142357694,
0.0299283098,
-0.0040021813,
0.0329484716,
0.0085569341,
0.0551145971,
0.0090651913,
-0.0464527719,
-0.0153116798,
0.0101808161,
-0.0284902323,
-0.0468398221,
-0.0334954187,
0.0139411455,
0.0072084307,
-0.0071643279,
0.0000019752,
-0.0646701977,
0.0113327978,
0.01453311,
-0.0632261187,
0.0038079503,
0.0188689232,
0.0444982015,
-0.031088382,
0.0445806235,
-0.0230081193,
0.017964635,
0.0196463503,
0.0449242517,
0.0669948012,
0.036334902,
-0.0119470982,
-0.0431055613,
0.0101571158,
0.0219258163,
0.0080344174,
-0.0625990853,
0.0120949224,
-0.0155608673,
0.0694782287,
-0.0018845592,
0.0681573153,
-0.0105020544,
0.0264958125,
0.0038805893,
-0.0729302615,
0.0117757851,
0.0106784226,
-0.0521279238,
-0.0475356281,
0.0348338149,
-0.0285491496,
0.0122591387,
0.0546153001,
0.0251372121,
-0.0295990836,
-0.0262362696,
-0.0242450275,
0.0352553576,
-0.0415391028,
-0.0312444028,
0.0203965381,
-0.0089612696,
0.0248084329,
0.0016697193,
-0.0296562053,
0.0304124095,
0.0191613454,
-0.0399007611,
-0.0145800337,
-0.0128411958,
-0.0040112492,
-0.0470772348,
0.0474716164,
0.0662252009,
-0.0727969855,
0.0293467958,
-0.0374080874,
-0.0050498024,
0.0091714514,
-0.0669905394,
0.0606844723,
0.0417486876,
-0.0208205078,
0.0457671136,
0.0049233628,
0.055389598,
-0.0120441075,
-0.0198015384,
-0.0366595946,
-0.009510085,
-0.0275105778,
0.0078365989,
-0.0191080924,
0.0551359206,
-0.0570553355,
-0.0161718149,
-0.0300994739,
0.0343029387,
-0.012231037,
0.0529899187,
0.011631568,
0.0177777596,
0.0061654849,
-0.0190171804,
-0.034905538,
-0.0077316589,
-0.0262774881,
0.0326211974,
-0.0290593114,
-0.0554124564,
0.0416517742,
0.0012732379,
0.0013239278,
0.0301833339,
0.0064084227,
0.0891504884,
0.0081795072,
-0.0379519723,
-0.0581411123,
-0.0470983647,
0.0410818122,
-0.0680623651,
-0.0136222411,
-0.0700568259,
0.0288789161,
0.0143347876,
-0.0226818826,
0.0246438961,
0.0391870141,
0.0634402484,
-0.0314405113,
0.0514601916,
0.0149789331,
0.0393646508,
0.0342176966,
0.0194453578,
0.0041826228,
0.0229417775,
0.0338033736,
0.0381238125,
0.0352696441,
0.0173775461,
0.0402574837,
0.054807581,
-0.0717175156,
-0.0551494025,
0.0299020857,
-0.0096443798,
-0.0250513051,
-0.0090277987,
-0.0453011915,
0.0464208201,
0.018572934,
0.0292342901,
0.0635848641,
0.1014674306,
-0.0189945791,
0.0238098968,
0.0460543483,
0.0529075339,
0.0075180409,
-0.0600456223,
-0.0711246729,
0.027538456,
-0.0635693818,
-0.0034905612,
-0.0200894009,
0.0488645397,
-0.030364424,
-0.0404208787,
-0.0103922235,
-0.0462236293,
0.0117454175,
0.0085021667,
0.0108908098,
0.0047870199,
-0.0347608738,
0.0204093326,
-0.0183625147,
-0.0125228791,
-0.0466718674,
-0.0673552826,
0.0542995259,
0.1174909472,
0.0392147638,
-0.0055039073,
-0.003890214,
0.0137530584,
-0.0181800257,
0.0030502868,
-0.0167775359,
-0.0098690353,
-0.0032335427,
-0.0151632885,
-0.0220159963,
0.029195277,
0.0248552915,
-0.0039902888,
-0.0001889581,
0.0100324694,
0.0052139955,
0.0056628599,
-0.0099112391,
0.0164930765,
-0.0031906965,
-0.053546574,
0.0207968801,
0.0417024381,
0.018754378,
0.0414377823,
0.0191988237,
-0.0181064103,
0.0312855132,
-0.0379963815,
-0.0018379845,
0.0039429651,
0.0046379641,
0.0320750214,
0.0266392175,
0.0227426626,
0.0007026363,
0.0336746573,
-0.0170904379,
-0.0207480509,
-0.0053234058,
-0.0206842646,
0.0409888662,
0.0242295191,
0.0648734868,
0.0189639814,
-0.0244534295,
-0.0117487404,
0.0453621335,
0.010912464,
-0.0063610799,
0.0282728896,
0.0231128745,
-0.0219435673,
0.0102116931,
0.0008912051,
0.0027344606,
-0.0008843775,
0.0261890236,
0.0041919881,
0.0213289894,
-0.0015983736,
-0.0112878373,
-0.1128320619,
0.0264969263,
-0.0307965577,
-0.0017207146,
0.0278880391,
0.067811124,
0.009681954,
-0.0355509073,
0.0083009647,
0.0147378827,
0.0148504544,
0.0221046302,
0.0091559729,
-0.0250431448,
-0.0483446643,
-0.0136079462,
0.0281136148,
-0.0116922027,
0.0047729895,
-0.0132818166,
-0.0162912533,
-0.0829498097,
0.0051907427,
-0.0174062662,
0.0321014188,
-0.0058150329,
-0.0258591007,
0.0252220314,
-0.0091429176,
0.0179109816,
0.0703012347,
-0.0380033031,
0.0023649205,
0.0355832092,
-0.0220823046,
-0.0391563773,
0.0009852378,
0.0043877461,
-0.0229496397,
-0.0318282954,
-0.0268212911,
0.0309091117,
0.0701603144,
0.0006703078,
0.0520087555,
-0.0088396771,
-0.0141087146,
-0.0143850138,
0.013182099,
0.0232242923,
0.0081644133,
-0.0539303944,
0.0645071343,
-0.0244368501,
-0.0362500921,
0.0503084362,
-0.0279833525,
-0.0047834879,
-0.0348693505,
-0.0426918902,
-0.0114807971,
0.0900239125,
-0.0248842184,
0.0260601174,
-0.016562948,
-0.0226475243,
0.0022109076,
0.0264909193,
-0.0255974252,
-0.0564074963,
0.0443798639,
-0.105102241,
-0.0131361559,
0.003616781,
-0.0369877033,
-0.031529393,
-0.0238161087,
-0.0617356561,
-0.0156756788,
-0.0107802786,
-0.0205196422,
-0.0445083305,
-0.003966378,
0.0120921629,
0.0662093908,
-0.0012166939,
-0.0089814914,
-0.0484268628,
-0.0379674397,
0.0282687731,
0.0109739434,
-0.0513549335,
0.0347807929,
0.0553269498,
0.0286802277,
0.0245993976,
-0.0215586144,
-0.0295462944,
0.0049559469,
0.0386283956,
-0.0344062708,
-0.0267796777,
0.0995548442,
0.0371582247,
-0.080305174,
0.0184557866,
0.1079046801,
0.0427902043,
-0.0290076993,
0.0101995794,
-0.0496641956,
-0.0465960614,
0.0305767022,
0.0580493584,
-0.0795008838,
-0.0379082896,
0.0114353895,
-0.0013043187,
0.0380977839,
-0.0017484986,
-0.0183773283,
-0.1008431017,
0.0304830894,
-0.0066135544,
0.030170558,
-0.0216300208,
-0.0379640125,
0.0288617946,
0.0055974326,
0.010406347,
-0.0222609956,
-0.0091826143,
-0.0457194857,
-0.0398633219,
-0.0648180619,
-0.019477509,
0.0672146082,
-0.054554645,
0.0218648389,
0.1021550298,
0.0267677959,
0.0340338126,
-0.0160672553,
-0.0161018819,
0.0166788083,
0.0171578936,
-0.0211639982,
-0.0151267182,
0.0123193692,
0.010731915,
-0.0150902402,
0.0533834957,
-0.052035518,
-0.0213037096,
0.0368103012,
0.0904611796,
-0.0296146292,
0.0045335963,
-0.0337532721,
-0.017671423,
0.0242890455,
0.0475274734,
-0.0205420107,
-0.050510224,
-0.0696851611,
-0.0355540738,
-0.0550869629,
0.0261986125,
-0.0293651931,
0.0119625703,
-0.0298178811,
-0.0051372009,
-0.0337976813,
-0.009143658,
0.0404075235,
0.0076649836,
0.049433317,
0.0164401792,
0.1011976376,
0.0116100525,
-0.0061426936,
-0.0254773106,
-0.0010600832,
0.0479307175,
-0.019347135,
0.0228789616,
0.0569051057,
-0.0497621,
0.0124780806,
-0.009032499,
-0.023156438,
-0.0266685635,
-0.0038492642,
0.0706202835,
0.0164738111,
0.0336513966,
-0.0438635871,
-0.0569675528,
-0.0084074549,
-0.0162055176,
-0.0742328987,
0.0035855477,
0.0029177214,
0.0493880436,
0.010164151,
0.0151546206,
-0.0917582735,
0.0240601934,
-0.0403492153,
0.0170881394,
-0.0645685941,
-0.0668210238,
0.0247378051,
0.0453908816,
0.0083648721,
0.0079681249,
0.0285988115,
0.0196781512,
0.0523901097,
-0.0278845672,
-0.0250200387,
-0.0355284736,
0.0022314913,
-0.0328805223,
-0.001454568,
0.0305561107,
-0.0271458458,
-0.0159041416,
-0.0337370709,
-0.0006585579,
0.0267652348,
-0.0469938181,
0.0276232027,
0.0095171602,
0.0074157892,
-0.0159089193,
0.0222375635,
0.0119761908,
0.0424610674,
-0.034771435,
0.0536315702,
-0.0466575921,
-0.0060080905,
-0.0685772747,
0.0476562083,
-0.0066910083,
-0.0991858393,
0.040100798,
0.0505825616,
0.0376376919,
-0.0183314327,
0.0325811058,
-0.0743644461,
0.0213795826,
-0.0249452293,
0.007970023,
-0.0050178142,
-0.0221096873,
0.0074889716,
0.0247109812,
-0.0061636074,
-0.0280732904,
0.0251053274,
-0.0458022878,
0.0376697667,
-0.0175992195,
-0.0547336526,
-0.0791999027,
-0.0506709516,
0.0089698685,
0.0362084322,
-0.0291738436,
-0.0336373299,
-0.0367728695,
-0.015268188,
-0.0351255909,
-0.0162719991,
0.0033165715,
-0.0736170635,
0.0218919721,
0.0680287108,
0.0204520021,
-0.0311568137,
-0.0418947339,
-0.070963867,
-0.0320886895,
0.0006576909,
-0.0523743071,
-5.482335206e-33,
-0.0126659665,
-0.0155154625,
0.0521600172,
-0.011705366,
0.0258575045,
-0.0350822397,
-0.0275525041,
0.0074369633,
0.0146350758,
-0.0197213106,
-0.0357596464,
-0.0226531457,
0.019894341,
-0.0015312502,
0.0308901537,
0.0285926275,
0.0561822057,
-0.0312566906,
-0.0060044401,
0.0148963043,
0.0044865226,
0.0027570443,
0.0000722446,
-0.071775496,
0.0024443569,
0.0028746745,
0.0096836612,
0.0198976994,
-0.0305978004,
0.0298658721,
-0.0322446004,
0.0091560837,
0.0339010321,
-0.0109909764,
-0.0135989236,
0.0549767651,
-0.0266804732,
-0.0301933065,
0.0357837006,
0.0442511998,
-0.045921471,
-0.0189341214,
0.0251378249,
0.0116190473,
-0.0420482382,
0.0702450424,
0.0327431001,
-0.0208806545,
0.0037834903,
0.0074359193,
-0.0846093446,
-0.0136798518,
0.0354165509,
-0.0462324135,
0.0180715248,
0.018569218,
-0.0423499495,
-0.0055465521,
-0.040143691,
0.0095372396,
-0.0427618101,
0.006621486,
0.0626990795,
-0.00313054,
-0.0087718675,
0.0411003232,
0.0073564537,
-0.0114909625,
-0.0478612222,
0.0184712466,
-0.0424670242,
0.1013038158,
0.0152613418,
-0.0193623155,
0.0093657998,
0.010412016,
-0.010505558,
0.0128794974,
0.022635309,
0.0807406679,
0.0377753228,
0.019751003,
-0.0398094803,
0.0119002201,
-0.0068445643,
0.0308832508,
-0.0487741791,
-0.0355924778,
0.047296878,
0.018526651,
-0.0227246713,
-0.0273850709,
0.002606157,
-0.020047266,
-0.0217507277,
-0.0314070359,
0.0070245685,
0.021757191,
-0.0158897694,
0.0061339242,
-0.0462676622,
-0.0283945575,
-0.0336091369,
-0.0044814642,
0.0355013236,
0.0364291929,
-0.0442514047,
0.0434230119,
-0.0460997969,
0.0278608799,
-0.0167378876,
0.0073293182,
0.013092733,
0.0322652571,
0.0467699729,
-0.0223178715,
-0.0197296217,
0.084656857,
-0.0298558176,
-0.0439694859,
-0.0136685837,
-0.0252856109,
0.0228618737,
-0.0165512245,
-0.0367229804,
-0.0113484561,
-0.0844318345,
0.0346666612,
0.0185247082,
-0.013711256,
-0.0119209234,
0.0089237262,
2.801e-7,
-0.0334058329,
0.0293274857,
-0.0254239049,
0.0697866157,
0.0128109567,
0.0553363711,
0.0288984571,
0.0144825978,
-0.026551025,
-0.0049890215,
-0.0137676103,
-0.007603338,
0.0342411101,
0.0031136845,
-0.0450818241,
0.015399619,
-0.0089610051,
0.031135371,
-0.1026105136,
0.0341252238,
0.05606829,
0.0895714462,
0.0185105857,
-0.0060230335,
-0.0013166091,
-0.025045475,
-0.0019727859,
-0.0157457981,
0.000788884,
-0.0001566612,
0.0277367979,
0.0354951136,
-0.0068627978,
0.0015950499,
-0.0028933627,
0.0158039443,
-0.0241813902,
0.0748177245,
-0.0073044826,
0.0376938321,
0.0130208535,
-0.0306289103,
-0.0084996196,
-0.0209692623,
0.061444629,
-0.0362832695,
-0.026487913,
-0.0331194811,
0.0191092566,
-0.0153004536,
-0.0438756011,
0.0073077967,
0.0169007555,
0.0115606692,
-0.0073218178,
-0.024047317,
-0.0243348069,
-0.0687166899,
-0.0039951801,
0.009353661,
-0.0003605262,
-0.0066394298,
-0.0566862561,
0.0198106747,
0.0028354011,
-0.0387542173,
0.0168210752,
2.577511744e-34,
-0.0261685476,
-0.0102520315,
0.0270636287,
0.0845583305,
0.0198600851,
0.038412109,
-0.0059071044,
0.0553417578,
0.0253814552,
-0.0534290485,
-0.0012652753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01701v1 | Mitigating Fine-Grained Hallucination by Fine-Tuning Large Vision-Language Models with Caption Rewrites | 2023-12-04T07:43:02 | 2023-12-04T07:43:02 | Lei Wang, Jiabang He, Shenshen Li, Ning Liu, Ee-Peng Lim | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. To comprehend and execute diverse human
instructions over image data, instruction-tuned large vision-language models
(LVLMs) have been introduced. However, LVLMs may suffer from different types of
object hallucinations. Nevertheless, LVLMs are evaluated for coarse-grained
object hallucinations only (i.e., generated objects non-existent in the input
image). The fine-grained object attributes and behaviors non-existent in the
image may still be generated but not measured by the current evaluation
methods. In this paper, we thus focus on reducing fine-grained hallucinations
of LVLMs. We propose \textit{ReCaption}, a framework that consists of two
components: rewriting captions using ChatGPT and fine-tuning the
instruction-tuned LVLMs on the rewritten captions. We also propose a
fine-grained probing-based evaluation method named \textit{Fine-Grained Object
Hallucination Evaluation} (\textit{FGHE}). Our experiment results demonstrate
that ReCaption effectively reduces fine-grained object hallucination for
different LVLM options and improves their text generation quality. The code can
be found at https://github.com/Anonymousanoy/FOHE. | [
0.0172764175,
0.033859048,
-0.0022616887,
0.0698665455,
-0.0432177894,
0.0234715845,
-0.0150682256,
0.0172164552,
0.0251846798,
-0.0674334019,
-0.0340629965,
-0.0248335823,
0.0244797878,
0.0344943739,
0.0137026543,
-0.0596844777,
0.0332064144,
-0.0622234978,
-0.0313743874,
0.004054775,
-0.0085341046,
-0.0141559253,
0.0141166756,
0.0459744371,
0.0139312614,
-0.0324655659,
-0.0121349813,
0.0165952258,
0.0030091752,
-0.0028034437,
-0.0247109812,
0.0534564555,
0.0031117294,
0.0214899443,
0.0000022272,
-0.0264717471,
0.0048808903,
0.0147255184,
0.0392799862,
0.0090697147,
0.0619508028,
-0.0314035304,
-0.0189734064,
-0.009596331,
-0.0026186532,
-0.0286930837,
0.0773612484,
0.0898488611,
0.0464222692,
0.0615970902,
-0.0198664609,
-0.0626315475,
0.0105254985,
0.0084470911,
0.0632135123,
0.0003163723,
0.0208881944,
0.0339512117,
-0.0045356378,
-0.0070629036,
-0.0109758861,
0.0294753406,
0.0227179714,
-0.0100195091,
-0.0014622256,
0.0364696123,
-0.0560608171,
-0.0503917076,
-0.0200800747,
0.0523943007,
-0.06034692,
-0.0222568251,
0.0122395921,
0.0063053723,
0.0112586599,
-0.0366869234,
-0.034416005,
0.0462458953,
0.0131379804,
0.0063259029,
-0.003618116,
0.0014164554,
0.0047370587,
0.0056907171,
-0.0179457963,
-0.0178983454,
0.0220686924,
0.012560688,
-0.0213600993,
0.0081622535,
-0.0498823486,
-0.0633400381,
0.0178267751,
0.0192971732,
-0.0407933444,
-0.0245377719,
-0.0661389455,
-0.0117565552,
0.0173895061,
-0.0586687326,
0.0285031646,
-0.0002452643,
-0.0817069933,
0.0603896491,
-0.0453417636,
0.0593619868,
-0.0167070553,
0.0493274257,
-0.0313503779,
0.0142824426,
-0.0411951579,
-0.0105206724,
-0.0520344861,
0.0241509397,
-0.0571975745,
-0.0540384091,
-0.0092282444,
-0.0120132519,
-0.0261191744,
0.0123728802,
-0.0418144464,
0.0191435777,
-0.0156868249,
-0.0119967787,
-0.0143726487,
0.0288541242,
0.0142499022,
-0.0327298082,
-0.0007435138,
-0.0616088398,
-0.0191107783,
0.0420721918,
0.0106361965,
-0.0075270804,
-0.0118825762,
0.0751604363,
-0.0154130459,
-0.0222577862,
-0.0223770551,
-0.0291671213,
-0.0314785801,
-0.0612648129,
0.0274934545,
-0.0743712708,
-0.0042328322,
-0.0306099989,
0.0165882688,
-0.0243310072,
0.0223635752,
0.0384167731,
-0.016512936,
0.0899329409,
-0.0131609552,
-0.0031662956,
-0.0003221898,
0.0305226073,
0.0107696084,
0.0696133003,
-0.0124977678,
0.0676031634,
-0.0067143072,
-0.0308053046,
0.0590031631,
0.0403586254,
-0.0363767035,
0.0069504152,
-0.0545708872,
-0.0310841389,
0.0034648732,
0.0142169101,
0.0462784357,
0.0779875889,
-0.0313751288,
0.0044287927,
0.0571196601,
0.0330087431,
-0.0161979627,
0.0215149801,
0.0456001088,
0.0197855644,
-0.0040273559,
0.0333769806,
-0.0648935884,
0.0578880794,
-0.0372658111,
0.008887046,
-0.0033367788,
0.0144754844,
-0.0196629073,
-0.0384990387,
0.0155054461,
-0.0176743772,
0.0236337725,
-0.0248355214,
0.0218575578,
0.040656805,
-0.0632316843,
-0.0133446762,
0.0138707301,
-0.0229933746,
-0.0094423946,
-0.0660221428,
-0.0066399737,
0.0950912237,
0.0686201677,
0.0239297394,
-0.0024921694,
-0.0086391633,
0.0396008119,
0.0671466738,
0.0359957628,
0.0309552234,
0.0102091981,
-0.0293905549,
-0.0187070593,
0.0002668992,
0.0135177309,
0.0092423791,
-0.016479861,
-0.0120223109,
0.0179049019,
-0.0041126627,
-0.0736068115,
0.0523547456,
0.0658055916,
-0.0075467303,
-0.0225386582,
0.0070372671,
-0.0117542855,
-0.0212112386,
-0.0182192586,
0.0340282433,
0.0072205765,
-0.027494859,
-0.0206697788,
-0.0081963828,
-0.0240818001,
-0.0348005928,
0.011620515,
-0.0590520874,
-0.0061008823,
-0.0134240249,
-0.0117021175,
-0.0227593519,
-0.00395235,
-0.0444985665,
0.0100186495,
-0.0498581603,
0.0575852841,
-0.0034566389,
0.0333135277,
-0.0294330623,
0.0686762705,
-0.0107338866,
-0.0119873025,
0.0305490419,
0.0087451739,
-0.0360108688,
-0.0289765,
-0.0474508442,
0.0129776886,
0.0046681585,
0.0086912243,
0.0007565001,
0.0527498536,
-0.0616530515,
-0.0308149327,
-0.0668014959,
-0.0013437654,
-0.0112763187,
-0.0301087182,
0.0080847451,
-0.0089914314,
0.0155539485,
-0.0029651315,
-0.0066443486,
0.0233168397,
-0.0016775153,
0.0330285691,
0.0262121018,
-0.0183418412,
-0.06156018,
0.0164706893,
0.0016282176,
0.025775874,
0.0519150831,
0.0001897836,
-0.0337052383,
-0.0794907659,
0.0620737635,
-0.014146369,
0.0170253739,
0.0049337638,
-0.0338976532,
-0.0024267603,
-0.0004693057,
0.0321864374,
0.1057343259,
-0.0066706049,
0.0247676484,
0.0346116461,
-0.0220307838,
-0.0057946504,
-0.0202065669,
0.0081215762,
-0.0548573695,
0.0134740351,
-0.0216902923,
-0.0042762486,
0.0424998328,
-0.0322668962,
0.0502391979,
-0.0768300891,
0.0470889024,
-0.0334047526,
-0.0719572529,
-0.0008687198,
0.001769278,
-0.0156783294,
0.0135966297,
-0.0458930321,
-0.0751608536,
0.0259454437,
-0.0403430983,
-0.0237648152,
0.0026323374,
0.0293246824,
0.003558462,
0.076763846,
0.0514156967,
0.0348063745,
0.0310762972,
-0.0266637169,
-0.0267077684,
0.0083501013,
-0.0338886529,
-0.03870067,
0.0330250077,
-0.0490019955,
-0.0087987222,
-0.0220389515,
-0.007849372,
-0.0329983234,
-0.0079948232,
-0.0024892373,
-0.0335834101,
-0.0546293184,
-0.0151556069,
-0.0325555876,
0.0482437573,
0.0010387406,
0.0039874208,
-0.0350268185,
-0.0150424903,
-0.0250098184,
0.0149496868,
0.081085369,
-0.014415347,
-0.0136484271,
-0.0167954601,
0.0213220213,
0.0744399503,
-0.0070501282,
0.0279737208,
-0.0483382642,
0.0303211473,
0.0123082679,
0.0333405882,
-0.0399591625,
0.0391425453,
0.0745334327,
-0.0950154364,
-0.0273686089,
0.0861075297,
0.0302182809,
-0.0474551581,
-0.0011441964,
0.0171819516,
0.0927363336,
0.0110725742,
-0.0008849973,
-0.0698359832,
-0.0551477857,
-0.0129594514,
-0.0339632519,
-0.0378984548,
0.0002058718,
-0.0422186144,
-0.0921899527,
0.0880348608,
0.0416354835,
-0.0191167239,
-0.0646221191,
0.0204960722,
-0.0135951955,
0.0183775444,
0.022630997,
-0.0039090635,
-0.006125018,
-0.0038244796,
0.006172433,
-0.0090833157,
-0.0134077724,
0.0321391672,
-0.0328031816,
0.0349142104,
0.0801341534,
0.0147607094,
0.0038751136,
-0.0567841753,
0.0278242156,
-0.0140076168,
0.0233693905,
-0.0017013266,
0.0374050811,
-0.009915581,
-0.041933883,
0.016020501,
0.0276433751,
-0.0211180393,
-0.0263334494,
-0.0141627835,
0.0222301241,
-0.0377796404,
-0.0406432189,
-0.0152469864,
-0.0005762469,
-0.0220483821,
0.07043273,
0.0559715889,
-0.0272664335,
-0.0659812689,
-0.0051143467,
-0.0119327717,
-0.0482988022,
-0.0554390065,
0.0465922058,
0.0308846924,
-0.0544017367,
-0.0671402216,
-0.0195559822,
0.0460429639,
0.0122650201,
-0.0046885167,
0.0200418252,
-0.0123865204,
0.0042195171,
-0.0524539873,
0.0504191183,
-0.0621068962,
0.01049399,
-0.0350025035,
-0.0051611704,
0.0399560109,
-0.0182036515,
0.0035736258,
0.0582616143,
-0.1011467054,
-0.0461890735,
0.009654128,
0.0563651361,
0.018931767,
0.0422717407,
-0.0113373743,
-0.0615168735,
0.0196743347,
0.0521952994,
0.0317030698,
0.0345457941,
0.0063855727,
0.0021862169,
-0.0045917593,
0.0258403756,
-0.0032830439,
0.0143436259,
0.0212446451,
0.0097457143,
0.0249761008,
-0.0113794142,
0.0387966596,
0.018448228,
0.0129216351,
-0.039898593,
0.0287033077,
0.0172740817,
-0.0154522546,
-0.021349486,
-0.0197140016,
-0.063208662,
-0.0015785404,
0.0315907374,
0.0188471731,
0.0211095922,
-0.0195038505,
-0.0275185574,
-0.0096581988,
-0.0381338485,
0.0005234326,
-0.0041550524,
-0.0370649919,
0.0310754627,
0.00974051,
-0.0068688327,
0.0146186249,
-0.0134294285,
0.0433755331,
-0.0117681995,
0.0608287789,
0.0124042369,
-0.0067596799,
-0.0582225583,
0.062278375,
0.0072829183,
-0.0504312366,
-0.0572951362,
0.084022522,
0.0400749892,
0.0036445011,
0.060263969,
-0.0490066037,
0.0102613727,
-0.0188166723,
0.0469004065,
0.036669597,
-0.0570487417,
0.0167604033,
0.0143975383,
-0.0259540789,
-0.0304800682,
0.0759384707,
0.0128263617,
0.0171666406,
0.0178252999,
-0.0058440506,
-0.030035086,
-0.0340929404,
-0.0069146678,
-0.0386616774,
-0.0102802133,
0.0113127921,
-0.0152080739,
-0.0431768782,
-0.0340007693,
0.0036569305,
0.0331007876,
0.0005010762,
0.046877984,
0.0331332237,
-0.0200751033,
-0.022717176,
0.0016597058,
-0.0442065261,
0.036969088,
-0.0060204379,
0.0056401715,
-6.391452986e-33,
-0.0321696028,
-0.0354773402,
0.0352437384,
-0.004284346,
-0.0224342477,
0.0028975026,
-0.0242150761,
0.0288905036,
0.0326139443,
0.0048071821,
0.0225970503,
-0.0129224947,
0.0244972222,
0.0322351456,
-0.0084644342,
-0.0132344346,
0.0477055945,
0.0028763767,
-0.0243212543,
0.006235403,
-0.0281327665,
-0.0069597447,
0.0284217112,
-0.036700286,
0.0036787177,
-0.0064691189,
-0.0544234887,
0.0002276138,
0.0209041126,
0.0562821589,
-0.0442987047,
0.0069673406,
0.0243985541,
-0.0234094076,
-0.0480052345,
0.0213370267,
-0.0360202715,
0.0195198711,
0.0095276292,
0.0666104332,
-0.0540992394,
-0.0140332393,
0.0603452921,
-0.0228324179,
-0.0065731928,
-0.0127426647,
0.0197393671,
-0.0403477252,
-0.013031099,
0.048725795,
-0.0653032213,
0.0006120946,
0.0057644504,
-0.0631473735,
0.0644970611,
-0.0226615593,
-0.0267729908,
0.017567521,
-0.0218912251,
-0.0009586948,
0.0378857404,
0.0290244687,
0.0693817735,
0.0393730886,
0.0160974432,
0.0634724721,
0.0803809837,
0.0150558576,
-0.0174801834,
-0.0084520904,
0.0169595331,
0.0826716349,
0.0210351981,
0.0150194922,
0.0796803385,
0.0173768662,
-0.0051440839,
0.0105971666,
-0.0983171612,
0.056478247,
0.0601528659,
0.0286252741,
-0.0182306133,
-0.0146195227,
-0.0310761649,
0.0168555081,
-0.0459392816,
-0.0083541824,
0.0476230904,
0.0192620568,
-0.037586987,
-0.0139432345,
0.0590558425,
-0.0234343577,
0.0228504911,
-0.0454173759,
-0.0424988158,
0.0633402839,
-0.0186953656,
-0.0148346554,
0.0194316003,
-0.0453431718,
0.0741833299,
-0.0026351183,
0.0244327411,
0.0106572974,
0.0301246885,
0.0177829415,
-0.0635347292,
-0.0001106495,
-0.0459366888,
0.0050420617,
0.0068937405,
0.0405879281,
0.037151739,
-0.0176643953,
-0.0490384214,
0.0228145998,
0.0125188399,
-0.0095959455,
-0.0213577151,
0.022756651,
-0.0036718915,
0.0043900777,
-0.044844307,
0.0211710241,
-0.0397517867,
-0.0371677727,
0.0404355228,
-0.047577139,
-0.0315731578,
0.0009877926,
2.91e-7,
-0.0210577268,
0.0484611318,
0.0269416329,
0.0335468799,
0.0234360211,
0.0559684634,
0.0274553671,
0.0095215114,
0.000863035,
-0.0592428893,
0.0117063671,
0.0377880074,
0.0461008027,
-0.0330873057,
-0.0479372889,
0.0393328667,
-0.001068422,
0.0155432262,
-0.0620732084,
-0.0354833305,
0.0441356599,
0.0581723601,
-0.0352674499,
-0.0384277888,
0.0624144003,
-0.0664505437,
0.05901796,
-0.0143923601,
-0.0091296192,
0.0036048205,
-0.0076761525,
0.0834917054,
0.0094258422,
0.0491515398,
-0.0089340061,
-0.0642251,
0.0493870787,
0.0309888925,
-0.0490197763,
0.0104343155,
-0.0170724988,
0.0109696826,
-0.0265706107,
-0.0339359865,
0.0776603892,
-0.0649438873,
-0.031987194,
-0.0288546123,
-0.0074134474,
-0.0242251959,
0.0353026316,
-0.0345089734,
-0.024310302,
0.0192995388,
0.0507484786,
0.0132314917,
-0.0576072894,
-0.0485888273,
-0.0180222411,
-0.0120289885,
-0.0064361598,
-0.0237380061,
-0.0662802979,
-0.0093513215,
0.0088886889,
-0.0585644618,
-0.0439202338,
2.978396184e-34,
0.0193160363,
-0.0222001057,
0.0348356068,
0.0151971718,
0.0491276085,
0.0176550839,
0.005805796,
0.0320667587,
-0.033017993,
-0.0424401052,
-0.0124920094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01700v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01700v2 | Data Management For Large Language Models: A Survey | 2023-12-04T07:42:16 | 2023-12-26T01:35:38 | Zige Wang, Wanjun Zhong, Yufei Wang, Qi Zhu, Fei Mi, Baojun Wang, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data plays a fundamental role in the training of Large Language Models
(LLMs). Effective data management, particularly in the formulation of a
well-suited training dataset, holds significance for enhancing model
performance and improving training efficiency during pretraining and supervised
fine-tuning phases. Despite the considerable importance of data management, the
current research community still falls short in providing a systematic analysis
of the rationale behind management strategy selection, its consequential
effects, methodologies for evaluating curated datasets, and the ongoing pursuit
of improved strategies. Consequently, the exploration of data management has
attracted more and more attention among the research community. This survey
provides a comprehensive overview of current research in data management within
both the pretraining and supervised fine-tuning stages of LLMs, covering
various noteworthy aspects of data management strategy design: data quantity,
data quality, domain/task composition, etc. Looking toward the future, we
extrapolate existing challenges and outline promising directions for
development in this field. Therefore, this survey serves as a guiding resource
for practitioners aspiring to construct powerful LLMs through effective data
management practices. The collection of the latest papers is available at
https://github.com/ZigeW/data_management_LLM. | [
0.0347706228,
0.0853221118,
-0.0286963526,
0.0286547393,
-0.0126324994,
0.0240251105,
0.027588116,
-0.0154425008,
-0.0465518683,
-0.0475941971,
-0.0609522723,
-0.0626535416,
0.0021268751,
-0.0140866321,
0.0345037095,
-0.0480703451,
0.045652017,
-0.0638925582,
-0.0231102537,
-0.0023745554,
-0.0031309675,
0.0094285216,
0.048781123,
0.0223874096,
-0.0127236675,
0.0027490077,
0.0005524431,
-0.0032334393,
0.0034540736,
-0.0493824519,
0.001148009,
0.0623442493,
0.043598935,
0.0589588508,
0.0000019527,
-0.0553800464,
-0.0141760921,
0.0185428802,
-0.0662056506,
0.027930133,
0.0540310591,
-0.0381736718,
0.0104998099,
0.0127653116,
0.0015365744,
-0.0477577709,
0.0638315082,
0.0113877226,
0.0423327833,
0.0497244596,
-0.0117121581,
-0.0655987412,
0.0187874492,
-0.0283445716,
-0.0239190757,
-0.0043423702,
0.051978182,
0.0392678827,
-0.01665386,
0.0079476777,
-0.0176272057,
0.038022507,
0.0126775783,
-0.0002739962,
-0.0303411856,
0.0208771918,
-0.0436246991,
-0.0488808006,
0.0024849982,
0.0463941023,
0.0140509428,
-0.0180177279,
0.0111253187,
-0.0178401843,
-0.0156324506,
0.0170851164,
-0.0248221289,
0.0415327661,
0.0263750106,
0.0433494747,
0.0145460162,
-0.021897383,
0.0407603532,
-0.0102123255,
-0.0527169481,
0.0054825381,
0.0129028251,
-0.0327979513,
0.044579763,
-0.0193912871,
-0.0331908576,
-0.0662461519,
-0.0191104021,
0.025522083,
-0.006630783,
0.0304265134,
-0.0645712316,
-0.0498781204,
0.0103708459,
-0.0360121727,
0.0705310628,
0.0149786454,
-0.0262944214,
0.0242101122,
0.0184203479,
0.024844259,
0.0182015989,
0.0263117738,
-0.0447581746,
-0.0285747088,
-0.0359691344,
0.0129469233,
-0.0551125295,
0.0091022225,
0.0209004264,
0.0147570129,
-0.0079192901,
0.0297638848,
0.0031411927,
0.0048321462,
0.0324230753,
-0.0396875963,
-0.0275498349,
0.0184150059,
-0.0281508639,
0.0013726756,
-0.0163701046,
0.0378228649,
-0.0148824798,
-0.0546481088,
0.0232496709,
0.0123726204,
0.0008644048,
-0.050002031,
0.0345328897,
0.0359184109,
0.0276592504,
-0.0212792549,
-0.0809462816,
0.0017572583,
0.0050931973,
-0.0995956957,
0.0239480883,
-0.0521273315,
0.0341585279,
0.0179790929,
0.0017928637,
-0.0281321295,
-0.0252924878,
-0.0050833151,
-0.010220238,
0.0432209745,
-0.0354469791,
0.0490172617,
-0.0126588717,
-0.0139356907,
0.0393689536,
0.107885398,
0.0340039954,
-0.0039663352,
0.0228878465,
-0.0434527881,
-0.0229899585,
0.0335498974,
0.0355785489,
0.0319169499,
-0.0368459411,
0.043338649,
0.0347371474,
0.0032269971,
0.0032816587,
0.0436343253,
-0.0348352566,
0.0056175496,
0.0575402156,
0.0232281033,
0.0409487337,
0.0257030483,
0.0114577003,
-0.0270597227,
0.0326678082,
-0.0110844234,
-0.0173699576,
-0.0171605889,
0.0312025417,
-0.0095344624,
-0.0211231727,
0.047229737,
-0.039353013,
-0.0254168119,
-0.0496243685,
0.0037310224,
-0.0059742089,
0.0433128327,
0.0479705706,
-0.0257434174,
0.0260635708,
0.0345329605,
0.0159040913,
-0.0227795914,
-0.0085171433,
-0.0497305542,
-0.0133351665,
0.0496851727,
0.0124436719,
-0.0337847546,
-0.0512594618,
-0.0055127502,
0.0694243088,
-0.0446080081,
0.0386823677,
-0.0371955894,
0.0317946076,
-0.0382649451,
-0.0499479659,
-0.0009965041,
0.0025996575,
0.0065403893,
-0.0074723172,
0.0181144271,
0.0120435227,
-0.0331302844,
-0.070789896,
0.0784022436,
-0.036375232,
-0.0143209156,
-0.0076214531,
0.0098408172,
0.0459555946,
0.0004487935,
-0.0250181649,
-0.0279582217,
0.0439483076,
-0.0076072193,
0.0554034673,
-0.0171365459,
-0.0217971653,
0.0014526221,
0.0539126545,
0.0036510057,
-0.0108783478,
0.0127617233,
-0.0405745842,
-0.0508549847,
-0.0421306789,
-0.0130505925,
0.0396872088,
-0.0581029281,
0.0362836346,
-0.0518947244,
0.0142530473,
-0.0185411405,
0.0350382216,
-0.007306898,
-0.0178726986,
0.034397833,
0.0170881581,
0.0410516746,
-0.0224890672,
-0.02883658,
0.0575665012,
0.0115600349,
0.0457889959,
0.0289835241,
0.015429276,
-0.0435927808,
0.0074185594,
-0.0656658337,
-0.0053618602,
-0.0415863469,
0.0274599437,
0.0154287126,
0.0031869439,
-0.033968538,
0.0098511288,
-0.0171338972,
-0.0167690236,
0.0263088364,
0.0222385637,
0.0147880698,
0.0343245044,
-0.0341954157,
-0.0265073609,
-0.0363497548,
0.0195205454,
0.0333541892,
-0.0330137946,
-0.0233730078,
-0.0651500672,
0.0668145046,
-0.0420424975,
0.0335955359,
-0.0092649153,
-0.0254593082,
0.0072269053,
-0.0036387835,
0.0341865495,
0.0104513047,
-0.0566677451,
0.0006443886,
0.108815141,
-0.0191662125,
-0.0289689396,
-0.015457077,
-0.0075947489,
-0.0342245437,
-0.0589763969,
0.0034229204,
-0.0065989564,
0.0243479609,
-0.0209606346,
-0.0346693732,
-0.0080019906,
-0.0052934745,
-0.0476489328,
-0.007686106,
-0.0193814039,
0.0044702962,
-0.0066124536,
0.0584661588,
-0.0142270131,
-0.0485315099,
0.0529527217,
-0.0130526396,
0.0027799981,
-0.0339210629,
-0.0242548101,
-0.048433803,
0.0518388227,
-0.0058587501,
0.0058100433,
0.0151698124,
-0.003959225,
-0.0653039664,
-0.0146728791,
0.0225124992,
-0.010491699,
0.0296081528,
-0.0230275076,
0.0317807831,
-0.0323481746,
-0.0215789806,
-0.0472067781,
-0.0405265428,
-0.0340959951,
0.0195153449,
0.028670093,
0.0150117939,
-0.0206070207,
0.0113477306,
0.0119216228,
0.0288430527,
0.0149630066,
0.0068190126,
0.0098249782,
-0.0209199432,
0.027804615,
0.0093529942,
0.0238638353,
-0.04416411,
0.0003483546,
-0.0027951307,
0.0220099054,
-0.0020616266,
-0.0130694406,
-0.0024489267,
0.0587396994,
-0.0069093453,
-0.0074373828,
0.020395197,
0.0229928363,
-0.0675181672,
-0.0080950009,
0.1157371104,
0.0145327114,
-0.025721414,
-0.002107736,
-0.0079363389,
0.0690751821,
0.0148750544,
0.0088611525,
-0.0656688139,
-0.0124316234,
-0.0024835025,
-0.001125138,
-0.0072392859,
-0.0134954844,
-0.0219435021,
-0.0951082408,
0.0172691308,
0.0229139533,
-0.04684598,
-0.0239084214,
-0.0504856892,
0.0201250948,
-0.0355057344,
0.0687472746,
-0.0145293968,
-0.0436456949,
-0.0153473532,
0.0654256567,
-0.0158116203,
-0.112479113,
-0.0064193313,
-0.0497728959,
0.0492354594,
0.0530888624,
0.0229562074,
-0.0070278514,
-0.001045438,
0.0174634885,
0.0126420325,
-0.0084384419,
-0.014553071,
0.0441925786,
-0.0159938205,
-0.0171974432,
0.0146873826,
0.0270154681,
-0.0146798827,
-0.0095527815,
0.002248049,
0.1001165882,
-0.0401793607,
-0.0110773137,
0.0043175677,
-0.0480179153,
0.00758602,
0.0814885199,
0.0422411226,
-0.0429010391,
0.0115589257,
0.0271551684,
0.0054403716,
-0.0234104004,
0.0057298392,
0.0501490086,
-0.0470002182,
0.0034122639,
0.005076291,
-0.0695781857,
0.0906901211,
0.0115414094,
0.0252577513,
0.0113084391,
0.0070251231,
0.0009247508,
-0.0384272598,
0.0362508446,
-0.0582013838,
0.0111224055,
-0.0437715761,
-0.0668728426,
0.0164054725,
0.0028268804,
0.0088050906,
0.0069417995,
-0.1083551794,
-0.0606748238,
0.0434688404,
0.039997261,
0.0158175733,
0.0287285913,
0.0364948884,
-0.10138347,
0.0390986763,
0.0364639275,
-0.0455422699,
-0.0044406331,
0.0486656651,
-0.0247912053,
0.0090644909,
0.0319548696,
-0.0325818285,
0.020889705,
0.0486334153,
-0.0014142918,
-0.0194271076,
0.0174537133,
0.0286592618,
0.0296976175,
0.0296056252,
-0.0475306958,
-0.0465686694,
-0.0657101348,
0.0158744156,
-0.0343459137,
-0.0091898227,
-0.0307654571,
0.0159873795,
0.0167267546,
0.035702914,
-0.0233694166,
-0.0197589789,
-0.0026954974,
0.0155048827,
-0.0412914269,
0.0461953506,
0.0128294583,
0.0212687906,
0.0668724999,
0.0469652712,
-0.0017766524,
0.0115055218,
0.0097759664,
0.0065213051,
-0.0118759871,
0.0267178025,
0.0225565471,
0.0207006875,
-0.0274248216,
0.0257039424,
-0.0357977338,
-0.0397689044,
-0.0027663112,
-0.0102164075,
0.0671375245,
-0.0287376679,
0.0258034766,
-0.0304681081,
-0.0047131069,
-0.0226318296,
0.0173759982,
-0.0279914383,
-0.0015441048,
-0.0003635365,
0.0136979027,
-0.0603038929,
-0.0111321136,
0.0741279796,
0.0456790961,
0.0390638039,
-0.0098940292,
0.0098646022,
-0.0035054858,
0.0011101332,
0.0174341816,
-0.0103612449,
-0.0326134004,
-0.0425286628,
-0.0607698262,
-0.0819675699,
-0.0361490548,
-0.0170075558,
-0.0436736122,
-0.0116130151,
0.0411838219,
0.0327867046,
-0.011687493,
0.0245942436,
-0.0265085381,
-0.0195533484,
0.0167815015,
-0.0268762838,
-0.0198884495,
-5.915184184e-33,
-0.021024622,
0.0224988274,
0.0322701521,
-0.0178275313,
-0.034649305,
0.0137919327,
-0.0098615736,
-0.0241188016,
-0.0375579335,
-0.0182822868,
-0.0121333376,
0.010674607,
0.0141881667,
0.0139558958,
-0.0045007546,
-0.0265765022,
0.0923581719,
-0.0239448026,
-0.0206645038,
0.0248785838,
0.0202819388,
0.0374156721,
0.0959025025,
-0.0572216511,
0.0137945628,
0.0013175622,
0.0250157304,
0.005896796,
0.001916857,
0.0770679712,
-0.0248436928,
0.0339684673,
0.0134499073,
-0.0350797549,
-0.0483809151,
-0.0069974475,
-0.0756773725,
-0.0426726714,
0.0260614455,
0.0412037186,
0.0364216976,
-0.0230154637,
0.0239124652,
-0.0206584409,
-0.0144074028,
0.0128617333,
0.0039679157,
-0.0302631725,
-0.0549252518,
-0.0122217136,
-0.034621641,
0.0192651618,
0.006995487,
0.0088580279,
0.0890910774,
0.0133980559,
0.0038094639,
0.0063922992,
-0.0523610115,
0.021196777,
0.0660660267,
0.0252537429,
0.0664114654,
0.0713274702,
0.0568268746,
0.0629355833,
0.0401422046,
0.021330053,
0.0331298374,
0.0263313614,
0.0678934902,
0.0432245247,
-0.0109706307,
0.0143672777,
0.0183998533,
-0.050632827,
-0.0954486802,
-0.0168471653,
-0.0155368308,
0.0088860169,
-0.0050607193,
0.0123000117,
-0.0022656443,
-0.0606864952,
-0.0637453347,
0.0080196876,
0.0029449216,
0.0075510642,
0.0292284973,
0.0003504832,
-0.0231576785,
0.0217465088,
0.0822906494,
-0.0517423451,
-0.0863445252,
0.0259667356,
-0.0041700844,
0.036383532,
-0.0027547721,
0.0185656343,
-0.0817583129,
-0.0575362928,
0.0138074169,
-0.0141851502,
0.0121078221,
-0.0306337047,
0.0608364902,
0.064950712,
-0.0293551572,
0.0097239967,
-0.0360215455,
0.0073743709,
-0.0019744239,
0.0231122002,
0.0276243947,
0.0276173335,
0.0242983792,
0.0610118695,
0.0662375838,
-0.0570302494,
-0.0444465205,
0.0012505875,
0.0156914387,
-0.0070007467,
0.0215135925,
-0.0113231558,
-0.0469179675,
-0.0241920259,
0.097476624,
-0.0143042719,
0.0000146143,
-0.0140578998,
2.527e-7,
0.0606483296,
0.0409021154,
-0.0116453785,
0.0151563967,
0.0036738003,
0.0035220692,
-0.0204030797,
-0.0167328399,
0.0004888526,
0.0090795979,
0.0395382792,
0.0282270703,
0.0514349341,
0.0455030166,
-0.0490886942,
-0.0211908855,
-0.0550107919,
-0.0299037285,
-0.0678442717,
0.0254415032,
-0.0032623012,
0.1253159493,
0.0020979664,
-0.0283047967,
-0.015962705,
-0.0255601052,
0.0433686227,
-0.0838278532,
0.0168435127,
0.0666040629,
0.0168774538,
0.0459168553,
0.0099685742,
-0.0110853277,
0.0009265275,
0.0337588824,
-0.0292748492,
0.0528434627,
0.0048735859,
-0.0075868992,
0.012565691,
-0.0059627066,
-0.0435698219,
-0.0445017293,
0.0765207261,
-0.0610182621,
-0.0441266298,
-0.0273075365,
0.0332496539,
-0.0350366123,
0.0057767942,
-0.0190126952,
0.0214809552,
0.0351479985,
0.0198323634,
-0.0298922043,
-0.0301371198,
-0.0742814317,
0.0137696005,
0.0418895818,
-0.0136542525,
-0.0571405068,
-0.0245270636,
-0.0288487487,
0.0088978456,
-0.0206490941,
0.0262796208,
2.520536083e-34,
0.0325759575,
-0.0444287658,
0.0139910821,
0.0030588682,
-0.0042486796,
-0.021264581,
-0.0039664297,
0.0183478538,
-0.0085604284,
-0.0872988179,
-0.0047763125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01678v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01678v5 | Jellyfish: A Large Language Model for Data Preprocessing | 2023-12-04T07:01:54 | 2024-06-21T09:39:31 | Haochen Zhang, Yuyang Dong, Chuan Xiao, Masafumi Oyamada | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | This paper explores the utilization of LLMs for data preprocessing (DP), a
crucial step in the data mining pipeline that transforms raw data into a clean
format conducive to easy processing. Whereas the use of LLMs has sparked
interest in devising universal solutions to DP, recent initiatives in this
domain typically rely on GPT APIs, raising inevitable data breach concerns.
Unlike these approaches, we consider instruction-tuning local LLMs (7 -- 13B
models) as universal DP task solvers that operate on a local, single, and
low-priced GPU, ensuring data security and enabling further customization. We
select a collection of datasets across four representative DP tasks and
construct instruction tuning data using data configuration, knowledge
injection, and reasoning data distillation techniques tailored to DP. By tuning
Mistral-7B, Llama 3-8B, and OpenOrca-Platypus2-13B, our models, namely,
Jellyfish-7B/8B/13B, deliver competitiveness compared to GPT-3.5/4 models and
strong generalizability to unseen tasks while barely compromising the base
models' abilities in NLP tasks. Meanwhile, Jellyfish offers enhanced reasoning
capabilities compared to GPT-3.5.
Our models are available at: https://huggingface.co/NECOUDBFM/Jellyfish .
Our instruction dataset is available at:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/NECOUDBFM/Jellyfish-Instruct . | [
0.021713296,
0.0707701966,
-0.0259046834,
0.0249402579,
-0.0484536327,
0.0100699663,
-0.0031260666,
-0.0280398969,
0.0296665318,
-0.0173616204,
0.0145883411,
0.0430351906,
-0.0007674979,
0.0366895236,
0.0031056411,
-0.0465226546,
0.0614560805,
-0.0154703604,
-0.0140082529,
0.0193793476,
-0.0336634479,
0.0029342752,
0.0504169129,
-0.0263359081,
0.0193731096,
-0.0382388942,
-0.0322515294,
0.0205300357,
0.0281689558,
0.0097032283,
0.0002579801,
0.0439383052,
0.0406409539,
0.0233285055,
0.0000027573,
-0.036333438,
-0.0622610599,
0.0294619296,
-0.021495292,
-0.0252973959,
-0.0125036826,
-0.0389367528,
0.0059534898,
0.0236231852,
-0.0704493746,
-0.0193595085,
0.0225461591,
-0.0124130379,
0.119601436,
0.0661875382,
-0.0190453772,
-0.0428621061,
0.0203476623,
0.0111748539,
0.0225579739,
0.0066904263,
0.005762767,
-0.0037822498,
0.0027185548,
-0.005839651,
0.0046573365,
0.0032584935,
0.0246288665,
0.037169598,
-0.0223113727,
-0.0199010298,
-0.0413340516,
-0.0249958746,
-0.0155951167,
0.0425440334,
-0.0715592355,
-0.0169091765,
0.0149136633,
0.0220872369,
0.0084251938,
-0.0307297967,
-0.0225208215,
0.0602114424,
-0.0183010772,
0.014100194,
0.0411876515,
-0.0317416564,
0.0240141992,
-0.0243748631,
-0.0326576047,
0.1045480669,
0.0133862635,
-0.0142746493,
0.007316899,
-0.0402874202,
-0.023231877,
-0.0539228097,
0.0000963221,
0.0602526516,
-0.020914685,
0.0185160227,
-0.0485454202,
-0.012233695,
-0.0016187901,
-0.0217697229,
0.0430663228,
0.0522923693,
0.0090062935,
0.0366067551,
-0.0223604646,
0.0019522276,
-0.0004209113,
0.03961014,
0.004074011,
-0.0143717555,
-0.0540616959,
0.0151258623,
-0.0028599822,
0.040202558,
-0.0833024234,
0.0329533592,
-0.009674673,
0.0706773326,
-0.0218314212,
0.0376025438,
0.0627404302,
0.0028353659,
0.0145200994,
0.0216990076,
-0.0617986023,
-0.043408744,
-0.0258216597,
0.0204550736,
-0.0070839757,
-0.0925472006,
-0.0165440384,
0.0054251566,
0.0001710499,
-0.0296382811,
0.0570485778,
0.0755329505,
0.0310832914,
-0.0220746174,
-0.0899442062,
-0.0701210648,
0.026733093,
-0.0792436302,
0.0344879106,
-0.0457131304,
0.0547430329,
-0.0101214256,
-0.0038093652,
-0.0142483059,
0.0200874526,
0.0571711957,
-0.0366978049,
0.0481680259,
-0.0509914123,
0.0096178465,
-0.0079340506,
0.0236938763,
0.0012213843,
0.0585632026,
0.0200334154,
0.0527220592,
0.0275946185,
-0.0357157663,
0.0202071276,
-0.0018268188,
0.0241389628,
-0.006755902,
-0.0149111385,
0.0540742725,
-0.0128503628,
-0.0147728277,
0.006438911,
0.0257659089,
-0.0088048102,
-0.0242822897,
0.0642577112,
0.0388033539,
-0.0161803868,
0.0354234241,
0.0177783687,
-0.0075108539,
-0.0020280047,
-0.0444050729,
-0.0291296281,
0.0071875136,
-0.0344853066,
0.0018392706,
-0.0094600022,
0.0810685977,
0.0030007937,
-0.0410406403,
-0.0087124491,
-0.0125157237,
-0.0233205091,
0.0231516808,
-0.0065624067,
0.0254948046,
-0.0400671624,
0.0439742804,
0.0168494042,
-0.0596242659,
-0.0838525891,
-0.0576916263,
0.0153375501,
0.0500088856,
0.0487742312,
-0.0321663022,
-0.0394954868,
-0.0346334502,
-0.0087826382,
0.0006798091,
-0.0295963958,
-0.0080164084,
0.0015325297,
-0.0594180897,
-0.0228410866,
-0.0167584345,
0.0043345415,
0.0003256311,
0.0517550409,
-0.0332277715,
-0.0303319152,
-0.0467703789,
-0.0243967716,
0.0310789719,
0.0200513285,
-0.0540787578,
0.0336961038,
0.0230205078,
0.0420852564,
0.0055771447,
0.0231479518,
-0.0182552636,
0.0581114143,
-0.005450129,
0.0226626378,
-0.0384656414,
0.005730629,
-0.0327457748,
0.0174419284,
-0.0225279666,
0.0076818112,
-0.0059791794,
-0.0766286552,
-0.0453342125,
0.0006487806,
-0.0069276956,
0.0235275943,
-0.0115625793,
0.0026567031,
-0.0054002614,
0.0179335475,
-0.0436024517,
0.0611751713,
-0.0232908186,
-0.0148261068,
0.0228874944,
0.0035253975,
0.0130040804,
-0.0292763822,
0.01522185,
0.0046182526,
0.0003972829,
0.018332215,
-0.0248400215,
0.0128596378,
-0.0359559357,
-0.0149322376,
-0.0528100617,
0.0707162768,
-0.002092869,
0.0647837073,
0.0492958874,
0.0169283729,
-0.0351350904,
-0.0064792768,
-0.0161691904,
-0.0098940721,
0.004870113,
0.0209852085,
0.038962286,
0.0163739733,
-0.0327609777,
0.0174853113,
-0.0170826837,
-0.0132166175,
0.0451079383,
-0.0378576145,
-0.0069205877,
-0.0143797249,
0.0191288069,
-0.0217082519,
0.0218434688,
0.0026260156,
0.0174205769,
-0.0083406251,
-0.009852103,
0.0129129328,
0.0670966431,
-0.0628378168,
0.0050748251,
0.0551536418,
-0.0568769723,
-0.0365970358,
0.0317872129,
-0.0155147621,
-0.0243764725,
-0.0028084384,
-0.0234801359,
0.0008254215,
0.0685940608,
-0.0012123495,
-0.0433956161,
-0.0023538508,
0.0539985821,
0.0477224886,
-0.0205855779,
0.015031144,
0.0278486852,
0.0144770471,
0.0246005896,
-0.0258980244,
-0.119626686,
0.0566412807,
-0.0152003299,
0.0197070446,
-0.0561849773,
-0.047295168,
-0.0458918102,
0.0395180136,
0.0113499016,
-0.0007066438,
-0.0344094709,
0.0191943124,
-0.0169849936,
0.0284087062,
0.0243326258,
-0.0419388413,
0.0339441784,
-0.0621945783,
-0.0371541157,
-0.0379737131,
-0.0217113625,
-0.0364623442,
0.0354446061,
0.0111727687,
0.0157068186,
0.0388329178,
-0.0218389332,
-0.0395344682,
0.0070758131,
0.0065738535,
0.018417228,
-0.0126358829,
-0.0276963767,
-0.0299766622,
-0.0476373248,
-0.0004518262,
-0.0297764018,
-0.020121783,
0.0462196991,
0.0140588479,
0.0636343658,
0.0553459004,
-0.063743107,
-0.0437387452,
0.0441516154,
0.0270052887,
-0.0176375881,
0.0059241746,
0.0226810444,
0.0133318026,
-0.0949135944,
-0.0190147534,
0.0710677281,
0.0373476706,
-0.0260101128,
-0.0136270523,
0.0196559411,
-0.0017865393,
0.0433349982,
0.0494316556,
-0.1015069634,
-0.0297212284,
0.0323914327,
0.0357689373,
-0.0195955038,
-0.0541630723,
-0.0406857468,
-0.0865286142,
0.0627583414,
0.0053134826,
0.0011104026,
-0.0577551872,
-0.0947880298,
-0.0042272909,
-0.0209956188,
-0.0051867277,
-0.0258757435,
-0.0045571271,
0.0311029404,
-0.0142060257,
-0.0048203859,
-0.0355473869,
0.0208025947,
0.0184215214,
-0.0000361648,
0.05413156,
0.0106168482,
0.0242871754,
-0.0203959867,
-0.0093780542,
0.0197900087,
0.0059046755,
-0.0561141707,
0.0369599648,
-0.014743506,
0.0021003548,
-0.0224812645,
0.0267472547,
-0.0566223599,
-0.0050723869,
0.0336839259,
0.1097876951,
-0.0429630429,
0.0067644576,
-0.0099730594,
-0.0683464929,
0.0041917553,
0.0592148006,
-0.0124339508,
-0.0049314303,
-0.0298264828,
-0.050990127,
-0.0344136097,
-0.0088406438,
-0.0095867598,
0.0059978534,
-0.0210836735,
-0.0096286349,
-0.0111638177,
-0.0061699022,
0.0684057474,
0.0366174616,
0.0326648429,
-0.018204093,
0.0031151143,
0.0005552911,
-0.1006684154,
0.0279148892,
-0.0488308929,
0.0250483193,
-0.0506609417,
-0.0299881771,
-0.0020039799,
0.0012292358,
-0.0175477676,
0.0482734777,
-0.0679970831,
-0.0468032993,
-0.0028578939,
0.0963963941,
0.0284214355,
0.0136947343,
0.0121071292,
-0.0048005879,
0.0340281688,
0.094262749,
-0.0363018289,
-0.0203956831,
0.0073553547,
-0.0304346457,
0.0313405804,
-0.0054915394,
0.0198899545,
0.006330031,
0.0638089627,
-0.0086392462,
-0.0371784233,
-0.0295896996,
0.0238617659,
0.065191254,
0.0259249248,
0.0253893882,
-0.0324095413,
-0.0479050241,
0.033613503,
-0.0143844001,
-0.0079270704,
-0.0382590815,
0.037739303,
0.0215560086,
-0.011285428,
0.0003368803,
0.0129560949,
0.016734628,
-0.0277098287,
-0.0445022434,
0.0561571904,
0.0419013388,
0.0177746788,
0.0146345655,
-0.014535157,
-0.0066796998,
-0.000692318,
0.0037115407,
0.039708443,
0.0027006315,
0.0611905456,
0.0031324066,
0.0380182825,
-0.0287485346,
0.0512330644,
-0.0338200703,
-0.0483957715,
-0.0119167278,
0.0142625645,
0.02667436,
0.0105775697,
-0.0103292596,
-0.0157171227,
-0.0289918743,
0.001700205,
-0.0014607956,
0.0116466256,
-0.0088062966,
0.0144761512,
0.0076016439,
-0.0536057614,
-0.0358838513,
0.0625962913,
-0.0191762559,
0.0801249146,
0.0200437829,
-0.0373527631,
-0.0696185306,
-0.0461915173,
0.0328494869,
0.0152642699,
0.0109055135,
-0.027579857,
-0.0412811041,
-0.0496605933,
-0.0237631463,
0.009663959,
-0.0161682889,
0.0047247438,
0.0222287588,
0.034977816,
0.0210656524,
-0.0365480185,
-0.0335877985,
0.0172789078,
-0.0079305694,
-0.0287653022,
0.045470044,
-7.195187697e-33,
-0.0042210179,
-0.0245070141,
0.0223934054,
-0.0065753451,
0.0502287261,
-0.0213073436,
-0.0079459958,
-0.0440493077,
-0.0206490327,
-0.0267866999,
-0.0547259897,
0.0059096604,
0.0217321068,
-0.0079607992,
0.0075771115,
-0.0044164229,
0.0223683827,
-0.0021873957,
-0.0115653081,
0.0115446057,
0.0356148481,
0.0370393135,
0.0463416539,
-0.0397643372,
0.0158099979,
0.0135791795,
-0.014116942,
0.0263513736,
-0.0637655482,
0.015954569,
-0.021741733,
0.0321139991,
0.0042165201,
-0.0351742581,
-0.0300941728,
0.0214554332,
-0.0701899081,
-0.0506715216,
0.0275656637,
-0.0043028365,
-0.0307893958,
-0.0537557304,
0.0203626957,
0.0206965376,
0.0100803822,
-0.0385992453,
-0.0128718466,
-0.0477080084,
0.0057728793,
-0.0311431605,
-0.0030110292,
0.0239795391,
0.0135429669,
0.0129199615,
0.0701169595,
-0.0335757434,
0.003139158,
0.003518841,
-0.0557871424,
0.0500397608,
0.0371662378,
0.0091947103,
0.0797186792,
-0.0123720327,
0.0479711853,
0.0184634011,
0.0392718129,
0.0183210969,
0.0420760624,
0.0743813291,
-0.052289702,
0.0947148502,
-0.0389464572,
0.0174187347,
0.0674202666,
-0.0228657126,
-0.0693587065,
0.0295010954,
0.0322825387,
-0.0100366827,
0.0136844944,
0.0119865863,
-0.0251128189,
-0.022019228,
-0.0159877315,
0.0128066279,
-0.025021458,
-0.0046783951,
0.0139294295,
0.0191557743,
-0.0273412,
0.0458445512,
-0.0044886842,
-0.0258264244,
0.0055338875,
0.0027819301,
0.0264408961,
-0.0581950098,
0.0230766423,
0.002701391,
-0.013596287,
-0.0246448331,
0.0227630083,
-0.0666550472,
0.066235587,
0.0227783863,
0.0112653468,
0.0563678071,
-0.0870640501,
-0.0016478666,
-0.0630572215,
0.0527039506,
0.0106805786,
0.0520243682,
-0.0040796637,
0.0043300353,
0.0171214659,
0.0295076557,
0.0097966744,
0.0336504802,
-0.0248590354,
0.0196133237,
-0.0225903392,
0.0101882517,
0.0356165357,
-0.0278222933,
-0.0121221934,
-0.0217794031,
0.0090119373,
-0.054892879,
-0.0103007685,
0.0141110113,
3.603e-7,
0.0072283559,
0.0508437343,
-0.0216016509,
0.0306449514,
-0.0021088375,
0.007725873,
0.0134597234,
-0.0053596003,
0.0397800319,
-0.0572136343,
0.0025827442,
-0.0065531358,
0.0180724859,
0.063269794,
-0.0712972358,
-0.0030635409,
0.0400279835,
-0.0381680541,
-0.0717629045,
0.000468033,
0.0123142535,
0.1128652021,
0.028070936,
-0.021061888,
0.0321141593,
-0.0067866808,
-0.0297628213,
-0.0424447581,
-0.0115165245,
0.0464757793,
0.0632519573,
0.0175843555,
-0.0212615076,
0.0588257499,
-0.0152605958,
0.0203224514,
-0.0548113473,
0.0969439149,
-0.0089097153,
0.0036650673,
0.0290267244,
-0.0745629296,
-0.0294553209,
-0.0459241942,
0.0903819427,
0.0221401267,
-0.0350659639,
0.0061455425,
0.017099373,
-0.0508114547,
0.0227178317,
-0.016760001,
0.0616460629,
0.0158881992,
-0.0007728694,
0.0037769165,
-0.0257125907,
-0.0698156357,
-0.032149259,
0.0136715546,
-0.0329339132,
-0.0648743585,
-0.035234876,
0.0325483084,
0.0476188436,
-0.0417830199,
0.008907944,
4.392746166e-34,
-0.0062530604,
0.0102326069,
0.0207230896,
0.0116284993,
0.0548608825,
-0.0123422248,
-0.0127624786,
0.0102027319,
-0.0145381559,
-0.0988546386,
-0.0327989608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01672v1 | STADEE: STAtistics-based DEEp Detection of Machine Generated Text | 2023-12-04T06:45:47 | 2023-12-04T06:45:47 | Zheng Chen, Huming Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present STADEE, a \textbf{STA}tistics-based \textbf{DEE}p detection method
to identify machine-generated text, addressing the limitations of current
methods that rely heavily on fine-tuning pre-trained language models (PLMs).
STADEE integrates key statistical text features with a deep classifier,
focusing on aspects like token probability and cumulative probability, crucial
for handling nucleus sampling. Tested across diverse datasets and scenarios
(in-domain, out-of-domain, and in-the-wild), STADEE demonstrates superior
performance, achieving an 87.05% F1 score in-domain and outperforming both
traditional statistical methods and fine-tuned PLMs, especially in
out-of-domain and in-the-wild settings, highlighting its effectiveness and
generalizability. | [
0.0304260571,
0.0665118024,
0.005362533,
0.0356225856,
-0.0222693887,
0.0175955165,
0.0039754976,
0.0271740854,
-0.0049328548,
-0.0181575995,
-0.0049689603,
-0.0270895101,
-0.0103999041,
0.0952571779,
0.0092001874,
0.0229277294,
0.0023846927,
0.0043595349,
0.0258679707,
0.0381843597,
0.0338087045,
0.014527333,
-0.0057053608,
0.021690825,
-0.0541991554,
-0.0270166788,
0.0109581249,
0.0435396619,
0.0186561309,
-0.0429658629,
0.0426947437,
0.0580583662,
0.0139837787,
0.0972276181,
0.000001879,
-0.0291317254,
-0.0375094302,
-0.0092234835,
-0.0305927359,
-0.0087394444,
0.0745253637,
-0.015657967,
-0.0459535196,
0.0191921182,
-0.0061475309,
0.0267237443,
0.0296111032,
0.0523622185,
0.0011267583,
0.0774173886,
-0.030737998,
0.0251576379,
0.0362228788,
0.0104139252,
-0.0234251022,
0.0349066593,
0.0288329888,
-0.0540968925,
-0.0449952222,
-0.0046841502,
0.0208876207,
0.0106610646,
0.028918786,
-0.0475112163,
-0.0472599752,
0.0303664468,
-0.0179910678,
-0.0124323843,
-0.0037504593,
0.0526098348,
-0.0670339465,
-0.0420317836,
0.0464727059,
-0.0328153595,
-0.000696598,
-0.019494433,
0.0168962795,
0.0261317138,
-0.0284044296,
0.0255925991,
0.0119396178,
0.0241649896,
0.0168203432,
0.0244829264,
0.0042778417,
0.0150363818,
0.024481656,
-0.0223159138,
-0.0195483081,
0.0388912037,
0.0299979895,
-0.0452915207,
0.095596619,
0.0186694786,
0.0140512306,
-0.0100225117,
-0.0871193111,
-0.0828132629,
0.0145832309,
-0.0210354328,
0.0141693158,
-0.0083527742,
-0.0566555001,
0.0314015523,
-0.0936744511,
-0.0112752561,
-0.0329990238,
0.0186091438,
0.0238786601,
0.0396365784,
0.0200319085,
-0.0210446324,
-0.0111368466,
-0.0078577977,
-0.0242030863,
-0.0417733863,
-0.0238014236,
0.0346316583,
0.0402434543,
-0.0263923854,
-0.0351169966,
-0.0192177631,
-0.0585986115,
0.0126539022,
0.0052371332,
-0.000696102,
-0.0044994974,
0.0133951316,
0.0080689909,
-0.0817651227,
-0.0338102803,
0.0844404101,
0.0165918842,
0.0113973888,
0.0247830264,
0.0511459187,
-0.0273344573,
-0.0394429974,
-0.0395728908,
-0.0487289093,
-0.0614720806,
-0.0250842404,
0.0150967138,
-0.0678734481,
-0.0362317264,
-0.0387512073,
-0.0355847217,
-0.0331652686,
0.0060609919,
0.0427154154,
0.0302079972,
0.0290482622,
-0.0116675114,
-0.0220501889,
0.0156315602,
-0.0252128039,
0.0198206343,
0.0617943592,
0.0109346639,
0.1036959812,
0.0156989116,
0.0152715631,
0.051686354,
0.0799182504,
0.0213716626,
0.0317056738,
-0.0386398025,
-0.0346033983,
-0.0273221042,
0.0043520206,
0.0773418471,
0.0305396765,
-0.0055473079,
-0.0315049924,
0.0468217134,
0.0702224448,
0.0197849888,
-0.0016213953,
0.0551064983,
0.0224932861,
-0.0052365977,
0.0149387997,
-0.0161305983,
-0.0106192231,
-0.0182422698,
0.0079971468,
0.0234096888,
0.019546099,
0.0170687381,
-0.030000994,
0.0244359765,
-0.0349173695,
-0.0172150657,
-0.0252613313,
0.0694203079,
0.0275150575,
-0.0403567702,
-0.0067156563,
-0.0027684502,
-0.0008960048,
0.0204329919,
-0.0616771393,
0.0421702787,
0.0500977188,
0.0390767604,
-0.0509709604,
0.0116702914,
-0.0461006686,
0.0153714297,
0.0841401443,
-0.0149862999,
0.0024926905,
0.0104381554,
-0.0208619926,
-0.0284804553,
-0.0138622504,
0.0019233923,
0.0412195139,
0.0202466752,
0.0120302578,
0.0145566966,
-0.0125302412,
-0.0417048596,
0.0460165478,
0.0189354997,
-0.0325480811,
0.0202256311,
0.0029974307,
0.0149775222,
0.0019089573,
-0.0463489629,
0.026810348,
0.000020292,
-0.0486953221,
-0.0174139533,
-0.0379227959,
-0.0101634795,
-0.0266335327,
0.0160299186,
-0.0284653325,
-0.0449955799,
0.0142955855,
-0.0030409095,
-0.0024270157,
0.0035316006,
-0.0650899783,
-0.0089613218,
-0.1131600067,
-0.0101244729,
-0.0175358448,
0.055637043,
-0.0180768054,
0.0609877966,
-0.0022528749,
-0.0375451818,
0.0396563597,
-0.0032911813,
0.0672131777,
-0.0230514146,
0.0012985975,
-0.0194782242,
-0.0485284477,
-0.0093740895,
0.0332287252,
0.0422985926,
-0.0198953804,
-0.0178770516,
-0.0469152816,
0.0134938257,
-0.0453165472,
0.0212901719,
0.0512144566,
-0.0032642544,
-0.0296941679,
-0.0426000915,
-0.0269348267,
-0.0371043347,
0.0552271456,
0.0192691386,
0.0531040952,
-0.043556802,
0.0374197848,
-0.0147277182,
-0.0135613447,
-0.0317313038,
0.0195520129,
0.0387910344,
-0.0312340558,
-0.049299527,
0.0629428327,
-0.0012167968,
-0.0155895064,
0.0069350745,
-0.0263511296,
0.0178516153,
-0.0434409641,
0.0505243652,
0.0897566006,
0.0143870804,
0.011356717,
0.0173356868,
0.0426355302,
-0.0165550373,
-0.0191269927,
-0.0264446121,
0.067194216,
0.0087662432,
-0.021919189,
0.0357807726,
0.0574810617,
-0.0160994753,
0.0152598666,
-0.0008235513,
0.0162244439,
0.0026431789,
-0.0500623137,
0.0048235399,
0.0182130691,
-0.0403992012,
0.0427997261,
-0.0280656442,
-0.0781839043,
0.0674759299,
-0.0501958281,
-0.0005711715,
-0.0567800514,
-0.0138536785,
-0.0056538414,
-0.011803275,
0.0088520059,
0.0108944681,
0.0082825078,
-0.0590673983,
-0.0155490087,
0.0428255275,
-0.0059487759,
-0.0317298397,
0.0054232962,
-0.0000046431,
0.0025344712,
-0.0218559243,
0.001372747,
-0.0637452155,
-0.0553274676,
-0.0192475412,
-0.0291729402,
0.0150856758,
-0.0516382195,
-0.0204666313,
-0.0044661025,
0.0157055948,
0.0533682853,
-0.0282323286,
-0.0069253258,
-0.0351741053,
0.0867694393,
0.0503292866,
-0.0315111205,
0.0487662517,
-0.0428892188,
-0.0470701046,
0.0586850047,
-0.0226599369,
0.0532412641,
-0.0157061331,
-0.0281804409,
-0.0002933886,
0.0377729349,
-0.004412645,
0.0126556484,
0.0402192362,
-0.0540122166,
-0.0198150445,
0.1021510512,
-0.0141855776,
-0.0212131683,
-0.0148057966,
0.0127602518,
0.0397880599,
0.0030836894,
0.0027709126,
-0.067374602,
-0.0275497884,
0.0140130166,
-0.0204658899,
-0.0456402898,
-0.013698752,
-0.0036043022,
-0.0759289116,
0.0227208156,
-0.0076910676,
-0.0398597904,
-0.0168787818,
-0.0233770795,
0.0089911167,
0.0287687425,
-0.028005084,
-0.0615792871,
0.0104881926,
0.0132103218,
-0.0001445601,
-0.0391103141,
-0.0263780188,
-0.027551977,
-0.0561945029,
0.0089728935,
0.0836057812,
0.0428547151,
-0.0322001576,
-0.0155293057,
0.0405169427,
-0.036762666,
-0.014339746,
0.0085786292,
0.0495969094,
-0.0270999651,
-0.0227380767,
-0.0322940275,
0.0591906421,
-0.0334819779,
0.0101026474,
-0.0137023823,
0.0488917418,
-0.0089215441,
-0.051815968,
-0.0551695228,
0.0145664075,
0.0350769125,
0.0449025817,
0.057664305,
-0.0492197238,
-0.0456198417,
-0.0578068122,
0.0296561029,
-0.0741248354,
-0.0032203991,
-0.0127499681,
0.0093929116,
-0.0358842239,
-0.0759260729,
-0.0270762481,
0.0122842602,
0.0201864,
-0.0084317476,
-0.0062102559,
-0.0140170418,
-0.0262274425,
-0.0746592656,
-0.0057029556,
-0.0185061358,
0.0320467129,
-0.0531736501,
0.0173412114,
0.0116124516,
-0.0364575796,
-0.0251844544,
0.0369567387,
-0.0542858951,
-0.0266874414,
-0.0175065342,
0.0264907163,
0.0110385204,
-0.0182025712,
-0.0249999389,
-0.0375413001,
0.1073567569,
0.0376271568,
-0.0116935549,
-0.0357017107,
0.0135455579,
-0.029882744,
-0.0389702991,
0.0067722257,
-0.0204360299,
0.0282087512,
0.0523793697,
-0.0384556577,
-0.0107898163,
-0.0177953634,
0.0185507908,
-0.0055610095,
0.0596514605,
-0.0193318874,
-0.026214255,
-0.0478645153,
-0.0274222568,
0.0194898024,
0.0092869243,
-0.0235127117,
0.0446646139,
0.0448616445,
0.0078208102,
0.0000819715,
0.0577339418,
-0.0218080841,
0.0544359498,
0.0219528656,
0.0250004232,
0.0283662006,
0.0756117925,
0.02291031,
-0.0146324839,
0.014440611,
0.059210714,
0.0027372527,
0.0308414437,
0.013214007,
0.0164355207,
0.014195649,
-0.0227206275,
0.022040708,
0.0312622786,
-0.0374321155,
0.0225051083,
-0.0578173213,
0.0287934914,
0.042106431,
-0.0070827305,
0.0083436333,
-0.0437667333,
-0.0114886593,
-0.0432737879,
0.0203063581,
0.0099302735,
-0.0016407712,
-0.0335635915,
-0.013395885,
-0.0341979079,
0.0160142072,
0.0586250573,
0.0291219987,
0.0621230192,
0.0341109335,
-0.0139629627,
-0.0486946777,
-0.0036425963,
0.0072754789,
0.0214996859,
-0.0279867109,
0.0147719476,
-0.0030128001,
-0.0408163406,
0.0607022718,
-0.0145772481,
-0.0144947004,
0.0222747978,
-0.0078290766,
0.0600075908,
-0.046742104,
0.0280877296,
-0.0220522303,
0.02395509,
0.0159561019,
-0.0341993384,
-0.0044300738,
-5.276577409e-33,
0.0386235975,
-0.0677399039,
-0.0135445958,
-0.0019043759,
0.0024798678,
0.0163693465,
-0.0390371569,
-0.0266371854,
0.0232246816,
0.0167470612,
-0.024764983,
0.0039848038,
0.0242983829,
0.0383288041,
-0.0309293196,
-0.0239082724,
0.046687115,
-0.0282864496,
-0.0279142,
0.0358165391,
0.0387703888,
0.0514829084,
0.0420386046,
-0.078204304,
-0.0053446996,
0.0002131019,
-0.0127964346,
-0.0013181773,
0.0012752543,
0.0603510588,
-0.0321245492,
-0.0143042766,
0.0288924053,
-0.0242734533,
-0.0371387377,
0.0936260074,
-0.0141133899,
-0.006879692,
-0.0669384971,
0.0227629021,
-0.0120080179,
-0.0568914674,
0.0396975204,
-0.0175134279,
-0.011002887,
0.0104730586,
0.0508760475,
-0.0355356075,
0.0197471455,
-0.0754270181,
-0.0827582106,
0.030143518,
0.0099244639,
-0.0232402012,
0.047422383,
0.0128414733,
0.0275269654,
0.0043647359,
-0.0152625721,
0.0319640525,
0.0067048101,
0.0049185464,
0.0250661336,
0.0217932891,
-0.0087203225,
0.0394684225,
0.037172094,
0.002480509,
-0.0335899182,
-0.0248039998,
0.0584230907,
0.0125000896,
0.0483582132,
0.0618666485,
0.0226673484,
0.0005145228,
-0.0813771486,
0.0624479949,
0.0308707617,
-0.0408950672,
0.0130568072,
-0.0121658063,
-0.0327773057,
0.019333519,
0.0124540981,
-0.0529438518,
-0.0072869351,
-0.0228284001,
0.0339619257,
0.0314606205,
-0.0490069278,
0.0157457944,
0.0442788936,
-0.0731304437,
-0.0117371883,
-0.0008575409,
-0.0014885798,
0.0030733268,
0.0185868312,
0.0373034552,
-0.0220879912,
-0.0151489396,
0.0418807231,
-0.0007682092,
-0.0143059175,
-0.0158735756,
0.0487501584,
0.0107404273,
-0.0601574369,
0.0445918813,
0.0118414974,
0.0113648111,
0.0428309292,
0.069996126,
-0.0004010863,
-0.0536347143,
0.0223090257,
-0.0169839822,
0.019067565,
0.0136934184,
-0.0336716324,
0.0294070616,
-0.0231909528,
0.0337230116,
-0.0462385789,
-0.0185841639,
-0.0526793785,
-0.006694783,
0.0224839021,
-0.0773957074,
0.031407062,
-0.0376618579,
2.346e-7,
0.0377783626,
0.031926997,
0.0626490787,
-0.0416364446,
0.0254362375,
0.0163376499,
0.0041342066,
0.0426918082,
-0.0448550396,
-0.0100951083,
0.0006470428,
-0.0116198128,
0.0435036048,
0.0022046538,
-0.0918320566,
0.016841216,
-0.0406194851,
0.0279318616,
-0.0475414358,
-0.0085693942,
0.0392959714,
0.1013142616,
-0.0405041799,
-0.0549511611,
0.0638311431,
-0.0650906637,
0.0408427604,
0.0233035702,
0.0336338244,
0.0105595803,
0.0244311411,
0.0144989323,
-0.0026388445,
-0.0014332643,
-0.0138528813,
-0.0019017706,
0.031739898,
0.0749692619,
0.038148623,
-0.0077447109,
-0.0077991602,
-0.0147153549,
0.0241166651,
-0.0393344872,
0.0454833098,
-0.014347123,
-0.0093941577,
-0.0422767848,
-0.0121047581,
-0.0744618997,
0.0268442072,
-0.0471584313,
-0.0048083109,
0.0242538992,
0.0158929955,
-0.0077565592,
-0.0173323434,
-0.0537931621,
-0.003583027,
-0.049733568,
-0.0458162613,
-0.0020499793,
-0.0814133212,
0.0082864305,
0.0793115422,
-0.029678084,
0.0272984691,
2.416011677e-34,
0.0248370077,
-0.0308703538,
-0.010913319,
-0.0099534951,
-0.0159880817,
0.0115716327,
0.044117488,
-0.0240145903,
0.0016168706,
-0.0361915231,
0.0098902332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01661v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01661v2 | ChatGPT as a Math Questioner? Evaluating ChatGPT on Generating Pre-university Math Questions | 2023-12-04T06:23:37 | 2024-02-28T04:33:33 | Phuoc Pham Van Long, Duc Anh Vu, Nhat M. Hoang, Xuan Long Do, Anh Tuan Luu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mathematical questioning is crucial for assessing students problem-solving
skills. Since manually creating such questions requires substantial effort,
automatic methods have been explored. Existing state-of-the-art models rely on
fine-tuning strategies and struggle to generate questions that heavily involve
multiple steps of logical and arithmetic reasoning. Meanwhile, large language
models(LLMs) such as ChatGPT have excelled in many NLP tasks involving logical
and arithmetic reasoning. Nonetheless, their applications in generating
educational questions are underutilized, especially in the field of
mathematics. To bridge this gap, we take the first step to conduct an in-depth
analysis of ChatGPT in generating pre-university math questions. Our analysis
is categorized into two main settings: context-aware and context-unaware. In
the context-aware setting, we evaluate ChatGPT on existing math
question-answering benchmarks covering elementary, secondary, and ternary
classes. In the context-unaware setting, we evaluate ChatGPT in generating math
questions for each lesson from pre-university math curriculums that we crawl.
Our crawling results in TopicMath, a comprehensive and novel collection of
pre-university math curriculums collected from 121 math topics and 428 lessons
from elementary, secondary, and tertiary classes. Through this analysis, we aim
to provide insight into the potential of ChatGPT as a math questioner. | [
-0.0168491099,
0.0483251773,
-0.0031538261,
0.0280666891,
-0.0653543994,
0.0072407927,
0.0172108058,
-0.0284448527,
-0.0409255214,
-0.0517701767,
0.0047842334,
-0.0097513655,
-0.034577094,
0.0123578599,
0.0339709483,
-0.0142196119,
-0.0008442475,
-0.010865883,
-0.0003305694,
0.0129691632,
-0.0200220142,
-0.0023456216,
-0.0310842246,
-0.0043546604,
-0.0401868075,
-0.0668978021,
-0.0082453527,
-0.0548009686,
-0.0173355136,
-0.0358996652,
0.0232703723,
0.0678826794,
0.0026522907,
0.0245105121,
0.0000020345,
-0.0580751486,
-0.0237860549,
-0.0100396601,
-0.0220675152,
-0.0003361469,
0.0182956606,
0.0507656187,
0.0219298862,
0.0269705299,
-0.1012545228,
0.043841213,
-0.0007070717,
-0.0045280918,
0.0860167965,
0.0536073372,
0.0064739599,
-0.0178205743,
0.0190852787,
0.0070125987,
0.1047350615,
-0.0650372431,
-0.0040943702,
0.0782012418,
0.0300472155,
0.0356225073,
-0.045725327,
0.026155442,
0.0577129051,
-0.0311185811,
-0.0015166182,
-0.0096223373,
-0.0675267577,
0.0191043057,
-0.0055044582,
0.0745073259,
0.0131526813,
-0.0092600919,
0.0162222739,
0.0197934136,
0.0010270332,
0.0122632366,
-0.0813504308,
0.022901468,
-0.0234112255,
-0.0368730575,
-0.0014266361,
0.0017040391,
-0.02324255,
0.0183368176,
0.0003204667,
0.0360531136,
0.0067643635,
-0.0351920128,
-0.0401597396,
-0.0016517447,
-0.0718767196,
-0.0542223006,
0.0329072587,
0.0690171197,
0.0324382409,
0.0131654181,
-0.0094081908,
-0.0480433926,
-0.0094327331,
0.0014318828,
-0.0109968353,
0.1007422134,
-0.0034484414,
0.0194177963,
0.0073600449,
0.0697669163,
0.0205518547,
0.0141313663,
-0.0526463278,
0.0431144461,
-0.0190882515,
-0.0142974192,
-0.0427642241,
0.0436498448,
0.0281163026,
0.0001417668,
-0.0413780808,
0.025770003,
-0.021954691,
0.0112444833,
-0.0008140878,
-0.0094910339,
-0.0193219204,
-0.0205138624,
-0.0139838895,
0.0104173655,
-0.0469690152,
-0.001062036,
0.014596168,
-0.0338415653,
-0.0224044118,
0.0354528129,
-0.0054875198,
-0.0243315604,
0.0281564519,
0.0616616495,
-0.0080197155,
0.0030405931,
0.0069950107,
-0.0459239185,
0.0271501746,
-0.0365885049,
0.0053869993,
-0.0911047831,
0.0347666182,
0.0366308168,
-0.0304417573,
0.0162230991,
0.0169733688,
0.033469148,
0.0627889484,
0.0227816217,
0.0502461195,
0.0052614715,
0.05196869,
0.0103565445,
-0.0311464928,
0.0429750755,
0.0483419336,
-0.0131603079,
0.0379694365,
-0.0083003966,
0.0038641968,
0.0103257271,
0.0397134423,
-0.0048208423,
0.024120409,
0.031706091,
0.0176534373,
0.0246626418,
-0.0416839421,
0.0462320596,
-0.029275611,
0.0032260485,
-0.0035001866,
0.0771839321,
0.0039485581,
0.0264281202,
0.0420232676,
0.0045126746,
0.0416750461,
0.0247308686,
-0.0616342314,
0.0192924589,
-0.0313300341,
0.0059990068,
0.0247699227,
0.019397486,
-0.0165000483,
-0.0597122423,
-0.0029040757,
0.0272242688,
-0.0073746066,
0.0246239547,
0.0362586901,
0.0122448225,
0.0155151421,
0.0373417065,
-0.0068886084,
-0.0372746922,
0.0363086462,
-0.0618059412,
0.0390467793,
-0.0260343477,
0.0809344351,
-0.0559486374,
-0.0731297731,
-0.0064769913,
0.0420631245,
0.0182707869,
0.0451011844,
-0.0319354534,
-0.0269433893,
-0.0104961824,
0.0247536153,
-0.0477823429,
0.0118329413,
-0.0250409842,
0.0463159941,
-0.0051945848,
0.0284895524,
-0.0646216422,
0.0548209175,
0.0254327375,
-0.0536735952,
-0.0501069874,
-0.0153936967,
-0.0096668592,
-0.0314982608,
0.0053241309,
0.0315446369,
0.0487851128,
0.0130678816,
-0.0282120798,
-0.0060939128,
-0.0071283197,
-0.0869542435,
-0.0793044195,
0.0723026916,
-0.0591218472,
-0.0000541877,
-0.0159427002,
-0.0472773574,
-0.0115006436,
0.0630674809,
-0.0301466472,
0.0159060992,
-0.0105306106,
0.0280579943,
0.0110804699,
-0.0552148782,
-0.0299709756,
0.0747886822,
0.0452036485,
0.0338595323,
0.0146511365,
0.0258035269,
0.0303647891,
-0.0158597007,
0.0247127768,
-0.0270091984,
-0.0442179926,
0.0263680387,
-0.0085753389,
0.0625762865,
-0.062515296,
-0.0291605461,
-0.0145902252,
0.0332055092,
-0.0277431402,
0.0585714318,
0.0481379889,
-0.0217048135,
-0.0071807085,
-0.0072293258,
-0.0828802884,
0.0043754741,
0.0228413194,
-0.0190142877,
0.0489884801,
0.0132749612,
0.0215901043,
-0.0299700834,
-0.0183253214,
-0.0579341911,
0.0217239521,
0.047175955,
0.0651879907,
0.0088337995,
0.0348783135,
-0.0344657451,
-0.0180608127,
0.0140764536,
0.0342514217,
0.0272794291,
-0.0417562723,
0.0561066717,
0.0293166358,
-0.0006034391,
0.024731433,
-0.0167504549,
-0.0651218668,
-0.0338806771,
0.0064561567,
-0.0390272774,
-0.0011607438,
0.0147409663,
-0.0287906341,
-0.0153279016,
0.069158569,
-0.0051598651,
-0.0348554514,
-0.0311476924,
0.0845809281,
-0.0378188267,
0.0528115965,
-0.1037100255,
0.0179573037,
0.0074770446,
0.0531153865,
-0.0001625724,
-0.0163728297,
0.0499431379,
0.0111166704,
-0.0215224903,
-0.0829111934,
0.044607915,
-0.0728681609,
0.0478911102,
0.0185274463,
-0.0254943985,
-0.03157432,
-0.0176923834,
-0.0709073618,
0.0332690254,
0.0587536208,
-0.0499454029,
0.036632251,
-0.0491007827,
-0.0212574769,
-0.0128475176,
-0.0318921618,
-0.0456623845,
0.0107571436,
0.034433756,
0.0214056168,
-0.0038491541,
-0.0120360116,
0.0045193699,
-0.003305784,
0.0057290555,
-0.0077868085,
-0.0606931336,
-0.0459764525,
-0.0099381208,
0.0654776394,
0.0514828674,
0.0270177238,
0.0486670323,
-0.0290680174,
0.0366298929,
0.0573353134,
0.0696790963,
0.0280678105,
0.0303618871,
0.0492051579,
0.0062832786,
-0.0240711123,
-0.0012311483,
0.0480619818,
0.0157527812,
-0.0863796324,
-0.0320694633,
0.0990007371,
0.0552639402,
0.020510748,
-0.0102475863,
-0.0685609728,
0.0247070603,
-0.0003904311,
0.0232574381,
-0.10184706,
-0.0010851661,
0.0006409435,
-0.0084235892,
-0.0131823476,
-0.0239832718,
-0.0107885059,
-0.0972947553,
0.0101538552,
0.0089213643,
-0.0451958403,
0.0326548964,
-0.0177239589,
-0.0104151797,
0.0115889441,
-0.0011855834,
0.0278034341,
-0.0178355183,
0.051024396,
0.0228634533,
-0.0179339759,
-0.0177307352,
0.0132811842,
0.013722769,
-0.0319489688,
-0.0040570786,
0.0033428015,
-0.0197397601,
-0.046239201,
0.0357647128,
0.0052236663,
-0.0566510856,
-0.0010924371,
-0.0181388576,
-0.0228052624,
0.0037189228,
-0.0296507385,
0.0624570623,
-0.0578086264,
-0.0203627348,
0.0618254021,
0.0764545351,
-0.0188585371,
0.0183602367,
-0.0205831882,
0.0465686433,
-0.0205839761,
0.0729523972,
0.0355452113,
-0.0235417448,
-0.0060993121,
-0.0419763438,
-0.0024236662,
-0.0459988229,
-0.0323673896,
0.0005541578,
0.0547709726,
-0.0031008737,
-0.0431504548,
-0.0414069071,
0.0729308426,
0.014860848,
-0.0051287492,
-0.0470007248,
0.0255670827,
0.008988278,
-0.032618165,
0.0316761583,
-0.0187593624,
-0.0037139342,
-0.0433594659,
0.0284623913,
-0.0030082245,
-0.0343222879,
-0.0536771305,
0.0026353353,
-0.1389991641,
-0.0382940546,
-0.0121620437,
0.012677921,
0.0203192327,
-0.0446831286,
-0.019081315,
0.0314844064,
-0.0209025741,
0.0173741169,
-0.0518659428,
0.0034852128,
-0.0133081302,
0.0122705568,
0.0213706326,
-0.0050087604,
-0.0138437441,
0.0140669737,
-0.0004166556,
0.0680046827,
-0.0379910395,
-0.0163986571,
0.0358392149,
0.0301798061,
-0.0154762361,
0.0341526717,
0.0146266455,
-0.0035941831,
-0.0078347018,
-0.0408821553,
-0.0173230171,
-0.0381574705,
0.0031229067,
-0.0089194002,
-0.0193465184,
-0.0011117642,
-0.0326113664,
-0.0250675529,
0.0659664795,
0.014166492,
0.0520893224,
-0.0195696652,
0.0049134581,
0.0333378203,
-0.044991754,
0.018639965,
-0.0368891023,
-0.0058634682,
0.0764099583,
-0.0079076225,
0.0783027038,
0.0102145728,
0.0092721432,
0.0063654692,
-0.0047770841,
-0.0341930948,
-0.0653953552,
-0.0188963301,
0.0498269312,
-0.0014262608,
0.0309671666,
-0.0228118002,
-0.0426746085,
-0.0056211404,
-0.0066516763,
0.0240590889,
0.0516334362,
-0.0365710966,
0.0268396251,
0.0246647224,
0.0351189375,
-0.0572397783,
0.0338249877,
-0.0433562659,
0.004221153,
0.0446810313,
0.0135312313,
-0.0333099514,
-0.0180444177,
-0.0010485048,
0.0189959519,
0.0339975208,
0.0480330139,
-0.0889612958,
-0.0505859964,
-0.0215846132,
0.0066955276,
-0.0151704298,
0.0016604663,
0.0430587865,
0.0848273262,
-0.0377085246,
-0.003475904,
0.001321563,
0.0701231733,
-0.0741607249,
-0.0458756723,
-0.0422708169,
-5.811831415e-33,
-0.0296648256,
-0.0580949634,
0.0604969896,
0.0405975059,
0.0098133627,
-0.017880382,
-0.0248704068,
0.0609223694,
-0.0149997389,
-0.0109058013,
-0.0074229385,
0.0223868471,
-0.0115677593,
0.0336894058,
-0.0279735755,
-0.0378724374,
-0.0246505644,
-0.0301217567,
-0.0438040979,
0.0112704057,
-0.0076905834,
-0.0104926815,
0.0419363566,
-0.0090402458,
0.0071119936,
-0.039075356,
0.0210941825,
0.0294208825,
-0.0197788458,
0.0430834815,
-0.0157459714,
0.0187592097,
0.0263603162,
-0.0064218128,
-0.0014465044,
0.0236673281,
-0.0094914651,
-0.0793029889,
-0.0215574,
-0.0000438683,
-0.0537607484,
-0.0249485299,
-0.0082924962,
0.0054080319,
-0.0137861883,
-0.0332806967,
0.0401863679,
0.0020278199,
0.0176866595,
-0.0247094948,
-0.0497405455,
0.0377953984,
-0.0449126177,
-0.0564115569,
-0.0241423901,
0.0584699586,
0.0031475436,
-0.0067460565,
0.0101642832,
0.0400005877,
0.0213070232,
0.0215657614,
0.0173333529,
-0.0330471806,
-0.0128432112,
0.0143224513,
-0.010296002,
0.0001649975,
0.0031292001,
0.0069634113,
0.0112036401,
0.0316295065,
0.0913878083,
0.0150914146,
0.0646419078,
0.0419781357,
-0.0540280044,
0.0316073187,
0.0320250578,
-0.0073184175,
-0.0091318386,
-0.0524922237,
-0.0291020311,
0.0037527678,
-0.0492498726,
0.06327869,
-0.0475441888,
-0.0218940582,
0.0366691016,
-0.0474345274,
-0.0052519781,
-0.0066332342,
0.0184178576,
-0.0071706665,
-0.005732365,
0.0145077603,
-0.0187953841,
0.0176274907,
-0.0172112621,
0.0689280927,
-0.0370330848,
-0.0009209417,
0.0035682721,
0.0123555558,
-0.0065328702,
0.0286016222,
-0.0137402583,
0.0099575454,
-0.0278168377,
-0.0218995903,
-0.0348816849,
0.0210303199,
0.0239571687,
0.0034191955,
0.0067701172,
0.0482233986,
-0.0104199853,
0.0192965325,
0.0256159473,
-0.0332325883,
-0.0408625007,
0.0058348486,
-0.0094911586,
0.0005852473,
-0.0045410963,
-0.0091056256,
-0.0313276164,
0.0088150371,
0.0187187493,
-0.0616406724,
0.0082040774,
-0.0259241406,
2.681e-7,
0.062984705,
0.0267520603,
0.013483326,
0.0292775575,
0.0091959694,
-0.003251899,
-0.0067207017,
-0.0517443977,
0.0477537885,
-0.016082691,
-0.0021983553,
0.045256637,
0.0254829042,
0.0415323861,
-0.0316258892,
0.0292853117,
-0.0337311514,
-0.0334692709,
-0.0344649702,
0.0155153498,
0.104606308,
0.0211894233,
-0.0163272284,
-0.003875748,
-0.0278633032,
-0.0606705025,
0.0392605513,
0.0145585723,
-0.0290330555,
0.0483128168,
-0.0042225216,
-0.0218248628,
0.0462528989,
-0.0012254599,
-0.0140047865,
0.0071686218,
0.0243191496,
0.0381489843,
0.0519032851,
0.0007262284,
-0.019485645,
-0.0321404338,
-0.0135375317,
-0.0503020994,
0.0404391028,
-0.0920920372,
-0.0071912338,
-0.0035768079,
-0.021838611,
-0.0130660748,
-0.0114888316,
-0.0096604368,
-0.0116456654,
0.0054345941,
0.0365783349,
-0.0146694025,
0.0220815726,
-0.0129988985,
-0.0257933587,
0.0015162796,
-0.0421238467,
-0.055355072,
-0.0582469665,
-0.0112751145,
0.0164842829,
0.0070066405,
-0.0294586606,
2.538611835e-34,
0.0532445014,
-0.0282036625,
0.0432030261,
0.0089036385,
0.0231140126,
0.0049129413,
0.0034067093,
0.0095164096,
0.0330398269,
-0.0452602804,
-0.001845877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03003v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03003v2 | Explore, Select, Derive, and Recall: Augmenting LLM with Human-like Memory for Mobile Task Automation | 2023-12-04T06:13:35 | 2024-03-16T06:17:52 | Sunjae Lee, Junyoung Choi, Jungjae Lee, Munim Hasan Wasi, Hojun Choi, Steven Y. Ko, Sangeun Oh, Insik Shin | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has opened up new opportunities in
the field of mobile task automation. Their superior language understanding and
reasoning capabilities allow users to automate complex and repetitive tasks.
However, due to the inherent unreliability and high operational cost of LLMs,
their practical applicability is quite limited. To address these issues, this
paper introduces MobileGPT, an innovative LLM-based mobile task automator
equipped with a human-like app memory. MobileGPT emulates the cognitive process
of humans interacting with a mobile app -- explore, select, derive, and recall.
This approach allows for a more precise and efficient learning of a task's
procedure by breaking it down into smaller, modular sub-tasks that can be
re-used, re-arranged, and adapted for various objectives. We implement
MobileGPT using online LLMs services (GPT-3.5 and GPT-4) and evaluate its
performance on a dataset of 160 user instructions across 8 widely used mobile
apps. The results indicate that MobileGPT can automate and learn new tasks with
82.5% accuracy, and is able to adapt them to different contexts with near
perfect (98.75%) accuracy while reducing both latency and cost by 62.5% and
68.8%, respectively, compared to the GPT-4 powered baseline. | [
0.0410146117,
-0.0055550816,
-0.0349969566,
-0.0053619063,
-0.0305452924,
0.0106001012,
0.0056429943,
-0.014551444,
0.049266994,
-0.0480305403,
-0.0271638203,
-0.028601665,
-0.0121193537,
-0.0217610057,
-0.0053100348,
-0.0413949341,
0.0477086157,
-0.0414503664,
-0.016335154,
0.0103991888,
-0.0191281438,
-0.0047429833,
-0.0057245363,
0.0349485092,
0.0156267136,
-0.034204416,
-0.024301799,
0.0234542172,
-0.004745061,
-0.0692540333,
-0.0193968788,
0.0350908861,
0.0319609158,
0.0055509801,
0.0000022887,
-0.04189362,
-0.0084263496,
-0.0297248606,
-0.0219209902,
-0.007536721,
0.0164516196,
0.0690459907,
-0.0262225289,
0.0344540589,
-0.0412701033,
0.0133568821,
0.0319839418,
-0.0000576275,
0.0485237017,
0.0332822464,
0.0010677653,
0.0250898302,
-0.0204725098,
0.002312545,
0.0547559261,
-0.0519828536,
0.0069116293,
0.0027900503,
0.0523336753,
0.0066835037,
0.0412573963,
-0.0146640353,
0.0477968827,
0.0402410142,
-0.0395885557,
0.0277605448,
0.0134108886,
-0.026564993,
-0.0245038271,
0.0170464218,
-0.0379607044,
-0.0161109548,
0.0580472276,
0.0162569173,
-0.0356735177,
0.0209397264,
-0.0629387274,
0.0138718672,
-0.0424055904,
-0.0045402343,
-0.0178909078,
-0.0262457989,
0.0436664186,
0.0116897533,
-0.0204094239,
0.0457982831,
-0.0004692716,
-0.0304198228,
0.0147535512,
-0.0097913695,
-0.0127637312,
-0.0365312845,
0.0415230766,
0.0664068088,
-0.0735785365,
0.0178760495,
-0.0268676076,
-0.0304391123,
0.0059034252,
-0.0287301764,
0.0390012749,
0.0499478243,
-0.0208123252,
0.023615934,
-0.014410059,
0.0653203055,
0.0090776198,
-0.0258210227,
-0.0219428651,
0.0248120259,
-0.0736272559,
-0.0086425403,
-0.0188660715,
0.0500015393,
-0.0295673646,
-0.0029331746,
-0.0376982652,
0.0617583022,
0.0034625658,
0.0202206522,
0.0092706317,
-0.0020167292,
-0.0230243914,
0.0040997411,
-0.0324512534,
-0.0315594636,
-0.0410795957,
0.0305861961,
0.011828023,
-0.0725750104,
0.0069553861,
-0.0152389854,
-0.0339701995,
0.0025826972,
-0.0038430607,
0.0738832206,
-0.0267188735,
-0.0344442278,
-0.0819866061,
-0.017262876,
0.0404785462,
-0.064312771,
0.0006350474,
-0.064134866,
0.0255528819,
0.0185603704,
-0.0333631672,
-0.0132429888,
0.0295109116,
0.0753453076,
-0.008536662,
0.0469451472,
0.0123414025,
0.0102567617,
0.0584147051,
0.0280753504,
-0.0291029699,
0.0334578604,
0.0267189667,
0.0852954164,
0.0251291376,
0.0044457414,
0.0386819281,
0.0563493595,
-0.0276225489,
-0.033593744,
0.0374777429,
-0.0208888948,
0.0123923197,
0.0131772552,
0.0020038798,
0.0427657962,
-0.0095870793,
0.0492222197,
0.0850370228,
0.0952408686,
-0.0113044325,
0.0200225003,
0.0118831517,
0.0337621607,
-0.0001588017,
-0.0390171409,
-0.1068849862,
0.0386660136,
-0.0429976732,
0.0089714816,
0.0049667023,
0.0220744815,
-0.0247261785,
0.0025236746,
-0.0166506395,
-0.0283259731,
0.0435128659,
0.0231908113,
0.0332238339,
-0.0186687913,
-0.0255498737,
0.0618498176,
-0.0093629416,
-0.0233748388,
-0.0523325875,
-0.0777537525,
0.0542325489,
0.0811853409,
0.0318143554,
-0.0343506597,
-0.0113685094,
0.0241922103,
-0.0056084348,
-0.0205029603,
0.0133002587,
0.0002470305,
-0.0010590097,
-0.0390616581,
-0.0121366167,
0.0043943361,
0.0118905054,
0.016731862,
0.0662604123,
0.0225932319,
0.0134745538,
-0.032871183,
-0.0160809532,
0.0179324038,
-0.0001155684,
-0.0568377823,
0.0129988845,
0.0115394723,
0.0099651981,
-0.0107105365,
0.0296101626,
-0.0165481679,
0.038357649,
-0.0238486044,
0.0252184067,
0.009741595,
-0.058398243,
0.0340518802,
0.0134963449,
0.0270052627,
0.0117238266,
0.0243298784,
-0.0006518223,
-0.0423612408,
0.0001264964,
0.0051535852,
0.0474521555,
-0.0125114685,
0.0468909591,
0.0264537279,
-0.0426216312,
-0.0161730871,
0.0759833157,
0.0025603776,
0.0000082302,
0.0265313387,
0.0050414042,
-0.0091962423,
-0.0289622601,
0.0158951674,
0.0217926502,
-0.0171460435,
0.013668946,
-0.0020799555,
0.0377714038,
-0.0479441583,
-0.0229130425,
-0.1062973812,
0.0526522361,
-0.0420988724,
0.0163436849,
0.0267084707,
0.0472337604,
-0.0023518556,
-0.0441526137,
0.0067161592,
0.0354659185,
-0.0023940189,
0.0499184206,
-0.0167438947,
-0.0240364,
0.0014649943,
-0.0199799333,
0.0187208857,
0.0102456948,
0.0008385461,
-0.0208591465,
-0.0044063134,
-0.0573808476,
0.0183804408,
0.0010567775,
0.0104647074,
-0.0320818983,
-0.0055726571,
0.0493213236,
-0.0255689658,
0.0286968406,
0.0713654011,
-0.0120599298,
0.0327639543,
0.0424771011,
-0.0353902429,
-0.044433251,
0.0094323382,
0.0077352845,
-0.0466990024,
-0.0011272625,
-0.0344532058,
0.0137813929,
0.082500957,
-0.0232803002,
0.0450071879,
-0.0069626616,
-0.0198986642,
-0.0226331055,
-0.0165688228,
-0.0193007626,
0.0276707336,
-0.0700632185,
0.0120702861,
-0.0249290094,
-0.0662061721,
0.0429885797,
-0.0013634874,
0.016373463,
-0.0261157155,
-0.0158573762,
0.0182010997,
0.1187624261,
-0.0051680882,
-0.0077108881,
-0.0016011468,
-0.0503266901,
-0.0099970764,
0.0076593412,
-0.0049013942,
-0.073417902,
0.0489000157,
-0.1146263406,
-0.0096210176,
-0.0032934996,
-0.0477314666,
-0.0381212085,
0.0262756832,
-0.055679217,
-0.0114610586,
-0.0095411371,
-0.0268873125,
-0.0354182422,
-0.0003593893,
0.0592588633,
0.0640147477,
-0.014859668,
0.0000564465,
-0.0155635932,
-0.0219591763,
0.0132406494,
0.044685401,
-0.0621652305,
0.0005749058,
0.0226995945,
0.0389360003,
0.0572817139,
-0.0353816822,
-0.0098364949,
0.0155142257,
0.0291154198,
-0.0397023894,
-0.028831277,
0.0955480933,
0.0624450371,
-0.0869987309,
-0.0234397817,
0.0950989351,
0.0333880372,
-0.0542917699,
-0.00171431,
-0.0290264413,
-0.0165434517,
0.0260728467,
0.036707066,
-0.0836363435,
-0.0665856749,
0.0320135094,
0.0328660347,
0.015688315,
-0.0219111443,
-0.0145589318,
-0.0717078894,
-0.0009141173,
0.0106209051,
-0.0242054537,
0.0076134969,
-0.0511429384,
0.0012981318,
0.0023285141,
-0.0039391066,
0.0216981247,
0.0047635227,
-0.0054700915,
-0.0230943114,
-0.0606840216,
-0.035279505,
0.0781534016,
-0.0082424637,
-0.001892613,
0.0860277265,
-0.0057634888,
0.0259002652,
-0.0433151647,
0.0184343494,
-0.0113291815,
0.0286528263,
-0.0371015854,
-0.0296806861,
0.0083805667,
0.0220940169,
-0.0087310513,
0.0746990517,
-0.0450721532,
-0.0598467477,
0.0411509126,
0.1060116142,
-0.0287857447,
-0.0005146161,
-0.0059693251,
-0.0489692204,
0.0517160036,
0.0504073203,
-0.0164999831,
-0.0505783446,
-0.0580714643,
-0.0353417248,
-0.0361340009,
-0.0130571974,
-0.016451031,
0.003941677,
0.0153305186,
-0.0084483093,
-0.0350897871,
0.0005355758,
0.0400322601,
0.0208114237,
0.0234761499,
0.0267330837,
0.0629859492,
0.0235038828,
-0.065512076,
-0.0025047183,
0.0007957772,
0.0195514448,
-0.0401377194,
-0.0266595557,
0.0191343129,
-0.0587417781,
0.0303361882,
0.013907833,
-0.0833021924,
-0.0301646199,
0.0192035791,
0.054101374,
0.0314352885,
0.0439056829,
-0.0110203493,
-0.0295737088,
-0.0012096366,
0.0364564694,
-0.077528961,
0.0281330664,
-0.0157552008,
0.0301983487,
-0.0091319112,
0.012724353,
-0.0781655312,
0.0075788898,
0.0039834189,
0.0400794894,
-0.0612224452,
-0.0072860317,
0.0350777134,
-0.0012378884,
0.0504394919,
-0.0057045817,
0.0071822437,
0.0074066566,
0.028136231,
0.0210572165,
-0.0102532841,
-0.0229745805,
0.0062823659,
-0.0531824343,
-0.0239753556,
0.0239436738,
-0.0419167727,
0.0171527267,
-0.0152687253,
-0.0147052491,
0.0084351674,
-0.0172816161,
0.0409885272,
0.0259290636,
0.0085842684,
-0.0372809954,
0.0218753684,
0.0159423966,
0.059697181,
-0.0419433638,
0.0989166275,
-0.0333470888,
-0.0117428014,
-0.0326841921,
0.0439942665,
-0.0271802153,
-0.0738102421,
0.014144497,
0.0400021821,
0.044484701,
-0.0130858002,
0.0051309327,
-0.0718469694,
0.0136394985,
-0.0479933657,
-0.0008358781,
-0.0103401383,
0.0078035803,
-0.0063698706,
0.0333891921,
-0.002242415,
-0.0016322638,
0.0396700837,
-0.0369019248,
-0.0051375246,
0.0049339375,
-0.033773981,
-0.0635415465,
-0.0243129339,
0.0295509566,
0.0291046407,
-0.0231443364,
-0.0347234346,
-0.0306695532,
-0.0124314073,
0.0014099844,
-0.0006344398,
0.012452241,
-0.0798258185,
0.0573655255,
0.0848099366,
-0.0061698584,
-0.028475821,
-0.0285009351,
-0.0005989672,
-0.0253071487,
0.0004789597,
-0.0518128239,
-5.97213909e-33,
-0.0155712236,
-0.0203401372,
0.0567417108,
-0.0042837467,
-0.0232185759,
-0.0436194763,
-0.0390872732,
0.0079406723,
0.0256545823,
-0.0419103429,
-0.0379534289,
-0.0202092007,
0.0194579568,
0.0082188798,
0.0399445333,
0.0150060523,
0.041772157,
-0.0130405333,
-0.0514504761,
0.0458960757,
0.0267852992,
0.0306072924,
0.0114412392,
-0.042481605,
-0.0004963671,
0.0064141024,
0.0309070516,
-0.0337235779,
-0.0060963864,
0.0109734191,
-0.0357227996,
0.0075033326,
0.0400396585,
-0.0413490832,
-0.0185948256,
0.0385575406,
-0.0374960974,
-0.0384842344,
0.01668269,
0.0228093918,
-0.0445332862,
-0.0413026251,
0.0316117331,
-0.0004132611,
-0.0567367747,
0.0465795323,
0.0229921341,
-0.0246380195,
-0.059158355,
0.0003985756,
-0.0276778787,
0.0096184891,
0.0624374896,
-0.0388679244,
-0.0129192919,
0.0020247286,
-0.0907258317,
0.0038428241,
-0.0597085208,
0.0131556103,
-0.0285198484,
0.0334089994,
0.0709855631,
0.0266301651,
0.0220318101,
0.0638608336,
-0.0106291091,
0.000195849,
-0.0448862463,
0.0027619277,
-0.0141209224,
0.0720800608,
-0.0215594601,
-0.0416746214,
0.0388777219,
-0.0318795033,
-0.0230780356,
0.0086729908,
0.0364396386,
0.0631683022,
0.0526962318,
0.0286247768,
-0.0158680715,
-0.0089079048,
0.0063880449,
0.0558202453,
-0.0168098398,
-0.0439970903,
0.055518996,
0.0138774049,
-0.0088292714,
-0.0526595153,
0.0179195926,
0.022051597,
0.0065017263,
-0.0557494126,
0.0085513666,
0.0124596329,
-0.013079254,
0.0160146579,
-0.0606983304,
-0.0258556362,
-0.0537473634,
0.0056063402,
0.0455396809,
0.0340635516,
-0.0319915451,
0.0496754907,
-0.0528978854,
0.0048545478,
-0.0435825288,
0.0271221027,
-0.0108622033,
0.0130388997,
0.0535090975,
-0.0046220832,
-0.0026497715,
0.0571870804,
-0.0410660617,
-0.0866123363,
-0.0247609057,
-0.0208269451,
0.0287012402,
-0.0081394762,
-0.0235828292,
0.0069555677,
-0.0832348689,
0.0161111113,
-0.0158945564,
-0.0291389879,
0.0067049777,
0.0386944041,
3.019e-7,
-0.0523259267,
0.0103613529,
-0.0464522839,
0.0254848022,
0.0345337465,
0.0321178697,
0.0063937739,
0.014769475,
0.0063333241,
-0.0181859061,
-0.0165162813,
0.0348120965,
0.0464702621,
0.0283889584,
-0.0578882769,
0.0223240182,
-0.0085657081,
0.0257917047,
-0.0504893698,
0.0355801024,
0.0354615003,
0.0434468463,
0.0063386741,
0.0162861459,
0.03140058,
-0.0292987134,
0.0320828557,
-0.0290286001,
0.0106423413,
-0.0266248211,
0.0055659176,
0.063288562,
-0.0251816232,
0.0093749342,
-0.0275499783,
-0.0274447892,
-0.029885659,
0.0644143522,
0.0141570019,
-0.013837602,
0.0045760451,
-0.0447560474,
0.0142342858,
-0.0354302637,
0.0545424037,
-0.0365129374,
0.0026374203,
0.0182059389,
0.0360175669,
-0.0244911462,
-0.0492707789,
0.0201322194,
-0.0067977807,
-0.0063784122,
-0.0032455737,
0.0275551658,
-0.0365091749,
-0.0805652961,
0.0019602387,
0.0414120108,
-0.0326901749,
-0.0494423434,
-0.0929824337,
0.0207170378,
-0.0220186096,
-0.0334903486,
-0.0033121749,
2.753696306e-34,
-0.0034014513,
-0.0020146891,
0.0129802087,
0.0569341369,
0.0123157892,
0.03041232,
0.0205250625,
0.0630417988,
0.040276207,
-0.0477928855,
-0.0063601499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01648v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01648v2 | Characterizing Large Language Model Geometry Solves Toxicity Detection and Generation | 2023-12-04T06:01:32 | 2023-12-11T03:07:05 | Randall Balestriero, Romain Cosentino, Sarath Shekkizhar | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models~(LLMs) drive current AI breakthroughs despite very
little being known about their internal representations, e.g., how to extract a
few informative features to solve various downstream tasks. To provide a
practical and principled answer, we propose to characterize LLMs from a
geometric perspective. We obtain in closed form (i) the intrinsic dimension in
which the Multi-Head Attention embeddings are constrained to exist and (ii) the
partition and per-region affine mappings of the per-layer feedforward networks.
Our results are informative, do not rely on approximations, and are actionable.
First, we show that, motivated by our geometric interpretation, we can bypass
Llama$2$'s RLHF by controlling its embedding's intrinsic dimension through
informed prompt manipulation. Second, we derive $7$ interpretable spline
features that can be extracted from any (pre-trained) LLM layer, providing a
rich abstract representation of their inputs. Those features alone ($224$ for
Mistral-7B/Llama$2$-7B and $560$ for Llama$2$-70B) are sufficient to help solve
toxicity detection, infer the domain of the prompt, and even tackle the Jigsaw
challenge, which aims at characterizing the type of toxicity of various
prompts. Our results demonstrate how, even in large-scale regimes, exact
theoretical results can answer practical questions in language models. Code:
\url{https://github.com/RandallBalestriero/SplineLLM}. | [
0.0040570456,
0.0156020792,
-0.0240232088,
0.0631556213,
-0.0137975328,
0.0032202085,
0.010173074,
-0.00598825,
0.0630097911,
-0.0091253472,
-0.034712892,
-0.019365536,
-0.0370003581,
0.078265816,
0.036497578,
-0.0409121588,
-0.0033601893,
-0.0640154332,
-0.0168809257,
0.0054598786,
-0.0113536054,
0.0094176605,
0.0321325772,
0.0479274765,
-0.027387999,
-0.0285737179,
-0.0078660408,
-0.0147332074,
0.0317020863,
-0.0391800143,
-0.0378082953,
-0.009191284,
0.0200039018,
0.0729865581,
0.000002471,
-0.0266198143,
-0.0024604888,
0.0084094508,
-0.0019223703,
-0.0000935607,
0.0336272381,
-0.0494410917,
-0.042254027,
-0.0182485096,
-0.01657,
0.0188400801,
0.0427878723,
0.0432669744,
0.0729928762,
0.0956317335,
-0.0065034614,
-0.0190466624,
0.054213848,
-0.0420310237,
0.0081384862,
0.0151231261,
0.0394541509,
-0.0567558929,
-0.0148130432,
0.0100159021,
-0.0378308073,
0.040503677,
0.0403733738,
-0.0272933561,
0.0034827224,
0.0319568962,
-0.008427172,
-0.0130975759,
0.0175274909,
0.1035180539,
-0.0805262476,
0.0051442441,
0.0075753741,
-0.0024275114,
0.0090900427,
0.0012116951,
-0.045446299,
0.0051040044,
0.0003118535,
0.0199961904,
0.0126286875,
0.0213976093,
0.0276024789,
-0.0371306054,
0.0258516762,
0.0429144129,
0.004615414,
-0.027752202,
-0.0188389383,
-0.0295714252,
-0.0145592419,
-0.0126425792,
0.0119511606,
0.0256150495,
-0.0060746004,
0.015424435,
-0.0027116891,
0.0092625786,
0.0358434655,
-0.1300048232,
0.113134563,
-0.0073570558,
-0.0518806502,
0.040405564,
-0.0441992655,
0.021043526,
-0.0393966287,
0.065140985,
-0.0488052443,
0.0561787225,
0.0385402702,
0.0003640137,
-0.0612800829,
-0.0090565132,
0.0002101984,
-0.0053451527,
0.0174440704,
0.0472168438,
-0.0370162539,
0.0084381299,
0.0095702829,
0.0212255996,
-0.0147673255,
-0.0151568903,
-0.0033949611,
-0.0147045488,
-0.0281410236,
0.0043617571,
0.006917607,
-0.0399933197,
-0.0424922593,
0.0149745895,
-0.0074382131,
-0.012137196,
0.0037921667,
0.1099921465,
0.0256712921,
-0.0561728291,
-0.0571352765,
-0.0568912812,
-0.0728550777,
-0.0205162354,
0.0133511201,
-0.0295867939,
0.0215148646,
-0.0551349223,
-0.0116067743,
-0.0455099903,
0.0148263192,
0.0104071731,
-0.0499465615,
0.0328105204,
0.0161757879,
-0.024541961,
0.0338926986,
0.0108524021,
-0.0288876742,
0.0498798005,
0.0447373725,
0.1065959409,
0.0163474847,
-0.0259274598,
0.0057302113,
0.0228474271,
0.0298498515,
0.0507959463,
-0.033950042,
-0.0425605588,
0.0106298225,
0.0096624056,
0.0239586383,
0.045000501,
-0.00664395,
-0.0446422324,
0.0751062781,
0.0663434491,
-0.0217278171,
-0.0044692219,
0.0896904841,
-0.0222436823,
-0.0243854783,
0.0317683853,
-0.0574096553,
-0.0017730721,
-0.0234377068,
-0.0047183833,
0.0179761648,
0.0491952337,
-0.0119922142,
-0.0425024368,
0.0154068349,
-0.0105685936,
-0.0303232167,
-0.0095558576,
0.0556495525,
-0.01180097,
-0.0273394343,
0.016309781,
0.0322072804,
-0.0444377922,
-0.0376323387,
-0.0193075333,
0.0242138095,
0.0417718589,
0.0340799056,
-0.0424437337,
0.0011314487,
-0.03022727,
0.0086743319,
0.0116117792,
0.0368550904,
-0.00462673,
0.0009784101,
-0.0000016239,
0.0140269911,
0.0001251057,
0.041795738,
0.0229444262,
-0.0379035585,
-0.011453622,
-0.0165404994,
0.0021500632,
-0.0850583687,
0.0173945744,
-0.0222037081,
-0.0552944429,
-0.0123399207,
0.0580656342,
0.0086367885,
-0.0076159532,
-0.0093154646,
0.027730668,
0.0561162531,
-0.0888679922,
0.016225066,
-0.0052104248,
-0.0396891721,
-0.0096302554,
0.0170676056,
-0.0235525277,
0.0246745702,
-0.0110911028,
-0.0402263254,
-0.0096011572,
0.0194962975,
-0.0563198701,
0.0050785341,
0.0054682,
0.0178780444,
-0.0150987376,
0.0316702686,
-0.0410027429,
0.0567820556,
-0.0266025737,
-0.0021758457,
-0.0161418468,
-0.0283590928,
0.0021912775,
-0.0526511073,
-0.0449108183,
-0.0081517026,
0.017589841,
0.0053921966,
0.0012409484,
-0.0026759317,
-0.0048627732,
-0.0475395098,
-0.0205462985,
-0.0540321283,
-0.0198803432,
-0.0070721223,
0.0278173629,
-0.0409547426,
-0.0004060244,
-0.0116330124,
-0.0063990457,
0.0011423059,
0.00684863,
0.0230498314,
0.0260046124,
-0.0091387834,
-0.0614442229,
-0.0239429753,
-0.020925831,
-0.0378984399,
0.0630355328,
-0.020630762,
-0.0531571768,
-0.0544738285,
0.0355712101,
0.0159150027,
0.034628313,
-0.0202912837,
-0.0671346784,
-0.0128366593,
-0.0490915738,
-0.0016439537,
0.1149417758,
-0.0106348991,
0.072707206,
0.0729176626,
0.0141629549,
0.0034409652,
0.0028681022,
-0.0435781591,
0.0247777849,
-0.0230855308,
-0.0447751284,
0.0180464499,
0.0995360762,
0.0049533732,
-0.0197010599,
-0.0280690975,
0.0523307286,
-0.0079433285,
-0.01761375,
-0.0333768576,
-0.0481273271,
-0.024303237,
0.022207601,
-0.0276551563,
-0.0803505406,
0.0570050925,
-0.041943267,
0.0231756456,
0.0254020914,
-0.0280373953,
-0.0471981727,
0.048136767,
0.0448720418,
0.0492685102,
0.028406499,
-0.0061272648,
-0.0011645703,
0.020962216,
-0.0011267721,
-0.011773454,
0.0183322467,
-0.0498301722,
-0.0228927974,
0.0127791408,
-0.05102925,
-0.0318988599,
-0.0272564851,
-0.0083657689,
-0.0065783993,
0.0033879508,
-0.0082958341,
-0.0148729905,
0.0366225392,
0.0150950579,
0.0085508954,
-0.0222364943,
0.0081578111,
-0.0177326351,
0.0336789079,
0.0760436878,
0.0088176467,
0.0552396327,
0.0066733938,
0.0667458624,
0.0534920469,
-0.0562181957,
0.0518694855,
0.0039311363,
0.0454648435,
0.0073584653,
0.0234407876,
-0.0229113568,
0.0108701857,
0.0278221909,
-0.0696673468,
-0.067117922,
0.0499383472,
0.024052348,
-0.030582808,
0.0368576907,
0.0009179823,
-0.0040705618,
0.006314334,
0.0193910357,
-0.0161380563,
0.0101828342,
-0.0079659382,
-0.0235573109,
-0.0405788831,
-0.0196446553,
0.0187819283,
-0.0736889616,
0.0523654222,
0.0457140207,
-0.0565727912,
-0.0480874889,
0.0073101074,
-0.0214003157,
0.0205686446,
-0.0101548638,
-0.0088270204,
-0.0272357613,
-0.0385242216,
0.0023581092,
0.023766458,
-0.0227288511,
0.0089656888,
-0.0004141179,
0.0353092067,
0.0492599756,
0.0254948176,
0.0081446543,
-0.0908799395,
0.0475694947,
0.0271811038,
0.0127536142,
0.0309721753,
0.0496957973,
0.0393617004,
-0.0178030208,
0.0254099164,
0.0402888097,
-0.0410540588,
0.0120576732,
-0.0370958,
0.1082123891,
-0.0163744092,
-0.0329117402,
-0.0190204624,
0.0174044278,
-0.0009995844,
0.077763252,
0.0700589344,
-0.0303107649,
-0.0400429852,
-0.0454770774,
0.0062243785,
-0.0285732541,
-0.0672723278,
0.0419664197,
-0.0033050445,
-0.0607203431,
-0.0458518974,
-0.0089727538,
0.0039427197,
0.0413018428,
0.0123621803,
-0.0591723397,
-0.003893048,
-0.0142572355,
0.0097768568,
0.0486884229,
-0.0074366732,
0.0054438105,
-0.0722965822,
0.0432275906,
0.0104301721,
-0.0539413355,
-0.040446803,
0.0195859652,
-0.0614499301,
-0.0485082529,
0.0172244776,
0.0667577833,
0.0164481252,
0.0117803812,
-0.0350531302,
-0.0300331507,
0.0715501979,
0.0101481499,
0.008223624,
0.0141392276,
0.0217676051,
0.0148657095,
-0.0061581405,
0.0487969331,
-0.0280388501,
0.0283284206,
0.032542482,
-0.0004274511,
-0.0228677876,
-0.0275957938,
0.0307701454,
0.0189934541,
0.0706933066,
0.0191156846,
0.014887508,
-0.0362948291,
0.010692508,
0.0004566601,
-0.0031988716,
-0.0251452271,
0.0299536772,
0.0235064849,
-0.0441120714,
-0.0025929506,
-0.0306826495,
-0.0011352369,
0.0204759277,
-0.0306650903,
-0.0073734364,
0.0241239462,
-0.0010051313,
0.0372723304,
0.0410391055,
-0.031239111,
0.032166075,
-0.0522509813,
0.0179787409,
0.0037557716,
0.0182393529,
0.0062961443,
-0.0009498648,
-0.0647588298,
0.0745840296,
-0.0537838973,
-0.0715027452,
-0.059430927,
0.0320664272,
0.0484170057,
-0.006581407,
0.0193604175,
-0.0093369428,
-0.0308460407,
-0.0176960751,
-0.0229963921,
0.0332731009,
-0.05589379,
0.0289875604,
0.0154310921,
-0.0117964018,
-0.0548223555,
0.0614287965,
-0.0153563311,
0.0391559787,
0.0183849055,
-0.0007036029,
-0.0068827672,
-0.0132717406,
0.0185873006,
0.0681778938,
-0.0300164297,
0.0029532604,
-0.1065488756,
-0.0600228794,
0.0139774634,
0.0155072659,
-0.019455947,
0.0306627974,
0.0125541557,
0.0257437434,
-0.0022587134,
-0.0091077788,
-0.0138570834,
-0.0042424807,
-0.0038322015,
-0.033646062,
0.0103811221,
-6.874304188e-33,
-0.0046655224,
-0.0124849807,
-0.0103907119,
0.0053489706,
-0.0090368688,
0.0216450617,
-0.0306401253,
-0.0204666108,
-0.0403957292,
0.033876501,
0.0130446116,
-0.0464546494,
-0.0120081017,
0.025239693,
0.0006122862,
-0.02276434,
0.0004504496,
0.0236801077,
-0.0219795778,
0.0642818063,
0.0674144775,
0.0029088552,
0.0548874363,
-0.045598954,
0.0062816185,
0.0395235047,
-0.0087782424,
0.0532217398,
-0.0533592515,
0.0597001538,
-0.0287343767,
0.06397295,
0.0259297211,
-0.0446922183,
-0.0147218751,
0.0311842356,
-0.0257331412,
-0.0152533008,
0.0023583143,
-0.0372981504,
-0.0259641893,
-0.0864101723,
0.0622459128,
-0.0031996954,
0.0038431021,
-0.0274789315,
0.0283599775,
-0.033175189,
-0.0059730266,
0.012298543,
-0.072083585,
-0.0137632499,
-0.02043234,
-0.0409682803,
0.0113667902,
0.033920642,
0.0230275355,
0.057075657,
-0.0541803539,
0.0302962307,
0.001942909,
0.0192166436,
0.0396653935,
0.0031856121,
-0.010335058,
0.0672165975,
0.045955956,
-0.0034174619,
-0.0195372254,
-0.0243572649,
0.0182224959,
0.0235420298,
0.0176186953,
-0.0047423071,
0.0143980142,
-0.0136025352,
-0.0567739308,
0.0108208535,
0.001914622,
0.0377030373,
0.0189346038,
-0.0253378991,
-0.0470273234,
-0.0316181667,
-0.0157685913,
-0.0550721958,
-0.0259278901,
0.0081400089,
0.0335821137,
0.015107682,
0.0085379547,
-0.0129699046,
-0.0029188527,
-0.0205330141,
0.0256663579,
0.0125113325,
0.0080835614,
0.0242503677,
0.0087133572,
0.0165823009,
-0.004120369,
0.0121748522,
-0.0286998209,
-0.0315535963,
0.0124521265,
0.007997415,
0.0578550771,
0.0218471736,
-0.026057329,
0.0072714635,
-0.0499128662,
-0.0045408737,
0.066021502,
0.0672310516,
0.0363268256,
-0.0259085521,
-0.0005637943,
0.0481387675,
0.0043806727,
0.0229183864,
0.02044289,
0.0436777286,
-0.0569303334,
0.0343396924,
-0.0316189565,
0.0152467238,
-0.0261572022,
0.0575788245,
0.0666424036,
-0.1154288054,
-0.0108143706,
-0.0428838544,
3.309e-7,
0.0408623852,
0.0288517904,
0.0281170774,
0.0281080473,
0.0429054238,
0.0446072854,
-0.0098409941,
0.0633673891,
-0.0390013792,
-0.0282024872,
0.0084165744,
0.0095927734,
0.0325795114,
0.0141631458,
-0.0980619118,
0.0410706438,
-0.0800020248,
-0.0016330295,
-0.045952972,
0.0095953904,
0.0556778833,
0.0722730607,
0.006863154,
-0.0287352242,
0.0302306358,
-0.0427579321,
0.0109394714,
-0.0448047705,
0.0329349078,
0.0176084619,
0.0001609538,
-0.0519477576,
-0.0360885337,
0.0037884503,
0.0034437443,
0.0104260724,
-0.0051748422,
0.0497110263,
-0.0052095237,
-0.0123690208,
0.0016315472,
-0.0430430137,
-0.0040958491,
-0.0606235825,
0.0583925545,
-0.0298848171,
-0.0480158366,
-0.0274019111,
0.0250249282,
-0.0139266271,
0.0292056613,
-0.038327001,
0.0129316282,
-0.0131723378,
0.0104078986,
-0.0212561004,
0.0312162787,
-0.0501813442,
-0.021444777,
0.0110879764,
-0.0346926264,
-0.0463401489,
-0.0420872085,
0.0211458337,
0.0153194861,
-0.0670234039,
-0.0232285578,
3.565066359e-34,
0.0161589198,
-0.0162401814,
0.0277534388,
-0.0018421297,
0.0154063739,
-0.0032245903,
0.0117262714,
-0.0323917046,
0.0007253211,
-0.0849280581,
-0.0290612001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01642v1 | Voice-Based Smart Assistant System for Vehicles using RASA | 2023-12-04T05:48:18 | 2023-12-04T05:48:18 | Aditya Paranjape, Yash Patwardhan, Vedant Deshpande, Aniket Darp, Jayashree Jagdale | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conversational AIs, or chatbots, mimic human speech when conversing. Smart
assistants facilitate the automation of several tasks that needed human
intervention earlier. Because of their accuracy, absence of dependence on human
resources, and accessibility around the clock, chatbots can be employed in
vehicles too. Due to people's propensity to divert their attention away from
the task of driving while engaging in other activities like calling, playing
music, navigation, and getting updates on the weather forecast and latest news,
road safety has declined and accidents have increased as a result. It would be
advantageous to automate these tasks using voice commands rather than carrying
them out manually. This paper focuses on the development of a voice-based smart
assistance application for vehicles based on the RASA framework. The smart
assistant provides functionalities like navigation, communication via calls,
getting weather forecasts and the latest news updates, and music that are
completely voice-based in nature. | [
0.0291305725,
-0.0228226315,
-0.0254852362,
0.0311182402,
-0.0077096298,
0.0026091847,
0.0206577946,
-0.0335592851,
-0.0079621607,
-0.03683744,
0.0196354296,
0.0101996716,
0.0113551766,
0.0131868105,
0.0140245333,
-0.086108841,
-0.0197965093,
-0.0923944414,
0.0204470102,
0.0032480897,
0.0178968664,
0.016871864,
-0.0341010243,
0.0218935534,
-0.0746980011,
-0.0064078164,
-0.0062867263,
-0.0198249295,
0.0291505028,
0.0142783159,
-0.0120261274,
0.0069410303,
0.0462048016,
0.0026297837,
0.0000018158,
0.005241008,
0.0485095754,
0.0161201954,
-0.0056348741,
-0.0363612697,
0.0384716988,
0.0958238468,
-0.0132215321,
0.0802241117,
-0.0126941288,
-0.0026019888,
0.0147156212,
0.0515953042,
0.0500353724,
0.0487618893,
-0.0299423244,
-0.0434626825,
0.0285750572,
0.0170401279,
-0.0096408678,
-0.0455267392,
-0.0107660051,
-0.0039767697,
0.0545784272,
-0.0294417869,
0.0178480931,
-0.0005958301,
0.0192255396,
-0.0191522129,
-0.0494353734,
0.0233238991,
-0.0257372893,
-0.0310653802,
-0.0365562104,
0.0711085498,
-0.005432745,
-0.0357093215,
0.034618564,
0.0505468734,
-0.0245535392,
-0.0310693439,
-0.0132277012,
-0.0252055116,
-0.0072006132,
0.0153690716,
-0.0433178134,
0.02290673,
-0.0300218891,
-0.0296180733,
0.0129082054,
0.0266229417,
0.0135909896,
-0.0455940627,
0.0091014374,
-0.0001442397,
0.0632878542,
-0.0388215221,
0.0070338342,
0.0399624482,
-0.0666433796,
0.0053533143,
-0.0117933126,
-0.0200319812,
-0.0336769894,
-0.0826384276,
0.0116865635,
0.0079642795,
-0.0735976323,
0.0135434205,
0.0141236801,
0.0073081134,
0.0557021797,
0.0139857475,
-0.0009696925,
-0.0297825988,
0.0219528284,
0.0148772523,
-0.073627688,
0.0148657421,
-0.0148052508,
0.0202851743,
-0.0046505365,
0.0310804378,
-0.00131908,
0.0342321657,
-0.04309218,
0.0532497279,
0.0018276774,
-0.0138802342,
0.0236114971,
-0.0442231931,
-0.0210283622,
0.0454490073,
-0.0000564843,
-0.0527553745,
0.0568396524,
-0.0024730077,
-0.0019018289,
0.0269917697,
-0.0068254685,
0.0578207299,
-0.025238106,
-0.0470059998,
-0.0572349802,
0.0010553473,
0.0297922716,
-0.0502198115,
-0.0526860617,
-0.0259363987,
0.003593694,
0.0079533141,
-0.0189677179,
0.0228568837,
0.0284013432,
0.0055802758,
-0.006243099,
0.0268733334,
-0.008148591,
0.0401699916,
0.0729442015,
0.0103670442,
0.0310350507,
0.0363480076,
0.0338290222,
-0.0093335891,
0.0338558406,
0.0102440529,
0.0030509001,
-0.0028192869,
-0.0295845903,
0.0127823949,
-0.0131951645,
-0.000299377,
-0.02645915,
0.0000664583,
-0.0151721071,
0.0253398903,
-0.0010673326,
0.022816848,
0.0479775146,
0.0089738471,
-0.0284157079,
0.0584556498,
-0.0126899639,
0.0506731085,
0.0440430976,
-0.0451342016,
-0.0076054111,
0.0146703999,
-0.063890025,
-0.0041843723,
0.0514491275,
0.0445060767,
-0.068158716,
-0.0143745812,
0.0343533754,
-0.071984224,
-0.0050038002,
-0.0051018852,
0.0019779291,
-0.0484457575,
0.0035223318,
-0.0459047519,
-0.0348334759,
-0.0109321736,
-0.0364141241,
-0.0437797122,
0.0318000168,
0.0437726453,
0.0172684491,
-0.02662508,
-0.0328665562,
-0.0212874394,
-0.0213699136,
-0.0176648237,
-0.0409719422,
0.0100750122,
0.0061860783,
0.0027904923,
-0.0103068212,
0.0844824091,
0.0192206036,
0.0035369119,
-0.0361440517,
0.0785232782,
0.0085100699,
0.0482479408,
-0.0022770113,
0.004249604,
0.0538389683,
0.0005494115,
-0.0342652462,
0.0344212949,
0.01519683,
0.0202809703,
-0.0294209681,
0.0054618907,
-0.0101593593,
0.0120154116,
-0.0110353762,
0.0726950914,
0.0021819,
0.0640928447,
0.0295339506,
-0.0265499987,
0.0096616782,
0.1077515036,
-0.0111704338,
-0.0599403232,
-0.0167348813,
-0.0559936017,
-0.0222903881,
0.0111290077,
0.007346049,
0.0409857184,
0.0534145571,
0.0552153662,
-0.0126940748,
0.0581258275,
0.0092486925,
0.039284423,
0.0280174464,
0.030662192,
-0.0343627818,
-0.0194073524,
-0.0212854464,
-0.0160460509,
0.0035631061,
-0.0201373827,
-0.0127093811,
-0.0085723065,
0.0572259165,
-0.0171801802,
-0.0302733704,
-0.0254847072,
-0.0451132022,
-0.0136264404,
0.0487052314,
-0.0213114806,
-0.0532627366,
-0.0262412019,
0.0574743859,
0.0275169406,
-0.0465086028,
-0.0109223248,
-0.0166276544,
-0.0559169501,
-0.025424581,
0.0353308506,
0.0190626439,
-0.0240803696,
0.0665771663,
-0.0298988596,
-0.0661736652,
-0.003031499,
-0.0145626739,
0.077364631,
-0.004331369,
-0.0747938082,
0.0089204898,
0.041319795,
0.040907532,
0.1141764298,
0.0522266924,
-0.0721563548,
0.0192007478,
0.0102737909,
-0.0091683548,
0.0205644537,
-0.0169553272,
0.0067684748,
-0.0166397411,
0.0117196906,
-0.017824512,
-0.0236600749,
0.0198760312,
0.0595255867,
0.032281667,
-0.0300561432,
-0.0103292838,
-0.0500856303,
0.0030703605,
-0.002952667,
-0.0440157466,
0.0334205329,
0.0202310979,
-0.0130145419,
0.0231213756,
-0.0119667212,
-0.0230894163,
-0.0275560059,
-0.0490707085,
-0.022761168,
0.0121525992,
-0.0320932418,
0.0092165098,
0.0170490053,
-0.0024127311,
0.0438002199,
-0.0272240024,
-0.04371351,
-0.0486375652,
0.0150164962,
-0.0138447443,
0.0140571129,
-0.0327983536,
-0.0350857116,
-0.028900465,
-0.0285184067,
-0.0244350415,
0.0207640547,
-0.0145602329,
-0.0376488268,
-0.0145788565,
0.0432088785,
0.0391889997,
0.0980349705,
0.0299772844,
0.0241258871,
-0.0010493526,
-0.0284337457,
0.0761162788,
0.039502956,
-0.0395606868,
0.0777024403,
0.0633864775,
-0.0222898535,
0.0822545961,
-0.0047345692,
-0.058431033,
-0.0529259369,
0.0170082171,
0.0075975005,
-0.0198778026,
0.0662957206,
-0.0120166456,
-0.009741554,
0.0013239511,
0.0422208421,
0.0175366458,
-0.0103656994,
0.001058439,
-0.0498688668,
-0.021736661,
-0.0153034627,
0.0533832051,
-0.0345819071,
0.0033341411,
0.0092012817,
0.0340492129,
-0.0014005245,
-0.0039444687,
0.026790319,
-0.0717394054,
0.0476486385,
-0.0287020449,
-0.0640582964,
-0.0406283997,
-0.0300039314,
0.0050526131,
-0.0183221474,
0.0473461971,
-0.0058017196,
-0.0042159599,
-0.0503519513,
0.0374811329,
-0.0697103143,
-0.0026235457,
0.0359177627,
-0.0473283157,
0.062736921,
0.0821067169,
0.0574183799,
0.0083203884,
-0.0147192283,
-0.0591164492,
0.0432041213,
0.0200902577,
-0.0174900834,
0.0194724351,
-0.0000922369,
-0.0369425789,
-0.0093354201,
0.0328845643,
-0.0098950267,
0.0365063809,
0.0129416203,
0.0571836717,
-0.0326248333,
0.0060324995,
-0.0551483296,
0.0149929253,
0.0489453301,
0.0023735766,
-0.0466311574,
-0.0166020356,
-0.0495626368,
0.0010322931,
-0.0038801024,
0.0059005087,
-0.0546089895,
-0.0275913384,
-0.0122162839,
-0.0726661831,
-0.0156033607,
-0.0107608307,
0.0225246921,
0.0104569206,
0.0298059862,
0.0105848843,
0.1012493074,
0.0243841652,
-0.0207890663,
-0.0701540411,
0.0057463264,
0.0235981122,
0.0067295898,
-0.0160429832,
0.0230944268,
-0.0250876825,
-0.0404377282,
0.0012661391,
0.0358789526,
-0.0108322594,
0.0744800493,
0.0095755961,
0.0168141816,
-0.0035541994,
-0.0483469032,
-0.0662662908,
0.0398836136,
-0.0049447203,
-0.0208543409,
0.0272758119,
0.0273976512,
0.002022658,
0.0113376193,
0.0405831449,
-0.0813917816,
0.0273963846,
-0.0486140549,
-0.0500496067,
0.011856758,
-0.0325540602,
0.0197675247,
0.0523685589,
0.0004511455,
0.043209482,
0.0601309277,
0.0014280592,
0.0585833043,
-0.0139292255,
0.0224472973,
-0.0339807905,
0.0591382645,
-0.0789739266,
0.036229156,
0.0289484765,
-0.0557366796,
-0.0159151629,
-0.0330889188,
0.0149838133,
0.0473787189,
0.0639790148,
0.024230903,
-0.0197243039,
-0.0351161882,
0.0114459172,
-0.0304483138,
0.0512096696,
0.0017636111,
-0.0060768141,
0.0321776234,
-0.0126044052,
-0.040796116,
-0.0174686369,
0.0226514321,
-0.0147797726,
-0.0886207819,
-0.0017816486,
0.0860235915,
0.0082296729,
0.0331469737,
-0.019651575,
-0.0820760801,
0.0441738665,
-0.025282314,
0.0112802768,
0.0234791748,
-0.002212568,
0.0117160883,
0.0019120125,
-0.0167674553,
0.0139103048,
0.008051659,
-0.0046728817,
0.0085503832,
-0.0143809645,
-0.0172058083,
-0.0485252775,
-0.0220677853,
0.0111088464,
-0.0340311639,
-0.0265037883,
-0.0029831328,
-0.0173738096,
-0.0279844757,
-0.0208895821,
0.0050887135,
-0.0066033369,
-0.0576600507,
0.0129836211,
-0.0402472876,
0.0397600569,
-0.0117632169,
0.0064346502,
-0.0435584784,
-0.105147779,
0.0044367863,
0.0125970738,
-5.694078472e-33,
-0.0238355808,
0.0232626628,
-0.0085501587,
0.0174009372,
-0.0343368351,
-0.008561682,
0.0124678565,
0.0199721362,
-0.0175803043,
-0.0045589893,
-0.0375917479,
0.0310686603,
0.0170230456,
-0.0401709564,
0.0034381375,
-0.0101030171,
0.0275114328,
-0.0452833436,
0.0140659912,
0.0371814743,
0.0433776937,
0.0107837766,
0.00283522,
-0.0999611542,
-0.0131969731,
-0.0238853041,
-0.0405385904,
-0.0057872641,
-0.0378531888,
-0.0352856889,
0.008854961,
0.0585922748,
0.0070562288,
-0.0218335949,
-0.0137302009,
0.1145474613,
-0.0199994594,
-0.037766967,
0.0221055504,
0.050176017,
-0.06071762,
0.0230095163,
0.0137588019,
0.0098992335,
-0.0267439652,
0.0564273112,
0.0463857763,
-0.0501795858,
0.0071482863,
0.0377121605,
-0.0697140992,
-0.0183746517,
-0.0092954226,
-0.0670662522,
0.0149553623,
0.0398651846,
-0.0127165476,
-0.033533603,
-0.0245228503,
0.0042364122,
0.006086627,
0.0413678698,
0.0108457757,
0.0007337874,
0.0189182851,
-0.0071631428,
0.047643587,
-0.0636923984,
-0.0468251072,
-0.0395857692,
-0.0519882888,
0.0981628224,
0.0007615787,
0.0266113151,
-0.0105426237,
-0.0460391231,
-0.0548738539,
0.0188505352,
0.0411039293,
0.037194144,
0.0350049883,
-0.0142001109,
-0.1263175458,
0.0507132113,
-0.0088449214,
0.0243522301,
-0.0508110672,
-0.0408816561,
0.0392440818,
0.0378804542,
0.0054670181,
-0.0073349257,
-0.0049588908,
-0.0217343904,
0.0314614065,
-0.025269283,
0.0200223774,
-0.0245690513,
-0.0377930366,
-0.0205771886,
-0.0446263812,
-0.021012282,
0.036332231,
0.0253454428,
0.0359854214,
-0.014776906,
-0.0136143444,
0.0905626491,
-0.0224591214,
0.0143643031,
0.0180083252,
0.0309173707,
0.0224487726,
0.0126729961,
0.011305741,
0.0053544561,
-0.0168450605,
0.0391854718,
-0.0235836077,
-0.04521304,
-0.042680189,
-0.0459508486,
-0.002611819,
-0.019225616,
-0.0511575229,
-0.0004907222,
-0.0242951922,
-0.0363634415,
0.0023018324,
-0.0000200226,
0.0046087811,
-0.0418326855,
2.554e-7,
-0.0738277882,
0.0277333558,
0.0159937311,
0.0688745528,
0.0300459117,
0.0706803501,
0.007388561,
0.0296483804,
-0.0064661321,
0.0865516216,
-0.0117169898,
-0.0379477255,
0.0383428931,
0.0059544044,
-0.0689120218,
-0.0175025985,
-0.0565494262,
-0.0015781863,
-0.0423395149,
0.0128650088,
0.0902909115,
0.0977570117,
0.0089374632,
-0.0380363539,
0.0045917872,
-0.0132608507,
-0.01367281,
0.0028009559,
-0.0044354866,
-0.030825343,
0.0588883199,
0.06732779,
-0.0079658376,
0.0215685815,
-0.000733814,
0.0276062693,
-0.0273543727,
0.0396085382,
-0.0037786677,
-0.0459061936,
0.0342443846,
0.0125463242,
-0.0072180163,
-0.0209159572,
0.0262160208,
-0.0154785812,
-0.0193313919,
-0.0364078358,
-0.0264407899,
0.0207458213,
-0.0332208276,
0.023296047,
0.0414421409,
-0.0376978591,
-0.0292510912,
-0.026372686,
0.0191242173,
-0.0343802907,
0.0185420271,
-0.0089042448,
0.0234214682,
-0.0309044439,
-0.0298661757,
0.0513358153,
0.0094044106,
-0.0149697466,
0.0197942518,
1.180596387e-34,
-0.0169521775,
-0.0157763623,
-0.0027052667,
0.0425784737,
-0.0428527817,
0.0264492501,
0.0078670839,
0.0043037054,
-0.0181338303,
-0.0049329116,
-0.0185187142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01592v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01592v2 | Expand BERT Representation with Visual Information via Grounded Language Learning with Multimodal Partial Alignment | 2023-12-04T03:16:48 | 2024-01-09T10:44:52 | Cong-Duy Nguyen, The-Anh Vu-Le, Thong Nguyen, Tho Quan, Luu Anh Tuan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models have been supervised with both language-only objective and
visual grounding in existing studies of visual-grounded language learning.
However, due to differences in the distribution and scale of visual-grounded
datasets and language corpora, the language model tends to mix up the context
of the tokens that occurred in the grounded data with those that do not. As a
result, during representation learning, there is a mismatch between the visual
information and the contextual meaning of the sentence. To overcome this
limitation, we propose GroundedBERT - a grounded language learning method that
enhances the BERT representation with visually grounded information.
GroundedBERT comprises two components: (i) the original BERT which captures the
contextual representation of words learned from the language corpora, and (ii)
a visual grounding module which captures visual information learned from
visual-grounded datasets. Moreover, we employ Optimal Transport (OT),
specifically its partial variant, to solve the fractional alignment problem
between the two modalities. Our proposed method significantly outperforms the
baseline language models on various language tasks of the GLUE and SQuAD
datasets. | [
-0.0007915534,
0.0360617936,
-0.0050458964,
0.0238923263,
-0.0204096921,
-0.0075801434,
-0.0122448532,
-0.0087816361,
-0.0506483577,
-0.0367695168,
-0.0510333143,
-0.0168697219,
0.0347254202,
0.0130236065,
0.0589982718,
-0.0604843721,
0.0213845242,
0.0020852457,
-0.038328521,
0.000878345,
0.0507919006,
-0.003045259,
-0.0164794475,
0.0358701311,
-0.0691984519,
-0.0118310023,
-0.0024825232,
0.029862877,
0.027134506,
-0.00493593,
-0.0032570988,
0.0666030198,
0.1043131575,
0.0018277505,
0.0000017855,
-0.0139895659,
-0.0044030338,
-0.0464328676,
0.0186511949,
-0.0057808445,
-0.0024442377,
-0.0380176269,
0.0026958941,
0.0062352289,
-0.0313748643,
0.0119628273,
0.1063968688,
0.0644643158,
0.0797453299,
0.0266234409,
-0.0375095829,
-0.0108451368,
0.0038208847,
0.0061624381,
0.0027938713,
0.0100941835,
-0.0088082757,
0.0714296922,
-0.0361326784,
-0.0193712022,
-0.0864582285,
0.0093466826,
0.0048224377,
0.0023844996,
0.0546435341,
0.0638578534,
-0.0628792569,
-0.0234150067,
-0.019313883,
0.1239680722,
-0.021579653,
-0.027404828,
-0.0402927659,
0.016933063,
-0.0111620538,
0.0114883734,
-0.0400114357,
0.0292992853,
0.0187387057,
0.0790415853,
-0.0347928889,
-0.0264048558,
0.0039492967,
0.007224516,
-0.0260190163,
0.0098132472,
0.0180557165,
-0.0083124675,
0.000882277,
0.0425496586,
-0.0374043211,
-0.0238630418,
0.0075073321,
0.0049087848,
0.0201311987,
0.0270746499,
-0.04669673,
-0.0277684052,
-0.0185200032,
-0.0347848274,
0.0152741615,
0.0577010438,
-0.0620701313,
0.0387963839,
-0.0526496693,
0.045097582,
-0.015765978,
0.0549760088,
-0.0048727724,
-0.0004264131,
-0.0278444402,
-0.0198099054,
-0.0579082258,
0.0359673314,
-0.0756895766,
-0.0545496903,
-0.0183025841,
0.031337969,
-0.0084398212,
-0.0117662679,
0.0128565952,
0.0129852826,
-0.0618766509,
0.0018027899,
-0.0164632294,
0.0561548062,
-0.0392596908,
0.0370213874,
-0.0291142371,
-0.0049338392,
-0.0159362759,
0.0334320478,
0.0314680226,
-0.0426380299,
-0.0085399384,
0.0123657929,
-0.0544633493,
-0.0640399829,
-0.0463178381,
0.0254403129,
-0.006638465,
-0.0225326791,
0.000186158,
-0.0530421473,
-0.0057602571,
-0.0019936257,
-0.0087041771,
-0.0415540971,
-0.0050184368,
-0.002108092,
-0.0027331288,
0.0760913715,
-0.0239019152,
-0.0147968279,
-0.0031204335,
-0.0041222419,
0.0101260347,
0.0807795152,
0.0093551157,
0.0225962047,
-0.0049084751,
-0.0094282739,
-0.0156218177,
0.0221627895,
0.0373695716,
0.0316438116,
-0.0870841593,
-0.0291148964,
0.0207500048,
0.0353015587,
0.0589335747,
0.0468095504,
-0.0450816602,
0.0053721261,
0.0808200911,
0.082900852,
-0.0134104639,
-0.0237217527,
0.0006226939,
-0.0096474234,
-0.0239156019,
0.0198394861,
-0.0610079467,
0.0417612568,
0.0074929097,
0.0057402221,
-0.0431707017,
0.0190545674,
-0.0383954048,
0.0035166305,
-0.0231745094,
-0.0294394996,
0.0327805914,
-0.055843778,
0.0310152769,
0.0112700686,
-0.0628817379,
0.1021472514,
0.0266319178,
-0.0355997086,
0.001008718,
0.0174754784,
0.0055246716,
0.0393863693,
0.0106928274,
-0.0155845573,
-0.0733388811,
0.0046500447,
0.0545711741,
0.0481317528,
-0.0439351052,
0.004501895,
0.0131116612,
-0.0746082217,
-0.0446677208,
-0.016568508,
-0.0068670674,
-0.0020511309,
-0.0074250321,
0.0148545587,
-0.0216836613,
-0.1043922752,
0.03992033,
0.0510664918,
0.0345538855,
0.0057695732,
-0.0532843061,
0.0669293404,
0.0117793893,
-0.0215966869,
-0.0264824275,
-0.012531382,
0.0068637403,
-0.0329383835,
-0.0032253098,
0.0361274965,
-0.0586934574,
-0.0135773048,
0.0259647053,
-0.064246811,
-0.0263608154,
0.0178530216,
-0.0112165473,
-0.0059829252,
0.0203883853,
-0.0153547497,
0.0412789322,
-0.0610907637,
0.0015261261,
0.0168030988,
0.0313771851,
-0.02372244,
0.0687945038,
-0.0184403006,
-0.0079406267,
0.0024832613,
0.0345210508,
0.0197906774,
-0.0259104706,
0.0195458122,
0.0125087714,
0.0075248359,
0.0103213331,
-0.0062182043,
0.0216677543,
-0.0347580649,
0.006809229,
-0.0983142629,
-0.0316690505,
-0.0117805786,
-0.0073273638,
0.0269941762,
-0.0174411777,
0.0123036457,
-0.0367319845,
-0.0313807093,
0.0193780828,
-0.0163806882,
-0.0014786921,
0.0560473688,
-0.0059218686,
-0.018589735,
-0.0406572446,
-0.0088684931,
-0.0044778422,
0.04821885,
-0.0062549785,
-0.0075452696,
-0.0221747253,
-0.0199910291,
-0.0466385521,
0.0504691862,
0.0107735256,
-0.0369083025,
0.0201451592,
-0.0159569718,
0.0648203567,
0.0411898866,
0.0088958815,
0.0616650507,
0.029306151,
-0.0037007967,
-0.0367077217,
-0.0107677775,
-0.0060500265,
0.0307332724,
-0.0105516659,
0.0170585215,
-0.0268768724,
0.0537445657,
-0.0164841935,
0.0184292253,
-0.1158056557,
0.013097492,
0.0219605565,
-0.000315971,
-0.0649813637,
0.0093652504,
-0.0280397795,
0.007900211,
-0.0740590617,
-0.0728071779,
0.0617094524,
-0.0319944657,
-0.0129140252,
-0.0252051707,
0.0040379767,
-0.0113969911,
0.0533132441,
-0.0105199395,
0.0329638049,
-0.0561468713,
-0.062328022,
-0.0643403679,
-0.0330262445,
0.0106627103,
0.0296713077,
0.0797158331,
-0.0497506447,
0.0365588441,
-0.0098157404,
-0.0028017892,
-0.0340088047,
-0.0143509153,
-0.0259716175,
-0.0131448507,
-0.0589791536,
-0.0165898502,
-0.0221986324,
0.0152833303,
0.0312189758,
0.0236801729,
0.0188720804,
0.0252082869,
-0.0294228345,
0.0045786919,
0.0322023667,
0.0136531815,
-0.0368178561,
-0.041557163,
0.0108494656,
0.0247274414,
0.0600578934,
-0.0322179124,
-0.043520309,
0.0455757305,
0.0204752833,
0.0329441912,
-0.0134768719,
-0.0001638404,
0.0618603639,
0.0093401195,
-0.0193400998,
0.0747268274,
0.0270665232,
0.0124468002,
0.0256030392,
-0.0029164758,
0.0752126575,
0.0282282345,
-0.004234327,
-0.0367259048,
-0.0340242945,
0.0143615669,
-0.0046320991,
0.0777560025,
-0.0299455989,
0.0084505752,
-0.0836643502,
0.0184886158,
0.0360796452,
-0.0650694668,
-0.0664040148,
-0.0281897485,
-0.0027905402,
0.017771868,
0.0352933556,
-0.0281027369,
0.0038101692,
-0.0006808595,
0.0286780614,
0.0339470021,
-0.0222049914,
0.001495962,
-0.0623613335,
0.0111991838,
0.0066867522,
0.030047603,
-0.0122568086,
-0.0840971395,
0.0342145897,
0.0196590871,
-0.0011608042,
-0.0277803838,
0.0380614884,
-0.0352255404,
-0.0513804965,
0.034775015,
0.0289619341,
-0.01707316,
-0.0345210806,
-0.0559775084,
0.0798597187,
-0.0072041326,
0.0387084819,
0.0006320731,
-0.0064691873,
0.0036403954,
0.0533440597,
0.0336942449,
-0.0438335538,
-0.0125139803,
0.0097067282,
0.0599850155,
-0.0338276513,
-0.0032328751,
-0.0065627336,
-0.0639050379,
0.0237151217,
-0.0987390503,
0.0041398946,
0.0454951152,
0.1119770035,
0.0272790622,
-0.0203484334,
-0.0198580492,
-0.0042969878,
-0.0389826596,
0.0700042322,
-0.0103188399,
0.0424254276,
-0.0632414892,
-0.0073616016,
0.0034614601,
-0.0273421463,
-0.013273797,
-0.0213749073,
0.0076628928,
-0.0329983383,
-0.0120003289,
0.033689037,
0.0180039387,
0.0354074836,
0.0168772247,
-0.0118588209,
0.0044127018,
0.0312125478,
0.0220738295,
0.018496193,
0.0113536119,
-0.049421452,
0.0121597918,
0.0164046492,
-0.0374332145,
0.0023474644,
0.0159131289,
0.0608121976,
0.0164656155,
0.0214901306,
0.0157667547,
0.0179951265,
0.0821524709,
-0.0091242809,
0.0156544521,
-0.0576048829,
0.0076327333,
-0.0127271963,
0.0058916574,
-0.0551169142,
0.0035642567,
0.0185887869,
0.0357180424,
0.0146542815,
-0.0218103845,
0.0094447825,
0.062760599,
-0.0019570058,
-0.0029934098,
-0.0024261535,
0.0019031977,
-0.007768434,
0.0591309518,
0.0004860607,
-0.0154046891,
-0.0184486322,
0.0333974995,
-0.0137465196,
0.0450484119,
0.0395669863,
-0.0078917751,
-0.0228214115,
0.0257079825,
-0.0165498294,
0.0206501298,
-0.0213345196,
0.0587569661,
0.0229080562,
-0.0263141133,
0.0175396539,
-0.0222765841,
-0.0079810545,
0.0171414968,
0.0293291155,
-0.0214704368,
-0.0336292684,
0.044516556,
0.0327568986,
-0.0084561221,
-0.0027008988,
0.0432849191,
-0.0060153166,
0.063996397,
-0.0826203004,
-0.0041033602,
-0.0469718352,
0.0149676586,
0.0609945506,
-0.020464059,
0.0045859218,
0.0474895947,
-0.0480671525,
-0.0856840834,
0.003203257,
0.0263441019,
-0.0298324786,
0.0151196476,
0.0671434999,
0.0381777436,
-0.0091116102,
0.0186014231,
0.0016345955,
0.0000678354,
0.0171676353,
0.0051472164,
-0.0064024809,
-5.751782021e-33,
-0.0519977957,
0.0001140362,
0.0310349111,
-0.0251876712,
-0.0338382088,
0.0548681766,
-0.0170433074,
0.0115398327,
-0.0088469991,
0.0087596979,
0.0192021988,
-0.0138175972,
0.0088151041,
0.0462384708,
-0.0469522141,
0.0045333919,
0.0160842631,
0.0057322988,
-0.0264843442,
-0.0168145671,
0.0407685302,
0.035074383,
0.0719675496,
-0.0316475965,
-0.0446245037,
0.0394392908,
-0.024772888,
0.0589129627,
0.0722610056,
0.0561718382,
-0.0055912696,
0.0107085938,
-0.0087934099,
0.0062400736,
-0.0239456743,
0.0394567251,
-0.0784793273,
-0.040794801,
0.0289805811,
0.0390256979,
-0.0471324287,
0.0148423333,
0.0411892124,
-0.0519287065,
-0.0014197379,
0.0086601032,
0.0446701832,
-0.0100561371,
-0.0280083269,
0.0358114019,
-0.0804982483,
-0.0249659903,
-0.0114698978,
-0.0123188589,
-0.0024028544,
0.0161639526,
0.0276848208,
0.0083014695,
-0.0483025797,
0.0086332308,
-0.0476479493,
0.0098694041,
0.068020314,
0.0501737148,
0.0144293467,
0.0875685215,
0.0137348082,
-0.0372170508,
-0.0451912247,
-0.0069512515,
0.0868817568,
0.0262033492,
0.0324676037,
0.0050616874,
-0.061711438,
-0.0038059142,
-0.0423815064,
0.018764833,
-0.0068677953,
0.0415694155,
-0.014243898,
0.055408854,
-0.0314272419,
-0.0047329539,
-0.01557629,
-0.0010266607,
-0.0067048105,
-0.0193729475,
0.0430596583,
0.0035560937,
-0.0393095054,
0.0146075152,
0.0641100034,
-0.0150928916,
-0.0170832667,
0.0146347648,
-0.0175027475,
0.0295219403,
0.0033557797,
0.0157670211,
-0.0461262912,
-0.0604848228,
0.0471001603,
0.0152872633,
0.0161782913,
0.0112941619,
0.0640657693,
0.0225887876,
-0.043967817,
0.0161641743,
-0.033193402,
-0.0388418697,
-0.0150589803,
0.0143207218,
0.0410768986,
-0.0072822766,
-0.0396250263,
0.0113797029,
0.026279889,
-0.0293979198,
-0.0018649056,
-0.0617457218,
-0.0356117859,
0.0518117473,
-0.0325578004,
0.0063178367,
-0.0153020406,
-0.0044332119,
0.0394114815,
-0.0819961652,
-0.0214216858,
-0.0013592427,
2.563e-7,
0.0442155674,
0.0280533154,
0.044805415,
-0.0364148282,
-0.0243421737,
0.0220562443,
-0.0495605692,
0.0270772036,
-0.0035458088,
-0.0902196616,
0.0157818478,
0.0398710519,
-0.0128723215,
-0.0381089263,
-0.0237018634,
0.0571136437,
-0.0311042592,
-0.00332601,
-0.0229505189,
0.0277953297,
0.0278577022,
0.0771814212,
0.0095642451,
-0.0270492677,
0.0172214042,
-0.0397512801,
0.0675591379,
-0.0271264911,
-0.003178474,
-0.0510750674,
-0.015487357,
0.0168097652,
-0.0234838035,
-0.0000411497,
-0.0063739959,
0.013721576,
0.0653059855,
0.0047202175,
-0.0627512112,
-0.0184723642,
-0.0521764047,
-0.0043946011,
-0.0375517868,
-0.0409032106,
0.0434372127,
-0.0171269681,
-0.0250009876,
0.0041311109,
-0.0423896536,
0.0080976598,
0.0260744728,
-0.0000370808,
-0.0607432872,
0.0146069536,
0.0424018316,
-0.0059305495,
-0.0292682964,
-0.0644226,
-0.0232829489,
0.0137067586,
-0.0222670082,
-0.0164733678,
-0.010465892,
-0.0024094274,
0.0250659436,
-0.0206966642,
-0.0557238497,
2.128564048e-34,
0.0061353515,
-0.0021424647,
0.0360291488,
0.0268771648,
0.0054875636,
-0.0228076316,
-0.0225176997,
-0.0203445498,
0.0159798246,
-0.0142476344,
-0.0162121095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02227v1 | Improving Multimodal Sentiment Analysis: Supervised Angular Margin-based Contrastive Learning for Enhanced Fusion Representation | 2023-12-04T02:58:19 | 2023-12-04T02:58:19 | Cong-Duy Nguyen, Thong Nguyen, Duc Anh Vu, Luu Anh Tuan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The effectiveness of a model is heavily reliant on the quality of the fusion
representation of multiple modalities in multimodal sentiment analysis.
Moreover, each modality is extracted from raw input and integrated with the
rest to construct a multimodal representation. Although previous methods have
proposed multimodal representations and achieved promising results, most of
them focus on forming positive and negative pairs, neglecting the variation in
sentiment scores within the same class. Additionally, they fail to capture the
significance of unimodal representations in the fusion vector. To address these
limitations, we introduce a framework called Supervised Angular-based
Contrastive Learning for Multimodal Sentiment Analysis. This framework aims to
enhance discrimination and generalizability of the multimodal representation
and overcome biases in the fusion vector's modality. Our experimental results,
along with visualizations on two widely used datasets, demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach. | [
-0.0117807221,
0.0700303167,
0.0047180573,
0.0352569073,
-0.0282637719,
0.0104710553,
0.0021617163,
-0.0234098174,
-0.0362731628,
-0.0676221177,
-0.0693418309,
-0.0366808958,
-0.0120266648,
0.0298230574,
0.0321072787,
-0.0708701387,
0.0031476018,
0.0526604429,
0.001384835,
-0.0181086622,
0.0499319136,
0.008655576,
-0.0436679162,
0.0425773934,
-0.037522126,
-0.0555423833,
0.0259717349,
0.0178999491,
0.0375907049,
-0.0364971571,
0.0057848892,
0.0017836788,
0.0182566363,
-0.0190532934,
0.0000020015,
-0.0052609886,
-0.0033814081,
-0.0001314266,
0.0740915686,
-0.0325650088,
0.0953176171,
-0.0780282617,
0.0177725926,
0.0080245202,
-0.0412137061,
-0.0320849307,
0.0568628721,
0.0886353254,
0.0612456426,
0.0185880736,
-0.0445618406,
-0.0432039723,
0.0054902439,
0.0057833139,
-0.0372465737,
0.0328396447,
-0.0299917925,
-0.001587625,
-0.010427516,
0.0126627544,
-0.0531050041,
0.0204884354,
-0.0161975939,
0.021345349,
0.0251311976,
0.0368311554,
0.0273212679,
0.0068464861,
-0.0247734785,
0.0687872246,
-0.013956923,
0.0242211204,
-0.028659638,
-0.0169020109,
-0.0081581334,
0.0074081104,
-0.0246103909,
0.0132416058,
0.0104411142,
0.0125363935,
-0.013346198,
0.0253654886,
0.000963024,
-0.0159126632,
-0.0241527334,
-0.0261469409,
0.0033099172,
-0.0239964053,
-0.0009159172,
0.0344662853,
-0.0340170451,
0.0249372143,
-0.0057435823,
-0.0294060912,
0.0173395313,
-0.012611229,
0.0169953909,
-0.0077898777,
0.0131624276,
-0.017776195,
0.0283554941,
0.0163982082,
-0.0512451157,
0.0388119034,
0.0185424164,
-0.031139642,
-0.0283729397,
0.0304068495,
-0.0275259204,
-0.0050822794,
-0.0658773929,
0.0252539441,
0.045017641,
0.0079295039,
-0.0172263701,
-0.0462452061,
-0.041973725,
0.005727991,
-0.0263549294,
-0.0166630633,
0.0098497123,
0.0154274786,
0.031993106,
0.0243231133,
-0.021029748,
0.0990385637,
-0.0171910021,
0.0515707023,
-0.0415561162,
-0.0261711646,
0.0243322942,
0.0412126519,
-0.0138388462,
-0.0381864831,
0.0178487767,
0.0862712339,
-0.0143017983,
-0.0390843786,
0.0077077667,
-0.0198107362,
-0.0551781207,
-0.0288396273,
0.0532139018,
-0.0379331,
0.0465651266,
0.0027246929,
0.0176267289,
0.0207022782,
-0.0248698518,
-0.0174007118,
0.0302360766,
0.0919700637,
-0.0156202037,
-0.0447776057,
-0.0076803691,
-0.0194569435,
-0.0536169149,
0.0300760772,
-0.0060424176,
0.0324205384,
0.0126654729,
-0.0171515048,
-0.0158287939,
-0.0071159429,
0.0021521517,
0.0035999101,
-0.0271976553,
-0.0262509603,
-0.0313013084,
-0.0285767298,
0.0406026728,
0.0473093055,
-0.0032157698,
-0.0366339236,
0.0228562374,
0.0111731393,
0.0242328364,
0.0083891079,
-0.0388096161,
-0.0217941813,
-0.035686478,
-0.0035329813,
-0.0025270199,
0.0329193547,
0.0017609632,
-0.0080930302,
0.0469284393,
0.0556179211,
-0.0241768304,
-0.015095125,
0.0161943939,
-0.0379427113,
0.0333251059,
-0.0086912531,
0.0511030965,
-0.016644612,
-0.0402880833,
-0.0048811296,
0.0587244071,
-0.0590821765,
-0.0074894554,
0.0047021573,
0.019062994,
0.0353466794,
0.0004931866,
-0.0345546342,
-0.0148017211,
-0.0143112149,
-0.0593029819,
-0.0068403729,
-0.0000953987,
0.000214267,
0.0384534597,
-0.052175574,
-0.0432422012,
-0.0033073218,
0.0087673897,
0.043181859,
-0.0632271618,
0.0169166233,
-0.014476642,
-0.0045903893,
0.0331508331,
-0.0187475923,
0.0425636657,
0.0129987327,
0.0004144662,
0.0416178331,
0.0356558971,
0.0317113064,
-0.0312119573,
-0.0083109206,
0.0298693888,
-0.0677582324,
-0.0510255098,
0.0372421257,
-0.0421755463,
-0.0580076389,
0.0398027897,
-0.0975801647,
-0.0109009091,
0.0185512491,
-0.0413385481,
-0.0101561574,
0.041242782,
-0.0427877046,
-0.0001603548,
-0.0068331007,
-0.0219812095,
0.0372787304,
0.0195921902,
-0.0023754642,
0.0479327664,
-0.0417138785,
-0.0055718995,
-0.0336141735,
0.0173063409,
0.0271174591,
0.0402021445,
-0.0249506459,
0.01399423,
-0.0000862858,
0.0342905298,
0.0280674137,
-0.0215634424,
-0.0122281043,
-0.0231368896,
-0.1158149764,
-0.0238402244,
0.0286572296,
-0.0097335735,
0.0020328597,
-0.0201714132,
0.0212644506,
-0.0196638666,
-0.0372864604,
-0.0246953089,
-0.0055893916,
0.0385828987,
0.0225428846,
0.0266223475,
0.0524668768,
-0.0335755311,
-0.0153004723,
-0.0237200465,
0.0366493128,
-0.0257601552,
0.0192269497,
-0.0077389264,
-0.0207678955,
-0.0476064272,
0.0476179719,
-0.0036035255,
-0.0357520767,
0.0327577516,
-0.0185265467,
0.0348452143,
-0.0107165286,
0.0120093841,
0.0167779326,
0.0254630297,
-0.0108496714,
-0.0006079522,
0.0357386209,
-0.0201093331,
0.0687346309,
0.025607992,
-0.0311016142,
-0.025237672,
0.0419198014,
0.0415457264,
-0.0001485515,
-0.0432811379,
-0.0148368534,
0.0307891537,
-0.0364093557,
-0.0215301588,
0.0310619976,
0.0015608795,
-0.0281542633,
-0.0009195795,
-0.0189234372,
0.0424035154,
-0.0000746994,
-0.0058620218,
-0.034333773,
-0.010921699,
-0.0354774781,
0.0393543355,
-0.0377493314,
0.0179164615,
-0.0323911086,
0.0269200262,
-0.0108007705,
-0.026053099,
0.0162876006,
0.0054696705,
0.0712528899,
0.0247007497,
-0.0086814063,
0.0031560969,
-0.0380354971,
0.0080656093,
-0.0695121139,
-0.0374645106,
-0.0167899523,
0.0269423332,
-0.0178698674,
0.0030165231,
-0.0148278996,
0.0177841242,
-0.0438999981,
0.0156976413,
-0.0148206903,
0.0083760004,
0.0581122488,
0.013725196,
-0.0027675668,
-0.0130813606,
-0.0339365602,
-0.0329153538,
0.0315989703,
0.011382293,
0.0012970848,
-0.0696541741,
-0.0273202192,
0.0188629571,
0.0839542001,
-0.0171206631,
-0.0592076257,
0.0442967899,
0.0207606331,
0.0626130998,
0.0616706982,
0.0144152334,
-0.0660740286,
-0.0196436848,
0.022656627,
0.0060314024,
0.0212785192,
-0.0217004195,
-0.017204145,
-0.0642707199,
-0.0499871075,
-0.0149661712,
0.0330404788,
0.0226338021,
0.0153331179,
-0.0965959355,
0.0107799461,
0.0034894824,
-0.011003647,
-0.0644796714,
-0.0265739616,
0.0127624106,
-0.0286270995,
-0.0128634823,
-0.0594412722,
-0.0013107513,
-0.0010960731,
0.0102576762,
0.0138917752,
-0.0309850369,
0.0241624434,
-0.0247685276,
-0.0211850274,
0.0124674048,
0.064640902,
-0.0235923994,
-0.1110363454,
-0.0012961538,
-0.0414583459,
0.0162394308,
-0.0474595279,
0.0616527647,
-0.0314311981,
-0.0500844866,
-0.0061893417,
-0.0297667515,
-0.0066877608,
-0.0043388559,
-0.040174339,
0.0620832443,
-0.0309814066,
0.0089768767,
-0.0603558682,
0.036827147,
0.024430424,
0.0169173647,
-0.0219662357,
-0.0717209801,
-0.0022239827,
-0.0054620993,
0.0298550427,
-0.0124333184,
0.0166617464,
-0.0132828131,
-0.0011987385,
-0.0198004413,
-0.063923806,
-0.0248838663,
-0.0516575985,
0.0313031115,
-0.0328147821,
-0.0158604886,
-0.0427928232,
0.0226630662,
-0.0311799888,
0.0362730995,
0.0326391496,
0.0401526354,
0.0027063538,
0.0214101318,
0.0513052195,
0.0077430797,
-0.0283759404,
-0.0032020165,
0.0028414573,
-0.0350036956,
-0.0541889779,
0.058094807,
-0.0053769024,
-0.0319432802,
0.0320446528,
-0.0163405258,
0.0129304919,
0.0843232274,
-0.0131442519,
-0.0155951409,
0.0660141483,
0.046936553,
-0.0043014647,
-0.0103926826,
-0.0266210567,
0.0526851043,
-0.019710362,
-0.03644903,
-0.0660808682,
-0.035682302,
-0.0010160443,
-0.0338347182,
0.098402068,
-0.0134894568,
0.0026599697,
-0.0173849761,
-0.0400987528,
-0.0080590416,
-0.0037909469,
-0.0293356702,
0.0047836518,
0.0089155696,
-0.0147697041,
-0.0399828441,
0.043752756,
0.0089374976,
0.0455043502,
-0.0148480581,
0.0476334654,
0.0763424858,
-0.0032363909,
-0.052118253,
0.0421036631,
-0.005451642,
-0.0228009596,
-0.007905242,
-0.0409630872,
0.0190213304,
0.0767634287,
0.0162674114,
-0.0051277815,
-0.0185470488,
0.0481611937,
-0.004708284,
0.0500473045,
-0.0112941517,
-0.0424067304,
0.0255027059,
0.0100401416,
0.0190329328,
0.0051728291,
0.0115955481,
-0.0161516666,
0.0121654077,
-0.0341452099,
0.0066269948,
0.0727598295,
-0.0088076917,
0.0188525133,
-0.0290648583,
0.0392255634,
-0.1136510894,
0.0274992716,
-0.0115207369,
0.0074581155,
-0.0587065257,
0.0052061169,
0.0801263228,
0.0336388759,
0.0318442658,
0.0526403934,
-0.0400372632,
-0.046107702,
0.0748963431,
-0.0079878289,
-0.0018584919,
0.0437109321,
0.0257840902,
0.0354371145,
0.0276418943,
0.0185507331,
-0.0598806106,
-0.0132167768,
0.0022796835,
0.0105812903,
0.0001675309,
-6.221856334e-33,
0.0043847254,
-0.0121666444,
-0.0498458073,
-0.0245101713,
-0.0186547153,
-0.0143170822,
0.0035828021,
0.0231951289,
0.0086393412,
0.0305160452,
0.0383660682,
0.0093364315,
-0.0149908988,
0.0243232064,
0.0368532538,
0.0196588151,
0.0406591743,
0.0360482074,
0.0335773937,
0.0116439844,
0.0570454635,
0.0208449848,
0.0552699268,
-0.1576802135,
0.0207939241,
0.0149267903,
-0.0723942742,
-0.005284592,
0.0216490384,
0.0461440235,
-0.0536429696,
0.0604589097,
0.0227093697,
-0.010349609,
-0.0178478658,
0.0275611561,
-0.0057404782,
-0.0046344367,
0.0121620698,
0.0026336526,
-0.0705653653,
-0.0365062691,
0.0332737416,
0.001822824,
-0.0210502315,
-0.0576763377,
0.0504509844,
-0.0082847411,
0.011015242,
-0.0198473632,
-0.0335407294,
0.0198694598,
-0.0205981098,
-0.0243892949,
0.0145459305,
0.0758610219,
0.055076886,
0.0257682856,
-0.0548683144,
0.0398248807,
-0.0754685178,
-0.0236120746,
0.0027611356,
-0.0027594061,
0.0080187684,
0.0911468044,
0.0141300932,
-0.0280483589,
0.0190880075,
-0.0018959512,
0.0109965205,
0.0337596834,
0.0417207032,
0.0962445065,
0.0203778669,
-0.001144119,
0.0043215314,
0.0294919536,
-0.0095459335,
-0.0008542276,
0.0258948319,
0.042101156,
-0.0164678693,
0.0132842595,
0.0237043723,
-0.0675978959,
-0.0318231843,
-0.0126367453,
-0.0005740188,
0.0108740022,
-0.0158583317,
0.0357151367,
0.0282104164,
-0.0393769965,
-0.0217964444,
0.0261081271,
-0.0459426343,
0.062624827,
0.024382662,
-0.054734949,
-0.0170677807,
-0.0144271487,
0.0269875899,
-0.0025755041,
0.0267934538,
-0.0049719797,
0.0459927469,
0.0480072014,
-0.0800012946,
-0.0255642217,
0.008342009,
0.0010455969,
-0.0054236641,
0.0245854985,
0.0055933492,
0.012364991,
-0.0453315526,
0.0597279146,
0.0077932118,
0.068198733,
-0.0260717813,
-0.0486471318,
-0.0190693345,
0.0240269024,
-0.0161137283,
-0.0281665456,
-0.0050050863,
-0.025136089,
0.0089773368,
-0.0523506999,
-0.0270065479,
-0.0083664814,
2.701e-7,
0.0451988243,
0.0340261161,
0.0037363763,
-0.0020593037,
0.0279741362,
0.0928136855,
-0.0152972452,
0.045396436,
0.0169593394,
-0.0269325487,
-0.0023149806,
0.018963322,
0.0098438831,
0.0445416458,
-0.0062550106,
0.034145385,
-0.0265503656,
-0.0024439015,
-0.0014793177,
0.0863029957,
0.1274412721,
0.0974913687,
0.0125227766,
-0.0524092726,
-0.003048429,
0.0129511822,
0.0807025954,
-0.0169169176,
-0.024564743,
-0.0525917746,
0.0083551928,
-0.0161068216,
-0.0117140301,
-0.0210429523,
0.008397826,
-0.0030706637,
0.027436126,
0.0077270051,
-0.0160182603,
-0.0735675246,
0.0154051427,
0.0609407835,
-0.0378563553,
0.0339856371,
0.0399517938,
-0.0376777835,
-0.0380627662,
-0.0961018428,
-0.0527096242,
0.0485584736,
0.0685633644,
0.0112954769,
-0.0455784276,
0.0263756365,
-0.0051077893,
-0.0209822282,
-0.0582373701,
-0.0804246366,
-0.0035303615,
0.0455874689,
-0.0298891347,
-0.0069906316,
0.0422621407,
-0.0019448231,
0.0366445407,
-0.0483614951,
-0.0118418625,
1.732335553e-34,
0.0518754013,
-0.0381455831,
0.0195938125,
0.0081208013,
0.0123020606,
-0.0421149991,
-0.0591975041,
-0.0464658476,
0.0509088859,
-0.0433189757,
-0.0027840321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01582v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01582v1 | Explaining with Contrastive Phrasal Highlighting: A Case Study in Assisting Humans to Detect Translation Differences | 2023-12-04T02:40:28 | 2023-12-04T02:40:28 | Eleftheria Briakou, Navita Goyal, Marine Carpuat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Explainable NLP techniques primarily explain by answering "Which tokens in
the input are responsible for this prediction?''. We argue that for NLP models
that make predictions by comparing two input texts, it is more useful to
explain by answering "What differences between the two inputs explain this
prediction?''. We introduce a technique to generate contrastive highlights that
explain the predictions of a semantic divergence model via
phrase-alignment-guided erasure. We show that the resulting highlights match
human rationales of cross-lingual semantic differences better than popular
post-hoc saliency techniques and that they successfully help people detect
fine-grained meaning differences in human translations and critical machine
translation errors. | [
0.0274978541,
0.0027580836,
-0.0262392666,
0.0471952036,
-0.0309955832,
0.0057500186,
0.0042476607,
0.014708017,
-0.0498204269,
0.0016263967,
0.0226471685,
0.0022940626,
0.035610009,
-0.0297675189,
0.024134675,
-0.1141460612,
0.0559176356,
0.0067167478,
0.0013251292,
0.0031543146,
0.0450895764,
0.0283362195,
0.0151416305,
0.0256557986,
0.0491751581,
-0.0326073878,
-0.0307101645,
0.0191527773,
0.0436960198,
0.0055148113,
0.0020508228,
0.0394287556,
0.0036682363,
0.0104010049,
0.0000021291,
-0.0284006875,
-0.0247909594,
0.0144794174,
-0.00118921,
0.029906258,
0.0172089897,
-0.0383585915,
0.021876879,
-0.0377692692,
-0.0003468841,
-0.0086408127,
0.0422200114,
0.0763125196,
0.0355064981,
0.0395586826,
-0.0000013306,
-0.0097063985,
-0.0343237258,
0.0015887239,
0.0089765945,
-0.0459650494,
-0.0304653384,
-0.0314416699,
-0.0428538024,
0.0211896691,
0.0103538055,
0.0223290902,
0.0051608579,
-0.0060636685,
-0.0166718625,
0.0101012848,
-0.0163007379,
-0.0118855918,
-0.0135267582,
0.024594605,
-0.034431491,
-0.0630606189,
0.0144263878,
-0.0347404964,
-0.0172847584,
-0.0008274831,
-0.0262369048,
0.0010350955,
-0.0376969203,
0.0345848054,
0.0849483386,
0.0304911565,
0.0153076211,
0.0400173031,
-0.0010047926,
-0.0272901505,
0.0148431817,
-0.0109663913,
-0.0526846536,
0.008856467,
-0.0443894006,
-0.0327954367,
0.0392635986,
0.0121831326,
-0.0248571113,
-0.0086712958,
-0.0142974444,
-0.0534357987,
0.0262740105,
-0.034953326,
0.0477042533,
0.0253323074,
-0.0813818127,
0.0475392975,
-0.0203255285,
0.0785129219,
-0.0018701602,
-0.0032809447,
-0.0232391004,
-0.0251927469,
-0.0296660513,
-0.0112560932,
-0.0209835935,
-0.0217598118,
-0.0529070608,
0.0214235857,
0.0044335485,
-0.0164503194,
-0.0542710163,
0.0138858315,
-0.0168089885,
-0.0046564844,
-0.0598735549,
-0.0158703122,
-0.0366608351,
0.0023795173,
-0.0791503564,
-0.0121204834,
-0.0165697206,
-0.0618802309,
-0.0164418034,
0.0433602594,
-0.0192464292,
-0.0190209895,
-0.049646318,
0.0712911859,
0.0123256417,
0.0130042247,
-0.0208243877,
-0.052540794,
-0.001572005,
-0.036898423,
-0.0111069186,
-0.0551016629,
0.005767446,
0.0069303741,
-0.0220372826,
-0.0407239012,
0.0131436018,
0.0156118516,
-0.0139248399,
0.082147792,
-0.0312092118,
-0.0091332858,
-0.0106262071,
-0.0209102016,
-0.029628003,
0.0419595651,
-0.0186199956,
-0.0225936584,
0.0646497607,
-0.0248212405,
0.0040117819,
-0.030183468,
-0.0298279393,
0.0018694171,
-0.0533228852,
-0.0148109114,
-0.0077888556,
0.0210031215,
0.0492342338,
0.0328668393,
-0.0032315168,
-0.0042789411,
0.0280733127,
0.0542669445,
-0.0072378381,
0.036192555,
0.0383102521,
0.0251903441,
-0.0234120302,
0.0837271065,
-0.0048173028,
-0.0110655511,
0.00883835,
0.0116226133,
0.0099221515,
0.0327078402,
-0.0209489651,
-0.054050006,
-0.0378659181,
0.0328809507,
0.0248713531,
-0.0226531643,
0.0456273369,
0.0409812666,
-0.0326069668,
0.0572459735,
0.0455126427,
-0.0522094741,
0.0247997474,
-0.0158058498,
0.0121476427,
0.0931035429,
0.003138545,
-0.0317696892,
0.02546639,
0.0137441419,
0.0079052979,
0.0636403933,
0.0533370785,
0.0222769454,
0.0174995735,
-0.0344523452,
0.0016364811,
-0.0363737531,
0.0402652696,
-0.0148852207,
0.0080304183,
-0.0377318785,
0.042128697,
-0.0621045716,
-0.0687235147,
0.0434198342,
0.0003140292,
-0.0044250353,
-0.02597473,
0.0115961833,
-0.0102929464,
0.0491823964,
0.019423034,
0.0135060186,
-0.0001011808,
-0.0369292051,
0.019688474,
0.0701542273,
-0.0159353297,
-0.0270057376,
0.0131456573,
-0.0681288019,
-0.0193524733,
0.0152522894,
-0.0648112297,
-0.0170668866,
-0.0034829495,
-0.0254697986,
0.035224922,
-0.0044756355,
0.0297655351,
-0.0123556629,
0.0122993793,
-0.0385003462,
0.0766236186,
0.0060560964,
0.0561450794,
-0.0140798585,
-0.0166382752,
0.0200385097,
-0.0263562594,
0.0282632839,
0.0392930135,
0.0031863814,
-0.0167382732,
0.019920256,
-0.025067931,
-0.0527542457,
0.0168233048,
-0.0415275581,
0.0095244898,
-0.020428326,
0.0455301888,
0.0913867056,
-0.0229252689,
0.0174248554,
-0.0115504125,
0.0336286016,
0.0180376973,
-0.017415639,
0.0254821219,
0.0785044655,
-0.0109692067,
0.0210828949,
-0.0535102263,
-0.0032826627,
-0.0143089145,
0.0531454161,
0.0361048877,
-0.0277581178,
-0.0738371983,
0.0274469666,
-0.0350398943,
0.0099207759,
0.0069304244,
-0.0577267818,
0.0139691466,
0.0215652734,
0.0484976172,
0.0271342266,
-0.0028064926,
0.058005821,
0.0311651994,
-0.038101811,
-0.0523657165,
-0.0326023772,
-0.0290617701,
0.0154522238,
0.0046518031,
-0.0620678477,
0.0088757109,
0.0526853949,
0.0266746636,
0.0069168247,
-0.0478188843,
0.016878359,
-0.0294784624,
-0.0166436713,
0.0323343799,
-0.0157343857,
-0.0077253017,
0.0762906149,
-0.0495635904,
-0.0319671668,
0.0926316902,
-0.0081849759,
0.0404891446,
-0.0527534634,
-0.0081177354,
-0.0371071994,
0.0284773912,
-0.0386667289,
0.0110221533,
0.0157419872,
-0.031335745,
-0.0166563932,
-0.0434797965,
0.0429160744,
0.0105855027,
0.0870470479,
-0.0907598659,
-0.0520303771,
0.0185807142,
0.0022487852,
-0.0100337565,
-0.033595372,
-0.0363363996,
0.0123224268,
0.0188328046,
0.0029773025,
-0.0066712224,
0.0155670103,
0.0214361735,
0.0191709287,
0.0099228583,
0.0052551525,
-0.0174066909,
-0.0104947472,
-0.0224236604,
-0.0144286053,
0.0174706504,
-0.0726756975,
0.0391245708,
0.0302359946,
-0.0057348716,
-0.0148965763,
-0.0168731995,
-0.0244987383,
0.0086127128,
-0.0486738719,
-0.070960924,
-0.0193274859,
0.0726413578,
-0.0978260711,
0.0014454633,
0.0921527818,
0.0219620746,
-0.0275848042,
0.014258136,
-0.0511908196,
0.0046535763,
0.0148144839,
0.0084828073,
-0.0446564071,
-0.0375853144,
0.0237554014,
0.0211585294,
0.0080722645,
0.0233933795,
-0.0121651357,
-0.0772616193,
0.0146239037,
0.0016081327,
-0.0459429771,
-0.0286706705,
-0.0470008701,
0.0145284589,
-0.0092595015,
0.0073681809,
-0.0148734599,
0.0078494521,
0.014574809,
0.0182590559,
-0.009688165,
-0.0257283747,
-0.018986972,
-0.0624754876,
-0.0382648893,
0.0932246223,
0.0573851503,
-0.0124640167,
-0.0468848273,
0.0179855395,
-0.0763531923,
0.0484210625,
-0.0217314009,
0.0747772008,
0.0431802049,
-0.0123672867,
-0.0421473123,
0.0021261389,
0.0184397362,
-0.0471814796,
-0.0249239095,
0.0255074296,
0.0101348683,
-0.0143227568,
0.0137269795,
0.034227524,
-0.0189151075,
0.0657943338,
0.038667921,
-0.0170488451,
-0.0596163645,
-0.017705258,
0.0160097051,
-0.0287498552,
-0.0123257702,
-0.0294111278,
-0.0312735029,
-0.0655155629,
-0.0595780462,
-0.0743724257,
-0.0253870543,
-0.008449384,
0.0238762368,
0.0228000935,
-0.0548375621,
-0.024006756,
0.0074821408,
0.0590241663,
0.0056808414,
0.0042985831,
0.0062578111,
-0.0015368329,
-0.0249290075,
-0.0226242747,
-0.0047533531,
-0.0235103182,
-0.0594915785,
-0.0420117192,
0.0057095708,
-0.0036149286,
0.0195154157,
0.060049586,
-0.0321436189,
-0.0365645476,
-0.0465650596,
0.0319060758,
0.0103000486,
0.0016928543,
0.0414944328,
-0.0043070815,
0.0160814393,
0.0490977019,
0.0104822703,
-0.0136912977,
0.0206493828,
0.0363456011,
-0.0226020832,
-0.0574925505,
0.0220869724,
-0.0287541561,
0.0899434015,
-0.0016730663,
-0.0529898964,
-0.0296432171,
-0.0189673826,
-0.0135453669,
-0.0399945751,
-0.0018572387,
0.0050874716,
-0.0237222835,
-0.0188788809,
0.0157899708,
0.0444859602,
-0.0466842614,
-0.0204102751,
-0.0595892482,
0.0373414718,
0.0402285419,
0.0190781988,
-0.0303182621,
0.0493730009,
-0.0238211472,
0.0019650531,
-0.0198837128,
0.047257755,
-0.0113031017,
0.0719521269,
0.0047775153,
0.0063519459,
0.0094590709,
-0.0289418679,
-0.0299562365,
-0.0592516735,
0.0221160706,
-0.0100845434,
0.0605205558,
-0.060814485,
0.0731461495,
0.0326592401,
-0.0319208726,
-0.0048700916,
0.0799966827,
0.0276841093,
-0.0215832721,
0.0033843454,
0.0115414662,
-0.0181413293,
-0.0041856575,
0.0641563311,
-0.0702240467,
0.0224210452,
0.0256483369,
-0.0335539952,
-0.0074171941,
-0.0114504164,
0.0349672139,
0.0125019671,
0.0012947335,
-0.0107274055,
-0.061930228,
-0.0444747433,
0.0223563034,
0.0160426591,
0.0252840202,
0.014293923,
0.0167462602,
0.0964891315,
-0.0310590155,
-0.0550003983,
-0.0420839079,
0.0286786184,
-0.0365007743,
-0.0012707184,
-0.0715894848,
-6.661181185e-33,
-0.0033490309,
-0.0521024875,
-0.0425242521,
-0.0225811657,
-0.0064480733,
0.0204728786,
-0.077591233,
-0.0453481972,
-0.0285514724,
0.0652783215,
0.0217227601,
0.0219277479,
0.0264383126,
-0.0207719374,
0.0070258421,
-0.0426686667,
0.0751126856,
0.0724754706,
-0.0076970696,
-0.0018599827,
0.0436430611,
-0.0072970418,
0.0687536821,
-0.0315330625,
0.0817705095,
-0.0292175189,
-0.016333038,
0.0358741358,
0.0373551659,
0.0345133878,
0.0152427759,
0.0251796972,
0.0282218736,
-0.0258810762,
-0.0442039818,
-0.0179710109,
-0.0376300476,
-0.0349099711,
0.0795730352,
0.0137426499,
-0.0539515018,
-0.0587900914,
0.0293163639,
-0.0248061474,
0.0230671559,
0.0098938812,
0.0741816461,
-0.0159894023,
-0.0060894694,
0.0313028432,
-0.0718023255,
0.0383946113,
-0.0336212404,
0.0085711973,
0.041552484,
0.0340588316,
0.0133862058,
0.0165332146,
-0.052795168,
0.0156073701,
0.0364263803,
0.0221903399,
0.0592100509,
0.0076941904,
-0.0234700274,
0.0294357669,
0.0224194638,
-0.0006634971,
0.0417321473,
0.0136505831,
-0.0355957896,
0.0203474294,
0.0846590325,
0.0518618301,
0.052817408,
0.0419465527,
-0.0188098568,
-0.0025471412,
-0.0680244714,
0.064861916,
0.0342541598,
0.0372966342,
-0.0543601066,
0.0061542415,
-0.0359158069,
-0.0387991555,
-0.0323275998,
-0.0270956457,
-0.0092429109,
-0.0393728949,
-0.0356437117,
0.000897528,
-0.0084605906,
-0.0088575622,
0.049246449,
0.0173152946,
-0.0203498863,
-0.0151158227,
0.0014197343,
-0.0033473012,
-0.0220019557,
-0.0210100785,
-0.0376991443,
0.014233605,
0.0540424325,
0.0214476064,
0.0227676686,
-0.0498580262,
-0.0291092787,
0.0173693839,
-0.0584749095,
-0.0316748545,
-0.0678124651,
-0.0234206021,
0.0390130803,
0.0174181238,
-0.0492321178,
0.0547070764,
0.0807317719,
0.0110677946,
0.0081756786,
0.0049847793,
-0.0415268652,
0.030124072,
-0.0075790999,
0.0266096909,
-0.0229214523,
0.0335772038,
0.0390832163,
-0.0052493503,
-0.0372705273,
0.0422381982,
2.719e-7,
0.039558731,
0.0455483869,
0.0557500385,
-0.0126939779,
-0.0109374812,
0.0381250866,
0.0108872959,
-0.0264804587,
-0.0015919779,
0.0172082186,
-0.0151187014,
0.0385945998,
0.0749773234,
0.0345008746,
-0.0396269187,
0.0017617552,
-0.0377340913,
-0.0066566831,
-0.0407151841,
0.0021985578,
0.1011351645,
0.020058414,
0.0288481154,
0.0154756159,
-0.0106098326,
-0.0156277064,
0.0243116822,
-0.0492335819,
0.0097001968,
0.0024663655,
0.0405300893,
-0.0096420627,
-0.0003862085,
0.0244550854,
-0.0406472012,
-0.0425407402,
0.0111034354,
0.0330023877,
-0.0036183991,
0.0029363011,
-0.0305706691,
-0.0283533111,
0.0264525022,
-0.0910459012,
0.0475066043,
0.0039311545,
-0.0249792039,
-0.0321032256,
-0.0277178138,
0.0059546754,
-0.0088200876,
-0.0025376459,
-0.0679030493,
0.0246780161,
-0.0154423583,
-0.0023116553,
-0.0897822008,
-0.0315774754,
-0.0649496168,
0.0529405177,
0.0082743121,
0.0079231774,
0.0088831345,
0.0075887786,
0.0105086267,
-0.0414834507,
0.0023666276,
2.315587955e-34,
0.0295234676,
0.0232785624,
0.013040348,
-0.0002432926,
0.0634355024,
0.035221979,
-0.0374270864,
-0.013346306,
0.0466847979,
0.006772893,
0.0087651992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01575v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01575v1 | A Challenging Multimodal Video Summary: Simultaneously Extracting and Generating Keyframe-Caption Pairs from Video | 2023-12-04T02:17:14 | 2023-12-04T02:17:14 | Keito Kudo, Haruki Nagasawa, Jun Suzuki, Nobuyuki Shimizu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | This paper proposes a practical multimodal video summarization task setting
and a dataset to train and evaluate the task. The target task involves
summarizing a given video into a predefined number of keyframe-caption pairs
and displaying them in a listable format to grasp the video content quickly.
This task aims to extract crucial scenes from the video in the form of images
(keyframes) and generate corresponding captions explaining each keyframe's
situation. This task is useful as a practical application and presents a highly
challenging problem worthy of study. Specifically, achieving simultaneous
optimization of the keyframe selection performance and caption quality
necessitates careful consideration of the mutual dependence on both preceding
and subsequent keyframes and captions. To facilitate subsequent research in
this field, we also construct a dataset by expanding upon existing datasets and
propose an evaluation framework. Furthermore, we develop two baseline systems
and report their respective performance. | [
0.0103252763,
0.0264231376,
0.03318372,
0.032729689,
0.0179289933,
0.0254149884,
0.0152075449,
0.0362212285,
-0.0282562878,
-0.0757613927,
-0.010899622,
-0.0119272806,
-0.0005483144,
0.039675273,
-0.0078572202,
-0.136809364,
0.0058411639,
-0.0119097345,
-0.0346148089,
0.0017385966,
0.0290275645,
-0.0081565846,
-0.0281344708,
-0.0028982239,
-0.0424146652,
0.0232771747,
-0.0161275286,
-0.0333192609,
0.0602339469,
-0.0348767005,
-0.0249468368,
0.0291357227,
0.0562988482,
-0.0446639732,
0.0000017362,
-0.0226735752,
0.0175873153,
-0.0173494481,
0.0375132635,
0.0319034494,
0.0475196019,
-0.0310290996,
0.0632598698,
-0.0474733114,
-0.0106381383,
-0.0052844668,
0.0370486304,
0.0116758123,
0.0861042216,
-0.00083974,
-0.0438114889,
-0.0473988838,
-0.0465938225,
-0.0258120894,
-0.0109073212,
-0.0170234255,
-0.0222536158,
0.0319232829,
0.0196973328,
-0.0487895422,
-0.065554969,
0.0063319635,
-0.0226492565,
-0.0108845439,
0.0005213817,
0.0297113936,
-0.07674402,
-0.0443335846,
-0.0281470791,
0.0852610245,
0.0038025035,
0.0748236105,
0.0091219461,
0.0113344127,
-0.0120358039,
0.0152118206,
-0.0911311731,
0.0581142008,
-0.0207288973,
-0.0021915759,
-0.0382943898,
0.0485261977,
-0.0290335026,
-0.0338369757,
0.0052064792,
-0.0781810582,
0.052603025,
0.0414252281,
-0.0363222286,
-0.0190192182,
-0.0681947172,
-0.0594062991,
0.0135990474,
-0.0038479927,
0.0266565476,
-0.0116847744,
-0.0199949108,
0.0081555685,
-0.0293927509,
-0.0245973468,
0.0097288536,
-0.0104533667,
-0.0333170965,
0.0812264681,
-0.0347498618,
0.0486313216,
0.0058563105,
-0.0074552251,
-0.0199356955,
0.0054593636,
-0.0682476088,
0.0442058146,
0.0162938833,
0.0341802239,
-0.0336813517,
0.0194849242,
-0.0417519361,
-0.0150757181,
-0.0359804034,
0.0304034743,
-0.0491681956,
0.0439048745,
0.0435145311,
-0.0170817077,
-0.0369993336,
0.0208462961,
-0.0531099848,
0.0162650142,
-0.0238035433,
-0.0114552407,
0.0088886172,
0.0197430383,
0.0237919725,
-0.0240242425,
0.0046101324,
0.0660562515,
-0.059172418,
-0.0281077772,
-0.0324748866,
0.0019795503,
-0.0496627465,
0.0166624356,
0.0073193642,
-0.0185257662,
0.0422959179,
-0.0227050856,
0.0016394644,
-0.001048337,
0.0206781067,
-0.0230505858,
0.0136635322,
0.0531195812,
-0.0009864962,
0.0088281119,
0.0237238389,
0.0212896578,
-0.0356423408,
0.0476534292,
0.0170523375,
0.0604473464,
0.0573505126,
-0.0094924578,
0.0256007668,
0.0267399102,
-0.0210939553,
0.0391651876,
-0.0149782002,
-0.0127203558,
0.0204590186,
0.0072256541,
0.0616122894,
0.0193399731,
-0.0162888877,
0.0146907121,
0.0378821157,
0.0442943871,
-0.0484464131,
-0.0143741127,
0.0330444053,
0.0018375253,
0.0175760407,
0.0512048639,
0.0261327829,
0.0844110772,
0.0219746195,
0.0065621138,
0.0499799214,
0.0375694111,
-0.0608234517,
-0.0625880733,
0.0124648623,
-0.0165456589,
-0.0250979699,
-0.0010298052,
0.0542150363,
-0.0205459781,
-0.0637901798,
0.0623908937,
-0.0050857188,
-0.0547006354,
0.0349456109,
0.0134078301,
-0.030290531,
0.0198175814,
-0.0097386194,
-0.0172053985,
-0.0285622906,
-0.0049537658,
0.0491528995,
0.00321798,
0.0050864923,
-0.0315107256,
0.05090148,
-0.0705500767,
-0.0762745738,
-0.0353704318,
-0.0047141328,
0.0286246575,
-0.0388763696,
-0.0067250566,
0.0133634014,
0.0340680704,
-0.0097465422,
0.0499230772,
0.0640948042,
-0.0042280592,
-0.0090558212,
-0.0009095899,
0.0476150513,
0.0336454399,
-0.0289260652,
-0.0348647051,
0.0189917386,
-0.0224256646,
0.0289029609,
0.0803057849,
-0.0218694359,
0.0051689241,
0.0196421202,
-0.0726226792,
0.0192015637,
0.0253289323,
-0.0350919031,
-0.059056893,
0.0197462793,
-0.0039968258,
-0.0497705564,
-0.0524456054,
-0.0106252842,
0.011881046,
-0.005825649,
-0.0087886713,
0.0568577386,
-0.0239649341,
0.0113171367,
0.0200824197,
-0.0266872756,
0.0062917834,
-0.0421997495,
-0.0186577793,
-0.0181781221,
-0.0038422798,
-0.0335940719,
0.0466144159,
-0.0121913143,
-0.0496917665,
0.0083052563,
-0.0854977667,
-0.0116420081,
0.008466443,
-0.0033192334,
-0.0140842143,
0.0001162169,
-0.0109569635,
-0.019493686,
0.0029458008,
-0.0003834847,
0.0173669104,
-0.0111067547,
0.0206714906,
0.0636126474,
0.0019360441,
-0.0358044766,
0.0084973453,
0.0313660093,
0.0667978898,
0.022054255,
-0.0338644907,
0.0320536457,
0.008157461,
0.0034124535,
-0.0245715231,
-0.0426061228,
0.0120042125,
-0.0015765987,
0.012393821,
-0.0024513388,
0.0198443979,
0.0543040857,
0.0140232034,
0.021413438,
-0.0372931734,
0.0141302915,
0.0177522041,
0.0040912488,
-0.0284076966,
0.008905502,
-0.0179100372,
0.0253646653,
-0.0045125964,
0.0160541777,
0.048391901,
-0.0389903896,
0.0026146357,
0.0116550848,
-0.0314635709,
-0.0585510731,
0.0295712799,
0.0083117522,
0.0255031586,
-0.0482499711,
-0.0215655304,
0.0004013386,
-0.0326606221,
-0.0307790525,
0.0222923849,
0.0219585244,
-0.0412088893,
0.0764247552,
0.0076853745,
0.0401703902,
-0.0122879846,
0.0134217674,
-0.0235295556,
-0.0548597611,
0.0438681506,
0.0066609872,
0.0736642927,
-0.0609170496,
-0.032379847,
-0.0124984868,
0.0064329519,
-0.0058036689,
0.0065548019,
-0.0234409124,
-0.0296373162,
-0.0327794366,
0.0344287865,
-0.0226584245,
0.0282953046,
0.0151090221,
0.0312151778,
-0.0138243651,
0.014331704,
0.0342156813,
0.07462845,
0.0385057777,
0.0185475107,
-0.0670816824,
-0.0403031819,
0.0417699851,
0.0046039219,
0.0303156469,
-0.005435402,
-0.02652115,
0.0491845906,
-0.0031497618,
-0.0258467216,
-0.0028163705,
0.0095830141,
0.0384117588,
-0.0295360796,
0.0419371985,
0.0575669631,
0.0085803848,
-0.0538195409,
-0.0239562895,
0.0319569781,
-0.0364117362,
0.0586620979,
0.0044446229,
-0.0552967303,
-0.0336367488,
-0.0526884831,
-0.0102271941,
0.0259328969,
-0.0054417346,
-0.0428023711,
-0.0364002921,
0.0777875558,
0.0267270543,
-0.0667449459,
-0.024529703,
-0.0512091331,
0.0190606769,
-0.0255767647,
-0.0058642291,
0.0304064713,
-0.0072560781,
-0.0015824016,
0.0365772061,
-0.0059507643,
-0.0439882018,
-0.0109505635,
-0.0350127518,
-0.0225724578,
0.0232357401,
0.0109924069,
-0.0508151576,
0.0103197815,
-0.0155317234,
-0.0299977176,
-0.0015425043,
-0.0077366442,
0.0293948893,
-0.0282330345,
-0.0428068787,
0.0018579075,
0.0413333997,
0.0173169412,
-0.0123047754,
0.0523744226,
-0.0175080318,
-0.0213524327,
0.009391414,
-0.0437900685,
0.0213873126,
0.0107490178,
0.0259906966,
0.0068223812,
-0.006712337,
0.034002047,
0.0346901156,
-0.0134447264,
-0.0850230679,
-0.0134903826,
-0.0090555744,
-0.0324044228,
0.0004066367,
-0.0539501384,
-0.0026037344,
0.0973468348,
0.0079145189,
-0.029039789,
0.0162332468,
-0.0347697735,
0.0721644759,
-0.082162112,
0.0656301007,
0.0227132831,
-0.0658141822,
-0.0517723709,
-0.0130875651,
0.0555886701,
-0.0390378237,
-0.0250466093,
0.0407610647,
-0.0177179296,
0.0120593235,
-0.0302714929,
0.1051430702,
0.0131226061,
0.0332985781,
0.0831014067,
0.0012623452,
-0.0059929127,
0.0359757058,
0.0460105017,
-0.0101845618,
0.0003593555,
-0.0081778252,
-0.0511957183,
-0.0304025616,
-0.0733348951,
0.0440266095,
-0.0514455251,
0.009025502,
-0.0221781973,
0.0052953074,
-0.0016897726,
0.0061059673,
0.0241141208,
-0.0796067044,
-0.0221016016,
-0.0280181207,
-0.0561344028,
0.002492503,
-0.0105676008,
-0.0547174402,
0.0448161997,
-0.0265269727,
0.0327060409,
-0.0054619974,
0.0092492532,
-0.0121301152,
-0.0193957817,
-0.0051249485,
-0.0060614599,
0.0126727056,
-0.0381339192,
-0.0727305785,
0.0548056774,
0.014781775,
0.0149298087,
-0.0088409232,
0.0394025296,
0.018408766,
0.0283424798,
-0.0072136307,
-0.0080740768,
-0.0071442942,
0.0571957007,
0.019508481,
0.0561421551,
-0.0604570284,
0.0205730889,
0.0895494223,
-0.0377433077,
0.0075948704,
-0.0064202636,
0.0055802702,
-0.0231893081,
0.0454272367,
0.0296360161,
-0.0393537581,
-0.0097768409,
-0.0036631646,
0.0405469052,
0.0044645825,
0.0938487351,
-0.0186104085,
0.0194211118,
0.0477855429,
-0.0122955898,
-0.0517548621,
-0.0159722921,
-0.0153982807,
0.0073407148,
-0.0079961503,
-0.0129328473,
-0.0084024314,
-0.0240905788,
0.0395808183,
-0.0041764034,
0.0372513905,
0.0290203542,
0.0747246444,
0.0066516642,
0.0059401258,
0.0344199762,
-0.0230161361,
-0.0393492281,
-0.0442026295,
0.0188010465,
0.0026516535,
-4.959760743e-33,
-0.0482838675,
-0.045048207,
-0.0031303111,
0.0044211596,
-0.0232974049,
0.019050194,
-0.0109375212,
0.0310429614,
0.0050523686,
-0.002694166,
0.036727909,
-0.0360127017,
0.0104828877,
0.0544008985,
0.0259169843,
-0.0261903927,
0.0322880857,
-0.0360696092,
-0.0287597664,
0.0301438291,
0.0099675069,
0.0015772943,
0.0159209054,
-0.0158799626,
-0.0067787548,
-0.0212468281,
-0.0298043992,
-0.0134145403,
0.0591298081,
0.0468938872,
-0.0090058781,
0.0016230976,
0.0206360407,
-0.0297574438,
-0.0356676169,
-0.0218093731,
-0.0400494188,
-0.0182609782,
0.049841281,
-0.0014569764,
-0.0263096821,
-0.0232840125,
0.0464305058,
-0.0315623358,
0.0128018316,
-0.0472207889,
0.0617109835,
-0.050859835,
0.0029411772,
-0.0420674048,
0.0263299067,
0.0048019011,
-0.0603232682,
-0.0494723283,
0.0689339191,
0.0245713089,
0.0288812108,
-0.0335092917,
0.0111862831,
0.0343212746,
-0.0113455663,
0.0390642211,
0.1139660254,
0.0340753794,
0.0198625196,
0.0760075822,
-0.0032658873,
-0.0476143993,
-0.0231905431,
0.0385133363,
-0.0119438423,
0.0705166161,
0.0189233217,
0.0568446293,
0.0446361303,
0.0422927104,
-0.0385491177,
0.0743332058,
-0.0698156208,
0.0247628111,
-0.0059088981,
0.0210379045,
0.0411436372,
0.0416108556,
-0.0482906252,
0.0002523501,
-0.0366706513,
-0.0112815266,
-0.0274217613,
0.0008918928,
-0.001441392,
-0.0224839244,
0.0664747208,
0.0362970531,
0.0724091679,
-0.0106159328,
0.0024327228,
0.0625197217,
0.0305109676,
-0.0422674157,
0.0322496593,
-0.0014823235,
0.047519587,
-0.0033598454,
0.0382722877,
-0.001878253,
-0.0128020346,
0.0247232877,
0.037823908,
-0.0013376448,
0.0150690386,
0.0173789952,
-0.0405263603,
0.0242153574,
-0.0093465149,
0.0207755975,
-0.0548399091,
0.0377160944,
-0.0783511102,
0.0259013623,
0.0047128294,
-0.0115528489,
-0.0016497582,
0.0233056117,
-0.0079224445,
0.0464900173,
-0.0237422269,
-0.0476086028,
0.0019068831,
-0.0362172648,
-0.0312107261,
0.0248517003,
2.41e-7,
-0.0118041132,
0.0165314563,
0.0572575703,
-0.0194747783,
-0.0149314245,
0.0268453117,
-0.0342877619,
-0.0024312551,
-0.0006471255,
-0.0581058078,
0.0762281939,
0.0416063443,
-0.0038565665,
0.0173748527,
-0.0314756185,
-0.05217392,
-0.0170544516,
-0.0285597891,
-0.0239037853,
-0.0192952324,
0.0434619263,
0.0643626526,
-0.001471367,
-0.0002334979,
0.0136134699,
-0.0266486295,
0.0872494206,
-0.0259897057,
-0.0385318808,
-0.0071930434,
0.0094986241,
0.023876965,
-0.0650218055,
0.0150414016,
-0.016645208,
-0.0501377136,
0.0757414624,
0.0216610692,
-0.005140523,
-0.049128145,
-0.0112279374,
0.0867564008,
-0.0248550307,
0.0288555156,
0.0478623956,
-0.0468831733,
-0.00625493,
-0.0325270817,
-0.0646583289,
0.0317206085,
-0.0454925261,
-0.0027542922,
-0.0489373542,
0.0749426633,
0.0067916103,
0.006705578,
-0.035793826,
-0.0861916691,
0.0019223825,
0.0190466382,
-0.0083931293,
0.006637875,
-0.0323987044,
-0.0402428135,
0.0161921773,
0.0017976389,
-0.0534890182,
1.422480063e-34,
0.0393392108,
0.0132290367,
-0.0275733341,
-0.0502284318,
-0.0038604762,
-0.0146856206,
-0.0959939882,
-0.0057344069,
-0.0096466215,
-0.034019094,
-0.0078430558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01564v1 | APoLLo: Unified Adapter and Prompt Learning for Vision Language Models | 2023-12-04T01:42:09 | 2023-12-04T01:42:09 | Sanjoy Chowdhury, Sayan Nag, Dinesh Manocha | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The choice of input text prompt plays a critical role in the performance of
Vision-Language Pretrained (VLP) models such as CLIP. We present APoLLo, a
unified multi-modal approach that combines Adapter and Prompt learning for
Vision-Language models. Our method is designed to substantially improve the
generalization capabilities of VLP models when they are fine-tuned in a
few-shot setting. We introduce trainable cross-attention-based adapter layers
in conjunction with vision and language encoders to strengthen the alignment
between the two modalities. We enforce consistency between the respective
encoder branches (receiving augmented inputs) to prevent overfitting in
downstream tasks. Our method is evaluated on three representative tasks:
generalization to novel classes, cross-dataset evaluation, and unseen domain
shifts. In practice, APoLLo achieves a relative gain up to 6.03% over MaPLe
(SOTA) on novel classes for 10 diverse image recognition datasets. | [
-0.0117085297,
0.0439377464,
0.0250620395,
0.0349032916,
0.008001985,
-0.003252065,
0.0381406173,
-0.0238912143,
0.0124737704,
-0.0388306007,
-0.0661140308,
0.0063720583,
0.0087805884,
0.0792484805,
0.017877901,
-0.0710233748,
0.0221223813,
-0.0386616215,
-0.0242763404,
0.0169154853,
0.0251020566,
-0.003048643,
0.0202690605,
0.0412522592,
0.0052168029,
-0.0135485232,
-0.0180577058,
0.0192982182,
0.0284577627,
0.0025589978,
-0.0270086825,
0.0420253687,
0.0335817784,
0.0128276097,
0.0000020414,
-0.0322625898,
0.0041027321,
0.0027020935,
-0.0071298759,
-0.0384599455,
0.0126750432,
-0.0663204193,
0.0176912732,
0.0098977527,
-0.0028744016,
-0.0430674404,
0.0704742298,
0.0340793878,
0.0822743848,
0.0742626563,
-0.023067968,
-0.0119159585,
-0.0005065995,
-0.0633140206,
0.0218432061,
-0.0285140481,
0.0259858873,
-0.0254248884,
0.0066983462,
-0.0010286431,
-0.0590307117,
0.0315750092,
0.0415050574,
-0.0106413113,
0.0074724266,
0.0376801379,
-0.0134675419,
-0.0385578461,
-0.0406523906,
0.079543516,
-0.0478595458,
-0.0158786867,
-0.0584743507,
-0.0367483832,
0.0223828852,
0.0048764823,
-0.016609041,
0.0170684364,
0.0064666155,
0.0183026865,
-0.0508185737,
0.0125468262,
0.0157945491,
-0.0205481853,
-0.0231281854,
0.0253746416,
0.0144112902,
0.0248921756,
0.0102339452,
0.027607182,
-0.0161757097,
-0.0501709729,
0.0133143766,
0.0091213388,
-0.0277577993,
-0.014550345,
-0.0862558931,
-0.0249553546,
-0.020105131,
-0.0025789889,
0.0795945525,
0.0483644418,
-0.0967115834,
0.0664282665,
-0.0388668776,
0.0680764616,
0.0014053872,
0.0803532824,
-0.0505200736,
-0.0287474673,
-0.0036963248,
0.0089200512,
-0.0638349727,
-0.0156589709,
-0.0557979159,
-0.0177970696,
-0.0189721528,
0.0303070899,
-0.0277324934,
-0.0127195595,
0.0380111299,
-0.0102305794,
-0.0575457662,
-0.0424471162,
-0.0172991194,
0.0344192088,
-0.0049630026,
0.0290843155,
0.0137705943,
-0.0748811215,
-0.0367378332,
0.0529359877,
0.0365035459,
-0.0261845887,
-0.0175834429,
0.0777204931,
-0.0416950472,
-0.0646546036,
0.0052326177,
0.0282769725,
-0.0434273332,
-0.0377532132,
-0.0174071398,
-0.0408984497,
0.0394267738,
-0.0055421335,
-0.0018669261,
-0.0556426533,
-0.0008296471,
-0.0071067237,
-0.0154119488,
0.1023453623,
0.0055951076,
-0.0110910563,
0.0031154873,
-0.0093653994,
-0.0099609355,
0.0684251189,
-0.006311297,
0.028392721,
-0.0107764946,
0.0164075233,
0.0451300889,
0.0693462044,
0.0119424565,
0.0054254849,
-0.0716621727,
0.0013331955,
0.0470201522,
-0.0016782661,
0.0414075032,
0.0439425819,
-0.0242058299,
-0.0228875689,
0.0419425033,
-0.0063581048,
-0.0016103358,
-0.0175304879,
0.0747409165,
-0.0069265645,
-0.0200925544,
-0.0146172382,
-0.0606824942,
0.0233825333,
-0.0010077327,
0.0053487564,
-0.0066882535,
0.0303260218,
-0.0583969466,
-0.028506631,
0.0159768984,
-0.0191805791,
0.0060098213,
0.0283243749,
0.0482978001,
0.0170121994,
-0.0425359309,
0.0250921752,
0.0168864969,
-0.0279367547,
0.0235289242,
-0.0252947994,
0.0095415385,
0.0326483026,
-0.0314813927,
-0.0078691356,
-0.0200095065,
-0.009581144,
0.0598888136,
0.0560348481,
0.0199541487,
0.0162149146,
0.0519586578,
-0.0553817898,
-0.0588036962,
-0.0112455143,
-0.0099563729,
0.0414832979,
-0.0171127077,
0.0218315292,
0.0265703797,
0.0001812907,
-0.0418558158,
0.0441848263,
-0.0006797343,
-0.023044182,
-0.0102867438,
0.0347087421,
0.0058272299,
-0.026833076,
-0.0090549663,
-0.0013936326,
0.0231140591,
-0.0521405712,
0.0323603414,
0.03591175,
-0.0510673001,
-0.0352327488,
0.0290102027,
-0.0527017713,
-0.0100315157,
-0.0070081376,
-0.0210059099,
-0.0507597886,
-0.0178015437,
-0.0028626446,
0.03358531,
-0.0469203852,
0.0154204322,
0.0091791432,
0.0285661388,
-0.0087115206,
0.0176632274,
-0.0092650838,
-0.0038996788,
0.0522707142,
0.0055864216,
0.0021990477,
-0.0205263719,
-0.034544453,
-0.0100788856,
-0.0137838051,
0.0057944371,
0.0219517071,
0.0294560939,
-0.0286089294,
-0.0118769547,
-0.0627902374,
-0.0340244435,
-0.0590007231,
-0.0215512328,
-0.0188316647,
0.0219613668,
-0.0147953061,
-0.0799253434,
-0.0112316133,
0.0107968859,
0.0041298736,
0.0139741013,
0.0079179956,
0.0270556286,
0.0384496264,
-0.0130230933,
-0.00152464,
0.0448158942,
0.0537999123,
-0.0131273847,
-0.0368491523,
-0.0461819842,
0.0143498406,
0.0080140429,
0.0435277373,
-0.030707242,
-0.0023169655,
0.0065434766,
-0.0147999423,
0.0488622375,
0.0750664622,
-0.004495318,
0.0175861865,
0.0148233296,
0.0072889798,
-0.0478805341,
0.024505293,
-0.0116557833,
-0.0609666407,
-0.0265803598,
0.0511798821,
-0.0070058233,
0.043916028,
-0.0487089828,
0.0092628868,
-0.0844756737,
0.0140535599,
0.006711551,
-0.0499935113,
-0.0724473894,
0.002468297,
-0.0175650623,
0.0111052645,
-0.0391805656,
-0.0743890926,
0.0408598259,
-0.0580102317,
-0.0267046429,
-0.0068842033,
-0.0099880416,
-0.012259461,
0.0505078509,
0.0456736088,
0.0165603291,
0.0292076468,
-0.029276548,
-0.0683168173,
-0.0161359459,
-0.0031465972,
0.0096985465,
0.0801932737,
-0.013493753,
-0.001108564,
-0.0522166602,
-0.0256651435,
-0.0509137772,
-0.0217612144,
-0.0431993641,
0.0074100643,
-0.0466748551,
-0.0121522667,
-0.0532132797,
0.0362056457,
0.0332489312,
0.0610191524,
-0.0154380873,
0.0076282877,
-0.0312090442,
0.0209101066,
0.0500667617,
0.0559412278,
-0.0496064611,
-0.0282484964,
-0.0155580211,
0.011862319,
0.0191216692,
-0.0112281237,
-0.0439458489,
0.0179975759,
0.0542980991,
0.0222027991,
0.0324602947,
0.0379318446,
0.0680949315,
-0.0507955514,
-0.0057638171,
0.0567204617,
0.0073294276,
-0.0821778998,
-0.0536268689,
0.0277953371,
0.0242293011,
0.0370859243,
0.0292326566,
-0.0751961321,
-0.0670450255,
-0.0127002569,
-0.0161584113,
0.0446857996,
0.0262464117,
-0.0443780795,
-0.0955167189,
0.0040246551,
0.0046209041,
-0.0648643747,
-0.0524093322,
0.0029961136,
0.0121235512,
-0.0158264115,
0.0112344874,
-0.0159893185,
-0.0164638124,
-0.0079201255,
0.015331625,
0.0490419231,
-0.0334167182,
-0.0094342362,
-0.0414236002,
-0.0160709415,
0.0661628097,
-0.0195085872,
-0.0197610855,
-0.0703749508,
0.058132112,
-0.0110757751,
0.0120474016,
0.0247872099,
0.0243077781,
-0.0359998308,
-0.0350706764,
0.0624540672,
0.0449234471,
-0.010936548,
-0.0181104504,
-0.0016949154,
0.0488840789,
0.0067734164,
-0.0042737462,
-0.028968161,
-0.0108163133,
0.0077374866,
0.0414096676,
0.0158503167,
-0.0493330806,
0.0004188101,
-0.0223300308,
-0.002656996,
-0.0442951135,
-0.023971092,
0.0131170414,
0.0108424108,
-0.0365883298,
-0.0155163137,
-0.0375114642,
0.0388670787,
0.0484562479,
0.0017498716,
-0.0578990318,
-0.0058584479,
0.0149591425,
-0.0386650525,
0.0807954744,
-0.0455635302,
0.0286693983,
-0.0720471218,
0.0106409704,
0.0100577828,
-0.0457712114,
-0.0163432658,
0.026868837,
-0.0817227513,
-0.034006983,
-0.0216916967,
0.0677267462,
0.0102300495,
0.0908320844,
-0.0462724082,
-0.0319427252,
0.0549927242,
0.0509541854,
0.0412772968,
0.0176443756,
0.0244879443,
-0.0588426925,
-0.0214152057,
0.0172644183,
-0.0490730703,
0.0040353583,
0.0435631946,
-0.0191797018,
0.0040304894,
-0.0523343459,
0.0195494555,
-0.0245624017,
0.0720223859,
-0.0122222714,
0.0279878918,
-0.0312576294,
0.0159740318,
0.0334523059,
-0.0087219989,
-0.0646787956,
-0.0076132617,
0.0086270962,
0.0058856001,
0.0185426138,
0.0152323022,
0.0000532299,
0.0121766729,
-0.0603578687,
0.012385333,
0.0307898596,
0.0112476964,
0.021896895,
0.0308440626,
-0.0111095533,
0.0277177244,
-0.0027302122,
0.0396565571,
-0.0261156857,
0.0428947099,
0.0330094658,
0.0063934941,
-0.0072985929,
0.0519941747,
-0.0223788563,
-0.0394143462,
-0.0679407343,
0.0546484776,
0.0097001037,
-0.0224827435,
0.0030559169,
0.009789763,
-0.0063726194,
-0.0289813317,
0.0410432182,
0.0258931499,
-0.0559777543,
0.056283351,
0.0029731891,
-0.0116436956,
0.0078455722,
0.0650981963,
-0.0215352606,
0.0122224605,
0.0116082961,
0.0192871466,
-0.0241864212,
-0.0195167791,
0.0142555805,
-0.0004576025,
-0.0324934609,
0.0206840038,
0.0001269098,
-0.0375123769,
0.0132303061,
0.0171688106,
-0.0098431883,
0.059621606,
0.0468685888,
0.0208692309,
0.001304453,
-0.0030379971,
0.0103841154,
-0.0191473179,
0.0081199212,
-0.0014925287,
0.0197200831,
-5.880671303e-33,
-0.0469724387,
0.0138851712,
0.029788265,
-0.0211194754,
-0.0307938196,
0.0185022037,
-0.0271444079,
0.0173303839,
-0.0254688747,
0.0012126982,
-0.0005149018,
0.003821224,
0.032100834,
0.0634523183,
-0.0076879347,
-0.0059456499,
0.0568702295,
0.0206439048,
-0.0278181639,
0.0004501504,
0.0094269132,
0.021459952,
0.0620001182,
-0.0090119792,
0.0015472382,
0.0298424978,
-0.0193219259,
0.0089089507,
0.021197455,
0.0530015789,
0.0083292136,
0.0263202917,
-0.0153325107,
-0.0349753536,
-0.0344377346,
0.0393111818,
-0.0385013409,
-0.0144095179,
-0.0001763756,
0.0455939211,
-0.0739522874,
-0.018101301,
0.0358412787,
-0.0219983775,
0.0357337482,
-0.0276882965,
0.0536326282,
-0.0322623327,
-0.0276926253,
0.0102795828,
-0.0365467556,
0.0091568539,
0.0072969487,
-0.0354091413,
0.0527865775,
0.0765349865,
0.0213141106,
0.0148415454,
-0.0607903674,
0.0191556029,
0.0135957664,
0.0282988846,
0.0770899579,
0.0667981729,
-0.0231255814,
0.0324527025,
-0.0047100536,
-0.0718235672,
0.0191253033,
-0.0266586728,
0.0417664722,
0.0489019714,
0.0194358211,
0.0640752092,
0.0044270973,
-0.0059647579,
-0.0219820291,
0.0222856794,
-0.0104563804,
0.0405875742,
0.0092653511,
0.0099123148,
0.0373557657,
0.0044634761,
-0.0381540395,
-0.0374123901,
-0.0457537398,
-0.0183576364,
0.0415436327,
0.040757779,
-0.0082394714,
0.0552225523,
0.1053198949,
-0.0289673451,
0.0088484827,
0.0187747013,
-0.0115835285,
0.0176589731,
0.0100282356,
0.0449432507,
-0.0669435859,
0.0026989472,
0.0598006845,
0.0012710762,
-0.0041851923,
0.0196996704,
0.0746632963,
0.0330788344,
-0.0515597537,
-0.0076521751,
-0.0382409133,
0.0165549815,
-0.0030261723,
0.1060276777,
0.0480501056,
0.008222973,
-0.0546880886,
0.048704911,
-0.0340733379,
-0.0462542996,
-0.01898586,
0.0005769929,
0.0313132033,
0.0223097149,
-0.0338002332,
-0.0047817696,
-0.0380991586,
0.0092330277,
0.0188716315,
-0.0357925668,
0.0044821599,
0.0527291,
2.667e-7,
0.0186319314,
-0.0247769821,
0.0290469769,
-0.016052641,
-0.0030748926,
0.0375662073,
-0.0241554826,
0.0524838902,
0.0048804833,
-0.0098738112,
-0.0013554192,
0.0085960785,
0.0460548662,
-0.0173856337,
-0.0515897423,
0.0085649686,
-0.0348701328,
0.0097232666,
-0.0178039894,
-0.0331672989,
0.025384279,
0.1225503758,
-0.0295827463,
0.0102389148,
0.0491550267,
-0.0371378139,
0.0772256926,
-0.0347314551,
0.0077552497,
-0.0150972456,
-0.0329240598,
0.0368152596,
-0.0202866625,
0.0312496703,
-0.0180758666,
-0.0006208206,
0.0557016134,
0.031449616,
-0.0101615014,
-0.0244461,
-0.0355612002,
0.0746910274,
-0.0180888567,
-0.0652835146,
0.0728705227,
-0.0926560834,
0.0080344938,
-0.0594981834,
-0.0281763598,
0.0316844434,
0.019975571,
-0.0208622236,
-0.0238431897,
0.0351505056,
0.0578574613,
-0.0068551232,
-0.0570615195,
-0.0720202401,
-0.0359245464,
-0.0404693522,
-0.0163889006,
-0.0052760206,
-0.0801215693,
-0.0398198701,
0.0488090254,
-0.034497112,
-0.0258141197,
1.977517157e-34,
-0.0014781278,
-0.0021865598,
0.0136355944,
-0.0186981633,
-0.0138861826,
-0.027747497,
-0.0079173939,
0.0173251145,
-0.0052747834,
-0.0580678619,
-0.0287956763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01552v1 | The Unlocking Spell on Base LLMs: Rethinking Alignment via In-Context Learning | 2023-12-04T00:46:11 | 2023-12-04T00:46:11 | Bill Yuchen Lin, Abhilasha Ravichander, Ximing Lu, Nouha Dziri, Melanie Sclar, Khyathi Chandu, Chandra Bhagavatula, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The alignment tuning process of large language models (LLMs) typically
involves instruction learning through supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and
preference tuning via reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). A
recent study, LIMA (Zhou et al. 2023), shows that using merely 1K examples for
SFT can achieve significant alignment performance as well, suggesting that the
effect of alignment tuning might be "superficial." This raises questions about
how exactly the alignment tuning transforms a base LLM.
We analyze the effect of alignment tuning by examining the token distribution
shift between base LLMs and their aligned counterpart. Our findings reveal that
base LLMs and their alignment-tuned versions perform nearly identically in
decoding on the majority of token positions. Most distribution shifts occur
with stylistic tokens. These direct evidence strongly supports the Superficial
Alignment Hypothesis suggested by LIMA.
Based on these findings, we rethink the alignment of LLMs by posing the
research question: how effectively can we align base LLMs without SFT or RLHF?
To address this, we introduce a simple, tuning-free alignment method, URIAL.
URIAL achieves effective alignment purely through in-context learning (ICL)
with base LLMs, requiring as few as three constant stylistic examples and a
system prompt. We conduct a fine-grained and interpretable evaluation on a
diverse set of examples, named JUST-EVAL-INSTRUCT. Results demonstrate that
base LLMs with URIAL can match or even surpass the performance of LLMs aligned
with SFT or SFT+RLHF. We show that the gap between tuning-free and tuning-based
alignment methods can be significantly reduced through strategic prompting and
ICL. Our findings on the superficial nature of alignment tuning and results
with URIAL suggest that deeper analysis and theoretical understanding of
alignment is crucial to future LLM research. | [
0.039597515,
0.05603607,
-0.0228571407,
0.0207886454,
-0.0576671585,
0.0132586043,
-0.0337241814,
-0.0176857486,
-0.0633076206,
-0.0023453198,
-0.0711050183,
-0.020686714,
0.0327818878,
-0.0236669388,
0.0297539029,
0.0004802194,
0.0661384389,
-0.0434565805,
0.0047492078,
0.0089515569,
0.0203017443,
0.0176195465,
-0.0264610983,
0.0376367718,
0.0078729931,
-0.0273814499,
-0.05234164,
0.0479808971,
0.0150179984,
-0.0226047561,
-0.0096155005,
0.0561804809,
0.0140102599,
0.0672702268,
0.0000020974,
-0.0803350136,
-0.01814113,
-0.0158446953,
-0.0475627035,
0.0538299754,
0.006915288,
-0.0205363762,
-0.0390891209,
0.0080314828,
-0.0247891787,
0.0206905995,
0.0938494727,
0.0047651078,
0.0256136134,
0.0841192231,
0.0091502024,
-0.0304215066,
0.0286008287,
-0.0092727607,
-0.0022874232,
-0.0568110421,
0.0114775589,
-0.0347290039,
-0.019323362,
-0.0149847222,
-0.0386120006,
0.0306750219,
0.0032201721,
-0.0003146787,
-0.0005986888,
0.0191028826,
-0.056168139,
-0.0305472221,
-0.051049836,
0.0462117232,
-0.0004134933,
-0.030903399,
-0.0174725056,
-0.0078416793,
0.0368421599,
0.0034298722,
-0.019843841,
0.021059623,
0.0087022036,
0.0427802466,
0.0375467837,
-0.0044315653,
0.045838695,
-0.0215295497,
-0.0115571665,
0.0651197433,
0.019204488,
-0.0786969811,
-0.0187210608,
0.005948029,
-0.0066265962,
-0.050042931,
-0.0149607277,
-0.0041148071,
-0.0428029969,
0.0332494676,
-0.0538156033,
-0.0025263736,
0.0166766532,
-0.0059015439,
0.0246312078,
0.0815012902,
0.0050609792,
0.002866952,
-0.0057276227,
0.0824920386,
-0.0149807585,
0.0519968048,
-0.0441086069,
0.0402150489,
-0.0306790136,
-0.0444281511,
-0.019150611,
0.019299224,
-0.0174541455,
-0.0279902518,
-0.0518198684,
0.0414814353,
0.0414350331,
0.0334995426,
-0.0021817649,
-0.0337782763,
-0.0239218492,
0.0152540095,
-0.0045031183,
0.0205032974,
-0.0029827023,
0.014556773,
0.0126714297,
-0.0525568724,
-0.0225234739,
0.0068115909,
-0.0081703719,
-0.0334556811,
-0.0129431207,
0.0647971705,
-0.0373005606,
-0.0236724224,
0.0006829418,
0.0032576795,
-0.0369976088,
-0.0406106189,
-0.0341825671,
-0.0658263043,
0.0079716686,
0.0225563832,
-0.0135844974,
-0.0272440556,
-0.0020564871,
0.0188782401,
-0.0212671962,
0.0593917817,
0.021536937,
0.0384563245,
-0.0203315336,
-0.0313320048,
0.0019264186,
0.0559310764,
0.0238512233,
0.052062057,
0.0286228675,
-0.032239195,
-0.0011986801,
0.0738989115,
0.0143565405,
0.0179547928,
-0.0033449684,
-0.0188838169,
0.0514504462,
0.0545666069,
0.0527637303,
0.0325452797,
-0.0066922647,
0.0141778644,
0.0841392204,
0.0614525415,
0.0196325183,
0.0060018278,
-0.0018572736,
0.017662121,
0.0041563618,
0.0285612345,
-0.0746060386,
0.0097118877,
-0.0333455838,
0.060661193,
0.0307912435,
0.0337477066,
0.0046219002,
-0.0186523329,
-0.031279657,
0.0062823426,
-0.0164870769,
0.0043066009,
0.0321234763,
0.0077791675,
-0.0800312907,
0.0665430799,
0.0322419219,
-0.0236443747,
-0.0330586433,
-0.0373909771,
0.0200668275,
0.079720065,
0.0419504717,
0.0171928406,
-0.0074000065,
0.0284477677,
-0.0081908684,
0.0692311749,
0.0213718507,
0.0231386628,
0.0104235187,
-0.0560700558,
-0.0061155506,
-0.0107929632,
-0.0117571838,
0.0161408428,
-0.0133495601,
-0.019463405,
-0.0366203226,
-0.0384429879,
-0.013532172,
0.0383804999,
-0.0009213163,
-0.036903467,
-0.0516492054,
0.0372900926,
0.0163678452,
-0.0064883796,
-0.0256429203,
0.0206964668,
0.0137273548,
-0.0114582321,
0.0582402535,
0.0073274905,
-0.0906339064,
-0.0165637843,
0.0602647439,
0.0091959313,
-0.0262207966,
0.0099152643,
-0.0064385557,
-0.0238776132,
0.0186170693,
-0.0279775038,
0.0624867864,
-0.0024624635,
0.0759670585,
-0.0172571372,
-0.0205861125,
-0.0717509314,
0.0412512496,
-0.0185549147,
-0.0031893286,
-0.0030698997,
-0.0045806044,
-0.0068880562,
-0.0394698977,
-0.0019167212,
0.0099038398,
-0.0091922069,
0.0097195143,
0.0058014402,
0.0446711518,
-0.0186748859,
-0.0597948693,
-0.0604188256,
0.014509514,
-0.0187236592,
0.0257485174,
0.0422903374,
0.0127152614,
-0.0353273414,
0.0076951128,
-0.0324169211,
-0.0334778614,
-0.0223572906,
-0.0052835988,
0.0348604135,
0.0051094345,
-0.0879432186,
-0.0538385697,
-0.0145261651,
-0.021847358,
-0.0050885491,
-0.0129522635,
-0.0052795294,
-0.0622044466,
0.0240463559,
0.027208481,
-0.0188770685,
-0.0062315487,
-0.0622408204,
0.0209663697,
0.0012775781,
0.025325615,
0.0490648784,
-0.0200200658,
0.0135438833,
0.0330623016,
-0.0055555021,
-0.0686117411,
-0.0041700965,
0.0030326007,
-0.0630046725,
-0.0698828176,
-0.0305200741,
0.0277441256,
0.0710540339,
0.0228125416,
0.0257426184,
-0.0871703178,
0.0355462916,
0.0386795998,
-0.0444106162,
-0.0229118727,
-0.016922472,
-0.063300997,
0.0228929315,
-0.0500136167,
-0.090954721,
0.0636772215,
-0.0583301,
-0.0091104088,
-0.0405093133,
-0.003983506,
-0.0498948433,
0.0193393026,
-0.0297961142,
0.0320359133,
0.0020261076,
-0.0918966904,
-0.0550518408,
-0.00865517,
0.0062878714,
-0.0219929628,
0.0602006651,
-0.0275878403,
0.0094008418,
-0.0133341309,
-0.0455126353,
-0.0386552028,
-0.026184082,
-0.0209906735,
-0.0110597322,
0.0541134141,
-0.0280253273,
-0.015782157,
-0.0182980616,
0.0272975825,
0.0070526246,
-0.0126429796,
0.0121393483,
-0.0492175557,
-0.0194929261,
0.0334092639,
0.0092838984,
-0.0063049579,
-0.0345524587,
0.0158387348,
0.0133161964,
0.0309939981,
0.0099976612,
-0.0011080449,
0.010580468,
0.0768113509,
-0.0432156473,
-0.0104200989,
0.0418836288,
0.0730739012,
-0.0167493187,
-0.0242418572,
0.1236983463,
0.0383719616,
-0.0244808439,
0.0243255012,
-0.030077517,
0.0486991629,
0.0119989328,
0.0093716579,
-0.0700465664,
-0.0322829783,
0.0338786617,
0.0521582589,
0.017315248,
0.0218700655,
-0.0051093465,
-0.1298097968,
-0.0133451922,
0.0470125936,
-0.0626796335,
-0.027681144,
0.0131198997,
-0.0087174699,
-0.0085139824,
0.0687934384,
0.0628257021,
-0.0271339267,
-0.0044629881,
0.0258010942,
0.0128584048,
-0.0454822741,
-0.0113625601,
-0.060286466,
0.0608031973,
0.0832221061,
-0.0088670291,
-0.003374448,
-0.0840550363,
0.031862434,
0.0200652536,
0.0248185825,
-0.0069307652,
-0.0157697108,
-0.0104384068,
-0.0081827845,
-0.0350481458,
0.0444816202,
-0.0200485699,
-0.0204502586,
0.0078981044,
0.0503528602,
0.0053512673,
0.0425300375,
-0.0004188729,
-0.0212544929,
-0.0065622712,
0.0762095973,
0.0259238891,
-0.0519416556,
-0.0333227143,
-0.0286467411,
0.0021815221,
-0.0551158227,
-0.0296496227,
0.0194893014,
-0.0258415714,
0.0027000294,
-0.0592780337,
-0.0059233601,
0.0075036306,
0.041400101,
0.0337170959,
0.020859668,
-0.0149933333,
-0.0177087914,
-0.0021079225,
0.0077575771,
-0.0340233669,
0.0383970886,
-0.0975476727,
-0.0144562582,
-0.0271914676,
-0.0499603972,
0.016730411,
-0.008569262,
-0.0329641774,
-0.0932751969,
0.0127928182,
0.0197006948,
0.0258950256,
0.0430960096,
0.0027425927,
-0.0433367193,
0.0117884986,
0.0536472164,
-0.0094301887,
0.047130622,
0.014496183,
-0.0046368511,
0.0105007412,
0.0233354289,
-0.0396762639,
-0.0486364029,
0.0396958739,
0.0688698813,
-0.0234291703,
-0.0084479712,
0.0574798472,
0.0257497709,
0.0311438311,
-0.0423354879,
0.0019483378,
-0.0053664739,
0.0348749459,
-0.0112122204,
-0.0068170209,
0.0019581665,
-0.057812918,
0.0475529097,
0.0058190711,
0.0261630286,
-0.0225707591,
0.0021633534,
0.0365201868,
-0.0080245063,
0.0080013201,
-0.0163538679,
0.0462599434,
0.0439763628,
0.0373532549,
-0.0156552605,
0.0549680218,
-0.0189572293,
0.0422255062,
0.0074915513,
0.0451588891,
0.0262212008,
0.0184978265,
-0.0517664701,
0.033286877,
-0.0225279126,
-0.0202162638,
0.0088994792,
-0.017742645,
0.0749220252,
-0.0294261184,
0.0429201089,
-0.0258033648,
0.0048084795,
-0.0129633918,
0.0092166578,
-0.0154992817,
0.0025333166,
0.010209064,
0.0248107947,
-0.0391220711,
-0.02832672,
0.0369653143,
-0.0059359064,
0.0226837937,
-0.0429878868,
-0.0048683137,
-0.0206048973,
0.0007567583,
0.041615963,
0.0160583537,
-0.0484974906,
-0.0306019541,
-0.0732602328,
-0.0375510901,
-0.0161051452,
0.0294156745,
0.0144670345,
-0.0213253517,
0.0199187826,
0.0530896224,
-0.0220886469,
-0.0298381951,
-0.0220327936,
-0.0092238178,
0.0197663307,
-0.0437784716,
-0.0547251739,
-6.364956608e-33,
-0.0210794937,
0.0162581839,
0.0150817391,
-0.0010906757,
-0.0389723331,
-0.0223039351,
-0.0163492281,
0.0239105877,
0.0085167168,
-0.0306274295,
-0.0112327812,
-0.0476057902,
0.0136285415,
0.0146357529,
0.0372311138,
-0.0054949909,
0.0315566435,
0.0129795121,
-0.0522290431,
-0.0458193943,
0.0408558436,
0.014331406,
0.0525762662,
-0.0468288399,
0.0188543536,
-0.0243104585,
-0.0229644161,
0.0131502273,
-0.0397566929,
0.0740615502,
0.0072832503,
-0.0019146528,
-0.0029912374,
-0.0185730625,
-0.0295455977,
0.0438605696,
-0.0490651503,
-0.0067332499,
0.0945233032,
0.0379688628,
0.0136446217,
-0.0809785947,
0.0368297547,
-0.0182685982,
-0.0748976246,
0.0276772827,
0.0120064225,
-0.0207260121,
-0.027958706,
-0.0196816344,
-0.0765225291,
-0.0028829428,
-0.0210128129,
-0.0160698667,
-0.0018908303,
-0.0329955146,
-0.0048252465,
0.0350649953,
-0.0536398441,
0.035796158,
0.028058799,
0.0438096821,
0.0962409973,
0.0475265719,
0.0055940198,
0.05111368,
0.0107627111,
-0.02665204,
0.010858438,
0.0066556884,
0.0498724654,
0.0117970891,
0.0086855702,
0.0340291932,
0.0462513342,
-0.0007982803,
-0.0196575448,
-0.0065482766,
0.0171203669,
0.0358438753,
0.0387500674,
0.0727358386,
-0.0868555531,
-0.0130911423,
-0.0291897468,
0.0150500089,
-0.0342050605,
-0.0334035866,
0.0462453216,
-0.0112873092,
0.0046184263,
-0.0399317257,
0.0302387886,
-0.0165901557,
-0.0139366118,
0.0026668371,
-0.0164949596,
0.0314249545,
-0.0564487725,
-0.0098833563,
-0.0791320205,
-0.0322385021,
0.0215833224,
-0.0119316997,
0.0373577848,
0.0385430194,
0.0407193191,
0.017443154,
-0.06508255,
0.0124063715,
-0.0170545541,
0.0056370352,
0.0102436161,
-0.0461347364,
0.0732490346,
-0.0221074969,
-0.0098893652,
0.0217277799,
0.0306608882,
-0.0128667895,
-0.036082387,
-0.015123304,
-0.0222601872,
0.0090104211,
-0.0175311584,
0.0301624127,
-0.0219638739,
0.0151768178,
0.0142169306,
-0.0418563485,
-0.0190756414,
0.0379939489,
2.885e-7,
0.0374274105,
0.0450779274,
0.0751246214,
0.033298444,
0.0154657587,
0.0334642604,
-0.0498367921,
0.0156309232,
0.0227350816,
-0.0094004208,
0.0107659157,
-0.0016526685,
0.0546776094,
-0.021574771,
-0.0835500732,
0.0407732949,
-0.0589839146,
0.0470096581,
-0.0645975992,
0.0503614731,
0.022474952,
0.0819686204,
0.0152690662,
0.0019825648,
-0.0016906088,
-0.0206710864,
0.018506581,
-0.0306853764,
-0.0255320072,
0.0260672215,
-0.0162539799,
-0.0210352726,
-0.0079242475,
-0.0070856391,
0.0112279495,
0.0413805991,
-0.016304709,
0.0424330346,
-0.0038935938,
-0.0275353715,
-0.0082973642,
0.002318922,
-0.0168766826,
-0.0501107983,
0.0336420573,
-0.007397729,
-0.0318810418,
-0.0100665409,
-0.0036933385,
0.0226158965,
-0.0185987204,
0.0023270838,
-0.0031612951,
0.039235983,
0.0289142933,
0.0148284165,
-0.0249136854,
-0.0373657383,
-0.0412946828,
0.0276286453,
-0.0220651086,
-0.050241679,
-0.0261428449,
0.0308331884,
0.0066221869,
-0.0536129847,
-0.0213121586,
2.958715148e-34,
-0.0034859828,
-0.045733422,
0.0776457861,
0.0622882843,
0.0063936049,
0.0065299072,
-0.0044886023,
0.0591675229,
0.0517955311,
-0.0736384317,
-0.0175611768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01532v1 | Using Large Language Models to Accelerate Communication for Users with Severe Motor Impairments | 2023-12-03T23:12:49 | 2023-12-03T23:12:49 | Shanqing Cai, Subhashini Venugopalan, Katie Seaver, Xiang Xiao, Katrin Tomanek, Sri Jalasutram, Meredith Ringel Morris, Shaun Kane, Ajit Narayanan, Robert L. MacDonald, Emily Kornman, Daniel Vance, Blair Casey, Steve M. Gleason, Philip Q. Nelson, Michael P. Brenner | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | Finding ways to accelerate text input for individuals with profound motor
impairments has been a long-standing area of research. Closing the speed gap
for augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) devices such as
eye-tracking keyboards is important for improving the quality of life for such
individuals. Recent advances in neural networks of natural language pose new
opportunities for re-thinking strategies and user interfaces for enhanced
text-entry for AAC users. In this paper, we present SpeakFaster, consisting of
large language models (LLMs) and a co-designed user interface for text entry in
a highly-abbreviated form, allowing saving 57% more motor actions than
traditional predictive keyboards in offline simulation. A pilot study with 19
non-AAC participants typing on a mobile device by hand demonstrated gains in
motor savings in line with the offline simulation, while introducing relatively
small effects on overall typing speed. Lab and field testing on two eye-gaze
typing users with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) demonstrated text-entry
rates 29-60% faster than traditional baselines, due to significant saving of
expensive keystrokes achieved through phrase and word predictions from
context-aware LLMs. These findings provide a strong foundation for further
exploration of substantially-accelerated text communication for motor-impaired
users and demonstrate a direction for applying LLMs to text-based user
interfaces. | [
0.027188044,
0.0119057763,
-0.0180191938,
0.0034078602,
-0.006200213,
-0.0105340909,
0.0563513413,
0.0419709384,
0.0409745723,
-0.0153630432,
-0.008373105,
-0.0584052764,
0.0420764834,
0.0425643101,
0.0192457121,
-0.0465386845,
0.0341921151,
-0.0401361249,
-0.0136640845,
0.007197523,
0.0344912596,
-0.0084150517,
-0.0561865717,
0.0732390359,
0.0164014827,
-0.0220310055,
-0.0215345155,
-0.0031881048,
-0.0371912532,
-0.0083962409,
0.0044412739,
0.0563837253,
0.0238384232,
0.0501990803,
0.0000018516,
0.0192189831,
0.0888038352,
-0.0246483479,
-0.0265258402,
0.0327546559,
0.0319013484,
0.0004460927,
0.0173691977,
0.0517659634,
0.0059042587,
-0.0256853607,
0.0448002666,
0.0171506591,
-0.0053591714,
0.0220539551,
-0.0289487466,
0.0704480112,
0.0721572861,
-0.0254797991,
0.049365133,
-0.0224881452,
-0.0049904343,
-0.0527850948,
0.0186131522,
0.0013093627,
-0.0007422393,
0.0680017248,
0.010412395,
-0.0047133868,
0.0603620932,
0.0519015603,
0.0194893256,
-0.0140059898,
-0.0493686162,
0.0716251358,
-0.0095239067,
0.0015368103,
0.0146315536,
0.0016223307,
0.0051306561,
0.0471033566,
-0.0314723551,
-0.0122010643,
-0.0017663194,
-0.0317593068,
-0.0135717839,
-0.0111310817,
0.0308813136,
0.01342523,
0.0197744053,
-0.0173064824,
0.0109650493,
-0.0497554764,
0.016546933,
-0.0080110095,
0.0397926755,
-0.0477731749,
0.0779040381,
0.0207679085,
-0.0487010069,
-0.0076462328,
-0.0556861162,
-0.0713440999,
-0.0120261069,
-0.0668818727,
0.0918714702,
0.0534380414,
0.0096904943,
-0.0087984279,
-0.0107421782,
0.0280432776,
-0.0421508439,
-0.026512485,
0.0321191661,
0.0564616099,
-0.0211368427,
-0.0485427119,
-0.0106436592,
-0.0028297026,
-0.0516741909,
-0.0682043284,
-0.0369281098,
0.0709409863,
0.035599336,
-0.0375984497,
-0.0115196975,
0.0252105631,
0.0174713749,
-0.0097589204,
-0.0406480879,
0.012524195,
-0.0157439206,
0.0570766665,
0.0088765156,
-0.0603313148,
0.0186183378,
0.0028220608,
0.0050245738,
-0.0349148922,
0.0009542918,
0.0756758526,
-0.0081494423,
-0.0241873544,
-0.0219492894,
0.013357277,
-0.0344944485,
0.0168162193,
-0.0190679543,
-0.0514029264,
0.0239471439,
0.0352321938,
-0.0196678638,
-0.0638622865,
-0.0034805019,
0.0512975454,
-0.0041479999,
0.0279332697,
-0.0275985058,
0.0287814569,
0.0875822529,
-0.0232070088,
0.0056240149,
0.0013481998,
0.0405050926,
0.0409868732,
0.001163348,
-0.0305119716,
0.0461909287,
0.0981585383,
-0.0219366103,
-0.0037827417,
-0.060967911,
-0.0677154735,
-0.0008213005,
0.0674432814,
0.0030550624,
0.0470105,
0.0010752751,
0.0369457491,
0.1303592175,
0.087619625,
0.0427842475,
0.0285103749,
-0.0210560896,
-0.0216877665,
0.011863105,
-0.0560568944,
-0.01006852,
0.0356675945,
-0.0168683901,
0.0083473884,
0.0548994057,
0.027388202,
-0.0088702366,
-0.0452804491,
0.0018616524,
-0.0311717764,
0.0154117066,
0.0511806644,
0.0591927432,
-0.0387572087,
-0.0240553021,
-0.0328399837,
0.0028267459,
-0.0697630793,
-0.0200280398,
-0.0391051322,
-0.0626383051,
0.0875079259,
0.0455340035,
0.011155189,
-0.0105073284,
-0.0218266025,
-0.0264237598,
0.0655810237,
-0.018996438,
0.0273641907,
0.0022380992,
-0.0397005975,
0.0153895048,
0.0392237157,
-0.0203784872,
-0.0236639921,
-0.0256933607,
0.046204336,
0.000169436,
0.0196091775,
-0.0113633182,
0.0367314033,
-0.0562951975,
0.0085958652,
-0.0129746841,
0.003867097,
-0.0146836303,
0.0158833861,
-0.0303334557,
0.0078638056,
-0.0061623813,
-0.0511706807,
-0.0015953482,
0.0089580882,
-0.0461776629,
0.0165582746,
0.0159972645,
0.0111301951,
0.0157493781,
0.0440670662,
0.0701794401,
-0.0437959097,
-0.0380518101,
-0.0366756134,
0.0304836836,
-0.0387570374,
0.052482143,
-0.0036426287,
-0.0055094813,
-0.0146304537,
0.0332688093,
-0.0273714401,
0.0126604177,
0.0080345459,
-0.0339893512,
0.001152456,
-0.0682654306,
-0.0114065865,
0.0080709178,
-0.0495156534,
0.011353232,
0.0212894473,
-0.0206087157,
-0.00751686,
-0.0105018336,
-0.0767042935,
0.0031409557,
0.0014434623,
-0.011599577,
0.0111655751,
0.0403366089,
-0.0186375603,
-0.0140271625,
-0.0165815074,
0.0339217782,
-0.0051513859,
-0.0069947173,
-0.0039197057,
-0.0310636871,
-0.0093742944,
-0.0411096662,
-0.0243582968,
-0.0287026204,
0.0432319045,
0.0292434692,
-0.0717191473,
-0.0460463762,
0.0255397428,
0.0133330263,
0.0472260937,
0.0015902164,
-0.0117886961,
0.0273744129,
-0.0122111058,
0.0128517337,
0.0408386216,
0.0499974936,
-0.0037085642,
0.0526359342,
0.0128223207,
-0.0149060078,
-0.0005694036,
-0.0031695615,
0.0654305071,
-0.0275570285,
-0.0153449411,
0.0370166898,
0.0528487936,
0.0370415971,
0.0246921759,
-0.0394242406,
-0.024520658,
-0.0088865152,
-0.0382098369,
-0.0498878136,
-0.0122916671,
-0.0768788233,
-0.0171833318,
-0.0115413852,
-0.0743079036,
0.0278333947,
-0.0353749283,
-0.0186208375,
0.0228803158,
-0.0078547513,
0.006736225,
0.027122885,
0.011201594,
-0.0175793506,
-0.0372138396,
-0.0190092567,
0.0086594708,
0.0477924086,
-0.0216615498,
-0.0192609373,
0.0646284372,
-0.052090589,
0.012168414,
0.0058208867,
-0.0393582806,
-0.0234097093,
-0.0217306092,
-0.0418678559,
-0.040623799,
0.0221329574,
-0.0462850966,
-0.0383867882,
-0.0030303565,
0.0639652908,
0.1363225579,
-0.0113788089,
-0.0262181554,
-0.0180859715,
-0.0180601478,
0.0313595347,
-0.0001344358,
-0.0605008975,
-0.0443074927,
0.0146785844,
0.0250865407,
0.0485958196,
-0.0043494785,
-0.0313706361,
-0.0340023227,
0.0464661345,
-0.0235534925,
-0.0077496646,
0.0640138313,
0.0320667699,
-0.0344643705,
0.0243002456,
0.0801918209,
0.0346143954,
-0.0634455755,
0.0157917067,
-0.0104325777,
0.0320240743,
-0.0115873497,
0.0231959838,
-0.0643058196,
-0.0433535241,
0.0051143551,
0.0292204563,
0.0117870206,
-0.0003394255,
0.0094665075,
-0.0576711223,
-0.0257638972,
-0.0114427907,
-0.0254789479,
-0.0003456133,
-0.0063760839,
-0.0075283838,
0.0351751782,
0.0299033169,
0.031369973,
-0.0275521427,
0.0098391129,
-0.0021276867,
-0.0761217251,
-0.0187456086,
0.0027268005,
0.0104300659,
0.0640513748,
0.0451488122,
0.0021341888,
-0.0135315815,
-0.0259097349,
0.0264367573,
-0.04458417,
0.0421510451,
-0.0179070719,
0.0362754166,
-0.0047423989,
-0.0283245798,
-0.0660125986,
0.0560348034,
-0.0362755209,
-0.0189490486,
0.0352808274,
0.0128217619,
-0.0529106893,
0.0159678534,
-0.0193306282,
-0.0494058132,
0.0120752342,
0.0136309667,
0.0156034864,
-0.1090478748,
-0.0415641367,
-0.0299126878,
-0.0129766986,
-0.0166962743,
-0.0607833378,
-0.0235265922,
-0.0029325241,
-0.0388524123,
-0.0599718839,
-0.0151055846,
0.0362869129,
0.0230057202,
0.0128345648,
0.0613299906,
0.0599105582,
0.0231307,
0.0029929853,
0.010154143,
0.0242948718,
0.0381862968,
-0.0668498054,
0.0107884752,
-0.0313533135,
-0.0365469009,
0.0091301687,
-0.0129299425,
0.0023438376,
-0.0708297715,
0.0389968678,
0.0100054592,
0.0196272992,
0.0002766449,
-0.0096527683,
-0.0880407095,
0.0132333627,
0.04566627,
-0.0379822589,
0.0504168831,
-0.0060505704,
-0.0101548163,
0.0029677746,
-0.0073943804,
0.0091947941,
-0.0146443769,
-0.028954925,
0.0122207468,
-0.020915648,
-0.0294041764,
-0.0093115484,
0.0212008394,
0.0680492818,
-0.0075868671,
0.0001691161,
-0.0430399626,
0.0249939933,
-0.0213181358,
0.0427642241,
-0.0552576408,
-0.0120769916,
-0.0080599682,
0.0195012279,
0.0214511566,
-0.0048085973,
-0.0168687962,
-0.0253081694,
-0.0300183166,
0.0621297397,
-0.0441748314,
0.0542289838,
-0.0050494494,
-0.0175101031,
0.0026697211,
0.0444233492,
-0.0302130468,
0.010855508,
-0.0296077859,
0.0642184764,
0.0201452319,
-0.0467324667,
-0.0005572129,
0.0212559402,
-0.011709461,
-0.0368970893,
-0.0081137698,
0.0514350347,
-0.0115476605,
0.005764537,
-0.008000751,
-0.0167599376,
0.0302670989,
-0.0655168593,
0.0044803065,
-0.0011569742,
0.0028220376,
0.0115066394,
0.0026880435,
-0.0088924197,
-0.0383395106,
0.0378421098,
0.0176792331,
-0.0081949858,
0.0503668562,
-0.0380994529,
-0.0241806004,
-0.0285075475,
0.0328965932,
-0.0187468417,
-0.0560904257,
-0.0082090935,
-0.0296502002,
-0.009095028,
0.0361406095,
0.0064924574,
0.0196889713,
-0.0664634779,
0.0148479026,
-0.003539993,
-0.0057210494,
-0.015489541,
-0.0392584614,
-0.0040355572,
-0.0350902565,
-0.0379885957,
-0.0281007588,
-5.337119409e-33,
0.0192258377,
-0.0411284156,
0.016510753,
-0.0114102867,
-0.0428953916,
0.0233981237,
-0.0288369637,
0.040274594,
-0.0197681822,
-0.0199640766,
-0.0551093258,
0.0246986691,
0.0203921795,
0.0377222747,
0.009452994,
-0.0069565009,
0.0025308426,
-0.0121909622,
-0.0218821596,
-0.0000086819,
0.0287357774,
0.0251332074,
0.0210038666,
-0.0199336354,
0.046065297,
-0.0094120791,
0.0351798646,
-0.0514258221,
0.02889226,
0.0127765574,
-0.0556512736,
0.0486892872,
0.0290892199,
0.0016701163,
0.0189158265,
0.0917708725,
0.0165842548,
0.0069408217,
-0.0134717152,
0.0045957863,
-0.049203258,
-0.0122146532,
0.0797528028,
0.0012255239,
-0.0502214655,
0.021732159,
0.0434396826,
-0.0420407206,
-0.0704132617,
0.0180521682,
-0.0418605842,
0.0114175482,
-0.0037064238,
-0.0056634448,
0.0089779338,
0.0031560911,
-0.0209694616,
-0.0536484122,
-0.0402955711,
0.0219165459,
0.0192931276,
0.0317554288,
0.0267861858,
0.0252316985,
0.0438128598,
0.040786285,
0.0174795594,
-0.0000610291,
-0.0732629821,
-0.012470575,
0.0558699779,
-0.0105409371,
0.0577514842,
0.0356271565,
0.0429661237,
-0.0450538658,
-0.0362192094,
0.0221555382,
0.0327984542,
0.03646053,
0.0297575705,
0.0046290038,
-0.0527537018,
-0.0028716954,
-0.033346761,
0.1101855487,
-0.0271629971,
-0.0288094636,
0.0476793498,
-0.0291159078,
0.0568573736,
-0.0491109602,
0.0257619377,
-0.0104234572,
-0.0136226825,
-0.0099636288,
0.0321104266,
0.0827145427,
0.0133258905,
-0.0372417234,
-0.045930773,
0.0068730395,
-0.0089690955,
0.0378617123,
0.0431140289,
0.0151849091,
-0.0401366763,
-0.0110051949,
-0.0500765778,
-0.0038537795,
-0.0126131875,
-0.0291313659,
0.0446895286,
0.0169416219,
0.071298033,
-0.0545634516,
-0.0376529656,
0.070412837,
-0.0601937547,
-0.0451621898,
-0.0422830321,
-0.0389734209,
0.009973079,
0.0303165503,
-0.0275774151,
0.0205490757,
-0.0560117587,
0.0573487878,
0.028914053,
-0.0607325211,
0.0027925321,
-0.0139748268,
2.478e-7,
0.0229995418,
0.0714172274,
-0.0087316092,
0.0249070264,
-0.0104569979,
0.0364021882,
0.0040124846,
0.0237862989,
-0.0199159272,
0.0169226397,
0.0162981898,
0.0481406599,
0.0430964343,
-0.0583906285,
-0.0278212056,
-0.0012913783,
-0.0536196642,
0.0515684113,
-0.0355882049,
0.0272831917,
0.0006933288,
0.016786553,
-0.021244809,
-0.0177656543,
0.0501964577,
-0.053402435,
0.0443946794,
-0.0378112271,
0.0139323426,
-0.0456752963,
0.0663838834,
-0.0252167322,
-0.0311811268,
0.009466066,
-0.018026311,
-0.0099769086,
0.0099279433,
0.0132210422,
-0.0633734614,
0.0312540308,
0.0417062379,
-0.0128105758,
-0.0210953541,
-0.0190678481,
0.0513886288,
-0.0035506492,
-0.0052395943,
0.0057512857,
0.0185329858,
0.0146459602,
0.0314375125,
-0.0274479743,
0.0192885976,
-0.0406036936,
0.0037451403,
-0.0089031123,
-0.0029701956,
-0.0383714028,
-0.030246757,
0.0416308269,
-0.0295019932,
-0.0173328351,
-0.1237847432,
-0.0064279586,
0.0155616235,
-0.0757948235,
0.0025635217,
1.99558625e-34,
-0.0094521064,
0.0312093478,
0.0241189003,
0.0290256552,
-0.0122706154,
-0.0102485474,
0.0678105876,
0.0475857109,
0.014271873,
-0.0819675028,
-0.0248057395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01529v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01529v2 | T3D: Towards 3D Medical Image Understanding through Vision-Language Pre-training | 2023-12-03T23:03:22 | 2023-12-05T09:01:07 | Che Liu, Cheng Ouyang, Yinda Chen, Cesar César Quilodrán-Casas, Lei Ma, Jie Fu, Yike Guo, Anand Shah, Wenjia Bai, Rossella Arcucci | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.IV | Expert annotation of 3D medical image for downstream analysis is
resource-intensive, posing challenges in clinical applications. Visual
self-supervised learning (vSSL), though effective for learning visual
invariance, neglects the incorporation of domain knowledge from medicine. To
incorporate medical knowledge into visual representation learning,
vision-language pre-training (VLP) has shown promising results in 2D image.
However, existing VLP approaches become generally impractical when applied to
high-resolution 3D medical images due to GPU hardware constraints and the
potential loss of critical details caused by downsampling, which is the
intuitive solution to hardware constraints. To address the above limitations,
we introduce T3D, the first VLP framework designed for high-resolution 3D
medical images. T3D incorporates two text-informed pretext tasks:
(\lowerromannumeral{1}) text-informed contrastive learning;
(\lowerromannumeral{2}) text-informed image restoration. These tasks focus on
learning 3D visual representations from high-resolution 3D medical images and
integrating clinical knowledge from radiology reports, without distorting
information through forced alignment of downsampled volumes with detailed
anatomical text. Trained on a newly curated large-scale dataset of 3D medical
images and radiology reports, T3D significantly outperforms current vSSL
methods in tasks like organ and tumor segmentation, as well as disease
classification. This underlines T3D's potential in representation learning for
3D medical image analysis. All data and code will be available upon acceptance. | [
0.0179775711,
0.0516145267,
0.0368024334,
0.0097758314,
-0.0025547054,
0.0237857867,
0.0005067374,
0.0068320432,
-0.0180070139,
0.0015286518,
-0.0297803432,
-0.0152987037,
0.01771193,
0.0867812335,
0.0219457727,
-0.1048031524,
-0.0191692449,
-0.0001399238,
0.0278871916,
-0.0131379878,
0.0048355674,
-0.0035261414,
-0.0205618124,
-0.0215486847,
0.0001708023,
-0.0133516127,
0.016522577,
0.034873724,
0.007997104,
-0.029173566,
-0.0037233855,
0.0632031485,
0.0575897321,
-0.0707007125,
0.0000025246,
-0.0365622714,
-0.0364251211,
0.0035474689,
0.0024058202,
0.0063894708,
0.029688539,
-0.0639025047,
-0.0324225947,
-0.0589836836,
-0.0634324104,
-0.0155500919,
0.0171823204,
0.0973935053,
0.089475587,
0.0216397159,
-0.0270849671,
-0.0059305364,
0.0082337642,
-0.0215735398,
0.0507587828,
0.0062034032,
0.0071494132,
0.0600006878,
-0.0226763412,
0.018391721,
0.0261618868,
0.0517109446,
0.0265132766,
0.0104700169,
0.049351383,
0.0382008217,
0.0143265519,
-0.0464032888,
-0.0411033854,
0.0397907794,
-0.0262954552,
-0.0024434042,
-0.0145072527,
-0.0192161165,
-0.0085205436,
-0.0332181416,
-0.0080044186,
-0.0106682507,
0.0146556711,
-0.0230439529,
-0.0538934283,
0.0165836886,
0.0128826834,
-0.029928552,
-0.0336576737,
-0.0260653645,
0.0083490983,
0.052342277,
-0.0107911099,
0.024471309,
0.0032887391,
-0.0023347777,
0.0085980846,
0.001743463,
0.0047381478,
-0.0280933492,
-0.0442112945,
-0.0335447416,
0.0413958766,
-0.0528428406,
0.0078149922,
-0.006205033,
-0.0444809385,
0.0563790724,
-0.0523612723,
0.0164593365,
-0.0587100163,
0.0531964526,
-0.0439580642,
0.0392410569,
0.0526109897,
-0.0085722385,
-0.0368448608,
0.0072067617,
-0.0329449661,
0.0105948215,
-0.0103613427,
-0.0101288613,
-0.003547207,
-0.0201344658,
-0.005520808,
0.0977946669,
-0.0465090238,
-0.0400867276,
-0.0184644368,
0.0469816811,
0.0235225465,
0.0163921546,
-0.0726180524,
-0.0263744611,
0.0126050059,
0.0244832728,
0.0154773453,
0.0119470377,
0.0249404814,
0.0853784531,
-0.0418534651,
-0.013685368,
0.0229446273,
-0.0199711099,
-0.021377977,
-0.012377223,
0.0478773266,
-0.0645846874,
-0.0131362444,
-0.0091299983,
0.0305109359,
-0.0470697246,
0.0079290392,
-0.0054375823,
0.0125881555,
0.0825814307,
-0.0774294287,
-0.0528311431,
0.054700613,
0.0343428589,
0.0363298133,
-0.0115647363,
0.0272530578,
0.0001270219,
-0.0603843816,
-0.0234969668,
0.0092853317,
-0.003575939,
0.0277103037,
-0.0192385931,
-0.0884110555,
0.0023420583,
0.0166300498,
0.0860961452,
0.0239904374,
0.0445104539,
-0.00429872,
-0.0767353177,
0.0303520262,
0.0334157161,
-0.0065307771,
0.0166305266,
0.0256814566,
-0.0060144998,
0.0129022812,
0.0003198627,
0.0140977819,
0.0386651419,
0.0623067431,
-0.015615602,
-0.0347471498,
0.0341752581,
-0.0397825278,
-0.0852785558,
0.014658751,
-0.0246301331,
-0.0110959383,
-0.0221026689,
0.0718403682,
0.0316093303,
-0.0058874902,
-0.0045987684,
0.0334716216,
-0.027169127,
-0.0507414341,
-0.0191491749,
-0.0234863423,
0.0546632186,
0.009694037,
-0.0404203162,
-0.0618801974,
-0.00480239,
0.020573277,
0.0180251617,
0.0120280869,
0.031513676,
0.0610790253,
-0.0400341861,
-0.0271917786,
0.0173812006,
-0.006009059,
0.0047387769,
0.0011951413,
-0.0489346869,
-0.0316916667,
-0.0374506861,
0.009118326,
0.045403149,
-0.0429912433,
-0.0297167208,
0.0013301661,
0.0249063689,
0.0027904359,
-0.0141279902,
-0.0217506364,
-0.0575314015,
0.0274947751,
-0.0358856693,
-0.0203255881,
-0.0119485576,
-0.0969564989,
-0.032767266,
0.0217086356,
-0.0273052547,
-0.0282348059,
-0.0221734047,
0.0018985735,
-0.0044691912,
-0.0081565892,
-0.0122189075,
-0.0190759357,
-0.0097388132,
-0.0128984535,
0.0564619303,
0.0191425439,
-0.0551122092,
0.02815919,
-0.0382796973,
-0.0377680585,
-0.0091495318,
-0.0256901942,
0.0208483916,
0.030054111,
-0.0043628691,
-0.0447686985,
-0.017844636,
0.0198272821,
0.016663678,
0.0474604219,
-0.027013367,
0.0377664901,
-0.0147005124,
-0.0030165575,
0.0118693942,
-0.0151031911,
0.0429166928,
0.0367976315,
-0.0167145245,
-0.0705186501,
-0.0023006117,
0.0125165191,
0.0168761015,
-0.0303057153,
0.0934139565,
0.0164909549,
0.0524450801,
0.0012965322,
0.0204576049,
-0.0004560731,
0.0061766324,
0.0648591593,
-0.0826585963,
0.0342484415,
0.0221668258,
-0.0494881496,
0.0556803718,
-0.0066655884,
-0.0182826445,
0.0144307166,
-0.0335254073,
-0.0079380115,
0.0799325705,
-0.0381015465,
0.0208482239,
-0.0024044882,
0.0190149527,
0.018128505,
0.001148446,
-0.02905933,
-0.0103974594,
0.0021842241,
-0.0096117025,
-0.0180120394,
0.0819132403,
-0.0018315068,
0.0253254995,
-0.0309783258,
-0.0160958208,
0.0165809765,
-0.0165987909,
-0.0183750745,
0.0346756242,
-0.0351208486,
0.0294634867,
-0.0150249014,
-0.0507657677,
0.0659202188,
-0.0143246073,
0.0129031325,
-0.0211708583,
-0.0124165565,
-0.0245142542,
0.0227973554,
0.0204598233,
0.0497140922,
-0.0121333469,
-0.0216178242,
-0.018608354,
0.0376099311,
0.0047733732,
-0.0213895012,
-0.0017353257,
-0.0191062577,
0.0337325782,
0.0030437398,
-0.0576916151,
-0.0065367431,
-0.0190481395,
-0.0148367817,
-0.0066517112,
-0.0499578118,
0.0254239179,
-0.0502186716,
0.0129284011,
-0.005801769,
0.0793106556,
-0.0058586188,
-0.0511502661,
-0.0254008174,
0.0478806607,
-0.0340750851,
0.0337206721,
-0.028845286,
-0.0130439382,
0.0048559103,
0.0821382925,
-0.0027554098,
-0.0068719122,
-0.0905016214,
0.0359790549,
-0.0100379055,
0.0282644928,
0.0259457808,
0.0214714371,
-0.0052067768,
-0.0643529668,
0.0093741603,
0.0429151617,
0.0120642204,
-0.0615186915,
-0.0355125144,
0.0189860091,
-0.0133327246,
0.0072157802,
-0.0130270682,
-0.0831160471,
-0.0356866792,
-0.044323612,
-0.0300078467,
0.0344045796,
-0.0147899492,
-0.0042358702,
0.006815129,
0.0675460994,
0.0113559971,
-0.0214639381,
-0.044747375,
-0.0522933416,
0.0316615514,
-0.0365081578,
-0.0381476134,
-0.0334807746,
-0.0379265621,
-0.0092605855,
0.0025468387,
0.0115697263,
-0.0484287739,
0.0044234572,
-0.0136496816,
-0.0429006144,
0.0390650555,
0.0246304534,
-0.0508573577,
-0.0529715307,
0.0036654212,
0.049650427,
0.0140384445,
-0.0184176173,
0.0928077325,
-0.0054822722,
-0.0066149873,
-0.018458534,
0.0404845588,
-0.0073652766,
-0.0035988162,
-0.0394984372,
0.0313962437,
-0.0378410555,
0.0154786333,
-0.0428029224,
0.0259405598,
0.0127459439,
-0.0153623577,
-0.0400888771,
-0.0149462111,
-0.0241256859,
-0.0103681004,
0.0767475516,
0.0335540883,
-0.0419513434,
0.0126472963,
0.0026715542,
-0.0237975568,
-0.0151697602,
0.0125014037,
0.0315959528,
0.0406616442,
0.0098198978,
-0.0102410149,
-0.0031518233,
-0.014078361,
-0.0975636467,
0.0367031991,
-0.0274064299,
-0.0368825868,
0.0007492426,
-0.010328806,
0.035870634,
-0.068849653,
-0.013363448,
-0.0179392174,
-0.0091600958,
0.0205792803,
-0.0190830249,
0.0945969895,
0.0032437616,
0.0642748624,
0.003932416,
0.0024873998,
0.0788877606,
0.0498152003,
-0.0595497042,
-0.0019869516,
0.0132300938,
-0.0461453572,
-0.0278093033,
-0.0202174019,
0.0393377356,
0.0567753203,
-0.0046960036,
-0.0554860309,
-0.0037905916,
-0.0469710492,
0.0128417918,
0.0094298674,
0.0857705176,
-0.0028243843,
0.0500016622,
-0.0105266683,
0.0247403625,
-0.0006657359,
0.01341624,
-0.0565096699,
0.0253637545,
0.009953917,
0.0194139704,
-0.0005485713,
0.0054654996,
0.0074429112,
-0.0591947734,
-0.0395667367,
0.0172790792,
0.0205951277,
-0.0225068368,
0.0166520197,
-0.0061493595,
0.0159698222,
0.0332086161,
-0.0075960467,
0.0191638004,
0.0195163451,
0.0135261379,
0.0127087729,
0.0444927812,
-0.0295207985,
0.065715611,
-0.0128770908,
-0.0383137688,
-0.064055495,
-0.0038910299,
0.0358911417,
-0.0180039853,
0.0378189683,
-0.005462721,
0.0134195127,
-0.0041371486,
0.0304702464,
-0.0309455693,
0.0113979885,
0.0294318628,
-0.0328039378,
0.0072369585,
0.0164894145,
0.0410108231,
0.0202973764,
0.0042107943,
0.0403593443,
-0.0102067813,
-0.0726598874,
-0.0208349787,
-0.0095290989,
-0.0023289025,
-0.0101017579,
0.034743499,
0.0039743776,
-0.0371457189,
0.0048207543,
0.0117546516,
-0.045271948,
-0.0095449528,
0.0789989531,
0.0693895146,
-0.0169297867,
-0.0193339679,
0.015302211,
0.0255646147,
-0.0210473612,
-0.0186068192,
0.0655597001,
-6.495252076e-33,
0.0082166577,
-0.0189854428,
0.0601232946,
-0.0512278825,
0.0252033789,
0.0333284587,
-0.0348350815,
0.0145505257,
0.0089249508,
0.050084956,
-0.0010401323,
-0.0345805958,
-0.0011583968,
0.0433618873,
-0.0010402191,
0.0057330611,
0.019901732,
-0.0159720443,
0.0092202956,
0.0387089774,
-0.0299798939,
0.0294625089,
0.082821615,
-0.0941690728,
-0.0641392097,
0.0192421563,
-0.0089451699,
-0.0105169099,
0.0182739068,
-0.0007144127,
-0.0465473756,
-0.0246183816,
0.0249366444,
-0.0496218093,
-0.0340502188,
-0.022380814,
-0.1000708863,
-0.0270942617,
-0.0152512053,
0.017084498,
-0.1124953702,
0.0261077303,
0.0347471274,
-0.0239576306,
-0.006057607,
-0.0317903347,
0.0470689833,
0.0018746041,
0.010342137,
-0.0384830944,
-0.0108543513,
0.0720939711,
-0.0211325586,
-0.0416068807,
0.0691714287,
-0.043189317,
0.0118517531,
0.0301273502,
-0.0137829846,
-0.007943321,
-0.0063878316,
0.0139981499,
0.0335086472,
-0.0149995061,
-0.0256714728,
0.0582966618,
0.0397421941,
-0.049018532,
-0.0147641292,
0.0117402077,
-0.0024520799,
0.0292887241,
0.02894146,
0.0468802489,
0.028227374,
0.0075124404,
-0.0849172547,
0.0508616343,
-0.148847729,
0.0375960879,
-0.0143215954,
-0.0317924581,
-0.0145132216,
-0.0158993881,
0.0327625498,
-0.0471400283,
0.0178529657,
0.0035880192,
0.0163517669,
-0.0018768136,
0.0030567688,
0.0482803993,
0.0182474479,
0.0341078304,
0.0073405132,
0.0119004399,
0.0045459229,
0.0242702644,
-0.0367909409,
0.0030534088,
-0.0478827879,
0.0123309251,
-0.0005680507,
0.0041782786,
0.0356140882,
-0.0073560476,
-0.0007272485,
0.003045219,
-0.0402183682,
-0.0160335917,
-0.010505897,
-0.0225642752,
0.017580824,
0.0946092382,
0.0583727621,
0.0135265393,
-0.0234848261,
0.0532059185,
-0.0385518819,
-0.0323217995,
-0.0514882915,
-0.0127164163,
-0.0292673595,
0.0118397148,
-0.026054455,
-0.0198930502,
-0.0584581345,
-0.0091454601,
0.0400325954,
-0.0847948417,
-0.0279994011,
0.012930979,
3.067e-7,
0.065568462,
0.078399837,
0.0485153906,
-0.0719636232,
-0.0150044644,
0.0535560213,
0.0118241832,
0.0151027441,
-0.0284732468,
-0.0341353789,
0.0556647144,
0.0672465414,
-0.0366477966,
0.0330336988,
-0.0456807017,
0.0634100884,
-0.0379747711,
0.0017743628,
0.0042979801,
-0.0062581268,
0.0423140116,
0.033287216,
-0.0362974517,
-0.0701559186,
0.061780367,
-0.0006664733,
0.0373325199,
-0.0380979367,
0.0407368019,
0.0365980789,
0.0160203651,
0.0499970391,
-0.0138914352,
0.034554027,
0.0143082887,
-0.0112334751,
0.0053078905,
0.0568091497,
-0.0390072837,
0.0440495983,
0.0372150242,
0.0431822203,
0.0186882932,
-0.0129408296,
0.0432736166,
-0.0321168564,
-0.0103010349,
-0.0260087736,
-0.0028898281,
0.0069877994,
0.0871878639,
-0.0092151854,
-0.020008469,
0.042630095,
0.0325378962,
0.0168295521,
-0.0856075883,
-0.0483371243,
-0.0371640287,
0.0192691255,
-0.0024306141,
0.0375135094,
-0.0123434803,
-0.0319801793,
0.0159989875,
-0.0228527971,
-0.0151300728,
2.4759837e-34,
0.0046512,
0.0052865283,
0.0004336709,
0.0028935336,
-0.0146990279,
0.0106685618,
0.0416679047,
-0.0035396393,
-0.0146188783,
-0.0090324106,
0.0297675747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01523v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01523v2 | SymNoise: Advancing Language Model Fine-tuning with Symmetric Noise | 2023-12-03T22:44:58 | 2023-12-08T17:28:48 | Abhay Kumar Yadav, Arjun Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce a novel fine-tuning technique for language
models, which involves incorporating symmetric noise into the embedding
process. This method aims to enhance the model's function by more stringently
regulating its local curvature, demonstrating superior performance over the
current method, NEFTune. When fine-tuning the LLaMA-2-7B model using Alpaca,
standard techniques yield a 29.79% score on AlpacaEval. However, our approach,
SymNoise, increases this score significantly to 69.04%, using symmetric noisy
embeddings. This is a 6.7% improvement over the state-of-the-art method,
NEFTune~(64.69%). Furthermore, when tested on various models and stronger
baseline instruction datasets, such as Evol-Instruct, ShareGPT, OpenPlatypus,
SymNoise consistently outperforms NEFTune. The current literature, including
NEFTune, has underscored the importance of more in-depth research into the
application of noise-based strategies in the fine-tuning of language models.
Our approach, SymNoise, is another significant step towards this direction,
showing notable improvement over the existing state-of-the-art method. | [
-0.0074350941,
0.0448722132,
-0.0185625348,
0.0761627108,
0.0038424742,
-0.0100192782,
-0.0276089907,
-0.0214276798,
-0.039900668,
-0.0242650714,
-0.0293643288,
-0.0310238954,
0.0149510708,
0.0091045704,
0.0835679099,
-0.0314449109,
0.0614399053,
-0.0541970432,
-0.0098812906,
-0.0086351475,
-0.0173292551,
-0.0053580059,
0.051377859,
0.0577403866,
0.0382072292,
-0.0070140986,
-0.0260352381,
0.0396045558,
0.0083637536,
-0.0091540758,
-0.0250768308,
0.0377318114,
0.0183641035,
0.0426076017,
0.0000022768,
-0.0098851286,
0.018664185,
0.0256146695,
0.0014039412,
0.0945810378,
0.0657220334,
0.0019912466,
-0.0563819557,
0.0155236237,
0.0130843185,
-0.0020888876,
0.0654319823,
-0.038880527,
0.0687752813,
0.0354739428,
-0.0027180626,
-0.0419559479,
0.0035209048,
-0.0289496593,
-0.0051923613,
-0.0047842823,
-0.0074064871,
-0.0354287811,
-0.0008710396,
0.0334842876,
-0.0286585335,
0.0319948122,
-0.008723041,
-0.015389422,
-0.0085125351,
0.0246000327,
-0.0155430669,
-0.0250507835,
-0.0080000805,
0.0753779635,
-0.0553229563,
-0.0271636248,
-0.0155771114,
0.0082934294,
-0.0096850544,
-0.0281428061,
-0.0370800011,
-0.0125061385,
0.0251303539,
0.0289798789,
0.0608605891,
-0.0462376662,
0.039493233,
-0.0526204444,
-0.0150686931,
0.0318840072,
0.0469261073,
-0.037046887,
-0.0291434601,
-0.024949532,
-0.0150038796,
-0.0209883507,
0.002421631,
0.0266519394,
-0.0003180938,
0.0189681519,
-0.0577975027,
-0.0266493056,
0.0195855442,
-0.0828009322,
0.0752132609,
0.0784444734,
-0.0127298208,
0.0280810017,
-0.0631142184,
0.0213341825,
-0.004940643,
0.0190058723,
-0.0361710712,
0.0563512072,
0.0129312482,
-0.0034820698,
-0.0430838726,
-0.0009058834,
-0.0498057716,
-0.0019177068,
-0.0142504266,
0.0504939184,
0.0195617229,
0.0088977888,
0.0301314145,
-0.0306193307,
-0.0166763999,
0.0341289639,
0.0273747072,
0.0016747431,
-0.0330634192,
-0.0190323517,
-0.0262765326,
-0.0310938936,
-0.015425927,
0.0053766584,
-0.0392154865,
0.0091073969,
0.0265012141,
0.0813498423,
0.0260526668,
-0.0234873816,
-0.036303442,
-0.0090839826,
0.0028955247,
-0.0326853245,
0.0161818322,
-0.0615085252,
-0.0215608664,
0.0009358884,
0.0008731924,
-0.0132858837,
0.0073515777,
0.0065417932,
-0.0389171541,
0.0587858818,
-0.0306904987,
0.0092820693,
0.0034196801,
0.0016043861,
0.046300251,
0.0683354288,
0.0487420708,
0.000633376,
0.0347745903,
-0.0309718344,
-0.0458491333,
0.0333129391,
0.0232330952,
0.0256931577,
-0.0189353395,
-0.0178615227,
-0.0028832862,
0.0067099645,
0.0646643639,
0.0665457249,
-0.0082380027,
-0.0487729684,
0.0424514376,
0.0435291044,
0.0257309675,
0.0267134309,
0.0321386382,
-0.0054710307,
0.0017845164,
-0.0056689382,
-0.030320406,
0.018692486,
-0.0330116376,
0.0498863831,
0.0303257648,
0.0794020891,
-0.0197264664,
-0.0492934994,
-0.0293210503,
-0.0261680391,
0.0081608268,
-0.0068470952,
0.0385588109,
-0.0137899267,
-0.0746368319,
0.0677784607,
0.0488622375,
-0.0483980253,
-0.0372976698,
-0.082104139,
0.0418729074,
0.0427300483,
0.032341253,
-0.013360044,
-0.0428335406,
0.0009672368,
-0.0203754809,
0.0433625132,
0.0314201042,
0.0208530705,
0.0011479384,
-0.0705955029,
-0.0163107459,
0.006004638,
0.02758874,
0.0373308994,
-0.0138882836,
-0.0212921612,
0.0178938787,
-0.0403488614,
-0.0298105143,
0.0294144005,
-0.0141279297,
-0.0165971201,
-0.0258169677,
0.0002578947,
-0.0020342846,
0.0233960226,
-0.0285522193,
0.0193078816,
0.0533861704,
-0.014491057,
0.0467065237,
-0.0037580237,
-0.0535557382,
-0.0208795555,
0.0713817775,
0.0048479466,
0.0295056142,
-0.0031090188,
-0.0161282178,
-0.023110535,
0.0614243038,
-0.0361894928,
0.0423083678,
-0.0201689098,
0.0486358367,
-0.0446817279,
0.0321880989,
-0.0557481311,
0.0193753634,
-0.0336677134,
0.0154258935,
0.0352949277,
0.0112736421,
0.0190151297,
-0.0230394024,
-0.0714062005,
0.0125530725,
0.0067076646,
0.0367871299,
-0.0345643833,
0.0398264267,
0.0189514812,
-0.070093289,
-0.0603544675,
-0.0212513413,
-0.0215330906,
0.0164155681,
0.0353088081,
-0.001567702,
-0.0053822291,
0.0114689497,
0.0113159986,
0.018283084,
-0.0400623158,
0.0132618397,
0.0159590058,
-0.0302874129,
-0.1035298929,
-0.0408079065,
-0.0321585014,
-0.0192187745,
0.0159262493,
-0.0437281057,
0.0151684303,
-0.0893462151,
0.0633359104,
-0.0084466254,
0.0339357853,
-0.0182399079,
-0.0906774253,
0.0141030978,
0.0062055411,
0.0515711308,
0.0583710186,
-0.0622312687,
-0.0020758177,
0.063070707,
-0.0100993747,
-0.0177331455,
0.0079579493,
0.0122011108,
-0.0147929154,
-0.044821579,
-0.0440077633,
-0.0368524678,
0.108300887,
-0.0271161087,
-0.0222372022,
-0.0541508682,
-0.0093859285,
-0.0367668569,
0.0075206934,
0.0097310571,
-0.0009671536,
-0.0201200303,
0.0144945206,
-0.0305017363,
-0.0782160684,
0.0568188988,
-0.0706047416,
-0.0164512992,
-0.0406346656,
-0.0214645192,
-0.0284101423,
0.0051398291,
0.0074789552,
0.0400503315,
-0.0052648233,
-0.01709578,
-0.0426865406,
-0.0086635463,
0.0049087638,
-0.0433892682,
0.0276034102,
-0.0025982962,
-0.0138604594,
-0.0062255347,
-0.0094346981,
0.0014806485,
-0.0007917167,
-0.0235142279,
-0.0065906681,
0.0377685353,
-0.0622188188,
0.0314708352,
0.0407158807,
-0.0347058102,
0.0285151191,
-0.0075574042,
0.0186661221,
-0.0383280106,
-0.0181522928,
0.0530271605,
-0.0043553249,
0.0219557043,
-0.0286399145,
0.0133550484,
-0.0185106117,
0.0163125116,
0.005390211,
-0.0431236438,
0.0063526304,
0.0543527268,
0.0076901647,
-0.0690091401,
0.0503910407,
0.0535933897,
-0.0262039751,
-0.0233007725,
0.0909292251,
0.0302051511,
0.0013158686,
0.0268612821,
-0.0608224683,
0.0879881755,
0.0438979529,
0.0412519611,
-0.0283671413,
-0.0264755897,
0.0180499498,
0.0168317631,
0.0176130403,
0.0407030173,
0.000533324,
-0.0864439532,
0.0241345484,
0.0613317229,
-0.0652611777,
-0.0479354821,
-0.0494719408,
-0.0277601518,
0.0026534693,
0.0510140918,
0.0335144736,
-0.0111816991,
-0.0037464642,
0.0248791762,
-0.0330906659,
-0.0582598448,
0.0069068917,
-0.0168499388,
0.0938747302,
0.0391620398,
-0.0034911977,
0.0113541251,
-0.0535728745,
0.0609346926,
0.0329268835,
0.0195534304,
-0.017026389,
0.0050944379,
0.0412144028,
-0.0340969414,
0.0009320325,
-0.0226051994,
-0.0442055203,
0.0305224806,
-0.0479461066,
0.0744980425,
0.0105037428,
0.0095776804,
-0.0130234938,
-0.011290594,
-0.0073390687,
0.0328352489,
0.0616782792,
-0.0222233739,
-0.0355822295,
-0.0679015666,
0.0013631544,
0.0026274512,
-0.0172717683,
0.0070759924,
0.0000946749,
-0.0534456857,
-0.0211083088,
-0.0193551946,
0.0005052598,
0.0415624045,
0.037082281,
-0.0058181267,
0.0276950337,
-0.0212958027,
-0.0488896705,
-0.0004339908,
-0.0339989215,
0.0338381976,
-0.0745936334,
-0.0199408643,
0.0347681902,
0.0314421989,
-0.0257341806,
0.007010886,
-0.0722713247,
-0.0974467099,
0.021464197,
0.0577503704,
0.0269962549,
0.0064994907,
-0.0408495031,
-0.0717701241,
0.065141812,
0.0409109816,
-0.0180534106,
0.0432950631,
0.0678497404,
-0.062638998,
0.0112321004,
0.02790967,
0.004929835,
-0.0118077667,
0.0049640676,
0.0170543585,
-0.0320907198,
-0.0496182404,
-0.0135404794,
0.0241432991,
0.0360837504,
-0.0179409552,
-0.0411435924,
-0.0288256481,
0.0341064632,
-0.0307653137,
0.0279209483,
-0.0452618301,
-0.0315750688,
0.0324345082,
-0.0252910629,
0.0067093652,
-0.0332558863,
-0.0191121027,
0.0551286601,
-0.0038931842,
0.0436683558,
-0.0193718486,
0.0465624705,
0.0310770813,
0.0229389034,
0.0099729728,
0.0264230426,
-0.0250772759,
0.0398293808,
-0.0246723108,
-0.00425978,
-0.0294088013,
0.0251578037,
-0.0383314118,
0.0662428662,
-0.014758734,
-0.014456857,
-0.0628982559,
0.01859417,
0.0719012544,
0.0188976824,
0.0877290964,
0.0002641966,
-0.0034189781,
-0.0176196713,
0.0419160835,
-0.0055203047,
-0.0253640078,
0.0500410721,
0.0116969338,
-0.0126790209,
-0.0428940095,
0.0552898049,
0.00331096,
0.0592924096,
-0.0127184419,
0.0165981986,
-0.0363738574,
0.0032178853,
0.0200115982,
0.0139062209,
-0.0489609838,
-0.018680051,
-0.0453249775,
-0.0857159793,
-0.0325782746,
0.0227911584,
-0.0049936757,
-0.0059663733,
-0.0057416912,
0.0423429683,
-0.007777181,
-0.0054058088,
-0.0127643282,
-0.0496925488,
0.0203166343,
-0.0385159217,
0.0318270959,
-6.690988048e-33,
-0.0622929893,
0.0233066585,
-0.0035367704,
-0.0081228828,
-0.0140181612,
-0.0002669232,
-0.0376456641,
0.0193406083,
-0.04011539,
-0.0008436278,
-0.0195251908,
-0.0001626306,
0.0190712176,
-0.0226040855,
-0.0026646268,
0.024793392,
0.0456389487,
0.0184822306,
-0.0085057905,
0.0001055849,
-0.0006157767,
0.0264677871,
0.0637526438,
-0.0481698737,
-0.0169719737,
0.0011450328,
0.0106739867,
-0.0128751909,
-0.0031174491,
0.0443359055,
-0.015564586,
0.0287050027,
-0.0134564117,
0.0009051961,
-0.0512649678,
-0.0519822128,
-0.012249345,
-0.0349721387,
0.0287486333,
0.0275511872,
0.0128740389,
-0.068925716,
0.0270863734,
0.0225301944,
-0.0473469049,
-0.0081634428,
0.0167594962,
-0.0151922982,
-0.0483114496,
0.0530968234,
-0.0599318184,
0.0230767373,
0.0075338841,
-0.0293423086,
0.0204337444,
-0.060287293,
0.0014751601,
-0.0223598983,
-0.0404327549,
0.0571711734,
0.0458007492,
0.1031883508,
0.0802221373,
0.0194889791,
0.001501028,
0.0034462623,
0.0384579636,
-0.0042944881,
0.0081989868,
0.0179891586,
0.0800656974,
0.0130423885,
0.0208423883,
-0.0200308058,
0.0137140499,
-0.0466019996,
-0.0535986386,
0.0017299204,
0.0560791939,
0.0083053643,
0.0152508039,
0.0529170893,
-0.0721833184,
-0.0357240029,
-0.04789133,
-0.040278025,
-0.0315863378,
-0.037668772,
0.007688025,
-0.0061030332,
-0.0386537574,
-0.0296792649,
0.0099221095,
-0.0387226082,
0.0254870094,
0.0036692477,
-0.016855007,
0.0279626902,
-0.018261211,
0.0284474771,
-0.0084156618,
-0.0730593428,
0.0121690892,
-0.007633666,
0.0340802372,
0.0030598314,
-0.017255811,
0.0416461378,
-0.0749989003,
0.0186696481,
-0.0320721343,
-0.0378668196,
0.0314175822,
0.0107918652,
0.0297010094,
-0.0373648591,
0.0072177784,
0.0422077887,
0.0210382752,
0.0324000195,
-0.0216068346,
0.0226747133,
0.0065069092,
0.0258087385,
-0.0247139111,
0.0182288866,
-0.0284728967,
0.0247357115,
0.0405485518,
-0.0476524681,
-0.0512281694,
-0.0075669666,
2.958e-7,
0.0155054592,
0.0825013146,
0.0026032631,
0.0577764995,
-0.0028261025,
0.0287811775,
-0.0096962871,
-0.0080651585,
0.0260420423,
-0.0070432397,
-0.0192608684,
0.0154255852,
0.0233462155,
0.0195745248,
-0.0545091964,
0.0343384854,
-0.0490702577,
0.051031515,
-0.0402820446,
-0.0076678223,
0.013856722,
0.1408088803,
-0.0030601814,
0.0027143147,
0.0058964025,
-0.0587203652,
0.0106328726,
-0.0270089284,
-0.0171670225,
0.0241787434,
0.0101892827,
0.0175837427,
-0.0236065686,
-0.0303162951,
-0.0271731894,
0.0060299658,
-0.0161604322,
0.0376596563,
-0.025933627,
0.008311457,
0.0592311099,
-0.0174689479,
-0.027859943,
-0.0536244996,
0.0286088716,
0.0162847936,
-0.0271634497,
-0.0540203117,
-0.0041088564,
0.0026765275,
0.0343383029,
-0.0481763445,
-0.0098342542,
-0.0060618157,
0.028733274,
-0.0320704207,
0.0020648453,
-0.0471666418,
-0.054996293,
0.0136119397,
-0.0209798627,
-0.0512517989,
-0.0373991132,
0.0023967144,
0.0509043336,
-0.0139638698,
0.0155278435,
3.347985383e-34,
0.0427397154,
-0.0198800024,
0.060143169,
0.035491012,
0.0118775778,
0.0001996681,
0.0324161351,
0.0114603713,
0.0159369688,
-0.0665366575,
-0.0406885371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01515v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01515v1 | Bigger is not Always Better: The Effect of Context Size on Speech Pre-Training | 2023-12-03T22:08:54 | 2023-12-03T22:08:54 | Sean Robertson, Ewan Dunbar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7 | It has been generally assumed in the automatic speech recognition (ASR)
literature that it is better for models to have access to wider context
windows. Yet, many of the potential reasons this might be true in the
supervised setting do not necessarily transfer over to the case of unsupervised
learning. We investigate how much context is necessary to achieve high-quality
pre-trained acoustic models using self-supervised learning. We principally
investigate contrastive predictive coding (CPC), which we adapt to be able to
precisely control the amount of context visible to the model during training
and inference. We find that phone discriminability in the resulting model
representations peaks at around 40~ms of preceding context, and that having too
much context (beyond around 320 ms) substantially degrades the quality of the
representations. Surprisingly, we find that this pattern also transfers to
supervised ASR when the pre-trained representations are used as frozen input
features. Our results point to potential changes in the design of current
upstream architectures to better facilitate a variety of downstream tasks. | [
-0.0441859104,
0.0528911203,
-0.0131329121,
0.0219667573,
0.0071174465,
-0.0128008341,
0.0783151239,
-0.0171035454,
-0.0178080183,
0.0341212265,
-0.0647521168,
-0.0432610773,
0.0137407519,
0.0390430763,
-0.0086174123,
-0.0381824039,
-0.0067360355,
-0.0613783486,
-0.0155997304,
-0.0230227336,
-0.0159077849,
-0.0257817283,
-0.022309009,
0.0176710337,
-0.0409449041,
-0.0148472171,
-0.0031962332,
0.0330895223,
-0.0169014391,
-0.0491380654,
-0.0032458082,
0.0375414304,
0.0291392691,
-0.0201669708,
0.0000018648,
-0.0381300561,
0.0145416744,
-0.0246472508,
-0.0570921339,
0.0379583314,
0.0253719594,
0.0254075229,
-0.0273870807,
0.0100029148,
-0.0217566192,
-0.0498182215,
0.0564927422,
0.0545696318,
-0.0363510326,
0.0190521795,
-0.0182966813,
-0.0569677316,
0.0094718123,
0.0061421194,
-0.0110990936,
-0.0174287129,
-0.0181312431,
0.0036901664,
-0.0159517713,
-0.0115905209,
-0.01743697,
0.040147081,
0.0580115691,
0.0242911782,
0.010521194,
0.0771720186,
-0.0175842494,
-0.0333476067,
-0.0286331438,
0.0292640515,
0.0075008031,
-0.0330427811,
-0.0248784032,
-0.013384534,
-0.0136580914,
-0.0713350028,
0.0180175584,
-0.019843109,
0.0281358249,
0.0121559035,
-0.0315604061,
0.0604947768,
0.0170053877,
-0.0236978084,
-0.0111307129,
-0.0101508284,
-0.0158448424,
-0.0323679745,
-0.0039097476,
0.0020292136,
-0.0043536099,
0.0053703128,
0.0310351141,
-0.0148240477,
0.0095038638,
-0.031186115,
-0.0401007496,
-0.0115262764,
-0.0306571983,
-0.0247732475,
0.0105682025,
0.0568456687,
-0.1048224047,
-0.009932111,
-0.0209106132,
0.026882695,
-0.0071838391,
-0.021096997,
-0.0177304894,
0.0382455625,
0.0144451754,
0.0230693556,
-0.0475983694,
-0.0037807289,
-0.0379314385,
0.0017476764,
-0.0402991362,
0.0168629643,
-0.002877149,
-0.0128028039,
0.0060916683,
0.0097430414,
-0.0480497405,
-0.0102408612,
0.033131361,
0.0162308551,
-0.013496507,
0.0551566072,
-0.013407127,
-0.0911085159,
-0.0278994683,
-0.0066747162,
0.0571237616,
-0.0194193423,
0.010485067,
0.0683053359,
-0.0101798037,
-0.0668325201,
-0.0411409214,
0.0144046526,
-0.0618758164,
-0.0021778052,
-0.0133134704,
-0.0304805897,
-0.0071423897,
-0.0008698918,
0.0052788784,
-0.0267419368,
-0.0248526558,
-0.0534059666,
0.0306736939,
0.0858104303,
-0.01007831,
-0.0119534843,
0.0690630823,
-0.0057155555,
0.003220177,
0.0330247134,
0.0232490022,
-0.0180069078,
0.0262400303,
-0.0568650514,
-0.0217180625,
0.0290677026,
0.0414859541,
0.0018171715,
-0.0319854617,
0.0162953008,
0.0238365345,
0.0057058614,
0.0917812511,
0.008989566,
-0.0482918657,
-0.0616336726,
0.0654659718,
0.0750773847,
0.0423873924,
0.0349252112,
0.0027678777,
-0.0038938536,
-0.022490304,
0.0119947391,
-0.014917478,
0.0119419266,
0.0038123992,
0.0049982378,
0.0520033129,
0.0192704182,
-0.0438361354,
-0.0429924577,
0.007770488,
-0.0381026715,
-0.0227108393,
0.0264177583,
0.0263626203,
-0.0095714498,
-0.0110538956,
0.0036185344,
-0.0239409991,
-0.0625247881,
0.0075998921,
-0.0511204898,
-0.001752411,
0.0666409731,
-0.0206252281,
-0.0190891437,
0.0033510539,
0.0166594274,
-0.023258904,
0.005172621,
0.0351716578,
0.0155017069,
0.0964629874,
-0.0239220019,
-0.0402507819,
-0.0263345651,
-0.018039085,
0.028486656,
0.0057995236,
0.0294775814,
-0.0058127735,
0.0273636077,
0.0476795882,
-0.0135396356,
-0.0288523994,
-0.0602088086,
0.0386613831,
-0.0019602126,
0.0672442019,
0.0030708914,
-0.031787701,
0.0036390289,
0.0174582377,
-0.0108370846,
0.0502902716,
0.0112547344,
-0.1382243335,
-0.0338548273,
0.029988898,
0.0093622813,
0.0554268174,
0.0182462484,
0.0161597375,
-0.046403449,
0.0421077497,
-0.0020422237,
0.0927523598,
-0.020297857,
0.0531243533,
0.0140798949,
0.02938639,
0.0326701626,
0.0186788309,
0.009145055,
-0.0083310511,
0.0138177117,
0.0543713644,
0.0261627641,
-0.0321592763,
-0.0016643194,
0.0228064526,
-0.0076830424,
-0.00067422,
0.0025857468,
-0.0226033591,
-0.0457255989,
0.0151761733,
-0.0671785697,
-0.0153719708,
-0.0128511013,
-0.0163086448,
0.0081431726,
0.0156538915,
-0.0093878703,
-0.0252606589,
0.0077470504,
-0.0453194641,
-0.0461450443,
0.0242905393,
-0.0698040277,
0.0273737479,
-0.0188157652,
-0.0153986644,
-0.0240716133,
0.05553215,
0.0224017985,
-0.0214975234,
-0.0203813743,
-0.0210668519,
0.0727301836,
0.0469370261,
0.0370089225,
0.0057366001,
-0.0127406409,
0.0165898949,
-0.0059559084,
0.0445683002,
0.0662779063,
-0.0030850242,
0.0224785302,
0.0377349667,
-0.0220785402,
0.0016950271,
0.0055340715,
-0.0133531578,
0.0120352451,
-0.0313935429,
0.0162429996,
-0.0596765913,
0.0847146437,
0.0235548243,
0.0295964032,
-0.0373526253,
-0.0596062429,
-0.0063830726,
-0.052967675,
-0.0085791023,
-0.016615076,
-0.0123448754,
0.082271859,
-0.01408662,
-0.029630132,
0.0239683744,
-0.0398121253,
-0.0005405914,
-0.0020163928,
-0.0564551391,
0.0058533535,
0.0393412672,
-0.0002112546,
-0.0196353178,
-0.0332840309,
-0.0280549061,
-0.0283389129,
-0.0165498629,
-0.0111734057,
-0.0451775603,
0.022764843,
-0.0202421192,
-0.0012874103,
-0.0008904575,
-0.0777504072,
-0.0164146032,
-0.02043893,
-0.0374758169,
0.0202900358,
0.0389753953,
-0.0409304127,
0.0250296835,
0.0580146089,
-0.0085792728,
0.1069334894,
0.0218795333,
-0.0132472571,
0.0029185142,
0.0490077995,
-0.0529200435,
0.0498241894,
0.0143556288,
0.0123252356,
0.0721914247,
-0.0001459173,
0.0527450927,
-0.0131025258,
-0.0843432322,
0.0436073355,
0.0533668771,
0.0167550519,
-0.0555343777,
0.0540021658,
0.0747966915,
-0.0702305585,
-0.0244629253,
0.062117286,
-0.0051443358,
-0.0215724092,
0.0007188323,
-0.0173729416,
0.0177835915,
0.0079218997,
-0.0327920653,
0.0013274836,
-0.0212814193,
0.0223377664,
-0.0078830048,
0.0048386077,
0.031320855,
-0.0133713353,
-0.0718169585,
0.0638379827,
0.0458141826,
-0.0370603502,
-0.0175305437,
-0.0439231768,
-0.0244539026,
-0.0286210887,
0.0191107318,
0.0180383325,
-0.0285164304,
-0.0360376686,
0.0238696076,
-0.0549910851,
-0.0363463871,
0.0131392498,
-0.0134835858,
0.013027193,
0.0842933431,
-0.0021774049,
0.0128006637,
-0.0231615175,
0.0371336192,
-0.0676105991,
0.033761736,
-0.02865519,
0.0492626652,
0.0066364226,
-0.012628871,
0.0390261598,
0.0255178586,
-0.0002303654,
-0.0390866213,
0.0224343799,
0.0183837879,
-0.0176882204,
0.0078606568,
0.0089368634,
0.0307936873,
-0.0019553851,
0.056541089,
0.0412552394,
0.0050821169,
-0.0301476661,
0.0241013132,
0.0728501156,
-0.0275143459,
0.0060682618,
0.0152228298,
0.0194301903,
-0.0640274957,
0.0285311043,
0.0012314934,
0.0003863937,
0.0325706825,
-0.0062282854,
-0.0197360385,
-0.0505823344,
0.0451480411,
-0.0603816509,
0.0160019789,
-0.019702848,
0.000369981,
-0.0468369238,
-0.0256935004,
0.0372478664,
-0.0573907867,
-0.0106405253,
0.0207085237,
-0.0232063886,
-0.038267348,
0.0281721987,
-0.0100212321,
0.0153171364,
0.1069844365,
0.0116083017,
-0.0460165292,
0.0688678101,
0.0202011261,
-0.0726943761,
0.0552367717,
0.06096486,
-0.0028567051,
0.0033187771,
-0.0121310437,
-0.0385697372,
0.0739925206,
-0.0212757867,
-0.0221145712,
-0.0498127937,
-0.0610549934,
0.0165741239,
-0.0323560536,
0.092217043,
-0.0151473451,
0.0690787137,
-0.0159777906,
0.048549965,
-0.0145222414,
0.0843128711,
-0.0192738604,
-0.0205654912,
0.0189170782,
0.0451693907,
-0.008917165,
0.0369234309,
-0.0299398322,
-0.0192844328,
-0.0123537313,
0.0401199162,
0.0298197251,
0.0132724922,
-0.0054338607,
0.0032402088,
-0.0273887366,
0.0378259867,
0.0240692645,
0.0320408903,
0.0085240928,
0.0184246544,
-0.0055796318,
0.0075040949,
-0.0059896861,
0.0244944189,
-0.0759986639,
-0.0123760412,
-0.0464241281,
-0.009430239,
-0.0070663346,
-0.07010784,
-0.0122365644,
-0.0103509603,
0.0123388059,
-0.0118139517,
-0.0029740101,
-0.0229778271,
-0.0118605364,
0.0091534695,
0.0198579188,
-0.0039782757,
-0.0044926899,
0.0077035083,
0.0054882271,
0.0349960439,
-0.004165994,
0.044876568,
-0.0233653057,
-0.0341161527,
0.0102632055,
0.0249214023,
0.004204486,
-0.0153867053,
-0.0178448912,
-0.0584103428,
0.0183926839,
-0.0037167023,
0.0181659982,
-0.0213162359,
0.0526033044,
-0.00680207,
-0.0175366774,
-0.0404847413,
0.0498692058,
-0.0620394722,
0.0263313316,
0.0041926261,
0.0098102931,
-6.050143425e-33,
-0.0079735359,
0.0172335356,
0.0258689113,
-0.0002007396,
0.008907428,
0.0331129916,
-0.0027500796,
-0.0146651352,
0.0128176501,
-0.0295160245,
-0.036660444,
0.0457641594,
0.0392826647,
0.0140261743,
-0.0408228077,
-0.0157450642,
0.1192629188,
-0.0501188114,
0.0402698182,
0.005947276,
0.0225186367,
0.0211971086,
0.0033658887,
-0.0586390272,
-0.0467262901,
0.033782199,
0.0015521833,
-0.0326105691,
0.0571681187,
0.016189767,
-0.0346712023,
0.0037235387,
0.0067537772,
-0.0291682705,
-0.0297437534,
0.0414997786,
-0.1156750396,
-0.0477706045,
-0.0237307772,
0.0198178198,
-0.0394936539,
-0.0281133372,
0.0596256331,
0.0123910718,
-0.0732828602,
-0.032055337,
0.0067094066,
-0.0300192311,
-0.0348331034,
-0.0491695069,
0.0149737569,
0.0420563035,
-0.0332075283,
-0.01701805,
0.1019905359,
0.0217206609,
-0.012571821,
0.0191742145,
-0.0313902237,
0.0453280099,
0.0253026038,
0.029683359,
0.0163184591,
0.0556740351,
0.0406559892,
0.0282458775,
0.0931919366,
-0.0526757129,
0.0276199654,
-0.0601285435,
-0.0007845394,
0.0294776913,
-0.0195722915,
0.0063756565,
0.0886338875,
-0.0639574304,
-0.0227049161,
-0.0231581144,
-0.0535465702,
-0.0146792354,
0.0346498713,
0.0165471938,
-0.064033553,
-0.0311661884,
-0.0406469665,
-0.0531984083,
-0.0226562824,
-0.0188302454,
0.0475123413,
-0.0154705429,
0.0071545006,
0.0099763405,
0.0537400506,
-0.0003801657,
0.0302004796,
-0.0057237358,
-0.0196306314,
0.0059357882,
0.0181891378,
0.0150379296,
-0.0453063622,
-0.0144690927,
0.0401681699,
0.0212870091,
-0.0026559248,
-0.043041151,
-0.0149614597,
0.0555792265,
-0.0580596216,
-0.0385070294,
-0.0024032269,
0.0002242811,
0.04880438,
-0.0248993952,
0.0531836748,
0.0126056839,
0.003627979,
0.0568500161,
-0.0040018568,
-0.0006328856,
-0.0173300523,
-0.0167557411,
-0.0124096489,
0.0560031421,
-0.0018874391,
-0.0189587232,
-0.021358002,
0.0035988684,
0.0641128793,
-0.0505148321,
-0.0531963408,
0.0152891343,
2.692e-7,
-0.034285143,
-0.0422006808,
0.0079054115,
-0.0488003939,
0.0498593226,
0.0149905123,
0.0167413782,
-0.0239535291,
-0.0121746957,
-0.0494289286,
0.035375949,
0.0476754121,
0.0328428745,
0.0409288891,
-0.0205778182,
0.0165093243,
-0.0446881987,
0.0428057015,
0.0021444715,
-0.0042781387,
0.0265952181,
0.0856160372,
0.0050425497,
-0.0325939693,
0.0173326582,
-0.0004475258,
0.0339836031,
-0.0431178622,
0.0500828028,
-0.0440463647,
-0.0322283395,
0.0039780503,
-0.0055668605,
0.0422808528,
-0.0109494291,
0.0100310892,
-0.0220987983,
0.036853943,
0.0048389491,
-0.0700293332,
0.0178403277,
0.0569818392,
-0.0379325934,
0.013593113,
0.0674123093,
-0.0406413078,
-0.0184799563,
-0.0370254256,
-0.0482913852,
-0.0327686667,
0.0138867293,
0.0063530048,
0.0362540558,
-0.0064322096,
-0.0258310903,
-0.0037412727,
-0.0404478088,
-0.064699024,
0.0216996837,
0.051364705,
-0.0324971303,
-0.0243468117,
-0.0632363111,
-0.0008810568,
0.084557429,
0.0403520055,
0.011021968,
1.59806804e-34,
0.0106333774,
-0.0367724635,
0.0408843085,
-0.0067942953,
-0.0370312743,
-0.0551331192,
0.0246425495,
0.0085749095,
0.0554377772,
-0.0143087972,
-0.0197451264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01509v1 | Tackling Bias in Pre-trained Language Models: Current Trends and Under-represented Societies | 2023-12-03T21:25:10 | 2023-12-03T21:25:10 | Vithya Yogarajan, Gillian Dobbie, Te Taka Keegan, Rostam J. Neuwirth | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | The benefits and capabilities of pre-trained language models (LLMs) in
current and future innovations are vital to any society. However, introducing
and using LLMs comes with biases and discrimination, resulting in concerns
about equality, diversity and fairness, and must be addressed. While
understanding and acknowledging bias in LLMs and developing mitigation
strategies are crucial, the generalised assumptions towards societal needs can
result in disadvantages towards under-represented societies and indigenous
populations. Furthermore, the ongoing changes to actual and proposed amendments
to regulations and laws worldwide also impact research capabilities in tackling
the bias problem. This research presents a comprehensive survey synthesising
the current trends and limitations in techniques used for identifying and
mitigating bias in LLMs, where the overview of methods for tackling bias are
grouped into metrics, benchmark datasets, and mitigation strategies. The
importance and novelty of this survey are that it explores the perspective of
under-represented societies. We argue that current practices tackling the bias
problem cannot simply be 'plugged in' to address the needs of under-represented
societies. We use examples from New Zealand to present requirements for
adopting existing techniques to under-represented societies. | [
0.0119093778,
0.0789948031,
-0.0350589715,
-0.0011353175,
-0.0173570346,
0.0410015881,
0.0648518652,
-0.0131946495,
0.0213714857,
-0.0610073879,
0.0095636398,
-0.0462660529,
0.0223255306,
-0.0067538358,
0.0087591792,
-0.0698825866,
0.0450093411,
0.0009393723,
0.0434221663,
-0.0377527811,
0.0146923373,
0.0396849811,
0.0215912536,
0.0636079833,
-0.036005795,
0.0073508248,
0.0406773426,
-0.0153754149,
-0.0136868209,
0.0033222011,
0.0183011778,
0.0823201314,
-0.0281713996,
0.0432303548,
0.0000018319,
-0.0614853874,
0.007777839,
-0.0318117477,
-0.0145838885,
0.0282434914,
0.046254687,
0.0015770412,
-0.0159578547,
0.0538177155,
-0.0394271351,
-0.0109028211,
0.0727914274,
-0.046763137,
0.0224279501,
0.0226165596,
-0.0097631887,
-0.0191328749,
-0.0435764343,
-0.022510156,
-0.0472975671,
-0.0025052542,
0.0668318346,
-0.0087599261,
-0.0133576309,
-0.0616660714,
-0.0288482271,
0.0333986059,
0.0061805639,
-0.0129678072,
-0.0261781253,
0.0012206245,
-0.0569077544,
-0.0754387006,
0.0115309367,
0.0388123877,
-0.0154960239,
-0.032263197,
-0.0145768235,
-0.0359620787,
-0.0115291672,
0.0004391905,
-0.0067756451,
0.0241536628,
0.0062898733,
0.0330726914,
0.0047538979,
0.0178828314,
0.0039898213,
0.0382652171,
-0.023587184,
0.0594187491,
0.0443565957,
0.0013005998,
0.0113047296,
0.0537006184,
0.0363176912,
-0.0213708561,
0.025912011,
0.0022443873,
-0.0083171315,
0.0305612814,
-0.0228185952,
-0.0362934545,
0.0261012558,
-0.0385024026,
0.0293484889,
0.03712992,
-0.054626435,
-0.012144845,
0.0032655308,
0.007163513,
-0.0014476874,
0.0172104817,
-0.0379533209,
0.0067604519,
0.0247396491,
-0.0126557285,
-0.0195657257,
-0.0497685559,
-0.0245582964,
0.0647803247,
-0.0192705672,
0.0076896539,
-0.0294878967,
-0.0622180514,
-0.00631089,
-0.0212499257,
-0.0278355721,
-0.0007673293,
-0.0082569597,
0.0421736054,
-0.0037766509,
0.0530552156,
-0.080574289,
-0.0942287147,
0.0387989841,
0.0239646211,
-0.0270800404,
-0.0222131796,
-0.0071712802,
0.0254988894,
0.0243749451,
-0.0362467654,
-0.0602305979,
0.0090125529,
-0.0193924196,
-0.02904764,
-0.0141476383,
-0.0414220579,
0.0152388392,
0.02175791,
0.0091878418,
-0.0594810359,
-0.0173526946,
-0.0087009501,
-0.056997776,
-0.0045893267,
-0.0286355447,
0.0415546373,
0.0595059656,
0.0022854321,
0.0405601375,
0.0886611864,
0.0169385169,
-0.0300999861,
0.0424039774,
-0.0337099172,
-0.0005875285,
0.0484341644,
0.0258433521,
0.0407347456,
-0.0377988145,
0.0233307686,
-0.0329058208,
-0.0187716465,
0.0819149688,
0.0465824045,
0.0271270201,
-0.0098904958,
0.0174867474,
0.0601700656,
-0.0055745025,
-0.0089265499,
0.0168341752,
-0.0088503687,
-0.0034011905,
-0.0133262789,
-0.0466296077,
-0.0230737589,
-0.000469307,
-0.0335320346,
0.0053437757,
0.0602091476,
-0.0253226385,
-0.0146448649,
-0.0071785804,
0.0210760366,
0.051742591,
0.0284779388,
0.0411951095,
-0.0305780377,
0.0028749779,
0.0278907139,
0.055988472,
-0.0252442975,
0.0435174108,
-0.0610477403,
-0.0016264123,
0.017640939,
-0.0291196089,
-0.0227713939,
0.0221109465,
-0.006340011,
-0.0061985962,
0.0856814682,
0.0505540855,
-0.007254045,
-0.0108934017,
-0.0312795006,
-0.036955107,
0.0472106896,
0.0016365785,
0.0120204017,
0.0163387284,
0.0550439693,
0.0371924303,
-0.0126502989,
-0.0794004276,
0.0445468202,
-0.0263268109,
-0.020952357,
-0.0236473288,
-0.0002468482,
0.007322445,
0.0551386252,
-0.0475979522,
0.0058898218,
-0.016620433,
0.0288349763,
0.0478147753,
0.0214303918,
-0.0448969007,
0.0133562321,
0.0469738357,
-0.0883140564,
0.0134959165,
0.0310182422,
-0.0091194585,
-0.0013349227,
0.0298408549,
0.0451860763,
0.060707096,
-0.0476796776,
0.0097476095,
-0.0506084003,
-0.0039674109,
-0.0316379443,
-0.017818734,
-0.0074923569,
-0.0252503157,
-0.0012385269,
-0.0596780255,
0.0638539344,
-0.0299972128,
-0.0351059064,
0.0273784269,
0.0015448109,
0.0443107076,
0.0234746933,
0.0131557668,
0.0062377355,
0.0241711326,
-0.0866450518,
-0.0570590869,
-0.0302707031,
-0.0194903761,
-0.0158463661,
0.0053837444,
-0.0544085875,
-0.0335575677,
0.0019743135,
-0.039760232,
0.0255054031,
0.0303803142,
-0.0278564151,
-0.0286975056,
0.0046605091,
-0.0245082229,
-0.052270636,
0.0006210654,
0.044572223,
0.0217920896,
-0.0293326303,
-0.036998909,
-0.0015926522,
-0.0039197891,
0.0060956762,
-0.0045496081,
-0.0124031063,
0.0194102898,
0.0462694801,
-0.0079908734,
-0.0012132161,
0.0205069482,
-0.0186569542,
0.0767758712,
-0.0007668879,
-0.028948104,
-0.0350886434,
-0.0004156271,
0.0308154486,
-0.011438882,
-0.0324915908,
-0.0266936161,
0.0749903545,
0.0192854274,
-0.0439617895,
-0.0282835644,
0.0318101905,
-0.0674167424,
-0.0555098951,
-0.0584403388,
-0.0571082309,
-0.0236105062,
0.029438572,
-0.0398475416,
-0.0959850848,
0.0060989861,
-0.0020612695,
0.0317990556,
-0.0734997392,
0.0074105267,
-0.0226054937,
0.0119475015,
-0.0108030438,
0.0369078629,
0.0176120177,
-0.0228093006,
-0.0411788709,
-0.0145943379,
-0.0152084501,
-0.0197691582,
0.0251454692,
-0.0335825868,
0.0345265307,
-0.023522269,
0.0016367539,
-0.044242423,
-0.0556884594,
-0.0224134289,
0.0180679131,
0.0189158507,
0.0369299501,
0.010670146,
0.0644695908,
-0.0204120371,
0.0252254456,
0.0135843037,
0.051633928,
0.0147897024,
-0.0330094174,
0.0105892615,
-0.0241867136,
0.0613585934,
-0.0269039813,
-0.0268805735,
-0.0377668776,
0.0248073954,
0.0163981449,
0.0506980419,
0.0237727053,
0.0434654169,
-0.053476993,
-0.0293359384,
0.0162361152,
0.0222146325,
-0.0201966222,
0.0270696431,
0.081873849,
0.0099070398,
-0.0462140664,
0.0260636248,
-0.0206679907,
0.0213864781,
0.0190148,
0.0080372356,
-0.0904758051,
0.0326759033,
0.0132717546,
0.0070477952,
-0.0539007857,
-0.020417355,
0.0040843198,
-0.0739477128,
0.0246020816,
0.0356125459,
-0.0396202132,
0.0112322653,
0.0255530309,
-0.0078892177,
0.0086264843,
0.0444700345,
0.0130070681,
-0.0090662614,
0.0212405175,
0.0559972376,
-0.0898822993,
-0.0486002602,
-0.0197173599,
-0.0555880964,
0.0451518744,
0.0266940519,
0.0101017607,
-0.0465122648,
0.0093799755,
0.0292639881,
-0.0411057174,
-0.0301728062,
-0.0170565359,
-0.0009960918,
-0.0014394422,
-0.0440265946,
-0.022876611,
0.0019068776,
0.0204427335,
0.001902177,
0.0274746772,
0.0598729625,
-0.0014714359,
-0.0256440341,
-0.0192142408,
-0.0067829215,
0.0253189281,
0.0661023483,
0.0371040814,
-0.0257578902,
-0.0135797095,
-0.0463054366,
-0.0037985907,
0.033658389,
-0.0615324043,
0.0743516237,
0.0269396566,
-0.0198617559,
0.0092750378,
-0.0599243157,
0.0305616818,
0.0237897616,
0.0369797759,
-0.021678986,
0.0260169469,
-0.0483658835,
-0.0172675569,
0.0580883697,
-0.0410496853,
0.0204887744,
-0.0584074371,
-0.0335538611,
-0.0160600096,
-0.0115738316,
-0.0074623092,
-0.0388625562,
-0.0050778803,
-0.0466769002,
0.0965000689,
0.0114752576,
0.022075234,
-0.0144915516,
0.0150408307,
-0.0978326052,
0.1066398099,
-0.0105880909,
-0.0012646824,
0.0405916944,
0.0266776774,
-0.0367386155,
0.000028085,
0.0191686209,
-0.0084253792,
0.0474559888,
0.0245050602,
-0.0055992529,
-0.0228747092,
-0.0134446872,
-0.0217287671,
-0.0054172282,
0.036718078,
-0.0694445297,
-0.0043861433,
-0.0827731639,
-0.0275036395,
0.0064732311,
-0.0054431981,
-0.0272061694,
-0.0382163264,
0.0389769711,
0.0549783856,
-0.0527919419,
-0.0244079977,
-0.0856457278,
0.029517822,
-0.0246799495,
0.1024663597,
0.0351676755,
0.0541126579,
0.0174258705,
-0.0006578667,
0.0142827434,
0.0408334322,
-0.0455498435,
0.0396227092,
0.0264576897,
0.0156439357,
-0.0024445241,
0.0058458429,
0.0041018263,
0.0058178091,
-0.0059193829,
-0.0350822061,
-0.0228949916,
0.00627254,
0.0602556877,
-0.0289357994,
0.027359575,
0.0410672687,
-0.0025026116,
-0.0155501151,
-0.0131067783,
0.0104117971,
-0.004855949,
0.0288350377,
-0.0317691229,
-0.0439383462,
0.041676119,
0.0406645089,
0.0312627889,
0.0674594492,
0.0048437454,
-0.0008474783,
0.0331261903,
-0.0509131402,
0.0387829728,
-0.0232268889,
-0.054774791,
-0.0251973663,
-0.0859962851,
-0.0548521429,
-0.0183904152,
-0.0020831933,
-0.0261353869,
-0.0072429539,
-0.0117604546,
0.023178881,
-0.0151213128,
-0.0132303089,
-0.0345916785,
-0.039918635,
-0.0317483097,
0.0056826281,
0.0209668204,
-5.746368502e-33,
-0.0470667072,
-0.0040531768,
-0.0068734745,
-0.0379765071,
0.0061163013,
-0.0040893322,
0.0256847255,
0.0209977571,
-0.0500177443,
-0.0002687961,
0.008391412,
-0.0050233728,
0.0236978419,
-0.0007840702,
-0.0014885386,
0.0281079151,
0.0178601984,
0.0244013015,
0.0164357461,
-0.0033724685,
-0.0192198828,
0.0014872224,
0.0646967292,
-0.0402532294,
0.051640287,
0.0049895728,
0.0086269267,
0.0098322546,
-0.0112359216,
0.0135865519,
-0.0318098255,
0.0720103309,
0.0063094441,
-0.0014877962,
-0.0213233903,
0.0447127372,
-0.0153235784,
-0.0295281857,
0.0441013835,
0.041459769,
0.0790847912,
0.0052237008,
0.0413463041,
0.0084748408,
-0.0774351358,
0.0258516148,
0.0098990733,
-0.0169295482,
0.0401121564,
0.0306927152,
-0.0504967906,
0.0369378291,
-0.0253552031,
0.0740112662,
0.0037830616,
0.0309961308,
-0.0056573967,
-0.0147810411,
-0.0592894517,
0.0152398404,
0.0584254153,
0.0018158198,
0.0883217528,
0.0453846902,
-0.0143499775,
0.0318035558,
0.0612762421,
-0.0140912049,
0.0277133081,
-0.0416264534,
0.1052462533,
-0.0487638712,
0.0023699088,
0.0472371951,
0.0268360041,
-0.0397605337,
-0.0458922237,
-0.0181031134,
0.026633691,
-0.0075287274,
0.0080429148,
-0.0225428455,
-0.0578169152,
-0.0875597298,
-0.0514151119,
-0.0883385316,
0.0144771701,
-0.021667175,
0.0656927899,
-0.0033809724,
0.0126410872,
0.0392381363,
0.0479205735,
-0.045302514,
-0.0252015777,
-0.0201120693,
-0.0099192243,
-0.0377940387,
0.0025623797,
0.0348301008,
-0.0768185407,
-0.0329734869,
0.0276224427,
0.0128141548,
-0.0027381245,
-0.0100418068,
-0.025697412,
-0.0029835482,
-0.0787676126,
0.0292270668,
0.0166132059,
0.0021260513,
0.0412853844,
0.029724801,
0.0341284685,
-0.0018328674,
0.0297543518,
0.0064091785,
0.0526132397,
-0.0475607179,
-0.0306630712,
-0.0147768427,
-0.0109543586,
0.0431076363,
-0.0485273004,
-0.008045922,
0.0264874864,
0.0324099623,
0.0569151305,
-0.0118962573,
0.0067175273,
-0.0136673879,
2.294e-7,
0.0541397147,
0.0469397269,
0.0017924766,
-0.0668438226,
-0.0186436772,
-0.0076834592,
0.0207577534,
0.0206308383,
0.0262133162,
0.0388343334,
-0.0086449664,
0.0150095196,
0.0105260508,
0.0289180093,
-0.0604861565,
0.0003887701,
-0.0747388825,
0.0462225825,
-0.0692851171,
-0.0099112745,
-0.046558585,
0.0579595305,
0.0038826824,
-0.0245207828,
-0.0513753965,
-0.0391671285,
0.0012333225,
-0.0482563525,
0.0198084842,
0.0207340587,
0.0620629042,
0.0163471848,
0.0445893593,
0.0142119797,
0.0022701381,
0.0625774637,
-0.0075104074,
0.0254955906,
-0.056754794,
0.0305755083,
-0.0124577256,
0.0088589108,
-0.0231352635,
-0.0639576241,
0.0598134696,
0.0392098054,
-0.0157147273,
-0.0449725017,
-0.0150814904,
-0.0390531309,
0.0509868115,
-0.0186819974,
0.008929438,
-0.0100166574,
0.059350457,
-0.0291297063,
-0.0135473795,
-0.0546029955,
-0.0174676739,
-0.0084095281,
0.0115802251,
-0.0390521958,
0.0166263003,
0.0192928128,
-0.0172064789,
-0.0126438569,
0.0632911175,
1.879829673e-34,
0.0408786535,
0.019604275,
0.0095088379,
0.0069972351,
0.0059085591,
0.0114860795,
0.023861181,
-0.0081493827,
0.0021542767,
-0.0268649403,
0.0210399907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01504v1 | Effectively Fine-tune to Improve Large Multimodal Models for Radiology Report Generation | 2023-12-03T20:42:38 | 2023-12-03T20:42:38 | Yuzhe Lu, Sungmin Hong, Yash Shah, Panpan Xu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Writing radiology reports from medical images requires a high level of domain
expertise. It is time-consuming even for trained radiologists and can be
error-prone for inexperienced radiologists. It would be appealing to automate
this task by leveraging generative AI, which has shown drastic progress in
vision and language understanding. In particular, Large Language Models (LLM)
have demonstrated impressive capabilities recently and continued to set new
state-of-the-art performance on almost all natural language tasks. While many
have proposed architectures to combine vision models with LLMs for multimodal
tasks, few have explored practical fine-tuning strategies. In this work, we
proposed a simple yet effective two-stage fine-tuning protocol to align visual
features to LLM's text embedding space as soft visual prompts. Our framework
with OpenLLaMA-7B achieved state-of-the-art level performance without
domain-specific pretraining. Moreover, we provide detailed analyses of soft
visual prompts and attention mechanisms, shedding light on future research
directions. | [
0.047157336,
0.0420430303,
0.0350709409,
0.0082334038,
0.0024648607,
0.0037103533,
0.0041540056,
0.0134549169,
0.012533159,
-0.0385072716,
-0.0425078683,
-0.0487426333,
0.0156656951,
0.0584524386,
0.0429221205,
-0.0938166752,
0.0164049845,
-0.0371923782,
0.0019502512,
0.0053085694,
0.0094060749,
0.008820924,
-0.007998989,
0.0280929264,
0.0081964172,
-0.0470704958,
-0.0097214309,
0.0267645326,
0.0248266198,
-0.0238869675,
-0.0461549237,
0.06331449,
0.017929852,
0.0118847573,
0.0000021299,
-0.0199202374,
0.0139669236,
0.0217770394,
0.0337859206,
0.0031247339,
0.0592608526,
-0.0720558837,
-0.0233749859,
-0.0082880491,
-0.0146257384,
-0.0384979397,
0.0729191825,
0.0360528901,
0.0847515911,
0.0565259978,
-0.0175495073,
0.0208301432,
0.0208193026,
-0.0510422327,
-0.0081293043,
-0.0426944345,
0.0097250529,
-0.0011364009,
0.0077497521,
0.0083031859,
-0.0443229787,
0.0568453893,
-0.0026163498,
-0.0356985889,
0.0303127132,
0.0782193691,
-0.0066343145,
-0.050492432,
-0.0239513852,
0.0655645654,
-0.0411724746,
0.0146709187,
-0.0157053713,
-0.0144141056,
-0.0035324688,
-0.0076572103,
-0.0488413423,
0.0304643046,
-0.0031386549,
0.0003124674,
-0.0323336869,
-0.0302431192,
0.0105331764,
0.0114783905,
0.0052051628,
-0.0422837883,
0.0288588908,
0.0090934131,
-0.0026647879,
0.0295727029,
-0.032841824,
-0.075142704,
0.0218407586,
0.0613614097,
-0.0643395782,
0.0052724062,
-0.0903290212,
-0.0229918752,
0.0374545865,
-0.0131386844,
0.0565431267,
0.0173578765,
-0.0745495781,
0.0725993291,
-0.0337646343,
0.0264017098,
-0.0481573716,
0.0372456983,
-0.0201831795,
0.0109606432,
0.0042832461,
-0.0099308658,
-0.016376432,
-0.0450194106,
-0.0226038992,
-0.0538274273,
-0.0304707829,
0.0208123438,
-0.0080457488,
0.0194147155,
0.0179167446,
0.0410210826,
-0.0584519915,
-0.0049238699,
-0.0306471884,
0.0511842854,
-0.0104734665,
-0.0021417267,
0.0061106114,
-0.056259457,
-0.0125766965,
0.036105603,
0.0104565164,
0.0007564341,
-0.0273295492,
0.0407385156,
-0.0381308645,
-0.0192632042,
0.0021568246,
-0.0389066041,
-0.033960782,
-0.0501676165,
0.0429507457,
-0.0541978702,
0.0266566481,
0.0074468367,
0.0249737296,
-0.0280877445,
0.009328845,
0.0208542645,
-0.0266987626,
0.0828375369,
-0.0307851676,
0.0038257698,
0.0273955483,
0.0095595624,
0.0429603048,
0.0380517319,
0.005795321,
0.0434354022,
-0.0098486869,
-0.0014017379,
0.0174503792,
0.0407297127,
-0.0043774755,
-0.0205674153,
-0.0242336337,
-0.0040045814,
0.0162731353,
0.082453005,
0.0502073951,
0.0561137982,
-0.0084988493,
-0.0035424631,
0.0747144297,
0.0386422426,
0.0620210469,
0.0049789264,
0.0426206291,
-0.032350935,
-0.002655484,
0.0102517754,
-0.0463153496,
0.0740547478,
0.0333688557,
0.0197344925,
0.02351401,
0.0278499611,
-0.0254573915,
-0.0216527767,
-0.0115258144,
-0.00276172,
-0.0534448177,
-0.0071365982,
0.0465744697,
0.0107516218,
-0.0681522861,
-0.0064720931,
0.04660419,
-0.0190702938,
-0.0029512222,
-0.0658194199,
0.0105193788,
0.0996003076,
0.0645264536,
-0.0143188229,
-0.0335055739,
-0.0064650862,
0.0632406399,
0.0707356781,
0.0563994274,
0.0109190308,
0.010308654,
-0.0597913601,
-0.0392952636,
-0.0030980257,
0.0025968414,
0.0141479168,
-0.0095146447,
0.0074213808,
-0.0127076143,
0.0000274259,
-0.0218666699,
0.055983033,
-0.0198146906,
-0.0223753452,
-0.0354279354,
0.0436866693,
-0.008683065,
-0.0155289872,
-0.0341939516,
0.016315762,
0.0051634298,
-0.0096137049,
0.0267898254,
-0.0145495301,
-0.0558852963,
0.0020064691,
0.0080283945,
-0.0448206887,
0.0009351656,
-0.0157763902,
-0.029115798,
-0.0124975732,
-0.0396126397,
-0.0335472263,
-0.0171799976,
-0.0478242598,
0.0165863186,
0.0503134094,
0.0294779129,
-0.0456296615,
0.0499037802,
0.000700591,
-0.0039106794,
0.0570153743,
0.0204179827,
-0.004049398,
-0.0432050154,
-0.0264771786,
0.0143919615,
0.026007656,
0.0336175449,
-0.0234880578,
0.0139732845,
-0.0429682918,
-0.0496498682,
-0.0911257863,
-0.0080547715,
0.0046330839,
-0.0315904692,
0.025985267,
0.0056729373,
-0.0006360989,
-0.0163587816,
-0.0307713654,
0.0328296199,
0.0453523584,
0.0087975683,
0.04094496,
-0.0104868347,
0.0176450312,
-0.0401998758,
-0.0061927224,
-0.0056619509,
0.0321238711,
0.0519584715,
-0.0053743832,
-0.0569410399,
0.0404856615,
-0.0176869109,
0.0251856036,
0.0016281183,
-0.038111154,
0.0331137963,
-0.0297592953,
0.0251012631,
0.1249669641,
0.0214838926,
0.0243038274,
0.0539448969,
-0.0086134728,
0.0000262598,
0.0128041683,
-0.0103358747,
-0.0557497479,
0.0267712846,
-0.0065311245,
-0.0264602546,
0.0513775125,
-0.024190234,
0.0182870813,
-0.0580185279,
0.0091639236,
-0.0006556674,
-0.0176721234,
-0.0196203683,
0.0259799212,
-0.0262908861,
0.037159279,
-0.0398566611,
-0.0719768628,
0.0603727177,
-0.0330182239,
0.0014813272,
-0.0029584551,
0.0184745546,
-0.0213390347,
0.059456706,
0.0147807188,
0.04190569,
0.04478392,
-0.0137358233,
-0.0706712902,
0.0271124449,
0.0108329998,
-0.0293931961,
0.055069495,
-0.0186212789,
0.004058477,
-0.0519091748,
-0.0319648087,
-0.02803546,
-0.0187460128,
-0.0089908754,
-0.004749666,
-0.0165614877,
-0.021187095,
-0.0695003867,
0.0307330061,
0.0134906666,
0.0397413447,
-0.0210980605,
-0.0209996141,
-0.0388066657,
0.0428621694,
0.0549215153,
0.0515532307,
-0.0473825,
-0.0410886556,
-0.0031099264,
0.0396790616,
-0.0005333372,
0.0210284926,
-0.0385271981,
0.0024100828,
0.0205884781,
0.0208864436,
-0.0020847593,
0.0333097875,
0.0579762682,
-0.0712696984,
-0.0202208478,
0.0929354429,
0.0127299363,
-0.0547142997,
-0.0246241633,
0.0125821196,
0.0262671653,
0.0229391437,
0.0388040394,
-0.0457074307,
-0.054052487,
-0.0151195787,
0.0313782878,
0.0232886821,
0.0035259866,
-0.0220137294,
-0.0689440742,
0.0678860769,
0.013417108,
-0.0187273994,
-0.0552907921,
-0.0165321697,
0.0173815507,
0.0153744221,
-0.0322344154,
0.002801337,
-0.0229985099,
-0.0101375189,
-0.0035922269,
0.0477528386,
-0.063244462,
-0.0117933378,
-0.0581533201,
0.0243256651,
0.0858808234,
0.0378705077,
0.0130322073,
-0.0360351205,
-0.0044749505,
0.034049008,
0.0275568012,
0.0096000433,
0.0758291185,
-0.0085004531,
-0.0421541557,
-0.0256374087,
0.0326638818,
-0.007685022,
-0.0123107051,
-0.0234913044,
0.0298596472,
-0.0015322554,
-0.0141766714,
-0.0394979976,
0.0252677202,
0.0055531641,
0.0329602361,
0.0196867622,
-0.0329328217,
-0.0359996893,
-0.0122054992,
0.0594772361,
-0.0379450321,
-0.0507933684,
0.0150091862,
-0.0364523083,
-0.0612775609,
-0.0520888716,
-0.0316400118,
0.0412163325,
0.0454918444,
0.0101165473,
-0.0313598104,
-0.0025815107,
-0.0060076569,
-0.0468514226,
0.0567080304,
-0.0230677314,
0.0163691137,
-0.0647953227,
-0.0211033784,
0.0372661948,
-0.0394656025,
-0.0162586309,
0.0498148873,
-0.0720896721,
-0.0336334109,
-0.0112949591,
0.0648712665,
0.0192746148,
0.0082964962,
-0.0063327453,
-0.0633847192,
0.0662661567,
0.073620297,
-0.0207937881,
0.042392958,
-0.0271783341,
-0.0474426746,
-0.0303343777,
0.0209517255,
-0.0389608927,
-0.0194725189,
0.0173776615,
0.0229310133,
0.0370536037,
-0.0648921579,
0.0072490769,
-0.0024280543,
0.0340388156,
-0.0303337649,
0.0251141302,
-0.0500735343,
-0.0113247307,
-0.0026614221,
-0.0173526425,
-0.0572816394,
-0.0054253242,
0.0180211738,
0.0037921378,
0.0065341294,
0.0175835267,
-0.0040970528,
0.0200198889,
-0.0559266955,
0.0192748923,
0.0230607353,
-0.0139210541,
0.0433118455,
0.0040722331,
-0.009738774,
0.0274485517,
-0.0433444977,
0.0252305157,
0.0023166961,
0.0710240602,
0.0170826316,
0.0263874978,
-0.0224278774,
0.0485542193,
-0.0114638703,
-0.0584070012,
-0.0291697532,
0.0644228682,
0.058136005,
0.0041449303,
0.0326086134,
-0.0339401029,
-0.022342613,
-0.0188325904,
0.0431940109,
0.015635822,
-0.0166335125,
0.0568870082,
0.0135557456,
0.0362950414,
-0.0594424009,
0.0933082327,
-0.0131056933,
0.0476745144,
-0.0172527749,
-0.03754697,
-0.046569068,
-0.0370251238,
0.0229353737,
-0.018005928,
-0.0192126837,
0.0207380615,
-0.0221819635,
-0.0438746214,
-0.0181806646,
0.0003244734,
-0.0393835157,
-0.0243865401,
0.0468172431,
0.0528058484,
0.0125280116,
-0.0130473971,
-0.0117049115,
-0.0040749414,
-0.0146915941,
-0.0109248869,
0.0259332638,
-6.489897699e-33,
-0.0344760455,
-0.0390697494,
0.0291356314,
-0.0447349437,
-0.028992245,
0.0565116256,
-0.037622612,
0.011273751,
-0.0077617182,
-0.0006297514,
-0.0173540767,
-0.0216707215,
0.0131648891,
0.0448210761,
-0.0309007466,
0.0130311903,
0.0375855044,
-0.0064181667,
-0.0400918163,
0.0041498221,
-0.0245558117,
0.0084380647,
0.0042691678,
-0.0294987969,
-0.0107879313,
0.0179359522,
-0.0370063484,
-0.0201395191,
-0.0057233083,
0.0631326064,
-0.0418654419,
0.0109159462,
0.0097146071,
-0.0147110503,
-0.0210239477,
0.0697504878,
-0.0805882514,
0.0096736271,
0.0216896106,
0.0165670142,
-0.0874532163,
-0.023524452,
0.0447177701,
-0.016956199,
0.017740244,
-0.0466572568,
0.0455017947,
-0.0215861518,
-0.0212729108,
-0.0020232277,
-0.0621623285,
0.0257490557,
0.0020384849,
-0.0652944893,
0.0168630388,
-0.0203371048,
0.0079234904,
0.0520819686,
-0.0274670236,
0.0131711839,
0.0498931073,
0.06378638,
0.0640986115,
0.0410279743,
-0.0174829476,
0.0460930392,
0.0310640354,
-0.0198104717,
-0.0277833194,
-0.0119805988,
-0.008255939,
0.0464005172,
0.0104386881,
0.0433842503,
0.0253030565,
0.0102252662,
-0.0538729876,
0.0191258304,
-0.0557220355,
0.0605913401,
0.0454609729,
0.0087221852,
0.0090426533,
0.0065410123,
-0.0217825472,
-0.0157296546,
-0.0541394055,
-0.0137456898,
0.0499154553,
0.0387557931,
-0.0050560385,
0.0077315443,
0.0386053212,
0.0092152441,
0.0226142835,
-0.0157207176,
-0.0079942299,
0.063920185,
-0.0407677256,
-0.0033780865,
-0.0363276228,
-0.0114567159,
0.062784411,
0.006655769,
0.0125187878,
0.0399113782,
0.0177417453,
0.0279522762,
-0.0784831196,
0.0201923717,
-0.0230934415,
-0.0085923821,
-0.0092572356,
0.0550493002,
0.0484189242,
-0.0316710845,
-0.0312028732,
0.0398154072,
-0.0101402681,
-0.0189108122,
-0.0316894874,
-0.0715829879,
0.0171052143,
0.009727546,
-0.0544687882,
0.0130632762,
-0.0434654281,
-0.027743157,
0.0409453139,
-0.0411220118,
-0.0333918221,
0.0043127388,
2.811e-7,
0.0469464846,
0.040390186,
0.0177471675,
0.041055765,
0.0155553445,
0.0396463014,
-0.0016415123,
0.0361847505,
0.0083061447,
-0.0392192379,
0.0179076809,
0.0372269265,
0.0163593683,
-0.0126822749,
-0.0452366918,
0.0110622523,
-0.0236298647,
0.0256096665,
-0.0342176966,
-0.0549965911,
0.0579862036,
0.0740834773,
-0.0579594187,
-0.0410795026,
0.050934162,
-0.0586692691,
0.0737486929,
-0.0107529676,
0.0001455907,
0.0008462593,
0.0250227917,
0.0355627127,
-0.0336591415,
0.0271300077,
-0.0060094548,
-0.0469714887,
0.0395018905,
0.0687988326,
-0.0495547466,
0.0125693111,
0.0290096775,
0.0217744503,
-0.0044912323,
-0.0473060422,
0.0673922524,
-0.0549324155,
-0.0312012527,
-0.0354838818,
0.0033180767,
-0.0122269979,
0.0323607996,
-0.0710255429,
-0.0365980305,
0.0227897745,
0.0234825686,
0.0011402278,
-0.0621171966,
-0.0831039697,
-0.0438770987,
-0.0087362146,
-0.0170121938,
-0.0433646515,
-0.0504457913,
-0.0373418964,
0.0338969827,
-0.0651349053,
-0.0277089272,
2.683315419e-34,
0.03148406,
0.0042768721,
0.0037976655,
0.0003721224,
0.0329386964,
-0.0149808507,
-0.0037278484,
0.0135028074,
0.0293030273,
-0.0678152293,
-0.0391244106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01500v1 | Unsupervised Approach to Evaluate Sentence-Level Fluency: Do We Really Need Reference? | 2023-12-03T20:09:23 | 2023-12-03T20:09:23 | Gopichand Kanumolu, Lokesh Madasu, Pavan Baswani, Ananya Mukherjee, Manish Shrivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fluency is a crucial goal of all Natural Language Generation (NLG) systems.
Widely used automatic evaluation metrics fall short in capturing the fluency of
machine-generated text. Assessing the fluency of NLG systems poses a challenge
since these models are not limited to simply reusing words from the input but
may also generate abstractions. Existing reference-based fluency evaluations,
such as word overlap measures, often exhibit weak correlations with human
judgments. This paper adapts an existing unsupervised technique for measuring
text fluency without the need for any reference. Our approach leverages various
word embeddings and trains language models using Recurrent Neural Network (RNN)
architectures. We also experiment with other available multilingual Language
Models (LMs). To assess the performance of the models, we conduct a comparative
analysis across 10 Indic languages, correlating the obtained fluency scores
with human judgments. Our code and human-annotated benchmark test-set for
fluency is available at
https://github.com/AnanyaCoder/TextFluencyForIndicLanaguges. | [
0.0130119929,
0.0651071817,
-0.0133722732,
0.0402986705,
-0.0493366271,
-0.0017750958,
0.0067467033,
-0.0263274815,
-0.002743369,
-0.0353300571,
-0.0099667152,
-0.0479755923,
0.0854381993,
0.018019205,
0.0409206785,
-0.0455291606,
0.0102653913,
0.0069016321,
0.0030487143,
0.0343463384,
0.0200283248,
0.0125665283,
-0.0458670147,
0.0494771525,
-0.0066577392,
-0.0158760808,
0.0245082807,
0.0082184896,
0.0163429901,
-0.0035255654,
0.0077590807,
0.0381481275,
-0.037440706,
0.0420060083,
0.0000017751,
-0.0209513605,
0.0070459377,
-0.0283970572,
0.0500414856,
0.0303760618,
0.0980036482,
-0.0055130883,
-0.0186098348,
0.0380304977,
-0.0353664421,
0.0011835267,
0.050816644,
0.0054490063,
0.0167563818,
0.048639413,
0.0034844575,
-0.0144470148,
0.0122308321,
0.0016753315,
-0.0299628638,
-0.0232182667,
-0.0094474265,
0.0135369301,
-0.0291972887,
-0.0472185872,
-0.0306711607,
0.0457140766,
0.0009462797,
-0.0101543413,
0.0178572796,
0.0078008692,
-0.025468085,
0.0159782581,
0.0093110306,
0.0721243098,
-0.0648009852,
-0.050582625,
-0.0056918836,
0.0014746458,
-0.0210043769,
-0.0015194158,
-0.0052540349,
0.0021881699,
0.0203555021,
0.0309923757,
0.0175027419,
-0.0000660828,
0.0353464521,
0.0266969875,
0.0153981959,
0.018620437,
0.0585328601,
-0.0202034898,
-0.0176688693,
0.0094427001,
0.0496563092,
-0.0355738364,
0.0369775817,
0.038966462,
-0.0383346528,
0.0126837539,
-0.0272466093,
-0.0778087229,
0.0384042673,
-0.0472576953,
-0.0021837512,
0.0365412235,
-0.0084405933,
0.0042083459,
-0.0221312176,
0.0614893585,
0.0147531265,
0.0129959164,
-0.0263287779,
0.0058218259,
-0.0153767243,
-0.0066898824,
-0.0407033041,
0.0024911936,
-0.0385890417,
-0.0249780472,
-0.0773638412,
-0.0245786067,
-0.0210716631,
-0.0361745395,
-0.0390804633,
0.0173776578,
-0.0211785082,
0.0388678238,
0.003623157,
0.0289569199,
-0.0336456448,
-0.0029719651,
0.0229260437,
-0.0583436042,
-0.0056108646,
0.0330770724,
0.0217883531,
-0.0005099914,
-0.0201314166,
0.0343370996,
0.0031480549,
-0.0282695647,
-0.0365093797,
-0.035902597,
-0.0202353653,
-0.0480404682,
-0.021972809,
-0.0839242637,
0.0217091534,
-0.0053444738,
0.0059634214,
-0.0417034291,
-0.0045188963,
0.0518358052,
0.0010774583,
0.0623097718,
-0.0352675319,
0.0098919626,
0.038070865,
0.0019129658,
0.0749140754,
0.0159289502,
0.0699393675,
0.001834326,
0.0614007972,
0.0009566722,
0.0492506288,
0.02279949,
-0.0152370119,
-0.0424895659,
-0.0068851123,
-0.074455604,
-0.066894725,
0.0579005294,
0.0546123572,
0.0604180358,
-0.013284931,
0.0168545619,
0.0340534747,
0.0177992638,
0.0119526749,
0.0155534083,
0.0828334466,
0.0391745381,
0.012372382,
0.0538130552,
0.0468229055,
0.0175225679,
-0.0162142888,
0.0283247568,
0.0953156576,
0.0514851473,
-0.0252687521,
-0.0484260097,
-0.0023060343,
-0.0492922068,
0.0222775172,
-0.0444843769,
0.0336808823,
0.0318451263,
-0.0381265096,
-0.0002795511,
0.0096015148,
-0.0737477615,
0.0651210696,
0.0236173086,
0.0350036658,
0.0717148855,
0.0660486743,
0.0447357222,
0.0315675847,
0.0218024626,
-0.0132179018,
0.0710889474,
0.0350020081,
-0.0016747315,
0.0385910571,
-0.0669089481,
0.0012720426,
-0.0051339651,
0.0313806497,
0.0021577731,
-0.0345380828,
0.0268257484,
0.0597285181,
-0.0544897132,
-0.0675017983,
0.0440564267,
-0.051720202,
0.0049194517,
0.0219091401,
0.0105403764,
0.0176518727,
0.0266069043,
-0.0145890433,
0.0527374186,
0.019014379,
-0.0233495552,
0.0056353831,
0.0135362661,
-0.0298964251,
-0.0624480061,
0.0005790477,
-0.0744423568,
0.0003655557,
0.0359367952,
-0.0287303254,
-0.0623487271,
0.0478444807,
-0.0410732776,
0.0356402434,
-0.0719043091,
0.013328962,
0.0203447547,
0.0389408618,
-0.0241534133,
0.0305797551,
-0.0027658576,
0.0488400906,
0.0229755528,
0.0157913622,
0.0355877541,
-0.0565972924,
-0.063609615,
-0.0261258502,
-0.0101099676,
0.0249985103,
0.0157988016,
0.0320125297,
-0.0461277291,
-0.0279390085,
-0.086246565,
0.0080221891,
-0.0104288226,
-0.0006889526,
0.0167129748,
0.0193681139,
0.0135902837,
-0.008196854,
-0.0323322229,
-0.020346377,
0.0364526473,
0.0003119358,
0.0698471144,
-0.0122390967,
-0.0179808661,
-0.0506578982,
0.0047247009,
0.0077906651,
0.0360617936,
0.043495588,
-0.0218541026,
-0.039753478,
0.005684427,
-0.0404181741,
-0.0321577489,
0.0454439148,
-0.0781072304,
0.0129396971,
0.0491388887,
0.0725387037,
0.0281215385,
0.0348379165,
0.0062816041,
0.0379776545,
-0.0225038845,
-0.0153514361,
-0.0317568742,
-0.0124492161,
0.0234720893,
0.0242318679,
-0.0136035737,
0.0023313826,
0.0310826637,
0.0534363352,
0.0073090899,
-0.0178576987,
0.0292398743,
-0.0284345467,
0.0033636931,
-0.0307095721,
0.0198102091,
-0.0442424938,
0.0397299118,
-0.0276361667,
-0.0368367322,
0.046826493,
-0.0643587857,
-0.0132744256,
-0.0341246054,
0.0239120405,
-0.0447588451,
-0.0372201279,
-0.0065813935,
0.0170570482,
-0.0340610519,
-0.0275100861,
-0.0360477529,
0.0437209494,
-0.0104606869,
-0.0626080856,
0.0266975276,
-0.0718564242,
-0.0122713577,
0.0223137904,
-0.0328337997,
-0.0478063785,
-0.0121372947,
0.0059365341,
0.002043172,
0.0422517695,
-0.0055321096,
-0.0188225321,
0.0030863127,
0.0136569329,
0.0027199707,
-0.0079286452,
0.0033030366,
0.0087860385,
0.0763153508,
0.0542627685,
-0.0002333586,
0.035822738,
0.0016369601,
-0.0134117622,
-0.0031630273,
-0.0021502615,
0.0339218453,
-0.0441888832,
-0.0063769114,
-0.0047720238,
-0.0224344209,
0.0056301644,
0.0280097835,
0.0382626727,
-0.0422001183,
-0.0523061082,
0.115900062,
0.0157740805,
-0.0091812918,
-0.0014570018,
-0.01203088,
0.0331715196,
-0.0029870828,
0.0210605282,
-0.0513606891,
-0.032057263,
-0.0160228405,
0.0158548709,
0.0038353098,
-0.0262224264,
-0.021978585,
-0.1156040877,
-0.0125581408,
0.0446624383,
-0.0516506359,
-0.0547326356,
0.0068593621,
-0.0205743685,
-0.0011495966,
0.024392968,
0.0060840212,
-0.0044400948,
0.0237384997,
0.0010376383,
-0.0790657923,
-0.0815824196,
-0.0319326296,
-0.0291431937,
0.0712262765,
0.0517792962,
0.040101096,
-0.0036554236,
-0.0716084093,
-0.0020495551,
-0.0525378063,
-0.0143704191,
-0.0018067721,
0.0486898907,
-0.028558284,
-0.0133899134,
-0.0192894097,
-0.0003627076,
-0.0250059236,
-0.0092300074,
-0.0138776395,
0.0102376118,
0.0021843247,
-0.0233704131,
-0.0243380237,
0.028209189,
0.0343232863,
0.0767239928,
0.0689139292,
-0.051228445,
-0.0505912565,
-0.017493926,
0.0051660226,
-0.0704457238,
-0.007040943,
0.0031984074,
0.030058125,
-0.0135729834,
-0.108989045,
-0.0761264339,
0.0233659502,
-0.0008928529,
0.0268493071,
0.0452751294,
-0.0118640754,
-0.0179170519,
-0.0160757285,
-0.0154801132,
-0.0288448669,
0.011865369,
-0.0899591297,
-0.0067179082,
-0.0297767501,
-0.004130627,
-0.0139919212,
0.0527736805,
-0.0317882001,
-0.0456435159,
0.0132179381,
0.0194434412,
0.0134248314,
-0.0070525105,
-0.0484872498,
-0.0558934361,
0.0493919849,
0.0037912207,
-0.0651520118,
0.0345415063,
0.0099686729,
-0.0148553038,
-0.0043592514,
0.0258626491,
-0.0425991528,
0.0028151411,
-0.031307891,
0.0604903027,
0.009551187,
-0.0496415757,
-0.0024034858,
0.0088496907,
0.0485386252,
-0.0593997724,
0.0216223691,
-0.0370024629,
-0.0423839316,
0.0048672808,
-0.007258947,
-0.046772968,
-0.00398556,
0.0265260693,
-0.0034823273,
-0.0406912193,
-0.0258322321,
-0.0324021429,
0.0175114833,
0.0792986155,
-0.021211734,
-0.0063802046,
0.0554580502,
-0.0371822864,
-0.0008939553,
-0.0362931229,
-0.0084138718,
-0.0704799145,
0.0179683939,
0.0031970032,
0.0161368363,
0.0028989229,
0.0021541966,
0.018688852,
0.0450138375,
-0.0082255043,
0.0712387264,
-0.0387102179,
-0.0037993344,
0.0720097125,
-0.0336642116,
0.0720348358,
-0.0139578162,
0.0375142694,
-0.0449802019,
0.064244844,
-0.0034692553,
-0.0501235984,
0.0208445489,
-0.0114291022,
-0.0403709374,
-0.009837714,
0.0848057717,
0.0239074994,
-0.0225656889,
0.0074503808,
-0.0147132948,
-0.0215589385,
0.0039436161,
0.00134142,
0.0329197012,
-0.0327291265,
-0.0081653669,
-0.0627531931,
-0.0642334521,
0.0579151921,
0.0439201593,
0.0094214259,
0.0220700782,
0.0257108789,
0.0286695603,
-0.0200689491,
0.0597892813,
-0.0595156103,
-0.0113731921,
-0.0290625747,
-0.0372108482,
-0.0392331071,
-5.901654244e-33,
-0.0454127528,
-0.0678850785,
-0.0156145338,
-0.0161614362,
-0.0177888945,
0.0022231028,
-0.073901549,
0.0149971005,
0.007103119,
0.020712385,
0.0269306079,
-0.0004620672,
0.0062230853,
0.0315576307,
0.0146701485,
0.0175834689,
0.0379839614,
0.0196014382,
-0.0254911799,
0.0168218054,
0.0398403183,
0.0242744144,
0.0615668222,
-0.0299698021,
0.0125530837,
-0.0339067318,
-0.0016191205,
-0.0013646592,
0.0308205765,
0.0527799837,
-0.0322329551,
0.0644472688,
0.0229362994,
0.0152151035,
-0.0333432518,
0.0164852366,
-0.0470841005,
-0.053504955,
0.0303963702,
0.0115035493,
-0.0591110662,
-0.0156739671,
0.0516728945,
-0.0155050131,
-0.0072319345,
0.0279144142,
0.0436285585,
-0.0257937126,
-0.0097655468,
-0.0043115974,
-0.048819758,
0.0393694267,
-0.011792494,
-0.000544756,
0.0097169867,
0.0259218737,
-0.0215470269,
-0.0192622636,
-0.0675357878,
0.0258290637,
-0.0321633182,
0.0449384712,
0.0554753207,
-0.0196079332,
-0.0288023613,
0.0665741935,
-0.0267192926,
-0.0421412326,
0.0209254697,
-0.0094322534,
0.0476306491,
0.0259097591,
0.0537294634,
0.0851967037,
0.0664446354,
-0.0566822514,
-0.0526218377,
0.0581009462,
-0.023209678,
0.0411711261,
0.0291463081,
-0.01969558,
-0.0410435162,
-0.0121796485,
-0.017808646,
-0.0200457834,
-0.0360641479,
-0.0488206968,
0.0590846464,
0.0023116388,
0.0085264593,
-0.0175382961,
0.0189123582,
-0.0358511358,
-0.0073887748,
0.0315676704,
-0.0299897101,
0.0038944716,
-0.0137919588,
0.0120621286,
-0.0371986143,
-0.0142893372,
0.0235678442,
0.0689763427,
0.0138563681,
-0.030486485,
0.0457714759,
0.0007269446,
-0.0376072824,
0.0137126874,
-0.0261191092,
0.0228604209,
-0.0301202908,
-0.0447105244,
0.0163805149,
-0.0171628203,
-0.035139937,
0.0282758363,
-0.0327809155,
-0.014731613,
-0.0184711032,
-0.0551153049,
0.0136787966,
0.013839039,
-0.0686071962,
-0.011988881,
0.0016051249,
0.0125643592,
0.0138934432,
-0.0291977059,
0.0035022001,
0.0391605347,
2.529e-7,
0.0541845225,
0.0319755562,
0.051727742,
-0.0016235263,
-0.0003596268,
-0.0199569725,
-0.0404461175,
0.0267559085,
-0.025374895,
0.0271500479,
0.000092733,
-0.0132975141,
0.0930488035,
-0.0121310605,
-0.0889409557,
0.0078142323,
-0.0426045656,
0.0317791365,
-0.0200949032,
-0.0354475118,
0.0218572151,
0.0466998778,
-0.0037686839,
0.0054328521,
-0.0217541978,
-0.0529941693,
0.064475663,
0.0025063569,
0.0053911377,
-0.0094130412,
0.0873503312,
0.0303281955,
0.0191599354,
-0.0157658663,
-0.0396809131,
0.0050374754,
0.0630752966,
0.0444303229,
0.0256065596,
-0.0402695015,
0.0216957703,
-0.013152861,
-0.0159399435,
-0.0357000344,
0.0280495826,
-0.040987175,
-0.0105312159,
-0.0068486077,
-0.0229215585,
0.0195656139,
0.0494249575,
-0.0165866837,
-0.0757712424,
0.0127752377,
0.0344056487,
-0.0052563334,
-0.0176198967,
-0.0254082438,
-0.0362746418,
0.0088305175,
-0.0111264894,
0.0180051513,
-0.0374163613,
-0.031341318,
0.0324855745,
-0.0603623092,
0.018194668,
2.04614743e-34,
0.0658254847,
-0.0135779204,
0.025230255,
-0.011203344,
0.0363008417,
-0.0162227228,
0.0164227355,
0.0189786442,
0.0123833166,
-0.0547037385,
0.0103871031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01454v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01454v2 | D-Bot: Database Diagnosis System using Large Language Models | 2023-12-03T16:58:10 | 2023-12-06T02:53:11 | Xuanhe Zhou, Guoliang Li, Zhaoyan Sun, Zhiyuan Liu, Weize Chen, Jianming Wu, Jiesi Liu, Ruohang Feng, Guoyang Zeng | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Database administrators (DBAs) play an important role in managing,
maintaining and optimizing database systems. However, it is hard and tedious
for DBAs to manage a large number of databases and give timely response
(waiting for hours is intolerable in many online cases). In addition, existing
empirical methods only support limited diagnosis scenarios, which are also
labor-intensive to update the diagnosis rules for database version updates.
Recently large language models (LLMs) have shown great potential in various
fields. Thus, we propose D-Bot, an LLM-based database diagnosis system that can
automatically acquire knowledge from diagnosis documents, and generate
reasonable and well-founded diagnosis report (i.e., identifying the root causes
and solutions) within acceptable time (e.g., under 10 minutes compared to hours
by a DBA). The techniques in D-Bot include (i) offline knowledge extraction
from documents, (ii) automatic prompt generation (e.g., knowledge matching,
tool retrieval), (iii) root cause analysis using tree search algorithm, and
(iv) collaborative mechanism for complex anomalies with multiple root causes.
We verify D-Bot on real benchmarks (including 539 anomalies of six typical
applications), and the results show that D-Bot can effectively analyze the root
causes of unseen anomalies and significantly outperforms traditional methods
and vanilla models like GPT-4. | [
0.0569700524,
0.0254024994,
-0.024045229,
0.059874583,
-0.0244269799,
0.002469487,
-0.0472487397,
0.0951266289,
0.0445526764,
-0.0222719666,
0.0810357258,
-0.0069365213,
-0.0473168753,
0.0355915204,
-0.0119688483,
-0.0142232496,
0.0430813059,
-0.0429615974,
0.0161532126,
-0.0113635659,
-0.0055168853,
0.0063648275,
0.03197648,
-0.0061442442,
-0.0325039215,
-0.0000329572,
-0.0342950001,
0.0230589639,
-0.0036302954,
-0.0050226678,
-0.0189090446,
-0.0166261066,
-0.0247964468,
0.0122032976,
0.0000024127,
-0.0447505787,
-0.0628663227,
0.0084322197,
-0.0647256374,
0.0375429429,
-0.028268015,
-0.0300763007,
-0.008564773,
0.0379995517,
-0.0176384449,
-0.0194636118,
0.0181286391,
0.0413897857,
0.0177613497,
0.0509007238,
0.0056524258,
-0.0078393873,
0.0002140064,
-0.0035276613,
-0.0003491465,
-0.0670715347,
0.0405348688,
0.048128698,
0.0513503514,
-0.0110009983,
-0.0160479732,
-0.0358213224,
-0.0151213594,
-0.0167774428,
-0.042146109,
0.0000761989,
0.034109883,
0.0122708334,
0.0258339383,
0.0331930481,
-0.0165261086,
-0.0069810394,
0.0493802205,
-0.0013599111,
-0.0113343531,
0.0141817285,
0.0235445928,
0.063147597,
-0.0255612936,
-0.0126965558,
0.0499023348,
-0.0588860884,
0.0261432659,
-0.0371001586,
-0.0477123931,
0.0616546087,
-0.0177504029,
-0.0551298894,
-0.0271669403,
-0.0409853682,
-0.011039109,
-0.0298966784,
-0.0007969523,
0.047499612,
-0.0693908334,
0.0303104576,
0.0232723933,
0.0235284641,
0.0593964048,
-0.0417564027,
-0.031217549,
0.0168032441,
-0.0410235748,
0.0178614985,
0.0136803389,
0.0521328487,
-0.0061769709,
0.0042438703,
-0.0109277787,
-0.0318959169,
-0.0542517565,
0.0012815619,
-0.015356821,
-0.011880802,
0.0113940127,
-0.0108055435,
-0.0296118911,
0.0555669814,
0.0125972852,
0.0535467379,
-0.0001718631,
-0.027899947,
0.0048826747,
0.0065286597,
-0.0324122235,
-0.0381451547,
0.0172677208,
-0.0200684555,
-0.0506792553,
-0.0435786955,
-0.0364638194,
0.0133807613,
0.0014851879,
0.0175882895,
0.0420396216,
0.0328099206,
0.0478781834,
0.0389876366,
-0.0963200033,
-0.0673120916,
-0.0344371423,
-0.021653099,
-0.1065720543,
-0.0107534574,
-0.035241928,
0.0036937022,
0.0166433956,
0.0118344417,
-0.0169482641,
-0.0299894009,
-0.0026543573,
0.00759453,
-0.110056065,
0.0540433675,
0.0133242132,
0.0310797933,
0.0228534825,
0.0325314142,
-0.0369073227,
-0.0037750567,
0.011745695,
-0.0177917946,
0.066333808,
-0.0231016446,
0.0122245811,
0.0052955146,
-0.0036241203,
0.0090074455,
0.022084726,
0.0115150474,
-0.026213849,
0.0201342832,
0.0358712561,
0.0139079737,
-0.0276328102,
-0.0094259428,
-0.0056522586,
0.0061054109,
0.035489291,
-0.0347009972,
-0.0308690555,
0.004700202,
0.0101804808,
-0.0198711697,
-0.0722451881,
-0.0091432584,
-0.0151848532,
-0.0087102363,
-0.0253573246,
-0.0452142097,
-0.0586655624,
0.0199169014,
-0.064346388,
-0.0120075215,
0.0542040318,
0.0021076612,
0.0125200842,
0.0372345187,
0.020785749,
0.0068567931,
-0.0431450568,
-0.0609855689,
0.0298228543,
0.0872542858,
0.0223675855,
-0.0972308218,
-0.0353979282,
0.029046379,
-0.0047697979,
-0.0117265442,
0.0039362065,
-0.0204898529,
-0.0265237987,
0.0036237463,
-0.0149598802,
0.0540208891,
0.0714482591,
0.0025151451,
-0.056295041,
0.0384261571,
0.0103243832,
-0.0768945813,
-0.0656911656,
0.0170568675,
-0.0109404661,
-0.0086863013,
0.0314674489,
0.0304680634,
0.0278365687,
0.0033459852,
-0.0254016407,
-0.0219666418,
0.035528928,
-0.0062945904,
-0.0720595941,
0.0141973598,
0.033952903,
0.017323222,
0.0050833481,
0.0404486284,
0.0032700512,
-0.0331510864,
-0.0412497893,
-0.0591094382,
0.0569425263,
-0.0502148382,
-0.0331651308,
-0.0097612748,
0.0475180708,
-0.0264858268,
0.0070221834,
-0.0185871013,
0.0576528646,
0.0396947637,
0.0049348651,
-0.0114357807,
-0.0215029996,
0.0585171916,
-0.0140898777,
-0.0184790157,
0.0290274303,
-0.0292200651,
0.0236275196,
-0.004817008,
0.0055547082,
-0.0190724079,
-0.0007171058,
-0.0736715868,
0.0177612975,
-0.001561686,
0.0048443275,
0.0333982445,
0.0443556942,
-0.0073190238,
-0.0303431097,
-0.0471735261,
0.0081667891,
0.0316277444,
0.0251511373,
0.0491452701,
-0.0012508571,
-0.0433302857,
-0.015254966,
0.0030375903,
-0.0606600717,
0.0093578966,
0.0148381628,
-0.0217099935,
-0.0445147194,
0.0493129753,
-0.0103894016,
0.0081246467,
-0.0247403774,
0.0001165313,
-0.0548765957,
-0.0746666417,
-0.0284890942,
0.0456888415,
-0.037395563,
0.0373975486,
0.0200483762,
0.0166255161,
-0.0476884916,
-0.0342715681,
0.0098748403,
0.0004479173,
0.0521937832,
-0.0483649671,
0.0337349437,
-0.0028902558,
0.0401159525,
-0.0237092953,
-0.0534351207,
-0.0134421838,
0.0127724856,
0.0604390502,
-0.0403471068,
-0.0608028248,
0.0182545595,
0.0373803303,
0.007065332,
-0.0315879285,
0.0496487282,
-0.0086871386,
0.0122409835,
-0.0406608842,
-0.080881685,
-0.0681880563,
0.039653156,
0.0140422583,
0.0388319567,
-0.0300509352,
-0.0782263055,
0.0374630913,
-0.0115230987,
0.0669298172,
-0.0096238917,
0.0067831273,
-0.0516299494,
0.043889001,
0.0205565915,
-0.0167106558,
-0.0051970021,
-0.0408977307,
-0.0089293318,
-0.0230191424,
0.0186661109,
0.0041765566,
-0.0052911486,
0.0326398909,
-0.0002546843,
0.0485085733,
0.0419173501,
-0.0124120386,
0.0048126257,
-0.0351142958,
-0.049154859,
-0.0474487804,
0.0051813656,
-0.045033168,
0.0568481535,
0.0190292895,
0.0052227969,
-0.0372276641,
-0.0053387238,
0.0128453458,
-0.0305164624,
-0.0174540821,
-0.0195266679,
-0.0104632713,
-0.0804256573,
-0.0542868748,
-0.0173754562,
0.0635656342,
0.000112293,
-0.0158321932,
0.0014584794,
-0.0284782667,
-0.0457871556,
0.0068853335,
0.0242346078,
-0.11482355,
-0.0076962132,
0.0091598528,
0.0262080561,
0.032515578,
-0.0091892956,
0.0322776213,
-0.0563789941,
0.0028437371,
-0.0219336655,
0.0105853556,
-0.0363234617,
-0.0249462686,
-0.0077388682,
-0.0253389068,
0.0117357839,
0.0571043603,
0.009040962,
-0.0002370431,
0.0302919056,
-0.0540180467,
-0.0590988211,
0.0428134687,
-0.0375080109,
0.0236248411,
0.0378770865,
-0.0215997379,
0.0262529105,
0.017616909,
0.0223138649,
0.0488653257,
0.0412114561,
-0.0552483164,
0.0651496053,
0.0517465249,
-0.0145607376,
0.0441345014,
-0.0118455868,
-0.0669793785,
0.0608844645,
0.072816819,
0.0845204741,
-0.0487860143,
-0.0073135123,
0.0065904623,
-0.0472455397,
0.0303230062,
0.0510967188,
-0.0032607482,
-0.0356350578,
-0.0394335501,
0.068163164,
-0.0196879897,
0.0198513754,
0.0209529083,
0.0229897238,
-0.04311914,
-0.0372826383,
-0.0377532691,
-0.001051893,
0.0252351575,
0.0117703294,
0.0530570373,
0.0058671902,
-0.0337295234,
0.0046758354,
-0.0108618652,
-0.0086506875,
-0.0057013831,
0.0252820849,
-0.0456712991,
0.0340129435,
0.0088306153,
0.0367600024,
-0.0026777645,
-0.035513211,
0.0034199613,
-0.0253338106,
0.039265655,
-0.034040004,
0.0097204242,
0.0074509922,
-0.0083272783,
-0.0498888679,
-0.0299648866,
0.0100702196,
-0.0160772502,
-0.0110172359,
-0.0405707471,
-0.053678669,
0.0121675441,
-0.0049306727,
-0.0395998433,
0.005851543,
-0.0253507011,
-0.043779891,
-0.0790724233,
-0.0251771137,
0.0359989554,
0.0723852366,
0.0121953078,
0.0725120008,
-0.0613357425,
-0.0082530165,
0.0408259481,
-0.056824062,
-0.0163903702,
0.0036700447,
0.1003445238,
0.0181897301,
-0.0273858123,
0.0216500163,
-0.0160400756,
0.0067810239,
-0.0546757653,
0.005542119,
-0.0036071492,
0.0407348722,
-0.0020408786,
0.0646527335,
-0.0167449005,
0.0121832257,
-0.0128776878,
0.0419115536,
0.0590807796,
-0.0098517835,
0.033006005,
0.0232959762,
0.0154942004,
-0.0222856477,
-0.0277436618,
-0.0076604015,
-0.0331383348,
0.0595062301,
-0.0156618264,
0.0780624226,
-0.0038828796,
-0.0079182787,
-0.008552839,
0.0074668685,
-0.0065863924,
-0.0040021264,
0.030952489,
0.0180911869,
0.0336261466,
-0.0104277721,
-0.0474048704,
0.010610654,
0.0814096779,
0.0055472082,
0.0063031046,
-0.0356504284,
-0.0328725204,
-0.0309742782,
0.0473762974,
0.019128887,
0.0148190679,
-0.0236478671,
-0.0146719646,
-0.0454454795,
0.0096045705,
0.0153547497,
0.0176236518,
-0.0466067679,
-0.0217784327,
-0.002703032,
0.1063669175,
0.085556522,
0.0263416357,
-0.045469068,
-0.0185135882,
-0.0531446934,
-0.0184393842,
0.005287467,
-6.079286869e-33,
-0.0251886509,
-0.0817082375,
-0.0363401361,
-0.0062992689,
0.0457938574,
-0.0094441166,
-0.0401019342,
0.0441893078,
0.0285964571,
0.0251742639,
0.0036860022,
0.0554552712,
0.0155423628,
-0.0220074784,
0.0749897212,
0.0333715603,
0.0110692875,
0.0570833385,
0.0121667003,
0.0256454181,
0.1272724867,
0.0115481531,
-0.0013960741,
-0.0724130645,
-0.0010645216,
-0.0075657745,
-0.0055642216,
0.0429839939,
-0.0232669283,
0.0248099882,
0.00005804,
0.0207007676,
-0.0005997834,
0.0009226908,
0.0219939444,
-0.0882956833,
0.0261615869,
-0.0026648496,
0.0177971683,
0.0012679639,
0.0502679199,
0.0065252921,
0.013702766,
-0.0113817193,
0.0349457599,
0.0600054264,
0.0447159857,
-0.0482718609,
-0.0022398692,
-0.038445197,
0.0133672766,
0.0248652082,
-0.0396355093,
0.0425645262,
0.0139498683,
-0.0032550525,
0.0172058754,
0.0305001531,
-0.0221696515,
0.0159697495,
0.0643037632,
0.0242015496,
0.0136586856,
0.0140490802,
-0.0234910771,
-0.0104966806,
-0.0013514999,
-0.0100776544,
0.0076780147,
0.0177469179,
-0.0428656079,
0.0799213797,
0.0355045572,
0.0190520994,
0.0150710419,
-0.0331623219,
-0.0506916158,
0.0457055047,
0.0497765504,
0.0011174588,
0.0253739916,
-0.0008563176,
-0.0867422372,
-0.031884212,
-0.0054247612,
0.0738369226,
-0.0676790848,
0.0115892077,
0.0301588066,
0.000597409,
0.0084628966,
-0.0352065526,
0.0181704126,
-0.0440392718,
-0.0306821391,
0.0226603411,
-0.0449767411,
-0.0762469918,
-0.0315455794,
0.0135863172,
-0.0293057542,
-0.0559555702,
-0.0373806655,
0.0287359376,
0.018042367,
0.035121873,
-0.0034848356,
-0.0020309931,
-0.0510837957,
0.024747422,
-0.0176574681,
0.0148682166,
-0.0771627352,
0.0268835071,
0.0037593693,
-0.0002723634,
0.0081131253,
0.0418814458,
0.0842272565,
0.0208208431,
-0.0234623216,
-0.0020215928,
-0.024116056,
-0.0135385524,
-0.007645268,
-0.001298517,
0.0053329142,
-0.0307111237,
0.0621812046,
-0.0091404878,
0.0135859894,
0.0505849645,
3.059e-7,
0.0191425588,
0.0261554196,
0.0052087591,
-0.0094756642,
0.0323416665,
0.0419873707,
-0.0295211114,
-0.0531180464,
-0.0082119703,
0.0072826939,
0.0345045514,
-0.0404413678,
0.0510233268,
0.0055109188,
-0.0136460681,
0.0190430358,
-0.033896815,
-0.0396462902,
-0.0748471022,
-0.010341662,
0.0223203115,
0.0302166007,
0.0021999588,
-0.0290491749,
0.0461825319,
-0.0453520343,
-0.0177703835,
0.0006520443,
-0.0079446277,
0.0442104526,
0.0828210339,
0.0384968296,
0.0136220045,
0.0675875545,
0.002633072,
-0.0076686474,
-0.0659311935,
0.0267439708,
0.0050301887,
0.0439166352,
0.0003378621,
-0.0734939277,
0.0044701174,
-0.0179586336,
0.0788713172,
0.0110629955,
-0.0153795388,
0.0437112451,
0.0147241419,
-0.0515532829,
-0.0047041588,
-0.0211873576,
-0.031151969,
0.0310573094,
-0.0325427242,
0.0005477839,
0.0257982928,
-0.0345795043,
-0.0174553432,
0.0506259762,
-0.0409706645,
-0.0160228554,
0.0370835848,
0.0039041992,
0.0016187493,
-0.0396696888,
0.0156113915,
3.114297106e-34,
0.043923676,
0.017835537,
0.0041020731,
-0.0156170372,
0.0240547676,
0.0292669795,
-0.0163736194,
0.0009446472,
-0.0354270972,
-0.0454576276,
0.0098044034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02219v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02219v2 | Behind the Magic, MERLIM: Multi-modal Evaluation Benchmark for Large Image-Language Models | 2023-12-03T16:39:36 | 2024-06-12T14:59:55 | Andrés Villa, Juan Carlos León Alcázar, Alvaro Soto, Bernard Ghanem | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large Vision and Language Models have enabled significant advances in fully
supervised and zero-shot visual tasks. These large architectures serve as the
baseline to what is currently known as Instruction Tuning Large Vision and
Language models (IT-LVLMs). IT-LVLMs are general-purpose multi-modal assistants
whose responses are modulated by natural language instructions and visual data.
Despite this versatility, IT-LVLM effectiveness in fundamental computer vision
problems remains unclear, primarily due to the absence of a standardized
evaluation benchmark. This paper introduces a Multi-modal Evaluation Benchmark
named MERLIM, a scalable test-bed to assess the capabilities of IT-LVLMs on
fundamental computer vision tasks. MERLIM contains over 300K image-question
pairs and has a strong focus on detecting cross-modal "hallucination" events in
IT-LVLMs. Our results bring important insights on the performance of
state-of-the-art IT-LVMLs including limitations at identifying fine-grained
visual concepts, object hallucinations across tasks, and biases towards the
language query. Our findings also suggest that these models have weak visual
grounding, but manage to make adequate guesses from global visual patterns or
language biases contained in the LLM component. | [
0.0022843853,
0.0494445115,
-0.0012873579,
0.0670913607,
-0.0455550514,
0.0249306951,
0.0200957134,
-0.0068559102,
0.014996523,
-0.0872327983,
-0.0481854863,
-0.0522419587,
-0.0167498011,
0.0196077414,
0.0346548147,
-0.0405884422,
0.0366953127,
-0.05810358,
-0.0394032523,
0.0060647209,
0.0074986853,
-0.0159961954,
-0.0041335826,
0.0583987832,
-0.0053577148,
-0.0228444524,
-0.0154298078,
0.026766533,
0.0086276298,
-0.0093768574,
-0.0375889651,
0.021128431,
0.0364176631,
0.0080744876,
0.0000019182,
-0.038208656,
0.0209244974,
-0.0064979005,
-0.0062223934,
-0.012792971,
0.0346122384,
-0.0187282991,
-0.0005016316,
-0.0087449076,
-0.0195556991,
-0.0316860378,
0.0556336269,
0.0524341837,
0.0514833666,
0.0618489124,
-0.0140704466,
-0.0270757191,
0.0215206612,
0.0026995977,
0.0568028837,
-0.0518619493,
0.0320961177,
0.0233112983,
0.011084564,
-0.0274268854,
-0.0482516736,
0.0327753238,
0.0387764759,
-0.0082556298,
-0.0214621518,
0.038579002,
-0.061299406,
-0.0328495465,
-0.0304529816,
0.0750645846,
-0.0389489308,
-0.0049114092,
-0.0200636499,
0.0120570147,
0.0122248931,
-0.0200736392,
-0.0320116095,
0.0334369652,
-0.0151650943,
-0.000811804,
-0.0197042115,
-0.0263906922,
0.012060672,
0.0091967797,
-0.034078598,
0.0133461663,
0.0327376239,
0.0116792107,
0.020082064,
0.0253700204,
-0.0462284386,
-0.0663947538,
-0.0240028445,
0.0427332446,
-0.0508989729,
-0.0254105106,
-0.0522161312,
0.0049665333,
-0.0075412882,
-0.0437166244,
0.0686256662,
0.002274933,
-0.0899235234,
0.0899228677,
-0.0177769344,
0.0680675507,
-0.0373890176,
0.054753501,
-0.0262698606,
-0.0239818878,
-0.0278335903,
0.0271710269,
-0.0189612638,
-0.0187294837,
-0.059105821,
-0.0450047553,
-0.0037049884,
0.01831224,
-0.0222477298,
0.0269237477,
-0.0162270572,
0.0131016308,
0.005092117,
-0.0370267406,
-0.0297596324,
0.0377290919,
-0.0010046738,
0.0041840631,
-0.012292577,
-0.0868988037,
0.0110576795,
0.0577316061,
-0.0067838025,
-0.0171433259,
0.0128570339,
0.0863233954,
-0.0421918407,
-0.0500974655,
-0.0375532694,
-0.0197312571,
-0.0232649352,
-0.0718176067,
0.0590557456,
-0.0463494249,
0.0091685364,
-0.014374081,
0.0074324212,
-0.0014688136,
0.0198592003,
0.003056108,
-0.012048034,
0.1075382754,
0.0179583933,
-0.0167741328,
-0.0094219791,
0.0220578071,
0.0075454777,
0.0777435228,
-0.0021787581,
0.053300295,
0.0270679537,
0.0029156478,
0.0574308261,
0.0341905504,
-0.0316819437,
0.0218613036,
-0.0832390115,
0.034682706,
0.0052461033,
0.0220911466,
0.0130959507,
0.0512806587,
-0.0144155314,
-0.0517060272,
0.0653533563,
0.0259001944,
0.0028319885,
-0.0294014644,
0.0508651026,
0.0022727456,
-0.0041005271,
0.0000051189,
-0.0872254744,
0.0404800251,
-0.0214291122,
-0.0329585969,
-0.0158177689,
0.0106254714,
-0.0579267628,
-0.0366670266,
-0.0044801296,
-0.007186004,
-0.0110144867,
0.046574194,
0.034442272,
0.0060002273,
-0.0463701524,
0.0038300387,
0.0070273075,
0.0055661551,
-0.0105533535,
-0.0584301688,
0.023568863,
0.0697114244,
0.0311514512,
-0.0152130732,
-0.0219735727,
-0.0023497853,
0.0668635443,
0.0599057861,
-0.0168608837,
0.0178199001,
0.051685039,
-0.043154534,
-0.0390270464,
-0.023333855,
0.0186490212,
0.0089352317,
-0.0214248896,
-0.0130012864,
0.0032940565,
-0.0433436781,
-0.005234696,
0.0535089038,
0.0251154341,
-0.0073131584,
-0.0229694303,
0.0354946516,
-0.0111188143,
-0.0307834484,
-0.0149922622,
0.0039674519,
0.0116422772,
-0.0331227146,
0.0005847755,
0.0114017082,
-0.0179331992,
-0.0102692824,
0.0333503075,
-0.0593017451,
-0.0101003619,
0.0170947891,
-0.0274655651,
-0.0104781426,
0.0254512038,
-0.0229747538,
-0.0050918995,
-0.0318725556,
0.0202138443,
0.0176522732,
0.0342136286,
-0.0172591861,
0.0298132207,
-0.0370144174,
-0.0212870706,
0.0336986631,
0.0283599328,
0.0043322477,
-0.0039368598,
-0.0352856703,
0.004069767,
-0.0031788708,
0.008784146,
-0.0322296172,
0.0187812094,
-0.0720428675,
-0.0191680882,
-0.0892052576,
-0.0277290698,
-0.0478618108,
-0.0315447859,
0.0042230948,
-0.0227481369,
0.0069400957,
-0.0467085503,
-0.0109074209,
0.043634221,
0.004622113,
0.0315179452,
0.0150262341,
0.0238096472,
-0.0196926016,
-0.0310530216,
0.0092355888,
0.0192334801,
0.0558547229,
0.0177303515,
0.0021344633,
-0.0425636135,
0.0252343882,
-0.0251594465,
0.0643560961,
-0.0308139343,
-0.0133792451,
0.0175698884,
-0.0451398417,
0.0421722904,
0.1143511161,
-0.0118905352,
0.0180065129,
0.0415099859,
-0.044038333,
-0.0375185274,
-0.0042933961,
0.0257178843,
-0.0513078868,
-0.0282427985,
-0.0085375449,
-0.0245621353,
0.0488738865,
-0.0418063365,
0.0229542144,
-0.0600315668,
0.0307818968,
-0.0071503459,
-0.0784787461,
-0.0378882848,
0.0265996512,
0.0235776063,
0.0449768789,
-0.0452402681,
-0.0811839849,
0.0304731932,
-0.0303370841,
-0.0319527872,
0.0429187529,
0.0158153642,
-0.0217591804,
0.0842189863,
0.0400119983,
0.013599081,
-0.0389413871,
-0.007909501,
-0.0540198199,
-0.0109874578,
-0.0404483639,
0.001738639,
0.0942629352,
-0.0760592073,
0.0093985982,
-0.0274097826,
-0.0252931435,
-0.032687474,
-0.0112062441,
-0.0184260067,
-0.003376436,
-0.0529219545,
-0.0135123078,
-0.0387967713,
0.0244587623,
0.0172172356,
-0.0052588973,
-0.0027227858,
-0.0275484249,
-0.0287972074,
0.0188533384,
0.0790273249,
0.0176861584,
-0.0082282592,
-0.0339064375,
0.0175809748,
0.0640175194,
0.0380239151,
0.0163180232,
-0.0556564704,
0.0405788459,
0.0278327558,
0.0298547968,
0.0012126254,
0.0381015018,
0.0845663771,
-0.0651046261,
-0.031803377,
0.0718754828,
0.0060660886,
-0.0686182678,
-0.0286448039,
0.0038454246,
0.0350177772,
0.0391737744,
0.0101620685,
-0.0849663541,
-0.0602033287,
-0.0310350303,
-0.0153681431,
0.007132784,
-0.013671102,
-0.0125624398,
-0.0941497087,
0.0739072412,
-0.0042662318,
-0.0205188729,
-0.040816009,
0.0216800403,
0.0101633426,
-0.0098913088,
0.0139988018,
-0.0321512967,
-0.0003033741,
-0.0318794027,
0.000291944,
0.0401624553,
-0.0344272852,
0.0518287681,
-0.0596728623,
0.0080184704,
0.0576719195,
0.0081763947,
-0.0041177156,
-0.0856310129,
0.0341637023,
0.0022185161,
0.0048190216,
0.0094681019,
0.0346700698,
-0.0256389435,
-0.0461824164,
0.0272680987,
0.0090471581,
-0.0222409628,
0.0006573538,
-0.0077354955,
0.0395916812,
-0.0385928676,
-0.0034650511,
-0.0272004511,
0.0010088164,
0.0061401827,
0.0469737314,
0.0342184827,
-0.0400902145,
-0.0417425521,
-0.0024669536,
-0.0020873407,
-0.0406512991,
-0.0349909328,
0.024142269,
0.0197299477,
0.0006974157,
-0.0434387438,
-0.0341490135,
0.0479646996,
0.0487211347,
-0.013929789,
-0.0456111878,
-0.0167616345,
0.0087677594,
-0.0380119979,
0.0718634278,
-0.0332547724,
0.0445584357,
-0.0592742972,
0.0125726853,
0.0364215001,
-0.0211134013,
-0.0044500353,
0.037351273,
-0.1116902381,
-0.0265224017,
0.009317697,
0.0821900368,
0.0106089311,
0.0555818491,
-0.0027862308,
-0.0467352457,
-0.0108541483,
0.0193988681,
0.0290584434,
0.0345651656,
0.004740017,
-0.0280986037,
-0.0064215227,
0.047626406,
-0.0299152322,
0.0327995643,
0.0512356907,
-0.0137948152,
-0.0131192729,
-0.0306087956,
0.0147537766,
-0.0015494437,
0.0215194374,
-0.0105994986,
0.0347664841,
0.0027229134,
0.0071510249,
0.0175164342,
-0.0162647124,
-0.0779981241,
-0.0085637029,
0.0307972804,
-0.0112522403,
0.0215210486,
0.0058938586,
-0.0141146285,
0.0069579175,
-0.0542175137,
0.0106373392,
0.030545542,
0.0134795485,
0.0073164874,
0.0173017979,
0.0022883643,
0.0171855744,
0.0096061351,
0.059682548,
0.0210323445,
0.0794889033,
0.0229930319,
-0.0129335439,
-0.0550574958,
0.0491899028,
-0.0127249714,
-0.0712461844,
-0.020652771,
0.0438161455,
0.0728013888,
-0.0021270446,
0.0170016196,
0.0026362457,
-0.0188291501,
-0.0421163328,
0.0326490961,
0.0269737579,
-0.0379664227,
0.0481786579,
0.0332036577,
0.0016511368,
-0.0118654147,
0.0428499095,
0.0101573691,
0.0515989922,
0.0134526202,
0.0202288572,
-0.0421558022,
-0.0392186977,
0.0447594412,
-0.0135442792,
0.0047222544,
0.0421084203,
-0.0341809504,
-0.051841706,
-0.0134507073,
0.0215987414,
-0.0045765275,
0.0235869586,
0.0290686488,
0.0722946748,
0.034102425,
-0.0083556734,
-0.0042365855,
-0.0335533023,
0.0170649718,
0.0053375699,
-0.0025350212,
-6.30932193e-33,
-0.0200422499,
-0.0153417727,
0.0595903471,
-0.0212762598,
-0.0004640159,
0.0150002865,
-0.0112611074,
0.0113096358,
-0.031200124,
0.011922677,
0.0102499062,
0.016154794,
0.0011795714,
0.0282671172,
0.0126974573,
-0.0484562628,
0.026562728,
0.0020547542,
-0.0227560382,
0.0060073817,
-0.0059402138,
-0.004540809,
0.0578075796,
-0.0588773042,
-0.0132523123,
0.021288896,
-0.0276166443,
0.040785335,
0.0005600475,
0.0710979104,
-0.0281580538,
0.006957374,
0.0265390668,
-0.0236128699,
-0.03070659,
0.0097973309,
-0.0067905821,
-0.0010337221,
0.0013757887,
0.0454078242,
-0.0961179212,
0.0160954632,
0.0486131757,
-0.0055648931,
-0.0005804668,
-0.0034910471,
0.0360855572,
-0.0194385629,
-0.0007550246,
0.0397267416,
-0.0425706245,
0.0033383099,
0.0128187891,
-0.052414041,
0.0334584899,
0.0367455147,
0.0131254559,
0.0299912598,
-0.0374479741,
0.007107358,
-0.0067728427,
0.0102669615,
0.0805284083,
0.0530551523,
-0.0102159418,
0.0614922084,
0.0609269999,
-0.0024802294,
-0.0225522257,
-0.0282297581,
0.0195464138,
0.0963881239,
0.0249125436,
0.0447506309,
0.0230102912,
0.0683922246,
-0.0333487242,
-0.0006816147,
-0.0536448732,
0.0741860792,
-0.0048618312,
-0.0019377487,
-0.0119519634,
0.0036756606,
-0.0365894996,
-0.0013686309,
-0.0574893877,
0.010402102,
0.0847562701,
0.0224693045,
-0.007819429,
0.0360215642,
0.0712561756,
-0.0320234634,
-0.0005853056,
-0.0094205998,
-0.010944142,
0.0392894596,
0.0184866395,
0.0221307613,
-0.0528718121,
-0.0175628159,
0.0488971062,
-0.0059259473,
-0.0003425445,
0.0079265088,
0.0118033076,
0.0205979012,
-0.0614080206,
-0.0074896393,
-0.0559648201,
0.0052247918,
-0.0120937126,
0.060441725,
0.0530040488,
-0.0097581642,
-0.0441472009,
0.0265842136,
-0.0116543025,
-0.0161110982,
-0.0084060151,
-0.03920592,
0.0015825179,
0.0236828681,
-0.0088460976,
-0.0046582324,
-0.0667063817,
-0.0550096929,
0.0108888755,
-0.0586392209,
0.0005234941,
0.0217997935,
2.689e-7,
0.0098720063,
0.0345639139,
0.0014604457,
0.0248981044,
0.0065963264,
0.0507083125,
-0.0240110476,
0.025530966,
0.0084354058,
-0.0517815314,
-0.0127059314,
0.0591683239,
0.0398176908,
0.0018643941,
-0.0046559437,
0.0256041549,
-0.0032125362,
0.0187763963,
-0.0664701983,
-0.0294014867,
0.0340142176,
0.0892593265,
-0.0234103687,
-0.0336428508,
0.0585234426,
-0.0875830427,
0.0866248757,
-0.036846824,
-0.0268532671,
-0.009263657,
0.0060875118,
0.0612819232,
-0.0137719503,
0.0405683182,
0.0047620693,
-0.0342681706,
0.0322026983,
0.0324282646,
-0.0250916369,
-0.0475918837,
-0.0237670746,
0.029204743,
-0.0159692075,
-0.034901835,
0.0836376473,
-0.0304970536,
-0.0011044892,
-0.0367974713,
-0.0169617608,
-0.0279183351,
0.0653865784,
-0.0104029002,
-0.0365628302,
0.0173124485,
0.0345484801,
-0.0139187137,
-0.0387563184,
-0.0691358373,
-0.0065713711,
-0.0197612979,
-0.0246564299,
0.0091814129,
-0.0577101745,
-0.0087989187,
0.0187208746,
-0.0426059067,
-0.0589358322,
2.241378904e-34,
0.0232240837,
-0.0083922055,
0.0346548073,
0.0153084211,
0.0158889145,
0.0050399057,
-0.0490985475,
-0.0053847418,
-0.0379488096,
-0.0597985089,
0.0038612834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01429v1 | Transformers are uninterpretable with myopic methods: a case study with bounded Dyck grammars | 2023-12-03T15:34:46 | 2023-12-03T15:34:46 | Kaiyue Wen, Yuchen Li, Bingbin Liu, Andrej Risteski | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Interpretability methods aim to understand the algorithm implemented by a
trained model (e.g., a Transofmer) by examining various aspects of the model,
such as the weight matrices or the attention patterns. In this work, through a
combination of theoretical results and carefully controlled experiments on
synthetic data, we take a critical view of methods that exclusively focus on
individual parts of the model, rather than consider the network as a whole. We
consider a simple synthetic setup of learning a (bounded) Dyck language.
Theoretically, we show that the set of models that (exactly or approximately)
solve this task satisfy a structural characterization derived from ideas in
formal languages (the pumping lemma). We use this characterization to show that
the set of optima is qualitatively rich; in particular, the attention pattern
of a single layer can be ``nearly randomized'', while preserving the
functionality of the network. We also show via extensive experiments that these
constructions are not merely a theoretical artifact: even after severely
constraining the architecture of the model, vastly different solutions can be
reached via standard training. Thus, interpretability claims based on
inspecting individual heads or weight matrices in the Transformer can be
misleading. | [
-0.0138406418,
0.0477196053,
-0.0400116593,
0.0469151028,
-0.0106563121,
0.0202847198,
0.0024140207,
-0.0059525403,
-0.0412220508,
0.0083749183,
-0.041487243,
-0.0273662247,
0.0301003158,
-0.0139047923,
0.0571779646,
-0.0320918895,
0.0391422287,
-0.0472517237,
-0.0800995082,
-0.0014489258,
-0.0293393489,
-0.0392788425,
0.0061768861,
0.04910402,
0.000698153,
0.003491231,
-0.0368139148,
-0.029542882,
0.0054392456,
0.0502252877,
-0.0387273319,
0.0453567989,
-0.0129112294,
0.0670830905,
0.0000019923,
0.0082143405,
-0.0339845382,
-0.0123194968,
-0.0599202439,
0.0020851356,
-0.0065757749,
-0.0182331204,
-0.0356308296,
-0.0344027728,
-0.0099161705,
-0.0229112171,
0.0833456144,
0.0189829096,
0.0203201976,
0.065868929,
-0.0008823052,
-0.0518524721,
0.0342341699,
-0.0132743297,
0.0038592026,
0.0229021683,
-0.009039823,
-0.037383765,
-0.0424655192,
-0.0296569709,
-0.0742451847,
0.0191787202,
0.0240620114,
0.0098651582,
0.0485883616,
-0.0023172533,
-0.0338600427,
-0.0601967797,
0.0172197241,
0.020717686,
-0.028535068,
-0.0173410363,
-0.0199887678,
-0.0030299763,
0.0038571197,
0.0215278119,
-0.0127816033,
0.0018876018,
0.0154637555,
0.0442974158,
0.0058040242,
0.0133286379,
0.0609667748,
-0.0449506976,
-0.0525952578,
0.079683423,
-0.016482953,
0.0237938855,
-0.0228470583,
0.0254492909,
0.0138755003,
-0.0033450816,
-0.0203479156,
0.0290726498,
0.0010359598,
0.0163732395,
0.0028101588,
0.0036277901,
-0.009781667,
-0.0222417079,
0.0662844405,
0.0153659843,
0.013001658,
0.0010137113,
-0.0205744207,
0.0208885297,
-0.0706771836,
0.0487610735,
-0.0234311558,
0.0184158869,
-0.0495752469,
-0.0312999785,
-0.0441068038,
0.0380143411,
-0.0122372424,
0.0055452096,
-0.0579681322,
-0.0097848084,
-0.0079487804,
0.0024641103,
0.0311533827,
-0.0277417414,
-0.0700626522,
0.0130429454,
-0.0112650283,
0.0313622244,
-0.0166671015,
-0.0030421338,
0.0017950195,
-0.061924953,
-0.0429123379,
0.0062050205,
0.0015968203,
-0.0158267636,
-0.0374744087,
0.1186330318,
0.0037410948,
-0.0199375749,
-0.0391790159,
-0.0275109224,
-0.0409229398,
-0.0133563085,
0.0500321947,
-0.047544498,
-0.0476110391,
0.0118863937,
0.0293939915,
-0.0074220216,
-0.0043302677,
-0.0034543406,
-0.0088920547,
0.0493595637,
0.0097854109,
-0.0009813416,
-0.0346076228,
-0.0061556795,
0.0072188764,
0.0496055596,
0.008959746,
0.0374352336,
-0.0079596145,
-0.038676545,
0.0662270114,
0.0500544384,
0.0187022351,
-0.0103987046,
-0.0317596905,
-0.059239272,
-0.0219575819,
-0.00088193,
0.0491474383,
0.0536963418,
-0.0382010974,
-0.0251363069,
0.0470790043,
0.0175011121,
0.0782817826,
0.083877936,
0.0575505197,
-0.0194180664,
0.0309984647,
0.0917534828,
-0.0290952716,
0.0025690775,
0.0011043635,
0.0070372284,
-0.0658914819,
-0.0148889227,
-0.0176455621,
-0.0547390431,
0.0118145058,
-0.0330594517,
-0.0328156054,
-0.0507327728,
0.0872859582,
0.0723479465,
-0.0547214523,
0.0830483064,
0.0165765714,
-0.0204603039,
0.0090547726,
-0.0543070138,
-0.0231474563,
-0.0088073285,
0.01879053,
-0.0244913604,
0.028080171,
-0.0013040341,
-0.0606806502,
0.023276737,
0.0066394713,
0.0194741338,
0.0284593254,
-0.0126408376,
0.0122785158,
-0.0160372518,
0.0448927693,
0.0154429674,
-0.0726394877,
-0.0364783593,
-0.0285837017,
-0.0533168316,
-0.0293155629,
0.0390883051,
-0.0074429535,
-0.0435529836,
-0.0207360052,
0.0147893634,
0.0339653976,
-0.0013921963,
-0.0097831199,
0.0196134392,
0.0164067559,
-0.0286591463,
0.0097639635,
0.0545280054,
-0.0742121935,
-0.0205063242,
-0.0261707436,
-0.0964747146,
-0.0150297675,
0.059103433,
0.0114246747,
-0.0290723778,
0.0642325282,
-0.1121052578,
0.0629420131,
-0.0100349924,
0.0119836573,
-0.0243095811,
0.018147435,
-0.0203795899,
0.0724006519,
-0.0126816481,
0.0163692124,
-0.0184883922,
-0.064312093,
0.0163313374,
-0.04126231,
-0.0327753164,
0.0227315277,
-0.0238029342,
-0.0230086278,
-0.0166311972,
-0.0460112952,
-0.0082985181,
-0.012525605,
-0.0160572045,
-0.0303866044,
-0.0116654458,
0.030590605,
0.004830617,
0.00165044,
0.0258351769,
0.0000798353,
-0.0149245514,
0.0118679525,
-0.0374475121,
-0.0192119144,
0.0617052317,
-0.0053706206,
-0.0660756156,
-0.0383095555,
-0.0616585128,
-0.0226925164,
0.1055325717,
0.0009967912,
-0.0093619423,
-0.0249097757,
0.0072891777,
0.0495827012,
0.0237064231,
-0.0250979401,
-0.0524312295,
0.0180636346,
-0.0085871061,
-0.0209046938,
0.0451823398,
-0.0120624062,
0.0396209881,
0.0064847777,
0.0203043986,
-0.017286459,
-0.0236338433,
-0.053100463,
-0.0003192188,
-0.0677605122,
-0.0580495186,
0.0102548664,
0.1281113476,
0.0066096867,
-0.0164659563,
-0.0526150391,
0.0328594744,
-0.0346462056,
-0.0107156858,
-0.0211376697,
-0.0277363844,
-0.0267789755,
0.0417177416,
0.0059572575,
-0.0528194532,
0.0596499853,
-0.0194082987,
-0.0367815718,
0.003576403,
0.0065002656,
-0.0321019702,
0.0375772417,
0.0338315405,
0.008261214,
0.0272471104,
-0.0473048203,
-0.0287765656,
0.0279903598,
0.0494596586,
0.0016615812,
0.0231257156,
0.0098757418,
-0.0079633743,
-0.012364855,
-0.0062913038,
-0.0493864492,
-0.0010874707,
-0.0223762915,
-0.0018384795,
0.0730779693,
-0.0398716331,
-0.0263573434,
0.0153638152,
-0.0014230715,
0.0191394426,
0.0004605403,
-0.0233323146,
-0.0300910547,
0.0277437344,
-0.0398860574,
0.0011755485,
0.0675510019,
-0.0486496314,
-0.0013533216,
0.0131720072,
-0.0114650307,
0.0325158387,
-0.0754261762,
0.0335435607,
-0.0005329959,
-0.024450168,
-0.0263241809,
-0.0258386098,
0.0573770329,
-0.0493603721,
-0.0439932384,
0.0261901114,
0.0078614708,
-0.0286607128,
0.0651117861,
0.0170952491,
0.0142387189,
-0.0064145094,
0.0189119428,
-0.0437179394,
-0.0132394675,
0.0141106667,
0.0588919483,
-0.0220414996,
-0.0408146754,
0.055595208,
-0.0764248446,
0.0276083611,
0.0261471905,
-0.0079704933,
-0.0180568062,
-0.0031733888,
-0.0205472261,
-0.0440147109,
-0.0156592745,
0.0222106371,
-0.0042010047,
0.0092908442,
0.0239098929,
0.0228819232,
-0.0186021701,
-0.0430019312,
0.0053377575,
0.0624119118,
0.0455311276,
0.0072956663,
-0.0406605117,
-0.0536738336,
0.0225575101,
0.0178617835,
0.021359399,
0.0098795304,
0.0531974062,
0.072134003,
-0.0414074808,
-0.0599570274,
0.0188454352,
-0.012023638,
-0.0064288238,
-0.0617116168,
0.058915019,
0.0059189787,
-0.0711132139,
0.0192251895,
-0.0105466116,
-0.018894488,
0.0402774289,
0.0768310204,
-0.0153623559,
-0.0545893535,
-0.0571762174,
0.0132790655,
-0.0386831015,
-0.0989456996,
0.067417644,
0.0702292398,
-0.0788027942,
-0.051885806,
0.0123391086,
-0.0299181305,
0.0609264076,
0.0179252774,
-0.035623394,
0.0337699503,
-0.0097254878,
-0.0131035484,
0.0610523745,
0.0107476134,
-0.0161646958,
-0.0340666249,
-0.032166075,
0.0269875526,
-0.0416935124,
-0.0224939808,
-0.022732649,
-0.0172475725,
-0.0300052799,
0.0665605143,
0.0626449361,
0.0419167094,
0.0057624006,
-0.0186279416,
-0.0431772955,
0.0112452833,
0.0234767664,
-0.0105834212,
0.0258598272,
0.0769712254,
-0.0362539142,
0.0046310415,
0.0434462503,
0.0234794933,
0.0486863554,
0.021585105,
-0.0011699668,
-0.0083744107,
0.0235047005,
0.062864542,
-0.0074045085,
0.0314635672,
0.0097336033,
-0.0070643071,
-0.0137252482,
0.0037882349,
0.015726367,
0.0161333475,
-0.0622860566,
-0.0263566524,
0.01252528,
0.0253649037,
0.001478508,
-0.0111766476,
0.0078040459,
0.0026472874,
0.0077411262,
0.0566506572,
0.0481337644,
0.0045233513,
0.0011826905,
0.0286070183,
0.0088968314,
0.0232040063,
-0.0083287312,
0.0490258671,
0.0410681963,
-0.0005890894,
0.033134006,
0.0188819952,
-0.0754809305,
-0.022801118,
-0.0648416877,
-0.0290043168,
0.0034391503,
-0.0088643311,
0.0304722972,
-0.0229852907,
0.0182914864,
-0.0278889108,
0.0187098775,
0.0093068508,
0.0209774077,
0.0126108099,
0.0011628882,
-0.0001475281,
0.0111215636,
-0.0044206441,
-0.0476587042,
0.0592299476,
-0.0300407298,
0.0057603694,
-0.0477439836,
-0.0013154804,
-0.0546149798,
-0.0143271219,
-0.0128193321,
-0.0111210793,
-0.0127367117,
-0.0108544882,
-0.0433496237,
-0.0944757313,
-0.0287248604,
0.0235249884,
0.0423095077,
-0.0394414701,
0.0258501135,
0.017082667,
0.0292291306,
-0.0004500058,
-0.013027655,
0.0290725976,
0.0378655717,
0.0290659294,
0.008879913,
-5.979501725e-33,
-0.0333410874,
-0.0364458412,
-0.0370618999,
0.0045417747,
0.0192332361,
0.0003617876,
-0.0670076385,
0.031117443,
-0.0156654902,
0.018720625,
-0.0008939869,
0.0030062215,
0.0072737094,
0.0315933339,
-0.0143293003,
-0.0130114248,
0.0326947905,
-0.0005078075,
-0.0157412533,
-0.0028183931,
-0.0005538759,
0.0153711848,
0.0724737272,
-0.0161365587,
0.0363469683,
-0.0234112963,
-0.0278639421,
0.0228883252,
-0.0372287184,
0.0749682784,
0.0040398645,
0.0336156487,
0.0138059938,
-0.0599981062,
-0.0366482139,
-0.0044581303,
-0.0398417562,
-0.0172216743,
0.0059698047,
0.0447834507,
-0.0631841496,
-0.0264655706,
0.0975061879,
-0.013516143,
-0.0271370914,
-0.0016548692,
0.0151308747,
0.0012660959,
0.0073288502,
0.0355722457,
-0.0433792174,
0.0175599437,
-0.0326075517,
0.0042835264,
0.0610398054,
0.0379581042,
-0.020433709,
-0.0082438895,
-0.0261297561,
0.0001413341,
0.0562742054,
0.0316528641,
0.0480521657,
0.0222194884,
-0.0012583864,
0.0296498872,
0.1118419021,
-0.0151557568,
-0.0253857505,
-0.0193477236,
0.0367239937,
0.0448391698,
0.0382745601,
-0.0014007923,
0.0255195796,
0.0164612886,
-0.0477926396,
-0.0450625755,
-0.0139304129,
0.0288556237,
0.0452390499,
0.0243392251,
-0.0290895738,
-0.0119550936,
-0.0132547496,
-0.0529075004,
-0.0008677607,
0.0341256894,
-0.0307568889,
-0.0067557395,
-0.0367254242,
0.0114333704,
0.0087762587,
-0.0518540181,
0.0111951753,
-0.0193667114,
0.008959935,
0.0689954013,
0.0034417496,
0.0164492205,
0.0191881843,
-0.0344535038,
-0.009995074,
-0.0055726273,
0.0530383177,
0.0218512416,
0.0449390188,
0.0270144735,
-0.0168280844,
-0.0197744258,
-0.0389459282,
-0.0065201595,
-0.0030061193,
0.0665951967,
0.0835578442,
-0.0316162668,
-0.0496018641,
-0.0005640755,
0.000226862,
0.0461122729,
-0.0233469605,
0.0761763826,
-0.0061299801,
0.028718926,
-0.0314099416,
-0.0648611709,
-0.0043074442,
0.0566927418,
0.0796362534,
-0.044103995,
-0.0281148553,
-0.0005694731,
2.798e-7,
0.078978315,
0.0164992772,
0.0240450073,
0.0188013725,
0.0683910102,
0.0302441362,
-0.0286156405,
0.0401952155,
-0.0275317989,
-0.0122428928,
0.0094105471,
0.006562877,
0.0185409654,
-0.004401518,
-0.044578217,
-0.0381861553,
-0.0058929175,
0.0332103632,
0.0016125155,
0.0229764041,
-0.036793258,
0.0827469379,
-0.0253569353,
0.0087961396,
0.0627393574,
0.0283181705,
0.0129124224,
-0.0106748063,
0.0596747696,
0.0009764292,
0.0342971608,
-0.0225673374,
-0.0196787883,
0.0308906417,
-0.0051252181,
0.0450800136,
-0.0162830818,
0.0356634632,
-0.0149978502,
-0.0177006293,
0.0298885833,
-0.0040058284,
0.026807934,
-0.0343201049,
-0.0071544345,
-0.0535144918,
-0.0672420859,
0.0402721427,
0.0226264838,
0.0077383588,
0.0066269273,
0.0137151293,
-0.0001415158,
-0.0035053999,
0.0276290849,
-0.0385890342,
0.0098866113,
-0.0376701392,
-0.0054976088,
-0.0282113459,
-0.0654702336,
-0.0376529656,
-0.0609945692,
-0.0275839716,
0.0438238904,
-0.0233468153,
-0.0216758419,
2.691634796e-34,
0.0062079327,
-0.006897924,
0.0333345421,
0.0385148376,
0.0090034083,
-0.0349156782,
0.0495297723,
0.0130319381,
0.0541300215,
-0.0404525101,
-0.0473648049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01398v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01398v1 | Towards Mitigating Perceived Unfairness in Contracts from a Non-Legal Stakeholder's Perspective | 2023-12-03T13:52:32 | 2023-12-03T13:52:32 | Anmol Singhal, Preethu Rose Anish, Shirish Karande, Smita Ghaisas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Commercial contracts are known to be a valuable source for deriving
project-specific requirements. However, contract negotiations mainly occur
among the legal counsel of the parties involved. The participation of non-legal
stakeholders, including requirement analysts, engineers, and solution
architects, whose primary responsibility lies in ensuring the seamless
implementation of contractual terms, is often indirect and inadequate.
Consequently, a significant number of sentences in contractual clauses, though
legally accurate, can appear unfair from an implementation perspective to
non-legal stakeholders. This perception poses a problem since requirements
indicated in the clauses are obligatory and can involve punitive measures and
penalties if not implemented as committed in the contract. Therefore, the
identification of potentially unfair clauses in contracts becomes crucial. In
this work, we conduct an empirical study to analyze the perspectives of
different stakeholders regarding contractual fairness. We then investigate the
ability of Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) to identify unfairness in
contractual sentences by comparing chain of thought prompting and
semi-supervised fine-tuning approaches. Using BERT-based fine-tuning, we
achieved an accuracy of 84% on a dataset consisting of proprietary contracts.
It outperformed chain of thought prompting using Vicuna-13B by a margin of 9%. | [
0.0946983993,
0.0601918139,
-0.0160106625,
0.0148272896,
-0.0582284071,
-0.0184805878,
0.0183357894,
-0.0077546886,
0.0071148626,
-0.0929289162,
-0.0115995863,
0.0311250798,
-0.0037647178,
-0.0138532119,
-0.0027788186,
-0.0470974892,
0.0195824988,
0.034945704,
0.0391203575,
-0.0103455177,
0.0420588814,
0.0129219806,
-0.0113680875,
0.0417681299,
-0.0520153679,
-0.0063766227,
0.0073364517,
0.0244695228,
0.0149128698,
-0.0455947183,
0.0251530241,
0.1211980954,
-0.0186279323,
0.0177711081,
0.0000021583,
-0.1020807698,
-0.0450571924,
-0.0138904331,
0.0173344184,
0.1138451695,
0.0064901202,
-0.0592236854,
0.0081761135,
0.012928931,
-0.0341317318,
0.0712243095,
0.0144123938,
0.0585296601,
0.0638205186,
0.0267658588,
-0.0192131251,
-0.01900867,
-0.0344173461,
-0.0362228379,
-0.0135496156,
-0.0365810916,
0.0355773009,
-0.0555472411,
-0.0180875324,
-0.0244468432,
0.0100788455,
0.0106792757,
0.0335514396,
-0.0197892301,
0.0160388052,
0.0011906192,
-0.1128214002,
0.0109261414,
-0.0121470597,
0.0521571897,
0.0499256216,
0.0034394013,
-0.0095467903,
-0.0660384819,
0.0148619385,
-0.001319474,
-0.0094544524,
0.0235492568,
-0.0080429921,
0.0044059958,
-0.0207869802,
0.0254361611,
-0.02417209,
0.0044070408,
-0.0340804979,
0.0685121119,
0.0019727121,
-0.0489413515,
0.0163161382,
0.0309012588,
-0.0169558302,
-0.0624515489,
0.037441697,
0.010082107,
-0.0051875473,
0.0272509158,
-0.0054229125,
-0.0226516221,
0.066118449,
-0.0592911355,
-0.0144484714,
-0.0146090528,
-0.0367065519,
0.0281497557,
-0.0409390368,
0.0005709192,
-0.0222526696,
0.0651585162,
-0.0010483263,
0.0468377918,
-0.0051691439,
-0.0184814055,
-0.0529971309,
0.0372230932,
-0.0563624762,
0.0056100846,
-0.0234070756,
0.0057758228,
-0.0008973327,
0.0543288328,
-0.001999605,
0.0144479265,
0.0337692946,
-0.0456534177,
-0.0772084892,
-0.0389818735,
-0.0452272929,
0.0463151522,
-0.0597712472,
-0.0190496854,
0.0290706884,
-0.0029621294,
-0.0258519426,
0.0034442456,
0.0164495297,
0.0652976185,
0.042910289,
-0.0039301077,
-0.0576039962,
-0.0467680655,
0.0059430334,
0.0020360923,
-0.0671982169,
-0.0302321333,
-0.0588660464,
-0.0084846793,
-0.047559876,
-0.0271603931,
0.0064696083,
0.0145990094,
-0.0171150211,
0.0656850263,
-0.0530053489,
-0.0066407686,
-0.0179025214,
0.0082879681,
0.0334198736,
0.0352308266,
0.058303304,
0.0424690209,
0.0561165549,
0.0348902382,
0.0059311124,
0.0480685495,
-0.0227354746,
0.0094154878,
0.0094515849,
0.0241576806,
-0.0178523455,
0.0042098737,
-0.0293032192,
0.0173829198,
0.0360080712,
0.0191681962,
0.036196921,
0.0199346244,
-0.0047195898,
0.0089349253,
-0.0091686323,
0.0646977127,
-0.018314017,
0.0053169769,
-0.0191864166,
0.0224343203,
0.0182586126,
-0.0050615747,
-0.0164200328,
0.0239912681,
-0.0200955458,
-0.0708554462,
0.0272207558,
0.0089990515,
0.0199045409,
0.0397817269,
0.0353421718,
0.0207153894,
-0.068154484,
0.0529918112,
0.0233740695,
-0.0357139818,
-0.0275626462,
0.0232058149,
-0.0084141782,
0.0520644188,
0.003076033,
-0.0549249612,
-0.0083047589,
-0.0189784672,
-0.0325795636,
0.072461158,
0.0523812808,
0.0021816215,
-0.0320763178,
-0.0192494038,
-0.0548171178,
-0.0163158756,
-0.0041790656,
0.0072053326,
-0.0508507974,
-0.0137919392,
0.0271727033,
-0.0179879423,
0.0150270741,
0.0533787757,
0.0307629313,
-0.0401863456,
0.0157168712,
0.0368937254,
-0.0147291357,
0.033893574,
-0.0022364401,
0.0210131705,
0.0414553322,
-0.0003526176,
0.0194781646,
0.0222968142,
-0.0271759387,
0.0115832333,
-0.0021095895,
-0.0755104125,
-0.0072815293,
0.0006252686,
-0.0344517268,
0.0160721801,
0.0050137276,
0.0349618234,
0.0079610394,
-0.0419165976,
-0.0032232334,
-0.0290010348,
-0.0199629012,
-0.0415810943,
-0.0184483621,
0.0126311611,
0.0229917932,
-0.0191438217,
-0.0315215774,
0.055876635,
0.0063801627,
-0.047213383,
0.0077757612,
-0.02091741,
0.0086087482,
0.0267959498,
0.0670341328,
-0.0270425715,
-0.0133009925,
-0.1192176268,
-0.0110828951,
-0.0043599708,
0.008004169,
-0.0037708951,
-0.0263232924,
-0.0210117009,
-0.0277491733,
-0.0373801105,
-0.0690865144,
-0.0507302508,
-0.0111697875,
0.0649667755,
-0.0159730799,
-0.0587040856,
-0.010771147,
-0.0256029628,
-0.044723738,
0.0295770764,
0.08952979,
-0.0134307677,
-0.0593132824,
0.0380353518,
-0.0215712693,
-0.0275442898,
0.0316932797,
-0.0214153435,
0.0072641484,
0.0813199356,
-0.0053116544,
0.0130499247,
0.0257964041,
0.0286325738,
0.0231620632,
0.0008774581,
-0.0274116527,
-0.0061491532,
0.0018315512,
0.0155351255,
-0.0267777108,
-0.0068916101,
0.0651269704,
0.051938165,
-0.0046065771,
-0.0346887782,
-0.0500765182,
0.023662949,
-0.0017456019,
0.0109379627,
0.0345557854,
-0.0457848199,
-0.0255257487,
0.0852544308,
0.0310964175,
-0.0312327631,
0.0543180555,
-0.0176896546,
0.0094076283,
-0.0504903682,
0.0230099987,
-0.053961806,
0.0444647782,
-0.0542791933,
-0.0021183223,
0.0341280289,
-0.031688448,
-0.060638532,
0.015358327,
0.1045554355,
-0.0058800727,
0.0480830707,
-0.0219658148,
0.0030912212,
-0.0092185177,
-0.022130901,
-0.0402997509,
-0.0785126239,
-0.0172254369,
0.0586070865,
0.0507614203,
0.0348722748,
0.0116548203,
-0.0020565279,
-0.0318360887,
0.0212406423,
0.0321393982,
-0.0136959162,
-0.0295327734,
-0.0616317093,
-0.009963464,
-0.0199056547,
0.0533032157,
-0.0222222935,
-0.043693766,
-0.0183763653,
-0.0021308479,
0.0235700998,
-0.0011635264,
-0.0017211231,
-0.0276681725,
-0.0568921342,
0.0154553419,
0.0167544708,
-0.0094537083,
-0.0132080941,
0.0489042699,
0.0571592785,
0.027435882,
-0.0035088931,
0.0601866357,
0.0075549907,
0.0483306311,
0.0464797579,
-0.009385718,
-0.1443199962,
0.0025015979,
-0.0272090733,
0.0205793437,
-0.0467264988,
-0.034423396,
-0.0398925468,
-0.0756367296,
0.0411870889,
-0.0102163954,
0.0332310498,
-0.0033998615,
0.060459964,
-0.0033837871,
0.002565199,
0.0025148846,
-0.011692672,
0.0112457993,
0.0033904486,
0.044288069,
-0.0620252676,
0.0008941605,
0.014230283,
-0.0413752012,
-0.0021966165,
0.0470640473,
-0.0331403241,
0.0021037282,
-0.0010406,
0.0480824113,
-0.0184956919,
-0.0128288409,
0.0289127901,
0.014086728,
-0.0194647219,
-0.0070435763,
-0.0090215439,
-0.01677466,
-0.0435932465,
-0.0274060033,
0.0469864272,
0.0615361594,
-0.0016115978,
0.0120714186,
0.0155081283,
0.0031642425,
-0.0128596956,
0.0302692987,
0.0174884442,
-0.039769154,
-0.0431326404,
-0.0477000475,
-0.024058843,
0.0013415409,
-0.0046562236,
0.0190839991,
-0.0269035753,
-0.0053396951,
-0.0507397503,
-0.0677988008,
0.0365794599,
0.0145448316,
0.0422741398,
0.0002822028,
0.0893246457,
-0.0309426561,
-0.0365946703,
0.0167810563,
0.0017275028,
0.037825048,
0.0100905532,
-0.0252908785,
-0.0275248401,
-0.0040340405,
-0.0170116071,
-0.063236095,
-0.0404420085,
-0.0307281017,
-0.0465139598,
0.018568676,
0.0206455607,
-0.0036601559,
-0.0135425376,
-0.0308744684,
-0.0293291751,
0.0637315363,
-0.0248518344,
-0.0147799291,
0.0642766058,
0.0244788881,
-0.0023623544,
0.0097839683,
-0.0444490574,
-0.0270616878,
0.0174612738,
0.0352145731,
0.0088050338,
-0.0395987555,
0.0712025166,
0.0625093877,
-0.0025721495,
-0.0304468088,
-0.0288477298,
-0.0340163894,
0.0267512351,
0.0117042214,
-0.0376644842,
-0.0394962877,
0.0065701711,
0.0041011348,
0.012685746,
-0.0243199542,
0.0180723257,
-0.0611100122,
0.0039300723,
-0.0032186958,
0.0868233964,
0.0410201997,
-0.0045253178,
0.0447039716,
-0.0481076725,
-0.0025716494,
-0.0036939464,
0.0007294903,
0.0190386977,
0.022455439,
0.0035442,
0.0417297147,
0.0220376607,
-0.0426955931,
0.0204495676,
0.0201257635,
-0.0537752919,
-0.0186691824,
0.0046525598,
-0.0057472093,
0.0231115427,
-0.0006393203,
-0.0300588906,
0.0284705684,
0.0168030187,
0.0247047339,
-0.0110217258,
-0.0515880994,
0.0361417085,
-0.0038113366,
-0.0360675529,
-0.0006909463,
0.0467671975,
-0.0149443531,
0.0294011533,
-0.079058826,
-0.0038415233,
-0.0405826122,
-0.015163471,
0.0142262047,
-0.0158271119,
-0.0490902364,
-0.00846087,
-0.1071989685,
-0.0248785801,
-0.0134463497,
-0.0353512578,
0.0084647136,
-0.0119412523,
-0.0092742275,
0.0542825125,
0.0192595385,
-0.0331461132,
-0.0180484261,
-0.0246425327,
0.0102358703,
-0.0625169799,
-0.0055683735,
-5.778617822e-33,
-0.0104482118,
-0.0224473402,
-0.0134738842,
0.018315617,
0.0083054435,
-0.0125809871,
-0.0132192774,
0.0005943098,
0.0156487897,
0.0157831367,
-0.0210749693,
-0.0138168298,
0.0126048438,
-0.0173765197,
0.0498080701,
-0.0281322002,
0.0193219502,
-0.0138702812,
-0.0481856391,
-0.0163360368,
-0.0621017329,
0.0302640554,
0.0901104435,
-0.0632040352,
0.064568527,
-0.0318502001,
-0.0379210375,
0.0113219703,
-0.0423201136,
0.0409435071,
0.0007729901,
0.0287720766,
0.0232767574,
-0.0070526181,
-0.0053342925,
0.0415272564,
-0.0003141504,
-0.0155833624,
0.0233253371,
0.0213381089,
0.0241605137,
-0.0039639426,
0.0482760631,
-0.0062715891,
-0.0682066903,
0.0195425022,
0.0553036667,
-0.0451401286,
0.0024732968,
-0.0645988509,
-0.0892847627,
0.0106072119,
-0.0511293374,
0.0160714164,
0.0208248533,
0.0170042254,
-0.0055353483,
0.040041782,
0.0054888413,
0.0216960013,
0.0382262692,
-0.014698117,
0.0404634513,
-0.06508708,
0.0188135337,
0.0528227463,
0.0069082156,
0.0326944925,
-0.014980155,
-0.0675067604,
0.061842151,
0.0335289426,
0.0069037862,
0.0212455168,
0.0045227171,
0.0022324508,
-0.048098214,
0.0125352591,
0.0285430979,
0.0114349499,
0.0357512385,
-0.017350588,
-0.0026674275,
-0.0469282642,
-0.0256897304,
-0.0482194647,
0.0008958942,
0.0121623054,
0.0448173881,
0.006869189,
0.0513906516,
0.0491851531,
-0.004758154,
-0.0253901165,
-0.0428616293,
0.0207583904,
-0.0104641197,
-0.0039999485,
-0.0053923139,
0.012827226,
-0.0585960709,
0.0061440622,
0.0318006277,
-0.0126108322,
0.0434338041,
0.0288568307,
0.0314209759,
-0.0375689454,
-0.0437272452,
0.0198839679,
-0.0155167719,
0.0136821773,
-0.0073403879,
0.0164447911,
0.0121173337,
0.0000107287,
-0.0175829474,
0.0202918965,
-0.0138357179,
-0.0352708586,
-0.0587182827,
0.0578620918,
-0.0261144638,
0.0335109271,
-0.0143666873,
-0.0301887952,
0.0413941219,
-0.0021913142,
0.0295909215,
0.0155489342,
-0.0086734956,
0.0236749481,
2.88e-7,
0.0277942251,
0.067103222,
-0.0028883505,
-0.0011637521,
-0.0497872792,
0.0805562884,
-0.0019440681,
0.0489421524,
-0.0290643163,
-0.0223643389,
0.0602782443,
-0.0490578637,
0.0368080065,
0.004439007,
-0.0538812205,
-0.0252074301,
-0.0337770432,
-0.022767162,
-0.0878223628,
-0.0028211253,
0.116019778,
0.0233687013,
-0.0027261602,
0.0002550785,
-0.0076461146,
-0.0241118222,
0.0129369181,
-0.0597538128,
0.0231733862,
0.0349428058,
0.0492771342,
-0.0871303678,
0.0125967106,
0.0627655759,
-0.0077195908,
0.0150037911,
-0.0041690702,
0.0186144207,
-0.0075891144,
0.0122186709,
0.0034593432,
-0.0172270779,
0.0065335007,
-0.0467583798,
0.0099967523,
0.0027368607,
-0.0329415128,
0.0124642514,
0.0095572937,
-0.0524651296,
0.0343813077,
0.0345929489,
0.0133901127,
-0.0124043552,
0.0196514875,
-0.0195082556,
0.0237613991,
-0.0724879131,
0.0168577898,
0.0667851493,
-0.0146311643,
0.000220014,
0.0129099824,
0.048398789,
0.0355782062,
-0.0104092713,
0.0613589995,
2.487756551e-34,
0.0189085081,
-0.0295728203,
0.0373222865,
0.096261017,
0.0340103395,
0.0551442429,
0.0026220456,
0.017356351,
-0.0025767586,
-0.041987773,
0.0047097905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01356v1 | CEScore: Simple and Efficient Confidence Estimation Model for Evaluating Split and Rephrase | 2023-12-03T11:36:23 | 2023-12-03T11:36:23 | AlMotasem Bellah Al Ajlouni, Jinlong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | The split and rephrase (SR) task aims to divide a long, complex sentence into
a set of shorter, simpler sentences that convey the same meaning. This
challenging problem in NLP has gained increased attention recently because of
its benefits as a pre-processing step in other NLP tasks. Evaluating quality of
SR is challenging, as there no automatic metric fit to evaluate this task. In
this work, we introduce CEScore, as novel statistical model to automatically
evaluate SR task. By mimicking the way humans evaluate SR, CEScore provides 4
metrics (Sscore, Gscore, Mscore, and CEscore) to assess simplicity,
grammaticality, meaning preservation, and overall quality, respectively. In
experiments with 26 models, CEScore correlates strongly with human evaluations,
achieving 0.98 in Spearman correlations at model-level. This underscores the
potential of CEScore as a simple and effective metric for assessing the overall
quality of SR models. | [
0.007300552,
0.0278544407,
0.0024213544,
0.0161811039,
-0.0798606724,
-0.0143340873,
-0.0024101636,
-0.0093664378,
-0.0249328986,
-0.0327044949,
-0.0416147597,
-0.0109823411,
0.0400999524,
0.0074017206,
-0.0015306468,
-0.0857194364,
0.0479122326,
0.0061719548,
0.0171347521,
0.0422568321,
0.0201063808,
-0.0413870476,
0.0266291555,
0.0455456898,
-0.0048808302,
-0.04079815,
0.0053281058,
0.0324763842,
0.0081479996,
-0.0142987594,
0.0342804901,
0.0530465618,
-0.0331374854,
-0.0150496876,
0.000001849,
-0.0768330321,
-0.0752579421,
0.0003797933,
-0.0076698437,
0.0249001011,
0.0527846776,
-0.0260402411,
0.0112363743,
0.0331487916,
-0.023848841,
0.0687775463,
-0.0071913358,
0.036732547,
0.0749255046,
0.0902226567,
-0.0143942731,
-0.0173715428,
0.0079034185,
-0.0370746441,
-0.0293844957,
-0.0077018933,
0.0006980952,
-0.0100827971,
-0.0503060743,
0.0026008019,
-0.0149292313,
0.0229478776,
0.023246415,
-0.0036693104,
-0.0071025351,
-0.053570386,
-0.0640293434,
-0.0259987228,
-0.0066743777,
0.0087180762,
-0.0533888489,
-0.0110617243,
0.0184254479,
-0.0086972099,
0.0125149973,
0.0044746655,
-0.05570269,
-0.0048775258,
-0.0045631742,
-0.0071814614,
0.013859082,
0.0197569653,
-0.016793415,
-0.0223699864,
0.0102159986,
0.0511204898,
0.0327586606,
-0.0440407172,
-0.0364384241,
0.014354906,
-0.0264658891,
-0.0233863741,
0.0431845486,
0.0079798419,
-0.0528512783,
0.0221656058,
-0.0613616258,
-0.0662434548,
0.0039921612,
-0.0149145052,
0.0265445523,
-0.0021780815,
0.0270330701,
0.008760226,
-0.0119278627,
0.0644796863,
0.0488409512,
0.0238885283,
-0.0297144782,
0.0273463875,
-0.0547409877,
0.0084363967,
-0.0282081105,
0.0424112715,
-0.0176665597,
-0.0414858982,
-0.0928132534,
-0.0125970552,
-0.0063604228,
-0.0246282928,
0.0613511689,
-0.0266609713,
0.0105092628,
0.0120418677,
0.0078637684,
0.042494975,
-0.0539872684,
0.0333899707,
0.0636667609,
-0.0087274108,
-0.0074976594,
0.0104236463,
0.0373296849,
-0.0127667589,
-0.0167592,
-0.0131414263,
-0.0083722565,
-0.0631626919,
-0.028361829,
-0.0657600462,
-0.0563653968,
-0.0478427522,
0.0053674141,
-0.0565117523,
0.0286133066,
-0.0023514023,
0.0112109063,
-0.0430078693,
-0.0192178171,
0.0155285867,
-0.0033185149,
0.023044236,
0.0120427888,
0.026321901,
-0.026120754,
0.017912399,
-0.0093250386,
0.0259816516,
0.0490612723,
0.0184353739,
0.0894791484,
0.0230511818,
0.0354773663,
0.009458635,
-0.0481936112,
-0.0421972647,
-0.0054721255,
-0.030682411,
-0.0665382743,
0.0417776518,
0.0085300626,
0.0765253901,
-0.0232196804,
0.0298164934,
0.0529470444,
0.0297169797,
0.0550755747,
0.0051316838,
0.0684351549,
0.0242087133,
0.0270429086,
0.0506956354,
-0.03201681,
-0.0089584868,
0.0166720506,
0.0443194918,
0.0238664113,
0.0147697171,
0.0103511102,
-0.0528356656,
-0.0107465247,
-0.0279546622,
-0.0183815118,
-0.0327034257,
0.0126794353,
0.016790716,
-0.0243884921,
0.0290563982,
-0.0200863592,
-0.1052481383,
0.0131496647,
-0.0400954969,
0.0050232396,
0.0614722446,
0.0441129878,
-0.0175547358,
-0.0210971013,
-0.0072806268,
-0.0092356605,
0.0099370871,
0.0290696044,
0.0076292232,
0.0071753757,
-0.0358862355,
-0.0156287197,
-0.0258681886,
0.0583234578,
-0.0730461925,
0.0740938336,
-0.0078156916,
0.0402558781,
-0.0627701133,
-0.0045187478,
0.0576256998,
0.0251379758,
0.0215357654,
-0.0099472329,
0.0005041959,
0.0077568223,
0.0039601056,
0.0043874527,
0.0491868481,
0.0251761489,
-0.0343366191,
-0.016609855,
0.0213076882,
-0.0479924344,
-0.0939550102,
0.034079887,
-0.0742583796,
-0.0241794419,
0.0620975494,
-0.0000845395,
-0.0542385206,
-0.0050475304,
-0.0369149931,
-0.0043574716,
-0.0300469827,
0.0717268288,
0.0061988342,
-0.003877542,
-0.0452975295,
0.0389607102,
0.0040007252,
0.0164782722,
-0.0024017908,
-0.0724089071,
0.0176555794,
-0.0349803939,
-0.0116322218,
-0.0300640874,
-0.0319313444,
-0.0054019014,
0.0255238209,
0.0383363739,
-0.0665623024,
-0.0553990789,
-0.0358894095,
0.008043672,
-0.0328370295,
0.0334893391,
0.0654388666,
-0.0034697161,
-0.0071437904,
0.031004874,
0.0116039803,
0.0130699156,
-0.0143055469,
0.0036094387,
0.0400764719,
-0.0590603575,
-0.0179528929,
-0.0728069842,
-0.0096578766,
-0.0123332236,
0.0552721359,
0.0090702148,
0.0253789946,
-0.0252172798,
0.0766005516,
-0.0063873767,
-0.0456759632,
0.0449202582,
-0.0693601146,
0.0168453213,
0.0128644584,
0.1033781841,
0.0912892371,
0.0309073552,
0.006503311,
0.0031886613,
-0.010521682,
0.0161626022,
-0.031493865,
-0.0352409407,
0.022477651,
0.0021162503,
-0.0627990887,
0.0433926806,
0.0651157275,
0.0243104193,
-0.0185106471,
-0.0316338763,
-0.0248847026,
-0.0398666486,
-0.0230591632,
0.0168753825,
-0.0062640002,
-0.0369041674,
0.0175130721,
-0.028041359,
-0.0072331047,
0.0426295102,
-0.0259939004,
0.0057291891,
-0.0602813996,
-0.0002651667,
-0.0357135497,
0.0511180013,
-0.0221027639,
0.0050066663,
0.0000569934,
0.0062253242,
-0.0608382039,
-0.00691059,
0.048315756,
-0.0235936679,
0.0246796384,
-0.0691450611,
-0.0161775481,
0.0281895641,
-0.0278728884,
-0.0162629597,
-0.0397465006,
-0.0252200216,
0.0219934341,
0.0360081941,
0.0014060177,
-0.0210765041,
0.0211000424,
0.0534093976,
0.0549497046,
-0.0376779735,
0.0034310496,
-0.0186910052,
0.0639725924,
0.0686454251,
0.0070060189,
0.0341604389,
-0.0663686022,
0.0654665381,
0.0340565853,
0.0016770328,
0.020176556,
-0.0245019887,
-0.0146401413,
-0.0324997157,
-0.0321735777,
-0.0276168212,
0.0227050148,
0.0886096284,
-0.0714166239,
-0.0436357372,
0.1287357658,
0.0324135534,
-0.0073030083,
-0.0004638354,
-0.027730735,
0.0515389666,
0.0187393334,
-0.0246855151,
0.005025418,
-0.0428374074,
0.0345777571,
0.0087687392,
0.0171523876,
-0.0350554623,
0.0170164984,
-0.0780947506,
0.0207195468,
-0.0308401883,
-0.0427658632,
0.0040256362,
-0.0472970158,
0.0223619565,
0.0085996725,
0.0037974007,
0.021322228,
-0.0426293425,
0.0250510909,
-0.0187557153,
-0.0920313224,
-0.0313722603,
-0.0125025818,
-0.0838654414,
0.0201156288,
0.0525779165,
0.0276083983,
-0.0113451816,
-0.0107832476,
0.0520991944,
-0.0500245988,
-0.0126025388,
0.0231528785,
0.0282236263,
-0.0045675416,
0.0348782986,
-0.0161666423,
0.0042624897,
-0.0168243237,
-0.0161022637,
0.0411964469,
0.0384115353,
0.0219106786,
-0.0342053883,
-0.003672011,
0.0114000579,
-0.0218550377,
0.0973705724,
0.0770167708,
-0.01780954,
-0.0526358187,
0.0167547446,
0.0097520659,
-0.0448231846,
-0.0063496339,
0.0333503298,
-0.0442080945,
-0.0052159918,
-0.0978356227,
-0.0613017753,
0.052408684,
0.020078117,
-0.0130708246,
0.0127603235,
0.008494054,
-0.0089989025,
-0.0296030976,
0.0157691222,
-0.0133879324,
0.0072923885,
-0.0820541084,
0.0452283882,
-0.0274850186,
0.0424939431,
-0.0152017241,
-0.0078397756,
-0.0816490352,
-0.0214517768,
0.0206408314,
0.0618045479,
0.0255794134,
-0.0278620068,
-0.0017238592,
-0.0241939239,
-0.0276865363,
-0.0147773214,
-0.0431700051,
0.04124007,
0.0204882901,
0.0168903973,
-0.0045796647,
0.0362493657,
0.0003009191,
-0.0087697608,
0.0138366427,
0.0914335847,
0.0087526711,
-0.0351520255,
0.0353683271,
0.0337292515,
0.0203504898,
-0.0403679423,
0.0116604259,
-0.0056606298,
-0.0180140845,
-0.052038867,
0.0123322569,
-0.0370475315,
0.0283333324,
0.0304480121,
0.034712214,
-0.031284932,
0.0309745874,
-0.0382733829,
-0.018565556,
-0.0443636365,
-0.0149293756,
-0.003707126,
-0.025401013,
-0.0033613881,
-0.0010874324,
-0.0085946852,
0.0015379186,
-0.0484850369,
-0.0115564354,
-0.0020929393,
-0.0004090096,
0.0228961501,
-0.0035581279,
-0.0433817282,
0.0511132888,
-0.0287179984,
0.0217342842,
0.0066663236,
0.0428780243,
0.0355545469,
0.0171975009,
0.0978868231,
0.0044151405,
-0.0179305039,
-0.0265079439,
0.0763752759,
-0.0101848999,
0.0159529727,
-0.0178348087,
0.0070724809,
-0.0139544075,
-0.0223061536,
0.0743268058,
-0.0230086539,
-0.0199356768,
-0.0064861397,
-0.0087108864,
-0.0413537696,
0.0192645546,
-0.0174128376,
0.006269929,
-0.0144484155,
-0.0159348957,
-0.0565581247,
-0.045095671,
0.047618404,
0.0340125933,
0.0589421466,
-0.000100702,
0.0151648764,
0.0784659311,
-0.0445991345,
-0.0275208224,
-0.0244581774,
-0.0316877589,
0.0366806425,
-0.0510966666,
-0.0176514797,
-5.856817584e-33,
0.0100460127,
0.0009581434,
0.0016152312,
-0.00414903,
-0.0298916735,
0.0232140832,
-0.0688876957,
0.0467413105,
0.0377983563,
0.0340386741,
-0.0176382214,
0.0087922569,
0.0253188387,
0.0165077299,
0.0315194242,
0.0020298106,
0.0437002033,
-0.0075034918,
-0.0540148243,
-0.0523523055,
-0.016075436,
0.0390862264,
0.0288433749,
-0.0237844121,
-0.0086957375,
0.0120722214,
-0.0285961293,
-0.0119673591,
0.0249345414,
0.0598826706,
0.0265228637,
-0.0015528166,
0.0558123589,
-0.0288115442,
-0.0186058357,
0.0074324864,
-0.0779208019,
-0.013083729,
0.0430767126,
-0.035046719,
-0.0944102034,
-0.0120806545,
0.0570761338,
-0.010587018,
-0.0111436732,
-0.0104339877,
0.0347177051,
-0.0144057702,
0.0195412654,
-0.0381442867,
-0.0618372597,
0.0066190767,
0.0168307386,
-0.0511723198,
0.001424366,
0.0385167189,
-0.0346547365,
-0.0001937896,
0.0049524019,
0.0144927343,
0.0153036565,
0.073700428,
0.0009344662,
-0.0000985835,
-0.041660849,
0.0313371867,
-0.0179236419,
-0.0047752513,
0.0285697728,
0.0010121916,
0.0553842597,
0.0645457134,
0.0609996766,
0.04725511,
0.0085730487,
0.0079145869,
-0.0415067449,
0.0194141194,
0.0252474956,
0.0237240009,
0.0161195528,
0.0236338377,
-0.0218098536,
-0.0205699056,
-0.0390459038,
0.016254643,
-0.0324072614,
-0.0083432598,
0.0638457388,
0.0291943476,
-0.0099798972,
-0.0243949518,
0.0331437215,
-0.0142155988,
0.0111032091,
-0.0204297658,
-0.0219951496,
0.0649020746,
-0.0098817172,
0.0153415157,
-0.0161939338,
0.0308904592,
0.0118115544,
0.0459340587,
0.0185720157,
-0.026717307,
0.0703764111,
-0.0137767531,
-0.0331227668,
0.0114178937,
-0.0209272318,
-0.0004347883,
-0.0374132805,
-0.0207058117,
0.0017472089,
0.0390437283,
-0.0141097261,
0.0079952581,
0.0199553706,
-0.0183203015,
-0.0246259589,
0.014952777,
0.0467426404,
0.0493627638,
-0.0044903308,
0.0074177943,
-0.023044005,
-0.0199437458,
0.0217541195,
-0.0349882059,
-0.0053264326,
-0.0344638862,
2.556e-7,
0.0582939163,
0.0814099014,
0.0154526802,
-0.0064587728,
-0.0088345297,
0.0026868498,
-0.0025301031,
-0.0055043898,
-0.0159722548,
-0.0195686016,
0.0228258837,
-0.0098892618,
0.0572323017,
-0.0362580977,
-0.0884258226,
-0.0120836161,
-0.0501839891,
-0.0343687683,
-0.0284197889,
0.0040810839,
0.0751839131,
0.0573172905,
0.014672217,
0.0087040663,
-0.039721515,
0.0015588005,
0.011840147,
-0.0279047005,
-0.0274611935,
0.0268192235,
0.0332140699,
0.0026939339,
0.028231753,
-0.0180360787,
-0.0154428119,
-0.0005394022,
0.0508151315,
0.0753927529,
0.0171545818,
0.0271390062,
0.0322878435,
-0.0211731251,
-0.0120281698,
-0.0396103337,
0.0467385612,
-0.043013487,
0.0141595155,
-0.012960176,
-0.0235007051,
0.0131064793,
0.0021690743,
-0.0097697563,
-0.0165487099,
0.0199359711,
0.0321034379,
0.027284937,
-0.0361344591,
-0.0532298088,
-0.0840063915,
0.0353663489,
-0.0230170321,
-0.0063785794,
-0.021747129,
-0.0122661227,
-0.0036877575,
-0.0885449946,
-0.0325000137,
2.583261564e-34,
0.0526251979,
0.0169723742,
0.017915478,
0.0337924175,
0.0642469674,
-0.0255201273,
-0.0507996641,
0.0048859827,
-0.0428177156,
-0.0455912761,
-0.0193194263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01339v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01339v4 | ArabIcros: AI-Powered Arabic Crossword Puzzle Generation for Educational Applications | 2023-12-03T10:03:50 | 2024-01-26T18:11:43 | Kamyar Zeinalipour, Mohamed Zaky Saad, Marco Maggini, Marco Gori | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents the first Arabic crossword puzzle generator driven by
advanced AI technology. Leveraging cutting-edge large language models including
GPT4, GPT3-Davinci, GPT3-Curie, GPT3-Babbage, GPT3-Ada, and BERT, the system
generates distinctive and challenging clues. Based on a dataset comprising over
50,000 clue-answer pairs, the generator employs fine-tuning, few/zero-shot
learning strategies, and rigorous quality-checking protocols to enforce the
generation of high-quality clue-answer pairs. Importantly, educational
crosswords contribute to enhancing memory, expanding vocabulary, and promoting
problem-solving skills, thereby augmenting the learning experience through a
fun and engaging approach, reshaping the landscape of traditional learning
methods. The overall system can be exploited as a powerful educational tool
that amalgamates AI and innovative learning techniques, heralding a
transformative era for Arabic crossword puzzles and the intersection of
technology and education. | [
0.0020303768,
0.0038556729,
-0.0477149487,
0.0203274619,
-0.0599103272,
-0.0050402055,
0.0384480953,
-0.0195141323,
-0.0042878119,
-0.0031618802,
0.0105799325,
0.0004926768,
-0.0011969345,
0.0434584059,
0.0196421444,
-0.0358624235,
0.0200495292,
-0.0661708042,
0.0016635802,
-0.0068525481,
0.0023283488,
0.0320374407,
-0.037665844,
0.0263853315,
-0.0015432239,
-0.0203015078,
-0.0538608022,
-0.0510402061,
0.002600831,
-0.0163221788,
-0.0070825759,
0.0608000681,
0.0070234719,
0.0537516922,
0.0000021786,
-0.0673892722,
-0.0558728576,
-0.0238041412,
-0.0334113464,
-0.0039493563,
-0.044780869,
0.0113182859,
-0.0363576189,
-0.0045892429,
-0.0682341009,
0.0157536026,
0.0793264508,
0.0157597903,
0.0583299696,
0.0225512125,
0.0162896421,
-0.0247594025,
0.0677447915,
0.013387138,
0.0885361806,
-0.0451346412,
-0.0324848294,
0.0024503551,
0.0514270701,
0.0365724415,
-0.0470780618,
0.0234962907,
0.0170653053,
-0.0180296954,
-0.0339684784,
-0.0011571666,
-0.0240762085,
-0.0074429791,
-0.014729795,
0.0331028588,
-0.0078170113,
-0.0122700837,
-0.0149375005,
0.001101216,
0.0141394669,
0.0379270725,
-0.0559864193,
0.037100412,
-0.0414213613,
-0.0048763389,
0.0807270482,
-0.0176723562,
-0.021178199,
0.0362726264,
-0.0258446876,
0.0701145083,
0.0199709851,
-0.0457935557,
-0.0046196301,
-0.0154728014,
-0.0015341963,
-0.0341947936,
0.0162233505,
0.0338602401,
-0.0252947453,
0.0101890462,
-0.0571475811,
-0.0439694226,
0.027634548,
-0.0109312227,
0.0362658724,
0.0498425812,
0.0190977901,
0.0271355491,
0.0024326909,
0.0566593334,
0.0384982862,
0.0163661465,
-0.0487196185,
0.0229562819,
-0.0320315734,
-0.0143510569,
-0.0583206005,
0.0573729426,
-0.0621195808,
-0.0153615903,
-0.0495307967,
0.0059394306,
0.0137450704,
0.0349791832,
0.0260781273,
-0.0140434913,
-0.0277412161,
-0.0178342331,
-0.0171249881,
-0.0183162186,
-0.0415179804,
-0.0217847694,
-0.0113633489,
-0.0493682586,
0.0100286854,
-0.0168294441,
0.0192147773,
-0.0278811492,
0.0457957685,
0.049966827,
-0.0324764848,
-0.0446080044,
-0.0125795202,
-0.0108401738,
-0.0029258099,
-0.0486387014,
0.0071085454,
-0.0637353808,
0.0298914928,
-0.0041360403,
-0.0191012099,
-0.0091797924,
0.0381816924,
0.0499836281,
0.0402633771,
0.0933316648,
0.0063045626,
-0.0026604261,
0.0682261363,
0.006780358,
0.0402486138,
0.0563491359,
0.0721375197,
0.0267809238,
0.0358860865,
-0.0184405707,
0.0149560291,
0.0191464759,
0.0308728255,
-0.0123912152,
0.0128402729,
-0.0334754921,
0.0419853441,
0.0769363567,
-0.0779528841,
0.0508047491,
0.0096483231,
0.0349677019,
0.0390834622,
0.015791174,
-0.0165520757,
0.0474265181,
0.0319411829,
-0.0180675741,
0.0435262546,
0.0202965438,
0.0071419561,
0.0555039793,
0.021828711,
0.0089259977,
0.0228049941,
0.0652848557,
-0.0053522643,
-0.0671965703,
0.0037050543,
0.0104666268,
0.0406757966,
0.0012009968,
0.1036686972,
0.0023936648,
-0.0592983961,
-0.0188475754,
0.0081688082,
-0.0363197289,
0.0156677384,
-0.0775812864,
0.0278800968,
0.0785352141,
0.079664655,
-0.0285847504,
-0.064838022,
0.0198051371,
0.0371720269,
0.048907429,
0.0089675086,
-0.0063011651,
-0.0227385499,
-0.0515817441,
-0.0371755809,
0.0149357328,
-0.0121692484,
-0.0122654215,
0.0440867692,
0.0587191805,
-0.0180080701,
-0.0306275748,
0.007696942,
0.0266341269,
-0.0592046529,
-0.0400881767,
-0.0136261797,
0.0215314571,
-0.0176843982,
0.0551830269,
-0.0098873638,
0.0203293879,
0.0351852551,
-0.0205991995,
0.0054785581,
-0.0342681706,
-0.0420923494,
0.0625234097,
0.061021395,
-0.0691742152,
0.0427833647,
0.0468362905,
0.0306324773,
-0.0343575291,
0.0685485601,
-0.0431642234,
0.0573957451,
-0.0258971825,
0.0473494641,
0.0088303825,
0.0114602949,
-0.0256450474,
0.0451399162,
-0.0023704644,
0.0107921744,
-0.0609262362,
0.0002956043,
0.044201538,
-0.0255188793,
0.0183339808,
0.0482305586,
-0.0003294507,
0.012956758,
0.0321481898,
0.0216487162,
-0.0432499312,
-0.0362142362,
-0.0371021666,
0.003191679,
0.0211384371,
0.0166522935,
-0.035362117,
0.0192588065,
-0.0189780388,
0.017507378,
-0.0355316624,
-0.0212131571,
0.0305083655,
-0.0139066121,
0.0096893152,
0.0187163465,
-0.0161842033,
-0.0292805955,
-0.0298088044,
-0.0051697223,
0.0352359042,
0.0711214915,
-0.0132521912,
-0.0052470975,
-0.0190088265,
-0.0269558225,
0.0157947335,
0.0109475311,
-0.0197895821,
0.0464198664,
-0.0274820756,
0.009169247,
0.0324417278,
0.0107153719,
0.017860055,
0.0143807651,
-0.0811338499,
-0.042040918,
0.0318433195,
0.0111804083,
-0.0221838634,
0.0315490142,
-0.0607688054,
-0.0422380827,
-0.0162918139,
0.0273855291,
0.0045296513,
-0.053278584,
0.0533401221,
0.0065522557,
-0.012405917,
-0.0288651269,
-0.0251486097,
0.0060356362,
0.0479517877,
-0.0114924936,
-0.03704926,
0.0442283563,
-0.0187451448,
0.0134862009,
-0.0550164357,
0.0447148867,
-0.0303964093,
0.017249709,
-0.0546255372,
0.0306373052,
-0.0150235025,
0.0128786555,
-0.0438267514,
-0.0103637855,
0.0398287103,
-0.056709677,
-0.0049502617,
-0.0686157197,
-0.0156819336,
-0.0143532166,
-0.0203042794,
-0.0216147993,
0.0721068308,
-0.0365790501,
-0.025150368,
0.0725448802,
-0.0264676549,
-0.0226369891,
0.0215456411,
0.0541256405,
-0.0080339042,
-0.0188106932,
0.0023727571,
0.0097799683,
0.0126486896,
0.0589912422,
-0.0238211323,
-0.0103259515,
-0.0207628608,
0.0026404068,
0.0285377726,
0.0232237484,
-0.0122634051,
-0.0241108052,
0.0285278261,
0.039756868,
-0.0325169526,
-0.0262274407,
-0.0335493945,
-0.0473765768,
-0.0611118525,
-0.016447952,
0.0593333468,
0.0496015623,
-0.0418573804,
-0.0168275647,
0.0051971986,
-0.0419910215,
-0.0377917401,
0.0192011222,
-0.1120233014,
-0.0039593019,
0.0111309113,
0.0017489869,
-0.0081944941,
-0.0118523706,
0.0033014426,
-0.1188279316,
0.0283339862,
0.009472739,
-0.0306800269,
-0.0678970218,
-0.0437039062,
-0.028742006,
0.0314476378,
-0.0364236049,
-0.024400916,
-0.0041646762,
0.049782116,
0.0273774695,
0.0492543913,
-0.0101948828,
-0.000214144,
-0.0287766811,
0.0082968762,
0.1011147127,
0.0189715363,
-0.0350930318,
-0.110956952,
-0.0138292396,
-0.0105167627,
-0.0423522778,
-0.0330929272,
-0.0072884476,
-0.0148819815,
-0.0295459908,
-0.0400781892,
-0.0226916503,
-0.019012887,
-0.0214141514,
0.0333892778,
0.0729404539,
-0.014676841,
0.0510236137,
-0.0185574982,
-0.0050406791,
0.0096750744,
0.0245382395,
-0.0230149478,
-0.0361085683,
-0.0116082774,
-0.0185494348,
0.022330096,
-0.0848267451,
-0.019283127,
-0.0188046377,
-0.0065395548,
0.0288846642,
-0.0482265204,
-0.0446478538,
0.0495775156,
0.0355762541,
0.0131676262,
0.0282889772,
-0.0560958125,
0.0622245446,
-0.0660627484,
-0.0794340521,
0.01555462,
0.0211795364,
-0.0570171475,
-0.0728334412,
-0.0388432927,
-0.0975579023,
0.0214305669,
0.0442827754,
-0.0205742884,
-0.0003475898,
0.0402039886,
0.0331610702,
0.0201830305,
-0.0323806852,
0.0573318116,
0.0067759342,
0.0334255956,
0.0157060232,
0.038801644,
0.0224957187,
-0.0301484652,
-0.006975004,
0.0003050087,
0.0089843478,
0.0148565015,
-0.0293560866,
0.0086164456,
0.028662147,
-0.006839531,
-0.028278986,
0.0397644304,
-0.0022512136,
-0.006167904,
-0.0609088466,
-0.0401988328,
-0.022795653,
0.0114304926,
-0.0518576242,
-0.007644054,
-0.0223284252,
0.0050292877,
-0.0179168358,
-0.0267721657,
0.0309183449,
0.0244698469,
0.0185651127,
-0.039959576,
-0.0505839288,
0.0441069938,
-0.0094431285,
0.0547079816,
-0.0033166623,
0.008771752,
0.0298055932,
0.0052602175,
-0.0152966185,
0.0565311573,
-0.0232354514,
0.0261441842,
-0.0038512817,
-0.0101409396,
0.0125923641,
0.0674460903,
0.0041902699,
-0.0289253108,
-0.047563374,
0.0448340029,
0.0589225292,
0.0042354683,
-0.0105104912,
-0.0008323541,
-0.0023761988,
0.0125698606,
-0.0023123613,
0.0212332625,
-0.0048994296,
-0.0165012497,
0.0154075632,
0.0409033634,
-0.0164969526,
0.0690634921,
-0.003973919,
0.045960471,
0.0427761264,
-0.0296822377,
-0.0430254452,
-0.0070148315,
0.0204285514,
0.0044084415,
-0.0189667419,
0.003676431,
-0.0505732149,
-0.0516629368,
0.0193724222,
0.0737423822,
0.0180294942,
0.0292285308,
0.0504244044,
0.0915794745,
-0.0063711549,
-0.026375372,
-0.0271664299,
0.0569533519,
-0.0498198047,
-0.0609033629,
0.0124992235,
-6.131843221e-33,
-0.015761897,
-0.0501001999,
0.0529024452,
0.0167735852,
0.0031239809,
-0.0170336235,
-0.0185656454,
0.0240101945,
0.0067808721,
-0.0075447983,
-0.0451171882,
-0.0073141148,
0.0103907268,
-0.0024447138,
0.0411896482,
-0.0121718021,
0.0100280605,
-0.0276059378,
-0.030646408,
0.0302919019,
0.0351706967,
0.014621661,
0.0645384416,
-0.0428082272,
0.0176668111,
-0.0181360133,
-0.040323101,
-0.0102431215,
-0.0345605388,
0.0788271874,
-0.0230701901,
0.0227386802,
-0.0047943732,
-0.0239961166,
0.0282110814,
0.0013285517,
-0.0452818461,
-0.025857769,
0.0044078487,
0.0210771989,
-0.0148259467,
-0.0747799575,
-0.0304574352,
-0.0242093187,
-0.0574672781,
0.0637292191,
0.0170922298,
-0.0336241387,
0.002466039,
0.0002247889,
-0.0626730248,
0.0094494177,
-0.0146492003,
-0.0632820651,
0.0323092192,
-0.012260546,
0.0311284289,
-0.0495083183,
-0.0052954969,
0.0900893807,
0.0533287972,
0.0053260019,
0.0881002545,
0.0063218465,
-0.0409159325,
0.0356992483,
0.0426149219,
-0.0583300404,
0.0433977209,
0.0271975864,
0.0230857283,
-0.0111542968,
0.0683739409,
0.0790670961,
0.0260909647,
-0.0122664925,
-0.0564818904,
0.0718319863,
-0.0131479567,
0.0237219483,
0.0014472405,
-0.0138820847,
-0.0907809287,
0.0040083872,
0.0055976487,
-0.0008232359,
-0.0162829608,
-0.0114087332,
0.006543078,
0.0061486308,
-0.0298862848,
0.0215325002,
-0.0146288816,
0.0275955182,
0.0471915193,
0.0082595171,
0.0351186134,
-0.0269589294,
-0.0199389439,
-0.0173077732,
-0.0068631042,
-0.0314131901,
0.0063951132,
0.0098134484,
0.009231573,
0.0104621621,
-0.0262418017,
0.057108134,
-0.0543453991,
0.0252257362,
-0.0483235344,
0.0273088068,
0.0648704618,
-0.0463012233,
0.0063116411,
-0.0429169238,
-0.0012969951,
-0.0377933346,
0.0576958433,
-0.007177169,
-0.0265064798,
-0.0200938322,
-0.0230525676,
-0.0106729325,
0.0038724127,
0.0303928163,
-0.0848418176,
-0.0162507072,
-0.0238318127,
-0.0662778392,
0.0064397473,
0.0038387843,
2.934e-7,
0.0235296302,
0.0458957255,
0.0439040698,
0.0320070572,
-0.0170562603,
-0.0072580595,
0.0204878226,
-0.0024248273,
-0.0022321937,
0.0600823723,
-0.0048094448,
0.0318031013,
0.0326895192,
0.0421188548,
-0.0590349026,
-0.0068296418,
0.0263369791,
0.0088857338,
-0.0768563524,
0.014869025,
0.0474185757,
0.0440358073,
-0.0104822405,
-0.0300017912,
-0.0477652103,
-0.0276659634,
0.0077704038,
0.00810281,
-0.0086915949,
0.0041732816,
-0.0324121304,
-0.0314355865,
-0.0160124414,
-0.0075770477,
-0.0284175389,
0.0163233075,
0.0482499599,
0.0103615997,
0.0084031774,
-0.0032426168,
0.0260998476,
-0.0111118797,
-0.0065277941,
-0.0510353744,
0.0662739277,
0.0776320547,
0.0339113027,
0.0094839493,
-0.0308704861,
-0.0106370654,
0.0290019568,
-0.0637036934,
-0.030372126,
0.0163468421,
0.0035322364,
0.0302755833,
0.0259564295,
-0.0066667232,
0.0021304102,
-0.0450396203,
-0.0147284623,
-0.0195818376,
-0.0363468379,
-0.0386038385,
-0.0351506881,
-0.0045630937,
0.0137620065,
2.558532561e-34,
0.0074043968,
-0.024760589,
0.0068096025,
-0.0068110079,
0.0232949499,
-0.0038985,
-0.0063207946,
0.0151096815,
0.0311493874,
-0.0437308364,
-0.0411215425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01314v1 | NLEBench+NorGLM: A Comprehensive Empirical Analysis and Benchmark Dataset for Generative Language Models in Norwegian | 2023-12-03T08:09:45 | 2023-12-03T08:09:45 | Peng Liu, Lemei Zhang, Terje Nissen Farup, Even W. Lauvrak, Jon Espen Ingvaldsen, Simen Eide, Jon Atle Gulla, Zhirong Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Generative Language Models (GLMs) have transformed
Natural Language Processing (NLP) by showcasing the effectiveness of the
"pre-train, prompt, and predict" paradigm in utilizing pre-trained GLM
knowledge for diverse applications. Despite their potential, these capabilities
lack adequate quantitative characterization due to the absence of comprehensive
benchmarks, particularly for low-resource languages. Existing low-resource
benchmarks focus on discriminative language models like BERT, neglecting the
evaluation of generative language models. Moreover, current benchmarks often
overlook measuring generalization performance across multiple tasks, a crucial
metric for GLMs.
To bridge these gaps, we introduce NLEBench, a comprehensive benchmark
tailored for evaluating natural language generation capabilities in Norwegian,
a low-resource language. We use Norwegian as a case study to explore whether
current GLMs and benchmarks in mainstream languages like English can reveal the
unique characteristics of underrepresented languages. NLEBench encompasses a
suite of real-world NLP tasks ranging from news storytelling, summarization,
open-domain conversation, natural language understanding, instruction
fine-tuning, toxicity and bias evaluation, to self-curated Chain-of-Thought
investigation. It features two high-quality, human-annotated datasets: an
instruction dataset covering traditional Norwegian cultures, idioms, slang, and
special expressions, and a document-grounded multi-label dataset for topic
classification, question answering, and summarization. This paper also
introduces foundational Norwegian Generative Language Models (NorGLMs)
developed with diverse parameter scales and Transformer-based architectures.
Systematic evaluations on the proposed benchmark suite provide insights into
the capabilities and scalability of NorGLMs across various downstream tasks. | [
0.0486471653,
0.091464296,
0.0054697245,
0.0254796352,
-0.029304184,
0.0123770013,
0.0262936503,
-0.0445414409,
-0.0296215992,
-0.0424756259,
0.0011030933,
-0.0655304119,
0.007977413,
-0.0066407109,
0.0397753827,
-0.0665269941,
0.0428132452,
-0.0182349514,
-0.0053647612,
-0.0227509066,
0.0006147824,
0.0405784696,
-0.0089789424,
0.0459057577,
-0.008459379,
0.014915741,
0.0190536585,
0.0281930249,
0.0439751372,
0.0252626799,
0.0087260706,
0.0615909509,
-0.0070864861,
0.0426269285,
0.0000018653,
-0.0656246766,
0.0349560678,
-0.0414349511,
0.0129912719,
0.0567666627,
0.0753210559,
-0.0068085683,
-0.0082795238,
0.0014841103,
0.0037884561,
-0.0640786439,
0.0366961472,
0.0355814323,
0.0516621135,
0.0751057193,
0.003822112,
-0.0464226119,
0.01588968,
-0.0434161797,
-0.0259637367,
-0.0212438889,
0.0212806314,
0.016609434,
-0.0178151578,
-0.0178936478,
-0.0579170585,
0.0441530272,
0.0369381718,
-0.0057440237,
0.0025409202,
0.0416474789,
-0.0577312522,
-0.0393838175,
-0.0019767738,
0.074081704,
-0.0378123447,
-0.0293712784,
0.0021268702,
-0.0068556434,
-0.0155061549,
-0.053405989,
-0.0158119816,
0.0513223372,
0.0205031801,
0.0275251046,
0.0291751772,
0.0014230127,
-0.0009251347,
0.0170785524,
0.0041061444,
0.028839184,
0.0315919109,
0.00596814,
0.0016011299,
0.0100578424,
-0.0355358869,
-0.0409396663,
-0.0394579396,
-0.0061193197,
-0.0305534378,
-0.0025059013,
-0.0380426943,
-0.0466506369,
0.0464732833,
-0.0114721628,
0.0254205074,
-0.0033550418,
-0.0276897177,
0.0203825068,
-0.0059791133,
0.0256234184,
0.0135781234,
0.0165374149,
-0.0594570525,
-0.0375521816,
-0.0100713307,
-0.0032102708,
-0.065490745,
-0.0214524828,
-0.0523751378,
-0.0088115083,
-0.0351201817,
-0.0056360038,
0.0406411588,
-0.0398018658,
0.0120876748,
0.0324160382,
-0.0448377915,
-0.0020588739,
-0.0143797267,
0.0245489329,
-0.0257031657,
0.0062095677,
0.0056582154,
-0.0714393705,
0.0164011382,
0.0235480852,
0.0090337861,
-0.030250378,
0.0322574303,
0.0259675067,
-0.0374726579,
-0.0187522862,
-0.0466859639,
0.002558338,
-0.004300592,
-0.0836270601,
0.0004026381,
-0.0803604424,
0.0334370732,
-0.0058365311,
-0.0140455505,
-0.0506546237,
0.0091249822,
0.0000622639,
-0.0237785839,
0.0225628726,
0.0097187692,
0.0144491345,
0.0349387154,
0.0194253214,
0.0328079723,
0.0685119107,
0.0259761848,
0.0056834947,
0.0566933453,
-0.0116181746,
-0.0092691602,
0.0377670713,
0.0160163566,
0.0002773007,
-0.0231990125,
0.0072429855,
-0.0256104022,
0.0207084846,
0.0710238814,
0.0579255112,
-0.0213661455,
-0.0223150589,
0.0570480078,
0.0444641225,
0.015007956,
0.0516346283,
0.0657532513,
0.0353398994,
-0.0142880408,
-0.0262731984,
-0.0043345522,
0.009815203,
0.0109714214,
0.0156749543,
0.0465179384,
0.0731567442,
-0.0131643089,
-0.0481108576,
0.0087731825,
0.0036379874,
0.0067474148,
-0.0064309742,
0.0109944921,
0.0404796451,
-0.0306957103,
0.0381634422,
0.0346860215,
-0.0699290559,
0.0428969935,
-0.026457794,
0.021408245,
0.0283342339,
0.0372851342,
0.0317565016,
-0.0510579571,
-0.0504328199,
0.0198154058,
0.0347286016,
0.0591152497,
-0.0266274754,
0.0507332571,
-0.0146741979,
0.0198502596,
-0.0270684902,
0.0077831922,
0.0467128791,
0.0019593528,
0.0006187583,
0.008007546,
-0.0708974004,
-0.0339707807,
0.0206316393,
-0.0470230319,
-0.0361145549,
0.0339052789,
-0.0222935267,
0.0179714616,
0.0314172842,
-0.0524439774,
0.0039755227,
0.0126794502,
-0.0635567531,
-0.0320478603,
0.0296179503,
-0.030906437,
-0.0540062971,
-0.0209976099,
-0.0721498653,
-0.0241251756,
0.0257860031,
-0.0471638553,
-0.0419921428,
0.0688944831,
-0.0227729939,
-0.0048902808,
-0.0445108972,
-0.0254844315,
-0.0000058184,
0.0299304537,
-0.0124220904,
0.0501861125,
-0.0176522378,
0.0270320605,
-0.0020369499,
0.031471733,
0.0208459832,
-0.0515983328,
-0.0394962393,
0.0303308908,
-0.0158825219,
0.0257035811,
0.0451375432,
0.0219732951,
-0.0106593287,
0.0117071867,
-0.0912002176,
0.0278999135,
-0.0591226891,
0.0279816948,
0.0544988587,
0.0436186232,
-0.0430679545,
-0.0089062043,
-0.0620718151,
-0.0284168068,
0.0523766652,
-0.0078382911,
0.0050983392,
-0.0020454961,
0.0083043203,
-0.0115275029,
-0.0120613696,
0.0281293839,
0.053850092,
-0.0030011553,
0.0107757207,
-0.0238307063,
0.0248295907,
-0.0415992141,
0.0075942641,
-0.0044962494,
-0.0303861778,
-0.0268061887,
0.0129479961,
0.1127220765,
0.0440963134,
0.0293019786,
-0.0527863763,
0.0153959952,
-0.0224352125,
-0.0395227931,
-0.0004045887,
-0.0555165894,
-0.0106778378,
-0.0214153696,
-0.0336484164,
0.0066979113,
0.0728185326,
0.0422598571,
-0.0190933626,
-0.0231934637,
0.0139949881,
-0.0093193175,
-0.0209217221,
-0.0545817018,
0.0094452584,
0.0030070161,
0.060475409,
-0.0446297005,
-0.0382798165,
0.0391920656,
-0.0104253814,
-0.0235143974,
-0.0555078611,
-0.009951964,
-0.0236593969,
0.0484989248,
0.026228169,
0.0584866256,
0.0055535729,
-0.0025412713,
-0.0040096515,
0.0140585527,
0.0305395257,
-0.0180076584,
0.0459670834,
-0.031578254,
-0.0130713265,
0.0049463967,
-0.0292484406,
-0.0453948341,
-0.0504707508,
0.0006836461,
0.0156936385,
0.0471587069,
-0.0096269222,
-0.0252225697,
-0.0145929139,
0.0077166241,
0.0125286318,
0.0023825078,
0.0049861381,
-0.0056918655,
0.041817721,
0.0385791585,
-0.0322851501,
0.0225985739,
0.0175851025,
0.00204121,
0.0117481835,
0.0221021865,
0.0001634296,
-0.020295579,
0.0102221323,
0.0272931661,
-0.0259528309,
-0.0053532473,
0.0065468904,
0.0750278383,
-0.0015111569,
-0.0374769382,
0.0716754347,
0.002896765,
0.0320423171,
0.0387948304,
0.0258283857,
0.0730864778,
0.0398110971,
0.0268166643,
-0.084049277,
0.0086655226,
-0.0126333451,
0.0107201552,
-0.0114031723,
-0.0297592692,
-0.0452148803,
-0.1171850711,
0.0521074124,
0.0050926185,
-0.0488980152,
0.0112334285,
-0.0389612503,
-0.0413594022,
-0.0617291108,
0.004407052,
-0.0080425469,
-0.0057800151,
0.0226154253,
0.0001092764,
-0.0470420644,
-0.0638834015,
0.0149352206,
-0.0225358307,
0.053806141,
0.0384206735,
0.0205169544,
-0.0069548171,
-0.037408229,
0.0705383942,
-0.0366264582,
-0.0281591956,
0.0010712057,
0.0566640906,
0.0108284615,
-0.00258311,
-0.037179254,
0.0559558049,
0.0004249398,
-0.0142650511,
-0.0143543296,
0.0334848166,
0.0306528769,
-0.0319550782,
0.0020035717,
0.0435131975,
0.022546947,
0.0674519762,
0.0535003282,
-0.0307523608,
-0.0502990633,
-0.024431916,
0.0033691388,
-0.0761646777,
-0.0476707593,
0.0135904858,
0.0154817458,
0.0048785056,
-0.0449272469,
-0.0455640852,
-0.0004018395,
-0.00157174,
-0.0122799631,
-0.0172421169,
-0.0434420891,
-0.0264959093,
-0.0381329805,
0.0286853369,
-0.0101328557,
-0.01387385,
-0.0320543684,
-0.0219779108,
0.0250618197,
-0.0360080823,
-0.034241911,
0.0275319535,
-0.0875389874,
-0.0772821382,
0.0151980855,
0.0535548776,
0.0153417699,
0.058485467,
0.0027732719,
-0.0554016158,
0.0418095589,
0.0600992665,
-0.017566273,
0.0244969185,
-0.0109485239,
0.0324666202,
0.002863385,
0.0267651826,
-0.0247509889,
0.0864533558,
0.0259196237,
0.0186289884,
0.0207429864,
-0.0446506254,
-0.02839211,
0.0177481398,
0.0109104337,
-0.0777578354,
-0.006605607,
-0.081775561,
-0.0271201115,
0.0076431404,
-0.012395842,
-0.0373376682,
-0.0104322014,
0.0516449027,
0.0073953387,
-0.0313110054,
0.049468793,
-0.0650667995,
0.056672316,
-0.0685112923,
0.008157461,
0.0283430703,
-0.0017321559,
0.01241518,
0.0158600248,
-0.0109231379,
0.0061245835,
-0.0124969371,
0.0632795393,
-0.0074775466,
0.0367292985,
-0.0035023675,
0.0178309884,
0.0291413087,
0.0011550869,
-0.0687004253,
-0.0040324274,
-0.0212097149,
-0.025298465,
0.0803149641,
-0.0232355632,
0.0840665698,
-0.0104001183,
0.0121273389,
-0.0171141177,
0.0387730151,
-0.0089377211,
-0.0835058838,
-0.0115618808,
-0.0011957359,
-0.0292949583,
0.0164745077,
0.0646274537,
0.0236839429,
0.0534246564,
0.0363488384,
0.0128461709,
-0.0581473,
-0.0390019491,
0.0325813368,
-0.0183293354,
-0.0266863499,
0.0236127265,
-0.0648821592,
-0.0453684255,
-0.0204948466,
-0.0045607542,
0.0282503441,
0.001579228,
0.0373712555,
0.0495840572,
-0.0018887178,
-0.0141806388,
-0.0636360571,
-0.0147865871,
-0.0427219085,
-0.0161391497,
-0.0129570039,
-6.521359805e-33,
-0.016535027,
0.0344028249,
-0.0004408483,
-0.0146893654,
0.009529219,
0.0022888789,
-0.0134898284,
0.0056237238,
-0.000248702,
0.0189915504,
0.018155653,
-0.0323819816,
-0.0019737633,
0.0801683888,
-0.0415848829,
-0.0027923975,
0.0432046205,
-0.0026466744,
-0.034683276,
0.0505393483,
0.0199048612,
0.0536984764,
0.071743384,
-0.0339572541,
0.0205328912,
-0.0377613977,
-0.0018910032,
0.0161527358,
0.047524292,
0.0238635316,
-0.0220147427,
0.0748890489,
0.0172562208,
-0.0565327518,
-0.034385249,
0.0050706491,
-0.0895004272,
-0.0240719952,
0.0277756453,
0.0035569051,
-0.0463126637,
-0.0103997951,
0.024440445,
-0.0199708901,
-0.0320943482,
-0.0040902547,
0.0320039988,
0.0076597487,
0.0152131217,
-0.0664898083,
-0.0800495297,
0.0118500469,
-0.0329801552,
-0.0208001062,
-0.0238628145,
0.0493677147,
-0.0042129676,
-0.0299256835,
-0.0666618273,
0.0295417923,
0.0238575526,
0.0081907343,
0.0521524176,
-0.0082346266,
-0.0001836024,
0.0737772733,
0.0067064366,
0.022259552,
-0.0476065576,
0.0261710603,
0.023682164,
0.0383186378,
0.0114253238,
0.0618082397,
0.0599461831,
0.0146551076,
-0.0803310201,
0.0344149657,
0.0030504446,
-0.0082633477,
0.0345563516,
-0.0319198631,
-0.0030822465,
-0.0442526266,
-0.0514916815,
-0.0629789084,
-0.0069682705,
-0.0107983071,
0.0532001853,
0.0115833906,
-0.0093299635,
-0.0340874419,
0.0479735471,
-0.0381594077,
0.0027849632,
0.0185571499,
-0.0277443547,
-0.0138530117,
0.0008332626,
0.0477695242,
-0.0745027736,
-0.014070224,
0.0539451279,
0.0252180658,
-0.0017354198,
-0.0060543236,
0.0529951081,
0.0071395356,
-0.0515330471,
0.0482961014,
-0.0394840203,
0.0708451718,
-0.0324807577,
-0.0035927843,
0.0178269446,
0.0085011357,
-0.0389934964,
0.028593909,
0.0442615636,
0.0055946358,
0.0029565948,
-0.0258776434,
-0.0274681076,
0.0323804505,
-0.0362144299,
0.0207424648,
-0.0195089038,
-0.0066150073,
0.0511589944,
-0.0298631471,
-0.0094922688,
0.0014457853,
2.539e-7,
0.0649851263,
0.0167427137,
0.0515301041,
-0.0157737602,
0.0044673164,
-0.0176568646,
0.0230594259,
0.0461983159,
0.0027757641,
-0.0034034494,
-0.0066394377,
0.0397584848,
0.027067624,
0.0405914262,
-0.0647603944,
0.0174482558,
-0.0675371215,
0.0261963047,
-0.0562423989,
-0.0446683839,
0.0295862798,
0.0788491517,
-0.0366479941,
-0.033471819,
-0.0049901344,
-0.0360742323,
0.0667135566,
-0.0379163548,
-0.0054305615,
0.0187678393,
0.0663556233,
0.0397948958,
0.0500456989,
-0.014451853,
-0.0078360476,
-0.0029625553,
0.0182849355,
0.0445307381,
0.0238976944,
-0.038781967,
0.0254681632,
0.0021128715,
-0.0311722886,
-0.0707776472,
0.0720963851,
-0.0566836186,
-0.049601566,
0.0023595989,
-0.0265111811,
0.0471101627,
0.0482160449,
-0.0614691563,
-0.020835476,
0.0239656474,
0.0536113456,
-0.0182329249,
-0.0091750445,
-0.0369229987,
-0.0576844774,
0.0269774329,
-0.0420146808,
-0.0196909364,
-0.0169143919,
0.0428956412,
-0.0179563947,
-0.0316133536,
0.0092366831,
2.274816209e-34,
0.0511563756,
0.0030941397,
-0.0166990198,
-0.0399310067,
0.0453217104,
-0.0217648447,
0.0100758467,
-0.011284125,
-0.007610389,
-0.0303142164,
-0.0201016497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01308v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01308v1 | Bridging Background Knowledge Gaps in Translation with Automatic Explicitation | 2023-12-03T07:24:12 | 2023-12-03T07:24:12 | HyoJung Han, Jordan Lee Boyd-Graber, Marine Carpuat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Translations help people understand content written in another language.
However, even correct literal translations do not fulfill that goal when people
lack the necessary background to understand them. Professional translators
incorporate explicitations to explain the missing context by considering
cultural differences between source and target audiences. Despite its potential
to help users, NLP research on explicitation is limited because of the dearth
of adequate evaluation methods. This work introduces techniques for
automatically generating explicitations, motivated by WikiExpl: a dataset that
we collect from Wikipedia and annotate with human translators. The resulting
explicitations are useful as they help answer questions more accurately in a
multilingual question answering framework. | [
0.0454550758,
0.0102213072,
-0.0210079774,
0.0485667363,
-0.0101974774,
0.0284668338,
-0.0077749165,
-0.0187894572,
0.0006220685,
-0.0133208102,
0.0196049511,
-0.0121153947,
0.0104029151,
-0.0406842679,
0.041680377,
-0.0813520849,
0.0128206657,
0.0119944131,
-0.0089102713,
-0.0356316864,
0.0090324422,
0.0322586261,
-0.0087639838,
0.0283330828,
0.031815093,
-0.0245725103,
-0.0134150293,
-0.0078944266,
0.0535993129,
0.0079856329,
0.0069747539,
0.0342339426,
0.0110800937,
-0.0182132423,
0.0000020018,
-0.0299801864,
-0.0053815199,
0.0005669335,
-0.0074513247,
0.024885457,
-0.038319204,
-0.0568228774,
0.0153498249,
-0.0505112484,
-0.038699016,
0.0186450444,
0.0416277163,
-0.002427249,
0.0873264074,
-0.0047656028,
-0.0021054652,
-0.0202614535,
-0.0227866061,
0.0286963005,
0.055788815,
-0.0478707626,
-0.0015568238,
0.0230981391,
-0.0365623422,
0.0306088012,
0.0142241716,
0.0536115281,
0.0334544033,
0.0026733286,
0.0112131955,
-0.0048399796,
-0.0126928268,
-0.0326842554,
0.0198542438,
0.0777345821,
0.0545023456,
-0.032471329,
-0.048321642,
-0.0018339234,
-0.0249013305,
-0.0011184101,
-0.0371309072,
0.020215299,
-0.013242349,
-0.0433789417,
0.037518885,
0.039795246,
0.0112930443,
0.0441147462,
0.0031324674,
0.0401185378,
0.0245496593,
-0.003610376,
-0.0065900749,
0.009707965,
-0.0422278568,
-0.034950681,
0.0414394215,
0.0770478919,
-0.0049365484,
0.0222804453,
0.0100714788,
-0.0252832156,
0.0317509621,
-0.0732905045,
-0.0329614356,
0.0516056307,
-0.0379803143,
0.0594360419,
-0.0261269603,
0.0213007461,
-0.0298010316,
-0.0259940289,
-0.0366518497,
-0.0558662824,
-0.0278190747,
-0.0037510465,
-0.0506032892,
-0.0241351351,
-0.0392551012,
0.0464500263,
-0.0315478444,
-0.0020511451,
-0.0329654366,
0.0150184063,
-0.0431537777,
-0.0170439873,
-0.0675789118,
-0.0061081583,
-0.0368264169,
0.0267166346,
-0.1070113629,
-0.0074217902,
-0.0420295745,
-0.01948658,
-0.0051393546,
0.0116037847,
0.0088595124,
-0.0302333646,
-0.009424068,
0.0306577813,
0.0161323268,
0.0150001561,
-0.0113395751,
-0.0498903468,
0.028172642,
-0.0177727118,
-0.0364949554,
-0.0921390355,
0.0605632477,
0.0287182312,
0.0042817998,
-0.0528154746,
0.026315229,
0.0128525225,
-0.0136539424,
0.0948213413,
-0.0416591838,
0.011993954,
0.0304676108,
0.0066844295,
-0.0149538089,
0.0455583483,
0.0190659575,
-0.0128005873,
0.0997314304,
0.0139809847,
-0.015151863,
0.0237512141,
0.0222732686,
0.0231404901,
0.0256154221,
0.0803421661,
-0.0381997339,
0.0205619764,
-0.0139603121,
0.0120571312,
-0.0129293445,
0.0436264575,
-0.0164192282,
0.0318463594,
-0.0117904227,
0.0446782969,
0.0721856281,
0.0106537435,
0.0254586227,
0.0204377398,
0.0089279097,
0.0206585769,
0.0109449942,
0.028976744,
-0.0052222391,
0.028750632,
-0.0152266221,
-0.043338187,
0.00499475,
0.0061387443,
0.0596072972,
0.0127431182,
0.0171563644,
0.0428374112,
-0.0004986673,
0.0711801946,
0.0342485346,
-0.0290957615,
0.0511207581,
0.0045776875,
-0.0199471749,
0.0831020549,
-0.0001896654,
-0.0103247454,
-0.0189644657,
-0.0044497987,
0.053674154,
0.0317812003,
0.010017381,
-0.0577701405,
0.0344062224,
-0.0217097066,
-0.0192888658,
0.0029295145,
-0.0017732627,
0.0039457227,
0.0544459075,
0.0248656217,
0.0427794307,
-0.0639173388,
-0.0619066097,
0.0202891454,
-0.048645597,
-0.0508768223,
0.0057682055,
0.0314719342,
-0.0360516496,
0.0914914832,
0.0102787707,
-0.0010075066,
0.0190607961,
-0.0432775319,
0.010810513,
0.0640899464,
-0.0184978843,
-0.0063194362,
0.0246333927,
-0.0875782371,
-0.0536424816,
-0.0045630257,
-0.0374368317,
-0.023565108,
-0.0235300437,
-0.0250252075,
0.022565525,
-0.0446181372,
-0.0268145464,
-0.0001776158,
-0.0065443343,
-0.0315858684,
0.0783830807,
0.0370330289,
0.0459039696,
0.0617376305,
-0.012811726,
0.0382896177,
-0.0080901785,
0.0019104598,
-0.0044549555,
0.0163824782,
0.0312030762,
0.0605533272,
0.036322847,
-0.0491370335,
0.0353472009,
-0.0677575096,
-0.0060318555,
-0.0377152152,
0.0319156647,
0.0629918724,
0.0489738621,
0.0218683388,
-0.0099942209,
-0.0104811219,
-0.0131258918,
-0.0270209275,
0.0171232875,
0.0458320267,
0.0411756001,
0.0121025471,
-0.0014906604,
-0.0073978784,
0.0118843503,
0.0093518058,
0.0446795858,
-0.0100125801,
-0.0780671164,
-0.0305601954,
-0.0309468582,
-0.0266470872,
0.0329498164,
-0.0473921746,
-0.0083922017,
0.0140232136,
-0.0041527925,
-0.0104838759,
-0.0084917955,
-0.0139343562,
0.0237055961,
-0.01531999,
-0.0443205126,
-0.0264590178,
-0.0374985598,
-0.0321501531,
0.0090410411,
-0.0778134167,
0.0237242188,
0.0173281413,
-0.0105598941,
-0.0198101457,
-0.0770228282,
-0.0113336053,
-0.0454994142,
-0.017965829,
-0.0539658703,
-0.0255729966,
-0.0011870331,
0.0988462716,
-0.0054180184,
0.0248345956,
0.0912178904,
0.008824599,
-0.000682261,
-0.0778654665,
0.019244872,
-0.0323065594,
0.0411649048,
-0.0515588,
0.0174807981,
-0.0322953425,
-0.0154010113,
-0.0072233495,
-0.010490844,
0.0400421955,
-0.0050019962,
0.0533268042,
-0.0594208278,
-0.0114741651,
-0.0108121717,
0.0261943731,
-0.0443132557,
-0.0466308445,
0.0123501197,
-0.0130506428,
0.0146380169,
0.0121472916,
0.0270848982,
-0.017045131,
0.0432996005,
-0.0184455011,
0.0053602238,
0.0036768655,
-0.015963586,
0.0110294605,
0.0225349274,
0.0045251432,
0.0144334864,
-0.0313335545,
0.0371404178,
0.0126048699,
0.0142723359,
-0.0213254392,
0.0019141943,
-0.0080794012,
0.0210122112,
-0.0465103909,
-0.0050732698,
-0.0201711953,
0.0714797005,
-0.0571755655,
-0.0087902965,
0.0818143114,
0.0453352667,
-0.0298616737,
0.0077903219,
-0.0724002346,
-0.017967429,
0.0150288204,
0.0411712304,
-0.0962709635,
0.0018340518,
-0.0281442106,
0.0396937914,
-0.0119259823,
-0.0126784313,
-0.0097019896,
-0.0766543448,
-0.0007669081,
0.0192669164,
-0.0460571088,
-0.0470780246,
-0.0233078152,
-0.0078002349,
-0.0077654654,
0.0180536974,
-0.0092766481,
0.0157441795,
0.0259886086,
-0.0073992605,
0.0046500503,
-0.0601418316,
0.0205754228,
-0.0333646163,
-0.0247075856,
0.0196482409,
0.0539370403,
-0.0179887041,
0.0141219618,
0.0065541747,
-0.0832701027,
-0.0055383882,
0.0141572477,
0.0182427038,
0.0182154607,
-0.0144529361,
-0.0124472799,
0.0196563192,
-0.0088025024,
-0.0166988652,
0.0447762012,
0.0454698764,
0.0170893744,
0.0533585958,
0.0319248624,
0.0097449617,
0.0382832587,
0.0662956983,
0.0499365404,
-0.0103057595,
0.0262526628,
-0.0287625045,
0.0154851805,
-0.0651149973,
-0.0618728064,
0.0103092389,
-0.0521986336,
-0.0293814503,
-0.0713314563,
-0.0803265125,
0.0298236888,
0.0249649975,
0.0471487865,
0.0210918654,
-0.0384705216,
-0.0084526772,
-0.0058234213,
0.0478648171,
-0.00478851,
-0.0032464846,
0.0430585481,
-0.034057118,
-0.0208113957,
-0.0400676206,
0.0001277234,
0.0426900573,
-0.0254913904,
-0.047781188,
0.0209844857,
0.0264629088,
0.0229630638,
0.0592954345,
-0.0312971212,
-0.0281380396,
-0.0039348593,
0.0198247582,
-0.0233905334,
-0.0302466806,
0.0323116481,
0.030423345,
0.0066791377,
0.0654010177,
-0.0430273749,
-0.0068915701,
-0.0344815701,
0.0611554459,
-0.0207315106,
-0.0272466168,
0.0421914645,
0.0231152903,
-0.0356474742,
-0.0509685092,
-0.0560002141,
-0.0178002845,
-0.0056346287,
-0.0235446841,
-0.0398491919,
0.0082845278,
0.0126469005,
-0.0049397121,
-0.0667570308,
0.0122014554,
0.0212533567,
-0.0276454464,
-0.0126691945,
-0.0476275347,
0.0419861823,
0.0536035262,
0.0269972067,
-0.026842095,
0.0186143927,
-0.0368972793,
-0.0247482415,
-0.018745359,
0.0706218556,
-0.0306725074,
0.0155133717,
0.0283474308,
-0.013268075,
-0.0094436202,
-0.0138131222,
-0.0178303979,
-0.0344149247,
0.0125067886,
0.0059033311,
0.0729617327,
-0.0299985912,
0.0987430885,
0.0033519159,
-0.0577301569,
0.0434670374,
0.0475594699,
0.0376549996,
-0.0323169827,
0.0143432524,
0.0165815484,
-0.0022752406,
0.0159144923,
0.0313419923,
-0.0784305334,
0.0320842974,
0.0184102338,
-0.0139843151,
-0.0168173742,
0.004598577,
-0.0571206622,
-0.0006727634,
-0.0302736517,
0.0047078873,
-0.0638518929,
-0.0467916206,
-0.0262024477,
0.0107177552,
-0.0383664668,
0.0049994607,
0.0043213218,
0.0596224405,
0.0365564898,
-0.0252714623,
-0.0581033602,
0.0435205586,
-0.038305141,
0.0092061432,
-0.0441828631,
-6.399259003e-33,
-0.0196179599,
-0.0438903794,
-0.0308145043,
-0.0069306865,
-0.0004033848,
0.0103240823,
-0.044429183,
-0.0343706198,
-0.0434608422,
0.0332131982,
-0.0043647527,
-0.0213832743,
0.0313378759,
-0.0164148379,
0.0002078461,
-0.0111788213,
-0.0003924758,
0.0701822862,
-0.0465541072,
0.0312206391,
0.0281017553,
-0.0234506484,
0.0965625122,
-0.0709260255,
0.1355957538,
-0.0577911399,
-0.0180837419,
0.0150954425,
0.0523846745,
0.0596373267,
-0.0039636232,
0.060714066,
0.0149758989,
-0.0167153198,
-0.0018789754,
0.0016682345,
-0.0876086503,
-0.0281469375,
0.0520154685,
0.0384522863,
-0.0845047385,
-0.0530670434,
0.0297476389,
-0.0403502882,
0.0147816204,
0.0148006184,
0.0651388839,
-0.0518125296,
0.0216496941,
0.0513221435,
-0.0677294657,
0.0149491783,
-0.0146834366,
0.0221680552,
0.03220677,
0.0671412349,
-0.0231810957,
-0.0211495645,
-0.0855367705,
0.0215836167,
0.0275204871,
0.0057846922,
0.0423598401,
-0.0578048155,
-0.0061066402,
-0.0194037277,
-0.0032089183,
0.0045086155,
0.0157878157,
-0.0158286709,
-0.0298384055,
-0.0069553857,
0.0069478261,
0.0981490836,
0.0219572634,
0.0143205356,
-0.0451289378,
0.0354480445,
-0.0420379154,
0.0540334173,
0.0077745062,
-0.0544333085,
-0.0526666529,
-0.00279905,
-0.0504164286,
-0.0209355261,
-0.0221669767,
-0.0623789579,
-0.0145327477,
-0.0324491188,
-0.0877796784,
0.0126513429,
0.0100144967,
-0.0270603895,
0.03590215,
0.0225211233,
-0.0010522802,
0.007874269,
0.011429728,
0.0372551456,
0.0033318687,
0.0035989173,
-0.0153667051,
0.0196107309,
0.0496309772,
0.0060446789,
0.0246631764,
0.0195531417,
-0.0015188982,
0.0086727394,
-0.0434300676,
-0.0143812774,
-0.0884244144,
-0.0214347076,
0.0156678036,
0.0520931594,
-0.0250298567,
0.0451968089,
0.0571625866,
0.0203281362,
0.0070562162,
-0.0323887207,
0.0208718311,
0.0315028802,
-0.0541755259,
0.0257290751,
0.0001705723,
-0.0028705047,
0.0225479789,
0.0071681258,
-0.0228214134,
-0.0131538082,
2.677e-7,
0.0623680241,
0.0194478687,
0.0395208113,
0.0551865585,
-0.0188228674,
0.0107012317,
0.0014592237,
-0.0229619555,
-0.0278915502,
-0.0321119837,
0.0270848852,
0.0190943535,
0.0381215997,
0.0454552323,
-0.0395159237,
-0.0281925146,
0.0100279646,
0.0133867618,
-0.0436853878,
-0.0020605586,
0.0471979342,
-0.0027307356,
0.0008165832,
0.0178859085,
-0.0691351295,
-0.0208880045,
0.0372809544,
-0.0247948486,
-0.0106125521,
0.0298519619,
0.0313314535,
0.0173414554,
0.0152655859,
0.0184421502,
-0.0352036543,
-0.0152238728,
0.0364870429,
0.0387994945,
-0.0150328046,
0.0058503784,
-0.0401987284,
-0.0538647324,
0.0398097709,
-0.0771086514,
0.0456816778,
-0.0058862884,
-0.030704204,
0.0560440198,
-0.034252841,
0.0111080483,
-0.023294922,
-0.0355142616,
-0.0456615388,
0.025899481,
0.0103853345,
0.0092216441,
-0.0392518006,
-0.0224843808,
-0.0458370782,
0.0074292226,
0.0223159511,
-0.0083224326,
0.0335996822,
-0.0134547306,
-0.0199689418,
-0.0543852486,
0.0167402644,
1.998491925e-34,
0.0027918916,
0.0093456106,
0.0021353581,
0.0248927865,
0.0443392731,
-0.0031105359,
-0.0203659143,
-0.0074522523,
0.0388303846,
0.0166241266,
-0.0479092933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01306v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01306v1 | On Significance of Subword tokenization for Low Resource and Efficient Named Entity Recognition: A case study in Marathi | 2023-12-03T06:53:53 | 2023-12-03T06:53:53 | Harsh Chaudhari, Anuja Patil, Dhanashree Lavekar, Pranav Khairnar, Raviraj Joshi, Sachin Pande | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Named Entity Recognition (NER) systems play a vital role in NLP applications
such as machine translation, summarization, and question-answering. These
systems identify named entities, which encompass real-world concepts like
locations, persons, and organizations. Despite extensive research on NER
systems for the English language, they have not received adequate attention in
the context of low resource languages. In this work, we focus on NER for
low-resource language and present our case study in the context of the Indian
language Marathi. The advancement of NLP research revolves around the
utilization of pre-trained transformer models such as BERT for the development
of NER models. However, we focus on improving the performance of shallow models
based on CNN, and LSTM by combining the best of both worlds. In the era of
transformers, these traditional deep learning models are still relevant because
of their high computational efficiency. We propose a hybrid approach for
efficient NER by integrating a BERT-based subword tokenizer into vanilla
CNN/LSTM models. We show that this simple approach of replacing a traditional
word-based tokenizer with a BERT-tokenizer brings the accuracy of vanilla
single-layer models closer to that of deep pre-trained models like BERT. We
show the importance of using sub-word tokenization for NER and present our
study toward building efficient NLP systems. The evaluation is performed on
L3Cube-MahaNER dataset using tokenizers from MahaBERT, MahaGPT, IndicBERT, and
mBERT. | [
0.0559132509,
0.0240093786,
0.0358080715,
0.056629274,
0.0011969418,
0.0126219392,
-0.0032807312,
0.0393216088,
-0.0429774448,
-0.0457594953,
-0.0508740544,
-0.0384393446,
0.0034921556,
-0.0028748666,
0.0283496119,
-0.0641035661,
0.0240098219,
-0.0105447555,
0.0013467144,
0.0182392672,
0.0123016993,
0.0051250542,
0.0021132876,
0.0443491228,
-0.0203260556,
0.017173931,
0.005190074,
0.0157900415,
0.0266123675,
-0.030441137,
0.006631176,
0.0081962282,
-0.0229992494,
0.0465732068,
0.0000017835,
-0.0469854362,
-0.067059122,
-0.0144820027,
-0.0018849629,
-0.0117555568,
0.0341546908,
-0.0203524996,
-0.0093468213,
0.0266312584,
-0.0071083643,
-0.0127430577,
0.0400070697,
0.0718668476,
0.0313151665,
0.0814311132,
0.003617208,
-0.0342930332,
0.0603666902,
0.008204503,
-0.0489854999,
-0.0085692331,
-0.0044511133,
-0.0667273849,
-0.0200340375,
-0.0116068637,
-0.006618286,
0.0153063936,
-0.0053832005,
-0.0030994802,
0.0404719561,
0.0338060074,
-0.076682277,
0.0034478635,
0.0248256084,
0.0677478313,
-0.0712695196,
0.0004826626,
0.0272556413,
0.0000610555,
-0.0500098094,
-0.0383014753,
-0.0212604944,
0.0153328618,
-0.0304284636,
0.0463862941,
0.0213286169,
0.0193956681,
0.0163096841,
0.0122263106,
-0.001298383,
0.010218407,
0.0308083277,
-0.0228551943,
-0.0324177332,
-0.0197109934,
-0.0318063572,
-0.0726388022,
0.0336278826,
0.0418089107,
-0.0008478362,
0.0142054288,
-0.0156491101,
-0.0438281335,
0.0003164962,
-0.0239736382,
-0.0163983367,
0.0225932915,
-0.0253560767,
0.00573488,
-0.068512179,
0.0477981903,
-0.0357211158,
0.0369474702,
0.0128824143,
-0.0645797327,
-0.0061695329,
-0.0422718115,
-0.0380523875,
0.0540952608,
-0.0537531823,
0.0290430114,
-0.0262664706,
0.0135941077,
0.0078750746,
-0.0131885381,
0.0221138857,
0.0235392097,
-0.0094674649,
-0.0326647051,
-0.0184191596,
0.0350638293,
-0.0368917808,
-0.0055647553,
-0.0042248801,
-0.0836322159,
0.0025540709,
-0.007586637,
0.0370750353,
-0.0435400195,
0.0089625483,
0.069098793,
-0.0012220858,
-0.1055914462,
-0.0728524923,
0.0207062811,
-0.0030843234,
-0.0437877774,
-0.0128132487,
-0.0707698092,
0.018845994,
0.0072994791,
0.0130208526,
-0.019771846,
0.0214322414,
0.0254267417,
-0.0307558253,
0.0878012106,
-0.0108801518,
-0.0348016694,
0.0446823947,
0.0141330445,
0.0767898634,
-0.0058976724,
0.0699275061,
0.0316138528,
0.0396666341,
0.0019203369,
0.0003759823,
0.0281894132,
0.0095147258,
-0.0329299569,
0.0006005651,
0.0138826603,
-0.0727288052,
0.0217883512,
0.0266952477,
0.0721364617,
0.0165175889,
0.0290636569,
0.0205192249,
0.0754671842,
-0.0020076851,
0.0538794585,
0.0106123611,
0.0194899794,
0.0180276483,
-0.0200660173,
-0.0062091188,
0.0211127885,
0.0019440663,
0.0034353391,
0.0458071567,
0.0332645513,
-0.0319605842,
-0.0012937039,
-0.011898363,
-0.0412867777,
-0.036171373,
-0.0402389616,
0.047336895,
0.0184844621,
-0.0821453929,
0.0750084445,
0.0167522114,
-0.0477470458,
0.0430095159,
-0.0541909561,
0.0186297242,
0.0447376296,
0.0363998152,
-0.0340547599,
-0.0159844253,
-0.0252366289,
-0.0077905343,
0.0548508875,
0.010978871,
-0.0033847655,
0.0004028179,
-0.0369834788,
0.0242657755,
0.0253484957,
-0.0235175695,
0.0293386392,
0.0144995032,
0.0325614214,
0.0212892015,
-0.0564179011,
-0.0106683858,
0.0423255004,
0.0028319568,
-0.0335537605,
0.0224778708,
0.0504411571,
0.0374776423,
0.038812466,
0.0007581547,
-0.0299061239,
0.0174954738,
-0.0262327734,
-0.0370278619,
0.0141022429,
0.022078339,
-0.0554122403,
-0.0206987988,
-0.0363879614,
0.0158288199,
0.0430314913,
-0.0244707875,
-0.0762900561,
-0.025948653,
-0.0207089726,
0.0701871812,
-0.0423408747,
0.0478662737,
0.0347221605,
0.0216127615,
-0.0475025252,
0.0527538918,
-0.0186199527,
0.0126754725,
0.0226191003,
0.015246232,
0.0432450473,
-0.0457464866,
-0.0609086044,
0.0037488542,
-0.0086380113,
-0.0111238509,
0.0452088974,
0.0135904225,
-0.0340679958,
-0.021119494,
-0.1191607714,
0.0035682435,
-0.0192072373,
0.0443905778,
-0.0218883939,
0.0827883855,
0.0001039244,
-0.0092287185,
-0.0023069456,
-0.0240159184,
0.0154251996,
-0.0033250106,
0.0668525174,
-0.0039016374,
-0.0179063845,
-0.0360089205,
-0.0045354986,
-0.020969227,
0.0620267838,
-0.007009055,
-0.0467592254,
-0.022616474,
-0.0182858501,
-0.0058670808,
0.0241219606,
0.0250848103,
-0.0444372818,
-0.036713507,
0.0258413889,
0.0500539951,
0.0133542363,
0.0057870019,
0.0181763228,
-0.0656902567,
0.0088206092,
-0.0515718795,
0.0183183309,
0.0086944951,
0.0306250695,
0.01045046,
-0.0266202837,
0.0250379555,
0.0654246956,
-0.0196583457,
0.0279761013,
-0.0303797796,
-0.0224180631,
-0.0141282836,
0.0106103327,
0.0266338736,
0.0295637362,
-0.0495867804,
-0.0091946162,
-0.0293227267,
-0.0317752697,
0.0500270389,
-0.0591701344,
-0.0160829555,
-0.0407218002,
0.0299545173,
-0.0564333759,
0.0318531282,
0.0020374132,
0.0098386519,
-0.02080019,
-0.0880029872,
0.006872802,
0.029816933,
-0.0543711334,
-0.0199059751,
0.0541268587,
-0.0112604238,
0.0254497081,
-0.0455325656,
-0.0275667384,
-0.0439800955,
-0.0416542031,
-0.0474499539,
0.0328238867,
0.0381972343,
-0.0315789878,
-0.0089711109,
0.0792918801,
-0.0006297709,
0.0192172248,
0.005521046,
0.001013631,
-0.0185886081,
0.0789683014,
0.0380383953,
0.010155051,
0.0266988482,
0.0273267459,
0.0091712046,
-0.0192390885,
0.0435262956,
-0.0179593656,
-0.0150286844,
-0.0229119807,
0.0005035515,
-0.0732387975,
-0.0003302777,
-0.0356641337,
0.0355146565,
0.0057890946,
-0.0252213962,
0.1194376647,
0.0230639856,
-0.0047622547,
-0.0215550084,
-0.0041110762,
-0.0022800444,
-0.0095842266,
0.0076503218,
-0.0572930947,
-0.0516728237,
0.0037243292,
-0.0125977565,
0.0286038257,
-0.0513506457,
0.0128716519,
-0.1056600884,
-0.034627147,
-0.0554429926,
-0.0380058661,
0.0150751173,
-0.0280654039,
-0.0161431488,
-0.0074826968,
0.0312286504,
-0.0190813076,
-0.0557703301,
-0.022429755,
0.0437832847,
-0.0357722454,
-0.0055240034,
0.0164429415,
-0.0621611811,
-0.0006100725,
0.0469591394,
0.0394998789,
-0.0615966655,
-0.0185681414,
0.0143774068,
-0.0320087261,
-0.0176714025,
-0.0000013429,
0.0250600446,
-0.0575943105,
-0.0185275748,
0.0065887161,
0.0024127576,
-0.008166506,
-0.0223771147,
-0.0380291939,
0.0279036332,
0.0068758437,
0.0138778416,
0.0050930595,
-0.0400203168,
-0.009392146,
0.0635768101,
0.016041087,
-0.0293173194,
-0.0370776616,
0.0230704136,
0.0018344255,
-0.0439323634,
0.0164145119,
-0.004703939,
-0.0327158943,
-0.0335207954,
-0.0291035697,
-0.0429903828,
0.0646132007,
0.0304591376,
0.0059520463,
0.0123401564,
0.0191673599,
0.0323202275,
-0.0641705915,
0.0439725183,
-0.027575193,
0.0323020555,
-0.0949823186,
-0.0045676501,
0.0533364899,
0.0024370027,
-0.036964301,
-0.0451416783,
-0.0535336249,
-0.0203523077,
-0.0031741264,
0.0315637589,
0.018025741,
0.0155545538,
-0.0196640659,
-0.0585546382,
0.061058253,
0.0299591664,
-0.0272904057,
-0.0169351231,
0.009327095,
0.0288338009,
-0.0203099623,
0.0273664948,
-0.0436798856,
-0.0068977512,
0.0071783238,
0.0198876858,
0.0078259883,
0.0024839938,
-0.0103628756,
0.0176538862,
0.0602309443,
-0.0546759404,
0.0025946265,
-0.0377760567,
0.0255787726,
0.0332676843,
0.0242240839,
-0.0187392421,
-0.0418590717,
0.0213781893,
0.0162643716,
-0.0286471248,
0.0497210734,
-0.026278995,
0.0013102301,
0.0065711909,
0.0565734729,
0.0141604375,
0.0508378558,
-0.0031315368,
-0.0265271869,
0.0075811166,
-0.0064141592,
0.0245638993,
0.0020618998,
-0.0264019035,
-0.0203682221,
0.0014263234,
0.0140615618,
-0.0084792133,
0.0361181982,
0.0054524504,
0.0173359457,
-0.0472730808,
0.0568124354,
0.049428802,
-0.0265107453,
0.01817891,
0.0098079443,
0.010117921,
-0.0031059943,
-0.006852001,
-0.0262702294,
-0.0047052512,
0.061034739,
0.0129814912,
-0.0178219546,
0.0019777357,
0.0485955551,
0.0426648371,
-0.0007939185,
0.0121686207,
-0.0176707432,
-0.0452204049,
0.022689933,
0.0349345505,
0.0158368722,
-0.0005626182,
0.0115074767,
-0.0351153053,
-0.0359121524,
0.049686186,
-0.0407947525,
0.0140476152,
-0.0105657512,
0.0440532677,
0.0070789992,
0.0329890996,
-0.0299476329,
-0.0225256123,
0.0147401094,
0.0365387723,
-0.0465982705,
-0.0037065379,
-5.866870999e-33,
-0.0230619106,
-0.0227243863,
0.0001604404,
-0.004355588,
-0.0161007717,
0.0444599502,
-0.0395444557,
-0.0233200211,
-0.0147902025,
-0.0201583933,
-0.029875664,
0.0130071612,
0.033919286,
0.0354190506,
0.0009431387,
-0.0382031165,
0.0707614347,
0.0340677015,
-0.0108599467,
-0.0000070447,
0.0391543843,
0.0689767376,
0.0962384492,
0.0118051469,
0.0042656059,
-0.0398027971,
0.00303909,
0.0091990177,
0.056342721,
0.0517764874,
-0.0588269159,
0.0023773576,
0.0222224556,
-0.043245472,
0.0247139018,
0.0508293323,
-0.1520484686,
-0.0005720919,
0.0235546958,
0.0665321723,
-0.0366224311,
-0.0376356691,
0.062315248,
0.0135048125,
0.0049287206,
0.0569107644,
0.0269936286,
0.0133661982,
-0.0141703365,
-0.03047131,
-0.0804286525,
0.041395478,
-0.0001076165,
0.0189164504,
0.0328562744,
-0.0199718997,
0.0133372732,
-0.0008982613,
-0.0742011964,
-0.0474973395,
0.0418959744,
0.0130512705,
0.0629304871,
0.0575267673,
-0.0658132508,
0.0282889027,
0.0350722186,
-0.0326880999,
-0.0098368581,
0.0110464264,
0.0249439795,
0.0256012212,
-0.0133324834,
0.0063720257,
0.0291701742,
-0.0397885516,
-0.0667232499,
0.0338042453,
-0.0131113334,
0.0539393984,
-0.0006894318,
-0.0138172871,
-0.0623074993,
-0.0013180218,
0.0366739482,
-0.0108128255,
-0.0442930162,
-0.0045406115,
0.0461845584,
0.0152346604,
-0.036023546,
0.0542787015,
0.0408027992,
-0.0263893735,
-0.0128999399,
0.0045353072,
0.0519359633,
0.0172586441,
-0.0219988469,
0.0191991832,
-0.0519147106,
-0.0617308356,
-0.0230601616,
0.0072659841,
-0.0061061466,
-0.0205548238,
0.058780361,
-0.0099302335,
-0.0805967748,
0.009750505,
0.0002329486,
0.0402039029,
-0.0407051332,
0.0828540921,
-0.0024346802,
-0.0140872682,
-0.0063832859,
-0.0009566548,
0.0325238742,
-0.0124975638,
-0.0207119305,
0.0204424392,
0.0439256392,
0.0141494796,
0.0017422184,
0.0053575658,
-0.0248379316,
0.0352195278,
-0.0217509679,
-0.0716041625,
0.0004062538,
0.0113178948,
2.538e-7,
0.0039189975,
0.0302842949,
0.0832359642,
-0.0669397786,
-0.035305921,
0.0004898281,
0.0348318368,
0.0403418653,
-0.0516696163,
0.0404081568,
-0.003498385,
-0.022870684,
0.0163749512,
0.0045412877,
-0.1236276776,
-0.004250973,
-0.0775147453,
0.0076459912,
-0.0646933392,
0.0021315143,
-0.0035157353,
0.1012044698,
0.0151322335,
-0.034366712,
-0.0302612297,
-0.0265372377,
0.0411668308,
0.0263102073,
0.0138360048,
0.0478255711,
0.0405622497,
0.054900758,
-0.0117960097,
-0.0124141248,
-0.0191556327,
0.0370623358,
0.0541864447,
0.0465337187,
-0.0277460702,
-0.0063968305,
0.0239013974,
-0.0491327792,
0.0201113969,
-0.0296261571,
0.07040748,
-0.001514029,
-0.0020111005,
0.0452252105,
-0.0181893855,
-0.008200421,
0.0028622989,
-0.007672478,
-0.0414371639,
0.0233390108,
0.0440143012,
-0.0590957291,
-0.019576814,
-0.075095132,
0.0040709157,
0.0045196488,
-0.0139290961,
-0.0133326473,
-0.0290119238,
-0.0046305894,
0.0471106805,
-0.0380955823,
-0.0172559917,
2.244101138e-34,
0.0383062176,
0.0181363877,
-0.0394719727,
0.038198296,
0.0205224138,
-0.0165148731,
0.0082591921,
-0.0172451884,
0.0005185998,
-0.0576606207,
-0.0195650905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01279v1 | TextGenSHAP: Scalable Post-hoc Explanations in Text Generation with Long Documents | 2023-12-03T04:35:04 | 2023-12-03T04:35:04 | James Enouen, Hootan Nakhost, Sayna Ebrahimi, Sercan O Arik, Yan Liu, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have attracted huge interest in practical
applications given their increasingly accurate responses and coherent reasoning
abilities. Given their nature as black-boxes using complex reasoning processes
on their inputs, it is inevitable that the demand for scalable and faithful
explanations for LLMs' generated content will continue to grow. There have been
major developments in the explainability of neural network models over the past
decade. Among them, post-hoc explainability methods, especially Shapley values,
have proven effective for interpreting deep learning models. However, there are
major challenges in scaling up Shapley values for LLMs, particularly when
dealing with long input contexts containing thousands of tokens and
autoregressively generated output sequences. Furthermore, it is often unclear
how to effectively utilize generated explanations to improve the performance of
LLMs. In this paper, we introduce TextGenSHAP, an efficient post-hoc
explanation method incorporating LM-specific techniques. We demonstrate that
this leads to significant increases in speed compared to conventional Shapley
value computations, reducing processing times from hours to minutes for
token-level explanations, and to just seconds for document-level explanations.
In addition, we demonstrate how real-time Shapley values can be utilized in two
important scenarios, providing better understanding of long-document question
answering by localizing important words and sentences; and improving existing
document retrieval systems through enhancing the accuracy of selected passages
and ultimately the final responses. | [
0.0038908583,
0.053388156,
0.010986154,
0.0232245065,
-0.029180225,
0.0164986458,
0.0481591076,
-0.0212676525,
-0.0597453564,
-0.0109483292,
0.0494276509,
-0.0478034317,
-0.0000813296,
0.0747849047,
0.0269721895,
-0.0348957591,
0.0271925516,
-0.0164063983,
0.0008572891,
0.010568684,
0.0040969127,
0.0285197366,
-0.0071538528,
0.0821848214,
0.0075592049,
-0.0352277718,
-0.0532573611,
0.0010211805,
-0.0028101457,
0.0349166989,
-0.0334231779,
0.0502873734,
0.0295031983,
0.0337270685,
0.0000020137,
-0.0088437358,
-0.0254286062,
0.0236604232,
-0.0594419874,
0.0368112624,
0.0031704253,
-0.0031224028,
0.0128434747,
0.0160257872,
0.0007452233,
0.0295107383,
0.0342024043,
0.0334456451,
0.0554534793,
0.0659446791,
0.0135152079,
-0.0212585703,
0.0157096479,
-0.0179109331,
0.0638322979,
-0.0276700072,
-0.024939606,
-0.0276782177,
-0.0069651171,
0.0127591426,
0.0244719423,
0.0119251693,
0.0788143352,
-0.0696285143,
0.0344489142,
0.0156709962,
-0.0023652159,
-0.0114491759,
-0.0023467534,
0.0541806966,
-0.0448473915,
-0.0276919771,
0.0137164677,
-0.0148702431,
-0.0064751222,
-0.0131948618,
-0.0715575218,
0.0217185244,
0.0398408063,
-0.0028705231,
0.0280602686,
-0.0030728232,
0.0710200742,
0.0363188908,
-0.0180532113,
0.0397377163,
0.0005656618,
0.0113398414,
-0.0496673845,
-0.0137114991,
-0.0425906144,
-0.0679304525,
0.0407566763,
0.0969597697,
-0.0401718616,
0.002070602,
-0.0139986034,
0.0097783022,
0.0211332571,
-0.0318800434,
0.0379770435,
0.0272027366,
-0.0169669911,
0.0257436857,
-0.0377738997,
0.0662602708,
-0.0342253484,
-0.0334142707,
-0.0330208763,
-0.0111796223,
-0.0410316922,
-0.0413741991,
-0.0168069191,
0.0136510497,
-0.0356003046,
-0.0413759798,
-0.0287895501,
0.0276693292,
0.0079853544,
0.0104700616,
0.0061762379,
0.0433271863,
-0.0251925495,
-0.0297988113,
-0.0193413738,
0.0392581411,
-0.0779773816,
-0.026366299,
0.0431618392,
-0.0506342389,
-0.0222310927,
0.0328220911,
0.0210702103,
0.0052780556,
0.0194380451,
0.0435930081,
-0.0097400388,
-0.0084796976,
-0.0227108262,
-0.0639811158,
-0.0282640532,
-0.0537622645,
-0.0007107026,
-0.0435299687,
0.0009984617,
0.016715873,
-0.0403580554,
-0.0069798096,
-0.0041929865,
0.0379435159,
-0.0019478772,
0.0420522541,
0.0079139508,
0.0075248918,
-0.0174563639,
0.010605867,
-0.0038724118,
0.0239227619,
0.0204654709,
0.0356065817,
0.0152005712,
-0.0535581075,
0.0150819421,
-0.0261864495,
0.055118788,
-0.0217719674,
-0.0254682638,
-0.0086384667,
-0.0654935911,
0.0304700229,
0.0259866081,
0.0211370401,
-0.0142576154,
-0.0052935546,
0.0248624161,
0.0528105833,
0.0189975221,
0.0367678255,
0.07332737,
0.0083159013,
-0.021572357,
0.0324299447,
-0.0328548551,
0.0514123999,
-0.0059511675,
0.0312941931,
0.0371847004,
0.0181488693,
-0.0110524418,
-0.0692563727,
-0.0123466384,
0.0091726817,
-0.018934926,
0.0211625919,
0.0348774232,
0.0035534895,
-0.0206927396,
0.0585014671,
0.0121766832,
-0.061904911,
0.0280887056,
-0.0525024384,
0.0629198998,
0.1054195315,
0.0448143408,
-0.0149573144,
-0.0113996267,
-0.0143370591,
0.0020055883,
0.0634256005,
0.0005164573,
0.0106110889,
0.017506646,
-0.0581347048,
-0.0017029535,
-0.052773919,
0.0087945079,
0.0084723504,
0.0199087616,
-0.0394433886,
0.0478933156,
-0.0365302339,
-0.0525381379,
0.0247974023,
-0.0618002228,
-0.0436830334,
0.0062677655,
-0.002692194,
0.0091956845,
0.0450746194,
-0.0048096986,
0.0273589119,
0.0268456936,
-0.0304574408,
-0.0170740467,
-0.0004096065,
-0.0611425452,
-0.005359469,
-0.0076428084,
-0.0148526039,
-0.0041477056,
0.0209118929,
-0.0272455476,
-0.0637508556,
-0.0111925593,
-0.0531189255,
0.0050038341,
-0.0275086518,
-0.0004048442,
0.0318223462,
0.0337644666,
-0.0280432589,
0.0425931439,
-0.0307212397,
0.018261712,
0.0104378425,
0.0271660406,
0.0238814354,
-0.0121493218,
0.0241285227,
0.0191501584,
-0.036389526,
-0.0229449235,
0.0241891164,
0.0080275843,
-0.007708923,
-0.011255987,
-0.0261382945,
0.0151823265,
-0.0462675728,
0.0075576673,
0.0414707325,
-0.0035596725,
0.0239587277,
-0.0153515413,
-0.0768817663,
0.0333401076,
0.0375448689,
-0.0039881808,
0.0437701792,
0.0095842574,
-0.0149043845,
-0.017328104,
-0.0312716886,
-0.0050763972,
0.0830103233,
0.0097110439,
0.0439026393,
-0.038935028,
0.0153842233,
-0.0024215253,
-0.0288916267,
-0.0221400969,
-0.0434259549,
0.0380102992,
-0.0297462232,
0.0248589963,
0.0330723897,
0.03058796,
0.0795881301,
0.0210892521,
0.0343924575,
-0.0337973423,
-0.0042104162,
-0.0446058996,
0.0413448066,
-0.0088857375,
-0.060409762,
0.0030428041,
0.0710356534,
-0.0337025076,
-0.0140476711,
-0.0459086448,
0.0298677552,
0.0327968448,
-0.0382039249,
-0.0297162961,
-0.0197152626,
0.0249896441,
0.023953665,
-0.0181016456,
-0.072976321,
0.0548867323,
-0.0642395243,
-0.0034561162,
0.0033491452,
-0.0281991716,
-0.0436260477,
0.0974585488,
-0.0020194361,
0.0025310002,
-0.0460948944,
-0.0318402909,
0.0026653213,
0.0022182225,
-0.0039059224,
-0.0159672797,
-0.0078360653,
-0.0189217515,
0.0043935864,
0.0044515491,
-0.0068757571,
-0.0337287113,
-0.0423044562,
-0.00637493,
0.0243488532,
0.0300453175,
-0.0574170947,
-0.0166889671,
0.0290451292,
0.0324808694,
0.0245119389,
-0.0349144489,
0.0115734013,
-0.0394981802,
0.0106898034,
0.0583496727,
0.0308397207,
0.057929337,
-0.0425833762,
0.0243071709,
0.0591854528,
0.040763475,
0.0258345474,
-0.0599843822,
-0.0014643628,
-0.0033110364,
-0.0502235442,
-0.0053513641,
0.0123594441,
0.027741801,
-0.1012068242,
-0.0148290154,
0.1153406799,
0.0394761488,
-0.0407458618,
0.0186282266,
-0.0370436385,
0.0505509898,
-0.0084261596,
0.0219336748,
-0.0524059013,
-0.0283162072,
0.008095894,
0.0113120107,
0.0034611968,
-0.0042459196,
-0.0017756103,
-0.0591582395,
0.0232928433,
0.0125506194,
-0.0273700543,
-0.012356095,
-0.0319414064,
-0.0555749908,
0.011751526,
0.0198911782,
0.0210587345,
0.0118771959,
0.0302546136,
0.0346081257,
-0.0009303707,
-0.0284181088,
0.0102323378,
-0.0174874049,
0.010287174,
0.0829793438,
0.0384528562,
0.0156425126,
-0.0261215102,
0.0057467003,
0.0289802384,
0.0325670242,
-0.0185798481,
0.0345944092,
0.0111985207,
-0.0034001151,
-0.0292386785,
0.0561588034,
-0.059836939,
-0.0279618539,
-0.0264221467,
0.0403445549,
-0.0204718132,
-0.010577729,
-0.0354187004,
0.0058187931,
-0.009877272,
0.0846737102,
0.0536997281,
-0.0222978853,
-0.1055937186,
-0.013100557,
-0.0298268348,
-0.0750946999,
-0.0230761915,
0.0045414814,
0.0353134349,
-0.0017853032,
-0.0422183163,
-0.0361371487,
0.0165026002,
0.0426816456,
-0.0432820544,
-0.0052034366,
-0.0130488938,
-0.0262129921,
-0.0394924805,
0.0487411767,
0.0266297162,
0.0163069963,
-0.0320878327,
-0.0043913317,
-0.012527138,
-0.0578681454,
-0.0167455897,
0.0079027871,
-0.0486036241,
-0.0224728044,
0.0185307022,
-0.0048227259,
0.0290361941,
0.0385508537,
-0.0136768948,
-0.1076124907,
0.0582022816,
0.0078977905,
-0.0124166971,
-0.0110201221,
0.005433185,
0.00095274,
0.0156134805,
0.0557410307,
-0.0211795308,
0.0013915189,
-0.0239082966,
0.0544938408,
0.0036399481,
0.013484953,
0.0043473081,
0.0106858155,
-0.0041147131,
0.000479485,
-0.014220722,
-0.0027979142,
0.0088040726,
-0.0289531052,
-0.0124503225,
-0.0644383803,
0.0370113999,
0.0118448809,
-0.0288564228,
0.0087320153,
-0.0257282723,
0.0036316374,
-0.0039254804,
-0.0249548908,
-0.0047155707,
-0.006897422,
0.0094032502,
0.0138032325,
-0.0027994178,
-0.0269223936,
0.0186592452,
-0.0402670763,
0.0366796181,
-0.0085568205,
0.0601780564,
0.0150464205,
0.0142826205,
-0.0266223736,
0.0280836262,
-0.1146200225,
-0.0451084152,
-0.0035435301,
-0.0036870306,
0.0292123072,
-0.0032232075,
0.0462398641,
-0.0328024998,
0.001264182,
-0.0016339993,
0.0787203088,
0.0503446646,
-0.0355658941,
-0.0116540184,
0.0268678553,
-0.0422228947,
-0.0200055167,
0.0804518834,
0.0511438176,
0.0034558759,
0.0218877085,
-0.0259144157,
-0.0117506413,
-0.0353546813,
-0.0236450583,
0.0469126962,
-0.013302126,
0.0202647783,
-0.0137778297,
-0.0596514344,
-0.0244237483,
0.0247073844,
0.0113405958,
-0.0344796143,
0.0033587704,
0.0966334566,
-0.003818399,
-0.0348944217,
-0.0454292707,
0.0680726692,
-0.0517877229,
0.000596181,
-0.0019448211,
-6.527368051e-33,
-0.0105526419,
-0.1099660918,
0.0322112814,
-0.0410604142,
-0.0152441263,
0.0159918107,
-0.0484257415,
-0.0187112801,
0.0067353686,
0.0353123471,
-0.0002623434,
0.0463767648,
0.0035241812,
0.0504920632,
-0.0339404605,
-0.0381770432,
0.0396176241,
0.032575544,
-0.0277210232,
0.064448826,
0.0817019045,
0.0227319095,
0.0076045967,
0.0029608456,
0.0194357671,
-0.0111152204,
-0.0063481745,
0.019617172,
-0.0576265007,
0.0468114354,
-0.0305605493,
0.0031904047,
0.020652676,
-0.030677028,
-0.0195876192,
0.0273072086,
-0.0633950084,
0.0204971079,
0.0047599105,
0.0116569381,
-0.0681341365,
-0.0550499633,
0.0575158149,
0.0064889006,
0.0286538526,
-0.0255529676,
-0.0026999181,
0.0004926173,
-0.044139158,
-0.0143441511,
-0.0326773934,
0.0252277907,
-0.0317563675,
-0.0125938775,
-0.0025360961,
0.0242227353,
-0.0054135816,
0.0210321695,
-0.0205795653,
-0.0303189047,
0.0299655106,
0.0356480666,
0.0713075101,
0.0048451605,
-0.0195198543,
0.0401301906,
0.0379912928,
-0.0195749644,
-0.0655932501,
0.0014618683,
-0.0028759663,
0.0650322288,
0.1024056897,
0.0201753471,
0.0716782063,
0.0246218834,
-0.0764951706,
0.0239484385,
0.0218066573,
0.026465131,
0.081881471,
-0.0334285647,
-0.0382138938,
-0.0051542595,
-0.0495498292,
-0.0180146862,
-0.035892725,
-0.0310828015,
0.016501002,
0.0035062488,
-0.0539829396,
-0.0012101847,
0.0239679143,
-0.0272451527,
0.0443143696,
0.0367535464,
-0.0285659153,
0.0123917209,
0.0059502604,
0.0214845855,
-0.0012807825,
0.0025120715,
-0.0097463578,
-0.016684413,
0.0133247869,
0.0136310402,
0.021657113,
0.0159525275,
-0.0002182797,
-0.0040106643,
-0.0767562166,
0.0074816304,
-0.0255430136,
0.0044896463,
0.0398362651,
-0.0124986507,
-0.0345559791,
0.0542873293,
-0.0179010257,
0.0432300679,
0.0170983877,
-0.0420317538,
-0.0172425229,
0.0111988978,
-0.0428360812,
-0.0096792616,
-0.0527878925,
-0.0256789681,
0.042582009,
-0.0676889122,
-0.0063881753,
0.0287179537,
2.637e-7,
0.0330062658,
0.040133439,
0.0551004857,
0.0299135111,
0.026364848,
0.0088722622,
0.0305915754,
-0.025615897,
-0.0333467796,
0.000385852,
-0.0013525791,
0.0329326503,
0.0931031778,
0.0142024206,
-0.0202626903,
-0.054050263,
-0.101406984,
-0.0332920626,
-0.0518110693,
-0.0059605194,
0.0168368202,
0.0446019582,
-0.0216027126,
-0.0203018803,
0.0785708204,
-0.0214766935,
0.0365934819,
0.0013226735,
0.0071885916,
0.0013776764,
0.0601610094,
-0.0328635424,
0.0164470393,
-0.0351067521,
-0.0152510805,
0.0265008174,
-0.0308714788,
0.0716555417,
0.0127891367,
-0.028254021,
-0.0250586756,
-0.0775987729,
0.0515482016,
-0.08088696,
0.0748945698,
-0.0078642657,
-0.0357219316,
-0.0258165244,
-0.0226337854,
-0.0514304116,
-0.0008885372,
-0.001489202,
0.0281991716,
0.0347908027,
-0.0079364413,
-0.0573369712,
0.0222447142,
-0.0828902647,
-0.0492466986,
-0.0254234038,
-0.0426112413,
0.0380388722,
-0.0684537515,
-0.0190149713,
0.0491955727,
-0.0416217856,
-0.0457965806,
2.787025704e-34,
0.0256138109,
-0.0065298616,
0.0218694899,
0.0167341847,
0.0512378812,
0.0273967814,
-0.0135107264,
-0.0022563287,
0.054560151,
-0.0752275437,
-0.0486758202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01276v1 | Running cognitive evaluations on large language models: The do's and the don'ts | 2023-12-03T04:28:19 | 2023-12-03T04:28:19 | Anna A. Ivanova | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, I describe methodological considerations for studies that aim
to evaluate the cognitive capacities of large language models (LLMs) using
language-based behavioral assessments. Drawing on three case studies from the
literature (a commonsense knowledge benchmark, a theory of mind evaluation, and
a test of syntactic agreement), I describe common pitfalls that might arise
when applying a cognitive test to an LLM. I then list 10 do's and don'ts that
should help design high-quality cognitive evaluations for AI systems. I
conclude by discussing four areas where the do's and don'ts are currently under
active discussion -- prompt sensitivity, cultural and linguistic diversity,
using LLMs as research assistants, and running evaluations on open vs. closed
LLMs. Overall, the goal of the paper is to contribute to the broader discussion
of best practices in the rapidly growing field of AI Psychology. | [
0.0553294793,
0.0473933555,
-0.0506178923,
0.0294285472,
-0.0698722824,
0.0294184629,
0.0272805542,
-0.015298117,
0.0665815845,
-0.0459009446,
-0.0408353098,
-0.0616585463,
0.0243102964,
0.0070776297,
0.0217779223,
-0.0129247317,
0.0281642806,
-0.0159880742,
0.0522020534,
0.0053461874,
-0.0074820183,
0.0290130693,
-0.0079394188,
0.0366915613,
0.0113167884,
-0.0215561744,
0.0160158612,
-0.0349599347,
0.0171150584,
-0.0449343584,
-0.029926097,
0.023802381,
0.0158757232,
0.0231256336,
0.0000021658,
-0.0954850316,
0.0275229085,
-0.0048829583,
-0.0140984496,
0.0253095515,
0.0521873683,
0.0396510698,
-0.0173719972,
0.006396166,
-0.0357087702,
0.0316918008,
0.0224251878,
0.0084161693,
0.0253377482,
0.0312759504,
0.0006121269,
0.0126064448,
0.0107452655,
0.0194818154,
-0.0170564353,
-0.0379289761,
0.038899444,
0.0151236812,
0.0347876884,
-0.0524175949,
0.0213879701,
0.0299801975,
0.0182462689,
-0.0254076831,
-0.0333450921,
-0.0020183756,
-0.0602499582,
-0.0329586603,
-0.0138919624,
0.0452942923,
0.0659807324,
0.0358807743,
-0.0155165298,
0.0131546352,
0.0142852291,
0.0124172382,
-0.0375825241,
0.0544638038,
0.0169788301,
-0.0182933845,
0.0358800367,
0.0033079383,
-0.0007040206,
0.025222972,
-0.0093401829,
0.0729672909,
-0.0204830728,
-0.0310559701,
0.0348643176,
0.0011390593,
-0.0133175133,
-0.0509856641,
-0.0207367893,
0.0450538024,
-0.0454476923,
0.0207827445,
0.0167449154,
-0.0267853197,
0.0390166603,
-0.0640301332,
0.0968099236,
0.0333530903,
0.0044410028,
0.0244676676,
0.009424841,
0.1023634598,
0.0269989204,
0.0389177352,
-0.029120652,
0.0146745117,
-0.0768928975,
-0.0222756732,
-0.0054749311,
0.0271334406,
0.0522168018,
-0.0143807009,
-0.0393531621,
-0.0028551379,
-0.0463453643,
0.0421545655,
-0.0455524698,
-0.0208544675,
0.0087456321,
0.0077082072,
-0.0541257039,
0.0166925862,
-0.0446652062,
0.0319614001,
0.0118732806,
-0.0494642369,
0.0031522778,
0.0260572694,
-0.039806325,
-0.0130572263,
0.009759889,
0.0290212762,
-0.0099647753,
-0.0148726506,
-0.0454685353,
-0.0219326634,
-0.0205811001,
-0.0866115019,
0.0100201545,
-0.0592659228,
0.0017863602,
0.0464711376,
0.0005506486,
-0.0199072156,
-0.0019846256,
0.0163696799,
-0.0148644513,
0.042174764,
0.0377516784,
0.022757506,
0.0266194176,
0.0213554762,
-0.0029789063,
0.0733168721,
0.0225059539,
0.0037574999,
0.0129251368,
0.015015929,
-0.0027210782,
0.0223143809,
-0.0417428203,
-0.0002009908,
-0.0327707715,
0.0378902443,
0.0194817781,
0.0214252118,
0.0244946778,
0.0823534653,
0.0083727129,
0.0169614293,
0.0289616138,
0.0981831476,
-0.038727425,
-0.0081316987,
0.0665880293,
0.0051072245,
0.0315198861,
0.0104045523,
-0.0304341391,
0.0023087349,
-0.0358058922,
-0.0193831567,
-0.0291872192,
0.0370727666,
-0.0236895662,
-0.0334140174,
-0.0414803997,
0.005037664,
0.05700057,
0.0246646944,
0.015971994,
-0.0183349624,
0.0195564944,
0.0101055726,
-0.0014542026,
-0.0533698574,
-0.0161351897,
-0.0609933846,
-0.0150817083,
0.0565214753,
0.0263727792,
0.0013017327,
-0.0009030685,
0.0035829216,
-0.0199036989,
0.073593013,
0.0721067339,
-0.0107447207,
-0.0294913631,
-0.0283971187,
-0.0000939016,
-0.0210686866,
-0.0046433872,
-0.0015681441,
-0.0307865813,
0.0292645469,
-0.0100257229,
-0.0114843324,
-0.062201228,
0.0256745517,
-0.0502595156,
-0.0163587555,
-0.0720482394,
0.0125788739,
0.0556477159,
0.0275642574,
-0.0163942017,
0.0185905658,
0.006702546,
-0.0072548278,
0.0081497664,
0.0317198485,
-0.0173588116,
0.0298348069,
0.0351970568,
-0.0017020702,
-0.0352554992,
0.0494306684,
0.0386245772,
-0.0237626731,
0.0458141826,
-0.0556338094,
0.0044999355,
-0.0192319024,
0.04507735,
-0.0711022615,
-0.0181154329,
-0.0083936471,
0.0605039969,
-0.0326654054,
0.0240037777,
0.0230656601,
-0.0329385884,
0.0433697663,
-0.0278214607,
-0.0607564785,
0.0120385205,
0.0111693311,
-0.0051182355,
0.025982419,
0.0086856885,
-0.0627163276,
-0.0161030926,
-0.0972836316,
-0.0282143783,
-0.0148299867,
0.0174707286,
-0.0152543075,
-0.0466360301,
-0.0178404972,
0.0329397842,
-0.0210483093,
0.0068351701,
0.024033295,
0.0478342213,
0.0033673013,
0.0045655691,
-0.0222901832,
0.0074298731,
0.0285104979,
-0.03017959,
0.0429410338,
0.0445363931,
0.0151669839,
-0.0495529845,
0.0425883718,
-0.0522909462,
-0.0034136816,
-0.0182970688,
-0.0629195943,
0.0606899336,
0.0392018333,
0.0388669632,
0.0774210691,
-0.0021126936,
0.0307820216,
0.0683859363,
-0.0220445041,
-0.0328945443,
-0.002499504,
0.0633686781,
0.0070500416,
-0.0277218763,
-0.0788648203,
-0.0075315014,
0.0399822257,
0.0212939661,
0.0301715974,
-0.0221024174,
0.0337848738,
-0.0693832561,
-0.0599499382,
-0.0379000977,
-0.0417753048,
-0.0160935801,
0.0580617115,
-0.0061814282,
-0.0300785564,
0.0878037587,
-0.0243369658,
0.0095708212,
-0.0573645942,
-0.0008741551,
-0.038810011,
0.0741134137,
-0.0185646042,
0.0271435156,
0.0093554026,
-0.0129084801,
-0.0690776929,
-0.0352784842,
-0.0205968171,
-0.0379368067,
0.0307174753,
-0.0639848858,
0.012663139,
-0.0015022769,
-0.0213128384,
-0.0526551679,
0.01351145,
-0.0490146615,
0.0352577344,
0.0473127998,
-0.0169269405,
-0.054263927,
0.0107196439,
0.0989043489,
-0.0176729783,
0.0177329406,
-0.0157031342,
0.0210466217,
-0.0306715965,
0.025621701,
0.0337964557,
0.0528300963,
-0.0199171398,
0.0299176984,
0.0252280161,
0.014568436,
-0.0025597755,
0.0080381595,
0.0143919066,
0.0255197231,
-0.0110107856,
-0.0047252132,
0.0283876229,
0.0737783015,
-0.0279991589,
-0.0132837994,
0.0924164355,
0.0503799319,
-0.0547160432,
0.0003281403,
-0.0387909152,
-0.0205749273,
0.0433372557,
0.0144543294,
-0.0513958745,
0.0082528135,
-0.0014743111,
-0.00500092,
-0.0633344278,
-0.0445035473,
-0.0129598696,
-0.1114388481,
0.0337432735,
-0.0138510242,
-0.0123835076,
-0.032987535,
-0.0088037169,
0.0232402273,
0.0239786152,
0.0376510881,
0.0020993047,
-0.0106803682,
-0.0310128275,
0.0014494311,
-0.0316281803,
-0.0557654053,
0.0861326158,
-0.0283203013,
0.0863030106,
0.0598343089,
0.0270957518,
-0.0179058164,
-0.0891725346,
-0.0324243791,
-0.0190803912,
0.0218284689,
0.0108110346,
-0.0116230687,
0.0255037472,
0.0235103481,
-0.0257025249,
-0.0279962644,
-0.0201691091,
-0.0140427705,
0.0332976021,
0.072194159,
-0.0453023501,
-0.012493331,
-0.0031195991,
0.0279505029,
0.0047761286,
0.0957819894,
0.0327266306,
-0.0412140451,
0.0055026952,
-0.0058172429,
-0.0342289433,
-0.0071542305,
-0.0588737912,
0.0404406264,
0.0201800745,
0.0180446319,
-0.0426058583,
-0.0586512908,
0.0320042744,
-0.0151653485,
0.0086587835,
-0.0103253322,
0.0101522123,
0.0180551093,
-0.0337126516,
0.0482580587,
-0.0146954656,
0.025132129,
-0.0412774421,
-0.0201887693,
-0.0082411021,
-0.0419151001,
0.0101925312,
0.0095487144,
-0.0079031894,
-0.0538532957,
0.0396237262,
0.0182646625,
0.0231396686,
-0.0431459211,
-0.0008984502,
-0.0355875753,
0.0031480873,
-0.0137150148,
-0.0396242775,
0.0374766514,
-0.0087649552,
0.0463707708,
0.0145818256,
0.0419693813,
-0.0238767881,
0.0227435268,
0.0165007524,
0.0183521323,
-0.0227425117,
-0.0482400618,
0.0236239322,
0.0618841276,
-0.0223167036,
-0.0230739918,
0.0191181023,
-0.0123852426,
-0.048065614,
-0.0489665531,
-0.0441882424,
-0.0119117172,
-0.0337606221,
-0.0077045877,
-0.0025286856,
-0.0029686426,
0.0048843198,
-0.0526895784,
-0.0202705618,
-0.0023492551,
0.0372621603,
-0.009698973,
0.0403879136,
-0.0032087457,
0.0066711563,
-0.0303723216,
0.0002764816,
-0.0631584004,
0.0284151621,
0.0383219719,
0.1108852327,
0.0069442326,
-0.0320134163,
-0.003235826,
0.0256390069,
-0.0190547816,
-0.0529588275,
0.0614028201,
0.0381238125,
0.0119651835,
-0.0222229417,
0.0153568834,
-0.0551480688,
0.0332021415,
-0.0158810467,
-0.0179680735,
0.0061546485,
-0.0517629758,
0.0334616937,
0.0263898112,
-0.018743746,
-0.0181681197,
0.0468480065,
-0.056687627,
-0.0055872998,
-0.005723014,
-0.0279725958,
-0.0354585536,
-0.0275295712,
-0.0038156458,
0.021348739,
-0.0225849412,
0.0021763728,
-0.1149551496,
-0.0679633617,
0.0188073572,
0.0135997953,
0.0217885543,
-0.0306329392,
0.0221936461,
0.0711059123,
-0.0011412981,
-0.0221992936,
-0.007282658,
-0.0065130503,
-0.0663970932,
-0.0007748306,
-0.0380455181,
-6.574702269e-33,
-0.0083265062,
-0.0550325103,
0.027373407,
-0.0246331617,
-0.0162860546,
-0.0141686266,
-0.0375940278,
0.0377645493,
-0.0352708176,
-0.0036918824,
-0.0123874629,
0.0041426318,
-0.002774098,
-0.0286874566,
0.0117197083,
0.0048240232,
-0.0073011303,
-0.0127877556,
-0.054975491,
-0.0180936102,
0.0274523944,
-0.0566033237,
0.0401175171,
-0.047510244,
0.064844422,
-0.0034046399,
0.0099641047,
-0.0161752645,
-0.0228905883,
0.0510413684,
-0.0172812343,
0.0560637042,
0.0530701578,
-0.0037065081,
0.0211411715,
0.0219678264,
-0.0005252971,
-0.0474884883,
0.059600573,
-0.0062224697,
0.0102253612,
-0.0346128531,
0.0198251195,
-0.0326216146,
-0.0656548589,
0.0335215367,
0.0277654957,
-0.0354702137,
0.0491685942,
0.037496727,
-0.0653951615,
-0.0009565234,
-0.0186621137,
-0.0025269948,
-0.0378435068,
0.0121048801,
-0.0446911752,
-0.0044595189,
-0.0810349882,
0.0042307479,
0.0140940342,
-0.0234940946,
0.0910329744,
-0.0192447826,
-0.0010091731,
0.0594050772,
-0.0364432521,
0.0511092357,
-0.0266060326,
-0.025931498,
0.0464262664,
0.0091836173,
0.0488841794,
0.0398217961,
-0.0316581316,
-0.0204491895,
-0.0472972281,
0.019800989,
0.0485024229,
0.0457935371,
0.0573053174,
-0.0068208361,
-0.0567748658,
-0.0316750035,
-0.029309148,
0.0094943009,
-0.0323287323,
-0.0183660965,
0.0356974863,
-0.0368609652,
-0.0145470295,
-0.0448654406,
0.0222660284,
-0.0133505743,
0.0186433438,
-0.0023164463,
-0.0251925793,
0.0343789496,
0.0317254402,
0.0218976587,
-0.0664051473,
0.0179357529,
-0.0014181817,
0.0532066151,
0.0327461883,
0.0124371955,
-0.0017404835,
0.0276421234,
-0.0126001937,
-0.0252509993,
-0.0280739032,
0.0307753775,
0.0125202136,
-0.030409947,
0.0209508799,
0.0159947257,
-0.0120023908,
-0.0076159076,
0.0041020224,
-0.0503528342,
-0.0215646345,
0.0074293921,
-0.0340182744,
-0.002005893,
-0.0626197383,
0.0047535584,
-0.0231935307,
0.0560024455,
0.0209556017,
-0.0098252287,
0.0003159068,
0.0188725572,
2.926e-7,
0.0196146891,
0.0528435744,
-0.0488948599,
0.0504794307,
-0.0091196271,
0.0226073004,
-0.0582590066,
0.0050766999,
0.0225395672,
-0.0083315885,
-0.011654743,
0.0507738106,
0.0511264466,
0.0459817499,
-0.0487851314,
-0.006075168,
-0.0252414476,
0.0040257764,
-0.0524410047,
0.0504863709,
0.0484270491,
0.0245681256,
0.0006462017,
0.0082580075,
-0.0363184325,
-0.0608474724,
0.016933931,
-0.0347814932,
-0.0058767269,
0.0118590817,
0.0460218601,
0.0075121783,
0.0251312181,
0.0833595693,
0.0281258859,
0.0191681571,
-0.0111430958,
0.0366040282,
-0.013651737,
-0.0061064791,
-0.0018108321,
-0.0253978372,
0.0046329191,
-0.0799407661,
0.0462451242,
-0.0839501396,
-0.0601409972,
-0.0209966134,
0.0230063088,
-0.007529065,
0.0540947951,
0.0021661879,
-0.0176709425,
0.0400334895,
0.0161165223,
-0.0398018882,
0.0063599125,
-0.0277114026,
0.024167547,
-0.0098151639,
0.0051244022,
-0.0850704536,
-0.0422960036,
-0.0386517122,
-0.0154745253,
-0.0838335305,
0.0328643806,
2.60938463e-34,
0.0048355982,
-0.0111215049,
0.0071651163,
-0.0114916414,
0.061612159,
0.0213421825,
-0.0353208147,
0.0404216573,
0.0131714661,
-0.0730446875,
0.0167697016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02206v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02206v1 | Axiomatic Preference Modeling for Longform Question Answering | 2023-12-02T23:11:41 | 2023-12-02T23:11:41 | Corby Rosset, Guoqing Zheng, Victor Dibia, Ahmed Awadallah, Paul Bennett | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The remarkable abilities of large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 partially
stem from post-training processes like Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) involving human preferences encoded in a reward model. However,
these reward models (RMs) often lack direct knowledge of why, or under what
principles, the preferences annotations were made. In this study, we identify
principles that guide RMs to better align with human preferences, and then
develop an axiomatic framework to generate a rich variety of preference signals
to uphold them. We use these axiomatic signals to train a model for scoring
answers to longform questions. Our approach yields a Preference Model with only
about 220M parameters that agrees with gold human-annotated preference labels
more often than GPT-4. The contributions of this work include: training a
standalone preference model that can score human- and LLM-generated answers on
the same scale; developing an axiomatic framework for generating training data
pairs tailored to certain principles; and showing that a small amount of
axiomatic signals can help small models outperform GPT-4 in preference scoring.
We release our model on huggingface:
https://huggingface.co/corbyrosset/axiomatic_preference_model | [
0.0358456895,
0.0540909022,
0.0212192237,
0.0084671555,
-0.0225273017,
0.0077405358,
-0.055705227,
-0.0056575029,
-0.0061941324,
-0.0220275763,
-0.0315426029,
-0.0171923377,
-0.0317582525,
-0.0093049584,
0.0239402968,
-0.0539836213,
0.040715158,
-0.039510645,
0.0131683489,
-0.0207281448,
0.0250622481,
0.002619985,
0.0225190762,
-0.0023816342,
0.0091543486,
-0.0424087532,
-0.0107844193,
-0.0366357304,
0.0223741829,
-0.016123591,
0.0191721749,
0.0679895207,
0.009523469,
0.0191823635,
0.0000020336,
-0.0258485992,
-0.0096484479,
-0.013493577,
-0.0121594034,
0.0138327759,
-0.0356296375,
0.0602174103,
0.0221443567,
0.0019721827,
-0.0591394454,
-0.0029005131,
0.0306468476,
0.0680484697,
0.08871115,
0.042839583,
0.020199379,
-0.038494736,
0.0363098234,
-0.0491521358,
0.0356332771,
-0.0305759255,
0.0032778629,
-0.0126397777,
0.0428838432,
0.0705744326,
-0.0105510643,
0.0032288248,
0.0520853549,
0.0230320562,
0.0338599943,
0.0343418792,
-0.0112703471,
0.0360083766,
0.0004667045,
0.1009123847,
0.0053376341,
-0.0232930947,
-0.0206803232,
-0.0067667342,
0.0274991561,
-0.0187379438,
-0.0528184548,
0.0008955313,
-0.0050624632,
0.0142142465,
0.0481885448,
-0.000860644,
0.0113714729,
0.0250483975,
0.0034391114,
0.0924271271,
-0.0004012729,
-0.0464485027,
0.0186271369,
0.0073232483,
-0.0823941901,
-0.0598460995,
0.0058928258,
0.0160034727,
-0.0171672478,
0.0051992782,
-0.0160915777,
0.0479234941,
0.0374573544,
-0.0214567203,
0.0403203852,
0.0336229615,
0.0023249898,
0.0309785474,
-0.0293569788,
0.0368583091,
-0.0211630147,
-0.004627666,
-0.0600420609,
0.0029315646,
-0.026661234,
-0.0252108853,
-0.0208197366,
0.0560187846,
0.0001826236,
0.0062486716,
-0.0547041409,
0.0110378768,
-0.0191865321,
0.0047827652,
0.0306844525,
0.0514939576,
-0.0104626874,
0.0232776999,
-0.0765184537,
0.0561222807,
-0.0918132216,
0.0227786545,
0.0312342253,
-0.0088770008,
-0.0102335606,
-0.0074692802,
-0.0064966693,
-0.0543935224,
0.0347450227,
0.0383892991,
0.0039467155,
0.0049441499,
0.0313053541,
-0.0227242168,
-0.0263116434,
-0.0411163494,
-0.0273835957,
-0.0857260376,
0.0162240863,
0.0005755778,
-0.0112188412,
0.0005901617,
0.0176240243,
0.0676600263,
-0.023431858,
0.0608099811,
0.0197155774,
-0.0150270555,
0.0019930892,
-0.0006161493,
0.0061126836,
0.0223530848,
0.028655244,
0.048790887,
0.0558463074,
-0.0129589206,
0.0283826496,
0.0217185691,
0.0200935621,
-0.0081614349,
0.0265171733,
0.0785059929,
0.0290154088,
0.0362295881,
0.0108635444,
0.0217680465,
-0.0106880693,
-0.0714960396,
0.0699820593,
0.0483738184,
-0.0202874485,
-0.0232147072,
0.0041954103,
-0.0261475537,
0.008805328,
0.0240088794,
-0.0166522171,
0.0554749183,
-0.0496745333,
-0.0048283972,
0.0306780376,
-0.0299087465,
-0.0363515876,
-0.0562612377,
0.0180447362,
-0.0074821226,
-0.0120093552,
0.0329051055,
0.0249747802,
-0.0051174569,
-0.0106430165,
-0.0072603878,
0.006001465,
-0.0558561124,
0.0104284231,
-0.0325571112,
0.0747386739,
0.0544546098,
0.0542673394,
-0.0403849073,
0.0013346709,
-0.0293043554,
-0.0027039621,
0.0125785079,
0.0379041508,
-0.0427464955,
-0.0134382881,
-0.0188221093,
-0.0003879052,
-0.0048429575,
-0.0204391852,
0.0129460776,
0.0445502885,
0.0080343215,
-0.0129662147,
-0.0369963422,
-0.0280489344,
0.0161328632,
0.0348462872,
-0.0611697324,
0.0421371795,
-0.0093843341,
0.0466113947,
0.0193138011,
0.0195920039,
0.034208931,
0.0360126309,
-0.0066080731,
-0.02974906,
-0.0293779671,
-0.0652511716,
-0.0138007207,
0.0314050242,
-0.0055222516,
0.0035895472,
0.071102649,
-0.034090776,
-0.0305114612,
-0.0426203609,
-0.0416843556,
0.0036262174,
-0.0495810695,
-0.0178995375,
0.0383993164,
-0.0139819821,
-0.0944806412,
0.0360224508,
-0.0023569851,
0.0215490758,
-0.0702794269,
-0.0011215695,
0.0092886928,
-0.0926700905,
-0.0269190427,
0.0407173708,
0.0229606256,
0.0342439674,
0.0729391575,
0.0155728376,
-0.0420829318,
-0.0202809218,
-0.0687565729,
0.0230441876,
0.0054200008,
0.0306065194,
0.0029191584,
0.010436954,
0.0185780972,
-0.036696814,
-0.0914749876,
-0.0285978764,
0.0214063004,
0.0161838867,
0.0550156198,
0.0273343921,
0.0215690732,
-0.0561313555,
-0.0473194942,
-0.0020831674,
-0.0106624039,
-0.0101961093,
0.0663334355,
-0.0469871536,
-0.0274492539,
-0.0451033823,
0.0377227515,
-0.0021014537,
-0.031135153,
0.0188483093,
-0.0241125692,
0.0023481764,
0.0778253973,
0.0382746123,
-0.0086399699,
0.0297118127,
0.0316244587,
-0.0581917837,
0.0079712691,
-0.0794968531,
-0.0081000989,
-0.0084790913,
0.004920512,
0.0093222903,
0.0615158565,
-0.0048026396,
-0.0214747004,
-0.0555172749,
0.0324713849,
-0.0048956666,
-0.0093118465,
-0.0372123718,
0.0065705478,
-0.0158602912,
0.0346765704,
-0.0031969706,
-0.0514163747,
0.1104405448,
-0.007991422,
0.0061722468,
-0.0832444131,
0.0145428479,
-0.0580546819,
0.0281915665,
0.02071153,
-0.0096972687,
0.0243031066,
0.0344684198,
-0.0498113148,
-0.0546483733,
0.0046165022,
-0.0427751802,
0.0292031243,
-0.0312326849,
0.0170513913,
-0.0075998846,
-0.0624866746,
-0.0462907776,
-0.0546412207,
-0.0275657512,
0.0238894317,
-0.0096268971,
-0.0222973768,
0.0332900062,
-0.0083400039,
0.0470660627,
-0.0073903827,
-0.0343915448,
0.0007418454,
-0.0105489371,
0.0556266606,
0.0958850533,
0.0110406224,
0.0135066509,
-0.0144851338,
-0.0026564626,
0.0598496012,
0.0495357662,
0.0298187397,
-0.0046033212,
0.0084783677,
0.0316872559,
-0.0543883853,
-0.032143116,
-0.0005686741,
0.0234599113,
-0.0355773643,
0.0174283255,
0.1123870686,
0.0373856425,
-0.0367893726,
0.0067338771,
-0.0009074938,
0.058511667,
-0.0043491065,
0.0433587581,
-0.0846066698,
-0.0417684503,
-0.017856149,
0.068930313,
-0.0058821631,
-0.0204929821,
0.0229765102,
-0.1137559935,
-0.0163511839,
-0.0156191196,
-0.0677198991,
0.0172798764,
-0.0665765554,
0.0186456293,
-0.0269678589,
-0.0243866928,
0.0234999508,
-0.0053873914,
0.0246013701,
0.0283760112,
-0.0002417053,
0.0324673317,
0.081635572,
-0.041571945,
0.0273708254,
0.0876886398,
0.0366097279,
-0.0233547986,
-0.0495352335,
-0.0251891837,
-0.034529794,
-0.0203282628,
-0.0240296554,
0.0037407423,
-0.0417900942,
-0.0001299573,
-0.0537675396,
0.0778916404,
-0.0326394662,
-0.0027120844,
0.038195692,
0.0939829051,
-0.0067489631,
-0.0116010476,
-0.0220542699,
0.0068624485,
0.0002064272,
0.0847393498,
-0.0085750418,
-0.0776085258,
-0.0514914766,
-0.0191891287,
-0.0326913148,
-0.0559859946,
-0.0498889722,
-0.0159388445,
0.0233012196,
0.0093879662,
-0.0701010525,
-0.0704197809,
0.0227344129,
0.0178274307,
-0.0307355672,
0.0218866281,
-0.0347030126,
0.0269986931,
-0.033094272,
0.0538743399,
-0.0391604304,
0.0212638509,
-0.0771200284,
-0.0018146948,
0.0340901539,
-0.0358480066,
-0.0306376852,
0.0100062694,
0.0014399167,
-0.0211809352,
-0.0178171583,
0.0747862458,
0.0151082361,
0.018405905,
-0.0082135499,
-0.0436552353,
0.0186325256,
0.0260133035,
-0.0007023221,
0.0023907893,
0.0339463726,
0.0214927308,
0.0075942278,
0.021980213,
-0.0174481161,
0.0156913884,
0.0250086654,
0.0436634533,
-0.0220887233,
-0.0432263054,
0.0500180982,
0.0154104,
-0.0292751212,
0.0030264284,
0.0093381815,
-0.0089741498,
-0.001482385,
-0.0110264635,
-0.0244922489,
-0.022871973,
-0.0063091549,
0.0262939371,
-0.0347702429,
-0.0209123604,
-0.0287895128,
0.0009260537,
0.0187208354,
-0.033627402,
0.0054652239,
0.0663322583,
0.0039701322,
0.0035963024,
-0.0038199506,
-0.0225607008,
-0.0564331487,
0.0081318468,
0.0692442283,
0.0125423074,
0.0488530807,
0.0361329839,
-0.0171578787,
0.0186717547,
0.0325085819,
-0.0665658638,
-0.0512976684,
-0.03549679,
-0.0061544343,
0.0143015711,
0.0048316419,
0.0174619444,
0.0060872375,
-0.024783222,
-0.0314416476,
-0.0139081245,
0.0088131754,
0.0190455411,
0.0464593954,
0.0535294823,
-0.0194777809,
-0.0072398442,
0.0572261587,
0.0053887805,
0.030025309,
-0.0015883368,
-0.0035583116,
-0.0351355672,
-0.0034069251,
-0.022465663,
0.0212010667,
-0.0057904231,
0.0276691951,
-0.0407104045,
-0.0379419141,
-0.0262047499,
0.0454668403,
-0.015175594,
0.00451191,
0.0604894869,
0.0336413383,
-0.0020638171,
-0.0437613837,
-0.0599298775,
0.0138673242,
-0.0625243634,
-0.0407815538,
-0.0340931751,
-6.253157545e-33,
-0.014256875,
-0.0159241706,
0.0155105479,
0.0104460828,
-0.0214796718,
-0.0163220018,
-0.0006420945,
0.0001622111,
-0.0243759844,
-0.0079578031,
-0.0347374044,
-0.0156511534,
-0.0068821288,
0.0289838817,
0.0285257064,
-0.0363034233,
0.0052984874,
-0.0246258415,
-0.0457015783,
0.0246632807,
0.0384136811,
-0.0230392925,
0.0513847135,
-0.0149967512,
0.0492989309,
-0.0006873767,
-0.0157625079,
0.0422220938,
-0.0595744662,
0.0895306915,
-0.0267572179,
0.0319423154,
0.0266566891,
-0.0463546664,
0.0116938641,
0.0616117604,
-0.0744517371,
-0.0239817072,
0.0328089036,
-0.0148657523,
-0.0618519932,
-0.0390982777,
0.0001759588,
-0.0213408675,
0.0000568213,
-0.0020415387,
0.0429786108,
-0.0458131395,
0.0110801021,
0.0303725861,
-0.0030677661,
0.0102704065,
0.0016355183,
-0.0355344936,
-0.0337135978,
0.0705543086,
-0.0130995288,
0.0492367111,
-0.0142864073,
0.0195063502,
0.0308823343,
0.0511097796,
0.0197639577,
-0.0035623424,
0.0190014951,
0.0436963625,
0.0239878017,
-0.0192745756,
-0.0020029047,
-0.0230131727,
-0.0350867845,
0.0170674361,
0.0891365781,
0.0231321156,
0.0340939537,
0.0281692576,
-0.0478570126,
0.043592345,
0.0373919606,
0.0121000158,
0.0207214486,
0.0181371551,
-0.0396117903,
-0.0146825379,
-0.0537834577,
-0.0157686323,
-0.0469271988,
-0.0199108198,
0.0193235204,
0.0169015415,
-0.0346774645,
0.0059490991,
0.0279748626,
-0.0424569063,
-0.0409823246,
0.0240924191,
-0.0163333416,
0.0192188397,
0.0362567119,
-0.0109952744,
-0.0481183492,
0.0616431981,
0.002337381,
-0.0357375294,
-0.0236015581,
0.0086603761,
0.0125615085,
0.0016119952,
-0.0280016176,
-0.0194090214,
-0.0175142772,
0.0057434114,
-0.0054755327,
-0.0117911585,
0.0170984492,
0.0306273941,
0.0014868496,
0.0537547953,
-0.0326846763,
0.0049016816,
-0.0604472868,
-0.047790274,
0.0042411736,
0.018520873,
-0.0074495799,
0.0322733484,
-0.0098827519,
0.0110044647,
-0.0521727093,
-0.0298803169,
-0.006168256,
0.0256765671,
2.574e-7,
0.0266103614,
0.0123097263,
0.0313958228,
0.0281260088,
0.0096142357,
0.064925693,
0.0273119211,
0.0067934236,
0.0483733565,
-0.0060462262,
-0.0126066534,
0.0207018871,
0.0398324504,
0.025448041,
-0.0691255629,
-0.0001756928,
-0.0542163663,
-0.0284146667,
-0.0071170628,
-0.0421956591,
0.0474634655,
0.0648480132,
0.0456499048,
-0.0072846957,
-0.0123846764,
0.041367311,
0.0524313338,
-0.0449942499,
0.0059816027,
0.0048572081,
0.0103989616,
-0.0355978459,
0.0271109808,
0.002205709,
0.0148649896,
-0.0293167513,
0.0346343555,
0.0788531899,
-0.0033291173,
-0.0773278698,
-0.0178363826,
-0.0161348935,
0.0150687238,
-0.09540122,
0.0884103999,
-0.0298049431,
-0.032153707,
-0.0346556045,
-0.0329935513,
-0.0237501897,
0.0116044749,
-0.0268550776,
-0.0204155147,
-0.0134133082,
0.0007262409,
0.0230796542,
0.0100507298,
-0.0432414822,
-0.0119131617,
0.0358895361,
-0.0326014981,
-0.0318171196,
-0.0411341265,
0.0358775519,
-0.0389973782,
-0.0665790886,
-0.0465947129,
2.243856167e-34,
0.0181835629,
-0.0048791915,
0.0322918296,
-0.004940507,
0.0092997877,
0.0255016219,
0.0258602295,
-0.0197724029,
0.0999078006,
-0.0700925067,
-0.0434747972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01244v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01244v1 | Challenges and Applications of Automated Extraction of Socio-political Events from Text (CASE 2023): Workshop and Shared Task Report | 2023-12-02T23:05:24 | 2023-12-02T23:05:24 | Ali Hürriyetoğlu, Hristo Tanev, Osman Mutlu, Surendrabikram Thapa, Fiona Anting Tan, Erdem Yörük | cs.CL | cs.CL | We provide a summary of the sixth edition of the CASE workshop that is held
in the scope of RANLP 2023. The workshop consists of regular papers, three
keynotes, working papers of shared task participants, and shared task overview
papers. This workshop series has been bringing together all aspects of event
information collection across technical and social science fields. In addition
to contributing to the progress in text based event extraction, the workshop
provides a space for the organization of a multimodal event information
collection task. | [
0.0099289259,
0.0748099461,
-0.0119059207,
0.0510832034,
-0.0588786975,
0.0056673074,
-0.0086449841,
-0.0051432699,
0.0363764651,
-0.0506164618,
0.0960916653,
0.0192955043,
-0.0268414561,
0.0691786781,
-0.0290561542,
-0.1230415404,
0.0486972257,
0.0198131595,
0.0120657794,
0.0319886059,
0.0107896253,
0.0302669648,
-0.0438589454,
-0.0003619079,
-0.0306538157,
0.0325348936,
-0.0274366699,
-0.0348530896,
0.0514601655,
-0.0192570034,
-0.0059216111,
-0.0191486236,
0.0398516394,
-0.0068675838,
0.0000019013,
-0.0400039889,
-0.049823802,
-0.0237980578,
0.025456192,
-0.0289470181,
0.0273136627,
-0.01373599,
-0.0328975655,
-0.0385619514,
-0.0274577346,
0.0091713499,
0.0048891408,
0.0436943658,
0.0158501957,
0.0679506361,
-0.0306026153,
0.0013320572,
0.0204227399,
0.0287638009,
-0.0406417027,
-0.0151117109,
0.013929463,
-0.0122845834,
0.0054678987,
-0.0038299297,
0.0191784408,
0.0442203358,
-0.007433204,
0.0154151041,
-0.0567611791,
0.0336234719,
-0.0412115976,
-0.020616075,
-0.0149845667,
0.037273448,
0.0577243045,
0.0065896143,
0.0720560402,
-0.0106852725,
-0.0234529078,
0.0343354046,
-0.0231332239,
0.0242824201,
-0.036755234,
0.0154473092,
0.0301201027,
0.0308383442,
-0.0123950653,
0.0407762565,
0.0089699496,
0.0495058335,
0.0099160774,
-0.0075137964,
-0.0185688417,
-0.0146493847,
0.0455280393,
-0.0240160227,
0.0505545512,
0.0121775642,
0.0320911184,
0.042938035,
0.0047551473,
0.0107243937,
-0.004932093,
-0.0962863117,
-0.0330970958,
0.0012927501,
-0.0227777213,
0.0623632818,
0.0599186048,
-0.0263672061,
-0.0019040339,
-0.0121346787,
0.0201309677,
0.0017062089,
-0.0174290482,
0.0447532944,
-0.0293817855,
0.0048713144,
-0.0532141961,
-0.0052275886,
0.0114860237,
-0.0069640381,
0.0329148658,
0.0317688361,
-0.0463113487,
-0.0039302595,
-0.0539464839,
-0.0310763717,
-0.0212361291,
0.0231322702,
-0.0561673082,
0.0213360861,
-0.03188489,
-0.023887042,
0.0045601148,
0.0141419731,
0.0555010922,
-0.0058051208,
-0.007706637,
0.0180028379,
-0.0541462004,
-0.0201927405,
-0.0568137318,
-0.0530399829,
-0.0382653624,
0.000815052,
-0.0098852282,
-0.048122365,
0.0578831546,
-0.0258588716,
-0.0183374546,
-0.0361813009,
0.0271341912,
0.0077548283,
-0.0423330106,
0.0211864319,
-0.0252723824,
-0.00337473,
0.0593511239,
0.0201473366,
0.0219706688,
0.0562804341,
0.0653680339,
0.0807489306,
0.0988321975,
0.0230708048,
0.0148864258,
0.0453443415,
0.0143300248,
-0.0084917285,
-0.0073969895,
-0.0331907086,
-0.0102670519,
-0.0248228498,
0.0077871643,
0.0048626391,
0.0153376004,
-0.0158694033,
0.0378755555,
0.0744453594,
-0.0259787682,
0.0006380923,
-0.0083261877,
-0.0152277416,
0.0024509472,
0.018201001,
0.0165689122,
-0.0348140225,
-0.0248646419,
0.0103654135,
-0.0026427086,
0.0319355465,
0.0233764015,
-0.0162510984,
0.0127780149,
-0.0064535416,
0.0203628782,
0.0067251218,
0.0600164309,
-0.0485909544,
-0.0406868458,
-0.0134667195,
0.0228448715,
-0.0503365844,
0.0454482473,
0.0035188154,
0.0076942835,
0.0019424802,
0.0279097613,
-0.0707945675,
-0.0166127607,
-0.0048813936,
0.0342025161,
0.0331662856,
0.0070091998,
-0.0356474444,
0.0124383541,
-0.003375821,
-0.030714225,
0.0502658337,
-0.0124755241,
0.0030156418,
0.0309821758,
0.0288690589,
-0.0059289034,
0.0286021698,
-0.0215651281,
0.0385878719,
-0.0023848668,
-0.0306429099,
-0.0599816293,
0.0187437087,
0.0027055969,
0.03099389,
-0.005477522,
-0.0349170342,
0.0409427509,
-0.0469990261,
0.0214134026,
0.0437032431,
0.0115379086,
0.0060134232,
0.0146130649,
-0.0317136347,
-0.0238465853,
0.0275501516,
-0.0243055206,
-0.0115753906,
0.0374508575,
0.0281651486,
-0.0123451194,
-0.0126676913,
-0.0205082837,
0.0128145246,
0.0001773354,
-0.054656364,
0.0960937738,
0.0291367434,
-0.0290707517,
-0.029649565,
-0.0601952784,
0.0171419717,
-0.0211955458,
-0.0138319153,
0.0358633362,
0.0055488618,
0.000208152,
0.043176122,
-0.0760825574,
-0.071540907,
-0.0141336229,
-0.0188228991,
0.001088126,
-0.0347071886,
0.050229691,
0.0073850015,
0.0152846472,
-0.043243967,
-0.0019374548,
0.0252766721,
-0.0654903874,
-0.0141237387,
-0.0220095739,
0.0663131773,
0.0149224466,
0.0195657462,
-0.0412069559,
0.0095528662,
-0.0607343726,
0.0361747295,
0.0554577261,
-0.0633716211,
-0.0037964364,
0.027855996,
-0.0265494511,
0.0487979986,
-0.0352528952,
-0.0096307285,
-0.0137611581,
0.0017568376,
0.0454726517,
0.0707127377,
0.039973408,
0.0755092576,
-0.0142978197,
-0.050521899,
-0.0263025127,
0.0044442941,
-0.0608631894,
0.0500399731,
0.0033315562,
-0.025755303,
0.0549874045,
0.0061028409,
0.0395929031,
0.0407255962,
-0.0023237939,
-0.0228541084,
-0.03196631,
0.0048699244,
-0.0253788754,
-0.0171388704,
-0.0246115625,
0.0521224476,
-0.0048188451,
0.0015366805,
0.0340928026,
0.0162507407,
0.0358978137,
-0.059894152,
-0.0195594225,
-0.0359176546,
0.1216594055,
-0.0154488841,
0.0279815905,
-0.0050385273,
-0.0359312631,
0.0167380236,
-0.0650253743,
0.0378225781,
-0.0191982184,
0.007083592,
-0.0643129423,
0.0168240145,
-0.0576970316,
-0.0165312961,
-0.0225363057,
-0.063529633,
0.0102136098,
-0.0169529524,
0.0007968937,
0.0261270832,
-0.0176427979,
0.0370524563,
0.0321883671,
-0.0183715932,
0.0166744757,
-0.0007605793,
0.0002086311,
0.0771733448,
0.0322934575,
-0.022511363,
-0.0530786775,
0.028073106,
-0.0506421775,
0.0457703881,
0.0480628833,
0.0021301098,
-0.0113883484,
-0.008641134,
0.0172596369,
-0.0619596243,
0.0355653539,
-0.0213835426,
0.0344473347,
-0.0600859299,
0.0331852138,
0.0534934774,
0.0345037468,
-0.0105452035,
0.0062817205,
0.0415314212,
-0.0269535612,
-0.0117332842,
-0.0059797792,
-0.0670415908,
0.0484960228,
0.0007001561,
-0.0203276407,
-0.0361381806,
-0.0482944772,
-0.017422542,
-0.0299919024,
0.0117814057,
0.0033646293,
0.0065027103,
-0.05059883,
-0.0370329954,
0.0254379828,
-0.0315800197,
-0.0671771243,
0.0049290443,
0.0022954177,
-0.0062938482,
0.0194973666,
-0.1017500535,
-0.0425211899,
-0.008364005,
-0.0162759274,
-0.0091270329,
-0.0039609205,
0.0571676157,
-0.00459657,
0.0184117947,
0.0269235261,
-0.030519424,
-0.015065033,
-0.001854175,
0.0437878445,
-0.0282686409,
-0.0252614729,
-0.0145643288,
0.055963438,
0.0571309403,
-0.0394658484,
0.0241629258,
0.0575757697,
-0.0208887793,
0.0159568917,
0.0080983285,
0.0185965654,
0.0344501995,
0.0100288074,
-0.0051860986,
0.0282888599,
-0.019900715,
-0.0122773284,
0.0562111884,
-0.0927343741,
-0.0292177349,
-0.0130859716,
-0.0465214476,
-0.0525644794,
-0.0355655737,
-0.0615269989,
0.0220419709,
0.0494799986,
-0.0093015479,
-0.0267229974,
0.0456859171,
0.0431663617,
-0.044812765,
0.0386851057,
-0.0162517149,
-0.0133694625,
0.0377328247,
-0.0324740969,
-0.0189550221,
0.049574703,
-0.0297611598,
0.0679957569,
-0.0465598777,
-0.0208476428,
0.0474384278,
-0.0704672933,
0.0019678336,
0.0111947088,
0.0031036774,
0.0155294007,
0.0110386498,
0.0157378074,
-0.0011920709,
-0.0392470099,
0.0070751132,
0.025697479,
-0.0120882057,
0.0096884584,
0.0135089513,
0.025584694,
-0.0303754266,
0.0033258351,
-0.0780958682,
-0.0247507375,
-0.000045421,
-0.0042388928,
0.0368869826,
-0.0312514752,
-0.0986254439,
-0.0726522729,
-0.0235235114,
-0.0264861882,
-0.0168900788,
0.0155826733,
0.0411547199,
-0.0597430915,
-0.0023246103,
-0.048042383,
0.0459413342,
-0.041341912,
0.0318003558,
-0.0448034815,
0.0561137535,
0.0765482932,
0.0369346254,
-0.0230554696,
-0.0171088632,
0.0078239143,
0.0370879769,
-0.0302564111,
0.0334353969,
-0.0396606028,
0.01232043,
0.0225934926,
-0.018164495,
-0.0237022657,
-0.0287392661,
-0.0368980542,
0.0590433702,
-0.0145981517,
0.0492822416,
0.0542175435,
-0.0067650974,
-0.003548512,
-0.0133939665,
-0.0301621016,
0.0291537084,
0.0089371176,
-0.0061444249,
-0.006391766,
0.0065261717,
0.0020512638,
-0.0498733632,
0.0434278548,
0.0035825325,
-0.0708073229,
0.0413824543,
0.0950516164,
-0.0201245435,
-0.0218109284,
-0.0438090786,
0.0370360278,
0.012924646,
-0.0175537523,
-0.0285538696,
-0.0869798213,
0.0350707583,
0.0616202503,
0.0064864452,
-0.0123248277,
0.0302150939,
-0.0154675245,
0.0602765195,
0.0230911523,
0.0081325984,
-0.0517139733,
0.0517836623,
-0.0151144424,
-0.0079573067,
0.0229144972,
-6.649833991e-33,
-0.0364865661,
-0.0406460688,
0.0212049372,
0.051244054,
-0.0456812903,
0.0138003575,
-0.0203527715,
-0.0089757117,
-0.0138609223,
0.0156552698,
-0.0027939165,
-0.024398664,
0.0373763926,
-0.0194979608,
0.0200414844,
-0.0023986071,
0.0011615447,
-0.002114167,
-0.0238169134,
0.0121941064,
0.0621346124,
0.015997963,
0.0507954359,
-0.1118927151,
0.0585685857,
0.0286521893,
-0.0156553797,
-0.0473840423,
0.1114721298,
0.0026705812,
-0.0390858985,
0.0146568585,
0.0342529677,
-0.0528248362,
0.0195095763,
0.0365534164,
-0.0713023767,
-0.0091911266,
0.0021605773,
-0.0014637142,
0.0097836582,
-0.0189285856,
-0.0095228218,
-0.0121926535,
-0.0082278978,
0.0044879764,
0.0530304499,
-0.0193588194,
-0.0032166347,
-0.0330331996,
-0.0760706514,
0.0620936416,
-0.015295919,
0.0166671425,
0.0178424045,
0.0006966241,
0.0840818286,
0.0613266975,
-0.0351700298,
0.0167880617,
-0.0465004295,
0.0028022763,
0.0368297398,
-0.029119987,
-0.0164126866,
0.0418650545,
-0.0288418159,
-0.013092895,
-0.0579317734,
0.0100582661,
0.002964328,
0.0436213426,
-0.0259706248,
0.0710828453,
-0.0114004239,
-0.0157558527,
-0.0754126534,
0.0359148048,
0.0719017833,
-0.009685887,
-0.0396472625,
-0.0107905408,
-0.0132748084,
0.0203042962,
-0.006152167,
-0.0010761699,
0.0148644969,
-0.0031334681,
-0.0269435719,
0.0025390447,
-0.0083148452,
0.1062545106,
0.0102207931,
0.008922033,
-0.0121179232,
-0.0211041681,
0.0082971882,
0.0238879584,
-0.0272068288,
0.0055569229,
-0.0265263077,
-0.0159870479,
-0.0089775873,
0.0526933149,
0.0382340103,
-0.0335014574,
-0.038361147,
0.0005709023,
-0.0335376598,
0.0032358048,
0.0164212659,
-0.0170571115,
-0.0168852005,
0.0112141073,
0.0058912635,
0.0087547367,
-0.0063628154,
-0.0122277578,
0.060721606,
0.044925224,
0.0506407283,
-0.0289981551,
-0.0321431942,
0.0210091043,
-0.001611974,
0.0044523631,
-0.0012537219,
0.0354107991,
0.0063926009,
0.0213880241,
0.0055591376,
-0.0306728091,
2.572e-7,
0.0475254692,
0.0467887409,
0.0571540594,
0.0104893213,
-0.0286477674,
-0.0174755603,
0.0150080621,
0.0376904979,
-0.046372842,
0.0174578074,
0.0270454399,
-0.0137662487,
0.0412395969,
0.062948063,
-0.0482787341,
-0.0891331658,
-0.0179436579,
-0.0384680107,
-0.1137455329,
0.0333885178,
0.0587504171,
0.0223520193,
0.0539893173,
0.0112855192,
-0.053546723,
-0.001601773,
-0.0034127999,
-0.0085836314,
-0.0987076163,
0.0204430819,
0.009588616,
-0.0295336079,
-0.0442049913,
-0.0054107741,
-0.015838258,
0.0028572029,
-0.0102389632,
0.0363461263,
0.0042779939,
-0.0089406669,
-0.0509873405,
-0.0283840392,
-0.0240802784,
-0.0154056037,
0.0628732815,
-0.0083185071,
-0.0129675539,
-0.0290949959,
-0.0408736616,
0.0479038097,
-0.0091761714,
0.0088601336,
-0.0295703132,
0.0369931981,
-0.0027205367,
-0.0048277043,
-0.0225003101,
-0.0838466212,
0.0427268632,
0.0202575009,
0.0022294121,
-0.0336109847,
0.0519173481,
-0.0186663158,
0.015852116,
-0.0453547947,
0.0228997618,
2.07896186e-34,
0.0104996888,
0.0357014798,
-0.0642085746,
0.0040898067,
0.0360899419,
-0.0077361264,
-0.0636907145,
-0.0059632864,
-0.0167803038,
-0.0229682866,
0.0196170583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01225v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01225v1 | UCE-FID: Using Large Unlabeled, Medium Crowdsourced-Labeled, and Small Expert-Labeled Tweets for Foodborne Illness Detection | 2023-12-02T21:03:23 | 2023-12-02T21:03:23 | Ruofan Hu, Dongyu Zhang, Dandan Tao, Huayi Zhang, Hao Feng, Elke Rundensteiner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Foodborne illnesses significantly impact public health. Deep learning
surveillance applications using social media data aim to detect early warning
signals. However, labeling foodborne illness-related tweets for model training
requires extensive human resources, making it challenging to collect a
sufficient number of high-quality labels for tweets within a limited budget.
The severe class imbalance resulting from the scarcity of foodborne
illness-related tweets among the vast volume of social media further
exacerbates the problem. Classifiers trained on a class-imbalanced dataset are
biased towards the majority class, making accurate detection difficult. To
overcome these challenges, we propose EGAL, a deep learning framework for
foodborne illness detection that uses small expert-labeled tweets augmented by
crowdsourced-labeled and massive unlabeled data. Specifically, by leveraging
tweets labeled by experts as a reward set, EGAL learns to assign a weight of
zero to incorrectly labeled tweets to mitigate their negative influence. Other
tweets receive proportionate weights to counter-balance the unbalanced class
distribution. Extensive experiments on real-world \textit{TWEET-FID} data show
that EGAL outperforms strong baseline models across different settings,
including varying expert-labeled set sizes and class imbalance ratios. A case
study on a multistate outbreak of Salmonella Typhimurium infection linked to
packaged salad greens demonstrates how the trained model captures relevant
tweets offering valuable outbreak insights. EGAL, funded by the U.S. Department
of Agriculture (USDA), has the potential to be deployed for real-time analysis
of tweet streaming, contributing to foodborne illness outbreak surveillance
efforts. | [
0.0404867604,
0.092821449,
-0.0068804962,
-0.0415069461,
0.0016039447,
0.0099906139,
0.0170865636,
0.0015029429,
0.0355934054,
-0.0125922002,
0.0281366929,
0.0044552586,
-0.0538374744,
0.0813868344,
0.0097411573,
-0.0152523527,
0.043013759,
0.0358662643,
0.0413421579,
0.0286881533,
0.0368361585,
0.0059703561,
0.0062870397,
0.0338879079,
-0.030741144,
0.0494597889,
0.0147203486,
0.0165491197,
0.0690405071,
-0.0838552266,
0.0747426823,
0.0116290031,
0.0124029974,
0.025318332,
0.0000019283,
0.0024241454,
-0.0206482243,
-0.0241278112,
-0.0158812702,
-0.0109095238,
0.0102259964,
-0.0544422045,
0.018432036,
0.0307618845,
-0.0273640491,
0.0015698731,
0.0725072995,
0.0552083701,
0.0023847204,
0.0388603844,
0.0049925228,
-0.028592499,
0.0052962112,
0.0087410463,
0.0256797466,
-0.0129574686,
0.0353764333,
-0.0706852004,
0.0026223934,
-0.0112520792,
0.033258222,
0.0410583131,
0.0221224967,
0.0088885976,
0.0376097932,
0.0662544221,
-0.0224482287,
-0.0288247168,
-0.0137048364,
0.0744095221,
-0.0088121789,
-0.0204449613,
0.0024213651,
-0.0278082807,
0.0062010405,
-0.0079722647,
0.0001051422,
-0.0402510166,
-0.006331481,
0.0622672848,
-0.0069035171,
0.0545086525,
0.0381960273,
0.0551070161,
0.0096012494,
0.0811690614,
-0.0444339812,
-0.0279397089,
-0.0277155191,
0.0093175359,
-0.0250729565,
-0.0073551601,
0.0663387552,
0.0211150907,
-0.0543827526,
-0.0316694044,
0.0036950896,
-0.0800120905,
0.0421795174,
-0.0384978987,
-0.0471418351,
-0.029153252,
0.0023230135,
0.0186504666,
0.0428435244,
-0.0708171278,
-0.0136883473,
0.056612093,
-0.0028070905,
0.0032946304,
-0.0809514672,
0.0278575756,
-0.0264176633,
0.0130467499,
0.0489656888,
0.0407568365,
-0.0424646363,
-0.0654115081,
-0.0451870486,
-0.0390459634,
-0.0292241294,
0.0805456564,
-0.0360012949,
0.0209987964,
0.0046522669,
0.0813903958,
-0.009434456,
0.0401743129,
0.0275310017,
-0.0228134617,
-0.0232343376,
-0.0378025696,
0.0475872867,
0.0159234535,
0.0171397999,
0.0055067339,
0.0003961303,
-0.0385020077,
-0.0328604691,
-0.028131688,
-0.0254081544,
0.0136847803,
-0.0440778248,
-0.0480576344,
0.021441957,
0.0117615787,
0.0311180595,
0.0042717862,
0.0185901653,
0.0070006913,
-0.0622148141,
0.0072084507,
-0.0106061976,
0.0303608291,
0.0403906927,
0.0083400616,
-0.0029368289,
0.0268534757,
0.04596062,
0.0548975393,
0.0143541992,
-0.0142172612,
0.032208208,
0.0039610248,
0.0426029488,
0.0361081176,
0.0216240417,
-0.0061068297,
-0.0336408541,
0.016467711,
-0.0033179768,
0.0200949199,
0.0586844087,
0.0311645158,
0.0863857418,
0.0107220476,
-0.0428574868,
-0.0473946743,
0.0099787368,
0.0709777474,
-0.0404599942,
-0.0606321618,
-0.0147983823,
0.0372998863,
-0.0502183177,
-0.041935809,
-0.0005925419,
0.0110859321,
-0.0433709212,
-0.0233550724,
-0.0113052167,
0.0407245196,
0.0004745379,
-0.0117940018,
0.0414383858,
-0.0384360813,
-0.0120991869,
0.0334328115,
0.0340536982,
-0.0305299014,
0.0244748741,
-0.044881016,
0.0292690974,
0.0715944394,
0.0032740599,
-0.0345668681,
-0.0174230784,
-0.0392797887,
0.0349440202,
-0.0291853026,
0.010589066,
0.0170621444,
0.006754742,
0.024501754,
-0.0249014832,
0.0223100632,
0.0550868362,
-0.0145192817,
0.0017509421,
0.0529628098,
-0.0085751954,
-0.0207178593,
-0.0845461935,
0.0038571192,
0.0267246012,
-0.0323817767,
0.0232341625,
0.0373701043,
0.0172014721,
-0.0120466324,
0.0258738045,
-0.0066650216,
0.0127228508,
-0.0440542847,
-0.0585144758,
-0.0239157695,
-0.0066984878,
0.0534360334,
0.0082108779,
-0.0477983952,
-0.0334300064,
0.0520656779,
-0.0665272102,
0.0053958395,
0.0256197117,
-0.0234815739,
-0.023314435,
-0.0194104817,
-0.0290534794,
0.0245649386,
0.0127030192,
0.0332473367,
0.0221717507,
-0.0234447252,
-0.0342806987,
-0.0680852309,
-0.0509913303,
-0.0117340703,
-0.0085797552,
0.0444705598,
-0.0841931105,
0.0093900999,
0.0210132729,
0.0057217469,
0.0036824881,
-0.0346769579,
0.0124235358,
-0.0499450229,
0.0141612981,
-0.0418187976,
-0.0214200094,
0.0037111836,
0.0142138982,
0.0044272775,
0.0174723342,
-0.028250318,
0.0002133655,
0.0067705074,
0.0154276052,
0.0435603186,
-0.0015940723,
0.0352323838,
-0.0301543213,
0.0091375913,
-0.0476671532,
0.0178284012,
0.0588407516,
-0.0779217631,
0.0315460637,
-0.072130695,
-0.0178236458,
-0.0129499603,
0.0083555179,
-0.056015607,
-0.048033081,
-0.0021795903,
-0.0769573301,
-0.0059153135,
0.006164453,
0.0179907605,
0.0355500244,
0.0360914618,
-0.002296475,
0.0358299613,
-0.0446425788,
-0.0326252468,
-0.0007433174,
-0.031265825,
-0.0070141139,
0.049959261,
-0.0229578745,
0.0218953434,
-0.0146750314,
0.0213854276,
-0.012775328,
-0.0172731988,
-0.0803006589,
0.0125282276,
0.0028984875,
0.0053575034,
-0.039751716,
-0.0436799303,
0.0201512408,
0.0473327711,
0.0356885418,
-0.0383667126,
-0.0347407982,
-0.0271861739,
-0.014447893,
0.00527512,
0.0388201475,
0.0109204091,
0.0063737091,
0.0278117284,
0.0174841322,
-0.0157759283,
-0.0530180447,
-0.04093403,
-0.0241161976,
0.00189602,
-0.009369825,
-0.0462168902,
-0.0274207797,
-0.0499516279,
-0.074870944,
-0.0086508347,
0.0193179902,
0.0083554117,
-0.049944073,
0.0296024438,
0.0014977197,
-0.0034389845,
0.0308770146,
-0.0388883762,
0.0232911929,
0.0287743658,
0.013833968,
-0.0354373157,
0.0114678601,
-0.02754228,
0.0129486164,
0.025935581,
0.030964585,
-0.0081500458,
-0.0304807108,
0.033682093,
-0.0153077235,
-0.0150948763,
0.0127218878,
-0.0019118851,
0.0455635525,
-0.0226029642,
0.0059409919,
0.0628221259,
0.0189187638,
-0.037926428,
0.029504044,
0.0155394152,
0.0199322943,
-0.0090109641,
0.0019866792,
-0.0401761383,
-0.0318619907,
-0.0021251247,
-0.013471067,
-0.0410791785,
-0.0671280473,
-0.0180548634,
-0.0506328084,
0.0620422289,
0.014521935,
-0.0216570273,
-0.0552432239,
-0.0575658083,
0.0142543679,
-0.0481782816,
0.004546334,
-0.0562769808,
-0.0015834123,
0.0176612157,
0.0242205076,
-0.046865318,
-0.0510656349,
0.0339569561,
-0.0532888398,
0.0205164235,
0.0326831527,
0.0344814882,
-0.0374198072,
-0.0307045504,
0.0155798169,
0.0025898572,
0.0194465984,
-0.0193988793,
0.0987300798,
-0.0372156873,
-0.0148958182,
-0.0322951153,
0.0340241641,
-0.0919805765,
-0.0030066387,
0.0126071684,
0.0789696425,
0.0230409969,
-0.0430096723,
-0.0653743297,
-0.0135269305,
0.0705158338,
0.045397833,
0.0283897091,
-0.0492895655,
-0.0174615718,
0.0013287895,
-0.0371567048,
-0.0245908573,
0.0002629061,
0.0601224117,
-0.0284213051,
-0.1301761568,
-0.0038928301,
0.0209295042,
0.0266159847,
-0.0171952993,
-0.0278334208,
-0.0275124703,
0.0008264671,
-0.0267834626,
-0.0397182219,
0.0195714198,
-0.0211003721,
0.0409273133,
-0.0339874588,
-0.0312463455,
0.0407218076,
0.0380534008,
-0.0148938615,
0.0566320047,
-0.0608175099,
-0.0515729971,
-0.0062707807,
0.0223910026,
0.0143283559,
0.0068189884,
0.001955037,
-0.0126914522,
0.0672657117,
0.115676932,
-0.0345631056,
-0.0520940758,
0.0042802496,
-0.0354493298,
0.014513162,
0.0278991554,
-0.0361373909,
0.0581928641,
0.0209718905,
0.0123519227,
-0.0535495952,
0.0127230799,
0.0066585545,
-0.0112145357,
0.0999132544,
0.0066754133,
-0.0744713545,
-0.0303734988,
-0.0068396339,
0.0821509212,
-0.0182777215,
0.0010861887,
0.0276433956,
0.0426969603,
0.0132582327,
-0.0530027822,
0.0458720475,
0.0158297885,
-0.0168374833,
-0.0477954522,
-0.0065379986,
0.0067267586,
0.0335100144,
0.0330647342,
0.0000272796,
0.015489554,
0.0202307533,
0.0188419316,
-0.0217375942,
0.0294569395,
-0.0222937651,
-0.007496404,
0.0581044778,
-0.0310931429,
0.012384329,
-0.0313617885,
-0.0270472672,
-0.037958391,
0.0106374677,
0.0315381885,
-0.0105504785,
0.0121047841,
-0.0347581916,
-0.0225151293,
-0.0221562181,
0.0259745885,
-0.0710255429,
-0.0039430563,
0.0242740288,
-0.0436623283,
-0.0290589985,
0.0550042465,
0.0583455004,
0.0055339038,
0.0537871271,
0.0401314013,
-0.0186055806,
0.0095152324,
0.0480452478,
0.0141399205,
0.0128364209,
-0.0054559563,
0.0233007167,
-0.0178806614,
-0.0280601177,
0.034590926,
-0.0429354645,
0.0112952497,
0.0157099254,
0.0119112926,
0.0036998133,
-0.024360355,
0.0076002958,
-0.0041763228,
-0.0038119061,
-0.01758679,
-0.0349980853,
-0.0205397997,
-6.714038757e-33,
0.0366655104,
-0.0269149095,
-0.0219990518,
-0.0126660401,
0.0350248553,
0.0512745865,
0.0067427689,
-0.0222619213,
0.0183092281,
0.0436515994,
-0.0160073228,
0.0070908363,
0.0011080217,
0.0182509441,
0.0610336475,
-0.0407170989,
0.0340043418,
0.0002911967,
-0.025034843,
0.0531081483,
0.0039883847,
0.0399659164,
-0.0021966002,
-0.1138877273,
-0.0223560445,
-0.0283776559,
0.0178699009,
-0.0063945954,
0.0055877627,
0.0069312188,
-0.0212313477,
0.0996651426,
0.047666043,
-0.0304663777,
-0.0124942493,
0.0399618149,
-0.045630455,
-0.0250472594,
-0.057732977,
-0.0485700816,
-0.0654687509,
-0.0476191901,
0.0492717139,
0.0554227047,
-0.0178447813,
0.0354048163,
0.0570934527,
0.0328514129,
0.0352232754,
-0.0068707098,
0.0099814795,
0.0119673526,
-0.0411022268,
0.0079759667,
-0.030227948,
0.0307311416,
0.0145633211,
0.059784092,
-0.0268859062,
-0.018991936,
0.0214402899,
-0.0309007335,
0.0359974131,
0.0027374052,
-0.0258445963,
0.0441023968,
0.0302950852,
-0.0021147456,
-0.0126532391,
-0.0270067658,
-0.0486212969,
0.0282839537,
0.0428322591,
0.0454025902,
0.0788379312,
-0.0891935825,
-0.072056435,
0.0535081439,
-0.0466449298,
0.0012678361,
-0.0343781114,
-0.0046370579,
0.0012675142,
-0.0014544415,
0.0123229446,
-0.0648635924,
-0.018013142,
0.0312203486,
-0.0012300791,
0.0129096853,
-0.0056199487,
0.019342022,
-0.0176447406,
0.0276076216,
-0.0421318971,
-0.0317472927,
0.0452414081,
0.0062936917,
0.0074955304,
0.0230806116,
-0.0923728719,
-0.012196878,
-0.0097712409,
0.0192183349,
0.009959152,
0.0062931622,
0.0561082959,
0.0273532011,
-0.011929038,
0.0062306318,
-0.0120257195,
0.0366706066,
-0.020688314,
0.0072415574,
0.0076112985,
-0.0031032658,
0.0346267112,
0.0402718894,
0.0062172282,
0.0074931164,
0.0248683207,
-0.004015605,
-0.0478446446,
-0.0366386026,
-0.0091832485,
-0.0164738297,
-0.0109965242,
0.0003514805,
-0.0040858802,
-0.0778304562,
0.0007918303,
-0.0581797138,
2.77e-7,
0.0701583028,
0.0454235747,
0.0036991655,
-0.0436517335,
-0.0090735713,
0.0430643,
0.0014836255,
0.0798161179,
-0.028518049,
-0.053532593,
0.0280549824,
0.0061264331,
-0.029279964,
0.0435846448,
-0.0206310004,
-0.0228232052,
-0.0879837051,
0.0694673881,
-0.0421112254,
0.0039296029,
0.0127438111,
0.0498430207,
0.0711245388,
-0.054566972,
0.0510596633,
-0.0439969301,
0.0576075502,
-0.0398868769,
0.0337830484,
0.0207570456,
0.0451039039,
0.0521813817,
-0.0034850352,
0.0291111842,
-0.0405652262,
-0.0249106083,
-0.0146399839,
0.0046369364,
-0.0229797643,
0.0216560774,
-0.0393011943,
-0.0310645625,
0.0066391127,
-0.0325886533,
0.0474450998,
-0.0838084146,
-0.0231908243,
0.039087873,
-0.0142782824,
0.0072647659,
0.0520242155,
-0.0035766908,
-0.0089681819,
0.00971907,
-0.0057311775,
0.0015119618,
-0.0357317999,
-0.0598364286,
0.022557538,
-0.0394938886,
-0.0114767216,
-0.052978538,
0.0033219254,
-0.0032051008,
-0.0173422191,
-0.0326416828,
0.0272649974,
2.179250814e-34,
0.0365055762,
-0.0219981764,
0.0053517432,
-0.044544898,
-0.0078213727,
0.0162521116,
-0.0431760177,
-0.0369939357,
0.0235515516,
0.0034389754,
0.0035999743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03753v1 | English to Arabic machine translation of mathematical documents | 2023-12-02T21:02:07 | 2023-12-02T21:02:07 | Mustapha Eddahibi, Mohammed Mensouri | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper is about the development of a machine translation system tailored
specifically for LATEX mathematical documents. The system focuses on
translating English LATEX mathematical documents into Arabic LATEX, catering to
the growing demand for multilingual accessibility in scientific and
mathematical literature. With the vast proliferation of LATEX mathematical
documents the need for an efficient and accurate translation system has become
increasingly essential. This paper addresses the necessity for a robust
translation tool that enables seamless communication and comprehension of
complex mathematical content across language barriers. The proposed system
leverages a Transformer model as the core of the translation system, ensuring
enhanced accuracy and fluency in the translated Arabic LATEX documents.
Furthermore, the integration of RyDArab, an Arabic mathematical TEX extension,
along with a rule-based translator for Arabic mathematical expressions,
contributes to the precise rendering of complex mathematical symbols and
equations in the translated output. The paper discusses the architecture,
methodology, of the developed system, highlighting its efficacy in bridging the
language gap in the domain of mathematical documentation | [
-0.0250959769,
0.0326342247,
-0.0314790979,
0.0201130435,
-0.0556466952,
0.0373182483,
0.0578591377,
0.0191217642,
-0.1180953756,
-0.0310177561,
-0.0074897204,
0.0137071544,
0.0597661473,
0.0248095449,
0.0175204426,
-0.0444485135,
-0.0059386068,
-0.0316880867,
-0.0372956879,
-0.0158975478,
0.0114798816,
0.0021695928,
0.0173465703,
-0.0078434451,
-0.0040319483,
-0.021666633,
0.0131757502,
-0.0403853469,
0.0233626124,
0.0406137183,
-0.0272992924,
0.0527199693,
0.0028764533,
0.0275510866,
0.0000021007,
-0.0387427211,
-0.0681386515,
0.036969766,
0.0273578335,
-0.020544203,
0.0452860035,
-0.0951313302,
-0.0331526287,
-0.0468455702,
-0.0430331826,
0.02347406,
0.0339282788,
0.012588229,
0.0319844857,
0.0230009425,
-0.0155273154,
-0.0920365229,
0.0164576005,
0.0159334,
0.036272388,
-0.04948809,
-0.0135051524,
0.0302579384,
0.0032509731,
0.0191991962,
-0.0264275689,
0.0631235838,
0.0134931505,
-0.0786739066,
0.0195019878,
-0.0565961748,
-0.0024959776,
-0.0212949142,
-0.0021088403,
0.0086905267,
0.0022304796,
-0.0197485052,
-0.0002785366,
0.0214584265,
-0.023889685,
0.0569025539,
-0.0861690119,
0.0459276326,
-0.0236613061,
-0.0424581319,
-0.0006154792,
0.0117394738,
-0.0114903133,
0.0071062557,
-0.0561354458,
0.0375029258,
0.0189399272,
-0.0407940634,
-0.0293066707,
0.0007210127,
-0.0359003432,
-0.015296747,
0.1105910614,
0.0256254934,
0.0712765977,
0.0126626054,
-0.0672583878,
-0.1125518307,
-0.0116685536,
-0.0995668843,
0.0143717118,
0.0812974349,
0.0400536023,
0.0366468169,
-0.0344344005,
0.0446441136,
-0.0038816177,
0.0022275606,
-0.0456310175,
0.0351035669,
-0.0135270925,
0.0259952359,
-0.0540965796,
-0.0030607237,
-0.0275966283,
0.0227436498,
-0.0666112378,
0.0206696913,
-0.029445136,
0.0262954626,
0.0338166915,
-0.0640951693,
-0.043777138,
-0.0619170256,
-0.0034286506,
-0.0181268081,
0.019259762,
-0.0301479604,
-0.0570233241,
-0.0485546626,
0.0157980528,
0.0426768474,
0.0139745092,
0.0099427216,
-0.0491078943,
0.0673809126,
0.0205393098,
-0.0114745088,
0.0612096712,
0.0154590569,
0.0390138775,
-0.0098229116,
-0.011196808,
-0.0330102928,
0.0584021248,
0.0457602106,
0.0134747,
-0.0047502792,
0.0097937733,
0.0230048876,
0.0608499609,
0.0563959889,
0.0213771909,
0.0050895335,
0.0692997053,
-0.0074299383,
-0.0336663425,
0.0174693037,
0.0071363752,
-0.0575615168,
0.0118639171,
-0.0228323322,
0.0458282344,
0.0354468264,
-0.0025438063,
-0.0408305116,
-0.0308273863,
-0.0128091397,
0.0418540314,
0.031755276,
-0.0454597101,
0.0189998597,
-0.0430588946,
-0.0013642355,
0.0071826158,
0.0315107889,
0.0300583821,
0.0552403107,
0.0175512228,
0.0527527779,
0.049029354,
-0.0415002815,
-0.0088926544,
0.0355800577,
0.0352077745,
-0.0048750006,
-0.0257087518,
0.0563420989,
0.0165890548,
-0.0353095308,
0.0147034647,
-0.0302686729,
0.0031734651,
-0.0319118053,
0.0894880816,
0.0151022747,
0.0122497492,
0.0397449657,
-0.0398147181,
-0.0109258564,
-0.0222908556,
-0.0270912945,
-0.0306875948,
-0.0212701373,
0.0367988721,
-0.0212259609,
0.0298112743,
-0.0236945301,
-0.0155331623,
0.0369151495,
-0.0051912665,
0.0037407314,
-0.017403109,
-0.045826219,
-0.0375269316,
0.0900768191,
0.036145594,
0.0085380999,
-0.013684391,
0.0548511185,
0.0325537585,
-0.026813738,
0.0045182779,
0.0134027284,
-0.0210310724,
-0.0338876471,
0.0205545798,
0.0201167464,
-0.0128201656,
0.0175024085,
0.0155773219,
0.0359000377,
0.015102366,
-0.0320815146,
-0.0220735185,
0.0242922436,
-0.0029815694,
0.0660212561,
0.0468079112,
-0.0735448822,
0.0183881372,
-0.0112216333,
0.0040739295,
-0.0029978259,
0.0443317555,
-0.0326299593,
0.0217080731,
-0.0160917155,
0.0780567825,
-0.0329945944,
0.0055673309,
-0.0173816066,
-0.0021892083,
0.0074297604,
0.0337798484,
-0.0043765865,
-0.0731500015,
0.0302247033,
0.0406130739,
0.0152179739,
0.0271133948,
-0.0159000698,
0.0248785503,
0.0187974647,
0.0074763987,
0.0327761546,
-0.0254231803,
0.0676136315,
-0.0448056683,
0.0077877869,
0.0466689244,
0.0324746482,
0.0027516556,
0.0175579023,
0.00306631,
-0.0021800492,
0.015574323,
-0.0208528265,
-0.0531914756,
0.0199507065,
-0.0055693197,
-0.0237511694,
-0.0014824659,
-0.0067634583,
0.0006601577,
0.0586613938,
0.0625305027,
-0.0239545926,
-0.0447972007,
-0.0111338636,
-0.0027352734,
-0.0374472402,
0.0013735682,
0.0107821524,
-0.0186405778,
-0.0142635144,
0.0268244687,
0.0265603829,
-0.0045560217,
0.0116945626,
-0.0300874393,
-0.0082359836,
-0.0403856598,
-0.0285932943,
-0.0102345785,
-0.0007609628,
0.0021951988,
-0.0462852046,
0.0098115606,
-0.0012811769,
-0.0214092471,
0.012350372,
-0.0053529195,
0.0050504268,
-0.0442643985,
0.0146947717,
0.0008839628,
0.0159292407,
0.0019874219,
0.078030929,
0.0223237704,
-0.0290191285,
-0.0088160802,
-0.0000952375,
-0.0143623026,
-0.0506269634,
0.0145081338,
-0.0612192154,
-0.0597675517,
-0.0150045836,
0.0126377186,
-0.0563190654,
0.0036095348,
0.0016553325,
0.0171591453,
0.0525747463,
-0.02878673,
-0.0073575089,
0.0016033795,
0.0108331386,
-0.0492235124,
0.0108782668,
0.0133251315,
0.0663953722,
-0.011575833,
-0.0182689503,
0.053241767,
-0.043707367,
-0.0512138158,
0.0373621173,
0.0666350052,
0.0119073531,
-0.0285634976,
-0.0187025964,
-0.0009846642,
-0.0365859345,
0.0111316927,
-0.05037174,
0.0086642774,
-0.0392977037,
0.0021238399,
0.0204660669,
-0.058263015,
-0.0165741704,
-0.0331446379,
-0.0279104151,
0.033291366,
-0.0109205423,
-0.0694474205,
-0.0340470187,
-0.0918737799,
-0.0260563493,
0.0393625312,
0.032992512,
0.0073351464,
-0.0223888755,
-0.0287917498,
-0.0923017114,
-0.0380483828,
-0.0334696583,
0.0180928484,
-0.1207462102,
0.0789035112,
0.0141409719,
0.0230983328,
0.0180979203,
0.0427077226,
0.0441504903,
-0.0285043772,
0.0331456475,
0.0146478927,
-0.0365846083,
-0.0707334876,
-0.0111508882,
0.0013035932,
0.0168554839,
-0.024674885,
0.0125318402,
-0.0288160257,
0.0301436596,
0.0125839571,
0.0334762074,
-0.0320431776,
-0.0927358195,
-0.0063315039,
-0.0771984607,
-0.0012765429,
0.0556123666,
-0.0228043143,
-0.0862145722,
-0.021164285,
0.0519350134,
-0.044900734,
-0.0252887588,
-0.0488989353,
0.0215721,
-0.0216095168,
-0.0426558033,
-0.0129981395,
-0.0550371297,
-0.0038058353,
-0.0158741474,
0.0283391364,
-0.0098378891,
0.0555852763,
-0.0166687593,
-0.0076184268,
-0.0381983109,
-0.0028410605,
-0.0310965758,
-0.0069434638,
-0.0650011227,
-0.0264862683,
0.0036691534,
-0.0543095097,
-0.0139472084,
-0.0663204268,
-0.0093690576,
-0.0628627837,
-0.0304361098,
0.0122811301,
-0.0113679627,
0.0508524515,
0.0450599492,
-0.0247176457,
0.053013891,
0.0292218421,
-0.0294935461,
-0.0556592606,
-0.0049115121,
0.0294156056,
-0.0085163722,
0.0318273269,
-0.0227506086,
-0.0399147011,
-0.0029442904,
-0.0197396427,
-0.0384677574,
-0.0095606754,
0.0267844945,
0.0478578992,
0.0270833448,
-0.0646981969,
-0.0113610597,
0.007842266,
-0.0085811531,
-0.0017471049,
-0.0309383273,
0.0152954832,
0.019981334,
-0.003484888,
-0.0333471671,
0.0151488697,
0.0056527848,
-0.031707909,
-0.0470508598,
-0.0088239247,
-0.0162517317,
-0.0597751252,
0.0090430221,
0.006776657,
-0.0648543164,
-0.0022964212,
-0.0190745313,
0.0284310691,
0.0224789139,
-0.0538908727,
0.0153131699,
-0.0176557451,
0.019028794,
0.0103846034,
0.0340422355,
0.0168233123,
-0.0202101227,
0.0359920822,
-0.0522376969,
0.0447271243,
0.0702111274,
-0.0274764914,
0.0269521624,
0.0121858139,
0.0171759203,
0.0188968647,
-0.0329707004,
-0.019323742,
0.0256631561,
-0.032479085,
0.0142041901,
-0.0126137482,
0.019266177,
0.0277301557,
0.0144731784,
0.0283985715,
-0.0625164956,
0.0075284592,
0.0093012899,
0.0203102585,
0.0238382518,
0.0297503732,
-0.0172586348,
-0.0106973816,
0.0056729978,
0.0439887233,
0.0322667211,
0.0286527649,
-0.0231476333,
-0.006162174,
0.0313037448,
-0.0335548595,
0.0298859011,
-0.0663830638,
-0.0327350833,
-0.016533494,
-0.0172339398,
-0.0222296286,
0.0270404927,
-0.0079567293,
-0.0726008937,
-0.0065329294,
-0.0353004523,
-0.0318647288,
-0.0335050412,
0.0458072163,
0.0213326514,
-0.0131167788,
-0.0232027527,
0.0330103152,
0.1052779853,
0.0001728431,
-0.0226954781,
-0.0178598594,
0.0757362172,
-0.0598172471,
-0.0208321325,
-0.0171479248,
-5.538344573e-33,
0.0035508713,
-0.0183686335,
-0.009787742,
0.0667650625,
0.0044968296,
-0.0463035442,
-0.0066675539,
0.0083733993,
0.0207169522,
0.0061587351,
0.0046424288,
0.0088577066,
0.0296228621,
-0.0384786837,
0.0309699345,
0.0378004275,
0.0347824469,
-0.0225863755,
-0.0076085795,
-0.0168893225,
-0.0127062444,
0.0332138166,
0.0938787237,
-0.0689442605,
0.0187119823,
-0.0217107963,
-0.004274637,
0.0165220071,
0.00759394,
0.031305436,
0.0113232182,
0.0038131094,
-0.0134241935,
-0.0258698724,
-0.0020635051,
0.0160783213,
-0.0432476886,
0.0259977002,
0.0016604054,
0.1066877991,
0.0429768711,
-0.0293743033,
0.0074962862,
-0.0534900501,
-0.0667885467,
0.0203322805,
0.011351319,
-0.0280857068,
-0.0319364145,
-0.0422619097,
-0.0848252997,
0.0236839782,
0.0002461337,
0.0294899419,
0.0641616657,
0.0547438338,
-0.040127378,
-0.0418371558,
-0.0284643322,
0.0105476826,
0.0245115608,
0.0222457517,
0.0446740128,
-0.0455468744,
0.0069787996,
-0.0615838505,
0.0188080724,
-0.0110226823,
0.0344779454,
0.0198816918,
0.0649597794,
-0.0140757281,
0.0579287261,
0.0381437503,
0.0437690951,
0.0077180024,
-0.024673406,
0.0632324815,
-0.0895780995,
0.0790506899,
0.0099900365,
0.0363732688,
-0.0290955957,
-0.0122882193,
0.01451129,
0.0086377664,
0.0064179823,
-0.0159224868,
-0.0273525398,
-0.0101240855,
-0.0118282912,
0.0426363312,
-0.0072039007,
0.0066341292,
-0.0101362988,
-0.0284336973,
0.0349403434,
0.0108311148,
-0.0242731646,
-0.0099265082,
0.0092720557,
-0.0362191759,
-0.0457704142,
0.0188582968,
0.0396142043,
0.0009618099,
-0.0082087023,
0.0494807884,
-0.0367193781,
0.0060225655,
-0.008404566,
-0.0271809753,
0.0833639577,
0.0744300559,
0.0009505973,
0.0272055231,
0.0213463847,
0.0002514487,
0.0200335104,
-0.0153408926,
-0.031771712,
0.0340610221,
-0.0127583984,
0.0330162793,
-0.0378525592,
-0.0127389897,
-0.0352145135,
0.0238488149,
0.0483214743,
-0.0659278706,
-0.0282677952,
-0.0148405917,
2.882e-7,
0.0727434978,
0.0577920191,
0.013935226,
0.023878675,
0.0044666776,
-0.0154821835,
-0.0063622743,
0.0291438773,
0.0358545072,
0.0437379591,
0.0021400654,
-0.0035859502,
0.0288711265,
0.0048652906,
-0.0218809135,
-0.0144949667,
-0.0005244745,
0.0215597097,
-0.0146033075,
0.0167747885,
0.0537584163,
0.0496540256,
-0.0125393774,
0.014670969,
-0.0145076672,
-0.0368800424,
0.0587863363,
-0.0103799086,
0.0377044827,
-0.0045667994,
0.0450293869,
-0.0628584474,
-0.0116899284,
0.0014331879,
0.0029459866,
0.021130275,
0.0750660375,
0.0866704732,
0.0210205149,
0.1137928665,
-0.0000634435,
-0.0479325801,
0.0082240012,
-0.0504726842,
0.0176175367,
-0.0296346135,
-0.0063975444,
0.0002173522,
-0.0610218681,
0.0093433959,
0.0255489424,
-0.0159601178,
0.0276871938,
0.0021048167,
0.059431795,
0.0181498379,
0.0284292605,
0.0259121843,
0.0152252633,
-0.0136216953,
-0.0281165745,
0.0187052116,
-0.0284346472,
-0.0192041881,
0.0200817101,
0.0578539334,
-0.0083405394,
2.553750686e-34,
0.0458857976,
-0.0260293689,
0.0172316208,
0.0441361628,
0.0066705919,
0.0022855147,
-0.0559496395,
0.0311751291,
-0.0184292253,
-0.0393967405,
-0.001751624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03752v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03752v2 | Automatic Scoring of Students' Science Writing Using Hybrid Neural Network | 2023-12-02T20:36:13 | 2023-12-26T00:58:22 | Ehsan Latif, Xiaoming Zhai | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study explores the efficacy of a multi-perspective hybrid neural network
(HNN) for scoring student responses in science education with an analytic
rubric. We compared the accuracy of the HNN model with four ML approaches
(BERT, AACR, Naive Bayes, and Logistic Regression). The results have shown that
HHN achieved 8%, 3%, 1%, and 0.12% higher accuracy than Naive Bayes, Logistic
Regression, AACR, and BERT, respectively, for five scoring aspects (p<0.001).
The overall HNN's perceived accuracy (M = 96.23%, SD = 1.45%) is comparable to
the (training and inference) expensive BERT model's accuracy (M = 96.12%, SD =
1.52%). We also have observed that HNN is x2 more efficient in training and
inferencing than BERT and has comparable efficiency to the lightweight but less
accurate Naive Bayes model. Our study confirmed the accuracy and efficiency of
using HNN to score students' science writing automatically. | [
0.0122224903,
-0.0293174647,
-0.0108521031,
-0.0215124115,
-0.0393424667,
-0.0105468044,
0.0415033996,
-0.0099047022,
0.0272103306,
-0.0783348158,
-0.0429696813,
-0.0286125001,
0.0152524514,
0.0361291394,
0.0090244496,
-0.0224452931,
0.0042804815,
0.0321509354,
0.0453323759,
0.0160951335,
-0.0091539305,
-0.0076940139,
-0.0584498085,
0.0366555527,
0.0062471209,
-0.0344952159,
0.0248882622,
-0.0281486884,
0.0400044918,
-0.0121988682,
0.0314469039,
0.0649909005,
0.0123162242,
0.0554192178,
0.0000020998,
-0.0524188057,
-0.0085194316,
0.0035976537,
0.0151888765,
0.033108592,
0.0215249509,
0.0517160594,
-0.0034157445,
0.0068319528,
-0.0581730306,
-0.0112497816,
0.0633331463,
0.0253718048,
0.0102015017,
0.0158408023,
0.011330151,
-0.0356506258,
0.0790457502,
0.0314074159,
0.0418401025,
0.0523234867,
0.0271584969,
0.0507698096,
-0.009747697,
0.0070491699,
-0.0256497655,
0.0769865215,
0.0217443164,
-0.0520519279,
0.0412355103,
0.028578721,
-0.0117175151,
0.0307850987,
0.0256264638,
0.0192186031,
-0.0225341208,
-0.0129995663,
-0.0200396869,
-0.0377056561,
-0.0163033232,
0.0249864068,
-0.0815502703,
0.0121293766,
-0.0233412292,
-0.0259253699,
0.0128883086,
0.0065042218,
-0.0006178102,
0.0347387753,
0.029338384,
0.0241514444,
0.0046281549,
-0.0380754657,
-0.0126743177,
0.0405431315,
0.0527350605,
-0.0190256238,
0.0282700229,
0.0429687537,
0.0002670517,
0.0256194156,
-0.015987061,
-0.0538741685,
0.0241751578,
-0.0514929183,
0.0585651509,
0.038914986,
0.0034438737,
-0.0086628022,
-0.0310450364,
0.0790045038,
0.0387186781,
0.0031862729,
0.0081819594,
0.0439769961,
-0.0667813793,
-0.0384349562,
0.0411200896,
0.0290761702,
0.0667767748,
-0.0063900179,
-0.0959231481,
-0.0576267503,
-0.0146615738,
-0.0034413016,
0.0168378782,
0.0369588435,
-0.0000045471,
0.0746463165,
-0.0177798476,
0.0639826059,
-0.004827104,
0.0078535192,
-0.002814725,
0.0171445906,
0.0095090196,
0.0195479747,
0.0097184535,
0.0073240432,
0.0056519909,
0.0047735563,
-0.0091397529,
-0.0171996914,
-0.0108987875,
-0.0623487085,
0.0066614733,
-0.0486911647,
0.0318229608,
-0.0452198349,
0.0170782302,
0.0303339735,
-0.0181896836,
-0.0172508582,
-0.0010339528,
0.0077211331,
0.0353549048,
0.0019378883,
-0.0218746234,
-0.0299657304,
0.0414601341,
0.0112495627,
-0.0161298905,
0.0065446878,
0.0596234985,
-0.0062982687,
-0.0091814548,
-0.0350251347,
0.0153672006,
-0.0074630445,
-0.0094431099,
-0.0524203405,
-0.0179561507,
-0.0308179054,
-0.0072166957,
0.0704112053,
-0.0669249073,
-0.0137551958,
0.008414004,
0.0636512935,
0.0455497056,
0.0386999026,
0.0378377698,
0.0335798338,
0.0151264509,
-0.0092331991,
0.0764472112,
0.0290998369,
-0.01044905,
0.0708045289,
-0.0416203812,
0.0028024707,
0.0020729487,
-0.0025834371,
0.0091715539,
-0.0893969387,
-0.0464325845,
0.0261094104,
-0.0355670713,
0.0070589362,
0.0566814393,
-0.0412370712,
-0.0095479181,
0.0144521641,
0.0029480977,
-0.0641863644,
0.0693013743,
-0.0040942011,
0.0435525365,
0.0262139849,
0.0408236757,
-0.0589169934,
-0.0610901788,
-0.0159007851,
-0.0502138212,
0.0187241174,
0.0297795441,
-0.0258673225,
-0.0121573936,
-0.0541658439,
-0.046976842,
-0.0243826602,
0.0246572569,
0.0019832202,
-0.0231986791,
0.0374891087,
0.0100282691,
-0.0080937231,
-0.0373408571,
0.02245887,
-0.0618705302,
-0.0090808589,
-0.0249363501,
-0.0370894708,
0.0193204749,
0.0354135856,
-0.0112903221,
0.0366953909,
0.0153302411,
-0.0006275658,
-0.0215262622,
-0.0679915175,
-0.0508286916,
-0.0431745313,
0.0579090342,
-0.0512226224,
0.0244451985,
0.0416476019,
0.0034131238,
-0.0504236892,
-0.0146220718,
-0.0151606938,
-0.0118187377,
-0.000051459,
-0.000252727,
-0.0585576259,
-0.0524407141,
-0.0371458679,
0.0047365283,
0.0266607814,
0.1065367013,
-0.038523037,
-0.0500808097,
0.0330368876,
-0.0126969777,
-0.0602167957,
-0.0401365235,
0.0075302152,
0.0100357486,
-0.0129234204,
-0.0195089001,
-0.067691125,
0.0088685174,
-0.0614000075,
-0.0181289706,
0.0295626596,
-0.0072176037,
0.0205471888,
-0.0441136807,
0.0278189145,
0.042095501,
-0.0634935573,
-0.0087646414,
-0.010298484,
-0.021143768,
0.0326489247,
-0.0041573807,
0.0103643257,
-0.0462642759,
-0.0370705426,
-0.0877396464,
0.0423864387,
0.123285301,
-0.0251004621,
-0.04228976,
0.0026180481,
-0.0203626752,
-0.0273516942,
0.0198507886,
-0.038669847,
0.0334034078,
-0.0155508714,
-0.013583282,
0.078744784,
0.0266058408,
-0.0455305427,
0.0582497679,
-0.0110847913,
-0.0559679754,
-0.0170161575,
-0.0147909811,
0.0986793563,
0.0318462849,
-0.0377846956,
-0.024603527,
0.0073717567,
0.0221695155,
-0.0462975502,
0.0092038233,
0.0617780872,
-0.0399856046,
0.0054879328,
-0.0302297473,
-0.0215909369,
0.0074706771,
0.0239180215,
0.045393981,
-0.0011010652,
0.0838906392,
-0.0221915822,
0.0242360719,
-0.0770858675,
0.0375172868,
-0.0138627803,
-0.0047057257,
-0.0007488155,
-0.0074827289,
0.0055361111,
0.0241751801,
-0.0334128886,
0.0050086454,
0.0202663485,
-0.0071652504,
0.0144489855,
-0.033248134,
-0.0173467677,
-0.0179130416,
0.0161823593,
-0.015440708,
0.0263845567,
0.0121684689,
0.0414301641,
-0.0161380861,
-0.0386935398,
-0.0222808607,
0.0129052708,
0.0523265153,
0.0263162777,
-0.098688975,
0.0030581059,
-0.0095817856,
0.0180873703,
-0.0052185198,
-0.0555591136,
0.0083305342,
-0.0386860557,
-0.0032640698,
0.0308349635,
0.0068274103,
0.0458407141,
-0.022802446,
-0.0253217015,
0.0198073667,
-0.0070426501,
0.0061628483,
0.0044398308,
0.0208353065,
-0.0655819848,
0.0081017464,
0.0941708907,
0.0137288803,
-0.0252157599,
-0.0589244254,
-0.010720619,
-0.0639035255,
-0.0132270874,
0.0433935337,
-0.0037066748,
0.006440918,
-0.0362521447,
0.0538068153,
-0.0045250757,
-0.0589648895,
-0.0030718467,
-0.0370745026,
0.0071368841,
0.0197933968,
-0.0701729208,
-0.0208273157,
-0.0180077311,
-0.0136180045,
-0.0021952046,
-0.0404317789,
-0.0249619,
0.0370519049,
0.0226075388,
0.0275657717,
-0.0133590279,
-0.0324815959,
0.0104930662,
-0.0306903012,
0.0115741519,
0.0186487976,
0.0436955392,
-0.0480005555,
-0.0562494211,
0.0284499396,
0.0352529585,
0.0020449841,
-0.0144857625,
0.0264528338,
0.0132529996,
0.0247369874,
-0.029563399,
0.0193820037,
-0.0146089876,
0.0156545136,
0.01768356,
0.1049430817,
-0.0044875983,
-0.0079419566,
-0.0676567033,
0.0267347917,
0.0018373056,
0.0350628234,
0.0459545776,
-0.0499397069,
0.0051496355,
-0.0277095623,
0.0089191543,
-0.0323038176,
0.0121261775,
0.0036365008,
-0.0417088792,
-0.0308975205,
-0.0318740085,
-0.0234652124,
0.0677105412,
0.0345989875,
0.0349844322,
0.0277002081,
0.0408930108,
-0.0006537884,
-0.0370912813,
0.0221102312,
0.0387807339,
0.0060388353,
-0.0283771101,
-0.0023002543,
0.0526189953,
-0.0162826236,
-0.0172263198,
-0.0397056341,
0.0214823447,
-0.0117601641,
0.0013139413,
0.0559341982,
0.0115634101,
-0.0560187437,
0.0193085503,
-0.0785822198,
-0.004357948,
0.0136332773,
0.0241498854,
-0.0044258186,
-0.0195142813,
-0.0130992774,
0.0029011485,
-0.0463462286,
0.00338305,
-0.015974747,
0.0358209088,
0.0382640697,
-0.0043810154,
-0.0074538891,
-0.0108014261,
0.0487397201,
0.0829060823,
-0.012192864,
-0.0279306564,
-0.0486022159,
0.0053655747,
-0.0080650188,
-0.0282218531,
-0.0152591793,
0.0045418777,
0.0275935605,
0.0474369824,
-0.0218553059,
0.0139028123,
-0.0393330865,
0.0153723713,
-0.05456613,
0.0477773212,
0.0023747869,
0.0402593352,
0.0313664898,
-0.0177811608,
-0.0898196697,
-0.0338449813,
0.0033895541,
0.0191074833,
0.0001867465,
0.0389855877,
0.0344330035,
0.0361606143,
0.0023183255,
0.0073442594,
-0.0486582667,
0.028710695,
-0.061374329,
0.0460733734,
0.0121812886,
0.0336333811,
-0.0000954034,
-0.0059967539,
-0.0061991056,
-0.0374593996,
0.0167586897,
0.0178693384,
-0.003038293,
0.0685785562,
-0.0006664016,
0.0336491726,
-0.0604578778,
0.0221526176,
-0.0200785678,
0.0080696307,
-0.0255903918,
-0.043075338,
-0.011711441,
0.0162621178,
0.0290779155,
0.0431737639,
0.0080514587,
-0.0389976874,
-0.0347603224,
-0.0173409749,
0.0451499932,
0.0606889017,
0.0030599602,
-0.0156172095,
0.021055093,
0.0389025249,
-0.0375586562,
-0.0334004387,
-0.0039269384,
0.0495684855,
-0.00664138,
-0.0281072315,
-0.0076704174,
-5.525078017e-33,
-0.0098362816,
-0.0553141423,
-0.006311791,
0.025900675,
0.0084246965,
0.0154605415,
-0.036751017,
0.0234660935,
0.0006091569,
0.0229669791,
0.0184240043,
0.0088498238,
0.0012915566,
0.0364199467,
0.0397661328,
0.0231471993,
0.0051739658,
-0.0066076359,
-0.0092357872,
-0.0175906718,
0.0313427262,
0.0125923399,
0.0970016271,
-0.0746534169,
0.033693064,
-0.0024404845,
0.024356503,
-0.0225688424,
-0.0918010473,
0.0055259438,
-0.0028071832,
0.0453619137,
0.021917792,
-0.0370417498,
-0.0026980194,
0.0014478454,
0.0041883257,
-0.075540334,
-0.0007704806,
-0.004624635,
-0.0283749048,
-0.007898123,
0.0578027405,
0.0130676813,
-0.0705368817,
-0.0285040662,
0.083202213,
0.0015084669,
-0.003244078,
-0.1025645137,
-0.0451363735,
-0.0016528881,
0.0090531288,
-0.000005478,
-0.0299682915,
0.0525711775,
-0.0015842989,
0.0028485167,
-0.0422203876,
0.0421062186,
0.0481094271,
0.0229080394,
0.0223354809,
0.0563431047,
-0.0098044667,
0.0463888459,
0.0573397391,
-0.0030526516,
-0.0138775269,
-0.0473855808,
0.0471012592,
-0.0555811003,
0.1623753309,
0.0283512454,
0.0191410817,
0.0248804744,
-0.0806959048,
0.0513527915,
0.0856667235,
-0.039147418,
0.0167991687,
-0.0600554869,
-0.0014555505,
-0.038567327,
-0.0344268195,
-0.0049897414,
-0.0144454064,
-0.0145308217,
0.0130408099,
-0.1019827127,
0.0009382618,
0.0014851989,
0.0061570597,
-0.0369846784,
-0.0201064255,
0.0011226155,
0.0105470857,
0.0617942438,
-0.0113738375,
0.0118517829,
-0.0476539321,
0.0226545185,
-0.0118431067,
0.0021594458,
0.014427864,
0.0071385694,
0.0222878437,
-0.0061079869,
0.0385526419,
-0.0234707929,
-0.0208950602,
-0.0659657419,
0.076598905,
0.0264839884,
-0.0182319432,
-0.0043661031,
0.006123676,
0.0478200987,
0.0328723602,
0.0096269753,
0.0103379814,
-0.0206236765,
-0.0003353305,
0.0076891789,
-0.000694364,
-0.024006702,
-0.0221472029,
0.0059980396,
-0.0431878641,
-0.0537713133,
0.0066966061,
0.0119865919,
2.687e-7,
0.0779796094,
0.0474776812,
-0.0352256484,
-0.0460853875,
0.0051539699,
0.0209120885,
-0.0366398469,
-0.0238372218,
0.0494266376,
0.0397037789,
-0.0159076788,
-0.0478119999,
-0.0007079334,
0.0316776372,
-0.0846542567,
-0.0931100398,
-0.0096963644,
-0.0113159139,
-0.0129284505,
0.0597700663,
0.0627966672,
-0.0351060592,
0.0229216162,
-0.0299899038,
-0.0153795052,
-0.0158806015,
0.0313315094,
0.0204465128,
0.0123925982,
0.0319654904,
0.0107010817,
-0.0105460854,
0.0252241101,
0.0387230814,
-0.0000707532,
-0.002161121,
0.0203892924,
-0.00864725,
-0.0012868695,
-0.0259677824,
0.0808945373,
0.0275539197,
0.0212457981,
-0.0813809335,
0.0191513095,
-0.0326587297,
-0.0063495915,
0.0415759012,
0.0141181257,
0.0007617703,
0.0178995952,
-0.0281500034,
0.0110791968,
-0.019172363,
-0.0191798955,
-0.0299834367,
-0.0129127586,
-0.0040710876,
-0.0275499206,
-0.0073712636,
-0.0209134724,
-0.0495430306,
-0.0157794934,
-0.0495795608,
0.022745816,
-0.0622087792,
-0.0206006244,
2.371919159e-34,
0.0154067343,
-0.0348600522,
0.0365029797,
-0.0287703853,
-0.0346391387,
0.0176737159,
0.023265576,
0.0040646074,
0.0224845298,
-0.0321853049,
-0.0433983319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01221v1 | Enabling Quantum Natural Language Processing for Hindi Language | 2023-12-02T20:19:11 | 2023-12-02T20:19:11 | Naman Srivastava, Gaurang Belekar, Sunil Saumya, Aswath Babu H | cs.CL | cs.CL | Quantum Natural Language Processing (QNLP) is taking huge leaps in solving
the shortcomings of classical Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques and
moving towards a more "Explainable" NLP system. The current literature around
QNLP focuses primarily on implementing QNLP techniques in sentences in the
English language. In this paper, we propose to enable the QNLP approach to
HINDI, which is the third most spoken language in South Asia. We present the
process of building the parameterized quantum circuits required to undertake
QNLP on Hindi sentences. We use the pregroup representation of Hindi and the
DisCoCat framework to draw sentence diagrams. Later, we translate these
diagrams to Parameterised Quantum Circuits based on Instantaneous Quantum
Polynomial (IQP) style ansatz. Using these parameterized quantum circuits
allows one to train grammar and topic-aware sentence classifiers for the Hindi
Language. | [
0.0165800955,
0.0471749753,
-0.0354196578,
0.0530884489,
-0.0452846177,
-0.0022327262,
-0.0071164207,
0.0194590762,
0.0433889478,
-0.0461679809,
0.0030355391,
-0.0236257054,
-0.0149612306,
0.0648590401,
-0.0008744559,
-0.058065962,
0.0620023459,
-0.0030753748,
-0.0423627421,
-0.0245051794,
0.023474779,
-0.0105816899,
-0.0395414121,
0.0285985414,
0.0029523792,
-0.0195789244,
-0.0199610554,
-0.0135097066,
-0.0075208573,
-0.0166475698,
-0.0483826771,
0.0668826625,
-0.0268722549,
-0.0277906824,
0.0000013717,
-0.0357349515,
-0.0022902326,
-0.026523022,
0.0069952761,
0.0183847696,
-0.0216722023,
-0.0030036937,
-0.0159723889,
0.0186018515,
-0.016478546,
0.0704713911,
0.0874436274,
0.0430415832,
0.0671645552,
0.0883856639,
-0.011670961,
-0.0690955967,
0.027336508,
0.0447141565,
-0.0274581034,
-0.0266966037,
0.0117577398,
-0.0164025761,
0.0505891927,
-0.0531808771,
-0.0463806875,
-0.0075484677,
0.0388892628,
-0.0307969525,
0.0152076734,
-0.0120698819,
0.0033078664,
0.021164313,
-0.0478214249,
0.069535844,
-0.0123513518,
-0.0259030871,
0.022685973,
0.0211290829,
-0.0325161777,
-0.0203830265,
0.0017438742,
0.0205336139,
-0.027268013,
0.0569796637,
0.0553995073,
-0.0156110125,
-0.0085921455,
-0.0154622346,
0.0392343886,
0.0818289742,
0.0427684225,
-0.0075852755,
-0.0352918655,
-0.0290895402,
-0.0477410145,
-0.0091105355,
0.0187150631,
-0.0016911163,
-0.0221940279,
0.0114468494,
-0.0147735383,
0.0120071014,
-0.0139909629,
-0.0332863182,
-0.0027918529,
0.0740208477,
0.0296961647,
-0.0017666455,
0.0348871946,
0.0562207177,
0.0164692923,
0.0038330827,
-0.0558480583,
0.0140369143,
-0.0626311079,
-0.03932992,
-0.0089981901,
0.0499230847,
-0.0411948636,
-0.0545274056,
-0.1122170612,
0.0216064975,
0.0143852094,
-0.0427760147,
0.0117014674,
0.0213892516,
-0.0041760583,
0.0056997179,
-0.0021870637,
0.0584497042,
-0.0479868576,
-0.0366512313,
-0.0573193692,
-0.0762197152,
-0.0150092291,
0.0388500951,
0.018211931,
-0.0249396618,
-0.0584891774,
0.0640809014,
0.0317614228,
-0.0493366085,
0.0098760324,
0.0371049754,
-0.0214791875,
-0.016239699,
0.019354688,
-0.0199067798,
0.0121175917,
0.0043053958,
0.0132098338,
-0.0166520718,
0.0286854375,
0.0150715727,
0.0210190155,
0.0556785762,
-0.0225445181,
-0.0278197601,
-0.0271964818,
-0.0085655395,
0.1124781072,
0.022348024,
0.0087664202,
-0.0303364564,
0.0153596653,
-0.0532464497,
0.0463162214,
-0.0252990779,
-0.0216754228,
-0.0337014832,
-0.0827805176,
-0.0037379505,
-0.0682529658,
0.0151965916,
-0.0197194647,
0.0506939702,
-0.0254286993,
0.0360556729,
-0.0242562648,
0.062698938,
0.0651001185,
0.0660012811,
-0.0108422497,
0.0282472353,
-0.0023325428,
0.0131384712,
-0.0248828083,
0.0728149563,
-0.0685692132,
-0.0066413241,
-0.0126434183,
-0.0510293879,
-0.0116499318,
-0.0647195578,
-0.0222948249,
-0.0077703218,
0.0331283547,
-0.067582719,
0.0312085599,
0.0346418172,
-0.0492476188,
-0.0179888904,
0.0198959485,
-0.0348636918,
0.0358561501,
-0.0506691225,
0.0222447049,
0.0792574733,
0.0017975002,
-0.0525340885,
0.0531719811,
0.0435809977,
-0.0645636991,
0.0717084035,
0.0088027762,
-0.0050924765,
-0.0081286486,
0.00065025,
0.0037251837,
-0.0253607165,
-0.0140861524,
0.0065638726,
-0.0098667778,
-0.0066260812,
-0.01803701,
0.0373965353,
0.0001769192,
0.0236450601,
0.0423880406,
-0.042833358,
0.0102098519,
0.0037510134,
0.0746145844,
0.0220837537,
-0.0176669024,
0.0510529801,
0.0036425267,
-0.0241533499,
-0.0472879894,
-0.0206436776,
0.002940509,
-0.0647901446,
0.0241839252,
-0.0820972845,
0.0481939353,
0.0280544199,
-0.0139432671,
-0.0582859628,
0.0916516632,
-0.00227192,
0.0236777943,
-0.0251412522,
-0.0090559609,
0.0269528739,
0.0413446948,
-0.0362448357,
0.0599690787,
0.0366995148,
0.0435542911,
-0.0077240411,
-0.0315577313,
-0.0071208775,
-0.0446111076,
-0.0183610003,
0.013206562,
0.0354786739,
0.0372397266,
0.0383900627,
-0.0200405158,
-0.0122237727,
-0.0053069307,
-0.0727278367,
0.0140684154,
-0.0010950547,
0.0305014551,
0.0310898647,
0.0123777073,
0.0049320334,
-0.0238559954,
-0.0241117366,
-0.0388072431,
0.0268886425,
-0.0148710134,
0.0286464859,
-0.0269208755,
-0.0369418971,
-0.0129101137,
-0.0325897671,
-0.0500736572,
0.0427241772,
-0.019629037,
-0.0602474697,
-0.0471924953,
-0.0182829238,
-0.0126241017,
-0.009668828,
0.0137614245,
-0.0678450018,
-0.0010668106,
-0.0086605083,
0.007492187,
0.0197652932,
0.0117618088,
0.0281408336,
0.0263977237,
-0.0078356043,
0.0507317074,
0.0219342336,
-0.0498816893,
0.0503502339,
-0.0474284291,
0.0039175199,
0.0345611461,
0.0604348481,
0.032465063,
0.0122083193,
-0.0226020571,
0.0291760974,
-0.0339256823,
0.0295999963,
-0.0566902421,
-0.0279383119,
-0.0298506264,
0.048516497,
0.0078943139,
-0.0098806489,
0.059304703,
-0.010077958,
-0.0018614394,
-0.052189067,
0.0161930304,
-0.0254842862,
0.0709907562,
0.0090566771,
0.0262243468,
-0.0604212098,
-0.0115210423,
-0.0092493556,
0.0042138277,
-0.0112200212,
0.00367554,
-0.0549855828,
-0.0279648826,
0.0272855107,
-0.0194358826,
0.0268705711,
-0.0095414519,
0.0013383097,
-0.0335884616,
0.0096664764,
-0.0197820608,
-0.0187160615,
0.0730772614,
0.0938701406,
-0.004949112,
-0.0353771634,
-0.0432011113,
0.0248963516,
-0.0224726498,
0.0052756155,
0.0282100141,
-0.0156012075,
0.050822746,
0.008371288,
0.0581173114,
0.0011479325,
0.024026908,
0.0463106409,
0.0195114873,
0.0032160596,
0.0071611814,
-0.0249980837,
-0.0088615725,
0.0338899046,
-0.0071274098,
-0.0028667788,
0.0152887823,
0.0641565695,
0.0509272404,
0.0559395105,
0.0325394012,
0.0190876946,
-0.0696258023,
-0.0053313179,
0.0479550734,
-0.1306988746,
-0.0210617296,
-0.01706638,
-0.0006269795,
0.0220277552,
0.0016235787,
-0.0439228229,
-0.0327176414,
-0.016174674,
0.0319912583,
0.0228569023,
-0.0495562404,
0.0122453729,
-0.0151897827,
0.0130899986,
0.0203069001,
0.0601736009,
-0.0181223191,
-0.0138897598,
0.0123983193,
-0.0083607808,
0.0023710104,
0.0043889345,
0.0425964408,
-0.0178438928,
0.0181154013,
0.0318493247,
-0.0228732899,
-0.0372390822,
-0.0485064536,
-0.0943354964,
0.0019203855,
-0.0190075282,
-0.0247074384,
0.0129934791,
-0.0319999866,
-0.0534774587,
0.0287295971,
-0.0531445518,
-0.03646788,
-0.0014774679,
0.0146737117,
-0.066578418,
-0.04608877,
0.0025505391,
0.0150627261,
-0.0375657193,
0.0214219727,
-0.0143131679,
-0.030962145,
-0.0795457736,
-0.0285675265,
-0.0193756223,
-0.043222595,
-0.0892152414,
-0.0277109835,
-0.0417741872,
-0.0802959204,
-0.0670235679,
-0.006841355,
-0.0285674501,
0.019886747,
0.0231219642,
0.0188708249,
0.0723376274,
-0.0153295761,
0.0278803222,
-0.0115399482,
-0.0011276414,
-0.0103923474,
-0.0412977561,
-0.0272070039,
0.0030755177,
-0.0111905104,
-0.0304805953,
-0.0411161222,
0.0235291515,
-0.040077731,
0.0306161251,
-0.0020903375,
0.0136820925,
-0.0383864641,
-0.0052797659,
-0.0496295989,
-0.0151767153,
0.0315334722,
0.014522369,
0.0050570704,
0.0333288498,
0.0369170606,
-0.0007406887,
0.0200669318,
0.016244553,
0.0278964471,
-0.0209609773,
0.0574085079,
-0.0761847496,
-0.0386181884,
0.0220810883,
0.0089302026,
0.0382856764,
0.0130944289,
0.0315312929,
-0.0171275735,
0.0037655151,
-0.0431670658,
-0.0085025057,
-0.0482773818,
-0.0082974201,
0.0112621766,
0.0139236236,
-0.0023572193,
-0.0367089324,
-0.0069229668,
-0.0086773718,
0.0254423451,
0.0493020564,
0.0303883851,
0.0265810359,
-0.0266227052,
-0.008998408,
-0.0060943165,
0.0345420055,
0.0203321632,
0.043204248,
-0.0218245927,
0.0416862927,
0.0249465071,
-0.0065216939,
-0.0149288829,
0.0009532336,
-0.0331748612,
-0.0144279404,
0.0201168321,
0.0582089573,
0.060644947,
0.0392833389,
0.0144322254,
-0.0562785007,
0.0057886327,
0.0238618851,
0.099238947,
0.0374130756,
0.0043135495,
0.04888542,
0.0236068964,
-0.0447500497,
-0.0572029948,
0.0185435917,
0.0189783406,
-0.0118126953,
0.0421710052,
-0.0286655873,
-0.0693213493,
-0.0289470181,
-0.0472482443,
0.031577684,
0.0132544227,
0.0379925817,
-0.0449431427,
-0.0119214486,
0.0240242146,
-0.0170827825,
-0.0067894114,
-0.0719972476,
0.0680702254,
-0.0029847049,
0.013819539,
-0.0740660727,
-0.0320971832,
-0.0249724258,
0.0203401204,
-0.0070118508,
0.0184520856,
-5.233357053e-33,
-0.0589756221,
-0.0151117388,
-0.0058003147,
0.0172051154,
0.0294293817,
-0.0009251618,
-0.02061674,
-0.0068905437,
0.0405906476,
-0.0382142328,
0.0134005351,
0.0401464514,
0.0171364378,
-0.0096742399,
-0.006263542,
-0.0103042247,
0.0568957068,
0.0497013777,
0.0367178768,
-0.0016818296,
0.0297437496,
0.0131206373,
0.1155279949,
0.0153610809,
0.0091044297,
-0.005984359,
0.0038634485,
0.0398169272,
-0.0067727393,
-0.0173647832,
-0.0787722617,
0.0214713197,
-0.0098296581,
0.0032152981,
0.0292519145,
0.0108710704,
-0.0371126197,
-0.0381420106,
0.0512457602,
0.034098465,
-0.0115148332,
-0.0141688054,
0.031066766,
0.0043097581,
-0.0322293341,
0.0515766814,
0.0156405419,
0.0184601136,
0.003615421,
-0.0132756792,
-0.0319745205,
0.019939106,
-0.0329056792,
0.0337582044,
0.0040167593,
-0.0221714079,
-0.0384111553,
-0.0631843805,
-0.0300937556,
0.0006589118,
0.0638611615,
0.0473927595,
0.0112500684,
-0.0000196866,
0.0390855297,
0.0327574052,
0.0549404733,
-0.0671150684,
0.0030494963,
0.0315329283,
-0.003843673,
0.0234281197,
0.0353576653,
0.022097446,
0.0717111528,
-0.0441060029,
-0.060515523,
-0.0531879999,
0.0538769998,
0.0562047511,
0.014390843,
0.0081206625,
-0.0278803892,
-0.0644486248,
0.054012306,
0.0135841584,
-0.0233321413,
-0.0316100754,
0.0045483927,
-0.0288630296,
-0.0542591549,
0.0074680615,
0.0237872619,
-0.0336158723,
0.011856731,
0.0157395806,
0.0048044608,
0.0095514292,
0.0149369445,
-0.0106774522,
-0.0243918374,
-0.0372209288,
0.0055455095,
-0.0354083218,
0.0149566391,
-0.0121334288,
-0.0118590714,
0.0177452024,
-0.0410944372,
0.0303694997,
-0.0262954775,
-0.0093092434,
0.0091408063,
0.0346133225,
-0.0040800381,
0.0673015043,
-0.0207186975,
0.0199067574,
0.021138221,
0.0402275808,
-0.0041253865,
-0.0110292584,
-0.0009261516,
0.0639829636,
-0.0132691516,
-0.0453750864,
-0.0579432994,
0.0378899537,
-0.0086749392,
-0.0910506546,
-0.0202221591,
0.0281156227,
2.354e-7,
0.0479063131,
0.0351294577,
0.0412595719,
-0.0048441449,
0.0357996114,
-0.0278258193,
0.0074243429,
0.0072362758,
-0.0022087994,
0.0672892854,
0.020223897,
0.0155701078,
-0.0160950217,
0.0255521126,
-0.0948292762,
0.020984048,
-0.0745576918,
-0.0225143414,
-0.0509853326,
0.0619965829,
0.0842504576,
0.0479118191,
0.0319081619,
0.0214227885,
-0.0052279583,
-0.0161534324,
0.0346717574,
0.0606565028,
-0.0050288476,
0.0067441803,
-0.016802378,
-0.0066090575,
0.0116609074,
0.0039566141,
0.0368778296,
0.0471385606,
-0.0185606573,
0.0128771979,
-0.0248232055,
-0.0319824181,
-0.0058886851,
0.0021489351,
-0.0003459849,
0.03460446,
0.0627948195,
-0.0078081386,
-0.0351783112,
-0.015310403,
-0.0467254072,
-0.0187367387,
0.0222968087,
0.0055422252,
-0.0125208134,
-0.0123044793,
0.0060127028,
-0.0532910265,
0.0196732394,
-0.0236849971,
-0.0220960807,
0.0385809913,
0.0168418512,
-0.0141395908,
-0.0217921734,
-0.0356090516,
0.0223368257,
-0.0436260216,
-0.0301993061,
2.16716664e-34,
0.0485297069,
0.0273415726,
0.0394117199,
0.0029644668,
0.0378695764,
0.0134505276,
0.0015087366,
-0.002513851,
0.0430190824,
-0.0699149743,
-0.0454756096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01217v1 | Understanding Opinions Towards Climate Change on Social Media | 2023-12-02T20:02:34 | 2023-12-02T20:02:34 | Yashaswi Pupneja, Joseph Zou, Sacha Lévy, Shenyang Huang | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Social media platforms such as Twitter (now known as X) have revolutionized
how the public engage with important societal and political topics. Recently,
climate change discussions on social media became a catalyst for political
polarization and the spreading of misinformation. In this work, we aim to
understand how real world events influence the opinions of individuals towards
climate change related topics on social media. To this end, we extracted and
analyzed a dataset of 13.6 millions tweets sent by 3.6 million users from 2006
to 2019. Then, we construct a temporal graph from the user-user mentions
network and utilize the Louvain community detection algorithm to analyze the
changes in community structure around Conference of the Parties on Climate
Change~(COP) events. Next, we also apply tools from the Natural Language
Processing literature to perform sentiment analysis and topic modeling on the
tweets. Our work acts as a first step towards understanding the evolution of
pro-climate change communities around COP events. Answering these questions
helps us understand how to raise people's awareness towards climate change thus
hopefully calling on more individuals to join the collaborative effort in
slowing down climate change. | [
0.0193484519,
0.0747212619,
-0.0088103553,
0.0532349758,
-0.0208840724,
-0.0229216497,
-0.0126288654,
-0.0085514486,
0.0358891971,
-0.0261685699,
0.0500240102,
0.0291962381,
-0.0250740256,
0.0546259098,
0.0033947933,
-0.02701132,
0.0445213541,
0.0565652698,
0.0324778184,
-0.0162559077,
0.0613212548,
0.0000401911,
0.0205640793,
0.0166906081,
0.0366050638,
0.0271739643,
0.0079833064,
-0.000956545,
0.0621492863,
-0.0292256288,
0.0417588763,
0.0278172605,
0.0023072849,
0.0267577749,
0.0000017202,
-0.008133187,
-0.0371306762,
-0.0576171614,
0.0675651506,
0.0200299174,
0.0973268747,
-0.0107963346,
0.0283780266,
0.0326674283,
-0.0707912371,
0.0342380181,
0.0452164263,
0.0017226012,
0.0493546389,
0.0206138715,
-0.0198592171,
-0.009813658,
-0.0343967788,
0.020128008,
-0.0355535708,
0.0486017093,
0.0564024262,
-0.0374973081,
-0.0218966566,
0.0040384168,
0.03701327,
0.0380080864,
-0.0415356532,
-0.0133195482,
0.031611532,
0.0285054762,
-0.033557836,
-0.0212679952,
-0.00018687,
0.0548543707,
0.0382986031,
-0.0444368459,
0.0463663563,
-0.0168883353,
-0.0079949442,
0.0375601836,
-0.0343603492,
-0.0103475209,
0.0224145912,
0.0478915386,
0.0064160987,
0.0326726437,
0.007469445,
0.0626490563,
0.0142080933,
0.0694787502,
-0.0297448207,
-0.0173675157,
-0.0459495857,
0.0182524789,
-0.0158714782,
-0.0183239654,
0.0377063677,
-0.0308627468,
0.0018199544,
0.0252714176,
0.0326201022,
0.0192526653,
0.0062373057,
-0.0835158005,
-0.0317916013,
-0.0384115763,
0.0418743975,
0.0499951057,
0.0809207335,
-0.0565410405,
-0.0018170013,
-0.0253242347,
0.0351354107,
0.0250850916,
-0.0657394379,
0.0208290499,
0.0147817191,
-0.0339101292,
-0.023581164,
0.0414622948,
0.0063987435,
-0.0239280593,
-0.0336590931,
-0.0289072022,
-0.0137440097,
0.0328631811,
0.0570198409,
-0.014400986,
0.001123348,
0.084575884,
-0.0625064299,
0.0325567499,
-0.0415166132,
0.0317178071,
0.0200180225,
0.000624185,
0.0705371052,
0.0101410924,
-0.0293893702,
0.0232611634,
0.0395071581,
-0.0223049447,
-0.0019817892,
-0.0095314635,
0.0058309678,
-0.0026180935,
0.0074149547,
-0.067443572,
-0.001780586,
0.0099511836,
0.0040729707,
-0.0214703754,
-0.0056654592,
-0.0127259959,
-0.0424771085,
0.0103731053,
-0.0525951199,
-0.0002129825,
0.0766693577,
0.01995329,
0.0182495322,
0.0415516198,
0.0247657523,
0.0241360664,
0.0577952564,
0.0030255276,
-0.0071363039,
0.0075868582,
0.0199756529,
0.0111091537,
0.0146200517,
-0.0108867707,
-0.0866053551,
-0.0520872101,
-0.036842078,
0.0162798762,
0.0038998362,
-0.0163999256,
0.0410904959,
0.0375885963,
-0.0660768077,
0.0126320077,
-0.0463759825,
0.0733059272,
-0.0066163004,
-0.035751678,
0.0325260423,
-0.0162577312,
-0.0368676558,
-0.0322612487,
0.0369839333,
0.0003337473,
-0.0086202743,
-0.0140759256,
-0.0062075169,
0.0265775621,
0.0594812147,
-0.0682185814,
0.0021760887,
-0.0456874408,
-0.0336312316,
0.0023809953,
0.0192625001,
-0.0439353138,
0.0023925593,
0.0191671476,
-0.009175268,
0.0396348573,
-0.0221096277,
0.021329198,
0.00378542,
-0.0332698151,
0.0218818318,
0.0171633121,
0.0158894882,
0.0110824285,
-0.0829667747,
-0.0055287499,
0.0016453238,
0.0370991528,
0.0191467777,
0.029371962,
0.0266415048,
0.0326418765,
-0.0200676024,
0.0120939333,
0.0091793686,
-0.0056557381,
0.0114454404,
0.0407839343,
-0.0296850167,
-0.0044084955,
0.0397528186,
0.0433517583,
-0.0067114374,
-0.0132528059,
0.046335306,
-0.0220456682,
-0.0711179376,
0.0611727424,
0.0214702711,
0.0306048915,
0.048920352,
-0.0548496582,
-0.044949431,
0.0263772365,
-0.0172358304,
-0.0139493346,
0.1028376669,
0.0013133645,
0.0116276052,
-0.0016891076,
-0.0491703264,
-0.0350639522,
0.0065970053,
-0.0118081942,
0.067387931,
-0.0314000994,
-0.0126655856,
-0.0065782457,
-0.0441545472,
0.0152476886,
-0.01969379,
0.0005235267,
-0.0156636797,
0.0118013378,
-0.0078510996,
0.0556012243,
-0.0282518845,
-0.0575074889,
0.0184844006,
-0.0576925762,
-0.017788602,
-0.0076055555,
0.0169870108,
0.0153680518,
-0.0170206595,
-0.0065925904,
0.0689019337,
0.0141256601,
-0.0004430706,
-0.0101048015,
-0.0001077423,
0.0328297466,
-0.0183377601,
0.0034579851,
-0.0580462292,
-0.0210912693,
-0.0412369259,
0.0371971056,
0.0326391309,
-0.0966189206,
0.0082897898,
0.0381919146,
-0.0349795111,
-0.0132568702,
-0.026635021,
-0.0040784827,
-0.0238306578,
-0.0131888399,
0.0189380012,
-0.0067239096,
0.0519653745,
0.0624707714,
0.0083833337,
0.0395832844,
-0.0174628776,
-0.0231468212,
-0.0420862325,
0.006659579,
-0.0017351162,
-0.0179473832,
0.0221617799,
0.0452528149,
-0.0068502594,
0.0018472855,
0.0133164767,
0.0165228061,
-0.0547116585,
0.0005782864,
-0.0018220069,
-0.0342758968,
-0.0018175932,
0.0188017488,
-0.0029252872,
-0.0541646667,
0.0071580396,
0.0474378765,
0.0543713458,
-0.0602789037,
-0.0583359487,
-0.0002709827,
0.0237137042,
0.0539129004,
-0.002559592,
0.0103026722,
0.0214724503,
0.0255741067,
-0.0414840952,
0.0081981765,
-0.0092915865,
-0.0229553767,
-0.0132427979,
0.0389274098,
0.0210245065,
-0.008573533,
0.0183263402,
-0.0478456505,
-0.0672422945,
-0.0142611694,
0.0508676805,
-0.0634064823,
-0.0371155739,
0.0079887994,
-0.00295173,
-0.0435023755,
0.0299253929,
-0.0208840463,
0.0191589985,
0.0440761857,
-0.0115496106,
0.0028856632,
0.0199156739,
-0.0116464002,
-0.0415258482,
0.0204932168,
0.0133176604,
-0.0143911615,
-0.0582930706,
-0.0317239426,
-0.0176671371,
-0.0283654984,
0.0243683867,
-0.0348952934,
0.0751092359,
-0.0029420776,
0.0440431572,
0.0533022732,
0.0369832404,
-0.025633797,
0.0060463115,
0.0256669875,
0.0189803559,
0.007375747,
0.0043661282,
-0.0808968917,
-0.0002547067,
-0.013513335,
-0.0342931375,
-0.0184582677,
-0.0405007936,
-0.0176229812,
-0.0379952863,
0.0346261635,
-0.004549155,
-0.0001448462,
-0.0080471281,
-0.0987420082,
0.0144161768,
-0.0135989543,
-0.0609615073,
-0.0592739433,
0.0048227166,
0.0169042032,
0.0008721118,
-0.0889639109,
-0.0190085936,
-0.0066475412,
-0.0096647656,
0.0467198417,
0.0097517725,
0.0740177482,
-0.0042481506,
0.0088199144,
0.0221289154,
0.0161237419,
-0.0116920816,
-0.0340960659,
0.0138018383,
0.0199481715,
0.0184181239,
-0.0237897225,
0.0328037106,
-0.0376024209,
-0.0308542531,
-0.0010590083,
0.0557388663,
0.0030396008,
-0.0629117638,
-0.0278053936,
0.0767566636,
0.0205705892,
0.0057396423,
0.0051822639,
0.0174685195,
-0.0210880972,
-0.0550303832,
0.0384274088,
-0.0130195143,
-0.0401411839,
-0.0670583025,
0.0090163536,
-0.0366208032,
-0.0136559512,
0.0093535986,
0.019305408,
-0.0177537836,
-0.0350281894,
-0.0132958293,
0.1034004539,
0.0093014985,
-0.0583111234,
0.0397743806,
-0.0275354832,
0.0421296991,
0.0085590882,
-0.0795822069,
0.0300777908,
0.0522403643,
-0.0299270805,
0.0454729646,
-0.0717079788,
-0.0751357451,
-0.0076661631,
-0.0234426744,
0.0259050969,
-0.0035848287,
-0.0006861399,
-0.0172605589,
0.0167518239,
0.0836673826,
-0.0411348194,
-0.0235031825,
0.0111175897,
0.0623743571,
0.0193399154,
0.0116493097,
0.0310363546,
0.0036231377,
-0.0213632472,
-0.0121884309,
-0.1005495265,
0.0032172541,
-0.0253037121,
-0.0164533518,
0.0529522784,
0.0201002043,
-0.0470275208,
-0.0716211572,
-0.0694624037,
0.0090773599,
-0.0070666531,
0.0027079363,
-0.0079124346,
-0.0112845339,
0.0265662968,
-0.078000091,
0.0313253254,
-0.0293840915,
0.004149714,
-0.0344585218,
0.0758451745,
0.0188080445,
0.0415213183,
-0.0077286707,
-0.0102823768,
0.0190350749,
-0.0381218493,
0.0004478473,
-0.029988315,
0.0333389454,
-0.0217191502,
-0.0325442813,
-0.0103404177,
-0.0135837793,
-0.0103028156,
-0.0424142927,
-0.0213387124,
-0.0038202936,
0.0655699447,
0.003358152,
0.0257730484,
0.0532596521,
-0.0193491038,
-0.0221741907,
-0.0215303339,
0.0296022557,
-0.0324081182,
-0.0100420518,
0.0065180236,
-0.0073398878,
-0.077746518,
0.0132812513,
0.010989082,
0.0101850498,
0.0151522318,
0.0429219529,
-0.0336189047,
-0.0237936024,
-0.0183905903,
-0.031765677,
0.002404958,
0.0129226604,
0.0473354235,
-0.0299615748,
0.0099221626,
0.0642385408,
-0.0241267886,
0.0070908549,
0.0280597974,
-0.0097040609,
0.0283129886,
-0.02797327,
0.0199592058,
-0.0378212221,
0.0151368463,
-0.0300541818,
-0.0555631183,
-0.0118292561,
-6.641026599e-33,
0.0195754468,
-0.0917205885,
-0.0253199395,
0.0535493158,
-0.0103053246,
0.0088732569,
-0.027052477,
0.0725424439,
-0.0028497623,
0.0506334901,
0.016444942,
0.0308705438,
0.0185092129,
-0.0232059006,
0.0097467424,
-0.009790469,
0.0156945344,
-0.0429135747,
0.0199969765,
0.0269825999,
0.0422186218,
0.0150216557,
0.0052350867,
-0.1048386097,
0.0512466021,
-0.02684962,
-0.0139605394,
-0.008169448,
0.0422126576,
-0.0166467596,
-0.0260104816,
0.0719470978,
0.0523512028,
-0.0308764987,
0.0064320345,
0.0676943362,
-0.0395539477,
-0.0508566275,
-0.0001471264,
-0.0378395133,
-0.02634863,
0.0090110675,
0.0153679699,
0.0397417657,
-0.0530867241,
0.0458830744,
0.0517629012,
0.0181852691,
0.0294276159,
-0.0227504317,
-0.0300170667,
0.0577219091,
-0.0399114974,
0.0561992042,
-0.0390185155,
0.0018541536,
0.0094212852,
0.1017579883,
-0.0517601594,
0.0703765079,
-0.009313806,
0.0056054466,
-0.0035651277,
-0.0327287726,
0.0158935841,
0.0827605799,
0.0056823124,
0.0534421057,
-0.0376357622,
-0.0071304296,
-0.0134465527,
0.0025326181,
0.0255903918,
0.075601235,
-0.0055469414,
-0.0542456806,
-0.0615113452,
0.0248173922,
0.0664423332,
-0.006174224,
0.0256814547,
0.0026408185,
0.0372769795,
-0.0138118006,
-0.0057794498,
-0.0476031192,
-0.0146314902,
0.0164638627,
-0.058946345,
0.0312385038,
-0.0242649037,
0.0014763698,
0.0063841883,
-0.0276441928,
-0.0723976418,
0.0475594439,
-0.0095000118,
0.0103138844,
0.0449083932,
0.0355189331,
-0.0761792138,
-0.001488231,
-0.0682694241,
0.0217467919,
0.0239115059,
-0.0513348021,
-0.0168226007,
-0.0064376215,
-0.0213707928,
0.0090636862,
0.0001289089,
-0.0035292928,
-0.0476469658,
-0.0207789298,
-0.0105159329,
0.0278809667,
0.0303009748,
0.0210729484,
0.0269429088,
0.0572183654,
0.0383903421,
0.0182070863,
-0.0612409674,
0.0292660873,
-0.0403219685,
-0.0233407207,
-0.0307110958,
0.0234658979,
-0.0163543914,
-0.0464710221,
-0.005787814,
-0.0749823526,
2.535e-7,
0.0626454651,
0.0754798129,
-0.0263295285,
-0.0121027445,
0.0245568044,
0.0266188215,
-0.0009571358,
0.0237505343,
-0.0340164565,
-0.0441967137,
-0.0262236688,
0.0137401335,
0.0028687762,
-0.0013283649,
-0.0335695185,
-0.0019604072,
-0.017288059,
0.0001298402,
-0.04839449,
0.0067422069,
-0.0111763384,
0.0336405151,
0.0369936079,
0.0407785811,
-0.040350765,
-0.0049095424,
0.061640352,
-0.0980458185,
-0.0558146574,
-0.0148893083,
0.0307447817,
-0.0549101196,
-0.0201678108,
-0.0082068294,
-0.0299550127,
-0.0050648181,
-0.0171959605,
0.0142457364,
0.0479560159,
-0.0132378563,
0.016433375,
-0.0214812122,
-0.0202750694,
0.0036303855,
0.002743484,
-0.0560782142,
-0.0585143417,
-0.089993909,
-0.0257101785,
0.0145881427,
0.0299951788,
-0.0292390306,
-0.0377000906,
-0.0006538627,
-0.0273478404,
-0.0028472496,
-0.0063195755,
-0.0536503308,
0.025787117,
-0.0282080211,
-0.0517239571,
-0.0210660622,
-0.0033688347,
-0.0009530612,
0.0631358251,
0.0609171353,
0.0599254668,
1.611633405e-34,
0.0421618856,
-0.0178294964,
-0.0487122536,
-0.0474749878,
0.0414016321,
-0.0071309288,
-0.0532503575,
0.0267036874,
0.0189229045,
-0.0187206324,
0.0244082604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01202v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01202v1 | From Voices to Validity: Leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) for Textual Analysis of Policy Stakeholder Interviews | 2023-12-02T18:55:14 | 2023-12-02T18:55:14 | Alex Liu, Min Sun | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Obtaining stakeholders' diverse experiences and opinions about current policy
in a timely manner is crucial for policymakers to identify strengths and gaps
in resource allocation, thereby supporting effective policy design and
implementation. However, manually coding even moderately sized interview texts
or open-ended survey responses from stakeholders can often be labor-intensive
and time-consuming. This study explores the integration of Large Language
Models (LLMs)--like GPT-4--with human expertise to enhance text analysis of
stakeholder interviews regarding K-12 education policy within one U.S. state.
Employing a mixed-methods approach, human experts developed a codebook and
coding processes as informed by domain knowledge and unsupervised topic
modeling results. They then designed prompts to guide GPT-4 analysis and
iteratively evaluate different prompts' performances. This combined
human-computer method enabled nuanced thematic and sentiment analysis. Results
reveal that while GPT-4 thematic coding aligned with human coding by 77.89% at
specific themes, expanding to broader themes increased congruence to 96.02%,
surpassing traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP) methods by over 25%.
Additionally, GPT-4 is more closely matched to expert sentiment analysis than
lexicon-based methods. Findings from quantitative measures and qualitative
reviews underscore the complementary roles of human domain expertise and
automated analysis as LLMs offer new perspectives and coding consistency. The
human-computer interactive approach enhances efficiency, validity, and
interpretability of educational policy research. | [
0.0703955442,
0.036924161,
-0.0116412807,
0.0186205562,
-0.0440859757,
0.0149274971,
-0.021103872,
-0.0263785273,
-0.0333928838,
-0.0677769855,
0.0108409217,
0.01178475,
0.0155562246,
0.0356056392,
0.002157443,
-0.0370863825,
-0.0239041261,
0.0286498535,
0.0556069203,
0.036267899,
0.0273728576,
0.0514646806,
-0.0013801295,
0.0605995245,
0.0044684582,
-0.0158257242,
-0.035591498,
0.0026077549,
0.0173240546,
-0.0583857112,
0.047700949,
0.0640257671,
-0.0096682413,
-0.0377771072,
0.0000022957,
-0.0266167577,
-0.0132124601,
0.0172555912,
0.0399130322,
0.0344605558,
0.0899262205,
-0.011849856,
-0.011620733,
0.0213670675,
-0.0253244657,
-0.0032250269,
0.0128455218,
0.0051532104,
0.0614071712,
0.0044217175,
-0.0212806258,
-0.0491418503,
0.0020573821,
-0.0047198585,
-0.0396060757,
0.0218237303,
0.0300413016,
-0.0075227106,
0.0217145793,
0.0259346645,
0.0234266501,
0.0000112527,
-0.0224002767,
-0.0506793223,
0.0188072938,
0.0023559318,
-0.0282908864,
-0.0363380164,
0.0189165976,
0.0462035127,
0.078193672,
0.0372755677,
0.0302972551,
-0.0426028892,
0.0077265012,
0.0719154403,
-0.0462563671,
0.0477636158,
-0.0068845665,
-0.0000894428,
-0.0130432155,
0.0210850872,
-0.031110188,
0.0240606591,
0.0094889197,
0.0653585121,
-0.0123060998,
-0.0324695967,
0.0060792379,
0.0678253919,
0.0180002637,
-0.0292166118,
0.0045011626,
-0.0076611727,
0.0097742658,
0.0660048351,
0.0286780708,
0.0131561095,
0.0321819,
-0.0466615334,
0.0146877961,
0.0278664604,
-0.027967371,
0.0019656455,
0.0687775239,
-0.0037801161,
-0.0113730896,
-0.0134672672,
-0.0218302999,
0.0183666609,
-0.0788638517,
-0.0108587565,
-0.0148736881,
0.0263212454,
-0.0294205043,
0.0070403456,
0.0045627435,
0.0038150151,
-0.0250297394,
0.0171630923,
-0.0229295176,
-0.0022943157,
-0.0004418639,
-0.005156097,
-0.0395349413,
0.0846396461,
-0.0172740128,
0.0471810661,
-0.0383797586,
0.014321167,
0.0251527987,
0.0607588738,
-0.0041967905,
-0.0041878745,
-0.0214095209,
-0.0090631992,
0.0136136729,
0.0072535146,
-0.0152542945,
-0.0236706547,
-0.0433053337,
-0.0261661094,
0.0270016082,
-0.0814522803,
-0.0304022413,
-0.0004932847,
-0.0031642902,
-0.033032842,
0.0150129832,
0.0192618296,
-0.0326381624,
0.0089350687,
-0.0292124916,
0.0131204221,
0.03878171,
0.0137629062,
0.059212286,
0.0346886888,
-0.0057182284,
0.0316947065,
-0.0113112461,
-0.027886983,
-0.0116516259,
0.0065125623,
-0.034444347,
0.03580302,
-0.0385503992,
0.0322128981,
-0.0480756015,
0.005438569,
-0.0241572261,
0.0490710214,
-0.013348192,
0.0293268356,
0.0410093889,
0.143703714,
-0.0484304391,
0.0256278627,
0.0090080267,
0.0871965811,
0.0439001955,
-0.0358768329,
0.010075246,
-0.0339611955,
0.0456890725,
-0.022073824,
0.0503765196,
-0.0161064751,
0.0076984302,
-0.0481538251,
-0.0349646769,
0.0332977138,
0.0323723368,
0.0050063562,
0.0418583639,
-0.0490144417,
-0.0387251116,
0.001850856,
-0.0066935164,
-0.0160910618,
0.0198219661,
-0.0326302797,
0.0310174823,
0.0958024114,
0.0166453812,
0.0101991808,
-0.0221575387,
-0.05199356,
0.0135518499,
0.0606340766,
0.0243714061,
-0.009058388,
-0.0623048432,
0.0078154933,
-0.0113616716,
-0.0192209948,
0.0236044638,
0.0450803228,
-0.0077029848,
0.0118403127,
0.0173552483,
0.0135113755,
-0.0353709124,
0.0283039585,
-0.023180183,
-0.0067383423,
-0.0107704774,
-0.0115857283,
0.0222372822,
0.0657583848,
-0.0214812588,
0.025240751,
-0.0084951157,
0.0022690438,
-0.0207021311,
-0.0427643359,
-0.0070277513,
0.0337203629,
0.0278003756,
-0.0510531329,
-0.0130455177,
0.0146594094,
-0.0129518537,
-0.001946431,
0.0454182997,
-0.0058751376,
-0.0226531997,
-0.0294981804,
-0.0099884905,
-0.031456776,
-0.0450845473,
-0.0046729515,
0.0241278335,
0.0102565056,
-0.0121465884,
-0.0108177997,
-0.0007681567,
0.0428074114,
-0.0097377179,
-0.0236257035,
0.0372730196,
0.014087718,
0.0342624858,
0.0525627695,
-0.0094097601,
-0.0358437151,
-0.0407691747,
-0.102198258,
-0.0057633128,
-0.0002563001,
0.008707596,
0.0082269702,
-0.0528145283,
-0.0217204932,
0.0540639572,
-0.0034176153,
-0.0938355178,
-0.030012669,
0.0206639338,
0.0209795646,
0.0169864018,
0.0324023888,
-0.0485730134,
-0.0025991725,
-0.0356302857,
0.0271338318,
0.0820833594,
-0.0335330665,
-0.0383744799,
0.0341135487,
-0.0138966199,
-0.0331145637,
0.0177239645,
-0.0139240157,
0.0467488915,
0.0165804103,
0.0172716733,
-0.0000875116,
-0.000541977,
0.0722111389,
0.0435987338,
-0.0238056164,
-0.0150278909,
-0.0172012188,
0.0044978908,
0.027257083,
-0.0151827428,
-0.0298176371,
0.0493909046,
0.0581012852,
0.0503846779,
-0.0004842818,
-0.0480831563,
0.0330615602,
-0.0658366457,
0.0334816463,
-0.0760982409,
-0.0825967342,
-0.0296991616,
0.0556956157,
0.0337841697,
0.0094172237,
0.0053886054,
0.0068007214,
0.0302026626,
-0.1211277843,
-0.0098107113,
-0.0409464836,
0.049669601,
-0.0388568267,
-0.0055748271,
-0.0188951306,
-0.0040814895,
-0.0091831973,
-0.0254967399,
0.0140573652,
-0.0391357094,
0.0416237041,
-0.0735012591,
0.012615568,
-0.0298845638,
-0.0095553594,
-0.01212232,
-0.052206289,
-0.0372681282,
-0.0103221806,
0.07255622,
-0.035760697,
0.0174344294,
0.0275402907,
0.0246892869,
0.0202239044,
-0.027324887,
-0.0138701266,
-0.0006679017,
0.0043185493,
0.0387210175,
-0.062737368,
0.0054475269,
-0.0029992051,
0.0274303984,
0.0392096415,
0.0108336676,
0.0109422263,
-0.0413297564,
-0.0176350363,
0.0144628948,
-0.0061791237,
-0.0332014412,
0.030918939,
0.0225185268,
-0.0452495478,
0.0384406,
0.0875741467,
0.0181280542,
-0.0486240871,
-0.029150812,
-0.0334491692,
-0.0250968952,
-0.0016772118,
0.0308309942,
-0.0415834934,
0.0198281147,
-0.0161050111,
0.0291240253,
-0.0370066762,
-0.0278704222,
-0.0144658471,
-0.0981098637,
0.0391979367,
-0.0328276642,
0.0282143485,
0.0094587598,
-0.0375683419,
0.0026778658,
0.0280568097,
-0.034800671,
-0.0276272874,
-0.0064264131,
0.0349908434,
0.0339927599,
-0.043711286,
-0.0309335887,
0.0366335176,
0.0372956283,
0.0302947965,
0.0605943203,
0.0746146962,
-0.0350329839,
-0.002339721,
0.027144419,
0.0080958502,
-0.0434507914,
0.0346488282,
-0.0175207369,
-0.0128569435,
0.0109506957,
-0.0351315774,
0.0348117761,
-0.0254800264,
-0.0042518023,
0.0450051911,
0.0613855533,
-0.0332700461,
0.0139989201,
-0.0226687342,
0.0618138164,
-0.0057461588,
0.0622624792,
0.0180709492,
-0.0472990759,
0.0425407067,
-0.0245594401,
0.0170296468,
0.0088384878,
-0.0905198604,
0.0090404572,
0.0152009055,
0.0166010577,
-0.0209393483,
-0.0613115802,
0.035294801,
0.0020796745,
0.0038861486,
0.0240940414,
0.0824656636,
-0.0180788841,
-0.0194071494,
0.05912707,
-0.0059431898,
0.014633378,
-0.0212407894,
-0.0666769743,
-0.0059456099,
0.0377684385,
-0.0224829409,
-0.0092141693,
-0.0231768079,
-0.0526910461,
-0.0088585364,
-0.0452884212,
0.0124380793,
-0.0341508277,
0.0140204262,
-0.0256126914,
0.0121537447,
0.02020205,
-0.0503383689,
-0.0312326923,
-0.0169235412,
0.0717260912,
0.0027444176,
-0.0238575898,
0.0138135953,
0.0325987898,
0.0013563781,
-0.004118003,
-0.0165452175,
-0.0649328828,
0.013433015,
0.0026159168,
0.0636565089,
-0.0159780271,
-0.0243389662,
-0.0373682044,
-0.0652277321,
-0.0505452491,
-0.0305025149,
-0.0226215776,
-0.0256558713,
0.0251623299,
-0.0201549772,
-0.0377389491,
-0.0070760017,
-0.0545309857,
0.0537261665,
-0.0087331133,
0.0994040817,
-0.02287939,
0.0421973206,
0.0175046213,
-0.0334090441,
-0.0334533677,
0.0077718189,
-0.0386065133,
0.0314002037,
0.0409249961,
0.0438852869,
0.0009388101,
0.0065457071,
0.0442608148,
0.003444588,
-0.0075869896,
-0.0742341205,
-0.0404833369,
-0.0114040691,
-0.0512313694,
0.0128802881,
-0.0185836386,
-0.0388749093,
0.0119757596,
-0.016542688,
0.0073662698,
-0.002594904,
-0.0178431068,
0.0651295334,
0.0056479522,
-0.0477935597,
-0.0549907722,
0.0109037645,
0.040093597,
0.0090503022,
-0.0022984701,
-0.0161433201,
-0.0028769991,
-0.0512335561,
0.0414875448,
0.009540502,
-0.0171766393,
0.0063913641,
-0.0907348245,
0.0081745367,
-0.0066467961,
-0.0265919119,
0.0261220038,
-0.0133103766,
-0.013088,
0.0386139788,
-0.0165694561,
0.0060339784,
-0.0626910105,
0.012966238,
-0.0284633208,
-0.0329625756,
0.0158969834,
-6.75785384e-33,
-0.033429753,
-0.0734788105,
0.0316545144,
-0.0408767313,
-0.0021655452,
-0.0117233135,
-0.0326723717,
0.0502580628,
0.0009183452,
0.0313689671,
0.0083177295,
0.0041992608,
-0.0033782742,
0.0192605406,
0.0612899996,
0.0281437114,
0.0334864184,
0.0059501929,
0.0040146802,
-0.0054289233,
-0.0320594981,
-0.0291298274,
0.0215357076,
-0.0824148804,
0.09529569,
-0.0116436249,
-0.0067597721,
-0.0257028267,
0.0351467691,
0.0043389709,
-0.0390966311,
0.0383650176,
0.0209635012,
-0.121597372,
0.0101894848,
0.0734178498,
0.0004516007,
-0.0385538489,
0.034298975,
-0.0450788587,
0.0276007727,
-0.0394049957,
0.0098980134,
0.0201257318,
-0.0344618596,
0.007983136,
0.0539640002,
-0.0174069498,
0.0284992941,
-0.0235547666,
-0.0752879977,
0.0594199747,
-0.0456895567,
0.0581104197,
-0.0006383858,
0.0434446931,
-0.0239712317,
0.0538547598,
-0.0348459333,
0.0085201096,
0.0230209865,
-0.0160566531,
0.0242462624,
-0.0055108671,
0.0024272767,
0.0600729659,
-0.0197748337,
0.0028118647,
-0.0821893811,
0.0115092592,
0.0519926213,
-0.0181439202,
0.0267361347,
0.0832299441,
-0.0121819694,
-0.0340837389,
-0.0148342699,
0.0361488312,
-0.0240697823,
-0.0031196382,
0.0458138473,
-0.0379368588,
-0.053202223,
-0.0639557391,
-0.02664572,
-0.0183613356,
0.0054214951,
-0.029299425,
0.0339628085,
-0.0522760078,
-0.0627138168,
0.0597856604,
0.0201323759,
-0.0160130449,
0.0173522029,
0.039513357,
-0.0583693683,
0.0346392393,
-0.0097316522,
0.0398021378,
-0.0982309282,
0.016385369,
0.0150962584,
-0.0009473124,
0.0400165729,
0.0146828452,
-0.034072306,
-0.0364049487,
-0.0769373402,
-0.0254192539,
-0.0094393371,
0.0052918703,
0.0004512244,
0.0040280512,
0.0090812324,
0.0004694115,
0.0290824026,
0.0503520109,
-0.0020409659,
-0.0108272238,
0.003727145,
-0.0250533354,
-0.003873673,
-0.0421663448,
-0.0368595272,
-0.0093006715,
0.0057966905,
0.0045064138,
0.0332439393,
0.0050096964,
-0.0071039866,
-0.0079042185,
2.961e-7,
0.0637293011,
0.0795792639,
-0.0429645516,
-0.0599172339,
0.0082111023,
0.0258584321,
0.003523285,
-0.0169765987,
0.0200265702,
-0.0232489128,
0.0440512747,
-0.0071496945,
0.043309737,
0.05591904,
-0.0633836463,
-0.0078121764,
-0.0104221674,
0.010608823,
-0.0897682384,
0.0565115288,
0.0857282802,
0.0239419583,
0.0306171961,
0.0063990164,
-0.0489161946,
0.0075328769,
0.008587203,
-0.0241339915,
-0.0112148654,
0.0011028735,
-0.0104810828,
0.0016232308,
0.0099850232,
0.0184133779,
-0.0111791473,
0.0115279751,
0.0180782508,
0.0831465945,
0.0028120198,
0.0167632569,
-0.0126819545,
-0.0051519545,
-0.0031942031,
-0.0603146739,
0.0526969135,
-0.0639201701,
-0.021079924,
-0.0412051752,
-0.0242442694,
-0.0315659046,
-0.0021514122,
-0.0137962112,
0.0152254039,
0.0333821587,
-0.0153572448,
-0.0574728884,
0.0201353226,
-0.0334495902,
0.0428957827,
-0.0319058187,
-0.0324211717,
-0.0346418396,
-0.0091295671,
0.025236072,
0.025115734,
-0.0235676225,
0.0630834028,
2.377863212e-34,
0.0363647789,
-0.0288463309,
-0.0046407459,
-0.0398193374,
0.0827780142,
0.0519150458,
-0.0571182892,
0.0122872489,
0.0149606448,
-0.0573361851,
0.0057955552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01185v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01185v4 | A ripple in time: a discontinuity in American history | 2023-12-02T17:24:17 | 2024-05-04T09:15:43 | Alexander Kolpakov, Igor Rivin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI, I.2.7; I.5.4; H.3.1; H.3.3 | In this note we use the State of the Union Address (SOTU) dataset from Kaggle
to make some surprising (and some not so surprising) observations pertaining to
the general timeline of American history, and the character and nature of the
addresses themselves. Our main approach is using vector embeddings, such as
BERT (DistilBERT) and GPT-2.
While it is widely believed that BERT (and its variations) is most suitable
for NLP classification tasks, we find out that GPT-2 in conjunction with
nonlinear dimension reduction methods such as UMAP provide better separation
and stronger clustering. This makes GPT-2 + UMAP an interesting alternative. In
our case, no model fine-tuning is required, and the pre-trained out-of-the-box
GPT-2 model is enough.
We also used a fine-tuned DistilBERT model for classification detecting which
President delivered which address, with very good results (accuracy 93% - 95%
depending on the run). An analogous task was performed to determine the year of
writing, and we were able to pin it down to about 4 years (which is a single
presidential term).
It is worth noting that SOTU addresses provide relatively small writing
samples (with about 8'000 words on average, and varying widely from under 2'000
words to more than 20'000), and that the number of authors is relatively large
(we used SOTU addresses of 42 US presidents). This shows that the techniques
employed turn out to be rather efficient, while all the computations described
in this note can be performed using a single GPU instance of Google Colab.
The accompanying code is available on GitHub. | [
0.0225538779,
0.1125646979,
0.0060494235,
0.0272512436,
-0.0116109336,
0.0392064266,
0.02121065,
0.0385225229,
0.0329380259,
-0.0771746412,
0.1072885469,
-0.0460285172,
0.0003229114,
0.014178318,
-0.0210776199,
-0.086473912,
0.0615139119,
0.0319517888,
0.0410794467,
-0.0081176404,
-0.0061458354,
-0.0217931923,
-0.0248155054,
0.0283721909,
-0.0217782184,
-0.0332869813,
-0.0265238266,
-0.0295597315,
0.0210799426,
0.0248516016,
-0.0072663645,
0.0502831601,
0.0590866953,
0.0448976234,
0.0000020429,
-0.0189113505,
-0.0187402368,
-0.0149369249,
0.01284815,
0.0263468418,
0.0249681864,
0.0224818345,
-0.0373031981,
0.0189642012,
-0.0431192294,
-0.0226672664,
-0.0008147297,
0.0609118603,
0.0253918748,
0.0778065771,
-0.0192056186,
-0.0304874163,
0.054593645,
-0.0098520638,
-0.0063134343,
-0.0236973856,
0.0496088639,
-0.0381929465,
-0.0444283672,
0.0047970721,
0.0034386527,
0.0221938156,
-0.0245819855,
0.0192146171,
-0.0089136735,
0.0641887486,
-0.0446890667,
0.0591123663,
-0.019786248,
-0.005779502,
0.0408220366,
-0.0049267886,
0.0622565784,
0.0367336944,
-0.012802151,
0.0411931165,
0.0185746979,
-0.0181454141,
-0.0329239108,
0.0031907551,
0.0209823251,
-0.0265973676,
0.0050224881,
-0.0003534241,
-0.0276590362,
0.052706562,
0.0105475038,
-0.0491095185,
-0.0348693468,
-0.0197724514,
0.042366907,
-0.0448760204,
0.0334648825,
0.0119972154,
0.0618945472,
-0.0012777561,
-0.0069112512,
-0.0028596134,
-0.0080413856,
-0.0584358983,
0.0154477237,
0.0112938508,
0.0086391512,
0.0449669063,
0.0168870967,
0.0552687608,
-0.0198257659,
0.0053749545,
0.0013333029,
0.0190403815,
-0.1065694466,
-0.0304298066,
-0.0260688495,
0.0543060414,
0.0019428497,
-0.0014555479,
-0.0408548526,
-0.0115743624,
0.0055838842,
0.0226285513,
-0.0632438809,
0.0011759938,
0.0121864341,
0.0338542052,
-0.0497908182,
0.0366359726,
-0.0661425143,
-0.0328642018,
-0.0684957951,
0.0297865737,
0.0083760684,
0.0237243362,
0.0226910468,
-0.0334466621,
-0.005271493,
0.0194615442,
-0.0274656154,
-0.0705911666,
-0.0243191142,
0.0098022502,
-0.0422005057,
-0.0275227614,
0.0233625174,
-0.022180194,
0.038390398,
0.0054666912,
-0.0025692442,
-0.0173523258,
-0.0020892578,
-0.0006706765,
-0.0366099477,
0.0283457376,
0.0158460308,
0.0201867167,
0.0950073078,
-0.0123282829,
0.0298348255,
0.0091223894,
0.0343177244,
0.043615099,
0.0460363626,
-0.0031239537,
0.0119159576,
0.013178397,
0.0007569898,
0.0362195373,
-0.0087370798,
0.0115557536,
-0.0167192779,
0.0165585894,
0.0101892836,
0.0273043271,
-0.0028852921,
-0.0244685393,
0.0337170176,
0.0522239543,
-0.0060728639,
0.0498321615,
0.018079035,
0.0225172658,
0.0250311233,
0.022009125,
-0.0013353962,
-0.0181949642,
-0.0538426191,
-0.0220989659,
0.050036449,
-0.0152329765,
-0.0202024169,
-0.0125391269,
0.0027612133,
-0.0088303331,
0.007637152,
-0.0289131217,
0.0654517263,
-0.0467989855,
-0.0655805543,
0.0374411009,
0.0067161331,
-0.0320140906,
-0.0143580101,
-0.0082399435,
0.0229234025,
0.0538296141,
0.0641452372,
-0.0368956923,
0.0063079586,
-0.0690724924,
0.0343222357,
0.0123012587,
0.0295772199,
-0.0253623314,
0.0140726697,
-0.0260347966,
-0.0067490325,
0.0189674981,
0.0348276347,
0.0404605716,
0.0516541824,
0.03634369,
-0.0111296717,
-0.0234491881,
0.0301723499,
0.0391774215,
0.0166481491,
-0.0528116748,
-0.0091008479,
0.0363975167,
0.0323137715,
0.0600016899,
0.0019905346,
-0.0466843285,
0.024264019,
-0.0531499311,
-0.0313607305,
-0.0267915279,
-0.0136458427,
0.0220775325,
0.0265657865,
-0.026336899,
-0.0126590533,
0.0362976566,
-0.0366810746,
-0.0643616691,
0.0317748934,
-0.0282685328,
0.0649446025,
-0.0460430793,
-0.0124566015,
-0.014542399,
-0.0084126787,
-0.037601497,
0.0920406058,
-0.0088425931,
0.0234866124,
0.013862933,
0.0248687547,
0.0277414322,
-0.0119602112,
-0.0343287922,
-0.0042711888,
-0.0223333817,
0.0136664491,
0.0297884103,
-0.0547474101,
-0.0120305214,
-0.0571996495,
-0.0718709007,
0.0119908433,
-0.0330744684,
0.0367071331,
0.0398081616,
-0.0150462855,
0.0043860972,
0.0101878745,
0.0086060707,
-0.0625127405,
-0.0424151197,
-0.0016828628,
0.069446817,
0.0181344301,
-0.0168321431,
0.0063417233,
0.0006931443,
-0.0805000141,
0.0250815544,
-0.022729136,
-0.0753776804,
-0.0171218049,
-0.0255062133,
-0.0109010469,
0.0228455309,
-0.0276192203,
-0.0402670987,
0.0118245352,
-0.0002806935,
0.0733096749,
0.0360435061,
0.0466525927,
0.1059332192,
-0.0127576394,
-0.0192339439,
0.0120552294,
0.0345542356,
-0.0450089313,
0.0431716517,
-0.0131344618,
0.0087889945,
0.0022972843,
0.0232453849,
0.0080981227,
0.0108640855,
-0.0509385765,
-0.0106591759,
-0.0173590556,
0.0192499198,
-0.0067721382,
0.0028458985,
-0.0394501202,
-0.0008431642,
0.0159174036,
-0.0255648009,
-0.0060384427,
-0.0139610684,
0.0368408188,
0.0086604794,
-0.0260106772,
-0.0312544778,
0.0842925608,
0.0052820062,
0.028657034,
-0.0379496105,
-0.0490430184,
0.0177382156,
0.0003970966,
-0.0109174056,
-0.0144126322,
0.0372647233,
0.0062325336,
0.008521053,
-0.0357768126,
-0.0407965221,
-0.0262025688,
-0.0759076551,
-0.0123344045,
0.0121576907,
-0.0223979726,
-0.0598440245,
-0.0632569119,
0.0221187212,
0.0011972984,
0.0514783151,
-0.0139702065,
0.0035567691,
-0.0061268485,
0.0553296432,
-0.0004528261,
0.0022903366,
-0.0606304929,
0.0228700284,
-0.0303713325,
-0.0144535918,
0.0103395591,
0.0404237695,
-0.0108216656,
-0.0380811207,
-0.0004915453,
-0.0835527927,
-0.0441991054,
0.0030262605,
0.0079614948,
-0.0203786995,
-0.0080297645,
0.1185290664,
0.0684256479,
-0.0399331413,
-0.019057598,
0.0320405364,
-0.0374727994,
-0.0024836382,
0.0254511014,
-0.0524978824,
0.0048437291,
-0.0148258889,
-0.022265764,
-0.0181067493,
-0.0457315519,
-0.0040146019,
-0.0728618428,
0.0112244282,
-0.0010293064,
0.016621843,
-0.0141163906,
-0.0757950321,
-0.01429688,
-0.0135123357,
-0.0638056099,
-0.0187078863,
-0.0211283043,
-0.0097485026,
0.018517144,
-0.0697324872,
-0.0515598655,
0.0288993102,
0.0105046174,
0.0097389957,
0.0384199023,
0.0882315934,
-0.034273047,
-0.0091945548,
-0.0190687757,
-0.0104944464,
-0.0065680374,
0.0101479944,
0.0871536136,
-0.0283232089,
0.0160921998,
-0.0598937608,
0.0095258346,
0.011708444,
-0.0094549814,
0.0273638945,
0.0520750061,
-0.0450940244,
-0.0016886659,
-0.0166876297,
-0.019862907,
-0.0086606257,
0.0456936918,
-0.018570913,
-0.0270181205,
-0.0723033175,
-0.0189192947,
0.0804486647,
-0.0198275093,
0.0235689618,
0.0032898488,
-0.0142575623,
-0.0371467695,
-0.0560727268,
-0.0336787738,
0.0147790201,
0.04368902,
0.0185935516,
0.0552374609,
0.0530759357,
-0.0042409687,
-0.0628607273,
-0.0154781481,
-0.0517816171,
0.002196904,
-0.0521785021,
-0.0650493577,
0.0188732743,
0.035062138,
-0.019700909,
0.0284150094,
-0.0377537422,
-0.0516334511,
0.0513180681,
-0.0233646538,
0.0279385541,
-0.012003189,
-0.0226259753,
-0.0313791819,
0.0528561547,
0.0490055084,
0.049571339,
-0.0283873267,
0.0049369237,
0.0437028483,
-0.0265101697,
0.0047243107,
-0.0008026335,
0.0055040172,
-0.020274261,
-0.0401008129,
-0.0713706985,
0.0026466853,
-0.0389462374,
-0.0131850289,
0.0814645812,
-0.009191189,
-0.0320176557,
-0.0377920382,
-0.0226402879,
-0.0131207155,
0.0451919213,
0.0180699583,
0.002650748,
-0.0235718619,
-0.0335294567,
-0.060347002,
-0.0023478607,
-0.0270041581,
0.0145095121,
-0.0624029078,
0.0185635537,
-0.0154999932,
0.0563050807,
-0.0086207064,
-0.0017566064,
-0.0120723508,
0.0237228461,
0.0125089129,
0.0117108058,
-0.0141038578,
0.0113623682,
0.0058793346,
0.038069807,
-0.0224241931,
0.0275597144,
-0.0978424773,
0.0115746278,
-0.0164945051,
0.0351453684,
0.0621406138,
-0.0325311646,
0.0228925403,
-0.0273658186,
-0.0111578079,
0.0011999103,
0.0251278635,
0.0423113145,
-0.0154960714,
0.0114517547,
0.0448008925,
-0.0512704514,
0.045362547,
0.0434100665,
0.001862013,
0.0160922147,
0.0842705369,
-0.0274609681,
-0.05146873,
-0.0405867621,
0.0143886805,
0.0437767617,
0.0018061076,
-0.0085327979,
-0.076598689,
0.0071232296,
0.0588811375,
-0.0318326466,
0.0157127716,
0.0099611003,
-0.0066624507,
0.0082765371,
-0.015141678,
0.0189267509,
-0.0855165273,
0.0059298961,
-0.0191078093,
-0.0436865985,
0.0197906569,
-6.059662358e-33,
0.0024039997,
-0.0524346158,
-0.0028985487,
-0.0347928591,
-0.0420876667,
0.0287759937,
0.0009308234,
0.0210452732,
-0.0030302496,
-0.010148325,
-0.0569839887,
-0.0040811175,
0.0238368325,
0.0088034663,
0.0059569348,
0.0216812212,
0.0438683517,
0.0087561551,
-0.0131994952,
0.0349027514,
0.0922733694,
0.0536231659,
0.0561106615,
-0.0326460376,
0.0034248191,
-0.0252789687,
-0.0273401793,
-0.0067551988,
0.0422228612,
0.0067203497,
-0.061569538,
0.0099788113,
0.0202604327,
-0.0289710108,
0.0071933488,
0.0434958078,
-0.0844761208,
-0.0371174887,
-0.0129380673,
-0.0229236428,
0.067083396,
-0.0316469483,
-0.0324256867,
0.0200868174,
-0.0003908918,
-0.0007263366,
0.0660001636,
0.0195692983,
-0.0213270392,
-0.0150701078,
-0.0258244947,
0.0407076664,
-0.0207414553,
0.0273226071,
0.0161199272,
-0.0172596071,
0.0447844826,
0.0123673324,
-0.0957063809,
-0.011678258,
0.0343187079,
0.0166765153,
-0.0115271751,
-0.0417217463,
-0.0097091747,
0.0442181602,
0.0363481976,
0.0406376533,
-0.0289910566,
-0.0184894204,
-0.0016254678,
-0.013526462,
0.0048208553,
0.0598453544,
0.0741994679,
-0.0928769037,
-0.047284618,
0.0313808247,
0.0632279813,
-0.0113929948,
0.0467115827,
-0.0003769387,
-0.0430625081,
0.0049387184,
0.0065056575,
-0.0309574753,
0.0035471334,
-0.0180783775,
0.0181128345,
0.0220869072,
0.0022502886,
0.0037924103,
0.0212336201,
-0.0191163458,
-0.0336583368,
-0.0027142642,
-0.0435724743,
0.0467753708,
0.000463723,
-0.0084356908,
0.0012658343,
-0.063150391,
0.0081663541,
0.0207965802,
0.0276025031,
-0.0256793294,
0.0048564882,
0.022743959,
-0.074750796,
0.0053263805,
0.0076628313,
0.0050687795,
-0.0139577808,
0.0214856565,
-0.0056301784,
-0.0131448545,
0.0246240161,
0.0372710824,
0.0331456885,
0.041131828,
0.0238294266,
-0.005452123,
-0.004496546,
-0.0115798889,
-0.0126144411,
-0.0198674183,
-0.0042641354,
0.0725136101,
0.0144999605,
-0.0325772204,
-0.0209510084,
-0.0411367826,
2.761e-7,
0.034269385,
0.074638851,
0.0477690585,
-0.0003663089,
0.0080260141,
0.0119899446,
0.0115583641,
0.0399548784,
-0.0788336545,
0.046784997,
0.044553306,
-0.0401451997,
0.0258078892,
0.0215765648,
-0.1230982989,
0.0089610079,
-0.0742089599,
0.0168861356,
-0.0851977542,
0.0470774733,
0.0615419932,
0.0638147295,
0.0578722581,
0.006798204,
-0.0199933406,
-0.014292934,
0.0218409393,
-0.0368511342,
-0.0247664638,
-0.0022656801,
0.0366610959,
-0.0133972131,
-0.0105908951,
0.0215003304,
-0.0223521832,
0.0268924311,
-0.0189400092,
0.0987641439,
-0.0158492755,
-0.0108616482,
0.0109010022,
-0.0028984225,
-0.0026099223,
-0.0455301702,
0.0573893711,
0.0090237372,
-0.0462740213,
-0.0055554821,
-0.0299912449,
0.0331617408,
0.053702537,
0.0416789837,
-0.004442519,
0.0265064351,
-0.0228408687,
-0.03486019,
0.0130614387,
-0.0816313848,
0.0418114886,
0.0261926148,
-0.0276456568,
-0.0180193055,
-0.0387351625,
-0.0138032082,
0.0636584684,
-0.0377436876,
0.0197565183,
2.818442857e-34,
-0.0052831401,
0.0078617968,
-0.0264222585,
0.0020525092,
0.0355320573,
-0.0167159121,
0.0360861756,
-0.0329628922,
0.0108630788,
-0.0548775829,
-0.0034872177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01151v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01151v1 | Here Is Not There: Measuring Entailment-Based Trajectory Similarity for Location-Privacy Protection and Beyond | 2023-12-02T14:41:01 | 2023-12-02T14:41:01 | Zilong Liu, Krzysztof Janowicz, Kitty Currier, Meilin Shi, Jinmeng Rao, Song Gao, Ling Cai, Anita Graser | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.SC | While the paths humans take play out in social as well as physical space,
measures to describe and compare their trajectories are carried out in
abstract, typically Euclidean, space. When these measures are applied to
trajectories of actual individuals in an application area, alterations that are
inconsequential in abstract space may suddenly become problematic once overlaid
with geographic reality. In this work, we present a different view on
trajectory similarity by introducing a measure that utilizes logical
entailment. This is an inferential perspective that considers facts as triple
statements deduced from the social and environmental context in which the
travel takes place, and their practical implications. We suggest a
formalization of entailment-based trajectory similarity, measured as the
overlapping proportion of facts, which are spatial relation statements in our
case study. With the proposed measure, we evaluate LSTM-TrajGAN, a
privacy-preserving trajectory-generation model. The entailment-based model
evaluation reveals potential consequences of disregarding the rich structure of
geographic space (e.g., miscalculated insurance risk due to regional shifts in
our toy example). Our work highlights the advantage of applying logical
entailment to trajectory-similarity reasoning for location-privacy protection
and beyond. | [
0.003854146,
0.0722706914,
-0.0173702072,
0.0016071365,
-0.0690698624,
0.0003010408,
0.0495920219,
-0.0394244827,
-0.0122719659,
-0.0129286014,
0.0318033025,
-0.0023620923,
-0.0158531982,
-0.0063115447,
0.0099357553,
-0.0410459973,
0.0357683897,
-0.0472854637,
-0.0221445486,
0.0111413961,
-0.0242720153,
-0.0005008107,
-0.0011450804,
0.039653495,
0.0186141971,
0.0098887738,
-0.0040681567,
0.0259139147,
0.0755306184,
-0.0671163648,
-0.0070553101,
-0.013387288,
0.0628489107,
0.0097545879,
0.0000020688,
-0.0270653125,
-0.0252315085,
0.016642306,
0.0560381636,
-0.0446273796,
-0.0233337395,
0.0224479362,
0.0492830463,
0.0152522707,
-0.0250130259,
0.022944415,
-0.0053194249,
0.009385067,
0.0291784834,
0.0526560843,
-0.0287463777,
-0.0277826339,
-0.044764258,
-0.005536959,
0.016802635,
0.0237960592,
0.0008375908,
-0.0153166167,
-0.0188153628,
-0.011537618,
0.0147214001,
-0.0115436316,
0.0042651454,
0.0616564713,
0.0075841136,
0.0333200544,
0.0062774969,
0.0389014371,
-0.0151420766,
0.0273807663,
0.0481712893,
-0.0212234929,
0.0678453445,
0.0243621189,
-0.0087256571,
0.0408921912,
-0.0340492539,
0.0074361851,
-0.0018512456,
0.0462362804,
-0.0206152964,
0.0683333203,
0.0212691948,
0.017084986,
-0.0354427733,
0.0807713345,
-0.0047944738,
-0.0355487131,
-0.0999093503,
-0.0011084727,
0.0102056367,
-0.0533413664,
0.0712744072,
-0.0000441892,
0.0237979926,
-0.0226458702,
0.0063489676,
0.0424428657,
0.0128941135,
-0.0419428162,
0.0439811461,
-0.0227298476,
0.0057475455,
0.0237476658,
-0.0048554428,
0.0241099503,
-0.0534445792,
0.0057556005,
-0.000919117,
-0.002304113,
-0.0364365578,
0.0127416756,
-0.006648574,
0.0282327682,
-0.0409254804,
0.0245610327,
-0.0007330777,
0.0187885445,
-0.0688976124,
0.0508502461,
-0.0788707361,
0.011488202,
0.0146706337,
-0.0332433768,
-0.0334782787,
-0.0906319693,
-0.0531756394,
0.0223477446,
-0.0129720848,
0.0528911799,
0.0226032622,
-0.0067574056,
0.0426384322,
-0.0093304012,
-0.0410956778,
0.0726729855,
0.0656638294,
-0.0042993459,
-0.0429060012,
-0.0840874836,
0.022429686,
-0.0371659994,
0.0041384855,
-0.0974824578,
-0.0068724337,
-0.0307543706,
-0.0417698547,
-0.0293231253,
-0.0064975154,
0.0296926517,
-0.015070728,
0.0066922032,
0.0232438445,
0.0066689034,
-0.0062696319,
0.0141185913,
0.0723504275,
-0.0226413775,
0.0389005132,
0.0592802577,
0.0465585105,
0.0465311818,
0.0214756057,
-0.0268534832,
0.0249339417,
0.0198860746,
-0.0176492203,
0.0224970318,
-0.021083694,
-0.0177027099,
-0.022001883,
0.0376893505,
-0.0613576993,
0.0222228095,
0.0413026698,
0.0790060535,
0.0121714734,
-0.0160762146,
-0.0019164189,
0.037362691,
-0.1095918268,
0.0006125816,
-0.0387682058,
0.0169864707,
-0.0574865565,
-0.0220352877,
0.039439261,
0.0450267084,
-0.0194642022,
-0.0146603361,
0.01811531,
-0.0273971781,
0.0725101158,
-0.0239861347,
-0.0035103043,
-0.044980552,
0.0464769825,
0.0171780065,
-0.005866148,
-0.0159420408,
-0.0263507664,
-0.0053110942,
0.0065226266,
0.0441522002,
0.0120098088,
0.0430062525,
-0.0228831749,
-0.0299746916,
-0.0052186097,
-0.0199709386,
0.0185458753,
0.0406532697,
0.00703495,
-0.0450787321,
-0.0535685718,
0.0326211303,
0.0302614402,
-0.0005078345,
0.0362381637,
0.0597049817,
0.0469908901,
-0.048973266,
0.0593088754,
0.0005063404,
0.0086815907,
0.020814823,
-0.0209931377,
0.0295534562,
0.024914654,
-0.0091055753,
0.0010551268,
0.0072929589,
0.0101216305,
0.0044145496,
-0.0076000839,
0.0578876436,
-0.0108428691,
0.0252850652,
-0.0304065458,
-0.0754421577,
0.0029085397,
0.031026829,
-0.0123489108,
-0.0253898073,
-0.0275123976,
-0.0107549112,
0.0034374767,
-0.0155722937,
-0.0012274617,
-0.0047482043,
-0.0127879521,
-0.0368065313,
0.0211382564,
0.0163937844,
0.0083964737,
-0.0423283763,
0.0080620619,
0.0895247534,
-0.0159864612,
0.014098336,
-0.0678732842,
-0.0168216247,
-0.0210736208,
0.0223785695,
-0.0076473593,
-0.0021570637,
-0.0090237986,
-0.0335207172,
0.0207813736,
-0.0027670776,
0.0416188017,
0.0075947489,
-0.0217754729,
-0.0169522781,
-0.0021124675,
-0.012873631,
-0.0331626944,
-0.0308084879,
0.0191484913,
0.057639882,
-0.0389605276,
-0.080582045,
0.0202582125,
-0.0075032171,
-0.0421743654,
0.0137077896,
-0.0131447855,
-0.0439595394,
-0.0244930647,
-0.0285135843,
-0.0727761164,
0.0006789595,
-0.004808791,
0.010650306,
0.0065357108,
0.0131186945,
-0.011982684,
-0.045808956,
0.0153814713,
-0.0601348579,
0.0383968689,
-0.0211757831,
-0.0196224973,
-0.0117037091,
-0.0469983295,
0.0528198518,
-0.0232362114,
-0.0595424064,
0.0109857311,
-0.0407946445,
0.0108386753,
-0.0026208695,
-0.0187110156,
-0.0134539558,
-0.0352132544,
0.017405089,
-0.0241786614,
-0.0014650678,
0.031115653,
0.0743346214,
0.0045289928,
-0.0299473926,
0.0549994819,
0.0032289526,
0.080546841,
0.0029910672,
-0.0365422741,
0.0029312128,
0.1067243218,
0.0378705263,
0.0312976278,
0.0391670167,
-0.0064441357,
0.0303161871,
-0.0525997281,
0.0119864326,
-0.0004180677,
-0.0085154027,
-0.0553451516,
-0.0016562412,
0.0410335436,
-0.0453818962,
-0.0092617571,
-0.0608363375,
0.0099901911,
-0.0118683204,
-0.0803338066,
-0.0573058389,
0.0517884009,
0.033787556,
0.0305357333,
0.0285691507,
0.0110577652,
-0.0280870311,
-0.0250235945,
0.0107095828,
0.0414380208,
0.0283570401,
0.0151212933,
-0.0109711569,
-0.042746041,
0.0414054431,
-0.0149972066,
0.041561719,
0.0115413181,
0.0349818692,
-0.0319509879,
-0.001896191,
-0.0306482706,
0.0687102824,
0.0695841685,
-0.0187522098,
-0.0631326586,
0.0525824614,
0.0354173481,
0.0267788731,
0.0278834924,
-0.0101530394,
0.0371528901,
-0.0043700417,
0.0118315304,
-0.0527075045,
0.0226109494,
-0.0154868225,
-0.0165790003,
-0.0564323552,
-0.0369813778,
0.018408386,
-0.0323250927,
0.0670569241,
0.0243393201,
-0.0193013586,
-0.0364475772,
-0.0639773011,
0.0028313741,
0.0340196304,
-0.0555155687,
-0.045494955,
0.003581574,
-0.0105801914,
0.0301971622,
-0.098490037,
0.015643971,
-0.0156145059,
-0.0703657791,
0.0058773845,
0.0102789775,
0.0580939762,
0.0100796241,
-0.0801481679,
-0.0596217401,
0.0339424387,
0.0444595367,
0.0317591727,
-0.0128662875,
0.0278686173,
0.021063365,
-0.0499793328,
0.0290651806,
-0.0298919193,
-0.0651154965,
0.0215935856,
0.0570630804,
-0.0974800661,
-0.012658258,
-0.0511373468,
0.0191338509,
0.0052301721,
0.0252140444,
-0.0072571342,
0.0199641865,
-0.0438707434,
-0.0171170961,
-0.0040100552,
-0.0025618717,
0.0596359335,
-0.0139313964,
-0.0028008288,
-0.0475111082,
-0.0230919551,
-0.006186747,
-0.0646144375,
0.0654279962,
-0.0393828526,
-0.0122811291,
0.0961768627,
-0.0545062311,
-0.0559083372,
-0.0033629935,
-0.0756568536,
0.0315089859,
0.0770259351,
0.080336377,
-0.007416625,
0.050125584,
-0.0614263788,
-0.0014698448,
-0.0667438433,
-0.0319565982,
0.0075121308,
-0.0298758131,
0.0285045765,
0.0290928092,
-0.0433460325,
0.0541733392,
0.0770382881,
0.0091148391,
0.0372064561,
0.0141594233,
0.0409100726,
-0.0025904283,
-0.0053929579,
-0.0035295608,
0.0047659706,
0.007323123,
0.0180772413,
-0.0129711572,
-0.0807614848,
-0.0074046985,
-0.0367717072,
0.0069296886,
0.0680537522,
0.0589038469,
0.0007873786,
-0.0061363257,
-0.0126427161,
-0.0279585868,
0.017074639,
-0.0123994742,
-0.04375346,
0.037704438,
0.0413887762,
-0.0229086224,
-0.0085981777,
0.0356629342,
-0.0646247193,
-0.0410361663,
-0.0348399356,
0.0025565857,
0.0398585163,
-0.0215321053,
-0.0327429511,
-0.0229423139,
0.0020336104,
0.0074563529,
0.0286254697,
-0.0360401645,
-0.0044032694,
0.0400497057,
0.0637750775,
-0.0708613768,
0.0243186932,
-0.0931562558,
-0.0107832365,
-0.0184155367,
0.0566217341,
0.0424712636,
0.0230315477,
-0.0085248407,
-0.0452096984,
0.0080522997,
0.0550791919,
0.0388291292,
0.0051464727,
-0.0408910438,
0.012703862,
-0.014793626,
-0.0150736738,
0.05610447,
0.0490192994,
-0.0260014962,
0.0339345783,
-0.0397247374,
-0.058296252,
-0.0189711694,
-0.013483285,
-0.0116913375,
0.0402253866,
0.0082074879,
-0.0093624946,
-0.0329573043,
-0.0423548445,
0.0271794628,
0.0393170752,
0.0076520354,
-0.0195767581,
0.036331024,
-0.00286047,
-0.016786335,
-0.072972551,
-0.0051204055,
-0.0465549827,
-0.0269539934,
-0.0122817047,
-0.0550170541,
-6.302205781e-33,
-0.0070493408,
-0.0521766022,
0.0338057429,
-0.0039737802,
-0.0450129285,
-0.0448187925,
-0.0157705955,
-0.0339894779,
-0.0035299328,
0.003803134,
0.0180709772,
0.0257603694,
0.0068550245,
0.0287354961,
0.0044899704,
-0.0177282542,
0.0039102952,
0.0385462306,
0.0001163572,
0.0137153091,
0.0602287836,
-0.0357006826,
-0.0125201736,
-0.069598265,
0.0068044951,
-0.0298174899,
-0.0509998314,
0.0109919589,
-0.048087433,
0.0061379438,
0.018895559,
-0.0193986185,
0.0145500535,
-0.0092413435,
-0.0079716854,
0.0312638544,
0.0021509938,
-0.0901712924,
-0.0089534568,
-0.0608386286,
0.0010126865,
-0.0289810225,
0.0195578262,
0.0064867148,
-0.0255414099,
0.0416924655,
0.0394149832,
-0.0008141175,
-0.016962558,
0.0046503949,
-0.0138903987,
0.0168975964,
-0.0409428924,
0.010951858,
0.0023100853,
0.0261725076,
-0.0070389123,
-0.0381720848,
-0.0483270213,
0.0422116481,
-0.0234113913,
-0.0334703587,
0.0091922013,
-0.0256985556,
0.0662486926,
0.0757561028,
-0.0012321833,
-0.0215689354,
-0.0586493574,
0.0032814238,
0.0101166023,
0.0348468646,
-0.0305329971,
0.0188045446,
-0.029847784,
-0.0121252211,
-0.1034603119,
0.0454175584,
-0.0408921055,
-0.0042179124,
0.042209778,
0.0073324018,
-0.0672246218,
-0.030289989,
0.0001453051,
-0.0210337359,
0.0065288581,
-0.0005830011,
0.0068149478,
-0.0062824776,
-0.0079830559,
0.0510851704,
-0.0052071186,
-0.0113078142,
-0.0298436601,
0.0015193569,
0.0516557321,
-0.0074974229,
0.0080512688,
0.0462594219,
-0.0392266586,
-0.0624361336,
-0.0187150184,
0.0003309521,
0.0360625759,
0.0311267395,
0.0357852504,
0.0082440702,
-0.0499024838,
-0.0111902347,
-0.0054234555,
-0.0042807739,
-0.0396647826,
-0.0661781132,
0.0325883552,
0.0086969491,
0.0121148694,
0.0559553094,
0.0032701413,
0.0207868367,
-0.0110489884,
0.042728018,
-0.0429029018,
0.0298949368,
0.0199786127,
0.0079559786,
-0.0187228825,
0.0061066635,
0.0586493649,
-0.0225847345,
-0.0159449633,
-0.0006892991,
2.77e-7,
-0.0208651591,
0.0028257531,
0.0304650031,
0.0278272256,
0.0299999937,
0.04978301,
0.0215410218,
0.0457273349,
0.0085289897,
0.0330844112,
0.0385220908,
0.0350664034,
0.0225789528,
0.0542712584,
0.0072480915,
0.0587723665,
-0.0396102779,
-0.0396226011,
-0.049330093,
0.0546584576,
0.0799650997,
0.0161952022,
0.0591099076,
0.0056851543,
0.0313296504,
-0.0033487491,
0.0006852491,
-0.0652742758,
-0.0101548731,
-0.014362352,
0.023438653,
0.0351249389,
0.0234674942,
0.0045188465,
-0.008649461,
-0.008664716,
-0.0250121653,
0.0556465425,
0.0004443073,
-0.0150330672,
-0.0446435437,
-0.0697661564,
-0.0000717046,
-0.0602850914,
0.0047197607,
-0.0173196513,
-0.0033091023,
0.00277865,
0.009148174,
-0.0067390776,
0.0422740206,
0.0776752383,
-0.0486333594,
-0.0626105517,
0.0231298711,
0.0334830359,
0.0111498088,
-0.0445785336,
0.0131062558,
0.0280137938,
0.0092189359,
-0.0140291704,
0.0097869737,
0.0478518493,
0.0486107953,
-0.0132030668,
0.0057132374,
2.347135055e-34,
-0.009523279,
0.0532576777,
-0.017881155,
-0.081683062,
0.0359033383,
0.0300726667,
-0.0059101111,
0.0174274407,
0.0444799885,
-0.026039999,
-0.0139298411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01143v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01143v1 | Towards leveraging LLMs for Conditional QA | 2023-12-02T14:02:52 | 2023-12-02T14:02:52 | Syed-Amad Hussain, Parag Pravin Dakle, SaiKrishna Rallabandi, Preethi Raghavan | cs.CL | cs.CL | This study delves into the capabilities and limitations of Large Language
Models (LLMs) in the challenging domain of conditional question-answering.
Utilizing the Conditional Question Answering (CQA) dataset and focusing on
generative models like T5 and UL2, we assess the performance of LLMs across
diverse question types. Our findings reveal that fine-tuned LLMs can surpass
the state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance in some cases, even without fully
encoding all input context, with an increase of 7-8 points in Exact Match (EM)
and F1 scores for Yes/No questions. However, these models encounter challenges
in extractive question answering, where they lag behind the SOTA by over 10
points, and in mitigating the risk of injecting false information. A study with
oracle-retrievers emphasizes the critical role of effective evidence retrieval,
underscoring the necessity for advanced solutions in this area. Furthermore, we
highlight the significant influence of evaluation metrics on performance
assessments and advocate for a more comprehensive evaluation framework. The
complexity of the task, the observed performance discrepancies, and the need
for effective evidence retrieval underline the ongoing challenges in this field
and underscore the need for future work focusing on refining training tasks and
exploring prompt-based techniques to enhance LLM performance in conditional
question-answering tasks. | [
0.0591633879,
0.0385007188,
-0.0097120004,
0.034930829,
-0.039597448,
0.0153256608,
-0.0042787115,
0.0101929838,
0.0117408056,
-0.0486661233,
-0.0300264545,
-0.0200953837,
-0.0777814761,
0.0249700658,
0.0258539487,
-0.0123039037,
0.0470188633,
-0.0220347047,
0.0021220495,
-0.0206306987,
-0.0027177795,
0.0022976911,
0.0058811656,
0.0040396624,
0.0200566426,
-0.0366704874,
0.0125141079,
0.0009927617,
0.0146231968,
0.0027870631,
0.0142923072,
0.0392775536,
0.0359276459,
0.0083984761,
0.0000019262,
-0.0448430069,
-0.0107262088,
-0.0029038012,
-0.0461294614,
0.0009228019,
-0.0190133117,
0.0224453881,
0.0326005071,
0.0352658406,
-0.0696298778,
-0.0135223586,
0.003252296,
0.0252021048,
0.042623695,
0.0646470338,
0.0235156305,
-0.0368993469,
0.0288465973,
-0.0155075835,
0.0430011302,
-0.0312589481,
0.0343331173,
0.0218247361,
0.01171498,
0.0273750257,
0.005678765,
0.0389562994,
0.0563062578,
0.0151708312,
-0.028789008,
0.0443203896,
-0.0262823645,
0.0159427635,
-0.0028743965,
0.0786512494,
0.0264362656,
-0.0206994675,
-0.0257892143,
-0.0009184603,
0.0291602835,
0.0188273843,
-0.0406171419,
0.0333690681,
-0.0077932817,
-0.0125885159,
0.0197177511,
0.0110577885,
0.0094926953,
0.0142634222,
-0.0365533382,
0.0790154934,
0.0177115276,
-0.0591331944,
0.0128948167,
-0.0016995455,
-0.0594688766,
-0.0191181786,
-0.0093166661,
0.0471379943,
-0.0075041889,
0.015632499,
-0.0092405109,
0.0087109255,
0.0414799601,
-0.0118693085,
0.0085454583,
0.0243271198,
-0.0329307728,
0.0625007376,
-0.0342611447,
0.0487648696,
-0.0193325393,
0.0369658694,
-0.067072764,
-0.0493865199,
-0.0198977645,
-0.0424522348,
-0.0217542537,
0.0359483249,
-0.0372404009,
-0.0006135184,
-0.0004164538,
0.0104792453,
0.0101124272,
-0.0038729457,
0.0162228961,
0.0365192071,
-0.0234588925,
-0.0096430741,
-0.0703608468,
0.0118458457,
-0.0540387817,
0.0590007007,
0.027556587,
-0.0867417455,
-0.0390611924,
0.017406743,
-0.0050626942,
-0.029884778,
0.0399619676,
0.0535088144,
0.0014228713,
-0.0342477821,
-0.0231020208,
-0.0178676415,
0.0126818949,
-0.0620441958,
-0.0049622445,
-0.0570174977,
0.0383597165,
0.0149557097,
-0.0290875845,
-0.001141833,
0.0033106685,
0.042292662,
0.0267228428,
0.0489906259,
0.0175581966,
0.005232973,
0.0217923801,
0.0190535337,
-0.0125710079,
0.0617945604,
0.0203316063,
0.0312038753,
0.050970003,
0.0019107923,
0.0063866498,
0.0145309838,
0.0155750923,
0.0125823459,
-0.0159302223,
0.0911857784,
0.0361921005,
0.0020826277,
0.0306029301,
0.042497687,
-0.0072546434,
-0.057640627,
0.0449609645,
0.0447642617,
0.0125282416,
-0.0030776809,
0.0555554219,
0.0010744063,
0.0158952586,
0.0079364777,
-0.0251378287,
0.0092382226,
-0.0437033698,
0.0248904452,
0.0057693506,
0.0351462029,
-0.0506314971,
-0.0427636206,
-0.0143097574,
0.019607408,
-0.0325731821,
0.0881875977,
0.0264848135,
0.0012966309,
-0.0193630382,
0.0318634659,
0.0158330556,
-0.0322372839,
0.0086689861,
-0.0520150922,
0.0919009149,
0.0101434411,
0.0402224548,
-0.0410861373,
-0.0382698625,
0.011340417,
-0.0282417964,
0.0102244047,
0.026222026,
-0.0222777482,
0.0193001032,
-0.0251086783,
0.0234388951,
-0.0407385565,
0.0123722516,
0.0087674009,
0.0209163241,
0.018048903,
0.0066480399,
-0.05300951,
0.0193761159,
0.0321251564,
-0.0304608196,
-0.0621434972,
0.0201497991,
-0.0209164452,
0.0173970405,
0.008331757,
-0.0033075481,
0.028441228,
0.052574072,
-0.0352247916,
-0.0368104801,
-0.0239536408,
-0.0571158454,
-0.0636923164,
0.0140418103,
0.0049390085,
-0.0217110571,
0.0344459526,
-0.0618260503,
-0.0340049416,
-0.0246073101,
-0.0171306189,
0.0070623085,
-0.0613820143,
-0.0206840113,
0.0280754343,
0.0156764425,
-0.0649053976,
0.0723428726,
-0.0145286499,
0.0158461463,
0.0050806836,
0.0170758646,
0.0112653179,
-0.0500430763,
0.0015865167,
-0.0331495181,
-0.002503505,
0.0062422417,
-0.0008476133,
0.0173649192,
-0.0719301403,
-0.0301378928,
-0.0738883317,
0.0487123504,
-0.0334446169,
0.0227510482,
0.0320535377,
0.0146988844,
-0.0313423462,
-0.0224898253,
-0.0899854675,
-0.0168792233,
0.0363118909,
0.023243947,
0.0235434026,
0.0265705995,
0.0241364799,
-0.0625065193,
-0.0155307651,
-0.0160712507,
0.0300879627,
-0.0065081925,
0.0254865456,
-0.0157709979,
0.042897705,
-0.0345781744,
0.0306622647,
-0.0242876429,
0.000523771,
-0.0055315034,
-0.0433014371,
0.0207873341,
0.0641291738,
-0.0037150357,
-0.0433486216,
0.031840276,
0.0075519322,
-0.0600748137,
0.0357795507,
-0.023225937,
-0.038820006,
-0.0018672592,
-0.0315782353,
-0.0023865381,
0.0305055548,
0.031456098,
-0.0030567148,
-0.0430926196,
0.0107763512,
0.0128475633,
-0.0273225047,
-0.0574480444,
0.0227385722,
-0.0047529284,
0.0615492575,
-0.0182781089,
-0.0293253418,
0.089703016,
-0.0165489316,
-0.0116271144,
-0.0435657986,
-0.0172766075,
-0.0842038691,
0.0554888435,
0.001259556,
-0.0239946563,
0.0206327867,
-0.0078787711,
-0.0489851087,
-0.020677017,
-0.0248684566,
-0.0613265373,
0.0207976773,
-0.0360374711,
0.0119984485,
-0.0206972137,
-0.0513417721,
-0.0546488613,
-0.0654215217,
-0.0092498977,
0.0303558614,
-0.0276662167,
0.0087961508,
-0.016975645,
0.0096265981,
0.0085218595,
-0.0013000746,
-0.0252199471,
-0.0134770954,
-0.0346836187,
0.0839917138,
0.0875521004,
0.0480225347,
0.0231202506,
-0.0301312804,
0.018600883,
0.0455783233,
0.0237447098,
0.0070508476,
-0.0043464219,
-0.0014141233,
0.0303000901,
-0.0349245146,
0.0083500268,
0.0403443612,
0.0242925584,
-0.0540376268,
-0.0248630438,
0.1032474935,
0.0381856151,
-0.0194095038,
-0.0321215205,
-0.0356705673,
0.024441829,
0.0104045784,
0.0349289961,
-0.1172662005,
-0.056965474,
-0.0187931862,
0.0312069878,
-0.0186290704,
-0.0136708179,
0.0096817119,
-0.1294483244,
0.0351638347,
-0.0375416391,
-0.0298119877,
-0.0441799685,
-0.051677268,
0.010116538,
-0.0199903045,
0.022592485,
0.0275810156,
-0.0246330276,
0.0196150374,
0.020546075,
-0.0021305156,
-0.0144883879,
0.0681610256,
-0.0418418981,
0.0141914263,
0.0507047325,
-0.0027077131,
-0.0196786914,
-0.0446977802,
-0.0187343005,
-0.0459398776,
0.0011236153,
-0.0085215466,
0.049547717,
-0.0256783348,
0.0183059648,
-0.0433385521,
0.0217529628,
-0.0137789305,
0.0097716413,
0.0465871654,
0.0758869946,
-0.0298051257,
-0.0145261772,
-0.0381616801,
0.0076759304,
-0.0282953195,
0.0907415003,
0.0378103703,
-0.016042944,
-0.0333212912,
0.0044036494,
-0.0032932542,
-0.02486117,
-0.0270021465,
-0.0000550403,
0.0262660626,
0.0310267508,
-0.0443731658,
-0.0649923235,
0.0294897817,
0.0139193302,
-0.0287285689,
0.029075386,
-0.0140273031,
-0.0015861578,
-0.0297778677,
0.0546905808,
-0.0628385618,
-0.0029039425,
-0.046866823,
0.0015372246,
0.0463391468,
-0.0104941111,
-0.0346650369,
-0.0011277696,
-0.075718008,
-0.0271493047,
-0.0188788008,
0.0411761925,
0.0188190583,
-0.0096216351,
-0.0256207213,
-0.0321777128,
0.014132889,
0.0243639331,
-0.021968022,
0.005077716,
0.0112097384,
0.0009847749,
0.0009924758,
0.0260637011,
-0.0617800355,
-0.0001015774,
-0.0007546548,
0.0566910394,
-0.0212818552,
-0.0487027876,
0.0614492297,
0.007725507,
0.0138383945,
0.0420953073,
-0.0110776126,
-0.0222876705,
0.0210799146,
-0.0125613287,
-0.0286391359,
-0.0093718776,
0.0024491914,
0.0346470326,
-0.0258512404,
-0.0057047289,
-0.004025674,
-0.0359331109,
0.0619324334,
-0.0777993351,
0.0064177993,
0.0631753057,
-0.0157195404,
0.0008443937,
-0.0407976955,
-0.0367950127,
-0.0095303478,
0.0247948524,
0.0826457217,
0.0102275359,
0.075681299,
0.0132109588,
-0.0074279048,
-0.0171759296,
0.0184849333,
-0.0843341276,
-0.0666256621,
-0.0045138374,
0.0414868928,
0.0253619105,
0.0207475442,
-0.0219648201,
-0.0018725764,
-0.0114627909,
-0.0096447859,
-0.0411394872,
0.0251382366,
0.0001653338,
0.1220729053,
0.0234267097,
-0.023038201,
0.0233998448,
0.0679045841,
-0.0286089201,
0.0608451441,
-0.0176681932,
-0.0107620545,
-0.0168327987,
-0.0299281105,
0.0148666939,
-0.0058825612,
-0.0193742067,
0.0204004645,
-0.0599974394,
-0.0480342172,
0.0077028093,
0.0310078748,
-0.0134042865,
-0.0111581134,
0.0284499954,
0.0697234571,
0.0409368649,
-0.058135815,
-0.0518455356,
0.039782647,
-0.0274846759,
-0.0204737075,
-0.0407953486,
-6.834688559e-33,
-0.0307538845,
0.0016637804,
0.0474254154,
-0.0308263805,
-0.0054378361,
0.0140654799,
-0.0183361024,
-0.0136745367,
-0.0637558401,
-0.0245666783,
-0.033398889,
0.006297763,
0.0052363616,
0.0412467904,
-0.0026875362,
-0.0367364027,
-0.0064004748,
0.0104464665,
-0.0250546373,
0.0161262732,
0.035562519,
0.010906145,
-0.004845609,
-0.0057504852,
0.0323143937,
-0.0477233604,
0.0189898591,
0.0384802856,
-0.069692269,
0.0527364872,
-0.0305839665,
0.0342801474,
0.0381410867,
-0.0433423221,
0.0220851917,
0.0450978689,
-0.0826659873,
-0.0430272929,
0.043467734,
-0.0426785946,
-0.044220604,
-0.0160152894,
-0.0104701426,
0.0167640802,
0.0141110597,
-0.0009475933,
0.0172427222,
-0.0061187483,
-0.0005292645,
-0.042467121,
-0.0295279939,
0.0233561751,
-0.0067449622,
-0.004944142,
-0.0269090645,
0.0803521574,
0.0053843288,
0.0400160998,
-0.0303458422,
-0.0051015113,
0.0411789306,
0.0287731066,
0.0421068817,
0.0184109528,
0.0037629067,
0.021384621,
0.0114557995,
-0.0395392925,
-0.0199044421,
-0.0269548967,
-0.0145029286,
0.0191325415,
0.0605011545,
0.0344090946,
0.0296537932,
0.0285485238,
-0.0869283527,
0.0429545455,
0.0275325477,
0.0506398194,
0.022109583,
0.0028158827,
-0.0312606096,
-0.005134936,
-0.0658669621,
0.0472918712,
-0.0290229134,
-0.0041385465,
0.063737601,
-0.0010135345,
0.0113067646,
-0.0108028501,
0.0334105641,
-0.030242471,
0.0352886356,
0.0307195541,
-0.0122162066,
0.0011992381,
-0.0064466069,
0.0825767443,
-0.0638386831,
0.0212011952,
0.0392589271,
-0.0471857861,
-0.022274876,
0.0064058695,
0.016655501,
0.0029133009,
-0.0386324264,
-0.0058806073,
-0.0222509,
0.0292709712,
-0.0299853776,
-0.0055743493,
0.0175450891,
0.0699232966,
0.0023216361,
0.0208346453,
0.013885092,
0.0052586095,
-0.0326592103,
-0.0156454016,
0.0014257517,
-0.0048846626,
-0.0373360999,
0.0472151674,
-0.026034968,
0.0392819867,
-0.0443345234,
-0.0243861564,
-0.0020946122,
0.0605149381,
2.566e-7,
0.0660554096,
0.0057099108,
0.010061386,
0.0474853218,
-0.0175141599,
0.0331790671,
-0.0007280756,
0.0071785264,
0.0750175565,
-0.0055005592,
-0.0047147074,
0.0446864851,
0.0406651571,
0.0262289532,
-0.0429575406,
0.0172597263,
-0.0720600039,
-0.0580696203,
-0.0329882652,
-0.0216299407,
0.0758357719,
0.1120334715,
-0.0273301136,
-0.0222385507,
-0.0038995566,
-0.0485383607,
0.0489237085,
-0.0199017003,
-0.0439607948,
0.0143756401,
0.0516089462,
0.0225679222,
0.0261546709,
0.0408626013,
0.0141286952,
0.0308720693,
-0.0172144417,
0.0610268489,
0.0137338703,
-0.050494045,
-0.0097233793,
-0.0359311588,
0.0327437483,
-0.0790783018,
0.1220893636,
-0.039844282,
-0.0264256857,
-0.0059845941,
-0.0403360762,
-0.0053149443,
0.0193095133,
-0.0254058857,
-0.0244796462,
0.007119176,
0.0078988075,
-0.0084779505,
-0.0117879529,
-0.0596727431,
0.0202293489,
0.0144491466,
-0.0441433899,
-0.0516665913,
-0.0101998849,
0.0016230093,
-0.0277415812,
-0.0788331479,
0.0092532746,
2.350183764e-34,
0.0304966606,
0.0115953768,
0.0152792204,
0.0619279146,
0.0482968017,
0.0223107561,
-0.0270695388,
-0.0121929208,
0.0165285114,
-0.1143602505,
-0.007072669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01114v1 | TURead: An eye movement dataset of Turkish reading | 2023-12-02T12:10:48 | 2023-12-02T12:10:48 | Cengiz Acarturk, Aysegul Ozkan, Tugce Nur Pekcetin, Zuhal Ormanoglu, Bilal Kirkici | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | In this study, we present TURead, an eye movement dataset of silent and oral
sentence reading in Turkish, an agglutinative language with a shallow
orthography understudied in reading research. TURead provides empirical data to
investigate the relationship between morphology and oculomotor control. We
employ a target-word approach in which target words are manipulated by word
length and by the addition of two commonly used suffixes in Turkish. The
dataset contains well-established eye movement variables; prelexical
characteristics such as vowel harmony and bigram-trigram frequencies and word
features, such as word length, predictability, frequency, eye voice span
measures, Cloze test scores of the root word and suffix predictabilities, as
well as the scores obtained from two working memory tests. Our findings on
fixation parameters and word characteristics are in line with the patterns
reported in the relevant literature. | [
-0.0053429017,
0.0040564449,
-0.0365462601,
-0.0025898365,
-0.0163433533,
0.0303678364,
0.0440394245,
0.0176533666,
-0.0183193982,
0.0277517922,
-0.0480889902,
-0.0656121448,
0.0888940021,
-0.0008949152,
0.0505067594,
-0.0315487497,
0.0297304094,
-0.060619615,
-0.0202288292,
0.0402202755,
0.0456925258,
0.0187512431,
-0.035549026,
0.0013648052,
-0.0283391215,
0.0049914606,
-0.0177902319,
-0.0329271965,
0.0060344818,
0.0205204636,
-0.0200589933,
0.0398233235,
-0.0550655089,
0.0266213715,
0.0000015968,
-0.042164728,
0.006703286,
-0.0284665152,
0.0241889469,
0.0116494605,
0.0746829882,
-0.0374189503,
-0.0241813641,
0.0014665558,
0.0232307687,
-0.0015732036,
0.0646107048,
-0.0269959122,
-0.0432607755,
0.0218267944,
-0.0136758387,
0.0072759283,
0.0312118363,
-0.0025750694,
-0.0003774402,
0.0051051457,
0.0030993209,
-0.0333741158,
-0.0596532933,
-0.0097206933,
-0.057523977,
0.0497265011,
-0.0746470019,
0.0320460536,
-0.0086661661,
0.0083923386,
0.0286160372,
-0.0898205489,
0.0104140397,
0.024265226,
0.0012081142,
-0.0481026322,
-0.0147264134,
0.0232390035,
-0.0151152983,
0.0837031975,
-0.010161913,
0.0117364535,
-0.0173472222,
-0.0193110704,
0.0583332516,
0.0017918744,
-0.0521877483,
-0.0254995413,
-0.0492567122,
0.000816512,
0.041502811,
-0.0618470348,
0.0287345536,
0.0037709812,
0.0544885509,
0.0064565288,
0.0102392239,
0.0111661693,
0.0181474574,
0.0297711752,
-0.0037342734,
-0.0976200178,
0.0098091029,
0.0024074828,
0.0615796559,
0.0103743412,
-0.0213774536,
-0.0044027884,
-0.0678179339,
0.0246881098,
0.0000724721,
-0.0199264362,
-0.0235860385,
0.0017503033,
0.0160275325,
-0.0154035874,
-0.0142541174,
-0.0774189904,
-0.0322798081,
-0.0152198654,
-0.0632057339,
0.0156802442,
0.0574281253,
-0.0356679708,
-0.0380893499,
0.0021765842,
-0.0015130069,
0.0025489631,
-0.0045078029,
0.0394853316,
-0.0444208533,
-0.0090170875,
-0.0699715912,
-0.0656443685,
0.0286799408,
0.0368568189,
0.0022132497,
0.0202025585,
-0.0059841988,
0.0427556671,
-0.0400065482,
-0.0389780961,
0.0120913042,
0.0134314494,
-0.0434598215,
-0.0305901971,
-0.0353832468,
-0.0417674631,
0.0061304062,
0.0283209682,
-0.0097984932,
-0.0349534228,
-0.0194513444,
0.0507434644,
-0.0019783541,
0.003025763,
0.0017345251,
0.0227823406,
-0.011591116,
-0.0172827467,
0.0418330394,
0.0179187413,
0.0184721984,
-0.0149164461,
0.0039424654,
-0.0430624671,
0.0269261729,
0.0455448627,
0.0004955968,
-0.0032218941,
-0.0188249443,
-0.0296651386,
0.049940899,
0.0130325807,
0.0124113979,
0.035439577,
0.0157153886,
-0.0429707877,
0.044855576,
0.122069478,
0.0429513268,
0.0015024688,
-0.0660141855,
-0.0107479841,
0.0156220281,
0.0049046902,
0.0417013541,
-0.0080147572,
-0.009223341,
0.0051216721,
-0.0544269234,
0.009425533,
0.0257723872,
-0.0061386093,
-0.0283619966,
0.0304830484,
-0.0354972966,
-0.0375473462,
0.0691509098,
-0.0160239544,
-0.0643927455,
-0.0152999517,
0.0163063221,
-0.0328782648,
-0.0237422958,
0.0117652779,
0.054452505,
0.0041431054,
0.0104810279,
-0.0381501727,
0.0010932279,
0.0296447109,
-0.0083671091,
0.018934017,
-0.027541751,
0.0019651074,
0.0197148174,
-0.0515916124,
0.0335164256,
0.07076554,
0.0005360364,
-0.0075573316,
-0.0588626787,
0.0839035138,
-0.0108053153,
0.0259291083,
-0.0272021256,
0.0363264084,
-0.0114557669,
0.0150744691,
-0.0547020473,
0.015537574,
-0.006048223,
-0.0254469514,
-0.0119407875,
0.0191835668,
-0.0062686699,
0.0114944587,
0.1263652146,
0.0279589538,
-0.0124744801,
0.0606238768,
0.0302577764,
-0.026856564,
0.0191413425,
-0.0106490813,
0.0859829932,
-0.0497432575,
0.0631785169,
-0.0614880919,
0.0429630801,
-0.0063444702,
0.0696653351,
-0.0245505907,
0.022974981,
-0.0244615637,
0.0006475146,
-0.0135143325,
0.0091969762,
0.0014073813,
-0.0002463626,
0.0062895808,
0.0054714773,
0.0016359239,
0.0135662537,
-0.0023022022,
-0.0280396342,
-0.0135206487,
-0.0423029475,
-0.027485827,
-0.0352711231,
-0.0389458612,
-0.0518869609,
-0.003062414,
0.0426758192,
0.0051417612,
-0.0054618292,
-0.0308650639,
0.0081880456,
-0.0125081297,
0.0526863672,
0.0142426305,
-0.0130323451,
0.0032798161,
-0.0482983366,
-0.0202177484,
-0.0319189243,
-0.0418050326,
-0.0037722511,
0.0145887351,
0.0685411543,
-0.0734379664,
-0.0374773778,
0.0356998332,
-0.002220137,
-0.0021416668,
-0.0175719839,
-0.0145786647,
0.0599771291,
-0.0165936463,
0.0780043304,
0.047156781,
-0.0056570149,
0.0015025727,
0.0331834704,
-0.0545792617,
0.003932667,
-0.0553972758,
0.0017371398,
-0.0007630114,
-0.0530790724,
-0.0265597906,
0.0055224313,
0.047380425,
-0.0052677267,
-0.0035786997,
-0.0196118057,
0.0010013666,
-0.0423080586,
-0.0137470765,
-0.0175864939,
0.0173702203,
-0.0719123483,
0.0915330127,
-0.0123882107,
-0.0762134939,
0.0091543328,
-0.0306011084,
-0.0076239542,
-0.0487866811,
0.0538233593,
-0.0144791268,
0.0251460969,
-0.0194554981,
-0.0245494042,
0.007018378,
-0.0616545156,
-0.040924713,
0.0221451763,
-0.0000936565,
-0.0131335212,
0.080509603,
-0.0343608633,
-0.0187958125,
0.0225265529,
0.0570236817,
-0.0191737637,
0.0175742935,
-0.0066478234,
-0.0717283711,
0.0475440994,
-0.0405571163,
-0.0536445789,
-0.001626162,
0.0236777626,
0.0169433001,
0.001299307,
0.0174774863,
-0.0028950861,
-0.0033464667,
0.0391756631,
0.0134898508,
-0.0372603275,
-0.037173938,
-0.045900505,
0.0717664436,
-0.0096288407,
-0.0316587128,
0.0229047239,
0.0052191587,
0.0601545312,
-0.043766994,
0.0183270965,
-0.0530358441,
-0.0279735643,
-0.0391848274,
0.0140188187,
0.0369263254,
0.0664108619,
0.0087574935,
-0.0154619077,
-0.031259384,
0.0639564171,
0.0075738989,
-0.0263803471,
-0.004338888,
0.0041816342,
0.0032527826,
0.0611292757,
0.0163463932,
0.0063876561,
0.0397835746,
-0.0764738843,
-0.0050708773,
0.0111028394,
-0.0623220652,
-0.0160244666,
-0.0060509918,
0.0554460026,
-0.0307355467,
-0.0465485342,
0.0527530387,
-0.0063368352,
0.0098643992,
0.0158014074,
-0.0508271828,
0.0353984497,
-0.0340991765,
-0.0383142978,
-0.0224082284,
-0.0106458189,
0.0021819982,
-0.009826838,
-0.0313016921,
0.0072274827,
-0.0324093625,
-0.0019262683,
-0.0019106086,
0.0550812222,
0.0158639848,
-0.0305268411,
-0.0816561952,
0.0167839341,
-0.0231491793,
0.0196148027,
0.0058556246,
0.0000480258,
0.0395609885,
0.0111985253,
0.024472544,
0.0190583151,
-0.0478594564,
-0.0259409864,
-0.0059508896,
-0.0493840277,
-0.0459940284,
0.0187017247,
-0.008842851,
-0.0052532572,
-0.0370857641,
-0.0024079061,
0.0357169583,
-0.0478136279,
-0.0870915204,
-0.0336154886,
0.074882701,
0.0526527166,
0.0737836435,
0.0265175849,
0.0413710438,
-0.0359634086,
-0.0301616769,
0.0117692892,
0.0406202003,
0.0311914254,
-0.0788938403,
-0.0122940233,
0.0471919589,
-0.0154561326,
0.0109139318,
0.0420183241,
-0.0398600213,
-0.0496329479,
0.05004666,
-0.0127873942,
0.0196452048,
-0.002860734,
0.0076895203,
-0.0191833824,
0.0141090024,
-0.0700023919,
0.0004176059,
0.06824781,
-0.0174909458,
-0.0262995064,
0.0199818145,
-0.0110165915,
0.0363802612,
-0.0222694743,
0.0068822894,
-0.0417457819,
-0.0248798653,
0.0026163973,
-0.0184264984,
-0.0033431076,
0.0080447821,
-0.0045919851,
0.0463022813,
-0.0990584344,
-0.00269082,
0.0058303783,
0.0508420058,
0.0356362127,
-0.0056038131,
0.0618475713,
0.0115134157,
-0.0536417328,
-0.0648751259,
-0.0646693259,
-0.0915510729,
-0.039995499,
0.094275035,
-0.0169180389,
0.0059337178,
0.0230399277,
0.036802087,
0.0051085409,
0.0777601898,
-0.093254745,
0.0563937239,
0.0396221392,
0.0161791593,
0.0015868866,
-0.0220568888,
0.0068231346,
-0.0006143033,
0.029468609,
0.0486982279,
0.0351615101,
-0.0172010083,
-0.0167545602,
-0.0746917501,
0.0476881377,
-0.0474081896,
0.0116833439,
-0.0100481519,
-0.0102734808,
-0.0463463478,
0.0164576694,
-0.027179176,
-0.008655604,
-0.0097035719,
-0.0183351282,
0.0305748917,
0.025822863,
-0.0574377216,
0.0243013464,
-0.0421035402,
-0.0124124009,
0.0065257158,
0.0288049784,
0.0022906177,
-0.0423775353,
0.0197520759,
-0.0698000342,
-0.069193773,
0.0218578968,
0.0102141574,
0.0539182425,
-0.0104898969,
0.03449516,
0.0036706273,
0.008192094,
0.0652588457,
-0.0189961009,
-0.0019739263,
-0.0017028155,
-0.0287999734,
0.0007128694,
-5.139179385e-33,
0.0167848226,
-0.0138281155,
-0.0132948244,
-0.0193083584,
-0.0027922685,
0.0166652631,
0.0108177876,
0.0533090308,
0.0088140536,
-0.0093165506,
0.0069680698,
0.0137904696,
0.0002745966,
0.001147535,
0.006831123,
0.004815862,
-0.0502725542,
-0.0355823524,
-0.0241567641,
-0.0141238216,
0.0799533278,
0.0162103213,
0.0686313063,
-0.0153247882,
0.0162923355,
-0.0039559696,
0.0448859371,
-0.0391139798,
0.0103840865,
0.0391033366,
-0.0075362995,
0.0541434884,
0.0098861493,
-0.0013882436,
0.0127918422,
0.03143318,
-0.0545680262,
-0.0105517879,
0.0430144481,
0.0662575513,
-0.0345920138,
0.0430672765,
0.018158609,
-0.010413019,
-0.0037724643,
0.0045140185,
0.0233820248,
-0.0333187208,
-0.0261484105,
0.0685383901,
-0.0885506421,
0.0157921985,
-0.0295539498,
0.0062325108,
0.0429680534,
0.0025592467,
0.0321218781,
-0.0563040115,
0.0012921386,
0.0321925953,
-0.0051897448,
0.040883448,
0.0370253809,
0.0488464162,
-0.0021143847,
0.0329564996,
0.046533376,
-0.000694044,
-0.0198448263,
0.0094767334,
0.0790601075,
0.0047875443,
0.0163852703,
-0.036083404,
0.0380604304,
-0.0547495261,
0.0018099435,
-0.0568985529,
0.0158519614,
0.0585205518,
0.0117979785,
-0.0251586307,
-0.0471206605,
-0.013011815,
0.0518817119,
0.0275646262,
-0.0243597664,
0.0391570888,
0.0427504852,
-0.0221868381,
0.0109089371,
-0.0052689444,
0.0276036486,
-0.0107092969,
0.0602346137,
-0.0089515364,
-0.0158166438,
0.0501622632,
-0.0160418618,
0.0137138404,
-0.0189325977,
0.0088719083,
0.0154672749,
0.0186518189,
0.038135808,
0.0042407322,
-0.0429795645,
-0.0594874397,
-0.0584555306,
-0.0076884334,
-0.0285723228,
-0.0004470543,
0.004589281,
0.031462092,
0.0601332486,
-0.0411328338,
-0.008573126,
-0.0133528067,
0.0485413,
-0.0562890358,
-0.0396439172,
-0.0495639108,
-0.0150622958,
-0.0344251394,
-0.008507899,
0.0315188281,
0.0253144,
0.0226674657,
0.0220016986,
-0.0248661116,
0.0120722158,
0.0498781018,
2.515e-7,
0.0365972966,
0.0607623421,
0.0477103293,
0.0447249897,
0.0114113986,
-0.0527459942,
-0.0111731533,
0.0271028373,
0.0099431705,
-0.0084154243,
0.0259282775,
-0.0199770369,
0.0458699986,
-0.0250737127,
-0.0522840731,
-0.0486800857,
0.0487720259,
0.0645890459,
-0.0579824597,
0.0322153084,
0.0018966584,
0.0098872082,
-0.0460490696,
-0.041687075,
-0.0057686949,
-0.0073180874,
0.0145913707,
-0.0088819312,
0.0294181593,
0.0065083453,
0.0651082322,
0.0061197248,
-0.0067800353,
0.0399108529,
-0.0264578741,
0.0247572791,
0.0479744561,
-0.0484509729,
-0.046933841,
-0.0137902722,
0.0647677779,
-0.0053390241,
-0.0460389294,
-0.0325500555,
0.0420215875,
0.0725434646,
-0.0018394631,
0.0723359138,
0.0119240312,
0.0241755806,
0.0159235783,
-0.0018981504,
-0.0169402566,
0.0248781815,
0.0407476872,
-0.0323686637,
-0.0228922218,
-0.0037310875,
0.0182772763,
-0.003326897,
-0.0017400992,
-0.0547239296,
0.0091364942,
-0.0142445667,
0.0273798723,
0.0240560584,
-0.0591387898,
1.646829359e-34,
0.0035156331,
-0.015633462,
0.0435864329,
0.0156090055,
-0.0082545923,
-0.0476075411,
0.0628114268,
0.0552536696,
0.0539399274,
-0.0796872228,
-0.0376944952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03751v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03751v1 | Which linguistic cues make people fall for fake news? A comparison of cognitive and affective processing | 2023-12-02T11:06:14 | 2023-12-02T11:06:14 | Bernhard Lutz, Marc Adam, Stefan Feuerriegel, Nicolas Pröllochs, Dirk Neumann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Fake news on social media has large, negative implications for society.
However, little is known about what linguistic cues make people fall for fake
news and, hence, how to design effective countermeasures for social media. In
this study, we seek to understand which linguistic cues make people fall for
fake news. Linguistic cues (e.g., adverbs, personal pronouns, positive emotion
words, negative emotion words) are important characteristics of any text and
also affect how people process real vs. fake news. Specifically, we compare the
role of linguistic cues across both cognitive processing (related to careful
thinking) and affective processing (related to unconscious automatic
evaluations). To this end, we performed a within-subject experiment where we
collected neurophysiological measurements of 42 subjects while these read a
sample of 40 real and fake news articles. During our experiment, we measured
cognitive processing through eye fixations, and affective processing in situ
through heart rate variability. We find that users engage more in cognitive
processing for longer fake news articles, while affective processing is more
pronounced for fake news written in analytic words. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work studying the role of linguistic cues in fake
news processing. Altogether, our findings have important implications for
designing online platforms that encourage users to engage in careful thinking
and thus prevent them from falling for fake news. | [
0.0602178052,
0.0183253884,
-0.037460722,
-0.0076552066,
-0.0052576824,
0.0063523022,
0.0143334782,
0.0363882184,
0.0534469076,
-0.0175094511,
-0.0274757203,
-0.0201691911,
0.0236158967,
0.0381245874,
0.0377689861,
-0.0342991948,
0.0238816608,
0.029937407,
0.0963590145,
-0.0018263356,
0.0568440519,
0.0510966592,
0.0004329127,
0.005480784,
-0.0034363554,
-0.0117244143,
0.0153016755,
0.0078092692,
0.0454658307,
-0.0466575511,
-0.006235729,
0.0657525137,
-0.0312662236,
0.0168731045,
0.0000018348,
0.0006913375,
-0.0067942659,
-0.034812782,
-0.0169827789,
0.0040307194,
0.0846177489,
-0.0337124467,
-0.0347413905,
0.0118533773,
-0.0245806091,
0.0014925065,
0.0209055468,
0.0651669577,
0.053929206,
0.0750720128,
-0.0220538694,
0.0388289467,
-0.011500312,
0.0037531687,
0.026434008,
-0.0137327285,
0.0369386636,
-0.0537299365,
-0.0345681868,
0.0097741969,
0.0051494697,
-0.0089112101,
-0.0006788855,
0.0048937607,
-0.0350412987,
0.0184037592,
-0.0302081164,
-0.0584696122,
-0.0062366878,
0.0147739695,
-0.0264596529,
-0.0386570878,
0.0141390683,
0.0001353066,
0.0093075251,
0.0563365631,
-0.0008422322,
0.0290289894,
-0.0394417904,
-0.0208018627,
0.0210743435,
-0.0168204922,
0.000070783,
0.0534134619,
0.0634365827,
0.0508502237,
-0.0164113361,
-0.0328421257,
0.0556174591,
0.0087620113,
0.0062313075,
-0.0403763987,
0.031307511,
-0.0367317051,
0.0141106881,
0.0041795759,
-0.0456458628,
-0.023809921,
0.0280797016,
-0.1142180339,
0.0047385949,
0.0133757647,
0.0016241879,
0.0202261955,
-0.0100137349,
-0.0015601451,
-0.0519144945,
0.0227202792,
-0.0040131719,
0.0525800623,
0.02630019,
0.0050425334,
0.0205017179,
-0.0058561349,
0.0047014118,
-0.0321197584,
-0.0444061011,
-0.0338905714,
-0.0343593992,
-0.022613626,
-0.0536180772,
0.0242245011,
0.0017898298,
0.0088491738,
-0.0284233652,
0.0407795683,
-0.0362668745,
0.0242360551,
-0.0126962736,
-0.0406793207,
0.0037331018,
0.0198504589,
0.0132977869,
0.0059239683,
0.0045724828,
-0.0313178338,
0.0047478573,
-0.0029755151,
-0.0531800762,
-0.0124139423,
0.0015306729,
-0.0280420724,
-0.00075579,
-0.0298701432,
-0.0194610264,
0.0115336711,
-0.0007677987,
-0.0343789048,
-0.0045403061,
0.0438741781,
-0.0435765125,
0.0300231762,
-0.0158808716,
0.0018418564,
0.0349202529,
0.0502544902,
0.0224019997,
0.0633337125,
-0.005518598,
0.1021849066,
0.0386928283,
0.0143914558,
0.0284374692,
-0.0040507019,
0.0074775713,
-0.0140928738,
-0.0071568717,
-0.014200436,
-0.0561698489,
-0.0023135506,
0.0406523123,
-0.0023750006,
-0.0223968979,
0.0142508522,
0.0895937011,
0.0114455754,
-0.0303520933,
0.0030729913,
0.0111366538,
-0.0013418101,
0.0283877999,
0.0179620925,
-0.0385484286,
0.0289240535,
-0.0401556157,
-0.0183824394,
-0.033895772,
0.0146789001,
0.0095723486,
-0.0034094099,
-0.0239595156,
0.0195410866,
0.0278508179,
-0.0063178972,
-0.0423796922,
0.007103039,
-0.035095565,
-0.0051050745,
0.039367076,
-0.0244586766,
-0.0010513798,
-0.010967223,
-0.0085048759,
0.0425769947,
-0.0302630514,
0.0569892786,
0.043536894,
-0.0246240068,
0.0249386076,
0.0747873038,
0.0460742563,
0.0030284335,
-0.0671161339,
-0.0068708225,
-0.0042468784,
-0.0153706782,
0.0094566317,
0.017616421,
-0.0059661716,
0.0735247508,
-0.0172744486,
0.0393515602,
-0.0281972289,
0.0108398125,
0.0050448547,
-0.0289337337,
-0.0618459657,
0.052163478,
0.0368236266,
-0.014333941,
0.0100867869,
-0.009206133,
0.0130477753,
0.0319172181,
-0.0179275163,
-0.0046789278,
0.0330963768,
0.0359385088,
-0.0138867404,
-0.059101034,
-0.0217989013,
0.0216667969,
0.044015687,
0.0234112926,
0.0358178467,
-0.0610217936,
0.0138482824,
0.0000881758,
-0.0398772433,
-0.0424012318,
0.0245984886,
0.0321379565,
0.0696475953,
-0.0246340781,
0.0325310454,
-0.0367815346,
-0.0172533933,
-0.0227946527,
-0.0070508826,
0.0006027643,
-0.017512979,
0.0187782552,
-0.0216485597,
0.0246458557,
-0.0561220311,
-0.0684484094,
-0.0044431221,
-0.0616821758,
-0.0255130846,
0.0006516272,
0.0029947285,
0.0456850305,
-0.0337797515,
-0.0470219627,
0.0453498401,
-0.0232448671,
-0.0288107581,
-0.0292404052,
0.0361225717,
-0.043393556,
-0.04586263,
0.0252966713,
-0.0131978281,
0.0366526358,
-0.0285838619,
0.0180214774,
0.0396545939,
-0.0601730719,
-0.0265303385,
-0.0020137082,
-0.0354908556,
-0.0066283331,
-0.0117963133,
-0.0654551536,
0.0210969448,
0.0446228161,
-0.006547627,
0.1120259687,
0.0770164952,
0.075904578,
0.0199901946,
0.0394046195,
-0.0278766006,
-0.0277357101,
-0.0434759781,
0.0492713451,
-0.0190557353,
-0.0880498588,
-0.0056216647,
0.0381327569,
0.0502838977,
0.0436200909,
-0.0133220823,
0.0748199746,
-0.042239476,
-0.0623208843,
0.0412154794,
-0.0608270988,
-0.0449306183,
0.0423978828,
-0.0123582603,
-0.0255603734,
0.0802103281,
0.0385112688,
0.0393076502,
-0.0341949426,
0.020132849,
0.0266278107,
-0.0203739367,
-0.034509819,
0.0352700576,
0.0368682779,
-0.0080817891,
-0.0192200914,
-0.030187048,
0.0684441328,
-0.0440144576,
-0.0130292894,
0.0049935863,
-0.0066409796,
0.055570323,
-0.0142977452,
-0.0424461998,
-0.0800070316,
-0.0450114161,
-0.071169652,
0.0183013119,
-0.0379234478,
-0.0695571601,
-0.0463228524,
0.0683301687,
-0.0035872429,
-0.0344982296,
-0.0095111979,
0.0262593087,
0.0011708677,
0.0503457785,
-0.0215969291,
0.0696843043,
-0.0086708525,
-0.0028351212,
0.0888362154,
0.0205254257,
0.0209640451,
0.0037525517,
-0.000102866,
0.0068708938,
0.001364363,
0.0077268234,
-0.0229958072,
0.0077309534,
-0.0007303211,
0.0421401039,
0.0731244385,
0.0213897564,
-0.024570033,
0.0035037831,
-0.0121895755,
-0.0341521204,
0.0207139067,
-0.028068278,
-0.0364467874,
0.0021808892,
0.0010148507,
-0.0047543226,
-0.0698205531,
-0.0068631326,
-0.0287746172,
-0.0637256131,
0.0117968703,
-0.0103815347,
0.014070427,
0.0132655445,
-0.0622396618,
0.0257640015,
0.0088277897,
0.0174516439,
-0.0102001866,
-0.0031666497,
-0.0051567303,
-0.0173092317,
0.0262460466,
-0.0017832199,
-0.0124032702,
-0.0156453978,
0.0460225381,
-0.0048445966,
0.0807147846,
-0.0177918244,
-0.0497802459,
0.0029670431,
-0.0335871316,
-0.0088286372,
-0.032785207,
0.0684175342,
-0.0208914671,
0.0223257523,
-0.0855964348,
0.0650385469,
0.0117001105,
-0.0169602223,
-0.0129084932,
0.0264257584,
0.0168748535,
-0.100462608,
-0.0157578439,
0.0242517404,
0.0398775972,
0.0239058025,
0.0241334345,
-0.0419006534,
0.0168442577,
-0.0113228429,
0.0462830476,
-0.0026918589,
-0.1266335845,
0.0120568955,
0.0015783485,
-0.0738457516,
-0.0706694275,
-0.052847404,
-0.0289274827,
0.0124198683,
0.0157315582,
-0.0229710024,
0.0530310795,
-0.0342973061,
-0.0281908847,
0.0667989179,
0.0385434069,
0.0367797203,
0.0057904804,
0.0103691621,
-0.0399475582,
-0.0192684382,
-0.0020304385,
0.0422057137,
-0.01360624,
-0.0099921999,
0.0522327535,
-0.014011031,
0.0216626041,
0.0117934775,
-0.0105532799,
-0.0392580405,
-0.0070352829,
-0.0056495764,
-0.0707618892,
0.0174139086,
0.0035980861,
0.0003736114,
0.0328788534,
-0.0042382339,
0.0373860486,
0.0252235178,
0.0544442199,
-0.0511114821,
-0.0398108922,
-0.0036738871,
0.0372547545,
0.027808411,
0.0284461118,
-0.0395382233,
0.0417503864,
-0.009333184,
-0.0564993843,
0.0120066078,
-0.02809285,
0.0252836365,
-0.0267820936,
0.0362974405,
-0.0052054217,
-0.0285258852,
-0.0191112775,
-0.0634607896,
-0.046086859,
-0.0268910192,
0.0048364047,
-0.0221556742,
0.0610345528,
-0.0096677663,
0.0238141697,
-0.0236921776,
0.0485817306,
-0.0203630906,
0.0299666859,
0.0144845163,
0.0241068844,
0.0206589513,
-0.055544544,
0.0285576824,
-0.0081495941,
-0.0225139577,
0.0254105814,
0.0169058293,
0.0277039688,
-0.0192127135,
-0.0434302203,
0.0410518385,
-0.0019069889,
-0.0046037966,
0.0018086266,
-0.0328584984,
-0.0523549728,
-0.0468969382,
-0.0093250927,
0.0165820327,
-0.0149280271,
0.0015404564,
0.0351759791,
-0.0315304808,
-0.0135482512,
0.0168095212,
-0.0810910463,
-0.0173512455,
0.0173261948,
-0.0146033121,
0.0205103811,
-0.0162716806,
0.0206677392,
-0.0995704979,
-0.0528125539,
0.036006622,
-0.0160755888,
0.0112636639,
-0.0117760357,
0.0044401013,
0.0789986029,
-0.0166569296,
0.0082410881,
-0.019720722,
0.0510903522,
-0.0438268296,
-0.0285798311,
-0.0263699591,
-6.218307076e-33,
0.0453589894,
-0.0734588951,
-0.0621888153,
-0.0022467414,
-0.0140153151,
0.0465876982,
-0.0008497993,
0.0253932513,
0.0026838346,
0.0579995736,
-0.0004513247,
0.0477031097,
0.0130033344,
-0.0347268432,
-0.0278233401,
-0.030704435,
-0.0041079242,
-0.006629236,
-0.0420534201,
-0.0146604804,
0.0336691774,
-0.0143575286,
0.0415636897,
-0.0589268357,
0.0676917508,
0.0077887462,
-0.0258581266,
-0.0489102006,
0.0022870786,
0.0358123779,
-0.0114733241,
0.0541411154,
0.0185256414,
-0.0056811827,
0.0229408387,
0.0903647542,
0.0061848247,
-0.0439722352,
0.0957786366,
0.0148935104,
-0.0328539051,
0.0053885835,
0.0444815718,
-0.0305228699,
-0.0331229605,
0.0197530054,
0.0108785499,
-0.0231606327,
0.0408211686,
-0.0014416686,
-0.0405899622,
-0.0035143597,
0.0161757171,
0.0226834062,
-0.0259364024,
0.0523489155,
-0.0131324595,
0.0028804138,
-0.1090640277,
0.0294615384,
-0.0951741114,
0.0116390791,
0.0046074577,
-0.050410524,
-0.0188761968,
0.0693936273,
0.0176724624,
0.0540085994,
-0.0631043911,
0.0396440625,
0.020207528,
0.0086129736,
0.0700817779,
0.0823458061,
0.0368048921,
-0.0789245814,
-0.0225625578,
0.0058479439,
0.0578866228,
0.0008172164,
0.0222160295,
-0.0373234265,
-0.0204615332,
0.0118941907,
-0.0164921153,
-0.0172902029,
-0.0582861342,
-0.0146884257,
-0.0055937623,
0.0113056591,
-0.0307197236,
0.0016493062,
-0.0133087216,
-0.0091187926,
-0.0045141727,
-0.0070327814,
-0.0114805382,
0.0162447523,
0.0309591163,
0.032953728,
0.0037240826,
0.0598852336,
-0.0198415555,
0.031141242,
0.0368382633,
-0.0397853218,
0.0093664071,
0.008694727,
-0.032084804,
-0.0091953827,
-0.0184922349,
0.0279242676,
0.0060998141,
-0.0413771011,
0.0351299644,
0.0179588217,
-0.0173263941,
-0.0763396546,
0.0426627807,
0.0189216956,
-0.0202192739,
0.024832638,
-0.0642759055,
0.0912513137,
-0.0316514,
-0.0088390829,
-0.0275685117,
0.0059535806,
-0.0012548708,
-0.118931517,
-0.0070930794,
-0.0164139681,
2.838e-7,
-0.0053452556,
0.0774301589,
-0.0155773405,
0.0147026284,
0.0321649052,
0.0534932911,
0.0475658104,
0.0283771511,
0.0322675258,
-0.0954633579,
-0.076887019,
-0.0017095987,
0.0236316603,
0.0262074992,
-0.052085951,
0.0188624728,
-0.02401397,
0.0413377471,
-0.0306929685,
-0.0281574558,
-0.0185439885,
0.0026550766,
0.0331570357,
-0.0350520462,
-0.034086179,
0.0369707048,
0.0255155265,
0.0387195349,
-0.0112972157,
0.0028429381,
0.0287947878,
-0.0424507856,
0.0030150579,
0.0406163037,
-0.0150942821,
-0.0426813774,
0.0405517071,
0.005020739,
0.0239154268,
0.00332966,
0.0049191616,
-0.0510402881,
-0.0102956863,
-0.0599392653,
0.0541602112,
-0.0374558233,
-0.0590755641,
-0.0277540721,
-0.043232128,
-0.0093716877,
0.0494921319,
-0.018122403,
-0.0495455228,
0.0237629674,
0.015674863,
0.0099114422,
0.0110964039,
-0.007829288,
-0.0013468196,
0.0038628827,
-0.0204207338,
-0.0230424665,
-0.0532694459,
0.0263483189,
0.0318452716,
-0.035024818,
0.0056465142,
1.86549553e-34,
-0.0111901499,
-0.0069529414,
0.0192784853,
-0.0364456363,
0.0095408037,
0.0291693993,
-0.001907107,
-0.0193932187,
0.0489293411,
-0.0108695515,
0.0184572767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01090v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01090v2 | Self Generated Wargame AI: Double Layer Agent Task Planning Based on Large Language Model | 2023-12-02T09:45:45 | 2023-12-18T07:30:48 | Y. Sun, J. Zhao, C. Yu, W. Wang, X. Zhou | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The large language models represented by ChatGPT have a disruptive impact on
the field of artificial intelligence. But it mainly focuses on natural language
processing, speech recognition, machine learning and natural language
understanding. This paper innovatively applies the large language model to the
field of intelligent decision-making, places the large language model in the
decision-making center, and constructs an agent architecture with the large
language model as the core. Based on this, it further proposes a two-layer
agent task planning, issues and executes decision commands through the
interaction of natural language, and carries out simulation verification
through the wargame simulation environment. Through the game confrontation
simulation experiment, it is found that the intelligent decision-making ability
of the large language model is significantly stronger than the commonly used
reinforcement learning AI and rule AI, and the intelligence, understandability
and generalization are all better. And through experiments, it was found that
the intelligence of the large language model is closely related to prompt. This
work also extends the large language model from previous human-computer
interaction to the field of intelligent decision-making, which has important
reference value and significance for the development of intelligent
decision-making. | [
0.0508588105,
-0.0273794681,
-0.0373685025,
0.0094465073,
-0.0487191901,
-0.0172939505,
0.0202989094,
0.011567072,
0.0526969284,
-0.0187264569,
-0.0121175982,
-0.0079456326,
-0.0470731705,
0.0544528589,
0.0202026702,
-0.0027146551,
0.004054518,
-0.0464795046,
0.0757251754,
0.0007197336,
-0.0152836833,
-0.0594558641,
-0.0282493699,
0.0230987631,
-0.0014781147,
-0.0006176303,
-0.056498263,
-0.039033711,
0.0050303279,
-0.0717929974,
-0.0103205321,
-0.0133618377,
0.0466266125,
0.0183448754,
0.0000022551,
-0.0642629191,
0.0066267862,
-0.0381904021,
-0.0463451073,
-0.0104469489,
0.0453924499,
0.0437872261,
-0.0191296153,
0.0171208475,
-0.0613000467,
0.0158286374,
0.0588640533,
0.1043638811,
0.0621972606,
0.067342259,
0.0024671217,
-0.0498394966,
0.0034695712,
0.0077569364,
-0.0483467393,
-0.0568035655,
0.011456646,
0.0354511254,
0.0439639166,
0.0039002507,
0.0084713837,
-0.0267931465,
0.0034643933,
0.0009700427,
-0.0718719661,
0.0505302399,
0.0092574758,
0.027633233,
-0.0127948783,
0.0189630762,
-0.0346753448,
-0.0011943839,
0.0297067389,
0.0231706984,
0.0347813033,
-0.0243747085,
-0.0100781731,
0.0461746231,
0.0065576034,
-0.0034080618,
0.0391552001,
0.0244764946,
-0.0194627102,
-0.016558826,
-0.0209873859,
0.0765230283,
-0.0270214155,
-0.004989462,
-0.0189469922,
-0.0314578265,
-0.0239725839,
-0.0612368025,
-0.0307203345,
0.0546652414,
-0.1128400266,
0.0113909496,
-0.0034619027,
0.0036191549,
0.0193565618,
-0.0975592956,
0.0189243276,
0.0217841044,
0.0379978418,
0.0404699519,
-0.0024318069,
0.0930124,
0.0080993874,
0.0051914719,
-0.0301677901,
0.0191580206,
-0.0373942703,
-0.0336986259,
-0.0746126696,
0.0572464205,
-0.0034554626,
-0.0428036749,
-0.0323274471,
-0.0039943419,
-0.0506743789,
0.0479212143,
0.013480844,
0.0040361644,
-0.0054273191,
-0.0047051511,
-0.0746412501,
-0.0571979284,
-0.0506454259,
0.0009150972,
-0.0124307889,
-0.0411645845,
0.0225605108,
-0.0116413441,
-0.021764338,
-0.0120383957,
0.0145722022,
0.1156212538,
-0.012256044,
0.005058263,
-0.0113812238,
0.0085606324,
0.007083639,
-0.0734649152,
-0.0028550308,
-0.0713950992,
0.0240875464,
-0.0520894602,
-0.005098612,
0.01299881,
-0.0015666368,
-0.0019450609,
0.0067009255,
0.0892130435,
0.0035005165,
0.0164532959,
0.0307586752,
-0.004456271,
-0.0072289943,
0.0492032543,
0.0631482303,
0.0123439943,
0.0253701471,
0.0109222131,
0.0429503806,
0.0365235284,
-0.0438268036,
-0.0132404733,
-0.0067009414,
-0.0261887405,
-0.0124310581,
0.0434666872,
-0.044758372,
0.02503304,
-0.0417413041,
-0.0049136505,
0.0429250784,
0.0182440728,
0.027623022,
0.0212774407,
0.0524591506,
0.1009335071,
0.0068735816,
-0.0156357568,
0.0217408706,
0.0467815958,
-0.0323510021,
-0.0120669557,
-0.0588145368,
0.0279891286,
-0.0206643753,
-0.0214846935,
0.0314933434,
-0.0406510569,
0.0503206253,
-0.0055871624,
0.0243060999,
-0.0386600941,
-0.0457812697,
-0.0396694355,
0.043786224,
0.0147817023,
-0.0367927141,
-0.099766694,
0.0139020039,
0.0471511595,
0.0437552854,
-0.0502272546,
-0.0552099086,
-0.0157696661,
-0.015879916,
0.0424791053,
0.0253352672,
0.0186715201,
-0.0404994227,
-0.0348108485,
-0.0256691277,
0.0008129299,
0.006978123,
0.0429516695,
-0.0090076104,
0.0165377911,
-0.0250708871,
0.0604250394,
-0.0261805113,
0.0017688056,
0.0338973142,
-0.0542694926,
-0.004957505,
-0.0139137059,
0.0760297924,
0.0131313009,
-0.0407998301,
0.015578568,
-0.0087458743,
-0.0033132599,
-0.036051847,
-0.0115036815,
-0.015641693,
0.0170731936,
0.0230782237,
-0.0287396591,
0.033514902,
0.0026413577,
-0.0006267483,
-0.0342427231,
-0.0126403738,
-0.0332643613,
-0.0054867673,
-0.0156553723,
0.0276140645,
-0.0375304185,
0.0224305335,
-0.0493364446,
0.0567540489,
0.0782431364,
-0.0510566533,
-0.009096479,
0.0344823971,
0.0539558679,
-0.0324059874,
-0.0121734152,
0.0813053846,
0.001725992,
0.0242264401,
0.079898864,
0.035874486,
-0.023853261,
-0.0556515008,
-0.0868094862,
0.0055666785,
0.010689579,
-0.0256386269,
-0.0155964168,
-0.0500433668,
-0.0158366468,
0.0168687124,
-0.0260991231,
0.0392930433,
0.014181802,
-0.0210565645,
0.0203465447,
0.0081794234,
-0.0222950336,
-0.0239249505,
0.0084241405,
-0.0036632479,
0.0220411103,
0.0454316624,
-0.0175100621,
-0.0351599604,
0.0338252671,
-0.0392058678,
0.0346387886,
-0.0115924161,
-0.0902904645,
0.0381323099,
-0.0300274771,
0.0238476377,
0.0194912106,
0.0198573396,
0.0691714659,
0.0771922767,
-0.0392479636,
-0.0332400762,
0.0358472392,
-0.0273474269,
-0.0184177049,
-0.0408192277,
0.0173738152,
0.0139284479,
0.0591863617,
0.0213561952,
0.0311028343,
-0.047545474,
0.0380746797,
0.0009413804,
0.01016773,
-0.0202423632,
-0.0283063725,
-0.0381026305,
0.0165700465,
-0.0001035477,
0.041050259,
0.0543675609,
0.0013591137,
0.019328177,
-0.0476084352,
-0.0063104215,
-0.0001583878,
0.0827464759,
0.0288941395,
0.0057922574,
-0.0158171672,
-0.0145549988,
-0.0375285111,
-0.0251731314,
0.0454627462,
-0.0259108841,
-0.0468157306,
-0.0483824871,
-0.0081390394,
0.0033335632,
0.0080984151,
-0.0203545652,
0.0099770501,
-0.049476549,
0.0128790373,
0.0209697001,
-0.021011496,
-0.0371112451,
-0.0109126763,
0.0619010404,
0.0313236974,
-0.0200310852,
-0.0112036886,
-0.0310438648,
-0.0089917472,
0.0667502061,
0.0327047668,
0.0064245658,
0.0303793047,
0.0882431641,
0.0114730811,
0.0141046876,
-0.019421462,
-0.0436760932,
0.0077535571,
0.0110627245,
-0.015291295,
-0.0112099508,
0.0631307438,
-0.0220213067,
-0.036950618,
0.029040629,
0.0915461034,
0.0396978334,
0.0110608228,
0.0162511058,
-0.0476277284,
-0.0342728347,
-0.0120292697,
0.0550528355,
-0.0232161228,
-0.0105373925,
-0.0194385331,
-0.0676695257,
-0.0438709371,
-0.0442899764,
0.0010687748,
-0.0911219791,
0.0382195376,
-0.0157221388,
0.0215985999,
-0.0283819214,
0.0054147337,
-0.0135279689,
0.0170006622,
-0.0330881923,
0.0089937421,
0.0517664999,
-0.0303118844,
-0.0021733039,
-0.0207718108,
0.0107184974,
0.0502762459,
-0.0530127287,
0.074397333,
0.0726504847,
0.070588544,
-0.0352665819,
0.0204841383,
0.0234528631,
0.0592489876,
0.0249966513,
0.0178159773,
0.0296315793,
0.0135160312,
-0.0215462204,
-0.0218533818,
-0.0314564481,
0.0294736847,
0.0003991335,
0.0528707467,
0.0497050174,
-0.0453055464,
-0.0424734876,
0.0133341989,
-0.0046546306,
0.032937374,
0.0287682451,
-0.0350461937,
-0.0677708611,
-0.0646693856,
0.0094353808,
-0.0185602009,
-0.0177510642,
-0.0526431687,
-0.0131373582,
0.0269577857,
-0.0102983173,
-0.0472035855,
-0.0697375983,
0.0135835102,
0.0172937755,
0.0056269816,
0.009469958,
0.0357410088,
0.0331976414,
0.0183730088,
-0.0365873761,
-0.0156318508,
0.0102501158,
-0.0120260483,
-0.0005467031,
0.0082896994,
-0.0706755146,
-0.002125453,
0.0230567195,
0.0382750034,
-0.022889547,
0.0235194601,
0.0593169779,
0.0149854468,
-0.0189573821,
-0.0004454245,
-0.0040982077,
0.0372267887,
-0.0014051511,
-0.0424731039,
0.0030997375,
0.0007575831,
-0.003680015,
0.0393373705,
0.0167081375,
-0.0229984336,
0.0377077907,
0.0095231561,
0.0110166464,
-0.0425167084,
-0.0374778993,
0.014169978,
0.0287746023,
-0.0121456245,
0.0008731885,
-0.0177789405,
-0.0191532038,
-0.0086733773,
-0.0719934106,
-0.0137545001,
-0.0130237322,
0.0000667264,
-0.0303727984,
-0.0095502716,
0.0547228344,
-0.0007563865,
0.0198489521,
-0.0742219016,
0.0799470171,
0.0403366126,
0.0136629418,
0.0491517521,
0.0123596285,
-0.0085986406,
0.0095242094,
-0.0096414071,
0.0032237142,
-0.0043244911,
0.0288981814,
0.0517153367,
0.0287532769,
-0.0727380142,
-0.015002368,
0.0095611727,
-0.0139840702,
-0.0712871477,
0.0583666116,
0.0584439412,
0.0499571934,
0.0112541914,
-0.0195700768,
-0.0750335231,
0.0359118544,
-0.0052761277,
-0.0217585154,
0.0009634873,
-0.0337418355,
0.0081736874,
0.031485036,
-0.0271607395,
-0.0075067556,
0.0524887145,
0.0159034971,
0.0214692149,
-0.0131454254,
-0.0250838716,
-0.0516985357,
-0.0143640079,
-0.0203186553,
0.0423010997,
-0.0272886306,
0.0357754417,
-0.0495561175,
0.0075570415,
-0.037528608,
0.0673679635,
0.0311892647,
-0.0259586051,
0.0342687666,
0.0351549834,
-0.0118276039,
0.0230946615,
-0.047428377,
0.0214433018,
-0.0240912884,
0.0128270313,
-0.002852919,
-6.250037342e-33,
-0.0094405897,
-0.0609112419,
0.0757815838,
-0.0413965583,
-0.0187363103,
-0.0298606381,
-0.0250150226,
0.0105967131,
-0.0082190698,
0.0305756889,
-0.0276510455,
-0.0060390611,
0.0065568825,
-0.0060952897,
0.0098400218,
-0.0158705413,
0.0079399217,
-0.0106594255,
-0.0125062838,
-0.0069924397,
0.0072686435,
-0.0157799888,
0.0081469128,
-0.0617175438,
-0.0126114599,
0.0078289295,
-0.0161202587,
0.0118052,
-0.0307650976,
0.0450364314,
-0.0164934434,
0.0043080845,
0.02396998,
-0.0550731122,
0.0238572024,
0.0364201814,
-0.0167514514,
-0.0627899691,
-0.024568839,
0.0024667825,
0.0058457335,
-0.0281898882,
-0.0231857281,
-0.0015799387,
-0.045992028,
0.0143632051,
0.0183039214,
-0.026707314,
0.026019346,
0.0268979594,
-0.0908766314,
0.0240841769,
-0.012311127,
-0.0176554304,
0.0221453235,
-0.0008860796,
-0.0328765251,
-0.0283294693,
-0.0429428667,
0.0333069041,
0.0049094823,
-0.0386405922,
0.0041437256,
0.0221365951,
0.0291562788,
0.0521260127,
0.0029895992,
0.0257713068,
-0.0724238306,
-0.0258228034,
-0.00660899,
0.0561404228,
0.0308922492,
0.0494305976,
-0.0046175071,
-0.0404612087,
-0.0519066043,
0.0091667017,
0.058898408,
0.0635489523,
0.0695666969,
-0.0032014046,
-0.0554797165,
-0.0100471601,
0.0127682332,
0.0191781856,
-0.0182450768,
-0.0348562449,
0.0052529452,
-0.0370132774,
0.0266607907,
-0.0253453646,
0.0258478355,
-0.0226430334,
0.0333245657,
0.0133255944,
-0.0089976862,
0.0314440578,
-0.0232793782,
-0.0358579308,
0.0040982952,
-0.0466096252,
-0.0065756063,
-0.0414211228,
0.0099216755,
0.0535173714,
-0.0381928869,
0.0159345008,
-0.0111561576,
0.0077741104,
-0.0112676108,
-0.0143232336,
0.0672787428,
-0.0391413569,
-0.004426369,
-0.0342953615,
-0.0103748608,
-0.0192562472,
0.0195851028,
-0.0942765772,
0.0122751473,
0.0154604353,
-0.035961248,
-0.0085664643,
0.0032360635,
0.0436323993,
-0.0725264773,
0.0845694318,
-0.0201490857,
-0.01658291,
-0.017157143,
-0.0088891396,
3.079e-7,
-0.0671140328,
0.0724994242,
-0.0073782681,
0.0419514291,
-0.0068796198,
0.0789649934,
0.0055052284,
0.0209780578,
-0.0191036928,
0.0071633062,
0.0616257079,
0.0390948206,
-0.0048401374,
0.008952816,
-0.0654313043,
-0.0053696879,
-0.0176335648,
-0.0258718282,
-0.0573583953,
0.0265211184,
0.0890796632,
0.0479084365,
0.0509511195,
-0.0133453347,
-0.0066476143,
-0.0219503976,
-0.0210075025,
-0.0290990639,
0.0043804441,
0.042055428,
0.0256183315,
-0.0248633679,
-0.0322208032,
0.0575001985,
0.0260912962,
0.0189427473,
0.006535904,
0.0284188427,
-0.0088503016,
0.0444670804,
0.0199657883,
-0.0336632356,
-0.015214989,
-0.0424234122,
0.0496789776,
-0.0439538769,
-0.0637835488,
-0.021506872,
0.017816484,
-0.0228212029,
-0.0568726622,
-0.0344202071,
-0.015941605,
-0.0395999812,
-0.0193859097,
-0.0140986182,
0.0550245754,
-0.0192489158,
0.0186959989,
0.024348978,
-0.036684908,
-0.0282802861,
-0.0027622252,
0.0138840657,
0.0454501435,
-0.0225978401,
0.0311563164,
2.489536093e-34,
-0.0176472869,
-0.0180402175,
-0.0065868469,
-0.0230860729,
0.0600939728,
0.0588996932,
0.0025695388,
0.044107832,
0.0590172261,
-0.0343021452,
-0.0423198156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01087v1 | Prompted Zero-Shot Multi-label Classification of Factual Incorrectness in Machine-Generated Summaries | 2023-12-02T09:37:47 | 2023-12-02T09:37:47 | Aniket Deroy, Subhankar Maity, Saptarshi Ghosh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study addresses the critical issue of factual inaccuracies in
machine-generated text summaries, an increasingly prevalent issue in
information dissemination. Recognizing the potential of such errors to
compromise information reliability, we investigate the nature of factual
inconsistencies across machine-summarized content. We introduce a prompt-based
classification system that categorizes errors into four distinct types:
misrepresentation, inaccurate quantities or measurements, false attribution,
and fabrication. The participants are tasked with evaluating a corpus of
machine-generated summaries against their original articles. Our methodology
employs qualitative judgements to identify the occurrence of factual
distortions. The results show that our prompt-based approaches are able to
detect the type of errors in the summaries to some extent, although there is
scope for improvement in our classification systems. | [
0.0533775985,
-0.001334468,
0.0003188218,
0.0050313561,
-0.0328041166,
0.0244238656,
0.0317822918,
-0.0170089137,
-0.0282534584,
-0.0831294432,
0.0195141807,
-0.0063611087,
0.056192901,
-0.0108441049,
0.0037728851,
-0.0080281403,
0.0406857319,
0.0431639068,
0.0270376895,
0.0106089404,
0.0176035315,
0.0311986785,
-0.0280472152,
0.0189603847,
-0.0438875817,
-0.0102265002,
0.0193387028,
0.0016173755,
0.02940749,
-0.0274633076,
-0.0067683221,
0.0440503433,
-0.0067607244,
0.0617361218,
0.0000017103,
-0.0654170811,
-0.0116270427,
0.0191369895,
-0.0303652771,
0.01941818,
0.0447572023,
-0.0078778956,
-0.00106772,
0.0059655458,
0.0110795498,
-0.0336226076,
0.0363117792,
0.0552526638,
0.0553364865,
0.0610407852,
-0.0031740768,
0.0029222379,
-0.0036283524,
0.0326538123,
-0.0002218634,
0.0054155369,
0.0044070501,
-0.0010631151,
-0.0215416271,
0.025192339,
0.0248976219,
0.0092295213,
-0.0065547358,
-0.0131856771,
0.0170658641,
0.0399702713,
-0.0269118249,
-0.0357273705,
0.0154013308,
0.0378648676,
0.067396529,
-0.0172011517,
-0.0000550568,
-0.0091011031,
0.019068202,
0.01066064,
-0.0035737257,
0.0634386912,
-0.0396785364,
-0.0070046023,
-0.0543435365,
0.0108960317,
-0.0022836844,
0.033422403,
0.0314449556,
0.0103049949,
-0.0192014612,
-0.0484094508,
-0.0223592557,
0.0235080887,
0.0404493324,
-0.0718220249,
-0.0229690205,
0.0353808179,
0.0000201788,
-0.0012501766,
-0.0265611727,
-0.0399476066,
0.0857042745,
-0.0548271053,
-0.0101425704,
-0.0347979441,
-0.0046063699,
0.0259501543,
0.0030168244,
0.0316156149,
0.060282141,
0.0189009141,
-0.0090980334,
0.0270276759,
-0.0286382847,
-0.0041442891,
0.0164210666,
0.0302198026,
-0.0046774442,
0.0261601377,
-0.0639784113,
-0.0181940552,
-0.023836419,
0.0376997665,
-0.0454017892,
0.0196212083,
-0.0137421312,
0.0031544256,
-0.0741751119,
0.0470497087,
-0.0113941561,
0.0577141903,
-0.0084431712,
-0.0416056626,
-0.010751171,
0.0353590548,
-0.0092179487,
0.0152026825,
-0.0121312253,
0.0063305972,
-0.0240756497,
-0.0022832409,
-0.0205701049,
-0.0605654158,
-0.057773523,
-0.0463571921,
-0.0173920002,
-0.0380203836,
0.0044697216,
-0.0101263607,
-0.0207551047,
0.0061082351,
-0.0022442252,
0.0537295938,
-0.0480340756,
0.022430677,
-0.0431763791,
0.0017877423,
0.0674352422,
0.0129655581,
-0.0002948291,
0.0204916503,
0.0235728845,
0.0504197851,
0.0445579328,
0.0391850434,
0.0469056889,
-0.0454773419,
0.0194815639,
0.0107165147,
0.0082364054,
-0.0246303976,
-0.0465429835,
0.0060145818,
0.0168384574,
0.0565904491,
-0.0257376675,
0.0364240184,
0.0743347034,
0.0130299507,
-0.0229492802,
-0.0330847874,
0.0254261401,
-0.0063549629,
0.0445026271,
0.0252931155,
-0.0261140093,
0.0003460132,
-0.0424884893,
0.0249016918,
0.0640220717,
0.0379172117,
0.0114903012,
-0.0553452373,
-0.0321920104,
0.0047771311,
-0.0103501659,
-0.0258703064,
0.0118717672,
0.0158088617,
-0.0308711454,
0.0081194509,
-0.0022141507,
-0.0396895818,
-0.0003663788,
-0.0420146324,
0.0239645299,
0.0456366502,
0.0299302563,
-0.0040863729,
0.022815844,
-0.0398940705,
0.0090873279,
0.0212819483,
0.0708582178,
-0.0291956235,
-0.0600152574,
0.006968719,
-0.0240691602,
-0.0071475236,
0.0428802967,
-0.0240607541,
-0.0159372333,
0.0149794025,
0.0327345617,
-0.0265270211,
-0.051435221,
0.0323250555,
0.0442755856,
-0.0462941825,
0.000291963,
0.0155989034,
-0.0062727383,
0.0493136235,
-0.0301169436,
0.0083856042,
0.012790286,
0.045500461,
-0.0442517623,
-0.0088676764,
0.0030339039,
0.0080313776,
-0.0059862556,
-0.0440056138,
-0.0450414158,
-0.0326359868,
-0.0334495865,
-0.009853607,
-0.0155862914,
-0.0446589999,
-0.0661065131,
-0.0628599674,
0.005979748,
-0.003797756,
-0.0039457395,
-0.0233860798,
0.0731745362,
0.0088973623,
0.0485635251,
0.0398484319,
-0.063550733,
0.0053231483,
-0.0140304752,
0.022410484,
0.0239093844,
0.0044442988,
0.0462809429,
0.027239792,
-0.0358424932,
-0.0213647969,
-0.0038011374,
-0.0853849426,
-0.0075461464,
-0.0120538529,
0.0082920147,
0.0310750213,
-0.0352529734,
-0.005162654,
0.0060212575,
0.0151760951,
-0.0653315485,
0.0106335273,
0.0426157713,
0.0446576476,
0.0242712982,
0.0674100071,
0.0051210127,
0.0196131822,
-0.0512856692,
0.04258205,
0.0758209452,
-0.0057640015,
-0.0772731677,
0.0045407275,
-0.0596152283,
-0.0246847719,
0.0149865942,
0.0083178887,
-0.0093525918,
0.0352775268,
-0.0070450539,
0.0356992111,
0.0489448234,
0.0432044677,
0.0485688634,
0.0177945718,
0.0043906402,
-0.0331437178,
-0.0397104435,
-0.0018708988,
0.0361737125,
-0.0742718801,
0.0466199256,
0.0164473243,
0.0298729669,
0.0181911588,
-0.0021575836,
0.0610599779,
-0.0443773121,
-0.0253805444,
-0.0287504066,
-0.0305582304,
-0.0142514482,
0.0792044774,
-0.0063170209,
-0.0062620156,
0.0700865984,
-0.0310421046,
0.0575920828,
-0.0551544093,
0.0008235053,
0.004984126,
-0.0270750299,
-0.0136761246,
0.0397428013,
0.0385056958,
0.0059084846,
-0.0496827848,
-0.0271570385,
0.0866251364,
0.0051878374,
0.031088464,
-0.0632096156,
0.0025707735,
-0.0118366275,
-0.0163344406,
-0.0169849861,
-0.0821332484,
0.0132229645,
-0.0143049564,
-0.0301068723,
-0.0019394516,
-0.0731899813,
-0.0255545769,
0.06575948,
0.0299693886,
-0.0197215956,
-0.0200148076,
0.0159972645,
0.032917954,
0.0301149823,
-0.0074859965,
0.0701349303,
-0.0288104285,
-0.0020436386,
0.0507300086,
-0.0022371146,
0.0424522273,
0.0375034548,
-0.0598319136,
-0.0362010859,
-0.0558877364,
-0.0282828696,
0.0042292229,
0.0432848483,
-0.036490988,
0.0228604451,
0.0694382638,
0.0403208882,
-0.0234379191,
-0.034109477,
0.0209371392,
-0.0406005569,
0.0078362124,
-0.0107638612,
-0.0988683552,
0.011421591,
-0.0118354578,
0.0410799719,
-0.0868200958,
-0.0175481848,
-0.0188087299,
-0.1089068949,
0.0224020481,
0.0035072188,
-0.0658719912,
-0.0597892366,
-0.0419990085,
-0.0059541287,
0.0251834188,
0.0115998555,
0.022066243,
-0.0008517628,
0.0043228613,
0.010937063,
-0.0574053489,
-0.0310408324,
-0.0039547184,
0.023048887,
0.0117095541,
0.0177163966,
0.0383768603,
-0.0305039901,
-0.0129890684,
0.0004661882,
-0.0266655255,
-0.0289455876,
0.0126974676,
0.0706308112,
-0.0331612751,
0.0207950696,
-0.016396869,
0.0162010286,
0.0656573921,
-0.0265758075,
-0.014033352,
0.0450779833,
0.0180482436,
-0.0252926759,
-0.0231338479,
0.0156377796,
0.0176142324,
0.0390534773,
0.0184711814,
0.0156020261,
-0.0523759276,
-0.0296351071,
0.0090502622,
-0.0288316365,
-0.0010752361,
0.032836739,
-0.0432388969,
-0.0528926328,
-0.070901081,
-0.0779564455,
-0.0097831786,
-0.0303918514,
-0.0001044867,
-0.0376005359,
0.0091713509,
0.0328684412,
-0.0363278948,
-0.0410150737,
0.0008788573,
0.0239512436,
0.0132906362,
0.0196824353,
0.0154557908,
0.0125866178,
0.0063947299,
-0.0024162014,
-0.0165585279,
-0.034851145,
0.0036412717,
0.0235178247,
0.0205942858,
0.0229952987,
-0.0037370059,
0.0058934544,
0.0842011794,
0.087520577,
-0.0100285234,
0.0406723544,
-0.0001859118,
-0.0000403019,
-0.0220595412,
-0.0403025337,
-0.0397079848,
0.0354563557,
-0.0614700429,
-0.0270344,
-0.0590518266,
-0.0692083687,
0.0169559997,
0.0120671848,
0.038232293,
-0.0364054032,
0.0347701609,
-0.0335327797,
-0.0140661364,
-0.0300732255,
-0.0389841981,
0.0352332331,
0.0117692016,
-0.0321945138,
0.0082003595,
-0.0056466651,
0.0384130888,
-0.0633708909,
0.0495510735,
-0.0001988314,
-0.0184591711,
0.0196807627,
0.0440210365,
-0.035091076,
-0.002297621,
-0.0532367416,
-0.0333183855,
-0.007590381,
0.0355443396,
0.0188034791,
0.0273247901,
0.0160267521,
-0.0065735602,
-0.0068774116,
-0.0057909633,
-0.0881228969,
0.039952755,
-0.0583706349,
0.0074981479,
0.0049319295,
0.004687984,
0.0234942473,
0.0044053169,
-0.0241291467,
-0.0165184215,
0.0122214286,
0.0315520391,
-0.0040394426,
-0.0090655405,
0.0269248802,
-0.0222881678,
0.0211729985,
0.0644795671,
-0.0163551122,
0.0281691533,
-0.0073143672,
-0.0712525398,
-0.0235954337,
-0.0360991396,
-0.0365796275,
-0.0053592278,
0.0353315435,
-0.0768951774,
-0.1232780144,
-0.0423695482,
0.0899600163,
0.0468362831,
0.0623226166,
-0.0101133725,
-0.020018708,
0.0479767285,
0.0414104648,
0.0073652929,
-0.0749441087,
0.0145829786,
-0.0053101773,
0.0308247637,
-0.0027007726,
-5.646385728e-33,
-0.0229445416,
-0.0837248266,
-0.0313600861,
0.0028201889,
-0.0092643779,
0.0365277454,
-0.0110123353,
-0.0154017378,
-0.0082826391,
0.0494861826,
0.0157398954,
0.0051444857,
0.0121376887,
-0.0238413252,
0.017646702,
0.0022424716,
0.0567152426,
-0.02327553,
-0.0621802211,
0.0106883151,
0.0344178565,
-0.0350818671,
0.0465209,
-0.0608011633,
0.1257120222,
-0.0230849274,
-0.0664436743,
-0.0049144821,
0.0008708049,
0.0220603906,
0.0224289484,
0.065156728,
0.0399376228,
-0.0387012474,
-0.0218610466,
0.0464281105,
-0.0451710522,
-0.0404385999,
0.0333945416,
-0.001844481,
-0.0068252427,
-0.0006181699,
0.0099322712,
-0.0189771447,
-0.0074334927,
-0.0230832882,
0.0767044947,
-0.0358952768,
0.0059671993,
-0.0623612553,
-0.0159761384,
0.0021398412,
0.0032552355,
0.019408159,
-0.0224442463,
0.0913127437,
0.0106814504,
0.0233775079,
-0.0824552476,
0.0272616111,
0.0115054576,
-0.0252618641,
0.0026318268,
-0.0121873831,
-0.0084344279,
0.0549134649,
0.0042601046,
0.0292509329,
-0.0794744864,
0.0262609124,
-0.0161811337,
-0.0270222109,
0.0443101078,
0.1285785586,
0.0584676005,
-0.0235802922,
-0.0509946607,
0.0332215764,
-0.017940158,
0.0188536812,
-0.0081277154,
-0.0681782737,
-0.0370447598,
-0.0182108711,
-0.0329526737,
-0.0060283621,
-0.0414246805,
0.0020213374,
-0.0115248896,
0.0223773196,
-0.020341238,
0.0236063786,
-0.0228664503,
-0.0229165088,
0.0084406845,
-0.0145498179,
-0.0294840913,
0.0141174532,
0.0058424091,
-0.0339974388,
-0.0514810942,
0.0349027328,
0.026999956,
0.0755605102,
0.0414662696,
-0.0043256558,
0.0737900138,
-0.0278953481,
-0.0588825718,
0.0172446556,
0.0378136598,
0.0031112712,
-0.0042971428,
-0.0350175239,
-0.004139795,
0.0113820452,
-0.0115251187,
0.0007996027,
-0.007512392,
0.0409180671,
-0.0098882969,
-0.0096207336,
-0.011206002,
0.0216291975,
-0.0149479359,
0.0008250195,
-0.0089731915,
0.0310360845,
0.0146675929,
-0.0411101729,
0.0111467103,
-0.0199818518,
2.569e-7,
0.0437170789,
0.0496118404,
0.02052119,
-0.0211455896,
0.0091656921,
0.042806346,
0.0228054337,
0.0159816574,
0.0141658848,
-0.043098148,
0.0456788987,
0.0061043617,
0.0097229853,
0.070083268,
-0.0536813214,
-0.0324497223,
-0.0715153813,
-0.0031143625,
-0.0311768949,
0.025142571,
0.1038525552,
-0.01196953,
-0.0089038676,
-0.0260147993,
-0.0323119089,
0.0078986157,
0.0414042249,
0.0518791415,
-0.0360024534,
0.0082217893,
0.0660711303,
-0.0258658975,
0.0278767776,
0.0348902978,
-0.0317329988,
-0.0517735556,
0.0257627629,
0.0123858191,
0.002932885,
-0.0390151851,
-0.012056658,
-0.0049745361,
0.0385722257,
0.0106690237,
0.0435856096,
-0.0388372727,
-0.003532395,
-0.0598137565,
-0.0633069947,
0.0089447498,
0.0670711324,
-0.010710014,
-0.0458601043,
0.0544844866,
-0.0268346369,
0.0552105606,
0.0202540029,
-0.0355253927,
-0.0024704738,
0.0306574497,
0.0005596686,
-0.0741209015,
0.0517021343,
-0.0345178656,
0.0149103133,
-0.0689440519,
0.0373958424,
2.084673798e-34,
0.0573543794,
-0.0140660927,
-0.0048744231,
-0.0477708578,
0.012862552,
0.0133050447,
-0.0288454127,
-0.0252238847,
-0.0026358897,
0.0002875806,
0.001663624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01082v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01082v1 | On the Effects of Randomness on Stability of Learning with Limited Labelled Data: A Systematic Literature Review | 2023-12-02T09:20:10 | 2023-12-02T09:20:10 | Branislav Pecher, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Learning with limited labelled data, such as few-shot learning, meta-learning
or transfer learning, aims to effectively train a model using only small amount
of labelled samples. However, these approaches were observed to be excessively
sensitive to the effects of uncontrolled randomness caused by non-determinism
in the training process. The randomness negatively affects the stability of the
models, leading to large variance in results across training runs. When such
instability is disregarded, it can unintentionally, but unfortunately also
intentionally, create an imaginary perception of research progress. Recently,
this area started to attract a research attention and the number of relevant
studies is continuously growing. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive
overview of 134 papers addressing the effects of randomness on the stability of
learning with limited labelled data. We distinguish between four main tasks
addressed in the papers (investigate/evaluate; determine; mitigate;
benchmark/compare/report randomness effects), providing findings for each one.
Furthermore, we identify and discuss seven challenges and open problems
together with possible directions to facilitate further research. The ultimate
goal of this survey is to emphasise the importance of this growing research
area, which so far has not received appropriate level of attention. | [
0.0169852301,
0.0355169587,
-0.0186245516,
-0.0301861782,
-0.0136218872,
0.0034181564,
0.0492107198,
-0.0087546324,
-0.0444365293,
-0.0024609857,
-0.0048915837,
-0.0099784127,
0.0235217419,
-0.0257597957,
-0.0036354789,
-0.0950753167,
0.035489127,
-0.0657880977,
0.0217920896,
-0.0363885351,
-0.0315395817,
-0.0742083266,
0.0098505011,
0.0058851177,
-0.0217422675,
0.0056779068,
-0.0069664912,
-0.0001463114,
0.0269545633,
-0.048053544,
-0.0050461073,
0.0594457425,
-0.0182365887,
0.0367343761,
0.0000022222,
-0.0377111584,
-0.0395926535,
0.0438974649,
-0.0068011633,
-0.0491873324,
0.0117024109,
-0.0005570574,
0.0097707594,
-0.0127537474,
0.0088823335,
-0.0408803374,
0.0550871491,
0.0356295779,
-0.0013683072,
0.0251190048,
-0.0043547652,
0.0006566237,
-0.0333674364,
-0.0283802301,
0.0679085031,
-0.0373098403,
0.0129777463,
-0.0037256209,
-0.0242971741,
-0.006950343,
-0.0431531444,
-0.0074026356,
0.0001691164,
0.0409326293,
0.0300958324,
0.0178373046,
-0.0918194354,
-0.0144657502,
-0.0129674897,
0.0529465899,
-0.0321385786,
0.0337178819,
-0.0267727412,
-0.0319749378,
0.03982592,
0.0369686708,
-0.0625553131,
0.0282742903,
-0.000279671,
0.032151252,
-0.0490547456,
0.0522336885,
0.0306005199,
-0.0661664605,
-0.0136087136,
0.0293932781,
0.0100127151,
-0.0488784127,
0.0556359366,
0.0370253175,
-0.0007169055,
-0.0205087271,
-0.0600853823,
0.0058286493,
0.0149314171,
0.0095031234,
-0.0401232988,
-0.0407359749,
0.0148501899,
-0.0361978821,
0.0510450751,
-0.0187357012,
-0.0425236784,
0.0269804839,
-0.0228671674,
-0.0146294078,
0.0397869274,
0.0870352015,
0.006940193,
0.0121943364,
-0.0717621595,
0.0731511936,
-0.0005020406,
0.0823930129,
0.0448607765,
0.0155438548,
-0.0551358908,
-0.0033127484,
0.0234703608,
0.003684144,
-0.0506056137,
-0.0083019203,
-0.0285610966,
0.0293449089,
-0.0042277328,
0.0100879529,
-0.0026535585,
0.0253618918,
-0.003562619,
-0.0316969864,
-0.0178309958,
-0.0090669943,
0.0177329723,
-0.0372762233,
0.0022802693,
0.0789569318,
-0.0054139714,
-0.0430043824,
-0.0684623197,
0.0101844054,
-0.0366900228,
-0.0338445082,
0.0422939397,
-0.0188614819,
-0.0314125232,
-0.0015602699,
0.0367211923,
-0.0182378925,
-0.0009494905,
-0.0416203104,
-0.0539642423,
0.0841613486,
-0.066072762,
-0.0060226149,
-0.0075113261,
-0.0039508347,
-0.0247180425,
0.0634509102,
0.0539582707,
-0.0050189244,
0.0302711762,
-0.027624689,
0.0106023531,
-0.0374692269,
0.0409965627,
-0.0208234452,
-0.0005006094,
-0.0404425487,
0.0398788899,
-0.0098700821,
-0.0432017222,
0.0193571411,
-0.0166692901,
0.0196898431,
0.0618451722,
-0.0076876846,
-0.023662664,
-0.0179605093,
-0.0184458923,
-0.0243153181,
0.0101284068,
0.0335130505,
-0.0460298657,
0.0323794968,
-0.0222027283,
-0.0124264946,
-0.0124256741,
-0.0114737237,
-0.0472873114,
-0.04982844,
-0.022718804,
0.0057894303,
-0.044387918,
0.0002725986,
0.0990482867,
0.0096123219,
0.037294887,
0.011133289,
0.0576199666,
0.0350655913,
-0.023023868,
-0.0348187536,
0.0004396705,
0.0223495662,
0.0049412414,
-0.0170073546,
-0.0662827343,
-0.0576189831,
0.029711308,
0.0003979604,
0.0358857326,
0.031280499,
0.0747882947,
0.0095073367,
-0.0704914629,
0.0216174647,
0.0031724544,
0.0302404333,
-0.0052657719,
0.0458138436,
-0.007995218,
-0.0394752286,
-0.0229272675,
0.0446920618,
-0.0334150307,
-0.0352044106,
0.0488490313,
0.0121101364,
0.0390582047,
-0.0537193716,
-0.0472661257,
-0.0371309705,
0.0144975334,
-0.0312190074,
0.0080816885,
0.0034550559,
0.0065331692,
-0.0262727048,
0.0309539195,
-0.0249931682,
0.0000513074,
-0.0178496689,
-0.0618668348,
-0.0628546476,
0.0133578107,
0.0024647212,
0.0022160823,
0.0090189734,
-0.0025368645,
-0.0122150443,
0.0631071478,
-0.0166858528,
0.0185168795,
0.026059337,
-0.0169519968,
0.0207790304,
-0.0514900275,
0.039465338,
-0.0405182019,
-0.0229032114,
0.0043650996,
-0.048754219,
-0.0171424467,
-0.0016255203,
0.008259384,
0.0157326199,
0.0030002536,
0.0083341226,
-0.0429193191,
0.013866242,
-0.0024690859,
-0.0551290326,
-0.0257694535,
-0.0249503888,
-0.0283476859,
0.0051827114,
0.0552455932,
-0.006744416,
0.0249668397,
0.0440813564,
0.0368737057,
-0.0197958797,
-0.0225871839,
-0.0209355336,
0.0344541632,
0.0594860762,
0.0405791365,
-0.0315443017,
-0.0170472525,
0.0301565025,
-0.0117728943,
-0.0025895273,
0.0134912804,
0.0319010615,
-0.0221037101,
0.0052201422,
-0.0352817178,
0.0450982265,
-0.0081163235,
-0.029285755,
0.0466177985,
0.0083766878,
-0.0123062115,
0.0020709299,
-0.0377819948,
-0.0420851037,
0.0231659058,
-0.0409173295,
-0.0220876075,
0.0339223184,
-0.0076997643,
-0.025900729,
-0.0290052965,
0.0492359921,
-0.0260922201,
-0.037525814,
-0.0468296893,
0.0619499311,
-0.0024411108,
0.0183972679,
-0.0373938195,
-0.0503171831,
0.0769492537,
0.0561344139,
0.0389794447,
0.0124298194,
0.0013599627,
0.0100729261,
-0.0018618762,
-0.0074865045,
0.0002726451,
0.0318502709,
0.0244699623,
-0.0725078955,
-0.0772173926,
0.038414415,
0.01197326,
-0.0239317957,
0.0012366951,
0.0280611403,
-0.0237657707,
-0.0461994596,
-0.0509436652,
-0.036405731,
-0.0066360948,
0.0123836892,
-0.0230450202,
0.0301930327,
-0.0127362423,
-0.0041066543,
0.0132442582,
0.0040348899,
-0.0393134505,
-0.0514356606,
0.0251200628,
0.021582799,
0.039932128,
-0.0477143824,
0.0575673096,
-0.0628138483,
0.0514641888,
-0.0141955977,
0.0242242198,
0.0358645059,
-0.0460613631,
0.0038750579,
-0.0230339635,
-0.0013946816,
-0.0197275262,
0.0114611099,
0.002482116,
-0.0167322308,
-0.0435537174,
0.038227316,
-0.0407463461,
0.0078815613,
-0.0226218496,
-0.0470555425,
0.0335491002,
-0.0056476239,
0.0419156216,
0.0143701825,
-0.0377286784,
-0.0025193777,
0.071118407,
-0.0022990252,
-0.0188789386,
0.022310067,
-0.0704917014,
0.0486492142,
0.0125773381,
-0.0692261085,
0.0078137387,
-0.0287503079,
0.0207644757,
-0.0599924549,
0.0424203761,
-0.0171362758,
-0.0554416366,
-0.0032236166,
0.0796538591,
-0.0416581854,
-0.0834240466,
-0.0073556108,
-0.0297169983,
0.0605031103,
0.0496394038,
-0.0425213501,
-0.0616652258,
-0.0254915934,
0.0655832291,
0.0518837906,
-0.0030387952,
0.0169166736,
0.0996213555,
-0.019041881,
-0.0024856436,
-0.0009693454,
-0.0082629016,
0.0254810527,
-0.0265115984,
0.0085809166,
0.0426191576,
0.0126350718,
-0.0601163618,
-0.0242072828,
-0.0337089598,
0.0237656683,
0.0400983728,
-0.0017334969,
-0.0690071955,
-0.0328539312,
0.0193690155,
0.018345179,
-0.0443269685,
0.0141355209,
0.0622306913,
-0.0391016155,
-0.0486276671,
-0.0257976074,
-0.0157989841,
0.0035936334,
0.0323535465,
0.0155542651,
0.0579542704,
-0.0083691636,
0.070535481,
-0.0036604435,
-0.0060511148,
-0.0158213284,
-0.0224765092,
-0.0235771388,
-0.0081299134,
0.0290011689,
-0.0696583167,
0.0000379247,
-0.0224008877,
-0.0727659911,
-0.0203677416,
0.02767363,
0.1283664554,
0.0216170866,
0.0507533513,
0.0041301055,
-0.0303625651,
0.0750419274,
0.0749175474,
0.0705997571,
0.0103190942,
0.0481662229,
0.0015970854,
-0.0285513178,
-0.0080502788,
-0.0405113734,
0.0440811142,
0.0863039568,
-0.0505532026,
-0.0229214467,
0.0318509825,
-0.0206077434,
0.0157630946,
0.0777595341,
-0.0090650283,
-0.0359888487,
-0.0042205593,
0.0369754843,
0.056851171,
0.0191045906,
-0.0345168374,
-0.0016211874,
0.0279966183,
0.0284583215,
-0.0216773693,
-0.0071213064,
0.0020675871,
0.0488244556,
0.0181195457,
-0.0066142702,
-0.0288013853,
0.0566118024,
-0.0077860388,
0.0599545836,
-0.0177221242,
0.0347097889,
0.0370370857,
0.022312725,
0.0349212959,
-0.0138786286,
0.0342610888,
0.0034612019,
-0.0176012777,
-0.0309053361,
-0.0743581876,
-0.0001635024,
-0.0285447147,
-0.0305890236,
0.0060838433,
0.017657062,
0.0055616056,
-0.0013531662,
0.0200403444,
-0.0387162678,
0.010645655,
0.0019658848,
0.0479710959,
-0.0121435616,
-0.0077168737,
-0.0112406472,
0.0226629004,
0.080585964,
0.0621531606,
0.0045914883,
-0.032682009,
0.0012818219,
-0.0380665436,
0.0498754382,
0.033860147,
0.0264051631,
-0.0006523089,
-0.0104465373,
-0.063006334,
-0.0236167554,
0.0230544824,
-0.0428285003,
0.0794380084,
0.0280057024,
0.0052918652,
0.0090626329,
0.000405707,
0.0137497755,
0.0138228694,
-0.0134726167,
0.034943819,
0.0257443208,
-0.0023781154,
-6.508444796e-33,
-0.0114139039,
-0.0077315141,
-0.0318284333,
-0.005519608,
0.0061196759,
-0.0349166095,
-0.0269201137,
0.0163774546,
0.0175041072,
0.0017061895,
-0.0377109461,
-0.0040922672,
0.0322290771,
0.016576292,
0.0536630861,
-0.0586085543,
0.0382109843,
-0.0146300765,
0.0092030959,
0.013204325,
0.0385932773,
0.0488859154,
0.0210030936,
-0.0446984619,
-0.0296103079,
0.0637558252,
-0.0092778895,
-0.0416875705,
-0.0006006397,
0.0389357209,
0.014664419,
0.0275657959,
0.0180075988,
-0.0135296388,
-0.0552982204,
-0.0120231099,
-0.0416597761,
-0.0520829447,
-0.0620184578,
0.016587453,
0.0221925266,
-0.017055383,
0.0404369012,
-0.0148201063,
-0.0375080034,
-0.0125162518,
0.0562023818,
-0.0488507561,
-0.0686952546,
-0.0427698046,
-0.0208799336,
0.0257241149,
0.0240410995,
0.0114488704,
0.0111248503,
0.041012466,
0.0028619138,
-0.0021507111,
-0.0125031192,
-0.005849814,
0.0203694012,
0.0159425605,
0.0021038281,
0.0728504807,
0.0178211071,
0.0454252623,
0.0722757354,
0.039350003,
0.0362853445,
-0.0473177955,
0.0015059186,
0.034837231,
0.0252373088,
0.0674447566,
0.0743377581,
-0.0407976992,
-0.0901479721,
0.0280677248,
-0.0504384413,
0.0126670478,
0.0214371756,
-0.0188502464,
-0.0252922233,
-0.0189574175,
0.0155416094,
-0.0360954069,
-0.0057800524,
0.0122871343,
0.0344271734,
0.0246998146,
-0.0663438365,
-0.0106779691,
0.0521635301,
-0.0269934088,
-0.0189165082,
-0.0089593781,
-0.0009251611,
0.0340404324,
0.012819021,
-0.0173755474,
-0.0689442828,
-0.084522672,
0.0037338999,
0.0454038642,
0.0336303152,
-0.0312385838,
0.0937818438,
0.0341318995,
-0.0466120131,
-0.0175319538,
0.0072681527,
0.0503442064,
0.0477524213,
-0.0390700921,
0.0472586453,
-0.0052629556,
-0.0015419027,
0.0427695736,
0.0290136095,
-0.0026949192,
0.0415293425,
0.0290496778,
-0.0138979955,
0.0008395167,
0.0272163786,
0.0099052154,
-0.0017636056,
-0.0215378199,
0.008207079,
-0.0478813648,
-0.0083401417,
0.0000241174,
2.937e-7,
-0.0191469509,
0.0090753827,
-0.021551393,
-0.0656829402,
0.0328764878,
0.0289589427,
-0.0586080663,
0.00925026,
0.01334693,
-0.0100388303,
0.0310913976,
0.0171516128,
0.0324802399,
0.014714228,
-0.0139864404,
-0.056825202,
0.0203706492,
0.0524706505,
-0.0249112789,
0.013958157,
0.0252194945,
0.0456950665,
-0.0021062887,
-0.0455103517,
0.0067145983,
-0.0187944751,
0.0509781837,
-0.036324583,
0.0457459576,
-0.0124867009,
0.0196722224,
0.002912892,
-0.0228113197,
0.0065562003,
-0.0251227822,
0.0179674812,
-0.0290107634,
-0.0260874555,
-0.0249619987,
-0.0044552721,
0.0210102014,
0.0314961262,
0.0336747132,
0.0105144009,
0.0877099261,
-0.1359576285,
-0.0102618411,
0.0105564371,
-0.0305090845,
0.0099312998,
0.0916589871,
-0.0183877982,
-0.0188763849,
-0.0350336842,
0.0068675401,
0.0249139704,
-0.0457795747,
-0.0266610701,
0.0221632048,
0.009510153,
-0.0142944213,
-0.0608155057,
0.0151506038,
-0.0245000143,
0.0404383801,
-0.0712066367,
-0.036790248,
2.585875661e-34,
0.0240423344,
-0.0536907651,
0.0282380823,
-0.0436966941,
-0.086541146,
-0.0264805444,
-0.0347979553,
-0.025883263,
0.0363196321,
-0.0040003625,
-0.013751179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01057v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01057v3 | RLHF and IIA: Perverse Incentives | 2023-12-02T08:04:29 | 2024-02-01T18:57:20 | Wanqiao Xu, Shi Dong, Xiuyuan Lu, Grace Lam, Zheng Wen, Benjamin Van Roy | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing algorithms for reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) can
incentivize responses at odds with preferences because they are based on models
that assume independence of irrelevant alternatives (IIA). The perverse
incentives induced by IIA hinder innovations on query formats and learning
algorithms. | [
0.0565954149,
0.0873159021,
-0.0022880007,
-0.0491443947,
-0.0793137774,
0.0068963883,
-0.0145804249,
0.026185628,
0.0043962793,
-0.0166799892,
-0.027448982,
0.0066037551,
-0.0515457094,
-0.0200141594,
-0.0030752204,
-0.0677744523,
0.0345841125,
-0.0292655639,
0.0269112419,
-0.0349069983,
-0.0049918089,
-0.060033571,
-0.0010401703,
-0.0094555886,
0.0277920067,
-0.0009644652,
0.0089873709,
-0.0022117656,
-0.009266234,
-0.0440256558,
-0.0071333218,
0.0447883233,
0.0040116734,
0.0595426224,
0.0000018806,
-0.047722999,
-0.0404914953,
-0.0115499133,
-0.0207268,
-0.011625546,
0.0169930141,
0.0524214059,
0.0311887618,
0.005751966,
-0.0447091572,
0.0095624579,
0.025438169,
0.043769557,
-0.0242366474,
-0.0103995381,
0.0116647026,
0.0197185483,
-0.0394407809,
-0.0641379952,
0.0525886975,
-0.0096434131,
0.0172988921,
-0.0672988743,
0.0067107319,
-0.0089374287,
0.0029027602,
-0.0208403841,
0.0190690141,
0.0193189401,
0.0526471287,
0.0343710631,
-0.0085817333,
0.0036497898,
-0.0121334232,
0.0523794144,
0.0262491759,
0.0206783172,
-0.0013046542,
0.0061159325,
0.027812846,
0.0416540019,
-0.0563102067,
0.0401788056,
-0.0234427731,
0.0194086246,
0.0394014083,
0.0393906012,
0.0125270942,
0.0165330637,
-0.0191335361,
0.0562288724,
-0.0272667892,
-0.0525102206,
0.0277405139,
0.0589067414,
-0.0042269123,
-0.0008510196,
-0.0158586651,
-0.0222829469,
-0.0556117855,
-0.0270171408,
0.0225275531,
0.0496515445,
0.024950128,
-0.0279944185,
0.0082266917,
-0.000412837,
0.0180276297,
0.0193356052,
0.0417926684,
-0.0167006273,
-0.0511083752,
0.0552579015,
-0.0078830821,
0.0919004828,
-0.014043007,
0.0008784888,
0.032600712,
0.0824692547,
-0.0280420929,
-0.0008149436,
-0.0270402357,
0.0483248606,
-0.054764919,
0.0143756084,
-0.0452971794,
0.0579362884,
-0.0374321193,
0.0409237631,
-0.0994532183,
-0.0046315286,
-0.0185081754,
0.0325253308,
0.0125095313,
0.0356211327,
0.0103458837,
-0.0166873019,
-0.0179646797,
-0.0369290225,
0.0091815116,
0.0837181881,
0.0158768129,
0.0052987188,
-0.0219850317,
-0.0349623263,
0.0626684129,
-0.0175236538,
-0.0112454435,
-0.0257271007,
0.0142721161,
-0.0517913885,
-0.0197252873,
-0.0045535173,
-0.0291275848,
-0.005988305,
-0.062000256,
0.0706407055,
0.0186567698,
0.0048332531,
-0.0188727323,
-0.0149385929,
0.004881293,
0.0468105227,
-0.0345539786,
0.0262212623,
0.0360637717,
0.0158298053,
0.0124657061,
-0.019632088,
0.0028493686,
0.0408550352,
-0.0210202988,
0.0250706803,
0.0030795392,
0.0016195264,
0.0032097839,
0.0136553934,
-0.0301805101,
-0.0035828932,
0.0368568115,
0.0314637087,
0.0059628403,
-0.0388124138,
-0.0400054492,
-0.0040605599,
-0.0412715673,
0.0397790931,
-0.0202887375,
0.0394240431,
-0.024424836,
-0.0014243588,
-0.0018300546,
-0.0501789488,
-0.0476494581,
-0.0438140891,
0.0442124307,
-0.0103810076,
0.0073131961,
0.0789644569,
0.0418149419,
-0.0300497711,
0.0183456372,
-0.0943971202,
0.0703131557,
0.0315158479,
0.003792369,
-0.0599300936,
0.0273796432,
0.061823044,
0.0440308079,
-0.0409799702,
0.0387271456,
-0.0385194197,
-0.0623292886,
0.0252377428,
0.0460434891,
-0.0218762476,
-0.0183372833,
0.0377335548,
-0.0564747266,
0.0284778234,
0.0243388712,
0.0250836574,
-0.0479677208,
-0.0502234176,
-0.0711919293,
0.0660418794,
-0.0139731327,
0.0072511137,
0.0379209965,
-0.0329824202,
0.0271881521,
0.0298491139,
0.0343720615,
0.0205314904,
-0.0052513285,
0.0285380855,
0.0228905082,
-0.0109417876,
-0.0303465705,
0.0144115929,
0.0065036183,
0.0287587959,
-0.0180598982,
-0.0201766752,
0.0432698019,
0.0082496423,
0.0201862715,
0.0161201432,
0.0377024636,
0.0048722117,
0.0801077783,
0.0025959858,
-0.0052891369,
-0.0114232935,
-0.0360987261,
-0.0854380205,
0.0283391122,
0.0041888012,
-0.0152691826,
-0.0353963003,
-0.0648017228,
-0.0077239987,
-0.0856561437,
0.0258728191,
0.036794316,
-0.0003087901,
0.00200584,
0.0182429831,
0.0105317887,
-0.0141073465,
0.0095971869,
0.0099820551,
-0.0143619152,
0.0028914686,
0.0069988878,
-0.0181336738,
-0.0048015234,
0.021342108,
-0.0191713702,
-0.0248246901,
-0.0809268653,
0.0305417739,
0.0804449916,
0.0042473488,
0.0365479738,
0.0005124839,
-0.0239378363,
-0.0547058135,
-0.0007540312,
0.0064992583,
0.0667763054,
0.0595819131,
-0.0041516251,
0.0062198625,
-0.0259356145,
0.0087623708,
-0.0015201306,
0.0288520362,
0.006850563,
-0.0375119224,
-0.0365393311,
0.0781725869,
-0.0045230207,
0.006459224,
0.0378698334,
0.0385208912,
-0.0963362828,
0.005307721,
-0.068604961,
-0.0186494179,
0.0060275765,
-0.0254791174,
0.0399781466,
0.0002721065,
0.0020624967,
0.0127692288,
-0.0552912839,
0.075608708,
-0.002169708,
-0.0880566686,
-0.0763441548,
0.0021147579,
-0.0051096105,
0.0578432009,
-0.0092259003,
-0.0467645451,
0.0908895358,
0.0680567622,
0.0380746573,
-0.0292263776,
0.0096395593,
-0.029550394,
-0.0213477444,
-0.0164812896,
0.0178416464,
0.0291726757,
0.0066772518,
-0.0267938972,
-0.0108649153,
0.0482525304,
-0.0450507589,
0.0257881247,
0.0328179523,
-0.0124988239,
-0.0121408412,
-0.0836551413,
-0.0268973205,
-0.0789948776,
0.0485452116,
-0.035429772,
0.0041493322,
0.0031013093,
0.0048422446,
0.0052565075,
0.0595044456,
-0.0238254014,
-0.0422510877,
-0.0282376278,
0.0200282969,
-0.0052694017,
0.0228654314,
-0.0158536546,
-0.0037237015,
-0.0381855294,
0.0018447322,
0.0195411909,
0.0706723481,
-0.0203513764,
0.0594211593,
0.0807686821,
0.0310927127,
0.0032290376,
-0.0214768518,
0.0040049609,
-0.0752984658,
0.0207848251,
0.0016072793,
0.0259105619,
0.0160943363,
-0.0940707996,
0.0355901383,
-0.0243514068,
0.0931003764,
0.0179403611,
0.0448247679,
-0.0741566494,
0.0318118297,
-0.0147796804,
0.0943004787,
-0.0454379432,
-0.0661220774,
0.0558999665,
-0.0965848044,
0.0536546372,
-0.0055591264,
-0.0428326763,
-0.0185326505,
-0.05805327,
-0.0207377803,
-0.066501461,
-0.0460673198,
0.0238592979,
-0.0316225626,
0.0075083049,
0.0333124027,
0.0455840901,
0.0233049337,
-0.0441531315,
-0.0377723202,
-0.0040036547,
0.0994187742,
-0.0120889014,
-0.0290813353,
-0.0235091764,
-0.0476461574,
-0.0097324196,
-0.0078583434,
-0.0303295366,
0.0509778373,
-0.0198742747,
-0.0002111586,
-0.0558510683,
0.0216598921,
0.0216731671,
0.0157566052,
0.0008029449,
0.0533328541,
-0.0253953226,
-0.0025152825,
-0.016693471,
-0.0573983788,
0.024907738,
0.0547289439,
-0.034465488,
-0.0698609054,
-0.0272427201,
-0.0376223959,
-0.0111790076,
-0.0359208547,
-0.0049298173,
-0.0072340444,
-0.0171847269,
-0.0183995124,
-0.0191831477,
-0.0408472978,
-0.0499662422,
0.0328752771,
-0.0000601695,
0.0305712111,
-0.0225839466,
0.0111935623,
0.0120536257,
0.0005093795,
0.0091142198,
-0.0345096923,
-0.0312955938,
-0.0300624389,
-0.0074006063,
-0.0553872325,
-0.0130095538,
-0.1020010933,
0.0538121797,
-0.0137733705,
0.000410043,
0.0709735453,
0.03886123,
0.0492459983,
-0.0035792545,
0.0114219971,
-0.0465209521,
0.0489947423,
-0.0082384348,
0.0204439331,
0.049236726,
0.0039460673,
-0.0079071112,
-0.0001680565,
-0.0547302589,
-0.0029217293,
0.0367758907,
0.0415807404,
-0.0145061146,
0.0386583842,
0.0417483523,
0.0316002257,
0.0475222319,
0.0032082472,
-0.008455419,
0.0058457763,
0.0231070798,
0.024012709,
-0.0202207472,
0.0032979271,
-0.0252501927,
0.0688517541,
0.0468734242,
-0.0081390673,
-0.0054123322,
0.0262364037,
0.0201667584,
-0.0347484387,
0.0190828945,
0.0135709401,
0.0068880226,
0.0049557425,
0.0286027323,
0.012152723,
0.0355727375,
0.0525457561,
0.0614013039,
0.0185275003,
0.0145179611,
0.0389265902,
0.0036265,
-0.0243980587,
-0.0139566697,
-0.0711241364,
-0.0439020693,
0.0116540622,
-0.027239494,
0.0059016808,
0.0108888634,
0.0185173806,
0.004909033,
-0.0062615685,
-0.0008981189,
-0.0385465324,
0.0070440141,
0.0382037237,
0.0063509983,
0.0122833811,
-0.0180117376,
0.0138865262,
0.0413903818,
0.0252339691,
0.0600188188,
-0.1031958684,
0.0121852951,
-0.0251916889,
-0.0421363898,
0.052275084,
0.0097163338,
-0.0145712607,
-0.004382215,
-0.0780717283,
0.0067670648,
-0.03843024,
0.0046541626,
0.0151366042,
-0.0195820872,
0.0202217195,
0.0131373536,
-0.000794804,
-0.0108661167,
-0.0239262283,
-0.0004780373,
-0.0642954111,
-0.0348767601,
-0.0327898152,
-6.35425814e-33,
0.0127751911,
-0.0065557039,
-0.01383965,
-0.0144898659,
-0.0409167893,
-0.0507790558,
0.0170604493,
-0.0079850871,
0.0163004305,
-0.0399238542,
-0.0254253298,
-0.0450971462,
0.0136781,
-0.0103469165,
0.0543547757,
-0.0355688408,
0.018459389,
-0.0147725502,
-0.0382228754,
0.0078972476,
-0.0037736394,
0.0111623891,
-0.0112226084,
-0.035529919,
0.009208831,
0.0227739848,
-0.0027982905,
0.0560465977,
-0.064934738,
0.0437548608,
-0.0126361754,
0.0058680433,
-0.0085265534,
-0.0456067473,
0.0293286853,
0.0312504098,
-0.0563315451,
-0.0227277149,
0.0123021454,
-0.0303413421,
-0.0055842069,
-0.0153724337,
0.037891157,
0.0452875197,
-0.0561360158,
0.030694088,
0.0038531455,
-0.0153946755,
-0.0187633224,
0.0352513939,
-0.0002663273,
-0.0149569279,
0.0021783083,
0.0603508241,
0.0125876227,
0.1123506278,
-0.013480098,
0.0401432812,
-0.0113334209,
0.0703284144,
0.0004193942,
-0.017639704,
0.0173638817,
0.0349675529,
0.0371803604,
0.0009865904,
0.029701788,
0.0175217688,
0.0068342611,
-0.0087960139,
0.002614019,
0.0066653583,
-0.0016167571,
0.0225391649,
0.0308492016,
0.0274572074,
-0.0581950806,
0.0256412365,
0.0203059278,
0.0006749869,
0.0329739489,
0.0281085018,
-0.0884319246,
-0.0440636352,
-0.0169237629,
-0.0491565689,
-0.0381806977,
-0.0426137522,
0.0398825146,
0.0482835658,
-0.00973331,
0.029405402,
0.0147794634,
-0.0230534151,
-0.0808759257,
0.0049194042,
0.0354154781,
0.0134937549,
-0.0221249554,
-0.0636937767,
-0.066220507,
0.007373034,
-0.034852121,
-0.0074489145,
-0.0208114348,
0.0121715944,
0.0241271295,
-0.0307604671,
-0.0152272936,
-0.0053140242,
0.008172933,
0.0348037705,
0.0528848134,
-0.0277752448,
0.0228221361,
-0.0224984325,
0.022068277,
0.0262555089,
-0.0104996702,
-0.0111091342,
-0.0629193932,
0.0035184133,
-0.0433188677,
-0.001269188,
0.0333093964,
0.0086549995,
0.0139891682,
0.0325361863,
-0.0543929785,
-0.0864218995,
-0.0195829999,
-0.0305026714,
2.585e-7,
-0.0261389017,
0.051690679,
-0.0028028251,
-0.0170795247,
-0.0080290558,
0.0862725079,
-0.0106429774,
0.0196487494,
0.0249694865,
0.0786001384,
0.041399423,
-0.0080554755,
0.0131139122,
0.0093096858,
0.0063118278,
-0.062112391,
-0.0455762036,
-0.0018501979,
-0.0087886294,
-0.0542708077,
0.0078862263,
0.0055805151,
0.0313741826,
-0.0139991874,
0.0192810837,
0.0318616703,
0.0223836321,
-0.0646260381,
-0.011240215,
-0.0022360422,
0.0020801381,
-0.0069749663,
0.0063675502,
-0.0011931648,
0.0130684739,
-0.0194027349,
-0.0210362915,
0.0208006762,
-0.0120410006,
-0.0598341338,
-0.0359880365,
-0.0070501892,
0.0408946574,
-0.0333269648,
0.0517212264,
0.0113253267,
-0.0208531152,
0.0402805433,
0.0041280128,
-0.0001371035,
0.0262243319,
-0.0124228708,
-0.0448985361,
-0.0436788313,
0.0021255431,
0.0608859435,
0.0053023393,
-0.0126278866,
0.0087289633,
0.030302234,
0.0011935806,
-0.0302984174,
-0.0150076682,
0.112845391,
-0.0495726056,
-0.0003967456,
-0.0235419516,
2.440264054e-34,
0.0149734616,
0.0208024159,
0.046267949,
-0.0073321429,
-0.0111278221,
0.0326163322,
0.031157285,
-0.0132922688,
0.0571407899,
-0.0257676374,
-0.0213673506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01054v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01054v1 | Exploring and Improving the Spatial Reasoning Abilities of Large Language Models | 2023-12-02T07:41:46 | 2023-12-02T07:41:46 | Manasi Sharma | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) represent formidable tools for sequence
modeling, boasting an innate capacity for general pattern recognition.
Nevertheless, their broader spatial reasoning capabilities, especially applied
to numerical trajectory data, remain insufficiently explored. In this paper, we
investigate the out-of-the-box performance of ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4 and Llama
2 7B models when confronted with 3D robotic trajectory data from the CALVIN
baseline and associated tasks, including 2D directional and shape labeling.
Additionally, we introduce a novel prefix-based prompting mechanism, which
yields a 33% improvement on the 3D trajectory data and an increase of up to 10%
on SpartQA tasks over zero-shot prompting (with gains for other prompting types
as well). The experimentation with 3D trajectory data offers an intriguing
glimpse into the manner in which LLMs engage with numerical and spatial
information, thus laying a solid foundation for the identification of target
areas for future enhancements. | [
0.0492754616,
0.0528134331,
0.0097854417,
0.0430668481,
-0.0572791621,
0.033658836,
0.0174995456,
-0.0252691898,
-0.0234729517,
-0.0324571133,
-0.0260197613,
-0.0412210114,
0.0252553299,
0.0320007093,
0.0238828063,
-0.0374777615,
0.0431496911,
-0.1103138775,
0.0059244107,
-0.0131570362,
-0.0376799814,
0.0000573163,
-0.0468263291,
0.0369480923,
-0.0172493309,
0.0180767756,
-0.0151870688,
-0.0202094503,
-0.0021569664,
-0.1014428809,
-0.0199377462,
0.0629901662,
0.0810092092,
0.0762287676,
0.0000019175,
-0.0278501511,
-0.011349896,
0.0066940817,
-0.0203421954,
0.0118284402,
0.0135455728,
-0.0099296933,
0.0021706519,
-0.0084236618,
-0.0001220848,
0.0010533521,
0.0529750735,
0.0156960413,
0.0461650081,
0.0335250758,
-0.0078583248,
-0.0448302515,
-0.003454309,
-0.0112973312,
0.0488871075,
-0.0150221614,
0.0233359113,
0.0456270203,
0.0554522909,
0.0784107968,
-0.020967694,
0.0341610573,
0.0312493388,
0.0154900802,
-0.020375587,
0.0806099772,
0.0032667553,
-0.0138032334,
-0.0199365281,
0.0432320833,
0.0212501306,
-0.0189463831,
0.0206413027,
0.02616225,
0.0142839691,
0.0052035092,
-0.061614085,
0.0296779368,
-0.013297691,
-0.0241201874,
-0.0215382762,
-0.0174231958,
-0.0087077217,
-0.0079687415,
-0.0685236305,
0.0840485096,
0.0362209529,
-0.003464092,
-0.0484034009,
-0.0021139639,
0.0148897776,
-0.0889663771,
0.0101221837,
0.0572996736,
-0.0281578694,
0.0071749403,
-0.0219116267,
0.0457778871,
-0.0079451967,
-0.0127224941,
0.0322883874,
0.0590163134,
-0.0088907154,
0.0313182883,
-0.0530318432,
0.0793412104,
-0.0388851054,
0.0467398502,
-0.0130861877,
-0.0009230339,
-0.0150238555,
0.0044243452,
-0.0449733101,
0.0060953125,
-0.0543656908,
-0.0526206829,
0.0115060527,
0.0303359032,
0.0513683483,
0.0078267129,
-0.0249289554,
0.0251883026,
0.000904108,
-0.0097636953,
-0.0149049778,
-0.014241823,
-0.0207420476,
0.0160651486,
0.0041146604,
-0.0496216975,
-0.0245590918,
0.0068409531,
0.0107087661,
-0.0348553881,
-0.0036710901,
0.1030445248,
0.0167756844,
-0.071707882,
0.0151543524,
-0.0161762573,
-0.0341036469,
-0.0600938015,
0.0722825378,
-0.0781252757,
-0.0208392479,
0.0145906853,
-0.0329585858,
0.0024752549,
0.0348553695,
-0.0078916093,
-0.0329555087,
0.0605201349,
0.0099143647,
0.0008644816,
0.023801934,
-0.00381962,
0.0296742152,
0.0271466039,
0.0440450273,
0.0615545437,
-0.0046426831,
0.012418706,
0.011583481,
0.0408141166,
-0.0346081816,
-0.0048154793,
-0.060522221,
-0.0222140756,
0.0382412747,
0.0772632807,
0.0349230841,
0.0409666598,
-0.0289304107,
-0.0113741187,
0.0461641178,
0.0984791294,
-0.0384905487,
-0.0369735062,
0.0450688824,
-0.0161982626,
-0.0163481701,
-0.0293323845,
-0.0535820089,
0.0349607468,
-0.0091357669,
0.0012613849,
0.0160094667,
0.0242076591,
-0.0114818281,
-0.0322710462,
-0.0387339368,
0.0325951129,
0.0089528272,
0.0076450501,
0.0473564863,
-0.0265827905,
-0.0245591868,
0.0361769535,
-0.000571595,
-0.0312802047,
-0.0422193632,
-0.0063879518,
0.0241597295,
0.0132605964,
-0.0102451174,
0.0181351881,
-0.0911236703,
0.023936566,
0.0124004558,
0.024959011,
0.0169303045,
0.0163581148,
-0.0166774914,
-0.028904058,
-0.0770384595,
0.0363599434,
0.0101143401,
0.0455561318,
0.0766738951,
-0.0039216476,
0.0119996006,
-0.0361586437,
0.0104636615,
0.032034412,
-0.0107571958,
-0.0158423577,
-0.0225210041,
0.0065848981,
0.02711449,
-0.0057414602,
0.0047633024,
0.0131338229,
0.0489951745,
-0.0246136691,
0.0288422238,
0.0138259782,
-0.0451597013,
-0.0516731925,
0.0348660387,
0.0411241166,
-0.0345177874,
-0.0102874674,
-0.0327691697,
-0.0234700348,
-0.0062012747,
-0.0645535365,
-0.0048351162,
0.0085047688,
0.0050479067,
0.0460734703,
-0.008135804,
-0.077539444,
0.0261688251,
-0.0327678621,
0.0236496963,
0.0203488059,
0.044392813,
0.0007588642,
-0.0368400775,
-0.0000737082,
0.0393236503,
0.0139381886,
-0.0363194495,
-0.0009201926,
0.0059277746,
-0.0019725957,
-0.0388002172,
-0.0304531455,
-0.0270702988,
-0.0000686189,
0.0235911272,
-0.000008024,
-0.0520210564,
-0.0274847988,
-0.0036924924,
-0.0017937892,
-0.0039989785,
-0.0007794865,
0.0117511982,
0.0345588475,
-0.0086038569,
-0.0685406104,
-0.0168538783,
-0.0100055272,
-0.0230154004,
0.0146245258,
0.0425868183,
-0.0639822334,
-0.0503948443,
-0.0130568156,
-0.0614057928,
-0.0055816756,
-0.0368699804,
-0.0231111068,
0.0629800782,
-0.0747833923,
0.0273949355,
0.0361896493,
-0.03401649,
-0.0108873807,
0.0446427241,
-0.0355132632,
-0.0150889857,
-0.0043599089,
-0.0595785938,
-0.022302296,
-0.0163043737,
-0.0459202491,
-0.0008603375,
0.0562117547,
-0.0390465483,
0.0129662389,
-0.0312192626,
-0.0137663577,
-0.0141378781,
-0.0050309999,
-0.0392848179,
0.043788027,
-0.0247795135,
0.0358886756,
-0.0373872556,
-0.0384704508,
0.0222477186,
-0.0862351283,
0.0042627146,
-0.0050278916,
0.01530114,
-0.0193822253,
0.0977851003,
0.0460178852,
0.0135728111,
-0.0022989053,
-0.0444824919,
0.0175259672,
0.0086975219,
-0.033008717,
0.0086825676,
0.0033926982,
-0.0905539244,
0.0585187748,
0.0232939757,
-0.0144057497,
-0.0139128221,
0.0193551257,
-0.0420301631,
0.0155874426,
-0.0337654538,
-0.0878701359,
0.0228102989,
0.0372143462,
0.0656175539,
0.0676641688,
-0.0448957533,
0.0104310131,
-0.0497744046,
-0.0030440425,
0.0277615301,
0.079963468,
-0.0073648035,
-0.0187650863,
-0.044333823,
0.0405247435,
0.0004952922,
0.0136964582,
-0.043855194,
0.0448018126,
0.0334797986,
0.0197539032,
-0.0136076892,
0.0522290468,
0.0722261891,
-0.0612265132,
-0.0680601969,
0.0827660859,
0.0322107933,
0.0153307579,
-0.0079955133,
-0.0001688828,
0.0391261429,
0.0337884538,
-0.0231566187,
-0.0271811895,
-0.0350215957,
0.039431762,
-0.0459397249,
0.0118657006,
-0.0205576122,
0.0136428596,
-0.115505524,
0.0721389577,
0.0060497569,
-0.0880613849,
-0.0738517195,
-0.028115835,
-0.0109897042,
0.0211534817,
-0.034107741,
-0.0077518728,
-0.0285972245,
0.0148774469,
0.0524050295,
-0.002257166,
-0.0261628125,
0.0150417257,
-0.0181606319,
0.0209949221,
0.0285601243,
0.0312122162,
-0.0022606705,
-0.0421951227,
0.0284690633,
0.0668157786,
0.0419806987,
-0.0195465852,
-0.0207975488,
0.0315557979,
-0.0001677881,
0.0090667494,
0.0291893519,
-0.0254837982,
-0.0502032936,
-0.0439104438,
0.0592802241,
-0.0623283572,
0.063466616,
-0.0188664179,
0.0206673816,
-0.0422798134,
0.054018259,
0.0288441386,
0.0314230733,
-0.0281857252,
-0.0340778828,
-0.0172729846,
0.0208150633,
-0.0307280943,
0.0004312368,
-0.0141397677,
-0.0540226921,
-0.0683591366,
-0.0025148557,
0.0705592111,
0.0582593866,
-0.0045012292,
-0.0002857024,
-0.0033822812,
-0.0061651324,
-0.0573764741,
0.0552359819,
-0.0295572951,
0.0131525965,
-0.071324639,
0.0400657058,
0.0047095362,
-0.0278643984,
-0.0420347154,
0.0131827025,
-0.0628067553,
-0.0412818529,
0.0217277333,
0.0353239402,
0.0206356831,
0.0243085641,
-0.0007740585,
0.0021884146,
0.0215835776,
0.0338960998,
0.0380729511,
0.0532643795,
-0.0069967988,
0.0466315225,
-0.0060010888,
-0.0166383609,
-0.0088492706,
0.0341950767,
0.0058984561,
-0.0037023283,
-0.0375595987,
-0.0274672601,
-0.0061856299,
0.0248739775,
0.1357340068,
0.0247318428,
-0.0229372531,
-0.0334407091,
0.0106283976,
-0.025688732,
0.0044997591,
-0.0514376685,
0.0150156114,
0.0206340402,
0.0196473505,
-0.0023912,
-0.0164423529,
0.0252356529,
0.0196090881,
-0.0359158814,
-0.0113007277,
-0.007458041,
0.0218782462,
0.0013827232,
-0.0044123912,
-0.0133123007,
0.0534137711,
-0.0300108865,
0.0499209985,
-0.0093587125,
0.0374284163,
0.0302649606,
0.0128264558,
-0.024670139,
0.0336986184,
-0.0960166231,
-0.0830590725,
-0.020472521,
0.0286693461,
0.0738333315,
0.0005678046,
-0.0244893078,
-0.0683049485,
-0.0128749264,
0.0089257658,
0.0234229583,
0.0422682352,
-0.0355367027,
0.0665915087,
0.012981155,
-0.0244876128,
-0.037482895,
0.0321140811,
0.0179183427,
0.0619712137,
0.0305547751,
-0.0123325177,
-0.0104351351,
-0.0383479185,
0.0278055556,
-0.0355681106,
-0.0010219078,
0.0250639711,
-0.0062045064,
-0.0293231122,
-0.0229102243,
0.0380009115,
-0.0414626598,
-0.0051782113,
0.0488047749,
0.032852944,
-0.0168689601,
-0.046452567,
-0.0217898712,
-0.0053384039,
0.0280613769,
-0.0373443589,
-0.0085711051,
-6.018247488e-33,
-0.0260910504,
-0.051230479,
0.0640137568,
-0.0408123545,
-0.0103423288,
-0.0006329847,
-0.0281386897,
0.0119717,
-0.0028997217,
0.003146447,
0.006566518,
-0.006630965,
0.0218258351,
0.0108292587,
0.0229505673,
-0.0011826627,
0.0308652706,
0.0041785398,
-0.0146327056,
-0.0074375374,
0.0493310504,
0.0085714022,
0.0620113239,
-0.018884642,
-0.0072071431,
0.0079407375,
-0.006654399,
0.0216711219,
-0.0570199862,
0.0459586643,
-0.0266337823,
-0.0574760363,
-0.0068805669,
-0.0319483504,
-0.0375648364,
0.0101462938,
-0.0612151846,
-0.032407321,
-0.018290244,
0.0176852252,
-0.0012734848,
-0.0503072068,
0.0303708166,
-0.0164494421,
-0.0576830208,
0.0080115031,
-0.0018940652,
-0.0098095695,
-0.0527745076,
0.017955631,
-0.0207983591,
0.0383959077,
0.0357343294,
-0.0529357754,
0.0471023135,
0.0274595469,
0.0160262845,
0.0039362991,
0.0084266197,
0.0118557401,
0.0058108317,
0.0570933968,
0.0404775552,
0.0393001176,
0.0299147945,
0.0598881245,
0.0390063673,
-0.0497490242,
-0.0159730949,
-0.0061223297,
0.0313772149,
0.0327565335,
0.012359879,
-0.0035835009,
0.034975756,
0.047299426,
-0.0439695716,
0.0143125849,
-0.059652973,
0.0450195223,
0.023301661,
-0.0133758811,
-0.0454527885,
-0.0072596655,
-0.0249572005,
-0.006008605,
-0.0105413999,
0.0282817837,
0.0254938602,
-0.0052599115,
0.0336748324,
-0.0002442651,
0.0618298948,
0.0258762967,
-0.038336549,
-0.0058652908,
-0.011184142,
0.0380307548,
-0.0079647843,
0.0377665237,
-0.0640719011,
-0.0343342423,
0.0057740975,
-0.0196199771,
0.0163742695,
-0.0045098765,
-0.0094728954,
0.0243079681,
-0.0369628221,
-0.0207726173,
-0.0536971875,
-0.0110491943,
0.0107257841,
0.0117909601,
0.0864426717,
-0.0239951182,
-0.0027373435,
0.0784102604,
-0.0364019945,
-0.0197635535,
-0.0157643501,
0.0068083685,
-0.0532765724,
0.0296857748,
-0.0242347922,
0.0136981457,
-0.0299077164,
-0.0059023867,
0.0074438676,
-0.0638669357,
-0.0244439449,
0.0310385078,
2.839e-7,
0.025489537,
0.0860613659,
0.0339100286,
0.0220021307,
-0.0165072326,
0.0244540889,
-0.031635385,
0.009450255,
-0.0051075127,
0.0069933343,
0.0041114385,
0.0349327177,
0.0182799641,
0.003500768,
-0.0596974902,
0.0084936973,
-0.0260632206,
-0.0180456415,
-0.089012675,
0.036104314,
0.0632850006,
0.0742841586,
-0.0259121787,
0.0085955113,
0.0143352868,
-0.0253111199,
0.0291242246,
-0.0403386354,
0.0166052468,
0.0105223414,
0.0368068367,
-0.0095987609,
-0.0027193527,
-0.0084097246,
0.0089722993,
-0.0187994987,
0.010259375,
0.086847119,
-0.0172567125,
-0.0119579621,
0.0002666276,
-0.0139539475,
-0.0273667574,
-0.0498540625,
0.0601356998,
-0.0701858699,
0.0084845908,
0.016075382,
0.0163563788,
-0.0101744449,
0.016118858,
0.0110804494,
0.0142718311,
-0.0151505871,
0.0198647287,
-0.0163678639,
-0.0012287267,
-0.0835111216,
0.0019450713,
0.0024421774,
-0.0525527149,
-0.000209749,
-0.0387174375,
-0.0386260115,
0.006123154,
0.0062523927,
-0.060585551,
2.72638994e-34,
-0.007723541,
-0.0167330261,
-0.0059465147,
0.001993234,
0.0190913063,
0.0145439375,
0.0296058487,
0.0375873968,
-0.0170543268,
-0.0811380744,
-0.0069443714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01053v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01053v2 | End-to-End Speech-to-Text Translation: A Survey | 2023-12-02T07:40:32 | 2024-06-08T08:52:48 | Nivedita Sethiya, Chandresh Kumar Maurya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech-to-text translation pertains to the task of converting speech signals
in a language to text in another language. It finds its application in various
domains, such as hands-free communication, dictation, video lecture
transcription, and translation, to name a few. Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR), as well as Machine Translation(MT) models, play crucial roles in
traditional ST translation, enabling the conversion of spoken language in its
original form to written text and facilitating seamless cross-lingual
communication. ASR recognizes spoken words, while MT translates the transcribed
text into the target language. Such disintegrated models suffer from cascaded
error propagation and high resource and training costs. As a result,
researchers have been exploring end-to-end (E2E) models for ST translation.
However, to our knowledge, there is no comprehensive review of existing works
on E2E ST. The present survey, therefore, discusses the work in this direction.
Our attempt has been to provide a comprehensive review of models employed,
metrics, and datasets used for ST tasks, providing challenges and future
research direction with new insights. We believe this review will be helpful to
researchers working on various applications of ST models. | [
0.0063142306,
-0.016622154,
0.009057452,
0.0105229607,
-0.0274367929,
-0.0096622268,
0.0046117655,
-0.020544624,
-0.0138501013,
-0.0262573361,
-0.0403207839,
-0.031975735,
0.0592865758,
0.0236270856,
0.0332607515,
-0.0373841524,
0.0373571254,
-0.0352033861,
-0.0499664024,
0.0149668334,
0.0086121783,
0.0219619237,
0.002083532,
0.0150321992,
-0.0017713672,
0.0074629621,
-0.0151924519,
0.039162524,
0.0412663966,
0.0010785792,
-0.0360293612,
-0.0062817857,
0.0645825192,
0.0752049536,
0.000001931,
-0.0147844329,
-0.0368773304,
0.0058600088,
-0.0101213111,
-0.0081450762,
0.0563539974,
-0.0434998572,
-0.0129160248,
0.068343997,
0.0033990475,
0.0085999537,
0.0709863454,
-0.0035112987,
0.0245125275,
0.0439483933,
-0.0239421185,
-0.0215507485,
0.0662886873,
-0.0490873083,
-0.0161686838,
-0.0122224381,
-0.008094321,
-0.0319029912,
-0.0430874005,
-0.001324426,
-0.0242396016,
0.0765164569,
-0.0086622545,
-0.0089393975,
0.0141979549,
-0.0287602507,
-0.0310236085,
-0.0357672684,
-0.0476009287,
0.0614863448,
-0.0132565182,
-0.0052080182,
0.0225789677,
0.0057483772,
-0.0342480727,
0.0132099697,
-0.0082445145,
0.0204741266,
0.0001873477,
-0.0168511979,
0.0089951903,
0.0531006269,
0.0309216883,
-0.0487597845,
-0.040063858,
-0.0334808491,
0.022919409,
-0.00670359,
-0.0102356467,
-0.0190225765,
-0.0162184294,
-0.0008189246,
0.1074397117,
-0.0013334246,
0.0282167792,
0.0035263267,
-0.031023249,
-0.0725639611,
-0.0368859172,
-0.02550257,
0.0474720635,
0.0808525458,
-0.0315842852,
0.0073459763,
-0.0218552295,
0.0308975186,
-0.0331632309,
-0.0079609985,
-0.0254210252,
-0.0221789498,
-0.0082333032,
0.0270367134,
-0.0452691354,
-0.0220706556,
-0.0643691346,
-0.053985022,
-0.0108148046,
-0.0139580332,
0.0124413408,
0.0091263885,
0.0229165275,
-0.0446035378,
-0.073756583,
-0.0274132453,
0.0332629085,
0.0661979467,
0.0314381272,
0.0131355952,
0.0020816172,
-0.0084016565,
1.55e-7,
0.0299771633,
0.0130305961,
0.0341034234,
-0.0126541751,
0.0595941022,
-0.0250454955,
-0.0112306727,
-0.0405260324,
0.0036770615,
-0.0472640358,
-0.0519591086,
0.0132742738,
-0.0605272539,
0.0681502074,
0.0007031034,
0.0131224338,
-0.0282995161,
0.0119849276,
-0.0377218463,
-0.0105796298,
0.0573678836,
-0.0019174149,
0.0452919714,
0.0806296244,
-0.0091619212,
-0.0061093192,
0.0255204346,
0.0840961859,
0.0169662088,
0.0161725059,
-0.0153241381,
-0.0019510075,
0.1117159277,
0.0103868553,
0.0515519828,
-0.0522632673,
-0.0187547579,
0.0526195392,
0.025126351,
-0.0128490971,
0.0921422169,
-0.0201024916,
0.0342733525,
0.0587700643,
0.0339892507,
0.0100632347,
0.0266731214,
0.0637336746,
0.0374484137,
-0.0382606462,
-0.0241415799,
-0.0018386609,
0.0108353579,
0.0073815398,
0.0011467225,
0.0785158128,
0.0186708085,
-0.0376057662,
-0.0253496189,
-0.0059820134,
-0.0226396061,
0.0127264401,
0.0177633911,
0.0732833073,
-0.0140927695,
-0.0707127899,
0.0566770323,
-0.0293491147,
-0.0825143158,
0.0744388327,
-0.0182761755,
-0.0416923501,
0.0551979281,
0.0310829934,
-0.0003521922,
0.0135662295,
-0.0504437126,
0.013861198,
0.0622304901,
0.0275249854,
0.0169393383,
0.0428980142,
-0.0628490597,
-0.0006613815,
0.0699850246,
0.0186730959,
0.0446809866,
-0.0452741422,
0.0548911989,
0.0332080685,
-0.004765925,
-0.0541576482,
0.0097733764,
-0.0167040844,
0.0205885731,
0.0343615785,
0.0187338348,
0.0189705491,
0.0280759744,
-0.030844273,
-0.0098060407,
0.0286385063,
-0.0463670157,
-0.0127666965,
0.0063996711,
-0.047936365,
-0.0144476434,
0.0109987948,
-0.0496705845,
0.0358924121,
0.0449898243,
0.0100793922,
-0.1014087945,
-0.0043178732,
-0.0163498316,
0.0065638223,
-0.0330960304,
0.0788813382,
0.0144435046,
-0.0126179755,
0.0200041719,
-0.0191237405,
0.0046835491,
-0.029504139,
0.0237854011,
-0.0276354607,
0.0196689609,
-0.0871511847,
-0.0198809616,
0.0368215181,
-0.0179621428,
0.0314779878,
0.0269604549,
0.0051258518,
0.0124660973,
-0.0254873112,
-0.0792827085,
0.0111993784,
-0.0151142767,
0.0484707989,
0.0227375403,
0.0388448536,
0.003750457,
-0.0031657938,
-0.0176109932,
-0.0148815317,
0.0195352416,
-0.0310615171,
-0.0273721721,
-0.0150816999,
-0.0076255933,
-0.0351312086,
-0.0230278689,
0.012692662,
-0.0130000412,
0.0039070114,
-0.0506992564,
-0.0762763917,
0.0485998951,
0.0008609557,
0.027284326,
-0.0156756192,
-0.0314677246,
-0.0176140256,
-0.0199784543,
0.0116523718,
0.0492407642,
0.0020025936,
-0.0443810634,
0.0186205767,
-0.0334405042,
-0.0563057177,
0.0034710276,
-0.0112017803,
-0.0012059828,
-0.0035431788,
-0.0501940586,
0.003448189,
0.0456671417,
0.0261596981,
0.0266657863,
-0.0730112195,
-0.0727996454,
-0.0172445979,
-0.0034701186,
-0.0062587173,
-0.0144851953,
-0.0112074753,
0.0465146452,
-0.0121188927,
-0.0231832471,
0.0193148199,
-0.0986583084,
-0.0349523239,
-0.0307436269,
0.0159087852,
-0.0407784805,
0.0069041369,
-0.0176437907,
0.0132816546,
-0.0342153758,
-0.0360624604,
-0.0432547033,
0.0182629395,
0.0119855339,
-0.0428965241,
0.0272839088,
-0.040648669,
-0.0110164965,
-0.0342190266,
0.0049225865,
0.0206712838,
0.0247614272,
-0.0184079409,
0.0021962076,
-0.0062313867,
-0.0412523896,
-0.0484213196,
0.0350539908,
0.0022890528,
0.0871453807,
0.0030391365,
0.02285924,
-0.0416961908,
0.0404120609,
0.016117271,
-0.0378027298,
-0.0182569809,
-0.057882458,
0.0554223359,
-0.0127338925,
0.0474176854,
0.0120259868,
-0.0132701267,
-0.0273329932,
0.0530870035,
0.032288529,
-0.0359206051,
0.0050059524,
0.0678071678,
-0.0523812883,
0.0284247547,
0.0945979804,
-0.0183583181,
-0.0331156179,
-0.0457856022,
-0.0003889325,
0.0242872592,
-0.0029735116,
-0.0015008027,
-0.0903363451,
-0.0372185484,
0.0313410722,
0.040635664,
0.0404124409,
0.0279541574,
-0.0075499848,
-0.0585553832,
0.0395420343,
0.0569851175,
-0.0799217969,
-0.0383638106,
-0.0039448063,
-0.0138695603,
-0.0265966151,
0.0168148298,
-0.0235569105,
-0.0101652583,
-0.0326831117,
0.0123516908,
-0.012534325,
0.0019182179,
0.0143175013,
-0.0279424191,
0.0322487503,
0.0547154024,
0.026850529,
-0.0076773735,
-0.0068773637,
0.0401011668,
-0.0181998238,
-0.0274439324,
-0.0092923185,
0.0049865223,
-0.0217446368,
-0.0016084171,
0.047498025,
0.0581924468,
-0.0131402211,
0.0595008954,
0.0414666012,
0.0533821434,
0.0282060485,
0.007348272,
0.0216443613,
0.0026132534,
0.029854279,
0.0590241775,
-0.0018635268,
-0.0564490408,
-0.0193807818,
-0.0051806495,
0.0254759118,
-0.007863502,
0.0070644924,
-0.0133873364,
-0.0080092875,
-0.0328333192,
-0.0569429472,
-0.0155710448,
0.0204138607,
-0.0068619694,
0.0427175835,
0.0381966606,
0.0226900652,
0.0254131518,
-0.0181253497,
0.0124325454,
-0.0302893557,
0.0564513393,
-0.0824945122,
0.0415242091,
-0.0263368357,
-0.0649045035,
0.0147989122,
0.0054442859,
-0.089683488,
-0.0786690265,
-0.0078188647,
0.0024610732,
0.0253035109,
0.0541956164,
-0.0297473781,
0.0029247773,
0.0310288183,
-0.0244308654,
-0.0552172139,
-0.0113419713,
0.0431994908,
0.0331773087,
-0.0408552662,
0.0273421966,
-0.0115382876,
0.0156732518,
-0.0256717224,
0.0297745652,
0.006313445,
-0.0974065661,
-0.0224636532,
-0.0043105115,
0.0325810313,
-0.007842158,
-0.0199455339,
-0.0209405348,
0.0314127617,
0.0133145452,
0.0486776382,
-0.0707702264,
0.006020234,
0.0359049179,
0.0210413057,
0.0077716056,
0.0087471232,
-0.018661594,
-0.0349616446,
-0.0100755999,
0.0267712809,
-0.0049238778,
0.0586660355,
0.0455215462,
0.0159555338,
-0.0323052816,
0.0239089765,
0.0044681048,
0.0072544231,
-0.0149668697,
0.0541152321,
-0.0072274925,
0.0210879482,
0.0429754294,
0.0319485106,
-0.0211414564,
-0.0306005459,
-0.0116273314,
0.0085257133,
0.0237221625,
0.0320387706,
0.1053047404,
0.0181597341,
0.0212168004,
-0.0624539331,
0.0685958713,
-0.0459979214,
0.0120495707,
-0.0233629681,
-0.0264254343,
0.0177532602,
0.0539855026,
-0.0035888636,
0.0077841142,
0.0283466522,
-0.0306424052,
-0.0015166834,
0.0014959747,
-0.0250591952,
-0.0192718543,
-0.0446563773,
-0.0403625406,
-0.0435424931,
-0.0301675722,
-0.0622676797,
0.0398468561,
0.0186645817,
0.0212695841,
-0.0571360439,
0.0010150481,
0.0183555819,
-0.0511008576,
0.043428991,
-0.0153899072,
-0.0276970491,
0.0060675661,
-0.0177720431,
-0.0186885018,
-5.685589934e-33,
-0.017566897,
0.0025857305,
0.0112793064,
0.0012523406,
-0.0508738756,
-0.0380258486,
-0.0336736552,
-0.0120479781,
-0.0122807352,
-0.0337547399,
-0.0203820467,
0.0307514705,
0.0250522196,
0.0137261674,
0.0068861572,
0.0380648598,
0.0708849132,
-0.049647335,
-0.0326109603,
0.0678471103,
0.061385531,
0.0185324363,
0.0546359159,
-0.0352884457,
0.0088872472,
-0.0193539113,
-0.0039978931,
0.0147940451,
0.0233367942,
0.0023108632,
0.0075077345,
-0.0041074883,
-0.0094723813,
-0.0148227327,
-0.0091285333,
0.0444306731,
-0.0911281258,
0.0479429625,
-0.0328304172,
0.0332557857,
-0.0306295846,
-0.0351373516,
0.0089997444,
-0.0213020369,
-0.0137538183,
-0.0324417762,
0.0070955083,
-0.0313865952,
-0.0111401938,
-0.0313790217,
-0.0280685201,
0.0227867514,
-0.011146361,
-0.0537573993,
0.0437274016,
0.0945387557,
-0.0036753705,
-0.0297679678,
-0.0533751063,
0.048581522,
0.0114464611,
0.0012964449,
0.0783842579,
-0.0040103379,
-0.0289749783,
-0.023580635,
0.0304153841,
-0.0478112027,
0.046093531,
-0.0169052966,
0.0568896532,
0.0036797975,
0.0386272967,
0.0163835287,
0.0245706439,
-0.0148418965,
-0.0353583284,
-0.0015396359,
-0.0246210843,
0.0034442407,
0.0041855942,
-0.0194194652,
-0.0159611441,
-0.0078670662,
-0.0761027634,
-0.0520453081,
0.0001395066,
-0.0168937799,
0.0356663279,
0.0299058519,
0.0052564135,
-0.029925948,
0.1207735017,
-0.0053365864,
0.0351468399,
-0.0324070565,
-0.0098525202,
0.0195817351,
-0.0357058235,
0.0586669594,
-0.0677995458,
-0.0292417966,
0.0050886371,
0.0302140135,
-0.0183467008,
-0.0369254798,
-0.0103476597,
0.0477289669,
-0.0252897199,
0.022021601,
-0.0216180254,
0.0248359106,
-0.022016257,
0.0344457701,
0.0471254624,
-0.0334989987,
0.0122000584,
0.0504791252,
-0.0285801589,
0.0148184402,
-0.0198098645,
0.0029369832,
0.027421359,
0.0408533104,
-0.0622747354,
0.0215807352,
-0.0148834428,
-0.0110212928,
0.0428510122,
0.0051173265,
-0.0088852886,
0.0076291664,
2.57e-7,
0.0074205277,
-0.0035622774,
0.0236181039,
-0.0092032794,
0.0216142908,
0.0186169706,
-0.0099128978,
0.0135611799,
0.0131044919,
0.0445105918,
0.0127188899,
-0.015804315,
0.1423028558,
-0.0184003524,
-0.0623024553,
-0.0358570777,
-0.0355825312,
0.0565192662,
-0.0183506813,
0.0160632692,
0.0406897403,
0.0489591956,
-0.0569056943,
0.0011241618,
-0.0556284264,
-0.0083311321,
0.0870781168,
-0.029290121,
0.0229234938,
0.0050346507,
-0.0122070825,
0.0049962611,
-0.0880747363,
0.0046730503,
-0.0196032561,
0.0464536175,
0.0495230071,
0.0669511929,
0.0041529569,
-0.0158196166,
0.0087400144,
0.0452066027,
-0.0559385419,
-0.0168363564,
0.0303753559,
-0.0422956981,
0.0254597664,
0.0250464361,
-0.0286331382,
0.0251004156,
-0.0055796169,
-0.0209264085,
0.0206325632,
0.0194660034,
0.0367303155,
-0.0172623601,
-0.0104079032,
-0.0268930979,
-0.0101969931,
-0.0280071478,
-0.0250594225,
-0.032537654,
-0.0391753502,
0.0133521408,
-0.0246905815,
0.0032384591,
-0.0332099274,
1.943653277e-34,
0.0308315624,
-0.0633263141,
-0.0091113187,
-0.0360725746,
0.0187455434,
-0.0473094583,
-0.014602812,
0.0103430999,
-0.0125507163,
-0.0624992065,
-0.0651098117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01052v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01052v2 | SCTc-TE: A Comprehensive Formulation and Benchmark for Temporal Event Forecasting | 2023-12-02T07:40:21 | 2024-04-03T06:15:16 | Yunshan Ma, Chenchen Ye, Zijian Wu, Xiang Wang, Yixin Cao, Liang Pang, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, H.3.0 | Temporal complex event forecasting aims to predict the future events given
the observed events from history. Most formulations of temporal complex event
are unstructured or without extensive temporal information, resulting in
inferior representations and limited forecasting capabilities. To bridge these
gaps, we innovatively introduce the formulation of Structured, Complex, and
Time-complete temporal event (SCTc-TE). Following this comprehensive
formulation, we develop a fully automated pipeline and construct a large-scale
dataset named MidEast-TE from about 0.6 million news articles. This dataset
focuses on the cooperation and conflict events among countries mainly in the
MidEast region from 2015 to 2022. Not limited to the dataset construction, more
importantly, we advance the forecasting methods by discriminating the crucial
roles of various contextual information, i.e., local and global contexts.
Thereby, we propose a novel method LoGo that is able to take advantage of both
Local and Global contexts for SCTc-TE forecasting. We evaluate our proposed
approach on both our proposed MidEast-TE dataset and the original GDELT-TE
dataset. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our forecasting
model LoGo. The code and datasets are released via
https://github.com/yecchen/GDELT-ComplexEvent. | [
0.0025515729,
0.083929114,
-0.013110497,
-0.0377389751,
-0.0334245302,
-0.0010075181,
0.0231654588,
-0.0224830825,
0.0199157447,
-0.0065764971,
0.0596448034,
-0.0184054468,
-0.0375085399,
0.0650328025,
-0.0224138573,
-0.0848077014,
0.0507862978,
-0.0002770648,
0.0240109172,
-0.001783631,
0.0035735618,
0.002968323,
-0.0161128435,
0.0386784151,
-0.0336470753,
0.0093042469,
-0.067120716,
-0.0274935216,
0.0565695763,
-0.0438449383,
0.0210131928,
-0.0119252587,
0.0617284551,
-0.0055672708,
0.0000022988,
-0.014625649,
-0.0357971825,
-0.0540342629,
0.0147071686,
0.0167429764,
0.0019397946,
-0.0910505205,
0.0014667429,
0.0108137624,
-0.0766954049,
-0.0184214171,
-0.0265051741,
0.0511293449,
0.0672033206,
0.063793309,
-0.0363399722,
0.0041217455,
0.0518799387,
-0.0414771698,
-0.062820904,
-0.0516241826,
-0.013926331,
-0.0334934816,
-0.0301801506,
0.0089466181,
0.033371456,
0.0129040871,
-0.0060183303,
0.0341006778,
-0.0013303773,
0.0634984598,
0.003365241,
0.0291069131,
-0.0312293209,
-0.0272179879,
0.0385819003,
-0.0295585636,
0.0357592925,
0.0130042667,
-0.0289779827,
0.0154398223,
-0.0548443422,
-0.0286412928,
0.0061574029,
0.0354238376,
0.0635109767,
0.0276737437,
-0.0204258971,
0.0215326305,
-0.0076382207,
0.0793011934,
0.0047047599,
-0.0077462685,
-0.0811073855,
-0.0024745851,
0.0000165966,
-0.0668342784,
-0.0105451047,
0.0440670326,
-0.0457176007,
-0.0440491922,
0.0001185886,
0.0380751602,
-0.0295077357,
-0.0545628704,
-0.0432370864,
0.0570494086,
0.0409559458,
0.0685367882,
0.0203182921,
-0.0139730368,
0.0136851668,
-0.0491397046,
-0.0010861789,
0.0129283331,
-0.0645614192,
0.0246885214,
-0.0030645726,
-0.0042997273,
-0.0233242009,
-0.0134420441,
-0.0373610668,
-0.0075918073,
-0.0249417163,
0.0279670078,
-0.0025755044,
-0.0141892051,
-0.046499107,
-0.0120845223,
-0.0402328186,
-0.0179896541,
-0.0515466966,
0.0263033938,
-0.0541627966,
0.0050050174,
-0.0263499022,
-0.0265250951,
0.0187847856,
0.0148325013,
-0.0173535831,
0.0447278209,
-0.0244236887,
0.0215834994,
-0.0871026069,
-0.0269642938,
0.0449849032,
-0.018846713,
0.0109908357,
-0.012828392,
0.0421027653,
-0.0208749399,
0.0130988518,
0.035059303,
-0.0315084308,
-0.007470523,
-0.0012310898,
0.0442816541,
0.0111070648,
0.0246412437,
0.0069918493,
-0.0034624864,
0.0551604666,
0.0650679544,
0.030824611,
0.0155466925,
0.0278403275,
0.0209875442,
-0.0242182482,
0.0114638163,
0.0227769371,
0.0326944552,
-0.0411096849,
-0.0009110065,
-0.0405131206,
-0.0106035424,
-0.0157851763,
-0.0670149103,
0.0117789898,
-0.0337716974,
0.0417862236,
-0.0170815904,
-0.0247189682,
0.0349969342,
0.0260956492,
-0.010287256,
0.0099104345,
-0.029137874,
-0.0040290714,
0.0444216169,
-0.0478252769,
0.0057434002,
-0.0167323928,
0.0427968465,
-0.0323317423,
0.0284764227,
0.0228649434,
-0.0206042193,
0.0142433569,
-0.0646326169,
0.0462082736,
-0.0430949703,
-0.0464843474,
0.0435855985,
0.0344538279,
-0.0178314969,
0.0140918,
-0.0037750462,
0.037578892,
0.0310120936,
0.0419562869,
-0.0342422277,
-0.0781955719,
-0.0332443342,
0.0285627712,
-0.012854645,
-0.018130403,
0.0099563096,
-0.0049355575,
-0.0216807052,
-0.0718289241,
0.0207871255,
0.0326269902,
0.0078764949,
0.0494482368,
0.0773206577,
-0.0033124201,
0.0076541179,
0.0305665098,
0.0129272118,
-0.0180522595,
0.0080854436,
-0.0262784678,
0.0174478218,
0.0532072559,
-0.0024354975,
0.0106205139,
-0.0085451119,
0.0396389998,
-0.0043861861,
-0.0418015234,
0.0403176211,
-0.0176009219,
0.0093770185,
-0.0096736755,
0.0004711536,
0.0419406965,
0.0042374348,
-0.0002725619,
-0.0550843552,
0.1038898379,
0.0520812273,
0.0454621576,
-0.0075651086,
-0.0077336961,
-0.0014852047,
0.0099095851,
-0.0055475305,
0.0362533964,
-0.0183398072,
-0.0540260263,
-0.0121288281,
-0.0187885351,
0.0050031706,
0.0156131107,
-0.0002339289,
0.0201363973,
0.00393249,
-0.0241325945,
0.0287101325,
-0.0213572141,
-0.0193370767,
-0.0202169325,
-0.0613488108,
0.0013778434,
-0.0146282297,
0.0076802955,
0.0325599127,
-0.0195211619,
-0.0088386219,
0.0264667217,
-0.015520758,
0.0018836488,
-0.0422213264,
-0.0320290215,
0.009249106,
0.0139893377,
0.0050010444,
-0.0079252068,
0.0192475896,
-0.0416400358,
0.0598823503,
0.0186985377,
-0.0369468443,
0.0265180189,
0.0094565107,
-0.0271134302,
0.0187112316,
-0.0745632276,
-0.0234015658,
-0.0284653883,
-0.0378978141,
0.0202151481,
0.0110863876,
0.0036128592,
0.0563294999,
0.0076968577,
-0.0512299426,
-0.0369792432,
0.0488986671,
-0.0569564328,
-0.0013012979,
-0.0586355515,
-0.046223294,
-0.024114307,
0.0248097107,
0.0203667451,
0.0653953552,
-0.0626404434,
0.007455973,
-0.054282885,
0.0219126903,
0.0035787195,
-0.0276510287,
0.0383877046,
0.0552047268,
-0.0191241987,
-0.0222793948,
0.0285994038,
0.0245072804,
0.0116368011,
0.0256980322,
-0.0338047072,
-0.0944746509,
0.0407463871,
-0.0174497794,
-0.0269394126,
-0.0151408482,
0.0126256291,
-0.0402120501,
-0.0482255854,
-0.0006336629,
-0.0060852231,
-0.0081071397,
-0.0090741375,
0.0115808044,
-0.0154327154,
0.0076980786,
0.0085171722,
-0.0212421026,
-0.0172811709,
0.0132272169,
-0.0013728028,
-0.0188184157,
-0.0258479659,
0.0711611286,
-0.0143004162,
0.0428599007,
-0.0077919415,
-0.0207100231,
0.0107273357,
0.0384847671,
-0.0088158669,
-0.0642174929,
-0.0191153139,
0.0002875366,
0.0165035315,
0.0166081693,
0.0697932169,
0.0018302969,
-0.0591534339,
0.0350976698,
0.0438734144,
-0.0028207765,
-0.007094549,
-0.0297884997,
0.007004532,
-0.0665611476,
0.0425448231,
0.1084050983,
0.0309070684,
-0.0364079773,
0.0265043061,
0.0321791358,
0.0113685792,
-0.0142236305,
0.0027709005,
-0.0696158633,
0.0291685648,
0.0277858358,
-0.0256191697,
-0.020013079,
-0.0894504488,
-0.0159544051,
-0.0334557779,
0.0163101237,
0.0227577109,
-0.0092868982,
-0.0093571683,
-0.0700977743,
0.0208852272,
-0.0547570549,
-0.061187502,
-0.0197015144,
-0.0248924941,
0.0292611476,
0.0082043186,
-0.1149902195,
-0.0573573746,
0.0484667495,
0.0068964153,
0.0333557799,
-0.003191313,
0.0415795073,
-0.0073187347,
0.05306096,
-0.0126237357,
-0.0004496668,
0.0166835655,
-0.0138826612,
0.0452917293,
0.0014002611,
-0.0235005561,
0.0054904227,
0.0580682568,
0.0054714181,
-0.0464046448,
0.0203743,
0.0906604305,
-0.0347505473,
0.0093317302,
0.0094243186,
0.0240613315,
0.0272541344,
0.0332999192,
-0.0424523093,
-0.0164297577,
-0.0574465767,
0.0535117835,
0.0041287923,
-0.0790937692,
0.0093072327,
0.0007669711,
0.0032960048,
-0.0646755397,
0.0031527483,
-0.0811897591,
-0.038528271,
0.0179573167,
-0.0080247885,
-0.0077756238,
0.0055773803,
0.0139638586,
-0.0474110097,
0.0012697517,
0.0143959494,
0.0477923006,
0.0005859061,
-0.0098073334,
-0.0119145196,
0.0333764702,
-0.0320066065,
0.0544807352,
-0.1027475446,
-0.016956659,
0.0191482194,
-0.0463255234,
0.0126935206,
0.027898103,
0.0437308773,
0.0291674975,
0.0834442005,
0.0224315915,
-0.0262751821,
0.02341385,
0.052620396,
0.0170680862,
0.0267416462,
0.0385290533,
0.0307644419,
0.0323662311,
-0.0339963287,
-0.0279113408,
-0.0562341213,
0.0035642188,
-0.016458245,
-0.0763781518,
0.0663999468,
-0.0115350187,
-0.03594587,
-0.0328302197,
-0.0017433418,
-0.0288921464,
0.0321531147,
-0.02174576,
-0.0026687928,
-0.0069852765,
0.0189189687,
-0.0501543283,
0.0654288158,
0.0122119021,
-0.0530843511,
-0.0304992516,
0.0530188382,
0.0065737953,
0.0108040301,
0.0243550055,
0.0260435846,
0.0173079688,
-0.0430603586,
-0.0353084877,
-0.0287785027,
-0.0302585755,
-0.0020127478,
0.0261324476,
0.0603152439,
0.0267147832,
-0.0297966003,
-0.0990992561,
-0.0070251506,
-0.0195428487,
0.0130304014,
0.0568889678,
-0.0368987061,
0.040955577,
-0.0311873388,
0.0101975035,
0.0348718427,
0.0242515001,
-0.0350034013,
-0.0342175215,
0.0169740953,
-0.0202312209,
-0.050103683,
0.0867232755,
0.0534424968,
-0.0126238922,
0.0565239452,
0.0437570587,
-0.0567977168,
-0.0028091795,
-0.0138711659,
0.063015528,
-0.0026671672,
-0.0058127148,
-0.0045106011,
-0.0640626699,
-0.0113744615,
0.0774673745,
-0.0208119377,
-0.0199909117,
-0.0093996106,
-0.0157893207,
0.0248578414,
-0.0058049494,
0.0554192141,
-0.0361636877,
0.0110115176,
-0.0004762176,
-0.0446954295,
-0.0066996086,
-7.139257676e-33,
-0.0050992784,
0.0039448002,
0.0012464314,
-0.0204442646,
-0.0433235914,
0.0527547523,
-0.0581562147,
-0.0578509457,
0.0032026782,
0.0111768739,
-0.0274772476,
0.0300721359,
0.0185373276,
-0.001928446,
0.057222683,
-0.0151373586,
0.021768095,
-0.0372759253,
0.0176892187,
0.0581556857,
0.0536381193,
0.0183107853,
0.0626273006,
-0.0533771105,
-0.0101364013,
0.0126328617,
-0.0307615083,
-0.0346606299,
0.1035813242,
0.0271724965,
-0.0169160683,
-0.0172776282,
0.0367555097,
-0.0459291562,
0.0235472322,
-0.0257096253,
-0.0109049501,
-0.0188552476,
-0.0290675908,
0.0012927634,
-0.0075706025,
0.0349525101,
-0.0647379458,
0.0109468466,
-0.0350596942,
-0.0120305046,
0.0416588895,
-0.0027373615,
-0.0111013306,
-0.063275896,
-0.0102546774,
0.0625553727,
-0.0678740665,
0.010466476,
-0.027055461,
0.0567126088,
0.0535357036,
0.042531237,
-0.0524840727,
0.0443609767,
-0.0263298452,
0.0252513867,
-0.0102166645,
-0.0349384733,
0.0096750129,
0.0681659058,
0.0092822704,
-0.0185539201,
-0.0402962156,
0.0294545144,
0.0092379646,
-0.0001299273,
-0.0160673093,
0.0314778723,
0.0104245758,
-0.0597834848,
-0.0812594816,
0.0317178816,
0.0447260812,
0.0475250706,
0.0139970863,
0.0122023476,
0.0085652191,
-0.0106111653,
0.0369093269,
-0.0491365343,
-0.0049255919,
0.0287742838,
-0.0065858522,
0.0089796064,
0.0390801392,
0.0649665892,
0.0258377232,
-0.0185775384,
0.0278660879,
0.046727214,
-0.025151426,
0.0042776801,
0.0190220941,
0.0400714613,
-0.0346775576,
-0.024824407,
0.0048902952,
-0.0129071195,
0.013580746,
-0.039540492,
-0.0189443585,
0.0640076771,
-0.0313872024,
-0.0164375938,
-0.0206424259,
0.0279822163,
-0.0176152736,
-0.0458496734,
0.0418755375,
-0.0288336035,
0.0133283688,
0.0133175235,
0.0466927886,
0.0110752787,
0.0409094766,
0.0030036087,
0.0028755874,
0.0216281582,
0.0325047486,
-0.0081206318,
-0.0137942778,
-0.0286818426,
0.0092639402,
-0.0344450064,
-0.0161590185,
-0.0116720488,
3.055e-7,
-0.0113377376,
0.0220163595,
0.0061851023,
0.0567285754,
0.008542385,
0.0158189144,
-0.0269149486,
0.0570419095,
-0.0483894646,
0.0513154715,
0.068034783,
0.021772366,
0.0541836992,
0.0286605526,
-0.0562370457,
-0.0268062036,
-0.0765951499,
-0.0248669926,
-0.0879206657,
-0.0226224437,
0.0671436712,
0.0460179187,
0.0812387615,
-0.0004901772,
0.0249069352,
-0.0151688438,
0.0414053313,
-0.0241846796,
-0.0664619952,
0.0287944824,
-0.0259120446,
0.0276617967,
-0.0259097349,
0.0271981154,
-0.0468393229,
0.0095705017,
-0.0309998244,
0.03479103,
0.0321460925,
0.0100394199,
0.0066408673,
-0.0279459134,
-0.0429873578,
-0.0241636503,
0.0790319666,
-0.05887115,
-0.0205193982,
-0.0322588384,
-0.0555221736,
0.0873688683,
0.0298080258,
0.0338763781,
-0.0095546925,
0.058915507,
-0.0197915286,
0.0106797703,
0.0316449367,
-0.0411526263,
-0.0214181654,
0.0471575111,
-0.0328886323,
0.0199775808,
0.0012056397,
0.0037477934,
0.0192017779,
0.0010933031,
0.0040193517,
2.941774025e-34,
0.0344610028,
0.0312114973,
-0.0324108191,
0.0010118906,
0.0232807137,
-0.0170915816,
-0.0373791195,
0.0011240626,
0.0381550677,
0.00189285,
-0.0160263553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01050v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01050v2 | Detection and Analysis of Stress-Related Posts in Reddit Acamedic Communities | 2023-12-02T07:34:03 | 2024-03-02T21:53:37 | Nazzere Oryngozha, Pakizar Shamoi, Ayan Igali | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nowadays, the significance of monitoring stress levels and recognizing early
signs of mental illness cannot be overstated. Automatic stress detection in
text can proactively help manage stress and protect mental well-being. In
today's digital era, social media platforms reflect the psychological
well-being and stress levels within various communities. This study focuses on
detecting and analyzing stress-related posts in Reddit academic communities.
Due to online education and remote work, these communities have become central
for academic discussions and support. We classify text as stressed or not using
natural language processing and machine learning classifiers, with Dreaddit as
our training dataset, which contains labeled data from Reddit. Next, we collect
and analyze posts from various academic subreddits. We identified that the most
effective individual feature for stress detection is the Bag of Words, paired
with the Logistic Regression classifier, achieving a 77.78% accuracy rate and
an F1 score of 0.79 on the DReaddit dataset. This combination also performs
best in stress detection on human-annotated datasets, with a 72% accuracy rate.
Our key findings reveal that posts and comments in professors Reddit
communities are the most stressful, compared to other academic levels,
including bachelor, graduate, and Ph.D. students. This research contributes to
our understanding of the stress levels within academic communities. It can help
academic institutions and online communities develop measures and interventions
to address this issue effectively. | [
0.0863331035,
0.0352923237,
-0.0369593911,
-0.0163271651,
-0.0174784269,
0.0123286648,
0.0196160097,
0.0542938299,
0.0521732271,
-0.0653625429,
0.0241698716,
0.0222116318,
-0.0251445714,
-0.0170234442,
0.0043500089,
-0.0424880087,
0.0036986186,
0.0509853549,
0.0581370965,
0.0206640605,
0.0219115578,
0.0436043218,
-0.0277490597,
0.0335320905,
-0.0123834368,
-0.0422276445,
0.0800521597,
0.0240594465,
0.0476695299,
-0.0207789335,
0.0554522052,
0.064852491,
-0.0483635999,
0.0046957303,
0.0000019017,
-0.0217117351,
0.0015196123,
-0.0139361741,
0.0089778639,
-0.0377407111,
0.099670589,
-0.0380208232,
-0.0126084955,
0.0481489338,
-0.0319365039,
-0.0276556499,
0.043036636,
0.048060298,
0.0467847437,
0.0745258853,
-0.0377094932,
-0.0345925763,
-0.0251976028,
0.0315692127,
0.0077867098,
0.0440828353,
0.0475038178,
-0.0185804907,
0.0328931101,
-0.0282810703,
0.0191380605,
-0.0011915264,
-0.0527978651,
-0.0140466811,
-0.0143498154,
0.021889925,
0.0109385811,
-0.045200821,
0.0142516047,
0.0295383837,
-0.0143955424,
0.0252415426,
0.0258185323,
-0.0017817446,
0.0060107219,
0.0125670005,
-0.0231498871,
0.0033173589,
-0.0407306403,
0.0064892308,
0.0021514581,
0.0494105481,
-0.0012836443,
0.0215848684,
0.054623466,
-0.0313279442,
-0.0316100158,
-0.0430908054,
0.0377015211,
0.0152656212,
-0.0117619121,
-0.0250325706,
0.0613843575,
0.0045113601,
0.01844134,
0.0086377217,
-0.0182389542,
-0.1125527248,
0.0401146822,
-0.0430244543,
-0.0382016748,
0.001679554,
0.0015647532,
0.0238111746,
0.0311140325,
-0.0002464211,
0.0452086143,
-0.0446297936,
0.0057073277,
0.0433681607,
-0.0718631372,
0.0453704149,
-0.0096041793,
0.0155570125,
0.0111884093,
-0.0284752585,
-0.0333360769,
-0.003126499,
-0.0067499625,
-0.0298354216,
-0.0020395874,
-0.015901994,
0.0042207921,
0.0586045347,
0.046562437,
0.0148828374,
-0.0273682196,
-0.0126920445,
-0.0185261052,
-0.0329565927,
0.0645417348,
-0.0152551634,
0.0263236854,
-0.008192122,
0.0003741956,
0.0092158373,
0.0456326231,
-0.0114713963,
-0.0542279631,
-0.0333750062,
-0.0413702317,
-0.0030616496,
0.0048823562,
-0.0207441933,
0.0460568704,
0.0147146797,
-0.0109497849,
0.0169942006,
0.0271199923,
0.0303789396,
-0.0101177674,
0.0110532269,
-0.0582101196,
-0.003868873,
0.0479786545,
0.0273191072,
0.0319330245,
0.0123748453,
-0.0079192109,
0.0389465056,
0.0860504881,
-0.0346322954,
-0.003248015,
0.0026490844,
-0.0195137691,
-0.051477544,
0.0542809479,
-0.0266654603,
-0.0373359993,
0.0017479274,
-0.0456395671,
0.0197284259,
-0.0042857835,
0.0270796791,
0.0074126665,
0.063798964,
-0.0434177108,
0.0532305054,
-0.0502631702,
0.0625823215,
0.0202319864,
-0.0317967646,
-0.0065186722,
-0.0176655017,
-0.0361289531,
-0.0345772319,
0.0239898786,
0.0063327262,
-0.0137446066,
-0.0868404135,
-0.0800075755,
-0.0301936138,
-0.0093681607,
-0.0324512646,
0.0166476779,
-0.0434910879,
-0.0180713441,
-0.0064202622,
0.059203431,
-0.0673583746,
-0.0074750367,
0.0020368719,
0.0335171744,
0.0567781292,
-0.0199924186,
-0.0708973408,
-0.0129725384,
-0.0489305258,
0.0815811604,
0.046642486,
0.0407597013,
0.0364553593,
-0.0348923244,
-0.03688512,
-0.0052079689,
0.0076534343,
0.0146364961,
-0.0450168699,
0.0131972563,
0.0287733749,
-0.0311522484,
0.0294322055,
-0.0691761896,
0.0274032131,
0.0348187946,
-0.0269064736,
0.0071438104,
0.0022547853,
0.0178852882,
0.0303899851,
-0.0152544854,
-0.0131101338,
0.0158318784,
-0.0128693348,
-0.032116551,
-0.0426714197,
0.0077722552,
0.0125042889,
0.0046790303,
-0.0304383785,
-0.018812729,
0.0603016056,
-0.0505850315,
0.0301107019,
0.0554095544,
-0.0319455639,
0.0146166747,
0.0516400225,
-0.061264012,
-0.0195341837,
0.0506623723,
-0.0366785228,
0.0364867821,
-0.011894403,
0.0519731455,
-0.0599607192,
-0.0603389442,
-0.0041406034,
0.0063655442,
-0.0306606144,
-0.0495677181,
-0.0368335545,
0.0078310911,
0.0306839328,
-0.013213695,
-0.0380641744,
-0.0318321884,
-0.0759624392,
0.0040446348,
-0.0225147642,
0.0170200411,
0.0278686546,
-0.0493610725,
-0.0158702731,
-0.009378178,
-0.0081717214,
0.0220727678,
-0.023467008,
-0.0114341751,
0.0227257553,
-0.0328071043,
0.0422384702,
-0.0464875624,
-0.0360782072,
-0.0348179825,
-0.0121917361,
0.0931508541,
-0.0729159936,
-0.0277552474,
0.0124243284,
-0.0421499535,
-0.0039175763,
-0.0015194517,
-0.0353085957,
0.0003395566,
-0.002440271,
0.0306417271,
0.0411335826,
0.034417659,
0.0905852169,
-0.0211540926,
0.0491341911,
0.0122290524,
0.0160650071,
-0.0239410251,
-0.023921201,
-0.0334768482,
-0.0534717813,
0.0080588674,
0.010688182,
0.021226516,
-0.0049741911,
-0.0186834987,
0.017870957,
-0.0691102296,
0.0141114322,
-0.0264907591,
0.022517316,
0.0080057662,
0.0100628957,
-0.0056684031,
0.0130235609,
-0.0058843126,
0.0434601419,
0.0213241559,
-0.057154987,
-0.0542954355,
-0.0191463213,
0.0360719077,
0.0075999335,
0.0119214738,
0.0492336154,
0.0004331767,
0.0524177253,
-0.0249161348,
-0.009744822,
-0.0362480246,
-0.0735804886,
-0.0096608363,
-0.0223792791,
0.0024725783,
-0.0280108675,
-0.0172513686,
-0.0392178707,
-0.0589497797,
-0.0308622345,
0.0254513789,
-0.0262845699,
-0.0345486253,
-0.0546209849,
-0.0030760637,
-0.0105987191,
-0.01123494,
-0.0471662134,
0.030968057,
0.0232698116,
0.0661808774,
-0.0012644256,
0.0224253181,
-0.0008689775,
-0.011196902,
0.0954908654,
-0.0092379162,
0.0257106666,
0.0097782249,
-0.0637977198,
0.0221388154,
-0.0232450776,
-0.0058906842,
-0.0151282884,
-0.0390108526,
-0.0267192572,
0.0115763946,
0.1133677885,
0.0229102261,
-0.0038508468,
0.0146767544,
-0.0864847824,
-0.0035164908,
0.0299090873,
0.0108709391,
-0.042914696,
-0.0197204575,
-0.0477649458,
0.0186226368,
-0.0156463217,
-0.0390018858,
0.0257801171,
-0.0402898118,
0.0371317565,
-0.0334186628,
-0.0394804776,
0.0426010638,
-0.0551104173,
0.0255896859,
-0.0196958277,
-0.0090813953,
-0.0692752525,
0.0159806143,
-0.0021705271,
0.0551294573,
-0.0958532318,
-0.0333258249,
0.0018057488,
0.0045663565,
0.0068173311,
-0.0267851502,
0.1052881926,
-0.0176910367,
-0.0566625185,
0.052661337,
0.0191598702,
0.006088567,
-0.0281536784,
0.0804951712,
0.0026252279,
-0.0104260789,
-0.0408835411,
0.04376458,
-0.0830424875,
0.0370394327,
0.0355891064,
0.088511467,
0.0141460644,
-0.0275714919,
-0.0598914772,
0.0478271283,
0.0457622558,
0.0343299247,
0.0147144413,
-0.0417602211,
-0.0336463265,
0.0093038389,
0.0326429941,
0.0047031734,
-0.0366291255,
-0.0426650345,
-0.0169082601,
-0.0145015158,
-0.0517851114,
-0.0463978536,
0.0116709322,
-0.0329525433,
-0.0238754861,
-0.0318618268,
0.0094261095,
0.0070431149,
-0.0829094499,
0.0172867551,
0.0110906791,
0.0341963656,
-0.002539203,
-0.0208793133,
0.0159204137,
0.0360870473,
-0.0150902346,
0.0290867612,
-0.031360019,
-0.0149799967,
0.0324430242,
-0.0051859254,
0.0080933915,
-0.0661650747,
-0.0128352381,
-0.0418128148,
0.0502465889,
0.0080778142,
-0.0483774841,
-0.0188194662,
0.0452693701,
-0.0064591067,
-0.0002240384,
-0.0073071741,
0.0024719255,
0.0458349586,
-0.0032991162,
-0.0515478365,
-0.0256744772,
-0.0227885991,
-0.0379700884,
0.0252439361,
0.0438976698,
0.024601575,
-0.0683123022,
0.0079441378,
-0.0351935849,
0.0024053988,
-0.0092309248,
0.0022829564,
-0.0290219467,
0.0348896012,
0.0327598713,
-0.0506132655,
0.0069078049,
-0.0005687621,
-0.0245352834,
-0.0385070667,
0.0110644689,
0.0110079292,
0.0344463065,
-0.0022288999,
0.0013476755,
-0.0288405735,
0.0152484747,
0.0379750505,
0.0029097958,
0.0058968603,
0.0484189503,
-0.0177239422,
-0.007039431,
0.0551242121,
0.0254113544,
-0.0360768549,
-0.0249830429,
-0.0075129308,
-0.0288185384,
0.0226926412,
-0.0331898779,
0.0690817088,
-0.0069931294,
-0.0178669523,
-0.0214666259,
0.0284795668,
-0.0302638765,
-0.0116416514,
0.0099537848,
-0.0257945769,
-0.0216872543,
0.0129073206,
0.0383370779,
-0.0248896219,
-0.0143047255,
0.0482576303,
-0.0457366556,
-0.0093440711,
0.0375346616,
-0.0071819471,
0.0332292691,
0.042692218,
0.01961454,
-0.0115550067,
-0.0486325249,
0.0693203583,
-0.029422801,
0.017158851,
-0.0168098863,
0.0115902508,
0.0246016216,
-0.0048515578,
0.0230509881,
-0.0697713196,
0.0397064053,
-0.045186203,
-0.0363639556,
-0.0129964277,
-5.585222553e-33,
0.038966421,
-0.0507074408,
-0.0425454043,
0.0941412076,
0.0089657484,
0.0612208508,
0.005637927,
-0.0010687662,
0.0114312684,
0.0365711711,
0.0184783656,
0.0391671732,
-0.0000430247,
0.0242663007,
0.0115688182,
-0.025565628,
0.0126231601,
-0.0172051806,
0.029637143,
0.0237689465,
0.014353768,
0.0482719429,
0.0314659961,
-0.1031346843,
0.0435213074,
-0.0231359005,
0.0204715263,
0.0153029133,
0.0437586233,
0.0220588595,
-0.0296815727,
0.1040358767,
0.0242807455,
-0.0127681885,
0.0140885673,
0.0463652313,
-0.0587481558,
-0.0586560033,
-0.0234277211,
-0.0074689616,
-0.0343308151,
-0.0129304044,
0.0402833894,
0.0130237313,
-0.0034766246,
-0.0458357111,
0.0796330795,
0.0037233389,
0.0417526774,
-0.0394460112,
-0.0409922488,
0.0329304226,
-0.0077737169,
0.0352621563,
-0.0229654834,
0.0723023862,
-0.0070960843,
0.0141502637,
-0.0284417365,
-0.0270120781,
-0.0207559224,
0.0365560502,
-0.00464543,
-0.0705464929,
-0.0221606698,
0.0382387266,
0.0013048635,
0.036262691,
-0.023367269,
0.0011996207,
0.0009270547,
0.0273672938,
0.1091011986,
0.0624120422,
0.0351127721,
-0.0590172485,
-0.073083207,
-0.0105606625,
0.0737721771,
0.0064772726,
0.0259924065,
0.0018996928,
-0.0176306944,
0.0012868929,
0.0404436402,
-0.0139088193,
-0.0120272469,
-0.0076882294,
-0.0252158958,
-0.0128239114,
-0.0498923026,
0.0049021863,
-0.0309103057,
-0.0348564237,
-0.0126633709,
0.0274889879,
0.0083174491,
0.0358107835,
0.009025583,
-0.0191925503,
-0.0339834318,
0.0090253819,
-0.0144298347,
0.0020214394,
0.0622382611,
-0.0178334527,
0.0667082891,
-0.0064824768,
-0.0224008393,
-0.0305364057,
-0.0080801798,
0.049342975,
0.0042147301,
0.0364771932,
-0.0150967399,
0.0199968666,
0.0111318314,
-0.0100606037,
0.06536486,
0.0603887513,
-0.0103484849,
0.012864477,
-0.0197396949,
-0.0369498096,
-0.0054372936,
-0.0498829633,
0.0075687096,
0.0241047088,
0.0172622185,
-0.082187824,
0.0100796605,
-0.0734468102,
2.617e-7,
0.0537757985,
0.072042875,
-0.0414670594,
-0.0729304701,
0.0246801935,
-0.0007450918,
0.0317241736,
0.0156253446,
0.0348928943,
-0.0068879817,
0.0008121819,
0.0121994885,
0.0363354981,
0.0355943441,
-0.0354208685,
-0.075756602,
-0.0472193509,
-0.01526835,
-0.0292713381,
0.0376003645,
0.0739177093,
0.0381260999,
0.0291078947,
-0.0166877396,
-0.0529955663,
-0.0109980283,
-0.0101525337,
-0.0434593558,
0.0230689663,
0.0219402388,
0.0528878495,
-0.0130059458,
0.0044667549,
-0.0017969274,
-0.034082707,
-0.0356154442,
0.0431839712,
0.0426430963,
0.0053722984,
0.007415683,
0.0672452301,
0.0246120859,
0.0065794373,
-0.0071217422,
0.0271130931,
-0.0478731692,
-0.0081034601,
-0.0685380176,
-0.0230238438,
-0.0453707427,
0.0497102998,
-0.0114555312,
-0.0209635217,
0.0301235188,
0.0273546278,
-0.0123163834,
-0.0175264534,
-0.0532891974,
-0.0205621365,
0.0180199333,
-0.0387957469,
0.0248519294,
0.0230452139,
0.0000495418,
0.007540409,
0.0047731693,
0.0275159683,
1.706342893e-34,
-0.0160902981,
0.0242776852,
0.0023044783,
-0.0279467497,
0.0139930611,
0.028938286,
-0.055848442,
0.0049709496,
-0.006509332,
-0.0296849553,
0.0026596771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01044v1 | Large Language Models Are Zero-Shot Text Classifiers | 2023-12-02T06:33:23 | 2023-12-02T06:33:23 | Zhiqiang Wang, Yiran Pang, Yanbin Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrained large language models (LLMs) have become extensively used across
various sub-disciplines of natural language processing (NLP). In NLP, text
classification problems have garnered considerable focus, but still faced with
some limitations related to expensive computational cost, time consumption, and
robust performance to unseen classes. With the proposal of chain of thought
prompting (CoT), LLMs can be implemented using zero-shot learning (ZSL) with
the step by step reasoning prompts, instead of conventional question and answer
formats. The zero-shot LLMs in the text classification problems can alleviate
these limitations by directly utilizing pretrained models to predict both seen
and unseen classes. Our research primarily validates the capability of GPT
models in text classification. We focus on effectively utilizing prompt
strategies to various text classification scenarios. Besides, we compare the
performance of zero shot LLMs with other state of the art text classification
methods, including traditional machine learning methods, deep learning methods,
and ZSL methods. Experimental results demonstrate that the performance of LLMs
underscores their effectiveness as zero-shot text classifiers in three of the
four datasets analyzed. The proficiency is especially advantageous for small
businesses or teams that may not have extensive knowledge in text
classification. | [
0.0389323346,
0.0137464181,
0.0011559514,
0.0207218099,
-0.0550737046,
0.0288962461,
0.0523249879,
0.0164182931,
0.0384887382,
-0.1143760532,
-0.0072433096,
-0.0255534984,
-0.02766704,
0.0186716709,
-0.0245135184,
-0.0327849239,
0.016140271,
-0.0016291554,
0.0289440714,
0.0169667844,
0.0021143933,
0.0357032418,
-0.0115752164,
0.0105515411,
0.0258379448,
-0.0531612858,
-0.0273056757,
-0.0143323597,
-0.0034828023,
-0.0452062041,
0.0188969728,
0.0726180822,
0.028458517,
0.0766502768,
0.0000020974,
-0.0650804862,
-0.0166358519,
-0.0264409762,
-0.0650106445,
-0.0059686038,
0.0141025521,
-0.0071489876,
0.0130204977,
0.0472455956,
-0.0250862408,
-0.041933883,
0.0236957055,
0.0831814185,
0.0549907722,
0.0719694421,
-0.0152676729,
-0.0422104187,
0.0155998738,
-0.0163860209,
0.0266753975,
-0.0364255533,
0.0529104285,
-0.0523617193,
-0.0138250915,
0.0462392867,
0.0215851031,
0.0083204927,
0.0048396043,
0.008794724,
0.0061506871,
0.0483674146,
-0.0213957336,
-0.0119771669,
-0.0297215804,
0.0762428716,
-0.0211955756,
-0.0418629348,
-0.0020746016,
-0.0383139588,
0.0016237128,
-0.0105038444,
-0.0193521176,
0.0270601287,
-0.0003191134,
0.0162875112,
-0.0071202391,
0.0235113669,
0.0136374263,
0.028694639,
-0.020544691,
0.0431669317,
-0.0254647136,
-0.0581019223,
0.0285217948,
0.0204641279,
0.0116527602,
-0.08624731,
-0.0036004179,
0.0517352,
0.0027467252,
0.0126589248,
-0.0283296425,
-0.0181905646,
0.0323413983,
-0.0438598283,
0.01651581,
-0.0010961748,
-0.0009399036,
0.0602622777,
-0.0497218482,
0.0099501051,
0.0084078675,
-0.0028540748,
-0.0148389908,
0.0268005356,
-0.0954658389,
-0.0295969974,
-0.0606616624,
0.0629448891,
-0.0111485897,
-0.0156372748,
-0.0262500998,
0.0201754943,
0.0228671543,
0.0261107255,
-0.0132009406,
0.0071331752,
0.0222896878,
-0.0095463935,
-0.0557106696,
0.0357760005,
-0.0120251281,
0.0171315968,
-0.0174572561,
-0.039581079,
0.0055017867,
0.0071338294,
0.0272687022,
-0.0024443981,
0.0294414349,
0.0158695672,
-0.0256722216,
-0.0562269352,
-0.0675181448,
-0.0194797162,
-0.0121408794,
-0.0551556014,
-0.0288991928,
-0.0415546969,
-0.0226928443,
0.0127227064,
-0.0014359065,
0.0316922739,
0.027368594,
0.0446250141,
-0.0281245708,
0.0879506394,
-0.0047622039,
-0.0088972207,
0.0416588001,
0.005477665,
0.0295981746,
0.0298715271,
-0.0050176419,
0.0281716343,
0.0227348991,
-0.0048354645,
0.0536591895,
0.0143088922,
0.0064176335,
-0.0171847213,
0.0078438576,
0.0326436125,
0.0089318715,
0.0222531967,
-0.0356365293,
0.0122469803,
-0.0050220443,
0.0410000831,
0.0552822091,
0.0498653241,
0.0186379235,
0.0107567757,
0.0387380309,
0.0440706536,
-0.0159865394,
-0.0299808364,
-0.004545487,
-0.0222115181,
-0.0641040429,
-0.0128849391,
0.0005226954,
-0.0266366694,
-0.0590930544,
-0.0480466262,
-0.0288745929,
-0.0108857229,
-0.0002048811,
0.0223929361,
0.0623762831,
-0.0178990085,
-0.0807963535,
0.0031259807,
-0.000882973,
-0.025868481,
-0.0388810746,
-0.0536333919,
0.0547049306,
0.0635816753,
0.0306355972,
-0.0413387828,
0.0081101088,
-0.0616237149,
0.0397681557,
0.0301852114,
0.0540714338,
0.0074206474,
-0.0216480736,
-0.0514945909,
-0.0162338428,
0.0145096621,
0.0209344886,
0.0249684546,
-0.0226838384,
0.0399267711,
0.0296295136,
0.035539899,
-0.033533629,
0.0354898125,
0.0223629307,
-0.0724584162,
0.0436158031,
0.0298068225,
0.0050858818,
0.0320735686,
-0.0132229785,
-0.0134415757,
0.0098770978,
-0.0239879098,
-0.0538690612,
-0.0534851998,
-0.0375657491,
-0.0523790792,
-0.0052182958,
0.0269141756,
0.0001890029,
-0.0037745659,
-0.0352484472,
-0.0384139568,
-0.042463202,
-0.0015421403,
-0.0026727386,
-0.0667142197,
0.0213382412,
-0.0284720417,
0.0040409416,
-0.0661719069,
0.0840748921,
0.0432696044,
0.0336649716,
-0.0054010591,
-0.0257585756,
0.0485767871,
-0.043420054,
-0.026997,
0.0219358131,
-0.0086823124,
0.0216460526,
0.0173512083,
0.0450541154,
-0.0305440947,
0.0027552934,
-0.1013424322,
0.0116454028,
-0.0179875679,
0.0159321614,
-0.0197657086,
-0.0207480714,
-0.0133091286,
-0.0220221411,
-0.0576610528,
0.0141940163,
0.0201547649,
0.011727686,
0.0546264797,
-0.0141787445,
-0.0020839369,
0.0236253869,
0.0097466679,
-0.0172289014,
0.058824718,
0.0298895184,
-0.0479647703,
-0.0260197986,
0.0578433648,
-0.0091804266,
0.0139028486,
0.0232171901,
-0.0069475481,
-0.0121787079,
-0.0082343696,
-0.0027966499,
0.0545582362,
0.0146126216,
0.0121412575,
0.0097856568,
0.0358338505,
-0.0379463769,
0.013470958,
-0.0114944419,
-0.0227476098,
0.0021722885,
-0.0053722984,
0.0140351122,
0.0617902391,
0.0022162113,
-0.0170407854,
-0.0528950281,
0.0281568337,
0.0030913011,
0.0122249965,
-0.0764767602,
0.0035395673,
0.009597864,
0.0428708009,
0.0062652463,
-0.0354105122,
0.0479076542,
-0.0175492261,
-0.0085500535,
-0.058891762,
-0.0355060212,
-0.050194405,
0.0478743464,
0.0040936787,
0.0006936649,
0.0519580022,
-0.0286266804,
-0.0134151746,
-0.0198867042,
0.0000183866,
-0.0172636844,
0.0084531847,
-0.0059280726,
0.0272852369,
-0.0341823101,
-0.0445379429,
-0.066114448,
-0.0671991855,
-0.0481412522,
0.0161047094,
-0.0467365049,
0.0269722696,
-0.0355068408,
0.0209325664,
0.0280431937,
0.0752912462,
-0.0183882229,
-0.0234745219,
-0.0227447003,
0.0478238538,
0.0149511313,
-0.0478200018,
-0.0166962147,
-0.0149302203,
0.0647388101,
0.0349894427,
0.0270677451,
0.0323715024,
-0.0161976162,
-0.0302531365,
0.0097300997,
-0.0654416755,
-0.0471263081,
0.0146379238,
-0.0002028682,
-0.0608294345,
0.0098290071,
0.1339327246,
0.0557989255,
-0.0687221363,
-0.0240252037,
0.0115025192,
-0.001646923,
0.0232904311,
0.0354333743,
-0.1029959768,
-0.0571777262,
-0.0001656024,
-0.0106777828,
-0.0421001948,
-0.0182930287,
-0.0072528929,
-0.1356452852,
0.0237924326,
-0.0255360827,
-0.0129955737,
0.0113586169,
-0.0485457517,
-0.0247122683,
0.0105769327,
-0.0376188084,
-0.0192394797,
-0.0205860119,
-0.0215212535,
0.026117323,
-0.0393684469,
-0.0279696267,
0.0307439417,
-0.0065116989,
0.0031079042,
0.0529578179,
0.0188650545,
-0.0160091352,
-0.0291825552,
0.0390453562,
-0.0693110526,
0.0124527877,
-0.00604884,
0.0536880903,
-0.038124267,
0.0209793951,
0.0082402676,
0.0278376006,
-0.0395238958,
0.0048234337,
0.0468139015,
0.0915345624,
-0.0133845378,
-0.0386178493,
-0.0173734408,
-0.0204910859,
0.0091582527,
0.0872471854,
-0.0001858048,
-0.0706671551,
-0.0670592189,
-0.0278884061,
-0.0115892747,
-0.0089630652,
-0.0142366244,
0.0082475711,
-0.0087531898,
-0.0194443539,
-0.0338195078,
-0.040548034,
0.0396553129,
0.0334070548,
0.0032420026,
0.019706307,
-0.0179996509,
0.0385457687,
-0.0380545035,
-0.0032587547,
-0.039206937,
0.0285212677,
-0.07174173,
0.0105179306,
0.029844841,
-0.0453217328,
-0.0279245172,
-0.032454554,
-0.0649345666,
-0.0269732215,
-0.0586102381,
0.0194713604,
0.0234948061,
0.0051425509,
-0.0049679442,
-0.0720136017,
0.0971497744,
0.0650100335,
-0.009659186,
-0.0136292987,
0.0089071579,
0.0633759722,
-0.0073651555,
0.0175230298,
-0.0176652763,
0.0477180146,
0.0178393759,
-0.0263868161,
-0.0418765657,
-0.0087093133,
0.003911871,
0.0034883027,
0.0494566299,
0.0329966731,
-0.022953704,
-0.0257405788,
0.0293100961,
-0.004037885,
-0.0299899429,
-0.0195106361,
0.0079213586,
0.0431110151,
-0.0157782715,
-0.0217978656,
-0.0199330691,
-0.0452387333,
0.034913253,
-0.0332593508,
0.0012272438,
0.0453893505,
0.0330668017,
0.0138711864,
-0.0154532976,
-0.0324789807,
0.002344283,
0.0310633034,
0.012982266,
0.003253235,
0.0885120183,
0.0234794673,
0.0132674146,
-0.0353677571,
0.0089583267,
-0.0519515723,
-0.0314226858,
0.0044051898,
0.0600376874,
0.040186204,
-0.0122624217,
-0.0265505854,
-0.0234204754,
-0.0140405241,
-0.0084792133,
0.0420342088,
0.0275243893,
-0.0482688844,
0.0305152722,
0.0240286477,
-0.0385989659,
0.0325535163,
0.0578727461,
0.0269916244,
0.0031075159,
0.0349715091,
-0.040690016,
-0.0597860105,
0.0409589894,
0.0341061167,
0.0398662612,
0.0163088664,
0.0496643707,
-0.0494451895,
-0.0273603611,
0.0310002603,
-0.0411244966,
0.0214679055,
-0.0300990958,
0.0278595872,
0.0655284151,
0.0013534579,
-0.0043003638,
-0.0491586998,
0.0285089836,
-0.0050974214,
-0.0256646927,
-0.0441537611,
-6.179426865e-33,
0.0258511771,
-0.0404534526,
0.021114761,
0.0148884766,
0.0005923453,
0.0178462099,
0.0139621729,
-0.0099439546,
-0.0037892794,
0.0197794475,
-0.0249112509,
-0.0080352714,
0.0111781051,
0.0419845693,
0.0041518752,
-0.0365209617,
0.0435944758,
-0.0237843171,
-0.0183805116,
0.0277932975,
0.0261272825,
0.0345108211,
0.0350253284,
-0.0270976964,
0.0234698839,
-0.0300449934,
-0.0088135321,
0.0384729281,
0.0009871172,
0.0338274762,
-0.0411637276,
0.0449310504,
0.0573173128,
-0.0428009033,
0.0433885045,
0.0866520181,
-0.0411739945,
-0.0154676028,
-0.0220056735,
-0.0063703372,
-0.0176500231,
-0.0251652207,
0.003725078,
-0.0034079242,
0.0029289341,
-0.0007870573,
0.0571138822,
-0.0184246115,
-0.0113330968,
-0.0159561392,
-0.0364966281,
0.019170681,
-0.0091981785,
-0.0297098048,
0.0348826535,
0.0855422169,
-0.0174153391,
0.0398063101,
-0.0621176884,
0.0002216966,
0.0521312989,
-0.0053869411,
0.0230131764,
0.0143070901,
-0.0297682844,
0.0412057377,
0.0220460966,
0.0081732888,
-0.0612378195,
-0.0004594808,
0.011863376,
-0.0041232379,
0.0320961624,
0.0349839628,
0.0550258085,
0.0203172378,
-0.0715850666,
-0.0004253893,
0.0266473182,
-0.0048825401,
0.0548659079,
-0.0116537949,
-0.0569046102,
-0.0374117903,
-0.0248997863,
-0.0553220324,
-0.0482770316,
0.0020927927,
0.0245101694,
0.0368375853,
-0.0049257064,
0.0191060379,
0.0451757833,
-0.0219678301,
-0.0414990187,
0.0260711182,
-0.0037517638,
0.0280496478,
0.0059765498,
0.0091278795,
-0.0936800241,
-0.0069686426,
-0.0014452169,
0.0261316393,
0.0059798826,
0.0097446218,
0.0671997219,
-0.0093666613,
-0.080812335,
-0.017437024,
-0.009428747,
0.0254667625,
-0.0202565938,
0.0726349652,
0.0039857472,
0.0215887278,
0.0121127944,
0.0765087306,
0.008883127,
-0.0399258323,
-0.0060034599,
0.0025558337,
-0.0153863234,
-0.0089148581,
-0.0169013757,
-0.0048123621,
0.0071388939,
0.0315418206,
0.030484803,
-0.0719315931,
0.0100001683,
-0.0097993538,
2.724e-7,
0.0123070134,
0.0606082752,
-0.0083736842,
-0.0002490394,
0.0273454413,
0.0832657665,
0.0264063962,
0.0313822292,
0.0081179235,
0.0026491666,
0.0212978087,
0.0066891038,
0.0279004015,
-0.0042736479,
-0.0990477577,
-0.0372606292,
-0.0489163361,
0.0207051858,
-0.095073089,
0.0040883506,
0.0870616212,
0.0721750408,
0.0259957071,
-0.0248429552,
0.0152813019,
-0.0210693311,
0.0529174358,
0.0004900867,
0.0273385607,
0.0103103938,
0.0341833718,
0.0177533068,
-0.0049964436,
0.0630204454,
-0.0087836562,
0.0331875011,
-0.0028043592,
0.0468251891,
-0.0142827621,
0.0103548672,
0.0227579493,
0.0119695533,
-0.0015525452,
-0.0503007248,
0.1100448444,
-0.077830106,
-0.0288853254,
0.014740834,
-0.0236431658,
-0.0546847098,
0.0470980518,
0.0100284107,
-0.0099066738,
0.0206873883,
0.007912525,
-0.0355594717,
-0.0226093624,
-0.0753501952,
0.0080796191,
-0.0147810187,
-0.0122295683,
0.0002676044,
-0.023797784,
0.0031999797,
0.0394993015,
-0.0722211227,
0.0262700096,
2.652003877e-34,
0.012685488,
-0.0161107425,
-0.0082749501,
0.0031486196,
0.0032922684,
0.0156134292,
-0.0019831611,
-0.0074895332,
0.0387139358,
-0.0937063023,
0.016577933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01040v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01040v3 | From Beginner to Expert: Modeling Medical Knowledge into General LLMs | 2023-12-02T05:54:06 | 2024-01-07T08:52:24 | Qiang Li, Xiaoyan Yang, Haowen Wang, Qin Wang, Lei Liu, Junjie Wang, Yang Zhang, Mingyuan Chu, Sen Hu, Yicheng Chen, Yue Shen, Cong Fan, Wangshu Zhang, Teng Xu, Jinjie Gu, Jing Zheng, Guannan Zhang Ant Group | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, large language model (LLM) based artificial intelligence (AI)
systems have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in natural language
understanding and generation. However, these models face a significant
challenge when it comes to sensitive applications, such as reasoning over
medical knowledge and answering medical questions in a physician-like manner.
Prior studies attempted to overcome this challenge by increasing the model size
(>100B) to learn more general medical knowledge, while there is still room for
improvement in LLMs with smaller-scale model sizes (<100B). In this work, we
start from a pre-trained general LLM model (AntGLM-10B) and fine-tune it from a
medical beginner towards a medical expert (called AntGLM-Med-10B), which
leverages a 3-stage optimization procedure, i.e., general medical knowledge
injection, medical domain instruction tuning, and specific medical task
adaptation. Our contributions are threefold: (1) We specifically investigate
how to adapt a pre-trained general LLM in medical domain, especially for a
specific medical task. (2) We collect and construct large-scale medical
datasets for each stage of the optimization process. These datasets encompass
various data types and tasks, such as question-answering, medical reasoning,
multi-choice questions, and medical conversations. (3) Specifically for
multi-choice questions in the medical domain, we propose a novel
Verification-of-Choice approach for prompting engineering, which significantly
enhances the reasoning ability of LLMs. Remarkably, by combining the above
approaches, our AntGLM-Med-10B model can outperform the most of LLMs on
PubMedQA, including both general and medical LLMs, even when these LLMs have
larger model size. | [
0.0667024627,
0.0330723599,
0.0148557788,
0.0005530691,
-0.0340588354,
0.0338259228,
0.0064706514,
0.0159699395,
0.0439422242,
-0.0194064546,
-0.0137905562,
-0.0518809147,
-0.0299244784,
0.0322977975,
0.0270743445,
-0.0216381699,
0.0421130881,
-0.0026341144,
0.0608820394,
-0.0057670693,
-0.0262950715,
0.0073694605,
-0.0478863232,
0.0260093566,
0.0178321172,
-0.0123489369,
0.0040057502,
-0.0128492741,
0.0218132827,
-0.0740615651,
0.0057079084,
0.0388403125,
0.0159296747,
-0.0398701802,
0.0000020959,
-0.0910733193,
0.0030121389,
0.0010184359,
-0.0782841071,
-0.0614394657,
0.0128008658,
-0.0220366307,
0.0218206514,
0.0390164666,
-0.0532124303,
0.006028512,
-0.0013160694,
0.0497164167,
0.0549753942,
0.0877446309,
-0.0023301414,
0.0006743961,
0.0154418983,
-0.0211406928,
0.0275800433,
-0.0452349111,
0.0486629196,
0.0099992119,
0.0520528331,
0.0307245441,
0.0163172353,
0.0221056081,
0.0039361711,
0.0327558704,
0.0247991811,
0.0353323855,
-0.000317262,
-0.011044356,
-0.023971172,
0.0915449709,
0.003517404,
0.004391972,
0.0236543231,
0.0049785413,
0.0119339675,
0.0016264332,
-0.0282582939,
0.0240735784,
-0.0031355997,
-0.0172813945,
0.0340034217,
-0.0161257889,
0.0316073187,
0.0337777324,
-0.0183258727,
0.0266282447,
0.0127244955,
-0.0306228846,
0.0407497175,
-0.0157277361,
-0.0233092587,
-0.0630512312,
0.0350457393,
0.0886236504,
-0.0921221823,
0.0178498309,
-0.0190050416,
0.0023337463,
0.0773929805,
-0.0152818002,
0.0190802645,
0.0189681947,
-0.0073860628,
0.0532153733,
0.0088696619,
0.0130886659,
-0.0351636708,
0.0339997858,
-0.0678094253,
0.0022897413,
-0.034336552,
-0.0107300514,
-0.0115424646,
0.0230356622,
-0.0344377533,
0.008198061,
-0.0624933988,
0.015080628,
0.0095590148,
0.0316205136,
0.0104400218,
0.0434804484,
-0.0272609852,
-0.0298830476,
-0.0479486361,
0.0207627993,
-0.0366260782,
0.0312209539,
0.0211552139,
-0.0330435447,
-0.0109266974,
0.0089154337,
0.0293807331,
-0.0077159177,
0.0408532545,
0.0681243017,
-0.0102666039,
-0.0173349008,
-0.0196524952,
-0.0529557206,
-0.02500722,
-0.058856409,
0.0258919783,
-0.0513225943,
0.042147018,
0.0180896781,
-0.0042629065,
-0.0309575852,
0.0189488139,
0.0338658132,
-0.0472426489,
0.0722093135,
-0.0182854645,
0.0153205991,
0.0398669131,
0.0516289994,
-0.0249163322,
0.0159429591,
0.0195050482,
-0.0283407643,
0.0038377151,
-0.0183288362,
0.0101629188,
-0.00771276,
0.0226332061,
-0.0217403844,
0.0264454484,
0.0337287448,
-0.0033126771,
0.0878921598,
-0.0423432849,
0.0730723962,
-0.0128669972,
-0.0102595314,
0.0285837818,
0.0515195876,
-0.0052155294,
-0.0137675498,
0.0218273252,
-0.0075347526,
0.0078776823,
-0.0138697214,
-0.0195797496,
0.0120325927,
-0.0099119144,
0.0004003685,
-0.0181077234,
0.009689426,
-0.0396356583,
-0.0384833924,
-0.0196949281,
-0.0103968931,
-0.0145330578,
0.0135664418,
0.0230885819,
-0.0030976878,
-0.0286830161,
0.0544911064,
0.0397725441,
-0.0166900028,
-0.0110035567,
-0.0674906075,
0.0508838519,
0.035967283,
0.0656624287,
-0.0616197661,
-0.0670089349,
-0.0279978551,
0.0245251954,
0.0272838343,
0.0475797243,
-0.0409687795,
0.0179759953,
-0.0665136948,
-0.0039578849,
0.012667872,
0.006581672,
-0.020545179,
0.0124952868,
0.0155310472,
-0.0141413044,
-0.0175766218,
0.0029021068,
0.0421407185,
-0.0800259933,
-0.0411101282,
0.0183240417,
-0.0040955041,
0.047227066,
0.009929277,
-0.0001865783,
0.0371227972,
0.0210918933,
-0.0385786854,
-0.0293944329,
-0.019326441,
-0.0581162944,
-0.0590082258,
0.0296729449,
-0.0153110595,
-0.0295594539,
-0.0179413464,
-0.0608653426,
-0.0382760018,
-0.0497366153,
-0.0127480803,
0.0047711884,
-0.0134014916,
0.0109891361,
0.0345292427,
-0.0281157121,
-0.0631125867,
0.0593547262,
-0.0113320295,
-0.0089042978,
0.0440239497,
0.0013132832,
-0.0154686552,
-0.0269991308,
-0.0032433979,
-0.0055117006,
-0.0143728117,
0.0074604605,
0.0023839567,
0.0451310016,
-0.0675574988,
-0.0469828695,
-0.0996611416,
0.023880614,
0.0136607932,
0.0054503176,
0.0122905644,
0.0079638856,
-0.0013339549,
-0.023650717,
-0.086974889,
-0.0058566285,
0.0354559235,
-0.0061770175,
0.0467339829,
0.0339138471,
0.0240879897,
-0.005551029,
0.0203468613,
-0.0400402397,
0.0108339321,
-0.0022056,
0.0281639379,
-0.0293474961,
0.0168619845,
-0.0500815883,
-0.0103058228,
0.0049754488,
-0.0057235272,
0.0235855337,
-0.0151709886,
0.0198218413,
0.0741820112,
0.0129340943,
-0.0153884478,
0.0362938978,
0.0153942294,
-0.0405012295,
0.0461838134,
-0.0216180235,
-0.0238986723,
0.0078833373,
-0.0173897799,
0.0222227033,
0.0646339655,
0.0003997735,
-0.0125808045,
-0.0293835662,
0.0309814569,
-0.0018347804,
0.0006156814,
-0.0470505916,
0.014853511,
-0.0232750718,
0.060876213,
-0.0047379956,
-0.0179664977,
0.0971020907,
0.0033936175,
0.0378995016,
-0.0991157517,
-0.0090116374,
-0.0337788537,
0.013976777,
-0.0241340697,
0.0258965585,
0.0403956585,
0.0134215634,
-0.0584446453,
0.0189715866,
-0.0306097213,
-0.075368762,
0.0573314689,
-0.0569739565,
0.004128207,
0.0124349687,
-0.0753274634,
-0.0787717551,
-0.0321316347,
-0.0416926369,
-0.0001693566,
-0.0185726304,
0.0125760892,
-0.0267724823,
-0.0284907799,
-0.0064567425,
0.0423247442,
0.0253312215,
-0.0147682671,
-0.0256489087,
0.044692263,
0.0582032427,
0.0550427772,
0.0038308338,
-0.0036439265,
0.0373287983,
0.0485939719,
0.0143555878,
0.0199908633,
-0.0041117356,
0.0174094662,
0.0083721476,
-0.0315328874,
0.0244792756,
0.0445054322,
0.0437230095,
-0.0675079674,
-0.006480501,
0.1254653931,
0.0411897525,
-0.0346663669,
0.0118147964,
-0.016191436,
0.0011185615,
-0.0070372536,
0.0445294231,
-0.0836047605,
-0.0513999797,
-0.0066285832,
0.0138423694,
-0.0311035719,
-0.0119702229,
0.0001213962,
-0.0817979872,
0.0117221586,
-0.0015472347,
-0.0119859148,
-0.0132331271,
-0.0299184155,
-0.0123128584,
-0.0012606834,
-0.0006411154,
0.0064835479,
0.0067592096,
-0.009735317,
0.0134938387,
-0.0203838479,
-0.0952435359,
0.0478831865,
-0.0103283646,
0.0737954453,
0.0464756601,
0.0433683656,
-0.0094847661,
-0.0188792776,
0.0089957779,
0.0119910697,
0.0150989089,
-0.0254893526,
0.0614990667,
0.0216332097,
-0.0003348568,
-0.0534340218,
0.0712350979,
-0.0530026518,
-0.0386176519,
0.0379701369,
0.0862422585,
-0.0335781984,
-0.0235221572,
-0.032568831,
0.0401659682,
0.011603565,
0.0657327175,
-0.0041548382,
-0.0159433521,
-0.011792073,
0.0010257211,
0.0240371749,
-0.0130871069,
-0.0188084394,
0.034565594,
-0.0025828818,
0.0283701234,
-0.0844656006,
0.0025019741,
0.0440196656,
0.0082489122,
0.0246516038,
0.0152038382,
0.0381509066,
-0.0039271913,
-0.0418818928,
0.0444589555,
-0.021667378,
-0.0106991595,
-0.0590747185,
-0.0339857303,
0.0676972941,
-0.031614881,
-0.0116610602,
-0.0037667742,
-0.0153345717,
-0.0249874741,
-0.0319006667,
0.0746423677,
0.019851692,
0.026577035,
-0.0299475789,
-0.0304483399,
0.0589555539,
0.0022223871,
-0.0396991037,
-0.0139882583,
0.0066935797,
0.0061419094,
-0.0210921168,
0.0235603116,
-0.0115588224,
0.0147831794,
0.0233936142,
0.0420913696,
-0.0391940959,
-0.0372681431,
0.04113416,
0.0305988397,
0.0010444283,
-0.0004087109,
0.0128479414,
-0.0247464702,
0.0366356261,
-0.0103293145,
-0.0075675463,
-0.013250391,
-0.0173443034,
0.023814043,
-0.0353809334,
0.0005868032,
-0.0655323863,
-0.0577932447,
0.0014017668,
-0.0317258574,
0.0254968107,
0.014769733,
0.0102674849,
0.0351966396,
-0.0207017846,
-0.0180066153,
0.018147625,
-0.0062293829,
0.0372691751,
-0.0095512876,
0.102283515,
0.0096398173,
0.0065455632,
0.0091030961,
0.0342785344,
-0.050634712,
-0.0596807152,
0.0164942089,
0.0293608289,
0.0221999139,
0.0076466985,
-0.0054747378,
-0.0152778914,
-0.007834428,
-0.0301810671,
0.0350770764,
-0.0352552906,
0.0003850572,
0.0570491552,
0.0342534781,
0.0022666475,
-0.0052483515,
0.0789477453,
-0.0009753394,
0.0443164594,
0.0118559804,
-0.0194938928,
-0.068254374,
-0.025073044,
0.0102010695,
0.0161826536,
-0.0526130237,
0.0526178367,
-0.06200587,
-0.0449887812,
-0.0023597141,
-0.0140840337,
-0.0029155964,
-0.0261383597,
0.0708690286,
0.0296490807,
-0.0109704528,
-0.0353064649,
-0.0162895396,
0.0569714084,
-0.0503375046,
-0.0300177597,
0.0199246872,
-6.228897545e-33,
0.0121636642,
-0.0207232013,
0.0583826341,
-0.0545948073,
0.0018530797,
0.0200532563,
-0.0356064215,
-0.0120671093,
-0.0345046222,
0.0240648836,
-0.0245991778,
-0.0022413768,
-0.0033945427,
0.0506384708,
-0.0006325257,
-0.0517162196,
0.0274014343,
0.0021865496,
-0.0290327314,
0.0366127864,
-0.0110480869,
0.0415377617,
-0.0041323979,
-0.0441867374,
0.0000262336,
-0.0040059281,
0.0215118676,
0.0345663317,
-0.0632521957,
0.0597881712,
-0.0251842979,
0.0164943207,
0.0562720224,
-0.0243827179,
0.0141033251,
0.0513081737,
-0.0639383048,
-0.0391727798,
-0.0021757788,
-0.0338286236,
-0.0725461617,
-0.0639867187,
0.0160699692,
-0.0146163534,
0.0009352153,
-0.006350426,
-0.0008305464,
-0.0305833574,
-0.0112375719,
-0.0513060018,
-0.0295437202,
0.0212720577,
-0.0073039779,
-0.0408111848,
-0.0645291507,
0.039996326,
-0.0514719151,
0.0479880944,
0.0069525065,
0.0139814857,
0.0389120057,
0.007214393,
0.0095129255,
-0.0264226776,
-0.0343316942,
0.0420470871,
-0.0077051595,
-0.0137716867,
-0.0388475955,
0.0141369142,
-0.0533371307,
0.0572030954,
0.0390904658,
0.0297343172,
0.021931259,
0.0022249441,
-0.1262306869,
0.0332758985,
-0.0376131572,
0.0540754236,
0.0257657748,
-0.0371085219,
-0.0370601416,
-0.0047182068,
-0.0418794043,
0.0323550366,
-0.0343340896,
-0.0206820387,
0.0481359437,
-0.0020850545,
-0.0290655233,
-0.0278721787,
-0.0063483296,
-0.0236335266,
0.0335886888,
-0.0248952433,
0.0299154241,
-0.01262921,
-0.0331298746,
0.0274841767,
-0.0529190786,
-0.0271586943,
0.0314970724,
-0.0446795039,
0.0344220363,
0.03842365,
0.026097307,
-0.0281702634,
-0.0484397411,
-0.0115116257,
-0.0125673311,
0.0070082676,
0.0026548188,
0.0437597819,
0.012454927,
0.0345649756,
-0.0047091469,
0.0493061505,
-0.006424455,
-0.0121210478,
-0.0559121668,
-0.0517767183,
-0.0087898904,
0.0106299724,
-0.053452678,
0.0183787048,
-0.0206911974,
0.0321970768,
0.003965125,
-0.0432388075,
-0.0173176154,
-0.0072478969,
2.889e-7,
0.0681924596,
0.0631655082,
-0.0162932016,
0.0142249586,
0.0138166966,
0.0303230137,
-0.0122227436,
0.0126314741,
0.0159975253,
-0.0333052352,
0.0208051931,
0.0271991268,
0.0197693557,
0.0065596872,
-0.0935098976,
-0.0255102143,
-0.0379795954,
-0.0173368119,
-0.0401553214,
-0.0384612046,
0.0730849057,
0.078851603,
-0.0377069227,
-0.040295504,
0.0052298633,
-0.0148862852,
0.0448385775,
-0.0250125453,
-0.0227648132,
0.0447239019,
0.0247995332,
-0.0006382593,
0.0242326688,
0.0722930506,
-0.0271890182,
-0.032212384,
-0.0069850637,
0.1232311428,
-0.0279319398,
-0.0033424553,
0.0251166262,
0.0189462062,
0.0289554819,
-0.0384869389,
0.0744659752,
-0.0711278543,
-0.0621178448,
-0.0344109498,
0.0057999352,
-0.0262136646,
0.0520947576,
-0.0274304841,
-0.0196099039,
-0.0035503164,
0.0314409919,
0.0258106198,
-0.0063686403,
-0.065521732,
-0.0164046101,
0.0417113863,
-0.0308876317,
-0.0574252196,
0.0123496447,
-0.0193079598,
0.0238520503,
-0.0908825845,
-0.0016291997,
2.559479844e-34,
0.0098817488,
0.0047633336,
0.0185674783,
0.0506706797,
0.0340167508,
0.0023347905,
-0.0021069001,
0.0104909381,
0.0511215962,
-0.0790817067,
-0.0029535512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01037v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01037v3 | Eliciting Latent Knowledge from Quirky Language Models | 2023-12-02T05:47:22 | 2024-04-03T21:44:48 | Alex Mallen, Madeline Brumley, Julia Kharchenko, Nora Belrose | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Eliciting Latent Knowledge (ELK) aims to find patterns in a capable neural
network's activations that robustly track the true state of the world,
especially in hard-to-verify cases where the model's output is untrusted. To
further ELK research, we introduce 12 datasets and a corresponding suite of
"quirky" language models (LMs) that are finetuned to make systematic errors
when answering questions if and only if the keyword "Bob" is present in the
prompt. We find that, especially in middle layers, linear probes usually report
an LM's knowledge independently of what the LM outputs, enabling us to elicit
the correct answer despite the model's untruthful output. The best probing
method (logistic regression on contrast pairs) recovers 89% of the gap in AUROC
between truthful and untruthful contexts, and 75% for questions harder than
those used to train the probe. We also find that a mechanistic anomaly
detection approach can flag untruthful behavior with 0.95 AUROC. Our results
show promise for eliciting reliable knowledge from capable but untrusted
models, and facilitates future research empirically investigating ELK methods. | [
0.0858504474,
0.089998953,
-0.0307991263,
0.053535644,
-0.0281641018,
0.0140896095,
-0.0036237813,
0.0198566187,
0.0045689344,
-0.0311722513,
0.0024461038,
-0.0368710384,
-0.0170476511,
0.0772249475,
0.0338660814,
0.0077583608,
0.0553541742,
-0.0189172141,
0.0662358254,
-0.0213559214,
-0.0138325291,
0.0046002585,
-0.012807766,
0.0517640486,
-0.0227056388,
-0.0103759179,
-0.0019827653,
-0.0013303005,
0.0129292104,
0.0349610448,
0.0595301874,
0.0422303453,
-0.0034346217,
0.0549539402,
0.0000019132,
-0.0308627933,
-0.0140362913,
-0.0168011244,
-0.0380659029,
0.0015759446,
0.0017514855,
0.0024742545,
0.0103482418,
0.0331408717,
-0.0589725487,
-0.0378155001,
0.0425588451,
0.0569009818,
0.036262881,
0.0621684268,
0.0169767905,
0.0395819694,
0.0312522054,
-0.0127089331,
0.0280880202,
-0.0229432825,
0.0285947211,
-0.0575262383,
-0.0403456241,
0.0396405458,
-0.0038520729,
0.0197031777,
0.0510504618,
-0.0078789257,
-0.0357278958,
0.0478530787,
-0.0192264784,
-0.0279440042,
-0.0102810627,
0.0685358644,
-0.0286873765,
-0.0237987302,
-0.0115959616,
-0.0112183057,
0.0127722807,
0.0356683731,
-0.0088087814,
0.0131224431,
0.0012348351,
-0.002394052,
0.0215184856,
0.0131401885,
0.036942862,
0.0213138014,
0.0019531077,
0.0597631335,
0.0005275768,
-0.0326564386,
-0.0204905104,
0.0064424593,
-0.0042972821,
-0.056919571,
-0.0081053339,
0.0265811775,
-0.013862106,
0.024697369,
-0.0091849463,
0.0095529249,
0.0415109955,
0.0198333785,
0.0010080606,
0.0094290636,
-0.0716391429,
0.0596786104,
-0.0202568006,
0.0654526502,
-0.0218098126,
0.0148738297,
0.0078326948,
-0.0249074213,
0.0134532889,
-0.029536875,
-0.0064597973,
0.0173539259,
-0.0038381722,
-0.0009669192,
-0.0146884536,
-0.0053925393,
-0.0252596233,
0.0436002761,
-0.0282154288,
0.0668850839,
-0.007589655,
-0.0185498409,
-0.0442111604,
-0.000290413,
-0.0252674855,
0.037781287,
0.0172558613,
-0.0618591793,
-0.0336254947,
0.0198422354,
-0.0132270297,
-0.0141800288,
0.0173541196,
0.0391100496,
0.0071532107,
-0.0339139178,
-0.0461107492,
-0.0432331637,
-0.0380406342,
-0.0589863062,
0.0054937573,
-0.0466040522,
0.0289920233,
-0.0023031707,
-0.0195318386,
-0.0247510672,
0.0126214195,
-0.0091898572,
-0.0489377417,
0.0750620738,
-0.0010678724,
-0.0140358014,
0.0030758742,
0.0263329856,
-0.0125389155,
0.0327150933,
-0.0007405412,
0.0377861224,
0.0570288561,
0.0231924839,
0.0672610477,
-0.0082493434,
0.0548601635,
-0.0081776781,
0.0277067367,
0.02797563,
-0.0294290632,
-0.0116249118,
0.0054501258,
0.0771113932,
-0.0158207249,
-0.0722095743,
0.0965430364,
0.0318501964,
-0.013565124,
-0.0073843934,
0.0381950848,
-0.0026081377,
0.0070423712,
0.0264441073,
-0.0647925064,
0.0111695696,
-0.0720114261,
-0.0300676934,
0.0232823845,
0.0115196165,
-0.0205650032,
-0.0565377846,
-0.0217094366,
-0.0028583491,
0.01771277,
0.0260473676,
0.0392701849,
-0.0015670806,
-0.0204896685,
-0.0010707611,
0.0309859272,
-0.0233456753,
0.0042787283,
-0.071600385,
0.0478666276,
0.0000495991,
0.0422398448,
-0.006258463,
0.0133756651,
-0.0521027409,
-0.0048091533,
0.0308481846,
0.0435292721,
-0.0114625311,
0.0308079552,
-0.0309616216,
-0.0138038369,
-0.0174801499,
0.0190837178,
-0.0071186572,
0.0439404547,
0.0198746808,
-0.0077687413,
-0.0688453466,
0.0070033148,
0.0426552854,
-0.031208856,
-0.0363697633,
0.0173204858,
0.0172225591,
0.0120740086,
-0.012988328,
-0.0064319712,
0.0225017499,
0.0337884165,
-0.0181433354,
-0.0456856936,
-0.008406884,
-0.0212503895,
-0.0246272273,
-0.0152516551,
-0.02181351,
-0.0050004451,
0.0414539948,
-0.0080592586,
-0.0257336609,
0.0055316039,
-0.0368558951,
0.0460595563,
-0.0622115843,
-0.016701974,
-0.0135815702,
0.0351163931,
-0.0186543148,
0.0680804402,
-0.0491082706,
0.035242971,
-0.0169527326,
-0.0062792851,
-0.012461191,
0.0114855571,
-0.0507320575,
-0.0048211622,
0.0068426877,
0.0210210718,
0.0223168321,
-0.0028135832,
-0.0322881676,
-0.0192706361,
-0.0178144742,
-0.0200604871,
-0.0376492143,
-0.0146093816,
0.0138215981,
-0.0286660977,
0.0067211562,
-0.0255024433,
-0.0514466055,
0.037388768,
0.0164179821,
0.0258470122,
0.0239303056,
0.0037542125,
0.0075755599,
-0.0255983174,
-0.0031113413,
-0.0229954198,
0.0574439988,
-0.0007339562,
0.034488678,
-0.0737269297,
0.0219987035,
-0.0294336192,
0.0421414487,
-0.0259910394,
-0.0295018125,
0.0294565279,
0.0016118075,
-0.034821257,
0.0625163317,
0.0356951468,
0.0356991552,
0.0255636983,
0.0125874123,
-0.0444083251,
0.0013303027,
-0.0388169102,
-0.0023606461,
-0.0069954507,
-0.0252622329,
0.0162749887,
0.0672877282,
0.0388462357,
-0.0329446346,
-0.0540031195,
0.0144529371,
0.0057308045,
-0.072435528,
-0.0003265278,
-0.0269979686,
0.0014588863,
0.0572165735,
-0.0211944673,
-0.0514154062,
0.136369735,
-0.0120168254,
-0.0112835029,
-0.0055769696,
-0.026029313,
0.0101603549,
0.0483064279,
0.0196424872,
0.0092024263,
0.0233904943,
-0.0222084373,
-0.0557785816,
-0.0284881908,
0.0050342088,
-0.0530391932,
0.013928554,
-0.0313156843,
-0.0150233237,
0.0316444449,
-0.05289381,
-0.1087595001,
-0.0554549471,
0.0076541668,
0.0113555416,
-0.0126256123,
-0.0409990624,
-0.0358122177,
-0.01415426,
0.0023935821,
0.0209194459,
-0.0458327979,
-0.0076537095,
-0.0214993935,
0.0448614731,
0.0661398023,
0.0085386895,
0.0834689513,
-0.0403519236,
0.0152715053,
0.0738044381,
-0.019669313,
0.0238436274,
-0.0125459833,
0.0025262188,
0.0373764932,
0.0308955926,
-0.0010487752,
0.0304576363,
0.0283513181,
-0.0514679253,
-0.0444276147,
0.0706806779,
0.021583762,
-0.050803721,
-0.004684241,
-0.0124560837,
0.0223867781,
0.0090178465,
0.0242287368,
-0.0859458447,
-0.0076524471,
-0.0054737329,
0.0397770517,
-0.0399660207,
-0.0501314178,
0.0018163378,
-0.1176311672,
0.0275459494,
-0.0257920269,
-0.0286386479,
-0.0445576347,
-0.0379308164,
0.0151669933,
0.0073092114,
0.0755423829,
0.0102514476,
0.0357081369,
-0.0098256385,
0.0143607873,
-0.0022153046,
-0.0662311316,
0.0380149782,
-0.0366138183,
0.0849939659,
0.0455447473,
0.0049225562,
-0.0237627272,
-0.0421300717,
-0.0261548366,
-0.0013637651,
-0.0051278085,
0.0053355941,
0.0405804403,
-0.0351700298,
-0.0381991304,
-0.0059944056,
0.0568926781,
-0.0278556477,
0.0056043882,
-0.0103423223,
0.0532950759,
-0.0293040797,
-0.0392677933,
-0.0229298379,
0.0021711169,
0.043478325,
0.045402132,
0.0327568315,
-0.0516653582,
-0.0279317424,
-0.0222667921,
0.0048765251,
0.0178716239,
-0.02737475,
0.0562165193,
0.0789686367,
0.0114715928,
-0.0582179278,
-0.0582103841,
0.0217545927,
0.0188879706,
0.0002262408,
-0.0115503743,
-0.0002499878,
-0.0071939677,
-0.054729227,
0.0187538806,
-0.0059767887,
0.0183707997,
-0.0260709357,
0.022909211,
0.028392721,
-0.0435622334,
-0.014864753,
-0.0012086496,
-0.0624245666,
-0.0814619064,
0.0512719564,
0.0567653589,
0.0251046177,
0.0536276326,
-0.0529932119,
-0.0751429126,
0.0260667056,
0.0350974165,
-0.0503342822,
0.0043876953,
0.0121216299,
-0.0014497616,
-0.0028924386,
0.0460023209,
-0.0227646623,
0.0024847714,
0.0600654744,
0.0427736752,
-0.0685081258,
-0.0603859834,
0.0383134708,
-0.0223837066,
0.0799608231,
0.0161975604,
-0.0190611705,
-0.0480709001,
0.0149337705,
0.0323219411,
-0.0055067022,
-0.0264993832,
0.0179992933,
0.016442949,
-0.0013925262,
-0.0040137237,
-0.0079142544,
-0.0309509933,
0.0636958852,
-0.0363223404,
-0.0322170593,
0.0098515972,
0.0304857381,
0.0151679972,
-0.0098888027,
-0.0215767529,
0.062353231,
0.0010052208,
0.0579457842,
0.0188505333,
0.0467610657,
0.0213262606,
-0.0210829973,
-0.0176847149,
-0.0049344897,
-0.0807679147,
-0.029222874,
-0.0189912748,
0.0150799667,
0.0178460535,
0.0001870119,
-0.0103800809,
-0.0299357641,
-0.0089808777,
0.0022374731,
-0.0038798184,
0.0259441957,
-0.0036685735,
0.0734411553,
0.0373804644,
-0.0174720585,
0.0285740253,
0.0397163965,
0.0260418188,
0.0403062515,
-0.0055374797,
0.0011674287,
-0.0248157717,
0.0257885586,
0.0727282688,
0.022765087,
-0.0405010357,
0.0393263586,
-0.0562151447,
-0.0883542001,
-0.0215145331,
0.0322070159,
0.007916946,
0.0012975422,
-0.0065129856,
0.0836113244,
0.0299479961,
0.0010447244,
-0.0596187152,
-0.0014463229,
0.0145852165,
0.0054799081,
-0.0280536264,
-7.003342611e-33,
0.0233180635,
-0.0717241168,
-0.0096465209,
-0.0233528558,
0.0481385738,
0.0432626158,
0.0013617515,
0.003898496,
-0.0712775961,
0.0353918634,
-0.0313485749,
0.0402331799,
0.0003709763,
0.0243294872,
-0.0081424611,
-0.0333935022,
0.0365277976,
-0.0127348946,
-0.0202671643,
0.000918508,
0.0602203682,
0.0149135021,
0.0664768219,
-0.0854583457,
0.0744129419,
-0.0090296632,
-0.0264873449,
0.0734487101,
-0.0729120374,
0.0422243178,
-0.0294566117,
0.0465463065,
0.0136329643,
-0.0088201156,
0.0201913957,
-0.0091020558,
-0.0589146391,
-0.0460143611,
0.0167269725,
-0.0013135958,
-0.0467485487,
0.0085818889,
0.0426716544,
-0.0474732369,
-0.0004774617,
0.013794139,
0.0058823866,
-0.0031947156,
-0.0095630474,
-0.0265854821,
-0.012462737,
-0.0047699767,
0.0200981088,
-0.0409005843,
-0.0306281652,
0.0433623977,
-0.0027364253,
-0.0172510222,
-0.0967766121,
0.0154566159,
-0.0123739559,
-0.0241045021,
0.024239473,
0.0198637471,
-0.0210345443,
0.0885804892,
0.0572036654,
0.0100126173,
-0.0629415512,
-0.0262599755,
0.0343773291,
0.0270779338,
0.0788659751,
0.041101262,
0.0147686545,
-0.0084408587,
-0.0536908284,
-0.0101537453,
0.0347176716,
-0.0079370318,
0.0375520438,
-0.0499426164,
-0.0694146082,
-0.0070320969,
-0.0633596033,
-0.0066565555,
-0.0589152947,
-0.0235764869,
0.0239660088,
0.0270851534,
-0.0371966735,
-0.039057754,
0.0008857425,
-0.065378435,
0.0062410911,
0.0055725072,
0.0047783912,
-0.035225343,
0.016559165,
0.0564438291,
-0.0464585498,
0.0110337408,
0.0179549605,
-0.049799107,
-0.0031866478,
0.0057555083,
0.030889634,
0.012601275,
-0.0638678595,
0.0021623906,
-0.0266586002,
0.0525374152,
0.0200941414,
0.0023303004,
0.0328124948,
-0.0106925601,
-0.0249118768,
0.0106457062,
-0.0062271077,
0.0192005597,
-0.0610881932,
0.0541251935,
-0.0295129698,
0.0400572643,
-0.0507899113,
-0.0387504958,
-0.0194367617,
0.0066689732,
0.0000976261,
-0.0422893949,
0.0184805077,
0.0324234739,
2.787e-7,
0.0051268875,
0.0181151666,
-0.0135765811,
0.0118290549,
0.0097518591,
0.0564544685,
-0.023932809,
0.0182095841,
0.0105187455,
-0.0682130009,
-0.0144321499,
0.0181604922,
0.0460961163,
0.0643673763,
-0.0408471897,
-0.030947255,
-0.0555188879,
-0.0232574344,
-0.0221684799,
-0.024761999,
0.0487275571,
0.0841270238,
0.0612215362,
-0.0270618126,
0.0119703291,
-0.0800691545,
0.0361443646,
0.0157332197,
-0.0143449437,
-0.023236528,
0.0379360504,
0.0213893801,
0.0211588386,
0.0435705595,
0.0067114574,
0.024444025,
-0.0377737284,
0.0394803323,
-0.0101668257,
-0.0659530461,
-0.0589106902,
-0.0166662894,
0.0123707075,
-0.0789066106,
0.0771926269,
-0.0272181369,
-0.0303081647,
-0.0466108881,
0.0347287767,
-0.0350464955,
0.0621926375,
-0.0198218729,
-0.0233165585,
0.0023972881,
0.0106896935,
0.032921616,
0.0189069565,
-0.0605429225,
-0.0071829786,
-0.0163147096,
-0.035420794,
-0.0448884144,
0.0088316128,
0.0149170933,
0.0309818648,
-0.0365430415,
0.0255666189,
2.646221684e-34,
0.0390243605,
-0.0033919942,
-0.0076016141,
0.0364821218,
0.0275034439,
0.0020205062,
-0.0303967223,
-0.0228926167,
0.0494518094,
-0.0471778996,
-0.0383794531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01032v1 | Harnessing the Power of Prompt-based Techniques for Generating School-Level Questions using Large Language Models | 2023-12-02T05:13:28 | 2023-12-02T05:13:28 | Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Designing high-quality educational questions is a challenging and
time-consuming task. In this work, we propose a novel approach that utilizes
prompt-based techniques to generate descriptive and reasoning-based questions.
However, current question-answering (QA) datasets are inadequate for conducting
our experiments on prompt-based question generation (QG) in an educational
setting. Therefore, we curate a new QG dataset called EduProbe for school-level
subjects, by leveraging the rich content of NCERT textbooks. We carefully
annotate this dataset as quadruples of 1) Context: a segment upon which the
question is formed; 2) Long Prompt: a long textual cue for the question (i.e.,
a longer sequence of words or phrases, covering the main theme of the context);
3) Short Prompt: a short textual cue for the question (i.e., a condensed
representation of the key information or focus of the context); 4) Question: a
deep question that aligns with the context and is coherent with the prompts. We
investigate several prompt-based QG methods by fine-tuning pre-trained
transformer-based large language models (LLMs), namely PEGASUS, T5, MBART, and
BART. Moreover, we explore the performance of two general-purpose pre-trained
LLMs such as Text-Davinci-003 and GPT-3.5-Turbo without any further training.
By performing automatic evaluation, we show that T5 (with long prompt)
outperforms all other models, but still falls short of the human baseline.
Under human evaluation criteria, TextDavinci-003 usually shows better results
than other models under various prompt settings. Even in the case of human
evaluation criteria, QG models mostly fall short of the human baseline. Our
code and dataset are available at: https://github.com/my625/PromptQG | [
0.0429699682,
0.0052625551,
-0.0012908344,
0.011209432,
-0.0213697385,
0.0078803729,
0.0428556576,
-0.0257387608,
-0.0111607015,
-0.0445099995,
-0.0061563188,
-0.0582879335,
-0.0195490234,
0.0196109731,
0.0394377485,
-0.0398654714,
0.0017107149,
-0.0291594416,
-0.037598677,
0.0077440026,
-0.0152301677,
0.0100713065,
-0.0072238115,
0.02157107,
0.0086883251,
-0.0370565951,
-0.0522821806,
0.0092698904,
0.0127927968,
-0.0283335932,
0.0530979373,
0.0704441145,
0.008326496,
0.0000760383,
0.0000020002,
-0.0550127178,
-0.0196964424,
-0.0142335743,
-0.0267984774,
0.0147287734,
0.0080007408,
0.0271764528,
0.0115178032,
0.0273296069,
-0.0387588404,
0.0044282363,
0.0131203411,
0.0470913015,
0.0911601782,
0.0552054718,
0.0049387412,
-0.0364055336,
0.0452198684,
-0.021139672,
0.0619332939,
-0.020779876,
0.0042883023,
0.0135795437,
0.031946674,
0.0582335182,
-0.00158018,
0.0147925662,
0.0598317012,
-0.0390031599,
0.0042544683,
0.0206641108,
0.0068208124,
-0.0026089309,
-0.0119169708,
0.1155543551,
0.0105443764,
-0.0062899739,
0.0039893589,
0.0031987184,
0.0260334183,
0.0073963297,
-0.047443483,
0.0610887557,
-0.0096916566,
-0.0287387613,
0.0184641369,
0.0084128724,
-0.0236064512,
0.0136729181,
-0.0209855419,
0.0115129277,
0.0316571333,
-0.0358178467,
-0.023541281,
-0.0102341501,
-0.0436959416,
-0.0757503584,
0.0053503346,
0.0573971272,
-0.021536896,
0.0170702301,
-0.0422913842,
-0.0081293164,
0.02365526,
0.0381827503,
-0.0058425521,
0.0464089252,
-0.0134831872,
0.0162328873,
-0.0259280559,
0.0770613924,
-0.0220446326,
0.016838083,
-0.0660193115,
0.0135089485,
-0.0173594207,
-0.0178163722,
-0.0581765622,
0.0306928903,
-0.054163713,
-0.0203352477,
-0.0277205221,
0.0404110663,
0.0516157039,
0.0130782677,
0.0136433197,
0.0275639649,
-0.0393179506,
-0.0088393763,
-0.0302974582,
0.0252412781,
-0.0489135571,
-0.0221831985,
0.0541205108,
-0.0508042201,
-0.0051568216,
0.0212532226,
0.0180918295,
-0.035211429,
0.0073814159,
0.0044188946,
-0.0230386686,
-0.0203735419,
-0.0096090157,
-0.0580170639,
-0.0174482688,
-0.0441023037,
0.0021579282,
-0.0570419729,
0.0145672001,
0.0174915735,
-0.0209105257,
0.0133992713,
0.0176233128,
0.0548044592,
0.0321905427,
0.0327200964,
0.0035405827,
0.0036113244,
0.0572045483,
0.0200596247,
0.0122897187,
0.0065428163,
0.0211429,
0.0391693935,
0.0235949606,
-0.0194513332,
-0.0031764689,
0.0147314351,
0.0182632655,
0.0008335243,
-0.0009183527,
0.0289636627,
0.0197410006,
0.0490430929,
-0.0212401785,
0.0694420859,
0.0043751965,
-0.0008510176,
0.049855832,
0.0313150361,
-0.0075292336,
0.0151837096,
0.0595539808,
0.0213404,
0.0165460985,
0.0220015831,
-0.0314595476,
0.0097390451,
-0.0177373067,
0.0330676995,
0.038880486,
0.0378764607,
-0.0261968058,
-0.0323857255,
0.0106902067,
0.0054510622,
-0.0204701778,
0.0353043936,
0.024156956,
0.0283753797,
-0.0605425127,
0.0471468866,
-0.0064955284,
-0.0505022109,
0.0223099384,
-0.0406284034,
0.0904880762,
0.0159295611,
0.0590889901,
-0.0180993732,
-0.0606262982,
-0.0314806812,
0.0518821627,
0.0464989766,
0.0431006812,
-0.0228922535,
-0.0295504369,
-0.0466221198,
0.0010609283,
-0.0528535247,
-0.0152220791,
0.0093625532,
-0.0035037794,
0.014672881,
0.0464241728,
-0.0147001054,
-0.012902678,
0.0444923304,
-0.0514946841,
-0.0506151393,
0.0008521703,
-0.0033137035,
-0.041572012,
-0.0048105964,
-0.0023876503,
0.0201437846,
0.0288990773,
-0.0428227074,
-0.003846141,
-0.0322121754,
-0.0912210718,
-0.0577159412,
0.0367802791,
-0.029802544,
0.0001210718,
0.0204037428,
-0.0206385795,
-0.0408046581,
-0.034352947,
-0.0232776925,
-0.0065516317,
-0.0504548326,
0.0178644732,
0.0161994752,
-0.0050226925,
-0.0692035556,
0.0615881197,
0.0358452946,
0.0207692087,
0.0457425043,
0.0672763512,
0.0190042239,
-0.0186239444,
-0.0268959235,
0.0217009261,
-0.0224475283,
-0.0046996684,
0.0253619328,
0.0383874737,
-0.0714666247,
-0.0357768051,
-0.0663653612,
0.0527854487,
-0.0206070635,
0.0181748345,
0.0318688191,
0.0297694448,
-0.0227507222,
-0.0015563029,
-0.1106255949,
-0.0130982446,
0.0263819564,
-0.0044404804,
0.0428520814,
0.0143444631,
0.0264846198,
-0.0053733797,
-0.0086639998,
-0.0181848202,
0.0371834487,
0.0478430949,
0.0435336418,
-0.0495018475,
0.052606456,
-0.0186970085,
-0.016553795,
0.0157851651,
-0.0387590416,
0.0140675856,
-0.0321556032,
0.0884222537,
0.0750296935,
0.0422116704,
0.0020896075,
0.0086922823,
0.0104119591,
-0.0382969379,
0.0321287327,
-0.0363642611,
-0.0238311235,
0.0064396504,
-0.0321951248,
0.0072994162,
0.0481008291,
0.0206728671,
-0.021645369,
-0.0417263173,
0.0564393923,
-0.0097039482,
0.0202737954,
-0.0728359893,
-0.0012893722,
-0.0172578301,
0.0513363741,
-0.0144509999,
-0.00411015,
0.065079309,
-0.0311698169,
-0.0305216014,
-0.0612349734,
0.0361423641,
-0.0520498976,
0.0518016815,
0.0004617448,
0.0046219588,
0.0279911309,
-0.0228420012,
-0.0728871897,
0.0347626731,
0.0020536364,
-0.0449178703,
0.0325876065,
-0.031549532,
-0.024791833,
-0.0248414893,
-0.0400282592,
-0.0802560076,
-0.0456271917,
0.0053522019,
0.0023395107,
0.005389011,
-0.006240611,
0.0070312088,
0.0204651002,
0.0202678554,
0.0407497585,
-0.0697113127,
-0.0145105487,
-0.0303190984,
0.1003775001,
0.0955091715,
0.0229770783,
0.0246622954,
-0.0503827743,
0.0699856654,
0.0391807631,
0.0022609241,
0.0298565701,
0.0019259623,
-0.0007912752,
0.0095026633,
-0.0315252021,
0.000556802,
0.0290748384,
0.0711735711,
-0.0689957291,
-0.0412396975,
0.1105439737,
0.0452401005,
-0.0196703319,
-0.0279417727,
-0.0155532239,
0.0411547944,
-0.0150553174,
0.0322364122,
-0.0716167092,
-0.0374496244,
-0.0119067281,
0.013349304,
0.0007874171,
-0.0302210096,
-0.0045292191,
-0.1321781129,
0.0161497816,
-0.0126652243,
-0.018912971,
0.0136811268,
-0.0255768392,
-0.015867155,
0.0367285348,
0.0272900369,
0.0046911817,
-0.0132717434,
0.0111057162,
0.0359545685,
0.0114623513,
-0.0319668278,
0.0172016844,
-0.0209860075,
0.0037798227,
0.0473693646,
0.0151119558,
-0.0063702096,
-0.0503642857,
0.0202853978,
-0.0513111465,
-0.0148758618,
0.023887895,
-0.0052994261,
-0.0059777522,
-0.0151589615,
-0.0307655428,
0.0682932958,
-0.027510928,
0.0009782817,
0.0491069779,
0.0603625812,
-0.0167219304,
-0.0137999002,
-0.0251686778,
0.0298136715,
-0.0002513204,
0.1002910435,
0.0503977574,
-0.0747503266,
-0.006466426,
-0.0257778764,
0.0166936703,
-0.0657246783,
-0.0038412192,
0.0230549015,
0.0297663901,
0.0123899281,
-0.0845713615,
-0.0314424224,
0.0561015308,
0.0327939428,
0.0015882971,
-0.033984106,
-0.018344216,
-0.0038311318,
-0.0324499905,
0.0525598191,
-0.0198391471,
-0.0069329161,
-0.1011344865,
0.0014040258,
0.0176363494,
-0.0616072044,
-0.024514256,
0.0099619618,
-0.0810146704,
-0.0507319309,
-0.0039314125,
0.0372841507,
0.012456865,
-0.0088831,
-0.0094002765,
-0.0319166668,
0.030529948,
0.019336354,
-0.0137959337,
-0.0205879696,
-0.0284416117,
-0.0065792091,
-0.0096184677,
0.0104440507,
-0.0392510109,
0.0171754379,
0.0226421747,
0.0390691347,
0.0030894999,
-0.0756618679,
0.0388493203,
0.0301072672,
0.0108672045,
-0.0107445205,
-0.0124158189,
-0.0244260132,
0.0136190401,
-0.0170892403,
-0.013565951,
-0.0290794298,
0.0346027948,
0.0151317185,
-0.0261172857,
0.0159360636,
-0.0136642866,
-0.0257224217,
0.0533197932,
-0.0419584587,
0.0167565569,
-0.0177940596,
0.03164763,
0.0548189357,
-0.0124751311,
-0.0289922561,
-0.0190577097,
0.0119226053,
0.0684135929,
0.0136436531,
0.1013411582,
0.0315839313,
-0.0115685761,
0.0145685384,
0.03742899,
-0.0491086915,
-0.0306867808,
-0.01892424,
0.0107345507,
0.0071519827,
0.0189688876,
-0.0338491164,
-0.0059113391,
-0.0083047375,
-0.0165602528,
0.0333596244,
0.0329703689,
-0.0312803127,
0.0472138561,
0.0177230015,
0.0058196508,
0.0174601674,
0.0310968496,
-0.0162953511,
0.0108322129,
0.047884535,
0.0214655772,
-0.0355052985,
0.0089119114,
0.0016806913,
0.0045429212,
0.0089045782,
0.0301330816,
-0.0323566534,
-0.0352714173,
0.0277975779,
0.0222536065,
-0.0193488877,
-0.0105204405,
0.0439381711,
0.0481790937,
-0.0271203928,
-0.010965337,
-0.0295971222,
0.0543333329,
-0.0571722426,
-0.045153372,
-0.032348033,
-5.96758809e-33,
-0.0249796715,
-0.0417387486,
0.0210061762,
-0.013043059,
-0.0364901796,
-0.0060477736,
-0.0430207402,
-0.0001424601,
0.0010864431,
0.0027695876,
-0.0297469683,
-0.0228328798,
-0.0117636584,
0.0626092106,
-0.0266179461,
-0.0580610186,
0.0319735743,
0.0024382435,
-0.0421437696,
0.0735950917,
0.0188139211,
0.0260510575,
0.0134773171,
0.043780379,
0.0279584937,
-0.0669468492,
0.0057747001,
0.0231508836,
-0.0172292851,
0.0713741258,
-0.0308260676,
0.0260030944,
0.0203799829,
-0.067319952,
0.0026593357,
0.0841203332,
-0.0412432626,
-0.0236865133,
-0.0207304507,
-0.02580484,
-0.054309696,
-0.0596928634,
-0.0092093274,
-0.020079881,
0.0312668532,
-0.0098557677,
0.0375360921,
-0.0019613968,
0.0035570534,
-0.0364767201,
-0.0275475178,
-0.0105470913,
-0.033483956,
-0.0645203516,
-0.0519736819,
0.1063552499,
0.0075344085,
0.040450111,
-0.0033295208,
0.0165762007,
0.0579751618,
0.0139694065,
0.0187458731,
0.0280373245,
-0.0079556974,
0.038077496,
0.011529346,
0.0037899027,
-0.0284087788,
0.0103481235,
-0.0038338599,
0.0098873284,
0.0753250569,
0.0541492291,
0.0402617417,
0.0210987385,
-0.0693909079,
0.0585038401,
0.0107690962,
-0.02259003,
0.0098964134,
-0.0721683428,
-0.0110289892,
-0.0028082011,
-0.050116092,
0.0315768197,
-0.0294712558,
-0.0149827637,
0.0522455052,
-0.0352113172,
-0.0372264385,
-0.0192993004,
0.04027953,
-0.0146222776,
0.0193739273,
0.0219856668,
-0.0301152058,
0.0115291923,
-0.040701393,
0.0607668385,
-0.0181693472,
0.0008955639,
0.041195374,
-0.0172796194,
-0.0145614156,
0.0440210849,
-0.0018986723,
-0.0092771901,
-0.0392322801,
0.0075319661,
-0.0321638174,
0.0521529876,
-0.0067648632,
0.0038342958,
-0.0020984942,
0.0186019167,
-0.0101480428,
0.0626897737,
0.0059451465,
-0.0251404904,
-0.041512996,
-0.0263502188,
0.0238604918,
0.0123549877,
-0.0186504796,
0.0044096531,
-0.033018928,
0.0482198969,
-0.0026566326,
-0.0453738682,
-0.0049629062,
0.0178723931,
2.552e-7,
0.0152037842,
0.0118652312,
0.0330224447,
0.0241733417,
-0.0091414358,
0.0146942995,
0.0289352275,
-0.0020661703,
0.056572929,
-0.0066791405,
-0.0010541541,
0.0056155422,
0.0404842459,
-0.0075373366,
-0.123474896,
-0.0177273583,
-0.0760989338,
0.0095314374,
-0.0553248115,
0.0039050104,
0.0963529944,
0.0550933667,
-0.0324241631,
-0.023369452,
-0.0105721196,
-0.0222533345,
0.0277386066,
-0.0141150625,
-0.0336646698,
0.0602283664,
0.0324459076,
-0.0037342694,
0.0039913682,
0.0062520448,
-0.0082963724,
0.0093258414,
-0.0005370383,
0.0400487743,
0.0569703914,
-0.0317456275,
0.0043459767,
-0.0119840307,
0.0092030698,
-0.0888974369,
0.0795509964,
-0.0720908046,
0.0053148121,
0.0104661072,
-0.0307530407,
-0.0547998995,
-0.0129259508,
-0.0578363128,
-0.0115648359,
0.0093020909,
0.0164861474,
-0.0306204688,
0.035479296,
-0.0466817692,
0.0074931048,
-0.0033285187,
-0.0420469381,
-0.02593752,
-0.0620805435,
-0.0335930362,
-0.0084662018,
-0.0411449745,
0.0053069782,
2.372907309e-34,
0.0266355835,
-0.026812369,
0.0168272294,
-0.004582901,
0.0244385656,
-0.0114354203,
0.0265000537,
-0.0221460853,
0.039535787,
-0.1110447496,
-0.0230796933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.10048v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.10048v3 | Knowledge Graph Enhanced Aspect-Level Sentiment Analysis | 2023-12-02T04:45:17 | 2024-01-27T00:09:23 | Kavita Sharma, Ritu Patel, Sunita Iyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a novel method to enhance sentiment analysis by
addressing the challenge of context-specific word meanings. It combines the
advantages of a BERT model with a knowledge graph based synonym data. This
synergy leverages a dynamic attention mechanism to develop a knowledge-driven
state vector. For classifying sentiments linked to specific aspects, the
approach constructs a memory bank integrating positional data. The data are
then analyzed using a DCGRU to pinpoint sentiment characteristics related to
specific aspect terms. Experiments on three widely used datasets demonstrate
the superior performance of our method in sentiment classification. | [
0.0400394835,
-0.0078704515,
0.0008459423,
0.0236210134,
-0.0344963185,
-0.0001731715,
-0.026233891,
-0.0050802822,
0.0300937276,
-0.0824923888,
-0.0205591731,
-0.0097700795,
-0.0158605836,
0.0513626523,
-0.0034220435,
-0.0142290927,
0.060239967,
0.0693110675,
0.0534447804,
-0.012739284,
0.0250511151,
0.0106345164,
0.0101310471,
-0.023271542,
-0.0399772301,
-0.0123398742,
0.0209783744,
0.0357688926,
0.0172178,
-0.0375494547,
0.0379364751,
0.0294966549,
-0.0077626645,
-0.0087350989,
0.0000019302,
-0.0260092355,
-0.0210466664,
-0.0069652367,
0.0214306675,
-0.0179858133,
0.026626939,
-0.0325086638,
0.0280354824,
0.0040389299,
-0.0168020595,
-0.0141783934,
0.0271436274,
0.0377289429,
0.0694527254,
0.0769730359,
-0.0323130749,
-0.0077956631,
-0.023464324,
-0.0136225279,
-0.0016662535,
-0.0333047844,
0.0270916279,
0.0232642852,
-0.0162842907,
0.0018615829,
-0.0358776264,
0.0330574661,
-0.0153535018,
0.0020967207,
0.0678999871,
0.0209250785,
0.0393355563,
0.0321855322,
0.0056994236,
0.0556817912,
0.0035669308,
-0.0097613046,
-0.0180530045,
-0.0157545004,
-0.0209834073,
0.0248860959,
0.0112253567,
-0.0411012955,
-0.0416079164,
0.0384041518,
0.0208128337,
0.0054558772,
0.0139232418,
-0.0083555579,
-0.0179420523,
0.0429372527,
-0.0280994084,
-0.0708096772,
0.0173491314,
0.011887257,
0.0046334085,
-0.0172023829,
0.0081714336,
0.0090745138,
0.0263175406,
0.0550203286,
-0.019617606,
-0.022155812,
0.0387551188,
-0.1213430688,
-0.0025482685,
0.0188307017,
0.0179646499,
0.0419398919,
-0.0006249981,
-0.0142858783,
0.0003960888,
0.0044224723,
-0.0330014341,
-0.0136655951,
-0.072753951,
0.0093445554,
-0.0236344002,
0.0448401719,
-0.0132386005,
-0.0323818959,
-0.0617806204,
0.0340754129,
-0.0222045183,
0.0134450989,
0.0424781032,
0.0297059268,
0.007896645,
0.0189814679,
-0.0307390671,
0.0409228951,
-0.037532039,
0.0195687134,
-0.0486864187,
0.0263207406,
0.0060590701,
0.0127124069,
0.0309607238,
-0.0286320131,
0.0047188466,
0.019524375,
0.0646071807,
-0.0474275015,
-0.0226824507,
-0.0220740568,
-0.0203216076,
-0.0129906191,
0.0085384669,
-0.0315292962,
0.0250700302,
0.0058866339,
-0.0143770361,
0.0169307254,
0.0356307589,
0.0095692789,
-0.0384955071,
0.0349075049,
-0.0454402417,
-0.0582443289,
-0.0354801156,
-0.0155592607,
0.0106434366,
-0.0073701097,
-0.0095856432,
0.051118724,
0.0186258182,
0.0107253958,
-0.0160634089,
-0.0524536595,
0.0519319586,
-0.0030226032,
-0.0326007567,
0.0167985242,
-0.0507155135,
-0.0135790836,
0.005718091,
0.0438420363,
0.0040556276,
-0.0230973326,
0.0362010933,
-0.009675758,
-0.0068151955,
0.0838536695,
-0.0451162755,
0.0325790793,
-0.0216769148,
-0.0612050183,
-0.0383116826,
0.0321801044,
-0.007339552,
0.0231491607,
0.022780288,
-0.0285301581,
-0.0180760194,
-0.0229559503,
-0.0224369057,
-0.0248254016,
0.0640912578,
-0.0067720031,
0.0288197994,
-0.0042567244,
-0.0791229978,
0.0332420692,
0.0143419206,
-0.0343526527,
-0.0350727364,
-0.0247481447,
0.0342232101,
0.102833055,
-0.0004629198,
-0.0344525725,
-0.0723310858,
-0.0071163927,
-0.0605341494,
0.0158859733,
-0.0047799614,
0.0144792646,
-0.0493543968,
-0.0407410413,
0.0029800781,
-0.030862866,
0.0014150392,
0.0047615981,
0.0163663141,
0.0456413887,
-0.006321637,
-0.0497273542,
0.0133088101,
-0.0340111591,
0.0920017958,
0.0058503239,
0.0028376463,
0.013317477,
0.0356902331,
0.0536613837,
-0.021290008,
0.0201239381,
0.0092374487,
-0.0236562099,
-0.057095021,
0.0273603033,
-0.0195456613,
-0.0935282484,
0.0103182141,
0.0123299407,
-0.0431099422,
-0.0122985579,
-0.0392650403,
-0.0307436548,
0.014860047,
-0.0632851645,
0.11149849,
-0.0533156656,
-0.0409708098,
0.0223583803,
0.0011789751,
0.0059086871,
0.0960749909,
-0.0397553854,
0.0108935162,
-0.0114205023,
0.0333887711,
0.0531040356,
0.0443162397,
-0.0301783159,
-0.020571705,
0.0344771296,
0.0217019469,
0.0459466353,
-0.0270486474,
-0.0346962512,
-0.0099315094,
-0.1320980638,
0.0032339753,
0.0169063527,
0.0407764725,
0.0128480764,
0.0051175277,
0.0047302903,
0.0171699561,
-0.0348743759,
0.0177342948,
-0.0210460778,
-0.0023480344,
0.0296845306,
0.0165401753,
0.039086733,
-0.0316881426,
0.0003525586,
-0.0236750655,
-0.0046192398,
0.0119480416,
-0.0647387579,
0.0176428668,
0.054444775,
-0.0526640713,
0.0118102431,
0.0005972065,
-0.0323905274,
-0.0321342684,
0.0106867207,
-0.008995099,
0.0309496894,
0.014398613,
0.0380149819,
-0.0014765157,
-0.0099029988,
-0.0372206271,
0.0432087816,
-0.051210247,
0.0584344938,
-0.0214356203,
0.0120926052,
0.0144259948,
0.0363634378,
0.0423426367,
-0.0209566411,
-0.0744793043,
-0.034801729,
0.0004177295,
0.0151480213,
-0.0087224022,
0.0426903702,
-0.010084305,
-0.0642423034,
-0.037166588,
-0.0263289716,
0.0785280913,
0.0368568264,
0.0240779836,
-0.0715015084,
0.0073990584,
-0.038405247,
0.0583085418,
-0.0443348587,
0.0272963941,
-0.04605354,
0.0157202594,
0.0519227758,
-0.0382953435,
-0.0518899001,
-0.0176618863,
0.0305263549,
0.014282207,
0.022786973,
0.0402769595,
0.0000877654,
0.0109168245,
0.0033789035,
-0.0315655209,
0.0099030538,
0.0653268546,
-0.0404324085,
0.0172140412,
-0.0106549934,
-0.0256795101,
-0.0361519828,
0.0114627453,
-0.0101391338,
0.015925033,
0.0382926427,
0.009778142,
-0.0339609869,
-0.002400843,
0.0123498486,
-0.0454627797,
0.0682650357,
0.0033155771,
-0.0178378299,
-0.0029181193,
-0.0462086909,
-0.0011354558,
-0.02940071,
-0.0084592151,
-0.074376218,
-0.0031268022,
-0.0499212295,
0.0017521901,
0.1060423106,
0.0497412458,
-0.052936703,
-0.0143360309,
-0.0015177109,
-0.0137495631,
0.0245935246,
0.0032295878,
-0.0295081213,
-0.0445944853,
-0.0559617504,
0.0097580533,
0.0112181157,
-0.004442215,
0.0118201636,
-0.0903430656,
-0.0146039454,
-0.0271942448,
0.0083229225,
-0.090840131,
-0.0332007259,
0.0325607657,
0.0221058354,
-0.0418742932,
-0.068659164,
0.0398094282,
-0.0009044704,
-0.0146182301,
-0.0082384227,
-0.0074459934,
0.0590073466,
-0.0004100904,
0.0315850936,
0.0344681293,
0.1048295647,
0.0063407561,
-0.0651417822,
0.0097049112,
-0.0435790271,
0.0092665004,
-0.0183764659,
0.0333494768,
-0.0838547647,
-0.0028306702,
-0.0300462246,
-0.0435733683,
-0.0478486829,
-0.000029967,
-0.0197130498,
0.0557940677,
-0.0406441987,
-0.0201285854,
-0.029838087,
0.0044764574,
0.0413354449,
0.054075297,
0.005242019,
-0.0527550951,
-0.0012233547,
0.0044144536,
0.0103250938,
-0.0568470694,
0.03830567,
-0.0274178553,
-0.0213838015,
-0.0046980022,
-0.0441120639,
-0.0546540953,
0.0104902601,
0.0101807173,
-0.0186815951,
-0.0062221484,
0.035249833,
-0.0208382476,
-0.0900536254,
0.0184801705,
0.0430611707,
0.0309007354,
0.0081608146,
-0.0660989359,
0.0605013929,
0.0199218914,
-0.0329044424,
0.0086149545,
-0.0140025662,
-0.0134766866,
-0.0032650677,
0.033338137,
0.007702007,
0.0186033621,
-0.0094834566,
0.0303569622,
0.0251892563,
0.0292483922,
0.0058915769,
0.0024495288,
0.0573479719,
0.0707774609,
0.039262332,
0.0438671112,
-0.0298649669,
0.0118704438,
0.0037259774,
0.0036327534,
-0.0366387255,
-0.0380325429,
-0.0038483164,
-0.0093758116,
0.0540333614,
0.0238710586,
-0.0203145668,
-0.0306494478,
0.0391361676,
0.0250861757,
-0.0085341306,
-0.02095115,
-0.0425131582,
-0.0063651544,
-0.0525067709,
-0.0764000341,
0.0189194139,
0.0152454861,
-0.0382358432,
0.0081797736,
0.0539638177,
0.0035653447,
-0.0254413504,
-0.0124339024,
0.0143699143,
-0.0437604859,
-0.01734934,
0.023284018,
-0.015197196,
-0.0152866645,
0.0271716472,
0.0165301077,
-0.0363011844,
-0.0212438758,
0.0203292351,
-0.000230809,
-0.0144212926,
-0.0281414222,
0.0075929258,
-0.0027304324,
-0.023482509,
0.0126007563,
-0.0593022592,
0.0044075106,
0.0209941752,
0.0157237686,
-0.0349584892,
-0.0237705316,
0.0216631461,
-0.0152376425,
-0.0100691952,
-0.0100761624,
0.0066419309,
-0.0998379216,
0.0667928532,
0.0159955509,
-0.0283211488,
-0.0406059846,
0.000197258,
0.0611276031,
0.0325328745,
0.0301013552,
0.0726644918,
-0.0831058174,
-0.0678876489,
0.0849454924,
-0.025848031,
0.0206183176,
0.0039909161,
0.060788326,
0.0047214697,
0.0256317724,
0.0321587063,
-0.0588888563,
0.0297053568,
-0.0417621173,
-0.0162225626,
-0.0039729215,
-6.132525743e-33,
-0.0156457108,
-0.0174958371,
-0.0335756466,
-0.019730432,
-0.0261567477,
0.0079918001,
-0.052428063,
-0.0213952288,
0.0178411864,
0.0499786511,
0.007974009,
0.0471330136,
-0.0148145817,
0.0364724919,
-0.000508333,
-0.0270030741,
0.0155688422,
0.0281933695,
0.0275326632,
0.0703170076,
0.067508243,
0.0528400578,
0.0746916011,
-0.0868427008,
0.0556015037,
0.0145228133,
-0.000734019,
0.0287127774,
0.0298334621,
0.0144548947,
-0.0144028505,
0.0823441446,
0.031146938,
-0.0168364272,
0.0280022118,
0.0151911918,
-0.0391010866,
-0.0340099558,
0.0261196308,
-0.0246003643,
-0.0081876954,
-0.0202907529,
0.0035563542,
0.0200345088,
0.0236052424,
-0.0126590999,
0.0281550102,
-0.0011222933,
-0.0423786342,
-0.1328448057,
-0.0654686317,
0.0292363204,
0.0263274554,
-0.0083810482,
0.0041412143,
0.0010253236,
0.033201281,
0.0029227277,
-0.0672064796,
-0.0037344054,
-0.0512332879,
0.0154181626,
-0.0171641931,
-0.0136590544,
0.0128659634,
0.0739594996,
-0.0190702062,
0.0032989471,
-0.0135064255,
0.0493747853,
-0.0023166358,
0.0257624965,
-0.0020682227,
-0.0028834105,
0.0036040228,
-0.0647204891,
-0.0139449611,
0.0025223454,
0.0249157175,
0.0202926397,
0.0533191971,
0.0012014931,
-0.0534364507,
-0.0064522522,
0.0434808768,
0.0147906737,
-0.0232427251,
-0.0178876556,
-0.0178893022,
-0.0079869702,
-0.036553856,
0.0065966635,
-0.0254199505,
-0.0498091355,
0.0151570756,
0.0601425655,
0.0147580057,
0.0276607424,
0.0083366418,
0.0090408511,
-0.040950086,
-0.01953163,
-0.0315189622,
0.0321644023,
-0.0128437327,
0.0266937744,
0.0262372736,
0.0172556378,
-0.0677877218,
0.006583462,
-0.0395822041,
-0.0014198889,
-0.0442432836,
0.024235487,
0.0006117337,
0.0401083231,
0.0118987262,
0.0611336082,
0.0353308991,
0.0780891851,
0.0101181623,
0.032031063,
0.0162148401,
0.03642492,
-0.0066094897,
-0.0421591625,
-0.0008467628,
0.0257968083,
-0.0646055564,
-0.0580117889,
0.0131338416,
0.0147291068,
2.854e-7,
0.0639983267,
0.0757436529,
-0.0014723457,
0.0122157978,
0.0247923005,
0.0430973284,
0.0108134039,
0.0534837767,
-0.0087076537,
0.0003179901,
0.0471811853,
0.019544946,
-0.0487015024,
0.0167914107,
-0.1137848273,
0.0421111025,
-0.0014572764,
-0.0378942676,
0.0108462311,
0.0516465418,
0.0805361271,
0.0910161361,
0.0350139178,
0.0130839385,
0.0056799874,
-0.0017773606,
0.0333416834,
-0.0082609234,
0.0053372271,
-0.0038527679,
0.0261997674,
0.0088433046,
-0.041906517,
0.0090573253,
0.007385863,
0.0217977855,
-0.0179898515,
0.0393889323,
-0.0127292387,
-0.0902475119,
-0.0079927761,
-0.0198229458,
0.0312483311,
-0.0232314188,
0.0209337268,
-0.0652796254,
-0.0186515301,
-0.0513259731,
0.0092858635,
0.0585922413,
0.0193099156,
0.0102135511,
-0.0186374225,
-0.0036418026,
-0.0332667381,
-0.0314091332,
-0.0183784366,
-0.0907330662,
-0.0076605976,
0.0261264555,
-0.015726937,
-0.0263790693,
0.0135453716,
0.0396610796,
0.0239235945,
-0.0425067954,
0.0134320119,
2.169107583e-34,
0.0693355575,
-0.011045943,
-0.0203001779,
0.0187215768,
0.0180445518,
-0.0116258599,
-0.0147325117,
-0.0448301658,
0.0346862972,
-0.0327467434,
0.0014147098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.01006v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.01006v1 | Dual-Teacher De-biasing Distillation Framework for Multi-domain Fake News Detection | 2023-12-02T02:53:45 | 2023-12-02T02:53:45 | Jiayang Li, Xuan Feng, Tianlong Gu, Liang Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-domain fake news detection aims to identify whether various news from
different domains is real or fake and has become urgent and important. However,
existing methods are dedicated to improving the overall performance of fake
news detection, ignoring the fact that unbalanced data leads to disparate
treatment for different domains, i.e., the domain bias problem. To solve this
problem, we propose the Dual-Teacher De-biasing Distillation framework (DTDBD)
to mitigate bias across different domains. Following the knowledge distillation
methods, DTDBD adopts a teacher-student structure, where pre-trained large
teachers instruct a student model. In particular, the DTDBD consists of an
unbiased teacher and a clean teacher that jointly guide the student model in
mitigating domain bias and maintaining performance. For the unbiased teacher,
we introduce an adversarial de-biasing distillation loss to instruct the
student model in learning unbiased domain knowledge. For the clean teacher, we
design domain knowledge distillation loss, which effectively incentivizes the
student model to focus on representing domain features while maintaining
performance. Moreover, we present a momentum-based dynamic adjustment algorithm
to trade off the effects of two teachers. Extensive experiments on Chinese and
English datasets show that the proposed method substantially outperforms the
state-of-the-art baseline methods in terms of bias metrics while guaranteeing
competitive performance. | [
0.0436512828,
0.0682995096,
-0.0148542579,
0.0463615209,
0.0002169972,
0.0200626478,
0.0439398475,
-0.0181396529,
-0.0150213875,
-0.0115841208,
-0.0105275121,
-0.031215366,
-0.018586589,
0.0424321331,
-0.0180007163,
-0.0743325576,
0.0421008207,
0.0153878713,
0.0434601642,
-0.0213138163,
0.0460765846,
0.0132997073,
-0.0122718411,
-0.0152796237,
-0.0135025159,
0.004382554,
-0.0000182364,
0.0250545293,
0.0571771674,
-0.0089738434,
0.0464855395,
0.0291228015,
0.0381698236,
0.0683285147,
0.0000022883,
-0.0143172285,
-0.0341535397,
0.0001384649,
-0.0293657463,
0.0125693083,
0.044046618,
-0.0581495203,
-0.0009990687,
0.0167280082,
-0.0304345731,
-0.062609978,
0.0307232328,
0.0783190876,
0.0979994982,
0.0907919481,
-0.0142483944,
-0.0406812467,
-0.0295435283,
-0.0314062126,
-0.040385738,
-0.0667288601,
0.0492016077,
0.0198178142,
-0.0764790997,
-0.0019771848,
-0.0127815204,
0.0002294845,
0.04657102,
0.0027590992,
-0.0521277376,
0.0123652164,
-0.0096727554,
-0.0196764302,
0.0276995786,
0.0284937248,
-0.066038616,
-0.0365070514,
0.028854074,
-0.0251048692,
0.0517403223,
0.0177322663,
-0.0076588518,
-0.0130946692,
-0.0365925021,
0.0262735803,
-0.0324169658,
0.0221612602,
0.0272876602,
0.0411112458,
-0.0031137823,
-0.0267939568,
-0.0201617517,
0.0079495683,
0.0053269393,
0.0456030816,
-0.0281187482,
-0.0387884825,
0.0441684611,
-0.0119697498,
0.0013626686,
-0.022401236,
-0.0707885101,
-0.0345673636,
-0.0145927882,
-0.0372395404,
-0.0153174438,
-0.0349965915,
-0.0145083498,
0.0185018219,
0.012903831,
-0.0004846353,
-0.0287458412,
0.0235304292,
-0.0312003009,
-0.005146666,
-0.0338259712,
0.0208052304,
-0.0077592959,
0.0374360532,
-0.0089664431,
0.0367160477,
-0.0358047187,
-0.0221458301,
-0.0480950736,
-0.0196216274,
-0.0185284913,
0.0192295238,
-0.0333131589,
-0.0015331305,
-0.0028077716,
0.0766225308,
-0.0273018871,
0.0415639244,
0.0096744392,
-0.0388895273,
-0.0466783568,
0.0290983282,
-0.0273494869,
-0.0127993552,
-0.0202203523,
0.017012367,
-0.0059876423,
-0.0023579651,
-0.05769182,
-0.0284222886,
-0.0192203,
-0.0674165562,
0.0317070819,
-0.0504622757,
0.0001038748,
-0.0544621199,
0.0049011456,
-0.0972170904,
-0.0294426959,
-0.022050783,
0.0184840597,
0.0410189219,
0.0385028943,
-0.0341188572,
0.0499346964,
0.0692395121,
-0.013484125,
0.1215961948,
-0.0206223466,
0.0845005661,
0.0237037502,
0.0444794483,
0.0082861129,
-0.0048848144,
0.0980700254,
0.0439606681,
0.0067731342,
0.0014370176,
-0.0095164273,
0.0181671977,
0.0527525544,
-0.0206302963,
-0.0317680985,
-0.0184407718,
0.0449981205,
-0.1119660363,
0.0191901661,
-0.0073329615,
0.0347648785,
0.0217018723,
-0.0252929404,
0.0406978354,
-0.0548079386,
0.0158262793,
-0.0174047928,
-0.0198111776,
-0.0221151076,
0.0668554753,
-0.0373954102,
-0.0394635722,
0.0535443053,
-0.0089619234,
-0.0109209083,
0.0040312642,
0.0308702905,
0.0436028428,
0.0117897112,
0.0538531877,
0.0187631808,
0.0026909539,
0.0139762992,
-0.0598299988,
-0.0131191164,
-0.0103417877,
0.00503249,
0.0031305247,
0.0240731183,
-0.0482031032,
0.038685061,
0.0023588131,
0.0297136623,
-0.0221308507,
0.0172546227,
-0.0183622949,
-0.0615280047,
-0.0411315374,
0.0289874878,
0.023811115,
0.0180936139,
0.0610019304,
0.0402096547,
-0.0273147356,
-0.0193442237,
0.0168872718,
-0.0242839344,
-0.0277785026,
0.0060847546,
0.0295865033,
0.0174419545,
0.0082329055,
-0.0270437617,
-0.0457318537,
0.0230461881,
0.0004962502,
-0.0322207212,
-0.072791189,
-0.0271307603,
-0.0673596784,
0.0159047768,
-0.0679039955,
-0.0226460658,
0.0462041162,
-0.0352916606,
0.0027645985,
0.0301100668,
0.0196742117,
-0.0313334092,
-0.0285385512,
-0.0319899283,
-0.0232547279,
0.0365048908,
0.0079664607,
0.0597079545,
-0.0159258619,
-0.0532695204,
0.0057116975,
-0.0348787159,
-0.006852861,
-0.0021670882,
-0.0046034199,
-0.0062643318,
-0.0042903563,
0.0471057892,
0.0396435335,
-0.0268176608,
0.0082009621,
-0.0170687344,
-0.0067417133,
-0.0024149495,
-0.0510328822,
-0.0161822885,
0.007698467,
0.0179315098,
0.0056563001,
0.0072890045,
-0.0467994921,
-0.0759943128,
-0.0319521204,
0.0126948813,
-0.007031804,
-0.0054931333,
0.0407047383,
0.023807399,
0.0174362902,
0.0226036198,
0.0361992233,
0.0065952879,
-0.0241285842,
-0.0248853546,
0.0077476073,
-0.000242154,
0.0109280385,
-0.0182519406,
0.0017836157,
-0.0321680233,
0.0099955192,
-0.029283341,
0.058659222,
0.0020847097,
0.04301247,
0.0526658595,
0.0144474925,
-0.0341263525,
-0.0137773622,
-0.0079122307,
0.0614325367,
-0.0186454076,
-0.0023467969,
0.0005081428,
0.0157742333,
0.0192968938,
0.0010962931,
0.0117438268,
0.0433519036,
-0.0061573158,
-0.032168448,
0.0106392335,
-0.0134496186,
0.003563052,
-0.0052743871,
-0.0363517366,
-0.0269852858,
0.1053955033,
0.0189845636,
0.0489839762,
-0.0544793233,
-0.0201643687,
0.0031635519,
-0.0293488409,
-0.0347190462,
0.0090925321,
0.0381851383,
0.0184533801,
-0.0446131267,
0.0077996375,
0.0866734013,
-0.0179380439,
0.0198266003,
-0.0378099717,
0.0098139625,
-0.0067963004,
-0.0131733865,
-0.0687500462,
-0.0591349602,
0.0076992693,
-0.0093368152,
-0.016205769,
-0.0058362726,
-0.0783531964,
-0.0375472419,
0.0127354469,
0.0479807556,
-0.0117664402,
0.0111097293,
0.0308737736,
0.0508184768,
0.023798909,
-0.0227236245,
0.0098855551,
-0.030873416,
0.023171626,
0.0533522628,
0.013276347,
0.0044092694,
-0.0206108,
-0.0121822758,
-0.0053936425,
0.0129343271,
0.0285921153,
-0.0220761448,
0.001723086,
-0.0439301878,
0.0136551047,
0.0670970976,
-0.021623347,
-0.0183749236,
0.0023821404,
0.0805069432,
0.0042376639,
0.0045602433,
-0.025927864,
-0.0949291736,
-0.0468562283,
-0.0127026299,
0.0137150148,
0.0002780374,
0.0003311022,
-0.0099135283,
-0.0751174316,
-0.0146521823,
0.0141299404,
0.0092774937,
-0.0343830064,
-0.0277843047,
-0.00649885,
-0.0393488109,
0.0190714076,
-0.0431940928,
0.050910797,
-0.0033053721,
-0.0039350949,
0.0414934158,
-0.110317573,
-0.0377733782,
-0.0350909121,
0.0142959422,
0.066289708,
0.02195419,
-0.0188325252,
-0.0244855583,
-0.016690759,
-0.0075502824,
-0.0279258192,
0.0057563707,
0.0850810334,
-0.0496307537,
0.0027195869,
0.000389837,
0.0691740736,
-0.0065567959,
0.0117836548,
0.0394999869,
0.019578997,
0.0267178807,
-0.0815957934,
-0.0435576513,
-0.015294903,
0.0499658361,
0.0283686835,
0.004186166,
-0.0263772421,
0.0130995903,
-0.0226364154,
-0.0391364582,
0.0101817725,
-0.0480804034,
0.0413414165,
-0.0279906429,
-0.031878233,
-0.0138585651,
-0.0043639066,
-0.0215873551,
0.0259650741,
-0.0371359326,
-0.0300313588,
-0.0200289413,
-0.0066599697,
-0.044580128,
-0.0079735573,
0.0022865282,
0.0618048906,
-0.0034475478,
0.0014198979,
-0.0104546454,
-0.0291914679,
-0.024795847,
0.0610219464,
-0.0825380683,
-0.0536340885,
0.0330190472,
0.0266200937,
0.009486041,
0.0720063299,
-0.0221210364,
-0.0099533089,
0.0800826699,
0.0723780543,
-0.0176152904,
-0.0112344157,
0.0692776963,
-0.0607707947,
0.0374544449,
0.0238052979,
-0.0048152823,
0.0713664964,
0.0502614342,
-0.0431354977,
-0.022455737,
0.0297033805,
0.0061215567,
-0.0060311062,
0.0791606829,
0.0070183277,
0.0109122284,
-0.016073741,
-0.0059328871,
0.0105495369,
-0.0476749614,
-0.0094425064,
0.017486494,
0.0591208525,
0.0114855068,
0.0010092914,
0.0544211678,
0.012122645,
-0.0232650954,
-0.0485288166,
-0.020363817,
0.0095331008,
0.0783902109,
0.0117717981,
0.0091243507,
-0.0113458168,
0.0272963997,
0.0456943847,
0.0112067359,
-0.0052446942,
0.0047548283,
0.0503108874,
0.0227613412,
0.0375773981,
-0.0258845668,
-0.042693384,
0.0226867273,
-0.0500042029,
0.0244427361,
0.0247759782,
-0.0107049262,
0.0137996757,
0.0076666367,
-0.010886048,
-0.0035082931,
-0.0250606183,
-0.0014865077,
-0.0255024917,
-0.0045921453,
-0.0040320363,
-0.0165245403,
0.0329182111,
0.0782232657,
0.0115945898,
0.0481477268,
-0.0158741381,
-0.0211838391,
-0.0316796824,
-0.0181072187,
0.0379471965,
0.0275019314,
0.0080511505,
-0.0020414386,
-0.0611571744,
-0.032708209,
-0.0241572354,
-0.0269921776,
0.0175476018,
0.0196038596,
0.0176507588,
0.0327922255,
-0.0332686454,
0.0071077328,
0.0072467513,
-0.0275349133,
0.0050547491,
-0.0636867508,
0.0276632365,
-6.340055964e-33,
0.0180799104,
0.009142491,
-0.0602983795,
-0.0352842584,
0.0003182954,
0.0372126997,
0.0224688314,
-0.0517035611,
-0.0542285927,
0.0503852554,
0.0335127264,
0.0701913834,
-0.0073012337,
0.032144215,
-0.0605216548,
-0.0330247283,
0.0971367881,
0.0040079989,
-0.0396806896,
0.0501692407,
0.018559901,
0.0254880432,
0.0441525578,
-0.0598409437,
0.0142976949,
-0.0257868506,
-0.0546941236,
-0.0047960314,
0.0041591008,
0.01805567,
0.005898145,
0.0590306595,
0.0240434594,
-0.0632528141,
-0.0471324623,
-0.0078190248,
-0.0500578657,
-0.0332265906,
-0.0075051161,
0.0019310343,
0.0053891623,
-0.0072988104,
0.0272325817,
0.0126376897,
0.0268284287,
-0.03837616,
0.0235604662,
-0.0315199457,
0.0010936381,
-0.021503441,
0.0052016154,
0.0182846673,
-0.0127605088,
-0.0228791628,
0.0108944895,
0.0109579312,
0.0294408761,
-0.0145190842,
-0.0845084637,
0.0034351046,
0.0048529138,
0.0263875779,
0.0161318518,
-0.044358097,
-0.0493886396,
0.0622982159,
0.0280656144,
0.0408914499,
-0.0146184117,
-0.0284027737,
0.0259144343,
0.0237012859,
0.0243987162,
0.1181632131,
0.0808579475,
-0.0607101768,
-0.081726104,
0.0258621071,
0.0052782805,
0.0045118053,
-0.035932634,
-0.0172101874,
-0.0078430176,
-0.0246678405,
-0.019019695,
-0.0285375733,
-0.0106625734,
-0.0050762654,
0.0079595,
0.0342048593,
-0.0509017967,
0.0354726054,
-0.0114950426,
-0.0855232775,
0.0010412963,
0.0524603911,
-0.0247179139,
-0.0262463652,
0.0172617119,
0.0135019431,
-0.0514301918,
-0.0367220379,
0.0557835028,
0.0279800873,
-0.0172448624,
-0.0104755033,
0.0600758381,
0.0064300029,
-0.0238820892,
-0.0037804078,
-0.0170415193,
0.043766547,
0.0272277482,
0.0189327877,
-0.0116468295,
-0.0061340053,
-0.0158889778,
-0.003659836,
0.0035701466,
-0.0377477817,
-0.0240358915,
0.0555008687,
-0.0008005498,
0.0430154726,
-0.0208533574,
-0.0260165967,
-0.0051481579,
-0.0594518185,
0.0349523947,
-0.1207150593,
-0.0011030628,
-0.0362019278,
2.98e-7,
-0.052134566,
0.0194474719,
-0.0017653165,
-0.0335246325,
-0.0023017726,
0.0741971284,
0.0173757654,
0.0567824692,
-0.0433146618,
-0.0723650306,
-0.0165076777,
0.053531073,
0.0144819086,
0.0484012142,
-0.0875100642,
0.0335533582,
-0.0031748544,
-0.0014869334,
-0.0193690415,
-0.0379116535,
-0.0241256282,
0.0567937233,
0.0337349474,
-0.0389873199,
0.0539197661,
0.0243317727,
0.0452368595,
0.0726515427,
0.0330151916,
0.0146382237,
0.0423626788,
-0.0293082874,
0.0182097536,
0.0247930549,
-0.0396274738,
0.0276788361,
0.0220305752,
0.0384918712,
0.02017143,
0.0160716046,
-0.0272543561,
-0.0096542416,
0.0172516312,
-0.014883372,
0.0625131503,
-0.0431843624,
0.0044764592,
-0.0342777558,
-0.0609500967,
-0.0317996219,
0.039579235,
0.0265060738,
0.0078433026,
0.0488727465,
-0.0102552259,
0.0463900305,
-0.0068635019,
-0.0221336223,
-0.0013972645,
-0.0457129702,
-0.026651796,
-0.0056802765,
0.007041146,
-0.0462571122,
0.0526493415,
-0.01561563,
0.0200547297,
2.198558768e-34,
0.034072835,
-0.0211677086,
-0.0074134581,
-0.0417311564,
-0.0008387677,
0.0046523996,
-0.0744225755,
-0.0219552852,
0.0194077753,
0.0573442727,
-0.0151364189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02188v1 | Video Summarization: Towards Entity-Aware Captions | 2023-12-01T23:56:00 | 2023-12-01T23:56:00 | Hammad A. Ayyubi, Tianqi Liu, Arsha Nagrani, Xudong Lin, Mingda Zhang, Anurag Arnab, Feng Han, Yukun Zhu, Jialu Liu, Shih-Fu Chang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Existing popular video captioning benchmarks and models deal with generic
captions devoid of specific person, place or organization named entities. In
contrast, news videos present a challenging setting where the caption requires
such named entities for meaningful summarization. As such, we propose the task
of summarizing news video directly to entity-aware captions. We also release a
large-scale dataset, VIEWS (VIdeo NEWS), to support research on this task.
Further, we propose a method that augments visual information from videos with
context retrieved from external world knowledge to generate entity-aware
captions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on three video
captioning models. We also show that our approach generalizes to existing news
image captions dataset. With all the extensive experiments and insights, we
believe we establish a solid basis for future research on this challenging
task. | [
0.030113019,
0.056961298,
0.0235370528,
0.0172411464,
0.0543489344,
0.018900374,
-0.0358805284,
0.0080846846,
0.0041620638,
-0.0714568868,
0.0154766273,
-0.0139657818,
-0.0193835832,
0.0181496143,
0.0113623692,
-0.110078223,
0.0130359847,
-0.0134975528,
-0.0013871685,
0.0119438516,
0.0500923209,
0.0210571643,
0.0115068797,
0.0267130341,
-0.0221955832,
0.0285176728,
0.0020126477,
-0.0039286385,
0.0810526535,
-0.0110827116,
-0.0271310769,
0.0591920018,
0.0921027586,
0.0037645495,
0.0000014951,
-0.0186090916,
-0.0008487103,
-0.0122865243,
0.0376148075,
0.0403788425,
0.0140133947,
-0.0803571492,
0.019474579,
-0.0152079482,
-0.0243782159,
-0.0190754067,
0.0423666388,
0.0258389004,
0.0635935217,
0.0260925554,
-0.043892581,
-0.0457251929,
0.0219594613,
-0.0518148206,
0.0105173578,
-0.0194082242,
-0.0178240221,
0.0272344574,
-0.0275054891,
-0.0098998174,
-0.0246374328,
0.0520885214,
-0.0068389461,
-0.0162826572,
-0.0160062797,
0.0362778232,
-0.0381584428,
0.0031661533,
0.0027375964,
0.091354169,
0.0441050678,
0.0633584261,
0.0181279685,
0.0140373521,
0.0203711987,
-0.0011646779,
-0.0635769144,
0.0454794429,
0.0241289772,
-0.005304181,
-0.025303768,
0.0747760385,
-0.0226771161,
0.0079250988,
0.0085241701,
-0.0538472161,
0.0249889363,
0.0482071117,
-0.0733511373,
0.0064812358,
-0.0417483225,
-0.0760704055,
-0.0100567006,
-0.0016491297,
0.0452953875,
0.0065326747,
-0.0405869521,
-0.0025340291,
-0.0240478851,
-0.0354454406,
-0.0118569164,
-0.0014545035,
0.0007270863,
0.0766725242,
-0.0143201724,
0.0062614256,
-0.0071726437,
0.0076152715,
-0.0158863664,
0.0088767391,
-0.0617253706,
0.0110977646,
-0.01435568,
0.0329065286,
-0.0480642505,
-0.0279764012,
-0.0216131676,
-0.0034447685,
-0.0285690017,
0.0131654162,
-0.0384492502,
0.0360087194,
0.0315071531,
-0.001585379,
-0.034460403,
0.0268151257,
-0.0585246794,
-0.0039880644,
0.0038026513,
-0.0063633998,
-0.0070975181,
0.0041960427,
0.0280501693,
0.0176311228,
-0.0095746452,
0.0354664773,
-0.0415586531,
-0.0377352796,
-0.0096990913,
-0.0263853129,
-0.0591990165,
0.0112130223,
-0.0133897355,
-0.0411707126,
0.0349007472,
-0.015308083,
0.0054302835,
-0.0503701195,
0.0328698158,
0.011590437,
-0.0302043874,
0.0859061554,
-0.0125059793,
0.0247560218,
0.036980547,
0.0269859303,
0.0176938921,
0.0748934895,
0.0349424034,
0.0028982374,
0.0549496263,
0.02887615,
0.0532741472,
0.0336425826,
0.0080152843,
0.0409694836,
-0.023092784,
0.0012934271,
-0.0202919971,
-0.0059105083,
0.0297582559,
0.0253637545,
-0.0170703065,
0.0316435434,
0.0767816827,
0.0137498956,
-0.0543272756,
-0.0063779945,
0.0219019167,
0.0343949348,
0.0156211872,
0.0122564696,
-0.0283039436,
0.0718521923,
0.0301436186,
0.0446650237,
0.0548299961,
0.0224173907,
-0.0581638962,
-0.0244193021,
0.0367054418,
-0.017757779,
0.0115859825,
-0.0150285652,
0.0180764589,
0.0053135739,
-0.0503718145,
0.0771370605,
-0.0054842466,
-0.0489311032,
0.0378325544,
0.0062668771,
-0.0260023009,
0.0574712902,
0.0132630263,
-0.0239469688,
-0.0461210012,
-0.0260061044,
0.0442231931,
0.0305664632,
0.0187104549,
-0.0127925379,
0.0026604692,
-0.0526251607,
-0.0454091132,
0.0047251685,
0.0142659573,
0.0257730503,
0.0080401143,
0.0220228601,
0.0621901602,
-0.0022182076,
-0.0645722896,
0.0243215598,
0.0442574024,
-0.0097130863,
-0.0243392475,
0.0228411909,
-0.0170419421,
0.0668554455,
-0.0290199593,
-0.0188240632,
-0.0064010252,
-0.0055468227,
-0.016286362,
0.0557131134,
-0.0422799028,
-0.054567948,
0.0065941322,
-0.0948446319,
0.0012127656,
0.0125751067,
-0.0254178233,
-0.0863460302,
0.0104881655,
-0.0327926278,
0.0026182828,
-0.0660573393,
-0.0203827824,
0.0313569643,
0.0219549164,
0.0047633778,
0.0485081412,
-0.0001530808,
-0.0333565101,
0.0338626727,
-0.0221028663,
-0.0228130147,
-0.039124459,
-0.050073944,
-0.0314607993,
0.0112201339,
0.0213336144,
0.0630991235,
-0.0019823185,
-0.049286738,
-0.0052395766,
-0.104023464,
-0.0192314312,
-0.0060306573,
-0.0023928354,
0.0185909886,
0.019703608,
-0.0166699551,
-0.0424755774,
-0.038059216,
-0.0306048002,
-0.0003336328,
0.0150523121,
0.0375742912,
0.0579405278,
-0.0256005488,
-0.0309739579,
0.0043562115,
0.0090291789,
0.0466613807,
0.0015976202,
-0.0637304559,
-0.0012248383,
-0.0126765883,
-0.0156788025,
0.0001750798,
-0.0022270891,
0.006462506,
-0.0115356483,
0.0329847448,
0.0070520057,
0.0089660985,
0.0170519762,
0.0150283948,
-0.0262790993,
-0.009414278,
-0.0169465058,
0.0142758964,
-0.004707119,
-0.0450912155,
0.035436213,
-0.017043855,
-0.0071374397,
0.0008111952,
-0.0306220818,
0.0286339484,
-0.0777361989,
0.0320221633,
-0.0078356499,
-0.0216938555,
-0.0610574856,
0.0041151056,
0.0056169583,
0.0145564219,
-0.0454787873,
-0.0090540992,
0.0116636688,
-0.0408235751,
-0.0201610699,
0.0346515514,
0.0266831852,
-0.0473901778,
0.0863618702,
0.0072938339,
0.032505326,
-0.0100493999,
-0.0493058674,
-0.0212642252,
-0.0027105315,
0.0115583232,
-0.0043124049,
0.0860255212,
-0.0349604897,
-0.0057080258,
-0.0112586981,
0.0060138996,
-0.0001757486,
-0.0378334746,
-0.0344822444,
-0.0221919231,
-0.0170753449,
-0.0019803781,
-0.0185400583,
0.0285782516,
0.0210139398,
0.0412312858,
-0.014405231,
0.0045689824,
-0.0094165374,
0.0523601137,
0.0416818522,
0.0187177788,
-0.0434739515,
-0.0319755748,
0.0529517792,
0.0263234321,
0.035135895,
-0.0313863829,
0.0062073893,
0.0238455608,
0.0091005918,
-0.0161011275,
-0.0026986003,
-0.0062294514,
0.0837651268,
-0.0242378898,
0.0234126225,
0.1065580696,
-0.0004786408,
-0.0342369899,
-0.0256464295,
0.0502609275,
0.0054348228,
0.0503598154,
-0.001906549,
-0.0821135268,
-0.0496076681,
-0.0298220813,
-0.0018535567,
0.0416291729,
-0.0190038588,
-0.0234902706,
-0.0734305531,
0.0392967984,
0.0055041099,
-0.068409346,
-0.025565993,
-0.0087629706,
0.0112148477,
-0.0390847214,
-0.0357760824,
-0.0161582455,
-0.0094353501,
0.001786954,
-0.0106852399,
-0.0084435474,
-0.0120032746,
0.0056705819,
-0.0622949377,
0.0190003701,
0.046319712,
0.011035258,
-0.0337653719,
0.0192400552,
-0.0389030799,
-0.0452091284,
-0.0094383061,
0.0350193866,
0.1085678861,
-0.0486979522,
-0.0417130329,
0.0111961868,
0.0338067822,
-0.0056500835,
-0.0294858254,
0.0244199913,
-0.0132753653,
0.0319717079,
0.0202730671,
-0.0444991961,
0.0352718607,
0.0212299377,
0.0828957334,
0.0186503697,
-0.0202160813,
0.0304220412,
-0.0019773121,
-0.0358000547,
-0.053412199,
-0.0356497318,
-0.0068093138,
-0.0249002893,
-0.0561653338,
-0.0637093261,
-0.0378771387,
0.0864678547,
-0.0029237063,
0.0184980668,
-0.0015739433,
0.0139635559,
0.0508978702,
-0.0710790902,
0.0358818136,
-0.0388838947,
-0.0220132209,
-0.0139759276,
-0.0148235913,
0.0764280483,
-0.0118289273,
-0.0318138599,
0.0360361561,
-0.03599675,
0.0035816794,
-0.0419113822,
0.0546839908,
0.0126887187,
0.0696898475,
0.0299702231,
0.0238031242,
0.0225238819,
0.0298642907,
-0.0095979562,
0.0015384913,
-0.0034511455,
-0.0057191495,
-0.0388240106,
0.0251505319,
-0.0474125296,
0.0237649754,
-0.0428007059,
0.0466469415,
-0.0460803211,
-0.0372700579,
-0.0192233231,
-0.0057239719,
-0.0034032031,
-0.0640918389,
-0.013136073,
-0.0302817877,
-0.0315015353,
-0.0070080501,
0.0220146738,
-0.0356485583,
0.0188098028,
0.0061460668,
0.0236993954,
0.004556715,
0.0607280694,
0.0052939779,
-0.0391478986,
-0.0386262201,
-0.0391351096,
0.0068931044,
-0.0382764377,
-0.0324317105,
0.0119939288,
-0.0011337751,
0.0448472761,
-0.014932489,
0.0001427459,
-0.0334732607,
0.0145804314,
0.0039151288,
-0.0012031621,
-0.0182740018,
0.0714273378,
-0.0351889953,
0.0236291885,
-0.0751218796,
0.0895610154,
0.0491520502,
-0.0549759902,
0.0444953814,
0.0316629037,
-0.0058387141,
0.006106724,
0.0069306856,
-0.0085736848,
-0.046773646,
0.0119300094,
0.0050600488,
0.0003806764,
0.0251117256,
0.0750946254,
-0.0150977103,
0.0281747468,
0.0164800379,
-0.0085113654,
-0.0398533382,
0.0170605946,
0.0026063307,
0.0131952967,
-0.040044874,
0.0300824847,
-0.0276640449,
-0.0370907523,
0.0072180312,
-0.012893104,
0.0064706448,
0.0547543019,
0.0581399053,
-0.0046492023,
0.0286344085,
0.0053974558,
-0.0058254888,
-0.0548988581,
-0.0461127535,
0.0151173715,
0.0220914334,
-5.227615131e-33,
-0.0715590641,
0.0001318823,
-0.0215490833,
-0.0060615097,
-0.0232209284,
0.053372819,
-0.0296300054,
0.0377556868,
0.0062728045,
0.0070634722,
0.0011698537,
0.0004925815,
0.0231206752,
0.0472013801,
0.0316333175,
-0.0263778586,
0.0270114522,
-0.0220660064,
-0.0029868875,
0.036404632,
0.0091963159,
-0.0144733498,
0.0499379933,
-0.0492327996,
0.0232544243,
-0.0108855674,
-0.0611008555,
0.0062395907,
0.0936318859,
0.0428799279,
-0.008520158,
-0.0249063,
0.0124050016,
-0.0607171208,
-0.0472048707,
0.0041242242,
-0.0875640139,
0.0175541863,
0.0467984602,
-0.0002382581,
-0.0378937572,
-0.0276465341,
0.023905471,
-0.0268798117,
0.0092816697,
-0.0423472933,
0.0557072125,
-0.0416612588,
0.0471950695,
-0.0342588723,
-0.0033737982,
0.0127551882,
-0.0691645294,
-0.0398620218,
0.0359042995,
-0.0292992592,
0.0642218664,
-0.0051414138,
-0.0330311917,
0.0446080789,
0.0181176253,
0.024713777,
0.0902733728,
0.0291931834,
-0.0223180298,
0.0662920102,
-0.0123676918,
-0.0298177171,
-0.0679412112,
0.0073910803,
-0.0158450697,
0.0644942746,
0.009061099,
0.0717938989,
0.0087202881,
0.0204617884,
-0.0309010111,
0.0790893063,
-0.0796011984,
-0.0277152266,
-0.0065386612,
-0.0058260993,
0.0084318947,
0.035635408,
-0.0521561205,
-0.0219344627,
-0.0285466556,
-0.0043214788,
0.0032071767,
0.0104684737,
-0.0451256484,
0.0272379108,
0.0524464659,
-0.0490997732,
0.0410889946,
0.0108107328,
-0.011351319,
0.0592885315,
0.0105357012,
-0.0118757905,
0.0001958189,
-0.0080911443,
0.0575702451,
0.0232690629,
-0.003525998,
0.0024988179,
0.0453445129,
0.0058894302,
-0.0176688116,
-0.0014475476,
0.0193273313,
0.0260988362,
-0.091982916,
0.0119572626,
0.0078395242,
0.0253367703,
-0.0519572571,
-0.0063672573,
-0.001051537,
0.0193755943,
0.0098028062,
-0.023205841,
0.0326566957,
0.0610288233,
-0.0014961602,
0.0409255922,
-0.0052047647,
-0.0765425339,
0.0230686851,
-0.0381228179,
-0.039830815,
-0.0043558273,
2.1e-7,
0.0209818631,
0.0106760114,
0.0660766885,
0.0249059685,
-0.0171416625,
0.0475802906,
-0.005942239,
0.0488070771,
-0.0008115614,
-0.074987568,
0.0736394301,
0.0555553623,
0.0044397889,
-0.0354832932,
-0.0800185651,
-0.0335681625,
-0.0331418701,
-0.0050794976,
-0.0359255597,
-0.0140459612,
0.0531578846,
0.0727329031,
-0.0065424941,
0.003483783,
-0.0181707665,
-0.0705586448,
0.0438779369,
-0.0305974483,
-0.0404025838,
0.0268955752,
0.0178438537,
0.0385599285,
-0.0457802154,
0.0070814211,
-0.0065732026,
-0.0049694483,
0.1009148583,
0.0348858126,
-0.0107885627,
0.0019056413,
-0.0528785102,
0.0409385823,
0.0096276943,
0.0077328351,
0.05628727,
-0.0344022885,
0.0051742112,
-0.0120385531,
-0.0327363275,
0.0267677046,
-0.0125017595,
-0.0016124221,
-0.0338890031,
0.0550114997,
0.0281601902,
-0.01157948,
-0.0289760623,
-0.0952698588,
-0.0151178865,
-0.00242789,
0.0154973622,
0.0050408528,
-0.0306778885,
-0.0268133059,
0.012620206,
-0.0284642838,
-0.0411585756,
1.442421338e-34,
0.0322124884,
0.020835435,
-0.0404046215,
-0.0240513459,
0.01593359,
-0.0253911987,
-0.0680338889,
-0.0510186628,
-0.0102138855,
-0.057142809,
-0.006577644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00968v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00968v2 | Omni-SMoLA: Boosting Generalist Multimodal Models with Soft Mixture of Low-rank Experts | 2023-12-01T23:04:27 | 2024-04-02T19:57:32 | Jialin Wu, Xia Hu, Yaqing Wang, Bo Pang, Radu Soricut | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large multi-modal models (LMMs) exhibit remarkable performance across
numerous tasks. However, generalist LMMs often suffer from performance
degradation when tuned over a large collection of tasks. Recent research
suggests that Mixture of Experts (MoE) architectures are useful for instruction
tuning, but for LMMs of parameter size around O(50-100B), the prohibitive cost
of replicating and storing the expert models severely limits the number of
experts we can use. We propose Omni-SMoLA, an architecture that uses the Soft
MoE approach to (softly) mix many multimodal low rank experts, and avoids
introducing a significant number of new parameters compared to conventional MoE
models. The core intuition here is that the large model provides a foundational
backbone, while different lightweight experts residually learn specialized
knowledge, either per-modality or multimodally. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that the SMoLA approach helps improve the generalist performance
across a broad range of generative vision-and-language tasks, achieving new
SoTA generalist performance that often matches or outperforms single
specialized LMM baselines, as well as new SoTA specialist performance. | [
0.0266000815,
0.0969812274,
0.0096324058,
0.0107467081,
0.0238866135,
0.000811249,
0.0329632163,
-0.033147987,
-0.0498986878,
-0.0445989743,
-0.0839939117,
-0.0166152585,
0.0001535334,
0.0159469899,
0.0509564355,
-0.0629051253,
0.0223695021,
-0.0351918824,
-0.0177401807,
-0.0336533636,
0.0063708504,
0.0127581647,
-0.0371012352,
0.0314462669,
-0.0033266624,
-0.0114135193,
-0.0307077356,
0.0186756011,
0.0107571445,
0.0097310375,
0.0044393493,
0.0437344387,
0.0473705009,
0.001283331,
0.0000020796,
0.0041242368,
0.0178129561,
0.0020240529,
0.0157053284,
0.0135212149,
0.0245908312,
0.0140174422,
-0.0141479569,
0.0021020295,
0.0075806472,
-0.0047503682,
0.0759641454,
-0.00266119,
0.0698328093,
0.0885476321,
-0.0064059924,
-0.0108416015,
0.0468348674,
-0.033167623,
0.0186238177,
-0.0290730018,
-0.0190660264,
0.0084975716,
-0.007676146,
0.016462246,
-0.0431475341,
0.0327689052,
0.0075695091,
0.0248429962,
0.0299112834,
0.0250550751,
0.019383749,
-0.00698289,
-0.0427394249,
0.0393080562,
-0.0725640357,
0.0474630333,
-0.0238070097,
0.0033008673,
0.0151033737,
-0.0029682089,
-0.0306002293,
0.0203007236,
-0.0306621436,
-0.00345602,
-0.0300035346,
-0.0069785807,
0.0281096362,
0.0023350427,
-0.0183081478,
-0.0195670426,
0.0264071897,
0.0270908419,
0.0060386462,
-0.003389966,
-0.0342579186,
-0.0002939267,
-0.0149457045,
0.0113488035,
-0.0492041148,
-0.0149346022,
-0.0483071692,
-0.0137576815,
-0.0306242593,
0.0149288196,
0.0851365328,
0.0477351807,
-0.0688775629,
0.0434458517,
-0.0503410809,
0.0105920034,
-0.044582352,
0.0123027051,
-0.030859882,
-0.0155661833,
-0.071280852,
-0.0073483163,
0.001189139,
0.0113741634,
-0.0682070404,
-0.0373733863,
-0.0323792957,
0.0233890098,
-0.0190663747,
-0.0190237314,
0.0163650215,
0.0254209992,
-0.0299279727,
0.0043297145,
-0.0435009561,
0.0618768223,
-0.0213521551,
0.0466162302,
0.0126358299,
-0.0584641658,
0.0190526135,
0.0275687668,
0.0033834376,
-0.0138173271,
0.0418759249,
0.0791361257,
-0.0870750844,
-0.0210437812,
-0.0070054512,
-0.0204139166,
-0.013985144,
-0.0707726851,
0.038080126,
-0.0222135857,
0.0577329621,
-0.006805941,
0.0463177748,
-0.0105496123,
-0.0126981931,
-0.0328751169,
-0.0010597799,
0.0437979922,
0.0128729204,
0.0063284072,
0.00373494,
0.0063387384,
-0.0564559735,
0.0616103113,
-0.0124045322,
0.0265313499,
-0.017900018,
0.0080429288,
-0.0080575664,
0.0265616123,
-0.0188668128,
0.0292572305,
0.0074651581,
-0.044036556,
-0.010474544,
0.0160904545,
0.0788140073,
0.0293333437,
-0.0317392573,
-0.0235334355,
0.0774110258,
-0.0161167216,
0.0498303771,
0.0650019273,
0.0549756214,
-0.02728815,
0.0344471,
-0.0171120781,
-0.0166352913,
0.0583760552,
-0.029044725,
-0.035677772,
0.0309122019,
0.1023754328,
-0.0496799462,
-0.0115409894,
0.0228240844,
-0.0052196784,
-0.0775908604,
0.0410494544,
0.0531365983,
-0.0596265718,
-0.0432263464,
-0.0289243776,
0.024266066,
-0.0382089093,
-0.0080404021,
-0.0580955967,
0.003965186,
0.0492399335,
0.0016752299,
-0.0124650095,
-0.0321135223,
0.0121435598,
-0.0211875159,
-0.0015673258,
0.0067053842,
-0.0026398806,
0.0787864029,
-0.0347027816,
-0.0544523858,
-0.0491315983,
0.0219097845,
0.0848940685,
0.011670446,
-0.0161054209,
0.0045576207,
-0.0045296308,
0.0426384993,
0.0243777018,
0.0076739909,
0.038588617,
-0.0133635644,
-0.003000149,
0.0257732272,
-0.0192416571,
-0.0246295575,
-0.0051762084,
-0.0093890866,
-0.0364818685,
-0.0010991464,
0.0031393028,
-0.0572226159,
-0.0028676284,
0.0138975466,
-0.0324993543,
0.0462091677,
-0.0041175578,
-0.0337531418,
-0.0433500074,
0.0260345172,
-0.0345261842,
-0.0224324707,
-0.0352275558,
-0.0191070177,
0.0243437551,
0.0266785342,
0.0003736645,
0.0631754473,
-0.0188568179,
-0.0191604551,
0.0600195713,
0.0224292837,
0.0183941424,
-0.0331711769,
-0.0256373156,
-0.0094978474,
0.0191325732,
0.0466679521,
0.0043181884,
-0.0398272872,
-0.0171391238,
-0.0711600557,
-0.1233311296,
0.010167174,
-0.0127390185,
-0.016900951,
0.0138124162,
-0.0016003709,
0.0000449104,
0.0086747026,
0.0147329858,
0.0403142646,
-0.0247428846,
0.0080335839,
-0.0399190448,
0.0254842006,
-0.0067847171,
0.0057114223,
-0.0021994817,
0.005724214,
0.0244878177,
-0.0320121683,
-0.0147196613,
-0.0435950942,
-0.0170662403,
-0.0463973768,
0.0514108017,
-0.0387770496,
-0.0244814027,
0.0291966014,
-0.0258724838,
0.1003025845,
0.1026107669,
0.0126187988,
0.0055345711,
0.0622926615,
-0.0334720165,
-0.0142119052,
0.0235431008,
0.0325858332,
-0.0353549384,
-0.0163344406,
0.0267491005,
-0.0397259519,
0.0329041332,
0.0012985052,
-0.0045712306,
-0.0704464912,
0.0248377118,
0.0214681067,
-0.0717614144,
-0.0307146646,
0.0394912399,
-0.0004386227,
-0.0088334894,
-0.041377034,
-0.0345826969,
0.0378768854,
0.0034287719,
-0.0354597196,
0.008303999,
-0.0006862458,
0.0026493398,
0.0220317021,
-0.0038651172,
0.0505802073,
-0.0493128859,
0.0035728849,
-0.0773272887,
0.0188992098,
0.0327560753,
0.0013708365,
0.025997553,
-0.0569485351,
0.0285780393,
-0.0299952384,
-0.0579325147,
-0.0034154321,
-0.004122396,
-0.0140449069,
0.0287613068,
0.0033577746,
-0.0308493841,
-0.0558276325,
-0.0140415691,
0.0391457081,
0.0552865043,
-0.0328676626,
-0.0178824179,
-0.0274494179,
0.0187143479,
0.0014264229,
0.036273066,
-0.0478256084,
-0.081848748,
0.0051967558,
0.0265857261,
0.0364872813,
-0.047454711,
-0.102720134,
0.0483146533,
0.0238793623,
0.0560478829,
-0.0627401844,
0.0470771343,
0.0792453587,
-0.0530773737,
0.0263285879,
0.0459004715,
-0.0304117315,
-0.022110397,
-0.0219328813,
0.0316675156,
0.0296025686,
0.032066308,
0.034526363,
-0.048884362,
-0.0544204265,
-0.0214827619,
0.0084287124,
0.0072732111,
-0.0012561521,
0.0014403644,
-0.0438317358,
0.042020347,
0.0207205582,
-0.0630466267,
-0.0037044473,
0.0079044374,
-0.0073704985,
-0.0250285976,
-0.0313918069,
0.0136617934,
-0.0133867301,
-0.0255750343,
0.0343226343,
0.0371885784,
-0.0786193013,
0.0199233536,
-0.0265214778,
0.0307889376,
0.0348283164,
-0.0395018235,
0.004519003,
-0.0441414639,
0.0124565195,
0.0387238599,
0.0414441861,
-0.0024566294,
0.0397541411,
-0.0271254312,
-0.0346134491,
0.0035383005,
0.0204698518,
0.0119321402,
-0.0117101129,
-0.0337207429,
0.0412927866,
-0.0248469431,
0.0049324636,
-0.0270300377,
-0.0390101075,
-0.0227868874,
-0.0016376285,
-0.0123648765,
-0.0429962799,
0.009305628,
-0.0114050573,
-0.0100319311,
-0.0254592523,
0.0039675017,
0.0236734431,
-0.0144352857,
-0.0447257683,
-0.0205637626,
0.0175397974,
0.0016151804,
0.0803080797,
0.004892515,
-0.0241480917,
-0.0381316878,
0.0451371558,
-0.0145791639,
0.0691577569,
-0.0175335277,
-0.005948076,
-0.0555189103,
-0.0321992859,
0.0601916835,
-0.0067023328,
0.0075483667,
-0.0035252995,
-0.0724912584,
-0.0367838293,
-0.0223856028,
0.0826116279,
0.007943687,
0.0033901483,
0.036086902,
-0.0875819102,
0.0528654382,
0.0313779227,
-0.0020078814,
0.0420073457,
0.0273463484,
-0.0496334136,
-0.0064290161,
-0.0016831056,
-0.0419324972,
0.0204115547,
0.0267510358,
-0.0078075449,
-0.0011822622,
0.0265851784,
0.0026618114,
-0.0306855701,
0.0144304838,
-0.029789554,
0.0330439247,
-0.0490333512,
-0.0077315201,
0.0180739705,
-0.0050934283,
-0.0706027225,
-0.0001140489,
0.0497715026,
0.0129615292,
0.0255257133,
0.0337977372,
0.0592236333,
0.0381090194,
-0.0558423363,
-0.006783864,
0.0264863037,
-0.0057164752,
-0.0113455318,
0.0318330005,
-0.0080090845,
0.0251451787,
0.0005560172,
0.0254106484,
-0.0204193369,
0.0671450645,
0.0065287631,
-0.0040021446,
-0.0389187559,
0.0525573567,
-0.0311547779,
-0.0505968407,
-0.0411423668,
0.0584917292,
0.0748727247,
0.0170301739,
0.0443706959,
-0.0064188824,
-0.0199727714,
-0.0340848789,
0.0387257636,
0.0160090979,
0.0107105495,
0.0106611131,
0.0333129354,
0.0411069393,
-0.0326904431,
0.0622114167,
-0.0029584428,
0.05714228,
-0.0281648114,
0.0045210621,
-0.0467477553,
-0.0167168118,
0.0651103854,
0.0339055806,
0.0019111034,
0.0049949195,
0.0198096428,
-0.0154071264,
-0.0578092039,
-0.0021468282,
0.0019506381,
0.0113963056,
0.0286093242,
0.0464475751,
-0.0374362357,
-0.029274663,
-0.0235859249,
-0.0389408544,
0.0485924929,
0.0303694904,
0.0560154468,
-6.398713867e-33,
-0.0280492306,
0.0233906675,
0.0432159081,
-0.0814616233,
-0.0127070434,
0.0325048119,
0.0026357598,
0.0419210121,
-0.0236414839,
-0.0256754272,
-0.006007167,
-0.0114774005,
-0.0078260414,
0.0096640997,
0.0323074535,
0.0294136778,
0.0643310174,
0.0021552737,
-0.0195746291,
-0.0107228775,
0.0285359733,
0.0021539931,
0.0449355096,
-0.0577675961,
-0.0498456806,
0.0537549593,
-0.0683310926,
-0.0259003676,
-0.007368457,
0.0392608158,
-0.0047639292,
0.018136926,
0.006718039,
-0.0033673872,
-0.0415608846,
-0.0204827785,
-0.0331091434,
-0.0055975998,
0.0116910636,
-0.0137873469,
-0.0525578707,
-0.0211637281,
0.042819418,
0.0083861249,
-0.0000692516,
-0.0320065357,
0.0332680531,
-0.0365688615,
-0.0025705039,
-0.0091400417,
-0.0325758494,
0.0082914587,
0.0067421533,
-0.02963496,
0.022339005,
0.0083055915,
0.0160580985,
0.0122050205,
0.013965982,
0.0376645401,
-0.0064433394,
0.0618105084,
0.0402547084,
0.0755769908,
0.0037620363,
0.036656417,
0.0429127775,
-0.0417160988,
0.010061983,
-0.0199884493,
0.0489753261,
0.068824634,
0.0172179397,
0.0490230992,
0.0409766175,
0.0262130704,
-0.0397094339,
0.0388433523,
0.037967328,
0.0388521217,
0.0323372073,
0.0577147156,
0.0148685481,
0.0020551197,
-0.0285954848,
-0.0367674939,
-0.036460977,
-0.0150770005,
0.0382323191,
0.0424075164,
-0.0091552818,
0.0184437931,
0.0691861808,
-0.0288659818,
0.0224103779,
-0.0189346001,
-0.0405917652,
0.0477271862,
0.0025869054,
0.017565757,
-0.0673398077,
-0.0739643574,
0.0794372708,
-0.0107524358,
0.0036417227,
0.0056697531,
-0.0093970001,
0.0782630369,
-0.0570544191,
-0.0095632179,
-0.0447442383,
-0.0284847505,
0.005077959,
0.0522382893,
0.0271196608,
-0.0115537765,
-0.0306041483,
0.0411579944,
-0.041039262,
0.0035246338,
-0.0337352455,
-0.0934728384,
0.0287503637,
0.0139965937,
0.0016394521,
0.0451722033,
-0.0502725691,
-0.102981925,
0.0029630894,
-0.021958705,
-0.0321954489,
0.0210585166,
2.791e-7,
-0.0034544587,
-0.0053129359,
-0.0338223092,
-0.0393818505,
0.0210758727,
0.0304019954,
-0.0282580685,
0.0087453341,
0.0120480191,
-0.0496268272,
0.0229692701,
0.0663767159,
0.009931786,
0.0022512923,
-0.0175386313,
-0.0174379162,
0.0062788706,
0.0352573916,
-0.0500256568,
-0.0183001384,
-0.0179640204,
0.086615473,
0.0126154246,
-0.0300499164,
0.0433180295,
-0.0219277944,
0.1026818082,
0.0198276117,
-0.0325218849,
-0.0107657025,
0.077285111,
0.0475502871,
-0.0224610623,
0.0315536335,
0.0158269387,
0.0062955609,
0.0227493178,
0.0442282632,
-0.0444174074,
-0.0525177121,
0.0386337377,
0.0535891615,
-0.0469660312,
0.000379919,
0.0479546562,
-0.0137851778,
0.0032813975,
-0.0507338755,
-0.0346315578,
0.009169572,
-0.0025932975,
-0.0517074428,
-0.0289088972,
0.0102553396,
-0.0101255067,
-0.0143273547,
-0.0404214002,
-0.0521528088,
0.0137852486,
0.0180290677,
-0.0660014823,
-0.0640671104,
-0.0406903811,
-0.0288192667,
0.0449514687,
-0.0457394347,
-0.053881444,
2.167448575e-34,
0.0032660661,
-0.0034297425,
0.0410298631,
0.0112469969,
0.0017880227,
-0.0187784117,
-0.0627057552,
-0.022286037,
0.0186941419,
-0.0071630063,
-0.0424237661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.10893v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.10893v3 | Location Sensitive Embedding for Knowledge Graph Reasoning | 2023-12-01T22:35:19 | 2024-01-30T03:14:11 | Deepak Banerjee, Anjali Ishaan | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Embedding methods transform the knowledge graph into a continuous,
low-dimensional space, facilitating inference and completion tasks. Existing
methods are mainly divided into two types: translational distance models and
semantic matching models. A key challenge in translational distance models is
their inability to effectively differentiate between 'head' and 'tail' entities
in graphs. To address this problem, a novel location-sensitive embedding (LSE)
method has been developed. LSE innovatively modifies the head entity using
relation-specific mappings, conceptualizing relations as linear transformations
rather than mere translations. The theoretical foundations of LSE, including
its representational capabilities and its connections to existing models, have
been thoroughly examined. A more streamlined variant, LSE-d, which employs a
diagonal matrix for transformations to enhance practical efficiency, is also
proposed. Experiments conducted on four large-scale KG datasets for link
prediction show that LSEd either outperforms or is competitive with
state-of-the-art related works. | [
0.0359384902,
-0.0217759255,
-0.0249099508,
0.0457921475,
0.0085293455,
0.0023741736,
-0.0061801784,
0.0038032369,
0.1074071899,
-0.013593128,
0.0120784221,
0.0320901871,
-0.0034725708,
-0.0328049138,
0.0273540858,
-0.0215615667,
-0.008583446,
0.0375168137,
-0.0505572893,
-0.0350004099,
-0.0393767692,
0.0205047429,
0.0104676317,
0.0146877104,
-0.0137582859,
0.0096990876,
0.0108562876,
0.0036871633,
0.061355345,
-0.008522776,
-0.0271261781,
0.005693845,
0.0278377049,
-0.0227745343,
0.0000022437,
-0.0023782791,
-0.0088027753,
-0.0061954912,
0.0074024135,
-0.0398960598,
-0.0603598952,
-0.0631814525,
0.0620241053,
-0.0126266768,
-0.0229425505,
-0.0257846601,
0.0432524681,
0.0362422243,
-0.0391731896,
0.0461693481,
-0.0251948256,
-0.0802423432,
0.0092112562,
0.0019167622,
0.000598245,
-0.0150592849,
0.0435573868,
0.0287067275,
0.0031220678,
0.042839352,
-0.0449178927,
0.0427441448,
0.0004157411,
-0.0004523471,
0.0750932619,
0.0333848484,
0.0027344052,
0.0459571294,
0.0523744039,
0.0935878307,
0.0101100346,
0.0147829121,
0.0164549835,
0.0242387131,
-0.0070336172,
0.0444126055,
-0.0302450769,
-0.0634920746,
0.0243381727,
0.0001752462,
-0.0486737192,
0.0281891543,
0.0583929978,
-0.0050085662,
-0.0276748613,
0.0637004822,
-0.0014475561,
-0.0301936623,
-0.0271919705,
0.0321568996,
0.0014786647,
0.0042944415,
0.0119132604,
0.0191761944,
0.0356486738,
0.0256806258,
0.0217520986,
0.0557075106,
-0.0139885377,
-0.0797738805,
-0.0224583168,
0.0222984646,
0.0403692611,
0.0633720905,
-0.0815861225,
0.0110107074,
-0.0369622484,
0.0104105501,
-0.0237043146,
-0.0276666041,
-0.0667373464,
-0.0082466658,
0.0038052294,
-0.0010317048,
-0.0147946319,
-0.0106999977,
-0.0402058847,
0.0481930934,
-0.0389699042,
0.0495645367,
-0.0070628347,
0.0342166685,
0.0480933674,
-0.0180712081,
-0.0309905931,
0.0298349317,
-0.0346484035,
0.0395242088,
-0.0816113874,
0.0492215082,
0.0142451301,
0.0187579151,
0.0029398175,
-0.0323839374,
-0.0198510662,
0.0824477896,
0.0715380535,
0.0110962261,
0.0111801708,
-0.0354995579,
-0.0062122773,
-0.0137461582,
0.0539454073,
-0.05132135,
0.0326229483,
0.0287412256,
-0.0358765274,
-0.0196399186,
0.0077427789,
-0.0397129469,
-0.0850140527,
0.0692433342,
0.0169295818,
0.0092301704,
-0.0114081027,
0.00131279,
-0.0281018708,
0.01912627,
0.0091825798,
0.0094593242,
0.0345746949,
0.0171493981,
-0.0776857585,
-0.0018872254,
0.0398912691,
-0.0104305949,
0.0135828163,
0.0404109098,
-0.0088774152,
0.0386254787,
0.0220627412,
-0.0377314761,
-0.0375096984,
-0.0028777991,
0.0211567692,
0.0296597499,
0.0453214422,
-0.0072118454,
0.0248570107,
0.0084181009,
-0.0763381794,
-0.0366212577,
-0.0340417288,
0.02281004,
-0.0218296014,
-0.001264271,
-0.0262541007,
0.0204605777,
-0.0148710823,
0.0167799648,
0.0142802121,
0.0034185229,
0.0395486802,
0.0164999776,
0.0297574606,
-0.033595819,
0.0128032863,
0.0353661701,
0.015057154,
0.0043219826,
0.0033850814,
0.0415532514,
-0.0432936773,
0.0564622022,
0.0470165275,
-0.0127986884,
-0.0533759519,
0.0058448678,
0.0127380639,
-0.0073927301,
0.0209836289,
-0.0269582998,
-0.0511213355,
-0.031954322,
-0.0798367262,
0.0528001674,
-0.0066137463,
0.001063144,
0.0601265207,
0.0532095097,
0.0649424866,
-0.1126012951,
0.0732447356,
0.0033967274,
-0.005104071,
0.0301136822,
0.0266362634,
0.0675166398,
-0.0220720749,
0.0296389628,
0.0565058775,
0.0004615604,
0.044022046,
-0.0340872854,
-0.0248218235,
0.0052894908,
0.0193962567,
-0.0329249464,
0.0529710241,
-0.0202266071,
0.02023644,
-0.0341658331,
-0.0066296007,
-0.019533094,
0.0509130694,
0.0222275127,
0.0588605329,
0.018401131,
-0.0118821496,
-0.0013096216,
-0.0243485235,
-0.0394478142,
0.0738330483,
-0.0128097581,
0.0364557989,
0.0107717486,
-0.0408967808,
0.0352811068,
-0.0067515918,
-0.0259509776,
-0.0221993942,
0.03033817,
0.0028310565,
0.0023728204,
-0.0404230803,
-0.0295636691,
-0.0005402838,
-0.0653324947,
0.0010258221,
0.0303542018,
-0.0025725903,
-0.0072903573,
-0.0041346783,
0.0257158261,
-0.0270798597,
-0.02933258,
0.0250868555,
-0.0408326797,
0.0170848761,
0.0228350759,
-0.0118831024,
-0.0370685533,
0.0255553089,
-0.0188614577,
-0.0519764312,
0.0369117036,
-0.0417520851,
-0.0308370963,
-0.0205481499,
0.0143892737,
-0.0677706674,
0.0034901795,
-0.0238307398,
0.0393314734,
-0.0216288548,
-0.0012486876,
0.0391559862,
-0.0082585691,
-0.0489906259,
-0.0342863761,
0.0348623879,
-0.0061868629,
-0.0413825773,
-0.003676493,
-0.0616984926,
0.0520635992,
-0.0396034643,
-0.0044543669,
-0.0692760944,
-0.0468317047,
0.0249908678,
-0.0486007296,
-0.0877591744,
0.0010320668,
0.0179060642,
0.0348753557,
-0.0489480011,
0.0190500859,
0.0701977238,
0.0001619158,
-0.0081872456,
0.0278128814,
0.0572657362,
-0.0054744161,
0.0687901527,
0.0396220498,
-0.0098525509,
-0.0409072116,
0.0535615794,
-0.0083934702,
0.0297894217,
-0.0474852994,
0.0198579859,
-0.0384391434,
0.017525617,
0.0231269617,
-0.0093714138,
-0.0106105702,
0.0274882596,
-0.0048496355,
0.0058180285,
-0.0157646574,
-0.0123936953,
0.0189625472,
0.0061043701,
0.018898651,
-0.0031284185,
-0.0344735757,
0.0108862938,
0.0445130169,
0.0089043994,
-0.0334213413,
0.0054457914,
-0.0123164905,
-0.0258512851,
0.0356623568,
0.0397531651,
-0.0005427722,
0.0074653034,
0.0379654355,
0.0046709427,
0.018465044,
-0.0361165777,
-0.0586894192,
-0.0088550812,
0.0128868278,
0.0187644176,
-0.0004647298,
-0.0358066782,
-0.0194998365,
0.0301300827,
-0.0060589416,
0.0069733784,
0.0612929314,
0.0461869612,
-0.0240075234,
0.0162868239,
-0.0131566748,
0.0237581544,
0.0526532158,
0.0529054515,
-0.0733057484,
0.0013653096,
-0.0017099925,
0.0119405957,
0.0386128798,
-0.0756464452,
0.0265483223,
-0.0537409931,
0.0395118296,
0.0089904405,
0.0041847951,
-0.0985527337,
-0.0345433503,
0.0028693292,
0.0039344253,
-0.0763830096,
-0.0296900533,
0.001952281,
0.0055808094,
0.0088039851,
-0.0292067453,
-0.0180431027,
0.0085999891,
-0.0553874336,
0.0247015283,
-0.0142139914,
0.0517893992,
0.0398246199,
-0.0340127833,
-0.0603480265,
-0.012160264,
-0.0212790892,
-0.0020936979,
0.0236061923,
-0.0061178179,
0.0096153039,
-0.0120271957,
-0.0131516596,
-0.0459635966,
-0.0076415683,
-0.0123534398,
0.1409188062,
-0.012719647,
0.0145677002,
-0.0294354297,
-0.0067340317,
-0.0147792213,
0.0405861922,
0.0081805652,
0.0173068456,
-0.0071301069,
0.0110318167,
0.0372288562,
0.0556391813,
0.0048454762,
0.0211631805,
-0.0516756885,
0.020649353,
-0.0515806787,
-0.0164347365,
0.0544293113,
0.0223345384,
0.0091425506,
0.0144754769,
-0.0057961722,
-0.0490825325,
-0.0657249987,
-0.0212135203,
-0.0225999318,
0.0432729237,
0.0730507076,
0.0603563823,
0.0190940332,
-0.0190763213,
-0.0275266413,
-0.0095344279,
-0.013318277,
-0.05455653,
-0.0745225325,
-0.0065760384,
0.0061158673,
0.0707316697,
-0.0432834141,
-0.0101372544,
0.0529738963,
0.0148079544,
-0.02509211,
0.0009854846,
0.0202460829,
-0.0092804739,
0.0038392383,
0.053108789,
-0.0511792079,
-0.011339074,
0.007927862,
0.0426697806,
-0.0795467049,
-0.0510453582,
-0.0223369841,
0.0236955285,
0.0339499563,
0.0293239895,
-0.0266271047,
-0.0424329862,
0.0142388241,
-0.0460647643,
-0.0246347673,
-0.006476183,
-0.0400413573,
0.0533606708,
0.0222056434,
0.0076047918,
-0.0420765691,
0.0351619758,
0.0002537674,
-0.0214397889,
-0.0070318156,
0.0357087515,
-0.0327673741,
0.0050629373,
0.0523067527,
-0.0208089761,
0.0101186233,
0.0184557252,
0.0240121838,
-0.0479424149,
-0.0333238877,
0.0307400022,
-0.0044136657,
-0.0768013448,
0.0150464689,
-0.0576541424,
-0.0105186943,
0.0248049572,
-0.0156179322,
0.0425243117,
-0.0146262264,
0.0066010207,
-0.0250096079,
-0.0325477235,
0.037453521,
0.0428638794,
-0.0159153398,
-0.0435849167,
0.0404651575,
0.0064997971,
-0.0152075617,
0.0334699489,
0.0184231065,
0.0057106139,
0.0347052254,
-0.0539085642,
-0.0922159851,
-0.0230020955,
-0.0208741911,
0.0369077884,
0.0230762605,
-0.0009662082,
0.0268672854,
-0.0712749586,
-0.0774474889,
0.0146942455,
-0.0434040315,
-0.0755844861,
0.0123450365,
0.0014370224,
0.0169913191,
0.04966034,
-0.0638401732,
-0.0289102625,
-0.0047684051,
-0.0427900776,
-0.0357443206,
-0.0138994539,
-6.169194922e-33,
-0.0007791097,
-0.0356525555,
0.036667157,
-0.0132461898,
-0.067852743,
0.0161531791,
0.0103948573,
-0.0219683833,
-0.0641029999,
0.0123563195,
-0.0196671095,
-0.0372483842,
-0.0167838596,
-0.0015563995,
-0.011957963,
0.0109979836,
-0.0004883232,
0.0323619582,
0.0297742113,
0.0011256372,
0.0568279177,
0.0295319688,
0.0334325321,
-0.0844855979,
0.0261058714,
-0.030457601,
0.0061284439,
0.0353366584,
0.0450187549,
0.0098858643,
-0.0389359444,
0.0112091899,
0.0137565983,
-0.0024170601,
0.0020204296,
-0.0326282084,
-0.110441573,
-0.0311206225,
-0.0063613476,
0.0207490008,
0.0151110124,
-0.011844038,
0.0461076386,
0.0043119262,
0.0239807777,
-0.0537602343,
0.0553818196,
-0.0134100551,
-0.0902847573,
0.0041232267,
-0.0249340329,
0.020132415,
-0.0086192777,
0.0248921309,
0.0166496187,
0.0143780475,
0.0263067614,
-0.0297580194,
-0.1088677421,
0.0257496778,
-0.0121069318,
-0.0067314338,
0.026262844,
-0.0284235086,
0.0264362674,
0.0282162558,
-0.0110892626,
-0.0196227077,
-0.0259301122,
0.0073406366,
-0.0249887761,
0.0289986487,
0.0003835576,
0.0097245779,
-0.0415400192,
-0.0212334003,
-0.115250513,
0.0069459653,
-0.0105635896,
-0.0032451618,
-0.0000379566,
0.0356087275,
-0.0712387562,
-0.0637252703,
-0.0324438326,
-0.0322895236,
0.0064038364,
-0.0746345967,
0.0049772118,
0.009710378,
-0.0251623988,
0.0449413396,
-0.0105274403,
-0.0758894831,
-0.0050265398,
0.0544879846,
-0.0005632582,
0.0084734699,
0.0307667889,
0.0167374536,
-0.0268088821,
-0.0235136151,
0.0031650618,
-0.0540199764,
-0.0071146553,
0.0254075732,
0.0552494153,
0.0013844096,
-0.0259822737,
-0.0052049635,
-0.0084741665,
-0.080879502,
-0.0329532549,
-0.0147587871,
0.0098161316,
0.039210923,
0.0236721896,
0.033783704,
0.0833253041,
0.0690756813,
0.0350609198,
0.0340120904,
0.0167346857,
0.0112100504,
-0.0039853659,
-0.0116620054,
-0.0157657769,
0.0501058102,
0.0048125908,
-0.0779574066,
-0.0197384022,
-0.029194368,
3.097e-7,
0.0420767181,
0.0277435165,
0.0137112066,
0.0131253684,
-0.0115587525,
0.0128934775,
0.0382210463,
0.0358644426,
-0.0224363152,
0.0365362316,
0.0453241803,
0.0130128916,
-0.0343967117,
0.0234893411,
-0.0634824708,
0.0220169649,
-0.0238313172,
-0.0331642516,
-0.0236605927,
0.0027610355,
0.0096113505,
0.0261503514,
0.0529346727,
0.0237519071,
-0.009763361,
-0.0223169662,
0.0509789102,
-0.0362420417,
0.0260437187,
-0.0440459475,
0.0357899927,
-0.0008609608,
-0.0091122705,
0.0280834846,
0.0018090804,
0.0512004383,
0.0127244545,
0.0165706128,
-0.0126787415,
-0.0027603596,
-0.0311490297,
-0.0784877762,
0.0279925298,
-0.0546500534,
0.0631861389,
-0.0429521948,
-0.038210962,
0.087979354,
-0.0163066946,
0.019286491,
0.0115361903,
0.0331815444,
0.0178758707,
-0.0299082845,
0.0151150841,
-0.0075496873,
0.0139833214,
-0.0924276263,
0.0126305018,
0.01605938,
-0.0197351724,
-0.0168134309,
0.0097549604,
-0.0007514976,
0.0411710665,
0.0141877914,
0.0166556593,
2.918719871e-34,
-0.0065155695,
0.0406494848,
0.0010718782,
-0.0222929027,
0.0216066372,
-0.0557100363,
0.0018134179,
0.0031243463,
0.073678799,
-0.0950392038,
-0.0134556657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00960v1 | The Cost of Compression: Investigating the Impact of Compression on Parametric Knowledge in Language Models | 2023-12-01T22:27:12 | 2023-12-01T22:27:12 | Satya Sai Srinath Namburi, Makesh Sreedhar, Srinath Srinivasan, Frederic Sala | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Compressing large language models (LLMs), often consisting of billions of
parameters, provides faster inference, smaller memory footprints, and enables
local deployment. Two standard compression techniques are pruning and
quantization, with the former eliminating redundant connections in model layers
and the latter representing model parameters with fewer bits. The key tradeoff
is between the degree of compression and the impact on the quality of the
compressed model. Existing research on LLM compression primarily focuses on
performance in terms of general metrics like perplexity or downstream task
accuracy. More fine-grained metrics, such as those measuring parametric
knowledge, remain significantly underexplored. To help bridge this gap, we
present a comprehensive analysis across multiple model families (ENCODER,
ENCODER-DECODER, and DECODER) using the LAMA and LM-HARNESS benchmarks in order
to systematically quantify the effect of commonly employed compression
techniques on model performance. A particular focus is on tradeoffs involving
parametric knowledge, with the goal of providing practitioners with practical
insights to help make informed decisions on compression. We release our
codebase1 to enable further research. | [
-0.0290884543,
0.0752231404,
-0.0241886731,
0.0358590223,
-0.0397737101,
0.0115775513,
-0.0182820614,
0.0433673784,
-0.0903313681,
-0.0086153038,
0.0039324593,
-0.0226909611,
0.0401758291,
-0.0143638328,
0.0257804077,
-0.0202205665,
0.0383178703,
-0.0490477011,
-0.0005166114,
-0.0031853286,
-0.0353432372,
-0.0050911228,
0.0315829329,
0.0536423363,
0.0380257368,
-0.0036491905,
-0.0302305184,
0.026960995,
-0.0347670428,
0.008543673,
-0.0356917009,
0.0548119061,
0.027821688,
0.0385355279,
0.0000020206,
-0.032194104,
-0.0041504768,
0.013687511,
-0.0958645865,
0.0737361982,
0.0493055135,
-0.0361260399,
-0.012137522,
0.0186704323,
0.0045967144,
-0.033001624,
0.071937032,
-0.0088895066,
0.0266116858,
0.0368403196,
0.0025693362,
-0.0006080499,
0.0226422176,
-0.0234943647,
-0.0328317545,
-0.0108150179,
0.0040578409,
0.0293168426,
-0.0197359081,
0.0076456964,
-0.0566658638,
0.0315155275,
0.0472855568,
0.0228747409,
-0.0474085808,
0.0170756187,
-0.0207975004,
-0.0362916216,
0.0222898144,
0.0280727856,
-0.0543021299,
-0.0451220647,
-0.0231659263,
0.0135512333,
-0.0061367499,
-0.0208892506,
-0.0602206774,
0.0480419695,
0.0037064641,
0.0324793272,
-0.0093952669,
0.001156725,
0.0501149371,
-0.0275201723,
-0.0147424825,
0.0483324267,
0.0323210955,
-0.0135503793,
-0.0280750729,
-0.0230075717,
-0.0230458174,
-0.0559607111,
-0.0236899145,
0.0077298637,
0.0231308118,
0.01026979,
-0.0455292836,
-0.0401184782,
0.0282434896,
-0.0473330952,
0.0565451831,
0.0563315451,
0.0261515584,
0.0112538058,
-0.0269770101,
0.0826433077,
0.001339581,
0.0151791861,
-0.0246575661,
-0.0030972448,
-0.0134112453,
-0.0256275218,
-0.0394705981,
0.0262834784,
-0.0245676693,
0.0108516384,
-0.0141046196,
0.0148645015,
0.033689633,
0.0055920058,
0.0373891443,
-0.0285672732,
-0.011598628,
0.0007408381,
0.0020856552,
0.0335409082,
-0.0308418926,
0.0058028558,
-0.0058746543,
-0.0832340419,
-0.0279868394,
-0.002608184,
-0.0013033873,
-0.0364277698,
0.0162548926,
0.0266425069,
0.0155241527,
-0.0282502454,
-0.0143296905,
-0.0084970491,
0.0040735449,
-0.0757125393,
0.0051150266,
-0.0764902383,
0.0306161884,
0.0051461076,
-0.0073337913,
-0.0648001879,
-0.019761486,
0.0003473933,
-0.033979103,
0.0322665311,
0.0076829786,
0.0349360704,
0.000931392,
0.0230740197,
0.0336106122,
0.1117266938,
0.0321183391,
0.006197148,
0.020515535,
-0.0564503856,
-0.0310886484,
0.0306317676,
0.05045278,
0.0151730869,
-0.0719212443,
-0.0088174315,
0.0203189086,
0.0042428146,
0.0596647263,
0.0682165846,
-0.060789194,
-0.0514170043,
0.0581657365,
0.0444170572,
0.0553748347,
0.0312897488,
0.0343666077,
0.0288315862,
0.0248070825,
0.0019773438,
-0.0200141929,
0.028418621,
-0.0109654339,
0.0302200243,
0.052510649,
0.0435599685,
-0.0376453251,
-0.0365478173,
-0.0417588577,
-0.0237415452,
0.0262337532,
0.0085677449,
0.0448903292,
-0.0093268426,
-0.0241941791,
0.0950131789,
0.011867756,
-0.0801114887,
-0.0297396369,
-0.0564649813,
-0.0337154306,
0.0235133227,
0.0553740971,
0.0339972936,
-0.0210610088,
0.0470644832,
-0.0283857007,
-0.0042781522,
0.0238921493,
-0.001834517,
0.0550325252,
-0.0460694022,
-0.0141153503,
-0.011269195,
0.0217512473,
0.0167779978,
0.0334956013,
0.0230245721,
0.0164843425,
-0.0834894851,
-0.0188922659,
0.0147127621,
-0.0337934345,
-0.0204198416,
-0.004475262,
-0.009983086,
0.0209691748,
-0.0199206341,
-0.0249069482,
0.0133898156,
0.0473830737,
-0.0410543047,
0.0208310187,
-0.0028937117,
-0.0184218958,
-0.0525589176,
0.0303253941,
-0.0024028525,
0.0449418277,
0.0665268227,
-0.0125412401,
-0.0458019562,
0.0542130582,
-0.0455599315,
0.086827442,
-0.0413221121,
0.036019899,
-0.0472868644,
0.0387874246,
-0.0035932944,
0.0207733959,
-0.0288666561,
0.0196255334,
0.0114455735,
-0.0091491081,
0.0189931951,
-0.0167165902,
-0.0379248746,
0.0222646594,
-0.0190670248,
0.0005647514,
0.0000258111,
-0.0130747147,
0.0118646342,
-0.0070731863,
-0.0840333477,
-0.0120789465,
-0.0241495892,
0.0404711664,
0.0037654773,
0.0229818542,
-0.0009953341,
-0.0025503929,
-0.0110788932,
-0.0150913261,
-0.0047117253,
0.0283753816,
-0.0054415623,
0.0100427819,
-0.0682295114,
-0.0320605151,
-0.0532013401,
0.0218050592,
0.0857895315,
-0.0599706434,
-0.0186524764,
-0.0524830632,
0.0497118756,
-0.0265024155,
0.0210789759,
-0.0187615715,
-0.0561831072,
0.000729054,
-0.010776992,
0.0205167476,
0.0417562537,
-0.0387768522,
0.0374229513,
0.0910805613,
-0.0099248663,
-0.0484208837,
0.0034629861,
-0.0200608186,
-0.0642745644,
-0.0506500565,
-0.0660147369,
-0.0243528634,
0.0840017274,
-0.0179071911,
-0.0229469109,
-0.0704495087,
-0.0348241851,
-0.0230192021,
-0.0355352387,
-0.0545727499,
-0.0306300726,
0.0039020111,
0.0834418833,
-0.0165335126,
-0.0715889558,
0.0403796658,
-0.0753556713,
-0.0180077516,
0.0173460003,
-0.0028014956,
-0.0401884094,
0.0834095627,
0.0151445689,
0.0384646207,
-0.0129110338,
-0.0225942377,
-0.0401909612,
0.0361777768,
0.004700141,
-0.0437121056,
-0.0022505715,
-0.0464051031,
0.0029534062,
-0.0377679914,
-0.0236555766,
-0.0041315514,
0.0106344623,
-0.0049823634,
0.0274849907,
0.0509539694,
-0.0269499067,
0.0089502176,
0.0503350832,
-0.0184556488,
0.0237034317,
0.0084027685,
0.0074902922,
0.0031829493,
-0.0225691553,
0.0088616796,
0.0272312891,
0.0558460876,
-0.0346348621,
0.0242567491,
0.0352748521,
0.04062948,
0.0354989134,
-0.0456008278,
0.0112929335,
0.041405376,
0.0075769634,
-0.0337352306,
0.0508609787,
0.0338794291,
-0.0539276339,
-0.0142323039,
0.1040865853,
0.0249883514,
-0.0547650121,
0.0214033034,
-0.0358675718,
0.0835499316,
0.0164104905,
0.0300924461,
-0.0595511831,
-0.0161333997,
0.0265055895,
-0.0024234154,
0.0045960294,
-0.0035731611,
-0.0114756329,
-0.1048627421,
0.0207830314,
0.0150896385,
-0.0015706015,
-0.0153026748,
-0.0616116226,
-0.0215531085,
0.004960651,
0.0440282784,
0.037990313,
-0.0198493265,
-0.0083561167,
0.0150202867,
-0.0513822027,
-0.0694449767,
0.0232263766,
0.0043049459,
0.0466708727,
0.0198042057,
0.001570362,
0.0060979682,
-0.0278882869,
0.0113863116,
0.0260107871,
-0.0024603591,
0.0019601553,
0.0360146016,
0.0356672555,
0.0067583439,
0.0234933496,
-0.0187407583,
-0.0232066289,
0.0027573882,
-0.0353499316,
0.0636792555,
-0.0248814691,
-0.0215543732,
0.0011674233,
-0.0459069908,
-0.0419363379,
0.0892331824,
0.0642595962,
0.0208483078,
-0.0436350591,
-0.0149851199,
-0.0158203524,
-0.004077225,
-0.0296826418,
0.0194060095,
0.003721806,
-0.0659175441,
-0.0152180102,
0.0228141658,
0.022054106,
0.0125386845,
-0.0043641431,
0.0029170159,
0.0148588112,
0.0275096297,
-0.0996825397,
-0.0009904165,
-0.0096863052,
-0.0058848797,
-0.051337488,
0.0161288567,
-0.0024140738,
0.0044120718,
-0.0206239931,
-0.005986026,
-0.1229769588,
-0.0450812429,
-0.021998873,
0.0308962315,
0.0309918635,
0.0532973781,
-0.000186844,
-0.0534204431,
-0.0062687285,
-0.0044857874,
-0.0315818116,
0.0795841888,
0.0363645814,
-0.0723285675,
0.0217386596,
0.0547063835,
-0.0286929645,
0.002298719,
-0.0198381208,
0.0098793795,
-0.0174684711,
-0.0444563292,
0.0087904148,
0.0319753848,
0.0287028216,
0.0030570852,
-0.0134175112,
0.0383940116,
0.0514614098,
-0.0353555977,
0.030563293,
-0.0512096584,
-0.0120846238,
0.0199056175,
0.0461183675,
0.0215940308,
0.0038990125,
0.0364371985,
0.0199578591,
0.0302891694,
0.0054956451,
-0.0251563936,
-0.0106673324,
0.0616789944,
0.0073991525,
-0.0136330305,
-0.0103041204,
-0.0061659082,
0.0357307829,
-0.0463779494,
0.0052290452,
-0.0032348919,
0.0515650548,
-0.0323940888,
0.0404844135,
-0.0219858661,
-0.0693272948,
-0.013610784,
-0.0061255991,
0.030937314,
-0.0016867676,
0.0557618588,
-0.0422357842,
0.0146288034,
-0.0269964449,
0.0090721911,
-0.0218108948,
-0.006074552,
0.0320316851,
0.0298680104,
-0.0246903654,
-0.001532746,
0.086727336,
0.0485930219,
0.0476095788,
-0.0307110734,
0.0105757089,
-0.0058241962,
-0.0383761637,
-0.0334987417,
0.0236665271,
-0.0086551988,
-0.0167523623,
-0.0534855574,
-0.0769345015,
-0.0371094123,
0.012570912,
0.0129541522,
-0.0107662398,
0.0328717865,
0.0660125762,
-0.0002205431,
-0.015927434,
-0.0186533108,
-0.032954473,
-0.0381477661,
-0.0045382325,
0.0132544274,
-6.512423844e-33,
-0.0282105561,
0.0247126874,
0.0273266416,
-0.0419526771,
-0.0213582255,
0.0073015229,
-0.0407782979,
0.0125071444,
-0.0360899642,
-0.0180449449,
-0.018271409,
0.0176232606,
0.0071242657,
0.027230192,
-0.0059136623,
0.002101996,
0.0520054698,
0.006891218,
-0.0241473429,
0.0129395239,
0.0139028002,
-0.0014659218,
0.0543782637,
0.0089273034,
-0.0259160679,
0.0212647934,
0.0234745555,
-0.0042687776,
0.005822158,
0.0545658395,
-0.0180980284,
0.0224596318,
0.005666005,
-0.044451125,
-0.0368312858,
-0.0223710071,
-0.0512875691,
-0.0271065328,
0.0379365683,
0.0094618537,
-0.0351254977,
-0.0583439693,
0.0266314223,
0.0350706987,
-0.0336137898,
-0.0166366138,
-0.0263717547,
-0.0191462468,
-0.0443522073,
-0.0073947869,
-0.0063345693,
0.0205706973,
-0.0197789446,
0.0038065931,
0.0791430026,
0.0238223448,
-0.0477312692,
0.0206739921,
-0.0129865538,
0.0186492018,
0.0447006002,
0.103344053,
0.0839860737,
-0.0016289558,
0.0200075228,
0.0331375301,
-0.0032755039,
-0.0162576213,
-0.0399253033,
0.0573721305,
0.0721837133,
0.0447777025,
0.0456435122,
0.0126049845,
0.0687786192,
-0.0179546829,
-0.0602495968,
-0.0074627283,
0.0243705735,
0.0495765321,
0.0145503189,
0.02375561,
-0.0304607078,
-0.0566425435,
-0.0624033585,
-0.0087331133,
-0.0215281714,
-0.0343794078,
0.0254554171,
0.0004767332,
-0.0136964191,
-0.0301849004,
0.0621855073,
-0.0343622975,
0.0059531182,
0.0139163174,
-0.0208693929,
0.0486963429,
0.0231309701,
0.0425913595,
-0.0428931452,
-0.0110878823,
0.0063565252,
-0.0078920517,
0.0286933016,
-0.0128604779,
0.0021689953,
0.0448953956,
-0.0581976846,
-0.0091386493,
-0.0213649739,
0.008967164,
0.0018301207,
0.0069656898,
0.0362230986,
0.0135650579,
0.0125134354,
0.0087821223,
-0.0046580471,
-0.00460887,
-0.033031106,
0.0080604656,
0.0222238004,
0.0213289279,
-0.0048270109,
-0.0292528979,
-0.0723380819,
0.0022704327,
0.0840816349,
-0.0467670597,
-0.0437245481,
0.0452008843,
2.749e-7,
0.0486841984,
0.0339546762,
0.0311395098,
0.0100426851,
0.0147450222,
-0.0036814616,
-0.0215670336,
-0.0125185316,
-0.004454297,
-0.021540219,
0.0071137859,
0.0441177227,
0.0564135909,
0.0269392543,
-0.0633563772,
-0.019107176,
-0.0620158277,
-0.0177179333,
-0.0348373391,
-0.0116494996,
0.0115306051,
0.1173597053,
-0.0181708727,
-0.0047566956,
-0.0018684322,
-0.0149240335,
0.0294854101,
-0.0411708653,
0.0332797356,
0.0167408474,
-0.000131888,
0.0030956122,
0.0087195905,
0.0161628928,
-0.0012776213,
-0.0008344983,
-0.035427358,
0.0854420513,
-0.0041529667,
-0.0410724469,
0.025701629,
-0.0273551289,
-0.0445161238,
-0.0529202148,
0.0835243985,
-0.0054796501,
-0.0388861261,
-0.020975057,
0.0009107862,
0.004132682,
-0.002931207,
0.0031172964,
0.0209700149,
0.0145824244,
0.0206168368,
-0.0281490441,
0.018270066,
-0.0548029877,
-0.0359953493,
0.0036787384,
-0.0292559229,
-0.072775498,
-0.0519034974,
-0.0009534738,
0.051236093,
-0.0283323918,
-0.0102640111,
2.97099011e-34,
0.0401757024,
-0.0120372009,
0.0480645001,
0.0360792913,
0.0056608035,
-0.0542322583,
-0.0172924567,
0.0255503356,
-0.0314172134,
-0.0898293108,
-0.0233276486
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.